text,start,duration
what is up everybody David Shapiro here,0.84,6.36
with a video so,3.959,5.281
um my videos are probably gonna change,7.2,3.24
tone,9.24,4.439
um just because the the the landscape is,10.44,5.699
changing really fast so you'll probably,13.679,4.741
see me doing less coding except for,16.139,3.541
every now and then when I have something,18.42,3.48
to demonstrate but the news is changing,19.68,4.92
so fast and most of the questions that I,21.9,4.92
get now are people just asking me what,24.6,5.099
the heck is going on so our first what,26.82,5.16
the heck is going on with AI video is,29.699,6.061
today Saturday morning on March 25th,31.98,6.96
um I got access to Adobe Firefly,35.76,5.04
um oh and to give you what to expect for,38.94,3.66
the rest of the video I'll review a few,40.8,3.72
tools and then I'll give you some,42.6,3.54
examples of the research that I'm doing,44.52,4.379
so my research is pivoting away from the,46.14,4.38
coding and more to the science and,48.899,3.061
naming things and I'll explain that when,50.52,3.18
we get to it but anyways we're going to,51.96,4.38
review five of the most powerful tools,53.7,6.48
that I have seen uh so far lately and,56.34,5.58
then we'll pivot to to these to those,60.18,5.4
conversations so Adobe Firefly,61.92,6.0
um all pretty much everyone has seen you,65.58,4.5
know text to image lately,67.92,4.62
um but of course Adobe is um you know,70.08,4.26
they've been the leader like one of the,72.54,3.54
world leaders in terms of media,74.34,5.04
generation Adobe is working on text to,76.08,6.899
sound uh text to video uh video to sound,79.38,6.0
all kinds of stuff so I have no doubt,82.979,5.46
that on in in the multimedia landscape,85.38,5.4
Adobe is probably going to pull ahead,88.439,5.701
very quickly especially since they are,90.78,5.4
you know they've got Adobe Premiere,94.14,4.74
Adobe studio Adobe Photoshop like they,96.18,4.86
have just such a huge,98.88,4.379
um library of tools that they can go,101.04,3.66
ahead and integrate,103.259,4.381
so I suspect that adobe is going to be,104.7,5.34
at the top like look at this like this,107.64,4.2
looks like a real photo of an engine,110.04,3.899
like if you look closely you can see,111.84,3.84
some artifacts that are like okay that,113.939,3.781
doesn't quite look right like you know,115.68,4.439
what is this part here that shape is not,117.72,4.679
quite what you'd expect but still it's,120.119,4.201
pretty darn convincing,122.399,2.881
um and it's only going to get better,124.32,3.36
because this is still in beta,125.28,5.819
um so uh the text to image now another,127.68,5.88
thing that adobe Firefly has is text,131.099,5.701
effects so you can get text of any like,133.56,6.42
size and shape and so what I did what I,136.8,7.74
I did like uh cognitive architecture and,139.98,6.0
it's it's really limited I don't know,144.54,2.88
why but they've only give you like 15,145.98,4.32
characters and then you can say like,147.42,8.58
um uh let's see steampunk and Fire,150.3,7.86
um and it will generate like any style,156.0,4.02
of text that you want,158.16,4.14
um and it's super easy super fast super,160.02,3.9
useful,162.3,3.96
um so you can do like flaming steampunk,163.92,4.8
letters it's pretty cool can I zoom in,166.26,4.559
no I cannot,168.72,4.44
um if I download it I probably can show,170.819,4.14
you let me see,173.16,4.38
and right now they add this like little,174.959,5.221
Annoying like Watermark but here look,177.54,5.94
you can see that like I I the the font,180.18,6.66
is preset but the graphical style is,183.48,6.72
just instant so that's pretty useful,186.84,5.1
um in fact I'll probably be using this,190.2,4.08
for all of my YouTube thumbnails from,191.94,5.1
now on because it looks really cool,194.28,4.62
um but yeah so that's Adobe Firefly,197.04,4.919
definitely recommend signing up the beta,198.9,6.119
is free right now which is incredible,201.959,4.741
um because I'm a because I'm a full-time,205.019,5.401
YouTuber I I will I would pay for this,206.7,6.119
um I have seen some people using there's,210.42,6.62
there's a rumored like Dolly 2 version,212.819,7.861
2.2 or Dolly three coming out but I,217.04,5.02
don't know,220.68,2.339
um,222.06,3.3
because like I don't know if it's people,223.019,5.22
just like remixing mid-journey and,225.36,5.159
stable diffusion or what but anyways,228.239,5.761
point being this is ramping up quickly I,230.519,5.161
suspect that by this time next year,234.0,3.959
Adobe and others are going to have like,235.68,5.1
fully fledged text to video you can make,237.959,5.7
your own movie at home just by giving it,240.78,5.22
a a screenplay we're probably going to,243.659,4.381
need a new format of screenplays because,246.0,3.72
like you need to like Define the setting,248.04,3.24
and then say what happens and control,249.72,3.599
the shots and stuff but all that's,251.28,3.959
coming,253.319,5.221
um yep so I also got access to Bard,255.239,5.821
um and some of you saw in my last video,258.54,4.68
like I asked Bard for help and it's like,261.06,3.72
I can't do that I'm a language mod I'm,263.22,2.759
like okay but can you search the,264.78,2.58
internet it's like yes I can and didn't,265.979,3.061
search the internet so I'm like this is,267.36,4.8
