diff --git "a/determination_label_extracted_sentences.csv" "b/determination_label_extracted_sentences.csv"
new file mode 100644--- /dev/null
+++ "b/determination_label_extracted_sentences.csv"
@@ -0,0 +1,53978 @@
+decisionID;extracted_sentences_determination
+95013;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+121849;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54780;['appeal is allowed']
+88321;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+113298;['application to reopen an appeal that was abandoned is dismissed']
+80374;['appeal is allowed']
+123876;['appeal is dismissed']
+80986;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91451;['dismiss this appeal']
+110715;['rad denies the request for an oral hearing']
+79901;['appeal is allowed']
+107825;['appeal of the principal appellant is dismissed']
+109276;['reject his claim']
+113800;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm that xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx']
+60044;['claims fail']
+54816;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132767;['rad must reject these explanations']
+61451;['302 (c.a.']
+94667;['appeal is dismissed']
+125485;['appeal is dismissed']
+91377;['appeal is allowed']
+122896;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76416;['appeal is dismissed']
+54637;['appeal to be dismissed']
+77111;['appeal isallowedundersection']
+104101;['not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+124550;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109001;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+22993;['appeal be dismissed']
+130853;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision that', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69276;['appeal is allowed']
+86474;['appeal is allowed']
+69797;['appeal is allowed']
+95779;['appeal is dismissed']
+79937;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+95218;['appeal is dismissed']
+132774;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+77067;['appeal is allowed']
+123937;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+83670;['allow the minister’s motion to dismiss the appeal']
+98396;['appeal isallowed']
+106308;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+57773;['appeal is dismissed']
+29724;['appeal is allowed']
+70598;['appeal to be reopened']
+94386;['appeal is dismissed']
+90657;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxxis rejected']
+101903;['claimantxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+74225;['appeal is allowed']
+54252;['application will be dismissed']
+67739;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96698;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131915;['appeal is dismissed']
+96441;['appeal were dismissed']
+127455;['appeal be dismissed']
+123334;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+78776;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98922;['appeal is allowed']
+98535;['appeal is allowed']
+91224;['appeal is allowed']
+118176;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+40136;['appeal be dismissed']
+32172;['appeal isallowed']
+97568;['appeal is allowed']
+136419;['appeal is dismissed']
+141545;['appeal is allowed']
+60041;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103088;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+100620;['appeal is allowed']
+134307;['appeal is dismissed']
+45990;['appeal is denied']
+87146;['appeal is allowed']
+62625;['appeal is allowed']
+140066;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+135919;['rad finds that it is unable to confirm, or set aside and substitute its own decision']
+83027;['appeal is allowed']
+69275;['appeal is dismissed']
+96675;['appeal is dismissed']
+134216;['appeal is dismissed']
+107482;['appeal is dismissed']
+71361;['appeal is allowed']
+108698;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+56745;['appeal was previously dismissed']
+147874;['dismiss the appeal']
+150638;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+147799;['appeal is allowed']
+89453;['appeal be dismissed']
+102015;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+97388;['reject his claim']
+96919;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100845;['302 (c.a.']
+80662;['claimant is not excludable']
+105905;['claimant xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+98554;['appeal is allowed']
+67809;['appeal is allowed']
+102252;['dismiss the present appeal']
+68879;['302 (c.a.']
+39422;['confirm the rpd decision that', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82579;['appeal of agnes sia mansou is dismissed']
+102909;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither a “convention refugee”']
+99303;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+111332;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+61056;['appeal is allowed.the']
+95871;['appeal is terminated']
+102197;['appeal isallowed']
+128742;['dismiss the appeal']
+128375;['removal order is set aside']
+101168;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+21395;['refugee division, therefore, rejects the application filed by the minister']
+134292;['appeal is allowed']
+52107;['neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75467;['appeal is terminated']
+60888;['appeal is determined to be abandonedunderss']
+102673;['confirms the determination of the rpd']
+92930;['appeal is being allowed']
+64000;['appeal is allowed']
+128902;['confirm the determination', 'appellants xxxx xxxxxxxxand xxxx xxxx are excluded from refugee protection']
+47804;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+151426;['associate claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129155;['appeal is dismissed']
+35913;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+47168;['appeal is terminated']
+61902;['appeal is allowed']
+140920;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+74733;['appeal is dismissed']
+95393;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+113511;['appeal is allowed']
+62442;['appeal is allowed.the']
+91449;['appeal isallowed']
+77052;['appeal is allowed']
+78169;['negative']
+40656;['appeal is dismissed']
+76683;['appeal is allowed']
+60512;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+46073;['appeal is allowed']
+94777;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+79990;['panel rejects their refugee protection claim']
+64210;['application is allowed']
+96118;['302 (c.a.)']
+56640;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+71735;['appeal is allowed']
+76497;['appeal is dismissed']
+100925;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+91169;['officer’s   decision is valid in law']
+69704;['appeal is dismissed']
+80464;['appeal is dismissed']
+24513;['appeal is allowed']
+101313;['appeal is allowed']
+61931;['iad declines to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction']
+17945;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+105365;['302 (c.a.']
+123935;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+99095;['panel finds the refusal is legally valid']
+140792;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+73035;['appeal is dismissed']
+94513;['appeal is allowed']
+113248;['appeal fail']
+91443;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96648;['claim is denied']
+93085;['claimants are determined to be neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110976;['appeal is dismissed']
+100892;['appeal is dismissed']
+5595;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96094;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+61890;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpaparticularly in']
+69175;['appeal was first heard']
+57900;['appeal isdeterminedto be']
+85619;['appeal is dismissed']
+94444;['appellants’ argument']
+23092;['appeal is dismissed']
+68091;['allow the present appeal']
+76562;['respondents are neither convention refugees pursuant tos']
+13628;['appeal is dismissed.i']
+76717;['appeal is allowed']
+68751;['dismiss the appeal']
+108707;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+74171;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+123926;['allow the appeal']
+83834;['appeal isallowed']
+82433;['appeal is determined']
+72555;['dismiss the appeal']
+98283;['appeal is dismissed']
+124429;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neitherconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97831;['claim is rejected']
+136690;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+63175;['appeal isallowed']
+92804;['appeal of savorn chuon is dismissed']
+23847;['appeal is allowed']
+127471;['appeal is dismissed']
+26679;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+74027;['302 (c.a.)']
+123367;['confirms the decision of the rpd member']
+106284;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97600;['appeal isallowed']
+76782;['appeal isallowed']
+125518;['appeal is dismissed']
+95066;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand', 'rad finds that thesur placeassessment in this matter']
+95074;['appeal is granted']
+80514;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+67201;['appeal is dismissed']
+129162;['appeal is allowed']
+88056;['claimant is not a citizen of china']
+22123;['appeal is dismissed']
+89399;['negative']
+101045;['claimants are also not \xa0persons in need of protection']
+100012;['claimants are convention refugees']
+78741;['appeal is allowed']
+76508;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+87744;['decision is valid in law']
+42284;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+70084;['claimant excluded']
+99182;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+56917;['appeal isallowed']
+97233;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+81393;['appeal is dismissed']
+19162;['appeal of kazimierz dominik wronowski is allowed']
+94342;['appeal was allowed']
+71569;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+88326;['appeal of is dismissed']
+50668;['appeal were dismissed']
+94444;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76499;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+150684;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+67255;['appeal isallowed']
+74541;['appeals are allowed']
+104850;['appeal is abandoned']
+68175;['appeal of alhasan bin fuseni is dismissed']
+19120;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+113734;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+53858;['appeal is allowed']
+66782;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+84798;['appeal is allowed']
+152924;['rad concurs with the rpd']
+64314;['removal order is set aside']
+93615;['appeal isallowed']
+131028;['appeal is allowed']
+68206;['appeal of shamsher singh bhachu is dismissed']
+97579;['appeal is dismissed']
+76347;['dismiss the appeal']
+109039;['appeals are dismissed']
+69067;['removal order is set aside']
+135128;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+19233;['appeal is dismissed']
+142109;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+150710;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99978;['are rejected']
+141210;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89815;['appeal is allowed']
+95586;['appeal is terminated']
+97482;['302 (c.a.']
+140854;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64227;['dismissing this appeal']
+127351;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+104351;['appeal is dismissed']
+125498;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+102482;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+104354;['appeal is dismissed']
+107050;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136722;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+67921;['appeal is allowed']
+122678;['appeal is allowed']
+98575;['appeal is allowed']
+66777;['application to reopen is allowed']
+150782;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68620;['appeal is allowed']
+100910;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+123458;['rad confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125341;['appeal is dismissed']
+97901;['appeal is dismissed']
+99707;['allows the application to reinstate the appeal']
+97572;['appeal is allowed']
+11799;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+76712;['appeal will proceed to a full oral hearing']
+123366;['appeal must be dismissed']
+46076;['appeal isallowedand']
+71566;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+99542;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62487;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129401;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+101142;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+57065;['appellant’s claim fails']
+77681;['appeal allowed–']
+102122;['appeal proceeded']
+88158;['appeal is dismissed']
+90776;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+103608;['reject his claim']
+70074;['removal order is set aside']
+71184;['appeal of deepak kochar is allowed']
+98038;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+94949;['appeal is allowed']
+96993;['appeal is allowed']
+84609;['appeal is dismissed']
+47106;['appeal beallowed']
+87027;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+91221;['appeal is allowed']
+71081;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+19307;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94678;['appeal is allowed']
+82769;['appeal isallowedand']
+91577;['302 (c.a.']
+77551;['appeal isallowed']
+74741;['dismissing this appeal']
+23012;['allow the appeal']
+55213;['appeal is dismissed']
+52653;['neither convention refugees']
+80032;['xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+142964;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+85317;['appeal is dismissed']
+79638;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+106331;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+152945;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+87588;['negative']
+60974;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+108776;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+59765;['appeal isallowed']
+48105;['appeal is allowed']
+113243;['appeal be dismissed']
+108828;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68352;['appeal is dismissed']
+74261;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+72676;['appeal isdeclaredabandoned undersubsection']
+122908;['appeal is allowed']
+90679;['appeals should be allowed']
+100085;['appeal of wen ke mei is dismissed']
+92754;['appeal isallowed']
+77275;['appeal is terminated']
+68682;['appeal is allowed']
+94231;['appeal is dismissed']
+147567;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+121849;['allow these appeals']
+48412;['appeal is allowed']
+74545;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction to hear the appeal']
+72812;['appeal is allowed']
+13981;['appeal isallowed']
+96636;['appeal is allowed']
+88014;['declare the claim to be abandoned']
+31424;['appeal is allowed']
+68222;['appeal isallowed']
+107038;['appeal be allowed']
+67666;['appeal isallowed']
+94734;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+124312;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+101441;['302 (c.a.)']
+142997;['appeal is allowed']
+105224;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+102974;['appeal is allowed']
+62849;['appeal is under 63(4)']
+77918;['appeal is allowed']
+59365;['dismiss the appeal']
+101357;['appeal is allowed']
+88980;['appeal is allowed']
+24204;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxand her minor daughter', 'neither “convention\xa0refugees”']
+104357;['appeal is allowed']
+75653;['appeal is allowed']
+96933;['rad allows the appeal']
+24454;['appeal of queen nneoma mbah is dismissed']
+98652;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+100645;['dismissing the appeal']
+123621;['appeal is allowed']
+100191;['appeal isallowed']
+86214;['appeal is allowed']
+59668;['appeal isallowed']
+80251;['claimant is not a convention refugees', 'not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+91592;['dismiss the appeal']
+130750;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+82893;['appeal is allowed']
+12235;['appeal is dismissed']
+101406;['dismiss this appeal']
+129218;['appeal is allowed']
+141788;['appeal of dorjee gyaltsen is dismissed']
+110275;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+87432;['appeal isallowedand']
+98499;['appeal is moot']
+69789;['302 (c.a.']
+30380;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+107225;['rad cannot confirm the determination of the rpd']
+96509;['appeal is allowed']
+42317;['appeal is dismissed']
+132425;['appeals are dismissed']
+91267;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+6606;['refusal is therefore well‑founded in law']
+68207;['appeal is dismissed']
+52932;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal of gulzar singh sumal is dismissed']
+96877;['appeal is terminated']
+102541;['allow the appeal']
+69400;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+108777;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89832;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+104472;['appeal is dismissed']
+94161;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+151978;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98625;['appeal is allowed.the']
+97806;['claimantxxxxxxx xxxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+105909;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+92612;['claimants,xxxxxxxxx, aliasxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx,xxxxxxxxx, aliasxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxx,are not “convention\xa0refugees”']
+95604;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+55909;['appeal is allowed']
+100303;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26790;['appeal is allowed in law']
+76901;['allow the appeal']
+88431;['claims are rejected']
+86341;['appeal is allowed']
+95140;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+21346;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+79323;['appeal is terminated']
+59979;['negative']
+83185;['appeal is dismissed']
+101669;['appeal of hamidullah barkza is dismissed']
+107859;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+116766;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+116965;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+61003;['appeal is dismissed']
+151845;['appeal is dismissed']
+107928;['determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+50504;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+124344;['302 (c.a.)']
+96976;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx,is not a “convention refugee”']
+123631;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45998;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97109;['decision is well founded in law']
+61444;['302 (c.a.']
+95680;['appeal is dismissed']
+67615;['appeal itallowed']
+97470;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76657;['appeal is allowed']
+95240;['appeal isallowed']
+84022;['appeal isallowed']
+79951;['claim is rejected']
+57552;['appeal of diana agnes szalek is dismissed']
+34929;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95166;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47861;['appeal is dismissed']
+141601;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+114354;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92041;['appeal will be dismissed']
+66767;['appeal fails']
+97337;['negative']
+59808;['appeal is allowed']
+102687;['appeal is allowed']
+50796;['appeal be dismissed']
+151401;['302 (c.a.']
+70009;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+69067;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+124167;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71989;['appeal is allowed']
+50796;['appeal be dismissed']
+78051;['decision of the visa officer is thus legally valid']
+84450;['appeal is allowed.the']
+98245;['orders your departure from canada']
+138823;['removal orders areset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+93971;['appeal is dismissed']
+63926;['appeal isallowed']
+57793;['appeal isallowed']
+37869;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+44019;['appeal is dismissed']
+132823;['allow the appeal']
+78033;['dismiss the appeal']
+77005;['302 (c.a.']
+97467;['not convention refugees', 'or persons in need of protection']
+47572;['appeal is allowed']
+125397;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141658;['appeal is allowed']
+21326;['refugee division determines that xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+45228;['appeal is dismissed']
+76283;['decision is well founded in law']
+38413;['appeal is dismissed']
+107131;['appeals are dismissed']
+125116;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99300;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140723;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108072;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+121395;['appeals of the two united states born appellants']
+138832;['appeal be dismissed']
+105802;['appeal of quyen vinh truong is dismissed']
+92038;['appeal isallowed']
+47930;['appeal is determined to have beenabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+135129;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+25980;['appeal isallowed']
+27294;['302 (c.a.']
+84461;['appeal is dismissed']
+60947;['appeal should be withdrawn']
+26701;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+71271;['appeal is allowed']
+71176;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+93584;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+109003;['claimant is not a convention refuge']
+107815;['appeal is allowed']
+79244;['appeal is allowed']
+20443;['appeal is dismissed']
+72066;['appeal should be dismissed']
+74951;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+56691;['appeal were dismissed']
+27253;['appeal is dismissed']
+115220;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+144933;['they are not refugees']
+90325;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+151518;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+130776;['appeal isdismissed.']
+69445;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+49631;['appeal is allowed']
+121420;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99101;['appeal isallowedand']
+65645;['appeal is allowed']
+86346;['appeal is determined']
+29536;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+92578;['appeal is terminated']
+128436;['appeal is dismissed']
+89258;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+100725;['302 (c.a.']
+63871;['appeal is allowed']
+107181;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+13944;['appeal is dismissed']
+111182;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95774;['appeal is dismissed']
+67363;['dismiss the appeal']
+47156;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+123737;['appeal be dismissed']
+57509;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+85624;['appeal is dismissed']
+45203;['appeal isallowed']
+38418;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+72704;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+64650;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+124415;['substitute a determination']
+61862;['appeal is dismissed']
+144405;['allow the appeal of the principal appellant']
+87321;['removal order is set aside']
+104458;['appeal of mohan singh kandhola is dismissed']
+72891;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95134;['appeal is allowed']
+69222;['rad agrees with this reasoning']
+81201;['appeal is dismissed']
+143461;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+139880;['appeal is allowed']
+55107;['appeal is allowed']
+136109;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123010;['allow their appeal']
+60181;['appeal is allowed']
+47132;['appeal is allowed']
+65633;['appeal was allowed']
+101692;['appeal is allowed']
+67803;['appeal is allowed']
+90853;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52923;['allow the appellant’s appeal']
+104859;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+61487;['appeal isallowed']
+117124;['appellant aytug celikbas has not lost his permanent resident status']
+116746;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+114386;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+125574;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+58311;['rad cannot substitute its own decision']
+105877;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+98273;['appeal is allowed']
+45208;['appeal is allowed']
+31394;['nor a psychiatrist nor a registered psychologist']
+125145;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+85614;['dismiss your appeal', 'appeal is dismissed']
+80570;['appeal is allowed']
+114425;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125238;['rad finds the opposite in paragraph\xa013 of the rpd decision']
+99980;['appeal is dismissed']
+55180;['appeal is dismissed']
+83542;['decision is valid in law']
+31047;['appeal is allowed']
+103495;['allow the appeal']
+87705;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89032;['negative']
+91908;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+113634;['allow the appeal']
+88443;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx,', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+123611;['dismiss the appeal']
+44181;['rad concurs with the rpd’s finding on this issue']
+59181;['appeal is allowed']
+93667;['appeal is allowed']
+85874;['negative']
+78143;['claimants’ removal totanzaniawould']
+90051;['negative']
+92501;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96896;['appeal is dismissed']
+84641;['removal order is set aside']
+145514;['appeal is allowed']
+103112;['appeal terminated']
+72211;['leads me to conclude that he was not a careless, negligent and irresponsible young man']
+39073;['appeal is allowed']
+113227;['appeal isallowed']
+105232;['not a person in need of protection']
+71600;['appeal is allowed']
+116365;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+81419;['appeal is allowed']
+96794;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+93890;['appeal is dismissed']
+98451;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+143537;['appeal is allowed']
+84481;['appeal is dismissed']
+39063;['dismissed the appeal']
+76853;['appeal isallowedand']
+104002;['appeal is dismissed']
+128383;['appeal should be dismissed']
+64208;['appeal is dismissed']
+86852;['appeal isallowed']
+47755;['allows the appeal']
+96138;['appeal should be dismissed']
+66329;['appeal isallowed']
+76552;['appeal is allowed']
+94594;['appeal is dismissed']
+97893;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+107949;['appeal is dismissed']
+47709;['thattheclaimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+98499;['allows the minister’s application to dismiss the appeal']
+96567;['appeal isallowed']
+100909;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+100124;['appeal isallowedand']
+146890;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81184;['appeal is dismissed']
+54160;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+147567;['302 (c.a.)']
+94764;['appeal of is dismissed']
+109288;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+101870;['i am going to dismiss the appeal']
+97508;['negative']
+127337;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+55883;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+28061;['appeal of josefina diaz is dismissed']
+131010;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84814;['appeal were dismissed']
+99933;['claimants are not a “convention refugees']
+67666;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+37406;['determination is valid in law']
+36137;['appeal is dismissed']
+80217;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+141335;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+89946;['dismissing this appeal']
+77905;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+100535;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98104;['panel rejects the claim']
+142915;['302 (c.a.']
+98280;['appeal is allowed']
+86753;['decision of the adjudicator cannot be allowed to stand']
+107811;['claimants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+75945;['dismiss the appeal']
+95581;['appeal is dismissed']
+38253;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+59855;['appeal is allowed']
+124639;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+111347;['appeal is allowed']
+107471;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146839;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+57557;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107909;['set aside the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugees”']
+85380;['appeal is allowed']
+154095;['302 (c.a.']
+107887;['claimants, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees']
+84485;['appeal is dismissed']
+38394;['appeal is dismissed']
+131222;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+57741;['appeal isallowed.the']
+107042;['appeal is dismissed']
+107126;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+92465;['appeal isallowed']
+81237;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+143643;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision']
+90076;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+123395;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133689;['iset aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute a determinationthatxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+47327;['appeal is allowed']
+95867;['allow the appeal']
+97472;['appeal is terminated']
+92815;['appeal is dismissed']
+92246;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+116187;['appeal is allowed']
+139454;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+68102;['appeal is dismissed']
+99880;['1019, paragraphs67 and 68']
+73337;['…]”']
+152784;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not inadmissible in canada']
+75476;['dismissed the appeal']
+61960;['appeal is dismissed']
+57556;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+56913;['appeal is dismissed']
+98994;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72873;['appeal is dismissed']
+152945;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102459;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+95556;['appeal is dismissed']
+88105;['302 (c.a.']
+91112;['appeals are allowed.the']
+95275;['appeal isallowed']
+91336;['appeal isallowed']
+63055;['appeal of ravi amrit bassi is dismissed']
+105598;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+74681;['appeal of ahmed saleem is dismissed']
+76088;['appeal abandoned']
+56744;['regulation is intended to protect the integrity of the immigration system']
+82044;['appeal of chi bon luu is allowed']
+88429;['negative']
+35035;['removal order is set aside']
+94573;['appeal is allowed']
+140915;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132374;['appeal is dismissed']
+127434;['appeal isallowed']
+70666;['appeal should be dismissed']
+84438;['appeal is allowed']
+107706;['supports allowing the appeal.']
+83718;['appeal is dismissed']
+55197;['reject his claim for refugee protection']
+113216;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination']
+97640;['claimants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+70228;['dismissal of the present appeal']
+81259;['appeal is allowed']
+123970;['allow her appeal and set aside the decision of the rpd']
+102065;['appeal is allowed']
+93581;['application to cancel the stay is denied']
+94392;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+103893;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+79209;['appeal isallowed']
+108131;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+33692;['appeal is allowed']
+95403;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+61303;['appeal is allowed']
+98007;['claim is rejected']
+47721;['appeal of nachhattar kaur dhaliwal is dismissed']
+71630;['appeal is allowed']
+36573;['appeal is allowed']
+74561;['appeal is allowed']
+74775;['302 (c.a.']
+130955;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76773;['appeal isallowed']
+90050;['appeal is dismissed']
+107671;['appeal is allowed']
+129187;['appeal was dismissed']
+98068;['tribunal rejects their claim']
+59910;['appeal is dismissed']
+69065;['appeal is dismissed']
+145842;['appeal is allowed']
+105896;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+100524;['claimants have failed to establish a well-founded fear of persecution', 'claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+102534;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+131734;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+89219;['appeal isallowed']
+92539;['appeal isdismissed.']
+88454;['negative']
+151833;['appeal is dismissed']
+134406;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+79920;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+96746;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+111165;['appeal is dismissed']
+123921;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124478;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47393;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123968;['appeal is allowed in law']
+76914;['appeal is dismissed']
+87215;['appeal is allowed']
+126420;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+148773;['appeal is dismissed']
+124654;['302 (c.a.']
+83152;['appeal is dismissed']
+72181;['appeal is dismissed']
+100964;['appeal is allowed']
+96244;['appeal isallowed']
+90745;['appeal of fang liu is, therefore, dismissed']
+143146;['appeal is dismissed']
+49978;['immigration appeal division orders the appellant’s departure fromcanada']
+84799;['claimants are therefore neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+138837;['appeal is abandoned']
+40772;['rad finds no need to go further in its analysis']
+107066;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+86623;['appeal is dismissed']
+51289;['appeal is dismissed']
+95567;['appeal is dismissed']
+96543;['appeal is dismissed']
+109628;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+90752;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124366;['appeal is allowed']
+61806;['negative']
+152924;['appellant is not a convention refugee, nor, a person in need of protection']
+140210;['substitute my own decision that the pa is a convention refugee']
+148629;['removal order is set aside']
+99071;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+138851;['appeals are dismissed']
+124179;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62834;['allow this appeal']
+62882;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89439;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106149;['appeal isallowed']
+101036;['302 (c.a.']
+139874;['claimants have failed to establish a serious possibility of persecution']
+100013;['panel rejects this claim']
+82573;['appeal is allowed']
+42304;['allow the appeal']
+143550;['are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+111348;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+136719;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97291;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+102896;['claimants xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+63826;['appeal of karolina blaszczak is allowed']
+49135;['appeal is dismissed']
+83911;['appeal is allowed']
+17379;['appeal is dismissed']
+83723;['appeal is dismissed']
+56900;['appeal is allowed']
+147610;['rad finds the appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+56962;['appeal is dismissed']
+144020;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57810;['appeal is dismissed']
+95317;['dismiss the appeal']
+145573;['irb – id decision: x vs canada (minister of public safety and emergency preparedness),b6-00725-c (decision dated 2017-04-04).']
+94775;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+123067;['appeal is allowed']
+131050;['appeal is allowed']
+101299;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100525;['appeal isallowed']
+151618;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77688;['appeal isallowed']
+153273;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+63983;['allow the appeal']
+91125;['appeal is allowed']
+100482;['dismiss an appeal']
+148999;['appeal is allowed']
+131195;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+117111;['appeal is dismissed']
+123651;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100550;['appeal isallowedand']
+110310;['appeal is dismissed']
+83675;['refusal is thus well founded in law']
+94397;['appeal was allowed by the division']
+71795;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+64580;['claimants are persons in need of protection', 'allows their claim for refugee protection']
+95271;['appeal is terminated']
+123905;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+95888;['appeal is dismissed']
+62470;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+95611;['302 (c.a.']
+80119;['appeal is allowed']
+57300;['appeal is dismissed']
+31435;['nor a permanent resident of canada']
+108062;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76099;['appeal is allowed']
+94453;['appeal is dismissed']
+86219;['appeal is dismissed']
+120842;['302 (c.a.']
+59549;['appeal be allowed']
+101433;['panel finds that the immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+87099;['appeal is allowed']
+93347;['appeal isallowed']
+24503;['appeal is allowed']
+132268;['appeal is allowed']
+61003;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+143910;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+125524;['dismiss the appeal']
+74526;['appeal isallowed']
+74769;['appeal isallowed']
+14581;['appeal is dismissed']
+57026;['appeal is dismissed']
+129241;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76523;['appeal isallowed']
+116776;['appeal is dismissed']
+47767;['appeal isallowed']
+47369;['appeal is allowed']
+94773;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+139448;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+66658;['appeal is being allowed in law']
+89576;['appeal is terminated']
+142484;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95936;['rad finds the rpd’s failure to do so amounts']
+96799;['appeal is dismissed']
+47340;['appeal is dismissed']
+143141;['decision as written cannot stand']
+46085;['appeal isallowed']
+82879;['appeal of harpreet kaur dhaliwal is dismissed']
+110938;['dismisses the appeal']
+144386;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143178;['302 (c.a.']
+50258;['appeal be allowed']
+95200;['appeal is allowed']
+111326;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant are neither\xa0 convention refugee nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+78663;['appeal were dismissed']
+60052;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+68151;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+61546;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84638;['appeal is terminated']
+87388;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+123339;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+142294;['appeal is allowed']
+14334;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate reasons']
+62955;['appeal is dismissed']
+123434;['appeal is allowed']
+54276;['appeal is dismissed']
+77479;['dismissing the appeal']
+82574;['allow his appeal']
+124798;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93550;['appeal is allowed']
+90500;['appeal isallowed']
+60407;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71184;['appeal is allowed']
+75653;['appeal is allowed']
+147597;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+75082;['appeal is allowed']
+80245;['claim is rejected']
+146560;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+96730;['appeal is dismissed']
+60875;['appeal is dismissed']
+96379;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+131021;['appeal is dismissed']
+37827;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+88178;['appeal is dismissed']
+91633;['appeal is dismissed']
+62935;['appeal is dismissed']
+77255;['appeal isallowed']
+72067;['appeal is allowed']
+143246;['rad finds he is not a person in need of protection']
+65603;['appeal is allowed']
+141223;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91245;['appeal is dismissed']
+95537;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99770;['appeal is allowed']
+47568;['appeal isallowed']
+95822;['appeal is dismissed']
+129530;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+31983;['appeal is allowed']
+62456;['dismiss the claims of the minor']
+96881;['appeal is allowed']
+69486;['dismiss the appeal']
+95858;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+94423;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+107806;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+75836;['appeal is allowed']
+143860;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+66496;['thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+138861;['appeal would fail']
+81305;['appeal is allowed']
+127448;['appeal of augustine edewede ighekpe is allowed']
+144897;['appeal be dismissed']
+72310;['appeal isdismissedand a departure order is made against the appellant.under']
+65598;['appeal is dismissed']
+9680;['appeal is allowed']
+56613;['appeal is allowed']
+102942;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+120824;['appeal is allowed']
+94652;['appeal is dismissed']
+83077;['appeal of li zhu is dismissed']
+130780;['appeal is allowed']
+94141;['appeal is allowed']
+147628;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+105799;['appeal is dismissed']
+52524;['appeal ofarmando lezarda salvadoris dismissed forres judicata']
+75927;['allow this appeal']
+67422;['302 (c.a.']
+90106;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee']
+72642;['appeal is dismissed']
+60071;['appeal is dismissed']
+131104;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87319;['appellant lost his permanent resident status']
+117121;['appeal is allowed']
+111014;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+12234;['appeal is allowed']
+26854;['claimants, ms. xxxxxxxxxxxxxand her daughter, xxxxxxxxxxx,']
+112393;['appeal is dismissed']
+90092;['negative']
+100088;['appeal were not allowed']
+95502;['appeal is dismissed']
+152911;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98512;['negative']
+100870;['appeal is dismissed']
+76522;['tribunal dismisses this appeal in law and in equity']
+17370;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+82450;['appeal is terminated']
+52290;['appeal is allowed in law']
+122971;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+73207;['appeal is terminated']
+77012;['appeal is allowed']
+61936;['appeal of elaine goldade is dismissed']
+66660;['appeal isallowed']
+24467;['appeal is allowed']
+93067;['appeal is rejected']
+83240;['appeal is allowed']
+131521;['appeal is dismissed']
+104486;['appeal is dismissed']
+54638;['appeal is dismissed']
+57510;['application should be dismissed']
+63126;['negative']
+147789;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+106445;['appeal be dismissed']
+123634;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35229;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+40130;['appeal is dismissed']
+19157;['appeal is dismissed']
+97933;['appeal is dismissed']
+100774;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+99183;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+87072;['decision made by the visa officer is invalid in law']
+49235;['dismiss the appeal']
+68280;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+69414;['appeal isallowed']
+73190;['appeal is allowed']
+86312;['appeal is allowed forjin zhang']
+94275;['302 (c.a.']
+47378;['appeal is dismissed']
+80728;['appeal is allowed']
+85389;['appeal is dismissed']
+95987;['panel rejects the refugee protection claims']
+124083;['appellant is excluded from protection']
+92522;['appeal is dismissed']
+97624;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of claimants xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx']
+143638;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+122954;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+35876;['appeal is allowed']
+139800;['appeal is allowed']
+53437;['decision is well-founded in law and in fact']
+95010;['appeal is dismissed']
+77235;['appeal is allowed']
+38895;['appeal were dismissed']
+151511;['appeal is allowed']
+134221;['appeal is allowed']
+96565;['appeal is dismissed']
+96348;['appeal is allowed']
+107042;['substitutes its determination']
+96106;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+77006;['dismissing this appeal']
+71140;['appeal is allowed']
+100107;['302 (c.a.']
+121406;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+42394;['removal orders areset aside']
+106876;['appeal is allowed']
+69142;['appeal is allowed']
+101477;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+120758;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+70468;['appeal isallowed']
+98610;['appeal is allowed']
+81170;['appeal is dismissed']
+72905;['appeal isallowed']
+132792;['dismiss the appeal']
+97845;['panel rejects the claim']
+144267;['decision is valid in law']
+46987;['allow the appeal']
+46017;['appeal isallowed']
+82654;['appeal is allowed']
+5147;['appeals are dismissed']
+71540;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+89423;['appeal is terminated']
+113730;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+96661;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+142475;['rad finds that that the rpd correctly decided that thexxxxandxxxxare not refugees']
+87480;['appeal is dismissed']
+76511;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+83954;['appeal is also allowed']
+99599;['appeal is dismissed']
+133258;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+142074;['claimant is not a genuine falun gong practitioner', 'claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+94759;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+88262;['appeal is allowed']
+98313;['application is denied']
+73326;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+138835;['appeal is dismissed']
+95496;['appeal is dismissed']
+95271;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+77067;['appeal of olena buryak is allowed']
+101694;['appeal is allowed']
+87820;['appeal is dismissed']
+108854;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+36187;['appeal is not allowed']
+124364;['appeal is allowed']
+14698;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+61910;['appeal isallowed']
+124976;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124800;['appeal is allowed']
+40152;['appeal is allowed']
+96511;['appeal is allowed']
+88514;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor in need of protection']
+31977;['appeal is allowed']
+153253;['appellant is not a “convention refugee']
+74460;['appeal is allowed']
+71413;['appeal is allowed']
+100320;['claimants,xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx\xa0xxxxxxandxxxxx xxxx xxxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+55252;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+69358;['appeal is dismissed']
+99844;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+121543;['appeal is allowed']
+94832;['appeal is dismissed']
+106153;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+101520;['claim is therefore rejected']
+77278;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89229;['302 (c.a.']
+100991;['appeal is allowed']
+69934;['appeal was dismissed']
+27623;['appeal is terminated']
+99372;['visa officer’s finding is valid in law']
+59190;['appeal is determined']
+82181;['appeal is allowed']
+87224;['appeal must be dismissed']
+122371;['appellant is a convention refugees']
+95548;['appeal isallowed']
+26932;['xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are convention refugees']
+123028;['decision of the rpd is set aside']
+152239;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87199;['appeal isallowed']
+95788;['appellant was not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+85925;['appeal is dismissed']
+102670;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+76775;['appeal is allowed']
+101705;['appeal isallowed']
+61384;['allow the appeal']
+99236;['appellant does not meet the requirements of subsection 130 (1) (b) of the regulations']
+26591;['appeal is dismissed']
+104127;['claimants are not nationals of north korea']
+146569;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+144557;['appellants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+97288;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis also not a convention refugee']
+80795;['appeal is allowed']
+95548;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa isset aside']
+47883;['appeal is dismissed']
+98725;['appeal isallowed']
+125676;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+67632;['appeal isallowed']
+77585;['appeal is allowed']
+151469;['appeal is dismissed']
+46509;['appeal is allowed']
+78649;['appeal is terminated']
+94078;['appeal of these grounds of refusal is dismissed']
+116794;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100936;['appeal is dismissed']
+92444;['appeal isallowed']
+63011;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+27468;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+96237;['appeal is dismissed']
+48217;['dismiss the appeal']
+94778;['appeal is dismissed']
+87168;['dismiss the appeal']
+90370;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+87850;['dismiss this appeal']
+29810;['immigration officer’s decision is therefore valid in law']
+134516;['immigration officer’s decision is therefore valid in law']
+145331;['rad determines that the appellant is excluded from the application of the convention']
+57527;['removal orders areset aside']
+94734;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98578;['appeal is dismissed']
+13752;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100335;['you and your partner are neither convention refugees, nor are you persons in need of protection']
+75559;['allow the appeal']
+143236;['appeal being dismissed']
+84867;['appeal isallowed.the']
+107929;['appeals are dismissed']
+133749;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+97890;['appeals of mojgan emdadi and ali eslami are allowed']
+89853;['appeal of thao thi truong is allowed']
+90612;['allowed the amendment']
+98008;['302 (c.a.']
+133754;['appeal is dismissed']
+65624;['appeal isallowed']
+152390;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142080;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+29723;['removal order isset aside']
+103101;['appeal is allowed']
+71127;['allows this appeal']
+59953;['appeal is dismissed']
+76514;['dismiss the appeal']
+35239;['appeal is allowed']
+143249;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63823;['appeal of nasra arte haji is dismissed']
+37864;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+133743;['rpd’s negative decision is set aside']
+76836;['appeal is allowed']
+111012;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+131057;['appeal is allowed']
+89197;['dismiss the appeal']
+87313;['appeal is allowed']
+112318;['appeal is dismissed']
+106296;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+91706;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+52331;['rad allows the appeal']
+95222;['appeal is allowed']
+80762;['negative']
+45225;['appeals of allan james-decker from the removal orders issued 5 june 2006 and 8 november 2007 are dismissed']
+140733;['allow the appeal', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+129113;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+142441;['appeal cannot succeed']
+116852;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71550;['appeal may be dismissed']
+17966;['allow the appeal and']
+146859;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+150678;['negative decision']
+53764;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+96351;['appeal of chi hung phan is dismissed']
+123255;['appeal is allowed']
+127423;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+130929;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+45177;['appeal is allowed']
+71066;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+108200;['confirm the rpd’s overall determination']
+109629;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+55219;['appeal is dismissed']
+90288;['appeal is dismissed']
+71567;['appeal is allowed']
+151879;['appeal is dismissed']
+90115;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+92091;['claim is rejected']
+92025;['appeal should be allowed']
+83540;['302 (c.a.']
+80484;['appeal is dismissed']
+61961;['appeal is dismissed']
+101445;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+81133;['302 (c.a.']
+49548;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+75257;['appeal is allowed']
+74126;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+69216;['appeal was allowed']
+98560;['appeal be marked as either abandoned']
+76404;['appeal is allowed']
+20005;['appeal is dismissed']
+143564;['decision is well-founded']
+19146;['dismiss the present appeal']
+82853;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+90457;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101678;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71116;['negative']
+94216;['appeal is dismissed']
+68736;['appeal is allowed']
+62472;['rad rejects this argument']
+132396;['appeal is allowed']
+92490;['appeal is terminated']
+102084;['removal order is set aside']
+116185;['302 (c.a.']
+71155;['negative']
+131520;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+85849;['negative']
+18932;['appeal was allowed by consent']
+150621;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78741;['appeal is allowed']
+76012;['appeal isallowed']
+109292;['appeal is allowed']
+124738;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64640;['appeal isallowed']
+74172;['dismiss this appeal']
+100127;['appeal isallowedand']
+67778;['dismiss the appeal']
+90071;['claimants, mr.xxxxx xxxxxand ms.xxxxx xxxxx, are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47568;['appeal is dismissed']
+91773;['appeal is dismissed']
+54825;['302 (c.a.']
+99553;['appeal is allowed']
+84306;['appeal isallowed']
+84660;['appeal be and is hereby allowed']
+128291;['appeal ofduaa remmanisallowed']
+151927;['appeal is rejected']
+63119;['appeal should be dismissed']
+75232;['appeal is allowed']
+77452;['appeals are allowed']
+98509;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77011;['appeal is allowed']
+107697;['appeal is dismissed']
+113609;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84530;['appeal is allowed']
+113739;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+85508;['appeal was allowed by the iad']
+116184;['appeal is allowed']
+75927;['appeal isallowed']
+130920;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'neither “refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+135167;['302 (c.a.']
+73887;['appeal of simardeep kainth is dismissed']
+74628;['appeal isallowed']
+74221;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+122676;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124812;['panel allows the refugee protection claims']
+91685;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+97223;['appeal is dismissed']
+95055;['appeal is allowed']
+17955;['appeal is dismissed']
+140989;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97618;['302 (c.a.']
+66315;['panel finds that the removal order is valid']
+76246;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+152820;['appeal isallowed']
+91709;['appeal of bong hyeon eom is dismissed']
+49572;['appeal of son nguyen is dismissed']
+90919;['rad finds that the rpd’s reasons']
+113252;['appeal is allowed']
+125054;['setting aside the rpd’s decision with regards to her claim']
+131170;['appeal is dismissed']
+97459;['allow the appeal']
+84757;['appeal must be dismissed']
+61641;['appeal is allowed']
+92933;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination']
+90578;['appeal abandoned']
+141638;['allow the appeal']
+96420;['appeal is rejected']
+52070;['appeal is granted']
+71433;['appeal is allowed']
+47111;['appeal beallowed']
+144408;['appeal is dismissed']
+100038;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+94898;['negative']
+49392;['appeal is terminated']
+61218;['appeal is allowed']
+61015;['claims are rejected']
+73273;['appeal must be dismissed']
+112371;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+98114;['claim is rejected']
+132816;['appeal of tizeta seyoum woldemariam is dismissed']
+82581;['appeal is allowed']
+140799;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47146;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+21935;['appeal is allowed']
+57090;['appeal must fail']
+40118;['appeal is dismissed']
+104122;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82639;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+102945;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+131522;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+101241;['appeal is dismissed']
+142554;['appeal is granted']
+34928;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81642;['appeal is dismissed']
+142085;['302 (c.a.']
+89203;['302 (c.a.']
+152918;['appeals are dismissed']
+38246;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+104002;['appeal is dismissed']
+80449;['appeal is dismissed']
+96769;['appeals of muhammadmushtaqand jazeelamushtaqare dismissed']
+58820;['appeal is dismissed']
+101450;['board therefore rejects their claim']
+146774;['appeal would be dismissed']
+122946;['appeal is allowed']
+152847;['appeal is allowed']
+124689;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99016;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+65127;['appeal would be dismissed']
+143895;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89710;['removal orders areset aside']
+102922;['appeal is allowed']
+61972;['appeal is dismissed']
+91546;['rad substitutes its decision', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+42353;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+103690;['appeal of jasvir singh lidhar and harpreet kaur lidhar is dismissed']
+86637;['appeal is allowed']
+96497;['proceeding is declared null and void']
+98605;['302 (c.a.)']
+31435;['nor a permanent resident.']
+71719;['302 (c.a.)']
+97263;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'reject the claim']
+23071;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+148756;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86209;['appeal was still dismissed']
+54295;['appeal of bhupinder singh samra is dismissed']
+111353;['302 (c.a.']
+93324;['appeal is allowed']
+91700;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+130757;['302 (c.a.']
+144960;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+61627;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+138829;['appeal isallowed.thedecision']
+116734;['appeals are based']
+77826;['their claims fail']
+89151;['appeal is allowed']
+36567;['appeal is allowed']
+130735;['board reinstated the respondent’s stay of deportation']
+106336;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68555;['reject her claim']
+90258;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+128289;['appeal of yang yang luo is dismissed']
+52286;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+123117;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+68097;['appeal must be dismissed']
+89996;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+143025;['claimants is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+123819;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88709;['appeal is dismissed']
+20836;['appeal is dismissed']
+61943;['appeal is dismissed']
+75497;['appeal is dismissed']
+88093;['appeal is allowed']
+97839;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+83387;['appeal is allowed']
+60508;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+122890;['appeal is allowed']
+41568;['removal order isset aside']
+61735;['appeals are dismissed']
+93913;['appeal is allowed']
+96655;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, is not a convention refugees nor is he a person in need of protection']
+115232;['appeal is dismissed']
+93681;['appeal isallowed']
+149234;['appeal is dismissed']
+91072;['appeal is terminated']
+60054;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+100516;['claim is rejected']
+81154;['appeal is allowed']
+60044;['negative']
+51041;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+95930;['rad finds that the rpd’s overall determination fails to address the significant credibility problems']
+63827;['appeal is dismissed']
+144769;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+42219;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+56733;['appeal is dismissed']
+144561;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80231;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+114739;['appeal was dismissed']
+140237;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+135138;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113256;['panel therefore dismisses the appeal']
+84605;['appeal is dismissed']
+26858;['appellants have not established the basis of their claims', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102749;['appeal were dismissed']
+85465;['appeal is allowed']
+101876;['appeal is allowed']
+150775;['’ argument']
+95438;['appeal is allowed']
+64844;['appeal is dismissed']
+76396;['substitute the determination']
+71244;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+57562;['appeal of abdul suleman gangji and zarin abdul gangji is dismissed']
+128440;['theappealis allowed']
+148507;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82139;['appeal should be dismissed']
+30503;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+140842;['appeal is allowed']
+92025;['appeals are allowed.the']
+107238;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94288;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatms.xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+26657;['appeal is dismissed']
+87215;['appeal is allowed']
+73320;['appeal is allowed']
+151334;['appeals are dismissed', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+31461;['appeal was allowed']
+122869;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'find the appellant to be a convention refugee']
+84701;['appeal isallowed']
+122907;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+132753;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+85315;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87001;['appeal be dismissed']
+83916;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+60064;['appeal isallowed']
+124007;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+70169;['appeal is dismissed']
+152372;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75611;['appeal is allowed']
+54783;['appeal is terminated']
+26978;['adult claimant is not a convention refugee']
+82141;['appeal is allowed']
+100389;['appeal isallowed']
+146106;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96386;['appeal is allowed']
+113267;['appeal is allowed']
+71166;['appeal of syed faisal javed is dismissed']
+38242;['appeal is dismissed']
+75707;['appeal is dismissed']
+98492;['appeals are dismissed']
+56910;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+110267;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+143033;['claimantsare neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125038;['police are corrupt and unfair']
+139891;['appeal of madhwan naidu is dismissed']
+60864;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+113802;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is a person described in article 1e of the convention']
+61546;['nor a genuine practitioner in canada']
+47526;['appeal is dismissed']
+94107;['appeal allowed']
+105719;['appeal of the appellant minister is allowed']
+98686;['appeal is a dismissal']
+110322;['panel rejects the claimant’s refugee protection claim']
+95448;['appeal is allowed']
+98911;['appeal is dismissed']
+95589;['appeal is allowed']
+105306;['302 (c.a.']
+96367;['appeal is dismissed']
+72160;['appeal is dismissed']
+123628;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+95782;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62629;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+127427;['appeal is dismissed']
+123686;['dismiss the appeal']
+34890;['appeal is dismissed']
+107702;['appeal is dismissed']
+54831;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+105645;['appeal is allowed']
+90832;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+143244;['dismiss this appeal']
+124936;['dismiss the appeal']
+149571;['rad rejects the appellant’s argument']
+77602;['appeal is allowed']
+84833;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+100789;['appeal is allowed']
+67636;['appeal isallowed']
+143614;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105912;['removal order is set aside']
+40076;['appeal is dismissed']
+139807;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+142822;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+41826;['appeal is dismissed']
+95684;['appeal isallowed']
+127730;['appeal is allowed']
+116827;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+60033;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+102688;['appeals are dismissed']
+94919;['appeal is dismissed']
+125510;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+134182;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+96105;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection”']
+69628;['appeal isallowed']
+98695;['302 (c.a.']
+26796;['appeal is allowed in law']
+31412;['allow the appeal']
+93871;['appeal ought to be dismissed']
+76631;['departure order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+110712;['appeal is dismissed']
+89327;['appeal is allowed']
+143635;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the respondent is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+61809;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94930;['appeal be allowed']
+98302;['negative']
+101563;['appeal isallowed']
+87169;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+82679;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+100037;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+152577;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+108814;['panel rejects his claim']
+92516;['appeal is allowed']
+142827;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107053;['appeal is dismissed']
+153719;['appeal is allowed']
+60485;['appeal is dismissed']
+24480;['appeal isallowed']
+135947;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100005;['302 (c.a.)']
+140900;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60013;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+149495;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+62992;['appeal is dismissed']
+67712;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse permanent resident visas is set aside']
+22804;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpa']
+97909;['dismiss all the joint appeals']
+148605;['dismissing the appeal']
+74550;['appeal is dismissed']
+92969;['appeal is terminated']
+102889;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106917;['appeal is dismissed']
+13419;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60833;['…]”']
+96383;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+76550;['appeal is allowed']
+143583;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+101706;['appeal isallowed']
+142532;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+43325;['appeal is allowed']
+88156;['appeal is allowed']
+92242;['appeal is allowed']
+83461;['appeal is allowed']
+78297;['appeal is dismissed']
+21346;"[""not find the claimant's testimony about this incident trustworthy""]"
+122537;['rad confirms the decision of the rpdthat', 'appellants are neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78126;['appeal is dismissed']
+95391;['appeal is dismissed']
+69510;['appeal is dismissed']
+91289;['dismiss this appeal']
+107864;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+30537;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+103896;['application is allowed']
+136130;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81171;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+78663;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+56948;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+99367;['appeal of satinder waraich is dismissed']
+109537;['appeal must be discontinued']
+99011;['appeal is dismissed']
+67619;['appeal is dismissed']
+104480;['dismiss the appeal']
+90677;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+39892;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43718;['allow the appeal of meena rani shoker in law']
+71548;['appeal is allowed']
+95116;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77286;['allow the appeal']
+124190;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87362;['appeal is allowed']
+90992;['appeal is allowed']
+99939;['division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+95728;['appeal of adnew regassa haye is dismissed']
+67047;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+80208;['negative']
+129102;['appeal is allowed']
+87731;['appeal is dismissed']
+57098;['appeal is allowed.the']
+95366;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+17987;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+96958;['appeal is terminated']
+67784;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+71267;['appeal is dismissed']
+53137;['appeal is allowed']
+121856;['confirm the determination']
+139797;['appeal is allowed']
+39048;['appeal of ghulam nabi is allowed']
+91149;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in   ']
+81226;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+98062;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+76525;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+144769;['panel consequently rejects the refugee protection claim']
+86518;['appeal is dismissed']
+94589;['appeal is dismissed']
+107502;['rad finds that it cannot substitute its own finding']
+132292;['appeal is allowed']
+112388;['appeals are allowed']
+147439;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+18925;['appeal was dismissed']
+108755;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+69932;['appeal is dismissed']
+54193;['appeal isallowed']
+133688;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141600;['are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+94865;['appeal is dismissed']
+70890;['appeal is allowed']
+144568;['appellant’s claim fails']
+34097;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107195;['application is allowed']
+98224;['302 (c.a.']
+136710;['appeals are allowed']
+123900;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79215;['iad is without jurisdiction to hear the appeal']
+29636;['appeal isallowed']
+111304;['appeal is dismissed']
+91705;['appeal is allowed']
+65129;['appeal is dismissed']
+89056;['appeal isallowed']
+134175;['appeal is allowed']
+59375;['appeal is dismissed']
+123387;['appeal is dismissed']
+121578;['claimant is not a credible witness']
+87033;['appeal is allowed.the']
+56781;['panel rejects the claim to refugee protection']
+82621;['confirm the determination']
+124623;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+99436;['theclaimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+92506;['appeal is dismissed']
+76491;['appeal is dismissed']
+91071;['appeal is terminated']
+91549;['302 (c.a.']
+82211;['appeal be dismissed']
+142840;['application is dismissed']
+122097;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+81109;['appeal is based']
+76055;['appeal is terminated']
+153629;['appeal is dismissed']
+98081;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+86614;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+96914;['appeal is allowed']
+80471;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+31412;['appeal isallowed']
+125481;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neitherconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121408;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97386;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59910;['appeal is dismissed']
+61931;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+121543;['appeal is allowed']
+141215;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+125025;['appeal is allowed']
+94551;['not a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+100908;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+93606;['appeal isallowed']
+17970;['appeal is dismissed']
+112401;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+95028;['appeal isallowed']
+153795;['appeal is allowed']
+58118;['appeal isallowed']
+95361;['appeal is dismissed']
+17117;['appeal is allowed']
+151613;['302 (c.a.']
+143649;['rad agrees with the finding of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52113;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101783;['appeal is allowed']
+101031;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+80685;['refugee protection division determinesxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+56896;['appeal isallowed']
+74067;['appeal was dismissed']
+93770;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+140889;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124990;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+84872;['appeal is dismissed']
+23026;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+56989;['refugee protection division finds the claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects herclaim to refugee protection']
+62488;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+107324;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+97943;['appeal is dismissed']
+82853;['appeal is allowed']
+131041;['appeal is dismissed']
+143156;['allow the appeal and refer the matter back to the rpd']
+76324;['appeal isallowed']
+90034;['302 (c.a.)']
+138288;['appeal is allowed']
+132314;['negative determination']
+17940;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+131509;['appeal is dismissed']
+75887;['appeal is allowed']
+76790;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80486;['confirm that the immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+62865;['appeal is terminated']
+99975;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate consideration']
+74163;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant is a convention refugee']
+53138;['appeal be allowed']
+103541;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+131862;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+80062;['appeal isallowed.the']
+89354;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+134306;['appeal is allowed']
+131079;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+107825;['board rejects a claim']
+131717;['appeal is allowed']
+127720;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+89516;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+136669;['appeal is allowed']
+121870;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that mr. xxxx is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+144479;['appeal is not allowed']
+133754;['appellant is not a permanent resident']
+67625;['appeal isallowed']
+94598;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+55245;['or a person in need of protection']
+57892;['appeal is allowed']
+82238;['appeal against the decision not to issue a visa']
+52091;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146554;['claim is rejected']
+103821;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+131064;['appeal is allowed']
+93311;['appeal is dismissed']
+99760;['tribunal rejects her claim']
+64261;['appeal is dismissed']
+113572;['appeal is allowed']
+110684;['decision of the rpd stands']
+105901;['neither a passport', 'nor a national identity document.']
+74132;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116820;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+102407;['302 (c.a.']
+94950;['appeal isallowed']
+91949;['appeal is terminated']
+125128;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+98820;['appeal is allowed']
+68312;['appeal of jagbin singh mand is dismissed']
+59730;['appeal isallowed']
+91109;['appeal is allowed']
+129880;['set aside the rpd’s decision and substitute this decision']
+152907;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+83946;['rad confirms the\xa0 determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+108886;['claim is therefore rejected']
+71548;['appeal is allowed']
+29721;['removal order isset aside']
+95210;['appeals are allowed']
+143146;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94574;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+17168;['appeal is dismissed']
+46023;['appeal is allowed']
+107931;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+17967;['appeal should be dismissed']
+69614;['appeal is dismissed']
+69656;['appeal oflakhbir kaur uppalis dismissed forres judicata']
+66631;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125517;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124081;['appeal is dismissed']
+79969;['claims are rejected']
+97904;['appeal isallowed']
+45413;['dismiss the present appeal']
+24247;['appeal be dismissed']
+44025;['appeal is allowed']
+123139;['appeal is allowed']
+76303;['dismiss this appeal']
+125521;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+135472;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+12001;['appeal isallowed']
+149009;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+97406;['appeal isallowed']
+83159;['dismissing this appeal']
+60047;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+142516;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140858;['ifa is not reasonable']
+120809;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+68896;['appeal isallowed']
+82981;['appeal be dismissed.one']
+99992;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+47917;['appeal isallowed']
+97325;['negative']
+127698;['appeal is dismissed']
+141164;['appeal is dismissed']
+52295;['appeal isallowed']
+84656;['appeal isallowed']
+38845;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108932;['appeal isallowed']
+110288;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+134438;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+23005;['appeal of mohamed bazza is dismissed']
+124977;['appeal is allowed']
+17974;['appeal is allowed']
+109171;['appeal is rejected']
+68416;['appeal is allowed']
+77235;['302 (c.a.)']
+73313;['appeal be dismissed']
+83279;['rad substitutes the decision', 'determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+84858;['appeal is determined']
+5589;['appeal must be dismissed']
+93921;['appeal is allowed']
+22996;['appeal isallowed']
+87324;['officer’s decision is therefore not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+87013;['appeal is allowed']
+36947;['appeal is dismissed']
+100128;['appeal isallowedand']
+128386;['appeal is dismissed']
+3905;['appeal filed byxxxx xxxxis dismissed']
+144263;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+98440;['appeal abandoned']
+123555;['appellant was not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151438;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+90819;['appeal isallowed']
+77834;['negative']
+68140;['allow this appeal']
+99733;['appeal is dismissed']
+128740;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69778;['appeal be allowed']
+24504;['appeal is dismissed']
+39919;['appeal is allowed']
+81215;['appellant is no longer established in canada']
+128271;['appeals are dismissed']
+123335;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee or a person in need of protection.he']
+69445;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+144562;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+109026;['appeal was dismissed']
+107803;['panel rejects their refugee protection claims']
+124972;['claimants have not displaced']
+76707;['appeal is dismissed']
+52922;['dismiss the appeal']
+78129;['negative']
+69067;['appeal isallowed']
+97219;['appeal is allowed']
+100753;['appeal is dismissed']
+85452;['appeal is terminated']
+102797;['appeal isallowedand']
+129877;['rad therefore determines that the appellants are convention refugees']
+24473;['appeal is dismissed']
+71492;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+24506;['appeal is allowed']
+52072;['appeal is terminated']
+94755;['appeal is allowed']
+82116;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+125563;['302 (c.a.']
+83662;['appeal isallowed']
+124000;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+82118;['appeal was dismissed']
+75892;['appeal is dismissed']
+100155;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+136137;['appeal is dismissed']
+97086;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94032;['appeal isallowed']
+96435;['appeal is allowed.the']
+68898;['appeal is allowed']
+69714;['appeal isallowed']
+101513;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+76844;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+150637;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68103;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+132832;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93599;['refusal is valid in law']
+81620;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+75974;['appeal is allowed']
+95984;['302 (c.a.']
+28289;['appellant is not a convention refugee,', 'appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+71659;['appeal is dismissed']
+99536;['stay is cancelled']
+84518;['appeals of yimin hu and aihua zhou are dismissed']
+105697;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+111290;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+95007;['appeal is terminated']
+77987;['not grant discretionary relief']
+78071;['appeal is determined']
+127462;['appeal is allowed']
+69535;['appeal is allowed']
+97135;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+108471;['appeal is allowed']
+153283;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+97343;['appeal is allowed']
+101567;['appeal is dismissed']
+143153;['appeal is allowed']
+69532;['appeal isallowed']
+105913;['appeal is allowed']
+80051;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+60517;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+129100;['appeal is allowed']
+148592;['appeal is allowed']
+47584;['appeal cannot succeed']
+110266;['rad, denies   this application']
+147781;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83052;['appeal is allowed']
+19143;['appeal were dismissed']
+26764;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+80724;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76341;['appeal is allowed']
+81412;['appeal is terminated']
+91658;['appeal is allowed']
+87465;['appeal is determined']
+142979;['302 (c.a.']
+134495;['appeals are allowed.the']
+116757;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+101298;['neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+148722;['associate claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87461;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+17381;['appeal is dismissed']
+44982;['302 (c.a.)']
+96774;['officer’s decision is not valid in law', 'allow the appeal']
+79459;['appeal isallowed']
+28482;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+47281;['dismisses the appeal']
+86454;['appeal is allowed']
+142122;['rad, therefore, cannot allow this application']
+57535;['appeal is therefore allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+40480;['appeal is dismissed']
+82202;['nor a citizen of canada']
+82895;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+116851;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+88902;['appeal is allowed']
+48102;['appeal of ravin singhis allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+83673;['removal order is set aside']
+128443;['appeal is allowed']
+89444;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+93043;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+141234;['rpd’s decision is upheld']
+143005;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+90970;['appeal of waritu tusa wako is dismissed']
+72207;['appeal is allowed']
+124552;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128344;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+67239;['claim is rejected']
+91817;['confirm the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugee”']
+70099;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+134517;['appeals be allowed']
+146845;['panel rejects their claims']
+98102;['allows the application to vacate']
+44031;['appeal is allowed']
+90546;['appeal is determined']
+100507;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77772;['appeal is terminated']
+128263;['appeal isallowedfor']
+134748;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71278;['appeal is dismissed']
+61047;['appeal is allowed']
+153280;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+152058;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+102538;['appeal is dismissed']
+67509;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+100499;['appeal isallowed']
+133270;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+143866;['rad finds the rpd’s determination is correct']
+136158;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination']
+59783;['appeal is allowed.the']
+151631;['rad finds these submissions have merit']
+82870;['302 (c.a.']
+59925;['dismiss this appeal']
+51812;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+92093;['reject your claims for refugee protection']
+143554;['rad concludes that the rpd’s determination is correct']
+71249;['appeal of moises cruz is dismissed']
+93084;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+143239;['appeal is dismissed']
+34693;['visa officer’s determination is valid in law']
+84829;['appeal is allowed']
+135471;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86309;['exclusion order is set aside']
+102986;['rad finds the rpd’s findings are untenable', 'rpd decision cannot stand']
+60362;['appeal is dismissed']
+151836;['dismisses the appeal']
+44740;['appeal is determinedto have beenabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+105231;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84061;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89220;['appeal isallowed']
+100846;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+100060;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+123638;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugee nor persons in need of protection']
+17940;['appeal is dismissed']
+72700;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+107198;['302 (c.a.']
+61864;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+78008;['appeals of bahram ebadian and his wife, farouzandi farazian are dismissed']
+94025;['appeal is dismissed']
+70095;['allows the appeal']
+77574;['appeal isallowed']
+148980;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95198;['appeal is terminated']
+95770;['rpd decision should be set aside']
+106144;['appeals are allowed']
+111167;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88065;['appeal is dismissed']
+91247;['appeal is allowed']
+107253;['appeal is dismissed']
+90898;['appeal is dismissed']
+86934;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+36107;['allow the appeal']
+23023;['removal order isset aside.the']
+90982;['appeal is allowed']
+70946;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+42211;['appeal is dismissed']
+71434;['appeal is allowed']
+145349;['claim is rejected']
+43389;['appeal is dismissed']
+96295;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+95936;['appeal is allowed']
+142466;['appeal is allowed']
+51048;['appeal were dismissed']
+95148;['allows the appeal']
+103047;['appeal isallowed']
+45989;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+65120;['appeal is allowed']
+62119;['appeal be dismissed']
+107440;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+99586;['dismissing the appeal']
+147130;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+98602;['appeal is allowed']
+128302;['appeal is allowed']
+57794;['stay the removal order in accordance']
+99494;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+136664;['positive irb decision of xxxx xxxx']
+50455;['appeal is allowed']
+101665;['appeal isallowed']
+117114;['appeal is allowed']
+80747;['appeal must fail']
+52072;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+96834;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+96101;['pc and the ccs are not convention refugees', 'rejects their claims']
+54795;['removal order isset aside']
+90250;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+66937;['appeal isallowed.the']
+97028;['claimant is not in need of protection']
+69409;['appeal isallowed']
+143893;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismiss this appeal']
+133191;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd']
+62452;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+52130;['appeal is allowed']
+38426;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91603;['appeal is allowed']
+61294;['appeal is dismissed']
+124619;['dismiss the appeal']
+24504;['appeal should be dismissed']
+83542;['appeal were dismissed']
+94694;['appeal is dismissed']
+140279;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+24247;['appeal is allowed.the']
+105621;['appeal isallowed']
+106335;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+121546;['appeal is dismissed']
+69864;['removal orders are set aside']
+63948;['appeal is dismissed']
+74260;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116818;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+150665;['302 (c.a.']
+67355;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+82101;['appeal is dismissed']
+94577;['you are not a convention refugee']
+123278;['rad finds that the rpd committed a critical objective basis assessment error']
+77810;['not a person in need of protection']
+67443;['appeal is dismissed']
+94768;['appeal isallowed']
+74698;['appeal of gabriel deng degieudit, also known as ajith deng young, is dismissed']
+72665;['dismiss it for lack of jurisdiction']
+119832;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+99087;['appeal is dismissed']
+142946;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125419;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+77319;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+116778;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+151508;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56272;['appeal is allowed']
+113627;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+151491;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+48212;['application to reopen is allowed']
+95312;['allows the appeal']
+80482;['appeal is allowed']
+133272;['not find that the rpd erred in its application of guideline 3 in its assessment']
+44017;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82167;['appeal is allowed']
+99269;['appeal is allowed']
+97004;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+66322;['dismiss the appeal']
+92773;['appeal be dismissed']
+60121;['refugee protection division rejects this claim', 'claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151492;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+107636;['rad confirms the determination']
+147622;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77920;['appeal is allowed']
+34891;['iad therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+55031;['appeal is allowed']
+71419;['appeal of glicerio urbano josol is dismissed']
+116826;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94408;['appeal is allowed']
+134294;['appeal is allowed']
+74493;['appeal isallowed']
+89925;['appeal were dismissed']
+74848;['allow the appeal']
+125380;['appeal is allowed']
+21339;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+91457;['appeal is dismissed']
+151742;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106677;['appeal is allowed']
+68319;['appeals do not merit special relief']
+98718;['appeal is terminated']
+87400;['302 (c.a.)']
+89879;['claimants are not afforded refugee protection']
+80679;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection', 'claimants not to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+102556;['appeal regarding the appellant’s mother is allowed']
+140071;['confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+24464;['appeal is allowed']
+101009;['appeal in this case is dismissed']
+116778;['appeal is allowed.the']
+66251;['appeal is allowed']
+124268;['appeals of both malek alzamel and bara alzamel are dismissed']
+138836;['appeals are dismissed']
+151520;['appeal is allowed']
+17427;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxxxxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+88023;['negative']
+84547;['appeal is dismissed']
+94005;['appeal is dismissed']
+103500;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+97669;['negative']
+130885;['appeal is dismissed']
+83673;['appeal isallowed']
+72709;['application is therefore also denied']
+143179;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+92734;['appeal is allowed']
+128289;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+102805;['appeal isallowed']
+87096;['appeal was dismissed']
+126390;['rad is not in a position to substitute a decision']
+97845;['negative']
+36125;['appeal is allowed']
+37897;['appeal is allowed.the']
+105808;['appeal being dismissed']
+75493;['appeal is dismissed']
+128327;['appeal is allowed']
+89293;['appeal is dismissed']
+78340;['appeal is dismissed']
+21301;['302 (c.a.']
+93323;['appeal is dismissed']
+133402;['negative determination']
+34698;['appeal of michael ross whelan is allowed']
+110991;['appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+77045;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+125622;['thesur placeclaim fails']
+43329;['appeal is dismissed']
+121446;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+35430;['appeal is dismissed']
+108781;['appeal is dismissed']
+83045;['appeal of yi ming zhang is dismissed']
+125405;['decision must be set aside']
+132831;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+42944;['appeal is dismissed']
+143890;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+101875;['appeal is dismissed']
+125616;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94596;['appeal is allowed']
+107651;['appeal is dismissed']
+90694;['appeal isallowed']
+31969;['appeal is allowed']
+123390;['confirm the rpd’s decision that they are neither “convention refugee(s)”', 'nor “person(s) in need of protection']
+34935;['appeal is dismissed']
+94357;['appeal isallowed']
+54186;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69601;['appeal is dismissed']
+116204;['rpd’s conclusion is confirmed']
+94718;['exclusion order is set aside']
+77310;['appeal isdismissed.']
+44029;['appeal is allowed']
+94248;['rad concurs with the rpd’s finding']
+147574;['appeal is allowed']
+69165;['panel finds that it is appropriate to dismiss this appeal']
+100581;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+83027;['appeal is allowed']
+106810;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97282;['claims are rejected']
+151880;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+92498;['appeal is dismissed']
+100955;['appeal is allowed']
+71662;['appeal is dismissed']
+97669;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+31395;['appeal isallowedand']
+32085;['appeal is denied']
+95997;['appellant is not inadmissible']
+106137;['appeal isdismissed.']
+91730;['appeal is dismissed']
+88148;['appeal is allowed']
+150673;['ifa fails']
+110912;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+99879;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+138816;['appeal is denied']
+88034;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102291;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is erroneous']
+89825;['appeal is allowed']
+148725;['302 (c.a.']
+85507;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+101178;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination']
+130854;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71707;['appeal is denied']
+104289;['appeal of nishan singh thind is allowed']
+99160;['appeal is dismissed']
+46108;['appeal isallowed']
+29298;['appeal is dismissed']
+105713;['302 (c.a.']
+131159;['removal order is set aside']
+43727;['appeal of sheik umar kamara is dismissed']
+79242;['appeal is dismissed']
+75007;['appeal of yoleng khiev is dismissed']
+69077;['appeal is allowed']
+103109;['refugee from colombia']
+43328;['appeal is allowed']
+17966;['appeal is allowed']
+98593;['stay is set aside']
+110946;['claimant is not a person who is perceived to be linked to the']
+146613;['appeal is dismissed']
+131865;['rpd’s decision must be set aside']
+98526;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+137483;['appeal is dismissed']
+41249;['appeal is allowed']
+103688;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93890;['appeal is dismissed']
+79462;['appeal is dismissed']
+146847;['you are neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97128;['appeal must be dismissed']
+99731;['appeal is dismissed']
+118335;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140985;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+127434;['appeal is allowed']
+141642;['appeal is dismissed']
+123390;['allow this appeal in part']
+81288;['removal order is set aside']
+97916;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+102050;['appeal is allowed']
+82809;['appeal isallowed.the']
+26775;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+72073;['appeal must be dismissed']
+61926;['application to extend time to file the notice of appeal is dismissed']
+47186;['doctrine of abuse of process']
+150753;['appeal is allowed']
+77262;['302 (c.a.)']
+122099;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+94910;['application to reopen is denied']
+106144;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+96604;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+122844;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+153286;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99977;['appeal is dismissed']
+89742;['appeal is allowed']
+124342;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+79868;['appeal is allowed']
+150154;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+139453;['appeal is allowed']
+75165;['dismiss the appeal']
+130692;['appeal is allowed']
+38768;['appeal is dismissed']
+85229;['appeal is allowed']
+80747;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+94379;['appeal is allowed']
+92574;['appeal is terminated']
+107674;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76231;['appeal is allowed']
+54264;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95531;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+151801;['appeal is dismissed']
+75428;['appeal should be dismissed']
+80481;['appeal is allowed']
+65676;['appeal is allowed']
+25982;['appeal is dismissed']
+121404;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81918;['appeal is dismissed']
+131157;['departure order is set aside']
+111002;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+98566;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+151371;['302 (c.a.']
+91676;['appeal is dismissed']
+95875;['appeal is dismissed']
+142089;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject the claim']
+103549;['appeal is allowed']
+93963;['302 (c.a.)']
+12152;['appeal isallowed']
+135137;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47290;['appeal is allowed']
+57529;['appeal is determined']
+94764;['appellant is established in sri lanka']
+94158;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+50523;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87978;['appeal is based']
+105439;['appeals of the appellants nafesa abuhelala, sara faraj and lena faraj areallowed']
+95675;['appeal is allowed']
+77882;['appeal of manjit kaur thandi is dismissed']
+124480;['appeal is dismissed']
+143595;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes it with a determination that the appellants are protected persons', 'appeal is allowed']
+133367;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+111024;['appeal is referred to the']
+95443;['appeal is allowed']
+143556;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+76030;['appeal isallowed']
+74886;['dismiss the appeal']
+69110;['appeal is allowed']
+120826;['302 (c.a.']
+82655;['appeal isallowed']
+149574;['rad finds that the children are convention refugees']
+103094;['appeal is dismissed']
+76620;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+139894;['appeal is allowed']
+62250;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+50466;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71272;['appeal is accordinglydismissed']
+142901;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee']
+98668;['documentation is not admissible']
+151181;['rpd decision is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+74235;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+35051;['appeal of harmeet kaur gill is allowed']
+125340;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+143626;['rad panel finds that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+124905;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147596;['rad allows the appeal']
+123344;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90235;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+73300;['allow this appeal']
+111020;['appeal is dismissed']
+133695;['appeal is allowed in part']
+131533;['refusal is set aside']
+26694;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+92281;['claims are rejected']
+95023;['appeal is terminated']
+23084;['allows the appeal']
+98311;['appeal is allowed']
+56867;['appeal isallowed']
+100547;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+67245;['appeal isallowed']
+82657;['allow his appeal']
+99395;['appeal is dismissed']
+30513;['appeal is not allowed']
+135113;['confirm the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+95066;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+141054;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143867;['appeal is allowed']
+37836;['allows this appeal']
+83067;['appeal is terminated']
+54260;['appeal is allowed']
+91340;['appeal is dismissed']
+97960;['appeal is dismissed']
+68145;['refugee appeal division (rad) dismisses the appeal']
+113300;['appeal is allowed']
+57290;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+70747;['theappealis dismissed']
+87041;['appeal is allowed']
+23079;['appeal is allowed']
+40077;['appeal is allowed']
+102073;['appeal is allowed']
+59180;['appeal is allowed']
+80774;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+124424;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+144249;['302 (c.a.']
+62896;['appeal were dismissed']
+133697;['set aside the rpd determination', 'substitute the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare convention refugees']
+43717;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+38163;['appeal is denied']
+59720;['appeal is dismissed']
+100088;['appeal is allowed']
+22125;['appeal should be dismissed']
+15874;['the claims fail']
+99868;['appeal is allowed']
+70968;['appeal is allowed']
+95768;['appeal is rejected']
+145827;['appeal is allowed']
+89379;['appeal is terminated']
+67679;['appeal is dismissed']
+53836;['appeal is dismissed']
+66764;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71054;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+70041;['allows the appeal']
+124187;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+143163;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+28295;['appeal is dismissed']
+150640;['dismiss the appeal']
+144035;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99772;['negative']
+69982;['appeal is dismissed']
+79872;['appeal is allowed']
+123788;['appellant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+52483;['declare this appeal abandoned']
+107042;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+103528;['allow the appeal']
+69603;['appeal is dismissed']
+84747;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+124093;['appeal isallowed.the']
+83651;['appeal is dismissed']
+96775;['nor persons in need of protection']
+105757;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+94511;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89283;['appeal is allowed']
+131874;['allow the appeal']
+140862;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84146;['appeal is allowed']
+63069;['appeal is dismissed']
+69849;['appeal is terminated']
+80514;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+117196;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+113270;['appeal is allowed']
+89306;['claimants, xxxxx and xxxxx, not to be convention refugees']
+35068;['appeal of chokkamma shadagopal is dismissed']
+102160;['appeal were dismissed']
+89071;['appeal is dismissed']
+103048;['leads me to conclude that she did not enter this marriage']
+104462;['appeal is allowed']
+42175;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+133403;['appeal was dismissed']
+30531;['appeal is allowed']
+79953;['negative']
+64257;['appeal is dismissed']
+85929;['302 (c.a.)']
+88092;['appeal is dismissed']
+87695;['appeal isallowed']
+64246;['appeal is dismissed']
+104453;['appeal isallowed']
+54277;['appeal is allowed']
+58752;['appeal is dismissed']
+75003;['appeal is terminated']
+47797;['appeal isallowed']
+46048;['appeal isallowed']
+122133;['dismiss the appeal']
+141251;['appeal is dismissed']
+8344;['appeal is allowed']
+148271;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm that the', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90655;['appeal is allowed']
+75561;['appeal is dismissed']
+84334;['appeal is dismissed']
+106135;['appeal is determined to beabandonedas']
+132778;['appeal is allowed']
+114929;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+74522;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+85432;['appeal is dismissed']
+94935;['appeal is dismissed']
+80506;['appeal is allowed']
+61490;['appeal isallowed']
+77549;['302 (c.a.']
+125394;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+145039;['302 (c.a.']
+73887;['appeal is allowed']
+89857;['appeal of soriba jalloh is dismissed']
+61373;['appeal must be dismissed']
+123659;['substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+34626;['appeal isallowed']
+76700;['appeal is allowed']
+146771;['appeal is allowed']
+128559;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80040;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80672;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110682;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+60944;['302 (c.a.']
+67922;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+149490;['302 (c.a.']
+17373;['appeal is dismissed']
+142734;['appeal is allowed']
+93277;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+94072;['appeal is dismissed']
+128437;['appeals were to be allowed']
+146950;['appeal is allowed']
+90056;['appeal is allowed']
+61014;['appeal is dismissed']
+130860;['302 (c.a.)']
+111174;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80464;['application must fail']
+58419;['appeal is terminated']
+90248;['application is allowed']
+73196;['appeal is dismissed']
+87859;['decision finding the respondents to be convention refugees is vacated']
+49518;['appeal is dismissed']
+90942;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+101435;['appeal must therefore, on that basis, on a jurisdictional basis']
+42018;['tribunal concludes that the decision of the i']
+122845;['302 (c.a.']
+66925;['appeal is dismissed']
+123961;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants, xxxx xxxx xxxxand xxxx xxxx xxxx']
+92438;['appeal is dismissed']
+47315;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+141038;['appeal is allowed']
+50752;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+84359;['appeal is dismissed']
+95157;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+89838;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject her claim']
+63925;['appeal fails']
+108689;['rad has found:']
+105610;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+68157;['removal order is set aside']
+103810;['302 (c.a.']
+127395;['appeal is dismissed']
+133708;['302 (c.a.']
+81931;['appeal was scheduled for an oral hearing']
+86936;['appeal is dismissed']
+72191;['allows the appeal']
+81112;['appeal were dismissed']
+90987;['appeal fails']
+4624;['appeal is allowed']
+16764;['appeal isallowed.the']
+69372;['panel dismisses this appeal']
+93877;['appeal is allowed.the']
+71634;['appeal is dismissed']
+96572;['appeal is dismissed']
+69453;['appeal should be dismissed']
+69084;['appeal is allowed']
+19720;['appeal of harpreet kaur sidhu from the refusal to issue a permanent resident visa']
+92170;['appeal is dismissed']
+68273;['dismiss the appeal of ying huang']
+104949;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+122808;['reverse the decision of the rpd']
+91669;['appeal is allowed']
+101678;['appeal is allowed']
+108249;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+103908;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+19247;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71689;['appeal is allowed']
+94033;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+94663;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+121456;['appeal is allowed.the']
+135477;['claimant’s refugee protection is hereby ceased', 'claimant is rejected']
+74550;['exclusion order is set aside']
+43720;['appeal is allowed']
+95401;['appeal is allowed']
+90761;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125414;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68584;['appeal isallowed']
+98775;['appeal is dismissed']
+48010;['appeal is dismissed']
+80195;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124127;['substitute its own decision']
+98788;['appeal is dismissed']
+99604;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+142482;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+100544;['appeal isallowed']
+94350;['appeal is allowed']
+57895;['appeal is dismissed']
+103526;['decision of the immigration is valid in law']
+97459;['removal order is set aside']
+130763;['appeal is allowed']
+100027;['negative']
+29695;['appeal is dismissed']
+85489;['appeal is dismissed']
+93581;['allows the appeal', 'sets aside the removal order.']
+102984;['appeal is dismissed']
+60031;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, is not a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+80774;['appeal is allowed']
+67191;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+65606;['appeal isallowed']
+52064;['appeal isallowedand']
+85513;['appeal is allowed.the']
+85914;['302 (c.a.']
+80368;['appeal is allowed']
+84314;['appeal is dismissed']
+73709;['allows the appeal']
+125245;['mek was removed from the list of']
+146109;['appeal is dismissed']
+44522;['appeal is allowed']
+60887;['appeal is determined']
+87056;['appeal isallowed']
+68293;['appeal is dismissed']
+90800;['appeal isdismissed.']
+96954;['appeal is dismissed']
+100872;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+107428;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124072;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151838;['appeal is denied']
+59998;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+62456;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96672;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+102734;"['claimantsxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare ""convention refugees']"
+91904;['appeal is allowed']
+93159;['appeal of oluwasayo emmanuel oguntoye is allowed']
+99290;['board rejects a claim']
+93827;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'panel rejects his claim']
+24192;['appeal is dismissed']
+113744;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98553;['dismiss the subsection 4(1) appeal']
+68025;['appeal isallowed']
+94106;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+44040;['appeal is allowed.the']
+44041;['rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+77628;['appeal isallowed']
+71642;['appeal is terminated']
+57564;['appeal isallowed']
+73222;['tribunal declares the appealabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+124918;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59852;['appeal is dismissed']
+92613;['negative']
+70968;['appeal is allowed']
+8298;['appeal isallowed']
+59833;['appeal isallowed']
+98725;['appeal is allowed']
+151309;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81925;['appeal is allowed']
+101718;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+63518;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+105709;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+123006;['appeal is allowed']
+94811;['appeal of monika beatrice varga is dismissed']
+63947;['appeal is dismissed']
+124590;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90627;['allows the application']
+72178;['dismiss this appeal']
+136739;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100392;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a person excluded under article 1e of the convention', 'neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150914;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106132;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+122948;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+51041;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80460;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+43323;['appeal is allowed inlaw.']
+69995;['allow the appeal']
+87217;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+82884;['appeal is governed']
+90815;['302 (c.a.)']
+131709;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47559;['appeal is dismissed']
+47576;['appeal of virendr singh sohal is dismissed']
+101757;['appeal is allowed']
+54765;['theappeal is allowed']
+91546;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30410;['appeals are dismissed']
+76401;['appeal be dismissed']
+149493;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made']
+47365;['appeal is allowed']
+97397;['refugee protection division rejects the claimant’s claim for refugee protection']
+92751;['appeal is dismissed']
+85875;['dif is an acronym']
+143845;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+114432;['appeal is allowed']
+47582;['appeal is allowed']
+91307;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+129261;['appeal is dismissed']
+81927;['appeal should be dismissed']
+79978;['claim is rejected']
+93043;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+96628;['appeal is allowed']
+42567;['appeal is dismissed']
+102160;['appeal is allowed.the']
+22389;['appeal is allowed']
+81425;['leads me to conclude that a']
+96517;['appeal fails and must be dismissed']
+54798;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+67653;['appeal is allowed']
+49160;['appeal is allowed']
+124994;['appeal is allowed']
+22815;['appeal is dismissed']
+94075;['appeal isallowed']
+99441;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+102076;['appeal is dismissed']
+28044;['appeal is dismissed']
+86323;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a “conventionrefugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+117214;['appeal is allowed']
+108742;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+47306;['appeal of ghaffar nabizadeh is allowed']
+94603;['appeal of jia jun wei isallowed']
+67521;['appeal is dismissed']
+17963;['appeal is allowed']
+96947;['appeal is dismissed']
+69830;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+23007;['appeal was dismissed']
+75006;['appeal is dismissed']
+38877;['removal order is set aside']
+54739;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99752;['appeal is allowed']
+76919;['appeal, therefore, is dismissed']
+36188;['appeal is dismissed']
+69091;['dismiss this appeal']
+125423;['appeal is allowed']
+69652;['appeal isallowed']
+124081;['removal order is set aside']
+101773;['appeal is dismissed']
+108252;['appeal is dismissed']
+22709;['appeal is dismissed']
+139678;['appeals are dismissed.a']
+93071;['appeal is dismissed']
+26822;['youxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+91136;['appeal isallowed']
+101845;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+100248;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+62480;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+125478;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+117140;['appeal is dismissed']
+52096;['appeal isallowed']
+111175;['confirm the rpd member’s determination', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+94779;['appeal is allowed']
+121045;['302 (c.a.']
+124452;['appellant is neither convention a refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+100326;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70102;['appeals abandoned']
+75499;['appeal is allowed']
+78073;['appeal is dismissed']
+99600;['appeal is dismissed']
+53200;['appellant is inadmissible to canada']
+85911;['appeal is allowed']
+96352;['appeal is allowed']
+56987;['application to re-open is allowed']
+124902;['reject his argument']
+69220;['appeal is dismissed']
+83838;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+17964;['appeal be dismissed']
+128295;['appeal is allowed']
+121462;['appeal is dismissed']
+70072;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+74856;['appeal is allowed']
+95052;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87347;['appeal is allowed']
+101202;['appeal dismissed']
+69080;['appeal is allowed']
+56681;['appeal is allowed']
+72671;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+110987;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+132774;['appeal is dismissed']
+121953;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+8343;['appeal is determined']
+89382;['appeal is dismissed']
+16753;['appeal is dismissed']
+75473;['appeal terminated']
+100521;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+83672;['appeal is allowed']
+151438;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+63972;['appeal is allowed']
+113290;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+12216;['appeal is allowed.the']
+97401;['appeal is allowed']
+84554;['appeal isallowed.the']
+86520;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+47605;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+40051;['appeal is allowed']
+123004;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+124415;['appeal is allowed']
+38991;['appeal is dismissed']
+89236;['appeal is allowed']
+22130;['302 (c.a.']
+123539;['appeal is allowed']
+35039;['appeal of gaganjot kaur bhullar is allowed']
+56879;['appeal bedismissed.']
+73713;['appeal is allowed']
+87806;['removal orders are set aside']
+51286;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+66309;['departure order is set aside']
+26810;['refusal is invalid in law', 'appeal of baljinder singh mand is allowed in law']
+17993;['appeal isallowed']
+73330;['appeal is dismissed']
+143574;['rpd’s negative determination', 'substituted positive decisions']
+99995;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxx,not to be a convention refugee']
+69784;['appeal is dismissed']
+40072;['appeal is allowed']
+132883;['appeals of appellant km, appellant ma, appellant am, and appellant kam are dismissed']
+93289;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+125494;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+46004;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123023;['nor is she a person in need of protection']
+64312;['appeal is allowed']
+96107;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxxis rejected']
+76806;['appeal is allowed']
+91328;['appeal is dismissed']
+84642;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a claim for refugee protection']
+144723;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+56964;['appeal is allowed']
+13956;['appeals are dismissed']
+73255;['appeal is allowed']
+27588;['appeal of the december 22, 2014 determination is dismissed']
+70784;['appeal is dismissed']
+90990;['appeal is dismissed']
+40063;['appeal is dismissed']
+128881;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+74233;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+107483;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+93656;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+26785;['refusal is invalid in law']
+80466;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+131862;['confirm the rpd determination', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26490;['appeal is dismissed']
+60369;['removal order isset aside']
+91223;['appeal is allowed']
+87323;['appeal is allowed']
+111316;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+76456;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95947;['appeal of wendy lynn ivancic is dismissed']
+85386;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal', 'allow his appeal']
+77467;['appeal is terminated']
+100825;['appeal isallowed.the']
+99091;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107373;['appeal is dismissed']
+129401;['rpd’s credibility assessment stands']
+112374;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+99184;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+95766;['application to vacate is moot']
+107090;['appeal is allowed']
+76537;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+77089;['dismiss this appeal']
+136076;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+96846;['appeal is allowed']
+116352;['302 (c.a.)']
+56508;['dismiss the application for an extension of the time limit']
+93346;['appeal is allowed']
+123290;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76978;['appeal is dismissed']
+67534;['appeal is allowed']
+124087;['appeal is allowed']
+79201;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+71115;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+56708;['appeal isallowed']
+67729;['appeal is allowed']
+80492;['appeal isallowed.the']
+106806;['reject such argument']
+145387;['nor a risk of cruel and unusual treatment or punishment']
+138281;['appeal is dismissed']
+121404;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67016;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+127703;['appeal is thereforeallowed']
+62997;['appeal isallowed']
+146156;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131710;['appeal is dismissed']
+83090;['appeal is allowed']
+99669;['302 (c.a.)']
+86954;['appeal is not without its negatives']
+46017;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+77581;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+99947;['appeal of yih-shin shu is dismissed']
+147610;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+81231;['appeal is dismissed']
+151903;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57294;['appeal is dismissed']
+123343;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+61972;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+101255;['allows the appeal in law']
+56501;['appeal is dismissed']
+120796;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99697;['appeal is dismissed']
+148608;['dismiss the appeal']
+16825;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61489;['appeal isallowed']
+105231;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82788;['appeal isallowed']
+56731;['appeal is dismissed']
+100415;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89720;['appeal is terminated']
+100248;['allow the appeal']
+80460;['appeal is dismissed']
+98949;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+94430;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98114;['the claim fails']
+58569;['appeal isallowed']
+99020;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+75487;['appeal is dismissed']
+90596;['appeal is determined']
+145432;['decision is legally valid']
+147443;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+95115;['appeal is dismissed']
+82691;['appeal isallowed']
+100856;['claimantis a convention refugee']
+143915;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+13956;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+75004;['appeal is allowed']
+37409;['appeal of trung hung dieu is allowed']
+54728;['appeal is deemed to be abandoned']
+89886;['“convention refugees”', 'rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+46104;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+108068;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108125;['appeal is dismissed']
+95142;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107044;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+68205;['appeal of elizabeth torres sta']
+97478;['claims are rejected']
+75160;['appeal is dismissed']
+92999;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+21391;['not convention refugees']
+124370;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+93972;['appeal is allowed']
+88327;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+121450;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110306;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+45391;['appeal is dismissed']
+80508;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+145386;['302 (c.a.']
+142996;['appeal is allowed']
+89897;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102695;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+59801;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+50428;['appeals are dismissed']
+100971;['immigration appeal division therefore orders the appellant’s removal from canada']
+123723;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+61009;['negative']
+73897;['appeal isallowed']
+151906;['appeal is dismissed']
+131707;['302 (c.a.']
+105895;['appeal is dismissed']
+104466;['appeal is dismissed']
+56730;['appeal is dismissed']
+45990;['appeal is dismissed']
+95232;['decision is valid in law']
+129735;['appeal is allowed.the']
+103718;['302 (c.a.']
+77973;['appeal is dismissed']
+56941;['case is dismissed']
+134310;['appeal is allowed']
+145533;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+139451;['appeal were dismissed']
+90589;['tribunal\xa0dismisses the appeal']
+130969;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124736;['rad finds that the rpd’s change of circumstances']
+145875;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69466;['appeal isallowed']
+26699;['four removal orders are accordingly quashed']
+104352;['appeal is dismissed']
+130746;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+62934;['appeal of victor chan is dismissed']
+85307;['appeal must be dismissed']
+46536;['appeal is dismissed']
+143242;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30548;['appeals are dismissed']
+98670;['appeal of shoukat samina is dismissed']
+17147;['appeal is allowed']
+82207;['application was dismissed']
+26673;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+41199;['appeal is allowed']
+84824;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+46241;['find the visa officer’s decision valid in law']
+90772;['dismiss the appeal']
+65418;['appeals of chun ku lai and chun ti lai are allowed']
+83046;['appeal is allowed']
+100052;['appeal were dismissed']
+95388;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+47618;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare “convention\xa0refugees”']
+75605;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate reasons']
+149570;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+46074;['appeal isallowedand']
+67523;['appeal is allowed']
+34699;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+113784;['refugee appeal division (rad) dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124016;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+102259;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+92492;['appeal is allowed']
+107097;['appeal is allowed']
+17935;['appeal isallowedand']
+71161;['negative']
+68579;['refusal invalid in law']
+81081;['appeal is dismissed']
+26796;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+136087;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+101719;['appeal is allowed']
+56891;['appeal fails']
+106801;['appeal is dismissed']
+53143;['appeal is determined']
+63895;['appeal is allowed']
+91911;['appeal is allowed']
+17999;['appeal isallowedand']
+153145;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+108760;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87507;['appeal is allowed']
+74699;['appeal is dismissed']
+86025;['appeal is allowed']
+43322;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+97781;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+19304;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47400;['rejects his claim']
+97561;['appeal is allowed']
+108694;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107187;['appeal is dismissed']
+17961;['appeals are dismissed']
+101237;['appeal isallowed']
+90482;['appeal is allowed']
+107250;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+123129;['substitute my own decision that he is a convention refugee']
+76539;['allow the appeal']
+90202;['neither convention refugees']
+46101;['dismiss the appeal']
+148634;['appeals were dismissed']
+61481;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+47141;['appeal is dismissed']
+116850;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+47300;['appeal is allowed']
+68423;['appeal is terminated']
+122857;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140864;['appeal is allowed']
+141320;['dismiss the appeal']
+75981;['appeal is allowed']
+52711;['claimants do not fall under the category of persons in need of protection']
+13419;['appeal isallowed']
+5156;['appeal is allowed']
+83016;['elf-rc']
+91370;['appeal is dismissed']
+19310;['refugee appeal division sets aside the decision of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+82049;['appeal is allowed']
+140814;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+70953;['reject his claim']
+138821;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+81327;['appeal is dismissed']
+76334;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71711;['appeal is dismissed']
+144382;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+148492;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+111035;['claimant xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection', 'division rejects her claim']
+123918;['appeal is allowed']
+77446;['appeals of wen ge li and his son bo cheng li are dismissed']
+50522;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+127351;['appeal is allowed']
+84658;['appeal is allowed']
+98136;['appeal is allowed']
+122973;['appeal is allowed']
+38242;['appeal fails']
+46103;['appeal dismissed']
+145382;['302 (c.a.']
+145426;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+74628;['appeal is allowed']
+139463;['appeal is dismissed']
+79750;['302 (c.a.)']
+54285;['appeals of mei huan yu, shao quan yu and shao jie yu are dismissed']
+50427;['appeal is allowed']
+134736;['rad cannot confirm or set aside the decision']
+100821;['appeal is allowed']
+87692;['appeal isallowed']
+26532;['appeal is dismissed']
+92830;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+102037;['appeal is allowed']
+43716;['appeal is dismissed']
+91117;['appeal is dismissed']
+66919;['dismiss the appeal']
+82182;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96495;['appeal is allowed']
+153018;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+121461;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+98098;['application is denied']
+145049;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+128375;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+97404;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+16829;['appeal is dismissed']
+148642;['appeal is dismissed']
+151935;['appeal is allowed']
+8335;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+99487;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+59791;['removal order is set aside']
+94821;['appeal is allowed']
+90485;['appeal is allowed']
+152015;['appeal is allowed']
+62991;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+66638;['decision of the immigration officer to be valid in law']
+44900;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+78070;['appeal isallowed']
+72673;['appeal fails']
+97477;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+144031;['appeal is allowed']
+54793;['appeal is terminated']
+101395;['appeal is allowed']
+67922;['dismiss this appeal']
+102140;['rad agrees with the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+141787;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+59800;['appeal is dismissed']
+56677;['appeal is not allowed in law']
+47328;['appeal is allowed']
+29685;['appeal is terminated']
+10838;['appeal isallowed.the']
+79332;['appeal is dismissed']
+55910;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+106942;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+123264;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125499;['they are unfounded']
+145384;['302 (c.a.']
+67719;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94350;['appeal is allowed']
+94986;['appeal isallowed']
+147628;['rad concurs with this remedy']
+95677;['appeals are dismissed']
+50476;['appeal is allowed in law']
+131717;['rad therefore finds that the rpd’s decision cannot be upheld']
+107899;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+86317;['appeal is allowed.the']
+79976;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+134297;['appeal is dismissed']
+37870;['302 (c.a.']
+71281;['appeal is allowed']
+91546;['appeal is allowed']
+31975;['appeal is allowed']
+132366;['appeal is dismissed']
+69536;['appeal is thereforedismissed']
+127703;['appeal is allowed']
+72896;['appeal is allowed']
+125038;['appeal is allowed']
+69080;['appeal is allowed']
+96294;['appeal is allowed']
+85631;['appeal is terminated']
+105633;['appeal is dismissed']
+152921;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71232;['appeal is allowed']
+107645;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+141230;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100637;['appeal dismissed']
+131089;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+152017;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+144556;['they are therefore not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+140900;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis referred to insection 98of theirpaand']
+50535;['appeal of jhanvi shailesh shah is allowed']
+108944;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+79682;['appeal is dismissed']
+54639;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+71228;['appeal is allowed']
+12994;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+121440;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86631;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+52062;['appeal is dismissed']
+135899;['appeal is allowed']
+20008;['appeal of markus johannes prenner is allowed']
+85873;['negative']
+61452;['dismiss this appeal']
+105315;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100714;['claimants not to be convention refugees and not to be persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+108803;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+112350;['appeal is allowed']
+145320;['rad confirms the rpds determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+117117;['appeal would be dismissed']
+102692;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+153814;['appeal is allowed']
+101365;['appeal is adjourned']
+86984;['appeals are allowed']
+102922;['application is dismissed']
+91819;['appeal is dismissed']
+95450;['appeal is dismissed']
+99598;['appeal is dismissed']
+26756;['appeal must be dismissed']
+87824;['not a person in need of protection']
+98802;['appeal is allowed']
+96563;['appeal is terminated']
+49236;['claimant is not a convention refugee and the']
+120818;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91265;['regulations are worded']
+105305;['appeal is dismissed']
+64922;['appeal isallowed']
+93774;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105344;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+27310;['appeal is allowed']
+59159;['appeal would be dismissed']
+84450;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+47787;['allow the appeal']
+84531;['appeal is dismissed']
+87156;['appeal is dismissed']
+114351;['appeal is allowed']
+87196;['appeal isallowed']
+55205;['reject her claim']
+76686;['appeal is dismissed']
+85979;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident   visa is set aside']
+52598;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+15562;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+105297;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+153629;['appeal is dismissed']
+78069;['appeal of jaspreet kaur khandal is allowed']
+106624;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+100896;['appeal is dismissed']
+99740;['appeal is allowed']
+107813;['claimants are neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+95335;['appeal is dismissed']
+89225;['appeal is terminated']
+121952;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+79749;['appeal is terminated']
+69085;['appeal is denied']
+60461;['appeal isterminated']
+83509;['dismissal of the appeal']
+98667;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98647;['rejects this claim']
+91407;['negative']
+76083;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+129150;['appeal is allowed']
+34928;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision must stand']
+42392;['appeal isallowed']
+142499;['appeals are dismissed']
+107187;['rad finds no errors of fact or law']
+98289;['appeal is dismissed']
+108734;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is not supportable']
+93655;['appeal isallowed']
+13552;['appeal is dismissed']
+69672;['appeal is allowed']
+96569;['appeal is allowed']
+113755;['appeal is allowed']
+99596;['appeal is dismissed']
+103501;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+151557;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+130690;['appeal isallowed']
+50753;['appeal isallowed']
+94668;['appeal isallowed']
+113629;['theappealis allowed']
+127367;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76914;['appeal is dismissed']
+151905;['decision cannot stand']
+75569;['appeal isallowed']
+75881;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+101457;['appeal isallowed']
+103612;['appeal is dismissed']
+69082;['appeal is allowed']
+90108;['302 (c.a.)']
+99630;['appeal is   ']
+137676;['appeal be dismissed']
+47119;['removal order is set aside']
+84209;['appeal be and is hereby dismissed']
+101614;['appeal was dismissed']
+57083;['appeal being dismissed']
+96312;['appeal is dismissed']
+97487;['claimant is neither a convention refugee/s nor a person/s in need of protection']
+67227;['appeal is allowed']
+30505;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+104164;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+99508;['panel rejects this claim']
+103716;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+79215;['appeal is dismissed']
+86144;['appeal is governed']
+145356;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95247;['appeal is allowed']
+88160;['appeal is dismissed']
+59804;['determination is valid in law']
+94431;['appeals are dismissed']
+80824;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+97384;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+85534;['dismissal of the appeal']
+73349;['nor a security risk']
+102553;['appeal is allowed']
+74783;['appeal isallowed']
+101466;['appeal isallowed']
+30412;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+13756;['appeal is dismissed']
+97117;['appeal is terminated']
+107619;['302 (c.a.']
+128421;['appeal is dismissed']
+54251;['appeal is dismissed']
+102934;['appeal is dismissed']
+128373;['appeals of yasamin elyasi bakhtiari and nazanin elyasi bakhtiari are allowed']
+102753;['application to re-open is allowed']
+65664;['dismissing this appeal']
+94540;['appeal must be dismissed']
+59998;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+69068;['appeal isallowed']
+81077;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+57533;['appeal is dismissed']
+83437;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+142502;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+69783;['appeal is terminated']
+76562;['negative determination']
+126391;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+142455;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+102450;['appeal is dismissed']
+131522;['appeal is allowed.the']
+34628;['decision is well founded in law']
+76150;['appeal is dismissed']
+90914;['visa officer’s determination is valid in law']
+127475;['appeals are allowed']
+93891;['appeal of charlene stushnoff is dismissed']
+56589;['appeal is dismissed']
+65677;['appeal is allowed']
+123545;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123451;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+102035;['application to reopen the appeal isdismissed.']
+81854;['determination is valid in law']
+110988;['appeal is allowed']
+106444;['appeal is allowed']
+121435;['appeal would be dismissed']
+26930;['xxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+132752;['panel rejects both claims']
+67512;['appeal is dismissed']
+82572;['appeal is terminated']
+74033;['302 (c.a.']
+85463;['removal orders areset asidethe', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+148058;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128380;['appeal is allowed']
+63756;['appeal isgranted']
+27721;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+93659;['appeal is allowed']
+68598;['appeal isallowed']
+108811;['appeal is dismissed']
+108688;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45233;['appeal of esam kolta is dismissed']
+130976;['appeal is denied']
+52093;['appeal is dismissed']
+45426;['decision is well-founded in law and in fact']
+81862;['appeal is determined']
+100524;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects their claims']
+89212;['appeal allowed']
+133738;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+116763;['appeal be dismissed']
+124707;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97496;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+98563;['dismissed the appeal']
+132392;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'allow the appeal']
+57828;['appeal is dismissed']
+71637;['allow his appeal.']
+108758;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84292;['appeal is dismissed']
+51051;['appeals are dismissed']
+98992;['appeal is dismissed']
+125691;['appeal fails']
+142972;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69990;['appeal in this case is dismissed']
+19241;['rad finds that theappellant is a convention refugee']
+125238;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+127362;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+84066;['appeal isallowed']
+137677;['appeal is dismissed']
+70069;['…]”']
+149017;['302 (c.a.']
+95595;['reject his claim']
+130765;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+52219;['appeal is allowed']
+84469;['appeal is allowed']
+80522;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+130687;['dismiss the appeal']
+100456;['appeal isallowed']
+94279;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+144752;['decision of the immigration division is upheld']
+84232;['appeal isallowed']
+47185;['appeal from a second refusal is dismissed']
+59776;['appeal isallowed']
+91214;['appeal is allowed']
+104001;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+85459;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94141;['appeal of rajinder singh khosa is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+76828;['appeal is dismissed']
+69406;['appeal isallowed']
+68726;['dismiss the appeal']
+123535;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131136;['appeal is based']
+132430;['xxxx xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee, neither is he a person in need of protection']
+94751;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+95375;['appeal is dismissed']
+85871;['302 (c.a.']
+133257;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+71145;['appeal is allowed']
+99291;['rad finds no errors in those reasons']
+99102;['appeal is allowed']
+35057;['dismissing the appeal']
+134399;['appeal is dismissed']
+66247;['appeal is dismissed']
+142991;['allow the appeals']
+63517;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+132883;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151972;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+121482;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a person described in article\xa01e of the convention', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+84371;['appeal is terminated']
+68330;['appeal is allowed']
+122669;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+50729;['appellant has not lost her permanent residence status']
+111324;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is he a “person in need of protection']
+87996;['all five claimants are not convention refugees']
+113592;['appeal is allowed']
+71367;['appeal is dismissed']
+83126;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+146640;['reject their claims']
+101774;['appeal is allowed']
+99863;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+83087;['appeal isallowed.the']
+133374;['appeal is allowed']
+72777;['appeal must be dismissed']
+111286;['302 (c.a.']
+67610;['appeal ofdaljit natt, in respect to his wife']
+55291;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+141638;['appeal is allowed']
+88906;['appeal is based']
+83110;['appeal is terminated']
+93942;['appeal is allowed']
+123432;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+122644;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76159;['appeal isallowed']
+132784;['appellant cannot claim refugee status']
+93613;['appeal isallowed']
+88011;['reject his claim']
+113509;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+84060;['appellant has lost his permanent resident status']
+71465;['appeal is dismissed']
+54267;['appeal of hussan abdul is dismissed']
+87286;['negative']
+130701;['removal order isset aside']
+88888;['refugee protection claims ofxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxmust therefore be rejected', '“convention refugees”']
+69083;['appeal is dismissed']
+92775;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+128443;['appeal is allowed']
+92277;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee a person in need of protection', 'claim is, therefore, rejected']
+90829;['appeal abandoned']
+86835;['appeal is allowed']
+78193;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+63975;['removal order isset aside']
+83385;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101481;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+117208;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+107193;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+93875;['appeal is dismissed']
+47344;['appeal is allowed']
+116130;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+75618;['dismiss the appeal']
+90651;['appeal is dismissed']
+19726;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+84910;['confirm the determination']
+81852;['appeal is allowed']
+62122;['appeal is terminated']
+102173;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+121399;['appeal is allowed']
+114356;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125026;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+141205;['appeal is dismissed']
+68579;['appeal is allowed']
+105195;['appeal is dismissed']
+124667;['appeal is also denied']
+19114;['appeal is dismissed']
+143851;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+143578;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77275;['appeal terminated']
+80126;['appeal is allowed']
+96724;['appeal is terminated']
+61736;['appeal is determined']
+76690;['dismiss her appeal']
+100772;['appeals are determined to beabandonedunders.']
+130859;['appeal is allowed']
+101407;['appeal is granted']
+52276;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+62212;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+97376;['appeal is allowed']
+131912;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal for lack of interest']
+71157;['refusal is invalid']
+100268;['appeal is allowed']
+59864;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+131156;['appeal is dismissed']
+98982;['neither a convention refugee']
+148733;['claim is rejected']
+87450;['appeal were dismissed']
+63927;['appeal is dismissed']
+66253;['appeal from the 117(9)(d) refusal']
+70937;['appeal is dismissed']
+133408;['appeal were dismissed']
+121106;['claimant is a person in need of protection', 'allows his refugee protection claim']
+69466;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89812;['appeal ought to be dismissed']
+69671;['dismisses this appeal']
+71192;['appeal of paramjit kaur malhi aka paramjit kaur sangha is dismissed']
+98904;['appeal isallowed']
+99352;['appeals were dismissed']
+109028;['appellant lacks the right of appeal']
+109032;['appeals forgurdev singh gill and gurdev kaur gill are dismissed', 'appeal regarding kuldeep sing gill, is withdrawn']
+35243;['appeal be dismissed']
+103882;['you are not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim']
+152022;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+124029;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+90069;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+81880;['visa officer’s determination is not legally valid']
+114453;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90197;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+57729;['appeal was declared abandoned']
+144418;['appeal is dismissed']
+107194;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130959;['appeals of xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are allowed']
+47119;['appeal isallowed']
+91067;['appeal is allowed']
+68259;['appeal is allowed']
+78193;['allow his appeal']
+91925;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+83669;['appeal isallowed']
+143641;['appeals aredismissed.']
+42412;['appeal isallowed']
+105776;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a conventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71791;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+131095;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm thatxxxx xxxx xxxxdoes not face a serious possibility of persecution']
+74463;['appeal is allowed']
+96276;['not a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+103459;['appeal is allowed']
+136153;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes that decision with its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+142451;['appeal is allowed']
+102076;['appeal is dismissed']
+123609;['appeal is allowed']
+70943;['appeal is dismissed']
+150151;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124609;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+127470;['appeal is allowed']
+47718;['appeal is allowed in law']
+147603;['appeal is dismissed']
+69784;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+21440;['refugee division determines xxxxxxx xxxxxx, the claimant']
+138880;['appeal is allowed']
+19307;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98139;['removal order is set aside']
+112788;['appeals are dismissed']
+111014;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69589;['appeal is allowed']
+112339;['appeal is dismissed']
+131864;['rpd determination is thus set aside']
+18015;['appeal is determinedabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+143669;['appeal is allowed']
+139838;['appeal is dismissed']
+76731;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+83196;['appeal is dismissed']
+121223;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+99602;['appeal is dismissed']
+94422;['appeal is allowed']
+45399;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+116748;['appeal is allowed']
+73304;['appeal is allowed']
+98853;['appeal is dismissed']
+95532;['nor a “convention refugee”']
+61413;['appeal is dismissed']
+81371;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is there any evidence']
+90983;['appeal of abdul kanu is dismissed']
+72678;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+84478;['appeal is allowed']
+142823;['appeals should be dismissed']
+98555;['appeal is allowed']
+57906;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+96861;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+13419;['departure order isset aside']
+99385;['claimants,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+100149;['appeal is dismissed']
+53144;['appeal is thus allowed']
+91686;['appeal is dismissed']
+77843;['negative']
+92768;['appeal isallowed']
+100986;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+105625;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+29464;['appeal is dismissed']
+135146;['appeal is dismissed']
+143001;['appeal is allowed']
+96251;['appeal is dismissed']
+82880;['appeal is allowed']
+111180;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+39568;['appeals are allowed']
+100495;['appeal is allowed']
+88086;['appeal is allowed']
+91143;['appeal is dismissed']
+74284;['concur with her decision']
+46388;['appeal is dismissed']
+132384;['appeal is dismissed']
+144395;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+146870;['appeal is allowed']
+77275;['appeal terminated']
+107159;['negative decision would be overturned']
+18863;['appeal is allowed']
+141211;['neither the objective evidence']
+42419;['appeal is allowed']
+91149;['refuse the present appeal']
+66765;['appeal is allowed']
+54208;['negative decision']
+76332;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+71609;['appeal is not allowed']
+69386;['appeal is dismissed']
+98141;['appeal is determined']
+99307;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+108725;['appeal is dismissed']
+76721;['appeal is allowed']
+94130;['appeal of shitay birare birare is dismissed']
+31995;['appeal is dismissed']
+132806;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125582;['appeal is allowed']
+95050;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99146;['appeals are allowed.the']
+76836;['appeal is allowed']
+56979;['” exception', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+101926;['appeal isallowed']
+58126;['appeal isdismissed.']
+77651;['appellant is established in canada']
+101450;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94276;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+128909;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are excluded under article\xa01e of theconvention relating to the status of refugeesand', 'not be refugees or persons in need of protection']
+100157;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+105890;['rad finds that its positive decision in regard to these claims']
+87443;['appeal is determined']
+45211;['appeal of qi chao wang is dismissed']
+60129;['appeal is terminated']
+98497;['appeal is terminated']
+152027;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+76667;['appeal isallowed']
+95587;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+89321;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+91564;['302 (c.a.']
+89817;['302 (c.a.']
+110567;['not find him to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+29693;['appeal is dismissed']
+123002;['refugee protection division (rpd) rejected his claim for refugee protection']
+128932;['appeal is dismissed']
+68431;['appeal is dismissed']
+143010;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100359;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+65115;['appeal is allowed']
+77230;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+121866;['dismiss this argument']
+84138;['appeal isallowed']
+131147;['302 (c.a.']
+123711;['appeal is allowed']
+98555;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+97655;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis rejected']
+59821;['appeal be dismissed']
+87514;['appeal is dismissed']
+92512;['appeal is dismissed']
+89136;['appeal must fail']
+53828;['appeal is abandoned']
+95578;['application is allowed']
+142501;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87505;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+71284;['appeal isallowed.the']
+133370;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+89362;['appeal isallowed']
+107461;['dismisses the appeal']
+128183;['appeal is dismissed']
+123759;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+22815;['dismiss the present appeal']
+113792;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88980;['appeal isallowed.the']
+129241;['appeal is allowed']
+93286;['appeal is dismissed']
+26786;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+96497;['proceeding is declared null and void']
+100230;['panel finds the visa officer’s determination to be valid in law']
+121434;['appeal would be dismissed']
+60199;['appeal is allowed']
+116754;['rad confirms that the adult appellants']
+101026;['appeal is governed by theact']
+17165;['allow this appeal']
+74847;['appeal of jasbir singh randhawa is dismissed']
+96655;['claim is rejected']
+90611;['appeal is allowed']
+71554;['appeal is allowed']
+102031;['appeal isallowedand']
+131864;['rpd determination is set aside']
+95394;['appeal is allowed']
+107443;['leads me to conclude that the', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+105302;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143550;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93831;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129914;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+137569;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+110718;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+27479;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+149445;['appellant is excluded from claiming that he is a convention refugee and/or a person in need of protection']
+148727;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+43713;['appeal is allowed']
+101953;['ifa fails on the first prong']
+102023;['appeal is determined']
+36135;['appeal is allowed']
+61432;['appeal is allowed']
+86889;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+85481;['appeal is allowed']
+102556;['application is being dismissed']
+66770;['appeal is allowed']
+56955;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+48096;['appeal is allowed']
+123360;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+92932;['appeal is terminated']
+108055;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+125483;['rpd’s decision is correct']
+129858;['appeal is dismissed']
+100075;['appeal is dismissedand']
+41570;['appeal has been abandoned']
+45172;['appeal is dismissed']
+91273;['appeal isallowed']
+123113;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+46556;['allows this appeal']
+15019;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+82104;['appeal is dismissed']
+94923;['appeal is allowed in law', 'stay is cancelled']
+97948;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+94180;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60953;['appeal is dismissed']
+121558;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+75708;['appeal were dismissed']
+96112;['not a “person in need of protection']
+107249;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+77339;['appeal is dismissed']
+122897;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+153278;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+93057;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand']
+87306;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+68422;['sets aside the removal order and allows the appeal']
+63834;['appeal may proceed no further']
+98006;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+93062;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+70796;['allow the appeal']
+59818;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98446;['appeal must be dismissed']
+150633;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98269;['appeal is dismissed']
+27294;['order isnot valid in law']
+107047;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+124414;['appeal is allowed']
+62628;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+144007;['appeals are dismissed']
+114359;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95924;['rad directs the rpd to reconsider the claimde novo']
+91588;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+27243;['appeal be dismissed']
+67439;['appeal be allowed']
+46271;['appeal is dismissed']
+101479;['appeal must be dismissed']
+48205;['federal case was dismissed']
+17943;['appeal is determined']
+83076;['appeals are allowed']
+94339;['appeal isallowed']
+74150;['appeal of tej singh brar be rescheduled']
+26821;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+81662;['appeal isallowed']
+104105;['refugee protection division rejects his claim', 'claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+142303;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+132351;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+31414;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+21413;['not convention refugees']
+94292;['application for an extension of time is dismissed']
+50931;['application for an extension of time']
+130998;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69123;['appeal is allowed']
+21318;['negative - ethiopia']
+123472;['appeal is dismissed']
+72016;['appeal is dismissed']
+100289;['302 (c.a.']
+85919;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+74477;['appeal isallowed']
+42297;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69615;['iab allowed the appeal']
+19997;['appeal isallowed.the']
+36107;['appeal is allowed']
+89330;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+94473;['appeal is dismissed']
+101326;['appeal isallowed']
+95384;['appeals cannot succeed']
+91616;['appeal is dismissed']
+69606;['appeal isallowed']
+69758;['removal orders are set aside']
+128301;['appeal is dismissed']
+62452;['appeal is allowed']
+90968;['appeal is dismissed']
+54200;['appeal is allowed']
+92024;['appeal is allowed']
+148655;['appeal is dismissed']
+101240;['appeal abandoned']
+96717;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+142525;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56791;['refugee protection division rejects this claim to refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+78013;['determination is valid in law']
+93657;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+75080;['appeal be dismissed']
+85256;['appeal is terminated']
+91740;['appeal is allowed']
+86060;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+94702;['appeal were dismissed']
+52117;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81000;['appeal is allowed.the']
+97963;['302 (c.a.']
+77540;['appeal is dismissed']
+44731;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+17384;['appeal is dismissed']
+95949;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83442;['appeal dismissed']
+69545;['appeal is dismissed']
+142971;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122113;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+150683;['substitute a decision that these appellants are convention refugees']
+60954;['appeal is dismissed']
+67373;['appeal isallowed']
+44920;['rpd decision is set aside']
+97439;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+131754;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+36115;['appeal isallowed']
+141630;['appeal is dismissed']
+69594;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+96914;['appeal is allowed']
+97386;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+146969;['application for withdrawal is dismissed']
+85476;['appeal is dismissed']
+30553;['appeal is dismissed']
+130973;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+26510;['appeal isallowed']
+77912;['appeal of amrit pal dhillon is dismissed']
+90144;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92515;['appeal is allowed']
+121950;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+35155;['appeal is allowed']
+93918;['appeal is dismissed']
+94182;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+82199;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99923;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+96413;['appeal isallowed']
+42331;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+40664;['appeal isallowedand']
+99185;['reject his claim']
+64624;['appeal is dismissed']
+131917;['appeal is allowed']
+80453;['appeal is dismissed']
+108808;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person who would be subject to persecution should she return to china']
+99941;['claim is rejected']
+85922;['302 (c.a.']
+123875;['appellants are convention refugees']
+93222;['appeal fails to be a negative factor']
+122950;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+99862;['appeal is dismissed']
+147452;['claims are rejected']
+63975;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+108121;['rad confirms the decision of rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+152026;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+98340;['appeal fails']
+97525;['negative']
+46025;['302 (c.a.)']
+133388;['appeal is dismissed']
+92775;['removal order isset aside']
+74664;['appeal is allowed']
+61211;['appeal is allowed']
+17385;['appeal is dismissed']
+82203;['allow his appeal']
+45394;['302 (c.a.']
+122888;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98229;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+104289;['appeal is allowed']
+81848;['appeal is allowed']
+100793;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+122624;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84136;['appeal isallowed']
+83382;['appeal is terminated']
+128270;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+78169;['xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees']
+84718;['appeal isallowedfor']
+98436;['appeal is dismissed']
+38411;['appeal is dismissed']
+52621;"['xxxxxxxx is a ""convention refugee']"
+81376;['appeal is allowed']
+38785;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94164;['claimants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54631;['appeal should be dismissed']
+84152;['appeal isallowed']
+151784;['appeal is allowed']
+112376;['appeal is allowed']
+124684;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+58103;['appeal is dismissed']
+123647;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+57065;['appeal is dismissed']
+144940;['appeal is allowed']
+121872;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+130961;['nor a genuine christian shouter']
+81880;['visa officer’s determination is not valid in law']
+72730;['appeal is dismissed']
+102168;['appeal is dismissed']
+110904;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78664;['appeal be dismissed']
+61367;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+100604;['removal order is set aside']
+123991;['set aside the rpd determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+72066;['appeal is allowed']
+26692;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+152012;['dismissing the appeal for lack of perfection']
+70469;['appeal respecting romina villamonte is dismissed']
+57738;['dismisses the appeal']
+95267;['application to reopen the appeal is denied']
+97481;['appeal is found to have merit']
+92956;['appeal is terminated']
+86340;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+88515;['her claim also fails']
+106754;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+99069;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+122703;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+13678;['appeal is dismissed']
+55295;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+21306;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+121403;['leads me to conclude that the appellant has not established that he was ever threatened or targeted by individuals']
+27018;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx, andxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+76595;['appeal is dismissed']
+97988;['appeal is allowed']
+47298;['appeal of zhao san liu is dismissed']
+89458;['appeal is dismissed']
+122972;['appeal is allowed']
+92167;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is 30']
+86990;['appeal is allowed']
+94592;['appeal allowed in chambers']
+100347;['appeal is dismissed']
+70843;['dismiss this appeal']
+145845;['appeal is allowed']
+52672;['claimant was not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection.rpd']
+68106;['appeal is allowed']
+52773;['appeal is dismissed']
+136694;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143913;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80114;['appeal is allowed']
+50470;['uphold the rpd’s findings']
+99863;['appeal is allowed.the']
+132755;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+83037;['appeal is allowed']
+78026;['appeal is dismissed']
+55273;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+91215;['appeal is terminated']
+84414;['panel declines jurisdiction']
+92500;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+123434;['appeal is dismissed']
+92766;['dismiss her appeal,']
+74713;['appeal is terminated']
+135146;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56965;['appeal of ali mehdylou is allowed']
+76945;['appeal could be dismissed']
+45155;['appeal of khalid ramadan is allowed in law']
+47879;['appeal isallowed']
+30509;['determination is valid in law']
+100016;['appeal is dismissed']
+136114;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145230;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+113627;['removal order is set aside']
+98638;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+143502;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46575;['appeal isallowed']
+61621;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+83030;['dismiss the appeal']
+96665;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the', 'respondents are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107066;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107940;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+136675;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113515;['appeal is dismissed']
+98575;['decision of the id is set aside']
+71690;['appeal isallowed']
+61947;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+63704;['appeal is allowed']
+153274;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76704;['appeals of rasham singh atwal and tarsem kaur atwal are dismissed']
+107246;['rad finds the decision of the rpd is wrong in law']
+87694;['302 (c.a.)']
+74125;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+112385;['removal order is set aside']
+97394;['appeal is dismissed']
+95042;['appeal is dismissed']
+61457;['allows this appeal']
+96879;['appeal is dismissed']
+92991;['appeal isallowed']
+63199;['appeal is terminated']
+151940;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+52315;['appeal of mohamed sanaz kaleel is dismissed']
+132332;['dismiss the appeal']
+111026;['dismisses the appeal']
+96627;['appeal were dismissed']
+138864;['appeal is allowed']
+99094;['sponsor is a sponsor within']
+74759;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+126418;['appeal is dismissed']
+10990;['sponsor is not a sponsor']
+87964;['appeal be allowed']
+81856;['appeal is dismissed']
+63972;['appeal is allowed']
+69216;['appeal isallowed']
+88169;['appeal is dismissed']
+63808;['claimant is, therefore, not a convention refugee']
+66779;['allow the appeal']
+128609;['appellants are convention refugees']
+129165;['determination is valid in law']
+89346;['negative']
+96100;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim of xxxx xxxx xxxx']
+92171;['appeal is dismissed']
+131103;['appeal isallowed']
+128908;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67743;['appeal is allowed']
+87167;['appeal constitutes an abuse of process']
+12205;['appeal is allowed.the']
+121435;['appeal were dismissed']
+132810;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133398;['appeal is dismissed']
+110562;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125511;['appeal is allowed']
+94027;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89891;['appeal isallowed']
+93805;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+148646;['dismissal of this appeal is not a ban from canada']
+145823;['302 (c.a.']
+37831;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+76249;['appeals are allowed']
+132758;['appeal has been withdrawn']
+107624;['appeal is dismissed']
+90796;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+61429;['appeal isallowedand']
+83169;['appellant lost his permanent resident status']
+58490;['dismiss the appeal']
+116862;['appeal is dismissed']
+109277;['application to reopen the appeal is granted']
+72530;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47380;['appeal is dismissed']
+38785;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+65624;['appeal is allowed']
+98268;['appeal is allowed']
+134313;['appeal is dismissed']
+74450;['appeal is dismissed']
+132639;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78666;['allows the appeal']
+100983;['appeal is dismissed']
+100997;['appeal isallowed']
+106841;['appeal is allowed']
+94058;['appeal is dismissed']
+80031;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124056;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+152926;['appeal is dismissed']
+80470;['appeal is allowed']
+101338;['appeal isallowed']
+76100;['appeal is allowed']
+74784;['appeal isallowed']
+85934;['appeal isallowed']
+84830;['appeal isallowed']
+50514;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+95910;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+52370;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124583;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87089;['appeal isallowed']
+130706;['appeal is allowed']
+61012;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+94370;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+60416;['application is dismissed']
+17184;['appeal be dismissed']
+99648;['removal order is set aside']
+94755;['appeal is allowed']
+122906;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60082;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+69534;['appeal is allowed']
+140865;['rad rejects this argument']
+63126;['reject this claim to refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee']
+140820;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+47119;['removal order isset aside']
+95088;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+92471;['appeal is allowed']
+122762;['claimants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+99652;['appeal is dismissed']
+124715;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a person of interest']
+61802;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim for refugee protection']
+84784;['appeals are dismissed']
+56818;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxx xxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+151404;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+54712;['appeal isallowed']
+40656;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+149069;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+121442;['appeal is dismissed']
+74888;['appeal isallowed']
+135181;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are excluded from refugee protection']
+145215;['dismiss the appeal']
+26740;['appeal brought']
+102693;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+40077;['appeal is allowed']
+53855;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+38241;['appeal is allowed']
+143642;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30542;['appeal is allowed']
+113682;['appeal dismissed']
+76415;['appeal isallowed']
+129187;['appeal was dismissed']
+146546;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+123332;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+31461;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+131084;['substitute my determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+76812;['appeal isallowedand']
+90928;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+118660;['confirm the rpd’s positive determination']
+145179;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+52046;['appeal is terminated']
+56679;['appeal is dismissed']
+41079;['appeal of david adomako yeboah is dismissed']
+122222;['appeal is allowed']
+60894;['appeal is allowed']
+93806;['negative']
+142819;['appeal is allowed']
+79203;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+102027;['application to reopen the appeal isdismissed.']
+83088;['appeal is allowed']
+147476;['crc/c/arg/co/5–6.']
+138884;['appeal is allowed']
+98314;['appeals were dismissed']
+95132;['appeal is caught by the provisions ofregulation4']
+135154;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision appealed', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+98719;['302 (c.a.']
+59388;['appeal is dismissed']
+133362;['not uphold the decision to reject their claims']
+63196;['pardon is subsequently revoked']
+57784;['allows the appeal', 'sets aside the removal order made against him']
+99985;['appeal isallowed']
+123257;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+65093;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26679;['appeal division finds the appellant has failed to demonstrate']
+59373;['panel finds the visa officer’s decision that the appellant is in breach of his residency obligation']
+82254;['appeal ofthe minister of public safety and emergency preparedness']
+149022;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26977;['xxxxxx xxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+96887;['appeal is allowed']
+57225;['appeal is terminated']
+34878;['appeal is allowed']
+48271;['appeal is dismissed']
+124659;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+69094;['allow this appeal']
+97588;['dismisses the appeal']
+108711;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+131718;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+142487;['appellants were not refugees or persons in need of protection']
+84194;['appeal cannot proceed']
+142796;['rad panel finds that the appellant is a convention refugee unders']
+68347;['appeal is dismissed']
+101352;['appeal isallowed']
+71142;['appeal is dismissed']
+46039;['appeal isallowed']
+76618;['appeal isallowed']
+82260;['appeal is dismissed']
+84339;['appeal is allowed']
+107593;['appeal is allowed']
+26687;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+136724;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97218;['allows the application to reinstate the appeal']
+128615;['appeal is allowed']
+68448;['appeal is dismissed']
+67639;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+88331;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98370;['appeal is determined to be']
+60508;['appeal must therefore fail']
+121441;['appeal is dismissed']
+77856;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+24450;['appeal is dismissed']
+81147;['appeal is allowed']
+98003;['“associated   claimant”), are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+99866;['appeal isallowed']
+83096;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+140809;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+109534;['appeal is dismissed']
+109637;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+76033;['appeal is dismissed']
+123758;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+43408;['appeal is terminated']
+85973;['appeal should be dismissed']
+68422;['allows the appeal']
+87120;['appeal isallowed']
+56925;['appeals are dismissed']
+98348;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+94945;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+94813;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+96906;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+82087;['appeal is terminated']
+104476;['allowed this application']
+85946;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+57063;['appeal is dismissed']
+89681;['appeal is allowed']
+19238;['appeal therefore is allowed']
+94062;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+129248;['appeal is allowed']
+98816;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+82793;['appeal is allowed']
+107906;['appeal be dismissed']
+63114;['appeal of greg garfield bennett (the appellant) to be abandoned']
+103667;['claimants are convention neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76497;['appeal is dismissed']
+80743;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+56929;['appeal isallowed']
+128607;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+91680;['appeal is allowed']
+57817;['appellant is no longer eligible to appeal', 'appeal is dismissed']
+68692;['appeal is dismissed']
+107191;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150723;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44179;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither “convention refugees”']
+69197;['appeal of the appellant balwinder singh tatla is allowed']
+106173;['appeal fails']
+37828;['appeal is allowed']
+53834;['appeal is allowed']
+77578;['decision of the visa officer is legally valid']
+81007;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+113758;['appeal is dismissed']
+101777;['appeal is allowed']
+60043;['negative']
+151316;['not uphold the rpd’s decision']
+146436;['appeal is dismissed']
+114349;['appeal is dismissed']
+2807;['tribunal dismisses the appeal']
+78006;['appeal is dismissed']
+99993;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+30543;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26905;['claimants xxxxxxxand xxxxxxxx are not convention refugees']
+82875;['appeal of zheng he is dismissed']
+129536;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+107221;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+102105;['appeal is allowed']
+90127;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+86518;['appeal is dismissed']
+100663;['appeal is dismissed']
+80743;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+140970;['appeal is allowed']
+95791;['xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+31233;['appeal isallowed']
+101692;['appeal is allowed']
+102197;['allow the appeal']
+89917;['appeal be dismissed']
+100328;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94813;['appeal must be dismissed']
+58144;['not allow this application']
+113283;['302 (c.a.']
+94440;['appeal is allowed']
+121809;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+65704;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+123714;['appeal were dismissed']
+72801;['appeal is allowed']
+54230;['dismiss the appeal']
+135142;['appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+54818;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+50762;['appeal is dismissed']
+59709;['appeal is dismissed']
+74241;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+52100;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a claim for refugee protection']
+46500;['appeal is allowed']
+103799;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89747;['appeal was allowed']
+84658;['appeal isallowed']
+72563;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26514;['appeal isdismissed.']
+130977;['appeals are dismissed']
+71411;['appeal is allowed']
+128404;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+133740;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77081;['removal order isset aside']
+93696;['decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122858;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82622;['confirm the determination']
+88263;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+65113;['allows this appeal']
+13758;['appeal isallowed']
+87704;['negative']
+77777;['302 (c.a.)']
+13970;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87216;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+21397;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+127702;['appeal is dismissed']
+138873;['appeal was dismissed']
+98526;['302 (c.a.']
+125149;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+151938;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+71271;['allow the appeal']
+63909;['appeal is dismissed']
+92035;['appeal was dismissed']
+105444;['claimant is not a person in need of protection', 'rpd rejects his claim']
+76596;['appeal is allowed']
+102435;['appeal is dismissed']
+76073;['appeal is dismissed']
+101866;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61052;['appeal is allowed']
+116746;['dismiss the postponement application']
+108674;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95062;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+82802;['appeal is allowed']
+84060;['appeal is dismissed']
+54826;['respondent is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+81139;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99599;['appellant is a person described insubsections 64(1)and(2)of theirpaand']
+123067;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100525;['allowing the appeal']
+63753;['appeal is dismissed']
+143867;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+84021;['302 (c.a.)']
+80500;['appeal is terminated']
+71707;['application to re-open this appeal is denied']
+104557;['application for extension of time is therefore denied']
+79995;['claimants are not convention refugees.the', 'claimants are persons in need of protection']
+82875;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+35544;['appeal is allowed']
+79940;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+146442;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105314;['appeal is dismissed']
+147614;['appeal is dismissed']
+89084;['refugee protection division rejects this claim for protection']
+94624;['appeal is dismissed']
+76171;['negative']
+121526;['application to reopen this appeal is dismissed']
+71110;['appeal of xiu jin ye is therefore dismissed']
+10907;['appeal is dismissed']
+37186;['appeal is allowed']
+59672;['appeal isallowed']
+122873;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision']
+82868;['appeal is allowed']
+68710;['appeal of lan kim bui pursuant to paragraph 77(3)(b) of theactis allowed']
+122651;['appeal is allowed']
+99983;['appeal is allowed']
+152005;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101031;['claims are rejected']
+140981;['appellant is not a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+108077;['dismisses the appeal']
+151811;['302 (c.a.']
+97667;['claimants,xxxxx\xa0xxxxx\xa0xxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+61393;['appeal was declared abandoned']
+76314;['appeal is terminated']
+93692;['appeal is allowed']
+81127;['appeal is dismissed']
+62383;['appeal isallowed']
+127336;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83369;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+60957;['appeal is allowed']
+143856;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61351;['ms. mushtaq is inadmissible']
+65656;['appeal isdismissed.']
+52137;['appeal is dismissed']
+52948;['appeal is allowed']
+79193;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+130960;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101265;['appeal is allowed']
+152914;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108741;['appeal is allowed']
+67693;['allow the appeal of naginder kaur mangat in law']
+106146;['appeal is allowed']
+121853;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+87394;['appeal is allowed']
+42337;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+121574;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84551;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71164;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76823;['appeal is dismissed']
+92611;['claimants are not “refugees” and are not “persons in need of protection']
+106287;"[""rad concurs with the panel's finding in this regard""]"
+125409;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67558;['appeal is allowed']
+87387;['appeal is allowed']
+89977;['appeal is dismissed']
+123726;['appeal is dismissed']
+124988;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124982;['appeal is dismissed']
+95872;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+139447;['appeals are dismissed']
+18930;['appeal of michael teye mensah is allowed']
+101710;['appeal isallowed.the']
+101482;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+132803;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83644;['appeal is dismissed']
+139876;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx, is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+62835;['dismisses the present appeal']
+131189;['appeal isdismissed.']
+106183;['appeal is dismissed']
+63160;['appeal is dismissed']
+76738;['appeal is allowed']
+66945;['appeal is terminated']
+70759;['appeal is dismissed']
+136083;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132359;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102481;['appeal allowed case']
+90221;['appeal is terminated']
+95451;['appeal is allowed']
+56621;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+134169;['appeal is allowed']
+105210;['appeal is allowed']
+72663;['appeal is dismissed']
+95552;['appeal is dismissed']
+108807;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95675;['appeal is allowed']
+99993;['claimant is \xa0not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+70884;['appeal is allowed']
+90844;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+108860;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+96359;['appeal is dismissed']
+54267;['appeal should be dismissed']
+99028;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79189;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+128603;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+74643;['appeal is allowed']
+72892;['appeal is allowed']
+61625;['claim is rejected']
+30507;['appeal is allowed']
+92149;['appeal is dismissed']
+59668;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99069;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects the claims for refugee protection']
+50254;['appeal is dismissed']
+94004;['appeal is allowed']
+101237;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95178;['appeal is dismissed']
+44727;['appeal is determined']
+61962;['appeal is dismissed']
+104430;['appeal is dismissed']
+116965;['refugee appeal division sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+68169;['appeal is allowed']
+118390;['appeal is allowed']
+96160;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+142900;['rad finds that it must set aside the rpd’s determination']
+101546;['dismiss the appeal']
+111317;['rad has found that the rpd erred in its assessment of']
+143597;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87822;['negative']
+69113;['dismiss the appeal of kulwinder singh grewal']
+151468;['rad dismisses this appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+132277;['rpd’s decision should be set aside']
+62643;['claimant is not a genuine falun gong practitioner']
+83866;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+118633;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96532;['appeal is dismissed']
+75231;['appeal is terminated']
+151725;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+148999;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+102164;['appeals are dismissed']
+21407;['refugee division, therefore, finds xxxxxxxxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+97620;['appeal is allowed']
+70884;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84230;['appeal isallowed']
+85168;['rad finds the respondent is not excludable from the refugee convention']
+91144;['appeal is allowed']
+83343;['appeal isallowed']
+52221;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+52293;['rpd’s decision must therefore be set aside']
+99948;['appeal is dismissed']
+65604;['dismiss the appeal']
+94167;['rpd’s decision must therefore be set aside']
+43141;['appeal is dismissed']
+99445;['claimant is not in need of protection']
+60016;['negative']
+151942;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand']
+130978;['appeal is allowed']
+123016;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+13674;['appeal is abandoned']
+102799;['allowed the appeal']
+107894;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+60040;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+77589;['appeal isallowed']
+9676;['appeal be dismissed']
+142291;['appeal is dismissed']
+75166;['appeal is dismissed']
+152054;['302 (c.a.']
+93571;['decision of the visa officer is upheld']
+35063;['neither a permanent resident of canada', 'nor a protected person']
+101868;['appeal is allowed']
+107901;['request for an oral hearing is dismissed']
+91810;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+77666;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+60822;['appeal is allowed']
+102869;['claim is rejected']
+111172;['appeal is dismissed']
+107069;['appeal is dismissed']
+99850;['appeal of phuc hau nguyen is dismissed']
+128902;['appellants xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+101465;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+121603;['radconfirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+108733;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+96096;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+105220;['appeal is allowed.the']
+106789;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+94083;['appeal is allowed']
+123048;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+92447;['appeal isallowed.the']
+50554;['appeal is allowed']
+96641;['allow the appeal']
+151741;['appeal is allowed']
+95510;['appeal is allowed']
+91687;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76429;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98430;['appeal is allowed']
+71705;['appeal is dismissed']
+82892;['appeal isallowed']
+56966;['appeal is allowed']
+29725;['appeal should be dismissed']
+87197;['appeal is dismissed']
+49169;['appeal is allowed']
+129918;['removal order is set aside']
+72186;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+29536;['appeal is dismissed']
+107022;['appeal is allowed']
+89384;['appeal is terminated']
+89546;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+87942;['appeal is dismissed']
+95937;['appeal is dismissed']
+51848;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+96899;['appeal is allowed']
+38426;['appeal is allowed']
+142587;['appeals are allowed.the']
+71098;['appeal is dismissed']
+111297;['dismisses the appeal']
+88453;['rejects this claimant’s claim for refugee protection']
+99923;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+92732;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+15578;['appeal isallowed']
+122635;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+90847;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+86053;['allow the appeal']
+46086;['appeal is allowed']
+84544;['removal order is set aside']
+143028;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+67668;['appeal is dismissed']
+128548;['appellants are not currently persons of interest']
+107244;['appeal is allowed']
+96847;['appeal is allowed']
+84650;['dismissed this appeal']
+151776;['appeal is allowed']
+96754;['not find the applicant or the appellant to be credible']
+46054;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123670;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+115284;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+106640;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+59941;['negative']
+124699;['appeal is dismissed']
+72827;['appeal isallowed']
+69153;['dismiss the appeal']
+96510;['appeal is dismissed']
+128441;['appeal is allowed']
+95140;['appeal is dismissed']
+106803;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+146103;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100059;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+82149;['appeal is dismissed']
+59825;['appeal be dismissed']
+88094;['appeal fails']
+58106;['appeal is dismissed']
+32134;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67220;['appeal is terminated']
+122699;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+121389;['appeal is allowed']
+85311;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+67638;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+71166;['appeal is governed by theact']
+100704;['appeal is allowed']
+94271;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71742;['appeals are dismissed']
+107927;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+81183;['appeal is allowed']
+90229;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+125430;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99937;['appeal of mary jean pia is dismissed']
+46481;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+48910;['appeal was dismissed']
+140291;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+104495;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95335;['appeal be allowed']
+54257;['appeal is, thereby, discontinued']
+151509;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+98539;['appeal isallowedand']
+91597;['appeal is allowed']
+100466;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77328;['appeal is allowed']
+67986;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+48095;['stay the removal order in accordance']
+87521;['appeal is dismissed']
+85479;['appeal is terminated']
+85168;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+132071;['appellants are therefore convention refugees']
+117123;['appeal is allowed.the']
+128443;['appeal is allowed']
+125612;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+48615;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+80570;['appeal is allowed']
+76541;['appeal is dismissed']
+113580;['appeal is allowed']
+77444;['appeal is dismissed']
+69173;['302 (c.a.']
+103026;['302 (c.a.)']
+43718;['appeal is allowed']
+41967;['appeal is allowed']
+131081;['appeal is allowed']
+70782;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+134212;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+84857;['appeal is terminated']
+84427;['appeal isallowed']
+56741;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+125029;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142793;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+77270;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71528;['visa officer’s decision will be set aside', 'appeal will be allowed']
+90919;['rad finds that']
+65196;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+63094;['panel rejectstheir claims for refugee protection']
+107825;['appeals are also dismissed']
+100577;['dismiss the appeal']
+84760;['dismiss the appeal']
+56691;['appeal were dismissed']
+76959;['appeal is allowed']
+94520;['appeal is dismissed']
+91559;['rpd’s holdings were set aside']
+154089;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+98667;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+103113;['appeal is dismissed']
+108269;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77637;['appeal is allowed']
+89307;['appeal is governed by theact']
+47143;['appeal is dismissed']
+132655;['appellant’s claims fail']
+52485;['appeal isallowed']
+107589;['appeal isallowed']
+123887;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90488;['appeal is accordinglydismissed']
+122985;['rad disagrees']
+104530;['nor a person in need of protection']
+101771;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+130678;['appeal is allowed']
+76803;['appeal isallowed']
+98458;['appeal isallowed']
+96181;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+151909;['appeal is dismissed']
+50481;['dismiss the appeal']
+125697;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94322;['dismiss her appeal']
+20000;['appeal isallowed']
+69987;['negative']
+123667;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+58417;['appeal is allowed.the']
+21105;['appeal is a hearingde']
+108251;['appeal is dismissed']
+28070;['appeals are dismissed']
+68421;['sets aside the removal order and allows the appeal']
+121935;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'not refugees or persons in need of protection']
+133704;['confirm the rpd determination', 'not “convention refugees”']
+128166;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection']
+76669;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+125108;['appeal is allowed']
+36083;['appeal is allowed']
+102566;['appeal is allowed']
+59039;['dismisses the appeal']
+74179;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105222;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+90635;['appeal isallowed']
+100648;['application is allowed']
+124965;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66635;['appeal is allowed']
+72967;['appeal is dismissed']
+133693;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+140933;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82208;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+104273;['302 (c.a.)']
+81495;['rad determines that xxx is a person in need of protection']
+77678;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+59717;['appeal is dismissed']
+98358;['appeal is allowed']
+117201;['rpd’s decision is set aside', 'substitute the determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are convention refugees']
+120772;['appellants are convention refugees']
+134357;['appeal is dismissed']
+71539;['appeal isallowed']
+67782;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+52308;['appeals are allowed']
+95601;['appeal is dismissed']
+44724;['appeal is declared to beabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+62451;['rpd determination is set aside', 'rad substitutes its own determination that xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+59824;['appeal is allowed']
+82021;['appeal isallowed']
+74216;['appeal is allowed']
+30377;['appellants are excluded fromsections 96and97(1)of theirpapursuant']
+83060;['appeal of aristeo maltu gascon is dismissed']
+87204;['appeal is dismissed']
+89970;['appeal isallowedand']
+152469;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+143086;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+132776;['appeal is allowed']
+92403;['appeal is dismissed']
+98438;['appeal is terminated']
+50648;['appeal isallowed']
+70364;['appeal is allowed in law']
+88880;['appeal is allowed']
+65652;['appeal is dismissed']
+107217;['rad finds in favour of the panel’s decision on the']
+143470;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+106790;['appeal is allowed']
+94986;['appeal is allowed']
+111309;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63920;['appeal is allowed']
+129396;['appeal is allowed']
+48097;['appeal must be dismissed']
+66493;['appeal isdismissed for lack of jurisdictionbecause']
+52158;['panel accepts the claim of xxxxxxxxxx for refugee protection']
+63985;['appeal is dismissed']
+89788;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67518;['appeal is dismissed']
+82581;['appeal is allowed']
+86889;['appeal is dismissed']
+82653;['appeal is allowed']
+89578;['appeal is terminated']
+143557;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+82674;['appeal is terminated']
+128157;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+97642;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+139419;['appeal is dismissed']
+47352;['appeal is governed by theact']
+98628;['stay is set aside']
+87187;['appeal is dismissed']
+84613;['appeal isallowed']
+96833;['negative']
+61968;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+116745;['appeal is dismissed']
+84432;['appeal is dismissed']
+75257;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+64607;['appeal was dismissed']
+107472;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+73703;['appeal is allowed']
+76180;['appeal of allison jayne heighington (lowe) is dismissed']
+80994;['appeal is allowed', 'decision is set aside']
+143646;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+37409;['appeal of trung hung dieu is allowed']
+100881;['refugee protection claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+26845;['xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxis not a conventionrefugeeas defined']
+65123;['appeal would be dismissed']
+104490;['appeal of phou sanith is dismissed']
+133743;['appeal is allowed']
+77773;['appeal is allowed']
+55118;['appeal is dismissed']
+44082;['theappellant is not a “convention refugee']
+80040;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145847;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+143909;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133725;['appeals are dismissed']
+94389;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+123863;['appeal is allowed']
+31381;['appeal is allowed']
+151965;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+99162;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxx xxxx']
+81054;['appeal isallowedand']
+98667;['appeal is allowed']
+92788;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+100904;['appeal isallowedand']
+72854;['appeal is allowed']
+102453;['appeal is dismissed']
+34159;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+71403;['appeal is dismissed']
+80787;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+46503;['appeal isallowed']
+77257;['appeal isallowed']
+92401;['officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+100292;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+84588;['appeal is terminated']
+48103;['appeal is allowed']
+151859;['appeal is dismissed']
+139674;['appeal is allowed']
+113273;['appeal is allowed']
+13754;['appeal isallowed']
+73201;['appeal is allowed']
+144549;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57548;['appeal being dismissed']
+96813;['appeal is allowed']
+83308;['appeal is allowed']
+152614;['302 (c.a.']
+102684;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102052;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+61319;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+128606;['appeal is allowed']
+87791;['claimants are not convention refugee nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+71747;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96590;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+151746;['appeal is dismissed']
+92823;['appeal of is dismissed']
+107078;['appeal is dismissed']
+142986;['appeal is dismissed']
+106396;['rad finds that the rpd']
+113732;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88662;['appeal is dismissed']
+87000;['appeal is dismissed']
+100100;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52127;['appeal is dismissed']
+56880;['appeal is dismissed']
+86309;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+83663;['appeal be dismissed']
+147465;['claim is dismissed']
+52276;['upheld the decision of the iad']
+65418;['appeals of li kuan hu lai and chieh kan lai are dismissed']
+116763;['appeal be dismissed']
+52049;['appeal is terminated']
+63091;['application to reopen the appeal is allowed']
+132630;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+97984;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80157;['appeal filed byxxxx xxxxis dismissed']
+105295;['rad finds that the appellants are not convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s decision']
+11469;['appeal is dismissed']
+145213;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+111163;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+90644;['appeal is dismissed']
+143587;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+122636;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101555;['appeal isallowed']
+101769;['appeal of nachhattar singh gill is dismissed']
+138810;['appeal isallowed']
+90555;['appeal is dismissed']
+69399;['appeal isallowed']
+67407;['appeal proceeded']
+124004;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+92793;['appeal is allowed']
+63935;['appeal is allowed']
+43708;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+65672;['allow her appeal']
+96468;['determination of the rpd']
+113631;['appeal is allowed']
+99572;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+145046;['panel accepts his claim']
+74069;['appeal is allowed']
+26958;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+76608;['appeal is allowed']
+92505;['appeal is dismissed']
+71202;['appeal of krishan kumar ghakkar is dismissed']
+49976;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+94491;['appeal is dismissed']
+76735;['appeal in regards to the validity of the marriage is allowed']
+102572;['dismissing the appeal']
+70009;['removal orders are set aside']
+122695;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67635;['appeal being dismissed']
+64585;['appeal is dismissed']
+101213;['application to add a ground of refusal']
+95301;['appeal isallowed']
+137446;['i reject this second argument']
+70490;['appeal isallowed']
+136717;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124584;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100962;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71361;['appeal is allowed']
+40154;['appeal is dismissed']
+101308;['appeal is allowed']
+118236;['appellants are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122134;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding is in error']
+101340;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+14654;['xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+84822;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+141265;['translation is merely a summary of the news article']
+69801;['appellant is not a sponsor within the meaning of theregulations']
+129217;['appeal is terminated']
+133344;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87609;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99259;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+31433;['appeal is dismissed']
+99712;['appeal is allowed']
+132333;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134312;['theappealis allowed']
+113629;['removal order is set aside']
+148497;['refugee protection division therefore rejects these claims']
+104088;['appeal isallowed']
+47313;['appeal is allowed']
+74555;['appeal is dismissed']
+143520;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151323;['302 (c.a.']
+84034;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+103006;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+31381;['appeal is allowed']
+109321;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute it with my own determination that the xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+100361;['claimants to not be convention refugees']
+61372;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+84676;['support my findings']
+101853;['appeal was allowed in 2006']
+103666;['302 (c.a.']
+99658;['appeal is allowed']
+80805;['appeal is dismissed']
+68197;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+85521;['allow the appeal']
+87299;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+28704;['appeal is dismissed']
+15562;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+102736;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+5594;['application to reopen is therefore dismissed']
+116222;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+102150;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+97376;['appeal is allowed']
+80756;['appeal is allowed.the']
+81394;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+49072;['appeal is allowed']
+122834;['claimant is not a refugee']
+123458;['appeal is dismissed']
+45183;['appeal is dismissed']
+107612;['302 (c.a.']
+125388;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+33086;['dismissing the appellant’s refugee claim']
+89958;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+95910;['rpd decision cannot stand and is hereby set aside']
+71146;['nor a protected person', 'nor a person who holds a permanent resident visa']
+126407;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101473;['decree may be set aside']
+62625;['appeal should be allowed']
+70046;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101233;['appeal isallowed']
+48424;['appeal is allowed']
+108693;['rad sets aside the determination\xa0 of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+133381;['appeal isallowed']
+78068;['appeals are dismissed']
+43907;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+132288;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+91451;['panel finds that the officer’s decision is valid in law']
+96251;['appeal is dismissed']
+59811;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+148638;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+45644;['request is denied']
+37428;['appeals are allowed']
+79873;['appeal isallowed']
+47107;['decision to refuse the application']
+116796;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+68537;['allow the appeal']
+111103;['appeal is dismissed']
+114385;['appeals are dismissed']
+141673;['appeal be dismissed']
+129264;['appeal of muhammed hussain is dismissed']
+54255;['allow the appeal']
+99902;['appeal’s relative merit']
+148993;['radallows the appeal', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+144898;['set aside the rpdf determination', 'neither a “convention refugee”']
+131715;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+45858;['302 (c.a.)']
+131709;['appeal is dismissed']
+68884;['appeal isallowed']
+58520;['appeal is dismissed']
+68904;['appeal beallowed']
+96901;['claimants have not been, and will not be, pursued by the psb,']
+103654;['claimant in not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+86324;['dismissing the appeal']
+75984;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87185;['appeal is dismissed']
+95369;['motion for reconsideration isgranted']
+69949;['appeal is dismissed']
+134516;['appeals are based']
+139865;['302 (c.a.']
+123647;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+123443;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees']
+67554;['appeal is allowed']
+69082;['appeal is allowed']
+143248;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61316;['appeal is dismissed']
+115220;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+87721;['negative']
+148737;['claimant is not a refugee']
+133257;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+141061;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63929;['allowing his appeal']
+71815;['appeal isallowed']
+127372;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+90661;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+102957;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+91086;['appeal is allowed']
+123401;['dismiss the appeal']
+100416;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+60971;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+57921;['appeal is dismissed']
+136749;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx,failed to establish that she is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151954;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s decision']
+61471;['appeal is dismissed']
+101099;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+100598;['appeal being allowed']
+34928;['appeal is dismissed']
+77320;['appeal dismissed']
+97118;['stay is cancelled, or terminated', 'appeal is allowed']
+131213;['appeal of kuldeep kaur sawaich is dismissed']
+58111;['appeal isallowed']
+71234;['immigration appeal division dismisses an appeal']
+81255;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+105635;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+61883;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+85522;['appeal is allowed.the']
+85441;['application is therefore found to have some merit']
+69499;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+83903;['appeal is dismissed']
+113574;['appeal was dismissed']
+76305;['appeal of aquinata zwichasa mutsatsa is dismissed']
+46050;['appeal should be dismissed']
+129396;['appeal is allowed']
+66300;['appeal isallowed']
+105775;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+116360;['confirm the rpd determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees']
+83668;['appeal is allowed for the appellant nambrou kouassi']
+113246;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+88170;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+122840;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107622;['appeal is dismissed']
+70012;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+124956;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or persons in need of protection']
+95788;['appeal is dismissed', 'rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76286;['appeal isallowed']
+82112;['negative']
+91152;['appeal on that basis is also dismissed']
+62453;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+50427;['appeal is allowed']
+74840;['appeal is allowed in law']
+76833;['appeal is allowed']
+82026;['appeal isallowedand']
+131062;['appeal were dismissed']
+141686;['allow the appeal']
+88339;['appeal is dismissed']
+104454;['appeal will be reconsidered']
+99535;['appeal isallowedand']
+64130;['dismiss this appeal']
+37496;['appeal is dismissed']
+104126;['you are not a convention refugee']
+69438;['application is amended to remove bindu sekhri (sister) and ranji sekhri (sister)']
+98780;['appeal is allowed']
+74585;['appeal is allowed']
+83308;['appeal isallowed.the']
+147875;"[""visa officer's determination is valid in law""]"
+93287;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim']
+60652;['appeal is dismissed']
+76499;['appeal is dismissed']
+91762;['appeal is dismissed']
+121953;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+66628;['appeal is dismissed']
+49235;['dismiss the appeal']
+31970;['appeal isallowed']
+110998;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+101712;['appeal is terminated']
+135136;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+98772;['reject your claim']
+101703;['appeal were dismissed']
+50758;['…]”']
+69381;['appeal is dismissed']
+123435;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd determination', 'appellants are excluded']
+142307;['appeal is dismissed']
+59159;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+135899;['appeal of the minor appellant']
+99808;['appeal is dismissed']
+75936;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+88157;['appeal is dismissed']
+30524;['appeal is allowed']
+77304;['appeal is dismissed']
+26714;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+95793;['appeal is rejected']
+101319;['appeal is dismissed']
+49716;['irb (intervener) (f.c.a., no']
+29300;['appeals are dismissed']
+55267;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+112358;['determinations are valid in law']
+63981;['appeal isdismissed.']
+75619;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+145822;['appeal is allowed']
+70762;['appeal regarding stalin francisco tandazo is allowed']
+113568;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+105899;['respondent is not a convention refugee']
+110719;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+57566;['appeal is dismissed']
+38878;['appeal isallowed.the']
+36613;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a   permanent resident visa is set aside']
+95447;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93072;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the respondent not to be a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55123;['appeal isallowed']
+101507;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+104110;['302 (c.a.']
+23003;['appeals are dismissed']
+123387;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67418;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+140935;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+121474;['appeal is allowed']
+84344;['appeal is dismissed']
+98913;['appeal isallowed']
+144567;['associate appellants are not convention refugees']
+149275;['appeals are allowed']
+61804;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+143858;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26475;['appeal is dismissed']
+46515;['appeal is allowed']
+91017;['appeals of aleksandr yuffa, elena yuffa, and daniil yuffa are dismissed']
+142469;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+103721;['claimant is not convention refugee or persons in need of protection']
+118639;['appeal is dismissed']
+18925;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+125030;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+104977;['appeal isallowed']
+80074;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+68792;['panel rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+26926;['xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx are not convention refugees']
+39909;['appeal was rejected']
+59038;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+84027;['302 (c.a.']
+147876;['dismiss the appeal']
+130856;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+100754;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+26482;['appeal is dismissed']
+54659;['appeal is dismissed']
+81019;['appeal is quashed']
+130924;['appeal is allowed']
+52487;['appeal is allowed']
+132639;['appeal is dismissed']
+52221;['appeal is allowed']
+77858;['claim is rejected']
+142499;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97204;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54632;['appeal is dismissed']
+84519;['appeal is dismissed']
+128188;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+27012;['appeal is dismissed']
+91100;['appeal is allowed']
+142819;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+129158;['appeal is dismissed']
+55977;['appeal is terminated']
+100497;['appeal is']
+121880;['appeal is allowed']
+94315;['appeal is dismissed']
+112337;['appeal is allowed']
+96826;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+145386;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+100661;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95118;['negative']
+85247;['appeal isallowed']
+101663;['appeal is dismissed']
+110924;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appeal is dismissed']
+77885;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95829;['appeal is   ']
+76054;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+78338;['appeal is dismissed']
+124113;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+56879;['appeal, brought']
+95467;['appeal is dismissed']
+71397;['appeal is dismissed']
+100733;['claimant, xxxxxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+59038;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+129141;['appeal is allowed']
+82839;['appeal is dismissed']
+75443;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101154;['allow the appeal']
+77121;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+68282;['appeal is allowed']
+87100;['appeal is allowed']
+123455;['dismiss the appeal', 'uphold the rpd’s determination']
+17169;['appeals are determined']
+81150;['appeal is allowed']
+74510;['declare the appeal ofsebastian\xa0dante\xa0abarca\xa0malbran(the appellant) to be abandoned']
+76928;['appeal isallowed']
+47217;['appeal of marianne cerezo boulet is dismissed']
+76365;['appeal is terminated']
+69859;['appeal is dismissed']
+110929;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'directs that the matter be returned to the rpd']
+46551;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+128376;['appeals are dismissed']
+89859;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects the claim ofxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxfor refugee protection']
+84573;['appeal isallowedand']
+50473;['allow this appeal and find']
+92760;['appeal is allowed']
+98979;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+100068;['appeal is dismissed']
+75600;['appeal is allowed']
+99488;['appeal is dismissed']
+89854;['panel rejects their refugee protection claim']
+143477;['not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75993;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97781;['negative']
+70670;['negative']
+107794;['claimant,xxxx\xa0xxxx\xa0xxxx\xa0xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+151579;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+38863;['appeal is allowed']
+151740;['appeal is dismissed']
+79726;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+151559;['appeal is allowed']
+75005;['appeal is allowed']
+112398;['appeal is dismissed']
+130846;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxxare not convention refugees', 'or persons in need of protection']
+71482;['appeal isallowed']
+86957;['appeal is dismissed']
+138828;['appeal is dismissed']
+84469;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+152822;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95961;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74045;['appeal isallowed']
+57745;['neither a “conventionrefugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+149014;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+141633;['appeal is allowed']
+95546;['appeal is dismissed']
+143871;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90995;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142800;['appeal is allowed']
+94462;['appeal is dismissed']
+93669;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your removal from canada']
+121849;['appeal is dismissed']
+89779;['application to dismiss the appeal', 'appeal is dismissed']
+94766;['appeal is dismissed']
+123957;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+6665;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+99227;['refugee protection division rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+72810;['refusal is invalid in law']
+57462;['appeal regarding legal validity of the residency obligation decision is dismissed']
+87949;['claim is rejected']
+95184;['appeal is allowed']
+81619;['appeals are dismissed']
+122672;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+61416;['reject her claim']
+122634;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+141636;['appeal is allowed']
+91903;['appeal must be dismissed']
+74765;['dismiss the appeal']
+91571;['302 (c.a.)']
+100323;['appeal is allowed']
+74470;['appeal isallowed']
+80132;['appeal is dismissed']
+104845;['appeal isallowed']
+81584;['appeal is dismissed']
+93660;['appeal be dismissed']
+101042;['appeal is terminated by operation of law']
+52667;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxx are convention refugees']
+57935;['nor the genuineness of the marriage']
+122818;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+84459;['appeal is allowed']
+44275;['appeal is allowed']
+98874;['appeal is dismissed']
+99744;['appeal is dismissed']
+93704;['appeal is dismissed']
+27499;['appeal of tuyet minh nguyen is dismissed']
+99664;['appeal is allowed']
+142962;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+29699;['appeal is allowed']
+106307;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113596;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+98690;['appeal is terminated']
+61212;['appeal is allowed']
+98146;['appeal is dismissed']
+52366;['appeal is allowed']
+118661;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+149267;['appeal is terminated']
+94375;['appeal isallowed']
+129106;['allow the appeal']
+91857;['appeal isallowed']
+148679;['appeal is dismissed']
+38792;['appeal is dismissed']
+143865;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+111028;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+93609;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+97131;['appeal is dismissed']
+50930;['appeal is dismissed']
+69949;['iad dismissed the appeal in law']
+77996;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+114340;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+72621;['appeal is dismissed']
+121384;['appeal is dismissed']
+73320;['appeal isallowed']
+130890;['appeal is dismissed']
+113231;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+80553;['appeal is allowed']
+113784;['appeal is allowed']
+102432;['appeal isallowed']
+94924;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+63878;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+94283;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+67496;['allow this appeal']
+133695;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143504;['reject this explanation']
+90184;['appeal is terminated']
+34701;['appeal is dismissed']
+91659;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+90758;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+74267;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+113587;['appeal is dismissed']
+85624;['appeal be dismissed']
+39568;['appeals are allowed']
+105788;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+52073;['appeal is allowed']
+104072;['appeal has not been challenged in law']
+100812;['thepanel finds the removal order valid in law']
+78725;['appeal is allowed']
+74788;['appeal is allowed']
+123020;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108715;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is are neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61371;['appeal is allowed']
+46077;['allows this appeal']
+74261;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+99474;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+71130;['appeal is allowed']
+94757;['not a person in need of protection']
+121449;['appellant is excluded']
+113733;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124007;['appeal is allowed']
+86333;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89201;['appeal isallowed']
+91526;['appeal is terminated']
+70908;['appeal of emmanuel meraptan maglaya is dismissed']
+47193;['appeal is dismissed']
+129244;['302 (c.a.']
+122769;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+102752;['appeal is dismissed']
+94285;['appeal is allowed']
+42214;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+90683;['appeal is dismissed']
+130862;['appeal is allowed']
+102160;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+60873;['appeal isallowed']
+125424;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+95370;['allows the minister’s application to dismiss the appeal']
+125321;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+52082;['appeal isterminated']
+102963;['rad allows the appeal']
+50248;['appeal is dismissed']
+140902;['appeal is allowed']
+149189;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+91203;['appeal is allowed']
+108416;['302 (c.a.']
+83113;['appeal is terminated']
+59982;['negative']
+88501;['claimants are not a convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+82198;['appeal is allowed']
+49709;['appeal is dismissed']
+94454;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98873;['removal order is set aside']
+83253;['appeal is allowed']
+105815;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+56102;['appeals are accepted']
+87787;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+132347;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the respondent is not a convention refugee']
+17117;['302 (c.a.']
+104393;"['appeal is allowed', ""officer's decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside""]"
+81314;['appeal is allowed']
+76904;['panel finds the refusal is valid in law']
+132381;['appeal is dismissed']
+88166;['appeal is allowed']
+101263;['appeal isallowedand']
+66629;['rad allows the appeal']
+69530;['appeal is therefore allowed in law']
+86352;['appeal is determined']
+86837;['appeal is dismissed']
+97289;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+141666;['appeal were dismissed']
+47132;['appeal is allowed']
+75325;['appeal isallowed']
+98835;['appeal is dismissed']
+81023;['appeal is terminated']
+55188;['appeal is dismissed']
+13697;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+84012;['appeal is dismissed']
+95362;['302 (c.a.']
+83673;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26702;['appeal division orders that the']
+131050;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'find the appellant to be a convention refugee']
+101298;['rad dismisses the appeals of the associate appellant', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+34870;['stay decision and the extended stay decision are cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+126431;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+87497;['appeal of yan hong zhao is dismissed']
+103112;['appeal is dismissed']
+125378;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+83242;['appeal is dismissed']
+90666;['appeal of clinton barretto']
+67772;['appeal is terminated']
+59983;['negative']
+90942;['appeal isallowed']
+47747;['appeal is allowed']
+76663;['appeal isallowed']
+89740;['appeal is allowed in law']
+97584;['appeal is dismissed']
+72817;['appeal is allowed']
+88851;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his \xa0permanent resident status']
+107221;['rad rejects that explanation']
+95225;['302 (c.a.']
+124370;['appeal is allowed']
+60996;['appeal is dismissed']
+90154;['appeal is allowed']
+102925;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107317;['302 (c.a.']
+122883;['rad finds that it did']
+110922;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140718;['uphold the rpd’s findings']
+103999;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+76839;['appeal is allowed']
+101715;['appeal is declared to be abandoned']
+97607;['claimant is not a citizen of china']
+83723;['appeal is dismissed']
+130695;['appeal is dismissed']
+30382;['appeal fails']
+99648;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77835;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+153629;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+124173;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+121530;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131528;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+52512;['dismiss the appeal']
+59770;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+39771;['appeal is dismissed']
+47819;['appeal is dismissed']
+107932;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+17182;['appeal isallowedand']
+49969;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+99285;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+76072;['appeal isallowedand']
+122256;['appellant meets the test']
+86152;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68909;['appeal isallowed']
+91539;['appeal is allowed']
+56738;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+96216;['appeal is allowed']
+74107;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91767;['dismiss this appeal']
+50525;['dismiss your appeal']
+13931;['appeal is dismissed']
+131911;['appeal isallowed']
+124797;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor in need of protection']
+102886;['appeal is allowed']
+69572;['appeal is dismissed']
+85856;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+125668;['rad also confirms the rpd’s determination in part', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+60120;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+70070;['appeal ofrobert aibuokae edokpayi, in respect to his wife']
+86454;['appeal is allowed']
+66573;['appeal is dismissed']
+90819;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+100167;['claimants are excluded from making a claim for protection']
+97160;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+132831;['appeal was dismissed']
+88456;['appeal is allowed']
+68227;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+146101;['rad sets aside the rpd’s decision', 'substitutes a positive determination']
+70789;['appeal is dismissed']
+102080;['appeal is dismissed']
+91715;['appeal is allowed']
+118390;['dismiss the appeal']
+131176;['appeal is allowed']
+93684;['appeal is dismissed']
+111645;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+26695;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+94183;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+125226;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+13975;['appeal is allowed']
+56650;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+55196;['appeals are dismissed']
+89022;['appeals are allowed']
+76530;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+72819;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+58122;['appeal is allowed']
+52489;['appeal isdismissedand the']
+87840;['negative']
+107486;['rad finds that the rpd’s credibility determination']
+69759;['appeal isallowed']
+96769;['appeal of farheenmushtaqis allowed']
+21077;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+74870;['appeal isallowed']
+100910;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116341;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100829;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76657;['allow the appeal']
+143615;['refugee appeal division dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+122547;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82125;['appeal is allowed']
+66769;['appeal is allowed']
+45613;['302 (c.a.']
+107908;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made']
+47381;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law', 'appeal is allowed in law']
+151807;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+116806;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+35905;['appeal is dismissed']
+120774;['appeal is allowed']
+23012;['appeal is allowed']
+98103;['negative']
+99821;['appeal is allowed']
+89113;['claimants are neither “convention refugees”']
+89879;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'nor are they persons in need of protection']
+96762;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95463;['appeal is dismissed']
+74566;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedundersubsection']
+19719;['application is allowed ands']
+38425;['appeal is dismissed']
+89950;['dismiss the appeal']
+81646;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+99040;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69695;['appeal is allowed']
+100000;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+138822;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+85235;['dismisses the appeal']
+130925;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+88976;['appeal isallowed']
+40801;['appeal is allowed']
+32135;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+81621;['appeal is determined']
+50762;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60084;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+45415;['appeal of eskender fuad ibrahim is dismissed']
+30296;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+102418;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+95360;['motion to set them aside is dismissed']
+87878;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+40157;['appeal is allowed']
+78746;['appeal is dismissed']
+80783;['appeal is dismissed']
+125426;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99065;['302 (c.a.']
+91159;['appeal isallowed']
+82034;['appeal is dismissed']
+131005;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is excluded from the protection of canada']
+85606;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96496;['302 (c.a.)']
+94400;['appeal is dismissed']
+148756;['appeal is dismissed']
+97331;['not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+123372;['appeal is allowed']
+113551;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+101016;['appeal is allowed']
+37509;['dismiss an appeal']
+52375;['appeal is dismissed']
+125410;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+65353;['appeal is dismissed']
+67497;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+54760;['appeal is dismissed']
+90039;['appeal is terminated']
+72622;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+52784;['appeal is allowed']
+86652;['appeal is allowed']
+50769;['allow this appeal']
+69938;['appeal isallowed']
+101908;['rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+52121;['appeal is allowed']
+114381;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122381;['appeals are allowed']
+98624;['dismiss the appeal']
+100356;['appeal is dismissed']
+95512;['appeal is allowed']
+44041;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+144772;['panel allows the refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx']
+72216;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+85872;['negative']
+139451;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99371;['appeal is allowed']
+102740;['dismisses the appeal']
+129126;['appeal is abandoned']
+84311;['appeal is allowed']
+13692;['appeal isallowed']
+113800;['they are not convention refugees']
+47884;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed']
+133261;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+107905;['interpretation is not translation']
+98819;['appeal is allowed']
+99349;['appeal is dismissed']
+62955;['appeal ofpavelkravchov,a.k.a mark vaisman, a.k.a mark wiseman and a.k.a ernest frolov, is dismissed']
+110569;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+127702;['appeal is dismissed']
+92567;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+142837;['appeal is allowed']
+73355;['appeal isallowed']
+153274;['appeal is dismissed']
+131136;['appeal isdeterminedto be']
+70223;['appeal is dismissed']
+100391;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+139865;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+107623;['rad agrees with the finding of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+130768;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+92947;['appeal ofminal saurabh patelisallowed']
+36245;['departure order is set aside']
+143558;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor people in need of protection']
+102094;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108859;['appellant is not a “person in need of protection']
+148499;['nor a risk of cruel or unusual treatment or punishment', 'nor torture']
+143483;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+68721;['appeal is allowed']
+57892;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83535;['appeal is determined']
+84738;['appeal is allowed']
+92737;['appeal should be allowed']
+110565;['rad determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+41829;['appeal is dismissed']
+107688;['appeal is allowed']
+47571;['appeal should be allowed']
+132813;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+79999;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+62847;['embassy’s refusal is valid in law']
+72637;['appeal may not succeed']
+92795;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+72664;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+108210;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+139442;['appeal is dismissed']
+124725;['allow the appeal and refer this matter back to the rpd']
+77294;['appeal is dismissed']
+87730;['appeal is allowed']
+91224;['appeal is allowed']
+75232;['appeal isallowedpursuant tos']
+132294;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+82621;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+98518;['appeal is not terminated']
+19381;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60279;['appeal is terminated']
+100686;['appeal be dismissed']
+78716;['appeal is allowed']
+89349;['allowed the appeal']
+17163;['appeal were allowed']
+90977;['appeal is dismissed']
+18925;['appeal isallowed']
+38849;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+93971;['302 (c.a.)']
+50482;['302 (c.a.']
+19120;['appeal was dismissed']
+61529;['appeal isallowed']
+107091;['appeal were dismissed']
+96684;['claimants,xxxxx xxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx, not to be convention refugees']
+113223;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+67582;['dismiss the appeal']
+101902;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+99202;['appeal is allowed']
+78084;['appeal is allowed']
+145046;['panel rejects their claims']
+34627;['decision of the visa officer is well-founded']
+69465;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+116761;['rpd decision cannot stand']
+81260;['appeal isdismissed.']
+40147;['appeal is dismissed']
+138809;['negative determination']
+65015;['appeals are dismissed']
+124549;['accept his claim for refugee protection']
+142517;['associate appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+92782;['appeal is allowed']
+26491;['appeal is dismissed']
+128886;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx,is not a “refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+92197;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+101758;['appeal is allowed']
+117112;['appeal is allowed']
+34638;['appeal is determined']
+22815;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+122863;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+95940;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision in this matter was wrong in fact and law']
+76268;['appeal isallowed']
+100144;['appeal is dismissed']
+101365;['appeal should be dismissed']
+96279;['tribunal rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+94507;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+124006;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+91399;['appeal is allowed']
+111102;['appeal is   ']
+106615;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+77987;['appeal is dismissed']
+100961;['board therefore rejects their claims']
+68336;['appeal of salvacion ferrer is dismissed']
+87828;['302 (c.a.']
+61042;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+62395;['appeal of vladimir larcencov is dismissed']
+21382;['claimants, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx and her daughter']
+85321;['appeal be dismissed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+72192;['appeal is terminated']
+13929;['appeal is dismissed']
+136743;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+116190;['appeal is dismissed']
+22116;['decision of the id is set aside']
+101356;['appeal is allowed']
+124426;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146098;['rad sets aside the rpd’s decision', 'substitutes a positive determination']
+104852;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+67232;['dismiss the appeal']
+97833;['claimant is excluded from refugee protection']
+68130;['appeal is allowed']
+99228;['negative']
+72169;['appeal is allowed']
+77948;['appeal is allowed']
+132868;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+129904;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+122242;['rad allows the appeal']
+53017;['appeal is dismissed']
+80237;['negative']
+136657;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,']
+95246;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+115207;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+64307;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+19147;['appeal concerns reopening after abandonment']
+129398;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124009;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61864;['appeal is dismissed']
+10838;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+86955;['appeal is allowed']
+101748;['appeal is allowed']
+108127;['rad will not substitute its own determination']
+80675;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+83058;['appeal is allowed']
+17969;['appeal isallowed']
+108859;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+100158;['appeal is dismissed']
+80133;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+93334;['302 (c.a.)']
+113215;['appeal is dismissed']
+74169;['appeal isallowed']
+90184;['appeal isterminated']
+82254;['dismiss the appeal']
+132346;['appeal is dismissed']
+52200;['application to reopen the appeal is allowed']
+106665;['appeal of shankaron abdi mohamed is dismissed']
+104835;['appeals should be allowed']
+76781;['dismisses an appeal']
+59855;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95000;['appeal isallowed.the']
+28021;['allow the appeal']
+101203;['appeal was dismissed']
+59793;['appeal is allowed']
+108125;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+77639;['appeal isallowed']
+80274;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+43748;['dismiss the appeal']
+92095;['claimants,xxxx xxxxand his wifexxxx xxxx xxxxnot', '“convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+63956;['appeal of the appellant is dismissed']
+59977;['claimants not to be convention refugees']
+69806;['appeal is dismissed']
+76523;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+95092;['302 (c.a.']
+103754;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+96751;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+74264;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125621;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+125487;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'appeal is dismissed']
+77028;['appeal isallowed']
+143593;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124717;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+42176;['departure orders areset aside']
+121634;['appellants are convention refugees']
+77285;['appeal is allowed']
+80465;['appeal is terminated']
+106673;['appeal is allowed']
+111291;['appeal is dismissed']
+128933;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99658;['appeal is allowed.the']
+107604;['appeal is dismissed']
+123290;['claim therefore fails']
+38412;['appeal is dismissed']
+144409;['appeal is dismissed']
+82200;['appeal is allowed']
+96997;['appeal is allowed']
+95632;['appeal abandoned']
+71805;['appeal is dismissed']
+76449;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+64031;['appeal is allowed']
+90935;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+70693;['panel orders that the interim review of stay']
+81073;['302 (c.a.']
+100003;['dismissing the appeal']
+52116;['appeal is dismissed']
+129113;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+81288;['appeal is allowed']
+106155;['appeal is allowed']
+68562;['appeal is dismissed']
+95901;['appeal is dismissed']
+59909;['appeal is dismissed']
+82221;['appeal is dismissed']
+143499;['302 (c.a.']
+96683;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+89430;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+86193;['dismiss this appeal']
+142462;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101539;['appeal is allowed']
+91528;['appeal is dismissed']
+76167;['panel rejects his claim']
+61222;['appeal is allowed']
+89251;['appeal must be dismissed']
+113594;['appeal isallowed']
+71689;['appeal is allowed']
+60988;['appeal is allowed']
+141620;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+51337;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98523;['appeal has not been abandoned']
+80554;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+74509;['appeal is deemed abandoned']
+99410;['appeal is dismissed']
+116809;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+63169;['panel finds that the removal order is valid in law']
+110275;['four claimants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+62258;['302 (c.a.']
+144043;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+32080;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77677;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+81148;['appeals are dismissed']
+50620;['appeal is allowed']
+124111;['appeal is dismissed']
+71116;['refugee protection division determines thatxxxxxxxxxx', 'not convention refugees']
+89726;['appeal isallowed']
+77228;['appeal of the principal appellant']
+76240;['claimant and the co-claimant']
+125667;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is excluded']
+89937;['appeal isallowed']
+63955;['appeal is allowed']
+63177;['appeal is dismissed']
+76529;['appeal isallowed']
+98383;['dismiss this appeal', 'appeal is hereby dismissed']
+61484;['stay is set aside']
+95547;['appeal is dismissed']
+101904;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+32166;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+67524;['appeal is allowed']
+153417;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+75478;['appeal is dismissed']
+61214;['appeal is allowed']
+63928;['appeal isdismissed.']
+103914;['appeal is dismissed']
+52315;['appeal is dismissed']
+64002;['appeal isallowed']
+148629;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+132322;['appeal is dismissed']
+46039;['appeal fails']
+95981;['claim is rejected']
+120826;['appeal is allowed']
+59765;['refusal is valid in law']
+99644;['appeal is allowed']
+104843;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+88163;['appeal is dismissed']
+100348;['claimant is excluded from claiming for refugee protection']
+83716;['allows the appeal']
+88403;['application is allowed']
+123765;['appeal is allowed']
+80455;['appeal is allowed']
+92416;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+122632;['appeal concerning them is allowed']
+141063;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97890;['removal orders are set aside']
+87607;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69385;['302 (c.a.']
+62717;['appeal is allowed']
+123266;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'declares that the appellant, xxxx xxxx xxxx , is a convention refugee']
+97817;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+77850;['appeal is allowed']
+95883;['appeal is dismissed']
+19238;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+128336;['appeal is allowed']
+108733;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+40151;['theappealis dismissed']
+88505;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+86946;['appeal of peter kay-yan chan is dismissed']
+131736;['rad substitutes the negative determination of the rpd', 'allows the appellants’ appeal']
+90284;['appeal is determined']
+151809;['appeal is dismissed']
+110963;['appeal is dismissed']
+94656;['appeal is allowed']
+35878;['officer’s decision is therefore valid in law']
+122123;['appeal is allowed']
+57930;['appeal is dismissed']
+95337;['appeal from the april\xa022, 2010, removal order made against the appellant']
+93022;['not find that there was a violation of the principles of natural justice']
+98483;['appeal isallowed']
+135149;['appeal is allowed']
+113746;['appellant is a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+26929;['302 (c.a.']
+98237;['appeal be dismissed']
+110944;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+73677;['appeal is allowed']
+88811;['appeal is dismissed']
+100701;['claim is therefore rejected']
+121865;['302 (c.a.']
+76231;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+127372;['appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection”.the', 'appeals are dismissed']
+87594;['reject their claims']
+47388;['appeal is allowed']
+74069;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+92833;['appeal is dismissed']
+133404;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100016;['appeal is dismissed']
+68095;['appeal is allowed']
+81418;['appeal is allowed']
+135492;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+88445;['panel rejects the claim']
+114432;['substitute my determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+133343;['appeal is dismissed']
+32085;['board is not a tribunal of first instance']
+63824;['appeal of baljit bassi is allowed']
+142307;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75704;['appeal is dismissed']
+85463;['appeal isallowedfor']
+52331;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+69205;['rpd’s determination must be set aside']
+79238;['appeal is dismissed']
+77587;['302 (c.a.)']
+31389;['appeal were dismissed']
+145513;['appeal is allowed']
+104846;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96634;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99780;['appeal is dismissed']
+92273;['deny your claim']
+66532;['appeal beallowed']
+151428;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+146605;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+47297;['appeal is dismissed']
+123822;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83045;['appeal is dismissed']
+96341;['appeal is allowed']
+68616;['appeal is allowed']
+111001;['appeal is dismissed']
+123739;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+77605;['appeal is dismissed']
+106804;['appeals are dismissed']
+95246;['appeal must be dismissed']
+135136;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+91583;['appeal is allowed']
+124429;['dismiss the appeal']
+95618;['appeal isallowed']
+95106;['negative']
+93045;['appeal is suspended']
+97022;['her claim fails']
+81083;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95270;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+123866;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94282;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+40646;['appeal should be allowed']
+130940;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a refugee']
+123675;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76651;['appeal is allowed']
+58638;['appeal is dismissed']
+85525;['appeal is dismissed']
+94000;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69418;['appeal isdismissedand departure orders are made against the appellants']
+108828;['appeals are dismissed']
+90808;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+101353;['appeal is allowed']
+93672;['appeal is allowed']
+122225;['appeal is allowed']
+82794;['appeal isallowed']
+72874;['appeal is terminated']
+40287;['appeal is dismissed']
+40158;['appeal is dismissed']
+101714;['appeals are allowed']
+140927;['boc was not amended']
+14694;['appeal division further orders the removal ofangela evadniejohnin']
+122829;['appeal is allowed']
+90912;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129909;['appeal is determined']
+74072;['appeal is allowed']
+95889;['appeal is allowed']
+139854;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151582;['appeal is allowed']
+128912;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd’s determination is correct and appropriate']
+67501;['appeal is dismissed']
+90996;['appeal is dismissed']
+140993;['rpd decision is correct']
+70648;['dismissed the appeal']
+96348;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+153148;['rad has found that the rpd decision in this case cannot stand']
+121946;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+110042;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+91252;['appeal is terminated']
+23099;['cancel the stay of removal', 'allow this appeal']
+90757;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+87153;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77559;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+57524;['appeal is allowed']
+90995;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+42453;['appeal is allowed']
+145807;['appeals are dismissed']
+31263;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+57822;['appeal isallowed']
+136156;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+91449;['302 (c.a.']
+80809;['appeal isallowed']
+99980;['dismiss this appeal']
+148936;['appeal is dismissed']
+38612;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+98453;['appeal is deemed to be abandoned']
+79759;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+100368;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+146106;['appeal is dismissed']
+122373;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82716;['appeal isallowed']
+151618;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77115;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+62254;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+134517;['appeals are allowed']
+90035;['negative']
+104470;['appeal of yue zhu wu is allowed']
+67561;['appeal is allowed']
+107844;['appeal is allowed']
+98635;['appeal is allowed']
+143915;['302 (c.a.']
+115216;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+95059;['appeal is allowed']
+118170;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+103543;['appeal is dismissed']
+60310;['appeal is allowed']
+149480;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal']
+84079;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+107169;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+98280;['decision of the immigration division is set aside.under', 'immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+127422;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+93921;['appeal from the officer’s decision of may 10, 2012 regarding mni is allowed']
+84365;['appeal is dismissed']
+59944;['panel rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+145433;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+125340;['dismiss this argument']
+115283;['appeal is dismissed']
+100749;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73319;['appeal be dismissed']
+46014;['appeal is allowed']
+101164;['appellants ask the refugee appeal division (rad) to find them to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+109275;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102673;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+93323;['appeal is dismissed']
+80052;['appeal is dismissed']
+97623;['claim is therefore rejected']
+90246;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+58125;['appeal is allowed']
+45999;['appeal is abandoned']
+129151;['appeal is dismissed']
+47131;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+128181;['appeal is allowed']
+97247;['appeal is dismissed']
+84574;['appeal is terminated']
+90084;['appeal is terminated']
+74022;['appeal is allowed']
+61222;['appeal is allowed']
+63057;['appeal of tammy-lynne mahdwan is therefore dismissed']
+92757;['application to reopen the appeal in file mb1-06955 is dismissed']
+59729;['302 (c.a.']
+70160;['appeal is allowed']
+91452;['appeal is terminated']
+76469;['appeal is allowed']
+76294;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+87120;['appeal is allowed']
+89421;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+120739;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151906;['appeal is dismissed']
+94618;['appeal is allowed']
+125023;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71681;['appeal isallowed']
+89925;['appeal were dismissed']
+26710;['appeal bedismissed']
+101266;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+70947;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+122654;['appellants are recognized are persons in need of protection']
+89427;['appeal isallowed']
+74619;['appeal is dismissed']
+68268;['appeal is allowed']
+84224;['appeal is allowed']
+58835;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+90025;['appeal isallowed']
+148173;['panel rejects the claimants’ refugee protection claim', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+44085;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+9486;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96509;['allows the appeal', 'cancels the removal order']
+85543;['appeal is allowed']
+123975;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102063;['appeal is allowed']
+99287;['appeal is allowed']
+83905;['appeal is terminated']
+57667;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'dismisses the appeal']
+88130;['302 (c.a.']
+132417;['appeal is dismissed']
+125001;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94529;['appeal of khadija zidoune is allowed']
+75474;['allow the appeal of lakhbees singh chuhan in law']
+112374;['allow the appeal and refer the matter back to the rpd']
+69108;['allow this appeal']
+141635;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96440;['appeal is allowed']
+109702;['appeal is allowed.the']
+69462;['appeal isallowed']
+30497;['appeal is dismissedand']
+84817;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+125632;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75134;['appeal of calfukna veronica levy (the appellant) to be abandoned']
+75482;['appeal fails']
+68534;['appeal is allowed']
+96238;['appeal is allowed']
+64593;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80679;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+31992;['appeal is allowed']
+61006;['appeal of yvonne ofori is dismissed']
+87398;['appeal is dismissed']
+94217;['appeal is dismissed']
+135897;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection']
+47355;['appeal is allowed']
+95913;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47171;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+65132;['dismiss the appellant’s appeals']
+70913;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+14516;['favourable decision form is attached to these reasons']
+36131;['appeal be allowed']
+83448;['appeal is dismissed']
+98665;['xxxx xxxx xxxxclaim for refugee protection is rejected']
+74656;['appeal is dismissed']
+22395;['appeal is determined']
+59764;['appeal is allowed']
+72632;['removal order is set aside']
+128210;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+79217;['appeal is dismissed']
+54244;['application to cancel the stay of the deportation order is dismissed']
+68227;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+37632;['appeal be allowed']
+128930;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+93962;['appeal of gurdev singh tatla is dismissed']
+47917;['departure order is set aside']
+104075;['appeal is allowed']
+141562;['appeal of sharafuddin mohammad yunis is dismissed']
+104441;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+28084;['appeal is allowed']
+63718;['appeal is allowed']
+38569;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+133173;['allow the appeal']
+134239;['appeal is dismissed']
+95575;['appeal is determined']
+43326;['appeal is allowed']
+99012;['not “convention refugees”']
+17940;['dismiss the appeal']
+81377;['appeal is dismissed']
+124004;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96740;['negative']
+127700;['appeal is determined']
+42210;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+122889;['rpd’s findings are upheld']
+86146;['appeal is allowed']
+80371;['appeal of the remaining family members in this application is allowed']
+125462;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+64835;['allow the appeal']
+75009;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+116344;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59860;['appeals were filed']
+108185;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+67436;['appeal isallowed']
+21301;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+101872;['appeal is dismissed']
+103178;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+102146;['302 (c.a.']
+82249;['appeal is allowed']
+81820;['appeal is dismissed']
+151947;['302 (c.a.']
+98521;['appeal is granted']
+131731;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95087;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+80523;['appeal is dismissed']
+133694;['appeals are dismissed']
+96625;['neither convention refugees']
+100512;['claimants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124078;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee']
+132768;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+84501;['appeal is terminated']
+91146;['appeal is dismissed']
+84454;['appeal is allowed']
+132423;['neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+46475;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+72070;['removal orders are set aside']
+124336;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123924;['appeal is allowed']
+64207;['appeal is allowed']
+130918;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+104982;['dismiss the appeal']
+123555;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56495;['appeal is allowed']
+98070;['appeal is dismissed']
+125458;['affirm that the explanation is unreasonable']
+77028;['appeal is allowed']
+100232;['panel dismisses the appeal']
+29061;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50353;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+39054;['appeal is allowed']
+72631;['appeal is allowed']
+152004;['appeal is dismissed']
+143635;['302 (c.a.']
+104480;['appeal is dismissed']
+61966;['appeal should now']
+61418;['not find the refusal not to be legally valid']
+78718;['appeal is allowed']
+27152;['appeal of ahtisham zeb rajpoot is dismissed']
+95214;['appeal is dismissed']
+35884;['appeal is allowed.the']
+111164;['appeal is allowed']
+47114;['allowed the appeal']
+90926;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26740;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+97809;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105881;['appeal is dismissed']
+108714;['rad (refugee appeal division) confirms the decision of the rpd']
+71172;['appeal is dismissed']
+80042;['302 (c.a.']
+88253;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+46553;['302 (c.a.)']
+12001;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+52142;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+95783;['appeal is dismissed']
+79704;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+76711;['appeal is allowed']
+82254;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+107623;['applicants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+72813;['dismiss this appeal']
+133256;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94689;['appeal isallowed']
+59584;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+128447;['appeals are dismissed']
+90130;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94013;['appeal is allowed']
+76006;['appellants are not convention refugees']
+76942;['appeal is allowed']
+26885;['claimant, mr. xxxxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+146902;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86305;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedundersubsection']
+26711;['appeals must be dismissed']
+99511;['appeal is dismissed']
+32165;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+41568;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+57782;['appeal is allowed']
+81880;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101356;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+39064;['appeal is dismissed']
+144554;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+69623;['appeal isallowed']
+108729;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47098;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+65014;['appeal isallowed']
+88401;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124651;['dismiss the appeal']
+96910;['rad upholds the rpd’s findings']
+52110;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+71408;['appeal is dismissed']
+83317;['appeal is dismissed']
+91308;['appeal is dismissed']
+115284;['appeal is dismissed']
+44737;['appeal is allowed']
+93681;['appeal is allowed']
+92548;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+20003;['appeal is allowed']
+10021;['panel finds the exclusion order to be legally valid']
+50522;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+47374;['appeal is allowed']
+99979;['rejects this argument']
+31417;['appeal is dismissed']
+125498;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38397;['appeal is dismissed']
+122834;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+118293;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+85858;['negative']
+75619;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+83313;['appeal is dismissed']
+22659;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+60059;['appeal isallowed']
+153045;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd rendered the correct decision in excluding the appellant']
+87793;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+113538;['appeal be dismissed']
+28058;['appeal is dismissed']
+59874;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87229;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+97215;['302 (c.a.)']
+123922;['appeal is dismissed']
+47875;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+122866;['302 (c.a.']
+88344;['ana and nds']
+38855;['appeals are allowed']
+63719;['appeal of fatmata babakay koroma is dismissed']
+127718;['appeal is allowed']
+77456;['appeal is allowed']
+143619;['appeal is allowed']
+98751;['appeal isallowed']
+55192;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+93816;['claimantxxxx xxxxx xxxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+129105;['appeal is dismissed']
+88024;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+152137;['sponsor or the foreign national']
+77824;['negative']
+56870;['appeal isallowed']
+21387;['motion to re-open the refugee claim of xxxxx xxxxxx is denied']
+55194;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+68116;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+85234;['appeal is dismissed']
+124099;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+107379;['appeal is dismissed']
+120765;['302 (c.a.']
+97445;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143010;['appellant is not a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+132829;['appeal be dismissed']
+89441;['negative']
+104004;['dismiss the present appeal']
+87036;['appeal is dismissed']
+82271;['appeal isallowed']
+124744;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+47295;['appeal is dismissed']
+40291;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+82216;['appeal of shirley valdez uy is dismissed']
+93913;['appeal before the panel today has two issues']
+70602;['dismissed the appeals']
+53835;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95224;['appeal isallowed']
+87842;['appeal is dismissed']
+60052;['appeals of mehnaz a. kashouri and asmaa m.h.a.r al bloushi are hereby allowed']
+56701;['appeal is therefore, dismissed']
+99583;['appeal is dismissed']
+106835;['leads me to conclude that the visa officer failed to conduct a fair and individualised assessment of the couple’s marriage']
+67803;['302 (c.a.']
+89867;['dismiss the appeal']
+74849;['appeal is allowed']
+87148;['appeal must fail']
+101797;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+78054;['appeal isallowed']
+113612;['appeal is allowed']
+123303;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141321;['appeal is allowed']
+143648;['appeal is dismissed']
+37186;['allows the appeal']
+90635;['appeal is allowed']
+71995;['dismiss this appeal']
+26812;['appeal of randeep kaur sandhu pursuant to paragraph 77(3)(a) of theimmigration actis allowed']
+71235;['allow this appeal']
+36128;['appeal of virginio macababat quebec is dismissed']
+134394;['officer’s decision is well-founded in law']
+105641;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+106297;['appeal is allowed']
+121452;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+90007;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+52653;['refugee protection claims are rejected']
+150700;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96528;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+83064;['appeal of david turay is dismissed']
+40371;['appeal should not be terminated']
+75886;['appeal is allowed']
+108819;['302 (c.a.)']
+124805;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+144389;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+86308;['appeal is dismissed']
+105434;['appeal is allowed']
+83645;['appellant is not established incanada']
+80128;['appeal is abandoned']
+102015;['appeal is dismissed']
+128160;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+73058;['appeal is allowed']
+56895;['dismiss the appeal']
+91112;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+82738;['appeal is terminated']
+5144;['appeals should be dismissed']
+49741;['appeal is dismissed']
+80189;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+72173;['appeal is allowed']
+36572;['appeal were dismissed']
+98949;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+92780;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+13606;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+98811;['appeal is allowed']
+101022;['appeal isallowed']
+83091;['appeal is allowed']
+69624;['dismissing the appeal']
+61906;['appeal is allowed']
+76002;['appeal is allowed']
+127702;['appeal is allowed']
+5146;['appeal is allowed']
+94502;['appeal is dismissed']
+74464;['appeal of john victor hayes is dismissed']
+104173;['claimants are neither convention refugees']
+95602;['appeals are dismissed']
+68922;['appeal is allowed']
+93903;['302 (c.a.']
+135118;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106155;['appellant has not lost her']
+149571;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136656;['appeal is allowed']
+93307;['appeal is dismissed']
+90143;['appeal is allowed']
+107498;['appeal is dismissed']
+102978;['appeal is allowed']
+77436;['appeal is allowed.the']
+95659;['appeal is allowed']
+59405;['appeal comes before me', 'appeal is therefore dismissed']
+44090;['refugee appeal division confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+130687;['appeal is allowed']
+97467;['negative']
+54799;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+63740;['appeal is allowed']
+103538;['appeal is dismissed']
+34891;['appeal is dismissed']
+94084;['allow the appeal']
+57912;['appeal be dismissed']
+117213;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee']
+59838;['appeal is allowed']
+140923;['rpd’s decision is wrong in law', 'not be allowed to stand']
+105868;['rad finds that the respondent’s refugee claim has']
+98634;['appeal is allowed']
+100764;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+52625;['not a “convention refugee']
+107491;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93091;['appeals are allowed']
+98807;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+79324;['appeal isallowed']
+90260;['appeal is dismissed']
+125440;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+130739;['appeal were dismissed']
+90127;['reject their claims']
+17980;['appeal is allowed']
+90672;['appeal is dismissed']
+124964;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+48273;['appeal is dismissed']
+95402;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+96711;['appeal isallowedand']
+94196;['appeal is allowed']
+22128;['appeal is dismissed']
+44732;['dismiss the appeal']
+110723;['appeal is dismissed']
+129166;['appeal is dismissed']
+144024;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108794;['appeal is rejected']
+79473;"[""visa officer's decision must stand""]"
+89061;['appeal isallowed']
+124318;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99284;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+135899;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes that decision with its determination']
+98609;['appeal is dismissed']
+88515;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+105812;['appeal is allowed']
+104840;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96139;['appeal is allowed']
+131182;['appeal is allowed']
+114374;['302 (c.a.']
+89789;['dismiss the appeal']
+46567;['appeal is allowed']
+147609;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+70493;['appeal is terminated']
+47924;['appealis allowed']
+42564;['appeal is allowed']
+142303;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55951;['appeal is dismissed']
+98497;['appeal is terminated']
+31992;['allows the appeal']
+95156;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74258;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94079;['dismiss the appeal']
+125405;['appeals of the associate appellant']
+107926;['rad upholds the rpd decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+77609;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+56618;['appeal is terminated']
+104053;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93224;['appeal isallowed']
+43410;['appeal is allowed']
+93616;['appeal is dismissed']
+104345;['appeal must be dismissed']
+131739;['minor appellants are not refugees or persons in need of protection']
+83904;['appeal is terminated']
+29307;['appeal is dismissed']
+91321;['appeal is allowed']
+88127;['appeal is terminated']
+132408;['appeal is dismissed']
+88896;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+77228;['appeal of alap rajeshkumar shah isallowed']
+54242;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+102537;['application is dismissed']
+38869;['appeal is allowed']
+88894;['claimantxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+95359;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+148506;['dismiss the claim']
+85447;['appeal is allowed']
+9680;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+78176;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142974;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+90743;['appeal is allowed']
+88049;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+99964;['appeal of sumaira qureshi is dismissed']
+142821;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143518;['claimants will not be persecuted']
+124569;['appeal is allowed']
+61544;['appeal is allowed']
+67477;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+54655;['appeal is dismissed']
+56985;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+135119;['confirm or reject some or all of its conclusions']
+77688;['appeal is allowed in law']
+26946;['xxxxxx and xxxxxxx are not convention refugees']
+72316;['appeal is allowed']
+105700;['refugee protection claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+94573;['appeal is allowed']
+143596;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71727;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+131171;['appeal of angela dawn taylor is allowed']
+85930;['appeal isallowed']
+125341;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+93340;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+92071;['appeal is dismissed']
+91021;['application is dismissed']
+92991;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95157;['appeal is dismissed']
+146538;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144016;['cedaw/c/sau/co/3-4']
+76773;['appeal was pursued']
+23018;['appeal is allowed']
+122226;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92572;['appeal terminated']
+96928;['claim is rejected']
+134181;['appeal is allowed']
+123424;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130733;['appeal was dismissed']
+86525;['dismiss this appeal']
+74218;['request for hearing is therefore dismissed']
+84688;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95303;['appellant is not a person described bysection 36(1)(a) ofirpa.']
+57078;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+37853;['appeal is dismissed']
+36100;['dismiss this appeal']
+73869;['dismiss the appeal']
+117155;['appeal is dismissed']
+60194;['appellant has not losthispermanent resident status']
+146820;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+145590;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+53135;['appeal is allowed']
+23073;['appeals of manoharan natesan and sakunthalai manoharan are dismissed']
+97601;['panel rejects these claims for refugee protection']
+100757;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+83040;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+94617;['appeal is allowed']
+60066;['appeal is dismissed']
+75882;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69090;['appeal is allowed']
+77856;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+60041;['reject this explanation']
+1756;['appeal is dismissed']
+99787;['appeal of james robert sinclair is allowed']
+74716;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+131053;['appeal is dismissed']
+95178;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+47216;['adr will proceed']
+71269;['appeal isdismissed.']
+100743;['appeal is dismissed']
+74877;['appeal was dismissed']
+125151;['rpd’s findings are upheld']
+36105;['appeal were dismissed']
+82031;['appeal is dismissed']
+99417;['appeal is dismissed']
+95868;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89837;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123554;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+79212;['appeal is terminated']
+92764;['appeal isallowed']
+140704;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee']
+96704;['appeal isallowed']
+100056;['appeal is dismissed']
+82621;"[""rad confirms the rpd's negative determination""]"
+68186;['appeal of leonard punzala gabriel is dismissed']
+85864;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+69780;['appeal is allowed']
+93079;['appeal is allowed.the']
+61365;['appeal of balbir kaur is allowed']
+74068;['appeal is allowed']
+95279;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124569;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+42393;['appeal is dismissed']
+81203;['appeal is dismissed']
+124931;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94454;['appeal is dismissed']
+94688;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+84785;['appeal cannot succeed']
+147631;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+136748;['not confirm the decision on other grounds']
+87372;['appellants have not lost their']
+94838;['appeal is dismissed']
+58754;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+82846;['decision is well founded in law']
+99097;['appeal is allowed']
+72878;['appeals of jasveen kaur sethi and santej singh sethi are dismissed']
+35056;['appeal is allowed']
+96436;['appeal is dismissed']
+95021;['appeal isallowed']
+151871;['appeal is dismissed']
+152149;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+64641;['appeal is allowed']
+39059;['dismissal of this appeal']
+102074;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107649;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+103812;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113594;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+66938;['appeal isallowedand']
+87409;['appeal is dismissed']
+61413;['appeal is based']
+107610;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its decision that the respondents are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97322;['appeal to be dismissed']
+31928;['appeal is allowed']
+105423;['appeal isallowed']
+63190;['appeal isallowed']
+72659;['appeal is denied']
+151925;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+99011;['appeal is dismissed']
+38427;['appeal is dismissed']
+136718;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+46291;['appeal is dismissed']
+151832;['rad finds that the', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+57524;['appeal isallowed']
+107617;['removal orders areset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+75496;['appeal of zheng gang liu is allowed']
+62626;['appeal is dismissed']
+48754;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+123868;['associate appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83488;['appeal is allowed']
+98296;['negative']
+82886;['appeal is allowed']
+145423;['appeal is based']
+151580;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56271;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62635;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+112371;['appeal in respect of the minor male', 'appellant is dismissed']
+98828;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+108209;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+134208;['appeal should be allowed']
+89309;['the claim fails']
+70661;['nor are they persons in need of protection']
+78014;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+136089;['appeal is allowed']
+83486;['appeal isallowed']
+78745;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+116768;['appeal is allowed']
+82062;['appeal is valid in law']
+94027;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+88329;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93665;['appeal is allowed']
+94268;['appeal is allowed']
+143845;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+151951;['appeal is dismissed']
+142448;['appeal is allowed']
+99227;['nor are they persons in need of protection']
+125160;['confirm the rpd determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+101341;['appeal isallowed']
+97453;['appeal is allowed']
+42225;['302 (c.a.']
+36127;['appeal is dismissed']
+82708;['appeal isallowed']
+124647;['appeal is allowed']
+33240;['appeal should be dismissed']
+106406;['appeal was dismissed']
+80824;['302 (c.a.']
+96889;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+113548;['appeal is allowed']
+94770;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+94574;['claimants are not citizens of the people’s republic of china']
+141635;['appeal is allowed.the']
+71334;['appeal is allowed']
+99450;['claimantxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+50484;['appeal is dismissed']
+107369;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+95526;['allow the appeal']
+88169;['appeal is dismissed']
+28048;['appeal is dismissed']
+140064;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+84722;['appeal is dismissed']
+111320;['302 (c.a.']
+56641;['appeal has been abandoned']
+126443;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+91662;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+62123;['appeal be dismissed']
+43394;['appeal is dismissed']
+102566;['appeal is allowed']
+103754;['appeal is dismissed']
+101534;['appeal is dismissed']
+150242;['appeal is allowed']
+116357;['appeal is dismissed']
+124706;['appeal is allowed']
+99464;['three claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+36944;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+41964;['appeal is dismissed']
+91282;['dismiss the appeal']
+106305;['appeal is dismissed']
+72008;['appeal is dismissed']
+80042;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+72058;['appeal is dismissed']
+71672;['appeal is dismissed']
+76662;['appeal of sarjan jagdev singh sandhar is allowed']
+13970;['appeal isallowed']
+68151;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93072;['respondent is not a convention refugee']
+88064;['dismissing the appeal']
+35561;['allowing the appeal']
+99671;['appeal fails']
+142695;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+95247;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+146887;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70957;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+43324;['appeal is dismissed']
+82642;['appeal be allowed']
+102964;['i agree with the rpd’s findings']
+106775;['appeal is allowed']
+82391;['appeal were dismissed']
+26850;['claimants, xxxxx and xxxxx, are “convention refugees”']
+93600;['302 (c.a.']
+77315;['decision is valid in law']
+29597;['appeal isallowed']
+130793;['appeal is dismissed']
+92412;['appeal is allowed']
+97904;['application should be dismissed']
+95184;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+70075;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+78778;['appeal isallowed']
+128267;['appeal ofsalah eddine ferahis dismissed']
+97085;['claims are rejected']
+124423;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+36244;['appeal is dismissed']
+94538;['appeal is dismissed']
+77930;['appeal is dismissed']
+31048;['appeals of abdolmajid ashoori, akram haji hakimi and ali reza ashori aredismissed.']
+100551;['stay is set aside']
+87612;['appeal is allowed']
+87402;['appeal is dismissed']
+28298;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+87193;['appeal fails']
+145835;['appeal is allowed']
+37156;['appeal is terminated']
+67467;['dismiss this appeal']
+151795;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+89340;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+105653;['appeal is dismissed']
+77961;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+100771;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+68894;['dismissed the appeal from the bench']
+68874;['appeal is dismissed']
+125447;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+140248;['application to reopen a previously abandoned appeal is dismissed']
+71044;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79718;['appeal is dismissed']
+14332;['appeal is dismissed']
+145108;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82180;['departure order isset aside']
+87146;['appeal be dismissed']
+90848;['appeal is dismissed']
+85497;['appeal is allowed']
+77211;['appeal is allowed']
+13691;['appeal is dismissed']
+134746;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+70719;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+102698;['rad finds that it does not']
+103534;['allows the appeal']
+82859;['dismissal of the present appeal']
+83245;['appeal isallowed.the']
+67784;['appeal is dismissed']
+47140;['dismissal of this appeal']
+52281;['appeal is terminated']
+86643;['appeal is dismissed']
+57536;['appeal is allowed']
+147777;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+132644;['rpd’s determination is therefore confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+100777;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+102562;['appeal is allowed']
+93765;['appeal is allowed']
+96851;['appeal is dismissed']
+78676;['appeal is allowed']
+45182;['appeal of asit kumar biswas is therefore allowed in law']
+68590;['appeal fails on both grounds']
+64848;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+57808;['appeal is dismissed']
+38835;['appeals are allowed']
+100321;['claimants,xxxx xxxx,and his motherxxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+54320;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+123456;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86898;['set aside the removal order.']
+76078;['appeal isallowed']
+13692;['removal order isset aside']
+76032;['appeal of babatunde ojo is dismissed']
+132721;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+100412;['appeal is dismissed']
+61044;['appeal of tze loong (sylvester) chan is dismissed']
+144479;['not a convention refugee nor is a person in need of protection']
+85542;['appeal is allowed']
+98270;['appeal is allowed.the']
+146537;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59049;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+106278;['appeal is dismissed']
+85511;['appeal is terminated']
+88332;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+70228;['appeal must be dismissed']
+81261;['appeal were dismissed']
+101325;['appeal is allowed']
+136133;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd decision']
+152024;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+141163;['visa officer’s refusal is not valid in law']
+98736;['appeal is dismissed']
+145352;['rpd finds that the p.c.']
+45226;['appeal is dismissed']
+77855;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+89896;['appeal is dismissed']
+131717;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+77628;['decision is valid in law']
+95527;['appeal is terminated']
+54657;['appeal is allowed']
+63203;['appeal is dismissed']
+103799;['the claim fails']
+140888;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76896;['exclusion order is set aside']
+68365;['appeal is dismissed']
+54737;['appeal should be dismissed']
+98139;['departure order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+38863;['appeal isallowed']
+98157;['appeal is dismissed']
+64585;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+131914;['appeal is dismissed']
+99734;['appeal will not be reopened']
+49582;['appeal is allowed']
+86993;['appeal is dismissed']
+89806;['appeal is allowed']
+109006;['appeals are dismissed']
+129878;['rpd decision stands']
+146878;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses this appeal']
+86449;['appeal is dismissed']
+99936;['panel, therefore, rejects her claim']
+40280;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+142409;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+104125;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+91379;['appeal is allowed']
+122252;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+42312;['appeal of olurotimi olufunso mejule is dismissed']
+95350;['constitution provides for']
+72886;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+123664;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+91951;['rejects his claim']
+109138;['appeal isallowed']
+107428;['rad confirms\xa0 the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122676;['dismiss the appeal']
+92765;['appeal is dismissed']
+152910;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+55910;['appeal is allowed']
+107861;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145818;['appeal is allowed']
+19726;['appeal is dismissed']
+94592;['appeal is allowed']
+94599;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+47159;['appeal is discontinued is dismissed']
+104838;['appeal is allowed']
+83919;['appeal is dismissed']
+87252;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+133245;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94496;['appeal is dismissed']
+72647;['appeal is dismissed']
+95659;['removal order isset aside']
+51337;['appeal is allowed.the']
+77319;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+87132;['appeal is dismissed']
+92176;['appeal is dismissed']
+151779;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not inadmissible to canada']
+131537;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+25985;['removal order is set aside']
+56872;['appeal is allowed']
+76352;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+131273;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+23115;['appeal is not allowed']
+94356;['dismiss the appeal']
+104971;['appeal is allowed']
+130765;['appeal is allowed']
+108130;['appeal is allowed']
+82741;['leads me to find the witnesses deliberately misrepresented particular facts']
+83467;['negative determination']
+74779;['appeal is allowed']
+99972;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+131202;['allows this appeal']
+23043;['appeal of dr. ayesha imran is allowed.the']
+26937;['claimant does not meet the definition of convention refugee']
+128631;['appeal is allowed']
+73351;['appeal is dismissed']
+101299;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96421;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45179;['appeal is allowed']
+76047;['appeal isallowed']
+67721;['appeal is allowed']
+82901;['appeal is allowed']
+49971;['appeal is allowed']
+72911;['302 (c.a.)']
+51849;['302 (c.a.']
