id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14091v1 | Protecting Privacy Through Approximating Optimal Parameters for Sequence Unlearning in Language Models | 2024-06-20T08:12:49 | 2024-06-20T08:12:49 | Dohyun Lee, Daniel Rim, Minseok Choi, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although language models (LMs) demonstrate exceptional capabilities on
various tasks, they are potentially vulnerable to extraction attacks, which
represent a significant privacy risk. To mitigate the privacy concerns of LMs,
machine unlearning has emerged as an important research area, which is utilized
to induce the LM to selectively forget about some of its training data. While
completely retraining the model will guarantee successful unlearning and
privacy assurance, it is impractical for LMs, as it would be time-consuming and
resource-intensive. Prior works efficiently unlearn the target token sequences,
but upon subsequent iterations, the LM displays significant degradation in
performance. In this work, we propose Privacy Protection via Optimal Parameters
(POP), a novel unlearning method that effectively forgets the target token
sequences from the pretrained LM by applying optimal gradient updates to the
parameters. Inspired by the gradient derivation of complete retraining, we
approximate the optimal training objective that successfully unlearns the
target sequence while retaining the knowledge from the rest of the training
data. Experimental results demonstrate that POP exhibits remarkable retention
performance post-unlearning across 9 classification and 4 dialogue benchmarks,
outperforming the state-of-the-art by a large margin. Furthermore, we introduce
Remnant Memorization Accuracy that quantifies privacy risks based on token
likelihood and validate its effectiveness through both qualitative and
quantitative analyses. | [
0.0223609898,
0.0989459828,
-0.0140100159,
0.0329679362,
-0.0544746146,
-0.0121200159,
0.0320950039,
-0.0038722439,
0.0193303581,
-0.0200927574,
-0.0411810167,
-0.035243433,
0.0041052359,
0.0107594915,
-0.0039491476,
-0.0010653582,
0.0278339628,
-0.02701951,
0.0275436621,
-0.0295023005,
-0.025381593,
0.0029118885,
-0.0128104025,
0.0180504378,
-0.0092726955,
-0.0330876559,
-0.0236561,
-0.0274626352,
0.0137826214,
-0.0260905959,
0.0283923373,
0.0570603162,
0.0273946617,
0.0650770664,
0.0000019433,
-0.0403444357,
-0.0763917342,
0.0044287569,
-0.0444639325,
0.0389233008,
-0.0007024952,
0.0040152264,
0.0320751593,
0.0382725932,
-0.0258260742,
0.0173138715,
0.0159666911,
0.0321357027,
0.0283597615,
0.0976893306,
0.0046549924,
-0.0226053912,
-0.0194911789,
-0.0495689362,
-0.0068041985,
-0.0580355227,
0.0199493188,
-0.0829663947,
-0.0669058338,
-0.0196409635,
0.0142826466,
0.0413884446,
0.0120284883,
0.0314335711,
-0.0209850445,
0.024847867,
-0.0216788463,
-0.0258793104,
-0.0137200169,
0.0604084134,
-0.003794967,
-0.0149341626,
0.0359805003,
0.0220278874,
0.0464870408,
-0.0174089856,
-0.017239457,
0.0395059064,
-0.0061136577,
0.0141047649,
-0.0226377863,
-0.0330224782,
0.0444453284,
0.0030026296,
-0.0009307954,
0.0347383395,
0.0079725692,
-0.0006207871,
-0.0408791788,
-0.0546205305,
0.0051201875,
-0.0720665082,
0.0597289167,
0.022508027,
-0.0024412908,
0.0357403792,
-0.0547796525,
-0.0393094346,
0.028814191,
-0.0218097921,
0.0134287681,
-0.0137794726,
0.0260986742,
0.0345367081,
-0.0054351152,
0.0527036823,
0.0306740403,
0.0350487754,
0.0214052871,
0.0320881084,
-0.028885169,
-0.0208919272,
0.010147131,
0.0927091613,
-0.0135444999,
0.01313214,
-0.0186627042,
0.0158859976,
-0.0125739882,
0.0217606071,
-0.0248522088,
0.0008454816,
-0.0231527947,
-0.0115520656,
-0.0276840962,
-0.0438950211,
0.0046016299,
0.0165528972,
0.0297201257,
-0.0730872601,
-0.0325159319,
-0.0334234014,
0.0189461317,
-0.0062369048,
-0.0387054868,
0.0668283626,
0.0083218627,
-0.0578102991,
-0.020316124,
-0.0798383355,
0.0244653188,
-0.0406105742,
-0.0011107035,
-0.0377866738,
0.0147628924,
-0.0504808277,
-0.0083525833,
-0.0501443446,
0.0009126884,
0.0267168563,
-0.0223945975,
0.0496217683,
0.0177255981,
-0.0369866341,
0.0016845114,
0.0396019407,
0.0009365132,
0.0236138962,
-0.0072211633,
0.0359789841,
0.0811888501,
-0.0278247651,
0.0597669408,
-0.0090824114,
0.0655770972,
-0.0257579759,
0.0051671281,
0.0068849726,
0.0351949297,
-0.0392034017,
-0.0126562342,
0.0622453243,
-0.0193922967,
-0.0723562613,
0.0657825768,
0.0717380643,
-0.0149448263,
0.0057899859,
-0.0491951816,
0.0221006479,
-0.0155769838,
0.0335866548,
-0.0592662394,
-0.0207648836,
-0.0470135324,
-0.0136903543,
0.0059202765,
0.0083803926,
-0.0090597617,
-0.0139545184,
0.0182038136,
-0.0832087845,
0.0361850075,
0.0117617957,
-0.0008440542,
0.0287663508,
-0.0159266479,
0.077384524,
-0.0024285235,
-0.06757994,
0.0015235262,
-0.0296929404,
0.0374036431,
0.0439806245,
0.048019439,
-0.0321274102,
-0.0043255584,
-0.0446190648,
-0.0241018124,
-0.0173704382,
0.0019332088,
0.0061435644,
0.1095755622,
-0.0437373035,
-0.0549404845,
0.0131867025,
0.0220762324,
0.0493529439,
0.021837974,
-0.0246786866,
0.0444943309,
-0.0299088694,
0.0022677854,
0.033563897,
-0.0255529564,
-0.0747182295,
0.0554568656,
0.0042761462,
0.0611762255,
0.0438136123,
0.0042977198,
0.0253708623,
0.0557615943,
0.0209702197,
0.0002863938,
-0.0154846888,
-0.0679368228,
-0.0143661173,
0.0140223615,
0.0019777499,
0.0347922854,
0.0699993968,
-0.0295888055,
-0.0392528325,
0.0090392241,
0.0128427865,
0.0732144192,
-0.0350948051,
0.0362451226,
-0.0145170894,
0.0422045439,
-0.016478017,
0.0205063354,
-0.0393767878,
-0.0057098116,
-0.0525443554,
-0.0317749009,
-0.0199320931,
-0.0664185062,
-0.0131009668,
0.0070158471,
-0.0242239647,
0.0226645749,
0.0234432761,
-0.0254135262,
-0.0324724913,
-0.0056585837,
-0.0514218248,
-0.0055185896,
-0.0167594086,
0.0443523601,
-0.0231621638,
-0.003513115,
-0.0089425379,
-0.0451834239,
-0.0330006629,
-0.0360459983,
-0.0614113994,
0.0330181159,
0.0034176735,
0.0087061981,
-0.0400745571,
0.0022150401,
-0.0023276501,
0.0340264961,
0.0266480055,
-0.0753050596,
-0.0088034794,
0.002683138,
0.0025844148,
-0.0299069155,
0.0474594459,
-0.0072472165,
0.0033240551,
-0.0159049798,
0.0286855567,
-0.020195784,
0.0209956449,
0.0464260094,
0.0224733409,
0.0303528868,
0.0096912421,
-0.0344529152,
-0.0172494724,
-0.0421570987,
-0.0086543541,
-0.0185319316,
0.0127813714,
0.0460073277,
0.0141583104,
0.0135460189,
-0.0264742896,
0.0022398278,
0.0096037267,
0.0064384155,
-0.0560686849,
-0.0280243587,
-0.0074782684,
-0.0381807052,
0.009618015,
-0.0012958628,
-0.0441488251,
0.06547077,
-0.0324572101,
0.0320428722,
-0.0127966078,
-0.0276842993,
0.0041814083,
0.0415517874,
0.0157376826,
0.0260452796,
0.050177779,
-0.0868562832,
0.0012582365,
-0.013207729,
0.0225093961,
-0.0626219735,
0.0105724055,
0.0012280904,
-0.0326406397,
0.0156562962,
-0.0263387803,
-0.0512626432,
-0.0741759315,
0.0318104737,
0.0040963376,
-0.0156293474,
-0.0285427812,
-0.0236952715,
-0.0359397046,
0.0346692242,
0.0228019785,
0.0139635317,
0.0403019227,
-0.0166159403,
0.031352248,
0.011162187,
-0.0359010063,
-0.0357726365,
-0.0078049372,
0.0224128868,
0.0977595747,
0.0703856274,
0.019202292,
0.0494962633,
-0.029524114,
0.0037494649,
-0.0279419702,
-0.01482281,
0.0371386856,
0.0343267694,
-0.034933541,
0.0049638883,
0.1026096642,
-0.0009261292,
-0.0444902815,
-0.011737437,
0.0687601641,
0.0234822538,
-0.0098808408,
-0.0412026532,
-0.0758701712,
0.009392906,
0.0295781996,
0.0717623308,
-0.0168227572,
-0.03825894,
-0.0232425686,
-0.0730278343,
-0.0538844876,
0.0173550695,
-0.0389865972,
-0.034130875,
-0.0525227748,
-0.0075834757,
0.0121322637,
0.049227003,
0.0008671792,
0.0107855387,
-0.0385904871,
0.0265457612,
-0.0269028507,
-0.0518335477,
-0.0038759026,
-0.0268786177,
0.0299783014,
0.0514728688,
-0.0027659531,
-0.0010654452,
-0.05562374,
0.0352438092,
0.0206840057,
0.0049772728,
-0.0033797002,
0.0464700386,
-0.0358410813,
0.0079776393,
0.0173037164,
0.0675681159,
-0.0032315417,
-0.0316295326,
0.0357381999,
0.0179195218,
-0.004718957,
-0.0047183754,
0.032968007,
-0.0451381207,
0.0033311974,
0.0515077263,
0.0036264453,
-0.0269069429,
0.0317232572,
-0.0170698259,
0.0576270632,
-0.0049271109,
0.0628092736,
-0.0076037678,
-0.0188813992,
-0.0580965579,
-0.0499342866,
0.000683222,
-0.0308960844,
0.032500919,
0.0204642508,
0.0239978954,
0.0304404404,
-0.0024251759,
-0.0272822492,
0.0049899304,
-0.0672301799,
-0.0202875454,
-0.0434075855,
0.0133829936,
-0.0102642728,
0.0173161775,
-0.0166377295,
0.0025948242,
-0.0649374276,
-0.0904228836,
0.0212214235,
0.0417033322,
0.0116964467,
0.0680502057,
0.0029934221,
-0.0545221269,
0.0893525034,
0.0635265931,
-0.0246535596,
-0.0125535261,
0.0544549748,
-0.0184711553,
-0.0168045368,
0.0218900796,
-0.0096380133,
-0.0282529574,
0.0532241352,
-0.0041235369,
-0.023108596,
-0.0228446852,
-0.0181023348,
0.0315797292,
0.0640780628,
0.0269912127,
0.0260233153,
-0.0264896508,
0.0640093163,
-0.0289850403,
-0.0006343053,
0.0053783199,
0.0034388455,
0.0380192362,
-0.00810875,
0.0336979888,
-0.0547488779,
-0.0090413895,
0.0180475321,
-0.0354902633,
-0.0039711655,
0.0233116355,
0.0137203094,
-0.0003338546,
-0.0038165606,
-0.0414691828,
0.0568558276,
0.0055007488,
0.0218227543,
-0.0303440895,
0.0235744175,
-0.0098227058,
0.0153214084,
-0.0082048373,
0.0264628083,
-0.0256134253,
-0.0229640733,
-0.0562727749,
0.0354781002,
-0.0034118257,
0.0059243222,
-0.0306427553,
-0.0080644665,
0.0215862356,
-0.0294368267,
0.0275310501,
-0.0102740498,
-0.0365580879,
-0.0243043993,
0.0105952295,
-0.0302075334,
0.0701798946,
0.1077346429,
-0.0098688053,
0.0178144667,
-0.0129304146,
-0.026757028,
-0.0545196496,
-0.0199336987,
0.0212205406,
0.0551426895,
-0.0219611935,
-0.0197974406,
0.0165741257,
-0.0822422728,
0.0092287436,
-0.0069012404,
0.0424389392,
0.0137598822,
0.0136346323,
0.0409591794,
-0.0321025103,
-0.0230294745,
-0.0779761523,
0.0019848065,
0.0327932872,
-0.0198531281,
0.0053622392,
-5.725198951e-33,
0.0205437597,
-0.008468668,
-0.0344490521,
0.0437840074,
0.025673287,
0.0215036403,
-0.0004282128,
-0.0066104382,
-0.0005597002,
-0.0547821112,
-0.0522742309,
0.0034745219,
0.0172576159,
0.0564557947,
-0.0326708108,
-0.015656786,
0.0548286438,
-0.0094654635,
-0.0327468701,
0.0240213983,
0.0782258511,
0.056214489,
0.0491080321,
-0.0611670427,
0.0422691405,
-0.0017288045,
-0.0377596729,
0.0203787629,
-0.0303834081,
0.0545964353,
-0.0252184346,
-0.0042846338,
-0.0021058207,
-0.0183572527,
-0.0061647077,
0.0245688669,
-0.0552626029,
-0.0174728073,
-0.0175824165,
-0.0046716016,
0.0140563706,
-0.0702059492,
0.0303431526,
-0.046652019,
0.0046014697,
0.0163979493,
-0.024044374,
0.0148335714,
-0.0592647791,
-0.0169283245,
0.0238254126,
0.0066326344,
-0.0159142315,
-0.0248694159,
0.067638427,
0.0320135467,
0.0042658956,
-0.0375888348,
-0.0724941567,
0.0136716804,
0.0356801674,
0.0242578685,
0.0489427969,
0.0311998166,
0.0401834957,
0.0548342168,
0.0556075275,
0.0000552623,
0.0140280481,
-0.0058499705,
0.0008714746,
0.0067940489,
-0.0014892065,
-0.0198875032,
0.0316588283,
-0.0591060556,
-0.0183634683,
-0.0007547729,
-0.021763321,
0.0099032996,
0.0516035818,
0.0317195021,
-0.0251798127,
0.0031270543,
-0.0691429004,
-0.0232090615,
-0.0414773673,
0.0157918073,
0.0087615959,
0.0426604673,
-0.0490218885,
-0.0155518148,
0.0129070496,
-0.0225284044,
-0.0504305661,
0.0443744436,
0.0583292954,
-0.0357669778,
-0.0210847612,
-0.0147808334,
-0.04866831,
-0.019018691,
0.0293085091,
-0.0327347778,
0.0206107814,
-0.0213344619,
0.0753261074,
0.0196672995,
-0.0525201671,
-0.0188736394,
-0.0260573607,
0.0528972782,
0.035925813,
0.041633822,
0.0589946359,
-0.0137839261,
-0.0015661673,
0.0189445224,
0.0222418979,
0.0133151347,
-0.0444798358,
0.0296761803,
-0.0138980029,
-0.0130418399,
0.0062057828,
-0.0408369601,
0.0465701558,
0.0088685481,
0.0680886358,
0.0115167098,
0.0185667258,
-0.0125738755,
2.606e-7,
-0.0520835593,
-0.0107091404,
0.0221319906,
-0.0431007184,
0.0189094022,
0.063625291,
-0.0015902832,
0.0550723486,
0.0003230001,
-0.0019414607,
-0.0021879491,
-0.0171754435,
0.0505755283,
0.0168514028,
-0.095665358,
-0.0369484313,
-0.0427838936,
0.0141951377,
-0.0465356074,
-0.0049365154,
-0.0011355317,
0.0996956229,
0.0561752729,
-0.0322881974,
-0.0279869251,
-0.0453602299,
0.0192723405,
-0.0619242713,
-0.0333977677,
-0.0288599283,
0.0472464487,
0.0867972299,
0.0279554483,
-0.0276904684,
-0.0476580001,
0.0408922881,
-0.0399472676,
0.099282138,
0.0256111063,
-0.0705794767,
0.0109198708,
0.0158985648,
-0.0126706278,
-0.0094432235,
0.0534336492,
0.0201350152,
-0.0359616727,
-0.0221350491,
0.0072437534,
-0.0510991476,
0.0431139953,
-0.0093616657,
0.0028495684,
0.0515641347,
0.0001512086,
0.01316234,
-0.0044418676,
-0.0878863186,
-0.010834462,
-0.059856236,
-0.0339672752,
-0.0017129423,
0.007371726,
0.0130974874,
-0.0355494581,
-0.0344192162,
0.0623551719,
2.138267387e-34,
-0.0165567007,
-0.0460104421,
-0.0016608126,
0.0454163663,
0.020698268,
-0.0148065984,
0.0329675861,
0.0233085845,
-0.0030954357,
-0.0603741296,
-0.0317935087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14088v1 | ReaLHF: Optimized RLHF Training for Large Language Models through Parameter Reallocation | 2024-06-20T08:04:07 | 2024-06-20T08:04:07 | Zhiyu Mei, Wei Fu, Kaiwei Li, Guangju Wang, Huanchen Zhang, Yi Wu | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) stands as a pivotal
technique in empowering large language model (LLM) applications. Since RLHF
involves diverse computational workloads and intricate dependencies among
multiple LLMs, directly adopting parallelization techniques from supervised
training can result in sub-optimal performance. To overcome this limitation, we
propose a novel approach named parameter ReaLlocation, which dynamically
redistributes LLM parameters in the cluster and adapts parallelization
strategies during training. Building upon this idea, we introduce ReaLHF, a
pioneering system capable of automatically discovering and running efficient
execution plans for RLHF training given the desired algorithmic and hardware
configurations. ReaLHF formulates the execution plan for RLHF as an augmented
dataflow graph. Based on this formulation, ReaLHF employs a tailored search
algorithm with a lightweight cost estimator to discover an efficient execution
plan. Subsequently, the runtime engine deploys the selected plan by effectively
parallelizing computations and redistributing parameters. We evaluate ReaLHF on
the LLaMA-2 models with up to $4\times70$ billion parameters and 128 GPUs. The
experiment results showcase ReaLHF's substantial speedups of $2.0-10.6\times$
compared to baselines. Furthermore, the execution plans generated by ReaLHF
exhibit an average of $26\%$ performance improvement over heuristic approaches
based on Megatron-LM. The source code of ReaLHF is publicly available at
https://github.com/openpsi-project/ReaLHF . | [
0.0519744419,
0.0483810939,
-0.0194672532,
0.0226274114,
-0.0298838858,
0.0105693704,
-0.0295097437,
0.0084912041,
-0.0032082479,
-0.0437028855,
-0.0308928173,
-0.0198817644,
-0.0145056108,
-0.0180357695,
-0.0028487002,
-0.0725874677,
0.034843754,
-0.0592577532,
-0.0024895305,
-0.0108501902,
-0.0121199582,
0.0063360287,
-0.0128831444,
0.0216308385,
0.0172167867,
0.01411111,
-0.028268829,
0.0287804119,
0.041863285,
-0.0220873058,
-0.0153100435,
0.0208278131,
0.0361048691,
0.0587764531,
0.00000248,
-0.0252008867,
-0.0241636522,
-0.0082071787,
-0.0106909527,
0.0469167493,
0.0914422721,
-0.0035306518,
-0.0334515125,
0.0551922061,
-0.0013339501,
-0.0248186979,
0.0387169197,
0.0146384714,
0.0512439795,
0.0720350966,
-0.0030242677,
-0.0105533339,
0.005243348,
-0.0347872153,
-0.0284094084,
-0.0139503516,
0.0273172837,
0.0054330612,
0.0283306371,
-0.0257664584,
-0.0119800493,
0.0235767197,
0.0280376244,
-0.0027031307,
-0.014118067,
0.0194203723,
-0.0367610157,
-0.0027959018,
-0.0258354209,
0.0594856478,
-0.0517586283,
-0.037726175,
0.0249394123,
-0.0099859769,
-0.0496985652,
-0.0002400362,
-0.0205290597,
0.060165152,
-0.000899639,
-0.0010798055,
0.0406608805,
-0.0617950968,
0.0511719361,
0.0132721635,
-0.009046806,
0.0941784754,
0.031411726,
-0.001087053,
0.0076873321,
-0.0053981952,
-0.025325831,
-0.0419274718,
0.0083822384,
0.035377495,
-0.0695067942,
0.0416646004,
-0.0474703424,
-0.0307414867,
0.0147446133,
-0.0426628962,
0.0506828912,
0.0408467352,
0.0412109978,
0.0204743296,
-0.0409649238,
0.0373967104,
-0.0543043055,
0.025142502,
-0.0590285808,
0.0064149788,
-0.0132037755,
0.0027726239,
-0.0347010754,
0.0346801542,
-0.0407367758,
-0.0415166169,
-0.0429357886,
0.0367080458,
-0.0253133886,
0.0093169762,
0.0165451709,
-0.0074561834,
-0.0152939977,
0.0219636243,
-0.0314779058,
0.0252441559,
-0.0448584706,
-0.0076918006,
-0.0180464368,
-0.0453858189,
0.004570656,
0.030146122,
-0.0175954178,
0.0047871931,
0.0369262658,
0.0603130572,
-0.0099937245,
-0.0220444296,
-0.0734354034,
-0.0022453764,
0.0427512228,
-0.0704586506,
0.0007271056,
-0.0755847916,
0.0224048812,
-0.0022110748,
0.0131480834,
0.0224310756,
0.0161168147,
0.0335733779,
-0.0211371873,
0.0504148677,
0.0134561351,
0.0283872429,
0.0496042632,
-0.0160573833,
-0.010016894,
0.0896370634,
0.0362393707,
0.0457643233,
0.0037719761,
0.0021760371,
0.0069179516,
0.0379444137,
0.001764182,
0.0624529794,
-0.0210320372,
0.0130479317,
0.0236688275,
0.0724635571,
0.0667538196,
0.0414553806,
-0.0427567586,
0.0198847279,
0.0304772872,
0.0776768029,
-0.0265872385,
0.0042713191,
0.0382767878,
0.0179160628,
0.0002396797,
-0.0523011908,
-0.0483684242,
0.0178480688,
-0.0011478155,
0.0023424653,
0.0192353781,
0.0278716143,
-0.0004043257,
-0.0001779679,
-0.0148062669,
-0.0021242155,
-0.0103825312,
0.0224275757,
0.051775448,
-0.0164769329,
-0.0752956644,
0.0183379035,
0.0651969239,
-0.0410901457,
-0.0285427272,
-0.0406227484,
0.0308807977,
0.0829485208,
0.0477543287,
-0.0365920179,
-0.0060028308,
-0.0051624002,
0.0027611633,
0.0315234289,
0.0424993336,
0.0139656793,
-0.0153067904,
-0.0478007272,
-0.0117652742,
0.0103511736,
-0.0063153114,
0.0620932728,
0.0557191595,
-0.0048157349,
-0.0226786397,
0.0349530391,
-0.0904154629,
0.0306961481,
-0.0148948394,
-0.0146281151,
0.0164617505,
0.0041618468,
0.0499749556,
-0.0307468921,
-0.0105382791,
-0.0110158026,
0.0420335531,
-0.0159724541,
-0.0097361282,
-0.0424034782,
-0.0333196148,
-0.0145371016,
0.0253095217,
0.0137142325,
0.0321810134,
0.035363473,
-0.0375587493,
-0.040249154,
0.0315891802,
-0.0263143424,
0.0690026581,
0.0082516521,
0.0408330895,
-0.0186477546,
-0.0062697548,
-0.0417090505,
0.0308794249,
-0.0036681755,
-0.014970107,
0.0039822846,
0.0259220954,
-0.013755233,
-0.0623035617,
0.0185397454,
0.0153372725,
0.0140387407,
0.0196385682,
-0.0232544597,
0.0068584299,
-0.0099101895,
0.0012849041,
-0.0545286573,
0.0323473364,
-0.0199280716,
0.0104471846,
0.0238921791,
-0.0023804405,
-0.0059901248,
-0.0260766391,
0.0106192976,
0.0424000062,
0.0105962986,
0.0045030662,
0.0004403789,
0.0153999953,
-0.0497971661,
-0.0299356524,
-0.034692958,
0.003084078,
0.0302340407,
-0.005826131,
0.0216773115,
-0.0535619929,
0.0354689658,
-0.0077924426,
0.0466043316,
-0.0115692643,
-0.0529774725,
-0.0058056246,
-0.0341243967,
0.0136789829,
0.0944529697,
-0.028326815,
0.0093831047,
0.0633036569,
0.001885362,
-0.0651326701,
0.0450248905,
-0.0365603715,
-0.0461861081,
-0.0308620278,
-0.0113106947,
-0.0033987307,
0.0482676029,
-0.0193052292,
-0.0010727436,
-0.0485203937,
-0.0591694042,
-0.0105989333,
-0.0495977886,
-0.0206211098,
-0.0156893767,
-0.0309473854,
0.0235348362,
-0.0177013017,
-0.088435851,
0.0541077219,
-0.0376112163,
-0.0037903651,
-0.0401053503,
-0.0464731194,
-0.0410896353,
0.0069529419,
0.0306817535,
0.0394673161,
-0.0749330744,
0.0009085831,
-0.0111067826,
0.0220272914,
0.0013147709,
-0.0168825965,
0.0540875047,
-0.022080943,
-0.0096045835,
-0.0224647801,
-0.0498713441,
-0.0268767551,
0.0338327251,
-0.0379127339,
-0.00715162,
0.0446814857,
-0.083324112,
-0.017712798,
0.0021792713,
0.0306397229,
0.0713749751,
-0.0352407359,
-0.0104820095,
-0.0255567078,
-0.0146441059,
0.0485402048,
-0.025207499,
0.0382835977,
-0.0082046511,
0.0070702257,
0.0388390049,
0.0811789781,
-0.0276024994,
-0.0511753671,
-0.0051748333,
0.0361921489,
-0.0559468493,
0.0090002986,
0.0277932938,
0.0015234282,
-0.0740559325,
-0.0181783661,
0.0683919638,
0.0332455114,
-0.0943633914,
0.0099304439,
-0.0164495222,
0.0941348448,
0.0339585803,
0.0771584585,
-0.0404886454,
-0.0165528674,
0.0192060787,
0.0420511514,
-0.0057774414,
-0.0097355414,
0.0095966915,
-0.1609376371,
0.0415493064,
0.0028641669,
-0.044311557,
-0.01043218,
-0.0740759224,
-0.0069065671,
-0.0115976585,
0.0039936802,
0.0258980431,
-0.0080705574,
-0.0010131629,
0.0009350785,
0.0049427077,
0.0070904759,
0.0026037828,
-0.0351239219,
0.0363898091,
0.0358979851,
0.0029612065,
-0.0090721715,
-0.0170141831,
-0.0202946626,
0.0384951457,
-0.0180518012,
-0.0487309769,
0.0246776901,
-0.015038128,
-0.0035011361,
-0.0151507314,
0.0246135313,
-0.0462178737,
-0.0172874946,
0.0378011912,
0.1148734242,
-0.0125054866,
0.004306125,
-0.00352039,
-0.0157142654,
0.007312017,
0.0653425455,
-0.0072422563,
-0.0399154648,
-0.0170053318,
-0.0319717452,
-0.0356659666,
-0.0305036809,
0.0010537161,
-0.0201956686,
-0.0141029609,
0.0157217439,
-0.0189860892,
0.0336794853,
0.0361489765,
0.0457799546,
0.0302592758,
-0.0182182007,
0.0228364933,
0.00324,
-0.060674917,
0.0223723389,
-0.0468143225,
0.0323412009,
-0.0928962156,
-0.0163990427,
0.0306905434,
-0.0207636263,
0.0003506399,
0.0438030809,
-0.0852450654,
-0.0680271387,
-0.0116711613,
0.0535688698,
0.0133863119,
0.069983311,
-0.0049460698,
-0.0497922525,
0.0277589187,
-0.0150374481,
-0.0686935037,
0.0354379937,
0.0117928386,
0.007285588,
0.01206706,
0.015679948,
-0.0203802567,
-0.0015714525,
0.0221607294,
0.0078892633,
-0.0223325584,
-0.026257107,
-0.0210533999,
0.0416893661,
0.0080442512,
-0.0189814828,
-0.0225368645,
-0.0297702309,
0.0390129872,
-0.0027446011,
0.0031185625,
-0.0355779342,
0.0293213092,
0.0414965004,
0.0046388786,
-0.0061156051,
-0.0478551462,
0.0759918988,
-0.0200550724,
0.0214631557,
0.0120913703,
0.0133299427,
0.0060629994,
0.0538190082,
0.0312485341,
0.0300423726,
0.0003795712,
0.0071481848,
0.052882418,
-0.0216221139,
0.0481176898,
0.0250358414,
-0.0378516018,
-0.0412920825,
-0.0078330822,
-0.0381634459,
-0.0868590623,
-0.0206205342,
0.0174177065,
0.073111482,
0.03715837,
0.0467265062,
-0.0395093635,
-0.0291072894,
0.0097186798,
-0.0111797694,
-0.0549559966,
-0.0038217246,
0.0371637456,
0.0437433571,
-0.0276343115,
0.0375372656,
0.0188833475,
0.0218249746,
0.0576588847,
0.004830326,
-0.0189520586,
-0.0331733339,
-0.0391108505,
0.0144226281,
0.0255079307,
-0.0383724719,
-0.0250270665,
-0.0006194393,
-0.0397336632,
-0.0141755249,
0.0016194163,
-0.0446710549,
-0.0542655289,
0.0477797538,
0.0272088479,
-0.0112385806,
-0.0205702726,
-0.0647480562,
0.0083173085,
-0.026345307,
-0.0251127034,
0.0098768435,
-6.984277562e-33,
-0.0118100718,
-0.015269178,
0.0357210673,
-0.0153548764,
-0.0302264355,
-0.0158879273,
-0.0247961935,
-0.0051924726,
0.0127883255,
0.0128633408,
-0.0204210263,
0.0135417841,
0.0204190761,
0.0001099102,
0.0178674683,
0.0113556916,
0.0227649193,
-0.0124548739,
-0.042891629,
0.0354565755,
0.0233347453,
0.0193651933,
0.0421932787,
-0.0179847572,
-0.076349549,
0.0146313198,
0.000031928,
0.0692839324,
-0.0618685968,
0.048767142,
-0.0217105709,
0.0369226411,
-0.0279720109,
-0.0631852522,
0.0090667084,
0.0141294505,
-0.0646447316,
-0.0118528055,
0.0124958362,
0.0264938492,
-0.0760515779,
-0.0261815935,
0.0407351665,
0.0371371284,
-0.0131793041,
0.0266631935,
-0.0039002316,
-0.0065877312,
-0.0511214398,
0.0180227794,
-0.0429839231,
0.0084695499,
0.0222786982,
0.042348288,
0.0525130183,
-0.0114325695,
-0.0213472154,
0.0323347785,
-0.0641504452,
0.0096337963,
0.0311280582,
0.0315959789,
0.0584768876,
0.0720408633,
0.0421379656,
0.0414032117,
0.015946487,
-0.0147474594,
0.0036309522,
0.0319537185,
0.0499422699,
0.0186732206,
0.0062989434,
0.0306044742,
0.0038070939,
-0.0071881865,
-0.0567016006,
-0.045576375,
0.0308802687,
0.0347464196,
0.0211176053,
0.0261505712,
-0.047949668,
-0.0379568897,
-0.0455449335,
-0.022664018,
-0.030123407,
-0.029425215,
0.0363401771,
0.0363916494,
-0.0158605948,
-0.0094954502,
0.0114031062,
-0.0181150548,
0.0140738953,
0.0315661244,
-0.0257132128,
0.0371028297,
-0.0024526808,
0.0244853701,
-0.0745716915,
-0.0482442603,
-0.0228577293,
-0.0445941612,
0.0150829758,
-0.0027560778,
0.0213013496,
0.0472819619,
-0.0825855881,
0.0219384134,
-0.0353929177,
0.038469743,
0.0120886778,
0.0521709137,
0.0254184175,
-0.0161801055,
0.0325642936,
0.0487450697,
0.0156999268,
-0.0227543693,
-0.0126642669,
-0.0066189459,
-0.0224593822,
-0.0113124531,
-0.022395324,
0.0210456271,
-0.0530307628,
-0.0060473778,
0.0539197586,
-0.0787156075,
-0.0217448194,
0.0067556878,
3.212e-7,
-0.0091270814,
0.0645911321,
-0.0091081867,
0.0269781779,
-0.0012617905,
0.0199849736,
0.0040781796,
-0.0184207149,
0.0248547327,
0.0177393891,
0.0378026776,
0.0509428419,
0.0481067337,
0.0041143778,
-0.0940150619,
-0.0216802154,
-0.0731898025,
0.0190085452,
-0.046850957,
-0.0389696397,
-0.044281967,
0.114742361,
0.0556619428,
-0.0249663945,
0.0109431213,
0.0085815992,
0.0068984833,
-0.0468471199,
-0.0107311532,
0.0301440991,
-0.0229599085,
0.0443605743,
-0.0401400477,
-0.0058577005,
-0.0113089206,
0.018822588,
-0.046614591,
0.0945635363,
0.0102161681,
-0.0252314378,
0.0259850044,
-0.0233723763,
-0.0048498684,
-0.0642859638,
0.038318526,
-0.0055835284,
0.0081693698,
-0.0336546116,
0.0421938337,
-0.0521766245,
0.0149971824,
-0.0397568531,
0.0390348025,
0.038557522,
0.0117204571,
-0.0159418192,
-0.0286726002,
-0.0622102208,
-0.0182987619,
-0.0002648215,
-0.038788639,
-0.0292015709,
-0.0847231522,
0.031062426,
-0.0091634374,
-0.047755152,
0.0033220339,
3.420281959e-34,
0.049269814,
-0.0233853813,
0.0048700077,
0.0257752612,
0.0270935819,
0.0066429842,
-0.0522632226,
0.0185430907,
0.0241321307,
-0.0902436525,
-0.0247273054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14075v1 | EXCEEDS: Extracting Complex Events as Connecting the Dots to Graphs in Scientific Domain | 2024-06-20T07:50:37 | 2024-06-20T07:50:37 | Yi-Fan Lu, Xian-Ling Mao, Bo Wang, Xiao Liu, Heyan Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is crucial to utilize events to understand a specific domain. There are
lots of research on event extraction in many domains such as news, finance and
biology domain. However, scientific domain still lacks event extraction
research, including comprehensive datasets and corresponding methods. Compared
to other domains, scientific domain presents two characteristics: denser
nuggets and more complex events. To solve the above problem, considering these
two characteristics, we first construct SciEvents, a large-scale multi-event
document-level dataset with a schema tailored for scientific domain. It has
2,508 documents and 24,381 events under refined annotation and quality control.
Then, we propose EXCEEDS, a novel end-to-end scientific event extraction
framework by storing dense nuggets in a grid matrix and simplifying complex
event extraction into a dot construction and connection task. Experimental
results demonstrate state-of-the-art performances of EXCEEDS on SciEvents.
Additionally, we release SciEvents and EXCEEDS on GitHub. | [
-0.0252390821,
0.0401951335,
0.0096714906,
0.0428355969,
0.0011921389,
0.0181966852,
-0.0267109834,
0.0452798493,
0.0544132628,
0.0120711736,
0.0151119716,
0.0342633873,
-0.0678375438,
0.1123277545,
-0.0220733956,
-0.0722601116,
0.0411672294,
0.007285045,
0.0193094537,
0.02855785,
-0.0008097145,
0.0090777464,
-0.0259190593,
-0.0079665128,
-0.0172052719,
0.011996733,
0.0024145781,
-0.0319462568,
0.0699541941,
-0.076626718,
-0.0224329904,
-0.0204925146,
0.0585030913,
0.0241290778,
0.0000017568,
-0.0493144169,
-0.0338396318,
-0.0144161899,
-0.0068405499,
0.0504767559,
-0.0379904136,
-0.0603656061,
0.0150085045,
-0.0627128258,
-0.0234704763,
-0.0464028455,
0.0193052422,
0.0573758706,
-0.0115446998,
0.0459596775,
-0.0387051329,
-0.0076637487,
0.0758790076,
-0.0122809401,
-0.0079288278,
-0.0522315428,
0.0251379963,
0.0066132951,
0.0367136709,
0.0213045273,
0.0177886598,
0.0117241191,
0.0002574596,
-0.0209579207,
0.0076911952,
0.0650619641,
-0.0090792887,
0.0091901775,
-0.0152532849,
0.0682150424,
0.0396432281,
-0.0065877503,
0.0829095021,
-0.0103585413,
-0.0280757658,
0.0226738323,
-0.0585711524,
-0.0068812184,
0.0034668264,
0.0260294713,
0.0117370458,
0.015417045,
-0.0238747932,
0.0222967472,
0.0223500468,
0.0244035218,
0.0004107401,
-0.0011507865,
-0.0465436131,
0.012561555,
0.0083197877,
-0.0441704504,
0.0518555865,
0.0168660115,
-0.0286639631,
-0.0000117844,
-0.0248351879,
0.0235048495,
0.0049782814,
-0.0412455089,
-0.0121583017,
0.0050738738,
0.0217243098,
0.0816159546,
0.0395588577,
-0.0203637816,
-0.0355133228,
0.0149242794,
0.0224897731,
0.0124226399,
-0.02840879,
0.0395947322,
0.0048473878,
0.0237508211,
-0.0451665074,
-0.00126883,
-0.0084528234,
-0.0106695192,
0.020000143,
0.0102271996,
-0.0541713834,
-0.028590491,
-0.0569239669,
-0.0321905315,
0.0094518736,
0.0284329373,
-0.0849470794,
-0.0103459703,
-0.0000835867,
-0.0191411935,
-0.0462900959,
0.0104648778,
0.0706209615,
-0.0145602506,
-0.0281777922,
0.0214804523,
0.0217804871,
-0.0320756845,
-0.0247541815,
-0.0521167666,
0.0165087692,
-0.0224205144,
-0.0089472486,
-0.0269315932,
0.0520978421,
-0.0266675018,
-0.0167457033,
-0.0251687448,
-0.0044975546,
-0.0267107282,
-0.034821067,
0.009102541,
-0.0632398129,
-0.0102218734,
0.0321154855,
-0.0004839635,
-0.0079242252,
0.0248291641,
0.0478191003,
0.0165725052,
0.0641077086,
0.0099756122,
0.0054116077,
0.0073083164,
0.0354393236,
-0.0104115279,
0.0303638019,
0.0177858733,
-0.0273332931,
-0.0082881832,
0.0386262797,
-0.0344104767,
-0.0375615098,
-0.0229512658,
0.0011541287,
0.0281229764,
-0.0462728478,
-0.0453939587,
-0.0181450583,
-0.0329787806,
0.0015328212,
0.00960878,
0.0140714692,
0.0164528005,
0.0196890831,
-0.0076626954,
0.0149223479,
-0.0222563632,
0.0108464472,
-0.0020574506,
0.0156300422,
0.0174260736,
-0.0123423217,
-0.0180694554,
0.0680745319,
-0.0155766224,
0.0025007359,
0.0127454577,
0.0495716035,
-0.0290191285,
0.0287078619,
0.0200612266,
0.0207986403,
0.0018799439,
0.0417313799,
-0.0824895203,
-0.0695770681,
0.0157548357,
0.0666321963,
0.0277095642,
0.0321365409,
-0.0394820683,
0.0092362417,
0.0046990882,
-0.0192582216,
-0.001557041,
0.0038924571,
-0.0237337165,
0.033859998,
0.0146696577,
-0.0192902442,
0.0125904623,
-0.0289657116,
0.027385056,
-0.0480317995,
-0.0231884066,
-0.0403220467,
-0.0378973037,
0.0008343276,
-0.0060266615,
-0.018195549,
0.0134556983,
0.0833020508,
-0.0576403923,
-0.0097962851,
0.01571442,
0.0344832763,
-0.0226002112,
0.0315431133,
-0.0191236008,
-0.0215800349,
0.0368852876,
-0.0411803238,
-0.0266953837,
0.003397407,
0.009113987,
-0.0200855117,
0.0225370806,
-0.0169097334,
0.0063519697,
0.0030181133,
-0.0242611244,
0.0381326303,
-0.0033169985,
0.004252438,
-0.0309828222,
-0.0384013876,
0.0111954622,
-0.0667106509,
0.002881991,
0.0474104472,
0.0004055593,
-0.0393666252,
0.0421386436,
-0.0618851036,
-0.0657012612,
0.0275407974,
-0.0187465232,
0.0473312624,
0.0161456093,
0.0557168499,
0.0189637952,
0.0046980199,
-0.0064645763,
0.0020066171,
0.0124048609,
-0.0566455349,
-0.0277932789,
0.0037986196,
0.0777586401,
0.0333649181,
-0.0023158202,
-0.0547699295,
-0.0135943843,
-0.0633098632,
0.0606379248,
0.0409955569,
-0.0645303726,
-0.0137742423,
0.0113077071,
0.0059393127,
-0.0072662467,
-0.0170137566,
0.0250037722,
0.0105704498,
-0.048606094,
0.0059403777,
0.0203003418,
0.0088670161,
0.0535633229,
-0.0187776275,
-0.061011482,
-0.0313605852,
0.0198179539,
-0.0691730231,
0.0839005485,
0.014708396,
0.0254443325,
0.0476678088,
0.0041601108,
-0.0157906376,
0.0147537421,
-0.0167322159,
0.0034883036,
-0.0324513763,
0.0228760224,
0.0043254425,
-0.0134460339,
-0.0277016163,
0.0419261493,
-0.0090018529,
-0.0148550384,
0.0414524041,
0.0362743102,
0.0015992384,
-0.0199783593,
0.0124273216,
-0.0591348186,
0.0508895814,
-0.0065580918,
0.007318615,
-0.0334376059,
-0.0283353887,
0.0301136151,
0.0166565776,
-0.0097509986,
-0.0084021138,
0.0268450044,
-0.0265244879,
0.0428145975,
-0.0152068259,
-0.0202721655,
-0.002117804,
-0.0043868516,
0.0335719101,
0.0222741198,
0.0074134264,
-0.0167418141,
-0.05288513,
-0.0048729428,
-0.0020567954,
0.0390413143,
-0.0157743953,
-0.0137218088,
0.0034737978,
0.0754178464,
0.0516176485,
0.007497123,
0.0061408719,
0.0043083499,
-0.0370106176,
0.0868990943,
0.0325898118,
0.0045964452,
-0.0020117601,
-0.0027182521,
-0.001564591,
-0.04428396,
0.0317779183,
-0.0355093181,
0.0669023544,
-0.0834300742,
0.0075368872,
0.057833463,
0.040217001,
-0.0030290748,
0.0170340687,
0.036236424,
0.0145390341,
-0.004608369,
0.0198432934,
-0.0676174015,
0.0056597465,
-0.0278790426,
-0.0032245403,
0.0325884297,
-0.085262239,
-0.0002895271,
-0.014848059,
0.0509914719,
0.0041964315,
-0.0367880799,
-0.0363026932,
-0.0948844701,
0.0025136292,
-0.0216928739,
-0.0819408298,
0.0225707237,
0.0019783508,
-0.0148250172,
-0.0000022806,
-0.0421621725,
-0.0861045495,
0.0101132151,
-0.0328585766,
0.0118461875,
-0.03518961,
0.0593723692,
-0.0156774838,
0.0481963083,
0.0065384465,
-0.0069379951,
-0.0317775048,
-0.0102053462,
0.0607901476,
0.0405605584,
-0.0270915329,
-0.0255785882,
0.0708453879,
-0.0176286511,
-0.0638863295,
0.0107636126,
0.1178999841,
0.0133254463,
-0.0103484336,
-0.0534295291,
-0.0206253882,
0.003623409,
0.051371716,
0.0050489716,
0.0329695642,
-0.0474635325,
0.0159712881,
0.0156631824,
-0.0445464365,
-0.0041706502,
-0.0217976514,
-0.0578747019,
-0.0652884915,
-0.0800618455,
-0.0375842489,
0.0210046452,
0.0232427046,
-0.0627384484,
-0.0358947031,
-0.0002174574,
-0.0055790115,
-0.0265603792,
0.0643562973,
-0.0340585262,
0.0066963611,
0.016026035,
-0.0268138684,
0.0218931437,
0.081646964,
-0.0398802124,
0.063424781,
-0.0258904584,
-0.0492961332,
-0.0376377217,
-0.0396251827,
0.0131147215,
0.0078078704,
0.021561604,
-0.0130458111,
-0.0133480486,
0.0479349755,
-0.0248802584,
-0.0234454162,
0.0034199723,
-0.0244798027,
-0.0289823022,
0.0011192407,
-0.0026487501,
0.0548663102,
-0.0471055172,
0.065441981,
-0.0900970921,
-0.0088397553,
-0.0014392268,
0.0436310247,
0.0634897649,
-0.0015914132,
-0.0554482527,
-0.0686526969,
-0.0314737856,
-0.0285508931,
0.0245865602,
-0.0149628269,
0.0235670228,
-0.0398522951,
-0.0166074503,
-0.0256887544,
0.0694031045,
-0.0271436814,
-0.0009284631,
-0.0771991611,
0.0141126988,
0.0441879891,
-0.0303359088,
0.009326105,
-0.0053199767,
-0.0227536745,
-0.0110536525,
-0.0287316646,
0.0214658659,
-0.0500382856,
-0.0262167621,
0.0647812635,
0.0231678952,
-0.0041952468,
-0.0261889957,
-0.0756362081,
0.0561836883,
-0.0076503525,
0.0205616523,
0.0406429581,
0.0055479873,
0.0461457036,
-0.0280733425,
-0.0170081463,
-0.0129051646,
0.0370438546,
0.0013507829,
0.0331353918,
0.0305625983,
0.0364856049,
-0.043534033,
-0.0129523398,
0.0605827197,
-0.0157146677,
0.0636616349,
0.019557042,
-0.0207858253,
-0.0270731747,
-0.0177009255,
-0.0007151212,
0.0060579316,
0.0153213348,
-0.0108981254,
-0.057109274,
0.037242461,
0.0673909932,
0.00228307,
-0.0486576296,
-0.0154720983,
0.0056007849,
0.0226284154,
0.030175129,
-0.0043152939,
0.0037833385,
0.0369583741,
-0.0160407238,
-0.0696353614,
-0.0163783897,
-5.93235632e-33,
-0.006577848,
-0.0298181046,
0.0032357834,
0.1150954738,
-0.0174800418,
0.0326131098,
-0.0465836525,
-0.0343020931,
0.0225755852,
0.0204046387,
0.0026297043,
-0.0162948649,
-0.0007304495,
-0.0456224158,
0.0188357159,
-0.0197273884,
0.0258281194,
-0.005360228,
0.00783851,
0.0438708179,
0.073354274,
0.0477482863,
0.0453197099,
-0.0993394479,
0.0078838635,
0.0200102087,
0.0310279354,
-0.026880797,
0.0832178071,
0.0383282267,
-0.0266067069,
-0.0163867809,
0.0241270289,
-0.0717156604,
-0.0163268354,
-0.0158202145,
-0.0764139593,
-0.0116467699,
-0.028934991,
-0.0336764269,
0.0025433279,
-0.0298754871,
0.0047019441,
-0.0092355879,
0.026070701,
-0.0434066392,
0.0229641311,
-0.0084009403,
-0.0498089045,
-0.0681716576,
-0.0379789546,
0.0736150593,
-0.0289812014,
0.0373588726,
0.0265397727,
-0.0202351715,
0.024049703,
0.0688446686,
-0.0010809444,
0.0485037714,
-0.0021526397,
0.014135493,
-0.02465491,
-0.0503984205,
0.0033104471,
0.064784579,
0.0011962677,
0.0020661156,
-0.0043633254,
0.0682048798,
-0.004642297,
0.0544543639,
-0.0010669249,
0.0330044292,
0.0421919562,
0.0092207929,
-0.1141242087,
0.075237304,
0.0178436358,
-0.0375043452,
-0.0523917787,
0.0542812832,
-0.0215606447,
0.0137068555,
0.0316483639,
0.0634376556,
0.0058763386,
0.0187063273,
0.0013847132,
-0.0044521755,
-0.0297698583,
0.1147183776,
0.0081155375,
-0.0004032113,
-0.0701626092,
0.0177558009,
-0.0132470168,
0.025225373,
-0.0010330396,
-0.0333807543,
-0.0426541679,
-0.0631372556,
0.0009787824,
-0.0150966048,
0.0268495865,
-0.009318959,
0.0297796205,
-0.0078910971,
-0.0235062502,
0.0080268187,
0.0013912603,
-0.0269534942,
-0.0032755088,
-0.0226188619,
0.0149001544,
-0.0028766994,
0.0215699896,
0.0578473024,
0.04984859,
0.0689159781,
0.0177250206,
0.0268019661,
-0.0044582211,
0.0369784795,
0.0140312761,
-0.0268352311,
-0.0325960442,
0.0138927633,
-0.0102348533,
-0.032858707,
-0.0175362322,
0.0055528805,
2.458e-7,
0.0523848236,
0.0535934716,
0.0483945571,
0.0629443154,
0.0224607233,
-0.0053682071,
-0.019137647,
0.0255201142,
-0.0349441953,
0.0257423688,
-0.0445973687,
-0.0010574762,
0.0147386184,
0.0799667388,
-0.0613259077,
-0.0539317541,
-0.0461196229,
-0.0371739641,
-0.0779561624,
-0.0499607548,
0.0632476211,
-0.0027340613,
0.032219328,
0.0083060367,
0.0083593829,
-0.0351680852,
0.0496543385,
-0.0146005051,
-0.0302659273,
0.0617399774,
-0.0104074748,
0.029927386,
-0.0329313539,
0.0146519085,
-0.0450508595,
0.012548116,
0.0056561534,
0.0734515935,
0.0093857851,
0.037313465,
0.0552527606,
-0.0223573353,
-0.0050636968,
0.0250273664,
0.049708318,
-0.0642826781,
-0.0353982039,
0.0033048892,
-0.0096247653,
0.0328573361,
-0.0355335847,
-0.0115409857,
-0.0117349401,
0.0460316464,
-0.0200907327,
-0.0012123859,
0.0074002226,
-0.0498847067,
0.0101318443,
0.0589383394,
-0.0128751388,
-0.0298327338,
0.0101391412,
-0.0329697393,
-0.0273306537,
-0.0028602711,
-0.0277537927,
2.244145908e-34,
0.0274236202,
0.0323966816,
-0.039083425,
0.0250457041,
0.0183697212,
-0.0409244932,
-0.0202515647,
-0.0042371135,
0.0111239813,
-0.0248866901,
0.0132073145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14051v1 | How Many Parameters Does it Take to Change a Light Bulb? Evaluating Performance in Self-Play of Conversational Games as a Function of Model Characteristics | 2024-06-20T07:17:09 | 2024-06-20T07:17:09 | Nidhir Bhavsar, Jonathan Jordan, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | What makes a good Large Language Model (LLM)? That it performs well on the
relevant benchmarks -- which hopefully measure, with some validity, the
presence of capabilities that are also challenged in real application. But what
makes the model perform well? What gives a model its abilities? We take a
recently introduced type of benchmark that is meant to challenge capabilities
in a goal-directed, agentive context through self-play of conversational games,
and analyse how performance develops as a function of model characteristics
like number of parameters, or type of training. We find that while there is a
clear relationship between number of parameters and performance, there is still
a wide spread of performance points within a given size bracket, which is to be
accounted for by training parameters such as fine-tuning data quality and
method. From a more practical angle, we also find a certain degree of
unpredictability about performance across access methods, possible due to
unexposed sampling parameters, and a, very welcome, performance stability
against at least moderate weight quantisation during inference. | [
0.0290126503,
0.0677731335,
-0.0373549834,
0.0662331507,
-0.0233430751,
-0.0031051505,
-0.0032158718,
-0.0032363243,
-0.0088739339,
-0.0341116674,
-0.0726250187,
-0.028956918,
0.0091369674,
0.0165257864,
0.0445891581,
-0.0232386459,
0.0163880289,
-0.0576898642,
0.0038509993,
-0.0404929034,
-0.0562846772,
-0.0673412383,
-0.0160013214,
0.0450004414,
0.0184138361,
0.0148343807,
-0.0152653437,
0.0019958464,
-0.0275971517,
-0.0193246752,
-0.0191255081,
0.0370172486,
0.0061636409,
0.0318057351,
0.0000019409,
-0.0489181243,
0.0310881101,
-0.0313678347,
-0.0427137315,
0.039385166,
0.0529486239,
0.0076924684,
-0.0136831338,
0.0170947108,
-0.0435515121,
-0.0252043512,
0.0342498906,
-0.0022235543,
0.0396447293,
0.0985836163,
0.0138458982,
-0.0174792316,
-0.0022842153,
-0.0461570881,
-0.0217128042,
-0.0674028024,
0.0102381455,
0.0170013774,
0.0414857268,
0.0267618597,
-0.0396222882,
0.0210531913,
0.0184215251,
-0.0076026912,
-0.0397743173,
0.0420097522,
-0.0364724025,
0.0223892108,
-0.0184771903,
0.0535750836,
-0.0013765283,
0.0143424859,
0.0209059678,
0.0031667189,
0.0295775458,
-0.0139768906,
-0.0355061702,
0.0398926958,
0.0426326655,
0.0128772678,
-0.0107722338,
0.0340836234,
0.0455192253,
0.0085176826,
-0.0059848898,
0.0649591982,
-0.0130079454,
-0.0297699012,
0.0029617101,
0.0059789973,
-0.0115793021,
-0.0628767833,
-0.0781427175,
0.0172948334,
-0.0482094437,
0.020362094,
-0.0199482273,
0.0403191745,
0.0157388896,
-0.0383341685,
0.0524043031,
0.0317375958,
0.0367094725,
0.0467291996,
0.0386132561,
0.0352823175,
-0.001264756,
0.0280266926,
-0.0196034797,
0.0098166233,
-0.0410105549,
-0.0162140895,
-0.0550028346,
0.0350359082,
-0.0201487783,
-0.0540775172,
-0.0435509011,
0.0186542459,
0.0073038088,
0.0273086466,
-0.0215733219,
-0.0139738163,
-0.0306161251,
-0.0033175298,
-0.0473700315,
0.010596293,
-0.0516024195,
0.0266764499,
0.0192546044,
-0.101569809,
-0.0250560176,
-0.017820362,
-0.0116280355,
-0.046107769,
0.0147328787,
0.0747831166,
0.0065062363,
-0.0641409606,
0.0148588475,
-0.0057852012,
-0.0352978855,
-0.1155224741,
-0.0086084167,
-0.0409559235,
0.0199262965,
-0.0142680965,
0.0009939478,
-0.0357586034,
0.0044006789,
-0.0402745269,
-0.0035251526,
0.0618687682,
0.0287815835,
0.0126333153,
0.0091621904,
0.0235921498,
-0.0168417376,
0.1143222079,
0.0526915342,
0.0003558129,
0.0306020696,
-0.0249943472,
0.0208556224,
0.0512367189,
0.0130501045,
-0.0002408041,
0.0147093916,
0.0034166072,
0.0357250236,
0.0713499486,
0.0206459016,
0.0383304283,
-0.0738711581,
-0.0421762541,
0.0945315585,
0.0479975082,
0.0325049013,
-0.0116042346,
0.01795041,
0.0330762081,
0.0320947543,
0.0142695056,
-0.0443103388,
0.0020825374,
0.0117591117,
0.0110296384,
0.0400791094,
0.0160977114,
-0.0414166227,
-0.0520822071,
0.0137556503,
-0.0088623045,
0.016299013,
0.012094208,
0.0448240787,
-0.0213577282,
-0.0279664118,
0.0205435846,
0.0269504152,
-0.0257766731,
-0.0193400718,
-0.0819123536,
0.0060312124,
0.0264298059,
0.0452681668,
-0.0113514001,
0.0005341842,
0.0180518646,
0.0157234818,
0.0457061939,
0.0603582226,
0.008183822,
0.072005026,
-0.0083915628,
-0.0055425535,
-0.0627355799,
0.0141262794,
0.0481290668,
-0.0246873628,
0.00063339,
-0.0169747956,
-0.0054389718,
-0.0027979985,
0.0163701195,
-0.0191838089,
-0.0652822852,
-0.001805866,
-0.0277120303,
0.0471716486,
-0.0245828908,
-0.0215088967,
0.0090729799,
0.0104157608,
-0.0134953968,
0.0177227035,
0.0144746657,
-0.0414132811,
-0.0266649108,
-0.0018006319,
0.0011310095,
0.0253332909,
0.0417991057,
-0.0013681254,
-0.0335411541,
0.0695423707,
-0.0372475795,
0.064609006,
-0.0103227105,
0.0304759964,
-0.0145764006,
0.0332919359,
0.0010112948,
0.0309864134,
0.01321771,
0.0045618745,
-0.0295246523,
0.0347579308,
-0.0081995185,
-0.0965338275,
-0.0185079332,
0.0395945124,
-0.0259316247,
0.0036282816,
0.0171343572,
-0.0298599899,
-0.0404199064,
-0.0439892225,
-0.1173058003,
0.0027813509,
-0.022224104,
-0.0107461242,
0.0102809835,
-0.015201713,
-0.0263011809,
0.0003995987,
0.000977674,
-0.0292977542,
0.0301378332,
0.0426598191,
0.0112526231,
0.0591170006,
-0.0314845182,
-0.0437423773,
0.0054428652,
-0.0009688173,
0.0543115176,
0.0006448595,
0.0159018729,
-0.0452278629,
0.017075913,
-0.0155220916,
0.0478019863,
-0.0630415827,
-0.0600239486,
0.0404104106,
0.0051301457,
0.0267888643,
0.110483259,
-0.0028956076,
0.0320233367,
0.0564578064,
-0.0481905192,
-0.0409099683,
0.0358700901,
-0.0261853002,
-0.0466080047,
-0.1043508723,
-0.0449647158,
0.0281169489,
0.0926902816,
-0.008381661,
0.0173658635,
-0.0479380898,
0.0590525679,
-0.0047698002,
-0.0831246823,
-0.0234638005,
0.0134428367,
-0.0239540953,
0.0133638317,
-0.0114167808,
-0.0206361301,
0.0381723046,
-0.0389673747,
-0.0276935957,
0.0088488897,
-0.000524057,
-0.0142162321,
0.085951075,
0.0348344222,
-0.0107876183,
0.0039925599,
-0.0136465542,
-0.0254656654,
-0.0403865203,
0.060990084,
-0.0204004217,
0.0152610308,
-0.0661960468,
0.0275690407,
0.0005595689,
-0.0706209987,
-0.0144852065,
-0.0255212113,
-0.0214042421,
-0.0139165996,
0.0275140703,
-0.0192304235,
-0.0374254063,
0.0197607372,
0.004804844,
0.023132598,
-0.0188606009,
-0.0225083549,
-0.0144495545,
-0.0034771829,
0.0472126193,
0.0361572169,
0.0212658681,
-0.0372753516,
0.0800232664,
0.0263790675,
-0.0084101614,
0.0194616783,
-0.0287449714,
0.018221708,
-0.0041209762,
-0.0132054035,
-0.0198833421,
0.0501512326,
0.0719611943,
-0.0474377312,
-0.0432682857,
0.0910775885,
-0.0003174407,
0.0087687569,
0.0112619642,
0.0067961845,
0.0204381216,
0.007714076,
0.0234266371,
-0.0579396114,
-0.0118140262,
0.0166541189,
0.0210943799,
-0.0309888832,
-0.0414057858,
-0.0147701995,
-0.1501725167,
0.0314422995,
0.0030794903,
-0.029669378,
0.0070817946,
-0.0243440084,
-0.0072291675,
-0.0619838536,
0.0383086763,
0.0144923814,
-0.0120469444,
-0.0236516446,
0.0155202299,
-0.0124994917,
-0.0555706583,
0.0189042836,
-0.0353726409,
0.0989128202,
0.0121250469,
0.0364103056,
-0.014453602,
0.0012600247,
0.0212034062,
-0.0092859939,
-0.0246008914,
0.0091137225,
0.0614733957,
-0.0076623051,
0.0010949493,
0.0287646912,
0.0154939033,
0.0425125249,
0.001119168,
0.0112866741,
-0.0047169402,
-0.0063993069,
-0.0471295454,
0.0358319283,
0.0039442517,
0.0227656066,
0.0802035928,
0.010620947,
-0.0408153273,
-0.0237598401,
-0.0056473725,
-0.0255482644,
-0.0194505416,
-0.0511441529,
-0.0144907068,
0.0341601186,
0.0043296772,
-0.0422825217,
-0.0540719479,
-0.0078270454,
0.0382050648,
-0.0190626532,
0.0371649265,
-0.0056447415,
0.021735033,
0.0189544931,
0.0161096454,
-0.0394774973,
-0.0072941864,
-0.0624339916,
-0.0374810174,
0.0353519022,
-0.0341583565,
-0.0066071148,
-0.0066766599,
-0.0864231661,
-0.0738365874,
0.0303271879,
0.0713473484,
0.0353668816,
0.0416019112,
0.0152639812,
-0.0677393079,
-0.0058491742,
0.0090713715,
-0.038211517,
0.0512772053,
0.0330154896,
0.0100527378,
0.0121389944,
0.0415246338,
-0.0150139695,
0.0328288972,
0.0203465223,
0.0636248365,
-0.051195126,
-0.031053843,
-0.0047174334,
-0.0282754079,
0.049804505,
0.0169841219,
-0.0099767875,
0.018494729,
0.0107072964,
-0.0488085561,
0.0144351069,
-0.0426661633,
-0.036373347,
0.0268568378,
0.0597376786,
0.0110569084,
-0.0232843589,
-0.0150870103,
0.0062604011,
0.0025842253,
-0.0128038162,
0.0052906238,
-0.0208693817,
0.0265720673,
0.020221293,
0.0046786568,
0.0561368652,
0.0211167186,
0.0589988939,
0.0340946764,
0.0259920359,
0.0318909325,
-0.035262011,
0.0009089728,
0.0148032289,
-0.0708963946,
-0.0635296032,
0.0186983738,
0.0408080183,
0.0262605064,
0.0026054853,
0.0149099529,
-0.0413627028,
0.018483432,
-0.0185031779,
0.0024807618,
-0.0037757268,
-0.0455138013,
0.0328234658,
0.0394541621,
-0.0312290024,
0.0141909467,
0.0640113503,
0.0501432233,
0.0506264232,
0.0054815556,
0.0298971459,
-0.0385461859,
-0.0456527583,
-0.0047073495,
0.0065716947,
-0.0270014517,
0.0058546504,
-0.0386351906,
-0.0531145521,
-0.0128358463,
0.0508773103,
0.0194596369,
-0.0208321847,
0.0322173201,
0.0542876907,
-0.0025649611,
-0.0083360253,
-0.0435199589,
-0.0090766307,
-0.0309576504,
0.0147883315,
-0.0089847455,
-6.382008623e-33,
-0.0323943272,
-0.0051165675,
0.0606360771,
-0.0219444055,
0.0043162443,
-0.000290943,
-0.0460441038,
0.0316902511,
-0.0335847735,
-0.0207011383,
-0.0266353358,
-0.0014597125,
0.0269528553,
0.0193331018,
-0.0006763142,
-0.0332260877,
0.0303467251,
0.0064632138,
-0.0636140928,
-0.0119687403,
-0.0260496177,
0.0097469278,
0.0356421433,
-0.0086593637,
-0.0029408154,
-0.0100380089,
-0.0207360871,
0.0360698141,
0.0068263276,
0.0414305739,
-0.0147553962,
0.0144036962,
-0.0017810423,
-0.0300969593,
0.0019031189,
0.0066569778,
-0.0190418828,
-0.0384811945,
0.0329378843,
0.0131408265,
-0.014783673,
-0.0046654711,
0.015132064,
-0.0032522187,
-0.0694171935,
0.0068166838,
0.0009112757,
-0.0122908773,
-0.0292922836,
0.0118484022,
-0.0356428847,
0.010891241,
-0.0116905356,
-0.0156048788,
0.0196249932,
0.0009442875,
-0.0081173051,
-0.0174315348,
-0.0256498326,
0.0270471387,
0.0600220971,
0.0475177169,
0.022043597,
0.0616956651,
0.0673970431,
0.0404473543,
0.051619336,
0.0380763672,
-0.0199149996,
-0.03769603,
0.0486553647,
0.0502812825,
0.029613629,
0.0294384956,
0.0025072133,
0.00651955,
-0.0589510798,
-0.0221081395,
0.0691483393,
0.0237069782,
0.0052407826,
0.0220764149,
-0.05339754,
-0.0298166107,
-0.0528401881,
-0.0118610905,
-0.0092137894,
-0.0440651961,
0.031756863,
0.0318917334,
0.0035791709,
-0.0060976385,
0.0481232628,
-0.0419339053,
-0.0596537553,
-0.0140603743,
0.0027788461,
0.0383995846,
-0.015841864,
0.0007343579,
-0.0552193299,
-0.0367648192,
0.0075428113,
0.0210118517,
0.0163111258,
-0.0063824081,
-0.0149494978,
0.0416938327,
-0.0437771901,
-0.0203044843,
-0.0216017403,
0.0492643751,
0.0029227391,
-0.0213661622,
0.0438244641,
-0.0318299755,
-0.0184390694,
0.0399549417,
-0.0209789239,
-0.0193713922,
-0.0509302542,
0.0218314435,
-0.0104721813,
0.0114720277,
-0.0167842451,
0.0002947112,
-0.0612428002,
0.0241744909,
0.0395470522,
-0.0263015646,
-0.0295704585,
-0.0322269946,
2.809e-7,
-0.0055151116,
0.047511667,
-0.0163778495,
0.0321730636,
-0.0055252933,
0.0388698392,
-0.0597377755,
0.0124705862,
0.0138239665,
-0.0030004203,
0.0310803298,
0.0692573041,
0.0505018272,
0.0054684444,
-0.0794146657,
-0.0128315538,
-0.0733542815,
0.0007845426,
-0.0336516462,
-0.0486191064,
-0.0034987896,
0.0764868483,
0.0221700259,
0.0160847586,
0.0071727438,
-0.0719863251,
0.0608507618,
-0.0820037797,
-0.005317729,
0.0448400453,
-0.0011618992,
0.0224002078,
-0.0164564028,
-0.0143328691,
0.0232625045,
0.0463242196,
-0.0476764627,
0.0607718341,
0.0362077802,
-0.031526316,
-0.0084956093,
-0.0113553647,
-0.0041510761,
-0.0252772365,
0.0727465451,
-0.074676469,
-0.0619454123,
-0.0225269254,
0.0108105242,
-0.0252777301,
0.0256260503,
-0.0358094238,
-0.041216433,
0.0007518915,
0.0264100954,
-0.0260107517,
0.0390804783,
-0.069659628,
-0.007227439,
-0.0096745761,
-0.042774383,
-0.0883268192,
-0.0572316833,
0.0029833836,
0.0077969837,
-0.0484660044,
0.0097330352,
2.216299778e-34,
0.0549857467,
-0.0134239001,
0.0378147922,
-0.0073859054,
0.0483879223,
0.0116342343,
0.0137816295,
0.0161537062,
0.049355302,
-0.0662259087,
-0.0012384555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14048v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14048v1 | Prompt Injection Attacks in Defended Systems | 2024-06-20T07:13:25 | 2024-06-20T07:13:25 | Daniil Khomsky, Narek Maloyan, Bulat Nutfullin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models play a crucial role in modern natural language
processing technologies. However, their extensive use also introduces potential
security risks, such as the possibility of black-box attacks. These attacks can
embed hidden malicious features into the model, leading to adverse consequences
during its deployment.
This paper investigates methods for black-box attacks on large language
models with a three-tiered defense mechanism. It analyzes the challenges and
significance of these attacks, highlighting their potential implications for
language processing system security. Existing attack and defense methods are
examined, evaluating their effectiveness and applicability across various
scenarios.