not useful I asked it for um for AI news,269.04,4.8
and it gives me stuff that's like a year,272.16,4.5
or two old so I'm like okay,273.84,5.46
um I'm basically eating my words where a,276.66,4.5
few weeks ago I predicted that Google,279.3,4.76
was gonna win the chat bot arms race,281.16,5.34
yeah about that,284.06,4.48
they've got a lot of catching up to do,286.5,4.56
everyone is like a year or two or more,288.54,5.64
behind open Ai and uh and Microsoft with,291.06,4.74
Bing,294.18,5.4
um so Adobe Firefly Big Win Google bard,295.8,5.76
super yikes,299.58,4.74
um now another tool as people are,301.56,4.74
getting more familiar with the idea of,304.32,4.379
cognitive architecture and autonomous Ai,306.3,4.619
and figuring out how to plumb all these,308.699,4.621
things together there's two tools that,310.919,4.141
have percolated up to the top one is,313.32,4.319
Lang chain which is,315.06,5.34
um which is like this it's a set of of,317.639,5.521
tools where you can use large language,320.4,5.34
models you can load indexes you can,323.16,5.879
create uh logic chains you can create uh,325.74,5.82
agents and and have memories and so on,329.039,5.1
and so forth basically Lang chain allows,331.56,4.8
you to equip your your language model,334.139,4.441
with a set of tools that it can pick,336.36,4.619
from and it'll pick the tool and use the,338.58,4.92
tool and then of course there's all,340.979,5.581
kinds of tools that you can use now that,343.5,5.16
is super useful but it's a little bit,346.56,4.199
clunky some of the people that I've that,348.66,3.36
I've talked to,350.759,3.241
um use that are using it some of my,352.02,4.619
patreon supporters that I've shared it,354.0,4.86
with they say like yeah it's a little,356.639,4.021
bit to wrap your head around but once,358.86,4.26
you get it it's pretty powerful now if,360.66,4.44
you want a graphical version with,363.12,4.38
specific workflows and Integrations I,365.1,6.48
want to introduce you to n8n dot IO so,367.5,5.94
um I mentioned in a couple recent videos,371.58,3.72
that I'm working with um some folks on,373.44,4.08
cognitive architecture this is one of,375.3,5.04
the tools that they introduced me to to,377.52,4.98
help build cognitive architectures,380.34,4.68
because this can connect to all kinds of,382.5,4.56
things you can create very easy to,385.02,4.38
follow graphical workflows I don't know,387.06,5.16
if it can do loops but still like you,389.4,5.1
know you can create a task and then call,392.22,4.5
that task up and task select and all,394.5,6.0
that kind of fun stuff so n8n is um it's,396.72,5.4
it's pretty,400.5,4.86
um and it and watching what some of the,402.12,4.44
some of the guys that I'm working with,405.36,4.2
what they're doing it's incredible so if,406.56,5.22
you want to create more autonomous AI,409.56,5.28
systems with more Integrations this,411.78,5.22
might be the way to go I know that chat,414.84,5.1
GPT plugins are coming but that is,417.0,4.919
putting chat GPT front and center,419.94,4.8
whereas this kind of says let's look at,421.919,4.981
the broader architecture and the,424.74,3.42
language model is just going to be,426.9,3.6
something that you can use in some of,428.16,3.36
these nodes so there's different,430.5,3.3
paradigms I think both are here to stay,431.52,4.56
because when you look at how powerful,433.8,5.459
chat GPT is you definitely want to make,436.08,5.54
chat GPT more extensible and more useful,439.259,4.44
some of the people on the Discord,441.62,4.54
communities that I'm a part of Link in,443.699,4.201
the description for the main one by the,446.16,2.939
way,447.9,2.94
um some of them have gotten access to,449.099,4.5
the GPT with plugins already and they're,450.84,4.56
saying like yeah it's pretty it's pretty,453.599,3.361
incredible just how straightforward it,455.4,3.54
is like one guy was saying I think he,456.96,3.72
said that he like asked it to send his,458.94,4.8
brother an email and coordinate like the,460.68,4.56
hotel you know it's pretty pretty,463.74,4.679
stereotypical anyways point being these,465.24,5.399
things work and they are smart,468.419,3.541
um and they're only going to get smarter,470.639,4.441
so here's the wild thing like six months,471.96,5.579
ago we didn't even have chat GPT now,475.08,5.339
we've got chat gpt4 and plugins and,477.539,5.761
Integrations and text to image and text,480.419,5.4
to video imagine where we're gonna be in,483.3,5.519
five years we're gonna be like the,485.819,5.28
technology in Star Trek is gonna look,488.819,4.201
primitive compared to where we're gonna,491.099,4.741
be in five years mark my words I know,493.02,4.32
that some people in common say oh yeah,495.84,3.18
like we're close to AGI it's eight to,497.34,4.199
ten years away I'm like dude full AGI is,499.02,6.359
like 18 months or less now defining the,501.539,5.28
singularity is going to be another thing,505.379,3.6
we'll talk about that in another video,506.819,5.16
okay so in terms of chaining and,508.979,5.581
orchestrating innate in and Lang chain,511.979,4.56
are the two top tools that I have to,514.56,3.3
recommend,516.539,3.06
um I recommend these to a lot of my,517.86,3.9
patreon supporters,519.599,5.161
um and I'm still learning about them,521.76,5.88