+83301;['dismiss the appeal']
+59784;['appeal must be dismissed']
+60950;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+93645;['appeal isallowed']
+99243;['appeal isallowed']
+61392;['appeal is dismissed']
+18002;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69434;['not find that the applicant has temporary resident status']
+87037;['appeal isallowed']
+69604;['appeal will be dismissed']
+52113;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+145216;['appeal is allowed']
+99543;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97199;['claims are rejected']
+97520;['not a person in need of protection']
+84601;['appellant is a protected person.subsection']
+40128;['appeal is dismissed']
+71406;['appeal is dismissed']
+43747;['appeal is dismissed']
+125037;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108267;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+83669;['allow the appeal']
+120808;['appellant’s argument fails']
+96117;['appeal must accordingly fail']
+62631;['appeal is dismissed']
+99918;['appeal is dismissed']
+70053;['appeal be reopened']
+95569;['appeal is allowed']
+101454;['appeal is abandoned']
+60001;['reject their claims']
+89152;['appeal is allowed']
+122948;['rad finds that it did']
+28285;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+26479;['appeals in files mb3-03810 and mb5-05892 are dismissed']
+81868;['appeals are allowed.the']
+52761;['appeal’s abandonment']
+34164;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+23970;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+122672;['appeal is allowed']
+54652;['appeal was declared abandoned']
+100628;['appeal is allowed']
+83023;['removal order is set aside']
+121848;['rad dismisses the appeals and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+97880;['thatxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+95639;['appeal is dismissed']
+95763;['application ought to be dismissed']
+92395;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+141062;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+98077;['xxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+76888;['appeal was dismissed']
+74067;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+101446;['appeal is dismissed']
+96184;['appeal is dismissed']
+87195;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+136118;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither “refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+92730;['appeal is allowed.the']
+80302;['negative']
+133259;['dismiss the appeals']
+96090;['appeal isdeterminedto be']
+99861;['appeals of jinbao cao and shaoyan cao are dismissed']
+42335;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+114322;['appeal is dismissed']
+49066;['appeal of li yan huang is allowed']
+85493;['appeal is allowed']
+76686;['appeal fails']
+94218;['decision under appeal is set aside']
+39079;['appeal is allowed']
+59183;['appeal is allowed']
+100271;['appeal is allowed']
+100624;['appeal is allowed']
+151586;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+90483;['appeal isallowed.the']
+92486;['appeal is allowed']
+140736;['302 (c.a.']
+76762;['appeal is determined to have beenabandonedundersubsection']
+54185;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+83036;['appeal is allowed']
+56770;['reject his claim for refugee protection']
+102114;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+74798;['appeal is allowed']
+141614;['appellant is not aconventionrefugee or a person in need of protection']
+96794;['appeal isallowed']
+73874;['appeal is dismissed']
+52291;['ms. akthar is not a member of the family class']
+133741;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a conventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+53444;['panel finds that the removal orders are valid in law']
+144771;['claimant is neither a refugee within the meaning ofsection\xa096of theirpanor']
+84493;['appeal is allowed']
+71065;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+81177;['appeal is based']
+94221;['refugee protection division rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+71267;['appeal is allowed.having']
+21315;['you are not a convention refugee']
+44985;['appeal is dismissed']
+37901;['appeal is allowed']
+70023;['appeal is dismissed']
+100192;['appeal is allowed']
+134332;['appeal is dismissed']
+92740;['appeal is allowed']
+147461;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+149575;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+81264;['appeal is allowed']
+54638;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90807;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+89430;['declare the appealabandoned']
+30542;['appeal is allowed']
+57791;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+113254;['panel finds that the visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+56578;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+123472;['appeal is allowed']
+125472;['rad, pursuant', 'substitutes a decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86377;['appeal is allowed']
+140843;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80137;['appeal is terminated']
+131003;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis excluded from refugee protection']
+62251;['not a convention refugee']
+48722;['appeal is dismissed']
+40773;['rad has found that the rpd decision can stand albeit with different reasons']
+127733;['application was denied']
+85514;['appeal should be reopened']
+104937;['appeal is terminated']
+63941;['appeal is allowed']
+76720;['appeal is allowed']
+69958;['appeal be dismissed']
+74508;['appeals could be dismissed']
+63955;['removal order is set aside']
+140898;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+106295;['302 (c.a.']
+62385;['negative']
+38873;['appeal is allowed']
+71007;['appeal raises a strict question of law']
+98153;['appeal is dismissed']
+74748;['application to re-open is allowed']
+76945;['appeal differs fromsingh']
+96591;['appeal is allowed']
+125093;['appeal is allowed']
+67794;['appeal is dismissed']
+94616;['claim is rejected']
+125432;['appeal is dismissed']
+144022;['appeal is allowed']
+21300;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80668;['not a person in need of protection']
+55125;['appeal is allowed']
+151579;['leads the rad to conclude that the appellant is an untrustworthy person']
+87320;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+113292;['appeal is allowed']
+45188;['appeal is allowed']
+102833;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+129929;['appeal has been abandoned']
+71473;['appeal is without merit']
+41571;['appeal is dismissed']
+72104;['ms.\xa0xxxx is a refugee protection claimant']
+56875;['dismiss the appeal']
+74129;['appeals are allowed']
+63994;['appeals are dismissed']
+97606;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+55182;['appeals of dominguilio g. paragas and erlinda a. paragas are dismissed']
+150643;['appeal is allowed']
+55188;['appeal is dismissed']
+57953;['appeal was dismissed']
+37417;['appeal were dismissed']
+92281;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+70884;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123409;['appeals are allowed']
+97482;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107643;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd’s decision', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of canada’s protection']
+125647;['rad rejects this argument']
+142505;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes that decision with its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+86218;['appellants maintain their permanent resident status']
+110678;['appellants are not likely to be removed']
+100658;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+61220;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94177;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+125087;['appeal is allowed']
+83915;['appeal is from a refusal to approve the permanent resident visa application']
+94898;['or a “person in need of protection']
+93683;['rad disagrees']
+60945;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+123668;['302 (c.a.']
+84442;['appeal is allowed']
+105866;['appeal is dismissed']
+78013;['appeal is dismissed']
+62239;['negative']
+69781;['appeal is dismissed']
+74814;['…]”']
+77468;['appeal is terminated']
+102412;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+99740;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate circumstances']
+85450;['appeal is dismissed']
+46535;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+69524;['dismiss the appeal']
+121434;['appeal is allowed']
+99297;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68338;['appeal is allowed']
+35052;['appeal is allowed']
+107149;['appeal is dismissed']
+83348;['appeal is dismissed']
+46500;['appeal was dismissed']
+122806;['substitute my own decision that the respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26747;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+85430;['appeal is allowed']
+143592;['appeals are dismissed']
+98276;['appeal is allowed.the']
+134282;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+123966;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55180;['appeal is dismissed']
+91239;['appeal is allowed']
+146817;['appeal is allowed']
+30483;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+88252;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision falls within the range of possible, acceptable outcomes']
+47364;['appeal is dismissed']
+52162;['not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+84293;['appeal is allowed']
+70017;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+105785;['appellant and the husband are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134284;['order is valid in law and fact']
+99644;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67435;['appeal isallowed']
+77971;['appeal is allowed']
+15583;['appeal is allowed']
+111009;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+66942;['allow the appeal']
+82995;['appeal were dismissed']
+104505;['rpd’s decision is erroneous']
+83108;['appeal has been abandoned']
+89374;['appeal is dismissed']
+151316;['allow the appeal']
+30499;['appeal be dismissed']
+110967;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need   of protection']
+70669;['appeal is allowed']
+47472;['dismissed the appeal']
+100388;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+102912;['appeal is allowed']
+57926;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+86055;['appeal is terminated']
+87450;['appeal isallowed']
+147461;['appeal is dismissed']
+47746;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+69273;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+98328;['appeal be dismissed']
+77006;['302 (c.a.']
+91621;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+74774;['appeal abandoned']
+101265;['appeal is allowed']
+107442;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+72838;['decision is well founded in law and fact']
+52709;['refugee protection division rejects the claim for protection']
+64133;['appeal isdismissed.']
+73038;['allow the appeal']
+97445;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+52510;['deny the appeal']
+83551;['appeal is allowed or dismissed']
+59841;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+81613;['appeal is dismissed']
+99851;['appeal is dismissed']
+57931;['appeal is a hearingde']
+76246;['reject this explanation']
+72855;['appeal is dismissed']
+83065;['appeal is allowed']
+100335;['302 (c.a.']
+98593;['appeal is allowed']
+104443;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142809;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+142814;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+132793;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appeal is dismissed']
+103022;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+143613;['dismiss the appeal']
+46386;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+92790;['appeal is dismissed']
+76787;['appeal is allowed']
+52913;['appeals were filed by ms.assumpta\xa0kanimba\xa0mukankusiand dr.pierre\xa0celestin\xa0kanimba(the appellants)']
+108059;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+123913;['appeal is allowed']
+34687;['302 (c.a.']
+101048;['appeal is allowed']
+132779;['appeal is dismissed']
+94577;['you are not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+143018;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+77839;['panel rejects this claim']
+125147;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124647;['substitute the determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+105421;['appeals are allowed']
+128380;['adoption conforms to the laws of the prc']
+77621;['appeal is allowed']
+84621;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+81105;['appeal is dismissed']
+62642;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+95181;['appeal is dismissed']
+101275;['appeal is allowed']
+58388;['appeal is allowed']
+97280;['panel rejects this claim for refugee protection']
+139885;['appeal is dismissed']
+85862;['claimant’s claim fails']
+91322;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96982;['302 (c.a.']
+97463;['application to extend the time to file the notice of appeal is dismissed']
+93816;['negative']
+125464;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61425;['appeal is dismissed']
+29150;['appeal isterminated']
+55184;['appeal is refused']
+63700;['appeal is dismissed']
+92789;['appeal isallowed']
+124042;['appeal is dismissed']
+84183;['appeal is dismissed']
+96624;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86408;['appeal were dismissed.the']
+45170;['appeal is allowed']
+90844;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142457;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+123308;['appeal is allowed']
+84624;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+69695;['allows this appeal']
+132844;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+42412;['upholds the minister’s positive recommendation', 'allows the appeal']
+69767;['appeal be allowed']
+91590;['appeal be dismissed']
+72589;['appeal is allowed']
+150943;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106809;['appeal is dismissed']
+141786;['appeal of benjamin mendoza dikit is dismissed']
+130756;['appeal is allowed']
+150847;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare convention refugees']
+96020;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101320;['appeal is terminated']
+93291;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98510;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+101951;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects their claims']
+26679;['appeal of raja muzamal kiani yaqoob is dismissed']
+101976;['appellant is in default of proceedings']
+57043;['appeal isallowed']
+94201;['appeal is dismissed']
+92401;['appeal is allowed']
+69240;['appeal is dismissed']
+48719;['appeal is allowed']
+98083;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+92431;['appeal is dismissed']
+88907;['declare mr. kozlov’s appeal to have been abandoned']
+34933;['302 (c.a.']
+112792;['appeal is dismissed']
+84189;['appeal is dismissed']
+83835;['allow the appeal, set aside the original decision and']
+124737;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+149581;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+78191;['appeal is allowed']
+110954;['is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99919;['appeal is abandoned']
+143502;['rpd therefore rejects her claim']
+80461;['appeal is dismissed']
+100958;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+100401;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+124574;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+61430;['appeal is allowed']
+123998;['302 (c.a.)']
+132383;['appeal is dismissed']
+98504;['tribunal allows the appeal in law']
+90632;['appeal is dismissed']
+47309;['appeal is allowed']
+124911;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97624;['302 (c.a.']
+40651;['appeal is allowed']
+85237;['appeal isallowed']
+141085;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+106820;['appeal is allowed']
+96646;['claim for refugee protection of xxxxx xxxxx is rejected']
+103499;['appeal is dismissed']
+77321;['appeal is allowed']
+79979;['negative']
+54313;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+17986;['appeal is dismissed']
+98441;['appeal is determined']
+125436;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd determination', 'claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66241;['appeal dismissed']
+99382;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+89988;['appeal is dismissed']
+74205;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+139801;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+36105;['appeal is allowed']
+107436;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+89968;['appeal is terminated']
+102663;['appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+130879;['appeal is dismissed']
+95242;['appeal is dismissed']
+76063;['appeal is allowed']
+74557;['appeal is dismissed']
+8340;['dismissal of the appellant’s appeal']
+151927;['appeal is rejected']
+89900;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+122915;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89785;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+92174;['appeal is dismissed']
+94681;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+31993;['appeal of pius ozoemenam udeh is dismissed']
+86958;['appeal is terminated']
+123931;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142484;['rad rejects the appellant’s argument']
+108843;['appeal is allowed']
+99634;['sufficient humanitarian or compassionate considerations']
+75590;['appeal is allowed']
+124739;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+128572;['appeal is allowed']
+67781;['appeal is dismissed']
+101414;['appeal isallowed']
+135129;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83709;['appeal is allowed']
+42085;['appeal abandoned']
+84060;['appeal be dismissed']
+107930;['appeal is dismissed']
+116799;['appeal isdismissed.']
+102415;['leads me to conclude the']
+55501;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+146127;['refugee protection claim filed byxxxx xxxxis rejected']
+59753;['appeal is dismissed']
+26741;['appeal is allowed in law']
+79234;['appeal is dismissed']
+62245;['claimant is not a “convention” refugee']
+80823;['appeal isallowed']
+59832;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+74664;['determination is valid in law']
+87591;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+93802;['thatxxxx\xa0xxxx\xa0xxxxx\xa0', '“convention refugees”']
+61234;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+58571;['not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+85492;['appeal is allowed']
+143150;['appeal is allowed']
+67599;['appeal is allowed']
+96208;['appeal abandoned']
+98401;['appeal isallowedand']
+111117;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107440;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding in this regard']
+14706;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+50645;['appeal be dismissed']
+96026;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+94988;['application is denied']
+151617;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69592;['appeal isallowed']
+70161;['appeal is allowed']
+146539;['xxxx xxxx is not aconventionrefugee undersection 96or']
+124954;['argument is dismissed']
+111338;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92377;['appeal is dismissed']
+75583;['appeal is dismissed']
+130723;['appeal is dismissed']
+62253;['panel rejects his claim']
+101258;['account is of no use']
+94591;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+95219;['appeal is dismissed']
+94083;['appeal of kamaljeet kaur dhaliwal is allowed']
+101400;['appeal is allowed']
+143926;['appellant to be a convention refugee']
+90041;['appeal of gurpreet singh sran is dismissed']
+151806;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+19112;['appeal isallowed']
+84323;['negative determination']
+83550;['not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+53855;['appeal is allowed']
+90581;['appeal isallowed']
+77933;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+153161;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38370;['appeal is dismissed']
+121448;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87793;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90190;['fmln is now the party in power']
+98921;['rejects his claim']
+15562;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+84540;['application should be dismissed']
+101881;['appeal is allowed']
+123087;['allow the appeal']
+84817;['appeal isallowed']
+31215;['determination is valid in law']
+146869;['appeal is dismissed']
+73875;['appeal is allowed']
+74456;['appeal is allowed.the']
+68327;['officer’s decision to refuse permanent resident visas is set aside']
+90495;['appeal isallowed']
+114309;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+27009;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+72624;['appeal is dismissed']
+62486;['uphold the rpd’s findings']
+26662;['not instruct immigration to postpone your removal']
+99270;['removal order is set aside']
+45223;['appeal’s dismissal']
+85836;['appeal of mosharuf hossain is dismissed']
+98731;['appeal is determined']
+95659;['appeals are dismissed']
+98242;['appeal is dismissed']
+57068;['appeal is allowed']
+124321;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+96152;['appeal is allowed']
+91406;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98035;['negative']
+99710;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+44086;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129258;['appeals are allowed']
+56889;['appeal is dismissed']
+132654;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+93961;['my decision that the visa officers decision is valid in law']
+132728;['claimants are not convention refugees as defined bys']
+42224;"[""officer's decision is valid in law""]"
+86524;['allows this appeal']
+102435;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+132316;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+106443;['appeal of lyle gordon thompson is allowed']
+28075;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+127485;['appeal is allowed']
+113793;['rad confirms that the appellant is excluded from the application of the conventionbecause of his permanent resident status']
+85519;['appeal is allowed']
+51763;['appeal is dismissed']
+56882;['allows the appeal']
+145501;['appeal is allowed']
+80750;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+149270;['declare this appeal to be abandoned']
+54717;['appeal is dismissed']
+21455;['not a convention refugee']
+80548;['appeal should be dismissed']
+98690;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+127715;['appeal is allowed']
+133379;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64675;['appeal must fail']
+31147;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+143926;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+131696;['thatxxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+78734;['appeal is allowed']
+102893;['appeal is dismissed']
+50776;['appeal is allowed']
+151320;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm, for other reasons', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74135;['confirm the rpd’s decision that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123398;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76946;['appeal is allowed']
+124079;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80302;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+143900;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+91733;['appeal is dismissed']
+30542;['appeal is allowed']
+94928;['appeal abandoned']
+76446;['appeal is dismissed']
+83371;['appeal is allowed']
+136710;['rpd’s determination is set aside']
+150479;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72788;['appeal is dismissed']
+69514;['application is denied']
+99883;['appeal of pierre gilles joseph lanoue isdismissed.']
+70958;['appeal of the appellant fangouyangis dismissed']
+49162;['appeal isallowed']
+61378;['appeal is dismissed']
+72027;['appeal dismissed']
+125327;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+121558;['appeal is dismissed']
+57392;['appeal is allowed']
+147878;['appeal is allowed']
+92495;['appeal is dismissed']
+83080;['appeal is allowed']
+142728;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82171;['appeal is dismissed']
+107922;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+17193;['appeal is allowed.the', 'decision of the id member is set aside']
+67774;['appeal is allowed']
+99026;['appeal is allowed']
+19152;['appeal is dismissed']
+106778;['appeal should be dismissed']
+103508;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+152924;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+79321;['appeal is allowed']
+60119;['302 (c.a.']
+96178;['appeals be dismissed']
+90618;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+105792;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+76615;['…).”']
+100521;['reject this explanation']
+83357;['appeal is dismissed']
+140721;['appeal is allowed']
+94301;['appeal is dismissed']
+103911;['application is allowed']
+93807;['reject the refugee claim']
+106297;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the respondent to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+38862;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+81639;['application to reopen isdismissed.']
+149570;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89680;['appealis allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse permanent resident visas is set aside']
+50758;['appeal isallowed']
+100472;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+60042;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+130998;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination']
+82840;['appeal is terminated']
+128275;['appeal is dismissed']
+96112;['claim is rejected']
+102084;['appeal is allowed']
+94323;['claims are therefore denied']
+78135;['appeal should be dismissed']
+71739;['appeal is dismissed']
+61902;['appeal is allowed']
+93817;['claimantxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+94444;['appellants’ arguments']
+91435;['302 (c.a.']
+37838;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+68904;['appeal is allowed']
+61871;['removal order is set aside']
+72552;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+87711;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+122248;['set aside the rpd determination', 'substitute my own determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+57671;['appeal is dismissed']
+96525;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+95768;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+39041;['appeal is dismissed']
+142966;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107863;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+83077;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+106419;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+76799;['appeal is allowed']
+128668;['associate and minor appellants']
+69778;['theappealis allowed']
+25967;['appeal isallowed']
+99691;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+91710;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+130707;['appeal is dismissed']
+55123;['appeal is allowed']
+59842;['appeal is allowed']
+92758;['dismiss the appeals of the two adults']
+95071;['appeal is allowed']
+61052;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+67185;['appeal is dismissed']
+62446;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100095;['appeal of xxxx xxxx is dismissed']
+76720;['appeal is allowed']
+77070;['appeal is allowed']
+98883;['appeal therefore, is dismissed']
+117191;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108696;['appeal is allowed']
+108248;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+100624;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+106155;['appeal isallowed']
+140922;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99171;['appeals are allowed']
+87713;['appeal is dismissed']
+98758;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+146934;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+125493;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+80678;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'nor are they persons in need of protection']
+99279;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131182;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+128437;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+67422;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+74769;['allows this appeal']
+99330;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+28062;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+91315;['appeal is allowed']
+71363;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+80190;['claimants are not convention refugee or persons in need of protection']
+93857;['appeal of piara singh is dismissed']
+26504;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+122900;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86540;['appeal is dismissed']
+80029;['302 (c.a.']
+105705;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+114323;['appeal is dismissed']
+21350;['xxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxx not to be a “convention refugee']
+98271;['appeal is dismissed']
+128299;['order is valid']
+79892;['negative']
+106625;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+39072;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+75325;['appeal is allowed']
+131107;['rpd decision will not stand']
+107673;['appeals are allowed']
+21345;['ms. xxx xxxxxx xxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+131756;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+89767;['dismiss the appeal']
+37425;['appeal isallowed']
+65686;['appeal is dismissed']
+113286;['appeal is allowed']
+125554;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+125675;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+122382;['appeal is allowed']
+57930;['panel therefore dismisses the appeal']
+143016;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140837;['302 (c.a.)']
+44434;['appeal isallowed']
+122937;['appeal is allowed']
+58421;['appeal is allowed']
+57540;['appeal is allowed']
+84568;['allows this appeal']
+60822;['allowed the appeal']
+95264;['appeal isallowed']
+99691;['panel rejects the claim']
+143029;['302 (c.a.']
+70414;['appeal was dismissed']
+101348;['appeal is allowed']
+67624;['appeal is allowed']
+37632;['appeal allowed or reconsidered is dismissed']
+45412;['appeal of inder jit kaur bajwa is dismissed']
+83396;['appeal is allowed']
+108682;['appeal is dismissed']
+70466;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+68707;['appeal is dismissed']
+132348;['appeal is allowed']
+67392;['appeal is allowed']
+146122;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76147;['appeal is dismissed']
+132365;['appeal is allowed']
+106153;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+97596;['dismisses the appeal']
+151944;['appeal is dismissed']
+67485;['dismiss the appeal']
+150944;['appeal is allowed']
+87977;['negative']
+120772;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+52057;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+96333;['allow the appeal']
+98656;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+77301;['appeal is dismissed']
+70175;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+102480;['appeal is dismissed']
+77867;['appeal is allowed']
+77535;['appeal is not allowed']
+89723;['appeal is terminated']
+84599;['dismiss the appeal']
+92967;['appeal is allowed']
+124177;['appeal is allowed']
+84792;['appeal is dismissed']
+109023;['appeal is allowed']
+81129;['appeals are allowed']
+105767;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+36566;['dismiss the appeal']
+102890;['rad confirms that rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+146773;['appeal would be dismissed']
+40478;['appeal is dismissed']
+131231;['appeal isallowed']
+99871;['appeal is allowed']
+107854;['claims are rejected']
+142488;['rpd’s negative determination', 'substituted positive decisions']
+81882;['rpd’s determination must be set aside']
+94769;['appeal isallowed']
+76071;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+149490;['appeal is dismissed']
+115284;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99443;['pc and the mc are not convention refugees']
+95220;['appeal be allowed']
+56887;['appeal isallowed']
+142295;['appeal is dismissed']
+122961;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67227;['refusal is invalid in law']
+91814;"[""rad confirms the rpd's decision that the"", 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses their appeal']"
+77679;['appeal is dismissed']
+85323;['appeal should be allowed']
+109702;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80800;['appeal is dismissed']
+61473;['not provide the notification of agreement']
+122922;['appellant is neither a convention refugee']
+142464;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”']
+151846;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+88164;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+97283;['appeal is allowed']
+93805;['claim is therefore rejected']
+77446;['appeal ofwen ge liis dismissed']
+85382;['sufficient humanitarian and compassion considerations']
+85446;['appeal isallowed']
+71553;['dismiss her appeal']
+61636;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+80245;['negative']
+61364;['appeal is allowed']
+145848;['appeal is allowed']
+124485;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98522;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+87944;['appeal is allowed']
+19724;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74831;['appeal is allowed']
+26736;['appeal allowed']
+85224;['allows the application to reinstate the appeal']
+90648;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+87797;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+26847;['claimants, xxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, are not convention refugees']
+85512;['appeal is dismissed']
+75701;['appeal isallowed']
+17960;['appeal is dismissed']
+132266;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+94221;['302 (c.a.']
+77982;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+89123;['appeal isallowed']
+151962;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+124928;['neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+67231;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+47781;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+89434;['appeal isallowed']
+89579;['appeal is terminated']
+94989;['302 (c.a.)']
+61493;['appeal is dismissed']
+85454;['appeal is not allowed']
+131544;['appeal is dismissed']
+67673;['dismiss this appeal']
+67740;['appeal therefore is dismissed']
+130741;['appeal of hanna lemma beyena is dismissed']
+123330;['appellants have not established their allegations']
+80501;['appeal is allowed']
+10246;['appeal is determined']
+70575;['appeal is dismissed']
+82903;['appeal is allowed']
+98164;['appeal is dismissed']
+56748;['appeal filed by the appellant is therefore dismissed']
+139890;['appeal is allowed']
+85979;['allow the appeal']
+97378;['appeal is allowed']
+69104;['appeal be dismissed']
+153162;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses this appeal']
+35154;['appeal of mariellarey-dimaapiis allowed']
+90095;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+140874;['appeal is allowed']
+32166;['appeal isallowed']
+72776;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+74238;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+100476;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+76906;['appeal isallowed']
+26763;['appeal is dismissed']
+92544;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+123985;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89960;['dismiss this appeal']
+139432;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+95364;['appeal is dismissed']
+116854;['neither convention refugees']
+140993;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123391;['appeal is allowed']
+77658;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+142472;['rad confirms that the rpd did not err', 'appeal is dismissed']
+128575;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+102015;['removal orders are set aside']
+84031;['appeal fails']
+142097;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99057;['rpd’s decision is unreasonable']
+98332;['302 (c.a.)']
+93663;['appeal is allowed']
+151340;['confirm the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83646;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95333;['appeal is allowed']
+95147;['negative decision']
+66308;['appeal is dismissed']
+115283;['appeal is dismissed']
+76320;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+82255;['appeal is dismissed']
+71688;['appeal isallowed']
+104859;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+121386;['302 (c.a.']
+69120;['appeal is allowed']
+92784;['appeal is allowed']
+71223;['appeal is dismissed']
+123402;['rad finds that the rpd did not err in its conclusions']
+141666;['appeal is dismissed']
+61454;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+76396;['appeal is allowed']
+116813;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101231;['appeal is allowed']
+83243;['appeal has been abandoned']
+132649;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+138285;['appeal is allowed']
+89575;['appeal is terminated']
+67404;['appeal isallowed']
+94029;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+81022;['appeal was dismissed']
+93276;['302 (c.a.']
+74459;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+67474;['sufficient compassionate or humanitarian considerations']
+103048;['appeal is allowed']
+84491;['dismiss the appeal']
+84729;['dismiss this appeal']
+123543;['appeal is dismissed']
+100055;['appeal were dismissed']
+60478;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+29151;['appeal isallowed']
+109291;['claimant is neither a “conventionrefugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+71210;['appeal is dismissed']
+92396;['appeal is dismissed']
+142306;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+101178;['appeal is allowed']
+77268;['dismiss this appeal']
+148727;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+49977;['appeal is allowed']
+71407;['appeal of elizabeth begum mukhtar is allowed']
+99722;['appeal of huy hieu nguyen is dismissed']
+116735;['appeal is based']
+58094;['appeal is dismissed']
+128337;['appeal is dismissed']
+136113;['rpd’s negative determination is set aside']
+13696;['appeal is dismissed']
+140934;['appeal is allowed in part']
+72713;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+113276;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+152373;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145433;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+100741;['appeal is dismissed']
+94978;['appeal is dismissed']
+44335;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+93956;['appeal must be dismissed']
+79719;['dismiss the appeal']
+107026;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+13334;['appeal is dismissed']
+46067;['allow the appeal']
+124189;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+58381;['appeal is dismissed']
+105867;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89012;['appeal was dismissed']
+60119;['negative']
+132795;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that these appellants are convention refugees']
+83487;['appeal isallowed']
+16822;['appeal is allowed']
+77955;['appeal of the refusal of his most recent application to sponsor karamjit kaur sangha is dismissed']
+77071;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76946;['appeal isallowed']
+96622;['panel rejects the claim']
+128878;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70039;['appeal ofbulbul islamis dismissed']
+122548;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+45173;['appeal is allowed']
+100428;['appeal isallowed']
+69770;['impediment to sponsorship has been removed']
+94704;['appeal is allowed']
+26960;['claimants, xxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, are not convention refugees']
+71743;['appeal isallowed']
+52741;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97626;['302 (c.a.']
+91602;['302 (c.a.']
+60041;['reject the claimant’s explanations']
+100710;"[""rad cannot confirm or set aside the rpd's determination""]"
+104432;['panel finds the exclusion order pursuant tosection 40(1)(a) of theirpais valid in law']
+77961;['appeal is allowed']
+105883;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+60306;['appeal no longer merits humanitarian and compassionate relief']
+90179;['appeal isallowed']
+102701;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94695;['appeal is dismissed']
+93738;['allegation is therefore not founded']
+81853;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+99766;['appeals of bong hyeon eom, sook hee lee, tae sung eom and tae ho eom are allowed']
+57064;['rad finds the rpd’s rejection of this explanation is sound']
+76765;['appeal is allowed']
+92069;['appeal is terminated']
+56262;['rad finds there are errors in the rpd’s decision']
+68115;['appellantxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee']
+69248;['appeal is allowed']
+70775;['appeal is dismissed']
+73259;['appeal is dismissed']
+95500;['allow the appeal']
+76678;['appeal is allowed']
+99086;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+87963;['appeals are dismissed']
+67927;['appeal must be dismissed']
+71470;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+55124;['appeal isallowed']
+54758;['appeal is allowed']
+52121;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+62897;['appeal of khadra sulaimen hashi is dismissed']
+94539;['appeal is terminated']
+79026;['appeal is dismissed']
+135893;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+34175;['appeal is dismissed']
+123863;['determination of the rpd is set aside', 'substitute my determination that the principal appellant is a refugee']
+127373;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+148627;['removal order is set aside']
+153796;['appeal is allowed']
+106292;['rad has found that the rpd decision will stand']
+149098;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx,a.k.a.']
+94431;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+145812;['appeal was dismissed']
+135161;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+110321;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+92451;['appeal is dismissed']
+123792;['appeal is dismissed']
+107148;['dismiss the appeal']
+98422;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+54714;['appeal is dismissed']
+68258;['allow his appeal']
+68698;['appeal is dismissed']
+87301;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+49583;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98068;['tribunal rejects their claim']
+131056;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+104943;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+94836;['appeal must be dismissed']
+123413;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+100641;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+81582;['appeal is dismissed']
+124074;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+114405;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79214;['terminates his appeal']
+100723;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+77960;['appeal of songlith singthong is dismissed']
+145534;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96971;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+54796;['appeal is dismissed']
+145855;['appeal is allowed']
+122884;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94508;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+87466;['dismiss their claims']
+66488;['appeal is dismissed']
+98216;['appeal is allowed']
+95884;['rpd’s decision to reject the appellant’s refugee claim']
+108118;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are excluded from refugee protection']
+146852;['set aside the rpd’s decision and substitute a positive determination']
+132646;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+57065;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93157;['appeal should be allowed']
+23040;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+81145;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+152782;['favourable decision is issued']
+62991;['appeal isallowed']
+93324;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+141608;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+90330;['negative']
+151793;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+12224;['theappealis dismissed']
+77853;['appeal is allowed']
+53835;['i agree with and accept the recommendation']
+94344;['appeal isallowed']
+82172;['appeal is allowed']
+82180;['appeal isallowed']
+121958;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+70879;['appeal is dismissed']
+98700;['appeal is allowed']
+91369;['appeal is dismissed']
+44098;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+68895;['dismiss the appeal']
+134286;['appeal is allowed']
+141808;['appeal is allowed']
+138832;['appeal to be dismissed']
+22999;['appeal isallowed']
+76075;['appeal is determined']
+67773;['appeal is allowed']
+104081;['appeal is allowed']
+90072;['appeal is allowed']
+85964;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+84276;['appeal is allowed']
+85174;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not “convention refugees”']
+73585;['appeal is dismissed']
+143554;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+65410;['appeal is allowed']
+147612;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80983;['appeal is dismissed']
+123309;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+59370;['appeal is dismissed']
+96286;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+63914;['appeal isallowed']
+93909;['appeal is allowed']
+67247;['appeal should be dismissed']
+80298;['claimants are determined to be convention refugees']
+113547;['appeal is allowed']
+85429;['appeal is allowed']
+81413;['appeal isallowed']
+78642;['appeal isallowed']
+82136;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+124129;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+99265;['refugee protection division excludesxxxxxfor refugee protection']
+100822;['appeal is dismissed']
+124576;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+84798;['dismiss the claim']
+8342;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection\xa0168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+80566;['appeal is allowed']
+140238;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+84325;['appeal is allowed']
+94053;['appeal is terminated']
+145042;['claims are dismissed']
+145351;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+139475;['appeal is dismissed']
+122861;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+103539;['appeal is dismissed']
+71242;['appellant is not a permanent resident ofcanadaand', 'appeal is dismissed']
+105758;['appeal is allowed']
+65661;['appeal is allowed']
+125362;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+88081;['appeal is allowed']
+147831;['appeal is allowed']
+84818;['appeal is dismissed']
+56639;['appeal is dismissed']
+49166;['appeal is dismissed']
+88260;['appeal is dismissed']
+146843;['rpd’s determination is set aside']
+129859;['appeal is allowed']
+95351;['dismissing the appeal']
+81623;['appeal would be dismissed']
+77848;['appeal is allowed']
+105344;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77271;['appeal is dismissed']
+99371;['appeal be allowed']
+107180;['appeal is dismissed']
+67572;['appeal is allowed']
+125459;['appeal is dismissed']
+75900;['appeal is dismissed']
+91421;['appeal is allowed']
+100125;['allow the appeal']
+45191;['appeal is allowed']
+86320;['appeal is dismissed']
+38903;['appeal is allowed']
+140265;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130686;['tribunal declares the appealabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+98117;['appeal is allowed']
+87982;['negative']
+130869;['appeal is allowed']
+61442;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+144551;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+37901;['appeal isallowed']
+38161;['appeal is dismissed']
+86214;['appeal isallowed']
+140634;['panel finds the exclusion order made may 17, 2016 to be legally valid']
+94588;['appeal of lieh-sheng wang is allowed']
+49545;['appeal be dismissed']
+130930;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+90838;['302 (c.a.']
+82684;['appeal is dismissed']
+89967;['appeal is allowed']
+98625;['appeal is allowed']
+65670;['appeal isallowed']
+151751;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+136731;['appeal is dismissed']
+57819;['appeals are allowed']
+96387;['appeal is allowed.the']
+97049;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+144962;['nor am i in a position to dismiss the appeal']
+77258;['appeal is allowed']
+68539;['appeal isallowedand']
+94519;['appeal is allowed']
+94580;['negative']
+86628;['appeal is dismissed']
+18924;['fear to be unfounded']
+102065;['appeal isallowed']
+123981;['appeal is allowed']
+75997;['appeal isallowed']
+87372;['appeal isallowed']
+123684;['uphold the rpd’s findings']
+97558;['appeal is dismissed']
+108780;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85222;['iad is without jurisdiction to hear this appeal']
+52597;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+92691;['appeal is terminated']
+93227;['appeal of lisa tracy-ann watson is allowed']
+82252;['allow this appeal']
+151809;['appeal is dismissed']
+106916;['sponsor may not appeal to the taq against the rejection']
+19148;['appeal is dismissed']
+101459;['appeal is allowed']
+82153;['appeal is dismissed']
+102881;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+36958;['appeal isdismissed.']
+114409;['appeal is allowed']
+129101;['appeal is dismissed']
+58417;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+103088;['appeal is dismissed']
+68371;['appeal is dismissed']
+139795;['appeal will proceed to normal processing']
+131724;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+108083;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99469;['reject his claim']
+106938;['302 (c.a.']
+74239;['appeal isdismissed.']
+90079;['appeal is dismissed']
+91086;['appeal is allowed']
+77979;['allow her appeal']
+47160;['appeal is allowed in law']
+96223;['appeal is dismissed']
+141160;['allow your appeal']
+69247;['appeal isallowed']
+62486;['appeals are dismissed']
+74461;['appeal is allowed']
+64367;['reject those explanations']
+94442;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96913;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees']
+95536;['negative']
+62845;['tribunal dismisses the present appeal']
+98913;['appeal isallowed']
+93059;['appeal is allowed']
+105659;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83485;['appeal is dismissed']
+136722;['appeal is allowed']
+121808;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+107657;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+101418;['302 (c.a.']
+67254;['appeal isallowed']
+69956;['appeal should be dismissed']
+52482;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+90752;['appeal is therefore, dismissed']
+110997;['17 cases were dismissed']
+82453;['appeal is terminated']
+92273;['302 (c.a.']
+76662;['appeal is allowed']
+131222;['appeal is allowed']
+38417;['determination is valid in law']
+140872;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61230;['appeal is allowed']
+99400;['appeal was dismissed']
+56618;['appeal is dismissed']
+143561;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92484;['appeal is allowed']
+82798;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+25984;['appeal is allowed']
+78717;['appeal is dismissed']
+55974;['appeal is terminated']
+32173;['appeal isallowed']
+116735;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+111179;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95767;['appellant is, in fact, a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96707;['appeal is terminated']
+15562;['appeal be dismissed']
+104503;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+47808;['appeal is allowed']
+80234;['negative']
+74522;['removal order isset aside']
+107039;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70411;['dismiss the appeal']
+130752;['appeal is dismissed']
+99140;['appeal is dismissed']
+146888;['appeal is dismissed']
+133347;['appeal is allowed']
+147465;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+135947;['confirm the rpd’s decision']
+153793;['appeal is dismissed']
+39914;['appeal of mawahieb yousif yousif is dismissed']
+118157;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89973;['appeal is allowed']
+102083;['appeal is allowed']
+123469;['appeal is dismissed']
+72577;['case is dismissed']
+54264;['removal order is set aside']
+76622;['appeal is allowed']
+94261;['appellant is an excluded person']
+74867;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+106810;['appeal is allowed']
+17188;['appeal of thi trang ngo is allowed']
+88078;['appeal is allowed']
+107839;['appeal is allowed']
+67605;['appeal isallowed']
+60459;['appeal allowed']
+21938;['appeal is dismissed']
+129246;['appeal is allowed']
+122946;['302 (c.a.']
+105819;['appeal is allowed']
+91566;['dismiss the appeal']
+91742;['appeal is allowed']
+98523;['appeal has not been abandoned']
+88038;['negative']
+64581;['appeal isallowed']
+71730;['appeal is allowed']
+96333;['appeal is allowed']
+45168;['appeal is allowed']
+102446;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+83951;['adoption is accordingly not in the best interests of the child']
+111336;['rad (refugee appeal division) confirms the decision of the rpd']
+148610;['appeal is allowed']
+40652;['appeal is allowed']
+86959;['appeal is allowed']
+61863;['appeal is allowed']
+81619;['appeals are also undermined']
+149013;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+14694;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal be allowed']
+94007;['appeal is allowed']
+106143;['dismiss the minister’s appeal']
+39574;['appeal is allowed']
+99064;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+53137;['appeal is dismissed']
+148623;['appeal is allowed']
+114326;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+118259;['appeal is dismissed']
+98370;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+91709;['dismissal of the appeals']
+95482;['appeal is dismissed']
+102724;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77279;['dismiss the appeal']
+82229;['appeal was dismissed']
+90480;['appeal is dismissed']
+73276;['appeal is dismissed']
+80006;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124066;['appeal is dismissed']
+96178;['appeals are dismissed']
+99101;['appeal dismissed']
+121521;['appeals are dismissed']
+70663;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+108680;['appeal of iouri chtchelkanov is dismissed']
+94010;['appeal is allowed']
+69660;['appeal is allowed']
+17191;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+72577;['appeal was dismissed']
+150848;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+100641;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+57039;['appeal is dismissed']
+60978;['appeal isallowed']
+82870;['appeal is allowed']
+26791;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+48292;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a claim for refugee protection']
+66933;['appeal isallowed']
+31420;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+57475;['appeal is determined']
+83456;['application is allowed']
+90835;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76455;['appeal is allowed']
+105173;['appeal is allowed']
+139862;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124823;['adopt the rpd reasons in paragraph 9']
+92249;['appeal is allowed']
+98652;['negative']
+74631;['appeal is allowed']
+26487;['appeal isallowed']
+143640;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their appeal']
+71091;['appeal is dismissed']
+106815;['appeal isdeterminedto be']
+84470;['appeal is terminated']
+98455;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+70941;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law', 'appeal is allowed in law']
+102156;['appeal is dismissed']
+74799;['appeal isallowed']
+20004;['determination is valid in law']
+107202;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+101327;['appeal isallowed']
+135210;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132755;['302 (c.a.']
+57301;['appeal is dismissed']
+99269;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98348;['appeal is dismissed']
+65679;['appeal isallowed']
+98997;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+107814;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+88030;['appeal is allowed']
+92094;['appeal is dismissed']
+76341;['appeal is allowed']
+125052;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+62709;['appeal is dismissed']
+84611;['appeal is dismissed']
+46546;['302 (c.a.)']
+112362;['appeal is dismissed']
+76063;['appeal is allowed']
+98163;['appeal ofsanaa el houkmiis allowed']
+69180;['appeal is allowed']
+91527;['allows this appeal']
+124201;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+77121;['appeal isallowed']
+63520;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+19153;['dismiss the present appeal']
+84370;['appeal is allowed']
+96355;['appeal is dismissed']
+90953;['appeal is dismissed']
+53833;['appeals of noe aguilar and aida esmeralda de la o. de aguilar are dismissed']
+94013;['appeal is allowed']
+122241;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+69512;['application is denied']
+28160;['appeal isallowed']
+55005;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+71604;['appeal is dismissed']
+14683;['not convention refugees']
+64870;['appeal is allowed']
+82876;['appeal is dismissed']
+100246;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98103;['panel rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+26774;['appeal is allowed in law']
+38868;['appeal is allowed', 'visa officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+107168;['dismisses the appeal']
+80740;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+81088;['appeal is dismissed']
+98325;['appeal is granted']
+49520;['appeal is dismissed']
+99058;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144042;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81223;['appeal is dismissed']
+27743;['appeal is dismissed']
+24464;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74612;['appeal is allowed']
+133259;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+73252;['appeal is dismissed']
+78192;['appeal is dismissed']
+93885;['appeal is allowed']
+121447;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees']
+145230;['appeal is allowed']
+83521;['appeals are dismissed']
+64029;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+48614;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+44176;['appeal is dismissed']
+141310;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of therpdthat theappellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98559;['appeal is allowed']
+69436;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+124706;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+94976;['appeal is allowed']
+107884;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84277;['appeal is dismissed']
+121221;['appeal is dismissed']
+142789;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+102997;['appeal is allowed']
+152822;['departure order isset aside']
+88316;['appeal isallowed']
+64255;['panel finds that the immigration officer’s decision is valid']
+80123;['appeal isallowedand']
+83180;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+100270;['appeal is allowed']
+139681;['appeal is dismissed']
+74045;['appeal is allowed']
+111041;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143407;['appeal is allowed']
+71791;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+87166;['appeal is dismissed']
+77557;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+71471;['appeal is allowed']
+98966;['appeal is dismissed']
+130706;['appealis allowed']
+102753;['appeal is allowed']
+125017;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102126;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+109628;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+27219;['appeal is allowed']
+84053;['appeal was dismissed']
+90616;['appeal is dismissed']
+86194;['appeal isallowed']
+123043;['appeal is allowed']
+45156;['allow this appeal']
+92513;['appeal is dismissed']
+101289;['appeal is allowed']
+96905;['rad allows the appeal']
+56800;['xxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+140858;['appellants are convention refugees']
+123317;['appeal is allowed']
+115285;['appeal is allowed']
+63809;['rejects her claim']
+99606;['iad declines to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction']
+125040;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+40129;['appeal is allowed']
+105349;['claim is therefore rejected']
+76621;['appeal is allowed']
+88970;['appeal is dismissed']
+113217;['appeal is allowed']
+114354;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+82708;['visa officer’s decision is set aside']
+50455;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+38388;['appeals must therefore fail']
+116130;['appeal is allowed']
+140865;['rad rejects this argument']
+43749;['appeal is dismissed']
+109016;['appeal be dismissed']
+134279;['appeal is dismissed']
+110045;['appeal is dismissed']
+85628;['appeal is terminated']
+143860;['appeal is allowed']
+8291;['appeal is dismissed']
+68366;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+59944;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101547;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47605;['appeal is dismissed']
+98951;['appeal was not declared abandoned']
+68280;['appeal isallowed']
+60923;['dismissing the appeal']
+71674;['appeal isallowedand']
+76936;['dismiss the application']
+40804;['rad finds that']
+101438;['appeal is allowed']
+69238;['appeal is dismissed']
+57539;['appeal of christoph aregger and ines aregger is dismissed']
+72849;['appeal is allowed']
+148716;['claims are rejected']
+31415;['appeal is allowed']
+63878;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+30378;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101660;['appeal is allowed']
+89123;['appeal is allowed']
+124412;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+90194;['negative']
+130970;['appellant is not a wanted person']
+101671;['appeal were dismissed']
+144028;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+129250;['decision is legally valid']
+71567;['appeal is allowed']
+145424;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+98303;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+37417;['appeal was dismissed']
+101194;['appeal is dismissed']
+68697;['appeal is allowed.the']
+123674;['302 (c.a.']
+140865;['rad rejects the appellants’ submissions']
+54819;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59027;['appeal isallowed']
+123979;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122982;['rad allows the appeal']
+97121;['appeal is allowed']
+72696;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+102407;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+135109;['appeal is allowed']
+99425;['application for leave\xa0 /\xa0 dismissed']
+124800;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is aconventionrefugee']
+98267;['appeal is dismissed']
+19248;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101717;['appeal isallowed']
+109705;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+23026;['appeal is allowed']
+107840;['appeal is allowed']
+52933;['appeal is allowed']
+134178;['appeal were dismissed']
+77599;['appeal is allowed']
+48418;['appeal is dismissed']
+44212;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67626;['appeal is allowed']
+21335;['not a convention refugee']
+57951;['appeal is dismissed']
+131522;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95103;['negative']
+23015;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+104400;['appeal is allowed']
+78180;['order is upheld']
+100254;['appeal is allowed']
+77484;['appeal isallowed']
+76775;['appeal is allowed']
+88305;['cancel the stay of removal', 'allow the appellant’s appeal']
+90360;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+74219;['rad dismissed the appeal', 'upheld the decision of the rpd']
+133408;['appeal is dismissed']
+84661;['appeal is allowed']
+122990;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+99588;['appeal is allowed']
+139439;['appeal were dismissed']
+103025;['rpd’s determination must be set aside']
+81883;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,are not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+134422;['appeal be dismissed']
+70657;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+80199;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+97421;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94138;['appeal is dismissed']
+140728;['appeal must be dismissed']
+100750;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+122980;['appeal is allowed']
+54641;['appeal of gurjit singh kamow and sarbjeet kaur kamow is dismissed']
+99634;['appeal is allowed']
+78298;['removal order is set aside']
+91669;['appeal is allowed']
+88446;['claimant,xxxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+87996;['he is not a convention refugee']
+104071;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+64240;['appeal is terminated']
+17935;['appeal beallowed']
+80192;['her claim fails']
+49135;['appeal is dismissed']
+88423;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects the claims for refugee protection']
+129123;['dismissing the appeal']
+43329;['appeal is dismissed']
+96325;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+108819;['panel therefore rejects the claims']
+100298;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+85240;['appeal is dismissed']
+101210;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87973;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+67447;['appeal is dismissed']
+142809;['substituted a positive decision']
+98455;['application to reopen should be dismissed']
+63190;['appeal is allowed']
+100888;['appeal is dismissed']
+95378;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+143999;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78289;['appeal is dismissed']
+107796;['panel rejects the refugee protection claims']
+132279;['appeal is allowed']
+123972;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+113557;['appeal is allowed']
+140242;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+78767;['appeal is dismissed']
+9682;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+122981;['set aside the rpd’s negative determination', 'substitute a positive decision']
+90911;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+101274;['appeal is allowed']
+38418;['determination is valid in law']
+144406;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97611;['appeal is allowed']
+76371;['appeal is allowed']
+37495;['iad does not have jurisdiction to review or return this decision to them']
+65414;['appeal is allowed', 'decision of the id is set aside']
+57731;['appeal is dismissed']
+93893;['appeal is dismissed']
+75598;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+121862;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not refugees']
+76244;['negative']
+81244;['appeal be dismissed']
+99580;['appeal is allowed']
+146967;['appeal is dismissed']
+80290;['negative']
+98563;['appeal is dismissed']
+98090;['negative']
+69324;['appeal isallowed']
+101210;['appeal is dismissed']
+113624;['appeal is dismissed']
+139455;['appeal is allowed']
+148660;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+79217;['iad is without jurisdiction to hear this appeal']
+33315;['appeal is allowed']
+59374;['appeal is allowed']
+89700;['claim is denied']
+19721;['appeal is dismissed']
+139888;['appeal of kui tong is dismissed']
+97638;['refugee protection claims filed byxxxx']
+108762;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+86542;['appeal is allowed']
+131226;['appeal will be dismissed']
+87328;['appeal is not granted']
+95642;['appeal is terminated']
+93320;['appeal should be dismissed']
+146771;['appeal is allowed']
+5143;['appeal should be dismissed']
+13554;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+87127;['appeal is allowed']
+74101;['xxxx family are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+140071;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+87516;['appeal is dismissed']
+94084;['appeal is dismissed']
+47783;['appeal is dismissed']
+131531;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+64592;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26689;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+109015;['appeal is dismissed']
+101363;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+97772;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+96739;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+107194;['nor a person in need of protection']
+101706;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84488;['appeal is allowed']
+129233;['appeal is allowed']
+60198;['appeal isallowed']
+97505;['claimant is determined to be neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122990;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+90041;['appeal fails']
+38866;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89870;['appeal of yan rong si tu is dismissed']
+72193;['appeal isallowed']
+69567;['dismiss this appeal']
+128301;['appeal dismissed']
+69462;['appeal is allowed']
+110678;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+66771;['appeal is dismissed']
+88331;['appellants are excluded by section e of article 1 of the convention']
+60021;['negative']
+100040;['refugee protection claimantxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'not a “person in need of protection']
+77451;['appeal is allowed']
+94144;['appeal is dismissed']
+89251;['appeal must be dismissed']
+96620;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95681;['appeal is allowed']
+146543;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+65131;['dismiss it for lack of jurisdiction']
+98294;['negative']
+82732;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+99932;['appeal is allowed']
+101060;['appeal is allowed']
+142898;['rad rendered a split decision']
+94757;['tribunal rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+100824;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+52352;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+99913;['appeal is dismissed']
+61477;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+124736;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+23062;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+127448;['appeal of augustine edewede ighekpe is allowed']
+144931;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98909;['panel allows the appeal', 'sets aside the removal order.']
+125328;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee undersection 96ofirpanor a person in need of protection']
+87100;['appeal is allowed']
+21077;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+83443;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+19232;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+114293;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+93873;['appeal is dismissed']
+148618;['appeal is allowed']
+31226;['application to re-open the appeal of parminder kaur dhaliwal (narwal) is denied']
+105850;['appeal is dismissed']
+102733;"['thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are ""convention refugees']"
+142513;['appeal is allowed']
+131100;['appeal is allowed']
+123374;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+131165;['appeal is terminated']
+100400;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+69376;['appeal is allowed']
+30500;['appeal is dismissed']
+143501;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+105882;['the claim fails']
+108879;['panel, therefore, rejects his claim']
+106789;['appeal isallowed']
+111359;['302 (c.a.']
+60419;['appeal is allowed']
+120776;['appeal is allowed']
+60117;['negative']
+132295;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90537;['appeal is allowed']
+84072;['appeal is abandoned']
+122244;['appeal is allowed']
+69801;['appeal is dismissed']
+102730;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+124568;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94551;['tribunal rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+126398;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133187;['appeal is dismissed']
+113287;['leads me to conclude that he entered the marriage']
+57560;['appeal of tomasz w. krazon is allowed']
+96478;['appeals are allowed']
+64591;['panel finds the exclusion order is legally valid']
+145345;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+102960;['appeal is dismissed']
+107821;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+78699;['appeal isallowed']
+85246;['appeal is allowed']
+105206;['appeal is allowed']
+123664;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69654;['appeal is determined']
+113216;['appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx,is a convention refugee']
+52053;['appeal is allowed']
+124535;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70463;['dismiss this appeal']
+131177;['appeal is not allowed']
+95970;['appellant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+90078;['appeal isallowed']
+95226;['appeal is dismissed']
+102148;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+93308;['appeal is dismissed']
+100886;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+149151;['application for an extension of time is denied']
+133734;['appellants are convention refugees']
+147453;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+96822;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in needofprotection']
+99434;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the', 'respondent is neither a conventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100861;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+145426;['appeal is allowed']
+107194;['rad rejects this explanation']
+13565;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57546;['appeal of rabeya akther is dismissed']
+146447;['rad agrees with the finding of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+145823;['appeal is allowed']
+90241;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+61637;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+91933;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'panel therefore rejects her refugee protection claim']
+50506;['appeal is dismissed']
+74164;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+150675;['cia, september\xa010, 2020']
+82220;['appeal is allowed']
+98462;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71424;['appeal is dismissed']
+135908;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee']
+40775;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+96216;['appeal is allowed']
+28087;['appeal is dismissed']
+113545;['appeal is dismissed']
+132805;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26841;['appeal is allowed']
+26847;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+114411;['appeal is allowed']
+40157;['removal order is set aside']
+71747;['appeal is abandoned']
+94345;['appeal is allowed']
+107628;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60701;['dismiss this appeal']
+110917;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113596;['appeal be dismissed']
+65299;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+96017;['appeal is terminated']
+96519;['appeal is dismissed']
+130687;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140721;['rad finds the rpd decision must be set aside']
+116751;['rad finds that the rpd correctly applied the jg']
+110285;['appeal is dismissed']
+79689;['appeal be dismissed']
+103714;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+64231;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+61018;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+69622;['appeal isallowed']
+28159;['appeal isallowed']
+67432;['appeal isallowed']
+101801;['appeal isallowed']
+106292;['appeal is dismissed']
+136717;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+67562;['appeal dismissed']
+79223;['appeal isterminated']
+82393;['appeal isallowed']
+142298;['appeal is allowed.the']
+54710;['appeal is dismissed']
+57827;['appeal in respect to abiodun is dismissed']
+87962;['appeal is dismissed']
+70190;['appeal is allowed']
+145386;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+125575;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82075;['appeal is allowed']
+88056;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60970;['appeal is dismissed']
+87320;['neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+100805;['appeal isallowed']
+74627;['appeal isallowed.the']
+95208;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+83868;['appeal is allowed']
+97516;['“convention refugees”']
+125484;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+133382;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79984;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+92239;['appeal is allowed']
+109275;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+101461;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+63732;['appeal is dismissed']
+146843;['appeal is allowed']
+64841;['appeal is dismissed']
+100934;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+124178;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68103;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+70883;['appeals of xiao qiang chen, xiao bo liu, and si cong chen are dismissed']
+61911;['decision is legally valid']
+28284;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69947;['appeal is dismissed']
+99475;['302 (c.a.']
+114385;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+47807;['appeal isallowed']
+70091;['appeal should be and is allowed']
+44210;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91160;['appeal is allowed']
+143922;['appellants were neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+117111;['appeal is dismissed']
+130995;['they are therefore not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+107155;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+98516;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+97917;['appeal isallowedand']
+102088;['panel finds the exclusion order made october 18, 2017 to be legally valid']
+47099;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+89403;['appeal isallowed']
+126734;['appeal were dismissed']
+124319;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neitherconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99331;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90766;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+54752;['appeal is allowed']
+46076;['appeal was thus to proceed to final reconsideration']
+82883;['302 (c.a.']
+110930;['appeal is dismissed']
+93085;['they are not convention refugees']
+74245;['appeal isallowed.the']
+38391;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63871;['appeal isallowed']
+82706;['appeal isallowed']
+91358;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+63567;['appeal of jagpal singh saran is therefore dismissed']
+58128;['appeals are   ']
+60109;['appeal of ceres macoy yurkiw is dismissed']
+98651;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+102900;['appeal is allowed']
+78058;['appeal is allowed']
+132737;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+98287;['appeal is terminated']
+68345;['appeal be dismissed']
+82217;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+40298;['appeal is dismissed']
+27245;['appeal isallowed']
+150257;['appeal is allowed']
+44859;['appeal is dismissed']
+100307;['board therefore rejects their claims']
+98519;['appeal isallowedand']
+52765;['appeal of deng malith jok deng is dismissed']
+93804;['not a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+97260;['panel rejects the present claims']
+99799;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+67179;['dismiss this appeal']
+90662;['“convention refugees”', 'refugee protection claim is rejected']
+79627;['appeal is dismissed']
+89420;['appeal allowed']
+59935;['panel rejects the claim ofxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (a.k.a.xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx)']
+116782;['appeal is dismissed']
+65621;['dismiss his appeal']
+84604;['appeal be dismissed']
+81267;['appeal is dismissed']
+89023;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+99594;['panel finds the refusal to be valid in law']
+58099;['appeal isallowed']
+37836;['appeal is allowed.the']
+124970;['302 (c.a.']
+98718;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+31973;['appeal is allowed']
+57528;['appeal is determined']
+70403;['dismiss the appeal']
+101014;['tense is implied']
+91231;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+88504;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+71399;['dismiss this appeal']
+75920;['appeal iswithdrawnconcerningrajinder singh chuhan']
+146882;['rad allows the appeal']
+52501;['appeal is allowed']
+94830;['appeal is allowed']
+135891;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee']
+28045;['appeal is dismissed']
+125518;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95966;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86899;['appeal is allowed']
+21459;['xxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+85871;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+85387;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+90240;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxx is also not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+66630;['appeal is allowed']
+95112;['302 (c.a.)']
+65681;['appeal is allowed in law']
+103638;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+142827;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+56912;['appeal is allowed']
+38388;['appeals are dismissed']
+148520;"[""al-sama'neh.""]"
+108208;['rad disagrees']
+27219;['appeal isallowed']
+106782;['appeal is determined']
+80980;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+98566;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+128636;['appeal is dismissed']
+52267;['appeal is allowed in law']
+132722;['302 (c.a.']
+83381;['appeal must fail']
+76772;['appeal is allowed']
+84641;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91154;['appeal is allowed']
+91331;['case is dismissed']
+26488;['302 (c.a.)']
+51124;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+96863;['allow the appeal']
+19116;['appeal is dismissed']
+95109;['appeal is dismissed']
+143180;['302 (c.a.']
+95316;['appeal is allowed']
+86452;['appeal of wai cheng is dismissed']
+82702;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83294;['appeal is dismissed']
+22713;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+63001;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+85946;['appeal is allowed']
+98721;['302 (c.a.']
+95638;['appeal is allowed']
+74515;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+43138;['appeal isallowed']
+97652;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+80735;['claimant is not aconvention refugee']
+97462;['refugee protection claim']
+60429;['appeal pertaining to thi hong nhung vu is dismissed']
+50453;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination in part', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare', '“convention refugees”']
+59734;['appeal is allowed']
+61052;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+146101;['rad finds that the']
+35553;['dismiss the appeal']
+51757;['allows the appeal']
+42297;['appeal is dismissed']
+35811;['theappealis dismissed']
+122550;['xxxx xxxx xxxx to be inadmissible']
+71147;['appeal is allowed']
+96937;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100355;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96948;['rad allows the appeal']
+95653;['appeal is dismissed']
+57740;['appeal isallowed']
+95599;['appeal is dismissed']
+131146;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+105600;['302 (c.a.']
+88415;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+131729;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+96312;['appeals were dismissed']
+15664;['appeal is dismissed']
+107263;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+88103;['appeal is dismissed']
+33315;['appeal is allowed']
+80773;['appeal is dismissed']
+125052;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+46511;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+144550;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+26735;['appeal is dismissed']
+76836;['appeal isallowed']
+93785;['appeal is allowed']
+87322;['appeal is allowed']
+54303;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+9484;['appeal is dismissed']
+143151;['302 (c.a.']
+89317;['refugee protection division rejects the claim ofxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxfor refugee protection']
+75141;['appeal is allowed']
+121942;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+96343;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+95586;['appeal is terminated']
+118734;['appeal is dismissed']
+148721;['refugee protection division rejects these claims']
+59023;['appeals of samir al-saffar and mohamed samir al-saffar are dismissed']
+118640;['allow the appeal']
+108119;['appellant is not excluded from consideration of her refugee claim']
+98421;['appeals of larbiel houkmi and nadia el houkmi are allowed']
+105316;['appeal be dismissed']
+106150;['appeal is dismissed']
+100364;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+93910;['appeal is dismissed']
+104972;['appeal is allowed']
+79880;['appeal is dismissed']
+77570;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+54268;['dismissal of this appeal']
+123985;['rad agrees with the rpd’s conclusion']
+101264;['appeal abandoned']
+74817;['appeal is dismissed']
+98430;['302 (c.a.']
+74865;['appeal is allowed']
+67628;['appeal isallowed']
+79236;['appeal is dismissed']
+97405;['negative']
+132773;['rad dismissesxxxx xxxx xxxxappeal', 'confirms the determination']
+124492;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+129735;['appeal be dismissed']
+60365;['appeal is terminated']
+103890;['appeal is dismissed']
+76551;['appeal isdismissed.']
+79466;['appeal isallowed']
+89361;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+103026;['302 (c.a.)']
+36129;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+107318;['board therefore rejects each of their claims']
+144959;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88403;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+125050;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93634;['appeal isallowed']
+132436;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+92737;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95518;['appeal is allowed']
+90082;['appeal is terminated']
+110297;['appeal is dismissed']
+38247;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+46452;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'ms. xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+104347;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+87865;['negative']
+131154;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+106406;['appeal is dismissed']
+146072;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+91355;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+128375;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+106292;['appellants are not protected persons or convention refugees']
+77795;['negative']
+70650;['appeal isdismissed.']
+18927;['appeal is dismissed']
+93674;['appeal is dismissed']
+141607;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+118231;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+125631;['appeal is allowed']
+80232;['negative']
+140875;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95895;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59916;['appeal is allowed']
+76895;['dismiss the appeal']
+88502;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+84711;['appeal is allowed.the']
+87150;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+61039;['appeal of malyisa rochelle calvin is allowed']
+31931;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60052;['appeal isallowed']
+99954;['appeal is allowed']
+58308;['appeal is dismissed']
+90773;['claim is dismissed']
+140898;['appellants are convention refugees']
+71051;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+105646;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+92157;['appeal is allowed']
+52373;['appeal isallowed.the']
+148748;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxx xxxxis rejected']
+76859;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+60652;['theappealis allowed']
+75616;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+135942;['appeal is allowed']
+124012;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+28018;['dismisses the appeal']
+91618;['appeal is allowed']
+118199;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76896;['302 (c.a.']
+13966;['appeal is dismissed']
+46279;['appeal must be dismissed']
+100366;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+65195;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+106341;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88418;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+114420;['appellants are excluded from protection']
+129937;['appeal isallowed']
+69106;['appeal of sarmukh singh sangha is dismissed']
+144004;['rad rejects this argument']
+54023;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+89299;['appeal is dismissed']
+94249;['appeal is dismissed']
+88255;['appeal is dismissed']
+47134;['appeal is dismissed']
+140948;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+140288;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102709;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+98451;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96440;['appeal were dismissed']
+72155;['dismiss the application to reopen']
+99102;['appeal isallowedand']
+108757;['claimant is not a refugee']
+89827;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123817;['ifa fails']
+84027;['appeal is allowed']
+100794;['appeal is allowed']
+100803;['appeal is allowed']
+89559;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+122240;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+143598;['appellants are convention refugees']
+144250;['appellant is not a refugee or a person']
+92251;['appeal isallowed']
+101706;['appeal is allowed']
+75902;['dismiss your appeal', 'appeal is dismissed']
+90242;['claimant, xxx xxxx xxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46526;['appeal is allowed']
+87153;['appeal isallowed']
+108048;['appeal is allowed']
+97325;['302 (c.a.)']
+92540;['appeal is allowed']
+128597;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+102997;['appeal isallowed']
+77067;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+132637;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+43722;['appeal of mieczyslaw herba is dismissed']
+146942;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121937;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69653;['appeal is allowed']
+102432;['appeal is allowed']
+110982;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+49076;['appeal is allowed']
+71135;['appeal is allowed']
+126394;['appeal is dismissed']
+73300;['appeal isallowed']
+131716;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62009;['appeal was dismissed']
+88344;['dismisses the appeal']
+69400;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+31995;['appeal is dismissed']
+56935;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+54208;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+18011;['appeal was dismissed']
+99315;['appeal be dismissed']
+87864;['appeal will be dismissed']
+101471;['appeal isallowed.the']
+120802;['appeal is allowed']
+54757;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+92545;['appeal should be allowed']
+63611;['negative']
+91310;['appeal is allowed']
+107917;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made']
+70997;['decision under appeal']
+61351;['ms. mushtaq is inadmissible for financial reasons']
+72713;['appeals are allowed']
+92397;['declare these appeals abandoned']
+29724;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+69350;['dismiss this appeal']
+76571;['appellant’s appeal is dismissed']
+144039;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+153056;['rostov-on-don, russia']
+124455;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97625;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+101337;['appeal is allowed']
+55200;['reject his claim']
+97391;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+26730;['appeal bedismissed.']
+98550;['appeal is allowed']
+138832;['appeal isallowed']
+120797;['appeal is allowed']
+99288;['refugee appeal division', 'confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78674;['appeal is allowed']
+120863;['appeal is allowed']
+89158;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+70377;['appeal is dismissed']
+151524;['appeal is dismissed']
+51714;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+125591;['rpd’s decision is upheld']
+146605;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140720;['reject the appellants’ argument']
+61293;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+96654;['not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person']
+45426;['appeal is dismissed']
+52125;['appeal is dismissed']
+67250;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+90177;['appeal isallowed']
+100690;['appeal isallowed']
+139439;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+34959;['appeal isallowed']
+31935;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+132370;['appeal is dismissed']
+113237;['appeal is dismissed']
+97219;['appeal is therefore allowed in law']
+98315;['appeal will be dismissed']
+84790;['appeal is dismissed']
+47826;['appeal is dismissed']
+18922;['appeals are dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76015;['appeal of raymond duc hanh lam is allowed']
+134285;['appeal is dismissed']
+107179;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108777;['appeals are dismissed']
+99149;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+109696;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+37403;['appeal being allowed']
+88084;['panel finds the refusal is valid in law']
+96807;['appellants were not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71283;['appeal is determined']
+86350;['appeal is determined']
+73051;['appeal is allowed']
+89095;['302 (c.a.']
+21383;"['claimant xxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a ""convention refugee""within']"
+27475;['appeal isallowed']
+134180;['appeal is dismissed']
+100776;['appeal be dismissed']
+67578;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate reasons']
+69481;['two appeals are dismissed']
+79971;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+102036;['appeal isallowed']
+88418;['reject their claims']
+127909;['xxxx, and xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees or a persons in need of protection']
+85238;['appeal isallowed']
+123790;['rad agrees with the rpd']
+31992;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+48417;['appeal is allowed']
+149179;['appeal is dismissed']
+95074;['application is granted']
+101261;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a person in need of protectionandxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+138804;['decision is well-founded in law']
+136684;['rad can neither confirm nor set aside the rpd’s determination']
+124035;['appeal will be dismissed']
+56900;['appeal fails']
+65420;['appeal of cheng-hsin yao is dismissed']
+92737;['appeal is allowed']
+89239;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+105620;['appeal isallowed']
+141610;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+60926;['appeal is not within the competent jurisdiction', 'appeal is dismissed']
+98706;['302 (c.a.']
+75588;['appeal isallowed']
+58420;['determination is valid in law']
+77025;['appeal is dismissed']
+99021;['thepanel finds the removal order valid in law']
+90618;['appeals are dismissed']
+66767;['appeal, however, fails']
+128547;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97340;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+82390;['appeal is dismissed']
+99749;['appeal is dismissed']
+76850;['appeal fails']
+100755;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+100391;['refugee appeal division\xa0(rad) dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147623;['302 (c.a.']
+123378;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+145138;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+44739;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+124093;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+82230;['appeal is dismissed']
+89120;['refugee protection claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+63079;['claimants are intelligent people']
+88129;['appeal is allowed']
+121411;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare “convention refugees”']
+124540;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146108;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+40146;['appeal is dismissed']
+87736;['appeal is allowed']
+133723;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+102888;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+73210;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+64235;['appeal isallowedand']
+95973;['thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+129392;['rpd’s negative decision is set aside']
+86056;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67717;['appeal is dismissed']
+125432;['appeals are allowed']
+128179;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+87347;['removal order is set aside']
+69991;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+89782;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+39576;['appeal is abandoned']
+128615;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+104095;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+81585;['appeal is dismissed']
+72180;['appeals ofcarmelo santiago alcantara iiandcesar rafael santiago alcantaraareallowed.the decision of the officer made outside ofcanadaon the appellants’ residency obligation']
+108723;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+50758;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71434;['appeal is allowed']
+140258;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101237;['appeal should not be dismissed']
+98309;['appeal isallowed']
+131912;['application to reopen the appeal is granted']
+99509;['appeal is allowed']
+108753;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+47102;['appeal is dismissed']
+84813;['appeal is allowed']
+134328;['appeal is dismissed']
+27249;['appeal is dismissed']
+72823;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+145535;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+49070;['appeal will be allowed']
+87201;['appeal is dismissed']
+94773;['appeal being allowed']
+56923;['appeal isallowed']
+90129;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+94202;['appeal is dismissed']
+52921;['appeal is allowed']
+90908;['appeal is dismissed']
+40136;['appeal by dismissed']
+51766;['appeal is allowed']
+70899;['appeal is allowed']
+105909;['appeal is allowed']
+105560;['appeal is allowed']
+59044;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+149067;['appeals are dismissed']
+84190;['appeal is dismissed']
+90926;['appeal is dismissed']
+50745;['appeal is allowed']
+105861;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+90973;['appeal isallowed']
+112353;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26892;['claimant, ms. xxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+107131;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+143473;['302 (c.a.']
+141790;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77864;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105318;['appeal is allowed']
+100003;['appeal be allowed']
+150703;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+127702;['appeal is not allowed']
+85486;['appeal is dismissed']
+85395;['appeal isallowed']
+99179;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+100466;['appeal is dismissed']
+71067;['negative']
+84660;['appeal isallowed']
+98895;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+75934;['claimant is not aconvention refugee']
+21105;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+128402;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+127414;['appeal is allowed']
+89324;['appeal is terminated']
+94068;['appeal is dismissed']
+97821;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+127374;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70656;['appeal is terminated']
+56708;['allow the appeal']
+96861;['appeal is dismissed']
+60413;['id decision is set aside']
+76025;['appeal isallowed']
+101160;['dismisses the appeal']
+98271;['appeal were dismissed']
+152010;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+132440;['claimants, are not “convention refugees”']
+83085;['appeal should be dismissed']
+106471;['appeal is dismissed']
+35720;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+37868;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+90930;['appeals are dismissed']
+87015;['appeal is dismissed']
+93473;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'claim is therefore rejected']
+98565;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+68902;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125205;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123448;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+79226;['appeal is dismissed']
+114431;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+80576;['reject her claim']
+109025;['appeal is terminated']
+38382;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+91583;['appeal is allowed']
+124924;['decision is upheld']
+105778;['302 (c.a.']
+77620;['appeal is dismissed']
+60930;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+61019;['appeal division allows the appeal']
+12228;['appeal is dismissed']
+35126;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+75258;['appeal is allowed']
+61379;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+102022;['appeal is determined']
+47733;['submission therefore fails']
+49632;['appeal is allowed']
+120759;['appeal is allowed']
+94107;['appeal is allowed']
+108728;['appellant’s argument fails']
+101314;['stay is set aside']
+152137;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+143636;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100494;['302 (c.a.']
+96998;['appeal isallowed']
+123270;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+36463;['…]»']
+111327;['appeal is allowed']
+91744;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+151527;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99133;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+92532;['appeal isallowed']
+96439;['appeals are dismissed']
+75258;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98921;['negative']
+43735;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95129;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+22678;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+27517;['appeals are dismissed']
+82731;['appeal isdismissedbecause the']
+103724;['reject these claims for refugee protection', 'claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+88035;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+81072;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+58117;['decision is well founded in law']
+132833;['appeal is allowed']
+82176;['appeal is determined']
+71640;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+62455;['appeal is allowed']
+87851;['appeal is dismissed']
+63917;['sponsor are a genuine couple']
+93069;['rad finds the rpd’s conclusions']
+80748;['appeal is allowed']
+79726;['appeal is dismissed']
+26825;['xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+49162;['appeal is allowed']
+46997;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101470;['302 (c.a.']
+90923;['rad concurs with the rpd’s conclusion']
+110992;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91697;['appeal is dismissed']
+34943;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination']
+85860;['claimants not to be convention refugees and not to be persons in need of protection']
+99297;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101410;['appeal is allowed']
+50525;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+89814;['302 (c.a.']
+83502;['appeal is abandoned']
+61016;['claimant’s claim fails']
+69279;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+74728;['appeal isallowed']
+100123;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+100462;['appeal is dismissed']
+69733;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+84146;['302 (c.a.)']
+76799;['appeal is allowed']
+91173;['appeal is allowed']
+69187;['appeal is allowed']
+95034;['appeal is dismissed']
+90254;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+133369;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+90049;['appeal is allowed']
+136664;['appeal is allowed']
+69184;['appeal may still fail']
+71685;['appeal is allowed']
+122122;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98720;['appeal is dismissed']
+115225;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+88975;['appeal is allowed']
+143544;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95176;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+60082;['negative']
+59179;['appeal is dismissed']
+95939;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+117201;['appeal is dismissed']
+24498;['appeal is allowed']
+106871;['appeal isallowed']
+133381;['appeal is allowed']
+43379;['302 (c.a.)']
+104511;['application is allowed']
+47776;['allow the appeal']
+98063;['appeal isallowed']
+103753;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+46000;['appeal is allowed']
+100092;['constitution guarantees freedom of religion']
+133717;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+142805;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97920;['appeal isallowedand']
+51743;['appeal is dismissed']
+140066;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98167;['appeal is allowed']
+44859;['appeal is dismissed']
+91093;['dismiss the appeal']
+69397;['negative']
+105706;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+65413;['appeal is dismissed']
+102429;['appeal is allowed']
+82180;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94278;['302 (c.a.)']
+96062;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86457;['appeal is allowed']
+94453;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54782;['appeal is allowed']
+92112;['appeal isallowed']
+132633;['rpd’s negative determination is confirmed']
+85308;['appeal is terminated']
+87792;['appeal is dismissed']
+77962;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+97362;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+90004;['appeal isallowed']
+144903;['not allow this application']
+66203;['appeal is allowed']
+83149;['appeal is allowed.the']
+81149;['appeal is dismissed']
+54322;['tribunal is independent']
+96923;['xxxxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+113617;['appeal is dismissed']
+143496;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+60384;['appeal is dismissed']
+128291;['appeal of duaa remman is allowed']
+90647;['appeal is dismissed']
+122819;['appeal is allowed']
+31045;['appeal is allowed']
+84601;['appeal is dismissed']
+95004;['appeal is allowed']
+76362;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+146710;['appeal is dismissed']
+147433;['uphold the rpd’s overall']
+47568;['appeal is allowed']
+110972;['appeal is dismissed']
+75556;['appeal is allowed']
+87428;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+84523;['appeals of gurcharan singh brar, baljit singh brar, kartar kaur brar and veerpal kaur brar are allowed']
+90784;['appeal is dismissed']
+39056;['appeal is dismissed']
+96432;['appeal is dismissed']
+35053;['appeal is allowed']
+100987;['rules cannot supersede theact']
+43406;['appeal is dismissed']
+71252;['appeal is dismissed']
+123007;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+96920;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+109275;['reject his claim for refugee protection']
+67478;['panel concludes that the visa officer’s decision is valid']
+138827;['appeal abandoned']
+16811;['appellant is either a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+93959;['appeal is dismissed']
+101686;['appeal is allowed']
+73039;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+47363;['appeal is allowed.the']
+76838;['appeal is dismissed']
+95307;['appeal is dismissed']
+107660;['appeal is dismissed']
+105785;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+128618;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+83636;['appeal is allowed']
+59742;['appeal of tanvir kaur randhawa is allowed']
+147441;['appeal was dismissed']
+97008;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+129852;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91654;['appeal is allowed']
+128603;['appeal is allowed']
+95420;['appeal is dismissed']
+81615;['appeal is dismissed']
+142947;['appeal is allowed']
+68375;['appeal filed']
+128607;['appeal is allowed']
+100436;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+110963;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133740;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136677;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93907;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+99804;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+108215;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105214;['appeal should be dismissed']
+85864;['reject these explanations']
+89428;['dismissing this appeal']
+62708;['appeal is allowed']
+149276;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+69602;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+92020;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+132806;['decision of the rpd is confirmed']
+68680;['appeal is dismissed']
+133259;['appeals are dismissed']
+86638;['appeal is allowed']
+16818;['appeal is dismissed']
+84422;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+130958;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+140796;['302 (c.a.']
+82250;['appeal is dismissed']
+116851;['appeal is dismissed']
+83051;['appeal is allowed.the']
+91215;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+81175;['appeal is dismissed']
+138861;['appeals are dismissed']
+100850;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+144388;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70075;['appeal is allowed']
+123790;['rpd’s decision is upheld']
+128572;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+82377;['appeal is allowed']
+145326;['not be recognized as refugees']
+74268;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+113793;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129870;['appeal is allowed']
+69596;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+90030;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+96247;['appeal isallowedand']
+87027;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+47389;['appeal is allowed']
+63737;['appeal were dismissed']
+86987;['appeal is dismissed']
+99164;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx, is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+110948;['determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx,   and xxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of   ']
+85870;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+37838;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+130765;['appeal is allowed']
+100025;['you are not a convention refugee']
+81010;['dismiss your appeal']
+91672;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+38865;['appeal is dismissed']
+84701;['appeal is allowed']
+92247;['allow the appeal']
+134212;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+28375;['appeal is dismissed']
+104104;['appeal is allowed.the']
+71682;['negative']
+125458;['dismiss mr. n’s appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that he is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+136114;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+83285;['appeal is dismissed']
+143609;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102166;['appeal is dismissed']
+57034;['appeal is dismissed']
+96634;['appeal is dismissed']
+123474;['appeal is allowed']
+83725;['appeal is dismissed']
+151376;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+133381;['appeal be dismissed']
+84625;['appeal is allowed']
+103086;['appeal must be dismissed']
+144015;['rad therefore finds that the rpd’s decision is in error']
+144021;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69716;['appeal isallowed']
+104076;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+94055;['determination is valid in law']
+58414;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+74717;['appeal isallowed']
+76279;['application is therefore dismissed']
+123723;['appeal were dismissed']
+105603;['302 (c.a.']
+42382;['appeal is allowed']
+34105;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+107191;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+72056;['appeal is dismissed']
+93077;['refugee protection claimant,xxxx\xa0xxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+110982;['302 (c.a.']
+90915;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+91728;['appeal is dismissed']
+151878;['appeals are dismissed']
+77274;['allowed the appeal']
+146070;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+87131;['appeal is dismissed']
+133246;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26807;['dismissed her appeal']
+99873;['appeal of vikas vasdev is dismissed']
+151463;['removal order is set aside']
+103716;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+102391;['appeal is dismissed']
+47794;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99985;['appeal is allowed']
+133715;['appeal is allowed']
+96636;['appeal is allowed']
+77482;['appeal isallowed']
+33086;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66232;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', '“convention refugees”']
+69420;['panel allows this appeal']
+107129;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+108697;['rad concurs with the rpd’s finding on this issue']
+26704;['appeal pursuant to section 70(1)(b) of theimmigration actis dismissed']
+100723;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67496;['appeal isallowed']
+88977;['appeal is allowed']
+77278;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+120803;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+146925;['appeal isallowed']
+84327;['appeal is dismissed']
+84803;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+79329;['allow the appellant’s appeal']
+26826;['thatxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugeeas']
+84523;['removal orders are set aside']
+87359;['appeal is dismissed']
+21366;['“convention refugees”']
+99820;['appeal is dismissed']
+69665;['appeal dismissed']
+131211;['appeal is allowed']
+125054;['dismisses the minor appellant’s appeal', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98352;['appeal is allowed']
+55223;['appeal is dismissed']
+102900;['appeal is allowed']
+45154;['appeal is dismissed']
+132750;['rpd’s decision is well founded']
+36098;['appellant is not a permanent resident and']
+98048;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74785;['appeal is allowed']
+97518;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claims']
+66242;['appeal is dismissed']
+91533;['302 (c.a.']
+62399;['appeal is allowed']
+17957;['appeal is dismissed']
+38244;['appeal is allowed']
+80473;['appeal of muhammad anwar butt is allowed']
+96511;['appeal isallowedand']
+121634;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+145827;['appeals are dismissed']
+56939;['appeal dismissed']
+84315;['dismiss the appeal']
+131514;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98677;['allow the appeal']
+112392;['appeal is allowed']
+132286;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee']
+61958;['appeal is allowed']
+72698;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+61953;['appeal is allowed']
+19120;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93874;['appeal is allowed']
+136086;['appeal is dismissed', 'rpd’s determination is confirmed']
+74295;['appeal is dismissed']
+63066;['appeal of gurdip singh kandola is dismissed']
+151955;['appeal is dismissed']
+98723;['appeal is dismissed']
+67625;['allow this appeal']
+91721;['appeal is allowed']
+52086;['appeal must be dismissed']
+103530;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+124110;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95397;['dismiss the appeal']
+93011;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69743;['appeal is allowed inlaw']
+80477;['appeal is dismissed']
+138877;['appeal is allowed']
+129254;['appeals are dismissed']
+125576;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+84582;['appeal is terminated']
+61545;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+93594;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+67776;['appeal of melikole negash alemayehu is dismissed']
+83507;['appeal is dismissed']
+80766;['appeal is allowed']
+105439;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+99737;['appeal is dismissed']
+42564;['appeal fails']
+104098;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124645;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+101705;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+146773;['appeal would be dismissed']
+56917;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+64035;['appeal is dismissed']
+92023;['appeal is allowed']
+54662;['appeal fails']
+98514;['stay is cancelled']
+101017;['appeal is allowed']
+27521;['appeal is dismissed']
+97875;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+132297;['appeal is dismissed']
+143004;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63909;['appeal should be dismissed']
+92876;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96334;['appeal is dismissed']
+82712;['appeal isallowed']
+87250;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76535;['appeal is allowed']
+24245;['appeal is dismissed']
+49540;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+41828;['appeal is allowed']
+68205;['ana is dismissed']
+87873;['appeal is dismissed']
+108879;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a protected person']
+49066;['appeal is allowed']
+59627;['appeal is allowed']
+59188;['appeal isallowedand']
+124613;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects the claim']
+96190;['appeal is allowed']
+47789;['appellant has not lost his premanent resident status']
+130703;['appeal is dismissed']
+30504;['appeal should be dismissed']
+88161;['appeal is dismissed']
+93686;['appeal dismissed']
+98379;['appeal is dismissed']
+110928;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+83185;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+54231;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+88495;['reject this claim']
+9679;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+99338;['ms. kaur is not a canadian citizen.']
+61046;['appeal is allowed']
+121384;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44730;['appeal is allowed']
+63881;['allows the appeal filed']
+102015;['appeals in both cases are allowed']
+39036;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+101347;['appeal is allowed']
+133246;['appeal is dismissed']
+50353;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84174;['appeal is allowed']
+94716;['appeal is dismissed']
+148604;['dismissing the appeal']
+114312;['appellant cannot be recognized as a refugee']
+115217;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+90253;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+69413;['appeal was dismissed']
+129997;['appeal is dismissed']
+148646;['appeal is dismissed']
+27015;['abandonment proceeding is therefore set aside']
+106811;['302 (c.a.']
+123311;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+89721;['appeal is dismissed']
+74607;['appeal of sarbjit singh dhaliwal is dismissed']
+87164;['appeal is dismissed']
+36107;['decision is not valid in law']
+105912;['appeal is allowed']
+118249;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108083;['appeal is allowed']
+87699;['claimant’s claim fails']
+61650;['302 (c.a.']
+99266;['appeal is dismissed']
+60037;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+89434;['appeal is allowed']
+95178;['appeal is dismissed']
+47385;['appeal is allowed']
+100921;['appeal is dismissed']
+140738;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124673;['appeal is allowed']
+60912;['appeal isallowed']
+79998;['appeal is dismissed']
+101447;['appeal fail']
+82027;['appeal isterminated']
+46078;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+107432;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+48619;['sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'declares the principal appellant a convention refugee']
+90826;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+77576;['appeal be allowed']
+44033;['dismiss the appeal']
+97639;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+110678;['appellants claim fails']
+89897;['302 (c.a.']
+89942;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96853;['appeal isallowed.the']
+125048;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+59839;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+81002;['appeal is dismissed']
+101016;['appeal is allowed']
+81619;['appeal would be dismissed']
+105211;['appeal is   hereby allowed']
+89068;['allow the appeal']
+68310;['appeal would be dismissed']
+133718;['substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+31048;['appeals of mr. ashoori, ms. hakimi and ali are dismissed']
+122530;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132757;['appeal is allowed']
+97510;['claimants not to be convention refugees and not to be persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+95772;['appeal is dismissed']
+12209;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+85926;['appeal is allowed']
+90456;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+73598;['appeal is terminated']
+92718;['appeal is allowed']
+94011;['determination is valid in law']
+95509;['appeal is allowed']
+104089;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+86902;['appeal is abandoned']
+143567;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes its own determination']
+45202;['appeal is determined to have been abandoned']
+69594;['appeal is allowed']
+52786;['appeal is dismissed']
+83157;['appeal is dismissed']
+69660;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+57953;['application is dismissed']
+152391;['appeal is allowed']
+123534;['dismiss the appeal']
+88808;['appeal is allowed']
+107172;['application is allowed']
+123760;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+47337;['appeal is dismissed']
+54173;['appeal is allowed']
+68313;['dismiss the appeal']
+102166;['dismiss the appeal']
+131134;['appeal is dismissed']
+70175;['tribunal finds that the departure order is valid in law']
+84521;['appeal is allowed']
+98914;['dismiss this appeal']
+97344;['appeal is allowed']
+94752;['negative']
+81081;['ms.\xa0seydou cannot be sponsored in canada']
+71989;['appeal is allowed']
+52683;['panel rejects the claims of xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx to refugee protection']
+130928;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46392;['appeal is allowed']
+97616;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99403;['dismiss this appeal']
+49121;['appeal of nader fahed hassoun is dismissed']
+62454;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+99466;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+92797;['panel finds the refusal valid in law']
+47385;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law', 'appeal is allowed in law']
+92789;['removal order is set aside']
+102897;['dismiss the appeal']
+89099;['refugee protection claim is rejected']
+99170;['appellant has not lost their permanent resident status']
+79870;['appeal is dismissed']
+107443;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appeal is dismissed']
+72620;['appeal is dismissed']
+151509;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+61038;['appeal is allowed']
+97214;['appeal is allowed']
+83672;['determinations are not valid in law']
+69402;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+145833;['appeal is allowed']
+83503;['appeal is dismissed']
+59668;['appeal is allowed']
+67531;['appeal is terminated[emphasis']
+79876;['appeal is dismissed']
+104499;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+69227;['rad agrees with these conclusions']
+60491;['appeal is dismissed']
+70214;['appeal is dismissed']
+80785;['appeal is allowed']
+89764;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+101759;['appeal is allowed']
+76835;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+140815;['appeal is dismissed']
+98386;['appeal is allowed', 'visa officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+89133;['appeal isallowed']
+93784;['confirm the rpd decision', 'dismiss the appeal']
+102982;['appeal is dismissed']
+141335;['appeal is allowed']
+131707;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94512;['appeal is dismissed']
+92815;['appeals are allowed']
+55299;['appeal is dismissed']
+130728;['appeal is dismissed']
+44018;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94990;['302 (c.a.)']
+77858;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+68166;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+46047;['appeal is determined']
+90812;['appeal isdismissed.']
+102887;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention\xa0']
+59805;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+89879;['claimants, xxxxx xxxxx and xxxxx xxxxx, are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+101407;['appeal isallowed']
+69194;['appeal is dismissed']
+76393;"[""rad finds that the rpd's findings""]"
+52671;['motion to re-open the claim of xxxxxxxxxxxx is denied']
+104141;['refugee protection division rejects her claim', 'claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+123679;['appeal is allowed']
+125508;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104501;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+83102;['appeal is dismissed']
+96591;['appeal is allowed']
+141654;['appeal is therefore denied']
+148429;['appeal may be dismissed']
+143861;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+77603;['appeal isallowed']
+94441;['appeal is dismissed']
+63982;['appeal is dismissed']
+150632;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70936;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+52074;['allows this appeal']
+144041;['allow the appeal']
+98829;['appeal is allowed']
+104835;['appeals are dismissed']
+68218;['appeal isallowed']
+26712;['appeal bedismissed.']
+91018;['appeal is dismissed']
+47350;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+36564;['appeal is dismissed']
+100898;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102568;['appeal be dismissed']
+89777;['negative']
+81124;['appeal is dismissed']
+100655;['appeal is allowed']
+88113;['302 (c.a.']
+80693;['claimants do not a have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+145435;['appeal is allowed']
+18012;['appeals are allowed']
+57030;['appealis allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa isset aside']
+40136;['appeal be dismissed.while']
+92235;['dismissing the appeal']
+87693;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96122;['302 (c.a.']
+91805;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+38240;['appeal is dismissed']
+56957;['appeal is dismissed']
+86388;['appeal is allowed']
+140919;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+71188;['appeal is allowed']
+45404;['appeal is dismissed']
+133275;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124554;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94319;['appeal is dismissed']
+97004;['appeal isallowed']
+151913;['dismisses the appeal']
+71422;['appeal is allowed']
+34926;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95613;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+57947;['appeal is allowed']
+101880;['appeal is allowed']
+101213;['application to add a ground of refusal']
+98448;['appeal is dismissed']
+101899;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+99951;['appeal is governed by theact']
+104510;['rad dismisses the application for an extension of time']
+78298;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+69414;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+107708;['appeal is terminated']
+63737;['appeal be dismissed']
+74211;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132634;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+97425;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+71095;['appeal is allowed']
+108704;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110969;['dismisses the appeal']
+96683;['appeal is dismissed']
+128379;['appeal is dismissed']
+103610;['claim is rejected']
+82366;['appeal is dismissed']
+133708;['allow the appeal', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+66305;['appeal isallowed.the']
+101458;['appeal is abandoned']
+131088;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+125002;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69550;['appeal isallowed']
+151950;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+56780;['refugee protection division rejects the claims', 'arenot convention refugees']
+58550;['appeal is allowed']
+101820;['appeal is dismissed']
+113802;['appellant cannot be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97915;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+46532;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+86320;['appeal is dismissed']
+95767;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96909;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30498;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+94017;['appeal is dismissed']
+81626;['appeal is dismissed']
+107937;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106169;['appeal isdismissed.']
+140723;['decision of the rpd']
+93336;['appeal isallowed']
+96258;['allow the minister’s application for dismissal of the appeal']
+95506;['appeal is dismissed']
+136702;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+96143;['appeal is dismissed']
+91170;['appeal is allowed']
+37438;['appeal is allowed']
+98214;['appeal is dismissed']
+19139;['appeal is dismissed']
+18000;['appeal is dismissed']
+151630;['rad finds that the rpd’s conclusion is absent of any error']
+88407;['appeal is allowed']
+71270;['appeal is allowed']
+47381;['appeal is allowed']
+99690;['appeal is allowed']
+81052;['appeal is terminated']
+150722;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95462;['appeal is dismissed']
+92198;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+19385;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+64252;['302 (c.a.']
+98318;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+65629;['appeal isallowed']
+26674;['appeal of diljeet goel is dismissed']
+77317;['appeal is dismissed']
+87029;['appeal is dismissed']
+139864;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+58090;['stay the removal order in accordance']
+77775;['302 (c.a.']
+82035;['appellant is dismissed']
+98617;['appeal isallowedand']
+123407;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+87820;['appeal isallowed']
+96809;['protestants are not persecuted']
+71200;['appeal is allowed.the']
+38873;['appeal is allowed']
+142978;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82239;['appeal is allowed']
+24247;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+63190;['allowed the appeal']
+62212;['appeal terminated']
+84819;['appeal is dismissed']
+125590;['not substitute a decision under either paragraphs 111(1)(a) or (b) of theimmigration refugee protection act(irpa)']
+105641;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+91585;['appeal isallowed.the']
+35667;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+89414;['appeal isdismissedfor a lack of']
+72917;['appeal isallowed']
+65665;['appeal is dismissed']
+76900;['appeal is dismissed']
+67607;['appeal isallowed']
+99268;['appeal is allowed']
+98355;['dismiss the appeal']
+150712;['substitute my own decision that the appellants areconventionrefugees']
+104943;['appeal is terminated']
+77826;['claimants not to be persons in need of protection']
+78769;['appeal is allowed']
+98197;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+146712;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+150232;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+44725;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed']
+87802;['refusal is valid in law']
+76333;['appeal isallowed']
+139889;['appeal of guan feng yi is dismissed']
+107160;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+77870;['appeal is dismissed']
+80361;['appeal is dismissed']
+82648;['appeal is allowed']
+93809;['302 (c.a.']
+123464;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124703;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+113558;['appeal is dismissed']
+88907;['appeal is abandoned']
+15581;['appeal of the first order is dismissed']
+114389;['appeal is allowed']
+86635;['appeal is dismissed']
+147574;['appeal is allowed.the']
+81075;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+102694;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+129857;['appeal is allowed']
+105909;['xxxx is a minority clan in somalia.the']
+92530;['panel rejects this argument']
+102745;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+55175;['appeals of richard blair illingworth, helen mary illingworth, grace elizabeth illingworth, libby mary illingworth, and blair robert illingworth are dismissed']
+108253;['appeal is dismissed']
+143999;['thereforeconfirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+91726;['appeal were dismissed']
+76719;['appeal is dismissed']
+68425;['dismiss the appeal']
+54264;['appeal is allowed']
+105638;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee”']
+90934;['appeal is dismissed']
+38791;['appeal is dismissed']
+87205;['appeal is dismissed']
+26777;['appeal should be dismissed']
+87147;['appeal is allowed']
+118659;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+83240;['id’s decision is set aside']
+26684;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+78772;['appeal is dismissed']
+50752;['appeal is allowed']
+97336;['nor a\xa0 “person in need of protection']
+134283;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+124092;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+78742;['appeal is dismissed']
+131062;['appeal be dismissed']
+100156;['302 (c.a.)']
+47611;['rad concurs with the rpd’s decision to reject the appellant’s refugee claim']
+100912;['appeal is based']
+90054;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99049;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+109288;['appeal is rejected']
+108766;['rad concurs with the rpd’s findings']
+114305;['appeal is dismissed']
+137457;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97832;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89843;['appeal is allowed']
+64130;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+151625;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+96942;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84727;['appeal is allowed']
+106336;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+146640;['claimants do not meet the criteria to be recognized as convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+79331;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+99016;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89783;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+121948;['appeal is allowed']
+141160;['appeal be dismissed']
+106794;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+115286;['orders your deportation']
+102935;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+151807;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+22764;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+101262;['appeal of sawda abdi ahmed is allowed']
+96296;['dismiss the appeal']
+93325;['302 (c.a.)']
+68988;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+35035;['appeal of hanaa eidda is allowed']
+92027;['appeal is dismissed']
+121471;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellantxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+105758;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94540;['appeal is dismissed']
+75441;['appeal isallowed']
+89140;['appeal is allowed']
+96028;"[""rad confirms the rpd's negative determination""]"
+95905;['not a convention refugee']
+81817;['appeal is allowed']
+100220;['appeal is allowed']
+99475;['302 (c.a.']
+54212;['appeal is dismissed']
+99062;['appeal is dismissed']
+38388;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+130966;['confirm the decision appealed', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”', 'appeal is dismissed']
+101014;['appeal is allowed']
+110311;['appeal is dismissed']
+99914;['appeal isdismissed.']
+147433;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71339;['appeal is dismissed']
+8802;['appeal filed']
+123399;['appeal is allowed']
+80485;['appeal is dismissed']
+87953;['claimant is not a refugee']
+26810;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+125233;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136729;['appeal is dismissed']
+122889;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132437;['appeal is dismissed']
+75152;['appeal oftimothyearl tyler is terminated']
+89362;['appeal isallowed']
+44024;['appeal is dismissed']
+132627;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+2905;['appeal is determined']
+76777;['dismiss the appeal']
+64240;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+69796;['appeal is terminated']
+77062;['appeal isallowed']
+132267;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”']
+38867;['appeal is allowed']
+78026;['appeal is governed']
+48615;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+96939;['appeal is dismissed']
+69664;['appeal is dismissed']
+85449;['appeal is allowed']
+117147;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+111333;['appeals are dismissed']
+54742;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+105858;['appeal is dismissed']
+88534;['appeal is allowed']
+91293;['appeal is allowed']
+120765;['appeal is dismissed']
+120799;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the respondents are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92152;['appeal is dismissed']
+124743;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38845;['appeal be dismissed']
+78125;['claimants not to be convention refugees']
+84640;['appeal is dismissed']
+40145;['appeal is dismissed']
+96811;['appeal is allowed']
+142526;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,has not established that he is a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+84414;['appeal is dismissed']
+151522;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+64248;['302 (c.a.)']
+100377;['appeal is allowed']
+80791;['dismiss this appeal']
+61409;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+107610;['rad finds that state protection']
+97264;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+54718;['appeal is allowed']
+101762;['appeal is allowed']
+144017;['appeal is dismissed']
+59838;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+55121;['appeal is dismissed']
+50663;['dismiss this appeal']
+74066;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+143489;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+113233;['appeal is dismissed']
+89726;['allows the appeal']
+71525;['appeal should be dismissed']
+142496;['appeals of xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are dismissed']
+121878;['are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108834;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+152949;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123318;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+76888;['dismiss the appeal']
+88137;['appeal is allowed']
+91418;['appeal is dismissed']
+77081;['appeal is rejected']
+152774;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92511;['appeal is dismissed']
+58103;['appeal is dismissed']
+95951;['rad finds the appellant’s argument is without merit']
+94834;['appeal is dismissed']
+79216;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+17899;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+91070;['appeal is terminated']
+140273;['appeal is dismissed']
+136145;['appeal is allowed']
+77073;['appeals are dismissed']
+87518;['appeal is allowed']
+108996;['claim is therefore rejected']
+134174;['appeal is dismissed']
+121457;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+78165;['immigration appeal division orders your deportation']
+84910;['appeal is dismissed']
+50502;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+40133;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+75483;['appeal fails']
+34933;['appeal fails']
+71733;['appeal is dismissed']
+97217;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+105311;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99399;['appeal is dismissed']
+90994;['appeal is dismissed']
+91682;['appeal is terminated']
+131523;['appeal is dismissed']
+136087;['appeal is dismissed']
+107173;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+74768;['appeal is allowed']
+94251;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision, cannot substitute its own determination']
+98460;['refugee protection claim']
+61380;['dismiss this appeal']
+90036;['appeal isallowed']
+129904;['appeal is allowed']
+83168;['appeal is dismissed']
+123909;['appeal is allowed']
+92986;['appeal is terminated']
+143552;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93015;['dismiss the appellant’s application to extend the time']
+105859;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54759;['allow the appeal']
+64631;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+123382;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+88852;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101911;['appeal is allowed']
+84815;['appeal of junior west from the removal order issued on 16 january 2009 is dismissed']
+83086;['appeal must be dismissed']
+92961;['appeal is terminated']
+80195;['negative']
+130983;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133350;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132273;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68899;['appeal is dismissed']
+106396;['adopts their reasons']
+116190;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52305;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+92939;['appeal isallowedand']
+59664;['appeal is dismissed']
+63955;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68211;['appeal isallowed']
+36095;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+95588;['appeal is allowed']
+112350;['appeal is allowed']
+81918;['appeal is dismissed']
+79691;['appeal is allowed']
+93546;['appeal is dismissed']
+110568;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134750;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+52052;['appeal isallowedand']
+69971;['appeal is dismissed']
+124370;['appeal is allowed']
+132405;['appeal is allowed']
+91621;['appeal proceeded']
+146561;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+95083;['appeal is allowed']
+73708;['appeal currently before the iad is dismissed']
+118184;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90206;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+61454;['appeal isallowed']
+90702;['appeal isallowed']
+153268;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105556;['rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+87947;['appeal isallowed']
+105905;['claimant xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+145179;['grant the appeal']
+123763;['board rejected this notice']
+83086;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+100805;['appellant has not lost his   permanent resident status']
+116355;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+144554;['appeal is allowed']
+113544;['appeal is allowed']
+69408;['appeal is dismissed']
+66657;['dismiss this appeal']
+143851;['appeal is allowed']
+140817;['302 (c.a.']
+87587;['associate claimant is a convention refugee.conclusion']
+98221;['appeal is dismissed']
+100260;['appeal is dismissed']
+80717;['negative']
+69721;['appeal isallowed']
+105218;['appeal is allowed']
+124733;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52606;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+95044;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+113255;['dismiss the appeal']
+39040;['theappealis dismissed']
+31265;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+145757;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+26962;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+146969;['application to withdraw the appeal is an abuse of process']
+52196;['appeal is dismissed']
+122885;['i disagree with the rpd’s reasons']
+88498;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87676;['appeal is dismissed']
+77810;['claim is rejected']
+38889;['determination is valid in law']
+91191;['appeal is allowed']
+24243;['appeal is dismissed']
+76343;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+17164;['appeal for sponsorship was dismissed']
+122637;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+123108;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143233;['allow the appeal']
+101751;['appeal is dismissed']
+142744;['appeal is dismissed']
+50756;['appeal were dismissed']
+79468;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+94757;['negative']
+151520;['rpd decision is hereby set aside']
+71579;['appeal is allowed']
+84909;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+94367;['appeal is allowed']
+67012;['appeal is allowed']
+95368;['appeal isallowed']
+76054;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+63739;['appeal is allowed']
+121520;['appeal would be dismissed']
+99534;['appeal is dismissed']
+81127;['appeal is dismissed']
+64006;['appeal were dismissed']
+14699;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+87672;['decision of the id is set aside']
+73193;['appeal is allowed']
+125078;['appeal is allowed']
+61233;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+134312;['appeal is dismissed']
+81173;['302 (c.a.']
+54654;['appeal is dismissed']
+45395;['appeal is dismissed']
+61016;['negative']
+100826;['appeal is dismissed']
+61896;['thepanel finds the removal order valid in law']
+28076;['appeal is allowed']
+144044;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104346;['appeal is allowed']
+113788;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention\xa0']
+77288;['appeal is dismissed']
+95342;['appeal is allowed in part']
+38249;['appeal is determinedto']
+84782;['appellant was neither a convention refugee pursuant tosection 96of theimmigration and refugee protection act(the “act”)nor']
+62395;['appeal fails']
+88152;['appeal is allowed']
+133264;['appeal is allowed']
+50621;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+51811;['appeal is dismissed']
+73704;['appeal is dismissed']
+124437;['appeal is allowed']
+59974;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+125243;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+95286;['appeal isallowed']
+97635;['negative']
+10839;['appeal isdismissed.']
+131202;['orders your deportation from canada']
+65122;['appeal is allowed']
+43907;['appeal is dismissed']
+110988;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+98396;['allow the appeal']
+145855;['refusal is set aside']
+115276;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+55117;['appeal is allowed']
+85854;['thatxxxxxandxxxxx xxxxxare not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of canada’s protection']
+64256;['appeal must be dismissed']
+146451;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90690;['appeal is allowed']
+59186;['appeal is allowed']
+97328;['allows this appeal.the', 'stay is cancelled']
+64040;['appeal is allowed']
+69415;['appeal isallowed']
+139680;['appeal is dismissed']
+23097;['dismiss the appeal']
+64249;['302 (c.a.)']
+123731;['appeal is allowed']
+133360;['rad is not in a position to substitute the rpd’s decision and find that the appellant is a refugee or person in need of protection']
+66633;['appeal may be dismissed']
+84741;['appeal is dismissed']
+55498;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+24245;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+86198;['appeal of eunice torh is dismissed']
+52729;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+101399;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+97384;['negative']
+23100;['appeal may have some merit']
+131169;['appeal is dismissed']
+105695;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+23066;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+124069;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83316;['appeal is dismissed']
+121957;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132284;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+107202;['appeal is allowed']
+50905;['materiality is moot']
+122920;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+140718;['appeals are dismissed']
+68275;['appeal isallowed']
+38877;['appeal isallowed']
+78086;['appeal isallowed']
+51755;['appeal was dismissed']
+87619;['appeal is terminated']
+102543;['appeal is dismissed']
+42393;['appeal is allowed']
+63515;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79934;['claimant’s claim fails']
+124410;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+60249;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89010;['appeal is allowed']
+135939;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46198;['appeal is dismissed']
+95984;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+42301;['appeal be dismissed']
+105656;['appeal is allowed']
+84788;['appeal is dismissed']
+77111;['appeal isallowedundersection']
+88908;['appeal is allowed']
+36599;['appeal is abandoned']
+69866;['appeal is dismissed']
+63980;['appeal is dismissed']
+94316;['appeal isallowed']
+99500;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+94252;['appeal is terminated']
+80045;['negative']
+37895;['appeal is dismissed']
+63757;['appeal isallowed.the']
+64874;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the negative determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+123147;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+57887;['appeal is dismissed']
+87365;['appeal of theresa torh is dismissed']
+143874;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'allow the appeal']
+59666;['appeal of girmail singh dhesi is allowed']
+97411;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+102916;['appeal isallowed']
+100665;['appeal isallowed']
+96783;['claimants xxxx xxxxxxxx,xxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx and xxxx xxxxxxxx are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+84188;['appeal is dismissed']
+94500;['appeal is dismissed']
+89724;['appeal isallowed']
+63870;['appeal isallowed']
+79228;['appeal is dismissed']
+128295;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+113214;['appeal is allowed']
+87718;['negative']
+96306;['negative']
+135516;['declare the person concerned inadmissible']
+99383;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+98503;['within appeal is dismissed']
+67375;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+143922;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd']
+116901;['appeal be dismissed']
+103609;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+63129;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction to hear the appeal']
+82648;['appeal is allowed']
+95542;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+96137;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+114319;['appeal is dismissed']
+27463;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+146551;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+62999;['appeal is allowed']
+116819;['appeal is dismissed']
+87445;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+99143;['appeal isallowed']
+129860;['appeal is dismissed']
+82868;['appeal is allowed']
+96249;['allow the appeal']
+99805;['appeal is governed by theact']
+20002;['appeal is dismissed']
+125371;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+111646;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+91698;['appeal is dismissed']
+98288;['application for reopening is denied']
+67485;['appeal is dismissed']
+71992;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+90114;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+73268;['appeal is allowed']
+141816;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+38401;['appeal is dismissed']
+22819;['appeal is dismissed']
+98266;['panel rejectsxxxx xxxxs claim for refugee protection']
+76081;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+68123;['appeal is allowed']
+88902;['appeal is allowed']
+54720;['appeal is dismissed']
+60956;['dismiss the appeal']
+106802;['dismiss the appeal']
+110293;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+80989;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand as it is']
+97872;['appeal isallowed']
+84517;['appeal allowed']
+105600;['rad finds the appellant’s argument fails']
+116336;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+150716;['appellant is neither a refugee nor person in need of protection']
+97473;['appeal is dismissed']
+144243;['appeal is allowed']
+108935;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+56872;['appeal is allowed in law']
+142452;['appeals are dismissed']
+123852;['rad allows the appeal', 'sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+91689;['appeal is dismissed']
+87161;['appeal is allowed']
+76243;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+69439;['appeal is allowed']
+99207;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+23026;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+106287;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103053;['dismiss the appeal']
+40798;['rad agrees with the decision of the rpd']
+19380;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+79229;['appeal is dismissed']
+92738;['appeals are dismissed']
+145324;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84231;['appeal isallowed']
+71206;['appeal is dismissed']
+146587;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+108782;['appeal is dismissed']
+95632;['appeal abandoned']
+37529;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+93010;['negative']
+147619;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+86382;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+77576;['appeal isallowed']
+77011;['302 (c.a.']
+77575;['appeal isallowed']
+107926;['appellants are not are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+64244;['302 (c.a.)']
+122923;['ground of appeal fails']
+108765;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+78188;['appeal is allowed']
+146566;['appeal is allowed']
+101783;['appeal is allowed']
+85430;['appeal is allowed']
+82159;['appeal is allowed']
+125420;['appeal is allowed']
+68437;['appeal is dismissed']
+127732;['dismiss this appeal']
+108974;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+55003;['appeal is dismissed']
+98343;['appeal of mandeep kaur sidhu is allowed']
+140803;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90501;['appeal (ta8-07368) is allowed']
+80668;['negative']
+91085;['appeal is allowed']
+70027;['appeal is terminated']
+26483;['appeal is allowed']
+128906;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', '“convention refugees”']
+74841;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+101165;['appeal is allowed']
+142513;['” page 300']
+40479;['appeal is dismissed']
+72827;['appeal is allowed']
+69548;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+97009;['negative']
+97464;['reject this claim']
+63709;['appeal is dismissed']
+84064;['appeal is dismissed']
+76042;['appeal is allowed']
+131093;['appeal is allowed']
+61908;['appeal therefore must be dismissed']
+100098;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision falls within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes']
+110970;['not a person in need of protection']
+71217;['appeal of van khanh tang is allowed']
+92575;['302 (c.a.']
+95088;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+153147;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+136072;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+152823;['removal orders are set aside']
+35228;['appeal is dismissed']
+8295;['removal orders areset aside']
+93085;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+71467;['allow his appeal.']
+45387;['cancel the stay of removal']
+94578;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+115281;['appeal is dismissed']
+95103;['panel rejects these claims']
+63176;['appeal isallowed']
+94323;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+73188;['appeals are dismissed']
+63810;['302 (c.a.']
+80777;['claim of xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is rejected']
+88889;['xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42824;['appeal is dismissed']
+76045;['appeal is allowed']
+79221;['appeal is dismissed']
+137448;['appeal is allowed']
+103011;['appeal is allowed']
+90965;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84569;['appeal is terminated']
+92496;['appeal is dismissed']
+94835;['appeal is allowed']
+111314;['rpd’s decision therefore cannot stand']
+20837;['appeal is dismissed']
+86906;['dismiss the appeal']
+83107;['appeal is dismissed']
+57541;['appeal is dismissed']
+114353;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+88497;['negative']
+77082;['set aside the decision', 'allow the appeal']
+125315;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142463;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83487;['appeal is allowed']
+121991;['appeal is allowed']
+42567;['appeal is allowed']
+90018;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+93071;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99620;['appeal is dismissed']
+99705;['appeal of nada ablaba johnson is dismissed']
+57555;['appeal isallowed']
+98410;['appeal is dismissed']
+124598;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+24492;['appeal be dismissed']
+123894;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30411;['appeal is dismissed']
+89523;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+124984;['appeal is allowed']
+42216;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+111098;['appeal is dismissed']
+142479;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+105814;['appeal is dismissed']
+153265;['appeal is allowed']
+101529;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+76549;['appeal isallowedwith']
+138832;['appeal were dismissed']
+84367;['appeal is allowed']
+84609;['appeal is dismissed']
+68103;['appeal isallowed']
+133282;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'his claim is dismissed']
+68216;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+87792;['302 (c.a.']
+94932;['appeal isterminated']
+71247;['appeal of michael rehbein is therefore dismissed']
+122831;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+117159;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+91430;['appeal is allowed']
+74542;['appeal is dismissed']
+97585;['appeal is allowed']
+91194;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+52191;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugees”']
+36094;['appeal is dismissed']
+83303;['…]”']
+45157;['appeal fails']
+66312;['appeal is dismissed']
+69278;['allow your appeal']
+100677;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+112390;['appeal is allowed']
+136742;['appeal is allowed.pursuant', 'set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+77801;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75131;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+49393;['appeal isallowedand']
+97233;['appeal is dismissed']
+103905;['rad disagrees with this reasoning']
+100940;['appeal is allowed']
+76417;['neither a permanent resident nor a citizen of canada']
+92792;['theappeal is allowed']
+70663;['departure order is set aside']
+80686;['refugee protection division determinesxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+16824;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+40143;['applicants are not persons described inparagraph 117(1)(f) of theregulationsand']
+123055;['appeal is allowed']
+26844;['xxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+136121;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79687;['appeal is terminated']
+134362;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+139854;['appeal is dismissed']
+107818;['302 (c.a.)']
+94067;['appeal is dismissed']
+99002;['removal orders areset aside']
+113561;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+132358;['appeal is allowed']
+74100;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106307;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+129897;['appeal is allowed']
+102920;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+76167;['negative']
+140962;['dismiss this appeal', 'confirm that the appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+143158;['rpd’s decision is erroneous']
+92934;['appeal is terminated']
+138865;['appeal is allowed']
+47376;['appeal of jaswinder kaur dhaliwal is dismissed']
+116751;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68329;['appeal is dismissed']
+87716;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131052;['appeal is allowed']
+107325;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+40772;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99207;['appeal is allowed']
+47161;['appeal is allowed']
+125122;['appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+61799;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+98532;['stay is cancelled']
+98621;['appeal is allowed']
+101007;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+87101;['appeal is dismissed']
+89708;['appeal isallowed']
+102973;['appeal is allowed']
+124199;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97608;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+37863;['dismiss the present appeal']
+54228;['application for dismissal of the appeal']
+60696;['appeal is dismissed']
+23080;['panel dismisses the appeal']
+153158;['appeal is allowed']
+73355;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+62997;['appeal is allowed']
+98463;['appeal isallowed.the']
+73865;['xxxx xxxx xxxxalso known as xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+152909;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+96157;['appeal should be allowed in law']
+74487;['appeal is dismissed']
+22717;['dismiss the appeal']
+97020;['rad therefore finds that the claim under section 97 cannot succeed']
+38370;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+99554;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+91229;['reject this explanation']
+57809;['appeal isallowed']
+120775;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+23008;['appeal is allowed']
+109537;['appeal was not resolved']
+97572;['appeal is allowed']
+98801;['appeal is allowed']
+123427;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94328;['appeal is allowed']
+110989;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+96010;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140245;['302 (c.a.']
+87062;['appeal isallowed']
+148868;['appeal is allowed']
+77888;['appeal is allowed']
+107318;['claimants have not established that they are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+96378;['appeal is dismissed']
+67431;['appeal is allowed']
+103722;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102395;['panel orders that the stay is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+76659;['appeal is dismissed']
+90978;['appeal allowed']
+90721;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123527;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpdthat', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94971;['appeal of mossie mebrahtu rada is dismissed']
+73023;['appeal is allowed']
+61056;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108741;['decision must therefore be set aside']
+83452;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+63970;['appeal isdismissed.']
+89197;['appeal is allowed']
+91446;['appeals ofalay sanjaykumar shah and khush sanjaykumar shah are allowed']
+19313;['appeals are also dismissed']
+117116;['appeal is allowed']
+107046;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100649;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+105793;['application to suspend must be dismissed']
+133751;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83361;['appeal is dismissed']
+147786;['confirm the rpd decision', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+112784;['appeal is dismissed']
+103819;['claim is therefore rejected']
+76320;['appeal is dismissed']
+145328;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108051;['appeal is allowed']
+69612;['dismiss the appeal', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+98629;['appeal is dismissed']
+142995;['she is a convention refugee']
+106174;['appeal is dismissed']
+97828;['negative']
+30549;['appeal is allowed']
+62119;['appeal should be dismissed']
+141323;['302 (c.a.']
+147727;['appeal is allowed']
+108865;['decision must be upheld']
+54711;['pronounce theabandonment.']
+87865;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+100649;['appeal isallowed']
+82898;['appeals are dismissed']
+104068;['appeal is allowed.the']
+78028;['application to re-open the appeal is denied']
+50543;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+47923;['appeal isallowed']
+77276;['appeal of oscar armando castellanos is terminated']
+71288;['appeal is allowed']
+19726;['appeal is dismissed']
+61325;['302 (c.a.']
+96378;['appeal is dismissed']
+13945;['appellant is a person found inadmissible unders']
+100702;['appeal is allowed']
+74841;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93675;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision']
+74819;['appeal isallowed']
+80995;['declare the appellants have abandoned their appeals', 'appeals are dismissed']
+122133;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113741;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67699;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92482;['they are not convention refugees or people in need of protection']
+68338;['appeal is allowed']
+69326;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+102683;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62634;['appeal is allowed']
+66947;['appeal isallowed']
+127399;['appeal is dismissed']
+71706;['dismisses this appeal']
+98565;['appeal is allowed']
+97005;['nor a danger of torture']
+144957;['rad \xa0dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89293;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+103007;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+59785;['appeal is dismissed']
+47322;['appeal is allowed']
+99665;['appeal isallowed']
+97891;['appeal is dismissed']
+77839;['claimant is deemed not to be a convention refugee']
+47393;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+77451;['appeal is allowed']
+94260;['appeal is dismissed']
+78757;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95930;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its own determination', 'respondent is neither a conventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84743;['appeal is allowed']
+128375;['appeal for appellant nc is allowed']
+95444;['appeal is dismissed']
+87827;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+86144;['dismiss the appeal']
+125078;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+61971;['appeal is dismissed']
+129535;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+75471;['appeal is allowed']
+144484;['claim for protection therefore fails']
+67378;['appeal isallowed']
+92340;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need or protection']
+85176;['rad is setting aside the rpd’s decision']
+129899;['decision is valid in law']
+100429;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+122829;['substitute my own decision that ms. xxxx is a convention refugee']
+84479;['appeal is allowed']
+151512;['302 (c.a.']
+69262;['appeal is allowed']
+90944;['appeal is terminated']
+47308;['appeal is allowed']
+84199;['appeal is allowed']
+103916;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54179;['appeal is allowed']
+96276;['tribunal rejects the claimant’s application for refugee protection']
+94621;['appeal is allowed']
+130941;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thexxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98393;['appeal is dismissed']
+98745;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+34882;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+82181;['appeal is allowed']
+97338;['appeal is dismissed']
+55199;['thatxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+88816;['302 (c.a.']
+19304;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+147001;['appeal is dismissed']
+96444;['appeal is allowed']
+122618;['appeal is allowed']
+86874;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107476;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98549;['appeal is allowed']
+60909;['appeal isallowed']
+13630;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78016;['appeal is allowed']
+100242;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87025;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+47164;['board may at any time thereafter quash the order']
+45156;['appeal is allowed']
+150679;['appeal is allowed']
+101270;['appeal isallowed']
+69418;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+131216;['appeal is dismissed']
+33072;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147605;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71114;['appeal of harkamaljeet kaur buttar (aulakh) is allowed']
+102232;['appeal is determined']
+71470;['appeal must be dismissed']
+52790;['appeal is dismissed']
+61861;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+121197;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+122635;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+99882;['appeals are allowed']
+47363;['appeal is allowed']
+146076;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'claim is dismissed']
+138291;['determination of the visa officer is legally valid']
+62197;['negative']
+120821;['appeal is dismissed']
+64286;['appeal is terminated']
+89754;['claimants are not\xa0 convention refugees and not\xa0 persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+102567;['appeal is allowed']
+48223;['appeal is allowed']
+82622;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+102689;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101548;['appeal is allowed']
+99477;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+19725;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+130970;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90275;['appeal is dismissed']
+100356;['appeals of kashmiraben shankarbhai patel']
+115222;['appeal is dismissed']
+89306;['claimants are not persons in need of protection', 'panel rejects their claims']
+70213;['second secretary’s decision is not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+108714;['appeal is dismissed']
+151792;['rad tb7-11835, g. erauw, 3 november 2017']
+78293;['appeal is allowed']
+103905;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+120814;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69273;['appeal is dismissed']
+73317;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+100190;['appeal is allowed']
+91727;['appeal is dismissed']
+72772;['appeal is allowed']
+63749;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+104848;['appeal is allowed']
+94504;['appeal is dismissed']
+76030;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+123934;['appeal is allowed']
+148647;['302 (c.a.']
+100456;['302 (c.a.']
+31986;['appeal is dismissed']
+91215;['appeal is terminated']
+102491;['favorable decision form is attached']
+100130;['claimants to not be convention refugees unders']
+92877;['appeal is dismissed']
+129735;['appeal be dismissed']
+29303;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+84447;['appeal is not allowed']
+33065;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+82020;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+86384;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+101094;['dismiss the appeal']
+78670;['appeal isallowed']
+95630;['claimants are neither migrant workers nor asylum seekers']
+76912;['appeal isallowed']
+123933;['appeal is dismissed']
+144019;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+152822;['appeal isallowed']
+117384;['rad allows the appeal,', 'substitutes its decision that xxxx xxxxand xxxx xxxxare convention refugees']
+121956;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47615;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+87249;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+94401;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+72713;['appeals are allowed']
+60521;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+118429;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+146112;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+70116;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+81280;['appeal is allowed']
+90969;['appeal isallowed']
+82072;['appeal is terminated']
+136658;['appeal is dismissed']
+81025;['panel finds that the decision is valid in law']
+74478;['appeal is allowed']
+69098;['appeal is dismissed']
+56496;['appeal is allowed']
+25985;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124466;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101953;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+123384;['appeal is dismissed']
+81642;['appeal were dismissed']
+26843;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+89197;['dismiss the appeal']
+96190;['allow the appeal']
+61957;['appeal isallowed']
+28088;['appeal is terminated']
+132774;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+140965;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is excluded', 'dismiss the appeal']
+89923;['appeal is allowed']
+122880;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+30301;['application to re-open her appeal is therefore allowed']
+30547;['appeal is dismissed']
+26998;['claimants are convention refugees']
+74515;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+111004;['rpd is set aside']
+106426;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+105705;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+14472;['appeal should be dismissed']
+147449;['nor are they persons in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects the claims of the minor claimants']
+100472;['panel rejects this claim']
+97397;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+135157;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+51757;['appeal were dismissed']
+100898;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+99825;['appeal is dismissed']
+124073;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+141284;['substitute my own determination']
+87115;['appeal is dismissed']
+114359;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82268;['appeal of ghias khalon is allowed']
+76371;['appeal is allowed']
+108775;['appeal is dismissed']
+80565;['claimants are “convention refugees”']
+99123;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+104028;['appeal is allowed']
+123364;['rpd decision is set aside']
+144711;['appeal is terminated']
+92569;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+69448;['appeal isallowed.the']
+68102;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+97133;['appeal is denied']
+59551;['panel denies the application']
+110324;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+93585;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+81253;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98866;['appeal isdismissed.']
+41831;['appeal is terminated']
+52274;['appeal allowed']
+91936;['appeal is denied']
+103504;['request for an oral hearing is dismissed']
+113555;['appeal is allowed']
+63185;['appeal is dismissed']
+124440;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92789;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94302;['appeal is allowed']
+76456;['appeal isallowed']
+23109;['appeal is allowed']
+72218;['dismiss the appeal']
+74716;['appeal isallowed']
+74627;['appeal isallowed']
+123530;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+115206;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+114311;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94615;['appeal is dismissed']
+90462;['reject their claims']
+77969;['appeal is allowed']
+85319;['appeal is dismissed']
+148870;['appeals are dismissed']
+124030;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146490;['panel finds that, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are convention refugees']
+64853;['appeal is allowed']
+12234;['302 (c.a.']
+54547;['appeal is allowed']
+69335;['appeal must be dismissed']
+67569;['dismiss this appeal']
+100949;['appeal is dismissed']
+108061;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+30379;['appeal is allowed']
+107037;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+77880;['reject their claims']
+105448;['appeal of both appellant mother and appellant father are dismissed']
+31994;['appeal is dismissed']
+95509;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61798;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141794;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90534;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+117102;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76248;['claimants not to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+56806;['xxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68346;['appeal of kirandeep sharma is allowed']
+142888;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division']
+89141;['appeal is dismissed']
+93821;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+87831;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+125045;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93831;['your claim fails']
+124585;['rad finds that it agrees with the rpd']
+106269;['appeal is dismissed']
+57782;['appeal isallowed']
+75412;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+116759;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128907;['rpd decision is correct']
+91756;['appeal fails']
+45885;['appeal is dismissed']
+72886;['appeal isallowedand']
+47773;['appeals are allowed']
+91945;['appeal isallowed']
+68379;['appeal is dismissed']
+89263;['appeal is allowed']
+146884;['302 (c.a.']
+62996;"[""visa officer's decision is not valid in law"", 'appeal is allowed']"
+141830;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject the claim for refugee protection']
+123680;['appeal is allowed']
+64256;['302 (c.a.']
+61011;['claim is rejected']
+126402;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”']
+89346;['panel must therefore reject his claim for refugee protection']
+68717;['appeal is allowed']
+74534;['appeal is allowed']
+42968;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+46530;['302 (c.a.)']
+84203;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+87205;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+152261;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95914;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142455;['set aside the rpd’s negative determinations', 'substitute a positive decision']
+150942;['not a person in need of protection', 'nor a convention refugee']
+77469;['appeal is terminated']
+125129;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46290;['appeals are allowed']
+21385;['xxxxxx xxxxxxxx and xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx to be convention refugees']
+142961;['appellant’s claims fail']
+23757;['claimants do not need refugee protection']
+57033;['appeal is dismissed']
+95218;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+44022;['appeal is denied']
+98713;['leads me to find that the appellant married the applicant']
+12199;['appeal is dismissed']
+130886;['appeal is dismissed']
+98929;['reinstate the claims of the applicants is dismissed']
+124936;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+64039;['appeal is dismissed']
+39909;['appeal is dismissed']
+84607;['dismiss this appeal']
+95941;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision does not fall within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes', 'decision is therefore set aside']
+130011;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+69338;['appeal is allowed']
+122383;['appeal is dismissed']
+94715;['appeal is allowed']
+69097;['appeal is allowed']
+82680;['appeal is terminated']
+107654;['appeal is dismissed']
+122110;['rad, pursuant', 'substitutes a decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+143086;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+69622;['refusal is invalid in law']
+99279;['appeal must fail']
+116131;['appeals are dismissed']
+83061;['appeal is allowed']
+35881;['appeal is allowed']
+87143;['appeal is terminated']
+142105;['claimant is neither aconvention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132287;['rad sets aside the impugned decision and substitutes its own determination']
+65644;['appeal is dismissed']
+94444;['appeal is dismissed']
+89093;['negative']
+100092;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+82994;['appeal is dismissed']
+63823;['appeal is dismissed']
+99546;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+38878;['fan xi lin is not a person described by section 117(9)(d) of theregulations']
+93289;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+85463;['appeals ofejaz shahidandzeba shahidaredismissed.']
+87710;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+105714;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention\xa0']
+130725;['appeal is allowed']
+48294;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+95188;['appeal is allowed']
+105791;['appeal isallowed']
+132807;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113276;['appeal is allowed']
+141619;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+85394;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107553;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67369;['appeal isallowed']
+59032;['appeal is dismissed']
+65627;['appeal is allowed']
+99043;"[""rad finds that the rpd's determination that the"", 'appellants were not convention refugees', 'nor were they persons in need of protection']"
+100450;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71525;['appeal were dismissed']
+63016;['appeals should be dismissed']
+89856;['negative']
+59749;['appeal is dismissed']
+144570;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+121456;['appeal is allowed']
+82871;['appeal is allowed']
+90371;['confirm that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+80743;['panel rejects these claims for refugee protection', 'claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+80217;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+81099;['appeal is dismissed']
+93342;['appeal is allowed']
+122875;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+40776;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134299;['appeal is dismissed']
+80752;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+131065;['appeal is dismissed']
+107030;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+89284;['appeal is allowed']
+68417;['appeal is dismissed']
+97462;['negative']
+90538;['appeal abandoned']
+62871;"[""board rejected the appellant's motion to reopen the""]"
+60020;['negative']
+95279;['appeal be dismissed']
+50479;['appeal is dismissed']
+47096;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+93634;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59407;['appeal is allowed']
+91216;['appeal isallowedand']
+107491;['appeal is dismissed']
+138829;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+57064;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52925;['dismiss the appeal']
+71662;['appeal is dismissed']
+105333;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant and her children are neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+54202;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+122914;['allow this appeal and substitute my own determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+114380;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93064;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+99097;['appeal is allowed']
+108056;['claim is hereby rejected']
+129399;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+147991;['appeal of the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness against a decision of the immigration division']
+103892;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+113565;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+152389;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+139873;['appeal is allowed']
+111150;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+86455;['appeal of noreen mabel meetoos is dismissed']
+71173;['orders your departure fromcanada.']
+95576;['appeal is allowed']
+124732;['302 (c.a.']
+99974;['opposes the application']
+74476;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+128407;['appeal is dismissed']
+98227;['appeal isallowed']
+147474;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94320;['adoption is not an international adoption']
+133249;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+84487;['appeal is allowed']
+106472;['rad confirms the determination', 'not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+77806;['claimants are therefore not convention refugees']
+102108;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+42276;['appeal is allowed']
+151318;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26814;['appeal of shingara singh dhesi, pursuant to paragraph 77(3)(b) of theact, is dismissed']
+68143;['appeal of liezel gomez sanchez tiongco is dismissed']
+142480;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61911;['appeal is dismissed']
+87737;['appeal is determined']
+122955;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+143610;['rad finds that the rpd’s analysis is correct']
+93278;['claim is denied']
+22123;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+57947;['appeal is allowed']
+75159;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+93808;['claimant and the minor claimant are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+124996;['rad confirms the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+80046;['they are not convention refugees']
+144006;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68115;['appeal is allowed']
+152012;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+142745;['appeal is dismissed']
+49180;['appeal is dismissed']
+140958;['allow this appeal, set aside the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugee(s)”']
+143473;['claimants do not meet the definition of “a person in need of protection']
+148630;['appeal is allowed']
+60315;['appeal is allowed']
+91649;['appeal is dismissed']
+43398;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+42291;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+42301;['removal orders are set aside']
+95354;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+66234;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a person referred to in article\xa01f(b) of the refugee convention']
+82154;['appeal is dismissed']
+107673;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71516;['appeal is dismissed']
+77597;['appeal isallowed']
+96641;['appeal is allowed']
+76600;['appeal is dismissed']
+103039;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+75236;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+75001;['panel finds that the refusal is invalid in law']
+99654;['appeal (vb2-00198) is dismissed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a sponsorship application is valid in law']
+107597;['appeals are dismissed']
+101542;['appeal isallowed']
+94641;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+72214;['appeal is dismissed']
+86371;['appeal isallowed']
+44019;['rad has found that the rpd did not err in its credibility assessments']
+105755;['rad agrees with the findings of the rpd']
+49069;['appeal is dismissed']
+99576;['appeal is allowed']
+59725;['appeal is granted']
+98358;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+79638;['appeal is dismissed']
+77864;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxxx']
+105657;['appeal is allowed']
+99176;['appeal is allowed']
+94109;['302 (c.a.']
+95902;['appeal is dismissed']
+64233;['appellant is not a person who has a']
+59823;['claim was therefore rejected']
+74720;['appeal isallowed']
+103941;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+75980;['application to cancel stay is granted', 'appeal is dismissed']
+108946;['appeal is allowed']
+91701;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+131733;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+12199;['appeal is dismissed']
+89259;['appeal is dismissed']
+68578;['appeal isallowed']
+87439;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+96861;['appeal is dismissed']
+25978;['appeal is dismissed']
+92527;['appeal is dismissed']
+51746;['dismiss the appeal']
+97278;['appeal isallowed']
+68406;['prefer the appellant’s interpretation of the legislation']
+116185;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+99065;['302 (c.a.']
+70738;['appeal is dismissed']
+89270;['appeal is allowed']
+96002;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+83280;['rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'substitutes a determination of its own']
+123447;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88893;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+54799;['appeal isallowed']
+102142;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+145539;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+127359;['appeal is allowed']
+38890;['appeal isallowed']
+130688;['appeal isallowed']
+72020;['appeal should be dismissed']
+94769;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68272;['decision of the visa officer was not valid in law']
+89795;['dismiss this appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+82742;['appeal is allowed']
+101963;['decision of the id is set aside']
+26668;['appeal section have jurisdiction to look at the circumstances of the case']
+129392;['appellants are convention refugees']
+46014;['appeal was dismissed']
+96333;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+152241;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+19311;['appeal is allowed']
+96692;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx,', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+49164;['appeal is dismissed']
+71383;['dismiss this appeal']
+64594;['board allows the appeal']
+99076;['claim is rejected']
+65257;['appeal will be reconsideredtwo']
+153045;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+132417;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+28307;['appeal is dismissed']
+144962;['appellant is a refugee or person in need of protection']
+21388;['xxxxxxxx xxxxxx and xxxxxxxxx are convention refugees']
+105634;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143623;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84530;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+95915;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134334;['appeal is allowed']
+79762;['appeal is dismissed']
+74577;['appeal is dismissed']
+102570;['appeal is allowed']
+122691;['substitute my own decision that the principal appellant is a convention refugee']
+63991;['appeal isdismissed.']
+54843;['appellants are convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100120;['panel rejects the present claims']
+83025;['appeal is allowed']
+70069;['appeal is dismissed']
+57739;['appeal is dismissed']
+25522;['appeal is dismissed']
+56741;['appeal is allowed']
+128686;['allow the appeal for the associate appellants', 'substitute my own decision that the associate appellants are convention refugees']
+152480;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59986;['302 (c.a.']
+67538;['appeal is dismissed']
+112335;['appeal is allowed']
+50542;['appeal be dismissed']
+123913;['appeal were dismissed']
+69569;['appeal isallowed']
+142969;['claim ought to be dismissed']
+116776;['appeal fails']
+148936;['appeal is dismissed']
+95210;['appeals are allowed']
+107131;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+122927;['appeal is dismissed']
+140898;['302 (c.a.']
+72173;['removal order is set aside']
+84134;['appeal isallowed']
+127712;['dismisses this appeal']
+79744;['appeal of vasanthakumary sithiravadivel is allowed']
+77819;['negative']
+78029;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+91231;['appeal is dismissed']
+91701;['appeal is dismissed']
+129884;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122991;['appeal is allowed']
+143622;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60918;['appeal is allowed']
+132634;['appeal was dismissed']
+83437;['appeal is dismissed']
+140261;['appeal is terminated']
+152731;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+122647;['appeal is allowed']
+70199;['appeal is allowed']
+90673;['appeal was subsequently declared abandoned']
+121842;['confirm the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+153015;['claimants are convention refugees']
+67532;['appeal is dismissed']
+46495;['allows the appeal']
+34891;['appeal is dismissed']
+47222;['appeal is dismissed']
+109026;['appeal was dismissed']
+76389;['appeal is dismissed']
+98657;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123342;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66201;['dismiss the appeal']
+87877;['negative']
+96367;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+60898;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+143136;['appeal is allowed']
+71665;['appeal is dismissed']
+92410;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69265;['appeals are allowed']
+31432;['appeal is dismissed']
+148621;['appeal is dismissed']
+34884;['dismiss the appeal']
+76393;['negative determination']
+77293;['appeal is governed by theact']
+122974;['appeal is allowed']
+77056;['appeal is dismissed']
+95650;['appeal is dismissed']
+102477;['appeal isallowed']
+18001;['sufficient hc considerations']
+52949;['appeal is allowed']
+89734;['appeal is terminated']
+82392;['appeal isallowed']
+101539;['appeal is allowed']
+107935;['appeal is allowed']
+87081;['appeal isallowed']
+75997;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+70117;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx, a.k.a.xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+37238;['application to reopen the appeal is allowed']
+81022;['appeal isallowed.the']
+86209;['dismissing this appeal']
+136074;['appeal is dismissed']
+95012;['appeal is dismissed']
+41681;['appeal is allowed']
+95495;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+44966;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+149015;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43400;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+135943;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+84019;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+140824;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+95673;['allowed the appeal']
+56825;['appeal bedismissed.']
+131193;['allow this appeal']
+90898;['appeal is dismissed']
+89287;['appeal is terminated']
+93313;['appeal is dismissed']
+107024;['appeal is dismissed']
+93049;['appeal is allowed']
+97599;['reject these claims']
+124323;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+129108;['appeal is dismissed']
+88979;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+76552;['appeal isallowed']
+94316;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+14710;['dismisses the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+140865;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+23008;['appeal is allowed']
+104358;['appeal isallowed']
+60069;['appeal isallowed']
+95253;['allowed the three appeals']
+89128;['appeal is dismissed']
+83124;['appeal is terminated']
+91138;['appeal filed']
+98569;['appeal be allowed']
+101771;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98518;['appeal is terminated']
+101710;['appeal is allowed']
+121379;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89891;['appeal is allowed']
+100943;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+55264;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70889;['appeal is dismissed']
+121248;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96180;['appeal isallowed.the']
+101229;['appeal is terminated']
+101306;['dismiss the appeal']
+68182;['application is dismissed']
+24493;['removal order isset aside']
+43380;['302 (c.a.)']
+123855;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+133181;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85496;['appeal is allowed.the']
+130977;['uphold the rpd’s findings']
+19134;['appeal be dismissed']
+153270;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+89260;['appeal is allowed']
+80670;['not convention   refugees, nor persons in need of protection', 'i reject their   ']
+79205;['dismiss the appeal']
+151716;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+70373;['appeal is dismissed']
+82886;['appeal is allowed']
+107328;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+125128;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+71331;['appeal is dismissed']
+49057;['appeal isallowed']
+101530;['allow the appeal']
+122687;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+40797;['rad finds that the decision of the rpd']
+75958;['appeal is dismissed']
+69481;['dismissal of the appeals']
+39908;['allow the appeal']
+135452;['claimants would not face']
+61928;['appeal is terminated']
+101675;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+102547;['appeal is dismissed']
+128560;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50455;['appeal was dismissed']
+73200;['appeal is allowed']
+84414;['dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+142795;['appellants are not a convention refugees and are excluded']
+99538;['appeal is allowed']
+86525;['dismiss this appeal']
+86653;['appeals in relation to the other appellants are allowed']
+21323;['refugee division determines that you are a convention refugee']
+95929;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd']
+76365;['sba does not fall within the definition of a person']
+76023;['appeal isallowed']
+106430;['appeal be dismissed']
+116765;['appeal is allowed']
+99610;['appeal on behalf of the principal applicantmimoza nicka and the dependent applicants, viktor nicka, and albana nicka is allowed']
+94369;['appeal is allowed']
+139878;['appeal is dismissed']
+95058;['appeal is dismissed']
+62238;['negative']
+45231;['nor a permanent resident ofcanadaand that he had been a crew member of a ship in possession']
+102708;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+98602;['appeal is allowed']
+49165;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+123313;['302 (c.a.']
+89885;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79937;['negative']
+66910;['appeal isallowed']
+96684;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+89212;['appeal is dismissed']
+117190;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+91562;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76410;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+80749;['negative']
+135899;['appeal is dismissed']
+91016;['appeal is allowed']
+99259;['negative']
+15429;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+68714;['allow the minister’s appeal']
+116764;['appeal is dismissed']
+78034;['appeal is dismissed']
+90426;['appeal is allowed']
+139843;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+101024;['appeal is dismissed']
+94945;['appeal is allowed']
+91018;['appeal is dismissed']
+94807;['appeal is dismissed']
+101861;['appeal is allowed.the']
+72681;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107948;['appeal is allowed']
+80376;['appeal is allowed']
+90793;['302 (c.a.)']
+76970;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83346;['appeal is allowed']
+122237;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+97424;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+95451;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80826;['the claim fails']
+95780;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71559;['appeal would be dismissed']
+82389;['appeal is dismissed']
+131158;['appeal is allowed']
+37904;['appeal is allowed']
+84580;['appeal is terminated']
+93288;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+78718;['appeal is allowed']
+81100;['appeal is dismissed']
+98862;['appeal isallowed']
+94069;['appeal of zahirun nasa is allowed']
+90548;['appeal is determined']
+98251;['appeal of frank si keung chiu is dismissed']
+72872;['appeal is allowed']
+84573;['appeal be allowed']
+95502;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+94014;['appeal isallowed']
+104080;['appeal is allowed']
+149011;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+23065;['appeal is allowed']
+71802;['appeal is dismissed']
+94069;['appeal is allowed']
+124016;['appeal must be dismissed']
+142823;['confirms the decision of the rpd to reject the appellants claim for refugee protection']
+151862;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83315;['appeal isallowed']
+103625;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52595;['claimant xxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+125383;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+99735;['appeal is dismissed']
+125409;['appeal is dismissed']
+90987;['appeal of vivian le is dismissed']
+140064;['allow this appeal, set aside the determination of the rpd']
+81052;['appeal isterminated']
+151858;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+68979;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+72887;['appeal isallowedand']
+62194;['appeal was dismissed']
+45160;['allow the appeal of sukhwinder singh chahal in law']
+90801;['appeal is dismissed']
+68145;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97804;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+103804;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84524;['appeal is dismissed']
+81179;['appeal is allowed']
+69975;['appeal is dismissed']
+69740;['dismisses the appeal']
+21103;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+102419;['appeal isallowed']
+54197;['appeal was dismissed']
+129895;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101878;['dismiss the appeal']
+61624;['negative']
+110944;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104530;['claim is rejected']
+84667;['appeal is allowed']
+123110;['substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+104109;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+125439;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63195;['appeal is terminated']
+95956;['rad finds that the rpd’s findings in this regard are reasonable']
+100820;['appeal is allowed']
+26801;['appeal is allowed']
+75870;['appeal isallowed']
+89163;['appeal against the second deportation order is allowed']
+88527;['302 (c.a.']
+91550;['dismiss this appeal']
+102663;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+71748;['302 (c.a.']
+26964;['hussein xxxxxxxxxx is excluded from consideration as a convention refugee']
+95641;['application to reopen the appeal is allowed']
+93649;['dismiss the application']
+69068;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+14472;['appeal isdismissedand adeparture order']
+77215;['appeal is allowed']
+72623;['appeal isallowed']
+44839;['appeal is allowed']
+100613;['appeal is terminated']
+93155;['appeal is allowed']
+123885;['appeal is dismissed']
+59138;['appeal is terminated']
+76244;['claims fail']
+79478;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+94102;['appeal isres judicata']
+93065;['claim is rejected']
+77007;['appeal isallowed']
+92091;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+80714;['negative']
+87672;['appeal is allowed']
+85542;['appeal is allowed']
+74851;['allow the appeal of alaba dupe ogunsanya.']
+98750;['302 (c.a.']
+94676;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+89387;['appeals aredismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+128352;['appeal is dismissed']
+47168;['appeal isterminated']
+98848;['appeal is allowed']
+143881;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81260;['panel finds']
+89757;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+95428;['appeal is dismissed']
+50645;['appeal be dismissed']
+143183;['panel therefore rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+86338;['appeal is determined']
+107144;['appeal is dismissed']
+60984;['appeal must be dismissed']
+100237;['panel rejects the present claims']
+135153;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees']
+107587;['twins are now 15 or 16 years old']
+108271;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+83371;['appeal is allowed']
+122857;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+151477;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+110983;['appeals are allowed']
+99384;['claimants are immigrants who came here']
+116797;['documentation confirms this']
+100436;['302 (c.a.']
+103541;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76055;['appeal isterminated']
+95819;['appeal is allowed']
+108873;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69421;['appeal isallowed']
+100107;['appeal is dismissed']
+151468;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+87366;['appeal isallowed.the']
+71230;['appeal is allowed']
+123376;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+143022;['appeal isdismissed.']
+151941;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+61737;['appeals were dismissed']
+31229;['appeals are allowed']
+129401;['302 (c.a.']
+102415;['leads me to conclude that the applicant’s parents are not very involved in this couple’s marriage']
+86994;['appeal of asfa bagum wahla is dismissed']
+26503;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74870;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+153144;['allows the appeal']
+59669;['dismisses the appeal']
+97613;['appeal is dismissed']
+129253;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+81495;['substitute the determination that should have been made']
+92486;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+77986;['appeals are dismissed']
+99759;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+121864;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96937;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+118239;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52325;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+136726;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81156;['appeal is allowed']
+141808;['rad is not able to substitute its own determination']
+124546;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79868;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+52124;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+98500;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedunders']
+92387;['appeal ofintesar sabri al joundiis allowed']
+90478;['appeal was dismissed']
+47144;['appeal is dismissed']
+97790;['negative']
+47135;['appeal isallowed.the']
+98687;['appeal of ahmed ismail hassan satti is dismissed']
+133724;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+97898;['appeal is dismissed']
+90700;['appeal is allowed']
+83350;['appeal is dismissed']
+83914;['appeal is dismissed']
+77932;['appeal is dismissed']
+52741;['appeal is dismissed']
+98526;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99182;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+142513;['” pages 301-302. rpd record.']
+86632;['appeal is dismissed']
+128343;['appeal is dismissed']
+95477;['appeal is dismissed']
+139477;['appeal is allowed']
+106183;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100622;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+69573;['appeal is allowed']
+45404;['determination of the high commission is legally valid']
+56260;['rad allows the appeal', 'respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+23037;['dismiss the present appeal']
+90655;['appeal isallowed']
+59773;['appeal will proceed to hearing']
+65674;['pardon removes any disqualifications or obligations']
+84548;['appeal is allowed']
+87506;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+54204;['appeal is dismissed']
+55878;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+147590;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94745;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxxxx, his wifexxxx xxxx xxxx, and their sonxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+134300;['decisions are legally valid']
+129938;['appeal is allowed']
+124562;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66636;['decision of the rpd cannot stand']
+44433;['appeal is dismissed']
+24191;['appeal is dismissed']
+88849;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+70661;['claims are rejected']
+107333;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131166;['appeal is dismissed']
+124675;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87093;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+116750;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection', 'dismiss this appeal']
+90765;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43404;['appeal isallowed.the']
+43732;['appeal is dismissed']
+99470;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+100788;['appeal is allowed']
+84293;['appeal is allowed']
+124624;['appellant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+124935;['appeals are dismissed']
+92718;['appeal is allowed']
+94156;['negative']
+36245;['appeals of the father, kar wai thomas shek, the mother, suet fan shek cheung, and the son, lok hei shek, are dismissed']
+100505;['appeal isallowed']
+123681;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102203;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69110;['appeal is allowed']
+47160;['iad subsequently dismissed the appellant’s appeal of this decision']
+94586;['appeal is dismissed']
+45856;['appeal is accordinglydismissed']
+31395;['appeal beallowedand']
+84795;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a claim for refugee protection']
+124192;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95450;['appeal is dismissed']
+49976;['removal order isset aside']
+75616;['appeal isallowed']
+128293;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+150684;['appeal is allowed']
+85325;['appeal is terminated']
+70011;['appeal is terminated']
+95189;['appeal is dismissed']
+83500;['appeal is dismissed']
+123838;['vapp is not adopted']
+106641;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90204;['302 (c.a.']
+142836;['appeal is dismissed']
+95926;['rad confirms   the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee   nor a person in need of protection']
+71641;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26763;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+55256;['refugee protection division rejects their claims for protection']
+69745;['appeal is dismissed']
+91309;['dismiss this appeal']
+122881;['appeal is allowed']
+96205;['appeal isallowed']
+84483;['appeal is dismissed']
+94413;['appeal isallowed']
+44964;['appeal is dismissed']
+89119;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+49573;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+127391;['appeal had to be dismissed']
+26838;['refugee division determines thatxxxxxxxxxxx,xxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees']
+59186;['appeal is allowed']
+85907;['appeal is terminated']
+44425;['appeal is dismissed']
+69851;['appeal is dismissed']
+99625;['appeal is allowed']
+134421;['appeal is based']
+87520;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+94725;['appeal of terina nicole douglas is dismissed']
+93738;['allegations are not founded', 'favourable decision is attached to this decision and reasons']
+132344;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84813;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+147602;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+84351;['appeal is dismissed']
+47818;['appeal is dismissed']
+104857;['appeal abandoned']
+103538;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+45201;['tribunal allows the appeal']
+55374;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+102379;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+122916;['appeal is allowed']
+13833;['appeal is allowed']
+146884;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+116206;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+37408;['appeal is dismissed']
+98669;['application is allowed']
+122862;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+77615;['appeal is allowed']
+46387;['allow the appeal']
+124679;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66630;['rpd’s determination cannot stand']
+122548;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+76483;['appeal isallowed.the']
+91309;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+21334;['leads me to conclude that you had a very limited, if not totally absent']
+89828;['negative']
+26767;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+124734;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+85607;['allows the minister’s application for dismissal of the appeal']
+77555;['appeal is dismissed']
+132387;['appeal isallowed']
+57776;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+121957;['al is dismissed']
+106788;['appeals were allowed']
+141247;['appeal is allowed']
+97196;['302 (c.a.']
+45863;['302 (c.a.)']
+100587;['you are not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim']
+94834;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+65601;['appeal ofyvonne ann-marie ferguson, in respect to her husband,']
+94368;['appeals are allowed.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+57450;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+91908;['appeal proceeded on the iad’s discretionary jurisdiction']
+40798;['appeal is dismissed']
+14695;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+87385;['appeal dismissed']
+132280;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68880;['appeal is dismissed']
+95295;['appeal is terminated']
+122734;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38429;['appeal is dismissed']
+5583;['appeal is determined']
+56969;['appeal of bilal hassan sayed is allowed']
+65695;['panel accordingly allows the appeal']
+122648;['appeal is allowed']
+82699;['appeal isallowed']
+142498;['appeals are dismissed']
+87467;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+68340;['appeal is allowed']
+131917;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87152;['appeal isallowed']
+95931;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'appellants are not convention refugees']
+54750;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+89844;['appeal of qun qun liu is dismissed']
+56264;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+46296;['favourable decision form is attached to these reasons']
+123725;['appeal is dismissed']
+124325;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99018;['appeal is dismissed']
+36135;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90239;['negative']
+88440;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+56809;['appeal to proceed']
+105369;['appeal is dismissed']
+78762;['appeal is terminated']
+38864;['appeal is dismissed']
+92967;['appeal isallowed']
+88021;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+87695;['appeal is allowed']
+99372;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102969;['application is allowed']
+87685;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+50477;['irb (intervener)(f.c.a., no']
+40133;['appeal is dismissed']
+99989;['appeal of jagroopinder singh is dismissed']
+140210;['appeal is allowed']
+69605;['appeal isallowed']
+101917;['not “convention refugees”', 'nor are they “persons in need of protection']
+102808;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134353;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76146;['appeal is dismissed']
+91744;['appeal is dismissed']
+96938;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'determines thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+135203;['appeal is allowed']
+129940;['appeal in its entirety isdismissed.']
+22819;['appeal is dismissed']
+82798;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+60500;['appeal is dismissed']
+84457;['determination is valid in law']
+67431;['appeal isallowed']
+132332;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor persons in need of protection']
+92507;['appeal is allowed.the']
+60011;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+73295;['nor a permanent resident ofcanada.']
+145760;['302 (c.a.']
+102458;['appeal isallowedand']
+60929;['appeal is dismissed']
+71127;['appeal is allowed']
+105917;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+58835;['allows the appeal']
+47141;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+99756;['appeal isallowed']
+46042;['appeal is allowed']
+150711;['appeal is allowed']
+86900;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+86453;['appeal is dismissed']
+109633;['302 (c.a.']
+59807;['appeal is allowed']
+141615;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83041;['appeal is terminated']
+105556;['decision cannot stand']
+64313;['appeal is dismissed']
+84581;['appeal is allowed']
+139673;['appeal is allowed']
+88129;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+114374;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+77816;['reject these claims']
+88342;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+67364;['302 (c.a.']
+104094;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'or persons in need of protection']
+95081;['claimant is not a “convention\xa0']
+91695;['appeal is dismissed']
+128907;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+120807;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124017;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+70459;['appeal is allowed']
+81116;['appeal were dismissed']
+151061;['claim is rejected']
+89309;['claimantxxxxx and his wifexxxxxare not convention refugees', 'not persons in need of protection']
+84196;['appeal be reinstated is dismissed']
+95628;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+124650;['appellant is not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+30504;['appeal is dismissed']
+121399;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+84573;['allowing the appeal']
+82394;['allowing the appeal']
+84815;['appeal of junior west from the removal order issued on 16 january 2009 is dismissed']
+115218;['appeal is allowed']
+94925;['appeal is terminated']
+91293;['appeal is therefore allowed in law']
+97395;['confirms her church membership']
+100330;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+99737;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+76263;['appeal is dismissed']
+107906;['appeal is allowed']
+60004;['claimants to be convention refugees']
+93557;['appeal is terminated']
+136732;['rad finds that it is unable to confirm, or set aside and substitute its own decision']
+76081;['allow the appeal and']
+46555;['appeal is dismissed']
+53871;['appeal is allowed']
+48284;['appeal is dismissed']
+131139;['removal order is set aside']
+124716;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92805;['appeal is dismissed']
+87367;['appeal is allowed']
+74067;['appeal is not allowed']
+74167;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+142839;['appeals of bowen xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx are allowed']
+60917;['appeal isallowed']
+69492;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+96704;['appeal is allowed']
+98671;['claim is rejected']
+33075;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention\xa0']
+75966;['appeal is dismissed']
+107129;['appeal fails', 'rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+131142;['removal order isset aside']
+105260;['appeal is dismissed']
+123405;['appeals are dismissed']
+88083;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+67372;['appeal isallowed']
+93858;['appeal of jaisalpreet singh sidhu is dismissed']
+109000;['claim is therefore rejected']
+148503;['302 (c.a.']
+123831;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88453;['she is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+110713;['appeal is dismissed']
+89115;['302 (c.a.)']
+102979;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+69766;['appeal isallowed']
+130764;['appeal is allowed']
+151943;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125626;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+12227;['appeal is dismissed']
+63881;['appeal beallowed']
+107824;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136688;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+70964;['appeal is allowed']
+84154;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+24467;['appeal is allowed']
+69588;['appeal beallowed']
+59816;['appeal is allowed']
+94591;['appeal is allowed']
+90911;['appeal is dismissed']
+91325;['regulation is notutltra\xa0']
+97859;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+82796;['appeal is dismissed']
+81413;['appeal is allowed']
+140886;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+99231;['refugee protection claims are rejected']
+70948;['claimants’ removal']
+63125;['dismiss this appeal']
+67926;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+83450;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+134297;['appeal is dismissed']
+147440;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+28292;['appeal is allowed']
+27288;['appeal isallowed']
+71636;['appeal is allowed']
+94860;['appeal is dismissed']
+26756;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+72649;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+66779;['appeal is allowed']
+89555;['motion is allowed', 'appeal of the visa officer’s decision is referred to a full hearing']
+69265;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+98748;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+100805;['removal order is set aside']
+50353;['appeal is dismissed']
+143854;['appeal is allowed']
+68714;['thatman cheungbe excluded']
+72186;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+88450;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+80760;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+68278;['appeal was dismissed']
+74645;['appeal is allowed']
+92950;['application for reinstatement of the appeal is allowed']
+84453;['appeal is dismissed']
+69948;['appeal isallowed']
+81865;['appeal is allowed']
+127355;['appeal be dismissed']
+37851;['appeal is allowed']
+90125;['claimant xxxx xxxx xxxx has not established a serious possibility of persecution']
+69993;['removal orders are set aside']
+107941;['appeal is dismissed']
+48625;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'not “convention refugees”']
+77997;['appeal is allowed']
+87604;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+86844;['appeal isdismissed.']
+145213;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+95602;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+122252;['appeal is allowed']
+60127;['dismiss this appeal']
+73870;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+133740;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62211;['claimant it not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+150668;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60157;['appeal is allowed']
+106794;['removal order isset aside']
+88166;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+101285;['appeal is dismissed']
+140964;['decision of the rpd']
+45201;['appeal isallowed']
+99913;['appeal were dismissed']
+70485;['appeal is dismissed']
+143241;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+56644;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+77804;['refugee protection division rejects this claim for protection']
+82791;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+101285;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143555;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+92272;['panel therefore rejects his claim']
+150617;['appeals are dismissed', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98637;['appeal is dismissed']
+108744;['appeal is allowed']
+13936;['appeal is dismissed']
+124653;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133373;['appeal is dismissed']
+105760;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+58116;['appeal is dismissed']
+100163;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52328;['rad finds that the rpd did not err in its']
+101951;['determine the claimants not to be convention refugees or persons in need of canada’s protection']
+146888;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant, the associate appellant, and the minor appellants are neither convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+87738;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+102119;['appeal isdismissedand a departure order']
+105418;['they are not convention refugees']
+132276;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146886;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+59850;['appeal is dismissed']
+100692;['appeal isallowed']
+46029;['302 (c.a.']
+60507;['rad allows the appeal and returns the matter to the rpd']
+117106;['appeal is dismissed']
+94319;['appeal is dismissed']
+94262;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirm the determination of the refugee protection division']
+66303;['appeal isallowed.the']
+97454;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132310;['302 (c.a.']
+22703;['rpd’s decision is erroneous']
+57514;['appeals are dismissed']
+90958;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a protected person']
+76718;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+50249;['appeal is dismissed']
+76822;['appeal isallowed']
+105321;['appeal isallowed']
+133711;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97973;['appeal is dismissed']
+86047;['appeal isallowedand']
+54308;['appeal is dismissed']
+77845;['nor is she a person in\xa0 need of protection']
+111173;['rpd decision stands']
+142827;['appeal is dismissed']
+49119;['appeal be dismissed']
+34107;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99544;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+99773;['appeal is allowed']
+62629;['appeals are allowed.the']
+31979;['appeal is dismissed']
+123457;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146935;['claims is therefore rejected']
+115283;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+95074;['appeal of michael robert segal is reinstated']
+107583;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedundersubsection']
+142808;['appeal must be dismissed']
+99025;['302 (c.a.']
+96358;['allows the minister’s application to dismiss the appeal']
+49566;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+132400;['appeal should be dismissed']
+85859;['negative']
+151373;['appeal is allowed']
+144017;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76553;['appeal isallowed']
+142105;['302 (c.a.']
+103542;['appeal is allowed']
+110940;['appeal is dismissed']
+133361;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+90760;['appeal isallowed']
+80476;['removal order is set aside']
+62396;['appeal is dismissed']
+68330;['appeal is allowed']
+68316;['dismisses this appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+74610;['appeal is dismissed']
+79869;['appeal isallowed']
+60003;['claim is rejected']
+94446;['removal order is set aside', 'you have not lost your permanent resident status']
+141790;['dismiss the appeal']
+106172;['appeal is dismissed']
+27460;['appeal is allowed']
+74825;['appeal is dismissed']
+84234;['appeal is determined']
+81582;['dismissal of the appeal']
+105301;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+101845;['refugee protection division shall accept a claim for refugee protection', 'claimant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject the claim']
+68227;['appeal isallowed']
+111362;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+82870;['appeal is allowed']
+68160;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77845;['not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100730;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143601;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146896;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeals']
+60042;['application for leave to appeal dismissed']
+111182;['appeal is dismissed']
+94305;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+67534;['appeal isallowed']
+93123;['appeal is terminated']
+80237;['thatvillafrancais particularly applicable to this claim']
+107029;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+68696;['removal order is set aside']
+91321;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97112;['appeal is allowed']
+70024;['appeal is allowed']
+130691;['appeal were dismissed']
+122893;['decision of the rpd is set aside']
+103685;['302 (c.a.']
+98930;['appeal is dismissed']
+100641;['appeals are dismissed']
+99156;['appellant is not a good candidate']
+128284;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+77917;['appeal is dismissed']
+100636;['appeal is allowed']
+23115;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+132288;['appeals of all appellants']
+77689;['negative']
+122141;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+83302;['dismiss the appeal']
+75460;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+106881;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+95270;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is allowed']
+123146;['allow this appeal, set aside the determination of the rpd']
+49138;['appeal is allowed']
+91600;['appeal is allowed']
+50551;['appeal is allowed']
+72664;['appeal is allowed']
+133185;['appeal is allowedin part']
+76496;['appeal is dismissed']
+58756;['appellants’ argument']
+100520;['302 (c.a.']
+97673;['their claims fail']
+80735;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+102697;['appeal is dismissed']
+98437;['appeal is dismissed']
+88891;['dismisses the application for cessation']
+124677;['not agree with the rpd’s reasons']
+99428;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+44987;['appeal isallowed']
+101411;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse the permanent resident visa application is set aside']
+40292;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+127723;['appeal is dismissed']
+147549;['minister’s application is allowed']
+150240;['appeal is allowed']
+123278;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+71078;['reject their claims']
+100738;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+97894;['appeal’s relative merit']
+88181;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+77650;['302 (c.a.)']
+74205;['appeal is allowed']
+95147;['claimants cannot be found to be persons in need of protection']
+110978;['appeal is allowed']
+129860;['appeal is dismissed']
+142987;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107316;['leads me to find that his claim fails']
+103107;['appeal, on that ground, is allowed']
+63905;['appeal is allowed']
+98816;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+148642;['application for extension of time is therefore denied']
+125446;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+89328;['appeal is allowed']
+99925;['appeal is allowed']
+80030;['negative']
+26792;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+77887;['negative']
+127353;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'respondent is not excluded from refugee protection']
+106287;['appeal is dismissed']
+101271;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+101303;['appeal is allowed']
+78764;['302 (c.a.']
+87617;['appeal is dismissed']
+17152;['appeal is dismissed']
+86046;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101772;['appeal of bing chao fang is allowed']
+138851;['appeals be dismissed']
+95380;['rad confirms the decision of therpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+88061;['appeal isallowed']
+48104;['appeal is dismissed']
+92775;['appeal is dismissed']
+77981;['appeal isallowed']
+76619;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+52127;['rad has found that the rpd did not err in its assessment of this claim']
+96917;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+58565;['appeal isallowed']
+92551;['appeal is allowed']
+122940;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124921;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+113631;['officer’s decision is set aside']
+87097;['appeal is dismissed']
+55170;['appeal is allowed.the']
+85456;['appeal is dismissed']
+142122;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+95819;['appeal is allowed']
+139447;['appeals are dismissed']
+89752;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+52669;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+5148;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123762;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+81000;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+33316;['appeal is allowed']
+143877;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+56808;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxx xxxxx, xxxxx xxxxx, and xxxxx xxxxx are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99353;['allow the appeal']
+98112;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+56720;['appeal isallowed']
+50528;['appeal were dismissed']
+67588;['appeals should be reopened']
+98829;['appeal isallowed']
+124071;['appeal is dismissed']
+94159;['rad finds that the p.a.']
+116358;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+102732;"['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a ""convention refugee']"
+143183;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+98897;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100211;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects the claim']
+44084;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+55293;['xxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+54297;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+89342;['appeal is allowed']
+58755;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+19140;['appeal is allowed']
+80681;['negative']
+93571;['appeal is dismissed']
+49970;['thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+129099;['allows the appeal']
+40647;['appeal areallowed']
+134738;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+151570;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141299;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+84463;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+82651;['appeal is allowed']
+92343;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+123010;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67747;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+81410;['appeal isallowed']
+96015;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+68915;['appeal of charles kwok chu chan and wai kuen chan are dismissed']
+79460;['appeal is dismissed']
+94017;['appeal is dismissal']
+76244;['refugee protection division rejects all the claims']
+92399;['appeal is dismissed']
+84044;['appeal is dismissed']
+31381;['appeal isallowed']
+96386;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+110292;['rad is unable to find the appellant to be a convention refugee']
+21311;['appeal is dismissed']
+91378;['stay is set aside']
+89038;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+107643;['rad thus confirms the rpd’s determination']
+53442;['appeals of the appellants are allowed']
+66773;['appeal is allowed']
+96024;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75236;['appeal is allowed']
+132721;['claim is rejected']
+63989;['appeal is allowed']
+139677;['302 (c.a.']
+97347;['theclaimant’s claim for refugee protection fails']
+57003;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxxxxxxxx']
+87806;['appeals are allowed']
+124001;['appeal is allowed']
+71397;['appeal is dismissed']
+152823;['appeals are allowed']
+33328;['appeal is dismissed']
+121435;['appeal were dismissed']
+59808;['officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+42315;['theappeal is allowed']
+90707;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124982;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+124010;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitute the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare “convention refugee(s)”']
+72013;['appeal is allowed']
+122733;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+115232;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101549;['appeal is dismissed']
+77306;['302 (c.a.)']
+47363;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+56613;['appeal were dismissed']
+59974;['negative']
+89402;['appeal of anna fabiano is allowed']
+90042;['appeal isallowedand']
+72664;['removal order isset aside']
+151715;['appeal is dismissed']
+103498;['rad is therefore not able to substitute its own determination']
+88502;['claimant,xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee']
+108245;['dismisses the appeal']
+47155;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+99894;['appeal is allowed']
+73876;['appeal is allowed']
+123367;['decision must be set aside']
+122263;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+78678;['302 (c.a.']
+94205;['declares his appeal abandoned']
+96826;['negative']
+13754;['appeal is allowed']
+91167;['allowed the appeal pursuant']
+87838;['not a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection']
+68137;['appeal is allowed']
+143647;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90266;['appeal is terminated']
+150653;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+123397;['rpd decision stands']
+76447;['appeal be dismissed']
+52774;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+93804;['not a person in need of protection']
+102116;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+29601;['appeal isallowed']
+143608;['appeal is allowed']
+107184;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'upholds the decision of the rpd']
+96916;['panel therefore reject his claim']
+107499;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+143648;['appellant is excluded', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+129874;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82984;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+113257;['appeal is allowed']
+97020;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+57025;['dismiss the appeal']
+80495;['appeal is dismissed']
+108471;['appeal is allowed']
+59916;['rad therefore sets aside the rpd’s decision']
+97083;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+100041;['appeal isallowed']
+94158;['claimants, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxx, not to be']
+121403;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109278;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+54710;['allow the appeal']
+99301;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+76250;['appeal isallowed']
+63753;['appeal is dismissed']
+55111;['appeal is dismissed']
+98316;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+34933;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67569;['appeal isallowed']
+89366;['appeal is allowed']
+102986;['claimant is not a genuine falun gong practitioner']
+93290;['appeal allowed']
+94059;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142494;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+80206;['rejects his claim']
+152901;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141606;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107435;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+124364;['allow the appeal']
+107685;['appeal is dismissed']
+123126;['302 (c.a.']
+151526;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91324;['appeal is dismissed']
+67820;['appeal beallowed']
+125133;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+69438;['appeal isallowed']
+122374;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42213;['appeal is dismissed']
+66763;['appeal must be dismissed']
+97981;['appeal be dismissed']
+145827;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+143669;['i find that i must set aside the rpd’s negative determination']
+93617;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+138857;['appeal be dismissed']
+94012;['appeal is dismissed']
+122681;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151496;['rad finds that they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89389;['appeal is allowed']
+71155;['not convention refugee', 'rejects their claims']
+62867;['appeal is terminated']
+57793;['appeal is allowed']
+69750;['appeal isallowed']
+31215;['dismiss the appeal']
+44738;['appeal is unfounded in law']
+140996;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+15426;['appeal isallowed']
+77303;['appeal is dismissed']
+123322;['appeal is allowed']
+91819;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+91812;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+50654;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+62500;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81864;['appeal is dismissed']
+67496;['appeal is allowed']
+55275;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+128611;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106825;['appeals of gholamreza rezaei, gelareh rezaei, aryan rezaei, and golestoo rezaei are dismissed']
+125098;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113629;['appeal is allowed']
+56875;['dismissed the minister’s preliminary motion']
+69188;['appeal was dismissed']
+123885;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a protected person']
+102174;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunder subs']
+50497;['appeal is dismissed']
+52479;['appeal is allowed']
+135155;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is not a refugee or a person” in need of protection']
+61221;['appeal is allowed']
+123033;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+106754;['appeal isdetermined']
+96385;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+76172;['reject his claim']
+108757;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95791;['appeal is allowed', 'substitutes the determination that should have been made']
+45225;['appeals dismissed']
+93116;['appeal isallowed']
+83486;['appeal is allowed']
+95650;['application for postponementsine diemust be rejected']
+148672;['appeal is allowed']
+120806;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+68750;['appeal is allowed']
+98540;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+67364;['appeal be and is hereby dismissed']
+105862;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+132404;['immigration appeal division orders that the present appeal is allowed']
+70911;['allow the appeal of douglas hernan mazariego arana in law']
+82184;['appeal is allowed']
+81185;['appeal should be dismissed']
+69130;['appeal is dismissed']
+55183;['appeal is allowed']
+50772;['appeal is dismissed']
+73251;['appeal is dismissed']
+145055;['reject the claim underss']
+74655;['appeal is dismissed']
+46049;['dismissal of the appeal']
+107903;['appellants are stateless persons']
+96421;['appeal is dismissed']
+93308;['appeal is dismissed']
+130706;['appeal is dismissed']
+91771;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69316;['appeal be dismissed']
+68867;['appeal is dismissed']
+24466;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+122904;['appeal is allowed']
+8279;['appeal is allowed']
+74625;['appeal is allowed']
+121255;['set aside the rpd decision and substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+89768;['dismiss the appeal']
+74224;['appeal of kipengie jean-marie yambayamba is dismissed']
+100966;['appeal will proceed to normal processing']
+146438;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'rejects the appeal']
+134741;['appeal isdismissed.']
+84069;['appeal is allowed']
+145491;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+130795;['appeal to be dismissed']
+79951;['not a person in need of protection']
+138835;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+76306;['appeal is allowed']
+42289;['appeal is allowed']
+113213;['appeal is dismissed']
+130864;['appeal is allowed']
+93232;['appeals in files mb3-01025 and mb6-05632 are dismissed']
+83871;['rad concludes that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+107568;['favourable decision is attached to these reasons']
+87142;['appeal is terminated']
+26755;['allows this appeal in law']
+124085;['appeals are dismissed']
+63750;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90188;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+83391;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107706;['appeal was dismissed']
+89705;['appeals aredismissedand departure orders are made']
+64050;['appeal is allowed']
+84736;['dismiss the application for the extension of time']
+152208;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151868;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66651;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+26729;['appeal is allowed']
+99822;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108749;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+127696;['appeal is dismissed']
+98330;['appeal is allowed']
+89135;['appeal is dismissed']
+94541;['appeal to the iad is dismissed']
+146838;['appeal is allowed']
+94739;['appeal of yohannes ayele manchlot is dismissed']
+146882;['rad rejects the appellant’s argument']
+84436;['appeal is allowed']
+62998;['appeal is dismissed']
+74890;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+77911;['appeal is dismissed']
+13832;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99547;['302 (c.a.)']
+136689;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69493;['appeal isallowed']
+131232;['appeal is allowed']
+96295;['negative']
+97000;['appeal is dismissed']
+99867;['appeal is dismissed']
+68682;['appeal is allowed']
+98066;['appeal is terminated']
+125316;['allow the appeal,', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+123400;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own decision, namely,', 'appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+113213;['appeal is dismissed']
+105701;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+72832;['appeal is allowed']
+98535;['allows this appeal']
+97121;['appeal is allowed']
+84298;['appeal is dismissed']
+80675;['claimants are notconvention refugees']
+96827;['302 (c.a.']
+19309;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatflutur stejais not a “convention refugee” or a “person in need of protection']
+127910;['302 (c.a.']
+78724;['appeals are allowed']
+31425;['appeal is dismissed']
+18932;['appeal is dismissed']
+60664;['theappealis allowed']
+69222;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+52942;['appeal is allowed']
+136147;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79602;['appeal is allowed']
+77547;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+94750;['appeal is terminated']
+63990;['appeal is dismissed']
+98379;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+71372;['appeal is dismissed']
+81222;['appeal is allowed']
+116204;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54278;['application is dismissed']
+141038;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+110961;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98996;['appeal is dismissed']
+91926;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+89127;['appeal should be dismissed']
+153254;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+89031;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+75870;['appeal must therefore be allowed']
+99661;['appeal is allowed']
+49188;['appeal is allowed']
+46010;['appeal is dismissed']
+72180;['appeal ofcesar rafael santiago alcantara is allowed.the']
+52352;['appeal isallowed']
+124979;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+120793;['appeal is allowed']
+132371;['appeal of resan zaynb is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+69116;['appeal is allowed']
+107870;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99723;['appeal is allowed']
+85539;['appeal is dismissed']
+70780;['appeal is dismissed']
+133357;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76651;['notice of the decision is the appeal is allowed']
+47142;['appeal is dismissed']
+123715;['appeal is dismissed']
+147460;['claim is, therefore, rejected']
+83050;['appeal is allowed']
+78285;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+52346;['appeal of papandeep singh kahlon is allowed']
+76444;['appeal isallowedand']
+83453;['appeal is allowed']
+129175;['appeal isallowed']
+108190;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70196;['appeal of melanie gamayon manuel (nee erice) is dismissed']
+92520;['appeal isallowed']
+62961;['appeal is allowed']
+122493;['reject the appellant’s argument']
+89262;['appeal is terminated']
+123157;['appeal is terminated']
+40111;['appeals are allowed.the']
+120777;['appeal is allowed']
+52083;['appeal is allowed']
+120841;['appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+110996;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+144958;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx et xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+88302;['appeal is dismissed']
+96805;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38851;['removal order is set aside']
+108213;['appeal is dismissed']
+54210;['appeal is allowed']
+145814;['appeal is allowed']
+102034;['appeal is determined']
+91131;['appeal is allowed']
+26725;['appeal is allowed in law']
+146433;['decision of the rpd is wrong']
+125344;['appeal is allowed']
+81581;['appellant has not lost his permanent residents status']
+114381;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99206;['appeal being allowed']
+37401;['removal order is set aside']
+63876;['appeal is allowed']
+65360;['appeal is dismissed']
+94433;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+25983;['appeal be reinstated']
+26779;['appeals of shahzeema safi dawlatkhil, noor safi dawlatkhil, and shahzadi bulan safi dawlatkhil is dismissed']
+108940;['appeal is dismissed']
+68584;['appeal is allowed']
+59741;['appeal is allowed']
+145338;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+86389;['appeal is allowed.the']
+67509;['appeal isallowed']
+124910;['appeal is allowed']
+60511;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+46518;['appeal isallowed']
+111366;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+97460;['claimants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92960;['appeal is terminated']
+146885;['appeal is dismissed']
+59834;['appeal is allowed']
+76836;['removal order is set aside']
+94822;['appeal is allowed']
+53442;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+153158;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision, cannot substitute its own determination']
+47386;['appeal is dismissed']
+53132;['appeal is allowed']
+97594;['appeal is allowed']
+83655;['appeal is allowed']
+85605;['dismiss the appeal']
+11068;['appeal is allowed']
+73316;['appeal is dismissed']
+37396;['panel finds the exclusion order made on june 6, 2018 to be legally valid']
+95855;['appeal is dismissed']
+130788;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+65629;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+153262;['rad concurs with the rpd’s decision']
+127348;['appeal is allowed']
+34168;['appeal cannot succeed']
+61010;['appeal of kofi antwi is dismissed']
+23082;['302 (c.a.']
+42386;['appeal is dismissed']
+91068;['appeal is terminated']
+107809;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+107622;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83947;['appeal were dismissed']
+87364;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+63954;['appeal is terminated']
+121530;['dismiss the appeal']
+54653;['appeal is allowed']
+107672;['appeal is dismissed']
+73253;['appeal is dismissed']
+100649;['302 (c.a.)']
+100143;['conclude xxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+82127;['appeal is dismissed']
+123552;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+31413;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+84424;['302 (c.a.)']
+81347;['appeal is dismissed']
+87419;['tribunal hereby cancels the stay', 'allows the appeal']
+74063;['appeal is allowed']
+24184;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142473;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67782;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+102073;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+122246;['dismiss the appeal']
+91450;['appeal is allowed']
+83925;['decision of the id member is set aside']
+73215;['appellant is not a sponsor for the purpose of this application']
+76775;['appeal is allowed']
+73586;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96864;['dismiss the appeal']
+120847;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+64287;['appeal is dismissed']
+89965;['appeal isallowedand']
+122922;['appeal fails']
+107476;['rad agrees with these findings']
+21367;['tribunal decides that ms.xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxis a convention refugee']
+118230;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+123999;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+87717;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, is not a \xa0convention refugee', 'rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+88032;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+80545;['embassy’s decision is valid in law']
+56665;['neither the international convention, nor our act']
+69353;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+82980;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96623;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+65663;['appeal isallowed']
+54759;['appeal is allowed']
+71246;['appeal is dismissed']
+51825;['302 (c.a.']
+111345;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+96142;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+118327;['appeal is dismissed']
+76323;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+129165;['appeal is dismissed']
+49185;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+124536;['appeal is allowed']
+80731;['appeal is dismissed']
+123042;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+44090;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+134737;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither “a convention refugee”', 'nor “a person in need of protection']
+104286;['dismiss this appeal']
+64600;['appeal is dismissed']
+123784;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+73364;['appeal is allowed']
+100132;['appeal isallowed']
+92404;['appeal is allowed']
+81121;['appeal is dismissed']
+99856;['appeal isallowed']
+140941;['i agree with the rpd’s findings']
+56503;['allows the minister’s application to dismiss the appeal']
+128350;['appeal is dismissed']
+52174;['appeal is well founded']
+71216;['appeal is dismissed']
+39903;['appeal is dismissed']
+54789;['appeal with respect to the applicant is also allowed']
+64252;['appeal is dismissed']
+127347;['allow this appeal, set aside the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugee”']
+124199;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+100865;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97010;['negative']
+29713;['appeal is dismissed']
+84833;['appeal is allowed']
+46512;['appeal isallowed']
+103495;['appeal is allowed']
+107812;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+94103;['appellant has not lost her']
+108953;['appeal is allowed']
+74028;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+31974;['appeal be dismissed']
+150693;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+81213;['appeal is dismissed']
+107194;['rad rejects this explanation']
+70600;['appeal is dismissed']
+71210;['appeal isrefused']
+99043;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+121951;['dismissing the appeal']
+99577;['appeal is dismissed']
+61435;['appeal is allowed']
+93337;['appeals of both the applicant and her minor son are both dismissed']
+35877;['appeal is dismissed']
+148630;['appeal is allowed.the']
+105827;['appeal is dismissed']
+56643;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+55976;['302 (c.a.)']
+128447;['appeals are dismissed']
+112778;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+138834;['appeal is determined']
+47761;['appeal is allowed']
+132424;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+80196;['negative']
+76246;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101949;['claim is rejected']
+151894;['appellant is an excluded person']
+146452;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+54249;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+97891;['application is granted']
+128589;['substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+146389;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116349;['appeal is allowed']
+111290;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+88440;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+89366;['appeal is allowed']
+87709;['negative']
+111355;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+31412;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+100202;['appeal is allowed']
+69744;['appeal isallowed']
+93192;['appeal is allowed']
+92878;['appeal is terminated']
+93964;['appeal is allowed']
+147885;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82062;['appeal is allowed']
+63854;['negative']
+105663;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination']
+122690;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+56733;['application of the respondent is granted']
+125036;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+53864;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+40772;['appeal is dismissed']
+107607;['rad upholds the appeal according']
+132829;['appeal is dismissed']
+26739;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+135945;['302 (c.a.']
+63180;['appeal is terminated']
+130873;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+110949;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+127361;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+107922;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+111045;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+74713;['appeal is dismissed']
+76140;['removal order is set aside']
+52479;['appeal is allowed']
+116356;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee']
+62399;['appeal is allowed']
+64911;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+37404;['appeal is allowed']
+94443;['appeal is determined to have beenabandonedunder\xa0']
+46008;['appeal is dismissed']
+104347;['appeal isallowed']
+63753;['appeal isdismissed.']
+98853;['appeal is dismissed']
+92176;['appeal is dismissed']
+99202;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+146112;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+89580;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+67782;['appeals are allowed.the']
+110304;['appeal is dismissed']
+108200;['rad finds the appellant’s argument is without merit']
+108695;['rad refuses the application to re-open the appellant’s appeal']
+123402;['rad found no error in these conclusions']
+84203;['appeal is dismissed']
+104430;['appeal is dismissed']
+129106;['dismiss your appeal']
+101982;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+92393;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+40489;['appeals are allowed']
+99869;['appeal of aidico aiza alaro is dismissed']
+107434;['appellant is \xa0neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80678;['nor rule 107 of the rules of practice of theimmigration and refugee boardin']
+72820;['appeal must be dismissed']
+57446;['appeal is dismissed']
+95771;['appeal is allowed']
+124078;['rad also dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55515;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143944;['appeal must be dismissed']
+57817;['appeal is dismissed']
+99687;['appeal is dismissed']
+94930;['appeal is allowed']
+85848;['appeal is terminated']
+143013;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+100919;['refugee protection division accepts the claim of xxxx xxxx xxxx']
+76835;['appeal is allowed']
+28975;['dismiss these appeals']
+113561;['allows the appeal']
+100767;['appellants 1 and 2’s appeals are dismissed', 'appellants 3 and 4’s appeals are allowed']
+28076;['appeal is allowed']
+76140;['appeal is allowed']
+85959;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+116790;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+124134;['appellants are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+73191;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+63609;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+92089;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+98894;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is excluded from being a convention refugee']
+147007;['allow the appeal']
+96238;['appeal is allowed']
+60459;['appeal isallowedand']
+95044;['appeal is terminated']
+104184;['appeal is allowed']
+93849;['appeal is allowed']
+109019;['appeal being dismissed']
+90654;['appeals are dismissed']
+123392;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+93905;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+68925;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+97421;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+133275;['claim is rejected']
+94381;['appeal of milagros noyola is allowed']
+142523;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70220;['appeal isallowed']
+86377;['appeal is allowed']
+151506;['appeal is dismissed']
+59784;['dismiss this appeal']
+94305;['appeal is allowed']
+107694;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98817;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+97446;['302 (c.a.']
+54662;['appeal is allowed']
+45180;['appeal is allowed']
+51285;['appeal isallowed']
+151616;['appeal is dismissed']
+80677;['negative']
+17182;['allow this appeal']
+81493;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+26961;['not convention refugees']
+95533;['appeal is dismissed']
+78068;['appeal is dismissed']
+17154;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124058;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146903;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes a determination that, in its opinion, should have been made']
+99578;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84723;['not grant the appeal.']
+105900;['appeal is allowed']
+99979;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+87330;['appeal isallowed']
+82837;['appeal is dismissed']
+152949;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+134437;['appeal is dismissed']
+124913;['rad allows the appeal']
+145490;['appeal is allowed']
+40774;['rad finds that']
+54169;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+131146;['not confirm the decision of the rpd']
+90102;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83674;['appeals are dismissed']
+39141;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99443;['panel rejects these claims']
+150954;['appeal is allowed']
+140233;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+27223;['appellant is no longer a permanent resident of canada', 'appellant is not a protected person']
+135475;['appeal is dismissed', 'rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99503;['302 (c.a.)']
+140255;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”']
+52159;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+86399;['302 (c.a.)']
+129873;['dismiss the appeal']
+89923;['appeal isallowed']
+89872;['appeal is dismissed']
+47122;['appeal is allowed']
+91174;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98132;['appeal is dismissed']
+86211;['appeal is dismissed']
+97436;['determination is valid in law']
+74036;['appeal is allowed']
+124567;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99021;['appeal is allowed']
+62487;['decision of the rpd']
+80060;['appeal is dismissed']
+141275;['appeal is allowed']
+73675;['appeal is dismissed']
+135145;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46533;['appeal is dismissed']
+113579;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+105606;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention\xa0']
+83296;['appeal is allowed']
+123429;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+129240;['appeal is allowed']
+32133;['appeal is dismissed']
+97977;['application to extend the time to file the notice of appeal is dismissed']
+125240;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+76967;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+80205;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97010;['panel, therefore, rejects her claim']
+60029;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97880;['negative']
+86537;['dismiss the appeal']
+98422;['appeal isallowed.the']
+48621;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105770;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121939;['appeal is allowed']
+132304;['appeal is allowed']
+83441;['appeal isallowed']
+84628;['appeal is allowed']
+76162;['302 (c.a.']
+125636;['rad allows the appeals ofxxxx']
+136670;['appeal is allowed']
+100900;['appeal is granted']
+106816;['appeal of winefreda hobayan beck is dismissed']
+13629;['appeal is allowed']
+93668;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95880;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+125604;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142727;['appellants are convention refugees']
+67247;['dismissing the appeal']
+99401;['appeal isallowed']
+95168;['appeal isallowed.the']
+123417;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+96235;['appeal should be re-opened']
+74215;['appeal is allowed']
+94828;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+93048;['appeal is dismissed']
+95207;['appeal isallowedand']
+96103;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+140794;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124133;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+23116;['appeal is determined']
+148055;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+120814;['dismiss the appeal']
+55882;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+130766;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+152392;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56915;['appeal isallowed']
+124721;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35036;['appeal of ahmed farid is allowed']
+141817;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128569;['appeal is dismissed']
+93628;['appeal is terminated']
+60822;['appeal proceeded by way of a hearingde novo']
+134384;['appeal is allowed']
+63565;['appeal is allowed']
+92801;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+108736;['rad finds the decision of the rpd to be wrong in law']
+144767;['refugee protection claimant is neither a “convention\xa0']
+96420;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97015;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+97426;['not a person in need of protection']
+123056;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113735;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+83257;['appeal is allowed']
+132405;['appeal is allowed']
+87049;['appeal is dismissed']
+133355;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64033;['decision is valid in law']
+93072;['rad is therefore not able to substitute its own determination']
+94749;['appeal is terminated']
+99618;['appeal is allowed']
+101208;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+46093;['dismiss the appeal']
+132631;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91018;['appeal be dismissed']
+102020;['appeal is dismissed']
+151361;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100107;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108997;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79963;['negative']
+151886;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71382;['dismiss this appeal']
+33693;['appeal is dismissed']
+78671;['appeal must be dismissed']
+82356;['dismiss the appeal', 'allow the appeal', 'dismiss the appeal', 'allow the appeal']
+148584;['appeal is dismissed']
+107553;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+90853;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96698;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+83057;['appeal is allowed']
+81167;['appeal is allowed']
+77487;['appeal isdismissed.']
+48597;['appeal is allowed']
+52363;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+152136;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91406;['appeal is allowed']
+60936;['appeal is dismissed']
+124482;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+100019;['reject his claim']
+86752;['claimants to be convention refugees', 'accepts their claims']
+82739;['appeal is dismissed']
+100389;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+139680;['appeal was dismissed']
+123463;['rpd determination is set aside', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+97961;['application is dismissed']
+123105;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+61624;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+122126;['appeal is allowed']
+81123;['302 (c.a.']
+123329;['appeal is allowed']
+130706;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+81896;['allows the minister’s application for dismissal of the appeal']
+92412;['allowed the appeal']
+90063;['claimant is a “convention refugee”']
+77869;['refugee protection division determines', 'claimant, not to be a convention refugee']
+57821;['appeal is allowed']
+92967;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+128299;['allow the appeal']
+68416;['appeal is allowed']
+77058;['appeal is determined']
+136678;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+22821;['appeal would be dismissed']
+105871;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not “convention refugees”']
+91179;['appeal should be allowed']
+60426;['appeal of rajinder kaur sandhu is dismissed']
+52604;['xxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+95357;['302 (c.a.']
+106645;['determine the claimant not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+122370;['appeal is allowed']
+42383;['appeal is dismissed']
+105331;['appeal is allowed']
+81614;['declare the case abandoned']
+149489;['rad finds that the federal court of appeal']
+128440;['302 (c.a.']
+102439;['ms. zhang is inadmissible to canada']
+135162;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100344;['claims of xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are rejected']
+103815;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim']
+76707;['appeal is dismissed']
+66918;['appeal isallowed']
+122555;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100175;['302 (c.a.']
+143541;['appeal is allowed']
+123792;['rad finds no error in this finding']
+83293;['rad denies the request for an oral hearing']
+52665;['minister’s application is allowed']
+73038;['dismiss this appeal']
+70092;['appeal is dismissed']
+145104;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+56740;['appeal isallowed']
+43479;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+123733;['not find that the applicant']
+95363;['appeal is dismissed']
+105778;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89259;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+84490;['determination is valid in law']
+66257;['appeal is dismissed']
+68131;['appeal of harpreet singhsodhiis allowed']
+94316;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+101694;['appeal isallowed']
+52772;['appeal is dismissed']
+88319;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+83633;['appeal is terminated']
+144244;['rad finds that the rpd decision cannot stand']
+60418;['appeal is allowed']
+130994;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+56754;['application isgranted.']
+100174;['claim is therefore rejected']
+59783;['appeal is allowed']
+107627;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+134295;['“regulations”']
+90490;['appeal of narendrabhai paragji patel be rescheduled']
+67634;['appeal is allowed']
+105777;['302 (c.a.']
+138289;['appeal is allowed']
+123359;['appeal is allowed']
+107671;['appellant is a refugee']
+140968;['302 (c.a.)']
+123259;['appeal is allowed']
+52314;['appeal is dismissed']
+116783;['substitute my determination']
+100653;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124765;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132655;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+139474;['appeal is allowed']
+71207;['appeal is allowed']
+77668;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+132737;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd rendered the right and correct decision']
+98444;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96668;['rpd is thus set aside']
+30388;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104937;['appeal is terminated']
+43329;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+67933;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99537;['appeal is allowed']
+136703;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a conventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123450;['decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123524;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55170;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98757;['appeal is also dismissed']
+117111;['appeal is dismissed']
+90654;['appeals should be dismissed']
+87169;['appeal is allowed.the']
+47318;['2005 decisionwas a final one']
+103206;['rad finds that this decision must be set aside']
+129400;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+68599;['appeal be allowed']
+47335;['appeal is allowed']
+67171;['appeal be allowed']
+106283;['appeal is dismissed']
+79190;['appeal is dismissed']
+99455;['claim is rejected']
+124300;['appeal is allowed']
+61221;['appeal is allowed']
+31982;['appeal is allowed']
+95827;['appeal be dismissed']
+111126;['appeal is dismissed']
+64570;['appeal is, therefore,dismissed']
+40651;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+90940;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+84636;['appeal isallowed']
+31450;['appeal is allowed']
+106148;['appeal is dismissed']
+100727;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+147615;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109623;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84325;['appeal should be dismissed']
+93732;['positive decision is rendered in his favour']
+100551;['appeal is allowed']
+98606;['appeal isallowed']
+59940;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+44088;['rad concurs with the rpd’s findings']
+116785;['appeal is allowed']
+73706;['appeal is allowed']
+77446;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+83549;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+46481;['appeal is allowed']
+97573;['appeal isallowed']
+69405;['appeal isallowed']
+47176;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+85865;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+89408;['appeal is terminated']
+76165;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+97778;['claimant is not credible']
+69466;['removal order isset aside']
+80455;['appeal were dismissed']
+128593;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+120803;['appeal is allowed']
+89109;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+80729;['appeal is allowed']
+98531;['negative']
+131001;['appeal is denied']
+69578;['appeals that decision to this tribunal']
+109036;['appeal is allowed.the']
+142452;['confirm the refugee protection division’s decision that', 'appellants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+123032;['allow the appeal']
+87481;['appeal is dismissed']
+99020;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+71254;['appeal is dismissed']
+99404;['appeal is dismissed']
+99595;['302 (c.a.']
+131204;['appeal of kulvinder kaur randhawa is allowed']
+87710;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+21461;['thatxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+94320;['appeal is allowed']
+87927;['reject the claims ofxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx']
+110914;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91056;['appeals are allowed']
+87841;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+101926;['appeal is allowed']
+18923;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+34629;['removal order is set aside']
+95937;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd’s decision']
+67634;['appeal isallowed']
+39066;['appeal is dismissed']
+77079;['removal order isset aside']
+115276;['appeal is allowed']
+29637;['appeal is terminated']
+75456;['appeal is dismissed']
+86203;['dismiss the appeal']
+84331;['appeal is dismissed']
+45864;['appeal isallowed']
+83378;['appeal is dismissed']
+99239;['appeal is allowed']
+72209;['appeal is allowed']
+140288;['appeal is dismissed']
+34698;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+13689;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124163;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+45408;['appeal is dismissed']
+62254;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+69955;['appeal is dismissed']
+118243;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67019;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102691;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34686;['dismiss this appeal']
+96422;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96733;['appeal is dismissed']
+143468;['appeal is based']
+46023;['appeal is allowed']
+136154;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96365;['302 (c.a.']
+49965;['302 (c.a.']
+131171;['appeal is allowed']
+95037;['appeal is terminated']
+90362;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123823;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+139459;['appellant is not a person described insection\xa063(2)of theact']
+149481;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+77071;['appeal isallowed']
+86384;['appeal isdismissed.']
+99936;['302 (c.a.']
+66930;['appeal is terminated']
+125342;['appeal is allowed']
+21443;['xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+90960;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144007;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96684;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+131056;['appeal is allowed']
+98700;['appeal isallowed']
+26800;['appeal is dismissed']
+142911;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+69399;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+29303;['appeal is denied']
+143547;['is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+100073;['appeal is dismissed']
+105364;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124300;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+44017;['rad concurs with the rpd']
+104280;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+42082;['appeal was dismissed']
+68304;['appeal of stephen patrick veness is dismissed']
+51045;['appeal is allowed']
+99911;['appeal is allowed.the']
+71167;['claimants are notconvention refugees']
+96362;['appeal is terminated']
+129191;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+111305;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+99856;['’ joint recommendation', 'appeal is allowed']
+80537;['appeal isallowed']
+108682;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+147611;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision that the', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+40120;['dismiss the appeal']
+56314;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98932;['negative']
+87979;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection']
+75150;['decision may not be binding on the iad']
+69702;['application is dismissed']
+82904;['appeal is allowed']
+70891;['appeal is allowed']
+99436;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+100415;['appeal should be dismissed']
+89415;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+81630;['appeal isallowed']
+67572;['decision of the immigration officer is well founded in law']
+96386;['appeal is allowed']
+94774;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+51824;['panel rejects the claims']
+43332;['appeal is allowed']
+122112;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100946;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+113583;['appeal is dismissed']
+52691;['not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection', 'panel rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+79996;['appeal is allowed']
+50537;['appeal is dismissed']
+132291;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a refugee within the meaning of the united nations convention', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+151724;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the determination']
+112425;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+55164;['appeal be dismissed']
+97928;['appeal of lance donald hayter is dismissed']
+153094;['allow the appeal']
+96173;['appeal is dismissed']
+69174;['appeal is dismissed']
+144246;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76656;['appeal is allowed']
+105307;['302 (c.a.']
+88269;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+64130;['dismissing the appeal']
+90327;['negative']
+66656;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52144;['appeal is allowed']
+88981;['appeal isallowed']
+35227;['appeal is allowed']
+87284;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+83252;['appeals are allowed']
+151911;['appeal is allowed']
+95412;['appeal isallowed']
+91113;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84016;['appeal isallowed.the']
+98747;['appeals aredismissedand a']
+50646;['appeal is based']
+74054;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+72835;['appeal isallowed']
+63079;['constitution provides for']
+77646;['appeal isallowed']
+55184;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+87735;['appeal is allowed']
+43334;['appeal of tejinder kaur bhattal is dismissed']
+103006;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+86645;['appeal is dismissed']
+94342;['appeal is allowed']
+105206;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+62637;['appeal is dismissed']
+107170;['rad rejects this explanation']
+39897;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94342;['appeal is allowed']
+21097;['appeal is dismissed']
+133695;['substitute my own determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare']
+107914;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+89354;['appeal is allowed']
+151332;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+30517;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+12248;['appeal is allowed']
+38787;['appeal is dismissed']
+76707;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+113591;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+63001;['appeal is allowed']
+108801;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+123594;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146969;['appeal is dismissed']
+61304;['appeal is allowed']
+131521;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80506;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'theremoval order is set aside']
+53130;['appeal is dismissed']
+76161;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+68115;['appeal is dismissed']
+86943;['appeal is terminated']
+108783;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96840;['tribunal dismisses the appeal']
+89361;['appeal is dismissed']
+107487;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+148691;['appeal to be dismissed']
+68079;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+99924;['appeal is dismissed']
+96847;['appeal is allowed']
+105777;['claim is rejected']
+105786;['appeal is allowed']
+50503;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+34709;['appeal is dismissed']
+97640;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89229;['302 (c.a.)']
+99688;['application is denied']
+82027;['appeal is terminated']
+73039;['appeal is allowed']
+74179;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56379;['appeal is not allowed']
+71573;['appeal isallowed']
+101146;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+77124;['appeal is allowed']
+123619;['appeal is allowed']
+80483;['appeal is dismissed']
+46983;['appeal is allowed']
+123731;['decision of the visa officer is set aside']
+94711;['applicants are not persons described in s. 117(1)(f) of theregulationsand']
+87828;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+122545;['hcr/eg/col/15/01 at footnote 21']
+99578;['appeal is allowed']
+91270;['appeal is allowed']
+70090;['appeal is allowed']
+99318;['appeal is dismissed']
+105622;['claimant, xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+125441;['appeal is dismissed']
+75966;['nor the authority to revise the officer’s decision']
+138827;['appeal is abandoned']
+103616;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140900;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+70102;['appeal is determined']
+96283;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+24464;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140946;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45421;['appeal be dismissed']
+143549;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+24498;['appeal is allowed']
+134734;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee']
+54682;['appeal was dismissed']
+66311;['appeal is dismissed']
+151554;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is excluded from refugee protection']
+131528;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+64844;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76974;['appeal isallowed']
+124920;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+69405;['appeal is allowed in law']
+84259;['dismissed the appeal']
+62869;['appeal bedismissed.']
+101711;['appeal isallowed']
+125014;['appeal is allowed']
+108759;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+77344;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+47615;['302 (c.a.']
+84700;['departure order is set aside']
+80026;['not a convention refugee']
+108191;['appeal is dismissed']
+60054;['allows this appeal']
+102418;['appeal is dismissed']
+86025;['appeal were dismissed']
+100725;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54709;['appeal is allowed']
+81092;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+27309;['appeal is allowed']
+123792;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82226;['appeal isallowed']
+94268;['negative determination of the rpd']
+110715;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+31398;['appeal is allowed']
+97449;['claimant is neither a convention\xa0refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76447;['appeal abandoned']
+77897;['appeal of joshua adeyemi odufuwa is dismissed']
+27339;['appeal is allowed']
+123855;['rad finds that the rpd’s credibility conclusion is correct']
+104123;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject this claim']
+99428;['leads me to infer that the']
+101496;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+47805;['dismissing the appeal']
+134217;['immigration officer’s decision is therefore valid in law']
+149067;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74672;['appeal isallowed']
+117189;['neither his refugee application']
+95894;['appeal be allowed']
+107062;['appeal is allowed']
+110987;['appellant was not a convention refugee']
+75670;['appeal isallowed']
+82235;['302 (c.a.']
+59861;['302 (c.a.)']
+100569;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+62888;['appeal proceeded by way of a hearingde novo']
+152389;['rpd decision is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+49707;['appeal is dismissed']
+68302;['appeal of hguon ho don is dismissed']
+88903;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+94432;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+71557;['appeal isallowed']
+104477;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+70665;['appeal is terminated']
+18008;['appeal isallowed']
+123987;['rad allows the appeal and refers the matter to the rpd']
+101478;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+71691;['appeal is dismissed']
+98487;['appeal is dismissed']
+57920;['allows this appeal']
+76942;['appeal isallowed']
+132443;['302 (c.a.']
+95822;['appeal is dismissed']
+139443;['appeals are allowed']
+100867;['appeal is dismissed']
+151794;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107933;['appeal is accepted']
+74507;['appeal is dismissed']
+45612;['appeal is dismissed']
+76310;['appeal is being allowed']
+64255;['appeal isallowed']
+55195;['reject his claim']
+124894;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+93329;['appeal is dismissed']
+89209;['appeal is allowed']
+108672;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+58134;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+86860;['appeal is dismissed']
+134432;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+127340;['appeals are allowed']
+138857;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+122628;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+84828;['appeal is allowed']
+122952;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+135903;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96361;['appeal is dismissed']
+69367;['appeal is dismissed']
+87806;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+141614;['appeal is rejected']
+8336;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection\xa0168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+99967;['allow the appeal and return it to processing']
+82182;['appeal is allowed']
+139454;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+100057;['claimantsare not “convention refugees”']
+124452;['dismiss the appeal']
+38779;['appeal is dismissed']
+98494;['appeal is allowed']
+98414;['removal order is set aside']
+104387;['appeal isallowed']
+133403;['appeal was dismissed']
+80238;['refugee protection division determines that the first, second, third and fourth claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims to refugee protection']
+146934;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+107611;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appeal is dismissed']
+44987;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+132432;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71799;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+144267;['appeal to the iad of his deportation order, dismissed']
+134421;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+102084;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+84241;['appeal isallowed']
+141160;['removal order is set aside']
+55250;['panel accepts his claim for refugee protection']
+121417;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134278;['“regulations”']
+143228;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+122814;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+72862;['appeal must be dismissed']
+8291;['appeal should be dismissed']
+142059;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+134497;['appeal is allowed']
+82703;['appeal is allowed']
+91621;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+90313;['302 (c.a.']
+101176;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+89810;['appeal is allowed']
+38873;['removal order is set aside']
+40079;['appeal is dismissed']
+124039;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the   ', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need   of protection']
+58311;['appeal is allowed']
+64251;['appeal be dismissed']
+114422;['appeal is allowed']
+101322;['appeal is dismissed']
+143021;['appeal is dismissed']
+46514;['appeal is dismissed']
+98164;['appeal is dismissed']
+50736;['appeal be dismissed']
+54826;['appeal is allowed']
+88056;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+45985;['appeal is dismissed']
+128895;['302 (c.a.']
+124202;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+151958;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102557;['appeal is dismissed']
+98525;['appeal is denied']
+84816;['appeals are dismissed']
+120785;['rad is not able to either substitute its own determination', 'confirm the rpd’s decision for different reasons']
+89736;['appeal has been abandoned']
+80038;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+80692;['appeal isallowed']
+128366;['appellant is not a person described insection 133(1)(e)(ii) of theregulations']
+38865;['appeal isdismissed.']
+125332;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+117116;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90743;['negative determination', 'substitutes it with the determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+71583;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+26469;['application is dismissed']
+42394;['removal orders are set aside']
+13930;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+20003;['appeal is allowed']
+94173;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108802;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+108754;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+91353;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+146938;['respondents are neither convention refugees pursuant to section 96 of the act', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+86396;['appeal is allowed']
+105655;['appeal is allowed']
+69612;['dismissing the appeal']
+96980;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+87205;"[""dismissing the appellant's appeal""]"
+143642;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98445;['adc also dismissed the appellant’s application to appear']
+71432;['iad dismisses this appeal']
+107805;['claimants are not “convention refugees”', 'rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+51743;['appeals are dismissed']
+100887;['claimants, mr.xxxx xxxx, ms.xxxx xxxxand mr.xxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+99830;['appeal were dismissed']
+98268;['appeal is allowed']
+89573;['appeal isallowed']
+86944;['appeal is allowed']
+94277;['confirm the determination of therpdthat', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+103205;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71792;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+144405;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'the associate appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx,are neither refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection', 'appeals are dismissed']
+150354;['302 (c.a.']
+118137;['deny the appeal with', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54758;['appeal isallowed']
+77024;['302 (c.a.']
+153156;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90671;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77793;['appeal to the iad dismissed']
+131700;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+104086;['panel reject his claim']
+85442;['appeals are dismissed']
+36084;['appeal of thanh thanh nguyen is allowed']
+71149;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+68919;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+93689;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+106283;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77281;['appeal must fail']
+124687;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86451;['appeal is terminated']
+108934;['302 (c.a.']
+90981;['appeal should be dismissed']
+99559;['appeal is allowed']
+145061;['claim is rejected']
+60939;['sponsor is not yet a permanent resident or citizen']
+89402;['appeal is dismissed']
+42292;['appeal was dismissed']
+77827;['panel rejects his claim', 'thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugees and is not a person in need of protection']
+100712;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+87394;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125515;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+78125;['claimants, not to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+96274;['negative']
+90742;['302 (c.a.']
+71185;['appeal is allowed']
+151968;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92566;['appeal is terminated']
+47219;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+95072;['not a “convention refugee”']
+107033;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+76912;['appeal is allowed']
+142977;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+88300;['appeal isallowed']
+56686;['panel orders the registrar’s office to set a new hearing date']
+92713;['appeal is allowed']
+70006;['appeal is allowed']
+103902;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+77839;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+110716;['appeal is allowed']
+43739;['appeal is dismissed']
+19385;['appeal stands or falls']
+142075;['302 (c.a.']
+80781;['negative']
+99690;['appeal is allowed']
+153282;['appeal is dismissed']
+122869;['appeal is allowed']
+105891;['appeal is dismissed']
+47155;['appeal is dismissed']
+150925;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74541;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+103713;['302 (c.a.']
+104077;['appeal is allowed']
+12842;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection', 'application is rejected']
+31966;['appeal is dismissed']
+86337;['appeal isallowedand']
+77110;['dismiss the appeal']
+94687;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+150671;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143633;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94865;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+68783;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96505;['appeal is dismissed']
+42303;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+129405;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108058;['302 (c.a.']
+150643;['overturn the rpd’s credibility finding']
+144028;['appeal is allowed']
+74814;['appeal is dismissed']
+93894;['appeal is allowed.the']
+86312;['appeals are dismissed']
+153574;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+73705;['appeal is allowed']
+94503;['appeal is dismissed']
+17156;['appeal is dismissed']
+112777;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+110301;['appeal is allowed']
+78062;['appeal is dismissed']
+96209;['appeal isallowed']
+60941;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+65117;['appeal is dismissed']
+91354;['appeal is dismissed']
+131057;['appeal is allowed']
+84322;['appeal is terminated']
+97088;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105769;['sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+75600;['appeal isallowed']
+75925;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+74036;['appeal isallowed']
+110313;['appeal is dismissed']
+130957;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141658;['appeal is allowed']
+74987;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+54180;['appeal is allowed']
+129871;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+125217;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94500;['appeal still fails']
+100385;['dismiss the appeal']
+87175;['appeal is dismissed']
+76612;['appeal isabandonedpursuant tosubsection\xa0']
+143154;['appeal is allowed']
+96028;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+102880;['application for an extension of time', 'appeal are therefore dismissed']
+83373;['appeal is allowed']
+14670;['claimant, xxxx xxx xxxx, who is excluded from the provisions of the convention', 'not a convention refugee']
+107859;['appeal is dismissed']
+94332;['appeal is dismissed']
+67691;['appeal is allowed']
+18004;['appeal isallowed']
+146635;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+74572;['appeal is dismissed']
+97460;['claimants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92999;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+76798;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95546;['appeal is dismissed']
+87825;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+24203;['appeal is dismissed']
+98845;['appeal is allowed']
+90972;['appeal isallowed']
+76397;['appeal isallowed']
+98873;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67587;['appeal is allowed']
+84012;['302 (c.a.']
+142438;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination that the appellantsxxxx', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62886;['appeal isallowed']
+135127;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+56699;['appeal bedismissed.']
