instruction
stringlengths
147
1.1k
output
stringclasses
2 values
generator
stringclasses
3 values
<question> What is the difference between 'HAZMAT Cars Damaged/Derailed' and 'Cars Releasing HAZMAT'? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the event of a confirmed false activation with a warning time of over 60 seconds, how can railroad operators rapidly identify and respond to the issue to minimize disruptions and ensure the safety of rail operations and nearby communities? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If our railroad operates a freight train that is crewed by another railroad, which railroad is responsible for reporting the freight train-miles for that train? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In a scenario where a railroad employee sustains an injury while working on a freight train, which form(s) should the railroad use to report the incident and comply with safety regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Under the Telephonic Notification Chart, what constitutes a 'collision or derailment' that would require telephonic notification? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the voluntary nature of the Employee Statement Supplement impact the railroad's ability to assess and learn from accidents, and what potential risks or benefits arise from this voluntary system? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do the auditing procedures outlined in the passage contribute to ensuring accurate and timely reporting of accidents and incidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How can railroads effectively manage the potential for varied and complex incident scenarios at highway-rail grade crossings, given the broad range of highway users and the impact on reporting and safety procedures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a railroad employee is injured while working for a contractor, which railroad is responsible for reporting the injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a derailment occurs on a joint track where both railroads suffer damage, how is the reporting threshold determined, and what actions should each railroad take to ensure compliance with the reporting requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the event of a major rail equipment accident, how does the two-year retention period for the "Employee Human Factor Attachments" (Form FRA F 6180.81) and the corresponding employee statements (Form FRA F 6180.78) contribute to a thorough investigation and the development of effective safety improvement strategies? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In which situations does a railroad need to submit multiple forms for a single accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an employee decides to submit a Supplement to the railroad's accident report, what are the procedures and deadlines for ensuring that the Supplement is properly filed and considered by the railroad and FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the time limits for recording and re-evaluating a claimed occupational illness? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A train derails on a main line that is used for scheduled passenger service, but there are no injuries or fatalities. Is telephonic notification required in this case? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee was walking through the shop and suddenly felt a sharp pain in their back. There were no obvious slips, trips, or falls, and the employee cannot pinpoint a specific event or action that caused the pain. Is this injury considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the significance of the distinction between Class D and Class J nontrespassers in railroad safety reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In the event of a highway-rail grade crossing accident, what are the immediate steps that railroad personnel should take to ensure the safety of passengers and highway users, and how can these actions mitigate the impact of the accident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A freight train derailed, and the front of a boxcar was damaged. The total cost to repair the damage is estimated to be $9,500. The derailment did not result in any injuries or other significant incidents. Is this incident reportable, and if so, which form should be used for the report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the Accident Reports Act of 1910 impact the reporting of incidents and accidents in the railroad industry, and what are the consequences for non-compliance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a train accident occurs and the primary cause is identified as a suicide attempt by a pedestrian, but the investigation also reveals that the train's brakes were not functioning optimally, how should the primary and contributing cause codes be entered on Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a PLHCP recommends in writing that an employee take two days off work, but the employee returns to work on the first day and works their full schedule, how many days away from work should be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a report was submitted in error for a non-reportable event, what is the proper procedure for correcting this mistake? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I code the location and physical act if a passenger is injured while stepping across the gap between the train and the platform? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a rail equipment accident/incident results in damages below the reporting threshold but causes a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident, do both incidents need to be reported, and if so, on which forms? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a joint operation involves multiple railroads, how should the reporting threshold be calculated for a rail equipment accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad identifies an employee as a contributing cause of an accident but later determines that the employee was not at fault, what steps must the railroad take to correct the report and notify the affected employee? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What steps should an employer take to determine the work-relatedness of an injury when the employee is involved in a work-related activity but the cause of the injury is unclear? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In what circumstances might a railroad be exempt from penalties for violations of Part 225 requirements, and what evidence is required to support this exemption? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Describe the process for determining if an injury or illness is work-related when the cause is not immediately clear, as outlined in the FRA Guide. </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A rail equipment accident/incident resulted in damage to a locomotive and a signal system. The total estimated cost of repairs is $10,000. The accident is attributed to an employee human factor. What forms need to be completed and submitted to the FRA, and within what time frame? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Our employees are frequently tested for drug or alcohol use after an accident/incident. Company policy prohibits an employee from returning to work until the results of the tests are known and it is established that there is no risk factor due to impairment. Must we make a report because of the days the employee was held out of service while awaiting test results? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> What is the significance of the track type codes "CWR" and "OTH" in the Special Study Block A (49a), and how do they contribute to accident analysis and prevention? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What steps should a railroad take if an employee reports an injury but the supervisor believes the injury is not work-related or not reportable, and the employee feels they are being discouraged from reporting the injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the context of a non-fatal, yet severe injury, what specific criteria or guidelines do railroads follow to determine whether an incident is classified as "reportable" or "accountable"? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A freight train derailment caused extensive damage to the track and surrounding property. The preliminary estimate of the damages is $12,000. The derailment occurred in 2023. What steps should the railroad take to determine if this incident is reportable, and what form should be used to report it? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the required components of a railroad's internal policy and procedures for reporting accidents and incidents, and how must they be communicated to employees and management? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should railroad miles be reported to avoid duplication in Items 11-14 of Form FRA F 6180.55? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What types of accidents/incidents must a contracting railroad report to the FRA, and under what conditions, when it has contracted out its operations to another railroad? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the purpose of the FRA Guide for Preparing Accident/Incident Reports, and who is it applicable to? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA guide's definition of assigned working hours impact the reporting of work-related injuries for employees who work non-traditional hours, such as shift workers or those with flexible schedules? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the FRA's reporting system, particularly the use of specific forms, contribute to the overall safety and risk management strategies of railroad companies? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the significance of the "presumption of reportable injuries" for highway users in the context of railroad safety regulations, and how does it affect the reporting process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the definition of 'day away from work' in the context of railroad injury reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of 'confirmed' in the context of warning times at highway-rail grade crossings? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the use of non-prescription medication at prescription strength affect the classification of medical treatment for record-keeping purposes? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What does 'getting out' or 'getting off' refer to in the context of the Physical Act codes on Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the reporting requirements and guidelines outlined in the FRA Guide contribute to overall railroad safety and the prevention of future accidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the potential consequences for railroads that fail to obtain a valid crossing number for a new crossing, and how does this impact safety regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In a scenario where a railroad receives multiple claims of occupational illness through a class action lawsuit, what specific challenges might they face in managing and prioritizing these claims, and how can they ensure timely and effective reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In Scenario 4, if the employee had slipped and fallen while on a smoke break but outside of the normal working hours (e.g., after clocking out for the day), would this incident still be considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What steps must a railroad take to determine the nature and severity of injuries to highway users in a highway-rail grade crossing accident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How can railroads ensure the accurate and consistent recording of events by locomotive video recorders, given the potential for varying operator practices and equipment performance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What information must be reported if a hazardous material car releases any portion of its contents during an accident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the consist speed and timetable direction influence the severity of a railroad accident, and what safety measures can be enhanced or implemented to mitigate the risks associated with different speed and direction scenarios? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a passenger railroad contracts out the maintenance of its tracks to another railroad, which railroad is responsible for reporting the worker hours related to track maintenance to FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is an injury that occurs in the company parking lot or on a privately owned sidewalk leading to the workplace considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an employee is injured while performing a personal task, such as making a personal phone call, during their break, is this injury reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a locomotive's braking system failed, causing a derailment, and the locomotive was the first unit in the consist, how should the information be entered in Blocks 31a and 31b of Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad discovers a critical error in a previously submitted report, such as an incorrect classification of an incident, what immediate actions should they take to rectify the situation, and what potential consequences might they face if they fail to address the error promptly? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the opportunity for employees to review their files impact the accuracy and transparency of railroad safety reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a passenger slips and falls while stepping down from a train at a high-level platform, what specific codes should be used for the 'Physical Act,' 'Location,' and 'Cause' sections of Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the regulations regarding the naming of employees on FRA forms prior to a formal investigation impact the safety culture and the accuracy of incident reporting within the railroad industry? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A car driven by an individual who was experiencing a medical emergency (e.g., a heart attack) struck a train at a highway-rail grade crossing. The driver and a passenger in the car were both injured. The train crew was not injured. Is this incident reportable, and if so, how should it be reported on Form FRA F 6180.57? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a pedestrian is struck and injured by a sack of grain that falls from a railcar at a highway-rail grade crossing, is this incident considered a highway-rail grade crossing accident and reportable on Form FRA F 6180.57? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In cases of joint operation, where multiple railroads are involved, how is the responsibility for reporting an accident/incident determined if the identity of the responsible railroad cannot be established? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a vehicle collides with a train at a highway-rail grade crossing, and the driver is transported to a medical facility via ambulance but the passenger is not, how should the injuries be reported on Form FRA F 6180.57 and Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a train derailment leads to a subsequent collision with another train, how should the accident be classified on the FRA Form F 6180.54, and what costs should be included in the report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What does 'Type of Equipment Consist' refer to, and what are the different codes used to identify the type of equipment? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an employee is injured and seeks medical treatment from a healthcare professional, but the injury does not meet the general reporting criteria, is the injury still considered 'accountable' and must it be recorded on the Railroad Employee Injury and/or Illness Record (Form FRA F 6180.98)? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What types of events or exposures are considered to be within the work environment for the purpose of determining work-relatedness? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a car derails on an industry track due to vandalism by a non-railroad employee and there was no involvement of railroad employees, is this incident reportable to the FRA? If not, are there any specific records that need to be maintained? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should a railroad address and document instances where an employee refuses to report an injury or illness due to fear of harassment or retaliation from management, in compliance with their ICP requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway-rail grade crossing accident results in damages to both railroad and non-railroad property, but the total damage to railroad property is below the reporting threshold, is the accident still reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the process of contacting injured highway users contribute to the accuracy and completeness of accident/incident reports, and what are the potential consequences if this step is overlooked? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A train derails on railroad property, and the derailed cars come to a stop on a public road, causing damage to a vehicle and injuring a person on the road. How should this incident be classified and reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How can the FRA's guidelines for rail equipment accidents be improved to address the challenges posed by non-railroad personnel involvement, and what safety measures should be implemented to mitigate potential risks? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the purpose of Form FRA F 6180.55a, and when is it required to be filed? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A contractor working on railroad property was injured when he slipped on a wet floor. The injury required medical treatment beyond first aid. Is this injury reportable under the railroad's reporting requirements? If so, under which group and form should it be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the specific requirements for the electronic record-keeping system to ensure the integrity and accessibility of accident/incident records? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee sprained his ankle while playing in a company-sponsored softball game during his lunch break. Would this injury be reportable under the FRA's regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a single car in a train consist is transporting hazardous materials, how should this be reported in Item 20a of Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I determine if an injury that occurs in the company parking lot or on the grounds of the establishment is work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the 'OTH' track type code contribute to accident analysis, and what other track-related factors might be captured under this category? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A pedestrian was struck and killed by a train at a highway-rail grade crossing and was transported to a hospital via ambulance. The pedestrian later died from the injuries. Is this a reportable incident, and if so, which forms need to be completed and submitted to the FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In Scenario 4, where an employee slips on ice while outside during a smoke break to get sunglasses from his truck, why is the injury considered work-related despite the employee not performing tasks related to their employment? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Which form should be used to report a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident, and what is the reporting threshold for these incidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the requirements for centralized access to accident and incident records, and how quickly must these records be made available upon request? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of a 'Passenger Station Platform Gap Incident' and what specific conditions must be met for an incident to be classified as such? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should I handle the calculation and reporting of passenger miles operated if my railroad has multiple trips with varying numbers of passengers and distances? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the guidelines for counting lost days impact the reporting of near-miss incidents, and what challenges might this pose for safety managers? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A freight train derailment occurred on a main line that is also used for scheduled passenger service. The preliminary estimate of property damage is $175,000. What are the immediate reporting requirements for this incident, and which form should be used for the initial report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A highway-rail grade crossing accident occurred, and a motorist was injured. The railroad sent the Form FRA F 6180.150 and a cover letter to the injured motorist, but the motorist did not respond. What steps should the railroad take next to ensure compliance with the requirements for completing and filing Form FRA F 6180.150? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee was walking down a hallway at work and suddenly felt a sharp pain in his knee, which he believes was due to a preexisting knee issue. The hallway was level and seamless, with no identifiable hazards. How should the employer determine whether this injury is work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What methods or technologies are commonly employed by railroads to accurately determine and record vehicle speeds at the time of an accident or incident, and how do these tools contribute to overall safety and accident investigation? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the implications of not posting information on an injury or illness due to a privacy concern case, and how does this impact railroad safety regulations and procedures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Is an injury that occurs in the company parking lot before the start of the workday considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential consequences of failing to accurately report the type of track (CWR or OTH) in Item 49a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What should a railroad do if it discovers a significant discrepancy between the estimated and actual values reported on Form FRA F 6180.55a after the initial submission? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Can you provide an example of a scenario where the accurate reporting of locomotive and car positions, as outlined in the FRA guide, played a critical role in identifying the cause of an accident and implementing preventive measures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r