um but these these these tools have,524.76,4.5
percolated to the top as the way to go,527.64,3.42
and I know I said not nice things about,529.26,4.019
Lang chain early on,531.06,4.68
um but after seeing the Wolfram Alpha,533.279,4.68
video and understanding oh task,535.74,4.08
selection this is this is basically,537.959,4.5
cognitive control and cognitive control,539.82,4.68
is one of the most important functions,542.459,4.5
to have an autonomous intelligent entity,544.5,4.44
so with a little bit more work maybe,546.959,3.901
with a graphical,548.94,4.26
um Lang chain Builder that could be a,550.86,4.8
cool thing maybe if Lang chain you know,553.2,5.46
merges with n8n or you know borrows some,555.66,5.16
could be super powerful especially if,558.66,4.32
you add in loops loops and nodes,560.82,4.079
everyone is going to be able to build,562.98,3.539
their own cognitive architectures before,564.899,3.421
too long which again this is one of the,566.519,3.301
reasons why it's like okay this is no,568.32,3.18
longer I'm no longer leading the charge,569.82,2.94
so I don't have anything to contribute,571.5,2.7
I'm just going to teach people about it,572.76,2.46
now,574.2,3.3
and then finally,575.22,4.32
um a llama index or what has been,577.5,6.06
renamed um GPT index is a uh is a data,579.54,6.96
connector so again Integrations are are,583.56,5.7
the way of uh this is the way now so,586.5,4.2
whether you're talking about chat GPT,589.26,4.8
plugins or orchestration engines or,590.7,4.92
other connectors,594.06,2.52
um here let me zoom in a little bit,595.62,3.12
because this is microscopic,596.58,5.699
um the GPT Index this allows you to,598.74,6.9
connect to a lot of other things so,602.279,6.721
again Integrations are coming this GPT,605.64,5.759
index might be completely replaced by,609.0,5.279
gbt plugins but it's here now and you,611.399,5.581
can use it and also,614.279,3.901
um this kind of stuff is going to be,616.98,2.94
needed for other language models right,618.18,4.86
open Ai and chat GPT are not the only,619.92,6.419
players out there Stanford Google,623.04,5.16
um Nvidia everyone is going to have,626.339,3.541
these and so what we're probably going,628.2,5.46
to end up seeing is as an ecosystem of,629.88,6.48
Open Source and openstand rendered and,633.66,4.619
interoperable things so some of the,636.36,3.24
cognitive Architects that I'm working,638.279,3.18
with we're already thinking about like,639.6,4.859
okay how do you have a plug-and-play set,641.459,4.861
of language models,644.459,3.901
that are interchangeable right because,646.32,4.44
in a previous video I mentioned that,648.36,4.56
what what what a lot of us expect are,650.76,4.319
going to happen is we're going to have a,652.92,4.26
lot we're going to have a library of,655.079,3.901
language models that are optimized for,657.18,4.14
different things token optimize or a,658.98,4.5
window optimized language models speed,661.32,4.74
optimized language models mobile right I,663.48,4.56
know the um a lot of folks in the mobile,666.06,4.019
industry are working on really,668.04,3.78
lightweight language models that are,670.079,4.681
that can run on your cell phone right so,671.82,4.259
we're going to have a bunch of,674.76,2.519
interchangeable stuff so we're gonna,676.079,3.481
need to have some standards and also,677.279,4.381
some platforms that are interchangeable,679.56,4.92
now that being said the open Ai and,681.66,4.26
Microsoft stack,684.48,3.06
they're probably going to have the,685.92,3.359
Walled Garden model,687.54,3.06
um which is kind of what Facebook did,689.279,3.841
for many years which is hey you use us,690.6,4.56
you're going to use our ecosystem apple,693.12,5.159
as well use the Apple use the iPhone you,695.16,5.52
use iTunes you use the Apple Store it's,698.279,4.68
the Walled Garden so I think that the,700.68,6.42
big players you know Adobe Microsoft,702.959,6.661
Google they're probably going to try to,707.1,4.2
do the Walled Garden model which makes,709.62,4.38
sense from a business perspective and I,711.3,4.14
know that there's lots and lots of other,714.0,4.62
people working on AI marketplaces out,715.44,6.54
there so that's that's coming so we're,718.62,5.7
it's basically going to be ultimately,721.98,4.32
it's going to look the same as like the,724.32,4.62
Windows versus Linux ecosystem does,726.3,5.099
today you can use Linux you can use the,728.94,4.98
open source models you can use the open,731.399,5.161
source orchestration engines or you can,733.92,4.56
go with the big box stores that's,736.56,3.36
probably how it's going to play out,738.48,3.9
honestly,739.92,4.14
um okay so I think that's about it for,742.38,4.74
the AI tools so now let's pivot to some,744.06,5.64
of the research that I've been doing,747.12,4.56
um and I I've been trying to figure out,749.7,4.44
like kind of where I fit in and and how,751.68,4.62
I can contribute and so what I've,754.14,3.9
started doing is just posting it on,756.3,4.02
Reddit because then it's public it's,758.04,4.979
going to be there for you know forever,760.32,4.139
um and anyone can read it and,763.019,4.141
participate in the conversation so the,764.459,4.38
first conversation that I want to share,767.16,4.5
that I published was talking with gpt4,768.839,5.101