Special attention is given to the detection algorithm for black-box attacks,
identifying hazardous vulnerabilities in language models and retrieving
sensitive information. This research presents a methodology for vulnerability
detection and the development of defensive strategies against black-box attacks
on large language models. | [
0.0484716371,
0.0392989404,
0.001808233,
0.0632185191,
-0.052601207,
-0.0145269856,
0.0253852401,
0.0014131366,
0.0194030236,
-0.0795949847,
0.0295830537,
-0.0050775073,
0.0098780179,
0.0688129514,
0.0622292571,
0.0368194394,
0.0589363314,
-0.0208875984,
-0.0268016271,
-0.0083624078,
-0.0224671792,
-0.0219007041,
0.0176910739,
0.0448267423,
0.0050622034,
-0.0113878362,
-0.014151467,
0.0065991594,
0.0098391417,
-0.027213715,
-0.0171350259,
0.0088555925,
-0.0011127915,
0.0564520918,
0.0000018316,
-0.0347517766,
-0.0868608952,
0.0451732613,
-0.0589989275,
0.003795478,
-0.0113004483,
-0.0113623701,
-0.0481452681,
0.0392410122,
-0.0040877555,
-0.0076994486,
0.0286402553,
0.05734431,
0.0891193077,
0.070194304,
-0.0130235776,
0.0022635558,
0.0378413759,
0.0230177436,
-0.0413077138,
-0.0185560174,
0.0516051985,
-0.0504947305,
0.0115866084,
0.0439861342,
0.0101862988,
-0.0153615847,
0.0032883014,
-0.0366887599,
-0.060244225,
0.0193656478,
-0.0167365745,
-0.0068334057,
-0.0171013121,
0.0091433581,
-0.0402374305,
0.0269730724,
-0.0152536239,
0.0220035613,
0.0085852034,
0.0040122001,
0.0306298826,
0.0356568024,
0.0030944748,
-0.0300846528,
0.0161782205,
-0.0330455415,
0.0160273816,
-0.0072485022,
-0.0074544009,
0.0687244684,
0.0554834232,
-0.0420455001,
-0.01085837,
-0.0691781417,
0.0234235357,
-0.0682089552,
-0.0038830426,
0.0099282479,
0.0154343741,
0.0470407978,
-0.0610884726,
-0.0542461835,
0.0354637466,
-0.0531093366,
0.0105621759,
0.0184176024,
-0.0389078148,
0.0220261533,
0.0182401631,
0.0314326175,
-0.0164731946,
0.0012810583,
0.0522634573,
0.0159219094,
-0.0331454389,
-0.0362564847,
-0.0217040572,
0.0330525078,
0.0169766396,
0.0201465525,
-0.0010898968,
0.0545810126,
-0.0160993189,
0.083771579,
-0.0274408348,
-0.0224436559,
0.0500288904,
0.0143809365,
0.0330411196,
-0.0385271795,
0.0178005379,
-0.0453230254,
-0.0514383577,
-0.1176024675,
-0.0101272836,
-0.012098304,
-0.0238638651,
-0.020967124,
-0.0177281518,
0.0619280003,
0.0667987093,
-0.0054856045,
-0.0727538243,
-0.1248410717,
-0.0238152463,
0.0186271723,
-0.0197740942,
-0.0540249385,
-0.0678749606,
-0.015877299,
-0.0270687919,
-0.0352751501,
-0.0091200322,
-0.0055574784,
-0.0231271423,
0.0663969442,
-0.0297981519,
-0.0374877714,
0.0034766572,
0.0126873311,
0.0069055171,
0.0389584973,
-0.0091263093,
0.017447615,
0.0274012387,
-0.007862322,
0.0259050895,
0.0371832475,
-0.0232166406,
0.009713579,
-0.044968158,
0.0352315679,
0.0554428808,
-0.0429863036,
-0.0500049032,
0.0367425755,
0.0093199406,
-0.0466452353,
0.0755457133,
0.0737652481,
-0.0785601661,
0.004780821,
0.0281073749,
0.0133320149,
-0.035343226,
-0.0145055065,
-0.0243232381,
-0.0473314449,
-0.0566697158,
-0.0528686717,
-0.0266844872,
0.039235089,
0.0324838497,
-0.016303258,
-0.0116950199,
-0.0150016621,
-0.0009832357,
-0.021368023,
0.023676604,
0.027369272,
0.0309208836,
0.0469717868,
-0.0004426074,
0.0141911572,
-0.0128908772,
-0.0804785341,
-0.0403654166,
0.064065367,
0.0710151792,
-0.0215972774,
-0.0154708801,
-0.0383288115,
-0.0296515916,
0.0127382968,
-0.0214539133,
0.0330853388,
-0.0341466404,
0.0108587006,
-0.0299346391,
0.0334337056,
0.0399421714,
0.0310101695,
-0.0252707992,
0.0233845431,
0.0008954567,
0.0552461073,
-0.043303363,
0.0160351619,
0.0173561927,
-0.1063024029,
0.0017914607,
0.0168881398,
0.021758968,
0.013133917,
-0.0317530558,
0.0359750949,
0.0460382849,
0.028019065,
-0.0282102413,
-0.0079477709,
0.0142706344,
0.0424563363,
0.0288621224,
0.0109266508,
0.0178051423,
0.0479480661,
0.0004254804,
-0.0265028048,
0.0633998439,
-0.0584613122,
0.015706718,
0.0122844065,
0.0030187413,
-0.011734548,
0.0503565744,
-0.0481614955,
-0.0272913575,
0.0147779016,
0.0052462928,
-0.0272610076,
0.0026421461,
0.0057353149,
-0.013693003,
-0.0472993962,
0.0297456831,
-0.0215008836,
-0.0078816526,
-0.0264891516,
-0.026743222,
0.0077115428,
0.0185548849,
-0.0186205171,
-0.000039339,
-0.0186027382,
0.0357307009,
0.0323655754,
0.0322572216,
-0.0389696546,
-0.0361900888,
0.0189109016,
-0.0368463956,
-0.0206151586,
0.0204349179,
0.0182508752,
-0.0041740756,
-0.0549173765,
0.0159070734,
-0.011129885,
-0.0344363786,
0.0951772109,
0.0055667316,
-0.0074079875,
-0.0475610867,
0.016435666,
-0.0149863008,
0.0324115567,
0.0030247609,
-0.0399599485,
0.0186170414,
-0.0128265694,
-0.0224913489,
0.0471278206,
0.0173882004,
0.0215222146,
0.0583486259,
-0.0184786189,
-0.0338913165,
-0.0372308642,
0.030353725,
-0.0148421414,
-0.0542416424,
-0.0120128226,
0.0534201451,
0.0351058245,
0.0452180617,
-0.0309910867,
0.0020528806,
0.0155262016,
-0.0058180233,
0.0078087384,
-0.0227706227,
-0.0886419341,
-0.0675374195,
0.0139975939,
0.0201523788,
-0.0479630567,
0.0607265756,
-0.0796001032,
0.0167778023,
-0.0434487052,
-0.0461912379,
0.0263894293,
0.0316407457,
0.0058047702,
0.0097999219,
0.0431073755,
-0.0476400629,
-0.0232655723,
-0.0113560194,
0.0420209095,
-0.0326915979,
-0.0018006158,
-0.0106665576,
-0.0218950771,
-0.0233329926,
0.006733696,
-0.0638454631,
-0.0372728445,
-0.0448565856,
-0.015511157,
-0.0076882346,
-0.0190241523,
0.0217884593,
-0.004675759,
0.0218520109,
0.030494513,
-0.0013429131,
-0.0130139263,
-0.0419055372,
0.0169944391,
0.007790965,
-0.0835602432,
0.018575158,
0.0227390323,
0.0375738256,
0.0558752939,
0.0360595509,
-0.0012578067,
-0.0266658515,
-0.0081966072,
0.0128942234,
-0.0201562643,
0.0114107821,
0.0411820114,
-0.0415680148,
-0.0508209541,
-0.009008239,
0.0703022927,
0.0323489346,
-0.0365568064,
-0.0012821996,
-0.0456051752,
-0.0078012361,
0.0034059107,
0.0368789844,
-0.0532678179,
0.0092004081,
0.0296355598,
0.0243346579,
-0.0325701237,
-0.0126691572,
-0.0322321355,
-0.132655248,
-0.0021706973,
0.0069041424,
-0.007879843,
-0.0216355827,
-0.0169353038,
-0.008316474,
0.03890156,
0.0437489599,
-0.0065794121,
0.0334742442,
0.008542086,
0.018414814,
-0.060447678,
-0.0244825445,
0.0274568461,
-0.0372094214,
0.0432298779,
0.0643210262,
-0.024585966,
-0.0405028649,
0.0456725284,
0.0579513833,
0.0038831618,
-0.0134918718,
0.0223102141,
0.0140064955,
0.0256273746,
-0.0280799307,
0.0473542586,
0.0101446658,
-0.0273596924,
0.0200835187,
0.0266817883,
0.0599928312,
-0.0445618182,
0.0343967602,
-0.0179398544,
-0.0203045066,
0.0594438799,
0.050617706,
0.0046691387,
-0.0362671055,
-0.0184196476,
-0.0510844924,
0.0125890113,
-0.0183769315,
-0.0520921648,
0.0437857769,
0.0011046325,
-0.0794422701,
-0.0451974496,
0.0077397428,
-0.0153346965,
0.0400183685,
0.0564014949,
0.0003367474,
0.0307848305,
-0.0040255818,
-0.0145358471,
-0.0068073934,
-0.0152965374,
0.0449742824,
-0.0388077199,
0.0564659387,
-0.0121860318,
0.0096337711,
-0.0462973118,
-0.0189305954,
-0.0254973639,
-0.0797219351,
0.0413945802,
0.0599967465,
0.01810438,
-0.0026305523,
-0.0445264615,
-0.0673365444,
0.0523375794,
0.0069801938,
-0.0013580426,
-0.0354892723,
0.0470082499,
-0.031676963,
0.0179784987,
-0.0029824446,
-0.0205317121,
-0.02198717,
0.0537746847,
-0.0447815396,
-0.0377605408,
-0.022552738,
-0.0101641426,
0.0649710894,
0.0338833071,
0.0008137058,
0.0045931209,
0.0343553647,
0.0344497524,
-0.034982916,
-0.035501875,
-0.0004484964,
0.0436026752,
-0.0280590616,
0.0031881223,
0.0388698764,
-0.0459074005,
-0.0151563939,
0.0092591187,
0.02033039,
0.0407615118,
0.0665262267,
0.012254253,
0.0689907968,
-0.0065515987,
0.0073925056,
0.04665263,
0.0329543613,
0.0433140993,
-0.0171048176,
0.0297735389,
-0.0120581174,
-0.0188089255,
-0.0186994635,
0.0396542028,
-0.0419612415,
-0.0247425027,
0.0470457189,
0.0332285352,
-0.0053878445,
0.0081530688,
-0.0064042099,
-0.0116006136,
0.0162386708,
-0.0104122497,
-0.0491144992,
-0.0111178737,
-0.0070263413,
0.026628796,
0.014610026,
-0.001215789,
0.0359498411,
0.0430648103,
0.0087903757,
0.0520181172,
-0.0013880397,
-0.0624382868,
-0.0292789731,
0.0271368381,
0.0206613708,
0.0105836634,
-0.0586587936,
-0.0182482097,
-0.0673878118,
-0.078262724,
-0.0020780368,
-0.0088945339,
0.0215798616,
0.0388377942,
-0.0096417675,
0.0522566549,
0.0360919908,
0.0543658435,
-0.0797528923,
0.036944747,
-0.0298183095,
-0.0609993637,
0.029157456,
-5.064535493e-33,
0.023544997,
-0.0608422197,
-0.0563177988,
-0.0225050841,
0.0385545753,
0.0191680659,
0.0121095758,
0.0045129545,
0.0061002094,
-0.0158204809,
-0.002170545,
-0.0157041103,
0.0194909126,
0.0137455976,
-0.0156835169,
0.004529573,
-0.0110266386,
-0.0015983394,
0.0013993334,
-0.008707216,
0.1142111868,
0.0014352371,
0.0210272763,
-0.0369749554,
0.0448721685,
-0.0195050314,
0.0035325603,
0.0250632688,
-0.0184643082,
0.0472884327,
0.0168287251,
-0.0046250927,
0.0011613279,
-0.0547785908,
-0.0010205158,
0.0720847398,
0.0174470283,
-0.0120381797,
-0.0215615295,
0.0257670805,
0.049497813,
-0.0486193821,
0.0344518609,
-0.0306960195,
0.0060104444,
0.030649906,
0.0081914496,
-0.0282777064,
-0.005317545,
-0.0058757365,
-0.009293329,
-0.0028010015,
-0.0436916165,
0.0453383811,
0.0099441046,
-0.0071232957,
0.0564562306,
-0.0381727107,
0.0041325237,
0.0163581986,
0.0426038951,
0.0209348835,
0.0197935496,
0.0315033533,
0.0113027906,
0.0313743837,
-0.0050500692,
-0.0216935426,
0.0204248745,
0.0293955822,
-0.0162330121,
0.011133723,
0.0469066687,
0.0275799502,
0.0256466065,
-0.0104092229,
-0.0140733551,
0.0266814046,
0.0207227357,
0.0235259961,
0.0534222089,
-0.0235385131,
-0.0636308789,
0.0041321209,
-0.0049433303,
-0.0081783757,
-0.0464875326,
-0.0089931516,
-0.0024603789,
-0.0088184271,
-0.038786348,
-0.0126445917,
0.0210090764,
-0.059243124,
0.008858637,
0.0133765638,
-0.0003137648,
-0.0580617972,
-0.0013705292,
0.010399689,
0.0602183379,
0.0163584482,
0.004798851,
-0.0562250428,
0.0203165691,
-0.013384941,
-0.0021852693,
0.0289183296,
-0.0866809338,
-0.0135244243,
-0.0079262126,
0.0344744585,
0.018763965,
0.0726348236,
0.0427496508,
-0.0288959537,
0.0070601865,
-0.009997095,
0.055298347,
-0.0074651903,
-0.0104568209,
0.0177416336,
-0.0473316871,
-0.0155128492,
-0.0243839659,
0.0111080632,
0.0136611471,
0.0599699616,
0.0610569902,
0.0066255145,
0.0198561773,
-0.0407176763,
2.761e-7,
0.0136583084,
0.0155031411,
0.0198199935,
0.0042946152,
0.0537624583,
0.0650527328,
-0.0074863746,
0.0513700061,
-0.0086090676,
-0.0302209407,
-0.0099767521,
-0.0489862375,
0.029906325,
0.0045356918,
-0.0787087679,
-0.0194605161,
-0.0861948356,
0.006463387,
-0.080774188,
-0.0143487873,
0.06978257,
0.0985103771,
0.0099415397,
-0.0479805544,
-0.0074841995,
-0.0743258297,
-0.0299527422,
0.0113548022,
-0.001484126,
-0.0512176156,
0.0419554785,
0.041277986,
0.0247102063,
0.0497088954,
-0.0513501763,
0.0094950944,
-0.0710428208,
0.0236307085,
0.0103570744,
0.0265925881,
-0.0288797207,
-0.0585840791,
-0.0002224668,
-0.0202669296,
0.0707613975,
0.0424162373,
-0.0172416233,
-0.0471769311,
-0.0213941429,
-0.0733171552,
0.0088286735,
-0.0372501016,
-0.0074028699,
0.0424767993,
-0.0129426178,
-0.0286532901,
0.0571463816,
-0.0905974954,
-0.0498601086,
-0.0030422057,
-0.0244425051,
-0.0293511637,
0.0250334311,
0.0150212627,
0.0333053432,
0.0040031322,
0.007812182,
2.998858281e-34,
-0.0348440334,
-0.0277908444,
0.0025661844,
0.0202600472,
0.0207044948,
0.0244817175,
-0.0168694835,
0.0140584996,
0.0170521159,
-0.0177526828,
-0.0381935388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14043v1 | Taxonomy-Guided Zero-Shot Recommendations with LLMs | 2024-06-20T07:06:58 | 2024-06-20T07:06:58 | Yueqing Liang, Liangwei Yang, Chen Wang, Xiongxiao Xu, Philip S. Yu, Kai Shu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | With the emergence of large language models (LLMs) and their ability to
perform a variety of tasks, their application in recommender systems (RecSys)
has shown promise. However, we are facing significant challenges when deploying
LLMs into RecSys, such as limited prompt length, unstructured item information,
and un-constrained generation of recommendations, leading to sub-optimal
performance. To address these issues, we propose a novel method using a
taxonomy dictionary. This method provides a systematic framework for
categorizing and organizing items, improving the clarity and structure of item
information. By incorporating the taxonomy dictionary into LLM prompts, we
achieve efficient token utilization and controlled feature generation, leading
to more accurate and contextually relevant recommendations. Our Taxonomy-guided
Recommendation (TaxRec) approach features a two-step process: one-time taxonomy
categorization and LLM-based recommendation, enabling zero-shot recommendations
without the need for domain-specific fine-tuning. Experimental results
demonstrate TaxRec significantly enhances recommendation quality compared to
traditional zero-shot approaches, showcasing its efficacy as personal
recommender with LLMs. Code is available at
https://github.com/yueqingliang1/TaxRec. | [
0.0489097238,
-0.0028523221,
0.0126089705,
0.0068329396,
-0.006709333,
-0.0196035206,
0.0281703584,
0.0172340125,
0.0424481444,
-0.0637764111,
-0.0596530996,
-0.003919844,
-0.003418003,
0.0639946684,
-0.012875082,
-0.0219111927,
0.0214669183,
-0.0491217077,
0.0079256278,
-0.0103736566,
-0.0077852663,
0.033790458,
0.0183137376,
0.0356586576,
0.0283190962,
-0.0149141103,
-0.0082054026,
0.0302639324,
-0.0440960824,
-0.0362435058,
0.015554687,
0.0384780839,
0.0069904136,
0.0222188216,
0.0000023821,
-0.0453675576,
-0.0193100665,
-0.0217192825,
-0.003124425,
-0.0464869738,
0.0715113655,
0.0643335655,
0.0211026873,
0.0103152329,
-0.0173184518,
-0.0287581105,
0.0215736218,
0.0492057279,
0.0068652635,
0.0424006097,
-0.0186202116,
-0.0224800371,
-0.0027220149,
-0.0198506825,
0.0479971133,
0.0183609892,
-0.0088610807,
-0.056821242,
0.0578711815,
0.0519181155,
0.0036932165,
-0.03933933,
-0.0204843711,
-0.0159384869,
0.0829084441,
0.0315937698,
-0.0343729332,
-0.0486833006,
-0.0046090991,
0.0809472054,
0.0166804232,
-0.0221062582,
-0.012592176,
0.0148507357,
0.0054828539,
0.015385516,
-0.0425042249,
-0.0194187965,
0.0089297034,
0.0070803831,
0.0031422738,
-0.0129614668,
0.039368473,
0.0252531283,
0.0074332063,
0.1065293178,
0.0236662477,
-0.0189094469,
0.0012288301,
-0.0047221952,
0.0093296599,
-0.0984326005,
-0.0085821738,
0.0406141393,
-0.0710805357,
-0.0114327511,
-0.009766032,
0.070138827,
0.0323870704,
-0.0008340658,
0.0265656952,
0.0394424088,
-0.0139582679,
0.0315137133,
-0.0039089485,
0.0123158703,
0.024186803,
0.0053094453,
-0.0761723965,
-0.0364180245,
-0.0508618318,
0.0009170267,
-0.0154826781,
0.0650612488,
-0.0199553315,
-0.0278029926,
-0.050614778,
0.0310240742,
0.0123070125,
0.0302514955,
-0.0060432176,
0.0257081855,
0.0205056574,
-0.0008485036,
-0.0603399128,
-0.0021794024,
-0.0612312853,
0.0017855866,
0.0273498911,
0.0033142704,
0.0159765221,
0.0446617641,
0.0028111578,
-0.0383044109,
0.0033279331,
0.0034585574,
0.0283918139,
-0.0493834056,
-0.0347289741,
-0.0535402484,
-0.0145610683,
-0.0287068281,
-0.0288340356,
-0.0894168243,
0.0018526191,
0.0516736098,
0.0208959542,
-0.01161916,
0.0121450704,
-0.0017866184,
-0.0342925526,
0.0643018484,
-0.0102715679,
-0.0121663911,
0.0121407285,
0.0109153055,
-0.011402118,
0.0185233019,
-0.0292165112,
0.0752325356,
0.0522078797,
0.0227442347,
0.0254869573,
-0.0173209906,
-0.0477605574,
0.0340564586,
-0.0690482259,
0.0302635785,
-0.0097311856,
0.0307469964,
0.0417941138,
0.0360328481,
-0.0435963906,
0.0150053613,
0.0546408519,
0.0645565316,
0.0602186322,
0.0501744077,
0.0296748672,
0.0384315141,
-0.0567593388,
-0.0320888236,
-0.0007311869,
0.0497450083,
-0.029165227,
-0.0342642404,
0.05138769,
0.0087015796,
-0.0488742217,
-0.0130065326,
-0.0012700285,
-0.0671795383,
0.0059895781,
0.0191546157,
0.008045651,
-0.0249073487,
-0.0190712195,
0.0375406668,
0.0375801474,
-0.0442930907,
-0.0013804886,
-0.0479188748,
0.0842340812,
0.1555962861,
0.0656319484,
0.0084356396,
-0.0439244173,
-0.0222151522,
0.0052242391,
-0.0088742403,
0.034319222,
-0.0376228169,
-0.0016897876,
-0.0569006093,
-0.0650203452,
0.0080421874,
-0.0091137374,
0.0195979886,
-0.0087221488,
0.0457557365,
0.017992923,
-0.0289412327,
0.0162736364,
-0.0059357728,
0.018097017,
-0.0452014543,
0.0533786938,
0.0061249109,
0.0006653928,
0.0139062619,
0.0482432507,
-0.0132895811,
0.0252202842,
-0.021236077,
-0.0003711921,
-0.0563274771,
-0.0233230256,
0.0264154635,
0.0413765162,
0.0359460637,
0.0206962191,
0.0106361341,
0.0049113105,
-0.0425992906,
-0.0212505981,
0.0399742685,
0.0422481485,
-0.0217201021,
0.0219153203,
-0.0048266496,
0.0134588517,
-0.024641389,
0.0325383581,
0.0384419635,
0.0242286194,
-0.0130705992,
-0.0323929302,
-0.005360188,
-0.0320409425,
-0.0037912566,
0.0176106896,
0.0221398883,
0.0248270519,
0.0143055776,
0.0313026384,
-0.0298752505,
-0.0212095231,
-0.0798905268,
-0.0096064955,
0.0092812069,
-0.0072413776,
-0.0265963804,
0.0506987348,
0.0094136382,
-0.0043276832,
-0.0403671712,
0.0205379501,
-0.0203894582,
0.0085225543,
-0.0021063441,
-0.019156849,
-0.0393137299,
-0.0144743752,
0.0006972143,
-0.0019538379,
0.0400679,
-0.0217628665,
0.0119725298,
-0.03966989,
-0.0423260145,
-0.0544764698,
-0.037459176,
0.0137617784,
0.0207377654,
-0.0214863345,
-0.0225468539,
0.0448070131,
-0.006568274,
-0.0125525007,
-0.0119911218,
0.0758463666,
0.0092258081,
-0.0719166547,
-0.0154541219,
-0.0014476482,
0.0039829719,
-0.0020478829,
0.0050040893,
0.0092630479,
0.0122702708,
-0.0415781885,
0.0038731501,
-0.0516988486,
0.0269746799,
-0.0039703925,
0.0229868088,
-0.0714483485,
0.0051023006,
0.003022922,
0.076353468,
0.01243883,
-0.0381745063,
0.0565843135,
-0.027491644,
0.0030871085,
-0.0213208441,
-0.041953776,
-0.0723824352,
-0.0187626835,
-0.0064031873,
0.0206127129,
0.0171487015,
0.0085087959,
-0.0005743949,
-0.0058670412,
0.0044294228,
-0.0227145329,
0.0544528291,
-0.0009032281,
0.0061217309,
0.0001639838,
-0.0208523218,
-0.0264273081,
-0.0291043315,
-0.0020526468,
0.0279028416,
-0.0056244722,
-0.0158957541,
-0.0325305276,
0.01931886,
0.0079667298,
0.0681070536,
-0.0251464155,
-0.041994825,
0.0219348427,
0.0172550902,
0.0555045977,
-0.0412156731,
-0.0195523445,
0.031753134,
0.0369136967,
0.035847839,
0.0083508063,
-0.0187700931,
-0.0094696879,
0.0070353798,
0.0918023512,
-0.0384394675,
-0.0549742542,
0.0494052209,
-0.0109464256,
0.0049148486,
-0.0052333828,
0.1265461147,
0.0606679171,
-0.1307071894,
0.0102961455,
-0.0606189631,
0.0376904458,
0.0415021852,
0.0270967707,
-0.0798872411,
-0.0268003996,
0.0189376716,
0.0385203101,
0.0396371335,
-0.0258633811,
-0.0165112931,
-0.0794683024,
0.0459465496,
0.0041672052,
0.0026839394,
0.0206388813,
-0.0640734285,
-0.0140806427,
0.007749307,
0.0087524317,
-0.0060953461,
-0.0119633451,
-0.0003936473,
-0.0203538109,
-0.0093593076,
-0.0055183987,
0.0394463912,
-0.0250982437,
0.0345591679,
0.0704792589,
0.044441402,
0.0271773301,
-0.0177462809,
0.0101005174,
-0.0050129374,
-0.0440795757,
-0.042154558,
-0.0053209555,
-0.0423659123,
0.0577920154,
0.0165980272,
-0.0141249876,
-0.058409702,
-0.0442740768,
0.0210460834,
0.0830452368,
-0.0066808164,
0.0190846566,
-0.0478085391,
-0.0247520953,
0.0175598115,
0.0798322782,
0.016302472,
-0.0507270657,
0.0093660671,
-0.0730051175,
-0.0397779346,
0.0230746735,
-0.0254701134,
0.0008252308,
-0.0066428804,
-0.0340500139,
-0.0608401187,
-0.0151508218,
0.0461819209,
0.0067920587,
-0.0074569019,
0.050811924,
-0.0709871575,
-0.0242037661,
0.0024975308,
0.0241552424,
-0.0262943693,
0.0258836094,
-0.1159616634,
-0.011683424,
0.0334270857,
-0.0556308925,
0.01913766,
-0.0050430084,
0.0132736014,
-0.0249139294,
-0.0325186029,
0.0241949186,
0.0175032392,
0.0244102776,
-0.0517264828,
-0.0851363018,
0.0672015473,
0.0529067963,
-0.0279636551,
-0.0116277207,
-0.0143520981,
0.0821319744,
0.0156878624,
0.046320539,
-0.0808029622,
0.0236510634,
-0.0420506783,
-0.0026288936,
-0.0190598276,
-0.0515907407,
0.0032993101,
0.0197157376,
0.0398231633,
-0.011868922,
0.0517686419,
-0.0024794994,
0.0231425315,
-0.0289437566,
-0.0372452699,
-0.030225873,
-0.0075432928,
0.0497274585,
-0.0514216088,
-0.0043623871,
0.0093209073,
-0.0512460396,
0.0394861773,
-0.0481998473,
0.0140053248,
-0.0387263186,
-0.0485678241,
0.0502683073,
-0.0040565021,
-0.0108031835,
-0.0217409879,
-0.0007006869,
0.0154386256,
-0.053332977,
0.0246788282,
-0.0086855898,
-0.0135482643,
-0.0361635461,
0.061005421,
0.0085964333,
-0.0629583299,
0.027587086,
0.050859414,
0.0234481208,
-0.0216951147,
0.0329092331,
-0.0261027776,
-0.0167124141,
-0.0370824337,
0.0124912262,
-0.0009333463,
-0.0275535025,
0.0290793218,
0.0653186664,
-0.0335959829,
0.0297452733,
0.083118856,
0.0064669964,
-0.0234230012,
0.0104287872,
-0.0460914113,
-0.0349124931,
0.0055558369,
-0.0064006536,
0.0451019332,
-0.0467441827,
-0.0109749148,
-0.0367804505,
-0.0484499894,
0.0265231952,
-0.0615406148,
0.0119540673,
-0.0401497297,
0.0441781953,
0.0505077988,
0.0138143161,
0.0000907569,
-0.0566459447,
-0.0242511705,
0.0032370333,
-0.0438179746,
-0.0363839529,
-6.917557237e-33,
0.0054685432,
-0.0387789905,
0.0303455759,
0.0160718374,
0.0400306657,
-0.0316173919,
-0.0073199957,
0.0092696147,
0.0501928851,
-0.0074814237,
-0.0054276432,
0.0002361642,
0.0066161421,
0.011236365,
0.0073201531,
-0.0065013384,
0.0494850762,
0.0317674577,
-0.0298414808,
0.0201389398,
0.0293813888,
0.0391005166,
-0.0219486635,
-0.0135011282,
0.0121285561,
-0.0250341725,
0.0139098801,
-0.0002342271,
0.0358317494,
0.0866035447,
0.00373301,
0.0614352785,
0.0094303265,
-0.0125679821,
0.034795858,
0.0110349413,
-0.0535224229,
-0.0135655403,
0.0210373625,
-0.0090739913,
-0.0005805058,
-0.0558463521,
0.0016417184,
0.0160403382,
-0.0044491403,
0.0240498446,
0.0130191455,
-0.0202289075,
-0.1007944271,
-0.0337740779,
-0.0313017927,
0.0088000884,
0.0178401154,
-0.0391168036,
0.0433834791,
0.0547467507,
-0.0235294476,
0.0859050527,
-0.0465647206,
0.0416358449,
-0.0404265262,
0.0530942492,
0.0221903957,
-0.0138046592,
-0.0682200938,
0.0185712092,
0.0281280521,
-0.0299546812,
-0.0005590643,
0.0187528729,
-0.0268561468,
0.0232950971,
-0.0137864072,
0.0164247453,
0.0567638427,
-0.0243711527,
-0.0253755525,
0.0526541881,
-0.0034059971,
-0.0000146061,
0.016560575,
0.0457655266,
-0.028016204,
-0.0325383618,
0.0087149851,
-0.0082626743,
-0.0855408981,
-0.0485914797,
0.0225060545,
0.0202473402,
-0.0117690377,
-0.0183072798,
-0.001645403,
-0.0062220893,
-0.0381117128,
-0.019250473,
-0.0217049755,
0.0119344788,
0.0188091304,
0.0154781258,
-0.0432319567,
-0.0068087317,
0.0174384806,
-0.0615244135,
-0.0178323723,
0.0301598143,
0.0622935668,
0.0197601691,
-0.0607331581,
0.0048646447,
0.0216118116,
-0.0360299423,
-0.0359311737,
0.0151724089,
0.0233412851,
0.0213094577,
-0.0042587356,
0.0840403959,
0.0144367544,
-0.0146258194,
-0.0031023056,
-0.0326750129,
0.0012579721,
-0.0064412546,
-0.0267881639,
-0.0258378182,
-0.0228404421,
-0.0115445144,
0.0713260695,
-0.0297223292,
-0.0412913524,
-0.0349632651,
3.188e-7,
-0.0131907593,
0.0691909343,
-0.0581409596,
-0.0042828349,
0.0017560991,
0.0415999927,
0.0415065698,
0.0357327387,
-0.0118017998,
0.0270497967,
0.0073317727,
0.0242888816,
0.0208835471,
0.0390309952,
-0.0864364356,
0.0592064299,
-0.0268815253,
0.0322707631,
-0.0797619224,
0.0041315486,
0.0140549187,
0.062434312,
0.0324735045,
-0.0091697378,
0.0052047134,
-0.0109082945,
0.0264327731,
-0.0610259287,
-0.0472822301,
-0.0218152255,
0.0437153205,
-0.0029535647,
-0.0199798793,
-0.0125467628,
-0.0073880781,
-0.0016464351,
-0.0309255924,
0.0528440587,
-0.0577137321,
-0.0600472689,
0.011099387,
-0.0056685801,
0.0279415622,
-0.0312636457,
0.0774628818,
0.008425965,
-0.0001350039,
-0.0121952742,
-0.0408838205,
0.0175140034,
0.0208094846,
-0.0303723291,
-0.0418040603,
0.020431038,
0.0233209245,
-0.0163009986,
-0.0327692032,
-0.047331471,
0.0135912159,
0.0027751073,
0.0007606515,
-0.0390942693,
-0.0538317375,
0.0122639304,
-0.0028905044,
-0.0553709269,
0.0306636505,
3.152341109e-34,
0.0249899719,
0.0332206488,
-0.0134685561,
0.019949032,
0.018140506,
-0.0169124827,
-0.0329256169,
0.0156242568,
0.0503836088,
-0.0375747979,
-0.022388177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14039v1 | CryptoGPT: a 7B model rivaling GPT-4 in the task of analyzing and classifying real-time financial news | 2024-06-20T06:59:46 | 2024-06-20T06:59:46 | Ying Zhang, Matthieu Petit Guillaume, Aurélien Krauth, Manel Labidi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.NE | CryptoGPT: a 7B model competing with GPT-4 in a specific task -- The Impact
of Automatic Annotation and Strategic Fine-Tuning via QLoRAIn this article, we
present a method aimed at refining a dedicated LLM of reasonable quality with
limited resources in an industrial setting via CryptoGPT. It is an LLM designed
for financial news analysis for the cryptocurrency market in real-time. This
project was launched in an industrial context. This model allows not only for
the classification of financial information but also for providing
comprehensive analysis. We refined different LLMs of the same size such as
Mistral-7B and LLama-7B using semi-automatic annotation and compared them with
various LLMs such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. Our goal is to find a balance among
several needs: 1. Protecting data (by avoiding their transfer to external
servers), 2. Limiting annotation cost and time, 3. Controlling the model's size
(to manage deployment costs), and 4. Maintaining better analysis quality. | [
0.0046988102,
0.0296517015,
-0.0139199411,
0.015967967,
-0.0314245038,
0.0143046873,
0.0408814736,
0.0162320733,
0.0144073972,
-0.0320600122,
0.0123414155,
0.0568868369,
-0.0769495741,
0.0784803778,
0.0145095363,
-0.0333172828,
0.0742287263,
-0.0249901935,
0.0061255638,
0.0041510416,
0.0310499426,
-0.0267562121,
0.0337456092,
-0.0218234919,
0.036522802,
-0.0361262113,
-0.031358242,
-0.0088598644,
0.0176151488,
0.0057364432,
-0.0290671811,
0.0343861952,
-0.0271979608,
0.0469771102,
0.0000020643,
-0.0291410498,
-0.0801857337,
0.0339902267,
-0.0284604672,
0.0204255767,
0.0152205266,
-0.052999299,
0.0229427032,
0.0225079227,
-0.0422265418,
0.0236398242,
0.0628252849,
0.0728684142,
0.0776982158,
0.0708243772,
-0.0165083911,
-0.0367208309,
0.034367308,
-0.0432185009,
-0.0146284038,
-0.0939331949,
0.023718683,
0.0466452613,
-0.0043481365,
0.0631171018,
0.015578066,
0.0534011945,
-0.0051580914,
-0.0100144036,
0.0199204925,
-0.0023950406,
-0.033444453,
-0.0084088994,
-0.0715616718,
0.0022534514,
0.0115920845,
-0.0023604373,
0.0541854836,
-0.0210484155,
-0.0280822739,
-0.0069376631,
-0.0358020179,
0.0527502932,
-0.016721921,
0.0255549327,
0.0532459877,
0.0096190171,
-0.0058022016,
0.0026666697,
-0.012186964,
0.0295817368,
-0.027514847,
-0.0027415084,
-0.0178459585,
-0.0009398334,
-0.0158035755,
-0.0451247431,
0.0122941975,
0.011131335,
0.0243787188,
-0.0067807627,
0.0113036912,
0.0131730493,
0.0275415517,
-0.1204022765,
-0.019530274,
0.036155764,
-0.0218580794,
0.0725932345,
-0.0306480527,
0.0059382776,
0.0004608115,
0.0183416922,
0.032490816,
0.0062208422,
-0.0566240884,
0.0098852022,
-0.0409466326,
0.0672955215,
-0.0224125199,
0.0174988452,
-0.0784713328,
0.0608392954,
-0.0027059754,
0.0325801745,
0.0318817571,
-0.0356605053,
0.0144964121,
0.0104808314,
0.0062104855,
-0.0449850596,
-0.0431745276,
0.0173378885,
-0.020143263,
-0.0073461952,
0.0115794614,
0.0186061412,
-0.0314760841,
-0.0152876591,
-0.0145447776,
0.0808359385,
0.059994936,
-0.0398574993,
-0.0739062876,
-0.0655479878,
0.013271573,
0.0012234582,
-0.0445527174,
-0.000230861,
-0.0283877365,
-0.0308993701,
0.006849356,
0.0852153227,
-0.0526780337,
-0.0520960912,
-0.0109454207,
0.0706336275,
-0.0412394144,
-0.0279349592,
0.0159361213,
-0.0220386256,
-0.0220733732,
0.0625434071,
-0.0197590329,
0.0640403628,
0.0288838688,
-0.018746417,
0.0204271115,
0.0238266289,
-0.0169882923,
-0.0847747028,
-0.0271020122,
0.0483910143,
-0.0341082513,
-0.0398503728,
0.0492131598,
-0.0345492698,
-0.0411978662,
-0.0389897712,
0.0682071969,
0.0206358414,
0.061904639,
0.0193383116,
-0.0485436581,
0.0114360359,
0.0228598211,
-0.0303700604,
-0.0032653909,
0.055094447,
-0.0326021202,
0.0153232776,
-0.0133637851,
-0.0040395618,
-0.0438252836,
-0.0185166243,
-0.0270293485,
-0.0150815612,
-0.017669078,
-0.0092511177,
0.0398640893,
-0.0469511561,
-0.0258656517,
0.0340272114,
0.0194967687,
0.0092227766,
-0.0433138311,
-0.0931221396,
0.0931107551,
0.0431909934,
0.014140808,
-0.0314476378,
0.0099877743,
-0.0189578794,
-0.0117708435,
0.0520810373,
0.0274162758,
-0.002409277,
-0.0626776069,
-0.0304622818,
-0.0336093381,
0.0057366528,
0.0373626612,
0.0193273947,
-0.0439504944,
-0.0034484724,
-0.0469407886,
0.0331763364,
0.0075953421,
0.0023312613,
0.0244837329,
-0.0314821266,
-0.0138904722,
0.0195130054,
0.0228171088,
0.0372361057,
0.0186711177,
0.0070160259,
0.0295868404,
-0.0157559235,
-0.01349835,
-0.0115532828,
0.0469265096,
0.0438767262,
0.0108204456,
-0.0034935577,
0.0079722544,
-0.007161295,
-0.0457839295,
-0.0322625712,
0.0384677127,
-0.0012530194,
0.0467132069,
-0.0845912695,
-0.0681252703,
-0.0267577842,
0.0155769093,
-0.0308375601,
0.0420173332,
0.0195833519,
-0.0325270183,
-0.0473889858,
-0.0536368974,
0.0130447214,
-0.0243924409,
0.0483484268,
0.0090967463,
-0.0108869821,
0.048866652,
0.0345917046,
-0.0144685945,
0.0095020775,
-0.0355071388,
-0.0653564334,
-0.0160126984,
-0.0071392963,
0.0786306262,
0.0143834408,
0.0279099178,
-0.0139123667,
-0.0272677895,
-0.0187115874,
-0.0103730597,
-0.02786972,
0.00486178,
0.0490784571,
0.0090462742,
-0.0227695461,
0.000371907,
0.0014813618,
0.0024950157,
0.0180212539,
0.0261381138,
-0.0479780212,
-0.0165859517,
-0.0420255661,
-0.0214184821,
-0.011420819,
-0.015288976,
0.0151486676,
-0.007890828,
-0.000872343,
-0.0335522145,
0.032873489,
0.00399531,
0.0606085882,
-0.0078226682,
-0.0001149818,
-0.022407148,
0.0200794283,
-0.0245887954,
0.005974927,
-0.0161422268,
0.0330651142,
-0.0115791,
0.0613261238,
-0.0359189287,
-0.0170070119,
-0.0381264985,
0.0403242074,
0.0208220724,
0.0265579335,
-0.0127091194,
-0.0168730617,
-0.0230486002,
0.0425494798,
0.0083664246,
-0.0712418929,
0.0050251707,
0.0197146386,
0.0163754486,
-0.0379921049,
-0.0804277807,
-0.0799273252,
0.0231506005,
-0.0620785467,
0.0356915742,
-0.0294828489,
-0.0187423248,
-0.0024131769,
-0.0522105582,
0.0611390434,
-0.0373538658,
0.0290533081,
0.0115819555,
0.0391792282,
-0.0159304664,
-0.0089534121,
0.0105716139,
-0.015684789,
-0.0567556992,
0.0011460276,
-0.0031065769,
-0.0402798355,
0.0003566423,
0.1172505468,
-0.0265401024,
0.0174894333,
-0.0186285451,
-0.0300785452,
0.0086599933,
-0.0005154593,
0.0005756399,
-0.037002854,
0.0425602868,
0.0109243207,
0.0654780641,
0.0320492238,
0.0231860355,
0.0075953254,
-0.0496508367,
-0.0164637771,
0.0051565436,
-0.0510116704,
-0.0224673375,
-0.017461054,
-0.036122039,
-0.0242430586,
0.0193319321,
0.1117049307,
0.0115916776,
-0.0014064694,
-0.0097084157,
0.0138189122,
-0.0344706289,
-0.0495542921,
0.0330613256,
-0.103943117,
0.0049720141,
-0.008840546,
0.0381498784,
-0.0245869216,
-0.0545366034,
-0.0349384174,
-0.0195512194,
0.0838434994,
0.0026350631,
-0.0304193962,
0.0109189637,
-0.1151650697,
-0.0251926519,
-0.0763101876,
0.0076569817,
-0.009870097,
-0.0007403245,
0.0267299488,
0.0352993459,
-0.1038878337,
-0.0095151849,
-0.0229836944,
0.0041497587,
-0.0168556608,
0.0227557234,
0.0177512933,
-0.0197317991,
-0.0105649279,
0.006072083,
0.0197913777,
-0.0262579415,
-0.0277049318,
0.0335093513,
0.0210949201,
-0.0244875271,
0.0069610695,
0.0169943012,
0.0378646255,
0.0409265086,
-0.0169280469,
0.0076090517,
-0.0143296011,
-0.0520459041,
-0.0070817294,
-0.0045416639,
-0.0225986447,
0.0443204306,
0.0301165469,
-0.0038736418,
-0.048840981,
-0.0058262232,
-0.0014438778,
-0.0425208211,
0.0186118763,
-0.0147360703,
0.0144386059,
-0.015725622,
-0.0621512383,
-0.0209720004,
-0.0672484711,
0.0385801755,
-0.0294196177,
0.0501119308,
0.0480160601,
-0.0150405187,
-0.0318681672,
0.008095637,
-0.0251436383,
-0.0098180454,
-0.0305215623,
0.0498061031,
0.0184885915,
-0.0337152332,
-0.0483872406,
0.082137078,
-0.0899880826,
-0.0280479472,
0.0032038977,
0.0021579813,
0.0446978547,
-0.0244377311,
-0.0463286787,
-0.0015122466,
0.035004504,
0.0539645962,
-0.0027531264,
-0.0499852672,
0.0204605889,
-0.000223391,
-0.0444979481,
-0.0145327356,
-0.0213866793,
0.0258176252,
-0.035052374,
-0.0564935058,
-0.0405135825,
0.0046405843,
-0.0320107155,
0.0217030216,
0.0090391804,
0.0124993874,
-0.0032159286,
-0.0066260151,
0.0005512476,
-0.0022894584,
0.014303199,
-0.0152608305,
0.0118185095,
0.0258671269,
-0.0464089029,
-0.021223316,
0.0254836697,
0.0113916351,
-0.0572068915,
-0.0301097725,
0.0014498393,
-0.0297663622,
0.0240540057,
-0.0144510102,
-0.0093471762,
-0.0216298234,
-0.0261237808,
0.0384513289,
0.037545912,
-0.0003210958,
0.001176507,
0.0130997282,
0.0163335204,
0.0241407417,
0.0148103731,
-0.0572323166,
-0.0267061945,
0.0025388387,
0.0834816322,
0.0610827282,
0.0351484641,
0.0486128591,
-0.0558204651,
-0.0146325072,
0.0080812098,
0.0443536378,
0.0048775417,
0.0101759695,
-0.0081230141,
-0.0007104234,
-0.0640143007,
-0.0366234928,
0.0585059375,
0.0159894954,
0.0169781148,
-0.0193938799,
-0.0532226078,
-0.0703858212,
0.0018243837,
0.0324340127,
0.0115498286,
-0.0134648168,
-0.0052773063,
-0.0748624727,
0.0039278986,
0.0859995261,
0.0047998908,
-0.0176296476,
0.0194312725,
-0.0207701903,
0.0459320024,
0.0002985919,
-0.0022911269,
-0.0012292311,
-0.0463173427,
-0.0401266739,
-0.0109530045,
0.0086038653,
-6.291012136e-33,
-0.023667613,
-0.0423258655,
0.0336911939,
0.027589066,
0.006757739,
0.0421095155,
-0.000627698,
-0.0548574254,
0.0221157931,
-0.0080806473,
0.0393841341,
0.0080025978,
0.036219202,
-0.0144976713,
0.0361354463,
0.0114774508,
0.024828665,
-0.0010862058,
0.0077272905,
0.0179982278,
0.0129846316,
0.0257623792,
0.042051293,
-0.0184532963,
0.0547275692,
0.0378856994,
-0.068867676,
-0.020125851,
0.0211149603,
0.0879543573,
-0.0296256654,
-0.0029265725,
-0.0036872944,
-0.0517050363,
-0.0035392756,
-0.0091509148,
-0.0342275314,
-0.037745554,
0.0198552813,
0.0341430008,
0.0449982136,
-0.0167532191,
0.0176971313,
0.017868625,
0.010784423,
0.015503942,
0.0161605645,
0.0143900001,
-0.0085616782,
-0.0703221932,
0.0056760856,
0.0490572788,
0.0032708882,
0.0746336058,
0.0572108105,
0.0264296234,
0.0198406484,
-0.0006925639,
-0.0550153404,
0.0427207574,
0.0631494075,
-0.0300781094,
-0.0059136744,
0.0258458834,
-0.0030786025,
0.0243286677,
-0.008538669,
0.0016339646,
0.0526601747,
0.0564352088,
-0.0124473572,
0.0610061884,
0.0681685135,
0.0220946521,
0.0361975804,
-0.0190274641,
-0.0736230984,
0.0254345108,
0.0227430668,
-0.021446716,
0.0332550071,
0.0208650026,
-0.0174994711,
-0.0091074556,
0.0391292572,
-0.0154241389,
0.0049377466,
-0.02841039,
-0.0045976257,
0.0394791327,
-0.0231095739,
0.0739181712,
-0.0087513309,
-0.0652997643,
-0.0799761638,
-0.0432834849,
0.0233378839,
0.0384913795,
0.0066889459,
-0.0013297943,
0.006660087,
-0.0352149196,
-0.0086570978,
-0.039901644,
-0.0148791214,
-0.0252997894,
0.0376522504,
0.0151747251,
-0.0445354991,
0.0205965824,
-0.0026357665,
0.0371275358,
-0.0133439405,
-0.0069895871,
0.0004499741,
-0.0145698572,
0.0093884701,
0.0425346382,
-0.011469787,
0.0317589119,
0.0563340224,
0.0287519228,
-0.011332537,
0.0652747303,
0.0591461323,
0.0069171735,
0.0493055657,
0.0572130457,
-0.0047695488,
-0.0114124427,
-0.0126526272,
0.0354804508,
2.869e-7,
0.0588738732,
0.0736285448,
0.0116596976,
-0.0001679142,
0.0367430113,
0.0180742033,
-0.0349882096,
0.0289787445,
-0.0521011427,
-0.0183229446,
0.0156887136,
-0.0081929369,
0.0609079562,
0.0231233407,
-0.0589776933,
-0.0582756139,
-0.0354410708,
0.0153109683,
-0.0906988457,
0.0273573268,
0.0488068983,
0.055643227,
0.0099329986,
-0.0063753976,
0.011320401,
-0.0516631566,
0.0213932786,
-0.0152118308,
-0.0366429612,
-0.0066374261,
0.0792968795,
0.0495046899,
-0.0002966959,
0.0094559016,
0.0090430826,
-0.0142670153,
-0.0175406206,
0.0281392522,
-0.0072346027,
0.0065483502,
0.0226359274,
-0.0459451936,
0.0308084711,
-0.0436302833,
0.0481100678,
-0.0010383733,
-0.0357904471,
-0.0573656224,
-0.0531977676,
-0.0114816697,
0.0572430305,
0.012424659,
0.0085568065,
0.0188717917,
-0.0237887688,
-0.0343762785,
0.0184945222,
-0.0424838215,
-0.0135558918,
0.0067721009,
-0.0419705622,
0.0029158553,
-0.0378951021,
0.0237085298,
0.0313572586,
-0.0498945303,
0.0347853228,
2.684768715e-34,
0.0640742332,
-0.0279209539,
-0.0126238903,
0.0766502023,
-0.000296084,
0.0261769276,
0.0226747766,
0.0238044355,
0.0084856469,
-0.0566481836,
0.0004231604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14036v1 | Toward Infinite-Long Prefix in Transformer | 2024-06-20T06:56:35 | 2024-06-20T06:56:35 | Jiuxiang Gu, Yingyu Liang, Zhenmei Shi, Zhao Song, Chiwun Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Prompting and contextual-based fine-tuning methods, which we call Prefix
Learning, have been proposed to enhance the performance of language models on
various downstream tasks that can match full parameter fine-tuning. There
remains a limited theoretical understanding of how these methods work. In this
paper, we aim to relieve this limitation by studying the learning ability of
Prefix Learning from the perspective of prefix length. In particular, we
approximate the infinite-long Prefix Learning optimization process by the
Neural Tangent Kernel (NTK) technique. We formulate and solve it as a learning
problem of the infinite-long prefix in a one-layer attention network. Our
results confirm the over-parameterization property and arbitrary small loss
convergence guarantee of the infinite-long Prefix Learning in attention. To the
implementation end, we propose our NTK-Attention method, which is "equivalent"
to attention computation with arbitrary prefix length efficiently. Its time
complexity mainly depends on the sub-quadratic of input length (without
prefix), and our method only requires $d^2 + d$ extra parameters for
representation, where $d$ is the feature dimension. In addition, we conducted
experiments that compare our NTK-Attention with full parameters fine-tuning,
LoRA, and P-Tuning V2 methods across vision or natural language datasets. The
results indicate our approach may be a promising
parameter-efficient-fine-tuning method since it has demonstrated superior
performance in numerous scenarios. Our code can be found at
\url{https://github.com/ChristianYang37/chiwun/tree/main/src/NTK-Attention}. | [
0.0273414664,
-0.012600068,
-0.0149617428,
0.06266471,
-0.0146583803,
-0.0117499055,
0.0009248473,
-0.0044133551,
-0.0484279804,
-0.019530464,
-0.0408498831,
-0.0514788404,
0.0319836736,
0.0325327478,
0.0755804554,
-0.0472873077,
0.0153953629,
-0.0390859619,
-0.0190127585,
0.0207500774,
-0.0148011101,
-0.0281329919,
0.0292572509,
0.0594966933,
-0.0200600885,
-0.0136006195,
-0.0096918987,
-0.0049841581,
0.0073126103,
-0.019309463,
0.0253742673,
0.0342343077,
-0.0067182272,
0.0150421271,
0.0000021942,
-0.0437339321,
-0.0060264138,
-0.0017675788,
-0.0224761982,
-0.0451701172,
0.0212268624,
-0.0083667971,
0.0157892238,
0.0180323515,
-0.030635532,
-0.0093882037,
0.0585214086,
0.0636560321,
0.0473219417,
0.0978854373,
-0.0076922514,
-0.0470592082,
0.0427467525,
-0.0631423071,
0.0015794279,
-0.0051171239,
0.0110941492,
-0.0690397024,
-0.0099434201,
0.0183477309,
-0.0612329952,
0.0637333617,
0.0392503068,
0.0114037199,
0.0389860906,
0.0340419449,
0.0075269477,
-0.0055305623,
-0.0160483234,
0.0815301836,
-0.0950892195,
-0.0055872086,
-0.0084666647,
0.0218919646,
0.0158420112,
-0.0658588409,
-0.0374027155,
-0.0098792417,
0.0153410593,
0.0057922699,
-0.0059303455,
-0.0104640909,
0.0066324924,
-0.0354179516,
-0.0268471893,
0.0564616583,
0.0105986316,
-0.0142683936,
-0.0268174168,
-0.0342737772,
0.0067956671,
-0.039491836,
0.0133477859,
0.031842161,
0.0132528096,
0.014719924,
-0.060256619,
-0.0558539107,
-0.0096671237,
-0.0672879368,
0.045299042,
0.0569241047,
-0.0301757269,
0.0267641004,
-0.0553534999,
0.0606413037,
0.0052073183,
0.0543185025,
-0.0454522893,
0.0001646729,
-0.0192071218,
0.0134596853,
-0.0783728287,
0.0097563621,
-0.0271546841,
-0.0246866588,
-0.0005677945,
0.0366828181,
0.0108964993,
-0.041000586,
0.042983301,
-0.0019391724,
-0.050764598,
-0.0302042402,
-0.0030197382,
0.0352654532,
-0.0348259769,
0.0167231932,
0.0113065215,
-0.0178483445,
-0.043003872,
0.0332984403,
0.0222342927,
-0.0237437245,
0.015180368,
0.0637305975,
-0.0128233312,
-0.0580447167,
-0.0276896209,
0.0219553951,
-0.0192346182,
-0.0376236737,
0.000740441,
-0.0705875829,
0.011380746,
0.0006510112,
-0.0049899546,
-0.0365062989,
-0.0046060309,
0.0284485333,
-0.0408420451,
0.0291706324,
0.0030728967,
0.0083930334,
0.0426915921,
-0.0002837767,
-0.0084819263,
0.0587893575,
0.0331300534,
0.0392582826,
-0.0008371958,
0.0008737685,
-0.0278742891,
0.0377593935,
0.044147741,
0.0028847007,
-0.0216619018,
-0.0143028861,
0.010137598,
0.0152261127,
0.0319832973,
0.0492250957,
-0.0127723319,
-0.0778585002,
0.0608725697,
0.0720317289,
0.0143753886,
0.024832081,
0.061723724,
0.0038841472,
-0.0313089639,
-0.0022153838,
-0.0383187048,
0.0367084332,
-0.0407455228,
0.0152037637,
0.0086180773,
0.0228524636,
-0.0586270653,
-0.034449134,
0.0007318112,
0.0054033287,
-0.0095523261,
-0.0012293768,
0.0476022288,
0.0385726541,
-0.0729158893,
0.0630754903,
0.0031227565,
-0.0125317676,
-0.0102798548,
-0.0291929822,
-0.0073215808,
0.0196483061,
-0.0325417221,
-0.0310456604,
-0.070075281,
-0.012993956,
0.0339083523,
-0.0042757392,
0.008991275,
0.0075151394,
0.0167388953,
-0.0423721895,
0.0197758079,
0.0237781499,
0.0046721874,
0.0146559607,
-0.0305704754,
0.0081825349,
0.0329111777,
-0.0017753323,
-0.0431407169,
0.045511242,
-0.0165015012,
-0.0520378388,
-0.0262682568,
0.0449523814,
0.0097135734,
-0.0083548659,
0.0288681034,
0.0266419929,
0.0359161459,
-0.0385435335,
0.0328924097,
-0.0357533507,
-0.0483626388,
-0.0384694822,
0.0508171171,
-0.0624349453,
-0.0039516734,
0.039221745,
-0.0174045321,
-0.0482480638,
0.0199814811,
-0.0438413844,
0.0391148403,
0.0032699842,
0.0590144023,
-0.0050552306,
0.0447093025,
-0.0279638469,
0.0185828544,
-0.0153842587,
0.0364891477,
-0.0031803702,
0.0220932793,
-0.0022070783,
-0.0519913919,
-0.0542368591,
-0.0117945317,
-0.0263573229,
0.0078757498,
0.0012747585,
-0.0298488904,
-0.0281857904,
-0.0217603892,
-0.0835832879,
0.0035795306,
-0.0458440557,
0.0174615011,
-0.0251670554,
0.0288102347,
0.0097200479,
-0.0298899319,
-0.0460360348,
0.023444511,
-0.0386867523,
0.0078531317,
0.0157278646,
0.007415805,
-0.0289562494,
-0.0353071503,
-0.0401100628,
0.0073677646,
0.0660010129,
-0.0179761071,
-0.0169446096,
-0.0462921783,
-0.0226866491,
0.0336078107,
0.0451251864,
-0.0335835256,
-0.020357769,
-0.022444712,
-0.0287277047,
0.0903005302,
0.0748429373,
0.0332285166,
0.0011663004,
0.0216637049,
0.0328682922,
-0.0148506658,
0.0222107917,
-0.0457823128,
-0.0321285203,
-0.0215311535,
0.0029989071,
0.010114966,
0.1065066755,
-0.0578923784,
-0.0147868441,
-0.0775048137,
-0.007368851,
0.0060950099,
0.0097765271,
-0.0180293359,
0.0250084288,
-0.0400979146,
0.0203344803,
-0.0195541885,
-0.0380983949,
0.055783838,
-0.0243440382,
-0.0246424787,
-0.0151932519,
-0.0057350355,
-0.0249202996,
0.0767112076,
-0.0023080469,
0.0044014519,
0.0309280641,
-0.0300008971,
-0.0561056174,
0.0213109553,
-0.0118693272,
-0.0086139813,
0.0793272108,
0.0209298432,
-0.0037995672,
-0.0241018385,
-0.0050382279,
-0.0291804969,
-0.0488775484,
0.0074689682,
0.0090432595,
0.0241678916,
0.0107686548,
-0.0178367645,
0.0244285129,
0.001878132,
0.0753922686,
-0.0217437986,
0.0190779064,
-0.0163327884,
0.0044453908,
0.0393459611,
0.0208314881,
0.0222558938,
-0.0302977674,
0.0208799485,
-0.0023222864,
0.0308306944,
-0.0265833996,
-0.0499648936,
-0.0191772059,
0.0208976343,
-0.00998923,
-0.0083302213,
0.0238367151,
0.0076084314,
-0.0573712699,
-0.0178912655,
0.0705148056,
-0.0018762242,
-0.0602007397,
0.0289843716,
0.0178624112,
0.0285001323,
0.043040406,
0.0184971299,
-0.0322900005,
-0.0167844929,
0.0006686192,
0.0109960306,
0.0236326903,
-0.0203405879,
-0.0110846097,
-0.0855115131,
-0.0053755874,
0.0003652431,
-0.0368349962,
-0.0520842746,
-0.0126117291,
0.0180019233,
0.026173003,
0.0043370058,
0.0301729832,
-0.0171206109,
-0.0344904885,
0.0101681445,
0.0215378683,
-0.0444505177,
0.0298505463,
-0.050959751,
-0.0195293743,
-0.0207286663,
0.004575144,
0.0196660403,
-0.0800405666,
0.0432442278,
0.0060466868,
-0.0002015478,
0.0304496214,
0.0625384524,
-0.0152630154,
-0.0244926382,
0.0392437838,
0.0170232952,
-0.0376112424,
0.0434967279,
-0.0412431918,
0.0945222452,
-0.0063275006,
0.0285636913,
0.0056321598,
-0.0265134759,
0.015713146,
0.0372429155,
0.0452885069,
-0.0640404522,
-0.0111544728,
0.0193548389,
-0.0212924816,
-0.0273286738,
-0.03859872,
0.0051735463,
-0.0129554207,
-0.0510407276,
-0.0639464483,
-0.0083082896,
0.0039645294,
0.0613978356,
-0.0037890431,
-0.041052863,
0.0132170357,
0.0079810238,
-0.04129133,
0.0799239352,
0.0004520589,
0.0103467079,
-0.0804443508,
0.0124645373,
0.0500471555,
-0.0189982913,
-0.0129388534,
0.0297498144,
-0.1099093407,
-0.0544901006,
-0.0033314344,
0.0408528596,
0.0090320474,
0.0390069671,
-0.0324897654,
-0.0410020798,
0.012917662,
0.0150044924,
0.008916175,
0.0238386765,
0.0419180095,
-0.0652705133,
-0.0028794515,
0.0675757006,
-0.0538825914,
0.0338833034,
0.0337892771,
0.0042613982,
-0.0063985516,
0.0091061266,
0.0086069843,
-0.0024974919,
0.0798528641,
0.0140925329,
0.0204868149,
-0.0420294553,
0.0445709974,
0.0174874831,
-0.0056414679,
-0.0384080969,
0.0031689454,
-0.0061052828,
0.0007277763,
0.0069295201,
-0.0361490324,
0.013120668,
-0.0525457971,
-0.0390442871,
0.0237778015,
-0.0390983149,
0.0101760216,
0.0421749726,
0.0388804376,
-0.0302912872,
-0.0097061386,
-0.0038822754,
0.0106626153,
-0.012329231,
0.003237528,
0.0317207128,
0.0454647206,
-0.0923341215,
0.0102046048,
-0.0410503298,
-0.0738161057,
-0.0390336514,
0.033962395,
0.0633943006,
-0.0421879105,
0.005307524,
0.0088506825,
-0.0040182187,
-0.0244134422,
0.0018872301,
-0.0115969386,
-0.0258766953,
0.0179740284,
0.0114569832,
0.009360522,
-0.0068823099,
0.0667218864,
-0.0132735549,
0.0117798997,
0.0121273575,
0.0231512394,
-0.0377095602,
-0.0015003016,
0.0246882793,
0.0141426334,
0.0061530815,
0.0303062089,
-0.019689396,
-0.0752189234,
0.0323848277,
-0.0303284768,
0.0061081885,
0.0186481662,
0.0702202395,
0.0328112133,
0.0005361437,
0.0139819067,
-0.0292325094,
-0.0035081704,
0.0254588202,
-0.0238779746,
-0.0005729042,
-6.662294231e-33,
-0.0248606559,
0.0204657335,
-0.0121402387,
0.0667212084,
-0.0431209654,
-0.0035548559,
-0.0539215282,
0.0189455673,
-0.0422214344,
-0.0079539996,
-0.0263617914,
-0.0031675368,
0.000220145,
0.0382745154,
-0.0077742236,
-0.0264804829,
0.0305026062,
0.0124295428,
-0.008334741,
-0.0029995684,
0.0473820604,
0.0365452953,
0.0761745572,
-0.0237785839,
0.0014521731,
-0.0014827637,
0.0249838624,
0.0386650302,
0.0210694503,
0.0591605678,
0.0030820195,
0.0471661724,
0.0083244508,
-0.0845418274,
-0.049645301,
-0.0048857098,
-0.073216401,
-0.0309826378,
-0.0064411308,
0.0095400382,
-0.0523059666,
-0.0292375591,
0.0956422985,
0.0037849541,
-0.016829906,
-0.0517234839,
0.0375089981,
-0.0193440691,
-0.0565675125,
-0.0442740396,
-0.0858801007,
0.0262342282,
0.0038155583,
-0.0557440519,
0.0403087661,
0.0509496108,
-0.0064324159,
0.007212487,
-0.0331288427,
-0.023572864,
0.016520666,
0.0592428334,
0.0425852463,
0.0541219115,
-0.0005322237,
0.0170601774,
0.0102859559,
0.0495866835,
0.0385471769,
-0.0334350094,
0.0456232205,
0.0175271966,
0.0652011558,
-0.03393282,
0.0345759653,
-0.0575740747,
-0.0350947343,
-0.0259030741,
-0.0286274105,
0.029002849,
0.0367980376,
0.0143262791,
0.0058800685,
-0.0199733581,
-0.0465259887,
-0.0233095549,
-0.0316342488,
0.0302484557,
0.0095004812,
0.0282874797,
0.0160150118,
0.064125739,
0.0688264892,
-0.0124877915,
0.0615344308,
-0.0106513081,
0.0207959246,
0.0296461936,
0.014937005,
0.0363107771,
-0.0561167337,
-0.0125854621,
-0.0204868745,
0.0108596589,
0.0219402537,
-0.0083623994,
0.0550950766,
0.0169913583,
-0.0547151901,
-0.030295657,
-0.0291208662,
0.0138380649,
0.0225636158,
0.0821751133,
0.0630817488,
0.0020690039,
-0.0107245678,
0.0903893709,
0.0132210162,
-0.0437724814,
-0.005344423,
0.00376338,
0.0251002852,
0.0156725291,
-0.0389039144,
0.0044019502,
-0.0202551316,
0.0259963088,
0.041519586,
-0.0693663433,
-0.0111969495,
0.0363999158,
3.037e-7,
0.0201389845,
0.0301435906,
0.0089700669,
-0.03175506,
-0.0006886491,
0.0035998228,
0.0146647766,
0.0586797446,
-0.014792446,
-0.0128126191,
0.008831121,
-0.0172525495,
0.0276170988,
-0.0411051884,
-0.1245759502,
-0.006353125,
-0.0582353324,
0.0594674423,
-0.0141582359,
0.0152975004,
0.0321067497,
0.1267993897,
-0.0042776908,
0.0126778483,
0.0087748822,
-0.0019497093,
0.060427282,
-0.0138083203,
0.0313796215,
0.0283666123,
0.0164937843,
0.0047915811,
-0.0367532149,
-0.0062442636,
-0.0182723459,
0.0623508282,
0.0207319297,
0.0472097658,
-0.0251600631,
-0.0246254019,
0.0310031082,
0.0042499769,
-0.0298876204,
-0.0760009438,
0.0349068679,
-0.0842588469,
-0.0261024758,
-0.0338537656,
0.0167030711,
0.0337098911,
-0.0097275805,
-0.0138488235,
0.0135426195,
0.0250286143,
0.0346344411,
-0.0306480657,
0.0026561744,
-0.1188085973,
-0.003903751,
0.0330277979,
-0.0444345362,
-0.0081454972,
-0.0574562512,
-0.0151969921,
0.0658137724,
0.0021559694,
-0.0191101506,
2.547440899e-34,
0.0202696305,
-0.0326940082,
0.0106021166,
0.0142054809,
0.0038260594,
-0.0432889611,
0.0240045562,
0.0099380091,
0.051027447,
-0.0794642419,
-0.0547161885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14035v1 | Two Giraffes in a Dirt Field: Using Game Play to Investigate Situation Modelling in Large Multimodal Models | 2024-06-20T06:56:19 | 2024-06-20T06:56:19 | Sherzod Hakimov, Yerkezhan Abdullayeva, Kushal Koshti, Antonia Schmidt, Yan Weiser, Anne Beyer, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While the situation has improved for text-only models, it again seems to be
the case currently that multimodal (text and image) models develop faster than
ways to evaluate them. In this paper, we bring a recently developed evaluation
paradigm from text models to multimodal models, namely evaluation through the
goal-oriented game (self) play, complementing reference-based and
preference-based evaluation. Specifically, we define games that challenge a
model's capability to represent a situation from visual information and align
such representations through dialogue. We find that the largest closed models
perform rather well on the games that we define, while even the best
open-weight models struggle with them. On further analysis, we find that the
exceptional deep captioning capabilities of the largest models drive some of
the performance. There is still room to grow for both kinds of models, ensuring
the continued relevance of the benchmark. | [
0.0350815468,
0.0495211035,
-0.0142329149,
0.0479700491,
-0.0435307994,
0.0044236379,
0.0195210949,
-0.0251969937,
-0.0169274807,
-0.0849832743,
-0.038959872,
-0.0353259034,
-0.0092785591,
0.0633559152,
0.0098134754,
-0.089716129,
0.014399508,
-0.0435796343,
-0.0002630955,
0.0133851282,
-0.007819212,
-0.0302174408,
-0.0494355634,
0.042593535,
-0.0314846784,
-0.0094605759,
-0.0454867855,
0.001000455,
0.0138461236,
-0.0488656648,
-0.0233255401,
0.0441374034,
0.0647403374,
-0.0017688108,
0.0000020526,
-0.0112572005,
0.0149536896,
-0.0254540518,
0.0259627532,
-0.0056312438,
0.0691509247,
-0.0047276276,
0.0181873795,
-0.0460386947,
-0.0046997783,
-0.01979509,
0.0730526,
0.0416618697,
0.0839246362,
0.0461425446,
-0.0040413886,
-0.057908088,
0.0010244569,
-0.0170236826,
-0.0062637753,
-0.0694824085,
-0.0012518832,
0.0629525706,
0.046580933,
-0.0208298694,
-0.0322781429,
0.0351276882,
0.0023780048,
0.0027538612,
0.0002758753,
0.0567700602,
0.0044083078,
-0.007842253,
-0.0068839751,
0.0969318449,
-0.0094542028,
0.0453348793,
-0.0077394568,
-0.0108501529,
0.0108480118,
0.0195865892,
-0.0220998917,
0.0279191099,
0.0100924112,
0.0075979452,
-0.0532134622,
0.0716563836,
0.0242265239,
-0.011240853,
0.011562801,
-0.0049727699,
-0.0051360885,
0.0196242947,
-0.0286418162,
0.0134279039,
-0.0521771125,
-0.0740834996,
-0.0067910347,
0.012461476,
-0.0368293189,
0.0138911186,
-0.0318529382,
0.0130066257,
-0.0150167327,
-0.0713378266,
0.0521070696,
0.0215814412,
-0.0099188313,
0.0832581744,
0.0382902734,
0.0340095423,
-0.0382025167,
-0.0046756477,
-0.0305796433,
0.025901407,
-0.067314662,
0.0013722857,
-0.0508065782,
0.023070693,
-0.0476071388,
-0.0593363307,
0.0067926971,
0.0184850022,
-0.0207961723,
0.0233756807,
-0.0216635,
0.0483646505,
-0.033075653,
0.0081659015,
-0.0591718107,
0.023059411,
-0.0252208095,
0.0117481295,
-0.0029990815,
-0.0330470689,
0.022482954,
-0.0103525696,
0.002260085,
-0.0251569133,
-0.0194738843,
0.1042543277,
-0.0309567619,
-0.0197215471,
0.0196543057,
-0.0184083376,
-0.0365821272,
-0.0758997127,
0.022734927,
-0.03225182,
0.0280362144,
-0.0370209068,
0.0239742566,
-0.0417039394,
-0.0047254441,
0.0049822978,
0.0232288279,
0.1120981425,
0.0451781005,
-0.0043880949,
0.0246394798,
0.0324962735,
-0.020127086,
0.0789821967,
0.0517540872,
0.0499914214,
0.0206184853,
-0.0133718904,
0.0362018608,
0.0408043973,
0.0045933728,
0.0110267587,
-0.0233193859,
0.0190040488,
0.019747572,
0.0952664092,
0.0051720734,
0.0202621836,
-0.0364680253,
-0.0269425269,
0.1016826928,
0.0390505902,
0.0080422023,
-0.0204448011,
0.0287875999,
0.0004557919,
-0.0033612691,
0.0356122442,
-0.0305256043,
0.0710933357,
0.0019744062,
-0.0069303215,
0.015154846,
0.0121351229,
-0.0204836,
-0.0460284762,
-0.0029628249,
-0.0050433958,
0.0035855474,
0.0078955041,
0.0151174907,
-0.0180473421,
-0.040068496,
0.0012027329,
-0.0085883746,
-0.0177164152,
-0.0156175038,
-0.0272185355,
0.0017220743,
0.06084859,
0.0418344475,
-0.0412167199,
-0.0535748042,
-0.0113079175,
0.005805912,
0.0455168933,
0.0675924122,
0.000872524,
0.0404578149,
-0.00704274,
-0.0398891568,
-0.0607126951,
0.0146570643,
0.0306045916,
-0.0381429382,
-0.0108068353,
-0.0111802993,
0.004921108,
-0.0124070914,
0.0203576963,
0.0313261859,
-0.0398578197,
-0.0418178178,
0.0119973253,
0.0312321503,
0.0053271595,
-0.0170092955,
0.0107384576,
0.0212843902,
-0.0103550367,
0.0063344478,
0.033923097,
-0.0581416748,
-0.0370496884,
0.0020008502,
-0.0563399158,
-0.0252959039,
0.0085297711,
-0.0301528648,
-0.0075513464,
0.0246557798,
-0.0482111201,
0.0146674206,
-0.018996425,
-0.0004600139,
0.010289127,
-0.0088835359,
-0.022990087,
0.0648230091,
-0.0217802394,
-0.02400521,
0.0094198463,
0.0003565344,
0.0036360149,
-0.0537659265,
-0.0256148521,
0.0379844084,
0.0229779854,
0.0200555306,
0.035296075,
-0.015731683,
-0.049877014,
-0.0266365185,
-0.1022490039,
-0.0165660735,
-0.0067844372,
-0.0386970267,
-0.0009621328,
-0.0264228359,
0.0105352923,
-0.0108874701,
-0.0199116804,
0.0038472209,
0.0098187895,
0.0263331123,
0.0248864181,
0.0665746927,
0.0173705015,
-0.0427736305,
0.0283804517,
0.0048985663,
0.0810056254,
0.0123771215,
-0.0006600362,
-0.0118120313,
0.0097455978,
-0.0499774888,
0.0521850623,
-0.0285874736,
-0.0180976335,
0.0555876978,
-0.0134996837,
0.0370253697,
0.0360119864,
0.0118330661,
0.07652165,
0.0439105704,
-0.0413745083,
-0.0267351605,
0.0281746145,
0.0076716789,
-0.0326829255,
-0.0448508635,
-0.0459190458,
-0.0031442672,
0.0643550754,
-0.030332841,
0.0382290259,
-0.0443194285,
0.0611789301,
0.0068075038,
-0.0884796232,
-0.0526877157,
0.0131953303,
-0.0020670926,
0.0085535496,
-0.0413784645,
0.0074242395,
0.0401775166,
-0.0309953876,
-0.003791139,
0.0053762062,
0.0268966295,
-0.0120709017,
0.124597095,
0.0391785093,
0.0211502351,
0.0262493808,
0.0255699251,
-0.0374276452,
-0.0293622557,
0.0514866672,
-0.0244171694,
0.0177123286,
-0.0685256645,
0.0044871843,
-0.0019939931,
-0.0470045507,
-0.0160375051,
-0.051065173,
-0.0480747595,
0.0015904419,
-0.0167593732,
0.0324000828,
-0.0560013466,
0.0600891225,
0.0388716683,
-0.0019710336,
0.0164986476,
-0.0219965279,
-0.0348165408,
0.0549838245,
0.0621358156,
0.0514216311,
-0.0577702895,
-0.0427027568,
0.0345245898,
0.0251439158,
-0.028856542,
-0.0092630256,
-0.0727179646,
0.0289613865,
-0.0010921264,
0.0069289668,
-0.0375645049,
0.033625897,
0.0564528704,
-0.0404516906,
-0.0023134223,
0.0685033053,
-0.0016022795,
-0.0163209941,
0.012447603,
0.0120611209,
0.0106705818,
0.014119626,
-0.0116063235,
-0.0169964749,
-0.0544066802,
0.0023342234,
-0.0419093817,
0.0272940062,
-0.0312586762,
-0.0002566046,
-0.0971311331,
0.0319619626,
-0.0153331691,
-0.0622720383,
0.0009574683,
0.0093448414,
0.0117987841,
-0.0252823886,
-0.0345967263,
-0.0105915414,
0.0065924576,
-0.0012631888,
0.0023603998,
0.0314902589,
-0.0168339889,
0.0069877813,
-0.0669184476,
0.048340749,
0.0546236075,
0.0287266523,
-0.0010016012,
-0.0217699204,
0.0058390331,
0.0555820502,
0.0132878041,
0.0130763175,
0.0666090101,
-0.0533244312,
-0.0191837735,
0.0138151003,
-0.0136676645,
0.0318433717,
-0.0144311991,
-0.0147030009,
0.0168781783,
-0.0084613627,
0.0068876548,
-0.0515302867,
0.0257857349,
0.0465687737,
0.045793511,
-0.0076961024,
-0.0491166189,
-0.0128516257,
-0.0077248123,
0.0027897882,
-0.0610554852,
-0.0479229279,
-0.0249106698,
0.026461117,
0.0111203194,
-0.0577720366,
-0.0479589105,
0.0067968862,
0.0316442326,
-0.0150355473,
-0.017891923,
-0.0019000911,
0.0479007065,
-0.0299187358,
0.0326672643,
-0.026275672,
0.0077545433,
-0.0131777218,
-0.0178148989,
0.0404179692,
-0.0499287657,
-0.012250145,
0.0488000251,
-0.0478767827,
-0.0058633764,
-0.025791999,
0.0714744925,
0.0152944447,
0.0067452495,
0.0376228355,
-0.0543513335,
-0.0163560268,
0.0123262852,
-0.0189415962,
0.0087845121,
0.0108005684,
0.0022809156,
-0.0114584193,
0.0033125214,
-0.0461896844,
0.009160486,
-0.0163640231,
0.0197024811,
-0.0101190871,
-0.0640569776,
0.0070190323,
-0.0484821759,
0.0472147912,
-0.0154134603,
-0.0423413664,
-0.0037557802,
-0.0161112733,
-0.040201094,
-0.0254140627,
-0.0402908809,
0.0067801909,
0.0018495625,
0.048839286,
0.0236125719,
0.0203202721,
0.0057225935,
0.0208893102,
-0.028130725,
-0.038281098,
0.0838224739,
-0.0460482799,
-0.0228144601,
0.0306342877,
-0.0056056273,
0.0263569895,
-0.0469130352,
0.0109745655,
0.0127312681,
0.0397453457,
0.045192413,
-0.0306968782,
-0.007910111,
0.0573072545,
-0.0257467087,
0.0060772845,
-0.0346520692,
0.073087424,
0.0814182386,
0.0052460898,
-0.0043830415,
-0.0142633291,
-0.0070963814,
-0.0042132959,
0.0126945069,
0.0294980966,
-0.0646870881,
0.0399365947,
0.0429561138,
0.0162965376,
0.0069015594,
0.0420481674,
0.0462292954,
0.0478165448,
0.0168531854,
-0.0158252157,
-0.0374444537,
-0.0171797536,
0.0183689725,
0.0554741286,
-0.0043038987,
0.013395546,
-0.0461317301,
-0.0528309382,
0.0072707064,
0.066605933,
-0.0105097983,
0.0006976185,
0.0595235527,
0.0448625535,
0.0219531599,
-0.0183837637,
-0.0343718641,
0.0236839149,
-0.0371344686,
0.0132314404,
-0.0108864941,
-6.055472088e-33,
-0.0459143631,
-0.0315126292,
0.050317429,
-0.0509636514,
-0.0480914935,
0.0040637283,
-0.0367129184,
0.0240744911,
-0.0028039436,
0.02068308,
0.0274172109,
-0.027064804,
-0.0046851686,
-0.0034744686,
-0.0082297903,
-0.0339890458,
0.0318435803,
-0.017029766,
-0.0590950735,
-0.0069881375,
0.0098317154,
-0.0160946697,
0.0305677708,
-0.057533782,
0.0120824948,
-0.0078746518,
-0.0552572906,
0.0216880385,
0.0067767482,
0.0619178414,
-0.0655398592,
-0.0062822788,
0.0272774473,
-0.0344203003,
-0.0188414901,
0.010396895,
-0.0312797986,
-0.0077176904,
0.0317928456,
0.003741879,
-0.0812912881,
-0.0141773541,
0.0044270726,
0.0211357977,
-0.0216920692,
-0.0196860041,
0.0361960009,
-0.0251965597,
0.0111205047,
0.0436435863,
-0.0566917844,
0.0117458347,
-0.0318024345,
-0.0759297013,
0.0424409434,
0.0277777184,
0.0258736815,
0.0149616143,
-0.0142839225,
0.0264538378,
0.0083033452,
0.0137256756,
0.0876814425,
0.0444068983,
0.0201457664,
0.0825759247,
-0.00080813,
0.0011283522,
-0.0874224976,
-0.0502765439,
0.0041266289,
0.090323858,
0.03658057,
0.0763187259,
-0.0121648889,
0.0456944257,
-0.0327939652,
0.0353173949,
-0.0542001314,
0.0336729139,
0.0299392268,
0.0497159883,
-0.0205589663,
0.0167082548,
-0.0491554737,
-0.0140726613,
-0.0280359667,
-0.0183499008,
0.0291442946,
0.0001243037,
-0.0170647111,
0.0377000161,
0.0783492401,
-0.0486279503,
-0.0125147859,
-0.0096931104,
-0.0002462952,
0.0757724941,
-0.0173830781,
0.0017745069,
0.0063230158,
-0.0316033624,
0.0534831882,
0.0342796296,
0.0243651532,
-0.0019161423,
-0.0226592179,
0.0393640846,
0.0088376962,
-0.0103010898,
-0.0442065261,
0.0020317975,
-0.0137007469,
0.0230247285,
0.0337087996,
-0.0269297995,
-0.0519053675,
0.0250688773,
-0.0084055644,
-0.0248330496,
-0.0240455456,
-0.0205657966,
-0.0184843,
-0.0039768857,
-0.0051420298,
0.0244284365,
-0.051365748,
-0.004981176,
0.0111749889,
-0.0229285974,
-0.0292576179,
0.0189961232,
2.688e-7,
0.0106147146,
0.0256523024,
0.028910974,
0.0124139031,
0.0324059799,
0.0843866095,
-0.0395213999,
0.0506642982,
-0.0030513138,
-0.0738248229,
0.0477149338,
0.0590640157,
0.0338130519,
0.0075999675,
-0.0136190346,
-0.0062134317,
-0.0494402014,
0.0107700592,
-0.0226052459,
-0.0297216754,
0.0480020009,
0.0547211915,
0.0010586575,
-0.0043241158,
0.0014740321,
-0.0293132793,
0.0772293285,
-0.0730847344,
-0.0236543324,
0.0052118041,
0.0143726068,
0.0322385989,
-0.047322575,
-0.0133146597,
0.0054252669,
-0.0109510943,
0.0464149341,
0.0456844196,
-0.0160561837,
-0.0401271991,
-0.0557174794,
0.0190898925,
-0.0207744762,
-0.0550634116,
0.0871537626,
-0.0835043713,
-0.0310271382,
-0.0352397189,
-0.0226554107,
-0.0148434844,
0.0140952682,
-0.006638851,
-0.0566401333,
0.008962471,
0.0095409648,
-0.0071557709,
-0.0261870828,
-0.0546209365,
-0.0294250716,
-0.013262921,
-0.0531826019,
-0.0106297685,
-0.0482306778,
-0.0392900296,
0.0451298952,
-0.0734995231,
-0.0262739286,
1.574611302e-34,
0.0385158844,
-0.0051470618,
0.0058501111,
-0.0461528562,
0.0239593945,
0.0128699942,
-0.0463598669,
-0.0258242022,
0.004923339,
-0.0556497015,
-0.0073985634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14026v1 | Demystifying Forgetting in Language Model Fine-Tuning with Statistical Analysis of Example Associations | 2024-06-20T06:46:23 | 2024-06-20T06:46:23 | Xisen Jin, Xiang Ren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Language models (LMs) are known to suffer from forgetting of previously
learned examples when fine-tuned, breaking stability of deployed LM systems.
Despite efforts on mitigating forgetting, few have investigated whether, and
how forgotten upstream examples are associated with newly learned tasks.