+59837;['leads me to conclude that the']
+81642;['appeal isallowed']
+93766;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+47800;['appeal is dismissed']
+103498;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+143611;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+104072;['appeal is allowed']
+52137;['rad cannot find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+80982;['rad finds the decision of the rpd to be wrong in law']
+53137;['appeal isallowed']
+47716;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94145;['appeal is allowed']
+96748;['appeal is dismissed']
+52088;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+93098;['irb’s guideline on women refugee']
+61375;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+134221;['decision of the visa officer is not legally valid']
+103899;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68095;['appeal is allowed']
+97794;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+98586;['allows this appeal', 'quashes the removal order made against the appellant']
+142842;['appeal is allowed']
+50742;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+107109;['stay is cancelled']
+134313;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+109288;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+28373;['appeal is dismissed']
+94628;['appeal is dismissed']
+69145;['appeal is dismissed']
+99714;['appeal must fail']
+73302;['appeal is allowed']
+95994;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'panel rejects her claim']
+86274;['appeal isallowed']
+97641;['panel rejects this claim']
+151928;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+152003;['appeal was dismissed']
+86390;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+153732;['removal order is set aside']
+107840;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision, cannot substitute its own determination']
+123827;['302 (c.a.']
+97567;['appeal of huu lam pham is dismissed']
+94759;['dismiss the appeal']
+87992;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+69952;['appeal should be allowed or dismissed']
+68554;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+121674;['appeal is allowed']
+97483;['panel rejects the claims for refugee protection']
+49578;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+88159;['appeal is dismissed']
+142515;['302 (c.a.']
+95046;['appeal is dismissed']
+96584;['appeal is allowed']
+57566;['appeal is dismissed']
+51284;['appeal isallowed']
+40065;['allow the appeal']
+69354;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+82436;['appeal is dismissed']
+82800;['appeal isallowed']
+74714;['appeal is allowed']
+150157;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+77859;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+132817;['appeal was dismissed']
+133735;['appeal is dismissed']
+74672;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89029;['negative']
+52300;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+69417;['appeal is allowed']
+142107;['rejects this claim']
+50453;['rad also confirms the rpd’s determination in part', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+141042;['rpd’s determination is correct and confirmed by the rad']
+110718;['appeal is dismissed']
+136119;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+107049;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+134419;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+82376;['removal order isset aside']
+61216;['302 (c.a.']
+146447;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78025;['appeal is dismissed']
+98464;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+74718;['302 (c.a.']
+71792;['appeal isallowed']
+146543;['appeal is dismissed']
+23644;['removal order is set aside']
+133182;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+21352;"['not a ""convention refugee']"
+151477;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+108063;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38782;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+106185;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant and the sons are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+143863;['appeal is allowed']
+107483;['appeal is dismissed']
+90177;['302 (c.a.']
+91281;['appeal isallowed']
+97493;['panel therefore rejects their claim']
+118143;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+70662;['allow the appeal']
+46478;['declares the appeal abandoned']
+83659;['appeal is terminated']
+95140;['appeal is dismissed']
+18930;['appeal of michael teye mensah is allowed']
+82071;['appeals with respect to olalekan temitope kolawole and oluwakemi olajumoke kolawole are dismissed']
+123342;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+46028;['appeal was dismissed']
+96850;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124615;['nor a risk of cruel or unusual punishment', 'nor torture']
+89024;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83092;['appeal is dismissed']
+42315;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+105345;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+79941;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+103547;['appeal is dismissed']
+90902;['appeal is dismissed']
+30540;['appeal is dismissed']
+113228;['appeal were dismissed']
+152216;['application to reopen the appeal dated july 13, 2021, is dismissed']
+140209;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+27300;['appeal isallowed']
+148776;['appeal is dismissed.conclusion']
+86404;['appeal isallowed']
+95759;['refugee protection division may reject the application']
+71463;['appeal is dismissed']
+131917;['removal order is set aside']
+28079;['appeal is dismissed']
+79930;['negative']
+105366;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd’s decision', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+80288;['negative']
+95070;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+74701;['appeal brought by the appellants with respect to their residency obligation is dismissed']
+143613;['appeal dismissed']
+91179;['appeal isallowed']
+80367;['appeal is terminated']
+40134;['appeal is dismissed']
+58569;['appeal isallowed']
+91201;['appeal is allowed']
+39584;['appeal is dismissed']
+47581;['appeal is allowed']
+94899;['refugee protection division therefore, rejects the claims for refugee protection']
+100832;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'ms. xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “persons in need of protection']
+29601;['removal order isset aside']
+76569;['appeal isallowed']
+94092;['appeal is allowed']
+143600;['appellants are therefore convention refugees']
+100313;['302 (c.a.']
+87381;['appeal is dismissed']
+90776;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76392;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+108792;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+37065;['dismiss the appeal']
+91558;['appeal isdismissed.']
+100531;['panel therefore rejects the claims']
+98734;['warssama is not a refugee']
+143194;['302 (c.a.']
+69325;['appeal ofhina kausar-ahmadwith respect to her husbandsami ullahis allowed']
+146456;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+86407;['302 (c.a.)']
+90047;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+37901;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+89571;['appeal isallowed']
+87848;['appeal is allowed']
+73319;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+72649;['appeal was dismissed']
+26942;['convention refugee determination division determines xxxxx xxxxxx xxx to be a convention refugee']
+105786;['appeal is allowed']
+91713;['appeal is dismissed']
+4624;['appeal isallowed']
+123861;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+42337;['theappeal is allowed']
+143889;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+80304;['reject his claim']
+98572;['appeal is allowed']
+90020;['allow the appeal']
+76094;['dismissing this appeal']
+84544;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89803;['allows this appeal']
+74177;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+91733;['allow the appeal']
+84412;['appeal is terminated']
+72078;['appeal isallowed']
+113247;['appeal is allowed']
+26473;['appeal of marilou ponon gayos is allowed']
+76806;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+107136;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+138882;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+146638;['allows the application to reopen']
+145830;['appeal is allowed']
+73684;['appeal is terminated']
+128922;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'neither “refugees”']
+91253;['appeal of estelita sajonia garbino is dismissed']
+142972;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+68247;['appeal isallowed']
+99966;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+91736;['removal order is set aside']
+93320;['appeal is dismissed']
+79473;['appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+52340;['appeal is allowed']
+143906;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69245;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+49978;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+128548;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95068;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+141047;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132838;['appeal is allowed']
+77541;['appeal is dismissed']
+90439;['appeals are allowed']
+59806;['appeal isallowed']
+122947;['302 (c.a.']
+131040;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+23846;['appeal is allowed']
+102798;['appeal is dismissed']
+80193;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+105312;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128399;['appeal is dismissed']
+81854;['appeal is dismissed']
+79873;['appeal is allowed']
+140906;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+37156;['appeal is terminated']
+26934;['not determine the claimant to be a convention refugee']
+152136;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+75617;['appeal is terminated']
+105849;['dismissing this appeal']
+82199;['appeal is dismissed']
+106836;['appeal is allowed']
+76054;['appeals are dismissed']
+84763;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+132922;['appeal is allowed']
+107632;['determinations are valid in law']
+70766;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+103660;['claimants are not people in need of protection']
+93192;['appeal should be allowed']
+123891;['substitute my finding']
+93311;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+77858;['not a person in need of protection']
+90552;['tribunal\xa0dismisses the appeal']
+61972;['appeal is dismissed']
+146927;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+50795;['appeal is allowed']
+152006;['appeal is dismissed']
+13833;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+78719;['appeal of simarjeet kaur sandhu is dismissed']
+46107;['appeals are allowed']
+57955;['appeal be dismissed']
+50354;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+69721;['appeal be dismissed']
+66918;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99403;['appeal is allowed']
+151779;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is inadmissible to canada']
+90936;['appeal is rejected']
+86853;['appeal is allowed']
+142893;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+125483;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+128442;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+106328;['appeal is allowed']
+144032;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95186;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+37865;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+105713;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination rendered', 'substitutes its own determination']
+26910;['not convention refugeesas']
+102469;['appeal is allowed']
+71641;['appeal isallowed']
+85248;['appeal is allowed']
+101243;['appeal is allowed']
+87996;['assembly passed a law on religious freedom']
+123356;['appeal is dismissed']
+28589;['appeal is dismissed']
+76687;['appeal of hour long khy is allowed']
+105854;['dismiss the appeal']
+143282;['appeal is dismissed']
+94929;['appeal terminated']
+147779;['appeal is allowed']
+96978;['appeal is terminated']
+46475;['appeal is terminated']
+144386;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95355;['appeal is dismissed']
+91702;['appeal is dismissed']
+150732;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76136;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77572;['appeal is allowed']
+68331;['appeal is dismissed']
+47361;['appeal is dismissed']
+67360;['deportation is not valid in law']
+90603;['removal order is set aside']
+68245;['appeal isallowed']
+106860;['appeal is allowed']
+13698;['appeal is terminated']
+136668;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99934;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47180;['appeal of labh singh raika is dismissed']
+57910;['appeal is dismissed']
+110964;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81269;['appeal is dismissed']
+51134;['appeal isallowed']
+130725;['dismiss the appeal']
+31225;['appeal of the refusal']
+125167;['appeals are allowed']
+107074;['appeal was dismissed']
+23005;['appeal is dismissed']
+124463;['appeal is allowed']
+94329;['appeal is allowed']
+91182;['appeal is terminated']
+85976;['appeal should be dismissed']
+47319;['appeal is allowed']
+64043;['appeal is allowed']
+60030;['negative']
+94136;['appeal must be dismissed']
+127731;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+143169;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87367;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+47355;['appeal of manjit kaur bains is allowed']
+70091;['appeal isallowed']
+44037;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+136073;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+19144;['dismiss the appeal']
+129735;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+96349;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+95479;['appeal is dismissed']
+62940;['appeal is allowed']
+83385;['appeal isallowed']
+124182;['appellant is excluded from international protection']
+84636;['exclusion order is set aside']
+125006;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130972;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+96035;['appeal is dismissed']
+71229;['appeal is dismissed']
+85502;['appeal is dismissed']
+77295;['appeal is dismissed']
+56631;['appeal is dismissed']
+71812;['appeal is dismissed']
+54799;['appeal is allowed']
+143604;['appeal is allowed']
+100793;['appeal is terminated']
+78776;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+139858;['substitute its determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+79189;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123973;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+97794;['tribunal rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+47397;['appeal is allowed']
+99570;['appeal fails']
+122673;['appeal is dismissed']
+29687;['appeal is dismissed']
+30508;['appeal is dismissed']
+19138;['allow the appeal']
+94359;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+67409;['dismiss this appeal']
+89343;['not a convention refugee', 'reject her claim']
+98479;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+118236;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+59046;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+125507;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107137;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+64300;['appeal is dismissed']
+100404;['appeal is dismissed']
+141658;['appeal is allowed']
+134235;['appeal is allowed']
+150734;['appellant is a “person in need of']
+77460;['302 (c.a.']
+19172;['appeals are dismissed']
+64305;['appeal of galareh farhadian is allowed']
+109617;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+134746;['substitutes its finding that the principal appellant and the minor appellant']
+74885;['appeal is allowed']
+101850;['appeal isallowed']
+92495;['appeal is dismissed']
+97373;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+50760;['appeal is allowed']
+64043;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87844;['appeal isallowed']
+84713;['appeal is allowed']
+138826;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74597;['appeal is dismissed']
+70643;['appeal is allowed']
+69173;['appeal be and is hereby dismissed']
+91160;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+55113;['appeal is allowed']
+101366;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+54656;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+143543;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143228;['appeal is dismissed']
+49533;['appeal isallowed']
+80735;['claimants are determined to be convention refugees']
+12213;['302 (c.a.']
+108270;['not find him to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+147006;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+25985;['appeal isallowed']
+68089;['appeal is dismissed']
+150336;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+88514;['claimant not to be a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+71088;['appeals with respect to both the applicants are dismissed']
+99212;['appeal is dismissed']
+124909;['appeal must be dismissed']
+134745;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee']
+30383;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+40379;['appeal is terminated']
+142896;['allow the principal appellant’s appeal']
+127722;['appeal is determined']
+79320;['appeal is dismissed']
+102550;['appeal is allowed']
+54806;['appeal is allowed']
+99708;['appeals are allowed']
+56952;['appeal is allowed']
+93879;['appeal is allowed']
+60027;['negative']
+95099;['claimant to not be a convention refugee']
+123290;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+146222;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+95421;['appeal is allowed']
+76511;['appeal isallowed']
+84735;['dismiss his appeal']
+71062;['negative']
+57093;['appeal is dismissed']
+23970;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+100508;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+72140;['appeal isallowed']
+120968;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+20000;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107504;['rad finds that the rpd findings in this regard']
+123367;['rpd decision must be set aside']
+147791;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination', 'not substitute its own decision to that of the rpd']
+99413;['appeal is dismissed']
+56799;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+103050;['appeal is dismissed']
+76835;['removal order is set aside']
+108084;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+102024;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+70168;['appeal is allowed']
+112398;['appeal is dismissed']
+51712;['appeal is dismissed']
+88144;['appeal is terminated']
+99990;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+58749;['appeal is dismissed']
+100734;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+105657;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+62849;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+38162;['appeal is dismissed']
+136738;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94397;['immigration   officer’s decision is valid in law']
+96616;['appeal were dismissed']
+122932;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+80780;['claimants are in need of refugee protection']
+99376;['appeal must be dismissed']
+75869;['appeal is dismissed']
+52501;['appeal isallowed']
+54704;['appeal is dismissed']
+95158;['nor a person in need of protection']
+142793;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+108864;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither “convention refugees”']
+148626;['appeal is dismissed']
+122875;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+73363;['appeals of yih wen lin and yi jiun lin areallowed']
+96159;['appeal is allowed']
+94423;['appeal is allowed']
+61950;['appeal of shu sen gu is dismissed']
+124925;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96815;['appeal is dismissed']
+87687;['appeal is allowed']
+125361;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100024;['appeal is terminated']
+122998;['appeal is allowed']
+115177;['theappealis dismissed']
+85857;['or a person in need of protection']
+66783;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76738;['appeal is allowed']
+93306;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+102963;['rad finds that the rpd did not provide adequate reasons']
+123823;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+102745;['decision of the immigration division cannot stand']
+143540;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96673;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+54809;['302 (c.a.']
+91123;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+105304;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99370;['iad remains without jurisdiction']
+26743;['appeal under section 77(3)(a) ofthe immigration actis dismissed']
+61061;['appeal is allowed']
+31985;['appeal is allowed']
+142692;['appeal is allowed']
+96901;['claim is rejected']
+88022;['claimants are convention refugees']
+58313;['appellant is convention refugee']
+87505;['appeal is dismissed']
+123416;['appeal is allowed']
+98634;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+81163;['appeal is allowed']
+62837;['appeal is allowed']
+107154;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+62392;['appeal is allowed']
+49161;['appellant lost permanent resident status']
+74887;['appeal isallowed']
+100618;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+136710;['substitute my determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+151299;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97279;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+106936;['rad sets aside the rpd determination']
+93120;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+62832;['appeal is dismissed']
+85166;['appeal’s relative merit']
+77027;['appeal is allowed']
+124370;['appeal is allowed']
+123741;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99020;['reject his claim']
+100856;['thatxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+76355;['appeal must fail']
+124391;['appeal is allowed']
+125615;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85625;['appeal isallowed']
+46106;['appeal is terminated']
+121415;['appeal is allowed']
+120822;['appeal is allowed']
+147886;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+98884;['302 (c.a.']
+100733;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+73195;['appeal is allowed']
+89313;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+47371;['appeal is dismissed']
+124578;['appeal is dismissed']
+71550;['appeal must be dismissed']
+122129;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+22819;['appeal is dismissed']
+89093;['claimant is not in need of protection']
+79198;['appeal is allowed']
+104452;['appeal be allowed']
+21939;['appeal should be dismissed']
+50352;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is he a “person in need of protection']
+89463;['appeal is dismissed']
+34101;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+117109;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+101892;['appeal isallowed']
+107636;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+92607;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+134386;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+30493;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate consideration']
+46242;['appeal is dismissed']
+97915;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+96496;['appeal isallowed']
+113270;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99931;['appeal is dismissed']
+100675;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+108874;['claimants not to be convention refugees unders']
+123962;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121947;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80192;['refugee protection division rejects the claims made by xxxxxxxxxxand xxxxx xxxxx']
+101318;['appeal is allowed']
+19162;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96178;['appeals were dismissed']
+71238;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+47608;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+97369;['appeal isallowed']
+102676;['appeal is dismissed']
+142296;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56824;['appeal bedismissed.']
+28100;['appeals are allowed']
+145756;['sur place claim is dismissed']
+121565;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+89837;['appeal is allowed']
+81623;['appeal is dismissed']
+52323;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made', 'appellant xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+101920;['appeal isallowed']
+42285;['appeal is withdrawn']
+48617;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+45237;['allow the appeal ofxxxxxxxxxxin law']
+46080;['allows this appeal']
+100098;['appeals are dismissed']
+122872;['appeal is allowed']
+56794;['302 (c.a.']
+72836;['appeal is dismissed']
+123834;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+62442;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+34685;['dismiss the appeal']
+94467;['appeal is allowed']
+55266;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+71043;['negative']
+123776;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80718;['302 (c.a.']
+94778;['appeal is dismissed']
+101237;['allow the appeal']
+89217;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+93321;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99083;['panel rejects this claim']
+148986;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+153264;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+28099;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+70422;['appeal is dismissed']
+128170;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+105369;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68989;['appeal isallowed']
+97813;['not a convention refugee']
+130717;['appeal is allowed']
+103876;['302 (c.a.']
+87236;['claim is rejected']
+83483;['appeal is dismissed']
+53865;['appeal is dismissed']
+135160;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+38391;['appeal is dismissed']
+146565;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+123669;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “refugee”']
+108775;['rad concurs with the rpd']
+111012;['appeal is dismissed']
+84561;['appeal is terminated']
+69599;['appeal isallowed']
+61904;['appeal is subject']
+88718;['appeal isallowed']
+62204;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+28301;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+70473;['appeal isdismissed.']
+60122;['negative']
+149478;['appeal is dismissed']
+142481;['substitutes a determination that the respondent is excluded']
+95228;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+121454;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx \xa0xxxx \xa0xxxx \xa0xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection”']
+123837;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+133363;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis aconvention refugee']
+39054;['appeal is allowed']
+98993;['appeal is dismissed']
+101256;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+52192;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+62893;['appeal is allowed']
+123110;['ifa fails in both safety and reasonableness']
+97603;['appeal is dismissed']
+113634;['allow the appeal']
+150650;['appellant is a convention refugee', 'substitute a positive decision']
+99040;['appeal is dismissed']
+72671;"[""officer's decision is set aside""]"
+123054;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+69078;['appeal is dismissed']
+21466;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+99304;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+133276;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim']
+113791;['appeal is dismissed']
+130796;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+55516;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+108956;['appeal is allowed']
+101053;['appeal is dismissed']
+123598;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56722;['appeal is dismissed']
+39916;['appeal is allowed']
+73332;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+150934;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42229;['appeal is allowed']
+124270;['appeal is dismissed']
+145385;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+54743;['appeal isallowed']
+123412;['dismiss the appellant', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108931;['appeal is allowed']
+68925;['appeal is dismissed']
+123323;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+101269;['submission is rejected']
+99175;['appeal is allowed']
+124314;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+121873;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+49568;['appeal is allowed']
+98518;['appeal is terminated']
+44177;['rad confirms the determination of the psb', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99638;['appeal isallowed']
+148709;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57527;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+112385;['appeal is allowed']
+61373;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+62403;['nor a comprehensive risk assessment']
+98427;['appeal is determined']
+98534;['allows this appeal']
+125387;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61830;['appeal must fail']
+86022;['appeal is allowed']
+143866;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34691;['appeal is dismissed']
+113630;['appeal is dismissed']
+151812;['substitute a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+113733;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130919;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+99376;['dismiss the appeal']
+81138;['appeal was dismissed']
+95824;['appeal was set down for hearing']
+133271;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86625;['302 (c.a.']
+81145;['appeal is allowed']
+72651;['dismisses this appeal']
+144011;['appeal is dismissed']
+71080;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+99942;['negative']
+127337;['appeal is dismissed']
+61809;['negative']
+60193;['appeal isallowed']
+129249;['appeal is allowed']
+99467;['appeal of the principal appellant, majid shahlavi, is dismissed']
+59811;['appeal is allowed']
+61887;['appeal is allowed']
+146875;['appeal is allowed']
+107502;['rad finds that the rpd’s credibility findings are insufficient']
+79192;['appeal is dismissed']
+140744;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+38835;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+67797;['appellants have not lost their permanent residency status']
+83669;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+125613;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57916;['appeal isallowed']
+40156;['appeal is allowed']
+53826;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+91705;['appeal is allowed']
+123411;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+108721;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+70417;['appeal of kwun kit ngan is dismissed']
+68296;['appeal is allowed']
+83372;['appeal is allowed']
+94657;['appeal is allowed']
+89263;['appeal is allowed.the']
+91209;['appeal is allowed']
+92959;['appeal isallowedand']
+100251;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+100310;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+96234;['appeal is dismissed']
+57955;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+26699;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+152703;['appeal is dismissed']
+114348;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67615;['appeal isallowed']
+103890;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60921;['appeal is dismissed']
+121479;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+34885;['appeal is allowed']
+85676;['rad finds that the rpd decision contains palpable and overriding errors', 'substitutes a determination']
+129254;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+13985;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107925;['appeal is allowed']
+120802;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+99382;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+145437;['appeal is allowed']
+91193;['appeal is allowed']
+67603;['appeal isallowed']
+68299;['appeal is dismissed']
+110915;['appeal is dismissed']
+67175;['appeal is dismissed']
+74623;['appeal is dismissed']
+101172;['dismiss the appeal']
+75504;['appeal is dismissed']
+71624;['appeal is not allowed']
+96323;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+151472;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86475;['appeals of royce henry damian de souza and patricia de souza are allowed']
+143601;['appeal is allowed']
+103909;['application to reopen must be dismissed']
+40149;['allows the appeal']
+100808;['appeal isallowed']
+95906;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93875;['appeal is dismissed']
+65677;['appeal isallowed']
+76905;['appeal is allowed']
+109690;['appeal was dismissed']
+77228;['appeal of xitij rajeshkumar shah is declaredabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+61807;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+66630;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123848;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+115218;['rad is in no position to substitute its own determination of the appellant’s refugee claim']
+103022;['these claims fail']
+130745;['appeal of henain tehini is dismissed']
+94258;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+60825;['appeal is allowed']
+84011;['appeal is allowed']
+40663;['appeal is allowed']
+47552;['appeal is determined']
+98361;['appeal were dismissed']
+97502;['neither convention refugees']
+52044;['appeal is dismissed']
+151878;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86105;['appeal isallowed']
+99467;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+96361;['appeal is dismissed']
+151499;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+134209;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+26860;['appeal is dismissed']
+149449;['appeal is dismissed']
+66774;['appeal of qi jin cheng is allowed']
+89271;['appeal is allowed']
+138835;['appeal is dismissed']
+66772;['302 (c.a.)']
+100305;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+75463;['appeal is allowed']
+104971;['removal order is set aside']
+61436;['appeal is allowed']
+81929;['appeal is dismissed']
+75442;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+63722;['appeal is allowed']
+92074;['appeal is allowed']
+145748;['removal order is set aside']
+124963;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73897;['removal order is set aside']
+105296;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+90119;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+140961;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90207;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+76732;['appeal of santokh singh ponaich is allowed']
+84609;['appeal is subject to a finding ofres judicata']
+100076;['appeal is allowed']
+97352;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+41566;['appeal is dismissed']
+34165;['appeal isallowed']
+71701;['appeal is dismissed']
+98917;['negative']
+70657;['appeal is terminated']
+135194;['appeal is dismissed']
+43719;['allow her appeal.']
+128296;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+107231;['i agree with the rpd’s conclusions']
+56499;['appeal isallowed']
+129872;['appeal is allowed']
+97324;['appeal is dismissed']
+97886;['appeal is dismissed']
+91910;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95247;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123589;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+52741;['rad has found that the rpd decision can stand on its own merit']
+148996;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+86404;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59807;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95091;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+76699;['appeal is allowed']
+50736;['visa officer’s determination is valid in law']
+124970;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52034;['allows the minister’s application to dismiss the appeal']
+127730;['appeal is allowed']
+89997;['he is not a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+79326;['appeal is terminated']
+35154;['appeal is allowed']
+52638;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”,for']
+94298;['claimants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx,are not “convention refugees”']
+101324;['appeal were dismissed']
+94034;['appeal isallowed']
+84456;['appeal is allowed']
+114420;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+36105;['appeal be dismissed']
+109169;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person who would be subject to persecution should she return to barbados.']
+122690;['appeal is allowed']
+46389;['appeal isallowed']
+121945;['rad allows the appeal']
+24185;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxisneither a convention refugee']
+135114;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52606;['reject his claim']
+61933;['appeal must be allowed']
+41824;['appeal is allowed']
+123271;['allow the appeal']
+123714;['appeal be dismissed']
+94092;['appeal is allowed']
+84019;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+31997;['appeal is dismissed']
+107326;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+125591;['appellants are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+75255;['appeal is refused']
+54700;['appeal is allowed']
+121567;['refugee protection claim and that of her daughter are allowed']
+90204;['reject her claim']
+151514;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+37429;['appeal is allowed']
+77228;['removal order is set aside']
+99455;['nor persons in need of protection']
+69458;['appeal is allowed']
+90823;['appeal is dismissed']
+85502;['appeal is dismissed']
+76386;['appeal is allowed']
+65631;['appeal isallowed']
+27013;['rad is therefore not able to substitute its own determination']
+98256;['rpd’s determination is erroneous']
+20445;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+118185;['302 (c.a.']
+61323;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+128631;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+114367;['appeal is denied']
+26683;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+84601;['iad is without jurisdiction']
+105196;['appeal is allowed']
+97808;['negative']
+55876;['appeal isallowed.the']
+91217;['iad has not denied the appellant natural justice']
+22121;['appeal is dismissed']
+103510;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+150683;['uphold the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57447;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+96900;['appeal is dismissed']
+96364;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+74865;['appeal is allowed']
+63975;['appeal isallowed']
+40805;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68184;['appeal of mi oak park is dismissed']
+128876;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+61450;['reject this claim for refugee protection']
+30931;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95915;['appeal is allowed']
+108705;['rad finds that the rpd did not err in its decision']
+61485;['appeal is allowed']
+71181;['appeal of sani ram pursuant to section 63(1) ofirpais allowed']
+71615;['appeal is dismissed']
+111116;['appeal is   ']
+80358;['appeal is terminated']
+139858;['substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76243;['claim is rejected']
+94152;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+47098;['…]”']
+86312;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99747;['dismiss the appeal']
+26484;['appeal is allowed']
+90496;['appeal is allowed']
+74611;['allow the appeal']
+141687;['appeal is allowed']
+112343;['appeal is determined']
+98932;['xxxxxxxxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103049;['allow the appeal']
+122675;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+132375;['appeal is dismissed']
+151004;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59996;['claimant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+137449;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89962;['appeal is dismissed']
+98668;['appeals are allowed.the']
+80517;['appeal is dismissed']
+125308;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+132766;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+99040;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110953;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134306;['appeal is allowed']
+145819;['appeal is dismissed']
+62883;['the claim fails']
+151402;['302 (c.a.']
+123140;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96637;['appeal is allowed']
+113236;['appeal is dismissed']
+93654;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+46485;['determination is valid in law']
+84665;['appeal is dismissed']
+37838;['dismiss the present appeal']
+74600;['appeal is dismissed']
+97244;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+134735;['appeal is dismissed']
+65295;['appeal is allowed']
+88066;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+108677;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+17968;['appeal is allowed']
+101138;['appeal is dismissed']
+52168;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare neither“convention refugees”undersection\xa0']
+58107;['appeal ofvedie abiad manongsongis dismissed']
+107709;['appeal were dismissed']
+69227;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+87322;['removal order is set aside']
+61648;['302 (c.a.)']
+13695;['appeal is dismissed']
+60310;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+71704;['appeal beallowed']
+54235;['application is dismissed']
+26504;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+89327;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+50476;['allow the appeal']
+132437;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101756;['appeal is dismissed']
+145590;['reject this explanation']
+47155;['refusal of june 21, 2001 is not invalid in law']
+96945;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+88304;['appeal isallowedand']
+93942;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+82568;['appeal is dismissed']
+96630;['appeal isallowed']
+61935;['appeal of kong prach is dismissed']
+134748;['appeal isdismissed.']
+76603;['appeal should be dismissed']
+54712;['appeal is allowed']
+102561;['appeal is allowed']
+57302;['appeal is based']
+88814;['appeal is allowed']
+87420;['appeal is terminated']
+63750;['appeal is denied']
+82456;['appeal is thereforeallowed']
+100478;['neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+79928;['negative']
+103226;['refugee protection claims']
+81380;['application to reopen the application to vacate the refugee status']
+72908;['appeal must be dismissed']
+89675;['appeal of ranjeet kaur is allowed']
+76770;['appeal is dismissed']
+146836;['appeal is allowed']
+122953;['rad, pursuant', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes a decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+150244;['appeal is allowed']
+110955;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90824;['appeal isallowed']
+70676;['allows this appeal']
+81163;['decision is legally valid']
+132311;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection” within']
+105786;['appeal was dismissed']
+91100;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+113745;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+90065;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72870;['appeal is dismissed']
+110906;['appeals are dismissed']
+80207;['xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees']
+72735;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+138842;['appeal is allowed']
+72213;['appeal is dismissed']
+89677;['removal order is set aside']
+95936;['rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+130352;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+63611;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+87495;['confirm the determination']
+93664;['appeal is allowed']
+39041;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99206;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+94458;['appeal is allowed']
+89330;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+128371;['appeal is allowed']
+130791;['appeal is allowed']
+85375;['appeal isallowed']
+69584;['nor their sponsor, may appeal to the iad']
+129201;['appeal is dismissed']
+100220;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+132651;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146120;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+95672;['appeal is dismissed']
+96610;['appeal is dismissed']
+82466;['appeal is dismissed']
+79750;['appeal isallowed']
+103178;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+85509;['appeal is dismissed']
+80486;['appeal is dismissed']
+116338;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+88101;['302 (c.a.']
+46242;['appeal is dismissed']
+64045;['appeal is allowed']
+43416;['appeal is allowed.the']
+94195;['appeal isallowed']
+118257;['appeal is dismissed']
+35037;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74682;['exclusion order isset aside']
+140634;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+129240;['appeal is allowed']
+29726;['appeal is dismissed']
+79978;['negative']
+95179;['appeal is allowed']
+113609;['appeal were dismissed']
+53408;['appeal is not overly complex']
+106272;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+72645;['appeals are dismissed']
+142490;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+77126;['appeal is allowed']
+96990;['allow the appeal']
+84185;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+77941;['appeal is allowed']
+96771;['negative']
+121866;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110983;['negative determination of the appellants’ refugee claims']
+96811;['302 (c.a.']
+69746;['appeal isallowed']
+66327;['appeals ofefat peikaniand offatemeh heydaribabakhaniare dismissed']
+128378;['appeal of jorenda soler is dismissed']
+123937;['appeal is allowed']
+34175;['appeal is dismissed']
+46075;['dismiss the appeal']
+98347;['appeal is allowed']
+84770;['appeal is allowed']
+132261;['rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+27223;['appeal should be dismissed']
+61042;['appeal is dismissed']
+130004;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81112;['twins, born in algeria in 2017']
+104464;['appeals of zhu hui cen, cai hua chen, chu jun cen and jin ping cen are dismissed']
+52484;['appeal be dismissed']
+74674;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+89783;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99754;['appeal is dismissed']
+95274;['appeal isallowed']
+64285;['appeal of robel debesay arefaine is dismissed']
+94639;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+85629;['appeal is terminated']
+98841;['appeal is allowed']
+139840;['appeal is dismissed']
+134733;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62866;['appeal bedismissed']
+99965;['appeal is dismissed']
+96319;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+83898;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+108761;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84600;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+101099;['appeal isdismissed.the respondent retains her permanent resident status']
+87157;['appeal is dismissed']
+80123;['allows this appeal']
+71196;['appeal is allowed']
+100606;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+76180;['appeal is dismissed']
+102865;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+146110;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'rejects the appeal']
+44083;['rad finds that the appellant is an excluded person', 'confirms the rpd’s decision']
+56496;['appeal is allowed']
+63704;['appeal is allowed']
+89786;['dismiss this appeal']
+124923;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention “refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+143903;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+133383;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+88110;['appeal is terminated']
+100317;['appeal is allowed']
+8624;['appeal to be terminated']
+18005;['appeal is dismissed']
+100853;['appeal is dismissed']
+47707;['refugee protection division accepts the claims of xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx']
+94714;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+106667;['appeal isallowed']
+89342;['removal order is set aside']
+74590;['appeal isallowed']
+124615;['nor a risk of cruel or unusual punishment', 'nor torture']
+103614;['302 (c.a.']
+110294;['rpd’s determination cannot stand']
+39907;['appeal is allowed']
+40777;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+23091;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+37855;['appeal should be dismissed']
+97440;['you are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83000;['“convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+85515;['appeal is dismissed']
+52126;['rad finds the decision of the rpd to be wrong in law']
+92492;['appeal is allowed']
+141161;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+95600;['302 (c.a.']
+131018;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the impugned decision that the appellants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99017;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66780;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+88502;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+106791;['appeal of bhuwan kharal is dismissed']
+90564;['appealis allowed']
+40122;['determination is valid in law']
+125141;['not confirm it.']
+144242;['rad has found that the rpd decision will stand']
+57478;['appeal is determined']
+93330;['302 (c.a.']
+95666;['appeal is dismissed']
+52770;['302 (c.a.)']
+129127;['removal order isset aside']
+146430;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+14655;['not convention refugees']
+26949;['xxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+68150;['appeal is dismissed']
+84744;['appeal is allowed']
+63181;['appeal is terminated']
+95356;['appeal isallowed']
+76329;['appeal isallowed']
+99133;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+87123;['appeal is allowed']
+41570;['appeal is determined']
+123835;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99531;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+76705;['appeal is dismissed']
+83827;['appeal is allowed']
+78670;['appeal is allowed']
+65119;['dismiss this appeal']
+130759;['appeal is allowed']
+97111;['appeal is terminated']
+105899;['panel therefore rejects the cessation application']
+128744;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+111321;['appeal is allowed']
+67369;['appeal be allowed']
+104834;['claim is rejected']
+125691;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83047;['appeal is allowed']
+140278;['302 (c.a.']
+88152;['appeal is allowed']
+72770;['appeal is dismissed']
+69099;['appeal is allowed']
+95150;['appeal is dismissed']
+40516;['appeal isallowed']
+58103;['appeal is dismissed']
+148623;['appeal is allowed.the']
+61803;['negative']
+83166;['appeal is dismissed']
+84484;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+125040;['appeal is allowed']
+63881;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107030;['dismiss the appeal', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+17954;['iad dismisses the present appeal']
+95205;['appeal is dismissed']
+46489;['appeal is allowed']
+74892;['appeal isallowed']
+107903;['appeals are allowed']
+99298;['appellants are not similarly situated persons']
+72643;['appeal is allowed']
+90458;['division rejects both claims']
+114380;['appeal is dismissed']
+131521;['appeal is allowed.the']
+124451;['dismiss the appeal']
+84575;['appeal isallowedand']
+47335;['appeal is allowed']
+91699;['appeal is dismissed']
+87012;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+149481;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+151408;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77897;['appeal is dismissed']
+97411;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+76180;['appeal were dismissed']
+70197;['allow the appeal of sarbjit kaur dhami']
+88322;['dismiss the appeal']
+130706;['appeal is dismissed']
+17982;['appeal of bishnu kumari subedi is dismissed']
+60880;['appeal is dismissed']
+28071;['appeal is allowed']
+98171;['visa officer’s decision must be set aside', 'appeal is allowed']
+99578;['appeal is allowed']
+68712;['appeal is allowed']
+103207;['appeal is allowed']
+107695;['appeal is allowed']
+90680;['appeal isallowed']
+95246;['appeal is dismissed']
+143921;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+94902;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+89967;['appeal is allowed']
+125077;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80458;['appeal is allowed.the']
+17145;['appeal isallowed']
+26912;['xxxxxxxxxxxxand xxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees']
+94968;['application is denied']
+94531;['appeal is allowed']
+77051;['appeal is allowed']
+68322;['allow the appeal']
+29699;['appeal of surafeal fesseha gezahegn is allowed']
+89707;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+54302;['appeal of gurwinder kaur johal is therefore dismissed']
+11463;['appeal is determined']
+146096;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+108696;['appellants were not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+37404;['appeal is allowed']
+114436;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+131865;['appeal is allowed']
+69330;['appeal is allowed']
+94055;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140816;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108799;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+133401;['appeal is allowed']
+58489;['appeals of juan fernando cifuentes juarez and luis eduardo cifuentes juarez are dismissed']
+122233;['appeal is allowed']
+31407;['appeal is dismissed']
+124062;['substitute my determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+59815;['rad therefore allows their appeal and sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+141070;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+53200;['appeal is allowed']
+99836;['appeal is dismissed']
+44735;['appeal is allowed']
+79961;['negative']
+102285;['appeal is dismissed']
+94841;['appeal is dismissed']
+92754;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+33076;['rad dismissed the appeal']
+72640;['appeal be dismissed']
+132847;['decision of the immigration officer is legally valid']
+71132;['appeal should be therefore allowed']
+86021;['appeal is allowed']
+69538;['appeal is allowed']
+86105;['appeal is allowed']
+56980;['negative']
+58110;['appeal isdismisseddue to']
+30503;['appeal was dismissed']
+122938;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+141268;['appeal is allowed']
+85304;['appeal is dismissed']
+100541;['appeal is dismissed']
+132814;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'theappellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74742;['appeal isallowed']
+122703;['psb is agent of persecution']
+127698;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+73708;['appeal be terminated']
+85239;['appeal is allowed']
+19144;['appeal would be dismissed']
+32175;['dismiss the appeal']
+79244;['appeal is allowed']
+130954;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'deny this appeal.xxxx', '“convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+109695;['substituted a positive decision in its place']
+112373;['appeal is dismissed']
+125021;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+40371;['appeal is terminated']
+82067;['appeal is allowed']
+76329;['allows this appeal']
+96326;['appeal is dismissed']
+81177;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+102965;['application is allowed']
+96896;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94019;['appeal is allowed']
+111309;['appeal is dismissed']
+96728;['allowed the appeal']
+90017;['appeal is allowed in law']
+61861;['appeal isallowed.the']
+98015;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+132839;['appeal is allowed']
+82800;['appeal is allowed']
+96342;['appeal is allowed']
+52356;['appeal of kishan chand is allowed']
+99159;['appeal of ronal vikash naicker isdismissed.']
+124114;['set aside the decision of the rpd']
+146544;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+44017;['rad finds the', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+50728;['dismiss the appeal']
+76494;['appeal is allowed']
+143178;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93079;['theappealis allowed']
+152153;['claimants are not convention refugees,', 'or persons in need of protection']
+102746;['removal order is set aside']
+99701;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+63913;['allow his appeal']
+133720;['appeal is dismissed']
+26831;['claimant mr xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+72910;['appeal is dismissed']
+85378;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+121565;['302 (c.a.']
+108259;['appeal is allowed']
+98090;['panel therefore rejects this claim']
+89674;['appeal is dismissed']
+86880;['appeal is allowed']
+29711;['appeal is dismissed']
+65674;['stay is cancelled']
+69558;['appeal isallowed']
+100776;['appeal is dismissed']
+53133;['appeal isallowed']
+17899;['appeals are allowed.the']
+97049;['appeal is dismissed']
+127421;['appeal is dismissed']
+66912;['appeal isallowed']
+150720;['appeal is dismissed']
+102672;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+78341;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is wrong']
+84407;['appeal is terminated']
+84179;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+76788;['appeal beallowedand']
+84439;['appeal is dismissed']
+40122;['appeal is dismissed']
+98263;['rad determines that the rpd’s decision is erroneous']
+88715;['appeal be dismissed']
+71810;['negative determination']
+116821;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123592;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+131191;['appeal is allowed']
+94841;['appeal is dismissed']
+72156;['appeal brought bydenis kenol(“the appellant”)']
+63921;['appeal is terminated']
+101713;['appeal is allowed']
+30300;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+99314;['appeal is dismissed']
+134391;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74669;['appeal is allowed']
+115233;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”undersection']
+133412;['appeal is dismissed']
+103499;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74355;['appeals are dismissed']
+130783;['appeals are allowed']
+50778;['appeal isallowed']
+139875;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104426;['claims are therefore rejected']
+98642;['appeal is dismissed']
+70405;['appeal is dismissed']
+110985;['302 (c.a.']
+85231;['appeal isallowed']
+76918;['appeal is allowed']
+127330;['appeal is dismissed']
+21454;['refugee division determines that xxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+105219;['appeal of xiao feng peng is dismissed']
+98284;['appeal is dismissed']
+65629;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100564;['appeal isallowed']
+123447;['uphold these findings']
+128179;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+108741;['dismissed the claim under section 96']
+83127;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90710;['panel\xa0therefore orders the exclusion of ms. alcequiez jimenez']
+61019;['appeal of kanwaldip kaur dhillon is allowed']
+74763;['appeal is allowed']
+63189;['appeal isallowed']
+85237;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+62254;['negative']
+60062;['appeal is allowed']
+55178;['appeal is dismissed']
+94076;['appeal is allowed']
+97860;['appeal is terminated']
+84769;['appeal is dismissed']
+102902;['application is allowed']
+59739;['appeal is dismissed']
+91204;['appeal is dismissed']
+136753;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+152946;['302 (c.a.']
+142298;['officer’s decision is invalid in law']
+117215;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+151515;['rad sets aside the negative determination of the rpd']
+125335;['rad cannot confirm or set aside the rpd’s determination']
+83293;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62895;['appeal is dismissed']
+77666;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+78733;['appeal isallowed.the']
+56275;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+84075;['appeal is allowed']
+147616;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100295;['claims for protection']
+91653;['appeal is dismissed']
+111012;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+136664;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+114356;['appeal is dismissed']
+116801;['appeal is dismissed']
+57067;['302 (c.a.']
+141298;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77270;['removal order is set aside']
+78171;['claimants, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx,are convention refugees']
+72883;['appeal must be dismissed']
+76163;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+110304;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82700;['appeal is dismissed']
+96993;['appeal isallowedand']
+27516;['appeal is allowed']
+98509;['appeal isallowed']
+46561;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+147612;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+143896;['appeal is dismissed']
+57554;['appeal of wen lin shuai is dismissed']
+40074;['appeal is dismissed']
+132353;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+91758;['appeal of xiao wen guan is allowed']
+83711;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+101439;['appeal is allowed']
+71638;['appeal isallowed']
+95641;['appeal is allowed']
+69426;['appeal isallowed']
+99451;['appeal is dismissed']
+43385;['appeal is dismissed']
+42170;['appeal isallowed']
+84737;['appeal is terminated']
+135477;['minister’s application is allowed']
+143160;['appeal is allowed']
+70016;['allow the appeal']
+79879;['appeal were dismissed']
+99734;['appeal will not be reopened']
+61412;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+90634;['appeal is dismissed']
+99473;['appeals are dismissed']
+81305;['appeal is allowed']
+91604;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+88426;['thatxxxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26701;['appeal was considered in chambers']
+87733;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+69592;['appeal is allowed']
+86841;['appeal isallowed']
+93472;['reject your claims']
+107075;['appeal isallowed']
+107931;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89347;['negative']
+59847;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+52138;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89327;['allowed the appeal']
+102104;['dismissing the appeal,']
+85980;['appeal is terminated']
+143535;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+87810;['appeal is allowed']
+124005;['tps is a temporary permission']
+83176;['rad refuses the application to re-open the appellant’s appeal pursuant', 'rejects the application to join the appeals']
+146877;['confirm the determination of   the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in   need of protection']
+129181;['appeal is dismissed']
+66483;['appeal isallowedon consent']
+151903;['appeals are denied']
+52067;['appeal is allowed']
+43411;['appeal is terminated']
+113543;['appeal be dismissed']
+35915;['appeal is dismissed']
+91436;['appeal is allowed']
+107094;['appeal is dismissed']
+87679;['appeal is allowed']
+107671;['appeal is allowed']
+91672;['appeal is dismissed']
+132824;['panel, therefore, dismisses the appeals']
+111323;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76619;['appeal is allowed']
+96950;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47785;"[""officer's decision is legally valid""]"
+84469;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+56786;['claimants areconvention refugees']
+98713;['appeal is dismissed']
+91418;['appeal is dismissed']
+39773;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+129536;['appeals are dismissed']
+98975;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+60505;['appeal is terminated']
+85840;['appeal be dismissed']
+97482;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+24476;['appeal isallowed']
+7156;['appeal is allowed']
+123856;['substitute a determination that she is a convention refugee']
+100829;['appeal is dismissed']
+38390;['appeal is dismissed']
+94369;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+152127;['302 (c.a.']
+153265;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61967;['appeal is allowed']
+46549;['appeal isallowed.the']
+91343;['appeal of vladyslav nikolayevich frolov is dismissed']
+108132;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+34160;['appeal is dismissed']
+113282;['appeal is allowed']
+90035;['claim is rejected']
+136667;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+98558;['appeal is allowed']
+38251;['appeal is terminated']
+69206;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+83528;['appeal isallowed']
+69756;['allows the appeal']
+68098;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+134360;['appeals are allowed.the']
+129930;['appeal is dismissed']
+101439;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+52682;['claimants are not convention refugees or people in need of protection']
+108053;['appeal is dismissed']
+95155;['negative']
+46245;['appeal of the removal order is dismissed']
+103025;['appeals are allowed']
+95645;['two appeals are allowed']
+90640;['appeal is dismissed']
+114929;['appellant is not excluded from refugee protection']
+133709;['appeal is allowed']
+52089;['appeal is dismissed']
+139877;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98248;['appeal is allowed']
+95894;['appeal is allowed']
+21105;['appeal is allowed']
+105899;['respondent is not a convention refugee']
+151931;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision and rejects the appeal']
+38892;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76385;['appeal is allowed']
+128373;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+100151;['appeal is allowed']
+74559;['appeal is terminated']
+120793;['appellants are refugees or persons in need of protection', 'confirming the rpd’s determination']
+72802;['appeal is dismissed']
+82202;['appeal is dismissed']
+77051;['appeal is allowed']
+84250;['allowed the appeal in']
+76022;['appeal is dismissed']
+100945;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+98466;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+71169;['appeal of jia qing hu is dismissed']
+47806;['appeal is dismissed']
+87311;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx, is found not to be a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54165;['appeal is dismissed']
+98417;['allow the appeal']
+108861;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+93997;['appeal isallowed']
+56861;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+30531;['appeals are dismissed']
+61912;['appeal is allowed']
+131876;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+57669;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+102563;['appeal is dismissed']
+87353;['appeal is allowed']
+47163;['appeal is terminated']
+73870;['appeal is allowed']
+80693;['claimant is not an mdc member']
+49525;['appeal is dismissed']
+26479;['appeals in files mb3-03810 and mb5-05892 are dismissed']
+69328;['appellant is not established incanada']
+77044;['appeal is dismissed']
+95177;['appeal is allowed']
+98331;['application to reinstate is denied']
+87391;['appeal is allowed']
+100071;['board rejects a claim']
+84715;['allows the appeal']
+99483;['appeal is dismissed']
+94722;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”']
+102698;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102542;['appeal is dismissed']
+146445;['rad confirms the decision of therpdthat', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134313;['appeal is allowed']
+131743;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+45186;['appeal is dismissed']
+93893;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+79719;['appeal isallowed']
+92793;['appeal isallowed']
+61449;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+21442;['refugee division therefore determines xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx be a convention refugee']
+69345;['appeal is dismissed']
+124945;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98661;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claims']
+82886;['appeal is allowed']
+80663;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+17165;['removal order is set aside']
+95622;['appeal is dismissed']
+77980;['appeal isallowed']
+88900;['panel rejects the minister’s application', 'first determination is upheld']
+144265;['appeal is dismissed']
+143142;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+143627;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98289;['appeal is dismissed']
+78024;['appeal is dismissed']
+12215;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+81070;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+111352;['appeals are dismissed']
+94256;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+80213;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+120798;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+130856;['negative determination of the refugee protection']
+150775;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89923;['appeal is allowed']
+68356;['appeal is allowed']
+96137;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100968;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143629;['not confirm the rpd’s decision']
+94196;['appeal is allowed']
+101315;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+31412;['removal order is set aside']
+70472;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+90058;['appeal is dismissed']
+43734;['appeal of hilaria elena breidenbach fehr is dismissed']
+65655;['appeal is allowed']
+121468;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+135459;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77692;['not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim']
+101678;['removal order is set aside']
+54524;['appeal is dismissed']
+73023;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'allow the appeal']
+108906;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142840;['application is dismissed']
+99599;['appeal is dismissed']
+54806;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+118165;['substitute my own decision thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are convention refugees']
+98776;['dismiss the appeal']
+76051;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+76678;['decision of the id is set aside']
+101689;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+101664;['dismiss the appeal']
+49966;['302 (c.a.)']
+151326;['dismiss the appeal']
+89888;['negative']
+131223;['appeal by the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness is allowed']
+128390;['appeal is allowed']
+99748;['appeal is not allowed']
+69697;['appeal is allowed']
+129857;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+106279;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+102411;['appeal is allowed']
+40120;['dismisses the appeal']
+100812;['appeal isdismissed.']
+78089;['appeal is dismissed']
+96279;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+91743;['appeal is allowed']
+90994;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+95204;['dismiss the appeal']
+71068;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+77554;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94973;['appeal is terminated']
+111640;['appeal is dismissed', 'rpd decision is upheld']
+89357;['appeal isallowed']
+45414;['allow the appeal']
+146548;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+37843;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+104269;['appeal isallowed']
+68164;['appeal is allowed']
+125489;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100672;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+85971;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98690;['appeal is terminated']
+74205;['positive refugee decisionfrom']
+59997;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+105346;['claimants are convention refugees, and not persons in need of protection']
+60197;['appeal isallowed']
+88499;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+57035;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+91806;['appeal is dismissed']
+65401;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+105234;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86340;['removal order isset aside']
+45178;['appeal is allowed']
+135940;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx, his spouse', 'not refugees']
+98557;['appeal is allowed']
+145230;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+64854;['appeal which was filed by ms. lee last may, is dismissed']
+100309;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+88132;['appeal is dismissed']
+98282;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151784;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+47188;['appeal is dismissed']
+86743;['bonds are still in place']
+140719;['appeal is dismissed']
+69424;['appeal is allowed']
+71259;['appeal is allowed']
+26795;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+124818;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+71982;['appeal is dismissed']
+146917;['appeal is allowed']
+145438;['appeal is dismissed']
+143146;['302 (c.a.)']
+90738;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+31213;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76564;['appeal is allowed']
+103545;['appeal is dismissed']
+49976;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123464;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71667;['appeal is determined']
+31050;['appeal is dismissed']
+99409;['negative']
+128189;['appeal is dismissed']
+93637;['within application is dismissed']
+55133;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96304;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+124971;['appeal is dismissed']
+149571;['appeal is dismissed']
+47775;['appeal bedismissed']
+108820;['claim is rejected']
+94865;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+68676;['appeal is dismissed']
+107667;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedundersubsection']
+36136;['appeal is dismissed']
+123475;['appeal is dismissed']
+95245;['appeal is allowed']
+86369;['appeal is allowed']
+96808;['rad allows the appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+15003;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+42282;['appeal is allowed']
+111015;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons who would be subject to persecution']
+101466;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+68108;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61903;['appeal isallowed']
+86955;['appeal is allowed']
+76486;['appeal is dismissed']
+105446;['appeal is dismissed']
+107492;['rad rejects the appellant’s submissions']
+71528;['appeal isallowed']
+139680;['appeals were dismissed']
+48283;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+141669;['appeal were dismissed']
+26736;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+80988;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61644;['302 (c.a.']
+52043;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+100090;"[""rad finds the rpd's findings and overall determination were reasonable""]"
+89397;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+100531;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+34097;['appeal fails']
+150880;['appeal is dismissed']
+76042;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+151893;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102116;['removal order is set aside']
+95407;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+70460;['appeal of balbir kaur sohal is dismissed']
+124651;['rpd decision is therefore correct']
+102912;['decision of the visa officer is not valid in law']
+81819;['determination is valid in law']
+100769;['officer’s decision that the applicant is criminally inadmissible']
+94681;['negative']
+73677;['appeal be allowed']
+82281;['appeal is allowed']
+14435;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+141227;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+71115;['negative']
+85465;['appeal isallowed']
+77675;['appeal isallowed']
+145334;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+97287;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+124097;['iad dismissed the application']
+78017;['dismiss the appeal']
+79631;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+90605;['appeal isallowed']
+83475;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+100974;['appeal is allowed']
+74070;['appeal is allowed']
+109625;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+121858;['rad dismisses the associate appellant’s appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82064;['appeal is dismissed']
+151349;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitute my own decision']
+77920;['allow his appeal']
+145054;['refugee protection division rejects this claim for refugee protection']
+86213;['appeal is allowed']
+47142;['claimant is excluded from the application of the definition of convention refugee', 'claimant is excluded from the status of a person in need of protection']
+46475;['appeal be allowed']
+132315;['allow the appellants’ appeals', 'substitute my own that they are convention refugees']
+142439;['rad disagrees']
+151622;['appeal is dismissed']
+59820;['appeal isallowed']
+47324;['appeal is allowed']
+143611;['appeal is allowed']
+110930;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+100810;['appeal is dismissed']
+100984;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+123010;['set aside the rpd’s decision regarding their claims', 'substitute a determination that they are convention refugees']
+61013;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+77677;['exclusion order is set aside']
+94919;['appeal of his august 8, 2008 deportation order must therefore be dismissed']
+125034;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+75467;['appeal is terminated']
+123393;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99517;['appeal of yaghoub nasri-saraei is allowed']
+94774;['negative']
+74742;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+86404;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+88323;['panel dismisses his appeal']
+88415;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69436;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+69729;['appeal isallowed']
+134748;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+124615;['xxxx is not a person in need of protection']
+151752;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+93656;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+62259;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+35067;['appeal is dismissed']
+123982;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+101431;['appeal is dismissed']
+105842;['appeal is allowed']
+96737;['appeal is determined']
+95067;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+55163;['appeal is allowed']
+93764;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+49567;['appeal isallowed.the']
+122544;['appeal is allowed']
+143863;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+87723;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+77658;['appeals brought underparagraph 67(1)(c) of theactare allowed']
+87424;['appeal is allowed']
+26686;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+47711;['appeal isallowed']
+102870;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+77277;['appeal of tigist fekadu eyassu is dismissed']
+98353;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+68209;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+68367;['appeal is dismissed']
+76504;['appeals are dismissed']
+143282;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125376;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95982;['xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+100254;['appeal is allowed']
+113290;['appeal isallowed']
+123591;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+14701;['appeal is thereforeallowedby']
+93698;['appeal is allowed']
+81169;['officer’s decision is well-founded in law']
+79897;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+83369;['appeal is allowed']
+85857;['claim is rejected']
+129205;['appeal is allowed']
+129218;['appeal is allowed']
+62124;['appeal is allowed']
+94908;['appeal must be dismissed']
+15584;['appeal is allowed']
+85478;['appeal is terminated']
+125660;['appeal is allowed']
+24494;['appeal is allowed']
+146110;['rad finds that this error is insufficient']
+124059;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+107433;['appeal is   ']
+96610;['appeal is dismissed']
+34941;['appeals are dismissed']
+21359;['not a “convention refugee”']
+110311;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71276;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+54294;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+84726;['appeal is dismissed']
+58811;['appeal was dismissed']
+84137;['302 (c.a.)']
+100033;['appeal be dismissed']
+91283;['appeal is allowed']
+23069;['dismissal of the appeal']
+52681;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+123271;['respondent is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97805;['appeals are dismissed']
+64904;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+58091;['dismiss the appeal']
+105325;['appeal is dismissed']
+132646;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83666;['appeal isallowed']
+104169;['appeal isallowedand']
+59744;['appeal is allowed']
+103618;['claimants are convention refugees']
+124068;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92446;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate reasons']
+90917;['appeal is allowed']
+93662;['appeal is allowed']
+27462;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+68141;['reject the appellant’s argument']
+127732;['appeal is allowed']
+68203;['appeal of ambesagir hadish kidane is dismissed']
+153284;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor is are they “persons in need of protection”']
+61213;['appeal is allowed']
+44212;['removal order isset aside']
+132417;['appeal should be allowed or dismissed']
+120913;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92831;['appeal is dismissed']
+63099;['appeal of opal delia buchanan to be abandoned']
+77548;['appeal must fail']
+95449;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+101531;['decision of the visa officer is set aside']
+97933;['appeal is dismissed']
+112326;['appeal was dismissed']
+98514;['appeal is allowed']
+69680;['dismiss the appeal']
+5587;['appeal is allowed']
+84222;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+100702;['appeal is']
+95928;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140805;['302 (c.a.']
+84634;['appeal is dismissed']
+116133;['appeal is dismissed']
+101058;['officer’s decision not valid in law']
+98481;['xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxx, and xxxxxxxx (akaxxxxxxxxxxx) are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+90842;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision in this matter was wrong in law']
+96474;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+132836;['appeal has been abandoned']
+148722;['refugees and persons in need of protection']
+93335;['appeal will be dismissed']
+74585;['appeal isallowed.the']
+77331;['appeal is dismissed']
+63623;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+124536;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+144031;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+101311;['appeal is allowed']
+47394;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+110685;['appeal is allowed']
+97475;['appeal is dismissed']
+54662;['appeal is allowed']
+87426;['appeal isallowedand']
+67687;['appeal is allowed in law']
+88851;['appeal isallowed']
+17987;['appeal is allowed']
+76396;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56613;['appealis allowed.the']
+90811;['appeal is terminated']
+96144;['appeal is denied']
+56725;['appeal is dismissed']
+93819;['application to reinstate is therefore dismissed']
+150702;['appeal is allowed']
+116789;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+104635;['dismiss this appeal']
+100194;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+69532;['appeal is allowed']
+91709;['appeal of sook hee lee is dismissed']
+23759;['application is allowed']
+67373;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84249;['appeal is allowed']
+87843;['appeal is dismissed']
+29711;['appeal is dismissed']
+88402;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+96264;['dismisses the appeal']
+131001;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102419;['removal order isset aside']
+38405;['appeal is dismissed']
+65415;['appeals are dismissed']
+90729;['appeal is allowed']
+110711;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a   person in need of protection']
+107658;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93654;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+116206;['appeal is dismissed']
+99768;['appeal must fail']
+64036;['appeal is dismissed']
+58138;['appeal is dismissed']
+61650;['appeal is dismissed']
+72792;['appeal is allowed']
+47097;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+40155;['appeal is allowed']
+56749;['appeal be dismissed']
+81817;['appeal is allowed']
+54227;['appeal is dismissed']
+98421;['removal orders are set aside']
+122926;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+85390;['appeal must fail']
+68168;['appeal be dismissed']
+44181;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+63710;['appeal is dismissed']
+52050;['appeal is allowed']
+98418;['appeal is allowed']
+75422;['dismiss the appeal', 'dismissing this appeal']
+60483;['appeal is terminated']
+122964;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+23755;['appeal is dismissed']
+81394;['appeal is allowed']
+75486;['dismiss the appeal']
+87945;['claimant is not a   convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+148717;['xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are convention refugees']
+81215;['appeal is dismissed']
+87677;['appeal is allowed']
+106398;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+50534;['appeals are dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+45867;['302 (c.a.)']
+134217;['appeal be dismissed']
+100763;['appeal is allowed']
+87594;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+66255;['appeal is allowed']
+95031;['appeal isallowed']
+146447;['applicants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+85933;['appeal is terminated']
+121560;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87591;['board, therefore, rejects his claim']
+107668;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80719;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+122619;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+147441;['appeal was dismissed']
+68111;['appeal is allowed']
+96886;['appeal from the refusal is therefore allowed']
+23096;['appellants are not permanent residents', 'appeals are dismissed']
+129147;['appeal is allowed']
+63146;['appeal is allowed']
+101501;['appeal is allowed']
+39918;['appeal of maninder singh khosa is dismissed']
+51693;['appeal is allowed']
+76172;['negative']
+94517;['appeal is terminated']
+151765;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+124270;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+65628;['appeal is dismissed']
+68328;['appeal is determined to be abandonedundersection']
+139680;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+86475;['appeals are allowed.the']
+56915;['appeal was dismissed']
+73589;['decision is well founded in law']
+107138;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+77445;['appeal of satpal lal is allowed']
+45202;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+83551;['appeal is allowed']
+76186;['appeal of zhen qi liu is dismissed']
+147472;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+111352;['appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67571;['appeal dismissed']
+69581;['appeal isallowed']
+56738;['appeal isallowed']
+37862;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60315;['appeal is allowed']
+95559;['appeal is dismissed']
+67784;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+98744;['appeal were refused']
+35807;['appeal were dismissed']
+33070;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+94636;['appeal is dismissed']
+94179;['appeal is dismissed']
+90952;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+100802;['appeal is dismissed']
+104859;['appeal is allowed']
+92169;['appeal is dismissed']
+111013;['appeal is dismissed']
+101139;['appeal is dismissed']
+99537;['appeal isallowedand']
+62485;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+59799;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+110906;['appellants are excluded from refugee protection']
+81374;['appeal is allowed.the']
+49236;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+139792;['appeal is dismissed']
+138826;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+55182;['appeals of dominguilio g. paragas and erlinda a. paragas are dismissed']
+101844;['dismiss the appeal']
+130783;['appeal areallowed']
+76535;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94747;['appeal is allowed']
+56730;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+97134;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+57042;['appeal is allowed']
+54235;['appeal was dismissed']
+123528;['grant this appeal', 'substitute a determination thatxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+144417;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96973;['appeal is dismissed']
+82844;['appeal is dismissed']
+99625;['appeal is allowed']
+116751;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+88091;['appeal is dismissed']
+102296;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+135191;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87498;['appeal will be allowed']
+57027;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+67773;['departure order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+120913;['dismiss the associate appellant’s appeal']
+113280;['appeal is dismissed']
+50743;['sufficient h&c\xa0considerations']
+46041;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate ground']
+92480;['negative']
+146564;['appeal is allowed']
+50652;['appeals are dismissed']
+67244;['appeal is dismissed']
+71486;['appeal must be dismissed']
+13332;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+41725;['appeal is dismissed']
+90849;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+107924;['appeal is allowed']
+85934;['appeal is allowed']
+111002;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants, are neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+48103;['appeal is allowed']
+103687;['302 (c.a.']
+94161;['appeal is dismissed']
+47187;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+100208;['appeal is dismissed']
+123403;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+148991;['dismiss the appeal']
+42387;['appeal is determined']
+71552;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+122770;['appeal is allowed.pursuant', 'rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+64209;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+73302;['allow the appeal']
+59783;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+114339;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+71371;['appeal is allowed']
+60881;['dismiss the appeal']
+102078;['appeals are dismissed']
+153145;['appeal fails']
+146926;['appeal is allowed']
+103520;['appeal is allowed']
+46088;['appeal is dismissed']
+83179;['appeal is dismissed']
+99771;['appeal is dismissed']
+47102;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+64245;['appeal is allowed']
+100687;['appeal is dismissed']
+99067;['thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+95819;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+13955;['appeal were dismissed']
+75135;['appeal is dismissed']
+82740;['appeal is dismissed']
+67506;['case is dismissed']
+127702;['appeal is not allowed']
+79185;['appeal is dismissed']
+49983;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+129803;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx\xa0xxxx(the principal claimant']
+92271;['rejects his claim']
+94006;['appeal is allowed.the']
+78757;['appeal isallowed']
+95783;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95693;['appeal of the removal order be reopened']
+132760;['appeal is dismissed']
+151596;['appeal is dismissed']
+87050;['appeal is dismissed']
+43744;['appeal isallowed']
+69670;['appeal is dismissed']
+68097;['dismisses the appeal']
+101891;['application to extend time is granted']
+128260;['decision is valid in law']
+24495;['removal order isset aside']
+128334;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+114439;['appeal is allowed']
+99922;['appeal is dismissed']
+76353;['302 (c.a.']
+45407;['removal order isset aside']
+88327;['appeal isdismissed.']
+132375;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+47713;['appeal is dismissed']
+139418;['appeal should be dismissed']
+95294;['appeal is dismissed']
+73280;['appeal must be dismissed']
+81817;['appeal was dismissed']
+61804;['claimants are determined to be convention refugees']
+120778;['appeal is allowed']
+26931;['not a convention refugee']
+71911;['reject his claim']
+56966;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+94043;['appeal is dismissed']
+95955;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+93246;['appeal isallowedand']
+96772;['panel therefore rejects his claim']
+131052;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+24477;['appeals are dismissed']
+120810;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61035;['leads me to conclude']
+81098;['appeal is dismissed']
+83666;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+45229;['appeal is denied']
+93090;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+99606;['appeal of kousha malekpour is dismissed']
+83349;['appeal is dismissed']
+80304;['negative']
+140855;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+89109;['appeal isallowed']
+84667;['removal order is set aside']
+70012;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+81091;['appeal isallowed']
+54247;['appeal pursuant to section 77(3)(b) is dismissed']
+11070;['application is dismissed']
+95517;['appeal is dismissed']
+36941;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+56890;['appeal is dismissed']
+44841;['removal order isset aside']
+96522;['negative']
+96494;['appeal is allowed']
+123538;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71745;['stay of the removal order is extended']
+28015;['appeal is allowed']
+96606;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+94236;['appeal was dismissed']
+61012;['claimants are similar to the appellant in theurbanekcase and']
+151608;['rad substitutes its own decision for that of the rpd']
+90759;['appeal is dismissed']
+143869;['appeal is dismissed']
+95481;['appeal is dismissed']
+74456;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+75988;['appeal isallowed']
+25979;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+116853;['rpd’s decision must be set aside']
+98697;['appeal is allowed']
+87059;['appeal oftehmina\xa0asimand her daughter,soha asim, is dismissed']
+88098;['appeal is allowed']
+113563;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95916;['appeal isallowed']
+64629;['allows this appeal']
+103901;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+60947;['dismiss the appeal']
+73681;['appeal is allowed']
+62442;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+117120;['appeal is dismissed']
+124823;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85857;['or a person in need of protection']
+100412;['appeal is dismissed']
+77854;['appeal is dismissed']
+18931;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+54519;['appeal is terminated']
+87090;['302 (c.a.)']
+94757;['not a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+143070;['appeal is allowed']
+118733;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+105858;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87843;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+142493;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94724;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+88259;['confirm the determination']
+59185;['appeal is allowed']
+80088;['appeal must be dismissed']
+107328;['claim is rejected']
+94574;['claimants have failed to establish their identity']
+97832;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+94631;['302 (c.a.']
+83549;['claimant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+87285;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+73305;['302 (c.a.']
+113549;['appeal is dismissed']
+111322;['302 (c.a.']
+66761;['appeal is allowed']
+86614;['appeal is allowed']
+77333;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+142556;['appeal is dismissed']
+71994;['appeal is dismissed']
+100962;['appeal is dismissed']
+89267;['appeal is dismissed']
+95781;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104841;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107258;['rad finds no such errors that are fatal to its determination']
+100924;['appellant has not lost their permanent resident status']
+87204;['302 (c.a.']
+145832;['appeal is dismissed']
+90204;['negative']
+86019;['appeal is dismissed']
+89966;['allow the appeal']
+140807;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+24491;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+46081;['appeal is allowed']
+26923;['refugee division determines that xxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, are not convention refugees']
+100356;['appeal is dismissed']
+94498;['appeal is allowed']
+150689;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection.the', 'appeal with respect to her claim is dismissed']
+77586;['appeal isallowed.the']
+61291;['appeal is dismissed']
+101420;['appeal isallowed']
+89141;['appeals ofbipinchandra contractor, the “applicant']
+105870;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69556;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+46041;['appeal is dismissed']
+72068;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+67515;['appeal isallowed']
+136662;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79460;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+74835;['appeal isallowed.the']
+82678;['appeal isallowed']
+97806;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+78165;['allows the minister’s appeal']
+94265;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+127715;['302 (c.a.']
+146969;['appeal be dismissed']
+128905;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+142512;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97217;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+33694;['appeal is dismissed']
+103663;['reject these claims']
+82725;['appeal is allowed']
+83149;['appeal is allowed.the']
+84355;['appeal is dismissed']
+99019;['appeal is dismissed']
+98011;['claim is rejected']
+55135;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+106159;['appeal is allowed']
+104145;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+91297;['appeal is dismissed']
+127471;['appeal is dismissed']
+72676;['appeal abandoned']
+143907;['deny the appeal']
+19313;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees']
+48282;['appeal is dismissed']
+74867;['appeal of maggie king jong cheung is dismissed']
+100801;['appeal is allowed.the']
+78078;['appeal is governed']
+101805;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+37897;['appeal is allowed']
+107890;['302 (c.a.']
+65633;['application is dismissed']
+125220;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+59742;['appeal is allowed']
+124068;['dismiss the appeal']
+52599;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+82161;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107267;['appeal is allowed']
+38774;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+60987;['appeal is dismissed']
+82185;['appeal is dismissed']
+107388;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+101272;['appeal is allowed']
+92194;['refugee protection division rejects his claim', 'claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+66659;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+62834;['appeal is allowed']
+82088;['dismiss your appeal', 'appeal is dismissed']
+77448;['appeal is allowed']
+131734;['appeal is allowed']
+77681;['appeal isallowed']
+80121;['application to extend the delay to file a notice of appeal']
+151601;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+148745;['claimant, xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+67734;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+94673;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+73588;['appeal is terminated']
+99434;['appeal is allowed']
+57026;['appeal were dismissed']
+94620;['appeal is dismissed']
+125622;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90365;['appeal is dismissed']
+122540;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100710;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is erroneous']
+68981;['appeal isallowed']
+80136;['appeal is allowed']
+80553;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+55162;['appeal is allowed']
+89804;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+90175;['appeal is dismissed']
+75610;['appeal was dismissed']
+71080;['302 (c.a.']
+88101;['appeal is allowed']
+105220;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+92467;['appeal is dismissed']
+90119;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+142310;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80451;['appeal is dismissed']
+133407;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99487;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+94967;['panel rejects her assertions']
+140260;['appeal is dismissed']
+132275;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, failed to establish his identity', 'not a “convention refugee”']
+86954;['appeal isallowed']
+72893;['appeal is dismissed']
+99478;['appeal is dismissed']
+105623;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59373;['appeal isdismissed.']
+97676;['negative']
+62445;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis excluded from the provisions of the convention', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+62250;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+61830;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79504;['favourable decision is attached to these reasons']
+89738;['appeal is dismissed']
+107167;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+56943;['appeal is dismissed']
+58130;['appeal is allowed']
+108742;['rad (refugee appeal division) confirms the decision of the rpd']
+90810;['appeal fails']
+87685;['appeal is allowed']
+89375;['appeal is dismissed']
+67514;['appeal isallowed.the']
+98873;['appeal isallowed']
+4746;['appeal isallowed.the']
+52293;['appeal is allowed']
+81631;['appeal is dismissed']
+95411;['dismiss the appeal']
+85837;['appeal isallowed']
+123665;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+91234;['appeal is terminated']
+87816;['negative']
+94447;['rad finds that it need not go on to assess the merits of the claim']
+129197;['appeal is dismissed']
+142807;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71224;['appeal fails']
+97379;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+92023;['appeal is allowed']
+97843;['nor, on a balance of probabilities']
+60034;['negative']
+100550;['appeal is allowed']
+96963;['appeal is dismissed']
+47558;['appeal is dismissed']
+94777;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+148650;['appeal fails']
+90361;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+61880;['appeal is terminated']
+100319;['not a “convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+88852;['appeal is dismissed']
+121862;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+31379;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+102379;['appeal is allowed']
+83911;['appeal is allowed']
+111039;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+146920;['appeal is dismissed']
+145492;['appeal should be dismissed']
+115235;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96990;['appeal isallowedand']
+54700;['appeal is allowed']
+54193;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+67700;['appeal is dismissed']
+97577;['appeal is dismissed']
+82585;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+101159;['appeal is dismissed']
+39072;['appeal is allowed']
+76002;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89159;['applicants are not persons']
+93300;['appeal isallowed']
+83655;['appellant has not lost his permanent residence status']
+125670;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxxxxxx, is excluded under']
+91533;['appeal is dismissed']
+106674;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84176;['appeal of kawaljeet kaur is dismissed']
+96359;['appeal is dismissed']
+55949;['appeal is allowed']
+94316;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+91650;['appeal is allowed']
+85492;['appeal is allowed']
+74570;['appeal is allowed']
+90686;['appeal isallowedand']
+123863;['appeals of the remaining appellants are dismissed']
+57821;['appeal is allowed']
+68469;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+89205;['appeal is terminated']
+77638;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+104489;['appeal is dismissed']
+90094;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxx xxxxis rejected']
+62643;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+107584;['appeal is allowed']
+66778;['appeal is allowed']
+98671;['claimants to not be convention refugees']
+55179;['appeal of shaza abdel wahal ahmed el kourashy is dismissed']
+33228;['appeal isallowed']
+105763;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+130882;['appeal is dismissed']
+96615;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+129921;['appeal is allowed']
+60004;['thatxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+86022;['appeal is allowed']
+31928;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+61970;['appeal be dismissed']
+82136;['application to postpone was allowed, peremptory']
+91409;['dismissal of the appeal']
+75988;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+100593;['appeal isallowed.the']
+58756;['appellants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+46497;['appeal were dismissed']
+98219;['appeal is dismissed']
+75989;['appeal in relation to the applicant’s daughter']
+79940;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+90909;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+128351;['appeal is allowed']
+82211;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+136082;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91311;['appeal isallowed']
+60665;['application for leave to appeal is therefore dismissed']
+98563;['appeal is dismissed']
+51682;['appeal is allowed']
+121959;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+82657;['appeal is allowed.the']
+105876;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52107;['appeal is dismissed']
+34880;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+106266;['302 (c.a.']
+123763;['rpd decision cannot stand']
+124998;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123929;['appeal is allowed']
+71462;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+105796;['appeal is allowed.the']
+123321;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96556;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+91728;['appeal is dismissed']
+107256;['appeal is dismissed']
+149576;['claimant xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection', 'division rejects his claim']
+56953;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+100363;['appeal isallowed']
+129128;['appeal abandoned']
+89453;['appeal were dismissed']
+98353;['appeal is allowed']
+91567;['appeal is dismissed']
+120849;['appeals are allowed']
+23062;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90540;['appeal must be dismissed']
+96244;['appeal isallowed']
+93616;['appeal failed']
+124114;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxis a “person in need of protection']
+49065;['appeal is allowed']
+61975;['appeal is terminated']
+67507;['appeal is allowed']
+99562;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+118137;['allow the appeal', 'substitute a determination that they are convention refugees']
+150640;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+62902;['appeal is dismissed']
+71407;['appeal is allowed']
+98688;['appeal is allowed']
+63981;['panel finds the exclusion order is legally valid']
+102124;['appeal is allowed']
+87600;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+141650;['appeal is allowed.the']
+79975;['negative']
+28063;['appeal of victor hugo moreno is dismissed']
+98296;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92783;['appeal is dismissed']
+100360;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+130714;['appeal were dismissed']
+76277;['appeal isallowed']
+99614;['application is allowed']
+44735;['appeal is allowed']
+57935;['appeal is allowed']
+74177;['allow the appeal']
+57938;['allow the appeal']
+71144;['appeal must be dismissed']
+142457;['rad disagrees']
+63058;['appeal is allowed']
+63894;['appeal is terminated']
+96903;['appeal be dismissed']
+50933;['appeal would be dismissed']
+98037;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor she is a person in need of protection']
+129887;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+124347;['appeal is allowed', 'panel sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+96561;['appeal is allowed']
+148502;['claimant is not a convention refugee, or a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects her refugee protection claim']
+141641;['appeal is dismissed']
+88259;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'appeal is rejected']
+92717;['appeal is allowed']
+131080;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee']
+94152;['refugee protection definitions are forward-looking']
+93692;['rad dismisses the minister’s appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+71142;['appeal is allowed']
+86349;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+91910;['appeal is allowed']
+99572;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+130919;['appeal is allowed']
+95393;['appeal is allowed']
+101764;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+82801;['appeal is allowed']
+47132;['appeal isallowed.the']
+97036;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+150678;['not agree with the rpd’s decision']
+109026;['appeal was dismissed']
+124451;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99462;['302 (c.a.)']
+132927;['allow the appeal']
+103800;['panel rejects the present claims']
+83482;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+91355;['appeal is allowed']
+127396;['appeal of emma tjongarero is dismissed']
+98923;['appeal isallowed']
+72874;['appeal isterminated']
+116763;['appeal be allowed']
+52656;['reject their refugee protection claims']
+141637;['appeal is allowed.the']
+128336;['appeal is allowed']
+130956;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95447;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71599;['appeal is dismissed']
+93682;['appeal is allowed']
+74173;['appeal is dismissed']
+94086;['refugee protection claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+73358;['appeal is allowed']
+104972;['allows the appeal']
+151843;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+143870;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee']
+122382;['appeal is allowed']
+95784;['appeal is allowed']
+47763;['appeal isallowed']
+95985;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87813;['appeal is dismissed']
+70384;['appeal is dismissed']
+100476;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+83149;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76091;['appeal isallowed']
+93550;['appeal is allowed']
+100643;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+84453;['appeal is dismissed']
+80120;['appeals are dismissed']
+121845;['appeal is allowed']
+81237;['removal order is set aside']
+97858;"[""immigration officer's decision is valid in law""]"
+26786;['appeal pursuant to paragraph 77(3)(b) is dismissed']
+125551;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd determination', 'appellant is not a refugee']
+31974;['appeal is allowed']
+118198;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83827;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+83059;['appeal is allowed']
+48285;['application is allowed']
+106469;['appellants,xxxxandxxxx xxxx,are not “convention refugees”']
+80570;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+94284;['appeal is allowed']
+93766;['appeal is allowed']
+147451;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+96897;['appeal is dismissed']
+89996;['negative']
+124178;['appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor person in need of protection.the']
+40850;['appeal is allowed']
+94904;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+150689;['confirm the rpd’s decision']
+93074;['two american-born claimants are not convention refugees or people in need of protection']
+131019;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+145320;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor person in need of protection']
+143129;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+86521;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+54195;['appeal is dismissed']
+76781;['appeal is dismissed']
+52125;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63607;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66201;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+91147;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+131064;['302 (c.a.']
+56903;['appeal isallowed']
+65620;['appeal isallowed']
+98765;['dismiss this aspect of the appeal']
+77928;['appeal is allowed']
+69715;['declare this appeal abandoned']
+132278;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98614;['dismiss the appeal']
+52367;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96872;['appeal isallowed']
+136184;['panel sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+68786;['appeal is dismissed']
+121381;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96734;['appeal is abandoned']
+91316;['appellant is not a person described in subsection 133(1)(k) of the regulations']
+76636;['appeal is allowed']
+100224;['appeal isallowed']
+107677;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+60043;['claimants are determined to be neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151861;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26983;['xxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+128147;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+73027;['appeal of katrina mansour is allowed']
+123712;['appeal is allowed']
+131085;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+123625;['appeal is allowed']
+104341;['appeals are dismissed']
+109036;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+146919;['appeal isdismissed.']
+45422;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+68275;['visa officer’s decision will be set aside', 'appeal will be allowed']
+47609;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+107700;['appeal is dismissed']
+100653;['appeal is allowed']
+101908;['not a “person in need of protection']
+100459;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69573;['appeal isallowed']
+134495;['theappealsare allowed']
+95054;['appeal is allowed']
+99204;['appeal is dismissed']
+99885;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+123837;['appellant is not aconventionrefugee or a person in need of protection']
+107594;['appeal is allowed.the']
+95892;['appeal is dismissed']
+139679;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+91526;['appeal is terminated']
+72862;['appeal is dismissed']
+78002;['appeal is dismissed']
+57955;['appeal is based']
+26758;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+61887;['appeal is allowed']
+91427;['claimant\xa0 is not a convention refugee']
+102394;['appeal should be dismissed']
+98786;['appeal of giorgi veshaguri is dismissed']
+74657;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+141402;['application to extend the time to file the noa is dismissed']
+150717;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+66331;['dismissing this appeal']
+97025;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx\xa0xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+70074;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+44961;['allows the appeal']
+143022;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85627;['appeal is dismissed']
+142524;['rad dismisses the appeals of the principal appellant', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100951;['appeal is allowed']
+108869;['appeal is allowed']
+53448;['appeal isallowed']
+87216;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26753;['appeal is allowed in law']
+51089;['appeal is dismissed']
+148982;['appeal is allowed']
+81052;['appeal is terminated']
+113214;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+142971;['dismiss the appeal']
+75150;['appeal is terminated by operation of law']
+98840;['appeal isallowed']
+69835;['appeal is dismissed']
+124668;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97470;['negative']
+75005;['appeal is allowed.the']
+94174;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+70118;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+140207;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+23104;['appeal of tuan van to is dismissed']
+108060;['appeal is dismissed']
+73019;['appeal is dismissed']
+22398;['appeal is allowed']
+92021;['appeal is allowed']
+99100;['appeal is allowed']
+14669;['motion to re-open the claim']
+129109;['appeal is dismissed']
+47919;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+69418;['appeals are dismissed']
+93265;['appeal is allowed']
+132795;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84492;['appeals are allowed']
+73017;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+35430;['appeal is dismissed']
+77857;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+133262;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87033;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+97392;['three claimants are not convention refugees and they are not persons in need of canada’s protection']
+98470;['appeal isallowed']
+74548;['appeal is allowed']
+101698;['appeal of rajesh joshi is allowed']
+87813;['appeal be dismissed']
+143182;['reject your claim']
+130959;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101709;['tribunal declares the appealabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+50354;['rpd is set aside']
+72672;['appeal is dismissed']
+152970;['cancel the stay of removal', 'dismiss the present appeal']
+76672;['appeal is allowed']
+115280;['appeal is allowed']
+77055;['appeal is dismissed']
+108769;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+87938;['appeals are based']
+68271;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77993;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+99002;['appeal isallowed']
+94295;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, and their daughterxxxx', '“convention refugees”', 'rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+71479;['appeal isallowed']
+92863;['appeal is allowed']
+53449;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107592;['appeal is dismissed']
+94635;['appeal isallowed']
+95487;['appeal is dismissed']
+44181;['appeal is dismissed']
+94919;['appeal be dismissed']
+89680;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+122239;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96898;['appeal is allowed']
+124928;['dismiss the appeal']
+57822;['appeal is allowed']
+40144;['appeal is dismissed']
+94632;['appeal is allowed']
+68266;['appeal of the appellant jasvir kaur sandhu is allowed']
+100240;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+100021;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+108925;['appeal is dismissed']
+81151;['appeal is allowed']
+110306;['appeal is dismissed']
+96149;['appeal is allowed']
+77298;['appeal is dismissed']
+71530;['appeal is allowed']
+71666;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+84478;['appeal is allowed']
+98379;['302 (c.a.']
+71563;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+21444;['claimant’s claim must fail']
+144013;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75604;['appeal is dismissed']
+19305;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx\xa0xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+107675;['appeal is dismissed']
+100492;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95386;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own decision that the appellants are convention refugees as well as persons in need of protection']
+85510;['appeal is dismissed']
+75991;['appeal isallowed']
+71375;['appeal is dismissed']
+98212;['appeal is allowed']
+64857;['appeal of mohamed abdelgadir fudl elmawlla is dismissed']
+128373;['appeals of jahangireliasi bakhtiari and sedigheh ameriare dismissed']
+121859;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+153271;['appeal is dismissed']
+132313;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100486;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+56506;['appeal is terminated']
+77799;['302 (c.a.']
+92782;['appeal is allowed']
+134221;['appeal is allowed']
+51123;['appeal be dismissed']
+88318;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+84763;['departure order is set aside']
+133273;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76385;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+84078;['302 (c.a.)']
+98115;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100063;['panel rejects this claim']
+75473;['appeal is terminated']
+95147;['negative']
+94935;['determination is valid in law']
+59810;['appeal is dismissed']
+134490;['appeal is allowed.the']
+127339;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+120764;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+148604;['appeal is dismissed']
+42434;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99300;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+89781;['claimants who are citizens of the czech  republic are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+76558;['appeal is terminated']
+50476;['appeal is allowed']
+70915;['negative']
+128874;['appellants are not “convention refugees”']
+125316;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+68323;['appeal isallowed']
+71215;['appeal is dismissed']
+112359;['appeal is dismissed']
+90832;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+99534;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+76808;['dismissing the appeal']
+14583;['appeal is dismissed']
+152917;['submission has no merit']
+124964;['appeal is allowed']
+106886;['appeal is allowed']
+74984;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is an excluded person']
+96878;['appeal is dismissed']
+105655;['rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+143567;['ifa is objectively unreasonable']
+94349;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+63946;['appeal isallowed']
+81005;['appeal is dismissed']
+136710;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124648;['appeal is allowed']
+17937;['appeal terminated']
+80298;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+90235;['panel therefore rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+46999;['appeal isallowed']
+123359;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+31263;['appeal is dismissed']
+150944;['appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+101775;['appeal is allowed']
+141278;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+82900;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+42086;['appeal isallowedand']
+96062;['claimant is not a convention refugee and the']
+62446;['is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83653;['appeal is allowed']
+64585;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+78638;['appeal is dismissed']
+128426;['appellant has not his permanent resident status']
+31973;['appeal is allowed']
+70064;['appeal was dismissed']
+140927;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100918;['appeal is dismissed']
+78692;['appeal is dismissed']
+132402;['appeal is allowed']
+146454;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69690;['appeal is dismissed']
+76392;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision in this matter was wrong in law']
+74534;['appeal is allowed']
+83191;['appeal is based']
+77273;['allowed the appellant’s prior appeal']
+81427;['appeal is allowed']
+120737;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+140729;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95069;['appeal regarding the principal appellant xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+128296;['appeal is dismissed']
+129106;['appeal is dismissed']
+83123;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+12010;['appeal of amir zia is dismissed']
+83674;['appeal should be dismissed']
+143872;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+102863;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+84863;['terminates his appeal']
+123314;['appeal is allowed']
+132790;['appeal is allowed']
+12209;['appeal is dismissed']
+40796;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+67661;['appeal allowed']
+125662;['rad rejects the appellant’s arguments']
+134228;['appeal is dismissed']
+79980;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+135207;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+65422;['appeal is dismissed']
+90747;['appeal isallowed']
+151867;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+63200;['appeal is dismissed']
+39925;['appeal is dismissed']
+140992;['rad allows the appeal', 'sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+86990;['appeal of syed njam hussain is allowed']
+107861;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+75713;['appeal is dismissed']
+105884;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+84034;['appeal isallowed']
+89756;['appeal is allowed']
+60524;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+107851;['appeal is dismissed']
+96330;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+100194;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+60991;['appeal is allowed']
+101002;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+13683;['appeal of sinkinesh amente abagifar is dismissed']
+114439;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+98705;['302 (c.a.']
+107930;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+122120;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'find the appellant to be a convention refugee']
+90835;['refugee appeal division', 'confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+134985;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+95080;['appeal is allowed']
+89023;['302 (c.a.)']
+121253;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+94864;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96304;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+107651;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146559;['appellant,xxxx xxxx, is a convention refugee']
+98538;['reject the refugee claim']
+125427;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100620;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74883;['appeal isallowed']
+130929;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+47882;['appeal is allowed']
+89585;['appeal is terminated']
+69723;['appeal is allowed']
+152040;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69985;['negative']
+30498;['appeal is allowed']
+91357;['appeal of mouhannad husein is allowed']
+56803;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxx xxxxx']
+47612;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+90722;['appeal is not allowed']
+143534;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+71568;['appeal is dismissed']
+124575;['dismiss the appeal']
+72868;['appeal of beza mekonnen is dismissed']
+52302;['appeal is dismissed']
+106153;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+147471;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98062;['appeal isallowed']
+127360;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86333;['appeal is allowed']
+95516;['appeal is dismissed']
+122966;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+150913;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128608;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+44207;['declare the appeal to be abandoned']
+13977;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+98790;['dismiss the appeal']
+105612;['claim is rejected']
+59665;['appeal of balwinder kaur hundal is dismissed']
+65109;['appeal must be dismissed']
+82465;['appeal of marie ridza eugene is dismissed']
+108974;['removal order isset aside']
+150754;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+98829;['allowed the appeal']
+26835;['claimant, ms.\xa0xxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+74101;['appeals are dismissed']
+144032;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+94077;['application for reconsideration is denied']
+103052;['allow the appeal']
+110303;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+76055;['appeal is terminated']
+46085;['appeal is allowed']
+89523;['removal order is set aside']
+35552;['appeal isallowed']
+123418;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95447;['appeal is allowed.the']
+77256;['appeal is dismissed']
+69173;['panel finds']
+140860;['appeal is allowed']
+99023;['claims are rejected']
+134520;['appeal is dismissed']
+74295;['dismiss the appeal']
+92271;['rejects the claim of xxxx xxxx xxxx']
+56510;['appeal is allowed']
+100210;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+90085;['appeal is terminated']
+151878;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123442;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+63915;['appeal is dismissed']
+79953;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+26832;['xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+104838;['appeal is allowed']
+52644;['“convention refugees']
+40147;['appeal is dismissed']
+98197;['panel rejects this claim for refugee protection']
+75662;['appeal brought by ramona baltazar is therefore dismissed']
+134279;['appeal is dismissed']
+142565;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99593;['appeal is dismissed']
+110297;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94223;['decision is valid in law']
+101868;['appeal is allowed']
+38779;['appeal is dismissed']
+73186;['appeal is allowed']
+49070;['appeal is allowed.the']
+60652;['appeal is dismissed']
+81329;['appeal is allowed']
+91317;['appeal isallowed']
+44018;['rad finds no error in the rpd’s assessment of this issue']
+82659;['appeal is allowed']
+85597;['appeal is dismissed']
+98235;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+103543;['appeal were dismissed']
+67231;['dismiss the appeal']
+100243;['refugee protection division rejects his claim', 'claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+153287;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx, the claimant, is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+59936;['lp is not a very popular party inalbania,']
+85835;['appeal is allowed']
+151876;['appeal is dismissed']
+24244;['appeal being dismissed']
+50478;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+132289;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx,is not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+123408;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”']
+58109;['appeal is dismissed']
+56687;['appeal is dismissed']
+86042;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant was not a convention refugee nor was he a person in need of protection']
+69360;['appeal is dismissed']
+21937;['application is dismissed']
+123916;['appeal is allowed']
+95253;['appeals be stayed or dismissed']
+21464;['thatxxxxxxxx,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees']
+34869;['appeal is granted']
+80522;['appeal is allowed']
+69582;['appeal is allowed']
+100893;['appeal is allowed']
+150847;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+90775;['appeal is dismissed']
+113683;['appeal is allowed']
+151470;['rad cannot confirm the rpd determination']
+86529;['appeal is determined']
+13769;['appeal isallowed.the']
+30510;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+23026;['appeal is allowed.the']
+140727;['decision of the rpd is confirmed']
+107033;['appeal be dismissed']
+103801;['302 (c.a.)']
+56934;['appeal is allowed']
+122648;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+153278;['appeal is allowed']
+56669;['not a convention refugee']
+42293;['appeal is allowed']
+80824;['claimant is not aconvention refugee']
+66320;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+71265;['appeal is allowed']
+107023;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96379;['appeal is allowed']
+56935;['appeal isallowed']
+30483;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+46070;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95560;['appeal is dismissed']
+81618;['appeal is dismissed']
+105367;['rad finds that the', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122930;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+149004;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+82790;['appeal is allowed']
+124065;['appeal is allowed']
+90252;['negative']
+130974;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+71737;['appeal isallowed']
+96514;['claimants do not require canada’s protection']
+111155;['appeal is dismissed']
+87351;['appeal is dismissed']
+64605;['dismisses the appeal']
+108452;['appeal is allowed']
+74633;['appeal is dismissed']
+71734;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+147573;['appeal is allowed.the']
+82573;['appeal is allowed']
+109144;['claimants xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+151818;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+104507;['rad sets aside the rpd determination rendered', 'substitutes its own determination']
+124616;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96870;['appeal is dismissed']
+65659;['appeal is dismissed']
+70676;['appeal being allowed']
+87221;['appeal isallowed']
+138832;['appeal is dismissed']
+48609;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugee nor persons in need of protection']
+86640;['appeal is allowed']
+96161;['appeal is determined']
+83871;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+63904;['appeal is terminated']
+134422;['appeal is based']
+95915;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70097;['appeal is allowed']
+153728;['allow the appeal']
+135901;['appellants are neither convention refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+78186;['appeal is allowed']
+52503;['dismiss the appeal']
+151630;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56919;['appeal is allowed']
+132372;['appeal is terminated']
+80786;['appeal is allowed']
+135918;['appeal is allowed']
+134359;['appeal is allowed']
+107929;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+132808;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+99745;['application is dismissed']
+59782;['appeals as they relate togeeta deviramdass, gaitri deviramdassand rukminiramdassareallowed.the']
+86631;['appeals are allowed.the']
+125505;['appellant,xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+110961;['clan is no longer a main issue']
+99622;['appeal is allowed']
+23096;['appellants are not permanent residents']
+147795;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+100482;['dismisses the appeal']
+113546;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+128889;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+106419;['appeal is allowed']
+126404;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+35230;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92400;['appeal is allowed']
+84618;['appeal is terminated']
+99808;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+24453;['appeal is dismissed']
+84643;['appeal were dismissed.there']
+92393;['removal order is set aside']
+46985;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+76544;['appeal isallowed']
+118218;['appeal is allowed']
+69255;['appeal isallowed']
+89129;['appeal isallowed']
+68727;['appeal is allowed']
+132912;['appeal isdismissed.']
+68978;['appeal is allowed in law']
+90777;['dismiss the appeal']
+88534;['appeal is allowed']
+89302;['negative']
+107316;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74581;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125502;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+14684;['not a “convention refugee']
+94688;['appeal is dismissed']
+148722;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+106676;['appeal is allowed']
+80522;['appeal is allowed.the']
+95959;['rad concludes that the rpd’s conclusions']
+31047;['appeal is allowed']
+47561;['appeal is dismissed']
+26724;['appeal is dismissed']
+117214;['rad therefore finds that the rpd’s decision cannot be upheld']
+107807;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'panel therefore rejects her claim']
+81633;['decision of the immigration officer is not legally valid']
+42415;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+92471;['appeal isallowed']
+49119;['appeal of surinder singh caude is dismissed']
+90950;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108752;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+138274;['appeal is allowed']
+80216;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+138812;['appeal of the appellant’s father was allowed']
+147792;['appeal is dismissed']
+58545;['appeal must be dismissed']
+21467;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+80666;['not a person in need of protection']
+110953;['appeal therefore cannot succeed']
+122872;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+94650;['appeal is terminated']
+86451;['appeal terminated']
+122254;['appeal is allowed.mrs']
+130952;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+148653;['appeal is dismissed']
+54802;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+70906;['officer’s decision to refuse permanent resident visas is set aside']
+90922;['appeal   must be dismissed']
+91159;['appeal is allowed']
+46041;['appeal is dismissed']
+60652;['appeal is allowed.the']
+47579;['appeal isallowed']
+109633;['appeal is allowed']
+94820;['appeal is allowed']
+95000;['appeal is allowed']
+75465;['nor a person in need of protection']
+102697;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83078;['appeal is allowed']
+99575;['appeal is allowed']
+88417;['appeal is allowed']
+141226;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+78322;['appeal isallowed']
+46496;['appeal is allowed']
+97425;['refugee protection division therefore, rejects the claims for refugee protection']
+75992;['appeal isallowed']
+143603;['appeal is dismissed']
+123147;['appeal is allowed']
+122766;['rad concludes that the appellant is excluded from the protection of the conventionundersection']
+108959;['appeal should be dismissed']
+140822;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75938;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+101310;['appeal is dismissed']
+65706;['appeal is allowed']
+71037;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+83032;['appeal of yu long qian is dismissed']
+123362;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+15018;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+33311;['appeal is declared to beabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+77012;['appeal is allowed']
+104371;['appeal isallowed']
+103461;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+113543;['appeal is dismissed']
+77459;['appeal is terminated']
+128613;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the principal and female minor', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+144556;['appeal is dismissed']
+143231;['appeal is dismissed']
+95477;['appeal is dismissed']
+108671;['rejects her evidence']
+99205;['appeal is dismissed']
+136093;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+56895;['application to dismiss this appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+51135;['allowing the appeal']
+110282;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+123429;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+62993;['appeal is dismissed']
+61627;['victims do not become convention refugees']
+85517;['appeal isallowed']
+95548;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+125000;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52070;['appeal isallowedand']
+116831;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+52149;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+56984;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69591;['appeal is allowed']
+77556;['appeal is dismissed']
+127413;['removal order is set aside']
+93332;['appeal isallowed']
+45213;['iad does not have jurisdiction to hear the appellant’s appeal']
+96776;['appeal is dismissed']
+151753;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+55520;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+86900;['appeal is allowed']
+64578;['appeal is allowed']
+108783;['appeal is dismissed']
+105639;['appeal is dismissed']
+127727;['302 (c.a.']
+74260;['appellant is not a member of the shouter group']
+87092;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+99805;['appeal of graeme james o’connor is dismissed']
+40776;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of canada’s protection']
+109630;['appeal is dismissed']
+77533;['decision cannot be amended']
+88607;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+128287;['appeal is dismissed']
+132778;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97628;['appeal brought by the appellant would be dismissed']
+85856;['negative']
+123473;['appeal is allowed']
+151553;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+91209;['removal order is set aside']
+68783;['appeal is allowed']
+41828;['appeal is allowed']
+60526;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes a determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare “convention refugees”']
+48911;['appeal is dismissed']
+90439;['appeals are allowed']
+47313;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+111323;['appeal is dismissed']
+148712;['claimants are not at risk']
+93900;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+66631;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+40371;['appeal is terminated']
+69737;['appeal is allowed']
+79190;['appeal isdismissed.']
+93586;['appeal be dismissed']
+97278;['appeal is allowed']
+56690;['appeal is allowed']
+96235;['appeal is subject']
+94583;['appeal is dismissed']
+106423;['appellants are either convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+98228;['appeal is abandoned']
+143035;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'or persons in need of protection']
+136094;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+135935;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitute it with this determination']
+113299;['appeal is allowed']
+99103;['appeal is dismissed']
+130066;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+86904;['appeal must fail']
+39570;['appeal is allowed']
+92567;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+103104;['appeal terminated']
+108718;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100842;['appeal is dismissed']
+124563;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90203;['negative']
+60318;['appeal is allowed']
+94201;['appeal is dismissed']
+72830;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+59699;['neither a “convention refugee”']
+151627;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+85855;['not a convention refugee']
+56248;['appeal is allowed for aveena kaur gill']
+150480;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+73703;['dismiss the overall appeal']
+69103;['appeal is allowed']
+60041;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+56614;['appeal isdismissed.']
+62946;['appeal isallowed']
+89022;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+86469;['appeal is allowed']
+92507;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+23095;['appeal isallowed']
+95651;['appeal isallowed']
+89257;['dismiss the appeal']
+142111;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+123819;['appeal is dismissed']
+72818;['appeal is dismissed']
+101411;['appeal isallowed']
+77796;['reject this claim to refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee']
+123847;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102678;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+32134;['appeal is dismissed']
+124571;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125135;['allow the appeal', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+136137;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+109028;['appeal is dismissed']
+81381;['appeal would not be dismissed']
+8283;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+64835;['appeal must be allowed']
+52727;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+77840;['panel, therefore, rejects her claim']
+95645;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+90588;['reject the appeal']
+68285;['allow this particular appeal']
+128361;['appeal is allowed']
+79466;['allow the appeal']
+86647;['appeal is dismissed']
+88260;['application for an oral hearing is denied']
+101424;['appeal is allowed']
+76770;['appeal fails']
+79722;['302 (c.a.']
+89074;['appeal is terminated']
+100879;['three claims are rejected']
+108881;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+122865;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+16763;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+72761;['appeal isallowed']
+96355;['appeal is dismissed']
+84216;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+123685;['substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+124077;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+23086;['appeal is dismissed']
+74999;['stay of the removal order is set aside', 'appeal is dismissed']
+63951;['appeal isallowed']
+42218;['appeals were dismissed']
+147794;['appeal is allowed']
+128418;['allows the minister’s appeal']
+132435;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107677;['tribunal therefore declares the appealabandoned']
+82701;['appeal isallowedand']
+92742;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+123704;['appeal is allowed']
+79033;['appeal is allowed']
+88525;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+44425;['appeal is dismissed']
+77329;['appeal must fail']
+96670;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+42221;['removal order is set aside']
+93913;['removal orders are set aside']
+140818;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor person in need of protection']
+86340;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+143536;['allow the appellants’ appeal']
+84460;['dismiss this appeal']
+86196;['appeal of besufekad debel ashame is dismissed']
+132813;['substitute a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+66307;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+122258;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+89329;['appeal is dismissed']
+74179;['appeal is dismissed']
+83504;['appeal isallowed']
+87468;['appeal is dismissed']
+92604;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+130758;['appeal is dismissed']
+63750;['appeal is dismissed']
+132813;['appeal is allowed']
+84354;['neither a permanent resident nor a protected person']
+91723;['appeal of krishnan nair is dismissed']
+151608;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+129191;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+26785;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+71035;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxisnot a convention refugee']
+152146;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the impugned decision', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need to protection']
+123763;['appeal is allowed']
+19118;"[""officer's decision is valid in law""]"
+81090;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87402;['dismiss the appeal']
+60322;['appeal of simona cozmescu is dismissed']
+124200;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85909;['appeal being allowed']
+93932;['appeal is allowed']
+82357;['appeal is allowed']
+34706;['appeal is dismissed']
+71043;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx,is not a convention refugee']
+87446;['appeal is dismissed']
+80674;['neither a convention refugee']
+75922;['appeal is allowed']
+78191;['appeal of tamineh rassoizadebh mehraban, her daughter, melissa marino and son, loris marino, are allowed']
+97600;['appeal is allowed']
+100435;['dismiss the appeal']
+30524;['appeal is allowed']
+74611;['appeal is allowed']
+82580;['appeal is dismissed']
+73201;['appeal in relation to rajinder kaur mann and gurpreet singh mann is allowed']
+100963;['appeal should be dismissed']
+105423;['appeal is allowed']
+99149;['removal orders areset aside']
+94534;['appeal is allowed']
+91164;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+91947;['dismissal of the appeal']
+94227;['dismiss the present appeal']
+87032;['allow the appeal of mylene clarita yasay']
+36122;['appeal is determined']
+59976;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+64242;['appeal is allowed']
+126421;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+71580;['appeal is allowed']
+81613;['appeal is dismissed']
+76050;['declare the appeal withdrawn']
+107950;['302 (c.a.']
+101064;['appeal is dismissed.as']
+91667;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+83836;['appeal is allowed']
+131032;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+65651;['appeal isallowed']
+83253;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+44842;['reject his claim']
+95122;['negative']
+124180;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+124657;['appeal is allowed']
+87859;['application is allowed']
+100408;['appeal isallowed']
+74792;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+35878;['appeal is dismissed']
+75258;['appeal is allowed']
+55166;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+40516;['302 (c.a.)']
+123417;['appeal is allowed']
+24494;['determination is not valid in law']
+111025;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+132643;['appeal is dismissed']
+29301;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+151367;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim made byxxxx xxxx xxxx']
+104394;['appeal of anne marie langley is dismissed']
+100765;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+94205;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+123294;['appeal is allowed']
+47550;['dismisses this appeal']
+57069;['appeal is allowed']
+125055;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+143580;['allow the appeal']
+128348;['appeal is allowed']
+129209;['appeal of may eleonor cabrera is dismissed']
+76633;['appeal is dismissed']
+131724;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+42329;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+94010;['appeal is allowed']
+80197;['rejects her claim']
+55284;['xxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+78662;['appeal is dismissed']
+110302;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151305;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is dismissed', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+82079;['appeal of chris mitchell is dismissed']
+97905;['appeal is dismissed']
+141267;['claim therefore fails']
+91217;['iad has not denied the appellant natural justice']
+97031;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeals']
+128364;['appeal is allowed']
+124681;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+145427;['appeal were dismissed']
+108709;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+74265;['rpd’s decision cannot stand and must be set aside']
+110690;['302 (c.a.']
+91683;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89897;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+90704;['appeal is allowed']
+96975;['appeal is dismissed']
+149015;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is duly dismissed']
+91601;['dismiss the appeal']
+65122;['appeal would be dismissed']
+84451;['appeal is dismissed']
+129919;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+90261;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a claim for refugee protection']
+82076;['appeal is allowed']
+90370;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+37837;['appeal is allowed']
+134211;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+62896;['appeal of kattie jane atasie is dismissed']
+126431;['302 (c.a.']
+106129;['appeal is dismissed']
+113626;['appeal is allowed']
+35882;['appeal is dismissed']
+45182;['refusal is invalid in law']
+92198;['302 (c.a.']
+91165;['appeal isallowed']
+97465;['claimant xxxx xxxx xxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+88839;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+131545;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+100255;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86876;['appeal is dismissed']
+15876;['appeal isallowed']
+22116;['appeal is allowed']
+56643;['decision must be upheld']
+89269;['appeal is allowed']
+142538;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+8293;['appeal is terminated']
+69317;['appeal is dismissed']
+90550;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+145133;['appeal is allowed']
+99212;['appeal is dismissed']
+93073;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97808;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+103107;['appeal is allowed']
+95102;['appeal is allowed']
+104123;['reject their claims']
+90903;['appeal is dismissed']
+60652;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+135168;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+43748;['appeal is dismissed']
+129140;['appeal is dismissed']
+78097;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+75927;['allow this appeal']
+148717;['xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are convention refugees']
+148650;['appeal may still fail']
+123607;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59712;['appeal is dismissed']
+133700;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109705;['appeal is denied']
+123018;['dismiss the appeals']
+69077;['appeal is allowed']
+54208;['appeal is dismissedfor']
+99612;['decision is not binding on other iad panels']
+64856;['appeal is allowed']
+96803;['appeal isallowed']
+83831;['appeal is allowed']
+111447;['302 (c.a.']
+96485;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+70645;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74469;['appeal is dismissed']
+46090;['appeal is allowed']
+52505;['appeal is allowed']
+98081;['“convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+115255;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+98054;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+84131;['appeal is dismissed']
+148999;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+68363;['appeal is allowed']
+97130;['appeal must be dismissed']
+63938;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+56950;['appeal is allowed']
+59858;['appeal ofhamid reza askari hazavehis dismissed in law and on discretionary grounds']
+91693;['appeal is allowed']
+65116;['dismiss this appeal']
+98512;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+59978;['negative']
+96652;['not allow her refugee protection claim']
+101257;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+120716;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+105709;['refugee protection claimant']
+146879;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination of the appellant’s claim']
+46539;['appeal is dismissed']
+144037;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141305;['rpd decision therefore cannot stand and is set aside']
+84735;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+131761;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+80035;['negative']
+68750;['appeal of gurinder pal singh sidhu is allowed']
+60123;['appeal of balvir singh johal is dismissed']
+123328;['302 (c.a.']
+136727;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a “convention refugee']
+67371;['appeal is dismissed']
+90648;['decision is not subject to appeal to the rad']
+26671;['appeal is allowed']
+91529;['appeal is terminated']
+86654;['appeal is allowed']
+31265;['appeal is allowed.the']
+101868;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94704;['appeal is allowed']
+105430;['appeal is allowed']
+140637;['appeal is dismissed']
+150683;['neither state protection', 'nor a viable ifa are available']
+143610;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83239;['appeal is dismissed']
+61339;['appeal is allowed']
+92435;['appeal is dismissed']
+106306;['appeals are dismissed']
+47577;['appeal is dismissed']
+14713;['refusal is invalid in law']
+117193;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+65399;['appeal is dismissed']
+28022;['appeal is dismissed']
+16821;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+94055;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+64308;['appeal is dismissed']
+39890;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86633;['appeal of jaspal kaur dhaliwal is allowed']
+78125;['negative']
+103624;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+93096;['claimants are neither convention refugee nor are they persons in need of protection']
+101798;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+112393;['appeal is dismissed']
+88500;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+106812;['appeal is dismissed']
+146836;['appeal is allowed']
+142839;['appeals of xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx are allowed']
+96061;['negative']
+67559;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis a convention refugee']
+130800;['refugee protection division excludes xxxx xxxx xxxx']
+98804;['appeal is allowed']
+148596;['dismiss the appeal']
+125353;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+72918;['appeal isallowed']
+67612;['dismissing the appellant’s appeal']
+71793;['dismissal of this appeal']
+89412;['appeal is terminated']
+83139;['appeal isallowed']
+124024;['dismiss the appeal']
+88082;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+129987;['appeal abandoned']
+122694;['appeal is allowed']
+94155;['negative']
+97316;['appeal is dismissed']
+122226;['dismiss the appeal']
+84727;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+137448;['appeal is allowed']
+74211;['302 (c.a.)']
+116756;['appeal is allowed']
+98065;['appeal is dismissed']
+54757;['appeal of tesfay kahsay bayru is dismissed']
+96499;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+38855;['appeal is dismissed']
+23097;['appeal is dismissed']
+78094;['appeal is allowed']
+47151;['appeal isallowed.the']
+74887;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+65408;['appeal is dismissed']
+74834;['appeal is allowed']
+95679;['appeal is allowed']
+93287;['claimants, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+127355;['appeal is dismissed']
+116898;['appeal should be allowed']
+89380;['appeal is terminated']
+47289;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+47389;['appeal is allowed']
+60124;['appeal is allowed']
+55343;['appeal is allowed']
+74860;['removal order is set aside']
+84746;['dismiss the appeal']
+118406;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+133284;['panel finds xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx not to be convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+96220;['appeal isallowed']
+145348;['claim is therefore rejected']
+84076;['appeal is allowed']
+100143;['xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+87682;['appeal is dismissed']
+15003;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+40112;['appeal is dismissed']
+135153;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+32085;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+98757;['dismissing the appeal in law']
+24463;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+131221;['appeal is allowed']
+94469;['appeal is allowed']
+115209;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+100653;['appeal isallowed']
+149109;['appeal is dismissed']
+132721;['theclaimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89314;['appeal is dismissed']
+86305;['dismiss the appeal']
+62470;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+111018;['appeal is dismissed']
+55205;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+123989;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+52923;['appeal is allowed']
+74234;['appeal is allowed']
+106678;['appeal is allowed']
+152820;['decision of the id is set aside']
+83839;['appeal is allowed']
+83077;['appeal is dismissed']
+130066;['claim is rejected']
+85505;['appeal of balwinder kaur sidhu is dismissed']
+152950;['appeal is rejected']
+56865;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+89904;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+43728;['appeal is, therefore']
+94004;['appeal isallowed']
+123546;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+40147;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+52059;['appeal is terminated']
+121549;['appellants are convention refugees and persons in need of protection']
+64236;['appeal is allowed']
+99241;['appeal is dismissed']
+56874;['appeal is terminated']
+69989;['appeal is allowed']
+62479;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90322;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+73256;['appeal is allowed']
+87202;['appeal is terminated']
+69964;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds', 'allow this appeal']
+84267;['appeal is allowed']
+146999;['appeal of aryan vijay soral is allowed']
+70175;['removal order is set aside']
+146948;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+151788;['european asylum support']
+105208;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96236;['appeal isallowed']
+88018;['neither a “convention refugee”']
+99875;['appeal abandoned']
+78014;['appeal is allowed']
+52079;['appeal isallowedand']
+100214;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102920;['appeal is allowed']
+153282;['rad finds that the p.a.']
+128401;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+101420;['appeal is allowed']
+77810;['the claim fails']
+22768;['appeal is dismissed']
+152479;['302 (c.a.']
+97452;['negative']
+93676;['dismiss this appeal']
+76183;['appeal of yin shui is allowed']
+47150;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+85951;['appeal is allowed']
+151749;['dismisses the appeal']
+64031;['appeal isallowed']
+42394;['appeals of the principal appellant and the co-appellants are allowed']
+113251;['appeal is allowed']
+149937;['appeal is allowed']
+94497;['appeal is dismissed']
+83446;['appeal is dismissed']
+99517;['appeals are allowed']
+130855;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+109172;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102131;['appeals are dismissed']
+95641;['dismissed the appeal.however']
+110274;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is inadmissible']
+101153;['dismiss the appeal']
+107321;['claimant is not a genuine practitioner of christianity']
+84763;['appellant is established in canada']
+123013;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+98885;['appeal is allowed']
+124105;['appeal is allowed']
+101879;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+88455;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+22740;['appeal is allowed']
+58639;['appeal is dismissed']
+83136;['appeal of andrei pasichnik is dismissed']
+146870;['appeal is allowed']
+146890;['appeal is dismissed']
+91317;['appeal be dismissed']
+64290;['appeal is dismissed']
+90236;['negative']
+121522;['appeal is dismissed']
+116747;['appeal is dismissed']
+132389;['appeal is allowed']
+141277;['rpd’s determination is set aside']
+26696;['appeal is allowed']
+72863;['panel finds that it concurs with the visa officer’s determination']
+72860;['appeal is dismissed']
+77653;['appellant is not well established incanada']
+83438;['dismiss the appeal']
+72209;['allow his appeal']
+77548;['appeal is dismissed']
+16810;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+90245;['panel therefore rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+141242;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+68111;['appeal is allowed']
+104935;['appeal is allowed']
+148762;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+98376;['appeal is dismissed']
+27721;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+53875;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+40805;['rad has found that the rpd decision can stand']
+36564;['appeal’s dismissal']
+53765;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+77855;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59662;['reject the claim for refugee protection']
+147803;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88504;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94582;['appeal isallowed']
+125115;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67245;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+125461;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80271;['reject her claim']
+88452;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+123891;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+88084;['appeal is dismissed']
+74701;['appeal dismissed']
+113264;['appeal was not allowed']
+62190;['appeal is terminated']
+46040;['appeal is determined']
+73253;['iad therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74204;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128375;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+78678;['appeal isallowed']
+98245;['appeal is dismissed']
+26473;['appeal is allowed']
+98638;['appeal is dismissed']
+82377;['appeal is allowed.the']
+49318;['appeal is allowed']
+16761;['application to reinstate the appeal is dismissed']
+91014;['appeal isallowed']
+131033;['appeal isdismissed.']
+77260;['appeal is allowed']
+32080;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67639;['appeal isallowed']
+69086;['appeal is allowed']
+99556;['appeal is allowed']
+76503;['allows the appeal']
+85233;['appeal isallowed.the']
+59979;['302 (c.a.']
+26686;['appeal is allowed in law']
+108907;['panel finds xxxx xxxx to not be a convention refugee']
+98241;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+54702;['appellant is not a sponsor,']
+128157;['302 (c.a.']
+130770;['302 (c.a.']
+53852;['appeal is allowed']
+71409;['appeal is dismissed']
+77675;['appeal is allowed']
+101508;['appeal is allowed']
+77632;['appeal isallowed']
+121937;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+76483;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+143876;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+133352;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76153;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+95649;['appeal was dismissed as abandoned']
+139843;['appeal is allowed']
+100986;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101791;['appeal is dismissed']
+134733;['associate appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84074;['appeal isallowed']
+130885;['appeal is dismissed']
+49067;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+38770;['appeal with respect']
+56796;['rejects this claim']
+135898;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+129869;['appeal is allowed']
+96626;['302 (c.a.']
+74838;['appeal is dismissed']
+99905;['appeal is dismissed']
+98412;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101814;['appeal was adjourned']
+89789;['dismiss this appeal']
+56947;['appeal is dismissed']
+139460;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+20003;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97303;['neither a convention refugee']
+59022;['dismisses the applicant’s application to reopen']
+63644;['theappealis allowed']
+105280;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+14699;['allow this appeal']
+88171;['appeal is dismissed']
+85531;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+78092;['appeal is allowed']
+84435;['appeal is allowed']
+113528;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+65197;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+72623;['appeal is allowed']
+83314;['appeal has been abandoned']
+123009;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+90582;['appeal isallowed']
+74167;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140300;['panel rejects this']
+151756;['appeal is dismissed']
+52160;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128745;['appeals of the other appellants are allowed']
+100050;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+132375;['appeal was dismissed']
+63609;['appeals are allowed']
+70756;['appeal isallowed']
+81372;['negative']
+116835;['appellant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+35435;['appeal is allowed']
+86552;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+123980;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+85435;['appeal is allowed']
+77470;['appeal is terminated']
+148617;['appeal is dismissed']
+32167;['appeal isallowed']
+85388;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is accordingly allowed']
+91341;['appeal can therefore be dismissed']
+101194;['decision of the rpd']
+63094;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+125054;['rad therefore finds that the rpd’s decision regarding her claim is correct']
+104949;['claim is rejected']
+74817;['appeal ofdenroy sewellis dismissed']
+56895;['appeal is dismissed']
+142523;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+150786;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106296;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77801;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+21463;['claimant,xxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+123318;['appeal is allowed']
+70642;['appeal is dismissed']
+100175;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+108214;['appeal is dismissed']
+69737;['appeal isallowed']
+87696;['declare the appealabandoned.']
+96982;['negative']
+94651;['appeal is allowed']
+52367;['sponsorship is for her sister']
+101277;['appeal is dismissed']
+56901;['appeal isallowed']
+110315;['appeal is dismissed']
+143179;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124960;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45244;['application is granted']
+123058;['rpd decision therefore cannot stand and is set aside']
+104346;['appeal isallowed']
+97959;['appeal is allowed']
+78330;['appeal is allowed']
+91313;['dismiss the appeal']
+68435;['appeal isallowedand']
+99921;['appeal be allowed']
+57480;['allowed the postponement request']
+100779;['appeal is allowed']
+31933;['appeal is dismissed']
+131033;['appeal is dismissed']
+100013;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94094;['appeal is allowed']
+82143;['appeal was dismissed']
+95928;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants named are convention refugees']
+95451;['appellant has not lost her']
+105650;['appeal is dismissed']
+78195;['xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx and xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+108808;['nor a genuine falun gong practitioner']
+83101;['dismiss the appeal']
+88109;['appeal isallowed']
+136670;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+89352;['appeal isallowed']
+48209;['appeal is dismissed']
+23057;['appeal is dismissed']
+99612;['appeal must be discontinued']
+67703;['x.is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+125548;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+84067;['302 (c.a.']
+88252;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94662;['appeal isallowed']
+111016;['appeal is dismissed']
+111008;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+148610;['appeal is allowed.the']
+38246;['appeals are allowed']
+121470;['refugee appeal division dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78085;['appeal isallowed']
+73876;['appeal is allowed']
+74603;['appeal is dismissed']
+146969;['appeal should be dismissed']
+101285;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+142730;['rpd’s findings on these issues are therefore overturned']
+27296;['allow the appeal']
+84241;['allows this appeal']
+132883;['appeal is allowed']
+139678;['appeals are dismissed']
+96335;['appeal be dismissed']
+71062;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+47110;['panel finds the deportation order valid in law']
+106894;['removal order is set aside']
+26697;['appeal is dismissed']
+127337;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+136085;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88508;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+60895;['302 (c.a.)']
+49543;['appeal isallowed']
+46484;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+76456;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101337;['appeal is allowed']
+107476;['appeal is dismissed']
+70780;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+58547;['appeal is dismissed']
+45399;['appeal is dismissed']
+123612;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83380;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+72678;['appeal is abandoned']
+62988;['appeal isallowed.the']
+93591;['appeal is dismissed']
+146929;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+77318;['appeal is dismissed']
+102918;['appeal is terminated']
+71540;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+94718;['appeal is allowed']
+84473;['appeal is terminated']
+152036;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decisionthat', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+106267;['panel rejects her claim']
+101763;['appeal of manjeet kaur dhaliwal is allowed']
+68088;['appeal is allowed']
+76307;['appeal is allowed']
+88333;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71179;['appeal is dismissed']
+47116;['appeal is dismissed']
+129116;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+67681;['appeal bedismissedand']
+122926;['appeal is allowed']
+84189;['appeal is dismissed']
+84689;['appeal is dismissed']
+95080;['confirm the rpd determination']
+29538;['appeal of yan zhen chen is allowed']
+90638;['appeal isallowed']
+102113;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd rendered the appropriate decision']
+135203;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellantsxxxx xxxxxxxx,xxxx xxxxxxxxandxxxx xxxxxxxxare convention refugees']
+113622;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+97416;['claim is therefore rejected']
+76540;['appeal is dismissed']
+69153;['appeal is dismissed']
+82204;['appeal is dismissed']
+77934;['appeal is dismissed']
+133702;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72140;['removal order is set aside']
+74635;['iad is without jurisdiction']
+77596;['appeal isallowed']
+141659;['appeal is allowed']
+105795;['appeal is dismissed']
+57734;['appeal isallowed']
+24486;['appeal is dismissed']
+48222;['appeal is dismissed']
+59661;['reject the claims for refugee protection']
+124127;['appeal is allowed']
+46475;['appeal is allowed']
+151516;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+21409;['application to reinstate the claim to convention refugee status']
+91077;['appeal is dismissed']
+60993;['appeal is allowed']
+40664;['allow the appeal']
+68578;['appeal is allowed']
+93648;['appeal is allowed']
+112785;['allow the appeal']
+121215;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141221;['rad rejects this argument']
+98376;['appeal is dismissed']
+95092;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+63857;['claimant in not a convention refugee']
+82807;['appeal is dismissed']
+76527;['appeal isallowed']
+90729;['appeal is allowed']
+144260;['302 (c.a.']
+83257;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+34168;['appeal is dismissed']
+94584;['appeal is allowed']
+76570;['appeal is allowed']
+79988;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+87824;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+151759;['appeal is dismissed']
+93809;['302 (c.a.']
+129194;['appeal is dismissed']
+43604;['appeal is allowed.the']
+24513;['appeal is allowed']
+88099;['appeal isallowed']
+73284;['appellant is not a good candidate']
+19313;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+148641;['appeal is allowed']
+132312;['not a person in need of protection']
+63878;['appeal isallowed']
+122658;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+123452;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+109037;['appeals are dismissed']
+97016;['negative']
+114695;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+94554;['appeal is allowed']
+82734;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+102072;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88327;['appeal is dismissed']
+38835;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107609;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121416;['appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+50439;['appeal is allowed']
+94595;['appeal is dismissed']
+107692;['appeal is dismissed']
+42329;['appeal is allowed.the']
+110904;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will stand']
+125123;['rad rejects this argument']
+102901;['appeal is allowed']
+67659;['appeal is allowed']
+31400;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+140918;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxand the childrenxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+62878;['xxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+69176;['appeal is dismissed']
+94029;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77780;['appeal is allowed']
+97992;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+77696;['appeal must succeed']
+85513;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100781;['appeal should therefore be dismissed']
+86058;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee not a person in need of protection']
+105430;['appeal is allowed']
+70192;['appeal is dismissed']
+75588;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84489;['appeal is allowed']
+142829;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68785;['appeal is dismissed']
+93589;['appeal is allowed']
+148761;['claimantis neithera convention refugee']
+124939;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92408;['appeal isallowed']
+17971;['dismiss the appeal']
+132658;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'appeal must be dismissed']
+142817;['negative determination']
+19383;['appeal is dismissed']
+93631;['appeal must be dismissed']
+76239;['appeal is dismissed']
+89396;['appeal is dismissed']
+54709;['appeal is dismissed']
+124696;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+98910;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84294;['appeal is allowed']
+62382;['claim is rejected']
+74849;['allow her appeal']
+97200;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+123404;['appeals are dismissed']
+82140;['appeal be dismissed']
+60122;['reject this claim']
+100369;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+143029;['panel rejects his explanation']
+84609;['appeal of the refusal']
+115280;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+46240;['appeal is abandoned']
+50554;['appeal isallowed']
+94103;['appeal is allowed.the']
+82217;['appeal is allowed']
+57933;['appeal is determined']
+90408;['appeal is dismissed']
+94972;['appeal is terminated']
+102699;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44271;['appeal is allowed']
+99775;['confirms her church membership']
+76165;['panel therefore rejects her claim']
+90625;['appeal is terminated']
+132391;['appeal is dismissed']
+49527;['appeal is allowed']
+60481;['application is allowed']
+22820;['appeal of oscar armando velis vaquerano is dismissed']
+52367;['appeal is allowed']
+59860;['appeals are allowed']
+71555;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+145383;['rejects the claims']
+34625;['appeal were dismissed']
+92541;['allow this appeal']
+98625;['appeal is allowed']
+76909;['application to reopen is allowed']
+88099;['appeal is allowed']
+81132;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+142076;['not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+98243;['appeal is allowed']
+136700;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+118334;['appeal is dismissed']
+116803;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+96317;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+142086;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98657;['appeal is allowed']
+124459;['appeal is dismissed']
+52302;['board does not lose jurisdiction']
+143140;['appeals are dismissed']
+93684;['decision is legally valid']
+105322;['appeal is dismissed']
+100761;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+29709;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+91097;['ms. nadia asim is not described unders']
+98007;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+102031;['allow the appeal']
+95389;['appeal was dismissed']
+121160;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+84859;['allows this appeal']
+126412;['confirm the rpd determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+105880;['302 (c.a.']
+82163;['appeal is dismissed']
+82443;['appeal isallowed.the']
+141306;['allow the appeal and', 'substitute my decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+93097;['claimant isnot a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+105445;['appeal is allowed']
+100420;['dismissing this appeal']
+128260;['appeal is dismissed']
+76051;['appeal isallowed']
+124014;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140905;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96658;['his claim fails']
+143545;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'claim is dismissed']
+143626;['appeal is allowed']
+124824;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+89394;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+94129;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+88027;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+114292;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84872;['appeal be dismissed']
+69520;['appeal isdismissed.']
+61411;['appeal is determined']
+108254;['appeal is allowed']
+92810;['appeal is allowed']
+78140;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70475;['302 (c.a.']
+99455;['claimants to not be convention refugees unders']
+38994;['appeal is allowed']
+18995;['officer’s decision is set aside', 'appeal isallowed']
+95408;['appeal is allowed']
+90007;['appeal is allowed']
+132841;['appeals before me are both terminated by operation of law']
+96923;['negative']
+83312;['appeal isallowed']
+49161;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+102107;['appeal is dismissed']
+104287;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+106843;['appeal is dismissed']
+84181;['dismiss the appeal']
+145426;['appeal is allowed']
+123064;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71792;['appeal isallowedand']
+87796;['appeal isallowed']
+131079;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeals of the associate appellants are also dismissed']
+111014;['rpd found that the respondent was a convention refugee']
+99037;['302 (c.a.']
+105305;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69426;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+149018;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+150755;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection” within']
+91574;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+70103;['allowed the appeal in a bench decision']
+75991;['appeal of akhtar banu and jafar reza khan is therefore allowed']
+105863;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143609;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+94089;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+26801;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+60434;['appeal is allowed']
+70960;['appeal fails']
+94335;['appeal is dismissed']
+148981;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+117123;['appeal is granted']
+95689;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+104079;['appeal is allowed']
+136086;['rpd’s determination is correct']
+125684;['302 (c.a.']
+133381;['removal order is set aside']
+92540;['appeal is allowed']
+69864;['panel finds that the removal orders are valid in law']
+138826;['appeal isallowed']
+93942;['appeal is allowed']
+91022;['appeal of mario koch is dismissed']
+133256;['appeal is allowed']
+82975;['appeal is dismissed']
+77979;['appeal is allowed']
+81002;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+90671;['appeal is allowed']
+141246;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74756;['appeal is determined to beabandoned undersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+68187;['appeal is dismissed']
+116828;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+130788;['removal order is set aside']
+144401;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not “convention refugees”']
+94695;['appeal is dismissed']
+122115;['appeal is allowed']
+26894;['claimants, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxx,are “convention refugees”']
+102991;['decision is ill-founded']
+96027;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision to reject the appellant’s refugee claim']
+13943;['appeal of parminder kaur khosa is dismissed']
+87345;['appeal is dismissed']
+99929;['application to change the location of the proceeding is denied']
+151521;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+88775;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124799;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69786;['appeal is dismissed']
+152127;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+86935;['appeal is dismissed']
+96477;['appeals are dismissed']
+116830;['rad confirms that the']
+16764;['appeal is allowed']
+101055;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80806;['appeal of kanwaljit kaur gill is allowed']
+71064;['appeal is allowed']
+90628;['appeal is dismissed']
+37495;['appeal is dismissed']
+144550;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+24501;['appeal of jamie sue fournier is dismissed']
+92814;['appeal is dismissed']
+59746;['appeal isallowed']
+114303;['dismiss the appeal']
+136737;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55282;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101987;['appeal isallowed']
+88812;['appeal isallowed']
+83673;['removal order isset aside']
+152622;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+103666;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+87098;['appeal is dismissed']
+122263;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+89351;['appeal is terminated']
+125056;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm, for other reasons', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35812;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+66327;['appeals aredismissedand departure orders are made']
+62486;['are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+31051;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+85522;['appeal is allowed.the']
+108677;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92497;['appeal of ayantu ibrahim is dismissed']
+114347;['rpd’s determination is set aside']
+60833;['appeal is discontinued']
+17141;['appeal is determined']
+36243;['appeal is dismissed']
+30488;['appeal regarding the appellant’s sister, manpreet kaur dhaliwal, is withdrawn']
+87823;['claim is therefore rejected']
+74781;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+146841;['appeal is allowed.the']
+72625;['appeal be allowed']
+44212;['appeal isallowed']
+69574;['appeal is allowed']
+84867;['appeal is allowed']
+69343;['appeal is dismissed']
+72670;['appeal is dismissed']
+132733;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+69261;['appeal is dismissed']
+63095;['claim for refugee protection is hereby rejected']
+103612;['presumption is rebuttable']
+80776;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+60053;['appeal is allowed']
+68584;['appeal dismissed']
+98434;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+93626;['appeal is dismissed']
+81071;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+100969;['appeal isallowed']
+72654;['appeals of the appellant and the co-appellant are, therefore, dismissed']
+103021;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+123254;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151871;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention   refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52714;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+113258;['appeal isallowed']
+18863;['appeal is allowed']
+133734;['appeal is allowed']
+121869;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+142894;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+77084;['appeal is allowed']
+79471;['appeal is dismissed']
+45896;['appeal is dismissed']
+96470;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+36125;['appeal is allowed']
+93914;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+135122;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+80108;['appeal is dismissed']
+151749;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+76938;['appeal is dismissed']
+84141;['appeal isallowed']
+26939;['not a convention refugee']
+104260;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+129530;['appeal isallowed']
+133242;['appeal ends here and is dismissed']
+104431;['appeal is dismissed']
+98241;['appeal is allowed']
+94243;['appeals are dismissed']
+77075;['appeal is allowed']
+108196;['argument fails']
+133726;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67530;['appeal isallowed']
+79359;['appeal is dismissed']
+24469;['appeal is terminated']
+9491;['appeal isallowed']
+79929;['302 (c.a.']
+97394;['302 (c.a.)']
+69094;['appeal is allowed']
+100828;['302 (c.a.)']
+38837;['appeal were dismissed']
+96895;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision must be set aside']
+111289;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+46520;['appeal is allowed']
+151327;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+106812;['appeal is allowed']
+63752;['appeal is dismissed']
+103802;['claimantxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+93085;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+42416;['appeal should be dismissed']
+110685;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+140889;['302 (c.a.)']
+24207;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+55272;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+89554;['appeal is terminated']
+24204;['appeal cannot be allowed']
+36182;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+77990;['appeal is dismissed']
+74531;['appeal is dismissed']
+148595;['appeal is dismissed']
+74168;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94331;['appeal is allowed', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+71077;['refugee protection division determinesxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, andxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees', 'rejects their claims']
+59851;['appeal is allowed']
+152917;['rad denies the appeal.']
+130730;['appeal is allowed']
+123837;['rad further finds and confirms the rpd’s uncontested decision']
+89010;['appeal is allowed']
+96154;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+66570;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+152006;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+105912;['appeal isallowed']
+102919;['appeal of is dismissed']
+40131;['appeal is dismissed']
+44097;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+125344;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+19164;['appeal is dismissed']
+52792;['deny the application']
+76498;['appeal is terminated']
+26993;['aaaaaaaaa not to be a convention refugee']
+76542;['appeal isallowed']
+83377;['appeal isallowed']
+99333;['refugee appeal division confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+113754;['appeal is allowed']
+75447;['appeal isallowed']
+94264;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+84330;['appeal is allowed']
+53444;['appeals of the principal appellant']
+71206;['appeal is dismissed']
+61918;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+81137;['appeal is dismissed']
+56941;['appeal was dismissed']
+71694;['appeal is dismissed']
+68922;['appeal isallowed']
+51674;['appeal is dismissed']
+87026;['appeal is dismissed']
+105875;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person who would be subject to persecution should he return to china']
+99295;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106678;['appeal is allowed']
+105307;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+89093;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+22130;['positive decision is rendered']
+60700;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+99498;['appeal is dismissed']
+92957;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+83916;['appeal isallowed']
+69361;['appeal is dismissed']
+59841;['appeal is allowed']
+60190;['appeal is dismissed']
+125227;['appeal is dismissed']
+92610;['or a “person in need of protection']
+81114;['appeals are based']
+109022;['appeal is dismissed']
+80550;['dismissing the appeal']
+73279;['appeal is dismissed']
+100700;['appeal is dismissed']
+58418;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+140064;['appeal is allowed']
+87791;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+100993;['appeal is dismissed']
+13694;['allows this appeal']
+151492;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+69940;['appeal is therefore   ']
+107468;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+67800;['appeal is dismissed']
+21332;['claimant fits the definition of a convention refugee', 'claimant to be a convention refugee']
+101060;['appeal isallowed']
+69991;['appeal of scott daniel ritchie is dismissed']
+96749;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92242;['appeal isallowed']
+99028;['panel rejects these claims']
+124137;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89124;['appeal is dismissed']
+142817;['appeal is allowed']
+77454;['appeal is dismissed']
+137678;['appeals are dismissed']
+84715;['allow the appeal']
+42448;['appeal is allowed']
+95358;['appeal is dismissed']
+100753;['appeal is dismissed']
+93549;['appeal is dismissed']
+147879;['appeal is allowed']
+34694;['appeal is denied']
+98863;['302 (c.a.']
+96858;['appeal is allowed']
+72643;['appeal is dismissed']
+143537;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+44736;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+87457;['appeal is determined']
+100796;['appeal is allowed']
+60195;['appeal is dismissed']
+64314;['appeals of sam choi, sylvia kim choi and anna choi']
+113560;['appeal be dismissed']
+70211;['appeal is allowed']
+142310;['appeal is dismissed']
+108799;['rad finds that the rpd panel erred']
+98805;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+64234;['appeal isallowed.the']
+99408;['negative']
+107910;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124980;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+55276;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+101805;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+124565;['appeal is allowed']
+124185;['appeal is allowed']
+73184;['appeal is dismissed']
+94029;['appeal is allowed']
+48589;['appeal isallowed']
+103206;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+77090;['appeal isdismissed.']
+120821;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+66915;['appeal is dismissed']
+97085;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52917;['panel finds the visa officer’s decision of july\xa011, 2006']
+150720;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+103611;['you are not a convention refugee']
+141245;['appeal is allowed']
+108117;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+90738;['appeal isallowed']
+14700;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+91951;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, is therefore excluded from the definition of convention refugee']
+97427;['dismiss the appeal']
+123307;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'you are not a refugee']
+56891;['appeal is dismissed']
+102096;['appeal is dismissed']
+98475;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+35879;['appeals are dismissed']
+129101;['appeal is dismissed']
+52122;['appeal is allowed']
+69523;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+56786;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx are convention refugees']
+92512;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+71597;['appeals are dismissed']
+139804;['appeals are allowed']
+56500;['appeal is allowed']
+130697;['appeal is dismissed']
+91667;['leads me to believe that the appellant’s primary purpose']
+127426;['appeal is dismissed']
+128367;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74230;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+97084;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+92464;['appeal is dismissed']
+99050;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd’s decision', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+103617;['not a person in need of protection']
+37902;['appeal is allowed']
+21349;['not a convention refugee']
+116777;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76766;['appeal isallowed']
+101107;['couple’s reasons lack substance']
+92935;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+122229;['appeal is allowed']
+135462;['dismissing the appeal']
+133253;['appeal is allowed']
+93311;['appeal is dismissed']
+121569;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+91529;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+94103;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+106341;['appeal is dismissed']
+81193;['appeal is allowed']
+92472;['appeal is allowed']
+44098;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+24849;['appeal is allowed']
+8283;['dismiss this application']
+144773;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+143629;['appeal is allowed']
+96608;['negative']
+124817;['appellant is not a refugee or asylum seeker']
+98518;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+129997;['reject the appellant’s argument']
+90095;['claimant is neither a convention refugee unders']
+148627;['appeal is allowed']
+90287;['iad is without jurisdiction to hear this appeal']
+44180;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62009;['appeal isallowed']
+76903;['appeal is allowed']
+104071;['appeal isallowed.the']
+96175;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+152059;['claimants are excluded from refugee protection', 'reject their claims']
+74178;['appellants are convention refugees']
+108211;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84684;['302 (c.a.)']
+80249;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+51338;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+101471;['appeal is allowed']
+21444;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+82711;['appeal isallowed']
+71732;['appeal would be dismissed']
+82569;['appeal is allowed']
+131711;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+70113;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+66774;['appeal is allowed.the']
+69474;['appeal dismissed']
+131020;['appeal is dismissed']
+99786;['appeal with respect to the appellant’s residency obligation was dismissed']
+135460;['neither a falun gong practitioner', 'nor a genuine practitioner']
+74735;['appeal is allowed']
+76655;['visa officer’s refusal is not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+46245;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+102991;['rad concludes that the rpd decision is wrong']
+122244;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+143479;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+60873;['appeal is allowed']
+88311;['appeal isdismissed.']
+72613;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+122634;['appeal is allowed']
+151868;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+118137;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151498;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+110965;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+99031;['panel rejects this claim']
+95868;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+49147;['appeals are allowed.the']
+86653;['appeal in relation to the principal appellant is dismissed']
+122246;['respondent is a convention refugee']
+122562;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+94144;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+54678;['appeal is allowed']
+95480;['appeal is dismissed']
+72203;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+86310;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69332;['allows this appeal']
+124115;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+71239;['appeal is allowed']
+97447;['appeal is allowed']
+96934;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+94996;['appeal is allowed']
+87324;['appeal is allowed']
+30485;['appeal is allowed']
+88016;['claimants’ removal']
+99006;['appeal is dismissed']
+109622;"[""rpd's determination cannot stand""]"
+93061;['appeal is dismissed']
+147011;['appeal is allowed']
+30510;['appeal were dismissed']
+132208;['appeal of zuliang zhen is dismissed']
+69494;['appeal isallowed']
+100264;['rejects this claim']
+71625;['appeal is allowed']
+100748;['appeal is allowed']
+46385;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+117122;['appeal is allowed']
+99089;['appeal is terminated']
+97827;['application to reopen is therefore dismissed']
+59668;['removal order isset aside']
+98571;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+65629;['appeal is allowed']
+78087;['appeal is allowed']
+105333;['appeal is dismissed']
+91536;['leads me to conclude that the primary purpose']
+125496;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is excluded']
+42218;['appeals are dismissed']
+153286;['refugee protection division determines that xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee', 'allows her claim']
+139678;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+97392;['reject her claim']
+113285;['appeal is dismissed']
+61223;['appeal is allowed']
+99103;['appeal isdismissed.']
+103045;['appeal is dismissed']
+148776;['appeal of the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness against a decision of the immigration division']
+152949;['appeal is dismissed']
+73194;['appeal is terminated']
+144554;['neither state protection']
+121868;['rad allows the appeal, sets aside the rpd determination']
+37827;['appeal was dismissed']
+95594;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+23023;['appeal isallowed']
+111107;['rad finds that the', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirm the determination of the refugee protection division']
+59755;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is dismissed']
+89150;['appeal is dismissed']
+68713;['appeal is allowed']
+82657;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99775;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+101305;['appeal is allowed']
+97280;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+113609;['appeal is allowed']
+59766;['officer’s decision cannot stand in law']
+74463;['appeal is allowed']
+22116;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100106;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151483;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+146880;['appeal is dismissed']
+64239;['appeal is allowed']
+103888;['appeal is dismissed']
+141160;['appeal is allowed']
+106414;['panel confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+54246;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+75912;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+90909;['appeal isallowedand']
+142069;['appellant is an excluded person']
+100082;['negative']
+148733;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+38840;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+47178;['appeal of swarn singh dhaliwal is dismissed']
+101449;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+104259;['appeal is allowed']
+111000;['appeal is allowed']
+101865;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+101169;['appellant a convention refugee']
+83142;['302 (c.a.)']
+50758;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77892;['appeal is dismissed']
+144484;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99182;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+85978;['appeal isallowed']
+27297;['panel finds the decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+47762;['appeal isallowed']
+141676;['appeal is allowed']
+80229;['negative']
+104342;['appeal isallowedand']
+104072;['appeal proceeded']
+101452;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80284;['negative']
+83547;['appeal isdismissed.']
+60430;['appeal is allowed in law']
+73310;['allow the appeal']
+94983;['appeal isallowed.the']
+83861;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee.']
+127702;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+106610;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', '“convention refugees”']
+110678;['appeal is dismissed']
+116828;['302 (c.a.']
+73337;['appeal isallowed']
+123380;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+67662;['appeal should be allowed']
+95941;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision in this matter was wrong in fact and law']
+70175;['appeal isallowed']
+55149;['appeals of charles adafe adigolo, evelyn adeola adigolo, precious ejirooghene adigolo, victoria oghenerukwe odigolo, and emmanuela oluseyi adigolo are dismissed']
+101304;['appeal is allowed']
+87354;['appellant is a refugee']
+36105;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59368;['appeal is dismissed']
+64260;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+82178;['appeal should be dismissed']
+82852;['appeal of everton lorenzo ambersley is dismissed']
+125372;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes its decision in place of that of the rpd']
+84076;['appeal is allowed']
+64297;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+52785;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+105301;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd']
+101762;['appeal is allowed']
+92806;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+132430;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+108784;['appeal is denied']
+34708;['appeal is dismissed']
+89561;['appeal is dismissed']
+72917;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+96737;['declares the appeal abandoned']
+78674;['appeal isallowed.the']
+54814;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision, cannot substitute its own determination']
+43705;['dismissed the appeal']
+122732;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding is correct']
+99423;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection', 'division rejects his claim']
+102143;['appeals are dismissed']
+104487;['appeal is dismissed']
+85216;['appeal is abandoned']
+93087;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+113537;['dismiss the appeal']
+123889;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106427;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128159;['appeal is allowed']
+110930;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+57545;['appeals of hao wang and jinan tian are dismissed']
+109701;['appeal is allowed']
+28100;['removal orders areset aside']
+90222;['appeal is terminated']
+69180;['appeal is allowed']
+89741;['appeal is terminated']
+39904;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+60482;['appeal is dismissed']
+95381;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131069;['appeal is dismissed']
+57927;['appeal is dismissed']
+138294;['appeal is dismissed']
+122833;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77326;['dismissal of the appeal']
+91734;['appeal is dismissed']
+105437;['determination is valid in law']
+72007;['appeal is allowed']
+123453;['appeal is dismissed']
+77890;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+101151;['appeal has been abandoned']
+65683;['appeal be and is allowed']
+146107;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+63733;['appeal is dismissed']
+52273;['panel orders the appellant’s case re-opened']
+67525;['appeal isallowed']
+95050;['appeal is dismissed']
+70766;['nor a person in need of protection']
+8279;['appeal isallowed.the']
+110953;['appeal is dismissed']
+122621;['appeal is allowed']
+92192;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,is not a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+125328;['appeal therefore fails']
+124203;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+153290;['dismiss this appeal']
+116342;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84667;['appeal is allowed']
+68525;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+96112;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+101613;['determination is valid in law']
+151846;['appeal is allowed']
+122868;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+97025;['rad rejects that explanation']
+113584;['appeal is dismissed']
+91109;['appeal is allowed']
+63702;['appeal is allowed']
+71265;['appeal is allowed']
+113567;['appeal is based']
+106278;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+45161;['appeal is allowed']
+142500;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+19115;['appeal is allowed']
+112386;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+145356;['claim is rejected']
+122990;['substitute a decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+99727;['appeal is dismissed']
+132318;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54680;['appeal is allowed']
+49064;['appeal is dismissed']
+89756;['appeal is allowed']
+121217;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104943;['appeal is terminated', 'appeal is dismissed']
+80781;['reject his claim']
+100580;['claimant is not in need of protection']
+104106;['panel rejects this claim']
+99717;['appeal is dismissed']
+95075;['appeal of diego alonso carbajal is dismissed']
+47794;['appeal is allowed']
+80127;['dismiss the appeal']
+84584;['appeal is terminated']
+80007;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+76072;['appeal is allowed']
+99195;['refugee protection division determines that the claimant is excluded from the refugee protection afforded convention refugees and persons in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+104161;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his claim']
+77242;['appeal is allowed']
+38849;['appeal isallowed.the']
+46073;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+87732;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+52493;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+144381;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made']
+99744;['302 (c.a.']
+69085;['appeal is dismissed']
+97002;['appeal isallowed']
+63229;['appeal isallowed']
+38873;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+127466;['appeal is allowed']
+60970;['appeal is dismissed']
+124333;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+142502;['302 (c.a.']
+146932;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99502;['appeal of thuc ky lam is dismissed']
+96809;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+12223;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+95390;['rad finds that the rpd’s conclusions were reasonable']
+108185;['appeal was not dismissed']
+148679;['appeal is dismissed']
+97117;['appeal is terminated']
+140790;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor are they “persons in need of protection']
+96620;['appeal is allowed']
+52517;['appeal is allowed']
+74854;['appeal is dismissed']
+141023;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+20432;['removal orders are set aside']
+103549;['appeal is allowed']
+135157;['appeal is allowed']
+144390;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+19302;['confirm the rpd decision', '“convention refugee”']
+83547;['appeal is dismissed']
+56505;['appeal is dismissed']
+104140;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+44979;['removal order is set aside', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+91545;['appeal is dismissed']
+92500;['appeal is allowed']
+96217;['appeal is dismissed']
+65647;['appeal is dismissed']
+101708;['appeal is allowed']
+96863;['appeal is allowed']
+125001;['rpd’s findings are upheld']
+26759;['appeal is dismissed']
+71910;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+64622;['appeal is allowed']
+10021;['allow the appeal']
+124904;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+74690;['appeal of ding xi lin is dismissed']
+150689;['appeal is allowed']
+64367;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+100567;['appeal is allowed']
+93586;['302 (c.a.)']
+61970;['appeal is dismissed']
+78034;['decision is valid in law']
+115222;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74849;['appeal is allowed']
+107933;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+47352;['appeal of dermopth ian moody is dismissed']
+56690;['appeal is allowed']
+70964;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+135919;['rad allows the appeal']
+78769;['appeal isallowed']
+142995;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+114302;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+67667;['appeal is dismissed']
+83365;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+37395;['appeals of nikolaj paul, emmanuil paul and anita paul are dismissed']
+76288;['appeal isallowed']
+129187;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+132735;['refugee protection claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+68106;['appeal is allowed']
+52729;['convention refugee division determines xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+84599;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+126400;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+112367;['appeal is dismissed']
+76657;['appeal is allowed']
+96027;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46284;['appeal is allowed']
+88066;['confirm the determination']
+128879;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+96801;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93694;['appeal is allowed']
+123665;['appeal is allowed']
+69673;['not find that the applicant has temporary resident status']
+99215;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+151369;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95946;['appeal is allowed']
+123030;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93328;['appeal isallowed']
+61448;['appeal is allowed']
+120799;['ministers’ appeal is allowed']
+102911;['claim is rejected']
+99549;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+74559;['appeal is terminated']
+124455;['appeal is dismissed']
+95934;['appeal must therefore fail']
+106411;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+104281;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+123105;['appeal is allowed']
+97873;['appeal is allowed']
+123112;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95710;['302 (c.a.']
+38788;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision cannot stand as the rpd has failed to provide reasons']
+103802;['claimant is not a “convention refugee��']
+143902;['appeal is dismissed']
+27339;['appeal is allowed']
+92853;['appeal ofiness\xa0arifis allowed']
+129172;['appeal is dismissed']
+23089;['appeal be dismissed']
+99163;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+61465;['appeal is allowed']
+131941;['appeal is allowed']
+132400;['appeal being dismissed']
+94599;['appeal is allowed']
+124661;['not substitute a decision under eitherparagraphs 111(1)(a) or (b) of theirpawithout']
+15424;['appeal of jia wei liang is dismissed']
+85323;['appeal is allowed']
+66933;['appeal is allowed']
+59839;['appeal is dismissed']
+69850;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+90829;['nor a permanent resident ofcanada.']
+46098;['appeal is dismissed']
+107620;['appeal is dismissed']
+44023;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+52535;['appeal is dismissed']
+72563;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+125490;['appeal is dismissed.xxxx', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94215;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+130806;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79328;['appeal is dismissed']
+104976;['appeal is allowed']
+143248;['appeal is dismissed']
+136158;['appeal is allowed']
+122372;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123371;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+29128;['appeal is dismissed']
+145823;['appeal is allowed']
+55264;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+102147;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+79691;['appeal isallowed']
+105557;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+71128;['appeal of phung te tu is therefore dismissed']
+35037;['appeal is allowed.the']
+60431;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+75134;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+71170;['appeal is governed by theact']
+141827;['claimant is not a   convention refugee', 'division rejects her claim']
+140726;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+133179;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+56665;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+87077;['appeal is allowed']
+113256;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+14675;['claimant xxx xxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+136136;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+77818;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95338;['appeal is allowed']
+142891;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision']
+94744;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+129235;['appeal is dismissed']
+121456;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+128360;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+91668;['appeal is dismissed']
+53831;['appeal is dismissed']
+47139;['appeal isres judicata']
+42317;['appeal is dismissed']
+82381;['appeal is dismissed']
+90186;['appeal is terminated']
+140210;['appeal is allowed']
+74657;['appeal is allowed']
+130932;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26530;['appeal was reinstated']
+83658;['appeal isallowed']
+107826;['rad allows the appeal,']
+33316;['appeal is allowed']
+36244;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93804;['tribunal rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+71792;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76408;['appeal isallowed']
+98330;['allow the appeal']
+81919;['appeals are dismissed']
+23046;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpaparticularly in']
+117108;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+79233;['appeal is dismissed']
+24468;['appeal of bizuneh tekola merein is dismissed']
+105628;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+123265;['appeal is allowed']
+34099;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+108766;['appellant is not a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+151792;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeals']
+150687;['appeal is allowed']
+151379;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94381;['appeal is allowed']
+76550;['appeal isallowed']
+95407;['appeal is dismissed']
+123601;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugee nor persons in need of protection']
+74265;['302 (c.a.']
+27246;['appeal is dismissed']
+105607;['reject his claims']
+74120;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+129402;['appeal is allowed']
+121460;['rad dismisses the appeals of the principal appellant', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125038;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+133728;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87466;['reject their claims']
+37840;['appeal isallowed.the']
+100959;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither xxxx xxxx xxxx or xxxx xxxx xxxx c are either convention refugee or persons in need of protection', 'appeals are hereby dismissed']
+83940;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention\xa0']
+139675;['appeal is dismissed']
+76173;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+114305;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71413;['appeal is allowed']
+83711;['determination is valid in law']
+96301;['refugee protection division therefore rejects these claims']
+63725;['appeal is dismissed']
+123931;['appeal is allowed']
+61295;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+76368;['t89-01771,v.']
+131059;['302 (c.a.']
+101153;['appeal is dismissed']
+61468;['appeal is allowed']
+65662;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+148989;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+58005;['panel’s determination must be set aside']
+25977;['application by the minister’s counsel is dismissed']
+99635;['appeal is dismissed']
+143642;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+26789;['appeal of tu hue mai pursuant to paragraph 77(3) (a) is dismissed']
+141678;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+131223;['appeal of the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness is allowed']
+121957;['appeal is allowed']
+80798;['appeal is allowed']
+136723;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+104976;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+83009;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+56510;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+128281;['appeal is allowed']
+142477;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+52759;['appeal is dismissed']
+76031;['appeal is dismissed']
+82878;['appeal is dismissed']
+87976;['negative']
+129400;['appeal is dismissed']
+87211;['claim is denied']
+59994;['refugee protection division rejects the claims to refugee protection', 'claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+125596;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73872;['appeal is allowed']
+100007;['refugee protection division excludes xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx from refugee protection']
+41830;['appeal of dhiraj thakur is dismissed']
+74689;['appeal is dismissed']
+33237;['appeal isallowed.the']
+93768;['appeal is allowed']
+108087;['appeal is allowed']
+56738;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+110300;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+85252;['appeal is dismissed']
+69140;['appeal isallowed']
+83451;['appeal is dismissed']
+76880;['appeal is allowed.it']
+67574;['appeal isallowed']
+98869;['appeal isallowed']
+69228;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+106132;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+61357;['appeal was dismissed']
+129233;['removal order is set aside']
+94261;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+97507;['negative']
+125682;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+73707;['appeal is allowed']
+144893;['allows the appeal']
+128604;['appeal is allowed']
+97288;['302 (c.a.']
+49393;['allow the appeal']
+43393;['appeal is terminated']
+146106;['supports its determination']
+131512;['appeal is allowed']
+76668;['appeal is dismissed']
+131702;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66767;['appeal of ana bela pereira is dismissed']
+100883;['appeal were rejected']
+31996;['appeals are dismissed']
+64852;['appeals are allowed.the']
+127713;['appeal is dismissed']
+28293;['appeal is dismissed']
+76853;['appeal being allowed']
+26979;['panel finds xxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+121948;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+104088;['appeal is allowed']
+74106;['appeal fails']
+67455;['appeal is dismissed']
+87408;['appeal is dismissed']
+84803;['appeal is dismissed']
+64206;['appeal is dismissed']
+46535;['appeal is terminated']
+129934;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107486;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+74182;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+125570;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77642;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+99634;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+76276;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+123006;['appellant meets the requirements']
+71165;['claimant is neither a convention refuge nor a person in need of protection']
+85861;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+77249;['302 (c.a.)']
+58547;['appeal is dismissed']
+106782;['appeal abandoned']
+67607;['appeal is allowed']
+74885;['appeal is allowed']
+101863;['appeal is dismissed']
+128263;['appeal is allowed']
+70193;['appeals of parvaneh zaman vaziri, bahareh karimnejad and pegah karimnejad esfahani are dismissed']
+95432;['appeal must be allowed']
+75956;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+129989;['application must be dismissed']
+101527;['302 (c.a.)']
+47315;['appeal is allowed']
+71170;['appeal is dismissed']
+24207;['appeal is dismissed']
+85252;['appeal is dismissed']
+99663;['appeal is dismissed']
+90690;['appeal is dismissed']
+76042;['appeals are allowed.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+141810;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+36571;['application to reopen is allowed']
+47172;['appeal isallowed']
+77891;['appeal is dismissed']
+34644;['appeals are allowed']
+150608;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100919;['ms. xxxx is a convention refugee']
+76772;['appeal isallowed']
+98528;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+100312;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47885;['dismisses the appeal filed by the appellant']
+54211;['appeal being dismissed']
+102467;['appeal be dismissed']
+102084;['stay is cancelled']
+59909;['appeal is dismissed']
+86880;['appeal isallowed']
+89516;['appeal be dismissed']
+122925;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+105558;['appeal will be dismissed']
+122096;['appeal is allowed']
+104274;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+59771;['appeal of dharminder singh is allowed']
+143233;['appeal was dismissed']
+49968;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxa.k.a.xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee']
+67242;['appeal must be dismissed']
+61527;['dismiss this appeal']
+71435;['negative']
+71417;['appeal isallowed']
+68599;['appeal is allowed']
+121587;['appeal is allowed']
+59766;['appeal isallowed']
+96382;['appeal is dismissed']
+99078;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+108769;['appeal is dismissed']
+104396;['appeal is dismissed']
+77197;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62869;['appeal is dismissed']
+76932;['allows this appeal']
+93913;['departure orders are set aside']
+104120;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61429;['appeal is allowed']
+110976;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+29716;['appeal isallowed']
+106891;['appeal is terminated']
+143899;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100542;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismiss this appeal']
+97565;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95408;['allows the appeal']
+146537;['refugee protection division rejects this claim']
+56682;['allow the appeal in law']
+82693;['appeal isallowed']
+87703;['panel rejects her claim']
+148431;['appeal is dismissed']
+91580;['appeal is dismissed']
+94934;['appeal is allowed in law']
+87177;['appeal is allowed']
+9681;['theappealis dismissed']
+143536;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+103611;['reject your claim']
+76844;['appeal is terminated']
+75130;['appeal is allowed']
+92393;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84614;['appeal is dismissed']
+143999;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80275;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+98146;['appeal is allowed']
+106178;['appeal be dismissed']
+22764;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+52329;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89964;['motion is allowed']
+69655;['dismisses their appeal']
+96935;['negative']
+21371;['xxxxxxxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+30499;['appeal is dismissed']
+139850;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+45155;['appeal is allowed']
+104449;['appeal is allowed']
+70092;['dismiss this appeal']
+64870;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+55235;['appeal is allowed']
+19120;['appeal is dismissed']
+93156;['appeal is allowed']
+91643;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+101499;['302 (c.a.']
+72772;['allows the appeal']
+106415;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+97479;['appeal is dismissed']
+74618;['appeal is dismissed']
+88335;['appeal of afendi ahmed ali is dismissed']
+151617;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+29691;['appeal is dismissed']
+89399;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+148597;['dismiss the appeal']
+95233;['appeal is terminated']
+125151;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+37895;['appeal is dismissed']
+129239;['appeal is dismissed']
+82390;['sponsorship be withdrawn']
+73890;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113786;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98211;['appeal is allowed']
+82203;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+136112;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83139;['appeal is allowed']
+75711;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+76388;['appeal is dismissed']
+90817;['appeal is dismissed']
+91151;['appeal is dismissed']
+125532;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93119;['302 (c.a.)']
+89350;['allows this appeal']
+26766;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+68423;['appeal is terminated']
+56936;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84664;['sponsor withdraws their sponsorship application']
+108695;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+91927;['appeal is allowed']
+144898;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+63828;['appeal of jagtaran singh rai is dismissed']
+56795;['nor a person in need of protection']
+52047;['appeal were allowed']
+74701;['appellants are well established inindia']
+80756;['appeal is allowed']
+93549;['appeal is dismissed']
+127414;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+128598;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+58748;['appeal is dismissed']
+94730;['appeal of rafik khlgatyan is dismissed']
+90848;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101289;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+124612;['allow the appeal and']
+55908;['appeal is dismissed']
+96865;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+84296;['appeal is allowed']
+73308;['appeal isallowed']
+64258;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+73363;['appeals of yih wen lin and yi jiun lin are allowed']
+74289;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+92429;['appeal is terminated']
+101433;['appeal is allowed']
+130976;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+24508;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+94668;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+130928;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75989;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+125444;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+87013;['appeal is allowed']
+87250;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+59853;['appeal is dismissed']
+89708;['appeal is allowed in law']
+91113;['appeal is allowed']
+148024;['302 (c.a.']
+70379;['appeal is dismissed']
+77449;['appeal is dismissed']
+135895;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79971;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+80467;['appeal is allowed']
+80732;['appeal is terminated']
+143471;['appeal is based']
+151963;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination']
+106845;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+148662;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69410;['appeal isallowed']
+89332;['appeal is terminated']
+109296;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+46029;['appeal is allowed']
+132372;['appeal is terminated']
+60518;['302 (c.a.']
+151894;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+49068;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69563;['appeal isallowed']
+77953;['dismiss your appeal', 'appeal is dismissed']
+74791;['appeal is allowed']
+71631;['panel, accordingly, allows the appeal']
+108689;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not in need of refugee protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+140236;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”']
+70074;['appeal isallowed']
+130779;['appeal is allowed']
+148710;['claim is rejected']
+13331;['appeal is dismissed']
+103011;['removal order is set aside']
+98163;['allowed the appeals of her mother']
+62472;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+58095;['theappealis allowed']
+77086;['appeal is allowed']
+54286;['appeal of nafiz ahmed khan is dismissed']
+69789;['appeal isallowed']
+123126;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122551;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is inadmissible underparagraph\xa036(2)(b) of theact']
+85957;['appeal isallowed']
+131720;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+76267;['dismiss this appeal']
+85232;['appeal isallowed']
+95270;['appeal forlara kanbar (appellant 2) isallowed']
+91132;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+73210;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+52287;['appeal isallowed']
+84700;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+146563;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+86400;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+131207;['appeal is dismissed']
+77197;['appeal is dismissed']
+96117;['leads me to conclude that the']
+131547;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76415;['appeal be allowed']
+70656;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+69691;['appeal is dismissed']
+95062;"[""rad confirms the rpd's negative determination""]"
+68201;['appeal of odalys victoria aguiar is dismissed']
+147603;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+56901;['appeal is allowed']
+63563;['allow the appeal']
+153018;['claim is rejected']
+50450;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+123046;['substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+143140;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+24508;['appeal is allowed']
+103800;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+118634;['appeal is dismissed']
+151576;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+141250;['appeal is allowed']
+69541;['appeal will accordingly be dismissed']
+111039;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+86868;['302 (c.a.']
+146887;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+143233;['appeal must be dismissed']
+110043;['appeal is dismissed']
+56912;['appeal isallowed']
+72663;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+69758;['appeals of his wife']
+133190;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee” or a “person in need of protection']
+75710;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+113222;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+121861;['appellantsxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not convention refugees']
+95510;['appeal is allowed']
+100415;['appeal is allowed']
+134424;['appeal is dismissed']
+80207;['reject these claims']
+114739;['appeal is dismissed']
+51041;['allow the appeal']
+99734;['appeal is dismissed']
+72701;['’ argument fails']
+86464;['nor a spousal relationship based on common-law or conjugal partner']
+97468;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+19170;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+37418;['appeal being dismissed']
+120795;['rpd decision stands']
+151784;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination']
+140741;['deny the appellants’ appeals']
+103638;['appeal is dismissed']
+46453;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+143547;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+107867;['refugee protection division determines the xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee', 'xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+62644;['claimant is not a convention refuge']
+69706;['appeal abandoned']
+110977;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99001;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+71337;['appeal is dismissed']
+62440;['appeal is dismissed']
+75950;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+130843;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70602;['application to reopen the appeal of hanz kenleyis dismissed']
+52794;['appeal is dismissed']
+133742;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a “convention refugee']
+59750;['appeal is allowed']
+82799;['appeal is dismissed']
+102799;['appeal isallowed']
+11469;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+124915;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+88449;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee']
+73040;['allowed the appeal']
+104116;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71623;['appeal is dismissed']
+82685;['302 (c.a.)']
+67570;['appeal is dismissed']
+108054;['appeal is dismissed']
+141813;['appeal is allowed']
+57925;['appeal is allowed']
+54713;['appeal is dismissed']
+148691;['dismissal is the most appropriate disposition']
+76670;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89698;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57569;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+123790;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78172;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90914;['appeal is allowed']
+106305;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123769;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+48034;['appeal is dismissed']
+110300;['rad will replace the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+47131;['dismisses this appeal']
+72663;['dismiss the present appeal']
+40649;['appeal is allowed']
+142831;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+21102;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+131209;['appeal be allowed or dismissed']
+96939;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108816;['claimants do not face a serious possibility of persecution']
+67597;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+140874;['appellant was neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84482;['appeal is dismissed']
+91929;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx\xa0xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+39910;['appeal is determined']
+82720;['appeal is dismissed']
+90114;['terminates his appeal']
+145181;['rad substitutes its determination that these appellants are convention refugees']
+56718;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+68690;['appeal is dismissed']
+92967;['citizenship do not apply to']
+149021;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101230;['appeal is allowed']
+90239;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+61339;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77962;['appeal is allowed.the']
+74556;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+76671;['visa officer’s decision to reject this application is not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+89155;['appeal is allowed']
+138857;['appeal is allowed']
+90011;['appeal is terminated']
+108202;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84724;['appeal isallowed.the']
+26698;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+131045;['appeal is allowed']
+91182;['appeal isterminated']
+86866;['appeal is terminated']
+128276;['appeal fails']
+61433;['negative']
+144015;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination and finds that the appellants are convention refugees']
+56941;['dismisses this appeal']
+146852;['appellants are convention refugees']
+13418;['appeal isallowed in law']
+83030;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+82710;['appeal isallowed']
+102040;['allow the appeal, set aside the officer’s decision']
+61290;['iad dismissed the appeal']
+109007;['appeal is dismissed']
+75868;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+107796;['refugee protection claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+151877;['appeal is denied']
+88315;['appeal is dismissed']
+150704;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+77031;['appeal is allowed']
+104849;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+54296;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+46007;['appeal is allowed']
+91695;['orders your departure fromcanada.']
+125346;['appeal is allowed']
+87317;['appeal isallowed']
+28283;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113802;['not convention refugees']
+124827;['reject the appeal']
+68301;['appeal ofsukhjinder singh dhillonis dismissed']
+60509;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77668;['appeal isallowed']
+33317;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+26834;['bill has not been passed']
+10999;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94234;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+140822;['appeal is dismissed']
+13767;['appeal of qijie man is dismissed']
+91196;['appeals of zainab mansaray']
+139442;['appeal is dismissed']
+70946;['appeal is allowed']
+98321;['ppp and its federal coalition partners']
+34699;['appeal is allowed or dismissed']
+86150;['appeal isdismissed for lack of jurisdictionbecause']
+72217;['dismiss the appeal']
+52665;['dismiss the minister’s application']
+92511;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+128304;['appeal is dismissed']
+129898;['appellant,xxxx xxxx, is a convention refugee']
+143502;['302 (c.a.']
+101144;['rad dismisses the application for an extension of time']
+91093;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+125681;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+94240;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+47760;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+151509;['appeal is dismissed']
+76010;['appeal isallowed']
+98732;['appeal is dismissed']
+72591;['appeal is allowed']
+80014;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+76231;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89318;['appeal is terminated']
+80782;['appeal is allowed']
+151624;['appeal is dismissed']
+78182;['appeal is dismissed']
+49138;['302 (c.a.']
+134305;['theappealis allowed']
+69432;['appeal allowed—']
+144386;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93044;['appeal is dismissed']
+125214;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+68145;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84234;['appeal is abandoned']
+149112;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+145427;['appeal was dismissed']
+96308;['negative']
+151521;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+126400;['appeal is allowed']
+96873;['appeal is allowed']
+34162;['appeal is dismissed']
+100415;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84053;['appeal is allowed']
+58113;['appeal is dismissed']
+26891;['decision insheikhshould apply:']
+128843;['appeal is allowed']
+96341;['appeal is allowed']
+93148;['appeal is dismissed']
+105789;['dismisses the appeal']
+91111;['appeals of mohammad osama al-qadhi, suzan al-kilany, hala al-qadhi, abdul rahman al-qadhi, and sebha al-qadhi are allowed']
+111151;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144397;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+91135;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+69478;['dismiss this appeal']
+148972;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124408;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+152901;['appeal is dismissed']
+98502;['appeal isallowed.the']
+65014;['appeal is allowed']
+145858;['appeal is allowed']
+125310;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+72140;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91142;['appeal is allowed']
+106810;['appeal isallowed']
+108128;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+100533;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50435;['appeal of asha mohamed is dismissed']
+47133;['appeal is dismissed']
+93324;['appeal is allowed.the']
+94999;['appeal is dismissed']
+77838;['claimants are persons in need of protection']
+76599;['appeal is dismissed']
+102006;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97862;['visa officer’s determination is valid in law']
+100666;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+60119;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+68181;['appeal is governed by theact']
+81011;['appeal must be dismissed']
+74263;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96790;['appeal isdismissed.']
+101266;['appeal isallowedand']
+99206;['appeal isallowed']
+92541;['appeal isallowedand']
+69410;['allowed this appeal in a decision given from the bench']
+149445;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+87847;['appeal be dismissed']
+16818;['appeal is dismissed']
+55044;['appeal is allowed']
+54750;['appeal is allowed.the']
+121385;['appeal is dismissed']
+140905;['nor the doctor’s report']
+64308;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+128326;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+124657;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+145490;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97472;['appeal is terminated']
+72632;['appeal is allowed']
+80531;['claimants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+126411;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+29125;['appeal is dismissed']
+63207;['appeal is dismissed']
+82873;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80820;['negative']
+69477;['appeal be dismissed']
+64286;['appeal terminated']
+134159;['appeal is dismissed']
+95829;['relief sought undersubsection 67(1)(c) ofirpais also   dismissed']
+96035;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+94909;['application is dismissed']
+80056;['negative']
+95173;['appeal is terminated']
+87439;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+64255;['appeal of that refusal basis is allowed']
+92834;['appeal is governed by theact']
+76372;['application is granted']
+103105;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+98012;['appeals aredismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+49185;['allow the appeal']
+71367;['appeal of john santiago is dismissed']
+86615;['orders your departure from canada']
+122842;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+47817;['appeal is dismissed']
+71483;['appeal is allowed']
+122647;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+87693;['reject that explanation']
+146820;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55356;['appeal is allowed']
+62384;['application to re-open is dismissed']
+76506;['appeal is dismissed']
+89391;['appeal isallowed']
+67445;['appeal isallowed']
+70645;['appeal is dismissed']
+97337;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor person in need of protection']
+121528;['appeal would be dismissed']
+96873;['appeal isallowed.the']
+89839;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+42278;['appeal is dismissed']
+124677;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+147608;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+19228;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision to reject the appellant’s refugee claim is supportable']
+57556;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97842;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+114346;['claimants are not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+61472;['302 (c.a.']
+68189;['appeal of hesamuddin khedri is dismissed']
+93096;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+52320;['appeal is dismissed']
+56637;['appellant fails undersection 97of theirpaand']
+80806;['appeal is allowed']
+71402;['appeal is dismissed']
+108271;['claimants are therefore neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77612;['appeal is dismissed']
+52221;['rad is setting aside the decision of the rpd']
+67581;['appeal is allowed']
+99139;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+151619;['appeal is dismissed']
+102675;['dismissing an appeal']
+84562;['appeal was dismissed']
+110935;['dismisses the appeal']
+83372;['appeal is allowed']
+146950;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+84414;['dismiss the appeal']
+58835;['appeal isallowedand']
+151478;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141244;['appeal is allowed']
+145326;['appellants are excluded from the protection of theirpaunder']
+47390;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his or her permanent resident status']
+80509;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+101279;['appeal is dismissed']
+151919;['rad rejects the appellant’s submissions']
+59549;['appeal is allowed.the']
+98624;['appeal is dismissed']
+48105;['appeal is allowed']
+140272;['confirm the rpd decision', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76060;['encourage the']
+101503;['appeal is dismissed']
+68734;['appeal is dismissed']
+60307;['allow his appeal.']
+23076;['appeal is allowed']
+99970;['302 (c.a.']
+106146;['appeal isallowed']
+76596;['appeal be dismissed']
+13757;['appeal is dismissed']
+80531;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+141649;['appeal is terminated']
+30875;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+54750;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125306;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100908;['appeal is allowed']
+97119;['appeal is terminated']
+84585;['appeal is terminated']
+145293;['panel rejects their claims']
+85217;['sentence is set aside']
+100341;['appeal is terminated']
+151524;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+51767;['dismissing his appeal']
+72017;['appeals are allowed']
+128594;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60002;['negative']
+122644;['appeal is dismissed']
+87321;['appeal is allowed']
+82659;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+105867;['appeal is dismissed']
+47000;['appeal be dismissed']
+122232;['appeal is allowed', 'appellant is a person in need of protection']
+143511;['panel abandons this claim']
+74182;['not a refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+83176;['application to re-open this file is dismissed', 'application to join the appeals is dismissed']
+94060;['appeal is dismissed']
+153262;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106142;['appeal isdismissed.']
+123297;['appeal is allowed']
+127421;['determination is valid in law']
+76615;['allow the appeal']
+66311;['appeal is allowed']
+88016;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+81162;['appeal is allowed']
+99992;['reject his claim']
+150647;['appeal is allowed']
+72824;['appeal isallowed']
+49582;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+69539;['appeal is dismissed']
+80758;['negative']
+71522;['appeal isallowed']
+82178;['appeal should be dismissed']
+142892;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78775;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+145040;['not refugees or persons in need of protection']
+68158;['appeal of sukdev singh mangat is dismissed']
+77693;['appellant has not lost their permanent resident status']
+80448;['appeal is dismissed']
+66327;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+132844;['allows the appeal']
+131913;['appeal was dismissed']
+103900;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+97654;['negative']
+50739;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+101019;['appeal is allowed']
+99789;['appeal is dismissed']
+146847;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131046;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84542;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+90697;['appeal of']
+129929;['dismiss the appellant’s application to withdraw his appeal']
+95479;['appeal is dismissed']
+66238;['appeal is allowed']
+132784;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+138873;['appeal is dismissed']
+85616;['appeal is terminated']
+77305;['sponsor subsequently withdraws the application to sponsor and undertaking']
+105906;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131141;['allow the appeal']
+114375;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87499;['appeal is allowed']
+151832;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+105320;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+28306;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the negative determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+45165;['dismissing this appeal']
+87220;['appeal is allowed']
+80679;['claim also fails']
+100186;['appeal is dismissed']
+128386;['appeal is allowed']
+87133;['appeal isallowed']
+78015;['appeal is dismissed']
+74116;['allow the appeal']
+24234;['appeal is dismissed']
+82383;['appeal is dismissed']
+89140;['appeal is allowed']
+115175;['appeals are dismissed']
+95136;['appeal is dismissed']
+113510;['appeal is dismissed']
+59862;['appeal is terminated']
+64266;['appeal isallowed']
+55303;['appeal isallowed']
+84225;['appeal is terminated']
+71810;['dismiss his appeal']
+67830;['appeal is dismissed']
+98677;['appeal is dismissed']
+54788;['removal order isset aside']
+97420;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+74834;['appeal isallowed']
+120720;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+113239;['appeal is allowed']
+71236;['appeal is allowed']
+51767;['appeal be dismissed']
+129906;['appeal is dismissed']
+110318;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention\xa0 ']
+128424;['appeal is dismissed']
+19997;['dismissal of the appeal']
+90895;['302 (c.a.']
+107438;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+90852;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69978;['appeal isallowed']
+125010;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+47146;['appeal is dismissed']
+131510;['appeal is terminated']
+64604;['appeal is dismissed']
+90598;['appeal must be dismissed']
+122821;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+101351;['appeal is allowed']
+145237;['appeal is allowed']
+69495;['appeal isallowed']
+90718;['appeal of hanson amo-ameyaw is dismissed']
+107946;['determination of the rpd is set aside', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+68210;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+74048;['appeal is allowed']
+105207;['appeals are dismissed']
+82689;['appeal isallowed']
+69316;['appeal is dismissed']
+132368;['appeal of pooja rani kalsi willproceed to normal processing']
+90028;['appeal be allowed']
+100507;['appeal isallowed']
+103688;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+42081;['removal orders areset aside']
+69277;['appeal is denied']
+118220;['dismiss the appeal', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82265;['appeal were dismissed']
+95622;['appeal is dismissed']
+92619;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+145064;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79990;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+105694;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+103048;['appeal is allowed']
+56804;['his claim is rejected']
+100813;['appeal of the appellant']
+145536;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+79719;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+68596;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+97587;['appeal is dismissed']
+73276;['panel finds the decision of the immigration officer to be valid in law']
+91350;['appeal is terminated']
+62884;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+96450;['allowed the appeal']
+75604;['appeal is dismissed']
+67717;['appeal was dismissed']
+124703;['appeal is allowed']
+53134;['appeal is allowed']
+125375;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+128556;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+151518;['302 (c.a.']
+139454;['appeals are dismissed']
+67604;['dismiss the appeal']
+108119;['appeal is allowed']
+95118;['xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+99997;['allows the appeal']
+71114;['appeal is allowed']
+99444;['panel rejects this claim']
+90442;['removal order is set aside']
+130776;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+97505;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+140244;['appeal is allowed']
+64605;['panel finds the visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+99988;['appeal isallowed']
+84267;['appeal is allowed']
+92573;['appeal is terminated']
+86396;['appeal is allowed']
+47193;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+69244;['appeal isallowed']
+98637;['appeal is dismissed']
+85604;['appeal is allowed']
+140826;['appeal is allowed']
+88016;['claimants’ claims fail']
+102173;['appeal was dismissed']
+73052;['appeal is dismissed']
+145067;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+96272;['negative']
+109533;['appeal is dismissed']
+81255;['appeal were dismissed']
+151590;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107433;['rad sets aside the decision of   the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in   need of protection']
+95094;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+132776;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+97441;['appeal of seyed mohammad milani tabriz is dismissed']
+79605;['appeal isallowed']
+65093;['appeal is allowed']
+59812;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+75932;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+71182;['appeal is dismissed']
+54294;['appeal of roop singh chatrath pursuant to paragraph 77(3)(b) of theimmigration actis allowed']
+101881;['appeal is allowed']
+99932;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+127360;['substitute my finding']
+99806;['appeal is allowed']
+83711;['appeal is allowed.the']
+56685;['appeal is dismissed']
+84674;['appeal is terminated']
+76036;['appeal is allowed']
+123286;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102490;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+91607;['appeal is abandoned']
+79465;['declare it abandoned']
+122643;['appeal is allowed']
+67683;['appeal is dismissed']
+94153;['panel rejects this claim']
+117105;['appeal is allowed']
+69265;['appeals are allowed']
+85238;['appeal is allowed']
+131034;['appeal is allowed']
+141322;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26862;['claimant “convention refugee” status']
+28483;['appeal isallowed']
+111022;['rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+76089;['dismissing the appeal']
+72903;['appeal will not proceed to a hearing on the merits']
+79324;['appeal is allowed']
+85513;['appeal is allowed']
+54183;['appeal is dismissed']
+38866;['appeal is allowed']
+71600;['appeal is allowed']
+131721;['appeal is dismissed']
+142475;['appeal of the principal appellant', 'appeals of the minor appellants, xxxx and xxxx, are rejected']
+52124;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand', 'substitutes that decision with its own']
+42003;['appeal is allowed.the']
+89750;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+43326;['appeal is allowed']
+21308;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87866;['application to extend the time to file an appeal is denied']
+99047;['appeals are dismissed']
+84422;['appeal isallowed']
+131043;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+93651;['appeal isallowed']
+151863;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124311;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93547;['appeal is dismissed']
+74636;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+122837;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151812;['appeal is allowed']
+74165;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+101427;['appeal is allowed']
+59666;['appeal is allowed']
+34643;['appeal is allowed']
+79895;['negative']
+63737;['appeal isallowed']
+125055;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection”.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+108071;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71999;['appeal must be dismissed']
+84007;['302 (c.a.)']
+134418;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+127330;['appeal is dismissed']
+76820;['appeal isallowed.the']
+90721;['appeal is allowed']
+31401;['appeal is dismissed']
+26659;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+99451;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+91356;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+95388;['rad finds that the rpd’s conclusion was reasonable']
+124083;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is excluded from protection', 'not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+152479;['nor a person in need of protection']
+77211;['appeal isallowed.the']
+68990;['appeal beallowed']
+121386;['appeal is allowed']
+107246;['302 (c.a.']
+66487;['appeal isallowed']
+73364;['appeal isallowed']
+70783;['appeal is dismissed']
+103660;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+100510;['refugee protection claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,is not a “convention refugee”']
+118239;['panel therefore confirms the decision of the rpd', 'rejects his claim']
+110677;['appeal is   therefore dismissed']
+45395;['appeal is dismissed']
+42003;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87787;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject her claim']
+73874;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+24484;['appeal is allowed']
+139852;['panel confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+80201;['claimant’s claim fails']
+46539;['302 (c.a.']
+153173;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+125019;['appeal is allowed']
+62634;['appeal is allowed']
+22988;['appeal is dismissed']
+58099;['appeal isallowed']
+95235;['appeal is dismissed']
+142896;['dismiss their appeals']
+88405;['appeal must be dismissed']
+71671;['dismiss the apellant’s appeal']
+96411;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+71557;['appeal is allowed']
+135894;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142693;['appeal is dismissed']
+38869;['appeal isallowedand']
+139858;['appeal is allowed']
+55124;['appeal is allowed']
+77652;['appeal isallowed']
+82998;['appeal is dismissed']
+102047;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+147880;['appeal isdenied']
+89446;['claim is rejected']
+136681;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+139890;['appeal is allowed']
+94165;['rad finds that the decision of the rpd']
+77115;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90458;['xxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151873;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+87364;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74528;['appeal is terminated']
+106426;['rad considers that the rpd rendered the correct and appropriate decision']
+67452;['appeal fails in respect of any of the three issues']
+96700;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+92778;['refusal is not founded in law']
+104474;['appeal is dismissed']
+133720;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131142;['officer’s decision is clearly valid in law']
+45991;['appeal is dismissed']
+100934;['302 (c.a.']
+67579;['appeal is allowed']
+56986;['refugee protection division determines thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+110981;['rpd decision stands']
+89271;['appeal is allowed']
+63517;['rejects his claim for refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+90144;['appeal isallowed']
+50796;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+47374;['appeal is allowed']
+47763;['appeal is allowed']
+149580;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees or persons in need of international protection']
+69480;['application is denied']
+97320;['claimant is not a ‘convention refugee']
+73040;['appeal being allowed']
+100224;['appeal is allowed']
+122957;['allow this appeal in part']
+123885;['302 (c.a.']
+150616;['appeal is allowed']
+91353;['appeal terminated']
+91133;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+111167;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+81168;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+56676;['appeal is dismissed']
+61037;['appeal is dismissed']
+67454;['appeal proceeded by way of a hearingde novo']
+77977;['appeal isallowed']
+84061;['appeal isallowed']
+94138;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+75887;['appeal of zhi qiang lei is allowed']
+91238;['appeal is terminated']
+76953;['appeal is determined']
+71217;['appeal is allowed']
+94822;['appeal is allowed']
+143923;['appeal is allowed']
+121245;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither conventions refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98406;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+64866;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+60913;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+34941;"[""rad cites the federal court's decision injiang,""]"
+123873;['appeal is allowed']
+124454;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76167;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+98910;['removal order is set aside']
+64866;['appellants to be convention refugees']
+103655;['claimants’ allegations of persecution']
+87501;['appeal is allowed']
+52274;['appeal being dismissed']
+100036;['appeal is dismissed']
+71609;['appeal isallowed']
+102818;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare “conventionrefugees”']
+94439;['appeal is dismissed']
+87180;['appeal is allowed']
+16759;['allow the minister’s application for dismissal of the appeal']
+103498;['appeal is allowed']
+88062;['allows the appeal']
+63742;['appeals are allowed']
+139871;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+84074;['appeal is allowed']
+146538;['claim is dismissed']
+125382;['dismiss the appeal']
+123683;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx\xa0xxxxis neither a“convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+68912;['appeal is dismissed']
+47295;['appeal was dismissed']
+145057;['you are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+75455;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+37396;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+103536;['immigration appeal division lacks jurisdiction to hear the present appeal']
+48416;['appeal is dismissed']
+152062;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+134515;['appeal is dismissed']
+46491;['302 (c.a.']
+140732;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxand their', 'not “convention refugees”']
+81087;['appeal is dismissed']
+113609;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+122105;['appeal is allowed']
+60504;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+87323;['appeal isallowed']
+95921;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+109288;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95660;['appeal is dismissed']
+74459;['appeal is allowed.the']
+64040;['appeal is allowed']
+123703;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+45243;['appeal is dismissed']
+80715;['appeal is allowed']
+149152;['appeal is allowed']
+86656;['appeal is allowed']
+30502;['appeal is dismissed']
+66581;['appeal is dismissed']
+85504;['appeal is dismissed']
+125555;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86369;['appeal is allowed']
+56510;['appeal is allowed.the']
+134420;['appeal is allowed']
+49966;['302 (c.a.)']
+98620;['panel finds that it lacks jurisdiction under the circumstances']
+91589;['theapplicationtore-openthe removal order appeal is denied']
+114303;['nor a person in need of protection']
+145323;['rad confirms the rpds determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71480;['appeal is allowed']
+91112;['appeals are allowed.the']
+135934;['rad finds the rpd’s decision is incorrect', 'grants the appellant’s appeal']
+93071;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77235;['appeal isallowed']
+92392;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80463;['appeal is dismissed']
+97874;['appeal is allowed']
+87478;['appeal is dismissed']
+90018;['appeal is allowed']
+83897;['appeal is allowed']
+71063;['appeals are dismissed']
+93581;['appeal is allowed']
+152917;['rad upholds the rpd’s denial of the appellant’s claim for refugee status']
+92493;['appeal is dismissed']
+23107;['appeal isallowed']
+99585;['appeal is dismissed']
+133736;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102895;['appeal isallowed.the']
+76098;['chun i lai are dismissed']
+98112;['negative']
+26685;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+130952;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+148618;['appeal is allowed']
+71149;['appeal isallowed']
+120802;['panel therefore finds that they are convention refugees']
+93705;['appeal is dismissed']
+123860;['allow the appeal']
+97882;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+46017;['appeal would be dismissed']
+124055;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+120792;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+112342;['appeal is allowed']
+133734;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+70667;['panel rejects these claims']
+114300;['ms. xxxx is not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+37403;['appeal is allowed']
+125377;['appeal is allowed']
+79951;['negative']
+57670;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+62637;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+26818;['xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+95180;['appeal is allowed']
+57824;['appeal is dismissed']
+22659;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+107152;['neither a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+141240;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69468;['appeal is allowed']
+40289;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+100441;['appeal must fail']
+104457;['appeal is dismissed']
+138845;['appeal is allowed']
+96606;['not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+97259;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx', 'not “convention refugees”']
+133697;['confirm the rpd determination', 'neither a refugee']
+40285;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+100136;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+94646;['appeal is dismissed']
+90924;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+70755;['appeal is dismissed']
+9678;['removal order is set aside']
+45173;['allow the appeal of bao zhu qiu in law']
+82893;['appeal is allowed']
+55119;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+68285;['appeal isallowed']
+142451;['appeal is allowed']
+100256;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97083;['302 (c.a.']
+69445;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+81131;['appeal is allowed']
+100452;['appeal isdismissed.']
+99596;['appeal’s relative merit']
+68360;['appeal is allowed']
+74355;['appeal of tatiana yurieth diaz zapata is dismissed']
+101242;['leads the panel to conclude that the appellant does not reside in canada']
+60982;['appeal is dismissed']
+102897;['appeal is allowed']
+90093;['division rejects all five claims']
+92535;['appeal was dismissed']
+90812;['appeal is dismissed']
+97559;['appeal is allowed']
+78078;['negative decision issued']
+101707;['appeals are dismissed']
+94735;['appeal is terminated']
+144415;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+22814;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+59859;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+124097;['appeal is dismissed']
+141637;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123415;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+57482;['removal order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67426;['appeal isallowed']
+81615;['appeal is dismissed']
+77253;['appeals allowed']
+79872;['appeal was dismissed']
+47465;['appeal is dismissed']
+125297;['rad confirms the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+74221;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+52044;['appeal is terminated']
+37854;['appeal isallowed.the']
+83393;['appeal is terminated']
+125041;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85328;['appeal is allowed']
+54223;['motion to reopen the removal order appealbe granted']
+37495;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+64270;['appeal is dismissed']
+92569;['appeal is allowed']
+108802;['appeal is dismissed']
+151879;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68579;['appeal isallowed.the']
+66201;['appeal is allowed']
+103052;['appeal is allowed']
+34154;['appeal is determined']
+97437;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+45205;['appeal is allowed in fact and in law']
+49547;['appeal of milagros milango ecal is dismissed']
+100301;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+90956;['appeal were dismissed']
+142302;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+57809;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+148503;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+26693;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+132393;['appeal is dismissed']
+94763;['xxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+102936;['appeal is allowed']
+131231;['departure order isset aside']
+13989;['appeal abandoned']
+75152;['dismiss the appeal']
+85246;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67358;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+70652;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+92432;['appeal is terminated']
+65107;['appeal is dismissed']
+21408;['not a convention refugee']
+94696;['appeal is allowed']
+67250;['negative']
+117201;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122834;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104268;['appeal is dismissed']
+72017;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+151901;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection”']
+146929;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80533;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123642;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82992;['appeal of gerald michael surrette is dismissed']
+52505;['appeal isallowed.the']
+100375;['appeal is allowed']
+68730;['appeal of sarbjit kaur jhawar is therefore dismissed']
+74889;['appeal isallowed']
+138819;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+147445;['reject both the adult claimants', 'i also reject that claim']
+56747;['dismiss this appeal']
+86309;['appeal is allowed']
+54744;['appeal isallowed']
+61492;['302 (c.a.']
+85618;['’ application is denied']
+67579;['appeal is allowed']
+72318;['appeal is dismissed']
+34153;['appeal is dismissed']
+129141;['appeal is allowed']
+76615;['appeal is allowed']
+73898;['appeal is allowed']
+124916;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+110991;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision']
+87521;['appeal is dismissed']
+75462;['allow the appeals']
+56271;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+90809;['appeal is allowed']
+125604;['uphold the decision']
+147621;['application is dismissed']
+63892;['allow his appeal']
+84699;['appeal is terminated']
+83303;['appeal isallowed']
+55132;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+55726;['appeals are dismissed']
+55876;['appeal is allowed']
+45387;['allow the appeal']
+84154;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+49136;['appeal is allowed']
+17145;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+130970;['notice is central to the claim itself']
+84906;['negative']
+96231;['appeal isallowed']
+91759;['appeal is allowed']
+99857;['appeal is allowed']
+95443;['appeal is allowed']
+97460;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+99939;['determine the claimant not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+95557;['appeal is dismissed']
+104113;['claim is therefore rejected']
+127734;['appeal is allowed']
+94171;['rad disagrees']
+123302;['appellant is neither a conventionrefugee or a person in need of protection']
+84873;['appeal is allowed']
+99408;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects the claimant’s claim']
+101557;['appeal is allowed']
+87354;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+99643;['appeal is dismissed']
+69211;['decision of the rpd is wrong in fact and in law']
+66240;['appeal is dismissed']
+99262;['claim is rejected']
+80462;['removal is set aside']
+146586;['panel therefore rejects this claim']
+139478;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+128373;['appeals of the appellants jahangir eliasi bakhtiari and sedigheh ameri are dismissed']
+72319;['appeal in this matter is accordingly allowed']
+72788;['appeal is dismissed']
+127466;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+59758;['302 (c.a.']
+92948;['appeal is allowed']
+94806;['appeal is dismissed']
+123107;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151457;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+107175;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101871;['appeal is dismissed']
+89200;['appeal is terminated']
+144962;['appeal is allowed']
+111039;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+19118;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+123724;['appeal is allowed']
+18002;['appeal is allowed.the']
+92461;['appeal isallowed']
+135182;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+75963;['appeal is allowed']
+95103;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61915;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of canada’s protection']
+52508;['appeal is allowed']
+125582;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+143033;['302 (c.a.']
+153279;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+143590;['rad dismisses the minor belgian appellants’ appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+149577;['claim is, therefore, rejected']
+147773;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+124709;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+130872;['appeal must be dismissed']
+125415;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103503;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42313;['appeal is dismissed']
+123757;['appeal is allowed']
+94299;['appeal is allowed']
+52346;['appeal is allowed']
+88880;['appeal is allowed']
+99636;['appeals are dismissed']
+84462;['appeal is dismissed']
+144042;['appeal is dismissed']
+76254;['appeal is allowed']
+63761;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedundersubsection']
+61383;['appeal isallowed']
+100499;['appeal is allowed']
+47575;['appeal is allowed']
+17145;['removal order is set aside']
+31975;['appeal isallowedand']
+98036;['negative']
+28094;['appeals are dismissed']
+62869;['supports the tribunal’s conclusion']
+120819;['appellant should be excluded from refugee protection']
+143840;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+102920;['dismiss the appeal']
+151489;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61220;['appeal is dismissed']
+98493;['application to re-open is, therefore, denied']
+116782;['officer’s decision is well-founded in law']
+93022;['appeal had been dismissed']
+67721;['appeal is allowed']
+109616;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+71295;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+92452;['appeal is allowed']
+125238;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+93065;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is she a “person in need of protection']
+112322;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+144476;['302 (c.a.']
+57809;['appeal isgranted']
+95498;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+151577;['rad, according toirpa, section 111(1)(a) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+69356;['dismiss this appeal']
+73046;['appeal is allowed']
+68342;['appeal is allowed in law']
+132296;['decision of the rpd']
+76618;['appeal is allowed']
+78172;['reject this explanation']
+80767;['refugee protection division rejects this claim for protection']
+54788;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61928;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+102661;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+65600;['appeal is based']
+38161;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+93014;['rad finds itself in agreement with the panel’s determination']
+124660;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90752;['appeal cannot succeed']
+123306;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+102922;['appeal is allowed']
+123373;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131707;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+125318;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146735;['favourable decision which is attached']
+91807;['appeal is dismissed']
+19143;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+50779;['appeal is dismissed']
+94412;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+75991;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+55044;['appeal is allowed']
+17144;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+136071;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+54170;['appeal is dismissed']
+97870;['appeal is allowed']
+25526;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+122535;['appeal of the united states born appellant is dismissed']
+101178;['appeal is dismissed']
+29598;['appeal of obumneme ezeibe is dismissed']
+85982;['appeal is allowed.the']
+138816;['appeal is dismissed']
+87693;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+93593;['302 (c.a.)']
+68345;['appeal of sukdeep kaur grewal is allowed in law']
+98240;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+148586;['appeal is dismissed']
+52145;['appeals filed by xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+106402;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare “convention refugees”']
+108213;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+125008;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+45407;['officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+144018;['“practice notice- allegations against former counsel']
+72571;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+99753;['allow the appeal']
+124431;['appeal is allowed']
+54189;['appeal of charles philip mason is dismissed']
+52363;['appeal is allowed']
+36944;['appeal is allowed.the']
+59798;['appeal is allowed']
+67458;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+126653;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+82650;['appeal is terminated']
+98038;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+44185;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99790;['deny your claim']
+122901;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140719;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150667;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+136185;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146710;['appellant is a refugee from iran']
+111289;['appeal is dismissed']
+80502;['appeal of navdeep kaur sran is dismissed']
+129938;['appeal was dismissed']
+46449;['rad, on its own initiative']
+52718;['gia is no longer a nationwide force']
+80509;['appellant has not lost his   permanent resident status']
+82142;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+57031;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+121587;['rad sets aside thedeterminationof the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97809;['negative']
+94642;['dismiss the appeal']
+82110;['appeal is allowed']
+26701;['appeal division does not have jurisdiction']
+60980;['appeal of sukhwinder kaur malhi is dismissed']
+81800;['appeal isallowed']
+52103;['appeal is dismissed']
+104083;['appeal of fitzroy scott is dismissed']
+143034;['302 (c.a.']
+99450;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+63607;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+117141;['appeal is allowed']
+42280;['appeal of mengisteab russ doboch is allowed']
+53861;['appeal is allowed']
+81261;['appellant is far more established in india']
+92246;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90839;['refugee appeal division dismisses the appeal']
+61484;['appeal is allowed']
+32177;['appeal is allowed']
+125551;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75596;['appeals aredismissedand departure orders are made']
+125217;['appeal is dismissed']
+75588;['appeal is allowed']
+83133;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+36941;['removal order is set aside']
+102023;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+92157;['appeal is allowed']
+132353;['appeal is allowed']
+94108;['appeal isallowed.the']
+151497;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant and the sister are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+128574;['appeal is allowed']
+78663;['appeal were dismissed']
+95417;['appeal is dismissed']
+61002;['appeal is allowed']
+95814;['appeal isallowed']
+96273;['appeal is determinedto']
+99594;['appeal is dismissed']
+94565;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98997;['panel rejects the present claim for protection']
+42297;['appeal is dismissed']
+90798;['appeal isallowed']
+21316;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+46108;['appeal is allowed']
+94080;['dismiss the   ']
+96038;['appeal is dismissed']
+59755;['appeal is refused']
+61798;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122732;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+149456;['appeal is allowed']
+61369;['appeal is determined']
+67005;['appeal is dismissed']
+62473;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+107223;['appeal is dismissed']
+91618;['appeal should be dismissed']
+91650;['appeal of yeu fong lee is allowed']
+134169;['appeal is allowed']
+90539;['appeal is dismissed']
+86046;['appeal is therefore, dismissed']
+135484;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76682;['appeal is allowed']
+140728;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+40773;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47570;['appeal is dismissed']
+45159;['dismiss the appeal']
+107371;['appeal is dismissed']
+142997;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76470;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+123429;['appellants are ukrainian citizens']
+95087;['id’s decision is set aside']
+81637;['appeal is allowed']
+69943;['appeal isallowed']
+77260;['appeal isallowed.the']
+84820;['appeal isallowed']
+76457;['appeal isallowed']
+64914;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatmarie xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+58102;['appeal is dismissed']
+24245;['dismiss the present appeal']
+147772;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+96550;['appeal is allowed']
+99135;['appeal is dismissed']
+130859;['rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+82643;['appeal is terminated']
+93889;['appeal ought to be allowed']
+152820;['appeal is allowed']
+70909;['appeal is allowed']
+120791;['rpd decision stands']
+90093;['not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+105220;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+31977;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+151426;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131051;['appeal is allowed']
+91331;['appeal was dismissed']
+76810;['decision is well founded in law']
+98589;['appeal is allowed']
+73328;['appeal is dismissed']
+51758;['dismiss the appeal']
+107071;['appeal of ezechiel kalinda magene is dismissed']
+77776;['appeal is terminated']
+62483;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54699;['appeal is dismissed']
+115255;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76098;['appeals of chung ming lai, shu ching lai yang']
+83001;['appeal isallowed']
+132883;['appeals are dismissed']
+123826;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69074;['appeal is allowed']
+95867;['appeal is allowed']
+67628;['allow this appeal']
+80989;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+72774;['appeal is dismissed']
+68178;['appeal is allowed']
+87144;['appeal is determinedabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+50495;['appeal of marie kasthine reia littaua picardal is dismissed']
+76310;['appeal is allowed']
+110917;['appeal is dismissed']
+56652;['dismiss the appeal']
+69420;['appeal isallowed']
+112384;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104936;['appeal is allowed']
+87111;['appeal is dismissed']
+95737;['appeal is dismissed']
+97452;['panel rejects the claimant’s claim for refugee protection']
+58559;['appeal ofyoussef bouamranis allowed']
+39900;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+84695;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+95029;['appeal isallowed']
+128876;['appeals are dismissed']
+106278;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+61436;['appeal is allowed']
+38391;['rad must first seek to supplement them']
+87856;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97896;['appeal is dismissed']
+123359;['removal order is set aside']
+135938;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+141217;['leads me to conclude that it is correct']
+107580;['appeal isallowed']
+93318;['appeal is allowed']
+67516;['appeal is dismissed']
+123983;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+76714;['appeal of hong yang wen dismissed']
+89523;['appeal is allowed']
+76736;['appeal is allowed']
+71718;['dismiss his appeal']
+69330;['appeal isallowed']
+104345;['appeal is dismissed']
+75996;['appeal isallowed']
+98484;['dismiss the appeal']
+84207;['appeal is dismissed']
+63810;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+123779;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+87182;['appeal is allowed']
+90265;['appeal is terminated']
+44212;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+129172;['appeal was dismissed']
+74697;['dismiss this appeal']
+94934;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74599;['appeal is dismissed']
+144713;['appeal is terminated']
+106448;['appeal of abdi ali ibrahim is allowed']
+123963;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99310;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+87960;['appeal is dismissed']
+84562;['application is moot']
+64586;['appeal is allowed']
+55973;['appeal is terminated']
+74744;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+107687;['allow the appeal']
+83489;['appeal isallowed']
+102568;['appeal is allowed']
+71663;['appeal of the applicant daughter is dismissed']
+114385;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93642;['appeal is allowed']
+23100;['appeal against citizenship and immigration canada’s decision to delete muhammad irfan anjum from the application is dismissed']
+140837;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitute my own decision that mr.xxxx is a convention refugee']
+94601;['appeal is allowed']
+111334;['appeal is allowed']
+95212;['appeal is dismissed']
+93551;['withdraw my appeal']
+96933;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+72649;['appeal was dismissed']
+140788;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99368;['appeal isallowed']
+57923;['appeal is dismissed']
+84451;['reject this appeal']
+130731;['appeal is dismissed']
+123453;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+64613;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+38426;['appeal is allowed.the']
+65643;['appeal dismissed']
+73258;['appeal is dismissed']
+130771;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87298;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+122988;['appeal is dismissed']
+69861;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+113747;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee', 'appeal is dismissed']
+83445;['appeal is abandoned']
+87178;['appeal is allowed']
+95451;['appeal is allowed.the']
+74355;['appeals being dismissed']
+26743;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+122693;['appeal is allowed']
+104609;['application for a summons is granted']
+109711;['appeal is allowed']
+80139;['appeal is dismissed']
+145215;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98586;['appeal is allowed']
+60472;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+144770;['302 (c.a.']
+90063;['302 (c.a.']
+82394;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71265;['appeal is allowed']
+140975;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141214;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+79891;['negative']
+144679;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+148644;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeals']
+54227;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+97354;['claim is rejected']
+124878;['rad points out that the federal court’s remarks insoimincould easily apply to the case at hand']
+106849;['appeal is allowed']
+92840;['appeal is dismissed']
+89776;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+79206;['appeal should be dismissed']
+82385;['appeal is allowed']
+70407;['appeal is dismissed']
+30495;['appeal is allowed']
+71800;['dismiss the appeal']
+69975;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+138863;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+100606;['appeal is allowed']
+104457;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+131513;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77319;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+120826;['substitutes its own determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+54282;['not find that the applicant has temporary resident status']
+87945;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+103615;['claim is therefore rejected']
+89080;['claimants are excluded']
+108209;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+90533;['appeal is determined']
+123926;['appeal is allowed']
+102930;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+77032;['appeal is allowed by consent']
+47335;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151903;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division']
+90971;['appeal isallowed']
+55875;['appeal is dismissed']
+83117;['appeal is dismissed']
+84429;['appeal is allowed']
+95352;['application must be dismissed']
+96140;['appeal isallowed']
+97373;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101762;['appeal isallowed']
+130759;['appeal is allowed']
+127440;['appeal is dismissed']
+132783;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+130734;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142117;['division therefore rejects their claims']
+68283;['appeal is dismissed']
+124588;['appeal is allowed']
+107828;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+73323;['appeal is allowed']
+74593;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+77958;['application is denied']
+85844;['appeal is allowed']
+57791;['appeal isallowed']
+151608;['rad finds that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+91580;['appeal is allowed']
+136112;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151343;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94827;['appeal is allowed']
+102892;['application to reopen must be dismissed']
+135159;['appeal is allowed']
+29246;['appeal is terminated']
+123622;['appeal is allowed']
+150647;['appellants are convention refugees']
+31929;['appeal is allowed']
+92991;['appeal is allowed']
+109144;['302 (c.a.']
+130861;['appeal of valentina dimitrova is dismissed']
+140730;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54814;['rad cannot substitute']
+95462;['appeal is dismissed']
+108210;['appeal is allowed']
+72210;['appeal is allowed']
+34869;['appeal isallowedand']
+91758;['appeal is allowed']
+134406;['appeal is dismissed']
+97228;['appeal is dismissed']
+71585;['appeal is dismissed']
+94932;['appeal is terminated']
+93317;['appeal is dismissed']
+27486;['appeal isallowed']
+149066;['applicants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+84598;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of']
+48268;['appeal is dismissed']
+95039;['appeal is dismissed']
+47317;['appeal of thi lanh nguyen is dismissed']
+132429;['claim is rejected']
+83293;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+40478;['appeal is dismissed']
+34378;['appeal is allowed']
+40371;['appeal would be terminated']
+56895;['appeal isdismissed.']
+68289;['appeal isallowed']
+44209;['appeal isallowed']
+92482;['negative']
+128742;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+153732;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+71177;['appeals are allowed']
+62397;['appeal is allowed']
+87417;['appeal is dismissed']
+38875;['302 (c.a.']
+72671;['appeal is allowed']
+67188;['appeal is allowed']
+123529;['appeal is allowed']
+98668;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+125603;['she is a convention refugee']
+87321;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+132727;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92145;['appeal was dismissed']
+129237;['appeal is allowed']
+94429;['appellant is not a refugeesur place']
+95965;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+108871;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+61347;['appeal is dismissed']
+124270;['appeal is allowed.the']
+68427;['appeal is granted']
+97531;['officer’s decision to be valid in law']
+26782;['appeal is dismissed']
+73927;['appeal should be dismissed']
+63164;['appeal isallowed']
+44970;['appeal isallowed']
+95454;['appeal is dismissed']
+81866;['appeal is dismissed']
+76012;['decision is not valid in law', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+65627;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+55503;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+53104;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+100835;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89210;['appeal is allowed']
+151519;['dismisses the appeal']
+123685;['appeal is allowed']
+35562;['appeal is allowed']
+89348;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+26992;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+99234;['appeal is dismissed']
+91307;['appeal isallowed']
+100368;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+35914;['appeal is dismissed']
+72571;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+100401;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+146925;['appeal is allowed']
+63760;['appeal isallowed']
+136705;['rpd’s conclusion regardings']
+54310;['appeal of dwight anthony smith']
+97435;['appeal is allowed']
+96980;['negative']
+96893;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96888;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+70086;['appeal isallowed.the']
+46107;['appeals are allowed']
+98826;['neither a “convention refugee', 'rejects her claim']
+92501;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+102568;['appeal is allowed']
+71241;['appeal is dismissed']
+105709;['302 (c.a.']
+102425;['appeal isallowed']
+70051;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+103666;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113533;['appeal is based']
+55106;['appeal is dismissed']
+78023;['appeal should be dismissed']
+94943;['appeal is dismissed']
+103049;['appeal is allowed.the']
+131199;['appeal isallowed']
+98637;['appeal is allowed']
+98240;['appeals are allowed']
+14706;['appeal is allowed']
+120724;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,is not a convention refugee or a “person in need of protection']
+124320;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+146534;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+56646;['appellant is not a suitable candidate']
+141118;['appeal is dismissed']
+106648;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+77079;['appeal isallowed']
+61449;['appeal is terminated']
+26991;['not a convention refugee']
+74069;['appeal is allowed']
+99052;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unreasonable decision']
+61016;['not a person in need of protection']
+76150;['…).”']
+23067;['removal order isset aside']
+69257;['appeal isallowed']
+58421;['appeal is allowed']
+13765;['appeal isallowed']
+13955;['appeal were dismissed']
+102113;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+88851;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+131509;['appeal was dismissed']
+82872;['appeal is allowed']
+142467;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+88843;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+33068;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+116199;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+34158;['appeal is dismissed']
+71571;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+99661;['appeal is allowed']
+85516;['appeal being allowed']
+89730;['appeal is terminated']
+81922;['appeal is dismissed']
+85587;['appeal is terminated']
+86392;['appeal isallowed']
+91213;['appeal isallowedand']
+81661;['allows this appeal']
+102406;['appeal is dismissed']
+102955;['appeal is dismissed']
+50503;['appeal is allowed']
+139807;['appeal isallowed']
+52276;['appeal is, therefore, terminated']
+91446;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+113563;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+88301;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+111121;['appeals are dismissed']
+92767;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+151615;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128884;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+77907;['appeal is dismissed']
+103894;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+77063;['appeal is dismissed']
+80097;['stay of the removal order is revoked', 'appeal is dismissed']
+96775;['negative']
+52766;['appeal is terminated']
+97892;['appeal’s relative merit']
+85377;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+69511;['application is denied']
+47345;['appeal is dismissed']
+101037;['panel rejects the claims of xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx for refugee protection']
+123537;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71219;['appeals are dismissed']
+110989;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+23120;['appeal is dismissed']
+80561;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+71411;['appeal is allowed']
+108194;['appeal is dismissed']
+87200;['302 (c.a.']