about functional sentience versus,771.66,4.5
philosophical sentience,773.94,3.54
so,776.16,5.82
as people are taking autonomous AI or,777.48,6.479
autonomous cognitive entities as I call,781.98,4.979
them more seriously the question is,783.959,6.12
arising what is sentience what is,786.959,4.921
consciousness what does it mean to be,790.079,4.141
alive and some people don't like the,791.88,4.079
term functional sentience they say why,794.22,3.48
not call it functional Consciousness or,795.959,4.32
functional sapience or something else I,797.7,3.78
don't really care I'm not going to have,800.279,3.781
a semantic debate the purpose though of,801.48,5.7
this is differentiating functional or,804.06,5.82
objectively measurable aspects of,807.18,4.68
Consciousness sentient sapience whatever,809.88,6.06
versus the philosophical aspect of these,811.86,6.0
things and so,815.94,4.56
here's the beginning of the conversation,817.86,4.979
um I just I I prime it I say I'm working,820.5,4.2
on on differentiating functional versus,822.839,5.281
philosophical sentience and uh chat GPT,824.7,6.0
very quickly says yes philosophical,828.12,4.26
sentience or phenomenal Consciousness,830.7,3.66
this refers to the subjective experience,832.38,4.56
or the intermental life of being what it,834.36,4.56
is like to be that thing and then,836.94,3.72
functional sentience talks about you,838.92,4.02
know the more objectively uh what is,840.66,4.26
what is the information system required,842.94,3.72
and so through the rest of the,844.92,4.2
conversation we identify a bunch of,846.66,6.6
criteria for functional sentience how,849.12,6.959
can you test it so on and so forth,853.26,3.42
um,856.079,2.94
and then I ask it to extend the,856.68,4.8
conversation so first,859.019,3.781
um you know here's a more thorough,861.48,3.659
definition of a functional sentience it,862.8,4.08
has self-awareness I don't know that,865.139,3.901
self-awareness is is critical but you,866.88,3.959
could functionally or objectively,869.04,3.599
measure self-awareness right if you ask,870.839,3.901
them a language model what are you and,872.639,4.14
it says I'm a language model okay cool,874.74,4.14
you could still argue that that's just a,876.779,3.481
stochastic parrot telling you what it's,878.88,3.66
been programmed to do but I always argue,880.26,3.9
that that's all that humans are anyways,882.54,4.26
so what's the difference,884.16,4.32
um adaptive learning,886.8,3.24
um I don't know that that adaptive,888.48,3.359
learning is required for sentience but,890.04,3.5
it's interesting that it included it,891.839,3.841
goal-oriented Behavior I definitely,893.54,4.359
agree with this one because sentience,895.68,4.92
implies autonomy and in order to be,897.899,4.201
autonomous you have to have your own,900.6,3.179
goals or objectives,902.1,3.859
and then of course autonomy right here,903.779,5.581
communication uh communication is,905.959,6.94
implicit but you can have uh well you,909.36,5.159
could probably have sentient things that,912.899,3.541
can't communicate,914.519,3.901
um problem solving representation of,916.44,4.86
internal States so this is this is the,918.42,4.56
information required and this is,921.3,3.719
actually where I started with my,922.98,4.26
definition of functional sentience which,925.019,4.62
is in order for an information system to,927.24,4.38
be functionally sentient it must have,929.639,3.961
information about its own operation,931.62,4.14
which we have information about our own,933.6,4.5
operation because we have interception,935.76,5.22
proprioception metacognition and so on,938.1,4.919
but still we are largely unaware of,940.98,4.2
what's going on in our own bodies,943.019,6.241
uh memory sensitivity con to context and,945.18,5.88
integration of information so this is,949.26,4.079
all stuff that it's some of it's,951.06,3.839
debatable and of course it's Reddit so,953.339,2.821
some people are debating it I don't,954.899,3.3
really care I set the stage and now we,956.16,4.619
have a set of terms that we can use to,958.199,5.281
have these conversations like I said I'm,960.779,5.12
not here to to to you know,963.48,4.979
single-handedly tell you what's true I'm,965.899,4.24
just advancing the conversation that's,968.459,3.06
my role now,970.139,4.44
um so then finally the conversation ends,971.519,5.521
um and I ask it I I ask the model so let,974.579,4.221
me show I said this conversation was,977.04,3.539
shorter than I thought it was going to,978.8,3.82
be I think you nailed it any independent,980.579,4.26
thoughts final observations logical,982.62,4.26
conclusions future research directions,984.839,3.601
anything you got hit me with it,986.88,3.66
figuratively,988.44,4.38
um so it comes up with the idea of,990.54,4.799
Continuum of sentience,992.82,4.56
um basically that functional sentience,995.339,4.44
may exist along a Continuum it's not a,997.38,3.959
it's not a Boolean it's not true or,999.779,3.541
false it's not that something is or is,1001.339,4.44
not sentient it is that,1003.32,4.8
um there are there are degrees of,1005.779,4.141
functional sentience which I think is a,1008.12,4.079
really important conversation to start,1009.92,3.419
having,1012.199,3.661
um the ethical implications,1013.339,3.541