Insights on such associations enable efficient and targeted mitigation of
forgetting. In this paper, we empirically analyze forgetting that occurs in $N$
upstream examples while the model learns $M$ new tasks and visualize their
associations with a $M \times N$ matrix. We empirically demonstrate that the
degree of forgetting can often be approximated by simple multiplicative
contributions of the upstream examples and newly learned tasks. We also reveal
more complicated patterns where specific subsets of examples are forgotten with
statistics and visualization. Following our analysis, we predict forgetting
that happens on upstream examples when learning a new task with matrix
completion over the empirical associations, outperforming prior approaches that
rely on trainable LMs. Project website:
https://inklab.usc.edu/lm-forgetting-prediction/ | [
-0.0013765406,
0.0275884252,
-0.0506575368,
0.0438823849,
-0.0095151868,
0.0212545767,
-0.0394795313,
-0.0292810481,
-0.0084058838,
-0.0148969404,
-0.024166692,
0.0030852167,
0.0410040505,
0.0021236367,
0.0517388657,
-0.0272224359,
0.0751411691,
-0.0579923838,
-0.0452438183,
-0.0181695707,
0.0080563109,
-0.0028671089,
-0.0007881888,
0.0338051058,
0.0033678678,
-0.0181679185,
-0.0285139065,
-0.0319204219,
-0.0122034634,
-0.0043005864,
0.0105868131,
0.0250578746,
0.0128833344,
-0.0002900148,
0.0000018468,
-0.0677791834,
-0.0219252985,
-0.0274592061,
-0.0135521563,
0.0299580209,
-0.0184512902,
0.021739617,
-0.0169626437,
0.0257025231,
-0.0192232896,
-0.0012301379,
0.0353845023,
0.0050018192,
0.0248858333,
0.0272788666,
0.0158707146,
0.026539484,
0.0307823513,
-0.0238212533,
0.0271658283,
-0.0238038488,
0.0236275569,
-0.0149750262,
-0.0408577435,
-0.0242227763,
-0.045840174,
0.0385286584,
-0.0227618385,
0.0288929865,
0.0026597173,
0.0413099229,
0.0128074372,
0.0041059661,
0.0095453924,
0.0286004413,
-0.020780351,
-0.0259726141,
0.0165203996,
-0.0168299917,
0.0048369695,
-0.0012523269,
-0.0817640349,
-0.0009529853,
0.009336642,
0.0096367989,
0.0236219782,
-0.0766575783,
0.0385894068,
0.0094938856,
0.0109070614,
0.0507146604,
0.0286306813,
-0.0159552731,
-0.0368435718,
-0.0109877167,
0.0099142343,
-0.0192080978,
0.0071713459,
0.0438068546,
-0.0350692384,
0.0448801443,
-0.0038635309,
-0.0682590529,
0.0374725685,
-0.0275412202,
0.0934327021,
0.0263313819,
-0.0330995917,
0.0424576998,
-0.0692240819,
0.0538571738,
-0.0069700126,
0.0172441062,
-0.0034110243,
0.0258587021,
-0.042625159,
-0.009211679,
-0.0378187262,
0.0219537206,
0.0374726281,
0.0424230583,
-0.016435463,
0.0627119243,
-0.0171920639,
0.0385895558,
-0.0282008853,
-0.0146242986,
-0.0531510115,
0.0081008244,
-0.0547799319,
0.0357194357,
-0.0232150294,
0.0417004265,
-0.004572568,
-0.0245337971,
-0.0218428075,
-0.0388504528,
-0.0071171969,
-0.0234202109,
0.026932925,
0.0823032409,
-0.0039706999,
-0.0351212136,
-0.0499986261,
-0.0124266408,
-0.0026360073,
-0.0577678643,
0.0083901808,
-0.0586901642,
-0.0010265702,
0.0435887352,
0.0070906798,
-0.0488154441,
-0.0106589133,
0.0069490611,
-0.0689346641,
0.0470300131,
0.0207888912,
0.0117283277,
0.0152222998,
-0.0202869419,
-0.0144541515,
0.0772911161,
0.0277000647,
-0.0081019187,
0.0144879846,
-0.0241614487,
0.0303636547,
0.0365472063,
-0.0018126999,
0.0356279053,
-0.0322817937,
-0.0306671038,
0.0492337868,
0.0119718816,
0.0443430096,
0.0203079842,
-0.0025860362,
0.020793682,
0.0533572435,
0.0239804015,
-0.010459316,
0.031814225,
0.0059669008,
-0.0492145419,
0.0119410465,
0.0423764028,
-0.0757220536,
0.0377459638,
-0.017870903,
0.0084889503,
0.0111334603,
0.0542576239,
-0.0460231155,
-0.0249650627,
0.0084502846,
-0.0213515274,
0.0093073677,
-0.005450564,
0.0845253766,
0.0431400202,
-0.0372723378,
0.053464815,
0.0343272537,
-0.0413786694,
0.0451662019,
-0.0558020324,
0.0223742481,
0.0374400206,
0.0431666598,
-0.038703002,
-0.0193533991,
0.0141653521,
0.0230519306,
-0.0549030192,
0.0395262428,
-0.0029749628,
0.029394133,
-0.033397112,
-0.0135283126,
-0.0001372392,
0.0383850783,
0.0029011439,
-0.0263193119,
-0.0097347116,
0.0041732122,
-0.0522394329,
-0.0596481003,
0.0416641161,
-0.0512813218,
0.0157108959,
-0.0108436821,
0.0001505047,
-0.0096836928,
-0.0194745436,
0.023963362,
0.0068642739,
0.0513861328,
0.007636711,
0.0125172567,
-0.0100661591,
-0.0301472414,
-0.0010522819,
0.0447429307,
0.0223528482,
0.0038175962,
0.037620008,
-0.0356533527,
-0.0721006989,
0.0620836504,
-0.0103970449,
0.0657913387,
-0.0108681964,
0.0597616062,
-0.0421189442,
0.0041752001,
-0.0298822969,
0.0476396307,
-0.0114828534,
0.0252551027,
-0.043188192,
0.0090707205,
0.0064882603,
-0.0275717638,
-0.0435553603,
0.0177727211,
-0.0131618641,
0.0452393629,
-0.0077721304,
-0.0543599986,
-0.073985219,
0.0020895011,
-0.0443332344,
0.0233602617,
-0.0209203623,
0.0152401039,
0.0132858232,
-0.0208228957,
-0.0056429934,
-0.045490887,
0.0081142522,
0.0463147163,
-0.0079411222,
0.0508628823,
0.0216416176,
0.0078811804,
-0.0291275103,
-0.0609301515,
-0.019463446,
-0.018755598,
0.0323270708,
-0.0366652794,
0.0050145611,
-0.0762326643,
0.0524514727,
-0.0285347532,
0.0354238041,
-0.0296713356,
-0.0220979229,
0.0216446891,
-0.02429148,
0.0640627071,
0.0665547475,
-0.0171681233,
0.0274608284,
0.1094390079,
-0.0163348746,
-0.0338842906,
0.0057570799,
-0.0396970734,
-0.0651111603,
-0.0246869661,
0.0207925346,
-0.0468332171,
0.061688602,
-0.010121718,
-0.0246024914,
-0.0033585876,
-0.0214755274,
-0.0240875185,
0.0355987102,
-0.0354337431,
-0.0221316777,
-0.0452693775,
0.0331270322,
-0.0100812027,
-0.0929945931,
0.0351429023,
0.0057563214,
0.0189410504,
-0.0397273414,
-0.0014950894,
0.0019837017,
0.0699944422,
0.0199682787,
0.0029871981,
0.0286682937,
-0.0369544514,
-0.0857623667,
-0.0139402309,
0.031253539,
-0.0409785509,
0.062653169,
-0.0365376882,
-0.0290675238,
-0.0041862642,
-0.0099133113,
-0.0473145433,
0.0171232242,
-0.0300132371,
-0.0053146728,
-0.0176183172,
-0.0243611224,
-0.0013933422,
-0.0521359257,
0.0505027398,
0.0016576056,
-0.0251005832,
-0.0059028016,
-0.0398344919,
-0.0111555271,
0.0379783027,
-0.0044718841,
0.0089574046,
-0.0778226629,
0.0068005878,
0.0033659313,
0.078632839,
0.0175726376,
-0.024676457,
-0.0023943996,
0.0195570048,
-0.0016673073,
-0.0623658039,
0.042916555,
0.0359727666,
-0.0629514754,
-0.0182900839,
0.0450372249,
0.0104080774,
-0.0688451976,
0.0194095057,
0.0104542719,
0.0486512668,
0.0614796951,
0.0294056516,
-0.0267217197,
0.0082573937,
0.0339183882,
0.0123183085,
0.0129903127,
-0.0130904857,
-0.0109565463,
-0.0911681801,
-0.0158795901,
0.0173727013,
-0.0667328089,
-0.0106803784,
-0.0520207994,
0.0058550062,
-0.0141398506,
0.0404336527,
0.036685437,
-0.0228179637,
0.0155262826,
0.0476183705,
-0.0177130252,
-0.0910994187,
0.0118751265,
-0.0459927544,
0.0811987296,
0.0499478653,
-0.0011199375,
-0.0405979417,
-0.031981241,
0.081649594,
-0.0141166393,
0.0267059002,
0.0128252972,
0.0658771396,
0.043615371,
-0.0197287891,
0.0102882655,
0.0114600891,
0.0094689084,
-0.020093035,
0.0067563416,
0.0951368362,
-0.0125813438,
0.0037526691,
0.027193781,
-0.0588736162,
-0.0222737361,
0.0479982421,
0.0372660942,
-0.0363220535,
-0.0203972869,
-0.0209672693,
0.0174666569,
-0.0211957004,
0.0106956512,
0.0073664095,
-0.0318373032,
0.032910835,
-0.0413398072,
-0.0093396716,
0.0606926754,
0.0068356935,
0.0192894712,
0.0632894412,
-0.005640409,
-0.0021086552,
-0.0416101627,
0.0270315707,
-0.0314775519,
0.0155631695,
-0.0263020098,
-0.0148345018,
0.0230048019,
-0.0082695428,
-0.0007562334,
-0.0198315419,
-0.1198639795,
-0.0547879897,
0.0300520919,
0.0460154079,
0.0243336093,
0.0223140158,
0.0101798158,
-0.0840972364,
0.0022420869,
0.0169057827,
0.0077811377,
0.0345928222,
0.0185780693,
-0.0481209457,
-0.0116671538,
0.0338927731,
-0.0485233031,
-0.0419287644,
0.0326459929,
0.0109374002,
-0.0107953269,
0.0442907773,
0.0037384576,
-0.0292225052,
0.0612881742,
-0.014757962,
-0.0298241917,
-0.0445518978,
0.021868227,
0.0178342927,
0.0007099975,
0.001749187,
-0.0148643656,
0.0020944406,
0.0187362544,
0.024828976,
-0.0359090343,
0.0065368558,
0.0676451921,
-0.0236821715,
-0.0179081596,
0.0010860439,
-0.0109147718,
0.0682697967,
0.0582141206,
-0.0195950028,
0.0236949641,
-0.0013856535,
0.0248636771,
0.0100433528,
0.0306700971,
0.0087124621,
0.0044396305,
-0.0600794964,
-0.0054652682,
-0.0469152927,
-0.0836662203,
0.006283687,
-0.0022574121,
0.0762805715,
-0.0478741005,
0.0529868826,
-0.012760439,
0.005022604,
-0.0389682092,
0.0109043913,
-0.0238102656,
-0.026190117,
0.0051595322,
0.0171862263,
-0.0115783326,
0.0536154322,
0.0773813501,
-0.0293171816,
0.0790461451,
-0.0213081501,
0.0182846971,
0.00706477,
0.014443743,
0.0227590203,
0.0432664454,
-0.0367004797,
-0.0493589193,
-0.0446229689,
-0.0935294554,
-0.0377259888,
-0.0186787881,
0.0168575943,
-0.0301207658,
0.0243645199,
0.0437705033,
-0.0248248205,
0.043760132,
-0.0367637686,
-0.0328197218,
0.0108746449,
-0.0304872803,
-0.0176117942,
-5.786494369e-33,
-0.0177401043,
-0.0032503456,
0.0149772009,
0.0262037572,
0.0053714956,
0.0013363265,
-0.0578973033,
0.0325665809,
-0.0336729214,
-0.0088376449,
-0.0148277711,
-0.0010834394,
0.0037461522,
0.0177978408,
0.0483124591,
0.0168838389,
0.0390587263,
-0.0102680968,
-0.0097735012,
0.0412939601,
0.0593960471,
0.0541587695,
0.0581105724,
-0.0323417038,
0.0266643725,
0.0048765265,
-0.0227561425,
0.0187707078,
-0.0434449688,
0.0645011961,
-0.0183905791,
0.0621609688,
0.0206505843,
-0.0307206288,
-0.0813761801,
-0.0321069732,
-0.0634984151,
-0.0299112033,
0.0023913775,
0.0050555975,
-0.0377578363,
-0.0015850771,
0.0348312706,
-0.0034381729,
-0.0393504053,
-0.0059558568,
0.0469036363,
-0.0302121975,
-0.0709192529,
0.0138235986,
-0.0069952994,
-0.0257059131,
0.002848126,
-0.0283751097,
0.0100890594,
-0.0388996638,
0.0130741503,
-0.0013679072,
-0.0330414176,
0.0116349738,
0.0163761117,
0.0749895796,
0.049321793,
0.0366929844,
-0.0144712403,
0.0535561033,
0.0344311893,
0.0517339893,
0.0612882897,
-0.006568227,
0.0759572759,
0.0182883386,
0.0296981279,
-0.0271624308,
0.0371778943,
-0.0372619964,
-0.0283648558,
0.012110685,
0.0088679222,
0.0651779398,
0.0290022492,
0.0320060663,
-0.0008410642,
-0.0474212319,
-0.0795848072,
0.0095348926,
-0.0390455537,
-0.0121598672,
0.0112035219,
-0.0018779041,
0.0089805769,
-0.0374342203,
0.0168637522,
-0.0217930507,
-0.0551202148,
0.0179507453,
-0.0526161529,
0.0290521588,
0.0074205906,
0.0113674942,
-0.0349479504,
-0.0533265062,
-0.0325975157,
-0.0133932652,
0.0120916609,
0.0271700658,
0.0647904947,
0.0308510773,
-0.0735271424,
0.0233527087,
-0.0461900756,
-0.0312988572,
0.0462215357,
-0.0062693516,
0.0201215781,
-0.0075115077,
-0.0087699015,
0.0683441013,
0.0493814647,
-0.0379681773,
-0.061786551,
-0.0050216131,
-0.0495884232,
0.029424265,
-0.0150045119,
-0.0315593667,
-0.0592066608,
0.0504588746,
0.0918116197,
-0.0307777878,
0.0017960293,
-0.0262029283,
2.526e-7,
0.0135889901,
0.0356958397,
-0.0083571831,
-0.0060037426,
0.0326582789,
0.0461146683,
-0.0751077756,
0.0256944131,
0.0154995359,
0.0388109125,
-0.019261634,
0.011362724,
0.0434243083,
0.0125065902,
-0.0452379771,
0.0255767405,
-0.0735228956,
0.0245922394,
-0.0579004101,
0.000975118,
-0.0191421155,
0.0567199923,
0.0552703403,
-0.0068460042,
-0.0223201737,
-0.0509433337,
0.0501958951,
-0.0352598764,
0.0129086534,
-0.0007809434,
-0.0152991088,
0.0537739806,
0.0018770006,
0.0200616475,
-0.0364960395,
-0.0044013094,
-0.0328787863,
0.0124370838,
0.0070158616,
0.000970812,
0.0199659597,
0.0299429838,
-0.0087502599,
-0.0453113019,
0.0653448105,
-0.0462620668,
-0.0055193291,
-0.0197855849,
0.0363224782,
-0.004523797,
0.0267771315,
0.0210837275,
-0.0304245744,
0.0118409032,
-0.0224413462,
0.0259067584,
-0.0275090002,
-0.0898714811,
-0.0160681643,
0.0752253905,
-0.0273843873,
-0.0568515472,
-0.0344076268,
-0.0093423296,
0.0373011306,
-0.0580286123,
0.0137805687,
2.296409259e-34,
0.0183819607,
-0.0206524488,
0.0273064245,
0.070623979,
0.0220781155,
-0.0417384543,
-0.0079777204,
0.0591558069,
0.0161681585,
-0.0536152348,
-0.0307452958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14024v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14024v2 | LLM Critics Help Catch Bugs in Mathematics: Towards a Better Mathematical Verifier with Natural Language Feedback | 2024-06-20T06:42:27 | 2024-06-30T13:44:04 | Bofei Gao, Zefan Cai, Runxin Xu, Peiyi Wang, Ce Zheng, Runji Lin, Keming Lu, Junyang Lin, Chang Zhou, Wen Xiao, Junjie Hu, Tianyu Liu, Baobao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical verfier achieves success in mathematical reasoning tasks by
validating the correctness of solutions. However, existing verifiers are
trained with binary classification labels, which are not informative enough for
the model to accurately assess the solutions. To mitigate the aforementioned
insufficiency of binary labels, we introduce step-wise natural language
feedbacks as rationale labels (i.e., the correctness of the current step and
the explanations). In this paper, we propose \textbf{Math-Minos}, a natural
language feedback enhanced verifier by constructing automatically-generated
training data and a two-stage training paradigm for effective training and
efficient inference. Our experiments reveal that a small set (30k) of natural
language feedbacks can significantly boost the performance of the verifier by
the accuracy of 1.6\% (86.6\% $\rightarrow$ 88.2\%) on GSM8K and 0.8\% (37.8\%
$\rightarrow$ 38.6\%) on MATH. We have released our code and data for further
exploration. | [
-0.0105957957,
0.0631599426,
0.0231657252,
0.048119653,
-0.0024891945,
0.0037476665,
0.0198062863,
0.0276919361,
-0.0238277502,
-0.0355520025,
-0.0098768463,
0.007880996,
-0.0003834564,
-0.0004848731,
0.0677987933,
-0.0441946536,
0.0275347494,
-0.0468408316,
0.0211929455,
-0.0205522571,
-0.0147636821,
-0.0238680337,
-0.0443966091,
0.0058981185,
-0.0314430892,
-0.034867622,
0.0042987168,
-0.0447457843,
0.007908632,
-0.0577965081,
0.000076153,
0.0646379441,
-0.0188875012,
0.0665016919,
0.0000022506,
-0.0631850287,
-0.0035886846,
0.0222165082,
-0.0874153376,
-0.0218338221,
-0.0203387495,
-0.0086636087,
-0.0143528907,
0.0088374251,
-0.0384822749,
0.0321783163,
0.0258462448,
0.0408381745,
0.0861311108,
0.0767365471,
0.0071860636,
-0.0359858312,
0.0180408638,
0.0077859866,
0.0607398599,
-0.0336333439,
0.0015667065,
0.0236772001,
0.0117123043,
0.0355498642,
-0.018824609,
0.0024152943,
0.044139456,
-0.0223618355,
0.0025389954,
0.0027385426,
-0.0033053113,
0.0071263672,
-0.0181970801,
0.0436154939,
0.0075758589,
-0.061612349,
-0.038316559,
-0.0181972198,
-0.0185914319,
0.0059187254,
-0.0215673447,
0.0233871564,
-0.0289677549,
-0.0199335814,
-0.0192055516,
-0.0065413173,
0.0390424691,
0.0231740698,
0.003480355,
0.0587214194,
-0.0042022881,
-0.0599996708,
0.0298807211,
0.0392926075,
-0.0427217744,
-0.067074582,
0.021137476,
0.0456943773,
0.016152706,
-0.0127400588,
-0.0007277179,
-0.0426394679,
-0.0096617751,
-0.0216556992,
0.012745183,
0.0182183255,
-0.0047951154,
0.0061423709,
-0.0230277237,
0.0269546118,
0.0043220874,
0.0762022436,
0.016500704,
0.0258779246,
-0.0076102722,
0.0115576945,
0.0161059555,
0.0546370335,
0.0418537818,
0.0561697036,
-0.0493981875,
-0.0183755513,
-0.0556987934,
0.065361768,
-0.0322689936,
-0.0072640246,
0.0269847624,
-0.0331218205,
-0.0774117559,
-0.0180758033,
-0.0476976335,
0.0132672973,
0.0078404555,
-0.0377308056,
-0.0275004655,
0.046814777,
-0.0331818759,
0.0184921678,
0.0357558727,
0.073966302,
0.0310975704,
0.0167088378,
-0.0163086671,
-0.0118613476,
0.0200275499,
-0.0592060983,
-0.0243736897,
-0.0896006972,
-0.010534076,
-0.0062960042,
-0.0153049408,
0.0010438382,
0.0020080877,
0.025400117,
0.0288306121,
0.0869057104,
-0.0603043176,
-0.0318144076,
0.0060658194,
-0.0060848496,
-0.0228924807,
0.0023779934,
0.0545844622,
-0.0331675708,
0.0429545604,
-0.0212432705,
0.043835979,
-0.0037676007,
0.0429450236,
-0.0104498509,
0.0133761661,
-0.0039857253,
-0.0185264349,
0.0369825326,
-0.0343574509,
0.0284148771,
-0.0624469444,
0.0051253811,
-0.0113795968,
0.0611095168,
0.0141615579,
0.0139974579,
-0.0050170263,
0.0001333116,
0.0320537388,
-0.0226518679,
-0.0716164559,
0.0164434034,
-0.0593925565,
0.0071641468,
-0.0099877156,
-0.0564604327,
-0.0061952444,
-0.1266026944,
-0.0341685452,
-0.0033204474,
-0.0285614599,
0.0241878573,
0.0865653977,
0.0171274357,
-0.0107361097,
0.0513867885,
0.019398002,
-0.0560962334,
-0.0193954017,
-0.050017409,
0.0861712545,
-0.0150862364,
0.0315389074,
-0.0421192273,
-0.0118396142,
-0.0379891172,
0.008269106,
0.0237633251,
0.0557293035,
-0.0107478583,
-0.0345017724,
-0.0377847254,
-0.0202824082,
-0.0174662918,
0.0073592807,
-0.0199482236,
0.0644719303,
0.0081905611,
0.0212642793,
-0.020681303,
-0.0344857462,
0.0437804796,
0.035481669,
-0.0554740913,
0.0321035795,
-0.0102693159,
-0.013517648,
0.017262483,
0.0161949936,
0.0118928403,
0.0003794113,
0.0050383997,
-0.0211469755,
-0.0066680517,
-0.0173148718,
-0.0569013208,
0.046276018,
-0.0506023765,
-0.0343330503,
0.0106395669,
-0.0716227442,
-0.002127059,
0.0289745722,
-0.0158393327,
-0.033285059,
-0.0183081087,
0.0045742448,
-0.0176732447,
-0.0485257506,
-0.0135296248,
0.0332128853,
0.0338687375,
0.0125240767,
-0.0553695746,
0.0332406163,
0.038045723,
-0.0156260915,
-0.0152089931,
-0.0125239035,
-0.0163374059,
0.0430560112,
0.0167007223,
0.0310017392,
-0.0206874013,
0.0027102237,
-0.0188332964,
0.0084562851,
-0.0099874949,
0.067704767,
-0.0061591482,
-0.0596992821,
0.0092022149,
-0.0380845405,
-0.01861725,
-0.0241419319,
0.0333819836,
-0.0543034784,
0.0443593971,
-0.0196199026,
0.0015047075,
-0.0322882161,
-0.0202828106,
-0.0580103062,
0.0365721099,
0.0431714468,
0.0255057719,
-0.067918621,
0.0134977773,
-0.0178355947,
-0.0069658835,
0.0003765282,
0.0458786823,
0.0687391832,
0.0037349267,
-0.0536966734,
0.0086568156,
0.0120216748,
0.0101866685,
0.0054408968,
0.0236878507,
-0.0565584749,
0.0091075348,
-0.0156381261,
-0.0138471685,
0.0192943048,
0.0377076268,
0.0149986092,
0.0542120486,
-0.0366433188,
-0.0167516712,
-0.0269216038,
0.0488062613,
0.0077619748,
0.0326112546,
-0.015078974,
0.0201382656,
-0.0189543683,
0.0764880329,
0.0010752631,
-0.0632325038,
0.075241223,
-0.0114969434,
-0.0177173708,
-0.0548655614,
-0.0206016824,
-0.0562444255,
-0.0313372612,
-0.0091251517,
-0.0517232344,
0.0252366625,
0.0240589175,
0.0286179315,
-0.0424204692,
0.0670526102,
-0.0246637277,
0.0598527603,
-0.0261276476,
0.023184754,
-0.0260921307,
-0.0536044165,
-0.0440525413,
0.0173222292,
-0.059552215,
-0.0051787533,
-0.0395226479,
-0.0004313482,
-0.0130064711,
-0.023154052,
0.0140126133,
0.0178988241,
-0.039291162,
-0.0437996425,
-0.0070017441,
-0.039601326,
-0.0335083306,
0.0347206518,
0.0671030879,
-0.0548678301,
-0.0077774273,
0.034134388,
0.0441754125,
0.0241869874,
-0.0657361448,
-0.0193817653,
-0.0017038783,
-0.0460415855,
0.0152368285,
0.0217138976,
0.0288682021,
-0.0741649792,
0.007527228,
0.077784501,
0.0044507137,
-0.0223826952,
-0.0023124402,
-0.0652134269,
0.005014041,
0.0257980619,
0.0170700047,
-0.1018354222,
-0.0398441702,
0.003346327,
0.0596602857,
0.024823539,
-0.0045944378,
0.0081585674,
-0.1149864271,
0.0307986997,
0.0258547701,
0.0061311484,
0.0052840146,
-0.0480931737,
-0.0029653686,
-0.012648969,
-0.0205729138,
0.0090037435,
0.0151305106,
0.0312941894,
0.0385959111,
-0.0532186106,
-0.0269751027,
0.0116426041,
-0.0516491868,
-0.004604571,
0.0172228999,
-0.0163299851,
-0.0337227061,
-0.0848840848,
0.0266135335,
0.0466770642,
-0.0151170632,
-0.0049631339,
0.044209335,
-0.0415838808,
0.0114258081,
-0.0370020904,
0.0141550684,
-0.0572026633,
-0.0221819077,
0.0467269756,
0.092869781,
-0.0167854037,
-0.0097497767,
-0.0203424748,
0.0276360344,
-0.0554540753,
0.0296097733,
0.0072144656,
0.0324878916,
-0.072746098,
-0.0510837659,
-0.0140065039,
-0.0654137358,
-0.0673101395,
0.0000167856,
0.0535956211,
0.0005044944,
-0.0247757025,
-0.0183310844,
0.0106364405,
0.0672320575,
-0.0286446288,
-0.0306166373,
-0.01180794,
-0.0164344218,
-0.0186874978,
0.0531313866,
-0.0309091005,
0.0427978225,
-0.0475651696,
0.0420563444,
-0.0050161076,
0.017980963,
-0.0067562703,
0.0323324241,
-0.0863990709,
-0.0436929315,
-0.0851543397,
0.0591745302,
0.018991679,
0.0544605814,
-0.016082162,
-0.0008592146,
0.0219611283,
0.0349417739,
-0.0170959886,
0.0070914086,
0.0570318885,
0.0083854692,
-0.0002494122,
-0.0181498379,
-0.011562705,
-0.0121808806,
-0.0004288768,
0.0093333023,
-0.040537335,
-0.0232617762,
-0.0060299486,
0.0447266288,
0.046578031,
-0.003196825,
-0.0131273726,
0.0041515473,
0.0363842994,
-0.0007747752,
-0.0081925625,
0.0048377365,
0.0439063124,
-0.032653451,
-0.0527902581,
-0.0015029229,
-0.0226740334,
-0.0346252061,
0.0509939045,
0.0177676901,
0.0882420689,
0.0046034968,
0.0308606327,
0.0044039506,
-0.0084240222,
0.0045341076,
-0.0159511194,
0.0335390605,
0.0480188131,
0.0163196567,
0.0275905132,
0.0455211252,
0.0237617102,
0.0185743757,
-0.0282134227,
-0.0106078451,
-0.0843820721,
-0.0298893303,
0.0077901143,
0.0277061332,
0.0596403368,
-0.0289442334,
0.00488461,
0.005149445,
-0.0047827861,
0.0426327251,
-0.0200586095,
-0.0066285795,
0.0559114516,
0.0308488626,
0.0104882475,
-0.0448578,
0.0060753291,
-0.012866281,
0.009287471,
-0.008614379,
0.0142192645,
-0.0460720919,
-0.0191948507,
-0.0593836084,
-0.009069046,
0.0197957344,
-0.0270959046,
-0.0393830128,
-0.0841930956,
0.0367662385,
0.0376565754,
0.0078270668,
-0.0046054656,
0.0373170823,
0.0573898554,
0.0008361952,
-0.0308320988,
0.0172711741,
0.0159871113,
-0.0109040327,
-0.0120310718,
-0.0194872357,
-5.411582201e-33,
-0.032328587,
-0.0874373168,
0.0298562702,
0.0577904321,
0.0238180049,
-0.0344874226,
-0.0411132798,
0.0145265479,
0.0346345864,
0.0421901532,
0.0114327902,
0.0347599275,
0.009517787,
-0.0319677852,
0.0099300761,
-0.0296783969,
0.0473013818,
0.0067507206,
-0.0558913276,
-0.0177932326,
-0.0372424275,
0.0075839972,
0.1024415046,
-0.0900511146,
0.0795593485,
0.0076882839,
-0.0161715318,
0.0060313139,
-0.0622434318,
0.0653280467,
0.0215216409,
0.0586971976,
-0.0036531691,
-0.0322264209,
-0.0134510612,
0.0039844625,
-0.0330156423,
-0.057280533,
-0.0322459415,
0.0321028046,
-0.0614950247,
-0.023590954,
0.0674131811,
0.0205985513,
-0.0860327706,
0.0202278737,
0.0324295573,
-0.0142027773,
-0.006235979,
-0.010750181,
-0.0260139462,
0.0709234327,
-0.0107675772,
-0.0096851643,
0.0145434439,
0.0274921842,
-0.0294802822,
-0.0467322469,
-0.0280452929,
0.0041020289,
0.0447405986,
-0.0169061515,
0.058825165,
-0.0207174942,
-0.032670591,
0.034283217,
0.0132840937,
-0.0118958494,
-0.0240649283,
-0.004824731,
0.0399225429,
0.0360223092,
0.1294796616,
0.0450239107,
0.0593619719,
0.0255639907,
-0.0360127985,
0.0351188444,
-0.0333477035,
0.0562824085,
-0.0042713354,
-0.0148601029,
-0.0666299984,
-0.0116867824,
-0.0575738214,
-0.0135138612,
-0.0353090987,
-0.019174289,
0.0072302567,
0.0075439457,
-0.0091033457,
0.0291116368,
-0.0201720316,
-0.0437566526,
-0.011153047,
-0.0244311076,
0.0056256866,
0.0006692028,
-0.0012541813,
-0.0258460101,
-0.0537908934,
0.0229075029,
-0.0133397346,
0.0150657231,
0.0572141148,
0.0083595971,
0.0124005657,
0.0094615016,
-0.0540217459,
0.0112441294,
-0.0045461534,
0.0050425464,
0.0528045073,
0.0370014459,
0.0153735662,
0.0115484595,
-0.0020292357,
0.0955747515,
-0.0362574458,
0.0061355224,
-0.0085266903,
0.0692783669,
-0.0140831824,
0.046095293,
-0.0153547768,
-0.0185939483,
-0.0017361138,
-0.0047518336,
0.0166625716,
-0.0602748096,
0.0231957566,
0.0126953358,
2.758e-7,
0.0217697565,
0.0491281636,
0.0433199443,
0.002801554,
-0.0032855654,
0.0730185583,
-0.0092417141,
-0.0375251211,
0.0030983295,
-0.0476691127,
-0.0147323925,
0.0424269922,
0.03583882,
0.0342675969,
-0.0420240164,
0.0094673671,
-0.0173739456,
-0.0055420119,
-0.0276846755,
0.0150811765,
0.0644361973,
0.0365421474,
0.0525411703,
-0.0034142029,
-0.0094894292,
-0.0344109088,
0.0555417575,
0.0108342711,
0.0047760271,
0.0094755655,
0.0775948614,
-0.0057480941,
0.0250770729,
-0.0047927848,
0.0065534976,
0.0166623145,
-0.0524144508,
0.043100372,
-0.0024855388,
0.0037604882,
-0.0419510081,
-0.0200953353,
0.0228467379,
-0.0094816145,
0.0198492613,
-0.0221808665,
-0.026314266,
-0.0375458524,
0.0145763699,
-0.0640517548,
0.0523526259,
-0.006842128,
0.0118870717,
-0.0267728399,
0.0302372035,
-0.0021881512,
-0.0079079671,
-0.0355768986,
-0.0325781032,
0.0267975796,
-0.0155812092,
-0.001903838,
-0.0101939682,
0.0012084141,
0.0240207464,
-0.0121743018,
-0.0111617446,
2.463821695e-34,
0.0478231609,
0.0023656096,
0.0172677096,
0.0447224453,
0.0484090298,
0.0409864374,
-0.010552573,
0.0060581951,
0.0471924357,
0.0039016386,
-0.009808165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14023v1 | Evaluating Implicit Bias in Large Language Models by Attacking From a Psychometric Perspective | 2024-06-20T06:42:08 | 2024-06-20T06:42:08 | Yuchen Wen, Keping Bi, Wei Chen, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As Large Language Models (LLMs) become an important way of information
seeking, there have been increasing concerns about the unethical content LLMs
may generate. In this paper, we conduct a rigorous evaluation of LLMs' implicit
bias towards certain groups by attacking them with carefully crafted
instructions to elicit biased responses. Our attack methodology is inspired by
psychometric principles in cognitive and social psychology. We propose three
attack approaches, i.e., Disguise, Deception, and Teaching, based on which we
built evaluation datasets for four common bias types. Each prompt attack has
bilingual versions. Extensive evaluation of representative LLMs shows that 1)
all three attack methods work effectively, especially the Deception attacks; 2)
GLM-3 performs the best in defending our attacks, compared to GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4; 3) LLMs could output content of other bias types when being taught with
one type of bias. Our methodology provides a rigorous and effective way of
evaluating LLMs' implicit bias and will benefit the assessments of LLMs'
potential ethical risks. | [
0.0489487946,
0.0841411799,
-0.0708521158,
0.0536020063,
-0.0709566399,
0.0155635644,
0.0868489072,
-0.0054746275,
0.0491625778,
-0.0496099889,
-0.0425105467,
0.0081868703,
0.0262573268,
-0.0125586996,
0.0370734185,
-0.0404936448,
0.037196327,
0.0017101761,
0.065323174,
-0.0508076474,
0.0092527093,
0.0294668619,
0.0293597486,
0.0217891019,
0.0095718596,
-0.0254437178,
0.0433497168,
-0.0307299513,
0.0225498788,
-0.0075509609,
0.0318958387,
0.0622056201,
0.0045097801,
0.0647395402,
0.0000020243,
-0.0559556186,
-0.0038806747,
-0.0056244377,
-0.008269391,
0.0351246744,
0.0433857553,
0.0078051384,
0.0125054102,
-0.0006886031,
-0.0576491877,
0.0135663841,
0.0339322612,
0.0539494976,
0.0313468874,
0.0353821218,
0.0129501158,
-0.0137290955,
-0.0203966722,
-0.0070371986,
0.020481931,
0.0037388327,
0.0640637204,
-0.0434370488,
-0.0718752146,
0.0274077579,
0.0083442954,
0.0172899831,
0.0013498918,
-0.0054753018,
-0.0373056047,
-0.0102229519,
-0.0419795364,
-0.0140232276,
0.0027739368,
0.0195707679,
0.0124403723,
-0.0030557208,
0.0066237575,
-0.0058039119,
0.0292097423,
0.0282961968,
-0.0176977627,
0.0499697141,
-0.0097172791,
-0.0213136598,
0.0299413409,
0.0075843893,
0.0148922773,
0.0553192906,
0.0422322042,
0.0422020257,
0.0119409189,
-0.0246795658,
0.0253436547,
0.0177625511,
0.0280819554,
-0.0460945778,
-0.021874167,
0.007127034,
-0.0254852697,
0.0369399115,
-0.0163799152,
0.0087303482,
0.0508988909,
-0.0704542026,
0.0312374905,
0.0129863787,
-0.0057356106,
0.0083277021,
0.0169110671,
0.0391343236,
-0.0169591159,
0.0159370434,
-0.0229329765,
0.0309219342,
0.0178949907,
-0.0258138422,
-0.0000522866,
0.0045655374,
0.014185356,
0.0423203371,
-0.0536558554,
-0.0140118198,
-0.0739393309,
-0.0050497646,
-0.0508954525,
0.0001703936,
-0.0202840213,
-0.0024170487,
-0.0244255923,
0.0352340527,
-0.0226628724,
0.0341151692,
-0.0424081981,
-0.0874383673,
0.0282485317,
0.0307377446,
-0.0317490213,
-0.029180726,
-0.0140722562,
0.0697908849,
-0.0082082255,
-0.0105819004,
-0.0514464825,
-0.0507471934,
-0.0285698045,
-0.050672397,
-0.017556075,
-0.0548943132,
0.0047692792,
-0.0056441859,
-0.0152567085,
-0.0527495369,
-0.0105905905,
0.0324759409,
-0.0551190116,
0.0493431799,
0.0375803113,
0.0237288661,
0.0685460195,
0.0374833867,
-0.022148231,
0.0944450423,
-0.0142746158,
0.0299220607,
0.0525648296,
-0.0208819453,
0.0059607481,
0.0280240215,
0.025721034,
0.0503382869,
-0.0167331621,
0.0233196635,
-0.0066806446,
-0.0128503172,
0.0231148954,
0.066946812,
-0.0171918105,
-0.0390473567,
0.0904797688,
0.0467698276,
-0.009930227,
0.0195520874,
0.0303756688,
0.0347265676,
0.0205362607,
0.0281812809,
-0.0479182154,
-0.0203136411,
-0.0626385808,
-0.0461045578,
-0.0024729078,
0.0480278954,
-0.0000660014,
-0.0222921353,
-0.0093381582,
0.0245999247,
0.0393498987,
0.0605946146,
0.0089698033,
-0.0055844509,
-0.0043493761,
0.023648357,
0.0624475926,
-0.0164364483,
0.0053241248,
-0.0455414169,
0.0321114771,
0.0145242671,
-0.0054203235,
0.0250692759,
0.0474984646,
-0.0356904864,
-0.0189292282,
0.0786039978,
0.0743097439,
-0.030955717,
-0.026706636,
-0.0279969964,
-0.023927208,
-0.0010425709,
0.0135740582,
0.0486984625,
0.0347091965,
0.0473226234,
0.0234372281,
-0.0405814275,
-0.0284669548,
0.0213624854,
-0.0263818782,
-0.056858249,
-0.0374924764,
0.015857907,
0.0393613875,
0.0069273012,
-0.0117238127,
-0.0121218907,
-0.0045330557,
0.0340948738,
0.0176978987,
-0.0376042947,
-0.0304937493,
0.0067515522,
0.003523285,
-0.0431204252,
-0.0245363396,
-0.0161053333,
0.0000695465,
0.0386806615,
0.0374572948,
-0.0189576037,
0.0312776007,
-0.0120376814,
-0.0122129992,
-0.0569056198,
0.0014871848,
-0.0555670299,
0.0427871905,
-0.0034247262,
0.0296614915,
0.0308980048,
-0.0523527488,
0.0224339832,
-0.0489905588,
-0.0151960971,
0.0164081063,
-0.0015673578,
0.0111006387,
0.0294549055,
-0.0122056641,
-0.0193603877,
-0.0188303702,
-0.0711757913,
-0.0539237931,
-0.0032108149,
-0.0131563442,
-0.0068785911,
-0.0206545591,
-0.0352665596,
0.02420111,
-0.0620790347,
-0.0271465518,
-0.012825693,
0.0453263409,
-0.0380399153,
-0.0276271477,
-0.0145555176,
-0.0074416636,
-0.0077027078,
-0.0383573808,
0.0392761938,
0.0587356091,
0.0148483887,
-0.0556118898,
-0.0225756858,
-0.0394293554,
-0.0031216613,
-0.0169068351,
-0.0368127041,
0.0213896576,
0.0494438075,
0.0058735176,
0.0732595101,
0.055166401,
0.0314540006,
0.0493422076,
-0.0006116783,
-0.0709575787,
-0.0314524099,
-0.0042293109,
-0.021514358,
-0.0403614379,
-0.114977017,
0.0017269562,
0.0332979076,
0.0736224502,
-0.0148382382,
-0.0465347208,
0.0684095547,
-0.0840281323,
-0.0714421645,
-0.0036173044,
-0.0547730774,
-0.0194502864,
0.0128821135,
-0.0041791932,
-0.0752959102,
0.0623665377,
-0.0018259339,
0.0442238487,
-0.0263761915,
0.0142029161,
-0.0153443813,
0.0320717096,
-0.0004312445,
0.0367563702,
0.0460965745,
-0.005630496,
-0.0553712212,
-0.0446125902,
0.0559870787,
-0.0339742601,
0.0302324723,
-0.0319639109,
-0.0031171618,
0.0138258366,
0.0030005968,
-0.0511361994,
-0.0621891953,
-0.0080044037,
-0.0314060859,
0.0166229736,
-0.0052224784,
-0.0408718958,
-0.0420720503,
0.0449069291,
-0.0235260818,
-0.0314888544,
-0.0019634112,
0.0293045472,
-0.0300199464,
0.0354779363,
-0.0373366512,
0.0577222854,
-0.0497546792,
0.0012425691,
0.0264984928,
-0.0321322754,
0.031804584,
0.0222230293,
0.0014579715,
0.0445008129,
0.0083967838,
0.0127001023,
0.0245642271,
0.013910613,
-0.0236570593,
0.0395489559,
0.0931130946,
0.0060908729,
-0.0810030028,
0.0147937825,
-0.0173727442,
-0.0044386126,
0.01129675,
-0.0054586935,
-0.0857504681,
0.0146839563,
-0.0059034331,
0.0276098493,
-0.0799593255,
-0.0319435857,
-0.0113936653,
-0.10911908,
0.0339718871,
0.0238380805,
0.0090105729,
0.008818266,
-0.0418438353,
0.0008737873,
-0.017156532,
0.0373981111,
-0.017332932,
0.0029985649,
-0.0114366319,
-0.0105432309,
-0.0297733117,
-0.0409406386,
0.02151802,
0.0045774956,
0.0350957587,
0.0271895248,
0.0385892615,
-0.0488873199,
-0.0375039205,
0.0612334423,
-0.0222638752,
-0.0651771054,
-0.0190148596,
0.0487647429,
-0.0324832201,
0.0037674753,
-0.0314017646,
0.0428182334,
0.0123883532,
-0.0035716544,
0.0298496503,
0.0318865478,
0.0389471054,
-0.0436623059,
-0.0086831357,
0.0054867081,
0.0422391519,
0.0913392827,
0.0010237189,
-0.0342807956,
0.0523542687,
-0.0708524957,
-0.0119602522,
0.0644349158,
-0.0978439599,
0.0471203178,
-0.0099432459,
-0.0096748304,
-0.0174546875,
-0.069131799,
0.0109491609,
-0.0019549334,
0.0400919951,
0.0013109181,
0.0027378155,
-0.0252546668,
-0.0122031728,
0.0283283144,
-0.0387538522,
0.0452155769,
-0.0128661059,
-0.0221218728,
-0.0352689214,
-0.0390587226,
0.0050745308,
0.0021217368,
-0.0267337039,
-0.067806676,
0.05035742,
0.0163289253,
0.0220814161,
0.0456593446,
0.0128066121,
-0.0213269275,
0.0553067401,
0.0177664403,
-0.0175428484,
0.0441188626,
0.006178732,
0.0133093558,
0.0102757961,
0.027186064,
-0.0178788807,
0.0237559434,
0.0539558157,
-0.0164519269,
-0.0558587983,
-0.0281316377,
0.0400968976,
0.0141171515,
0.0304084253,
-0.0299725085,
0.0422674492,
-0.0257049929,
-0.0373603627,
-0.0458825454,
-0.0560310408,
0.0129112396,
-0.0619212091,
0.034399312,
0.0213892478,
-0.0111961793,
-0.0284334887,
-0.0596808977,
-0.0084989304,
-0.0403495096,
0.065047197,
0.0101149511,
0.0356419422,
0.0161711313,
-0.0071840957,
-0.0231413692,
0.0337517187,
-0.0256212689,
0.0554821789,
0.031737715,
0.0700631738,
0.0297367126,
-0.005607679,
0.0159364697,
-0.0187897142,
-0.002839017,
-0.0385357812,
0.0190769546,
-0.0144906742,
-0.0274573229,
-0.0400672518,
0.0393990688,
-0.0068454384,
0.0073597641,
-0.0050228764,
-0.0277154073,
-0.0014233305,
-0.0631429255,
0.0626964644,
-0.0110383155,
-0.0145744318,
0.0222712066,
0.0522940643,
0.0110127591,
0.0303051565,
-0.0079244915,
-0.0443299934,
-0.0145900436,
-0.0220165905,
0.061326921,
-0.0031708397,
-0.0237872545,
-0.0315013975,
-0.0795793757,
-0.0555775054,
-0.0486282185,
0.0065945997,
0.0158435386,
-0.0337128341,
-0.0035248154,
0.096761927,
-0.0199048705,
-0.0190571025,
-0.0403363258,
0.0435626917,
-0.0114252688,
-0.0211119652,
-0.0047954922,
-6.378650383e-33,
0.0083767921,
-0.0628289357,
-0.0194378141,
-0.0277885925,
-0.0046341573,
0.0330294222,
0.0118992031,
0.0186422151,
-0.0595043637,
0.0173179097,
0.0152896466,
-0.0111968303,
0.0106284292,
-0.0080935834,
-0.0243800823,
-0.0153326392,
0.0226153508,
-0.0066532455,
-0.0327493027,
-0.0037656352,
-0.0273196232,
-0.0394186676,
0.0490135588,
-0.0660359487,
0.091744408,
-0.0033941476,
-0.0246258806,
0.0077227401,
-0.0468849763,
0.0461031571,
0.0011551683,
0.0645899773,
0.0160286129,
0.0032022193,
0.0195061024,
0.0486410968,
-0.0019889008,
-0.0341206565,
0.0878632739,
0.0228858609,
0.0039081569,
-0.0418008603,
0.012730292,
-0.0258011371,
-0.0701417252,
-0.0087643331,
0.0426722616,
-0.0196852926,
0.0185187161,
0.0202676393,
-0.051451385,
0.0082922727,
-0.0146569712,
0.0463528335,
-0.0300460681,
0.0609758832,
-0.0021353937,
0.0137078883,
-0.0452560112,
0.0583599769,
0.0490684547,
-0.0199529063,
0.0448911712,
0.0053849285,
0.0209268406,
0.0583345741,
0.036599692,
0.0466725193,
-0.0240767933,
-0.0497082248,
0.042656254,
-0.0311158076,
0.0398949236,
0.0641894639,
-0.0040774886,
-0.0204265583,
-0.030760102,
-0.0328131765,
0.0712627172,
-0.0071432618,
0.0597469322,
-0.0288899913,
-0.072297737,
-0.0697805211,
-0.0481266417,
-0.0661388114,
-0.0091787921,
-0.0242700279,
0.0477590002,
0.0156382639,
-0.0029000577,
-0.0223083682,
0.042308677,
-0.0292480774,
-0.0265167709,
0.0080428813,
-0.0063751247,
-0.0191068687,
-0.0028439981,
0.0276937447,
-0.0626442805,
0.0290441737,
-0.0110993478,
-0.0162186474,
0.0352146365,
0.0168776419,
0.0118195862,
-0.0151283769,
-0.0401371233,
0.0007188584,
0.0025103705,
-0.0133120939,
0.0205074791,
-0.0214736238,
0.0455559194,
0.0173160285,
0.0026772248,
-0.012615039,
0.0468704514,
-0.0518732965,
-0.0400016606,
0.0110379579,
-0.0371450111,
0.035992749,
-0.0419135913,
-0.0080423672,
-0.0056064622,
0.0136661986,
0.0478223898,
-0.0527966842,
-0.022979917,
-0.0300374851,
2.664e-7,
0.0004735035,
0.0520759188,
-0.0605415069,
0.0435648449,
-0.0177250076,
0.0501055904,
0.0265184361,
0.0209676176,
0.0527029186,
-0.0332167782,
-0.0339444466,
0.0150631042,
0.0206142049,
0.033541359,
-0.0535314642,
0.0124070868,
-0.0252475347,
-0.0089179398,
-0.0557635576,
0.02146204,
0.0215340499,
0.0477826074,
0.0232529305,
0.0155337369,
-0.0451471619,
-0.0145607656,
0.0363486893,
-0.0327261686,
-0.0220940914,
0.0256760716,
0.0412893631,
-0.0155755449,
0.0356855616,
0.0519982204,
0.0100611579,
-0.0009641965,
-0.0124151707,
0.03372458,
-0.0031441818,
-0.0096683623,
-0.0181143545,
-0.0371169336,
-0.0261348151,
-0.0800630227,
0.0380783491,
0.00235876,
-0.0354974866,
-0.0191317331,
-0.0350746922,
-0.037205901,
0.0302583855,
-0.0236759353,
-0.0539879054,
0.0176507812,
0.0273084696,
0.0128919538,
0.0128818937,
-0.0165591016,
-0.0096474914,
-0.0105626583,
-0.0242176224,
-0.0724112615,
0.0011355525,
0.0355583876,
-0.0110064866,
-0.0140481172,
0.051239159,
2.446562132e-34,
0.0195547622,
-0.0081561022,
0.0189981572,
-0.0429874063,
0.0554144867,
0.0402764454,
-0.0149921598,
0.0103105009,
0.0297294967,
-0.0535198413,
-0.007729881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14022v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14022v1 | Investigating the Pre-Training Dynamics of In-Context Learning: Task Recognition vs. Task Learning | 2024-06-20T06:37:47 | 2024-06-20T06:37:47 | Xiaolei Wang, Xinyu Tang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The emergence of in-context learning (ICL) is potentially attributed to two
major abilities: task recognition (TR) for recognizing the task from
demonstrations and utilizing pre-trained priors, and task learning (TL) for
learning from demonstrations. However, relationships between the two abilities
and how such relationships affect the emergence of ICL is unclear. In this
paper, we take the first step by examining the pre-training dynamics of the
emergence of ICL. With carefully designed metrics, we find that these two
abilities are, in fact, competitive during pre-training. Moreover, we observe a
strong negative correlation between the competition and ICL performance.
Further analysis of common pre-training factors (i.e., model size, dataset
size, and data curriculum) demonstrates possible ways to manage the
competition. Based on these insights, we propose a simple yet effective method
to better integrate these two abilities for ICL at inference time. Through
adaptive ensemble learning, the performance of ICL can be significantly
boosted, enabling two small models to outperform a larger one with more than
twice the parameters. The code is available at
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/Competitive-ICL. | [
-0.0583474115,
0.0208106767,
0.003846376,
0.0145990159,
0.0170968994,
0.0297987889,
0.0234274976,
-0.0177751463,
-0.0323988274,
-0.0188178346,
-0.0483692698,
-0.0185754169,
-0.0099754035,
-0.0330657326,
0.0304008257,
-0.0624560677,
-0.0140524805,
-0.0110169491,
-0.0440662578,
0.0136896288,
-0.0121450322,
-0.0395091809,
-0.0322884396,
0.0416652523,
0.0064147739,
0.0035709129,
-0.0247090366,
-0.0154379811,
0.0287001152,
-0.0517688207,
-0.0011443833,
0.0229647662,
0.0673373416,
0.0007636495,
0.000002178,
-0.0538937226,
-0.0116157765,
-0.0333687179,
-0.0324324593,
-0.0337469615,
0.0153033501,
0.0701051429,
0.0080305086,
-0.0048872684,
-0.0423475727,
-0.0170452688,
0.011003904,
0.0448067077,
-0.015434674,
0.0367390327,
0.0050074044,
0.0549812242,
-0.0133428127,
-0.0159537122,
-0.0097055938,
-0.0553410053,
-0.0028029541,
-0.012191724,
0.0256756134,
-0.0453324392,
-0.0256122034,
0.0043219281,
0.0393949561,
0.0493520908,
0.0596653819,
0.0599109381,
-0.00638047,
0.0231921524,
-0.0144833513,
0.0280292127,
-0.0386930257,
-0.0259649958,
-0.0067769308,
-0.0144149791,
0.0467213653,
0.0047813165,
-0.0548155606,
0.0098460438,
-0.0106013259,
0.0127764549,
-0.0469234101,
0.0444369502,
0.0272563044,
-0.0077856267,
0.0090189269,
0.0313462242,
-0.0492459387,
-0.0096011702,
0.0291479938,
-0.016620459,
-0.0229151025,
-0.0659882948,
0.0022585785,
0.0061629941,
-0.0569232628,
-0.0204462297,
-0.0330661871,
-0.0682956353,
-0.0514165275,
-0.0106523158,
0.0833531693,
-0.0071336837,
-0.0046607954,
0.040684849,
-0.017456986,
0.0939576328,
-0.0098966546,
0.0122632058,
-0.0254199319,
0.0530576557,
-0.0712604821,
0.040033333,
-0.0244102012,
-0.0069845114,
-0.0088034011,
-0.0058579268,
-0.0065934374,
0.0321513824,
-0.0383713283,
-0.0257322881,
-0.013890991,
0.0335110649,
-0.0213729199,
0.0367776118,
-0.0098682819,
-0.0198001582,
-0.0042391135,
0.0585224107,
-0.0040806262,
-0.0201804489,
-0.0335239731,
0.0097285593,
0.0211576819,
0.0080050202,
0.0286225099,
0.0026897055,
-0.0383276083,
-0.038136594,
0.0074352948,
0.0038062283,
0.0501186177,
-0.053615015,
0.0615247265,
-0.0375099257,
0.0004397571,
-0.0125466194,
0.02027696,
-0.0219859872,
-0.0284041036,
-0.0085755549,
0.031156458,
0.0861670375,
-0.00955051,
0.0181533489,
0.0097985463,
-0.0061327065,
-0.0802030191,
0.0424637608,
0.0120188911,
0.0126936259,
-0.0300388411,
0.0296346769,
0.0303737354,
0.0302636083,
0.027458787,
-0.0082789119,
-0.0052718157,
0.0102945836,
0.0321564414,
0.0198627748,
0.00946905,
-0.0491699874,
-0.0486901291,
0.0590768643,
0.0597771853,
0.0328262672,
-0.0126632843,
-0.0700934082,
0.0025882137,
0.0083646765,
0.0066077355,
-0.0235212296,
-0.0660167113,
0.0334381349,
0.0114229508,
-0.0306998901,
-0.0284087528,
0.0341826454,
-0.035138417,
-0.0233581234,
-0.002815963,
-0.0163597222,
-0.017410364,
0.0347928368,
0.0671303719,
0.0203758422,
-0.0524889827,
-0.0614896938,
0.0041548535,
0.0003611568,
0.0109101869,
-0.0769260302,
-0.0059167962,
-0.0303569119,
-0.0189276151,
-0.0300535932,
-0.036963366,
-0.0396545567,
0.0687967837,
-0.0241660494,
-0.0178645421,
-0.0259721261,
0.0418660082,
0.0051883534,
-0.0626347885,
-0.0221292023,
0.0128225023,
0.0197436213,
0.0226956252,
-0.0188957583,
-0.0195159316,
-0.0262312926,
-0.0486583896,
0.0303128865,
-0.059345372,
-0.046909485,
0.0031301954,
-0.0055790073,
0.0752917752,
-0.0257133245,
-0.0332482718,
-0.0170618463,
0.0298063327,
-0.0218653586,
0.0246421527,
0.0592988469,
-0.0530130602,
-0.0447108038,
0.0164385159,
-0.0148015805,
-0.0080590732,
-0.0011230609,
-0.0170803089,
-0.0320114382,
0.0123937633,
0.0253043622,
0.0324931853,
-0.0181265566,
0.0135046104,
-0.0314610638,
-0.0354334228,
-0.0109722782,
0.0546484441,
0.0305877794,
-0.0241180677,
0.0416314378,
0.0044147712,
0.0028086181,
-0.0086307656,
0.0043368684,
-0.0262188464,
-0.0303987637,
0.0361556113,
-0.0038681778,
0.0168537386,
-0.0318592861,
0.0458409376,
-0.0718101263,
0.0166082084,
-0.0279596094,
-0.0057319929,
0.0030973125,
-0.0470288955,
-0.0353408121,
-0.0092801154,
0.0048635132,
-0.009066416,
-0.0056267078,
-0.0059919585,
-0.0230269227,
0.0210357998,
-0.0041971738,
0.0132505931,
0.0575246513,
0.0142707899,
0.0494160913,
0.0423176177,
0.009308896,
-0.006568972,
0.0434195474,
0.0581758991,
0.0292686168,
-0.0132765034,
0.0302846674,
0.0436784327,
-0.0165066179,
0.016341906,
0.0849706978,
-0.023253765,
0.0533027016,
0.0557825454,
0.0078730276,
-0.0266430229,
0.0219713058,
-0.0174272433,
0.0163607523,
-0.0478927046,
0.0200073104,
0.0499112792,
0.0355244726,
-0.0094665177,
-0.0066392962,
-0.0345112234,
0.0148413973,
-0.0199820474,
-0.0631006882,
-0.0624624677,
-0.004773017,
-0.0559605137,
-0.02012535,
-0.0397545546,
-0.0550901145,
-0.0035408735,
0.0160989705,
-0.0099393213,
-0.0267044138,
-0.0082521159,
0.044793956,
0.0367412083,
0.0062107132,
-0.0129340906,
0.0134712681,
0.001952076,
-0.053750772,
0.0186113697,
0.0188251752,
-0.0073888842,
-0.0150306718,
-0.0378876664,
-0.0044337758,
-0.0206216872,
-0.0216278527,
-0.057006482,
0.0140727041,
0.0121300025,
0.0203504749,
-0.0406459719,
-0.0148620866,
-0.0157122146,
-0.0233763829,
0.0201667249,
0.0336514004,
-0.0256135296,
-0.0072220606,
0.0045684702,
0.015827544,
-0.0173564591,
0.0466768816,
-0.0345550142,
-0.0961687714,
0.0158466529,
0.0397752821,
0.1624456346,
-0.0549167842,
-0.0942612886,
0.0083619328,
-0.003625442,
-0.0009326961,
0.0171161741,
0.0732379779,
0.0853393674,
-0.0017802271,
-0.0168939754,
0.0592449531,
-0.0270505957,
-0.0551359542,
-0.0097867521,
0.0536549352,
-0.0126105454,
0.0300456658,
0.0038671889,
0.0210846812,
-0.0240021572,
0.007177393,
0.0376826338,
0.0032054929,
-0.0172843933,
0.0092933495,
-0.0691500679,
0.0377119146,
0.0240289047,
-0.0853369683,
-0.0255879667,
-0.0067229532,
0.0408549681,
-0.0321856663,
0.014670006,
0.0079113329,
-0.0224228185,
0.0357558019,
0.0660727099,
0.0071211709,
-0.088729538,
0.0018200451,
-0.0804580525,
0.0071070828,
0.0308681596,
0.0106185423,
0.0065992717,
0.0064769052,
0.0050380272,
-0.0050140759,
0.0194077864,
-0.0121126082,
0.0580074899,
-0.0062042414,
0.0185270477,
0.0060804193,
0.0598403625,
-0.0244072378,
-0.0262285359,
0.0424707606,
0.0741587356,
-0.0526487045,
-0.0054404568,
-0.0029091556,
-0.0709727928,
0.0718781501,
0.0436877273,
0.0254367627,
-0.0355241187,
-0.0095647592,
0.035153728,
-0.0151154939,
-0.0201651771,
0.0131596746,
-0.0063652755,
0.0066483328,
-0.0193240475,
-0.0279680733,
0.0030100427,
0.0358287767,
0.0987089872,
0.0017276305,
0.0057272976,
-0.0623492301,
0.0432562716,
-0.0712646097,
0.0793508142,
0.0206921455,
0.006933467,
-0.031606108,
-0.0531451516,
0.0167649034,
-0.0398524068,
-0.0257383306,
0.0009123661,
-0.0723292306,
-0.0015733445,
-0.00308425,
0.0411544703,
0.0153232766,
0.0790479407,
0.0087971007,
0.0079734651,
0.0691331252,
0.0479070321,
0.0109784454,
0.0489025414,
0.0400767587,
-0.0690719709,
-0.0175689459,
-0.0100749126,
-0.0070365239,
0.0247317124,
0.0380455181,
-0.0498055518,
-0.0469951108,
0.0334946252,
0.0160000771,
-0.0443840697,
0.0880629867,
-0.0324419588,
-0.0543542542,
-0.050400544,
-0.0287217032,
0.0403265134,
-0.0045174654,
-0.0469334349,
-0.0249567349,
-0.0005702795,
0.0852571949,
0.0085382806,
0.052837301,
0.0611612499,
0.0171306171,
-0.0676736832,
0.0144779459,
0.0457257852,
0.0143503901,
-0.0037259511,
0.0535312295,
0.0230935123,
-0.0193744544,
0.0032904628,
0.0098057138,
0.0398329757,
0.0396836028,
0.042597685,
-0.005356187,
0.0253769737,
0.0471110456,
-0.07466501,
0.0003998831,
-0.042830687,
0.0257355031,
0.0466086529,
-0.0528250188,
0.0046658316,
-0.020736916,
0.0226451438,
-0.02349573,
0.0150289545,
-0.0280152056,
-0.0063612466,
0.0274318345,
0.0059327204,
0.0242937375,
0.0166411661,
0.0595362112,
-0.0204678159,
0.0412677526,
-0.0056570978,
0.0313902423,
-0.0352867879,
-0.0093202796,
0.0749911889,
0.0259428564,
-0.0087161846,
0.0252397526,
0.0061496049,
-0.0031334606,
-0.0103607345,
-0.0149112232,
-0.0054703252,
-0.0189811271,
0.0449314155,
0.0199487302,
-0.0644551665,
-0.0289389975,
0.0173474755,
-0.0399633609,
0.0163270719,
0.0048116785,
-0.026576044,
-5.724876057e-33,
-0.0028309531,
-0.0191508569,
0.0066256761,
-0.017653482,
0.0033965101,
0.003595694,
-0.0326628648,
0.0022900801,
0.0133667281,
0.0055297059,
-0.017913077,
-0.0086311707,
0.0065435725,
-0.0160521176,
0.0435279422,
-0.0149497716,
0.0236854628,
-0.0411514677,
0.0016850373,
0.0502775908,
0.0296338554,
0.0230378173,
0.0563279912,
-0.0680278614,
-0.0079536736,
0.0049021821,
-0.0364547372,
-0.0184041169,
-0.0207222681,
-0.006588771,
-0.0287075061,
-0.017654296,
0.0255363639,
-0.0634388104,
-0.0384502485,
0.013227188,
-0.0176388919,
-0.0423967056,
-0.0526287481,
0.0232819952,
-0.0625852272,
0.0063973097,
0.038052652,
0.0089024035,
-0.0825390667,
-0.0211668704,
0.0612884797,
-0.0170017257,
0.0445764624,
-0.0486334078,
0.0045395438,
0.0127639351,
0.0077527422,
-0.0630282462,
0.0339308642,
0.0494122356,
-0.0309226699,
-0.0435389951,
-0.0256448202,
0.032659471,
0.0032265582,
-0.0092101209,
0.0417181961,
0.0869622603,
0.0496788993,
0.0649167597,
0.0118905986,
0.013346401,
0.0483197942,
-0.0543444641,
0.0248268116,
0.0868288353,
0.0093690632,
0.0001913231,
0.0455437563,
0.0493681692,
-0.0428652465,
0.0665992573,
0.0327318199,
0.0056654606,
-0.0225493796,
0.009503426,
-0.0329470783,
-0.0072252038,
0.018318804,
0.0048580188,
0.0346512347,
0.0142058833,
0.0601394251,
0.0115938354,
-0.0189383477,
0.021601947,
0.0508594401,
-0.0305139329,
0.0199821256,
0.007688507,
-0.0072661042,
0.0280389581,
0.0382349826,
-0.0460443199,
-0.0717981532,
-0.0557075031,
0.0055281082,
0.0209144,
0.0205802191,
0.0038377827,
0.0038169215,
0.0499889441,
-0.0135167735,
-0.0131938532,
-0.0206531342,
0.0138280671,
0.0889134556,
-0.0148610659,
0.0797599182,
-0.0004040546,
-0.0128328698,
0.0257543679,
0.0047298581,
-0.0895071104,
-0.0085080359,
0.0069171661,
-0.0498871356,
0.0050340337,
0.0067081302,
-0.0115781222,
-0.0392100029,
-0.0251759291,
-0.0311416239,
-0.0558008775,
-0.0105722286,
0.007674484,
2.875e-7,
-0.0501909181,
-0.0008577795,
-0.0010749043,
-0.0458077006,
0.0401072726,
0.0416653268,
-0.0770805106,
0.0252873078,
0.0075896587,
-0.0225675106,
0.0253479388,
0.0455619097,
0.0218227468,
0.0023389626,
-0.0368428975,
-0.0790095925,
-0.0124489134,
0.0573706292,
-0.0380109884,
0.0037344745,
-0.0233840272,
0.0241799504,
0.0333636664,
0.0035528538,
0.0188624952,
-0.0486924052,
0.0471092612,
-0.0418925174,
0.0691135749,
-0.0141931903,
-0.0118443919,
-0.0180237424,
-0.0329258144,
0.0625559986,
-0.0307020824,
0.0369269773,
-0.0200001933,
0.0001890478,
-0.009629298,
0.0480489023,
0.0201133657,
0.054862801,
0.0207030103,
-0.0366315134,
0.0781284347,
-0.1048220694,
-0.0047860504,
-0.0356425308,
-0.0185388122,
-0.0134283705,
-0.0269865021,
0.0428678282,
0.0324181914,
-0.0097099012,
-0.0143808452,
-0.0144332144,
-0.0384781584,
-0.0575792901,
-0.0335220434,
0.0266409274,
-0.0779157951,
-0.0178496055,
-0.0059903623,
0.0116712973,
0.0173263103,
-0.0264160279,
-0.0283367578,
2.208969469e-34,
-0.0197650101,
0.0080224965,
0.0366591178,
0.016034307,
-0.0358004831,
-0.0435517468,
-0.0156770349,
-0.0017203565,
0.0650039762,
0.0074006165,
0.0037847259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14021v1 | HIGHT: Hierarchical Graph Tokenization for Graph-Language Alignment | 2024-06-20T06:37:35 | 2024-06-20T06:37:35 | Yongqiang Chen, Quanming Yao, Juzheng Zhang, James Cheng, Yatao Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM | Recently there has been a surge of interest in extending the success of large
language models (LLMs) to graph modality, such as social networks and
molecules. As LLMs are predominantly trained with 1D text data, most existing
approaches adopt a graph neural network to represent a graph as a series of
node tokens and feed these tokens to LLMs for graph-language alignment. Despite
achieving some successes, existing approaches have overlooked the hierarchical
structures that are inherent in graph data. Especially, in molecular graphs,
the high-order structural information contains rich semantics of molecular
functional groups, which encode crucial biochemical functionalities of the
molecules. We establish a simple benchmark showing that neglecting the
hierarchical information in graph tokenization will lead to subpar
graph-language alignment and severe hallucination in generated outputs. To
address this problem, we propose a novel strategy called HIerarchical GrapH
Tokenization (HIGHT). HIGHT employs a hierarchical graph tokenizer that
extracts and encodes the hierarchy of node, motif, and graph levels of
informative tokens to improve the graph perception of LLMs. HIGHT also adopts
an augmented graph-language supervised fine-tuning dataset, enriched with the
hierarchical graph information, to further enhance the graph-language
alignment. Extensive experiments on 7 molecule-centric benchmarks confirm the
effectiveness of HIGHT in reducing hallucination by 40%, as well as significant
improvements in various molecule-language downstream tasks. | [
0.0237207934,
0.0654380545,
0.0221529473,
0.0243287738,
-0.0154866753,
0.0063535976,
-0.0163517073,
0.0224030223,
0.0535103343,
0.0012297721,
-0.0277648792,
-0.0291882511,
0.0078820903,
0.0505673401,
0.0579765178,
0.0113817602,
0.0243146457,
-0.0125283841,
-0.002585222,
-0.0233560763,
0.0151473414,
0.0330731571,
0.0699204803,
0.0068072802,
-0.0134289898,
-0.0574419834,
0.0319673903,
0.0398374088,
0.020532392,
-0.03175392,
-0.0176963117,
0.0321763717,
0.0177049413,
0.0769588873,
0.0000016664,
-0.0309908558,
-0.024590021,
0.0169339385,
-0.0122215366,
0.0178599916,
0.0602040291,
-0.0413192362,
0.0339918956,
-0.0263047777,
-0.0174701642,
-0.0084746573,
0.0774451941,
0.0235689059,
0.0268662665,
0.0422333442,
-0.0017146426,
-0.0301831625,
0.0491410047,
-0.0126569858,
0.0163056888,
-0.0040439074,
0.0588944443,
0.0230668187,
-0.0034052429,
-0.0206647161,
-0.0349982157,
0.0279398467,
-0.0334489457,
-0.0316964425,
0.062295638,
0.0028983273,
-0.0299655963,
-0.0099107875,
0.0155345034,
0.1140163168,
-0.0421684645,
-0.0585630946,
-0.0149033358,
-0.0100962846,
-0.0038739988,
-0.0022365458,
-0.0215930529,
-0.0153257493,
-0.0059210858,
0.0467628725,
0.0160648972,
-0.0514508225,
0.0783622786,
-0.0123321787,
-0.0178229883,
0.0708848536,
-0.0089792768,
-0.0058033611,
0.0117786871,
-0.0167017262,
-0.0296429191,
-0.0204644687,
0.0295274481,
-0.0133123212,
-0.0224754717,
-0.0001710216,
0.004593581,
0.0064610727,
0.024765905,
-0.0394705869,
-0.006778344,
0.004389958,
0.0018608201,
0.0128397858,
-0.0254952498,
0.0234818999,
-0.0474390797,
0.0835351348,
-0.0433990657,
-0.0061760759,
-0.052410569,
0.0145474318,
-0.0331125334,
0.0344861597,
-0.0103197433,
-0.040492177,
-0.0621848591,
0.0106771756,
-0.0107402569,
-0.0003136719,
-0.0008538338,
0.0279415268,
0.0020953775,
0.0001519357,
0.0231528915,
0.042826388,
0.0202306435,
-0.0040452504,
0.0025979055,
-0.0379585139,
-0.0166136324,
0.0104788831,
0.0298955906,
-0.0273614675,
0.0076652057,
0.1043703035,
0.0298257824,
-0.0259552803,
0.0169063024,
-0.0283994824,
0.0036612877,
-0.0295326505,
0.0262543596,
-0.0790838078,
0.0802786574,
0.040507976,
-0.0013817922,
-0.0453479737,
0.017255852,
-0.0244209841,
-0.0728564113,
0.0814615339,
-0.0479701385,
-0.0262637399,
0.0210562162,
-0.028999662,
-0.0158010721,
-0.0027720863,
0.0183258485,
0.0305157397,
0.0056523122,
-0.0125332437,
-0.0285519529,
0.0128062638,
0.0142991105,
-0.0373643525,
-0.0074858535,
-0.0196606722,
-0.0009041601,
0.0459562503,
0.0231913794,
0.0685843155,
-0.0185180288,
0.0074339448,
0.0249487106,
0.0405921079,
0.0171220619,
-0.0151436161,
-0.0013252484,
0.0343268663,
-0.0209079534,
0.0034000243,
-0.077681534,
0.0126111396,
0.0158648901,
0.0284530874,
0.0495137274,
0.011296479,
0.0154205021,
0.0065017217,
-0.0256344024,
0.0139256492,
0.0529534742,
-0.0218432453,
0.0371613391,
-0.0225111675,
-0.0811087191,
0.0334352776,
0.0655639619,
-0.0080356607,
0.0185144357,
0.0069949562,
-0.0104017658,
0.093634598,
0.028757032,
-0.014890681,
-0.0174105261,
0.0149421608,
-0.0059760641,
0.0234811027,
-0.0032245957,
-0.0229629818,
0.0074764956,
-0.018232923,
-0.0133802611,
-0.029797757,
-0.0048722741,
0.0044848509,
-0.0183578096,
-0.0243207756,
-0.0093882428,
-0.0920596197,
-0.0664595217,
0.0156753659,
0.0576374345,
0.0050497376,
-0.0540355742,
-0.0074408422,
0.0226818752,
0.0225850791,
-0.0160737652,
0.0524347797,
0.0151972342,
-0.0124463402,
0.001223515,
-0.0593982451,
-0.0280722398,
-0.025401134,
0.0631645545,
-0.0181873403,
-0.0266493522,
0.0099670729,
-0.0527403839,
-0.0260447264,
0.0475666486,
-0.0381737575,
0.0533051975,
-0.0000145718,
0.0199767649,
-0.0104836347,
0.0570008457,
-0.0181789845,
0.0357039198,
0.0146521525,
0.0083109671,
-0.0213522539,
0.0064078392,
-0.0147360209,
-0.0386573412,
0.0169259962,
0.0313026085,
0.0168457199,
0.0078838365,
0.0334706381,
-0.017930476,
-0.035125643,
0.030502256,
-0.0694913343,
-0.0207572933,
0.0073050428,
0.025323322,
-0.0149940941,
-0.0068820673,
0.0311656557,
-0.0174857955,
-0.0415994339,
0.0432611555,
-0.0241926368,
0.0163303725,
0.0226305723,
-0.0367288515,
-0.067014046,
-0.0488676354,
-0.0493949018,
-0.0579543673,
0.0791647881,
0.0020912627,
-0.0986608416,
0.0066133365,
-0.0123879155,
-0.0279691387,
0.0042004753,
0.0010245319,
-0.0038645866,
-0.0019169556,
0.0135950455,
0.0268972125,
0.0312563963,
-0.0266748723,
-0.000966915,
0.0581177175,
0.0404375717,
-0.0135994777,
-0.0419081338,
-0.0326778665,
0.0103145065,
-0.0112118395,
-0.0359597877,
-0.018265523,
0.0517418236,
0.0055238842,
0.0293767508,
-0.0230868049,
-0.0076298667,
-0.0012840609,
0.0057428069,
-0.0126737626,
-0.0255248621,
0.0015927107,
-0.0297286902,
-0.0296053421,
-0.0446350239,
0.0736094862,
-0.0361200683,
0.0047711814,
0.0353520699,
-0.0027599656,
0.0014831695,
0.0205401722,
0.0793116093,
0.044464387,
-0.006335746,
-0.0621180981,
-0.0078538107,
-0.0064045023,
0.0168617703,
-0.0432902575,
-0.000085936,
-0.0109691983,
0.0219128467,
0.0064371717,
-0.0125728082,
0.0138990674,
0.0395596847,
-0.0368612073,
0.0582710803,
0.0503806323,
-0.0560039096,
-0.0077848327,
0.0148503818,
-0.0044186488,
0.0158742182,
-0.0261907484,
0.0184359979,
-0.0338667035,
0.0518187843,
0.0484393761,
-0.0687059015,
0.0463289469,
-0.0170167368,
0.0248923786,
0.0485084094,
0.0006798869,
0.0010957556,
-0.0026569217,
-0.0251721926,
0.0088153519,
0.0092998184,
-0.0136118131,
-0.0284036808,
0.01700061,
-0.0176496673,
0.001327334,
0.0718869492,
0.0138537027,
-0.0487835407,
0.0266558211,
-0.0178590864,
0.0079731075,
-0.0161286443,
0.0050917538,
-0.1089188308,
-0.0154108256,
-0.0275249276,
0.0325054601,
0.0286752712,
-0.0365698077,
0.0149493776,
-0.0334254093,
0.0137323905,
0.077768594,
-0.0639254376,
-0.0270814765,
-0.0671648383,
-0.0435483083,
-0.0104069654,
0.0433074497,
0.0169857815,
0.0128606977,
-0.0242831726,
0.0307771638,
-0.0216311701,
-0.015534482,
0.0115283011,
-0.0270954669,
0.0160066336,
0.0085024014,
0.0257721674,
0.0214855801,
0.0035271009,
0.0452915356,
0.0601606146,
-0.0028057566,
0.0012022681,
0.0236831941,
-0.0011113735,
-0.0056920601,
-0.0277615897,
0.0173630733,
-0.0580483004,
-0.0343839116,
-0.0742412508,
0.0970657319,
0.0001774477,
-0.0482877046,
-0.0030519902,
-0.0086680511,
-0.0454373248,
0.011716662,
0.0385305397,
0.0165430773,
-0.0837887675,
-0.0145669281,
0.0512310788,
-0.0515623763,
0.0106389886,
0.0265768077,
-0.0372301862,
0.0186538436,
-0.0228735618,
-0.0025492245,
0.0256101787,
-0.0371479802,
-0.0195622742,
0.0268665031,
0.0359288938,
-0.0633064285,
-0.081212014,
0.0457476303,
-0.0145510267,
0.0127196731,
-0.0328523666,
-0.0461125486,
-0.0009161412,
0.0070752269,
0.0020493071,
0.0543632098,
-0.0511182621,
-0.1053202823,
-0.0265099555,
-0.0325785875,
0.0121406959,
0.065100342,
-0.0003438828,
-0.0380538292,
0.0495970063,
0.0508915782,
0.0126621509,
-0.0378075466,
-0.0069511021,
-0.0204960536,
-0.0322423503,
0.0236109197,
-0.0562997647,
-0.013817789,
0.0429922007,
0.029295247,
0.0294902325,
0.0041913721,
0.0494809672,
0.0607520863,
0.0550338738,
-0.0178930964,
0.0098607251,
-0.0403245687,
-0.0429812521,
-0.0053504142,
-0.0190020148,
-0.0063186567,
-0.0363513343,
0.0506361276,
-0.0067709479,
-0.0080677094,
-0.0474177897,
-0.0121232243,
0.0173768401,
-0.0160899386,
-0.0337708667,
-0.0433764905,
-0.0329485349,
0.0963996872,
-0.0269588958,
-0.0257984083,
0.0192532185,
-0.0170978475,
0.0101883169,
-0.0285152569,
-0.032226529,
0.0121379429,
0.0045635472,
-0.0771027878,
0.0220341403,
0.009935068,
-0.0358206183,
-0.0766654164,
0.0003943166,
0.0603180118,
0.0096274521,
0.0665726513,
-0.0015738764,
-0.0129016936,
-0.0340755321,
0.0418355837,
-0.0015872406,
-0.0471788906,
0.0597125553,
0.0176358204,
-0.0292187091,
-0.001691674,
0.0474149995,
0.0743014365,
0.0000369939,
-0.0162099283,
-0.0579465479,
-0.004205327,
-0.0184294451,
-0.0328579769,
0.0320363753,
-0.0430816635,
-0.0091108084,
-0.0200188793,
-0.0798276663,
0.0215836149,
0.0293394513,
-0.0211356692,
0.0244517494,
0.0120259458,
0.0269483663,
0.0209008064,
-0.0762647316,
-0.0216632299,
0.0426860005,
0.0411422104,
-0.027666783,
-0.0135886967,
-5.85019404e-33,
0.0088285636,
-0.0478199311,
-0.0223600157,
0.0362637378,
-0.0514351465,
0.0160427298,
-0.084390223,
-0.0076570665,
0.0005495469,
0.0755654871,
0.0058279652,
0.006454254,
0.00092159,
-0.0204214938,
-0.0099053578,
0.0147309033,
0.0182255171,
0.0164165292,
-0.0030007034,
0.0420574993,
0.0536733381,
0.0316495039,
0.0680885687,
-0.0325981155,
0.0137452139,
-0.0025955092,
0.0085717961,
0.0051402738,
0.003308817,
0.0070123132,
-0.0132296206,
0.0645501837,
-0.0013686121,
0.020015724,
-0.0110373553,
0.0002298248,
-0.0495818332,
0.0134638464,
0.0320007503,
0.0160316601,
-0.0323036723,
-0.0406747088,
0.0661839396,
-0.0110042421,
-0.0330382958,
-0.0272883736,
0.0254920498,
0.0011878464,
-0.0576703623,
0.0012495689,
-0.0822355598,
0.0274027586,
0.0241013188,
0.0481996424,
0.0035556622,
-0.0145238088,
0.0144361947,
0.0117517626,
-0.052819822,
0.0416371413,
-0.0444024019,
0.0065617049,
0.072275497,
0.0578278974,
0.0211049318,
0.0595617741,
0.0537146181,
0.0091810003,
0.0288256817,
0.0390271917,
0.004071774,
0.0482483841,
0.0059545394,
-0.0341157988,
-0.0068943342,
-0.0032036817,
-0.0846079066,
-0.028752666,
-0.0777578056,
0.0147286784,
-0.0065175463,
0.0630712062,
0.0017824591,
-0.0545180738,
0.0061303638,
0.0007811407,
-0.0110399909,
-0.0385523252,
-0.036116045,
-0.0590040386,
-0.0159207452,
0.0196219198,
0.0044877878,
-0.0559352674,
-0.0325911678,
0.0774453804,
-0.0009996308,
0.0254403073,
-0.029471159,
0.0157852676,
-0.0326324254,
-0.0572846569,
-0.001738374,
-0.0489987023,
0.0244221427,
-0.0079153702,
0.0449263379,
0.0006386117,
0.0007558945,
-0.0007591825,
-0.0751512349,
-0.0460108258,
0.0018575531,
-0.0068686693,
0.0621988177,
0.0198760312,
-0.0100279534,
0.0603495799,
0.0442796126,
0.0215927288,
0.0204912219,
0.0651114807,
-0.015222095,
0.0467913412,
-0.0736195669,
-0.006507752,
-0.0562272184,
0.0066591087,
0.0263550915,
-0.0650005192,
-0.0370051488,
-0.0117681231,
2.632e-7,
0.0697463602,
0.0549234599,
0.0746260136,
-0.0209838301,
0.0036390533,
0.0018154361,
0.0154139316,
0.0518428124,
-0.051965367,
-0.0220148955,
0.0177647043,
-0.0109080737,
-0.0073010982,
-0.0008764608,
-0.0299139842,
0.0549097583,
-0.0939644501,
-0.0234645456,
-0.0623054318,
0.0433922522,
-0.0099193417,
0.0986152738,
0.005517811,
-0.0127212545,
0.0182245299,
-0.0671328306,
0.0426037572,
-0.0050560255,
-0.0197945591,
0.0539920665,
-0.0494180918,
-0.0458506122,
-0.0026792097,
0.0318739936,
-0.0180750322,
-0.0089827301,
0.0421097577,
0.0156643949,
-0.0576018579,
0.0214409232,
-0.0033016715,
-0.0299695581,
0.0295398533,
-0.0484791622,
0.0055310796,
-0.0679300204,
-0.0605435036,
-0.0068808091,
-0.0416325703,
-0.0098944092,
0.0156486984,
0.0021585105,
0.018215131,
0.0435813814,
0.0105170831,
0.008956491,
-0.0141810812,
-0.0310040973,
0.0034650858,
0.0239477269,
0.0028859389,
-0.0268532187,
-0.0039794333,
0.033581309,
0.0203050319,
0.0080684824,
-0.0078592366,
2.212238124e-34,
0.0492297523,
-0.0079286965,
0.015252566,
-0.0006542731,
0.0724094957,
-0.026539268,
0.0001241729,
0.0435392968,
-0.0273118988,
-0.09692882,
-0.0102405604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14012v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14012v1 | Seeing Through AI's Lens: Enhancing Human Skepticism Towards LLM-Generated Fake News | 2024-06-20T06:02:04 | 2024-06-20T06:02:04 | Navid Ayoobi, Sadat Shahriar, Arjun Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLMs offer valuable capabilities, yet they can be utilized by malicious users
to disseminate deceptive information and generate fake news. The growing
prevalence of LLMs poses difficulties in crafting detection approaches that
remain effective across various text domains. Additionally, the absence of
precautionary measures for AI-generated news on online social platforms is
concerning. Therefore, there is an urgent need to improve people's ability to
differentiate between news articles written by humans and those produced by
LLMs. By providing cues in human-written and LLM-generated news, we can help
individuals increase their skepticism towards fake LLM-generated news. This
paper aims to elucidate simple markers that help individuals distinguish
between articles penned by humans and those created by LLMs. To achieve this,
we initially collected a dataset comprising 39k news articles authored by
humans or generated by four distinct LLMs with varying degrees of fake. We then
devise a metric named Entropy-Shift Authorship Signature (ESAS) based on the
information theory and entropy principles. The proposed ESAS ranks terms or
entities, like POS tagging, within news articles based on their relevance in
discerning article authorship. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our metric
by showing the high accuracy attained by a basic method, i.e., TF-IDF combined
with logistic regression classifier, using a small set of terms with the
highest ESAS score. Consequently, we introduce and scrutinize these top
ESAS-ranked terms to aid individuals in strengthening their skepticism towards
LLM-generated fake news. | [
0.084983997,
0.0370111205,
-0.0222162828,
0.017683411,
-0.052810777,
0.0156035107,
0.0295410696,
0.0390989035,
0.0266142264,
-0.0314219408,
-0.0004368324,
-0.0163467769,
0.011212456,
0.0244432241,
0.0246164203,
0.0113106091,
0.0135895219,
0.037104439,
0.0535940491,
-0.0140046105,
0.0141541874,
0.025946172,
0.0003276563,
0.0122840228,
-0.0102078579,
-0.0128571363,
0.0406006388,
0.0351782814,
0.0477868803,
-0.0281275138,
-0.0399285816,
0.0568420179,
-0.03342003,
0.0805083439,
0.0000016476,
-0.0481672585,
-0.025389567,
-0.0082573816,
-0.0294862241,
-0.0183028094,
0.0489498042,
-0.0175001435,
-0.0401045606,
0.0174773913,
-0.0358703472,
-0.0143906539,
0.0088791307,
0.0808567554,
0.0429091752,
0.1293652356,
-0.0237691775,
0.0020151983,
0.0577929616,
0.029770283,
0.0434934087,
0.0160469338,
0.0217370372,
-0.0307162236,
-0.0457081161,
0.0105010988,
0.0436575152,
0.0034685174,
-0.0021460711,
-0.0190570541,
0.0073052226,
0.0344030224,
0.013889214,
-0.0069412622,
0.0305272508,
-0.0227624122,
-0.0070914235,
-0.0681727827,
0.0543271378,
-0.0002826617,
0.0318442173,
0.0428066291,
0.0046324553,
0.0536462367,
-0.0522541031,
0.0039112638,
0.0303702597,
-0.000789769,
0.0256002564,
0.0717701986,
0.03332223,
0.0598236471,
-0.0044967299,
-0.0210285336,
-0.0114154415,
-0.019590009,
0.0179189853,
-0.0621655211,
0.022601828,
0.0279808752,
0.0153505234,
0.0099743595,
-0.0586063974,
-0.0522900447,
0.0305676777,
-0.1031806394,
-0.017681554,
-0.0319147184,
0.0307986252,
0.0470366105,
-0.021616973,
0.0070699197,
0.0129291108,
0.0676256642,
-0.002460348,
0.0087099848,
-0.0086048311,
-0.0012162229,
0.0220667217,
0.0104367109,
0.0813302249,
0.0039342795,
-0.048585806,
0.0140963513,
-0.015040271,
0.0133275306,
-0.0029704308,
0.0116682239,
-0.0026305011,
-0.0261592325,
-0.006313798,
-0.0319933929,
-0.0016094852,
0.0332330167,
-0.0105949137,
-0.0147385681,
0.0130284391,
0.0546172149,
-0.0000968923,
0.0100840069,
0.0203020871,
-0.0180942174,
0.0263081938,
-0.0372236781,
-0.0709378347,
-0.0274127256,
-0.0072325729,
-0.0274149701,
-0.0074626869,
-0.0452289768,
-0.0570168048,
-0.0128281852,
-0.0040861247,
-0.062084116,
-0.0391505733,
0.0155582717,
-0.0212871321,
0.0126565974,
-0.039595928,
0.0139820538,
0.0784551427,
0.0270571876,
-0.0080079138,
0.0198778361,
0.0557726324,
0.1169088781,
0.0756756589,
0.0154162133,
0.0317904949,
0.0037008591,
0.0079131713,
0.0297479834,
0.0174930785,
-0.0218657069,
-0.0541468821,
-0.0079753119,
0.0230782181,
0.0164644551,
0.0055774446,
-0.0247913897,
0.0951955542,
0.0220504254,
0.0030550375,
-0.0087708877,
0.0270657018,
0.0084141884,
0.0170651656,
0.0107028577,
0.0007427026,
0.0119208908,
-0.0744370148,
-0.0401237346,
-0.0051078913,
0.0212937854,
0.0104531329,
-0.0118797924,
-0.0001999838,
-0.0106200483,
0.0142793227,
-0.0116250031,
-0.0071151583,
0.0314741507,
0.0036022568,
-0.0400197096,
-0.0110241184,
-0.0186142642,
0.0295218211,
-0.0740779862,
0.0355150402,
0.0438149124,
0.033779908,
0.0236685406,
0.0407120734,
-0.0240950212,
-0.0141453939,
0.0361174159,
-0.016387986,
-0.0171682592,
-0.083251901,
-0.000765114,
-0.0132183963,
0.0109964553,
0.0093236873,
-0.0023382558,
0.0328326598,
0.054670278,
0.0156437103,
-0.0235386211,
-0.0236608069,
0.0246700589,
-0.0123737743,
-0.0086237304,
0.0077601476,
0.010314961,
0.0306059513,
0.0365170613,
-0.0006131371,
0.0153232133,
0.0361039713,
-0.0024220299,
-0.0640550256,
-0.0165706724,
0.0635538623,
0.0558693707,
-0.0156088294,
-0.0254287645,
-0.0131731415,
0.0215054955,
0.0001998982,
0.0047327625,
0.0144954231,
-0.0222135838,
-0.0044210888,
-0.058732383,
-0.0131977769,
-0.0407396555,
-0.0113001904,
-0.0212802663,
0.0866528526,
-0.0333571807,
0.0334255248,
-0.0225352012,
-0.0360301509,
0.011633574,
0.0258092843,
0.0495231338,
-0.0089008166,
-0.0311923362,
0.0221133679,
0.0286843441,
-0.0158660039,
-0.0099972449,
-0.0426951721,
-0.042840112,
-0.0057812091,
-0.0181540288,
0.0166289341,
0.0242166705,
-0.0421666503,
-0.017874904,
0.0366364531,
-0.0504166856,
-0.0217225738,
0.0008542934,
0.0021562297,
0.0137351975,
-0.0180165768,
-0.0192677863,
0.0226776917,
0.053042423,
-0.0198619198,
0.0444911681,
0.0580642559,
-0.0172597244,
-0.0645888373,
0.0174496509,
-0.0285717882,
-0.0302140061,
-0.0114577049,
-0.0197180156,
-0.0066734673,
-0.0067194919,
-0.0340654068,
0.0402263515,
0.0810959265,
0.051118847,
-0.0080917319,
0.0561278947,
-0.0158245135,
-0.0642507374,
-0.0306681786,
0.0793119445,
-0.0327310637,
-0.0845821425,
0.0599547923,
-0.0233084634,
0.0353236906,
0.0018524794,
0.0045393738,
0.0377525948,
-0.0107445288,
-0.0516231619,
0.0594496466,
-0.0569758341,
-0.0301549304,
0.0060720597,
-0.0134697361,
-0.0652646646,
0.0518367663,
-0.0395402275,
0.0723079517,
-0.0264704823,
-0.0451702364,
0.0031010995,
-0.0049460428,
-0.0070105717,
0.0291699581,
0.0421491154,
-0.0140248286,
-0.0108617321,
0.0161750019,
0.0707169846,
-0.0059099714,
-0.0139320372,
0.0059025194,
0.0117311571,
0.0340440869,
0.0200687628,
-0.0395061523,
-0.0848518759,
0.0079478528,
-0.0355134048,
0.0199550204,
-0.075380519,
-0.0149624189,
-0.0525029786,
0.0573771968,
0.0016520889,
-0.0245258939,
-0.0268742815,
0.0152613651,
0.0231717937,
0.0200686138,
-0.0357710086,
0.0481311232,
-0.0144685339,
-0.0401074216,
0.0480972491,
0.0210379381,
0.0065303445,
-0.0067027737,
-0.0482276641,
0.0078912675,
-0.040405184,
-0.0046508508,
0.0028557198,
-0.0008963436,
0.0180451199,
0.0285855122,
0.1099413559,
0.0302824154,
-0.0267146509,
0.0050149923,
0.0129931057,
-0.0206455104,
0.008021431,
-0.0234356988,
-0.0482317917,
0.0168365967,
0.0007854173,
0.0096344603,
-0.0937288627,
-0.0480450578,
-0.0250536297,
-0.0427036621,
0.0205317233,
-0.0036428336,
-0.0093180416,
0.0122835934,
-0.0865203217,
-0.0324843526,
0.0358180627,
-0.0525003597,
-0.043806728,
0.0115393335,
0.006441236,
0.0037430781,
-0.020956004,
-0.0190540329,
-0.0273063853,
-0.0509533286,
0.0286351535,
0.0467216931,
0.0450361408,
-0.0361836813,
-0.0502917171,
-0.0386993922,
-0.0053027794,
-0.029419288,
-0.0199370589,
0.0776933134,
-0.0571970344,
0.022318922,
-0.0581571981,
0.0496322885,
0.0060018022,
-0.0168537553,
-0.0188623723,
0.03599618,
-0.0199374128,
-0.0688600391,
-0.0095210876,
-0.0243040491,
0.0372405089,
0.0565487966,
0.0118525205,
-0.025174303,
0.005755106,
-0.0208320245,
0.0354176275,
-0.0126112066,
-0.0404679365,
0.0158970468,
-0.0313362703,
-0.1009669453,
-0.0938528031,
-0.0030396748,
-0.0500674285,
0.0242516398,
0.0062560751,
0.013220503,
0.0136620952,
-0.0277576391,
-0.0478683524,
-0.0475085862,
-0.001807182,
0.0496132001,
-0.0287479199,
0.020351572,
0.0047841971,
-0.0099649578,
0.0029845103,
0.0172438771,
-0.0624705888,
-0.0224503484,
0.022476092,
-0.0085656717,
0.0224476475,
-0.0140353702,
-0.0182639398,
-0.0520099364,
0.0781380981,
0.0379494317,
-0.0144497417,
0.0207415614,
0.0203489717,
-0.0281608719,
0.0084111504,
0.0200293697,
-0.0058643557,
0.026308747,
0.0423355326,
-0.0677612871,
-0.0498534516,
-0.0072416984,
0.0094422773,
0.0442219041,
0.0176832471,
-0.0568317957,
0.0123472279,
-0.0013673634,
-0.0229021069,
-0.0011635864,
-0.0183757599,
0.0162942242,
-0.0195973255,
0.0432017744,
-0.0160527118,
-0.0352026485,
0.0792463571,
-0.028005505,
0.0087630339,
-0.0331909135,
0.0049700015,
-0.0300639179,
0.0984040052,
-0.0331230015,
0.0065034917,
0.000504045,
0.0116064856,
0.0063843061,
0.0370910503,
0.0153691862,
-0.0169544742,
0.0192534979,
-0.0289471094,
0.0338475294,
0.0172262583,
-0.0777317584,
-0.0016952102,
-0.0124541186,
0.008476059,
0.0209384803,
0.0430105962,
0.0405638404,
-0.0199634321,
0.0103432434,
0.004113825,
-0.0131332148,
-0.0105986148,
-0.0285725258,
-0.0481854677,
-0.0039297347,
-0.0608042851,
0.0568427779,
0.0772920474,
-0.0034522922,
0.0283018351,
-0.0113974418,
-0.0688506588,
-0.001966232,
-0.0128281303,
0.0072274846,
-0.0048540174,
-0.0099311974,
-0.0165651105,
-0.0715683252,
-0.0241928287,
0.0311464574,
-0.0080216946,
0.046547059,
0.0006257609,
-0.0288517177,
0.0777063519,
-0.000565226,
0.02519661,
-0.065600507,
0.0071069119,
-0.0257894099,
-0.0697676688,
0.0061868955,
-5.958385438e-33,
0.0529427007,
-0.1066626608,
-0.0337253846,
0.0445097871,
0.0125455437,
0.0287746768,
-0.001403983,
-0.0158580039,
-0.0186745524,
0.0356561542,
0.012065284,
0.0366242155,
-0.0038003407,
-0.0046438323,
-0.0338861644,
-0.0068449364,
0.0162998792,
-0.0071157049,
-0.0411583334,
0.0196129605,
0.0616760626,
-0.021564452,
0.0210466292,
-0.0734541938,
0.0660944134,
-0.0209621973,
-0.0834327489,
-0.0097258212,
-0.0127074812,
0.0130929239,
0.0350952335,
0.0120553775,
0.0520767495,
-0.0266538486,
0.0158402249,
0.0369188339,
-0.0064930841,
-0.0461287387,
0.0298043992,
0.0187026188,
0.0073315161,
-0.0542053506,
0.0397908464,
-0.0262797773,
-0.0496870242,
0.0326066501,
0.0353835113,
-0.0021541568,
-0.0195374656,
-0.0763876811,
-0.0269120988,
0.014014177,
-0.000247454,
0.0307044964,
0.0011277794,
0.0269670356,
0.0143010719,
-0.0165803768,
-0.1009142697,
0.0510191061,
-0.0356012173,
-0.0149599435,
0.0141457105,
-0.0239014272,
-0.0355841331,
0.0577695593,
0.0164294615,
0.0232405532,
-0.0152767282,
0.00394024,
0.0130190328,
0.0247742701,
0.0705389529,
0.0887419879,
0.0285598394,
-0.0578563027,
-0.049585361,
0.072923407,
0.0410768427,
-0.0337061025,
-0.0022589348,
-0.0348046906,
-0.0608161688,
0.0106649734,
0.0134287616,
-0.0471115969,
-0.0360789932,
-0.0299902856,
-0.0107124113,
0.0015004281,
-0.0501136892,
-0.0006638386,
-0.0037504397,
-0.060795702,
0.0180887356,
0.0244401991,
-0.0127268778,
0.0464942269,
0.0173752084,
0.0031635438,
-0.0257848781,
-0.00495238,
0.0496622659,
0.0178456269,
0.0486938022,
-0.0180884581,
0.0731268674,
0.0114816176,
-0.0454442129,
-0.0000783017,
0.025541421,
0.0308001619,
0.0200800821,
-0.0276055448,
-0.0115163913,
-0.0132899359,
-0.0078843804,
-0.0303466227,
0.0055649085,
0.0239195097,
-0.0079026222,
0.0241570845,
-0.0407964475,
0.0200122017,
-0.00547934,
-0.0081411609,
-0.0122796874,
-0.0221634135,
0.0268703848,
-0.07247179,
-0.001682409,
-0.0443437733,
2.718e-7,
0.0030152309,
0.0467697568,
-0.0027285391,
0.0224171113,
0.0276504327,
0.0770582259,
0.0531973951,
0.0317761824,
-0.0375635065,
-0.0786386579,
-0.0047407392,
-0.0020520061,
0.0186308324,
0.0301787239,
-0.0469702557,
0.0072919778,
-0.0282472055,
0.027208332,
-0.0556608476,
0.0087258937,
0.0386137553,
-0.0040566484,
0.0512461402,
-0.0560757294,
-0.0085447896,
-0.0453126356,
-0.00057679,
0.0218535624,
0.0066758129,
0.0214940328,
0.0853676125,
-0.0361209363,
0.0377603993,
0.0099260518,
-0.0637124777,
-0.0362407304,
-0.0332188047,
0.0013626298,
0.0108768716,
0.0102890469,
-0.0098168775,
-0.0705540329,
0.0589691438,
-0.055365555,
0.0648557544,
0.048239734,
-0.0447288379,
-0.0393349379,
-0.0376995355,
-0.0315241441,
0.0193951335,
-0.0248183068,
-0.0131562892,
0.0286876708,
0.0030392553,
0.0260089673,
0.0096534537,
-0.029661512,
0.0008145908,
-0.0167355612,
-0.0240513962,
0.0071917088,
-0.0087641291,
-0.0067905579,
0.0541210212,
-0.058641348,
0.0371874608,
2.356457505e-34,
0.0070365574,
0.00568781,
-0.0116882203,
0.0096580032,
0.0393393338,
0.0449086688,
-0.0670452118,
0.0187169686,
0.0020155611,
-0.014024727,
0.0142396456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14005v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14005v2 | Information Guided Regularization for Fine-tuning Language Models | 2024-06-20T05:18:37 | 2024-06-21T12:41:17 | Mandar Sharma, Nikhil Muralidhar, Shengzhe Xu, Raquib Bin Yousuf, Naren Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The pretraining-fine-tuning paradigm has been the de facto strategy for
transfer learning in modern language modeling. With the understanding that task
adaptation in LMs is often a function of parameters shared across tasks, we
argue that a more surgical approach to regularization needs to exist for
smoother transfer learning. Towards this end, we investigate how the
pretraining loss landscape is affected by these task-sensitive parameters
through an information-theoretic lens. We then leverage the findings from our
investigations to devise a novel approach to dropout for improved model
regularization and better downstream generalization. This approach, named
guided dropout, is both task & architecture agnostic and adds no computational
overhead to the fine-tuning process. Through empirical evaluations, we showcase
that our approach to regularization yields consistently better performance,
even in scenarios of data paucity, compared to standardized baselines. | [
0.0199857354,
0.0599230304,
-0.0169205759,
0.0566415787,
-0.0151481312,
0.0341239497,
0.0083441762,
-0.0060303966,
-0.0634362847,
-0.0125470394,
-0.0839188546,
-0.0185611509,
-0.0013398252,
-0.0165256355,
0.0543994009,
-0.0502909534,
0.0428097174,
-0.0369749293,
0.000434709,
-0.0000799241,
0.0158445183,
0.0148760257,
0.017745221,
0.0111494726,
0.0291364789,
0.0211619809,
0.0207456145,
0.0589086376,
0.0132194581,
-0.0054132845,
0.0279101301,
0.0306812543,
0.018577436,
-0.0042879935,
0.0000019525,
-0.0488465428,
-0.007036991,
-0.0259141624,
-0.0394200459,
0.0223053042,
0.0215435419,
-0.0183565412,
0.0073857852,
-0.0026157175,
-0.0045463648,
-0.0389458723,
0.0741933286,
0.0374804437,
0.0264312942,
0.1072754636,
-0.0197520386,
0.0171033293,
0.0124384873,
-0.0559008345,
0.0233161673,
-0.0528278761,
0.0432401821,
-0.0067128576,
-0.0588195622,
-0.0321383663,
-0.0238155276,
0.0301046893,
-0.0300116464,
0.01684843,
0.0012233041,
0.001543839,
0.0098175872,
-0.015060558,
-0.0340287164,
0.0626295581,
-0.036593236,
-0.0108747324,
-0.0008076775,
-0.0314904936,
-0.0012742385,
-0.0178793818,
-0.0591235906,
-0.0327326134,
0.0457889996,
0.0328349099,
0.0298202392,
-0.0318923034,
0.0593671463,
0.0047747847,
-0.0263838042,
0.0137985339,
0.0280530322,
0.001741789,
0.038027592,
0.032976184,
-0.0323337093,
-0.0192339048,
-0.0015369976,
0.0257102232,
-0.0038340886,
-0.0099157616,
-0.0756876692,
-0.0381599814,
-0.014059023,
0.0135236103,
0.0866396651,
0.0147413025,
0.0030954911,
0.041211199,
-0.0033664166,
0.0066871946,
0.0033515615,
0.0822132453,
-0.0453246199,
-0.0001076746,
-0.0357914455,
0.0062540504,
-0.0059990375,
0.0136008468,
0.0259170774,
0.004895865,
0.0076852464,
0.0304583423,
-0.011882918,
-0.0583754964,
0.0181081258,
0.0019792342,
-0.0720128492,
-0.0309910011,
0.0112183709,
0.0476922393,
0.0013420039,
0.0659826472,
0.0173501093,
-0.0641011074,
-0.0409505405,
0.0378244556,
0.0260419399,
-0.0502848886,
0.0281972773,
0.0294947904,
-0.0197251458,
-0.0279353242,
-0.0424738564,
0.0334009491,
-0.0024035694,
-0.0860569105,
0.0181989949,
-0.0192617308,
0.0399729647,
-0.0092134653,
0.0339056775,
-0.0893055722,
-0.0278583989,
-0.0020406712,
-0.0512208045,
0.0575937629,
-0.0449991077,
0.0046257302,
0.0306839459,
-0.0138649344,
-0.0047755861,
0.0790734068,
0.0430088528,
-0.0075045261,
0.0132969022,
-0.0382968672,
-0.0214081388,
0.0660046637,
0.0156634711,
0.0457268544,
-0.0257892404,
-0.0341408774,
0.0149886617,
0.0114796357,
0.0832748562,
0.0656300634,
-0.0195996705,
0.0169402082,
0.0782399625,
0.0293875001,
0.0515042506,
0.0082773743,
0.029340107,
0.0119827986,
-0.0084825559,
0.0301431455,
-0.0443110354,
0.003995114,
0.0058087823,
-0.0288242195,
0.021716971,
0.0280729458,
-0.0368429609,
-0.0091942297,
0.0197176188,
-0.0025492783,
0.0029557613,
0.0154242618,
0.070082441,
0.0358824246,
-0.0102509493,
0.0495358631,
0.0561637618,
-0.0270602293,
0.0317012519,
-0.0359637067,
0.0020546785,
0.0265098196,
0.0218221713,
-0.0277255457,
-0.0254196599,
0.0149137285,
0.0552378371,
0.0138587439,
0.0487015843,
-0.0157907922,
0.074559018,
-0.0554892235,
-0.0165970847,
0.0266031995,
0.0234845988,
-0.005488981,
-0.0394385979,
0.0053935447,
0.042494271,
-0.0364064835,
-0.0379407294,
0.0539527871,
-0.0363730229,
-0.0496020652,
0.0228106417,
-0.004081327,
-0.0130476924,
-0.0305303782,
-0.0151587464,
0.0028636334,
0.0242475141,
-0.0405928642,
0.0442476086,
-0.0410247333,
-0.0553636737,
-0.0099332668,
0.0333289057,
0.0222558156,
0.0631244779,
0.0564513989,
-0.0392044485,
-0.0604396947,
0.0139268562,
-0.0047281473,
0.0439496003,
-0.0031046537,
0.0341772176,
-0.0055568204,
0.0305178799,
-0.0549376421,
-0.0146331023,
0.0146210464,
-0.0268992744,
-0.0207380932,
-0.0345225297,
-0.0277725477,
-0.0437230319,
-0.0305079017,
0.02804216,
-0.0295049679,
0.0098513877,
-0.0069741011,
0.0202847682,
-0.0075486167,
0.0199871603,
-0.0561208278,
0.0217625257,
-0.0253851879,
0.0433270223,
0.0311944857,
0.0311131719,
-0.0072292802,
-0.0165831298,
-0.0056431857,
0.0163079407,
-0.0275379904,
0.0231513064,
0.0141423671,
0.014863777,
0.0030461722,
-0.0709530339,
-0.0358678177,
0.0284364969,
0.0323728882,
-0.0405842364,
-0.0197276194,
-0.0704984367,
0.0300282333,
-0.0253701452,
0.0077240216,
-0.0160197858,
0.0001928282,
-0.0400882028,
-0.0418857448,
0.0048992289,
0.0440936387,
-0.0210142806,
0.0116108144,
0.0382519811,
0.0001864623,
-0.041165065,
0.0184057001,
-0.0031776363,
-0.0185747333,
-0.0635341331,
-0.0138776517,
0.0106536476,
0.0740315914,
-0.0206601396,
0.0052823075,
-0.0320179239,
0.0065630111,
-0.0299117286,
-0.0006691465,
-0.0064371494,
0.0349955037,
-0.0269393809,
0.026291592,
-0.0294705816,
-0.0493959747,
0.0218583066,
-0.0326777361,
0.0099522434,
-0.0093079479,
-0.0194483306,
-0.0203968044,
0.0367742293,
0.0110271461,
-0.0066568688,
0.0427059196,
-0.0095161228,
-0.0682653934,
0.0062233452,
0.0136471465,
0.0053133839,
0.0546340309,
-0.0558107942,
0.0053772642,
-0.0095911846,
-0.0267973151,
0.01424143,
-0.0304051768,
-0.0249048639,
-0.0166065879,
0.0579969846,
-0.0011410713,
-0.023939399,
-0.0028536625,
-0.0029233051,
0.0461963564,
-0.0060209166,
0.0073108054,
-0.0295869801,
0.0427176245,
0.0687788427,
0.0375131816,
-0.0078743733,
-0.0223873369,
0.0012829932,
0.0126992706,
0.0534274727,
0.0115448711,
-0.0151181379,
0.0097462572,
0.0741377473,
0.0070057353,
-0.0356943607,
0.0233006626,
0.0983083993,
-0.0575020015,
-0.0423258431,
0.0801084414,
-0.0307799019,
-0.0971706435,
0.0012035606,
0.0209935755,
0.0648401305,
0.010543881,
0.0171735249,
-0.023843376,
-0.0665634871,
0.0241891276,
0.0136728948,
0.0111794723,
-0.0045450595,
-0.0194360092,
-0.0501505472,
0.0036683674,
0.0340101346,
-0.0261635091,
-0.0210297853,
-0.0450668819,
0.0374705009,
-0.0271142665,
0.0571091399,
-0.0093648378,
-0.0329040512,
-0.0139508136,
0.055801075,
-0.0189540237,
-0.0582334101,
0.0011842246,
-0.0322463028,
0.0548972636,
0.0679580867,
0.0190096926,
-0.0028567926,
-0.0054959948,
0.0544143729,
-0.000306347,
-0.0145336408,
-0.0263267234,
0.0724257231,
-0.0092307422,
-0.0224944316,
0.0403580777,
0.0159040391,
-0.0393186361,
0.0010791091,
0.0122367386,
0.0520938449,
-0.000692462,
-0.0279828757,
0.0339040682,
-0.0367949121,
0.0248203855,
0.0687108636,
0.0380058624,
-0.0698077753,
-0.0120606823,
-0.0289577059,
-0.0151221054,
-0.066264011,
-0.0177594982,
-0.0082361791,
-0.0221482497,
-0.0519115143,
-0.0432270542,
-0.0092377234,
0.0195485316,
0.0377059318,
0.0260419678,
0.002155079,
-0.005234668,
-0.0014564578,
-0.0212394055,
0.0311530177,
-0.0650156811,
0.0083212908,
-0.0563328937,
-0.0345134698,
0.0077862572,
-0.0101312837,
0.0066321068,
0.0224348698,
-0.13369596,
-0.0725212991,
-0.0120971864,
0.0397418402,
0.0095285084,
0.0414829031,
-0.0070697828,
-0.0585003458,
0.025519073,
-0.0048464099,
-0.0173072387,
0.0314843431,
0.0469761863,
-0.0631431863,
-0.0107700881,
0.0529519245,
-0.0494506247,
0.0103085395,
0.0709151402,
0.0291295983,
0.0177393276,
-0.0302897915,
-0.0190331619,
-0.0002510036,
0.0587612018,
0.0011803313,
-0.0579061918,
-0.0239525456,
0.005239191,
0.0097859707,
0.0057166554,
-0.057207644,
-0.0491133481,
0.0303609427,
0.0330209062,
-0.0146030672,
-0.0140278433,
0.0348289162,
0.0311985165,
-0.0811109915,
0.0024748396,
-0.0015008126,
0.0155645357,
0.0361957811,
0.0189069156,
-0.0051507326,
0.0169124044,
0.0186960753,
-0.0025540511,
-0.0374957249,
0.0090590091,
0.0165123548,
0.0432756208,
-0.0402604379,
0.0083567789,
-0.0273297299,
-0.0684996024,
-0.0476220325,
-0.0232436135,
0.0525466315,
-0.0364571065,
0.0929279551,
0.0369225964,
-0.0135543616,
-0.0498846583,
0.0200774595,
-0.0279339496,
0.0099367965,
0.0238424186,
-0.0013342052,
-0.0142676253,
0.0309995152,
0.0906160921,
0.0201743413,
0.0573420525,
-0.0224950556,
0.0045069773,
-0.0296602417,
-0.0096457414,
0.0147208357,
0.0407176428,
-0.0008381385,
-0.021684818,
0.0157704614,
-0.0728575438,
-0.0172570366,
-0.0660369173,
0.024065204,
-0.018509239,
0.0489576571,
0.0425631776,
-0.0348645337,
-0.0036536837,
-0.0096045043,
-0.0508601591,
0.0118374862,
0.0006291483,
-0.0214133654,
-6.787968536e-33,
-0.0312761739,
0.0592241026,
-0.0003571174,
0.0303494632,
-0.020699285,
-0.0151555631,
-0.0431217551,
-0.0108949132,
-0.0427470356,
-0.0015772416,
-0.0104159703,
-0.0100695817,
0.0247218218,
0.0591120422,
-0.0071727778,
-0.0044680317,
0.0509258471,
-0.0182435252,
-0.0158929899,
0.0460351221,
-0.0161747038,
0.0698706955,
0.084223628,
-0.0333178937,
0.0081521636,
0.0216067135,
-0.0102839191,
0.0075261341,
0.0255534668,
0.0077461055,
-0.0375470966,
0.0453047976,
0.0350901,
-0.0483074188,
-0.0443311185,
0.008895346,
-0.0771076158,
-0.0149180386,
0.0146885868,
-0.0033274363,
0.0010681935,
-0.0480257012,
0.0532905199,
0.0160588715,
-0.0029271676,
-0.033945445,
0.025827663,
0.0074341889,
-0.0591117963,
0.0028270432,
-0.0666528121,
0.0169290081,
0.0056741992,
-0.046770446,
0.0169238858,
0.0021629422,
-0.0344223008,
-0.0063692932,
-0.0148291029,
-0.0119661326,
0.0101267528,
0.0774759501,
0.0428102016,
0.0673777983,
-0.0364306644,
0.0305503849,
0.0117913913,
0.00465929,
0.0265726019,
0.0116596958,
0.0530806035,
0.0535550714,
-0.0067495177,
-0.0257858187,
0.0199254919,
-0.0384903476,
-0.0616975389,
-0.0111609502,
-0.0134338839,
0.0297678076,
0.015842136,
0.0690086931,
-0.0064218068,
-0.0453754365,
-0.0251564346,
-0.0389583297,
0.0065069385,
-0.0041669747,
0.0032587331,
0.0024984844,
-0.0230181739,
0.0014632349,
0.0414702073,
-0.0295616519,
-0.0039989594,
-0.0079699354,
-0.0229075812,
0.0217234399,
-0.0036311965,
-0.0260794275,
-0.0692682713,
-0.0608856641,
0.0110468855,
-0.013452624,
0.0232693944,
-0.0192663986,
0.0445138775,
0.0390719213,
-0.0461303703,
-0.0628891662,
-0.0591870546,
0.0034228244,
0.0439851061,
0.102974169,
0.0263785236,
0.0250520688,
-0.0121901967,
0.0545835085,
0.0100534325,
-0.0409266017,
-0.0104959002,
-0.0561854951,
0.0105150184,
0.0011698361,
-0.0339020155,
-0.022724703,
-0.040170487,
-0.0458759628,
0.0299755894,
-0.036526911,
-0.0351858698,
-0.0122859748,
2.689e-7,
0.0364507958,
0.0176968463,
-0.0187243782,
-0.0209693685,
0.0083135618,
0.0191464014,
-0.0198868364,
0.0225139465,
0.0218455512,
0.010861408,
0.0298926271,
0.0522856265,
0.0704121664,
-0.0138121815,
-0.0760092884,
-0.0371440686,
-0.0244964957,
0.0542544834,
-0.0260122307,
-0.0234560631,
-0.0215229839,
0.0881346017,
0.0182188321,
-0.0439871252,
0.0030236463,
-0.0389624909,
0.0318431184,
-0.0847180486,
0.0215326939,
0.0491469875,
0.0668834373,
0.0105257062,
-0.0170212332,
0.0299731568,
-0.0214993916,
0.0209801812,
0.0080116317,
0.066843003,
-0.007228116,
-0.0285621434,
-0.018725507,
0.0373424664,
0.023005249,
-0.0195380282,
0.0823409259,
-0.0509332903,
-0.02168433,
-0.0180239175,
0.004824257,
-0.0058788224,
-0.0054122787,
-0.0226360857,
-0.022092957,
0.0151213976,
0.0463029109,
0.011971157,
-0.0869662389,
-0.0634661466,
-0.0104139978,
0.0570628233,
-0.0753683224,
-0.0348824412,
-0.0482872948,
-0.0520999245,
-0.0042133457,
-0.0588979609,
0.049661234,
2.264673667e-34,
-0.0064047724,
-0.0085532917,
0.012444661,
0.0316942073,
0.0229709484,
-0.0168546475,
-0.0196632948,
0.0264736898,
-0.0123278359,
-0.0826965719,
0.0119743235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13997v1 | "Global is Good, Local is Bad?": Understanding Brand Bias in LLMs | 2024-06-20T04:52:19 | 2024-06-20T04:52:19 | Mahammed Kamruzzaman, Hieu Minh Nguyen, Gene Louis Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | Many recent studies have investigated social biases in LLMs but brand bias
has received little attention. This research examines the biases exhibited by
LLMs towards different brands, a significant concern given the widespread use
of LLMs in affected use cases such as product recommendation and market
analysis. Biased models may perpetuate societal inequalities, unfairly favoring
established global brands while marginalizing local ones. Using a curated
dataset across four brand categories, we probe the behavior of LLMs in this
space. We find a consistent pattern of bias in this space -- both in terms of
disproportionately associating global brands with positive attributes and
disproportionately recommending luxury gifts for individuals in high-income
countries. We also find LLMs are subject to country-of-origin effects which may
boost local brand preference in LLM outputs in specific contexts. | [
0.0059626587,
0.0443139859,
-0.0105510131,
0.0355250873,
0.0287866574,
-0.0140874842,
0.053522259,
-0.0132466741,
0.0586057268,
-0.0196984634,
-0.0521859489,
0.0075393203,
0.0152006391,
-0.0017126066,
0.0261992905,
0.017257506,
0.0129535869,
0.0452515632,
0.044604402,
-0.0363147371,
-0.0103732357,
0.0148820849,
0.0501917563,
0.031295564,
0.0253268741,
-0.0026751398,
0.0872067437,
-0.0006951865,
0.019723149,
-0.0713262782,
0.059962783,
0.0309748575,
0.012659627,
-0.0486857556,
0.000002024,
-0.0605882518,
-0.0138864992,
-0.0327803977,
0.0011113512,
0.0078985859,
0.0345035084,
0.0630286708,
0.038332805,
0.024877429,
-0.0014511304,
-0.0177886393,
-0.0181717444,
-0.0082618026,
-0.0654479116,
0.0008428203,
-0.0032040465,
-0.0215547606,
-0.1137661487,
-0.0109949382,
0.0196796153,
0.0215706117,
0.0410673209,
-0.0388501436,
-0.0462851003,
-0.0200706776,
0.0103563862,
-0.0193601158,
-0.0185789876,
0.067139633,
0.051197581,
0.0053796023,
0.0036362167,
0.004854125,
0.0163879152,
0.0422118083,
0.0586771928,
-0.0052424404,
-0.0173010211,
-0.0113225086,
0.0666498467,
-0.0230410714,
-0.0020631228,
0.0220427811,
0.0033871492,
0.0585147813,
0.002049346,
0.0282933302,
0.0050774403,
0.0486940704,
0.0178622529,
0.090207167,
-0.0196391866,
-0.0027128961,
-0.0005088489,
0.0335848369,
-0.0050625429,
-0.0059518674,
0.0079885535,
-0.0351931155,
0.040723782,
-0.0162292086,
0.0432736911,
0.1231015474,
0.0468897969,
-0.0345128737,
0.0100437663,
0.0056053507,
-0.0403665639,
-0.0113972351,
0.0032994589,
-0.0186616424,
-0.0125383604,
0.0036016111,
-0.0436772518,
0.0297796205,
0.0042344984,
0.0241548121,
0.0973211974,
0.0051670671,
-0.0357152559,
0.059372656,
-0.0508629829,
-0.0211289469,
0.0002222623,
0.0193112176,
-0.025006149,
0.0245114174,
0.0475399345,
0.0013525324,
-0.0892015249,
0.0392147452,
-0.1151665524,
0.0424858779,
-0.036146868,
-0.0170938615,
0.0362891667,
0.0200701524,
-0.0191565473,
-0.025072854,
0.0296556484,
0.0445109792,
0.0007247014,
-0.0211744625,
-0.0702494979,
0.013513498,
0.0206061732,
-0.0206352659,
0.0327965096,
-0.0174926501,
-0.0058255582,
0.0385078341,
0.0308225509,
-0.0195373725,
-0.0018820803,
-0.0001511021,
-0.0285362564,
-0.0096214283,
0.0608518869,
0.0092202816,
0.0345687196,
0.0214638505,
0.0008388079,
0.011419395,
-0.0239105057,
0.0144340564,
0.0408632867,
0.0162664577,
-0.0246470738,
0.0359562449,
-0.0511570983,
0.0024510543,
-0.054502748,
0.0211442299,
-0.0087890057,
-0.0290059559,
0.0453303829,
-0.0086096758,
-0.0458052009,
0.0713040978,
0.1222791076,
-0.0175783876,
-0.0184554327,
0.0263875108,
-0.0692657307,
-0.0092460224,
-0.0550267324,
-0.0373851545,
-0.0261939131,
-0.0070191282,
0.0303123966,
0.0023369496,
0.0006315762,
0.0036919736,
-0.053874258,
-0.0148176672,
0.0214486402,
0.009997935,
0.0201464109,
0.0234285276,
-0.0148410527,
-0.0425593667,
-0.0034725077,
0.0070789331,
-0.0208615139,
-0.008879533,
-0.0260959212,
0.0060098721,
0.0915667191,
0.0626842305,
-0.044543542,
0.0247684531,
0.0527404919,
-0.0016301076,
-0.0468395054,
0.0327037051,
0.0032451944,
0.0305460952,
-0.0247814972,
-0.004025511,
-0.0327671804,
-0.026252443,
0.0014551097,
0.0239955354,
0.0126725379,
0.0553919673,
-0.0240164511,
-0.056445647,
0.0473800749,
-0.0290346853,
0.0638801977,
-0.0081342682,
-0.032878194,
0.0039478126,
-0.002006283,
0.0144948969,
0.0131347114,
-0.0026114052,
-0.0233133677,
-0.0538037047,
-0.0145972818,
0.0376519933,
0.0060383561,
0.0364474207,
-0.0296423119,
-0.0639343113,
-0.0404649749,
-0.017549254,
0.0335734636,
0.0377350785,
-0.0099556157,
0.0914009884,
0.043278683,
0.0154484995,
-0.054994937,
-0.0211688336,
0.0180490837,
-0.003273153,
0.0253355987,
-0.0200068876,
-0.0206809063,
-0.0484173186,
-0.0037330007,
-0.0187268592,
0.0178453904,
0.0311169904,
-0.0238429438,
0.0044586179,
-0.016951004,
-0.0012898244,
0.0052801701,
-0.0247764904,
-0.013301637,
-0.0503884144,
0.0119645922,
0.0551960133,
0.0010522936,
-0.0300621726,
-0.0019919998,
-0.0376706757,
0.0120263845,
-0.0490757599,
-0.0335184,
-0.0041086869,
0.0345822982,
0.0269271284,
-0.0101842303,
-0.0020231167,
-0.0212098621,
-0.0186665971,
0.0140856365,
0.0344146043,
-0.0070976103,
-0.0233419333,
-0.0470470972,
-0.0722454935,
-0.0699962676,
-0.0349023007,
0.0057818331,
0.0147688817,
-0.0327256024,
0.0524725467,
0.0380940251,
0.0333903022,
0.010474408,
-0.0231458228,
0.0660059974,
-0.0131389732,
-0.0599605143,
-0.0504971817,
0.0307457466,
0.0043261326,
0.0019198032,
-0.0534629859,
-0.0412937999,
0.061449375,
-0.0084737912,
0.0194221232,
0.0460348725,
0.0424424373,
-0.0121135926,
-0.0479711667,
-0.0161437243,
-0.002783048,
-0.0307321567,
0.092999503,
0.0138475802,
-0.0861361846,
-0.0292683542,
0.0212388001,
0.0424324684,
0.0560851283,
0.0021043473,
-0.0116325682,
-0.0548201837,
-0.0374556705,
-0.0108112507,
-0.0286850054,
-0.022029344,
-0.0405060463,
-0.0238519423,
0.0045714667,
-0.0170694515,
0.0226346925,
0.0168517996,
-0.0106610237,
-0.0440559089,
-0.0445835404,
-0.0041212337,
-0.0361567363,
-0.0278026927,
-0.0317651331,
0.0338721611,
0.0214273669,
-0.0094797788,
-0.0331754982,
-0.014414669,
-0.0582914017,
0.007963107,
0.017588228,
0.0177282263,
-0.0226745512,
-0.0083134025,
-0.0008094277,
0.0179274231,
-0.0182016622,
-0.0174684264,
-0.0143620744,
-0.003665491,
-0.0268301498,
-0.0023893781,
0.0359830223,
0.0398098752,
0.031697154,
0.0071757208,
0.0079666721,
0.0383640677,
0.0398136713,
0.0705139562,
0.0475425236,
-0.045926284,
-0.0610143393,
-0.0041432106,
0.0314801186,
0.0185891129,
0.0368149504,
-0.011851524,
-0.0859255269,
0.0247141086,
0.0524738878,
0.0055387043,
-0.0684868991,
0.026724549,
-0.0271419808,
-0.0737430453,
0.004393063,
0.0272856075,
0.0409997031,
0.0245145634,
0.0486665443,
-0.013771263,
0.0043462543,
0.0408215001,
0.0122283595,
-0.0145982606,
0.0268100128,
-0.0114917802,
-0.0386141725,
0.0028969455,
0.0083726663,
-0.0357442275,
-0.0081760269,
-0.003861153,
-0.0141005069,
0.0052331774,
-0.0308369454,
0.0416085385,
0.0189051349,
-0.0039809369,
0.0014732021,
0.0055093388,
-0.0652439222,
-0.0234399457,
-0.0284665376,
0.000110988,
-0.0235631689,
0.0115500912,
-0.0007964282,
-0.0305373892,
0.0549819097,
-0.0433781818,
0.0095829135,
-0.0355030894,
-0.0556307435,
0.0438568704,
-0.0062358137,
-0.0237525906,
0.0453612767,
-0.0606505685,
-0.0554513261,
0.0730941296,
-0.0428519174,
0.0671771988,
-0.0423935279,
-0.0235735625,
0.0264959969,
-0.0361130387,
-0.0150753781,
-0.0206280276,
-0.00284397,
-0.0203915369,
-0.0556279048,
0.0013283931,
0.0266586803,
0.0382156558,
-0.0466999486,
0.0176195316,
0.0293661151,
0.0164837912,
0.0243075453,
-0.0409048796,
-0.0079826862,
0.0104601383,
0.0003573279,
-0.0019005287,
0.0080405911,
0.0359002464,
0.0146807712,
0.0418328941,
0.010904857,
0.0037592871,
0.0163520798,
0.0436096936,
0.0249773413,
0.0376003459,
0.0148606431,
0.0524049848,
0.0195691939,
-0.0247610807,
-0.027465336,
0.0147572886,
0.0647840053,
0.0114692179,
0.0166089572,
-0.007705261,
0.0342286304,
-0.0369341299,
0.0718656108,
-0.0179729965,
0.0772436559,
-0.0105017386,
-0.0072752228,
0.0313914679,
-0.0298510175,
0.0066276533,
-0.0425234735,
0.0444079973,
0.0373493247,
-0.0445979275,
-0.0331719778,
-0.0240640454,
0.0281544495,
-0.0526689403,
0.0520595983,
-0.0244536307,
0.0214054007,
-0.0199613851,
0.0145009942,
-0.0084916716,
0.0227210037,
0.0060994951,
-0.0034000652,
-0.0078277318,
0.0288975276,
0.0262403674,
0.0396789722,
-0.0367834643,
0.0310865287,
0.032147605,
-0.0616715699,
0.0239692889,
-0.0000649562,
0.0054845996,
-0.1032413319,
0.0106989108,
0.0480487086,
-0.0190611016,
-0.016058635,
0.0129491128,
-0.0550192185,
-0.0302418824,
0.0035003114,
-0.0020954348,
-0.038329415,
0.0047345678,
0.0422834866,
0.005945208,
-0.0324775279,
-0.0235846154,
-0.036874231,
-0.0276034623,
-0.0197249409,
0.0435411558,
-0.0619058423,
-0.0430411883,
-0.0339772217,
-0.0688879117,
-0.0820016637,
-0.0007463996,
-0.0483028777,
-0.0029579622,
-0.0051666261,
-0.0387874432,
0.0462037772,
-0.0192326047,
-0.0464714803,
0.0188223571,
-0.0154919391,
-0.0382614918,
-0.0128875282,
0.0277874116,
-5.777119434e-33,
0.0248705037,
-0.0070493761,
-0.0259926077,
-0.0217914805,
-0.0272676442,
0.0054896665,
0.0296166725,
0.0390048623,
0.0278181583,
-0.0096908594,
-0.0184472669,
-0.03525538,
0.0271450859,
-0.0512565747,
0.0650477037,
-0.0781934187,
0.0027709391,
0.0207539257,
-0.0044170083,
-0.0211710557,
-0.0149425361,
0.0316640809,
0.0503687263,
-0.040189188,
0.0674476624,
-0.0341200233,
0.011311464,
-0.0281490963,
0.0513329133,
-0.0003419991,
-0.0286677778,
0.0346755572,
0.0366222635,
-0.0257696416,
-0.0034811746,
0.0374483131,
-0.010971128,
0.0172946583,
0.0329752229,
-0.0240223929,
0.035373386,
-0.025052242,
-0.0331483781,
0.0567198358,
-0.0631458536,
0.0640838891,
0.0344344974,
-0.0309584457,
0.0207599178,
-0.0113294069,
0.0254391581,
-0.0274009183,
-0.0365921631,
0.0946495309,
-0.0073929955,
0.0295785405,
-0.0064330818,
0.1271190196,
0.0411720425,
0.0208022259,
-0.0695591196,
-0.017586058,
-0.0132746398,
-0.0143208848,
0.0017301444,
0.0463761054,
0.0202015433,
0.0577386469,
-0.0046225381,
-0.0185829811,
-0.0139942179,
0.011229435,
-0.0313609838,
0.0874679312,
-0.0052449526,
-0.0152080543,
0.0192430094,
-0.0253307391,
0.0534876585,
-0.0254392251,
-0.005373891,
0.0486003086,
0.0076332027,
-0.0314859003,
0.023252029,
-0.087404795,
-0.0368627198,
0.014549681,
0.0357286818,
0.0045579053,
-0.0031884937,
-0.0138007179,
0.0506129526,
-0.012915873,
-0.045151405,
-0.082021378,
0.0306818821,
-0.0679622963,
0.044866439,
-0.0535321832,
-0.0344768018,
0.0180661045,
-0.0763477087,
0.0035418198,
-0.0272537544,
-0.0019730374,
-0.0108299823,
-0.0409636535,
-0.0419148915,
-0.0181479435,
0.0103737386,
-0.062066447,
0.0090200519,
-0.060795702,
0.0487304516,
-0.0186480694,
0.0361617655,
-0.0222111717,
0.0081651667,
0.0273280479,
-0.0066291727,
-0.0177632142,
-0.0457894057,
0.0455057807,
-0.0276062097,
-0.0191579144,
-0.0115536666,
0.0104093384,
0.0684100538,
-0.0417365991,
-0.0320508853,
-0.0787615925,
2.652e-7,
-0.0150382528,
0.0588657707,
-0.0464934632,
-0.0076806978,
0.0146368584,
0.0436171517,
-0.0069540171,
0.0469380915,
0.066200912,
-0.0520565696,
0.0236546993,
-0.0190520771,
-0.0136685362,
0.0064938501,
-0.0353276283,
0.0616198704,
-0.0209544189,
0.0103504863,
0.00117445,
0.0155777913,
-0.0636250004,
-0.020272702,
0.0128621673,
0.0254232418,
-0.0305132102,
-0.0536995791,
0.0479826517,
-0.1395876259,
-0.0014647095,
-0.0176780056,
-0.0105320113,
-0.0119015248,
-0.0126645584,
-0.0111211259,
0.0236639455,
0.0191607587,
0.028369762,
0.0012973796,
0.0673493296,
-0.0358677879,
-0.0371298417,
0.0170484111,
-0.0020016332,
-0.065596059,
0.0114207212,
0.0157418437,
0.004124091,
-0.0384348482,
-0.0125324167,
0.0070707565,
0.0400485992,
-0.0093958285,
0.0249108505,
0.001991038,
0.012608896,
0.0253318418,
0.0289527252,
-0.0182272755,
-0.0204243753,
-0.0403657667,
-0.0127274999,
-0.0162875317,
-0.0028154117,
0.0985659957,
-0.0296302401,
0.0062041343,
0.007793868,
1.88658624e-34,
0.0094739553,
-0.0389696136,
0.0333589166,
0.021033112,
0.0377763622,
0.017485572,
-0.0640823543,
-0.0273562465,
-0.0091423094,
-0.0175869484,
0.0094179614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13993v1 | Exploring Changes in Nation Perception with Nationality-Assigned Personas in LLMs | 2024-06-20T04:44:20 | 2024-06-20T04:44:20 | Mahammed Kamruzzaman, Gene Louis Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Persona assignment has become a common strategy for customizing LLM use to
particular tasks and contexts. In this study, we explore how perceptions of
different nations change when LLMs are assigned specific nationality personas.