+93876;['appeal is dismissed']
+151912;['appeal is dismissed']
+21456;['xxxxx) is not a convention refugee']
+24489;['appeal is dismissed']
+132781;['rpd’s determination is correct']
+145345;['302 (c.a.']
+101549;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed']
+75459;['appeal isallowed']
+145572;['irb – id decision: x vs canada (minister of public safety and emergency preparedness),b6-00725-c (decision dated 2017-04-04).']
+86006;['appeal is allowed']
+60819;['302 (c.a.']
+38868;['appeal isallowed.the']
+8338;['appeal is determined']
+80360;['appeal is dismissed']
+66767;['appeal is dismissed']
+80566;['appeal is allowed']
+104510;['application for an extension of time is dismissed']
+72900;['appeal is dismissed']
+105880;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+50494;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93589;['appeal is allowed']
+89914;['order is therefore enforceable']
+94905;['appeal must be dismissed']
+99565;['appeal is dismissed']
+96825;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee']
+94551;['not a person in need of protection']
+101684;['appeal is allowed']
+146223;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+77212;['appeal dismissed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+14695;['appeal is allowed']
+143636;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+82152;['appeal isdismissedand a departure order is issued']
+81276;['appeal be dismissed']
+140714;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+133706;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+123610;['appeal is allowed']
+67509;['allows the appeal']
+77638;['appeal isdismissed.']
+125356;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+42276;['appeal is allowed.the']
+77477;['dismissing the appeal']
+108734;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+67493;['appeal is allowed']
+101963;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+40124;['appeal is dismissed']
+94008;['appeal is dismissed']
+31989;['appeal is dismissed']
+116742;['appeal is dismissed']
+56875;['appeal is dismissed']
+95231;['appeal isallowed']
+17117;['appeal is allowed']
+142843;['appeal is   ']
+92470;['302 (c.a.)']
+74529;['appeal of ajulu eugene ozoemena is dismissed']
+95090;['negative']
+132446;['claimants are not “convention refugees”', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+67702;['appeal is dismissed']
+69361;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+140271;['claimant is a “conventionrefugee”']
+135489;['declare the person concerned inadmissible']
+106847;['appeal is dismissed']
+95090;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+96288;['negative']
+60428;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+85965;['appeal is allowed']
+13416;['appeal is terminated']
+131509;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+89024;['panel rejects the claimant’s claim for refugee protection']
+96145;['appeal of maggi xiao yin lo be rescheduled as a hearingde']
+76429;['appeal is dismissed']
+136667;['appeal is allowed']
+76534;['appeal is allowed']
+83861;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+89923;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+81852;['removal order is set aside']
+98649;['claimant,xxxx xxxx,is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+68095;['decision of the id is set aside']
+131072;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+135886;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87436;['appeal is terminated']
+39827;['application by the appellant to add an additional ground of inadmissibility is dismissed']
+81823;['302 (c.a.']
+77275;['appeal is terminated']
+130687;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+141044;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74565;['decision of the visa officer is set aside']
+93612;['dismissing this appeal']
+116353;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91767;['appeal is dismissed']
+98120;['claim is rejected']
+101838;['appeal is allowed']
+14694;['appeal is allowed']
+95896;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59854;['appeal is dismissed']
+132300;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+98808;['302 (c.a.)']
+108783;"[""rad concurs with the panel's finding in this regard""]"
+78190;['allow his appeal']
+69451;['appeal is allowed']
+111291;['appeal is dismissed']
+124132;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+107625;['departure order is set aside']
+74825;['appeal is dismissed']
+59192;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+51087;['appeal is dismissed']
+61945;['application is dismissed']
+67585;['appeal is dismissed']
+79237;['appeal is dismissed']
+130775;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+148491;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101777;['appeal is allowed']
+63922;['allow his appeal']
+149489;['rad dismisses this appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+102741;['appeals are dismissed']
+109301;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+42332;['appeal was dismissed']
+144023;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94998;['appeal is allowed']
+131543;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+39900;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77773;['appeal is allowed']
+114336;['rpd decision is set aside']
+80025;['not a person in need of protection']
+95665;['appeal is declared to beabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+72766;['appeal is allowed']
+74728;['appeal is allowed']
+123918;['appeal was dismissed']
+85549;['appeal is allowed']
+94273;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+76185;['appeal of abhinay deep singh is allowed']
+82085;['appeal is allowed']
+104288;['appeal of quan lin zhang is dismissed']
+97263;['302 (c.a.']
+26710;['dismisses the appeal']
+102912;['appeal is allowed']
+61337;['appeal is allowed']
+76345;['appeal is dismissed']
+122139;['appeal is allowed']
+123934;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94397;['appeal isallowed']
+141249;['appeal is determined']
+142454;['appeal is allowed']
+56883;['appeal is dismissed']
+52087;['appeal isallowedand']
+105755;['rad concurs with the rpd’s decision to reject the appellant’s refugee claim']
+74174;['allowed the appellant’s first wife’s appeal.']
+77770;['appeal is allowed']
+15012;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxxxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+77639;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+85855;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+142441;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90324;['tribunal rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+71134;['appeal isallowed']
+70782;['appeal isallowed']
+124180;['appellant’s argument fails']
+43382;['appeal is allowed']
+99092;['appeal is dismissed']
+90690;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+28084;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+42299;['appeal is allowed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+131087;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees']
+123922;['dismissal of the appeal']
+40278;['application of xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is dismissed']
+83713;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+103206;['appeal is allowed']
+151927;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+33321;['appeal is allowed']
+42221;['appeal is allowed']
+93548;['appeal is dismissed']
+91155;['appeal is dismissed']
+52378;['appeal is dismissed']
+123295;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89885;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+60911;['appeal is dismissed']
+60995;['dismiss an appeal']
+151474;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+59931;['negative']
+38905;['appeal is dismissed']
+99903;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87149;['appeal is allowed']
+102881;['thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare', '“convention refugees']
+91685;['determine the claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+36568;['immigration appeal division orders that the present appeal is allowed']
+42276;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71711;['appeal is moot']
+77538;['appeal isallowed']
+96720;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+124931;['not uphold the rpd’s finding']
+52755;['appeal is dismissed']
+58548;['appeal is dismissed']
+134221;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+148640;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+74468;['appeal is dismissed']
+45219;['appeal is dismissed']
+35037;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140556;['refugee protection claim is allowed']
+71122;['appeal is dismissed']
+62383;['appeal is allowed']
+31413;['appeals aredismissedand a']
+101719;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+144409;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97495;['négative']
+63812;['negative']
+141399;['appeal is allowed']
+101682;['appeal is dismissed']
+98472;['302 (c.a.']
+57918;['appeal isallowed']
+63119;['dismiss this appeal']
+99830;['appeal of mohammadullah hayat is dismissed']
+52129;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35915;['appeal is dismissed']
+135198;['appeal is allowed']
+76848;['appeal isallowedand']
+106807;['appeal is allowed']
+47667;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+98832;['appeal is allowed']
+33314;['appeals of chawki chahine and zeinab chahine are dismissed']
+79985;['not\xa0 convention refugees or\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+54812;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+49631;['appeal is allowed']
+110267;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+133371;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68700;['appeal is dismissed']
+42279;['appeal is allowed.the']
+88978;['appeal is allowed']
+78292;['appeal is dismissed']
+95660;['appeal isallowed']
+115231;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither\xa0 convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+151371;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92567;['appeal isallowed']
+85386;['dismiss his appeal']
+73274;['appeal is dismissed']
+68135;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84639;['302 (c.a.)']
+74766;['appeal was dismissed']
+95812;['appeal is dismissed']
+17377;['application is allowed']
+105435;['appeal is dismissed']
+74526;['appeal is dismissed']
+52757;['appeal is allowed']
+54188;['appeal is dismissed']
+123121;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91185;['appeal is terminated']
+89022;['dismiss the appeal']
+71199;['appeal is dismissed']
+77259;['appeal is determined']
+71379;['appeal is dismissed']
+80070;['negative']
+78641;['appeal isallowed']
+18862;['appeal is based']
+98365;['appeal is dismissed']
+26813;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+52292;['application to dismiss the appeal is granted', 'appeal of wing char kwan is dismissed']
+77024;['appeal is dismissed']
+68196;['appeal is allowed']
+4538;['appeal isallowed']
+76032;['appeal is dismissed']
+48089;['appeal is terminated']
+148270;['appeals are therefore allowed']
+71478;['appeal is dismissed']
+76896;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+86322;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+80686;['negative']
+89401;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+116738;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+88254;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses their appeal']
+87122;['appeal is']
+106328;['decision of the immigration division is legally valid']
+59774;['appeal is allowed']
+62237;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+66918;['removal order isset aside']
+105212;['appeal is dismissed']
+17974;['allows the appeal in part', 'dismisses the appeal']
+152319;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is inadmissible to canada']
+102997;['removal order isset aside']
+98659;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+148637;['appeal is allowed']
+36107;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+68701;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+126734;['appeal were dismissed']
+92794;['removal order is set aside']
+52282;['refusal is not valid in law']
+74651;['appeal being dismissed']
+87198;['appeal is terminated']
+148492;['appeal is dismissed']
+91453;['appeal isallowed']
+123544;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136186;['appeal is allowed']
+94923;['appeal is allowed']
+143570;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+30550;['appeal fails']
+81643;['appeal is dismissed']
+99817;['appeal is dismissed']
+151064;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+29635;['appeal is dismissed']
+99492;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+90641;['appeal is allowed']
+98910;['appeal is allowed']
+104350;['appeal is dismissed']
+94979;['application is denied']
+47811;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+105823;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+106146;['appeal is dismissed']
+65660;['appeal is dismissed']
+84268;['appeal of marsela nunaj is dismissed']
+83118;['appeal is terminated']
+96344;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+97627;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of\xa0 ']
+59844;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+77791;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+40279;['appeal is dismissed']
+101540;['appeal is dismissed']
+96140;['302 (c.a.']
+123623;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121406;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52068;['appeal isallowedand']
+75131;['appeal isallowed']
+76945;['theappeal is allowed']
+102939;['confirm the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+55123;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+105896;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+86317;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+130916;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+108822;['application is allowed']
+135145;['neither a convention refugee']
+100043;['appeal isallowed']
+77199;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+105437;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96585;['appeal is dismissed']
+102083;['appeal is allowed']
+26766;['appeal is allowed']
+110973;['rad denies the appeal', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+68253;['302 (c.a.']
+94634;['appeal is allowed']
+110569;['appeal is allowed']
+82236;['appeal is allowed']
+114405;['jordan is not a democracy']
+141295;['appeal is allowed']
+97423;['division rejects his claim']
+62194;['appeals aredismissedand a removal order (departure order']
+78763;['appeal isallowed']
+124131;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+74241;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+121942;['appeal is allowed']
+80072;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+99199;['claimants are excluded']
+140791;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+74754;['appeal isallowed']
+85548;['appeal is dismissed']
+116792;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+95383;['appellant is not a sponsor within the meaning of the act']
+151483;['appeal is dismissed']
+129865;['applicability of section 117(10) fails']
+97118;['appeal is allowed']
+86274;['appeal is allowed']
+21450;['refugee division determines that xxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+95782;['appeal is dismissed']
+96265;['appeal is abandoned']
+49168;['appeal should be dismissed']
+27460;['removal order is set aside']
+116820;['rad confirms that the appellant is excluded from the application of the conventionby']
+22822;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+17170;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+42217;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+76481;['appeal is allowed']
+59791;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+97204;['panel, therefore, rejects her claim']
+100938;['appeal is allowed']
+67722;['appeal is dismissed']
+68099;['appeal is dismissed']
+101063;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+110924;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+123255;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90457;['302 (c.a.']
+124728;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+98401;['appeal is allowed']
+108833;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97381;['claimant, xxxxx xxx xxxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+19310;['302 (c.a.']
+115917;['appeal is allowed']
+81926;['appeal is dismissed']
+86631;['appeals are allowed']
+109013;['appeal is dismissed']
+107685;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+90090;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+52167;['not a convention refugee']
+76624;['appeal isallowed']
+127402;['appeals are dismissed']
+144560;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+89270;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+105760;['appeal is dismissed']
+116134;['appeal is dismissed']
+93591;['appeal is dismissed']
+55132;['appeal is allowed']
+83949;['appeal fails']
+67797;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+84583;['appeal isallowed']
+61434;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+100698;['appeal is dismissed']
+94401;['appellant was not a convention refugee nor was he a person in need of protection']
+98011;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+48231;['appeal is allowedpursuant']
+78659;['appeal is dismissed']
+23086;['dismiss the appeal']
+68525;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject her claim']
+78722;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+129258;['removal orders are set aside']
+83236;['dismiss the appeal']
+76768;['appeal is dismissed']
+99004;['determine the claimant not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+63004;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+94325;['appeal is allowed']
+29308;['appeal is dismissed']
+136682;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, failed to establish that he is a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+61463;['allows the appeal']
+99054;['appeals are dismissed']
+78160;['dismiss this appeal']
+95008;['appeal is barred']
+71557;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87116;['appeal is dismissed']
+96243;['withdraw my appeal']
+95197;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+95360;['appellants are not canadian citizens']
+99928;['claimantsxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+78169;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+61907;['appeal isallowed']
+46453;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+113596;['appeal is dismissed']
+123887;['rpd’s decision is upheld']
+140718;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97276;['302 (c.a.']
+79986;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69619;['appeal is dismissed']
+143885;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxand his daughter', 'not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+93296;['dismiss the appeal']
+76154;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law', 'appeal is dismissed']
+124660;['dismiss the appeal']
+97661;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94756;['“convention refugees”']
+81852;['appeal is allowed']
+131175;['appeal is allowed']
+50425;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+95155;['panel rejects these claims']
+52708;['refugee protection division determines that the']
+52934;['allow the appeal']
+69564;['dismiss this appeal']
+85257;['appeal is terminated']
+80510;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96709;['appeal is dismissed']
+142978;['appeal is dismissed']
+80044;['panel rejects the claim of xxxxx xxxxx for refugee protection']
+47286;['claimant is not convention refugee']
+145807;['appeals are dismissed']
+100518;['refugee protection division rejects her claim', 'claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+45400;['appeal is dismissed']
+90463;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+129852;['appeal dismissed']
+128189;['appellants are not refugees']
+13953;['appeal is dismissed']
+142905;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+152577;['appeal is dismissed']
+66607;['appeal is allowed']
+69581;['appeal is allowed']
+79746;['appeal is dismissed']
+132272;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+87139;['appeal isallowed']
+76689;['appeal is dismissed']
+74283;['appeal isdismissed.']
+93996;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38781;['appeal is dismissed']
+128745;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91206;['appeal is allowed']
+97518;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+107862;['reject your claim']
+129920;['302 (c.a.']
+128157;['appellants are convention refugees']
+99624;['appeal is allowed']
+122093;['she is a convention refugee']
+60035;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+84500;['appeal is allowed']
+33695;['appeal isallowed.the']
+57811;['appeal is dismissed']
+128263;['appeal is denied']
+108072;['appeal is allowed']
+116755;['appeal is dismissed']
+142788;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109146;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+97360;['negative']
+130936;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+84029;['appellant is not currently resident in canada']
+125643;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+105768;['appeal is dismissed']
+102683;['appeals are dismissed']
+93614;['appeal is allowed']
+59136;['appeal is dismissed']
+67450;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+87127;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+143642;['appeal must be dismissed']
+133691;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+98172;['appeal is dismissed']
+89072;['appeal to the iad']
+124990;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103663;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+74813;['appeal is allowed']
+132817;['appeal was dismissed']
+56498;['request for summons is dismissed']
+90574;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+103897;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+107591;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108830;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96170;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+90032;['appeal is terminated']
+54298;['appeal of randip singh kang is dismissed']
+45407;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61871;['appeal is allowed']
+105713;['appeal ofxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx']
+141215;['appeal is allowed']
+77568;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+45244;['appeal from the 2006 removal order moot']
+102024;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+111362;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+151978;['appeal is dismissed']
+152261;['associate claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140923;['appeal is allowed']
+80664;['claims are rejected']
+30514;['panel of the immigration appeal division (iad) allows the appeal']
+47139;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+84069;['appeal isallowed']
+148780;['mr. xxxx is inadmissible']
+123721;['appeal should be dismissed']
+105796;['allow the appeal and']
+67437;['dismisses this appeal']
+94158;['reject their claims']
+81134;['appeal is allowed']
+99156;['appeal is dismissed']
+101475;['appeal is dismissed']
+38895;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+22128;['appeal should be dismissed']
+152929;['rad concurs with this remedy']
+106152;['appeals aredismissedand two']
+71428;['appeal is dismissed']
+34629;['appeal is allowed']
+127362;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection”.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+58138;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+143184;['respondent retains his refugee status']
+96707;['appeal is terminated']
+90833;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100615;['allows this appeal']
+62381;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+102568;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77929;['appeal is allowed']
+94133;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93275;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+94545;['appeal of huang feng wu is dismissed']
+89717;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+103725;['xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+90624;['appeal is dismissed']
+146936;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made']
+80072;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+134515;['appeal is dismissed']
+141673;['appeal be dismissed']
+88319;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77063;['appeal is dismissed']
+75902;['appeal of charles kwame obeng is dismissed']
+52504;['appeal is allowed']
+124331;['appeal is allowed']
+138887;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+55046;['appeal is allowed']
+140252;['dismiss the present appeal']
+100672;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83255;['appeal is allowed']
+89864;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+102962;['rad agrees with the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of canada’s protection']
+69456;['appeal is dismissed']
+146815;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97395;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+72153;['appeal is dismissed']
+47310;['appeal of sawinder preet sharma is dismissed']
+123642;['appeal is dismissed']
+141312;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91147;['appeal is allowed']
+85853;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+4743;['appeal is dismissed']
+84466;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+52289;['appeal is allowed']
+144036;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76257;['appeal isallowed']
+40147;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+72851;['appeal is dismissed']
+100674;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+102977;['application is allowed']
+98104;['negative']
+116800;['law does not prohibit discrimination based on']
+47176;['appeal of ravinder kumar verma pursuant to paragraph 70(1)(b) of theactis dismissed']
+88079;['appeal is allowed']
+47877;['appeal be dismissed']
+48415;['appeal is terminated']
+90694;['302 (c.a.']
+97890;['appeal of hormoz eslami is allowed']
+106145;['appeal is determined']
+86009;['allow the appeal']
+77898;['appeal is dismissed']
+102892;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+93310;['appeal is dismissed']
+63750;['appeal is dismissed']
+52329;['rad agrees with the finding of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+76693;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+55914;['appeal is allowed']
+108930;['appeal is allowed']
+82245;['appeal of jia jia tang is dismissed']
+74266;['appeal is allowed']
+125042;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+38392;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+12207;['determination is valid in law']
+142696;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71579;['appeal is allowed']
+91163;['appeal is dismissed']
+63174;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+77681;['appeal brought underparagraph 67(1)(c) of theactis allowed']
+64044;['appeal is allowed']
+150832;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision']
+102746;['appeal is allowed']
+90233;['declare this claim to have been abandoned']
+99694;['appeal is allowed']
+79220;['appeal is allowed']
+98812;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+74785;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+69544;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+141596;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+148724;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+21101;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+13975;['removal order is set aside']
+68095;['appeal is allowed']
+36105;['appeal is allowed.the']
+14668;['not a convention refugee']
+96564;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+84528;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+64628;['appeal is allowed']
+80125;['appeal isdismissed.']
+60116;['panel rejects the claims']
+139473;['appeal is allowed']
+97574;['appeal isallowedand']
+90187;['appeal isallowed']
+63067;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76249;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+14693;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+61419;['appeal abandoned']
+112783;['appeal is allowed']
+92840;['sponsor is not a sponsor within the meaning of theregulations.']
+141022;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100946;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+48426;['appeal is dismissed']
+140985;['appeal is allowed']
+69355;['appeal isallowed']
+146550;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+130735;['board had no jurisdiction to reinstate the respondent’s stay']
+61372;['appeals are dismissed']
+81227;['determination of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+94508;['appeal is allowed']
+96491;['appeal is allowed']
+95446;['appeal is dismissed']
+89782;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+100296;['nor a person in need of protection']
+132886;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+53104;['appeal is allowed']
+56094;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+83214;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+146551;['refugee appeal division confirms the   decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+98238;['302 (c.a.)']
+95325;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+69256;['appeal is dismissed']
+60369;['appeal ofanita abou nahedisallowed']
+105346;['claims are therefore rejected']
+90227;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+102723;['appeals are dismissed']
+64314;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+65664;['appeal fails']
+71996;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80568;['appeal is dismissed']
+94059;['appeal isallowed']
+76186;['appeal were dismissed']
+131529;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+139680;['appeal is dismissed']
+108196;['appeal is dismissed']
+110954;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+101859;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+31962;['appeal is dismissed']
+128177;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83157;['refusal is valid in law']
+68684;['appeal of gagandeep kaur mahal is dismissed']
+59365;['appeal is allowed']
+133181;['rad considers the rpd’s conclusion to be correct']
+13980;['appeal isallowed']
+142965;['rad can still confirm the decision of the rpd']
+125343;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83249;['appeal is dismissed']
+52717;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+34700;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+102075;['appeal is allowed']
+13955;['appeal were dismissed']
+122099;['appeal is allowed']
+101560;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+136695;['appeal is allowed']
+79995;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+29466;['appeal is dismissed']
+125226;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+52054;['appeal is allowed']
+136656;['appellants are convention refugees']
+80776;['appeal is dismissed']
+90942;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26739;['appeal is based on a hearingde novo']
+66572;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+42567;['appeal is dismissed']
+121557;['claimant xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'division rejects the claim']
+62014;['appeal is dismissed']
+128933;['appeal is allowed']
+99393;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+33066;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+150739;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx, andxxxx xxxxareneither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60519;['appeal is allowed']
+82281;['appeal is allowed']
+77046;['appeal is dismissed']
+100725;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+56945;['appeal is dismissed']
+83063;['appeal of betty gale el aazouzi is dismissed']
+26689;['appeal bedismissed.']
+45223;['appeal of jitendra kumar is dismissed']
+61441;['appeal is allowed']
+100055;['theappeal is allowed']
+50253;['appeals to be dismissed']
+96659;['claimants are excluded from the refugee protection afforded to convention refugees and persons in need of protection']
+77231;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+110975;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+23007;['appeal is allowed']
+123319;['appeal is allowed']
+62246;['panel rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+123855;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+148172;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection', 'rejects their refugee protection claims']
+91323;['dismiss the appeal']
+17900;['appeal should be heard on its merits']
+94593;['appeal is terminated']
+128189;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146432;['appeal is dismissed']
+72879;['appeal of kibru meseret moshe is allowed']
+52591;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxx, to be a convention refugee']
+118419;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+60037;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+102456;['appeal of dai hong zhang is dismissed']
+60438;['appeal is governed by theact']
+61543;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105628;['rad finds that the appellant’s argument has no merit']
+90960;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142963;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+127370;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+82257;['appeal dismissed']
+149282;['appeal is allowed']
+99060;['appeal must be dismissed']
+35415;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+100861;['302 (c.a.']
+70036;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal allowed']
+147452;['302 (c.a.']
+94645;['appeals are dismissed']
+134313;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+26508;['appeal isallowed']
+120774;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+42334;['panel therefore dismisses the appeal']
+86934;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+76543;['appeal is dismissed']
+61230;['appeal is allowed']
+151584;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+94684;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+123272;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+44841;['appeal isallowed']
+140710;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'are neither convention refugees']
+87455;['appeal is dismissed']
+31423;['appeal is allowed']
+108192;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+116789;['appeal were dismissed']
+76003;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+50249;['appeal is allowed']
+47325;['appeal is allowed']
+99717;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+106472;['appeal is dismissed']
+130887;['appeal is dismissed']
+75579;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+89738;['appeal must bedismissed']
+59364;['appeal isallowed']
+132634;['not allow this application']
+68300;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69565;['appeal is allowed']
+31227;['appeal is dismissed']
+89959;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+89816;['appeal isallowed']
+113800;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination by the rpd', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+81424;['appeal is allowed']
+54808;['appeal is dismissed']
+107668;['appeal is allowed.the']
+117207;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+123369;['appeal is allowed']
+42294;['appeal is allowed']
+107639;['appeal is dismissed']
+92435;['appeal is dismissed']
+107136;['appeal is dismissed']
+148659;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100123;['appeal is allowed']
+116761;['appeal is allowed']
+61901;['allows this appeal']
+129100;['theappeal is allowed']
+91644;['appeal is dismissed']
+101755;['appeal is dismissed']
+75468;['appeal isallowed']
+87515;['appeal is dismissed']
+141816;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+68699;['appeal is allowed']
+54273;['appeal is allowed']
+16826;['confirm the rpd’s finding']
+90949;['appeal isallowed']
+81186;['appeal is allowed']
+76715;['appeal is dismissed']
+49070;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125107;['appeal is dismissed']
+68468;['claimants are not “convention refugees”', 'rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+51095;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+151921;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+9677;['appeal is dismissed.conclusion']
+131158;['appeal is allowed']
+78772;['302 (c.a.']
+123714;['appeal be dismissed']
+122820;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108740;['rad disagrees']
+17165;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+145059;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,is not a “convention refugee', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+17954;['nor any other evidence required by theact']
+88809;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+153145;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+29725;['appeal is dismissed']
+35874;['appeal will fail']
+139418;['appeal is dismissed']
+89427;['allows this appeal']
+98978;['rad dismisses the application for an extension of time']
+96383;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+63742;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+89214;['302 (c.a.']
+89261;['appeal is allowed']
+89552;['appeal is terminated']
+83088;['appeal is therefore, allowed']
+69709;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+107831;['rad finds that the appellant’s arguments']
+57814;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+74869;['appeal is dismissed']
+26711;['application is denied']
+132786;['they are therefore not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70027;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+62830;['appeal is dismissed']
+47142;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+63911;['appeal is dismissed']
+94085;['appeal is dismissed']
+64836;['allow the appeal']
+150734;['appeal is allowed']
+131181;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+84528;['appeal is dismissed']
+89574;['appeal is terminated']
+121956;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121465;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+116806;['appeal is dismissed']
+85970;['appeal is allowed']
+141229;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+123882;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+45192;['appeal of razieh sabzevari is dismissed']
+69353;['appeal isallowed']
+100816;['appeal abandoned']
+101472;['302 (c.a.']
+130762;['dismissal of this appeal']
+95869;['appeal is terminated']
+46089;['302 (c.a.']
+95334;['appeal is allowed']
+28704;['appeal is dismissed']
+79188;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+72835;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89867;['dismiss this appeal']
+130938;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a conventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34098;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+114385;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor person in need of protection']
+121564;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87308;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+89329;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+52764;['appeal is dismissed']
+145344;['xxxx xxxx is   not a convention refugee, neither is he a person in need of protection']
+62949;['appeal is allowed']
+54166;['appeal fails']
+71042;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+87962;['theappealis dismissed']
+95359;['appeal should be dismissed']
+97195;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+52270;['appeal is dismissed']
+118633;['appeal is allowed']
+80278;['refugee protection division rejects the claim/s']
+99092;['appeal is dismissed']
+83636;['appeal isallowed.the']
+84817;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+94325;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+64298;['appeal of talongombe umambo is dismissed']
+105886;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+143132;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+89221;['appeal is dismissed']
+115225;['appeal is dismissed']
+102548;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+38853;['appeal is dismissed']
+93646;['appeal isallowed']
+98457;['negative']
+109283;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+29601;['appeal is allowed']
+63713;['appeal is dismissed']
+97341;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42279;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+113740;['confirm the rpd’s determinationthat', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+133387;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+98515;['allows this appeal']
+121523;['appeal is dismissed']
+98968;['rad dismissed the appeal on']
+142742;['appeal be dismissed']
+101904;['appeal is allowed']
+95084;['302 (c.a.)']
+63921;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+106145;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+108954;['appeal is dismissed']
+61878;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+127398;['confirm the visa officer’s decision that the applicant']
+100315;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+68339;['appeal is allowed']
+69409;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+72661;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+96674;['negative']
+71619;['panel dismisses this appeal']
+61364;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+78023;['appeal is allowed']
+84655;['appeal is terminated']
+80455;['appeal of harpreet kaur maan (a.k.a harpreet kaur bhullar) is allowed']
+99885;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+117197;['rad sets aside the rpd’s decision', 'appellant to be a convention refugee']
+52081;['appeal isterminated']
+89952;['appeal is dismissed']
+139474;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+105324;['stay is set aside']
+143548;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+37901;['removal order is set aside']
+68421;['cancels its order dated july\xa08, 1999', 'allows the appeal']
+40478;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+151613;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100906;['appeal is dismissed']
+82880;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+99738;['appeal is allowed']
+118634;['dismissal of the appeal']
+72169;['appeal is allowed']
+76622;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98411;['appeal is allowed in law']
+108842;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94638;['appeal is dismissed']
+129167;['appeal of charles antwi effah is dismissed']
+72573;['appeal isallowed']
+95957;['appeal is dismissed']
+95913;['appeal cannot succeed']
+83280;['rad determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+73872;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+87099;['appeal isallowed']
+132331;['dismiss the appeal']
+100417;['appeal is dismissed']
+53864;['appeal is allowed']
+142484;['appeal is dismissed']
+66920;['appeal isallowed']
+114364;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102471;['appeal of vijay kumar chumber is dismissed']
+13946;['appeal has been abandoned']
+84647;['appeal is terminated']
+74541;['removal orders are set aside']
+97314;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+64620;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+105705;['appeal fails']
+77927;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+93223;['allows the appeal']
+99239;['appeal is allowed']
+97349;['allow the appeal and']
+82995;['appeal were dismissed']
+100268;['appeal is allowed']
+85970;['appeal of jennifer phillips-alghali is allowed']
+99636;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+47393;['removal order is set aside']
+49715;['irb (intervener) (f.c.a., no']
+68374;['appeal of tak kuen kenny chan is dismissed']
+59040;['dismiss the appeal']
+74860;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77696;['appeal is allowed']
+102947;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+90258;['negative']
+88050;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+108729;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70372;['appeal is dismissed']
+103451;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107429;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”']
+128368;['appeal is dismissed']
+121842;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130796;['appeal is allowed']
+74875;['appeal is allowed']
+102122;['appeal is allowed']
+18008;['allow the appeal']
+144899;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43735;['appeal of houtan pour-tavakoli is allowed']
+16827;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is she a “person in need of protection']
+129904;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+56267;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+60439;['dismiss the appeal']
+142465;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+83391;['appeal is dismissed']
+75568;['appeal is dismissed']
+33695;['appeal is allowed']
+124018;['appeal is allowed']
+50513;['appeal is dismissed']
+100366;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+62865;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+106814;['allow the appeal']
+104079;['appeal is allowed']
+97829;['negative']
+65128;['appeal should be dismissed']
+85394;['appeal is allowed']
+73051;['refusal is not valid in law']
+52609;"[""claimants' motion must be dismissed""]"
+86467;['appeal will now be further processed']
+134748;['appeal is also denied']
+81646;['appeal is allowed']
+54729;['application is dismissed']
+111180;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98372;['appeal is dismissed']
+90671;['appeal isallowed']
+123038;['confirms the rpd finding that it was not reasonable']
+82228;['appeal should be dismissed']
+89749;['appeal is dismissed']
+83936;['appeal is dismissed']
+134308;['appeal is dismissed']
+16443;['appeal is dismissed']
+146843;['nor a viable ifa']
+79884;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+81800;['appeal is allowed']
+106290;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+139461;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+143149;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+140817;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+60067;['appeal isallowed']
+48218;['panel dismisses the appeal']
+88892;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+55121;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+91232;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+82687;['appeal is allowed']
+107471;['rad will not overturn the rpd’s decision']
+47304;['appeal of yeung yau lee is allowed']
+76386;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89118;['302 (c.a.']
+49708;['appeal of navdeep kaur grewal is therefore dismissed']
+125654;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+120787;['rad substitutes the rpd’s decision', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+38567;['appeal is dismissed']
+23040;['appeal is allowed']
+131737;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+125303;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+33238;['appeal is determined']
+76231;['appeal is allowed']
+116186;['appellants are convention refugees', 'allow their appeal']
+27306;['appeal is allowed']
+97395;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46526;['appeal is allowed']
+129185;['appeal is dismissed']
+78018;['determination is valid in law']
+133185;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants who are citizens of india and pakistan', 'appeal of the appellant who is a citizen of the united states is dismissed']
+128156;['appeal is allowed']
+82649;['appeal is dismissed']
+96703;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+128888;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+97008;['appeal isallowed']
+131034;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+93346;['appeal is allowed']
+122985;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+54805;['rad concurs with the rpd’s finding']
+93067;['neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection”']
+127397;['allow the appeal']
+67461;['dismiss the appeal']
+72647;['appeal is dismissed']
+60363;['appeal isallowed']
+23022;['dismiss this appeal']
+88162;['appeal is dismissed']
+80279;['negative']
+86146;['appeal is allowed']
+14709;['appeals are never adjournedsine']
+95312;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+130694;['appeal is dismissed']
+97589;['appeal isallowedand']
+142446;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+145321;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of therpdthat', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+154026;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67805;['appeal is dismissed']
+94355;['appeal is dismissed']
+102584;['appeal is allowed']
+150612;['appeal of the male appellant']
+71213;['appeal is dismissed']
+112779;['appeal is dismissed']
+87981;['neither a “convention refugee', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+135890;['not confirm the rpd’s decision']
+124908;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+57787;['appeal is dismissed']
+140996;['rad confirms that the rpd determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+61053;['appeal is dismissed']
+127422;['appeal is allowed']
+87688;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+78092;['appeal isallowed']
+85923;['appeal is dismissed']
+100630;['stay is cancelled']
+81159;['appeal is allowed']
+85440;['appeal oftu phat la is to be scheduled for an oral hearing']
+139434;['appeal is dismissed']
+107673;['appeal isallowed.the']
+131861;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46387;['appeal is allowed']
+70914;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+146824;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123836;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+98622;['appeal is dismissed']
+121856;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'the associate appellants (the minor children) are not “convention refugees']
+128894;['appellant is neither a “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+94142;['appeal is dismissed']
+99451;['appeal is dismissed']
+56805;['not a person in need of protection']
+90249;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+127416;['appeals of georgina kayastha, shirish kayastha and simran kayastha are dismissed']
+79976;['xxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+17967;['appeal is allowed']
+130700;['appeal is determined']
+94610;['appeal is allowed']
+104443;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+138852;['stay of the exclusion order is not appropriate']
+141002;['appeal is allowed']
+47294;['allow her appeal']
+8334;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection\xa0168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+97244;['appeal isallowed']
+22102;['appeal is allowed']
+76138;['appeal should be dismissed']
+127391;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+151812;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+87444;['appeal isallowed']
+105304;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+53439;['appeal isallowed']
+151479;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62472;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124585;['302 (c.a.']
+92022;['appeal is allowed.the']
+71142;['appeal is allowed']
+102978;['appeal is allowed']
+69934;['appeal is dismissed']
+50357;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+52054;['appeal is allowed']
+83343;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99901;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+80277;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100359;['panel rejects his claim']
+84826;['appeal is dismissed']
+132831;['appeals was dismissed']
+95094;['negative']
+92151;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+99658;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+99923;['appeal is allowed']
+80359;['appeal is allowed']
+96387;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+134748;['rpd decision, para']
+91116;['appeal is allowed']
+77968;['appeal is dismissed']
+46994;['302 (c.a.)']
+124032;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+100269;['appeal is allowed']
+113259;['appeal is dismissed']
+65418;['removal orders are set aside.the']
+97508;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+102546;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99331;['appeals are dismissed']
+82905;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+89758;['nor is he a convention refugee']
+49927;['appeal is allowed']
+134739;['confirm the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+25529;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+9678;['appeal is allowed']
+140282;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+98730;['appeal is terminated']
+98139;['appeal isallowed']
+57446;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+93689;['appeal is allowed']
+107473;['determination of the rpd is set aside']
+136139;['appeal is dismissed']
+60405;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+76487;['appeal isallowed']
+134302;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+99051;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses this appeal']
+97300;['appeal is determined']
+74857;['appeal of bharpur saound is dismissed']
+141260;['confirm that it is correct']
+151804;['appeal is dismissed']
+66929;['application to re-open is allowed']
+111025;['appeal is allowed']
+95555;['appeal isallowed']
+102950;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is erroneous']
+71204;['reject her explanation']
+55109;['removal orders are set aside']
+95785;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99369;['appeal of phuc hong nguyen is dismissed']
+91141;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+85172;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+95541;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+42392;['allow this appeal']
+95958;['appeal is dismissed.pursuant', 'rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+13956;['appeals are dismissed']
+100934;['panel rejects the present claim']
+107647;['appeal is dismissed']
+59743;['appeal is dismissed']
+67479;['appeal isallowed']
+104146;['nor a person in need of protection']
+105697;['appeals are dismissed']
+140286;['his claim is deemed to be rejected']
+20837;['appeal is not allowed']
+60404;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+15573;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+124937;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70364;['appeal isallowed']
+146841;['appeal is allowed']
+106420;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67928;['appeal is therefore dismissed.undersection65']
+124728;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88146;['appeal is dismissed']
+74462;['appeal is allowed']
+95660;['appeal is allowed']
+26901;['xxxxxxxxxxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+123316;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+122954;['appeal is allowed']
+83713;['appeal is dismissed']
+114254;['application is allowed']
+46017;['appeal be dismissed']
+56939;['nor a protected person']
+88330;['appeal is dismissed']
+101549;['appeal is dismissed']
+96228;['302 (c.a.)']
+131746;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+146875;['rad sets aside the negative determination', 'substitutes its own finding that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+56953;['appeal is allowed']
+78734;['appeal is allowed']
+88179;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxnot to be a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+115208;['decision cannot stand']
+92463;['appeal isallowed']
+76629;['appeal isallowed']
+124704;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59549;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+72811;['appeal is dismissed']
+74846;['appeal is allowed']
+71142;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+23026;['appeal is allowed']
+96640;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+100369;['appeal is abandoned']
+59689;['appeal isallowed']
+148585;['appeal is dismissed']
+94255;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision, cannot substitute its own determination']
+133377;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94578;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+73022;['appeal is allowed']
+65685;['appeal is allowed']
+73025;['application is dismissed']
+140840;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100763;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+150828;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61029;['appeal is dismissed']
+74614;['appeal is allowed']
+142304;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+108748;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98793;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+98915;['appeal were dismissed']
+132822;['appeal is dismissed']
+92946;['appeal is terminated']
+99103;['appeal is dismissed']
+129261;['appeal is dismissed']
+69385;['negative']
+130771;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80510;['appeal is allowed.the']
+89290;['appeal is allowed']
+130786;['appeal is terminated']
+61377;['tribunal declares the appealabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+134176;['appeal is dismissed']
+95071;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47330;['appeal isdismissed.']
+89904;['neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+59132;['appeal should be dismissed']
+134279;['appellant is not a permanent resident (pr) of canada or a protected person']
+55107;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+29602;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+88865;['appeal is dismissed']
+84622;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+14457;['dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+34936;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124921;['christian converts']
+85312;['appeal is terminated']
+54718;['appeal is allowed']
+67744;['allows the appeal']
+80247;['negative']
+80743;['negative']
+75467;['appeal terminated']
+54518;['appeal may be dismissed']
+94325;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26836;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+86951;['appeal is dismissed']
+96966;['claimant is not a “person in need of protection']
+76525;['appeal isdismissedwith respect to maria theresa javier']
+100775;['xxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+143162;['ms xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+132748;['not a “convention\xa0', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+143892;['appeal is denied']
+68285;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+136704;['dismisses the appeal']
+107433;['rpd be set aside']
+61631;['302 (c.a.']
+129888;['appeal is dismissed']
+76775;['appeal isallowed']
+92383;['appeal is dismissed']
+62879;['reject their claims']
+132347;['appeal is allowed']
+78052;['302 (c.a.']
+94035;['appeal is allowed']
+123385;['appeal is allowed']
+74633;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+48287;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54289;['appeal is terminated']
+54313;['appeal is allowed']
+136079;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89338;['appeal is dismissed']
+78035;['appeal isallowed']
+76901;['appeal allowed']
+108876;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+47365;['appeal is allowed']
+122656;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76273;['appeal is allowed']
+100486;['appeal isallowed']
+99436;['302 (c.a.']
+140920;['302 (c.a.']
+90234;['panel rejects his claim']
+83655;['appeal isallowed']
+145388;['claimants, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx\xa0xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+131217;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+54712;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124929;['appeal is allowed']
+95067;['rad finds that this decision must be set aside']
+90228;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxxxandxxxxx\xa0xxxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+76420;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+99849;['appeal is dismissed']
+23115;['appeal is allowed']
+101463;['dismiss this appeal']
+125514;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76687;['appeal is allowed']
+71170;['appeal of anthony cruzada tolentino is dismissed']
+105425;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+130731;['appeal is premature']
+94491;['appeal is dismissed']
+60429;['appeal with respect to the appellant’s step-daughter']
+56707;['appeal will be dismissed']
+134438;['appeal is allowed']
+98817;['leads me to conclude that the']
+68295;['appeal is dismissed']
+20445;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee']
+100361;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+94044;['appeal is allowed']
+106588;['appeal is dismissed']
+107604;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83678;['appeal is terminated']
+40280;['appeal is also dismissed']
+102197;['appeal is allowed']
+90599;['panel endorses the favourable recommendation', 'allows the appeal']
+47390;['appeal of each appellant is thus allowed', 'appeals are allowed']
+101187;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95889;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+93924;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+42288;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+74813;['stay is cancelled']
+54310;['application to dismiss the appeal']
+92238;['appeal is dismissed']
+104426;['claimants do have status']
+102878;['not find him to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+80295;['302 (c.a.)']
+133272;['302 (c.a.']
+108765;['appeal is dismissed']
+37867;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+75609;['appeal is dismissed']
+145380;['request to reopen the claims of the applicants is denied']
+143144;['appeal is allowed']
+140746;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+122985;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+87830;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52683;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+87446;['appeal is dismissed']
+95584;['appeal is dismissed']
+107609;['appeal is dismissed']
+65635;['appeal is terminated']
+81144;['appeal be dismissed']
+113230;['appeal be dismissed']
+99427;['claimant is neither a\xa0\xa0 convention refugee']
+67558;['allow the appeal']
+54557;['appeal is allowed']
+152044;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd determination']
+129402;['appeal is allowed']
+91110;['appeal of shiu shan susan lee is dismissed']
+88094;['appeal is allowed']
+116191;['appeal is allowed']
+143874;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+45196;['appeal isallowed']
+90914;['appeal is allowed']
+97421;['negative']
+107616;['appeal is allowed']
+22987;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+139866;['rad substitutes its decision for that of the rpd', 'determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+77875;['appeal is allowed']
+85439;['appeal is dismissed']
+79339;['appeal is dismissed']
+72207;['appeal is allowed']
+68103;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+87615;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97412;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+146916;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107440;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding cannot be sustained']
+39897;['rad concurs with the rpd’s findings']
+67775;['appeal is terminated']
+102729;['claimant is not a “conventionrefugee”']
+94245;['appeal isallowed']
+79977;['claim is rejected']
+23118;['appeal is allowed']
+94204;['appeal is dismissed']
+77214;['appeal isallowed']
+98560;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+91243;['appeal is dismissed']
+108131;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+136730;['appeal is allowed']
+75464;['appeal is dismissed']
+150698;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+85959;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+131909;['appeal is dismissed']
+101047;['appeal is allowed']
+57449;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56271;['rad finds he is not a person in need of protection']
+61364;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+47405;['appeal is allowed']
+144047;['set aside the rpd’s decision', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+38781;['appeal is dismissed']
+61964;['appeals are dismissed']
+95280;['appeal is dismissed']
+146894;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+58119;['appeal is dismissed']
+73272;['appeal is dismissed']
+117122;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+67658;['appeal isallowed']
+142834;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+94312;['appeal is terminated']
+61001;['appeal is dismissed']
+83460;['appeal is dismissed']
+89837;['appeal isallowed']
+76087;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+147000;['appeal is dismissed']
+80283;['negative']
+80547;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedundersubsection']
+124579;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92344;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+91226;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+67736;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+95526;['appeal is allowed']
+127476;['appeal is allowed']
+85460;['allow the minister’s application for dismissal of the appeal']
+94986;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76159;['appeal is allowed']
+100074;['allows your appeal']
+98757;['appeal is dismissed']
+116354;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”']
+72840;['appeal isallowed']
+70459;['appeal is allowed']
+151336;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+26868;['xxxxxxxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+143898;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+28041;['appeal is dismissed']
+132421;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95372;['appeal isallowed']
+122131;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94103;['appeal is allowed']
+93913;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+98549;['appeal be dismissed']
+77857;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+40148;['appeal is dismissed']
+9489;['appeal is abandoned']
+27247;['decision is wrong in law']
+90066;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+95516;['appeal is dismissed']
+67377;['dismissal of the appeal']
+47718;['appeal is allowed']
+87326;['appeal is allowed']
+95928;['appeal is dismissed']
+124637;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+128890;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+132820;['appeal is dismissed']
+48414;['appeal is dismissed']
+69557;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+77569;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+91673;['appeal is dismissed']
+54199;['appeal is allowed']
+89807;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+135895;['uphold this finding']
+142896;['appeals are dismissed']
+87512;['appeal is dismissed']
+61642;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+37864;['appeal is determined']
+95098;['appeal is allowed']
+59937;['nor a person in need of protection']
+87252;['negative']
+81077;['appeal isallowed']
+80009;['negative']
+90077;['appeals are allowed']
+54319;['appeal is allowed']
+56916;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+79333;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+65692;['appeal is allowed']
+38772;['appeal is allowed']
+100856;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+74486;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+99161;['appeal is dismissed']
+100457;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+23120;['appeal is dismissed']
+124412;['appeal is rejected']
+131912;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+147623;['appeal is dismissed']
+98824;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+69264;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+59725;['appeal isallowed']
+122632;['302 (c.a.']
+76632;['appeal is determined']
+52319;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101426;['appeal is allowed']
+56826;['appeal will be dismissed']
+65693;['appeal is allowed']
+93072;['rad finds that this decision must be set aside']
+76379;['appeal is allowed']
+66328;['appeal ofjasbir kaur johal, in respect to her husband,karamveer singh johal, is allowed']
+97456;['negative']
+69678;['appeal isallowed']
+62476;['appeal is allowed']
+88423;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+72589;['appeal is allowed']
+23094;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+105797;['appeal of taruna patel is dismissed']
+151904;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+69530;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+54631;['appeal should be dismissed']
+107656;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+108882;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+89163;['appeal (ta9-17672) with respect to that order is allowed']
+47778;['appeal is allowed.the']
+52696;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95692;['positive crdd determination']
+146098;['rad finds the appellant to be a convention refugee']
+90932;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+139455;['appeal is allowed']
+82125;['appeal is dismissed']
+73601;['allowed the appeal']
+46481;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+91219;['appealis dismissed']
+99032;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+89569;['appeal is terminated']
+54230;['appeal is an abuse of process']
+144712;['appeal were dismissed']
+55260;['refugee protection division rejects the application']
+93973;['negative']
+123409;['substitute a determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+54707;['appeal is dismissed']
+105366;['rad finds and confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+143474;['appeal was allowed']
+99145;['appeal is dismissed']
+63855;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+132438;['appeal is dismissed']
+101553;['appeal is abandoned']
+125097;['set aside the decision of the rpd']
+60108;['appeal of simarjit kaur rai is allowed']
+60962;['dismiss the appeal']
+89900;['claimant is not at risk of persecution']
+125591;['neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67507;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+79971;['panel rejects these claims for refugee protection', 'claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+122230;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+91451;['appeal of yao chen is dismissed']
+96997;['302 (c.a.']
+90462;['reject her claim']
+124614;['302 (c.a.']
+68109;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+116772;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94519;['appeal is allowed']
+125310;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77472;['dismiss the appeal']
+84020;['appeal is allowed']
+139451;['appeal is allowed']
+83020;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+132640;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47148;['appeal is dismissed']
+74682;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+77574;['endorses the minister’s recommendation']
+61371;['appeal isallowed']
+56892;['appeal filed against the visa officer’s determination will be dismissed']
+150741;"['dismiss the appeal and', ""confirm the rpd's determination"", 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']"
+115206;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+52929;['appeal dismissed']
+57449;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+26778;['appeal of baljit kaur dhaliwal is dismissed']
+50512;['appeal of ambreen mansoor milak is dismissed']
+18004;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+117122;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+130925;['appeal isdismissed.']
+13678;['appeal should be dismissed']
+47805;['appeal were dismissed']
+101267;['appeal is allowed']
+97381;['negative']
+99680;['you are not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68095;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+147623;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132845;['appeal is allowed']
+89793;['appellant does not lose his permanent resident status']
+95101;['302 (c.a.']
+80212;['negative']
+57904;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+125234;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+72799;['appeal isallowed']
+62444;['appeal is allowed']
+67251;['appeal proceeded by way of a hearingde novo']
+49566;['appeal is dismissed']
+152009;['appeal is dismissed']
+122941;['appeal is allowed']
+122370;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+130988;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141216;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+62460;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+143881;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86006;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91293;['appeal isallowed']
+84863;['appeal is terminated']
+67456;['appeal isallowed']
+124022;['appeal is allowed']
+99252;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96277;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+51045;['appeal is allowed']
+97626;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+95186;['appeal is dismissed']
+102116;['appeal is   ']
+82460;['appeal is terminated']
+100362;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+24200;['neither a “convention refugee”']
+88095;['302 (c.a.']
+133374;['appeal is allowed']
+125678;['appeal is allowed']
+97028;['panel rejects this claim']
+99216;['appeals were dismissed']
+128565;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+80214;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+75494;['appeal of jagdish kaur rai is allowed in law']
+94677;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96300;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+99422;['appeal is allowed']
+125680;['appeal is dismissed.pursuant', 'appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+65015;['appeal is dismissed']
+87858;['negative']
+39596;['appeal is dismissed']
+97614;['appeal is dismissed']
+79191;['appeal is dismissed']
+78082;['appeal is allowed']
+118170;['appeal is allowed']
+97087;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+121542;['appeal is allowed']
+131233;['appeal is allowed']
+146886;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79747;['appeal isallowed']
+114347;['overturn its finding']
+81424;['appeal is allowed']
+20446;['appeal is dismissed']
+36182;['appeal is allowed']
+85306;['appeal is terminated']
+87117;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+109705;['appeal is dismissed']
+54737;['appeal is dismissed']
+38418;['appeal is allowed']
+31399;['appeal is not allowed']
+105374;['appeal is dismissed']
+87449;['appeal isallowed']
+84251;['appeal is dismissed']
+132824;"[""panel finds that the visa officer's decision is legally valid""]"
+90092;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+93347;['appellant is not a person']
+89280;['appeal is allowed']
+87399;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101752;['favourable decision is issued']
+123371;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+83497;['appeal is allowed']
+34108;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+100437;['appeal is dismissed']
+47306;['appeal to fail in its entirety']
+80786;['appeal is allowed']
+104283;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+77437;['appeal is allowed']
+108976;['appeal is dismissed']
+147780;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72856;['appeal is dismissed']
+71559;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+143916;['appeal is allowed']
+54557;['appeal of thi lien pham is allowed']
+63760;['appeal isallowed']
+97515;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+147596;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+121437;['confirms the impugned determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxare neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97923;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+125641;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+52082;['appeal is terminated']
+47750;['appeal is allowed']
+114406;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141376;['id is set aside', 'appeal is allowed']
+75886;['appeal is allowed']
+80659;['claim is rejected']
+65134;['appeal is allowed']
+95553;['appeal is dismissed']
+88978;['appeal is allowed']
+67529;['appeal isallowed']
+149109;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141642;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction to hear this appeal']
+9679;['appeal is dismissed']
+88142;['appeal is dismissed']
+99815;['appeal isdismissed.']
+71197;['appeal is allowed']
+75473;['appeal is terminated', 'stay is cancelled']
+40125;['appeals are allowed.the']
+47807;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+104076;['appeal is dismissed']
+128337;['appeal is dismissed']
+87508;['appeal is dismissed']
+76070;['appeal is allowed']
+30407;['rad finds that the application does not comply with the rules']
+75931;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+59142;['appeal is terminated']
+95936;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94258;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+24205;['appeal is dismissed']
+44037;['appeal is dismissed']
+62940;['appeal ofjagmohan singh deolis allowed']
+77945;['appeal is dismissed']
+141677;['appeals are dismissed']
+47780;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95938;['appeal isallowed']
+131519;['appeal is dismissed']
+49634;['appeal was scheduled']
+133180;['not be recognized as refugees']
+132795;['appeal is allowed']
+34883;['appeal is dismissed']
+122696;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98375;['appeal is dismissed']
+85463;['appeals ofomer shahid ahmadandahad shahid ahmedareallowed.']
+71366;['appeal of davinder kaur johal pursuant toparagraph 67(1)(c)']
+101813;['appeal is allowed']
+105628;['appeal is dismissed']
+123688;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination in part', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”']
+90913;['appeal is dismissed']
+70574;['“convention refugees”']
+71267;['appeal is dismissed']
+60983;['appeal is terminated']
+95055;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+90313;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87681;['appeal is allowed']
+89110;['claimants are not “convention refugees” unders']
+120791;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94838;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+68093;['appeal is dismissed']
+83673;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+146895;['confirm the determination of the   refugee protection division', 'appellant is neither a convention   refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132647;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+96723;['appeal is terminated']
+75169;['appeal isdismissed.']
+102289;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+83048;['appeal is dismissed']
+37869;['appeal is allowed']
+87134;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+122877;['appellants are convention refugees']
+83505;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+121388;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+105701;['appeal is allowed']
+84437;['appeal is dismissed']
+36098;['appellant is not a permanent resident', 'appeal is dismissed']
+104552;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its finding that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94264;['appeal is allowed']
+140874;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56998;['negative']
+48426;['appeal be denied']
+87433;['appeal is granted']
+112376;['appeal is dismissed']
+111036;['claimant and his family are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+109629;['appeal is dismissed']
+71698;['appeal is dismissed']
+116753;['appeal is allowed']
+128743;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is excluded from protection']
+99800;['appeal were dismissed']
+78002;['appeal isdismissed.']
+92247;['appeal isallowed']
+96094;['claims are rejected']
+58142;['appeal is terminated']
+47343;['appeal is dismissed']
+65683;['appeal isallowed']
+107043;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+73214;['appeal is dismissed']
+90190;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+92867;['302 (c.a.']
+117193;['appeal is allowed']
+82027;['appeal is terminated']
+61508;['negative']
+100010;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+125683;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+114338;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+37860;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+110570;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+68723;['appeal is dismissed']
+94588;['appeals are allowed']
+107034;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+152480;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+132285;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+68702;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+80802;['leads me to conclude that ms. gurmeet kaur had no intention of passing this course']
+107851;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83039;['appeal is dismissed']
+110961;['appeal is dismissed']
+98347;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+116849;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+90638;['allows the appeal']
+42301;['appeals are allowed']
+101757;['appeal is allowed in law']
+48287;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+65681;['appeal isallowed']
+105647;['appeal filed by xxxx xxxx is dismissed']
+68876;['appeal is allowed']
+36249;['application is dismissed']
+107471;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+99760;['tribunal rejects her claim']
+89440;['appeal is dismissed']
+87062;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98438;['appeal is terminated']
+46561;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+83463;['appeal is terminated']
+88822;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+94553;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+141231;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87730;['appeal is allowed']
+125323;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+101903;['claimants,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are “convention refugees']
+54808;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76678;['appeal is allowed']
+110979;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”']
+104433;['appeal is dismissed']
+130872;['appeal were dismissed']
+140953;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108762;['rad rejects this explanation']
+93822;['you,xxxx xxxx xxxx, not to be a convention refugee or a person in need ofcanada’s protection']
+86320;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+142898;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+70191;['appeal is allowed']
+62119;['application is granted']
+65114;['appeal is dismissed']
+149284;['appeal isallowed']
+31435;['appeal is dismissed']
+54551;['appeal is dismissed']
+90457;['negative']
+86395;['appeal isallowed']
+37899;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123791;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42395;['appeal isdeterminedto be']
+139421;['appeal is dismissed']
+71244;['appeal is allowed']
+38776;['appeal is dismissed']
+113283;['302 (c.a.']
+116135;['appeal is dismissed']
+146845;['claimants are not of interest']
+98549;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+121415;['rad finds that the rpd erred in itssection 97determination', 'substitutes its decision that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+76373;['appeal is dismissed']
+93296;['appeal isallowed']
+124674;['appeal is allowed']
+68890;['dismissal of this appeal']
+110713;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+58005;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+76052;['dismissing the appeal']
+88180;['claimants xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees', 'nor are they persons in need of protection']
+103001;['neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67390;['appeal must fail']
+125327;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+83235;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+145032;['application to\xa0reopen\xa0the appeal is dismissed']
+22120;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+35561;['appeal is dismissed']
+46985;['appeal isdismissed.']
+101312;['appeal is allowed']
+59812;['appeal be dismissed']
+99494;['claimants to not be convention refugees unders']
+77790;['appeal should beallowed']
+77669;['appeal isallowed']
+93062;['not a convention refugee']
+124432;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95870;['appeal is dismissed']
+125652;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+134517;['appeals to be allowed']
+92606;['claimant, xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+76885;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+76396;['rad substitutes its decision']
+55968;['appeal of jian gahwar abdi is dismissed']
+144025;['302 (c.a.']
+122830;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx, is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61052;['appeal is allowed']
+33695;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+129394;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+50478;['irb (intervener)(f.c.a., no']
+124195;['302 (c.a.']
+17147;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69342;['appeal is allowed']
+124627;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+52291;['sponsor dies']
+98166;['appeal is dismissed']
+144385;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+124816;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+147591;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+67239;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+35227;['appeal is allowed']
+124981;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68197;['appeal is terminated']
+94061;['appeal isallowed']
+86839;['appeal isallowed']
+132648;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94580;['i reject your claim']
+95517;['appeal is dismissed']
+88252;['appeal is dismissed']
+99477;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124658;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46538;['appeal isallowed']
+82201;['appeal is terminated']
+64305;['appeals of galarehfarhadianand delaramfarhadianare allowed']
+99634;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors', 'appeal is allowed']
+63175;['appeal were dismissed']
+88150;['appeal is allowed']
+69578;['appeal isallowed']
+124740;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+49236;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+89147;['appeal of jose wilfrido martinez rivera is dismissed']
+71603;['allow this appeal']
+62204;['dismisses this appeal']
+99501;['appeal is dismissed']
+151392;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+120797;['appellants are convention refugees and/or persons in need of protection']
+74187;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80763;['negative']
+76693;['appeal of hormat khanom haji mohammadali teherani is dismissed']
+66309;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+55282;['rad has found that the rpd decision will stand']
+151464;['refugee protection claimant', 'not a “convention refugee']
+125009;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+52689;['reject their claims']
+92715;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+76160;['appeal is dismissed']
+77988;['appeal of delroy nicholas morgan from the removal order issued 29 november 2007 is dismissed']
+59783;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+36565;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+99414;['appeal is allowed']
+76855;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+92246;['removal order is set aside']
+103535;['appeal is dismissed']
+99030;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+47160;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+97828;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+73215;['appeal is allowed']
+88974;['appeal isallowed']
+105868;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+89788;['removal order is set aside']
+128377;['appeal is dismissed']
+49636;['appeal is dismissed']
+82232;['appeal is dismissed']
+74581;['removal order is set aside']
+127361;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection”.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+105610;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+96935;['application to re-open the abandoned claim is denied']
+128263;['appeals are dismissed']
+56730;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+84152;['302 (c.a.)']
+86953;['appeal fails']
+39915;['appeal of boniface terhemen nongo is dismissed']
+66250;['appeal is allowed']
+145226;['302 (c.a.']
+100353;['declare both the appealsabandoned.']
+91694;['appeal is allowed']
+94209;['appeal is dismissed']
+56783;['reject the claim']
+65113;['appeal is allowed']
+151469;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150670;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+82803;['appeal is dismissed']
+89681;['appeal is allowed']
+99087;['appeal is dismissed']
+136720;['appeals are dismissed']
+95249;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+92834;['appeal of rafael ernesto castillo cruz is dismissed']
+69472;['dismiss this appeal']
+114308;['appeal is dismissed']
+63723;['removal order is set aside']
+80497;['appeal is dismissed']
+144959;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131075;['appeals are allowed']
+39079;['appeal is allowed']
+89302;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+132352;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60833;['…]”']
+112340;['appeal is dismissed']
+30486;['appeal is dismissed']
+100152;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+39773;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+98253;['appeals are dismissed']
+100824;['removal order is set aside']
+89159;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+100778;['appeal is allowed']
+141309;['appeals ofxxxx']
+105833;['appeal is allowed']
+96414;['appeal is dismissed']
+99517;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+69731;['appeal was dismissed']
+112329;['appeal is dismissed']
+76289;['dismiss the appeals']
+45399;['appeal is dismissed']
+91147;['appeal is allowed.the']
+83644;['panel finds that the visa officer’s determination is valid in law']
+78072;['appeal isallowed']
+77250;['appeal is allowed']
+26486;['allow the appeal']
+134515;['appeal is dismissed']
+75670;['appeal is allowed']
+142993;['rad dismisses the appeals and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92791;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+73186;['appeal is allowed']
+52491;['appeal is dismissed']
+117212;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94333;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+146871;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+90982;['set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+122543;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+60478;['appeal is dismissed']
+86011;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+69823;['dismiss this appeal']
+74484;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+103722;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+49979;['appeal is terminated']
+70885;['appeal of bernd michael gaal is dismissed']
+13830;['appeal is allowed']
+67438;['appeal is dismissed']
+68706;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95196;['appeal is dismissed']
+87699;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+132385;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+85537;['appeal is dismissed']
+31465;['appeal is allowed']
+94354;['appeal terminated']
+94409;['appeal is dismissed']
+105912;['exclusion order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+23027;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95538;['appeal is allowed']
+130692;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+86376;['appeal is allowed']
+131143;['appeal isallowed']
+94652;['appeal is dismissed']
+99244;['removal order is set aside']
+97809;['claimant is excluded from refugee protectionpursuant']
+101396;['302 (c.a.']
+124170;['not uphold its decision']
+71268;['appeal of the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness against a decision of the immigration division']
+130004;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+93088;['rad (refugee appeal division) confirms the decision of the rpd']
+94308;['appeal is allowed']
+132785;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131044;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “refugee”']
+67005;['allow the appeal.given']
+78761;['appeal is terminated']
+148652;['appeal is allowed']
+82209;['appeal is allowed']
+84825;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90557;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+131231;['appeal were dismissed']
+107877;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+50501;['appeal ofhassan elkadriis dismissed']
+100087;['appeal is dismissed']
+101338;['appeal is allowed']
+88509;['reject his claim']
+73316;['irpa does not give the iad jurisdiction']
+84229;['appeal is terminated']
+79920;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+94069;['appeal were dismissed']
+74548;['appeal isallowed']
+73586;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98797;['appeal of abdullah mujadidi is dismissed']
+86656;['appeal is allowed']
+14702;['appeal of luc chu should be dismissed']
+81264;['appeal were allowed']
+31928;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76096;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+138807;['appeal isallowed']
+59368;['appeal would be dismissed']
+60924;['appeal will therefore be adjournedsine']
+67256;['appeal isallowed']
+92796;['removal order isset aside']
+116824;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96153;['appeal is dismissed']
+122889;['uphold this finding']
+71167;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+92436;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+82879;['appeal is dismissed']
+21299;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108258;['appeal is allowed']
+46999;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+16819;['appeal is dismissed']
+84564;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+88450;['negative']
+54815;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+60039;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+33321;['appeal is allowed']
+45153;['appeal is dismissed']
+98534;['appeal is allowed']
+31987;['appeal is allowed']
+102846;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is a “person in need of protection']
+134279;['appeal is dismissed']
+91167;['appeal is allowed']
+125671;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76424;['appeal is terminated']
+103726;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee   or person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+68376;['appeal is allowed']
+81151;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+98125;['appeal is allowed']
+73263;['allows the appeal']
+139798;['appeal is dismissed']
+96271;['negative']
+100837;['claimant is not a convention refugee, or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+148491;['appeal is dismissed']
+91636;['dismissal of the appeal']
+135124;['appeal is dismissed']
+146613;['dismiss the appeal']
+69103;['appeal of rui qiong lin is allowed in law']
+76451;['appeal isallowed']
+101706;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+82446;['appeal is allowed']
+68915;['appeal must be dismissed']
+92033;['appeal of umul khair siddiqa is dismissed']
+123406;['uphold the rpd’s findings']
+60362;['appeal of mayala mundele is dismissed']
+114304;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+60698;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+69397;['claim is rejected']
+74122;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+101814;['appealof gagandeep singh grewalisallowed']
+146545;['appeal is dismissed']
+46385;['appeal is allowed']
+122315;['appeal is allowed']
+141233;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection']
+68212;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+132337;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63952;['appeal isallowed']
+113756;['appeal is allowed']
+74892;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+132419;['302 (c.a.']
+46284;['dismiss the appeal']
+59815;['dismisses the minor appellant’s appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145431;['appeal is dismissed']
+122772;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+64865;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+86406;['appellant is not a sponsor within the meaning of theirpr']
+130009;['appeal is dismissed']
+123769;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+44728;['appeal is determined']
+95785;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision to reject the appellants’ refugee claims']
+38996;['rad finds that the rpd’s rejection']
+101169;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+88123;['removal order is set aside']
+100172;['claim is rejected']
+54643;['appeal for huifeng yu is dismissed']
+92940;['appeal is allowed']
+148647;['302 (c.a.']
+19170;['dismiss the appeal']
+19386;['thehoukouwas not rejected']
+79755;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+76651;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+146923;['appeal would be dismissed']
+97388;['reject the claim']
+74785;['appeal isallowed']
+87153;['removal order is set aside']
+75001;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80664;['refugee protection division', 'not convention refugees']
+80713;['appeal isallowed']
+28537;['appeal is dismissed']
+137680;['appeal be allowed or dismissed']
+71706;['appeal is declared to be abandoned']
+94360;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95048;['appeal is allowed']
+63919;['application must be dismissed']
+132806;['appeal is dismissed']
+68176;['application is denied']
+124042;['rpd’s negative determination']
+123425;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in protection']
+125338;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from the application of the refugee protection regime']
+82377;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76915;['dismisses the appeal']
+61959;['appeal is dismissed']
+89376;['appeal is terminated']
+108257;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77881;['appeal is allowed']
+125364;['confirm the rpd determination']
+80051;['not convention refugees']
+70386;['appeal is dismissed']
+94142;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+132325;['appeal is allowed']
+95564;['appeal is dismissed']
+132633;['appeal is dismissed']
+147617;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52482;['appeal isallowed']
+47336;['appeal is allowed']
+123265;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+94148;['appeal is dismissed']
+60106;['appeals of ernest aron pillay and thevanayagi pillay are dismissed']
+68303;['appeal is allowed']
+47121;['dismisses his appeal']
+132635;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100856;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+124975;['appeal is dismissed']
+23087;['removal order isset aside']
+70643;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+14714;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+60817;['appellant is not a convention refuge']
+143466;['302 (c.a.']
+96810;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77879;['reject her claim']
+37405;['appeal was dismissed']
+38392;['appeal is dismissed']
+69969;['appeal is dismissed']
+124173;['appeal is allowed']
+60363;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87459;['appeal is allowed']
+56170;['refugee protection division accepts their claims']
+87168;['appeal dismissed']
+55916;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+69192;['appeal is allowed']
+108772;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+83255;['appeal is allowed']
+81077;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+100086;['appeal of manjeet kaur gill isdismissed.']
+143649;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90781;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103714;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+45185;['appeal is allowed']
+70668;['panel therefore rejects their claim']
+98359;['set aside the immigration officer’s decision', 'allow the appeal']
+26693;['appeal was heard on the merits']
+106783;['appeal is dismissed']
+39567;['appeal is allowed']
+89092;['negative']
+49967;['appeal is terminated']
+121953;['302 (c.a.']
+67062;['appeal is dismissed']
+102681;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+36120;['appeals are dismissed']
+136667;['overturning the decision of the rpd']
+118247;['302 (c.a.']
+55913;['appeal isallowed']
+123448;['appeal is allowed']
+100257;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+91146;['appeal is dismissed']
+123295;['appeal is dismissed']
+113225;['appeal is allowed']
+83051;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91774;['appeal is allowed']
+67629;['appeal isallowed']
+34100;['rpd’s decision is wrong in fact']
+97927;['dismissal of the present appeals']
+100530;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+102108;['appeal is allowed']
+81642;['appeal were dismissed']
+65706;['appeal is allowed']
+97373;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+100700;['dismissing the appeal']
+143912;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+56911;['appeal shall proceed to a hearing on its merits']
+67360;['appeal is allowed']
+89102;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+60473;['302 (c.a.)']
+74836;['appeal proceeded today']
+62468;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134237;['appeal is allowed']
+85437;['appeal is dismissed']
+149476;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+96700;['negative']
+151587;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131528;['removal order is set aside']
+52712;['application to reopen his claim is dismissed']
+55003;['appeal is dismissed']
+89719;['allow the appeal']
+56808;['claimants’ removal']
+107684;['appeal is allowed']
+95596;['appeal is dismissed']
+70037;['allows the appeal']
+69940;['appeal is   ']
+96358;['appeal is dismissed']
+56740;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+47556;['appeal is dismissed']
+98260;['application to reopen the claim of xxxx xxxx is dismissed']
+138805;['appeal is allowed']
+21375;['not a “convention refugee”']
+99660;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140284;['claimants do not face a serious possibility of persecution']
+123022;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+57550;['appeal of hoa hieu ngo is allowed']
+91338;['appeal is withdrawn']
+72668;['appeal is dismissed']
+31461;['appeal of is dismissed']
+122963;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+124270;['appeal is allowed']
+124985;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protectionas']
+103020;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50527;['appeal is dismissed']
+92839;['appeal is allowed']
+150244;['appeal is allowed']
+102999;['panel agrees with the minister']
+27470;['appeal is dismissed']
+22822;['appeal is dismissed']
+95623;['appeal is terminated']
+102746;['appeal is allowed']
+76290;['appeal is dismissed']
+70653;['appeal is terminated']
+101306;['allow the appeal']
+91711;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'claims are, therefore, rejected']
+64223;['appeal was withdrawn']
+114315;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45424;['appeal isallowed']
+93116;['appeal is allowed']
+59365;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89085;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134307;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+127361;['submission is unfounded']
+100236;['appeal isallowed']
+36565;['appeal is allowed']
+85489;['appeal is dismissed']
+124669;['302 (c.a.']
+84607;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+101275;['allows this appeal']
+109695;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+108904;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+80205;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+141044;['rpd’s decision must be upheld']
+74625;['appeal is allowed']
+150673;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+142907;['reject these claims']
+17191;['appeal is allowed']
+49975;['appeal is allowed']
+77771;['appeal is terminated']
+116764;['appeal is allowed']
+127432;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+91812;['appeal is denied']
+68195;['302 (c.a.)']
+108879;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+35807;['appeal were dismissed']
+151437;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34707;['appeal is dismissed']
+146998;['appeal is dismissed']
+81083;['appeal is allowed']
+100900;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+79945;['negative']
+94086;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+112349;['appeal is dismissed']
+23084;['appeal is allowed']
+101846;['appeal is dismissed']
+67014;['appeal is dismissed']
+80978;['appellantis neither a convention   refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113593;['appeal is allowed']
+84567;['appeal is terminated']
+71614;['dismiss this appeal']
+46999;['dismiss this appeal']
+38241;['appeal is allowed']
+105605;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+104128;['thatxxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxxare not persons in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+88138;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+23001;['appeal is dismissed']
+62718;['appeal isallowed']
+102407;['removal order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98541;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+78293;['appeal is allowed']
+67529;['appeal isallowed']
+103051;['thepanel finds the removal order valid in law']
+97647;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+124086;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98247;['respondent remains a convention refugee']
+95206;['irpa does not prohibit such considerations']
+46050;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+42329;['appeals are allowed']
+107667;['declares the appeal abandoned']
+75136;['appeal isallowed']
+68739;['appeal is allowed']
+124072;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+105812;['appeal is allowed']
+60418;['appeal fail']
+90746;['appeal isdismissedand adeparture orderis made against the appellant']
+107633;['rad will substitute its own finding and determination']
+90021;['dismiss the present appeal']
+98074;['302 (c.a.)']
+132808;['appellant is not a refugee']
+94153;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+28283;['appeals are dismissed']
+79964;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+18010;['appeal is allowed']
+134399;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+65645;['appeal isallowed']
+142450;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+62453;['appellants are convention refugees']
+94452;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+21317;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+98854;['appeal is dismissed']
+76320;['nor a permanent resident and can']
+107445;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+61641;['appeal is allowed']
+87037;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+24198;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+50644;['appeal is dismissed']
+81172;['appeal is dismissed']
+52724;['motion isgranted.']
+131505;['appeal is dismissed']
+40773;['appeal is dismissed']
+97307;['panel rejects this refugee protection claim']
+101336;['appeal is terminated']
+91185;['dismiss the appeal']
+134496;['appeal is terminated']
+56314;['appeal is dismissed']
+130682;['appeal is allowed']
+27308;['appeal is dismissed']
+81265;['appeal is dismissed']
+55303;['appeal is allowed']
+99200;['appeal is allowed']
+46577;['appeal is dismissed']
+131193;['appeal is to be dismissed', 'appellant will be removed']
+57812;['appeal is allowed']
+67611;['appeal is dismissed']
+81230;['appellant is not a member of the family class']
+35874;['appeal may still fail']
+84537;['rad sets aside the rpd’s decision']
+121945;['rad finds the rpd’s errors', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+70412;['appeal is allowed']
+74260;['appeal is dismissed']
+34881;['appeal is dismissed']
+140280;['302 (c.a.']
+77126;['appeal isallowed.the']
+76241;['appeal is moot']
+66902;['appeal isallowed']
+77106;['appeal isallowed.the']
+15423;['appeal is dismissed']
+125545;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+81141;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76658;['appeal is dismissed']
+111167;['appeal is dismissed']
+104074;['appeal is dismissed']
+107588;['dismiss your appeal']
+80503;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+107852;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146833;['appeal is allowed']
+100090;"[""rad confirms the rpd's determination"", 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']"
+113730;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+80000;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+145060;['appeal is dismissed']
+77774;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+79991;['negative']
+125312;['appeal is allowed']
+54202;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+78774;['appeals are dismissed']
+130678;['appeal isallowed']
+100010;['panel rejects the present claims']
+100373;['appeal is dismissed']
+77772;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+85859;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+100164;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+96912;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+24464;['appeal is allowed']
+97080;['claims are rejected']
+100792;['appeal is dismissed']
+70768;['appeal is allowed']
+82890;['appeal is allowed']
+146113;['claimants would not face a serious possibility of persecution']
+68322;['appeal is allowed.the']
+128891;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+26690;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+68118;['dismiss the appeal of manjit singh buttar']
+38370;['appeal of the adult appellants is dismissed']
+146873;['appeal is dismissed']
+80214;['302 (c.a.']
+62942;['appeal were dismissed']
+52928;['appeal is dismissed']
+88609;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+98240;['removal orders are set aside']
+82790;['appeal is allowed']
+81273;['appeal of nina tarasikova is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+68694;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+75432;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+97908;['appeal by gloria teixeira tavares (the appellant) is dismissed']
+96062;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+71663;['appeal of the appellant’s daughter is dismissed']
+89036;['appeals are dismissed']
+148059;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89445;['refugee protection division rejects their claims.xxxxxis']
+91232;['appeal must be dismissed']
+71134;['allows this appeal']
+46046;['appeal is dismissed']
+60407;['appeal is allowed']
+12231;['appeal is dismissed']
+91180;['appeal isallowed']
+75004;['appeal is allowed']
+105907;['rad concurs with the minister’s submissions']
+54843;['rpd’s decision is not supportable']
+81280;['appeal is allowed']
+38258;['appeal is dismissed']
+96296;['sponsor is a sponsor as']
+81596;['appeal is allowed']
+144015;['appellants are convention refugees']
+107228;['302 (c.a.']
+144028;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes that decision with its own determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+100780;['appeal isallowed']
+107589;['appeal is allowed']
+89849;['appeal is dismissed']
+127409;['appeal is allowed']
+90115;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a “person in need of protection']
+65093;['appeal isallowed']
+82647;['appeal is dismissed']
+70494;['302 (c.a.)']
+46483;['appeal is determined']
+62878;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+27475;['appeal is de novo']
+65017;['appeal is dismissed']
+82204;['appeal is dismissed']
+75477;['appeal is dismissed']
+115175;['appeals would be dismissed']
+96176;['302 (c.a.']
+116187;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees and persons in need of protection']
+69759;['allow this appeal']
+54814;['appeal is allowed']
+122803;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+57092;['appeal is dismissed']
+48222;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+58819;['appeals are allowed.the']
+94037;['appeal is dismissed']
+122984;['appeal is allowed']
+98354;['appeal is allowed']
+95792;['appeal is allowed']
+125052;['appeal is allowed']
+96466;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+98495;['appeal is allowed']
+69517;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+58416;['appeal is dismissed']
+95983;['reject their claims']
+110959;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69817;['appeal is dismissed']
+122918;['appeal is allowed']
+139843;['302 (c.a.']
+59725;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+86063;['rad finds that the rpd’s reasoning is flawed']
+123817;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+55130;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+114330;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+95210;['removal orders are set aside', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+123389;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+133268;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44969;['dismiss the appeal']
+88154;['appeal is terminated']
+65696;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+91417;['appeal is dismissed']
+77573;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+84243;['appeal isallowed']
+81246;['appeal is dismissed']
+124816;['appeal is allowed']
+36139;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+81165;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+143470;['appeal is allowed']
+100262;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+81802;['appeal is dismissed']
+86654;['appeal is allowed']
+84354;['appeal is dismissed']
+138828;['appeal is dismissed']
+96422;['appeal is dismissed']
+137447;['appeal is allowed']
+48288;['appeal is dismissed']
+76469;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination', 'respondents are neither conventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100998;['302 (c.a.)']
+70026;['appeal is allowed']
+87872;['appeal is allowed']
+81636;['appeal is allowed']
+46078;['appeal isallowedand']
+133391;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+14334;['appeal isallowedin law']
+123662;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+75411;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+70019;['appeal must be dismissed']
+28062;['appeals are dismissed']
+61448;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+146635;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+103624;['claim is rejected']
+84193;['appeal is dismissed']
+64611;['appeal isallowed']
+76671;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+147457;['dismisses this appeal']
+128152;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87375;['appeal is dismissed']
+101876;['appeal is allowed']
+124096;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76733;['appeal dismissed']
+77276;['application is granted']
+104475;['appeal is dismissed']
+71041;['negative']
+82683;['appeal isallowed']
+55167;['appeal is dismissed']
+138803;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80749;['panel rejects this conclusion as well']
+88111;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+125657;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+94944;['appeal be dismissed']
+96158;['appeal is allowed']
+139470;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+54700;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+76499;['appeal is dismissed']
+111038;['panel rejects his claim']
+133192;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52722;['motion isgranted.']
+124708;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appeal is dismissed']
+114349;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101881;['appeal is allowed']
+116357;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57302;['appeals areallowed']
+40649;['appeal is allowed']
+93943;['appeal is allowed']
+69616;['dismiss the appeal', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+62402;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+90192;['claimants are not “persons in need of\xa0']
+61230;['allow his appeal']
+70051;['appeal isallowed']
+94181;['appeal is dismissed']
+98663;['appeal of jeffery cedric joseph stewart is dismissed']
+131039;['rpd’s decision is correct', 'confirm it']
+62954;['appeal is allowed in law']
+102928;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+74069;['removal order is set aside']
+73681;['appeal is allowed']
+133242;['appeal is dismissed']
+142497;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+107176;['appeal is dismissed']
+76727;['appeal is dismissed']
+40076;['appeal is dismissed']
+57099;['appeal is dismissed']
+93121;['appeal is terminated']
+37835;['appeal is allowed']
+87876;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+46480;['appeal is allowed']
+74070;['302 (c.a.)']
+98464;['appeal isallowed']
+76021;['appeal is dismissed']
+60024;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+122368;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125665;['appeal is allowed']
+23067;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+113261;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+66314;['appeal ofcarolyn dawn dohertyin respect to her husband,munther shadeha al‑masri, is allowed']
+140237;['appeal is dismissed']
+83524;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+135124;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94000;['302 (c.a.']
+77229;['appeal is allowed']
+143892;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+92070;['appeal is dismissed']
+46008;['appeal is allowed']
+112391;['rad denies the request for an extension of time']
+123692;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+98097;['appeal isallowed']
+44095;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+92759;['appeal is allowed']
+55298;['appeal is allowed']
+57569;['appeal is allowed']
+95019;['appeal isallowed']
+108774;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+91233;['appeal is allowed']
+99774;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+66930;['appeal is terminated']
+97472;['appeal is terminated']
+97886;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+52124;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+93146;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+122680;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+91715;['removal order is set aside']
+94926;['appeal is allowed']
+47829;['appeal isallowed']
+127468;['appeal is dismissed']
+57938;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+37858;['appeal is allowed']
+122665;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+88090;['302 (c.a.']
+93594;['appeal is dismissed']
+120817;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69735;['appeal is allowed']
+96903;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+63985;['appeal is dismissed']
+83660;['appeal is allowed']
+68583;['appeal isallowed']
+77071;['removal order is set aside']
+132743;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+99251;['appeal is allowed']
+57482;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124065;['appeal is allowed']
+123610;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+88525;['claimant is a not “convention refugee']
+128260;['appeal is dismissed']
+29127;['appeal is dismissed']
+124971;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+27013;['rad finds the rpd decision must be set aside']
+92177;['appeal is dismissed']
+63860;['appeal isallowed']
+128264;['appeal isallowed']
+60697;['appeal is dismissed']
+93880;['appeal of meng hang is dismissed']
+56615;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+122769;['appeal is dismissed']
+97338;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+74084;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee']
+124975;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.unhcr report']
+69835;['appeal is dismissed']
+87333;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+69624;['appeal be dismissed']
+92273;['not a convention refugee']
+136727;['appeal is allowed']
+125636;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that these appellants are convention refugees']
+97853;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+72571;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+77811;['negative']
+74262;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+79468;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+121877;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113570;['appeal is allowed']
+72563;['appeal isdismissed.']
+65666;['allowed the application']
+64129;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+102026;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+55880;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+96199;['appeal be allowed']
+109035;['appeal is dismissed']
+68705;['appeal is dismissed']
+129186;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+133709;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+66299;['appeal is dismissed']
+102480;['determination is valid in law']
+101060;['allow the appeal']
+95121;['appeal is allowed']
+107055;['appeal is allowed']
+52696;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (a.k.a.']
+95279;['appeal isallowed']
+52059;['appeal is terminated']
+18929;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+62448;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm, on different grounds', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100185;['appeal is allowed']
+93042;['negative']
+144413;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79941;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+29463;['appeal is dismissed']
+94896;['negative']
+79996;['appeal isallowed']
+103799;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxx xxxx']
+102071;['dismiss the appeal']
+88500;['negative']
+48269;['appeal is dismissed']
+53405;['appeal is dismissed']
+50259;['appeal is allowed']
+110317;['dismisses the appeal']
+101340;['appeal is allowed']
+89788;['appeal is allowed']
+80749;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+26672;['appeal of nana nagawa zubedi is dismissed']
+131543;['appeal is allowed']
+92565;['appeal is terminated']
+98834;['appeal is dismissed']
+86868;['appeal isallowed']
+103508;['appeal is dismissed']
+46480;['appeal is allowed']
+57564;['appeal is allowed']
+99693;['visa officer’s determination is valid in law']
+123369;['substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+91302;['appeal isallowed']
+81918;['appeal is dismissed']
+71625;['appeal isallowed']
+83908;['dismiss the appeal']
+72184;['immigration appeal division dismisses the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+39067;['appeal is dismissed']
+36259;['appeal is terminated']
+77311;['appeal is allowed']
+87707;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+60115;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+94452;['appeal is dismissed']
+95020;['allow the appeal']
+83014;['refugee proetction claim was rejected']
+102419;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+153148;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+129913;['dismisses the appeal']
+151409;['appeal isallowed']
+131142;['appeal is allowed']
+124660;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76363;['appeal is dismissed']
+69797;['appeal is allowed']
+133184;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+121843;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86459;['appeal is allowed']
+135142;['rad confirms the appealed determination']
+59159;['appeal is dismissed']
+77959;['appeal is allowed']
+145056;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+76035;['appeal of mamie manko is dismissed']
+80242;['302 (c.a.']
+91139;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+40660;['appeal is allowed']
+88252;['confirm the determination\xa0 /\xa0 ']
+107180;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+70023;['appeal of chandrakumar kumarasingham is abandoned']
+37419;['appeal is dismissed']
+127718;['appeal fails']
+131177;['appeal is dismissed']
+122888;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+91938;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+100187;['appeal ought to be dismissed']
+146489;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+145231;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52603;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+83023;['appeal isallowed']
+87813;['302 (c.a.)']
+15017;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52517;['appeal isallowed']
+143550;['neither a convention “refugee” nor a person in need of protection']
+143068;['appellant is therefore a convention refugee']
+145290;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+112339;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+100789;['appeal isallowedand']
+77900;['appeal is dismissed']
+89677;['appeal of salsabel adel aboktef is allowed']
+42299;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80014;['negative']
+68695;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91427;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+131070;['allows the minister’s appeal']
+68218;['tribunal allows the appeal']
+100828;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72679;['appeal is dismissed']
+115210;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+82126;['appeal is postponed']
+60490;['appeal is terminated']
+39567;['appeal is allowed']
+123934;['appeal is allowed.the']
+124902;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+99101;['stay is cancelled']
+61321;['appeals are dismissed']
+85167;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee']
+76711;['appeal is allowed']
+77281;['appeal is dismissed']
+125493;['appeal is allowed']
+128913;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+102541;['appeal is dismissed']
+83548;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108876;['refugee protection division rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+100216;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+41251;['appeal is terminated']
+140241;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+91206;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+85509;['appeal is dismissed']
+83648;['appeal isallowed.the']
+64648;['decision of the immigration officer is legally valid']
+21340;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+93809;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects their claims']
+84700;['appeal is allowed']
+95062;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+69241;['appeal is allowed']
+82046;['appeal is allowed']
+117206;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+63515;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+46049;['appeal were dismissed']
+78728;['appeal is allowed']
+82693;['hearing date is vacated']
+124343;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx are convention refugees']
+128569;['rad concludes thatxxxx xxxxis excluded from the application of the convention']
+115181;['appeal would be dismissed']
+127415;['appeal of sivakamy mohanaram is dismissed']
+47609;['appeal is allowed']
+98472;['negative']
+108193;['rpd is set aside']
+123375;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+56885;['appeal is allowed']
+95765;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85850;['dismissing his appeal,']
+76683;['appeal is allowed']
+52706;['refugee protection division rejects the claims of xxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxx for refugee protection']
+118433;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+27222;['appeal is dismissed']
+130982;['are neither refugees nor persons in   need of protection']
+91652;['appeal is dismissed']
+75993;['appeal isallowed']
+51087;['appeal is dismissed']
+134408;['appeal is allowed']
+90952;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+34702;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+9491;['allows the appeal']
+77863;['appeal is dismissed']
+92625;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+100230;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+122695;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+76674;['appeal of raymond louie is dismissed']
+130961;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+148664;['appeal is allowed']
+44272;['appeal is dismissed']
+80463;['decision of the visa officer is legally valid']
+81084;['appeal is allowed']
+82360;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+42308;['appeal is allowed']
+105849;['appeal is dismissed']
+105298;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131533;['appeal is allowed']
+98110;['negative']
+69706;['appeal is dismissed']
+59992;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+123619;['substitute my own decision that the appellantxxxx xxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+66202;['dismiss the appeal']
+113795;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+52688;['claimant is not from rwanda']
+136084;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142733;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+79188;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+72871;['appeal must be dismissed']
+72009;['appeal is dismissed']
+93809;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77903;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+92549;['appeal is dismissed']
+69666;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+61393;['application to re‑open is allowed']
+90283;['appeal is based onsubsection']
+78176;['appeal of kuldip singh isallowed']
+101020;['appeal is dismissed']
+76098;['appeal of chai hua laiis determined to be abandoned']
+70794;['dismiss this appeal']
+74518;['appeal is dismissed']
+107233;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145853;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+103096;['appeal is allowed']
+89781;['claimant who is an irish citizen', 'rejects her claim']
+93662;['appeal is allowed']
+89308;['appeal of carmen cortez dela cruz is dismissed']
+90989;['appeal is allowed']
+70965;['negative']
+97307;['negative']
+98332;['appeal is allowed']
+106847;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151874;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a persons in need of protection']
+64274;['appeals are dismissed']
+74856;['appeal is dismissed']
+59133;['dismissing this appeal']
+106790;['appeal is allowed']
+99306;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+30536;['appeal of lawrence robert bell is dismissed']
+115175;['appeals would be dismissed']
+97559;['appeal is allowed']
+82996;['appeal is dismissed']
+98195;['negative']
+86029;['appeal isallowed']
+26784;['appeal is dismissed']
+77293;['appeal of angelina tolentino is dismissed']
+147595;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+129179;['appeal is dismissed']
+72163;['appeal is allowed', 'appellant has not lost her permanent residency status']
+89959;['citizenship are not based on facts']
+73226;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+129939;['appeal is allowed']
+88104;['302 (c.a.']
+98514;['appeal is allowed']
+106289;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+101753;['favourable decision is issued for him']
+74053;['appeal is dismissed']
+61052;['appeal is allowed.the']
+57527;['appeals of the appellants are allowed']
+81202;['appeal is dismissed']
+150663;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116752;['confirms the determination of the rpd']
+71513;['302 (c.a.']
+100938;['appeal is allowed']
+148730;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124161;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97883;['appeal isallowed']
+68361;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+13770;['appeal is dismissed']
+142991;['dismiss the appeal']
+152785;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a person who is inadmissible to canada']
+102103;['appeals were dismissed']
+98636;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+152948;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84911;['appeal is dismissed']
+86144;['appeal of rufino darwin randolph caluza is dismissed']
+74175;['302 (c.a.']
+49067;['appeal is allowed.the']
+91225;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+151847;['appeal is allowed']
+42380;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95977;['appeal is dismissed']
+60310;['appeal is allowed']
+39568;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+90834;['dismisses the appeal']
+93154;['appeal is allowed']
+107497;['appeal was dismissed']
+92105;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59946;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'or persons in need of protection']
+148625;['appeal were dismissed']
+94248;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98892;['appeal is dismissed']
+47796;['appeal is dismissed']
+73021;['appeal is dismissed']
+153269;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+132739;['302 (c.a.']
+130706;['removal order is set aside']
+89123;['appeal isallowed']
+83074;['appeal is allowed']
+94151;['appeal is dismissed']
+135462;['appeal was dismissed']
+85226;['appeal is dismissed']
+100971;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+26755;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+98617;['appeal is allowed']
+139877;['appeal is dismissed']
+108185;['rad, therefore, cannot allow this application']
+69996;['allows the appeal']
+132657;['appeal is dismissed']
+89009;['appeal is allowed']
+92248;['appeal isallowed']
+124420;['appellant is excluded from protection']
+144894;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77927;['appeal is allowed']
+116775;['appeal is allowed.the']
+94383;['allows the appeal']
+140300;['nor is she a person in need of protection']
+8894;['appeal allowed in law']
+34164;['appeal is allowed']
+76462;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+148718;['claim is rejected']
+70026;['allow his appeal', 'set aside his deportation order']
+72800;['appeal is dismissed']
+132420;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+97413;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim']
+95438;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+121527;['appeal is dismissed']
+59808;['appeal isallowed']
+121941;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62464;['appellants are convention refugees who have']
+91645;['application to add a ground of refusal']
+141783;['appeal of thor jacob mut is dismissed']
+56902;['application to reopen and set aside the deportation order isdismissed.']
+107465;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appeal is dismissed']
+125373;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx,']
+101551;['appeal is allowed']
+123402;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+73595;['dismiss the appeal']
+121460;['rad allows the daughter’s appeal']
+76564;['appeal isallowed']
+84594;['adoption is not a genuine adoption']
+123275;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94982;['appeal is dismissed']
+94591;['appeal is allowed']
+61636;['negative']
+77536;['appeal is dismissed']
+24504;['appeal is dismissed']
+143556;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+70043;['allows the appeal']
+152906;['appeal is allowed']
+95714;['appeal isallowed']
+124688;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63723;['appeal is allowed']
+92389;['appealis allowed']
+40297;['appeal is dismissed']
+86032;['appeal is allowed']
+45226;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+70172;['appeal is allowed']
+102953;['appeal is allowed']
+59844;['appeal is dismissed']
+98147;['appeal is allowed']
+144264;['panel rejects the claim']
+145822;['302 (c.a.']
+96259;['appeal is dismissed']
+42304;['appeal is allowed']
+123109;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+95049;['appeal was reopened']
+129933;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84195;['appeal is dismissed']
+80776;['appeal is dismissed']
+151489;['appeal is dismissed']
+104112;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claim']
+87837;['302 (c.a.']
+132844;['appeal is allowed']
+71541;['appeal isallowed']
+80750;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+99075;['claimant, xxxx xxxx,not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+81153;['dismisses this appeal']
+61035;['appeal of danh quang bui is dismissed']
+94902;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+111305;['appeal is allowed']
+108775;['appellants are therefore not persons in need of protection']
+132287;['appeal is allowed']
+88818;['appeal is allowed']
+88320;['appeal is allowed']
+77453;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98828;['negative']
+74604;['appeal is dismissed']
+89548;['appeal is terminated']
+103895;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+89727;['appeal is terminated']
+96038;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67014;['dismiss the appeals']
+88081;['appeal is allowed']
+132792;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26668;['rejected the appeal']
+124929;['substitutes its determination']
+103018;['dismiss their appeal']
+93770;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84453;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+39876;['application to extend the time to file the notice of appeal is dismissed']
+130988;['not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151859;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99411;['allow the appeal']
+129924;['appeals are dismissed']
+76351;['appeal is dismissed']
+45192;['appeal is dismissed']
+72853;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+103598;['302 (c.a.']
+97500;['negative']
+55876;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151772;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the negative determination']
+83832;['appeal is dismissed']
+96708;['appeal is dismissed']
+109624;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85923;['302 (c.a.']
+140830;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+38789;['appeal is allowed']
+141686;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+77534;['302 (c.a.)']
+62196;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+100626;['appeal is allowed']
+99790;['negative']
+80663;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+71728;['appeal is allowed']
+71368;['appeal is governed by theact']
+105422;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+150641;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+41572;['appeal has been abandoned']
+8335;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+110971;['appeal is dismissed']
+66916;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+102415;['appeal was dismissed']
+87599;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80995;['they are accordingly hereby dismissed']
+130985;['appeal is dismissed']
+107260;['appeal was dismissed']
+103050;['appeal is allowed']
+80684;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+77880;['not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+88718;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+80201;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77607;['appeal is allowed']
+95856;['appeal is dismissed']
+24201;['appeal is dismissed']
+87597;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+92768;['appeal is allowed']
+104835;['appeals are dismissed']
+105179;['302 (c.a.)']
+107865;['appeal is dismissed']
+83551;['appeal isallowed']
+26724;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+71227;['appeal of sanjeet singh thandi is dismissed']
+60437;['appeal of oluwaweun rotim fanawopo is dismissed']
+85240;['appeal were dismissed']
+61324;['decision of the rpd']
+90243;['claimants xx xxx xxx and xx xxx xxx are not in need of refugee protection', 'claims are rejected']
+63834;['dismiss the appeal']
+121955;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78169;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+76828;['appeal ofaldo malfeois dismissed']
+59857;['appeal is allowed']
+87435;['appeal is terminated']
+34699;['appeal is allowed']
+148488;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+61362;['appeal is allowed']
+90201;['refugee protection division rejects these claims']
+62250;['negative']
+62488;['appeal is allowed']
+72833;['allows this appeal']
+87951;['neither convention refugees']
+89805;['appeal is allowed']
+69567;['appeal is dismissed']
+92168;['appeal is dismissed']
+97528;['neither convention refugees']
+60947;['appeal is dismissed']
+113263;['appeal is dismissed']
+90919;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+84512;['appeal is allowed']
+72070;['allows this appeal']
+19237;['appeal is dismissed']
+91427;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+123737;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+138820;['appeal be dismissed']
+152911;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+102252;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+94685;['appeal of gurjinder kaur minhas is allowed']
+145438;['appeal is dismissed']
+97359;['302 (c.a.']
+74220;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73332;['…]”']
+23085;['appeal is allowed']
+98656;['panel rejects this claim']
+69393;['claimants are neither convention refugees']
+95887;['rad finds no errors of fact or law']
+125142;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80279;['claimants,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx,xxxxx xxxxx,xxxxxxxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx, not to be convention refugees and not to be persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+107107;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+146123;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+114316;['claim is therefore rejected']
+49164;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140214;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+75891;['appeal be dismissed']
+90457;['pc is not a person in need of protection']
+76414;['appeal is dismissed']
+128307;['appeal is dismissed']
+135139;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128877;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, and their children,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are neither “convention refugees”']
+47778;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124005;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the contested decision', 'neither convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+138811;['appeal is abandoned']
+91305;['appeal be dismissed']
+48417;['i agree with and accept the recommendation']
+68537;['appeal is allowed']
+102535;['appeal is allowed']
+96963;['dismiss the appeal']
+67733;['decision is well founded in law']
+97279;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+138802;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+94395;['appeal is dismissed']
+79920;['not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+124948;['appeal is allowed']
+107633;['appeal is dismissed']
+43724;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+42081;['appeals are allowed']
+135913;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct determination']
+151406;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91100;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90775;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125020;['appeal is dismissed']
+146968;['appeal is allowed']
+122876;['appeal is allowed']
+92790;['appeal is dismissed']
+76084;['dismiss the appeal']
+101780;['appeal is abandoned']
+144019;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143854;['302 (c.a.']
+54303;['appeal is dismissed']
+46068;['appeal is dismissed']
+130746;['appeal is allowed']
+131014;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+72702;['appeal is allowed']
+101302;['appeal isallowedand']
+86463;['appeal is allowed']
+116864;['appeal is dismissed']
+59837;['the claim fails']
+121953;['appeal is dismissed']
+123404;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91560;['panel finds that you are convention refugees']
+53858;['appeal isallowed.the']
+113537;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+144566;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+28087;['appeal is dismissed']
+147903;['rad confirms the decision of the rpo', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need ofprotection.']
+131195;['theappeal istherefore dismissed']
+143068;['appeal is allowed']
+64057;['appeal isallowed']
+81141;['appeal be dismissed']
+153019;['claimant is a “convention refugee”', 'allows his claim for refugee protection']
+99536;['appeal is allowed']
+108814;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+98051;['appeal is allowed']
+124420;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72632;['appeal of jickson racelis is allowed']
+101860;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90361;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70785;['appeal dismissed']
+8295;['appeals of the principal appellant']
+42309;['appeal is dismissed']
+68543;['appeal isallowed']
+38996;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78291;['appeal is dismissed']
+96162;['appeal is allowed']
+140867;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+47822;['appeals are dismissed']
+101061;['claimants, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx and xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+125335;['rad allows the appeal', 'sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+91944;['appeal isallowed']
+69616;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed']
+83709;['appeal is allowed']
+122740;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+148648;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+26704;['appeal bedismissed.']
+76501;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+131507;['appeal would be dismissed']
+91599;['appeal isallowed']
+69336;['appeal is dismissed']
+76016;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142807;['appeal is allowed']
+67536;['dismiss the appeal']
+113790;['“convention refugees”']
+94061;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+85388;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+59806;['appeal is allowed']
+144004;['rad therefore confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+88116;['appeal is allowed']
+144554;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+74512;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+102529;['appeal is dismissed']
+21302;['rad allows the appeals']
+74685;['appeal is denied']
+105304;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52487;['appeal is allowed']
+99827;['302 (c.a.']
+47839;['appeal is dismissed']
+80065;['appeal is dismissed']
+93147;['appeal is dismissed']
+28289;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147798;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+77691;['claimants are not persons in need of protection', 'panel rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+65657;['appeal is dismissed']
+46006;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+131913;['appeal was dismissed']
+145039;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+44739;['dismisses the appeal.moreover']
+142462;['302 (c.a.']
+146101;['rad finds the principal appellant to be a convention refugee']
+97956;['xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+78058;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+111308;['appeal is allowed']
+62205;['appeal is dismissed']
+99046;['rad confirms the determination', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+114739;['appeal is allowed']
+61880;['appeal is terminated']
+130746;['appeal is allowed']
+38792;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63517;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+77797;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+143598;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80559;['appeal is dismissed']
+71037;['claimantsxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugees']
+27518;['appeal is determined']
+47117;['appeal is dismissed']
+52600;['claimants, xxxx and xxxxx, are “convention refugees”']
+72027;['appeal dismissed']
+100604;['appeal is allowed']
+100463;['negative']
+95240;['dismiss the appeal']
+123309;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+83081;['decision of the visa officer not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+61469;['appeal dismissed']
+142967;['confirm the finding of the rpd']
+75598;['removal order is set aside']
+102109;['appeal is allowed']
+97493;['claimants,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees', 'nor are they persons in need of protection']
+94026;['appeals are dismissed']
+145338;['appeal is allowed']
+101339;['302 (c.a.)']
+78016;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+37405;['appeal is dismissed']
+110273;['panel finds the associate claimant to be a convention refugee']
+69104;['appeal be dismissed']
+91569;['appeal isallowed']
+125491;['respondent is a convention refugee']
+43410;['appeal is allowed']
+13769;['appeal is allowed']
+101887;['dismiss this appeal']
+114379;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+68696;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+93687;['decision is legally valid']
+86012;['appeal must be dismissed']
+90684;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84604;['appeal is dismissed']
+147831;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+82105;['appeal is dismissed']
+131748;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+55107;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+35431;['appeal is dismissed']
+62637;['appeal is dismissed']
+105868;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101889;['appeal isallowed']
+77461;['302 (c.a.']
+107267;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100777;['appeal is dismissed']
+105783;['appeal is allowed']
+51812;['appeal is dismissed']
+95630;['claimants are excluded fromsections 96and97(1)pursuant to article 1e of theunited nations convention relating to the status of refugees']
+27294;['appeal is allowed']
+49182;['appeal is dismissed']
+139474;['appeal isallowed.the']
+123671;['oea/ser.l/v/ii']
+57895;['appeal is dismissed']
+102877;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects her refugee protection claim']
+100819;['dismiss the appeal']
+88027;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+108119;['rad sets aside the rpd’s decision excluding the appellant from consideration of her refugee claim']
+105626;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68355;['appeal is allowed']
+63194;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+62988;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+151298;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90645;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+125005;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+134401;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89560;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+70382;['appeal is dismissed']
+143068;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+52522;['appeal isallowed']
+97432;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+70410;['appeal is allowed']
+70647;['appeal is dismissed']
+73033;['appeal is dismissed']
+76730;['appeal of nazmie mohamad saleh is dismissed']
+123923;['appeal is allowed']
+90997;['appeal is allowed']
+101166;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+151380;['sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+77256;['appeal is not allowed']
+83864;['302 (c.a.']
+140270;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is excluded']
+106836;['appeal is allowed']
+98326;['determination is valid in law']
+151603;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94431;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87464;['appeal isallowed']
+87817;['appeal is not without any merit']
+84449;['appeal is dismissed']
+74118;['appeal is allowed']
+99614;['appeal is dismissed']
+153282;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+69555;['appeal is dismissed']
+100102;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appeal is dismissed']
+81094;['appeal is allowed']
+43706;['dismiss the appeal']
+104841;['appeal isallowed']
+103878;['application is allowed']
+98385;['appeal be dismissed.finally']
+97353;['panel rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+58185;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+88414;['claimants are convention refugees']
+104101;['302 (c.a.']
+148759;['appeal is dismissed']
+76404;['substitute the determination /\xa0 ']
+99698;['appeal is dismissed']
+96281;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+131867;['appeal dismissed']
+100855;['appeal is allowed']
+57550;['appeal is allowed']
+47774;['appeal beallowedand']
+102925;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124634;['pc is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72635;['appeal is dismissed']
+133239;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141019;['panel confirms the decision of the rpd', 'rejects this claim']
+54723;['appeal is allowed']
+113233;['appeal is dismissed']
+104260;['declare this appeal abandoned']
+77270;['appeal is allowed']
+107186;['appeal is dismissed']
+145767;['application is granted', 'proceedings are stayed']
+59135;['appeal isallowed']
+68529;['postponement\xa0 /\xa0 ']
+90079;['appeal is dismissed']
+133183;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+69473;['appeals should be allowed']
+36114;['appeals of natalia melman, dmitri melman and liran melman are allowed']
+73678;['appeal is dismissed']
+47808;['appeal is allowed']
+142989;['reject this explanation']
+40131;['appeal is dismissed']
+108721;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75661;['appeal brought by jeenarain ramdatt is accordingly dismissed']
+123997;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+65695;['appeal isallowed']
+80551;['departure order isset aside']
+133241;['decision of the rpd is wrong']
+102486;['appeal is allowed']
+61224;['negative']
+72073;['appeal is dismissed']
+140272;['appellants’ submissions have no merit']
+89425;['appeal is terminated']
+55189;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+103024;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+50732;['appeal is dismissed']
+107591;['appeal is allowed.the']
+90536;['appeal is dismissed']
+92518;['appeal is not allowed']
+124101;['appeal is allowed']
+75938;['appeal brought undersection 63(2)of theactis dismissed']
+127372;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+49976;['appeal isallowed']
+40125;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107939;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100857;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+90659;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+136665;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151948;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+96853;['appeal is allowed']
+54264;['appeal beallowed']
+69437;['claimant’s claim fails']
+153286;['denies their claims']
+106939;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+151345;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50542;['appeal were dismissed']
+98647;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30525;['appeal is allowed']
+84669;['302 (c.a.)']
+76570;['appeal isallowed']
+125594;['appeal is allowed']
+122654;['rpd’s decision is set aside', 'substitute the following determination']
+97946;['appeal of xuerui sun and lin yang is dismissed']
+66207;['appeal of leona de la pena sto (santo) domingo amorsolo is dismissed']
+54188;['appeal were dismissed']
+61445;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+110912;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142287;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94779;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+88973;['appeal must be dismissed']
+129124;['appeal of david chong is dismissed']
+143854;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100490;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm that xxxx xxxx']
+123650;['confirm the rpd’s decision']
+27003;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+90461;['reference has been removed']
+63807;['refugee protection division rejects your claim']
+81858;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+61451;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+46279;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+45222;['appeal is allowed']
+86308;['iad therefore orders your departure from canada']
+83159;['appeal is dismissed']
+56248;['appeal ofaveena kaur gillisallowed.the']
+93634;['appeal is allowed']
+121482;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98902;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+90980;['appeal is terminated']
+60277;['you are not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim']
+103530;['appeal is dismissed']
+124462;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77078;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+152209;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76814;['appeal is allowed']
+31414;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+37896;['appeals are dismissed']
+100190;['appeal is allowed']
+90204;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+102746;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94208;['appeal is allowed']
+145576;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+53131;['allow the appeal']
+145753;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+45427;['appeal is dismissed']
+53826;['iad has lost its jurisdiction']
+61224;['302 (c.a.']
+93628;['appeal is terminated']
+62381;['theclaimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+123595;['appeal is allowed']
+114328;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+103917;['appeal is dismissed']
+143471;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+77008;['appeal is dismissedpursuant']
+47294;['appeal is allowed']
+131727;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+140875;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+69131;['appeal is allowed']
+84483;['appeal is dismissed']
+104937;['appeal is terminated']
+147782;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+94768;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+69238;['appeal is dismissed']
+73022;['appeal is allowed']
+58834;['allowed the appeal']
+121521;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+96705;['appeals are dismissed']
+59989;['the claim fails']
+80086;['appeal is based']
+99835;['decision finding the respondent to be a convention refugee']
+86524;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87333;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60039;['negative']
+105857;['substitutes a determination']
+68536;['appeal is allowed']
+105208;['appeal is allowed']
+76070;['appeal isallowed']
+47925;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+92963;['appeal is terminated']
+56718;['appeal isallowed']
+96797;['appeal is allowed']
+123339;['appeal is dismissed']
+88078;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+57031;['appeal is allowed.the']
+84628;['appeal isallowed']
+80301;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+137456;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97788;['negative']
+40774;['rad finds that this is a case']
+150689;['i disagree with the rpd’s decision on the claims made by the principal appellant, his wife']
+59735;['allow the appeal']
+55275;['reject the claim of xxxxxxxxxxxxxx to refugee protection']
+35404;['respondent is not a convention refugee']
+92964;['appeal is terminated']
+74851;['appeal is allowed']
+150626;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+80472;['appeal is dismissed']
+81181;['appeal be dismissed']
+84780;['appeal is dismissed']
+84013;['302 (c.a.)']
+27589;['302 (c.a.']
+77533;['appeal will be']
+78689;['appeal isallowed']
+25985;['appeal were dismissed']
+69755;['allow the appellant’s appeal']
+97226;['appeal is dismissed']
+27240;['appeal is dismissed']
+69672;['appeal is allowed']
+92101;['not find her allegations to be a sufficient basis']
+57070;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+102126;['appeal is allowed']
+84192;['appeal isallowed']
+50763;['appeal isallowed']
+84685;['dismiss the appeal']
+60868;['appeal isallowed']
+96086;['appeal isallowed']
+71467;['appeal is allowed']
+94172;['appeal is dismissed']
+46566;['appeal is dismissed']
+93647;['302 (c.a.']
+128162;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+124909;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82021;['removal order is set aside']
+123771;['appeal is allowed']
+124023;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+133747;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+123663;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+113618;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+100732;['appeal is allowed']
+82975;['appeal be dismissed']
+146603;['claimant is a not a convention refugee, or a person who needs protection', 'reject this claim']
+8770;['removal orders areset aside']
+17960;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+60833;['appeal terminated']
+71261;['appeal is dismissed']
+94150;['appeal is allowed']
+122881;['302 (c.a.']
+55274;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+67776;['appeal is dismissed']
+101852;['appeal is allowed']
+47166;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+72217;['appeal is caught']
+149113;['appeal is allowed']
+69470;['appeal is dismissed']
+70646;['appeal is dismissed']
+78326;['appeal is dismissed']
+80214;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+102674;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+34696;['appeal is dismissed']
+125049;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+67750;['appeal is allowed']
+5140;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99413;['appeal is dismissed']
+100607;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+136086;['neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+74547;['appeal is allowed']
+101359;['appeal is allowed']
+75881;['removal order is set aside']
+72569;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+54817;['appeal is dismissed']
+69952;['appeal should be allowed']
+113571;['appeal is dismissed']
+86650;['appeal is dismissed']
+77060;['dismissing the appeal']
+82379;['appeal is dismissed']
+19127;['appeal is dismissed']
+93282;['claim is rejected']
+108247;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+91573;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+108718;['rad agrees with the rpd’s findings']
+145828;['appeal rested solely on his general credibility']
+39773;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+70602;['application to reopen the appeal of hantz kenley is dismissed']
+116209;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+123661;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+23051;['appeal is dismissed']
+42382;['appeal is allowed']
+134742;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+74727;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+145328;['appeal is dismissed']
+125119;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+100307;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89785;['claims are rejected']
+121463;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+24463;['appeal is allowed']
+60433;['dismiss the appeal.if']
+79477;['appeal isallowed']
+77995;['appeal is dismissed']
+84060;['appeal is dismissed']
+145133;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+143476;['appeal is allowed']
+101547;['allows this appeal']
+2904;['appeal isdeterminedto be']
+31229;['appeals are allowed']
+36188;['determination is legally valid']
+144385;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105604;['302 (c.a.']
+82145;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+62938;['appeal of boon lim vong is allowed in law']
+86308;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+102271;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+79204;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+91651;['officer dismissed the visa applications']
+80013;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+81262;['visa officer’s decision is valid']
+77901;['appeal is allowed']
+102462;['appeal is allowed']
+98124;['applications are denied']
+70657;['appeal is terminated']
+147433;['appeal is dismissed']
+83840;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+107067;['appeal is allowed']
+140896;['appeal is allowed']
+121482;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43390;['allow the appeal']
+100799;['appeal is allowed']
+87719;['panel therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+87470;['appeal is determined']
+81009;['appeal is dismissed']
+16791;['removal order isset aside']
+99424;['xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+39050;['appeal is dismissed']
+73045;['appeal is determined']
+123898;['appeal is dismissed']
+95016;['appeal is dismissed']
+96329;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72158;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a“convention refugee”']
+107635;['appeal is allowed']
+100149;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate consideration']
+42216;['appeal is allowed']
+96867;['appeal is terminated']
+105651;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination']
+52913;['appeals are dismissed']
+87160;['dismiss the appeal']
+30518;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+151580;['rad finds that the appellant’s argument has some merit']
+101666;['appeal is allowed']
+82240;['appellant is established in canada']
+87355;['appeal is abandoned']
+35544;['appeal is withdrawn']
+36463;['…]»']
+84644;['appeal is dismissed']
+21325;['claimant xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+72184;['dismiss the appeal']
+97386;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+92787;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxx xxxxis rejected']
+94864;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90902;['appeal is allowed']
+100181;['appeal is allowed']
+111289;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+130882;['application must be dismissed']
+133716;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92804;['appeal fails in large part']
+145591;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'claims are dismissed']
+37894;['appeal is allowed']
+60911;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction to hear his appeal']
+74130;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121520;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124419;['appeal is allowed']
+93907;['appeal is dismissed']
+136679;['’ argument']
+103903;['rad rejects it']
+85310;['appeal is terminated']
+66243;['appeal isallowed']
+122979;['mr. xxxx is a convention refugee']
+77999;['appeal is dismissed']
+132300;['set aside the rpd’s decision']
+152901;['dismiss this appeal']
+99554;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+69148;['appeal is dismissed']
+132643;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60085;['rpd rejects the claimant’s claim to refugee protection', 'not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+81238;['appeal is allowed']
+74502;['appeal is allowed']
+123316;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26773;['appeal respecting you meng lav is allowed in law']
+125459;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73263;['appeal isallowed']
+124593;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94540;['dismiss his appeal']
+97505;['the claim fails']
+66490;['appeal is allowed']
+145375;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor on a balance of probabilities']
+127698;['decision is valid in law']
+146538;['302 (c.a.']
+28163;['appeal is dismissed']
+151329;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxand xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+69362;['dismiss the appeal']
+56981;['respondent is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66762;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+105760;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+38993;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+75926;['appeal is allowed in law']
+94269;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105901;['rad disagrees with the rpd’s reasoning']
+86333;['appeal is allowed']
+73298;['dismiss the appeal']
+96813;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+136107;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees in their respective countries of citizenship', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+51132;['appeal is dismissed']
+143848;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101289;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+100005;['appeal is dismissed']
+68426;['appeal is dismissed']
+97403;['negative']
+133694;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52045;['allows this appeal']
+55909;['appeal is allowed.the']
+103619;['appeal is allowed']
+94744;['negative']
+21390;['refugee division determines that xxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+45235;['appeal is dismissed']
+97370;['appeal is allowed']
+68710;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+94633;['appeal isallowed']
+95094;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+27515;['appeal of nho minh nguyen is dismissed']
+47113;['argument is rejected']
+59842;['appeal is allowed']
+108699;['appeal is allowed']
+77468;['appeal is terminated']
+102382;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+87108;['appeal is dismissed']
+88260;['confirm the decision\xa0 /\xa0 ']
+70083;['appeal is dismissed']
+74617;['appeal is dismissed']
+95519;['appeal is allowed']
+107135;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71580;['allows this appeal in equity']
+153729;['allow this appeal']
+21354;"['claimant, xxxxxxxxxx,is not a ""convention refugee']"
+147459;['claimant xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+74046;['appeal is allowed']
+77312;['appeal has some merit']
+93088;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+17374;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+90976;['appeal is dismissed']
+51767;['dismisses the appeal on its merits']
+71093;['appeal is dismissed']
+83644;['dismissed this appeal']
+108777;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103109;['appeal is dismissed']
+69851;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+79339;['302 (c.a.)']
+100103;['claimants are neither\xa0\xa0  convention refugees']
+79960;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+125422;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention “refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+84276;['appeal is allowed']
+106939;['claims are rejected']
+150849;['associate claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110300;['rpd decision will not stand']
+87450;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+52511;['appeal isallowed']
+135920;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+23020;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+76853;['appeal is allowed']
+59370;['children are orphans']
+121417;['uphold these findings']
+110975;['appeal is dismissed']
+74842;['appeal isallowed']
+78335;['302 (c.a.']
+92025;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+94929;['appeal is terminated']
+81224;['appeal is dismissed']
+52705;['refugee protection division determines xxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxx to be convention refugees']
+123616;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108749;['appeal is dismissed']
+86628;['neither a permanent resident nor a person who has been granted protection']
+46477;['appeal is dismissed']
+89364;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+122930;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+144043;['appeal is allowed']
+78721;['appeal of davinderjit kaur pandher is allowed']
+98825;['negative']
+152773;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78017;['appeal is caught']
+130742;['appeal be allowed or dismissed']
+100135;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+60428;['appeal is allowed.the']
+85672;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108943;['application to   reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+54785;['appeal is dismissed']
+100122;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+100049;['appeal is dismissed']
+124941;['uphold the rpd’s finding accordingly']
+127365;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77939;['appeal is dismissed']
+56623;['appeal isallowed']
+134282;['appeal is allowed']
+75597;['appeal is dismissed']
+66609;['appeal must be dismissed']
+87104;['appeal of benson eboremen is dismissed']
+70650;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98007;['302 (c.a.']
+98125;['appeal is allowed']
+30550;['appeal is allowed']
+130701;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+111447;['appeal is dismissed']
+69069;['appeal is dismissed']
+70907;['appeal is dismissed']
+127695;['appeals were dismissed']
+30377;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+28070;['appeal was dismissed']
+98686;['appeal is dismissed']
+102040;['appeal is allowed.the']
+86376;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+16757;['appeal isallowed']
+81615;['appeal is dismissed']
+142067;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125366;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is excluded']
+78190;['appeal is allowed']
+121390;['appeal is allowed']
+89933;['decision of the visa officer is not valid']
+124315;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+111326;['appeal is dismissed']
+123023;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+122360;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150618;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70902;['appeal is allowed']
+95730;['appeal is allowed']
+151943;['appeals are dismissed']
+98653;['appeal is dismissed']
+80505;['appeal is terminated']
+95114;['appeal is dismissed']
+54204;['appeal is dismissed']
+62437;['appeal of tajinder singh minhas is allowed']
+87217;['negative']
+96004;['claimant’s claim for protection fails']
+59401;['appeal is allowed']
+143572;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+84678;['appeal is allowed']
+77893;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+106136;['theappeal is allowed']
+125511;['appeal is allowed and returned']
+62449;['appellants are convention refugees']
+21373;['xxxxxxxxx is not a refugee']
+55193;['reject his claim']
+76411;['appeal isallowed']
+60701;['appellant has lost his permanent resident status']
+146879;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54167;['allows the appeal']
+146547;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+64310;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+147779;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+78015;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+93974;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+49978;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+107700;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+83390;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+53767;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+21416;['not a convention refugee']
+79931;['panel rejects her claim']
+13972;['appeal is dismissed']
+106469;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis excluded from the application of the convention']
+68905;['appeal is dismissed']
+56894;['appeal isallowed']
+107502;['appeal is allowed']
+88145;['appeal is allowed']
+37897;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+59916;['rad dismissed the appeal']
+100358;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+63739;['appeal is allowed']
+78746;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+107610;['appeal is allowed']
+101837;['appeal is allowed']
+101689;['appeal is allowed']
+81235;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100048;['appeal were dismissed']
+71447;['appeal is allowed']
+99662;['302 (c.a.)']
+98661;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94318;['appeal is dismissed']
+111321;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+60408;['rad dismissed the appeal for lack of perfection']
+140731;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125143;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+63758;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+67719;['appeal is allowed.the']
+57041;['appeal is dismissed']
+113278;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+144956;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+118122;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+60909;['appeal is allowed', 'refusal set aside']
+75570;['appeal is dismissed']
+40798;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+32135;['appeal of the appellants is dismissed']
+31428;['appeal is dismissed']
+91456;['302 (c.a.)']
+98978;['appeal is dismissed']
+92178;['appeal is dismissed']
+78015;['appeal is dismissed']
+110680;['appeal is dismissed']
+140925;['appeal is allowed']
+150615;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+71555;['appeal is allowed']
+81852;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95108;['302 (c.a.']
+61227;['appeal is terminated']
+42000;['appeal is dismissed']
+107178;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130709;['appeal is allowed']
+142988;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+122858;['appeal against the rpd’s decision about bisexuality is dismissed']
+24247;['appeal is allowed']
+54262;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+99058;['appeal is dismissed']
+84367;['appeal is allowed']
+147777;['appellants are not convention refugees, or persons in need of protection']
+105239;['appeals are allowed']
+52043;['appeal is allowed']
+70090;['appeal is allowed']
+92338;['you are a convention refugee']
+71806;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+97810;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+95956;['appeal is dismissed']
+129877;['negative decision is set aside']
+108451;['appeal is allowed']
+146643;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “conventionrefugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+141274;['appeal is allowed']
+61967;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+46066;['appeal is allowed in law']
+131529;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+75939;['appeal is dismissed']
+34166;['allow the appeal']
+97515;['negative']
+102910;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxand his wife,xxxx xxxx,are not “convention refugees”']
+47753;['appeal is allowed']
+96740;['the claim fails']
+87732;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+70072;['appeal isallowed']
+97900;['appeal is allowed']
+49070;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+139673;['appeal must fail']
+123977;['appeal is allowed']
+61933;['appeal is allowed']
+101484;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+84026;['appeals are allowed in law']
+65623;['appeal is dismissed']
+98727;['appeal is determined']
+101516;['claimants are neither convention refugees']
+105862;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+116210;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116130;['appeal is allowed']
+83169;['appeals in files mb1-06404 and mb3-03589 must be dismissed']
+23007;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+83711;['appeal is allowed']
+79456;['appeal must be dismissed']
+96571;['appeal is terminated']
+95101;['rad further finds the rpd’s finding in this regard is reasonable']
+26792;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+132416;['appeal is allowed']
+56492;['appeal of jasvir kaur rai is dismissed']
+72711;['appeal is allowed.the']
+144479;['appeal is allowed']
+90829;['appeal must bedismissed for lack of']
+73887;['application is granted']
+141236;['heis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100893;['appeal is allowed']
+67017;['appeal is allowed']
+122769;['appeal is allowed']
+76100;['appeal isallowed']
+82566;['appeal is terminated']
+50930;['appeal were dismissed']
+57304;['appeal is dismissed']
+52948;['appeal is allowed']
+120819;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+133406;['appeal is allowed']
+51907;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes a determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+113797;['appeal is dismissed']
+56864;['appeals are hereby dismissed']
+151829;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+49120;['appeal is dismissed']
+45416;['appeal is abandoned']
+99651;['302 (c.a.']
+66202;['appeal is terminated']
+136419;['appeal is dismissed']
+108903;['claims are rejected']
+23083;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+93700;['appeal is allowed']
+100270;['appeal is allowed']
+153731;['appeal is dismissed']
+72912;['appeal is allowed']
+89420;['302 (c.a.']
+96449;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+5145;['appeal is allowed']
+90670;['appeal isallowed']
+74173;['appeals should be dismissed']
+80073;['negative']
+17194;['appeal is dismissed']
+100622;['appeal is dismissed']
+113683;['appeal is allowed']
+64674;['appeal is allowed']
+106894;['appeal is allowed']
+86637;['appeal is allowed']
+90686;['stay of the removal order   is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+99282;['decision is therefore set aside']
+99190;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+84687;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+101432;['302 (c.a.']
+107835;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+93115;['302 (c.a.)']
+47567;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedpursuant']
+50355;['302 (c.a.']
+107692;['appeal should be dismissed']
+77910;['appeal is allowed']
+92778;['appeal isallowed']
+122694;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a person in need of protection']
+65697;['appeal fails']
+99728;['appeal of ayodele fatai salami is dismissed']
+151486;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71254;['appeal is dismissed']
+87712;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96661;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96385;['appeal is dismissed']
+116736;['appeal is dismissed']
+56824;['appeal, brought']
+87738;['claim has been rejected']
+47332;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80573;['appeal is dismissed']
+72851;['appeal must fail']
+38834;['appeal isallowed']
+91914;['appeal is allowed']
+57932;['appeal is dismissed']
+55201;['appeals are dismissed']
+96739;['appeal is abandoned']
+106410;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+45163;['appeal of komal sidhu is dismissed']
+35051;['appeal is allowed']
+94473;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+28163;['“… sponsor is applicant’s brother']
+95382;['rad directs the rpd to reassess the claim in its entirety']
+128276;['appeal fail']
+73219;['tribunal declares the appealabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+79929;['negative']
+142086;['panel rejects his claim']
+68423;['panel therefore allows the respondent’s request']
+84246;['appeal isallowed']
+85386;['appeal is allowed']
+36084;['appeal is allowed']
+30484;['appeal is allowed']
+88298;['appeal is determined']
+85948;['appeal isallowed']
+125659;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+84686;['appeal isallowed']
+74266;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+88503;['negative']
+90828;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+115213;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82211;['appeal is dismissed']
+45166;['allow his appeal']
+85384;['appeal is terminated']
+84770;['appeal isallowed']
+94202;['appeal is dismissed']
+138282;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+55005;['appeal must be dismissed']
+22856;['appellant has not lost their permanent resident status']
+102997;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91642;['appeal is allowed']
+26755;['sufficient compassionate or humanitarian considerations']
+99152;['dismiss the appeal']
+86473;['appeal is allowed']
+90482;['appeal isallowed']
+96713;['appeal is terminated']
+91924;"[""dismiss the appellant's application"", 'application is accordingly dismissed']"
+56876;['allow her appeal']
+121865;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+100564;['appeal is allowed']
+56809;['dismiss the present appeal']
+98250;['appeal is allowed']
+76511;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+152008;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+100847;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+50433;['appeal is dismissed']
+43708;['appeals are dismissed']
+98106;['panel rejects xxxxxxxxxxxx claim for refugee protection']
+131509;['appeal is not allowed']
+78549;['panel rejects these claims']
+128342;['appeal was allowed']
+89360;['appeal is terminated']
+140803;['appellant’s claim fails']
+143556;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+133687;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91527;['appeal isallowedand']
+26705;['appeal beallowed']
+125200;['302 (c.a.']
+87680;['appeal is dismissed']
+48225;['appeal should be dismissed']
+80001;['claim of xxxxxxxxxxis rejected']
+124456;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42081;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+43409;['appeal is dismissed']
+74820;['appeal isallowed']
+22767;['appeal is terminated']
+101262;['appeal is allowed']
+141311;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+21320;['appeal isdismissedand a departure order is issued']
+60004;['claimants to be persons in need of protection']
+85306;['stay ought not to be cancelled']
+60046;['negative']
+26771;['appeal of chayabahen sureshkumar patel made pursuant to paragraph 77(3)(a) of theimmigration actis dismissed']
+91229;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+152947;['rad finds that the', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+72917;['302 (c.a.']
+19386;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee']
+133719;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+102862;['claimant,kojo xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee', 'rejects his claim']
+53837;['appeal of bao wei zhang is dismissed']
+108755;['appeal is dismissed']
+49973;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+125148;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73192;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+73897;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+93221;['appeal is allowed']
+40054;['appeal of wendell pagalan radaza is dismissed']
+55883;['rad determines thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+124943;['appeal is allowed']
+151323;['302 (c.a.']
+4744;['dismiss the appeal']
+98782;['appeal is allowed']
+104471;['appeal is dismissed']
+83868;['rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+84728;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+106846;['appeal is dismissed']
+101531;['appeal isallowed']
+37407;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+69242;['appeal is dismissed']
+67616;['appeal should not be dismissed']
+151905;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+76378;['appeal is allowed']
+24472;['appeal is dismissed']
+87682;['appeal is dismissed']
+79927;['negative']
+129401;['appeal is without merit']
+17192;['appeal is dismissed']
+143542;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+108836;['claim is therefore rejected']
+90921;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+75990;['appeal is dismissed']
+74163;['appeals of the male appellant and minor appellant are dismissed']
+52533;['appeal is dismissed']
+27519;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+131169;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+30498;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88443;['302 (c.a.']
+151726;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+113282;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+22124;['appeal is allowed']
+111178;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+86145;['appeal of maria cecilia palmares ignacio is dismissed']
+99253;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68787;['appeal of mary jo trinidad pursuant to paragraphs 77(3)(a) and (b) of theactis dismissed']
+128789;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+72788;['appeal is dismissed']
+113803;['rad confirms that the appellant is excluded from the application of the conventionon']
+61491;['dismiss the appeal']
+113553;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+84554;['refusal is invalid in law']
+151515;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+80044;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+43735;['appeal is allowed']
+116787;['appeal is dismissed']
+20432;['appeals are allowed']
+103622;['claimant and her daughter are not convention refugees and could return to china']
+27237;['appeal isallowed']
+98466;['claimant is not a person in need or protection']
+61439;['claimantsxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+95938;['allow the appeal']
+17147;['appeal isallowed']
+133348;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98776;['appeal is also dismissed']
+111161;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57911;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+93611;['appeal is allowed']
+61219;['appeal is allowed']
+134229;['appeal is dismissed']
+89895;['appeal is allowed']
+96239;['appeal isallowed']
+60306;['dismiss this appeal']
+151426;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63700;['appeal of kin ming wan is dismissed']
+71694;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96701;['appeal is dismissed']
+141251;['appeal is dismissed']
+96994;['appeal is terminated']
+68717;['appeal is allowed']
+84306;['appeal is allowed']
+82571;['appeal is dismissed']
+100494;['allow the appeal']
+94548;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+79746;['appeal be allowed']
+129157;['appeals are allowed.the']
+98092;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+146866;['appeal is dismissed']
+71635;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law', 'appeal is dismissed']
+121946;['appeal is allowed']
+95654;['appeal isallowed']
+89841;['appeal terminated']
+71084;['negative']
+80509;['appeal is   ']
+79214;['appeal is terminated']
+63065;['appeal is allowed']
+80069;['appeal is dismissed']
+97881;['302 (c.a.)']
+73873;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee oraperson in need of protection']
+88429;['neither convention refugees norpersons in need of protection']
+71357;['appeal is allowed']
+52072;['appeal is terminated']
+74873;['302 (c.a.)']
+73301;['302 (c.a.']
+44742;['appeal is determinedto']
+124994;['rad substitutes the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a person in need of protection']
+123652;['appeal is allowed']
+76939;['appeal isallowed']
+89078;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+110271;['pc is therefore excluded from refugee protection']
+95858;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+47578;['appeal of isaac kwame domson is dismissed']
+128893;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is excluded under article 1e of the refugee convention', 'not be a person in need of protection']
+37905;['appeal is allowed']
+52678;['302 (c.a.']
+36112;['appeal is allowed']
+110721;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+153161;['appeal is dismissed']
+91152;['decision of the visa officer is valid']
+109042;['appeal is allowed']
+148867;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+105872;['rad sets aside the determination\xa0 of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+124707;['substitute my finding']
+104287;['appeal is dismissed']
+142799;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80663;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+59726;['dismissing the appeal of faa']
+91772;['appeal is allowed']
+140906;['rpd’s decision must be upheld']
+69494;['allows this appeal']
+80156;['302 (c.a.']
+80454;['appeal is dismissed']
+98375;['appeal is dismissed']
+89414;['appeal is dismissed']
+93307;['appeal is dismissed']
+85960;['appeal isallowed']
+133367;['appeal is allowed']
+152926;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30488;['appeal for the applicants is allowed']
+113617;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+147450;['rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+76754;['appeal isallowed.the']
+89801;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+88098;['appeal is allowed']
+28068;['appeal is dismissed']
+104459;['appeal isallowed']
+93548;['appeal is dismissed']
+122096;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+26762;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+151935;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+108697;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132430;['302 (c.a.']
+102574;['appeal is allowed']
+105175;['appeal is dismissed']
+97526;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+65699;['appeal isallowed']
+131231;['appeal were dismissed']
+53853;['appeal is allowed']
+60486;['appeal isallowed']
+16446;['appeal must be allowed']
+99966;['appeal is dismissed']
+142996;['negative determination of the appellants’ refugee claims']
+98260;['application to reopen the claims of xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+139887;['appeal is dismissed']
+93697;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+70948;['negative']
+72654;['decisions of the immigration officer are valid in law']
+93625;['appeal is allowed']
+98118;['appeal is dismissed']
+71717;['appeal is allowed']
+87940;['appeal is dismissed']
+17188;['appeal is allowed']
+110926;['dismissing an appeal']
+19146;['appeal is dismissed']
+113783;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+56723;['appeal isallowed']
+19304;['appeal cannot succeed']
+38390;['appeal is dismissed']
+144396;['appeal is allowed']
+47789;['appeal isallowed']
+108060;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98347;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+109143;['302 (c.a.']
+124987;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+151919;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+151949;['appeal is allowed']
+111008;['rad concurs with the rpd’s analysis of this claim']
+124119;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+60013;['claimant not to be a person in need of protection']
+136697;['appeal is allowed']
+85376;['appeal is dismissed']
+100767;['appeals of ji heui jung (appellant 1) and ji yeong lim (appellant 2)']
+98871;['dismiss the appeal']
+52059;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+129173;['appeal be dismissed']
+61050;['appeal is dismissed']
+133372;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant is a convention refugee']
+130919;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+152039;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54736;['appeal is dismissed']
+49064;['appeal is dismissed']
+110905;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94351;['allowed his appeal']
+73185;['appeal is allowed']
+91251;['appeal was legitimately withdrawn']
+52285;['appeal is allowed']
+108805;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108755;['rad (refugee appeal division) confirms the decision of the rpd']
+95825;['appeal isallowed']
+143477;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+124314;['appellant is not aconventionrefugee or a person in need of protection']
+105621;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+128154;['appeal is allowed']
+22392;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+95469;['appeal is dismissed']
+128861;['appeals are allowed']
+99648;['appeal isallowed']
+77635;['appeal isallowed']
+35908;['officer’s decision is well-founded in law']
+11740;['appeal is allowed']
+34927;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81868;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+140742;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99783;['refugee protection claimant']
+63983;['officer’s decision to']
+74550;['appeal is allowed']
+56709;['appeal is dismissed']
+60971;['appeals are allowed']
+131228;['appeal be allowed or dismissed']
+123775;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+46018;['appeal is allowed']
+91417;['appeal filed by onyinye okorafo is dismissed']
+82578;['appeal is governed by theact']
+139460;['appeal is allowed']
+114404;['claim ought to be dismissed']
+15575;['adoption proceeded as a domestic adoption.']
+80692;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+92484;['appeal isallowed']
+40158;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+123462;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92481;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95926;['appeal is denied']
+88034;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects the claim']
+152945;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69181;['appeal should be dismissed']
+68368;['dismiss the appeal']
+96838;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+71253;['appeal of amar nath is dismissed']
+118095;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+121398;['appeal is allowed']
+82713;['appeal isallowed']
+71072;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+74168;['appeal is allowed']
+10990;['appeal must fail']
+52727;['panel rejects the claim of xxxxxxxxxxxxxx to refugee protection']
+101520;['claimants have not been persecuted while']
+76481;['appeal is allowed']
+142888;['appeal is denied']
+82688;['appeal isallowed']
+128668;['substitute my own determination that the principal appellant is a convention refugee']
+146857;['appeal was dismissed']
+123692;['appeal is allowed']
+65620;['appeal is allowed']
+144003;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134803;['appellant is not a refugee nor a protected person']
+107840;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination of this claim']
+123025;['appeal is allowed']
+26767;['appeal pursuant to section 77(3)(b) of theactis dismissed']
+138844;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52765;['dismiss the appeal']
+26808;['appeal of pritam singh chahil is dismissed']
+47372;['appeal is allowed']
+89432;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+101665;['visa officer’s refusal will be set aside']
+98821;['appeal is dismissed']
+149488;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+132303;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd’s determination is correct']
+135108;['appeal is allowed']
+63763;['appeal is dismissed']
+98693;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+88525;['negative']
+101208;['appeal isallowed']
+80681;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+34099;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77886;['appeal is dismissed']
+110911;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+88091;['302 (c.a.']
+24500;['appeal is dismissed']
+101344;['appeal is allowed']
+86953;['appeal is allowed']
+102696;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+134162;['appeal were dismissed']
+132746;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+107326;['claimant is not a convention refugee,']
+87219;['panel rejects the claimant’s claim for refugee protection']
+80382;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+70160;['appeal is allowed']
+129172;['appeal is not allowed']
+64674;['appeal is allowed']
+108803;['appeal is dismissed']
+52758;['appeal is allowed']
+125400;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45225;['application is granted']
+60824;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+69812;['appeal is allowed']
+98072;['appeal is dismissed']
+96595;['appeal is allowed']
+74831;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+60979;['appeal is allowed']
+97626;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+21373;"['claimant, xxxxxxxxxx, is not a ""convention refugee']"
+124016;['appeal is dismissed']
+101335;['appeal is terminated']
+116863;['appeal be dismissed']
+148640;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+151586;['appeal is allowed']
+132428;['302 (c.a.']
+87519;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107055;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+99126;['appeal is determined']
+17163;['appeal is dismissed']
+99806;['appeal is allowed']
+99261;['panel rejects the refugee protection claims']
+51691;['appeal is dismissed']
+126408;['appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+97481;['application to extend the time to file the notice of appeal is dismissed']
+100043;['removal order is set aside']
+89549;['appeal is terminated']
+124445;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76318;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+139424;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124134;['rpd’s decision is upheld']
+151333;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+153983;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+88160;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+72615;['appeal is allowed']
+18002;['appeal is allowed']
+143461;['refugee protection division determines that xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are also not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+96013;['application to reopen is denied']
+67012;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+101514;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+63988;['appeal is abandoned']
+128876;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142969;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124686;['dismiss the appeal']
+77775;['appeal is dismissed']
+47100;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+46000;['appeal isallowed.the']
+95959;['appellant was not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+144419;['claimants are not convention refugees,']
+50528;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+100965;['claimant is not a convention refugee and could return to china']
+98800;['appeal were dismissed']
+89322;['appeal is dismissed']
+107658;['appeal must fail']
+61060;['appeal is dismissed']
+153158;['appeal is allowed']
+68100;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+139807;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+1259;['appellant is not a protected person']
+102972;['appeal is allowed']
+34927;['application for an oral hearing is dismissed']
+31429;['appeal isallowed']
+57527;['removal orders are set aside']
+82675;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+124117;['302 (c.a.']
+52697;['refugee division finds xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx to be convention refugees']
+86458;['appeal is dismissed']
+132802;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69387;['appeal is dismissed']
+90951;['appeal is dismissed']
+114317;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+47587;['appeal is allowed']
+110568;"[""rad concurs with the panel's finding in this regard""]"
+77079;['appeal is allowed']
+78130;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects the claim of xxxxx xxxxx']
+58186;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+86013;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+103535;['appeal is dismissed']
+68689;['appeal is dismissed']
+86144;['appeal is dismissed']
+107873;['rejects the claim for protection of the respondent']
+76929;['appeal has been abandoned']
+49173;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+99790;['not a convention refugee']
+87444;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87830;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+93142;['appeal is allowed']
+76166;['negative']
+110272;['claimants, mr.xxxx xxxx, ms.xxxx xxxxand ms.xxxx xxxx, are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+92547;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+94206;['appeal is dismissed']
+96613;['neither a convention refugee nora person in need of protection']
+107459;['rad finds the decision of the rpd to be wrong in law']
+112387;['appeal is allowed']
+82052;['appeal is allowed']
+85244;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+98690;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+106794;['appeal isallowed']
+81350;['appeal is dismissed']
+92853;['allows the appeal of iness\xa0arif']
+143461;['refugee protection division rejects the claimants’ claims for refugee protection']
+24495;['allows the appeal']
+69735;['appeal isallowed']
+16823;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is he a “person in need of protection']
+132421;['appeal is dismissed']
+110951;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+73253;['appeal is dismissed']
+87331;['terminate the appeal']
+88261;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+13975;['appeal isallowed']
+95056;['appeal is allowed']
+14686;['claimant, ms. xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+143862;['appeal is dismissed']
+52291;['appeal can not survive his death']
+128154;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90047;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+133744;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84797;['appeal is dismissed']
+103542;['appeal is allowed']
+131033;['appeal is dismissed']
+51677;['appeal is dismissed']
+60210;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+122628;['rad allows the appeal']
+135492;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+132390;['appeal is dismissed']
+44181;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+110920;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+125526;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98803;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+106795;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+106856;['appeal of bernard militala is dismissed']
+82996;['appeal is dismissed']
+149060;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69075;['appeal is governed by theact']
+98523;['appeal has not been abandoned']
+49138;['appeal is allowed']
+80723;['302 (c.a.']
+124364;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+121458;['appeal is terminated']
+80551;['appeal isallowed']
+84014;['appeal is dismissed']
+75653;['decision of the id is set aside']
+109301;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151613;['appeal is allowed']
+90093;['his claim fails']
+75893;['appeal has been abandoned']
+57784;['appeal isallowedand']
+147458;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of   ']
+146841;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+55978;['appeal is terminated']
+143479;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63946;['appeal is allowed']
+123865;['appeal is allowed']
+129105;['iad does not have jurisdiction']
+141042;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107173;['rad agrees with these findings']
+75243;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects the refugee protection claim']
+151347;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+133407;['appeal isallowed']
+83930;['appeal is dismissed']
+68090;['appeal is allowed']
+46024;['allows the appeal\xa0\xa0 in law']
+78335;['appeal be and is hereby dismissed']
+110712;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98896;['302 (c.a.']
+96367;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+87444;['removal order isset aside']
+67047;['appeal will fail']
+94246;['appeal is allowed']
+61343;['302 (c.a.']
+91703;['appeal is allowed']
+72860;['appeal must be dismissed']
+77328;['appeal is allowed']
+122994;['302 (c.a.']
+96199;['appeal allowed']
+57932;['appeal is dismissed']
+5588;['appeal is determined']
+142089;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+54730;['theappealis dismissed']
+96859;['dismiss the appeal']
+104529;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+71626;['appeal isallowed']
+113543;['appeal be dismissed']
+106819;['appeal isdismissed.']
+80824;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+91588;['appeal isallowed']
+52934;['appeal is allowed']
+54812;['appeal is allowed.pursuant']
+69334;['appeal isallowed']
+36095;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101178;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67242;['appeal must be dismissed']
+84531;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96283;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+147458;['claim is dismissed']
+98968;['appeal is deemed to have been reopened']
+82233;['appeal is dismissed']
+92473;['appeal is dismissed']
+55188;['allow the appeal']
+71430;['appeal is allowed']
+105344;['appeal is dismissed']
+46997;['appeal isallowed.the']
+90994;['appeal is dismissed']
+68706;['appeal is allowed']
+84177;['appeal was dismissed']
+91559;['appeal of xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+76655;['appeal is allowed']
+105366;['appeal is dismissed']
+81421;['appeal is allowed']
+148751;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68736;['appeal is allowed']
+99186;['negative']
+124324;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+125087;['negative determination']
+77624;['appeal is allowed']
+38901;['dismisses this appeal']
+129233;['appeal is allowed']
+111107;['appellant is excluded', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+42380;['appeal is allowed']
+66258;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+76831;['appeal isallowed']
+68370;['appeal of the appellant, gurvinder singh uppal, is allowed']
+120824;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+93154;['appeal should be allowed']
+152595;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+83896;['appeal is terminated']
+96291;['negative']
+30385;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105220;['appeal is allowed']
+49564;['appeal is determined']
+42292;['removal order is set aside']
+47336;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law', 'appeal is allowed in law']
+143581;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84523;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+77624;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26691;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+97254;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+67028;['appeal is allowed']
+89296;['application to reinstate is allowed']
+132390;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+78086;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95177;['appeal is allowed']
+101059;['appeal is dismissed']
+95238;['appeal is allowed']
+87733;['negative']
+106851;['appeal is allowed']
+140629;['appeal is allowed']
+116345;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”']
+147009;['appeal is allowed']
+106839;['appeal is determined']
+138830;['appeals have been abandoned']
+123007;['appeal is allowed']
+87612;['appeal is allowed']
+99674;['appeal is dismissed']
+66630;['appeal is allowed']
+98064;['dismiss the appeal']
+94091;['appeal to be dismissed']
+76708;['appeal ofbelen bustriais dismissed in law']
+100365;['appeal isallowed']
+84780;['appeal is dismissed']
+91221;['appeal is allowed']
+71384;['appeal is dismissed']
+99071;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+94584;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+132314;['appeal is allowed']
+136699;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54200;['theappeal is allowed']
+94216;['appeal of yong hua shi is dismissed']
+125117;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68095;['decision of the id member is set aside']
+90852;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98555;['allow the appeal']
+134177;['appeal is dismissed']
+80749;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+140806;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+99535;['appeal is allowed']
+99282;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+14658;['claimant, xxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+90125;['nor a risk or danger']
+100986;['appeal is allowed']
+142980;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+87501;['appeal is allowed']
+87348;['appeal is dismissed']
+39054;['appeal were dismissed']
+67375;['claim has been rejected']
+151348;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+113596;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+79610;['allows this appeal']
+151890;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+78077;['appeal is governed by theact']
+127704;['appeal is allowed']
+72209;['allow his appeal']
+99779;['appeal is dismissed']
+135169;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143535;['first rad decision does not form part of the rpd record']
+96885;['appeal ofhien chac lamis allowed']
+147467;['dismiss the appeal', 'reject the refugee protection claim']
+122927;['appeal is dismissed']
+45400;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+69808;['appeal is dismissed']
+71053;['302 (c.a.']
+141271;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124593;['appeal is allowed']
+76713;['appeal is allowed']
+85450;['dismissed the appeal']
+100894;['appeal is dismissed']
+7587;['dismiss the appeal']
+142979;['appeal is dismissed']
+59860;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+88022;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+125580;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52925;['appeal may be dismissed']
+40517;['appeal is dismissed']
+100079;['appeal is dismissed']
+94767;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+83551;['appeal is dismissed']
+142529;['appeal is allowed']
+68924;['appeal is allowed']
+56714;['appeal isdismissed']
+21404;['xxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+57296;['appeal is dismissed']
+107949;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86315;['appeal is dismissed']
+123775;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+68179;['appeal is allowed']
+96680;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd']
+118183;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101412;['appeal isallowed']
+90711;['appeal is allowed']
+123991;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+101758;['appeal is allowed.the']
+98476;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+151833;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89584;['appeal is terminated']
+97858;['dismiss the present appeal']
+99265;['negative']
+52204;['appeal is dismissed']
+108069;['rad substitutes its own decision for that of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+113559;['appeal is allowed']
+132868;['appeal is allowed.the']
+60062;['appeal isallowed']
+69770;['appeal isallowed']
+73189;['visa officer’s decision is confirmed', 'theappeal is dismissed']
+107330;['dismisses the appeal']
+73344;['appeal is dismissed']
+122917;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+64689;['appeal is dismissed']
+17980;['appeal is allowed']
+151740;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94253;['rad has found that the rpd decision can stand it will not be disturbed']
+99391;['claimant, xxxx xxxx,not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+52135;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+15578;['appeal is allowed']
+14692;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+97642;['panel rejects his claim for protection']
+23067;['appeal is allowed']
+77840;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+150611;['rad cannot confirm or set aside the rpd’s determination']
+95116;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+96156;['appeal is dismissed']
+43389;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+56631;['appeal were dismissed']
+94147;['appeal is allowed']
+108054;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+85433;['dismissal of the appeal']
+46099;['appeal is dismissed']
+66764;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67696;['appeal is dismissed']
+85515;['dismiss the appeal']
+87432;['appeal is granted']
+100266;['claimants are claiming protection']
+99094;['appeal is allowed']
+91946;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+81242;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+107605;['appeal is dismissed']
+97649;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+100841;['claim is rejected']
+20000;['departure order is set aside']
+140712;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”']
+27293;['appeal being allowed']
+102121;['appeal is allowed']
+78171;['reject his claim for refugee protection']
+80373;['appeal is not dismissed']
+76023;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+146931;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+64243;['appeal be allowed']
+107128;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+91239;['appeal is allowed']
+82167;['not find it is a compelling enough factor']
+141283;['302 (c.a.']
+129222;['appeal fails']
+138832;['removal order is set aside']
+62838;['panel finds that the order is legal']
+69943;['appeal is allowed']
+72021;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+124065;['appeal is allowed']
+72636;['appeal is allowed']
+98644;['claimant, xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his claim']
+69101;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+93739;['decision is rendered in favour of the person concerned']
+90028;['appeal is not allowed']
+121860;['appeal is allowed']
+81184;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+91657;['appeal is dismissed']
+98143;['appeal is allowed']
+100472;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+52307;['appeal is dismissed']
+89254;['appeal is allowed']
+76260;['appeal is dismissed']
+140802;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+94527;['appeal is allowed']
+34932;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+95340;['appeal is allowed']
+99142;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+82884;['appeal is allowed.the']
+98753;['302 (c.a.']
+89206;['302 (c.a.']
+151407;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69696;['appeal should be dismissed']
+144558;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77182;['appeal is dismissed']
+71082;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+87210;['appeal is allowed']
+98879;['appeal is allowed']
+114326;['appeal is allowed']
+94033;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+93232;['appeals in files\xa0mb3-01025 and mb6-05632 are dismissed']
+105367;['appeal is dismissed']
+145036;['302 (c.a.']
+124822;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+73256;['decision of the immigration division is set aside.the']
+138837;['appeal abandoned']
+74458;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law', 'appeal is dismissed']
+86848;['allows this appeal']
+50478;['application to reopen the claims']
+122098;['appeal is allowed']
+90947;['appeal is terminated']
+143842;['appeal is allowed']
+97274;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim']
+124182;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from international protection']
+92972;['appeal is allowed']
+84551;['appeal is allowed']
+105871;['rad finds that they are not “persons in need of protection']
+61649;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+95985;['appeals are dismissed']
+142078;['claim is dismissed']
+19133;['appeal is allowed']
+76349;['appeal is dismissed']
+117205;['confirme la décision']
+57781;['appeal isallowedand']
+87425;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67699;['appeal be dismissed']
+139809;['appeal is dismissed']
+90234;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+86940;['appeals are dismissed']
+124734;['302 (c.a.']
+77929;['appeal of li chang wu is allowed']
+108247;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113566;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+151341;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131528;['removal order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99328;['appeal is dismissed']
+97982;['appeal be dismissed']
+88494;['claim therefore fails']
+71708;['allow his appeal.']
+118633;['visa officer’s decision was valid in law']
+97288;['refugee protection division rejects the claimants’ claims for refugee protection']
+89409;['appeal is dismissed']
+122532;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+108839;['appeal is dismissed']
+69808;['appeal is dismissed']
+103225;['claimant, xxxx\xa0xxxxxxxx\xa0xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+152134;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95319;['appeal is dismissed']
+66258;['appeal is dismissed']
+17932;['appeal is allowed']
+96950;['appeal is dismissed']
+141247;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+72616;['appeal isallowed']
+99230;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71487;['appeal isallowed']
+117124;['removal order is set aside']
+92028;['appeal is allowed']
+14689;['appeal beallowed']
+74689;['appeal is dismissed']
+151630;['appeal is dismissed']
+34703;['appeal is dismissed']
+78162;['appeal is terminated']
+56982;['application to exclude the transcript and reasons for decision of the previous panel is dismissed']
+124805;['appeal is allowed']
+99814;['appeal of jason hoang is dismissed']
+50494;['appeal is dismissed']
+90616;['appeal is dismissed']
+104342;['appeal is allowed']
+95101;['appeal is denied']
+48621;['302 (c.a.']
+30507;['appeal isallowed']
+122916;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+99624;['appeal is allowed']
+102978;['appeal is allowed']
+56781;['claimant is a convention refugee or a person in need of refugee protection']
+92807;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+103809;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+61437;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123978;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+97127;['appeal is allowed']
+137447;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+91726;['appeal were dismissed']
+148647;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+68123;['appeal is allowed']
+125391;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+77997;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100645;['appeal is brought']
+99907;['appeal is dismissed']
+151458;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52485;['dismiss this appeal']
+123328;['appeal is dismissed']
+130769;['appeal is allowed']
+142994;['refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92516;['appeal is allowed']
+99330;"[""rad sets aside and substitutes the rpd's determination""]"
+107216;['appeal is dismissed']
+123741;['appeal is dismissed']
+102468;['appeal is dismissed']
+80039;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+95135;['appeal of dupinder singh kahlon is dismissed']
+107918;['appeal is dismissed']
+109041;['appeal is allowed']
+100530;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+52592;['thatxxxxxxx xxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+150630;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxareneither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99793;['appeal is dismissed']
+146015;['claimant’s to be convention refugees']
+104353;['appeal of sarabjit kaur uppal is dismissed']
+53828;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+60979;['allow the appeal']
+101713;['appeal be allowed']
+89363;['appeal is terminated']
+81086;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+77963;['appeal is allowed']
+92756;['appeal isallowed']
+60502;['appeal of ali ahmad bhatti is dismissed']
+40111;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+84855;['appeal is dismissed']
+128335;['appeal is allowed']
+141663;['appeal is allowed']
+83833;['appeal is allowed']
+108834;['dismisses the appeal']
+127457;['appeals are dismissed']
+80039;['xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+105351;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87992;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+73360;['appeal is allowed']
+101866;['determination is valid in law']
+90660;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+61045;['appeal from the refusal is therefore allowed']
+106789;['appeal is allowed']
+96309;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxneither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69359;['appeal is dismissed']
+114325;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+52483;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90743;['set aside the negative determination', 'substitute it with the determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+123334;['appeal is allowed']
+125096;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+117191;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+98763;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+120711;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'deny this appeal.xxxx']
+63754;['dismiss the appeal']
+134298;['appeals are allowed', 'removalorders are set aside']
+110997;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80364;['appeal isallowed']
+56755;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+116760;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104396;['appeal is allowed']
+96956;['appeal is terminated']
+108132;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+72661;['appeal is dismissed']
+124724;['appeal is dismissed']
+83452;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+134292;['appeal were dismissed']
+129876;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+95467;['appeal is dismissed']
+56914;['appeals are dismissed']
+100544;['appeal is allowed']
+123879;['panel sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision with a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+131032;['appeal is denied']
+107162;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+118639;['sponsor is not a sponsor within the meaning of theregulations.']
+29723;['appeal is allowed']
+65598;['appeal ofduc tuan nguyenis dismissed']
+106647;['refugee protection claims filed byxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare rejected']
+52337;['appeal was allowed']
+103001;['appellant is either a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+107047;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+145379;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89701;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+31217;['appeal is dismissed']
+14487;['appeal is dismissed']
+123116;['appellant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+102537;['appealis dismissed.the']
+129919;['appeal is allowed']
+69597;['appeal is allowed']
+61398;['appeal is allowed in law']
+13685;['appeal is dismissed']
+103051;['appeals are dismissed']
+63704;['appeal is dismissed']
+59827;['appeal isallowed']
+50458;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,andxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+59975;['negative']
+80556;['you are not a convention refugee', 'nor do i believe that you are a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim']
+121852;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither\xa0 convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+19147;['appeal is dismissed']
+97617;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+102063;['appeal is allowed']
+152780;['favourable decision is rendered']
+102074;['appeal is allowed']
+95550;['appeal is dismissed']
+70178;['appeal is allowed']
+77342;['dismissing the appeal']
+100130;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+77667;['appeal is allowed']
+148622;['application by minister’s counsel is denied']
+89757;['negative']
+91540;['dismissing the appeal']
+67590;['appeal is dismissed']
+96762;['appeal isallowed']
+110566;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87862;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96626;['negative']
+76368;['appeal is dismissed']
+111296;['appeal is allowed']
+100316;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+77919;['appeal is allowed']
+71185;['appeal is allowed']
+35069;['appeal is dismissed']
+140726;['appeal is allowed']
+78298;['appeal isallowed']
+26919;['not a convention refugee']
+140954;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are excluded under article\xa01e of the convention']
+95447;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+141248;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67699;['dismiss the appeal of kulwinder kaur samra']
+86149;['appeal is terminated']
+116754;['they are therefore not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+113291;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107702;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+82646;['appeal is terminated']
+56936;['appeal is allowed']
+149475;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102390;['appeals are dismissed']
+59815;['302 (c.a.']
+96840;['dismissal of this appeal']
+90624;['302 (c.a.']
+143905;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+71285;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+144937;['302 (c.a.']
+52068;['allow this appeal']
+96473;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68334;['appeal is allowed']
+125007;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107880;['dismiss this appeal']
+123544;['302 (c.a.']
+77699;['appeal isallowed.the']
+92740;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90097;['panel rejectsxxxx xxxxclaim for refugee protection']
+129922;['appeal is dismissed']
+70034;['appeal bedismissed.']
+72555;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95293;['appeal is dismissed']
+120825;['rpd decision is set aside']
+153286;['neither convention refugee nor persons in need of protection']
+45394;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+60822;['appeal isallowed']
+88518;['claimant is excluded from all three protection grounds']
+89077;['appeal is not allowed']
+68582;['appeal must be dismissed']
+61227;['appeal is terminated']
+110914;['appeal is dismissed']
+94359;['appeal is dismissed']
+85374;['appeal is dismissed']
+91197;['appeal isallowed']
+131273;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92469;['appeal is dismissed']
+34157;['appeal is allowed']
+125590;['decision cannot stand']
+67497;['appeal isallowed']
+79336;['appeal is allowed']
+76836;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+121257;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+27304;['appeal is dismissed']
+84666;['application to extend the time to file the notice of appeal is dismissed']
+104052;['appeal cannot succeed']
+87728;['claimants are convention refugees']
+140296;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+103638;['dismiss this appeal']
+90076;['dismisses this appeal']
+125614;['appeal is dismissed']
+68211;['appeal is also allowed']
+35720;['appeal isallowed']
+86842;['302 (c.a.)']
+54226;['appeal beallowed.the']
+47407;['appeal of bella poisson is dismissed']
+47304;['appeal is allowed']
+64269;['appeal is allowed']
+22740;['appeal is allowed']
+102929;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+69197;['appeal is allowed']
+95687;['reject their claims for refugee protection']
+63191;['appeal is dismissed']
+110313;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70664;['claimants have not established a well-founded fear of persecution']
+60441;['dismiss the appeal']
+147455;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+82901;['appeal is allowed']
+87826;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+101341;['appeal is allowed or dismissed']
+89220;['appeal is allowed']
+31265;['appeals are dismissed']
+33081;['appeal is dismissed']
+69498;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+71400;['appeal is dismissed']
+94752;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+134226;['appeal is allowed']
+96473;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60032;['negative']
+61233;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+65672;['appeal is allowed']
+72903;['iad dismissed the appellant’s appeal']
+80279;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+87313;['302 (c.a.']
+57540;['appeal is allowed']
+88068;['appeal is dismissed']
+45243;['appeal of herbert goldhawk is dismissed']
+116743;['appeal is dismissed']
+153730;['allow the appeal']
+39917;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+29689;['appeal is allowed']
+116853;['appeal is allowed']
+100054;['iad’s decision was set aside']
+54211;['appeal of the departure order should be dismissed']
+91340;['appeal is dismissed']
+146939;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+87850;['dismiss the appeal']
+92245;['appeal isallowed']
+52357;['appeal isallowed']
+98396;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97412;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+99134;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+71221;['appeal is allowed']
+16814;['appeal is dismissed']
+109624;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101904;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+109613;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+35918;['appeal is allowed']
+99459;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+101190;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+120773;['not stand']
+59996;['panel rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+95488;['appeal is dismissed']
+96372;['appeals of tracy and arnold are dismissed']
+85673;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+89887;['“convention refugees']
+133401;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+108819;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+113801;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61324;['decision cannot stand']
+55120;['appeal is dismissed']
+148994;['appeal is allowed']
+72701;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+134418;['appeal is dismissed']
+151321;['claimant is neither a “conventionrefugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+115176;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+66483;['appeal is allowed in law']
+95491;['appeal is dismissed']
+85837;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+54745;['appeal is allowed']
+107253;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123940;['appeal is dismissed']
+93222;['appeal fails']
+100478;['nor on a balance of probabilities']
+81031;['appeal isallowed']
+95566;['appeal is dismissed']
+44035;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+55180;['appeal is dismissed']
+82990;['appeals are dismissed']
+98081;['negative']
+89269;['appeal is allowed']
+68722;['appeal is dismissed']
+94947;['appeal is dismissed']
+129900;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+70067;['appeal isallowed']
+34989;['302 (c.a.)']
+100296;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+150944;['appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+93781;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+109020;['appeal is dismissed']
+49897;['appeal of hammad yousuf khan is allowed']
+30519;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77237;['appeal should not be dismissed on its merits']
+52502;['appeal is allowed']
+107911;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+68337;['appeal will be dismissed']
+48599;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+22385;['appeal is dismissed']
+125470;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+72898;['appeal is dismissed']
+102082;['determination is valid in law']
+59140;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+143166;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142804;['rad sets aside the determination', 'substitutes a determination']
+96468;['appeal is rejected']
+123415;['appeal is allowed']
+96149;['appeal is allowed']
+68165;['appeal is allowed']
+89899;['appeal is dismissed']
+129532;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+47126;['immigration appeal division further orders the conditional deportation']
+36108;['appeal is allowed']
+91682;['appeal is not terminated']
+110915;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98421;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+151940;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60461;['appeal is terminated']
+63958;['appeal is dismissed']
+84603;['appeal is dismissed']
+129132;['appeal is allowed']
+84075;['appeal is allowed']
+145422;['appeal is dismissed']
+121484;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+148651;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77250;['appeal isallowed']
+151480;['appeal is allowed']
+96779;['negative']
+75963;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+99283;['appeal is allowed']
+74171;['appellants are convention refugees']
+50749;['appeal is allowed']
+81392;['appeal is dismissed']
+52293;['rad finds that the rpd erred in rejecting the appellant’s claim']
+50764;['appeal is allowed']
+106623;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+133343;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97629;['refugee protection division rejects her claim', 'claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+95311;['appeal isallowed']
+96009;['claimant is excluded from refugee protection']
+36569;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+77282;['appeal is dismissed']
+100727;['panel rejects the present claim for protection']
+131071;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+124421;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+78716;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+68902;['appeal isallowed']
+61007;['appeal is allowed']
+95154;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+85490;['appeal is allowed']
+100353;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+68534;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+62258;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+118521;['appeal is allowed']
+94029;['appeal is allowed']
+141228;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+142796;['appeal is allowed']
+50641;['appeal is allowed']
+26743;['appeal division makes no finding']
+44032;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113596;['appeal be dismissed']
+132348;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+146552;['refugee protection claimants are not convention refugees']
+120719;['not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99315;['appeal was dismissed']
+122860;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'find the appellant to be a convention refugee']
+13550;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96967;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+96771;['negative']
+101763;['appeal is allowed']
+84856;['appeal is allowed']
+71132;['appellant is not a person caught by']
+100512;['claims are rejected']
+130758;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+92712;['appeal isallowed']
+106131;['appeal be dismissed']
+95730;['appeal isallowed.the']
+107829;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60436;['appeal of joyce poku is dismissed']
+86838;['appeal is allowed']
+128294;['appeal of solace aiwanfo akade is allowed']
+93574;['appeal brought by the minister is allowed']
+134358;['appeal is based']
+94674;['appeal is allowed']
+99831;['appeal is allowed']
+52041;['appeal isallowed']
+96112;['claimant,xxxxxx xxxxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+61807;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+84666;['appeal’s relative merit']
+54306;['appeal is dismissed']
+144564;['leads me to find, on a balance of probabilities']
+26889;"['not a ""convention refugee']"
+106755;['appeal of larry nguyen is allowed']
+101309;['appeal is allowed']
+111176;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+77570;['removal order is set aside']
+99257;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+100066;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+43391;['302 (c.a.)']
+100797;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+70203;['appeal is governed by theact']
+98345;['appeal is allowed']
+43710;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+66649;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+69582;['appeal isallowed']
+79761;['appeal isallowed']
+143197;['appeal is allowed']
+103659;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+72906;['appeal is dismissed']
+111350;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+143649;['applicants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+76767;['appeal is dismissed']
+136746;['she is a convention refugee']
+49565;['appeal is allowed']
+102197;['appeal is denied']
+133371;['appeal is dismissed']
+141030;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84645;['appeal is dismissed']
+100587;['302 (c.a.)']
+57089;['appeal isallowed']
+98889;['appeal is allowed']
+65407;['appeal is dismissed']
+113730;['appeal is allowed']
+87100;['appeal is allowed']
+129885;['rpd’s negative determination is confirmed']
+111001;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91324;['dismissal of the appeal']
+107188;['appeal is dismissed']
+108827;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95830;['appeal is allowed']
+109292;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+150656;['dismiss the appeal']
+144408;['dismiss the appeal']
+90603;['appeal was dismissed']
+96482;['appeal isallowed']
+124677;['not recognize the appellant as a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96843;['appeal is based']
+49983;['removal order isset aside']
+87160;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+85924;['appeal is allowed']
+54794;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+90940;['allow this appeal']
+75984;['appeal is allowed.the']
+128901;['confirm its determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+128354;['appeal of natalia beatriz marcenaro is allowed']
+71726;['appeal is allowed']
+57575;['appeal ofalmaz beyene mebrhatuis dismissed']
+83833;['appeal is allowed']
+90678;['302 (c.a.']
+143873;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+99886;['appeal is dismissed']
+123762;['rad finds that it did']
+83248;['appeal is allowed']
+77677;['allow the appeal']
+123116;['appeal is dismissed']
+69760;['appeal ought to be dismissed']
+65016;['appeal is dismissed']
+95588;['appeal isallowedand']
+76162;['negative']
+125662;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+49123;['allow the appeal']
+108693;['appeal is allowed']
+111330;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+151759;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100967;['appeal isallowed']
+76788;['allows the appeal']
+102250;['appeals are dismissed']
+129110;['appeal is dismissed']
+61370;['appeal isdetermined to beabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+103105;['appeal is dismissed']
+69415;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+91453;['302 (c.a.)']
+101693;['appeals to be abandoned']
+95246;['appeal is dismissed']
+71664;['case is dismissed']
+93640;['302 (c.a.']
+69412;['appeal isallowed']
+127359;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+100630;['appeal isallowedand']
+64619;['appeal is dismissed']
+28704;['appeal is dismissed']
+99566;['appeal is dismissed']
+89827;['appeal isallowed']
+61417;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+82467;['appeal is governed by theact']
+39059;['appeal were dismissed']
+110959;['appeal is dismissed']
+90369;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+147443;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'appellants are persons referred to in article 1e of the convention']
+136713;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35400;['appeal is dismissed']
+95143;['negative']
+79324;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+42082;['appeal is dismissed']
+105374;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+27588;['appeal is dismissed']
+72643;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+92161;['appeal is dismissed']
+107026;['appeal be dismissed']
+71664;['appeal was dismissed']
+24511;['appeal is dismissed']
+103053;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+76261;['appeal is allowed']
+132662;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78174;['panel finds that the visa officer’s determination is valid in law and fact']
+86063;['rad finds that the appellant’s argument has some merit']
+97923;['appeal is allowed']
+116764;['appeal is allowed']
+74752;['appeal is allowed']
+99911;['appellants have not lost his permanent resident status']
+99676;['appeal isallowed']
+83918;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+121634;['rad disagrees']
+128338;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+123677;['allow this appeal']
+70033;['application to reopen']
+135188;['rpd’s negative determination', 'rad substitutes a positive determination']
+117112;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94511;['appeal is allowed.the']
+104732;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151589;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+93324;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107164;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97357;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+72907;['appeal isallowed']
+110290;['appeal is dismissed']
+110995;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+75136;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124617;['xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees']
+21342;['refugee division determines that xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+95909;['302 (c.a.']
+87697;['your claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+24777;['appeal is determined']
+90742;['appeal is terminated']
+91023;['appeal is dismissed']
+82272;['appeal is withdrawn']
+143594;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+65410;['appeal being allowed']
+68447;['appeal is allowed']
+80027;['panel rejects his claim']
+67567;['refusal is well founded in law']
+146849;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+150620;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77876;['appeal is allowed']
+76712;['application is dismissed']
+64622;['panel rejects the opinion of the miu']
+152048;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101152;['appeal is dismissed']
+147788;['appeals are allowed']
+136674;['appellant, xxxx xxxx, is not a refugee']
+10909;['allow the appeal']
+88145;['appeal is allowed']
+49389;['appeal is terminated']
+151780;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+93022;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+56743;['appeal is allowed']
+78644;['appeal isallowed.the']
+93161;['appeal is allowed']
+77340;['appeal is dismissed']
+54285;['appeal division orders that the appeals bedismissed.']
+109396;['rad has found that the rpd decision as it is cannot stand']
+146856;['appeal with respect to the principal appellant and the female associate appellant is allowed']
+94812;['appeal is dismissed']
+52698;['rejects her claim to be a protected person']
+77974;['appeal is terminated']
+100768;['appeal is allowed']
+48619;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision to the effect that they are not convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+96832;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70673;['negative']
+60941;['allowed his application']
+71445;['appeal is dismissed']
+74593;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+109172;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'upholds the rpd’s decision']
+113537;['dismisses the appeal']
+100968;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+143637;['rad allows the appeal']
+18010;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+146864;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+46052;['appeal is terminated']
+113781;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+92984;['stay of   the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+67453;['appeal is dismissed']
+107463;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+72573;['appeal isallowed']
+129168;['appeal isdismissed.']
+26978;['302 (c.a.)']
+99144;['allows the appeal']
+89301;['appeal is dismissed']
+87588;['thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+52695;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+30534;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+114314;['appeal is dismissed']
+54762;['appeal were dismissed']
+80462;['appeal is allowed']
+134734;['leads me to believe that the country’s general situation']
+34108;['rpd decision stands']
+148664;['removal order is set aside']
+95049;['appeal is dismissed']
+74881;['appeal is dismissed']
+31971;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+75998;['appeal is allowed']
+107200;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+89964;['appeal is dismissed']
+125603;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision', 'substitute a positive decision']
+40051;['appeal is allowed']
+114321;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+59830;['302 (c.a.']
+98806;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+148733;['not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+68229;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+47616;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+105778;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+106306;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+58819;['appeals are allowed']
+96573;['application is dismissed']
+141376;['appeal is allowed']
+58520;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88263;['confirm the determination']
+77845;['claimant was not dismissed']
+87014;['appeal be allowed']
+109700;['302 (c.a.']
+22764;['removal orders areset aside']
+124069;['rad therefore sees no reason to overturn the rpd’s conclusions']
+129121;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+102415;['leads me to conclude that it is not a genuine marriage']
+136161;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+129129;['appeal is allowed']
+115286;['appeal is allowedand']
+76451;['appeal is allowed']
+127699;['appeals are allowed']
+99037;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+48417;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+42283;['appeal is terminated']
+110967;['appeal is rejected']
+77230;['appeal isallowed']
+132792;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81782;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107022;['appeal is allowed']
+60459;['allow the appeal']
+75159;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+13419;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+99703;['appeal of john xuan lam is dismissed']
+75912;['appeal isallowed']
+67712;['appeal is allowed']
+84363;['allow the appeal']
+42220;['appeal be dismissed']
+27459;['appeal is determined']
+69936;['appeal is allowed']
+52672;['reject her claim']
+131913;['appeal is allowed']
+77975;['appeal is dismissed']
+81623;['appeal would be dismissed']
+68557;['appeal is allowed']
+96220;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+44184;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+133255;['appeal is dismissed']
+14713;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+70416;['appeal is dismissed']
+96004;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96450;['appeal isallowed']
+84328;['appeal is dismissed']
+134417;['appeal is dismissed']
+16817;['appeal is allowed']
+70651;['appeal must be dismissed']
+15004;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+86389;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+56755;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64866;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+144401;['rad concludes that the rpd’s determination is correct']
+115209;['appeal is allowed']
+59370;['children are not the adopted children of the']
+98747;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+105866;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+73368;['appeal isallowed']
+68272;['appeal is allowed']
+100636;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+94658;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+74788;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101532;['allow the appeal']
+61924;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+82793;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+72216;['appeal is dismissed']
+102121;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+19175;['appeals are dismissed']
+100448;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70067;['appeal is allowed']
+85599;['appeal is terminated']
+98321;['panel rejects this claim']
+71652;['appeal is dismissed']
+84216;['appeal isallowed']
+68334;['appeal isallowed']
+88416;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71236;['appeal is allowed']
+57573;['appeal is dismissed']
+152474;['appeal may be dismissed']
+124479;['appeal is allowed']
+145294;['302 (c.a.']
+94142;['appeal is dismissed']
+22848;['proceeding is dismissed']
+50502;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+87785;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+21933;['appeal dismissed']
+94523;['appeal is dismissed']
+131013;['removal order isset aside']
+70179;['appeal is allowed']
+123741;['appeal is dismissed']
+133191;['confirms the determination of the rpd']
+92692;['appeal is dismissed']
+46033;['appeal is terminated']
+128412;['appeal is dismissed']
+125018;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconvention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110319;['appeal is dismissed']
+76624;['visa officer’s decision is invalid in law']
+96113;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+65123;['dismissed the appeal']
+86527;['appeals are allowed.the']
+102575;['appeal is allowed']
+17190;['appeal is determined to have been abandoned']
+80041;['xxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95335;['appeal fails']
+129997;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+37824;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+147469;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76746;['appeal is dismissed']
+131149;['appeal is dismissed']
+111028;['appeal is allowed']
+70004;['appeal is allowed']
+128390;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+132738;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+67748;['appeal has been abandoned']
+87680;['dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+69461;['appeal is allowed']
+151882;['dismisses the appeal']
+91945;['302 (c.a.']
+100248;['appeal isallowed']
+23096;['appellants are not permanent residents']
+76537;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+79071;['appeal is dismissed']
+130857;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugees']
+93896;['appeal is allowed']
+72183;['appeal isallowed']
+106614;['rad upholds the rpd decision and rejects the appeal']
+140629;['appeal is allowed']
+46023;['appeal is dismissed']
+122640;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123382;['appeal is allowed']
+124033;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+92773;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92739;['appeals should be dismissed']
+61475;['appeal isallowed']
+91740;['appeal is allowed']
+59860;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+93192;['appeal isallowed']
+74067;['appeal was dismissed']
+89737;['appeal is allowed']
+60889;['appeal isallowedand']
+101038;['302 (c.a.']
+125354;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+129152;['appeal is dismissed']
+72019;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95147;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+85939;['appeal is allowed']
+88134;['appeal is allowed']
+28092;['appeal isallowed']
+47875;['removal order is set aside']
+64367;['appeal is allowed']
+98408;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95435;['appeal of yu hua cen is dismissed']
+54718;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+97867;['appeal is allowed']
+80576;['negative']
+98235;['appeal is dismissed']
+143554;['neither “convention refugees”']
+127731;['appeal is determined to be']
+107478;['appeal is dismissed']
+121485;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not “convention refugees”']
+135125;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'neither a “convention refugee”']
+103899;['302 (c.a.']
+51669;['sponsor ceases to be in breach of the obligation']
+75140;['appeal is declared to be abandoned']
+94450;['appeal is allowed']
+123466;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+95357;['appeal is dismissed']
+70956;['appeal of king fang yong is dismissed']
+151472;['appeal is allowed']
+122676;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66658;['appeal isallowed']
+37900;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100672;['removal order is set aside']
+122774;['rad finds that the majority of the rpd’s findings are in error']
+143557;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are excluded from the application of the convention']
+89214;['appeal isallowed']
+122229;['decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+120714;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+74892;['allow the appeal']
+52530;['decision of the visa officer is thus valid in law']
+95953;['appeal is dismissed']
+72712;['appeal will proceed to normal processing']
+91610;['refugee protection division therefore determines the claimant is not a convention refugee']
+89775;['dismiss both appeals']
+146436;['determination that the appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94588;['removal orders are set aside']
+97809;['claim is therefore rejected']
+89023;['claimant is not a person needing protection']
+96300;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+72679;['appeal is dismissed']
+121847;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+107827;['claim is therefore rejected']
+88105;['appeal isallowed']
+47715;['appeal is dismissed']
+102702;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122732;['appellant is not a person of interest']
+125534;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68925;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+111107;['confirm the rpd’s finding']
+19722;['appeal is dismissed']
+73050;['appeal isallowed']
+94024;['appeal of marcelle aurelio howlett is therefore dismissed']
+92737;['appeal isallowed']
+121530;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61465;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+97417;['reject his claim']
+122806;['appeal is allowed']
+123361;['appeal is dismissed']
+100815;['appellants have not their permanent resident status']
+83929;['appeal is dismissed']
+30390;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+96940;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+122923;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84237;['appeal isallowed']
+53838;['appeal is dismissed']
+95941;['appeal is allowed']
+102407;['appeal was dismissed']
+99408;['nor is she a person in need of protection']
+108758;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+76383;['appeal is allowed']
+63701;['appeal is dismissed']
+49160;['appeal isallowed']
+113258;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+34609;['appeal isallowed']
+95932;['rad finds that the rpd’s reasons are not justifiable, intelligible, and transparent']
+90081;['appeal is allowed']
+43398;['appeal is dismissed']
+98486;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+113279;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+77670;['appeal is allowed']
+77010;['302 (c.a.)']
+71074;['rejects his claim']
+86461;['appeal of avtonom nikolayevich kulikov is dismissed']
+109621;['decision contains material errors']
+105882;['appeal is dismissed']
+151897;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+142454;['appellants are convention refugees']
+69964;['appeal is allowed']
+83530;['appeal is dismissed']
+128355;['appeal is allowed']
+71636;['appeal isallowed']
+83506;['appeal is determined']
+143532;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,andxxxx xxxx xxxxare excluded']
+98373;['appeal dismissed']
+75138;['dismissal of this appeal']
+144394;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+71796;['302 (c.a.']
+12216;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101145;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+143902;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+36138;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+61926;['appeal is allowed to proceed']
+96313;['appeal isallowed']
+54638;['appeal is allowed.the']
+87170;['appeal is allowed']
+129873;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+82895;['appeal is allowed.the']
+146559;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+105850;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+122221;['appeal is allowed', 'appellant is a person in need of protection']
+135202;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+101170;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+139859;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+74988;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+52509;['appeal is allowed']
+60490;['appeal is terminated']
+99971;['negative']
+101017;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97601;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+100577;['appeal is dismissed']
+95771;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+123862;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26521;['dismiss the appeal']
+121442;['refugee appeal division dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+36083;['undertaking is no longer in effect']
+105712;['neither a “convention refugee”']
+105891;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+110928;['appeal is dismissed']
+124812;['refuses the minister’s application']
+100682;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+52509;['appeal is allowed']
+80680;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of   ', 'rejects her claim']
+124012;['appeal are without merit']
+5148;['exclusion orders areset aside']
+57820;['appeal is allowed']
+70180;['appeal is allowed']
+95400;['appeal is dismissed']
+69788;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+69836;['appeal is dismissed']
+98547;['negative']
+112790;['appeal to be reopened']
+23043;['appeal must be dismissed']
+74465;['appeal is dismissed']
+90927;['appeal is dismissed']
+47367;['appeal is dismissed']
+76762;['appeal has been abandoned']
+43338;['appeal is allowed']
+95510;['exclusion order is set aside']
+97341;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+19227;['application is allowed']
+46101;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+38247;['appeal isallowed.the']
+71234;['dismiss the appeal']
+100212;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+140722;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+151727;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+136722;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+30491;['appeal is dismissed']
+38833;['appeal is allowed']
+90219;['appeal is terminated']
+85836;['appeal is governed by theact']
+97260;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+96626;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89433;['appeal is dismissed']
+81636;['appeal is dismissed']
+143591;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90792;['appeal is allowed']
+78720;['appeal of alganesh haileslassie is dismissed']
+94149;['appeal is dismissed']
+47873;['appeal is dismissed']
+100626;['appeal isallowedand']
+45161;['allow the appeal of harjinder singh mandla']
+71494;['appeal isallowed']
+94970;['appeal is terminated']
+95291;['appeal is dismissed']
+55188;['appeal was dismissed']
+92184;['appeal is dismissed']
+9486;['appeal isallowed.the']
+92101;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+26833;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugeeas']
+145027;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+83707;['appeal of harkamal singh chohan is allowed']
+129241;['appeal be allowed']
+62717;['appeal isallowed']
+71075;['the claim fails']
+68552;['claimantis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+74048;['appeal is allowed']
+91743;['appeal is allowed']
+60956;['appeal be dismissed']
+98087;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+92547;['panel finds that the removal orders are valid in law']
+93298;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your removal from canada']
+121881;['appeal is allowed']
+50351;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not “convention refugees”']
+35915;['appeal is allowed']
+24849;['appeal is allowed']
+34157;['appeal is allowed']
+135479;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85097;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+82462;['appeal is dismissed']
+148648;['rad agrees with the appellant’s submissions, in part']
+123772;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+141064;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+81923;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+63924;['allow his appeal.']
+98799;['appeal is dismissed']
+16440;['appeal of aïcha harrat was held']
+40805;['appeal is dismissed']
+99638;['appeal isallowed']
+83542;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94523;['appeal is dismissed']
+50523;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+71211;['appeal is dismissed']
+63179;['appeal is dismissed']
+56755;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+104108;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92604;['nor a danger of torture']
+43339;['dismiss the appeal']
+79752;['appeal isallowed']
+17111;['application to reopen the appeal is denied']
+99679;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+92750;['appeal is dismissed']
+105221;['appeal is dismissed']
+135453;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94054;['appeal is dismissed']
+69593;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94018;['appeal is dismissed']
+103106;['application is not an abuse of process']
+105803;['appeal is allowed']
+86107;['appeal is terminated']
+27588;['appeal of the february 14, 2013 determination is dismissed']
+129129;['appeal isallowed']
+83724;['dismiss the appeal']
+94525;['appeal is dismissed']
+87976;['refugee protection claim is rejected']
+97610;['claimant to not be a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+92577;['appeal is terminated']
+12214;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+131003;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+146558;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+142311;['appeal is dismissed']
+68542;['302 (c.a.']
+47315;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83128;['appeal is dismissed']
+52289;['appeal isallowed']
+95463;['appeal is dismissed']
+124830;['claimants are not “conventionrefugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+131508;['appeal is not allowed']
+152924;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+127339;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134744;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellantxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+66242;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+131029;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+99062;['appeal is dismissed']
+23059;['dismiss the appeal']
+131217;['appeal is dismissed']
+151557;['application for an oral hearing is dismissed']
+107930;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+94701;['appeal is dismissed']
+89217;['appeal is dismissed']
+74223;['appeal is dismissed']
+48088;['appeal is allowed']
+100031;['ms. xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+87474;['appeal is dismissed']
+68896;['allow this appeal']
+94651;['appeal isallowed']
+95911;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+40136;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+60933;['appeal is dismissed']
+36095;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+103941;['appeal is dismissed']
+87429;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+34328;['appeal is allowed']
+93596;['302 (c.a.']
+111356;['appeal is allowed']
+95368;['appeal is allowed']
+59030;['appeal isallowed']
+99015;['negative']
+95031;['appeal is allowed']
+114340;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+85967;['appeal is dismissed']
+98146;['appeal isallowed']
+57511;['appeals are determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+76766;['appeal is allowed']
+112372;['appeal is dismissed']
+55209;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+84413;['appealis dismissed']
+145577;['reject their claims']
+101880;['appeal is allowed']
+145844;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101671;['appeal were dismissed']
+141827;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+59864;['appeal is allowed']
+99721;['appeal is allowed']
+49542;['appeal is dismissed']
+117204;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees']
+71605;['appeal fails']
+90439;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+81647;['removal order isset aside']
+13985;['appeal isallowed']
+130688;['appeal is allowed']
+104052;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143607;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+94092;['appeal is allowed']
+77954;['appeal is allowed']
+123708;['appeal is allowed']
+135503;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151063;['claim is rejected']
+48088;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+145105;['decision rendered by the rpd is vitiated']
+67452;['appeal fails']
+65401;['appeal is allowed in law']
+100120;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+107173;['rad disagrees']
+116799;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+124817;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+54819;['appeal is dismissed']
+52510;['appeal is dismissed']
+139448;['tribunal grants the appellant’s appeal and', 'appellant does not lose his permanent resident status']
+99665;['appeal is allowed']
+68120;['removal order is set aside']
+145754;['not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+74866;['appeal is allowed']
+91162;['officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+56867;['appeal is allowed in law']
+107077;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107838;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+29469;['appeal isallowed']
+101001;['appeal isallowed']
+126396;['appeal is dismissed']
+44176;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'nor is he a “person in need of protection']
+108258;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+93090;['they are not “persons in need of protection']
+91209;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+38248;['appeal is dismissed']
+85909;['appeal isallowedand']
+69207;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+150734;['rpd decision is set aside']
+99820;['appeal is dismissed']
+87035;['appeal is allowed']
+139468;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+52723;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+116133;['dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+69150;['appeal is dismissed']
+85910;['appeal is abandoned']
+40156;['appeal is allowed']
+130937;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its own determination, that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+99804;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74611;['removal order is set aside']
+136671;['appeal is dismissed']
+64591;['allow the appeal']
+125465;['not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+144018;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77264;['302 (c.a.)']
+71593;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+63821;['appeal was dismissed']
+52690;['claimant xxxxxxxxxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+82391;['allow this appeal']
+24492;['appeal is allowed']
+102672;['appeal is dismissed']
+34152;['appeal is dismissed']
+83015;['appeal is allowed']
+64055;['302 (c.a.']
+87871;['claimants are not refugees']
+97428;['panel rejects the claims for refugee protection']
+58136;['appeal be dismissed']
+94317;['appeal abandoned']
+89570;['appeal is terminated']
+90274;['appeal is dismissed']
+114358;['claimant is not a “conventionrefugee”', 'rejects his claim']
+69262;['appeal isallowed.the']
+88899;['claimantxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+148487;['appeal is dismissed']
+93877;['appeal of trishnee chinniah is allowed']
+31048;['appeal is denied']
+136706;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision']
+100360;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+26761;['appeal bedismissed.']
+93643;['302 (c.a.']
+145811;['appeal is allowed']
+108735;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is not supportable']
+29073;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91179;['appeal is allowed']
+76016;['appeal is allowed']
+112371;['302 (c.a.']
+100472;['negative']
+69116;['appeal of mei xian cai is allowed']
+107925;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+62851;['appeal isallowed']
+89842;['panel rejects this claim']
+130851;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+93737;['nor a permanent resident in canada']
+92092;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+86397;['appeal is dismissed']
+83153;['appeal is dismissed']
+87124;['appeal isallowed']
+94558;['appeal is allowed']
+37835;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+102154;['appeal is dismissed']
+100809;['appeal is dismissed']
+146969;['appeal has been abandoned']
+92837;['appeal is dismissed']
+78188;['appeal is allowed']
+135147;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+94446;['appeal is allowed']
+61389;['appeal is dismissed']
+98419;['tribunal allows the appeal']
+54560;['appeal is allowed']
+89808;['dismiss the appeal']
+92240;['appeal isallowedand']
+101714;['appeal isallowed']
+68341;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”']
+104110;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+102122;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate and compassionate considerations']
+69862;['allow the appeal']
+34684;['dismiss this appeal']
+125304;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140276;['appellant is neither a convention refugee']
+105715;['302 (c.a.']
+83360;['dismiss this appeal']
+121398;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+93090;['claims are rejected']
+143018;['appeal is dismissed']
+152946;['appeal is allowed']
+95341;['appeal is dismissed']
+150640;['appeal is dismissed']
+76974;['appeal is allowed']
+151824;['appeal is dismissed']
+88455;['negative']
+77680;['appeal is dismissed']
+61357;['appeal is dismissed']
+39063;['appeal is allowed.the']
+97246;['appeal isallowed']
+151503;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+93895;['appeal is dismissed']
+60350;['appeals are dismissed']
+46084;['appeal is allowed']
+102172;['appeal isallowed']
+92794;['appellant has not lost her']
+21196;['appeal is dismissed']
+107639;['appeal is dismissed']
+98337;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+151834;['rad allows the appeal but finds that it cannot make a decision on this matter']
+94011;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+146862;['appeals are dismissed']
+75411;['appeal is allowed.the']
+89395;['appeal is terminated']
+120816;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+56678;['appeal is allowed in law']
+123680;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+27232;['panel finds that the refusal is not valid in law']
+103713;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+84538;['appeal is terminated']
+80366;['appeal is terminated']
+54752;['appeal is allowed']
+52771;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+68725;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60465;['appeal is dismissed']
+120792;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+107214;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+44210;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+97423;['thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122998;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+56876;['appeal beallowed']
+105321;['302 (c.a.)']
+117185;['appeal is dismissed']
+84559;['appeal isallowedand']
+110310;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+46030;['appeal is dismissed']
+142537;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+91282;['removal order is set aside']
+66322;['appeal bedismissed.']
+97222;['appeal is allowed']
+129911;['appeal is allowed']
+123767;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96306;['thatxxxxxxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98059;['appeal is allowed']
+98795;['appeal is dismissed']
+121528;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+28081;['appeal is dismissed']
+141815;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+46284;['appeal isallowedand']
+107249;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+77553;['appeal is dismissed']
+96656;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+61414;['request is denied']
+123407;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+49976;['appeal isallowed']
+70673;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+37841;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+151457;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+60836;['appeal is dismissed']
+122689;['appeal is allowed']
+122661;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76420;['appeal isallowed']
+56701;['appeal is discontinued']
+125169;['appeal concerning the refusal dated november\xa011, 2015 is dismissed']
+89442;['claimants,xxxxxxxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx, are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+146824;['appeal of the minor associate appellant is dismissed']
+130709;['appeal is allowed']
+98496;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+128161;['appeal is allowed']
+129886;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither\xa0 convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+76425;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+142067;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+103104;['appeal is dismissed']
+113231;['appeal is dismissed']
+94165;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+90591;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+77070;['appeal isallowed']
+73027;['appeal is allowed']
+56808;['claimants do not meet the definition of persons in need of protection']
+44017;['appeal is dismissed']
+92965;['appeal is dismissed']
+90898;['appeal is dismissed']
+141789;['appeal is determined']
+91436;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95434;['appeal is dismissed']
+108702;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+97474;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+89300;['appeal is terminated']
+71177;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+72013;['appeal be allowed']
+68681;['appeal of\xa0 duc nghiep huang is allowed']
+94518;['appeal is allowed']
+68380;['appeal is dismissed']
+28095;['appeal is dismissed']
+94742;['appeal is dismissed']
+113271;['appeal is allowed']
+76684;['appeal is dismissed']
+114300;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96269;['appeal is abandoned']
+91908;['appeal is allowed']
+83126;['appeal is dismissed']
+140852;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+110267;['appeal fails']
+123547;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69444;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+107638;['appeal is allowed']
+70412;['appeal of naresh sharma is allowed']
+143864;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+90501;['appeal (ta8-07364) is dismissed']
+57902;['bso’s decision is legally valid']
+151899;['302 (c.a.']
+76504;['appeals are dismissed']
+101761;['appeal be dismissed']
+116799;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109921;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+82126;['appeal is postponed']
+103533;['appeal is allowed']
+134746;['rad finds that principal appellant and her minor son, xxxx, are convention refugees']
+95432;['appeal is allowed']
+107694;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87419;['removal order is set aside']
+15019;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxxisneither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+148671;['appeal is allowed']
+122668;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+93684;['appeal is dismissed']
+95334;['appeal isallowed.the']
+124337;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81371;['panel finds that they are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+65409;['appeal will be allowed']
+56276;['appeal isallowedin']
+135486;['reject your claim']
+106654;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+82642;['302 (c.a.)']
+80190;['theclaimantis not a person in need of protection']
+47924;['appeal is allowed']
+128892;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+109146;['302 (c.a.)']
+86312;['appeal were not allowed']
+87493;['confirm the determination']
+64063;['appeal is allowed']
+96806;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+107938;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appeal is therefore dismissed']
+144559;['appeal is dismissed']
+55288;['not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+76376;['appeal is allowed']
+57558;['decision is valid in law']
+98736;['appeal is not allowed']
+88606;['“convention refugees”']
+140953;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54749;['removal orders are set aside']
+60821;['appeal should be allowed or dismissed']
+52344;['appeal of jasdeep kaur lalli is dismissed']
+145593;['reject his claim']
+111010;['rad dismisses the appeal,', 'upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person who would be subject to persecution should he return to china']
+108704;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133269;['rad allows this appeal']
+87846;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+102669;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+67652;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+72714;['appeal is dismissed']
+121395;['appeal of the nigerian born appellant']
+96018;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+88320;['appeal is allowed']
+142489;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+136716;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+102415;['appeal was dismissed']
+97350;['panel rejects this claim']
+84053;['appeal is allowed']
+54248;['appeal is finally allowed or dismissed']
+67783;['appeal is dismissed']
+107869;['appeal is allowed']
+128388;['appeal is allowed']
+88033;['claimants re not convention refugees', 'rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+116772;['appeal is allowed.the']
+108895;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+93828;['negative']
+128375;['appeal be dismissed']
+26787;['appeal of rajwant singh toor is dismissed']
+42284;['appeal would be dismissed']
+87372;['appeal isallowed']
+146452;['appellant is a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+121528;['appeal is dismissed']
+22706;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+105299;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+68322;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+83713;['appeal is dismissed']
+128375;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98010;['claims are therefore rejected']
+22707;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+82971;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+146109;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81190;['appeal were allowed']
+50258;['appeal is based']
+90988;['appeal was dismissed']
+101801;['appeal isallowed']
+108703;['appeal is dismissed']
+143905;['appeal is allowed']
+121437;['rad concludes that the rpd’s determination is correct']
+7588;['appeal is allowed']
+123128;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91406;['removal order is set aside']
+96468;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'nor is she a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+128274;['302 (c.a.']
+100868;['appeal is allowed']
+80750;['claimants are determined to be convention refugees']
+82875;['appeal is dismissed']
+68420;['appeal isallowed']
+86318;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxhas not established that there is a serious possibility of persecution']
+73347;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+102437;['favourable decision is issued to him']
+133282;['her claim for protection is also dismissed']
+86481;['appeal of oomesh dutt sohan is dismissed']
+96708;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+87308;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+99882;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+55131;['appeal is allowed']
+67237;['appeals are dismissed']
+63716;['appeal is dismissed']
+49058;['appeal is dismissed']
+73357;['appeal isallowed']
+94348;['appeal is dismissed']
+98606;['302 (c.a.)']
+77615;['appeal isallowed']
+99437;['claim is rejected']
+68202;['appeal of regina chopra is dismissed']
+100675;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+153733;['appeal is dismissed']
+78128;['claim is rejected']
+26878;['claimants are excluded from the convention']
+98540;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+104622;['appeal is allowed']
+61933;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+100128;['appeal is allowed']
+74218;['rad dismissed the appeal']
+95142;['appeal is dismissed']
+53857;['appeal is allowed']
+84185;['appeal is dismissed']
+87858;['claimant is neither a convention refugee undersection 96']
+99023;['his claim fails']
+107082;['appeal is dismissed']
+82856;['appeal ofmandeep kaur padda']
+87087;['appeal is dismissed']
+57299;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+59052;['appeal still fails']
+90053;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94609;['constitution establishes islam']
+96965;['appeal is dismissed']
+123884;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+90423;['appeal is dismissed']
+98543;['appeal is allowed']
+123534;['appeal is dismissed']
+65421;['appeal is terminated']
+76377;['appeal is allowed']
+89764;['appeal is allowed']
+78745;['appeal is dismissed']
+100844;['the claim fails']
+140627;['appeal is dismissed']
+92867;['appeal is allowed']
+89356;['allow the appeal']
+116758;['appeal is dismissed']
+83829;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+132282;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+102481;['allows the appeal']
+49630;['appeal is dismissed']
+86872;['appeal is dismissed']
+122556;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+80553;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+56702;['appeal is dismissed']
+105639;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+150612;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'are neither convention\xa0refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80980;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+69607;['appeal is dismissed']
+107594;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95471;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+49123;['appeal is allowed']
+60971;['appeals are allowed']
+79318;['appeal is dismissed']
+130988;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35722;['appeal isallowed']
+99203;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+90122;['negative']
+46104;['appeal is terminated']
+33083;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60425;['appeal should be allowed']
+128330;['appeal is allowed']
+83539;['appeal isallowedand']
+99279;['appeal is dismissed']
+91623;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+59020;['sets aside the deportation order and allows the appeal']
+124667;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151811;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88494;['the claim fails']
+94563;['appeal is dismissed']
+148427;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+85906;['appeal isallowedand']
+72072;['appeal is dismissed']
+132299;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+151380;['302 (c.a.']
+84597;['appeal was without']
+83394;['appeal is allowed']
+96104;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+141814;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+146547;['appeal is allowed']
+143244;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+145752;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+69767;['appeal isallowed.the']
+124585;['rad therefore allows her appeal and sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+129251;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+76859;['appeal ofy.y.is dismissed']
+60500;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+123319;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+95247;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+85860;['claims are rejected']
+69780;['appeal is allowed']
+98624;['dismiss the appeal']
+94614;['appeal isallowed']
+131047;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor persons in need of protection']
+75906;['appeal is dismissed']
+114366;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93580;['appeal isallowed']
+134384;['appeal is allowed']
+54789;['appeal is allowed']
+95561;['appeal is dismissed']
+41250;['dismissal of the appeal']
+52771;['appeal is dismissed']
+65704;['appeal is dismissed']
+71173;['appeal is dismissed']
+99467;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+86845;['appeal fails']
+77640;['appeal is allowed']
+108196;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59996;['negative']
+59976;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+99263;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+101684;['appeal is allowed']
+79708;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+79473;['appeal is dismissed']
+91153;['appeal is allowed']
+146923;['appeal would be dismissed']
+97244;['appeal is allowed']
+100101;['appeal is allowed']
+68152;['appeal must be dismissed']
+94013;['exclusion order is set aside']
+81927;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+124733;['rad concurs with the finding']
+146434;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+107444;['appeal is dismissed']
+81315;['appeal is dismissed']
+93964;['appeal is allowed']
+113293;['appeal is allowed']
+96350;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+36114;['appeals of natalia melman, dmitri melman and liran melman are allowed']
+95451;['appeal is allowed']
+85510;['appeal is dismissed']
+148607;['appeal is dismissed']
+96589;['appeal is allowed']
+45238;['302 (c.a.']
+55192;['appeal is dismissed']
+123716;['appeal is dismissed']
+93020;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89706;['appeal is dismissed']
+99572;['appeal is allowed']
+98347;['appeal is allowed']
+85495;['appeal is dismissed']
+135460;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection', 'claim is dismissed']
+77059;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+12229;['appeal is dismissed']
+54211;['appeal of the deportation order was heard']
+124101;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is aconventionrefugee']
+69788;['appeal is allowed']
+66626;['iad therefore does not have jurisdiction']
+38855;['appeal is dismissed']
+82273;['appeal of jasvinder kaur is dismissed']
+65631;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+96449;['appeal dismissed']
+49393;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+77561;['appeal is allowed']
+132415;['removal order is set aside']
+125407;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134310;['appeal is allowed']
+121549;['appeal is allowed']
+123129;['appeal of the principal appellant is allowed']
+123852;['rad cannot confirm or set aside the rpd’s determination']
+78032;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90603;['appeal was dismissed']
+91144;['appeals are allowed.the']
+52702;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+61796;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123316;['appeal is allowed']
+122138;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+78091;['appeal isallowed']
+92813;['appeal is dismissed']
+76076;['appeal is determined']
+107250;['rad rejects the appellant’s submissions']
+101343;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+93016;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal']
+103534;['appeal is allowed']
+83660;['appeal isallowed']
+78644;['appeal isallowed.the']
+69143;['appeal of rahman mahfuzur is dismissed']
+135891;['confirm the rpd’s decision']
+105905;['neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection', 'division rejects their claims']
+80481;['appeal is allowed']
+99002;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+91725;['appeals are dismissed']
+90178;['appeal isallowed']
+55120;['appeal is dismissed']
+94766;['appeal is dismissed']
+71725;['dismiss this appeal']
+69417;['appeal isallowed']
+143155;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+143876;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+136709;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143012;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+42448;['appeal is allowed']
+101853;['appeal being allowed']
+146943;['reject that explanation']
+99268;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+56937;['appeal is dismissed']
+57066;['appeal is allowed']
+71565;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+127334;['appeal is dismissed']
+153418;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made']
+91618;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+141795;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71809;['appeal isallowed']
+94222;['panel therefore rejects this refugee protection claim']
+84493;['appeal is allowed']
+101592;['appeal is dismissed']
+107607;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+100356;['dismissed the appeals of the parents']
+141163;['appeal is allowed']
+84822;['officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+88523;['negative']
+81661;['appeal isallowed']
+128345;['appeal is dismissed']
+37844;['appeal is allowed']
+149581;['302 (c.a.']
+97385;['panel finds that xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+91633;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100311;['appeal is dismissed']
+89273;['appeal allowed –']
+83108;['appeal is determined']
+26805;['appeal of nirmal singh toor is dismissed']
+96261;['claimants,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxand her brother,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, are not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+124461;['appeal is allowed']
+77106;['appeal be allowed']
+78289;['appeal is dismissed']
+125044;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+139849;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90499;['appeal is terminated']
+133747;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+70023;['dismiss the appeal']
+77964;['appeal is dismissed']
+76046;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+41681;['appeal is allowed']
+116805;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123985;['appeal is dismissed']
+89335;['appeal isdismissedfor a lack of']
+77858;['negative']
+121957;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+60700;['appeal is dismissed']
+5142;['appeal is dismissed']
+107821;['appeal is dismissed']
+74570;['appeal is allowed']
+83169;['dismisses the appellant’s appeals']
+59680;['appeal is dismissed']
+87107;['appeals are dismissed']
+133240;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+88138;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+121450;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+148355;['thisappeal is dismissed']
+109304;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor person in need of protection']
+77082;['immigration officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+96979;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+77607;['appeal isallowed']
+146718;['appeal is allowed']
+60938;['appeal is allowed']
+91169;['appeal is   ']
+81256;['appeal is allowed']
+151599;['appeal is   ']
+100904;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+86345;['appeal is determined']
+83148;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+123550;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47155;['appeal be dismissed']
+116358;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+107042;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99704;['appeal is determined']
+54808;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+116346;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+67169;['appeal is dismissed']
+48417;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+81185;['ms. jamila hassanyar nor her dependents can be sponsored']
+72655;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97457;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94159;['rad finds that it cannot provide a remedy']
+108747;['appeals are allowed']
+54283;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+88881;['appeal is dismissed']
+76394;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+108801;['302 (c.a.']
+89565;['appeal isdismissed for lack of jurisdiction']
+97267;['refugee protection claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+101313;['appeal is allowed']
+116815;['appeal is allowed']
+108865;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+97261;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+113295;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+75425;['appeal of alton anthony reid']
+106430;['appeal is dismissed']
+125132;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101355;['appeal is allowed']
+71250;['appeal is allowed']
+92243;['appeal isallowed']
+104555;['appeal is allowed']
+30382;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146901;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+26898;"[""concur with my colleague's decision""]"
+66906;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident visa']
+92803;['appeal is determined']
+70210;['appeal isallowed']
+94392;['appeal is allowed.the']
+10235;['appeal is dismissed']
+99654;['appeal (vb3-00567) is dismissed']
+38586;['appeal of isha fatmata bangura is dismissed']
+102569;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108709;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+117118;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+52087;['appeal is allowed']
+129881;['appeal is dismissed']
+82363;['dismisses the appeal']
+108705;['appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+97600;['allowed the appeal']
+97005;['negative']
+69241;['appeal isallowed']
+81203;['appeal is dismissed']
+75705;['panel’s order of march\xa02002 may not be varied by the administration']
+72022;['appeal isallowed']
+80107;['appeal ofsong ling shiis dismissed forres judicata']
+108713;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38778;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+96364;['appeal is dismissed']
+50553;['appeal is dismissed']
+121747;['appeal is allowed']
+147784;['appeal is dismissed']
+140777;['confirm, but for different reasons', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47338;['appeal is allowed in law']
+85381;['appeal isallowed']
+94964;['appeal is allowed']
+94461;['appeal isallowed']
+74950;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+85495;['appeal is dismissed']
+114391;['appeal is allowed']
+85979;['appeal is allowed']
+112385;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+69677;['appeal is dismissed']
+49533;['appeal is allowed in law']
+97980;['appeal is allowed']
+98089;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+35905;['appeal is dismissed']
+143579;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+98739;['appeal isdismissed.']
+141161;['visa is set aside']
+110295;['dismissing an appeal']
+150644;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+111876;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93150;['appeal is terminated']
+99548;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+131524;['favourable decision form is attached']
+107473;['appeal is accepted']
+44900;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+89870;['appeal was dismissed']
+70884;['appeal of haileyesus getahun zewdie is allowed']
+107070;['appeal is dismissed']
+72836;['appeal must be dismissed']
+148716;['302 (c.a.']
+47151;['appeal is allowed']
+103811;['application to vacate is allowed']
+95465;['appeal’s relative merit']
+26484;['appeal being dismissed']
+80773;['appeal is dismissed']
+46006;['appeal is dismissed']
+77818;['claimant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+90962;['appellant is not established incanada']
+139868;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+99388;['refugee protection claim filed byxxxx xx xxxx xx xxxxxis rejected']
+122693;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+63902;['appeal is allowed']
+100782;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+47133;['appeal bedismissed.']