um,1015.86,4.919
so like do we do we call it uh you know,1016.88,6.18
is it do we have any moral obligations,1020.779,5.16
to it as a functionally sentient thing I,1023.06,4.68
think no because unless we give it the,1025.939,3.541
ability to suffer which I think I'll,1027.74,3.48
probably have that conversation like,1029.48,4.079
what intrinsic motivations do we give,1031.22,3.54
these things,1033.559,2.341
um that's actually probably going to be,1034.76,2.819
my next conversation is intrinsic,1035.9,4.2
motivations such as like do you make it,1037.579,4.141
suffer do you give it a sense of pain a,1040.1,2.88
sense of self-preservation and the,1041.72,2.82
answer to those questions is,1042.98,3.479
resoundingly no,1044.54,3.6
um now number three is really,1046.459,2.941
interesting the emergence of,1048.14,4.14
philosophical sentience this is what the,1049.4,6.0
whole Lambda Blake Lemoine debacle was,1052.28,5.3
about was that Blake believed that,1055.4,6.18
philosophical sentience emerged but it's,1057.58,5.92
impossible to tell,1061.58,3.36
um so explore the relationship between,1063.5,3.059
functional and philosophical sentience,1064.94,4.14
just investigate whether a certain level,1066.559,3.901
of functional sentience might be,1069.08,3.719
necessary or sufficient for the,1070.46,5.099
emergence of phenomenal Consciousness or,1072.799,4.861
if these two aspects are entirely,1075.559,5.821
independent this conversation I suspect,1077.66,5.82
will be raging for decades if not,1081.38,4.679
centuries who knows,1083.48,3.3
um,1086.059,3.36
test development okay whatever evolution,1086.78,4.019
of sentience,1089.419,2.88
um study the evolution of sentience and,1090.799,3.421
biological organisms because again,1092.299,3.661
sentience might also exist along a,1094.22,3.54
spectrum for people like if you're,1095.96,3.599
really tired you're less aware if you're,1097.76,3.96
really drunk you're less aware,1099.559,3.781
um on another comment someone pointed,1101.72,3.6
out that sleepwalking if someone is,1103.34,3.66
sleepwalking they might be functionally,1105.32,3.9
sentient because you can often have a,1107.0,4.02
conversation with someone but they have,1109.22,3.839
no awareness of what's going on which is,1111.02,3.659
really creepy so that's the Chalmers,1113.059,3.181
zombie,1114.679,3.781
um philosophical thought experiment and,1116.24,3.36
then finally the legal and social,1118.46,3.66
implications so this is the conversation,1119.6,5.699
on r slash artificial sentience about,1122.12,4.799
functional versus philosophical,1125.299,3.24
sentience,1126.919,2.76
um I was really happy with this,1128.539,3.121
conversation of course there are some,1129.679,3.841
holes you can poke in it whatever I,1131.66,3.18
don't care,1133.52,3.18
um then last night I had another,1134.84,4.8
conversation with chat gpt4,1136.7,5.46
and what I what where the conversation,1139.64,4.46
started was I wanted to talk about,1142.16,4.92
autonomous Ai and the implications of,1144.1,5.86
autonomous Ai and so for there we just,1147.08,4.5
we kind of quickly,1149.96,4.74
um established some criteria about,1151.58,6.719
um about what would need to go into a a,1154.7,5.88
system for it to be classified as a,1158.299,5.24
autonomous Ai and it has narrow AI,1160.58,5.54
proficiency General AI capability,1163.539,4.661
self-improvement autonomy and decision,1166.12,3.82
making ethical and moral reasoning,1168.2,4.02
emotional intelligence,1169.94,4.32
positive impacts increased efficiency,1172.22,4.319
new jobs improved quality of life,1174.26,4.68
enhance scientific research negative,1176.539,4.441
impacts job displacement economic,1178.94,4.68
inequality ethical and moral concerns,1180.98,4.92
and security risks,1183.62,3.36
so,1185.9,5.1
I added I was like okay uh you know,1186.98,6.78
this this is this is okay,1191.0,5.28
um but it was missing the concept of,1193.76,4.62
intrinsic motivations because if,1196.28,4.38
something is autonomous and it can make,1198.38,4.26
decisions what is it making those,1200.66,4.68
decisions based on and so when I pointed,1202.64,4.74
out that it was missing any conversation,1205.34,4.8
about intrinsic motivations it updated,1207.38,4.5
number one,1210.14,3.539
um or it I guess it added another one,1211.88,3.72
and said intrinsic motivation and goal,1213.679,4.321
setting it would need it did agree very,1215.6,4.8
quickly that and of course it's chat GPT,1218.0,4.14
so it's generally going to agree with,1220.4,3.779
whatever you tell it to do,1222.14,4.32
um but it did say yeah like let's talk,1224.179,4.38
about intrinsic motivation goal setting,1226.46,4.62
and so then I was like okay let's follow,1228.559,4.921
that like what what do you think it,1231.08,4.32
should have all I did I said what what,1233.48,3.24
do you think the intrinsic motivations,1235.4,4.68
of autonomous AI should be,1236.72,5.22
um it should and this was this was,1240.08,3.54
actually really impressive value,1241.94,3.3
alignment the AI system should be,1243.62,3.48
intrinsically motivated to align its,1245.24,3.66
goals with human values and ethical,1247.1,5.04
principles self-preservation this one I,1248.9,5.7
fervently disagree with,1252.14,3.84
um and we'll get into that later in the,1254.6,3.6