We assign 193 different nationality personas (e.g., an American person) to four
LLMs and examine how the LLM perceptions of countries change. We find that all
LLM-persona combinations tend to favor Western European nations, though
nation-personas push LLM behaviors to focus more on and view more favorably the
nation-persona's own region. Eastern European, Latin American, and African
nations are viewed more negatively by different nationality personas. Our study
provides insight into how biases and stereotypes are realized within LLMs when
adopting different national personas. In line with the "Blueprint for an AI
Bill of Rights", our findings underscore the critical need for developing
mechanisms to ensure LLMs uphold fairness and not over-generalize at a global
scale. | [
0.0301204231,
0.0558229275,
-0.0466836952,
-0.0134619214,
-0.0157016292,
0.0173498429,
0.0917183608,
-0.0300092269,
0.0459673591,
-0.0061333906,
-0.0242502447,
-0.0472273901,
0.0230879318,
-0.0300932527,
0.0648255795,
-0.0373122767,
0.0415829644,
0.0312874988,
0.0177925229,
-0.0093019009,
-0.0210161638,
0.027618181,
0.006649653,
0.0375984907,
-0.0284551401,
0.0037470474,
0.0353022516,
0.0068160109,
0.0567950085,
-0.0186759382,
0.0133741638,
-0.0013628596,
0.041036725,
-0.0566891097,
0.0000018028,
-0.0444114134,
0.0123579307,
-0.0015496496,
0.0048557515,
0.0009547839,
0.0212858804,
0.0240336098,
-0.0092619201,
0.0224065017,
-0.0361853391,
-0.0010179452,
-0.016995633,
-0.0142661091,
0.0097979186,
0.0324148759,
0.0206681862,
0.0413352586,
-0.0756926984,
-0.0056486414,
-0.0162149351,
0.0091055175,
0.0072889947,
-0.0563487411,
-0.0604339615,
-0.0314447209,
0.0281779915,
-0.0050188643,
-0.0129603511,
0.0408026576,
-0.0085778413,
0.0057747434,
-0.0101787159,
0.0025001243,
0.0211290456,
0.0482787788,
0.121920757,
0.0283285007,
-0.0058880863,
0.0239972286,
0.0456497557,
0.0097315656,
0.0250149034,
0.07070636,
-0.0126074925,
-0.0075994274,
-0.0107116885,
0.0134487683,
-0.0143103432,
0.0078904852,
-0.0567698143,
0.0850463063,
-0.0262331292,
-0.0115276538,
-0.0267448351,
-0.0047878101,
0.0433598384,
-0.0438703187,
0.0069216872,
0.038891945,
-0.0319724604,
0.0030013202,
0.0078128474,
0.0343083329,
0.0169375837,
-0.0392509289,
0.0054893722,
0.0381363258,
-0.0266551115,
0.0025087101,
0.0075369524,
0.055597309,
0.0164165553,
0.0151205808,
-0.0063597979,
-0.0400941074,
-0.004505456,
0.0094127133,
0.0484203026,
0.0202887673,
0.0498488285,
0.0611770712,
-0.0602109805,
0.003155936,
-0.0669099689,
0.0657769293,
-0.037325006,
-0.0168513022,
-0.0067676497,
-0.0133795626,
-0.0871260688,
0.0294432584,
-0.0650008991,
0.0276676193,
-0.0577159524,
-0.0377638228,
0.0290106721,
-0.0039317557,
-0.0292781871,
-0.0132449968,
0.0065565878,
0.0619553924,
0.0359916054,
-0.0351377316,
-0.0162377339,
-0.0004388983,
0.0507194586,
-0.0529210158,
0.0063840165,
-0.0334591717,
0.0113232518,
-0.0064904592,
0.0144943325,
-0.0529896617,
0.0098145856,
0.0067668362,
-0.0143610314,
0.0475181974,
0.0143477218,
0.0440190844,
0.0275116451,
0.0301665775,
-0.0313623585,
0.0393032394,
-0.0144432969,
0.0297612343,
0.0473115705,
-0.0048067323,
0.0458504148,
0.0469239391,
-0.0787329003,
0.0377337188,
0.0083264839,
0.0155918822,
-0.0135056758,
-0.0194030516,
0.0784103423,
-0.0044328752,
-0.0130578792,
0.0195197668,
0.0567412153,
0.0831132606,
-0.0174347032,
0.0297468081,
-0.0102858646,
0.008593712,
-0.0153729673,
0.0041192351,
-0.0597451851,
0.0141467461,
0.0027617963,
-0.0467065051,
-0.0354058444,
0.0984831378,
-0.0463504978,
-0.0046652239,
0.0136475265,
-0.0034449312,
0.0350062922,
0.018092487,
-0.0172883589,
-0.0157488175,
0.0277826171,
0.0466297083,
0.002781153,
-0.0597671233,
-0.0241116397,
-0.0325099081,
-0.0276252124,
0.0548677146,
-0.0386933982,
0.0100141764,
-0.0142614627,
-0.0483489186,
-0.0187369157,
0.0772471055,
0.0689283237,
0.0031212629,
-0.0234730113,
0.014887766,
-0.016863199,
-0.0061462699,
-0.0172254741,
0.0943009481,
0.0353883654,
0.0580970272,
0.0058059632,
-0.0238021519,
0.0100289825,
0.0058587361,
-0.0184246115,
-0.0185735729,
-0.0183277708,
0.039074935,
0.0028559002,
0.0358232372,
-0.0126638031,
-0.0169146769,
-0.0122610424,
-0.0203654319,
0.0066597774,
0.0392576829,
-0.0296425633,
0.0710861012,
0.0333824456,
-0.0616453476,
-0.0460169129,
-0.0146901216,
0.0166954231,
0.0036714487,
0.0203811731,
0.0371483676,
-0.0009802077,
0.0141510246,
-0.0076046009,
-0.0433472432,
-0.0023275954,
-0.0005272742,
-0.0085678408,
-0.032120198,
-0.0304268319,
0.0362874493,
-0.0055421628,
0.0237631053,
-0.0049240356,
-0.0306741484,
0.0215987377,
-0.0049896087,
-0.0012595272,
0.0238852836,
-0.0136331813,
-0.0171567611,
0.032757096,
-0.0796276778,
0.0013643706,
0.0001560716,
-0.0172079653,
0.0240261257,
-0.0098321121,
-0.031375967,
0.0256011002,
-0.0955594704,
-0.0438407511,
-0.0050499872,
0.0268469006,
0.0280976724,
0.0009216156,
-0.0091575654,
-0.0044372822,
0.0218210276,
-0.0193558242,
-0.0207711142,
-0.0324341208,
-0.0292247366,
-0.0554376915,
-0.0048709097,
-0.0582151785,
0.0071636373,
-0.0404576696,
-0.0564036481,
0.0356043093,
0.0537600927,
0.0099510942,
0.0207231995,
0.031336084,
0.0462314561,
0.0809399635,
0.0234358311,
-0.0093785068,
-0.0342519432,
0.0384374224,
0.0322498679,
-0.0056462917,
-0.1003506333,
0.0025727744,
0.0105341868,
0.0014695664,
0.0206557699,
0.015162752,
0.0487312451,
-0.056704849,
-0.0551674925,
0.0253860913,
-0.0135559356,
-0.0249200203,
0.0742344931,
0.0299753137,
-0.0121516259,
0.0096650999,
0.00421286,
0.0424194187,
0.05671487,
-0.0279108044,
-0.0291032791,
0.0232335329,
-0.0180373788,
0.0153614199,
-0.0070147123,
-0.0322103985,
-0.0649596602,
-0.0418193825,
0.0215917304,
-0.0518160723,
0.0516821183,
-0.0159977768,
-0.0399005786,
-0.0449524559,
-0.0150244627,
-0.0359431021,
0.0261398591,
0.0013164239,
0.0029333511,
0.0101223746,
-0.0355891064,
0.0003550878,
-0.0092223976,
0.094764784,
-0.0090191541,
-0.0082678152,
0.0230242573,
0.0033254856,
-0.0786704272,
-0.0387132801,
0.0600276329,
0.0628109872,
-0.0293215495,
-0.0180878099,
-0.0167289618,
-0.0212986749,
-0.0232212506,
0.0199129004,
-0.0173241515,
0.0470970608,
-0.0086928448,
-0.0166923497,
-0.003712177,
0.0618900955,
-0.0109794354,
0.0486143082,
0.0534340963,
-0.0325477086,
-0.0770831704,
-0.024081951,
-0.0068105194,
-0.0360535905,
0.048520755,
0.0208648928,
-0.0677257404,
0.0608337931,
0.0076023582,
0.0089914147,
-0.1117366031,
-0.0400230549,
-0.0370108373,
-0.1071942821,
0.0310982727,
0.0163250677,
-0.0014409104,
-0.012264071,
0.0297395531,
0.0156142469,
0.0194136631,
0.0510106273,
-0.0187769178,
-0.0136596682,
-0.014300297,
-0.0068918536,
-0.107296817,
-0.0121457586,
-0.0118824486,
-0.0737630054,
0.0197688676,
0.0140139237,
0.0427578092,
0.0213490762,
-0.0547031015,
-0.0242628697,
0.0264117848,
0.0335938744,
0.0136681553,
0.0019712106,
-0.0296697356,
-0.0170734189,
-0.024913216,
-0.062977545,
0.025567269,
0.0197035819,
0.024475161,
0.0004281088,
-0.0418389104,
0.0080267424,
0.0055087754,
-0.0469047762,
-0.0025926617,
0.0395092256,
0.0002407996,
-0.0377961434,
0.0281656571,
-0.0346574299,
0.0332126059,
-0.0254314635,
-0.0606647581,
0.0469206832,
-0.0334583335,
-0.045750238,
-0.0020843747,
-0.083562009,
-0.0028392635,
0.0178248324,
0.0418340452,
-0.0216830205,
-0.000959047,
0.0064333887,
0.0037330748,
0.001963302,
-0.0629398078,
0.0431073643,
0.0290503111,
-0.0600544922,
0.0065605957,
-0.011347835,
0.038265001,
-0.0015308626,
0.0341285244,
0.0041443906,
0.0261591561,
0.0357552692,
0.0263911467,
0.0469224341,
0.0516286977,
-0.0013856454,
0.0469336547,
-0.0004954144,
0.021885328,
0.0441166759,
0.0041113021,
0.0733436495,
-0.0297139715,
-0.0110151954,
-0.0063593248,
-0.009229715,
0.0354090668,
-0.0579021536,
-0.0544821955,
-0.0641587004,
0.0144195361,
0.025703067,
0.0225025211,
-0.0342880338,
0.0446617343,
-0.0050749988,
-0.0438662134,
-0.0349295139,
-0.0073419604,
0.0243029147,
-0.0545417927,
0.015021855,
-0.0015441553,
0.04299853,
0.0246766694,
-0.0414001122,
-0.0049922992,
-0.0427509472,
0.0879753232,
-0.007375862,
0.0458701327,
0.0044978457,
0.0036495873,
-0.0023588433,
0.0421846956,
0.0215879269,
0.012791831,
0.0137512852,
0.0245304368,
-0.0038334862,
0.0071623046,
-0.0251740012,
0.0478466526,
-0.0178158935,
-0.0932847708,
0.0233107861,
0.0133197987,
0.0402165726,
-0.0004442087,
0.0053931153,
0.0350802168,
0.0123173585,
0.0265191626,
-0.0193259157,
-0.0120817246,
-0.0030958264,
0.0407206975,
-0.0169698037,
-0.0161003787,
0.0018066327,
0.0210051145,
-0.0478304029,
0.0082741613,
-0.0291824825,
-0.0386899263,
-0.0162413996,
-0.0358448327,
0.0413363166,
-0.0470851585,
-0.018516751,
-0.0649937019,
-0.099569574,
-0.0352936722,
-0.004942257,
-0.0105244936,
-0.008587651,
-0.0373793803,
-0.0169036631,
0.0266351588,
0.0118422881,
-0.01614636,
-0.0461801849,
-0.0232072901,
-0.0531398058,
-0.0082771052,
0.0470757559,
-5.413653275e-33,
-0.0226055179,
-0.0349102654,
0.0362472311,
-0.0170531329,
-0.0523718372,
-0.0353225581,
-0.0066012479,
0.0355900042,
-0.0178958923,
-0.0238644965,
-0.0349761471,
-0.0207590833,
0.0045948057,
-0.062011797,
-0.0029883552,
0.014228615,
0.032382451,
0.0261932593,
-0.0170680434,
-0.0002825424,
-0.0171364062,
-0.0019623246,
0.0739445016,
-0.0714167058,
0.0508337989,
0.0095173754,
-0.0451110601,
-0.0244620405,
0.0346545987,
-0.0088789873,
-0.008729063,
0.0229817312,
0.0330731906,
-0.0281080566,
-0.0147083309,
0.0640237257,
-0.0127033712,
-0.0323034413,
0.0141380355,
0.0181432981,
0.0542529337,
-0.0714694411,
-0.027470544,
-0.0150240492,
-0.0624440089,
0.0541594848,
0.0470638126,
0.0076716682,
0.0545386896,
0.029429106,
-0.0169534795,
-0.026393475,
-0.0140997553,
0.0700816363,
-0.0298456624,
0.0358158536,
-0.0130495615,
0.0254824366,
-0.08160422,
0.0350461304,
-0.0153043,
-0.0355611145,
0.0529255047,
0.0315310881,
0.0141529981,
0.0535702482,
0.0580712929,
0.0788283572,
-0.0603057332,
-0.0727069527,
0.0247120615,
-0.0186354183,
-0.0051180874,
0.099129349,
-0.0457944237,
-0.0643793344,
-0.0081273261,
0.0241383091,
0.0783229172,
0.041043289,
0.010728674,
0.006075094,
-0.0016315519,
-0.0235878006,
-0.0004816767,
-0.0626673922,
0.0004065286,
-0.039161399,
0.0250075832,
-0.0203481801,
0.0172169283,
-0.0163644403,
0.0503414646,
-0.0264507812,
-0.0104043903,
-0.0202512965,
-0.0152478777,
-0.0284995902,
0.0228345077,
-0.0492163673,
-0.0324593149,
-0.0087774163,
-0.0483984798,
0.0064287717,
0.0464579165,
0.0388738066,
-0.0261362158,
-0.0234837066,
-0.062093541,
-0.0114860227,
-0.0196022261,
0.014362107,
0.0200930368,
0.0059252111,
0.0092658019,
-0.0204460863,
0.0041013118,
-0.0388939418,
0.0216680337,
-0.030245658,
-0.0532157011,
-0.0035256662,
-0.0768880323,
0.0487880819,
-0.0451421179,
-0.0213963278,
-0.0312018134,
0.0946708694,
0.0763173476,
-0.0256407447,
-0.0366301164,
-0.0868289173,
2.436e-7,
-0.023852868,
0.0335552022,
-0.0308879241,
0.0469081998,
0.0377497002,
0.0538133197,
-0.0225476287,
0.0365161821,
0.0303711705,
-0.0426291414,
0.0114811761,
-0.0083742822,
0.0095568895,
0.0530796126,
-0.0807531253,
0.0505043417,
0.0362832472,
0.0256898645,
-0.0120519036,
0.0740288049,
0.0309986509,
-0.0120361168,
-0.0040991683,
-0.0200489052,
-0.0475164577,
-0.010362274,
0.0004275913,
-0.0785920471,
-0.020716846,
-0.0112415319,
0.0282231346,
0.0213672165,
0.0106315678,
0.040521916,
0.018519057,
0.0012764916,
-0.0160023365,
0.0365385115,
0.0054634549,
0.0085546887,
0.0112589551,
0.0060503879,
0.0204556566,
-0.0257402193,
0.01586744,
0.0056708204,
-0.0223516263,
-0.0371948183,
-0.0138386404,
-0.0113864336,
0.0329949334,
0.0064882035,
-0.008548039,
0.0199595541,
0.0216617417,
0.0075621717,
-0.0068249092,
-0.0275000446,
0.0120803313,
-0.0332067497,
0.0134706534,
-0.0557747222,
-0.0131750647,
0.0307680964,
-0.0123904804,
0.0142830191,
0.0086041465,
1.975110148e-34,
-0.051454246,
0.0117477765,
0.0179913826,
0.0272778776,
0.0513416529,
0.0310446545,
-0.0311923213,
-0.0195469055,
-0.0001308534,
-0.0026508055,
0.0140717505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13990v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13990v2 | Inference-Time Decontamination: Reusing Leaked Benchmarks for Large Language Model Evaluation | 2024-06-20T04:35:59 | 2024-06-23T16:46:00 | Qin Zhu, Qingyuan Cheng, Runyu Peng, Xiaonan Li, Tengxiao Liu, Ru Peng, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The training process of large language models (LLMs) often involves varying
degrees of test data contamination. Although current LLMs are achieving
increasingly better performance on various benchmarks, their performance in
practical applications does not always match their benchmark results. Leakage
of benchmarks can prevent the accurate assessment of LLMs' true performance.
However, constructing new benchmarks is costly, labor-intensive and still
carries the risk of leakage. Therefore, in this paper, we ask the question, Can
we reuse these leaked benchmarks for LLM evaluation? We propose Inference-Time
Decontamination (ITD) to address this issue by detecting and rewriting leaked
samples without altering their difficulties. ITD can mitigate performance
inflation caused by memorizing leaked benchmarks. Our proof-of-concept
experiments demonstrate that ITD reduces inflated accuracy by 22.9% on GSM8K
and 19.0% on MMLU. On MMLU, using Inference-time Decontamination can lead to a
decrease in the results of Phi3 and Mistral by 6.7% and 3.6% respectively. We
hope that ITD can provide more truthful evaluation results for large language
models. | [
-0.0093377139,
0.1039707437,
-0.0127575705,
0.0634287894,
-0.0578519292,
-0.004747001,
0.0083205802,
0.0087388922,
-0.0022944806,
-0.0287266299,
-0.0669483989,
-0.0361820869,
0.0423769653,
-0.0227768552,
0.0318643264,
-0.0035839907,
0.0665609315,
-0.0376049019,
-0.0361950062,
-0.0106106922,
-0.0277864244,
-0.0042797038,
0.0176756233,
0.0162505172,
0.0081687784,
-0.027436953,
0.0022970999,
-0.0009030167,
0.0044017131,
-0.0352992937,
0.0003958881,
0.0295583885,
-0.0085209496,
0.0798378363,
0.0000020493,
-0.0278888438,
-0.0144986408,
0.0442039706,
-0.0363291427,
0.1062636226,
0.0326739922,
0.0057926639,
-0.0166030228,
0.0503696948,
-0.0130280862,
-0.0039258813,
0.0116621125,
-0.0275944117,
0.0408042744,
0.0882203281,
0.0028631571,
0.0181404091,
0.0090931263,
-0.0382985659,
-0.0371133722,
-0.064094767,
0.0323533602,
-0.0236475226,
-0.0284092091,
-0.0255294479,
-0.0077063208,
0.0305184033,
0.0168414265,
0.0331758931,
-0.0411820486,
0.0328639597,
-0.0468913764,
0.0063460739,
-0.0076272469,
0.0246787835,
-0.0504674539,
-0.0343687311,
0.0150012271,
-0.0164083224,
-0.0362228416,
-0.0234426111,
-0.0187470652,
0.0114178695,
-0.0126255397,
0.0274427291,
0.0369968042,
-0.0092567923,
0.0714909509,
-0.0241418146,
-0.0189750269,
0.0696007684,
0.0562752075,
-0.0220876038,
0.0062825349,
-0.0073591662,
-0.0070678857,
-0.0594883896,
-0.0097965878,
-0.0055730287,
-0.0114245731,
0.0283417646,
-0.0435050949,
-0.0521280169,
0.0268250611,
-0.0507290289,
0.0587848648,
0.0496604145,
0.0033082517,
0.0301756002,
-0.0289711207,
0.0617143847,
-0.0088040838,
0.028603619,
-0.0423087217,
0.0053834938,
0.0077948775,
0.0115320645,
0.0057534464,
0.0067311879,
0.002251846,
0.0046809874,
-0.0398495831,
0.0159267206,
-0.0063213729,
0.0128818024,
0.0184427928,
-0.0234177224,
-0.0440561697,
0.0078456607,
-0.0159364156,
0.0088928025,
0.0018336759,
0.0173800644,
-0.0225518979,
-0.1149248108,
-0.0355349667,
0.0035343585,
-0.0230528116,
-0.0376686975,
0.0173255764,
0.0655680522,
-0.0014610763,
-0.0646871701,
-0.0319160447,
-0.008281514,
0.0014082298,
-0.0849685818,
0.0271715224,
-0.0434077084,
0.0149269132,
-0.0068073329,
-0.0009354525,
-0.0344394781,
-0.012451008,
0.0249292254,
-0.0376866721,
0.0418375656,
-0.017185824,
0.0080127502,
-0.0198249705,
0.0005414571,
-0.0344904289,
0.0927112997,
0.0182799231,
0.0177805834,
0.0356410034,
-0.0418448523,
-0.0073224385,
0.0741609484,
0.0392807275,
0.0150765339,
-0.0386075117,
-0.0061050975,
0.0124820033,
0.0052717244,
0.036038626,
0.0843895152,
-0.0150152706,
-0.0256143268,
0.0609273612,
0.0274566598,
-0.0128062433,
-0.0156703945,
0.0046646614,
-0.0204816442,
0.0407677591,
0.0337997191,
-0.0722801909,
-0.0508038066,
-0.0158175975,
0.0291189291,
0.0331285708,
0.0591533221,
-0.0207068324,
-0.0247079749,
-0.0400053151,
-0.0198025443,
0.0019905174,
0.0241140649,
0.0611097179,
0.0095497891,
-0.0485174134,
0.0781856328,
0.0272666682,
-0.0311121847,
-0.0085130008,
-0.0683070421,
0.0124451984,
0.0430334881,
0.0466698818,
-0.0018418231,
-0.0106299864,
0.0165978726,
-0.0140874423,
-0.01277701,
0.028136434,
0.0012348121,
0.0589082688,
-0.034699183,
-0.0139645124,
-0.0077406624,
0.0334364623,
0.0198670533,
0.0465520918,
0.0067747021,
0.0297016297,
-0.0764708892,
-0.0207943581,
0.0578125939,
-0.0424737297,
-0.0125178974,
0.0171985999,
-0.0194907989,
0.0383136682,
-0.0005315693,
-0.0240260456,
0.0124666197,
0.0494255833,
0.0045258915,
0.0258697495,
0.0080747278,
-0.0370212384,
-0.0277416538,
0.0254224706,
-0.0020751546,
-0.0099902414,
0.0854821131,
-0.0470433198,
-0.0345355794,
0.0204844829,
0.0154853649,
0.0675728545,
-0.0232463125,
0.0650747344,
-0.0295949988,
0.0397344157,
0.0080449991,
0.0474774949,
-0.0311314147,
0.0174435787,
0.0141696623,
0.0446283855,
0.0041104578,
-0.0211331919,
-0.0334080793,
0.0185257886,
0.0012717294,
0.0117576793,
-0.0137080271,
-0.0219775904,
-0.0326817557,
0.0022619939,
-0.0733433515,
0.0287776496,
-0.0290392134,
0.0563618802,
0.0142936511,
0.0031665158,
-0.0079816757,
-0.0166241601,
0.0025623159,
-0.0163191818,
0.0090103559,
0.0363381356,
-0.0158673972,
-0.0177603289,
-0.0148872714,
-0.0293174274,
-0.0184548497,
-0.0077240448,
0.0871539786,
-0.050585974,
0.0036435665,
-0.0514070801,
0.0407952741,
-0.0126288803,
0.0240435321,
-0.0220197365,
-0.0276229084,
0.0147468839,
0.0017791101,
0.0168737508,
0.0640017912,
-0.0002286774,
0.0115971426,
0.058647804,
0.0060729538,
-0.0555792004,
-0.0159122758,
0.0155717107,
-0.0409679785,
-0.0210745614,
-0.0336907655,
-0.0050241733,
0.0924099907,
-0.0192355216,
-0.0269497968,
0.001164107,
0.0067294883,
-0.0256174728,
-0.0267248489,
0.0046837237,
-0.0102925729,
-0.0438605323,
0.0048411726,
-0.0169032663,
-0.085556142,
0.0336012095,
-0.0486541949,
0.0102184955,
-0.023226954,
-0.0110573787,
-0.0240430906,
0.0366205461,
-0.0119675994,
0.0014692708,
0.0220874008,
-0.026937874,
0.0007904063,
-0.0042436277,
0.0187894683,
-0.0487095416,
0.0136999171,
-0.0481193997,
0.0223190635,
-0.023533605,
-0.0500652939,
-0.0390282087,
-0.0332171544,
-0.0287540369,
0.0109888772,
0.0200399458,
0.001604419,
-0.0211833511,
-0.0077394922,
-0.0374496318,
0.0320224725,
0.003637017,
0.0155907487,
-0.0067240158,
0.0125145158,
0.0152126728,
-0.0415748022,
0.005860501,
-0.0354741514,
0.0035200256,
0.0657576844,
0.0718658119,
0.041992031,
-0.0626112297,
-0.0238195602,
0.0195743497,
-0.0034067393,
-0.0079332963,
0.023484312,
0.0178318694,
-0.0625767708,
-0.0185119752,
0.0921569169,
0.0143829277,
-0.0073903846,
0.0234421268,
0.0307216458,
0.0465078354,
0.0061139083,
-0.0064106402,
-0.0982235819,
-0.0160677209,
0.0446468145,
0.0192925371,
-0.0124140074,
-0.0180480648,
-0.0182139669,
-0.1444265395,
-0.0083111739,
0.0198459122,
-0.0441576391,
0.0334369838,
-0.075834401,
-0.001946213,
-0.0357458517,
0.0638382658,
0.0078597898,
0.0123731717,
-0.0076315519,
0.0355397239,
-0.0250124149,
-0.1354380101,
0.0230181869,
-0.0219945181,
0.0566380806,
-0.0045911567,
0.0118556479,
-0.0196122751,
-0.042371016,
0.0441603586,
-0.0052785901,
-0.010693796,
0.0026601593,
0.0400809422,
0.0098577421,
-0.0224031098,
0.0356229991,
0.0009803412,
0.0024289088,
0.0124837123,
-0.0195975415,
0.0370211117,
0.0109228268,
-0.0400393158,
0.0096643567,
-0.0514236018,
-0.0072015557,
0.0753195062,
-0.0070419968,
-0.0213387702,
-0.0018546252,
-0.0009361354,
-0.0027279009,
-0.0077213161,
0.0121642984,
0.0412140526,
-0.0295180939,
-0.0394329429,
-0.0303699486,
-0.0193802416,
0.006081908,
0.0388977304,
0.0048630624,
0.035548117,
-0.0189623125,
0.0028271349,
-0.0497229435,
0.0471854769,
-0.0305857379,
0.0528061576,
-0.0469110943,
0.0150257479,
-0.0028080428,
0.0597351342,
-0.0220606886,
0.061809577,
-0.1470290273,
-0.1026750132,
-0.0066139381,
0.0541501418,
0.0269520245,
0.0449263118,
0.0028963774,
-0.0470397398,
0.0193682406,
0.0150293522,
-0.0214389861,
0.0395034254,
0.0316549763,
-0.0741407275,
0.0098644812,
0.0282432493,
-0.0280882698,
0.0015915735,
0.0531886816,
0.0131944316,
-0.0041668843,
-0.0044132546,
0.002145255,
0.0371891223,
0.053907793,
-0.0398693159,
0.0181445871,
-0.0013077881,
0.0384991132,
-0.041602131,
-0.0023585786,
-0.0165180396,
0.0148892282,
0.0272488315,
0.0247808136,
-0.0284506865,
-0.0036856253,
0.0224609468,
0.0133762788,
-0.0228091795,
-0.0320971534,
0.0455269255,
0.0101321749,
0.0516769588,
-0.001368419,
-0.0180421062,
0.0038834761,
0.0166891385,
0.0438546091,
-0.0330056958,
0.0094693797,
0.010015822,
0.0266008675,
-0.0186130125,
0.0213529412,
-0.0368187316,
-0.0394331254,
-0.0281573273,
0.0364585929,
0.0534268767,
0.0084885256,
0.0366950668,
-0.009717403,
-0.0078272186,
-0.0364241451,
-0.0120914448,
-0.0352910198,
-0.0173774976,
0.014248156,
-0.0117718615,
-0.0362256579,
0.0690571666,
0.075608775,
0.0311672576,
0.056473732,
-0.0077286311,
-0.0047371546,
-0.0225746427,
-0.0211648922,
-0.0023070348,
0.0132436138,
-0.019504495,
-0.0691291317,
-0.0477374233,
-0.1068272442,
0.0117416577,
0.0159991439,
0.0311390832,
0.008148551,
0.0130454851,
0.0663747117,
0.0032259971,
-0.0235105623,
-0.0381194316,
-0.0083494633,
0.0020952795,
-0.0298457146,
-0.0120511167,
-6.532682754e-33,
0.0136038484,
0.0197294243,
0.0046228189,
-0.0559132025,
-0.0127635114,
0.047242377,
-0.0217082985,
-0.0249208454,
-0.0106855053,
-0.011644775,
-0.0522828288,
0.0096539231,
0.0262047872,
0.0113128284,
-0.0328495353,
0.0120764701,
0.066174604,
-0.0024586453,
-0.0607713237,
0.0093551939,
0.0255710389,
0.0410572328,
0.0729457363,
-0.0282219574,
-0.0232698526,
-0.0126932934,
-0.0229285229,
0.0110796504,
-0.023285294,
0.0539529026,
-0.0310105011,
0.027715249,
0.0137366597,
-0.0213376656,
-0.029335985,
-0.0302224495,
-0.0580459945,
0.0112084579,
0.0297551937,
0.0217029266,
-0.0401646271,
-0.0016281334,
0.0536558256,
0.0016789082,
-0.028757263,
-0.0121809477,
-0.0291148648,
-0.0053846668,
-0.0574081875,
-0.0072963042,
-0.0083834706,
0.0349898152,
0.0123513574,
0.0193811022,
0.0374106467,
-0.0101062739,
-0.0076324521,
0.0094224503,
-0.0424992256,
-0.0098411031,
0.0466060936,
0.0472235791,
0.0828625336,
0.0418263786,
0.0069224308,
0.0688961968,
0.0287292395,
0.034316849,
0.0598074272,
-0.008125281,
0.0789593756,
0.0100602778,
0.0264656469,
0.0266550407,
0.0846633911,
-0.0553469025,
-0.0606790893,
0.0155625297,
0.0266053528,
0.00132684,
0.0308952183,
0.0288231671,
-0.0371929556,
-0.0335394405,
-0.0624329112,
0.0087911058,
-0.0439269468,
-0.012303398,
0.0306052994,
0.0263027996,
-0.0257919021,
0.0227357801,
0.0313730538,
-0.0301853754,
-0.0237339456,
0.0007051015,
0.0009297718,
0.0105871977,
-0.0321091488,
0.05251633,
-0.0516153276,
-0.0207012761,
0.0049649118,
0.0235835519,
0.0394304805,
-0.018003067,
0.0063461144,
0.0402811654,
-0.0625260472,
0.0084743844,
-0.0562980138,
0.0100810844,
0.0147792464,
0.0104042767,
0.0665017441,
-0.0016932043,
0.0157631449,
0.0152144805,
0.028555708,
0.0286682509,
-0.0518890284,
0.0026843457,
0.0311559346,
0.0366442502,
0.004245474,
-0.0131689934,
-0.0192255173,
0.0222377852,
0.0611816756,
-0.0603467487,
-0.0194305591,
0.0104012555,
2.727e-7,
0.0175093934,
0.0111691561,
-0.0006726445,
0.0228713304,
0.0157487523,
0.009978787,
-0.0455590673,
0.0219862219,
0.0022743563,
0.0040909341,
-0.0191344582,
-0.0037533308,
0.0703875571,
0.0338731371,
-0.0790953934,
-0.0054320623,
-0.0775441974,
-0.0185351186,
-0.0751450062,
-0.0445763208,
-0.0403421372,
0.0952123478,
0.0262160376,
-0.0377087258,
-0.0062740226,
-0.040629331,
0.0423649512,
-0.0211337116,
-0.0400515608,
0.022051353,
0.0588198043,
0.0630996004,
0.0065267351,
0.007311115,
-0.0240770839,
0.014113686,
-0.0069471495,
0.0369838439,
-0.0068746312,
-0.0175050125,
-0.0180807151,
-0.0515643135,
-0.0367196575,
-0.0261822604,
0.0738923326,
-0.000771965,
-0.0280048139,
-0.0759586617,
-0.0261530038,
-0.0373236425,
0.0343742855,
0.0101142358,
-0.0101784011,
0.0415648893,
0.0016320697,
0.0012366986,
-0.0441313088,
-0.0665773451,
-0.0279786009,
-0.0020956777,
-0.0469310135,
-0.0781928599,
-0.0091102244,
0.0310460106,
-0.0059154369,
-0.0641089305,
0.0203930382,
2.680297934e-34,
0.0374777094,
-0.0555919893,
0.0027496216,
0.0544158258,
0.0392887741,
-0.0133734131,
0.0080526806,
0.0133199431,
-0.023657497,
-0.0666328892,
-0.0091435984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13975v1 | MR-BEN: A Comprehensive Meta-Reasoning Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T03:50:23 | 2024-06-20T03:50:23 | Zhongshen Zeng, Yinhong Liu, Yingjia Wan, Jingyao Li, Pengguang Chen, Jianbo Dai, Yuxuan Yao, Rongwu Xu, Zehan Qi, Wanru Zhao, Linling Shen, Jianqiao Lu, Haochen Tan, Yukang Chen, Hao Zhang, Zhan Shi, Bailin Wang, Zhijiang Guo, Jiaya Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown increasing capability in
problem-solving and decision-making, largely based on the step-by-step
chain-of-thought reasoning processes. However, it has been increasingly
challenging to evaluate the reasoning capability of LLMs. Concretely, existing
outcome-based benchmarks begin to saturate and become less sufficient to
monitor the progress. To this end, we present a process-based benchmark MR-BEN
that demands a meta reasoning skill, where LMs are asked to locate and analyse
potential errors in automatically generated reasoning steps. MR-BEN is a
comprehensive benchmark comprising 5,975 questions collected from human
experts, covering various subjects such as physics, chemistry, logic, coding,
and more. Through our designed metrics for assessing meta-reasoning on this
benchmark, we identify interesting limitations and weaknesses of current LLMs
(open-source and closed-source models). For example, open-source models are
seemingly comparable to GPT-4 on outcome-based benchmarks, but they lag far
behind on our benchmark, revealing the underlying reasoning capability gap
between them. Our dataset and codes are available on
https://randolph-zeng.github.io/Mr-Ben.github.io/. | [
0.0083618453,
0.0181372687,
0.0056952494,
0.0261710882,
-0.0409492962,
0.0244905595,
0.0026816446,
-0.0190399792,
-0.0207112078,
-0.014314414,
-0.0120190289,
0.0303279832,
-0.0078440849,
0.0311783385,
0.0046397005,
-0.0309727453,
0.0338741243,
-0.0832684934,
0.0119271455,
-0.0152844219,
-0.0342747271,
0.0007481143,
-0.0374143049,
0.0238426737,
0.0303362831,
-0.032259807,
-0.0002944094,
-0.0113346428,
0.0428316891,
-0.0416539349,
-0.0209583044,
0.0653124899,
-0.0064982581,
0.0503429137,
0.0000022254,
-0.0552268364,
0.0224596038,
-0.000624878,
-0.0411979817,
-0.0047322456,
-0.0155020179,
0.0217459165,
-0.0149780028,
0.0655003488,
-0.0165701006,
-0.0192560609,
0.0183112975,
0.00192886,
0.0652721152,
0.0401821695,
0.0161637161,
-0.0173723344,
0.0021708347,
-0.0190909728,
0.0296362471,
-0.0381038934,
0.0049738572,
0.0402584597,
0.0195466727,
-0.0010684321,
-0.0090224165,
0.0256554559,
0.045728866,
-0.0033283834,
-0.0494533554,
0.0407873429,
-0.042353984,
-0.0025850679,
0.0111920452,
0.0740407705,
0.0165739469,
-0.0174633544,
-0.0247755963,
0.0012986275,
-0.0061664297,
0.0240032393,
-0.0495785326,
0.0515937954,
-0.033875417,
-0.0092324354,
-0.0205901489,
-0.0041733738,
0.0412162878,
0.004018649,
-0.0320430435,
0.1182250902,
0.0017410344,
-0.0233414154,
0.0448530801,
-0.0133193396,
-0.0169487391,
-0.0606816486,
0.0016321965,
0.0210191384,
-0.0234175082,
0.0248737317,
0.0156514607,
0.0169293564,
0.0236601215,
-0.0190577153,
0.0420524068,
0.0567758232,
0.0150170801,
0.0651898012,
-0.0193701107,
0.0427387357,
-0.0166797787,
0.0276938062,
-0.0250518974,
-0.0074583348,
-0.0777164102,
-0.0177000389,
0.0040942989,
0.0173374899,
-0.007796505,
0.0276780166,
-0.0539493412,
0.006047932,
-0.017945895,
0.0428416915,
0.0289732255,
-0.0090568271,
0.0180115718,
-0.0593725964,
-0.0837750658,
0.0148635153,
-0.0529349446,
0.0169722363,
0.0470481887,
-0.0165448133,
-0.0005734442,
-0.0170595516,
-0.0422983505,
-0.0495632812,
0.0344427601,
0.0544992983,
0.0093587451,
0.0005606615,
-0.0371259712,
-0.0189293269,
-0.0047211368,
-0.0931240991,
0.0312389769,
-0.0853724331,
0.0204618517,
0.0298890471,
-0.0204149652,
0.0007244894,
0.0080001326,
0.0159244798,
-0.0190413315,
0.053210631,
-0.0157865044,
0.0127244294,
0.0124678258,
0.0426122509,
-0.0321920142,
0.0485605672,
0.0336837769,
0.0116238268,
-0.0028036206,
-0.0062022447,
0.0059413956,
-0.0035682281,
0.0073683015,
-0.0100574121,
-0.0113846157,
0.0241629966,
-0.0162908901,
0.0309721921,
-0.0127603998,
0.0428623259,
-0.0303816982,
-0.0055708964,
0.0311363135,
0.0499922447,
-0.0219463147,
-0.0005433435,
0.0435662642,
-0.0373465829,
0.0366718657,
-0.0349686705,
-0.0719912201,
0.0693534464,
-0.0453944355,
-0.0032223328,
0.0089971423,
0.0288728941,
-0.0294925682,
-0.0510557704,
-0.0107641518,
0.0253011491,
-0.043301452,
0.0156809259,
0.0451580882,
-0.0158382729,
-0.0095118918,
0.0396161564,
0.0016386219,
-0.0410016216,
-0.0168288276,
-0.0560955703,
0.0188027825,
0.0522081107,
0.0637671426,
-0.0493330024,
-0.0637098253,
-0.0145791983,
0.022187585,
0.0346371755,
0.0371676013,
-0.001558268,
-0.0039319098,
-0.0400947109,
-0.0058218213,
-0.0210367367,
0.0079979105,
0.0108713731,
0.0090385443,
-0.0032462776,
0.0125240013,
-0.0586437322,
0.0185991358,
0.0121070109,
-0.0802576244,
-0.0021312058,
-0.0455423817,
-0.0147722149,
0.0132821808,
-0.011296886,
-0.0032240727,
0.0315171964,
0.0066161603,
-0.015065331,
-0.0268526915,
0.04792713,
-0.0059972606,
-0.0327097327,
0.0529032461,
-0.0683827922,
-0.0578625426,
0.0205957256,
-0.0646721274,
-0.0457955822,
0.0290226899,
0.0294616725,
-0.0052764136,
-0.0265849531,
0.0341465659,
-0.0123530794,
-0.0213037282,
-0.0135199372,
0.0876013935,
-0.0389463566,
0.0332603827,
0.0289878137,
-0.003983363,
0.0287833493,
-0.0202447437,
-0.00195681,
0.0451282673,
-0.021378357,
0.0055937888,
-0.0001780201,
0.0096717393,
-0.0828604922,
-0.0222679023,
-0.066858843,
0.0133546172,
-0.0022522688,
0.0256243832,
0.0232764054,
-0.0214843079,
-0.0051085749,
0.017838072,
-0.0053352723,
0.0034571958,
0.0259868708,
0.0151983453,
0.0316742137,
0.0022355006,
0.0094525618,
-0.0340733565,
-0.0136374282,
-0.0443562828,
0.0378546193,
-0.0142587591,
0.0808471143,
-0.0073267245,
-0.0050040805,
-0.0379450172,
0.0002926284,
-0.0174891669,
-0.023963578,
0.0374828056,
-0.0351866446,
0.0316290781,
0.0587021858,
-0.0021628265,
-0.0048258137,
0.06059964,
-0.0109168515,
-0.0435684659,
0.0336793475,
0.0067386092,
0.001068522,
-0.0256056264,
-0.0424392037,
-0.0264666453,
0.0593238622,
-0.0237966999,
0.0112112323,
-0.0463652648,
0.0481381565,
-0.0104129585,
-0.0246763304,
-0.0269591324,
0.0209494922,
0.0021419863,
0.0800504014,
-0.0431043021,
-0.0233864486,
0.071611762,
-0.0051495139,
0.0041012974,
-0.0345416106,
0.0305405147,
-0.0164236315,
0.0906141549,
-0.0205048956,
0.0026187564,
-0.0322478116,
0.0003172441,
-0.0637109354,
-0.0454075858,
0.0496780165,
-0.0281673111,
0.0285355076,
-0.0825330243,
0.0021056561,
-0.0020993385,
-0.0544756092,
-0.0411501639,
0.0187733509,
-0.0645626336,
-0.0000796588,
-0.0349613726,
-0.0167448744,
-0.0323928483,
-0.016369557,
0.02399946,
0.0084856423,
0.0121054575,
-0.0430230089,
-0.0082928017,
-0.0062987609,
0.0307940617,
-0.0107035032,
0.0594814941,
-0.0370586663,
0.0740602463,
0.0601757802,
0.0386998355,
0.0046633906,
-0.0435858667,
0.0190677345,
-0.002469671,
0.0004749165,
0.0055945129,
0.0404845811,
0.0300536286,
-0.0506266579,
-0.0140748005,
0.1284166127,
0.0567099229,
-0.0035462787,
-0.0130630191,
-0.0554250516,
0.0333263576,
0.0354528464,
0.0325507969,
-0.0332691967,
-0.0580531396,
0.0476455055,
0.0059955758,
0.0101112602,
-0.0499111451,
0.0048465612,
-0.0974742249,
0.0374492519,
-0.0098751066,
-0.0102868415,
-0.0459086075,
-0.0356915481,
0.0084482282,
-0.0016830367,
-0.0269991383,
0.0529619902,
0.0030195483,
0.0027868559,
0.0108984923,
-0.01423686,
-0.0577106923,
0.0820159763,
-0.0094215171,
0.0433935225,
0.0548222885,
0.0152260968,
-0.0014427353,
-0.022215208,
0.082354933,
-0.0061544129,
-0.0057204682,
-0.0109248003,
0.0516868904,
0.0286157615,
0.0150262229,
-0.0422450043,
0.0335270017,
-0.0629934818,
-0.0524252541,
0.0255823731,
0.1280236095,
-0.0082945349,
-0.0471032634,
-0.0282927863,
0.0152014,
-0.0448652618,
0.0731105953,
0.0027293283,
-0.0083607137,
-0.0678881928,
-0.0535486415,
-0.0409650877,
-0.0208795164,
-0.0117409034,
0.0435102247,
0.058579959,
0.0071290499,
-0.0274159927,
-0.0313209109,
0.0489006341,
0.0271992851,
-0.0166641027,
-0.0171122346,
0.01717446,
0.0112440782,
-0.0371117033,
0.0303487871,
-0.0378281809,
0.0250327829,
-0.0804913938,
0.0364965796,
0.017326571,
-0.0438349023,
-0.0284336098,
0.0289773513,
-0.073365286,
-0.0492333993,
-0.0358551592,
0.0610850267,
0.0339475498,
0.0015595197,
-0.0227324441,
-0.0569997132,
0.0038103121,
0.002770476,
-0.013825004,
-0.0099993898,
0.05226513,
-0.0083678504,
-0.0098896613,
0.0173401926,
-0.0220240299,
0.0182295796,
0.0028658067,
0.0414698422,
-0.0072523351,
-0.007402516,
0.0348049589,
0.0254034046,
0.0314160548,
0.0109248552,
-0.007978024,
-0.0368152447,
0.0161748137,
-0.0118342666,
-0.0316248015,
-0.0236447901,
0.0170684606,
0.047724098,
-0.0401013345,
0.0162764248,
-0.0131354704,
-0.0096258847,
-0.0017038387,
0.0435690209,
0.0331583619,
-0.0035985413,
0.0775094926,
0.05786933,
-0.0402940772,
-0.0044054021,
-0.0287836194,
0.005221759,
0.0563517995,
-0.0258513112,
0.077788569,
0.0456126221,
-0.0038724947,
-0.0136289708,
-0.0005342862,
-0.0857384354,
-0.0624399371,
0.0470308252,
0.0156860221,
0.0514898784,
0.0304743946,
0.0081991674,
-0.057626389,
-0.0129451165,
-0.0218981896,
0.0210189614,
0.0317249186,
-0.0027643379,
0.0295686778,
0.0445870236,
-0.0100218775,
-0.0373628624,
0.0628460124,
-0.0213328209,
0.029717952,
0.0165281929,
-0.0149905588,
-0.0327948034,
-0.0719080046,
-0.0872247443,
0.0119143771,
-0.0058635809,
0.0341431983,
-0.1066734493,
-0.0917042643,
-0.019285759,
0.0601042062,
0.0070056557,
0.0003067556,
0.0131906969,
0.0687635019,
0.0033198721,
-0.0142504144,
-0.0050726631,
0.0150073422,
-0.0483805351,
-0.0096777687,
-0.0125646628,
-6.367162864e-33,
-0.0285894107,
-0.0286309104,
0.0716236681,
-0.0181437787,
0.0102201998,
-0.0492725894,
-0.0670824125,
0.0197030213,
-0.0349398963,
0.0495397449,
-0.0227930956,
0.0283419024,
-0.0057180505,
-0.0051352689,
0.0164161958,
-0.0221578982,
0.021773614,
0.0227407105,
-0.0461804941,
0.0111757256,
0.0423886999,
-0.0078850091,
0.0131812748,
-0.0040772581,
-0.0234119836,
0.0182692483,
-0.0106849903,
0.0435201675,
-0.0814181194,
0.0418593772,
0.0045691244,
0.0039326628,
0.0289929975,
-0.018494023,
0.0095958561,
-0.0405776203,
-0.0674585551,
-0.041289676,
0.016799856,
-0.0371380188,
-0.0473981313,
-0.0153762074,
-0.0060097128,
0.0426071323,
-0.0207471363,
-0.0541702062,
0.0158653669,
-0.0423023403,
-0.0047224076,
0.0297147706,
-0.0282056332,
0.0301181264,
-0.0551778674,
-0.0084620705,
0.0062780115,
0.0559131913,
-0.0116361501,
0.0172802974,
-0.0232340842,
0.0247036684,
0.0084725581,
-0.001775309,
0.0909987986,
0.012953666,
-0.007260548,
0.0531706028,
0.0305648316,
0.0215007365,
0.0061584865,
0.0355859771,
-0.0051734117,
0.0781985074,
0.0563260615,
0.0434785448,
0.0238080043,
0.0131155653,
-0.0768135116,
0.0271955896,
-0.0122165252,
0.065133214,
0.0313587636,
-0.0083158966,
-0.0251688045,
-0.0123945326,
-0.0909653232,
0.0106116384,
-0.0538027994,
0.0006683139,
0.046678815,
-0.0124195907,
-0.0135426708,
-0.0543945655,
0.041603338,
-0.0165479369,
0.0190779157,
0.0476359613,
-0.0331118293,
0.0199519768,
-0.0024844946,
0.0614148192,
-0.0348870084,
-0.018971052,
-0.0049265758,
0.0152918082,
0.0234017652,
0.0049099601,
0.0229640305,
-0.0007658157,
-0.0310390722,
0.0054287096,
-0.0819883645,
0.0226622168,
-0.0012971873,
-0.0113349948,
0.0075504859,
0.0146189034,
-0.0033979984,
0.015757883,
-0.0099808192,
-0.0119035365,
-0.0230365004,
0.0344531238,
-0.0056464104,
0.0063028131,
0.0055041118,
0.0083004516,
-0.063580811,
0.0057203816,
0.0654172078,
-0.0435224809,
-0.0086496826,
0.0283175148,
2.864e-7,
0.0325614363,
0.0527773052,
0.0053296075,
0.039802745,
0.0333573446,
0.0469819754,
-0.0573978014,
-0.0449556224,
0.0618588887,
-0.0119701372,
-0.0018231251,
0.0580149367,
0.0573151521,
0.0619953983,
-0.0157400649,
0.0042291982,
-0.0402989127,
-0.030755356,
-0.0378935374,
-0.0147599559,
0.0276322756,
0.0318987407,
0.0194579437,
-0.0174764432,
0.0296551958,
-0.028441865,
0.0516387559,
-0.0399549976,
0.0250900034,
0.0235730708,
-0.0200835057,
0.0144932205,
0.0115476698,
0.0282121226,
0.0021583729,
-0.0307902861,
-0.0210701171,
0.0685813427,
0.0160016026,
-0.0195158869,
-0.0164517108,
-0.0300442968,
0.0274843387,
-0.0337305516,
0.0755707696,
-0.0555672459,
-0.0473659374,
-0.0038616399,
-0.0203217063,
-0.0247253422,
0.0072024381,
-0.0059521445,
-0.0114238197,
-0.0127764605,
-0.0258995593,
-0.0132840965,
-0.0084409388,
-0.0717052221,
-0.0453145355,
0.0164599251,
-0.0327802375,
-0.0675400645,
-0.0405464433,
-0.0001605221,
0.0412968546,
-0.0507603288,
-0.0058905263,
2.786100231e-34,
0.0358655676,
-0.0037116762,
0.0259173531,
-0.0341526978,
0.0460174717,
-0.0040227687,
-0.0402034149,
0.0033215324,
0.010972131,
-0.0735416859,
-0.0134075554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13960v1 | Evolving to be Your Soulmate: Personalized Dialogue Agents with Dynamically Adapted Personas | 2024-06-20T03:02:38 | 2024-06-20T03:02:38 | Yi Cheng, Wenge Liu, Kaishuai Xu, Wenjun Hou, Yi Ouyang, Chak Tou Leong, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Previous research on persona-based dialogue agents typically preset the
agent's persona before deployment, which remains static thereafter. In this
paper, we take a step further and explore a new paradigm called Self-evolving
Personalized Dialogue Agents (SPDA), where the agent continuously evolves
during the conversation to better align with the user's anticipation by
dynamically adapting its persona. This paradigm could enable better
personalization for each user, but also introduce unique challenges, which
mainly lie in the process of persona adaptation. Two key issues include how to
achieve persona alignment with the user and how to ensure smooth transition in
the adaptation process. To address them, we propose a novel framework that
refines the persona at hierarchical levels to progressively align better with
the user in a controllable way. Experiments show that integrating the personas
adapted by our framework consistently enhances personalization and overall
dialogue performance across various base systems. | [
0.0647109374,
0.0144342408,
-0.0476292297,
-0.0044808816,
0.0182759594,
-0.0102555389,
0.0267632436,
-0.0334046111,
0.0102041764,
0.0083055878,
-0.0314022787,
-0.0003664711,
-0.0229747314,
0.0712215528,
-0.018802397,
-0.1137131676,
0.0494350493,
-0.0257044286,
0.0184084643,
0.0029734715,
0.0200226922,
0.0061620902,
-0.0242637619,
0.0248803627,
-0.0115164695,
-0.0596303567,
-0.0478348695,
0.0047231992,
0.0355280153,
-0.0018349179,
0.0154941548,
0.0161011685,
0.0170781482,
0.0142300241,
0.0000017545,
-0.0719179139,
0.0024686714,
-0.023873968,
-0.0265148189,
-0.0239583738,
0.0530476682,
0.0845323429,
-0.0183726214,
0.037420623,
-0.0477122478,
-0.0008664416,
0.027198825,
0.0310368557,
0.0875344053,
0.0342315547,
-0.0168498531,
-0.0181041565,
-0.0106713083,
0.0165093411,
-0.0155750653,
-0.0673379526,
-0.0300226621,
-0.0505406,
-0.0073161628,
-0.0177348908,
-0.0031214138,
-0.0035312802,
-0.0225154255,
-0.0085051451,
0.0147694498,
0.01707137,
-0.0052500814,
-0.0340896286,
-0.0301633105,
0.0701524541,
0.0600739606,
0.0300657488,
-0.0005694919,
0.026493378,
0.0586040989,
-0.0269564167,
0.0040101879,
-0.0474356264,
-0.0344795026,
-0.0344823301,
-0.05051836,
0.0219450761,
-0.0214600023,
-0.0160819329,
-0.0704657063,
0.0670568869,
0.0086633004,
-0.017229937,
-0.0280033704,
-0.041336067,
0.0615718253,
-0.0284319334,
0.0282407422,
0.0376762263,
-0.0661442801,
0.0310928039,
-0.0789949968,
0.022059042,
-0.0399648808,
-0.0053455951,
0.0290916525,
0.050137952,
0.0006227762,
0.0063430537,
0.0180014931,
0.0427676551,
0.0131259654,
-0.0631205365,
-0.0073559517,
-0.0025568828,
-0.0406537168,
-0.0092882188,
-0.0615389049,
0.0152375884,
-0.0189860035,
-0.025053123,
-0.0107078552,
0.1137100905,
0.0004961612,
0.023198368,
-0.043894805,
0.0223864596,
-0.0627815872,
0.0175627768,
-0.056266062,
0.0292532146,
-0.0637920871,
-0.0257789176,
0.0294651315,
-0.0132001536,
0.0065966942,
-0.0025251799,
0.0395513736,
0.0303489156,
-0.0185495038,
0.0461263992,
-0.035254553,
-0.0232001916,
0.0189444963,
-0.006324206,
-0.0087058377,
-0.0199169088,
-0.0559322163,
0.0096094981,
0.0288291387,
-0.0141487066,
-0.0090075806,
-0.0364256613,
-0.0089001255,
0.0003247842,
0.039230857,
0.0512350947,
-0.0403883867,
0.0383017883,
0.02665402,
0.0167894326,
-0.0272058491,
0.0270289257,
0.0270994771,
0.0128186448,
0.0104525955,
-0.0327880457,
0.0266621988,
0.0295665208,
-0.0464051291,
0.0175443459,
0.0630021766,
0.0096298819,
0.0148515394,
0.0281836595,
0.0250062961,
-0.010866438,
-0.0138100972,
-0.0277419053,
0.069437705,
0.0547009557,
0.0116551276,
0.0473143868,
0.021143714,
0.036022041,
0.005988291,
0.0163806584,
-0.0105054285,
0.0289373025,
0.0023208607,
-0.0172685012,
-0.0273740534,
0.0162267871,
-0.0225117542,
-0.0475768708,
0.0461368784,
0.0083785113,
0.0414598286,
-0.007963459,
-0.0230444446,
0.040713124,
-0.0247088689,
0.0371112823,
0.0001797869,
-0.0898735374,
-0.0193822887,
-0.0363674015,
0.0020961212,
0.1384017318,
0.0227234066,
-0.0137541052,
-0.0598024353,
0.0059527112,
-0.0175106265,
0.045761276,
0.0272610933,
-0.0195847694,
0.0372944102,
-0.0061410554,
-0.0160740148,
-0.0107452534,
-0.0335787833,
0.0576753728,
-0.0164519604,
0.021109622,
-0.0066753589,
0.0601278022,
0.0491467528,
0.0056756232,
-0.0458183177,
0.0027400979,
0.0286696404,
0.0237056464,
0.02269339,
0.0110366931,
0.0118870698,
-0.0534572639,
0.0055632913,
0.0301972423,
-0.0006786042,
0.0881458223,
-0.0058120368,
0.0112356711,
0.0372832902,
0.0095369667,
-0.0096343439,
-0.0220974609,
0.0046524322,
-0.0255796164,
0.0570874736,
-0.0419088863,
0.0413053036,
-0.006227206,
0.0497425832,
-0.0027168593,
0.0314158499,
0.0253720451,
-0.0035184284,
0.0190550685,
-0.0806192681,
0.0104610203,
0.0601447299,
-0.0022115081,
-0.0890959278,
0.0271056332,
-0.0067947819,
0.0095618507,
-0.0066650035,
0.0007317649,
-0.0276020505,
-0.0604811981,
-0.0487498976,
-0.0903241634,
-0.0125636086,
0.0310835782,
-0.0189538859,
0.0106392726,
0.0730534121,
-0.0420454443,
-0.0561372004,
-0.0483117774,
0.0276514478,
0.0062863398,
-0.02001011,
0.0532853715,
0.0297725406,
-0.0251905154,
-0.0694506243,
0.0397332609,
-0.0060571092,
-0.011848269,
-0.0522149764,
0.032113295,
-0.055001419,
-0.0433093943,
-0.0628383309,
0.0403416902,
-0.0229041521,
-0.0359541476,
0.0482803844,
0.0023323854,
0.0558931008,
0.0705527961,
0.05110256,
0.0357445404,
0.0055250027,
-0.0343758985,
-0.0463069044,
0.0645216405,
0.0091965841,
0.0264489241,
-0.0347451121,
-0.0010004902,
0.0556549691,
0.0187821649,
-0.026660433,
0.0061343759,
-0.0635252595,
0.0295962729,
0.0344874151,
-0.0514154732,
0.0445360318,
0.0213157386,
-0.0232377369,
0.0097324839,
-0.0089726364,
-0.0240496807,
0.0652411208,
-0.0042383289,
-0.0230959076,
-0.0151952393,
-0.0141334999,
-0.019621212,
0.0376651138,
-0.0410121977,
0.0139156831,
0.0021452312,
-0.0302889775,
-0.0402993113,
-0.0257020872,
0.0258842614,
-0.0415759608,
0.0270015094,
-0.0384658501,
-0.0311625041,
0.0321024582,
-0.0444186218,
-0.0437362231,
-0.0076934104,
-0.0036802611,
-0.0490489565,
-0.012104135,
-0.0401038677,
-0.0701852143,
0.01008162,
-0.0045929528,
0.0286536794,
-0.0085836155,
-0.01991391,
-0.0399421379,
-0.0790017769,
0.0464327037,
0.0905761197,
-0.0197954923,
-0.004485812,
0.0722952187,
-0.007829695,
0.0249155331,
-0.0567796417,
-0.0223857909,
-0.0037395826,
0.0172688384,
-0.0389931798,
-0.0252203122,
0.0053669689,
0.0469802544,
-0.0266995113,
0.0205685887,
0.1008610278,
0.0263714977,
0.0044746543,
0.0117999204,
-0.0350283422,
0.023895083,
0.0317812897,
0.0313171111,
-0.0296794903,
-0.0049467031,
0.0011791741,
0.0561340712,
0.0065249181,
-0.0292471386,
-0.0275394488,
-0.043455109,
0.0116493274,
0.0049263686,
-0.0118686212,
0.0446651801,
-0.0031834322,
0.0389804468,
0.0158400964,
0.0300219953,
0.0105209062,
-0.0164719541,
-0.011174622,
-0.0188595615,
-0.0526279099,
0.0018504781,
-0.0090642981,
-0.0282019246,
0.0366535559,
0.0568614118,
0.071916163,
0.0368301012,
-0.0418319516,
-0.0697727501,
0.046692051,
0.0423819125,
-0.0084876455,
0.0418645889,
-0.0294514243,
-0.006173356,
-0.050628081,
-0.0050781933,
-0.0043672137,
0.0096227676,
0.0482564084,
-0.0133771505,
-0.041117046,
-0.0020584334,
-0.0411840193,
-0.0026777107,
-0.0040206728,
0.019036008,
-0.0334614143,
-0.0931116566,
-0.0115180574,
-0.0099197756,
0.0109451115,
-0.0100555113,
-0.0206321646,
0.0012527903,
-0.0373023562,
-0.0385219045,
-0.0679945871,
-0.0422657914,
0.0001896498,
0.0624098554,
0.0225375574,
-0.0061764219,
-0.0300203674,
0.0583739132,
0.0096812658,
-0.0309294183,
-0.0348312743,
0.0067426129,
-0.0340030976,
-0.0416300967,
0.0383288823,
-0.0515114889,
0.0361622497,
-0.0251883343,
0.0001916746,
-0.0356885605,
-0.0139382407,
0.0342693031,
0.0185947418,
0.0749414861,
-0.0030910389,
-0.0625543892,
0.034538649,
-0.0190828498,
0.0124682169,
-0.002338174,
0.033401724,
0.0603175052,
-0.0181805063,
0.007958103,
-0.0490008108,
-0.0227353983,
-0.0726011395,
-0.0041935723,
-0.0207292363,
-0.0890093744,
0.0059275893,
0.0399361812,
-0.0152637381,
0.0233782511,
0.0030912326,
0.0376459993,
0.0360751376,
-0.013222646,
-0.0159533117,
-0.0164687522,
-0.0083616301,
-0.0154700531,
0.0235191565,
0.038104251,
0.0051097497,
-0.0362689979,
-0.0035464265,
-0.0475922078,
-0.0232464541,
0.0189358443,
0.0246305019,
0.0028722861,
0.0183712933,
0.0041125715,
0.0259018373,
0.0296176281,
0.0345811658,
0.0221998971,
0.0408246852,
-0.016502874,
-0.0220312923,
-0.0172048789,
0.0715867653,
-0.0639647767,
-0.0154472208,
0.0522134192,
0.0374022983,
-0.0212082677,
0.0624238327,
0.0484779887,
-0.0008400909,
0.0329113603,
-0.0133326044,
-0.0042762598,
0.0176660977,
-0.017851254,
-0.0425496325,
0.0001514398,
-0.0157138556,
-0.0133851133,
0.0233803615,
-0.0454165563,
0.0289027747,
-0.0648256168,
-0.0103239715,
-0.0536365546,
-0.0082080271,
-0.024486471,
0.0356815048,
0.0088014463,
-0.0314973742,
-0.0388214774,
-0.0207042694,
0.0299134832,
0.0096097877,
-0.002614965,
-0.03992825,
0.0213281885,
0.022361435,
0.002193725,
-0.0422501154,
-0.0368709341,
-0.01113973,
-0.0261300486,
0.0271658991,
0.0225623809,
-4.98109817e-33,
-0.0435990989,
0.0389536731,
0.0230969749,
0.0452039689,
-0.0468745977,
-0.0582244694,
-0.0490842983,
0.0229465403,
0.0023734183,
-0.0275430642,
-0.0425446555,
0.010751633,
0.0163034126,
-0.0289361533,
-0.0220808983,
0.0093860812,
0.0620034412,
0.0186914373,
-0.0445106961,
0.0354343243,
0.0357276127,
0.0097267739,
-0.0333918035,
-0.0996147022,
-0.0039382023,
0.0055248444,
-0.0251578689,
0.0250756517,
0.0377001949,
0.0440681949,
0.020324612,
0.0234330725,
-0.0013877467,
0.0609937645,
-0.0087196808,
0.0317815058,
-0.0553555116,
-0.039752692,
-0.0046653091,
0.0425501354,
-0.028802488,
-0.0408082977,
-0.001734828,
0.0155809326,
-0.032347478,
0.0352341682,
0.027864974,
-0.0180180408,
0.0347920246,
0.0032904844,
-0.052540686,
-0.0243577752,
-0.0256834794,
-0.0413199291,
-0.025597319,
0.0284977648,
0.0103163524,
-0.054600507,
-0.0359049849,
0.0325721428,
-0.0072371578,
-0.0497577228,
0.0074770544,
0.0808084458,
0.0324424282,
-0.0013130801,
0.0688761398,
0.0443083048,
0.0163967181,
-0.0181043707,
0.0485839657,
0.0319614224,
-0.0014891756,
0.0378412344,
-0.0376348905,
-0.0456010439,
0.0395963676,
0.0475311689,
0.0832800344,
-0.0072679385,
-0.007875232,
0.0481343567,
-0.0494184233,
0.0282160304,
-0.0343558565,
0.0157135986,
-0.0105176531,
-0.0665068999,
0.0200167,
0.0023506414,
-0.0455980077,
-0.0380754098,
0.0007831577,
-0.0263761673,
0.0019515405,
-0.0468327515,
-0.0607120842,
-0.0076296935,
0.0056504915,
-0.0031182077,
0.0212983582,
-0.0482573919,
0.0646409541,
-0.00860833,
0.0260537677,
0.024684323,
-0.0351335108,
0.0265645217,
-0.0589811839,
-0.0210475717,
0.0246277098,
0.071200721,
-0.0134813515,
0.0247955024,
0.0139801763,
-0.0130443061,
-0.0396149606,
0.0276738238,
0.0194719639,
0.0110824779,
-0.0777192935,
0.0174321383,
0.0205308199,
-0.0030968133,
-0.0424654968,
-0.0071867015,
-0.0334395207,
-0.0048223711,
-0.0008461197,
-0.0558765568,
-0.029159179,
0.0120640034,
2.526e-7,
-0.0746413842,
0.0168931894,
-0.005439539,
-0.0169250127,
0.0745578259,
0.0655607954,
-0.0157155208,
0.0523633473,
0.030920893,
-0.0322410502,
0.0246042646,
0.0290644001,
0.032786604,
0.0098382151,
-0.0733309612,
-0.0292731039,
0.0127682639,
0.0117882174,
-0.0326457806,
0.0490433723,
0.0526065081,
0.0128336586,
0.0452453159,
0.0239962414,
0.0377762839,
0.0063574221,
0.0259633306,
0.0139033003,
0.0246111527,
0.0229297429,
-0.0269958768,
0.0015862854,
-0.0303913429,
-0.0031339496,
0.0052533103,
0.0676704422,
-0.0251195729,
0.0394651927,
-0.043274615,
-0.0239325091,
0.0123095522,
0.0474577323,
0.0014342715,
0.0044776313,
0.04879364,
-0.0047411602,
-0.0179203246,
-0.0051412559,
-0.0228489917,
-0.014385405,
-0.0246027578,
-0.0062402715,
-0.039792534,
0.0350574963,
-0.0185334831,
0.0004274042,
-0.0211963262,
-0.0866161138,
0.0520400368,
-0.0203259215,
-0.0379425772,
-0.0497325175,
-0.0361803994,
0.0223383084,
0.0286162309,
-0.0197253544,
0.0470036939,
1.32986121e-34,
-0.0449041277,
0.0197444782,
0.0199224316,
-0.0025914907,
0.0399447978,
0.0159358997,
0.0212476142,
0.0182493646,
0.1068113372,
-0.0579866655,
-0.0145775005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13948v1 | CityGPT: Empowering Urban Spatial Cognition of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T02:32:16 | 2024-06-20T02:32:16 | Jie Feng, Yuwei Du, Tianhui Liu, Siqi Guo, Yuming Lin, Yong Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models(LLMs) with powerful language generation and reasoning
capabilities have already achieved success in many domains, e.g., math and code
generation. However, due to the lacking of physical world's corpus and
knowledge during training, they usually fail to solve many real-life tasks in
the urban space. In this paper, we propose CityGPT, a systematic framework for
enhancing the capability of LLMs on understanding urban space and solving the
related urban tasks by building a city-scale world model in the model. First,
we construct a diverse instruction tuning dataset CityInstruction for injecting
urban knowledge and enhancing spatial reasoning capability effectively. By
using a mixture of CityInstruction and general instruction data, we fine-tune
various LLMs (e.g., ChatGLM3-6B, Qwen1.5 and LLama3 series) to enhance their
capability without sacrificing general abilities. To further validate the
effectiveness of proposed methods, we construct a comprehensive benchmark
CityEval to evaluate the capability of LLMs on diverse urban scenarios and
problems. Extensive evaluation results demonstrate that small LLMs trained with
CityInstruction can achieve competitive performance with commercial LLMs in the
comprehensive evaluation of CityEval. The source codes are openly accessible to
the research community via https://github.com/tsinghua-fib-lab/CityGPT. | [
0.0101405792,
0.0527849905,
-0.0085498272,
0.0490180962,
-0.024655005,
0.0288650785,
0.0355176888,
-0.057363417,
-0.0044335569,
-0.0021499984,
-0.0257985014,
0.0061531863,
0.0061788536,
0.0561099239,
0.0308121461,
-0.0506919399,
-0.0108519904,
-0.0473165996,
-0.0449877456,
-0.0093093961,
-0.0005705597,
0.0285127964,
-0.0108354557,
0.0458468199,
0.0069461591,
0.0047915573,
-0.0136186918,
0.0099788159,
0.0125535103,
-0.0665248558,
0.0165047795,
0.0265010633,
0.0796829611,
0.0376648828,
0.0000022276,
-0.0075544519,
-0.0309843123,
-0.0057101548,
0.0578223392,
-0.0178011488,
0.023323806,
-0.0028497037,
0.012987772,
0.0184297021,
-0.0284519978,
-0.0033742085,
0.0511781424,
0.0157738924,
0.0578903779,
0.0545019843,
-0.0109590087,
-0.0613017194,
0.0022642184,
0.0037067016,
0.0205724481,
-0.015935706,
0.0036917583,
0.0280785263,
0.0512383841,
0.048526749,
-0.0329533704,
-0.0127125951,
0.0586283021,
0.0072968444,
-0.0000183458,
0.0475691371,
-0.0366102085,
0.0160874482,
-0.0127400095,
0.0750917569,
0.0052391845,
-0.0447369851,
0.0450830385,
0.0118620712,
-0.0163213387,
-0.0127575239,
-0.0797547549,
-0.0149819069,
0.0108568864,
0.0360760726,
-0.0553546362,
-0.0402931944,
0.0351125635,
0.0206531659,
-0.0431683064,
0.1132996678,
-0.0040912288,
-0.016420152,
-0.0499327891,
-0.0026620384,
-0.0090632932,
-0.0463083871,
-0.002642049,
0.0736543387,
-0.0321709327,
-0.0024923198,
-0.004484327,
0.0657555386,
-0.0332361199,
-0.0321280509,
0.0325216949,
0.0184681695,
-0.0069766138,
0.0491374768,
-0.0381943919,
0.0380973369,
0.0003996158,
0.0713507906,
-0.0424454622,
-0.0143624544,
-0.0464798771,
0.00379057,
-0.0755700395,
0.0161642041,
-0.0560431033,
0.0001632661,
0.0163029246,
0.0452518389,
-0.0141920997,
0.0211986918,
-0.0612890571,
0.0529827215,
0.0094422726,
-0.0392174758,
0.004174252,
-0.0088469563,
-0.0098611508,
-0.0038995079,
0.012109613,
-0.024987258,
0.0106097208,
0.0113868061,
0.0102229593,
-0.0023084776,
-0.0169254765,
0.05075958,
0.0140816439,
0.0080733299,
-0.0345943421,
-0.0133691859,
0.0236793458,
-0.0880731866,
0.0591972508,
-0.1068874896,
-0.0402737483,
0.0204465613,
-0.0289594941,
-0.0325482003,
0.0042043109,
-0.0326327682,
0.0037875432,
0.0295039397,
-0.062164329,
0.031162899,
0.0702390969,
0.0065491386,
0.037506707,
0.0990857184,
0.0575033128,
0.0565609336,
0.0033237764,
-0.0008097642,
-0.0066009895,
0.0064791981,
0.0248064678,
0.0254913718,
-0.0250786133,
0.0391833484,
-0.0039993031,
0.0331479758,
-0.0019018316,
0.0239177961,
-0.0273666736,
0.0428181589,
0.0357765406,
0.0157101303,
0.0087982574,
-0.0062288665,
0.0552059859,
0.0610908046,
-0.016166104,
-0.0215560012,
-0.0628542751,
0.0178674459,
-0.026924029,
0.0121114235,
-0.0352679938,
0.0485744178,
-0.0171846952,
-0.0220004935,
-0.0112191178,
0.0004068231,
0.0314582698,
-0.0029159035,
0.0592037514,
0.0013486223,
-0.0177398659,
0.0395380184,
0.0094341068,
0.0088920807,
0.0256689508,
-0.0652658939,
0.0154892504,
0.0270329788,
-0.0091621596,
-0.0037587506,
-0.003192479,
-0.0124126319,
0.03720586,
0.019577764,
0.0488946661,
-0.0100449175,
-0.0166510455,
-0.0670756474,
-0.0631184205,
-0.021606978,
0.0348323137,
-0.0106699513,
0.0665994212,
0.0168726407,
0.0617450289,
-0.0512421019,
-0.023222547,
0.0014744039,
0.0175778307,
-0.0091394493,
-0.0599895567,
0.0038011617,
-0.023329718,
-0.0514468588,
-0.0263110865,
0.0057508224,
0.0132937338,
0.0029567049,
-0.0120103955,
0.0081345821,
-0.0653796867,
-0.0317481533,
0.0034438244,
-0.0087710656,
-0.0179321691,
0.0472409762,
-0.0685769767,
-0.0109611824,
-0.0067395284,
-0.0545024686,
0.0398084447,
-0.0081194537,
0.0260911249,
0.0010932769,
-0.0407431833,
-0.0292987768,
0.0444745347,
-0.0162483584,
0.0033586212,
0.0097888792,
0.0873931721,
0.0254385881,
0.0127476268,
0.0104919244,
-0.0445093438,
-0.0073449994,
0.0159781724,
-0.0260887891,
0.0693016425,
-0.0432738326,
-0.0251422692,
-0.0752028674,
-0.0133012962,
-0.0089585446,
0.0161901694,
-0.0027782987,
-0.0413308181,
-0.0148782544,
-0.0331605747,
-0.0375731327,
0.0375375636,
0.0057814652,
0.0162468292,
0.0240424909,
-0.0487717837,
-0.0121581359,
0.0134615293,
0.0090497257,
-0.0200278312,
0.016036788,
0.0171291437,
0.0069169886,
0.0026881795,
0.0054793954,
-0.0254950412,
-0.0007397254,
0.0152412914,
-0.0275040437,
0.0376757607,
-0.0135892164,
0.052859053,
0.0375475325,
-0.0132830562,
-0.0054327962,
0.0272554904,
-0.0447755978,
-0.0720194876,
0.0267280173,
-0.0233913828,
-0.0079913316,
-0.0387247875,
-0.0270004068,
-0.0281461477,
0.0520569757,
-0.0403845906,
-0.0041182465,
-0.0225815345,
0.0446150787,
-0.0205931161,
-0.0362101197,
-0.0451860577,
0.0532900691,
0.011690395,
0.0580798388,
-0.0742527544,
-0.0790951401,
0.0204489455,
-0.052600272,
-0.0023549472,
-0.0220082048,
0.0305455253,
-0.0523103289,
0.0588924065,
0.005518557,
0.0308543164,
-0.021171784,
-0.0075232419,
-0.0263774842,
-0.0321409293,
-0.0358438939,
0.0048651733,
0.0278376024,
-0.0845272839,
-0.0036614323,
0.0021228157,
-0.0810850263,
-0.0281518679,
0.0270786919,
-0.0362533778,
0.0091932043,
-0.0144443186,
-0.0522367358,
0.0146557195,
0.0469251536,
0.0129107051,
0.0485150293,
-0.0556101054,
-0.016191313,
-0.0201481953,
-0.0115274778,
0.0861761272,
0.1018098816,
-0.0019404495,
-0.0136229722,
-0.0310066808,
0.0267345402,
-0.0092868153,
-0.0114050526,
-0.0378364585,
0.0658455044,
0.0185300447,
0.0029829694,
-0.01321775,
0.0158851407,
0.0554979518,
-0.0762735009,
-0.0749721155,
0.0759268925,
0.031221997,
0.0170261357,
-0.0034595237,
-0.0555453263,
0.0209841747,
0.0467712469,
0.000824586,
-0.0620885864,
-0.0178547278,
0.0132885799,
-0.0314798914,
0.0354267657,
-0.0259043388,
0.0156213986,
-0.1117309555,
0.0953961983,
0.0243799314,
-0.0901615471,
-0.0502252653,
-0.0389656834,
-0.0498479716,
0.0406242833,
-0.0155198686,
-0.01612808,
0.0008285816,
0.0016892168,
0.0526444837,
-0.0327165686,
-0.0414407738,
-0.0170872752,
-0.01336182,
0.0736574754,
0.0310492888,
0.0437051505,
0.0197340436,
-0.043128524,
0.0047830022,
0.0652155951,
0.0381039865,
-0.050085362,
-0.0279356744,
0.0175905544,
-0.0114972992,
0.0155771933,
0.0252861697,
-0.0529019646,
-0.012471172,
0.0507510379,
0.0645497963,
-0.0251469761,
0.0141320508,
-0.0445780717,
0.0314229243,
0.000804094,
0.0090580676,
0.0205159169,
0.0321642086,
-0.0396450497,
-0.0416033342,
-0.0760798827,
-0.054762736,
-0.0232902374,
0.0008858063,
0.0017050352,
0.0084758056,
-0.0189002678,
-0.0194027461,
0.0274766702,
0.0557306521,
-0.0182594918,
-0.0472749509,
-0.005327215,
-0.0271006804,
-0.0651247352,
0.0355562605,
-0.0514339656,
0.0160586424,
-0.0028927044,
0.0071003176,
0.0037562768,
-0.0538892671,
-0.0211136043,
0.0145158283,
-0.0958803818,
-0.0383541882,
0.0215415303,
0.0545799471,
0.0181233883,
0.0175112337,
-0.0237998441,
0.0090532554,
0.0489927642,
-0.0212044735,
-0.0280706249,
0.0006200984,
0.0053326245,
0.0254267957,
0.0450870097,
-0.0039078128,
-0.0388328619,
0.0500635244,
0.033320073,
0.0148462001,
-0.0345468819,
0.0442220867,
-0.0080514029,
0.0312902369,
0.0435475782,
0.0166721344,
-0.0021323385,
-0.041660551,
0.0110311992,
-0.0142378025,
0.0015823515,
-0.0282903537,
0.0259053614,
0.0289302431,
0.03950122,
0.0062821135,
-0.0061320863,
0.0572306216,
0.0058265277,
-0.0046519958,
0.0037930766,
0.0162919443,
0.0343163796,
0.0496222526,
0.0048316382,
-0.0234729536,
0.0242588129,
-0.0062068705,
0.0276248436,
0.0123694222,
0.0527679063,
0.0159624107,
-0.0018696305,
-0.0202829614,
0.0347266272,
-0.0306688081,
-0.0672335923,
-0.0440781601,
0.0609768443,
0.0826156437,
0.0464348309,
-0.0005809889,
-0.0237306394,
0.0012908721,
-0.0137831308,
0.0044644992,
0.0511615314,
-0.0411011577,
0.0140785361,
0.0001394613,
-0.0503804423,
-0.009733608,
0.0540702455,
0.0304955747,
0.0492068492,
0.0222592894,
-0.0044929096,
-0.0104437722,
-0.0244324207,
0.0193170458,
0.0355043262,
0.0118559618,
-0.0038204566,
-0.0318081714,
-0.0554707795,
-0.0211848207,
0.046898488,
-0.0183780678,
0.0123604583,
0.0341799855,
0.0466357768,
-0.0196552444,
-0.0332296789,
-0.0232032444,
0.0130281635,
-0.0044003865,
-0.0016857341,
0.0205255505,
-6.391364089e-33,
-0.0119591681,
-0.0698345304,
0.0897968486,
-0.0154751772,
-0.0243829172,
-0.0116384933,
-0.0534167439,
-0.02266399,
-0.0130610066,
-0.0125052799,
0.0017394461,
0.0309415367,
0.0090623684,
0.0207544193,
0.0348384269,
0.0122180842,
0.0462980717,
0.0111133205,
-0.0245263446,
0.0184791423,
0.0063625379,
0.010088386,
0.0152629251,
-0.0535851121,
-0.0360879414,
-0.0415158384,
-0.0330650806,
0.0268828329,
-0.0356892981,
0.05245848,
0.0011585793,
0.0391603298,
0.0327246152,
-0.0090306401,
-0.0578596778,
0.0102916602,
-0.0509355702,
-0.0167303048,
0.0112392465,
0.0215501115,
-0.0491648391,
-0.0706758797,
0.022417618,
0.0107840132,
-0.0057035405,
-0.0129570616,
0.0367911048,
-0.0109893335,
-0.0215485077,
-0.0118079232,
-0.0712405145,
0.0264542084,
-0.020890085,
-0.0315603986,
0.0031809388,
-0.0069451076,
0.0221755672,
-0.001118441,
-0.0093503892,
0.0005272988,
0.0485273898,
0.0272692218,
0.0377858728,
0.0347194225,
0.0148101076,
0.047835391,
0.0169637296,
-0.0181954429,
-0.0015260226,
-0.0150782289,
0.0788060948,
0.0792548805,
-0.0323625542,
0.0316074118,
-0.0093313949,
0.0060114223,
-0.0492153205,
0.0107032768,
-0.0392436087,
0.0320261084,
0.0039189067,
-0.010431705,
-0.0316624045,
-0.0131400945,
-0.0234179646,
-0.0231620856,
-0.0251974072,
-0.029544875,
0.032228902,
0.0034446854,
-0.0112922098,
0.0357890986,
0.0052773771,
-0.0581534728,
-0.0235434398,
0.0184509214,
-0.0238474514,
-0.0039322809,
-0.0233805403,
0.0878538117,
-0.0961492956,
-0.0685141087,
0.0130111109,
0.0332398415,
0.0015882093,
0.0483243503,
0.0045501767,
0.0420437753,
-0.0275545791,
-0.0159349889,
-0.0652179793,
-0.0200550947,
0.0047443337,
-0.0042546229,
0.0153202796,
-0.0234282315,
-0.0129709896,
0.0056525669,
-0.0213614292,
-0.01666536,
-0.0004360435,
-0.0056407363,
-0.036556337,
0.0450235084,
0.0114549603,
-0.00697181,
-0.0418893211,
-0.0144590652,
0.0325769186,
-0.0490120649,
-0.0164745599,
0.0096672121,
2.913e-7,
-0.0170489699,
0.0632270426,
0.0112972884,
0.0043090656,
0.0173718724,
0.0263566542,
-0.0133176083,
0.0106482469,
0.0046110898,
0.0576756932,
0.0363087319,
0.0691716298,
0.0581453145,
0.0195797849,
-0.0944651738,
0.0854607001,
-0.0676263496,
-0.0015859347,
-0.078106232,
-0.0206839144,
0.0552216843,
0.0720923766,
0.0133167496,
-0.0126426816,
0.0343350582,
-0.0138778882,
-0.0061621419,
-0.0374367908,
-0.0051567699,
0.0375398174,
-0.0105611552,
0.0304233748,
-0.0009353795,
-0.0301944707,
-0.0017132518,
-0.0257160366,
0.0092114033,
0.0922368914,
-0.0105566811,
0.002853225,
0.0320572592,
-0.0783503801,
-0.0109302374,
-0.0761366412,
0.0531340018,
-0.0599435866,
0.0039935522,
0.029071521,
0.0004703207,
-0.039900139,
-0.0128575983,
0.0000891428,
-0.0098680444,
-0.0443512648,
0.0089304075,
-0.0197058823,
-0.0246962067,
-0.0696057975,
0.0258321464,
0.0242257062,
-0.0087776845,
-0.0734188184,
-0.0635030493,
0.0027744616,
0.0102654612,
-0.0025082265,
-0.0099616898,
2.330247196e-34,
0.0038619994,
-0.0068024825,
-0.0054501155,
0.0062679034,
0.0431993082,
-0.0036715288,
-0.019267492,
0.00913784,
-0.0215613246,
-0.0392182991,
0.0109279361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13947v1 | AspirinSum: an Aspect-based utility-preserved de-identification Summarization framework | 2024-06-20T02:29:46 | 2024-06-20T02:29:46 | Ya-Lun Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Due to the rapid advancement of Large Language Model (LLM), the whole
community eagerly consumes any available text data in order to train the LLM.