+142726;['appeal is allowed']
+104005;['appeal is dismissed']
+123104;['appeal is allowed']
+145347;['claim is rejected']
+77852;['appeals are allowed.the']
+122651;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugees']
+46076;['appeal is granted']
+95480;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+95083;['appeal is allowed']
+114303;['adopt them as my own']
+91229;['rpd’s determination is correct']
+82051;['appeal is a hearingde']
+84714;['appeal is dismissed']
+113549;['appeal was dismissed']
+56943;['dismiss your appeal']
+132336;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94746;['negative']
+49165;['departure orders areset aside']
+56578;['appeals are allowed.the']
+90542;['appeal is determined']
+66647;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes a determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+47101;['appealbe allowedbecause']
+95940;['appeal is allowed']
+99897;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+50729;['appeal is allowed']
+41076;['appeal is dismissed']
+128613;['appeal of the male minor appellant is rejected']
+153157;['appeal is allowed']
+100279;['appeal isallowed']
+141784;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+85177;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention\xa0']
+125136;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35230;['appeal is allowed']
+49061;['appeal must be dismissed']
+105319;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26748;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+125013;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+67728;['appeal is allowed']
+45157;['appeal fails']
+67682;['dismiss the appeal']
+46554;['appeal is allowed']
+22992;['appeal is dismissed']
+93572;['appeal isallowed']
+87940;['appeal is dismissed']
+90204;['her claim fails']
+120741;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26764;['appeal is dismissed']
+107460;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101812;['appeal is abandoned']
+66330;['appeal is dismissed']
+54631;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+86303;['appeal is determined']
+89342;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+140844;['appellants are convention refugees']
+81917;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+74461;['appeal is allowed']
+77476;['appeal is allowed']
+31442;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+102526;['appeal is dismissed']
+150611;['rad allows the appeal']
+83534;['appeals are dismissed']
+130852;['substitutes the determination that should have been made']
+91761;['appeal is allowed']
+151628;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+151766;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+106806;['appeal isallowed']
+76179;['appeal of jalal adada is dismissed']
+86380;['appeal isallowed']
+82459;['appeal is terminated']
+61532;['appeal is allowed']
+98812;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+64273;['appeal isdismissed.']
+58748;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142725;['panel confirms the decision of the rpd', 'rejects her claim']
+131739;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50353;['rad disagrees']
+106778;['appeal is dismissed']
+72765;['allows this appeal']
+94063;['appeal isallowed']
+123367;['rejects the minor claims']
+142734;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+93231;['appeal is therefore determined to be abandoned']
+83345;['appeal is dismissed']
+108118;['rad finds that the appellants are not convention refugees', 'dismisses the appeal']
+69762;['allow this appeal']
+100527;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69560;['appeal is dismissed']
+142518;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107227;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+24471;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+45239;['refugee protection division rejects the claim ofxxxxxxxxxxpursuant']
+60477;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction to hear the appeal']
+101909;['appeal is dismissed']
+120799;['substitute my own determination that the respondents are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68887;['appeal is dismissed']
+107033;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+142742;['appeal was dismissed']
+123818;['appeal is allowed']
+98366;['appeal is dismissed']
+93046;['appeal should be allowed']
+101759;['appeal should be allowed']
+129411;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+108773;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97608;['appeal is dismissed']
+76593;['appeal is allowed']
+107156;['rad concurs with the rpd’s decision that the appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+107814;['302 (c.a.']
+90627;['refugee claim of xxxxx xxx xx is, therefore, rejected']
+149151;['appeal is dismissed']
+76835;['appeal isallowed']
+50750;['appeal is allowed']
+96974;['allow the appeal']
+91946;['appeal abandoned']
+93298;['appeal is dismissed']
+106399;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+51675;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+107871;['302 (c.a.']
+148973;['claimants are not “convention refugees”', 'rejects their refugee protection claims']
+74031;['appeal isallowed']
+133261;['rad finds no error in the rpd analysis']
+81202;['appeal is dismissed']
+96842;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+77828;['findsxxxxxxxxxxnot a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+71270;['appeal is allowed']
+89276;['appeal of duy huynh nguyen is dismissed']
+54273;['appeal is allowed in law']
+84687;['iad dismissed the appellant’s appeal']
+100977;['appeal is dismissed']
+109692;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+32081;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with refugee protection claims']
+98450;['appeal is dismissed']
+105870;['appeal is dismissed']
+48208;['appeal isallowed']
+87599;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+110315;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87502;['appeal is allowed']
+57568;['appeal of jemal aliyi mumed is dismissed']
+46541;['dismiss this appeal']
+103655;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151909;['rad finds that the respondent is a target of the farc']
+60013;['claimant not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+74768;['appeal isallowed']
+95959;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+77081;['appellant has not lost his permanent residence status']
+42018;['appeal is allowed']
+107145;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+49739;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+126734;['appeal be dismissed', 'nor the best interests of the child']
+66305;['allows the appellant’s appeal']
+71158;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of   ', 'rejects his claim']
+69566;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+95516;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+90047;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+152003;['dismissed the appeal']
+60181;['appeal is allowed']
+23113;['allow the appeal']
+125617;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60733;['appeal is dismissed']
+125547;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71662;['appeal is dismissed']
+19146;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+93613;['appeal is allowed']
+129136;['appeal is allowed']
+68268;['appeal isallowed']
+43400;['appeal is dismissed']
+36111;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+108066;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71334;['appeal is allowed']
+122253;['appeal is allowed']
+91625;['appeal is allowed']
+99573;['appeal is allowed']
+37833;['appeal is dismissed']
+94457;['favourable decision is attached to these reasons']
+74999;['appeal was allowed']
+63954;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+82170;['appeal is allowed']
+98524;['appeal is allowed']
+125859;['appeal is allowed']
+87794;['302 (c.a.']
+130997;['confirm the impugned decision', 'dismiss the appeal']
+152028;['appeal is dismissed']
+95046;['appeal is terminated']
+71415;['appeal is allowed']
+87082;['appeal is dismissed']
+100325;['not a person in need of protection']
+69495;['appeal is allowed in law']
+153156;['appeal is dismissed']
+24451;['appeal of yuan chang yang is allowed']
+121402;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+42221;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+103658;['claimant, xxxx   xxxx, not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151482;['appeal is allowed']
+89297;['appeals are dismissed']
+57913;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+101309;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+89141;['appeal is allowed']
+129241;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+22659;['dismiss this appeal']
+99082;['appeal is dismissed']
+124968;['not a person in need of protection']
+77483;['appeal is dismissed']
+93303;['appeal of rajbans kaur kang is allowed']
+60982;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+70899;['allow his appeal']
+77969;['appeal is allowed']
+114321;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95976;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+139785;['appeal is dismissed']
+100674;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95228;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+81262;['appeal is allowed']
+109299;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44181;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+40125;['appeals are allowed']
+140994;['appeal is allowed']
+88113;['appeal is allowed']
+63998;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80230;['thatxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+63729;['appeal is allowed']
+88031;['appeal is allowed']
+125225;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+60922;['appeal is allowed']
+69988;['appeal is allowed']
+46498;['application should be dismissed']
+26817;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+77474;['appeal is allowed']
+125246;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+93318;['appeal is allowed']
+147456;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+38389;['appeal is dismissed']
+78663;['theappeal is allowed']
+128281;['removal order is set aside']
+61482;['appeal of guo ping zhao is dismissed']
+103706;['appeal should be dismissed']
+97372;['302 (c.a.)']
+91715;['appeal is allowed']
+68751;['appeal is dismissed']
+141224;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57309;['his claim is rejected']
+94458;['appeal isallowed']
+98798;['appeal is dismissed']
+113230;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+49116;['appeal will be dealt with on its merits']
+58811;['appeal is dismissed']
+84418;['appeal is allowed']
+99307;['appeal is allowed']
+76549;['appeal is allowed']
+110928;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+123133;['substitute my own decision that the appellants areconventionrefugees']
+95650;['application for postponementsine diemust be rejected']
+58118;['appeal is allowed']
+132422;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+105807;['allow the appeal of samantha']
+95554;['appeal of inderpal singh nijjar is dismissed']
+104395;['appeal of the refusal']
+125499;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94269;['appeal is dismissed']
+86889;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+102450;['appeal is dismissed']
+152369;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63747;['appeal is dismissed']
+49395;['appeal is dismissed']
+143173;['302 (c.a.']
+47825;['appeal is dismissed']
+19229;['appeal is dismissed']
+106331;['appeal is dismissed']
+149004;['appeal is allowed']
+77026;['appeal is dismissed']
+94407;['appeal is dismissed']
+64631;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+48102;['allow the appeal']
+66781;['appeal is dismissed']
+122261;['302 (c.a.']
+81235;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91410;['appeal of mohamed anounkou is dismissed']
+69275;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+92500;['appeal is allowed.the']
+83937;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+47391;['appeal is allowed in law']
+123728;['appeal is allowed']
+113518;['appeal is dismissed']
+123003;['appeal is allowed']
+124818;['appeal is allowed']
+80540;['appeal is dismissed']
+84151;['appeal is dismissed']
+84424;['appeal is allowed', 'visa officer’s decision is set aside']
+70643;['appeal is allowed']
+107709;['appeal is dismissed']
+84514;['appeal is dismissed']
+60065;['appeal isallowed']
+21299;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirm the determination of the refugee protection division']
+102672;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+37852;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+37400;['appeal is allowed']
+82396;['allow the appeal']
+120717;['appeal is allowed']
+87178;['appeal is allowed']
+144027;['appeal is allowed']
+24186;['appeal is dismissed']
+95131;['appeal is dismissed']
+56923;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+96096;['claimant, xxxx xxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+114347;['substitute my determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+80460;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+79106;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person inneed of protection', 'dismiss herclaim.']
+61426;['appeal is allowed']
+52341;['appeal is dismissed']
+144249;['appeal is allowed']
+113742;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+130698;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+94028;['appeal is dismissed']
+93073;['refugee protection division shall accept a claim for refugee protection', 'claimant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject the claim']
+97122;['appeal is allowed']
+146931;['302 (c.a.']
+59748;['appeal is allowed']
+148589;['appeal is allowed']
+63725;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97428;['they are not refugees']
+125108;['substitute the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+75412;['appeal is dismissed']
+140891;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+40647;['appeals are allowed']
+52143;['appeal fails']
+80044;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+68245;['302 (c.a.)']
+123988;['confirm the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee']
+147444;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+102050;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+98360;['appeal was dismissed']
+71572;['appeal is dismissed']
+30522;['appeal is dismissed']
+121455;['appeal would be dismissed']
+23060;['appeal is dismissed']
+82050;['appeal is allowed']
+54816;['appeal is dismissed']
+44730;['appeal is allowed']
+60026;['negative']
+89349;['appeal isallowed']
+56919;['appeal isallowed']
+112319;['appeal is allowed']
+87703;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+75592;['appeal is dismissed']
+89996;['panel rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+90719;['appeal is dismissed']
+62715;['appeal isallowed']
+83656;['appeal is allowed']
+88145;['appeal is allowed']
+97903;['appeal of is dismissed']
+105224;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+76042;['appeal is allowed']
+44031;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+92945;['appeal is dismissed']
+46519;['appeal is allowed']
+16445;['appeal is dismissed']
+107328;['claimant is not a convention refugee,']
+84578;['appeal isallowed']
+97002;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101865;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71814;['appeal dismissed']
+84551;['appeal isallowed.the']
+75459;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+133252;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+142520;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+133735;['appeal of the minor appellant is also dismissed', 'not a convention refugee']
+47615;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+59373;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+90843;['appeal is dismissed']
+53826;['appeal is terminated']
+90110;['not “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+68300;['appeal is allowed.the']
+69834;['appeal is dismissed']
+84188;['dismiss the appeal']
+107200;['appeal is dismissed']
+132408;['appeal is dismissed']
+67691;['decision of the canadian embassy in vienna is valid in law']
+108944;['appeal is dismissed']
+103451;['appeal is dismissed']
+101172;['appeal is dismissed']
+98462;['refugee protection division his claim']
+82708;['appeal is allowed']
+95137;['appeal is terminated']
+74501;['appeal being allowed']
+95036;['appeal is terminated']
+90952;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+87159;['appeal is allowed']
+68588;['appeal is allowed']
+76380;['appeal is allowed']
+97478;['negative']
+65409;['appeal is allowed']
+67750;['appeal is allowed']
+97821;['she is not a convention refugee']
+86342;['appeal isallowed']
+42082;['decision is well‑founded in law']
+81113;['appeal is dismissed']
+44430;['appeal is allowed']
+91312;['appeal isallowed.the']
+92279;['constitution prohibits discrimination']
+48093;['appeal is dismissed']
+76797;['appeal is allowed']
+123041;['negative decision must therefore be set aside']
+69661;['appeal isallowed']
+145493;['appeal is dismissed']
+123057;['appeal is allowed']
+21339;['neither the principal claimant, nor the minor claimant']
+75934;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+41832;['appeal is allowed']
+107239;['appeal is allowed']
+64872;['rpd decision therefore cannot stand']
+92951;['appeal isallowed']
+39896;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+89747;['appeal is allowed']
+144567;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+74466;['appeal is dismissed']
+98356;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+106840;['appeal is allowed']
+107164;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+131542;['appeal is allowed']
+127713;['appeal is dismissed']
+55309;['application for refugee protection is accepted']
+57551;['appeal of muhammad atif khan is allowed']
+152923;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+94773;['appeal is allowed']
+132376;['appeal be dismissed']
+123325;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+87816;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+71263;['appeal is moot']
+124695;['appeal is allowed']
+79747;['appeal is allowed']
+35431;['appeal is dismissed']
+66253;['dismissal of the appeal']
+129254;['appeal is denied']
+106299;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89264;['appeal is dismissed']
+76724;['appeal is allowed']
+80126;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+97350;['negative']
+28033;['negative']
+71259;['appeal isallowed']
+107368;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+123001;['302 (c.a.']
+80273;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+134735;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83091;['appeal is allowed']
+84763;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+14584;['application to extend time to file the appeal is dismissed']
+125428;['dismiss the appeal', 'uphold the rpd’s determination']
+90179;['appeal is allowed']
+96189;['appeal is allowed']
+133703;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision']
+87170;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102994;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+74456;['appeal is allowed']
+88255;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82133;['appeal is dismissed']
+75426;['appeal is allowed']
+142794;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+69190;['appeal is dismissed']
+145378;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+103663;['panel rejects these claims']
+77903;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89295;['appeal is terminated']
+132350;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71741;['appeal is dismissed']
+97676;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128183;['dismiss the appeal']
+75492;['appeal is allowed']
+45153;['appeal of wilma diawadin garcia is dismissed']
+151588;['appeal is dismissed']
+123784;['appeal is dismissed']
+87289;['tribunal rejects the application filed by the applicant to vacate']
+124699;['appellant cannot be recognized as a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+62900;['appeal of shi jun huang and lihong zhang is dismissed']
+97326;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+105881;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77545;['appeal is dismissed']
+71104;['appeal of sukhvir kaur kahlon, pursuant to paragraph 77(3)(b) of the formerimmigration act']
+77548;['adoptions of iquo and thelma are not legal adoptions']
+63722;['appeal isallowed']
+135196;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86452;['appeal is dismissed']
+87486;['appeal is dismissed']
+99512;['appeal isallowed']
+100151;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+44028;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+122621;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+99386;['claimant, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+89023;['panel therefore rejects his claim']
+151622;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84301;['appeal is allowed']
+27293;['appeal is allowed']
+106757;['appeal is dismissed']
+92547;['appeals of the principal appellant']
+97926;['appeal is dismissed']
+87312;['appeal isdismissed.']
+69447;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law', 'appeal is allowed in law']
+123423;['set aside the rpd decision and substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+94490;['appeal is dismissed']
+120794;['appeal is allowed']
+31048;['appeal of amir is allowed']
+122686;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123430;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+58236;['appeal isallowed']
+147623;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination']
+70103;['appeal isallowed']
+78035;['302 (c.a.']
+89970;['appeal is allowed']
+31977;['appeal is allowed']
+83913;['appeal is dismissed']
+80067;['appeal is dismissed']
+122684;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+90851;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a \xa0convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88157;['appeal is dismissed']
+123871;['confirm the rpd’s determination', '“convention refugee']
+96640;['appeal is dismissed']
+75569;['appeal is allowed']
+135479;['appeal is dismissed']
+83901;['appeal is terminated']
+80828;['not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+86054;['appeal is allowed']
+68200;['appeal of arnavaz phiroze kapadia is dismissed']
+123038;['302 (c.a.']
+49200;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+43741;['appeal is dismissed']
+128375;['appeal be dismissed']
+150719;['appeal is allowed']
+85323;['appeal is allowed']
+102262;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+79459;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26788;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+91339;['appeal is not within the competent jurisdiction', 'appeal is dismissed']
+95839;['appeal is allowed']
+103616;['claim is rejected']
+88608;['refugee protection division rejects his claim', 'claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+140705;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26790;['refusal is invalid in law']
+114336;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+93888;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+46070;['appeal isallowed.the']
+152241;['not a person in need of protection']
+82652;['appeal is allowed']
+85446;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+129924;['appeals were dismissed']
+66916;['appeal isallowed']
+80569;['302 (c.a.']
+99782;['appeal is dismissed']
+106776;['appeal is allowed']
+47566;['appeal is dismissed']
+31050;['appeal is dismissed']
+111107;['appellant is an excluded person']
+52112;['rad finds the appellant’s argument fails']
+131060;['appeal was dismissed']
+140722;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+87793;['appeal is allowed']
+143556;['rad confirms that the adult appellants']
+77867;['appeal is allowed']
+74522;['appeal isallowed']
+37832;['appeal is allowed.the']
+143478;['claims are therefore dismissed']
+96740;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+60408;['appeal was dismissed']
+47469;['appeal is dismissed']
+142795;['appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+97022;['negative']
+50736;['appeal be dismissed']
+133263;['appeal is dismissed']
+88865;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+95272;['dismiss the appeal']
+84510;['appeal is dismissed']
+100337;['appeal is dismissed']
+134741;['thatxxxx xxxxis excluded from refugee protection']
+41791;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+143868;['appeal is allowed']
+65696;['appeal isallowed']
+49169;['appeal isallowed']
+99844;['spouse’s claim is also rejected']
+49118;['dismiss the appeal']
+99524;['appeal is dismissed']
+97971;['appeal isallowed']
+52496;['appeal is allowed']
+72012;['exclusion order is set aside']
+123856;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+69949;['allowed the appeal']
+74822;['appeal is dismissed']
+83082;['appeal of volodymyr gabalis is dismissed']
+104543;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+140743;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxand their daughter,xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees']
+130720;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+77215;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98716;['appeal has been abandoned']
+78031;['dismiss an appeal']
+80752;['appeal is dismissed']
+95133;['appeal is allowed']
+59839;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+109285;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+90455;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+46016;['appeal is allowed']
+98965;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+93911;['appeal is allowed']
+128423;['appeal is dismissed']
+143413;['appeal is apparently']
+125247;['allow the appeal']
+107624;['appeal should be allowed']
+142887;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+124164;['appeal is dismissed']
+143869;['appeal is dismissed']
+89786;['dismiss the appeal']
+111040;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'panel rejects his claim']
+101759;['appeal is allowed in law']
+48497;['appeal is dismissed']
+27292;['iad decision is based on adequate reasoning']
+122235;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97946;['appeal is dismissed']
+100113;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appeal is dismissed']
+83045;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+94576;['claims are rejected']
+107240;['appeal is dismissed']
+74632;['appeal isallowed']
+10743;['appeal is dismissed']
+100248;['appeal would have been dismissed']
+84785;['rad must first seek to supplement them']
+97346;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+59747;['panel finds that the immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+93973;['determine the claimants not to be convention refugees or persons in need of canada’s protection']
+27246;['appeal is dismissed']
+94816;['appeal is dismissed']
+75980;['appeal bedismissed']
+153253;['appellant is not a“convention refugee”']
+79932;['rejects the joined claims of the claimants']
+102947;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+59043;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+84792;['appeal is dismissed']
+132224;['appeal is dismissed']
+47393;['appeal is allowed']
+98613;['appeal is dismissed']
+104468;['appeal is allowed']
+98666;['appeal is dismissed']
+94134;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+57789;['appeal isallowed']
+103664;['reject your claim']
+90965;['appeal isallowed']
+56706;['appeal is allowed']
+98364;['appeal is allowed']
+84642;['appeal is dismissed']
+87251;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+79223;['appeal is terminated']
+107612;['appeal is dismissed']
+83720;['appeal is allowed']
+124942;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122877;['allow the appeal']
+46479;['appeal is determined']
+49975;['appeal is allowed']
+151783;['appeal is allowed']
+138279;['appeal is allowed']
+146840;['appeal is dismissed']
+89791;['appeal is dismissed']
+131091;['302 (c.a.']
+79868;['appeal is allowed']
+81849;['appeal is dismissed']
+46087;['appeal is allowed']
+99215;['appeal is allowed']
+100421;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees']
+99508;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+74134;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxx, the minor us appellant, is dismissed']
+72168;['appeal was dismissed']
+4742;['appeal is determined']
+77689;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+95076;['claimants,xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not convention refugees', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+140279;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68279;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+150659;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+78162;['appeal is terminated']
+68444;['application is allowed']
+124801;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94372;['appeal is determined']
+148486;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+98657;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124723;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96761;['appeal of rezwan sufi is dismissed']
+139439;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+95248;['appeal is dismissed']
+107840;['rad finds the rpd’s reasons to be circular']
+114430;['appeal is dismissed']
+101414;['appeal is allowed']
+91605;['appeal is allowed']
+92252;['appeal is allowed']
+116830;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+27303;['removes the iad’s discretionary jurisdiction']
+46984;['appeal is dismissed']
+93271;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+83894;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+131015;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+52791;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+80787;['appeal is allowed']
+54829;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+140246;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70378;['appeal is dismissed']
+99384;['claimants are immigrants and not refugees']
+62941;['appeal ofsai wah (dominic) wong, in respect to his wife,li jie li, is allowed']
+143641;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94600;['appeal is allowed']
+142513;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136094;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67602;['appeal is dismissed']
+70038;['appeal be allowed']
+73350;['appeal is dismissed']
+76166;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+87370;['appeal was allowed']
+142970;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeals']
+32177;['appeal isallowed.the']
+133240;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91717;['appeal is dismissed']
+135185;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+34163;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+57953;['application to reopen the appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96950;['reject the appellant’s argument']
+30522;['appeal is allowed']
+22848;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+33239;['appeal is terminated']
+108132;['appeal is dismissed']
+64210;['appeal has no merit']
+37495;['appeal is dismissed']
+102161;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67697;['appeal is allowed']
+118266;['removal order is set aside']
+127478;['appeal is dismissed']
+60937;['302 (c.a.']
+95633;['appeal is dismissed']
+127339;['appeal is dismissed']
+94570;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+151801;['appeal is dismissed']
+124719;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129216;['appeal is dismissed']
+13985;['removal order isset aside']
+69498;['appeal isallowed']
+83549;['reject this explanation']
+40152;['appeal is allowed']
+54712;['removal order isset aside']
+125642;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+91647;['appeal of zinnah manssally is dismissed']
+151455;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72914;['appeal isallowed']
+54780;['appeal is allowed']
+54842;['not a convention refugee']
+39044;['appeal is dismissed']
+76794;['appeal is dismissed']
+124974;['allow the appeal']
+98877;['appeal is allowed']
+76944;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+42354;['dismiss this appeal']
+100644;['appeals are dismissed']
+109019;['dismissal of this appeal']
+18932;['appeal is dismissed']
+107128;['rad finds that the rpd’s determination is supportable', 'confirms the rpd’s finding']
+140715;['302 (c.a.']
+147798;['appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90761;['appeal is rejected']
+96917;['appeal is dismissed']
+84523;['appeals of gurcharan singh brar, baljit singh brar, kartar kaur brar, and veerpal kaur brar are allowed']
+118429;['appeal is allowed']
+123361;['appeal is dismissed']
+100204;['theappealis dismissed']
+124560;['302 (c.a.']
+123066;['appeal is dismissed']
+36255;['appeal is dismissed']
+89764;['appeal isallowed']
+133361;['appeal is allowed']
+101330;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+94463;['dismiss the appeal']
+84762;['appeal is allowed']
+124683;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+80089;['appeal is terminated']
+141654;['appeal is dismissed']
+122972;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+122898;['i disagree with the rpd’s decision']
+70485;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107173;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144412;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42337;['removal order is set aside']
+63989;['appeal is allowed']
+103692;['claimants, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,not to be convention refugees of persons in need of protection']
+77957;['appeal is dismissed']
+113627;['appeals are allowed']
+56625;['appeal is determined']
+49057;['appeal isallowed']
+26970;['xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+95590;['appeal is dismissed']
+122678;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+115219;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+144252;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+138808;['appeal is dismissed']
+107035;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+125413;['appeal is allowed']
+105705;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+77537;['302 (c.a.)']
+21453;['xxxxxx and xxxxxxxx are also determined to be convention refugees']
+140819;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+35434;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+123905;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+81258;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+38406;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+92386;['allow the appeal']
+90042;['appeal is allowed']
+88428;['claimants,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxare', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84319;['appeal isdismissed.']
+125617;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94523;['appeal is dismissed']
+90819;['removal orders are set aside']
+95419;['appeal is dismissed']
+90899;['302 (c.a.']
+90544;['appeal must be dismissed']
+97466;['appeal is allowed']
+144482;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+114331;['appeal is allowed']
+93046;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96088;['appeal isallowed']
+24497;['application to reopen the appeal should be dismissed']
+88149;['appeal is dismissed']
+98266;['not a “person in need of protection']
+80998;['appeal is dismissed']
+19306;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx, her three minor daughters', 'not “convention refugees”']
+89028;['negative']
+96825;['negative']
+152783;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is inadmissible']
+63006;['appeal is allowed']
+74100;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+96312;['appeals are dismissed']
+72202;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+89164;['appeal appears to have some merit']
+97267;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+100184;['appeal is allowed']
+107329;['reject your claim']
+26800;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+94174;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97205;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38858;['appeal isallowed']
+134215;['appeal is allowed.the']
+83024;['appeal is allowed']
+101291;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74578;['appeal fails']
+109396;['302 (c.a.']
+124642;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60283;['appeal isallowed']
+53444;['removal orders are set aside']
+113849;['appeal is allowed']
+91090;['appeal is terminated']
+101168;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+102071;['appeal is dismissed']
+54561;['appeal is dismissed']
+102724;['appeal is dismissed']
+19137;['appeal is allowed']
+72916;['302 (c.a.']
+84695;['designated immigration officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+87023;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+87826;['negative']
+111155;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+120789;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+142509;['appeal is allowed']
+67597;['appeal is dismissed']
+105906;['rad agrees with the conclusion of the rpd']
+87842;['appeal is dismissed']
+54252;['court of appeal allowed the minister’s appeal']
+107098;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+128418;['allows this appeal']
+109030;['application to reopen the appeal therefore is allowed']
+50795;['appeal is allowed']
+98164;['appeal is rejected']
+64289;['appeal is dismissed']
+58751;['appeals are allowed']
+90060;['dismiss the present appeal']
+69535;['appeal is allowed']
+73893;['appeal is allowed']
+149572;['appeals are dismissed']
+98772;['neither a convention refugee, nor are you a person in need of protection']
+100884;['302 (c.a.']
+107918;['appeal is dismissed']
+23037;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+83180;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+90586;['appeal abandoned']
+100350;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+126518;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+79330;['appeal is dismissed']
+104494;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+69666;['appeal is allowed']
+89077;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+57027;['appeal is dismissed']
+34329;['appeal is allowed']
+87716;['negative']
+94643;['appeal is dismissed']
+46519;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+84667;['appeal is allowed']
+142308;['appeals are dismissed']
+130796;['removal order is set aside']
+72218;['dismiss the appeal']
+60737;['appeal is dismissed']
+132412;['appeal be allowed or dismissed']
+82158;['appeal is dismissed']
+54683;['302 (c.a.']
+96593;['appeal is allowed']
+100368;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151932;['appeal is dismissed']
+65021;['rpd therefore dismisses the application to reinstate the claim of xxxx xxxx']
+76734;['appeal is dismissed']
+99564;['appeal is allowed']
+128263;['determination is valid in law']
+123788;['appeal is dismissed']
+137453;['refugee appeal division dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56734;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+68726;['dismiss the appeal']
+79962;['reject his claim']
+61902;['appeal isallowed']
+62258;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+55198;['reject his claim']
+106872;['appeal is dismissed']
+144260;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+64633;['appeal is dismissed']
+85604;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61905;['dismiss the within appeal']
+103021;['appeal is allowed']
+77265;['appeal isallowed.the']
+133358;['302 (c.a.']
+81172;['appeal will be allowed']
+55290;['reject their claims']
+60906;['appeal is dismissed']
+142096;['claimant, xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+80207;['negative']
+103053;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+17953;['302 (c.a.']
+99706;['allow the appeal']
+151306;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71007;['appeal is dismissed']
+95371;['appeal isallowed']
+84195;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+113797;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+40801;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+77345;['appeal isallowed.the']
+98780;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123333;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+135927;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99801;['appeal is allowed.the']
+77915;['appeal is allowed']
+142815;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal of the mother']
+131020;['appeal must be dismissed']
+84761;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+61934;['appeal of yeanor kamara is dismissed']
+85596;['appeal is allowed']
+27007;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is 30']
+16822;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+74171;['302 (c.a.']
+101641;['panel makes a favourable decision']
+96294;['removal order isset aside']
+124610;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68343;['appeal is allowed']
+92776;['appeal is dismissed']
+72217;['dismissed the appeal']
+71256;['decision is wrong in law']
+64114;['appeal isabandoned.']
+139456;['appeal is dismissed']
+96895;['appeals are allowed']
+77698;['appeal is dismissed']
+93899;['appeals of philip walter leech, deborah louise leech, jordan philip leech, and ayesha maria leech are dismissed']
+26771;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+22765;['appeal is terminated']
+122544;['rad substitutes the findings of the rpd', 'decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+105645;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+74794;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+99738;['appeal should be allowed']
+26750;['appeal is dismissed']
+97774;['claim is rejected']
+67687;['appeal is allowed']
+123022;['i agree with the rpd’s conclusion']
+55512;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+108839;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101237;['removal order isset aside']
+13964;['appeal is determined']
+73187;['appeal is allowed']
+77326;['appeal is dismissed']
+104622;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+112318;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+87096;['appeal isallowed']
+130926;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133358;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee” or a “person in need of protection']
+28033;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+99763;['negative']
+64059;['appeal is dismissed']
+101268;['appeal isallowedand']
+84295;['declare the appeal herein is abandoned']
+60926;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+142957;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98271;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74680;['appeal isdeclaredabandoned undersubsection']
+83453;['appeal is allowed']
+38369;['appeal is dismissed']
+70476;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+91655;['appeal is allowed']
+130704;['appeal isallowed.the']
+123326;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101527;['appeal is dismissed']
+106301;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142491;['claimants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”', 'rejects their refugee protection claims']
+96188;['appeal is allowed']
+25962;['appeal is dismissed']
+86388;['appeal is allowed']
+94297;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+73709;['appeal is allowed']
+83505;['appeal is abandoned']
+144938;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76420;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+107608;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+97292;['appeal is determined']
+122772;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+136129;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+71443;['appeal is dismissed']
+100183;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+17148;['appeal is determined']
+142998;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95385;['appeal is terminated']
+37395;['appeals of nikolaj paul, emmanuil paul and anita paul are dismissed']
+96759;['claimant,donatha\xa0uwambajimana, is not a “convention refugee']
+100469;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+138879;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+140891;['302 (c.a.']
+141787;['appellant is excluded']
+82165;['appeal is allowed']
+107429;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+54838;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+124184;['dismiss the appeal']
+57557;['appeal is allowed']
+74735;['appeal isallowed']
+40657;['appeal is dismissed']
+97268;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+101421;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+74785;['appellant has not her permanent resident status']
+105195;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+123361;['appeal is dismissed']
+102838;['you are a convention refugee']
+146918;['appeal isdismissed.']
+68731;['appeal is dismissed']
+95638;['removal order is set aside']
+68325;['appeal were dismissed']
+50498;['appeal is dismissed']
+59674;['appeal isallowed']
+123433;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+66930;['appeal is terminated']
+48228;['appeal is postponed']
+125625;['ms.xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+143543;['claim for protection therefore fails']
+60468;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+107179;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+60316;['appeal is dismissed']
+79335;['appeal isallowed']
+79477;['appeal is allowed']
+125520;['substitute my own decision that the appellantxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+79877;['appeal is allowed']
+42393;['appeal is allowed']
+97964;['appeal is allowed']
+98139;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74586;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80127;['appeal is allowed']
+88412;['appeal is dismissed']
+46103;['appeal is terminated']
+114289;['appeal is dismissed']
+81370;['negative']
+90425;['appeal isallowed']
+98747;['three appeals are dismissed']
+61045;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+105226;['appeal is allowed']
+95010;['appeal of thanh le phung is dismissed']
+97796;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84068;['appeal is dismissed']
+39049;['appeal is dismissed']
+87786;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151556;['appeal was dismissed']
+63938;['appeal is dismissed']
+102412;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+91622;['negative']
+64622;['appeal isallowed']
+62251;['claimant is determined to be neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95663;['allow this appeal']
+123120;['appeal is dismissed']
+76258;['appeal is dismissed']
+85864;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141314;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+120761;['not uphold its decision']
+88454;['claimant,xxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+59684;['appeal is dismissed']
+89731;['appeal be dismissed']
+8299;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+55911;['appeal is dismissed']
+100266;['refugee protection claimants,xxxx xxxx, the principal claimant, his sisterxxxx xxxx, and their motherxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,are not “convention refugees”']
+85383;['decision is valid in law']
+146953;['rad is not able to substitute its own determination']
+86048;['appeal is dismissed', 'rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90188;['appeal is dismissed']
+131749;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+116770;['decision is legally valid']
+98162;['appeal is allowed']
+98335;['appeal is allowed']
+128444;['appeal is dismissed']
+135888;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+118240;['302 (c.a.']
+110287;['dismissing an appeal']
+67627;['appeal isallowed']
+17024;['appeal is allowed']
+72735;['appeal isdismissed.']
+69994;['appeal isallowed']
+122102;['rad allows the appeal', 'substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+91338;['appeal is withdrawn']
+80006;['negative']
+101481;['appeal isallowed']
+80979;['appeal is allowed']
+100513;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+127457;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+55907;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94164;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+68732;['appeal is dismissed']
+113612;['appeal is allowed']
+85602;['appeal is denied']
+106266;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+93155;['appeal isallowed']
+109171;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87206;['appeal of john edmund wilson is dismissed']
+55193;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+108845;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+92835;['appeal is dismissed']
+42213;['appeal is allowed or dismissed']
+84186;['appeal is dismissed']
+142117;['determine the claimants not to be convention refugees or persons in need of canada’s protection']
+125379;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxxand xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+80090;['appeal isallowed']
+91436;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+29687;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+87804;['appeal isallowed']
+124081;['appeal is allowed for nockeen chetolo peck']
+142980;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+81818;['appeal is dismissed']
+112373;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125583;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121196;['appeal is dismissed']
+141239;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122962;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+150683;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx is dismissed']
+99572;['appeal is allowed.the']
+47147;['appeal isallowed']
+90621;['appellant is not a sponsor within the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+140877;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99477;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+104287;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+93156;['appeal should be allowed']
+146949;['appeal is allowed']
+100813;['appeal must be dismissed']
+129258;['removal orders are set aside']
+132398;['appeal is dismissed']
+76069;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+65656;['appeal is terminated']
+31229;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+69752;['appeal is allowed']
+110684;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99036;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108756;['rad finds that the rpd’s analysis in this regard is flawed']
+93290;['appeal is dismissed']
+100125;['appeal isallowedand']
+63698;['appeal is dismissed']
+87023;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76749;['dismiss this appeal']
+78700;['appeal is allowed']
+96357;['appeal is dismissed']
+72552;['appeal isdismissed.']
+68461;['appeal is dismissed']
+54202;['appeal is allowed']
+83394;['appeal isallowed']
+79214;['appeal isterminated']
+116793;['appeal is dismissed']
+87929;['claim is rejected']
+42222;['appeal is allowed']
+42290;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151623;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+94027;['appeal is allowed']
+138874;['allow the appeal']
+84080;['appeal is allowed']
+104854;['appeal is allowed']
+21405;['refugee division determines that xxxxxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+76096;['appeal is dismissed']
+100030;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+123450;['appeal is dismissed']
+143532;['“convention refugees”']
+59995;['reject this claim to refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee']
+94100;['appeal is allowed']
+129177;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+75940;['appeal is dismissed']
+42352;['appeal will not be reopened']
+54023;['appeal is allowed']
+86339;['appeal is determined']
+68282;['appeal isallowed']
+108757;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor person in need of protection']
+97385;['302 (c.a.']
+13761;['appeal is dismissed']
+104068;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+75442;['appeal is dismissed']
+75620;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+75614;['application to re-open the appeal is granted']
+52142;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+66940;['appeal isdismissed for lack of jurisdictionbecause']
+22822;['immigration appeal division, therefore, orders your departure from canada']
+61878;['appeal is dismissed']
+77608;['appeal isallowed']
+118248;['appeal is allowed']
+138846;['appeal is allowed']
+72698;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+50469;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+34165;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+143586;['appeal is allowed']
+131735;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are excluded', 'not be refugees or persons in need of protection']
+132830;['appeal is allowed']
+89077;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100179;['appeal isdismissed.']
+75558;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+66782;['appeal is allowed']
+116352;['rpd determination must be set aside']
+42825;['appeal is dismissed']
+41087;['appeal is dismissed']
+113585;['appeal is dismissed']
+64578;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26483;['allow the appeal']
+52117;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100385;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+123793;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94605;['dismiss this appeal', 'dismiss the appeal']
+69416;['appeal is dismissed']
+90954;['appeal is allowed']
+111336;['appeal is dismissed']
+90595;['appeal is determinedto be abandonedundersection']
+89326;['appeal is terminated']
+70072;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+124442;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+47679;['appeal is dismissed']
+45998;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+81860;['appeal is allowed']
+122132;['appeal is allowed']
+54258;['appeal is dismissed']
+97084;['panel rejects this claim']
+67478;['appeal is dismissed']
+81587;['appeal is dismissed']
+27479;['appeal isallowed']
+95712;['appeal is dismissed']
+56652;['appeal is dismissed']
+98425;['dismiss the appeal']
+69675;['appeal isallowed']
+108978;['appeal is allowed']
+144022;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+94338;['appeal is abandoned']
+89965;['allow the appeal']
+128878;['appeal is dismissed']
+78011;['appeal of gurvinder singh sandhu is dismissed']
+125449;['substitute my own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+55305;['appeal of vassilios s. dovas is dismissed']
+99710;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+103891;['rad determines that the rpd decision is well founded in fact and in law']
+47153;['motion is denied']
+79231;['appeal is dismissed']
+123838;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+96466;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees']
+124079;['dismiss the appeal']
+101013;['302 (c.a.)']
+77048;['appeal is allowed']
+124444;['302 (c.a.']
+94650;['302 (c.a.)']
+94416;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+54826;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+104342;['id’s decision is set aside']
+146643;['tribunal rejects this\xa0\xa0 ']
+129395;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+21196;['dismissing the appeal']
+80115;['appeal isallowed']
+152919;['appellants are not convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+93156;['appeal isallowed']
+130775;['appeal isdeterminedto be']
+131876;['appeal is allowed']
+82892;['appeal is allowed']
+151817;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+92545;['appeal is allowed']
+124554;['appellant is a refugee of a person in need of protection']
+81139;['appeal is allowed.the']
+92531;['appeal is dismissed']
+104513;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+38856;['appeal is dismissed']
+73595;['appeal isallowedand']
+76717;['appeal is allowed']
+97335;['appeal is allowed']
+56624;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+74629;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+110927;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141816;['appeals aredismissed.']
+80713;['allows the appeal']
+66762;['appeal is dismissed']
+47311;['appeal is dismissed']
+99513;['appeal is allowed.the']
+71357;['appeal is allowed']
+153729;['sufficient humanitarian considerations']
+47405;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law']
+51077;['appeal is allowed']
+124017;['appeal is allowed']
+100632;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+140836;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93157;['appeal is allowed']
+108735;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83710;['appeal is allowed']
+142791;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86192;['appeal is dismissed']
+72017;['removal orders are set aside']
+125410;['appeal is allowed']
+94246;['appeal isallowed.the']
+138813;['appeal is dismissed']
+55307;['negative determination']
+145233;['302 (c.a.']
+96955;['appeal is terminated']
+115226;['appeal is allowed']
+105884;['appeal is allowed']
+49981;['appeal is dismissed']
+70093;['application must be dismissed']
+147464;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+101817;['favourable decision in this matter']
+62943;['appeal is dismissed']
+74169;['appeal is allowed']
+85632;['appeal is allowed']
+125020;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+111640;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+121937;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+66257;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+84244;['appeal isallowed']
+136696;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90005;['decision is well founded in law']
+150689;['negative decisions on their claims are set aside']
+121879;['dismiss the appeals', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+141213;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+87471;['appeal isallowed']
+135911;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes its own determination']
+63004;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+31984;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+135126;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102404;['appeal is dismissed']
+82896;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+97899;['dismiss the appeal']
+91326;['appeal is terminated']
+41250;['stay is quashed, or terminated', 'appeal is dismissed']
+94944;['appeal should not be dismissed']
+31217;['appeal of biju cherian is dismissed']
+40489;['appeals be rejected']
+26712;['appeal, brought']
+82580;['dismiss her appeal']
+87875;['appeal isallowed']
+91217;['application to re-open be dismissed']
+123840;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89565;['appeal must be dismissed']
+93300;['appeal is allowed']
+78775;['appeal isallowed']
+122627;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+86312;['appeal is dismissed']
+80280;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee and is not in need of protection']
+93042;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+43398;['appeal is dismissedand']
+147441;['dismissing the appeal']
+75450;['appeal isallowed']
+123729;['allow the appeal']
+132640;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+88892;['not a “person in need of protection']
+125230;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+61894;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+29711;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+59047;['appeal of mohamed sulaiman mirza is dismissed']
+122641;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+81053;['allowed the appeal']
+72874;['appeal is terminated']
+99377;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+100283;['appeal is dismissed']
+99541;['appeal isallowed']
+73677;['appeal is allowed.the']
+74221;['appeal is allowed']
+72796;['appeal isallowed']
+135198;['removal order is set aside']
+91282;['panel finds that the removal order is valid in law']
+135939;['appeal is dismissed']
+20432;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+124133;['appeal is dismissed']
+131102;['appeal is dismissed']
+112331;['appeal is allowed']
+74528;['appeal is terminated']
+111292;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+150679;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+13981;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124690;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85531;['dismiss the appeal']
+120767;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143550;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100868;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+82898;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+105815;['application was allowed']
+74486;['appeal isallowed']
+97604;['appeal is allowed']
+129907;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140211;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+120840;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143505;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99401;['appeal is allowed']
+95510;['iad allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+105893;['dismissing the appellant’s submissions']
+124982;['appeal is dismissed']
+69259;['appeal must be dismissed']
+143166;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+87850;['appeal is also dismissed']
+146070;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+59045;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+123879;['panel therefore sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision with a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90723;['appeal is dismissed']
+123066;['appeal is dismissed']
+56695;['appeal dismissed']
+107920;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses their appeals']
+82135;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+96813;['appellants to be convention refugees']
+107098;['appeal is dismissed']
+76401;['appeal isallowed.the']
+87943;['appeal is allowed']
+34107;['dismisses the appeal']
+108816;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93591;['orders your departure fromcanada.']
+92444;['appeal is allowed']
+67801;['appeal is dismissed']
+71603;['appeal isallowed']
+90580;['appeal is dismissed']
+123123;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75462;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+87824;['neither a convention refugee']
+132723;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+66251;['appeal is allowed']
+108082;['appeal is dismissed']
+124132;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+45223;['appeal is caught']
+63058;['appeal is allowed today']
+151803;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+73042;['allow the appeal']
+68148;['dismiss the appeal']
+68911;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+50511;['appeal of ana delfa robles gomez is allowed']
+52774;['appeal is allowed']
+63764;['appeal is dismissed']
+62996;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+62645;['panel rejects the claim']
+128366;['appeal is allowed']
+77333;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+68187;['appeal is allowed']
+46004;['appeal is allowed']
+61052;['children are all']
+92183;['appeal is dismissed']
+26519;['appeal of dung quoc tran is dismissed']
+125390;['allow the appeal']
+120720;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+96338;['appeal is dismissed']
+72419;['appeal is dismissed']
+93575;['appeal isallowed']
+95506;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+89966;['appeal isallowedand']
+83383;['appeal is dismissed']
+84911;['rad finds that the rpd’s state protection']
+123644;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150640;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+91413;['appeal of olexander biletsky is dismissed']
+125043;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+106629;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+103538;['appeal is dismissed']
+22804;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+94831;['appeal is terminated']
+143599;['substitute my own determination']
+94181;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+129132;['appeal is allowed']
+100898;['appeal is dismissed']
+94219;['appeal isallowed']
+87025;['appeal isallowed']
+81282;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+45233;['appeal is governed by theact']
+11015;['appeal is dismissed']
+90051;['302 (c.a.']
+106333;['appeal is dismissed']
+131528;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98347;['removal order is set aside']
+100326;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+90491;['appeal isallowed.the']
+108994;['claim is rejected']
+61646;['302 (c.a.)']
+132268;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+87991;['claimant is not convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+90620;['appeal isallowed.the']
+61544;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+63967;['appeal is dismissed']
+117141;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+100796;['appeal is allowed']
+96121;['appeal is allowed']
+131225;['appeal isallowedand']
+94828;['appeal is dismissed']
+43382;['allow his appeal']
+96688;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim']
+134280;['appeal is allowed']
+82167;['appeal was dismissed']
+122232;['1256, 1\xa0f.c.']
+149057;['appeal is allowed']
+117117;['appeal is dismissed']
+77826;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+101800;['dismiss this appeal']
+51134;['appeal be dismissed']
+72656;['dismiss this appeal']
+151558;['appeal is dismissed']
+41791;['appeal is allowed.the']
+110683;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104543;['panel therefore rejects the claims']
+134494;['appeal is dismissed']
+96169;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx, is not a“convention refugee”or']
+58185;['appeal isallowed']
+96772;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+99979;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+49317;['appeal is dismissed']
+105370;['appeal is dismissed']
+68620;['appeal is allowed']
+143869;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71222;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+105904;['not find him to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+72001;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+69473;['appeals are allowed']
+82873;['appeal is allowed']
+17978;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+87717;['negative']
+149278;['appeal is allowed']
+67389;['appeal is dismissed']
+94325;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+61448;['panel finds the exclusion order made on march 8, 2018 to be legally valid']
+132069;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+123035;['appeal is allowed']
+104937;['appeal is terminated']
+122912;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+68152;['appeal is dismissed']
+68558;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+59043;['appeal would be dismissed']
+65698;['appeal isallowed']
+151061;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+145295;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77207;['appeal isallowed']
+82081;['appeal is allowed']
+71425;['appeal of\xa0 wen huang hsiao (huang']
+99762;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+131192;['302 (c.a.']
+60964;['appeal is dismissed']
+102933;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+85960;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71749;['appeal is dismissed']
+47791;['appeal is dismissed']
+60913;['appeal is allowed']
+92401;['allow the appeal and']
+88865;['appeals are dismissed']
+80456;['appeal is dismissed']
+98749;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination rendered']
+130949;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection']
+79987;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97085;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+102161;['appeal is dismissed']
+61232;['appeal is terminated']
+95778;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding in this regard is reasonable under the circumstances']
+49230;['appeal was dismissed']
+52593;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+56684;['appeals ofbrandon daniel garcia valdezandashly dayanara garcia valdezare dismissed']
+114340;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+48096;['appeal of yu shih wong is allowed']
+83030;['appeal is brought']
+63878;['appeals are allowed']
+125303;['appeal is dismissed']
+77941;['appeal is allowed']
+93040;['302 (c.a.)']
+113279;['appellant is not a pr of canada or a protected person']
+129990;['appeal is terminated']
+134328;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87182;['appeal is allowed']
+139417;['appeal is dismissed']
+42088;['appeal is terminated']
+65641;['appeal is dismissed']
+25530;['appeal is dismissed']
+63610;['appeal is dismissed']
+63938;['appeal is terminated']
+54565;['appeal is dismissed']
+108779;['rad finds the decision of the rpd to be wrong in fact']
+77911;['appeal of yi ping liang is dismissed']
+90040;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+92939;['appeal is allowed']
+94549;['appeal is allowed']
+70211;['appeal is allowed']
+149477;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+76422;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+69668;['appeal is dismissed']
+62010;['appeal should be dismissed']
+97676;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+110924;['rad concurs with the rpd’s finding']
+107880;['dismiss this appeal']
+96142;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+57954;['appeal is allowed']
+140788;['appeal is dismissed']
+77324;['appeal is dismissed']
+69391;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+91305;['appeal be dismissed']
+83471;['appeal is dismissed']
+31389;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+40651;['appeal is allowed.the']
+151940;['302 (c.a.']
+100358;['appeal is dismissed']
+131107;['appellants are not excluded']
+123440;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+123968;['appeal is allowed']
+22701;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+104975;['appeal is allowed']
+35039;['appeal is allowed']
+54792;['appeals should be dismissed']
+124480;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+28304;['302 (c.a.']
+47565;['appeal is allowed']
+92814;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+27462;['removal order isset aside']
+71113;['appeal is dismissed']
+71798;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+89015;['appeal is dismissed']
+124181;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+51675;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+113273;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124683;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128874;['rad confirms that the appellants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are excluded from the application of the convention']
+111285;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+89455;['appeal is dismissed']
+82267;['tribunal declares the appealabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+57809;['removal order isset aside']
+151605;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+52189;['dismisses the appeal']
+70170;['appeal is allowed']
+92797;['appeal is allowed']
+96477;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96271;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+63973;['tribunal allows the appeal']
+30510;['appeal is dismissed']
+89825;['appeal is allowed']
+84629;['appeal is dismissed']
+122227;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+77229;['appeal isallowed']
+90941;['appeal is dismissed']
+123778;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+144562;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither “convention refugees']
+89439;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+147783;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+76250;['appeal is allowed']
+46392;['appeal of harneyk singh sandhu is allowed']
+139482;['appeal is determined']
+84636;['appeal is allowed']
+40803;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination that should have been made']
+101164;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+140925;['302 (c.a.']
+78746;['appeal is dismissed']
+78735;['appeal is dismissed']
+111166;['appeal is allowed']
+108071;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+90841;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”']
+38898;['appeal is allowed']
+90975;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+108666;['refugee protection division rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+143605;['appeal for mr. guo (the son) is allowed']
+88821;['appeal is allowed']
+92572;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+79465;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+100922;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75002;['appeal is terminated']
+85391;['appeal is moot']
+112778;['appeal is allowed']
+90790;['appeal is allowed']
+90092;['panel rejects these claims']
+8770;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+94585;['appeal is terminated']
+98414;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+128179;['appeal is allowed']
+88068;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+140932;['appeal is allowed']
+101523;['302 (c.a.']
+52682;['claimant’s therefore are not convention refugees or people in need of protection']
+93676;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+83652;['appeal is dismissed']
+103496;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+75900;['appeal is dismissed']
+81058;['rad grants an extension']
+105896;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+116130;['decision of the id is set aside']
+52508;['appeal isallowed.the']
+91739;['appeal is allowed']
+89855;['appeal is allowed']
+100583;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+84492;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+17940;['dismiss the request for an extension of time']
+135906;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxand their children,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+81140;['officer’s decision is valid in law', 'appeal is therefore dismissed']
+150644;['appeal is allowed']
+83825;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90832;['appeal isallowed']
+54784;['appeal isallowed']
+99939;['reject this explanation']
+111293;['appeal is dismissed']
+94034;['appeal is allowed']
+124827;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102920;['appeal is allowed']
+78778;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74188;['appellants are convention refugees']
+35240;['appeal is dismissed']
+100819;['appeal isallowedand']
+102084;['appeal is allowed']
+151835;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+60067;['appeal is allowed']
+97509;['not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+26858;['rad disagrees']
+96421;['appeal therefore cannot succeed']
+31937;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+60012;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'i reject his claim']
+143163;['appeal is dismissed']
+62013;['appeal is dismissed']
+97977;['appeal’s relative merit']
+26761;['appeal is dismissed']
+61455;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+125516;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68597;['appeal isallowed']
+101693;['appeal is determines to be abandoned']
+144752;['appeal is dismissed']
+88495;['claims fail']
+52161;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+99803;['appeal is dismissed']
+64625;['appeal is allowed']
+97347;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+84182;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+144404;['302 (c.a.']
+61637;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+93292;['claimantxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+35905;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+112335;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+86370;['appeal is dismissed']
+71460;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+12233;['dismisses the appeal']
+123606;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+125104;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92732;['appeal was dismissed']
+107430;['appeal is allowed']
+28082;['appeal is allowed']
+80018;['negative']
+95770;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+73312;['appeal isallowed']
+125632;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99302;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+101032;['appeal is allowed']
+134209;['appeal is dismissed']
+87129;['appeal isallowed']
+107376;['appeal is dismissed']
+99563;['302 (c.a.']
+113288;['appeal is allowed']
+64262;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+77312;['appeal will proceed to normal processing']
+71133;['appeal is allowed']
+105604;['302 (c.a.']
+122970;['rad, pursuant', 'substitutes a decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100185;['appeal is allowed']
+63822;['appeal of virpal kaur dhaliwal is dismissed']
+92448;['appeal is allowed']
+69366;['appeal is allowed']
+148489;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+135190;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+46042;['appeal is allowed']
+95105;['appeal is dismissed']
+94393;['dismiss this appeal']
+120798;['appeal is allowed']
+99268;['removal order is set aside']
+93849;['appeal isallowed']
+83469;['appeal is dismissed']
+71468;['allow the appeal']
+90557;['appeals are dismissed']
+100552;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+61738;['appeal terminated']
+26520;['determination is valid in law']
+50751;['appeal is allowed']
+33315;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+49983;['appeal is accepted']
+124115;['appeal is allowed']
+94101;['appeal is allowed']
+92450;['appeal isallowed.the']
+89390;['appeal is allowed']
+74616;['appeal fails']
+90842;['rad allows this appeal and sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+141250;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+97827;['negative']
+72319;['appeal isallowed']
+124109;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90575;['appeal is dismissed']
+59937;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+49125;['appeal is dismissed']
+87786;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+86377;['appeal is allowed']
+62630;['appeal is dismissed']
+134382;['appeal is allowed']
+46083;['appeal is allowed']
+105611;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+26820;['claimant, ms. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is a convention refugee']
+99228;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+110720;['appeal is dismissed']
+120715;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitute it with this one']
+82863;['appeal is dismissed']
+93653;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+71630;['appeal is allowed']
+43705;['dismiss this appeal']
+98516;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151949;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94948;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+47882;['appeal is allowed']
+67690;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse permanent resident visas is set aside']
+52303;['appeal should be dismissed']
+60961;['appeal is dismissed']
+91195;['appeal is allowed']
+68406;['appeal is allowed.the']
+60959;['appeal is dismissed']
+72739;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+93765;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+37321;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+68378;['appeal is dismissed']
+93069;['rad confirms the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+39873;['302 (c.a.']
+50763;['appeal is allowed']
+53449;['appeal isallowed.the']
+61019;['appeal is allowed']
+59787;['appeal of enana negash mebrat, is dismissed']
+128895;['not be recognized as a refugee']
+140879;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84224;['appeal is allowed']
+143621;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+54314;['appeal is allowed']
+30521;['appeals are dismissed']
+89215;['appeal is dismissed']
+52939;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+60032;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+146114;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105771;['appeal is dismissed']
+107674;['appeal is allowed']
+105172;['allow the minister’s application for dismissal of the appeal']
+95873;['appeal is dismissed']
+71660;['appeal is allowed']
+74165;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+61931;['appeal of terrence allan walcott is dismissed']
+146428;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+28161;['appeal is consequently dismissed']
+75946;['appeal is dismissed']
+84191;['appeal is dismissed']
+91614;['appeal isallowed.the']
+52164;['xxxxxx xxxxxx is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+143641;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+50738;['appeal is dismissed']
+81097;['dismissal of this appeal']
+91306;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+144021;['appeal is dismissed']
+133281;['claim is rejected']
+99466;['appeal is allowed']
+35416;['appeal is dismissed']
+125466;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84871;['appeal is terminated']
+21439;['xxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+93056;['appeals are dismissed']
+100644;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76390;['appeal is allowed']
+87141;['appeal is dismissed']
+23058;['appeal isallowed']
+24493;['appeal isallowed']
+59678;['appeal isallowed']
+44020;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92241;['dismiss the appeal']
+101272;['appeal is allowed']
+95009;['appeal must be dismissed']
+25967;['appeal were dismissed']
+96225;['appeal is allowed']
+125477;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80051;['claimants are not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+126433;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102546;['dismisses this appeal']
+127403;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+95059;['appeal is allowed']
+69065;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90549;['appeal isallowed']
+99281;['appeal is allowed']
+105755;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101283;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97572;['removal order is set aside']
+76306;['appeal is allowed']
+107829;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94422;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+93291;['appeal is allowed']
+77311;['appeal is allowed']
+93813;['claimantxxxx xxxx xxxxxxis not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140821;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+89130;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+83475;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+95159;['dismiss the appeal']
+94505;['appeal is allowed']
+72792;['appeal isallowed']
+101536;['appeal is allowed']
+73875;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+61440;['negative']
+87059;['appeal were dismissed']
+56734;['appeal isallowed']
+90459;['claimant is not in need of protection']
+83053;['appeal is allowed']
+80004;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+87800;['302 (c.a.']
+108666;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+20014;['appeal is allowed']
+33311;['appeal abandoned']
+128151;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92411;['appeal isallowedand']
+96957;['appeal is allowed']
+105825;['appeal is allowed']
+90437;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96176;['appeal is allowed']
+104126;['reject your claim']
+122617;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+98259;['appeal is allowed']
+96888;['appeals are allowed', 'determinations are set aside', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+85524;['appeal is dismissed']
+47181;['refugee protection division therefore rejectstheir claims']
+137449;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141796;['appeal is allowed']
+55298;['removal order is set aside']
+52514;['appeal isallowed']
+98702;['appeal is allowed', 'stay is cancelled']
+70193;['ms. vaziri and bahareh and pegah have no present personal establishment']
+84141;['allow this appeal']
+91069;['appeal is terminated']
+130967;['appellants, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx, are excluded from protection under the convention.they', 'are therefore neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97523;['“convention refugees”']
+148499;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+47315;['appeal underparagraph 67(1)(c) is allowed']
+99629;['appeal is allowed']
+102558;['appeal isallowed']
+87731;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95372;['appeal isallowed']
+83397;['appeal is terminated']
+127733;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+63129;['appeal is dismissed']
+102932;['appeal is dismissed']
+95586;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+98515;['appeal isallowedand']
+134741;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+76433;['allows this appeal']
+56803;['not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+85480;['appeal is terminated']
+125028;['302 (c.a.']
+96276;['negative']
+66608;['appeal isallowed']
+50666;['appeal is dismissed']
+104272;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+99353;['removal order isset aside']
+97035;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+105607;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+80501;['appeal is allowed']
+30497;['appeal is dismissed']
+134178;['removal order is set aside']
+100971;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+60947;['appeal is dismissed']
+148497;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+38845;['appeal is allowed']
+93688;['request is denied']
+122963;['appeal is allowed']
+68186;['appeal is governed by theact']
+56900;['appeal isallowed']
+113562;['appeal is dismissed']
+26808;['thatnahar singh chahilis not a member of the family class']
+144260;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+79921;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151378;['not uphold the rpd’s findings']
+101987;['appeal is allowed']
+88451;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+91708;['appeal is dismissed']
+97447;['appeal of patricio lupisan erni is allowed']
+77962;['appeal is allowed']
+144398;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+96291;['thatxxxxx xxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+91138;['appeal deals with an rpd decision']
+106667;['appeal is allowed']
+99800;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeals are dismissed']
+24492;['appeal is allowed']
+100118;['appeal is allowed']
+67935;['appeals of appellants 1, 2 and 4 are allowed', 'appeal for appellant 3 is dismissed']
+76402;['dismiss the appeal']
+69525;['dismiss the appeal']
+52190;['rpd decision to be wrong']
+96669;['appeal is dismissed']
+76527;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+75132;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71551;['appeal isallowed']
+84210;['appeal is allowed']
+124091;['substitute my own decision that the appellants areconventionrefugees']
+46506;['appeal is dismissed']
+133690;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need ofprotection']
+124913;['rad cannot confirm or set aside the rpd’s determination']
+76158;['appeal isallowed']
+76962;['appeal is dismissed']
+99286;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection', 'appeals are dismissed']
+68093;['appeal of ju young jung']
+106292;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+85522;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80061;['appeal is dismissed']
+26479;['appellant has lost his permanent resident status']
+83926;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+91710;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+136161;['appeal is dismissed']
+38383;['appeal is dismissed']
+124656;['appeal is dismissed']
+75907;['appeal order is allowed']
+72011;['appeal be dismissed']
+70026;['allow his appeal']
+69625;['case is dismissed']
+110292;['appeal is allowed']
+63762;['dismisses this appeal']
+70671;['appeal is allowed']
+59777;['appeal is discontinued']
+90143;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+85168;['dismiss the appeal']
+148994;['substitute the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+151061;['302 (c.a.']
+151802;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'dismisses the appeal']
+64273;['appeal is dismissed']
+21472;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+104496;['appeals of svitlana cheshenchuk are dismissed']
+60057;['appeal is allowed']
+77460;['appeal is dismissed']
+88865;['appeals of fareya khan and of rabeya khan are allowed']
+85542;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91761;['appeal is allowed']
+56728;['appeal is dismissed']
+42301;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+123035;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention a refugee']
+38400;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+87610;['reject his claim']
+128561;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+78724;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+94967;['dismiss the appeal']
+106429;['appeal is allowed']
+76052;['dismissing his appeal']
+35405;['claimant is not wanted by the psb']
+73050;['refusal is invalid in law']
+38836;['appeal isallowed']
+108254;['rad cannot substitute']
+106621;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47875;['appeal is allowed']
+96869;['appeal is allowed']
+28975;['appeals are dismissed']
+126450;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104280;['appeal of surinder kumar talwar is dismissed']
+95128;['appeal’s relative merit']
+136741;['appeal is allowed']
+129187;['appeal was dismissed']
+57448;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+118230;['appellants are not convention refugees', 'allow the appeal']
+71359;['appeal is dismissed']
+100339;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+68886;['dismiss this appeal']
+131913;['302 (c.a.']
+47394;['appeal is allowed']
+82855;['appeal of jit kaur atwal is dismissed']
+42357;['appeal is determined to have beenabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+92087;['not a “person in need of protection']
+95605;['rejects the claim of xxxx xxxx xxxx']
+87322;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+61377;['appeal is abandoned']
+84192;['appeal were dismissed']
+63920;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+109301;['appeal in respect of the minor appellant is dismissed']
+47301;['appeal of bhulinder singh rai is allowed']
+99577;['appeal is dismissed']
+124026;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+60054;['appeal isallowed']
+94864;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+128418;['appeal is allowed']
+121951;['appeal is dismissed']
+99596;['appeal is dismissed']
+83096;['appeal is allowed']
+123931;['appeal is allowed.the']
+108885;['i reject all of their claims']
+124827;['dismiss the appeal']
+95437;['appeal of zhong liang wu is dismissed']
+67442;['appeal is dismissed']
+118333;['appeal is dismissed']
+87469;['dismissing this appeal']
+87433;['appeal isallowed']
+96251;['appeal is dismissed']
+93650;['appeal is allowed']
+132772;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+77571;['appeal is allowed']
+102072;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+51130;['appeal isallowed']
+124878;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100916;['appeal is allowed']
+128390;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+57538;['appeals of nicolae avrigeanu and florinuta avrigeanu are allowed']
+141797;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant to be a convention refugee']
+89969;['appeal is terminated']
+147600;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77632;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92755;['appeal isdismissed.']
+125636;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+153272;['appeal is dismissed']
+13987;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107870;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+74510;['appeal is determined']
+152953;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122361;['rpd’s findings are overturned']
+97470;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+44091;['rad cannot find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+142804;['appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+76749;['appeal is allowed']
+151527;['rad allows the appeals']
+75477;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+31414;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+99970;['negative']
+95609;['appeal is dismissed']
+96717;['appeal is dismissed']
+72669;['appeal was dismissed']
+99781;['negative']
+75168;['appeal is dismissed']
+97226;['appeal is dismissed']
+140948;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees']
+123676;['not substitute my own decision']
+101784;['dismiss this appeal']
+135167;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+103053;['appeal is dismissed']
+87080;['appeal is dismissed']
+81146;['appeal is dismissed']
+88898;['claims for refugee protection are rejected']
+136418;['appeal is terminated']
+87495;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+93065;['not a “person in need of protection']
+101239;['appeal to be dismissed']
+90825;['appeal isallowed']
+124961;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88508;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46997;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83486;['departure order is hereby set aside']
+89839;['appeal is allowed']
+87128;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+30408;['appeal was not perfected']
+124975;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+12209;['i reject it']
+82737;['appeal isallowedand']
+95326;['appeal is dismissed']
+47748;['appeal is dismissed']
+87322;['appeal is allowed']
+121428;['appeal is allowed']
+149488;['rpd’s determination is wrong in fact and in law']
+90537;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status in canada']
+37856;['appeal isallowed']
+81875;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+146131;['decision granting refugee status toxxxx xxxxis vacated']
+88708;['appeal is allowed']
+82982;['appeal is dismissed']
+116800;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd.xxxxxxxxis a convention refugee']
+122994;['appeal is allowed']
+149014;['appeal is allowed']
+89484;['appeal cannot succeed']
+101252;['appeal is allowed']
+58140;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+82706;['appeal is allowed']
+88042;['negative']
+76694;['appeal is allowed']
+105366;['rad finds that the rpd’s credibility determination']
+56886;['appeal should be dismissed']
+88421;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+76482;['appeal isallowed']
+132399;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+147609;['leads me to conclude, as did the rpd']
+74049;['appeal is allowed']
+97521;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+77596;['appeal is allowed']
+132319;['substitute it with my own determination', 'the principal appellant is a convention refugee', 'sons, xxxxand xxxx, are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+75715;['appeal isallowed']
+90240;['302 (c.a.']
+91746;['appeal is allowed']
+85385;['appeal isallowed']
+68699;['appeal is allowed']
+118390;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144029;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94047;['appeal isallowed']
+79331;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90483;['appeal is allowed']
+25977;['appeal isallowed']
+54750;['appeal was dismissed']
+141062;['appeal is allowed']
+61954;['dismisses the appeal']
+124183;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+140274;['appeal has only some merit']
+99712;['appeal is allowed']
+94144;['appeal is dismissed']
+98583;['appeal is allowed']
+146118;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+98438;['appeal is terminated']
+49515;['appeal is allowed']
+71139;['appeal isallowed']
+75126;['appeal should be dismissed']
+45199;['appeal is dismissed']
+123330;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98484;['appeal isallowedand']
+151601;['appeal is allowed']
+83454;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+90182;['appeal is terminated']
+97401;['allow the appeal']
+40073;['appeal is determined']
+81878;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+75589;['appeal isallowed']
+101495;['appeal is allowed']
+127347;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+110689;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+90785;['appeal is terminated']
+96860;['appeal must be dismissed']
+28162;['appeal is dismissed']
+53763;['application is allowed']
+145812;['appeal is allowed']
+70901;['appeal must be dismissed']
+31966;['appeal is dismissed']
+67688;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101224;['appeal is dismissed']
+125609;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89582;['appeal is allowed']
+92732;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+88514;['panel rejects this claim']
+55171;['appeal is allowed']
+77052;['appeal isallowed']
+30486;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+139449;['appeal is terminated']
+101559;['allows the appeal']
+39893;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination', '“convention refugees']
+85927;['appeal isallowed']
+56674;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+144383;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+52296;['appeal isallowed']
+87115;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+103998;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+97648;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98791;['appeal is determined']
+107948;['rad finds that the rpd decision is wrong']
+69515;['appeal is dismissed']
+127356;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxxxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+144555;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+132723;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+72920;['302 (c.a.']
+74604;['appeal is dismissed']
+54312;['appeal is allowed']
+75977;['dismiss this appeal']
+146969;['appeal has been abandoned']
+136092;['cedaw/c/hti/co/8-9, p.\xa08, 9']
+101279;['appeal of the january 30, 2007 deportation order is dismissed']
+69087;['appeal isallowed']
+100968;['302 (c.a.']
+52119;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither\xa0 convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113564;['appeal is dismissed']
+71187;['appeal of benito kahl is therefore dismissed']
+29306;['appeal is dismissed']
+68189;['appeal is governed by theact']
+89415;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+97879;['appeal is allowed']
+145216;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+89864;['appeal is allowed']
+69427;['appeal isallowed']
+52519;['appeal is dismissed']
+81848;['appeal is allowed']
+148996;['us associate appellant’s appeal is dismissed']
+148606;['appeal is dismissed']
+147433;['appellants are not credible']
+81073;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+92629;['negative']
+71745;['stay of the removal order is extended']
+132826;['dismiss the present appeal']
+78773;['appeal isallowed']
+94529;['appeal is allowed']
+105365;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93816;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+97934;['appeal is dismissed']
+116819;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59407;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+131169;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+60381;['appeal is dismissed']
+62483;['appellant is neithera convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+28042;['decision is not valid in law']
+64240;['appeal is dismissed']
+136095;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+64213;['allow the appeal']
+80124;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101043;['appeal is dismissed']
+89137;['appeal is allowed']
+147595;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+69548;['appeal isallowed']
+69129;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+153286;['xxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68420;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+94253;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95556;['appeal is dismissed']
+47104;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+52267;['appeal is dismissed']
+68866;['appeal isallowed']
+132308;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the impugned decision that the appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+121951;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107045;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84734;['appeal is allowed']
+98684;['appeal is dismissed']
+106644;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'panel therefore rejects the claim']
+131211;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+114409;['appeal is allowed']
+142509;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+98244;['appeal isallowed']
+138861;['appeal in respect to warda’s application is dismissed']
+97950;['appeal of qing yun zheng is dismissed']
+61643;['allow the appeal']
+102974;['appeal is allowed']
+122969;['appeal is allowed']
+152043;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+148738;['claims are rejected']
+67572;['appeal isallowed']
+92528;['appeal isallowed']
+57064;['appeal is dismissed']
+123468;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+153282;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+22712;['appeal is dismissed']
+127394;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+69718;['appeal isallowed']
+131912;['dismissing the appeal']
+100457;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+62964;['claimants,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxare convention refugees']
+94424;['stay is cancelled']
+69101;['appeal is dismissed']
+137678;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+54551;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+95555;['appeal should be allowed', 'appeal is allowed']
+97426;['refugee protection claim of xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx is rejected']
+55274;['xxxxxxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+71112;['appeal is allowed']
+124125;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+101298;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that he is a convention refugee']
+83146;['appeal is dismissed']
+130744;['appeal is allowed']
+77665;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+99410;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+110313;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88853;['appeal is dismissed']
+36119;['appeal is dismissed']
+89854;['not\xa0 “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+94203;['appeal is allowed']
+95464;['appeal is dismissed']
+82454;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+89717;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+94711;['appeals are dismissed']
+101766;['dismiss the within appeal']
+79240;['appeal is dismissed']
+89093;['rejects this claim']
+21408;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+125695;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+75986;['appeal isallowed']
+62639;['appeals are decided in chambers']
+98931;['thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+69424;['appeal be allowed']
+82656;['302 (c.a.)']
+16756;['application to reinstate the appeal is allowed']
+99700;['appeal isallowed']
+95769;['appeal is rejected']
+102173;['appeals are allowed']
+102723;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68024;['appeal is dismissed']
+150666;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+69339;['appeal is dismissed']
+86852;['appeal is allowed']
+19726;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+76013;['appeal is dismissed']
+81181;['appeal be dismissed']
+77628;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+102018;['appeal is dismissed']
+55884;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+88132;['appeal is dismissed']
+94761;['appeal is dismissed']
+120772;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+38406;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+85981;['appeal is allowed']
+128259;['appeal is thus dismissed']
+141809;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87082;['appeal be dismissed']
+84436;['appeal isallowed']
+113252;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+59777;['appeal is terminated']
+141809;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+49519;['appeal is dismissed']
+47755;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76430;['appeal isallowed']
+75611;['appeal isallowed']
+61466;['reject his claim']
+68134;['appeal is allowed']
+72322;['appeal isallowedand']
+66311;['appeal is dismissed']
+135450;['claims are rejected']
+26541;['appeal is dismissed']
+82211;['appeal isdismissedand adeparture order is made against the appellant']
+30402;['appeal is dismissed']
+95774;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96356;['appeal is dismissed']
+67651;['appeal is dismissed']
+31045;['appeal isallowed']
+56696;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed', 'appeal of stanhope st. aubyn cooper is dismissed']
+84297;['appeal is allowed']
+93925;['appeal is allowed']
+69580;['appeal is dismissed']
+110291;['appeal is dismissed']
+100169;['appeal is dismissed']
+129914;['appeal is denied']
+129934;['appeal is dismissed']
+100236;['appeal is allowed']
+83831;['appeal is allowed']
+110925;['appellants’ argument']
+54228;['appeal dismissed']
+92931;['appeal is terminated']
+96567;['allowed the appeal']
+105822;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+92831;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+130682;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100365;['appeal is allowed']
+123441;['appeal of the principal appellant is allowed']
+124952;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94534;['appeal is allowed']
+124088;['appeal is allowed']
+23104;['appeal was dismissed']
+13949;['appeal is dismissed']
+128188;['appeal is dismissed']
+60074;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+143590;['appeal is allowed']
+78127;['appeal is allowed']
+114438;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+76748;['appeal is allowed']
+52282;['appeal isallowed']
+76635;['appeal is allowed']
+83022;['appeal of henh lay is dismissed']
+66570;['appeal isallowed']
+75585;['appeal is allowed']
+122259;['appeal is allowed']
+121747;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+47930;['appeal is deemed to be abandoned']
+142912;['appeal is dismissed']
+100431;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+101393;['appeal isallowed']
+38877;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+40489;['appeals are allowed']
+100898;['302 (c.a.']
+117155;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+105912;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+67537;['appeal is allowed']
+87966;['appeal is allowed']
+23063;['appeal is allowed.the']
+82640;['appeal is dismissed']
+138816;['appeal is dismissed']
+141314;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis excluded', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+128349;['appeal is allowed']
+92753;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+85232;['appeal is allowed']
+96169;['negative']
+94931;['appeal be allowed']
+56767;['claimant is excluded from the application of the convention']
+76052;['appeal is dismissed']
+151979;['support a favourable decision']
+129915;['appeal is allowed']
+20006;['appeal being dismissed']
+101339;['appeal be dismissed']
+73203;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+104469;['appeal of cheng bo he isdismissed']
+71164;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84438;['appeal isallowed']
+101269;['substitutes the determination']
+148934;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+95936;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision in this matter was wrong in fact and law']
+110306;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+14396;['appeal is dismissed']
+69243;['302 (c.a.)']
+5587;['theappeal is allowed']
+101006;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+63079;['claimants, therefore, are not persons in need of protection']
+79742;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+92522;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+128338;['appeal is allowed']
+133725;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+63904;['appeal is terminated']
+95645;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+73215;['appeal isallowed']
+37832;['appeal be dismissed']
+83256;['appeal is dismissed']
+63514;['negative']
+122807;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+129202;['appeal is allowed']
+56379;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+51050;['appeal is allowed']
+76976;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law', 'appeal is dismissed']
+46069;['appeal abandoned']
+99143;['appeal is allowed']
+60906;['decision is legally valid']
+59928;['appeal of amandeep kaur bains is dismissed']
+17965;['appeal were dismissed']
+83551;['appeal isallowed']
+28066;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76714;['appeal of\xa0 hong yang wen is dismissed']
+146437;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+80134;['appeal is allowed']
+52131;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+130923;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+100676;['302 (c.a.)']
+85539;['appeal is dismissed']
+95238;['appeal is allowed in law']
+114423;['appellant is not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+49150;['appeal is allowed']
+91108;['decision of the adjudicator cannot be allowed to stand']
+83720;['appeal is allowed']
+76929;['appeal is determined']
+123086;['appeal is allowed']
+117147;['appeal is allowed.the']
+92504;['appeal is dismissed']
+93689;['appeal isallowed.the']
+100426;['allow the appeal']
+100586;['claim is rejected']
+98995;['appeal is dismissed']
+50500;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+133278;['302 (c.a.']
+77870;['appeal failed']
+83436;['appeal of neelab rahimi is dismissed']
+99631;['appeal is allowed']
+122685;['dismiss this application to reinstate the claims']
+77842;['refugee protection division determines the claimant not to be a convention refugee and not to be a person in need of protection']
+100756;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90670;['appeal is granted']
+35237;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+67698;['appeal is dismissed']
+77067;['appeal is allowed']
+77781;['appeal is allowed']
+100138;['appeal isallowed']
+70174;['appeal is allowed']
+77797;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+83724;['appeal is dismissed']
+130937;['appeal is allowed']
+95242;['appeal is dismissed']
+36469;['appeal isallowed']
+106818;['287 (34+3+36+24+73+75+42']
+99787;['appeal is allowed']
+85495;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+33692;['appeal should be dismissed']
+110946;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106871;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+72215;['appeal is allowed']
+106144;['removal orders areset aside']
+105220;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+91397;['302 (c.a.']
+75000;['appeal is dismissed']
+134296;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80233;['negative']
+71743;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+142077;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+106132;['five appeals are allowed']
+68235;['302 (c.a.']
+54181;['appeal is dismissed']
+69933;['appeal is dismissed']
+59977;['negative']
+60821;['appeal is dismissed']
+45177;['appeal is allowed']
+96368;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+153143;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+95678;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+61294;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+67240;['claimantxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+107687;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+149016;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither conventions refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123009;['appeal is allowed']
+95398;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83839;['appeal should be allowed']
+60832;['appeal will be reconsidered']
+91190;['appeal is allowed']
+76627;['decision of the visa officer is well founded in law']
+60442;['appeal of asadullah hedaiat is dismissed']
+50648;['appeal is dismissed']
+72212;['appeal isallowed.the']
+30487;['appeal is dismissed']
+151888;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+127913;['claimants having failed to establish a well-founded fear of persecution', 'panel finds that they are not convention refugees']
+124537;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither aconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81214;['appeal is dismissed']
+37843;['appeal is allowed.the']
+83057;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+72830;['appeal isallowed']
+77326;['appeal were dismissed']
+82639;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80666;['negative']
+52137;['rad finds the appellant’s claim fails']
+81126;['appeal is allowed']
+64002;['appeal is allowed']
+95582;['application is allowed']
+90120;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+62119;['dismiss the appeal']
+107576;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98255;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+48414;['determination is valid in law']
+136148;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142944;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+124649;['appeal is allowed']
+98216;['appeal is allowed']
+150347;['appeal is allowed']
+145027;['appeal is allowed']
+42305;['appeal of philip santigue kamara is dismissed']
+75956;['appeal is allowed']
+106795;['appeal isallowed']
+74561;['appeal is allowed']
+96836;['negative']
+132272;['rpd determination is set aside']
+39912;['appeal isallowed']
+47341;['dismiss this appeal']
+69981;['appeal isallowed']
+68735;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+61921;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+39570;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+82367;['appeal abandoned']
+101647;['nor a permanent resident of canada']
+70183;['appeals of yi yun chen and jun tiao huang are dismissed']
+95331;['appeal is dismissed']
+143554;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxxxxxcannot be a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+128547;['appeal is allowed']
+14579;['support dismissal of the appeal']
+136671;['is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96865;['terminates her appeal']
+100265;['appeal isallowedand']
+82898;['appeals of doroteo jr. penaflor oliveros, josephine santa maria oliveros, kyle marc santa maria oliveros, kim peregrine santa maria oliveros and kit joseph santa maria oliveros are dismissed']
+72711;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+146122;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+104936;['allowed the appeal']
+55280;['declare the claim of xxxxxxxxxxxx to have been abandoned']
+128168;['appeals are dismissed']
+149567;['rad concurs with the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93807;['negative']
+106280;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131159;['appeal is allowed']
+61016;['claim is rejected']
+77923;['appeal is dismissed']
+74554;['appeal is dismissed']
+62903;['appeal should be dismissed']
+99691;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+140630;['appeal is allowed']
+123340;['appeal is allowed']
+99941;['claimants to not be convention refugees']
+76917;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+103543;['appeal of abdul basit mannir is dismissed']
+96269;['appeal has been abandoned']
+61899;['appeal is dismissed']
+61550;['appeals of marcelo litan and his wife, elvia correa, are dismissed']
+93343;['appeal is dismissed']
+100184;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59183;['appeal is allowed']
+90938;['dismiss the appeal']
+124727;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+19381;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44022;['appeal is allowed']
+54321;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+96333;['removal order is set aside']
+109532;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69370;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+106290;['appeal is dismissed']
+141624;['appeal is allowed']
+71738;['appeal is dismissed']
+127345;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102108;['appeal were dismissed']
+120791;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123533;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+101290;['rad dismisses the minister’s appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+102210;['appeal is dismissed']
+89846;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+107248;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+92938;['appeal is allowed']
+110296;['dismissing an appeal']
+76535;['appeal is allowed']
+91170;['appeal is allowed']
+98977;['appeal filed by xxxx xxxx is dismissed']
+80978;['appeal is allowed']
+97485;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147574;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+56615;['appeal is allowed']
+23846;['appeal is allowed']
+62988;['allows this appeal']
+152906;['rpd is set aside']
+141646;['appeal is allowed']
+90254;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46551;['appeal is allowed']
+91525;['appeal is granted']
+100192;['allows the appeal']
+90641;['appeal is allowed']
+13945;['appeal is dismissed']
+77807;['you are not a convention refugee and neither are you a person in need of protection']
+141590;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95330;['appeal is allowed']
+101296;['appeal isallowedand']
+95177;['appeal being allowed in law']
+130352;['appeal is allowed']
+88142;['appeal is dismissed']
+78773;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87051;['appeal was dismissed']
+109625;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+99855;['appeal of yassah nowu quiqui is dismissed']
+57917;['appeal is allowed']
+71405;['appeal is dismissed']
+106422;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+33319;['appeal of alemayehu takele hagos is dismissed']
+144419;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+102484;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+125605;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+149112;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77852;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+132284;['rpd’s decision is set aside']
+123125;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is aconventionrefugee']
+85458;['stay of the removal order   is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+68890;['appeal is dismissed']
+55291;['refugee protection division determines that\xa0 xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+100613;['appeal is terminated']
+87466;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+84424;['appeal isallowed']
+120780;['appeal is allowed']
+84662;['appeal of yuniar indriati is dismissed']
+63698;['appeals are dismissed']
+54304;['appeal is dismissed']
+78739;['appeal isallowed']
+108208;['rad finds that the rpd did not err in its assessments']
+65296;['appeal is dismissed']
+59034;['appeal is dismissed']
+74642;['theappealis dismissed']
+67372;['appeal is allowed']
+65697;['appeal isdismissed.']
+96884;['appeal is allowed']
+95769;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142845;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+69391;['negative']
+86344;['appealis allowed']
+94020;['appeal is allowed']
+97419;['302 (c.a.']
+127910;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96011;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90254;['302 (c.a.']
+90751;['appeal is allowed']
+98229;['dismissing the appeal']
+129894;['appeal is deemed abandoned']
+74876;['appeal is dismissed']
+147887;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+51128;['302 (c.a.)']
+123340;['rpd’s negative determination is set aside', 'positive decision is substituted']
+141672;['appeals are dismissed']
+35925;['declare her appeal to be abandoned']
+102666;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+17151;['appeal abandoned']
+63963;['appeal is dismissed']
+68877;['dismiss the appeal']
+109396;['decision of the rpd']
+15015;['302 (c.a.']
+48226;['appeal is allowed']
+78768;['appeal is allowed']
+124656;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither conventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61922;['rpd decision stands']
+123640;['decision of the rpd is therefore set aside']
+40377;['appeal fails']
+122654;['appeals are allowed']
+24185;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+82872;['appeal is allowed.the']
+47724;['adoption is invalid in law']
+124006;['appeal is allowed']
+51284;['appeal is allowed']
+94013;['exclusion order is set aside']
+88077;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+27236;['appeal is allowed']
+61440;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+68783;['removal order is set aside']
+146900;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+130993;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67017;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+100690;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+95993;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+139473;['appeal is allowed']
+73591;['appeal isallowed']
+82986;['appeal is dismissed']
+127698;['appeal is dismissed']
+61871;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76903;['appeal isallowedand']
+91742;['appeal is allowed']
+76427;['appeal is dismissed']
+141686;['appeal is allowed.the']
+69075;['appeal of dun wang is dismissed']
+82714;['appeal is dismissed']
+135918;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes that decision with its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+99026;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77228;['appeals of the principal appellant']
+114352;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+94374;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+80362;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95896;['appeal is dismissed']
+96887;['appeal of greg mark sinnett is allowed']
+52220;['appeal is dismissed']
+96374;['appeal is dismissed']
+124538;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101148;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+47344;['appeal is allowed']
+140713;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”']
+47372;['appeal is allowed']
+57907;['appeal were dismissed']
+151742;['appeal is dismissed']
+141278;['appeal is allowed']
+74721;['appeal isallowed']
+140066;['rpd’s determination is set aside', 'rad substitutes this determination']
+63914;['appeal is allowed']
+124542;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+151874;['confirms the determination of the rpd']
+46104;['appeal is terminated']
+56874;['appeal division did not have jurisdiction to hear the appeal', 'dismissed the appeal']
+69402;['claimants are not convention refugees or are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+54310;['deny the minister’s application to dismiss']
+129409;['appeal is allowed']
+151502;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110042;['appeal is allowed']
+131705;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+28075;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+131026;['appeal is allowed']
+94686;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+128265;['appeal isallowed']
+92491;['appeal is allowed']
+106271;['appeals are dismissed']
+69600;['not find that the applicant has temporary resident status']
+132365;['appeal is allowed']
+49059;['appeal is allowed']
+134237;['appeal isallowed']
+99498;['appeal be dismissed']
+95772;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61738;['appeal is terminated']
+81077;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69530;['appeal isallowed']
+67177;['appeal is allowed']
+67193;['appeal is dismissed']
+8290;['removal order isset aside']
+98533;['negative']
+77251;['appeal isallowed']
+39584;['appeal is dismissed']
+70781;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+43325;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+98672;['appeal is allowed']
+83532;['appeal is allowed']
+94465;['appeal is allowed']
+153271;['appeal is dismissed']
+71679;['appeal isallowed']
+57032;['appeal is dismissed']
+123883;['appeal is allowed']
+67758;['appeal must be dismissed']
+26939;['claimant, not to be a convention refugee']
+106144;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+90130;['negative', 'negative']
+143892;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+31937;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90993;['appeal is dismissed']
+130943;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+13971;['appeal is allowed']
+130782;['appeal is terminated']
+84153;['appeal is allowed']
+70192;['appeal is dismissed']
+59988;['negative']
+74688;['appeal is governed by theact']
+131143;['appeal isallowed']
+51768;['appeal is allowed']
+74072;['appeal is allowed']
+152041;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+123433;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+20002;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+48092;['appeal is dismissed']
+85172;['decision should be set aside']
+90227;['negative']
+130968;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+117186;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+109537;['appeal is discontinued']
+61450;['302 (c.a.']
+86309;['appeal is allowed']
+141683;['appeal is allowed']
+26965;['xxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+101184;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+129174;['appeal is dismissed']
+49972;['appeal is dismissed']
+77314;['appeal is dismissed']
+129852;['appeal dismissed']
+92467;['appeal isallowed']
+96898;['substitutes its determination that the appellant has established her personal and national identity']
+111316;['appeal is allowed']
+102897;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88123;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76309;['appeal is allowed.the']
+107192;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+81315;['appeal is dismissed']
+49165;['appeal isallowed']
+78728;['appeal was dismissed']
+151344;['appeal is allowed']
+95227;['appeals are dismissed']
+132771;['decision must be set aside']
+105315;['rad finds that there was no denial of natural justice']
+44988;['appeal is allowed']
+85963;['allow the appeal']
+78663;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95937;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+100124;['302 (c.a.']
+62394;['appeal is allowed']
+78332;['appeal would be dismissed']
+73199;['appeal of ashvinkumar hashmukh vyas is allowed']
+27008;['xxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+84457;['appeal is dismissed']
+26946;['302 (c.a.)']
+153268;['appeals are dismissed']
+82805;['appeal isallowed']
+62933;['appeal of opinder singh braich is dismissed']
+87731;['appeal is allowed.the']
+89961;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+99786;['appeal is dismissed']
+97951;['negative']
+84258;['appeal is dismissed']
+103531;['appeal isallowed']
+125664;['appellant,xxxx xxxx,is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+88063;['rad does not need to intervene']
+87160;['dismiss the appeal']
+24483;['appeal is denied']
+105808;['appeal is dismissed']
+124270;['appeal were dismissed']
+67723;['appeal is dismissed']
+102155;['appeal is dismissed']
+142822;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97591;['appeals are allowed']
+71798;['302 (c.a.)']
+48590;['appeal isallowed']
+37416;['appeal is allowed']
+123695;['uphold the rpd’s findings']
+94400;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+75442;['appeal is dismissed']
+125524;['not be granted refugee protection']
+142904;['302 (c.a.']
+88086;['appeal is allowed']
+99459;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100992;['allow the appeal from the']
+142487;['uphold the rpd member’s finding on this issue']
+140941;['i agree with the rpd’s conclusion']
+76382;['appeal is dismissed']
+128389;['appeal is dismissed']
+19130;['appeal is allowed']
+53410;['rad’s intervention is justified']
+29636;['appeal be allowed']
+107810;['neither a “conventionrefugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+79203;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+124104;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+102154;['appeal is allowed']
+105343;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97256;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86937;['appeal is dismissed']
+68088;['appeal is allowed']
+98100;['appeal is allowed']
+72173;['theappeal is allowed']
+92181;['appeal is allowed']
+91658;['appeal isallowed']
+87466;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+93119;['302 (c.a.)']
+77944;['appeal is dismissed']
+89212;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102911;['claimant is not a convention refugee,']
+69092;['appeal is allowed']
+81373;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+55149;['appeals of charles adafe adigolo, evelyn adeola adigolo, precious ejirooghene adigolo, victoria oghenerukwe odigolo, and emmanuela oluseyi adigolo are dismissed']
+59685;['appeal is dismissed']
+74572;['appeal is dismissed']
+91324;['appeal is caught']
+124479;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+113617;['appeal is dismissed']
+44735;['appeal isallowed']
+120785;['appeal is allowed']
+59707;['appeal isdismissed.']
+77473;['appeal is terminated']
+102564;['appeal is terminated']
+77454;['appeal is dismissed']
+93889;['appeal is allowed']
+90708;['appeal is allowed']
+142090;['302 (c.a.']
+148632;['appellants are neither   convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+28075;['appeal is dismissed']
+67922;['appeal must be dismissed']
+62704;['appeal is dismissed']
+125336;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145347;['302 (c.a.']
+97902;['removal order is set aside']
+143245;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+80749;['panel rejects the brief’s conclusion in this regard']
+87724;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+67711;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse permanent resident visas is set aside']
+83893;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+98602;['removal order is set aside']
+97591;['appeals of rasbhinder kaur singh, baldeep kaur grewal and gundeep kaur grewal are allowed']
+123287;['nor a likelihood of harm']
+97237;['reject his claim']
+135163;['appeal is allowed']
+82658;['appeal is terminated']
+122547;['302 (c.a.']
+100801;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+92841;['appeal isallowed']
+128276;['appeal is allowed']
+76052;['dismiss the appeal']
+78169;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+118638;['appeal is dismissed']
+141045;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+127341;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96289;['reference has been removed']
+139840;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108841;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94345;['appeal is allowed.the']
+130781;['appeal is allowed']
+41252;['appeal is allowed']
+79478;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+82694;['appeal is dismissed']
+99531;['appeal of ever adan castro is dismissed']
+98450;['appeal is dismissed']
+69948;['appeal is allowed']
+145109;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitute it with the determination that should have been rendered', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+60053;['appeal isallowed']
+113530;['appeal is dismissed']
+80240;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+81095;['appeal is allowed']
+96174;['appeal is dismissed']
+63856;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+52784;['appeal is allowed']
+101789;['appeal is dismissed']
+64921;['appeal is dismissed']
+94333;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+13988;['appeal is dismissed']
+22805;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+121519;['appeal is dismissed']
+101866;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95046;['appeal is dismissed']
+106265;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+57094;['appeal is dismissed']
+38852;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90827;['appeal be re-heardde']
+59046;['appeal were dismissed']
+123536;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88118;['appeal is dismissed']
+45419;['appeal of george kimpex boateng is dismissed']
+94920;['appeal isallowed']
+101910;['refugee protection claim filed byxxxx xxxx xxxxis rejected']
+82136;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+144755;['appeal is dismissed']
+46501;['appeal is allowed']
+86538;['dismiss the appeal']
+90910;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+107621;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+97422;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+150726;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70576;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101671;['appeal is dismissed']
+33323;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+122909;['appeal is allowed']
+78015;['determination is valid in law']
+72619;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+96669;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116828;['appeal is allowed']
+68339;['allow the appeal of thi bich lieu doan in law']
+131874;['rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+50930;['appeal is allowed']
+69984;['appeal isallowed']
+128177;['appeal is dismissed']
+108774;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+110564;['rad disagrees']
+80478;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+130849;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”']
+123888;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95342;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination']
+141156;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76321;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+70210;['allows her appeal']
+122228;['appeal is allowed', 'appellant is a person in need of protection']
+60908;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77636;['decision is well founded in law']
+77899;['appeal is dismissed']
+122129;['grant the appeal']
+97419;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor she is a person in need of protection']
+13759;['appeal is determined']
+129894;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+28197;['application to re-open is allowed']
+131870;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131148;['i am going to allow the appeal']
+57563;['appeal of paras gunvantkumar patel is allowed']
+76079;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+52065;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate reasons']
+93667;['appeal is allowed.the']
+118236;['appeal is dismissed']
+54245;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+120824;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+105369;['request for an oral hearing is dismissed']
+143888;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52265;['appeal isallowed']
+69655;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+94249;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+46534;['appeal turns primarily on four concerns']
+135941;['rpd decision is therefore correct']
+84430;['appeal is dismissed']
+132745;['rad is unable to substitute its own determination']
+84717;['appeal is terminated']
+144386;['rad concurs with the rpd’s determination of these claims']
+143232;['appeal of joel yutuc malang is dismissed']
+121477;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+88402;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+80498;['appeal is allowed']
+86462;['appeals are dismissed']
+46488;['application to re-open the appeal is dismissed']
+87976;['claimants are therefore not persons in need of protection']
+64244;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+108903;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need or protection']
+67665;['appeal isallowed']
+96308;['reject the claim', 'reject his claim']
+60464;['couple to be compatible']
+94619;['appeal is terminated']
+151758;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+112341;['appeal is allowed']
+37832;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123660;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94380;['appeal is dismissed']
+84245;['appeal isallowed']
+128178;['appeal is dismissed']
+100899;['appeal is dismissed']
+100444;['xxxxxx xxxxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47282;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+58123;['appellant’s appeal is dismissed']
+81877;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52756;['appeal is dismissed']
+70916;['appeal isallowed']
+96225;['appeal is allowed']
+62936;['appeal is allowed']
+104087;['panel finds the removal order valid in law']
+92153;['appeal is dismissed']
+46990;"[""application to reopen the appellant's sponsorship appeal is denied""]"
+114342;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96253;['appeal is terminated']
+150629;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxand xxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugeesnor persons in need of protection']
+69550;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+117117;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+78679;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+8336;['appeal abandoned']
+76379;['appeal is allowed']
+74987;['decision must be upheld']
+68596;['appeal isallowed']
+47188;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+96141;['appeal isallowed']
+83363;['appeal is terminated']
+135469;['dismiss this appeal']
+61297;['immigration appeal division therefore orders the following person’s removal from canada']
+54824;['appeal to rad is dismissed']
+94408;['appeal is allowed']
+108740;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67472;['appeal isallowed']
+151618;['rad allows the appeal']
+93342;['appeal is allowed']
+87335;['appeal isallowed']
+78057;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+81148;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+101532;['appeal isallowed']
+13830;['appeal isallowed']
+36950;['appeal is moot']
+61942;['appeal is dismissed']
+89837;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+43263;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+116191;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+41681;['reject this   ']
+125019;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94155;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+151496;['appeal is dismissed']
+37529;['appeal is dismissed']
+34872;['302 (c.a.)']
+13630;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+77436;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80192;['she is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+105231;['appeal is dismissed']
+108125;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+23109;['appeal is allowed']
+135473;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nora person in need of protection']
+98716;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96584;['appeal is allowed']
+148741;['confirms your citizenship']
+129241;['appeal is allowed']
+114318;['substitute it with my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+54809;['appeal is allowed']
+142063;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104860;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+23030;['appeal is dismissed']
+124931;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+87810;['appeal isallowed']
+88456;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+94440;['appeal is dismissed']
+34875;['appeal is allowed']
+141399;['appeal is allowed']
+100125;['appeal was dismissed']
+86003;['appeal is allowed']
+95065;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of canada’s protection']
+153018;['claimant is not a convention refugee,']
+84078;['appeal isallowed']
+62831;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+123441;['substitute my own decision that she is a convention refugee']
+97937;['appeal of james cameron george yavis is dismissed']
+121455;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107923;['application is allowed']
+57534;['appeal of xinfeng ma is dismissed']
+65128;['appeal dismissed']
+39057;['iad lacks jurisdiction to hear this appeal']
+140919;['appellant is therefore a convention refugee']
+91414;['appeal of wayne ellison is dismissed']
+76099;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+99801;['appeal is allowed']
+81168;['appeal is dismissed']
+83831;['appeal is allowed']
+92143;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+48102;['application for reconsideration is granted']
+120758;['allow the appeal']
+94649;['appeal isallowed']
+88307;['appeal is allowed']
+99670;['appeal is allowed']
+150926;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100926;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'panel therefore rejects their claims']
+36246;['dismiss the appeal']
+79937;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+101285;['302 (c.a.']
+85974;['appeal isallowed']
+98861;['appeal is allowed']
+76685;['appeals of devinder singh sodhi, his wife rani sodhi and his son karanveer singh sodhi are dismissed']
+67626;['appeal isallowed']
+107593;['appeal isallowed']
+97642;['negative']
+145853;['appeal is dismissed']
+96743;['negative']
+140981;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69729;['appeal is allowed']
+102751;['appeal is allowed']
+67235;['dismiss this appeal']
+111314;['appeal is allowed']
+77274;['appeal isallowed']
+60977;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+23063;['dismiss the appeal']
+42417;['appeal is dismissed']
+60918;['allows this appeal']
+108998;['302 (c.a.']
+148507;['claim is rejected']
+63095;['claimant is determined not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68178;['appeal is allowed']
+74118;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+47929;['appeal is allowed']
+103024;['appeal is dismissed']
+81005;['dismisses this appeal']
+98819;['appeal is allowed']
+133708;['he is a convention refugee']
+124676;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54726;['appeal is allowed.the']
+142973;['confirm the rpd decision']
+116781;['confirms the rpd’s determination']
+140980;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+42318;['appeals are dismissed']
+13975;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+46027;['appeal is allowed']
+23009;['allow the appeal']
+81925;['appeal is allowed']
+57548;['appeal is dismissed']
+127339;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis excluded from refugee protection']
+133345;['appeal is allowed']
+146943;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+79689;['appeal is dismissed']
+81142;['appeal is allowed']
+74654;['appeal would be dismissed']
+106831;['appeal is dismissed']
+60427;['302 (c.a.']
+125464;['aa’s appeal is dismissed']
+57083;['appeal is allowed']
+145427;['dismiss the appeal']
+82804;['appeal is allowed']
+130771;['appeal is allowed']
+143194;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+71116;['claims are rejected']
+77782;['appeal is terminated']
+141402;['application for an extension of time is denied']
+94987;['appeal is dismissed']
+95077;['appeal is dismissed']
+91928;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+23846;['appeal is allowed.the']
+55198;['claimantxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+55176;['appeals of yizhi luo and qicheng xing are dismissed']
+83507;['appeal isallowedas regardsaibutalifu aisikaer.accordingly']
+97599;['302 (c.a.']
+104460;['cancel the stay of removal', 'allow the appeal']
+90144;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+73262;['dismiss this appeal']
+139445;['appeal is allowed.the']
+106291;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+45205;['appeal isallowed']
+80242;['rejects the claim']
+133719;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68581;['appeal is dismissed']
+108761;['rad rejects both of these explanations']
+125091;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104124;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+134293;['appeal is dismissed']
+95457;['appeal is dismissed']
+85854;['division rejects both of their claims']
+66322;"[""iad's order granting the stay is cancelled"", 'appeal is dismissed']"
+125662;['rad considers the rpd’s decision to be correct']
+87138;['appeal isallowed']
+77437;['appeal is allowed']
+71225;['appeal of mantejinder singh dhillon is dismissed']
+142466;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+81080;['appeal is allowed']
+14708;['dismiss the section 70 appeal']
+110945;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77859;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+100704;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76712;['application of the respondent is dismissed']
+142994;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99977;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+63167;['appeal is terminated']
+47392;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law', 'appeal is allowed in law']
+60046;['findxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+102753;['application to be dismissed']
+129932;['allow the appeal']
+78665;['panel dismisses the appeal']
+43728;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+73894;['appeal isallowed.the']
+72662;['appeal is allowed']
+no_match_filename;['appeal is dismissed']
+52084;['appeal abandoned']
+83903;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+151006;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89834;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54755;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+117189;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+142475;['rad grants xxxx appeal', 'substitutes its decision in place of the decision rendered by the rpd']
+47921;['appeal is determined']
+54183;['appeal were dismissed']
+14690;['appeal is allowed']
+91638;['appeal is allowed']
+139422;['appeal is dismissed']
+92985;['appeal isallowedand']
+104144;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+151748;['appeal is dismissed']
+94237;['appeal is not allowed']
+124975;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+140734;['appeal is dismissed']
+78724;['removal order is set aside']
+80474;['appeal of tsang sheng ma is dismissed']
+80253;['negative']
+152055;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+36188;['sufficient humanitarianand compassionate considerations']
+92430;['appeal is terminated']
+97279;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'rejects the claims']
+98807;['appeal isallowedand']
+150622;['appeal for xxxx xxxx xxxx is dimissed.']
+128567;['appeal is allowed']
+92755;['appeal be dismissed']
+122958;['rejects the claim of the principal appellant’s son']
+52056;['appeal is terminated']
+142794;['thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108837;['claims are rejected']
+131912;['dismissed the appeal']
+142488;['i disagree with the rpd’s determination of the facts']
+81239;['appeal is allowed']
+82116;['appeal be dismissed']
+78760;['appeal is allowed']
+91120;['appeal is dismissed']
+59793;['appeal is allowed']
+78722;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+125483;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+145420;['appeal is dismissed']
+72320;['appeal isallowed']
+86942;['appeal is allowed']
+139438;['appeal is dismissed']
+97373;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+125486;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88123;['appeal is allowed']
+47109;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+101204;['application to reopen the appeal is granted']
+107487;['302 (c.a.']
+109035;['appeal is dismissed']
+71420;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+52316;['appeal is allowed']
+99927;['appeal is dismissed']
+67400;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+95668;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+128930;['appeal is allowed']
+121477;['appeals are dismissed']
+36112;['appeal is allowed']
+115182;['dismissed the appeal']
+60987;['appeal is dismissed']
+82906;['appeal is allowed']
+149283;['appeals are dismissed']
+57774;['appeal is allowed']
+116899;['appeal is dismissed']
+89222;['appeal is dismissed']
+47346;['appeal beallowed']
+84560;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+100996;['appeal is terminated']
+82719;['appeal is dismissed']
+95369;['appeal isallowed']
+100312;['claims are rejected']
+151411;['appeal is allowed']
+43396;['appeal is dismissed']
+40078;['appeal is allowed']
+136135;['appeal is allowed']
+59977;['reject the claimants’ claims']
+97338;['appeal in abeyance is dismissed']
+102559;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+90262;['appeal isallowed']
+89994;['dismissing this appeal in law']
+76291;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+57785;['appeal isallowed']
+140849;['appeal is allowed']
+149273;['appeal is dismissed']
+98928;['appeal is allowed']
+18012;['removal orders areset aside']
+104861;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+63067;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+72199;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+73040;['appeal isallowedand']
+55155;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+51812;['appeal is dismissed']
+94944;['dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+150682;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151427;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+123031;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+71329;['appeals are dismissed']
+75479;['appeal of twzen–shang geng is dismissed']
+29807;['appeal is dismissed']
+107198;['dismiss the appeal']
+47770;['irb (intervenor)(f.c.a., no']
+85523;['appeal isallowed']
+106138;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+88029;['302 (c.a.']
+30518;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+143926;['appeal is allowed']
+96384;['appeal isallowed']
+41966;['appeal is dismissed']
+133245;['appeal is dismissed']
+38245;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+44209;['appeal is allowed']
+100712;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+118249;['appeal is dismissed']
+110043;['appeal is dismissed']
+71078;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+94544;['not “convention refugees”']
+73310;['appeal is allowed']
+89580;['appeal isallowed']
+132721;['302 (c.a.']
+123421;['not be recognized as refugees']
+104974;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+125437;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+92957;['appeal is terminated']
+37861;['appeal is determined']
+99394;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92796;['appeal isallowedfor']
+93268;['sponsor is eleven years older']
+83915;['appeal is dismissed']
+145875;['appeal is allowed']
+62441;['appeal is dismissed']
+108061;['rad allows the appeal']
+62635;['application for leave to appeal federal court of appeal decision number a-531-14,2015 fca 237, dated october\xa030, 2015, was allowed']
+69585;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+60045;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+102701;['appeal is dismissed']
+13630;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+17121;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+68467;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+129910;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+14700;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+47676;['appeal is dismissed']
+84194;['appeal of asif nawaz khan is dismissed']
+75474;['appeal is allowed']
+83119;['appeal is dismissed']
+99414;['appeal isallowed']
+112356;['appeal is dismissed']
+38877;['appeal is allowed']
+142947;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+26470;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+76832;['appeal is allowed']
+62884;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+82045;['appeal is allowed']
+80511;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandonedundersection']
+64042;['appeal isdismissed.']
+76333;['exclusion order is set aside']
+149275;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+106340;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'returns the matter to the rpd for redetermination by a differently constituted panel.']
+77550;['302 (c.a.']
+123052;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113284;['appeal is allowed']
+64130;['appeal is refused']
+99796;['negative']
+59809;['appeal is dismissed']
+76731;['appeal is allowed.the']
+132346;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93056;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106162;['appeal is allowed']
+83949;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96812;['respondent is a convention refugee']
+99871;['appeal is allowed']
+52220;['appeal is dismissed']
+105196;['appeal is allowed']
+105332;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+71186;['appeal is allowed']
+95387;['appeal is allowed']
+83155;['appeal is dismissed']
+99673;['appeal is dismissed']
+97003;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+23076;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+89037;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+141676;['removal order is set aside']
+32084;['appeal is dismissed']
+102525;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+76967;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+102901;['appeal was dismissed']
+148978;['dismiss this appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+61624;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77862;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+88100;['appeal isallowed']
+113547;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+61830;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+129533;['appeal isallowed']
+104836;['appeal is based']
+124576;['i agree with the rpd']
+54725;['opposes the granting of a stay of removal']
+84358;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+148611;['appeal is allowed']
+47388;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74565;['appeal is allowed']
+37865;['appeal were dismissed']
+76636;['appeal isallowed']
+110949;['appeal is dismissed']
+98107;['negative']
+79745;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+106633;['application is allowed']
+96274;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+89028;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+94719;['substitute my own']
+92799;['appeal is dismissed']
+69999;['dismiss the appeal']
+120719;['not a convention refugee']
+79207;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+71070;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96545;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+30543;['appeal isallowed']
+99031;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+49631;['appeal is allowed in law']
+72311;['appeal is terminated']
+79921;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+122958;['panel sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are persons in need of protection']
+82039;['appeal is allowed']
+54813;['appeal is allowed']
+113268;['appeal is allowed']
+68470;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, cannot be a “convention refugee”']
+131017;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52608;['claim to refugee status therefore fails']
+99860;['appeal is dismissed']
+141811;['appeals filed byxxxx']
+142815;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses her appeal']
+92947;['removal order is set aside']
+132829;['appeal is dismissed']
+98114;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+136752;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+95494;['appeal isdismissed.']
+95966;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75482;['appeal of khin wai is dismissed']
+55728;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107915;['appeal is dismissed']
+80109;['appeal isallowed']
+107071;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+93969;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+152775;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+150702;['appeal is remitted back to the rpd']
+141640;['allow the appeals']
+59841;['rpd’s determination']
+145104;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+29696;['appeal is dismissed']
+94428;['appeal abandoned']
+93808;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+77266;['appeal isallowed.the']
+88498;['claim is rejected']
+99822;['appeal is allowed.the']
+68223;['appeal certainly fails']
+124089;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision']
+69241;['appeal is allowed']
+144461;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99353;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+91769;['appeal is terminated']
+125531;['appeal is allowed']
+100202;['nor permanent inadmissibility']
+139450;['appeal is dismissed']
+132820;['appeal should be allowed to proceed']
+98148;['appeal is allowed']
+124899;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+80489;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+91127;['appeal is dismissed']
+124202;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99064;['claim is rejected']
+148653;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+87965;['appeal is allowed']
+23757;['not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+101774;['appeal is allowed']
+116348;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56667;['nor a danger of torture']
+47776;['deportation order is set aside']
+81121;['sponsor is not a sponsor within the meaning of theregulations.']
+76719;['appeal is dismissed']
+99266;['decision of the visa officer is legally valid']
+147615;['appeal is dismissed']
+62251;['negative']
+114405;['appellants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+64620;['negative']
+124344;['appeal is dismissed']
+129400;['appeal is dismissed']
+65255;['appeals of the']
+98426;['appeal is dismissed']
+91556;['appeal isdismissed.']
+124334;['302 (c.a.']
+151354;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+95356;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74031;['appeal isdismissed.']
+95439;['appeals are dismissed']
+80074;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+23062;['declare this appeal abandoned']
+134356;['appeal is dismissed']
+71698;['appeal is dismissed']
+101448;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+104026;['claimants are neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+143592;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+118744;['appeal is allowed', 'substitute my own decision that she is a convention refugee']
+151330;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91442;['dismiss this appeal']
+62486;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98158;['appeal isallowedand']
+37414;['appeal is dismissed']
+75498;['appeal of kulwinder kaur samra is dismissed']
+89798;['dismiss this appeal']
+68991;['appeal is allowed']
+133735;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81927;['appeal is allowed']
+97385;['refugee protection division rejects their claims of for refugee protection incanada']
+123063;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129912;['appeal is determined']
+77961;['appeal is allowed']
+99576;['appeal is allowed']
+59791;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+135458;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128932;['appeal is dismissed']
+95094;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a “person in need of protection']
+103904;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+143625;['dismiss the appeals', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+57041;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+54748;['appeal is dismissed']
+140844;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+89235;['302 (c.a.']
+52791;['dismiss the appeal']
+94977;['appeal of yasaman sabersheikh is dismissed']
+130869;['appeal is allowed']
+104497;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+123848;['dismiss the appeal']
+90246;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94229;['appeal is dismissed']
+76304;['appeal is dismissed']
+151462;['appeals are dismissed']
+97301;['appeal is dismissed']
+98697;['appeal isallowed']
+149269;['appeal is to be rescheduled']
+81004;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+147878;['appeal is allowed']
+38394;['appeal is dismissed']
+60050;['negative']
+64867;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94412;['appeals are dismissed']
+96476;['appeal isallowed']
+94267;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+23087;['appeal isallowed']
+68358;['appeal is dismissed']
+58496;['appeal is terminated']
+92936;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+5140;['appeal is dismissed']
+128405;['appeal is dismissed']
+145049;['appellant is neither a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+47290;['appeal is allowed']
+87786;['not a convention refugee']
+101301;['request for an oral hearing is therefore dismissed']
+60821;['dismiss the appeal']
+72789;['appeal must be dismissed']
+116185;['appeal is allowed']
+90178;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+108760;['appeals are dismissed']
+129187;['appeal is allowed']
+16754;['appeal isallowed']
+95312;['allows the appeal']
+45865;['302 (c.a.']
+24475;['appeal is dismissed']
+74602;['appeal is not caught by', 'appeal will proceed to a full hearing']
+107881;['rejects the claim for protection of the respondent', 'rejects his claim']
+52081;['appeal is terminated']
+58751;['rpd decision must be set aside']
+138813;['appeal were dismissed']
+131145;['appeal is dismissed']
+89836;['immigration officer’s decision is founded in law']
+57730;['appeal is dismissed']
+122542;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant, as a person referred to in article\xa01f(a) of the convention', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87396;['appeal is dismissed']
+125470;['appeal is allowed']
+96015;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122622;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56739;['appeal is refused']
+125242;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61223;['appeal is allowed']
+100081;['appeal is dismissed']
+64000;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98602;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+91602;['appeal is dismissed']
+124992;['rad, pursuant', 'substitutes a decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+111038;['rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+153146;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not “convention refugees']
+13953;['appeal should be dismissed']
+86209;['appeal is dismissed']
+129897;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+73602;['appeal isallowedand']
+125170;['appeal is allowed']
+96474;"[""rad finds that counsel's arguments cannot stand""]"
+72571;['negative']
+144935;['appeal is dismissed']
+152948;['appeal is dismissed']
+96295;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+121468;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100259;['panel rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+125563;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72626;['appeal is dismissed']
+76270;['appeal is dismissed']
+95591;['appeal is allowed']
+63737;['appeal is allowed']
+132831;['appeal was dismissed']
+94731;['appeal is dismissed']
+41822;['appeal is allowed']
+107875;['302 (c.a.']
+125524;['dismiss the appeal']
+75500;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+71560;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+67431;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+143585;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92794;['appeal isallowed']
+97282;['claimants,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees nor are they in need of protection']
+90934;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a claim for refugee protection']
+44044;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+68356;['appeal is allowed']
+96289;['neither convention refugees']
+95586;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+78663;['removal order isset aside']
+124048;['appeal is allowed']
+71624;['appeal is not allowed']
+56805;['xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+72709;['appeal is determined']
+75391;['appeal is dismissed']
+84637;['appeal is allowed']
+148991;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82196;['appeal is allowed']
+67729;['appeal is allowed']
+45386;['appeal is dismissed']
+63233;['appeal isallowed']
+35053;['appeal isallowed']
+146549;['rad confirms the rpd decision', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+29634;['appealed is valid in law']
+40127;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+124549;['appeal is allowed']
+107134;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand as the reasons are unclear and insufficient']
+91188;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+130842;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+87196;['appeal is allowed']
+82215;['appeal is allowed']
+71135;['allow this appeal']
+73225;['tribunal declares the appealabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+93618;['application to re-open is dismissed']
+94205;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+138292;['appeal is allowed']
+38792;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+151331;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60493;['appeal be dismissed']
+136735;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96740;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+125569;['appeal is allowed']
+96777;['appeal isallowed']
+63607;['negative']
+47166;['appeal of lucy eastwood denton-james is dismissed']
+91451;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your removal fromcanada.']
+23087;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+143171;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection', 'claim is dismissed']
+107044;['appellant is not in need of refugee protection']
+49545;['appeal of bartele van der haak (the “appellant”']
+23057;['dismiss the present appeal']
+128280;['appeal be dismissed']
+133359;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60774;['appeal is dismissed']
+68142;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+95067;['appeal is allowed']
+66780;['appeal is allowed.the']
+151342;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+97419;['refugee protection division rejects the claim ofxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxfor refugee protection']
+98091;['appeal is dismissed']
+69134;['appeal is rejected']
+94654;['appeal isallowed']
+36085;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+108118;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+143475;['appeal is dismissed']
+60734;['appeal isallowed']
+110564;['appeal is dismissed']
+63705;['appeal is dismissed']
+104110;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+84369;['appeal is dismissed']
+60194;['appeal is allowed']
+103103;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71444;['appeal is dismissed']
+91109;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125032;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+123686;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76343;['appeal is allowed']
+31985;['appeal is allowed']
+94188;['appeal is dismissed']
+146535;['claimants are neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142311;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+122939;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108746;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+44018;['appeal is dismissed']
+46497;['appeal is allowed']
+151367;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+68135;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+58122;['appeal allowed']
+84851;['appeal is dismissed']
+101191;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99026;['appeal isallowed']
+71621;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+60090;['refugee protection division rejects these claims', 'claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77573;['appeal isallowed']
+136656;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+61211;['allows this appeal']
+107365;['appeal is dismissed']
+124658;['rpd’s findings are upheld']
+53830;['appeal of chi phong lu is dismissed']
+38395;['appeal is dismissed']
+95064;['confirms the statements of the embassy']
+109396;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+79214;['appeal is terminated']
+76706;['appeal is dismissed']
+60405;['rpd’s decision, when considered in its entirety']
+68360;['allow the appeal of cuong van mai in law']
+84552;['appeal is dismissed']
+99047;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101141;['appeal is dismissed']
+47181;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69078;['leads me to infer the applicant’s family']
+46495;['appeal is allowed']
+141297;['substitute my determination', 'appellant is a refugee']
+123474;['removal order is set aside']
+73600;['appeal is terminated']
+103913;['appeal is dismissed']
+78768;['appeal isallowed']
+68924;['appeal isallowed']
+123605;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+127425;['appeal is dismissed']
+96656;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+62717;['allow the appeal']
+87149;['appeal would be dismissed']
+106444;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+99119;['three appeals are dismissed']
+143862;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94652;['appeal is dismissed']
+98404;['appeal is allowed']
+35437;['appeal is dismissed']
+69109;['tribunal allows the appeal']
+99304;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding']
+124057;['appeal is terminated']
+62957;['appeal isallowed']
+84143;['appeal is allowed']
+72180;['appeal ofcarmelo santiago alcantara is allowed.the']
+142459;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94465;['appeal is allowed']
+72817;['appeal is allowed']
+125333;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+108979;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84469;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89876;['claimants are not persons in need of protection', 'panel rejects their claims']
+101252;['appeal is allowed']
+136116;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64673;['appeal is allowed']
+147799;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+92583;['appeal is refused']
+150952;['appeal is dismissed']
+107428;['appeal is dismissed']
+59133;['appeal ofiris odstrcilis allowed']
+61444;['appeal is allowed']
+54722;['appeal being dismissed']
+90484;['appeal isallowed.the']
+81596;['appeal is allowed in law']
+99197;['claim is rejected']
+125153;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+88897;['dismiss the case for lack of jurisdiction']
+78668;['appeals of you zhou and chen ping xie are dismissed']
+123058;['appeal is allowed']
+120710;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+136712;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the female appellant is a convention refugee']
+96484;['appeal is allowed']
+91936;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+72556;['appeal of van nhu luat le is dismissed']
+121386;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100520;['rad dismisses the minister’s appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+99034;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+76366;['appeal is denied']
+68428;['appeal is dismissed']
+106159;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+121160;['appeal is dismissed']
+124332;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43738;['appeal of abraham haylu is dismissed']
+92785;['appeal is allowed']
+129925;['appeal is allowed']
+67692;['appeal of tat man chan is dismissed']
+46028;['appeal were dismissed']
+113729;['rad confirms, for reasons other than those given by the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+89230;['appeal is terminated']
+75392;['appeal is allowed']
+95656;['appeal is determined']
+123063;['rad rejects this argument']
+124031;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+80124;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+53871;['appeal is allowed']
+90786;['appeal is terminated']
+133381;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97907;['appeal is dismissed']
+105822;['appeal is allowed']
+151862;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+84133;['appeal is allowed']
+65105;['302 (c.a.']
+91062;['appeal is dismissed']
+58377;['appeal isallowed']
+131089;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+153796;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+146862;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+131053;['appeal is allowed']
+144393;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+100986;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+72638;['appeal is allowed']
+69546;['appeal is dismissed']
+76091;['appeal is allowed']
+63175;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76856;['appeal is allowed']
+68893;['appeal isallowed']
+13974;['appeal is abandoned']
+141796;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+147622;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+98433;['appeal is dismissed']
+131039;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145304;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects the claims']
+97475;['visa officer’s determination is valid in law']
+99775;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+41965;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'ms. xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “persons in need of protection']
+74114;['appellant is excluded from the definition of convention refugee']
+107231;['rad confirms the rpd decision', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+98989;['claimants are neither convention refugees', 'rejects their claims']
+147008;['appeal is allowed']
+149058;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+122773;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47303;['appeal is denied']
+68192;['appeal of surafel sharew kuchem is dismissed']
+83912;['appeal isallowed']
+79942;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+83462;['appeal of thang van le is dismissed']
+63009;['appeal isallowed']
+129210;['appeal is allowed']
+98273;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89327;['appeal isallowed']
+38854;['appeal is allowed']
+108048;['determination of the rpd is set aside']
+71044;['they are not convention refugees']
+76665;['appeal division is not a social agency']
+80006;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+21419;['decision thatxxxxxxxis a convention refugee']
+44027;['appeals of manuel rotoni ligeralde, beatriz ildefonso ligeralde, bea amirah ildefonso ligeralde, and del mariz ildefonso ligeralde are dismissed']
+111310;['rad finds that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+77924;['appeal is allowed']
+78185;['appeal is allowed']
+60506;['dismisses the appeal']
+85462;['appeal is terminated']
+145353;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96743;['302 (c.a.']
+117151;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+66586;['appeal were dismissed']
+69411;['appeal is dismissed']
+90821;['appeal is allowed']
+42168;['appeal is dismissed']
+90007;['mni is only a guideline']
+46019;['appeal isallowed']
+80507;['appeal is allowed.the']
+90001;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97979;['appeal isdismissed.']
+110319;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142806;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76896;['appeal is allowed']
+67806;['appeal is allowed']
+77230;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+68277;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+131513;['appeal is allowed']
+99491;['appeal is dismissed']
+61798;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+144426;['appeal is dismissed']
+38772;['appeal is allowed']
+55204;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim for refugee protection']
+128372;['appeal is dismissed']
+81142;['appeal is allowed']
+72882;['appeal is allowed']
+58187;['appeal is dismissed']
+88035;['reject their claims']
+114295;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102454;['appeal is dismissed']
+102833;['claimants are convention refugees']
+94031;['appeal is dismissed']
+85604;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+105873;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+51692;['appeal is allowed']
+61002;['appeal is allowed']
+77816;['not convention refugees']
+75137;['appeal is allowed']
+86984;['removal orders are set aside']
+76479;['appeal is allowed']
+71809;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90841;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+47301;['appeal is allowed']
+37401;['appeal is allowed']
+85912;['appeal being allowed']
+140841;['appellants are not convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+142856;['not confirm the rpd’s decision']
+58415;['appeal is allowed']
+48413;['appeal of kokeb gebru birhane is dismissed']
+58313;['appeal is allowed']
+62394;['appeal is allowed']
+138817;['appeal isallowed']
+99270;['appeal isallowed']
+89092;['panel rejects their claims']
+98780;['appeal was dismissed']
+101172;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+143593;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+44095;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+101782;['appeal is dismissed']
+81130;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+142076;['302 (c.a.']
+86484;['appeal is dismissed']
+93963;['appeal isallowed']
+102735;['dismissing the application']
+99545;['appeal is not allowed']
+125049;['appeal is allowed']
+72166;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+87311;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34948;['pol 10/3202/2021.']
+43728;['allow this appeal']
+62633;['appeal isallowed']
+132883;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67724;['appeal is denied']
+84745;['appeal isallowed.the']
+26976;['xxxxxx xxxxxxxx), is not a convention refugee']
+58089;['appeal is dismissed']
+113291;['appeal is allowed']
+81189;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+107064;['appeals are allowed']
+86326;['appeal is allowed']
+87613;['appeal is dismissed']
+19240;['application is allowed']
+142488;['they are convention refugees']
+73214;['dismiss this appeal']
+112331;['appeal isallowed']
+131008;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132400;['appeal is dismissed']
+65415;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95572;['appeal is allowed']
+77248;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96657;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+53142;['appeal is dismissed']
+95338;['allowed the appeal']
+18004;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+100109;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+54804;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of canada’s protection']
+66645;['rpd’s decision is wrong in law']
+100415;['appeal is allowed']
+30626;['appeal is allowed']
+151970;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+52045;['appeal is allowed']
+123964;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+55890;['appeal is allowed']
+98438;['appeal is terminated']
+102398;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+91116;['appeal is allowed']
+70600;['appeal is dismissed']
+94248;['rad concurs with the rpd’s decision']
+100121;['claimant,xxxxxxxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+136087;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+129186;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+35035;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68783;['appeal is allowed']
+92717;['appeal fail']
+99269;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+44029;['appeal is allowed']
+76066;['appeal must therefore be allowed']
+42228;['appeal is allowed']
+95209;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71140;['appeal is allowed']
+75453;['appeal is dismissed']
+128882;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143915;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+150664;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination', 'neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99203;['appeal is allowed']
+151063;['claimant isneither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+99425;['request to re-open the claim of the applicant is dismissed']
+151573;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'upholds the rpd decision']
+57043;['appeal is allowed']
+13415;['decision is well founded in law']
+87493;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+83149;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+62444;['substitute my finding', 'appellant is a refugee']
+50543;['appeals are dismissed']
+87611;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+86541;['appeal of bolanle mary oriyomi is dismissed']
+105660;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94604;['appeal isallowed.the']
+17901;['application to reopen is denied']
+67473;['panel rejects his claim']
+84071;['declares her oral decision null and void']
+93154;['appeal isallowed']
+83726;['appeal is dismissed']
+85326;['appeal to be dismissed']
+77329;['dismiss the appeal']
+97843;['negative']
+44177;['appeal is dismissed']
+53018;['dismiss the appeal']
+76142;['appeal is dismissed']
+100816;['dismissed his appeal']
+55121;['appeal is dismissed']
+60408;['rad refuses the application to re-open the appellant’s appeal,']
+96483;['302 (c.a.)']
+125146;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+76396;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+123006;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+43907;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+151570;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77983;['appeal was allowed']
+101676;['appeal is allowed']
+105194;['appeal is allowed.the']
+94934;['appeal isallowed']
+55046;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+124989;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+89385;['appeal is terminated']
+74581;['appeal is allowed']
+153796;['appeal is allowed']
+76323;['appeal is dismissed']
+120789;['appeal is allowed']
+74586;['appeal is allowed']
+81931;['application to add grounds of refusal is allowed']
+110977;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71622;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+71492;['appeal is allowed']
+61897;['appeal is dismissed']
+125672;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+97034;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131002;['dismiss the appeal']
+110905;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59755;['dismiss this appeal']
+99465;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+86984;['appeal is allowed']
+88336;['dismisses the appeal']
+95573;['application is allowed']
+68247;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+111338;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+73041;['appeal being allowed']
+133360;['rad allows the appeal']
+85913;['appeal is dismissed']
+88063;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+74171;['appeal is allowed']
+118187;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64613;['nor a risk of torture']
+66630;['appeal is allowed']
+91322;['appeal is allowed']
+84406;['appeal is dismissed']
+134213;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+106339;['appeals are dismissed']
+132723;['302 (c.a.']
+130873;['appeal is allowed.the']
+73680;['appeal is allowed']
+97593;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+76408;['dismiss the appeal']
+48418;['appeal was set for hearing']
+56959;['appeal of guangming zhang is dismissed']
+123027;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+111025;['302 (c.a.']
+140711;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128745;['substitute my own decision that they are convention refugees']
+131099;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77644;['appeal isallowed']
+98318;['appeal is terminated']
+95124;['appeal is dismissed']
+70381;['appeal is dismissed']
+93690;['appeals regarding the minor children are dismissed']
+120821;['reject the appellants’ argument']
+109038;['appeals are dismissed']
+110677;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx is neither   a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113755;['appeal is allowed']
+107470;"[""rad concurs with the panel's finding""]"
+113789;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+92843;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+148622;['appeal is allowed']
+95337;['appeal from the april\xa022, 2010, removal order is dismissed']
+66201;['immigration appeal division dismisses an appeal']
+143006;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+68693;['appeal is terminated']
+54786;['appeal is determined tobeabandoned unders']
+138847;['appeal is dismissed']
+82703;['appeal is allowed']
+84494;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+102861;['claimants xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “conventionrefugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+103876;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+67393;['appeal isallowed']
+100485;['claimant is not a convention refugeesection 96of theirpaor a person in need of protection']
+14435;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+89816;['appeal is allowed', 'visa officer’s decision, though legally valid, is set aside']
+139839;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+132776;['appellants to be convention refugees']
+69551;['appeal is allowed']
+107934;['appeal is allowed']
+92339;['refugee protection division excludes xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx from refugee protection']
+130727;['appeal is dismissed']
+102074;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96908;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+93048;['appeal is dismissed']
+73293;['appeal is dismissed']
+95630;['claimants are persons referred to insection 98of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+106333;['rad finds that the', 'appellant and her minor child', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57560;['appeal is allowed']
+70016;['appeal allowed']
+106799;['appeal is allowed']
+123270;['302 (c.a.']
+26681;['appeal were reinstated']
+69499;['appeal isallowed']
+111331;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “conventionrefugee”']
+30517;['appeal were dismissed']
+81125;['appeal is allowed']
+63813;['not a person in need of protection']
+49238;['appeal is allowed']
+56994;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+40384;['dismiss the appeal']
+61391;['officer’s decision must be set aside', 'appeal is allowed']
+69458;['appeal isallowed']
+141048;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxxxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+88170;['appeal is dismissed']
+91662;['appeal is allowed.the']
+142314;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+74641;['appeal be dismissed']
+57040;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+66200;['appeal is allowed']
+114353;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35433;['appeal of is dismissed']
+54203;['appeal is allowed']
+105207;['appeals are dismissed']
+25305;['appeal is dismissed']
+139466;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+136707;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52090;['appeal isallowedand']
+101904;['appeal is allowed']
+63931;['appeal is dismissed']
+84549;['appeal is terminated']
+43334;['appeal is governed by theact']
+99551;['302 (c.a.']
+36464;['appeal is dismissed']
+141319;['appeal is dismissed']
+77848;['appeal is allowed']
+94055;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123038;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124053;['appeal is dismissed']
+35925;['appeal is determined abandoned']
+77046;['appeal should be dismissed']
+85947;['appeal is dismissed']
+57783;['appeal is allowed']
+68891;['appeal isallowed']
+68384;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+105558;['appeal is allowed']
+37529;['ms. el\xa0saadi is not a member of the family class']
+95658;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+28091;['appeal isallowed']
+104470;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+91312;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa set aside']
+71224;['appeal of jagdeep singh punia is dismissed']
+108813;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+39890;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102149;['appeal is allowed.the']
+85672;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98801;['appeal isallowed']
+13982;['allow your appeal']
+51678;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+96329;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+112777;['allows the appeal']
+98424;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+8288;['appeal isallowed']
+81078;['appeal is allowed']
+54550;['appeal is allowed.the']
+74848;['appeal is allowed']
+151976;['appeal is dismissed']
+96116;['dismiss the appeal']
+91445;['appeal is dismissed']
+91300;['appeal isallowed']
+134422;['immigration officer’s determination is valid in law']
+98359;['appeal is allowed.the']
+89156;['appeal is dismissed']
+125317;['appellants should be recognized as persons in need of protection']
+60986;['appeal is terminated']
+99402;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+113233;['appeal is premature']
+37827;['appeal was dismissed']
+95428;['302 (c.a.']
+128897;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+13971;['appeal is allowed']
+37982;['appeal is allowed']
+125320;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+90241;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87322;['appeal is allowed']
+99246;['appeal is dismissed']
+131732;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80492;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+77806;['claimantsxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx,xxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxnot to be convention refugees and not to be persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+103024;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+151832;['appeal is dismissed']
+84748;['appeal is allowed']
+59747;['appeal isallowed']
+151834;['appeal is allowed']
+104077;['appeal was heard']
+84627;['appeal is dismissed']
+69865;['appeal is dismissed']
+110990;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+107139;['appeal is dismissed']
+99678;['appeal is allowed']
+105604;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand']
+130934;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45991;['appeal should be dismissed']
+123857;['appeal is allowed']
+123375;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+91282;['appeal is dismissed']
+87318;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+95353;['dismiss both appeals']
+74551;['appeal of cheryl green is dismissed']
+108680;['appeal is governed by theact']
+98133;['302 (c.a.)']
+123040;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision']
+97771;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+76724;['appeal is allowed']
+113241;['appeal is allowed']
+122923;['ground of appeal fails']
+144897;['rad dismisses the respondent’s request']
+77877;['appeal is allowed']
+90660;['xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+67222;['appeal is allowed']
+103527;['appeals are allowed']
+148062;['vapp is not enforced']
+124922;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123407;['appellants are not convention refugees']
+56969;['appeal is allowed']
+91301;['appeal isallowed']
+76464;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+73895;['appeal is governed by theact']
+89776;['panel rejects the claim ofxxxxxxxxxxfor refugee protection']
+69734;['appeal isallowed']
+71472;['appeal is declared to be abandoned']
+148498;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+76602;['appeal isallowed.the']
+95458;['appeal is dismissed']
+35696;['appeal is allowed']
+97315;['appeal is dismissed']
+96807;['appeal is dismissed']
+90367;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+148655;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102572;['dismissing the appeal the']
+124117;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+24200;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+91703;['appeal is allowed']
+146888;['confirm the rpd member’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+150646;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146556;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57504;['appeal is determined']
+126398;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91690;['appeal is allowed']
+52122;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+134293;['appeal is dismissed']
+148868;['appeal is allowed']
+49062;['appeal is allowed']
+102696;['appeal is allowed']
+151814;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+123780;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+31045;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+152051;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+13550;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+134491;['theappealis dismissed']
+80507;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+129122;['appeal is allowed']
+90978;['appeal isallowed']
+70648;['appeal is abandoned', 'appeal is dismissed']
+86475;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+132325;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+130974;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx are excluded']
+103055;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+87695;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124418;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75236;['decision of the id member is set aside']
+71717;['appeal is allowed']
+110968;['appeal is dismissed']
+90322;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+97863;['appeal is allowed']
+77968;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+60108;['appeal is allowed']
+63964;['appeal is allowed']
+87015;['appeal is dismissed']
+34159;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+144418;['appeal is dismissed']
+76417;['colombia is a refugee producing country']
+16760;['appeals of the principal appellant']
+142808;['rad rejects the appellant’s argument']
+59021;['panel cancels the stay', 'sets aside the removal order,', 'allows the appeal']
+131285;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+14709;['appeals are normally scheduled for hearing']
+93592;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+71124;['appeal in this case is consequently dismissed']
+82985;['appeal is allowed']
+98871;['dismiss this appeal']
+82642;['appeal isallowed']
+74217;['appeal is dismissed']
+135129;['dismiss the appeal']
+128605;['appeal is dismissed']
+99736;['appeal is dismissed']
+130726;['appeal is allowed']
+69431;['appeal isallowed']
+47220;['appeal of balwinder kaur brar is dismissed']
+108668;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+123304;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92941;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52139;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection', 'rad rejects this claim']
+62628;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+113607;['appeal is dismissed']
+113544;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+94293;['appeal is dismissed']
+89299;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95252;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151599;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither   convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93015;['appeal is dismissed']
+93009;['claim is denied']
+98863;['appeal isdismissed.']
+101257;['is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87783;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+105210;['appeal is allowed']
+77798;['rejects his claim']
+126422;['appeals of manpreet kaur khangura, rajvir kaur kangura and gurdip singh khangura are allowed']
+129393;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143029;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+99475;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for refugee protection']
+14677;['claimant xxxxx xxxx xx is not a convention refugee']
+100454;['302 (c.a.)']
+76155;['302 (c.a.']
+100110;['rad finds that the respondent is not a convention refugee']
+122992;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+12206;['appeal is allowed']
+15014;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+99230;['appeal isallowed']
+102561;['appeal is allowed']
+82217;['removal order is set aside']
+65705;['appeal is allowed']
+145058;['96claim fails']
+121857;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+119830;['appeal is reopened']
+89155;['appeal is allowed']
+114334;['xvii]']
+96352;['appeal is allowed']
+54751;['appeal is allowed']
+108700;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52672;['nor a person in need of protection']
+86390;['appeal is dismissed']
+94930;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+121941;['appeal is dismissed']
+97195;['negative']
+94511;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+142801;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are “convention refugees”']
+42379;['appeal of clement thomas is dismissed']
+151595;['appeal is dismissed']
+52627;"['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a ""convention refugee']"
+83951;['dismiss this appeal']
+70222;['appeal isallowed']
+97824;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+93271;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+98154;['appeal is allowed']
+28286;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+106895;['appeal of john wiyual kek is dismissed']
+72193;['appeal is allowed']
+140819;['appeal is dismissed']
+91902;['appeal is allowed']
+145830;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+63712;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+110977;['appeal is dismissed']
+95197;['appeal is allowed']
+136112;['appeal is dismissed']
+89209;['appeal is allowed']
+89242;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+139469;['appeal is dismissed']
+82123;['appeal is dismissed']
+84023;['appeal is dismissed']
+34893;['appeal is allowed']
+123915;['appeal is dismissed']
+71118;['appeal of mary margaret h. worobec altuntas is therefore dismissed']
+99385;['negative']
+82654;['appeal isallowed']
+107605;['rad disagrees']
+47558;['appeal was allowed']
+125107;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+77088;['appeal is dismissed']
+95882;"[""rad therefore confirms the rpd's negative determination""]"
+45214;['appeal of almira kolakovic is dismissed']
+86835;['appeal is allowed']
+128426;['appeal is allowed']
+125624;['appeal is allowed']
+26966;['xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+101477;['appeal dismissed']
+81205;['appeal dismissed']
+120828;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+142453;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”']
+31929;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+113296;['appeal is allowed']
+144410;['302 (c.a.']
+104284;['appeal is allowed']
+43711;['appellant is no longer subject to enforcement']
+74859;['appeal isallowed']
+62999;['appeal isallowed']
+87990;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+75580;['appeal is allowed']
+122925;['appeal is allowed']
+148872;['appeal is dismissed']
+89298;['appeal is terminated']
+46094;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+100791;['appeal is dismissed']
+128331;['appeal is dismissed']
+125227;['appeal is allowed']
+75918;['appeal is dismissed']
+90237;['claimant is neither a convention refugee unders']
+84527;['appeal must be dismissed']
+122534;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74113;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision that', 'appellants are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101266;['allowed the appeal']
+54817;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132375;['appeal is dismissed']
+153043;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee”']
+19385;['appeal is denied']
+125114;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+151808;['appeal is dismissed']
+128619;['allow the appeal']
+72653;['appeal is dismissed']
+109171;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+129236;['appeal is allowed']
+94253;['appeal is dismissed']
+54175;['appeal of rajinder singh brar is dismissed']
+105239;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+94150;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90746;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+71414;['appeal of van hung lai is dismissed']
+96300;['appeals are allowed.the']
+132794;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+86836;['appeal is allowed']
+79193;['appellant is a stateless person and a protected person']
+74068;['appeal is allowed']
+68350;['decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77066;['appeal is dismissed']
+22856;['appeal is allowed.the']
+79334;['appeals are dismissed']
+145759;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+83093;['appeal is dismissed']
+103452;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+109170;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151405;['appeal is allowed']
+71240;['appeal is governed by theact']
+75971;['appeal is dismissed']
+59942;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+96569;['appeal is allowed']
+124417;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+85871;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102682;['appeal is allowed']
+54633;['stay of the exclusion order is not appropriate']
+90478;['appeals of kaushik mohanlal chitalia, chhaya kaushik chitalia, udit kaushik chitalia and harsh kaushik chitalia are dismissed']
+101137;['decision of the visa officer is well-founded in fact and in law']
+98272;['appeal is allowed']
+94002;['appeal is allowed']
+97319;['appeal is dismissed']
+62987;['appeal isallowed']
+89213;['302 (c.a.']
+82264;['appeal is allowed']
+103914;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151560;['appeal is dismissed']
+107641;['appeal is dismissed']
+64615;['appeal is dismissed']
+107252;['appeal is dismissed']
+19147;['dismiss the application']
+138815;['declare this appeal abandoned']
+54804;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90480;['appeal is dismissed']
+63007;['appeal is dismissed']
+93645;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+152380;['appeal is dismissed']
+95253;['departure orders are set aside']
+97589;['allows this appeal']
+64006;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+150631;['dismiss the minister’s appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+51700;['appeal is allowed']
+107062;['appeal isallowed']
+58377;['appeal is allowed']
+74036;['appellant is not a sponsor pursuant']
+91251;['appeal is dismissed']
+129233;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95599;['rad dismissed the application for an extension of time']
+100842;['appeal of erlan lizandro acosta bonilla is dismissed']
+12225;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+83933;['appeal must fail']
+87341;['appeal should be dismissed']
+63908;['dismisses the present appeal']
+99657;['appeal is dismissed']
+70900;['appeal is allowed']
+108080;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+124424;['rad finds that the rpd committed a criticalsur placeclaim assessment error']
+96311;['appeal is terminated']
+93817;['negative']
+101843;['favourable decision is issued to him']
+27486;['appeal is allowed']
+145292;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+45996;['appeal is allowed']
+68678;['appeal is dismissed']
+76833;['appeal isallowed']
+129893;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+101714;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+111354;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+83839;['appeal is allowed.the']
+70459;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+37438;['appeal is allowed']
+143618;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93879;['appeal of karmjeet kaur gill is allowed']
+95342;['colombia is not a country of reference']
+66946;['appeal is allowed']
+123264;['rpd’s decision is upheld']
+112319;['visa officer’s determination is not valid in law']
+148429;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+101615;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+94228;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, andxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+76544;['302 (c.a.']
+97273;['302 (c.a.)']
+57561;['appeal is allowed']
+98313;['appeal will be set for hearing']
+123043;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+45419;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+91248;['dismissal of the appeal']
+69819;['appeal is dismissed']
+99052;['appeal is allowed']
+69758;['appeal of the principal appellant, toni elias bougharios, is allowed in law']
+96516;['appeal is allowed']
+146885;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107497;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+87347;['appeal is allowed']
+95974;['appeal is dismissed']
+144754;['appeal is dismissed']
+98484;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+146943;['appellant is not a “convention” refugee']
+49634;['appeal is allowed']
+52758;['appeal is allowed']
+80803;['appeal is allowed']
+77562;['appeal isallowed']
+52587;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+61233;['negative']
+99668;['appeal is dismissed']
+50504;['appeal isallowed']
+96743;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+107900;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+61812;['allow his appeal and order his removal order set aside']
+46481;['exclusion order is set aside']
+79066;['appeal is dismissed']
+140941;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+45237;['allow this appeal']
+81219;['appeal being dismissed']
+127407;['appeal is dismissed']
+69575;['appeal isallowed']
+139461;['appeal isallowed']
+147469;['appeals are dismissed']
+91420;['appeal is allowed']
+71795;['appeal dismissed']
+27516;['appeal of tony dale osachuk is allowed']
+50439;['decision is not legally valid', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+41249;['appeal allowed']
+45162;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90458;['ac is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+100468;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+71466;['appeal isallowed']
+40774;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+97882;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+152789;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is a person who is inadmissible to canada']
+89098;['refugee protection claimants', 'not “convention refugees”']
+86151;['appeal is terminated']
+123861;['appeals are allowed']
+44019;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94862;['dismiss the present   appeal,']
+61864;['determination is valid law']
+55199;['reject his claim']
+113536;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+88311;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+85255;['appeal is allowed']
+123650;['i agree with the rpd’s conclusions']
+121451;['appellants have not established their allegations']
+47342;['appeal is allowed']
+86396;['appeal isallowed']
+19120;['appeal was dismissed']
+11068;['appeal isallowedand']
+91684;['appeal is dismissed']
+140733;['302 (c.a.']
+75464;['appeal is dismissed']
+13417;['appeal isallowed']
+70399;['appeal is dismissed']
+140986;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56783;['claimant is in need of the surrogate protection']
+52303;['dismiss the appeal']
+85451;['appeal be dismissed']
+113518;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+143027;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151826;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+121541;['appeal would be dismissed.cahit']
+114404;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+146106;['rad rejects the appellant’s argument']
+71081;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+139679;['appeal isallowed.the']
+134163;['appeal is allowed']
+23007;['appeal isallowed']
+108727;['appeal is dismissed']
+125334;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+52115;['rpd confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128933;['removal order is set aside']
+57395;['appeal isdismissed.']
+17162;['officer’s decision cannot be overturned']
+96939;['appeal is dismissed']
+89887;['panel rejects the refugee protection claims']
+13419;['appeal is allowed']
+46511;['appeal is terminated']
+91120;['appeal is dismissed']
+150937;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81107;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98340;['302 (c.a.']
+98384;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+30547;['appeal is dismissed']
+88904;['appeal was dismissed']
+127475;['removal orders are set aside.the']
+91301;['appeal is allowed']
+55727;['appeals are dismissed']
+63936;['panel allows the appeal']
+98327;['appeal is dismissed']
+80524;['appeal is dismissed']
+88440;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+22986;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+69772;['appeal division has no jurisdiction to hear the appellant’s appeal']
+117201;['appeal is allowed']
+99444;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+121871;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+40062;['appeal is dismissed']
+36571;['matter is reopened']
+23069;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+65698;['appeal is allowed']
+26772;['appeal will be allowed']
+70212;['appeal is dismissed']
+97616;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+26910;['claimants have not established a well-founded fear of persecution']
+98467;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+74860;['appeal isallowed']
+99380;['appeal isallowed']
+150636;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52282;['appeal is allowed']
+95649;['request to reopen is dismissed']
+81251;['appeal is allowed']
+102698;['rad finds that it does not']
+69547;['appeal is dismissed']
+97207;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+47787;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74220;['appeal is therefore, dismissed']
+122669;['appeal is allowed']
+114335;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91736;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+106779;['appeal is allowed']
+136075;['rpd decision is therefore set aside']
+91663;['appeal is dismissed']
+89191;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+109623;['appeal is dismissed', 'rpd decision is upheld']
+125138;['rpd decision is set aside']
+84439;['302 (c.a.)']
+123705;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+124911;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+97625;['appeal is allowed']
+46050;['appeal is dismissed']
+139679;['appeal is allowed']
+13934;['appeal is dismissed']
+107215;['rad cannot substitute its own decision as further exploration']
+106612;['appeals are dismissed']
+90855;['not be found to be a convention refugee']
+105857;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+65666;['application to reopen the applicant’s appeal must be dismissed']
+146895;['appeal is denied']
+26503;['dismisses this appeal']
+63046;['appeal is allowed']
+108747;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+91109;['appeal is terminated']
+142515;['appeals are dismissed']
+106916;['sponsor does not meet all the regulatory requirements']
+93998;['appeal is allowed.the']
+90232;['rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+145328;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67560;['not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+98218;['302 (c.a.)']
+68593;['dismisses this appeal']
+8295;['removal orders are set aside']
+68160;['appeal is allowed']
+42563;['appeal is dismissed']
+102390;['appeal is dismissed']
+89193;['appeal is dismissed']
+40708;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+149234;['appeal is dismissed']
+130734;['appeal is allowed']
+92735;['appeal isallowed']
+104456;['appeal of kulwinder kaur nijjar, also known as kulwinder kaur dhaliwal, of the refusal of her spouse’s permanent resident visa application']
+63173;['appeal is allowed']
+125372;['appellant is a “convention refugee”']
+87849;['appeal is dismissed']
+145234;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88406;['appeal is allowed']
+130736;['appellant is not a permanent resident']
+90243;['negative']
+113256;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+76274;['dismiss the appeal']
+40126;['appeal be dismissed']
+99598;['appeal is dismissed']
+79932;['claimants were persons in need of protection']
+94710;['appeal before the iad must be dismissed']
+143467;['appeal is dismissed']
+58106;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+59844;['appeal is dismissed']
+88122;['appeal were dismissed']
+125687;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+146565;['appeal is allowed']
+52351;['appeal isallowed']
+93901;['appeal is dismissed']
+64869;['appeal is dismissed']
+90328;['negative']
+71561;['appeal is dismissed']
+54295;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+96892;['appeal will not be reopened']
+69968;['appeal is dismissed']
+143600;['appeal is allowed']
+31420;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+87431;['appeal is granted']
+152781;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not inadmissible in canada']
+49632;['appeal is allowed']
+114693;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+80507;['appeal is allowed']
+8296;['appeal isdismissedby reason']
+69319;['appeal is going to be allowed in law']
+52646;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is a convention refugeefor']
+96711;['appeal is allowed']
+142725;['panel therefore confirms the decision of the rpd', 'rejects her claim']
+58106;['appeal isdismissed,']
+94287;['appeal is dismissed']
+83253;['appeal is allowed.the']
+78146;['appeal is dismissed']
+99314;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+81393;['nor the charter arguments made therein']
+69086;['appeal is allowed in law']
+113731;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57029;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+121391;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+65125;['dismiss this appeal']
+111355;['appeal is dismissed']
+108955;['appeal is allowed']
+136655;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+121483;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+59368;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+44015;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89236;['appeal is allowed']
+39772;['appeal is dismissed']
+35433;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+132728;['302 (c.a.']
+88025;['claim is therefore rejected']
+94101;['appeal of van thanh nguyen is allowed']
+146430;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+91135;['appeal is dismissed']
+150847;['thatxxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx']
+111346;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+128168;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60522;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+61038;['appeal is allowed']
+123360;['appeal is dismissed']
+110982;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+113509;['appeal were dismissed']
+67473;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+107124;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+141085;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82356;['appeals of ajit singh, depinder kaur, and jaskaran singh are allowed']
+101412;['appeal is allowed']
+125016;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99005;['appeal is dismissed']
+123441;['substitute my own decision that she is a convention refugee']
+125465;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+136132;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60041;['negative']
+96319;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor person in need of protection']
+83156;['appeal is dismissed']
+83509;['appeal is dismissed']
+139880;['rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+34643;['appeal isallowed']
+91671;['appeal is dismissed']
+81219;['appeal is dismissed']
+140066;['appeal filed byxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis dismissed']
+89227;['appeal is allowed']
+63123;['appeal is allowed']
+64257;['leads me to find on a balance of probabilities']
+144957;['substitutes its own determination']
+132774;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+95908;['appeal is allowed']
+146107;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+87813;['appeal is allowed']
+133189;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+85385;['appeal is allowed']
+83058;['appeal is allowed']
+131010;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124533;['allow the appeal and']
+84139;['appeal is dismissed']
+59716;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+14295;['appeal is dismissed']
+111335;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+65632;['appeal is allowed']
+80126;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+152919;['appeal is dismissed']
+99130;['appeal is not allowed']
+150751;['nor persons in need of protection']
+86474;['appeal is allowed']
+132760;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+77989;['appeal is dismissed']
+107262;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+31400;['appeal isallowed']
+93555;['appeal is allowed']
+66574;['appeal is dismissed']
+140891;['appellants are convention refugees']
+87308;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+15016;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxand her five minor', 'not “convention refugees”']
+88345;['appeal is allowed']
+146331;['allow the appeal']
+21425;['xxxxx xxxx xxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+100687;['appeal should be dismissed']
+97087;['panel rejects these claims']
+117194;['appeal is allowed']
+97303;['negative']
+96679;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+99700;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+57544;['appeal of alamma alex and alex kotticheril abraham is dismissed']
+77345;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+89234;['appeal is dismissed']
+94949;['appeal is allowed']
+93246;['appeal is allowed']
+74107;['appeal is dismissed']
+26704;['appellant should not be removed']
+101767;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+117185;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96245;['appeal is allowed']
+99036;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+84495;['appeal of khanh huu ly is dismissed']
+97511;['negative']
+94309;['appeal is dismissed']
+96313;['appeal is allowed']
+92547;['removal orders areset aside']
+52603;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+46476;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96473;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision falls within the range of possible, acceptable outcomes']
+55175;['appeals of richard blair illingworth, helen mary illingworth, grace elizabeth illingworth, libby mary illingworth, and blair robert illingworth are dismissed']
+111304;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83046;['appeal of jian wei liu is allowed']
+124972;['claimants, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+82240;['appeal of gurpreet kaur manhani is dismissed']
+151961;['appeal is allowed']
+72642;['allow the appeal']
+143629;['not substitute a decision in this case']
+68902;['allow this appeal']
+30515;['appeal is allowed']
+103804;['302 (c.a.']
+96810;['appeal is dismissed']
+131215;['appeal is allowed']
+67681;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal of bimal chand is dismissed']
+123968;['appeal being allowed']
+71461;['appeal is allowed']
+57032;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60104;['appeal of narinder kaur bachhal is dismissed']
+111150;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+53403;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+63983;['appeal is allowed']
+103454;['appeal is allowed']
+108776;['appeal is dismissed']
+57737;['…]”']
+79979;['claim is rejected']
+60530;['application is allowed']
+82062;['appeal is allowed']
+35403;['302 (c.a.']
+60516;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+57820;['appeal is allowed.the']
+86393;['appeal isallowed']
+125145;['appeal is allowed']
+52075;['appeal isallowedand']
+62959;['appeal isallowed']
+95504;['appeal is dismissed']
+48424;['appeal is allowed']
+100929;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+70648;['appeal was dismissed']
+17985;['appeals are dismissed']
+97609;['appeal is allowed']
+90144;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+86519;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+67799;['appeal is allowed']
+69949;['appeal is dismissed']
+102443;['appeal is allowed']
+148590;['appeal is dismissed']
+124642;['appeal is dismissed']
+102467;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151479;['appeal is dismissed']
+86061;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124545;['appellant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+84498;['appeal is allowed']
+84219;['appeal is dismissed']
+47402;['complaint was dismissed']
+93668;['appeal is dismissed']
+51759;['appeal is allowed']
+94221;['thatxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+124458;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+60966;['appeal is dismissed']
+87096;['allows this appeal']
+79106;['302 (c.a.']
+97639;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+18012;['appeal were dismissed']
+151870;['appeal is dismissed']
+60379;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+133723;['rpd’s decision should therefore be set aside']
+91430;['302 (c.a.']
+96291;['302 (c.a.']
+130696;['appeal is dismissed']
+49182;['appeal is dismissed']
+55270;['refugee protection division rejects the claims of xxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxx for refugee protection', 'determines them neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50249;['removal order is set aside']
+91905;['appeal is dismissed']
+96906;['nor a person in need of protection']
+100643;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83295;['decision cannot stand']
+95481;['appeal is dismissed']
+124938;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+15562;['appeal is allowed']
+47792;['appeal is terminated']
+124664;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+97457;['panel rejects their claims']
+123867;['appeal is allowed']
+77614;['appeal is dismissed']
+135921;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+123595;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+67586;['dismiss the appeal']
+54713;['determination is valid in law']
+71160;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+63833;['appeal is allowed']
+132279;['leads me to set aside the rpd’s credibility analysis']
+150254;['appeal is allowed']
+116802;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101173;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+122637;['appeal is allowed']
+49135;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+48280;['appeal is dismissed']
+8279;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+130783;['removal orders areset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+76157;['appeal is dismissed']
+106336;['appeal is dismissed']
+56637;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97212;['refugee protection claim filed byxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis rejected']
+121211;['ifa locations fail']
+105604;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+108764;['appellants were not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+95912;['rad allows the appeal']
+101712;['appeal is terminated']
+101261;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a refugee']
+89679;['appeal is allowed']
+70066;['appeal is dismissed']
+112384;['rpd decision is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+92853;['removal order is set aside']
+95009;['dismiss the appeal']
+150672;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+95230;['appeal is dismissed']
+74682;['appeal isallowed']
+89547;['appeal is terminated']
+52129;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+153732;['allow this appeal']
+90176;['302 (c.a.']
+27252;['appeal is dismissed']
+123525;['appeal is allowed']
+104558;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34102;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+108794;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+27299;['appeal is allowed']
+50482;['appeal is allowed']
+125327;['appeal is allowed']
+145047;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26813;['appeal ofxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxis dismissed']
+152003;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+143872;['appeal is allowed']
+70009;['appeal is allowed']
+66583;['appeal of zahra ghanizadeh is dismissed']
+124919;['appeal is allowed']
+71151;['dismisses this appeal']
+87595;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+139838;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+100941;['appeal of deanna joan eli heffernan is dismissed']
+33240;['appeal is dismissed']
+81632;['appeal is dismissed']
+60951;['allowed the appellant’s appeal from conviction']
+17113;['appeal is dismissed']
+58389;['appeal is dismissed']
+102889;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143069;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+106797;['appeal were dismissed']
+19310;['appeal is allowed']
+102091;['appeal is dismissed']
+105616;['refugee protection claims ofxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare rejected']
+27310;['appeal is allowed']
+151488;['appeal must fail']
+110951;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94148;['appeal is not allowed']
+52787;['appeal is dismissed']
+76483;['appeal is allowed']
+90046;['appeal is allowed']
+73297;['appeal is dismissed']
+23079;['appeal is allowed']
+84443;['appeal is allowed']
+87199;['appeal is allowed']
+100400;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+71201;['appeal is dismissed']
+87100;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+114331;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+98531;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+47122;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+85608;['appeal is terminated']
+95065;['appeals of the other four appellants are also dismissed']
+55132;['determination is valid in law']
+67554;['appeal is allowed']
+52060;['appeal isallowedand']
+150741;['neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+14664;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+74612;['appeal is allowed']
+106851;['appeal isallowed']
+67929;['appeal is terminated']
+69627;['dismiss this appeal']
+100301;['refugee protection claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+69779;['appeal is dismissed']
+93805;['thatxxxx xxxxx xxxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+101343;['appeal is allowed']
+109693;['appeal is dismissed']
+64056;['dismissed the appeal']
+103532;['appeal is dismissed']
+61320;['rad substitutes its decision for that of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+60407;['appeal isallowed']
+111877;['appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123988;['302 (c.a.']
+101857;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+129916;['appeal is allowed']
+151922;['appeal is dismissed']
+95430;['appeal is allowed to proceed']
+110309;['dismissing an appeal']
+130795;['removal order is set aside']
+80364;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+132735;['claimants are therefore not “persons in need of protection']
+45173;['appeal be dismissed']
+99244;['appeal is allowed']
+100813;['appeal is dismissed']
+100976;['appeal is dismissed']
+54660;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+45404;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+100884;['board therefore rejects his claim']
+94184;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+18928;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+101312;['stay is cancelled']
+94719;['appeal is allowed']
+84071;['panel’s oral decision is a nullity']
+107152;['rejecting her appeal']
+15576;['appeal of merly sual flores is dismissed']
+95486;['appeal is terminated']
+98248;['appeal is allowed']
+79603;['appeal must be dismissed']
+148616;['appeal is allowed.the']
+108705;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither\xa0 convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104144;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93676;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+89137;['appeal is allowed']
+87437;['appeal is allowed']
+140628;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+98456;['negative']
+95279;['appeal be dismissed']
+74486;['visa officer’s decision is invalid']
+135450;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+60030;['claimant is determined to be neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70159;['leads me to doubt the applicant’s credibility']
+143413;['appeal is based onsubrule\xa058(d) of theimmigration appeal division rules']
+152469;['appeal is allowed']
+149487;['rad does not have any legislative jurisdiction']
+110709;['appeal is dismissed']
+151495;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54254;['appeal is dismissed']
+73680;['appeal is allowed']
+96285;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+35921;['appeal is allowed.the']
+144420;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124821;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection”']
+40484;['appeal is dismissed']
+52044;['panel has lost jurisdiction']
+151832;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd’s decision', 'not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26793;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+77691;['claimants are victims of vengeance.']
+57044;['appeal is dismissed']
+131042;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellantxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89401;['negative']
+91589;['application to re-open the applicant’s removal orderappeal']
+129175;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+88818;['appeal is allowed']
+91348;['application to late file brought by the appellant is dismissed']
+70009;['allows this appeal']
+102264;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+82433;['appeal abandoned']
+123837;['appeal is rejected']
+56924;['appeal isallowed']
+106651;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+142471;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+30495;['appeal isallowed']
+37857;['appeal is dismissed']
+30379;['rad concurs with this remedy']
+13950;['appeal is dismissed']
+103815;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103093;['appeal is allowed']
+90853;['appeal cannot succeed']
+151914;['rad finds that she is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+67204;['appeal is dismissed']
+94001;['appeal is dismissed']
+143014;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision that', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123404;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+117147;['appeal is allowed']
+140278;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+77785;['appeal is allowed']
+19111;['appeal is dismissed']
+94424;['appeal is allowed']
+42227;['appeal be dismissed']
+102039;['kids are not permanent residents of canada']
+93768;['appellants are convention refugees']
+78766;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+91449;['302 (c.a.)']
+125590;['appeal is allowed']
+122955;['appeal is allowed']
+34176;['appeal is allowed']
+135175;['not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+83279;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination of the appellant’s claim for refugee protection']
+110682;['dismisses the appeal']
+87822;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+52489;['appeal is dismissed']
+47123;['panel finds that the removal order is valid in law']
+69076;['refuse this appeal']
+108883;['claims are rejected']
+72312;['appeal is dismissed']
+92962;['appeal isallowedand']
+88304;['allow the appeal']
+68271;['appeal is allowed']
+55952;['appeal is dismissed']
+151844;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+100093;['panel therefore rejects these claims for refugee protection']
+21100;['appeal therefore is dismissed']
+71368;['appeal of ayan omar hassan is dismissed']
+113622;['appeal is dismissed']
+103039;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+90820;['appeal isallowed']
+72321;['appeal is dismissed']
+76807;['appeal is dismissed']
+18197;['appeal isallowedin law']
+83015;['appeal is rejected']
+124995;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+45188;['appeal is allowed']
+98312;['appeal is allowed']
+127340;['appeals are allowed']
+100363;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+38901;['appeal is dismissed']
+96209;['appeal is allowed']
+80548;['appeal is dismissed']
+76511;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107041;['appeal ofgurjeet kauris dismissed']
+117210;['not confirm the rpd’s determination']
+132777;['appeal is dismissed']
+87228;['appeal is dismissed']
+100064;['appeal is dismissed']
+105848;['appeal is dismissed']
+97850;['neither a “convention refugee', 'rejects his claim']
+94130;['dismissal of the appeal']
+128360;['appeal is allowed']
+134298;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+90123;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+87616;['appeal is allowed']
+90137;['allows the appeal']
+85393;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+145844;['appeal is allowed']
+151502;['appeal is dismissed']
+34870;['appeal isallowed']
+108756;['rad finds that the analysis provided by the rpd is insufficient']
+83537;['appeal is dismissed']
+72858;['appeal mustbe dismissed']
+47391;['appeal from that refusal was allowed']
+78094;['appeal isallowed']
+86396;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94281;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection”.']
+125025;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+98512;['claimant not to be a convention refugee', 'reject her claim']
+85436;['appeal is dismissed']
+91067;['appeal is allowed']
+38244;['appeal is allowed']
+108117;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107234;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+57932;['appeal is dismissed']
+125351;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87094;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97080;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+97288;['negative']
+98411;['appeal must be allowed']
+104557;['appeal is dismissed']
+71650;['appeal is allowed.the']
+73200;['removal order is set aside']
+87711;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+110308;['appeal is dismissed']
+69062;['appeal is allowed']
+69830;['appeal is dismissed']
+68187;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98170;['appeals ofsaadia\xa0zirari,yassine el\xa0houkmiandmaria el\xa0houkmiare allowed']
+90368;['negative']
+108953;['appeal is allowed']
+127404;['appeal is allowed']
+98626;['appeal is dismissed']
+54747;['appeal is dismissed']
+91709;['appeals of tae sung eom and tae ho eom are dismissed']
+63058;['appeal is allowed.the']
+98429;['appeal is denied']
+91636;['appeal is dismissed']
+73334;['decision of the visa officer is well founded', 'appeal is dismissed']
+131547;['appeal of gulfiya rakhmatulina is allowed']
+91370;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+124685;['302 (c.a.']
+54255;['appeal is not moot']
+26719;['appeal is dismissed']
+82358;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+29305;['appeal is dismissed']
+55230;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+70024;['appeal being allowed']
+99090;['appeal is dismissed']
+64057;['appeal is allowed']
+20013;['appeal is allowed']
+80996;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+143504;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+71203;['appeal is dismissed']
+56726;['appeal isallowed']
+114347;['appeal is allowed']
+128556;['appeal is allowed']
+87712;['appeal is allowed.the']
+67494;['appeal isallowed']
+145322;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144932;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62212;['appeal is terminated']
+82152;['appeal be dismissed']
+92510;['appeal is dismissed']
+52603;['xxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+107697;['appeal is dismissed']
+74664;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+146156;['appeals are dismissed']
+123474;['appeal is allowed']
+83365;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+99133;['appeal isallowed.the']
+67245;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+35670;['appeal isallowed']
+74108;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+26506;['appeal of junelle brillantes is dismissed']
+89853;['appeal is allowed']
+74714;['appeal isallowed']
+98385;['appeal is dismissed']
+9483;['dismiss the appeal']
+52285;['appeal isallowedundersection']
+75585;['appeal is allowed']
+105281;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a “convention refugee”']
+59404;['appeal is allowed']
+84693;['appeal is allowed']
+121221;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+110558;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+88975;['appeal is allowed']
+93321;['appeal isallowed']
+93682;['appeal of the appellant “sb” is allowed']
+142728;['appeals are dismissed']
+26699;['appellants should not be removed']
+68723;['appeal is dismissed']
+147441;['appeal was dismissed']
+132322;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103598;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+121253;['appellants are convention refugees']
+90849;['302 (c.a.']
+124194;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107161;['rad rejects the appellant’s argument']
+124931;['appeal is allowed']
+97339;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+99784;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38839;['appeal isallowed']
+105643;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+63720;['appeal is dismissed']
+91223;['appeal is allowed']
+107638;['appeal be dismissed']
+71565;['appeal isallowed']
+149578;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim']
+94821;['appeal is allowed']
+60210;['appeal is allowed']
+78296;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60318;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+70480;['application for a reconsideration of member dolin’s decision is dismissed']
+83075;['appeal is allowed']
+69198;['appeal is dismissed']
+63095;['not a convention refugee']
+101705;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93740;['favourable decision is attached to this decision and reasons']
+124419;['appellants have established that they are convention refugees']
+38878;['fan xi lin is not a person described by section 117(9)(d) of theregulations']
+107245;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+34894;['appeal is allowed']
+82693;['appeal is allowed']
+99505;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+101543;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+108342;['appeal is allowed']
+91447;['appeal is terminated']
+89581;['appeal is terminated']
+54524;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102409;['appeal is dismissed']
+94540;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+105915;['neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+77820;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+60470;['appeal is allowed']
+101417;['302 (c.a.']
+132295;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146544;['rpd found that the appellant was not a person in need of protection']
+40803;['appeal is allowed']
+87444;['appeal is allowed']
+67732;['decision is well founded in law']
+23023;['appeal is allowed']
+91932;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+131549;['appeal is dismissed']
+144397;['rad rejects the appellant’s argument']
+113794;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+99720;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpaparticularly in']
+111358;['appellant is not a refugeesur place']
+35072;['appeals are allowed']
+135502;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+91319;['appeal is terminated']
+103754;['confirms the determination of the rpd']
+94609;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+37844;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94746;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+69619;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+123996;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination']
+13809;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+31998;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+124941;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76537;['appeal isallowed']
+144940;['substitute it with my own determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+126449;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+140840;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+91630;['allow all the appeals']
+71161;['refugee protection division rejects the claim to refugee status']
+102210;['appeal is dismissed']
+83501;['appeal is determined']
+74106;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92444;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+54319;['appeal is allowed']
+77868;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+100475;['appeal is dismissed']
+21400;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+102291;['rad does not have enough elements to substitute its own decision']
+70171;['appeal is dismissed']
+84833;['officer’s decision is invalid in law']
+94575;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+37859;['appeal is allowed']
+139443;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+52125;['rad cannot find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+59830;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+149484;['appeal is allowed']
+73042;['appeal is allowed']
+56755;['reject his claim']
+75423;['appeal isallowed']
+123288;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+136735;['confirm the rpd’s decision']
+47387;['appeal is dismissed']
+96681;['transcript will constitute your decision']
+99173;['appeal is dismissed']
+131000;['appeal isallowed']
+109626;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'find the appellants be convention refugees']
+100260;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd']
+37077;['appeal is dismissed']
+100448;['appeal is dismissed']
+130864;['officer’s decision to refuse permanent resident visas is set aside']
+77931;['appeal is allowed']
+26830;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+68713;['appeal is allowed']
+94627;['appeal is dismissed']
+151728;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+40853;['appeal is dismissed']
+133722;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+49713;['appeal is allowed']
+95981;['claimant to not be a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+81247;['appeal is allowed']
+109283;['summons is not a genuine document']
+96880;['allows the application to reinstate the appeal']
+150945;['appeal is allowed']
+102134;['application to reopen the appeal isdismissed.']
+99157;['appeal is terminated']
+22125;['appeal should be dismissed']
+90707;['removal order is set aside']
+74794;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+82730;['appeal is dismissed']
+72817;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+80452;['appeals are allowed.the']
+126420;['rpd decision must stand']
+46543;['appeal isallowed']
+84554;['appeal is allowed']
+87709;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+62643;['302 (c.a.']
+82385;['determination is not valid in law']
+142475;['rad grants the appeal ofxxxxand']
+26746;['appeal accordingly is allowed']
+82884;['my decision that the visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+42293;['appeal is dismissed']
+128567;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+134288;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71089;['appeal is allowed']
+87451;['appeal be allowed']
+76149;['302 (c.a.']
+142304;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+67795;['appeal is allowed']
+59984;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+92543;['appeal is determined']
+99234;['appeal is dismissed']
+84907;['claimants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees']
+52128;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+99840;['appeal is allowed']
+71610;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+52106;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87807;['appeal isallowed']
+89703;['appeal is allowed']
+151718;['allows her claim for refugee protection']
+44337;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+70481;['appeal isallowed']
+143233;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+74228;['appeal is dismissed']
+89884;['appeal of saeed hersi mohamed is dismissed']
+107434;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+83500;['decision is well-founded in law and in fact']
+99132;['appeal is dismissed']
+121383;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+69491;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+22995;['appeal is dismissed']
+44018;['rad has found that the rpd has not erred in its findings']
+121482;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxxxxxis neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83012;['appeal is dismissed']
+71277;['appeal is dismissed']
+99977;['appeal of miao yu is dismissed']
+67169;['dismiss this appeal']
+85982;['appeal is allowed']
+131182;['removal order is set aside']
+149491;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+86301;['appeal is determined']
+63855;['panel rejects the claims of xxxxx xxxxx']
+59376;['appeal of surinder singh brar is dismissed']
+130772;['appeal isallowedby']
+141592;['rad dismisses the appeal forxxxx', 'confirms the rpd’s decision that he is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123694;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96466;['appeals are also dismissed']
+145291;['302 (c.a.)']
+79893;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95979;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116771;['appellant,xxxx xxxx, is not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+126446;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+112788;['decision is valid in law']
+108899;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+123772;['appeal is allowed']
+85944;['appeal isallowed']
+151747;['appeal is dismissed']
+123838;['appeal is allowed']
+150706;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+23074;['appeal is dismissed']
+61015;['the claim fails']
+65418;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+132773;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”']
+37844;['appeal is allowed']
+61880;['appeal is terminated']
+67525;['appeal is allowed.after']
+143533;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79628;['appeal is dismissed']
+84143;['appeal is allowed']
+150834;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26759;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+143131;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+145073;['claimant is not a convention refugee, or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+99563;['appeal is dismissed']
+72586;['appeal should be dismissed']
+134517;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+94212;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+71473;['appeal must be dismissed']
+92858;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+66759;['appeal is dismissed']
+102073;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89819;['appeal is allowed']
+91003;['appeal’s relative merit']
+85550;['appeal must accordingly fail']
+69624;['dismiss the appeal', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+150639;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95433;['appeal of surjan singh dhillon is dismissed']
+57514;['appeal is dismissed']
+100428;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+130791;['appeal is allowed']
+64226;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+8297;['appeals are dismissed']
+92772;['appeal is dismissed']
+134410;['appeal is dismissed']
+21427;['convention refugee determination division therefore finds xxxxxxx xxxxx to be a convention refugee']
+76557;['appeal isallowed']
+74526;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99686;['appeal is dismissed']
+73591;['appeal is allowed']
+153281;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+60408;['application to re-open this file is rejected']
+81101;['appellant is a refugee']
+21338;['ground is nationality']
+89189;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+131719;['appeal is dismissed']
+150232;['appeals are allowed']
+50521;['appeal is allowed']
+105372;['confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+75489;['deny his application to re-open']
+80463;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+51051;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+127476;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+124958;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+123470;['appeal is dismissed']
+124900;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+76155;['negative']
+151755;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made']
+151587;['appeal is dismissed']
+91610;['negative']
+129199;['appeal is allowed']
+142487;['are neither refugees nor pips is confirmed']
+94442;['appeal is dismissed']
+15579;['appeal is allowed']
+99464;['claims are rejected']
+135111;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd determination']
+151531;['302 (c.a.']
+77214;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+70894;['appeal is allowed']
+151857;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'not “convention refugees”']
+96294;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+64127;['appeal is allowed']
+142287;['appeal is allowed']
+133384;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98591;['appeal is allowed']
+54547;['appeal is allowed']
+118242;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151959;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+116742;['appeal is based']
+95923;['rad finds these assessments are not valid generally']
+95470;['appeal is dismissed']
+93086;['claimants are not ‘convention refugees’']
+124431;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+83712;['appeal is dismissed']
+97626;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+59671;['appeal isallowed']
+122675;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+48417;['determination is valid in law']
+63981;['appeal was dismissed']
+146440;['appeal is dismissed']
+74528;['appeal is terminated by operation of law']
+101504;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+70037;['sets aside the deportation order and allows the appeal']
+54721;['appeal is dismissed']
+83657;['appeal is dismissed']
+97873;['appeal isallowed']
+106817;['appeal of naveed khan is dismissed']
+72598;['appeal isallowed']
+152947;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+19245;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+76682;['appeal is allowed']
+54259;['appeal is discontinued']
+97232;['appeal is allowed']
+123396;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+85858;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+27290;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+87320;['negative']
+87352;['appeal is dismissed']
+93922;['appeal is dismissed']
+26749;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+114332;['appeal is allowed']
+97436;['appeal is dismissed']
+94616;['negative']
+74508;['appeals are dismissed']
+51759;['appeal isallowed']
+100994;['refusal is invalid in law']
+47123;['appeal isdismissed.']
+92984;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+67222;['appeal isallowed']
+52136;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45407;['appeal is allowed']
+141307;['not be granted refugee protection']
+51338;['officer’s decision is well-founded in law']
+102681;['appeal is accepted']
+70228;['appeal isdismisseddue to']
+89947;['dismiss the appeal']
+146634;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection”']
+125686;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”']
+44977;['appeal is dismissed']
+95180;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142796;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+89751;['appeal is dismissed']
+81586;['appeal is dismissed']
+142913;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+87020;['appeal be dismissed']
+81013;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+87507;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+130940;['appeal is allowed']
+90441;['appeal was declared']
+142286;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+152598;['claimants are neither “conventionrefugees”']
+139849;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100128;['allowed the appeal']
+95563;['appeal of cam loan truong is dismissed']
+100163;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+54202;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100052;['dismissal of the appeal']
+80769;['ms. xxxxx\xa0 xxxxx\xa0 is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+125614;['appellant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+107474;['not substitute the decision of the rpd']
+68181;['appeal of maria lanie lanthier is dismissed']
+38407;['appeal is dismissed']
+94082;['appeal is dismissed']
+98384;['appeal is allowed']
+57668;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+153267;['appeal is allowed']
+97992;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+144415;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+48419;['appeal is allowed']
+140809;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69213;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+128843;['substitute my own decision that the appellantxxxx xxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+93856;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+67475;['appeal is dismissed']
+98489;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+43413;['appeal is dismissed']
+68207;['appeal of selma yonlu is dismissed']
+18996;['appeal is dismissed']
+122134;['appeal is allowed']
+144417;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'rejects the appeal']
+123597;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57735;['appeal is allowed']
+96105;['refugee protection claims filed byxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare rejected']
+54179;['appeal isallowed']
+36179;['appeal isallowed']
+84763;['appeal isallowed']
+78189;['appeal is allowed']
+139795;['dismiss this appeal']
+95185;['appeal is allowed']
+145834;['appeal is allowed']
+96828;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+135121;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+82882;['appeal is allowed']
+95771;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76044;['appeal is dismissed']
+57570;['appeal is allowed']
+63750;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+81122;['appeal is allowed']
+105607;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+102473;['appeal for precious ugochukwu iwueke is dismissed']
+127744;['application is dismissed']
+151791;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+122689;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+136746;['rad substitutes a positive decision', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+35401;['appeal is dismissed']
+148730;['nor a risk of cruel or unusual punishment', 'nor torture']
+74042;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+124738;['neither a high-school']
+40060;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+103098;['appeal is dismissed']
+35879;['appeal was dismissed']
+118122;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+94767;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146110;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134433;['dismissing this appeal']
+90805;['appeal is allowed']
+98445;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedundersection']
+120765;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90598;['panel finds that the removal order is well‑founded in law']
+146953;['appeal is allowed']
+111293;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+88808;['appeal is allowed']
+84349;['appeal is dismissed']
+87816;['claimant is, therefore, not a convention refugee']
+103726;['claimant is a   convention refugee']
+146431;['negative determination']
+81827;['appeal is dismissed']
+73365;['appeal is dismissed']
+83868;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+70760;['appeal is allowed']
+31048;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123672;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+124820;['appeal is allowed']
+47570;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74034;['302 (c.a.)']
+98520;['appeal isallowedand']
+133365;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+89263;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+144039;['appeal is dismissed']
+45190;['appeal is allowed']
+14662;['xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+87706;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+144712;['appeal were dismissed']
+91235;['appeal is terminated']
+140274;['appeal is weak in law']
+82854;['appeal of ranjit singh hans is dismissed']
+70186;['appeal is allowed']
+107684;['appeal dismissed']
+62470;['appeal is allowed']
+110986;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60427;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+71511;['appeal is terminated']
+58142;['appeal isterminated']
+65661;['appeal isallowed']
+81413;['appeal is allowed']
+151463;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96437;['ms. shahimi has not met her burden']
+19166;['appeal is dismissed']
+58837;['appeal is dismissed']
+102026;['appeal is dismissed']
+84766;['appeal isallowed']
+111336;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+133397;['appeal were dismissed']
+60930;['appeal isallowed']
+92398;['appeal is dismissed']
+81932;['disclosure application is dismissed']
+102116;['departure order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+100333;['302 (c.a.']
+59046;['appeal is dismissed']
+83307;['appeal isallowed']
+46385;['appeal is allowed']
+129877;['rad substitutes a positive determination']
+101512;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+41567;['appeal is dismissed']
+123914;['appeal is allowed']
+101758;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89319;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92812;['appeal is dismissed']
+52502;['appeal is allowed']
+96021;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+151811;['appeal is dismissed']
+110294;['appeal is allowed']
+99399;['appeal will not be reopened']
+94400;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96100;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146534;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50621;['appeal is allowed.the']
+129139;['appeal is allowed']
+13833;['appeal isallowed']
+52683;['302 (c.a.']
+62380;['not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+30522;['appeal is dismissed']
+132824;['appeal be dismissed']
+139839;['dismiss the appeal']
+69374;['appeal isallowed']
+100323;['appeal is allowed']
+76679;['appeal is allowed']
+96751;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+97780;['negative']
+69458;['refusal is not valid in law']
+72643;['appeal is allowed.the']
+113217;['removal order is set aside']
+75483;['appeal of inderpal singh nijjar is dismissed']
+132348;['appeal is allowed']
+56671;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+125209;['appeal abandoned']
+87361;['appeal is determined']
+85166;['application to extend the time to file the notice of appeal is dismissed']
+116184;['rpd’s determination is set aside', 'appellants are persons in need of protection']
+52537;['appeal is allowed']
+21939;['appeal should be dismissed']
+116849;['302 (c.a.']
+149019;['appeal is allowed']
+151597;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+141068;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92471;['302 (c.a.']
+75241;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+74635;['appeal is dismissed']
+109532;['appeal is allowed']
+78724;['departure orders are hereby set aside']
+123641;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150480;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+97375;['negative']
+100533;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+67586;['appeal is dismissed']
+106798;['appeal is dismissed']
+125370;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73217;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+75008;['application must be dismissed']
+74106;['applicants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+94043;['appeal is dismissed']
+22120;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+94032;['302 (c.a.)']
+144938;['appeal is allowed']
+95257;['appeal is dismissed']
+139846;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89199;['appeal is dismissed']
+47368;['appeal of jatinder kumar lealh is dismissed']
+100447;['cliam is denied']
+47129;['dismiss your appeal']
+80750;['negative']
+101838;['appeal is allowed']
+100126;['appeal is allowed']
+136090;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142975;['confirm the rpd determination']
+147883;['i deny the minister’s application']
+95128;['application to extend the time to file the notice of appeal is dismissed']
+30547;['appeal be allowed']
+61967;['appeal isallowed']
+124365;['appeal is allowed']
+106292;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+39031;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+37412;['appeal isallowed']
+101799;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+92799;['appeal is dismissed']
+71805;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+128159;['rad finds that the rpd decision cannot stand']
+68407;['appeal is therefore re-opened']
+79111;['appeal is dismissed']
+130978;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63237;['appeal is dismissed']
+94248;['rad concurs with the rpd’s findings']
+69413;['appeal is dismissed']
+62439;['appeal is allowed']
+151926;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+108878;['claimant, xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+60418;['appeal is allowed']
+50471;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+63176;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+66913;['appeal is dismissed']
+80664;['302 (c.a.']
+39919;['appeal is allowed']
+98354;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90105;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+29634;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+31229;['removal orders are set aside']
+78056;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88155;['appeal is allowed']
+102393;['appeals are dismissed']
+130981;['nor a viable internal flight alternative']
+80476;['appeal is allowed']
+46293;['appeal is dismissed']
+59909;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+59993;['claims are rejected']
+107941;['decision has no precedential value for this decision']
+47767;['allows the appellant’s appeal']
+89354;['appeal is allowed']
+135467;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+142796;['302 (c.a.']
+79978;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124695;['confirm the negative decision']
+61218;['appeal is allowed']
+71554;['appeal is allowed']
+101309;['appellants are convention refugees']
+106166;['appeal is dismissed']
+136086;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor “a person in need of protection']
+23002;['appeal is allowed']
+145321;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+113560;['appeal is allowed']
+62385;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+140855;['appeal is allowed']
+77881;['appeal is allowed']
+42279;['appeal is dismissed']
+45182;['appeal is allowed']
+113626;['appeal is allowed.the']
+12226;['appeal isallowed']
+62953;['allows this appeal']
+75996;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+115181;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+83459;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “conventionrefugee”']
+98618;['appeal is terminated']
+139887;['…).”']
+103113;['appeal terminated']
+67744;['appeal isallowed']
+56812;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+72179;['appeal abandoned']
+69612;['appeal be dismissed']
+77323;['appeal of derrick winston green is to be rescheduled']
+84079;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98318;['appeal is terminated']
+101669;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+95601;['302 (c.a.']
+84466;['appeal is allowed.the']
+142961;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86195;['appeal of mohammad zubair khan is dismissed']
+109144;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim']
+79918;['rejects their claim']
+29692;['appeal is dismissed']
+38880;['302 (c.a.)']
+94302;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84132;['appeal is allowed']
+84637;['appeal is allowed']
+87133;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+131528;['appeal is allowed']
+46285;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+107237;['appeal is dismissed']
+100158;['appeal is dismissed']
+98857;['appeal is dismissed']
+129134;['appeal is dismissed']
+83668;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+143631;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96746;['302 (c.a.']
+77084;['appeal is allowed']
+112370;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+52296;['sponsorship is not a usual case']
+55980;['appeal is terminated']
+62241;['negative']
+81002;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+101321;['appeal is allowed']
+76835;['removal order is set aside']
+67400;['appeal isallowed']
+121954;['the claim fails']
+112776;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+67257;['appeal is hereby withdrawn']
+68923;['appeal isallowed']
+129139;['appeal is allowed']
+99679;['claim is rejected']
+59748;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+131503;['appeal is allowed']
+144899;['appeal is dismissed']
+75136;['appeal is allowed']
+68721;['appeal is allowed']
+13832;['removal order isset aside']
+150695;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+103051;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+31379;['appeal is not allowed']
+20014;['appeal isallowed']
+136115;['appeal is dismissed']
+90193;['“convention refugees']
+110045;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143231;['appeal may have some merit']
+122556;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+104109;['refugee protection division rejects this claim']
+85378;['appeal is dismissed']
+72615;['appeal is allowed']
+150616;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+93822;['division therefore rejects your claim']
+97009;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+24457;['appeal is dismissed']
+107156;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57516;['dismiss the appeal']
+93047;['appeal is not moot']
+143860;['appellants are convention refugees']
+146824;['substitute my own decision that the adult appellants are convention refugees']
+125323;['302 (c.a.']
+113296;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+95773;['appeal is dismissed']
+70005;['application is denied']
+142477;['appeal is denied']
+73197;['appeal of satinder singh sekhon is dismissed']
+94357;['removal order isset aside']
+54817;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+108941;['appeal is allowed']
+107613;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95413;['appeal fails for lack of evidence']
+94603;['appeal of this appellant is accordingly allowed']
+43323;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+70380;['appeal is dismissed']
+93828;['claim is rejected']
+64310;['appeal of jinder kaur aulakh is allowed']
+112365;['appeal is dismissed']
+124433;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention\xa0refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97384;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'rejects the claim']
+52789;['appeal is allowed']
+52706;['claimants are convention refugeesor persons in need of protection']
+125372;['appeal is granted']
+80049;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'i reject their claims']
+94396;['appeal is dismissed']
+125296;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx,pursuant tosection\xa098of theirpa', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122945;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94450;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+59159;['appeal is dismissed']
+84698;['appeal isallowed']
+125406;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+108191;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+74547;['appeal is allowed']
+56902;['application to reopen and set aside the deportation order is dismissed']
+142537;['appeal is allowed']
+131076;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+120759;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+151953;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+94722;['appeal is rejected']
+102119;['dismiss the appeal']
+118240;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141282;['appeal is allowed']
+102797;['allowed the appeal']
+90206;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+61898;['appeal is allowed']
+71189;['appeal is allowed']
+84815;['application is granted']
+69244;['302 (c.a.)']
+34877;['appeal isallowed']
+95108;['board therefore rejects his claim']
+75970;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+100994;['appeal is allowed in law']
+89567;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+100363;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+109035;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+40804;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+124898;['rad allows the appeal']
+101558;['appeal of quoc chi dang is dismissed']
+96652;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+101456;['appeals are granted']
+68407;['application to re-open is allowed']
+83866;['appeal is dismissed']
+67018;['application for extension of time is therefore dismissed', 'appeal is also dismissed']
+123067;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+87689;['stay of the removal order is revoked', 'appeal is dismissed']
+72777;['appeal is dismissed']
+60898;['appeal isallowed']
+134432;['appeal is allowed.the']
+131159;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71165;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+71232;['appeal is allowed']
+51670;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'respondent is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+56924;['appeal is allowed']
+125149;['dismiss the appeal', 'uphold the rpd’s determination']
+123325;['appeal is allowed']
+95939;['appeal is dismissed']
+88975;['appeal is being allowed']
+36612;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+142807;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination']
+27225;['appeal is determined']
+128441;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80243;['rejects his claim']
+26809;['appeal of karamjit kaur sandhu is dismissed']
+26828;['he is not a convention refugee']
+80993;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+147776;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+54224;['appeal isdiscontinuedpursuant tosection\xa0196of theimmigration and refugee protection actand']
+86052;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee']
+136704;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143478;['claimants are neither convention refugees not persons in need of protection']
+94177;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125244;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+82689;['appeal is allowed']
+98334;['302 (c.a.']
+70464;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+76342;['decision is well founded in law']
+30380;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+143229;['appeal of van du le is dismissed']
+91662;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+94297;['appeal is allowed']
+124195;['appeal is allowed']
+86641;['appeal is dismissed']
+52049;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+106832;['appeal was dismissed']
+76088;['appeal is determined']
+86027;['appeal isallowed']
+75600;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69590;['appeal is dismissed']
+63975;['appeal isallowed']
+42567;['appeal is allowed']
+98741;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+150674;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+14663;['crc was adopted by the united nations general assembly']
+42352;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+50450;['rpd’s determination', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+24244;['appeal is dismissed']
+70771;['appeal is dismissed']
+38428;['appeal is dismissed']
+17963;['appeal is allowed']
+86381;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+52162;['negative']
+88305;['appeal isallowedand']
+32082;['appeal is dismissed']
+71365;['appeal is dismissed']
+68719;['appeal is dismissed']
+69075;['appeal is dismissed']
+132316;['neither the objective evidence']
+54792;['appeals are dismissed']
+17145;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+105608;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90501;['appeal isallowed.the']
+123666;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+95021;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+102096;['determination is valid in law']
+144032;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+90671;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+60363;['appeal is allowed in law']
+74671;['theappeal is allowed']
+151647;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+98451;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90075;['appeal is dismissed']
+65128;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+68742;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+100024;['appeal is terminated by operation of law']
+24070;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+106637;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+90805;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+86054;['appeal isallowedand']
+101792;['appeal ofzhi wei li is dismissed']
+94171;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96805;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+63917;['appeal is dismissed']
+89764;['appellant does not lose his permanent resident status']
+68691;['appeal is allowed']
+67524;['appeal isallowed']
+89793;['appeal isallowed.the']
+86390;['appeal is dismissed']
+83060;['theappeal is dismissed']
+86639;['appeal is dismissed']
+123459;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”']
+82391;['removal orders areset aside']
+82385;['appeal is allowed']
+94445;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100067;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects her claim']
+122641;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124184;['appellant is neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+90844;['claimant was not a person in need of protection']
+94103;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123474;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88509;['negative']
+95117;['appeal is abandoned']
+80102;['appeal is terminated']
+124698;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+74791;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71807;['appeal isallowed']
+125661;['appeal is allowed']
+141268;['302 (c.a.']
+42002;['appeal isdismissed.']
+150941;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96822;['negative']
+95638;['appeal were dismissed']
+40647;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97317;['determination is valid in law']
+100285;['appeal is allowed']
+20011;['appeal is allowed']
+94809;['appeal is dismissed']
+105706;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+101927;['appeal isallowed']
+93669;['appeal is dismissed']
+133194;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+52493;['appeal isallowed']
+94132;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+89371;['appeal is terminated']
+118293;['adopt the findings of the rpd']
+97637;['not a convention refugee', 'nor are you a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim']
+82787;['appeal is dismissed']
+52329;['applicants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+141228;['appellants are not convention refugees undersection\xa096of theirpaor']
+107094;['appeal is not allowed']
+69128;['appeal is allowed']
+107625;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+121414;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+99186;['panel therefore rejects her claim']
+70115;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+56708;['appeal is allowed']
+153056;['claimants are not convention refugees,']
+89767;['dismiss this appeal']
+64007;['dismiss the appeal']
+107437;['appeal is dismissed']
+81136;['appeal is dismissed']
+63977;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+106806;['appeal is well‑founded on', 'officer’s decision to refuse to grant a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+123719;['appeal is allowed']
+88124;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+69562;['decision is valid in law']
+108727;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+55343;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100505;['appeal was dismissed']
+108246;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+146554;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+100214;['appeal isallowed']
+74476;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+101314;['appeal is allowed']
+71135;['refusal invalid in law']
+91908;['appeal is allowed']
+80805;['appeal is allowed']
+80247;['302 (c.a.']
+96775;['claimants to not be convention refugees unders']
+96529;['appeal is terminated']
+96736;['appeal is allowed']
+96648;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+102961;['appeal is dismissed']
+145370;['appeal were dismissed']
+35658;['appeal isdismissed.']
+83182;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+33696;['302 (c.a.)']
+91927;['appeal is allowed']
+100152;['appeal isallowedand']
+123690;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+45424;['allows the appeal']
+98142;['appeal is allowed']
+91646;['appeal is dismissed']
+66775;['dismiss the appeal']
+99565;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+96792;['appeal of saloumeh momenipour is dismissed']
+95931;['appellants are not convention refugees, or persons in need of protection']
+125571;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neitherconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78014;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+68619;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+76650;['appeal is governed by theact']
+46826;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+124344;['appellant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+131153;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95716;['appeal is allowed']
+111350;['appeal is denied']
+121396;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+73028;['appeal of the appellant is dismissed']
+53826;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+83930;['appeal is dismissed']
+88840;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+81380;['refugee is devoid of any remedy']
+122832;['appeal is dismissed']
+26837;['xxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxx are not convention refugees']
+91341;['appeal is dismissed']
+72633;['declare the appellant’s appeal abandoned']
+99960;['appeal is dismissed']
+129231;['302 (c.a.']
+124592;['dismiss the appeal,', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+38873;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107495;['appeal is accepted']
+121939;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+143622;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+88843;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69146;['appeal of thanh le is dismissed']
+79464;['negative permanent resident determination']
+128611;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+100841;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+141299;['appeal is dismissed']
+132326;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+78095;['appeal is dismissed']
+54224;['appeal is discontinued']
+92192;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+123549;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+95678;['appeal is dismissed']
+71485;['appeal isallowed']
+140985;['refugee claim analysis is forward-looking']
+122361;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132338;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+96769;['appeal is allowed']
+108717;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95325;['appeals are allowed']
+142818;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108871;['302 (c.a.']
+107650;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+31265;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71370;['appeal of zhan hong xie is dismissed']
+19379;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+132636;['application to reopen the appeal filed']
+129864;['removal order is set aside']
+83106;['appeal is allowed']
+83870;['appeal is dismissed']
+86626;['appeal is dismissed']
+109534;['appeals are dismissed']
+52143;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99003;['appeal is dismissed']
+31432;['appeal is dismissed']
+101051;['appeal is allowed']
+106844;['appeal is allowed']
+143137;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87085;['appeal should be allowed']
+107595;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+97262;['claim is therefore rejected']
+79872;['appeal is allowed']
+56261;['appeal isallowed']
+36465;['appeal of the refusal was dismissed']
+56968;['appeal is allowed']
+142460;['appeal is allowed']
+54161;['appeal of juliet mbambu is dismissed']
+52163;['claimant excluded']
+137481;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100900;['removal order is set aside']
+118538;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124665;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121382;['substitute the decision with its own decision that the appellant has established her claim']
+95199;['neither a canadian citizen', 'nor a permanent resident.']
+125007;['appeal is dismissed']
+58118;['allow his appeal']
+140738;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision']
+83252;['appeals are therefore allowed']
+24184;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140628;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+95449;['appeal is dismissed']
+52728;['convention refugee determination division determines xxxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+74687;['appeal is dismissed']
+71124;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+76456;['removal order is set aside']
+97437;['negative']
+130768;['appeal must be dismissed']
+124443;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+116799;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+113734;['appeal is allowed']
+105363;['rad confirms the rpd decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+105323;['302 (c.a.)']
+108772;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90986;['appeal is dismissed']
+97644;['claimants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are neither “convention refugees”']
+13682;['appeal of yulian ding is allowed']
+145064;['302 (c.a.']
+16790;['appeal is terminated']
+98551;['appeal is allowed']
+140242;['appeal is granted']
+35880;['appeal is allowed']
+101303;['appeal is allowed']
+82902;['appeal is dismissed']
+60048;['refugee protection division rejects the claim ofxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxpursuant']
+82174;['appeal abandoned']
+87689;['appeal is dismissed']
+125502;['appeal is dismissed']
+37423;['appeal is allowed']
+81625;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+33081;['appeal is dismissed']
+68187;['removal order is set aside']
+136122;['dismiss the appeals', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143865;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+65417;['appeal is dismissed']
+85847;['appeal is dismissed']
+84071;['refugee protection division rejects a claim']
+94449;['appeal is dismissed']
+80300;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+95779;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96802;['appeal is dismissed']
+147477;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125031;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142841;['appeal is dismissed']
+127475;['appeals are allowed']
+52522;['appeal is allowed']
+60024;['negative']
+125090;['appeal is dismissed']
+92028;['appeal is allowed']
+52036;['appeal is dismissed']
+94660;['appeal must be dismissed']
+96357;['appeal is dismissed']
+24508;['appeal was rescheduled']
+75575;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+148681;['appeal is dismissed']
+84809;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+152210;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85528;['appeal is dismissed']
+107182;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+88131;['dismissal of this appeal']
+78153;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+60319;['dismiss this appeal']
+47832;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+111166;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61386;['appeal must be dismissed']
+124265;['appeal is allowed.the']
+84587;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+94362;['appeal must be dismissed']
+128346;['appeal is allowed']
+90532;['appeal is dismissed']
+96376;['appeal is dismissed']
+84508;['appeal is allowed']
+74297;['appeal were dismissed']
+123130;['theappealis allowed']
+83644;['appeal is dismissed']
+42292;['theappeal is allowed']
+95597;['appeal is allowed']
+144773;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+67772;['appeal is discontinued']
+135942;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes that decision with its determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+88155;['appeal is allowed']
+124980;['support her claim']
+123679;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+143574;['they are convention refugees']
+68586;['appeal isallowed']
+75005;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98685;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+143901;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85531;['appeal is allowed']
+110268;['rad allows the appeal and returns the matter to the rpd']
+107037;['appeal is dismissed']
+92472;['appeal is allowed']
+107240;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87094;['appeal is allowed']
+123248;['theappeal is dismissed']
+124434;['appeal is allowed']
+96999;['appeal is dismissed']
+53826;['appeal is terminated']
+84221;['appeal isallowed']
+131541;['appeal is dismissed']
+98876;['302 (c.a.)']
+82252;['appeal is allowed']
+145042;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+130726;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+63160;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+108837;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+129259;['appeal is allowed']
+44333;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+97970;['appeal is allowed']
+141633;['appeal is allowed']
+78194;['appeal isallowed']
+53436;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+122992;['set aside the rpd’s negative determination', 'substitute a positive decision']
+45246;['appeal is coming up for hearing']
+93807;['the claim fails']
+103723;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124181;['confirm the rpd’s decision to exclude the appellant', 'appeal is dismissed']
+121442;['302 (c.a.']
+113295;['appeal is allowed']
+50734;['dismiss the appeal']
+99509;['appeal of reginald morval olsen is allowed']
+98648;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+72892;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+59382;['rad allows the appeal']
+102004;['appeal isallowed']
+96739;['appeal is abandoned']
+76965;['appeal is allowed']
+94588;['appeals are allowed']
+105888;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is she a “person in need of protection']
+96756;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+124572;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99966;['appeal is dismissed']
+77774;['appeal is dismissed']
+123877;['not substitute the decision of the rpd']
+147447;['302 (c.a.']
+122967;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees and/or persons in need of protection']
+86200;['appeal is allowed']
+69084;['appeal is allowed']
+102544;['appeal is allowed']
+97244;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98359;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+78000;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+45866;['appeal is dismissed']
+76505;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+25963;['appeal is determined']
+83941;['appeal isallowed']
+59780;['appeal is allowed']
+101860;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+61024;['appeal of chang mo ahn is dismissed']
+98789;['appeal of jagtar singh brar is dismissed']
+64255;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97432;['panel outright rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+48278;['appeal is dismissed']
+140894;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+104099;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+113262;['302 (c.a.']
+72663;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+75910;['appeal is dismissed']
+56098;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+84855;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+24200;['appeal is denied']
+92395;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from     ']
+140799;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+17983;['dismiss the appeal']
+97919;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+82123;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+101336;['appeal is terminated']
+151576;['allow the appeal and refer the matter back to the rpd']
+120766;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80675;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+123706;['appeal is dismissed']
+112341;['appeal is allowed']
+123028;['appeal is allowed']
+91195;['appeal is allowed']
+85394;['appeal is allowed']
+90748;"[""rad therefore confirms the rpd's negative determination""]"
+88452;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+35063;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95595;['i reject the claim']
+91275;['appeal is allowed']
+85853;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+43416;['appeal is allowed']
+57553;['appeal was to be scheduled']
+54280;['appeal is dismissed']
+100361;['nor persons in need of protection']
+55206;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+97393;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98608;['appeal isallowed']
+57899;['appeal is dismissed']
+34169;['appeal is dismissed']
+84083;['302 (c.a.']
+112376;['appeal is allowed']
+125167;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+69597;['appeal isallowed']
+67206;['appeal isallowed']
+101543;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+78168;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+82394;['removal order isset aside']
+70471;['dismiss this appeal']
+124654;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133381;['appeal were dismissed']
+68697;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+108195;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80196;['or a person in need of protection', 'rejects this claims for refugee protection']
+104086;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection from torture']
+64248;['appeal isallowed']
+100800;['appeal is dismissed']
+56884;['appeal is allowed']
+148717;['claimant, xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+105300;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+105809;['appeals are dismissed']
+123542;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95279;['appeal be dismissed']
+100884;['claimant, xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+113553;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+56756;['reject his claim']
+42276;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+80549;['appeal is terminated']
+91182;['appeal is terminated']
+61956;['appeal isallowed']
+113632;['appeal is allowed']
+105324;['appeal is allowed']
+42282;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+122771;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83920;['appeal is dismissed']
+100524;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140715;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74563;['appeal isallowed']
+139785;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+54760;['appeal is allowed']
+103907;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+61372;['appeals are successful']
+143617;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99793;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+47109;['appeal beallowed']
+26780;['appeal is allowed']
+95950;['appeal is allowed']
+23016;['appeal is allowed']
+84329;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+108252;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+93803;['claimants xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxare not “convention refugees', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+69371;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+90628;['appeal is dismissed']
+83651;['appellant is not a sponsor as described']
+114693;['claimant is not a “person in need of protection']
+100772;['appeals be determined dismissed']
+88141;['appeal is dismissed']
+132270;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97459;['exclusion order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91294;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+132363;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107922;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+99777;['appeal is dismissed']
+67513;['dismiss this appeal']
+100609;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+47720;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+145065;['claimants are not “convention refugees”', 'rejects their refugee protection claims']
+52295;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+111011;['appeal is dismissed']
+132784;['appeal is dismissed']
+143593;['rad agrees with the rpd’s conclusions']
+106155;['removal order isset aside']
+106446;['dismiss your appeal']
+61448;['removal order is set aside']
+83239;['appeal was dismissed']
+90547;['appeal abandoned']
+140978;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99083;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+80033;['negative']
+28072;['appeals are dismissed']
+123290;['her claim fails']
+107473;['rpd determination must be set aside']
+102922;['appeal is allowed']
+99898;['appeal is dismissed']
+121845;['appeal is denied', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71590;['appeal is allowed']
+74114;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from the definition of convention refugee']
+82661;['appeals of ahmad mehrabadi, his wife']
+76848;['appeal is allowed']
+100665;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+68297;['dismiss the appeal']
+77790;['appeal is allowed']
+92841;['appeal is dismissed']
+84806;['appeal isallowed']
+82983;['appeal is allowed']
+100139;['appeal isallowedand']
+83151;['appeal of william de jesus suarez is dismissed']
+93053;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+82214;['appeal dismissed']
+135912;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+122769;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133380;['appeal isallowed']
+68737;['appeal is terminated[emphasis']
+125620;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122767;['appeal is allowed']
+100347;['appeal is dismissed']
+124962;['dismiss the appeal.the', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82655;['appeal is allowed']
+125470;['302 (c.a.']
+69772;['appeal is dismissed']
+21321;['not convention refugees']
+121522;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+94421;['appeal is allowed']
+77771;['appeal is terminated']
+92503;['appeal is allowed']
+92481;['negative']
+104171;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+108823;['rad finds that the decision of the rpd cannot stand']
+38418;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100269;['appeal isallowed']
+105352;['claimants xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection', 'division rejects their claims']
+89743;['appeal isallowed']
+93579;['appeal isallowed']
+69589;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+122130;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110964;['appeal is dismissed']
+94702;['appeal must be dismissed']
+38990;['appeal is dismissed']
+63978;['appeal is determinedto']
+84662;['appeal should be dismissed']
+72151;['appeal is dismissed']
+96906;['claim is rejected']
+28062;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+65414;['appeal is allowed']
+59807;['appeal is allowed']
+110966;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx   are not convention refugees', 'nor   are they persons in need of protection']
+68533;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+56693;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+101544;['appeal is dismissed']
+95216;['appeal is dismissed']
+58414;['appeal is dismissed']
+63175;['appeal were dismissed']
+94643;['appeal dismissed']
+14585;['application is denied']
+133703;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94713;['appeal is allowed']
+149023;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee']
+93148;['appeal is dismissed']
+104078;['appeals are dismissed']
+60509;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+107856;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+79879;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+113634;['appeal is allowed']
+43328;['appeal is allowed']
+138873;['appeal is dismissed']
+52071;['dismiss the appeal']
+78053;['appeal is dismissed']
+111356;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99534;['appeal is dismissed']
+93624;['appeal is dismissed']
+42176;['appeals are allowed']
+63894;['appeal isterminated']
+74174;['appeal is allowed']
+69341;['appeal isallowed']
+81423;['appeal is allowed']
+35038;['appeal of jannet kiadii is dismissed']
+124063;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+141621;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+120726;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+141072;['appeal is allowed']
+113232;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+60285;['appeal is terminated']
+56620;['appeal is determined']
+56254;['allow this appeal']
+132742;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+69338;['appeal isallowed']
+74721;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87878;['negative']
+72903;['appeal is dismissed']
+49063;['appeal is dismissed']
+75712;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+87331;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+95129;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+68368;['appeal is allowed']
+117124;['appeals are allowed']
+26674;['appeal of diljeet goel is dismissed']
+110993;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+19384;['application is therefore dismissed']
+99488;['appeal is dismissed']
+57394;['application to reopen the appeal is denied']
+131183;['appeal is allowed']
+87956;['appeal is dismissed']
+103105;['appeal is dismissed']
+25967;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+50731;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+17191;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+121480;['appeal is allowed']
+81581;['appeal is allowed']
+125331;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+148025;['appeal be dismissed']
+86965;['appeal of hui hong deng is dismissed']
+85842;['appeal is terminated']
+77933;['appeal is allowed']
+124675;['nor a person in need of protection']
+102036;['appeal is allowed']
+23045;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpaparticularly in']
+143610;['appellants are not genuine christian converts']
+109002;['appeal is dismissed']
+74355;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+42361;['appeal should be dismissed']
+35807;['dismissal of the appeal']
+52684;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject this claim']
+142947;['appellant is not a citizen of the us']
+76694;['appeal is allowed']
+125090;['appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+78145;['appeal is allowed']
+132839;['appeal is allowed']
+38415;['appeal is dismissed']
+150783;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+91856;['appeal is allowed']
+61923;['mek is no longer on canada’s list of terrorist entities']
+131159;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+145812;['appeal is allowed']
+123892;['302 (c.a.']
+102151;['appeal is dismissed']
+66634;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+97495;['not a “convention refugee']
+74071;['appeal is allowed']
+96786;['appeal is allowed']
+103696;['appellants are no longer prs of canada']
+135945;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+149066;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90623;['appeal is dismissed']
+16760;['removal orders are set aside']
+148978;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45854;['appeal is allowed']
+96607;['reject his claim']
+102749;['appeal is dismissed']
+80554;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91760;['appeal is allowed']
+70462;['appeal is allowed']
+120828;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+104345;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+76046;['appeal is also denied']
+103663;['302 (c.a.)']