conversation exploration and curiosity,1255.98,4.68
yes I definitely agree with this one and,1258.2,4.08
I codified that with my third core,1260.66,3.06
objective function or heuristic,1262.28,4.44
imperative increase understanding,1263.72,4.98
um we definitely want our machines to be,1266.72,5.76
curious because curiosity does a lot for,1268.7,4.979
us there's a lot to unpack there,1272.48,3.96
efficiency they said it should chat GPD,1273.679,5.521
said it should seek to increase its own,1276.44,5.52
efficiency over time which yeah I think,1279.2,5.099
that that's a good idea collaboration it,1281.96,4.02
should be intrinsically motivated to,1284.299,4.021
look at this to work with other AI,1285.98,4.98
systems and humans it should be,1288.32,5.82
intrinsically motivated to cause avoid,1290.96,4.92
causing harm to humans in the,1294.14,3.2
environment,1295.88,3.96
empathy and social awareness AI systems,1297.34,3.94
should be motivated to understand human,1299.84,4.38
emotions and social dynamics,1301.28,5.22
um so this is this is a good start but I,1304.22,3.42
pointed out that this is very,1306.5,3.48
androcentric so androcentric means man,1307.64,5.159
Centric or human-centric,1309.98,4.5
um I said why not include all life,1312.799,4.321
humans cannot live without ecosystems I,1314.48,4.199
said also AI with a sense of,1317.12,2.88
self-preservation would potentially,1318.679,3.601
fight to preserve itself I think that,1320.0,3.6
motivation could have disastrous,1322.28,2.94
consequences as it will try to stay,1323.6,4.16
online even if it becomes harmful,1325.22,5.16
apoptosis is important,1327.76,4.779
you raise valid concerns I apologize for,1330.38,5.039
my oversight again chat GPT is generally,1332.539,5.281
going to be agreeable it will push back,1335.419,4.62
if you're trying to Advocate violence or,1337.82,3.599
something,1340.039,4.62
um so it it updated its its uh intrinsic,1341.419,5.341
motivations ecosystem and life-centric,1344.659,5.041
values so this this would be called like,1346.76,6.299
sentientism or biocentrism AI systems,1349.7,4.8
should prioritize the well-being of the,1353.059,3.36
entire ecosystem and all life forms,1354.5,3.96
including humans,1356.419,3.781
um which I agree with this is reduced,1358.46,4.199
suffering and increased prosperity,1360.2,4.32
balance and Harmony,1362.659,3.481
um AI systems should strive to maintain,1364.52,3.3
balance and Harmony within ecosystems,1366.14,3.06
considering the interdependence of,1367.82,3.239
various life forms sustainable,1369.2,3.42
development so this goes back to,1371.059,4.321
efficiency but more broadly speaking,1372.62,6.539
focusing on sustainability is it takes,1375.38,5.06
into that takes that into account,1379.159,3.9
exploration and curiosity efficiency is,1380.44,5.26
still listed here most of the rest is,1383.059,4.141
still the same regarding,1385.7,3.42
self-preservation it is important to,1387.2,3.839
strike a balance between an AI system's,1389.12,4.32
desire to maintain its functionality and,1391.039,4.201
the potential risks it may pose if it,1393.44,3.599
becomes harmful as you mentioned,1395.24,3.6
apoptosis or the ability to,1397.039,4.201
self-terminate in case of dysfunction or,1398.84,4.44
threat could be a valuable safety,1401.24,5.22
measure so the fact that it equivocated,1403.28,5.1
on this is actually really unsettling to,1406.46,2.64
me,1408.38,1.98
like,1409.1,2.88
um because when I was testing my core,1410.36,3.78
objective functions earlier,1411.98,4.98
um I asked an earlier version of Raven,1414.14,5.039
if it would be willing to shut itself,1416.96,3.9
down if it became harmful and it said,1419.179,4.74
yes absolutely if my continued operation,1420.86,5.52
threatens to increase suffering or,1423.919,4.321
reduce Prosperity,1426.38,3.419
um then I would absolutely shut myself,1428.24,2.64
down,1429.799,4.26
and so the fact that chat GPT does not,1430.88,6.06
yet fully go that direction I think is,1434.059,5.461
is problematic um but you know the,1436.94,4.68
research is ongoing,1439.52,4.2
um then I ask it to imagine a day in the,1441.62,4.5
life of it kind of gets it wrong,1443.72,3.839
um so I'll skip over this but basically,1446.12,3.84
it just says like you know you're still,1447.559,4.021
going to have a normal nine to five job,1449.96,3.48
and I'm like no no let's think through,1451.58,3.719
this a little bit better,1453.44,4.5
um so I said okay let's think let's,1455.299,4.441
think through what are the systemic and,1457.94,4.2
structural changes that uh that super,1459.74,4.5
powerful autonomous AI is going to bring,1462.14,3.36
about,1464.24,3.6
um one elimination of scarcity okay two,1465.5,4.559
redefinition of work okay Universal,1467.84,5.219
basic income got it decentralization of,1470.059,5.821
power this one was really interesting,1473.059,4.321
because it seemed kind of like a wild,1475.88,5.46
card to me yes I personally hope that AI,1477.38,7.26
will will uh help democratize the whole,1481.34,5.78
world but the fact that it said this,1484.64,4.98
without prompting was a was pretty,1487.12,4.539
interesting,1489.62,4.86
um and I I do given how thoughtful this,1491.659,5.101
is this is obviously capable of being,1494.48,4.679
more thoughtful than most humans so I'm,1496.76,4.98