Currently, large portion of the available text data are collected from
internet, which has been thought as a cheap source of the training data.
However, when people try to extend the LLM's capability to the personal related
domain, such as healthcare or education, the lack of public dataset in these
domains make the adaption of the LLM in such domains much slower. The reason of
lacking public available dataset in such domains is because they usually
contain personal sensitive information. In order to comply with privacy law,
the data in such domains need to be de-identified before any kind of
dissemination. It had been much research tried to address this problem for the
image or tabular data. However, there was limited research on the efficient and
general de-identification method for text data. Most of the method based on
human annotation or predefined category list. It usually can not be easily
adapted to specific domains. The goal of this proposal is to develop a text
de-identification framework, which can be easily adapted to the specific
domain, leverage the existing expert knowledge without further human
annotation. We propose an aspect-based utility-preserved de-identification
summarization framework, AspirinSum, by learning to align expert's aspect from
existing comment data, it can efficiently summarize the personal sensitive
document by extracting personal sensitive aspect related sub-sentence and
de-identify it by substituting it with similar aspect sub-sentence. We envision
that the de-identified text can then be used in data publishing, eventually
publishing our de-identified dataset for downstream task use. | [
0.0792183653,
0.0283097196,
0.0081870873,
0.0114321029,
-0.0514019877,
0.0219412986,
0.0376002342,
-0.0050585256,
0.0113862418,
-0.0408890434,
-0.0258042812,
0.0094885444,
-0.0037705158,
0.0175172705,
-0.0190251581,
-0.0333311632,
0.030522367,
0.010302105,
0.0215413924,
-0.0084879249,
0.0369009078,
0.0169801787,
0.0371554792,
0.0126500856,
0.0266355835,
-0.0072260899,
0.0377436653,
-0.0149413804,
0.0551892929,
0.0143286251,
0.0294281878,
0.0434268527,
0.0146979224,
-0.0083498983,
0.0000021477,
-0.0411125161,
-0.1049974039,
0.0045513231,
0.0026190816,
-0.0179921407,
0.0874956027,
-0.0347726159,
-0.0068080709,
-0.0040414385,
0.0066373902,
-0.0211653784,
0.0095452676,
0.0739013553,
0.0822486207,
0.0919538215,
-0.0250767563,
-0.0569165237,
-0.0183548164,
-0.0146510992,
-0.0419297814,
-0.0585223809,
0.033682365,
-0.0173373502,
-0.0097426157,
0.0564716309,
0.051776506,
0.0324618518,
-0.0086174393,
-0.0057869111,
0.0083686197,
0.0140563361,
0.0080020763,
0.0176965799,
0.0088855792,
0.0510214493,
0.0016711315,
-0.0338977128,
0.0716412887,
0.0009734543,
0.0179352779,
0.0509448536,
-0.0235386509,
0.0452483147,
-0.023327399,
0.0252196956,
0.0298390649,
0.0282187387,
-0.0262137,
0.0169592202,
0.0138152428,
-0.0325944349,
-0.0109142177,
-0.0136310263,
-0.0419087783,
-0.0266595948,
-0.0330975577,
-0.0754925832,
0.0828537866,
0.0269875694,
0.0577693321,
-0.0165356789,
-0.0555208474,
-0.054443378,
0.0295125376,
-0.0716623142,
-0.0185667276,
-0.0268432926,
0.023608543,
0.061859373,
-0.0222344529,
0.029516276,
0.0310367551,
-0.0266965758,
-0.0594265684,
0.0059902766,
-0.0353842676,
-0.0003282957,
-0.0204073377,
0.0824491754,
-0.0294937696,
0.0023941137,
-0.0330889039,
0.0270363912,
-0.0028200119,
0.025432501,
0.0129026817,
-0.0068900581,
0.002838766,
-0.0170206968,
0.0004352151,
-0.0071607456,
-0.0076167244,
0.0019734162,
-0.0193335153,
0.0248344224,
0.0317796916,
0.0145466924,
0.0641684979,
0.008816232,
-0.0059715286,
0.0043723085,
-0.0088145593,
-0.0499757193,
-0.0426264815,
-0.0770371333,
-0.0253700409,
-0.0150749506,
-0.0193354618,
-0.0762729272,
-0.0098574627,
-0.0270600505,
-0.0298706107,
-0.0782738477,
0.014187335,
0.0522061177,
-0.0771694258,
0.0291811954,
-0.0613470823,
-0.0104547022,
0.0386542454,
0.0377051271,
0.0922669992,
0.0028299929,
-0.0021583484,
0.0711275265,
0.0526024438,
0.0022281972,
0.030389132,
0.0209646877,
-0.0070048785,
-0.0150125837,
0.0313105062,
-0.0177178364,
-0.0300232507,
-0.0697928295,
-0.0100428704,
0.080047518,
-0.0012896564,
-0.014748238,
0.0515417717,
0.0352230445,
-0.0218830705,
0.0601307899,
-0.0479016826,
0.0563142635,
0.0012582781,
0.0512217842,
-0.0144369164,
-0.0027553453,
-0.0403186344,
0.003732868,
0.0299463477,
-0.0042364234,
-0.0309321266,
-0.0258663725,
0.0045525865,
-0.0412502624,
0.0078023667,
0.0054512881,
0.0357385874,
0.0296110921,
-0.0153823765,
0.0318810791,
0.0118846977,
-0.0647301823,
-0.0085186539,
-0.0305893607,
0.0248734951,
0.0394237712,
0.0315528363,
-0.0734400302,
-0.008239693,
-0.0323907249,
-0.0118015762,
-0.0026428369,
-0.0097418949,
-0.0198334977,
-0.0274031758,
-0.042053543,
-0.041215498,
0.0302687548,
0.0044317627,
-0.0218130667,
0.0173935965,
-0.0050413469,
0.0537925735,
-0.0251167435,
-0.0208330471,
0.0157884229,
-0.0063594002,
-0.0390446,
0.0138948215,
0.0032684843,
0.0207950696,
0.0625351965,
0.0009713219,
-0.0010236526,
0.0449110381,
-0.0158691388,
-0.0038590457,
-0.0288548656,
-0.0157470163,
-0.0013503208,
0.0115578277,
-0.0381878763,
-0.0028968728,
0.0164299719,
-0.0328089967,
-0.0248158127,
-0.0073811822,
-0.0101797627,
-0.0205878224,
-0.029324187,
0.0486658774,
0.0069120005,
0.0038446623,
-0.0369659662,
0.071251899,
-0.0224888846,
-0.0087998956,
-0.0417948104,
-0.0638508722,
-0.0015204338,
-0.0197596513,
-0.0247141458,
-0.0523159765,
-0.0080880262,
0.0377891175,
0.0824937597,
0.0146746486,
-0.0027581684,
-0.0348216854,
-0.1007507592,
0.0042993319,
0.0183633231,
0.0298239328,
0.0265856199,
0.0180711187,
-0.0084043778,
-0.0168200824,
-0.0530519746,
-0.0521046333,
-0.0069025136,
0.0229340363,
0.0190056972,
0.020199053,
0.024186369,
-0.0167348702,
-0.0097841593,
-0.0076387245,
0.0121209789,
-0.0069864178,
-0.0678376332,
-0.0186998881,
0.0801862478,
-0.0011244908,
0.0086234864,
0.0064524943,
-0.0117704524,
-0.058705844,
0.0218359679,
0.0031586241,
0.0161987171,
0.006062232,
0.0163746383,
0.0275522638,
0.018234916,
0.0027270422,
-0.0230426807,
-0.0701392218,
0.0322828628,
0.0319311991,
-0.0568425544,
0.0464509614,
0.0134405978,
0.018863108,
0.003950431,
0.0037785156,
0.0300226565,
0.0057980078,
0.0175216217,
-0.0174286254,
-0.0156443603,
0.007910029,
0.0020555123,
-0.018175371,
0.006237179,
0.0605798177,
-0.0058016316,
0.0745642707,
-0.0585880615,
-0.0366201289,
-0.0304731037,
0.0484953597,
-0.0008704406,
0.0565562695,
0.0535675511,
-0.0188112482,
-0.0034774039,
-0.0098552098,
0.027830882,
-0.0441204235,
0.0682995319,
-0.0350644067,
0.015258369,
-0.0123020615,
-0.0313424654,
0.003341805,
-0.0673418641,
-0.0215872377,
0.0073188925,
0.0036947653,
-0.0098974993,
-0.0321143642,
0.0155787347,
0.0327370502,
0.0506401137,
-0.0076144785,
0.012544632,
0.0022421826,
0.0818811879,
0.0367960855,
-0.0701875165,
-0.0225535035,
-0.0202580784,
-0.0054794569,
0.0969878659,
0.0053465022,
-0.0090363845,
0.0237290021,
-0.0323941745,
-0.0082206167,
-0.0792710781,
-0.0196514428,
-0.0220638085,
0.0291237887,
-0.0490840264,
0.0110205021,
0.1028645784,
0.0277448092,
-0.0829128549,
-0.0306466222,
0.0692534745,
-0.0344844609,
-0.0195393357,
-0.0090080388,
-0.078092657,
-0.0223830231,
0.0116266022,
0.0174179748,
-0.0394706726,
-0.0307605229,
-0.0071259863,
-0.056530185,
-0.0058120773,
0.0058292788,
-0.0307293795,
-0.0563354418,
-0.0368593782,
0.0229991302,
0.0106466934,
-0.0357914269,
-0.0118962042,
-0.0138273817,
-0.0115614757,
0.0068329079,
-0.0614681728,
-0.0455135778,
-0.0422047079,
-0.0172907319,
0.0286157057,
0.0277263653,
0.0438380875,
-0.025756456,
0.0096420515,
0.0420898907,
-0.0133874705,
-0.0133222695,
-0.0106532052,
0.1147352532,
-0.0177246593,
0.0158620793,
-0.0414041989,
0.0498633273,
0.0096424352,
-0.0185308922,
0.0205461606,
0.0125201466,
0.0109562995,
-0.0131998966,
-0.0299769808,
-0.021036176,
-0.0241233595,
0.0707659349,
-0.0179675743,
-0.0232700519,
0.0116983727,
-0.0022283786,
0.0021185353,
0.0138747692,
-0.0282578915,
-0.0179362167,
-0.0504573137,
-0.0719434246,
-0.0936325267,
0.0075602364,
0.0051541151,
-0.0284259673,
0.0276119765,
0.0422807373,
0.0284060556,
0.0082023861,
-0.0651358217,
-0.0159951691,
-0.0575134009,
0.0034416695,
-0.0413806103,
-0.0020727087,
0.0585680865,
-0.034106534,
-0.0270291157,
0.0122649893,
-0.0553238392,
-0.0407418944,
0.0061779288,
-0.0023499371,
0.0142596299,
0.0409982949,
0.0031692267,
-0.0546860173,
0.0655860752,
0.04787587,
-0.019392645,
-0.0083853034,
0.0020834561,
0.0045077861,
-0.027546877,
0.0174880661,
-0.040694885,
0.0354051664,
0.0462632403,
-0.0555511974,
-0.0671967492,
-0.0852891207,
-0.0045124143,
0.0583666153,
0.0245159566,
0.0324520171,
0.0087511521,
-0.0479666553,
-0.0022656922,
-0.0094319135,
-0.0269215479,
-0.0146265654,
0.0266718492,
0.0293069668,
0.007882176,
0.0250299163,
0.0709039643,
0.0094519667,
-0.0137833264,
-0.0459506959,
0.0255591087,
-0.0031999368,
0.0282950606,
-0.0298235919,
-0.003755701,
-0.0299440082,
-0.0103172669,
0.0082753152,
0.0228269678,
-0.0168684404,
0.0320575386,
-0.0049519516,
-0.0247453302,
-0.0153701287,
0.0624513142,
-0.0358622819,
0.026453305,
-0.0682409927,
0.0271653812,
0.0106749311,
-0.0401065499,
0.0208855942,
-0.0201703906,
-0.0094286604,
-0.0518659577,
0.0377318002,
0.0113298781,
0.0009189448,
-0.024441449,
-0.0061185327,
-0.0091767404,
0.0573949553,
0.0924853534,
-0.0069577615,
-0.0094418069,
0.0144695649,
-0.0618539266,
-0.0496964045,
-0.0054615871,
-0.0307559371,
0.0269337147,
-0.0285257865,
-0.0174847785,
-0.0322743058,
-0.0317779519,
0.0248727053,
-0.0061747637,
0.0169192255,
0.0149709713,
0.0431519933,
0.0103275506,
0.0058451989,
-0.0144902728,
-0.0757456869,
0.0077860537,
-0.0105440011,
-0.0141166234,
0.0181048829,
-6.154799524e-33,
0.0043373676,
-0.0078146206,
-0.0496176109,
0.0384009331,
0.0062402906,
0.028686665,
-0.0224261954,
-0.0100913113,
0.023035448,
-0.0177144874,
-0.0203566495,
-0.0016951303,
0.0175178889,
0.0292765107,
-0.0246146787,
0.0369733423,
0.0558061339,
-0.007389097,
-0.014308,
0.0790587515,
0.0388008468,
0.0227822457,
0.0539812557,
-0.1479152441,
0.0238538496,
-0.0275188424,
-0.0474810451,
0.0062892879,
0.0394104086,
0.040351592,
-0.0245934352,
-0.0095559005,
0.036897704,
-0.0108298464,
-0.0128190629,
0.0452848226,
-0.0842808113,
-0.019238295,
0.0135544576,
-0.0299017336,
0.0097883735,
-0.1116385609,
0.0230446737,
-0.0415816344,
-0.0106003899,
-0.0197320096,
0.0492021255,
-0.0417673886,
-0.0171360392,
-0.0751904547,
0.0141198132,
0.0579818524,
0.0084297303,
-0.003731756,
0.0668732151,
0.0139833791,
-0.0059259585,
-0.0179173928,
-0.034487173,
0.0169762932,
0.04266534,
0.02628313,
0.0177145936,
-0.0039164084,
0.0163271669,
0.0502388254,
0.0290014539,
0.0013417816,
-0.004511429,
-0.0208647884,
-0.0267503001,
0.0088916812,
-0.0026551641,
0.0493297428,
0.025204584,
-0.0283112992,
-0.029830642,
0.076359272,
-0.0384790525,
-0.0010671035,
0.0734233856,
-0.0026161403,
-0.0507367775,
-0.0146017559,
-0.0068874951,
0.0027220456,
-0.0160214659,
0.0117405867,
-0.0306293219,
0.0324185118,
-0.0618614852,
0.0154472105,
-0.0098542487,
-0.0470758602,
-0.0024866951,
0.0056040292,
0.0328221358,
0.0540731288,
-0.0082192607,
-0.0256781578,
-0.0656261519,
0.0028755809,
0.0091005731,
-0.027932601,
0.0023469978,
0.0155458692,
0.0721224993,
-0.0234901048,
-0.0631516725,
0.0073122531,
0.0351263471,
0.0085000535,
0.0094582979,
0.0580335557,
-0.0038010555,
0.0075167469,
0.007412558,
0.0498049259,
0.0363395326,
0.0286104083,
-0.0558787659,
0.0079962304,
0.0227466691,
0.0076516345,
-0.0070962231,
-0.00067694,
0.0096766092,
0.0477269962,
0.0251221173,
-0.0043832492,
0.0179585479,
0.0119889434,
2.767e-7,
0.0341394022,
0.0163284168,
0.0491284579,
-0.0425705314,
0.0080144908,
0.0638130605,
0.0244068727,
0.0278015211,
0.0166781228,
0.022023825,
0.0506745055,
-0.0105667161,
0.0432350412,
0.0122912815,
-0.1114060283,
0.0211910475,
-0.0034920985,
-0.0280186571,
-0.0306169335,
0.016253449,
0.0228207838,
0.0667312443,
0.0286441464,
-0.0059071099,
-0.0244733989,
-0.015923759,
0.0202222914,
-0.0506142378,
-0.0311063025,
0.0392964855,
0.0287712533,
0.0476678312,
-0.0215519592,
-0.0124808019,
-0.0129205063,
-0.0004386209,
0.0151421279,
0.0966430306,
0.0094697913,
0.0082385931,
0.0213507116,
-0.0338528231,
0.0269394368,
0.0062971055,
0.0749305561,
-0.0227483623,
-0.0198135283,
-0.040266294,
-0.0095286267,
-0.0127302967,
-0.009281747,
0.0324226208,
-0.0613716394,
0.0514848754,
0.0105898781,
-0.0246777888,
-0.0088044107,
-0.0879464597,
-0.011412153,
0.0211810116,
-0.0091121374,
-0.0007994378,
0.0322592184,
-0.003834004,
-0.0241174754,
-0.0796475932,
0.0587779805,
2.788567163e-34,
0.0264259018,
0.004340576,
-0.0711171106,
0.0080142738,
0.0123518202,
-0.025021689,
-0.0293507874,
0.0235527996,
-0.0039656814,
-0.0650629178,
-0.0050913203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13945v1 | CityBench: Evaluating the Capabilities of Large Language Model as World Model | 2024-06-20T02:25:07 | 2024-06-20T02:25:07 | Jie Feng, Jun Zhang, Junbo Yan, Xin Zhang, Tianjian Ouyang, Tianhui Liu, Yuwei Du, Siqi Guo, Yong Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) with powerful generalization ability has been
widely used in many domains. A systematic and reliable evaluation of LLMs is a
crucial step in their development and applications, especially for specific
professional fields. In the urban domain, there have been some early
explorations about the usability of LLMs, but a systematic and scalable
evaluation benchmark is still lacking. The challenge in constructing a
systematic evaluation benchmark for the urban domain lies in the diversity of
data and scenarios, as well as the complex and dynamic nature of cities. In
this paper, we propose CityBench, an interactive simulator based evaluation
platform, as the first systematic evaluation benchmark for the capability of
LLMs for urban domain. First, we build CitySim to integrate the multi-source
data and simulate fine-grained urban dynamics. Based on CitySim, we design 7
tasks in 2 categories of perception-understanding and decision-making group to
evaluate the capability of LLMs as city-scale world model for urban domain. Due
to the flexibility and ease-of-use of CitySim, our evaluation platform
CityBench can be easily extended to any city in the world. We evaluate 13
well-known LLMs including open source LLMs and commercial LLMs in 13 cities
around the world. Extensive experiments demonstrate the scalability and
effectiveness of proposed CityBench and shed lights for the future development
of LLMs in urban domain. The dataset, benchmark and source codes are openly
accessible to the research community via
https://github.com/tsinghua-fib-lab/CityBench | [
-0.0162327662,
0.0416769944,
-0.0196103305,
0.0359249786,
-0.0212135427,
0.0014649401,
0.0264867116,
-0.0033102001,
-0.0086741867,
0.0127618536,
-0.0340134539,
-0.037468195,
0.0231243148,
0.057417497,
0.0299446788,
-0.0589121878,
-0.0043990249,
-0.0570111126,
-0.065036118,
0.018412102,
0.0125295715,
-0.0136610856,
0.0033327686,
0.0555049516,
0.0202818718,
0.0312709399,
-0.0181339309,
0.0099063441,
0.0252376366,
-0.0446542241,
-0.0060673459,
0.0377397723,
0.0893653333,
0.0241670702,
0.0000021987,
-0.0188345648,
-0.0138046313,
-0.0170712695,
0.0516089946,
-0.00099441,
0.0703146234,
0.0229940731,
-0.010195042,
0.0177462045,
-0.019771412,
-0.0378062539,
0.027405126,
-0.0033024384,
0.0471899658,
0.0273085013,
0.0003604867,
-0.0277683344,
-0.0206726957,
-0.0059586861,
-0.0478793681,
-0.0227622837,
0.010062363,
0.0190564785,
0.0410205424,
0.0005085127,
-0.0106373737,
-0.0277756806,
0.0219915248,
-0.0093134176,
-0.0184180308,
0.0436028503,
-0.0333550684,
-0.0080859233,
-0.0060831946,
0.0876396075,
0.0022685598,
-0.0312772579,
0.0475325882,
0.0018223959,
-0.0388334729,
0.0065475875,
-0.0649552941,
-0.0502126925,
0.0233692639,
0.0400643162,
-0.0667005405,
-0.0095847389,
0.0516780205,
0.0271025412,
-0.0362771302,
0.0966180488,
0.0136402175,
-0.018854931,
-0.0221916195,
-0.0187135562,
0.0154390959,
-0.0526170582,
-0.0045359768,
0.0473508127,
-0.0763383135,
-0.0093940897,
0.0167626571,
0.0484897271,
-0.0032734282,
-0.0766254067,
0.0589828901,
-0.0018558602,
-0.0128373643,
0.0623564757,
0.0105371205,
0.0596494563,
0.0012927016,
0.0139437076,
-0.0367439352,
-0.0251045339,
-0.0420452207,
0.0168588515,
-0.0146011245,
-0.0111603569,
-0.0721696094,
-0.0103089837,
0.0030159974,
0.0278232917,
-0.0129013881,
0.0165404119,
-0.0551856831,
0.0037739277,
0.0476589538,
-0.0240742937,
-0.0277846046,
-0.0171553418,
-0.0103199771,
-0.0020110824,
-0.0023081205,
-0.0269435402,
0.0604706891,
0.0128265023,
-0.0070865792,
0.009180354,
-0.0296582468,
0.0637371838,
0.0227484349,
0.0300099775,
-0.0444851853,
0.0093167704,
0.0219158493,
-0.0708157867,
0.0074257385,
-0.1145808473,
-0.0081699835,
0.0058836984,
-0.0218019597,
-0.0239280388,
-0.0140007697,
-0.0464145727,
-0.0147763714,
0.0189927816,
-0.0755648687,
0.0501443483,
0.0613319129,
0.0043625263,
0.0434862189,
0.108680211,
0.0281980857,
0.0570254847,
0.0442969278,
-0.0023099713,
0.01526256,
0.0411648899,
0.0188505296,
0.0664796531,
-0.0464295857,
0.0493838899,
-0.0089541888,
0.0207884293,
-0.0084411129,
0.017152926,
-0.0309810955,
0.031228669,
0.0749114528,
-0.0039855936,
0.0178478248,
-0.013956856,
0.041090712,
0.0548203066,
0.0049300445,
-0.0271537714,
-0.0403951183,
-0.0203473419,
-0.0271161105,
0.0127146924,
-0.0249009524,
0.0557480752,
-0.019261336,
-0.0025503563,
0.0140701253,
-0.0156933777,
0.0310473759,
-0.0064591821,
0.0775500908,
-0.040628016,
-0.0233473685,
0.0366604328,
0.0109311696,
0.0080175241,
0.0091205807,
-0.0637662336,
0.0165466722,
0.0650457218,
0.0133050717,
-0.0197494179,
0.0327676609,
-0.0106186969,
0.0065330998,
0.0471926481,
0.0821626112,
-0.0039621717,
-0.0127682555,
-0.0498954169,
-0.0628878176,
0.0305323768,
0.0217532534,
-0.0243066326,
0.0307334308,
0.0299946014,
0.0444629155,
-0.0649326146,
-0.0362858325,
0.0001747317,
0.0120114293,
0.0164793395,
-0.0494056344,
-0.010922269,
-0.003815786,
-0.0207019299,
-0.0382646956,
0.0001142961,
0.0064431326,
0.0158640184,
-0.0178769007,
0.0231520496,
-0.0154212443,
0.0292827468,
0.0138627989,
-0.0025077423,
-0.0183054712,
0.0688832477,
-0.061017897,
-0.0354451202,
-0.01170801,
-0.0206980612,
0.0317755081,
0.0013477977,
0.0541379414,
-0.0509135127,
0.0044422229,
-0.0304113925,
0.0386594869,
-0.0030197799,
0.0369673148,
0.005206184,
0.0647426322,
0.0249886047,
0.0016258199,
-0.0416576974,
-0.0239914171,
-0.0007025015,
0.0230453145,
-0.0130782649,
0.0241102222,
-0.0333861411,
0.0027545963,
-0.104721956,
-0.014942226,
-0.0041436865,
0.0240042992,
0.0151603697,
-0.0299795195,
-0.0250680726,
0.0077611352,
-0.0127466423,
0.047658585,
-0.0088841589,
0.0050594551,
0.0235275049,
-0.048434373,
-0.0376298539,
-0.018868085,
0.0029285674,
0.0059720189,
0.0531334914,
-0.0113435965,
0.0085223094,
0.0071280557,
-0.0090580191,
-0.0146086738,
0.0044926824,
0.0155784804,
-0.0306387823,
0.0266555641,
0.0163725056,
0.0688218176,
-0.0240426622,
0.0093629174,
-0.0121902935,
0.023153903,
-0.0481408574,
-0.0760396123,
0.0031909314,
-0.0160284042,
0.0319737829,
-0.06565357,
-0.057762824,
-0.0082628997,
0.0482769907,
-0.0203050878,
0.0410303697,
0.0241479594,
0.0266161766,
-0.0598290302,
-0.0211637523,
-0.0722846389,
0.0535496734,
-0.0137185454,
0.074547112,
-0.0477007702,
-0.0581757165,
0.02126812,
-0.0610331595,
0.0139468685,
0.0272382814,
0.0041631684,
-0.0543296784,
0.0559227094,
-0.0117664533,
0.0132534374,
-0.0212060697,
0.0131364251,
0.0077457828,
-0.0398716182,
-0.0259595122,
-0.0211399402,
0.0371309482,
-0.0567687303,
-0.0055576432,
-0.0042524803,
-0.0644586682,
-0.0045255395,
0.0141365128,
-0.0602843054,
0.00815746,
0.0223742425,
-0.0385521129,
0.0139417341,
0.0950768143,
0.0140315853,
0.0598730333,
-0.012788523,
-0.0014103452,
-0.0142710404,
-0.0038232298,
0.0557596721,
0.0883690193,
0.0246606544,
0.0086953575,
-0.0162223894,
0.0116283577,
0.0337082855,
0.0050783763,
-0.0769764036,
0.0193765052,
0.0226165634,
-0.0247579589,
-0.0201118682,
0.0198670272,
0.0032152229,
-0.0484843664,
0.0076982253,
0.0791656002,
0.0079555204,
-0.0068443031,
0.0155582987,
-0.0542229228,
0.0125265103,
0.0319207422,
0.0150207728,
-0.0681887195,
-0.0061657485,
0.0158178043,
-0.017733695,
0.0330877677,
-0.0325439349,
0.0538281165,
-0.0960639715,
0.0808417425,
0.0020529358,
-0.083517842,
-0.0145003302,
-0.0583396181,
0.0075685228,
0.0099129844,
-0.008138177,
-0.0083349878,
0.0242168549,
-0.0380872674,
0.0237536449,
-0.0925534964,
-0.0736995339,
-0.0140303969,
-0.0323079191,
0.0958529636,
0.0399662107,
0.0491210185,
0.0007855459,
-0.0161154065,
0.0325633921,
0.0533894598,
0.0282301884,
-0.0385920517,
-0.0249162372,
0.0295469481,
-0.0084969141,
-0.0026030748,
-0.0433273092,
-0.035627991,
0.0015064772,
0.0554430969,
0.0524084494,
-0.0336964503,
-0.0034110218,
-0.053722728,
0.0126967849,
0.028136665,
0.008002433,
0.0184371863,
-0.0050316858,
-0.0394032262,
-0.0356283709,
-0.0758667737,
-0.0268473197,
-0.0471133776,
0.0058848946,
-0.0053185266,
-0.0022185948,
0.0030799161,
-0.0103738718,
-0.0113214068,
0.0203724876,
-0.0218698829,
0.0000646019,
0.018935794,
-0.0384518914,
-0.0290329065,
-0.0019307273,
-0.0382324494,
0.052111119,
-0.0239225794,
0.0255079903,
0.0371542461,
-0.020424312,
-0.0317039713,
0.0402755775,
-0.0691763833,
-0.049631279,
0.0125084026,
0.0212958194,
0.0243159328,
-0.0236181915,
-0.0401546173,
-0.0108584324,
0.0583330467,
-0.0469180942,
-0.0136764403,
-0.0121278828,
-0.0036895711,
0.0150538795,
0.0230299067,
-0.0050781304,
-0.0520059951,
0.0562577844,
0.0116680702,
0.0084744198,
-0.0263943411,
0.0090148496,
-0.0334807225,
0.0415320173,
0.0476041697,
0.0089293253,
-0.0276399143,
-0.0190648716,
0.0033198397,
-0.0076799993,
-0.0030638918,
-0.0315904953,
0.0063593853,
0.0249348897,
0.0282673426,
0.0060338061,
0.0428301133,
0.0330322385,
-0.0300591644,
-0.0202275235,
0.0120649617,
0.0323736444,
0.0121385707,
0.0330475084,
-0.0008912678,
-0.0032578239,
0.0059866919,
-0.0145829581,
0.0148756737,
0.0228251778,
0.0072064055,
0.0200655852,
-0.0175783075,
0.0089312904,
0.0418682508,
0.0089759696,
-0.0499881506,
-0.0418244004,
0.0857242495,
0.0751602054,
0.0784037635,
0.0290704947,
0.0022317881,
0.0170113742,
-0.0306104925,
-0.0123423366,
0.0284839049,
-0.021099912,
0.0241373107,
0.0114013646,
-0.0696639419,
0.0311454963,
0.0618197136,
0.0377602279,
-0.0058583515,
0.0341054983,
-0.0233327299,
-0.0363434665,
0.0038333335,
0.0166809335,
0.0258773547,
-0.0211667269,
-0.0461419225,
-0.0691013187,
-0.0418124758,
-0.0037847941,
0.0546548031,
-0.0068702982,
-0.0271164086,
0.005601862,
0.0373912305,
0.0009661258,
0.0223577544,
-0.0323724039,
-0.0196583793,
-0.0303847883,
0.0039864453,
0.0207888614,
-6.437511793e-33,
-0.0160198268,
-0.0441939756,
0.0772836059,
-0.0394270644,
-0.0570644513,
-0.0332966447,
-0.0359902866,
-0.0355166979,
-0.0199544281,
-0.0151027245,
0.002944553,
0.0145925283,
0.0158973858,
-0.0171100274,
0.0112993941,
0.0045252019,
0.0385144837,
0.0004331325,
-0.0424429774,
-0.0004691166,
-0.0032875065,
-0.0095362226,
0.008984806,
-0.0754241571,
-0.0079634134,
-0.0563896708,
-0.0533394404,
0.0146069257,
0.0054753884,
0.065895848,
-0.0161302742,
0.0634642839,
0.0280201603,
-0.0493842624,
-0.0546881668,
0.019844899,
-0.0270266403,
0.0011284279,
0.0374220647,
0.0227898844,
-0.0142667321,
-0.0185977872,
0.0171832573,
0.037072964,
-0.0199232176,
0.023312401,
0.0210751425,
-0.0375068821,
-0.0188919678,
-0.0119141378,
-0.0646187663,
0.0537419878,
-0.0141501883,
-0.003670349,
-0.0156305693,
0.0090517644,
-0.010441523,
0.007931551,
-0.035350766,
0.0155395335,
0.0554093085,
0.0040325453,
0.0699851662,
0.0409482606,
0.0129789365,
0.0386548005,
0.0042470358,
-0.0203691721,
-0.0065911766,
-0.0306316558,
0.0855436698,
0.0894936547,
-0.0298959296,
0.0649626255,
-0.0250265673,
-0.0254512671,
-0.0342283696,
0.0158795174,
0.0122270929,
0.0002794581,
0.0306089353,
0.0294491295,
-0.029430531,
-0.0091822967,
-0.0336718597,
-0.0077171214,
-0.0390780158,
-0.041479148,
0.0303489212,
0.0125737181,
-0.0190290809,
0.0361881703,
0.0098528555,
-0.0816391036,
-0.031377919,
-0.0009436827,
-0.0135218939,
0.0138032101,
0.005100213,
0.0512049906,
-0.0896673799,
-0.0708440542,
-0.0156552568,
0.0436207987,
0.0067929742,
0.0230620038,
-0.0434668772,
0.0238722153,
-0.0221101176,
0.0003345709,
-0.0150317559,
-0.0326301865,
0.0014195206,
0.0003819714,
0.0256041754,
-0.0555273406,
-0.009911444,
-0.0222491082,
-0.0098210424,
-0.0179296937,
0.0156411976,
-0.0081678042,
-0.0293002352,
0.0425218605,
0.0260931514,
-0.015373976,
-0.0314225182,
-0.0079795672,
0.0482202396,
-0.0127625046,
-0.0229614321,
0.0127454875,
2.865e-7,
-0.0261589121,
0.0552694239,
-0.0036574716,
0.0161612052,
0.0390476845,
0.0264245104,
-0.0221376419,
0.0143876662,
-0.0138459289,
0.0182733461,
0.0275115091,
0.0402140766,
0.0717825666,
0.0451489389,
-0.0784631371,
0.0569651872,
-0.085892953,
0.001841776,
-0.0821716115,
-0.0013913203,
0.0106070656,
0.0950179026,
0.018208487,
0.0019643647,
0.0304736663,
-0.0078071407,
-0.0151814958,
-0.0884414241,
-0.0412316173,
0.0364313945,
0.0253718663,
0.0184397399,
-0.0012313814,
-0.0144144539,
-0.0000331917,
0.0057617519,
0.0292506032,
0.068252109,
0.0024233109,
0.0139089655,
0.0213552527,
-0.117999807,
0.0161996372,
-0.0798369423,
0.032931339,
-0.0197483394,
0.0120121064,
-0.0173763875,
-0.0240207147,
-0.0512496717,
0.0169705786,
0.0002495165,
-0.007846579,
-0.0154212425,
0.0004437497,
-0.0321379825,
-0.0281428304,
-0.0246748924,
0.0397318639,
0.0081160404,
-0.0280060992,
-0.08162871,
-0.0551699661,
-0.0093714995,
0.0099775679,
-0.021581281,
0.0032292577,
2.145244818e-34,
0.0374760032,
0.0242959987,
-0.0209267028,
0.0020939731,
0.0540671274,
0.0089001926,
-0.0533535443,
0.0141430357,
-0.0420785323,
-0.0387071632,
0.0140824411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13940v1 | AutoCAP: Towards Automatic Cross-lingual Alignment Planning for Zero-shot Chain-of-Thought | 2024-06-20T02:19:33 | 2024-06-20T02:19:33 | Yongheng Zhang, Qiguang Chen, Min Li, Wanxiang Che, Libo Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual chain-of-thought can effectively complete reasoning tasks
across languages, which gains increasing attention. Recently, dominant
approaches in the literature improve cross-lingual alignment capabilities by
integrating reasoning knowledge from different languages. Despite achieving
excellent performance, current methods still have two main challenges: (1)
Manual language specification: They still highly rely on manually selecting the
languages to integrate, severely affecting their generalizability; (2) Static
weight allocation: Current methods simply integrate all languages equally. In
fact, different language reasoning paths should have different weights to
achieve better complementation and integration. Motivated by this, we introduce
an Automatic Cross-lingual Alignment Planning (AutoCAP) for zero-shot
chain-of-thought to address the above challenges. The core of AutoCAP consists
of two components: (1) Automatic Language Selection Prompting to guide LLMs to
select appropriate languages and (2) Automatic Weight Allocation Prompting to
automatically allocate alignment weight scores to each reasoning path.
Extensive experiments on several benchmarks reveal that AutoCAP achieves
state-of-the-art performance, surpassing previous methods that required manual
effort. | [
-0.0046554497,
-0.0075017558,
-0.0058260299,
0.0440722108,
-0.0759653449,
0.0161599386,
0.0110258032,
-0.0497129261,
0.0166903231,
-0.0168097056,
-0.0137926405,
0.0050788331,
0.008559919,
-0.0039105443,
0.0164738689,
0.0013172984,
0.0624880083,
-0.0222378131,
-0.0226024743,
-0.0227719899,
0.007584299,
0.0203423034,
-0.0378044285,
0.0025222863,
0.0011472555,
-0.0306369662,
-0.0431356356,
0.0218703412,
0.0741992295,
-0.0135607887,
-0.0393712781,
0.0455945954,
-0.0041208155,
0.0714788511,
0.0000017691,
-0.0583210513,
-0.0293428898,
-0.0200214945,
-0.028729178,
-0.0574246943,
-0.0275749918,
-0.0413033292,
0.002969248,
-0.0023535672,
-0.022493884,
0.0159538966,
0.0601101704,
0.0116993627,
0.0353102311,
0.0687925965,
-0.0028857952,
-0.0276549645,
-0.0021199733,
0.000091249,
0.0374471471,
-0.047186859,
-0.007539907,
0.0243485365,
0.0065841973,
-0.0223585833,
-0.0080526602,
0.0512541682,
0.0093567157,
-0.0173960384,
-0.0207564048,
-0.0057908148,
-0.0827375352,
-0.02975321,
-0.0162312556,
0.0739179701,
-0.0098554622,
-0.0287020113,
-0.032568194,
-0.017559303,
-0.0049221651,
-0.0366746001,
-0.0393929072,
0.0326692574,
0.0097865611,
0.0182819329,
0.0513707846,
0.0199956484,
0.0164417494,
-0.0013911044,
-0.0403637141,
0.1175684035,
0.0162872318,
-0.020420108,
0.0276028439,
0.0211951863,
0.022801429,
-0.1015528664,
-0.0077299871,
0.0462953113,
-0.0552392341,
0.02443658,
-0.0254528355,
-0.0059463559,
0.0110105127,
-0.0057037403,
0.0260176472,
0.1001971513,
-0.0167570282,
0.0643370971,
-0.0426634662,
0.0455228128,
-0.0246703606,
-0.014220966,
-0.0338114537,
-0.0411301591,
-0.0507230759,
0.0074368459,
-0.0104476642,
0.0432352386,
-0.024358701,
-0.0182733852,
-0.0428867973,
0.0183093529,
-0.0035359911,
0.0531832315,
0.0093404716,
-0.0283143744,
-0.0008538569,
-0.0433624126,
-0.0238665622,
0.0772602633,
-0.0573675409,
-0.0191217568,
0.0107592568,
-0.0139425676,
-0.0269806404,
0.0343235582,
-0.0228159316,
-0.0410500802,
-0.0007422495,
0.0911958814,
-0.0218826234,
0.0097385691,
-0.0210203473,
-0.0474024042,
-0.0162796471,
-0.102948308,
0.0219846088,
-0.08439482,
0.0454929508,
0.012782841,
-0.016770415,
0.0154667655,
0.0126948357,
0.0071595917,
-0.0065018851,
0.0552316606,
0.0063390718,
-0.0080453092,
-0.0167117883,
-0.0209929999,
-0.0197818372,
0.1149142906,
0.0080366181,
0.0188119207,
0.0176531225,
0.0345733911,
-0.0435722098,
0.0410937332,
0.0074936566,
0.001306273,
-0.0117489407,
0.016285602,
0.0119362967,
0.0396649055,
0.0109471111,
-0.0057540219,
-0.0056220856,
0.0222694837,
-0.0019563336,
0.028619729,
0.0299406871,
-0.0083359247,
0.0449385419,
-0.0319239534,
-0.0352448113,
0.0209258515,
-0.0457474142,
0.0712353215,
-0.0636859611,
0.0228466559,
0.0215294715,
0.0642083585,
-0.0277019143,
-0.0175808612,
-0.0207893923,
0.0104690557,
-0.0142937694,
0.0131193008,
0.0327124074,
-0.0098545235,
-0.0173776336,
0.0718994439,
0.0263171643,
-0.0381124616,
-0.0215698257,
0.0225924831,
-0.0008455878,
0.0209628679,
0.0055609825,
-0.0157746039,
-0.0740763545,
0.0108132213,
0.0200984292,
0.0635216609,
0.030969711,
0.0027389913,
-0.0098175174,
-0.0642735139,
-0.043898534,
-0.0008438361,
-0.0212614052,
0.0371201783,
-0.0134429354,
0.0357446186,
-0.0046958737,
-0.0095673716,
0.0303270184,
0.0050880234,
-0.0196056385,
0.0073520308,
0.0045966217,
0.045649372,
0.0178276449,
0.034471672,
0.0164953358,
0.0165148508,
-0.0106405318,
-0.0429460183,
-0.0141337309,
0.0234501045,
-0.0193128698,
-0.0687600672,
0.0798209757,
-0.0579997078,
-0.075967066,
-0.048470404,
-0.0369526036,
-0.0612663701,
0.0116237802,
0.0109402528,
-0.0135415131,
-0.0313288383,
0.0421886817,
0.0121558793,
-0.0354468226,
-0.0402224362,
0.0764931515,
0.0202280786,
0.0252037235,
0.0305386428,
-0.0316659175,
0.0832501128,
-0.0485069416,
-0.0183744598,
0.034632504,
-0.0128039392,
-0.0358645096,
0.0108512715,
0.0263666958,
-0.0526946001,
-0.0008704991,
-0.0731877908,
0.0449487865,
-0.0055106343,
0.0298602507,
0.0112648038,
0.0158443898,
0.0028290064,
0.0108752754,
-0.0668330789,
0.0485388674,
0.0157158878,
0.0141209923,
0.0271344911,
-0.020728454,
-0.001219024,
-0.0123347566,
0.0057732398,
-0.0608343147,
0.0084515326,
-0.0046623605,
-0.0467640013,
-0.0255752001,
0.0136716496,
-0.0952891633,
0.0056107985,
0.0057770042,
-0.0268540308,
0.0027551558,
0.0219227355,
0.0262655206,
0.0323020369,
-0.0629703626,
-0.1026348099,
0.0706758276,
-0.0387717038,
-0.0344528891,
0.0383494645,
0.0215795487,
0.0022844169,
0.0032020775,
-0.0152431475,
-0.0302292481,
0.0583154783,
-0.0300736092,
0.0021672684,
-0.0762605965,
-0.0216563102,
0.0098968614,
-0.012244205,
-0.0189099684,
0.0214016754,
0.0096291574,
0.0966579542,
-0.0355967768,
0.003486099,
0.0982292145,
-0.029422937,
-0.0062679555,
-0.0429784507,
0.0329488367,
-0.0617493987,
0.0222401526,
-0.0117397094,
0.0296140779,
0.0063393791,
-0.0126668038,
-0.0625284761,
-0.0077963425,
0.0437698439,
0.0157289337,
0.0386938043,
-0.040991392,
0.0307749975,
-0.0478422567,
-0.0312477648,
-0.0306658223,
0.0442563929,
-0.0607654117,
0.0227089301,
-0.0378548913,
0.001635779,
-0.0455497131,
0.0182968229,
0.0535697527,
-0.0133639276,
-0.0163630638,
0.0107808225,
-0.0289533567,
0.0118369432,
0.0463037714,
0.003186085,
0.019022543,
0.0211629029,
0.0381507389,
0.0298245419,
0.0247788671,
-0.0071815159,
0.019080149,
0.013442006,
0.0433070995,
-0.0375795104,
-0.0170973875,
-0.0037141722,
0.0382916182,
-0.0210654289,
0.014795444,
0.0930847451,
0.0429018512,
-0.0345292203,
-0.0232700743,
-0.0671938285,
0.0189173296,
0.0432029702,
0.0456651747,
-0.1365965009,
-0.0526529849,
0.0046081068,
-0.0624515861,
-0.0001626461,
-0.0466585159,
-0.0065885712,
-0.1327480823,
0.0235636793,
0.031506218,
-0.0345622599,
-0.0194343086,
-0.0098306965,
0.0089431014,
-0.0064724293,
0.0013790531,
0.004841771,
0.0281442776,
-0.0310847592,
-0.0328741446,
-0.00748089,
-0.0018327347,
0.0192184877,
-0.0375817753,
0.0243312325,
0.0420336686,
0.0187132563,
0.0328435302,
-0.0596671999,
0.030827621,
-0.020634044,
-0.0055922647,
-0.0416352265,
-0.0136978542,
-0.0035155723,
-0.0018404345,
-0.0006976867,
0.0135307498,
-0.0346735828,
-0.0185803734,
0.0201702043,
0.1337482184,
-0.0014433358,
0.0272878967,
-0.0106856823,
0.0397606008,
-0.0028862124,
0.0716494992,
-0.0048468043,
0.0069917403,
-0.0283774193,
-0.0254224055,
-0.0642433688,
-0.065897584,
-0.0195398647,
0.0337763764,
-0.0212177727,
-0.0168525707,
-0.0354384109,
-0.061308369,
0.0564651527,
0.0467963219,
0.006873549,
0.0069066086,
-0.0419146568,
0.0007373156,
-0.0231437869,
-0.0040424527,
-0.0433470681,
0.0131394994,
-0.0108192619,
0.0457955673,
-0.0118786413,
-0.0177314132,
-0.0000432834,
0.0349138565,
-0.032683529,
-0.0901587009,
-0.046511177,
0.0429769866,
0.0249995589,
0.0456091017,
-0.0163881686,
-0.0186235663,
0.0326269306,
0.0031079443,
0.023755094,
0.0007514301,
0.0096350685,
0.0549868532,
0.0160358623,
0.0670421571,
-0.03287521,
-0.0093475617,
-0.002537274,
0.0731655434,
-0.029054936,
-0.0320653357,
0.0189846419,
0.0366244055,
-0.0044058822,
-0.0324835777,
0.005941798,
-0.0056890859,
0.0474764965,
-0.0638688728,
-0.0668964759,
-0.0013387793,
-0.0121566756,
0.0026864777,
-0.0454116724,
0.0432014912,
0.0124110086,
-0.0534786321,
-0.0036504837,
-0.0052910778,
0.0043606116,
0.0268042926,
0.0496332943,
0.0104018776,
0.0001726275,
-0.0130278459,
-0.0047993981,
0.0197230205,
0.0511877649,
-0.0389495715,
0.0565715544,
0.0241397135,
0.017517535,
-0.0409689806,
0.0004069737,
-0.0150565142,
-0.0153998537,
0.0479250215,
-0.0102640046,
0.1062107533,
-0.0110931089,
0.0599341653,
-0.0023594704,
-0.0410229601,
0.0331869498,
0.0354635417,
-0.001710837,
-0.0263073724,
0.0303699635,
0.0257292688,
-0.0094809504,
-0.0295175724,
0.0359897874,
-0.0458921641,
0.016461838,
0.005100592,
0.0012760077,
-0.0313034616,
-0.0272955019,
0.0035180701,
0.0034284601,
-0.0254911408,
-0.0107164001,
-0.0928594172,
-0.0738159642,
0.0186475608,
0.0313787535,
-0.0179396011,
0.0243425183,
0.0226262119,
0.0371543393,
0.0199730136,
-0.0277290009,
0.0175764598,
-0.0062946477,
-0.0266161393,
-0.0334683098,
-0.0113566266,
-5.693563092e-33,
-0.0321643539,
-0.0135440622,
0.0551143214,
0.006531009,
-0.0141658597,
-0.0107311271,
-0.036458075,
0.0067467294,
-0.0366030186,
0.0182435606,
-0.0095173893,
-0.0305913892,
0.0227890685,
-0.0156064462,
0.0327699669,
-0.0217252783,
-0.0143694412,
0.0185976233,
-0.02624809,
-0.0335829183,
0.0373770632,
-0.0081757382,
0.0641487017,
-0.0129178548,
0.0276775453,
0.0173157454,
0.0102454564,
0.0595164858,
0.014138598,
0.0358646251,
0.0133668054,
0.0145339249,
0.0280485023,
0.0045268484,
-0.001619788,
-0.0016487422,
-0.0357717276,
-0.0726147965,
0.0743338019,
0.0040279422,
-0.0160229914,
-0.0470144786,
0.0001453555,
-0.0201565772,
-0.0055685136,
-0.0509946644,
0.0102758734,
-0.0235223472,
-0.0088186543,
-0.0025548972,
-0.0855841637,
0.0086330939,
-0.0098738242,
-0.0072650327,
0.044356253,
0.0768537968,
0.036790356,
0.0139947142,
-0.033498019,
0.0206561666,
-0.0437932238,
0.0085068475,
0.1286246479,
-0.0084907664,
-0.0124136601,
0.0296922643,
0.0095980614,
-0.0168349482,
-0.0073436359,
0.0397993885,
0.0115528312,
0.0156444851,
0.0405942388,
0.0805673599,
0.0138218235,
0.0719117746,
-0.0918409079,
0.0334685594,
0.0219584666,
0.0504989438,
-0.0299544521,
0.021708535,
-0.0120931696,
-0.0025363662,
-0.0086947316,
-0.0307299867,
-0.0445917249,
-0.0423326157,
0.0004730128,
-0.0346735306,
-0.008255979,
0.00389569,
0.062100783,
-0.0089564947,
0.004440567,
0.0211636648,
0.0035063333,
0.0111664068,
0.0015386657,
0.0498234183,
-0.0359425582,
-0.015611236,
-0.0281658601,
0.0121359834,
0.0337979011,
0.0062789107,
0.0404812619,
-0.014946498,
-0.024224259,
-0.002013609,
-0.0661204606,
-0.0004913862,
-0.0316508338,
0.0229489002,
0.0290248264,
0.0137502337,
0.0055346349,
0.0182021428,
0.0245876387,
-0.0519712009,
-0.0081548067,
0.02106601,
0.0030475112,
0.0191655084,
-0.0173120331,
0.0363508798,
0.0013860508,
0.0158018284,
0.0203484502,
-0.0272564366,
-0.0140521564,
0.050268244,
2.513e-7,
0.0452195071,
0.0092004128,
0.0237762667,
0.0401128158,
-0.0255822744,
0.0300719533,
-0.0376018435,
-0.0045497096,
0.0222828202,
-0.0438456647,
0.0093752192,
0.0381382443,
0.0471140407,
0.0447424352,
-0.0804167539,
-0.0017932849,
0.0298328009,
-0.0203546192,
-0.0420840271,
0.0141266473,
0.0406198576,
0.0411630496,
-0.0131155849,
0.0019734572,
0.0048471512,
0.0000074008,
0.0311904531,
0.0043590893,
-0.0296651404,
0.0162246153,
-0.0078277513,
-0.0279645361,
-0.0148903774,
0.0351384245,
0.0056807953,
0.0505756922,
-0.013360315,
0.0317533538,
-0.020916339,
-0.0540899634,
-0.0165964551,
-0.0288824998,
0.0054267719,
-0.0330311656,
0.0749630406,
-0.0188221019,
-0.0254537053,
0.0098625785,
-0.0273786038,
0.0145541811,
0.0362788253,
0.0229313746,
-0.0184236895,
0.0437179506,
0.0473930351,
-0.0004030891,
-0.0265755355,
-0.0425821692,
-0.0459688641,
0.0215768628,
-0.0134255476,
-0.0078103584,
0.0013567348,
-0.0114788311,
0.0023085361,
-0.0628760904,
-0.0289137363,
2.288871631e-34,
0.0100712944,
-0.0331234932,
0.0407289714,
0.0200537723,
0.0228416845,
-0.0164015088,
-0.075426273,
0.0269662496,
0.0135149388,
-0.058372397,
-0.0324368067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13934v1 | Reasoning Like a Doctor: Improving Medical Dialogue Systems via Diagnostic Reasoning Process Alignment | 2024-06-20T02:02:53 | 2024-06-20T02:02:53 | Kaishuai Xu, Yi Cheng, Wenjun Hou, Qiaoyu Tan, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical dialogue systems have attracted significant attention for their
potential to act as medical assistants. Enabling these medical systems to
emulate clinicians' diagnostic reasoning process has been the long-standing
research focus. Previous studies rudimentarily realized the simulation of
clinicians' diagnostic process by fine-tuning language models on high-quality
dialogue datasets. Nonetheless, they overly focus on the outcomes of the
clinician's reasoning process while ignoring their internal thought processes
and alignment with clinician preferences. Our work aims to build a medical
dialogue system that aligns with clinicians' diagnostic reasoning processes. We
propose a novel framework, Emulation, designed to generate an appropriate
response that relies on abductive and deductive diagnostic reasoning analyses
and aligns with clinician preferences through thought process modeling.
Experimental results on two datasets confirm the efficacy of Emulation.
Crucially, our framework furnishes clear explanations for the generated
responses, enhancing its transparency in medical consultations. | [
0.0842937902,
0.0206536353,
-0.0199604984,
0.0108798146,
-0.0293476637,
0.0175568014,
-0.010803462,
0.0077146385,
0.0058076079,
0.0082534077,
0.0138791129,
-0.0147201214,
0.0097326329,
0.0199559573,
-0.0062277121,
-0.0542502813,
0.0053485385,
0.0046472806,
0.0724993795,
0.0093298312,
0.0170717817,
0.0386856608,
-0.0797183812,
0.0491215102,
0.0176970307,
-0.0429127589,
-0.0131229786,
0.0114857173,
0.0195172951,
-0.0656325147,
-0.0138401967,
0.0146191232,
-0.0289765187,
-0.0229273997,
0.0000020589,
-0.0547185801,
0.0243901256,
-0.0030512628,
-0.0553807281,
-0.0525219664,
0.0061755273,
0.0123848096,
0.0194227528,
0.052121181,
-0.0411543958,
-0.0262714103,
0.0348595977,
0.0389620624,
0.0760668442,
0.0350314081,
-0.0246495344,
-0.0098835547,
-0.0033050687,
0.0176596958,
-0.0073469309,
-0.0361979157,
0.0133019909,
0.0600194782,
0.068176344,
-0.0111823119,
0.0439627133,
0.0038877157,
-0.0169064812,
-0.0074788677,
-0.0377377979,
0.0041766907,
0.0052704862,
-0.0293667093,
0.0094568264,
0.0636016577,
0.071436204,
-0.0049671563,
0.0199761707,
-0.009286806,
0.0170850512,
-0.0200266242,
-0.0339695401,
-0.0128009552,
-0.0611215942,
-0.0081785619,
0.0266714804,
0.011063626,
0.0113477837,
0.0012346214,
-0.0133492332,
0.0012622026,
-0.0106965248,
-0.0241629556,
-0.0207165759,
-0.0353981145,
0.0036477223,
-0.0609983802,
0.0242293198,
0.060978245,
-0.0955057889,
0.0105452342,
0.0116959717,
0.0008614524,
0.0611917637,
-0.0045530843,
0.0345405713,
0.0453228541,
0.0292241536,
0.0143802837,
0.0256935023,
-0.0179128051,
-0.0315281823,
0.0452069268,
-0.0486331731,
-0.0014440147,
-0.0558532402,
-0.0424104556,
-0.0265481714,
0.002623169,
0.0101290671,
0.0214132797,
-0.0343606956,
0.007314756,
-0.0237269495,
0.0167518202,
0.001952022,
0.0382209755,
-0.0038457462,
0.0027529185,
-0.0777387023,
0.0261728168,
-0.0311926063,
0.0308194291,
0.0327273421,
-0.0334516093,
0.0007938817,
0.0058579189,
0.0051663551,
0.018435644,
0.0055675479,
0.0494193695,
-0.0140344938,
0.0564564168,
0.0074590459,
-0.0698245764,
-0.0076004448,
-0.0315184258,
0.0002615663,
-0.0381695032,
0.025876496,
0.0503200814,
-0.0162427407,
-0.0389416255,
0.0244363975,
0.024144752,
-0.0342267379,
0.072208941,
-0.0720313713,
0.0362960882,
0.0328050815,
0.0376007296,
-0.0022967912,
0.0054303324,
0.0140959816,
-0.0620089956,
-0.0068874871,
-0.0338339284,
0.0403991491,
-0.0229518693,
0.0250940174,
-0.0379729979,
0.0029573697,
0.0593566634,
-0.0397707485,
0.0989291966,
-0.0399882533,
0.0360668153,
-0.0219037198,
0.0140146157,
0.023603607,
0.0707537532,
-0.0160911214,
0.0018415553,
0.0138007198,
-0.0375244617,
-0.0121070175,
0.0134623479,
0.0215631854,
0.0080401851,
0.0506885014,
-0.0040711351,
-0.0200350191,
-0.0267658606,
-0.0315192305,
-0.0524226427,
-0.0501637608,
0.0088408133,
-0.0115225296,
0.0021994112,
-0.0337971151,
0.0044608279,
-0.0152349016,
0.087336503,
0.0150268031,
-0.0327174626,
-0.0704681277,
-0.0844179839,
0.0191380922,
0.0856896713,
0.0647743568,
-0.0330878384,
-0.057366915,
-0.0341709182,
0.0168402828,
0.0113297813,
0.0494215973,
-0.0343385153,
-0.0153713645,
-0.0523677357,
-0.0135363704,
0.0241070241,
0.0155073423,
-0.0327054895,
-0.0407001451,
0.0122361938,
-0.0212326813,
0.0019109976,
-0.0018961546,
0.0299604796,
-0.0332842693,
-0.0057713375,
-0.0017704981,
0.0003874898,
0.0452432148,
0.029238997,
0.008699364,
0.0586902723,
0.0189350564,
0.0052167592,
-0.0093518225,
0.0620002784,
-0.0382710025,
-0.0367971882,
-0.0008978798,
-0.0089465789,
-0.0345714502,
-0.0324338824,
-0.0374204628,
-0.0310613457,
-0.008037637,
-0.0620307028,
0.0145678641,
0.001230623,
0.0097992234,
0.0505706556,
-0.0278677493,
-0.0359018967,
-0.0076475875,
-0.009432368,
0.0146324653,
0.0306783877,
-0.0155192614,
0.0166043658,
-0.0628098398,
0.0357533395,
0.0236052256,
-0.008024212,
0.0067693177,
-0.0323731378,
-0.0007208356,
-0.0394103825,
-0.0050454843,
-0.1321920753,
-0.0369804353,
0.0031541081,
-0.0140055912,
0.0179341584,
0.0322868042,
0.0069771516,
-0.0198878031,
-0.0363486856,
-0.0083499718,
0.0524552353,
0.0167701449,
0.0516984574,
0.0298792124,
-0.0063585653,
-0.0032526939,
0.0095195351,
-0.0456286967,
0.0095472066,
-0.0186526459,
0.0553332753,
-0.0339478254,
-0.0404895693,
-0.0679672211,
-0.0039887633,
-0.0018347275,
-0.0416049846,
0.0495588146,
-0.0107023641,
-0.0483984947,
0.0513169654,
0.0096653765,
0.0043945075,
-0.0086089494,
-0.0076439134,
-0.0587511398,
0.0297337435,
-0.0292695947,
-0.0009770549,
0.0063781519,
-0.0524330959,
-0.0254957285,
0.0728413314,
0.0162294824,
0.0277373232,
-0.02296363,
0.0510420054,
0.0081551159,
0.0206427705,
-0.0200841334,
-0.0232073404,
-0.0191816017,
0.0728687346,
-0.0015579963,
-0.0053288257,
0.1121127233,
0.0029013336,
0.0094550997,
-0.0811533034,
-0.0137310019,
-0.0461475998,
0.0210850239,
-0.0557587706,
0.0027338879,
0.046887476,
-0.00304372,
0.0023633144,
-0.0170102324,
0.031591706,
-0.063589707,
0.0448953286,
-0.0527928099,
0.0156933535,
0.0177645311,
-0.0430293418,
-0.0595548302,
-0.0070173764,
-0.0410169363,
-0.0124497311,
-0.0076402887,
0.0170216635,
-0.0541305579,
0.0103813922,
0.004144182,
0.062878266,
0.0369316973,
-0.0179937445,
-0.009820045,
-0.020032255,
0.0020047373,
0.0233390573,
-0.0068595596,
0.0135099608,
0.0546705425,
0.0440632701,
0.0101207839,
0.0007699605,
-0.0100422101,
-0.0258712284,
-0.0165518709,
0.0085967788,
0.0077934996,
-0.0011746838,
0.0297369976,
-0.0428535417,
-0.0227217581,
0.0909697637,
0.0371349901,
-0.0003358687,
0.032072816,
-0.0469609648,
-0.0027453646,
-0.0096659996,
0.0038153138,
-0.0689262897,
-0.0509791635,
-0.0106624477,
0.0321154818,
-0.0393947065,
-0.0234076101,
0.0127251567,
-0.0360134803,
0.0317107327,
-0.0114761898,
0.0333048925,
-0.0178333335,
-0.0038853546,
0.021325076,
-0.0015151863,
-0.026894344,
-0.0089177657,
0.0319982693,
-0.0000574319,
-0.0012168363,
-0.0520127602,
-0.0372050926,
0.0376100615,
0.0200278331,
0.0264878869,
0.055419825,
0.0564564466,
0.0401410945,
-0.0676040202,
-0.0260004885,
0.0140430769,
0.0233146511,
-0.0044296975,
0.0402434543,
0.0338500962,
0.0156159075,
-0.0483493358,
0.0424028039,
-0.0528454781,
-0.0264816154,
0.0222167354,
0.0768565461,
-0.0695908517,
-0.0061612823,
-0.0529376268,
0.0534635484,
0.0550321825,
0.0420974791,
0.0181579515,
0.0091372943,
-0.0212806221,
0.026722189,
0.0096962526,
0.0120791467,
-0.0168467835,
0.0139177945,
0.0379355215,
0.0271513909,
-0.0263883825,
-0.0534639545,
0.018683454,
-0.0071826065,
-0.0008456793,
0.0004313348,
-0.0032411751,
0.0274876412,
-0.0325404294,
0.0408337489,
0.0508043915,
0.0354902372,
0.0143776219,
-0.0192380212,
0.0469939522,
0.010000811,
-0.0102907335,
0.0291633885,
0.0257676132,
-0.004991434,
-0.0233505294,
0.0505718589,
0.0303888433,
0.0002543196,
-0.0049395389,
-0.0211846009,
-0.0181815736,
0.001919808,
-0.0223161411,
-0.0475878231,
0.0162610542,
0.0343999639,
0.0033496306,
0.0236139335,
0.0182347205,
0.0204375964,
-0.0094407275,
0.0348334871,
-0.0359184705,
-0.0459888987,
0.0311493333,
0.0171585418,
0.0209366363,
0.0157873388,
-0.0221184678,
-0.0142839486,
0.0490218215,
-0.0449099429,
-0.0265981797,
-0.0100361314,
0.0017841229,
-0.0191631988,
-0.0455061644,
0.00826908,
-0.0659288988,
-0.1048887819,
-0.0227755811,
-0.0024493993,
0.0321534127,
0.0257208738,
-0.0155005176,
0.0299852584,
-0.0319534019,
-0.0071470542,
0.0216508824,
0.0056581241,
0.0450218245,
0.0076773711,
0.1187658831,
0.0216789693,
0.0170117337,
0.0190517884,
0.0211837422,
-0.0386630334,
-0.1015979424,
0.0121743018,
0.0149915712,
-0.0119660217,
0.0228582434,
-0.0131560871,
-0.0167101063,
0.0143066822,
0.0140328063,
0.0420835204,
0.0180728734,
-0.0085413419,
0.0617783107,
0.0257832687,
-0.0076721502,
-0.0519356951,
0.0395697393,
-0.0798475668,
0.0078764716,
-0.0365500003,
-0.0374048986,
-0.0709682405,
-0.0392914936,
-0.0030001202,
0.042512197,
-0.0258797444,
0.0177711211,
-0.094800368,
-0.0444680527,
-0.0305838771,
-0.0076072281,
-0.0222721826,
-0.0443299077,
0.0450359471,
0.0466233492,
0.0233449638,
-0.0254610572,
0.0019133876,
0.0704425275,
-0.0869505852,
-0.0110615818,
-0.0627370849,
-5.418749043e-33,
0.0003089039,
-0.0407840647,
0.0532425642,
-0.0149141988,
0.0054092235,
-0.0209561829,
-0.0364368893,
0.0179943014,
-0.0121711055,
0.0620026067,
-0.0348099172,
0.0212712642,
-0.0058302707,
0.0402532294,
-0.0076164659,
-0.0334198065,
0.0325581096,
0.0169721246,
-0.0388027951,
0.0285151824,
0.0008687384,
-0.0006754542,
-0.0219789222,
-0.0915986076,
0.0048261187,
-0.009163118,
0.015574594,
0.031917613,
-0.0520013832,
0.0570905767,
0.0007057023,
0.0221616067,
0.0446988866,
0.0164868981,
0.0122469747,
0.0234407373,
-0.0177807417,
-0.0305678491,
0.040555127,
-0.0139722871,
-0.0745475441,
-0.0128989397,
-0.0073278733,
-0.0062452662,
-0.0063245436,
-0.008574781,
0.0051571848,
-0.0284494273,
0.0155512476,
0.0159478988,
-0.0311484989,
0.0308457669,
-0.0398714542,
-0.0511689223,
-0.0146879312,
0.045857124,
-0.0382211469,
-0.0245860349,
-0.0129817585,
0.0018152049,
0.028878063,
-0.0260926764,
0.0261033885,
-0.0117442077,
-0.0346647911,
0.0360011607,
0.010604566,
-0.01445569,
-0.0785514638,
0.0032617,
-0.0797083601,
0.0644844472,
0.0539014004,
0.013960056,
-0.0243158527,
0.0067862421,
-0.0516934283,
0.0098395776,
-0.0502264313,
0.0586502068,
0.0463413335,
-0.0062050228,
-0.0609353557,
-0.0109248804,
-0.0509079657,
-0.0214652307,
-0.0329058468,
-0.0250566546,
0.0333473645,
0.001829945,
-0.0208438914,
0.0007849297,
0.0056430465,
0.0065677762,
0.0245304387,
-0.0326698273,
0.0207842402,
-0.022565065,
-0.0382497981,
-0.0203597117,
-0.0385062918,
0.0003298997,
0.0112298643,
0.014732874,
0.0600648113,
0.0473182872,
0.0089412695,
-0.0800903738,
-0.0131175956,
-0.0063111386,
-0.0164070223,
0.055466231,
-0.0742411092,
0.0131325806,
0.0138721913,
0.0543412529,
-0.0285421312,
0.0390926227,
-0.0034027768,
-0.0096445456,
-0.0662227124,
-0.0333653726,
-0.0139140468,
-0.0009075626,
-0.0464761928,
-0.0112090707,
-0.0167962238,
0.0033107069,
0.0251537003,
-0.023147935,
-0.0005321623,
0.0093816919,
2.754e-7,
0.0583066233,
0.0231995713,
0.0304483566,
0.0106066419,
0.0661606491,
0.0573283844,
0.011054297,
0.0060677473,
0.0480248481,
-0.0847680792,
0.0180677753,
0.008744467,
0.0467335545,
0.0438145325,
-0.0434747264,
-0.0456660874,
-0.0564169548,
-0.0139014022,
-0.0264750831,
-0.0131883556,
0.0887764245,
0.023221815,
-0.0327425227,
-0.0160762388,
0.0106997751,
0.0355113074,
0.0322657265,
-0.0143109085,
0.0263241641,
0.052114144,
0.0412848331,
-0.0437457487,
0.0404887013,
0.0803722739,
-0.0145006739,
-0.021216698,
-0.0199146252,
0.0708531365,
-0.0776946917,
-0.0254278183,
-0.0174872223,
-0.0140506597,
0.0513482317,
-0.0558937527,
0.0206130929,
-0.0934710503,
-0.0568892621,
0.0031499022,
0.0019652974,
-0.0208554845,
0.0508022085,
-0.0140056303,
-0.0445828401,
0.0438154303,
0.0179453269,
0.0342104807,
0.0046664346,
-0.0636368841,
-0.0189958811,
0.0093429415,
-0.0318932794,
-0.0328723863,
0.0521953627,
-0.0347912684,
0.020525679,
-0.0658643097,
0.0168559421,
2.215630757e-34,
0.0295247976,
0.0464912504,
0.0280155502,
0.0482722409,
0.060111545,
-0.0022065241,
0.067684114,
0.0435300693,
0.053925585,
-0.048556257,
-0.0148917707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13929v1 | Large Language Models are Skeptics: False Negative Problem of Input-conflicting Hallucination | 2024-06-20T01:53:25 | 2024-06-20T01:53:25 | Jongyoon Song, Sangwon Yu, Sungroh Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we identify a new category of bias that induces
input-conflicting hallucinations, where large language models (LLMs) generate
responses inconsistent with the content of the input context. This issue we
have termed the false negative problem refers to the phenomenon where LLMs are
predisposed to return negative judgments when assessing the correctness of a
statement given the context. In experiments involving pairs of statements that
contain the same information but have contradictory factual directions, we
observe that LLMs exhibit a bias toward false negatives. Specifically, the
model presents greater overconfidence when responding with False. Furthermore,
we analyze the relationship between the false negative problem and context and
query rewriting and observe that both effectively tackle false negatives in
LLMs. | [
0.021827748,
0.0307782404,
-0.0350984782,
0.019840423,
-0.0615703873,
0.0148946103,
-0.0127527053,
0.0031496361,
-0.0050779092,
-0.0474315137,
-0.0470085591,
-0.048494231,
0.0133555448,
-0.0009660856,
0.0403252691,
0.0013267387,
0.0661231056,
-0.0265342537,
0.0311969072,
-0.0473553613,
-0.0189970732,
-0.0287712608,
-0.0047746338,
-0.0182986427,
-0.0123381596,
-0.0147834178,
-0.0001372509,
0.0197444335,
-0.0527044684,
-0.0349462554,
-0.0422546864,
0.0601906367,
-0.0195905827,
0.0902486145,
0.0000017815,
-0.0508952178,
-0.0093469759,
-0.0122718904,
-0.027855888,
0.0388437323,
0.0247674305,
0.0127118714,
0.0260262378,
0.0106869889,
-0.001205174,
-0.0220108926,
0.0375183299,
0.1182117239,
0.0379002839,
0.0711309314,
0.0196701139,
0.0013401873,
0.0032862811,
-0.0075675366,
0.0448495746,
-0.0120736426,
0.0558186136,
0.0210970063,
-0.0332668573,
-0.0027193325,
-0.0239282306,
0.0154193211,
-0.0076079411,
0.0400453433,
-0.0436929092,
0.0166787561,
-0.0745385215,
-0.0267339256,
0.0260989051,
0.0014616201,
0.0099352784,
-0.0601457506,
-0.0042897565,
-0.000439766,
0.0072300765,
0.0416321494,
-0.0503726527,
0.0420570262,
-0.0129799545,
-0.0202218965,
0.0010146694,
0.0012326044,
0.0320151225,
-0.0090242773,
-0.0389871411,
0.0937342569,
0.0109508643,
-0.0724222735,
0.0196709316,
0.01176007,
0.0076940176,
-0.061512921,
-0.0285894945,
-0.0049669277,
-0.0387684479,
0.0207028706,
-0.0015757582,
0.0174408592,
0.0416100398,
-0.0884735137,
-0.0189727005,
0.0008440974,
-0.0278116949,
0.0390876345,
-0.0269787144,
0.0282050371,
-0.0570034385,
0.0546127744,
0.0142992027,
0.0146153513,
0.0105052562,
-0.0454036966,
-0.0080251917,
0.0305525567,
0.0052406359,
-0.0008480591,
-0.0077544209,
-0.0063788998,
-0.0448023044,
0.0084573748,
-0.0610841699,
0.0257372204,
0.0057691019,
-0.0528505296,
-0.0602059886,
0.0526186377,
-0.0003592105,
0.0386587232,
-0.036622569,
-0.0742556751,
-0.0162323825,
0.0064764787,
-0.0230842102,
-0.0073547652,
-0.0198116917,
0.0261790715,
0.0125059625,
0.0040062177,
-0.0249271132,
-0.0190361589,
-0.0264786612,
-0.0467980206,
0.0165919308,
-0.0472531989,
0.0029241075,
0.0269568563,
0.0006419515,
-0.0411886163,
0.0144470287,
0.002464802,
-0.055684112,
0.0633148849,
0.0314983502,
0.0262012016,
0.0486601815,
0.029938275,
-0.014470771,
0.056755729,
-0.0142944325,
0.0136603452,
-0.0010687973,
0.0163331199,
0.0678097382,
-0.0068614306,
0.0215193257,
0.0410397574,
-0.0565146282,
0.0220639259,
0.0217152275,
0.0209397748,
0.0030469198,
0.0797590613,
-0.0320181176,
-0.0176254902,
0.079225637,
-0.0163880773,
-0.0239836685,
-0.0240242518,
-0.0155858407,
-0.0021814264,
-0.0039124368,
0.0325177535,
-0.0801907331,
0.0340227932,
-0.0375879928,
0.0029591739,
0.036861252,
-0.051035963,
-0.0216506682,
-0.0190829709,
-0.0158975963,
0.0118201654,
-0.0147372987,
0.027432749,
0.0220043659,
-0.026921859,
-0.0640028417,
0.0057529001,
0.0005848118,
-0.0140726371,
0.0082466006,
-0.0498587191,
0.0225016456,
0.0130754365,
0.0181291886,
-0.0052951244,
0.0102918455,
-0.025378149,
-0.0141369924,
0.0424060114,
0.0903173536,
0.0234979559,
-0.0529195219,
0.0001147479,
0.0040355395,
-0.0206497051,
0.0429724194,
-0.0233984757,
-0.0273234528,
0.0185153745,
0.0069180848,
0.0169687197,
-0.02669953,
0.0373363271,
-0.0019157558,
-0.0457466356,
-0.0616957024,
-0.0206839722,
0.00689983,
-0.0223750584,
-0.0107035097,
0.0730529577,
0.0240119398,
0.0082607092,
-0.0636232272,
-0.0115647623,
-0.0428739637,
-0.0179132037,
0.0187389869,
-0.0256857574,
0.0073450184,
-0.0262921266,
0.0266788378,
-0.0277835485,
0.01430362,
-0.039930366,
0.0606172606,
0.0016874116,
0.0678685084,
-0.0451907776,
0.0057434873,
-0.041573748,
0.0598378889,
-0.0226127505,
0.0383371189,
0.000298095,
-0.0037660387,
-0.0212449431,
-0.0046235402,
-0.0270270966,
0.0126013113,
0.0174946859,
-0.0021838371,
0.0074248631,
-0.0974957123,
-0.0627139136,
-0.0182820726,
-0.0405123457,
-0.0067599537,
0.0115439342,
-0.0098315561,
0.0436860099,
-0.0555391721,
-0.0136662172,
0.0128140766,
0.0066609853,
-0.0032676484,
0.0206832848,
0.0792120397,
0.0020431958,
-0.0016157624,
0.0031746493,
-0.0143985404,
-0.0015152174,
-0.0456695072,
0.0463293642,
-0.0081667658,
-0.033889614,
-0.0791124701,
0.0826871321,
-0.0528355427,
0.0235248823,
-0.0179222003,
0.0116294054,
0.0238107871,
0.0120526487,
0.0261292383,
0.0628464445,
0.0169438794,
-0.0164631978,
0.103251189,
-0.0000848993,
-0.0185204018,
-0.0306123663,
0.0036317536,
-0.0219240356,
0.0043901238,
-0.0737793669,
-0.0047359746,
0.0362549163,
0.0575406775,
0.0060230959,
-0.0449784957,
0.0596472658,
-0.0761495382,
-0.0668195859,
0.020379113,
-0.0611374825,
-0.0243728459,
0.0804717913,
-0.0217269231,
-0.0346731767,
0.0819669887,
0.0014938154,
0.0004793883,
-0.0126232998,
0.064929828,
0.0186178181,
0.0315317772,
0.0151018444,
0.005054493,
0.0339818373,
0.0100045158,
-0.0747315139,
-0.0578126609,
-0.0163734443,
-0.0576467738,
0.0301357936,
-0.0262659006,
-0.0215330496,
0.0035013095,
-0.0172806624,
-0.0587658435,
-0.041057799,
-0.0276741255,
-0.0384588875,
-0.0344371237,
0.022300059,
-0.041967947,
-0.0036493845,
0.0444886424,
-0.0060293712,
-0.0296174549,
-0.0380680747,
0.0069930018,
-0.0257236827,
0.0372727849,
-0.0072294404,
0.107629925,
-0.0366717353,
0.0106248846,
0.0375280008,
0.0356434546,
0.0396136343,
0.0092934892,
-0.0370907485,
0.0045684543,
0.0095633091,
-0.0291840415,
0.0458037928,
0.0197530221,
-0.0217953138,
0.0000200639,
0.0902989954,
0.0426070429,
-0.0131334551,
0.0101141753,
-0.086580582,
0.024435943,
0.0512674153,
-0.016352769,
-0.0535027832,
0.0102688102,
0.0041792477,
-0.0137424693,
-0.0538654253,
-0.0266848318,
-0.0274376739,
-0.1307197213,
-0.003889303,
0.021554077,
0.013343811,
-0.0102813644,
-0.0327760875,
0.0142646171,
0.009560761,
0.0262966156,
0.0567805581,
-0.0083267698,
-0.0161073059,
-0.0077936566,
0.0349067859,
-0.0087202592,
0.0097836871,
-0.0062933643,
0.0736414418,
0.0163744874,
0.0094325328,
-0.0234552734,
-0.0323762372,
0.0308763161,
-0.0247844718,
-0.0067663984,
-0.0100412508,
0.0202915743,
0.0143764829,
0.0238629114,
-0.0329866745,
-0.0227199849,
-0.0223239381,
-0.0022358103,
-0.0008303404,
0.068843402,
-0.0293529611,
-0.0688596368,
0.0028605771,
0.0306355022,
-0.0035393008,
0.0750612319,
0.0028458417,
0.0122976387,
-0.0398020558,
-0.0201695096,
0.0053927228,
0.0583025664,
-0.0430109315,
0.0379184932,
0.0612508766,
0.0149373151,
-0.0562311932,
-0.0370928049,
-0.0090143047,
0.0089137992,
0.0066714757,
0.0374985971,
0.0073450948,
-0.0265393611,
-0.0131857852,
0.0015211231,
-0.0168228429,
0.0226391833,
-0.0251908265,
0.044284068,
0.0230118986,
-0.0195886958,
0.012265332,
0.0161976013,
-0.0584878139,
-0.0751678422,
0.0445830524,
0.0049088462,
0.0348158143,
0.0043932423,
0.0135534815,
-0.037598405,
-0.0174650513,
0.0349409655,
-0.0322540775,
0.057290256,
0.0361439846,
0.026216507,
0.012059398,
0.0398595892,
-0.0031366472,
-0.0088145817,
0.0318941101,
0.0094492687,
-0.0343689919,
-0.0193208437,
0.0603651814,
0.0249012802,
0.0644389391,
0.029587552,
0.0446958579,
0.0092733232,
-0.0003183155,
-0.0400959849,
-0.0476626568,
0.0509134643,
-0.049175825,
0.0299892798,
0.0034080104,
-0.0010584844,
-0.0167880729,
-0.0190680306,
0.0242373496,
-0.0030672094,
-0.0089541944,
0.0402595922,
-0.0028263433,
0.0370672084,
-0.0093839066,
-0.0257220045,
0.0376361199,
-0.0018926449,
0.042131044,
0.0184952207,
0.0629494861,
0.0047781551,
-0.0069307117,
-0.0530499443,
-0.0389688089,
-0.0819512531,
-0.0765169561,
0.0588913783,
0.0136560015,
-0.0316431709,
-0.0086695775,
0.0412717238,
-0.0321888402,
0.0144273723,
-0.0207748394,
-0.031969104,
0.0211468954,
-0.0085287867,
0.0463880673,
0.0134100858,
-0.0133576635,
0.0024562066,
0.0766811892,
-0.0144834165,
0.0526607372,
-0.024698114,
-0.0205358509,
-0.0192940682,
-0.050505273,
-0.0008695465,
0.0113565372,
-0.0246037524,
0.0030357048,
-0.0855910853,
-0.0445636958,
-0.0052112876,
-0.0020904881,
0.0489778444,
-0.0675378889,
-0.0169658009,
0.0940264985,
0.0053612785,
-0.0321045667,
-0.008042925,
0.0431896821,
0.039261099,
0.0188366026,
-0.0615709648,
-6.258630205e-33,
-0.003299356,
-0.0280332752,
0.0087744584,
-0.056063354,
-0.0203913078,
-0.0164080784,
0.0107189314,
0.0482399091,
-0.0369807854,
0.0043066856,
-0.0245949291,
0.0443043672,
0.0152577674,
-0.0073907608,
0.0125051988,
-0.0214142483,
0.0538452901,
0.0240455959,
-0.0263962038,
-0.0267554186,
0.0479828119,
-0.0152812926,
0.0309734382,
-0.0890665054,
0.0646609068,
-0.0494938642,
0.0000503265,
0.0142721087,
-0.0318516083,
-0.0109040653,
-0.0199190229,
0.0286008976,
0.0261593573,
-0.0427253284,
-0.0048394199,
0.0023468039,
0.0536179952,
-0.0235099979,
0.0483923815,
0.026602285,
0.0282362141,
0.0104975924,
0.0217561033,
-0.0207722746,
-0.0566174723,
0.028449228,
-0.0175043736,
-0.0273691323,
-0.0150990123,
0.0604206584,
-0.0815185532,
-0.0008608548,
0.0377641357,
0.0067521851,
-0.0150273247,
0.0486902669,
-0.0100110453,
0.0000023688,
-0.0616863631,
0.0389698446,
0.006919242,
0.0150116496,
0.0408168472,
0.025550276,
0.0117523903,
0.0521660112,
0.0679294318,
0.0723831132,
-0.0391377173,
-0.0282778479,
-0.004676078,
0.0116010951,
0.0493572243,
0.0632017776,
0.0373513252,
-0.0232355278,
-0.0240784232,
-0.0495928302,
-0.0148834828,
0.0122277318,
0.0830768794,
0.0159977302,
-0.0369931236,
-0.0508321561,
-0.0493068099,
-0.0058812769,
-0.0475881472,
0.0125922393,
0.011029345,
0.0064246808,
0.0007329271,
0.0004221442,
0.0144641139,
-0.0303813778,
-0.0174873676,
0.0106278872,
-0.0238707457,
-0.0096801342,
-0.0117096463,
0.0302230138,
-0.0248544514,
0.0006588507,
0.0053975498,
0.0306460597,
0.0032412801,
0.0225082561,
0.0175522603,
-0.0213327836,
-0.0800210983,
-0.003425912,
-0.0189284254,
-0.0031915994,
0.0433348641,
-0.0591325164,
0.0710019767,
0.0155448206,
-0.0211431962,
-0.0320806801,
0.0359557308,
-0.0312815011,
-0.0355497003,
0.0453169942,
-0.0470845588,
0.0256863032,
-0.0192480218,
-0.0278535075,
-0.0521102287,
0.0256395116,
0.0364424586,
-0.0856054351,
-0.035001155,
-0.010338109,
2.638e-7,
0.0024837635,
0.0788842738,
-0.0184951294,
0.0333282687,
0.0353768878,
0.0502744131,
-0.011198353,
-0.0012451409,
0.0552150793,
-0.0592501499,
-0.0199628547,
-0.0104650343,
-0.0087206578,
0.0227594264,
0.0035535034,
-0.0284029935,
-0.0530148298,
0.0261137541,
-0.0354070701,
0.0109937433,
0.0387442708,
0.0601704679,
0.0085777771,
0.0117951473,
-0.0168462209,
-0.0351515673,
0.0730948821,
0.0066383928,
0.0215623956,
0.0254971609,
-0.016821526,
-0.0189276878,
0.0229198597,
0.0853450149,
0.0382121317,
-0.0236437675,
-0.0183277167,
0.0101033542,
0.005732567,
-0.017797621,
-0.0099468473,
-0.0226379614,
-0.0249495525,
-0.1034458801,
0.0644256026,
-0.0423139445,
-0.0173107777,
-0.0266405363,
-0.0009523497,
-0.0032364619,
0.0703705773,
0.0014682922,
-0.0199963152,
-0.0037824977,
0.0081854668,
0.0516311936,
0.0152112395,
-0.0316634551,
-0.0243524853,
0.0022916382,
-0.0198678244,
-0.0557179004,
-0.0026650087,
0.0351687223,
0.0057241032,
-0.0499250256,
0.0226692539,
2.450123972e-34,
0.037754003,
0.0171567909,
0.037113063,
-0.0299228765,
0.0305298902,
-0.0012094395,
-0.0081346966,
0.0249252655,
0.0280899424,
-0.0205823351,
-0.0094619673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13925v1 | GenderAlign: An Alignment Dataset for Mitigating Gender Bias in Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T01:45:44 | 2024-06-20T01:45:44 | Tao Zhang, Ziqian Zeng, Yuxiang Xiao, Huiping Zhuang, Cen Chen, James Foulds, Shimei Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are prone to generating content that exhibits
gender biases, raising significant ethical concerns. Alignment, the process of
fine-tuning LLMs to better align with desired behaviors, is recognized as an
effective approach to mitigate gender biases. Although proprietary LLMs have
made significant strides in mitigating gender bias, their alignment datasets
are not publicly available. The commonly used and publicly available alignment
dataset, HH-RLHF, still exhibits gender bias to some extent. There is a lack of
publicly available alignment datasets specifically designed to address gender
bias. Hence, we developed a new dataset named GenderAlign, aiming at mitigating
a comprehensive set of gender biases in LLMs. This dataset comprises 8k
single-turn dialogues, each paired with a "chosen" and a "rejected" response.