+122958;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+142821;['appeal is dismissed']
+92612;['negative']
+60922;['appeal is allowed']
+54222;['appeal having been dismissed']
+123273;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+97961;['application is dismissed']
+54809;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+82236;['appeal is allowed']
+105234;['appeal is dismissed']
+44003;['appeal is allowed']
+5140;['appeal is dismissed']
+123026;['appeal is allowed']
+90798;['dismiss the appeal']
+52042;['panel finds that the removal order is valid in law']
+141221;['rad therefore concurs with this rpd determination']
+110948;['appeal is dismissed']
+87430;['appeal is allowed']
+93013;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76707;['appeal is notres judicata']
+56634;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116896;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125220;['appeal is dismissed']
+105846;['appeal is also dismissed']
+90854;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+140556;['refugee protection claim is rejected']
+96117;['appeal would fail']
+122735;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93158;['appeal is terminated']
+45236;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95062;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+149486;['appeal is allowed']
+125022;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102553;['appeal is allowed']
+84443;['appeal is allowed']
+86653;['appeals of hadil elsayed and alaa mohamed elsayed are allowed']
+91242;['appeal of oleksandr kotendzhi is dismissed']
+47483;['application to withdraw is dismissed']
+85676;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the negative determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+91937;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+125524;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+147597;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75128;['appeal is dismissed']
+96222;['appeal is allowed']
+99557;['302 (c.a.)']
+45400;['appeal is dismissed', 'immigration appeal division orders the appellant’s departure from canada']
+59781;['dismissing the appeal']
+125384;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+43382;['appeal is allowed']
+125513;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+129869;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+129118;['appeals are dismissed']
+88430;['negative']
+151766;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+118406;['rad also confirms the decision of the rpd', 'pa and fa are excluded from refugee protection']
+47746;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+49177;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+37854;['appeal is allowed']
+82167;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99269;['appeal is allowed']
+85633;['appeal is terminated']
+28466;['dismiss the application to reopen the appeal']
+139442;['appeal is dismissed']
+94254;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+23094;['appeal is dismissed']
+144031;['not confirm the decision of the rpd']
+46563;['appeal is allowed']
+85326;['appeal is allowed']
+151960;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80010;['negative']
+27250;['appeal is dismissed']
+107431;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+70034;['appeal is dismissed']
+98633;['appeal is dismissed']
+61829;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93577;['appeal is allowed']
+55155;['appeal should be dismissed']
+99307;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision does not fall within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes', 'decision is therefore set aside']
+84464;['appeal is dismissed']
+100481;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77979;['allow her appeal']
+98114;['negative']
+140288;['appeal is dismissed']
+75471;['allow the appeal ofdeuk keun kim in law']
+81823;['302 (c.a.']
+100605;['appeal has been abandoned']
+86900;['appeal isallowed']
+98492;['appeal is dismissed']
+93309;['appeal   isdismissedand a']
+129869;['appeal isallowed']
+81181;['appeal be dismissed']
+124346;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+87192;['appeal is dismissed']
+61434;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+100436;['reject his claim']
+151778;['dismisses her appeal']
+84219;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+86615;['appeal is dismissed']
+107614;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+50749;['appeal be dismissed']
+122774;['appeal is allowed']
+79889;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+60932;['appeal is allowed']
+47722;['appeal is dismissed']
+39030;['appeal is dismissed']
+105325;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124956;['dismiss the appeal', 'uphold the rpd’s determination']
+151909;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+76409;['appeal is dismissed']
+62849;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107387;['rad therefore accepts this application']
+131862;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99776;['appeal is dismissed']
+59791;['appeal is allowed']
+144556;['rpd’s determination is correct and confirmed by this decision']
+75141;['appeal is allowed']
+33692;['appeal isallowed']
+57503;['appeal is dismissed']
+102930;['appeal is allowed']
+59160;['appeal be dismissed']
+110709;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141655;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69992;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+52197;['appeal is dismissed']
+75909;['appeal is allowed']
+114323;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+69605;['appeal is allowed']
+124338;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+112778;['rad overturns the rpd’s finding', 'substitutes its finding']
+141622;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+129872;['negative determination']
+151766;['appeal is dismissed']
+99609;['appeal is dismissed']
+56753;['dismiss this appeal']
+96725;['appeal is terminated']
+102699;['appeal is dismissed']
+89313;['rejecttheir claims']
+151631;['appeal is allowed']
+152902;['appeal is accepted']
+47392;['appeal is allowed']
+152392;['appeal is dismissed']
+134391;['appeal is allowed.the']
+68116;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+93650;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+106302;['appeal is dismissed']
+101667;['appeal is allowed']
+146081;['claimants are convention refugees']
+108935;['appeal be dismissed']
+98061;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+52356;['appeal is allowed']
+132743;['appeal is allowed']
+145330;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123377;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89881;['appeal is terminated']
+101452;['appeal is abandoned']
+144401;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+77259;['appeal has been abandoned']
+95448;['appeal is allowed']
+19722;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+56255;['302 (c.a.']
+91622;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects this claim']
+130950;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee” nor a “person in need of protection']
+60495;['appeal of mohammed babalukuku idris garba is dismissed']
+58381;['302 (c.a.']
+94826;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+57538;['appeals of nicolae avrigeanu and florinuta avrigeanu are allowed']
+77665;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+101297;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+144415;['appeals are dismissed']
+101301;['rad dismissed the appeal', 'upheld the decision of the rpd']
+64649;['dismiss the appeal']
+128210;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+76888;['application to re-open is dismissed']
+121441;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60839;['appeals are dismissed']
+152377;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100480;['appeal is dismissed']
+74041;['appeal isallowed']
+92387;['appeal ofjumanah mahmoud sbeihis allowed']
+66780;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+45871;['appeal is dismissed']
+108841;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101267;['appeal isallowed.the']
+62012;['appeal is dismissed']
+71080;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+95949;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67622;['appeals are allowed']
+93912;['appeal is dismissed']
+54520;['appeal is terminated']
+89398;['appealsof zareena bagum, ahsan riaz and husain riazare allowed']
+47774;['appeal be allowed']
+84312;['appeal is dismissed']
+80541;['appeal isallowed']
+99154;['claimant is a person in need of protection']
+105918;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97281;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+54561;['appeal is dismissed']
+105890;['appeals are allowed']
+27242;['appeal is dismissed']
+101793;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+131176;['appeal were dismissed']
+97632;['appeals are dismissed']
+74454;['appeal is terminated']
+87375;['appeal be dismissed']
+44432;['appeal isallowedand']
+97981;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+89191;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'allow the appeal']
+111015;['appellants are not convention refugees', 'nor are they persons in need of protection']
+99332;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+76814;['appeal isallowed']
+99490;['appeal is terminated']
+122105;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+55228;['appeal is dismissed']
+59855;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26722;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+45860;['appeal is dismissed']
+144752;['appeal is dismissed']
+98233;['appeal is dismissed']
+48223;['appeal isallowed']
+70673;['not a convention refugee']
+81280;['appeal is allowed']
+76972;['appeal isallowed']
+120794;['substitute my decision for that of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+47287;['guideline is not intended to apply to   ']
+89562;['appeal is dismissed']
+110722;['appeal is allowed']
+95254;['appeal isallowed']
+146104;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the negative determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+114336;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+71138;['appeal must be dismissed']
+107633;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144773;['302 (c.a.']
+94865;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+132639;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52102;['appeal is dismissed']
+80217;['claimants are determined to be convention refugees']
+98781;['appeal is dismissed']
+14705;['appeal should be allowed']
+90629;['appeal is dismissed']
+23063;['appeal is dismissed']
+147446;['claimantsare neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+33082;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd']
+107925;['rad finds that the rpd’s findings on the merits of the claim are insufficient']
+111003;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision can stand', 'appellants’ are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50428;['appeals are dismissed']
+149567;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90650;['not a “convention refugee']
+117124;['appeal is allowed']
+88167;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+39039;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+17110;['appeal is dismissed']
+101497;['appeal isallowed']
+67367;['appeal is dismissed']
+78063;['application to re-open is allowed']
+96551;['appeal is dismissed']
+71430;['appeal is allowed']
+71040;['claimants’ removal tonigeriawould not subject them personally to a danger of torture']
+68097;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+4741;['appeal is determined']
+81168;['appeal is dismissed']
+98220;['302 (c.a.']
+82423;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89443;['panel rejects the above claim for refugee protection']
+96334;['appeal be dismissed']
+122904;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94998;['appeal isallowed.the']
+123830;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26791;['appeal is allowed']
+122925;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+69955;['appeal is dismissed']
+144962;['302 (c.a.']
+100965;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim']
+87083;['appeal division cannot grant mandamus.']
+89098;['claimants are not “persons in need of protection']
+69994;['appeal is dismissed']
+83050;['appeal is allowed']
+85522;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+60999;['appeal is allowed']
+103054;['appeal is allowed']
+55162;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+115211;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+52715;['negative determination']
+56639;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102953;['appeal is allowed']
+104451;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+115212;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86018;['appeal is dismissed']
+72315;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+55513;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+99552;['appeal is allowed']
+98914;['appeal is allowed']
+93224;['allow the appeal']
+69436;['negative']
+131199;['appeal is allowed']
+83296;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97653;['panel rejects her claim']
+91717;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+72210;['appeal is allowed']
+125479;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+71416;['appeal is allowed']
+72868;['appeal is dismissed']
+102530;['appeal is dismissed']
+52285;['exclusion order is set aside']
+150254;['appeal is allowed']
+85874;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+79610;['appeal is allowed']
+73038;['appeal isallowedand']
+143197;['appeal is allowed']
+132644;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+104468;['appeal is allowed']
+69553;['appeal is dismissed']
+84206;['appeal is dismissed']
+141313;['appeal is dismissed']
+142532;['rad rejects the appellants’ submissions']
+140828;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+116352;['appeal is allowed']
+124634;['dismiss it']
+42360;['appeal of mohan singh dayal is allowed']
+121213;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+153145;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+83949;['appeal isallowed.the']
+151380;['appeal is allowed']
+40286;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+90699;['appeal is dismissed']
+136749;['302 (c.a.']
+44966;['appeal isallowed']
+134158;['appeal is allowed']
+52789;['appeal may have merit']
+101012;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+103607;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+101335;['appeal is terminated', 'appeal is dismissed']
+71795;['appeal isallowed']
+113301;['appeal were dismissed']
+104104;['appeal is allowed']
+151466;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee']
+151829;['rad finds that the rpd’s findings on the merits of the claim are insufficient']
+66920;['appeal is allowed']
+47352;['appeal is dismissed']
+94099;['appeal is dismissed']
+136080;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+18995;['appeal is allowed']
+152820;['decision of the immigration division isset aside']
+130795;['appeal is allowed']
+50751;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+72012;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+144957;['appeal is allowed']
+101855;['appeal is allowed']
+108215;['appeal is dismissed']
+108855;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is he a “person in need of protection']
+69371;['appeal isallowed']
+39047;['appeal is dismissed']
+69157;['appeal is dismissed']
+95883;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125367;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+43332;['appeal is allowed']
+90083;['appeal is terminated']
+80051;['negative']
+74777;['appeal is allowed']
+69464;['appeal is allowed']
+64640;['appeal is allowed']
+99991;['xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+73251;['appeal is dismissed']
+54782;['theappeal is allowed']
+110298;['appeal is allowed']
+68743;['appeal is dismissed']
+76835;['appeal is allowed']
+94369;['appeal is allowed']
+151743;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94613;['reference has been removed']
+85456;['appeal is dismissed']
+90631;['appeal is dismissed']
+26963;['xxxxxx xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+143911;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the impugned decision', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+123441;['dismiss the appeal of the minor appellant', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+46015;['appeal is allowed']
+122907;['appeal is allowed']
+73053;['302 (c.a.)']
+100482;['appellant has lost his']
+56263;['appeal is allowed']
+81210;['appeals are dismissed']
+90036;['dismiss the appeal']
+131227;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+31423;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47777;['dismissing this appeal']
+142077;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+95589;['stayof the removal orderis cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+40479;['dismissal of this appeal']
+125147;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+4743;['dismiss the appeal']
+128158;['appeal is dismissed']
+132415;['appeal is allowed']
+65410;['appeal’s dismissal']
+97569;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+94533;['appeal is dismissed']
+141266;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105897;['appeal is dismissed']
+74182;['not a refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+133386;['appeal is dismissed']
+88324;['appeal is dismissed']
+70467;['appeal is dismissed']
+105872;['appeal is allowed']
+132843;['appeal is dismissed']
+47406;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+93289;['appeal is dismissed']
+95253;['three appeals are allowed']
+140826;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+96843;['appeal isallowed']
+146544;['appeal is allowed']
+45231;['appeal of francisco jr. rubin relativo is dismissed']
+99088;['appeal is dismissed']
+70415;['dismiss the appeal']
+61421;['dismiss the appeal']
+102986;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination']
+70472;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+145760;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+30524;['allow the appeal']
+26471;['appeal is allowed']
+122774;['rad finds that that the rpd’s decision is in error']
+19228;['appeal cannot succeed']
+77949;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal of sima kalantarian is dismissed']
+32173;['appeal is allowed']
+30522;['appeal is dismissed']
+82186;['appeal were dismissed']
+49579;['dismisses the appeal filed by the appellant']
+39921;['appeal is ordered to be sent to normal processing']
+85838;['appeal is allowed']
+68540;['appeal of carl anthony smith of the removal order is allowed']
+95452;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+130841;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+140970;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76792;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+85096;['appeal isallowed']
+129534;['appeal of lhenard alday villanueva is dismissed']
+125023;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+93305;['appeal of the minister is allowed']
+96797;['panel is not in a position to substitute the rpd member’s decision']
+90965;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+116788;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91815;['appeal is dismissed']
+125326;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination']
+91909;['appeal is allowed']
+45187;['appeal is allowed']
+98151;['appeal is dismissed']
+98351;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107903;['appellants are convention refugees']
+74265;['appeal is allowed']
+82431;['appeal isallowedand']
+97992;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87147;['appeal is allowed']
+108705;['appeal is dismissed']
+76503;['appeal isallowed']
+86902;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+97961;['appeal will not be reopened']
+90939;['appeal is allowed']
+117106;['appeal is dismissed']
+136720;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101038;['appeal isallowed']
+44179;['…].”']
+60043;['she is not a convention refugee']
+87726;['negative']
+54555;['appeal is dismissed']
+123766;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+42563;['appeal is dismissed']
+63829;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+105890;['appellants are somali citizens']
+132649;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+68554;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102915;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+50641;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+22701;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+99753;['appeal is allowed']
+75920;['appeal of the appellant concerning rajinder singh chuhan is withdrawn']
+91622;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+22825;['appeal is dismissed']
+84330;['appeal is allowed']
+59182;['appeal is allowed']
+34179;['appeal is dismissed']
+73590;['appeal is terminated']
+100742;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+134162;['appeal is dismissed']
+126394;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62833;['appeal should be allowed']
+69578;['appeal will be allowed']
+21378;"['not ""convention refugees']"
+53766;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+113796;['appeal is allowed']
+47334;['appeal of harmanpreet kaur bath is dismissed']
+84814;['appeal is dismissed']
+47159;['appeal terminated']
+131714;['substitutes its determination that the appellant has established his']
+46043;['appeal isallowed']
+97642;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+70363;['dismiss this appeal']
+34170;['appeal is dismissed']
+92709;['dismiss the within appeal']
+145825;['appeal is terminated']
+94763;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+93089;['“convention refugees', 'panel allows their claims for refugee protection']
+93119;['appeal isallowed']
+108055;['appeal is allowed']
+77678;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+85456;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+87315;['appeal is terminated']
+84853;['appeal is terminated']
+82860;['appeal of ming hua zhang is dismissed']
+47572;['appeal is allowed']
+72002;['appeal is dismissed']
+143002;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+144388;['appeal is dismissed']
+52678;"['not a ""convention refugee']"
+89972;['appeal is terminated']
+80826;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+16751;['appeal were dismissed']
+128425;['appeal dismissed']
+150622;['appeal is allowed']
+108788;['rad must substitute its own determination']
+94931;['appeal is allowed']
+82727;['appeal isallowed']
+110308;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+31434;['appeal is dismissed']
+101409;['appeal isallowed']
+100138;['appeal was first heard']
+107687;['appeal is dismissed']
+108678;['refugee protection division rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+97397;['302 (c.a.']
+45406;['allow the appeal']
+71725;['appeal would be dismissed']
+51669;['sponsor reimburses the government concerned']
+118134;['appeal must be dismissed']
+80551;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+106285;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90824;['appeal isallowed']
+151970;['appeal is allowed']
+80522;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107323;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+87990;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+91206;['appeal is allowed']
+46035;['302 (c.a.']
+63928;['appeal is dismissed']
+69421;['appeal is allowed']
+99517;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+95956;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72675;['appeal is dismissed']
+151772;['substitute a determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+91625;['appeal is allowed']
+105899;['respondent is not a convention refugee']
+97042;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+94396;['appeal is dismissed']
+132838;['appeal is not successful']
+64239;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+81244;['appeal be dismissed']
+102058;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+61441;['appeal is allowed']
+108873;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+113216;['appeal is allowed']
+84738;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+133264;['substitutes its own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+75999;['negative']
+83040;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100490;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+45216;['appeal is allowed']
+100267;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+74853;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+52308;['appeals are allowed']
+63079;['claimants are neitherconvention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108944;['appeal is dismissed']
+8269;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+18012;['appeal is dismissed']
+147599;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+96679;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77955;['sponsor had been denied']
+103461;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+148623;['appeal is dismissed']
+88495;['claimants are not convention refugees and they are not persons in need of canada’s protection']
+88337;['decision is valid in law']
+98753;['appeal is allowed']
+100885;['thatxxxx xxxx isnot a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+109696;['rad upholds the rpd’s findings']
+67599;['appeal could have been dismissed']
+100966;['application is not an abuse of process']
+100572;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismiss this appeal']
+90366;['xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+76520;['appeal is dismissed']
+136685;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+142497;['appeal is allowed']
+60513;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+77655;['appeal brought underparagraph 69(1)(c) of theactis dismissed']
+99727;['appeal is dismissed']
+95940;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+104091;['302 (c.a.']
+47757;['appeal is terminated']
+69788;['appeal is allowed']
+84716;['appeal is dismissed']
+5157;['appeals are dismissed']
+96354;['appeal is dismissed']
+47182;['appeal is dismissed']
+79940;['negative']
+99120;['appeal were dismissed']
+99025;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+50731;['appeal is allowed']
+130975;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+110711;['rad confirms the decision of the   rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need   of protection']
+86146;['appeal is allowed']
+136660;['appeal is allowed']
+95911;['allow the appeal']
+56898;['appeal is dismissed']
+140241;['appeal is allowed']
+47187;['appeals of bo ram park, jung ha park and min park are dismissed']
+114291;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not refugees', 'or persons in need of protection']
+79602;['allows this appeal']
+105841;['appeal isallowed']
+92814;['appeal is dismissed']
+45244;['appeal of hiep van tiet from the removal order issued 11 april 2006 is dismissed']
+100130;['nor persons in need of protection']
+94371;['panel finds the exclusion order is legally valid']
+122643;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitute my own determination']
+98845;['appeal is allowed']
+81188;['appeal is allowed.the']
+94833;['appeal is allowed']
+80530;['appeal of danilo yanga is dismissed']
+87708;['neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+23065;['appeal of lorna ann alida mason is allowed']
+125239;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+94095;['appeal must fail']
+80786;['appeal was dismissed']
+80659;['302 (c.a.']
+83149;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+82462;['appeal is dismissed']
+90040;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+99755;['appeal is allowed']
+84631;['302 (c.a.']
+125512;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+16764;['appeal was dismissed']
+109015;['appeal is dismissed']
+143853;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+131164;['appeals of faris adeeb kalo jubouri, may kamal fadheel hannoodee, matti faris adeeb jubouri, adeeb faris adeeb jubouri, and yousif faris adeeb jubouri are dismissed']
+98997;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+92039;['appeal fails']
+96671;['appeal is dismissed']
+83542;['appeal were dismissed']
+89792;['dismiss the appeal']
+130998;['not a refugee or person in need of protection']
+54726;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95738;['appeal is dismissed']
+91601;['appeal is dismissed']
+97489;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+77197;['rad further finds the rpd’s finding is reasonable']
+141689;['appeal is allowed']
+116901;['appeal be dismissed']
+97444;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+47717;['appeal is allowed']
+59927;['appeal of imelda narca is dismissed']
+71181;['appeal is allowed']
+141654;['application to re-open her hearing is denied']
+77609;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+100198;['appeal is allowed']
+14505;['appeal is abandoned']
+20433;['dismiss the appeal']
+38877;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+48230;['appeal of amarjit singh parmar (the “appellant”']
+141646;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67241;['appeal isallowed']
+87848;['appeal is allowed']
+38873;['removal order is set aside']
+87193;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+30547;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+78060;['appeal is dismissed']
+99339;['302 (c.a.']
+89289;['appeal is dismissed']
+123797;['reject this ground of appeal']
+63519;['not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'panel rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+74042;['appeal isallowed']
+17165;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+67486;['appeal is allowed']
+145852;['appeal is allowed']
+22987;['appeal is allowed']
+62450;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123324;['appeal is allowed']
+46569;['appeal is dismissed']
+140733;['she is a convention refugee']
+98258;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+131003;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151456;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+83488;['appeal isallowed']
+69989;['appeal isallowed']
+121576;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+140710;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+129928;['appeal is abandoned']
+76402;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+98261;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+59859;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxand their childxxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither “convention refugees”']
+47369;['appeal is allowed']
+99656;['appeal is dismissed']
+68211;['allow the appeal']
+77061;['appeal is dismissed']
+94997;['appeal is dismissed']
+96832;['claimant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+62937;['appeal is dismissed']
+95781;['appeals are dismissed']
+111023;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+48099;['appeal is dismissed']
+131110;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95590;['appeal is dismissed']
+124644;['appeal is dismissed']
+102740;['rad rejects the appellant’s explanation']
+100155;['claimants, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+74594;['appeal is dismissed']
+100707;['panel rejects this claim']
+96323;['claim is rejected']
+77980;['appeal is allowed']
+52150;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+94272;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143260;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+14673;['xxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx and xxxx xxxxx are not convention refugees']
+114299;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the refugee protection division', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+76136;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+67590;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+16791;['appeal isallowed']
+121519;['appeal would be dismissed']
+125512;['rpd’s determination is correct']
+68140;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+93885;['appeal is allowed']
+99409;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62883;['claim is rejected']
+95393;['appellant has not lost her permanent residency status']
+133186;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+38992;['appeal is denied']
+102946;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+133345;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes that decision with its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86534;['appeal must be dismissed']
+76700;['appeal is allowed']
+110934;['nor persons in need of protection']
+122818;['appeal is dismissed']
+70203;['appeal of alexis rodriguez is dismissed']
+101515;['appeal isallowed']
+130750;['appeal is allowed']
+52287;['appeal is allowed']
+142846;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+70197;['appeal is allowed']
+88820;['appeal is allowed']
+90957;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+120801;['appeal is allowed']
+65252;['iad dismisses the appeal']
+70778;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+92238;['appeal is dismissed']
+24244;['appeal being dismissed']
+149274;['appeal is dismissed']
+46545;['302 (c.a.)']
+9677;['appeal was therefore dismissed']
+78639;['dismiss the appeal']
+148669;['appeal is dismissed']
+82376;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125386;['appeal is allowed']
+40134;['appeal was dismissed']
+96022;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110683;['appeal is dismissed']
+107128;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+40128;['appeal is dismissed']
+94555;['appeal be dismissed']
+97144;['application is dismissed']
+41827;['appeal is dismissed']
+39905;['appeal isdeclaredabandoned undersubsection\xa0168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+91232;['appeal is dismissed']
+50741;['appellant has been found to be a convention refugee']
+148610;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+82587;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+47285;['claimant is not convention refugee']
+130794;['appeal is allowed']
+97022;['claimants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78170;['appeal is dismissed']
+145231;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+148634;['appeals are allowed.the']
+89940;['visa officer’s refusal']
+82443;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident visa']
+98823;['negative']
+138812;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+98463;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80070;"['not convention refugees; neither are they persons in need of protection']"
+138285;['allows the appeal']
+85258;['appeal is terminated']
+139856;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee']
+87506;['appeal is dismissed']
+100971;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+62950;['application for a further postponement is denied']
+89243;['dismiss   the appeal']
+88155;['appeal is allowed']
+19386;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96241;['dismiss this appeal']
+26708;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+143566;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62386;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+148986;['complaint fails']
+99186;['claim is rejected']
+123104;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+69544;['dismiss this appeal']
+105720;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+72598;['appeal will be allowed']
+90932;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a claim for refugee protection']
+62449;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+69388;['negative']
+75594;['302 (c.a.']
+72195;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86959;['appeal is allowed']
+77292;['appeal is allowed']
+95073;['rad remits the matter to the rpd']
+10908;['appeal is dismissed']
+106459;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+106334;['dismisses the appeal']
+42281;['appeal is refused']
+95058;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision falls within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes']
+98774;['appeal is dismissed']
+78651;['appeal was dismissed']
+94009;['appeal was abandoned']
+92482;['or persons in need of protection']
+107187;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+39773;['appeal was not resolved at the adr conference']
+86392;['allowed the appeal']
+57308;['appeal is allowed']
+83520;['appeal is dismissed']
+89087;['appeal is dismissed']
+88011;['negative']
+70676;['appeal is allowed']
+107480;['appeal is allowed']
+80253;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88132;['appeal is dismissed']
+87856;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+124035;['302 (c.a.']
+69963;['appeal is allowed']
+121196;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+36107;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77546;['appeal is terminated']
+87136;['appeal should be dismissed']
+14708;['motion to dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+69215;['appeal is dismissed']
+72888;['appeal must be dismissed']
+114314;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+151408;['deny the appeal']
+120723;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43704;['dismiss this appeal']
+108754;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+52500;['appeal is dismissed']
+73594;['appeal isallowed']
+91438;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+65690;['appeal is dismissed']
+100400;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+52293;['letter is vague']
+131227;['confirm the legality of that decision']
+110940;['appeal is dismissed']
+92769;['appeal isallowed']
+143022;['rpd decision, para']
+97526;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+41964;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+124269;['appeal is allowed']
+122668;['rad allows the appeal']
+151322;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62385;['claimant is not person in need of protection']
+37417;['appeal were dismissed']
+146587;['302 (c.a.']
+59365;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96703;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+52613;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+76380;['appeal is allowed']
+81004;['appeal is allowed']
+100001;['appeal is dismissed']
+81863;['appeal is dismissed']
+56937;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+132658;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77983;['appeal isallowed']
+62719;['appeal isallowed']
+88297;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+101716;['appeal is allowed']
+150942;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62476;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+99056;['appeal is dismissed']
+122261;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+95537;['appeal is dismissed']
+111113;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+39921;['appeal is ordered to be sent to normal processing']
+96087;['appeal is dismissed']
+83280;['rad substitutes its decision for that of the rpd', 'determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+91454;['appeal is terminated']
+38774;['appeal is terminated']
+49135;['appeal be dismissed']
+91904;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+78129;['claimants’ are not persons in need of protection']
+123820;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103800;['302 (c.a.']
+23113;['appeal is allowed']
+86307;['appeal is dismissed']
+65653;['appeal is dismissed']
+17959;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+77977;['appeal is allowed']
+87474;['302 (c.a.']
+98356;['appeal is allowed']
+114403;['appeal is dismissed']
+148680;['appeals are allowed.the']
+129879;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+149002;['302 (c.a.']
+88423;['they are not convention refugees']
+60657;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+95398;['appeal is dismissed']
+80240;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+140799;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+85543;['302 (c.a.']
+105558;['appeal is allowed']
+133705;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+93321;['appeal is allowed']
+110276;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+114294;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+96038;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+103704;['appeal is allowed']
+134803;['appeal is dismissed']
+48930;['iad lacks jurisdiction to hear the appeal']
+107085;['appeal is dismissed']
+44275;['appeal is allowed']
+82386;['iad dismisses the present appeal']
+133263;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30530;['appellant is not a sponsor.']
+128896;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+101035;['appeal isallowed']
+105817;['appeal isallowed']
+89323;['appeal is dismissed']
+52057;['appeal is allowed']
+23063;['appeal is allowed']
+46027;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+89257;['appeal   is dismissed']
+151744;['302 (c.a.']
+87154;['appeal is allowed']
+68266;['appeal is allowed']
+59045;['appeal would be dismissed']
+97612;['appeal is allowed']
+107133;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94776;['appeal is dismissed']
+98790;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+101253;['appeal is dismissed']
+96335;['appeal were dismissed']
+130844;['appeal is allowed']
+123937;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+37830;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+132433;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+13553;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+77842;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+130734;['appeal is dismissed']
+47163;['appeal is terminated']
+30505;['appeal isallowed']
+100436;['negative']
+130856;['leads the panel to conclude that there is no union']
+100052;['appeal is allowed']
+97772;['negative']
+134280;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+37828;['appeal is allowed']
+100312;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89089;['appeal is dismissed']
+141564;['cancel the stay of removal', 'dismiss the appeal']
+44435;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61624;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151891;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+100844;['302 (c.a.']
+87709;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+89079;['claim is rejected']
+60891;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+54157;['appeal of wilson alexander paniagua guevara is dismissed']
+148597;['appeal is dismissed']
+91679;['appeal is allowed']
+100556;['appeal is allowed']
+134353;['appeal is allowed']
+86401;['appeal is dismissed']
+107264;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+96333;['appeal isallowed']
+95939;['rad finds the rpd’s decision to reject the appellant’s refugee claim']
+124557;['decision5 rendered by the rpd is vitiated']
+96504;['dismisses the appeal']
+29469;['appeal is allowed in law']
+121938;['set aside the rpd’s decision', 'substitute it with my own determination']
+54762;['appeal was dismissed']
+74638;['appeal is dismissed']
+123391;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+34610;['appeal isallowed']
+106333;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+78057;['appeal is abandoned']
+63858;['not find you to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+121472;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95955;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding in this regard was reasonable']
+74493;['appeal is allowed']
+70014;['appeal of the refusal of his most recent application to sponsor xiong ying zhu is dismissed']
+133389;['appeal is allowed']
+93970;['appeal of alex amitjot singh walia is dismissed']
+71204;['appeal of\xa0 kristal ann amoroso is dismissed']
+114409;['ms. xxxx and her daughter are not permanent residents of brazil']
+128285;['appeal is dismissed']
+113542;['appeal is dismissed']
+69585;['appeal is dismissed']
+38403;['appeal is dismissed']
+52304;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+124449;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62843;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+108767;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107848;['application for extension of time is therefore dismissed']
+96979;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+91913;['appeal of pik lo ng']
+92074;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+115225;['dismiss the appeal']
+89842;['negative']
+100155;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+108078;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is a “convention refugee”']
+91157;['appeal of zohreh jafari is dismissed']
+73202;['appeal of bowei chen is dismissed']
+96621;['appeal is allowed']
+92508;['appeal should be allowed']
+82972;['dismisses the appeal']
+13692;['appeal is allowed']
+144000;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+133707;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98623;['appeal isallowedand']
+86340;['appeal is allowed']
+64673;['allow this appeal']
+95496;['appeal is dismissed']
+24248;['appeal be re-opened']
+14690;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+98113;['appeal of nikhil sharda is dismissed']
+150729;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+13769;['visa officer’s refusal is set aside']
+79942;['negative']
+47353;['appeal should be dismissed']
+112384;['appeals are dismissed']
+84681;['appeal is dismissed']
+28081;['dismiss the present appeal']
+72730;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are \xa0neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+89431;['appeal is terminated']
+85961;['comenco is a canadian company']
+74591;['appeal is dismissed']
+100686;['appeal being dismissed']
+69686;['appeal is determined']
+88341;['appeal is allowed']
+143501;['claims are rejected']
+64264;['appeal is allowed']
+94261;['appeal is dismissed']
+94407;['appeal is dismissed']
+133368;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108943;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+102546;['appeal is dismissed']
+59627;['allowed the appeal']
+83055;['appeal is dismissed']
+81253;['appeal isallowed.the']
+86472;['appeal is not successful']
+106427;['appeal is dismissed']
+100714;['pcis not a convention refugee']
+89446;['negative']
+95617;['appeal is allowed']
+87000;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+98127;['appeal is dismissed']
+129859;['removal order is set aside']
+99792;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+143841;['dismiss this appeal']
+47113;['appeal ought to be dismissed']
+146882;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+141617;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+70199;['allow the appeal']
+96032;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+146938;['negative determination']
+89392;['appeal is terminated']
+69676;['dismiss this appeal']
+92468;['appeal is dismissed']
+148730;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+148762;['claims are rejected']
+87140;['appeal is terminated']
+14583;['determination is valid in law']
+129401;['rpd decision stands']
+98496;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+76450;['dismiss the appeal']
+88180;['negative', 'negative', 'negative']
+47319;['appeal is allowed']
+105215;['appeal is dismissed']
+76089;['appeal should be dismissed']
+141212;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+49149;['appeal is dismissed']
+110962;['appeal is dismissed']
+70421;['appeal be allowed']
+26839;['claimant xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+78078;['appeal of irmgard luise battista is dismissed']
+150622;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that they are convention refugees']
+122141;['appeal is allowed']
+148718;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+47162;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+87112;['terminate the appeal']
+108739;['appeal is allowed']
+21304;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of canada’s protection']
+95461;['appeal is dismissed']
+25977;['motion is dismissed']
+140874;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+102569;['appeal is allowed']
+93602;['appeal is dismissed']
+141792;['appeal of henriette amina nyakunova is dismissed']
+71461;['appeal is allowed']
+46540;['iad does not have jurisdiction']
+123278;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+44183;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67586;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+38996;['appeals are dismissed']
+129108;['appeal is allowed']
+98753;['appeal is allowed']
+69979;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+133351;['appeal is dismissed']
+123925;['appeal isdismissed.']
+123110;['ifa fails']
+124215;['appeals to be allowed']
+99778;['appeal be dismissed']
+99922;['appeal is dismissed']
+106134;['appeal is dismissed']
+101879;['appeal isallowed.the']
+66765;['appeal is allowed']
+130992;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+27363;['appeals are dismissed']
+102673;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+143022;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+84795;['appeal is dismissed']
+77641;['appeal is allowed']
+103005;['appeal was dismissed']
+101712;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+91152;['appeal undersubsection 67(1)(a) is dismissed']
+124093;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+13753;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+101147;['appeal is dismissed']
+88716;['dismiss the appeal']
+72814;['appeal is dismissed']
+106442;['cross-appeal is allowed']
+127711;['appeal be dismissed']
+125505;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a person referred to in article\xa01e of the convention']
+106881;['appeal is dismissed']
+95867;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+17946;['appeal is dismissed']
+114310;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62455;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+70461;['dismiss the appeal']
+98114;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45988;['appeal is dismissed']
+133252;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132434;['claim is dismissed']
+67804;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95454;['appellants do not have the right to appeal']
+131202;['appeal is allowed']
+113747;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+71200;['appeal of remziye akbay is allowed']
+101289;['appeals are dismissed']
+46009;['appeal is dismissed']
+92967;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+91721;['appeal is allowed']
+71661;['appeal is allowed']
+124559;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89221;['302 (c.a.']
+101243;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97609;['appeal is allowed']
+144414;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122361;['substitute my finding', 'appellant is a refugee']
+95778;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding in this regard was pre-emptive']
+139432;['dismissal of this appeal']
+74645;['appeal is allowed']
+102161;['appeal is allowed']
+76786;['appeal is dismissed']
+46081;['appeal is allowed']
+76820;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident visa']
+67398;['appeal isallowed']
+85433;['appeal is dismissed']
+57299;['appeal is dismissed']
+74179;['rpd’s determination is correct']
+104467;['appeal is dismissed']
+69255;['appeal is allowed']
+143471;['removal order is set aside']
+72205;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86475;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+80458;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+128883;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees']
+92387;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+55049;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+83359;['dismissing the appeal']
+74734;['appeal is dismissed']
+95250;['appeal is allowed']
+66779;['appeal is allowed']
+133742;['appeal is allowed']
+63997;['appeal is allowed']
+82221;['appeal was dismissed']
+99838;['appeal is dismissed']
+79341;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+59823;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108872;['refugee protection division rejects his claim', 'claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+46520;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+89023;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person needing protection']
+97833;['claimant is excluded from refugee protection']
+24197;['appeal is dismissed']
+70204;['appeal of lorna alvarez cimbala is dismissed']
+56921;['appeal isallowed']
+96435;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+150733;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+62243;['negative']
+139464;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+128292;['appeal of jasmit singh marwah, parminder kaur marwah and mehak preet singh marwah are dismissed']
+59791;['appeal is allowed']
+76343;['appeal is allowed']
+76000;['appeal is dismissed']
+84750;['appeal is dismissed']
+70046;['appeal isallowed']
+24497;['appeal is dismissed']
+135172;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96745;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+102703;['rpd’s decision to reject the appellant’s refugee claim']
+91675;['appeal is dismissed']
+150698;['appeal of the appellantsxxxx']
+94912;['appeal is dismissed']
+60192;['negative']
+106809;['appeal were dismissed']
+99304;['rad finds that the rpd erred in this finding']
+95483;['appeal is terminated']
+31378;['appeal is dismissed']
+107243;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+36941;['appeal is allowed']
+88422;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+47562;['appeal was dismissed']
+54163;['theappeal is allowed']
+91559;['determination of the rpd', 'substitute it with the determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+52166;['xxxxxx xxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+148652;['appeal is allowed']
+50794;['appeal is dismissed']
+94412;['appeals are dismissed']
+84499;['appeal is allowed']
+55276;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+109274;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+95953;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44436;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+107832;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108706;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+140252;['appeal is dismissed']
+59795;['dismiss the appeal']
+81917;['appeal is allowed']
+83085;['dismiss your appeal']
+31976;['appeal is dismissed']
+53138;['allow the appeal']
+62885;['refugee protection division determines that the second, third and fourth   claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims to refugee protection']
+90560;['appeal abandoned']
+95947;['appeal is dismissed']
+140242;['appeal is refused']
+69730;['appeal isallowedin law']
+73677;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83735;['appeal is dismissed']
+130962;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+63611;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+71373;['appeal is dismissed']
+89306;['panel also rejects their claims']
+94763;['negative']
+123031;['appeal is allowed']
+81647;['appeal isallowedforjoanne elizabeth john(mb5']
+61475;['appeal is allowed']
+130964;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx,are neither convention refugees']
+57778;['appeal is dismissed']
+97246;['appeal is allowed']
+76376;['appeal is allowed']
+125668;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination in part', 'substitutes the determination']
+151925;['rad points out that the refugee determination is forward-looking']
+31215;['appeal of anju susan biju is dismissed']
+78173;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'or a person in need of protection']
+86995;['appeal is allowed']
+85835;['allow the appeal and order that remaining applications be returned to the visa office']
+89707;['removal order is set aside']
+91438;['appeal isallowed']
+87205;['appeal is dismissed']
+150635;['302 (c.a.']
+143581;['302 (c.a.']
+116752;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147438;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125463;['dismiss the appeal', 'appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+101677;['appeal of hing chung cheng is dismissed']
+105908;['appeal is allowed']
+123690;['dismiss the appeal']
+95325;['appeals are allowed']
+105297;['appeal is dismissed']
+97564;['stay is not an appropriate remedy']
+149282;['appeal is allowed in law']
+101499;['appeal is allowed']
+147791;['appeal is allowed']
+102959;['appeal is allowed']
+99768;['appeal is dismissed']
+69658;['appeal isallowed']
+132840;['appeal is allowed']
+56651;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+140992;['rad cannot confirm or set aside the determination of the rpd']
+94305;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+134178;['appeal is allowed']
+135469;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+132298;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131073;['rpd decision is correct']
+60732;['appeal isallowed']
+121395;['substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+55308;['appeal of sophann am is dismissed']
+147781;['rad dismisses this appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+124695;['not confirm the rpd’s decision']
+58412;['appeal of tresor kasongo is dismissed']
+80216;['302 (c.a.']
+123455;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+82715;['appeal isallowed']
+72907;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+95952;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+145038;['rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'substitutes its own determination']
+80297;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+85475;['appeal will proceed to normal processing']
+91696;['appeal is dismissed']
+52788;['appeal is dismissed']
+100240;['panel rejects the present claims']
+140852;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89191;['appeal were dismissed']
+98827;['negative']
+131742;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+122678;['dismiss the appeal']
+95426;['appeal is dismissed']
+99913;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99498;['appeal is dismissed']
+54705;['appeal is dismissed']
+92239;['appeal isallowedand']
+102689;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+16819;['appeal is dismissed']
+122546;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+102100;['appeal is dismissed']
+46000;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+82027;['terminates his appeal']
+61227;['appeal is dismissed']
+122999;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+124094;['refugee appeal division allows the appeal', 'substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+46532;['appeal is allowed']
+72642;['appeal is dismissed']
+65693;['appeal isallowed']
+97923;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87232;['appeal is dismissed']
+38788;['302 (c.a.']
+80371;['appeal is allowed']
+36179;['immigration officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+107598;['appeal is allowed']
+47785;['appeal is dismissed']
+95839;['appeal is allowed']
+67475;['appeals were dismissed']
+96834;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+132785;['application for an oral hearing is dismissed']
+84181;['appeal is dismissed']
+100285;['appeal is allowed']
+140985;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is in error']
+84448;['appeal is dismissed']
+31034;['appeal of duc lam chu be rescheduled']
+139479;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+85924;['appeal isallowed']
+94353;['appeal is determined']
+108827;['rad allows the appeal']
+99304;"[""rad finds that the rpd's findings""]"
+100804;['appeal is allowed']
+69142;['appeal is allowed']
+60045;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+57790;['appeal isallowed']
+73213;['appeal is allowed']
+69569;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80802;['appeal is dismissed']
+99709;['appeal of vinh thanh quach is dismissed']
+133254;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+80693;['negative']
+132417;['appeal is dismissed']
+151615;['appeals are dismissed']
+72022;['visa officer’s decision is set aside', 'appeal is allowed']
+116814;['appeal is allowed']
+105663;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+80025;['claim is rejected']
+71726;['appeal is allowed']
+96415;['appeal is dismissed']
+76394;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56816;['panel rejectsxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxclaim to convention status or person in need of protection status']
+95282;['dismisses the appeal']
+122958;['appellant is not excluded from the definition of refugee']
+68879;['appeal is dismissed']
+129898;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx,is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+104856;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+69864;['appeals of the principal appellant']
+84307;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+79975;['the claim fails']
+17900;['appeal should therefore be heard on its merits']
+153043;['appeal is based']
+129187;['appeal was dismissed']
+47104;['appeal is dismissed']
+43722;['appeal be dismissed']
+84566;['denies the application to re-open']
+31465;['appeal is allowed']
+131068;['decision is invalid in law']
+65094;['appeal isallowed']
+85908;['appeal is allowed']
+65708;['appeal is allowed']
+71241;['appeal of hak ying cheng is dismissed']
+97670;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+36188;['appeal is dismissed']
+29220;['appeal is dismissed']
+45178;['appeal of farah mirabdolbaghi is therefore allowed']
+97431;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+123764;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+23055;['appeal is dismissed']
+142793;['appeal must be dismissed']
+70021;['appeal beallowedand']
+123294;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+87129;['appeal be and is allowed']
+57551;['appeal is allowed']
+95345;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83167;['appeal is dismissed']
+92747;['appeal is allowed']
+68366;['appeal isallowed']
+132434;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60864;['appeal is dismissed']
+146832;['appeal is dismissed']
+104126;['neither a convention refugee nor are you a person in need of protection']
+101502;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+102702;['appeals must fail']
+131523;['dismissing the appellant’s appeal']
+98793;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+22121;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+52601;['claimant,xxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+125300;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145809;['appeal is allowed']
+82569;['appeal is allowed']
+54711;['appeal is determined']
+50514;['officer’s decision to']
+97834;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+97348;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+71379;['appeal is dismissed']
+56883;['appeal is dismissed']
+67409;['appeal must be dismissed']
+133254;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+64853;['appeal is allowed.the']
+106810;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69271;['appeal is dismissed']
+103673;['application for a travel document is dismissed']
+17142;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpaparticularly in']
+9488;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+76032;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+86213;['appeal isallowed']
+71563;['appeal is dismissed']
+101202;['appeal dismissed']
+131723;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+33313;['appeal is dismissed']
+23090;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+91664;['appeal is dismissed']
+80209;['negative']
+57224;['appeal is dismissed']
+144560;['appeal is allowed']
+123648;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+42453;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88166;['appeal is allowed']
+51077;['allow the appeal']
+92539;['appeal is dismissed']
+135198;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+72874;['appeal is terminated']
+92410;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+94838;['appeal is dismissed']
+110568;['appeal is dismissed']
+69126;['appeal is allowed']
+116339;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+90498;['appeal isallowed.the']
+80748;['allow this appeal']
+85435;['appeal is allowed']
+85518;['appeal isallowed']
+93309;['immigration appeal division   therefore orders your departure from canada']
+102805;['allows the appeal']
+99844;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108217;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+98073;['negative']
+67239;['negative']
+102440;['appeal isdismissed.']
+89830;['dismiss the appeal']
+69332;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+64592;['appeal is allowed']
+49540;['declare these appeals abandoned']
+131034;['removal order is set aside']
+130780;['appeal isallowed']
+101853;['decisions of the visa officer are not valid in law']
+124158;['appeal is allowed']
+94926;['appeal is allowed']
+142475;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+66204;['immigration appeal division dismisses an appeal']
+99903;['appeal is allowed.the']
+87472;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+90457;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+38999;['appeal is dismissed']
+100847;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+8344;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87608;['claimant is neither a convention refugee unders']
+77802;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+97347;['reject his claim']
+128375;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+96322;['appeal is dismissed']
+33236;['appeal is terminated']
+79042;['appeal is dismissed']
+145385;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+12223;['theappealis dismissed']
+123376;['appeal is allowed']
+89146;['appeal is allowed']
+83114;['appeal is terminated']
+96589;['appeal is allowed']
+18011;['appeal is dismissed']
+103497;['appeal of valentine mmaduabuchi ezebili is dismissed']
+70418;['appeal is allowed']
+129857;['appeal is allowed']
+36094;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74846;['appeal is allowed']
+94196;['appeal be allowed']
+97316;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+125655;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60038;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'i reject their claims']
+101304;['appeal is allowed']
+146842;['claimants not to be convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+19144;['appeal is dismissed']
+59383;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140824;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+110684;['appeal is dismissed']
+101845;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+86385;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+65683;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+146776;['appeal isdismissed.']
+67932;['appeal is dismissed']
+70083;['appeal must be dismissed']
+108839;['rad finds no errors of fact or law']
+124577;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+87733;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+50516;['appeal is dismissed']
+78758;['appeal is terminated']
+106821;['appeal is dismissed']
+106150;['appeal is dismissed']
+131139;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+58521;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+129243;['appeal is dismissed']
+136739;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+121880;['rpd’s decision cannot be upheld']
+140720;['i reject this argument']
+91274;['appeal abandoned']
+143018;['appeal is dismissed']
+102707;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is he a “person inneed of protection”']
+100228;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142743;['appeal is dismissed']
+60018;['negative']
+97437;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+58490;['matter is dismissed']
+109016;['appeal were dismissed']
+89989;['appeal isallowed']
+82276;['appeal is dismissed']
+96141;['appeal is allowed']
+52767;['appeal is dismissed']
+76680;['appeal is allowed']
+87326;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+72708;['appeal is allowed']
+43323;['appeal is allowed']
+113514;['appeal were dismissed']
+57559;['appeal of rodney eli anderson is allowed']
+107654;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80098;['appeal is terminated']
+23019;['dismissing the appeal']
+130999;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+66765;['“principal enactment']
+91691;['appeal of alazer negasie is dismissed']
+151400;['substitute the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+87463;['appeal is dismissed']
+86200;['appeal is allowed']
+100772;['appeals have been abandoned']
+87014;['appeal isallowed']
+90198;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+121674;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+75936;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+87518;['appeal is allowed']
+58130;['appeal is allowed']
+97422;['negative']
+60521;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+124159;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+144034;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74550;['appeal is allowed']
+102564;['appeal is terminated']
+67689;['appeal is allowed']
+72518;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79071;['appeal would be dismissed']
+109019;['appeal is dismissed']
+102692;['appeal is dismissed']
+140896;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+145033;['appeals are allowed']
+139681;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+86987;['appeal isdismissed.']
+98661;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+101403;['appeal is allowed']
+22393;['application to reopen']
+61005;['appeal of thomas henry rafuse is allowed']
+124116;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+106641;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+84463;['appeal is allowed.the']
+13951;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+56910;['appeal isallowed']
+52376;['appeal is dismissed']
+134293;['appeal is dismissed']
+74178;['substitutes the decision of the rpd']
+77790;['appeal being allowed']
+102073;['appeal is allowed']
+87616;['appeal is allowed']
+77919;['appeal is allowed']
+144895;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the negative determination']
+98384;['appeal is allowed']
+47320;['appeal is dismissed']
+96491;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+104052;['rad finds that the appellants have not established their identity']
+105854;['appeal ofkavita chabedevi wordsworth is dismissed']
+49526;['appeal isallowedand']
+69094;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+26777;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+68120;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+96319;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95945;['appeal of sharmarke ahmed mohamed from the removal order issued 4 november 2009 is dismissed']
+101779;['appeal is allowed']
+94415;['appeal isallowed']
+95885;['appeal is allowed']
+97870;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+85835;['dismiss the appeal']
+118635;['appeal is dismissed']
+5145;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107174;['application is allowed']
+84056;['appeal being dismissed']
+57542;['deportation orders areset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+19113;['appeal is allowed']
+77302;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+66778;['appeal is allowed']
+98414;['theappeal is allowed']
+89485;['302 (c.a.']
+58093;['appeal is concluded']
+62996;['appeal isallowed']
+84295;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+71511;['appeal isterminated']
+56572;['appeal is dismissed']
+87966;['appeal is allowed']
+102108;['appeal is allowed']
+132650;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64302;['appeal is dismissed']
+95002;['appeal is terminated']
+130771;['removal order is set aside']
+151386;['appeal is allowed']
+96874;['appeal is terminated']
+95565;['application is allowed']
+84132;['appeal isallowed']
+45208;['appeal is allowed']
+99949;['appeal is allowed']
+94078;['appeal at bar is dismissed']
+123343;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is\xa0 neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71389;['appeal is dismissed']
+44983;['appeal isdismissed.']
+108829;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+84613;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+45166;['appeal is allowed']
+144768;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+98452;['application is allowed']
+78176;['appeal of dalbgah singh is administratively closed']
+135462;['appeal was dismissed']
+97129;['appeal is allowed']
+46010;['removal order isset aside']
+80205;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+88516;['reject her claim']
+131727;['appeal is allowed']
+151523;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+98492;['appeal is dismissed']
+31263;['appeal is dismissed']
+76920;['appeal isallowed']
+70011;['appeal terminated']
+59724;['302 (c.a.)']
+84598;['appeal is dismissed']
+41571;['appeal is dismissed']
+78187;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+71064;['appeal is allowed']
+79338;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+96889;['appeal is allowed']
+77689;['neither the principal claimantxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, nor the associated claimantxxxxx', 'reject both their claims for refugee protection']
+85545;['appeal is terminated']
+67622;['appeal isallowed']
+71482;['appeal is allowed']
+99844;['302 (c.a.']
+46499;['appeal isallowed']
+63000;['appeal is dismissed']
+101048;['appeal be dismissed']
+135120;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the impugned decision', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+8270;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77463;['dismiss the appeal']
+112318;['appeal is dismissed']
+146877;['appeal is denied']
+90684;['appeal is allowed']
+89924;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+106269;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100821;['appeal is allowed']
+13969;['appeal is dismissed']
+97459;['appeal is allowed']
+96305;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+99745;['appealis dismissed']
+125542;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+32076;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with refugee protection claims']
+130690;['removal order isset aside']
+108740;['appeals are dismissed']
+49067;['appeal is allowed']
+60030;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+151508;['appeal is dismissed']
+80488;['appeal is dismissed']
+72662;['appeal isallowed']
+44425;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+38834;['removal order is set aside']
+98519;['allows this appeal']
+103207;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+70893;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+89846;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+57819;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+96815;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92459;['appeal isallowed.the']
+141064;['appeal is allowed']
+96659;['negative']
+79970;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+69429;['rejects her claim']
+151375;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124171;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98162;['appeal is allowed']
+55190;['appeals are dismissed']
+61804;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124081;['appeal of knock peter peck is dismissed']
+47322;['appeal is allowed']
+96926;['negative']
+93894;['appeal shall be allowed']
+68231;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+81186;['appeal is allowed']
+87065;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+30522;['appeals were dismissed']
+134311;['appeal is allowed']
+46273;['appeal is dismissed']
+69758;['appeal must be allowed in law']
+117141;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102958;['claimants are stateless']
+102081;['appeal is dismissed']
+112792;['appeal were dismissed']
+94373;['appeal of is dismissed']
+125492;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92816;['appeal is allowed']
+70051;['appeal is allowed']
+98726;['appeal abandoned']
+144723;['appeals of babak zaami and fatemeh tabatabaeishoorijeh are dismissed']
+70168;['appeal is allowed']
+91122;['appeal is dismissed']
+80007;['thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+37634;['appeal is dismissed']
+97286;['neither convention refugees nor people in need of protection']
+145761;['appellants are not convention refugees']
+57893;['appeal is dismissed']
+68222;['allows the appeal']
+85615;['appeal is dismissed']
+106894;['appeal be dismissed']
+74795;['appeal is allowed']
+60471;['appeal isallowed']
+144047;['appeals are allowed']
+77780;['appeal is allowed']
+150949;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124174;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+68620;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+149572;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140234;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+100657;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+65107;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+95955;['appeal is allowed']
+61953;['appeal is allowed.the']
+97455;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+95683;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+102556;['appeal regarding her father is dismissed']
+124969;['appeal is dismissed']
+70491;['application must nonetheless be dismissed']
+108842;['rad finds him to be a convention refugee']
+75909;['dismiss the appeal']
+61028;['appeal is allowed']
+80462;['removal is set aside', 'appeal is allowed']
+49971;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+63179;['appeal is dismissed']
+66765;['appeal is allowed']
+105836;['appeal is dismissed']
+99282;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision in this matter was wrong in fact']
+142803;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76259;['appeal is dismissed']
+80368;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+75962;['appeal is dismissed']
+85394;['appeal isallowed']
+86397;['appellant is not a sponsor according']
+96603;['claimant is not a “convention refugee’’']
+95284;['appeal is dismissed']
+123712;['removal order is set aside']
+112391;['decision inrenteriaremains applicable']
+100104;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+105600;['urhd is not a human rights group']
+98218;['appeal is allowed']
+90997;['appeal is allowed']
+61448;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87828;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection']
+99505;['appeals of lu ning wang, ai di song, yu qing wang and yu chun wang are allowed']
+146850;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses this appeal']
+60871;['appeal is dismissed']
+99765;['appeal is allowed']
+68107;['appeal of parinder kaur khosa is dismissed']
+99527;['appeal isallowed']
+151601;['302 (c.a.)']
+147465;['nor a genuine shouter christian practitioner']
+82153;['appeal is dismissed']
+139445;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+139796;['appeal isallowed']
+76774;['appeal is dismissed']
+62993;['dismiss this appeal']
+21936;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+143628;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+56693;['appeal isterminated']
+62444;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a refugee']
+82448;['appeal is dismissed']
+91658;['removal order isset aside']
+80040;['nor a risk of cruel and unusual treatment or punishment']
+69685;['allows this appeal']
+17938;['dismiss the appeal']
+125159;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+95294;['appeal is dismissed']
+116785;['officer’s decision is not valid in law', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+66497;['application for vacation is dismissed']
+35923;['appeal is dismissed']
+152042;['302 (c.a.']
+44336;['appeal isdetermined to be abandonedpursuant']
+145815;['appeal is allowed']
+107625;['appeal was dismissed']
+68163;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83368;['appeal is allowed']
+66760;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+125611;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95337;['appeal from the february\xa020, 2008']
+62381;['302 (c.a.']
+123368;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+92345;['claimant is also not a person in need of protection']
+100581;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+25977;['appeal is allowed']
+143857;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+45423;['appeal isallowed']
+107446;['appeal is dismissed']
+40800;['appeal is allowed']
+124596;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+91664;['determination is valid in law']
+141277;['nor a viable ifa']
+40138;['appeal of nilda panahon is dismissed']
+116827;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+63965;['appeal isdismissed.']
+56958;['appeals are allowed']
+94470;['appeal is dismissed']
+54561;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+107587;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+84452;['appeal is dismissed']
+64280;['appeal is dismissed']
+107475;['appeal is allowed']
+71724;['appeals are dismissed']
+68432;['appeal is allowed']
+87210;['appeal isallowed']
+103545;['appeal is dismissed']
+62947;['appeal isallowed']
+149480;['appeal is now moot']
+103909;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+103003;['appeal is terminated']
+85481;['appeal is allowed']
+64848;['appeal is dismissed']
+99527;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+146833;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+89346;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+31971;['appeal is allowed']
+97405;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+52047;['appeal were dismissed']
+133383;['appeal is not moot']
+121573;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+69364;['appeal is allowed']
+52137;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83356;['appeal is terminated']
+77675;['302 (c.a.)']
+117208;['rad rejects counsel for the appellant’s argument']
+5600;['appeal is dismissed']
+62478;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106132;['appeals are allowed in filesmb6\xa000078, mb6\xa000079andmb6\xa004165.']
+44210;['appeal isallowed']
+20007;['appeal of vasanthi vijayakumar is dismissed']
+87449;['appeal is dismissed']
+100470;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+36182;['appeal is allowed']
+101891;['appeal may have some merit']
+75871;['appeal is allowed in law']
+100122;['appeal is dismissed']
+36250;['appeal is allowed']
+128445;['appeal isallowed']
+120808;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125209;['appeal is determined']
+27254;['appeal with respect to the misrepresentation ground is dismissed']
+17975;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+117111;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99088;['appeal is dismissed']
+11462;['appeal should be dismissed']
+107487;['appeals are dismissed']
+147600;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+28066;['appeal is allowed']
+12214;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+57816;['appeal is dismissed']
+90442;['appeal is allowed']
+72773;['appeal is dismissed']
+71695;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+139432;['appeal be dismissed']
+86369;['appeal is allowed']
+141650;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+78298;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89860;['claim is rejected']
+99917;['appeal is allowed']
+73279;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+115213;['appeal is dismissed']
+57482;['removal order isset aside']
+122533;['appeal is allowed']
+80736;['not a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects her claim to refugee protection']
+103803;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67406;['appeal is dismissed']
+98176;['appeal is dismissed']
+96768;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+89290;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+87424;['appeal isallowed']
+61806;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx,', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+78755;['appeal is terminated']
+99094;['appeal isallowed']
+107146;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+118135;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd']
+69557;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+106175;['appeal be dismissed']
+90898;['appeal is dismissed']
+113791;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91208;['appeal is dismissed']
+54160;['appeal is allowed']
+90933;['appeal is dismissed']
+140214;['appellants are convention refugees']
+68866;['appeal being allowed']
+84028;['appeal isallowed']
+140708;['appeal is allowed']
+93294;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+64294;['appeal of alan chung is dismissed']
+114420;['dismiss the appeals']
+90455;['negative']
+62472;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision was correct']
+113768;['appeal is dismissed']
+81180;['appeal is based']
+57732;['dismiss the application to reopen the appeal']
+134410;['panel therefore dismisses the appeal']
+82742;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+146894;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+86963;['appeal is allowed']
+101667;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate circumstances']
+76667;['appeal is dismissed']
+129878;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77984;['appeal isallowed']
+90369;['claims are rejected']
+100300;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+141059;['rad is of the opinion the rpd’s decision is correct and appropriate']
+69712;['dismiss the application']
+41078;['appeal of malefia defferu amare is dismissed']
+147034;['appeal is dismissed']
+50737;['appeal is allowed']
+82131;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+107904;['rad therefore sets aside the decision of the panel', 'appellant is excluded']
+83486;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+48087;['appeal must be dismissed']
+90459;['panel therefore rejects this claim']
+90086;['appeal isallowed']
+68267;['appeal be allowed']
+71742;['appeal dismissed']
+97572;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+129172;['appeal is dismissed']
+114328;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+117184;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+82873;['appeal is allowed']
+80498;['appeal is allowed']
+80981;['rad concurs in part with the respondent’s arguments']
+52052;['allow the appeal']
+127333;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”']
+60919;['appeal is dismissed']
+100125;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76265;['appeal is dismissed']
+56611;['appeal isallowed']
+74046;['appeal is allowed']
+100321;['claimants are not “persons in need of protection']
+76310;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107655;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+122812;['1256, 1\xa0f.c.']
+56641;['appeal is determined to have beenabandonedundersubsection']
+136136;['appeal is allowed']
+77639;['appeal is allowed']
+77572;['appeal dismissed']
+98136;['appeal isallowed.the']
+82673;['appeal is terminated']
+122222;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+66325;['decision is valid in law']
+80724;['negative']
+56495;['appeal is allowed']
+90065;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+94049;['appeal isallowed']
+143925;['appeal must be dismissed']
+141633;['appeal is allowed']
+148645;['appeal is allowed.the']
+69715;['appeal is determined']
+143555;['appeal is allowed']
+46556;['appeal is allowed']
+76624;['appeal is allowed']
+96910;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68990;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal allowed']
+145593;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+78125;['claimants not to be persons in need of protection']
+100655;['appeal isallowedand']
+85459;['appeal is allowed.the']
+43389;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+147470;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142907;['xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees']
+26481;['appeal isallowed']
+132883;['appeal of appellant dm is allowed.the']
+72869;['appeal is allowed']
+77804;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+35051;['dismiss the appeal']
+91738;['appeal of ken charn gee is dismissed']
+101522;['302 (c.a.']
+76957;['appeal is dismissed']
+128419;['appeal is not allowed']
+47790;['appeal isallowed']
+147573;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+148732;['claim is rejected']
+54259;['appeal bediscontinuedpursuant tosection 196of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+76068;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+135166;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”']
+77604;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+67454;['appeal is dismissed']
+18015;['appeal is deemed abandoned']
+104002;['visa officer’s refusal is legally valid']
+93288;['appeal is dismissed']
+67535;['appeal isallowed']
+99799;['appeals are dismissed']
+99714;['appeal is dismissed']
+116864;['appeal is dismissed']
+95552;['appeal is dismissed']
+153058;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+66914;['allows the appeal']
+110720;['302 (c.a.']
+95466;['appeal is dismissed']
+95415;['appeal were dismissed']
+48597;['appeal is allowed']
+127349;['rad confirms for other reasons', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+74178;['panel substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+71079;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+74124;['set aside the rpd decision', 'substitute a determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+39063;['application to re-open is allowed']
+87953;['her claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+62120;['appeal is terminated']
+87600;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+140796;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+14697;['appeal bedismissed.']
+73252;['appeal is dismissed']
+130701;['appeal isallowed']
+98575;['appeal is allowed.the']
+124491;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+82724;['appeal is allowed']
+95183;['appeal is dismissed']
+67385;['appeal is dismissed']
+133250;['appeal is dismissed']
+123825;['302 (c.a.']
+74229;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+77252;['appeal isallowed']
+72765;['appeal is allowed']
+113765;['302 (c.a.']
+87608;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+64288;['appeal is dismissed']
+13691;['appeals should be dismissed']
+80363;['appeal most certainly fails']
+85604;['appeal is allowed']
+92786;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'or a“person in need of protection']
+125126;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74614;['appeal is allowed']
+110918;['appeal is allowed']
+76293;['appeal is terminated']
+92736;['allow the appeal']
+141320;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130692;['appeal isallowed']
+143599;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+21356;['not a “convention refugee”']
+107481;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+82447;['appeal is determined']
+71035;['claim is therefore rejected']
+104089;['claim is rejected']
+40135;['appeal of gemma harina estares is dismissed']
+36107;['appeal isallowed']
+114378;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+17979;['appeal is dismissed']
+111344;['rad finds that it has no jurisdiction to entertain the appellants’ appeal']
+12218;['appeal is allowed']
+27247;['appeal is dismissed']
+144263;['you are neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147576;['appeal isdismissed.']
+63164;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47350;['removal order is set aside']
+100127;['appeal is allowed']
+60955;['appeal is dismissed']
+71173;['appeal is dismissed']
+107789;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+108825;['302 (c.a.)']
+92938;['appeal is allowed']
+123652;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87421;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+99469;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+102053;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+98143;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+46922;['appeal is allowed']
+96316;['appeal is allowed']
+80381;['appeal is dismissed']
+90189;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+150946;['rejected the refugee protection claim']
+90035;['claimant is not convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124676;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113512;['appeal is dismissed']
+30540;['appeal is dismissed']
+102751;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has notlosther permanent resident status']
+112351;['appeal isallowed.the']
+31423;['appeal is allowed']
+123614;['not confirm the rpd’s decision or substitute its own decision']
+135141;['appeal is allowed']
+90059;['appeal is allowed']
+26814;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+102974;['allowed the appeal']
+99983;['allow the appeal']
+75589;['302 (c.a.)']
+94542;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+86956;['appeal is terminated']
+72841;['appeal must be dismissed']
+106414;['rejects the claims of the minor appellants']
+121545;['appeal is allowed']
+91609;['appeal abandoned']
+132832;['appeal is allowed.the']
+60427;['appeal is allowed']
+74853;['appeal is allowed.the']
+69584;['appeal filed by the appellant is therefore dismissed']
+47804;['appeal is allowed']
+81129;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+124723;['dismiss the appeal']
+99868;['removal order is set aside']
+56809;['appeal is dismissed']
+74500;['appeal is dismissed']
+98852;['appeal is dismissed']
+110270;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123397;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+85525;['appeal terminated']
+88981;['appeal is allowed']
+98409;['appeal is dismissed']
+84673;['appeal is terminated']
+47555;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+101169;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+97520;['you are not a convention refugee']
+96341;['appeal is allowed']
+76816;['appeal is dismissed']
+89081;['thatxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+73201;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+85176;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is erroneous']
+103665;['declare your claim for protection']
+99685;['appeal is dismissed']
+122536;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83061;['appeal is allowed']
+133192;['rad concludes that the rpd’s determination is correct']
+52040;['appeal is allowed']
+14462;['appeal is abandoned']
+125543;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is a person referred to in article\xa01e of the convention', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123543;['confirm the rpd’s decision that', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130847;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+80272;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+90965;['appeal is allowed']
+142455;['appeal is dismissed']
+68025;['appeal is allowed']
+103685;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82449;['appeal is terminated']
+108768;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd’s decision', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor persons in need of protection']
+14704;['appeal bedismissed.']
+47861;['appeal is dismissed']
+151584;['302 (c.a.']
+52950;['appeal is dismissed']
+124553;['appellant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+91570;['302 (c.a.']
+151330;['302 (c.a.']
+76749;['appeal in file number ma6-06125 is dismissed']
+87441;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+133272;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+98382;['appeal is dismissed']
+143165;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+65694;['appeal is allowed']
+105835;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+100890;['appeal is dismissed']
+86950;['appeal is dismissed']
+98870;['appeal isallowed']
+125627;['dismiss the appeal']
+105317;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+43395;['appeal is allowed']
+74853;['appeal is allowed']
+105315;['appeal is dismissed']
+90067;['allow the appeal']
+74105;['appeals are allowed', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+97956;['negative']
+76444;['allow the appellant’s appeal']
+77853;['appeal is allowed']
+88411;['appeal is allowed']
+59839;['appeal is dismissed']
+29723;['appeal isallowed']
+143592;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+124998;['appellant does not qualify for refugee protection']
+115181;['appeals are dismissed']
+94081;['appeal is dismissed']
+26503;['appeal is dismissed']
+94946;['appeal is allowed']
+70663;['appeal is allowed']
+100443;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123263;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99053;['appeal abandoned']
+134278;['appeal is allowed']
+105642;['appeal is allowed']
+16791;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+13549;['appeal is dismissed']
+123259;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+49147;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+61035;['dismissing the appeal']
+96142;['appeal isallowed']
+21301;['appeal is allowed']
+35036;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90992;['appeal is allowed']
+121479;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+46491;['appeal be dismissed']
+89095;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+54565;['appeal is dismissed']
+110921;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person who would be subject to persecution should he return to china']
+151585;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'refugee protection division therefore rejects this claim']
+113265;['appeal is allowed']
+150832;['rad substitutes a positive decision', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+26470;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpaparticularly in']
+47185;['appeal from a second refusal is dismissed']
+61864;['appeal is dismissed']
+108974;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+121956;['appeal is dismissed']
+49718;['irb (intervenor)(f.c.a., no']
+152006;['rad concurs with the rpd’s findings', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+91625;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+106284;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+73221;['appeals are determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+60366;['appeal is terminated']
+123028;['302 (c.a.']
+61864;['appeal is dismissed']
+78766;['appeal isallowed']
+72011;['appeal is dismissed']
+31984;['appeal is allowed.the']
+78031;['appeal isallowed']
+152019;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+114315;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+74470;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+110950;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is therefore not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87607;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+107637;['appeal is dismissed']
+63753;['appeal is dismissed']
+132845;['allow the appeal']
+114387;['appeal is allowed']
+84184;['appeal is dismissed']
+58387;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100604;['appeal isallowed']
+107687;['dismissing it']
+133388;['appeal is dismissed']
+64037;['removal order is set aside']
+108082;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131039;['appeal is dismissed']
+143910;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+112333;['appeal is determined']
+58562;['appeal isallowed']
+47929;['appeal isallowed.the']
+89226;['appeal is dismissed']
+95504;['appeal is allowed']
+100670;['appeal is allowed']
+55192;['appeal is not allowed']
+99014;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+27244;['appeal is dismissed']
+142847;['appeal is dismissed']
+128277;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+93016;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98164;['appeal is dismissed']
+105642;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+150930;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+75416;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+34685;['appeal is dismissed']
+107663;['appeals are dismissed']
+114345;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71642;['appeal is terminated']
+72596;['appeal is dismissed']
+103548;['appeal is dismissed']
+46075;['appeal isallowedand']
+102407;['appeal is allowed.the']
+77608;['appeal is allowed']
+96837;['nor a personalized risk to their lives']
+109022;['appellant is a convention refugee with protected status']
+80525;['appeal is dismissed']
+125109;['appeal is allowed']
+135892;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+80301;['reject these explanations']
+92764;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+105302;['appeal is dismissed']
+90492;['302 (c.a.']
+122259;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+82215;['allowed the appeal']
+75476;['appeal is dismissed']
+94980;['302 (c.a.)']
+61912;['appeal isallowed']
+83945;['appeal isallowed']
+66625;['appeals of xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are hereby withdrawn']
+124988;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+98615;['appeal is dismissed']
+140934;['302 (c.a.']
+95341;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+37400;['appeal isallowed']
+149250;['appeal is dismissed']
+82187;['appeal is dismissed']
+87176;['appeal of sameer gupta is dismissed']
+113291;['removal order is set aside']
+43751;['decision is well founded in law']
+108696;['appeal is allowed']
+94947;['appeal must be dismissed']
+12001;['appeal is allowed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+64048;['appeal abandoned']
+28065;['appeal of adham radwan alhashemi is allowed']
+56496;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123138;['302 (c.a.']
+106338;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+87083;['appeal isallowed']
+83026;['appeal is terminated']
+124270;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+65410;['appeal is allowed']
+84726;['iad is without jurisdiction']
+71133;['appeal is allowed']
+152915;['appeal is allowed']
+83521;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+111118;['appeal   is dismissed']
+132300;['302 (c.a.']
+125297;['rad sees no reason to overturn the rpd’s conclusions']
+101500;['appeal is allowed']
+105608;['panel therefore rejects this claim']
+63812;['declare your claim to be abandoned']
+50434;['appeal is dismissed']
+29712;['appeal is dismissed']
+76356;['appeal is dismissed']
+153262;['appeal is dismissed']
+129252;['appeal is dismissed']
+89273;['appeal regarding legal validity']
+100871;['appellant’s argument fails']
+22988;['appeal is dismissed']
+125035;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70664;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+138817;['appeal is dismissed.to']
+38243;['appeal is allowed']
+102149;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+66255;['decision of the id member is set aside']
+83834;['sponsor is not subject to the mni provisions of theirpa']
+104028;['removal order is set aside']
+107662;['appeal is dismissed']
+89317;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69168;['appeal isallowed']
+102469;['appeal isallowed']
+152050;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110906;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143886;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+48592;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+58095;['appeal isallowed']
+110980;['appeals are dismissed']
+79218;['appeal is allowed']
+39075;['appeal isallowed']
+128913;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131179;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+123057;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+54162;['appeal is allowed']
+91295;['appeal is allowed']
+101426;['appeal is allowed']
+23043;['appeal of appellant a (dr. muhammad imran)']
+123856;['appeal is allowed']
+144937;['appeal is allowed']
+89163;['appeal against the second deportation order is allowed']
+98620;['appeal is dismissed']
+69611;['appeal is dismissed']
+146823;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+71234;['appeal is terminated']
+42217;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91073;['appeal is terminated']
+53859;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim']
+103460;['not allow this application']
+142517;['not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+82615;['appeal of chan bich dao is dismissed']
+81094;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+70778;['appeal is allowed']
+76334;['appeal isallowed']
+68116;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+142889;['dismiss the appeal']
+98637;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+51129;['dismisses this appeal']
+108069;['rad substitutes the decision', 'determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86864;['appeal is dismissed']
+123730;['appeal is dismissed']
+67632;['appeal is allowed']
+101533;['appeal isallowed']
+102946;['appeal is allowed']
+48616;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93686;['appeal be dismissed']
+94697;['appeal of gurpreet arun plaha is allowed']
+40065;['appeal is allowed']
+151610;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugee']
+61483;['302 (c.a.']
+51693;['appeal is allowed']
+89867;['immigration officer’s decision is founded in law']
+42381;['appeal was allowed']
+145037;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52112;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116186;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+86034;['appeal is dismissed']
+73185;['appeal is allowed']
+106616;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+42332;['appeal is dismissed']
+68173;['appeal is dismissed']
+148623;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+88427;['negative']
+132319;['irpa does not give the rpd the authority to make decisions on']
+91729;['appeal is dismissed']
+42413;['appeal isallowed']
+95042;['appeal is dismissed']
+77047;['appeal is terminated']
+88032;['negative']
+77257;['appeal is allowed']
+95526;['appeal is allowed']
+151343;['dismiss the appeal']
+96574;['appeal is allowed']
+96433;['appeal is allowed']
+142901;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+73220;['appeal abandoned']
+109295;['302 (c.a.']
+73276;['appeal is dismissed']
+91774;['appellant is established inbulgaria']
+123846;['ifas are unreasonable']
+41803;['appeal is allowed.the']
+122978;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+102547;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60422;['appeal is allowed']
+107051;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+62834;['appeal isallowed']
+151942;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+151945;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+145045;['claim is rejected']
+70229;['302 (c.a.)']
+138860;['appeal is allowed']
+83677;['appeal is terminated']
+103096;['appeal is allowed']
+52204;['appeal is dismissed']
+81178;['appeal is dismissed']
+71250;['appeal isallowed']
+85164;['appeal is allowed']
+124215;['appeals were dismissed']
+58549;['appeal of baljinder singh mullhi is dismissed']
+146613;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+144004;['rad also rejects this argument']
+92988;['appeal is abandoned']
+127473;['appeal is dismissed']
+77124;['appeal is allowed']
+44432;['appeal is granted']
+95030;['appeal is terminated']
+64593;['appeal were dismissed']
+95266;['appeal is allowed']
+60493;['appeal is dismissed']
+144461;['appeal be dismissed']
+73251;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+96186;['appeal is allowed']
+97027;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+94412;['appeals are dismissed']
+76307;['appeal is allowed']
+74232;['appeal must fail']
+71343;['appeal is dismissed.the', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+76749;['allows the appeal in files ma5-05047 foramal rostom, ma5‑04928 forzien sibaai, and ma6-06126', 'dismisses the appeal']
+68098;['appeal is dismissed']
+68431;['appeal is dismissed']
+91760;['appeal is allowed']
+92252;['appeal is allowed']
+147625;['set aside the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+103694;['302 (c.a.']
+140736;['setting aside the rpd’s decision']
+143588;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+38861;['appeal is dismissed']
+97876;['appeal is allowed']
+76761;['appeal isallowed']
+97879;['appeal is allowed']
+30517;['appeal isallowed']
+140254;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+100352;['claimant is not a refugee-sur place']
+83074;['appeal is allowed']
+138292;['appeal is allowed']
+82382;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+95394;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+101507;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+96480;['appeal be dismissed']
+52496;['appeal is allowed']
+152150;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132826;['appeal is dismissed']
+120799;['appeal is allowed']
+150784;['rpd decision does contain errors']
+110302;['appeal is allowed']
+109171;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103877;['appeal against the refusal']
+31986;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+26699;['appeal beallowed']
+56277;['302 (c.a.)']
+93851;['appeal is allowed']
+63089;['negative']
+90963;['appeal must be dismissed']
+96942;['appeal is dismissed']
+49548;['refugee protection division accepts the claims for refugee protection']
+69964;['appeal isallowed']
+84523;['appeal is dismissed']
+24474;['appeal of sherif kuleta is dismissed']
+129853;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+100236;['panel finds that the immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+99936;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+33330;['dismiss the appeal']
+84450;['appeal is allowed']
+125130;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+101819;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+125408;['appeal is allowed']
+52703;['nor a danger of torture']
+105603;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47325;['appeal is allowed']
+94294;['claimant is a refugee']
+151976;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91240;['appeal is terminated']
+55271;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98131;['appeal is dismissed']
+124019;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104092;['302 (c.a.']
+88819;['appeal is allowed']
+71266;['appeal isdismissed.']
+152010;['appeal is allowed']
+80508;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+123023;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+122556;['appeal is allowed']
+111175;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+145181;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59020;['iad cancels its order of february\xa015, 1989', 'allows the appeal']
+75412;['appeal is dismissed']
+131872;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'respondents are persons in need of protection']
+151883;['appeal is allowed']
+78063;['appeal being dismissed']
+100303;['appeal is allowed']
+135128;['rad finds the appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+111322;['appeal is dismissed']
+131227;['appeal is allowed']
+101015;['appeal of beatrice evelyn eduful is dismissed']
+84653;['appeal isallowed']
+102677;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+66202;['immigration appeal division dismisses an appeal']
+101110;['motion is denied']
+88150;['appeal is allowed']
+124917;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68742;['appeal is allowed']
+142075;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'panel rejects her claim']
+62949;['allow the appeal']
+97989;['appeal is dismissed']
+96917;['dismiss the appeal']
+98136;['appeal is dismissed']
+72791;['appeal is terminated']
+99895;['appeal is dismissed']
+34160;['appeal is allowed']
+74782;['allows the appeal']
+52923;['allow the appellant’s appeal']
+105882;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74541;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98820;['appeal isallowed']
+152237;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106634;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+99412;['decision of the visa officer is not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+130933;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66632;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94364;['appeal must be dismissed']
+73204;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+94974;['302 (c.a.)']
+84562;['application to re-open constitutes a preliminary motion']
+144018;['affirm its rejection of this claim']
+99309;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93310;['appeal is dismissed']
+102702;['appeals are dismissed']
+79750;['appeal is allowed']
+95787;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56825;['appeal is dismissed']
+76621;['appeal isallowed']
+88812;['appeal is allowed']
+63090;['negative']
+76468;['appeal is dismissed']
+52485;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76231;['removal order is set aside']
+152914;['appeal is dismissed']
+105917;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+39827;['appeal will proceed']
+46092;['appeal isallowed']
+93066;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+123977;['appeal is allowed']
+87510;['appeal is dismissed']
+93612;['appeal is dismissed']
+50492;['appeal was dismissed']
+105876;['rad concurs with the rpd’s findings']
+97519;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131138;['appeal is denied']
+71740;['appeal is dismissed']
+102677;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+71385;['appeal is dismissed']
+29698;['spouses are not exempt fromsection 39of theact']
+63520;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+72845;['appeal is denied']
+97581;['appeal is dismissed']
+90237;['nor a person in need of protection']
+92173;['appeal is dismissed']
+100743;['dismissing this appeal']
+151795;['appellant cannot be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77318;['appeal is dismissed']
+67197;['appeal division should not have dismissed her appeal based']
+149489;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+90672;['appeal is dismissed']
+143626;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+19136;['appeal is dismissed']
+128861;['dismiss the appeals']
+87743;['appeal is determined']
+98749;['appeals ofxxxx xxxx xxxx']
+101037;['claimants, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are not persons in need of protection']
+71130;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law']
+140279;['appeal is dismissed']
+145873;['appeal is dismissed']
+77708;['reject these claims to refugee protection', 'claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+69415;['appeals before the iad are hearingsde novo']
+80245;['refugee protection division', 'not a convention refugee']
+113753;['appeal is not granted']
+100376;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90843;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95151;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+146454;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+92486;['appeal isallowed.thedecision']
+143477;['appeal is dismissed']
+33086;['appeal is dismissed']
+94133;['appeal isallowed']
+122995;['appeal is allowed']
+91352;['appeals be allowed']
+123907;['appeal is allowed']
+108823;['appeal is allowed']
+143627;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143509;['panel finds xxxx xxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+138796;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+91679;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87938;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+86310;['appeal is allowed']
+130946;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62893;['appeal is dismissed']
+87847;['appeal be dismissed']
+96847;['appeal were dismissed']
+145833;['appeal is allowed']
+28484;['appeal is dismissed']
+81237;['appeal is allowed']
+95168;['appeal is allowed']
+74826;['allows the appeal']
+143844;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99093;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+85620;['appeal is dismissed']
+132372;['appeal is terminated']
+132301;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+98637;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+125346;['rad substitutes the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is a person in need of protection']
+67622;['appeal is allowed']
+105620;['appeal is allowed']
+71687;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+100661;['appeal isallowed']
+91810;['appeal is denied']
+125606;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69973;['appeal is dismissed']
+82843;['appeal is terminated']
+96478;['302 (c.a.']
+16760;['removal orders areset aside']
+98107;['nor a person in need of protection']
+150930;['confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78160;['dismiss the appeal']
+74185;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142083;['motion was also denied']
+114422;['302 (c.a.']
+135131;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the impugned determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+131081;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+99637;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+111322;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+141319;['appellant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+28292;['negative determination of the rpd is set aside']
+140280;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+89794;['appeal is allowed']
+97896;['appeal is dismissed']
+38419;['appeal is dismissed']
+138279;['302 (c.a.']
+52710;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+72702;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+142088;['you are not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim']
+102804;['appeal is dismissed']
+45394;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96726;['appeal is terminated']
+105640;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76168;['negative']
+140794;['appeal is dismissed']
+124707;['overturn this section accordingly']
+84764;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98918;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+58087;['appeal proceeded']
+97355;['appeal is allowed']
+34096;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94649;['appeal is allowed']
+110680;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of   ']
+123436;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+149007;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+90756;['decision is valid in law']
+134892;['appeals are dismissed']
+94643;['appellant is not a person described insubsection\xa063(1)of theact']
+135930;['rad therefore confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+96313;['appeal is allowed']
+60129;['my decision that']
+89348;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+89763;['appeal is dismissed']
+95189;['appeal is dismissed']
+90106;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+135478;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+70084;['claim is rejected']
+93590;['appeal is dismissed']
+114381;['appeal is dismissed']
+67216;['dismiss the appeal']
+99579;['appeal is allowed']
+80522;['determination is valid in law']
+60427;['appeal is dismissed']
+68882;['appeal isallowed']
+89247;['appeal is dismissed']
+124037;['302 (c.a), page 305']
+131755;['appeal is allowed']
+35904;['appeal is allowed']
+69752;['appeal is withdrawn']
+106832;['appeal is allowed']
+87380;['appeal is terminated']
+37838;['appeal is dismissed']
+142984;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+136120;['neither convention refugees']
+36253;['appeal isallowed']
+124624;['appeal is dismissed']
+87609;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+106631;['rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+133373;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in   need of protection']
+91712;['appeal is allowed']
+79223;['appeal is terminated']
+82394;['appeal isallowed']
+80100;['appeal is dismissed']
+88095;['appeal isallowed']
+136146;['refugee appeal division confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30499;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+122111;['appeal is allowed']
+98777;['appeal isdismissed.']
+73313;['appeal isallowed']
+60432;['appeals of the hui hsu and huei ying huang are dismissed']
+87181;['appeal is dismissed']
+135915;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93336;['appeal is allowed']
+135927;['dismiss the appeal']
+77770;['appeal is allowed']
+122843;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+97264;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+101813;['appeal is allowed']
+95944;['stay the removal order in accordance']
+87364;['appeals are dismissed']
+54517;['appeal is dismissed']
+124699;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+87870;['appeal is dismissed']
+63982;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+13553;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73018;['dismiss it for lack of jurisdiction']
+53135;['allow the appeal,']
+105765;['appeal is dismissed']
+98522;['appeal is dismissed']
+80827;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+66532;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal allowed']
+132441;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+63824;['appeal was dismissed']
+100656;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+107289;['appeal was dismissed']
+90426;['appeal is allowed']
+97631;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+60496;['appeal is dismissed']
+80751;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+70218;['allows the appeal']
+47318;['appeal is dismissed']
+107090;['removal order is set aside']
+91608;['appeal is dismissed']
+124989;['appeal is allowed']
+99494;['claimants will not be persecuted']
+124670;['rad finds that the rpd’s change of circumstances']
+69278;['appeal isallowed.the']
+78189;['appeal is allowed']
+96376;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your removal from canada']
+98348;['panel finds the visa officer’s decision to be valid in law']
+37238;['dismiss the appeal']
+5605;['appeal were dismissed']
+122776;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+87063;['dismiss the appeal']
+82711;['appeal is allowed']
+92154;['appeal should be dismissed']
+93619;['appeal of steven edward kollie is dismissed']
+87188;['appeal is dismissed']
+103713;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71478;['appeal would be dismissed']
+125317;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+124741;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86467;['appeal regarding legal validity of the marriage is allowed']
+73593;['appeal isallowedand']
+60928;['appeal is dismissed']
+45613;['302 (c.a.']
+81109;['dismissing the appeal will not create any new challenges']
+121528;['appeal is dismissed']
+71443;['appeal is dismissed']
+89725;['appeal must be dismissed']
+121565;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+77289;['appeal is dismissed']
+72000;['appeal isallowed']
+32168;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+72664;['appeal isallowed']
+99967;['appeal is allowed']
+101429;['appeal granted']
+78756;['appeal is dismissed']
+147879;['appeal is allowed']
+115178;['appeal is dismissed']
+75232;['appeal is being allowed']
+71223;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+31978;['appeal is dismissed']
+74545;['appeal is dismissed']
+105280;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+114377;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+50233;['claimant is a person in need of protection']
+100330;['negative']
+91614;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+70951;['appeal of abninder singh dutt is dismissed']
+47306;['appeal is allowed']
+84724;['appeal is allowed']
+129992;['appeal is dismissed']
+95767;['appeal is accepted']
+107615;['appeal is dismissed']
+40797;['appeal is allowed']
+93279;['appeal is dismissed']
+39030;['appeal was dismissed']
+100832;['appeal is denied']
+145370;['appeal dismissed']
+107026;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+103912;['application is allowed']
+97959;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+58752;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72879;['appeal is allowed']
+92984;['appeal is terminated']
+84083;['appeal isallowed']
+5142;['appeal should be dismissed']
+100017;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”', 'refugee protection claim is rejected']
+112789;['dismissing the appeal,']
+128339;['appeal is dismissed']
+57722;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+92875;['appeal isallowed']
+140892;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+38849;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124088;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90027;['appeal is dismissed']
+142079;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+87673;['appeal is dismissed']
+76304;['dismiss his appeal']
+88260;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144391;['appeal is allowed']
+14685;['claimant, xxxxxx xxxxx xxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+108764;['appeal is allowed']
+52092;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes it determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+86403;['appeal is allowed']
+87462;['appeal is allowed']
+125118;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77201;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+86351;['allows this appeal']
+105866;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will stand']
+144464;['appeal is allowed']
+128894;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis excluded from the convention']
+123060;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+56931;['appeal, therefore, isdismissed.']
+74999;['appeal is dismissed']
+110904;['appeal is dismissed']
+127435;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+84324;['appeal of ian kennedy kruger is dismissed']
+95431;['stay the removal order in accordance']
+44025;['appeal is allowed']
+60480;['appeal is dismissed']
+64873;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+128598;['302 (c.a.']
+30540;['dismiss this appeal']
+134335;['appeal is based']
+86008;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+98863;['appeal is dismissed']
+92743;['appeal is terminated']
+88421;['panel therefore rejects his claim']
+20011;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+96528;['appeal is allowed']
+46557;['302 (c.a.)']
+101862;['appeal is dismissed']
+81099;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+101534;['appeal is dismissed']
+40061;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+61804;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+37067;['appeal is allowed']
+92501;['appeal is allowed', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61914;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+36256;['appeal is dismissed']
+56958;['appeals are allowed']
+73708;['appeal is terminated']
+87460;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+93869;['appeal will be dismissed']
+88509;['panel rejects the co-claimant’s claim']
+131142;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+150784;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82372;['appeal is dismissed']
+68695;['appeal of min tang is allowed']
+73182;['appeal is allowed']
+113292;['302 (c.a.']
+89210;['appeal is allowed']
+84177;['appeal is dismissed']
+89397;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+60821;['appeal should be dismissed']
+122098;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+127338;['rad finds this error to be fatal to the rpd’s determination']
+72071;['appeal is allowed']
+55246;['claimant is a “convention refugee']
+62635;['application for leave to appeal federal court of appeal decision, number a-531-14,2015\xa0fca\xa0237, dated october\xa030, 2015, was allowed']
+61046;['appeal is allowed']
+90683;['appeal is dismissed']
+88660;['refugee protection claimant', '“convention refugees”']
+129908;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146116;['claim is therefore rejected']
+22824;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+89249;['appeal is allowed']
+57740;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94494;['appeal is dismissed']
+100808;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident   status.']
+99497;['appeal is dismissed']
+94239;['appeal is dismissed']
+78084;['appeal isallowed']
+8345;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+144380;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination']
+76066;['appeal isallowed']
+134161;['panel therefore dismisses the appeal']
+141306;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+96895;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89148;['appeal is dismissed']
+83464;['visa officer’s decision is confirmed', 'theappeal is dismissed']
+127908;['rad is of the view that the rpd rendered the appropriate, correct decision']
+50491;['appeal is dismissed']
+100986;['appeal is allowed']
+108749;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+50253;['appeals were dismissed']
+34929;['appeal is dismissed']
+123372;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+100924;['appeal isallowed']
+123139;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+101208;['appeal is allowed']
+80064;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77059;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+125123;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+143640;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74129;['substitute my determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+107470;['appeal is dismissed']
+82069;['appeal isallowed']
+46567;['appeal isallowed']
+12223;['appeal is dismissed']
+130757;['appeal is allowed']
+136116;['dismiss the appeal']
+100331;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101355;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+61384;['appeal is allowed']
+106643;['claims are rejected']
+96641;['appeal isallowed']
+28305;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+56951;['appeal is allowed']
+108214;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57307;['appeal is dismissed']
+95418;['appeal is dismissed']
+40055;['visa officer’s decision is valid']
+68727;['appeal is allowed']
+67191;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+118239;['panel confirms the decision of the rpd', 'rejects his claim']
+116816;['appeal is dismissed']
+107148;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+133750;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+101335;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+32167;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+46084;['appeal is allowed']
+129891;['confirm the rpd’s decision']
+145387;['thatxxxx xxxxxxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+97245;['appeal abandoned']
+125011;['appeal is allowed']
+111156;['appeal is allowed']
+47564;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+94320;['appeal is allowed']
+53144;['appeal isallowed.the']
+83143;['appeal is dismissed']
+31983;['appeal is allowed']
+147631;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91141;['appeal is allowed']
+36092;['appeal isallowed']
+35660;['appeal is dismissed']
+72833;['dismiss their appeals']
+143025;['302 (c.a.']
+86942;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+40799;['rad finds that this decision must be set aside']
+74563;['appeal is allowed']
+103039;['appeal is allowed']
+152003;['dismissing the appeal for lack of perfection']
+97587;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+153272;['appeal is dismissed']
+94715;['appeal is allowed']
+124958;['appeal is allowed']
+138853;['appeal be dismissed']
+80564;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99932;['appeal is allowed']
+63750;['appeals are allowed']
+124061;['rpd’s negative determination is confirmed']
+97429;['application to reopen is denied']
+47890;['302 (c.a.']
+83918;['appeal is abandoned']
+87447;['appeal should be allowed']
+54275;['dismiss this appeal']
+123380;['appeal is allowed']
+93657;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+81623;['appeal would be dismissed']
+89879;['nor are they persons in need of protection']
+15584;['appeal is allowed']
+74784;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+128381;['appeals do not fall into any of these categories']
+152474;['appeal is dismissed']
+132662;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95778;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding in this regard is not reasonable']
+80138;['302 (c.a.)']
+96780;['claimants,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx,and her husband,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'claims are, therefore, rejected']
+140924;['substitute my determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+82045;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+62480;['appeal is allowed']
+125464;['aa’s claim was rejected']
+134288;['appeal is allowed.the']
+60042;['refugee protection division rejects the claim ofxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx.because']
+95126;['appeal is dismissed']
+78141;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxxx xxxxx to be a convention refugee']
+59938;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+130802;['you are not a convention refugee']
+94217;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+43707;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+139851;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+81048;['appeal is allowed']
+97914;['appeals of both the appellant mum and appellant son are hereby dismissed']
+94813;['dismiss her appeal']
+95606;['appeals are determined tobe abandonedunders']
+79980;['negative']
+88073;['appeal is dismissed']
+104108;['panel rejects the claim']
+134172;['dismiss the appeal']
+135198;['id’s decision is legally valid']
+107179;['appeal is dismissed']
+130957;['rpd decision is correct in law']
+84910;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122245;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+68869;['appeal is dismissed']
+31424;['appeal isallowed.the']
+95574;['appeal is dismissed']
+124694;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+131157;['appeal is allowed']
+118231;['dismissing the appeal']
+38244;['stay is cancelled']
+77125;['appeal is dismissed']
+80797;['appeal is allowed']
+61865;['appeals of harvinder kaur, pavandeep kaur and sanjit kaur are withdrawn']
+113230;['appeal be dismissed']
+53019;['appeal is dismissed']
+60089;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+114334;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+121435;['appeal would be dismissed']
+81191;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+108248;['rad concurs with the rpd’s decision']
+75871;['appeal isallowed']
+52608;['reject his claim']
+84682;['appeal isallowed']
+95881;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72887;['panel orders the removal order made against the appellant', 'appeal be allowed']
+94621;['appeal is allowed']
+105332;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+90811;['appeal is terminated']
+27460;['appeal isallowed']
+123833;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+66582;['appeal is dismissed']
+71708;['appeal is allowed']
+77943;['appeal is allowed']
+45390;['appeal is dismissed']
+75452;['appeal isallowed']
+136751;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+132773;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97965;['appeal is allowed']
+131912;['dismissing the appeal']
+20120;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+142286;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is excluded from protection provided to refugees']
+42086;['appeal is allowed']
+90921;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80993;['appeal is dismissed']
+151774;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a person described inparagraph\xa034(1)(f)']
+90787;['302 (c.a.)']
+125384;['appeal is allowed']
+149002;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need ofprotection.']
+68373;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+50769;['appeal isallowed']
+52487;['302 (c.a.']
+104937;['appeal is terminated']
+102495;['favourable decision is attached to this decision']
+55252;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+26811;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+76631;['appeal isallowed']
+94528;['appeal is allowed']
+96566;['appeal isallowed']
+76731;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96291;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+80983;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+65419;['appeal is allowed']
+22117;['appeal is dismissed']
+144009;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55292;['refugee protection division determines xxxxxxx and xxxxxxx are convention refugees']
+123708;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123698;['appeal is allowed']
+123441;['302 (c.a.']
+22817;['appeal is dismissed']
+47115;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+61901;['appeal is allowed']
+97935;['appeal is dismissed']
+145577;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+134433;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+61474;['appeal isallowed']
+59976;['negative']
+76926;['302 (c.a.)']
+96593;['appeal of jian qiang wen is allowed']
+131139;['appeal is allowed']
+65418;['appeals are allowed']
+96100;['302 (c.a.']
+131152;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+101349;['appeal is allowed']
+130885;['appeal is dismissed']
+86308;['appeal is dismissed']
+151368;['rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+58551;['appeal be dismissed']
+47329;['appeal is dismissed']
+96249;['appeal isallowedand']
+71481;['appeal is declared to be abandoned unders']
+140820;['appeal is allowed']
+124667;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+136691;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+134413;['appeal is allowed']
+50491;['appeal is denied']
+98818;['panel rejects the refugee protection claims']
+100207;['reject the application for exclusion']
+123017;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124441;['302 (c.a.']
+90540;['appellant is not a refugee or a protected person']
+134441;['appeal is dismissed']
+96140;['appeal is allowed']
+49167;['appeal is determined']
+82675;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98412;['appeal is allowed']
+80664;['negative']
+100356;['dismissed the appeals of the parents']
+35919;['appeal is dismissed']
+124897;['appeal is allowed']
+85863;['refugee protection division rejects the claim/s']
+123248;['appeal is dismissed']
+123048;['appeal is allowed']
+91455;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+122704;['302 (c.a.']
+46498;['application to re-open is dismissed']
+99950;['appeal isallowed']
+52083;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+85169;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+51675;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61368;['appeal is dismissed']
+74067;['appeal were dismissed']
+92752;['appeal is allowed']
+48754;['confirm the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis excluded from the protection offered to refugees']
+99988;['appeal is granted']
+108958;['appeal is dismissed']
+90750;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+123289;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+67403;['appeal is allowed']
+73890;['i also reject their claims']
+151389;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99847;['panel rejects the claimant’s aforementioned refugee protection claim']
+82874;['determination is valid in law']
+60105;['appeal is allowed']
+95967;['appeal is dismissed']
+99193;['refugee protection claims ofxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare rejected']
+96305;['nor is he a person in need of protection']
+60317;['appeal is dismissed']
+74889;['appeal is allowed']
+150946;['substitutes the determination']
+136147;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+101351;['appeal isallowedand']
+26726;['appeal is dismissed']
+151938;['appeal is allowed']
+146612;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+63857;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+99860;['appeal is dismissed']
+151817;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+128400;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94717;['visa officer’s decision is confirmed', 'theappeal is dismissed']
+93068;['appeal is dismissed']
+107576;['panel finds the exclusion order to be legally valid']
+146837;['appeal is dismissed']
+94055;['appeal is allowed']
+85527;['appeal is terminated']
+103544;['appeal be dismissed']
+152479;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+129890;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+91911;['appeal is allowed']
+95071;['determination is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+72591;['appeal is allowed']
+76319;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+75423;['appeal is allowed']
+68291;['appeal is allowed']
+64641;['appeal is allowed']
+122948;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+121544;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+114295;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96824;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+139677;['appeal is allowed']
+82872;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+96301;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123717;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+123869;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+57521;['302 (c.a.)']
+124906;['appeal is allowed']
+80734;['negative']
+94493;['appeal is allowed']
+84308;['appeal was allowed']
+49165;['appeal is allowed']
+64852;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeals are allowed']
+94035;['appeal is dismissed']
+125434;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+92735;['appeal is allowed']
+81189;['appeal is dismissed']
+87847;['appeal be dismissed']
+52478;['appeal fails']
+67177;['appeal is allowed']
+52636;['claimant is an economic refugee']
+100262;['refugee protection claimant is not a\xa0“convention refugee”']
+40480;['appeal is dismissed']
+102692;['request is denied']
+82390;['sponsor withdraws their sponsorship application']
+26812;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+69984;['appeal is allowed']
+135452;['claims are rejected']
+90900;['appeal is dismissed']
+145056;['claim is rejected']
+71660;['appeal is allowed']
+103591;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+146632;['claimants, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+64848;['appeal is dismissed']
+42217;['appeal is allowed']
+52502;['allow the appeal']
+110954;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146566;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+95895;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+26910;['claimant’s refugee claim therefore fails']
+140857;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43801;['appeal is meritorious']
+108750;['appeals are allowed']
+96487;['appeal isallowed']
+79321;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+82044;['appeal is allowed']
+92789;['decision is not valid in law']
+97243;['appeal is allowed']
+61800;['not a person in need of protection']
+42391;['appeal of ahmed mohamed abdi is dismissed']
+102745;['appeal is allowed']
+98899;['appeal is allowed']
+91725;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140708;['appellants are convention refugees']
+140746;['confirm the rpd decision']
+146105;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+38258;['dismiss this appeal']
+78776;['appeal is allowed']
+71082;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55006;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+64869;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+98435;['appeal is dismissed']
+68140;['appeal is allowed']
+71535;['dismiss the appeal']
+68327;['appeal isallowed']
+122691;['appeal is allowed']
+94385;['claim is rejected']
+88062;['appeal isallowed.the']
+95872;['terminates his appeal']
+73293;['appeal must be dismissed']
+76679;['appeal is allowed']
+121382;['panel therefore set asides the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision with a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+62708;['appeal isallowed']
+44018;['rad disagrees']
+117115;['appeal is dismissed']
+42390;['appeal isallowed']
+9462;['appeal is allowed']
+44208;['appeal abandoned']
+69969;['appeal is dismissed']
+115229;['rad is in no position to substitute its own determination of the appellant’s refugee claim']
+83917;['appeal is dismissed']
+120801;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+79225;['appeal is allowed']
+59811;['appeal is allowed']
+93665;['appeal is allowed']
+153418;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses her appeal']
+68875;['dismiss the appeal']
+63929;['appeal allowed']
+92159;['appeal is dismissed']
+104081;['appellant is a refugee from iraq']
+66942;['appeal isallowedand']
+52531;['appeal is dismissed']
+91535;['302 (c.a.']
+145825;['appeal is terminated by operation of law']
+82046;['appeal is allowed']
+14712;['appeal division orders that the appeals bedismissed.']
+81224;['appeal is dismissed']
+93022;['dismissing the appeal for lack of perfection']
+73313;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+51809;['appeal is dismissed']
+107161;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101516;['board therefore rejects their claims']
+66326;['tribunal dismisses this appeal in law']
+152374;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55049;['appeal is allowed.the']
+132789;['appeal is allowed']
+122819;['substitute own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+62011;['appeal is allowed']
+105447;['appeal is dismissedand']
+77045;['appeals aredismissed.']
+80568;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+66204;['appeal is dismissed']
+46014;['appeal is allowed']
+98903;['appeal is dismissed']
+143550;['neither convention ���refugees”', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+99677;['appeal isallowed']
+130863;['appeal is dismissed']
+44980;['appeal is dismissed']
+50661;['appeal isallowed']
+125051;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+106630;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+100931;['302 (c.a.']
+77074;['appeal is allowed']
+100116;['appeal is allowed']
+94131;['appeal is allowed']
+94361;['tribunal\xa0grants the minister’s application', 'dismisses the appeal']
+30490;['appeal of emunti stephen amponsah is dismissed']
+142696;['appeal is allowed']
+115281;['appeal is allowed']
+142067;['rad therefore finds that the claim undersection 97cannot succeed']
+92272;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+76970;['appeal isallowed']
+146569;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+72669;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+131074;['dismissing the appeals', 'appeal of the appellant’s wife', 'appeal is dismissed']
+91645;['application to add a ground of refusal']
+130953;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101767;['appeal is then postponed']
+101548;['appeal is allowed']
+125341;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96238;['appeal is dismissed']
+81339;['appeal were dismissed']
+55187;['appeal is dismissed']
+48102;['allow the appeal']
+108898;['claimant, xxxx xxxx,not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+108128;['appeal is dismissed']
+146551;['rad concurs with the rpd']
+94350;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+71136;['appeal is allowed']
+95829;['appeal in respect   ofsubsection 67(1)(a) ofirpais dismissed']
+97488;['negative']
+111175;['appeal is dismissed']
+100400;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+108998;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+121451;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59829;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+19237;['appeal is dismissed']
+93339;['appeal isallowed']
+97242;['appeal is allowed']
+98424;['appeals are allowed']
+80991;['appeal is dismissed']
+129210;['allow this appeal']
+26797;['appeal be dismissed']
+98422;['appeal is allowed']
+95019;['allowed the appeal']
+122139;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+93621;['appeal is dismissed']
+63514;['not a person in need of protection']
+96473;['refugee protection division shall accept a claim for refugee protection', 'claimant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject the claim']
+122822;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+107650;['appeal is dismissed']
+101436;['appeal is allowed']
+152008;['allow the appeal and refer the matter back to the rpd']
+84648;['appeal must fail']
+69432;['appeal is dismissed']
+68742;['appeals are allowed']
+56613;['appeal were dismissed']
+63201;['appeal is allowed']
+82385;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+60878;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+80118;['appeal is allowed']
+95887;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128613;['appeal with respect to the principal appellant', 'appellants is allowed']
+98316;['302 (c.a.']
+59749;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+97633;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+76836;['appellant has not loss his permanent resident status']
+90240;['negative']
+94718;['appeal is allowed']
+99941;['nor persons in need of protection']
+32168;['appeal isallowed']
+123317;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+64213;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee']
+152247;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90497;['appeal isallowed.the']
+131148;['appeal is allowed']
+104974;['appeal isallowed']
+99702;['appeal is allowed']
+138830;['appeals abandoned']
+99535;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+94656;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+100372;['appeal is dismissed']
+64242;['appeal is allowed']
+151602;['rad allows this appeal']
+103874;['appeal were dismissed']
+90813;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+62246;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89426;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+56742;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+70888;['appeal is allowed']
+74457;['allow her appeal']
+106335;['rad rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+95342;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+121405;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+107937;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+123869;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd’s decision was correct and appropriate']
+153290;['appeal is dismissed']
+133278;['xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57003;['application for leave to appeal dismissed']
+63992;['appeal is allowed']
+70072;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+16826;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71036;['not a person in need of protection']
+122898;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision']
+134426;['decision by the visa office is valid in law']
+107040;['appeal is allowed']
+38835;['appeals are allowed']
+101330;['302 (c.a.']
+81189;['appeal is allowed']
+98496;['decision is well-founded in law and in fact']
+112361;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101041;['appeal isallowed']
+101559;['allows the appeal']
+26729;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+78169;['nor in need of protection']
+23115;['appeal is allowed.the']
+26773;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal be allowed in law']
+72642;['allow the appeal']
+61214;['appeal is allowed']
+92314;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+80001;['302 (c.a.']
+71998;['appeal of younis bilal isdismissedforres judicata']
+96434;['appeal is allowed']
+125522;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97865;['appeal is allowed']
+59681;['decision is valid in law']
+24191;['appeal is dismissed']
+130948;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89316;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'allow the appeal']
+77637;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+135931;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+80055;['appeal is dismissed']
+134166;['appeal is allowed']
+40051;['removal order is set aside']
+82725;['appeal isallowed.the']
+71999;['appeal was dismissed']
+122493;['rad allows the appeal and returns the matter to the rpd']
+66635;['rad is unable to substitute its own decision']
+69628;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+140259;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+92393;['appeal is allowed']
+105775;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+94203;['appeal is allowed']
+89336;['appeal is allowed']
+68287;['appeal of mr. courtney mckenzie is dismissed']
+51909;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+82844;['appeal is dismissed']
+52366;['appeal is allowed']
+151308;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+63830;['appeal is dismissed']
+44022;['dismiss the appeal']
+96765;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+132739;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+50645;['appeal be dismissed']
+93636;['appeal is dismissed']
+51135;['appeal allowed']
+91570;['appeal is allowed']
+107817;['appeal is dismissed']
+97199;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+60985;['appeal is dismissed']
+79456;['appeal is dismissed']
+82263;['appeal of gulbadan fahrozi is dismissed']
+54170;['appeal is dismissed']
+72013;['appeal is allowed']
+139860;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+86483;['allow this appeal']
+94495;['appeal is dismissed']
+91811;['appeal is dismissed']
+19116;['appeal is dismissed']
+91412;['appeal of hazem serag eldin mohamed is dismissed']
+90360;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+112319;['appeal isallowed.the']
+13806;['appeal is dismissed']
+49122;['appeal is dismissed']
+71359;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+26728;['appeal bedismissed.']
+81061;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+94708;['appeal is dismissed']
+121416;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+54525;['appeals are dismissed']
+146489;['302 (c.a.']
+132782;['rpd decision is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+135175;['confirm the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87785;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+64593;['appeal isallowed']
+96639;['appeal of jameelah yaqo is dismissed']
+72613;['appeal is allowed in law']
+48292;['appeal is dismissed']
+123930;['appeal is allowed']
+92804;['appeal fails']
+42453;['appeal is allowed']
+100951;['appeal is allowed']
+85322;['appeal is allowed']
+132365;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+31984;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95813;['appeal is dismissed']
+128880;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+46996;['appeal is dismissed']
+95778;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding in this regard is reasonable']
+52943;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+123388;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+123981;['substitutes its own determination', 'appellants are persons in need of protection']
+85506;['appeal is dismissed']
+61324;['rad cannot substitute a decision']
+60889;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+67651;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+50249;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87705;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+96312;['appeals were dismissed']
+16758;['allow the minister’s application for dismissal of the appeal']
+112788;['three appeals are therefore dismissed']
+150936;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+39051;['appeal is dismissed']
+71485;['appeal is allowed']
+140557;['application is therefore dismissed']
+152236;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105298;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+76278;['appeal is dismissed']
+68279;['appeal isallowed']
+92758;['allows the appeals', 'dismisses the appeals']
+151305;['rad is unable to substitute its own determination for the rpd’s determination', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+104184;['allow the appeal,']
+74871;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+110909;['appellant is a convention refugee or a protected person']
+21299;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+104371;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+19152;['dismiss the present appeal']
+111160;['determination of the rpd cannot stand and must be set aside']
+97328;['appeal is allowed']
+105860;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+104090;['302 (c.a.']
+97227;['appeal is dismissed']
+84613;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+108683;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87234;['appeal of amarjeet singh sihota is allowed']
+91158;['appeal is dismissed']
+97946;['appeal were dismissed']
+114303;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+67684;['appeal is allowed']
+104052;['appeal is dismissed']
+78090;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+47816;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+105663;['appeal is allowed']
+60971;['appeals are allowed']
+132373;['appeals that refusal to the immigration appeal division (iad']
+110280;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+133363;['appeal is allowed']
+59777;['appeal is terminated']
+142805;['appeal is allowed']
+59824;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+47676;['dismissing the appeal']
+82207;['application was dismissed']
+147727;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94187;['appeal is terminated']
+57074;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+93019;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+124711;['appeal is allowed']
+101566;['appeal is dismissed']
+86315;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+98576;['appeal is allowed']
+64032;['vo’s decision is valid in law']
+132301;['thatxxxx xxxxis excluded from refugee protection']
+98057;['rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'substitutes its determination to the effect that the appellant is a “convention refugee”']
+99486;['appeal is dismissed']
+95333;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+68317;['dismiss the appeal']
+130012;['theirs are rejected']
+146432;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74467;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+74870;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+145855;['appeal is allowed']
+94233;['appeal isallowed']
+92606;['reject him claim']
+125630;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100026;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+76084;['uphold the legal validity', 'dismiss the appeal']
+45235;['appeal of kulwant singh sivia is dismissed']
+94976;['appeal is allowed']
+132749;['appeal is dismissed']
+107636;['appeal is dismissed']
+87033;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+24450;['appeal is dismissed']
+68909;['appeal is allowed']
+95450;['appeal is dismissed']
+61546;['appeal is dismissed']
+82803;['appeal must fail']
+103609;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+152009;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145748;['appellant has not lost her']
+120824;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+150614;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+69483;['appeal is dismissed']
+100134;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+109626;['302 (c.a.']
+95005;['appeal is dismissed']
+90855;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82069;['appeal is allowed']
+85929;['appeal is allowed']
+107094;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+113243;['appeal is allowed']
+124926;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71271;['appeal was dismissed']
+84497;['appeal is allowed']
+40110;['appeal is allowed']
+87402;['appeal is allowed']
+108816;['claims are rejected']
+131758;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100030;['negative']
+68708;['appeal is allowed']
+13974;['appeal is determined']
+84517;['appeal is allowed.the']
+65093;['appeal is allowed']
+146445;['appeal is dismissed']
+122100;['302 (c.a.']
+129409;['appeal is allowed']
+27589;['appeal is allowed']
+100745;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+62945;['appeal isallowed']
+101433;['panel finds that the immigration officer’s decision is legally valid']
+76424;['appeal is terminated']
+97027;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52368;['appeal is allowed']
+94496;['appeal is dismissed']
+90935;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirm the determination of the refugee protection division']
+100167;['claimants are excluded from refugee protection']
+85543;['appeal is allowed']
+76309;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47300;['appeal is allowed']
+128262;['appeal isallowed']
+17140;['allow the present appeal']
+76963;['panel finds that the decision of the visa officer is correct']
+98412;['appeal is allowed']
+87186;['appeal is allowed']
+70213;['appeal isallowed']
+42288;['appeal is dismissed']
+60956;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+97789;['favourable decision is appended to these reasons']
+83646;['appeal is allowed']
+71415;['appeal is allowed']
+91624;['appeal is terminated']
+98061;['negative']
+97521;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+57556;['appeal of george kaniyara cyriac is allowed']
+69621;['appeal isallowed']
+52718;['xxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+17968;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+78006;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+99454;['appeal isallowed']
+93804;['negative']
+21304;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of canada’s protection', 'confirm the determination of the refugee protection division']
+100137;['appeal is allowed']
+130687;['appeal isallowed.the']
+46041;['appeal being dismissed']
+43397;['appeal is allowed']
+143147;['rad substitutes its decision for that of the rpd', 'determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+143167;['appeal is to be considered perfected']
+96491;['appeal isallowed']
+80200;['the claim fails']
+95147;['xxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx are not in need of refugee protection']
+64852;['i agree with and accept the recommendation']
+68435;['appeal is allowed']
+91419;['appeal is terminated']
+91705;['appeal is allowed']
+71145;['appeal is allowed']
+113276;['appeal is dismissed']
+99858;['application is denied']
+67171;['appeal is dismissed']
+124954;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87682;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+83029;['appeal is allowed']
+62720;['dismiss the respondent’s application']
+22126;['judical review application was dismissed']
+47154;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+143584;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is allowed']
+76545;['appeal isallowed']
+69397;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+144011;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91353;['appeal is terminated']
+46391;['appeal is allowed']
+110982;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+24494;['appeal is allowed.the']
+111101;['appeal is dismissed']
+98242;['appeal will proceed']
+140251;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+26760;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+85872;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101701;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+64301;['appeal cannot be allowed']
+125633;['appeal is allowed']
+71387;['appeal be dismissed']
+92784;['appeal is dismissed']
+93877;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+102903;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84294;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+59143;['…] \xa0”']
+124670;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+97777;['sponsor must first qualify as a sponsor.']
+75987;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+50768;['appeal must be dismissed']
+81216;['appeal is dismissed']
+144723;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95659;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98276;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94291;['appeal is referred to a full hearing']
+72170;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94303;['appeal abandoned']
+129136;['appeal is allowed']
+52934;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96516;['appeal isallowed']
+110908;['appeal is dismissed']
+66916;['appeal is allowed']
+101258;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis excluded']
+131711;['dismiss the appeal']
+35035;['appeal is allowed']
+69062;['appeal is allowed']
+69114;['appeal is dismissed']
+74675;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+113515;['dismiss the appeal']
+121631;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134307;['appeal is dismissed']
+77997;['appeal isallowed']
+141681;['appeal be dismissed']
+57952;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+100099;['appeal is dismissed']
+41965;['appeal is denied']
+138809;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84017;['appeal is allowed']
+123915;['appeal is dismissed']
+26996;['xxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+67172;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+151916;['appeal is allowed']
+100755;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70470;['appeal is dismissed']
+56811;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83658;['appeal is allowed']
+26954;['xxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+124186;['appellants are convention refugees']
+102052;['appeal of yons g egzabhe w. gebreal is dismissed']
+26700;['appeal must be dismissed']
+5146;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84586;['appeal is terminated']
+85490;['appeal is allowed']
+53132;['appeal isallowed']
+122929;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77072;['appeal isallowed']
+132722;['claimants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+97456;['reject their claims']
+125420;['302 (c.a.']
+87799;['appeal is dismissed']
+56936;['appeal isallowed']
+97609;['appeal is allowed']
+92241;['appeal isallowed']
+101059;['appeal is dismissed']
+70845;['appeal is dismissed']
+128150;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142447;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+52097;['appeal must therefore fail']
+151804;['appeal is dismissed']
+90610;['appeal is allowed']
+30522;['appeal of garo dermosessian isallowedin file mb4-03412']
+94248;['appeal is dismissed']
+94718;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+73044;['appeal is dismissed']
+101465;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+128363;['appeals must be dismissed']
+101873;['appeal is dismissed']
+59761;['appeal is allowed']
+89368;['appeal is allowed']
+39576;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+68586;['appeal is allowed']
+91191;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99572;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+132652;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+76181;['appeal of fayyaz mohammad is dismissed']
+122955;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+142909;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+72070;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107098;['appeal is dismissed']
+129711;['dismiss the appeal']
+58755;['appeal is dismissed']
+47342;['appeal of waseem akhtar is allowed']
+60664;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107239;['determination must therefore be set aside']
+124591;['ifas are reasonable']
+110978;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74782;['appeal isallowed']
+131918;['appeal is valid in law']
+130853;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+87415;['appeal must be dismissed']
+123422;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108718;['302 (c.a.']
+117184;['dismissing this claim']
+95902;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+138804;['appeal is dismissed']
+93780;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+101779;['appeal is allowed']
+75670;['removal order isset aside']
+52304;['appeal is dismissed']
+95183;['appeal is dismissed']
+26968;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+47119;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84315;['dismiss the appeal']
+57065;['not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+28309;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+61918;['appeal is dismissed']
+95381;['rpd decision is reasonable']
+75923;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+120713;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98170;['removal orders are set aside']
+102069;['appeal is dismissed']
+54642;['appeal is dismissed']
+90584;['allows this appeal in law']
+135174;['allow the appeal', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+92613;['xxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+22387;['appeal be dismissed']
+122555;['appeal is allowed']
+17170;['appeal isallowed']
+77836;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+145768;['you are not a convention refugee or even a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim']
+104284;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69108;['appeal is allowed']
+90733;['appeal is allowed']
+99049;['appeal is allowed']
+125024;['allow this appeal, set aside the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugee(s)”']
+69357;['appeal isallowed']
+96676;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+89861;['officer’s decision to refuse to issue a permanent resident visa is overturned']
+81826;['applications are not legally valid']
+67211;['appeal ofstephen amoahis dismissed forres judicata']
+90587;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+123774;['dismiss the appeal']
+92561;['302 (c.a.']
+142692;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107196;['application is allowed']
+68144;['appeal is dismissed']
+69588;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+63765;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+100768;['appeal is allowed']
+124934;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98326;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99737;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+76163;['negative']
+96156;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+81083;['appeal is allowed']
+94136;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+89402;['appeal is allowed.the']
+91809;['appeal is dismissed']
+92783;['appeal is dismissed']
+135934;['appeal is granted']
+87437;['appeal is allowed']
+76918;['appeal isallowed']
+96825;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+146440;['confirm the decision', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+91755;['appeal is dismissed']
+59723;['302 (c.a.']
+69657;['not find that the applicant has temporary resident status']
+65121;['appeal is allowed']
+102883;['not substitute my own determination for the rpd']
+97123;['appeal is allowed']
+105175;['appeal isdismissed.']
+26680;['appeal beallowed']
+76704;['appeals of rasham singh atwal and tarsem kaur atwal are dismissed']
+88130;['dismiss the appeal']
+101022;['allows the appeal']
+134168;['appeal is allowed']
+67782;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99507;['appeal is dismissed']
+83457;['appeal is dismissed']
+76628;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+143503;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+21936;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+93269;['appeal isdismissed.']
+97021;['negative']
+50511;['appeal of ana delfa robles gomez is allowed']
+97952;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+54171;['decisions of the immigration officer are valid in law']
+95052;['appeal is dismissed']
+24494;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142894;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+74258;['rad finds the rpd decision must be set aside']
+90774;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86030;['dismisses the appeal']
+9486;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+30626;['appeal is allowed']
+80124;['appeal is allowed']
+124591;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protectionas']
+124738;['dismiss the appeal']
+71100;['appeal is allowed']
+69656;['appeal should be dismissed']
+88079;['appeal is allowed']
+82574;['appeal is allowed']
+88849;['appeal is dismissed']
+22398;['allows this appeal']
+98140;['appeal is dismissed']
+100181;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74637;['appeal is allowed']
+144419;['claims are rejected']
+72835;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+45234;['appeal is dismissed']
+97513;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+79947;['nor a person in need of protection']
+36125;['appeal is allowed']
+133179;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+65678;['appeal is dismissed']
+67724;['appeal is dismissed']
+67582;['dismisses an appeal']
+95932;['rad therefore sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+82379;['appeal in this case is   therefore dismissed']
+70007;['appeal is terminated']
+149113;['appeal being allowed']
+35434;['appeal forfatemeh dastaviz isdismissedand']
+102952;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+116217;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neitherconventionrefugees undersection']
+103529;['appeals are dismissed']
+68096;['dismiss this appeal']
+82690;['appeal is dismissed']
+80122;['appeal is terminated']
+98806;['appeal isallowedand']
+65705;['appeal is allowed']
+95960;['appeal is allowed']
+121865;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+91700;['appeal for discretionary relief is dismissed']
+123828;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+121880;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+145062;['claimant, xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+107701;['appeal is dismissed']
+95212;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+100608;['appeal is dismissed']
+13630;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+132837;['appeal is allowed']
+81169;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+41199;['appeal is allowed']
+55121;['appeal is dismissed']
+99298;"[""rad confirms the rpd's determination"", 'appellants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']"
+50477;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+76568;['appeal isallowed']
+97823;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+96866;['appeal is terminated']
+36111;['appeal is dismissed']
+89488;['appeal isallowedand']
+97419;['negative']
+68406;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+38891;['appeal is dismissed']
+43750;['appeal isallowed']
+65625;['appeal is discontinued']
+142909;['appeal is dismissed']
+91692;['appeal is dismissed']
+105439;['appeals ofnafesa auhelala,sara farajandlena farajareallowed.']
+150845;['reject your claim']
+53866;['appeal was dismissed']
+47331;['appeal is allowed']
+46274;['appeal is terminated']
+57092;['appeal must bedismissed']
+58390;['appeal is dismissed']
+93580;['302 (c.a.)']
+66570;['appeal is allowed']
+140214;['appeal of the principal and associate appellants is granted']
+36250;['allow her appeal']
+135185;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+100037;['“convention refugees”']
+71577;['appeal isallowed']
+72810;['appeal isallowed']
+108994;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+97510;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+76932;['appeal isallowed']
+101844;['appeal is dismissed']
+105342;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+84830;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98175;['302 (c.a.']
+95035;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+103547;['appeal is dismissed']
+111104;['appeal is dismissed']
+132281;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122353;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+101555;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+57919;['appeal isallowed.the']
+89802;['appeal is allowed']
+75670;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+28303;['claim of xxxx xxxx xxxx is rejected']
+60894;['appeal is allowed']
+87965;['appeal is allowed']
+67229;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+94649;['sufficient compassionate and humanitarian grounds']
+69540;['appeal of gurdeep kaur chahal is dismissed']
+71148;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law']
+105897;['appeal is dismissed']
+102109;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87615;['appeal is allowed']
+94551;['negative']
+152822;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90077;['removal orders are set aside']
+26702;['motion of the applicant minister is granted in part']
+116779;['appeal is allowed']
+99865;['appeal of william anthony giglio is allowed']
+111290;['appeal is dismissed']
+96624;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+60383;['appeal is dismissed']
+124942;['dismiss the appeal']
+73306;['appeal is terminated']
+24463;['appeal is allowed']
+89253;['appeal is dismissed']
+87137;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+100089;['appeal is dismissed']
+122919;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76383;['appeal is allowed']
+148984;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+122903;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94368;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+96774;['appeal is allowed']
+106800;['appeal is allowed']
+89679;['appeal is allowed']
+31933;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47324;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+35063;['appeal is dismissed']
+52665;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+82577;['appeal of ebrahim esmaeelpour-ghouchan is allowed']
+100083;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96175;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+97792;['claimants are neither convention refugee nor persons in need or protection']
+77942;['appeal is dismissed']
+71799;['appeal isallowed']
+60129;['appeal is terminated']
+84734;['removal order is set aside']
+89228;['302 (c.a.)']
+71494;['appeal is allowed']
+67019;['appeal is dismissed']
+129864;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+52489;['decision is well founded in law']
+105313;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56904;['adoption was not revoked']
+99170;['appeal is allowed']
+99701;['refugee protection definitions are forward-looking']
+55048;['appeal is allowed']
+94330;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125644;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+100767;['removal orders are set aside']
+122989;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72761;['appeals from the immigration appeal division are hearingde novo']
+95489;['appeal is allowed']
+128668;['’ appeals are dismissed']
+26841;['appeal is allowed']
+89835;['neither convention refugees']
+112360;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100828;['appeal is rejected']
+46511;['appeal is terminated']
+67691;['appeal was dismissed']
+89860;['negative']
+80280;['negative']
+128306;['appeal is dismissed']
+74890;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+73317;['positive decision']
+134360;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107504;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30485;['decision of the immigration officer is not legally valid concerning the applicant']
+146588;['he is not a convention refugee', 'claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+56795;['refugee protection division rejects the minor claimant’s claim to refugee protection']
+90203;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151606;['appeal is allowed']
+104070;['appeal of asrat eshetu is dismissed']
+87693;['negative']
+64238;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+84469;['appeal is allowed']
+91707;['appeal is dismissed']
+107946;['appeal is allowed']
+136074;['neither the objective evidence']
+84556;['appeal is dismissed']
+102901;['appeal isallowed']
+70466;['dismiss the appeal']
+61325;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150757;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection', 'appeal is hereby dismissed']
+129852;['visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+133242;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97612;['appeal is allowed']
+71235;['appeal is allowed']
+108460;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+96335;['appeal is dismissed']
+96947;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+27232;['appeal is allowed']
+93932;['appeal is allowed']
+80847;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+96207;['appeal is dismissed']
+89826;['302 (c.a.']
+81130;['appeals are therefore allowed']
+83539;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+71069;['claimants,xxxxxxxxxx,xxxxxxxxxx,xxxxxxxxxx,xxxxxxxxxx,xxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxx, not to be convention refugees and not to be persons in need of protection', 'i reject their claims']
+96292;['appeals are dismissed']
+29710;['appeal is dismissed']
+110971;['302 (c.a.']
+114319;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89278;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+37851;['appeal is not allowed']
+47177;['appeal be dismissed']
+87064;['302 (c.a.']
+76669;['appeal isallowed']
+101802;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+38765;['appeal is dismissed']
+77890;['negative']
+76758;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+31980;['appeal is allowed']
+67351;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+87399;['appeal isallowed']
+142965;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'not “convention refugees”']
+124922;['dismiss the appeal']
+98782;['appeal isallowed']
+9490;['appeals are dismissed']
+87339;['appeal isallowed']
+75919;['appeal is dismissed']
+94384;['appeal is allowed']
+76255;['appeal is dismissed']
+99833;['appeal is dismissed']
+99897;['appeals are accordingly dismissed']
+76049;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+95376;['allow this appeal']
+125692;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76411;['appeal should be dismissed']
+96667;['negative']
+100402;['appeal is dismissed']
+64213;['allow the refugee protection claim']
+107609;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69383;['negative']
+86369;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+24247;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92529;['appeal is allowed']
+135889;['appeal is dismissed']
+63116;['thatxxxxx-xxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+101523;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+77448;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+129910;['appeal was dismissed']
+88819;['i agree with and accept the recommendation']
+55876;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+37837;['appeal is allowed']
+62258;['negative']
+143001;['appeal is allowed']
+132358;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+98655;['claimants,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+79875;['appeal is allowed']
+69599;['appeal is allowed in law']
+13753;['appeal abandoned']
+90093;['their claims fail']
+99183;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71369;['appeal is dismissed']
+102552;['appeal is allowed']
+147778;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+69096;['appeal of shu kan kwok is allowed']
+133243;['appeal is allowed']
+71257;['appeal is dismissed']
+98509;['removal order is set aside']
+37438;['immigration appeal division, therefore, orders your removal from canada']
+133362;['set aside the negative determination']
+96019;['rad confirms the finding of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105881;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will stand']
+126425;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87083;['appeal is allowed']
+82443;['appeal is allowed']
+142742;['appeal were dismissed']
+61802;['claimant is not a convention refugees and not a person in need of protection']
+94712;['appeal of gret long dy lounh isdismissed.']
+108060;['request for an oral hearing is dismissed']
+75900;['appeal is dismissed']
+129120;['appeal isallowed']
+96342;['appeal isallowed']
+102536;['appeal is dismissed']
+91269;['appeal of phoxay chanthalangsy is dismissed']
+56880;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+76147;['appeal is allowed']
+130011;['claim is rejected']
+81239;['appeal is allowed']
+57563;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+69498;['appeal is allowed in law']
+93647;['appeal isallowed']
+79718;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+96482;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+42335;['dismiss the present appeal']
+91813;['appeal is dismissed']
+96655;['negative']
+91614;['allow the present appeal and']
+134305;['appeal is allowed.the']
+26688;['appeal beupheldin law']
+101675;['appeal is dismissed']
+99615;['appeal of kam shuen wong is dismissed']
+121480;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+51046;['appeal is dismissed']
+75706;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse to issue a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+107262;['appeal is allowed']
+93327;['appeal is dismissed']
+23081;['appeal is allowed']
+147780;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+127358;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee']
+78676;['appeal isallowed']
+62189;['negative']
+82890;['refusal is not valid in law']
+114353;['302 (c.a.']
+129885;['appeal is dismissed']
+22685;['appeal is dismissed']
+98548;['dismiss this appeal']
+109289;['rad dismisses the appeal of the appellant', 'upholds the decision of the rpd']
+87589;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+107881;['claim of xxxx xxxx is rejected']
+56637;['appeal is dismissed']
+60997;['appeal is dismissed']
+151480;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+50922;['decision is well-founded in law']
+64613;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+52165;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee']
+87043;['appeal is dismissed']
+36613;['appeal is allowed']
+62958;['appeal be allowed']
+151556;['appeal was dismissed', 'dismiss this application']
+99898;['appeal is dismissed']
+87301;['claimant’s claim fails']
+100431;['appeal is allowed']
+131013;['appeal is allowed']
+135127;['appeal is allowed']
+127413;['appeal is allowed']
+90583;['appeal is dismissed']
+103899;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+52326;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither \xa0convention refugees nor \xa0persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+123695;['rpd’s decision is upheld']
+85523;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124736;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+91681;['appeal is dismissed']
+76696;['appeal is dismissed']
+49072;['appeal is allowed']
+74264;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+89390;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+107660;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100675;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+110717;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81258;['appeal is allowed.the']
+131141;['appeal is allowed']
+72180;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+7588;['uphold the decision of the visa office']
+45170;['appeal of paramveer singh brar is allowed in law']
+80546;['appeal is terminated']
+103907;['appeal was dismissed']
+133265;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97343;['appeal is allowed']
+128668;['appeal is allowed']
+65133;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+102700;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+95657;['appeal is terminated']
+94805;['application is denied']
+87040;['appeal was dismissed']
+107146;['appeal must fail']
+81068;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+94405;['appeal is dismissed']
+118149;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55343;['appeal isallowed']
+70949;['claimant is not in need of refugee protection']
+138829;['appeal is allowed']
+63162;['appeal is terminated']
+146047;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+92740;['appeal isallowed']
+98963;['appeal is dismissed']
+95616;['panel rejects this claim']
+136714;['appeal is allowed']
+97500;['neither convention refugees']
+99935;['panel denies her claim for convention refugee status']
+60664;['appeal is allowed.the']
+40139;['appeal was dismissed']
+93704;['orders your departure fromcanada.']
+70188;['appeal is dismissed']
+71200;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+82984;['claimant is convention refugee']
+23101;['appeal is dismissed']
+100945;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125359;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+134181;['appeal is allowed']
+94367;['appeal is allowed']
+95737;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95384;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94924;['appeal is allowed']
+103451;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+127408;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+122845;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+89748;['appeal is allowed']
+125630;['appeal is allowed']
+51712;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factor']
+46525;['302 (c.a.)']
+100125;['appeal will be allowed']
+13768;['appeal is dismissed']
+72910;['appellant has lost her permanent residence status']
+124826;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134290;['appeal is dismissed']
+69685;['appeal is allowed']
+81082;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97234;['appeal is terminated']
+64840;['appeal is dismissed']
+142487;['appellants are not refugees or pips as they']
+105430;['appeal is allowed']
+65674;['pardon is subsequently revoked']
+76563;['appeal isallowed.the']
+107504;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+89021;['appeal is dismissed']
+100820;['appeal is allowed']
+93550;['appeal is allowed']
+145072;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+53444;['appeals be dismissed']
+60415;['appeal is dismissed']
+61463;['appeal isallowed']
+107933;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute the determination']
+48293;['appeal is dismissed']
+105208;['appeal is allowed']
+47805;['appeal isallowed']
+38900;['appeal is allowed']
+82890;['appeal is allowed']
+102723;['appellants are not refugeessur placeand']
+142842;['removal order is set aside']
+102015;['appeal be dismissed']
+101907;['favourable decision is therefore attached']
+100252;['appeal is dismissed']
+121443;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+146824;['appeal of the principal appellant and adult associate appellant is allowed']
+66938;['allow the appeal']
+72595;['appeal isallowed']
+5157;['appeals should be dismissed']
+152902;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+67401;['appeal is dismissed']
+131231;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+74357;['appeal is dismissed']
+92343;['refugee protection division accepts his claim']
+128383;['appeal is dismissed']
+68296;['appeal isallowed']
+80796;['appeal is allowed']
+133366;['therpd’s negative determination is set aside']
+98145;['appeal isallowed']
+82995;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+106937;['appeals are dismissed']
+87154;['appeal is allowed']
+49740;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a claim for refugee protection']
+92072;['appeal is dismissed']
+88067;['appeal is allowed']
+87739;['appeal were dismissed']
+151308;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69460;['negative']
+112395;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+42001;['appellants are not permanent residents', 'appeals are dismissed']
+70653;['appeal is terminated']
+76749;['appeal is allowed']
+99270;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74067;['appeal is dismissed']
+143896;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128181;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+91197;['appeal is allowed']
+100165;['not a person in need of protection']
+67935;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+69382;['negative']
+73052;['302 (c.a.']
+52370;['appeal is allowed']
+128158;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+93667;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+17968;['appeal isallowed']
+71041;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx,is not a convention refugee']
+151503;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76250;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88180;['panel therefore rejects their claims']
+99789;['appeal is dismissed']
+108719;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+95184;['appeal is allowed']
+52097;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87405;['appeal isdismissed.']
+42453;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69792;['appeal is dismissed']
+61319;['302 (c.a.']
+138879;['appeal is allowed']
+54752;['allow the appeal']
+116816;['appeal is dismissed']
+92692;['appeal is dismissed']
+26734;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+143877;['302 (c.a.']
+54680;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors', 'appeal is allowed']
+148054;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+66309;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89280;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+71256;['appeal is allowed']
+84712;['appeal is terminated']
+26748;['appeal is allowed']
+108188;['rad supports the finding of the rpd']
+83682;['appeal is rejected']
+62120;['appeal isterminated']
+93282;['ms.xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'nor is she a “person in need or protection']
+67728;['appeal is allowed']
+87606;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+146940;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60322;['appeal is dismissed']
+145237;['neither the applicable case law', 'nor theconventionstates that the claimantmustclaim in a safe third country']
+89806;['appeal is allowed']
+98530;['appeal is allowed']
+54640;['appeal is dismissed']
+96029;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+141061;['appeal is allowed for the principal appellant']
+69852;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+93778;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95089;['appeal is terminated']
+60440;['appeal of saleha hayat is dismissed']
+125432;['appeals are allowed']
+99039;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for refugee protection']
+67404;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+60493;['appeal is dismissed']
+148610;['appeal is allowed']
+122238;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38245;['dismiss the appeal']
+100418;['appeal is dismissed']
+101236;['appeal is allowed']
+136081;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+106755;['appeal of larry nguyen is allowed']
+135115;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61880;['appeal is terminated.subsection']
+26797;['appeal is dismissed']
+84489;['appeal is allowed']
+68169;['appeal of kiranjeet sidhu is allowed']
+132764;['appeal is allowed']
+15583;['appeal is allowed']
+90959;['appeals are dismissed']
+131521;['appeal is dismissed']
+76850;['appeal is allowed']
+97597;['appeal is dismissed']
+96888;['appeals are allowed.the']
+98863;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+94249;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+22389;['appeal is allowed']
+76246;['reject this explanation']
+126398;['appeal is dismissed']
+100604;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+22711;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+78040;['appeal is dismissed']
+124160;['appeal is allowed']
+148646;['appeal is dismissed']
+113251;['appeal is allowed']
+90960;['appeal is dismissed']
+71673;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+108811;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+149483;['rad dismisses the appellant’s explanations']
+93068;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+15579;['appeal is allowed']
+100922;['302 (c.a.']
+86381;['appeal must fail']
+100940;['appeal is allowed']
+82376;['appeal isallowed']
+66572;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+82736;['appeal is terminated']
+85958;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+139869;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104831;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+9488;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87876;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+98418;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+80128;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+102072;['appeal is allowed']
+81206;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+142505;['appeal is allowed']
+130844;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+69936;['appeal is allowed']
+131027;['appeal is dismissed']
+89851;['claimants are not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+131539;['appeal is allowed']
+95830;['appeal is allowed']
+76322;['appeal abandoned']
+92392;['appeal is allowed']
+77893;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84421;['appeal isallowed']
+95087;['appeal is allowed']
+98492;['appeal is dismissed']
+114929;['nor a viable internal flight alternative']
+108253;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46453;['appeal is dismissed']
+99335;['favourable decision to them']
+19314;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx\xa0xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+131212;['appeal is allowed']
+87211;['claimantxxxxx xxxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+52106;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+36256;['dismiss the appeal']
+95647;['appeal is dismissed']
+37865;['appeal is dismissed']
+72012;['appeal isallowed']
+125610;['dismiss the appeal']
+77048;['negative determination is under review']
+138832;['appeal be dismissed']
+105765;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151977;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+19168;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69995;['appeal is allowed']
+97005;['302 (c.a.']
+97326;['appeals are allowed.the']
+94368;['appeals are allowed']
+92764;['removal order is set aside']
+76015;['appeal is allowed']
+73355;['removal order isset aside']
+123965;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm, for different reasons', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62828;['appeal abandoned']
+23017;['appeal is dismissed']
+86058;['appeal is dismissed']
+87944;['appeal is allowed']
+87083;['302 (c.a.)']
+151813;['appeal is allowed']
+67215;['appeal is allowed']
+95116;['negative']
+87426;['allow this appeal']
+151863;['appeal is dismissed']
+52252;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98285;['appeal is dismissed']
+5592;['appeal is determined']
+92987;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+43404;['appeal is allowed']
+92277;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140954;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106339;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70207;['appeal is allowed']
+86026;['appeal is dismissed']
+56510;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95271;['appeal is terminated']
+84764;['appeal isallowed']
+89103;['rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+43604;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71152;['appeal isallowed']
+90217;['appeal is terminated']
+117184;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+87372;['appellant has not lost her']
+107486;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd’s decision', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+98554;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not losthispermanent resident status']
+128422;['appeal of mesfin gebreeigziabiher is dismissed']
+106328;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+97314;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133388;['appeal is allowed']
+105313;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+92778;['appeal is allowed']
+60367;['appeal is dismissed']
+104115;['you are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'i reject your claims']
+106399;['panel confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+124807;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69442;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject her claim']
+45419;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+128881;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88262;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+85393;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+103694;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of   ']
+98350;['appeal isallowed']
+128914;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121456;['appeal would be dismissed']
+39899;['appeal of nancy nkeiru ajaero is allowed']
+90204;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+26745;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+86341;['appeal is allowed']
+99097;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+60466;['appeal is allowed accordingly']
+103018;['dismissing the appeal']
+95589;['appeal is allowed']
+47370;['appeal is allowed']
+85608;['appeal is terminated']
+94765;['appeal is allowed']
+93057;['appellants are convention refugees']
+89106;['appeal is allowed']
+26739;['appeal respecting aisha merlyn t. siddiqi is allowed in law']
+108703;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91316;['appeal is thus allowed']
+131011;['immigration officer’s decision is therefore valid in law']
+78190;['appeal is allowed']
+100030;['302 (c.a.)']
+79984;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+84017;['appeal isallowed']
+63126;['302 (c.a.']
+63909;['panel finds that the refusal is valid in law']
+140859;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83196;['appeal is dismissed']
+84744;['appeal isallowed.the']
+62890;['negative']
+18009;['appeals are dismissed']
+85233;['appeal turns on']
+85971;['302 (c.a.']
+77228;['appeal of the elder son, xitij rajeshkumar shah, is declared abandoned']
+84319;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+31389;['appeal of nnaemeka joseph maduekwe is allowed']
+121938;['’ basis of claims']
+98394;['tribunal allows the appeal']
+100820;['allow the appeal']
+26859;"['not a ""convention refugee']"
+151830;['appeal is dismissed']
+94076;['appeal is dismissed']
+76959;['appeal isallowed']
+74574;['appeal is dismissed']
+30543;['removal order isset aside']
+98984;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+140725;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+70421;['appeal is allowed']
+67361;['appeal is dismissed']
+91774;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+111287;['appeal is allowed']
+90896;['302 (c.a.']
+151584;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69265;['departures orders are set aside']
+95460;['appeal is dismissed']
+93817;['constitution establishes the country as a secular state']
+97818;['negative']
+82423;['appeal isallowed']
+99122;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+99714;['appeal is dismissed']
+95208;['appeal terminated']
+148998;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+111325;['appeal is dismissed']
+121437;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+111006;['appeal is allowed']
+85484;['appeal is allowed']
+54179;['appeal should be allowed']
+45217;['appeal of lo sang is dismissed']
+107587;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+23106;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+79473;['appeal be dismissed']
+125651;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+47139;['appeal is dismissed']
+69344;['appeal isallowed']
+103452;['upholds the rpd’s overall finding']
+98321;['claimant is not in need of protection']
+132296;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+55972;['application to reopen the appeal is denied']
+108713;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97413;['negative']
+74126;['appeal is allowed']
+142472;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50733;['appeal is allowed']
+55124;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+100957;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+76296;['appeal is allowed']
+13975;['appellant has not lost her']
+93270;['appeal is dismissed']
+97125;['appeal isallowed']
+146922;['appeal is allowed']
+81131;['removal order is set aside']
+63826;['appeal is allowed']
+81616;['appeal was allowed']
+90851;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision']
+69223;['appeal is allowed']
+58113;['appeal is dismissed']
+19142;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+129187;['appeal is allowed.the']
+102118;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95481;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+77851;['claimants are not persons in need of state protection']
+99682;['appeal of michelle maureen greer is dismissed']
+93807;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+67474;['appeal isallowed']
+78668;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+69621;['appeal is allowed']
+87856;['negative']
+94647;['appeal isallowed']
+95928;['ifa fails']
+47777;['appeal fails']
+143137;['appeal is dismissed']
+80094;['appeal isallowed']
+123684;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129189;['appeal isallowed']
+99270;['appeal is allowed']
+123042;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91144;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+76732;['appeal is allowed']
+100954;['appeal is allowed']
+96733;['appeal is dismissed']
+122112;['appeal is allowed']
+104146;['claim is rejected']
+45862;['appeal is dismissed']
+94834;['appeal is dismissed']
+95045;['appeal isallowedand']
+100127;['appeal being allowed']
+26869;['xxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+87736;['appeal is allowed']
+98871;['appeal must be dismissed']
+100069;['302 (c.a.']
+71811;['dismissing the appeal']
+95913;['rad finds this argument to be without merit']
+63171;['appeal is terminated']
+73362;['appeals are dismissed']
+76831;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+114410;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+99474;['claim is rejected']
+94220;['appeal is allowed']
+73026;['appeal of claudia marisol agafitei is dismissed']
+11461;['appeal is dismissed']
+125124;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+124646;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+140266;['panel rejects the refugee protection claims']
+142902;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+85503;['appeal of the refusal']
+83870;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93288;['dismisses this appeal']
+109711;['appeal is allowed']
+125050;['302 (c.a.']
+94113;['appeal isallowed.the']
+99568;['appeal is dismissed']
+102386;['appeal is allowed']
+134359;['appeal is allowed']
+71206;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+111173;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88083;['appeal is allowed']
+90236;['neither a convention refugee nor a person described insection 97of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+90489;['appeal is allowed both in law']
+106941;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+92544;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+145818;['appeal fails']
+101296;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+143035;['reject their claims']
+81620;['appeal is dismissed']
+62884;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+146880;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79974;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+56993;['refugee protection division finds thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+71449;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+105639;['confirms the decision of the rpd']
+101508;['appeal succeeds on that standard']
+71462;['allow his appeal.']
+69732;['appeal isallowed']
+122126;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+143572;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+98654;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+91377;['appeal is allowed']
+100100;['appeal is dismissed']
+96141;['allowed the appeal']
+94608;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+47390;['appeals are allowed']
+75943;['appeal isallowed']
+129229;['appeal is allowed']
+79235;['appeal is dismissed']
+136664;['application to admit new evidence is denied']
+49238;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98373;['appeal is dismissed']
+82710;"[""children are not part of the applicant's application""]"
+131205;['appeal is allowed']
+146451;['appeal is allowed']
+104100;['claimant, xxxx xxxx,not to be   a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+90125;['claims are therefore dismissed']
+89282;['appeal is terminated']
+143233;['appeal was dismissed']
+21452;['refugee division determines that xxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+80667;['refugee protection claim of xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx is rejected']
+94371;['allow the appeal']
+108190;['dismisses the appeal']
+86633;['appeal were dismissed']
+39031;['appeal is dismissed']
+135506;['protection is rejected']
+130971;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+75910;['appeal offoday kabbais dismissed']
+52921;['dismiss this appeal']
+101550;['appeal is allowed']
+150656;['appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+61864;['appeal is dismissed']
+70890;['allow the appeal']
+121645;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97891;['appeal is dismissed']
+56947;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+96159;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91600;['appeal is allowed']
+62461;['appeal is allowed']
+74875;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+76147;['appeal is allowed']
+106472;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision was not based on the issue of']
+141159;['appeal is dismissed']
+76017;['dismisses the appeal']
+107646;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+93769;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+72593;['appeal is dismissed']
+108342;['appeal isallowed']
+62437;['appeal is allowed']
+142522;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143536;['appeal is allowed']
+98628;['appeal is allowed']
+52715;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx\xa0 is not a convention refugee']
+102160;['appeal is allowed']
+94193;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+141059;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+89161;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+60929;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction to hear this appeal']
+94687;['appeal is allowed']
+84221;['appeal is allowed']
+93316;['appeal of khanh an is allowed']
+96626;['302 (c.a.']
+85500;['appeal is allowed']
+131529;['appeal is dismissed']
+113221;['irpa allows for family class sponsorships']
+128597;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+98545;['appeal isallowedand']
+101614;['appeal is denied']
+123854;['appeal is allowed']
+102916;['allow the appeal']
+46061;['302 (c.a.)']
+81375;['claimant’s claim fail']
+23085;['appeal is allowed']
+90704;['appeal is allowed']
+95217;['302 (c.a.']
+113634;['appeal should be allowed']
+76098;['appeals chung ming lai, shu ching lai yang']
+124719;['dismiss the appeal']
+52716;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+49715;['negative']
+101987;['officer’s decision to refuse the permanent resident visa is set aside']
+30522;['removal order isset aside']
+23055;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+57476;['appeal isallowed']
+66201;['appeal is allowed']
+75706;['appeal isallowed']
+132382;['appeal is allowed']
+151623;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47749;['appeal isallowed']
+81090;['appeal is dismissed']
+99886;['appeal is dismissed']
+34989;['immigration appeal division, therefore orders the appellant’s departure from canada']
+106611;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68267;['appeal isallowed']
+96322;['nor community support']
+96102;['not a convention\xa0']
+90810;['302 (c.a.']
+72638;['appeal is allowed']
+80753;['appeal is dismissed']
+133370;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81628;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+138846;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+83646;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91603;['appeal is allowed']
+96487;['302 (c.a.']
+50921;['appeal is terminated']
+99841;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+56938;['appeal is dismissed']
+54547;['appeal isallowed']
+151781;['iad orders your departure from canada']
+68174;['appeal of adebayo moruf adegbola is dismissed']
+67408;['appeal isallowed']
+123434;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+12229;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+120815;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141401;['appeal is dismissed']
+145856;['appeal is allowed']
+47711;['appeal isallowed']
+95480;['appeal is dismissed']
+146969;['dismiss the appellant’s application']
+114410;['dismiss the appeal']
+122220;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+97949;['not a convention refugee or a persons in need of protection', 'reject their claim']
+146562;['rad sets aside the rpd determination']
+102680;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80016;['negative']
+108902;['claimants, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx, are not convention refugees,', 'division rejects their claims']
+47716;['appeal is allowed both in law and on discretionary grounds']
+107238;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appeal is dismissed']
+71194;['appeal is allowed']
+89113;['claimants are not “persons in need of protection']
+149490;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98213;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+80784;['appeal is dismissed']
+105640;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+123405;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+50760;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+105194;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+62865;['appeal is terminated']
+123406;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+120761;['not substitute my own decision']
+123898;['neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150727;['allow this appeal']
+61481;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+74722;['302 (c.a.']
+150709;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+76803;['302 (c.a.']
+71124;['dismiss the appeal']
+96241;['appeal is dismissed']
+96920;['appeal is allowed']
+97513;['négative']
+62887;['appeal isallowed']
+71275;['appeal isdismissed.']
+38843;['dismisses this appeal']
+146071;['sur place claim are rejected']
+86642;['appeal is dismissed']
+92550;['appeal is allowed']
+36111;['appeal is dismissed']
+144391;['negative determination is under review']
+95645;['appeals are allowed']
+105445;['appeal is allowed']
+93011;['reject these explanations']
+131158;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+45409;['appeal is determined']
+139458;['appeal is dismissed']
+98521;['appeal is allowed']
+98196;"[""claimant is not a 'convention refugee""]"
+68219;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+84550;['appeal is terminated']
+122809;['allow the appeal, set aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitute it with the determination']
+127435;['appeal be dismissed']
+21396;['claimants, xxxxxx, xxxxx, xxxxx, xxxxxxxx, and xxxxxxxxx, are convention refugees']
+79947;['302 (c.a.']
+75653;['decisions of the immigration division are set aside']
+86389;['allow his appeal in law']
+110679;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+82729;['appeal is dismissed']
+102801;['allowed the appeal']
+73890;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88122;['appeal is dismissed']
+63001;['appeal isallowed']
+129184;['appeal is deemed to be abandoned']
+91230;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100487;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+129991;['application for reinstatement of the appeal is allowed']
+101525;['appeal be dismissed']
+24510;['appeal is allowed']
+94614;['appeal is therefore granted']
+125474;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130986;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is excluded from canada’s protection', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+62830;['appeal were dismissed']
+88850;['appeal is dismissed']
+96377;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+96522;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+58115;['appeal is dismissed']
+97377;['appeal is allowed']
+100450;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare excluded from protection']
+133730;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+61455;['appeal has been abandoned']
+15430;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+100074;['appeal dismissed']
+92491;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+135188;['appeal is allowed']
+104260;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+147471;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67742;['appeal is allowed in law']
+88093;['appeal is allowed']
+60999;['appeal is allowed']
+123731;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+81852;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98669;['appeal is allowed']
+89353;['appeal is terminated']
+103459;['negative determination is under review']
+63832;['appeal is dismissed']
+82184;['appelant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+149574;['rad substitutes its decision for that of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+125637;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47299;['appeal is allowed']
+69502;['application is denied']
+84869;['appeal is dismissed']
+63723;['appeal is denied']
+129855;['appeal is dismissed']
+83508;['appeals are dismissed']
+129215;['appeal is allowed']
+89306;['not convention refugees nor are they in need of protection']
+102543;['officer’s decision should be set aside']
+103611;['302 (c.a.']
+90110;['negative']
+104977;['appeal is allowed']
+87068;['appeals are allowed']
+96238;['appeal is dismissed']
+146553;['dismiss the claim']
+148489;['appeal is dismissed']
+138888;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+87949;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130855;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78025;['appeal of michael robert nichols is dismissed']
+76821;['appeal is dismissed']
+69402;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution', 'claimants are notconvention refugees']
+40799;['appeal is allowed']
+136702;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108725;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121383;['302 (c.a.']
+118266;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+124606;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+94894;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+81266;['appeal isdismissed.']
+71067;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+78057;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+144243;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+106270;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108251;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+47163;['appeal isterminated']
+145292;['panel rejects her claim']
+83718;['appeal is dismissed']
+73203;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95494;['thepanel finds the removal order valid in law']
+70472;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+128389;['appeal is dismissed']
+56611;['appeal isallowedand']
+138888;['rad agrees with rpd and finds that the decision of the rpd to proceed was not an error']
+105204;['appeal is dismissed']
+139420;['appeal isallowed']
+72626;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+109574;['appeal is allowed']
+95218;['appeal is dismissed']
+91087;['appeal is dismissed']
+96175;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+144932;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76803;['appeal is allowed']
+47104;['appeal were dismissed']
+125091;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+42431;['appeal is dismissed']
+63759;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+146856;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant and female associate appellant are convention refugees']
+98543;['appeal is allowed']
+58107;['appeal is dismissed']
+38781;['application dated december 1, 2014 is allowed.the']
+87610;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+152869;['claim is rejected']
+82369;['appeal is dismissed']
+97433;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+68146;['appeal is dismissed']
+101299;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+31998;['appeal is dismissed']
+132727;['claimants are excluded from refugee protection']
+122687;['appeal is dismissed']
+38163;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+52135;['appeal is allowed']
+94993;['appeal is terminated']
+83033;['appeal is terminated']
+52476;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+92337;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+143571;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+144395;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145429;['appeal is allowed']
+102974;['appeal is allowed']
+21327;['you are not a convention refugee']
+87977;['claim is rejected']
+123540;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84307;['appeal isallowed']
+125523;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+46523;['appeal is allowed']
+152947;['appeal is dismissed']
+41568;['appealis allowed']
+77838;['panel rejects the claims ofxxxxx xxxxx']
+31965;['appeal is dismissed']
+140703;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+53441;['appeal is dismissed']
+17937;['appeal is dismissed']
+125215;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+66304;['dismisses the appeal']
+122991;['substitute my own decision that mr. k is convention refugee']
+71460;['appeal isallowed']
+61012;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+79757;['appeal is terminated']
+63520;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+100404;['leave that aside']
+84477;['appeal of buta singh is dismissed']
+73871;['appeal is dismissed']
+92515;['appeal isallowed']
+63563;['appeal of teofila v. baculi is allowed']
+93690;['allow the appeal,']
+40126;['determination is legally valid']
+123829;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+54636;['appeal is allowed']
+88167;['appeal is allowed']
+100804;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+84660;['302 (c.a.']
+128409;['appeal is dismissed']
+69090;['appeal of bhupinder singh sandhu is allowed']
+68097;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+105912;['allow the appeal']
+144240;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87826;['claimant’s claim fails']
+94574;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+100441;['appeal is dismissed']
+47778;['appeal is allowed']
+89883;['iad declines to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction']
+127712;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+145748;['appeal is allowed']
+95898;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+115278;['appeal is allowed']
+50521;['removal order is set aside']
+140813;['rad finds the rpd’s error to be fatal to its determination']
+150242;['appeal is allowed']
+148670;['dismiss the appeal']
+106428;['appeal is dismissed']
+19312;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+55310;['removal orders are set aside']
+71396;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+98438;['appeal is terminated']
+68308;['appeal is allowed']
+54193;['appeal is allowed']
+132309;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76713;['appeal is allowed']
+53835;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+136672;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+84873;['appeal is allowed']
+134289;['appeal is allowed']
+145025;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98453;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+135913;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+81013;['appeal is dismissed']
+52156;['claimants are convention refugees']
+59553;['appeal is dismissed']
+89950;['dismiss the appeal']
+100470;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+115230;['appeal is dismissed']
+103055;['appeal is dismissed']
+98875;['appeal is allowed']
+82769;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+131193;['appeal is allowed']
+72706;['appeal is dismissed.she', 'appeal is dismissed.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+68540;['allow the appeal']
+150659;['appeal is allowed']
+142727;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+54289;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+87440;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a person in need of protection']
+132821;['appeal is dismissed']
+69854;['appeal is denied']
+62959;['appeal is allowed']
+80994;['appeal is allowed']
+151549;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxareneither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108687;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99030;['ifa fails on the first prong']
+57920;['appeal beallowed']
+50526;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+113240;['appeal be dismissed']
+99203;['appeal is allowed']
+76598;['appeal is dismissed']
+72072;['appeal must be dismissed']
+24465;['appeal of run jiao dai is dismissed']
+95907;['appeal is dismissed']
+67357;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+128897;['allow the appeal', 'appellant is a person in need of protection']
+94641;['appeal is dismissed']
+80292;['negative']
+151500;['appeal is dismissed']
+76390;['appeal is allowed']
+46006;['appeal is allowed']
+46295;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+98562;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+87197;['allowed the appeal']
+105434;['appeal is allowed']
+59855;['appeal is allowed']
+131719;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+64303;['appeal is dismissed']
+49975;['appeal allowed']
+141161;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+84487;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+52302;['appeal being allowed']
+129138;['appeal is dismissed']
+114290;['appellant,xxxx xxxx,is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69127;['appeal is allowed']
+95057;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+100155;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+85846;['appeal is dismissed']
+134410;['appeal is dismissed']
+65015;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+56885;['appeal isallowed']
+80252;['claimants are not convention refugees and do not need protection']
+46535;['appeal is terminated']
+135493;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+16025;['appeal is terminated']
+81850;['appeals are allowed']
+144376;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+70093;['dismiss the application']
+89368;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+26757;['appeal bedismissed.']
+110718;['302 (c.a.']
+77917;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+62123;['application is granted']
+100826;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123054;['appeal is allowed']
+101786;['allows the application to reinstate the appeal']
+76728;['appeal is allowed']
+148623;['appeal is allowed']
+81263;['appeal is allowed']
+97430;['claimants have not met the requirement of a reasonable chance']
+99374;['appeal of anh thi ngoc tran is dismissed']
+123381;['appeal is allowed']
+143565;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+17121;['appeal is dismissed']
+80482;['appeal is allowed.the']
+68706;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+76899;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+76948;['appeal is allowed']
+87052;['allows this appeal']
+99654;['appeal is dismissed']
+127350;['appeal is allowed']
+83657;['appeal is allowed']
+56715;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+100406;['appeal is dismissed']
+108792;['appeal is allowed']
+102382;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from     ']
+98654;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113736;['rad confirms, for reasons other than the rpd']
+92377;['appeal is dismissed']
+76664;['appeal is dismissed']
+98660;['appeal of allan naguit santos is dismissed']
+113630;['appellants are not permanent residents']
+45400;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+95430;['application to extend time is denied']
+113523;['appeal is allowed']
+108255;['appeal is dismissed']
+111338;['rad has found that the rpd decision will stand']
+108806;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination']
+104978;['allow the present appeal']
+67500;['appeal isallowed']
+26870;"[""panel rules thatxxxxxxxxxxxand his spousexxxxxxxxxxxare not ''convention refugees''within""]"
+113790;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis a person described in article 1e of the convention']
+125086;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123428;['rad, pursuant', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes a decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+66254;['appeal is dismissed']
+81008;['appeal is allowed']
+146949;['appeal is allowed']
+82842;['appeal is terminated']
+29303;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+144248;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision that the', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90114;['appeal is terminated']
+91230;['appeal is dismissed']
+111362;['confirm the rpd’s finding']
+66490;['appeals of hou rong xiao and mi dong yue are allowed']
+82355;['appeal is allowed']
+142587;['theappealsare allowed']
+67563;['appeal of my phuong tan is allowed']
+142531;['appeal is allowed']
+125158;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87476;['appeal is dismissed']
+68600;['appeal is dismissed']
+71640;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+125081;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+53864;['appeal is allowed.the']
+67743;['appeal is allowed in law']
+93675;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67562;['appeal is dismissed']
+107470;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93014;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142518;['appeal is dismissed']
+96632;['appeal is allowed']
+69739;['dismisses this appeal']
+38897;['appeal is dismissed']
+67783;['appeal was dismissed']
+80667;['negative']
+30533;['appeal of isabella morales meza is dismissed']
+83646;['appeal isallowed']
+71642;['appeal isterminated']
+108821;['claim is rejected']
+96815;['rad case cited states that somali heritage']
+34884;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+89784;['dismiss the appeal']
+141679;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+92753;['appeal is deemed abandoned']
+62703;['appeal is allowed']
+85235;['panel finds the visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+84062;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+87677;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+94063;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+151910;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+21397;['not a convention refugee']
+71449;['appeal is dismissed']
+132301;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124329;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+100372;['refugee appeal division dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124265;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97463;['appeal’s relative merit']
+70941;['appeal is allowed']
+56912;['appeal fails']
+107835;['appeal is allowed']
+132428;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+60908;['appeal is allowed']
+37186;['appeal is allowed']
+98156;['appeal is allowed']
+17977;['appeal is dismissed']
+101256;['appeal is allowed']
+87447;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+77956;['application to appeal the departure order against brandon leray mcclave is denied']
+52313;['appeal is allowed']
+146872;['appeal is allowed']
+100303;['appeal isallowed']
+14712;['appeals of gholam reza monzavi-zadeh, zohreh monzavi-zadeh, hamid monzavi-zadeh, saeid monzavi-zadeh and navid monzavi- zadeh are dismissed']
+75659;['appeal brought by kevin kwan chi wong is therefore dismissed']
+72086;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is inadmissible underparagraph\xa035(1)(a) of theact']
+8969;['appeal isallowed']
+95409;['appeal is allowed']
+81921;['appeal is dismissed']
+23024;['allow this appeal']
+93779;['appeals are dismissed']
+60083;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+106616;['rad rejects it']
+94033;['appeal isallowed']
+75488;['appeal is allowed']
+99412;['appeal is allowed']
+75488;['allow her appeal']
+132782;['appeal is dismissed']
+106421;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+12218;['appeal is allowed']
+143550;['appeal is dismissed']
+95172;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+60463;['allows his appeal']
+106133;['appeal isdetermined to beabandoned']
+89752;['negative']
+71106;['appeal of esmerelda murcia reyes is dismissed']
+55197;['refugee protection claimant', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+98403;['tribunal allows the appeal']
+77316;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+85862;['negative']
+91024;['appeal of jaspreet singh jammu is dismissed']
+148430;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+129891;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+101361;['within appeal is dismissed']
+82149;['visa officer’s decision is therefore valid in law']
+141265;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+71214;['appeal is determined to be\xa0']
+146925;['appeal isallowed']
+70894;['appeal is allowed']
+52093;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+22806;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpa']
+115275;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+151900;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+81007;['appeals are allowed']
+129397;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74798;['allowed the appeal']
+140974;['302 (c.a.']
+99027;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+127721;['appeal is determined']
+102743;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+82470;['appeal is terminated']
+80513;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandonedundersubsection']
+95611;['appeal isallowed']
+98335;['appeal is allowed']
+51764;['appeal is dismissed']
+117120;['appeal would be dismissed']
+45854;['appeal is allowed']
+147438;['appeal is dismissed']
+123621;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+73887;['appeal of simardeep kainth is dismissed']
+85433;['appeal is allowed']
+73602;['dismiss the appeal']
+90928;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+98401;['appeal being allowed']
+60976;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+41791;['appeal is allowed']
+71745;['appeals will be granted']
+27296;['appeal is allowed']
+13984;['not claim a status']
+83484;['stay is not an appropriate disposition in the circumstances']
+107167;['302 (c.a.']
+150927;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+122987;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108999;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+31461;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+93124;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124085;['appeals are dismissed']
+59946;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+105613;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+58550;['appeal of mandeep kaur brar (the “appellant']
+40055;['appeal was dismissed']
+95388;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103542;['sponsorship is for the purposes of family reunification']
+94384;['decision of the visa officer to be legally valid']
+23035;['appeal isallowed']
+81051;['allows the appeal']
+68318;['appeal is dismissed']
+87423;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+96495;['allow the appeal']
+146827;['appeal is allowed']
+26692;['dismiss the appeal']
+105884;['302 (c.a.']
+122107;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+93226;['appeal must be dismissed']
+69626;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+92022;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+62957;['allow the appeal']
+46560;['application to withdraw should be dismissed']
+96387;['appeal isallowed']
+131744;['appeal is dismissed']
+71524;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+99297;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd’s decision']
+134307;['appeal is dismissed']
+75082;['appeal is allowed']
+61402;['appeal must be dismissed']
+107903;['negative determination of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+97834;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71239;['appeal is allowed']
+23100;['appeal is dismissed']
+77943;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+87055;['appeal is determined']
+66330;['appeal ofakbar ali bajwahis dismissed']
+111161;['rpd decision is hereby set aside']
+76327;['appeal is dismissed']
+91532;['appeal is allowed']
+67464;['appeal isallowed']
+81157;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+118165;['appeals are allowed']
+85910;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+95124;['appeal is dismissed']
+22818;['appeal of ian arthur marshall is dismissed']
+91566;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+121676;['appeal is allowed']
+105284;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+145530;['appeal is allowed']
+40371;['appeal is terminated']
+93658;['302 (c.a.']
+131142;['appeal isallowed']
+87788;['panel therefore rejects their refugee protection claims']
+71530;['allow his appeal']
+63095;['302 (c.a.']
+98272;['appeal dismissed']
+100816;['appeal is declaredabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+128174;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95257;['appeal is allowed']
+89293;['appeal is dismissed']
+45999;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+76436;['appeal is allowed']
+106152;['iad therefore orders your departure from canada']
+43707;['appeal isallowed']
+93768;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+151003;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136746;['rpd’s negative decision is set aside']
+39078;['appeal of simranjeet kaur brar is dismissed']
+112385;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47724;['adoption is in contravention']
+80535;['appeal must be allowed']
+70021;['stay is cancelled']
+74818;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+91165;['appeal is allowed in chambers']
+61229;['302 (c.a.']
+135178;['appeal is allowed']
+91294;['appeal isallowed.the']
+101397;['302 (c.a.']
+70195;['appeal is dismissed']
+82576;['appeal is dismissed']
+80693;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+130935;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64627;['appeal is dismissed']
+144039;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79600;['appeal is allowed']
+56928;['appeal is dismissed']
+108731;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+46993;['appeal is dismissed']
+144936;['appeal is terminated']
+128360;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95785;['appeals are dismissed']
+142887;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+82203;['appeal is allowed']
+45422;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+131528;['appeal is allowed']
+89859;['claimant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+118659;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+53447;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+143005;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+37900;['appeal is allowed.the']
+84727;['appeal isallowedand']
+122937;['appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+103659;['panel rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+99263;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+100637;['appeal is dismissed']
+36466;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+31378;['appeal is dismissed']
+57005;['favourable decision and attach it to these reasons']
+66911;['appeal is dismissed']
+109706;['appeal is allowed']
+76169;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+49199;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69506;['application is denied']
+53409;['appeal is dismissed']
+94274;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+38416;['appeal is dismissed']
+31215;['appeal were dismissed']
+94326;['appeal is dismissed']
+94525;['appeal of xiang dong fan is dismissed']
+35562;['appeal is allowed']
+145023;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of therpdthat', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69497;['dismisses the appeal']
+44973;['stay the removal order in accordance']
+51135;['pardon is subsequently revoked']
+128423;['appeal being dismissed']
+82359;['appeal isallowed']
+57911;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+67410;['appeal isallowed']
+53835;['appeal is allowed.the']
+132420;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91173;['appeal is allowed']
+148484;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+73193;['appeal is allowed']
+76036;['appeal is allowed']
+66240;['appellant is not a sponsor']
+124002;['christian converts']
+71448;['appeal is allowed']
+83483;['appeal was dismissed']
+102399;['appeal is allowed']
+66638;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+105341;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+105364;['appeal is dismissed']
+87614;['appeal isallowed']
+22997;['appeal is allowed']
+122909;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+141163;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+61346;['appeals be dismissed']
+150685;['rad allows the appeal', 'sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+146937;['rad substitutes its decision for that of the rpd', 'determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+75235;['appeal is terminated']
+99429;['claimants are convention refugees']
+62465;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110685;['302 (c.a.']
+139853;['appeal is allowed']
+74062;['appeal was allowed']
+60310;['removal orders are set aside']
+67241;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+111362;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+77906;['appeal is dismissed']
+78085;['appeal were dismissed']
+78667;['appeals are dismissed']
+75994;['visa officer’s refusal is upheld']
+132425;['rad confirms the decisions of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107901;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94537;['appeal of barbara joan chaplin is dismissed']
+72613;['appeal isallowed']
+69610;['dismiss this appeal']
+128165;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+153016;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is a “convention refugee”', 'allows her claim for refugee protection']
+98153;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69236;['appeal is dismissed']
+84762;['appeal isallowed']
+86153;['appeal is terminated']
+60412;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+87126;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+144410;['appellant, xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+150932;['302 (c.a.']
+129852;['appeal is allowed']
+132410;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+100764;['appeal is allowed']
+32165;['appeal isallowed']
+124952;['appeal is allowed']
+101270;['appeal isallowed']
+130888;['appeal is dismissed']
+96034;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+48228;['panel so orders the removal']
+70161;['appeal is allowed']
+49982;['appeal is dismissed']
+140964;['appeal is allowed in part']
+49536;['appeal is abandoned']
+99188;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+64873;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+146917;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+122828;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee']
+43400;['appeal is dismissed']
+71103;['appeal is dismissed']
+140822;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104426;['claimants are excluded']
+121395;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94237;['appeal is dismissed']
+77325;['appeal is allowed.the']
+99774;['appeal,']
+150686;['nor persons in need of protection']
+54799;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99816;['appeal is dismissed']
+87047;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+123868;['appeal is allowed']
+70097;['appeal is allowed']
+71564;['appeal must be dismissed']
+66906;['appeal isallowed']
+68552;['negative']
+83654;['dismiss the appeal']
+101442;['appeal is allowed']
+103820;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140864;['rad rejects the core of the rpd’s credibility findings']
+95376;['appeal isallowedand']
+135927;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+95824;['appeal is dismissed']
+94556;['appeal is determined']
+84245;['appeal is allowed']
+97489;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+50524;['appeal is allowed']
+100939;['appeal is dismissed']
+98881;['appeal is allowed']
+19120;['appeal is allowed.the']
+147458;['302 (c.a.']
+63922;['appeal is allowed']
+104109;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93637;['dismissing the application to re-open']
+67462;['appeal be allowed']
+106798;['appeal is dismissed']
+46490;['appeal is allowed']
+105447;['appeal is dismissed']
+102964;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not “convention refugee”']
+61212;['appeal is allowed']
+101232;['appeal isallowed.the']
+70672;['appeal is dismissed']
+47219;['appeal is allowed.the']
+95997;['appeal is allowed']
+133725;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+103093;['appeal is well documented']
+76893;['appeal isallowed']
+102872;['reject the claims of these claimants']
+124102;['appeal is dismissed']
+22766;['appeal is terminated']
+80515;['theappealis dismissed']
+108130;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90325;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+129100;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+70900;['appeal ofbenjamin yeboahis allowed']
+90897;['appellant is not established incanada']
+84553;['dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+25981;['appeal is dismissed']
+96083;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+118734;['appeal is allowed']
+100099;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108053;['rad finds that the appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+27462;['appeal isallowed']
+121408;['irpa does not permit thesection 96test to be compromised']
+134158;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69424;['appeal isallowed']
+35923;['appeals are allowed.the']
+82070;['appeal is allowed']
+116758;['“regulations”']
+108256;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not\xa0 convention refugees or persons who would be subjected to persecution should they return to china']
+81097;['appeal is dismissed']
+132297;['rpd’s negative decision is confirmed']
+151781;['appeal isallowedand']
+51757;['appeal is allowed']
+55109;['removal orders areset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+98051;['appeal should fail']
+69978;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+92182;['appeals are dismissed']
+141272;['302 (c.a.']
+134168;['appeal is allowed']
+89037;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+89710;['appeals are allowed']
+151517;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+136687;['appeal is allowed']
+74779;['appeal isallowed']
+44040;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+16823;['appeal is dismissed']
+111109;['appeal is dismissed']
+80986;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+132803;['appellant is not a conventionrefugee or a person in need of protection']
+81622;['appeal is determined']
+94736;['appeal is dismissed']
+70760;['appeal is allowed']
+92780;['appeal is denied']
+124594;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+76081;['appeal isallowed.the']
+86055;['appeal isterminated']
+124342;['appeal is allowed']
+129143;['appeal of qun liu is dismissed']
+63944;['appeal is dismissed']
+122629;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61863;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+139862;['dismissing the appellants’ claims']
+65659;['appeal was dismissed']
+140925;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+99393;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91317;['302 (c.a.)']
+74203;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99842;['appeal of veerpal kaur brar is dismissed']
+67468;['dismiss this appeal']
+44213;['appeal has been abandoned']
+143090;['appeal is allowed']
+60833;['appeal is discontinued']
+68231;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+77031;['appeal is allowed']
+87733;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+86199;['appeal isallowed']
+114387;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+151773;['appeal is dismissed']
+130981;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision', 'substitute a positive determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+121874;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx\xa0xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+143236;['appeal is allowed']
+142973;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+124439;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86304;['appeal is declared to beabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+68889;['dismisses the appeal']
+96688;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+100693;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+91192;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94860;['appeal is dismissed']
+66253;['appeal is dismissed']
+94117;['appeal is allowed']
+56744;['dismiss thecharterchallenge,', 'dismiss the appellant']
+151946;['appellants are not are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78666;['appeal isallowed']
+47820;['appeal is allowed']
+151454;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142795;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+69092;['appeal is allowed']
+100118;['appeal isallowedand']
+91295;['302 (c.a.']
+87671;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+82638;['appeal isallowed']
+150725;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+81018;['appeal is dismissed']
+105440;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+127351;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+72906;['appeal must be dismissed']
+100754;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+104848;['appeal is allowed']
+98229;['nor a canadian citizen']
+92710;['appeal is dismissed']
+142468;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+59856;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80762;['dismiss the present refugee protection claim']
+81869;['appeal is allowed']
+107914;['rad finds that the credibility findings are insufficient']
+132780;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+61634;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+98230;['appeal should be allowed']
+123816;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+84228;['appeal is dismissed']
+95402;['appeal is dismissed']
+47162;['allows the appeal']
+57446;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94265;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90247;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110984;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81086;['appeal is allowed']
+69264;['appeal is dismissed']
+152912;['dismisses the appeal']
+81315;['appeal is dismissed']
+68696;['appeal is allowed']
+127713;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+101320;['appeal is terminated']
+142483;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+72313;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+50253;['appeals are dismissed']
+55120;['dismissing this appeal']
+80452;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80990;['appeal is dismissed']
+132288;['appeal of the u.s. citizen is dismissed']
+53762;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+52328;['appeal is dismissed']
+14010;['appeal is determined']
+116813;['appeal is dismissed']
+70218;['appeal isallowedand']
+94407;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+97988;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+140818;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+107237;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124662;['appeal is allowed']
+123360;['allow the appeal']
+61219;['appeal is allowed']
+124715;['appellant is not a specific person of interest']
+82851;['appeal is terminated']
+88321;['appeals are dismissed']
+80374;['appeal isallowed']
+71079;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72173;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99333;['negative determination']
+69440;['dismiss this appeal']
+78026;['appeal of alistair william johnston is dismissed']
+62459;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80562;['appeal is terminated']
+117139;['appeal is dismissed']
+108251;['rad finds the appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95763;['decision conferring refugee protection on the protected person is vacated']
+63750;['appeals ofjasrriet mahal and arjoi mehr mahalare allowed.the']
+111160;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+97297;['claimantxxxxxxxxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87085;['appeal is dismissed']
+100215;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+107924;['appeal was dismissed']
+40156;['appeal is allowed']
+59185;['appeal is allowed']
+135133;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47829;['appeal is allowed']
+151914;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+72616;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+69599;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+76303;['appellant does not have the status of refugee protection', 'not a protected person']
+82037;['stay is extended']
+16813;['appeal is dismissed']
+88255;['confirm the determination']
+124603;['reject their claims']
+55356;['appeal of huseyin gumus is allowed']
+92757;['application to reopen the appeal in file mb1-06955 is dismissed']
+44988;['appeal isallowed']
+91606;['302 (c.a.']
+59026;['dismisses the present appeal']
+96991;['negative']
+30518;['appeal is dismissed']
+18011;['appeal against that determination has been decided']
+140808;['confirm the rpd’s determination', '“convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+110927;['appeal is dismissed']
+142475;['rad finds the nigerian jg inapplicable']
+98361;['appeal of jan van leerdam and lioudmila jurievna sergueeva is dismissed']
+101019;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+94703;['appeal isallowed']
+76898;['tribunal dismisses this appeal in law']
+52713;['reject the claims of xxxxxxxxxxxx']
+151481;['appeal is dismissed']
+100256;['appeal is allowed']
+71163;['appeal is dismissed']
+102540;['appeal is allowed']
+64587;['appeal isdismissed.']
+58387;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+100929;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81075;['decision must be upheld']
+151471;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee']
+100600;['appeal is dismissed']
+68886;['dismiss this appeal']
+121604;['appeal is allowed']
+147440;['rad finds no errors in the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not at risk of harm']
+77838;['claimants are convention refugees']
+81094;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80482;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+67571;['sets aside the deportation order and allows the appeal']
+84208;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52305;['dismissing the appeal']
+31046;['application must be dismissed']
+21106;['appeal made pursuant to paragraph 77(3)(a) and (b) of theactis therefore allowed']
+93330;['appeal be dismissed']
+105866;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77199;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+107064;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+97866;['appeal isallowed']
+17152;['appealed is valid in law']
+75442;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+142532;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision']
+55310;['theappealsare allowed']
+90459;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+81251;['officer’s decision is not valid in law', 'appeal is therefore allowed']
+127449;['appeal is denied']
+78176;['appeal of kuldip singh is allowed']
+140744;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+63182;['appeal is terminated']
+67368;['appeal isallowed']
+123688;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination in part', 'substitutes the determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is a “convention refugee”']
+64243;['appeal is allowed']
+40374;['appeal is dismissed']
+73349;['appeal isallowed']
+100477;['302 (c.a.)']
+93091;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+95472;['appeal isallowed']
+124999;['appeal is allowed']
+26719;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+76100;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+62715;['appeal is allowed']
+107914;['rad finds that this decision cannot stand']
+89770;['appeal is allowed']
+93085;['board rejects the claims']
+66484;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+52119;['appeal is dismissed']
+64602;['appeal isdismissed.']
+64628;['appeal isallowed']
+61447;['302 (c.a.']
+107687;['appeal is dismissed']
+124448;['appeal is allowed']
+54807;['appeal is dismissed']
+122097;['appeal is allowed']
+46090;['appeal is allowed']
+80275;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+142910;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+52116;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80779;['appeal is allowed']
+123251;['dismiss his appeal']
+77577;['appeal isallowed.the']
+79479;['appeal is dismissed']
+102691;['appeal is dismissed']
+90054;['refugee protection division rejects the claim ofxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxfor refugee protection']
+105633;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+96637;['appeal is allowed']
+81596;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+79968;['negative']
+106619;['claim is rejected']
+101696;['appeal isallowed']
+74501;['appeal is allowed']
+94040;['appeal is dismissed']
+108058;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection in canada']
+102690;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101058;['appeal isallowed']
+113246;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+122123;['refugee appeal division (rad) sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+61630;['appeal isallowed']
+84149;['appeal isallowed']
+100393;['appeal be dismissed']
+125242;['appeal is allowed']
+122108;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80250;['refugee protection division determines thatxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+90462;['claimants are neither convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+91109;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+145179;['appeal is allowed']
+59977;['claimants not to be persons in need of protection']
+60080;['reject the claim ofxxxxx xxxxx']
+103619;['allowed the appeal']
+144900;['rad dismisses this appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+81821;['panel finds the exclusion order made november 3, 2017 to be legally valid']
+93152;['302 (c.a.']
+57543;['appeal is dismissed']
+136712;['appeals of the male appellant and minor appellant are dismissed']
+121444;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97404;['claimant, xxxxx xxxxx, is not a convention refugees or a person in need of protection']
+10838;['appeal is allowed']
+57561;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+80066;['appeal is allowed']
+59842;['appeal on this ground is also allowed']
+58420;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+65623;['appeal isdismissed.']
+52482;['appeal dismissed']
+91600;['appeal is allowed']
+59679;['appeal is dismissed']
+76047;['appeal fail']
+100912;['appeal isallowed']
+78722;['dismissal of this appeal']
+34937;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+19724;['appeal is dismissed']
+114424;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+69468;['appeal isallowed']
+111017;['rad finds that rpd decision is flawed']
+87739;['appeal is dismissed']
+98084;['claimants are not “convention refugees”', 'nor are they “persons in need of protection']
+102172;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+52340;['appeal of devinder singh is allowed']
+96701;['appeal is dismissed']
+139804;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+100501;['302 (c.a.']
+124720;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+122260;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101444;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+90666;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your   departure from canada']
+101898;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+123784;['dismiss the appeal']
+77910;['appeal is allowed']
+101316;['allows this appeal']
+140823;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+106261;['appeal is allowed']
+100005;['dismiss that appeal']
+17024;['appeal is allowed']
+111015;['appellants are not qualify undersection 97ofirpa']
+111325;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124187;['appeal is allowed']
+81259;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+57912;['appeal is allowed']
+98325;['appeal isallowedand']
+1381;['appeals filed']
+61293;['appeal is dismissed']
+88113;['appeal isallowed']
+89339;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+96233;['appeal is dismissed']
+87685;['exclusion/removal order is set aside']
+66250;['dismissing the appeal']
+85250;['appeal is dismissed']
+20003;['appeal is allowed']
+74672;['removal order is set aside']
+86385;['appeal isdismissed.']
+30389;['rad concurs with the panel’s finding in this regard']
+64909;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+67661;['allowing his appeal']
+151954;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+56927;['appeal is dismissed']
+60472;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80038;['claimant\xa0 is not\xa0 a\xa0 person\xa0 in\xa0 need\xa0 of\xa0 ']
+100083;['negative']
+98344;['appeal is being dismissed']
+100350;['i reject the claim']
+68370;['appeal is allowed']
+73191;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89580;['allow the appeal']
+21935;['appeal is allowed']
+98007;['theclaimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+48719;['appeal is allowed']
+68372;['appeal is dismissed']
+89573;['appeal is allowed']
+91951;['claimant is a person referred to insection 98of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+99047;['not justify allowing or rejecting their refugee protection claims']
+86062;['rad confirms the finding of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98469;['negative']
+111022;['appeals are allowed']
+101062;['appeal isallowed']
+26516;['302 (c.a.']
+98872;['appeal isallowed']
+27219;['appeal be dismissed']
+120813;['appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+54818;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+120794;['302 (c.a.']
+80466;['appeal of nikolai martynov leinweber is dismissed']
+93587;['appeal is allowed']
+149483;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+80744;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+38429;['appeal is dismissed']
+81081;['appeal is dismissed']
+124667;['appeals are dismissed']
+101342;['dismiss the appeal']
+112351;['appeal is allowed']
+97222;['appeal is allowed']
+113218;['appeal is dismissed']
+125171;['appeal is allowed']
+86988;['302 (c.a.']
+142460;['set aside the determination']
+133390;['determinations are valid in law']
+83059;['appeal is allowed']
+44181;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108960;['xvii]']
+100738;['appeal is terminated']
+68539;['appeal is allowed']
+141311;['appeal is dismissed']
+87732;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+84720;['appeal is dismissed']
+142515;['confirm the refugee protection division’s finding', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+59365;['appeal isallowed']
+107070;['appeal is allowed']
+110313;['rad finds that the rpd’s state protection conclusions']
+50739;['appeals are based']
+151350;['appeals are allowed']
+87313;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+128604;['decision contains errors of law and fact']
+67203;['appeal isallowed']
+96862;['appeal has been abandoned']
+50618;['irb (intervener)(f.c.a., no']
+68341;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101241;['appeal is dismissed']
+66484;['appeal may involve humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+27300;['allow the appeal']
+87072;['appeal is allowed']
+116789;['appeal were dismissed']
+82895;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+144008;['appeal is allowed']
+99911;['appeal be allowed']
+100628;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+70657;['dismiss or declare an appeal abandoned']
+134399;['appeal be dismissed']
+123995;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+120792;['appeal is denied']
+125441;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110975;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+68924;['appeal is allowed']
+69104;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal of dih jieh tsai is dismissed']
+66925;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+76421;['appeal is terminated']
+94361;['dismissed the appellant’s appeal']
+83711;['appellant has not lost her']
+150623;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60466;['appeal isallowed']
+99751;['appeal is dismissed']
+123687;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96701;['appeal of manpreet kaur khehra is dismissed']
+95827;['dismiss the present appeal']
+93017;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision, cannot substitute its own determination']
+102689;['appeal is dismissed']
+71996;['dismisses this appeal']
+59369;['appeal is terminated']
+52931;['appeal is dismissed']
+68919;['appeal isallowed']
+93897;['appeal is allowed']
+56703;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed', 'appeal of abdisamad warsame is dismissed']
+81245;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+86033;['dismisses the appeal']
+28300;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+51715;['appeal is dismissed']
+124490;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125666;['302 (c.a.']
+95423;['appeal is allowed']
+145843;['appeal is dismissed']
+87093;['appeal is allowed']
+91684;['appeal is dismissed']
+107085;['rad further finds that the rpd decision will stand']
+65670;['appeal is allowed']
+60962;['appeal is dismissed']
+151631;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+87942;['appeal is dismissed']
+100164;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+76537;['allow the appeal']
+97110;['appeal is dismissed']
+95689;['negative']
+38160;['appeal is allowed']
+69155;['appeal succeeds']
+131176;['appeal is allowed']
+125633;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+71512;['appeal is dismissed']
+114289;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145534;['appeal is dismissed']
+63916;['appeal fails']
+25980;['appeal is allowed']
+139861;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94636;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+124463;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+146852;['i disagree with the rpd’s decision']
+13631;['appeal is dismissed']
+44186;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+81130;['appeals are allowed.the']
+40051;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26485;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+102485;['appeal is allowed']
+100596;['appeal is dismissed']
+68094;['appeal of hailemariam mebrate mhirate is dismissed']
+104091;['panel rejects these claims']
+68712;['appeal is allowed']
+146899;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+142807;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98347;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94235;['appeal is dismissed']
+102693;['302 (c.a.']
+75591;['appeal isallowed']
+76736;['appeal is allowed']
+14656;['claimants, xxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxx, xxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxx, and xxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxx, are not convention refugees']
+123440;['appeal is allowed']
+72876;['appeal is allowed']
+58185;['appeal isallowed']
+21447;['refugee division determines you, xxxxxxxx, to be a convention refugee']
+109038;['appeals are dismissed']
+39039;['appeal isallowed.the']
+63718;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+44183;['appeal is dismissed']
+90649;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+43337;['appeal is dismissed']
+104491;['appeal is dismissed']
+69352;['appeal is allowed']
+123118;['i reject this submission']
+94732;['appeal is terminated']
+128354;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+54249;['case is dismissed']
+38894;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+88819;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71373;['appeal is dismissed']
+44769;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+99529;['appeal is dismissed']
+36095;['appeal is allowed.the']
+5157;['appeals aredismissed,']
+128157;['appeal is allowed']
+108212;['302 (c.a.']
+96025;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38855;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+133411;['appeal is allowed']
+99713;['appeal is allowed']
+97833;['negative']
+61884;['appeal must be dismissed']
+128910;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx,is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76322;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+134217;['appeal is based']
+107492;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+76434;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+139844;['appeal is dismissed']
+129127;['appeal isallowed']
+68383;['appeal is dismissed']
+87328;['appeal is dismissed']
+123373;['argument is dismissed']
+136736;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+83708;['appeal is dismissed']
+124340;['appellants are notconventionrefugees or persons in need of protection']
+108471;['dismiss the appeal']
+113738;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+129259;['allow this appeal']
+84339;['appeal is allowed']
+98049;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+74520;['appeal was dismissed']
+71212;['appeal is allowed']
+61437;['removal order is set aside']
+74244;['appeal isallowed']
+103889;['appeal is dismissed']
+76278;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+94345;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90460;['refugee protection division rejects these claims against colombia']
+69972;['appeal is dismissed']
+84466;['allow the appeal']
+76389;['appeal is dismissed']
+142795;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+151956;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+24483;['appeal is dismissed']
+14692;['appeal is allowed']
+112785;['panel finds the exclusion order to be legally valid']
+74226;['appeal is dismissed']
+134162;['appeal were dismissed']
+74545;['appeal is dismissed']
+95823;['appeal of xiao wang is allowed']
+58135;['dismiss her appeal']
+62190;['appeal is hereby terminated']
+99764;['appeal of janet evelyn morgan onwualu is dismissed']
+19308;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx\xa0xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+99393;['negative']
+95086;['claims are rejected']
+39603;['appeal is dismissed']
+55874;['appeal abandoned']
+123130;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+148493;['appellants have not established that they are convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+113618;['appeal is dismissed']
+145293;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+74651;['appeal is dismissed']
+101210;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+122877;['appellants are convention refugees']
+100422;['appeals are dismissed']
+61321;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107079;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+89865;['appeal is dismissed']
+69449;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+47384;['appeal is allowed']
+90324;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+95651;['appeal is allowed']
+148984;['appeal is allowed']
+100987;['appeal in this case is dismissed']
+90823;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90102;['appeal is dismissed']
+69516;['application is denied']
+95929;['appeal is allowed']
+61444;['302 (c.a.']
+52721;['xxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+146855;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74719;['appeal isallowed']
+69153;['appeal be dismissed']
+99741;['appeal is allowed']
+60044;['refugee protection division rejects the claims to refugee protection', 'claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+60509;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98551;['appeal was reopened']
+125675;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+107640;['appeal is allowed']
+136111;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84230;['appeal is allowed']
+97478;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+151181;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+41922;['removal order is set aside']
+87306;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+25527;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+135178;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+21303;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+21334;['leads me to find that your evidence']
+67227;['appeal isallowed']
+74647;['appeal is dismissed']
+99617;['appeal is dismissed']
+70650;['appeal is dismissed']
+106814;['panel finds the exclusion order to be legally valid']
+129234;['appeal isdismissed.']
+97822;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+92942;['application to re-open the appeal is denied']
+116359;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+67444;['dismisses the appeal']
+76093;['appeal is dismissed']
+47815;['appeal is allowed']
+107158;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+41793;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+74491;['appeal is allowed']
+135476;['302 (c.a.']
+95422;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+142957;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101165;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute its determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+56755;['reject his claim']
+108947;['appeal is allowed']
+95408;['appeal isallowed']
+122247;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+75573;['allows this appeal']
+74026;['302 (c.a.)']
+111153;['appeal is allowed']
+130999;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+89923;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90012;['dismiss this appeal']
+75950;['appeal is allowed']
+114351;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant and the daughter are convention refugees']
+125623;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94926;['appeal is allowed']
+99542;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+151840;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+114387;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+93808;['claimant and her daughter are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+23028;['appeal of is dismissed']
+91119;['appeal is dismissed']
+144018;['pa is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102153;['appeal is dismissed']
+85237;['appeal is allowed']
+94006;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59038;['appeal isdismissedand the']
+77850;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+120757;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+66774;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+52066;['appeal is allowed']
+106425;['appeal is dismissed']
+130351;['opposes the appellant’s application to reopen the appeal']
+15007;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+97403;['neither convention refugees']
+130771;['appeal were dismissed']
+81135;['appeal is dismissed']
+144041;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+82570;['appeal of jagdeep kaur sidhu is allowed']
+92243;['dismiss the appeal']
+127702;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+95650;['appeal should be dismissed']
+71097;['appeal of parvinder singh brar is therefore dismissed']
+96653;['not a convention refugee']
+82430;['appeal is terminated']
+60867;['appeal is allowed']
+71245;['appeal is allowed']
+141784;['appeal is allowed.the']
+106940;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'division rejects his claim']
+74831;['appeal is allowed']
+145377;['claimants are neither convention refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+31046;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+89946;['dismissing the appeal']
+19114;['dismiss the appeal']
+91910;['appeal is allowed.the']
+99041;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100814;['dismiss the appeal']
+90044;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+96804;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97878;['refugee protection claims filed byxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxandxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxare rejected']
+73046;['appeal isallowed']
+101345;['appeal isallowed']
+24471;['appeal isallowed']
+102911;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+83660;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69088;['dismiss the appeal']
+95949;['rad finds that the rpd’s findings in this regard are reasonable']
+93015;['appeal may be dismissed']
+91526;['appeal is terminated']
+123287;['appeal is dismissed']
+5148;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+138871;['302 (c.a.']
+102688;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+133192;['rad rejects these arguments']
+33074;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+150152;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73046;['allowed the appeal']
+153056;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+97698;['appeal isallowed']
+64874;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+28296;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+99399;['appeal will not be reopened']
+67596;['appeal isallowed']
+48424;['appeal be dismissed']
+106136;['appeal is allowed']
+128844;['appeal is allowed']
+36574;['appeal is not frivolous']
+143031;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100080;['appeal is dismissed']
+133412;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+122862;['appeal is allowed']
+76788;['appeal being allowed']
+88036;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'rejects these claims for refugee protection']
+91272;['appeal is dismissed']
+24490;['appeal is allowed']
+47832;['appeal is allowed']
+83485;['appeal should be dismissed']
+91282;['appeal is allowed']
+82379;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+129119;['appeal is allowed']
+87473;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+93251;['neither a canadian citizen', 'nor a permanent resident of canada']
+83455;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+69628;['appeal is allowed']
+81421;['appeal is allowed']
+79071;['appeal is dismissed']
+94003;['appeal is dismissed']
+13933;['appeal is dismissed']
+122697;['confirm therpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor person in need of protection']
+65133;['theappeal is dismissed']
+88164;['appeal is dismissed']
+100825;['appeal is allowed']
+49068;['appeal is dismissed']
+122679;['appeal is dismissed']
+105626;['appeal is dismissed']
+95033;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+113796;['rad sets aside the rpd’s decision and refers the matter to the rpd']
+52082;['appeal is terminated']
+141272;['appeal must fail']
+71800;['dismissing the appellant’s appeal']
+135941;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+30512;['appeal is dismissed']
+26725;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+84781;['302 (c.a.']
+94107;['appeal isallowed']
+123036;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+105378;['appeal is allowed']
+134357;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+87454;['302 (c.a.']
+94582;['302 (c.a.)']
+93049;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89861;['appeal is allowed']
+101963;['appeal is allowed']
+56985;['refugee protection division rejects the claim ofxxxxx.xxxxxfor refugee protection']
+67408;['appeal isallowed']
+124711;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+139800;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+116352;['appellant is recognized as a refugee']
+150626;['appeal is allowed']
+151729;['decision must be upheld']
+74457;['appeal is allowed']
+124663;['302 (c.a.']
+100839;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+41249;['appeal is allowed']
+38870;['appeal is dismissed']
+111298;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”']
+75083;['appeal is allowed']
+89983;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+93597;['302 (c.a.)']
+91695;['appeal is dismissed']
+139677;['appeal is allowed']
+90733;['appeal is allowed']
+46516;['appeal is allowed']
+85525;['appeal is terminated']
+52064;['allows the appeal']
+71519;['appeal isallowed']
+56793;['302 (c.a.']
+87075;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+45998;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96704;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97901;['appeal is dismissed']
+64037;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61880;['appeal is terminated']
+74870;['appeal is allowed']
+148996;['appeals of xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are allowed']
+93114;['appeal isallowedin']
+52265;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+56631;['appeal were dismissed']
+116772;['allow the appeal']
+47293;['appeal is allowed']
+99926;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+108739;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+104371;['appeal is allowed']
+69599;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+101272;['appeal is allowed']
+99908;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+108124;['substitute my own decision that the principal appellant is aconventionrefugee']
+98117;['dismiss the appeal']
+106266;['panel rejects his claim']
+108955;['appeal isallowed']
+74626;['application is denied']
+52511;['appeal is allowed']
+39066;['appeal is not allowed']
+99917;['appeal isallowed.the']
+38789;['appeal is allowed']
+92618;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+42169;['appeal is allowed']
+55195;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+105611;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72585;['appeal is dismissed']
+96348;['appeal is allowed']
+47179;['appeals of the appellant']
+107818;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+71490;['appeal isallowed']
+94002;['appeal isallowed']
+79993;['appeal be dismissed']
+83141;['appeal is allowed']
+121210;['appellants are convention refugees and persons in need of protection']
+90945;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+8296;['appeal is dismissed']
+57953;['appeal is dismissed']
+49124;['appeal is dismissed']
+152925;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+113553;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+102966;['appeal is allowed']
+30875;['appeal is allowed']
+122908;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+105868;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59770;['appeals are allowed']
+57932;['appeal is dismissed']
+78127;['allow the appeal']
+110715;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+50540;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+143616;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+71575;['dismissed the appeal']
+86340;['appeal isallowed']
+86005;['appeal is dismissed']
+134429;['appeal is dismissed']
+121478;['rpd decision must be read as a whole']
+87180;['appeal is allowed.the']
+139470;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+62189;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+83869;['rad finds that it is not in a position to substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+106653;['neither “convention refugees’ nor “persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+84236;['appeal is allowed']
+126425;['appeal is dismissed']
+133687;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+60495;['appeal is dismissed']
+131141;['appeal is dismissed']
+76076;['declare your appeal abandoned']
+71534;['appeal is allowed']
+74052;['dismiss it for lack of jurisdiction']
+88514;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+52789;['appeal is allowed']
+30377;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+118784;['appeal is dismissed']
+97158;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+132376;['appeal is dismissed']
+60878;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+89359;['appeal ought to be dismissed']
+107173;['rad disagrees']
+114371;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123331;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+96003;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+151822;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101228;['denies the application for reopening of this appeal']
+101804;['appeal is allowedpursuant']
+74644;['appeal is dismissed']
+71801;['appeal is dismissed']
+100992;['appeal is allowed']
+95673;['appeal is allowed']
+21311;['appeal isdismissedand a departure orderis issued']
+98398;['appeal is dismissed']
+49973;['appeal is dismissed']
+57745;['reject her claim']
+96606;['negative']
+89747;['appeal is allowed']
+38866;['appeal is allowed']
+95654;['appeal is allowed', 'counselor’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+125339;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67720;['appeal is dismissed']
+130735;"[""officer's decision is not a nullity""]"
+90798;['appeal is allowed']
+76369;['dismissal of the appeal']
+99637;['appeal is allowed.the']
+42329;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+23085;['appeal is allowed']
+84011;['appeal is allowed']
+97781;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+75469;['appeal is dismissed']
+69369;['appeal isallowed']
+97959;['appeal is allowed']
+67251;['appeal is allowed']
+138294;['dismisses this appeal']
+37412;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+104097;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nora person in need of protection']
+89357;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+83542;['appeal is allowed']
+84833;['appeal is allowed']
+108189;['appeal is dismissed']
+54178;['appeal of husan lal rao is dismissed']
+129203;['appeal is allowed']
+70159;['appeal is dismissed']
+123757;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+63904;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+122630;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+76355;['appeal is dismissed']
+75867;['appeal is allowed']
+75912;['appeal is allowed']
+34099;['rad therefore confirms the rpd’s determination']
+139477;['visa officer’s decision is set aside']
+49575;['appeal of raymond hon wing cheung is dismissed']
+134419;['officer’s decision is well-founded in law']
+47163;['appeal is continued']
+109534;['appeals must be dismissed']
+105327;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100749;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+87430;['appeal is allowed']
+83084;['appeal is dismissed']
+131191;['appeal of ehsanul haque is allowed']
+123313;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd']
+68916;['appeal isallowed']
+9676;['appeal is allowed']
+76517;['appeal is dismissed']
+110946;['appeal is dismissed']
+96081;['appeal is dismissed']
+96187;['appeal was dismissed']
+74459;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90760;['appeal is allowed']
+95905;['appeal is dismissed']
+117113;['appeal is dismissed']
+102061;['appeal is allowed']
+89416;['appeal is allowed']
+143282;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98270;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+104487;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140709;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+60036;['reject this claim to refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee']
+76485;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+87055;['appeal is abandoned']
+108696;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+110932;['appellants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+87076;['appeal isallowed']
+131160;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+57477;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+65702;['appeal is dismissed']
+80496;['appeal of kheira fatima messatfa and of cyril rachid lauer, mikael hafiz lauer and jean-paul sebastien lauer is allowed']
+76764;['allow the appeal']
+47723;['appeal is governed by theact']
+80192;['mother’s claim fails']
+97819;['not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+103000;['appeal is dismissed']
+84137;['appeal isallowed']
+84620;['appeal, therefore, is dismissed']
+97896;['appeal is dismissed']
+94709;['appeal is dismissed']
+148732;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+74268;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+97908;['appeal is dismissed']
+130736;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+94676;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+74883;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+90731;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+36569;['dismiss the present appeal']
+69619;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+66310;['allow your appeal']
+53408;['appeal is dismissed']
+95291;['appeal is an abuse of process']
+83056;['appeal is allowed']
+145876;['dismiss the appeal']
+95890;['302 (c.a.']
+69994;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+57226;['determination is valid in law']
+106176;['appeal is dismissed']
+104527;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+121520;['appeal is allowed']
+63520;['claimants are determined to be convention refugees']
+18924;['appeal is dismissed']
+77904;['appeal is dismissed']
+89311;['neither a convention refugee nor a person described insection 97of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+52088;['appeal is allowed']
+114366;['appeals are dismissed']
+57555;['appeal isallowed.the']
+73059;['appeal is allowed']
+39041;['appeal is dismissed']
+70472;['appeal be dismissed']
+94601;['appeal isallowed']
+54300;['appeal is dismissed']
+89070;['appeal isallowed']
+28081;['appeal is dismissed']
+83666;['removal order isset aside']
+74667;['appeal is allowed']
+70460;['appeal was dismissed']
+91557;['302 (c.a.']
+44205;['appeal is declared to beabandonedundersubsection\xa0']
+80235;['negative']
+107824;['302 (c.a.)']
+69577;['iab allowed the appeal']
+129100;['removal order isset aside']
+97476;['allowed the sponsor’s appeal']
+94013;['exclusion order is set aside']
+100242;['appeal isallowed']
+125544;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms, for other reasons', 'the principal appellant,xxxx xxxx,is a person described in article\xa01e of the refugee conventionand']
+107215;['appeal is allowed']
+90240;['not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+107166;['302 (c.a.']
+44967;['appeal is dismissed']
+85909;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+63737;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+68126;['appeal is allowed']
+69834;['appeal is dismissed']
+83441;['appeal is allowed']
+85862;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124459;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+8344;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+81120;['theappealsare dismissed']
+65691;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+68357;['appeal is allowed']
+148661;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+89832;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+125443;['christian converts']
+102575;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+47723;['application is denied']
+98391;['decision is well-founded in law and in fact']
+133409;['appeal were dismissed']
+61399;['appeal is allowed in law']
+109275;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+61466;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+99291;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125014;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+128904;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “refugee”']
+95318;['appeal is allowed']
+99439;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+74692;['appeal is dismissed']
+88256;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+108938;['appeal is allowed']
+79724;['appeal is terminated']
+68141;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94105;['appeal isallowed']
+146927;['appeal is allowed']
+141638;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101354;['appeal proceeded before me']
+83018;['allow your appeal']
+88021;['302 (c.a.']
+67247;['appeal must be dismissed']
+31382;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84307;['departure order isset aside']
+103101;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+102103;['appeals were dismissed']
+48592;['appeal is allowed']
+74225;['appeal is allowed']
+151647;['appeal is allowed']
+99592;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+85246;['appeal is allowed']
+28084;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+122261;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+100535;['appeal isallowed']
+95425;['appeal of ka guan sim isdismissed']
+122944;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107599;['appeal is allowed']
+91172;['appeal is allowed']
+82211;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+96358;['panel will not postpone its decision']
+121379;['dismiss this appeal']
+122984;['rad substitutes the findings of the rpd', 'decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+79333;['appeal isallowed']
+76158;['appeal was allowed']
+97422;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+100043;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+3955;['appeal is determined']
+17958;['appeal is allowed']
+108792;['rpd determination must be set aside']
+12222;['appeal isallowed']
+109618;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+145045;['panel accordingly rejects this claim for refugee protection']
+107038;['appeal is dismissed']
+90622;['allow the appeal']
+151453;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+58490;['appeal is dismissed']
+125028;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+30518;['appeal is dismissed']
+72027;['appeal dismissed']
+99291;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61467;['appeal is allowed']
+99972;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86009;['dismiss the appeal']
+83541;['appeal isdismissed.']
+104977;['appeal is allowed']
+59023;['appealofsoud abbas kandosh is dismissed']
+26752;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+14714;['appeal on behalf of balbir kaur dogra, tanvir singh dogra, and dilpreet kaur dogra is dismissed']
+87095;['appeal of yihong yao is dismissed']
+151514;['appeal is allowed']
+30494;['dismiss the present appeal']
+97081;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+125684;['rad confirms the rpd’s negative determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57100;['appeal is allowed']
+71363;['appeal is dismissed']
+17164;['appeal of manal zoobi is dismissed']
+123148;['allow this appeal, set aside the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugee”']
+77215;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+100438;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+75495;['appeal is allowed']
+97158;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69413;['application is allowed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+123109;['appeal is allowed']
+98197;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95313;['appeal is allowed']
+93912;['appeal is dismissed']
+38384;['appeal is dismissed']
+115917;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own decision that ms. a is a convention refugee']
+106445;['determination is legally valid']
+77113;['appeal is dismissed']
+97642;['he is not a convention refugee']
+96027;['appeal is dismissed']
+110560;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+47366;['appeal is allowed']
+106153;['appeal is dismissed']
+93320;['appeal was dismissed']
+95965;['rad finds the rpd’s decision in this case']
+87117;['appeal is allowed.the']
+31986;['appeal is dismissed']
+124455;['302 (c.a.']