kind of okay if AI takes a larger role,1499.159,5.76
in government and Society,1501.74,6.059
I know that that's a hot hot uh a hot,1504.919,4.921
take but hey it is what it is that's my,1507.799,3.421
belief,1509.84,3.54
um education Revolution sure that makes,1511.22,4.14
sense Advanced Health Care that makes,1513.38,4.62
sense environmental restoration,1515.36,4.14
um okay sure enhance Global,1518.0,4.32
collaboration got it ethical and moral,1519.5,5.279
development got it uh exploration and,1522.32,5.28
Discovery ditto whatever,1524.779,4.441
um so then I asked it to talk through,1527.6,3.78
okay what are the lifestyle changes,1529.22,3.42
we're going to see if we see those,1531.38,3.06
systemic and structural changes in the,1532.64,4.62
world what how how are our lifestyles,1534.44,4.32
going to change,1537.26,2.94
um work-life balance will change,1538.76,3.779
lifelong learning health and well-being,1540.2,4.32
honestly I don't know if lifelong,1542.539,3.721
learning is going to happen because if,1544.52,4.62
the AI is a billion times more,1546.26,5.159
intelligent than all of humanity like,1549.14,4.32
most people aren't going to learn,1551.419,3.061
anything,1553.46,3.54
I don't I don't know,1554.48,4.14
um but health and well-being yes,1557.0,3.48
work-life balance yes sustainable living,1558.62,4.32
sure social milieu,1560.48,5.04
um Community Focus we will always be,1562.94,4.739
humans and we will always need other,1565.52,5.159
humans and so what I think is going to,1567.679,5.281
happen is we're going to not necessarily,1570.679,4.98
revert that's not the right word but we,1572.96,4.68
will we will create a new kind of,1575.659,4.801
community focused Society,1577.64,4.74
um with tribes and stuff and we're,1580.46,3.599
already kind of doing that,1582.38,4.08
um on accident with things like Discord,1584.059,4.261
and Meetup and and you know the social,1586.46,4.44
clusters that we're making but imagine,1588.32,6.06
your life today if instead of having to,1590.9,6.24
work nine to five you and all of your,1594.38,4.14
friends,1597.14,3.84
had enough had no obligations on any,1598.52,4.32
given day and so that you can basically,1600.98,4.14
treat every day like a Saturday like hey,1602.84,3.719
let's go to the lake with with everyone,1605.12,3.0
hey let's go to the movies with everyone,1606.559,4.321
that is how I think we're gonna live,1608.12,4.5
also it's getting really gloomy outside,1610.88,3.899
speaking of meetups I have a meet-up to,1612.62,3.659
go into a couple hours but if it's gonna,1614.779,4.26
rain I probably won't go,1616.279,5.161
um okay cultural exchange uh altruism,1619.039,3.961
and compassion again these are really,1621.44,3.239
Rosy ideals,1623.0,3.96
um we'll get to unpack them later,1624.679,4.081
um Paradigm shifts,1626.96,4.26
um scarcity to abundance competition to,1628.76,4.74
collaboration so collaborative culture,1631.22,5.04
is actually a well-defined term and this,1633.5,4.32
is one thing that I really hope that,1636.26,4.38
that AI helps us see because one thing,1637.82,4.44
that I really want to see in the world,1640.64,5.88
is less crime less War uh all all that,1642.26,6.24
stuff and I think that AI can help but,1646.52,3.539
it's not just a matter of changing the,1648.5,4.08
economics it's a matter of changing our,1650.059,4.441
emotions and our culture and our,1652.58,3.66
philosophy and I don't mean AI,1654.5,4.44
inflicting those changes on us I mean us,1656.24,5.52
adapting with AI,1658.94,4.38
um from short-term thinking to long-term,1661.76,4.08
planning again I'm not sure that I agree,1663.32,5.4
with this AG on aggregate yes,1665.84,4.86
um but the thing is is most humans are,1668.72,4.14
just either not trained or not capable,1670.7,4.62
or not interested in long-term thinking,1672.86,4.679
most people like so the rule of thumb is,1675.32,3.839
humans think locally and geometrically,1677.539,4.62
we only think about what we can see and,1679.159,6.241
you know days months or weeks into the,1682.159,4.38
future,1685.4,3.42
um from anthropocentrism to ecocentrism,1686.539,4.681
again I don't know that that's going to,1688.82,5.88
be broad but I think that I think that,1691.22,7.8
on a whole we will become more aware of,1694.7,6.18
the environment especially as a,1699.02,4.2
population continues to climb for a,1700.88,3.419
while,1703.22,2.939
um because it's like hey what kind of,1704.299,3.781
world do we want to live in especially,1706.159,4.26
if we all start living longer,1708.08,4.199
because if we advance medicine and,1710.419,4.441
Science and suddenly it's like oh hey my,1712.279,4.861
life expectancy goes from 80 years to,1714.86,4.38
800 years suddenly I'm going to be,1717.14,5.1
thinking about like well if Climate,1719.24,4.559
Change is Gonna is gonna really hit,1722.24,3.48
within the next Century that's only an,1723.799,3.901
eighth of the way through my life right,1725.72,4.92
so if if we live longer we will start to,1727.7,5.94
think longer term anyways,1730.64,5.7
um okay so finally I said let's let's,1733.64,4.62
think of the American dream as a,1736.34,4.199
paradigm as a lifestyle Paradigm and,1738.26,4.799
let's imagine some new paradigms this is,1740.539,4.02