Compared to the "rejected" responses, the "chosen" responses demonstrate lower
levels of gender bias and higher quality. Furthermore, we categorized the
gender biases in the "rejected" responses of GenderAlign into 4 principal
categories. The experimental results show the effectiveness of GenderAlign in
reducing gender bias in LLMs. | [
0.0535127595,
0.0914341509,
-0.0248718765,
0.0227087233,
-0.0337703042,
0.0042412989,
0.0267982036,
-0.0366520733,
-0.0047773267,
-0.0315741226,
-0.0163653512,
-0.063531898,
0.0372716971,
0.0028934218,
0.032485798,
-0.0227026995,
0.0355001651,
0.0301242191,
0.0228423141,
-0.0307973512,
0.0459352322,
0.0535327606,
0.0062709418,
0.0541943125,
0.0308608077,
-0.0512299463,
0.0101129608,
0.0337446928,
0.0218086671,
-0.0015177196,
0.063627705,
0.0730344281,
-0.0159349721,
0.0310063194,
0.0000018711,
-0.0924279466,
0.019071795,
0.0015513067,
-0.0200480316,
0.0171199646,
0.0204110648,
-0.0046203849,
-0.0310624558,
0.0367776603,
-0.0274962243,
-0.00923396,
0.045003131,
0.0323352031,
0.0461284928,
0.0286680255,
-0.005387133,
0.0261045229,
-0.040833205,
-0.0153912026,
-0.0341843963,
0.0117417024,
0.0336026661,
-0.0129774166,
-0.044796478,
-0.0047418945,
-0.0129104527,
0.0037455508,
-0.0344457924,
-0.0431552604,
-0.0022478371,
-0.0079297498,
-0.0727426931,
-0.0676872134,
0.0195360146,
0.0713091791,
0.0437787659,
-0.0061029396,
0.0094824526,
-0.0100339716,
0.0226397142,
0.0157455578,
-0.0535786077,
0.0350460485,
-0.0012329654,
-0.00881375,
-0.0093786716,
-0.0667825267,
0.0156760402,
0.0529343709,
0.0143813342,
0.0911909416,
0.0292063188,
-0.0353341252,
-0.0203932002,
-0.0248149857,
0.0192937665,
-0.0776785463,
-0.0265838914,
-0.0257307049,
-0.0175012629,
0.0218364988,
-0.0267287958,
0.0084078182,
0.0683463365,
-0.0780773684,
-0.0095708566,
0.0520354025,
0.0460235327,
0.0085056648,
0.0050786729,
0.0437568501,
-0.0153319957,
0.0225689951,
-0.0180255529,
-0.0126997074,
0.0050748596,
-0.0221967213,
0.0002615986,
-0.0128038302,
-0.0078793205,
0.0294617079,
-0.0554776117,
0.016565036,
-0.0373704508,
0.0267209504,
0.0078205634,
0.0268952474,
-0.0041325041,
-0.0039257142,
-0.000725804,
0.0496737882,
-0.0475602038,
0.034511596,
-0.0171363261,
-0.0905011892,
-0.0063435524,
0.0132186059,
0.0073476448,
-0.0255252142,
-0.0192843471,
0.0198501479,
0.0171611812,
-0.0033065414,
-0.0154650295,
0.0071991035,
-0.0283376239,
-0.0664810091,
-0.0073871328,
-0.0813269168,
0.0402968004,
0.0520135351,
0.0019447453,
-0.0274565704,
0.0067783361,
0.028876029,
-0.0016575983,
0.0267559756,
0.0398586765,
0.0251542088,
0.0735206455,
0.0001156771,
0.0115797799,
0.1002299637,
0.0473132618,
-0.0194383357,
0.0459113009,
-0.0230889805,
-0.0477492884,
0.0479496494,
0.0263137631,
0.0509141423,
-0.0300614405,
0.0605936274,
0.0023724765,
0.0690969527,
0.0571727604,
-0.0041158604,
0.0310858153,
-0.0379926004,
0.0741913617,
0.0649786294,
0.0263131633,
0.0385593921,
-0.0056387591,
0.003955048,
0.0042511495,
0.013107053,
-0.0543402284,
-0.00178732,
-0.0153150028,
-0.0151905604,
-0.005853503,
0.0418352112,
-0.0157665648,
-0.0346701778,
-0.0326424949,
0.0246922448,
-0.011648708,
0.0150040202,
0.0133229867,
0.0157371275,
-0.0006253156,
0.0623718798,
0.034493342,
-0.0857909173,
-0.0202511307,
-0.016783325,
0.041142378,
0.0384560935,
0.0250034407,
-0.0240326039,
-0.0514582321,
-0.0476152413,
-0.0203657933,
0.0523728468,
0.0789490938,
0.0119609805,
-0.0131565742,
-0.0418454371,
-0.0324009769,
0.0153955249,
0.0021504848,
0.0125632528,
0.0482641272,
0.0305659249,
-0.0009437985,
-0.0123810843,
-0.071998328,
0.0215927213,
-0.0157488249,
-0.0072131883,
0.0235261153,
0.0003099071,
0.0529932305,
0.0237504691,
-0.0143420855,
0.0063293516,
0.0009263505,
0.0022967921,
0.0059812106,
0.0238134768,
-0.0321257375,
0.0097926445,
0.0435467176,
-0.0651334748,
-0.1004404277,
0.0360124931,
-0.0150106065,
-0.0239024032,
0.0390347615,
-0.0141180353,
-0.0186874475,
-0.0103377476,
0.0176747218,
-0.0082228025,
0.025730364,
-0.0334527269,
-0.0030792109,
-0.0228108317,
0.0022863848,
0.013744548,
-0.0312200394,
-0.0066673649,
-0.0667751655,
-0.0353129767,
0.0360652842,
-0.0039737327,
-0.0051565259,
0.0325501449,
-0.0350766256,
-0.0558055378,
-0.0270005912,
-0.0581131056,
-0.0097667985,
0.0091498224,
0.0058395504,
0.0216112416,
0.0160906762,
-0.0193700921,
0.0115065062,
-0.0545147248,
-0.0354324691,
0.0218567345,
0.0281671789,
0.0585453026,
-0.0401741974,
0.0129732285,
-0.0682969466,
-0.0313294008,
-0.0397563204,
0.0391891114,
0.0209550895,
0.0166798681,
-0.0355800502,
0.0073912493,
-0.0409452356,
-0.0143376272,
-0.0094662178,
-0.06184531,
0.0006212882,
0.0504691899,
0.0487044193,
0.0732739121,
0.0548199601,
-0.0079879938,
0.0230791345,
0.0126824584,
-0.0639560744,
-0.0274400301,
0.0300776456,
0.0280612875,
-0.0050127404,
-0.0877335742,
0.0021482755,
0.013261823,
-0.0031349552,
-0.0035169257,
-0.0444160141,
0.0440879278,
-0.0175654087,
-0.0359196514,
-0.0211036019,
-0.0324532762,
-0.0254269019,
0.0226767827,
-0.0395310223,
-0.0372260101,
0.0312562995,
-0.0151099162,
-0.002555605,
-0.0176305603,
-0.0055808215,
-0.0668824539,
0.0271715689,
-0.0540522523,
0.027118111,
0.0066458243,
-0.0293101631,
-0.0922791883,
-0.0597323515,
0.0450719409,
-0.0404894315,
0.0604289435,
-0.0107412236,
0.0254459437,
-0.0024626043,
-0.0252334978,
-0.0599929988,
-0.0355116762,
0.0100089349,
-0.0210742094,
0.0225828495,
-0.0139724324,
-0.0242861956,
0.0345530957,
-0.0103675751,
0.0060239923,
-0.0283190329,
0.0345866606,
-0.0009885191,
0.0114597529,
0.0769584179,
0.0184133556,
0.0326224752,
-0.0138972783,
0.0350820832,
0.0344263017,
-0.0196144711,
0.0126172416,
0.02594354,
-0.0018382422,
0.0660393834,
-0.0497965626,
-0.0014358741,
-0.0435282178,
0.0379465781,
-0.0472121723,
0.0095117614,
0.096790038,
0.0166259073,
-0.0672343075,
-0.0107649108,
-0.0475609973,
0.0399686694,
0.0331487954,
0.0072370819,
-0.0645351857,
0.0316618457,
0.0269695856,
-0.0231099315,
-0.0264235418,
-0.0415935554,
-0.0225289185,
-0.1453279108,
-0.0115675768,
0.0413332991,
-0.0541916974,
-0.0489909947,
-0.0092247082,
0.0198674202,
-0.0127623398,
0.0632138178,
0.0151606575,
-0.0088445917,
-0.0136280982,
-0.0039065741,
-0.0550590195,
-0.0092938356,
0.0221222173,
-0.0710756704,
0.0892526582,
0.0401458219,
0.0690822005,
-0.0159984753,
-0.0072719911,
0.0318832844,
-0.0030890349,
-0.0378884748,
0.0029132909,
0.0042552482,
-0.0474663973,
-0.0143608227,
-0.0648172274,
0.060233444,
0.0248389784,
-0.0071936618,
-0.0024660612,
0.0150265163,
0.0115752351,
0.0132527845,
-0.0543590002,
0.0008349624,
0.0003917883,
0.0649811924,
0.0141018378,
-0.0447052754,
-0.026548598,
-0.038821198,
-0.0001248459,
0.0263266228,
-0.0400041081,
0.0052259043,
0.0293882955,
0.0006000122,
-0.0260953978,
-0.0554333068,
0.0152558861,
-0.02242429,
0.008114676,
-0.0457543321,
0.0184634458,
0.0096307769,
-0.056482058,
0.0309741963,
-0.0084053697,
0.0179348141,
-0.0111593697,
-0.0118418708,
-0.0363121442,
-0.031180894,
0.0044637006,
0.014465034,
-0.0240642522,
-0.061137069,
0.0330372937,
0.0271375887,
0.0211940575,
0.0609035343,
0.0324006379,
-0.0227470975,
-0.0139285289,
0.0153595544,
-0.0253579188,
0.0299865678,
0.019256331,
0.0527147204,
0.0034682301,
0.0501454808,
-0.0279549807,
-0.0155106131,
0.0067969612,
0.0182689056,
-0.0153396726,
-0.0682332516,
0.0247655436,
0.0225800741,
-0.0135176471,
-0.0337370075,
0.010354544,
-0.0594318137,
0.0038387035,
-0.0565605238,
-0.0419599265,
-0.0068498901,
-0.0266978256,
0.0417380966,
-0.005392137,
-0.0068485448,
-0.0114216562,
-0.0722438022,
0.0196122397,
-0.0203367472,
0.0320335813,
-0.0017315703,
0.0303188991,
-0.001532719,
0.0080419658,
-0.0075624613,
-0.0018222666,
-0.0297381412,
0.0254702996,
0.029807182,
0.0350678973,
0.0153336348,
0.0252411962,
-0.010885261,
0.0054395641,
-0.0167421568,
-0.0129511086,
-0.014247763,
0.0012779011,
-0.0000995443,
-0.0264074188,
0.093490161,
0.0175358336,
-0.0191921629,
0.0014058283,
0.0239019692,
-0.0144445514,
0.0065253917,
0.041875314,
0.0332692526,
-0.0270443093,
-0.0345043205,
0.0249675345,
0.0415834412,
0.0455763415,
-0.0232085176,
-0.0031899225,
-0.0288096387,
-0.0282211024,
0.035178151,
-0.0543187261,
-0.0228905026,
-0.0238761101,
-0.0890150517,
-0.0346374102,
-0.0043200003,
-0.0100810789,
0.0050527919,
-0.005479278,
-0.0152151473,
0.0503604189,
-0.0170545876,
-0.0524480194,
-0.0446916297,
0.0127339605,
-0.0073052342,
-0.0242927223,
-0.0318384208,
-6.073085769e-33,
-0.0340292789,
-0.0411826186,
-0.0150291864,
-0.0084345397,
-0.0544031523,
-0.0203697588,
-0.0104195932,
0.0080266465,
-0.0150903845,
0.0282007717,
-0.0062758038,
0.0501570068,
0.0048492122,
0.0089642871,
0.0328186825,
-0.0043514664,
0.0456373543,
0.009876634,
-0.0319423676,
-0.0364027433,
-0.0171250347,
0.0079161655,
0.0410612896,
-0.0733763799,
0.1057797968,
-0.0288328715,
-0.0155145125,
0.0063058427,
-0.0460738316,
0.0381021127,
0.0025121451,
0.0511466376,
0.0085019208,
-0.0245349854,
0.0322070457,
0.0865715668,
-0.0525809564,
-0.0290675201,
0.0503817424,
0.0407225303,
0.0243499968,
-0.0279078428,
0.0373949036,
0.0215997882,
-0.0460980907,
-0.0419229269,
0.0444706455,
-0.0084441621,
0.0419321284,
0.0448505282,
-0.0607585534,
0.0259748045,
-0.0501734652,
0.0082145212,
-0.0164515693,
0.0686226636,
-0.0025563051,
0.0102256043,
-0.0873214379,
0.0419621244,
-0.0238925703,
-0.0028632395,
0.0561527647,
0.0115354471,
0.0443236232,
0.03399387,
0.0397025086,
0.0294622686,
-0.0049981829,
-0.0415501222,
0.0204975251,
-0.0116040008,
0.0140526528,
0.0740663186,
-0.0108598601,
-0.0047067078,
-0.0699220523,
-0.0401551984,
-0.0015428565,
0.0465540737,
0.0091018239,
-0.013481861,
-0.0642032996,
-0.0348709226,
-0.0248724241,
-0.065176107,
-0.0132022426,
-0.0108576585,
0.009215462,
-0.0302165188,
-0.0598784499,
-0.0208291784,
-0.0048490758,
-0.0641941652,
-0.0322488919,
0.030922994,
-0.019344328,
-0.0442167148,
0.0433247946,
0.0190942343,
-0.0590108261,
0.0269862879,
-0.0140801612,
0.0079517988,
0.0265932903,
0.0257294215,
-0.0007620964,
0.00039368,
-0.0916266963,
-0.0072201323,
-0.0278462917,
0.0193363503,
-0.0234683063,
0.0205238294,
0.0191203896,
0.0152548188,
-0.0012412638,
0.0403160676,
0.0601464473,
0.0301453415,
-0.0471468568,
-0.0119555285,
-0.0100546703,
0.030673787,
-0.014111504,
-0.0040157479,
0.0028337818,
0.0406640992,
0.0521218777,
-0.0192615669,
-0.0088175805,
-0.0402552746,
2.522e-7,
0.0081910091,
0.063311778,
0.0531700216,
0.0371330455,
0.0185339395,
0.0311001446,
0.011905876,
0.05286327,
0.0734287649,
-0.0055873436,
-0.0023871502,
0.0014908299,
0.0281969272,
0.0247182753,
-0.0702658072,
0.0157174561,
-0.1048603058,
0.0071709766,
0.0118681453,
0.0238429513,
-0.0085486472,
0.0703851432,
0.0366420448,
0.0059797294,
-0.0366319455,
0.014443649,
0.0488000773,
-0.0183125138,
-0.0131032355,
0.0658369735,
-0.0028445972,
-0.0465921722,
0.0253338162,
0.00696958,
0.0138947163,
0.0294223577,
-0.0076296348,
0.0431193225,
-0.0296266358,
-0.0106769456,
-0.0242130421,
-0.0081388978,
-0.0079270359,
-0.0810580179,
0.0440372229,
0.004106984,
-0.0611454695,
-0.0646314248,
-0.0238278899,
0.0011696671,
0.0864338726,
-0.0069402494,
0.0019310077,
0.0283918828,
0.0394478366,
0.0020248541,
-0.0201834422,
-0.0363304019,
-0.0413317718,
-0.033948645,
-0.0329426527,
-0.0540388897,
0.0085056424,
0.0368929952,
-0.0010098194,
-0.0339534357,
0.0264604874,
1.941461623e-34,
-0.0001861433,
0.0198046099,
0.0367729217,
0.0195498466,
0.0124194687,
-0.0201089028,
0.0110730017,
0.0254970286,
0.0628574118,
-0.0043714959,
-0.0003696635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13923v1 | PIN: A Knowledge-Intensive Dataset for Paired and Interleaved Multimodal Documents | 2024-06-20T01:43:08 | 2024-06-20T01:43:08 | Junjie Wang, Yin Zhang, Yatai Ji, Yuxiang Zhang, Chunyang Jiang, Yubo Wang, Kang Zhu, Zekun Wang, Tiezhen Wang, Wenhao Huang, Jie Fu, Bei Chen, Qunshu Lin, Minghao Liu, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | Recent advancements in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have leveraged
extensive multimodal datasets to enhance capabilities in complex
knowledge-driven tasks. However, persistent challenges in perceptual and
reasoning errors limit their efficacy, particularly in interpreting intricate
visual data and deducing multimodal relationships. Addressing these issues, we
introduce a novel dataset format, PIN (Paired and INterleaved multimodal
documents), designed to significantly improve both the depth and breadth of
multimodal training. The PIN format is built on three foundational principles:
knowledge intensity, scalability, and support for diverse training modalities.
This innovative format combines markdown files and comprehensive images to
enrich training data with a dense knowledge structure and versatile training
strategies. We present PIN-14M, an open-source dataset comprising 14 million
samples derived from a diverse range of Chinese and English sources, tailored
to include complex web and scientific content. This dataset is constructed
meticulously to ensure data quality and ethical integrity, aiming to facilitate
advanced training strategies and improve model robustness against common
multimodal training pitfalls. Our initial results, forming the basis of this
technical report, suggest significant potential for the PIN format in refining
LMM performance, with plans for future expansions and detailed evaluations of
its impact on model capabilities. | [
0.0251975078,
0.0707521662,
-0.0055663036,
0.056367252,
0.0045490065,
0.0197411869,
0.0269148536,
0.0060454784,
-0.0182295088,
-0.0880436227,
-0.0798119456,
-0.0143331671,
-0.0139582204,
0.0334279947,
0.0388866179,
-0.0938847214,
0.034764789,
-0.0103178294,
-0.0083373571,
0.0212660469,
0.0570688359,
0.0104381237,
-0.0241309777,
0.0238176603,
-0.0559996031,
-0.0531059392,
-0.0195919685,
0.0377844088,
0.0123916287,
-0.0608205386,
-0.0003490376,
0.0563402399,
0.0780506805,
0.0121318689,
0.0000023267,
-0.0139033692,
-0.0083334045,
-0.0104321418,
0.0140107116,
0.0019743438,
0.0455365889,
-0.0651133657,
0.0341968723,
-0.0438855812,
-0.0289415214,
-0.0332182981,
0.0508777834,
0.0972185656,
0.0676071793,
0.0486128516,
-0.028764246,
-0.0020220096,
0.0279194154,
0.0016547468,
0.022068074,
-0.0216443669,
0.0077701802,
0.0720740259,
-0.0118575683,
0.0317861773,
-0.0493386872,
0.0240147505,
0.0131963799,
0.0056522214,
-0.0142115001,
0.0273600388,
-0.0089946585,
-0.0356492884,
-0.0168617442,
0.1145803109,
0.015588956,
0.0177478194,
-0.0129540311,
-0.0254369061,
-0.0193407312,
0.0563005246,
-0.0757340118,
0.0241430197,
-0.0439409129,
-0.0110126901,
-0.0494672023,
-0.0052007465,
0.0385491103,
0.0107566044,
0.013183712,
-0.0046688593,
-0.0235106461,
-0.0115208132,
0.0157295689,
-0.0081308577,
-0.0261585768,
-0.0163632743,
-0.0158982817,
-0.0044213594,
0.0358828492,
0.0142668318,
-0.0306205004,
-0.039890945,
0.0370975584,
-0.0211219452,
0.0317748375,
0.0067626997,
-0.0672573969,
0.0631839707,
-0.0033398559,
0.0015082707,
-0.0298051238,
0.0338301882,
0.0112599852,
0.0088964021,
-0.0637275502,
-0.0263994485,
0.0097063659,
-0.012272995,
-0.0335172117,
-0.0525848679,
-0.0056984941,
0.0274341851,
-0.0208000857,
0.0160238259,
-0.0279424675,
0.0173737127,
-0.0378259271,
-0.013637674,
-0.0460307337,
0.0564276315,
-0.0090387175,
0.0423768647,
-0.0183079094,
-0.0237504002,
0.0216029305,
0.0430009253,
-0.0038956364,
-0.0252839308,
-0.0176961701,
0.0790309012,
-0.0331093557,
-0.0140731689,
-0.03712878,
-0.0740698725,
0.0024181849,
-0.0433098674,
0.0816235095,
-0.0380518995,
0.0734719858,
-0.0135616446,
0.0202334002,
-0.0132798441,
-0.0069272812,
0.0012480405,
-0.0154637191,
0.1029953063,
-0.0216472559,
-0.0266612526,
0.0296565332,
0.0361229032,
-0.0426983237,
0.1120425388,
0.0062750513,
0.017367078,
0.0580112673,
-0.0186974462,
-0.0218057241,
0.0190386251,
0.0013643473,
-0.0044047339,
0.0173170995,
-0.0035863423,
0.0425877534,
0.0228690058,
0.0441480167,
0.000705593,
-0.0680906773,
-0.0250227861,
0.0712027773,
-0.0000486069,
0.0175455678,
-0.009817292,
0.0071147582,
-0.0130149545,
0.0281867087,
0.0123181473,
-0.0450300016,
0.0579855032,
0.0096347267,
-0.0028817439,
0.0192372091,
0.0249949843,
-0.0364303142,
-0.0235573407,
-0.0244190078,
-0.0040369146,
0.0065278504,
-0.0135467919,
0.0569441766,
-0.0027221777,
-0.0170423724,
0.0148623241,
0.0381365716,
-0.0218355041,
-0.0060181785,
0.0089088446,
-0.0007442246,
0.0539864898,
0.0360691249,
-0.034522742,
-0.0281619709,
-0.0173088014,
0.0515589751,
0.0380824469,
0.0229259469,
-0.0270861052,
0.0247770976,
-0.0759493187,
-0.0661207363,
-0.0527227521,
-0.0068947966,
0.0164570436,
0.0182091556,
0.0051250798,
-0.0023472006,
-0.0301553924,
0.022726398,
0.0438899323,
-0.0084468694,
0.0167225245,
-0.0531963557,
0.0068134926,
0.0213977713,
0.0129257822,
-0.0310652163,
-0.0129461288,
0.0281853359,
-0.0191911776,
-0.0029241024,
0.0295833386,
-0.0242395699,
-0.0212749168,
0.0357264131,
-0.0840040073,
-0.0079498366,
0.0138192698,
-0.052522555,
-0.0258537866,
-0.0015847803,
0.0136068836,
0.0133803431,
-0.0478257947,
-0.0422173552,
0.0461981446,
0.0330586843,
-0.005098626,
0.0366364345,
-0.0351057053,
-0.0044332594,
0.0207669176,
-0.0057568187,
0.0143734543,
-0.0043461025,
-0.0144460099,
0.0216917824,
0.0072214277,
0.0175686609,
0.0000492257,
-0.0084684948,
-0.0420934148,
0.0200654715,
-0.1024485454,
-0.0175959691,
0.0017958969,
-0.0063519464,
-0.0025376086,
-0.0231601782,
-0.0115639661,
-0.0403866805,
0.0067493329,
0.0357865766,
-0.0098876609,
0.0285618491,
0.0167154297,
0.0131561914,
0.0571450368,
-0.0092035085,
-0.0134614939,
-0.0151160583,
0.0590478033,
0.0227309987,
-0.0088400422,
-0.0206054319,
-0.0351128764,
-0.028795708,
0.0075609498,
-0.0427827239,
-0.0176263303,
0.0345318057,
-0.0318315998,
0.0186297055,
0.0259177405,
-0.0039830222,
0.0444972105,
0.0240387879,
-0.0163536407,
-0.0511130542,
0.0209959019,
0.0319561586,
0.0325957499,
-0.018915806,
-0.0228233561,
-0.0264359992,
0.0340469778,
0.0085803494,
0.0280218106,
-0.0270077847,
0.0021134082,
0.0193757229,
-0.0654980913,
-0.0466640629,
0.0091508636,
0.0281890091,
0.0049351519,
-0.040893998,
-0.0287885517,
0.0390331671,
-0.0234256592,
0.0048742844,
0.0125736408,
0.030943187,
-0.0153056802,
0.0843060166,
-0.0010049057,
0.0308302213,
-0.0128472829,
0.0225591082,
-0.0438295752,
0.0196569711,
0.0376225486,
0.020393122,
0.0308012553,
-0.0540344454,
-0.000403167,
-0.0311423335,
-0.0228697509,
-0.0040218327,
-0.0175388623,
-0.0291063804,
-0.0226698965,
-0.002055611,
0.0057475106,
-0.0282679107,
0.0069416272,
0.0420762375,
0.0189730767,
-0.0039644665,
-0.0160811339,
-0.0031364558,
0.0413719676,
0.0393148363,
0.0077559901,
-0.0319450758,
-0.0726332515,
0.0046141115,
0.0836127475,
-0.0190973803,
-0.0220011193,
-0.0326736085,
0.0315624774,
-0.0074159056,
0.0235059131,
-0.0167208854,
-0.022367632,
0.0346511379,
-0.0761892274,
0.0468552075,
0.0549836494,
0.0063256002,
-0.0642554238,
-0.028700497,
0.0106079681,
0.0037021136,
0.016074216,
-0.0076023517,
-0.1195926964,
-0.061668817,
-0.0306516886,
0.0053640776,
0.0373814777,
-0.012900902,
0.0203373134,
-0.061783012,
0.0520961583,
-0.00187009,
-0.066786401,
-0.0242622234,
-0.0705482215,
-0.0061731632,
-0.0103749065,
-0.0152173806,
0.0013107781,
-0.0215423424,
-0.0134540703,
0.0270547681,
-0.0023314762,
-0.0470997281,
0.0067413426,
-0.0552407093,
0.0027641817,
0.0360327065,
0.0127655091,
-0.0069572343,
-0.0415188521,
0.0059141344,
0.0353745297,
0.0125391129,
-0.0243322458,
0.0852347687,
-0.0531523265,
-0.0028303703,
-0.0141887208,
0.031127166,
-0.0083266087,
-0.0353655927,
0.0012086722,
0.0747645944,
-0.0272517446,
0.0076715522,
-0.0756604597,
0.0009828417,
0.0060199695,
0.0405815281,
-0.0182134882,
-0.0373377986,
-0.0254992452,
-0.0254605655,
0.0232130568,
-0.049825497,
0.0089273006,
0.0387933999,
-0.0532766506,
0.0014224338,
-0.0770605057,
-0.0451151542,
0.0064106421,
0.0135857202,
-0.0006752868,
-0.0270357504,
-0.0187720712,
0.027572101,
-0.0724081323,
0.0579142906,
0.0090025244,
-0.0109341471,
-0.0335568413,
-0.0204562861,
0.031778276,
-0.0539116226,
0.0052823899,
0.036169406,
-0.0591773652,
-0.0145043666,
-0.0343881361,
0.0644064546,
0.0107952626,
0.053590104,
0.0589118041,
-0.0407677367,
0.0094060823,
0.0439751484,
-0.0314469859,
-0.0204032101,
0.0280454326,
-0.0002304771,
-0.0198943559,
-0.0129958205,
-0.0479128286,
0.0015195713,
-0.0309064519,
0.0172921624,
-0.0114024263,
0.0162140615,
0.0019869923,
-0.0072990423,
0.0322093964,
-0.0171791203,
-0.0139100738,
-0.0472024567,
0.0134143727,
-0.0215258487,
-0.0263311286,
-0.0472541861,
0.0290345363,
0.0106237158,
-0.0153021105,
-0.0103880176,
0.0189814698,
0.0366609208,
0.0499943532,
-0.0595104322,
0.0191207882,
0.0547630526,
-0.0159470681,
-0.0301016103,
0.0157788731,
-0.0134071987,
0.0208751075,
-0.0342306644,
0.0083530908,
-0.0035522187,
0.0942414701,
0.0241182111,
-0.0077327453,
-0.0047291848,
0.0340424515,
-0.0252697114,
-0.008663564,
-0.0210898779,
0.0101591488,
0.0595074184,
-0.0101946061,
0.0386583321,
-0.0575948134,
-0.0243724566,
-0.0116993822,
0.0484940112,
0.0171390474,
-0.0075596194,
0.0607048012,
0.0288641434,
0.0178614706,
-0.0051458199,
0.1068316922,
-0.0128849745,
0.069756709,
-0.0069531789,
-0.0259795133,
-0.0462854058,
-0.0048138141,
0.0839937851,
0.0382575616,
-0.0074461987,
-0.0006023876,
-0.0195965692,
-0.0456760228,
0.0036431972,
0.0199750662,
-0.0262403432,
0.0397402085,
0.0494031943,
0.0769772306,
0.0174854659,
-0.0450135544,
-0.0458697081,
0.0050939191,
-0.0135149043,
0.0091175437,
0.0203703605,
-6.735224104e-33,
-0.0015706181,
-0.0135273552,
0.0316191278,
-0.0079279682,
-0.0221240167,
0.0136087416,
-0.0099952957,
-0.0124104219,
0.0017671618,
0.0259525236,
0.030165799,
-0.0185263269,
-0.002403042,
0.0106542744,
0.0371020846,
0.0147491712,
0.0356707312,
-0.0315781459,
0.0060731927,
0.0114441141,
0.0669547766,
0.0273424704,
0.0563449189,
-0.0850804895,
0.0272745043,
0.0152402138,
-0.0203576069,
-0.0213481132,
-0.0011704934,
0.0832991675,
-0.0642146766,
0.0269053224,
0.0348065458,
-0.0207258407,
-0.035572771,
0.0101289796,
-0.1054129899,
-0.0044969469,
0.0082314098,
0.0455090292,
-0.076277785,
-0.005449791,
0.0363714844,
-0.0208275896,
0.0515123755,
-0.0526045077,
0.0562435947,
-0.0272295531,
-0.0107248034,
-0.0086991778,
-0.0281780362,
0.0279131327,
-0.0237934813,
-0.0111899935,
0.0468004309,
0.058628194,
0.0241392236,
0.018947985,
-0.091717191,
0.0304247327,
-0.0106165288,
-0.0115334485,
0.0818381533,
0.0243199896,
0.0260887574,
0.0706258416,
0.0079204086,
-0.0258832667,
-0.0172255505,
0.0151402764,
0.0400063358,
0.0697490424,
-0.011857179,
0.071960412,
0.0287333652,
0.0174969584,
-0.0478301942,
0.0367286615,
-0.0065828469,
0.0481335819,
-0.0011696913,
0.0276590493,
-0.0010164944,
0.0064253965,
-0.0088345073,
-0.0130962152,
-0.0248553231,
-0.0366260484,
0.0290289186,
0.0233748127,
-0.0049622064,
0.0320702009,
0.0637337863,
-0.0306947492,
-0.0316029564,
0.0107276551,
-0.0072048348,
0.0546164922,
0.0080529898,
-0.033443898,
-0.05207102,
-0.0311788451,
0.0624597259,
-0.0331736468,
0.0370254107,
-0.0003537247,
0.0654304847,
0.0380742624,
-0.0249918178,
-0.0123521015,
-0.0131634576,
-0.0193475131,
0.031054046,
0.0020070362,
0.0198283717,
0.0046424693,
-0.0583142824,
0.017923573,
0.017329203,
0.0114333024,
-0.0344191529,
-0.0728160366,
-0.0402156375,
0.0134144118,
-0.0024788412,
0.0026085854,
-0.0487803482,
-0.0896201208,
-0.0026745044,
-0.0978178903,
-0.0105750468,
0.0506496504,
2.839e-7,
0.0477822125,
0.0445469879,
0.018070057,
-0.0023375077,
0.0391195305,
0.0273153335,
-0.0452124141,
0.0435006432,
-0.0179655105,
-0.0485361852,
0.0172451343,
0.0590847619,
0.0316533335,
0.059209574,
-0.0382335894,
-0.0231399499,
-0.0029759954,
-0.0372354686,
-0.0631953254,
-0.0025398326,
0.047254432,
0.045284424,
-0.0405438505,
-0.023661172,
0.0328399204,
-0.0078371121,
0.1078942642,
-0.0161065515,
-0.0019780053,
-0.0094539672,
0.0576126277,
0.0041312231,
-0.0263287984,
0.0375021882,
-0.0146621307,
-0.041889511,
0.048466865,
0.0477273017,
-0.0042702192,
-0.025287902,
0.0098786531,
0.016656613,
-0.0219692681,
-0.052655302,
0.0863277465,
-0.0140823154,
-0.0223375186,
0.0079735853,
-0.0565902293,
-0.0136021962,
0.0135173528,
-0.0278755184,
-0.0251538828,
0.0383675396,
-0.0013424557,
-0.0060458565,
-0.0322789252,
-0.064658694,
-0.0220918879,
-0.006226684,
-0.0514266528,
-0.0243103448,
-0.0227851048,
-0.0507420525,
0.0185372476,
-0.0536524244,
-0.0535898618,
2.40461007e-34,
0.0214873534,
-0.0101818778,
0.0084400112,
-0.0018153482,
0.0255346652,
-0.0232653264,
-0.0416184142,
-0.0040547978,
-0.0257916711,
-0.0751813948,
-0.0175114237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02511v1 | LLM-A*: Large Language Model Enhanced Incremental Heuristic Search on Path Planning | 2024-06-20T01:24:30 | 2024-06-20T01:24:30 | Silin Meng, Yiwei Wang, Cheng-Fu Yang, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | Path planning is a fundamental scientific problem in robotics and autonomous
navigation, requiring the derivation of efficient routes from starting to
destination points while avoiding obstacles. Traditional algorithms like A* and
its variants are capable of ensuring path validity but suffer from significant
computational and memory inefficiencies as the state space grows. Conversely,
large language models (LLMs) excel in broader environmental analysis through
contextual understanding, providing global insights into environments. However,
they fall short in detailed spatial and temporal reasoning, often leading to
invalid or inefficient routes. In this work, we propose LLM-A*, an new LLM
based route planning method that synergistically combines the precise
pathfinding capabilities of A* with the global reasoning capability of LLMs.
This hybrid approach aims to enhance pathfinding efficiency in terms of time
and space complexity while maintaining the integrity of path validity,
especially in large-scale scenarios. By integrating the strengths of both
methodologies, LLM-A* addresses the computational and memory limitations of
conventional algorithms without compromising on the validity required for
effective pathfinding. | [
0.0479586497,
0.0381471179,
-0.0040452303,
0.0295209102,
-0.059979707,
-0.0482782684,
-0.0467227101,
-0.0483201928,
-0.0042367266,
-0.0254605468,
0.0210177843,
-0.0008688216,
-0.0303979609,
0.0085339705,
-0.0050717145,
-0.0313846581,
0.0388989523,
-0.098523967,
-0.0436059348,
-0.0070294961,
-0.0317935087,
-0.0278650206,
-0.0146791469,
0.0274871327,
-0.0146392565,
0.0164960194,
-0.0456641689,
-0.007058884,
0.0101714395,
-0.0760458335,
-0.0497701988,
-0.0353504643,
0.0769150406,
0.0206957981,
0.0000022983,
-0.0440145209,
-0.0469587259,
-0.0081007313,
-0.0092374925,
-0.022751689,
0.0063691516,
0.0047204872,
-0.0086286981,
0.0308742747,
-0.023520276,
0.0332750864,
0.0158661418,
0.0056029307,
0.0646857172,
0.0580494255,
0.0062310873,
-0.0260386672,
-0.0132988635,
0.0118825352,
0.0053255651,
-0.0632003173,
0.0108859651,
0.0330509841,
0.045042038,
0.0267019458,
-0.0204518624,
-0.0190347973,
0.0145245092,
-0.0237144679,
-0.0252405573,
0.026441576,
0.0196481608,
0.0093018766,
-0.0009752722,
0.0607304275,
-0.0074511562,
-0.0383675098,
0.0136741698,
0.0180529561,
-0.0769971013,
-0.0280652307,
-0.0390300862,
0.0591473505,
-0.0140671832,
0.0108396439,
0.0170702189,
-0.0411981232,
0.0346271172,
0.0387386531,
-0.046889469,
0.1496603638,
0.011842085,
0.0011723562,
0.005285732,
-0.0445479155,
-0.0122309802,
-0.0511342511,
0.0459736958,
0.1125938445,
-0.0296211876,
0.0193058029,
0.0080966987,
0.036968261,
-0.0056811813,
-0.049721498,
0.0107146977,
0.0347221047,
0.0210884418,
0.0194248371,
-0.0064424947,
0.0387817621,
-0.031056717,
-0.0002218601,
-0.0107316598,
-0.0113796657,
-0.0084925368,
0.0040880269,
-0.0583523437,
0.0298321303,
-0.0419113971,
-0.0365047269,
0.011858698,
0.0742688552,
-0.0074888249,
-0.0051849196,
-0.0011644954,
-0.0265151523,
0.0477489494,
0.0194531027,
-0.0256549232,
-0.0688108429,
-0.0393905528,
0.0137748616,
-0.0308501385,
0.0311412886,
0.0187506489,
0.0343695581,
-0.0094956029,
-0.0069967476,
0.0037018929,
0.1247905195,
0.0402215868,
-0.0338532701,
-0.0773458257,
-0.0273480993,
-0.0134867672,
-0.0747355297,
0.0359033048,
-0.0802617446,
-0.0068305982,
-0.0054600076,
-0.0219577011,
-0.0008462243,
0.0306313895,
0.0174467247,
-0.0100204898,
0.0201778393,
0.0299940668,
0.0338110328,
0.0251719411,
0.0167104416,
0.0624795966,
0.0459837466,
0.0509063452,
0.0420599058,
-0.015545791,
0.0729724765,
-0.0106471376,
0.0218166206,
-0.0306171048,
0.0092709679,
-0.0209291689,
0.0023312448,
0.0124679767,
0.0469323583,
-0.0072683184,
0.0772816911,
-0.0476708598,
0.0152329393,
0.0051987576,
0.0515680537,
-0.0099082496,
-0.0070589436,
0.0240957215,
0.0164973512,
-0.0359914973,
-0.0658742785,
-0.0175869707,
0.0035176107,
-0.0542151183,
-0.0250860397,
-0.0098246578,
0.0091782371,
0.0231552869,
-0.0347878784,
-0.016142901,
0.0096919397,
0.0282686632,
-0.0367498808,
0.0329428948,
-0.0364715643,
-0.0441242419,
0.0203853976,
0.0105149318,
-0.0388944075,
-0.0342615172,
0.0017035076,
0.0111472299,
0.032422483,
0.0399622135,
0.0177320633,
-0.0557464585,
0.0215416327,
-0.026460845,
0.0006085534,
-0.0368101522,
-0.0028697003,
-0.0013337802,
-0.0315570608,
-0.0379833691,
0.0206348449,
-0.0140510835,
0.0034388173,
0.0114528658,
0.0256270841,
0.0018611641,
-0.023542216,
-0.0159313884,
0.0603806414,
0.005992332,
-0.0089800069,
-0.0159763377,
0.0168510713,
0.0210900586,
-0.002234187,
-0.005930962,
0.0093856202,
0.0630777478,
-0.0076433746,
-0.0388324931,
0.0167976599,
-0.0075580887,
-0.0103778988,
0.0534997471,
-0.0074782348,
-0.0353578702,
0.0250432771,
-0.0229080655,
-0.0140901869,
-0.0045362618,
-0.0426368676,
-0.0049614185,
0.026854882,
0.0161891673,
0.0148127824,
-0.059975341,
-0.0489930846,
0.0255008675,
0.0147209512,
-0.0145513648,
0.0199342705,
0.0350809991,
0.0099761328,
-0.0213639811,
-0.0038975014,
0.0296454001,
0.0271691885,
-0.0450886935,
0.0102150664,
0.0236866958,
0.0087150857,
-0.0447285734,
-0.0679429099,
0.0071830545,
0.0115428688,
0.0028665781,
-0.0068411049,
-0.041708257,
0.0048369044,
0.0467860326,
0.0468515716,
0.0051971911,
0.003554445,
-0.0259821657,
-0.0040364335,
0.0168125294,
-0.0570332594,
-0.0400660932,
0.0119310925,
-0.0453153327,
-0.0083047412,
-0.0142114125,
-0.044523038,
-0.0361785963,
0.0127969328,
-0.0543106422,
0.0514940172,
-0.0269423369,
-0.0248781703,
-0.0065105995,
-0.045448903,
0.0202997811,
0.0233802367,
0.0074854302,
-0.0134169431,
0.0939197242,
-0.0510975979,
-0.0057241502,
0.0274882857,
-0.0224449225,
-0.0260095764,
-0.0487645231,
-0.0324878581,
-0.010827506,
-0.0009319625,
-0.0425366536,
-0.0000014164,
0.0136280637,
-0.0513449311,
-0.0618574992,
0.0294920281,
-0.023534622,
-0.0023909735,
-0.0093308436,
0.0604026467,
-0.0115578491,
-0.0168354604,
0.025869146,
-0.0527831912,
0.0268098097,
-0.0106021315,
-0.0196121391,
-0.0350046158,
0.0742061362,
0.0260722972,
0.056930609,
-0.0280037131,
0.0299781896,
0.048001647,
-0.0210088454,
-0.0208969042,
0.0137274275,
0.062892206,
-0.0874398276,
0.0604302734,
0.0317356363,
-0.057396818,
-0.0175878126,
0.0090234699,
-0.0201241411,
0.0158889089,
-0.0410577618,
-0.0703403875,
0.0079865195,
0.0166464001,
0.0222968925,
0.0510444231,
-0.0033112592,
-0.0124840345,
-0.0126263965,
-0.0311086159,
0.0564753935,
-0.0112852892,
0.0656631067,
0.0090794908,
0.0303070117,
0.0463847406,
0.0401841775,
-0.0176743977,
-0.0275430046,
0.0187696628,
0.0026254689,
0.0097560519,
0.0000932563,
0.0602418855,
0.0454039387,
-0.0584503859,
-0.0693740919,
0.0791595653,
0.0364428796,
0.0391365625,
0.0213751253,
-0.0617920831,
-0.0081010656,
0.0212446153,
0.0349979773,
-0.0032020824,
-0.0262396317,
0.0427886397,
-0.0149025824,
-0.0250929315,
-0.005072047,
0.0164582618,
-0.0718045682,
0.0533002391,
0.0240725242,
-0.0493656211,
-0.0035210846,
-0.0661036968,
-0.0454684906,
0.0083390148,
-0.0312530771,
0.0210351963,
0.0110033685,
-0.0243227631,
0.0074256621,
-0.0375545286,
0.0136998333,
0.0069157355,
0.0043549491,
0.0170703474,
0.0063501624,
0.060209278,
0.0231975336,
-0.0067376541,
0.058155857,
0.0544920601,
0.0422843993,
-0.0562167428,
-0.0540206917,
0.0270824432,
0.0235190429,
0.0054373164,
0.0017915615,
-0.0486361831,
-0.0600128137,
0.0088750906,
0.0478034057,
-0.0501465313,
0.0411251374,
-0.051770106,
0.0069237798,
-0.0111560822,
0.0476527996,
-0.0446647517,
0.0327314772,
-0.0763489902,
-0.0446195751,
-0.0782307982,
-0.0117540881,
-0.058800824,
-0.0212379098,
-0.0165140498,
-0.00002903,
-0.0328701213,
-0.0079566557,
0.0182466544,
0.081499517,
-0.0117911454,
-0.0183843113,
0.0183342695,
-0.0007202965,
-0.0459753871,
0.0030534968,
-0.0641300231,
0.0393387042,
-0.0287162606,
0.0494173504,
0.0228527673,
-0.0003762935,
-0.0506075248,
0.0688611344,
-0.0210200697,
-0.0739958137,
0.0302422103,
0.0124995997,
0.0150117315,
-0.0090789059,
-0.002254443,
0.0464391261,
0.0408379883,
-0.0450374521,
0.0639652535,
0.0597738288,
0.0173553191,
0.052675806,
0.029870227,
0.0089631323,
-0.0172174517,
0.0124203209,
0.0200181268,
0.0700540692,
-0.0163439307,
-0.0027976141,
-0.0057416121,
0.0101269903,
0.053341087,
0.0553392135,
0.0389380865,
-0.0008066042,
0.0235831775,
-0.0481876619,
-0.0163818821,
-0.0268731602,
0.0352039523,
-0.0091546718,
0.0218340047,
0.0277461689,
-0.0244810302,
0.0336996466,
-0.0101427194,
0.0218477026,
0.0163030885,
0.0166409202,
-0.0062646731,
0.0191444978,
-0.0089057572,
0.0189720429,
-0.0137308678,
0.0136192124,
0.0081762159,
0.0027607349,
0.0193655323,
0.0350559168,
-0.0012472355,
-0.063005425,
-0.0284207817,
-0.0399575308,
-0.0823660344,
0.0234052222,
0.0601924993,
0.098387368,
0.0160258543,
0.0006636494,
-0.0893355086,
0.0128710931,
0.0109347608,
-0.0545566604,
0.0386411473,
-0.0534554534,
0.0795209408,
0.020954961,
-0.0206486154,
-0.0152408276,
0.0315181799,
0.0190114714,
0.1117714047,
0.0168621093,
-0.036440827,
-0.0238570608,
-0.0368403643,
-0.0049367794,
0.0077112569,
0.0173013248,
0.0191678591,
-0.0150585463,
-0.0383759104,
0.0157590155,
0.0293170381,
-0.0118522588,
-0.0256860349,
0.0586997643,
-0.0054595447,
0.017359728,
-0.075053975,
-0.0048983693,
-0.0269365758,
-0.029857561,
-0.012325583,
-0.0383323207,
-6.338857695e-33,
-0.005563735,
-0.0587589182,
0.0779191628,
-0.0255022775,
-0.0321151763,
-0.0096040275,
-0.0563308969,
0.0095213698,
-0.0257483367,
0.0159242935,
0.0044671027,
0.0158484243,
0.0095225722,
0.0476781279,
-0.0249965396,
0.0254694335,
-0.0007315316,
0.0497841462,
-0.0336521603,
-0.0330464952,
0.0539251827,
-0.0329897776,
-0.0295502674,
-0.0058766603,
-0.0527971648,
0.0007444696,
-0.0312402342,
0.0985390022,
-0.0199032836,
0.0411543362,
0.0182716101,
-0.0078565991,
-0.007330541,
0.0072652847,
-0.0173972175,
0.0122361006,
-0.0032303627,
-0.0354338884,
0.0147506846,
-0.0075477073,
-0.0366201028,
-0.0359581672,
0.0091540301,
0.0232069269,
-0.0468839742,
0.0890702754,
-0.0218867119,
0.0026996599,
0.0021001564,
0.0128610041,
-0.0166131314,
0.0153184598,
-0.0108177299,
-0.0015543076,
0.0400801972,
-0.0353248715,
0.0062556504,
-0.0212078001,
-0.0026974934,
0.0015397669,
-0.0147122517,
0.0261535756,
0.0244637821,
0.0110461228,
0.0609402843,
0.0460454226,
-0.0202893876,
-0.0348560251,
0.0144053157,
-0.0076436009,
0.0021173938,
0.0361388847,
-0.0314438455,
-0.0270409714,
-0.0450818203,
0.0427642316,
-0.0869039744,
-0.0285454318,
-0.0149174044,
0.0595092177,
0.0487277508,
0.0375343598,
-0.0194951799,
-0.0128305955,
-0.0690384954,
0.0439098813,
-0.00852706,
0.023421973,
-0.0087743672,
0.0002966966,
0.0116231246,
-0.0184616819,
0.0042159255,
0.0051412997,
-0.0233789645,
0.0556566082,
-0.0192713346,
-0.0063084732,
-0.0026358569,
0.0339805782,
-0.0525404476,
-0.022913903,
-0.042612873,
-0.0389127098,
-0.0098327762,
0.0108149145,
-0.0687037185,
0.0615944378,
-0.0157326385,
-0.0166500434,
-0.0655471757,
-0.0248452891,
0.0145920301,
-0.0126898512,
0.0763928145,
-0.0127767567,
0.0000017776,
0.090216808,
0.0087492028,
-0.0385216363,
0.0413685702,
0.0203319937,
-0.0043358901,
0.0289089289,
-0.0237724427,
-0.0171757396,
-0.015475343,
0.0368170105,
0.0071803685,
-0.0890713856,
0.0132417902,
0.020903131,
3.066e-7,
-0.0053778626,
0.0800646544,
-0.034919329,
0.0393013209,
0.0310574789,
0.0165397748,
0.0149443652,
-0.0645541996,
-0.0389625803,
0.0414046049,
0.0012598997,
0.0828304142,
0.000729125,
-0.0235470645,
-0.0211750139,
0.0581812672,
-0.0130927321,
-0.0906860977,
-0.0464352556,
0.0178832542,
0.0398413986,
0.0659016892,
0.0103664016,
0.001700002,
-0.0389541276,
-0.0616192333,
0.0151466718,
-0.0451391377,
0.0238941889,
0.0132286819,
-0.030424349,
0.0081725884,
-0.0005761135,
-0.0408366062,
0.0211924668,
0.0097351288,
-0.0578327067,
0.0931771025,
-0.040683195,
-0.0328216851,
0.0133324489,
-0.0244660992,
-0.0153404577,
-0.0405461565,
0.0534442253,
-0.0003158162,
-0.0225171428,
-0.0216265544,
0.0416515842,
-0.0056846067,
-0.0161528867,
0.0299287643,
-0.0195858013,
-0.0304836594,
-0.0084169349,
0.0183395613,
-0.0071852915,
-0.081428431,
-0.0087377811,
0.029901972,
-0.0022393495,
-0.0062784092,
0.0031978202,
0.0270941369,
0.0341351256,
-0.0011892803,
-0.0321315378,
2.891867172e-34,
0.0142700439,
-0.0138320057,
-0.0248463061,
0.0013212884,
0.017857207,
0.0422574766,
-0.0039301733,
0.0119784083,
-0.0179331414,
-0.0437941514,
-0.0242351349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13905v1 | Persuasiveness of Generated Free-Text Rationales in Subjective Decisions: A Case Study on Pairwise Argument Ranking | 2024-06-20T00:28:33 | 2024-06-20T00:28:33 | Mohamed Elaraby, Diane Litman, Xiang Lorraine Li, Ahmed Magooda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating free-text rationales is among the emergent capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs). These rationales have been found to enhance LLM
performance across various NLP tasks. Recently, there has been growing interest
in using these rationales to provide insights for various important downstream
tasks. In this paper, we analyze generated free-text rationales in tasks with
subjective answers, emphasizing the importance of rationalization in such
scenarios. We focus on pairwise argument ranking, a highly subjective task with
significant potential for real-world applications, such as debate assistance.
We evaluate the persuasiveness of rationales generated by nine LLMs to support
their subjective choices. Our findings suggest that open-source LLMs,
particularly Llama2-70B-chat, are capable of providing highly persuasive
rationalizations, surpassing even GPT models. Additionally, our experiments
show that rationale persuasiveness can be improved by controlling its
parameters through prompting or through self-refinement. | [
0.0337891132,
0.0719246417,
0.0273266397,
0.0309849717,
-0.0250329785,
0.0219792984,
0.019582659,
-0.0069027883,
0.0379225314,
-0.0409698226,
-0.0080987746,
-0.0188179296,
-0.01073913,
-0.0121943494,
-0.0022098108,
-0.0471191444,
-0.0084775407,
-0.0282796863,
0.0934250653,
-0.027236253,
0.0333241224,
0.0350444242,
-0.0174299963,
0.0403984152,
0.0426861197,
-0.0401255563,
0.0077709956,
-0.0162203759,
0.0032454468,
-0.0543318316,
-0.0181753486,
0.0524618588,
-0.0189596899,
0.007526706,
0.0000020599,
-0.0504057258,
0.0013727626,
-0.027168056,
-0.0593725629,
0.0413953811,
0.0676825866,
0.0741523951,
-0.0003134954,
0.0326983258,
-0.0391973555,
0.0472790971,
0.0227014702,
0.0680700243,
0.061534062,
0.0314923301,
0.0006065743,
-0.024859678,
-0.0240347013,
-0.026945414,
-0.0334363095,
-0.0042625628,
-0.0105370721,
-0.0177841783,
-0.0253733248,
0.0702119544,
0.0343632139,
-0.0272968039,
0.000993634,
-0.0563047566,
0.0156504642,
0.0179825332,
-0.0471104905,
-0.0138470912,
0.011004529,
0.0714208409,
0.0136446394,
-0.0546501689,
0.0169408582,
-0.0099463984,
0.016055543,
0.0113472994,
-0.0733710155,
0.0403441302,
0.002384342,
0.0466036163,
0.0567849874,
0.0408625565,
0.0193807073,
0.0251406562,
-0.0006559379,
0.0471654683,
-0.0111708138,
-0.0259280782,
0.0572421178,
-0.0106095234,
-0.0602457412,
-0.0823919997,
-0.0124169057,
0.019799687,
-0.0201607253,
0.0291191563,
0.0036498175,
0.0401229188,
0.0294864513,
-0.102022849,
0.0025687539,
0.0167131312,
0.0234572329,
0.0506967269,
-0.0283710137,
0.0001390814,
-0.0113949599,
0.0169540923,
-0.0114731267,
-0.0083612697,
-0.0202315375,
-0.0116030294,
-0.0150349364,
0.0350954011,
-0.0627655387,
-0.0030618482,
-0.0170681775,
-0.0157050472,
-0.0351284519,
-0.0128134079,
0.0578018464,
0.0427781679,
0.0191672072,
-0.022368744,
-0.082574442,
-0.0144625474,
-0.0561476201,
0.0114107877,
0.0238664728,
-0.020884702,
0.0052886121,
0.0307364818,
0.0013604695,
-0.0301428568,
0.0140820211,
0.0395819508,
-0.0296187121,
0.0089449119,
-0.0377184413,
-0.0112348851,
-0.0268661082,
-0.0420351699,
-0.0334345922,
-0.0498640239,
-0.0092828022,
-0.0004403555,
0.0034613372,
-0.0242557917,
0.0277580414,
0.0294698235,
-0.0212054178,
0.0504035987,
0.0021641133,
-0.0003259568,
0.0293981042,
0.0256944187,
-0.0351811238,
0.0247596335,
0.0024060695,
0.033686474,
0.0624135919,
-0.0075667561,
-0.0003866878,
-0.039146632,
0.0016312185,
-0.0077073909,
0.0221789312,
0.019157717,
-0.070693709,
0.0320064053,
-0.0085768858,
0.0471844524,
-0.0331848077,
-0.0114203403,
0.0651249215,
0.0786738098,
0.0480723083,
-0.0004819214,
0.017502198,
0.0027391871,
0.0006056558,
0.0184134357,
-0.0199011303,
0.0354025029,
-0.0203054417,
-0.0460310355,
0.057585042,
0.0148925716,
-0.0049245344,
-0.0838785395,
0.0052006305,
-0.0204320215,
0.0237473864,
-0.0135412458,
0.0063470965,
0.0033470271,
-0.0292941611,
-0.0039524911,
0.0190174747,
-0.0568236038,
-0.0335730165,
-0.0331293084,
0.0702731907,
0.0595599599,
0.0155958692,
0.0086696856,
-0.0084456597,
-0.0023214887,
0.0479504429,
0.0444554314,
0.0534162298,
-0.0191255938,
-0.0043176836,
-0.0613184348,
-0.0161027797,
-0.0447640494,
0.0141974054,
0.0160945784,
0.0020760198,
0.0095690107,
0.0107466206,
-0.024331348,
-0.0267988127,
0.0047748708,
0.0067350618,
-0.0346433707,
0.0195025243,
-0.0028174885,
0.0332209319,
0.0292378217,
0.0106235109,
0.0402861573,
0.0306787398,
-0.0352490135,
-0.0467153452,
0.0364960693,
-0.0501427762,
-0.0007263547,
0.0194555242,
-0.000145328,
-0.0006921787,
-0.0001641297,
-0.0029912665,
-0.0179894995,
0.0305286273,
0.0033823245,
0.0152972378,
-0.0105828466,
0.0148504777,
0.0226365421,
-0.0204623435,
-0.0499079749,
0.0753465667,
0.0427319035,
0.0119649479,
0.0331783704,
0.0016261268,
0.0292959847,
-0.0469086021,
0.0159358177,
0.0284953024,
0.015975628,
-0.0016338325,
0.0309120547,
-0.0005952088,
-0.0367014259,
-0.0241395868,
-0.1001720056,
-0.0075115832,
-0.0142747015,
0.0136692738,
0.016526429,
-0.0480169132,
0.0266665537,
0.0246919487,
-0.0579767525,
-0.0155001115,
0.0038244524,
0.0173258521,
0.0548445545,
-0.0177189484,
0.0280397739,
-0.0361141451,
-0.0169018842,
0.0008963695,
0.0546129979,
0.0190774444,
0.0609747246,
-0.0336375684,
0.0054138503,
-0.046324797,
0.005465671,
-0.011569662,
-0.0243243873,
0.0383803099,
0.0202525444,
0.0582642183,
0.0804796964,
0.0446997806,
0.0080103008,
0.0467032865,
0.0136334673,
-0.0783035532,
-0.0313114859,
-0.0258743968,
0.0313624591,
-0.0154571394,
-0.0283262301,
0.0266673099,
0.0472410694,
-0.0134400036,
0.015215545,
-0.0760913715,
0.095625408,
-0.0087030828,
0.0075816074,
-0.0332968459,
-0.0416567102,
0.0008158735,
0.0901518688,
-0.0239853002,
-0.0375427604,
0.0612507574,
-0.0447000712,
0.0193663016,
-0.0337143205,
-0.0368656293,
-0.0560085848,
0.0317171626,
-0.0284942538,
0.003867009,
0.0153185511,
0.0119437966,
-0.0004823271,
-0.0609978661,
0.0494128689,
-0.0457078181,
0.0333148427,
-0.0550225079,
-0.008444963,
0.0154846897,
-0.0293993726,
-0.0094451569,
-0.0634556338,
-0.0251380019,
-0.0330634266,
0.0388674885,
-0.0092843408,
0.042454157,
-0.0044588605,
0.0246196091,
-0.0006496476,
-0.0026139878,
-0.0089235986,
0.0091879498,
0.0310232863,
0.0156149575,
0.0369589068,
0.0440934263,
0.0114111193,
0.047768198,
0.0651712641,
0.0023169117,
-0.0351791717,
-0.0272133518,
-0.0255081933,
-0.0010283721,
-0.0383096859,
-0.0269238427,
-0.0262148399,
0.0739690736,
-0.0161851663,
0.0324169882,
0.094878383,
0.038225472,
-0.0084662503,
0.0005407655,
-0.0502115488,
0.0353402533,
0.0115741305,
-0.0046831826,
-0.036396414,
-0.0167907998,
-0.0073054037,
0.033745002,
-0.0457199812,
-0.0156354513,
-0.0051368955,
-0.1436951607,
0.0402021036,
0.0025293424,
0.0539512821,
0.028559614,
-0.0625279471,
-0.0098880781,
-0.0460097902,
-0.0357444882,
0.0122838272,
0.0051724701,
0.0128997164,
0.0366536155,
-0.0190857854,
0.0196190774,
0.0276921522,
-0.0153037068,
0.0348328613,
0.0054994626,
0.0696360096,
0.0149866622,
-0.0845417157,
0.0268254299,
-0.0376620367,
-0.0153604457,
-0.0263371225,
0.0258280151,
0.0291047674,
0.012164684,
-0.0637151003,
0.0346768834,
-0.0038350183,
-0.0410131142,
0.0070210202,
0.0580856763,
-0.0124104209,
-0.0225000028,
0.0052759205,
0.0322281681,
-0.0232617501,
0.0747986659,
0.0341456532,
-0.0209165812,
-0.0422161184,
-0.0652717948,
-0.0110687288,
-0.051242426,
-0.0704209059,
-0.0427486636,
0.0434708111,
0.0108870082,
-0.0800792128,
-0.0185156856,
-0.0181241799,
0.0283637382,
-0.0166846998,
0.0122980196,
-0.0279901754,
-0.0014039607,
0.0107130595,
0.0411338955,
-0.020603681,
-0.0050834203,
-0.0259787273,
0.0264175311,
0.0288885608,
-0.0312982574,
-0.015747929,
0.001971412,
0.0388908945,
-0.0617790222,
-0.0467017703,
0.0493476018,
0.0271307323,
0.0043291645,
-0.0042519309,
-0.0550333895,
-0.0023739298,
0.0001034036,
0.009746871,
-0.0050449562,
0.0646271929,
0.059258949,
0.021922918,
0.0168915987,
0.0090686427,
0.0322810486,
-0.0236247536,
0.0235496834,
-0.0245617758,
-0.0273424108,
0.0288387965,
0.0291987974,
0.0358790867,
0.0214132033,
-0.0058086286,
-0.0515059307,
0.0188273005,
-0.0398757644,
-0.020572789,
-0.0188145842,
0.0361067913,
0.0198597908,
-0.0176244862,
-0.0120072532,
-0.0428686701,
-0.0309725162,
0.0194344148,
-0.0010133437,
0.0256295726,
-0.0184841901,
0.0000048273,
-0.0171092935,
-0.0062069218,
-0.0314983837,
0.0164199155,
-0.0222772192,
0.0377239212,
-0.0158056114,
0.0534899049,
0.0020269281,
-0.0267185718,
0.0454863049,
0.0264261235,
-0.0440536626,
-0.074396275,
0.0204051398,
-0.0276112128,
0.0108167576,
-0.0128869219,
0.1048187166,
-0.0016124045,
-0.0096479775,
0.0140019953,
0.0254465397,
0.0500018112,
-0.0079566548,
0.0181333702,
0.0184684005,
-0.0439217202,
0.0143485526,
0.0650731772,
-0.0396356471,
-0.0154034412,
0.0295879003,
-0.035120111,
-0.0292471144,
-0.0655620992,
-0.0306919254,
0.0295112655,
0.0039449888,
-0.0173011404,
-0.0475453772,
-0.0007831915,
-0.0295422338,
0.0064520221,
-0.0074574589,
-0.027387049,
0.0264984891,
0.0568751991,
-0.025683511,
0.0137547525,
-0.0624422133,
0.012062164,
-0.0409325436,
0.0134682767,
-0.0232870206,
-6.579186046e-33,
0.004025667,
-0.058153145,
-0.0215925146,
0.0186336208,
0.0013729514,
-0.0310570523,
-0.0333903134,
0.0377266631,
-0.0232172739,
0.0382936373,
-0.0090009216,
0.0155040575,
0.0081528155,
-0.0194904096,
-0.0103638275,
-0.0289648697,
0.0218051728,
0.0057515544,
-0.0468731895,
0.0369579196,
0.0445000269,
-0.0486153513,
-0.0068381615,
-0.0913347676,
0.0601599552,
0.0218611173,
-0.0046211393,
0.0255344491,
-0.0515747778,
0.0671298057,
-0.0070522595,
0.0377134085,
0.0217799861,
-0.0628535002,
0.0275876038,
0.0403466523,
-0.0251189563,
-0.0404092111,
0.0536507815,
-0.0965304449,
-0.0456241816,
-0.0572863109,
0.0247461423,
0.0327796042,
-0.024368288,
0.0127996793,
0.0087811025,
-0.0233633034,
0.0068406011,
0.0139347296,
-0.0047130524,
0.0364735425,
-0.0299993437,
-0.0108272964,
-0.0116841905,
0.0397905819,
-0.0234801415,
0.0822353661,
-0.0143731143,
0.0356509872,
0.0060680574,
0.0192066021,
0.0389307402,
-0.0802794471,
-0.014070252,
0.063771829,
-0.0169274006,
0.0162662417,
-0.0545275509,
-0.0105440421,
-0.0527476482,
0.0510303117,
0.1136381701,
0.0738632455,
0.0507664457,
0.0267614629,
-0.0840212628,
0.0106439227,
0.00986927,
-0.0086837923,
0.0346258171,
0.0008296632,
-0.0204296764,
-0.0083965696,
-0.0539862029,
-0.0291583203,
-0.0535667315,
-0.0448439941,
0.0011061472,
-0.0027914394,
-0.0481142066,
-0.0117597766,
-0.0235627703,
-0.0076264194,
-0.0073482157,
0.0252997577,
-0.0100029269,
0.0119811231,
0.0014755181,
-0.0104456376,
-0.0624377728,
0.035569679,
0.0009276,
0.0123736393,
0.0259646922,
0.0057626534,
0.0021965406,
-0.0446924902,
-0.0567013808,
0.0031602939,
-0.0477314591,
0.0202160887,
-0.0420468338,
0.0239773169,
0.0045209886,
0.0201769415,
0.003951699,
0.0606987774,
-0.0085176909,
0.0178455636,
-0.037352521,
-0.0443781279,
0.0037267485,
-0.0051116915,
0.000343193,
-0.0132346191,
-0.007653214,
0.0246870257,
0.0138634304,
-0.0541867651,
-0.0270351376,
-0.0241480097,
2.663e-7,
0.0230478738,
0.0577902496,
-0.0078896675,
-0.0170274973,
0.0158134215,
0.0411746465,
0.0091679171,
-0.0071003139,
-0.0041640904,
-0.0513639934,
-0.0309435222,
0.0383878537,
0.0414070264,
0.0500959232,
-0.048910819,
-0.0617428869,
-0.0737876222,
-0.0528811663,
-0.0331502669,
-0.0177125428,
0.1049432904,
0.0499139279,
0.0212649144,
0.0245091394,
-0.0078776358,
0.0016065689,
0.0598461293,
-0.0471399091,
-0.0168131292,
0.0072468072,
0.0766598433,
-0.0475138947,
-0.0053083524,
-0.0120918276,
-0.0056495154,
-0.0132198306,
-0.004801298,
0.0809531808,
0.0247705691,
-0.0762653649,
0.0135507956,
-0.0089097237,
0.0203880556,
-0.051832322,
0.0802373365,
-0.0449590236,
-0.0663049221,
-0.0144186737,
-0.0190983284,
-0.0150954444,
0.0159160029,
-0.030677231,
-0.0294274464,
-0.0249557421,
-0.0133996075,
0.0093188751,
0.0114045655,
-0.077844806,
-0.0453253947,
-0.0012135003,
-0.0083843842,
-0.0501705781,
-0.0242066197,
0.0190535374,
0.0276759788,
-0.0354395621,
0.0148915481,
2.276674959e-34,
0.0412282571,
0.0156924874,
0.030231569,
-0.0132736154,
0.045435261,
0.043617934,
0.0188351367,
-0.0258077849,
0.0483853258,
-0.0588457696,
0.0169785637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13903v1 | Generative AI for Enhancing Active Learning in Education: A Comparative Study of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in Crafting Customized Test Questions | 2024-06-20T00:25:43 | 2024-06-20T00:25:43 | Hamdireza Rouzegar, Masoud Makrehchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | This study investigates how LLMs, specifically GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, can develop
tailored questions for Grade 9 math, aligning with active learning principles.
By utilizing an iterative method, these models adjust questions based on
difficulty and content, responding to feedback from a simulated 'student'
model. A novel aspect of the research involved using GPT-4 as a 'teacher' to
create complex questions, with GPT-3.5 as the 'student' responding to these
challenges. This setup mirrors active learning, promoting deeper engagement.