+141817;['rpd decision is confirmed']
+130774;['appeal is dismissed']
+47820;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+45184;['dismiss the appeal']
+47161;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+132329;['request for an oral hearing is therefore dismissed']
+134171;['appeal is allowed']
+93944;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+99020;['appeal was dismissed']
+91306;['appeal is allowed']
+100581;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+143583;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+112378;['dismisses the appeals']
+90030;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+124186;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+102745;['removal order is set aside']
+95213;['appeal is terminated']
+122114;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106160;['appeal is allowed']
+146103;['appeal is dismissed']
+89888;['claimant is not a person in need of protection', 'panel rejects his claim']
+116798;['appeal is allowed']
+86482;['appeals of shima etezadi and shaghayegh etezadi are dismissed']
+106285;['appeal is dismissed']
+94435;['appeals are dismissed']
+113528;['appeal isallowed']
+90736;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+87103;['appeals are dismissed']
+67935;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+97320;['negative']
+45209;['appeal is dismissed']
+148656;['appeal is allowed']
+106640;['panel rejects the claim']
+97002;['appeal is allowed']
+45216;['appeal of za zhen gao is allowed in law']
+144057;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147462;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95858;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+69981;['appeal is allowed']
+100574;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+60071;['appeal is dismissed']
+70792;['appeal is dismissed']
+94721;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+76394;['substitute the determination\xa0 /\xa0 ']
+63824;['appeal is allowed']
+68231;['appeal is determined abandoned']
+80726;['rejects his   ']
+76400;['appeal isallowed']
+140275;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+132630;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+10743;['appeal is dismissed']
+70006;['appeal isallowed.the']
+94644;['application is therefore dismissed']
+63831;['appeal is dismissed']
+12001;['removal order isset aside']
+101698;['appeal is allowed']
+69144;['appeal is dismissed']
+57308;['allow the appeal of sam sasani in law']
+89130;['negative']
+59975;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+146552;['panel rejects their refugee protection claim']
+99870;['appeal before me is dismissed']
+40147;['appeal is dismissed']
+113563;['appeal is allowed']
+117119;['appeal is allowed']
+44094;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+97957;['dismiss the appeal']
+55298;['appeal is allowed']
+35809;['appeal is based']
+59805;['appeal of tesfamichael ab guta is dismissed']
+102126;['determination is valid in law']
+46240;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+129937;['exclusion orders areset aside']
+130722;['appeal is dismissed']
+127717;['appeal is allowed']
+95322;['appeal isallowedand']
+106130;['appeal abandoned']
+62490;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'confirms the decision thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare']
+80301;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82797;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+69519;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+95378;['appeal is allowed']
+123875;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+83543;['appeal fails']
+109290;['they are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+72863;['appeal must be dismissed']
+82467;['appeal of sheku ibrahim kemoh sesay is dismissed']
+56591;['appeal is allowed']
+99186;['not a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+107058;['appeal is thereforedismissed']
+126415;['appeal is allowed']
+128373;['appeals ofyasamin elyasi bakhtiari and nazanin elyasi bakhtiariare allowed']
+81177;['appeal is allowed']
+60021;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+54328;['application to dismiss the appeal']
+146439;['302 (c.a.']
+125049;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+146867;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105211;['stay is cancelled']
+101399;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+69963;['appeal be allowed']
+106805;['appeal is dismissed']
+90695;['dismiss the appeal']
+99887;['appeal is dismissed']
+61809;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+94618;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+136419;['opposes the application']
+145951;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+105315;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is absent of any error', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+91150;['appeal is dismissed']
+70952;['appeal ofjung hsi tsao']
+87849;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+52368;['appeal of yuen may lam (the “appellant”']
+81259;['appeal is dismissed']
+76670;['appeal isallowed']
+94216;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74672;['appeal is allowed']
+72921;['appeal is dismissed']
+146906;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+58100;['appeal is dismissed']
+99416;['appeal is dismissed']
+133265;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+98547;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+133745;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+87224;['appeal is dismissed']
+87078;['appeal is allowed']
+76424;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+68348;['appeal is dismissed']
+143553;['appeal is allowed']
+88269;['appeal is allowed']
+52485;['appeal is allowed']
+108124;['dismiss the associate appellant’s appeal', 'uphold the rpd’s finding']
+27720;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64607;['appeal is allowed']
+84304;['appeal is dismissed']
+92337;['appeal is dismissed']
+39046;['appeal is dismissed']
+51670;['rpd’s decision therefore cannot stand']
+123867;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+91241;['appeal is terminated']
+146849;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+130720;['appeal is dismissed']
+55874;['appeal is determined']
+82122;['appeal is allowed']
+49574;['appeal is dismissed']
+48219;['appeal is allowed']
+76038;['appeal is dismissed']
+99408;['302 (c.a.']
+124197;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121604;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+60047;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79604;['appeal isallowed']
+109008;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+108855;['rad is in agreement']
+105628;['confirms the decision of the rpd']
+142095;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55207;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+144756;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100592;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+65676;['appeal should be dismissed']
+98539;['appeal is allowed']
+82232;['appeal is dismissed']
+91425;['appeal is dismissed']
+98631;['appeal of abdul shakoor is dismissed']
+104099;['reject this claim']
+100937;['appeal is dismissed']
+69488;['appeal is dismissed']
+85236;['appeal is dismissed']
+49147;['appeals are allowed']
+88865;['removal orders areset aside']
+100981;['appeal ofhai bao zheng is dismissed']
+61939;['appeal of evelyn eve adams is dismissed']
+38855;['removal orders are set aside']
+98702;['appeal is allowed']
+152950;['determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+27013;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+104440;['panel rejects his claim']
+101054;['302 (c.a.)']
+52268;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+139430;['appeal dismissed']
+101935;['claimant is not a credible witness', 'not a convention refugee']
+68616;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+77959;['appeal is allowed']
+52761;['appeal is dismissed']
+57077;['substitute its own determination']
+73220;['tribunal declares the appealabandonedpursuant tosubsection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+83925;['decision of the id member is set aside']
+151781;['appeal is allowed']
+80681;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+84664;['sponsorship be withdrawn']
+95243;['appeal is terminated']
+98585;['302 (c.a.']
+59378;['appeal of wu ying dan is dismissed']
+30481;['appeal is dismissed']
+116358;['appeal is dismissed']
+116363;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94287;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+80293;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+92730;['appeal is allowed']
+63189;['appeals are allowed']
+92175;['appeal is dismissed']
+140264;['claimants, mr.xxxx xxxx, ms.xxxx xxxx, mr.xxxx xxxx, ms.xxxx xxxxand ms.xxxx xxxx, are “convention refugees,”']
+99530;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+28062;['appeals for mohammad khalid khan, shabeela khalid khan, maheen khan, zara khan, and mohammad danial khan are dismissed']
+64923;['appeal is allowed']
+113215;['appeal is dismissed']
+107242;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes its own decision, namely, that the appellant is a “convention refugee”']
+63161;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+38393;['appeal is dismissed']
+90941;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87787;['negative']
+104552;['appeal is accepted']
+98211;['appeal is allowed']
+122879;['rad, pursuant', 'substitutes a decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+110565;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+98368;['appeals are dismissed']
+85449;['appeal is allowed']
+146895;['confirm the   decision of the rpd']
+129896;['substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant is a convention refugee']
+134383;['appeal is dismissed']
+133283;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxx xxxxis rejected']
+151645;['claimants have failed to establish that they are either convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+60486;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100263;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+33086;['appeal is dismissed']
+23067;['appeal isallowed']
+63060;['appeal of ranjit singh giri is allowed']
+143608;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+75710;['appeal isallowed']
+105876;['appeal is dismissed']
+88076;['appeal is terminated']
+75934;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+67487;['appeal isallowed']
+105651;['rad finds the rpd erred in this respect']
+98513;['302 (c.a.']
+86987;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+99894;['appeal of vinnie ka nei cheung is allowed']
+16812;['appeal is dismissed']
+109011;['appeal is dismissed']
+120762;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124680;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+114388;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+52368;['appeal is allowed']
+74792;['appeal isallowed']
+106374;['appeal is dismissed']
+48141;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+123824;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+104146;['claimant to not be a convention refugee']
+124589;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+123673;['appeal is allowed']
+72066;['allow this appeal']
+104080;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+122934;['allow the appeal']
+101289;['rpd’s negative determination is set aside', 'positive decision substituted']
+103491;['appeal is dismissed']
+13331;['appeal is dismissed']
+97531;['appeal is dismissed']
+83926;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+101336;['appeal is terminated']
+105893;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand as it is not supportable']
+103724;['302 (c.a.']
+151582;['302 (c.a.']
+69953;['appeal is dismissed']
+60191;['appeal isallowed']
+95492;['dismiss this appeal']
+56504;['appeal should be, and it is, dismissed']
+72190;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+90480;['orders your departure fromcanada.']
+36105;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95825;['appeal is allowed']
+26754;['appeal is dismissed']
+100802;['decision is legally valid']
+19720;['appeal is dismissed']
+107626;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+61462;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123288;['appeal must fail']
+102555;['appeal is dismissed']
+151890;['i agree with the rpd’s analysis']
+78745;['appeal is dismissed']
+52656;['neither convention refugees']
+124080;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+63062;['appeal of minda orial valdez is dismissed']
+94434;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'appellants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+87409;['appeal is dismissed']
+46490;['appeal is allowed.the']
+77557;['appeal isallowed']
+121383;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+140732;['rad must reject the appellants’ argument']
+57741;['appeal is allowed']
+79932;['joined claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+33323;['appeal was dismissed']
+91318;['appeal is dismissed']
+48101;['appeal is allowed']
+44769;['appeal is dismissed']
+149060;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60810;"['appealis allowed.the', ""officer's decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside""]"
+117121;['appeal is allowed']
+60912;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94338;['appeal has been abandoned']
+93805;['negative']
+114414;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57819;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+50930;['appeal isallowed']
+98369;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal to this tribunal']
+108774;['appeal is dismissed']
+95416;['appeal is dismissed']
+99607;['appeal of halima omar is dismissed']
+52146;['negative']
+80277;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+107222;['appeal is allowed']
+67706;['appeal is dismissed']
+109279;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92444;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+151393;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68438;['appeal is allowed']
+127412;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92246;['appeal isallowed']
+59791;['removal order is set aside']
+152918;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96816;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+30514;['appeal isallowed']
+90813;['appeal is allowed']
+122670;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+83119;['iad is without jurisdiction']
+76180;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+97477;['negative']
+31224;['appeal is dismissed']
+123302;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151376;['appeal is allowed']
+83669;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+98284;['appeal is dismissed']
+85847;['decision is right or wrong']
+83368;['appeal is allowed']
+69661;['appeal is allowed']
+71542;['immigration appeal division must dismiss the appeal']
+96669;['rad disagrees']
+84060;['appeal is dismissed']
+27460;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+114347;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56955;['appeal is dismissed']
+102703;['appeal is allowed']
+100023;['302 (c.a.']
+26956;['xxxxx xxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+132804;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+138859;['appeal is dismissed']
+141791;['appeal is allowed']
+149480;['application to re-open the rpd decision was allowed by the rpd']
+95163;['appeal is dismissed']
+52344;['appeal is dismissed']
+86392;['appellant has not lost his permanent visa.']
+132751;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+125402;['appeal is allowed']
+42418;['appeal is allowed']
+69122;['appeal is dismissed']
+123978;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104463;['appeal is allowed']
+104390;['appeal for floresita calamiong, roselle calamiong and jason calamiong\xa0 is allowed']
+74050;['appeal isallowed']
+84870;['appeal is dismissed']
+127359;['appeal is dismissed']
+54550;['allow the present appeal']
+69433;['appeal isallowed']
+90630;['appeal is dismissed']
+123386;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105863;['appeal is dismissed']
+111316;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+23040;['removal order isset aside']
+128930;['appeal be dismissed']
+43725;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+140231;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxand her son,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees”']
+77944;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+82884;['appeal is allowed']
+81423;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+76721;['appeal is allowed']
+128371;['appeal is allowed']
+35886;['appeal be dismissed']
+65352;['dismiss the appeals']
+125401;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+87155;['appeal isallowed']
+56817;['refugee protection division determinesxxxxx xxxxx', 'not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+107895;['appeal is allowed']
+16828;['rad finds the decision of the rpd to be wrong in law']
+59736;['appeal is allowed']
+71609;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+29707;['appeal is dismissed']
+90958;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99557;['appeal be dismissed']
+94649;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98754;['appeal is allowed']
+66927;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+142898;['appeal must be allowed']
+70364;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+134312;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+85945;['appeal of hai gen lu is dismissed']
+130765;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+120841;['appeal is allowed']
+67511;['appeal isallowed']
+107430;['rpd’s decision must be set aside']
+106784;['appeal is being dismissed']
+133194;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+38402;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+76557;['302 (c.a.']
+28048;['appellant has no right of appeal', 'appeal is dismissed']
+141206;['allow this appeal']
+151425;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+27231;['dismiss the appeal']
+45162;['appeal is allowed.the']
+94565;['determination is valid in law']
+68325;['appeal is dismissed']
+90239;['negative']
+136672;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+133388;['appeal is denied']
+98876;['appeal isallowed']
+45151;['appeal isallowed']
+145429;['appeal is allowed']
+103696;['applications to extend the time to file the notices of appeals are dismissed']
+48094;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+99691;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+121415;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+102532;['appeal is dismissed']
+124707;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77475;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+113748;['rad confirms the impugned decision', 'neither convention refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+88311;['appeal is dismissed']
+88328;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+128574;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+142519;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+147467;['rpd’s determination is therefore correct']
+97591;['removal orders are set aside']
+28016;['appeal isallowedand']
+70954;['appeal is allowed']
+135205;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+53857;['appeal isallowed']
+128150;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+121559;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+81253;['appeal is based']
+98303;"[""claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of canada's protection""]"
+128289;['appeal of yang yang luo is dismissed']
+143500;['request to reopen the claim of the applicant is denied']
+101311;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+114295;['not aconvention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+122766;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76673;['appeal is allowed']
+115181;['appeals are negatively']
+77856;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+52732;['not a convention refugee and is excluded from the protection of the refugee convention']
+143194;['claims are rejected']
+52482;['appeal is allowed']
+98139;['appeal is allowed']
+38835;['appeals be allowed']
+138878;['302 (c.a.']
+96812;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+76435;['appeal is allowed']
+114453;['302 (c.a.']
+93677;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+12198;['appellant was established']
+124935;['appeals are dismissed']
+81126;['appeal is allowed']
+89381;['appeal is terminated']
+8532;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+87520;['appeal is dismissed']
+82717;['appeal is dismissed']
+68306;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+47132;['appeal is allowed']
+146124;['panel rejects her claim']
+76551;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+101033;['302 (c.a.']
+80753;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+74068;['appeal is allowed']
+124266;['appeal is denied|']
+146441;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71149;['appeal is allowed']
+90234;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+81259;['appeal is allowed']
+87060;['appeal is dismissed']
+87412;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+80449;['appeal is dismissed']
+74227;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+100043;['affirms the positive recommendation made by the minister’s counsel', 'allows the appeal']
+61976;['appeal is dismissed']
+24512;['appeal is dismissed']
+55261;['not be found to be a convention refugee']
+88420;['immigration appeal division orders your departure from canada']
+124910;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+62391;['appeal of joseph yuen wong is allowed']
+90254;['claimant is not a genuine practicing christian incanada']
+123060;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+109532;['removal order is set aside']
+57820;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74988;['appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+152917;['rad substitutes a determination that should have been made']
+83367;['appeal is dismissed']
+79742;['removal order is set aside']
+152051;['dismiss the appeal']
+97497;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+42331;['appeal is dismissed']
+55313;['appeals of elvera godoy celso and osorio robles celso are dismissed']
+71157;['appeal is allowed']
+124822;['panel rejects the refugee protection claims made byxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx']
+90907;['appeal is allowed']
+125647;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+89567;['iad dismissed the appellant’s appeal']
+38992;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+73322;['panel determines that it is valid in law']
+124014;['appeal is dismissed']
+94059;['appeal is allowed']
+88341;['appeal is allowed']
+125621;['appeal is allowed']
+94751;['appeal is dismissed']
+129211;['appeal is dismissed']
+113589;['302 (c.a.']
+106937;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees not persons in need of protection']
+127712;['appeal being allowed']
+105704;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+110291;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+64114;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96923;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+129918;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124588;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+84416;['appeal is terminated']
+84911;['confirm the determination']
+47094;['appeal has been dismissed']
+74775;['appeal isallowed']
+55268;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128397;['appeal of kurt savalan is dismissed']
+64586;['appeal is allowed']
+69163;['appeal is dismissed']
+22392;['appeal is dismissed']
+87731;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99079;['302 (c.a.']
+99236;['appeal is dismissed']
+100214;['appeal is allowed']
+98564;['appeal is granted']
+40475;['appeal is allowed']
+19165;['appeal is allowed']
+68234;['allow the appeal']
+109533;['appeal is dismissed']
+140721;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+131158;['appeal isallowed']
+142454;['appellants are convention refugees']
+47351;['appeal is allowed']
+95454;['appeal is dismissed']
+89488;['removal order is set aside']
+123899;['rad allows the appeal, sets aside the rpd determination']
+138872;['302 (c.a.']
+94552;['appeal is refused']
+19742;['appeal is based']
+148630;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94160;['appeal of su ling chen is dismissed']
+97229;['appeal is dismissed']
+142490;['302 (c.a.)']
+21104;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+70018;['appeal is dismissed']
+62210;['appeal is allowed']
+113779;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+17993;['allows the appeal']
+106164;['appeal is terminated']
+110980;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96885;['appeal is allowed']
+79480;['appeal is dismissed']
+125047;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146587;['panel rejects these claims']
+82039;['appeal isallowed']
+57934;['appeal were dismissed']
+97881;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+89418;['appeal is terminated']
+101029;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+27230;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+65689;['appeal is dismissed']
+107465;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83894;['appeal is dismissed']
+120849;['substitute my determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+26682;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+99144;"[""officer's decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside""]"
+75985;['appeal is dismissed']
+102047;['appeal is allowed']
+78295;['appeal is dismissed']
+141229;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+56578;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+68160;['allow the appeal of jaswir kaur sidhu']
+125138;['appellant is excluded from the definition of convention refugee']
+121861;['rad confirms the impugned decision wherebyxxxx xxxxis described in article\xa01e of the convention']
+84179;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+116756;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+62849;['appeal is dismissed']
+92539;['appeal is dismissed']
+105794;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47218;['appeal is dismissed']
+96680;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+61479;['302 (c.a.']
+55292;['refugee protection division', 'xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+146222;['appeal is dismissed']
+124971;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94896;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+76833;['decision is not valid in law']
+99572;['removal order is set aside']
+128737;['neither “convention\u2009refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+90459;['negative']
+100815;['determinations are not valid in law']
+144903;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+84368;['appeal is dismissed']
+147011;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+86483;['appeal of sam cho sing sze is dismissed']
+125015;['not be granted refugee protection']
+77822;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+52100;['appeal is dismissed']
+133698;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that mrs. a is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+105895;['rad concurs with the rpd']
+17380;['appeal is dismissed']
+73260;['appeal must be dismissed']
+54750;['appeal was dismissed']
+78725;['appeal isallowed']
+98850;['appeal is allowed']
+124413;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+37155;['appeal is dismissed']
+75911;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+102123;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+30538;['appeal is dismissed']
+73868;['appeal isallowed.the']
+124949;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+87124;['appeal is allowed']
+87825;['terminates his appeal']
+153264;['rad finds that she is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+110564;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147468;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89108;['appeal abandoned']
+90200;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+47466;['appeal is allowed']
+96442;['application is denied']
+101458;['appeal is determined to be and is marked as abandoned']
+89344;['claimant is a not a convention refugee']
+146969;['appeal is determined']
+80514;['claim is rejected']
+98264;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+75481;['appeal is dismissed']
+8297;['appeals should be dismissed']
+100690;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+42453;['removal order is set aside']
+133380;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76005;['appeal isallowed']
+100650;['application is allowed']
+47296;['appeal is allowed']
+94606;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96948;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+131713;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+89347;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+85965;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97243;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+76056;['appeal is dismissed']
+75928;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+53875;['appeal is dismissed']
+62468;['rad finds that the rpd’s assessment is correct']
+93585;['pa is excluded']
+78168;['claimant is determined to be neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90844;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+39917;['appeal is dismissed']
+68900;['dismisses this appeal']
+34161;['appeal is dismissed']
+135134;['rad confirms the rpd decision', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”under', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+77082;['appeal is allowed']
+70960;['appeal of amrik singh nahal is dismissed']
+71367;['appeal is governed by theact']
+80509;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+76025;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+70599;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+96568;['appeal is abandoned']
+103910;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+87347;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+70393;['appeal is dismissed']
+106298;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+82578;['appeal of gloria tamayo escobar is dismissed']
+98869;['302 (c.a.']
+85535;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+24487;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+69596;['appeal isallowed']
+141268;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+50522;['appeal is allowed.the']
+60983;['appeal is terminated']
+83104;['appeal is dismissed']
+91154;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98859;['appeal is dismissed']
+152921;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67688;['appeal is allowed']
+81166;['appeal was dismissed']
+24484;['appeal is allowed']
+99790;['302 (c.a.']
+99921;['appeals are the appropriate dispositions']
+92712;['302 (c.a.)']
+90115;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+71661;['appeal would be dismissed']
+21473;['xxxxx xxxxxxxx and xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx are not convention refugees']
+65685;['appeal isallowed']
+100552;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+125020;['dismiss the appeal']
+136684;['rad allows the appeal', 'sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+101563;['appeal is granted']
+135130;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+55119;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+121809;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64367;['allow the appeal']
+42169;['appeal is allowed']
+151910;['appeal is dismissed']
+73253;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+101905;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+64854;['dismissed her appeal']
+101353;['allows this appeal']
+87387;['allows the appeal']
+81190;['appeal is allowed']
+50661;['appeal is based']
+79219;['302 (c.a.)']
+54706;['appeal is dismissed']
+96904;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+102948;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97660;['“convention refugees”']
+131747;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+98212;['appeal is allowed']
+77677;['appeal isallowed']
+97393;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+80523;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+46478;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+113618;['appeal is allowed']
+92157;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142082;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+74881;['dismiss an appeal']
+78172;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+89286;['appeal is terminated']
+80116;['appeal is dismissed']
+121846;['appellants are therefore not refugees']
+126397;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79984;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+125048;['appellant is not a genuine falun gong practitioner']
+129893;['departure orders areset aside']
+36952;['appeal is dismissed']
+29722;['appeal was dismissed']
+82109;['negative']
+26778;['motion is allowed']
+26989;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+35050;['appeal is dismissed']
+50758;['appeal is allowed']
+130677;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+136146;['appeal is dismissed']
+46103;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+50743;['appeal is based']
+65627;['departure orders are set aside']
+104122;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+84330;['appeal is allowed']
+70886;['dismiss the appeal']
+66634;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55253;['panel rejects his claim']
+91591;['appeal is allowed']
+13835;['appeal is dismissed']
+76596;['appeal is dismissed']
+102094;['appeal is allowed.the']
+124481;['rad and the rpd are not courts']
+132438;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70714;['appeal was overturned']
+73886;['claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+71073;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+130701;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94322;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100473;['panel rejects these claims']
+99834;['appeal is dismissed']
+112363;['appeal isallowed.the']
+112369;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+76839;['appeal beallowedand']
+22990;['appeal is dismissed']
+101460;['appeal isallowed']
+32133;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+131096;['appeal is dismissed']
+77452;['appeals are allowed']
+68170;['appeal of reslan salem is dismissed']
+85672;['claimant is not a person who is perceived to be linked to the']
+45987;['appeal is dismissed']
+99729;['appeal is dismissed']
+23075;['appeal is allowed']
+91097;['favorable decision']
+63202;['appeal is terminated']
+30527;['appeal were dismissed']
+101613;['appeal is dismissed']
+84651;['appeal is terminated']
+70194;['appeal is dismissed']
+143901;['appeal is dismissed']
+70935;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+128340;['appeal is allowed']
+125658;['confirm the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+47557;['appeal is determined']
+45426;['immigration appeal division therefore orders their departure from canada']
+84836;['appeal is dismissed']
+69678;['removal order is set aside']
+121869;['allow the appellant’s appeal']
+80199;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+109146;['panel rejects these claims']
+134515;['appeal is dismissed']
+71237;['appeal is allowed']
+124636;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant\xa0 is neither a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+100950;['appeal is dismissed']
+90143;['removal order is set aside']
+124169;['appeal is allowed']
+74172;['appeal will therefore proceed without an oral hearing']
+72156;['appeal is dismissed']
+125157;['appeal is granted']
+25965;['appeal is dismissed']
+94435;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74188;['substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+90314;['application is dismissed']
+55979;['appeal isallowed']
+147437;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102155;['appeal is dismissed']
+63229;['appeal is allowed']
+86874;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+80170;['appeal is dismissed']
+99473;['appeals of mandeep kaur grewal and her two children']
+111312;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+124177;['ifa fails']
+28308;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+76431;['dismiss the appeal']
+38998;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+81094;['appeal is allowed']
+99139;['appeal is allowed.the']
+52143;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+73713;['appeal is dismissed']
+83065;['appeal is allowed']
+60811;['appeal were dismissed']
+105879;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+135176;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98858;['302 (c.a.']
+140850;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76747;['appeal is dismissed']
+69254;['appeal isallowed']
+132278;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+142896;['appeal is allowed']
+95941;['appeal is allowed']
+133194;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+53140;['appeal is dismissed']
+89928;['appeal is allowed in law']
+128282;['appeal is dismissed']
+129244;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+93641;['appeal had to be dismissed']
+88446;['negative']
+145828;['302 (c.a.']
+84643;['appeal is dismissed']
+95178;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+100110;['appeal is allowed']
+38408;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+75973;['appeal is dismissed']
+79337;['appeal is terminated']
+52063;['appeal abandoned']
+95208;['appeal is terminated']
+69525;['dismiss this appeal']
+96984;['claimant is neither aconvention refugee,', 'nor a person in need of protection', 'claim is rejected']
+69680;['appeal is dismissed']
+95253;['three appeals are allowed']
+81804;['appeal isallowedand']
+91302;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74791;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69599;['appeal is allowed']
+113540;['appeal is dismissed']
+137684;['application is, therefore, dismissed', 'appeal shall proceed with the scheduled hearing']
+94649;['appeal is allowed']
+99668;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+84250;['appeal isallowed']
+69752;['appeal is allowed']
+13763;['appeal is determined']
+82385;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+126424;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+21465;['refugee division determines that xxxxxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+123868;['dismiss the appeal']
+76240;['negative']
+84739;['deny the application to re-open his appeal.']
+98297;['refugee protection claim is rejected']
+110972;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128930;['appeal is allowed']
+84485;['appeal of andrews kwabena mensah is dismissed']
+40297;['rad disagrees']
+109278;['refugee protection division rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+105430;['appeal is dismissed']
+55181;['appeal is dismissed']
+70224;['appeal would be dismissed']
+92727;['appeal is dismissed']
+36102;['appeal is allowed']
+60423;['appeal is allowed']
+127474;['appeals are dismissed']
+123124;['appeal is dismissed']
+144900;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105368;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+76676;['appeal is dismissed']
+128366;['appeal is allowed']
+131919;['appeal is allowed']
+82083;['appeal is dismissed']
+64056;['dismisses the appeal for failure']
+133404;['determination is valid in law']
+82692;['appeal isallowed']
+77615;['appeal should be dismissed']
+72213;['appeal will be allowed']
+68594;['appeal is dismissed']
+121385;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+100523;['appeal isallowed']
+88505;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68325;['appeal is dismissed']
+83066;['appeal is dismissed']
+132887;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+115223;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101336;['appeal is terminated']
+95499;['appeal is dismissed']
+99383;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+90498;['appeal is accordinglyallowed']
+123267;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+26466;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+99495;['appeal of faradusa hassan farah is allowed']
+13762;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+122773;['appeal is dismissed']
+76889;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+108194;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52288;['dismissal of this appeal']
+79933;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+127366;['appeal to the fca dismissed']
+81288;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+100521;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80064;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+148056;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97220;['appeal is dismissed']
+71166;['appeal is dismissed']
+101907;['appeal court allowed the appeal']
+95332;['dismiss this appeal']
+74043;['appeal isallowed']
+34926;['appeal is dismissed']
+42381;['dismisses this appeal']
+91619;['appeal of mohammad faim saidali is allowed']
+100598;['appeal isallowed']
+57932;['dismiss the appellant’s application to withdraw his appeal']
+99600;['appeal must be dismissed']
+48227;['appeal is allowed']
+140855;['302 (c.a.)']
+71511;['allow the appeal']
+151611;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+102401;['appeal of mohammed yehea al-amrani is dismissed']
+100995;['appeal isallowed']
+80243;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+84858;['appeal abandoned']
+61947;['appeal of louay khalil is dismissed']
+88112;['appeal is allowed']
+50513;['appeal is dismissed']
+61057;['appeal is allowed']
+112785;['panel finds the decision of the id to be valid in law']
+98885;['appeal isallowed']
+66204;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+135165;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+60812;['allow the appeal']
+60491;['appeal was dismissed']
+68985;['application is therefore granted']
+122124;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+65410;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+100922;['panel rejects his claim']
+92528;['appeal, as']
+77325;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107699;['appeal is terminated']
+144003;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84497;['appeal is allowed']
+90698;['appeal of the minister is dismissed']
+99700;['appeal is allowed']
+99329;['appeal is dismissed']
+51750;['appeal is dismissed']
+50767;['302 (c.a.']
+54311;['appeal fails']
+142298;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+53760;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx\xa0xxxxis not a“convention refugee” or a “person in need of protection']
+38990;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+101263;['appeal is granted']
+90809;['appeal is allowed']
+87793;['appeal is allowed']
+66230;['jahanzeb malik is not a canadian citizen']
+35229;['appeal of harpaul singh dale is allowed']
+58562;['allows the appeal']
+36129;['allows the appeal']
+60462;['appeal is dismissed']
+66485;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+133193;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70385;['appeal is dismissed']
+134296;['appeal is allowed.the']
+50756;['decision of the visa office is valid in law']
+82972;['appeal is dismissed']
+68978;['appeal isallowed']
+95955;['rad finds that the rpd decision does not fall within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes', 'decision is therefore set aside']
+132834;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69117;['dismiss the appeal']
+60825;['appeal isallowed']
+69382;['reject his claim']
+99270;['removal order is set aside']
+95489;['appeal being allowed']
+99745;['appeal will not be reopened']
+61457;['appeal is allowed']
+122911;['i disagree with the rpd’s reasons']
+68562;['appeal isdismissedand departure orders are made against the appellants']
+99294;['appeal is dismissed']
+34928;['appeal must fail']
+71483;['appeal is allowed']
+62253;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+125357;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee']
+151506;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57728;['appeal is terminated']
+120761;['allow the appeal']
+84352;['appeal is allowed']
+33068;['rpd decision, on the whole, is reasonable']
+83869;['appeal is allowed']
+98669;['theappeal is allowed']
+6668;['appeal is determined']
+150692;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection”']
+151762;['appeal is dismissed']
+128298;['leads me to conclude that']
+114436;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+113289;['appeal is dismissed']
+54807;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97442;['appeal is terminated']
+77051;['appeal is allowed']
+125015;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+80735;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+90199;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+132775;['appeal of maria del carmen martinez is dismissed']
+124582;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+146966;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+8269;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+130927;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, and her minor child', 'are neither refugees nor person in need of protection']
+44731;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+111337;['appeal is dismissed']
+133738;['dismiss this argument']
+23075;['appeal is allowed']
+59784;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+31995;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure form canada']
+70202;['appeal is allowed']
+143624;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57027;['appeal is dismissed']
+128182;['dismiss the appeals', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+67242;['dismissal of the appeal']
+143544;['i reject the appellant’s argument']
+61056;['appeal is allowed']
+148713;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+76512;['appeal is dismissed']
+105174;['appeal isdismissed.']
+96673;['appeal is dismissed']
+42287;['removal order is set aside']
+50656;['appeal is allowed']
+52219;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+103101;['appeal is allowed.the']
+88426;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+94667;['302 (c.a.)']
+42306;['appeal is allowed']
+76735;['appeal is allowed']
+78060;['dismissing this appeal']
+69996;['appeal beallowedand']
+100734;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+79873;['dismiss this appeal']
+132642;['appeal must fail']
+55194;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+144264;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+101395;['appeal is allowed']
+105711;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+63921;['appeal is terminated']
+67403;['appeal isallowed']
+54209;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+102062;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination rendered']
+79937;['claimant is a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59757;['appeal isallowed']
+92070;['appeal is dismissed']
+109006;['appeals should be allowed']
+57394;['appeal is dismissed']
+81053;['appeal isallowed']
+69537;['appeal is dismissed']
+85906;['allow the appeal']
+85448;['appeal is dismissed']
+75084;['appeal of sehrish chachar is dismissed']
+92778;['appeal is allowed']
+60038;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+122902;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx,is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+133358;['appeal is dismissed']
+122107;['appeal is allowed']
+82165;['appeal is allowed']
+56743;['appeal isallowed']
+152480;['302 (c.a.']
+67047;['appeal may still fail']
+47774;['appeal dismissed']
+131513;['appeal is allowed']
+85754;['appeal was adjourned']
+93085;['claims for refugee protection are rejected']
+54842;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+88421;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+49636;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+149269;['appeal is to be rescheduled']
+79604;['appeal isallowed']
+128257;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+86017;['appeal is dismissed']
+146124;['claimant, xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93325;['appeal isallowed']
+98522;['appeal is terminated']
+77437;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+99057;['appeal is allowed']
+83839;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+143841;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+114303;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+43409;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+132305;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+74168;['appeal is allowed']
+42360;['appeal is allowed']
+124541;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+97563;['appeal is terminated']
+106651;['rejects his refugee protection claim']
+17428;['appeal is dismissed']
+139442;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+89810;['appeal is allowed']
+91588;['removal order is set aside']
+25531;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+44968;['appeal is dismissed']
+113527;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+120779;['allow the appeal']
+78773;['allow the appeal', 'dismiss the appeal']
+141275;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+70579;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+107856;['not allow this application']
+91744;['appeal is dismissed']
+127350;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+124090;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+93303;['appeal is allowed']
+72180;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+122810;['rad allows the appeal']
+73706;['appeal is allowed']
+90563;['decision is wrong in law']
+102704;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+52265;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+96015;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+77092;['nor is he a “person in need or protection”']
+89231;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+80208;['claimant, xxxxxxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+97591;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+100478;['negative']
+98279;['appeal is allowed']
+113629;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91125;['appeal is allowed']
+123308;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+147617;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+107617;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+35903;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+97828;['claim is rejected']
+124964;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+123832;['dismiss the appeal']
+68130;['appeal of gemma penieropaleritis allowed in law']
+94635;['allow the appeal']
+68353;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+37426;['appeal is allowed']
+100957;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+108754;['appeal is dismissed']
+94037;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+78176;['appeal should be administratively closed']
+72014;['appeal is allowed']
+69569;['appeal is allowed']
+138801;['appeal were dismissed']
+98847;['negative']
+105771;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+147441;['re-opening application is dismissed']
+130744;['appeal is allowed']
+103549;['appeal is allowed']
+8282;['appeal abandoned']
+76716;['appeal of leticia o. de quiroz is dismissed']
+99138;['appeal isallowed.the']
+99639;['appeal is dismissed']
+121846;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47918;['appeal is determined']
+98263;['rad is unable to substitute its own determination']
+70074;['appeal is allowed']
+60437;['appeal is governed by theact']
+100306;['claimant not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+76042;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+62466;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+65651;['appeal is allowed']
+125663;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97306;['claimants are not “convention refugees”', 'nor are they “persons in need of protection']
+52620;['xxxxxxxxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+23103;['appeal of trung dong to is dismissed']
+84191;['appeal is dismissed']
+80374;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+47825;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92752;['removal order is set aside']
+63061;['appeal of thanh hoai lam is dismissed']
+60820;['appeal must be dismissed']
+66302;['dismiss this appeal']
+89557;['appeal is terminated']
+87800;['appeal is allowed']
+16825;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+72618;['appeal isallowed']
+46574;['appeal is dismissed']
+69374;['appeal is allowed']
+58559;['appeal isallowed']
+101002;['appeal isallowed']
+124001;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+38765;['302 (c.a.']
+40282;['appeal is dismissed']
+50551;['appeal isallowed']
+48721;['appeal is dismissed']
+146923;['appeal is dismissed']
+124619;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86646;['appeal is dismissed']
+54741;['cancel the stay', 'allow this appeal']
+49146;['set aside the decision and allow the appeal']
+140261;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+124009;['confirm the rpd’s decision to reject']
+94325;['appeal is allowed']
+93898;['appeal of helen idami emmanuel is dismissed']
+98136;['appeal is allowed']
+62716;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+148987;['appeal is allowed']
+88164;['appeal is dismissed']
+66658;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+71546;['appeal was dismissed']
+93930;['appeal is dismissed']
+22824;['dismiss the present appeal']
+81860;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+122988;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+34152;['appeal would be dismissed']
+96926;['302 (c.a.']
+59373;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+98114;['claimant is not a convention refugee and the']
+83471;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71991;['appeal isallowed']
+103509;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+112425;['appeal is allowed']
+59733;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+107096;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee']
+46010;['appeal is allowed']
+108252;['appellant is not a genuine falun gong practitioner']
+122532;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87500;['appeal is allowed']
+62644;['302 (c.a.']
+97853;['removal order is set aside']
+122125;['dismiss the appellant’s application to appear in-person']
+93623;['appeal of martin norbert holmes is dismissed']
+26787;['appeal is, therefore']
+53412;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+123434;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+57930;['appeal is dismissed']
+80168;['appeal filed']
+98873;['appeal is allowed']
+106441;['appeal is allowed']
+54550;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108416;['rad therefore sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'respondent is neither a “convention refugee']
+133356;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67372;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+98293;['negative']
+83047;['appeal is allowed']
+88142;['iad therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+108688;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141817;['appeal is dismissed']
+95116;['your claim fails']
+99580;['appeal is allowed']
+63063;['allow the appeal']
+116364;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+98698;['appeal is dismissed']
+24201;['appeal also dismissed']
+31461;['appeal is dismissed']
+122958;['substitutes the decision']
+146894;['appeal is dismissed']
+122767;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+14705;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+91411;['application is denied']
+68588;['appeal isallowed']
+23015;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+66309;['appeal is allowed']
+108724;['rad finds the appellant’s argument has merit']
+96345;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+83245;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+34328;['appeal is allowed']
+89258;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+151607;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+60732;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+97563;['appeal is terminated']
+134352;['guidelines are not binding on the iad']
+96265;['appeal has been abandoned']
+61910;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124060;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+97119;['appeal is terminated']
+122632;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appeal concerning him is dismissed']
+101894;['appeals are dismissed']
+141334;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+60932;['appeal is allowed']
+128147;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+103011;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+81375;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+135106;['appeal is allowed']
+144264;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+102990;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+128151;['appeal is dismissed']
+146872;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+59808;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84234;['dismiss the appeal']
+99921;['appeals of avinesh lal and malni lata are allowed']
+102121;['appeal is allowed']
+38995;['appeal is dismissed']
+26968;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+76921;['appeal is dismissed']
+151849;['rad confirms the determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are \xa0not\xa0 convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+131867;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130948;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97659;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+104460;['appeal is allowed']
+101866;['appeal is allowed.the']
+46019;['appeal is allowed']
+94076;['appeal is allowed']
+93118;['302 (c.a.)']
+102889;['appeal is rejected']
+81856;['appeal is dismissed']
+89976;['302 (c.a.']
+68461;['rad has found that the rpd decision will stand']
+100327;['appeal isallowed']
+87456;['302 (c.a.']
+138294;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+87213;['appeal is dismissed']
+94471;['appeal is allowed']
+67498;['appeal isallowed']
+105298;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134334;['appeal is allowed']
+46242;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+124972;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+77215;['appeal isallowed']
+111288;['rad confirms\xa0 the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90609;['appeal is dismissed']
+130008;['claimants are not convention refugees, and not persons in need of protection']
+36101;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+88413;['appeal is allowed']
+82378;['appeal is dismissed']
+93882;['appeal of ephraim molapyane mahlase is dismissed']
+74856;['allow the appeal of makhan singh mangat']
+32170;['appeal is allowed']
+60878;['appeal is terminated']
+143899;['uphold this finding']
+101184;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+57513;['appeal is dismissed']
+52370;['appeal is allowed']
+91170;['appeal is allowed']
+81203;['appeal is dismissed']
+96006;['claimant is a refugeesur placeas']
+67484;['appeal is dismissed']
+151386;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+12210;['appeal be dismissed']
+28467;['appeal isallowedand']
+110970;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+117147;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+92442;['appeal is terminated']
+91674;['appeal is dismissed']
+132840;['appeal is not allowed']
+100607;['appeal is dismissed']
+100918;['appeal must be dismissed']
+113527;['appeals are based']
+129917;['appeal is allowed']
+87283;['302 (c.a.']
+135200;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee']
+121474;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125403;['substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant is a convention refugee']
+92145;['appeal were dismissed']
+91300;['appeal is granted']
+74606;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+148734;['application forvacationis allowed']
+56959;['appeal is dismissed']
+99919;['appeal has been abandoned']
+63165;['appeal is terminated']
+89774;['appeal is allowed']
+79222;['appeal is dismissed']
+17936;['appeal is dismissed']
+128283;['appeal of shannon denise whitford is allowed']
+71240;['appeal is dismissed']
+123839;['appeal is allowed']
+44435;['appeal isallowed']
+39827;['application is dismissed']
+105370;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93897;['appeal is allowed']
+47818;['appeal dismissed']
+26726;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+80000;['claimants, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxand xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxnot to be convention refugees and not to be persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+142078;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+90768;['rpd is set aside']
+80553;['removal order isset aside']
+50933;['appeal should be dismissed']
+46245;['appeal is terminated']
+87358;['appeal of jiexian feng is allowed']
+128878;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+93149;['appeal is determined']
+101302;['appeal is granted']
+144897;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision that, in its opinion, should have been made', 'not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82570;['appeal is allowed']
+89252;['appeal isallowed']
+70946;['appeal is allowed']
+49156;['reopens this appeal and finds that this file shall proceed']
+95920;['appeal is dismissed']
+121434;['appeal would be dismissed']
+93278;['claimant,xxxx xxxx,is not a “convention refugee”']
+116791;['appeal is allowed']
+110997;['appeal is dismissed']
+122775;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108247;['appeal is dismissed']
+97451;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+33330;['appeal is consequently dismissed']
+78186;['appeal is allowed']
+123007;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+75000;['appeal is dismissed']
+49544;['appeal of arafat abdul fattah']
+34893;['appeal is allowed']
+82981;['appeal is allowed']
+22824;['dismiss the present appeal']
+93222;['appeal isdismissed.']
+90554;['appeal is dismissed']
+104094;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+50442;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+82853;['appeal is allowed']
+81065;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+98619;['appeal is dismissed']
+54163;['appeal is allowed']
+71384;['appeal is dismissed']
+34935;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61913;['appeal is dismissed']
+97012;['negative']
+45387;['appeal is allowed']
+124265;['appeal is allowed']
+52153;['appeal is re-opened']
+132279;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+123993;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+80193;['panel rejects his claim']
+142872;['appeal is allowed']
+94102;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+23110;['appeal is dismissed']
+94161;['appeal is dismissed']
+84764;['appeal is allowed']
+104024;['appeal is allowed']
+101419;['appeal is allowed']
+97525;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+69419;['appeal is allowed']
+67725;['appeal of thanh kiem nguyen is dismissed']
+90038;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+94998;['appeal is allowed']
+107133;['appeal must fail']
+85672;['appeal is dismissed']
+117188;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+98290;['appeal is dismissed']
+19382;['appeal is allowed']
+80796;['appeal is allowed']
+110300;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86194;['appeal is allowed']
+85912;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+115233;['rad agrees with this reasoning']
+77918;['appeal is allowed']
+37401;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108737;['appellant’s argument fails']
+84512;['appeal is allowed']
+32078;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+123942;['dismisses the appeals']
+61343;['appeal is allowed']
+102086;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+107030;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+92854;['appeal is terminated']
+151486;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71808;['appeal is allowed']
+94096;['appeal is dismissed']
+97620;['appeal is allowed']
+99402;['appeal is allowed']
+79742;['appeal is allowed']
+76746;['appeal is dismissed']
+82858;['appeal of juliet b. torres is dismissed']
+50516;['appeal is dismissed']
+98466;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+125100;['appellant is neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+142508;['are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+144723;['appeal be dismissed']
+79329;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90723;['dismisses this appeal']
+108880;['claimant is not a convention refuge']
+78023;['appeal is allowed']
+62893;['appeal isallowed']
+145039;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107289;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+94014;['appeal is allowed']
+35552;['302 (c.a.']
+100096;['rad is unable to substitute its own decision']
+93607;['302 (c.a.)']
+94760;['claim is rejected']
+151400;['appeal is allowed']
+65645;['allows the appeal']
+94046;['appeal of parminder kaur hayre is dismissed']
+46036;['appeal is dismissed']
+60417;['appeal be terminated']
+148605;['appeal is dismissed']
+49146;['immigration officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+95877;['appeal isallowed']
+76321;['allowed the appeals']
+124429;['appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97946;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+122649;['appeal is allowed']
+122828;['appeal is dismissed']
+47142;['claimant is not a convention refugeeandis not a person in need of protection']
+76061;['appeal is terminated']
+60369;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+104858;['appeal isallowed']
+151896;['rad upholds the rpd decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+55269;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.']
+70777;['appeal isallowed']
+80124;['removal order is set aside']
+120822;['not dismiss this appeal']
+94775;['claimants are not being persecuted']
+122361;['substitute my determination', 'appellant is a refugee']
+81880;['appeal is allowed.the']
+61428;['claim is rejected']
+56735;['appeal underparagraph 67(1)(c) will be dismissed']
+131082;['appeal is dismissed']
+82461;['appeal is dismissed']
+129216;['appeal is dismissed']
+91594;['appeal is dismissed']
+99283;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s reasons']
+141297;['substitute my finding']
+28064;['appeal of sarmukh singh sangha is dismissed']
+64226;['appeal is dismissed']
+84850;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+99879;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87218;['negative']
+91450;['decision is valid in law']
+59404;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+116850;['appeal is allowed']
+70186;['appeal is allowed']
+77278;['appeal is allowed.the']
+98469;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+68340;['appeal is allowed']
+102731;"['thatxxxx xxxxis a ""convention refugee']"
+105631;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+61471;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+129392;['rad substitutes a positive determination']
+133406;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76254;['appeal is allowed']
+84764;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84148;['appeal isallowed']
+40296;['appeal is dismissed']
+99571;['appeal is allowed']
+95470;['appeal is dismissed']
+146774;['appeal is dismissed']
+122236;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+82396;['appeal is dismissed']
+138797;['appeal isallowed.the']
+93961;['appeal is dismissed']
+52286;['appeal is dismissed']
+100255;['appeal is allowed']
+94630;['appeal is dismissed']
+118266;['appeal is allowed']
+100010;['302 (c.a.']
+89068;['appeal isallowedand']
+102741;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113618;['appeal is allowed']
+56706;['appeal isallowed']
+84056;['appeal is   therefore allowed']
+71329;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+35070;['appeal is dismissed']
+68138;['confirm the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+70418;['appeal is allowed']
+81628;['determination is valid in law']
+95901;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+101699;['allow the appeal']
+57733;['appeal was from a deportation order issued']
+122665;['appeal is allowed']
+54292;['appeal is dismissed']
+132419;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+124461;['substitute the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+14486;['appeal is terminated']
+135193;['appeal is allowed']
+89118;['appeal isallowed']
+84739;['appeal is not re-opened']
+97845;['reject her claim']
+92959;['allow the appeal']
+99552;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47884;['appeal is dismissed']
+16822;['rad is unable to substitute a decision']
+67246;['appeal is dismissed']
+71791;['appeal isallowed']
+63067;['appeal is denied']
+91209;['appeal is allowed']
+116211;['appeal is allowed.pursuant', 'set aside the determination of the rpd', 'ms. xxxx is a convention refugee']
+107554;['refugee appeal division dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69225;['rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'substitutes its own determination']
+36250;['appeal is allowed']
+131075;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+116770;['appeal is allowed']
+100560;['appeal isallowed']
+87820;['302 (c.a.)']
+13757;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99512;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+69758;['appeals are allowed']
+133271;['rad therefore finds that the claim under section 97 cannot succeed']
+94903;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+110910;['dismissing an appeal']
+71704;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+63973;['appeal isallowed']
+91923;['appeal is allowed']
+120748;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+75233;['appeal is dismissed']
+108699;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination', 'respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94211;['dismiss this appeal']
+73301;['i am going to dismiss this appeal']
+141274;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+105651;['rad does not confirm the rpd’s determination']
+99689;['appeal is allowed']
+104849;['appeal is dismissed']
+65115;['appeal is allowed']
+75499;['allow the appeal of paramdeep kaur brar in law']
+71101;['appeal of salahuddin basir patel is dismissed']
+81177;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+108678;['they are neither convention refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+81824;['appeal is allowed']
+78671;['appeal is dismissed']
+61316;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+145590;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+66766;['appeal is dismissed']
+116771;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm its determination']
+101409;['appeal is allowed']
+145856;['appeal is dismissed']
+76004;['appeal is dismissed']
+14678;['not a convention refugee']
+128612;['appellants are not credible']
+123449;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+34933;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80736;['302 (c.a.']
+70398;['decision is well-founded in law']
+75924;['appeal is dismissed']
+139477;['sponsorship, however, was later withdrawn']
+87138;['appeal is allowed']
+132790;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+108728;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72168;['appeal is allowed']
+76560;['appeal isallowed.the']
+61805;['negative']
+139448;['appeal isallowed']
+94415;['appeal is allowed']
+68292;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+41248;['appeal is terminated']
+64281;['appeal is dismissed']
+76393;['substitute the determination', 'substitute\xa0 /\xa0 ']
+139873;['substitute my own determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+45235;['appeal be dismissed']
+96865;['appeal is terminated']
+102115;['appeal of shahbaz raza is dismissed']
+86524;['appeal isallowedand']
+94429;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136729;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47138;['appeal is allowed']
+97491;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+88369;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+105636;['appeal is allowed']
+105774;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+19997;['appeal is allowed']
+59549;['appeal is allowed']
+77240;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+122892;['302 (c.a.']
+77291;['appeal is allowed']
+122976;['appeal is allowed']
+76795;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+63097;['negative']
+98271;['appeal of ruo wen liu is dismissed']
+85948;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+53104;['appeal is allowed']
+81624;['appeal is dismissed']
+92737;['removal order is set aside']
+60982;['appeal is dismissed']
+84636;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+145432;['appeal is allowed']
+60084;['negative']
+42386;['determination is valid in law']
+62627;['appeal is dismissed']
+143603;['appeal is valid in law']
+131231;['appeal is allowed']
+76759;['appeal is dismissed']
+93957;['appeal is terminated']
+100916;['appeal isallowed']
+40297;['appeal must therefore fail']
+99642;['appeal is dismissed']
+100961;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+120759;['substitute my decision that the appellant has established his identity']
+108763;['appeal is allowed']
+102123;['appeal is allowed']
+99574;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98611;['appeal is allowed']
+82797;['appeal isallowed']
+47128;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+87421;['appeal is dismissed']
+123326;['appeal is dismissed']
+122092;['appeal is allowed']
+128300;['appeals are dismissed']
+63811;['negative\xa0 /\xa0 ']
+94842;['appeal is terminated']
+97902;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68174;['appeal is dismissed']
+61057;['appeal is allowed']
+94779;['removal order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost her status as a permanent resident of canada']
+78744;['decisions are well founded in law and in fact']
+100664;['appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+38784;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+135187;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122948;['rad agrees with that rpd finding']
+98599;['appeal is allowed']
+54290;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+134417;['appeal is dismissed']
+57084;['appeal isallowed']
+112328;['appeal is dismissed']
+101676;['appeal is allowed']
+57098;['appeal is allowed in law']
+107890;['appeal is allowed']
+77032;['appeal isallowed']
+106448;['appeal of abdi ali ibrahim is allowed']
+31984;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+96675;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+131700;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61431;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx, is neither a convention refugee', 'nor person in need of protection']
+123631;['dismiss the appeal']
+85526;['appeal ofru die li (also known as rudie li']
+12214;['appeal is allowed.the']
+62623;['appeal is allowed']
+100345;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+133696;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+68895;['dismiss the appeal']
+148270;['rpd decision is set aside', 'appellants are recognized as protected persons']
+56893;['appeal is dismissed']
+100675;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+93779;['appellants are neither convention refugees or a person’s in need of protection']
+124480;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80380;['appeal fails']
+90197;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+88332;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'theappellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+35072;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+81869;['appeal is allowed']
+77815;['claimant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+90608;['appeal is allowed']
+104091;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'nor are they persons in need of protection']
+87701;['refugee protection division rejects this claim', 'claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84529;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+87052;['appeal is allowed']
+8295;['appeals of the principal appellantcatherine mauricette lecoq(mb2-02785) and of the appellantspaul antoine victor lecoq(mb2-02784) andmelvin pierre paul lecoq(mb2-02787) areallowed.']
+107152;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+43709;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+36245;['departure order is set aside']
+103721;['panel rejects this claim']
+151765;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52060;['appeal is allowed']
+68681;['appeal is allowed']
+125478;['her claim fails']
+106414;['rejects the claim of the principal appellant and associate appellant']
+108189;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99396;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+60700;['appeal is dismissed']
+79942;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+95965;['appeal is allowed']
+79464;['appeal is dismissed']
+128391;['determination is valid in law']
+147435;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82247;['appeal is allowed']
+81155;['appeal is dismissed']
+29721;['appeal isallowed']
+100736;['appeal is dismissed']
+82458;['appeal is terminated']
+85911;['allow this appeal on review']
+148687;['dismiss the appeal']
+97571;['appeal is dismissed']
+54719;['appeal is dismissed']
+71139;['appeal is allowed']
+135141;['appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+85388;['appeal isallowed']
+98317;['appeal is allowed']
+148715;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+111323;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+56718;['appeal is allowed']
+83073;['application is dismissed']
+69127;['allow the appeal of luis alberto garcia']
+73020;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+98758;['claim is therefore rejected']
+26675;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+108705;['appeals must also fail']
+149631;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+40072;['appeal is allowed']
+55282;['appeal is dismissed']
+132630;['appeal is dismissed']
+65707;['appeal is allowed']
+53137;['appeal is dismissed']
+24237;['appeal is allowed']
+86644;['appeals are dismissed']
+131721;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+99944;['appeal is dismissed']
+102477;['appeal is allowed']
+69360;['302 (c.a.']
+107216;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96320;['panel rejects her claim']
+107931;['appeal is dismissed']
+77953;['appeal of daniel dennis llagas abundo', 'abundo is dismissed']
+56745;['appeal of s.m.']
+50519;['appeal is allowed']
+21365;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+56749;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+128374;['appeal is allowed']
+81084;['appeal is allowed']
+77466;['appeal is terminated']
+64309;['appeal is allowed']
+15011;['rad dismissed the appeal']
+94547;['appeal of ajaib singh sahota is dismissed']
+129127;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100213;['claimant is neither aconvention refugee']
+153732;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59976;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+99021;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+81271;['appeal is dismissed']
+19152;['dismiss the appeal']
+131067;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+104470;['removal order is set aside']
+58388;['refusal is invalid in law']
+89856;['neither a convention refugee nor a person described insection 97.1(b) of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+84783;['appeal is dismissed']
+84607;['dismiss the appeal']
+134289;['“regulations”']
+78039;['appeal is dismissed']
+71191;['appeal is allowed']
+145325;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+135169;['dismiss the appeal']
+87519;['appeals are allowed.the']
+80251;['302 (c.a.']
+102694;['appeal is allowed']
+26909;['xxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxx are not convention refugees']
+74620;['appeal is dismissed']
+70884;['allow this appeal']
+92755;['appeal were allowed']
+31420;['appeals are allowed']
+74779;['302 (c.a.']
+84521;['appeal is allowed']
+55194;['appeal is dismissed']
+52324;['appeal is allowed']
+139443;['appeal is not allowed']
+146817;['substitute my own decision that the appellantsxxxx']
+85944;['appeal is allowed']
+151574;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+142477;['dismiss the appeal']
+73224;['appeal is determined']
+127449;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+42415;['appeal is dismissed']
+148493;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+91448;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+131043;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129856;['appeal is allowed']
+87452;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+29706;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+71496;['appeal isallowed']
+87368;['appeal is dismissed']
+122617;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are excluded']
+83830;['appeal is']
+80750;['claimant is not aconvention refugee']
+34942;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+77117;['appeal isallowed.the']
+38239;['appeals are dismissed']
+147009;['appeal is allowed']
+95534;['appeal is dismissed']
+99283;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision does not fall within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes']
+124825;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+134490;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80242;['rejects the claim of xxxxx xxx xxxx to be a convention refugee']
+60939;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+98480;['negative']
+71148;['appeal is allowed']
+91563;['appeal is dismissed']
+47299;['appeal is allowed']
+132850;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+76758;['appeal is terminated']
+69500;['dismiss this appeal']
+17156;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+87024;['appeal is dismissed']
+132750;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+35058;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+95888;['rad disagrees']
+129157;['appeals be dismissed']
+94990;['appeal isallowed']
+90194;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+103697;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84544;['appeal isallowed']
+76093;['appeal is dismissed']
+101416;['appeal is allowed']
+107639;['appeal isallowed']
+104489;['appeal is dismissed']
+121541;['appeals would be dismissed']
+109143;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86905;['appeal is dismissed']
+121197;['appeal is dismissed']
+14661;['refugee division determines xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxx to be a convention refugee']
+99716;['appeal is allowed']
+140788;['dismissing the appeal']
+77788;['appeal is allowed']
+138863;['appeal is dismissed']
+125625;['appeal is allowed']
+100135;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+91190;['appeal is allowed']
+84718;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+123306;['appeal is allowed']
+107626;['appeal is allowed']
+138807;['appeal is allowed']
+90908;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+143460;['302 (c.a.']
+68343;['appeal is allowed']
+100790;['appeal is allowed']
+98161;['appeal is dismissed']
+69094;['appeal is denied']
+49146;['appeal isallowed']
+83825;['appeal is allowed.the']
+71794;['appeal isallowed']
+67522;['dismissing this appeal']
+102701;['rad concurs with the rpd’s finding on this issue']
+82236;['appeal is allowed']
+122535;['appellants are convention refugees / persons in need of protection']
+84190;['appeal must be dismissed']
+42207;['appeal is allowed']
+14580;['appeal isallowed']
+41081;['appeal is terminated']
+87819;['appeal is withdrawn']
+123045;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a person in need of protection']
+86633;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+91287;['negative']
+86152;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+79690;['appeal is dismissed']
+68187;['removal order is set aside']
+51743;['appeal must be dismissed']
+104026;['panel cannot grant refugee status']
+80191;['claimantsxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxare not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+49515;['allow the appeal']
+108676;['refugee protection division rejects her claim', 'claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+128180;['appeal is allowed']
+151742;['dismiss this appeal']
+125467;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+71404;['application to extend the time to file a notice of appeal is dismissed']
+103527;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+98122;['arenot convention refugees and not persons in need of protection', 'i therefore reject their claims']
+90556;['appeal is dismissed']
+51281;['appeal is terminated']
+124643;['not find that the rpd erred.']
+127465;['appeal is dismissed']
+71142;['appellant zhen huang has not lost his permanent resident status']
+48283;['i find that the rpd’s reasons are clear and explicit']
+97374;['302 (c.a.)']
+40297;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103637;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107694;['appeal is allowed']
+89516;['appeal be dismissed']
+107482;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102900;['appeal isallowed']
+69439;['appeal isallowed']
+78330;['appeal isallowed']
+41803;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+10172;['appeal of j.m.']
+102459;['appeal is dismissed']
+95255;['appeal isallowed']
+141670;['decision is legally valid']
+46452;['appeal is denied']
+95404;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+124131;['appeal is dismissed']
+153017;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+89405;['appeal is dismissed']
+24514;['appeal is dismissed']
+61800;['claim is rejected']
+107852;['appeal is dismissed']
+76739;['appeal is allowed']
+105643;['appeal is dismissed']
+130733;['appeal is dismissed']
+94208;['appeal is allowed']
+87682;['appeal was dismissed']
+61930;['appeal is allowed']
+125467;['appeal is allowed']
+71696;['appeal isallowed']
+106820;['appeal is allowed']
+23034;['appeal is allowed']
+95952;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132643;['uphold its finding']
+60041;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87441;['302 (c.a.']
+95402;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+74840;['appeal isallowed.the']
+151526;['appeal is dismissed']
+123049;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+34887;['appeal of kazeem kehinde ogungbemi is dismissed']
+8290;['appeal isallowed']
+71153;['appeal of doreen porohowski is allowed']
+96171;['appeal is dismissed']
+95322;['allow the appeal']
+93683;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+77977;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+8969;['appeal is allowed']
+76728;['appeal is allowed']
+71281;['appeal is allowed']
+80993;['appeal is dismissed']
+103528;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98498;['appeal is dismissed']
+125536;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee”']
+150658;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94448;['appeals are dismissed']
+142808;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+62642;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+110723;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90410;['motion to reopen is allowed']
+67256;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100063;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+97844;['negative']
+26874;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+83483;['appeal was not allowed']
+100160;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+54518;['appeal will be dismissed']
+103296;['appeal is allowed']
+96623;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+75475;['appeal is dismissed']
+88523;['refugee protection claimant is not a “convention refugee', 'not a “person in need of protection']
+50523;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+99886;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+130991;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+84016;['allow the appeal']
+93967;['appeal is allowed']
+96834;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+59936;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+47558;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+100811;['appeal is allowed.the']
+89190;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+105319;['rad finds that the rpd’s findings']
+82885;['appeal is allowed']
+72888;['appeal is dismissed']
+125454;['302 (c.a.']
+31433;['appeal is dismissed']
+76907;['appeal isallowed']
+130977;['appeal also fails']
+51087;['dismissing the appeal']
+142972;['appeal isdismissed.']
+70195;['appeal is dismissed']
+95775;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+128367;['appeal is allowed']
+108202;['appeals are dismissed']
+81847;['appeal is dismissed']
+89803;['appeal is allowed']
+90779;['appeal isallowed']
+79469;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+47580;['appeal is allowed']
+104069;['appeal isallowed']
+100297;['appeal is dismissed']
+68175;['appeal is governed by theact']
+147445;['claimants, they are not convention refugees, they are not entitled to protection']
+59849;['appeal is dismissed']
+144567;['associate appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+56736;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+78000;['appeals are allowed.the']
+99807;['appeal is dismissed']
+76563;['appeal is allowed']
+48419;['appeal of brenda lee starblanket is allowed']
+94531;['appeal is allowed']
+82220;['appeal is allowed']
+123063;['rad rejects these arguments']
+76034;['dismissing this appeal']
+57941;['appeal is dismissed']
+47790;['appeal were dismissed']
+88410;['appeal was dismissed']
+92158;['appeal is dismissed']
+79601;['appeal is allowed']
+130764;['appeal by the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness is allowed.the', 'decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+146902;['appeal is allowed']
+99382;['panel rejects these claims']
+96941;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+83309;['appeal isallowed.the']
+14680;['thatxxxx xxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+47752;['302 (c.a.)']
+44431;['servant was dismissed']
+105419;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90582;['decision of the visa officer is not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+60930;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+145033;['theappealsare allowed']
+44076;['appeal is dismissed']
+144036;['dismiss the appeal']
+101265;['appeal is allowed']
+52290;['appeal isallowed']
+153611;['302 (c.a.']
+95122;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+129926;['appeal be allowed or dismissed']
+100509;['appeal is dismissed']
+85936;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+113531;['appeal isallowed']
+78058;['appeal isallowed']
+27013;['appeal is allowed']
+115232;['302 (c.a.']
+130950;['302 (c.a.']
+60659;['appeal is allowed']
+109696;['rad finds the rpd has not erred']
+99166;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+41963;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+67012;['rad does not find the appellant to be a convention refugee']
+123311;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82172;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+132642;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+83668;['appeal of ahmed baba fall is dismissed']
+108211;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+38776;['appeal is dismissed']
+116819;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+39902;['appeal is dismissed']
+35061;['appeal isallowed']
+61902;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107898;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+146437;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, or person in need of protection']
+139472;['determination is valid in law']
+26807;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+77880;['302 (c.a.']
+23024;['appeal is dismissed']
+84494;['appeal is dismissed']
+143872;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'adult associate appellant and the minor associate appellant are neither convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+142958;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+74165;['confirms the impugned decision thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+106611;['appeal is dismissed']
+63921;['appeal dismissed']
+80996;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74855;['allow the appeal']
+56634;['appeal is dismissed']
+89921;['immigration officer’s decision is therefore upheld']
+147467;['appeal is dismissed']
+143461;['302 (c.a.']
+74166;['appeal is dismissed']
+148617;['appeal is dismissed']
+123401;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97200;['negative']
+90920;['appeal was dismissed']
+92564;['appeal is terminated']
+98195;['panel rejects these claims for refugee protection']
+84341;['appeal of maher bitar is dismissed']
+100200;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+72070;['appeal is allowed']
+62119;['appeal is dismissed']
+80826;['claim is rejected']
+77242;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+142729;['appeal is allowed']
+143925;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93072;['appeal is allowed']
+136719;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+103801;['claimants are found not to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99843;['appeal of carrie lee paquette is dismissed']
+110710;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+131531;['appeal is allowed']
+74892;['allow the appeal']
+99382;['negative']
+69320;['appeal isallowed']
+125419;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+50619;['appeal of the appellant is dismissed']
+98042;['appeal is allowed']
+96771;['all claims fail']
+149021;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+98591;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+93161;['appeal is allowed']
+61032;['appeal is dismissed']
+92157;['removal order is set aside']
+100139;['appeal is allowed']
+140256;['appeal is dismissed']
+68288;['appeal should be dismissed']
+106163;['appeal is dismissed']
+77973;['appeal is dismissed']
+91632;['appeal of ngoc suong ngo is allowed']
+82447;['motion to re-open under section 71 of theactis denied']
+118134;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99951;['appeal ofashok sadhwaniis dismissed']
+84206;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+54174;['sufficient h&c considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+67251;['appeal isallowed']
+110958;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of   ']
+114370;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+58521;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108805;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd']
+152946;['rad finds that she is a convention refugee']
+123268;['appeal of the ma, xxxx xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+52313;['appeal is allowed']
+71552;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+26972;['not convention refugees.']
+127361;['decision applies equally tos']
+57823;['appeal was dismissed']
+109763;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+146829;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+95626;['appeals of bing sen zhang and hui juan yang are dismissed']
+102295;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+110958;['appeal is dismissed']
+101520;['claimants are neither convention refugees']
+74180;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82158;['appeal is dismissed']
+28297;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+65128;['dismissed the appeal']
+50931;['appeal is dismissed']
+121471;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination']
+71704;['appeal is allowed']
+106403;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96307;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+104091;['302 (c.a.']
+97402;['appeal isallowed']
+77615;['appeal allowed']
+98919;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+130917;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+46080;['appeal is allowed']
+43045;['appeal is dismissed']
+71429;['appeal of van thang tran is dismissed']
+102536;['determination is valid in law']
+107140;['appeal must fail']
+100994;['appeal isallowed']
+86029;['appeal is allowed']
+107094;['appeal was dismissed']
+90797;['appeal is dismissed']
+61508;['thatxxxxxxxxxx-xxxxx,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxx-xxxxxare not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+88028;['negative']
+77993;['appeal was postponed']
+124680;['appeal is allowed']
+66904;['appeal be and is hereby dismissed']
+125404;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is a\xa0“convention refugee”']
+89779;['appeal is dismissed']
+100770;['appeal is dismissed']
+122885;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision', 'substitute a positive decision on this claim']
+84677;['appeal is terminated']
+68893;['appeal is allowed']
+52115;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+125610;['appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96670;['appeal is allowed']
+85222;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+136721;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83458;['appeal is dismissed']
+81924;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is dismissed']
+100088;['appeal is allowed']
+84227;['appeal isallowed']
+149496;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+60899;['appeal is dismissed']
+70202;['appeal is allowed']
+95197;['appeals are allowed']
+71569;['dismissed the appeal']
+142539;['rpd determination rejecting the claim for refugee protection']
+94913;['claimants are convention refugeessur place']
+90908;['is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+4743;['appeal is therefore premature']
+104122;['claimants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76339;['appeal is dismissed']
+110971;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55881;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+59143;['appeal isallowed.the']
+94688;['appeal is allowed']
+151856;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90701;['appeal is dismissed']
+123251;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136088;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+60199;['appeal is allowed']
+99973;['appeal isdismissed.']
+94084;['appeal is dismissed']
+77276;['appeal is terminated']
+83835;['appeal is allowed']
+107129;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+45237;['appeal is allowed']
+31381;['appeal is allowed in law']
+82170;['appeal is allowed']
+92455;['appeal is dismissed']
+122562;['appeal is allowed']
+151002;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87594;['negative']
+84211;['appeal isdismissed.']
+8292;['appeal is dismissed']
+73596;['appeal was dismissed']
+76525;['appeal is dismissed']
+56726;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+95366;['appeal isallowed']
+69084;['appeal is allowed in law']
+99244;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125432;['removal order is set aside']
+99804;['appeal is allowed']
+80169;['appeal is dismissed']
+151798;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91142;['appeal is allowed']
+140878;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+47720;['appeal is allowed']
+128420;['appeals are dismissed']
+129867;['appeal is dismissed']
+140721;['rad is not able to substitute its own determination']
+78012;['appeal is dismissed']
+128342;['appeals are dismissed']
+143550;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+99755;['appeal is allowed']
+129918;['appeal is allowed']
+75584;['appeal is allowed']
+38771;['appeal is granted']
+114317;['dismissing the appeal']
+125358;['appeal is allowed']
+123551;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61230;['allowing the appeal']
+148062;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99690;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+83826;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+131188;['appeal is allowed']
+69561;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+98761;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95093;['claim is rejected']
+152919;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+100335;['deny your claims']
+26693;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+142437;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+85962;['appeal of charles ezechinyere ibezimako is dismissed']
+95066;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+143603;['appeal dismissed']
+72184;['i am going to dismiss the appeal']
+73363;['dismiss their appeal']
+122111;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+108083;['302 (c.a.']
+86057;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+69485;['application is denied']
+78691;['appeal is allowed']
+105312;['appeal is dismissed']
+89724;['appeal is allowed']
+130788;['appeal is allowed']
+86408;['appeal is dismissed']
+124038;['appeal is allowed']
+144416;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+110966;['appeals   are dismissed']
+100358;['appeals are allowed']
+28094;['appeal filed byabla benmakhlouf(mb2-04372)isallowed.the']
+150152;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+73183;['appeal is dismissed']
+92970;['four appeals are dismissed']
+94021;['appeal is dismissed']
+75159;['appeal isallowed']
+72701;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+107190;['set aside the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+95458;['appeal is dismissed']
+96923;['302 (c.a.']
+56675;['appeal is terminated']
+143531;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76311;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+74104;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxand her two children,', 'not “convention refugees”']
+77857;['negative']
+59925;['appeal is dismissed']
+99801;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84700;['appeal isallowed']
+55113;['allow the appeal']
+109633;['appellant to be a convention refugee']
+65669;['appeal is dismissed']
+100643;['appeal is dismissed']
+98276;['appeal is allowed']
+76444;['appeal is allowed']
+123122;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+43403;['appeal is dismissed']
+64629;['appeal isallowed.the']
+77614;['appeal dismissed']
+47393;['appeal is allowed']
+149282;['appeal is also allowed']
+97806;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+128158;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90231;['xxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+91736;['appeal isallowed']
+68703;['appeal is dismissed']
+113743;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56721;['dismiss this appeal']
+63929;['appeal allowed']
+132415;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95220;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+82889;['appeal is dismissed']
+108208;['appeal is dismissed']
+99912;['appeal is dismissed']
+151401;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94091;['appeal is allowed']
+132266;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+105341;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+76403;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+149579;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+52642;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+21308;['appeal is dismissed']
+131736;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare convention refugees']
+21310;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84301;['appeal isallowed']
+149485;['appeal is dismissed']
+63203;['appeal is dismissed']
+16826;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96769;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+78019;['appeal is dismissed']
+89406;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+71146;['appeal must be dismissed']
+125431;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124270;['appeal is dismissed']
+130796;['appeal is allowed']
+151946;['rad upholds the rpd decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+57308;['dismissing this appeal']
+87862;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+106781;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+89078;['appeal is dismissed']
+69322;['appeal is dismissed']
+97255;['appeal is allowed']
+144386;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+123467;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94758;['appeal is terminated']
+68974;['appeal is allowed']
+129185;['dismiss the application for an extension of time']
+84193;['appeal is dismissed']
+94720;['appeal is dismissed']
+96560;['appeal is dismissed']
+102936;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+91191;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+99746;['appeals are dismissed']
+97195;['claimants are neither a convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+92812;['appeal is dismissed']
+67267;['appeal isallowed']
+22805;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpa']
+90223;['appeal is terminated']
+124067;['appeal is dismissed']
+125054;['rad finds that to be a denial of basic natural justice']
+98882;['302 (c.a.']
+79969;['negative']
+142727;['302 (c.a.']
+113526;['appeal is allowed']
+127365;['confirm the appellant’s lack of credibility']
+50428;['appeals are dismissed']
+142291;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+47919;['appellant lost permanent resident status']
+73711;['appeal is allowed']
+113588;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+100134;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+74839;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+60419;['appeal is allowed']
+107442;['302 (c.a.']
+96667;['claim is rejected']
+99513;['appeal is allowed']
+89417;['appeal isdismissed.']
+76163;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+141646;['appeal were dismissed']
+86009;['appeal is allowed']
+114369;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+95664;['appeal is dismissed']
+100069;['negative determination']
+125119;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx (a.k.a.']
+84480;['appeal is dismissed']
+77074;['appeal isallowed']
+82424;['appeal is dismissed']
+101579;['carlos alberto rico melo is inadmissible as alleged']
+93303;['appeal is allowed']
+86939;['appeal is allowed']
+93894;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+82440;['appeal isallowed.the']
+64295;['appeal of deborah angela henry is dismissed']
+22121;['appeal is dismissed']
+123780;['302\xa0(c.a.']
+122935;['appeal is allowed']
+80452;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+82159;['appeal fails']
+89998;['302 (c.a.']
+57067;['appeal is allowed']
+131217;['appeals are allowed']
+106443;['appeal oflyle gordon thompsonis allowed']
+93904;['appeal is allowed']
+70948;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'i reject their claims']
+75590;['appeal is allowed']
+100415;['exclusion order is set aside']
+124828;['application is denied']
+89283;['appeal is allowed']
+80825;['appeal is dismissed']
+14702;['appeal bedismissed.']
+69969;['determination is valid in law']
+75440;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+45423;['removal order isset aside']
+134425;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+134284;['allow the appeal']
+59838;['appeal is allowed']
+9490;['appeals should be dismissed']
+122245;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+84511;['appeal is dismissed']
+56726;['appeal is allowed']
+90995;['appeal is allowed']
+60998;['appeal is dismissed']
+107814;['refugee protection division rejects the claimants’ claim for refugee protection']
+70599;['appellant has not lost his / her permanent resident status']
+102461;['appeal is dismissed']
+56820;['reject this claim for refugee protection']
+78714;['appeal should be dismissed']
+95635;['appeal abandoned']
+94576;['negative']
+123993;['appeal is allowed']
+57029;['appeal is dismissed']
+123945;['appeal is dismissed']
+65106;['appeal must be dismissed']
+77655;['appeal dismissed']
+41571;['appeal is dismissed']
+131714;['appeal is allowed']
+96740;['claimant is determined to be neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63868;['appeal is dismissed']
+47307;['dismissing the appeal']
+137452;['appeals are dismissed']
+24471;['appeal is allowed']
+77818;['negative']
+100093;['they are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95940;['decision is therefore set aside']
+75255;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+66632;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132835;['appeal is allowed']
+97956;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+68679;['appeal of jagjiwan singh tung is dismissed']
+81131;['appeal is allowed']
+116817;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+13973;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+91156;['appeal is dismissed']
+99674;['appeal is subject toissue estoppeland']
+121459;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+81053;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+62439;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+21324;['you are not a convention refugee']
+34927;['appeals are dismissed']
+90028;['appeal isallowed']
+122656;['appeal is allowed']
+84827;['appeal is terminated']
+80213;['panel rejects herclaim for refugee protection']
+52097;['appellants are excluded from refugee protection']
+47362;['appeal is dismissed']
+71380;['appeal is dismissed']
+97778;['claimant is not a ‘convention refugee’']
+77606;['appeal is allowed']
+84030;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+90439;['removal orders are set aside']
+61213;['appeal is allowed']
+90269;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62252;['negative']
+150719;['set aside the rpd’s decision that', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is not convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+101003;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+87846;['appeal isallowed']
+123627;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellantsxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96639;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+150670;['appeals are allowed', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84856;['appeal is allowed']
+95095;['appeal is terminated']
+128294;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+138806;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+89043;['appeal is allowed']
+65412;['appeal of ashwini chandra is allowed']
+123133;['appeal is allowed']
+123306;['rpd dismissed the appellant’s claim']
+102094;['appeal is allowed']
+19120;['appeal is dismissed']
+84661;['appeal isallowed']
+99321;['appeal of frank tawiah osei is dismissed']
+134414;['appeal is allowed.the']
+150624;['appeal is allowed']
+102996;['appeal is dismissed']
+142090;['refugee protection division determines that the xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+99475;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+81824;['appeal is allowed']
+99950;['appeal is allowed']
+118236;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+128147;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+37438;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+52732;['leads me to conclude that the adult claimant']
+72833;['appellant have not lost their permanent resident status']
+131030;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+78732;['appeal is allowed']
+62939;['appeal is terminated']
+115287;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+143842;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+104285;['appeal is dismissed']
+99445;['panel rejects the claim']
+141252;['appeal is allowed']
+122701;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+101211;['appeal is dismissed']
+140235;['confirm the rpd determination', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+96674;['“convention refugees”']
+134226;['appeal is allowed']
+66628;['appeal is dismissed']
+92459;['appeal is allowed']
+139809;['appeal oflouisias\xa0junior\xa0jean-baptisteisallowed']
+58500;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+60282;['appeal isallowed']
+61797;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx,', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108957;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+74244;['appeal is allowed']
+113784;['substitutes its own determination by which the appellant is a convention refugee']
+104357;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+67614;['appeal isallowed']
+11124;['302 (c.a.)']
+142849;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123525;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+123846;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132445;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+75710;['appeal is allowed']
+57923;['appeal is dismissed']
+75133;['appeal is dismissed']
+91351;['appeal is dismissed']
+87486;['appeal is dismissed']
+72012;['appeal is allowed']
+96802;['appeal fails', 'appeal will fail']
+122813;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46496;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+132662;['appeal is dismissed']
+123928;['appeals are dismissed']
+26720;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+26924;['claimants xxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxx are not convention refugees']
+136742;['appellants should be recognized as refugees']
+57553;['appeal is dismissed']
+89278;['determination is valid in law']
+31379;['appeal is allowed']
+96186;['302 (c.a.']
+100356;['appeal is dismissed']
+99026;['removal order is set aside']
+47102;['appeal is dismissed']
+64130;['removal order isset aside']
+90424;['appeal is dismissed']
+141260;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugee(s)”', 'nor “person(s) in need of protection']
+101612;['appeal is allowed']
+81005;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+108208;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61885;['appellant has lost his permanent resident status']
+132791;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the rpd’s determinations']
+117123;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+136710;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113286;['appeal is allowed']
+63117;['appeal be dismissed']
+109041;['appeal is allowed']
+72735;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+100533;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+45870;['application is dismissed']
+79467;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+8281;['appeal is dismissed']
+64599;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+77692;['negative']
+97804;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95961;['appeal is dismissed']
+55123;['appeal allowed']
+92690;['allow the appeal']
+148600;['appeal is allowed']
+146096;['rad finds that the rpd’s finding on this issue is speculative']
+67446;['appeal is dismissed']
+80040;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+17899;['appeals are allowed']
+104081;['appeal is allowed']
+87939;['appeal is dismissed']
+21395;['respondent, xxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx, continues to be a convention refugee']
+135158;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”']
+32166;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+19228;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151914;['appeal is dismissed']
+50434;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+128178;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103103;['appeal is allowed.the']
+125405;['rad dismisses the appeal of the principal appellant', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+36131;['appeal is allowed']
+77079;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87105;['appeal is dismissed']
+105630;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+75136;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+86317;['appeal is allowed']
+147012;['appeal would be dismissed']
+137679;['appeal is allowed']
+60310;['allow this appeal']
+97312;['appeal is dismissed']
+105630;['rad has found that the rpd decision cannot stand']
+102433;['appeal of nhon tu phan is dismissed']
+68078;['panel denies theapplication']
+90024;['appeal is allowed']
+101051;['appeal is allowed']
+123833;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+60473;['appeal isallowed']
+26975;['claimant xxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+61490;['appeal is allowed']
+75426;['appeal isallowed']
+100172;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+125313;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87836;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+123766;['allow the appeal,', 'appellants are persons in need of protection']
+102686;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+136710;['appeal is dismissed']
+88525;['claim is denied']
+64224;['appeal is dismissed']
+107171;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+13767;['appeal is dismissed']
+71529;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+77220;['appeal is allowed']
+86401;['negative decision']
+52758;['appeal is not allowed']
+90923;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+96802;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77446;['appeals are dismissed']
+104095;['302 (c.a.']
+96375;['appeals are dismissed']
+142496;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84326;['appeal of mohammad saleem is allowed']
+70472;['appeal is dismissed']
+9679;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+97386;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+76449;['appeals are dismissed']
+76951;['appeal is allowed']
+84508;['appeal is allowed']
+140734;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74122;['appeal is allowed']
+136186;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+123358;['appeal be dismissed']
+59989;['negative']
+141221;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83550;['302 (c.a.']
+95792;['rpd’s decision to reject']
+96862;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+113525;['appeal is allowed']
+71608;['dismiss this appeal']
+18004;['departure order isset aside']
+75976;['allows the respondent’s application', 'dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+87825;['appeal is terminated']
+48100;['appeal is dismissed']
+145033;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+141313;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+143465;['appeal is dismissed']
+141793;['appeal of maria emily dasalla is dismissed']
+130974;['uphold the decision']
+150610;['appeal is allowed']
+111014;['appeal is allowed']
+103088;['dismisses this appeal']
+69589;['appeal isallowed']
+70482;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+78165;['appeal by the minister isallowed']
+72059;['appeal is dismissed']
+49543;['appeal is allowed']
+105776;['appellant is not a citizen of china']
+13977;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+124804;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70026;['appeal allowed']
+99927;['appeal must therefore fail']
+102267;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+88775;['panel rejects her claim']
+36944;['appeal is allowed']
+74356;['appeal is dismissed']
+108263;['dismisses the appeal']
+62959;['appeals before the iad are hearingsde novo']
+94913;['panel rejects his claim']
+98785;['appeal is allowed']
+35905;['appeal is dismissed']
+132404;['appeal is allowed']
+123829;['appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+72656;['appeal is dismissed']
+97840;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx for refugee protection']
+102117;['appeal is dismissed']
+30489;['appeal is determined']
+93968;['appeal is dismissed']
+124918;['appeal must be dismissed']
+151560;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150256;['appeal is allowed']
+131694;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+86406;['appeal is dismissed']
+17191;['appeal is allowed']
+94948;['appeal is abandoned']
+29636;['removal order isset aside']
+56884;['appeal isallowed']
+43705;['appeal is dismissed']
+96549;['appeals are dismissed']
+64869;['dismiss the appeal']
+94314;['appeal isallowedand']
+123855;['appellant is not excluded from refugee protection']
+98495;['stay is set aside']
+74771;['appeal is dismissed']
+80535;['appeal is allowed']
+69963;['appeal is allowed']
+60498;['appeal is dismissed']
+105796;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+96411;['appeal isallowed']
+132840;['appeal isallowed']
+124172;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105648;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+148664;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+141665;['appeal were dismissed']
+76309;['appeal of kuldip singh virk is allowed']
+83111;['appeal is terminated']
+144557;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93905;['appeal is dismissed']
+33323;['appeal is dismissed']
+60499;['appeal is dismissed']
+62192;['allows the withdrawal']
+89827;['appeal is allowed']
+97632;['appeals aredismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+139803;['appeal is allowed']
+96658;['claim is rejected']
+107655;['appeal is dismissed']
+91180;['appeal is allowed']
+124924;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144752;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+125456;['appeal is allowed']
+105699;['appeals are dismissed']
+96901;['claimants to not be convention refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+70366;['dismisses this appeal']
+80996;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96190;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+65604;['appeal is dismissed']
+67797;['appeal is allowed']
+96720;['appeal is allowed.the']
+143457;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim']
+71620;['appeal is dismissed']
+62246;['negative']
+120965;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not convention refugees']
+23034;['appeal is allowed']
+59995;['claimant is not a refugee']
+46570;['appeal is allowed']
+136113;['appeal is allowed']
+70035;['sets aside the deportation order and allows the appeal']
+106794;['appeal is allowed']
+96119;['appeal is allowed']
+95726;['appeal proceed to oral hearing']
+106825;['appeals of gholamreza rezaei, gelareh rezaei, aryan rezaei, and golestoo rezaei are dismissed']
+93572;['302 (c.a.)']
+93620;['appeal is dismissed']
+141296;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+82979;['appeal is dismissed']
+84683;['appeal isallowed']
+78759;['appeal is terminated']
+60368;['appeal isallowed']
+70893;['appeal be dismissed']
+80530;['appeal is governed by theact']
+117187;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neithera “convention refugee']
+69761;['appeal isallowed']
+107466;['appeal is dismissed']
+94588;['appeal is dismissed']
+110570;['appellant’s argument fails']
+118257;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+94628;['appeal of kimberlyann karla dill is dismissed']
+34154;['appeal has been abandoned']
+148716;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89327;['appeal is allowed']
+35405;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+148589;['appeal is allowed']
+78162;['appeal isterminated']
+61631;['appeal is dismissed']
+143247;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90461;['neither a convention refugee']
+102999;['pardon is revocable']
+128391;['appeal is dismissed']
+22764;['appeals are allowed']
+55194;['appeal is dismissed']
+102801;['appeal is allowed']
+96715;['appeal is terminated']
+123921;['appeal is allowed']
+89082;['appeal is dismissed']
+149007;['i agree with the appellants']
+60045;['negative']
+110313;['appeal is dismissed']
+85516;['appeal isallowed']
+151351;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93090;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+108781;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150862;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97673;['reject the claims']
+30875;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+99821;['appeal is allowed']
+94011;['appeal is dismissed']
+96152;['appeal is allowed']
+100193;['application to extend time is allowed']
+84303;['302 (c.a.']
+122138;['appeal is allowed']
+67390;['appeal is dismissed']
+122810;['appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+87328;['appeal be dismissed']
+148650;['appeal will fail']
+97383;['negative']
+133727;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+78014;['appeal is allowed']
+67398;['allowed the appeal in law']
+69380;['appeal is terminated']
+47565;['allow the appeal']
+148659;['appeals are dismissed']
+81626;['appeal is dismissed']
+118135;['appellants meet all the requirements']
+96717;['appeal is dismissed']
+92414;['appeal is dismissed']
+128416;['appeal is allowed']
+101192;['rpd’s decision must be set aside']
+84454;['appeal is allowed.the']
+106616;['rad rejects that explanation']
+130963;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination']
+95237;['appeal of mauricio ernesto francia is dismissed']
+132632;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor \xa0persons in need of protection']
+9675;['appeal is allowed']
+107221;['rad finds that analysis to be unnecessary']
+151748;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+50471;['appeal is allowed']
+102074;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123291;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+100183;['claim is rejected']
+100237;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+71492;['appeal isallowed']
+100359;['claimant’s claim fails']
+52067;['stay is set aside']
+56094;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+60898;['appeal is allowed']
+68087;['appeal isallowed']
+97206;['302 (c.a.']
+92503;['appeal is allowed']
+96377;['appeal is allowed']
+88125;['appeal is terminated']
+97442;['terminates his appeal']
+153058;['panel, therefore, rejects the claims']
+92611;['negative']
+73891;['appeal isallowedin']
+146104;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+101328;['appeal is dismissed']
+77457;['appeal is dismissed']
+71477;['appeal isallowed']
+123041;['appeal is allowed']
+94150;['appeal is allowed']
+19128;['appeal is dismissed']
+128406;['appeal of benyam afram zeray is dismissed']
+125205;['rpd’s findings are upheld']
+100690;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+84576;['appeal is terminated']
+142916;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+103724;['claimants’ fear of persecution']
+82277;['appellant is a convention refugee with protected status']
+102260;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+76034;['appeal fails']
+52111;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94049;['appeal isallowed']
+76536;['appeal is allowed']
+58546;['dismissal of the appeal']
+143165;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95904;['appeal is dismissed']
+81069;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not “convention refugees”']
+91531;['appeal isallowed']
+151482;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+123997;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'not be considered a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+143130;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+89410;['appeal is dismissed']
+109536;['appeal is dismissed']
+95451;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+58135;['appeal is dismissed']
+113620;['appeal is allowed']
+69249;['appeal is terminated']
+80719;['appellant is in default of proceedings']
+105599;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'panel therefore rejects his claim']
+82177;['appeal of tuoc ba huynh is dismissed']
+89563;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+64647;['appeal is allowed']
+142843;['appeal is dismissed']
+139863;['appeal is dismissed']
+136747;['confirm the determination of the refugee protection division']
+76656;['appeal is allowed']
+36099;['appeal isallowed']
+22717;['appeal is dismissed']
+142823;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+97507;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+35544;['appeal was withdrawn']
+70164;['appeal of zhu ji chen is dismissed']
+78171;['claimant is excluded from refugee protection']
+148636;['appeal is based']
+146921;['appeal is dismissed']
+36085;['regulation is notutltra virestheirpa']
+105810;['appeal is dismissed']
+150950;['dismiss the appeal']
+105806;['appeal is dismissed']
+75001;['appeal isallowed']
+95201;['appeal is dismissed']
+96528;['appeal isallowed']
+88174;['negative']
+124120;['appeal is allowed']
+66254;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+122904;['302 (c.a.']
+71650;['appeal is allowed']
+151962;['rad finds that all appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+122943;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83214;['appeal isallowed']
+151875;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+96456;['appeal be dismissed']
+49071;['leads me to conclude that the']
+108730;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102131;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+47107;['appeal dismissed']
+59372;['appeal is allowed']
+128211;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+100523;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+136711;['rpd’s negative decision is set aside']
+36104;['appeal of james mathew sands is dismissed']
+27475;['allow the appeal']
+100422;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+69835;['dismiss the appeal']
+84606;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+35417;['allows the appeal']
+91215;['appeal is terminated']
+47841;['appeal is dismissed']
+71211;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+85940;['appeal is allowed']
+129157;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+46451;['’ application is rejected']
+142984;['appeal is allowed']
+107939;['302 (c.a.']
+25977;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+74741;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+33066;['decision of the rpd']
+129403;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+84366;['decision is valid in law']
+102978;['allowed the appeal']
+81076;['appeal isallowed']
+85837;['appeal be dismissed']
+123900;['appeal in respect of these three appellants is dismissed']
+80247;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+87719;['negative']
+48938;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+141785;['dismisses this appeal']
+121482;['rpd’s determination is correct']
+61031;['appeal is dismissed']
+140920;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+100978;['appeal isallowed']
+76077;['appeal isallowed']
+126424;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd has rendered a correct and appropriate decision']
+80728;['appeal isallowed']
+90235;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+89069;['appeal isallowed']
+77024;['appeal is dismissed']
+26486;['appeal isallowed']
+85675;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees not persons in need of protection']
+138884;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+56694;['appeal is terminated']
+113549;['appeal is dismissed']
+122977;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80376;['appeal is allowed']
+123762;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+118236;['neither a refugee nor person in need of protection']
+97825;['negative']
+100385;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+88517;['negative']
+60468;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+123713;['appeal is allowed']
+50734;['appeal is dismissed']
+141605;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+92629;['“convention refugees”']
+124685;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101335;['appeal is terminated']
+46392;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47222;['appeal is dismissed']
+69551;['appeal isallowed']
+80848;['rpd determination must be set aside']
+70178;['appeal is allowed']
+76393;['rad finds that the rpd decision is not reasonable', 'rad sets aside the rpd determination', 'substitutes a determination that should have been made that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94224;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+76047;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+42081;['appeals were dismissed']
+94554;['appeal is allowed']
+101349;['appeal is allowed']
+83377;['appeal is allowed']
+142828;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither\xa0 convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+31937;['appellant’s argument fails']
+76566;['appeal is dismissed']
+100113;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+100699;['appeal is dismissed']
+124707;['substitute my reasoning for that of the rpd']
+113793;['rpd decision is correct']
+56813;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx is excluded from refugee protection']
+27519;['appeal is determined']
+116744;['appeal is based']
+91768;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+67711;['appeal is allowed']
+77841;['reject this claim to refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee']
+91736;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+64255;['appeal of that refusal basis is allowed']
+40803;['rad finds xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+143162;['allows the appeal']
+95906;['appeals are dismissed']
+117383;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96686;['neither convention refugees']
+78294;['appeal is allowed']
+42290;['appeal was dismissed']
+143600;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+97228;['appeal is dismissed']
+81855;['appeal of herode telusmont is dismissed']
+133364;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+45410;['appeal isdeclaredto be abandoned']
+98830;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+57030;['appeal is allowed']
+115290;['appeal will continue in its normal processing']
+97126;['appeal is allowed']
+121432;['appeal is dismissed']
+104426;['claimants are excluded fromsections 96and97(1)pursuant to article 1e']
+80107;['appeal should be dismissed']
+131190;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+64863;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+64849;['appeals of chia lin ko, yen ju ko and nai jung ko are dismissed']
+56691;['appeal is allowed']
+59040;['dismissing this appeal']
+19120;['appeal is dismissed']
+90228;['panel rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+62885;['farc is   ']
+91368;['appeal of faduma abdul hussein is allowed']
+84852;['allows this appeal']
+72595;['allows the appeal']
+35722;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+41080;['appeal of peyeatu nyenon is dismissed']
+102486;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+80019;['negative']
+131715;['appeal is dismissed']
+94950;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84711;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95951;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99548;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+67580;['appeal isallowed']
+48227;['appeal is allowed']
+54166;['appeal is dismissed']
+85961;['appeal isallowed']
+59188;['appeal is granted']
+75889;['appeal is allowed']
+129411;['appeal is dismissed']
+73284;['appeal is dismissed']
+124201;['appeal is allowed']
+70915;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+130932;['302 (c.a.']
+100632;['appeal is allowed']
+39049;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+99500;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+150780;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94384;['appeal is allowed']
+103716;['claimant is not at risk']
+94778;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+103792;['appeal is terminated']
+101476;['appeal is allowed']
+54788;['appeal isallowed']
+52763;['appeal is dismissed']
+13953;['appeal is dismissed']
+79216;['appeal isallowed']
+19168;['appeal is dismissed']
+26760;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+151522;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+33317;['appeal is dismissed']
+141246;['302 (c.a.']
+104000;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+143247;['appeal is dismissed']
+86615;['appeal is dismissed']
+99473;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+146832;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+84356;['appeal of emerino tabay barcoma is dismissed']
+54739;['appeal is allowed']
+141203;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96517;['dismiss this appeal']
+105660;['appeal is allowed']
+93919;['appeal is allowed']
+101433;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+59741;['appeal is allowed']
+134434;['appeal is based']
+98100;['appeal is allowed']
+79239;['dismiss the appeal']
+99693;['appeal is dismissed']
+152028;['dismiss this appeal']
+102540;['allow the appeal', 'set aside the removal order made against the appellant']
+95523;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+104171;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+105911;['dismissing an appeal']
+47571;['appeal will be allowed']
+71697;['dismiss it for lack of jurisdiction']
+56635;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+62991;['appeal is allowed']
+21331;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+86221;['appeal isallowed']
+44967;['appeal dismissed']
+90371;['appeal is allowed']
+100860;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+70671;['appeal isallowed']
+122531;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61036;['appeal is allowed']
+119833;['appeal is dismissed']
+105878;['xxxx xxxx xxxxclaim for refugee protection is rejected']
+47318;['appeal of thomas hon man tsang is dismissed']
+69618;['appeal is dismissed']
+89223;['appeal is allowed']
+81176;['appeal is allowed']
+23059;['dismiss the present appeal']
+21322;['appeal is dismissed']
+139467;['appeal is dismiss']
+103206;['rad is setting aside the decision of the rpd']
+98672;['appeal is allowed']
+125319;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47834;['appeal isallowed']
+23014;['appeal is dismissed']
+132628;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+45425;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+68445;['appeal of helen caguioa bareng is dismissed']
+26754;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+91355;['appeal is allowed']
+144408;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+54192;['appeal is allowed']
+151495;['appeal is dismissed']
+143886;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+52704;['refugee division, therefore, finds xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx not to be convention refugees']
+26802;['appeal of karen kaur brar is dismissed']
+61041;['appeal is dismissed']
+143507;['claimant, xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+143007;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76608;['appeal isallowed']
+56268;['appeal isallowed.the']
+146872;['302 (c.a.']
+44042;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+95593;['appeal isallowedand']
+54233;['dismissed the appeal']
+100304;['“convention refugees”']
+95207;['appeal is allowed']
+55266;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+110922;['appeal is dismissed']
+69969;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+87251;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26863;['302 (c.a.']
+143849;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88296;['appeals should be dismissed']
+83011;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+58565;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+104397;['appeal isallowed']
+95379;['appeal is allowed']
+96443;['appeal is allowed']
+90765;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+95742;['appeal isallowed']
+90952;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+64846;['appeal is dismissed']
+124415;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+88088;['appeal is terminated']
+54805;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+30378;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination', 'respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44039;['appeal is dismissed']
+69533;['appeal is dismissed']
+88404;['rpd decision must be set aside']
+147590;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+123437;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s impugned determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+58494;['appeal is dismissed']
+38385;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+103602;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+98223;['appeal isallowed']
+97374;['negative']
+106779;['appeal isallowed']
+25526;['rpd decision therefore stands and is correct']
+89802;['appeal has been allowed']
+53132;['appeal is allowed']
+94864;['appeal is allowed']
+132363;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+146839;['appeals are allowed']
+76292;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+151062;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+149487;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89259;['appeal is dismissed']
+129101;['appeal is dismissed']
+95166;['appeal isallowed']
+133729;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113513;['appeal is dismissed']
+97335;['appeal is allowed']
+71640;['appeal is dismissed']
+70172;['appeal is allowed']
+94314;['appeal is allowed']
+104845;['appeal should be allowed']
+88151;['appeal is allowed']
+32171;['appeal is dismissed']
+111337;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+94447;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71429;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+87122;['appeal isallowed']
+105653;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81816;['appeal is allowed']
+74574;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+99899;['appeal of mohammad ebrahim shafiee is dismissed']
+111877;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+150625;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94753;['appeal is dismissed']
+98081;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+101329;['dismissed this appeal']
+85588;['appeal is terminated']
+98761;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+89149;['appeal is allowed']
+122890;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is aconventionrefugee.']
+61473;['appeal is dismissed']
+86348;['appeal is determined']
+147880;['appeal is denied']
+153798;['appeal is allowed']
+84678;['appeal isallowed']
+32163;['allows this appeal']
+74028;['appeal of igor vasylkiv abandoned']
+55344;['302 (c.a.)']
+73322;['appeal is dismissed']
+117210;['appeal is allowed']
+56952;['appeal is allowed']
+102066;['appeal is allowed']
+81101;['appeal is dismissed']
+84195;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93343;['302 (c.a.']
+95069;['appeal is allowed']
+69718;['appeal should be and is allowed']
+42296;['appeal be dismissed']
+125369;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26772;['appeal beallowed']
+79458;['appeal is dismissed']
+143228;['rad confirms the rpd decision for other reasons', 'appellants are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110675;['rad sets aside the determination\xa0 of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+62867;['appeal terminated']
+64143;['appeal isallowed']
+124688;['rpd’s findings are upheld']
+77228;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+23846;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99718;['302 (c.a.']
+131203;['appeal of mohammad mohsen shakoor is dismissed']
+94835;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+86944;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+56823;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+48207;['appeal must therefore be considered']
+102926;['appeal is dismissed']
+47140;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+96888;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+95962;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146096;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+122628;['302 (c.a.']
+97521;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+95509;['removal order is set aside']
+46056;['appeal is terminated']
+71082;['reject this explanation']
+50743;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+97275;['dismiss this appeal']
+92344;['neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+146893;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+75410;['appeal is determined']
+94050;['appeal is allowed']
+54760;['appeal is allowed']
+21399;['claimant is excluded from convention refugee protection']
+68221;['appeal ofalma violeta pinto, in respect to her husband,adil rabya, is allowed']
+83241;['appeal is dismissed']
+54734;['appeal is abandoned']
+145538;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+96590;['appeals are allowed.the']
+106613;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant, the daughter and the son are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+57448;['appellants are convention refugees']
+30522;['appeals are dismissed']
+108733;['appellant’s argument fails']
+99138;['appeal is allowed in law']
+95551;['appeal is dismissed']
+127453;['appeal is dismissed']
+54709;['appeal being dismissed']
+54708;['appeal is dismissed']
+116798;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+81814;['appeal is dismissed']
+85531;['appeal is allowed.the', 'decision of the id member is set aside']
+69089;['dismiss the appeal']
+58236;['appeal dismissed']
+49163;['appeal is dismissed']
+47397;['appeal is allowed']
+95815;['appeal is not granted']
+145379;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claim']
+114405;['302 (c.a.']
+95930;['appeal is allowed']
+87350;['appeal is dismissed']
+84236;['appeal isallowed']
+69738;['appeal is dismissed']
+105890;['request for an oral hearing is dismissed']
+99645;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+85952;['appeal is allowed']
+88974;['appeal is allowed']
+61353;['appeal is allowed']
+62443;['confirming the rpd’s decision']
+87428;['appeal is allowed']
+49981;['appeal is dismissed']
+75459;['appeal be dismissed']
+76746;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+95522;['appeal is allowed']
+83347;['appeal is dismissed']
+94410;['appeal is allowed']
+76553;['appeal is allowed']
+47388;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+37824;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+63001;['appeal is allowed']
+105340;['appeal is dismissed']
+151952;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+81113;['appeal is dismissed']
+69993;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+82189;['appeal is allowed']
+81240;['appeal were dismissed']
+31264;['appeal is dismissed']
+95174;['appeal is terminated']
+131710;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+116749;['appeal is allowed']
+95469;['appeal’s relative merit']
+34329;['appeal is allowed']
+132413;['appeal is dismissed']
+130732;['appeal of juan lai is dismissed']
+82158;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+144568;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151488;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84418;['appeal isallowed.the']
+82722;['dismiss his appeal']
+150642;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+76850;['appeal isallowed']
+146097;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+78322;['302 (c.a.']
+101187;['rad allows the appeal']
+105232;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither\xa0 convention refugees nor\xa0 persons in need of protection']
+150921;['302 (c.a.']
+107064;['appeals are allowed']
+71609;['appeal is allowed in discretion']
+107165;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+99227;['302 (c.a.']
+57063;['rad finds that the appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89975;['302 (c.a.)']
+142449;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the impugned decision', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+72631;['appeal is allowed']
+93909;['visa officer’s determination is valid in law']
+94070;['appeal has merit']
+81850;['appeals are allowed']
+67705;['appeal of mohamad yaser ammar saflo is dismissed']
+125232;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108871;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68558;['negative']
+134215;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+78701;['appeal isallowed']
+77117;['appeal is allowed']
+39064;['appeal is dismissed']
+103508;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122912;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+47884;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed']
+143942;['allow the appeal']
+74173;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+89389;['appeal isallowed']
+99631;['appeal is allowed']
+39567;['appeal is allowed']
+145852;['decision that the appellant is not legally valid']
+131145;['appeal is dismissed']
+125698;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+107582;['appeals are dismissed']
+28095;['appeal were dismissed']
+85309;['appeal is dismissed']
+128446;['appeal is allowed']
+80073;['refugee protection division rejects the principal claimant and his wife’s claims']
+91174;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+148646;['appeal is allowed']
+77621;['refusal is invalid in law']
+142557;['appeal is allowed']
+105896;['appeal is dismissed']
+99982;['302 (c.a.']
+35873;['appeal is dismissed']
+109699;['302 (c.a.']
+95949;['appeal is dismissed']
+77684;['dismiss the appeal']
+36117;['appeal is dismissed']
+98787;['appeal is dismissed']
+13980;['appeal is allowed']
+151460;['appeal is allowed']
+150652;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124268;['appeal is dismissed']
+139859;['appeal is allowed']
+86060;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+60973;['appeal isallowed']
+59853;['appeal is dismissed']
+92039;['appeal is allowed']
+55298;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89729;['appeal is terminated']
+99715;['appeal is dismissed']
+94360;['appeal is allowed']
+113287;['appeal is dismissed']
+125403;['rad dismisses the appeal of the associate appellant', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'associate appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103497;['appeal were dismissed']
+37835;['appeal is allowed']
+147614;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90119;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+110993;['appeal is dismissed']
+107228;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+56628;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+92732;['appeal is dismissed']
+132769;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142511;['appeal is dismissed']
+79466;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+87598;['claimants,xxxxx,xxxxx,xxxxxandxxxxxxxxxx, not to be convention refugees and not to be persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+46057;['appeal abandoned']
+106180;['appeal is consequently dismissed']
+72180;['appeals of carmelo ilagan alcantara and regina santiago alcantaraare withdrawn']
+105875;['rad concurs with the rpd’s reasoning']
+67517;['appeal is dismissed']
+38907;['appeal are dismissed']
+131231;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84008;['appeal is terminated']
+141294;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+136655;['not be recognized as a refugee']
+124584;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+95919;['appeal is allowed']
+52676;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxx, not to be a convention refugee']
+101678;['appeal is allowed']
+76883;['appeal is dismissed']
+149112;['removal order is set aside']
+48219;['appeal isallowed']
+69944;['appeal is dismissed']
+77966;['appeal is dismissed']
+76261;['allow her appeal']
+142498;['confirm the rpd’s finding', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+72590;['appeal is allowed']
+34868;['appeal is allowed']
+90256;['negative']
+90082;['appeal isterminated']
+64001;['appeal is determined']
+144403;['rad allows the appeal']
+103726;['reject   this claim']
+96937;['church in fujian']
+140553;['neither a convention “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+63065;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+63046;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+61442;['refugee protection division rejects this claim for protection']
+77271;['allow the appeal']
+100362;['claimants are kurds']
+17962;['appeal is dismissed']
+77248;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+78776;['appeal isallowed']
+125540;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+67488;['appeal isallowed']
+90840;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+123011;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+39064;['officer’s determination is valid in law']
+100834;['claimants,xxxx xxxx, his wifexxxx xxxxand', 'not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+61437;['appeal is allowed']
+139789;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+77802;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+72803;['appeal is dismissed']
+52371;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102038;['dismissal of the appeal']
+85970;['dismissing the appeal']
+125631;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+146863;['allows the appeal']
+80252;['302 (c.a.']
+127426;['appeal is dismissed']
+92345;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+54800;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+15575;['appeal is dismissed']
+79965;['negative']
+86215;['appeal of frances osafamwen obasogie is dismissed']
+63241;['appeal is dismissed']
+123366;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128899;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+132310;['confirm the rdp determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98800;['appeal is dismissed']
+150647;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+92347;['ms. xxxx to be a convention refugee']
+103660;['claimants are not people in need of protection']
+124085;['appeals are dismissed']
+113548;['appeal is allowed']
+71693;['appeal is allowed']
+129103;['appeal is allowed']
+142563;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+19728;['nor a permanent resident of canada']
+146772;['appeal is allowed']
+140872;['rad rejects this submission']
+96503;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+143588;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71258;['appeal is dismissed']
+102876;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'panel therefore rejects his claim']
+124705;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+98416;['appeal is dismissed']
+61034;['appeal of dalvir kaur puri is dismissed']
+85632;['appeal is allowed']
+142063;['appeal is dismissed', 'rpd decision is upheld']
+96188;['appeal is allowed']
+147595;['302 (c.a.']
+133194;['appeal is dismissed']
+82723;['appeal is dismissed']
+76733;['appeal is dismissed']
+38906;['appeal is allowed']
+49064;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+105218;['appeal is allowed']
+152028;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+141218;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134410;['appeal is dismissed']
+123413;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101438;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26752;['appeal bedismissed.']
+82068;['302 (c.a.)']
+75138;['appeal should be dismissed']
+68720;['appeal is dismissed']
+37855;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+104935;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+129895;['appeals are dismissed']
+91619;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88080;['appeal is dismissed']
+100343;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+75392;['appeal is allowed']
+86202;['appeal of dawit welde gebrekidan is dismissed']
+52324;['decision cannot stand']
+49636;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+9488;['appeal isallowed']
+102684;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+87948;['appeal is dismissed']
+152147;['thatxxxx xxxxis neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+24190;['appeal is dismissed']
+118637;['appeal is dismissed']
+102131;['appeals aredismissedand departure orders are made']
+103706;['dismisses the appeal']
+50514;['appeal is allowed']
+97495;['reject your claim for refugee protection']
+59403;['appeal is dismissed']
+93965;['appeal is terminated']
+140207;['dismiss the appeal']
+39891;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+60057;['appeal isallowed']
+131863;['allow the appeal']
+97352;['claimant’s refugee protection claim']
+23039;['appeal is dismissed']
+68448;['appeal be dismissed']
+68168;['application to dismiss the appeal']
+81264;['appeal is allowed']
+60734;['appeal is allowed']
+22987;['appeal is allowed.the']
+99497;['appellant has lost his permanent resident status']
+93157;['appeal isallowed']
+131056;['appeal is allowed']
+77466;['appeal is terminated']
+70041;['sets aside the deportation order and allows the appeal']
+26490;['dismisses this appeal']
+21316;['appellant is neither a \xa0convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirm the determination of the refugee protection division']
+58144;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+73221;['declare your appeal abandoned']
+97269;['appeal is dismissed']
+72814;['allow the appeal']
+122685;['reinstatement is an exception to the']
+47284;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+81859;['appeal is dismissed']
+97378;['appeal is allowed']
+97504;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47156;['appeal is dismissed']
+113232;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+84724;['appeal is dismissed']
+64676;['appeal is dismissed']
+99294;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71050;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+84284;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+80459;['appeals are dismissed']
+98351;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+100184;['appeal is allowed']
+73040;['appeal isallowed']
+68715;['appeal is dismissed']
+76449;['appeals aredismissed.']
+116759;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+101298;['appeal is allowed']
+105368;['dismisses the appeal', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77772;['appeal is terminated']
+66902;['appeal be and is hereby allowed']
+73258;['appeal must be dismissed']
+94969;['appeal isallowed']
+82618;['appeal isallowed']
+151369;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+96620;['appeal is allowed']
+141251;['appeals are dismissed']
+17959;['determinations are valid in law']
+30486;['appeal is dismissed']
+78715;['appeal is dismissed']
+55251;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxxxxxxxx and xxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxx are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+104106;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+41922;['appeal is allowed']
+123370;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100807;['appeal is dismissed']
+122871;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96106;['negative']
+90645;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a claim for refugee protection']
+71188;['appeal of ramanjeet randhawa is allowed']
+81150;['appeal is allowed']
+17967;['appeal is allowed']
+71478;['appeal is dismissed']
+96950;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83487;['appeal is allowed']
+95868;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+59811;['appeal is allowed']
+94546;['appeal isallowed']
+34892;['appeal is dismissed']
+104288;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+65130;['appeal must be dismissed']
+46499;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+128344;['appeal is allowed']
+61325;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+120778;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+22399;['appeal is dismissed']
+100907;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor are they “persons in need of protection”']
+32162;['applicants are inadmissible']
+146924;['appeal isdismissed.']
+47285;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+100651;['appeal is dismissed']
+78172;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+106173;['appeal is allowed']
+21357;['not a «\xa0convention refugee']
+69484;['appeals are dismissed']
+78194;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+91003;['application to re-open is denied']
+95977;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83030;['appeal is allowed']
+86479;['appeal must be dismissed']
+69626;['appeal isallowed']
+96109;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+74688;['appeal of audie gomez hagong is dismissed']
+99333;"[""rad finds that the rpd's determination was reasonable""]"
+88340;['appeal is allowed']
+148773;['appeal is dismissed']
+105350;['child is not a refugee claimant']
+98657;['appeal is allowed']
+102480;['appeal is denied']
+151949;['rad denies the request for an oral hearing']
+92991;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84596;['appeal shall proceed to a hearing on the merits.resjudicataor']
+76333;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+136698;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86312;['appeal of jin zhang is allowed']
+147009;['appeal is allowed']
+146819;['dismiss the appeals', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees']
+76549;"[""appeal brought with respect to zoobe nasser's application for permanent resident is dismissed""]"
+115286;['allows the minister’s appeal']
+90734;['appeal is dismissed']
+49582;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+96278;['negative']
+27219;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123774;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+122620;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75952;['appeal be dismissed']
+42001;['appeals are dismissed']
+76702;['appeal is dismissed']
+90668;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+120764;['appeals are allowed']
+42824;['appeal is dismissed']
+147131;['appeal is dismissed']
+117199;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+90179;['allowed the appeal']
+104442;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+89805;['appeal is allowed']
+83908;['appeal isallowedand']
+70966;['appeal of mellie alaba callueng is dismissed']
+70193;['appeal is dismissed']
+20000;['appeal is allowed']
+143244;['not allow this application']
+78085;['appeal will be allowed']
+79464;['appeal is clearly moot']
+57482;['appeal isallowed']
+99497;['appellant is no longer a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+136725;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124957;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+126408;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+145828;['appeal is allowed']
+30525;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+142834;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor person in need of protection']
+89114;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+147466;['claimants are neither convention refugees', 'panel rejects the claimants’ claims for refugee protection']
+75967;['appeal is dismissed']
+131036;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+76690;['appeal is dismissed']
+64595;['appeal is valid in law']
+20011;['appeal is allowed']
+60040;['appeal is allowed.the']
+63188;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+47281;['appeal is dismissed']
+81079;['appeal of mahmood hussain bajwa is dismissed']
+76097;['appeal is allowed']
+69352;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+102416;['appeal is allowed']
+82850;['dismisses the appeal']
+81159;['appeal is allowed']
+86341;['appeal is allowed']
+77880;['negative']
+100819;['appeal is allowed']
+91143;['appeal is dismissed']
+95866;['thepanel finds the removal order valid in law']
+87451;['appeal is allowed']
+94427;['appeal is moot']
+79977;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+114736;['appeal is allowed']
+129391;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95947;['appeal is dismissed']
+50735;['appeal is allowed']
+56264;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+54201;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+98432;['appeal was refused']
+71251;['appeal is dismissed']
+69132;['appeal is allowed']
+75564;['appeal isallowed']
+70672;['appeal were dismissed']
+142837;['immigration appeal division therefore orders the following person’s removal from canada']
+86964;['appeal is dismissed']
+104978;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+26782;['appeal bedismissed']
+76520;['stay the removal order in accordance']
+102574;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98537;['regulation is notutltra\xa0']
+95599;['appeal is nevertheless dismissed']
+131135;['appeal is dismissed']
+147594;['dismisses the appeal']
+74562;['appeal isallowed']
+129859;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90721;['appeal is allowed.the']
+106894;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87339;['appeal is allowed']
+97566;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+85496;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+52051;['appeal is allowed']
+100730;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+73705;['appeal is allowed']
+64235;['appeal is allowed']
+74571;['appeal is dismissed']
+70464;['appeal is terminated']
+26731;['panel allows the respondent’s motion', 'dismisses the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+128578;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+95715;['appeal isallowed']
+105232;['rad confirms the finding of the rpd']
+22118;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+101042;['appeal is terminated']
+132393;['determination is valid in law']
+132886;['appeal is allowed']
+47611;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+54804;['appeal is dismissed']
+82074;['appeal is dismissed']
+131068;['appeal is dismissed']
+70069;['…]”']
+39042;['appeal is dismissed']
+97298;['application is dismissed']
+101837;['appeal will be allowed']
+71279;['appeal is allowed.the']
+96110;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+91199;['appeal isallowed']
+95187;['appeal must be dismissed']
+77200;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+106143;['dismisses this appeal']
+54291;['appeal is discontinued is dismissed']
+128668;['associate and minor appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+99513;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95712;['appeal is dismissed']
+89248;['appeal is allowed in law']
+92775;['appeal isallowed']
+94051;['appeal is terminated']
+98060;['appeal be dismissed']
+96799;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93159;['appeal were dismissed']
+73357;['appeal is allowed']
+87283;['not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim']
+121851;['appeal is allowed']
+60198;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+77452;['appeal is allowed']
+98137;['appeal is terminated']
+131273;['appeal for the adult appellants is allowed']
+70410;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96423;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+141272;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76151;['appeal of dianyi gao is dismissed']
+93881;['appeal of hans juergen bothe is dismissed']
+73265;['appeal must be dismissed']
+71395;['appeal is dismissed']
+124731;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57556;['appeal is allowed.the']
+99162;['claimant is therefore neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87986;['claimantxxxxxis not in need of refugee protection', 'claim is rejected']
+90603;['appeal is allowed']
+83726;['dismiss the present appeal']
+111357;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+83023;['appeal was allowed']
+84072;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+74949;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+74136;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96618;['appeal isallowed']
+101316;['appeal is allowed']
+85444;['appeal is dismissed']
+84734;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+64839;['appeal is dismissed']
+82874;['appeal is dismissed']
+88108;['appeal is dismissed']
+98051;['appeal were dismissed']
+97443;['appeal is dismissed']
+81076;['appeal is granted']
+57952;['appeal is allowed']
+94675;['appeal is dismissed']
+147792;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78138;['negative']
+76274;['appeal to be dismissed']
+63724;['appeal is dismissed']
+123253;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69965;['appeal is dismissed']
+94985;['appeal is terminated']
+96985;['appeal is allowed']
+70887;['appeal is dismissed']
+132798;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+84517;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+125349;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+88319;['dismiss this appeal']
+89909;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+7731;['appeal is dismissed']
+91067;['appeal is allowed']
+80570;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+148719;['claimant and minor claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+14659;['refugee division declares that xxxxxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+73288;['appeal must be dismissed']
+15428;['appeal is terminated']
+91279;['appeal is dismissed']
+106810;['removal order isset aside']
+113253;['decision is legally valid']
+108669;['claimant, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+133243;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+116768;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+76887;['appeal isallowed']
+52133;['negative determination of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+78141;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+76721;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse the permanent resident visa is set aside']
+91439;['appellant is established inqatar']
+52955;['appeal of margaret davidson-romano']
+132399;['appeal is allowed.the']
+73036;['appeal is allowed']
+123000;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98148;['dismissing those without']
+105762;['not allow this application']
+122671;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+112375;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+59991;['negative']
+84653;['appeal is allowed']
+40800;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+86059;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+73888;['appeal of wang xin yi is allowed']
+76043;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80274;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+77824;['claimants have not established that they are persons in need of protection']
+92547;['removal orders areset aside']
+64276;['allowed the appeal']
+60194;['appeal isallowed']
+46449;['rad dismissed the appeal']
+84065;['appeal is dismissed']
+100766;['appeal is dismissed']
+50357;['appeal is thereby dismissed']
+114308;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+125324;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+55189;['appeal isallowed']
+97475;['orders your departure from canada']
+139786;['appeal is dismissed']
+148652;['appeal were dismissed']
+69463;['dismiss the appeal', 'appeal is dismissed']
+44175;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', '“convention refugees”']
+110922;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+23098;['dismiss the present appeal']
+80189;['panel rejects the claims ofxxxxx xxxxx']
+76158;['appeal is allowed']
+60468;['appeal is determined']
+135492;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+74562;['appeal is allowed']
+151373;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+74765;['appeal is dismissed']
+85237;['allowed the appeal']
+108064;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+72057;['appeal is determined']
+120822;['appeal is allowed']
+87796;['appeal isallowed']
+63004;['appeal isallowed']
+46009;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+5145;['appeal isallowed']
+98726;['appeal is declaredabandonedundersubsection\xa0168(1)of theirpabecause']
+85546;['appeal is terminated']
+65661;['allows the appeal']
+98076;['negative']
+74696;['appeal is terminated']
+130788;['appeal ought to be dismissed']
+110940;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+58383;['appeal is dismissed']
+114406;['appeals are dismissed']
+70038;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+100806;['appeal is allowed']
+129120;['appeal is allowed']
+98509;['appeal is allowed']
+77876;['appeal is allowed']
+152915;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination']
+94454;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113752;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+17147;['removal order isset aside']
+101029;['appeal of shinderpal kaur badohal is dismissed']
+93594;['appeal isallowed.the']
+124075;['appeal is allowed']
+89832;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+96246;['appeal is terminated']
+102875;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+128260;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+87146;['appeal isallowed']
+60951;['appeal isallowedand']
+114393;['appeal is allowed']
+151769;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+100839;['claimant is not a true fg practitioner']
+43728;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93577;['appeal isallowed.the']
+42303;['appeal is allowed']
+98637;['appeal is dismissed']
+84507;['appeal is allowed']
+135462;['appeal was dismissed']
+149488;['rad shall set aside the rpd’s determination']
+75255;['appeal is allowed']
+87252;['claimant’s claim fails']
+129937;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107125;['appeal were dismissed']
+66492;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+8296;['appellant lost his permanent resident status']
+108841;['appeal is dismissed']
+96109;['claim is therefore rejected']
+52081;['appeal is terminated']
+67693;['appeal is allowed']
+114370;['rad rejects the appellant’s submissions']
+64919;['rpd is set aside']
+31960;['appeal is dismissed']
+71472;['dismisses this appeal']
+75566;['order is upheld']
+113213;['decision of the visa officer is valid']
+97633;['appeal is allowed']
+143597;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86152;['appeal isallowed']
+92393;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94447;['appeal fails']
+139885;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+142802;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93325;"[""visa officer's refusal is set aside""]"
+110290;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+16752;['appeal is dismissed']
+46529;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95959;['rad finds this conclusion to be reasonable']
+136084;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+34615;['appeal is dismissed']
+130739;['appeal were dismissed']
+62210;['appeal isallowed']
+101705;['appeal is allowed']
+95210;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107109;['minister’s application is allowed']
+138809;['appeal isallowed.the']
+132410;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+81647;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+42386;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89933;['appeal is allowed']
+142836;['appeal is allowed']
+87013;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+135124;['appeal is dismissed']
+54238;['motion to reopen is dismissed']
+86638;['appeal is allowed']
+38254;['appeal is terminated']
+123695;['uphold these findings']
+59688;['appeal is allowed']
+60941;['appeal isallowed']
+84625;['appeal isallowed']
+78729;['appeal is allowed']
+101306;['appeal is allowed']
+68159;['appeal is dismissed']
+2806;['appeal isallowed']
+70402;['appeal is dismissed']
+99660;['appeal of mohamed maamoun shahin is dismissed']
+130690;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+98773;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98125;['appeal is allowed']
+69770;['appeal is allowed']
+101866;['appeal is allowed']
+100732;['appeal is allowed']
+146860;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55299;['appeal was dismissed']
+145384;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98494;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+70085;['appeal is dismissed']
+81191;['appeal is allowed']
+91161;['appeal is dismissed']
+95853;['appeal is allowed']
+112382;['appeals are dismissed']
+69804;['dismiss this appeal']
+123611;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+23050;['appeal of sukhwant kaur kahlon is dismissed']
+134410;['appeal is dismissed']
+71105;['appeal of merla lugsanay massee is dismissed']
+100167;['board denies the claim']
+107829;['appeal is dismissed']
+69132;['appeal is allowed']
+124596;['appeal is dismissed']
+111100;['appeal is dismissed']
+84063;['appeal is allowed']
+28466;['application to reopen the appeal declared abandoned']
+95777;['appeal is dismissed', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+105329;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+94528;['appeal is allowed']
+94246;['visa officer’s decision is set aside']
+67581;['appeal isallowed']
+73279;['appeal is dismissed']
+69351;['appeal will be dismissed']
+123439;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91388;['appeal isallowed']
+146902;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+89873;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+77077;['appeal isdismissed.']
+55208;['appeal isdismissed.']
+125649;['appellant can be neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+51698;['appeal division dismisses the appeal brought by the appellant']
+82877;['appeal is dismissed']
+100569;['appeal is allowed']
+64590;['appeal is dismissed']
+23112;['appeals should be dismissed']
+133737;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+34941;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82173;['appeal isallowed']
+131532;['appeal be allowed or dismissed']
+121435;['appeal were dismissed']
+109145;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+129224;['appeal of abebech telahun jara is dismissed']
+121466;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not convention “refugees”']
+93089;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+95698;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appeal is dismissed']
+52708;['panel accepts her claim for refugee protection']
+124686;['appellant is neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+135167;['appeal is dismissed']
+73317;['appeal isallowed']
+124548;['302 (c.a.']
+108248;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+111160;['appeal is allowed']
+125309;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144253;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56999;['claimant is a convention refugeeand']
+76317;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+153267;['respondents are neither convention refugees pursuant to s. 96 nor persons in need of protection']
+79987;['refugee protection division rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+60033;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+108675;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+88110;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+103797;['claimants are not in need of refugee protection']
+51083;['visa officer’s determination is legally valid']
+96729;['appeal is dismissed']
+88131;['appeal is dismissed']
+58123;['dismiss the appeal']
+45423;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142695;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+88907;['appeal is abandoned']
+107388;['second rad decision upheld the original rpd decision', 'dismissed the appeal']
+89572;['appeal is terminated']
+89433;['appeal is also dismissed']
+122994;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+68227;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+100302;['claimant, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+142800;['substitute its decision with my own determination', 'appellants are persons in need of protection']
+29152;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131048;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+149000;['appeal must be dismissed']
+96586;['appeal is dismissed']
+121853;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+116783;['substitute my determination', 'appellants are refugees']
+95971;['refugee protection claim filed byxxxx xxxxis rejected']
+99152;['appeal is determined']
+59771;['appeal is allowed']
+75556;['allows this appeal']
+125417;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+123045;['appeal is allowed']
+59374;['appeal of ya nan zeng is allowed']
+69128;['appeal is allowed']
+53835;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87170;['appeal is allowed']
+21318;['you are not a convention refugee']
+82726;['appeal is terminated']
+99766;['appeals are allowed']
+120712;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+99498;['appeal must be dismissed']
+94826;['appeal is dismissed']
+49977;['appeal is allowed']
+83007;['appeal is dismissed']
+107793;['they are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+12229;['appeal were dismissed']
+142724;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90919;['rad finds that this is a case where the rpd could have exercised its jurisdiction and authority']
+56741;['appeal isallowed']
+88300;['appeal is allowed']
+104440;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+91632;['appeal is allowed']
+128398;['appeal is dismissed']
+96081;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57293;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+90617;['allow the appeal.']
+37899;['appeal isallowed']
+49119;['appeal is dismissed']
+145814;['appeal is dismissed']
+69557;['appeal isallowed']
+86312;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate reasons']
+142511;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84077;['support the officer’s conclusion']
+134178;['appeal were dismissed']
+151582;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination']
+78193;['appeal is allowed.the']
+85632;['appeal is allowed']
+67460;['appeal is allowed']
+70039;['appeal is dismissed']
+136690;['appeal is allowed']
+84824;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+108204;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its finding that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+59836;['appeal isallowed']
+84361;['appeal were dismissed']
+75928;['dismiss this appeal']
+122979;['appeal is allowed']
+81635;['appeal is determined']
+95145;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+77890;['panel rejects the claims of xxxxx xxxxx']
+95205;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+89252;['allowed the appeal']
+76946;['302 (c.a.']
+60306;['appeal bedismissed.']
+70023;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+82389;['appeal is dismissed']
+125648;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm for different reasons', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124177;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is convention refugee']
+98567;['appeal is dismissed']
+107256;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67504;['appeal is allowed']
+80050;['not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim']
+85458;['appeal isallowedand']
+61059;['appeal of beeja ram is dismissed']
+111178;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71151;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+71129;['appeal isallowed']
+132812;['appeal is dismissed']
+104066;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95518;['appeal be allowed']
+96443;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76062;['appeal isallowedand']
+127702;['appeal is allowed.the']
+105635;['appeal is allowed']
+99442;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+72173;['removal order is set aside']
+107605;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+138876;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is dismissed']
+62871;['application to reopen the appeal of michel john hamdani is denied']
+100761;['appeal is allowed']
+94233;['appeal is allowed']
+60901;['appeal is dismissed']
+64273;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+85500;['appeal is allowed']
+50755;['appeal ofliboth bangalais dismissed']
+64367;['appeal being allowed']
+133717;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+111021;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person who would be subject to persecution should he return to china']
+46106;['stay is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+129903;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26483;['appeal is allowed']
+97472;['appeal is terminated']
+107493;['rad concurs with the rpd’s findings above']
+38781;['application dated december 1, 2014 is allowed.the']
+28300;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd made the correct determination']
+75917;['appeal is allowed']
+98476;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx,is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+145298;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+13330;['appeal is allowed']
+98914;['removal order is set aside']
+95188;['appeal is allowed']
+55310;['appeals are allowed']
+84594;['appeal fails']
+67368;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+114296;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+51284;['302 (c.a.']
+19143;['appeal is allowed']
+139424;['appeal is dismissed']
+89521;['appeal is dismissed']
+87996;['negative']
+116195;['dismiss mr. xxxx appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s decision that he is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+103497;['appeal were dismissed']
+54795;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+125333;['panel sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision with a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+56259;['appeal is dismissed']
+40157;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+63116;['negative']
+21394;['not convention refugees']
+95698;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+62123;['appeal is dismissed']
+96947;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132836;['appeal is determined']
+41825;['appeal should be dismissed']
+71575;['dismiss the apellant’s appeal']
+81125;['appeal is allowed']
+76941;['appeal is allowed']
+98784;['appeal must be dismissed']
+97845;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+91282;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+62449;['appeal is allowed']
+97984;['appeal isallowed']
+64851;['appeal must be dismissed']
+90144;['appeal dismissed']
+62442;['appeal is allowed']
+82993;['allows the appeal']
+112319;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88068;['confirm the determination']
+108058;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+117214;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+123848;['not be granted refugee protection']
+96977;['dismiss the appellants’ appeals']
+132209;['appeal is dismissed']
+88445;['negative']
+121863;['appeal is allowed']
+22718;['appeal is dismissed']
+151729;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+131864;['appeals are thus allowed']
+99284;"[""rad finds that the rpd's individual findings and overall determination were reasonable""]"
+54796;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+17940;['dismiss the present appeal']
+77541;['302 (c.a.']
+60110;['appeal of sushil kumar is dismissed']
+75596;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+147885;['bible is a holy book']
+107086;['appeal is dismissed']
+101292;['fauré is not a canadian citizen or a permanent resident.']
+94364;['dismissing this appeal']
+54761;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunder subs']
+98914;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+82577;['appeal is allowed']
+63876;['appeal isallowed']
+58135;['appeal is dismissed']
+92316;['appeal is dismissed']
+152928;['appeal is allowed']
+107440;['rad finds the appellant’s argument has merit']
+143460;['claimants are persons in need of protection']
+72902;['appeal must be dismissed']
+52512;['dismiss the appeal']
+93239;['ndpvf is composed']
+81282;['appeal is allowed']
+108719;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+95775;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100865;['302 (c.a.']
+32080;['appeal is dismissed']
+96908;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+114337;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100437;['appeal is also dismissed']
+107478;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+85959;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+118182;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97491;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69619;['appeal pursuant tosection 67(1)(a) ofirpais dismissed']
+107071;['appeal of ezechiel kalinda magene is dismissed']
+60986;['appeal terminated']
+146102;['appeal is dismissed']
+52079;['allow the appeal']
+56966;['appeal is allowed']
+95592;['appeal isallowed']
+97803;['claimants xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90652;['appeal is dismissed']
+47756;['appeal is allowed']
+90256;['neither convention refugees']
+97242;['appeal isallowed']
+71807;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97135;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+85390;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+93682;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84215;['appeal is terminated']
+27205;['appeal was dismissed']
+138836;['appeals should be dismissed']
+123708;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+37421;['appeal is allowed']
+99676;['appeal is allowed']
+34894;['appeal is allowed']
+125443;['christian converts']
+101211;['dismissal of the appeal']
+50538;['appeal is dismissed']
+47303;['dismiss the appeal']
+81244;['appeal is allowed']
+116807;['not agree with the rpd’s finding']
+17191;['appeal isallowed.the']
+77894;['appeal of the appellant is dismissed']
+143460;['they are not persons in need of protection']
+92937;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+55176;['appeal were dismissed']
+99170;['appeal isallowed']
+73299;['appeal is determined']
+142979;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+121439;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+134338;['appeal is dismissed']
+145513;['appeal is allowed']
+45407;['appeal isallowed']
+40150;['dismiss this appeal']
+69526;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+101331;['appeal isallowed']
+113297;['appeal is dismissed']
+132835;['appeal is allowed']
+99329;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+51682;['appeal is allowed']
+77954;['appeal is allowed']
+24508;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+80457;['appeal is dismissed']
+68080;['appeal is allowed']
+69762;['appeal isallowed']
+104116;['claims are rejected']
+61443;['panel rejects the claim of xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx']
+83355;['appeal is dismissed']
+144030;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74262;['appeal is allowed']
+67503;['appeal is terminated[emphasis']
+79340;['appeal is dismissed']
+129929;['appeal is dismissed']
+109031;['302 (c.a.']
+88820;['appeal is allowed']
+151978;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+117117;['appeal is dismissed']
+101470;['302 (c.a.']
+59660;['reject the claim for refugee protection']
+99390;['appeal is dismissed']
+97033;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+87597;['negative']
+132371;['appeal is allowed']
+133375;['appeal is dismissed']
+128298;['decisions of the immigration officer are valid in law']
+100473;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+102115;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+67486;['appeal isallowed']
+91664;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71040;['reject their claims']
+98667;['appeal is allowed']
+51048;['appeal were dismissed']
+18007;['appeal is dismissed']
+68366;['appeal is granted']
+75132;['appeal isallowed']
+39896;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91004;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+139433;['appeal should be dismissed']
+72902;['sponsor is not a sponsor']
+45165;['appeal is dismissed']
+76552;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107036;['appeal is dismissed.in', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69522;['application is denied']
+72557;['appeal is dismissed']
+80764;['302 (c.a.']
+71196;['decision of the visa officer is invalid in law']
+116809;['appeals are dismissed']
+143643;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102022;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+110979;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+69154;['appeal is dismissed']
+143573;['are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+79606;['appeal isallowed']
+69107;['appeal of the appellant shao lan li is allowed']
+74855;['appeal is allowed']
+30479;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+54818;['appeal fails']
+148717;['claim is rejected']
+74051;['dismiss it for lack of jurisdiction']
+142517;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82447;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+36179;['set aside the decision', 'allow the appeal']
+27006;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+136083;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+124040;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124705;['appellant is not a person in need of persecution']
+49978;['appeal is dismissed']
+99535;['appeal is allowed']
+62954;['appeal isallowed']
+132832;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+104142;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+84613;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+75446;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+130996;['i therefore reject it']
+101681;['appeal is dismissed']
+111363;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+100344;['claimants, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx, not convention refugees']
+147788;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+100096;['appeals are allowed']
+75137;['appeal is allowed']
+82146;['appeal is allowed']
+95126;['appeal is dismissed']
+82206;['dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+84822;['appeal isallowed']
+67742;['appeal is allowed in law']
+36126;['appealis allowed.the']
+90563;['appeal isallowed']
+143648;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56276;['appeal is allowed in part']
+71160;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+69247;['302 (c.a.)']
+140726;['appellants are therefore convention refugees']
+102261;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+91620;['appeal is dismissed']
+35036;['removal order is set aside']
+63926;['appeal was contested']
+102172;['appeal is allowed']
+87740;['appeals aredismissed,']
+60874;['appeal isallowed']
+107821;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+82151;['appeal is dismissed']
+100151;['removal order is set aside']
+125504;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+141681;['appeal were dismissed']
+86217;['appeal is dismissed']
+107906;['rpd’s positive determination of the respondent’s refugee claim is therefore set aside']
+95508;['dismiss this appeal']
+97233;['appeal is dismissed']
+135122;['rad finds the appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55277;['negative']
+130778;['sponsor must not be in the default']
+108715;['appeal is dismissed']
+80978;['rpd decision   cannot stand and is hereby set aside']
+26742;['appeal is dismissed']
+148634;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+122256;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+84691;['appeal is dismissed']
+41572;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunder subs']
+102166;['allows the minister’s application']
+92735;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+62438;['appeal is allowed']
+74637;['appeal isallowed']
+97825;['302 (c.a.)']
+71276;['appeal is allowed']
+58550;['appeal is allowed']
+105238;['rad finds the rpd committed an error in law']
+122120;['appeal is allowed']
+57934;['appeal is dismissed']
+67935;['officer’s finding is valid in law']
+123676;['appeal is dismissed']
+84305;['appeal is allowed']
+95123;['negative']
+105887;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither “convention refugees”']
+129106;['dismissing your appeal']
+105340;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+42231;['visa officer’s decision is valid']
+108343;['appeal is dismissed']
+47158;['dismissed the appeal in law']
+54795;['appeal is allowed']
+150672;['refugee protection claim was rejected']
+113757;['dismissed mr. zheng’s appeal']
+124666;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+135159;['rad finds that there was a denial of natural justice']
+94050;['appeal isallowed']
+140935;['appeals are dismissed']
+37413;['panel finds the exclusion orders made on march 2, 2018 to be legally valid']
+82587;['appeal is allowed']
+144401;['appellants are not “convention\u2009refugees”']
+64645;['dismiss this appeal']
+100055;['appeal were dismissed']
+90702;['appeal is allowed']
+62380;['claimant’s claim fails']
+59813;['appeal is dismissed']
+101188;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis excluded from the protection offered to refugees']
+80846;['appeal is dismissed']
+124314;['appeal is rejected']
+84244;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+98630;['appeal is dismissed']
+38162;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+90364;['negative']
+99791;['appeal is allowed']
+142967;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+69457;['dismiss this appeal']
+98596;['302 (c.a.']
+149112;['appeal is allowed']
+59737;['appeal is dismissed']
+87070;['appeal be dismissed']
+96061;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+113520;['appeal is allowed']
+60833;['…]”']
+110680;['rpd   determination that the appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in   need of protection']
+59184;['appeal is allowed']
+24194;['appeal is dismissed']
+121518;['appeals are dismissed']
+143880;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89083;['appeal is dismissed']
+72882;['appeal isallowed']
+84742;['appeal is dismissed']
+153586;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+99062;['appeal isdismissedand a departure order', 'iad therefore orders your departure from canada']
+130945;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination']
+51676;['appeal isallowed']
+105235;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+143866;['appeal is dismissed']
+64840;['appeal be dismissed', 'appeal of ti jun li is dismissed']
+142524;['associate appellant’s appeal is allowed']
+114306;['appeal is dismissed']
+93959;['panel finds that the refusal is valid in law']
+101675;['appeal is dismissed']
+46507;['appeal is allowed']
+81183;['appeal is allowed']
+123119;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+125398;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+96158;['iad orders that the present appeal is allowed']
+142958;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a person at risk']
+68728;['appeal isallowed.the']
+52143;['appeal against the immigration appeal division was dismissed']
+52082;['appeal is terminated']
+152247;['appeal is allowed']
+30508;['appeal is dismissed']
+38903;['appeal is allowed']
+84010;['dismiss the appeal']
+125129;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+88971;['appeal is terminated']
+90956;['dismiss the appeal']
+66939;['appeal is dismissed']
+90770;['dismiss the appeal']
+95082;['appeal is allowed']
+82896;['appeals of klemenz schumann and marika paula schumann are dismissed']
+97916;['appeal isallowedand']
+123762;['rad finds that the rpd’s negative objective basis']
+128256;['appeal must be dismissed']
+44037;['appellant is not a person in need of refugee protection']
+100355;['minister’s application is allowed']
+100546;['appeal is allowed']
+62250;['reject the claim']
+86031;['appeal is allowed']
+58143;['appeal isallowed.the']
+98340;['appeal fails']
+94814;['appeal of herbert harvey is dismissed']
+149285;['appeal is dismissed']
+150939;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110715;['appeal is dismissed']
+130754;['appeal is dismissed']
+84751;['appeal is dismissed']
+89248;['appeal is allowed']
+29687;['decision is legally valid']
+82102;['appeal against the refusal to issue a visa']
+113536;['appeal is dismissed']
+124425;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+42087;['appeal was dismissed']
+99739;['appeal isallowed']
+52726;['refugee protection division determines that xxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+81172;['appeal is dismissed']
+95421;['appeal is allowed']
+26697;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+152003;['rad dismisses the application to re-open the appellant’s appeal']
+84821;['appeals are dismissed']
+94173;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision falls within the range of possible, acceptable outcomes']
+98355;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+122666;['child’s refugee protection claim has no merit']
+125503;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+132770;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'thatthey are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+131064;['refusal is set aside']
+101905;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97215;['claim is rejected']
+90849;['appeal is allowed']
+84060;['appeal is dismissed']
+74813;['appeal be allowed']
+136658;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44028;['rad concurs with the rpd’s determination']
+84575;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+103697;['302 (c.a.']
+57025;['appeal is allowed']
+123977;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+54206;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74258;['appeal is allowed']
+122617;['appellants are excluded']
+70893;['dismiss this appeal']
+76138;['appeal is dismissed']
+75891;['302 (c.a.']
+111043;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+83056;['appeal is allowed']
+128183;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+105232;['appeal is allowed in part']
+90803;['302 (c.a.']
+148683;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+96974;['appeal is allowed']
+84307;['appeal is allowed']
+92737;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+92567;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80492;['id’s decision is ill‑founded in fact and in law']
+39574;['appeal is allowed']
+94225;['appeal is dismissed']
+45401;['application is dismissed']
+72649;['appeal is dismissed']
+143593;['they are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151330;['rad finds that the rpd’s conclusion is correct']
+87225;['appeal is terminated']
+94010;['appeal isallowed']
+92948;['visa officer’s decision is set aside']
+76081;['two prra applications were dismissed']
+38774;['appeal isterminatedpursuant']
+84220;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+120780;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+69554;['appeal isallowed']
+56684;['appeals ofdaniel garcia tavera,dacia garcia valdez,danira garciavaldezanddenin ayari garcia valezare dismissed']
+108751;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person who would be subject to persecution should he return to china']
+53449;['appeal is allowed']
+91438;['appeal is allowed']
+74478;['appeal is allowed']
+96088;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+69120;['allow the appeal of moon leung woo']
+80721;['refugee protection division', 'not a person in need of protection']
+87950;['appeal is dismissed']
+85981;['appeal is allowed']
+40065;['appeal is allowed']
+48216;['dismisses this appeal']
+97888;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+52138;['rad determines the', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+56862;['appellants are not permanent residents, nor convention refugees']
+151354;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+141270;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+47119;['tribunal hereby cancels the stay', 'allows the appeal']
+100416;['appeal is dismissed']
+108802;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+74826;['appeal beallowedand']
+95886;['appeal is dismissed', 'rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+102127;['appeal is dismissed']
+123521;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99210;['appellants 1 and 2 in this case are also inadmissible']
+143607;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113295;['appeal is allowed']
+50475;['appeal is allowed']
+142692;['appeal was dismissed']
+140894;['appeal is allowed']
+100516;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52351;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+122771;['appeal is dismissed']
+90089;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+97362;['negative']
+150954;['appeal isallowed']
+71387;['appeal is dismissed']
+107095;['appeal is dismissed']
+124555;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+63987;['dismisses the appeal']
+28287;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76901;['appeal allowed']
+62715;['decision of the immigration officer is well founded in law']
+77864;['claimant’s claim fails']
+89250;['appeal is dismissed']
+65015;['appeal is dismissed']
+85169;['rad rejects them']
+70207;['appeal ofteodora rubio floresis allowed']
+40800;['appeal must be allowed']
+139893;['appeal was considered abandoned']
+148110;['appeals are dismissed', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141647;['appeal be dismissed']
+151908;['appeal is dismissed']
+88028;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxxxxxxx,', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+102989;['appeal is dismissed']
+74852;['appeal is dismissed']
+93014;['appeals are dismissed']
+72978;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+84748;['appeal isallowed']
+151837;['appeal is dismissed']
+91131;['substitutes a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97295;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+76346;['appeal is to proceed']
+64592;['appeal is allowed']
+86527;['appeals were dismissed']
+122129;['appeal is allowed']
+52281;['appeal is terminated']
+141795;['not a person in need of protection']
+87167;['dismiss her appeal']
+60469;['allows this appeal']
+68267;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+61947;['iad declines to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction']
+100554;['appeal is allowed']
+123430;['’ argument']
+37863;['appeal were dismissed']
+80042;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+9675;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+77922;['appeal of lang ji tan is dismissed']
+143644;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+89987;['appeal is allowed']
+76071;['appeal isallowed']
+61406;['appeal is dismissed']
+101868;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+81050;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+73034;['appeal of kheng ly phe is dismissed']
+75881;['appeal isallowed']
+59772;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+149576;['claimant xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+52672;['claimant was a convention refugee']
+83094;['appeal is dismissed']
+103614;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+41824;['appeal is allowed']
+135176;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+97791;['negative']
+123411;['appeal is dismissed']
+136153;['appeal is allowed']
+151106;['appeal is allowed']
+143891;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125491;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+144251;['refugee appeal division sets aside the decision of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+85754;['appeal is allowed']
+99517;['appeal ofzarrindokht pournasrollah haji saraeiis allowed']
+151960;['confirm the negative decision']
+74049;['appeal is allowed']
+74532;['appeal isallowed']
+60469;['appeal isallowed']
+94596;['dismiss this appeal']
+60505;['appeal is terminated']
+48416;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102700;['appeal is allowed']
+21411;['not convention refugees']
+67216;['appeal is dismissed']
+83036;['appeal is allowed']
+101363;['appeal is allowed']
+104127;['claimants are not north korean,', 'rejects their claim for refugee protection']
+114382;['dismisses the appeal']
+82268;['appeal of ghias khalon is allowed']
+60041;['reject the claimant’s explanation']
+82277;['appeal is dismissed']
+97633;['appeal is dismissed']
+88314;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+106835;['appeal is allowed']
+54256;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+132846;['appeal is allowed']
+51091;['appeal is dismissed']
+46997;['appeal is allowed']
+135107;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+61797;['negative']
+63902;['allows the appeal']
+143233;['appeal was dismissed']
+80001;['negative']
+89022;['removal orders are set aside']
+128387;['appeal should be dismissed']
+96339;['appeal is allowed']
+70891;"[""allow the appellant's appeal""]"
+98589;['appeal isallowedand']
+96006;['claimant is not excluded from claiming refugee protection']
+140706;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+62487;['decision of the rpd']
+60014;['negative']
+99963;['appeal is allowed']
+152731;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134221;['appeal is allowed']
+71244;['appeal is allowed']
+65094;['appeal is allowed']
+80473;['dismiss the appeal']
+86394;['appeal is dismissed']
+73308;['allows this appeal']
+104103;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56965;['appeal is allowed']
+92463;['appeal is allowed']
+70766;['panel, therefore, rejects this claim']
+101368;['appeal failed']
+96743;['panel therefore rejects his claim']
+50473;['appeal is allowed']
+62849;['appeal is allowed']
+105337;['rejects her claim']
+77965;['appeal is dismissed']
+87311;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+99454;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47823;['appeal is dismissed']
+99080;['appeal of patrick vandy is dismissed']
+66630;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+90839;['refugee appeal division, as persection 111(1)(a) of theimmigration and refugee protection act', 'confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89928;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107501;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71641;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+122873;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision', 'substitute a positive determination']
+107838;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+36245;['appeal of the daughter, lok ting shek, is allowed']
+59187;['appeal is allowed']
+85536;['appeal is allowed']
+87023;['appeal is allowed']
+94692;['appeal is allowed']
+29688;['appeal is dismissed']
+72586;['dismiss it']
+90197;['negative']
+71488;['appeal is dismissed']
+133693;['allow the appeal', 'appellants are a person in need of protection']
+141249;['appeal was determined to be abandoned']
+45990;['appeal should be denied']
+80085;['appeal is terminated']
+68303;['appeal of gurpreet singh kullar is allowed in law']
+130702;['appeal is terminated']
+58834;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+72632;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91644;['appeal of randy chow is dismissed']
+27292;['dismissal of the present appeal']
+94307;['appeal is terminated']
+31049;['appeal is dismissed']
+68157;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68694;['appeal is allowed']
+150862;['302 (c.a.']
+98509;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95212;['appeal is dismissed']
+82105;['dismiss the appeal']
+26890;['claimants are hindus']
+87872;['appeal is allowed']
+61348;['appeal is dismissed']
+122732;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+56722;['appeal is dismissed']
+80493;['appeal is terminated']
+30522;['appeals are dismissed']
+97353;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+112321;['appeal is determined to beabandonedundersection 168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+95950;['appeal is allowed']
+68079;['appeal is terminated']
+144038;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98396;['removal order is set aside']
+76492;['appeal is dismissed']
+79192;['iad is without jurisdiction']
+70639;['appeal is dismissed']
+146436;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72323;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+92807;['appeal isallowed.the']
+81825;['appeal is dismissed']
+24461;['appeal of balraj singh sandhu is dismissed']
+91211;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+106651;['supports its preceding findings']
+94017;['appeal is accordinglydismissed']
+19153;['appeal is dismissed']
+55273;['claimant is no longer a refugee or person in need of protection']
+110945;['appeal is dismissed']
+58749;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87411;['appeal is allowed']
+71220;['appeal is dismissed']
+76287;['dismiss the appeal']
+93677;['appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+102407;['appeal is allowed']
+123380;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+43410;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+97677;['negative']
+74606;['appeal is allowed.the']
+92524;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123298;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77893;['negative']
+107655;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+91349;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+151883;['rad finds the appellant is a convention refugee']
+97953;['302 (c.a.']
+150689;['rpd’s decision on xxxx claim is confirmed']
+153814;['appeal is allowed']
+47370;['appeal is allowed']
+80097;['panel dismisses the appeal']
+97887;['appeal is allowed']
+113543;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+93142;['appeal is going to be allowed']
+82423;['appeal is allowed']
+91346;['appeal is dismissed']
+92761;['theappeal is allowed']
+92408;['302 (c.a.']
+129925;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99708;['appeals are allowed']
+69413;['dismissing the appeal']
+98963;['appeal was dismissed.irpaprovides']
+88087;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+70095;['appeal isallowed']
+121245;['rad finds it to be correct']
+95793;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+87191;['appeal is dismissed']
+54834;['i agree with the rpd’s conclusions']
+123023;['reject her claim']
+124914;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+110929;['appeal is allowed']
+60699;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+80805;['appeal is allowed']
+77234;['appeal fails']
+107317;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+122733;['appeal is allowed']
+104072;['appeal is allowed']
+122253;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+113279;['appeal is dismissed']
+57089;['appeal is allowed']
+125212;['appeal was to be dismissed']
+98895;['appeal is allowed']
+12205;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+64843;['appeal is dismissed']
+74648;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+80746;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+125469;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76547;['appeal is dismissed']
+27299;['appeal isallowed']
+86480;['appeal is allowed']
+91347;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+122689;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+69675;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+144901;['rad allows the appeal']
+129919;['removal order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+122243;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+102695;['appeals are dismissed']
+94039;['appeal is allowed']
+101429;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+110908;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141616;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+62851;['appeal is allowed']
+47000;['appeal were dismissed']
+71288;['appeal is allowed']
+19381;['appeal is dismissed']
+134428;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+125695;['appeals are dismissed']
+66485;['appeal isallowed']
+91278;['appeal is allowed']
+125468;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124643;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98503;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+142895;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+96807;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+116342;['bjp is no longer part of the state government of punjab']
+143022;['appeal is also denied']
+48910;['appeal is dismissed']
+123984;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+52616;['claimant, mr. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+95028;['appeal is allowed']
+38425;['appeal is dismissed']
+132327;['dismiss these appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+31398;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+151793;['appeal is dismissed']
+80795;['appeal is allowed']
+49983;['appeal isallowed']
+133345;['allow the appellant’s appeal', 'substitute the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+82985;['appeal is allowed']
+50648;['appeal is based']
+135163;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+84784;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76769;['appeal isallowed']
+100543;['appeal is allowed']
+133369;['rpd’s determination is set aside', 'appellant is granted refugee status']
+136184;['substitutes the decision by finding that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+67472;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+108823;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx and her two minor sons, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugees']
+124640;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129123;['appeal is allowed']
+52199;['appeal is allowed']
+83184;['appeal is dismissed']
+74041;['appeal is allowed']
+84463;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68092;['appeal in this case is therefore dismissed.this']
+133267;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+78174;['appeal is dismissed']
+65199;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not a “convention refugees”']
+82891;['appeal is dismissed']
+83914;['appeal is dismissed']
+104839;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+99014;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+45885;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+101013;['appeal was dismissed']
+57069;['rpd’s decision therefore must be set aside']
+19243;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+77991;['appeal isallowed']
+83051;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89084;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89429;['appeal is dismissed']
+30528;['appeal is allowed']
+59187;['appeal is allowed']
+37904;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87740;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+85965;['dismissing this appeal']
+87230;['application to vacate is allowed']
+98288;['dismissing the appellant’s application to extend the time for filing the']
+63168;['appeal is terminated']
+82808;['appeal is terminated']
+69678;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+31988;['appeal is dismissed']
+90930;['appeals are dismissed']
+89712;['appeal is dismissed']
+84855;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98103;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+144407;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+139794;['appeal is dismissed']
+121529;['appeal would be dismissed']
+142808;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122816;['appeal is allowed']
+55945;['appeal requires an oral hearing']
+124588;['substitute my own decision']
+91613;['application for postponement was denied twice']
+70668;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83531;['appeal is allowed']
+122254;['daughter, xxxx xxxx xxxx, are convention refugees']
+133271;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+107463;['rad concurs with the rpd’s decision that the appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+89680;['appeal is allowed']
+93659;['appeal is allowed']
+147800;['appeal is allowed']
+62188;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+93906;['appeal isallowed']
+80167;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+98094;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+70781;['appeal isallowed']
+48417;['appeal is allowed.the']
+70939;['appeal of wen li hong \xa0is dismissed']
+129857;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+39892;['appeal cannot succeed']
+94132;['appeal is dismissed']
+113733;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130682;['appeal isallowed']
+130946;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+77878;['appeal of kam leong choi is dismissed']
+140296;['rad finds that the', 'appellants are not convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+83312;['appeal is allowed']
+43401;['appeal is dismissed']
+54551;['appeal of is dismissed']
+143899;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72642;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+47341;['sponsor is not a sponsor']
+104462;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76452;['appeal is dismissed']
+111181;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+140815;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'not a convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+107386;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+87340;['appeal is dismissed']
+124615;['xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+80167;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+96525;['negative']
+74168;['removal order is set aside']
+95920;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100639;['appeal isallowed']
+50762;['appeal is dismissed']
+102148;['rpd decision stands']
+55168;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+105765;['rad finds that the rpd’s conclusion is absent of any error']
+57035;['departure orders areset aside']
+74224;['dismiss the appeal.if']
+82574;['appeal is allowed']
+123592;['appeal is allowed']
+49546;['appeal is allowed']
+47805;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+88840;['negative']
+77685;['application to re-open is allowed']
+56269;['appeal isallowed']
+59406;['appeal is allowed']
+90685;['appeal is dismissed']
+88422;['negative']
+29686;['appeal is dismissed']
+101795;['appeal is dismissed']
+105795;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+68735;['appeal is dismissed']
+111312;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+95407;['appeal is dismissed']
+97483;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98300;['they are not convention refugees']
+139433;['appeal is dismissed']
+101308;['not substitute a decision that he is a convention refugee']
+146903;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101196;['appeal isallowed']
+95650;['appellant has lost his permanent resident status']
+94447;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+86341;['removal order is set aside']
+94696;['appeal is allowed']
+53443;['appeal is terminated']
+28290;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+74824;['appeal is dismissed']
+65668;['appeal must be dismissed']
+116348;['analysis is flawed']
+83679;['appeal should be dismissed']
+131101;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+80797;['appeal is allowed']
+23054;['dismiss the appeal']
+77920;['appeal is allowed']
+83304;['appeal is terminated']
+128297;['appeal is moot']
+28309;['rpd’s decision must be confirmed']
+47710;['appeal isallowed']
+79473;['appeal division must dismiss the appeal']
+89843;['appeal is allowed']
+13692;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61002;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+107236;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+145103;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination']
+75466;['appeals are allowed']
+72875;['appeal is dismissed']
+40129;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87388;['appeal isallowed']
+90462;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+124058;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+132224;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74989;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+133753;['appeal is dismissed']
+98158;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+87447;['appeal isallowed']
+127702;['appeal is dismissed']
+75500;['appeal of bich pha dip is dismissed']
+81218;['appeal is allowed']
+85861;['negative']
+108773;['appeal is dismissed']
+89912;['dismissed the appeal.as']
+122766;['rad rejects the appellant’s arguments']
+94818;['application is denied']
+81192;['appeal is allowed']
+76712;['appeal will proceed to a full oral hearing']
+141808;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+95123;['neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+97352;['negative']
+98707;['302 (c.a.']
+36134;['appeal is dismissed']
+96485;['appeal is rejected']
+102211;['dismiss this appeal']
+74831;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+70959;['appeal is allowed']
+68145;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+140278;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108856;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+127430;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+87191;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+83543;['immigration appeal board’s decision inchirwa v.canada(minister of manpower and immigration),sets']
+69723;['appeal isallowed']
+138860;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+69571;['dismiss this appeal']
+86342;['appeal should therefore be dismissed']
+13762;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+71814;['appeal is dismissed']
+58387;['appeal is allowed']
+140914;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91414;['appeal is dismissed']
+105367;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+144461;['appeal is allowed']
+147443;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+121392;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+135171;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxxis excluded and is not a “convention refugee”']
+123005;['appeal is allowed']
+98532;['appeal isallowedand']
+128547;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant is a convention refugee']
+47391;['appeal is allowed']
+84527;['appeal isdismissed for lack of jurisdiction']
+61379;['appeals were to be dismissed']
+80478;['appeal is allowed']
+140720;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96525;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+73898;['appeal is allowed']
+89162;['appeal must fail']
+99636;['appeal is dismissed']
+77300;['dismissed the appeal brought']
+132795;['neither adequate state protection']
+42287;['appeal isallowed']
+30531;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+86023;['appeal is dismissed']
+123465;['panel confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+141019;['confirms the decision of the rpd', 'rejects their claims']
+132651;['appeal is dismissed']
+128263;['determination is valid in law']
+104849;['appeal isdismissed.']
+99477;['refugee protection division therefore rejects this claim']
+97932;['appeal of sotero martinez pedalizo is dismissed']
+69608;['appeal is dismissed']
+89956;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+50431;['appeal is dismissed']
+101220;['dismisses the application for reopening of this appeal']
+58830;['appeal is allowed']
+110285;['rad confirms the determination', 'not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+84820;['appeal is allowed']
+86984;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+128362;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+101195;['rpd’s determination rejecting the appellant’s refugee protection claim']
+144935;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99865;['appeal is allowed']
+30478;['appeal is dismissed']
+143169;['appeal is dismissed']
+112423;['appeal is allowed']
+53442;['removal orders areset aside']
+125094;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+77788;['appeal is allowed']
+101799;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+145181;['appeal in respect of this associate appellant is dismissed']
+64918;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+47584;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+93098;['xxxx xxxx xxxxclaim for refugee protection is rejected']
+136110;['thatxxxx xxxxis not subject to article\xa01e of the convention']
+101477;['appeal is allowed']
+87157;['appeal is dismissed']
+76378;['appeal is allowed']
+49178;['appeal is dismissed']
+77114;['appeal isallowed']
+147779;['rad therefore sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+89811;['appeal is allowed']
+56634;['rad has found that the rpd decision will stand']
+97012;['claim is rejected']
+54708;['appeals are dismissed']
+96780;['his claim fails']
+135208;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67627;['appeal isallowed']
+90784;['appeal is dismissed']
+71691;['appeal is dismissed']
+108784;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+128305;['appeal is dismissed']
+101271;['appeal is allowed']
+89985;['appeal is allowed']
+140800;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+112786;['appeal was declared abandoned']
+50539;['appeal were dismissed']
+114375;['appeal is dismissed']
+3173;['appeal is dismissed']
+83545;['appeal isallowed']
+76980;['appeal is dismissed']
+76162;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+148739;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+35544;['appeal should be allowed']
+63971;['appeal is allowed']
+107695;['appeal is dismissed']
+69758;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+105791;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+134353;['appeal is allowed.the']
+92527;['appeal was dismissed']
+123695;['appellants are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83388;['appeal is terminated']
+48091;['appeal is dismissed']
+80787;['adoption is granted']
+75168;['appeal is dismissed']
+125681;['302 (c.a.']
+108782;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86839;['appeal is allowed']
+69417;['appeal fails']
+87845;['appeal   is dismissed']
+87679;['appeal is allowed']
+19117;['appeal is dismissed']
+88261;['appeal is allowed']
+56936;['removal order is set aside']
+124061;['appeal is dismissed']
+47571;['appeal allowed']
+100503;['appeal is dismissed']
+73200;['appellant has not lost his permanent residence status']
+81494;['not set aside the rpd’s determination']
+12206;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+99302;['confirms the determination of the rpd']
+107700;['appeal is allowed.the']
+101530;['appeal be allowed']
+90455;['302 (c.a.)']
+73032;['appeal is dismissed']
+97861;['appeal is allowed']
+94114;['appeal is dismissed']
+81092;['appeals are dismissed']
+89274;['appeal is allowed']
+80213;['302 (c.a.']
+68346;['appeal is allowed']
+81633;['appeal is allowed']
+133371;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70777;['allows this appeal as']
+123137;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69993;['appeals are allowed']
+77544;['appeal isallowed']
+97841;['claimant is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+127702;['appeal was dismissed']
+67434;['appeal is dismissed']
+99986;['reject his claim']
+86004;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+97606;['deny the claim']
+52198;['appeal is dismissed']
+106470;['appeal is dismissed']
+76965;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+148584;['appeal is dismissed']
+69975;['appeal is allowed or dismissed']
+91774;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+123850;['appeal is rejected']
+114327;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+95990;['claimant is a “convention refugee”']
+81427;['appeal is allowed']
+146014;['claimants are convention refugees and accepts the claims']
+30531;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94418;['302 (c.a.']
+106280;['appeal is dismissed']
+102953;['appeal is allowed']
+12212;['appeal is dismissed']
+125352;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+122893;['substitute for it my decision that the appellants xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are convention refugees']
+90952;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90409;['dismisses this appeal']
+123689;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101758;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+145181;['allow the appeal in', 'set aside the decision of the rpd']
+93009;['claimantxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+76963;['appeal is dismissed']
+48420;['appeal is terminated']
+95986;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+63808;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+77795;['refugee protection division determines the claimant not to be a convention refugee and not to be a person in need of protection']
+77071;['appeal is allowed']
+103891;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+59860;['removal orders are set aside']
+94159;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+124062;['appeals are allowed']
+60662;['appeal is dismissed']
+88296;['appeals are dismissed']
+77564;['appeal isallowed']
+109027;['appeal is dismissed']
+82900;['appeal is allowed.the']
+84034;['appeal is allowed']
+145334;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+99592;['appeal is allowed.the']
+76025;['appeal is allowed']
+47147;['appeal is therefore allowed in law']
+99040;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision falls within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes']
+102706;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+97585;['appeal is allowed']
+90205;['negative']
+68461;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72658;['appeal is dismissed']
+77938;['appeal ofneetu bains']
+150673;['appeal is allowed']
+45149;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81182;['appeal be allowed']
+124718;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85955;['appeal is terminated']
+91350;['application to reopen his appeal is denied']
+96086;['appeal is allowed']
+142529;['not hold an oral hearing']
+84749;['appeal isallowed']
+144387;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+42330;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+88816;['302 (c.a.']
+145221;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm, for other reasons', 'appellant is neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+94829;['appeal is allowed']
+67624;['appeal isallowed']
+46086;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+125553;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx,and her minor son', 'not “convention refugees”']
+100798;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+61357;['appeal was not allowed']
+90663;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+110294;['rad finds that the rpd erred here']
+52723;['convention refugee determination division determines xxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+99302;['appeal is dismissed']
+82440;['appeal is allowed']
+86880;['302 (c.a.']
+133346;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+99984;['appeal is dismissed']
+90057;['appeal is dismissed']
+107026;['appeal is dismissed']
+100373;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84578;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+77928;['appeal is allowed']
+80298;['claimants are notconvention refugees']
+59940;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+95063;['dismisses the appeal']
+13680;['appeal will continue normal processing']
+145753;['claims are rejected']
+86904;['dismiss the appeal']
+95352;['appeal isallowed.the']
+124724;['confirm the rpd’s decision that mr. xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142911;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+34096;['appeal is dismissed']
+46022;['302 (c.a.)']
+143551;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+109030;['appeal was abandoned']
+68140;['appeal is denied']
+62438;['appeal of jagjit singh mangat is allowed']
+72560;['allow the appeal']
+47346;['appeal is allowed']
+59779;['dismiss this appeal']
+100069;['302 (c.a.']
+84786;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82203;['appeal is allowed']
+96092;['claimants are neither convention refugeespursuant']
+97599;['reject her claim']
+80779;['appeal is allowed']
+71167;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+83017;['appeal is terminated']
+62938;['appeal is allowed']
+72792;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+50482;['appeal isallowed']
+41812;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+73200;['appeal is allowed']
+81168;['appeal is dismissed']
+131062;['appeal were dismissed']
+123388;['appeal is dismissed']
+94045;['appeal of kenan blakcori is therefore dismissed']
+104075;['appeal is allowed']
+67664;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+61928;['appeal terminated']
+88907;['appeal is based']
+70667;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77465;['appeal is terminated']
+85974;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+102564;['appeal is terminated']
+83018;['appeal isallowed.the']
+101061;['negative']
+83383;['appeal allowed']
+98375;['dismiss this appeal']
+55031;['appeal is allowed']
+44082;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+133178;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76978;['appeal is dismissed']
+80575;['negative']
+100049;['appeal be dismissed']
+63951;['appeal is allowed']
+102473;['appeals for joshua chibuike iwueke, favour ikechukwu iwueke and justice chukwuebuka iwueke are allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+88299;['appeal is allowed']
+52924;['appeal is allowed']
+100920;['appeal is allowed']
+81145;['appeal is allowed']
+95660;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+37065;['iad dismissed the appeal']
+90842;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+125634;['allow the appeal', 'substitute my own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+13832;['appeal is allowed']
+82676;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+133387;['appeal is dismissed']
+80378;['appeal is dismissed']
+122642;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+107818;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+83547;['appeal is dismissed']
+91217;['application to reopen should be dismissed']
+59987;['negative']
+134175;['appeal is allowed']
+88063;['confirm the determination']
+113614;['appeal is allowed']
+149571;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+100273;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+69155;['appeal ofgurdev singh dhaliwalwith respect to his fathermohinder singh dhaliwalis allowed']
+61428;['negative']
+38851;['appeal is allowed']
+14511;['appeal is dismissed']
+33086;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+46010;['appeal isallowed']
+13697;['appeals are allowed']
+108116;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+69200;['appeal of gurpal singh beelsa is dismissed']
+38878;['appeal in respect of the refusal of hong hua lin (and fan xi lin’s) apr is allowed']
+34629;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74729;['appeal isallowed']
+92405;['appeal is allowed']
+124648;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+101395;['visa officer’s decision, though legally valid, is set aside']
+146946;['rad concurs with the rpd']
+37398;['denies the appeal']
+124026;['appeal is allowed']
+101661;['appeal of kuljit singh takher is dismissed']
+125054;['rad finds that it did']
+98105;['appeal is dismissed']
+69135;['appeal is dismissed']
+106155;['appeal is allowed']
+95200;['allow the appeal']
+82267;['appeal to proceed']
+64624;['302 (c.a.']
+105233;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+94527;['appeal is allowed']
+108257;['appeal is dismissed']
+123384;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+80298;['claimants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+31296;['dismissing the appeal']
+135207;['appeal is allowed']
+96223;['appeal is dismissed']
+77811;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+106676;['dismiss the appeal']
+144755;['appeal were dismissed']
+93010;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection from torture']
+79074;['appeal may have merit']
+107223;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131739;['appeal is allowed']
+81602;['appeal is allowed']
+123971;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+92858;['appeal isallowed']
+124972;['302 (c.a.']
+84056;['appeal isallowed']
+93917;['appeal is dismissed']
+133739;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94084;['appellant is not a good candidate']
+102081;['dismissing the appellant’s appeal']
+140851;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+63198;['appeal is allowed']
+125103;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75931;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124615;['xxxx is not a person in need of protection']
+78006;['appeal is dismissed']
+84911;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87949;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+43709;['claim is therefore rejected']
+76767;['dismiss the appeal']
+140844;['appeal is allowed']
+98564;['appeal is allowed']
+95934;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+124638;['appeal is allowed']
+124549;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+99927;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94775;['board denies the claimants’ claim for refugee protection']
+88449;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+98561;['appeal of yan ling liu isdismissed.']
+72668;['appeal is dismissed']
+90904;['appeal isallowed']
+96631;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+131001;['i agree with the rpd’s determination']
+89331;['appeal isallowed']
+143246;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102165;['appeals are dismissed']
+103914;['appellant is not in need of protection']
+68742;['removal orders are set aside']
+23098;['appeal is dismissed']
+67932;['302 (c.a.)']
+123870;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+59837;['not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+92940;['appeal is allowed']
+107243;['appeal is dismissed']
+51126;['decision is well founded in law']
+101404;['appeal is allowed']
+143568;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96590;['appeals are allowed']
+87014;['appeal brought by the appellant']
+18004;['appeal is allowed']
+72319;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+67655;['appeal must fail']
+102686;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+125538;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+68364;['appeal is dismissed']
+96954;['appeal is dismissed']
+57948;['appeal is allowed']
+89922;['appeal is allowed']
+90229;['negative']
+62122;['appeal isterminated']
+78075;['appeal of rup chand with respect to all named applicants in the notice of appeal,']
+87981;['negative']
+107317;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+96735;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+93543;['appeal of dihua wang is allowed']
+93223;['appeal is allowed']
+127723;['appeal is dismissed']
+143565;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104558;['appeal is dismissed']
+111293;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+67488;['appeal is allowed']
+96665;['appeal is allowed']
+99439;['claim is rejected']
+151951;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86868;['appeal is allowed']
+123129;['appeals of the associate appellant and the minor appellants are allowed']
+118218;['rpd’s decision is set aside', 'substitute my own decision that the appellant is aconventionrefugee.']
+96181;['appeal is allowed.the']
+145829;['302 (c.a.']
+97379;['negative']
+76404;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87234;['appeal is allowed']
+86901;['appeal is dismissed']
+99826;['appeal is dismissed']
+46997;['appeal is allowed']
+19238;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+96332;['appeal is dismissed']
+95001;['dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+75604;['appeal is dismissed']
+142104;['panel rejects this claim']
+12219;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+57301;['appeal is dismissed']
+94343;['appeal is dismissed']
+52099;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+124818;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+95621;['appeal is dismissed']
+94092;['appeal is allowed']
+98917;['refugee protection claimant is not “convention refugee”']
+99352;['appeal is dismissed']
+98814;['application to vacate is accordingly allowed']
+101963;['appeal is allowed']
+81173;['appeal is allowed']
+102533;['appeal is dismissed']
+39567;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+104282;['appeal must be dismissed']
+72178;['appeal is dismissed']
+93097;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+103903;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+47581;['allow the appeal']
+92750;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+39031;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+74654;['inrahimi, stand']
+76372;['appeal is dismissed']
+64835;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+133381;['appeal were dismissed']
+59377;['appeal fails']
+146846;['appeal is allowed']
+149066;['rad agrees with the finding of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+97132;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+146814;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+122935;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+113239;['appeal is allowed']
+140287;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55313;['appeals of elvera godoy celso and osorio robles celso are dismissed']
+127711;['appeal is allowed.the']
+95293;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+73041;['appeal isallowedand']
+33071;['appeal is dismissed']
+76568;['refusal is not valid in law']
+34988;['appeal isallowed']
+106938;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+88030;['appeal is allowed']
+107904;['appeals are allowed']
+40665;['dismiss the appeal']
+47756;['appeal is dismissed']
+79755;['302 (c.a.)']
+83531;['appeal is allowed']
+151094;['appeal is allowed']
+94155;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+94195;['appeal is allowed']
+95262;['application to reopen the appeal, dated 7 april 2014, is dismissed']
+143842;['appellant is therefore a convention refugee']
+108708;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+92498;['appeal is dismissed']
+100168;['claimants are neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection', 'rejects their refugee protection claim']
+33316;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124340;['appeal is rejected']
+63954;['dismiss the appeal']
+108765;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+56995;['not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+111181;['appellants are convention refugees and/or persons in need of protection']
+142906;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+22806;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+87477;['appeal is dismissed']
+19153;['appeal is dismissed']
+38901;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99990;['appeals are dismissed']
+57507;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+49163;['appeal were dismissed']
+62987;['appeal is allowed']
+64312;['appeal of hongda zhang is allowed']
+26780;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+37844;['appeal were dismissed']
+128174;['appeal is dismissed']
+146856;['appeal of the male associate appellant is rejected']
+54834;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+52332;['rad allows the appeal']
+54765;['appeal is allowed']
+52715;['claimant cannot be excluded from refugee status']
+90049;['appeal isallowedand']
+144073;['appeal is allowed']
+96987;['appeal is dismissed']
+123324;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+58819;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+98089;['appeal is allowed']
+39574;['appellant had not lost her permanent resident status']
+92470;['appeal isallowed']
+102571;['appeal were dismissed']
+140935;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+121431;['appeal is allowed']
+76365;['sba meets the definition of an organization']
+28062;['appeal is allowed']
+80983;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99773;['appeal is allowed']
+92337;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+74092;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+123040;['i disagree with the rpd’s reasons']
+26491;['dismiss the appeal']
+89372;['appeal is terminated']
+82139;['appeal is dismissed']
+89106;['appeal isallowed']
+76377;['appeal is allowed']
+62845;['appeal isdismissedand the']
+7588;['appeal is allowed']
+152929;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+146827;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+134418;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+82085;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+102403;['dismiss the present appeal']
+86193;['appeal is dismissed']
+99778;['appeal be dismissed']
+83345;['appeal is dismissed']
+147467;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+135207;['rad finds that this is not a sufficient basis']
+95638;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+87990;['negative']
+76829;['appeal ofvijay boodram ramnathsinghis dismissed']
+89035;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+95018;['appeal is terminated']
+83009;['appeal is allowed']
+97018;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+51120;['appeal shall proceed to a hearing on the merits.res']
+75492;['appeal is allowed']
+102378;['appeal is allowed']
+91327;['appeal of sarbjit kaur thind is dismissed']
+106418;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87798;['decision of the adjudicator cannot be allowed to stand']
+68580;['appeal isallowed']
+80072;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+80744;['appeal is dismissed']
+151745;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination']
+85497;['appeal is allowed']
+144394;['appeal is allowed']
+87978;['appeal is dismissed']
+67522;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+143622;['appeal must be dismissed']
+80737;['appeal is dismissed']
+135186;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+89021;['appeal must be dismissed']
+96775;['claim is rejected']
+134164;['appeal is allowed']
+128295;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+56882;['appeal isallowed']
+70492;['appeal is dismissed']
+92436;['appeal isallowed.the']
+85521;['dismissed the appeal']
+66309;['appeal isallowed.the']
+94555;['appeal must be dismissed']
+64615;['appeal is dismissed']
+148645;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status.the', 'removal order is set aside']
+124828;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102801;['appeal isallowed']
+46035;['appeal isallowed']
+132907;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+98459;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+86326;['allow the appeal']
+76849;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+102553;['appeal should be dismissed']
+90654;['appeals filed bymarie dorothie jean\xa0charlesand her two daughters,angèle noorjean‑baptisteandmarilys noor jean-baptisteare dismissed']
+107064;['dismiss theappeal.']
+74653;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+83049;['appeal is dismissed']
+85229;['appeal isallowed']
+50524;['appeal is allowed']
+88844;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx', 'not “convention refugees”']
+101459;['appeal isallowed']
+85928;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+62891;['appeal is allowed']
+125009;['reject the appellant’s argument']
+146932;['rad confirms the rpd’s decision', 'dismisses the appeal']
+77875;['appeal is allowed']
+100081;['appeal is dismissed']
+90823;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+102116;['appeal is allowed']
+84725;['appeal is dismissed']
+54187;['appeal is dismissed']
+44033;['dismiss the appeal']
+19113;['appeal is allowed']
+151327;['appeal is allowed']
+5143;['appeal is dismissed']
+126422;['appeals of manpreet kaur khangura, rajvir kaur kangura and gurdip singh khangura are allowed']
+123853;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention\xa0refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+86884;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+99712;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+116797;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+75485;['appeal is dismissed']
+41963;['appeal is dismissed']
+132837;['appeal is allowed']
+120742;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34628;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+141061;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant is a convention refugee']
+92821;['appeal is dismissed']
+92572;['appeal is terminated']
+84734;['allow the appellant’s appeal']
+120775;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+76080;['appeal is dismissed']
+64852;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107837;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+61028;['appeal is allowed']
+146916;['appeal is allowed.the']
+107854;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95368;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+145352;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98621;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+122662;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+69975;['appeal is dismissed']
+122371;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'declares that the appellant, xxxx xxxx, is a convention refugee']
+93691;['appeal is allowed']
+107092;['appeal is dismissed']
+127908;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+97004;['appeal is allowed']
+123331;['appeal is allowed']
+61477;['302 (c.a.']
+96484;['appeal is allowed']
+93972;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+93053;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100188;['dismissed the appeal']
+96285;['negative']
+89096;['appeal is dismissed']
+57064;['rad supports the rpd’s finding']
+132760;['dismiss the appeal']
+95980;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim']
+100787;['appeal is allowed']
+65134;['appeal would be dismissed']
+52285;['exclusion order is set aside']
+55513;['application to reopen the appeal is allowed']
+130886;['refusal is set aside']
+100550;['stay is cancelled']
+80992;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100558;['dismiss this appeal']
+85838;['appeal is allowed']
+30515;['dismiss this appeal']
+95891;['appeal is dismissed']
+60087;['negative']
+94584;['appeal is allowed']
+125647;['rad finds that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+92749;['appeal is dismissed']
+87325;['appeal of is dismissed']
+46507;['appeal is allowed']
+31216;['appeal is dismissed']
+50505;['dismiss the appeal']
+100116;['appeal isallowedand']
+81866;['appeal is dismissed']
+46072;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+99962;['appeal is dismissed']
+89356;['appeal is allowed']
+43380;['302 (c.a.)']
+116781;['appeal is dismissed']
+47812;['appeal is dismissed']
+150948;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+83649;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+38783;['appeal isallowed']
+94823;['appeal is terminated']
+27237;['appeal is allowed']
+99829;['appeal is dismissed']
+56907;['appeals are dismissed']
+58128;['appeal be dismissed']
+93305;['appeal by the minister is allowed']
+105296;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+151326;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+75083;['appeal is allowed']
+102381;['dismiss the present appeal']
+70058;['appeal isallowed']
+98312;['appeal is allowed']
+87809;['appeal is allowed']
+68220;['appeal isallowed']
+49536;['appeal is dismissed']
+39074;['appeal of ranjeet kaur janjua is allowed']
+146838;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+142817;['rpd’s determination cannot be upheld']
+45156;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+151856;['appeal is allowed']
+28305;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+75987;['appeal isallowed']
+28043;['appeal is dismissed']
+90788;['302 (c.a.']
+140703;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+97981;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+92796;['appeal is rejected']
+72833;['appeal is allowed']
+56909;['appeal isallowed']
+105907;['negative decision should stand']
+124566;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+141637;['theappealis allowed']
+30522;['appeal is dismissed']
+105848;['appeal is dismissed']
+145769;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97947;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26731;['immigration appeal division further orders the appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+139867;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54700;['appeal should be dismissed']
+101290;['dismiss the appeal']
+112380;['appeals dismissed']
+59910;['appeal would be allowed or dismissed']
+142829;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+71189;['appeal of sarbjit kaur jassal is allowed']
+62938;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+76686;['dismiss her appeal']
+129184;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+88252;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+27227;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+126411;['302 (c.a.']
+68440;['appeal is dismissed']
+92796;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+125683;['302\xa0(c.a.']
+100811;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+86323;['302 (c.a.']
+75440;['appeal is dismissed']
+85304;['appeal is dismissed']
+143584;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that she is a convention refugee']
+113785;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'whichxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+55294;['panel finds them as well to be convention refugees']
+96289;['negative']
+58121;['regulation is notultra viresthe']
+107809;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+52347;['dismiss the appeal']
+93604;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+56272;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugees']
+55356;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+29634;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+116802;['dismiss the appeal']
+122359;['i\xa0am setting aside the rpd’s determination']
+36129;['appeal is allowed']
+74617;['appeal is dismissed']
+42299;['appeal isallowed']
+68585;['appeal isallowed']
+82191;['appeal is dismissed']
+96214;['appeal is dismissed']
+85476;['appeal is dismissed']
+108191;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99784;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+82679;['appeal isallowed']
+146388;['you are not a convention refugee or even a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim']
+33076;['rad reconsiders its decision of january 16, 2014']
+60924;['appeal isallowed']
+61364;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+140817;['appeal is allowed']
+99451;['appeal is dismissed']
+74487;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction']
+55346;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95024;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+125100;['dismiss the appeal']
+123671;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+121939;['302 (c.a.']
+144403;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97336;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+138865;['appeal of hussein ali sheriff is allowed']
+91437;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+72179;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+150951;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+136077;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+151900;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+150657;['confirm the rpd determination', 'appellant is excluded from the protection of theact', 'appeal is therefore dismissed']
+130935;['i agree with the rpd’s findings']
+84761;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+124919;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+91247;['appeal is allowed']
+106786;['appeal is dismissed']
+57089;['appeal is allowed']
+133389;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+61425;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+147473;['rad therefore confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+61493;['302 (c.a.']
+147877;['application is allowed']
+60914;['appeal is dismissed']
+63624;['appeal of siu har hung leung is allowed']
+140239;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+70036;['appeal beallowed']
+58567;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60665;['application for leave to appeal is dismissed']
+68291;['appeal isallowed']
+101754;['appeal is dismissed']
+128636;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+29127;['appeal is dismissed']
+97977;['appeal is dismissed']
+56170;['claimants are convention refugees']
+77605;['dismissing the first appeal']
+82687;['appeal isallowed']
+123399;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+99178;['appeal is dismissed']
+100620;['appeal is allowed']
+151496;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+143185;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143497;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+85924;['appeal isallowed']
+149284;['302 (c.a.']
+128426;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+108416;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+143593;['rpd’s determination is correct']
+74547;['appeal were dismissed']
+94071;['appeal is determined']
+84761;['exclusion order is set aside']
+142729;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+124036;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+105433;['appeal is allowed']
+58133;['appeal is dismissed']
+140707;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+26484;['appeal is allowed']
+131147;['appeal is allowed']
+69246;['appeal is dismissed']
+150712;['appeal is allowed']
+67436;['appeal is allowed']
+107056;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+113626;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94747;['appeal is allowed']
+77270;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+95680;['appeal with respect to that ground of refusal is allowed']
+113252;['appeal is allowed']
+96572;['appeal is dismissed']
+124050;['appeal is allowed']
+15874;['claimants have not established that they are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+90790;['appeal is allowed']
+59936;['claimants are persons in need of protection']
+131028;['appeal isallowed.the']
+133349;['appeal is allowed']
+148492;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+93633;['appeal is allowed']
+100817;['appeal is dismissed']
+96931;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+118408;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89834;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+54193;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+133689;['rad grants the appeal']
+80780;['not convention refugees', 'are not persons in need of protection', 'claims are rejected']
+87158;['appeal is dismissed']
+124948;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+152025;['appeal is dismissed']
+100839;['nor a person in need of protection']
+151926;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+52097;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+94991;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95338;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+19130;['appeal is allowed']
+95117;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+105211;['appeal isallowedand']
+98583;['appeal is granted']
+17192;['appeal is dismissed']
+94438;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision, cannot substitute its own determination']
+97633;['appeal is dismissed']
+96150;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+127457;['appeal would be dismissed']
+70908;['appeal is governed by theact']
+124013;['negative determination is therefore confirmed']
+94020;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+39910;['appeal is abandoned']
+70756;['appeal allowed']
+43399;['appeal is dismissed']
+80028;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxare\xa0 not\xa0 convention refugees or\xa0 persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+131053;['appeal is allowed']
+98332;['appeal is allowed']
+125554;['appeal is rejected']
+122671;['appeal is allowed']
+87054;['appeal is dismissed']
+68536;['appeal is allowed']
+148629;['appeal is allowed']
+92157;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+91254;['appeal is terminated']
+64634;['appeal is allowed']
+71254;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+98736;['appeal is dismissed']
+99157;['appeal is terminated']
+124972;['claims fail']
+133397;['appeal is dismissed']
+98087;['claim is therefore rejected']
+98973;['appeal is dismissed']
+95592;['appeal isallowed']
+69400;['reject this explanation']
+55273;['not invoke compelling reasons']
+152240;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+133281;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+102121;['removal order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91683;['appeal is allowed.the']
+98599;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+38899;['appeal of vita ion is dismissed']
+17983;['appeal is dismissed']
+47154;['appeal is also dismissed']
+83486;['removal order is set aside']
+89770;['immigration officer’s decision is wrong in law']
+47751;['appeal is dismissed']
+98907;['appeal of farqad hasan abdul al-zwaidy is dismissed']
+127449;['appeal isallowed']
+96900;['appeal must be dismissed']
+123857;['substitute my own decision that the appellantxxxx xxxx xxxxis convention refugee']
+84136;['302 (c.a.)']
+107630;['rad will not substitute its own determination for the rpd’s unsupportable decision']
+104096;['claim is therefore rejected']
+65195;['allow the appeal and set aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+98969;['rad allows the application to reopen the appellant’s appeal,']
+67614;['appeal is allowed']
+107612;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+29721;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+24398;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107142;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+77815;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+147450;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+140934;['dismiss the appeal']
+54767;['appeal is dismissed']
+132877;['appeal is dismissed']
+99269;['appeal is allowed in law']
+65687;['dismiss the appeal']
+77937;['appeal of hau se au yeung is dismissed']
+80678;['negative']
+126398;['claimant or appellant is therefore neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26753;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+83548;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+129407;['claimant is excluded']
+14701;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+101055;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+109627;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+107446;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92031;['dismissing the appeal']
+83023;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+92780;['dismissal of the appeals']
+94198;['appeal isallowed']
+100196;['appeal is dismissed']
+121808;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82993;['appeal is allowed']
+77988;['appeal of delroy nicholas morgan is dismissed']
+121857;['rpd’s decision is upheld']
+85538;['appeal is dismissed']
+107836;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+151409;['appeal is allowed']
+80695;['negative']
+111161;['appeal is allowed']
+141545;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+81122;['appeal is allowed']
+135465;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+149270;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+101541;['appeal is dismissed']
+111097;['appeal is dismissed']
+100569;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90247;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+94965;['appeal is dismissed']
+123302;['dismiss the appeal']
+52618;['…).”']
+98668;['appeals are allowed']
+78082;['allow his appeal.']
+122249;['substitute my determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+89855;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+22096;['appeal is allowed']
+151462;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108709;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+95579;['appeal is allowed']
+136120;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+48213;['appeal is dismissed']
+99868;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+94326;['appeal is dismissed']
+72858;['appeal is dismissed']
+50764;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+76697;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+141234;['appellant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62446;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+142495;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+53872;['appeal is dismissed']
+75242;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+109170;['appeal is dismissed']
+41824;['appeal is allowed']
+90501;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68424;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate reasons']
+90024;['appeal isallowed']
+73200;['removal order is set aside']
+99350;['ms. gill is inadmissible']
+94664;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+98102;['decision granting refugee status toxxxxxxxxis vacated']
+63825;['appeal of rin suon is dismissed']
+69218;['appeal is dismissed']
+137483;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82794;['appeal is allowed']
+63054;['appeal is allowed']
+124655;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+63709;['appeal of thi van tuong tran is dismissed']
+76273;['appeal is dismissed']
+59182;['appeal is allowed']
+50796;['appeal be dismissed']
+138824;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+88167;['appeal is allowed.the']
+63759;['appeal is allowed.the']
+124631;['302 (c.a.']
+89876;['claimants not to be convention refugees']
+108945;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+131198;['appeals are dismissed']
+94345;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151898;['appeal is dismissed']
+55104;['appeal is dismissed']
+61536;['appeal is dismissed']
+76739;['appeal isallowedand']
+88319;['appeal isallowed']
+147452;['not a person in need of protection']
+101756;['appeal is dismissed']
+82051;['appeal is allowed']
+95810;['appeal is allowed']
+129905;['appeal is allowed']
+58108;['appeal is dismissed']
+59860;['appeals are allowed']
+79889;['negative']
+95525;['appeal is allowed']
+101503;['appeal is dismissed']
+90228;['negative']
+101765;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+47103;['appeal bedismissed.']
+142842;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+141043;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither “convention refugees”']
+135491;['claim is rejected']
+103459;['appeal is allowed']
+61362;['appeal is allowed']
+105764;['appeals ofxxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxxare hereby withdrawn']
+62963;['appeal is dismissed']
+41964;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+102089;['appeal is dismissed']
+95567;['appeal is allowed']
+20837;['appeal is dismissed']
+99982;['claims are rejected']
+45235;['dismiss the appeal']
+84692;['appeal is terminated']
+94363;['appeal is allowed']
+84581;['appeal is allowed']
+34159;['appeal is allowed.the']
+74720;['appeal isallowed']
+30486;['appeal is dismissed']
+56868;['dismisses this appeal']
+87106;['appeal isallowed.the']
+114329;['appeal is dismissed']
+75408;['appeal is withdrawn']
+69763;['appeal ofgurpinder kaurdhaliwal, in respect to her husband,jagroop singh tiwana, is allowed']
+96037;['refugee appeal division (rad) confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+58126;['appeal is terminated']
+52136;['appeal is dismissed']
+88898;['claimants are not “convention refugees,”']
+98825;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+71720;['appeal is allowed']
+76508;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+6669;['appeal is determined']
+105827;['appeal is dismissed']
+132335;['appeal is allowed']
+45190;['appeal is allowed']
+106396;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+105830;['appeal is allowed']
+71248;['allows the appeal']
+89081;['negative']
+97413;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+46035;['appeal is allowed']
+89095;['negative']
+52074;['appeal is allowed']
+138807;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+28038;['appeal is dismissed']
+56797;['refugee protection division determines thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+90929;['appeal is allowed']
+100141;['neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+92761;['appeal is allowed']
+91922;['appeals are dismissed']
+78162;['terminates his appeal']
+92784;['appeal were dismissed']
+129997;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67520;['appeal is dismissed']
+120766;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79232;['appeal is dismissed']
+93061;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56736;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+81102;['appeal is allowed']
+124672;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+153144;['positive determination']
+97344;['appeal isallowed']
+66309;['appeal proceeded']
+81921;['appeal is dismissed']
+143005;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85935;['appeal isallowed']
+79961;['claimants,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx, are not convention refugees', 'rejects their claims']
+95655;['appeal is dismissed']
+90773;['refugee appeal division confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57084;['appeal is allowed in law']
+45241;['appeal isallowedand']
+91225;['appeal is allowed']
+91070;['appeal is terminated']
+101898;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+138860;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate reasons']
+131917;['appeal is allowed']
+25529;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+70401;['appealis dismissed.the', 'application is denied']
+46482;['appeal is allowed']
+67605;['appeal be allowed']
+97610;['claim is rejected']
+97794;['negative']
+36466;['appeal isallowed']
+121479;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes that decision with its own determination that she is a convention refugee']
+117114;['appeal is allowed']
+101270;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+129902;['appeal is allowed']
+26728;['appeal is dismissed']
+106819;['appeal is dismissed']
+57070;['rad finds that this decision must be set aside']
+124955;['appeal is allowed']
+46010;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107327;['reject the family’s claim']
+89994;['dismiss this appeal']
+137450;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx,did not establish that he is a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+103528;['appeal is allowed']
+128440;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99300;['appeal is dismissed']
+57821;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+82709;['appeal isallowed']
+130951;['rad confirms the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee']
+34178;['appeals are dismissed']
+103541;['appeal is allowed']
+72013;['appeal isallowed']
+82071;['appeals with respect to them are dismissed']
+94020;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+54255;['appeal is moot']
+81662;['appeal is allowed']
+80026;['reject his claim']
+54807;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+132638;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+72206;['appeal is allowed']
+123716;['appeal is allowed']
+73260;['appeal must be dismissed']
+69565;['appeal isallowed']
+21356;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+82081;['appeal is allowed']
+66491;['dismiss the appeal']
+93905;['appeal is dismissed']
+54707;['appeal is dismissed']
+55248;['claimant, is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor “a person in need of protection”']
+69125;['appeal is dismissed']
+129869;['removal order isset aside']
+103541;['appeal is allowed.the']
+77836;['panel rejects the claim ofxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxajayi for refugee protection']
+116764;['appeal is dismissed']
+75927;['appeal was argued']
+77226;['appellant has not lost their permanent resident status']
+128401;['appeal is allowed']
+100645;['appeal is allowed']
+94013;['appeal is allowed']
+136747;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+101317;['appeal is allowed']
+48136;['appeal is allowed']
+132823;['appeal is denied']
+112331;['appeal is dismissed']
+108932;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+81324;['appeal is allowed']
+36948;['appeal is allowed']
+102169;['appeals being dismissed']
+122381;['appeals are allowed']
+72552;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92759;['appeal, based onparagraph 67(1)(c) of theact']
+133188;['appeal is allowed']
+66783;['appeal is allowed.the']
+77627;['dismiss the appeal']
+97246;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+123981;['appeal is allowed']
+146131;['allows the application to vacate']
+98671;['nor persons in need of protection']
+73291;['appeal is dismissed']
+72854;['appeal is allowed']
+73319;['appeal be dismissed']
+144564;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+14031;['appeal is dismissed']
+77986;['appeals of hassan farshchiha, shahrzad mansour-zadeh and their daughters shirin farshchiha and shiva farshchiha are dismissed']
+121456;['appeal would be dismissed']
+52602;['claimant is not a convention refugee.']
+68704;['appeal is dismissed']
+54184;['appeal is allowed']
+45189;['appeal is allowed.the']
+80534;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+75446;['declare the matter abandoned']
+153275;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+26520;['appeal of phei phei teoh is dismissed']
+124694;['appeal is allowed']
+46013;['appeal is dismissed']
+56921;['appeal is allowed']
+108066;['appeal is dismissed']
+136740;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+38900;['appeal is allowed']
+83078;['appeal is allowed']
+90371;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100939;['dismissing the appeal']
+44091;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+63720;['appeal is dismissed']
+91162;['allow the appeal']
+124025;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97354;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124986;['rad concludes that the', 'appellants are excluded from the protection of the convention.accordingly', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+114322;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+82683;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+57086;['appeal is dismissed']
+100541;['stay is not an appropriate disposition in the circumstances']
+93611;['appeal isallowed']
+91718;['appeals are dismissed']
+85926;['appeals arede novoappeals']
+47923;['allows this appeal']
+132071;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123636;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56794;['claimant to be a convention refugee']
+148734;['minister’s application is therefore allowed']
+75920;['appeal of the appellant']
+68351;['six appeals are dismissed']
+105706;['appeal is dismissed']
+61867;['appeal is allowed']
+66252;['appeal is dismissed']
+122827;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84279;['appeal is terminated']
+96657;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+40119;['appeal is allowed']
+102432;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94602;['appeal isallowed']
+147793;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+55107;['appeal is allowed']
+74679;['appeal is dismissed']
+76447;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96020;['appeal is dismissed']
+123958;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69431;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+109005;['claimant’s claim fails']
+60118;['panel rejects his claim']
+39899;['appeal is allowed']
+63062;['appeal is dismissed']
+67386;['appellant is not a suitable candidate for a stay of his removal order and', 'appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+113217;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+139449;['applications to reinstate and reopen the appeal are dismissed']
+150950;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98768;['appeal is dismissed']
+98464;['removal order is set aside']
+76620;['appeal isallowed']
+93683;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92159;['appeal is dismissed']
+144045;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90234;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+40288;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+102913;['appeal is dismissed']
+132844;['removal order is set aside']
+99312;['appeal is allowed']
+24195;['appeal is dismissed']
+95032;['appeal is discontinued']
+95780;['appeal is dismissed']
+92026;['appeal of viktor robashchuk is dismissed']
+101530;['appeal isallowed']
+31996;['appeal is dismissed']
+50434;['appeal is being dismissed']
+102933;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+55520;['rad found the rpd’s conclusions']
+128912;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+52211;['appeal is dismissed']
+94600;['appeal is allowed']
+82789;['appeal is dismissed']
+42415;['appeal is dismissed']
+60909;['appeal will be allowed']
+95440;['appeal is dismissed']
+151745;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination of these claims']
+87419;['appeal is allowed']
+105215;['appeal is dismissed']
+107141;['appeal is dismissed']
+151962;['appeal is dismissed']
+63829;['appeal is allowed']
+57819;['appeals are allowed']
+130714;['appeal is dismissed']
+107068;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+60373;['appeal is terminated']
+99963;['appeal is allowed']
+132782;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+98709;['appeal is dismissed']
+66204;['dismiss the appeal']
+92794;['appeal is allowed']
+89853;['dismiss this appeal']
+95325;['removal orders are set aside', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+133729;['appeal is dismissed']
+107620;['appeal is dismissed']
+82862;['appeal is dismissed']
+101502;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+37411;['appeal of isha fatmata bangura is dismissed']
+81410;['appeal is allowed']
+151094;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+112340;['appeal would be dismissed']
+76529;['appeal is allowed']
+105236;['appeal is dismissed']
+96838;['negative']
+118260;['appeal is allowed']
+97350;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133351;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+110312;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+68589;['appeal be dismissed']
+63010;['appeal is dismissed']
+131755;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute its determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+108198;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+88066;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81782;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+124625;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+107613;['appeal is allowed']
+147010;['appeals are dismissed']
+58559;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal,']
+116835;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90121;['negative']
+87397;['appeal is dismissed']
+153267;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+13768;['decision is well-founded in law and in fact']
+80214;['claimants, more likely']
+71634;['appeal fails']
+77281;['dismiss the appeal']
+94468;['appeal is dismissed']
+132071;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+123018;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+42176;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+88134;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+109536;['appeal is dismissed']
+74489;['appeal is dismissed']
+111317;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+17149;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+72705;['appeal is dismissed']
+69364;['appeal beallowed']
+60652;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+55204;['application for leave to appeal dismissed']
+111106;['appeal is   ']
+124481;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+108459;['appeal was dismissed']
+82899;['appeal is dismissed']
+57954;['appeal is dismissed']
+67241;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108788;['appeal is allowed']
+103087;['appeal is dismissed']
+135890;['appeal is allowed']
+143599;['appeal is allowed']
+72874;['appeal is terminated']
+81644;['appeal is dismissed']
+77444;['appeal is dismissed']
+143605;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+21100;['appeal bedismissed.']
+96776;['appeal is dismissed']
+61442;['negative']
+95872;['appeal is terminated']
+100177;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+143147;['rad determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+94603;['removal order is set aside']
+75494;['appeal is allowed']
+93057;['appellants are christians']
+67555;['appeal of the appellant is dismissed']
+100794;['appeal is allowed']
+54269;['appeal is dismissed']
+145842;['appeal is allowed']
+81203;['appeal is dismissed']
+93284;['xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxare not convention refugees or person in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+125110;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44841;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+109694;['panel therefore dismisses the appeal']
+136711;['appeal is allowed']
+123313;['not a convention refugee or a protected person']
+99766;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+146129;['claim is rejected']
+106841;['appeal isallowed']
+110994;['appeal is dismissed']
+95042;['appeal is terminated']
+143923;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+107935;['rad allows this appeal', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+84825;['appeal is allowed']
+148995;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87878;['claimant is neither a convention refugee unders']
+77858;['claimant is not a person in need of protection', 'nor a convention refugee']
+99997;['appeal isallowed']
+97631;['302 (c.a.']
+96620;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+87027;['appeal isallowed']
+88318;['appeal is dismissed']
+99039;['claimants areneither convention refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+59671;['appeal is allowed']
+51823;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124391;['appeal is allowed']
+131038;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+131013;['appeal isallowed']
+36130;['appeal is dismissed']
+52675;['refugee protection division finds xxxxxxxxxxxxx not to be a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+126418;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+104358;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+133721;['appeal is allowed']
+53138;['appeal isallowedand']
+40708;['appeal is allowed.the']
+145538;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd decision is correct']
+30407;['appeal was not perfected']
+136156;['rad upholds the rpd’s finding']
+123293;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143635;['appeal is allowed']
+82903;['appeal is allowed']
+70599;['appeal of ms. islam is allowed.the']
+142896;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+142826;['rad confirms the rpd determination']
+28100;['appeals should be allowed']
+101483;['appeal were dismissed']
+39771;['appeal was later dismissed']
+50730;['appeal is dismissed']
+151608;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination of the appellant’s claim']
+40852;['appeal of mohsan raza is allowed']
+100328;['claim is rejected']
+98915;['appeal of li na yang is dismissed']
+34175;['appeal is dismissed']
+60991;['appeal is allowed']
+77294;['dismiss the appeal']
+28016;['appeal is allowed']
+70185;['appeal is dismissed']
+124435;['appeal is allowed']
+69427;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+128171;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+94392;['appeal is dismissed']
+93155;['appeal should be allowed']
+95039;['appeal be dismissed']
+70420;['appeal is dismissed']
+128382;['appeal be dismissed']
+132317;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122973;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+52073;['appeal is allowed']
+59990;['reject the claim ofxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx']
+124566;['appeal is allowed']
+90489;['appeal isallowed']
+130692;['removal order isset aside']
+80205;['refugee protection division rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+71256;['appeal is allowed']
+99945;['appeal is dismissed']
+29220;['appeal from the removal order made']
+52331;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76187;['appeal is terminated']
+151518;['appeal is allowed']
+95244;['appeal is terminated']
+81860;['appeal is dismissed']
+77901;['appeal is allowed']
+132387;['allows the appeal']
+27468;['appeals are dismissed']
+144015;['appeal is allowed']
+143237;['appeal is allowed']
+124424;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+105300;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”']
+107486;['rad thus confirms the rpd’s determination']
+90731;['appeal is allowed']
+143602;['appeal is dismissed']
+144005;['appeals are dismissed']
+123290;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+105327;['appeals are dismissed']
+125381;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+94523;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+26745;['appeal is dismissed']
+69401;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+129904;['appeal is allowed']
+47379;['appeal is allowed']
+105377;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination', 'xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees']
+91423;['appeal is terminated']
+94368;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+84791;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+97239;['appeal isallowed']
+27254;['appeal is allowed']
+98237;['appeal on this basis is therefore dismissed']
+100307;['302 (c.a.']
+64293;['appeal is allowed']
+122814;['request is denied']
+55290;['not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+113578;['appeal is dismissed']
+146544;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+77802;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+57955;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+45988;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+104463;['appeal of bhupinder kaur malhi is allowed']
+52138;['appeal is dismissed']
+85916;['appeal isallowed']
+105314;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a\xa0 convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73328;['appeal were dismissed']
+99353;['appeal isallowed']
+61657;['appeal is dismissed']
+87372;['appeal isallowed']
+123087;['set aside the rpd’s decision and substitute a determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+91555;['appeal isallowed']
+151761;['appeal is dismissed']
+102080;['appeal is dismissed']
+80992;['appeal is allowed']
+74478;['allowed the appeal from the bench']
+80772;['appeal is allowed']
+87041;['appeal isallowed']
+148729;['neither a convention refugee nora person in need of protection']
+142479;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146541;['302 (c.a.']
+33318;['appeal is dismissed']
+68916;['appeal is allowed']
+94282;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+59943;['claim is rejected']
+45245;['appeal is allowed']
+27471;['appeal isallowedand']
+77697;['appeal isallowed']
+148633;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+96574;['appeal is allowed']
+87740;['appeals are dismissed']
+69620;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+115226;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+96673;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+129991;['appeal is allowed']
+94680;['appeal isallowedand']
+15020;['allow the appeal']
+121564;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+61297;['appeal of the minister is allowed']
+59929;['appeal is allowed']
+46091;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+31216;['appeal of mini iype mundackal is dismissed']
+90325;['negative']
+94987;['immigration appeal division   therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+56909;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+49516;['appeal is dismissed']
+82167;['appeal is dismissed']
+124969;['dismiss the appeal']
+151589;['appeal is allowed']
+107136;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+30522;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+95939;['302 (c.a.']
+123845;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+123383;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56950;['appeal is allowed']
+89740;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+30551;['appeal is allowed']
+94190;['appeal is dismissed']
+128562;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86552;['appeal of joseph lado nikanora is dismissed']
+122673;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122965;['dismiss the appeals', 'confirm the decision of the rpd.xxxx', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50777;['appeal is dismissed']
+89937;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+125621;['rpd’s negative decision is set aside', 'rad substitutes a positive decision']
+142906;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+94419;['appeal is allowed']
+131085;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26707;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+152021;['appeal is dismissed']
+106283;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a persons in need of protection']
+67798;['appeal is dismissed']
+82637;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+112400;['appeal is dismissed']
+76404;['rad substitutes its decision', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+121525;['appeal is allowed']
+90201;['refugee protection division rejects these claims']
+100048;['appeal is dismissed']
+59410;['appeal is dismissed']
+121214;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82062;['appeal isallowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+80489;['appeal is allowed']
+64227;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+95017;['appeal isallowed']
+96806;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+101018;['appeal is allowed']
+80694;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+100668;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+21101;['appeal is allowed in law']
+81134;['appeal is allowed']
+94278;['302 (c.a.']
+69594;['appeal isallowed']
+95669;['appeal is allowed']
+75009;['appeal is dismissed']
+47393;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+3960;['appeal is dismissed']
+50461;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugee nor persons in need of protection']
+76493;['appeal isallowed']
+52050;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+69183;['appeal is allowed']
+101024;['302 (c.a.']