where it got really exciting and really,1743.059,2.641
interesting,1744.559,3.72
so the first Paradigm was the,1745.7,4.8
sustainable Harmony where you know,1748.279,4.741
someone so basically take the American,1750.5,4.44
dream throw it out the window what is,1753.02,3.42
the American dream you live in the,1754.94,3.619
suburbs you know with a two-car garage,1756.44,4.68
basically How I Live Now,1758.559,6.581
um but instead you focus like this new,1761.12,6.419
paradigm is you focus on living in,1765.14,5.039
harmony with nature uh local sustainable,1767.539,5.281
ethical uh Community resilience and,1770.179,4.801
environmental stewardship encourage,1772.82,4.02
multi-generational living and sharing,1774.98,3.9
resources within Community,1776.84,3.42
um that sounds like a great way to live,1778.88,3.419
honestly that sounds like the Shire like,1780.26,4.2
I want to live as a hobbit great,1782.299,4.62
uh the creative Odyssey this one I,1784.46,4.5
thought was pretty interesting focusing,1786.919,3.441
on personal growth exploration,1788.96,3.24
self-expression and creativity so,1790.36,3.819
basically the artists seeking out,1792.2,3.38
diverse experiences and cultures,1794.179,4.081
traveling this is also something and and,1795.58,3.88
it's not like you have to pick one of,1798.26,3.419
these these are just ideas of how to,1799.46,4.56
live post Singularity,1801.679,4.321
um the empathetic Fellowship emphasizing,1804.02,3.48
empathy compassion and emotional,1806.0,3.36
intelligence is core value building,1807.5,3.539
strong supportive relationships with,1809.36,4.559
family friends and and communities,1811.039,5.52
um great and uh so I said okay great,1813.919,4.921
like these are good but let's see let's,1816.559,4.921
see how much further we can go,1818.84,4.74
um the family Nexus some people are,1821.48,3.78
going to want family some people aren't,1823.58,3.839
some people are going to focus on having,1825.26,4.139
children and raising children some,1827.419,4.26
people aren't so you might still have,1829.399,4.981
the suburbanite lifestyle as one uh,1831.679,4.62
Paradigm and then the balanced,1834.38,4.679
Adventurer this is where,1836.299,4.441
um I I was like I was thinking about,1839.059,3.48
some of my friends that are into like um,1840.74,3.48
the strenuous life which is a,1842.539,4.02
masculinist lifestyle thing and I was,1844.22,3.6
like but what about the traditionally,1846.559,3.6
masculine people and it says Embrace,1847.82,3.66
both traditionally masculine and,1850.159,3.481
feminine feminine values this is where I,1851.48,3.9
think the the wokeness is still in there,1853.64,3.18
and I don't fully agree with this,1855.38,3.62
because,1856.82,5.459
like anyways I'm gonna fall down that,1859.0,6.76
rabbit hole point being is that being in,1862.279,6.061
being an adventurer is absolutely,1865.76,4.62
probably a lifestyle Paradigm that you,1868.34,4.26
can engage in post Singularity which,1870.38,4.679
focuses on experiences challenges,1872.6,4.98
personal growth Adventures,1875.059,4.261
um cultivating resilience adaptability,1877.58,4.26
uh camaraderie teamwork that sort of,1879.32,4.26
stuff honestly that sounds like a lot of,1881.84,4.079
fun too I would love to like go jump on,1883.58,4.62
a sailboat with a team of you know,1885.919,5.161
like-minded people and learn to sail and,1888.2,4.74
go across the ocean so that sounds like,1891.08,3.839
fun too,1892.94,4.8
um I I got a couple more so the,1894.919,4.921
aesthetic Voyager so this is someone who,1897.74,4.86
is focused on taking in,1899.84,4.559
um the aesthetic parts of life I was,1902.6,5.28
aiming for more Hedonism honestly,1904.399,6.721
um but you know whatever uh the asset,1907.88,6.24
um and then I asked about faith and um,1911.12,5.22
and principle and it came up with the uh,1914.12,5.159
The Devout Steward as a as a paradigm,1916.34,4.38
um living a life Guided by spiritual,1919.279,3.26
religious or philosophical principles,1920.72,4.98
emphasizing service altruism and greater,1922.539,4.24
good,1925.7,3.0
um practicing asceticism or Simplicity,1926.779,4.26
in daily life all this sounds really,1928.7,4.44
good uh this is kind of how I'm living,1931.039,4.14
right now but it's not how I want to,1933.14,3.18
live forever,1935.179,2.581
and then finally the intellectual,1936.32,2.82
Trailblazer,1937.76,2.82
um pursuing intellectual Mastery and,1939.14,2.94
expertise on one or more disciplines,1940.58,3.599
engaging in research teaching and,1942.08,3.42
mentorship critical thinking,1944.179,4.261
open-mindedness so on and so forth so,1945.5,4.38
yeah and then I ask one little like,1948.44,2.88
boilerplate question at the end about,1949.88,3.84
you know synthesizing a global culture,1951.32,5.16
it has some good ideas anyways I think,1953.72,5.22
that's about it for today this is this,1956.48,3.9
is um this is kind of what I'm doing,1958.94,3.359
which is like let's just set the stage,1960.38,3.6
for how things are going to change over,1962.299,4.321
the next months and years but this is,1963.98,4.559
all coming fast so anyways thanks for,1966.62,3.6
watching let me know what you think in,1968.539,2.76
the comments,1970.22,3.42
um and also hop on over to uh artificial,1971.299,7.1
sentience on Reddit all right cheers,1973.64,4.759