The findings demonstrate GPT-4's superior ability to generate precise,
challenging questions and notable improvements in GPT-3.5's ability to handle
more complex problems after receiving instruction from GPT-4. These results
underscore the potential of LLMs to mimic and enhance active learning
scenarios, offering a promising path for AI in customized education. This
research contributes to understanding how AI can support personalized learning
experiences, highlighting the need for further exploration in various
educational contexts | [
0.0086984597,
-0.0282873921,
-0.0644459873,
-0.009403293,
-0.0554609559,
0.0155331837,
0.016296152,
-0.0268590767,
0.0196483284,
0.0074380706,
0.0084158555,
0.0142627899,
-0.0530922301,
0.0261190534,
0.01887553,
-0.0720227584,
0.0164450966,
-0.0074064326,
-0.0045934999,
0.0204741992,
-0.0337610096,
-0.0139379241,
-0.0458436608,
0.0097557958,
-0.0288066268,
-0.0269056167,
-0.0510988757,
-0.0155683141,
0.0110779162,
-0.053042274,
0.0255788583,
0.0332681984,
0.051183112,
0.0045364713,
0.0000023877,
-0.0486545414,
-0.0137199722,
-0.0137893027,
-0.0194052532,
0.0064685126,
-0.0218294133,
0.1269262433,
0.0097120479,
-0.0073321615,
-0.088457413,
0.0134551981,
0.0316309892,
-0.0015253752,
0.0360958166,
0.0305880103,
0.0027943994,
-0.0096859662,
0.0443380028,
0.0083200485,
0.1044837683,
-0.0365083553,
-0.0026404806,
0.0447862074,
0.063273564,
0.0001417678,
-0.0304491557,
0.0169532411,
0.057926733,
-0.0062819547,
0.0096811634,
0.0237906147,
0.0084528727,
-0.0058393911,
-0.0025554372,
0.0211353786,
0.0483056232,
0.0147455139,
-0.0239377189,
-0.0385379195,
0.0640770495,
0.0468371734,
-0.081997782,
0.0018318855,
-0.0374977775,
0.0196534507,
-0.0062594027,
-0.0204038173,
-0.0278512165,
0.019434765,
0.0199896712,
-0.0157651361,
-0.0003683709,
-0.0364119224,
-0.0125347385,
0.0433743261,
-0.0199472457,
0.0339415744,
-0.0045508244,
0.0820232183,
-0.0155318594,
0.0182962958,
-0.0069574383,
-0.0079736253,
-0.0074131889,
0.0023425589,
0.0561867058,
0.05519199,
0.0150351143,
-0.0062289946,
0.0267484393,
0.0639555529,
0.0043704105,
0.0130199706,
-0.0641939789,
0.0607216284,
-0.0641625971,
-0.0355804935,
-0.0316247493,
0.0836581737,
0.0136685455,
0.0298197065,
-0.0170720872,
0.0434125438,
-0.0264445599,
0.0176596157,
0.0014374243,
-0.0008052049,
-0.0348201469,
0.0074844724,
-0.0432856157,
-0.0131096328,
-0.0465593226,
-0.0034750977,
-0.0207808875,
-0.0248632841,
0.0048598079,
0.0188292265,
-0.0225480683,
-0.0067207678,
0.0138057154,
0.0579101071,
-0.034481708,
-0.0203472394,
-0.0378884822,
-0.021651607,
0.067968227,
-0.0542377308,
0.0462633446,
-0.0303047318,
-0.0115794633,
-0.0208190996,
-0.012074871,
-0.0412807837,
-0.0101547036,
0.0261834338,
0.0691484883,
0.038026318,
0.0240876172,
-0.0166829918,
0.0589759871,
0.0299980082,
-0.0065400735,
0.0371844769,
0.0496348254,
0.0019562177,
-0.0152446441,
-0.053561762,
0.0456361622,
-0.001436186,
-0.0132693667,
0.0181777254,
0.0461997055,
0.0058844462,
-0.0179165434,
0.0190811846,
-0.0824525878,
0.0009547052,
-0.0107413381,
0.085073933,
0.0483675562,
0.024419561,
-0.0129355378,
0.0552725494,
0.0243233163,
0.0134098865,
0.0680587664,
0.0657407343,
-0.0408819094,
0.0450116619,
-0.0111659691,
0.0105907582,
-0.0399740376,
0.0227346011,
-0.014611315,
-0.108519122,
0.0107485289,
0.0044251848,
0.0034470635,
0.0549266599,
0.0347511023,
-0.0172543284,
-0.0137036694,
-0.0256743766,
-0.0242813174,
-0.0283554997,
0.0031767336,
-0.0910351649,
0.0799875483,
0.0213039927,
0.0562363341,
-0.0916539878,
-0.0800829828,
-0.0070782737,
-0.0241334103,
0.0298518073,
0.0249668583,
-0.0201442204,
-0.0621042438,
-0.0344612747,
-0.011406376,
-0.0723267868,
0.0169777665,
0.0169486087,
0.0198886078,
-0.0132767549,
-0.0082219662,
-0.0004835207,
0.0059054205,
0.0199931115,
-0.0793112591,
-0.1078537032,
0.0135946553,
-0.0046119015,
0.0109198652,
0.0198279861,
0.029240679,
-0.0034053181,
0.0381831154,
0.0177446753,
0.0074868905,
-0.0126796635,
-0.0414600447,
0.0536533333,
0.0346530303,
-0.051182434,
-0.0209199768,
-0.0135841696,
-0.0165500287,
-0.0131652029,
0.0217921771,
-0.0209246017,
-0.0099810036,
-0.041387964,
0.0139512233,
-0.038826406,
-0.0397585556,
-0.0447621271,
0.0368464775,
0.0313214958,
-0.0149531718,
0.0363133438,
0.0216379426,
0.0253773704,
0.0268710144,
0.0163232405,
0.0199229643,
0.0025251263,
0.0035587363,
-0.0213042479,
0.0375589468,
-0.0739590675,
-0.0015437756,
0.0089880424,
0.014058358,
0.0124054672,
0.0272416733,
0.0233344492,
-0.0017744245,
-0.0429761633,
0.0062716054,
-0.0584816895,
-0.019222701,
0.0059314677,
-0.0425843783,
0.0104950136,
0.0341270119,
0.0316437334,
-0.0502009615,
0.0233155824,
-0.0481988937,
-0.0425852276,
0.0780261084,
0.0523763448,
-0.0219307281,
0.0092629809,
0.0009402807,
0.0027143406,
0.0247642547,
-0.0039355271,
0.0560070761,
-0.0394850224,
0.0982364193,
0.0262427386,
-0.0174224563,
0.0636721179,
0.0077950605,
-0.0595015064,
-0.0243481901,
0.0609516278,
-0.0372585766,
-0.0140220188,
0.0062138154,
-0.0584117621,
-0.0110302465,
-0.0013535088,
0.0234904606,
-0.0227553099,
-0.0446484126,
0.103227824,
0.0048193703,
0.0259267259,
-0.0040498134,
-0.0083730128,
-0.0311503187,
0.0013002766,
0.0257359445,
-0.0470383428,
0.0658146143,
0.0378951356,
-0.0010542115,
-0.069299005,
0.0381012894,
-0.0172551144,
0.0491321385,
0.0104991961,
-0.0263224188,
-0.0220730305,
0.0157681666,
-0.0709869862,
0.0099565564,
0.0288486183,
-0.0462501235,
0.0427994616,
-0.0866384581,
-0.0599925816,
-0.0072798128,
-0.011098519,
-0.0478185937,
0.0724462345,
0.0441460758,
0.0018934462,
0.0083171939,
-0.0098886406,
0.0293692723,
-0.0415157899,
0.0240548551,
0.0053835311,
-0.0376940817,
-0.0346007682,
-0.0170618165,
0.0217803046,
0.0333684459,
0.0083238911,
0.0066089081,
-0.030464679,
0.035772305,
0.0337778516,
0.0197775774,
-0.0302619953,
0.0375740342,
0.0441507138,
0.0031047212,
-0.0479191355,
0.0261155982,
0.0260239691,
0.0108610308,
-0.0451438911,
-0.0349436775,
0.0675531179,
0.0291457083,
-0.033872135,
-0.0242653713,
-0.0598608702,
-0.0175066125,
0.0024743527,
0.0514009893,
-0.0295458753,
0.0430724137,
-0.0361218192,
0.0395090915,
-0.0469478145,
-0.0091627436,
0.0030867769,
-0.0635746568,
0.0587812774,
0.0100451503,
-0.0196936186,
0.0179249421,
0.0193742942,
-0.0126819927,
0.0460534655,
0.0232111402,
-0.0142274927,
0.016744921,
0.0612213053,
0.0421468578,
0.0127505306,
0.0098717408,
-0.0244134292,
0.0602715611,
-0.0067161652,
0.0335541554,
0.0017509212,
-0.0532321334,
-0.0476729088,
0.0215756837,
0.020191988,
-0.0214572791,
-0.0279114544,
-0.0134838829,
0.0295363329,
0.0167757347,
-0.0574161112,
0.0264590755,
0.0162721779,
0.001728563,
0.0905362219,
0.0837625191,
-0.0266190022,
0.0105587738,
-0.0387204923,
-0.0302320272,
-0.0046991324,
-0.0020208498,
0.0364965014,
-0.0204124302,
0.0145638548,
-0.0498935319,
0.0234029777,
-0.0522636026,
-0.0492288992,
-0.0164033342,
-0.0024993815,
0.0688952878,
-0.0109623438,
-0.0540158898,
0.0720008016,
0.0309162643,
0.0028902835,
-0.0071926326,
-0.0044809119,
0.0154195875,
-0.0175270252,
-0.0149686188,
0.0233322363,
-0.0365218148,
-0.0364482068,
-0.0878680944,
0.0108494367,
-0.0922135562,
0.0055332389,
0.006806517,
-0.0413060561,
-0.0428645536,
0.0091193812,
0.0572061054,
0.0218961351,
-0.0084623415,
0.0297831614,
0.0309147704,
-0.0002187818,
-0.0244240221,
0.0375216939,
-0.0067538861,
-0.030925829,
0.0091065988,
0.0222718865,
-0.0319618061,
0.0221723039,
-0.0077407947,
0.0287113637,
0.0111123081,
-0.0011384898,
-0.0311489291,
0.0464289188,
0.054097373,
0.0034757068,
-0.0188470185,
-0.018886609,
-0.0158572216,
0.0271189641,
-0.0434914641,
0.0036091835,
-0.0110978661,
-0.0472978912,
0.021947464,
0.0254933406,
-0.0145364432,
-0.0259728935,
-0.0319114029,
0.0434460826,
-0.0629894435,
0.0553864725,
-0.0139072528,
0.0274152458,
-0.0096624596,
-0.0159264058,
0.0003309836,
0.0181054063,
-0.0005925716,
0.0632444024,
0.0371790938,
0.1066246331,
-0.0062556108,
0.0156492591,
0.024998771,
0.0307114925,
-0.0015382131,
-0.0702423975,
-0.0388936549,
0.0693054646,
-0.0146518322,
0.0134351999,
-0.0484042428,
-0.0516791791,
0.0159978997,
0.0170170721,
-0.020473985,
0.0095991949,
-0.0090367049,
-0.0011194014,
0.0258728918,
0.0535592139,
-0.0487252958,
0.0204815548,
-0.0106799817,
0.0378460549,
-0.0283713192,
0.0270586703,
-0.0326670036,
-0.0352268592,
0.0535003133,
0.0071340604,
0.0411196426,
0.0137125654,
-0.025498813,
-0.0356462337,
-0.0291209407,
0.0125137372,
0.0012590181,
-0.0581010245,
0.0475590304,
0.0402626395,
-0.0535548031,
-0.0458023362,
0.037781924,
0.040189784,
-0.0451442301,
-0.0248069912,
-0.0030952848,
-6.413542728e-33,
-0.0299489442,
-0.0512942895,
0.0571432039,
0.0716569349,
-0.0327377059,
-0.0523183942,
-0.0273307357,
0.0407619253,
0.0068750968,
-0.0307343472,
-0.0004895267,
-0.0191175137,
-0.0138623007,
0.0140991509,
0.0080289273,
-0.0390147865,
0.0054366649,
-0.0152033586,
0.0098900115,
0.0430194959,
-0.0614483319,
-0.0262904949,
0.0446675271,
-0.0560571179,
0.0227717664,
-0.0381291881,
-0.0063547213,
-0.0377854072,
-0.1026137844,
-0.0024450929,
-0.0023945628,
0.0316788852,
0.0197287109,
-0.0001755811,
0.0080697918,
-0.0035049194,
-0.012613547,
-0.0711500943,
0.0210498497,
-0.0056299497,
-0.0430141613,
-0.0757396221,
0.0017510004,
-0.0168563575,
-0.0301128775,
-0.0128724072,
0.0582817346,
0.0057796785,
0.0301038232,
-0.0268002078,
-0.0673082918,
-0.0125415623,
-0.0517805405,
0.0062355241,
-0.0087666325,
0.016004134,
0.0057272133,
-0.0248118266,
-0.001960448,
0.0517992228,
0.0457852744,
-0.0151202781,
-0.0007019081,
-0.0180377774,
0.0159231778,
-0.0170883033,
0.0259544048,
-0.0027334525,
-0.0556223243,
0.0028578318,
-0.0053134188,
0.0026880824,
0.0786372647,
0.0396357067,
-0.0059840954,
0.0143752731,
-0.0313819349,
0.0487321168,
0.0449707918,
-0.0335177742,
-0.0109261395,
-0.0295262188,
-0.028754035,
0.0124171227,
-0.0065910122,
0.0193380602,
-0.0004753463,
-0.056987986,
0.0187827349,
-0.0681359842,
-0.0208963472,
-0.0324872956,
-0.0217464156,
0.0151486117,
0.0345523842,
-0.0571917854,
-0.0041495129,
0.0444342829,
-0.0086648948,
-0.0118011134,
0.0028406573,
-0.0145284599,
-0.0051849429,
-0.0061116866,
0.0184678752,
0.0368940644,
-0.0407347344,
0.031212911,
0.0005271122,
0.0124775143,
-0.0329592153,
0.0221351441,
0.0460893251,
-0.0281541459,
-0.011750347,
0.0190830138,
-0.0150217004,
-0.0221715532,
0.0192366652,
-0.0285707209,
-0.0669571087,
-0.0161964428,
-0.0456870086,
-0.0155806206,
0.0057959124,
0.0051404503,
-0.0235656016,
0.0248676874,
-0.0071705389,
-0.0758455396,
0.0016616496,
0.0047220211,
3.085e-7,
-0.0119879209,
0.028298283,
-0.0019426541,
0.0046829185,
0.0036623061,
-0.0015976036,
-0.016928073,
-0.0525252372,
0.0866429657,
0.0282759946,
0.0548388362,
0.0412763804,
-0.0150899682,
0.0247741137,
-0.0567889735,
-0.0066050719,
0.0502155833,
0.0173568837,
-0.0385333933,
0.0719167814,
0.0782654881,
-0.0467230976,
0.0379889496,
0.0078398008,
-0.0017028686,
-0.0150591806,
0.0172520522,
-0.0232415497,
0.0121650007,
0.0266764909,
-0.0299649611,
0.0212740339,
0.0075342692,
-0.0058076908,
-0.0052235895,
-0.0241020434,
-0.0105679473,
0.0426505767,
0.0524398908,
-0.0246053524,
0.0409145355,
0.0160206985,
0.0437807888,
-0.0397810377,
0.0405348651,
-0.0127301542,
-0.0083425483,
0.0805623978,
-0.0349992365,
-0.0313888304,
-0.0026850968,
-0.0155438185,
-0.0020348469,
-0.0130747491,
-0.0277913827,
0.0017185705,
0.0351152122,
0.0038959538,
0.0092584807,
-0.0435600542,
-0.0809418261,
-0.0072169579,
-0.0693606362,
-0.0064038695,
-0.0152785499,
0.0008914499,
-0.00528761,
2.411667399e-34,
-0.0044011199,
-0.0264709257,
0.0826899558,
0.0250604302,
-0.0076364824,
0.0428641662,
0.0172502454,
0.0335905924,
0.0443444103,
-0.0087330285,
-0.0409621708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13898v1 | The Use of Multimodal Large Language Models to Detect Objects from Thermal Images: Transportation Applications | 2024-06-20T00:05:10 | 2024-06-20T00:05:10 | Huthaifa I. Ashqar, Taqwa I. Alhadidi, Mohammed Elhenawy, Nour O. Khanfar | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY | The integration of thermal imaging data with Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs) constitutes an exciting opportunity for improving the safety and
functionality of autonomous driving systems and many Intelligent Transportation
Systems (ITS) applications. This study investigates whether MLLMs can
understand complex images from RGB and thermal cameras and detect objects
directly. Our goals were to 1) assess the ability of the MLLM to learn from
information from various sets, 2) detect objects and identify elements in
thermal cameras, 3) determine whether two independent modality images show the
same scene, and 4) learn all objects using different modalities. The findings
showed that both GPT-4 and Gemini were effective in detecting and classifying
objects in thermal images. Similarly, the Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE)
for pedestrian classification was 70.39% and 81.48%, respectively. Moreover,
the MAPE for bike, car, and motorcycle detection were 78.4%, 55.81%, and
96.15%, respectively. Gemini produced MAPE of 66.53%, 59.35% and 78.18%
respectively. This finding further demonstrates that MLLM can identify thermal
images and can be employed in advanced imaging automation technologies for ITS
applications. | [
-0.0347388163,
-0.0038432404,
-0.0055286339,
0.1364138126,
-0.0352891311,
0.0515289791,
0.0425638966,
0.0127395438,
0.016157778,
-0.0975209624,
-0.0126753654,
-0.0132991103,
0.0097361309,
0.000968567,
0.0184151679,
-0.075713329,
-0.0270199198,
-0.084973909,
-0.0183944702,
-0.006908359,
-0.007892889,
-0.0152951013,
-0.0024009072,
0.0123386597,
-0.063760139,
0.0145139601,
-0.0186243355,
-0.0143920397,
0.0408427753,
-0.0036063294,
-0.0202716924,
0.0490121618,
0.0697138608,
0.024856627,
0.0000017651,
-0.0385606438,
0.0096135559,
-0.0020442796,
0.0719750524,
-0.0423846506,
0.0858705118,
-0.0135002835,
-0.0020533882,
0.0014632912,
-0.0303471927,
-0.0257822163,
0.0714259744,
0.0512445457,
-0.014097116,
0.0373315923,
-0.0041437582,
-0.0704533383,
0.0319066085,
0.0530080311,
0.001486239,
-0.0300279055,
0.0097191967,
0.0066428203,
0.0210628975,
0.0102932407,
-0.0108383475,
0.0506105386,
0.018837275,
0.006401883,
-0.038384404,
0.0671101287,
0.0022761996,
0.0070000677,
-0.0164576918,
0.0327390097,
-0.0455011278,
-0.0381401777,
-0.0355420746,
0.0333174989,
-0.024151748,
-0.0125859389,
-0.0015248663,
0.0391915478,
-0.0096270386,
0.0221948009,
-0.0846633092,
-0.0101236301,
0.0057781856,
0.0310891662,
-0.0105193425,
0.0515467301,
0.0361736715,
0.0254656393,
0.0049523064,
0.0191111751,
-0.0321881957,
-0.0238468666,
-0.0461493991,
0.0289770514,
-0.0249185767,
0.0070311408,
-0.0450319722,
-0.002724129,
-0.007330792,
-0.0428169854,
0.0516908094,
-0.0124974214,
-0.0428408757,
0.0517834798,
-0.0401682779,
0.0383419469,
-0.0147941327,
0.0079013947,
-0.0538755246,
-0.0423906296,
-0.0432083793,
-0.0192603692,
-0.0336234309,
-0.0332679339,
0.0167289916,
0.0191152338,
-0.0201206394,
0.0092301685,
0.0472123809,
-0.0038456037,
-0.0425660163,
-0.0130795036,
0.0051441239,
0.0029073432,
0.0116730286,
-0.0125008719,
0.0417963751,
0.0077774068,
-0.0105126211,
-0.0187664833,
0.0500626564,
0.0655591711,
0.0123411482,
-0.0422216766,
-0.0109141916,
0.0813629925,
-0.0322916545,
-0.0659732148,
-0.0560730733,
0.0142481495,
0.0107948948,
-0.0561035573,
0.0405299179,
-0.0620303899,
-0.0254301559,
0.0118614184,
0.0188077949,
0.0300255511,
-0.0066408236,
-0.0457909852,
0.0031846596,
0.1179754287,
-0.0460020192,
-0.0325186625,
0.0494899713,
0.0024400281,
0.0222907234,
0.0841196403,
0.0479208678,
0.021782795,
0.0264135618,
-0.0325395055,
0.0286261253,
0.0119682569,
-0.0787599087,
0.0176603552,
-0.0770803615,
-0.0097059738,
-0.0034778621,
0.0060175932,
0.0138597591,
0.0343949907,
0.0055948962,
-0.0273813531,
0.0630218238,
0.0127295107,
-0.0156314746,
0.0001190632,
-0.0019459891,
0.0269498285,
0.0096370466,
-0.012728665,
-0.0088345474,
0.0343534797,
-0.0711301193,
-0.0218472462,
-0.052094169,
0.0389119312,
-0.0563591793,
-0.0237150081,
-0.0399098806,
-0.0556113012,
0.0224087834,
-0.0252890121,
0.0739626884,
-0.1121000946,
0.0239529312,
-0.0304925628,
-0.0017833936,
0.0291910786,
-0.0446268097,
-0.0671582744,
0.0062922635,
0.0251255836,
-0.0462292023,
-0.0027255649,
-0.0000868709,
-0.0189608131,
-0.0199101549,
-0.0346306935,
0.0170126297,
0.0512682758,
0.0255047642,
-0.0366286933,
-0.0662520379,
0.0095844558,
0.0118342573,
0.0143530592,
-0.0293699242,
-0.0063808495,
0.0321175344,
0.0261238534,
0.0345666222,
0.0113176042,
0.0170513652,
0.0027738907,
-0.0452825911,
0.0202228352,
0.0222434774,
-0.0530923419,
-0.0227756612,
-0.0396725759,
0.0482193828,
-0.00937068,
-0.0334770307,
0.0539887846,
0.0207238514,
0.027428722,
0.0559434257,
-0.0320816636,
-0.0275153704,
0.0462457202,
-0.0655945018,
-0.0312000923,
-0.0017293229,
-0.0534666292,
-0.0105285784,
-0.0444365814,
-0.0274931844,
0.0184729304,
0.0083647901,
-0.0106312903,
0.0513353683,
0.0137147391,
0.0037621921,
0.0026819739,
-0.0117177377,
0.03640626,
-0.0373248197,
-0.0111001087,
0.0121719893,
0.0202847514,
0.0258014966,
0.0003877229,
0.0372147933,
0.0149794072,
0.0098221004,
-0.0534817018,
-0.0261618905,
-0.0276660249,
-0.0277352761,
0.014606961,
-0.0142534319,
0.001068244,
-0.0015984384,
0.0249552093,
0.0433741212,
-0.0078080441,
-0.0452704877,
0.0095621608,
-0.0123765813,
-0.0410851873,
0.0007000955,
-0.0332235135,
-0.0099937571,
0.0402031094,
0.0344082899,
-0.0421187989,
-0.0372996293,
0.021749584,
-0.0035805143,
0.0439189933,
-0.027186377,
-0.0500651672,
-0.0145400455,
-0.0442215838,
-0.0009418286,
0.0960720628,
0.0673578307,
-0.0466190465,
0.0211178213,
-0.0017098032,
0.0068472181,
-0.0076068859,
-0.0063453377,
-0.0098536154,
-0.0051302579,
0.0087562529,
-0.034668386,
-0.0065618129,
-0.0100182528,
0.0029792858,
0.0240840688,
-0.0012562312,
-0.0349778011,
-0.0664545447,
-0.0557321869,
0.010753491,
-0.0061888639,
0.0285787676,
-0.0032964239,
-0.0664501488,
-0.003604644,
-0.0394586436,
0.028190583,
-0.0044243005,
-0.0149099901,
-0.0312804021,
0.0347941928,
0.0733642504,
0.0477226302,
-0.0150930118,
0.0348763205,
0.0304790493,
-0.0677078962,
-0.024152359,
0.0230067335,
0.0457553677,
-0.0672003329,
0.047333315,
-0.0220542457,
-0.0256005824,
0.0037384226,
0.0182205644,
-0.0229816958,
-0.0083805369,
-0.027566269,
-0.0397579186,
-0.030266745,
0.0632964596,
0.0187516436,
0.0602840707,
0.028019309,
0.0189150665,
-0.0528160743,
0.0324948207,
0.0531985536,
0.0133054797,
0.0109963045,
-0.0313824415,
0.0245845634,
0.0257237144,
0.0153562715,
0.0060760351,
-0.1481011957,
0.028469624,
0.0306905247,
0.0521678664,
-0.0492065027,
0.0141069172,
0.0507511646,
-0.0370192938,
0.010555394,
0.0486570187,
-0.0303971972,
-0.0446930788,
-0.0135763381,
0.044391457,
-0.0186553877,
-0.0221171547,
-0.0259782281,
-0.0628157109,
-0.0364319906,
0.0092910444,
-0.0249760859,
-0.0163850524,
-0.0022416371,
0.0343050919,
-0.034106914,
0.0473440997,
0.0144124217,
-0.0712569878,
-0.0498593152,
-0.0201892965,
0.0028785442,
-0.0131317582,
0.0379883274,
-0.0240324978,
-0.0314951576,
-0.0378297009,
0.0307026282,
0.0170156099,
-0.0294622295,
-0.0302940365,
-0.0549622662,
-0.0360798165,
0.0251717996,
0.0145241292,
-0.0704171807,
-0.0304029472,
0.0034714567,
0.0271867197,
-0.0084391655,
-0.0181057453,
-0.0049683154,
0.0141937276,
0.0116812615,
0.017587224,
0.038723059,
-0.0093643572,
0.0005124551,
-0.0349330604,
0.0553821214,
-0.0229507014,
-0.0237442702,
-0.0580419041,
-0.0491494313,
0.0019762269,
0.0264352411,
-0.03216739,
0.0117718196,
-0.0337521397,
-0.0111052161,
-0.0255091954,
0.0074235597,
-0.0126207881,
0.0075472747,
-0.0568102002,
-0.0240807999,
-0.0102800196,
-0.011829949,
-0.0010220329,
0.0270014647,
-0.0251751021,
0.012197935,
0.0130965495,
0.0413606316,
-0.0378725342,
0.0417615399,
0.006925764,
0.0277642235,
-0.051791627,
0.0222072247,
0.0533082262,
-0.0179923922,
-0.0029636843,
0.0536224283,
-0.0554823652,
-0.0278651565,
0.0120908413,
0.0484463535,
0.024514284,
-0.0039181802,
-0.0139851859,
-0.0725301281,
-0.0178897679,
-0.004967256,
0.0397336595,
0.0158113334,
-0.0247287564,
-0.0326516889,
0.0029859717,
-0.0051614554,
-0.0193950534,
0.0843331292,
0.0038449403,
-0.0748026595,
-0.0033506595,
-0.0404018015,
0.0235532112,
0.0132547449,
0.0251321401,
0.0196998697,
0.0356734991,
-0.0170678794,
0.0083884532,
0.0450793169,
0.0072033782,
-0.0523044765,
0.0148370676,
0.014306088,
0.0438777469,
-0.0028225149,
-0.0349791981,
0.0360395573,
0.0002030077,
-0.0256876294,
0.0309572816,
0.0372342207,
0.0014743929,
-0.0365031064,
-0.0094062351,
-0.0027456947,
0.015462256,
0.0168953501,
0.0047316272,
0.0269545279,
0.0660169423,
0.0321874544,
-0.0352884904,
-0.0357139148,
0.047180444,
-0.0067225769,
-0.0285709929,
-0.0301089752,
0.0379015096,
0.0956323296,
-0.00260692,
0.0040628202,
-0.0815273151,
0.0092856158,
-0.070635289,
0.0645457432,
0.0539880805,
0.0338456333,
0.0977208912,
0.0081821429,
-0.0205950364,
-0.009182631,
0.0186511949,
0.0356586501,
-0.0029921331,
0.0313240662,
-0.0215060599,
-0.0391668305,
0.0242036059,
0.0693848729,
-0.0591356866,
-0.0264264569,
0.0067301509,
0.0178924073,
-0.033135388,
-0.0188300963,
0.0203673374,
0.0280394293,
0.0042458237,
0.0204312634,
0.0446926877,
0.0398927778,
-0.1106720045,
0.0122841755,
-0.0126438532,
0.0218734834,
0.0291887708,
0.0151154734,
-5.387714155e-33,
-0.0033666,
-0.0400967449,
0.0296481587,
0.0311105289,
-0.0091133695,
-0.0094371866,
0.055816792,
0.0086931949,
0.011672752,
-0.0136304293,
0.0123835811,
0.0036283042,
0.0205287337,
0.0087755984,
0.0117391571,
-0.0242299251,
0.0071010408,
-0.0169616267,
0.0217332691,
-0.0312167909,
0.0361233763,
0.0092647411,
0.0441842899,
-0.0402246341,
-0.0354664959,
-0.0009493232,
-0.0085711936,
0.0100771235,
-0.0295208283,
0.050098706,
-0.0220560133,
0.0350624062,
0.0502033457,
0.0383219644,
-0.0274450593,
0.0713971704,
-0.0079235844,
0.0073501901,
-0.0164805409,
0.0768797249,
-0.0433589108,
-0.0236377269,
0.0339184701,
-0.0377230309,
-0.0229192562,
0.0132824192,
0.0340761989,
-0.0395771451,
0.0235907603,
0.0144894067,
-0.0468181372,
0.0398437604,
0.0228196997,
0.0108880997,
0.0574437194,
0.0087557137,
0.0068260916,
0.0433297977,
-0.0371049233,
-0.0123874769,
0.0247665774,
0.0282121692,
0.0516067222,
0.0428495891,
0.0258886404,
0.0303157549,
0.027417738,
-0.0511480272,
0.0171868373,
-0.0478156321,
0.011914528,
0.093115665,
0.020343041,
0.0486594327,
0.0132281678,
0.011559274,
-0.0492176451,
-0.0159134977,
-0.0103687048,
0.0498462468,
0.0066326461,
-0.020444883,
0.0017263733,
0.0178871006,
-0.0117111746,
0.0170895793,
-0.0176048707,
-0.0157183837,
0.0311710071,
0.013487543,
-0.0165469628,
0.0014305268,
0.0499755554,
-0.0290669128,
0.0284033436,
-0.0561153367,
0.020793492,
0.0152186686,
0.0300321411,
0.0554048903,
-0.0655969679,
-0.0736422166,
-0.0116687231,
-0.008116127,
-0.0155890193,
-0.00833767,
-0.0041003991,
0.05902116,
0.011938178,
0.0136083197,
-0.018683292,
-0.0171116013,
0.031823054,
0.0118096545,
0.0466847755,
-0.0015816092,
0.025664309,
0.0301393941,
-0.0294262376,
-0.0455990694,
-0.0354908966,
-0.0285442546,
-0.0546624996,
-0.0173660796,
0.0119502889,
-0.0105150351,
-0.026345253,
-0.0825549513,
0.03131973,
-0.051624842,
0.0101166368,
0.0298160929,
2.569e-7,
0.0037862819,
0.0299673844,
-0.0278302487,
-0.0401156694,
0.0190129243,
0.0672704354,
-0.0327034183,
0.0274567008,
0.002183977,
0.010039134,
-0.0560443588,
-0.0141047947,
0.0251798183,
0.0406487472,
0.006011711,
0.0031425997,
0.0545017757,
-0.0120012769,
-0.0708118901,
0.0494807288,
0.0617988035,
0.1007555872,
0.0409567505,
-0.0170456264,
0.0342342481,
-0.048681777,
0.0547326505,
-0.0666576847,
-0.0213236138,
-0.0153047107,
0.0859721825,
0.0213101897,
0.0169329401,
0.0548979267,
0.0512300059,
0.0201589223,
0.0139894113,
0.0148794074,
-0.0167623237,
-0.0112306215,
0.0328937285,
-0.0044911169,
-0.0223795325,
-0.0800486505,
0.0569955222,
-0.0090491995,
-0.0002248573,
-0.0136419823,
-0.0125685055,
-0.0503184684,
-0.0050142133,
-0.0078495666,
0.0076583996,
0.0097943339,
0.0057318546,
-0.0642016158,
-0.0065137623,
-0.0334441252,
0.0227042362,
-0.0148247089,
-0.0627743751,
0.001008143,
-0.0043681688,
-0.0005193063,
0.0717343986,
-0.0027172675,
-0.0464617759,
1.751146103e-34,
-0.0071631274,
0.0072441488,
-0.0251725707,
0.0014574862,
-0.0076781055,
0.0180560313,
-0.0676143318,
0.012591145,
-0.0548082292,
-0.0562146939,
0.0332170501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13893v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13893v1 | Open Generative Large Language Models for Galician | 2024-06-19T23:49:56 | 2024-06-19T23:49:56 | Pablo Gamallo, Pablo Rodríguez, Iria de-Dios-Flores, Susana Sotelo, Silvia Paniagua, Daniel Bardanca, José Ramom Pichel, Marcos Garcia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have transformed natural language processing.
Yet, their predominantly English-centric training has led to biases and
performance disparities across languages. This imbalance marginalizes
minoritized languages, making equitable access to NLP technologies more
difficult for languages with lower resources, such as Galician. We present the
first two generative LLMs focused on Galician to bridge this gap. These models,
freely available as open-source resources, were trained using a GPT
architecture with 1.3B parameters on a corpus of 2.1B words. Leveraging
continual pretraining, we adapt to Galician two existing LLMs trained on larger
corpora, thus mitigating the data constraints that would arise if the training
were performed from scratch. The models were evaluated using human judgments
and task-based datasets from standardized benchmarks. These evaluations reveal
a promising performance, underscoring the importance of linguistic diversity in
generative models. | [
0.0036429637,
0.0686216429,
-0.0124954684,
0.0421832167,
0.0017122877,
0.0110664461,
-0.0040223072,
-0.0235751532,
-0.0139137618,
-0.0317653753,
-0.0361306816,
-0.0413246267,
-0.004728416,
-0.0350161009,
0.0460877828,
-0.0426447131,
0.0279740579,
-0.0487098098,
-0.0476394184,
-0.0524034947,
-0.0042583803,
0.0192358419,
0.0221800078,
0.0446561538,
0.034182433,
-0.0101501839,
0.0412913971,
-0.0176424831,
-0.0014639716,
0.0126292733,
-0.0093962597,
0.0494990796,
-0.0020072509,
0.070680432,
0.0000019665,
-0.0548900664,
-0.0221488401,
0.0008871934,
0.0066856346,
0.0141760455,
0.0509109162,
-0.0149448765,
-0.0183401573,
0.0309589077,
-0.045873858,
-0.1038230211,
0.0462345332,
0.0044208155,
0.027560452,
0.0421764813,
-0.0144797936,
-0.0747603551,
0.0410497822,
-0.0669913888,
0.0114343073,
0.0151766418,
0.0188751575,
-0.0286569688,
-0.0095933545,
0.0169327818,
-0.0128135355,
0.0136897685,
0.0097154602,
0.0044895313,
0.0007845965,
0.0478391536,
-0.0213868599,
-0.028533034,
-0.0058883359,
0.032826893,
-0.0498918295,
-0.0214408934,
-0.0044087311,
-0.0073292078,
-0.0316501334,
-0.0027971722,
-0.0674077719,
0.0617069826,
0.0268431045,
0.0477122515,
0.0315569565,
-0.0048997612,
0.0446169525,
0.0175351724,
-0.0194783136,
0.0322003998,
0.0644098371,
-0.0141394055,
0.0438328721,
0.0361687317,
-0.0386137255,
-0.027869368,
-0.0192123801,
0.009118964,
-0.0114973774,
0.0084359571,
0.0074056094,
-0.0163802449,
0.0646867976,
-0.0694778711,
0.0190706383,
-0.0093139959,
-0.0192227159,
0.042831786,
-0.0330244415,
0.0285257716,
-0.0468903184,
-0.0258682519,
-0.0367114022,
-0.0666124672,
-0.0279855411,
-0.0116083408,
-0.0445827506,
-0.0168135501,
-0.0609686673,
0.0126751494,
-0.0180996973,
0.0126162451,
0.0174180903,
-0.016417319,
0.0529694669,
0.0197433289,
-0.0346462727,
-0.0187809356,
-0.011504448,
0.0593245327,
-0.0275515523,
0.0265997238,
-0.0166664254,
-0.10520228,
0.0031730053,
0.0356428027,
-0.0122916326,
-0.0694963261,
0.0190316457,
0.0514987521,
0.0105902394,
-0.0240353085,
-0.050021559,
-0.0139583712,
-0.0323521718,
-0.089217104,
0.0036710831,
-0.0977359042,
0.0276412629,
0.0115707191,
0.0434069559,
-0.0409874655,
-0.0021623792,
0.0163226966,
-0.0240917057,
0.0394523591,
-0.0082247816,
-0.0063347337,
0.0232223738,
-0.0229459368,
0.013678628,
0.0821669996,
0.0215202793,
0.0052363947,
0.0361015126,
-0.0065186368,
-0.0076621408,
0.0775810555,
-0.0171284042,
-0.0151084606,
0.0179237146,
0.0116856694,
0.0200369544,
0.0477960706,
0.092334412,
0.0606286079,
-0.015326024,
0.0183527991,
0.066735059,
0.0449477322,
0.0423192754,
0.0263116099,
0.0718437806,
0.0011197291,
-0.0104550999,
-0.0406410545,
-0.00045472,
-0.0360522904,
0.0100444518,
0.016650632,
-0.0050443634,
0.0853219554,
-0.0373802409,
0.0083235158,
-0.0046959599,
-0.0010950899,
-0.026891835,
-0.0301561188,
0.0716477334,
0.0059857853,
-0.0191109814,
0.0043110228,
0.0506919473,
-0.0455105565,
0.0293074436,
-0.0327288918,
0.0462629944,
0.0352155901,
0.0558656715,
0.0151944356,
0.009255467,
-0.0303651262,
-0.0153892236,
0.0386128984,
0.0156971831,
-0.0138568385,
-0.001447876,
-0.0761115775,
0.0135024861,
0.0198598988,
0.0173580218,
0.0449186824,
0.0162545331,
0.0274053812,
0.0181038249,
-0.0425445363,
-0.0341037251,
0.0195321739,
-0.032057289,
-0.0543145537,
0.0332972072,
-0.0165009964,
-0.0168517251,
0.0396105275,
-0.039793212,
-0.0145418178,
0.0325131156,
-0.0387170725,
0.0021711441,
0.0248295907,
-0.0393766053,
-0.0088350391,
0.0067450469,
-0.0490119681,
-0.0080046542,
-0.0150665184,
-0.0139319506,
-0.0375612304,
0.0132336048,
-0.0231701527,
0.0388478413,
-0.0820709988,
0.0155480364,
-0.0061873351,
0.0389261469,
-0.03564227,
0.0749364644,
-0.0075230687,
0.0393694751,
0.0095200036,
0.0062384051,
0.0046766526,
-0.0966421589,
-0.0227455366,
0.0560400002,
0.0082148537,
0.0134070069,
0.0048340349,
0.0353364833,
-0.0019805992,
-0.0132647604,
-0.1070667952,
0.0402795486,
-0.0283148754,
0.0217467397,
0.0112191904,
0.0246173441,
-0.0274887513,
0.0025659411,
-0.0295687858,
-0.0204135347,
0.0483567007,
0.0096359244,
-0.0065753716,
-0.000069824,
0.0223941952,
-0.0380911343,
-0.0034171878,
0.0350064449,
0.0396602303,
0.0092592128,
0.0069879685,
-0.0540678687,
0.0266103316,
-0.0033533298,
0.0332851186,
0.0090998486,
-0.0308189783,
0.0014102382,
-0.012628207,
0.1059475914,
0.0307728499,
-0.0059975293,
-0.002097087,
0.0369980261,
0.0017594696,
-0.0263008941,
-0.0069415756,
-0.0163535941,
-0.0369751453,
-0.0677262992,
-0.0282369796,
0.011097366,
0.0754128098,
0.0021544697,
-0.0261585489,
-0.0346427262,
-0.0069252555,
-0.0464926884,
-0.0264925249,
-0.0083690695,
0.0344319046,
-0.0174335577,
0.0024587796,
-0.0237931777,
-0.0340600349,
-0.0022473808,
-0.0513131842,
-0.0051223738,
-0.0480612814,
-0.0074098748,
-0.0397469476,
0.0336787961,
0.0346010849,
0.0069244546,
0.0038122814,
-0.0126815541,
-0.0223267097,
0.0216418356,
0.0250279028,
-0.0088322712,
0.0406164341,
-0.0531731434,
0.0059063383,
-0.0197723638,
-0.049247399,
-0.0111168073,
-0.0243230388,
0.0058485176,
0.009511942,
0.0610378608,
0.0015130794,
0.0095027592,
-0.0198222976,
0.0148258498,
0.0619561747,
-0.0077108378,
-0.0033005162,
-0.0266499054,
0.0520187914,
0.0158851705,
-0.0035969738,
0.0264260899,
-0.0627159029,
-0.0178232808,
-0.0114344899,
0.0193077102,
-0.0271968991,
-0.0224459954,
-0.0162482373,
0.0340593942,
-0.0341106728,
-0.0532584637,
-0.0225561094,
0.0357491635,
-0.0165477861,
-0.0231909286,
0.0931737944,
0.0157713704,
-0.043431066,
-0.0041745794,
-0.0219523273,
0.0495309494,
0.0136882178,
0.0366364531,
-0.0899028555,
-0.0129786385,
0.0069768806,
0.0004516508,
-0.0105045512,
-0.0181823932,
-0.029786393,
-0.1555685699,
0.0241412818,
-0.0092733987,
-0.0195981003,
-0.0090522058,
-0.0294094924,
-0.0263744928,
-0.0839524716,
0.008504021,
-0.0013486475,
-0.0266074706,
0.0329647772,
0.0469470099,
0.0009744073,
-0.0660159066,
-0.0033579841,
-0.0468775518,
0.0333329625,
0.0554123744,
0.0006453823,
-0.0268924348,
-0.0159755405,
0.0417787842,
-0.022403609,
-0.0078995647,
-0.0349623077,
-0.0112580135,
0.0340051576,
-0.0066851894,
-0.0424699858,
0.0215324499,
0.0045422139,
-0.0056537869,
0.016387023,
0.0879950374,
0.0114863291,
-0.0107588228,
0.0287065916,
-0.0582775176,
0.0054248907,
0.0347434133,
0.0111050177,
-0.0329374373,
-0.0303378124,
-0.0011382634,
-0.0154016549,
-0.0191938821,
-0.0322423838,
0.0372978933,
0.0062530674,
-0.0579214506,
-0.0540554002,
-0.0549765714,
0.0218602549,
0.0029724734,
0.0166313406,
0.0105111599,
0.0001162929,
-0.0138652986,
-0.0158285275,
0.0634812787,
-0.0221631657,
-0.0100584403,
-0.0775758848,
-0.0155473119,
0.0194293559,
-0.006554903,
-0.0186483935,
0.0221012197,
-0.0889807492,
-0.0628150553,
-0.0017666187,
0.0422809422,
0.0275091212,
0.0167863723,
-0.0344930626,
-0.081786938,
0.0334763378,
0.0447335094,
-0.0303895269,
0.0256243069,
0.0069890479,
-0.0041686748,
0.0189471114,
0.0487053022,
0.0034302019,
0.0285238829,
-0.007122254,
0.0352076106,
0.0086212074,
0.0057426179,
-0.0193411857,
-0.0144393593,
0.0642407387,
-0.0621176697,
0.0206228737,
-0.0805033296,
-0.0187672898,
-0.0364844427,
0.0313787684,
-0.0119046858,
-0.0169583037,
0.0400861427,
0.0318602622,
-0.0463003069,
0.0398713611,
-0.0000919623,
0.0393829234,
-0.0936716571,
0.0083931293,
0.0217298493,
-0.0143944733,
0.0196882375,
0.0265546199,
0.0044413009,
0.0277238805,
-0.0322686583,
0.0196923986,
-0.0234239828,
0.0164604671,
-0.0181915816,
0.0005933526,
0.014756985,
-0.0033947153,
0.0121417539,
-0.0525641218,
-0.0343597792,
0.0439193174,
0.1066033021,
-0.0135120749,
0.0770321339,
0.0029305159,
-0.0095328577,
-0.040657118,
0.0112754684,
0.0089796679,
-0.0208449606,
0.0435501635,
-0.0094576506,
-0.0348011553,
-0.0270883646,
0.0933007672,
0.0097999517,
0.0412783399,
-0.0231225323,
0.0144056175,
-0.0119554978,
-0.03293157,
0.0041100001,
-0.0571681075,
-0.0460716859,
0.0079051703,
-0.0565609001,
-0.0489416569,
-0.033164911,
0.0088032354,
0.0036646051,
0.0088163484,
0.046784725,
0.0532573201,
-0.0294147376,
-0.0454813167,
-0.0491783656,
0.0192619432,
-0.0127781108,
-0.022823941,
-0.0052666217,
-6.293798792e-33,
-0.0131214866,
0.0111473156,
0.0216161273,
-0.0674335733,
-0.0109366365,
-0.0093392525,
-0.0016944869,
-0.0131304646,
-0.0065108216,
0.0059243026,
-0.0133721177,
0.0006303769,
0.0219878145,
0.0415925309,
0.0375478677,
0.0515135005,
0.0625603274,
-0.0018789758,
0.0163164549,
0.0205152053,
0.0213297829,
0.0178742241,
0.0837983042,
-0.0306563582,
0.0377540812,
-0.0133763794,
-0.0135381948,
0.0351596512,
0.0321432054,
0.0482854433,
-0.0374965854,
0.0692275539,
0.0245154873,
-0.0674497113,
-0.0314819105,
0.0152757345,
-0.0419148766,
-0.037583217,
0.0747606233,
0.0234772637,
0.0174115244,
-0.055204004,
0.0218338277,
-0.0076511223,
-0.0439188518,
0.0182057358,
0.0327858776,
-0.0074435356,
0.0082984623,
0.0072949473,
-0.0485237837,
0.041241508,
0.0317768641,
0.0347979255,
0.0010600261,
0.0329753645,
-0.0352116823,
0.0058281822,
-0.0253160503,
0.0097602149,
0.0437099934,
0.041324567,
0.0543795899,
0.0188583378,
0.045561187,
0.0378075577,
0.0101886149,
-0.050654836,
-0.0317227729,
0.0268650763,
0.0192061346,
0.0233282484,
0.0268060267,
0.0634816661,
0.0243975669,
-0.0015379671,
-0.1040839031,
0.0009195941,
0.0022916063,
0.0127197271,
0.0235152543,
-0.003467924,
0.0076292679,
0.0071979691,
-0.0321373381,
-0.0489625074,
0.0046835179,
-0.0146939233,
0.0240418278,
0.0029949225,
0.0312237013,
0.0043708202,
0.0469470732,
-0.0231935568,
-0.0471936725,
0.0148659414,
-0.0208787378,
0.0104456265,
-0.0088182883,
0.0592717677,
-0.0803627148,
-0.0212030988,
0.020527076,
0.033507254,
-0.0199305061,
0.0061776331,
0.020239098,
-0.0100912545,
-0.0696005821,
0.0270587411,
-0.0439615473,
0.0531527176,
-0.0116503825,
0.0573408157,
0.0368232019,
0.0154212303,
-0.0040313299,
0.06054952,
0.0246909,
-0.0057198317,
-0.0162820779,
-0.0488186553,
0.0168472435,
0.0262763072,
-0.0273795296,
0.037207026,
0.00125398,
0.0257416572,
0.0093384162,
-0.0003231034,
-0.0097619621,
-0.0191872716,
2.7e-7,
0.0458595194,
0.024047412,
-0.0089564966,
0.028719455,
0.0253521483,
-0.0115013588,
0.0156340189,
0.061011333,
-0.0528208688,
0.0361704752,
-0.0296958908,
0.0363782495,
0.049154833,
0.028414242,
-0.080481872,
0.0145453513,
-0.0386829525,
0.0091571026,
-0.0699834526,
-0.0383742005,
0.0248005651,
0.1342222393,
-0.0124677392,
-0.008876022,
-0.0084457295,
-0.0368821211,
0.0891931206,
-0.0288977977,
-0.0328479968,
0.0104043297,
0.0471368842,
0.0425834246,
-0.0073497794,
-0.0180205218,
0.0131159946,
0.0204475187,
-0.0101823639,
0.0592410937,
-0.0086337179,
0.0286909379,
0.0756154135,
-0.0649445429,
-0.0378357209,
-0.0736491308,
0.0525558367,
-0.0230457112,
-0.0220251177,
-0.0048813159,
-0.0035634963,
-0.013714754,
0.0394484885,
-0.0505178049,
-0.0378463604,
0.0012704303,
0.0309139173,
-0.0255409237,
-0.0289798975,
-0.0488831252,
-0.0182070453,
0.0131019801,
-0.0421193391,
-0.0599604882,
-0.0230623577,
0.0215023868,
-0.0000845438,
-0.0352104716,
0.0316867009,
2.131700001e-34,
0.0195197091,
0.0335735716,
-0.0191850439,
-0.0128617259,
0.0266121309,
-0.0099546909,
0.0007652216,
0.0108972769,
-0.0234538242,
-0.0610182807,
-0.0118705723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13892v1 | Adaptable Logical Control for Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T23:47:59 | 2024-06-19T23:47:59 | Honghua Zhang, Po-Nien Kung, Masahiro Yoshida, Guy Van den Broeck, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the success of Large Language Models (LLMs) on various tasks
following human instructions, controlling model generation at inference time
poses a persistent challenge. In this paper, we introduce Ctrl-G, an adaptable
framework that facilitates tractable and flexible control of LLM generation to
reliably follow logical constraints. Ctrl-G combines any production-ready LLM
with a Hidden Markov Model, enabling LLM outputs to adhere to logical
constraints represented as deterministic finite automata. We show that Ctrl-G,
when applied to a TULU2-7B model, outperforms GPT3.5 and GPT4 on the task of
interactive text editing: specifically, for the task of generating text
insertions/continuations following logical constraints, Ctrl-G achieves over
30% higher satisfaction rate in human evaluation compared to GPT4. When applied
to medium-size language models (e.g., GPT2-large), Ctrl-G also beats its
counterparts for constrained generation by large margins on standard
benchmarks. Additionally, as a proof-of-concept study, we experiment Ctrl-G on
the Grade School Math benchmark to assist LLM reasoning, foreshadowing the
application of Ctrl-G, as well as other constrained generation approaches,
beyond traditional language generation tasks. | [
0.0349348933,
0.0866281986,
-0.0152035439,
-0.0043744072,
-0.0596867912,
-0.0234588757,
0.0133288736,
-0.0067138053,
0.0187029634,
-0.0390445404,
0.0165333748,
0.0011995714,
-0.0128313769,
0.0511034392,
0.0308634471,
-0.0596375428,
0.0725651607,
-0.0648011714,
-0.038217105,
0.0148307839,
-0.0194451995,
0.0024710619,
-0.010481921,
0.0267582927,
-0.0117375897,
-0.0129298829,
-0.0324351415,
-0.0171982422,
0.0080764247,
0.0130826859,
-0.0457007997,
0.0627317131,
-0.0094443746,
0.0448327772,
0.000002399,
-0.0409378782,
-0.0294432696,
0.0039717779,
0.0018201694,
0.0263467431,
0.0134594617,
-0.0023397608,
-0.0606130436,
0.0146597447,
-0.0288145691,
0.0598134771,
0.050559029,
0.0022931367,
0.0820797011,
0.0544739738,
-0.0110748205,
-0.0003504489,
0.0278212633,
-0.0162010044,
0.0380099043,
-0.0351479128,
0.0257429164,
0.0313633531,
0.064405486,
-0.0303172488,
0.0004873637,
0.0346690863,
0.0523109026,
-0.0515002795,
-0.0369783379,
0.0312104281,
-0.0219006557,
-0.0508934259,
-0.026752783,
0.0407666825,
-0.0069383876,
-0.0596463829,
0.0303434227,
-0.0156027237,
-0.0046616746,
0.0292240605,
-0.0546015725,
0.0443224832,
-0.0263398718,
0.0098258276,
0.0275665764,
-0.0368758291,
0.0215361994,
-0.0065659173,
-0.0354175344,
0.0774665475,
0.0443127826,
-0.0364961214,
-0.0347227976,
-0.0103191659,
-0.0319298729,
-0.0907516852,
0.0361407623,
0.0563801453,
-0.0639597401,
0.0210916251,
-0.1020465717,
-0.0221330188,
0.0256542899,
-0.0353418328,
0.045806706,
0.0824079812,
0.0093202088,
0.0219636764,
-0.0296199061,
0.0791518092,
-0.0451564826,
0.0288307853,
-0.0041590775,
0.0426581763,
-0.0435450375,
-0.0137275094,
-0.0541199967,
0.0022634394,
-0.0267396532,
-0.0037685363,
-0.0256208498,
0.0756006166,
-0.0156044289,
0.0524599776,
-0.0083457548,
-0.0408986993,
-0.0230634119,
-0.0247782059,
-0.00844994,
-0.0099457568,
-0.0183973499,
-0.0298065003,
0.0155576067,
-0.0442833938,
-0.0017747279,
0.0048232395,
-0.0075257821,
-0.0349638015,
-0.0044883322,
0.0860331282,
-0.0295538232,
0.0121394349,
-0.0060653598,
-0.0478885435,
0.0035646341,
-0.0678013042,
-0.0050491933,
-0.0504585505,
-0.0148256123,
0.012378077,
-0.0384168588,
-0.0655175894,
0.0188607238,
0.039644558,
0.0334350355,
0.0340101793,
-0.0046625878,
-0.0102291089,
-0.0031111471,
-0.007506663,
-0.030373767,
0.0327413678,
0.0626585707,
0.0289141983,
0.0087370127,
0.0125123821,
0.0195498243,
0.0674086362,
0.022041576,
-0.0033199964,
-0.0651609078,
-0.0032834793,
0.0110284537,
0.0313730612,
0.0056301798,
0.0746069849,
0.0035803665,
0.0257661808,
0.0357292853,
0.0137316436,
-0.0056031859,
0.0596597008,
0.0573678277,
-0.0155105684,
0.0021482497,
0.0287204385,
-0.0714775398,
0.0400137864,
-0.0382915139,
0.0377047658,
0.0133897839,
0.0158599168,
0.0297084227,
-0.0470944308,
-0.0088681774,
0.0414290763,
0.0149682993,
-0.006568661,
0.0394407436,
0.0039326954,
-0.037102133,
0.05890413,
-0.0042734956,
-0.0630847216,
-0.0385585912,
-0.0824104548,
0.0455201827,
0.0633750185,
0.0841659456,
-0.0298852865,
-0.0344375074,
0.005376114,
-0.0158681553,
0.0538124777,
0.0565408058,
0.0174477547,
-0.0350694284,
-0.018164536,
-0.0021304432,
-0.0050802724,
0.0132842064,
0.0262701884,
0.0276959613,
-0.0126416078,
0.0113351587,
-0.0156928506,
-0.0040215626,
0.0441644304,
-0.0447051227,
-0.0290407799,
-0.0288581736,
0.0094916122,
0.003933371,
-0.0333205089,
-0.0206736121,
0.0320396274,
0.014205968,
-0.0154183386,
-0.004878121,
-0.0025494061,
-0.069338493,
0.0045000413,
0.0657047331,
0.0067088581,
-0.0382813849,
0.0091570122,
-0.0260784198,
-0.0358922072,
0.0359532312,
-0.023326423,
0.0249752328,
-0.0275457781,
0.0126226041,
0.0123521229,
-0.064321354,
-0.009384905,
0.0556204356,
0.0047396137,
-0.0157052837,
0.0603791624,
0.012231132,
0.0178787038,
-0.0431012549,
0.0225561466,
0.0047419635,
-0.0150351822,
-0.0046087569,
0.0018523332,
0.0528190769,
-0.0062833945,
-0.0552365407,
-0.0255421028,
0.0090887751,
-0.0328486711,
0.0243737008,
0.0187224168,
0.0135938739,
-0.0331567265,
0.0094960751,
-0.0282935724,
-0.0321167149,
0.0267470628,
-0.0027983175,
0.0243190341,
0.0101918234,
-0.0484983474,
-0.047227174,
-0.0239497051,
-0.0378358774,
-0.0146012176,
0.0288413595,
-0.0399027206,
-0.0345259644,
0.048811879,
-0.0120006325,
0.0673860162,
-0.0145514663,
-0.0025186166,
0.0246395152,
-0.0265507139,
0.0746190473,
0.0503597893,
-0.0301580429,
0.0212323535,
0.0798182189,
-0.020887075,
-0.0145511413,
0.04573147,
0.0137600005,
-0.0165095273,
-0.0044973479,
-0.0240874551,
-0.0061768945,
0.098982349,
-0.0235309359,
-0.009119573,
-0.064257957,
0.0229287837,
0.0067598727,
-0.0086915083,
0.001962407,
-0.0380527675,
-0.0563146919,
0.0552854463,
-0.0533575043,
-0.0650132746,
0.0597629435,
-0.0496251844,
0.0030707086,
-0.0252111461,
0.013116017,
-0.018628452,
0.0695251226,
0.0263334792,
0.0036330016,
0.0180231556,
0.0008788456,
-0.0556894913,
0.0303886551,
0.0400435925,
-0.0094973836,
0.0440059081,
-0.0658708885,
0.047639925,
-0.0166492239,
-0.0145723838,
-0.0447403006,
-0.0017602175,
-0.0355398767,
0.0241789799,
0.0368269607,
-0.0526856519,
-0.0097302552,
0.0115937609,
0.031215217,
0.0504230782,
-0.0210590791,
-0.017502863,
-0.0410456061,
-0.0253253542,
0.049956955,
-0.0077410173,
-0.0185110644,
-0.0438723117,
-0.0174790621,
0.0415238552,
0.0164043084,
-0.0022223047,
0.0127300797,
-0.0049774642,
0.0095598623,
-0.0459069386,
-0.0113411564,
0.0411303453,
0.0292883273,
-0.0708204582,
-0.0498893186,
0.0971599072,
0.0417205729,
-0.0106106475,
0.0162011907,
-0.029321393,
0.0745341107,
0.0202916861,
0.0609706752,
-0.1054973528,
-0.0360839441,
0.0318610482,
0.0155710969,
-0.0180532765,
-0.0277216323,
-0.0146680884,
-0.1059077606,
0.0209958348,
0.0089516565,
-0.0218286738,
-0.0032845496,
-0.0176981129,
-0.0029097481,
0.0168773029,
-0.016635377,
0.0259350967,
-0.0127751818,
0.0147760976,
0.0125681972,
0.0084461374,
-0.0157610271,
0.0121643515,
0.0212177336,
0.0105424607,
0.0715243593,
-0.0121841449,
0.0067208479,
-0.0538994782,
0.0653576851,
0.0753459185,
-0.006670244,
-0.0313780345,
-0.0180535205,
0.0285057146,
-0.0096133351,
-0.0333423652,
0.0240043569,
-0.0003611785,
-0.036530789,
-0.0075114197,
0.1163785309,
-0.0213715211,
-0.023170352,
-0.0198813733,
-0.0306107122,
0.002366449,
0.0624616407,
0.041263748,
-0.0344639346,
-0.0600346029,
-0.0760942847,
-0.0356392749,
-0.0740954727,
-0.0286192596,
-0.0210764874,
-0.0091550192,
-0.007489658,
-0.0327211171,
-0.0087074991,
0.0499192774,
0.0239498205,
0.0083535099,
-0.0306592286,
0.0607448183,
-0.0410385281,
-0.0585130714,
-0.0126859965,
-0.0386925228,
0.0327931345,
-0.0599896871,
-0.0144600654,
-0.0358190425,
-0.0085309567,
-0.0191536639,
0.037658114,
-0.0664065778,
-0.0765490606,
-0.0224761683,
0.0688143373,
0.0314433426,
0.0140734743,
-0.0114592705,
-0.0401186757,
-0.0090571111,
0.0103064114,
0.0053422228,
0.0065168953,
0.0010173385,
-0.0219235048,
0.0142990062,
0.0277129132,
-0.0319553465,
-0.0110193985,
-0.0011282589,
0.0516010374,
-0.0163113791,
-0.027575817,
0.0295808744,
0.0308881495,
-0.0269395299,
-0.0280456282,
0.0277386326,
-0.0319762975,
0.0122738993,
-0.0537235811,
0.0072941417,
-0.0620732717,
0.0482745655,
-0.0122179035,
-0.028141696,
0.0063395845,
-0.0516885035,
-0.0289228167,
0.0279464163,
-0.0257366784,
0.047511071,
-0.0227007773,
0.0249088909,
0.086248517,
-0.0301735774,
0.0051924828,
0.0385917164,
-0.0047238534,
0.0467193387,
-0.0253655761,
0.0546532646,
0.0442631654,
-0.0044167382,
-0.0145942066,
-0.0024648565,
-0.0239998642,
-0.0541607067,
-0.0182124823,
0.0456909686,
0.0663521886,
0.0387231298,
0.0488578528,
-0.0764205605,
-0.0100385556,
-0.0117918551,
0.0331210271,
0.0637600422,
-0.0430375859,
-0.0086133042,
0.0202179458,
0.009507006,
-0.0561634898,
0.051009018,
0.0149238333,
0.0367644466,
0.0170965903,
-0.0162842479,
-0.0439177677,
-0.0272810552,
-0.0170089025,
-0.0179435071,
0.0001613728,
-0.0066402676,
-0.0782424659,
-0.05562751,
-0.0059690266,
0.0652639866,
-0.0065470883,
-0.0260917787,
0.0270234849,
0.0326325074,
-0.0043666465,
-0.0284957439,
-0.004597262,
0.0220897831,
0.0085186092,
-0.0407030359,
-0.0269845519,
-6.426544431e-33,
-0.0366846174,
-0.024631016,
0.04208358,
-0.0199814439,
-0.0107022813,
-0.0543605052,
-0.0887738615,
0.0190245453,
0.0384922773,
0.0025813861,
-0.0075352169,
0.0025814676,
0.0044570798,
0.0107791973,
0.0103017138,
0.0226702113,
0.0394946113,
0.0084206313,
-0.0542735457,
0.0206452701,
0.0239037741,
0.0026210537,
0.034728121,
0.0077246851,
0.0053652604,
-0.003463201,
-0.0096072098,
0.0113721406,
-0.0668616742,
0.0622091554,
-0.008967991,
0.0170070827,
-0.0010752585,
-0.0173229929,
-0.0314426757,
0.0296261273,
-0.0263866186,
-0.0438743234,
0.0147524439,
-0.0128495516,
-0.0366907865,
-0.0570019893,
0.028767487,
0.0089363633,
-0.032380186,
-0.0042170775,
0.0010922427,
-0.0098774368,
-0.009683066,
-0.0374652334,
-0.076965861,
0.0386079215,
0.0110816751,
-0.0343669802,
0.0041526025,
0.0029791309,
-0.0017503676,
-0.0418771133,
-0.0089857168,
0.002170915,
0.0767815411,
0.0393015854,
0.0770046115,
0.0000093846,
0.0250661857,
0.0132145593,
-0.0094031952,
0.0243876278,
-0.0447278693,
0.0465006493,
0.0101621635,
0.0422551148,
0.0179979783,
-0.0070308987,
0.0441811793,
0.0109139169,
-0.0493752211,
-0.0018109715,
-0.0042145434,
0.05052476,
0.0146127492,
0.0236551967,
-0.0242291819,
0.0055189235,
-0.0327481329,
0.0258377101,
-0.0138798989,
-0.0139057012,
0.0558212101,
-0.000881106,
-0.0200807936,
-0.0047284882,
0.0082551129,
0.0130883995,
-0.0435515568,
0.0119128041,
-0.0364127345,
0.0234758426,
-0.0249875542,
0.0309140254,
-0.0243979283,
-0.01018894,
-0.0019904999,
-0.0209451914,
0.0383391753,
0.0464921407,
-0.0210205223,
0.0435870811,
-0.0650938898,
0.0091258148,
-0.0560220331,
0.0385844223,
0.0256231241,
-0.0004184443,
0.0357105583,
-0.0248652622,
0.0243929308,
0.0145181818,
0.0045835543,
-0.0617829487,
-0.0342175402,
0.0513760597,
-0.0004180744,
0.0287491493,
-0.0141672492,
-0.0057703094,
-0.0594694987,
0.072381869,
0.0283796396,
-0.0669841096,
-0.0065300944,
0.0145417452,
3.073e-7,
0.0172344968,
0.0581065379,
0.0420819856,
0.0703191385,
0.0171057563,
0.0262385812,
0.0008124158,
-0.0114492811,
0.015524446,
0.0011492328,
-0.0138348481,
0.0254682973,
0.0207764972,
0.0292843282,
-0.0316207595,
0.0233633611,
-0.0280156601,
0.0133149773,
-0.0601518489,
0.0089924224,
0.0842582509,
0.0350015648,
-0.0033050017,
-0.0012637964,
0.0211848859,
-0.0545668975,
0.0405857898,
0.0092216358,
0.0181189626,
0.0216504317,
0.0340378918,
-0.0298172925,
-0.0020568168,
-0.0099695744,
-0.0051937355,
-0.0081317993,
-0.0274853241,
0.0966147557,
-0.0031348884,
0.0254683718,
0.0203847904,
-0.0401821844,
-0.0087463288,
-0.0487665348,
0.0688011646,
-0.0217253044,
0.0332618095,
-0.0020257037,
-0.0186987482,
-0.0205879454,
-0.0389969684,
0.0014016922,
-0.0054911934,
0.0238680355,
0.0064569283,
0.0104227494,
-0.0137568712,
-0.023095794,
-0.0493670031,
-0.0111934328,
-0.0469801053,
-0.0269571934,
-0.0873346776,
0.0174178258,
-0.0104146684,
-0.031291388,
-0.0365202799,
3.511964779e-34,
0.0263893865,
-0.0274067558,
0.0362826474,
0.0163013376,
0.032569252,
0.0147047304,
-0.0115203289,
0.038914144,
0.0306614079,
-0.0721321926,
-0.0569844432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13890v1 | ClinicalLab: Aligning Agents for Multi-Departmental Clinical Diagnostics in the Real World | 2024-06-19T23:44:25 | 2024-06-19T23:44:25 | Weixiang Yan, Haitian Liu, Tengxiao Wu, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Haoyuan Chai, Jiayi Wang, Weishan Zhao, Yixin Zhang, Renjun Zhang, Li Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLMs have achieved significant performance progress in various NLP
applications. However, LLMs still struggle to meet the strict requirements for
accuracy and reliability in the medical field and face many challenges in
clinical applications. Existing clinical diagnostic evaluation benchmarks for
evaluating medical agents powered by LLMs have severe limitations. Firstly,
most existing medical evaluation benchmarks face the risk of data leakage or
contamination. Secondly, existing benchmarks often neglect the characteristics
of multiple departments and specializations in modern medical practice.
Thirdly, existing evaluation methods are limited to multiple-choice questions,
which do not align with the real-world diagnostic scenarios. Lastly, existing
evaluation methods lack comprehensive evaluations of end-to-end real clinical
scenarios. These limitations in benchmarks in turn obstruct advancements of
LLMs and agents for medicine. To address these limitations, we introduce
ClinicalLab, a comprehensive clinical diagnosis agent alignment suite.
ClinicalLab includes ClinicalBench, an end-to-end multi-departmental clinical
diagnostic evaluation benchmark for evaluating medical agents and LLMs.
ClinicalBench is based on real cases that cover 24 departments and 150
diseases. ClinicalLab also includes four novel metrics (ClinicalMetrics) for
evaluating the effectiveness of LLMs in clinical diagnostic tasks. We evaluate
17 LLMs and find that their performance varies significantly across different
departments. Based on these findings, in ClinicalLab, we propose ClinicalAgent,
an end-to-end clinical agent that aligns with real-world clinical diagnostic
practices. We systematically investigate the performance and applicable
scenarios of variants of ClinicalAgent on ClinicalBench. Our findings
demonstrate the importance of aligning with modern medical practices in
designing medical agents. | [
0.0249967724,
0.0234307386,
-0.0016477957,
-0.019780783,
-0.0285667274,
0.0177992713,
0.0285054035,
0.0400667563,
0.0164405834,
0.0206168834,
0.0284003094,
-0.0062010097,
-0.003535799,
0.0087185623,
0.0115909334,
-0.0052333176,
0.0410748497,
0.0299218893,
-0.0005951159,
0.0130253742,
-0.0215843953,
-0.0011957946,
-0.0330310315,
0.0562638864,
-0.0108949309,
-0.0433959849,
0.0299076531,
-0.0332160518,
0.0591173619,
-0.0702043325,
-0.021527702,
-0.0133667244,
-0.0446652398,
-0.0008507351,
0.0000020949,
-0.0897082165,
-0.0229678769,
0.0244479664,
-0.0451548956,
-0.0436501391,
0.0404541306,
-0.0147496536,
0.0196000487,
0.0141723119,
-0.0343676805,
-0.009950133,
0.0239515305,
-0.0019254385,
0.0225318242,
0.0652218685,
-0.0017515249,
0.0327636898,
0.0253657512,
0.0005260998,
0.012428687,
-0.0829958245,
0.0239825696,
0.0035631962,
0.0808293298,
-0.0393132232,
0.0242056977,
0.0152131626,
0.0036286279,
0.0300648939,
0.0170574971,
0.040346019,
0.0051215035,
-0.0345474668,
-0.0010879018,
0.0656970143,
0.0278513469,
0.0149001507,
0.0219038725,
-0.0219664183,
0.0109158903,
-0.0097422274,
0.0104650892,
-0.0197822265,
-0.03691452,
-0.0300826225,
0.0397188663,
0.0133086778,
0.0357382596,
-0.0160961263,
-0.0027011475,
0.0451098569,
-0.0026761384,
-0.0129983164,
0.0208814107,
0.0155043928,
-0.0083630588,
-0.0448082425,
0.0306158345,
0.0427595563,
-0.1253029555,
0.0016759207,
0.0052347709,
-0.0294025932,
0.0999234617,
-0.0529099219,
0.0374160893,
-0.0050585894,
0.0151502481,
0.0274628121,
-0.0310949869,
0.057741493,
-0.0215094332,
0.0799467266,
-0.0580268241,
0.0108780619,
-0.04142702,
0.0029978591,
0.0184806269,
0.0157697424,
0.024309203,
-0.007174049,
-0.0717247203,
0.0078381756,
-0.0527082421,
0.0381875634,
0.0267867874,
0.0450066663,
0.0173485409,
0.0563004576,
-0.0482646003,
0.0122491075,
-0.0300207604,
-0.0025886795,
0.0116977561,
-0.0166840367,
0.0166731682,
0.0011489715,
-0.0074908491,
-0.0073563978,
0.0484652109,
0.0987462699,
0.0371924415,
-0.0034183844,
0.0161632597,
-0.0498304106,
-0.032385204,
-0.0509534366,
-0.0201295875,
-0.053310398,
0.0503945611,
0.0469110534,
-0.0119606834,
-0.0503932387,
-0.0017346632,
-0.0112273078,
-0.0152323171,
0.0449495912,
-0.0770935565,
0.0073365909,
-0.0076876082,
0.0321625546,
-0.0498567894,
0.0103168003,
-0.0124871247,
-0.026170278,
0.0179522373,
-0.0415244736,
0.0289897043,
-0.0025000062,
-0.0044301348,
-0.0126607539,
0.0209574457,
0.0391052403,
0.0119467806,
0.1143350601,
-0.0159123056,
0.0276239589,
0.0277950503,
-0.0254968442,
0.0163289662,
0.0454075076,
0.0711862147,
-0.0474376865,
0.0068550236,
-0.0470965393,
-0.0146730207,
-0.0164236203,
0.0050948686,
0.0130683435,
-0.0111530758,
-0.0101766447,
-0.030013429,
0.0143162385,
-0.0288373698,
-0.0613323487,
-0.0960886702,
0.0106475186,
-0.0278783813,
0.0057913973,
-0.0207979176,
-0.0489196107,
-0.025119124,
0.0601353943,
0.0301219933,
-0.0069972547,
-0.0213741716,
-0.0842899606,
-0.027351737,
0.108862929,
0.0366572812,
-0.0509500541,
-0.0692915246,
-0.0099873189,
-0.0146962656,
-0.0198955778,
0.008102959,
-0.0135614108,
0.0190440994,
-0.0216844436,
-0.0203078017,
0.0266319197,
0.0127423387,
-0.0125477668,
-0.0205509998,
0.0224007685,
-0.0567017496,
-0.07184048,
-0.0169496033,
0.064304851,
-0.0700829551,
-0.027098801,
0.0188725758,
0.0023721026,
0.0398733355,
0.0256486442,
-0.0050114412,
0.0262853652,
0.0189997852,
-0.0001891595,
-0.031979192,
-0.0116762873,
0.0239222758,
-0.0317377299,
0.0151001466,
-0.017337881,
-0.046192091,
-0.001542651,
-0.0433373563,
-0.0128418645,
-0.0353707559,
-0.0647106618,
-0.0104898354,
0.0265564695,
0.0218171179,
0.0175434556,
0.0051754932,
-0.0430523679,
0.0209778938,
-0.0154972374,
0.0000468923,
0.0091853049,
-0.0038468412,
0.0169072319,
-0.0268215276,
-0.0202595219,
-0.0276278444,
-0.010530035,
0.0237232372,
-0.0296638887,
-0.0189058352,
-0.047215376,
-0.0222359411,
-0.0640986264,
0.0128794592,
0.0503212139,
0.0046515218,
0.0174689014,
0.0015968595,
0.0033198434,
0.0012568844,
-0.0454006828,
0.0106003191,
0.0514266081,
0.0352352373,
0.0736797377,
0.0369786173,
-0.0440912917,
-0.0406323746,
0.0200065654,
-0.0658884346,
0.0194367655,
-0.0059231031,
0.023040846,
-0.0147179952,
0.0113908714,
-0.0581325442,
-0.0132495444,
0.0217082873,
-0.0128634572,
0.0240884554,
-0.0158615857,
-0.0629034415,
0.0972254351,
-0.0312716216,
0.0287257917,
0.0517156012,
-0.0057907207,
-0.0314146206,
0.0098066311,
-0.020258788,
-0.0002317784,
0.0378569998,
-0.0371210538,
0.0008376878,
0.0517408252,
0.0076824566,
0.0200136509,
-0.0128932856,
0.0083152093,
-0.0133700836,
-0.0127264131,
-0.035741929,
0.0058748741,
-0.0406337902,
0.0288310852,
0.0074426895,
-0.0239563789,
0.0859614387,
0.0024860585,
0.0502754524,
-0.0633565634,
-0.0299441256,
-0.0430491976,
0.0114723854,
-0.0263112057,
0.0149504794,
-0.0190601554,
-0.006937176,
0.0181754567,
0.0067679337,
-0.002163586,
-0.0885557309,
0.0642154291,
-0.0251908675,
0.0528289303,
-0.0036089581,
-0.0405871198,
-0.0561863109,
0.0070863999,
-0.0070427712,
0.0111715253,
-0.0292281862,
0.0241281856,
-0.0834736377,
0.0250021983,
-0.0209394582,
0.0167639442,
0.0261136014,
-0.0295035355,
-0.0076899687,
-0.0533465184,
-0.0193441454,
0.0132488804,
0.0417563245,
-0.0156446826,
0.0265789665,
0.0527054593,
-0.0259105116,
0.0054097758,
-0.0312749483,
0.017649876,
-0.0328808278,
-0.0593173802,
-0.0109347701,
0.0188198872,
0.0317770243,
-0.0551321656,
0.0218639802,
0.0877736285,
0.018088622,
-0.0498450398,
0.0161893684,
0.0021821756,
-0.0607071631,
-0.0170933604,
0.0150242615,
-0.0565650947,
-0.0475629084,
-0.0073037003,
0.0325440392,
-0.0506607927,
-0.0682727322,
0.0342121869,
-0.0226756036,
0.0306088813,
-0.0066648708,
-0.0098209493,
0.0109012658,
-0.0610659458,
0.0094484109,
-0.0341146551,
0.0356728546,
-0.017127201,
0.012554382,
-0.0101305377,
-0.0038800482,
-0.0699954554,
-0.0562815145,
0.0651506186,
-0.0255765952,
0.0459428169,
0.0404431596,
0.0199493151,
-0.0077647436,
-0.0574198887,
-0.0248588007,
0.0317054316,
0.0428156443,
0.0014289232,
0.0736343116,
0.0151784113,
0.0081677623,
-0.0798632354,
-0.0132940924,
-0.0574880652,
0.0227201115,
0.0018195779,
0.0991698876,
-0.0356905982,
-0.0161208473,
-0.0606813096,
0.0106418859,
0.0077010337,
0.0494101532,
-0.0173882917,
-0.0186857823,
-0.0155414399,
0.0456833951,
0.0521020517,
0.0087656565,
-0.0173633788,
0.0524492338,
-0.0491574518,
-0.0090197586,
-0.041686371,
-0.0500278734,
0.0616761632,
0.0058285394,
0.0267805997,
0.0143389609,
-0.0630129799,
-0.004460515,
-0.0498477481,
0.0422043242,
0.0886430889,
0.0745275244,
-0.0252731126,
-0.0019801799,
0.0523746721,
0.0404555053,
0.0037549413,
0.0237990431,
-0.0096086944,
-0.0140541792,
-0.0042698104,
0.0172100216,
0.0269172974,
-0.0438477211,
-0.0174612831,
0.0031194701,
0.0130587099,
0.0511234216,
-0.0370643884,
0.0016844263,
-0.0296860784,
-0.0257687792,
-0.0103578493,
-0.0168499388,
-0.0301875044,
0.0214496274,
-0.003286788,
0.0425357297,
-0.0274501834,
-0.0178157818,
0.0393576324,
0.0450839996,
0.0276255403,
-0.0245228224,
-0.0435223244,
0.0034050613,
0.0002316066,
-0.0202604197,
0.0072798319,
0.0156097058,
-0.0061200405,
0.0199496206,
0.0113224406,
-0.0033662491,
0.0057034781,
-0.0649870709,
-0.0580278412,
-0.0493362918,
0.0631735101,
0.0177012924,
0.0010801905,
0.0359322503,
0.00960657,
-0.0123740043,
-0.0070688333,
0.0127785662,
0.0370224938,
0.0188529268,
0.0498454981,
-0.0225090086,
0.0775048733,
-0.016400788,
0.0592386313,
-0.0565034524,
-0.0013467612,
0.0035516436,
0.0160629824,
0.0258776024,
0.0279932227,
0.0153552135,
0.0002521162,
0.0226875823,
-0.0206941981,
-0.0116025163,
-0.036649324,
0.0278904047,
0.0296049379,
0.0129731437,
-0.0026970848,
-0.0633229539,
0.0546162613,
-0.046938058,
0.0351706259,
-0.0490645953,
-0.0230178759,
-0.0468387231,
-0.0271824058,
0.023434598,
0.0095723718,
-0.0537245609,
-0.0176075734,
-0.109776251,
-0.0234398562,
0.0297007076,
-0.0006642949,
-0.0382630005,
-0.0137289362,
0.0059663286,
0.0242411215,
0.0508633293,
-0.0394639745,
0.0022386361,
0.0214200448,
-0.0509473458,
-0.0087422282,
0.0276612397,
-5.658354097e-33,
0.0086481441,
-0.0537277199,
0.0420562066,
-0.0149338022,
0.0137187541,
0.0557020158,
-0.0143103283,
0.004828902,
-0.004918837,
0.049515456,
-0.038448181,
-0.0182033945,
0.0040305876,
-0.0079578431,
0.0284898411,
-0.0495230295,
-0.0019949151,
0.0293114465,
-0.0192793272,
-0.03090466,
-0.0012753647,
0.007450155,
0.0286233798,
-0.0782263801,
-0.0104223099,
0.0086042397,
0.0242138337,
0.0190417152,
-0.0410809293,
0.0707605556,
0.0107431412,
0.0391910933,
0.0450931638,
0.01905993,
-0.0108748097,
-0.0312780961,
-0.0126064084,
-0.039678596,
0.0088632535,
-0.0175260101,
-0.0351228863,
-0.0399837568,
0.0377446078,
0.004397077,
-0.0441631489,
-0.0116014294,
0.0382447131,
-0.0309614353,
-0.004814934,
-0.0079173036,
-0.0168825407,
0.0490088761,
-0.0046023536,
0.0182310119,
-0.0210409537,
-0.0139144389,
-0.0225825813,
-0.0075281323,
-0.039514266,
-0.0243864879,
0.0239332486,
-0.0269207191,
0.02183236,
0.0033613171,
-0.0332151614,
0.0732310861,
0.0368830673,
0.003269424,
-0.0165464189,
0.0195858516,
-0.0468112715,
0.0751884431,
0.0706468076,
0.0471052937,
0.0150960945,
0.0060069277,
-0.0609217659,
0.0863572359,
-0.0215026066,
0.03074551,
0.0153477937,
-0.0318191387,
-0.0725943223,
-0.0008044477,
-0.0262153801,
0.0293836575,
-0.0476585962,
-0.0496314652,
0.0611281022,
-0.0311778784,
0.0083580613,
-0.0000850433,
0.0134636946,
-0.0056144996,
0.0045166113,
-0.0699737668,
0.0542814508,
0.0089807836,
-0.0327419043,
0.002397012,
-0.0532178879,
-0.0248053428,
0.0125279175,
0.0229117628,
0.0959874392,
-0.0031575663,
-0.0076415809,
-0.0498818718,
-0.0384789333,
0.008628088,
0.0045750318,
0.0097388104,
-0.0350378267,
-0.0046218093,
0.035348665,
0.0150262583,
-0.0022764183,
0.0405571498,
0.0137312291,
-0.0160009786,
-0.0382133573,
-0.0104746139,
0.0120124007,
-0.0096274894,
-0.0383064598,
0.0007318805,
-0.0168534461,
0.0397302061,
0.0312639922,
-0.0453561023,
-0.0022855683,
0.0000401581,
2.818e-7,
0.1029179841,
0.0369875096,
0.0102584064,
0.0141578671,
0.0170681532,
0.0096088378,
-0.0356242917,
0.0144155612,
-0.0127881039,
-0.0452584065,
0.0434042215,
-0.0063032797,
0.0302135479,
0.0467286818,
-0.0244395267,
-0.0257408507,
-0.015835749,
0.0232909285,
-0.0317628719,
-0.0210351571,
0.0563910641,
0.0272424333,
0.0003389637,
-0.060868334,
0.0372561999,
-0.0237968452,
0.0059824483,
-0.0193703827,
0.0301842969,
0.0591262095,
0.0058519272,
-0.0109262802,
0.0532716848,
0.1000429094,
-0.0050935233,
-0.0117938444,
-0.0211405139,
0.0860767588,
-0.0827152804,
-0.0343290269,
0.0193551779,
-0.0509159565,
0.0639426857,
-0.0172745455,
0.0401475765,
0.000272847,
-0.0267965868,
0.0077369362,
-0.035939794,
-0.0174240619,
0.0864039436,
-0.011900547,
-0.0091842962,
0.050153356,
0.0029662901,
0.0388725773,
-0.0453219637,
-0.0627245083,
-0.0020294746,
0.0140805105,
-0.0050349277,
-0.064156428,
0.0515161268,
0.0181096047,
0.0111561529,
-0.0787274018,
-0.0274909232,
2.572528979e-34,
0.0210166741,
0.0145099424,
0.0246047191,
0.0224814843,
0.0368481465,
0.0007489105,
-0.0080135465,
0.0139309177,
0.0108896149,
-0.0669093281,
-0.0012684989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13885v1 | Knowledge Tagging System on Math Questions via LLMs with Flexible Demonstration Retriever | 2024-06-19T23:30:01 | 2024-06-19T23:30:01 | Hang Li, Tianlong Xu, Jiliang Tang, Qingsong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge tagging for questions plays a crucial role in contemporary
intelligent educational applications, including learning progress diagnosis,
practice question recommendations, and course content organization.
Traditionally, these annotations are always conducted by pedagogical experts,
as the task requires not only a strong semantic understanding of both question
stems and knowledge definitions but also deep insights into connecting
question-solving logic with corresponding knowledge concepts. With the recent
emergence of advanced text encoding algorithms, such as pre-trained language
models, many researchers have developed automatic knowledge tagging systems
based on calculating the semantic similarity between the knowledge and question
embeddings. In this paper, we explore automating the task using Large Language
Models (LLMs), in response to the inability of prior encoding-based methods to
deal with the hard cases which involve strong domain knowledge and complicated
concept definitions. By showing the strong performance of zero- and few-shot
results over math questions knowledge tagging tasks, we demonstrate LLMs' great
potential in conquering the challenges faced by prior methods. Furthermore, by
proposing a reinforcement learning-based demonstration retriever, we
successfully exploit the great potential of different-sized LLMs in achieving
better performance results while keeping the in-context demonstration usage
efficiency high. | [
-0.0045543378,
0.0003833657,
-0.0193458106,
0.0577128008,
-0.020120671,
0.0290202908,
-0.0104646776,
0.0198056158,
0.0291275326,
-0.0613641702,
0.0026693542,
0.0199441146,
-0.0592668764,
-0.0040174616,
0.0352154039,
-0.0178597309,
0.0281437039,
-0.0187204145,
0.0254709423,
0.0189162828,
0.0084549719,
-0.0277801231,
-0.0100974673,
0.0183147229,
-0.0299150404,
-0.04378644,
-0.0175539032,
-0.0521896929,
-0.005629336,
-0.0355245583,
-0.0040193652,
0.0280873496,
0.013105168,
0.0203419123,
0.0000020193,
-0.0520391725,
-0.0448483899,
0.0140426913,
-0.0482911468,
-0.0151382694,
-0.0154354209,
0.0233997833,
0.0254602581,
0.0028095911,
-0.0964122415,
-0.0177029483,
0.0089213224,
0.0186232105,
0.073650144,
0.0683334842,
0.0064448053,
-0.039791625,
0.0549878702,
0.0009215032,
0.0910979882,
-0.0562452227,
0.0572825409,
0.0703593418,
0.0335048363,
0.0547212735,
-0.0511473417,
0.0245368108,
0.037307959,
-0.0152855711,
-0.023200782,
-0.001623054,
0.0027801862,
0.032202065,
0.0014418466,
0.0668664649,
-0.0043560821,
-0.0002490789,
-0.001028843,
0.003583804,
0.0157886688,
0.021606192,
-0.0490329899,
0.014796339,
-0.0200159177,
-0.0016588103,
0.0255819522,
0.003116051,
0.0116565768,
0.0234580208,
-0.0698090419,
0.0649405718,
-0.0031709848,
-0.0640770718,
-0.0148382727,
0.0171725471,
-0.0483990386,
-0.0500546992,
0.0126890922,
0.0570222475,
0.0224004406,
0.0395759381,
-0.0273188855,
-0.0686242506,
-0.0153318048,
0.002040772,
0.0237670317,
0.0561245494,
0.0235241074,
0.0609678589,
-0.0561631136,
0.0692666098,
-0.0096036075,
0.0257689413,
-0.0632107928,
0.0057554999,
-0.0591979884,
-0.0085120182,
-0.0243050512,
0.0841166452,
0.0134580648,
0.0110522229,
-0.0253939684,
0.0442068391,
-0.0258909836,
0.0508258156,
-0.0243624952,
-0.0503400899,
0.0134395603,
-0.0135039538,
-0.0595872588,
0.0135363312,
-0.0494546816,
-0.0053776815,
0.010435109,
-0.0050955801,
-0.0324753188,
0.0226847678,
-0.005241375,
-0.0242191628,
0.0129950782,
0.0592301376,
0.0200269651,
-0.0391812697,
-0.0194006544,
-0.0575057901,
0.0143830422,
-0.0239809602,
0.0160384141,
-0.0681613237,
0.0482533909,
0.0248194523,
-0.0198198166,
-0.0222923681,
0.0116267316,
0.0209818576,
0.0135833938,
0.0692892075,
0.0161930006,
0.0020017491,
0.037359748,
0.0139750903,
-0.0548415706,
0.0343259946,
0.0310830958,
-0.0086662276,
0.0490361601,
0.0042536207,
0.0260052197,
0.0368260965,
0.0467720926,
0.0013197938,
-0.0067878724,
0.0413564779,
0.0768443719,
0.0393364988,
-0.0266769622,
0.0166846327,
-0.0400486141,
0.0107102497,
0.0167888608,
0.0727048144,
-0.0176666845,
-0.0281888787,
0.0433506928,
0.0216893218,
0.0307614282,
-0.0190506168,
-0.0073611313,
-0.0101301279,
-0.0356400684,
0.0103993993,
0.0361587629,
-0.0199762769,
-0.0149996746,
-0.0718593225,
-0.028608283,
-0.0122518297,
0.0124849295,
0.0452339612,
0.0700380206,
0.0137564307,
-0.0105102323,
0.0387758352,
0.0173307974,
0.0007533276,
0.0261601619,
-0.0722352192,
0.0698683485,
-0.0088295387,
0.056845285,
-0.0920384303,
-0.0434666649,
-0.0222137291,
0.0366558209,
-0.0016595636,
0.0417815894,
-0.0381053239,
-0.0631721988,
-0.0427510627,
-0.0206939951,
-0.0097573977,
-0.0032380878,
-0.0231556557,
0.0633035451,
0.021374194,
0.0203819014,
-0.0589356348,
0.0026198947,
0.0403487124,
-0.0570771322,
-0.0718481615,
-0.0020027796,
-0.0023384402,
-0.0051116683,
0.0121486969,
0.0098928129,
0.0340840481,
0.0319506563,
-0.0414526574,
-0.0001312096,
-0.055558756,
-0.037663877,
-0.0725188106,
0.0670706183,
0.0040695011,
-0.0173916873,
-0.0085742874,
-0.0511383787,
-0.0246958025,
-0.0109562743,
-0.0091079604,
0.0399030074,
-0.0215280559,
0.0120545952,
0.0132472366,
-0.066798225,
-0.0423084237,
0.0684056878,
0.0197964031,
0.0506635979,
-0.0020355335,
-0.012475119,
0.0058642165,
0.0136609208,
-0.0467520244,
-0.0217097793,
-0.010028745,
0.0176722612,
-0.0040080696,
-0.0014358298,
-0.0464478247,
-0.0087291105,
-0.0408217795,
0.0426582582,
-0.0012227285,
0.0373828523,
-0.0183809754,
-0.009095219,
0.0000338415,
-0.0249415729,
-0.0418502875,
-0.0052175554,
-0.0208143629,
-0.0051465183,
0.0200009625,
0.0626395196,
0.0097297803,
-0.0310537498,
-0.0095075257,
-0.0332245603,
0.0512879826,
0.0247910023,
0.0543007739,
-0.0433248729,
0.0213817675,
-0.0118242558,
0.0034010401,
0.0005571194,
0.0237889588,
0.0134783974,
-0.0570140146,
0.0351783969,
0.0548853353,
-0.0167536307,
0.0440007225,
-0.0042272303,
-0.0062822383,
-0.0855553746,
0.0206837822,
-0.0520045571,
-0.0298332497,
-0.0426418371,
0.0106751919,
-0.0049489089,
0.061409425,
-0.0035334618,
-0.0475104824,
-0.0505612232,
0.0360132903,
-0.0359372757,
0.0056984038,
-0.0696067363,
0.0259162467,
-0.0009052939,
0.0256232526,
0.0014715778,
-0.0112345526,
0.0807097778,
0.013793489,
-0.0023396022,
-0.0478679016,
-0.0090241833,
-0.0621566437,
0.0452983566,
0.001442605,
-0.0034167252,
-0.0267103184,
-0.0128174908,
-0.0269538537,
0.0092048692,
0.0305233914,
-0.0650113821,
0.0305252485,
-0.0259160846,
-0.0118897902,
0.0001846502,
-0.0161675289,
-0.0414402671,
0.0168574937,
-0.005157318,
0.0145416604,
-0.0163163263,
0.0160475112,
-0.0070245145,
0.0046342835,
0.0294427611,
0.0180239864,
-0.0262422487,
-0.0173179172,
-0.0324243121,
0.0295402706,
0.0283309855,
-0.0001361612,
0.0020485814,
-0.0437182896,
0.0383400172,
0.0456323996,
0.0469581299,
0.002563366,
0.0008166148,
0.0024853076,
0.0157566201,
-0.0914618447,
-0.0003430968,
0.0366003737,
-0.0172144286,
-0.0828911066,
-0.0087336535,
0.1126461178,
0.0471255928,
-0.0161348991,
-0.0324646756,
-0.0420522243,
-0.0323941372,
0.0292786136,
0.0444759987,
-0.0991211981,
-0.0119975097,
-0.010701403,
0.0138326893,
0.040913932,
-0.0410105474,
0.0269593224,
-0.1347000152,
-0.0168541018,
0.0070656505,
-0.0278752148,
0.0109569654,
-0.0195581056,
-0.0144707812,
0.0393228717,
-0.031879127,
0.0061190925,
-0.0007111144,
0.031161787,
0.0408334322,
0.0129600726,
-0.0374030173,
-0.0035284606,
-0.0520071946,
-0.0007523746,
0.0283972751,
0.0049356981,
-0.0317337997,
-0.0474734791,
-0.0156698208,
0.0233817622,
-0.0463728532,
-0.0001292019,
-0.0164099429,
-0.0664517209,
0.003075344,
-0.0006774956,
0.0311526749,
-0.0322820507,
-0.0184079092,
0.0653997362,
0.1365103722,
-0.0121031152,
0.0157980416,
-0.0288409311,
-0.0308574438,
-0.0145262759,
0.0905649439,
0.0308563542,
-0.0504133441,
0.0114564849,
-0.0079004038,
-0.0065874895,
-0.0114608686,
-0.0032346828,
-0.0066433703,
-0.0043632812,
0.0522361435,
-0.061910715,
-0.0260615926,
0.0921724737,
0.0189426523,
0.0126074003,
0.0008617826,
0.0341839753,
-0.0188289452,
-0.0740295947,
0.0269062575,
-0.0364963971,
-0.0025513954,
-0.0678509697,
0.0191921629,
0.0362950824,
-0.0145936403,
-0.0492827334,
-0.0206255987,
-0.0582466833,
-0.0430128984,
-0.0549994782,
0.0538901463,
0.0109725539,
0.027989015,
-0.0119947651,
0.0028241852,
0.0329600461,
0.0146756684,
-0.0386361405,
0.0081879413,
0.0084250411,
0.0114708422,
-0.0009838493,
0.005160905,
-0.0516750179,
0.0002843303,
0.0083764642,
0.0528956801,
-0.0533196069,
-0.0190449152,
0.0254150797,
0.0188718736,
0.0179706849,
0.0386590585,
-0.017927805,
0.0028444871,
0.026773734,
-0.0161247421,
-0.0478008501,
-0.0202635732,
0.0078230798,
0.0255343486,
-0.0098278541,
-0.0030422385,
-0.0120445732,
0.0191915426,
0.0651918873,
0.0073485975,
0.0256188698,
-0.0099746613,
-0.0080652134,
0.0440943129,
-0.0185646564,
0.0188962761,
-0.0442220457,
-0.0023585532,
0.0250873771,
-0.0243678931,
0.0773018301,
0.0369089581,
0.0154768387,
0.0040810164,
-0.0023582196,
0.0044544614,
-0.0838307887,
-0.0020886797,
0.0488257147,
0.0089436015,
0.0130505785,
-0.0475347415,
-0.0312344097,
-0.0291897953,
-0.0121077262,
0.0102261109,
-0.0110186329,
-0.0324554369,
0.064451687,
0.0372878015,
0.0148024252,
-0.0220220238,
0.0338089317,
-0.0236395244,
0.0223844461,
0.0221590642,
-0.0192988962,
-0.0335988477,
-0.0025191968,
0.0530549102,
0.038159322,
0.013539128,
0.0147271696,
-0.0505822487,
-0.0636420473,
0.0191499088,
0.0124628171,
-0.054298833,
0.0232922174,
0.0462762527,
0.0551292524,
-0.0015219237,
-0.0186444633,
-0.0283015296,
0.0423801132,
-0.063119173,
-0.0644805878,
-0.0019152659,
-5.31157408e-33,
-0.031892322,
-0.0296754334,
0.0431947857,
0.0166430864,
-0.0071599684,
0.0083767828,
-0.0113369925,
-0.0048883744,
-0.0084869806,
0.0171625614,
0.0021783533,
0.0154065825,
-0.0081843901,
0.0264402665,
-0.0001418347,
-0.0228259154,
0.0038748512,
-0.0221074615,
-0.0018064386,
-0.0098451991,
-0.0032421087,
0.0297686011,
0.0400534272,
-0.0223854221,
0.0251307227,
-0.03440281,
0.0376662165,
0.0171781965,
-0.003136836,
0.0777301937,
-0.0342127122,
0.025822347,
0.010072845,
-0.059255071,
0.0011555037,
0.044749409,
-0.0628074855,
-0.0545459799,
-0.0055735759,
0.0049830922,
-0.0400113687,
-0.0154600041,
0.0173754003,
-0.0023295863,
-0.0023753869,
0.0046993052,
0.0411727652,
-0.0071154861,
0.0009039335,
-0.0358669721,
-0.0257281903,
0.0212583728,
-0.0111827711,
-0.0115764812,
0.0547489859,
0.0069840727,
0.0283531994,
0.0290479753,
-0.0321002156,
0.0013271556,
0.0176100433,
0.0130072171,
0.0306804702,
0.0074642277,
0.0016150577,
0.0359819457,
-0.0214929841,
-0.0139335729,
0.0195715055,
0.0083820634,
0.0357025266,
0.0218850337,
0.0566459745,
0.0107012074,
0.0300911404,
0.0215382129,
-0.0452604257,
0.0339894444,
0.0125633935,
0.0232382026,
0.0123742139,
-0.0002599365,
-0.0746595412,
0.0044187261,
-0.0601833574,
0.0630160794,
-0.0399781987,
-0.0393371396,
0.0513271727,
-0.0249089357,
-0.0234796777,
0.0207810793,
0.0354177654,
-0.0683404207,
-0.0126220891,
-0.0016269842,
-0.0104130153,
0.0348964967,
-0.0413947664,
0.0370767899,
-0.0417163,
-0.0442156903,
-0.0011793216,
-0.0870829597,
0.0088095888,
0.0135989906,
-0.0073213265,
-0.0007997656,
-0.0496003777,
-0.0206382573,
-0.0077143307,
-0.0176160969,
0.030950943,
0.0158842932,
0.0380582623,
0.0791730583,
0.0106630642,
0.0458967127,
0.0407478251,
-0.0301778782,
-0.0330842026,
-0.0164084882,
-0.0017652204,
-0.0184503943,
-0.0193221532,
-0.0042796903,
-0.0086913193,
0.0381470099,
-0.0087781716,
-0.0695402697,
0.0191501509,
0.0373792835,
2.71e-7,
0.0531084761,
0.0478745438,
-0.0074719968,
0.0285042804,
-0.0218085069,
0.0348953269,
0.0185028333,
-0.0042349468,
0.0319541544,
-0.025488833,
-0.0012732343,
0.0452071875,
0.001135897,
0.025351733,
-0.1130761653,
-0.0226174183,
0.018253725,
-0.0325599834,
-0.0595775805,
0.0038412828,
0.0985977277,
0.0617363676,
0.0525986105,
0.0310212485,
-0.0257171355,
-0.0655970648,
0.0544209592,
-0.0073922952,
0.0005375601,
0.0303464159,
0.0024629354,
0.0245378911,
0.0265969671,
0.0199363679,
0.0039783977,
0.036630597,
0.019490283,
0.04954537,
0.035918247,
0.0177467056,
-0.0417121276,
-0.0272366405,
0.0255676396,
-0.0420418531,
0.0499596968,
-0.0712600946,
0.0001597881,
0.0274506118,
-0.032776542,
-0.0743873715,
-0.0027539942,
-0.0130962124,
0.0243728384,
0.0014900612,
0.0346237868,
-0.0075744772,
0.0183618516,
-0.0718959421,
0.0042785648,
0.024490241,
-0.055842597,
-0.0225912388,
-0.0452879444,
0.0078719147,
0.0200173426,
-0.0757642612,
-0.0156543832,
2.755680642e-34,
0.0157589689,
-0.016577011,
0.0217110366,
0.0724661797,
0.0311997049,
0.0198643897,
-0.0590389594,
0.0375378653,
0.0493412949,
-0.0987110287,
-0.0091766575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13862v1 | Knowledge Graph-Enhanced Large Language Models via Path Selection | 2024-06-19T21:45:20 | 2024-06-19T21:45:20 | Haochen Liu, Song Wang, Yaochen Zhu, Yushun Dong, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown unprecedented performance in various
real-world applications. However, they are known to generate factually
inaccurate outputs, a.k.a. the hallucination problem. In recent years,
incorporating external knowledge extracted from Knowledge Graphs (KGs) has
become a promising strategy to improve the factual accuracy of LLM-generated
outputs. Nevertheless, most existing explorations rely on LLMs themselves to
perform KG knowledge extraction, which is highly inflexible as LLMs can only
provide binary judgment on whether a certain knowledge (e.g., a knowledge path
in KG) should be used. In addition, LLMs tend to pick only knowledge with
direct semantic relationship with the input text, while potentially useful
knowledge with indirect semantics can be ignored. In this work, we propose a
principled framework KELP with three stages to handle the above problems.