+144005;['rpd’s decision to reject the claims']
+95923;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision']
+95652;['appeal is dismissed']
+81275;['appeal is allowed']
+79474;['appeal is dismissed']
+81247;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+34880;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+42287;['appeal were dismissed']
+138862;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+90907;['appeal is allowed']
+97676;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+19112;['appeal fails']
+42319;['appeal is dismissed']
+102584;['appeal is allowed']
+105621;['removal order isset aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+143244;['appeal was dismissed']
+77885;['appeal is allowed']
+72801;['appeal isallowed']
+130704;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+60942;['appeal is allowed']
+112792;['appeal were dismissed']
+41726;['appeal is allowed']
+102927;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+140880;['substitute my own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+77645;['appeal is allowed']
+115289;['appeal is dismissed']
+13629;['appeal is allowed']
+143560;['substitute the determination that should have been made', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a refugee']
+133375;['appeal is dismissed']
+105377;['appeal is allowed']
+94549;['appeal is allowed']
+104474;['appeal is dismissed']
+70021;['appeal allowed']
+87604;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+134744;['appeal is allowed']
+132292;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellantxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+79875;['appeal isallowed']
+83164;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is']
+94899;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+100777;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+148773;['appeal is dismissed']
+100355;['302 (c.a.']
+85533;['appeal is dismissed']
+5146;['appeal isallowed']
+143005;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+142503;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97410;['appeal is dismissed']
+102157;['appeals are dismissed']
+99239;['appeal is allowed']
+99408;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+26518;['appeal isdismissed.']
+146862;['appeal was dismissed']
+96625;['negative']
+124024;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+139795;['appeal will proceed to normal processing']
+50451;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither convention refugees']
+95884;['appeal is dismissed']
+57897;['appeal is dismissed']
+142957;['appeal must be dismissed']
+47316;['appeal was heard']
+26867;"['not a ""convention refugee']"
+107895;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+83668;['appeal ofnambrou kouassiisallowed.']
+47356;['application is denied']
+94673;['302 (c.a.']
+77072;['refusal is found not valid in law', 'appeal is allowed']
+90368;['neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection”']
+123050;['302 (c.a.']
+72215;['appeal is allowed']
+31974;['appeal is allowed']
+100348;['claimant is excluded']
+124809;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71117;['appeal is dismissed']
+89082;['appeal was dismissed']
+74660;['determination is valid in law']
+121854;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67215;['appeal isallowed']
+89979;['appeal isallowed']
+144382;['appeal is allowed']
+86949;['appeal is allowed']
+129177;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+89341;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+52051;['appeal isallowedand']
+85314;['appeal isallowed']
+107907;['rpd’s reasons are set aside']
+71458;['appeal is dismissed']
+92384;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+68093;['nor a permanent resident of canada']
+70886;['appeal of bienvenido r. naz is dismissed']
+134298;['appeals are allowed']
+63897;['appeal is terminated']
+35561;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+77905;['appeal is allowed']
+39071;['appeal is allowed']
+77791;['he is not a convention refugee']
+47753;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+105214;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+44034;['appeal is dismissed']
+17960;['appeal is dismissed']
+54211;['appeal is dismissed']
+81095;['302 (c.a.']
+69245;['appeal is abandoned']
+76163;['rejects her claim for refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+100024;['appeal is terminated']
+107834;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67673;['appeal is dismissed']
+36104;['determination is valid in law']
+94389;['appeal is dismissed']
+151305;['rpd’s determination is set aside']
+71037;['negative']
+113540;['302 (c.a.']
+73279;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+81254;['appeal is allowed']
+113584;['appeal is allowed']
+85380;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+52139;['is neither a convention refugee', 'nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rad rejects his claim']
+107684;['appeal is allowed']
+99293;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+94357;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+100799;['302 (c.a.']
+82204;['nor a travel document.']
+90080;['appeal is dismissed']
+52091;['appeal cannot succeed']
+63897;['appeal is terminated']
+100676;['appeal isallowed']
+76142;['appeal is dismissed']
+133710;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+125501;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+107135;['applicants are convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+64049;['appeal is terminated']
+147622;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89341;['panel rejects the claims ofxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxand her four adult childrenxxxxx']
+94931;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+148633;['appellants are neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71225;['appeal fails']
+103001;['appeal is allowed']
+59137;['appeal is terminated']
+89112;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+74491;['appeal is allowed']
+61958;['appeal isallowed']
+40149;['appeal is allowed']
+61953;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87038;['appeal is dismissed']
+120823;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+105695;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+83644;['immigration appeal division, therefore, orders your departure fromcanada.']
+90125;['claimants,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”', 'nor are they “persons in need of protection']
+142513;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination']
+46027;['appeal allowed']
+99584;['appeal is dismissed']
+96844;['appeal isallowedand']
+93227;['appeal is allowed']
+28090;['appeal is terminated']
+92989;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+79948;['panel rejects the above claimants’ refugee claims']
+102103;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+106133;['appeal is determined abandoned', 'appeal is closed']
+107877;['302 (c.a.']
+109636;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+47562;['appeal is dismissed']
+111161;['appellant is, in fact, a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+131918;['appeal is dismissed']
+54714;['appeal is allowed']
+108896;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131521;['appeal be allowed']
+85625;['appeal is allowed']
+88075;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+62628;['appeal is dismissed']
+114929;['set aside the rpd’s negative determination', 'substitute a positive decision']
+71070;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+122233;['substitute my own decision that the appellant adenike xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+147804;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+132643;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101422;['appeal is allowed']
+84803;['appeal is dismissed']
+34695;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+85508;['appeal is dismissed']
+98323;['appeal therefore is dismissed']
+95905;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95521;['appeal is dismissed']
+151570;['appeals are therefore dismissed']
+91197;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+141613;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142802;['appeal is dismissed']
+14658;['claimant is excluded from the convention refugee definition']
+131078;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125482;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+49530;['appeal is dismissed']
+96701;['appeal is allowed']
+55209;['claimant not to be a person in need of protection']
+146556;['expropriation does in fact reflect a law of general application']
+55909;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+148429;['appeal is determined']
+82887;['appeal is dismissed']
+151606;['rpd’s determination cannot stand']
+148712;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+75430;['allow the appeal']
+63932;['appeal in respect of pushwinder singh bajwa is dismissed']
+100324;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+125211;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+132727;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+133411;['appeal is allowed']
+88503;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+150479;['appeal is dismissed']
+89841;['appeal is terminated']
+104270;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+52669;['302 (c.a.']
+60201;['appeal isallowed']
+44207;['appeal is determined']
+57502;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+143916;['rad finds that the appellant’s arguments have merit']
+84690;['appeal isallowed']
+95390;['rad finds that the rpd’s conclusion is supported by its analysis']
+40489;['removal orders are set aside']
+151614;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97561;['allow the appeal']
+129173;['decision of the visa office to be legally valid']
+69960;['appeal is dismissed']
+136156;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+37416;['appeal is allowed']
+73187;['appeal is allowed']
+55252;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+74125;['appeal is dismissed']
+83038;['appeal is dismissed']
+144888;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+86466;['appeal is allowed']
+151927;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+84364;['appeal is terminated']
+50618;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+142726;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+125215;['appeal is allowed']
+100717;['302 (c.a.']
+91755;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+31265;['appeal is allowed']
+64646;['decision is well founded in law']
+45389;['appeal is allowed']
+103510;['302 (c.a.']
+89274;['appeal is allowed']
+55297;['appeal is dismissed']
+76746;['appeal to this tribunal dismissed']
+91706;['disposition is appropriate']
+93058;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54713;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+122972;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+100806;['appeal isallowed']
+84572;['appeal is terminated']
+105758;['302 (c.a.']
+113243;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+142291;['appeal is dismissed']
+82896;['appeals are dismissed']
+80126;['removal order is set aside']
+72614;['appeal is dismissed']
+110723;['rad does not agree that it should be dismissed']
+98823;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+71538;['appeal isallowed']
+98354;['appeal is allowed']
+94329;['appeal is allowed']
+108776;['rad (refugee appeal division) confirms the decision of the rpd']
+87687;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+15007;['appeal is dismissed']
+56947;['appeal is dismissed']
+105341;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76251;['claimant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+102450;['appeal of najibeh ataei is dismissed']
+98225;['appeal is determined']
+84459;['appeal is allowed']
+69452;['appeal is terminated']
+123379;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+138885;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+93076;['appeal is dismissed']
+80037;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+102490;['ifa fails on the first prong']
+84799;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+127903;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, and not a person in need of protection']
+28094;['appeals filed by khadija and mounir should be dismissed']
+81288;['appeal is allowed']
+73192;['appeal is allowed.the']
+30497;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+71143;['appeal is dismissed']
+127348;['dismiss the appeal']
+82190;['appeal is allowed']
+76612;['appeal is abandoned']
+113595;['appeal is allowed']
+116796;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50654;['appeals are dismissed']
+107475;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'directs that the matter be returned to the rpd for re-determination']
+86457;['appeal is allowed']
+100019;['negative']
+103014;['appeal is dismissed']
+148867;['appeal is allowed or dismissed']
+76972;['appeal is allowed']
+91214;['appeal is allowed']
+90771;['appeal is accepted']
+107706;['application to re-open the appeal is denied']
+96638;['appeal is dismissed']
+82267;['appeal is abandoned']
+64127;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+72776;['allows this appeal']
+136748;['appeal is allowed']
+89851;['negative']
+94924;['appeal be allowed']
+96353;['appeal isdeterminedto be']
+114417;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151485;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+113551;['appeal is allowed']
+124898;['rad cannot confirm or set aside the determination of the rpd']
+77252;['appeal is allowed']
+90851;['appellant (their claimant) is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89882;['appeal of john baptist sarkar is dismissed']
+123055;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+113219;['appeal is allowed']
+77835;['claimant in need of protection']
+108700;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+55108;['appeal is dismissed']
+81015;['dismiss your appeal']
+98913;['302 (c.a.)']
+88905;['appeal is allowed']
+73882;['appeal is dismissed']
+98691;['appeal is allowed']
+92240;['appeal is allowed']
+102412;['not consider country conditions']
+91199;['appeal is allowed']
+86947;['appeal is dismissed']
+81016;['allow or dismiss the appeal']
+152920;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+76525;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+93319;['appeal abandoned']
+121416;['appeals are dismissed']
+106940;['refugee protection division rejects a claim for refugee protection']
+63565;['appeal is allowed']
+94727;['appeal is allowed']
+112339;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+86402;['allow the appeal', 'appeal is allowed']
+60867;['appeal isallowed']
+59627;['appeal isallowed']
+122108;['appeal is denied']
+60904;['appeal is allowed']
+84619;['appeal is terminated']
+71618;['appeal is allowed']
+91678;['sponsor must remain a sponsor up to']
+99022;['negative']
+142825;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72832;['appeal isallowed']
+93977;['negative']
+124419;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+131740;['appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+74763;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+21359;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+70024;['allows this appeal']
+92157;['removal order is set aside']
+67606;['appeal isallowed']
+84468;['appeal is terminated']
+96869;['appeal isallowedand']
+146815;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+46996;['appeal is dismissed']
+149271;['appeal is dismissed']
+94779;['allow the appeal']
+60025;['negative']
+151505;['rad cannot substitute the decision of the rpd']
+63860;['appeal should be dismissed']
+76973;['appeal isallowed']
+84311;['immigration division’s decision is not valid in law']
+91162;['appeal is allowed']
+77063;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+78008;['appeals are dismissed']
+100068;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+100333;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+76499;['immigration appeal division dismisses an appeal']
+104495;['appeal is allowed.the']
+102039;['appeal is denied']
+68591;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+71571;['dismisses the appellant’s appeal']
+70397;['allow the minister’s application to vacate that decision']
+100102;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+45413;['decision of the visa officer is valid in law']
+61973;['appeal is dismissed']
+13835;['immigration officer’s decision is valid']
+106442;['cross-appeal is allowed']
+99068;['302 (c.a.']
+40078;['appeal be dismissed']
+76405;['appeal is dismissed']
+77474;['appeal isallowed.the']
+74502;['appeal is allowed']
+5598;['appeal is dismissed']
+73708;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+90957;['appeal is allowed']
+103103;['officer’s decision is set aside']
+99711;['appeal is dismissed']
+130066;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+122776;['appeal is dismissed']
+100543;['appeal is dismissed']
+111114;['appeal is dismissed']
+83252;['removal orders are set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+103877;['appeal is dismissed']
+88160;['appeal of li yang is dismissed']
+95397;['dismiss this appeal']
+81324;['appeal is dismissed']
+107090;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26477;['appeal is determined']
+74858;['appeal of satpal singh jassar is dismissed']
+98887;['appeal could be dismissed', 'dismiss this appeal']
+111344;['appeal is dismissed']
+82795;['appeal be dismissed']
+89701;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+123970;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+95932;['appeal is allowed']
+116801;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68598;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+74873;['appeal isallowed']
+82996;['appeal is dismissed']
+139867;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+52609;"[""claimants' motion is dismissed""]"
+88151;['appeal is allowed']
+76737;['appeal of john kwabena ankamah is dismissed']
+61451;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+9487;['appeal is dismissed']
+79970;['negative']
+123922;['dismissal of the appeal']
+100273;['removal orders are set aside']
+63176;['appeal is allowed in law']
+96191;['appeal isallowed']
+86321;['claimant is a “convention refugee']
+141277;['appeal is allowed']
+76099;['appeal isallowed']
+81176;['appeal is allowed']
+76606;['reject this appeal']
+89792;['dismiss the appeal']
+142455;['appeals of the principal appellant, xxxx, and xxxx are allowed']
+151619;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61487;['appeal is allowed']
+105179;['favourable decision is attached to that effect']
+132781;['appellantsxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+121880;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+52345;['appeal ofxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis dismissed']
+103907;['application to reopen must be dismissed']
+87954;['appeal is dismissed']
+129196;['appeal is allowed']
+98168;['appeal must be dismissed']
+142798;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136674;['302 (c.a.']
+107081;['confirm the rpd’s decision', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+55519;['appeal is dismissed']
+84695;['appeal isallowed']
+111335;['appeal is dismissed']
+132795;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+73879;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a person referred']
+76457;['appeal is allowed']
+53131;['appeal is allowed']
+121455;['appeals are allowed']
+105788;['appeal is dismissed']
+84755;['appeal is dismissed']
+124570;['dismiss this appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+65416;['appeal is dismissed']
+126653;['appeal is allowed.the']
+82379;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your   departure from canada']
+141616;['appellants are convention refugees']
+40647;['removal orders areset aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+142527;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither refugees under section\xa096 nor persons in need of protection']
+136661;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97088;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+68139;['appeal of manjitkauris dismissed']
+76135;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxisnot a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+84442;['appeal isallowed']
+100025;['negative']
+105317;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+151571;['reject the claim']
+94219;['allows this appeal']
+2807;['appellant lost his permanent resident status']
+107695;['appeal is allowed']
+39925;['appeal of anita stephanie glover is dismissed']
+46005;['theappealis dismissed']
+93904;['appeal is allowed']
+77456;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+76077;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+37084;['appeal is dismissed']
+52636;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+83366;['dismissed the appeal', 'dismissed the appeal']
+81185;['appeal is dismissed']
+103916;['appeal is dismissed']
+130985;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+8283;['appeals to be abandoned']
+36946;['appeal is dismissed']
+49075;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+63699;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+80217;['negative']
+131157;['appeal were dismissed']
+129896;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84545;['appeal is terminated']
+39044;['appeal is dismissed']
+101477;['removal order is set aside']
+128932;['appeal is dismissed']
+55975;['dismiss the appeal']
+95888;['rad disagrees']
+100593;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80248;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+114339;['dismiss the appeal']
+38768;['appeal is dismissed']
+124932;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants, xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+87114;['302 (c.a.']
+68099;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+31987;['appeal is allowed']
+90258;['claimants are persons in need of protection']
+31047;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+139807;['appeal is allowed']
+95716;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+93944;['appeal is allowed']
+65686;['appeal must be dismissed']
+22119;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+5599;['appeal is determined']
+76536;['appeal isallowed']
+133340;['appeal is denied']
+124984;['allow the appeal and', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+77248;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+123419;['substitutes a decision that the principal appellant is a convention refugee and the associate appellant is a person in need of protection']
+72162;['appeal should be dismissed']
+131183;['appeal is allowed']
+141652;['appeal is dismissed']
+54204;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+102495;['allegation is not founded']
+100052;['appeal is dismissed']
+119833;['application to reopen her appeal is dismissed']
+84305;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+132766;['appellant cannot be considered as a refugee from brazil']
+123907;['appeal is dismissed']
+86648;['appeal is dismissed']
+101519;['claim is rejected']
+125029;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+81613;['appeal is dismissed']
+131090;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+86222;['appeal is dismissed']
+102548;['appeal is allowed']
+92036;['302 (c.a.']
+37846;['appeal is dismissed']
+91771;['appeal of xue feng li is allowed']
+100472;['claimant is therefore not a convention refugee']
+89146;['appeal is allowed']
+132320;['neither a convention refugee']
+84060;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+83137;['appeal isallowed']
+76801;['appeal be dismissed']
+116775;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+128311;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+93886;['appeal on theregulation4(1)(a) is dismissed']
+41681;['immigration officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+89856;['neither a convention refugee nor a person described in section 97.1(\xa0\xa0 \xa0\xa0 b) of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+144562;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+145821;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+144426;['appeal is dismissed']
+52197;['appeal is dismissed']
+95972;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+91368;['appeal is allowed']
+73705;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+103660;['claimants xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees']
+131741;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+116832;['appeal is dismissed']
+54700;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+107904;['rad sets aside the finding of the panel']
+40850;['appeal is allowed']
+106780;['appeal is allowed']
+65411;['appeal is dismissed']
+143174;['you are not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject your claim for refugee protection']
+91448;['appeal of genevieve (genevie) enoeis allowed.the']
+54188;['appeals were dismissed']
+19310;['appellant to be a person in need of protection']
+26879;"['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a ""convention refugee']"
+101042;['appeal isterminated']
+76829;['appeal is dismissed']
+96439;['appeal is dismissed']
+57462;['appeal will now proceed to a hearing']
+108716;['302 (c.a.']
+63755;['appeal is allowed']
+103465;['appeal isdismissed.']
+80822;['appeal is allowed in law']
+50483;['appeal is dismissed']
+71638;['appeal is allowed']
+123039;['rad, pursuant', 'substitutes a decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+98917;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+57036;['appeal is allowed']
+141797;['appeal is allowed']
+112350;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+54765;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+91232;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+42317;['appeal is dismissed']
+123086;['appellants are convention refugees']
+76082;['allow the appeal']
+97815;['negative']
+91100;['appeal isallowed']
+37410;['appeal is dismissed']
+90800;['appeal is dismissed']
+123712;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+108805;['appeal is allowed']
+94839;['appeals are dismissed']
+67439;['appeal isallowed']
+90083;['appeal isterminated']
+98803;['appeal isallowed']
+128153;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60441;['negative determination']
+100488;['appeal is allowed']
+88891;['dismisses the application']
+91184;['appeal is terminated']
+42210;['appeal is allowed']
+75986;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+101298;['pa is a convention refugee']
+124203;['dismiss the appeal']
+91181;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+99237;['appeal is allowed']
+78097;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+134312;['appeal is allowed.the']
+52775;['appeal is dismissed']
+95966;['appeal is dismissed']
+38851;['appeal isallowed']
+46014;['appeal was dismissed']
+48592;['appeal will be allowed in law']
+93942;['i agree with and accept the recommendation']
+76136;['neither convention refugees not persons in need of protection']
+124715;['appeal is allowed']
+92853;['appeals ofmourad\xa0arif,fatiha\xa0laidaouiandlina\xa0arifare dismissed']
+84306;['dismiss the appeal']
+87451;['supports the panel’s finding']
+116830;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30494;['appeal is dismissed']
+148500;['application is dismissed']
+124698;['appellant is neither a “conventionrefugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”.the', 'appeal is dismissed']
+100328;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+101522;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121936;['nor a person in need of protection']
+90096;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxxis rejected']
+129904;['appeal is allowed.the']
+100502;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor is she a person in need of protection']
+85630;['appeal is dismissed']
+74239;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+125659;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94824;['appeal is dismissed']
+125337;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64227;['appeal is allowed']
+46500;['appeal is allowed']
+52719;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+71492;['dismiss the appeal']
+99399;['application is dismissed']
+84080;['allowing the appeal']
+46045;['appeal abandoned']
+96690;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76455;['appeal isallowed']
+100639;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+64630;['appeal is dismissed']
+98538;['negative']
+138885;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+131006;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99130;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+97026;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+85614;['appeal of bashir gaashaan is dismissed']
+105719;['appeal is allowed']
+69375;['appeal is dismissed']
+71693;['appeal is allowed']
+85243;['appeal is allowed']
+91273;['appeal is allowed']
+83506;['appeal has been abandoned']
+52196;['appeal is dismissed']
+82082;['appeal is dismissed']
+141613;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+110281;['claims for refugee protection']
+95169;['appeal is allowed']
+138289;['appeal is allowed']
+95935;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+146710;['appellant remains a protected person']
+148651;['appeal is dismissed']
+140813;['appeal is allowed']
+67441;['appeal is dismissed']
+60084;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+93997;['appeal isallowed']
+102121;['removal order is set aside']
+57041;['appeal being dismissed']
+106302;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105795;['appeal is dismissed']
+100672;['appeal isallowed']
+76745;['appeal is dismissed']
+73895;['appeal of hajah masri is dismissed']
+100144;['appeal is dismissed']
+82249;['appeal is allowed']
+140737;['appeal is allowed']
+63173;['appeal is allowed']
+95176;['appeal is dismissed']
+111008;['appeal is dismissed']
+140964;['decision of the rpd']
+71808;['appeal isallowed']
+95078;['appeal is dismissed']
+122621;['rpd decision cannot stand']
+47838;['appeal is allowed']
+132797;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+42281;['appeals are dismissed']
+90483;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+79338;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+61917;['appeal isallowed']
+71228;['appeal is allowed']
+134313;['appeal is dismissed']
+99983;['appeal isallowed']
+69689;['appeal is allowed']
+93811;['claimant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+56621;['board rejects a claim']
+41999;['appeal is dismissed']
+100790;['appeal isallowedand']
+115229;['appeal is allowed']
+102073;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+112371;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95063;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+50521;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71345;['appeal is dismissed']
+132345;['rad dismisses the minister’s appeal']
+87222;['appeal is dismissed']
+47309;['appeal is allowed']
+93220;['ms. zhao lacks overall credibility']
+91717;['appeal is dismissed']
+143553;['appellant is a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+62888;['appeal is dismissed']
+102121;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+112355;['appeal is allowed']
+110994;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71537;['appeal filed byvenise\xa0saint‑hilaireis dismissed']
+80336;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+136676;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71088;['appeal is dismissed']
+87090;['appeal is also dismissed']
+131224;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+76723;['appeal is allowed']
+96550;['appeal isallowed']
+124438;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94377;['appeal is dismissed']
+83246;['appeal is terminated']
+94308;['appeal isallowedand']
+104288;['appeal is dismissed']
+104971;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97215;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+98706;['302 (c.a.']
+145043;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+78288;['appeal is dismissed']
+129244;['appeal is dismissed']
+121850;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination appealed', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+105233;['appeal is allowed']
+102895;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59836;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+113219;['appeal is allowed']
+67574;['appeal is allowed']
+117102;['appeal is allowed']
+60902;['appeal is dismissed']
+14688;['appeal be dismissed']
+77312;['appeal will proceed to normal processing']
+44088;['rad concurs with the rpd’s findings']
+57915;['appeal is dismissed']
+151531;['appeal is allowed']
+69961;['appeal isallowed']
+23102;['appeal is allowed']
+96995;['appeal is allowed']
+149568;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+121544;['appeal is allowed']
+128343;['appeal is allowed for khalil ur rehman']
+140776;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+91281;['appeal does not simply fail']
+132641;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm that the', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98533;['thatxxxx xxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+23059;['appeal is dismissed']
+87180;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+54729;['appeal is dismissed']
+120865;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70197;['appeal is allowed']
+69596;['appeal is allowed in law']
+69195;['appeal is allowed']
+130761;['appeal of maria haydee escobar-santos is dismissed']
+123673;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+108672;['refugee protection division rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+94183;['appeal is dismissed']
+136712;['appeal is allowed in part']
+60420;['appeal, daljeet singh narwal, is allowed']
+87989;['claimantxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+86007;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+26465;['appeal is dismissed']
+142792;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+61061;['appeal is allowed']
+39037;['appeal is dismissed']
+124084;['rad allows the appeal']
+98817;['negative']
+147874;['appeals are denied']
+98351;['appeal is allowed']
+80380;['302 (c.a.']
+56791;['negative']
+125171;['appeal isallowed']
+88451;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+84488;['appeal is allowed']
+52608;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+67504;['appeal isallowed']
+93060;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95106;['claimants are neither \xa0\xa0 convention refugees']
+87955;['appeal is allowed']
+52940;['appeal is dismissed']
+24481;['appeal is dismissed']
+103637;['appeals are dismissed']
+74114;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection.remedies']
+68120;['appeal is allowed']
+123553;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+139844;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+124043;['appeal is dismissed']
+63185;['dismiss the appeal']
+94110;['appeal is allowed']
+79218;['appeal isallowed']
+96001;['claim is rejected']
+46533;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+99854;['appeal is allowed']
+83307;['appeal is allowed']
+68619;['appeal is allowed']
+84209;['302 (c.a.']
+151807;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+128900;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140257;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142088;['not a person in need of protection']
+47328;['appeal is allowed']
+36100;['appeal is dismissed']
+21428;['negative']
+97083;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+93013;['appeal is denied']
+63980;['appeal is dismissed']
+150715;['rpd’s decision is appropriate']
+18933;['appeal is dismissed']
+70167;['dismiss the appeal']
+110268;['rad finds that it cannot substitute the determination of the rpd']
+87823;['negative']
+99384;['refugee protection claims filed byxxx']
+88500;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60917;['appeal would be dismissed']
+89757;['302 (c.a.']
+33690;['dismissing the appeal']
+54297;['application to reopen the appeal is governed by']
+21306;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+108811;['rad finds no errors of fact or law']
+99568;['appeal is dismissed']
+95522;['appeal to this board proved unsuccessful']
+100444;['gia is still in existence']
+89750;['appeal is dismissed']
+75607;['appeal is allowed']
+68897;['appeal is dismissed']
+123614;['rad finds that it committed both']
+48421;['appeal is dismissed']
+47874;['appeal isallowed']
+125216;['not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68102;['appeal is dismissed']
+143616;['appeal is allowed']
+71243;['appeal is dismissed']
+38160;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes the determination']
+100302;['claimant is not a convention refuge or person in need of protection']
+69354;['appeal is allowed']
+84718;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+115230;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109032;['appeals for the applicants are dismissed']
+77914;['appeal is allowed']
+72173;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74722;['appeal isallowed']
+77664;['appeal is dismissed']
+67774;['appeal is allowed']
+108979;['appeal isallowed.the']
+63821;['appeal is dismissed']
+74175;['appeal was dismissed']
+84138;['appeal is allowed']
+89292;['appeal is allowed']
+50756;['appeal is dismissed']
+71639;['appeal is dismissed']
+71180;['appeal is allowed']
+100532;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+82845;['appeal is terminated']
+128269;['appeal of brian kieth unrau is dismissed']
+82389;['appeal is dismissed']
+140860;['rad finds the rpd decision must be set aside']
+67458;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+69320;['allowed the appeal from the bench']
+123554;['overturn this finding']
+141305;['appeal is allowed']
+77215;['removal order is set aside']
+107258;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77781;['appeal isallowedand']
+92170;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+145301;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142062;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95531;['302 (c.a.)']
+101347;['appeal is allowed']
+93057;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+90269;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+86899;['appeal isallowed']
+68883;['appeal is dismissed']
+122256;['appeal is allowed']
+76977;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+37186;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+144420;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+74739;['dismiss the appeal']
+151487;['appeal is allowed']
+122538;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121405;['appeal is allowed']
+63932;['appeal is allowed']
+121845;['appeal is denied']
+91248;['appeal of jagdish kumar is dismissed']
+36597;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+93117;['appeal is allowed']
+73317;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+89577;['appeal is terminated']
+39063;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+80004;['appeal isallowed']
+97114;['appeal is terminated']
+116782;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+95614;['dismiss the appeal']
+69355;['decision is not binding on me']
+71202;['appeal’s dismissal']
+82871;['appeal is allowed']
+92509;['appeal of noel lloyd mellad is dismissed']
+62255;['reject this claim to refugee protection', 'claimant is not a convention refugee']
+100060;['claimants to not be convention refugees unders']
+69690;['appeal is dismissed']
+83095;['appeal is allowed']
+49532;['appeal is dismissed']
+132729;['claimants are not']
+46532;['appeal is allowed']
+137446;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105634;['appeal is dismissed']
+43720;['allow this appeal']
+34176;['appeal is allowed']
+124018;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is aconventionrefugee']
+77817;['thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+26846;['claimant, xxxxxxxxx, is a convention refugee']
+145844;['removal order is set aside']
+111354;['rad agrees with the rpd']
+30531;['appeal is allowed']
+96248;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+142733;['appeal is allowed']
+107859;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+89319;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+103804;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+47327;['appeal is allowed']
+98998;['appeal is dismissed']
+92583;['appeal be dismissed']
+85498;['appeal is dismissed']
+40299;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+151563;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+67732;['…]”']
+80067;['immigration appeal division, therefore, orders your departure fromcanada.']
+9486;['appeal is allowed']
+63903;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+17155;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90089;['claimant is not “convention refugee']
+94692;['appeal isallowed']
+80230;['negative']
+82585;['appeal is allowed']
+92538;['appeal is dismissed']
+56915;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+30376;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97309;['appeal is dismissed']
+81632;['appeal should be dismissed']
+90267;['302 (c.a.']
+93942;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+64314;['appeals of sam choi, sylvia kim choi and anna choi']
+98226;['appeal is allowed']
+59999;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+72188;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+81827;['appeal was dismissed']
+131083;['allow the appeal', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+89556;['appeal is terminated']
+82209;['appeal is allowed']
+131754;['appeal is dismissed']
+93221;['appeal isallowed']
+123299;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98780;['appeal is allowed']
+97418;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'rejects his claim']
+69579;['appeal isallowed']
+79976;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+80054;['negative']
+72646;['appeal is allowed']
+100424;['dismiss this appeal']
+64282;['appeal is dismissed']
+68131;['appeal is allowed']
+149210;['ms. iyalla is not a person described insection 38(1)(c) of theimmigration and refugee protection act']
+89894;['appeal isallowed']
+91938;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+89366;['decision is valid in law']
+91541;['appeal is allowed']
+108717;['appeal is dismissed']
+82047;['appeal is allowed']
+56589;['appeal been rendered moot']
+122990;['appeal is allowed']
+106823;['appellant is not a sponsor in relation']
+132363;['appeal is allowed']
+76152;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+129921;['appeal is allowed']
+130009;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73212;['appeal is allowed']
+128434;['appeal of everestus osondu gellert eze is dismissed']
+80027;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+125393;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147007;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+60527;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitutes the determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+56701;['appeal is therefore,dismissed']
+89911;['claimants are neither convention refugees']
+102040;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+151575;['appeal is dismissed']
+76455;['allow the appeal']
+92741;['appeal is allowed']
+84452;['appeal is allowed']
+135887;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77931;['appeal is allowed']
+66241;['appeal isallowed']
+114387;['appellants are refugees or persons in need of protection']
+127429;['appeals are, therefore, dismissed']
+76410;['302 (c.a.']
+153731;['appeal is dismissed']
+108842;['appeal is allowed']
+42337;['appeal is allowed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151743;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+122243;['substitute my finding']
+94020;['removal order is set aside']
+68721;['appeal was dismissed']
+75602;['appeal be dismissed']
+78010;['appeal is dismissed']
+108668;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+91306;['appeal isallowed']
+148712;['claims are rejected']
+50396;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+133404;['appeal is allowed']
+74109;['appeal is dismissed']
+52364;['appeal of ranjeeta arora is dismissed']
+59369;['appeal isterminated']
+101897;['appeal is dismissed']
+85912;['appeal isallowedand']
+151461;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122967;['appeal is allowed']
+98283;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+131163;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+93045;['application is allowed']
+14584;['application is dismissed']
+142561;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+116784;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+19389;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxxx xxxx xxxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+74629;['appeal isallowed']
+111023;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102052;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+93822;['negative']
+46392;['determination is valid in law']
+56680;['application is dismissed']
+90206;['negative']
+114354;['rad finds that it cannot hold a hearing']
+96221;['appeal is dismissed']
+54728;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+124711;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+92819;['immigration appeal division has no jurisdiction to consider discretionary relief']
+150715;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+84764;['exclusion order is set aside']
+129889;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+53444;['removal orders areset aside']
+65697;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+140242;['appeal isallowed']
+71045;['negative']
+77569;['appeal isallowed']
+76231;['appeal is allowed']
+84747;['appeal is allowed']
+12211;['appeal is allowed']
+74680;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+97843;['claimants, mr.xxxxxxxxx, mr.xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxand ms.xxxxxxxxxx, are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims']
+57740;['appeal is allowed']
+101295;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124064;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+147622;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+61644;['302 (c.a.']
+42214;['appeals are allowed']
+94104;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+78179;['appeal isallowed']
+98746;['appeal is allowed']
+77320;['appeal isallowed']
+52111;['appeal is dismissed']
+19246;['appeal is dismissed']
+71112;['appeal of ramandeep kaur sandhu is allowed']
+69074;['appeal is allowed']
+153802;['appeal is allowed']
+144011;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+89707;['appeal is allowed']
+84680;['appeal isallowed']
+63058;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97497;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+86219;['appeal would be dismissed']
+128609;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+147800;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+92434;['appeal is dismissed']
+76894;['appeal be and is hereby dismissed']
+122762;['panel rejects the refugee protection claims']
+144040;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+141689;['dismiss the appeal']
+45235;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+86379;['appeal isdismissed for lack of jurisdictionbecause']
+97173;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+91536;['appeal is dismissed']
+74188;['appeal is allowed']
+47583;['appeal of wongelawit gabeyehu is dismissed']
+123105;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+85600;['appeal is allowed']
+81129;['appeals are allowed']
+71007;['appeal is dismissed']
+72978;['appeal is allowed']
+123456;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+110984;['appeal is allowed']
+100651;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+94738;['appeal of deng lueth yuang is dismissed']
+97016;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+99938;['appeal is dismissed']
+153265;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104975;['appeal is allowed']
+68098;['appeal is dismissed']
+142068;['rad confirms the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+141217;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+111312;['i confirm the rpd’s finding']
+62867;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+76678;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+56615;['appealis allowed']
+13418;['allow the appeal in law']
+123067;['rpd’s decision cannot be upheld']
+141375;['appeal is dismissed']
+95347;['appeal is allowed']
+96377;['appeal is allowed']
+125455;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+67393;['appeal is allowed']
+47720;['appeal should be dismissed']
+39141;['determinations are valid in law']
+145106;['302 (c.a.']
+81227;['appeal is dismissed']
+69372;['dismiss this appeal']
+36612;['appeal is allowed']
+57036;['appeal is allowed']
+99526;['appeal is dismissed']
+151563;['302 (c.a.']
+129245;['appeal is dismissed']
+64255;['appeal of this basis of refusal is allowed']
+84665;['dismiss the appeal']
+128309;['appeal isallowed']
+107625;['appeal isallowed']
+68258;['appeal is allowed']
+114319;['dismissing the appeal']
+100220;['appeal isallowed']
+82124;['appeal fails on both grounds']
+105895;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142300;['appeal is valid in law']
+61638;['panel therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+132349;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor \xa0persons in need of protection']
+53401;['appeal is dismissed']
+102705;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+24504;['appeal is dismissed']
+26794;['motion to reopen is denied']
+95681;['visa officer’s determination is invalid in law']
+70035;['allows the appeal']
+107369;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+120784;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+123125;['appeal is allowed']
+68258;['appeal is allowed']
+105835;['appeal is allowed.the']
+105350;['appeal is dismissed']
+48279;['appeal is dismissed']
+140919;['appeal is allowed']
+141159;['appeal was dismissed']
+144559;['appellants are not convention refugees', 'or persons in need of protection']
+75881;['appeal of norris hugh blake is allowed']
+95179;['appeal is allowed']
+42300;['appeal is allowed']
+130351;['appeal is dismissed']
+95065;['rad finds the appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of canada’s protection', 'confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+47610;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses this appeal']
+82463;['appeal is dismissed']
+61043;['appeal is dismissed']
+94518;['appeal is allowed']
+61470;['appeal is allowed']
+138837;['appeal be heard']
+54643;['appeal for kexin zhao is allowed']
+123659;['appeal is allowed']
+128928;['appeal is dismissed']
+38400;['appeals are dismissed']
+61225;['appeal isdismissed.']
+128575;['appeal is allowed']
+54225;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+142524;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the associate appellant is a convention refugee']
+93058;['appeal is dismissed']
+83374;['appeal is dismissed']
+135505;['claimants are neither convention refugees as set out insection 96', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+71132;['appeal is allowed']
+110931;['rad cannot uphold this decision']
+132410;['appeal is dismissed']
+61217;['appeal is terminated']
+142912;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143246;['appeal is dismissed']
+24490;['appeal is allowed']
+75447;['endorses the minister’s recommendation']
+90115;['claim is denied']
+74616;['appeal of siu king mandy lau is dismissed']
+62936;['appeal is allowed']
+125045;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+85918;['appeal is terminated']
+105882;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision will stand']
+142506;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+82122;['appeal is allowed']
+108719;['appeal is dismissed']
+124015;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91189;['appeal is terminated']
+67606;['appeal is allowed']
+85434;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+105707;['refugee protection claim filed byxxxx xxxxis rejected']
+23018;['appeal is allowed']
+123716;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+148723;['claimant xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection', 'division rejects his claim']
+83707;['appeal is allowed']
+89553;['appeal is terminated']
+96568;['appeal is determined']
+46067;['appeal is allowed']
+45222;['allow the appeal']
+107263;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124897;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+69529;['appeal is dismissed']
+94678;['appeal is allowed']
+133342;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70940;['appeal of fushpinder brar is dismissed']
+96278;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+94730;['not consider discretionary relief']
+144244;['appeal is allowed']
+148746;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+47135;['appeal is allowed']
+91741;['appeal is dismissed']
+139439;['appeal is dismissed']
+76298;['appeal was dismissed']
+69136;['appeal is dismissed']
+97284;['claimants are\xa0 not “convention refugees”']
+17163;['appeal of fatemeh eftekhari is dismissed']
+141309;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'neither a convention\xa0', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+54518;['appeal will be dismissed']
+70653;['appeal terminated']
+128384;['appeal of mercedes mabilan medalla is dismissed']
+63808;['negative']
+83254;['appeal is dismissed']
+39915;['appeal were dismissed']
+80462;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+99575;['appeal being allowed']
+132729;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim']
+71230;['appeal is allowed']
+123454;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52954;['appeal isallowed']
+94505;['appeal is allowed']
+52679;['claimant was a convention refugee.crdd']
+113779;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+71479;['appeal is allowed']
+151339;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxxand xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+72310;['302 (c.a.']
+139870;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+68543;['appeal is allowed']
+52510;['appeal is dismissed']
+74845;['appeal must fail']
+61809;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+134282;['appeal is allowed']
+62196;['claimant is excluded']
+51287;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+146946;['dismisses the appeal']
+86403;['appeal isallowed']
+41816;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+101371;['appeal is withdrawn']
+99730;['appeal of tran bao tran is dismissed']
+95145;['appeal is allowed']
+51824;['claimants to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+109706;['appeal is allowed']
+48425;['appeal is dismissed']
+141605;['appeal is dismissed']
+65692;['appeal is allowed']
+77790;['appeal isallowedand']
+136731;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+94288;['appeal is dismissed']
+100738;['appeal is terminated']
+54841;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+79726;['application for a postponement is denied']
+96061;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108926;['appeal is dismissed']
+61039;['appeal is allowed']
+145022;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93677;['appeals are dismissed']
+82906;['appeal is allowed']
+124628;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74063;['appeal is allowed']
+85507;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+63712;['appeal is allowed']
+141259;['appeal is allowed']
+89680;['appeal is allowed']
+80005;['negative']
+87959;['appeal is terminated']
+61405;['appeal is abandoned']
+98532;['appeal is allowed']
+128404;['appeal isallowed']
+96891;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects her refugee protection claim']
+77320;['appeal is allowed']
+74699;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+108268;['claimant is excluded from refugee protection']
+96621;['appeal is allowed']
+107132;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+84496;['appeal is dismissed']
+122946;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+130724;['appeal were dismissed']
+59835;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+95778;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71202;['appeal’s dismissal']
+101202;['appeal dismissed']
+91237;['appeal is terminated']
+143024;['claimants are excluded']
+105280;['contradiction stands']
+47382;['appeal is dismissed']
+151425;['claims are dismissed']
+88124;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+99259;['panel therefore rejects this claim']
+149481;['302 (c.a.']
+58139;['appeal is dismissed']
+127735;['appeal is dismissed']
+143143;['rad concurs with this remedy']
+19170;['appeal is dismissed']
+82859;['dismiss the appeal']
+66906;['removal order is set aside']
+98363;['appeal is dismissed']
+35662;['appeal isallowed.the']
+84212;['appeal is dismissed']
+86392;['appeal is allowed']
+89202;['302 (c.a.']
+143944;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+49298;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+76663;['appeal is allowed']
+94997;['appeal is dismissed']
+107096;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+101512;['appeal is allowed']
+41832;['appeal is allowed']
+82379;['appeal is dismissed']
+94227;['dismiss the present appeal']
+68907;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+97466;['appeal is allowed']
+43730;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+91526;['appeal isterminated']
+60488;['appeal is terminated']
+63723;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+74742;['removal order is set aside']
+108782;['rad finds that the appellant’s refugee claim must fail']
+136669;['302 (c.a.']
+47786;['appeal is dismissed']
+139808;['appeal must be dismissed']
+43725;['appeal is allowed.the']
+44839;['appeal is allowed']
+71094;['appeal of diana thi my dung truong is dismissed']
+61228;['302 (c.a.)']
+60497;['appeal is dismissed']
+99894;['refugee claim was rejected']
+121455;['removal orders are set aside']
+82881;['appeal is dismissed']
+57931;['appeal is dismissed']
+71171;['appeal of rafael corbita tayag is dismissed']
+106834;['appeal is dismissed']
+125416;['appeal is allowed']
+72191;['panel allows the appeal']
+77237;['appeal is dismissed']
+123273;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+90573;['appeal is determined']
+50767;['appeal is dismissed']
+63067;['allow this appeal']
+102558;['allow this appeal']
+59552;['appeals could not be considered abandoned']
+63198;['appeal is allowed']
+122884;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+123464;['i agree with the rpd decision in this regard', 'reject the appellant’s related arguments']
+90052;['claimantsxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxandxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxare not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+64291;['appeal is dismissed']
+85941;['appeal is allowed']
+94347;['appeals are dismissed']
+86878;['appeal is terminated']
+56690;['appeal isallowed']
+121676;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+103460;['refugee appeal division does not have jurisdiction to reopen']
+55198;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+45420;['appeal is allowed']
+13832;['appeal isallowed']
+95900;['appeal is dismissed']
+76002;['appeal isallowed']
+74216;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a person in need of protection']
+40146;['appeal should be dismissed']
+49580;['appeal isallowed']
+108760;['302 (c.a.']
+103054;['appeal is allowed']
+37839;['appeal was dismissed']
+102154;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+121445;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105891;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107890;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+80013;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+99206;['allowed this appeal with reasons']
+95897;['appeal isallowed']
+38430;['appeal is allowed']
+140277;['appeal is dismissed']
+64058;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+60011;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+86651;['appeal of shahin karuei dismissed']
+19379;['appeal is rejected']
+106619;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+122679;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+113633;['appeal is dismissed']
+49714;['irb (f.c.a., no']
+48231;['decision was found to be invalid in law']
+107060;['appeal be dismissed']
+90112;['negative']
+91181;['appeal is abandoned']
+79336;['302 (c.a.']
+86649;['appeal is dismissed']
+21936;['appeal is allowed']
+151924;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26858;['rad must first seek to supplement them']
+105826;['appeals are dismissed']
+98527;['negative']
+128612;['decision of the rpd is confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+82980;['appeal is allowed']
+112777;['appeal is allowed.the']
+101667;['appeal is allowed']
+96252;['appeal is dismissed']
+84626;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+88443;['refugee protection claim is therefore rejected']
+52771;['appeal is dismissed']
+94571;['negative']
+68895;['appeal is dismissed']
+43712;['appeal is dismissed']
+130750;['appeal be dismissed']
+128263;['appeal is dismissed']
+51687;['appeal is dismissed']
+96814;['appeal is allowed']
+107093;['appeal is dismissed']
+142826;['appellants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+96915;['claims are therefore rejected']
+128374;['appeal is allowed']
+80755;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+123650;['not recognize him as a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+68792;['nor a person in need of protection']
+72018;['appeal is dismissed']
+87304;['negative']
+148720;['302 (c.a.']
+99609;['appeal is dismissed']
+27338;['appeal is allowed']
+103611;['you are neither a convention refugee nor are you a person in need of protection']
+91268;['appeal is dismissed']
+82661;['appeals are dismissed']
+76466;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+101699;['appeal isallowed']
+88177;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+129216;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+146106;['rad finds no error']
+122705;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92548;['appeal has been abandoned']
+57953;['appeal was dismissed']
+23105;['appeal is dismissed']
+101012;['appeal is allowed']
+101949;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+59747;['appeal is allowed']
+129399;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+57084;['appeal was allowed']
+132935;['appeals were dismissed']
+52283;['application is allowed', 'appeal of otinel winston obermuller is dismissed']
+91934;['claimants are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection”']
+84668;['appeal is terminated']
+101171;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+99130;['appeal is allowed.the']
+37903;['appeal is allowed']
+121577;['refugee protection claims filed byxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare rejected']
+52112;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+121425;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98386;['appeal is allowed']
+141999;['appeal is dismissed']
+17146;['appeal is terminated']
+48589;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+63945;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+86537;['appeal is dismissed']
+12211;['appeal is allowed']
+133391;['appeal is dismissed']
+123388;['302 (c.a.']
+71513;['dismisses this appeal']
+151334;['rad concludes that the rpd’s decision is correct']
+99237;['allows the appeal']
+68783;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+113516;['appeal is dismissed']
+63091;['appeal was declared abandoned']
+39872;['appeal was declared abandoned']
+28071;['appeal is allowed']
+100150;['appeal is dismissed']
+95156;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+19157;['dismiss the appeal']
+151328;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not “convention refugees”']
+122113;['appeal is dismissed']
+96624;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+98076;['xxxxxxxx is not in need of refugee protection']
+96370;['appeal is dismissed']
+70955;['appeal is dismissed']
+88044;['appeal is dismissed']
+99857;['decision of the immigration division is set aside.the']
+100651;['appeal is dismissed']
+90026;['appeal is dismissed']
+89216;['302 (c.a.']
+76682;['allow the appeal']
+124081;['appeal of nockeen chetolo peck is allowed']
+85859;['claimant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94571;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+72869;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74215;['appeal is allowed']
+99257;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102556;['appeal regarding the applicant sylvia gamboa dela cruz is allowed']
+52605;['xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+62999;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+123136;['appeal is allowed']
+48590;['appeal is allowed']
+13752;['removal order is set aside']
+73596;['appeal is dismissed']
+123845;['appeal is allowed.the', 'rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+92483;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+95058;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88454;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+94901;['panel rejects these claims']
+96384;['appeal is allowed']
+59832;['appeal isallowed']
+47394;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'allow the appeal']
+122101;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of therpdthat', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+71008;['appeal is dismissed']
+49199;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+121949;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+45988;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+121573;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee, neither is he a person in need of protection']
+95510;['removal order is set aside']
+102921;['appeal is allowed']
+90051;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+88412;['appeal is dismissed']
+124422;['confirm the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97459;['appeal isallowed']
+23098;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+92762;['appeal is dismissed']
+123783;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124081;['appeal isallowedconcerning theminorappellant anddismissedwith respect to theprincipalappellant']
+38879;['dismisses these appeals']
+68194;['dismiss this appeal']
+150663;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'neither “refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+151890;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+67494;['appeal is allowed']
+110675;['appeal is allowed']
+123715;['appeal is dismissed']
+132320;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+108188;['rad agrees with the finding of the rpd']
+134420;['appeal is allowed']
+73291;['appeal must be dismissed']
+88444;['negative']
+122535;['appeal is allowed in part']
+94792;['appeal is allowed']
+141563;['appeal is allowed']
+80217;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+67493;['appeal is allowed']
+146771;['appeal is allowed']
+122822;['appeal is allowed']
+135110;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151819;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+85547;['appeal is terminated']
+82043;['appeal is allowed']
+41681;['appeal is allowed']
+91422;['appeal is terminated']
+131066;['appeal is dismissed']
+102478;['appeal is dismissed']
+75428;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate consideration']
+80748;['appeal is allowed']
+65134;['appeal is allowed']
+81371;['claimants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+5591;['dismiss her appeal']
+113263;['appeal is dismissed']
+113636;['appeal is\xa0']
+54246;['appeal pursuant to section 77(3)(a) is allowed']
+148506;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'reject these claims']
+67785;['allow the appeal of hawa omar']
+108065;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee']
+105866;['leave to appeal to the supreme court of canada dismissed']
+89288;['appeal is terminated']
+26968;['refugee division, therefore, finds xxxxxxxxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+69430;['appeal isallowed']
+60662;['appeal is dismissed']
+133390;['appeals are dismissed']
+131757;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+59770;['removal orders are set aside']
+27290;['appeal abandoned']
+78760;['appeal isallowed']
+85551;['appeal is terminated']
+96086;['allowed the appeal']
+135907;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+47406;['appeals are allowed.the']
+87422;['appeal is dismissed']
+82429;['appeal is dismissed']
+89383;['appeal is terminated']
+129935;['appeal is allowed']
+81932;['theapplications are dismissed']
+94261;['appellant is an excluded person', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100992;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+128445;['conclude the decision of the visa officer on the applicant’s admissibility']
+84829;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90121;['neither convention refugees']
+99933;['claim is rejected']
+87829;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+87682;['appeal is dismissed']
+122677;['302 (c.a.)']
+86212;['appeal is dismissed']
+51756;['appeal is dismissed']
+93314;['appeal is dismissed']
+151587;['appeal is dismissed']
+26758;['appeal bedismissed.']
+96570;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+145826;['dismiss the appeal']
+54797;['appeal was disjoined from that of her husband']
+74531;['302 (c.a.']
+127338;['appeal is allowed']
+94262;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+64130;['appeal isallowed']
+122885;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+58105;['appeal is allowed']
+108886;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94210;['appeal is dismissed']
+134296;['theappealis allowed']
+47815;['appeal isallowed']
+113237;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+65639;['appeal is allowed']
+60948;['appeal is dismissed']
+88401;['appeal is dismissed']
+24509;['panel therefore dismisses the appeal']
+56725;['application of the respondent is granted']
+98485;['appeal is dismissed']
+39041;['appeal is dismissed']
+94165;['rad finds the rpd’s conclusions to be reasonable']
+67785;['appeal is allowed']
+98804;['appeal is allowed']
+66659;['appeal isallowed']
+87675;['appeal is dismissed']
+40149;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+75484;['appeal is allowed']
+151289;['appeal is dismissed']
+141279;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+97291;['or a “person in need of protection']
+49527;['appeal be allowed']
+104856;['appeal isallowed']
+64293;['appeal is allowed']
+68164;['appeal is allowed']
+90814;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+147468;['appeal is dismissed']
+97958;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90365;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69068;['allow this appeal']
+69093;['appeal is allowed or dismissed']
+43732;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+145370;['appeal is dismissed']
+70472;['appeal isallowed']
+98059;['appeal is not about perfection']
+63709;['appeal is dismissed']
+98668;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+64592;['appeal was dismissed']
+140741;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+72711;['appeal is allowed']
+110562;['dismisses the appeal']
+75563;['claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+98786;['appeal were dismissed']
+141563;['appeal of jose antonio alemany rubio is allowed']
+141308;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxher daughterxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxxher sonxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare', 'not “convention refugees”']
+79987;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+96945;['rad sets aside the determination of the   ', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention   ']
+108823;['nor persons in need of protection']
+127698;['appeal is dismissed']
+19112;['appeal is allowed']
+38902;['appeal is allowed']
+86870;['appeal is terminated']
+96709;['appeal is dismissed']
+124954;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+88107;['appeal is terminated']
+140720;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+131040;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124711;['302 (c.a.']
+56862;['appeal is rejected']
+91654;['appeal is allowed']
+69672;['appeal is allowed']
+142902;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd']
+69760;['appeal is dismissed']
+84435;['appeal isallowed']
+99552;['removal order is set aside']
+144937;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'appellant to be a convention refugee']
+71364;['appeal of german henry pagilagan is dismissed']
+68162;['appeal is dismissed']
+96781;['high court upholds convictions of five officers']
+105849;['appeal is dismissed']
+81233;['appeal is allowed']
+32165;['appeal is allowed']
+49065;['appeal is allowed']
+63870;['allow the appeal in law and in discretion']
+54283;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+74108;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+60505;['appeal is terminated']
+106298;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+56615;['removal order isset aside']
+93010;['claimant is excluded from canadian refugee protection']
+62629;['two appeals are allowed']
+108271;['claimants will not face a serious possibility of persecution']
+99714;['dismiss the appeal']
+98081;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+62878;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+60995;['allow the appeal']
+89759;['claimant is not a convention refugee, nor is he a person in need of protection']
+152951;['decision should be set aside']
+147007;['appeal is allowed.the']
+105169;['appeal is allowed']
+85433;['appeal of ammar attique is allowed']
+90287;['appeals are dismissed']
+94532;['appeal is dismissed']
+94074;['appeal is allowed']
+42314;['appeal is dismissed']
+123455;['302 (c.a.)']
+142896;['dismiss the minor appellants’ appeals']
+66767;['appeal fails']
+71402;['appeal is dismissed']
+104028;['appeal is allowed']
+93318;['appeal is allowed']
+97276;['negative']
+26819;['claimant xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+122883;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+59914;['appeals must be dismissed']
+49159;['appeal is dismissed']
+124119;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+103812;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+68438;['appeal is allowed']
+95093;['claimant is a not a convention refugee', 'nor is she a person in need of protection']
+13551;['appeal is dismissed']
+68558;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+88303;['appeal is abandoned']
+76276;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+82248;['appeal is dismissed']
+54293;['appeal is dismissed']
+37065;['dismiss this appeal']
+64236;['panel orders that the stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+59548;['appeal is dismissed']
+56954;['appeal of mohammed jalil khan is dismissed']
+85589;['appeal is allowed']
+87112;['appeal is terminated']
+93610;['appeal isallowed']
+113590;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+81824;['appeal is dismissed']
+149570;['appeal is dismissed']
+141651;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+111361;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105343;['minister’s application is allowed']
+84153;['appeal isallowed.the']
+148632;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses   the appeal']
+101656;['favourable decision is rendered in the file of ms. jakobovitz']
+96888;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+107891;['appeal is dismissed']
+70738;['appeal is dismissed']
+59184;['appeal is allowed']
+129159;['appeal is dismissed']
+123131;['appeal is allowed']
+95990;['dismisses the minister’s notice of intervention']
+100604;['removal order is set aside']
+123550;['confirm the rpd’s negative decision']
+100097;['appeal is allowed']
+75140;['dismisses this appeal']
+77055;['appeal is dismissed']
+80792;['appeal isallowed']
+99734;['application is dismissed']
+100548;['appeal is allowed']
+103050;['appeal is allowed']
+60197;['appeal is allowed']
+97918;['dismiss the appeal']
+19151;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+95490;['appeal is allowed']
+121845;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30488;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+26783;['appeal division orders', 'appeal from the refusal to approve the application for landing']
+89446;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+125309;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+87076;['appeal is allowed']
+73592;['allowed the re-opening']
+83898;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+108211;['appeal fails', 'rad confirms the rpd’s determination']
+132300;['rpd’s decision is set aside', 'appellant is granted refugee status']
+100701;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+68873;['appeal isallowed']
+147616;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+61638;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+68141;['appellant is not a turkish national']
+90255;['neither convention refugees']
+63765;['appeals are dismissed']
+77054;['appeal is dismissed']
+76948;['appeal is allowed']
+131875;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64279;['appeal is allowed']
+98600;['302 (c.a.)']
+105375;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+102924;['appeal is allowed']
+68345;['appeal is allowed']
+70787;['iad must dismiss the appeal']
+47292;['appeal is dismissed']
+101704;['appeal isallowed']
+89043;['appeal is allowed']
+101476;['appeal is allowed']
+23098;['dismiss the appeal']
+113573;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+40656;['appeal is dismissed']
+94953;['appeal is dismissed']
+69538;['appeal isallowed']
+31998;['appeal is dismissed']
+83447;['appeal is dismissed']
+97223;['appeal must be dismissed']
+131225;['allow the appeal']
+130748;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+57734;['allow this appeal']
+147434;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+111365;['appeal is allowed']
+45414;['officer’s decision is valid in law and fact']
+138863;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+63097;['theclaimantis not a person in need of protection']
+69196;['appeal is dismissed']
+68718;['appeal is dismissed']
+136732;['appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+99294;['appeal cannot succeed']
+77631;['appeal be dismissed']
+113746;['appeal is allowed']
+146128;['–section 96claim is rejected']
+69711;['appeal is allowed']
+102123;['removal order is set aside']
+145044;['xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx are notconventionrefugees undersection']
+68923;['appeal is allowed']
+86400;['appeal isallowed']
+82391;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+100105;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+45191;['appeal is allowed']
+70945;['appeal of rosalie dauz licudine is dismissed']
+29723;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84178;['appeal is dismissed']
+63905;['appeal is allowed']
+123781;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection”']
+131702;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+80103;['appeal is terminated']
+52373;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+70954;['appeal isallowed']
+123854;['allow this appeal']
+76886;['appeal is terminated']
+95006;['appeal is terminated']
+125395;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+131860;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60494;['dismiss the appeal']
+102529;['cancel the stay of removal', 'dismiss the appeal']
+103696;['applications are, therefore,dismissed']
+101445;['appealis allowed']
+128159;['302 (c.a.']
+12936;['appeal is allowed']
+82889;['302 (c.a.']
+129864;['appeal is allowed']
+88979;['appeal is allowed']
+150707;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+61304;['appeal is allowed.the']
+152762;['appeal is dismissed']
+89218;['appeal is allowed']
+153147;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+88077;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+95405;['appeal is dismissed']
+30295;['appeal is dismissed']
+130947;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68898;['appeal isallowed']
+56621;['appeal is allowed']
+104090;['appeal is allowed']
+25526;['i must dismiss']
+15017;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124070;['appeal in relation to xxxx xxxx xxxx (principal respondent) is allowed', 'rpd decision is set aside']
+87020;['appeal is dismissed']
+92772;['appeal is dismissed']
+84408;['appeal is terminated']
+94741;['appeal is allowed']
+151915;['rad is not in a position to make its own determination']
+87035;['appeal is allowed']
+101668;['appeal is dismissed']
+46083;['appeal is allowed']
+69513;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+123717;['appeal be dismissed']
+63177;['appeal is dismissed']
+99176;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+51665;['appeal is dismissed']
+99902;['appeal is dismissed']
+88897;['case is dismissed']
+109634;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+76698;['appeal is dismissed']
+132269;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+123131;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+105556;['appeal is allowed']
+90995;['appeal is allowed.the']
+76463;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+143143;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+146446;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+58236;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+49979;['appeal is terminated']
+86874;['appeal isallowed']
+83042;['appeal is allowed']
+55199;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+124585;['dismisses the minor appellant’s appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34883;['appeal is dismissed']
+50729;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+102088;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+151852;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+133372;['appeal is allowed']
+145826;['302 (c.a.']
+141235;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+53413;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+98353;['dismiss the appeal']
+98110;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+81637;['appeal is allowed']
+78651;['appeal is denied']
+94368;['appeal is allowed']
+153792;['appeal is allowed']
+81413;['appeal is dismissed']
+94272;['appeal is accepted']
+39064;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+58830;['appeal is allowed']
+148613;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+46287;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+30479;['appeal is dismissed']
+99540;['302 (c.a.']
+12233;['appeal were dismissed']
+101497;['refusal is set aside']
+72914;['appeal is allowed']
+89922;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+97989;['dismiss this appeal']
+129144;['appeal is dismissed']
+23043;['appeal of dr. ayesha imran is allowed']
+80294;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+60049;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+132276;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+36468;['appeal is dismissed']
+138799;['appeal abandoned']
+151409;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+74185;['sa and her daughter']
+85961;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+90796;['appeal is dismissed']
+84786;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82152;['appeal is dismissed']
+80682;['not a person in need of protection']
+124002;['appeal is allowed']
+144472;['appeal is allowed']
+56723;['refusal invalid in law']
+111447;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+146638;['application to reopen is therefore dismissed']
+46571;['appeal is allowed']
+124111;['appeal is allowed']
+101436;['appeal is allowed']
+54676;['appeal is dismissed']
+135149;['substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+91743;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+122236;['appeal is allowed.pursuant', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+81188;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+91342;['appeal is dismissed']
+93293;['appeal is dismissed']
+26736;['appeal is allowed in law']
+98088;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+83044;['appeal is allowed']
+74028;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+110270;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+26741;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+97332;['appeal is dismissed']
+143912;['negative determination']
+57482;['appeal is allowed']
+150672;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not refugees']
+93622;['appeal of sandeep kaur tamber is dismissed']
+134288;['appeal is dismissed']
+47716;['appeal is allowed.the']
+58137;['appeal is terminated']
+101948;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+34931;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100127;['appeal is allowed']
+110278;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99092;['appeal is dismissed']
+91635;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor person in need of protection']
+76920;['appeal is allowed']
+98618;['appeal is terminated']
+49067;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26694;['tribunal has no jurisdiction to hear this appeal']
+138796;['appeal is dismissed']
+49713;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+133341;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98483;['appeal is allowed']
+150651;['ms.\xa0xxxx xxxx is excluded from protection']
+76681;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+147130;['visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+80795;['appeal is allowed']
+128590;['appeal is allowed']
+110935;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+94075;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67407;['appeal isallowed']
+124100;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+127695;['appeals are dismissed']
+98790;['dismiss the appeal']
+47338;['appeal is allowed']
+128179;['appeal is allowed']
+123604;['dismiss the minister’s appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'respondents are convention refugees']
+89316;['appeal is allowed']
+113754;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101254;['application to reopen the file is dismissed']
+98122;['negative']
+31232;['dismiss the appellant’s appeal']
+89703;['appeal is allowed']
+52219;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+121382;['panel sets aside the decision of the rpd', 'substitutes the decision with a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+151515;['appeal is allowed']
+99738;['allowed the appeal']
+18010;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+98093;['appeal is allowed']
+69158;['appeal is allowed']
+92693;['appeal is dismissed']
+100653;['removal order is set aside']
+62840;['panel dismisses the appeal']
+71234;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+87333;['appeal isallowed']
+20004;['appeal is dismissed']
+99286;['claimant is not a refugee']
+103621;['302 (c.a.)']
+20444;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+81013;['appeal is dismissed']
+104530;['claimant to not be a convention refugee unders']
+153266;['decision of the rpd cannot stand']
+98743;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+102162;['appeal is dismissed']
+93910;['302 (c.a.']
+65632;['appeal beallowedand']
+94587;['appeal is dismissed']
+100543;['appeal is allowed']
+98147;['302 (c.a.']
+22102;['appeal isallowed']
+42001;['appellants are not permanent residents']
+57036;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+26734;['appeal is dismissed']
+57945;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+146564;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+74599;['appeal should be allowed']
+101478;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+91579;['appeal is allowed']
+101696;['allows the appeal']
+148658;['rad rejects the appellant’s reference to an irb decision, dated 2000']
+36568;['appeal is allowed']
+145324;['rad agrees with the finding of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+80111;['dismiss this appeal']
+78743;['appeal is based']
+148503;['panel rejects these claims']
+79600;['appeal is dismissed']
+71191;['appeal is allowed in law']
+76082;['appeal isallowed']
+39874;['302 (c.a.']
+39074;['appeal is allowed']
+67426;['allows the appeal in equity']
+54176;['appeal is dismissed']
+123844;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95201;['appeal is unsuccessful']
+97347;['negative']
+67487;['appeal is allowed']
+64638;['appeal is allowed']
+101359;['allow the appeal']
+148710;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+100653;['exclusion order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+49516;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed']
+75579;['302 (c.a.']
+50521;['appeal is allowed']
+42453;['removal order is set aside']
+37865;['appeal were dismissed']
+74467;['appeal is allowed']
+86473;['appeal is allowed']
+105349;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+146861;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxxxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+100187;['dismiss the appeal']
+67631;['dismiss this appeal']
+76680;['appeal is allowed']
+74150;['appeal dismissed']
+98924;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+131073;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72650;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+122116;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+142502;['appeals are dismissed']
+26775;['appeal was declared abandoned', 'appeal was dismissed']
+77081;['appeal isallowed']
+100463;['xxxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+96369;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+125382;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90550;['appeal is dismissed']
+144894;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+124692;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69258;['appeal isallowed']
+131520;['appeal is allowed.the']
+144255;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+135899;['appeal is dismissed']
+83897;['allow the appeal']
+47357;['appeal should be dismissed']
+67643;['appeal must fail in law']
+58498;['appeal is allowed']
+24398;['appeal ofabdullah bokesmatiisallowed.his']
+43338;['appeal is allowed']
+54833;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+144420;['claim is rejected']
+77027;['allow the appeal']
+115286;['allows this appeal']
+14582;['appeal is dismissed']
+90095;['negative']
+46995;['appeal is dismissed']
+40664;['appeal is allowed']
+57070;['appeal is allowed']
+109633;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+83711;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+19722;['appeal is dismissed']
+129147;['appeal isallowed']
+103620;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+97321;['appeal is allowed']
+100660;"[""rad sets aside the rpd's determination""]"
+125026;['appeal is allowed']
+94903;['claims are rejected']
+136082;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s negative determination']
+48418;['appeal is dismissed']
+132796;['appeal is allowed']
+38849;['appeal is allowed']
+89152;['appeal is allowed']
+26897;"['claimant, xxxxxxxxx, is not a ""convention refugee']"
+78135;['dismissing the appeal']
+146826;['substitute my own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+142856;['allow this appeal and set aside the decision of the rpd']
+101036;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not in danger of persecution']
+114364;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+38398;['appeal is dismissed']
+143153;['substitutes its determination']
+80992;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+70185;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+85915;['appeal is dismissed']
+87822;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need or protection']
+77265;['appeal is allowed']
+100295;['claimants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+127736;['appeal is determined']
+55134;['appeal is allowed']
+76152;['panel rejects the claim ofxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxfor refugee protection']
+77478;['appeal has been abandoned']
+88120;['appeal is allowed']
+82710;['appeal is allowed']
+29634;['appeals are dismissed']
+56956;['appeal of sherry lynn brunelle is dismissed']
+47346;['appellant has not lost his status incanada']
+61048;['appeal is dismissed']
+77971;['appeal is allowed.the']
+52046;['appeal is terminated']
+96886;['appeal is allowed']
+123693;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination']
+71175;['appeal is allowed']
+101749;['allow the appeal']
+70163;['appeal of ting yu ma is dismissed']
+123368;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97923;['appeal is allowed']
+72881;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+108452;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+80230;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+82884;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+81131;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+135491;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+90484;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+39063;['appeal is allowed']
+48423;['appeal of philip salviu anny is dismissed']
+70180;['appeal is allowed']
+34158;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+90934;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+15582;['application to reopen the removal order appeal is allowed']
+103226;['refugee protection claim of xxxx xxxx xxxx is allowed']
+65015;['appeal is dismissed']
+68695;['appeal is allowed.the']
+55249;['not convention refugees']
+71750;['appeal isallowed']
+120812;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+73191;['appeal is allowed.the']
+47787;['appeal isallowed']
+102112;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+67797;['appeal is allowed.the']
+61402;['appeal is dismissed']
+60952;['appeal isallowed']
+132331;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor persons in need of protection']
+82085;['appeal is allowed']
+82070;['appeal isallowed']
+148625;['appeal is dismissed']
+101260;['nor a citizen of canada']
+38848;['appeal is determined']
+96887;['dismissal of the appeal']
+69223;['appeal is allowed']
+71074;['negative']
+108845;['rad upholds the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons who would be subject to persecution']
+140964;['xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+124002;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+142816;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+88310;['appeal isallowed']
+69447;['appeal is allowed']
+124545;['appeal is dismissed']
+118327;['appeal is dismissed']
+102193;['appeal is dismissed']
+46291;['appeal ofverissimo pereira de araujois dismissed']
+98234;['appeal is dismissed']
+122120;['302 (c.a.']
+106860;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+151338;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+50530;['appeals be dismissed']
+95082;['respondents are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+45220;['appeal is dismissed']
+50741;['appeal is dismissed']
+72667;['appeals must be dismissed']
+76671;['appeal isallowed']
+111333;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68714;['appeal is allowed']
+60089;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+93769;['appeal is allowed']
+60697;['appeal is dismissed']
+39875;['appeal is dismissed']
+148601;['appeal is dismissed']
+31255;['appeal is dismissed']
+89838;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+123086;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees and persons in need of protection']
+76246;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123698;['302 (c.a.']
+100230;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+148498;['claimants do not face a serious possibility of persecution']
+40137;['appeal is determined']
+105820;['appeal was allowed']
+96634;['appeal were dismissed']
+125428;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+105834;['appeal of henedina baltazar abando is dismissed']
+91201;['appeal is dismissed']
+138804;['appeal is dismissed']
+96014;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70062;['appeal was allowed']
+97348;['negative']
+61228;['appeal isallowed']
+84280;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+84719;['appeal is dismissed']
+29636;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+128327;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+83081;['appeal is allowed']
+71574;['appeal is dismissed']
+99692;['appeals are dismissed']
+71086;['appeal is allowed']
+94737;['appeal of natasha lynn barley, also known as natasha lynn kler, is dismissed']
+94731;['appeal is dismissed']
+94441;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82355;['appeal isallowed']
+123850;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122899;['appeal is allowed']
+80756;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59945;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+94146;['appeal is dismissed']
+70658;['appeal is dismissed']
+70652;['appeal isallowed']
+135484;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+76556;['appeal is terminated']
+68691;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+47355;['appeal division allows the appeal']
+125673;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+139894;['appeal isallowed']
+67587;['appeal is allowed']
+102981;['appeal is allowed']
+67776;['appeal is governed by theact']
+36103;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+141267;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77936;['appeal is dismissed']
+61910;['appeal is allowed']
+143899;['appeal is dismissed']
+147784;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60424;['appeal is allowed']
+101799;['appeal is dismissed']
+152950;['appeal is denied']
+87106;['appeal is allowed']
+67809;['appeal is allowed']
+71599;['appeal is dismissed']
+104390;['appeal isallowed']
+13690;['appeal is terminated']
+142537;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67410;['appeal isallowed']
+31377;['appeal is dismissed']
+145054;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+74233;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+152595;['panel rejects the refugee protection claim']
+94416;['appeal of ibrahim jalloh is dismissed']
+124465;['appeal is allowed']
+61290;['impugned decision of the visa officer']
+140985;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+104259;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+44437;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+79759;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+142486;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+130737;['302 (c.a.']
+150643;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+101256;['appellant is therefore a convention refugee']
+114321;['appeal must be dismissed']
+55910;['appeal is allowed.the']
+87450;['removal order is set aside']
+47724;['adoption is invalid']
+123065;['302 (c.a.']
+91005;['appeal is dismissed']
+123824;['appeal is allowed']
+98819;['appeal is allowed']
+131167;['appeal is dismissed']
+102203;['appeal will be dismissed']
+34988;['appeal is allowed']
+106792;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+50491;['appeal is allowed']
+140211;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123818;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100264;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+98860;['appeal is allowed']
+83150;['appeal is dismissed']
+96716;['appeal is determined']
+76805;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+123519;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+147006;['appeal is allowed.the']
+121936;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108926;['appeal is dismissed']
+83295;['appeal is allowed']
+89413;['appeal is dismissed']
+151798;['appeal is dismissed']
+89744;['appeal is dismissed']
+98334;['appeal is dismissed']
+97505;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+104003;['appeal is dismissed']
+96588;['appeal is allowed']
+122868;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+142538;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+91710;['appeal is allowed']
+63734;['appeal is dismissed']
+142971;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95548;['appeal is allowed']
+87214;['appeal isallowed']
+52351;['removal order is set aside']
+54563;['appeal is dismissed']
+107831;['appeal is dismissed']
+80721;['negative']
+122897;['rad disagrees']
+75999;['claimant mr.xxxxx xxxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+96685;['appeal isdismissed.']
+124642;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+46387;['appeal is allowed']
+97525;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+39907;['appeal is allowed']
+57892;['appeal is allowed']
+95070;['appellant may still not be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+120770;['appeal is allowed']
+71495;['appeal is dismissed']
+147463;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+76355;['dismiss the appeal']
+85173;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+44186;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+122774;['rad substitutes its own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+100110;['respondent is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection']
+64227;['removal orders areset aside']
+74066;['appeal is allowed.the']
+69155;['appeal is allowed']
+66768;['appeal is dismissed']
+42280;['appeal of mengisteab russ doboch is allowed']
+60988;['appeal is dismissed']
+125212;['allow the appeal']
+90240;['refugee protection division rejects the claims']
+55122;['appeal is dismissed in law']
+76067;['appeal is dismissed']
+127443;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69503;['application to reopen this appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+74654;['appeal were allowed']
+80015;['negative']
+125156;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67586;['immigration appeal division dismisses an appeal']
+147461;['appeal is dismissed']
+36098;['appeal is dismissed']
+73223;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+150827;['appeal’s dismissal']
+108063;['appeal is dismissed']
+143173;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+69689;['appeal is allowed']
+140841;['rad finds it unnecessary to deal with this matter']
+107233;['appeal is dismissed']
+89085;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+118637;['appeal is dismissed']
+29724;['removal order isset aside']
+89276;['appeal be dismissed']
+46062;['appeal isallowed']
+99268;['appeal isallowed']
+90979;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+79198;['appeal is allowed']
+107029;['appeals are allowed']
+85523;['appeal is allowed']
+69423;['appeal isallowed']
+21097;['appeal division orders that the', 'appeal bedismissed.']
+57927;['302 (c.a.']
+101509;['302 (c.a.)']
+80539;['dismiss the appeal']
+128385;['302 (c.a.']
+127448;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77273;['dismiss the appeal']
+79071;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+71349;['appeal of paramjit singh basanti is therefore dismissed']
+89389;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+61379;['appeals are dismissed']
+149574;['appeal is allowed']
+94035;['appeal is allowed']
+55276;['appeals fail']
+89060;['appeal is dismissed']
+24248;['appeal abandoned']
+96618;['appeal is allowed', 'visa officer’s refusal is set aside']
+81276;['determination is legally valid']
+73897;['appeal is allowed in law']
+94649;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101517;['appeal must be dismissed']
+70911;['appeal is allowed']
+80475;['appeal is dismissed']
+89387;['appeal from the removal order made undersection 37(1)(a) is dismissed']
+17154;['appeal isallowed']
+36126;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+125224;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+93592;['302 (c.a.']
+151516;['appeal is allowed']
+108678;['mrs. xxxx and mr. xxxx xxxx have failed to establish that they would face persecution should they return to hungary']
+99901;['appeal of li min che is dismissed']
+28092;['appeal is allowed']
+135203;['negative decision were incorrect']
+91321;['appeal isallowed']
+107460;['appeal is denied']
+77225;['appeal must be dismissed']
+89359;['appeal isallowed']
+122957;['confirm the rpd’s decision that they are neither “convention refugee(s)', 'nor “person(s) in need of protection']
+87328;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+99591;['appeal is dismissed']
+71084;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+139871;['appeal is allowed']
+35884;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+101667;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate circumstances']
+97519;['negative']
+81190;['appeal is allowed']
+86034;['appeal is dismissed']
+49549;['rejects his claim']
+99901;['appeal is dismissed']
+91658;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95585;['appeal is terminated']
+139891;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+124408;['appeal is dismissed']
+89677;['ms. aboktef has not lost her permanent resident status']
+47570;['appeal is dismissed']
+31382;['appeal is allowed']
+151916;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+60442;['appeal is governed by theact']
+61476;['302 (c.a.']
+72637;['appeal is dismissed']
+97392;['his claim fails']
+76950;['appeals are dismissed']
+89801;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+86542;['appeal is allowed']
+143506;['302 (c.a.']
+101241;['appeal is dismissed']
+124578;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+38787;['appeal is dismissed']
+124661;['appeal is allowed']
+124164;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+102175;['appeal is dismissed']
+27297;['302 (c.a.)']
+73256;['appeal is allowed.section']
+132283;['rpd’s determination is, therefore, set aside', 'appellant is granted refugee status']
+114692;['claimants,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx, are not “convention refugees” or “persons in need of protection']
+74670;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+96316;['appeal is allowed']
+26790;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+91379;['appeal isallowedand']
+54712;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71981;['dismiss this appeal']
+87682;['appeal is dismissed']
+91683;['appeal is allowed']
+128264;['removal order is set aside']
+132652;['appellant, xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124941;['appellant is not a refugee']
+86934;['removal orders are set aside']
+90942;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+68904;['removal order is set aside']
+62892;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+90723;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+85381;['appeal is allowed']
+76966;['appeal isallowed']
+143886;['appeal is dismissed']
+96814;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+132753;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+54791;['appeals by the appellant and her son are dismissed']
+97951;['associated claimant xxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+64857;['convert the spousal sponsorship to a conjugal partner sponsorship application']
+26907;"['not a ""convention refugee']"
+42279;['appeal was dismissed']
+35696;['appeal is allowed']
+143562;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+50495;['appeal were dismissed']
+113222;['appeal is allowed']
+125696;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+69257;['appeal is allowed']
+39035;['appeal is not allowed']
+69814;['dismisses this appeal']
+21307;['not set aside the determination of the rpd']
+69129;['appeal is allowed.the']
+150696;['appeal is dismissed', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+98551;['appeal succeeds']
+87337;['appeal is terminated']
+87741;['appeal is dismissed']
+87090;['appeal is dismissed']
+14674;['xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+142798;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'appeal must be dismissed']
+71175;['appeal is allowed']
+34613;['appeal is dismissed']
+81279;['dismiss the appeal']
+70004;['appeal isallowed']
+17975;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed']
+23053;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+78062;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of']
+91536;['302 (c.a.']
+33082;['appeal is allowed']
+19721;['appeal is dismissed']
+100615;['appeal isallowedand']
+77538;['302 (c.a.)']
+85526;['appeal was dismissed']
+62945;['appeal is allowed']
+67935;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+144030;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+49529;['appeal is terminated']
+107698;['appeal is dismissed']
+87308;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+64213;['neither a “convention refugee”']
+109292;['removal order is set aside']
+95058;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection']
+50735;['appeal is allowed']
+71047;['302 (c.a.']
+45246;['appeal is determined']
+92620;['xxxxxxxxx is a convention refugee']
+68363;['appeal is allowed']
+124175;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+92788;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+135486;['not a “conventionrefugee”']
+40371;['appeal is terminated']
+90771;['rpd determination is set aside']
+95270;['removal order is set aside']
+97905;['appeal is dismissed']
+58421;['appeal of yan fen liu (the “appellant”']
+21441;['not a convention refugee']
+98875;['appeal is allowed']
+34943;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s decision', 'not substitute its own determination']
+98228;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+101924;['appeal be dismissed']
+135165;['appeal is allowed']
+52730;['xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+98847;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108184;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor is she a “person in need of protection']
+81374;['appeal of mr. gopalakrishnan venkatesan is allowed']
+92443;['appeal isallowed']
+123310;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+33087;['application for extension of time is therefore allowed']
+42359;['allows this appeal']
+98475;['panel therefore denies the present claim']
+19301;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+49531;['appeal is dismissed']
+96157;['dismiss the present appeal']
+93998;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+57075;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+51283;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+91541;['appeal is allowed']
+128187;['appeal is allowed']
+131232;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+92505;['appeal is dismissed']
+52934;['allow the appeal of jasmer singh shokar']
+101770;['appeal is dismissed']
+95436;['appeal of grace pana cutamora is dismissed']
+59700;['appeal is dismissed']
+91153;['set aside the decision and allow the appeal']
+89285;['appeal is dismissed']
+98568;['appeal is allowed']
+85431;['appeal is dismissed']
+89742;['appeal isallowed']
+50450;['rad allows the appeal']
+63015;['dismiss this appeal']
+116849;['appeal is allowed']
+82838;['dismissing this appeal']
+128565;['article is admissible']
+104445;['appeal is allowed']
+101421;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96019;['appeals are dismissed']
+124739;['appeal is dismissed']
+117105;['appeal isallowed']
+97442;['appeal is terminated']
+112338;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+35544;['appeal is reinstated']
+129130;['appeal is dismissed']
+67795;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+74559;['appeal is terminated']
+91914;['appeal is allowed']
+59406;['appeal is allowed']
+113622;['appeal is dismissed']
+93813;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+54229;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+61640;['appeal isallowed']
+99196;['appeal is allowed']
+75430;['appeal isallowed']
+114362;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+96871;['appeal is terminated']
+95888;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130923;['appellant is not a “refugee”']
+142299;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+71813;['appeal is accordingly dismissed']
+31966;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+116752;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+103045;['appeal is dismissed']
+81292;['determination is legally valid']
+73677;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84429;['appeal isallowed']
+71391;['appeal is dismissed']
+143243;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+136145;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+131273;['not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+122384;['appeal is dismissed']
+94311;['byxxxx xxxxis rejected']
+97393;['negative']
+74671;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+89329;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+64620;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+100806;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+30517;['appeal were dismissed']
+130953;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd determination']
+143601;['appellants are convention refugees and/or persons in need of protection']
+89328;['allow the appeal']
+90203;['reject his claim']
+113230;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+120813;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeals']
+80029;['negative']
+111113;['appeal is dismissed']
+70490;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+75455;['appeal isallowed']
+116201;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+133360;['rad finds that it is unable to confirm, or set aside and substitute its own decision']
+94623;['appeal is dismissed']
+149069;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52053;['appeal is allowed']
+60249;['appeal is dismissed']
+30517;['deportation order is set aside']
+134165;['decision of the visa officer is legally valid']
+100839;['claim is rejected']
+92397;['appeals are determined to be abandoned']
+80301;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60416;['appeal was then abandoned']
+63227;['appeal is terminated']
+95778;['appeal is dismissed']
+83028;['appeal of gerald michael condon is dismissed']
+99505;['appeal is allowed']
+47390;['appellant has not lost his or her permanent resident status']
+131507;['appeal is not allowed']
+111113;['appellant is a citizen of india']
+70217;['appeal isallowed']
+59847;['appeal of german enrique perez-mercado is dismissed']
+97881;['claim is rejected']
+130692;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84817;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+99982;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76882;['appeal isallowedand']
+54761;['appeal abandoned']
+40772;['appeal is dismissed']
+67497;['appeal be allowed']
+87993;['claimant is not a “convention refugee']
+123711;['appeal isallowed']
+139847;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'appeal is dismissed']
+107251;['appeal is dismissed']
+96449;['appeal isallowed']
+82274;['appeal be dismissed']
+80452;['appeals are allowed']
+95484;['appeal is dismissed']
+44430;['allow the appeal']
+96385;['appeal is dismissed']
+69549;['appeal respecting jerryson saludez is dismissed']
+100869;['appeal isallowed']
+99605;['appeal must be dismissed']
+33321;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+37425;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+52711;['negative']
+93808;['neither a serious possibility of persecution', 'nor a risk of cruel and unusual treatment or punishment']
+14332;['allow the appeal']
+111363;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of canada’s protection']
+149279;['appeal is dismissed']
+52688;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+101692;['appeal is allowed for the following reasons']
+83086;['children in question are canadian citizens']
+95024;['appeals are allowed']
+64208;['appeal is dismissed']
+76916;['appeal is dismissed']
+107320;['claimant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+143011;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77679;"['appeal division', ""dismiss the appellant's appeal""]"
+142307;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+63161;['appeal isallowed']
+107944;['appeal is dismissed']
+101308;['not substitute a decision on this basis']
+65124;['dismiss this appeal']
+142909;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+133244;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+18001;['appeal is dismissed']
+104087;['appeal is dismissed']
+64594;['appeal isallowed']
+67462;['appeal isallowed']
+69518;['application is denied']
+57072;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+69714;['appeal is allowed']
+65656;['appeal is dismissed']
+17935;['extend the stay order for one additional year']
+77824;['reject their claims to refugee protection']
+26757;['appeal is dismissed']
+91294;['appeal was dismissed']
+84676;['appeal isallowed']
+70166;['appeal is dismissed']
+50729;['appeal is allowed.the']
+57537;['appeal of abebe deres is dismissed']
+116338;['allow the appeal,', 'appellants are persons in need of protection']
+79941;['302 (c.a.']
+60951;['appeal is allowed']
+56952;['sufficient and humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+68558;['claimant is a convention refugee or a person in need of   ']
+122262;['rad, pursuant', 'substitutes a decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86939;['appeal is allowed']
+79204;['appeal is dismissed']
+78017;['dismissed the appeal']
+148677;['appeal is dismissed']
+52630;['respondent is not excluded from the convention refugee definition']
+77586;['appeal is allowed']
+91333;['allows the application to reinstate the appeal']
+77267;['appeal would be dismissed']
+98735;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+63059;['appeal is allowed']
+84492;['removal orders are set aside']
+83649;['appeal is allowed']
+54023;['appeal were dismissed']
+37841;['appeal is abandoned']
+77198;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+82850;['dismiss the appeal']
+148739;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject the claim']
+98350;['appeal fails']
+106612;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56742;['appeal isallowed']
+124669;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+153791;['appeal is allowed']
+83673;['appeal is allowed']
+100497;['appeal is allowed']
+69616;['appeal brought by dameon carmichael roy stewart is therefore dismissed']
+92088;['“convention refugees”']
+93067;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+24495;['appeal isallowed']
+68292;['dismisses this appeal']
+97034;['refugee protection division therefore rejects the claim']
+45426;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+142508;['uphold the rpd’s findings']
+18926;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+103546;['appeal is dismissed']
+40063;['appeal is dismissed']
+82360;['appeals are abandoned']
+74056;['appeal is dismissed']
+105890;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+107180;['rad rejects the appellant’s reasons']
+100815;['appeals are allowed']
+70886;['appeal is governed']
+47877;['dismissing the appeal']
+144383;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+125519;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd']
+89819;['appeal isallowed']
+148756;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62245;['negative']
+100436;['ifa fails on the first prong']
+57448;['substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+69074;['dismiss this appeal']
+94498;['appeal is allowed']
+17024;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142971;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+66606;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+42452;['appeal is dismissed']
+100817;['appeal is dismissed']
+150781;['hcr/eg/col/15/01.']
+87068;['appeals of naveed mohammed and nabiah mohammed areallowedand their departure orders are set aside']
+107382;['appeal is allowed']
+30484;['appeal was dismissed']
+61468;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+60081;['refugee protection division rejects this claim for protection']
+64050;['appeal isallowed']
+91591;['appeal isallowed']
+114350;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122903;['appeal is allowed']
+79229;['iad is without jurisdiction']
+92105;['board therefore rejects his claim']
+93310;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+77996;['appeal isallowed']
+107888;['claimant,xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+142069;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+74460;['appeal is allowed']
+60875;['appeal is dismissed']
+141280;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+49711;['appeal is dismissed']
+50542;['appeal is dismissed']
+152013;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+106796;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96471;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+98293;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx,not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+97563;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is terminated']
+121407;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+27243;['appeal be dismissed']
+61357;['allow the appeal']
+69812;['appeal is allowed']
+62380;['claim is rejected']
+96998;['appeal isallowed']
+76725;['appeal is dismissed']
+95608;['appeal is determined']
+107647;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+51768;['appeal isallowed']
+97003;['appeal isallowed']
+77533;['application to reopen is granted in part']
+133273;['claims are dismissed']
+92545;['appeal isallowed']
+44179;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+46527;['302 (c.a.']
+78337;['appeal of jose jessie matanguihan porillo is dismissed']
+128605;['appeal is dismissed']
+73218;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+86403;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+53018;['appeal is dismissed']
+55264;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+143283;['appeal is dismissed']
+146937;['rad determines that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+140814;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+141674;['appeal is dismissed']
+77860;['rejects their claim']
+122644;['appellant was not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+124586;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+32170;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+98302;['claim is rejected']
+130695;['appeal is dismissed']
+150651;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxareneither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132397;['appeal is dismissed']
+73599;['appeal is dismissed']
+89705;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+144472;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellantsxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare convention refugees']
+143875;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+69542;['appeal is dismissed']
+76835;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+96371;['within appeal is dismissed']
+38773;['appeal is dismissed']
+47350;['appeal is allowed']
+84479;['appeal is allowed']
+85851;['allows this appeal']
+132399;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+78294;['appeal of kamaljit singh mutti is allowed']
+91145;['appeal isallowed']
+99697;['appeal is dismissed']
+77859;['her claim fails']
+100883;['appeal be dismissed']
+90706;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+128343;['appeal is allowed']
+60479;['appeal is allowed']
+77942;['appeal dismissed']
+95532;['refugee protection claim filed by the claimant']
+102455;['appeal is dismissed']
+98692;['appeal must be dismissed']
+105629;['appeal of xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is dismissed']
+98331;['application to reinstate is denied']
+81243;['appeal isallowed']
+99923;['appeal is allowed']
+93679;['appeal is allowed']
+94761;['appeal is dismissed']
+145832;['appeal was dismissed']
+104121;['appeal of the minister is allowed']
+19742;['appeal is allowed']
+131215;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+150742;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94278;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+9485;['appeal should be dismissed']
+130967;['not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94030;['appeal is denied']
+40283;['appeal is dismissed']
+144427;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+128844;['rad cannot substitute a determination']
+148995;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+28375;['appeal is dismissed']
+121869;['allow the appeal']
+104512;['application is allowed']
+84428;['appeals are allowed']
+116771;['appellant, xxxx xxxx, is not a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+74727;['appeal isallowed']
+99021;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+16757;['appeal be dismissed']
+40129;['appeal is allowed']
+60049;['refugee protection division rejects this claim for protection.this']
+95350;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+76527;['appeal is allowed']
+81112;['appeal were dismissed']
+46510;['appeal isallowedand']
+99650;['appeal of harwinder kaur pannu is dismissed']
+91743;['decision of the id is set aside']
+147436;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+69170;['appeal is terminated[emphasis']
+87310;['refugee protection division determinesxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim']
+60313;['appeal of jeanette chui kwong is dismissed']
+123302;['dismiss this appeal']
+131727;['rad therefore finds that the claim undersection 97cannot succeed']
+23032;['appeal of warku teklehaimanot godi is dismissed']
+71649;['appeal is dismissed']
+105223;['appeal dismissed']
+72634;['appeal is dismissed']
+74555;['appeal is dismissed']
+45404;['appeal is dismissed']
+146830;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+105703;['appeal is allowed']
+22385;['appeal is dismissed']
+60420;['appeal is allowed']
+114420;['are neither convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+49526;['removal order is set aside']
+141307;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132627;['appellants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+47789;['appeal isallowed']
+23064;['appeal is allowed']
+79869;['appeal is allowed']
+151463;['appeal were dismissed']
+144412;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+76046;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+34178;['appeals should be dismissed']
+69598;['appeal with respect to section 4 of the regulations is allowed in law']
+108891;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+116833;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+142945;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26675;['appeal is allowed']
+84428;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+146431;['respondents are neither convention refugees, pursuant to section 96 of theact', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+121991;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+124927;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+67480;['appeal is dismissed']
+129131;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+113569;['appeal is dismissed']
+91948;['appeal of jesus antonio rodriguez montes is dismissed']
+21381;['302 (c.a.)']
+96651;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+76324;['appeal brought underparagraph 67(1)(c) of theactis allowed']
+23061;['appeal is dismissed']
+86853;['appeal isallowed']
+138866;['appeal is allowed']
+135899;['appeal is allowed']
+100960;['appeal is dismissed']
+124678;['appeal is allowed']
+141208;['confirm the determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+92858;['appeal were dismissed']
+142844;['confirm the validity of the removal order.']
+52137;['rad concurs with the rpd’s determination']
+147596;['appellants are not convention refugees']
+96909;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+131107;['appeal is allowed']
+52312;['appeal is dismissed']
+124742;['rad substitutes the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+76375;['appeal is allowed']
+63712;['appeal is allowed']
+101429;['appeal isallowed.the']
+102167;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+36136;['appellant’s appeal would be dismissed']
+59745;['appeal of inderjit kaur rana is dismissed']
+43395;['appeal is allowed']
+54764;['appeal is dismissed']
+97962;['appeal is dismissed']
+90700;['appeal isallowed']
+84906;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+69376;['appeal isallowed']
+37858;['appeal isallowed']
+27001;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+54247;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+95320;['appeal is allowed in law']
+105661;['appeal is allowed']
+131034;['appeal is allowed']
+74501;['appeal is allowed']
+103617;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'reject the claim']
+21435;['xxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+85851;['appeal isallowed']
+54192;['appeal is allowed']
+103819;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+61015;['not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+96717;['appeal is dismissed']
+76777;['dismiss the appeal']
+122661;['appeal is allowed']
+103055;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+100184;['appeal is allowed']
+91233;['appeal is allowed']
+48226;['appeal isallowed']
+96323;['nor a person in need of protection']
+62248;['negative']
+101258;['appellants are not “convention refugees”', 'or “persons in need of protection']
+132830;['appeal is dismissed']
+85927;['302 (c.a.']
+55951;['appeal is dismissed']
+92390;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+69351;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+111115;['appeal is   ']
+125034;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77849;['negative']
+83044;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+135144;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+80476;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+71704;['motion to cancel the stay', 'allow the appeal is granted']
+123013;['appeal is allowed']
+68282;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+92784;['appeal is dismissed']
+94674;['appeal isallowed']
+123301;['not confirm the decision', 'appeal is allowed']
+68991;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+105768;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+88977;['appeal is allowed']
+125141;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neitherconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+92389;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+60035;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+107671;['appeal is allowed']
+71643;['appeal is dismissed']
+13753;['appeal isdeclaredabandonedundersubsection\xa0168(1)of theimmigration and refugee protection']
+86402;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+95659;['appeal isallowedfor']
+53832;['appeal is dismissed']
+99547;['appeal is dismissed']
+89883;['appeal of timothy louie is dismissed']
+80276;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+93923;['appeal is dismissed']
+113580;['appeal is allowed']
+83540;['appeal is allowed']
+95616;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+124581;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+70935;['appeal was declared abandoned']
+67563;['appeal is allowed']
+139446;['appeal abandoned']
+132335;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+60934;['dismiss this appeal']
+90912;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+132304;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+140997;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151300;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+136691;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100716;['appeal is allowed']
+80379;['appeal isallowed']
+131742;['confirm the decision of the rpd']
+83826;['appeal is dismissed']
+123002;['appeal is dismissed']
+90691;['panel finds that the removal order is valid in law']
+109304;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'dismisses the appeal']
+141788;['appeal were allowed']
+122881;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+83157;['appeal is dismissed']
+47827;['appeals of all three appellants are dismissed']
+144558;['appeal is dismissed']
+92944;['appeal is dismissed']
+77296;['appeal is to proceed']
+77264;['appeal isallowed']
+95311;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+121250;['appeal is allowed']
+88252;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94173;['appeal is dismissed']
+125541;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89878;['appeal is dismissed']
+102106;['appeal is dismissed']
+90998;['appeal is dismissed']
+148773;['appeal is dismissed']
+99054;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98303;['negative']
+59377;['appeal of khuc sinh huynh is dismissed']
+100580;['panel rejects this claim']
+103023;['application for extension of time to file an appeal is dismissed']
+102569;['appeal is allowed']
+122807;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+129896;['appeal of the principal appellant']
+124955;['substitute my own decision that xxxx xxxx is a convention refugee']
+98295;['claim is rejected']
+82195;['appeal is dismissed']
+97503;['negative']
+90794;['302 (c.a.)']
+54307;['appeals of robert james kroupa and diana carol kroupa fail']
+151511;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+89463;['application for lack of jurisdiction is allowed']
+71346;['appeal is dismissed']
+100774;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+69546;['allow this appeal']
+74654;['regulation was enacted']
+52117;['appeal is dismissed']
+151474;['appeal is allowed']
+104068;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+31985;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+104452;['appeal isallowedand']
+100762;['appeal is dismissed']
+87431;['appeals are allowed']
+94578;['negative']
+89035;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+128426;['appeal is allowed']
+81374;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+102286;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+61054;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+140727;['appeals are dismissed']
+100426;['appeal isallowed']
+95101;['rad finds the rpd’s finding in this regard to be reasonable']
+102087;['appeal is dismissed']
+96155;['appeal is determined']
+72314;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+20006;['appeal is dismissed']
+81275;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+95185;['appeal is allowed']
+100215;['refugee protection claims are rejected']
+105780;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim']
+90557;['appeal isallowed']
+22706;['rad is of the opinion that the rpd rendered the correct decision']
+123114;['appeal is allowed']
+47343;['dismissal of the appeals']
+151387;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+122999;['appeal is allowed']
+101703;['appeal of maria roselvi platon is allowed']
+77816;['negative']
+141784;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate factors']
+90917;['appeal isallowed.the']
+125420;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+26491;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+94417;['appeal is dismissed']
+66590;['appeal is dismissed']
+151463;['appeal is allowed']
+112321;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+61017;['appeal is allowed']
+125624;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+122883;['appellant is a person in need of protection']
+107180;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+97930;['appeal of jian qiang wen is dismissed']
+81225;['appeals are dismissed']
+87475;['appeal is determined to be']
+36948;['appeal is allowed']
+67695;['appeal of harsimran singh brar is dismissed']
+32163;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+141226;['appeal is allowed']
+151806;['appeal is dismissed']
+75982;['appeal is dismissed']
+49063;['appeal is dismissed']
+124054;['appeal is allowed']
+97033;['302 (c.a.']
+151918;['appeal is dismissed']
+149019;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+120716;['appeal is allowed']
+75430;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142723;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+64276;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+124553;['dismiss the appeal']
+128909;['child was neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91339;['appeal is dismissed']
+38841;['appeal is allowed']
+95119;['appeal is not granted']
+47388;['appeal is allowed']
+47824;['appeal isallowed']
+116764;['appeal is dismissed']
+100362;['xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+92392;['appeal is allowed.the']
+97120;['appeal is allowed']
+88031;['appeal is allowed']
+89321;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+49238;['appeal is allowed.the']
+69326;['appeal isallowed']
+96986;['appeal should be allowed']
+11462;['appeal is dismissed']
+151849;['appeal is dismissed']
+99514;['appeal is allowed']
+45160;['appeal is allowed']
+93698;['determination of the rpd is set aside']
+101882;['appeal is allowed']
+42171;['appeal isallowed']
+63009;['appeal is allowed']
+125447;['appeal is allowed']
+43728;['appeal is allowed']
+62718;['allows the appeal']
+101764;['appeal isallowed']
+74559;['appeal is terminated']
+100246;['appeal isallowed']
+71150;['appeal is dismissed']
+21103;['appeal is dismissed']
+151487;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+24492;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97599;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+24196;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+96282;['or a “person in need of protection']
+36188;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+95044;['appeal is terminated']
+110291;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+76617;['appeal is dismissed']
+82259;['appeal should be dismissed']
+82897;['appeal is dismissed']
+92930;['appeal isallowedand']
+64276;['appeal isallowed']
+125095;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+100583;['panel therefore rejects these claims']
+66255;['appeal is allowed']
+87113;['appeal is allowed']
+125628;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+61438;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+95974;['rad confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+148645;['appeal is allowed']
+99291;['appeal is dismissed']
+81008;['appeal is allowed']
+82370;['appeal is dismissed']
+82019;['appeal filed byaurèle\xa0morinis dismissed asres judicata']
+49704;['appeal is dismissed']
+76152;['negative']
+94581;['claimant is neither a convention refugee']
+90796;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94626;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+135177;['appeal is allowed']
+76530;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+95518;['appeal is allowed']
+56748;['nor their sponsor']
+57520;['jurisprudence confirms this interpretation']
+146612;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+57311;['not a convention refugee']
+49719;['appeal is moot']
+76172;['302 (c.a.']
+103498;['rad finds the rpd decision must be set aside']
+82858;['appeal is governed by theact']
+76836;['removal order is set aside']
+151105;['appeal is dismissed']
+99857;['appeal is allowed.section']
+78336;['appeal of is hamid khan hakam penda dismissed']
+57827;['appeal in respect to abiodun oladuni oletubo is dismissed']
+60034;['dismiss the application']
+87827;['appeal is abandoned']
+63892;['appeal is allowed']
+101662;['appeal is dismissed']
+136686;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+96616;['appeal of francisco chispas is dismissed']
+79946;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+123934;['appeal is allowed']
+31426;['appeal of the first application refusal']
+55188;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+62475;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83716;['appeal is allowed']
+27463;['appeal would be dismissed']
+90677;['appeal is allowed']
+42223;['dismiss the appeal']
+54805;['rad concurs with the rpd’s decision regarding this matter']
+80798;['appeal is allowed']
+114430;['302 (c.a.']
+129915;['appeal is allowed']
+127734;"[""visa officer's determination is valid in law""]"
+80660;['negative']
+143907;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+71609;['appeal merits special relief']
+94257;['appeal is dismissed']
+124172;['neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+79033;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+28069;['appeal is dismissed']
+75572;['decision of the visa office is legally valid']
+69126;['appeal is allowed']
+95101;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109006;['appeals are dismissed']
+61432;['appeal is allowed.the', 'appeal is allowed']
+100167;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+96816;['not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+104978;['appeal is allowed']
+130858;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+72812;['appeal is allowed']
+55155;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+81380;['negative']
+97244;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+53826;['appeal is terminated']
+135119;['appeal is allowed']
+123664;['appeal is dismissed']
+64607;['appeal isallowed']
+95374;['allows the minister’s application to dismiss the appeal']
+95638;['theappeal is allowed']
+89973;['appeal be allowed']
+95934;['appeal is dismissed']
+77272;['appeal is dismissed']
+36098;['appellant is not a permanent resident']
+92037;['302 (c.a.)']
+113631;['appeal is allowed']
+136669;['appeal is allowed']
+110267;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+28016;['appeal is allowed']
+56926;['appeal is dismissed']
+88017;['declare his claim to be abandoned']
+100768;['appeal is allowed']
+40295;['appeal is dismissed']
+81079;['appeal is dismissed']
+151503;['appeal is dismissed']
+46510;['appeal is allowed']
+30484;['appeal is allowed']
+148487;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+133388;['appeal is dismissed']
+69384;['appeal is dismissed']
+144774;['claimant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+122225;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+74866;['appeal is allowed']
+100610;['appeal is allowed']
+67599;['appeal isallowed']
+63866;['appeal is therefore terminated']
+145880;['302 (c.a.']
+33077;['appeal is dismissed']
+63196;['appeal is dismissed']
+77950;['appeal is dismissed']
+90991;['appeal is dismissed']
+124579;['dismiss the appeal']
+68147;['appeal is allowed']
+77118;['dismiss an appeal']
+54832;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+142975;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+55203;['reject the claim for refugee protection']
+93925;['appeal is allowed']
+111363;['appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of canada’s protection', 'confirms the determination of the refugee protection division']
+95099;['claim is rejected']
+75904;['appeal is dismissed']
+88337;['appeal is dismissed']
+99220;['application is denied']
+140811;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+73051;['appeal is allowed']
+76855;['appeal isdismissed.']
+76440;['appeal is dismissed']
+88514;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+129232;['appeal is allowed']
+93117;['appeal is allowed']
+84823;['appeal isallowed.the']
+68732;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74730;['appeal is dismissed']
+132324;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+77662;['appeal is dismissed']
+104280;['appeal is dismissed']
+146123;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+113745;['appeal is allowed']
+77836;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+76016;['appeal is allowed']
+77215;['removal order is set aside']
+127405;['appeal is dismissed']
+126392;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143176;['neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+92785;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+128263;['appeal is denied']
+82702;['appeal isallowed']
+86204;['appeal isallowed.the']
+80134;['appeal isallowed']
+63227;['dismiss the appeal']
+92515;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77888;['appeal is allowed']
+90071;['negative']
+97118;['stay is cancelled, or terminated', 'appeal is allowed']
+143518;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+143157;['appeal is allowed']
+69152;['appeal is allowed']
+102691;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+98518;['appeal is terminated']
+116766;['appeal is allowed.the']
+34097;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+130011;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+111338;['appeal is dismissed']
+97902;['appeal is allowed']
+98685;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+49634;['appeal is allowed']
+90936;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'ms. xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+71153;['dismiss the appeal']
+145104;['302 (c.a.']
+94445;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52149;['neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+140244;['302 (c.a.']
+77685;['appeal is allowed']
+84715;['appeal beallowed']
+124602;['claim for protection is dismissed']
+68190;['appeal of howard li is dismissed']
+124267;['appeal is allowed']
+128189;['appeal is dismissed']
+84671;['appeal is dismissed']
+131047;['dismiss the appeal']
+86838;['appeal is allowed']
+128387;['appeal should be dismissed']
+73187;['appellant has not lost her']
+95884;['rad finds that there is no basis']
+98037;['refugee protection division rejects the claim of xxxx xxx xxxx xxxxx for refugee protection']
+17141;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+20010;['appeal of timotea lacsamana estandarte is dismissed']
+77570;['appeal is allowed']
+77560;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+64305;['appeal of delaram farhadian is allowed']
+129406;['confirm the rpd’s negative determination']
+93079;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+95071;['appeal is allowed']
+67653;['allow his appeal.']
+71725;['dismiss this appeal']
+62435;['negative']
+92988;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+108756;['appeal is allowed']
+57299;['decision of the visa officer is not well-founded in law']
+125040;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+59053;['appeal is allowed']
+8341;['appeal is dismissed']
+73268;['allows this appeal']
+106799;['appeal is dismissed']
+91187;['appeal is dismissed']
+46053;['appeal is dismissed']
+88067;['appeal was not allowed']
+72574;['appeal isallowed']
+100978;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+100574;['appeal is terminated']
+90768;['appeal is allowed']
+69558;['appeal should be allowed']
+99431;['claimant to not be a convention refugee', 'claim is rejected']
+108806;['rad does not find the respondent to be a convention refugee, or a person in need of protection']
+125520;['appeal is allowed']
+60310;['appeal is dismissed']
+56096;['xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+124921;['appeal is allowed']
+91315;['appeal isallowed']
+89334;['appeal is allowed']
+132755;['claimants are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+105827;['appeal is dismissed']
+122533;['substitutes its determination that the appellant']
+76523;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+143896;['appeal is dismissed']
+71153;['appeal is allowed']
+64206;['application to re- open the appeal is denied']
+91619;['appeal is allowed.the']
+55179;['appeal of shaza abdel wahal ahmed el kourashy is dismissed']
+50500;['appeal is dismissed']
+142484;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144464;['appeal is allowed']
+123712;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+89483;['302 (c.a.']
+76899;['declare the appealabandoned.']
+94512;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+84361;['appeal is allowed']
+123726;['appeal is dismissed']
+82050;['allow the appeal']
+126398;['uphold the rpd’s finding']
+57922;['appeal is dismissed']
+12199;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+60059;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+100165;['302 (c.a.']
+76188;['appeal is dismissed']
+83147;['application herein is allowed']
+22994;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+46540;['iad does not have jurisdiction']
+85218;['appeal is terminated']
+60925;['appeal is dismissed']
+84361;['appeal isallowed']
+46998;['appeal is dismissed']
+37412;['appeal were dismissed']
+99823;['appeal is dismissed']
+72851;['appeal must be dismissed']
+86846;['appeal is terminated']
+67411;['appeal is dismissed']
+81202;['appeal must be dismissed']
+94344;['appeal is allowed']
+64033;['appeal is dismissed']
+60945;['appeal is not related to any of the above-mentioned provisions']
+83019;['allows the appeal in law']
+37084;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+92605;['not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+89850;['negative']
+84210;['appeal is allowed']
+109030;['appeal was declared abandoned']
+134395;['appeals are based']
+144756;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+67191;['appeal isallowed']
+72715;['appeals are dismissed']
+45859;['appeal isallowed']
+88508;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+85965;['appeal is allowed']
+50648;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+59806;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+81241;['appeal were dismissed']
+122703;['appeal is allowed']
+54560;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+43719;['appeal is allowed']
+37852;['appeal is allowed']
+83721;['appeal isallowed']
+82371;['appeal is dismissed']
+145323;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+67726;['appeal is dismissed']
+102562;['appeal is allowed']
+92796;['appeal is dismissed']
+54223;['application to reopen the removal order appeal is allowed']
+95312;['appeal isallowed']
+129997;['appeal must be rejected']
+76415;['appeal is allowed']
+146844;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+82893;['appeal is allowed']
+49577;['application to dismiss the appeal is allowed']
+125127;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+96973;['appeal isallowed.the']
+100110;"[""rad sets aside the rpd's determination"", 'substitutes its own determination']"
+148713;['claim is rejected']
+23033;['appeal is dismissed']
+93122;['appeal is terminated']
+61420;['appeal is dismissed']
+144023;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+88019;['302 (c.a.']
+101788;['appeal is dismissed']
+140864;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+150671;['302 (c.a.']
+94562;['appeal is allowed']
+93212;['favourable decision is issued to ms. huang and her children.']
+84781;['rpd’s determination must be set aside']
+60464;['appeal isallowed']
+100362;['302 (c.a.)']
+114347;['appeals are dismissed']
+54798;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+37428;['appeals are dismissed']
+107902;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128569;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69177;['appeal is dismissed']
+88517;['thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+45411;['appeal of habibe ademi is dismissed']
+34157;['appeal were dismissed']
+97939;['appeal is allowed']
+49566;['appeal is dismissed']
+146829;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+101269;['appeal is allowed']
+79473;['appeal is dismissed']
+76832;['appeal isallowed']
+72704;['appeal is allowed']
+74514;['dismiss the appeal']
+68731;['appeal of chien hung bart wu is dismissed']
+84761;['appeal isallowed']
+94588;['appeal of pei-wen wang is allowed']
+54701;['appeal is dismissed']
+107659;['appeal is dismissed']
+101047;['appeal is allowed']
+89503;['appeal is allowed']
+54749;['appeal of hassen amari is dismissed', 'appeals of fatima amari and asma amari are allowed']
+70011;['appeal is terminated']
+47155;['appeal is dismissed']
+61375;['appeal be dismissed']
+99282;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83035;['appeal is allowed']
+62703;['appeal isallowed']
+75449;['appeal is dismissed']
+130000;['appeal is dismissed']
+87995;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44839;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+97459;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+29718;['appeal is dismissed']
+103018;['application to reopen the appeal is dismissed', 'dismissing the rad appeal']
+76896;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+122263;['appeal is allowed']
+66259;['appeal of xiang qi is dismissed']
+56621;['allow the appeal and refer the matter back to the rpd']
+103753;['appeal is dismissed']
+77445;['appeal is allowed']
+105757;['rad finds that the respondents are convention refugees']
+107690;['appeal be dismissed']
+152018;['rad cannot confirm the determination of the rpd', 'nor set aside the rpd determination', 'substitute a determination']
+84133;['appeal isallowed']
+99950;['appeal is allowed']
+136679;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90605;['departure order is set aside', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+124727;['appeal is allowed']
+84859;['appeal isallowed']
+147624;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee and a person in need of protection']
+69652;['appeal is allowed']
+61454;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+97641;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+15581;['appeal of the second order is also dismissed']
+128282;['appeal is dismissedfor']
+123367;['panel confirms the decision of the rpd']
+100895;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+61635;['negative']
+110716;['rpd’s decision to reject the appellants’ refugee claims']
+144399;['302 (c.a.']
+73195;['appeal is allowed']
+102962;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees, nor persons in need of canada’s protection']
+105425;['appeal is allowed']
+140636;['officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+107831;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107941;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+125403;['rad allows the appeal of the principal appellant']
+72005;['appeal is dismissed']
+59552;['appeal is dismissed']
+100618;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+52363;['appeal is allowed']
+87844;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+143473;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50750;['appeal isallowed']
+96804;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+104082;['appeal is dismissed']
+65694;['appeal isallowed']
+95884;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94987;['dismiss the appeal']
+87391;['appeal isallowed']
+116809;['appellants are neither refugees, nor persons in need of protection']
+102925;['appeal is allowed']
+77670;['appeal isallowed']
+138815;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedundersection']
+116738;['appeal is allowed']
+84358;['appeal is dismissed']
+89804;['appeal is terminated']
+147880;['appeal isdismissed']
+69992;['appeal isallowed']
+77273;['appeal is allowed']
+131144;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+151567;['appeal is dismissed']
+143282;['rad rejects the appellant’s argument']
+132303;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+8299;['appeal is dismissed']
+60812;['appeal beallowedand']
+116817;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+67609;['applicants are not members of the family class']
+57549;['appeal of rahman saghir is dismissed']
+102467;['appeal is dismissed']
+67741;['tribunal dismisses this appeal in law']
+67689;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+97291;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+47341;['appeal to fail']
+90600;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102677;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+97257;['neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+31936;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+96728;['appeal is allowed']
+26490;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+134167;['theappeal is allowed']
+108769;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+71590;['appeal is allowed']
+70640;['appeal is allowed']
+99745;['appeal will not be reopened']
+30483;['appeal is allowed.the']
+80985;['dismissing an appeal']
+58547;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+82454;['declare this appeal abandoned']
+148756;['appeal is dismissed']
+68322;['allow this appeal']
+104284;['appeal of mohammad reza hajimohammadibaroogh is allowed']
+98832;['appeal is allowed']
+145844;['appeal is allowed']
+62435;['claimant not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+111008;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+140725;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+141226;['302 (c.a.']
+122658;['rad finds that it did']
+57944;['appeal is allowed']
+124363;['appeal is allowed']
+81613;['appeal is dismissed']
+60885;['appeal isallowed']
+15014;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a claim for refugee protection']
+96187;['appeal is dismissed']
+73255;['appeal is allowed']
+50474;['appeal of the appellant is dismissed']
+80721;['claim is rejected']
+67660;['appeal re-opened']
+77877;['appeal is allowed']
+100850;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims for refugee protection']
+88321;['appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57533;['appeal is dismissed']
+50648;['removal order is set aside']
+94433;['appeal is dismissed']
+133704;['302 (c.a.']
+94711;['appeals are dismissed']
+91667;['appeal of wilben olibrice is dismissed']
+132771;['appeal is allowed']
+104437;['appeal is dismissed']
+29634;['appeal be dismissed']
+60475;['appeal is terminated']
+100228;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+99968;['appeal is dismissed']
+123464;['appeal must be dismissed']
+92734;['appeal isallowed.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+33238;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+80715;['appeal is allowed']
+56102;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+89398;['appeals of zareena bagum, ahsan riaz and husain riaz are allowed']
+152023;['decision of the rpd is wrong']
+39038;['appeal is allowed']
+123797;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+42383;['appeal is dismissed']
+76311;['appeal isallowed']
+97824;['negative']
+95103;['they are not convention refugees']
+74632;['allows the appeal', 'appeal is allowed']
+52080;['appeal is determined']
+72769;['appeal isallowed']
+106676;['appeal is allowed']
+62883;['not a person in need of protection']
+105560;['allow the present appeal']
+54818;['302 (c.a.']
+60508;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+105282;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not “convention refugees”']
+84654;['appeal is terminated']
+79902;['appeal is terminated']
+123832;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+104732;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+142995;['appeal is allowed']
+95882;['appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+128343;['appeal is dismissed']
+94131;['appeal is allowed']
+101716;['appeal is allowed']
+77048;['appeal is allowed']
+125475;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100106;['appeal is dismissed']
+124991;['allow the appeal and', 'substitute a decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+139447;['determination is valid in law']
+142896;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+84054;['appeal is dismissed']
+81596;['removal order is set aside']
+136664;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+26957;['xxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+123858;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101496;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+96975;['302 (c.a.']
+75836;['sufficient h&c factors']
+46075;['appeal is allowed']
+74182;['appeal is dismissed', 'rpd’s decision is confirmed']
+107639;['appeal is allowed']
+23063;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+113292;['appeal is allowed']
+87427;['appeal is terminated']
+17979;['dismiss the appeal']
+130977;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+144046;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57901;['appeal is allowed']
+143499;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+62628;['appeal isallowed']
+110566;['appeal is dismissed']
+84059;['appeal is dismissed']
+88499;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74135;['appeal is dismissed']
+107250;['not usurp the finding that the panel must make']
+92898;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+101679;['appeal is dismissed']
+14689;['appeal is allowed in law']
+71175;['appeal is allowed']
+101505;['appeal isallowed']
+136698;['rad dismisses the appeal']
+49391;['appeal is allowed']
+61474;['appeal is allowed']
+66241;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+129696;['appeal was discontinued']
+87449;['appeal isallowed']
+71484;['appeal is dismissed']
+90847;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+59770;['appeals are allowed']
+87712;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+103510;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104460;['appeal were dismissed']
+113271;['appeal be dismissed']
+116795;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99549;['appeal is abandoned']
+123666;['appeal is allowed']
+123620;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+124447;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151485;['appeal is allowed']
+93690;['1256, 1 f.c.']
+104459;['appeal is allowed']
+138845;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+69347;['appeal isallowed']
+101536;['appeal is allowed']
+55205;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+100381;['appeal isallowed']
+80996;['appeal is allowed']
+71464;['appeal is allowed']
+141054;['appeal is dismissed']
+134305;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+141676;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+47569;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+78695;['appeal of mr. anisur rahman is hereby dismissed']
+27293;['appeal isallowed']
+89378;['appeal is dismissed']
+100673;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+46025;['appeal isallowed']
+123618;['substitute a decision thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither convention refugee nor person in need of protection']
+96755;['appeal isdeterminedto be abandoned']
+100784;['appeal was dismissed']
+100294;['appeal is dismissed']
+60037;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is she a person in need of protection', 'rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+141226;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+51766;['appeal isallowed']
+103520;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+96804;['appellant is a convention refugee', 'accept his claim for refugee protection']
+113538;['appeal is dismissed']
+122115;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+131513;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+21328;['you are not a convention refugee']
+71447;['appeal is allowed']
+74576;['appeal is dismissed']
+107599;['appeal is allowed']
+125455;['dismiss the appeal', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+70365;['appeal is dismissed']
+113535;['appeal is allowed']
+122702;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'are neither a refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+79475;['appeal is dismissed']
+113534;['appeal is dismissed']
+21324;['concur with the decision and the reasons provided by my colleague']
+31420;['departure orders are set aside']
+116349;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+67663;['appeal is dismissed']
+148600;['appeal is allowed']
+100885;['panel therefore rejects his claim']
+74539;['appeal be allowed']
+80990;['appeal is decided in chambers']
+86326;['appeal isallowed']
+141622;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102128;['appeal is dismissed']
+75921;['appeal is dismissed']
+44003;['appeal is allowed']
+72026;['appeal is dismissed']
+68535;['appeal is terminated[emphasis']
+29697;['appeal of gorreth wavamuno is dismissed']
+111288;['appeal is dismissed']
+26984;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+56315;['appeal is dismissed']
+13681;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+90855;['appeal is dismissed']
+66255;['decision of the immigration division is set aside']
+101434;['302 (c.a.)']
+139869;['negative decision and reasons for decision']
+58126;['appeal is terminated']
+49742;['application is allowed']
+123392;['appeal is allowed']
+108788;['rad sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+145853;['appeal abandoned.section']
+80371;['appeal is allowed']
+79629;['appeal is dismissed']
+77572;['appeal isallowed']
+121867;['confirm the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+97893;['negative']
+95811;['appeal is allowed']
+125140;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64838;['appeal of yue wang is dismissed']
+89236;['appeal was dismissed']
+58110;['dismissal of the present appeal']
+60982;['appeal is dismissed']
+90565;['appeal must be dismissed']
+124625;['appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+76723;['appeal is allowed']
+60014;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'reject her claim']
+87016;['appeal is dismissed']
+74099;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+136672;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121881;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+101872;['appeal is dismissed']
+98981;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+76040;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+132277;['302 (c.a.']
+122772;['appeal is allowed']
+69451;['appeal is allowed']
+57514;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+69554;['appeal is allowed']
+71084;['refugee protection division rejects these claims for protection']
+92943;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+72890;['appeal is allowed']
+86009;['appeal is accordingly allowed']
+78774;['orders your departure fromcanada.']
+131703;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+153282;['rad finds that the p.a.']
+68407;['appeal is allowed']
+105698;['dismissing an appeal']
+31426;['appeal is dismissed']
+54255;['adjudicator is not binding on an immigration officer or a visa officer']
+35925;['appeal is declared abandoned']
+46290;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+76656;['appeal is allowed']
+55107;['appeal is allowed']
+111186;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor a persons in need of protection']
+100133;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+99660;['determination is valid in law']
+101660;['appeal is allowed']
+107694;['appeal isallowed.the']
+88062;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision was valid in law']
+21381;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+74573;['302 (c.a.']
+78652;['appeal must fail']
+106757;['appeal is dismissed']
+100482;['dismissing the appeal']
+96279;['negative']
+99571;['appeal is allowed']
+61895;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+100263;['refugee protection definitions are forward-looking']
+123404;['appeal is also denied']
+100098;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93869;"['appeal will be dismissed;nodecision']"
+131023;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither convention refugees']
+96294;['appeal isallowed']
+72007;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+26746;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+96093;['claimants are convention refugees']
+147002;['appeal is dismissed']
+125456;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+69094;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101714;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+102159;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+76087;['appeal abandoned']
+108069;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s determination of the appellant’s claim']
+95954;['appeal is dismissed']
+90441;['appeal was abandoned']
+83871;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+127344;['appeal is allowed']
+69071;['appeals are dismissed']
+31431;['dismiss this appeal']
+101718;['appeal is allowed']
+121944;['appeal is dismissed']
+78647;['appeal must be dismissed']
+50252;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+107060;['appeal isdismissed.']
+51676;['appeal is allowed']
+80064;['nor a risk of cruel and unusual treatment or punishment']
+69996;['appeal allowed']
+82387;['iad dismisses the present appeal']
+72668;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+68148;['appeal is dismissed']
+80785;['appeal is allowed']
+72697;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+90069;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83159;['appeal must be dismissed']
+102118;['appeal is allowed.the']
+74629;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+146444;['rad confirms   the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+92511;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+87821;['appeal is dismissed']
+102799;['appeal is allowed']
+60470;['appeal isallowed.the']
+108747;['rad allows these appeals']
+69606;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+89780;['claim is rejected']
+100968;['302 (c.a.']
+129403;['appeal is allowed']
+125506;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107648;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+52094;['appeal abandoned']
+54813;['rad cannot confirm the rpd decision, cannot substitute its own determination']
+74094;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+93698;['rad substitutes its own determination', 'appellants are convention refugees']
+114314;['302 (c.a.']
+117185;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+151401;['appeal is allowed']
+122947;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+54755;['appeal is allowed']
+94289;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95979;['rad finds the rpd’s finding in this regard not to be reasonable']
+49225;['appeal is allowed']
+121211;['substitute my own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+97308;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57515;['dismisses the appeal for lack of jurisdiction']
+131157;['appeal isallowed']
+83040;['appeal is allowed.the']
+115213;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96982;['302 (c.a.']
+108669;['302 (c.a.']
+140280;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+49230;['appeal is dismissed']
+40662;['appeal is allowed']
+54274;['appeal is dismissed']
+69373;['appeal is dismissed']
+140631;['appeal is dismissed']
+77667;['appeal isallowed']
+60039;['claimant is determined to be neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101686;['appeal is allowed']
+123960;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant, xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+91617;['appeal is dismissed']
+86850;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+96897;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+82396;['appeal is dismissed']
+92839;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+63192;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+102027;['immigration appeal division does not have jurisdiction to hear his appeal']
+107944;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143238;['appeal is allowed']
+30535;['appeal is allowed']
+21420;['convention refugee determination division', 'xxxxx xxxxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+86378;['appeal is dismissed']
+98840;['appeal is allowed']
+52769;['appeal is dismissed']
+66256;['appeal is terminated']
+82040;['appeal is terminated']
+107934;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+36466;['allow the appeal']
+57098;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+97238;['appeal is allowed']
+132426;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68716;['appeal is dismissed']
+57931;['appeal is allowed']
+96215;['appeal of thai xuan phan isdismissed.']
+97970;['appeal is allowed']
+124796;['declare xxxx xxxx inadmissible']
+150932;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109019;['appeal is dismissed']
+78140;['refugee protection division rejects this claim for refugee protection']
+132654;['appellant is not a “convention refugee”']
+127406;['appeal is dismissed']
+22382;['appeal is dismissed']
+95409;['appeal is allowed']
+97840;['claimant in this case is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94383;['appeal is allowed']
+56755;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+124116;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107849;['claim is therefore rejected']
+69598;['appeal isallowed']
+96369;['appeal is allowed.the']
+85841;['negative']
+57571;['appeal of eugene mensah is dismissed']
+143167;['application to reopen the appeal is allowed']
+95528;['dismiss the appeal']
+64445;['…]\xa0»']
+80553;['appeal isallowed']
+143630;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69344;['appeal is allowed']
+60011;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+131105;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “refugee”']
+42567;['appeal is also dismissed']
+71102;['appeal is allowed']
+111015;['rad disagrees']
+46518;['appeal is allowed']
+67254;['sufficient compassionate and humanitarian considerations']
+56957;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+134316;['panel therefore dismisses the appeal']
+140727;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+64124;['dismiss theappeal.']
+123976;['appeal is dismissed', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+52921;['appeal of the appellant is allowed']
+77864;['claim is rejected']
+90006;['appeal is terminated']
+151880;['appellants are neither a convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+59372;['allow the appeal']
+105376;['appeal is dismissed']
+90253;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101852;['allow the appeal']
+47753;['appeal was mounted']
+90449;['irb – id decision: x vs canada (minister of public safety and emergency preparedness']
+52518;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+151477;['appeal is dismissed']
+114310;['dismiss the appeal']
+80665;['reject her claim']
+113581;['appeal is dismissed']
+95005;['motion is allowed']
+101706;['removal order is cancelled', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+135491;['claimant is excluded from refugee protection']
+99406;['appeal isallowed']
+131716;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+28095;['appeal should be dismissed']
+112400;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34611;['appeal is dismissed']
+87137;['visa officer refusal is upheld']
+77800;['reject these claims to refugee protection', 'claimants are not convention refugees and not persons in need of protection']
+13951;['appeal is dismissed']
+72069;['appeal isallowed']
+116186;['appeal is allowed']
+146953;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+42287;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71174;['appeal of sunil kishor srivastava is dismissed']
+91116;['appeal is allowed']
+121466;['appeal is dismissed']
+99028;['claimants are not in need of protection']
+86892;['dismissing the appeal']
+99396;['claim is rejected']
+89340;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+53874;['appeal is allowed']
+95661;['appeal isallowed']
+101861;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+79966;['negative']
+62452;['rad finds that the principal appellant’s fears of the nis']
+109015;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+151469;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+71177;['appeals are allowed.the']
+131077;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellantxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96892;['application is dismissed']
+90325;['claimant is not the convention refugee']
+44087;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+57538;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+83954;['appeal is allowed']
+54815;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+60990;['appeal is allowed']
+88897;['dismiss the case for lack of jurisdiction']
+28434;['appeal is allowed']
+100767;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+84852;['appeal isallowed']
+94841;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+73890;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim']
+63003;['appeal is dismissed']
+90603;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94646;['motion is allowed']
+21315;['you are not a convention refugee']
+77280;['appeal is terminated']
+111170;['appeal isdismissed.']
+61635;['the claim fails']
+82892;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+88447;['panel rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+82052;['appeal is allowed']
+93151;['appeal isallowed']
+98380;['302 (c.a.)']
+101665;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+146883;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+91563;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+129123;['appeal is allowed']
+69595;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+124946;['appeal is allowed']
+149276;['appeal is dismissed']
+98497;['appeal is terminated']
+42225;['appeal is allowed']
+52629;"['not a ""convention refugee']"
+109692;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision will not stand']
+79931;['claimantis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+36248;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+83015;['appeal is allowed']
+100450;['dismiss the appeal']
+79605;['appeal is allowed']
+144553;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+146099;['appeal is allowed']
+23096;['appeals are dismissed']
+114313;['substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+95538;['appeal isallowed']
+131161;['appeal is dismissed']
+124158;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+67505;['appeal isallowed']
+98681;['appeal is dismissed']
+97673;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'their claims are therefore rejected']
+99731;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+115212;['appeal is dismissed']
+91306;['appeal is allowed']
+26906;"['claimant would be a ""convention refugee']"
+102142;['appeals are dismissed.\\']
+77316;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+59757;['appeal is allowed', 'visa officer’s decision to refuse the visa is set aside']
+27518;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+96545;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+102534;['appeals are allowed']
+69115;['dismiss the appeal']
+110277;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+84205;['appeal abandoned']
+76140;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+80189;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+98370;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+68165;['appeal of barham dev goshal is allowed in law']
+76387;['appeal of the appellant is dismissed']
+99039;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146016;['claimant to be a convention refugee']
+110559;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+75577;['appeal is dismissed']
+139676;['appeal was dismissed']
+35815;['appeal is dismissed']
+56633;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a “convention refugee”']
+72067;['appeal is allowed']
+49517;['appeal is dismissed']
+58125;['allow the appeal']
+45158;['appeal of varinder singh mann is dismissed']
+132416;['appeal ofmaria victoria infante santos is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse the permanent resident visas is set aside']
+50760;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+130758;['appeal is not allowed']
+116131;['insufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+108833;['appeal is dismissed']
+122905;['substitute my determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+138826;['appeal is allowed']
+92841;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+87369;['rad sets aside the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+136680;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+66324;['appeals should be dismissed']
+83080;['appeal is allowed']
+75953;['dismiss the appeal']
+123534;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+143925;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+13770;['appeal was dismissed']
+98280;['appeal is allowed']
+101523;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+104847;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedundersection']
+35878;['dismiss the appeal']
+97559;['appeal is allowed']
+115282;['theappealis dismissed']
+98997;['negative']
+63889;['appeal originally brought by the respondent is dismissed']
+138808;['appeal should be dismissed']
+92154;['appeal is dismissed']
+72918;['appeal is allowed']
+19116;['appeals are dismissed']
+120795;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79933;['panel rejects the claims ofxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx']
+76693;['appeal is dismissed']
+145041;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+84155;['appeal is terminated']
+81032;['allow this appeal']
+80726;['negative', 'positive']
+94351;['appeal is determined']
+69097;['appeal is allowed in law']
+13330;['appeal is allowed']
+54705;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+81930;['appeal is dismissed']
+95822;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+123473;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+109143;['claim is rejected']
+99257;['negative']
+50470;['are neither refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+135889;['is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+115219;['allow the appeal and refer the matter back to the rpd']
+70387;['appeal is dismissed']
+59676;['dismiss the appeal']
+131195;['appeal is dismissed']
+88069;['regulation is notutltra viresthe']
+101258;['rad rejects the minor appellant’s refugee protection claim']
+97349;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+138871;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+122927;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+91764;['application is accordingly dismissed']
+123037;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107493;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd']
+122913;['appeal is allowed']
+120718;['rpd’s decision is therefore confirmed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+105774;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+124365;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+112392;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+99538;['appeal is allowed']
+116832;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69993;['appeals are allowed']
+47123;['panel dismisses the appeal']
+72824;['appeal is allowed']
+84428;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+71279;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+34705;['appeal is dismissed']
+93202;['appeal is terminated']
+100884;['board therefore accepts his claim']
+13684;['appeal were dismissed']
+125626;['appeal is allowed']
+69248;['appeal is allowed']
+66202;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+90923;['appeal is dismissed']
+81819;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+95191;['appeal must fail']
+90601;['appeal of ping ren is dismissed']
+73881;['appeal is dismissed']
+16829;['appeal is dismissed']
+120994;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+98343;['appeal is allowed']
+90033;['application to re-open the appeal is denied']
+77108;['appeal cannot be allowed']
+35036;['appeal is allowed']
+99819;['court’s decree is not an immigration determination']
+58188;['appeal is terminated']
+54562;['appeal isallowed']
+106795;['appeal is allowed']
+28060;['appeal of mohammed moeeduddin ahmed is dismissed']
+149007;['appeal is allowed']
+61402;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+71613;['appeal is dismissed']
+50523;['dismisses the appeal', 'allows the appeal of the appellant son']
+143543;['rpd decision is correct']
+104066;['appeal is allowed']
+27003;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+69591;['appeal isallowed']
+84494;['appeal is dismissed']
+94280;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees” nor “persons in need of protection']
+135457;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+111042;['302 (c.a.']
+106301;['appeal is dismissed']
+89222;['302 (c.a.']
+94055;['appeal isallowed.the']
+130962;['nor a person in need of protection']
+99835;['minister’s application is allowed']
+92485;['appeal is dismissed']
+46522;['302 (c.a.']
+83373;['appeal is allowed']
+96178;['appeals are dismissed']
+123777;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “refugee”', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+93684;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+26680;['appeal is obviously dismissed']
+138845;['removal order is set aside']
+94525;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada']
+62439;['appeal is allowed']
+52320;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+5601;['application to reopen is dismissed']
+100803;['appeal is allowed']
+62467;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+88416;['refugee protection division rejects her claim']
+38837;['appeal were dismissed']
+29218;['appeal is denied']
+89153;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+56796;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+128394;['appeal of abiodun adebisi ogunbanwo is dismissed']
+118140;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+53855;['appeal is also allowed']
+95309;['appeal is dismissed']
+105880;['reject this']
+71577;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+116833;['appellant is neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+28082;['appeal is allowed']
+100967;['appeal is allowed']
+90950;['rad has found that the rpd decision stands on the merit of state protection']
+67365;['appeal isallowed']
+76398;['appeal isallowed']
+91346;['adopts her reasons']
+102046;['appeal dismissed']
+50528;['appeal is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+108766;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd']
+78721;['appeal is allowed']
+47741;['allow his refugee protection claim']
+13697;['allow the appeals']
+89841;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+99829;['appeal is dismissed.the']
+83499;['appeal is thereforedismissed.']
+113609;['appeal is allowed']
+100451;['nor a “person in need of protection']
+47308;['appeal is allowed']
+49225;['appeal isallowed']
+71618;['appeal isallowed']
+130701;['appeal is allowed']
+90915;['appeal isallowed']
+129220;['appeal is terminated']
+89919;['appeal is allowed']
+31996;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+85754;['appeal is allowed']
+64850;['appeal is allowed']
+94576;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+36600;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+131218;['appeal is allowed']
+47187;['appeals of chaung gyu park and hyang suk hwang park have been withdrawn']
+130960;['appeal is dismissed']
+89303;['neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+44182;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+108195;['appeal is dismissed']
+99975;['appeal is dismissed']
+125221;['appellant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+27469;['appeal is dismissed']
+95464;['appeal is dismissed']
+94207;['appeal isallowed']
+95626;['appeals of bing sen zhang and hui juan yang are dismissed']
+111355;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83509;['appeal is denied']
+89213;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+122836;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+137448;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that this appellant is a convention refugee']
+120852;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+152904;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+108254;['rad cannot confirm the rpd’s decision', 'not substitute its own determination']
+89823;['appeal is allowed']
+124693;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60421;['appeal is dismissed']
+52614;['claimant was excluded from the definition of convention refugee']
+61012;['302 (c.a.']
+78056;['appeal isallowed']
+43112;['1256,  1 f.c.']
+36597;['appeal is allowed']
+116826;['appeal is rejected']
+46006;['appeal is allowed.the']
+97083;['panel therefore rejects this claim for protection']
+149582;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+79467;['appeal isallowed']
+76249;['decisions are not valid in law']
+87423;['appeal is allowed']
+80189;['claimants are persons in need of protection']
+96282;['negative']
+125043;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+109293;['appeal is dismissed']
+147600;['appeal is dismissed']
+120757;['appeal is allowed']
+44016;['dismissed the appeal']
+116767;['appeal is allowed']
+87464;['302 (c.a.)']
+56269;['302 (c.a.)']
+106839;['appeal is determined abandoned']
+94212;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+117212;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+122911;['set aside the rpd’s negative decision', 'substitute a positive decision on this claim']
+148499;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+76397;['appeal is allowed']
+91202;['appeal is allowed']
+76433;['appeal isallowed']
+100399;['claimants are convention refugees']
+28091;['allow the appeal']
+84680;['appeal is allowed']
+123548;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neitherconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56934;['appeal isallowed']
+62391;['appeal is allowed']
+50456;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx,andxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+89022;['appeal would be dismissed']
+41569;['appeal isallowed']
+42224;['appeal is dismissed']
+71524;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+131739;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant,xxxx xxxx, is a convention refugee']
+125098;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143580;['not confirm the rejection of their refugee protection claims']
+62944;['dismissing the reconsideration application']
+142976;['302 (c.a.']
+88155;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+102432;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+74682;['appeal is based on']
+98243;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+126399;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither “convention refugees”', 'nor “persons in need of protection']
+69658;['appeal allowed without a hearing was dismissed']
+144413;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+90461;['negative']
+101174;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+104499;['302 (c.a.']
+94617;['appeal is allowed']
+76040;['appeal is dismissed']
+120794;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+121449;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is excluded', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+114329;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+134162;['appeal were dismissed']
+108780;['appeal is dismissed']
+76750;['appeal isallowed']
+121482;['appellant is a person described in article\xa01e of the convention on refugees', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+76365;['appeal is terminated']
+85964;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+76972;['appeal proceeded by way of a hearingde novo']
+74356;['appeal is dismissed']
+81292;['appeal be dismissed']
+92160;['appeal is dismissed']
+136728;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx, is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60983;['appeal terminated']
+78191;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+69319;['appeal isallowedin law']
+101869;['appeal is allowed']
+80734;['thatxxxxx xxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+19138;['appeal is allowed']
+98369;['appeal is dismissed']
+24478;['appeal of the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness is dismissed']
+70187;['appeal is dismissed']
+151730;['rpd’s decisions were upheld']
+23112;['appeals are dismissed']
+97807;['negative']
+145873;['appeal is dismissed']
+97507;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+138845;['appeal be dismissed']
+98632;['claim is therefore rejected']
+52302;['appeal is dismissed']
+73039;['appeal be allowed']
+84676;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+135132;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+27471;['allow his appeal']
+104112;['302 (c.a.']
+125093;['not confirm the rpd’s decision', 'substitute a positive decision']
+50642;['appeals are dismissed']
+151604;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+99513;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+142800;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+105342;['claims are rejected']
+113221;['appeal is dismissed']
+103499;['appellants are not persons in need of protection']
+94813;['appeal is dismissed']
+30488;['appealsfor darshan singh dhaliwal and surinder kaur dhaliwal are allowed']
+67191;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+89386;['appeal is allowed']
+79921;['negative']
+63895;['allow his appeal.']
+106299;['appeals are dismissed']
+57022;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+84454;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+127699;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+90443;['appeal is dismissed']
+95525;['appeal is allowed']
+78058;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+62641;['appeal is allowed']
+95778;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+104492;['appeal of albert kumah asiamah is dismissed']
+26757;['appeal be dismissed']
+90314;['negative']
+97925;['appeal is dismissed']
+71471;['appeal isallowed']
+87333;['appeal is allowed']
+86480;['appeal is allowed']
+78069;['appeal is allowed']
+135916;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+95215;['appeal is allowed']
+123021;['302 (c.a.']
+60664;['appeal is dismissed']
+101315;['appeal isallowedand']
+69508;['application is denied']
+102970;['claim is denied']
+46532;['302 (c.a.']
+75573;['appeal isallowed']
+67935;['appeals of jabbar mozayen abedin, taheri masoumeh moghaddam and arvan mozayen abedin areallowed.']
+63960;['dismiss the appeal of douglas dok']
+106423;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+114422;['substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+45178;['appeal is allowed']
+149281;['appeal is dismissed']
+96648;['negative']
+3991;['appeal is dismissed']
+98618;['appeal is terminated', 'stay is cancelled']
+94974;['appeal is dismissed']
+123260;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+113803;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125675;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+145331;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+95015;['appeal is terminated']
+48098;['appeal is dismissed']
+62251;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+80458;['appeal is being allowed']
+87303;['claimant is not convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+105625;['rad therefore confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+136706;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+142439;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+69472;['this case will be dismissed']
+24451;['appeal of yuan chang yang is allowed']
+70043;['appeal isallowedand']
+85525;['appeal is dismissed']
+129172;['appeal is dismissed']
+124970;['appeal is dismissed']
+95313;['appeal isallowed']
+77987;['appeal is caught by', 'appeal is dismissed']
+123881;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90241;['negative']
+101192;['rad allows the appeal']
+81224;['appeal is dismissed']
+62220;['302 (c.a.']
+98326;['appeal is dismissed']
+31961;['appeal isallowedand']
+91316;['appeal isallowed']
+31382;['appeal is allowed']
+68136;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+87788;['claimants are not convention refugees', 'or persons in need of protection']
+47753;['dismiss the appeal']
+92021;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+68373;['appeal is therefore, dismissed']
+68099;['appeal is dismissed']
+94270;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99373;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+142815;['negative determination']
+123317;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+65621;['refugee protection division may reject the application']
+143283;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52279;['appeal is dismissed']
+142557;['appeal is allowed']
+37854;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+112331;['appeal is allowed']
+63873;['appeal is dismissed']
+150917;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+79760;['appeal is dismissed']
+84726;['appellant is a protected person.subsection']
+98588;['officer’s decision is valid in law']
+107488;['refugee appeal division confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'dismisses the appeal']
+56624;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+73181;['appeal is dismissed']
+141810;['dismiss the appeal']
+75598;['appeal isallowed']
+141261;['appeal is allowed']
+77286;['appeal is dismissed']
+136688;['appeal is dismissed']
+61493;['appeal isallowed']
+73048;['appeal is dismissed']
+135182;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+82806;['appeal isallowed']
+134741;['not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+114357;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+75590;['appeal division finds that these conflicts are minor in nature']
+95049;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+76246;['reject these explanations']
+43802;['appeal is allowed']
+103887;['appeal filed by xxxx xxxx xxxx is dismissed']
+59728;['appeal is allowed']
+27251;['appeal is dismissed']
+146825;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+146836;['appeal is allowed']
+60118;['claimantis neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61917;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+89850;['panel rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+150785;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+31393;['appeal of fatuma kurfesa raya is dismissed']
+125240;['rad therefore allows the appeal and', 'sets aside the decision of the rpd']
+124661;['overturn the rpd’s decision']
+61464;['302 (c.a.']
+85541;['appeal on humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+90185;['appeal isallowed']
+152480;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+68723;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+88501;['refugee protection division rejects their claims']
+47884;['appeal is dismissed']
+55117;['appeal is allowed']
+127712;['appeal is dismissed']
+132817;['appeal is dismissed']
+124984;['set aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitute my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+14703;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+97264;['panel rejects the present claims']
+87171;['appeals of lalpreet singh jassal, his wife']
+144010;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+24469;['appeal is terminated']
+68196;['appeal isallowed']
+77198;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+77845;['panel therefore rejects her claim']
+83037;['appeal is allowed']
+99023;['refugee protection division, rejects all three claims']
+140867;['appeal is dismissed']
+52720;['302 (c.a.']
+77983;['appeal is suitable to be allowed']
+90325;['claimant not to be a convention refugee', 'reject her claim']
+145110;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+142815;['rad substitutes the rpd decision with a negative determination']
+101297;['appeal is allowed']
+72857;['appeal is dismissed']
+71576;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+89334;['appeal is allowed']
+77087;['claimants xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection', 'division rejects their claims']
+90599;['appeal isallowed']
+83680;['appeal is dismissed']
+93881;['appeal is dismissed']
+122932;['appeal is allowed']
+130756;['appeal is allowed']
+151614;['appeal is dismissed']
+110934;['appeal is accepted']
+107674;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+68529;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+153728;['appeal is allowed']
+13968;['302 (c.a.']
+91906;['appeal is allowed']
+54265;['appeal is dismissed']
+97288;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee']
+88121;['appeal is dismissed']
+96738;['not convention refugees']
+107029;['appeals are allowed']
+143645;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant cannot be a refugee or a person in need of protection']
+44091;['rad concurs with the rpd’s conclusion']
+28097;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+82167;['appeal is allowed.the']
+21401;['refugee division determines that xxxx xxx is a convention refugee']
+71572;['appeal is dismissed']
+107896;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+101469;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+141614;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+50523;['appeal is allowed.the']
+89863;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+132415;['appeal is allowed']
+13947;['application to reopen this appeal is dismissed']
+34172;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+35886;['appeal be dismissed']
+107070;['appeal is allowed']
+93847;['appeal is dismissed']
+88330;['appeal is dismissed']
+105346;['302 (c.a.']
+89188;['appeal is dismissed']
+94697;['appeal is allowed']
+68134;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are persons in need of protection']
+91638;['iad therefore orders your departure from canada']
+70888;['appeal is allowed']
+77819;['not convention refugees and have not shown that there is a serious possibility that they would be subjected personally']
+62462;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+15009;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with an rpd decision that is not subject to appeal']
+139844;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+29713;['appeal will fail']
+102975;['appeal is allowed']
+103022;['reject their claims']
+93326;['appeal is dismissed']
+95269;['302 (c.a.)']
+95019;['appeal is allowed']
+81141;['appeal is allowed']
+108767;['appeal is dismissed']
+123423;['appeal is allowed']
+8290;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99175;['appeal is allowed']
+28289;['board rejects a claim']
+27481;['appeal is dismissed']
+135120;['302 (c.a.']
+106639;['claimants xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are not convention refugees, nor are they persons in need of protection', 'division rejects their claims']
+87166;['appeal is moot']
+91904;['appeal is allowed']
+95466;['appeal is dismissed']
+90076;['appeal is dismissed']
+128344;['appeal is allowed']
+87199;['panel finds that the immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+93697;['appeal is allowed']
+131540;['appeal is dismissed']
+68217;['appeal isallowed']
+76400;['allows this appeal']
+122635;['confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+34096;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+121935;['confirm the rpd determination']
+44088;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60500;['appeal of adedokun adenipekun is dismissed']
+81167;['appeal is allowed']
+69184;['appeal will fail']
+63966;['appeal isdismissed.']
+44186;['appeal is dismissed']
+89339;['negative']
+85217;['leave to appeal sentence is granted']
+94471;['appeal is allowed']
+71248;['appeal is allowed']
+86945;['appeal is terminated']
+142308;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+84362;['appeal is dismissed']
+95380;['appeal is dismissed']
+38898;['appeal is allowed']
+98090;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+90622;['appeal isallowed']
+73323;['appeal is allowed']
+98997;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+17372;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+146835;['dismiss the appeal and', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132391;['appeal would be dismissed']
+52166;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+30506;['appeal is determined']
+129862;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+48293;['decision is not subject to appeal']
+76243;['claimant is therefore not a convention refugee']
+150919;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+137443;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52316;['appeal is allowed']
+61900;['appeal is dismissed']
+139418;['appeal is rejected']
+81171;['officer’s decision is well-founded in law']
+74791;['appeal isallowed']
+93623;['iad declines to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction']
+81213;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+138821;['appeal abandoned']
+61039;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+107641;['appeal is dismissed']
+26828;['nor any convention ground']
+92388;['appeal is accepted']
+61296;['resumption application is allowed']
+81647;['appeal are dismissed']
+73261;['appeal must be dismissed']
+143136;['refugee appeal division sets aside the determination of the refugee protection division', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+144384;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+69487;['dismiss this appeal']
+123643;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77903;['appeal is allowed.the']
+38405;['appeal is dismissed']
+47351;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost herpermanent resident status']
+94501;['appeal is dismissed']
+140734;['appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+77228;['appeal of the younger son, alap rajeshkumar shah, is dismissed', 'sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+68097;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+76164;['negative']
+84633;['appeal isallowed.the']
+77480;['i am dismissing your appeal']
+102163;['appeal was dismissed']
+44089;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+71271;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+57100;['appeal is allowed']
+84568;['appeal isallowed']
+85969;['appeal isallowed']
+103799;['302 (c.a.']
+100457;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+82249;['visa officer’s refusal is legally valid']
+26950;['refugee division determines xxxxxxxxxx to be a convention refugee']
+90025;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+89551;['appeal is terminated']
+60895;['appeal is allowed']
+143886;['allow the appeals of the principal appellant']
+134334;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+59408;['appeal isallowed.the']
+77581;['appeal isallowed']
+77631;['appeal is dismissed']
+90231;['division rejects his claim']
+98066;['appeal is terminated']
+31982;['appeal is allowed']
+105363;['302 (c.a.']
+24504;['appeal is dismissed']
+71626;['appeal is allowed']
+73713;['appeal isallowed']
+97948;['appeal is allowed']
+124825;['appeal is allowed']
+98969;['rad dismissed the appeal on april\xa020, 2015']
+116793;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+55207;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+26735;['appeal bedismissedfor lack of']
+38255;['appeal should proceed to a full hearing']
+105226;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination', 'respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+84205;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+84499;['appeal is allowed']
+144383;['302 (c.a.']
+86938;['appeals are dismissed']
+146823;['appeal is allowed']
+77270;['appeal is allowed']
+60819;['appeal is dismissed']
+98855;['appeal is withdrawn']
+96318;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+85380;['appeal isallowed']
+61543;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+70477;['dismiss this appeal']
+31933;['appellants’ arguments on state protection']
+61951;['appeal is dismissed']
+121210;['appeal is allowed']
+78126;['appeal is dismissed']
+100757;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+81379;['appeal of kulwinder singh sahota is dismissed']
+139457;['appeal abandoned']
+124463;['302 (c.a.']
+86327;['panel allows the refugee protection claim']
+116335;['refugee appeal division (rad) dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99772;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+97591;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+98620;['appeal is dismissed']
+152847;['appeal is re-opened']
+111332;['appeal is allowed']
+99699;['appeal is allowed']
+44183;['appellants are not citizens of china']
+95905;['rad disagrees']
+90989;['appeal is allowed']
+33327;['appeal is dismissed']
+136721;['appeals are dismissed']
+71508;['appeal is dismissed']
+69096;['appeal is allowed']
+54183;['appeal were dismissed']
+148495;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal is in respect of a decision by the refugee protection division']
+95144;['claimant not to be a convention refugee or a person in need of canada’s protection']
+63856;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+63520;['negative']
+95165;['appeal is allowed']
+106415;['appeal is allowed']
+89402;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+143572;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+90741;['appeal is allowed']
+82885;['appeal is allowed']
+48613;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+23065;['allow the appeal']
+74126;['appeal is allowed']
+80382;['appeal is allowed']
+71186;['appeal is allowed in law']
+123645;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+109003;['302 (c.a.']
+113523;['302 (c.a.']
+90909;['dismiss as unfounded']
+142846;['appeal is allowed']
+152064;['302 (c.a.']
+56939;['appeal is dismissed']
+105436;['dismiss the present appeal']
+77794;['negative']
+131722;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor \xa0persons in need of protection']
+23076;['appeal isallowed']
+60513;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101253;['appeal is dismissed']
+63982;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+153147;['i find that the rpd’s determination', 'confirm the rpd’s finding']
+100410;['appeal is dismissed']
+152913;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee']
+104090;['appeal is allowed']
+55315;['appeal is dismissed']
+74857;['appeal is governed by theact']
+76422;['dismiss the appeal']
+63974;['appeal isdismissed.']
+124969;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+77669;['allow this appeal']
+107028;['appeal is allowed']
+80274;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+102571;['appeal is dismissed']
+94074;['appeal of marilyn ruth stone is allowed']
+65676;['appeal isallowed']
+61829;['appeals are dismissed']
+56822;['application to vacate is granted']
+146102;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+116210;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+94061;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations', 'appeal is allowed']
+56953;['appeal is allowed.the']
+95393;['appeal isallowed.the']
+57783;['appeal isallowed']
+89149;['appeal is allowed']
+128400;['appeal be dismissed']
+123642;['appeal is dismissed']
+131742;['appeal is dismissed']
+30508;['appeal is dismissed']
+81636;['appeal is allowed']
+100458;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+132377;['appeal is allowed']
+87341;['appeal is dismissed']
+90748;['appellants are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+90957;['appeal isallowed']
+100137;['appeal isallowedand']
+152055;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+95892;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+100259;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94015;['appeal is dismissed']
+39071;['appeal is allowed']
+122841;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither aconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+101254;['investigation is terminated']
+87484;['appeal is dismissed']
+49526;['appeal is allowed']
+97890;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+84297;['appeal isallowed']
+19242;['appeal is dismissed']
+19726;['appeal is hereby dismissed']
+84641;['appeal is allowed']
+98587;['thatxxxx xxxxis a “convention refugee”']
+77969;['allow her appeal']
+86983;['appeal is allowed']
+60032;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+96012;['rad finds the decision of the rpd to be wrong in law']
+85242;['appeal is dismissed']
+93919;['appeal of saima jamal is allowed']
+60046;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+135919;['appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+83712;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+92405;['allow the appeal']
+47804;['appeal is dismissed']
+47551;['appeal is dismissed']
+1259;['dismisses the appeal']
+65643;['dismisses this appeal']
+132071;['appeal is allowed']
+101398;['appeal isallowed']
+141042;['appeal is dismissed']
+102881;['allow the appeal']
+74499;['appeal of kaltun rabile hufane is dismissed']
+83441;['appeal is allowed']
+142957;['appeal is dismissed']
+132785;['appeal must be dismissed']
+70933;['appeal is dismissed']
+69521;['dismiss this appeal']
+131233;['appeal is allowed']
+88139;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+98087;['negative']
+89242;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+56770;['claimant is neither a refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+60529;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+120763;['not convention refugees', 'nor persons in need of protection']
+93046;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+122960;['appeal is allowed']
+150728;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants areneither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+13809;['stay of the   removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+124111;['appeal is allowed']
+51665;['appeal is dismissed']
+94762;['appeal is dismissed']
+98152;['appeal is allowed']
+70959;['appeal is allowed']
+90735;['appeal is dismissed']
+125125;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+102467;['orders your departure from canada']
+107323;['claims are rejected']
+151750;['appeals are dismissed', 'appeals are in respect of a decision by the rpd']
+98013;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+34688;['appeal is dismissed']
+66773;['appeal is allowed']
+94439;['appeal is dismissed']
+79936;['claimant’s claim for refugee protection is rejected']
+102066;['appeal is allowed']
+50475;['appeal of is allowed']
+107871;['thatxxxx xxxxis not a “person in need of protection']
+76833;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent visa is set aside']
+84583;['appeal is allowed']
+95460;['appeal is dismissed']
+96702;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+97894;['appeal is dismissed']
+150687;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+136074;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+143160;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+84782;['application is therefore dismissed']
+124821;['302 (c.a.']
+95914;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+98257;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees']
+131540;['appeal is dismissed']
+102125;['appeal of fatima errami is dismissed']
+125594;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+23099;['appeal isallowedand']
+54702;['appeal is dismissed']
+26678;['appeal of jayne louise ogundehinde is dismissed']
+59402;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+30382;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+58103;['appeal were dismissed']
+88102;['appeal is allowed']
+100399;['claimants are convention refugees']
+123699;['appeal is dismissed']
+33237;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89488;['appeal is allowed']
+100737;['appeal is allowed']
+143156;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+21430;['nor voluntarily re-establishing oneself in that country']
+67214;['appeal is dismissed']
+108888;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'rejects their claim']
+90052;['claimants are notconvention refugees']
+75440;['appeal is dismissed']
+41084;['appeal isallowed']
+68268;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+77561;['appeal isallowed']
+100105;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+63736;['appeal is dismissed']
+124651;['appellant is neither convention refugees nor a person in need of protection']
+99015;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection', 'refugee protection division rejects these claims']
+113561;['appeal is a hearingde']
+82988;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”', 'or a\xa0“person in need of protection']
+118253;['dismiss the appeals', 'confirm the determination of the rpd']
+123328;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+57067;['rad cannot substitute its own decision in the particular circumstances of this claim']
+95603;['appeal isallowedand']
+108775;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+31389;['appeal is allowed']
+125661;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+130000;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97273;['appeal isallowed']
+96187;['appeal were dismissed']
+146555;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection', 'rejects his refugee protection claim']
+60659;['appeal is allowed']
+59768;['appeal of the appellant is dismissed']
+23035;['allow this appeal']
+71195;['appeal of jagraj singh toor is dismissed']
+80675;['claimants are determined to be convention refugees']
+122671;['appellants are convention refugees']
+72313;['appeal isallowed']
+94607;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+131190;['allow the appeal']
+26804;['appeal of sotha kong is dismissed']
+102481;['appeal is allowed']
+26671;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+97616;['appeal isallowed']
+70654;['appeal is dismissed']
+61911;['orders your departure from canada']
+47110;['appeal bedismissed.']
+54549;['appeal is dismissed']
+86310;['appeal is allowed.the']
+84048;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+100296;['claim is rejected']
+145539;['rad has found that the rpd decision will not stand']
+61435;['appeal is allowed']
+112377;['appeal is allowed']
+114345;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+76697;['appeal is dismissed']
+95155;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+40121;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+59131;['dismissed the appeal']
+82641;['appeal is allowed']
+122978;['appeal is allowed']
+128336;['302 (c.a.']
+76947;['appeal is dismissed']
+79755;['appeal isallowed']
+153266;['appeal is allowed']
+75922;['appeal is allowed']
+68142;['not be recognized as convention refugees or “persons in need of protection']
+49522;['thepanel finds the visa officer’s decision is valid in law']
+83475;['appeals are allowed']
+104498;['appeal is dismissed']
+94341;['appeal is dismissed']
+54183;['appeal were dismissed']
+149234;['appeal is to be dismissed']
+87089;['appeal is allowed']
+128599;['negative']
+21432;['refugee division finds that xxxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee']
+87847;['appeal be dismissed']
+96010;['appeal is rejected']
+91270;['appeal of yaw oppong is allowed']
+99143;['claim was dismissed']
+123678;['302 (c.a.']
+125235;['dismiss the appeal,', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neitheraconventionrefugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108974;['appeal isallowed']
+69400;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97487;['negative']
+38255;['neither a party nor a privy to the admissibility hearing']
+95921;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+125627;['confirm the determination of the rpd']
+62883;['negative']
+60157;['appeal is allowed']
+148595;['dismissal of this appeal']
+84263;['appeal is dismissed']
+87440;['appeal is allowed']
+124067;['are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101551;['appeal is allowed']
+93312;['appeal of mohamed abdul sathar fazeel is dismissed']
+67431;['appeal is allowed']
+71732;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+41728;['appeal is dismissed']
+94506;['appeals of ricardo mohammed and grace cynthia f mohammed are dismissed']
+64636;['appeal isallowed']
+46517;['appeal is dismissed']
+89820;['appeal is allowed']
+140899;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxre neither “convention refugees”']
+110981;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+98226;['appeal is allowed']
+61937;['appeal is dismissed']
+30544;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+69368;['appeal will be dismissed']
+81418;['appeal isallowed']
+87113;['appeal is allowed']
+122823;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellants, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+68281;['appeal is dismissed']
+140274;['appeal is dismissed']
+89453;['appeal isallowed']
+26995;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx,xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxxare not convention refugees']
+26985;['motion is denied']
+69833;['appeal is dismissed']
+23644;['appeal is allowed']
+92495;['appeal is dismissed']
+63880;['appeal is dismissed']
+69477;['dismiss the appeal']
+130996;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+122882;['appeal is granted', 'substitute a determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+141046;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+58131;['appeal is dismissed']
+135472;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+79974;['claim is rejected']
+77542;['appeal is allowed']
+74523;['appeal is dismissed']
+88503;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+77324;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+89941;['appeal is dismissed']
+133710;['appeal is allowed']
+97952;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95245;['allow the appeal']
+94263;['appeal is allowed']
+72662;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+62455;['allow the appellants’ appeal']
+32083;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+135910;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+94285;['appeal is allowed']
+112336;['appeal is deemed to have been abandoned']
+84570;['appeal is terminated']
+64062;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+69079;['appeal is dismissed']
+92562;['appeal is allowed']
+111644;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+142474;['appeal is allowed']
+88257;['appeal is allowed']
+88333;['appellants have not established']
+90457;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection']
+92755;['appeal is dismissed']
+80505;['stay of the removal order is cancelled']
+23054;['appeal is dismissed']
+95415;['appeal is dismissed']
+73171;['appeal is allowed']
+42386;['appeal of anthony chiedu nwade is dismissed']
+61025;['appeal is dismissed']
+29126;['appeal is dismissed']
+99495;['appeal is allowed']
+92956;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+88334;['appeal is terminated']
+92809;['appeal is dismissed']
+147789;['appellants are persons in need of protection']
+62961;['appeal isallowed']
+52297;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+49527;['appeal is allowed']
+49523;['appeal is dismissed']
+98348;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+61902;['officer’s decision is not valid in fact and law']
+96945;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+17958;['appeal is allowed']
+100272;['request to re-open the claim of the applicant is dismissed']
+70184;['appeal be dismissed']
+60731;['appeal is dismissed']
+92792;['appeal is allowed']
+87072;['appeal isallowed']
+86963;['appeal of liang zhou is allowed']
+26700;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+47377;['appeal is dismissed']
+37982;['appeal isallowed']
+84526;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+29129;['appeal is dismissed']
+69437;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+88139;['appeal is allowed']
+31147;['appeal is dismissed']
+56888;['appeal is dismissed']
+150324;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+114426;['confirm the rpd’s determination']
+114297;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+38386;['appeal is dismissed']
+94715;"[""my decision that the visa officer's decision is valid in law""]"
+109617;['rad finds the appellant’s argument must fail']
+47171;['appeal is abandoned']
+98928;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+93682;['appeal is denied']
+125449;['appeal is allowed']
+128439;['appeal is dismissed']
+68369;['appeals of lutchmee ramnath, culyanee ramnath, akheelesh ramnath, sundeep ramnath are dismissed']
+88023;['302 (c.a.']
+125646;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+83116;['appeal is allowed']
+106295;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+97875;['appeal is allowed']
+81237;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+95974;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+56271;['appeal is dismissed']
+71163;['appeal is governed by theact']
+89823;['appeal is allowed']
+100224;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+133340;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+121412;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+83043;['appeal is dismissed']
+30389;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68276;['appeal is dismissed']
+89333;['dismiss this appeal']
+87802;['appeal is allowed']
+17959;['appeals are allowed.the']
+74618;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+34097;['302 (c.a.']
+68247;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+22123;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+101535;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+98689;['appeal isdismissed.']
+69568;['dismiss this appeal']
+143142;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83089;['appeal is allowed']
+83660;['departure order isset aside']
+98052;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”']
+69107;['appeal is allowed']
+90600;['appeal isallowed']
+36097;['exclusion order is set aside']
+95990;['xxxx xxxx xxxx is a “convention refugee']
+145432;['appeal is not an alternative immigration scheme']
+144479;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the principal appellant is a \xa0convention refugee']
+50535;['appeal of jhanvi shailesh shah is allowed']
+77847;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+91719;['appeal is allowed']
+47724;['appeal of avtar singh khara is dismissed']
+78128;['claim is rejected']
+54812;['rad is unable to substitute its own decision']
+69990;['appeal is dismissed']
+71100;['appeal is allowed']
+125302;['dismiss the appeals and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neitherconventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89777;['claimant is not a “convention\xa0']
+122971;['appeal is allowed']
+93211;['302 (c.a.)']
+103715;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+122876;['substitute my own decision that the appellants are convention refugees']
+92383;['dismisses the appeal filed by the appellant']
+150676;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+56955;['appeal is dismissed']
+129113;['appeals be dismissed']
+57094;['appeal is dismissed']
+76051;['allows the appeal']
+62625;['appeal isallowed']
+99888;['appeal ofalaeddin mohammadi sarbandis dismissed']
+74814;['appeal isdismissedand the']
+51745;['appeal must be dismissed']
+98439;['appeal isallowed.the']
+122103;['302 (c.a.']
+112318;['appeal was dismissed']
+51754;['dismissing the appeal']
+67662;['appeal beallowed']
+36109;['appeals are dismissed']
+125506;['rad upholds the rpd’s decision']
+129193;['appeal is allowed']
+76359;['appeal is dismissed']
+90950;['appeal is dismissed']
+93977;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+146854;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+151455;['appeal is dismissed']
+71069;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+76913;['declare the appeal abandoned']
+69254;['appeal is allowed']
+143021;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+51756;['allow the appeal']
+55273;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+68697;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+97454;['refugee protection division therefore rejects their claims']
+96384;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+99293;['appeal fails']
+131154;['appeal is deemed abandoned']
+76251;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+111296;['set aside the determination of the rpd']
+124716;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+128789;['appeal is allowed']
+59853;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+125051;['appeal is allowed']
+127416;['appeals of georgina kayastha, shirish kayastha and simran kayastha are dismissed']
+26940;['convention refugee division determines xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+80476;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+118260;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+101794;['appeal is allowed']
+104495;['appeal is allowed']
+63178;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+123956;['appeal is allowed']
+128388;['appeal is allowed']
+99017;['refugee protection division rejects his claim']
+125157;['rad, therefore, sets aside the incorrect decision of the rpd', 'substitutes its decsion']
+142981;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxand her daughter,xxxx xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees']
+82452;['appeal is determined']
+96139;['appeal isallowed']
+100613;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+95609;['appeal is dismissed']
+145833;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+83008;['appeal is dismissed']
+69758;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+138807;['removal order isset aside']
+69350;['appeal is dismissed']
+100379;['appeal is dismissed']
+69172;['appellant is not established incanada']
+64037;['appeal is allowed']
+84290;['appeal is terminated']
+64227;['appeal isallowed']
+151411;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+100856;['refugee protection division, therefore, accepts the claim']
+79640;['appeal is dismissed']
+152596;['302 (c.a.']
+17145;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds']
+34684;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+91547;['302 (c.a.)']
+37412;['removal order is set aside']
+70902;['appeal isallowed']
+82367;['appeal is determined']
+124014;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+125033;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+144245;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+98420;['appeal isallowed']
+21337;['not a convention refugee']
+128263;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+130716;['appeal is dismissed']
+28290;['appeal is dismissed', 'appeal deals with a refugee protection claim']
+50542;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+47886;['decision is well founded in law and in fact']
+74983;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee']
+84217;['appeal is dismissed']
+147884;['claimants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+146862;['appeals were dismissed']
+108701;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142531;['set aside the decision of the rpd', 'find the appellant to be a convention refugee']
+69093;['appeal is dismissed']
+73205;['appeal is dismissed']
+77971;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+128187;['rad allows this appeal']
+100025;['deny your claim']
+96551;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+74219;['request for an oral hearing is therefore dismissed']
+8284;['appeal abandoned']
+15579;['appeal is allowed']
+93472;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+94340;['appeal is not allowed']
+69466;['appeal be dismissed']
+94688;['appeal is dismissedand']
+96603;['claimant,xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx, is not a “convention refugee']
+96664;['refugee protection division rejects the claim for refugee protection']
+20013;['appeal isallowed']
+56629;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+93157;['appellant is a sponsor within']
+95220;['appeal is allowed']
+90080;['appeal is dismissed']
+87305;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+140902;['appellants are convention refugees']
+96178;['dismisses the appeals']
+124575;['neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100844;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+94830;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+59370;['children are not adopted']
+83310;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+75948;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+107260;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+100900;['appeal isallowed']
+42420;['appeal is allowed']
+57559;['appeal is allowed']
+35908;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+81425;['appeal is dismissed']
+60460;['appeal isallowed']
+108894;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+123118;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+54212;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+100343;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+103540;['appeal is dismissed']
+37860;['appeal is dismissed']
+44032;['appeal is dismissed']
+98281;['appeal is dismissed']
+107184;['302 (c.a.']
+71631;['appeal is allowed']
+95440;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+91739;['appeal is allowed']
+118156;['appellant does not qualify for refugee protection']
+24184;['appeal is dismissed']
+81376;['appeal is allowed']
+99834;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+53407;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee”']
+56875;['appeal was dismissed']
+143850;['rad allows the appeal']
+144241;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+97305;['appeal is allowed']
+105282;['appeal ofxxxx xxxx xxxx']
+103503;['allows the appeal']
+141593;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+133242;['appeal is dismissed']
+70421;['appeal of sethi ram kohli is allowed in law']
+96722;['appeal is terminated']
+37865;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+134394;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+49181;['application is allowed']
+82586;['appeal is dismissed']
+98273;['302 (c.a.']
+152907;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'respondent is a convention refugee']
+136734;['appeals are dismissed']
+42299;['removal order is set aside']
+135905;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “refugee”']
+134426;['appeal is dismissed']
+81235;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+34886;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+71256;['appeal is allowed']
+139675;['appeal should be dismissed']
+98138;['appeal isallowed']
+130006;['noor ahmad is not a convention refugee']
+116748;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+84835;['appeal is terminated']
+41250;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is dismissed']
+127444;['appeal is allowed']
+129897;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellantxxxx xxxxis a convention refugee']
+123463;['appeal is allowed']
+93909;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+151392;['appeal is allowed']
+124016;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+67644;['dismisses this appeal']
+90069;['negative']
+58134;['appeal isallowed']
+53759;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”']
+71146;['appeal is dismissed']
+72637;['appeal is dismissed']
+65698;['allow this appeal']
+105439;['removal orders are set aside']
+74743;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+98548;['appellant is no longer a protected person']
+125603;['i disagree with the rpd’s decision']
+26951;['xxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx not to be a convention refugee']
+76956;['dismissing this appeal']
+124670;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+71198;['appeal of xi de john lin is dismissed']
+132629;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+88087;['appeal abandoned']
+82128;['visa officer’s refusal is valid in law']
+101760;['appellant is not a canadian citizen, permanent resident, or protected person']
+95482;['appeal is dismissed']
+72891;['appeal is dismissed']
+93595;['appeal is dismissed']
+61899;['appeal must be dismissed']
+95759;['positive refugee determination']
+91271;['appeal is dismissed']
+69560;['dismiss the appeal']
+98498;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+128281;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+134517;['appeals are based']
+45185;['appeal is allowed']
+58420;['appeal is dismissed']
+69496;['appeal is, therefore, dismissed']
+98431;['appeal is dismissed']
+89564;['appeal is dismissed']
+101680;['appeals are dismissed']
+128613;['refugee appeal division confirms the rpd’s determination']
+135188;['appellants are convention refugees']
+56492;['appeal fails']
+151786;['dismisses the appeal']
+135490;['claim is rejected']
+91299;['appeal isallowed']
+56788;['not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75948;['appeal is allowed']
+111361;['appeal is dismissed']
+106168;['appeal is dismissed']
+71159;['refugee protection division rejects the claim']
+69210;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention\xa0refugees”']
+86398;['appeal isallowed']
+101505;['appeal is allowed']
+105231;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+44025;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+143616;['appellants are therefore persons in need of protection']
+135140;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+123260;['appeal is allowed']
+76669;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal in law']
+106632;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+75496;['appeal is allowed']
+85305;['appeal is dismissed']
+4475;['claimant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is not a “convention refugee”']
+88328;['appeal is allowed']
+56654;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+96476;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+67933;['appeal isallowed']
+122549;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+21320;['appeal is dismissed']
+87181;['appeal allowed']
+27234;['dismisses the appeal']
+81139;['officer’s decision is legally valid']
+134171;['appeal is allowed']
+69697;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal is allowed']
+97890;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+87114;['appeal be and is hereby dismissed']
+70175;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+54280;['immigration appeal division shall dismiss an appeal']
+131204;['appeal is allowed']
+95330;['appeal is allowed']
+90681;['appeal is dismissed']
+68234;['appeal is allowed']
+91572;['dismiss the appeal']
+38859;['appeal is allowed']
+38255;['appeal will not be dismissed']
+62879;['claimants are not convention refugees']
+77251;['allows this appeal']
+80661;['neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection', 'rejects his claim']
+84832;['appeal is allowed']
+89709;['appeal isallowed']
+98579;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+72164;['appeal is allowed']
+87177;['appeal is allowed']
+37426;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+124722;['negative determination']
+89842;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+73262;['appeal is dismissed']
+95900;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+50450;['rpd’s determination thatxxxx xxxx xxxxisnot a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+94397;['allow the present appeal,']
+95134;['appeal is allowed']
+94414;['appeal is dismissed']
+98549;['302 (c.a.)']
+151490;['appeal is denied']
+74031;['appeal isdismissedas to']
+37845;['appeal is dismissed']
+70468;['appeal is allowed']
+122642;['appeal is allowed']
+108124;['appeal is allowed in part']
+100676;['302 (c.a.']
+43721;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee']
+38834;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+51759;['appeal isde novo']
+132747;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80245;['the claim fails']
+124710;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131157;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+99118;['appeal is dismissed']
+90568;['application for an extension of time']
+26693;['nor can i dismiss the appeal']
+94761;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+111007;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant,xxxx xxxx xxxx, is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+91437;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+90061;['determination is valid in law']
+100523;['removal order is set aside']
+30626;['appeal may have merit']
+107928;['appeal is dismissed']
+99943;['appeal is dismissed']
+75174;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+91564;['appeal be dismissed']
+142837;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+62958;['appeal isallowed.the']
+61058;['appeal is dismissed']
+71632;['appeal fails']
+31931;['appeals are dismissed']
+107891;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108204;['appeal is allowed']
+110954;['appeal is rejected']
+105424;['allow the appeal and']
+130765;['appeal be dismissed']
+97594;['appeal is allowed']
+76261;['appeal is allowed']
+18010;['appeal is allowed.the']
+102067;['appeal is allowed']
+81860;['appeal is dismissed']
+87255;['appeal of leksi gjoka is dismissed']
+101837;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+90982;['appeal is allowed']
+52792;['application to withdraw his appeal is denied']
+134497;['appeal is allowed']
+142408;['set aside the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+129103;['appeal is allowed']
+150699;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+138860;['appeal is allowed']
+123471;['appeal is allowed']
+91692;['appeal is dismissed']
+63562;['appeal is dismissed']
+84492;['appeals are allowed']
+123900;['substitutes its own determination that the associate appellant is a convention refugee']
+37065;['iad allowed the application']
+101851;['appeal is allowed']
+72790;['appeal is dismissed']
+130801;['claimant, xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection', 'rejects this claim for refugee protection']
+54305;['appeal of qing wei zeng is dismissed']
+135159;['rad finds the rpd decision must be set aside']
+95108;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+17982;['don’t be sad']
+123609;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+49169;['visa officer’s decision is set aside']
+101797;['appeal is dismissed']
+105376;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+111327;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+105609;['claim is rejected']
+97127;['appeal is allowed']
+56510;['determination is valid in law']
+76566;['panel finds the refusal valid in law']
+54191;['appeals are dismissed']
+52328;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+131538;['appeal is allowed']
+41922;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+135173;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+26783;['appeal of faizal abbas bakridi with respect to the applicant, kuldip kaur bakridi, is dismissed']
+30382;['302 (c.a.']
+58500;['appeal is dismissed']
+96762;['appeal is allowed']
+66946;['appeal isallowed']
+96815;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+87393;['appeal is allowed']
+75565;['dismiss the appeal']
+124087;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+144427;['appeal is allowed']
+125358;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+123590;['appeals are dismissed']
+134177;['appeal is dismissed']
+144246;['appeal is allowed']
+75836;['302 (c.a.']
+98813;['appeal be dismissed']
+31228;['appeal is dismissed']
+69402;['negative']
+3960;['appeal were dismissed']
+98909;['allows the appeal']
+97433;['claimants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74173;['appeals are dismissed']
+52665;['earlier decision is vacated']
+123472;['appeal is allowed']
+91216;['appeal granted']
+91420;['appeal isallowed']
+87696;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+82804;['appeal isallowed']
+69131;['appeal of tohari singh garcha is allowed']
+81032;['appeal isallowed']
+134307;['appeal is allowed for diego gabriel cruz.the']
+77242;['removal order is set aside']
+77275;['application is granted']
+90910;['appeal isallowed']
+146545;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74163;['appeal is allowed in part']
+81168;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is legally valid']
+75236;['appeal is allowed']
+142959;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+124729;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee”', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+72645;['appeal be dismissed']
+52703;['panel therefore rejects the claim to refugee protection']
+77991;['appeal is allowed']
+81244;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+146535;['claims are rejected']
+82859;['appeal of luis eduardo espinoza is dismissed']
+151374;['appeal is allowed']
+100398;['panel rejects the claims', 'claimants are not convention refugees nor are the persons in need of protection']
+95215;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+90324;['negative']
+78134;['appeal is allowed']
+97938;['appeal of afsheen amir is allowed']
+92024;['appeal is allowed']
+108200;['appellant’s argument fails']
+45164;['appeal of surjit singh toor is dismissed']
+124602;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+98111;['appeal isallowed']
+97936;['appeal is dismissed']
+91635;['302 (c.a.']
+66764;['appeal is allowed.the']
+61945;['dismissed the application.the']
+131095;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+75443;['appeal isallowed']
+41250;['appeal dismissed']
+17972;['appeal is dismissed']
+97639;['302 (c.a.']
+128903;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither “convention refugees”']
+80216;['claimant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+89349;['appeal is allowed']
+54717;['appeal is dismissed']
+134307;['appeal is allowed', 'appeal is dismissed']
+14485;['appeal is dismissed']
+97810;['claimants are persons described']
+90586;['appeal abandoned']
+86954;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+132763;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'dismiss the appeal']
+82110;['302 (c.a.']
+63063;['appeal is allowed']
+129172;['appeal is dismissed']
+142465;['appeal is allowed']
+106271;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+55183;['appeal is allowed']
+82391;['appeal isallowed']
+62461;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellants to be convention refugees or a persons in need of protection']
+69756;['appeal isallowed']
+99528;['appeal is subject']
+59936;['claimants,xxxxxxxxxxandxxxxx xxxxx, are not convention refugees nor are they persons in need of protection', 'reject their claims']
+123779;['appeal is allowed']
+81314;['appeal is allowed']
+68110;['appeal is allowed']
+63060;['appeal is allowed']
+28100;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+98195;['claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+91906;['appeal is allowed']
+100453;['or a “person in need of protection']
+100248;['removal order is set aside']
+125433;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+93285;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection', 'reject his claim']
+104283;['appeal of stephen gatluak nyang is allowed']
+94901;['claimants not to be convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+63808;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+101140;['allows the appeal']
+123342;['appeal must fail']
+82049;['appeal is, therefore, allowed']
+124027;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123843;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+30543;['appeal is denied']
+98865;['appeal is allowed']
+80826;['negative']
+98722;['appeal isallowed']
+94714;['appeal is allowed']
+99612;['appeal can']
+101700;['appeal is dismissed']
+94256;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+107056;['appeals are dismissed']
+90113;['negative']
+94167;['appeals are allowed']
+118140;['appeal is allowed']
+76136;['refugee protection division, therefore, rejects her claim for refugee protection']
+83042;['appeal is allowed']
+99191;['appeal must therefore be dismissed']
+124447;['oas/ser.l/v/ii']
+111876;['claims are rejected']
+69263;['appeal isallowed.the']
+99306;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+80025;['negative']
+77471;['appeal is terminated']
+28284;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination', 'respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+147727;['appeal is allowed']
+140826;['rpd decision must be set aside']
+99613;['appeal is dismissed']
+91086;['appeal is allowed']
+124959;['appeal is allowed']
+129222;['appeal is dismissed']
+128176;['appeal is dismissed']
+60870;['appeal is dismissed']
+2903;['appeal is determined']
+99049;['person is neither a convention refugee pursuant tos']
+78773;['appeal is accepted']
+107643;['rad finds that the appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of canada’s protection']
+108901;['claimants are convention refugees']
+54279;['appeal is dismissed']
+104171;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61408;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+133362;['appeal is allowed']
+88153;['appeal is dismissed']
+95487;['appeal is dismissed']
+125094;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143894;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+102959;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellants are convention refugees']
+97985;['appeal must be dismissed']
+110711;['appeal is dismissed']
+97339;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxxx, not to be a convention refugee', 'reject his claim']
+76394;['respondents are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+50256;['appeal is dismissed']
+83055;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+91378;['appeal isallowedand']
+87958;['appeal is dismissed']
+132444;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+94616;['claimant,xxxxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+24478;['appeal of the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness is dismissed']
+69795;['appeal is dismissed.the', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+150149;['appeal is dismissed']
+90933;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+136123;['appeal is dismissed']
+117107;['appeal is allowed']
+102099;['appeal is dismissed']
+138816;['appeal is dismissed']
+68878;['appeal is dismissed']
+73892;['appeal is dismissed']
+46521;['appeal is allowed']
+68342;['appeal is allowed']
+74265;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+38882;['appeal is dismissed']
+94637;['appeal is terminated']
+139674;['appeal is allowed']
+108869;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination', 'respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+142899;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxare not “convention refugees”']
+55276;['appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+12227;['appeal is dismissed']
+106332;['confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89420;['appeal is dismissed']
+90814;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+90741;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+50642;['appeals are dismissed']
+71662;['appeal would be dismissed']
+21330;['not convention refugees']
+9678;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+89157;['appeal isallowed']
+100525;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+153157;['rad concurs with the appellant’s reasoning']
+131100;['substitute its decision with my own determination', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+13953;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+60957;['appeal isallowed']
+121947;['appeal is dismissed']
+67536;['appeal isallowed']
+48230;['appeal be dismissed']
+13946;['appeal is determined']
+90663;['claimant is a convention refugee']
+100433;['three appeals are dismissed']
+99819;['appeal is allowed']
+61375;['officer’s decision must be upheld', 'appeal must be dismissed']
+82860;['appeal is governed by theact']
+26990;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+54314;['appeal of kamaljeet kaur kaler is allowed']
+68272;['appeal is allowed']
+100758;['appeal is dismissed']
+72815;['appeal is dismissed']
+99820;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+87030;['appeal is dismissed']
+88313;['dismiss the appeal']
+91244;['appeal of suk ha wendy li is dismissed']
+86952;['appeal is dismissed']
+99903;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+101757;['theappeal is allowed']
+101336;['appeal is terminated']
+53866;['appeal is dismissed']
+96032;['decision of the rpd']
+99378;['appeal is allowed']
+121541;['appeal would be dismissed']
+33073;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+42359;['appeal isallowed']
+69552;['appeal is allowed in law']
+61922;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+122638;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+153730;['appeal is allowed']
+89031;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96004;['refugee protection division therefore rejects his claim for refugee protection']
+37859;['appeal is allowed']
+60438;['appeal of amare robele sede is dismissed']
+27461;['appeal is dismissed']
+107571;['appeal is denied']
+70906;['appeal isallowed']
+89784;['dismiss this appeal']
+74099;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+101225;['denies the application for reopening of this appeal']
+36248;['appeal is allowed']
+45187;['appeal is allowed']
+91944;['302 (c.a.)']
+143154;['appeal is allowed']
+86625;['appeal is dismissed']
+81031;['appeal is allowed']
+87789;['negative']
+116352;['rpd determination is set aside']
+105894;['division rejects the application to reopen the refugee protection claim']
+93812;['claimant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+124986;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+48101;['appeal is allowed']
+125214;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+71194;['appeal of isher singh gill is allowed']
+104128;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+76046;['appeal isdismissed.']
+93328;['appeal is allowed']
+89072;['appeal is dismissed']
+25979;['appeal isdismissedand a']
+81340;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+34697;['appeal is allowed']
+74172;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither conventionrefugees nor persons in need of protection']
+71276;['appeal is allowed']
+99752;['appeal is allowed']
+146100;['appeal is allowed']
+104391;['appeal of indu shukla is dismissed']
+143920;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a “convention refugee']
+95161;['decision of the visa officer was not valid in law']
+47216;['application is denied']
+92180;['appeal is dismissed']
+46501;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+136755;['appeal is allowed']
+100234;['appeal is dismissed']
+29724;['appeal isallowed']
+70116;['302 (c.a.']
+44206;['appeal is determined']
+89550;['appeal isallowed']
+94575;['refugee protection division therefore rejects her claim']
+94757;['claimant was not a convention refugee']
+129102;['appeal is allowed']
+140071;['rad concludes that the rpd’s final decision is correct']
+74221;['rad finds that the rpd’s decision is in error']
+71163;['appeal of cresencia cera tabilin is dismissed']
+88153;['appeal of qingzhen hou is dismissed']
+75495;['appeal is allowed']
+82788;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+97469;['appeal is dismissed']
+96859;['dismiss this appeal']
+54765;['removal order is set aside']
+82721;['appeal is dismissed']
+80574;['application is denied']
+84785;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91153;['officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+63163;['appeal is dismissed']
+89160;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+73223;['dismiss the present appeal']
+94238;['departure order is set aside']
+37856;['appeal is allowed']
+90057;['appeal is dismissed']
+98411;['appeal isallowedin law']
+70792;['appeal is dismissed']
+67794;['decision of the immigration officer is valid in law']
+97790;['xxxx xxxx is not a convention refugee', 'not a person in need of protection']
+143925;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+121944;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+130765;['appeal be dismissed']
+148658;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+77896;['appeal is dismissed']
+94329;['appeal was dismissed']
+139785;['appeal is dismissed']
+101557;['appeal is allowed']
+125342;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+86312;['appeal of jin zhang is allowed']
+55192;['appeal was dismissed']
+76542;['allows this appeal']
+61225;['appeal can be dismissed']
+131202;['allows this appeal']
+113219;['appeal is allowed']
+97340;['negative']
+135117;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+102123;['appeal is allowed']
+60508;['appellant is excluded from refugee protection']
+57818;['appeal is dismissed']
+30501;['appeal is dismissed']
+43336;['appeal of dongfeng bai is dismissed']
+139858;['appeal is allowed']
+128283;['appeal of shannon denise whitford is allowed']
+61390;['appeal is dismissed']
+56276;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+153635;['application for a production order is hereby denied']
+76031;['appeal is dismissed']
+68199;['appeal of mary simon jimmy is dismissed']
+17946;['appeal is dismissed']
+136705;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+90494;['appeal isallowed.the']
+80064;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96320;['not find her to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+83868;['rad finds that this decision must be set aside']
+100575;['appeal isallowed']
+128152;['appeal is dismissed']
+55294;['302 (c.a.']
+68376;['appeal is allowed']
+142811;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'dismiss the appeal']
+63936;['panel allows the appeal']
+69155;['appeal isallowed.the']
+152946;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes a determination']
+76638;['appeal is dismissed']
+125377;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+90193;['panel rejects your claims for refugee protection']
+82065;['dismiss the appeal']
+54844;['determination of the rpd is set aside', 'rad substitutes a determination that the respondent, namely xxxx xxxx, is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+77623;['application to re-open is dismissed']
+57953;['appeal is dismissed']
+45157;['appeal of arvinder kaur sohal is dismissed']
+75476;['appeal was dismissed']
+94238;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+102051;['appeal is allowed']
+82909;['appeal is dismissed']
+82254;['appeal is dismissed']
+104270;['determine the claimants not to be convention refugees or persons in need of canada’s protection']
+54800;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+56626;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxisneither a “convention refugee']
+144250;['reverse the rpd’s finding']
+100751;['302 (c.a.)']
+69408;['appeal is dismissed']
+125330;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+99328;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+52127;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95014;['appeal is dismissed']
+94238;['appealis allowed']
+101247;['appeal is dismissed']
+140866;['rad confirms the rpd’s determination', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+93587;['appeal is allowed']
+107094;['appeal is dismissed']
+59954;['appeal isallowed']
+110683;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+95766;['refugee protection division dismisses as moot']
+68248;['dismiss the appeal']
+146070;['not convention refugees or persons in need of protection', 'i therefore reject their claims']
+142989;['confirm the rpd determination', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee']
+89131;['appeal is terminated']
+93082;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+55249;['302 (c.a.']
+67571;['immigration appeal division sets aside the order dated january\xa09, 2003', 'allows the appeal']
+58095;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+46536;['302 (c.a.']
+110962;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+94450;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+90442;['appellant has not lost his/her permanent resident status']
+8287;['appeal is determined to have been abandoned']
+45402;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+101407;['appeal is allowed']
+105447;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+74109;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'not a person in need of protection']
+74528;['appeal is terminated']
+61440;['not a convention refugee', 'rejects her claim']
+89973;['appeal is allowed']
+21341;['claimants have not rebutted the presumption of state protection']
+97507;['claimant is not a convention refugee']
+151105;['appeal must be dismissed']
+59976;['neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection', 'i reject his claim']
+77124;['302 (c.a.']
+124436;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+64615;['appeal is allowed']
+147011;['appeal is allowed.the']
+54260;['appeal isallowed']
+17121;['appeal is dismissed']
+59942;['claimants are not persons in need of protection']
+8801;['application is allowed']
+147577;['appeals are dismissed']
+77677;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+141564;['sufficient h&c considerations']
+60210;['appeal is allowed']
+87948;['appeal is dismissed']
+138832;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+104121;['decision of the id is set aside']
+95391;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+89080;['negative']
+67229;['dismiss the appeal']
+107247;['tribunal confirms the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+107140;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108752;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+94592;['appeal isallowed']
+121674;['rad cannot uphold the decision of the rpd']
+92168;['appeal is dismissed']
+71997;['appeal is dismissed']
+57449;['appeal is dismissed']
+48212;['irb (intervener)(f.c.a., no']
+82859;['appeal is governed']
+82848;['allow the appeal']
+105368;['appeal is dismissed']
+95440;['appeal is dismissed']
+127413;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+54546;['appeal isdismissed.']
+108737;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+121255;['appeal is allowed']
+127367;['appeal is allowed']
+130925;['thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+67930;['appeal must be dismissed']
+85911;['allow the appeal']
+122630;['rad dismisses the appeals', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection.there']
+131178;['appeal isdismissed.']
+149058;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+140214;['appeal of the minor appellants is dismissed']
+80364;['dismissing the appeal']
+63174;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+81105;['appeal is dismissed']
+141334;['dismisses the appeal as it concerns their claims', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+100210;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+96612;['appeal of walid aref hamed is dismissed']
+98567;['appeal must be dismissed']
+91925;['appeal is abandoned']
+21106;['appeal beallowedbecause']
+92179;['appeal is dismissed']
+131146;['appeal is allowed']
+84808;['visa officer’s decision valid in law']
+140872;['rad rejects the appellant’s submissions']
+95073;['appellant is a convention refugee or a person in need of protectionbecause']
+151976;['appeal is dismissed']
+29636;['appeal is allowed']
+42384;['appeal is dismissed']
+90369;['claimants, xxxx xxxx xxxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxxx and xxxx xxxxx xxxx are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+104357;['appeal isallowed.the']
+121212;['302 (c.a.']
+70190;['appeal is allowed']
+98856;['dismiss the appeal']
+73272;['dismiss this appeal']
+151409;['removal order isset aside']
+105831;['appeal is dismissed']
+53872;['appeal is dismissed']
+122621;['appeal is allowed']
+122900;['appellant is not a person in need of protection']
+97360;['neither a convention refugee, nor a person in need of protection']
+153056;['claims are rejected']
+97838;['claimant is found to be neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+38904;['appeal abandoned']
+17951;['appeal is dismissed']
+59804;['appeal is dismissed']
+26803;['appeals of lai tong chan, miu kwan chu and ting wai chan are dismissed']
+48101;['appeal is allowed']
+86006;['appeal isallowed']
+92407;['claimantsxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxnot to be “convention refugees”']
+94037;['appeal is dismissed']
+90940;['appeal isallowed']
+32087;['rad refuses the application to re-open the appellant’s appeal,']
+103093;['allow the appeal']
+108874;['claimants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution']
+138873;['appeal is dismissed']
+77638;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+76913;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+66306;['appeal is dismissed']
+144379;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugees nor a person in need of protection', 'dismisses the appeal']
+149000;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+107611;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+80803;['appeal is allowed']
+76015;['appeal fails']
+75865;['appeal is dismissed']
+72068;['appeal is allowed']
+47379;['appeal is allowed']
+94669;['appeal is terminated']
+17193;['appeal is allowed']
+105350;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123969;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143850;['appellant is not a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+93306;['stay of the removal order is cancelled', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+78185;['appeal isallowed']
+129928;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+38838;['appeal isallowed']
+102905;['302 (c.a.)']
+98837;['appeal is dismissed']
+90903;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+52049;['appeal is terminated']
+12840;['appellant is not a good candidate for a stay of his removal order and', 'appeal is dismissed']
+90737;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+78645;['immigration officer’s decision is therefore upheld']
+87979;['panel rejects his refugee protection claim']
+89117;['thatxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+144011;['appellant and xxxx are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74232;['appeal isdismissedbecause']
+97313;['claimant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+84081;['302 (c.a.)']
+93152;['negative']
+99467;['appeal ofnahal shahlaviisallowed']
+52092;['appeal is allowed']
+99041;['appeal is dismissed']
+88320;['appeal isallowed']
+129226;['dismiss the appeal']
+97353;['claimant is not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+61487;['allowed the appeal']
+81114;['immigration officer’s decision is valid in law']
+97853;['appeal isallowed']
+83542;['theappeal is allowed']
+76396;['respondent is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+103454;['substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+113616;['appeal is allowed']
+133717;['appeals are dismissed']
+97568;['appeal is allowed']
+101030;['claim is therefore rejected']
+62471;['request for an oral hearing is therefore dismissed']
+90707;['appeal is allowed']
+102925;['appeal is allowed.the']
+50505;['appellant himself is not a refugee']
+72869;['allows this appeal']
+130963;['302 (c.a.']
+132829;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+143002;['appeal is dismissed']
+47556;['appeal is dismissed']
+82265;['appeal was dismissed']
+76555;['appeal is dismissed']
+97276;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+85508;['appeal is dismissed']
+59668;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+96894;['appeal is dismissed']
+76795;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+43799;['appeal of keziah njeri ragui is dismissed']
+17932;['appeal should be dismissed']
+87323;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+131504;['appeal is dismissed']
+47372;['appeals are allowed']
+123893;['confirm the rpd’s determination', '“convention refugee']
+79932;['they are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+108213;['appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+65413;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+97902;['allow the appeal']
+86341;['removal order is set aside']
+60504;['302 (c.a.)']
+135895;['appeal is dismissed']
+146832;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+83148;['appeal is dismissed']
+17932;['appeal is allowed']
+100701;['not a “person in need of protection']
+75430;['appeal isallowed']
+141205;['appellants are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+82265;['appeal were dismissed']
+104470;['appeal is allowed']
+87403;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+142298;['appeal is allowed']
+129227;['appeal is dismissed']
+92102;['appeal is dismissed']
+143246;['appellant is not a convention refugee']
+89756;['visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+83941;['appeal be allowed']
+152779;['xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx is not a person who is inadmissible to canada', 'favourable decision is rendered']
+66770;['appeal is allowed']
+100707;['claimant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+39921;['appeal against that decision may have merit']
+111316;['rad must substitute its own decision']
+98636;['claimant is not a convention refugee and not a person in need of protection']
+102802;['appeal is dismissed']
+111154;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+143582;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+74151;['appeal isdismissed.']
+151391;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+33083;['appeal is dismissed']
+130924;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+5144;['appeals are dismissed']
+47288;['claimant is a convention   refugee']
+70481;['appeal is allowed']
+113582;['appeal is determined to beabandonedunders.']
+151481;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61338;['appeal isallowed']
+92839;['appeal is allowed']
+89836;['appeal is dismissed']
+89030;['appeal is dismissed']
+127723;['appeal is dismissed']
+135123;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+96473;['appeal is dismissed']
+94897;['negative']
+71560;['appeal would be dismissed']
+90978;['appeal is allowed']
+69994;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+121163;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the determination of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+108860;['appeal is accepted']
+59738;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+144426;['appeal is dismissed']
+79473;['appeal division has no jurisdiction to hear the appeal']
+124328;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'the principal appellant,xxxx xxxx, is excluded', 'not a “refugee”']
+112336;['appeal is determined']
+22397;['appeal of md tanvir zafar chowdhury is dismissed']
+67580;['allows this appeal']
+65412;['appeal is allowed']
+82115;['negative']
+51700;['appeal isallowed']
+85857;['claim is rejected']
+60910;['appeal is allowed']
+83344;['appeal must be dismissed']
+90249;['negative']
+141372;['appeal is dismissed']
+70757;['appeal is dismissed']
+87330;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+86015;['appeal is dismissed']
+98796;['appeal is denied', 'appeal isdismissed.']
+64650;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+91334;['appeal of moises angulo zamora is dismissed']
+84308;['appeal isallowed']
+55289;['1.xxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxxxx are not convention refugees and are not persons in need of protection']
+129154;['appeal is dismissed']
+68157;['appeal is allowed']
+62443;['dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the refugee protection division', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+68097;['allow the appeal', 'dismiss the appeal']
+61381;['dismisses the appeal']
+68885;['dismiss this appeal']
+95790;['rad confirms the determination', 'appellant is not a convention refugee nor is he a person in need of protection']
+90043;['appeal isallowedand']
+106296;['appeal is dismissed']
+86221;['appeal is allowed']
+98125;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+71426;['appeal is dismissed']
+102527;['appeal is dismissed']
+45869;['appeal is dismissed']
+91706;['appeal is allowed.the']
+148987;['substitute my own decision that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+114392;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81194;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+57907;['appeal be dismissed']
+89211;['appeal is dismissed']
+84174;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+102676;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+61454;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+94163;['appeal is terminated']
+38851;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+62442;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+94568;['appeal filed by wilson michaud is dismissed']
+29694;['appeals are dismissed']
+54641;['appeal ofgurjit singh kamow and sarbjeet kaur kamow is dismissed']
+80765;['negative']
+63750;['appeals of arjoi mehr mahal and jasrriet mahal are dismissed']
+83944;['appeal is dismissed']
+92180;['appeal is dismissed']
+123532;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+108666;['panel finds that xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx are also not convention refugees,', 'nor are they persons in need of protection']
+130774;['appeal is dismissed']
+122973;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its own determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+99101;['appeal is allowed']
+93636;['appeal isdismissedfor lack of jurisdiction']
+91441;['appeal is terminated']
+66943;['appeal is dismissed']
+61528;['appeal isallowed']
+98818;['refugee protection claimants are not “convention refugees”']
+105204;['appeal is dismissed']
+99882;['removal orders are set aside']
+101474;['dismiss this appeal']
+66939;['302 (c.a.']
+56930;['appeal, therefore, is dismissed']
+84615;['appeal is terminated']
+124340;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd']
+99645;['appeal is allowed']
+107584;['appeal was dismissed']
+151520;['appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67661;['appeal allowed']
+19140;['appeal of zhen fu is allowed']
+91677;['appeal is allowed']
+107032;['appeal by dismissed']
+61047;['appeal is allowed']
+96346;['claimant is not a “convention refugee”']
+74863;['appeal of balwinder dhillon is dismissed']
+69417;['appeal fails']
+95208;['appeal is terminated']
+100265;['appeal isallowed']
+84140;['appeal isallowed']
+143471;['appeal is allowed']
+32163;['appeal isallowed']
+88979;['removal order is set aside.the', 'appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+101559;['appeal isallowed']
+25526;['appeal is dismissed']
+132777;['appeal is dismissed']
+78644;['appeal is allowed']
+84797;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd']
+84797;['he is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+75485;['appeal is dismissed']
+95766;['application is allowed']
+136737;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'dismisses the appeal']
+125042;['appeal is allowed']
+81172;['appeal is dismissed']
+94316;['appeal is allowed']
+113799;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+81614;['appeal is determined']
+98385;['appeal is dismissed']
+120821;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89888;['claimant not to be a convention refugee']
+11469;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+26742;['appeal bedismissedbecause']
+94766;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure fromcanada.']
+102473;['appeals for joshua chibuike iwueke, favour ikechukwu iwueke and justice chukwuebuka iwueke are allowed']
+69486;['appeal be dismissed']
+76820;['allows this appeal in law']
+95664;['appeal should be dismissed']
+97839;['reject his claim']
+74652;['appeal ofjafari foma rugambais dismissed']
+53406;['appeal is dismissed']
+12214;['appeal is allowed']
+40142;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+60872;['appeal is dismissed']
+89861;['appeal isallowed']
+122674;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants,xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxx, are not convention refugees or persons in need of protection']
+148714;['claimants are neither convention refugees']
+82712;['appeal is allowed']
+113222;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+85624;['appeal is dismissed']
+94625;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+73317;['appeal is hereby allowed']
+110978;['appellant is, in fact, a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+59141;['appeal isallowed']
+87115;['appeal is dismissed']
+26964;['claimant, xxxxxxxxxx, is not a convention refugee']
+74774;['dismiss the appeal']
+94493;['appeal is allowed']
+86460;['appeal is allowed']
+69784;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+61434;['302 (c.a.']
+96377;['panel finds that the visa officer’s decision is not valid in law']
+56859;['appeal is allowed']
+140841;['rad finds that it is unable to confirm, or set aside and substitute its own decision']
+152953;['appeal is dismissed']
+125402;['rpd’s decision cannot stand']
+95967;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is a convention refugee']
+44437;['appeal isallowed.the']
+107085;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+83127;['appeal is dismissed']
+94557;['appeal is dismissed']
+83145;['appeal is dismissed']
+123876;['appellant is not a convention refugee and is not a person in need of protection']
+143579;['repsondents are not excluded']
+27304;['appeal is dismissed']
+83182;['decision is not subject to appeal to the rad']
+79600;['appeal is allowed']
+106781;['appeal is dismissed']
+60057;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+99583;['appeal is dismissed']
+87482;['appeal isallowed']
+91805;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+89891;['appeal isallowed.the']
+46013;['appeal is dismissed']
+125004;['rad dismisses the appeal and', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+60509;['rad has found that the rpd’s decision is not supportable']
+90008;['appeal is terminated']
+127711;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+107326;['claim is rejected']
+98066;['appeal is terminated']
+63067;['appeal is allowed']
+76064;['appeal isallowedand']
+132765;['set aside the rpd’s determination']
+68191;['appeal of huizhen xu is dismissed']
+96864;['appeal abandoned']
+38775;['appeal is dismissed']
+89039;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+106823;['appeal of kulsoom hussain is dismissed']
+127359;['pa and sudanese mas to be convention refugees']
+75979;['appeal is allowed.the', 'officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+116776;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+97616;['appeal is allowed']
+14664;['xxxxxx xxxxx is not a convention refugee']
+52353;['appeal is dismissed']
+87823;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+67661;['appeal is allowed']
+82365;['appeal is determined tobe abandonedunders']
+61812;['appeal is allowed']
+79338;['appeal isallowed']
+19176;['allows this appeal']
+67797;['appeal is allowed']
+84325;['appeal is allowed']
+138870;['appeal is allowed']
+125414;['dismiss the appeal and', 'confirm the decision of the rpd', 'appellants are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+89022;['appeals are allowed']
+70645;['appeal is dismissed']
+44176;['rad is in agreement with the rpd’s conclusion']
+148661;['immigration appeal division allows the appeal', 'set aside the original decision and substitute a determination']
+150619;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+124458;['appeal is dismissed']
+105213;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+61633;['302 (c.a.']
+23040;['appeal isallowed']
+69482;['application is denied']
+91562;['appeal is therefore dismissed']
+89762;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a “convention refugee', 'or a “person in need of protection']
+50529;['appeal of ehimatie adoghe eronmose is dismissed']
+77632;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+116790;['confirm the decision of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+89430;['dismiss your appeal']
+124446;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxis neither a convention refugee', 'nor a person in need of protection']
+148759;['rad confirms the decision of the rpd', 'appellant is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+141029;['confirm the rpd’s determination', 'xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx and xxxx xxxx are neither convention refugees']
+66608;['appeal isallowed']
+43382;['allowing the appeal']
+114301;['dismiss the appeal', 'confirm the rpd’s determination', 'appellant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+123397;['ttp are a']
+66916;['appeal is therefore allowed in law']
+103801;['claims are rejected']
+52698;['xxxxxxxxxx is not a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+45397;['appeal is determined to be abandoned']
+97468;['immigration appeal division therefore orders your departure from canada']
+18925;['appeal is therefore allowed']
+66775;['dismiss this appeal']
+53835;['appeal is allowed', 'officer’s determination is set aside']
+125085;['appeal is allowed']
+52614;"['not a ""convention refugee']"
+83665;['appeal is allowed']
+87285;['claimant is not a person in need of protection']
+88527;['appeal be and is hereby dismissed']
+122962;['appeal is dismissed']
+95941;['rad cannot substitute its own determination for that of the rpd', 'not find the appellant to be a convention refugee or a person in need of protection']
+10838;['appellant has not lost his permanent resident status']
+46077;['appeal is allowed']
+64609;['appeal is allowed']
+69598;['officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside']
+56729;['appeal is dismissed']
+67359;['appeal is dismissed']
+23055;['appeal is dismissed']
+45189;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+125859;['appeal is allowed']
+144262;['refugee protection claim ofxxxx xxxxis rejected']
+132767;['rad confirms the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxx xxxxandxxxx xxxx xxxxare neither “convention refugees”']
+47296;['appeal is allowed']
+98006;['claimant is neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+91642;['appeal is allowed']
+19997;['appellant has not lost her permanent resident status']
+38420;['appeal is dismissed']
+124037;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'thatxxxx xxxxis not a convention refugee', 'or a person in need of protection']
+71390;['appeal is dismissed']
+39048;['appeal of ghulam nabi is allowed']
+52757;['appeal is allowed']
+58101;['appeal is dismissed']
+95760;['application to vacate a determination of convention refugee status (section 109) is allowed']
+38991;['confirm the determination of the rpd', 'neither a “convention refugee”', 'nor a “person in need of protection']
+77267;['appeal is dismissed']
+89516;['appeal were to be dismissed']
+138876;['appeal was dismissed']
+37868;['appeal is dismissed']
+90617;['appeal is allowed']
+58379;['appeal beallowedand']
+95932;['rad sets aside the determination of the rpd', 'substitutes its determination that the appellant is a convention refugee']
+127448;['determination is valid in law']
+151921;['appeal is allowed']
+117207;['appellant is a convention refugee']
+128282;['appellant is no longer a convention refugee or person in need of protection']
+58821;['appeal is terminated']
+84498;['appeal is allowed']
+118240;['appeal is dismissed']
+152016;['302 (c.a.']
+84664;['appeal is dismissed']
+68179;['appeal is allowed']
+143620;['rad dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the rpd’s determination', 'appellants are excluded', 'are neither convention refugees nor persons in need of protection']
+35923;['appellants have not lost their permanent resident status']
+15873;['allows the appeal']
+49717;['irb (intervenor)(f.c.a., no']
+59835;['rpd decision is correct']
+78077;['appeal of nelia reyes yguinto is dismissed']
+72821;['canada is not a country']
+94171;['appeal is dismissed']
+56314;['302 (c.a.']
+47766;['sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations']
+59775;['appeal is dismissed']
+130987;['rad therefore dismisses the appeal', 'confirms the decision of the rpd', 'neither a convention refugee nor a person in need of protection']
+126403;['appeal is allowed']