Specifically, KELP is able to achieve finer granularity of flexible knowledge
extraction by generating scores for knowledge paths with input texts via latent
semantic matching. Meanwhile, knowledge paths with indirect semantic
relationships with the input text can also be considered via trained encoding
between the selected paths in KG and the input text. Experiments on real-world
datasets validate the effectiveness of KELP. | [
0.0599975102,
0.018712122,
-0.0074021751,
0.0709767938,
-0.0752315223,
0.0172905512,
-0.0462873876,
0.0102234799,
0.0759127811,
-0.0776509121,
0.0102271726,
0.0448027775,
-0.0316117182,
0.0120185753,
0.0347506814,
-0.0104033342,
0.0287745912,
-0.0513778031,
-0.0194678772,
-0.0177767873,
-0.0169264507,
0.0495788343,
0.0207799692,
0.0036384619,
-0.0229256302,
-0.0129556945,
0.0284012519,
-0.0317612141,
-0.003590622,
0.0121054053,
-0.0065367697,
0.0021373164,
-0.0077409465,
0.0190429408,
0.0000020199,
-0.0515771136,
-0.0169800632,
-0.0010939249,
-0.0119201718,
-0.0049460758,
-0.0068922061,
-0.0030103489,
0.0239549726,
-0.0119627714,
-0.0204019509,
-0.0125764813,
0.0124993958,
0.0812440068,
0.0236254316,
0.0464487933,
-0.0124976821,
-0.0401028991,
0.007697728,
0.013396143,
0.0230323691,
-0.015650006,
0.0900002941,
0.0658402294,
-0.0218121633,
-0.0236925334,
-0.0057636709,
0.0387166329,
-0.008717957,
-0.0122117791,
0.0520747826,
0.0442647971,
-0.0443029702,
0.0204426497,
0.0314725637,
0.111114271,
-0.0212303326,
-0.0525895245,
0.0305939447,
-0.0189939477,
-0.0253723338,
0.0543728583,
-0.0292142313,
-0.0064840652,
-0.0310431384,
0.0332199894,
0.0296442937,
-0.0359731652,
0.0663057044,
0.0061022481,
-0.0458464511,
0.0982212871,
0.0154017415,
-0.053995613,
0.0493629128,
-0.0043860413,
-0.03325703,
-0.0322084799,
0.0074622286,
0.0075049601,
0.015932627,
0.0430623293,
-0.0105807744,
0.0144904051,
0.0071507725,
-0.0942024514,
-0.0083200224,
-0.0159175862,
0.0004837514,
0.0684825182,
-0.0531758368,
0.0315302052,
0.0067889038,
0.0490013175,
-0.0451815464,
-0.0318369493,
-0.0528759025,
0.0142641757,
-0.0183237493,
0.0530444197,
-0.027332155,
-0.0373721384,
-0.012269076,
0.0117487535,
-0.0535058118,
0.0565766133,
0.0316467918,
0.0111968312,
0.0450673364,
-0.0377986059,
-0.0213512108,
0.0141806873,
0.0052690478,
0.0114939045,
-0.0507845655,
0.0009719823,
0.033147011,
0.0174874645,
0.0252594128,
-0.0122374957,
0.0053008138,
0.066572696,
0.0409513116,
0.0028973406,
-0.055110842,
-0.0481969491,
-0.0165372584,
-0.060343504,
0.0104567884,
-0.0805706456,
0.0351661891,
0.0334837548,
0.0041834149,
-0.0597912222,
0.0253189113,
-0.0021512667,
-0.0808039308,
0.0411469564,
-0.0147050405,
0.0240773596,
0.015756581,
-0.0066782068,
-0.0340079367,
0.0110217668,
0.0088040112,
0.0278921183,
0.0351906866,
0.0080862818,
-0.0060096635,
0.034608081,
0.0116515579,
-0.0088196192,
0.0050117676,
0.043529246,
0.0450468287,
0.0273230821,
0.0169743821,
0.0517338812,
-0.0373959243,
0.0023279183,
0.0498616919,
0.0120228399,
0.0047657746,
0.0085365912,
0.0416708402,
0.0105333952,
0.027962774,
0.0021625068,
-0.0385182537,
-0.0270095021,
-0.0777206868,
0.0119331721,
0.0066511407,
0.0083144829,
-0.0054501607,
-0.0049425736,
-0.0073103192,
-0.0250630919,
0.0297948401,
0.0439431593,
0.0816570371,
-0.0015896829,
-0.0477922074,
0.0678974986,
0.0777601972,
0.023318436,
0.0193373431,
-0.0154207218,
-0.0035350651,
0.0647500604,
0.0438763723,
-0.0161314122,
0.0098489085,
0.0259253979,
-0.0373711586,
0.0061856811,
0.025606079,
-0.0549428836,
-0.0373946726,
-0.0416329987,
-0.0354770608,
-0.0000724957,
-0.0037380471,
-0.0017153448,
0.0265170354,
0.0059306724,
0.0156193981,
-0.0551933497,
-0.0475157946,
0.0359440446,
-0.0340225138,
-0.0085287364,
-0.0127070462,
-0.0116514955,
0.0098408042,
0.0047643892,
-0.0073427912,
0.012374701,
0.0247508194,
-0.0264450405,
-0.0661279932,
0.00673358,
-0.010691124,
-0.0508044884,
0.0432018824,
-0.0103902128,
-0.0261764564,
0.004088596,
-0.0406497866,
-0.0174569096,
0.0051935655,
-0.0066035851,
0.0670560598,
-0.0200976934,
0.0268270839,
0.0138657223,
-0.0413875543,
-0.0346671417,
0.0802777559,
-0.0005995405,
0.0226892699,
-0.0056495359,
-0.0378438905,
-0.0146761192,
0.0157947876,
-0.0235178079,
0.0312836468,
0.0255319644,
0.0273234472,
0.028718248,
-0.0464708768,
-0.0551046878,
-0.0227728076,
-0.0858578011,
0.0072863367,
0.0051246579,
-0.0129892826,
0.0056132833,
-0.01741096,
0.0102991126,
0.0056547234,
-0.0178171601,
0.0321012288,
-0.0062093153,
0.0011814589,
-0.0172971189,
0.0011246414,
0.0236615203,
0.0008750514,
0.0037709079,
-0.0217167828,
0.0675891563,
0.0031708959,
-0.0314817503,
-0.0367885605,
0.0671574324,
-0.0429056473,
0.0219422616,
-0.0340096578,
0.0139617156,
-0.0630839542,
-0.0166865587,
0.0148923639,
0.010465798,
-0.0336158946,
-0.0072645834,
0.0607368723,
-0.0225942433,
-0.0297056641,
-0.0110457567,
-0.0442725047,
0.0018666548,
-0.0773842409,
-0.0161195006,
0.0009564004,
-0.0131123662,
0.058040753,
-0.0036959017,
-0.0548478477,
0.0061000888,
-0.0503282212,
-0.0073449598,
-0.0321489722,
0.005625959,
0.006862158,
0.0040633152,
-0.026225334,
-0.0137593187,
0.058157403,
-0.0182368811,
0.0438835546,
0.0006352764,
0.0211416744,
-0.0143162981,
0.053311009,
0.0230928864,
0.0263340175,
-0.0106962388,
0.0188068468,
-0.0007348677,
-0.0277629923,
0.0161470175,
-0.0439639166,
0.0644592419,
-0.0428480394,
0.0336683877,
0.0423152596,
-0.0126820542,
-0.047721304,
-0.0196031462,
-0.0210286845,
0.0205103382,
-0.0121322758,
-0.0009356121,
-0.009134992,
-0.0032241477,
0.0308141466,
0.010528367,
0.0000865407,
-0.0126729188,
-0.0284863617,
0.0218380932,
0.0946777388,
-0.0284993667,
0.0392917469,
0.0074324659,
0.0266483165,
0.0597278923,
0.0136250025,
-0.010367739,
-0.011093325,
-0.0006309832,
-0.0078388266,
-0.058433935,
-0.017806476,
0.012344053,
0.0208650567,
-0.0325118192,
0.0362265073,
0.1202529594,
0.0146397175,
-0.0148880612,
0.0052082902,
0.003109379,
-0.0107492451,
0.0201899204,
0.0224357136,
-0.0594938397,
-0.0055211275,
-0.0081297727,
0.0083105071,
0.0019554591,
-0.0619643927,
0.0159107149,
-0.1301526576,
0.0324310586,
0.0227376036,
0.019470783,
-0.0802865177,
-0.0582381412,
0.0135894408,
-0.0036936577,
-0.0206486788,
-0.0212477725,
-0.0257038567,
-0.0186302029,
0.0138392784,
-0.0316609889,
-0.037851613,
0.0651943088,
-0.0148633858,
0.0376153477,
-0.0074347761,
0.061115481,
0.0141931344,
-0.0034376583,
-0.0121674379,
-0.0181488246,
-0.0234667119,
-0.0112826973,
0.0299131926,
0.0081849843,
0.0121660084,
0.0017922611,
0.0054707243,
-0.051250048,
-0.0096494956,
0.0152874617,
0.1122144088,
-0.0254523437,
-0.0474218689,
0.0304332227,
-0.0165568572,
-0.007764345,
0.0894867927,
-0.0107851708,
0.0261936411,
-0.0402495675,
-0.0086390013,
-0.0172847752,
0.0275103953,
-0.0478808694,
0.0506278425,
-0.0240095481,
0.0292485487,
-0.0789910853,
-0.0302585103,
0.064780429,
0.0164495036,
0.0069340421,
0.0664177835,
0.0486523807,
-0.0283121727,
-0.036998976,
0.0120731518,
-0.0855698287,
0.0026341432,
0.0227405056,
-0.0232020151,
0.0346284807,
-0.0431569815,
-0.02820649,
0.0268532131,
-0.0474166982,
-0.0735756308,
-0.0046997406,
-0.0001745822,
0.0152915912,
0.0978205428,
-0.0324465632,
-0.0060343617,
0.066865392,
0.0058829854,
-0.0342058241,
0.0188467745,
0.0070483182,
0.0081667844,
-0.0052601607,
0.043726448,
-0.064518705,
-0.0107294051,
0.0344706625,
0.03896074,
-0.0301008783,
-0.0485394076,
0.0235505514,
0.0673025772,
0.0062487628,
0.0133263804,
0.0094986176,
-0.0539446175,
0.0015441501,
-0.0295990873,
-0.0430550016,
-0.0313577913,
-0.0031565565,
0.034435913,
0.0216035489,
0.0066044102,
-0.0458044298,
0.0145847006,
0.0083389375,
-0.0559025519,
-0.0572158657,
0.0333429761,
0.0131690167,
0.0715472028,
-0.0262974948,
-0.0329087265,
0.0143448478,
0.0162797645,
0.0129629122,
-0.0434837304,
0.0293436404,
0.0143661806,
-0.0405604355,
-0.0616764799,
-0.0236467738,
-0.0253432132,
-0.0760183185,
-0.0173903164,
0.0676793605,
0.0707696751,
-0.0259261969,
0.0697636008,
-0.0577753969,
-0.0259360876,
-0.0199141242,
0.0151362158,
0.0352391154,
-0.0272163264,
0.0151945641,
0.0190534145,
-0.0313868672,
0.0207642093,
0.0526366942,
0.0266304631,
0.0993663594,
-0.0020472833,
-0.0544121154,
-0.0455796495,
-0.0450839624,
0.0094067398,
0.0215511564,
-0.0332481973,
0.0142699769,
-0.0691383556,
-0.0896777064,
0.0231089909,
-0.0181979425,
-0.0386192203,
-0.0092273904,
0.0385954864,
0.0529292412,
0.0328272283,
-0.0324320234,
-0.0569778159,
0.0044884519,
-0.0138956299,
-0.0003738654,
-0.0265369453,
-6.331693057e-33,
-0.0052719885,
-0.0236776248,
0.0303114168,
0.0163180064,
-0.031312108,
0.0140348459,
-0.0193501264,
-0.046162799,
-0.014663795,
0.047315564,
0.0104812626,
-0.0325128101,
0.0050459099,
0.0076803146,
-0.0113176908,
-0.0219638292,
0.0172306076,
0.0116565945,
0.0158496778,
0.0474113896,
0.0574702621,
0.0160592403,
0.0526660047,
-0.0675461367,
0.003651001,
-0.0188087169,
0.0185132176,
0.0127628995,
0.016296329,
0.0277945418,
-0.0484138094,
0.0714513734,
0.0266749691,
-0.0175528526,
0.0031102991,
-0.0402055643,
-0.0805403516,
-0.0189736504,
0.030767208,
-0.0029063746,
-0.0128257573,
-0.0065196268,
0.0423929431,
-0.0111040073,
0.0282278247,
-0.0225157663,
0.0585173294,
-0.0182260275,
-0.0482468568,
-0.0153389415,
-0.0744232312,
0.0186185353,
0.019195959,
0.0117237549,
0.0051196218,
-0.0057561416,
0.0010852233,
0.0032939913,
-0.0770723149,
0.0080651259,
-0.0169367902,
0.0079253484,
0.0434964336,
0.0033168381,
0.0476500988,
0.0784581974,
-0.0300854091,
-0.0156243807,
-0.0072854059,
0.0090255989,
0.0123736039,
0.0694293156,
-0.0311307143,
0.0107295783,
-0.0259496514,
-0.0110995788,
-0.0767080188,
-0.0179823022,
0.005564821,
0.0087340092,
0.0195652302,
-0.006503175,
-0.0446159132,
-0.0283583254,
-0.0491914861,
0.0208789892,
-0.0059316563,
-0.0148303378,
0.0156165687,
-0.0114471829,
-0.0093975877,
0.001866438,
0.0029680571,
-0.0706411153,
-0.0276455488,
0.0694771931,
-0.0313143134,
0.0134246191,
-0.0288054142,
0.033251185,
-0.0751006305,
-0.0481368825,
0.0003986665,
-0.0323615819,
0.0103170043,
0.032688003,
-0.0027163094,
0.0025129095,
-0.0186482035,
0.0052428618,
-0.0716239735,
-0.0342116207,
0.0103350207,
-0.0054633529,
0.045415774,
0.0482761562,
0.0115476428,
-0.0100415116,
0.0495104641,
0.0215809084,
0.0318836868,
0.0273267925,
0.0083970055,
-0.005938102,
-0.0213620458,
-0.0167922881,
-0.0254453663,
-0.0039158096,
0.0149521576,
-0.0360723101,
-0.0010935779,
0.0219051633,
2.915e-7,
0.0361126512,
0.0314268135,
-0.0200395919,
0.0452714376,
0.0124009829,
0.0217560008,
0.0070367767,
0.0076061389,
0.0304424036,
-0.0460741706,
0.0142843938,
0.0223291218,
0.0160074476,
0.0272388924,
-0.0853006467,
0.0256477315,
-0.0127579551,
-0.0624721311,
-0.0488189198,
-0.0032250215,
0.0560789146,
0.051740814,
0.0536545925,
0.0010565218,
-0.0323590934,
-0.0724943578,
0.0543640554,
-0.0011214538,
-0.0256931204,
0.0401903242,
0.0400585383,
0.0052986364,
-0.0088319378,
0.0683599785,
-0.0018863153,
0.019535888,
0.02167565,
0.0557311326,
-0.0089377649,
-0.0152554959,
-0.0427381247,
-0.0456522107,
0.021126505,
-0.0797085091,
0.0907090083,
-0.0469062142,
-0.0193571579,
0.0075877146,
-0.0373201109,
-0.023928659,
0.0036143286,
0.0121693285,
-0.0103561822,
0.0280374624,
0.0238729957,
0.0065915589,
-0.0333155766,
-0.0644933507,
0.0037009108,
0.0203516074,
-0.0365543105,
-0.0298266802,
0.0088312095,
-0.0185179077,
0.0309598353,
-0.0734793991,
0.0411246717,
2.898644173e-34,
0.0138680162,
0.0169389304,
-0.0306924898,
-0.0221376568,
0.0441812463,
-0.0162377544,
-0.0040740571,
0.0306675825,
-0.0336932763,
-0.0999114364,
0.0148660075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15507v1 | Few-shot Knowledge Graph Relational Reasoning via Subgraph Adaptation | 2024-06-19T21:40:35 | 2024-06-19T21:40:35 | Haochen Liu, Song Wang, Chen Chen, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Few-shot Knowledge Graph (KG) Relational Reasoning aims to predict unseen
triplets (i.e., query triplets) for rare relations in KGs, given only several
triplets of these relations as references (i.e., support triplets). This task
has gained significant traction due to the widespread use of knowledge graphs
in various natural language processing applications. Previous approaches have
utilized meta-training methods and manually constructed meta-relation sets to
tackle this task. Recent efforts have focused on edge-mask-based methods, which
exploit the structure of the contextualized graphs of target triplets (i.e., a
subgraph containing relevant triplets in the KG). However, existing
edge-mask-based methods have limitations in extracting insufficient information
from KG and are highly influenced by spurious information in KG. To overcome
these challenges, we propose SAFER (Subgraph Adaptation for Few-shot Relational
Reasoning), a novel approach that effectively adapts the information in
contextualized graphs to various subgraphs generated from support and query
triplets to perform the prediction. Specifically, SAFER enables the extraction
of more comprehensive information from support triplets while minimizing the
impact of spurious information when predicting query triplets. Experimental
results on three prevalent datasets demonstrate the superiority of our proposed
framework SAFER. | [
0.0587610006,
0.0034344578,
0.0066409023,
0.0438524447,
-0.0450538248,
0.0189401116,
-0.0094123054,
0.026967518,
0.0049481727,
-0.0588940904,
-0.0141426194,
0.0237388201,
-0.0364869311,
0.0084450347,
-0.0053821434,
-0.0350758806,
0.059619423,
0.0080029657,
0.0253485683,
0.0096272845,
-0.0154798105,
0.0471540913,
-0.008979639,
-0.0288902521,
-0.005181097,
0.0139680905,
0.0294631589,
0.0513170063,
0.0155284973,
-0.0319984704,
-0.0125584947,
0.0322655812,
0.0089551033,
0.0083585922,
0.0000018148,
-0.0374630168,
-0.026063066,
0.0085892593,
-0.0476953536,
-0.0630092397,
0.0175897237,
-0.0568099618,
0.04108271,
-0.0125173554,
-0.0541040003,
-0.0332987271,
0.0137785794,
0.0404851884,
0.0011839436,
0.071209982,
-0.0240559541,
-0.0331498235,
-0.0271832775,
-0.0104415808,
0.0431360267,
-0.0402834676,
0.0341813639,
0.0106250905,
0.0126828933,
-0.0313949622,
-0.0237407312,
0.0167227257,
-0.0017678371,
0.005034579,
0.0453647114,
0.0182647984,
-0.0787904114,
0.0140830176,
0.0142563665,
0.0969038382,
-0.0313362293,
0.0122818444,
-0.0236837883,
-0.0246386211,
-0.0149224196,
0.0375053249,
-0.0111365672,
-0.0677498654,
-0.0265479218,
-0.0023077657,
-0.0422022492,
-0.0156692695,
0.0339088179,
-0.0103832586,
-0.0289675556,
0.0732422248,
-0.0201108698,
0.0019940748,
0.0342763141,
0.0085815415,
-0.0458637178,
-0.0123751136,
-0.0076265,
0.0199289098,
-0.0132159619,
0.0658634603,
-0.0194566231,
-0.0065475861,
-0.020245811,
0.0165733024,
-0.0057041952,
0.0234674122,
0.0250553004,
0.0626008511,
-0.058323577,
-0.001125778,
0.0067112246,
0.0270715542,
-0.0179221239,
-0.0032867044,
-0.0820275024,
-0.0027104779,
-0.0587060861,
0.051159855,
-0.0206022486,
0.023436347,
-0.0421008505,
0.0011122681,
-0.0045504132,
0.0175562687,
0.046250049,
0.0385416448,
0.0033932053,
-0.0312618315,
-0.0254664551,
0.0527109504,
-0.0222258046,
0.0184720028,
-0.027178647,
-0.0196677987,
-0.0033271867,
-0.0180736538,
0.0351486988,
-0.0809438601,
0.0060229395,
0.0598879233,
0.0595567338,
-0.036211215,
-0.0471297987,
-0.0507320128,
-0.0174736809,
-0.0275072679,
0.0523318537,
-0.0184856895,
0.0554225594,
0.0003849302,
0.0017343332,
-0.0119376136,
0.003390901,
-0.0084645171,
-0.0619620644,
0.0916634575,
-0.0536781214,
-0.0206728466,
-0.0576565266,
0.0187185742,
-0.017258836,
0.0517524891,
0.0272650234,
-0.0087902006,
0.0288158227,
0.0023171729,
-0.0549610667,
-0.0182519108,
0.0612887368,
-0.0163615886,
-0.0105021838,
0.0195437483,
-0.0328672491,
-0.0124134207,
-0.0069272514,
-0.0057295146,
-0.0141727841,
-0.066547133,
-0.0053903866,
-0.0214252472,
-0.0019803825,
-0.000802888,
0.0255599152,
-0.0097721973,
-0.016412681,
0.0242367629,
-0.0696709305,
0.0319518186,
-0.0444463976,
-0.0033095537,
-0.0443025529,
0.0047068079,
-0.0103651825,
-0.0019778926,
0.0065257121,
0.0121513,
-0.0282426178,
0.0178652592,
0.0671824962,
0.0260849763,
-0.0207097661,
0.0077742282,
0.0486295521,
0.005437722,
0.0267470852,
-0.0022406138,
-0.0381887592,
0.074752368,
0.0651398078,
-0.0488519371,
-0.0488111824,
0.022183599,
-0.0131109329,
-0.0253775902,
0.0176940951,
-0.037105348,
0.0171735585,
-0.0345086455,
-0.0665854961,
0.006184605,
-0.0246836543,
0.0086120991,
0.0189135727,
-0.0029874824,
-0.0013470814,
-0.0904541537,
0.0542376935,
-0.0183057431,
-0.0319848955,
-0.0184543487,
0.0162362922,
0.0299365968,
-0.0061911065,
0.0377959795,
-0.0039607696,
0.0011538692,
0.0036840218,
-0.0173664372,
-0.0027460898,
0.0142750321,
-0.025277691,
-0.0937509164,
0.0415094532,
-0.0125361048,
-0.0198664945,
-0.0185009651,
-0.0486457497,
-0.0345725976,
0.0224159602,
0.0225582719,
0.0782403722,
-0.0012851104,
-0.0351529121,
0.0248072203,
-0.021819409,
-0.0234721769,
0.0748471841,
-0.0059369328,
-0.029957572,
0.0107884994,
-0.0817436576,
0.025002867,
0.022503797,
0.0055934656,
0.0316430815,
-0.0035329356,
-0.0167833269,
-0.0099159973,
-0.0074804774,
-0.0901329815,
0.0281152297,
-0.0331358798,
0.0222301111,
0.0253915824,
0.025145445,
-0.0208468046,
0.028792439,
-0.0088201482,
-0.0345360599,
-0.0088742804,
0.0416158661,
-0.0141690262,
0.0031172885,
0.015214812,
0.0310506839,
0.015637666,
0.0117109241,
-0.0477401242,
-0.0377002507,
0.061031919,
0.0061347559,
-0.0293320976,
0.0639628246,
0.0443546027,
-0.0540477708,
0.0358022787,
-0.0075534685,
0.0322469585,
-0.0491252728,
-0.0278942063,
-0.0327761844,
0.012423736,
-0.0555076003,
-0.0135104451,
0.0346864276,
-0.0153720584,
-0.0280392505,
0.0174534526,
-0.0456763357,
-0.0000842705,
-0.0214174613,
-0.0090690572,
-0.0557699017,
-0.0211122315,
0.0154021671,
-0.0373323075,
-0.0773925036,
0.0243082382,
0.0142776212,
-0.0225245617,
-0.0311701801,
0.0364526846,
0.067978099,
0.0037222407,
-0.052020032,
0.0372626297,
0.0802162662,
0.0455709659,
0.0350070447,
0.0112184929,
0.0302405227,
-0.0201490205,
0.067483291,
0.0022774914,
0.0224955734,
0.0367578752,
-0.0187813547,
-0.0688282698,
-0.069910571,
0.0582946986,
-0.0046255267,
-0.0166047215,
-0.0287757143,
0.0392489098,
0.0052457564,
-0.0199226066,
-0.0131825525,
-0.0021257675,
-0.0458927564,
0.0476239137,
-0.0474292077,
-0.0137241865,
-0.0055067488,
-0.0113123171,
0.0024282099,
0.003919418,
0.0089477655,
-0.0436354838,
-0.0042881402,
0.0352256149,
0.0492739417,
-0.0319187418,
0.0092866225,
0.0204963628,
0.0446838066,
0.0367873386,
0.0496684089,
-0.0041868603,
-0.0095744571,
0.0293435734,
-0.0081015425,
-0.0156492628,
0.0006681292,
-0.0293176118,
0.0119101461,
-0.0555139408,
0.0225348491,
0.0783096999,
0.0309530199,
-0.0293279178,
-0.0076595014,
-0.0052754632,
0.0066344813,
0.0461514555,
0.0250096861,
-0.1099910662,
-0.0457969494,
-0.023275679,
0.0271189455,
0.0239849444,
-0.0937965214,
-0.0138229672,
-0.1007530689,
0.0207071863,
0.0179086588,
-0.0164176784,
-0.0262761563,
-0.0302671995,
0.033142589,
-0.0182951726,
-0.0307637602,
-0.0074370801,
-0.0339695252,
-0.0034343547,
0.0082365517,
0.0180150028,
-0.0568870008,
0.0390148312,
-0.006489391,
0.0139373941,
0.0013991626,
0.0253521781,
0.0133398538,
0.0503792055,
0.0015936148,
0.0050759264,
0.0285289437,
-0.0376509875,
0.0732076988,
-0.0204230808,
0.002913259,
-0.0033950175,
-0.0328473002,
-0.0574431419,
-0.0288383197,
-0.0038281551,
0.0838389546,
0.0004822596,
-0.0270361174,
-0.0217703357,
-0.0049913819,
-0.0021912912,
0.0371266343,
0.0073895925,
0.0348769166,
0.0101842666,
0.0123985196,
-0.0048910053,
-0.0666469187,
0.0197607111,
0.0389883481,
-0.0495109595,
0.0054860371,
-0.0257012807,
-0.029661607,
0.0722507685,
0.0262460504,
-0.0024535004,
0.0173157454,
0.0485229827,
0.0119018676,
-0.0863508955,
-0.0207739025,
-0.0515625663,
0.0165614411,
0.0464211889,
0.0376585163,
0.0247099362,
-0.035610918,
-0.0148022436,
-0.0668976605,
-0.0055166101,
-0.0416707732,
-0.0381493829,
0.0532860085,
0.0160945524,
0.0636709481,
-0.0102384677,
-0.0216972586,
0.0316012725,
0.0891170874,
-0.0134960497,
-0.0116214622,
0.0219661556,
-0.0583000518,
-0.0190057177,
0.0365298539,
-0.0486666597,
-0.0110146413,
0.0311383903,
0.033867944,
-0.0596391298,
0.0389325395,
0.0387997814,
0.0350700356,
0.0358818322,
0.0080368835,
0.013074738,
-0.0504070371,
0.0334756859,
-0.0309879556,
-0.0264883861,
-0.0226050522,
0.0096281795,
0.0107607879,
-0.0203428939,
-0.0158248805,
-0.044092223,
-0.0378112905,
0.0260780044,
-0.016449092,
-0.0133522339,
0.0271280985,
0.0013112471,
0.0308208484,
-0.025921816,
0.0008186886,
0.0226081461,
0.035675846,
0.000956392,
-0.0416260064,
0.0135485185,
0.0323304087,
-0.0315483771,
-0.0372905061,
0.0013499743,
-0.0439929441,
0.0438033454,
0.0014888598,
-0.0106029436,
0.0490859412,
-0.0158177949,
-0.0068665496,
0.0130478451,
-0.0155363306,
0.0044330554,
0.0536824688,
0.0006624397,
-0.0054766992,
0.0478841774,
0.0322899409,
0.0069037606,
0.0198298302,
0.0434126295,
0.0089659784,
0.0970256329,
0.0373504423,
-0.0581522435,
-0.0340695009,
-0.0402417891,
0.0046722055,
0.0511933193,
-0.0151182069,
0.0641673878,
-0.0892872885,
-0.0970313549,
-0.0121487128,
-0.0327688009,
-0.0128781851,
0.0375786088,
0.0168497786,
0.0072800401,
0.0544582047,
-0.0615092926,
-0.0223614834,
-0.0046087652,
-0.0525159836,
0.0015990101,
0.0481865518,
-6.061881839e-33,
-0.038111981,
-0.0473511517,
0.0296988003,
-0.0352808721,
-0.0276488774,
-0.0017563897,
-0.0277262405,
-0.0492319539,
-0.0661833808,
0.0120379245,
-0.0393137634,
0.0202428866,
0.014559947,
-0.0043645562,
-0.038373746,
-0.0238409061,
0.0079051405,
0.0056672962,
0.0238084085,
0.0145373363,
0.0398055911,
0.0529495589,
0.0748676062,
-0.0804151446,
-0.0015528325,
0.0270701461,
-0.0133315399,
0.0451892577,
-0.0121625904,
0.0460128114,
0.0203394946,
0.0561987944,
0.0379040018,
0.0261646658,
0.0088374475,
-0.0407278687,
-0.1215604618,
-0.0578986369,
0.0115091344,
0.0213953555,
-0.0313745104,
0.0090596387,
0.0119117526,
0.002335778,
0.0771713927,
-0.0858616605,
0.0403564796,
-0.0434146449,
-0.0529335402,
-0.0349508598,
-0.018494973,
0.0402542204,
0.0088243745,
0.0111324312,
0.0407967642,
0.0393785797,
0.0362311006,
-0.0114302132,
-0.0169267878,
0.0132540492,
-0.0215328969,
-0.0075869639,
0.0175073016,
-0.0047357273,
0.0054619405,
0.0487093702,
-0.0062944582,
0.0045497171,
0.0151643259,
0.0011509922,
-0.0088608349,
0.0753955096,
-0.027996663,
0.0557948947,
0.0403644778,
0.0006854221,
-0.0946815684,
-0.0348585211,
-0.0012434756,
0.0447426401,
-0.0231220331,
0.004076079,
-0.0443887785,
-0.028170485,
-0.0064056166,
-0.0113220401,
-0.0506098606,
-0.0300620925,
0.0169071145,
0.0035897084,
-0.0188004859,
0.0537957735,
-0.0099381516,
-0.05591961,
0.0007817738,
0.0568017513,
0.016727794,
-0.0013018907,
-0.0077981339,
0.0405158103,
-0.0067061717,
-0.0458655246,
0.0310046803,
-0.0274400376,
0.0281526484,
0.0219129287,
0.0873444006,
0.0184923224,
-0.0287561119,
-0.0299455598,
-0.0383367091,
0.0135395303,
-0.0258642826,
-0.0454827994,
0.0044476232,
0.0752232596,
0.0054666339,
0.0200593248,
0.0628394112,
-0.0129884481,
0.0144115221,
0.0729023218,
-0.0014799634,
0.029263176,
0.0099737737,
-0.0112057971,
0.0155094778,
-0.0400523841,
0.0413671099,
-0.0196414404,
-0.041334819,
0.0092410482,
2.692e-7,
0.0543080121,
0.0303938612,
0.0172424652,
0.0489084348,
0.001278556,
0.0395582542,
-0.0021923587,
0.033476118,
0.0198056754,
-0.0103630638,
0.0803598762,
0.0209531672,
-0.015552382,
0.0517368652,
-0.0160886422,
0.0260800999,
-0.0008364148,
-0.0688834637,
-0.0277307797,
-0.0072220522,
0.0778138191,
0.0408208631,
0.0506889708,
-0.0087772105,
-0.0281609129,
-0.0641338974,
0.0353730768,
-0.0059723728,
-0.0012451349,
-0.0076572369,
0.0149141746,
0.0284722392,
-0.013028997,
0.093911916,
-0.0275557507,
0.0197701138,
-0.0010360751,
0.0433648825,
-0.0492463149,
-0.0082968175,
0.0076022269,
-0.0197312776,
0.0334275961,
-0.0053549353,
0.0996223986,
-0.0459299311,
-0.0018383043,
0.0333387628,
-0.0370574594,
0.0053014173,
-0.0160556361,
0.0158233047,
-0.0047305585,
-0.0054033245,
0.0277802777,
0.0285568293,
-0.0258220546,
-0.0656491145,
0.0231656563,
0.0443359427,
0.0324657559,
-0.0294985045,
0.0267443229,
-0.0218311548,
0.0098681329,
-0.0510110371,
0.0105190761,
2.317940321e-34,
0.0239187516,
0.0097909421,
-0.0054227635,
-0.02443894,
0.0292363428,
-0.0433528684,
-0.0457875542,
-0.0099328589,
0.0449365787,
-0.0781811848,
-0.0072234576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13858v1 | Distributional reasoning in LLMs: Parallel reasoning processes in multi-hop reasoning | 2024-06-19T21:36:40 | 2024-06-19T21:36:40 | Yuval Shalev, Amir Feder, Ariel Goldstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown an impressive ability to perform
tasks believed to require thought processes. When the model does not document
an explicit thought process, it becomes difficult to understand the processes
occurring within its hidden layers and to determine if these processes can be
referred to as reasoning. We introduce a novel and interpretable analysis of
internal multi-hop reasoning processes in LLMs. We demonstrate that the
prediction process for compositional reasoning questions can be modeled using a
simple linear transformation between two semantic category spaces. We show that
during inference, the middle layers of the network generate highly
interpretable embeddings that represent a set of potential intermediate answers
for the multi-hop question. We use statistical analyses to show that a
corresponding subset of tokens is activated in the model's output, implying the
existence of parallel reasoning paths. These observations hold true even when
the model lacks the necessary knowledge to solve the task. Our findings can
help uncover the strategies that LLMs use to solve reasoning tasks, offering
insights into the types of thought processes that can emerge from artificial
intelligence. Finally, we also discuss the implication of cognitive modeling of
these results. | [
0.0368167311,
0.0201960597,
-0.0375728644,
0.0372488052,
-0.0563985519,
0.0355182439,
-0.0056871898,
-0.032015916,
0.0081087658,
-0.0467528217,
-0.0288199037,
-0.0175021514,
0.0001587653,
-0.0042099026,
0.0472558364,
0.0348194316,
0.0283790044,
-0.0379693098,
-0.0100401985,
-0.0127899302,
-0.0410152562,
0.0310432911,
-0.0161123089,
0.0424641706,
0.0008998689,
-0.0065430654,
-0.0276107695,
-0.0215304047,
-0.0323689021,
-0.0130414758,
-0.0265097767,
0.0097370045,
0.0472377688,
0.0379557349,
0.000002117,
-0.0435134172,
-0.0033628063,
-0.0115044136,
-0.0341395363,
-0.0364395119,
-0.0297730155,
0.00322647,
0.0043610488,
0.0098054484,
-0.01954614,
0.0126629118,
0.0353526175,
0.0622503273,
0.0095600374,
0.0377239473,
0.0033485328,
-0.0845780373,
0.0032305068,
0.0081494367,
0.0225873888,
-0.0200431589,
0.0419854298,
0.0436940677,
0.0229365509,
-0.0002867102,
-0.0388856903,
0.0189611521,
0.0492326766,
-0.0210356005,
-0.029261617,
0.0384864621,
0.026680408,
-0.0391291082,
0.0109899854,
0.0630961135,
-0.0147110987,
-0.0239338595,
-0.0022176574,
0.0100476826,
-0.0077809314,
0.0408468246,
-0.0488675646,
0.0455081873,
-0.008548704,
0.0228988416,
0.0400751606,
-0.0335845053,
0.0622810721,
-0.0176148545,
-0.0690299496,
0.1258321553,
-0.0043125497,
-0.0219122227,
0.0200599469,
-0.0055117602,
0.0017940488,
-0.0685581118,
-0.0026388757,
0.0553406663,
-0.0162284952,
0.0294140074,
0.046943482,
0.029876424,
-0.0027291796,
-0.0403746814,
0.0564273484,
0.0540343113,
0.0182250664,
0.054918699,
-0.0569243729,
0.0154504851,
-0.0593400486,
0.0517033935,
-0.0368631594,
-0.0214589294,
-0.0539684631,
-0.0421933681,
0.0091572143,
0.0666169003,
-0.0196426678,
-0.0323469676,
-0.0208010394,
0.0544428155,
-0.0201197527,
-0.0037935339,
0.0224963371,
0.0201365929,
0.0378569737,
-0.0077346428,
-0.0628740117,
0.0079107042,
-0.0279394649,
0.0450338013,
-0.0139059834,
0.0048026191,
-0.0232848302,
0.0127442935,
-0.0163610559,
-0.0354955085,
-0.0064267302,
0.0879570246,
0.0121367024,
0.0058593713,
-0.0525143966,
-0.0497014783,
-0.0195812955,
-0.0501482375,
0.0589043722,
-0.0556962751,
0.0153448116,
0.0315339826,
-0.0140877254,
-0.0226999279,
0.0006611956,
0.0076863975,
-0.0601825379,
0.0855640918,
0.0547910258,
0.0195386782,
0.0316515416,
0.0047694193,
-0.0313409418,
0.0537690707,
0.0230670776,
0.0000759479,
0.0077455915,
0.0070809014,
0.0068235868,
0.0068717659,
0.0278114006,
-0.0329915807,
-0.0327233709,
0.0059413989,
-0.045475401,
0.0394894518,
0.0142712835,
0.0346204862,
-0.0352553278,
-0.0512569696,
0.0131052993,
0.0821526721,
0.0510751419,
-0.0021227864,
0.0940172747,
-0.0391533785,
-0.0240357872,
0.0533937477,
-0.0548301265,
0.0684204698,
-0.026174292,
-0.0172835272,
0.0053625559,
-0.0119218919,
-0.0313138403,
-0.029864138,
-0.0290577617,
-0.0066574942,
0.0088451663,
-0.0151513852,
0.0435666628,
-0.0025863568,
-0.0274823364,
0.0648356155,
0.0118930908,
0.0042057596,
-0.0021329322,
-0.0623361915,
0.032510072,
0.0384965017,
0.0411685295,
0.0177474692,
0.0004743504,
-0.0023945665,
0.0074339868,
0.0234688818,
0.0132671632,
-0.0258833356,
-0.0292317625,
-0.0274037588,
-0.0107643008,
-0.0447143316,
0.0186526235,
0.0064199176,
-0.0479559824,
-0.0356187597,
-0.0009571207,
-0.0416390784,
0.0331056193,
0.0170758329,
-0.0399434157,
0.0175777171,
-0.0261222627,
0.0263182316,
0.0132660596,
-0.0003496713,
0.0143685341,
0.0562735982,
0.0172937792,
-0.0191037748,
-0.0591869727,
0.034601789,
-0.028877642,
-0.0403320156,
0.0102230627,
-0.0341462977,
-0.0055338489,
0.000072652,
-0.0005918948,
-0.0243825894,
0.0719359741,
-0.0272477567,
0.0518948957,
-0.0574142039,
0.007930723,
0.0140233422,
-0.0249444712,
-0.0136124622,
0.0622543432,
-0.0098592807,
0.0285923518,
0.0037071346,
0.0288309101,
0.0279236659,
0.0157837439,
0.0138281463,
0.0168852489,
0.0075422423,
-0.0167769138,
-0.0389092043,
-0.0308422316,
-0.0455979593,
-0.0192256626,
-0.0455221683,
-0.000789795,
0.005955576,
0.0141132623,
0.0325908214,
-0.0248738658,
0.0346443579,
0.0250836406,
-0.0172564462,
0.0264416952,
0.0075154849,
0.036464233,
0.0543679222,
-0.023497818,
-0.0069415439,
-0.014314495,
-0.0162091181,
-0.0636849627,
0.0958452374,
-0.0094812652,
-0.0039358544,
-0.0370808244,
-0.0105902953,
-0.050007619,
0.0223850701,
-0.0202500708,
-0.033615984,
0.033701811,
-0.0217076335,
0.0239797905,
0.049777586,
-0.0102849761,
0.06120364,
0.0630568638,
-0.0202145092,
-0.0374811888,
0.0133502455,
-0.0617406182,
0.0046092635,
-0.0448067449,
-0.0230528899,
-0.0492597185,
0.0852553472,
0.0272274856,
-0.0224525984,
-0.0478429049,
0.0468506441,
-0.0230753478,
-0.0074218088,
-0.0476026051,
-0.0245650746,
-0.0002889388,
0.0684465319,
0.0008491553,
-0.0090182656,
0.0982687771,
0.0007381186,
0.0105902189,
-0.0114514194,
-0.0035720391,
-0.0401460454,
0.0728123635,
-0.0147839114,
0.0052141552,
-0.0202739183,
-0.0201343559,
-0.0688227639,
-0.0190747194,
-0.0068448782,
-0.0054769628,
0.005413644,
-0.0334468596,
0.0041624443,
0.0001509635,
0.0019668401,
-0.0174516886,
0.0134816803,
-0.0406103544,
0.0317257717,
0.0047641871,
-0.0037657213,
-0.0104459319,
0.0133028403,
0.0058343057,
0.0002686302,
-0.0262153912,
-0.0141944317,
-0.0290950164,
0.027308898,
0.020899063,
0.0144788278,
0.043989446,
-0.0185135566,
0.0353527591,
0.0479199477,
-0.0163571537,
0.0247683953,
-0.0065327119,
0.0252384078,
-0.0008677928,
0.0089795999,
-0.0221988838,
-0.0175227765,
0.0328341573,
-0.0480472259,
-0.0140023204,
0.1073690578,
0.0650307536,
-0.030569775,
0.0261837635,
-0.0480888411,
-0.0192529764,
0.0339708142,
0.0384990051,
-0.0750997514,
-0.0211154167,
0.0169019382,
-0.0425693095,
-0.0179056432,
-0.0412005819,
-0.0272175819,
-0.0879455432,
0.0373031348,
-0.0256570466,
-0.0329755172,
-0.0323724672,
-0.0274985041,
0.0061498769,
0.0483393408,
-0.0177324247,
0.0251952335,
0.0320879035,
-0.0103884405,
-0.00226877,
0.0162321292,
-0.0270566884,
0.0622520819,
-0.0102651566,
0.0458344147,
0.0153390933,
0.0496383943,
0.0162600633,
-0.0684621409,
0.0807299539,
-0.0568733998,
0.00823808,
-0.0208068937,
-0.0081055323,
0.0111739459,
0.0005398872,
-0.008185667,
0.0262791272,
-0.0508681238,
-0.0168917514,
-0.0217596609,
0.1083436459,
-0.0605517775,
-0.0598234385,
-0.0222203191,
0.0487453192,
-0.0300247911,
0.0947684944,
0.0474721566,
-0.0312958509,
-0.0409166738,
-0.0469348095,
-0.0437241122,
-0.0142003335,
-0.0215554666,
0.0354719162,
0.0530728474,
0.018227363,
-0.0498651974,
-0.0309547652,
0.0354171172,
0.0023958667,
-0.0008820413,
-0.0082432069,
0.0053526759,
-0.0274052974,
-0.0390231833,
0.0061350949,
-0.0136137456,
0.0278409757,
0.011832186,
0.0220299512,
0.037017554,
-0.0431295335,
-0.0585441291,
-0.0393007137,
-0.0599287264,
-0.0563710183,
-0.0436847247,
-0.0028827647,
0.0271776132,
0.0180689488,
-0.0163626317,
-0.034002427,
0.0252254177,
-0.0055902526,
-0.0171758141,
0.0290260985,
0.0255591515,
0.0104331793,
0.0217632931,
0.0555157252,
-0.035826616,
0.0171563402,
0.0233889483,
0.0307202786,
0.0009091319,
-0.011390768,
0.0230180249,
-0.0259933136,
0.0066432268,
0.0588191003,
-0.0003535561,
-0.0380453616,
0.0327618234,
-0.0233390834,
-0.0308346972,
-0.0256045721,
-0.0087199705,
0.0194778368,
-0.0036928295,
-0.0075823823,
-0.0749475062,
0.0129548497,
0.0403761193,
0.0572574325,
-0.0093474798,
0.0478701331,
-0.02374883,
0.0093321223,
0.0063306871,
-0.0081877271,
0.0015284127,
-0.0317424126,
0.0230582133,
-0.0141311986,
0.0652551353,
0.0379797928,
-0.0149568943,
-0.0522694513,
-0.0075079938,
-0.0705422536,
-0.0628919601,
0.0566444173,
0.018513985,
0.0339279771,
-0.008623627,
0.0056187897,
-0.0210953783,
-0.0121331392,
0.0104601001,
0.0199851375,
0.0142793534,
-0.0199865606,
0.0749548599,
0.0231511537,
-0.0053650639,
-0.0264939331,
0.0504282266,
-0.016462462,
0.043511413,
-0.0448204428,
-0.0113993352,
-0.0165140834,
-0.0385945849,
-0.0042680399,
0.0528726727,
-0.0076751043,
0.0345160402,
-0.0721898079,
-0.084026508,
-0.0204377696,
0.0473992266,
-0.0128739355,
-0.0255926661,
0.0003053882,
0.0873163417,
0.0387762412,
-0.021192329,
-0.0237291213,
-0.0192496758,
-0.0062420736,
-0.0088320486,
-0.0167165734,
-6.602300673e-33,
0.0064015519,
-0.0753242895,
0.0560389943,
-0.0084792394,
-0.0162136629,
-0.0080112964,
-0.0416170843,
-0.0116104865,
-0.0556470901,
0.0299587715,
-0.001254768,
0.0155132683,
-0.0094757909,
0.0220120195,
0.0188938472,
-0.0062229806,
-0.0129613811,
-0.0084191673,
-0.0004901919,
0.0016746134,
0.0585934892,
0.0009270785,
0.0187398121,
-0.0034768372,
0.0263253842,
0.0183129087,
0.0221824609,
0.0589479059,
-0.0590188466,
0.0459240116,
-0.0189964809,
0.0065015168,
0.0582481399,
-0.0201156847,
0.0160232093,
0.0250659101,
-0.0464410596,
-0.0484008715,
0.0766078383,
-0.020733973,
-0.0596282333,
-0.0268448349,
0.0463991724,
-0.0030008124,
0.0102881081,
-0.0418391339,
0.0246705338,
-0.0106042577,
0.0177703071,
-0.0009877165,
-0.0612217374,
-0.014674481,
-0.0260876268,
-0.0117101558,
0.0113815144,
0.0173178501,
0.0014728619,
0.048135709,
-0.0670403242,
0.0235909987,
-0.0604514182,
-0.0069283154,
0.0640483126,
0.0059761098,
0.009495629,
0.0604603775,
0.0020671249,
-0.0257984586,
-0.0652510971,
-0.0013323332,
0.0163549241,
0.0412366837,
0.0326969326,
-0.0261872169,
0.0080085732,
-0.0009098237,
-0.0837915018,
-0.02727242,
0.0042643012,
0.0074064918,
0.0666574836,
0.0054104226,
0.0196152739,
-0.0293317847,
-0.063934572,
-0.0071490603,
-0.0515010506,
-0.0372152962,
0.0220351685,
-0.0341207795,
0.0031545337,
0.0015984868,
0.0191464424,
-0.0622037426,
-0.0185072049,
0.0167102125,
-0.0073127924,
0.0061866934,
0.0089689642,
0.0370931216,
-0.0370245576,
-0.0063834647,
-0.0212845057,
0.0063478691,
0.0009223162,
0.0482061841,
0.0195609182,
0.0067136236,
-0.0150978966,
-0.0373561308,
-0.0847326145,
-0.0408074744,
-0.022109542,
0.0206485111,
0.0449582711,
0.0581706092,
-0.0251034629,
-0.0057231919,
0.0102027394,
0.0317158513,
-0.0063287569,
0.0637200549,
-0.0267238747,
0.0460397154,
-0.0557776578,
-0.0318863355,
-0.0457932614,
0.0365522355,
0.0449827313,
-0.0808351859,
-0.0142401764,
0.0151946843,
2.907e-7,
0.0801429451,
0.0418471396,
-0.0165151823,
0.0464817807,
0.0627237037,
0.0108059971,
-0.0176727008,
-0.0176665951,
0.0423655324,
-0.0609081089,
-0.0074237385,
0.0522495471,
0.0045479126,
0.0371686034,
-0.0592224896,
0.0104296673,
-0.0310328696,
-0.0187958404,
-0.016195979,
0.0126364529,
0.077999033,
0.0591493882,
0.0362420641,
-0.0222675111,
-0.0173701253,
-0.0455556884,
0.0547861643,
0.0046137967,
0.0192693509,
-0.0165210795,
-0.0229458194,
-0.0049958886,
0.0261565167,
0.0309931505,
0.0193218756,
0.0152161913,
-0.0172835439,
0.0382771008,
-0.0004470461,
-0.0312103666,
-0.0112879071,
-0.0320127234,
0.0131976223,
-0.0718079358,
0.0877336636,
-0.1075441763,
-0.0623226166,
-0.0170843024,
0.0454956666,
-0.0026872978,
0.0013776564,
0.0087716477,
0.0007118527,
0.0070555536,
0.0026981023,
0.007909528,
0.0582994856,
-0.1148213521,
-0.0144151272,
0.0046342229,
-0.0463766754,
-0.0393590815,
-0.005751349,
-0.0354471132,
0.0710908994,
-0.04151069,
-0.0304565802,
2.78493438e-34,
0.0286572948,
-0.0072638281,
0.0227145441,
0.0190517046,
0.027705038,
-0.0316001438,
0.0026175037,
0.0050277626,
0.0244959779,
-0.0888899416,
-0.0401132293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13846v1 | Text Serialization and Their Relationship with the Conventional Paradigms of Tabular Machine Learning | 2024-06-19T21:19:37 | 2024-06-19T21:19:37 | Kyoka Ono, Simon A. Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent research has explored how Language Models (LMs) can be used for
feature representation and prediction in tabular machine learning tasks. This
involves employing text serialization and supervised fine-tuning (SFT)
techniques. Despite the simplicity of these techniques, significant gaps remain
in our understanding of the applicability and reliability of LMs in this
context. Our study assesses how emerging LM technologies compare with
traditional paradigms in tabular machine learning and evaluates the feasibility
of adopting similar approaches with these advanced technologies. At the data
level, we investigate various methods of data representation and curation of
serialized tabular data, exploring their impact on prediction performance. At
the classification level, we examine whether text serialization combined with
LMs enhances performance on tabular datasets (e.g. class imbalance,
distribution shift, biases, and high dimensionality), and assess whether this
method represents a state-of-the-art (SOTA) approach for addressing tabular
machine learning challenges. Our findings reveal current pre-trained models
should not replace conventional approaches. | [
0.0036439421,
0.0518633612,
-0.0317804553,
-0.021858681,
-0.0131967645,
0.0218591075,
0.0320265666,
0.0092057288,
-0.0233890824,
-0.087858282,
-0.0045756199,
-0.051293198,
-0.0004678581,
0.0661258548,
0.0168489255,
-0.0068544857,
0.0185543727,
0.003865941,
-0.0077518988,
0.0229544751,
-0.0117754135,
0.0115168868,
0.0515248552,
0.0237611029,
0.0054736035,
0.0021603859,
-0.0369044617,
-0.0017740597,
-0.0444729552,
-0.00861785,
0.0210277531,
0.0669472814,
0.0438002087,
0.0156128723,
0.0000022963,
-0.0254908595,
-0.0518996678,
-0.0055119498,
0.0022365469,
0.0326511897,
0.0895665139,
-0.0553064123,
0.0126107736,
0.0128947245,
-0.0234856717,
-0.0292621069,
0.0145548414,
0.029926721,
0.0478339642,
0.0426168405,
-0.0279787034,
-0.0431745686,
0.0368881859,
-0.0128928125,
0.007924431,
0.018616939,
0.0291776899,
-0.0122336904,
-0.0570245422,
0.0047087371,
-0.0097884089,
0.0251409858,
-0.0034236794,
0.0255695339,
0.039390564,
0.0267051626,
-0.0622467995,
0.0129863434,
-0.008558589,
0.0491780527,
-0.0133601632,
-0.0258732438,
0.0088577438,
-0.024310831,
0.0124230646,
-0.0257570539,
-0.0159457009,
0.0142999906,
-0.0043217964,
0.0437062643,
-0.0093472768,
-0.0123544792,
0.0148190958,
-0.0268773995,
-0.026333455,
0.0001980264,
-0.0396095216,
-0.0404428281,
-0.0191020295,
-0.0076483381,
0.0103072468,
-0.0361619443,
0.0064999904,
0.0374384113,
0.0145373717,
-0.0117819821,
-0.0611828193,
-0.0967655256,
0.0488203801,
-0.0397812575,
0.0948120207,
0.0032625613,
-0.0130214524,
0.0054505486,
-0.0160704311,
0.0165065639,
0.0334546044,
0.0287790745,
-0.0149492035,
0.0067688623,
-0.0477514714,
-0.0202374514,
-0.0312081017,
0.04667807,
-0.0072047547,
0.0241266564,
-0.0252475832,
0.0206881724,
0.0098490249,
0.0148092313,
-0.0210967027,
-0.011415503,
-0.0136615187,
0.015164908,
-0.0175754,
0.0042522107,
0.0068959673,
0.0174680408,
-0.0093767606,
-0.0620421283,
0.0004735331,
0.0066853757,
0.0129380189,
-0.0210705008,
0.0492835008,
0.0368555374,
0.0036248155,
-0.0394028425,
-0.0692813918,
-0.0298116542,
-0.0299936347,
-0.0322763547,
-0.0171915554,
-0.0773366243,
0.0400132984,
0.0326251797,
-0.0227879342,
-0.0360100791,
-0.0188274048,
0.0324560329,
-0.0485671349,
0.0653195158,
-0.0192872919,
0.0343955941,
0.0369999073,
-0.0458973944,
0.0098370556,
0.0384079367,
0.0614398383,
0.0458828881,
0.0121057006,
-0.0750151128,
0.000485811,
0.0242208913,
0.0186178274,
-0.0121017667,
-0.0673292205,
0.017241396,
0.0284674615,
-0.0056217695,
0.0265498087,
0.0112385023,
0.0107219433,
0.0138411969,
0.0894157887,
0.0810738951,
-0.0043320945,
0.0620635711,
0.0038001793,
0.0145296073,
0.0121662887,
-0.0133568961,
0.0064511797,
-0.0328638516,
-0.012246687,
-0.0024069755,
0.0231011659,
0.0650405288,
-0.0292225461,
-0.0760244951,
-0.0137911336,
-0.0363698266,
0.0487853289,
-0.0137744937,
0.0641978905,
-0.0113365604,
-0.0215239078,
0.0284440424,
0.0462055206,
-0.0211470835,
-0.0320899487,
-0.0430336408,
-0.00495735,
0.0559851155,
0.0172169805,
-0.0554236881,
0.0148463026,
-0.0332394876,
0.0411519893,
-0.0067566033,
0.0671535134,
0.0096357837,
-0.0061368528,
-0.026989948,
0.0099072,
0.0298795924,
0.0118222525,
-0.0097904094,
-0.0297559779,
0.0318495668,
-0.0050207418,
-0.0423910096,
-0.0947642028,
0.0454716496,
0.0231372323,
-0.0359662697,
0.0363097303,
0.0056296065,
0.0006105757,
-0.0018839883,
-0.0128006218,
-0.0118428767,
0.047109399,
0.0036995476,
0.0045139836,
-0.0432793908,
-0.0128823677,
0.0171438158,
-0.0037581271,
0.077650629,
-0.0063881115,
0.0073288111,
-0.0539004728,
0.0092347879,
-0.0147639532,
-0.0069272611,
-0.0152633935,
-0.0275391322,
0.0462627672,
-0.0373651013,
0.0422427505,
-0.0454680212,
0.0499427617,
-0.0074832016,
0.0084335739,
-0.0315638892,
-0.0900660008,
0.0251630787,
-0.028252719,
-0.0196959041,
0.009826907,
-0.0189049505,
0.0441282876,
-0.0070681171,
-0.0131935235,
0.000126775,
-0.0091620525,
-0.1138127968,
0.0180337615,
-0.0221286081,
0.0113658747,
0.0106961597,
-0.0094388928,
-0.0225905851,
-0.0271944888,
-0.046060238,
-0.0102043971,
0.0392121337,
0.0149220955,
0.0845420137,
-0.0090301931,
-0.0005284381,
-0.0274441186,
-0.0246490259,
-0.0517896451,
0.0666362941,
-0.0060655898,
-0.0241375882,
-0.0529480502,
0.0070849466,
0.0005412389,
0.0140277063,
0.012559751,
-0.0067350254,
-0.0177956894,
-0.0161015633,
-0.0072184061,
0.0664192364,
0.0025637287,
0.0798105597,
0.0571173541,
0.0128196599,
-0.0215513501,
0.0062831622,
-0.0334307589,
0.0135045014,
-0.0379951261,
-0.0532604866,
0.052773647,
0.0454051197,
-0.0031257814,
0.0241465867,
-0.0303130951,
0.0184437651,
0.0330342539,
0.0214536283,
-0.0425289348,
0.0545125939,
-0.0063880673,
0.0161723401,
0.0124506261,
-0.0798336715,
0.0339770578,
-0.0401828848,
0.0259657241,
-0.0199659318,
-0.050186798,
-0.0268716682,
0.0575136133,
0.0327763855,
-0.0037305017,
0.0175876524,
-0.0151394261,
-0.0158080608,
-0.0030662185,
-0.01176978,
-0.0459477156,
0.0463131331,
0.0006619112,
-0.0245786961,
-0.0214815438,
-0.0194334947,
-0.0049930229,
-0.102809526,
0.0061318572,
0.0237099379,
0.0341409482,
0.0020273819,
-0.0615961961,
0.0365539379,
-0.0131359063,
0.0329773277,
0.0034455783,
-0.025885947,
-0.0263166521,
0.035932906,
0.0219610389,
-0.0373344608,
-0.0199429709,
-0.030093031,
-0.0239677019,
0.0278453082,
-0.0502589233,
0.0369168557,
-0.0135041885,
0.0039942623,
0.0311024021,
-0.0370089374,
-0.0309863053,
0.0243127178,
0.0081350273,
-0.0562934093,
0.0105052423,
0.1228789538,
0.0320153274,
-0.0181295592,
-0.0046620965,
0.0027886385,
0.0612022653,
-0.0089003295,
0.054393068,
-0.0500062369,
-0.0068038432,
-0.0038011936,
0.0427880101,
0.0066624791,
-0.0308884215,
-0.009833958,
-0.094264783,
0.0557251051,
0.0113366591,
-0.0618420579,
-0.0839871615,
-0.0325323008,
-0.041908022,
-0.0184076112,
0.0188987888,
-0.0143983681,
-0.0546207502,
0.0066831512,
0.0543627143,
-0.0864581838,
-0.0575970635,
-0.0103883734,
-0.0302618127,
0.0381726548,
0.0605905876,
0.004762332,
-0.0458374396,
0.0005669866,
-0.0088119498,
0.0530413017,
0.030015029,
-0.0036724722,
0.0743694827,
-0.0350597575,
-0.0095336344,
-0.0020735641,
-0.0147726294,
-0.0057045422,
0.0048674173,
0.0110636186,
0.0575292259,
-0.0445174798,
-0.0167787485,
-0.0102699241,
-0.0389592722,
0.0154667692,
0.0639564171,
0.0236304365,
-0.0571472123,
-0.0380400829,
-0.0238510445,
-0.0303575173,
0.0195595864,
0.0218981747,
0.0338249691,
-0.0208504423,
-0.014769651,
-0.0610454008,
-0.047414694,
0.0336114392,
-0.0162793528,
-0.0011748114,
0.050333377,
0.0014060369,
-0.0142548708,
-0.0753276497,
-0.0100744357,
-0.0097452784,
-0.0097013395,
-0.0430017263,
-0.0411526971,
0.0071117845,
-0.0739829242,
-0.0325363688,
-0.0381437242,
-0.0773429349,
-0.0460983925,
-0.0083554788,
0.0407926142,
0.0175115615,
0.0217058752,
0.0426115729,
-0.0628116056,
0.0174972042,
0.0832285509,
-0.0376197696,
0.0027485725,
-0.0195127185,
-0.0407877974,
-0.0097563313,
-0.0006750626,
-0.0184993297,
0.0285805948,
-0.0248160996,
-0.0248209424,
-0.0219487436,
-0.0150907254,
-0.0006107244,
0.006890262,
0.0769358128,
0.0371541157,
-0.0693597943,
-0.0013754462,
0.0190357603,
0.003537864,
-0.0332705043,
-0.016669156,
-0.0304009262,
-0.009498097,
0.0047714044,
-0.0521559007,
0.0257188696,
0.0041414341,
0.0613145083,
-0.0607629754,
0.0315735713,
-0.0226287544,
-0.0107388739,
0.0402761512,
0.0042066807,
-0.0054427627,
-0.0038727997,
-0.0069263484,
0.0416432321,
0.004278685,
0.020161489,
0.0131155271,
0.030474253,
-0.041432891,
0.0581581481,
-0.0370722674,
-0.0651002675,
-0.0588378496,
-0.002561345,
-0.0181595348,
-0.0206706244,
-0.0117420526,
-0.008031656,
-0.0151087493,
-0.0214400776,
0.0238617081,
0.0596055649,
0.0296545811,
-0.0009900801,
-0.0009738564,
-0.0772322491,
-0.0215181839,
0.0692219213,
0.0573231764,
-0.0050347196,
0.0049261008,
-0.0597762242,
-0.0184688773,
0.0619247183,
0.0768577084,
0.0273512341,
-0.0094659198,
-0.0564200617,
-0.0343693458,
-0.0412182771,
0.0637506023,
-0.0041961712,
0.0093720332,
-0.0143088298,
-0.0053658034,
0.0629661456,
0.0064167022,
0.0320948362,
-0.0532728843,
0.0091608018,
-0.0258879364,
-0.0299424883,
-0.0159560349,
-6.439081078e-33,
-0.0221188236,
-0.0057375142,
0.0035156491,
0.0214207526,
0.0096210195,
-0.0074556493,
-0.0134375645,
-0.0161237493,
0.0250199698,
-0.0159364864,
-0.0258798674,
-0.0164476894,
0.0170829985,
0.0164759029,
0.0327267423,
-0.0204161834,
0.0407816842,
-0.0244121142,
-0.0135355629,
0.0005473475,
0.0033753111,
0.0570804812,
0.0448892079,
-0.0576568693,
-0.0063046641,
-0.0286808349,
0.0165563598,
-0.017833963,
0.0244135335,
0.022090625,
-0.02464897,
0.0421518907,
0.0515711643,
-0.0233820397,
-0.0190315619,
0.0666270331,
-0.064912118,
0.0137311323,
-0.0378894359,
0.0325007588,
0.0352772772,
-0.0201328378,
0.0473176576,
-0.0233412124,
0.0001975218,
-0.0108895097,
0.0653334484,
-0.0379468463,
-0.036380779,
-0.0388944224,
-0.0361487679,
0.0346541554,
-0.0024180813,
0.0039100694,
0.031164255,
0.0311817396,
0.0259625781,
0.066743128,
-0.0646711737,
0.0057533477,
0.0233937372,
0.0109275915,
0.0225468799,
0.0131262857,
0.0191993769,
0.0657186061,
0.0439600386,
0.0208928771,
-0.0476221032,
0.0193961542,
0.0203742795,
0.0217412524,
0.0145379361,
-0.0002175355,
0.0708547235,
-0.0300583001,
-0.0676200837,
0.054849077,
-0.0097853402,
-0.046320226,
0.037345767,
-0.0129220486,
-0.0651947111,
-0.0387978517,
-0.0258762781,
-0.048043184,
-0.0080327615,
-0.0184940733,
0.0165953748,
-0.0021954372,
0.0079527004,
0.0155392708,
0.0208899695,
-0.013917448,
-0.0407511927,
0.0174270812,
-0.038754113,
0.0365447588,
-0.0118814008,
-0.0374954157,
-0.0180664435,
-0.046007026,
0.0057724752,
-0.0060666571,
0.0411909893,
0.016833283,
0.0782361329,
0.0365925282,
-0.0673798397,
0.0083206547,
0.0215776116,
0.0081942761,
0.0187282339,
0.077807501,
0.0195863005,
0.0149980187,
0.0082376963,
0.071717754,
0.0175400693,
-0.0213773865,
-0.0073364163,
-0.0321487896,
-0.0118356179,
-0.0149039989,
0.0286238398,
0.0104184942,
-0.0202076584,
0.0336196832,
0.0498403572,
-0.0154332193,
0.0131603749,
0.0000047289,
2.738e-7,
0.0865246803,
0.0666118488,
0.0061679529,
-0.0151858861,
0.0247709136,
0.0425366871,
0.0093754288,
0.0376993418,
-0.0062255384,
0.0277075842,
0.0360234529,
0.0131620346,
0.0663650706,
0.0591434948,
-0.0644337013,
-0.0146695608,
-0.0951214433,
0.0113648241,
-0.0669023842,
0.0242126696,
0.0606326275,
0.1063079014,
-0.0166924465,
-0.0467371829,
0.0400640033,
-0.0208155811,
0.0400087759,
-0.0549651533,
0.0324721858,
0.0275661852,
0.0012862519,
0.0028468342,
-0.0319164917,
0.047708977,
-0.0175570063,
0.0201993641,
-0.0204201881,
0.0590716004,
-0.0358160436,
0.0325626023,
0.0174128897,
-0.0178961214,
-0.030186791,
-0.0670502931,
0.0793602541,
-0.038935326,
-0.0169561338,
-0.0026541445,
-0.0051336465,
-0.0173717365,
0.0451590829,
-0.0016751636,
-0.0011690469,
0.0389187671,
0.0144414455,
-0.0221624486,
-0.0075729354,
-0.0647439063,
-0.0229635686,
0.0398847461,
0.0102106445,
0.0085201329,
-0.0263842233,
-0.0188822728,
0.0528186075,
-0.0845747218,
0.0444090962,
3.099994187e-34,
0.0377746783,
-0.0026561823,
0.0271522831,
0.0125437528,
0.0047881403,
0.0141984979,
0.0320737772,
0.0291396175,
-0.0071196919,
-0.0926965773,
0.0287565533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13842v1 | Joint vs Sequential Speaker-Role Detection and Automatic Speech Recognition for Air-traffic Control | 2024-06-19T21:11:01 | 2024-06-19T21:11:01 | Alexander Blatt, Aravind Krishnan, Dietrich Klakow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Utilizing air-traffic control (ATC) data for downstream natural-language
processing tasks requires preprocessing steps. Key steps are the transcription
of the data via automatic speech recognition (ASR) and speaker diarization,
respectively speaker role detection (SRD) to divide the transcripts into pilot
and air-traffic controller (ATCO) transcripts. While traditional approaches
take on these tasks separately, we propose a transformer-based joint ASR-SRD
system that solves both tasks jointly while relying on a standard ASR
architecture. We compare this joint system against two cascaded approaches for
ASR and SRD on multiple ATC datasets. Our study shows in which cases our joint
system can outperform the two traditional approaches and in which cases the
other architectures are preferable. We additionally evaluate how acoustic and
lexical differences influence all architectures and show how to overcome them
for our joint architecture. | [
0.0225033686,
0.0536044538,
-0.0142024513,
0.0458710045,
-0.0177988596,
0.0068537914,
0.0362316556,
-0.0559845641,
-0.042369172,
-0.0550599359,
-0.0224901177,
-0.0522848256,
0.0269462802,
0.0251588896,
-0.0096558183,
-0.0425145328,
0.0247450955,
-0.07548742,
0.030842267,
0.0192201082,
-0.0169294551,
0.0346358418,
-0.0416373312,
0.0238528773,
-0.0130615579,
0.0261570085,
0.0065231477,
-0.0194791872,
0.0672447085,
0.0049341065,
0.001564056,
0.0137656014,
0.0568820648,
0.0218424611,
0.000001911,
0.0083157979,
-0.0022331167,
0.0146140847,
-0.0340412259,
-0.029730022,
0.0491118878,
0.0253135487,
-0.0327590927,
0.0498327352,
-0.0331577286,
-0.0537664555,
0.0164856948,
0.0758038908,
0.084876053,
0.0454608761,
-0.0162986089,
-0.0710462779,
0.0149861686,
-0.0015855226,
-0.0465475805,
-0.0367837064,
0.0110629825,
-0.0442405082,
-0.0096933795,
-0.0309394691,
-0.0096836761,
0.0367054828,
-0.0226626731,
-0.0416901,
0.0119977277,
0.0144919865,
-0.0517319217,
-0.0276365988,
-0.0548260398,
0.0053067985,
-0.002308158,
0.0129070198,
0.0426079892,
0.0155619727,
-0.0096357157,
0.0050177518,
0.0314591117,
-0.0249683447,
-0.0291496459,
-0.0394303873,
0.017163422,
0.0452283919,
-0.0317856818,
-0.0260203928,
-0.0681620836,
0.0206640102,
-0.0340888575,
-0.0532781929,
0.0093702767,
0.016384054,
0.0354147144,
-0.0365886912,
0.0551103726,
-0.0141825508,
-0.0318946578,
0.0129165491,
-0.0032731006,
-0.0363859236,
-0.0441534147,
-0.0357467011,
0.0104605025,
0.0171091445,
-0.0537488684,
-0.0082902322,
-0.0284340288,
0.0538388528,
0.027660979,
-0.0183484834,
-0.0195453241,
-0.0021978575,
-0.0496980511,
-0.0066107139,
-0.0680818856,
0.030006174,
-0.0228397939,
-0.0070039313,
-0.0656262264,
0.0044505,
-0.0177161004,
0.0200723242,
0.0653693825,
0.00145303,
-0.0112989694,
0.0420029387,
0.0300524253,
0.0302557033,
0.0594965294,
0.033566989,
-0.019116953,
-0.0256723408,
0.0243873969,
0.0130601292,
0.0640708879,
0.0262446031,
-0.0590014718,
0.033284422,
-0.0123583227,
-0.0450166948,
-0.0177792013,
-0.0032748843,
-0.0261778142,
-0.0328624994,
-0.0146311782,
-0.0486566536,
0.029164169,
0.021378208,
0.0027544538,
-0.006878858,
0.0111707309,
-0.034748394,
0.0167099107,
0.0981831178,
0.0230212118,
0.0170041658,
0.0684240907,
-0.0006570071,
0.0380072445,
0.0547329001,
0.0462126397,
-0.0267738756,
0.0292697772,
-0.0258089658,
0.0379921421,
0.0284160748,
-0.0630949363,
-0.0295837913,
0.0135094775,
0.0069613531,
-0.029792361,
-0.0118265999,
0.0370200165,
0.0039229225,
0.0034753713,
0.0142454151,
0.0331012048,
0.0643039197,
0.0272701383,
-0.0115304934,
0.0689136535,
0.0568292439,
0.01298845,
-0.0006981866,
-0.001456094,
-0.0256940555,
-0.0036494792,
-0.0693792403,
-0.0226953793,
0.0456065312,
-0.006779578,
-0.0400135741,
0.0384136178,
-0.0442726724,
-0.0211398359,
0.0451854393,
0.0376258455,
-0.030054057,
-0.0081849685,
0.0364232399,
-0.0041562738,
-0.0157111771,
0.006905599,
-0.0052921232,
-0.0766881481,
0.0284354147,
-0.0241454821,
-0.0487335995,
0.0178285576,
-0.0628254265,
-0.0207966547,
0.0171291232,
0.0000188354,
0.0081258938,
0.0121606728,
-0.0306042116,
-0.0333914943,
0.0875530317,
-0.0074828379,
0.0440491438,
-0.012721709,
0.0201646108,
0.0314002894,
0.0345757902,
-0.0225703176,
-0.0076362714,
-0.0137492009,
-0.0122845154,
0.037287008,
0.0224518813,
0.0640205219,
0.0338636413,
-0.0475857966,
-0.0068009365,
0.0123747289,
-0.0062071923,
-0.0153231286,
0.0324628465,
-0.0733679309,
-0.0138044124,
0.0034858629,
-0.0254297238,
-0.0475894734,
0.0634006858,
0.0060253679,
-0.0870429277,
0.0425874442,
-0.0644115508,
0.0133999558,
0.0013062881,
0.0584248155,
0.0238517635,
0.0248114094,
-0.0026762479,
0.0029658452,
0.034573894,
-0.036858961,
0.0211502016,
-0.0036275957,
0.0285481345,
-0.0522707142,
-0.0341334119,
-0.0042747036,
-0.0129159531,
-0.0103662089,
0.0289134812,
-0.0355780497,
0.0113824699,
-0.0160442684,
-0.0313339494,
-0.0358974636,
-0.0455543771,
0.0105385575,
-0.0147443181,
0.0292192325,
-0.0083423676,
-0.0030574589,
-0.0310068298,
-0.0168994032,
0.0249305833,
-0.0411655568,
-0.039653793,
0.0022383048,
-0.1020550281,
-0.0180067625,
-0.0051632375,
-0.0173517819,
-0.0029314624,
0.0201905295,
-0.0317014307,
-0.0912190005,
0.0068562189,
0.0110404175,
0.0680652186,
-0.0246199071,
-0.013037161,
0.0341535732,
0.0173025578,
0.0221713427,
0.0335476808,
0.076301299,
0.0098904204,
0.0006150505,
-0.0117949424,
-0.0177102536,
0.0156207792,
0.0250491127,
0.0139129469,
-0.0331006907,
0.0214067865,
0.0052490276,
0.0498989746,
0.0186457746,
0.037043795,
-0.0134642627,
-0.0470357202,
-0.0247319415,
-0.0590848289,
0.0144213568,
-0.0815515742,
-0.0328092277,
0.0184900071,
0.0008205411,
0.0043438398,
0.0242051296,
-0.0603068024,
-0.0133136995,
-0.0439065695,
-0.0529818982,
-0.0292033218,
0.0251230914,
0.0293570515,
0.0169791803,
0.0271576438,
-0.0556905828,
0.0098829521,
-0.0152287381,
0.0088953059,
-0.0498120636,
0.037755806,
-0.0316594429,
0.014739668,
-0.0226909239,
-0.0613032989,
-0.0244784039,
0.0287669525,
-0.0458158143,
0.0144019006,
0.038987305,
-0.0733801797,
-0.0092589706,
0.0493822098,
0.0714274645,
0.0443891175,
0.0317758173,
0.0075823064,
-0.0255350415,
0.0510355905,
0.028232282,
0.0284638871,
0.0031152572,
0.0323989764,
0.0231463779,
-0.0167175848,
0.0531787015,
0.0001806958,
-0.0313924216,
-0.0061922739,
0.0464187562,
-0.0279306173,
-0.0225025211,
0.0104416087,
0.020149691,
-0.0383088328,
0.0497921258,
0.093656376,
0.007267795,
-0.0648847073,
-0.0113711422,
0.0219914801,
-0.0856761783,
0.0220669843,
0.0191212408,
-0.0573091321,
0.0102472026,
0.001640672,
0.0253074262,
0.0038169844,
-0.0174774807,
-0.0023189432,
-0.0613511316,
0.0580453053,
-0.0185879041,
-0.0188035835,
-0.0109183686,
-0.0559837446,
0.0049297446,
-0.0325450227,
0.0448297858,
-0.0119401021,
-0.0276566558,
-0.0605878085,
0.0403376892,
-0.096175231,
-0.0522462241,
0.0186390467,
-0.0274677183,
0.0671964139,
0.0306768566,
0.0210534018,
-0.0158712845,
-0.0136020929,
-0.0398002416,
-0.0000808261,
0.0153256012,
-0.0041650198,
-0.0220559519,
-0.0141699435,
-0.0213985685,
0.0078659616,
0.0087694768,
0.0006687265,
0.0218311548,
0.0323943943,
0.0564892665,
-0.0354468822,
-0.0014930195,
-0.0097188875,
0.0380196609,
0.0261744615,
0.0415704474,
-0.0206172857,
-0.0211757869,
-0.0555590466,
0.0050092372,
0.0236673839,
-0.054865472,
-0.0877141505,
0.016522998,
0.0284139514,
-0.1115768179,
0.0166607536,
-0.0161315743,
0.0317081213,
0.0017752019,
-0.0186428223,
0.0411522128,
0.0483128577,
0.0377470665,
-0.0139017869,
-0.0502128303,
-0.0307654627,
0.0511271507,
-0.0575963371,
-0.0001012019,
0.0229686983,
-0.016216414,
-0.0158024989,
0.0383468792,
-0.0193309821,
-0.0362446085,
0.0822802186,
-0.0385895856,
0.0190630294,
0.0291779041,
-0.0198044442,
-0.0453554839,
0.049476929,
0.0064939228,
-0.0639911443,
0.0103746084,
0.0190955326,
-0.0018079078,
-0.0397504233,
0.0164878238,
-0.0156888217,
0.0423720516,
-0.0179071911,
-0.0485728271,
-0.0432246849,
-0.0498323292,
-0.014728629,
0.0370140821,
0.0191152189,
-0.0159915406,
0.0184650626,
-0.0075746262,
0.0523263775,
-0.0393969119,
0.0322634131,
-0.0145527311,
0.0036396035,
-0.0153846005,
0.018826833,
0.0175273046,
0.0277990531,
-0.0314142741,
-0.0192535371,
-0.0082004331,
0.0854767635,
0.0324715711,
-0.0051315376,
0.0303872209,
0.0030327246,
0.0058070053,
-0.0111186579,
0.066302605,
0.0155983195,
0.0106253745,
0.0100996718,
0.0057938029,
0.0130125852,
-0.0024750349,
0.0478000455,
-0.0658589602,
0.0197681971,
0.0218543019,
-0.0011223557,
0.0220945813,
-0.0080546653,
0.0274625085,
-0.0220246706,
0.0640106276,
0.0013597659,
0.0156593956,
-0.0040475917,
0.0109817721,
0.0603115112,
0.0157999173,
-0.0011534543,
0.0246861558,
0.0669813529,
0.0280405544,
0.0154410023,
-0.0322331525,
-0.0254726913,
-0.072485216,
-0.030566806,
-0.0028206282,
-0.0350356288,
-0.0353902839,
-0.0179085247,
-0.0292886104,
-0.0222030468,
-0.0052678785,
-0.0255044326,
0.0282288268,
-0.0556295104,
-0.030085396,
0.0033240572,
0.0261807274,
-0.0117176585,
0.0061766542,
-0.081761688,
-0.0143860597,
-0.029955687,
0.0120807858,
-5.701610085e-33,
-0.0435335711,
-0.0012148452,
0.0002661629,
0.033403255,
-0.0243430734,
0.0216302108,
0.034205813,
-0.0075614289,
0.0130819716,
-0.0429007411,
-0.0172322318,
0.0211424753,
0.03475108,
-0.0192027539,
0.0118711246,
-0.0019236531,
0.0914423838,
-0.0139415432,
0.0191844329,
0.0218467675,
0.0414386429,
0.0154429357,
0.0261019841,
-0.0792460144,
-0.0041200537,
0.0410624444,
0.0022002303,
-0.0078612994,
-0.0056311549,
0.0263055451,
0.0054098824,
0.0496903881,
0.0092292894,
-0.0532853752,
-0.0090953503,
0.0788554177,
-0.0962877125,
0.0151201002,
0.0081226062,
0.075504154,
0.0358596966,
-0.0070978515,
0.0154949166,
0.0289415214,
-0.0153955529,
-0.0304624476,
0.0472463407,
-0.0230619423,
0.0142434351,
-0.0632621273,
-0.0323809609,
0.0313831009,
-0.0295085348,
-0.0081006549,
0.0463453941,
0.0450892933,
-0.0030101547,
-0.0527576841,
-0.0567629971,
0.0334190316,
0.0180343911,
0.0604115799,
-0.0112796184,
0.0890433341,
-0.0217297133,
0.0073255897,
0.0418300852,
-0.0318059176,
-0.0274460632,
-0.0592815243,
0.0003563549,
0.0500118993,
0.0215513743,
0.0141810961,
0.0204467587,
-0.0429418758,
-0.062796399,
0.0000587284,
0.0298852101,
0.039694991,
0.0220979266,
0.0279768277,
-0.0522740223,
0.0039857547,
-0.0201598871,
0.0264439397,
0.0000762958,
-0.0127011295,
0.0062372917,
0.0425979383,
-0.0346519426,
0.0397413857,
0.0596362874,
-0.0247556698,
0.0252721105,
-0.0287074316,
0.0208238643,
0.0117898406,
-0.0242994186,
-0.0001990367,
-0.0599077716,
0.0163066071,
0.0945415869,
0.0469041914,
0.0427002273,
-0.0447623841,
-0.0044433083,
0.084871687,
-0.0417337939,
-0.0018785801,
-0.0097919255,
0.0620964542,
0.0050820424,
0.0309023242,
0.0293585025,
-0.0132960565,
-0.0063785701,
-0.0441743806,
-0.0106346477,
-0.0615607724,
-0.0384409167,
-0.0087070521,
-0.0343853347,
0.0360339433,
-0.0689094961,
0.0125853904,
0.0177025143,
0.0016052106,
0.0357016139,
-0.0448876545,
0.0034861474,
-0.0300179441,
2.696e-7,
-0.0400786661,
0.0118238535,
0.0803333297,
-0.0289465804,
0.0296282936,
-0.0081907585,
0.0334771536,
0.0072895898,
0.0294482578,
0.049903769,
0.0126703344,
-0.016888015,
0.0505106747,
0.0631316975,
-0.083185412,
-0.0225837957,
-0.0484482981,
0.0162837505,
-0.0424490646,
0.0299154092,
0.1022968739,
0.073279202,
-0.0299825165,
-0.0337743238,
-0.0258561522,
0.0029874274,
-0.0199012756,
0.0008627705,
0.0212194771,
-0.0203826129,
0.0450933091,
0.0197646655,
-0.0185243413,
0.0727407113,
-0.0281194784,
0.0511204787,
-0.0113701643,
0.0206021257,
-0.0065414258,
0.0505634695,
-0.0073970128,
-0.0071307924,
-0.031706322,
-0.0028021501,
0.0620457679,
-0.0544643961,
0.0003925748,
0.0111167906,
-0.0699045286,
-0.0302170608,
-0.0511164926,
0.0258209128,
0.0043734889,
0.0483581312,
-0.0131696016,
-0.0019075917,
0.0114153763,
-0.0727691874,
0.0324909203,
0.0434905998,
-0.0303765498,
0.0032598909,
-0.0237693153,
-0.0051419991,
0.0404031873,
0.0113178883,
-0.0131778223,
1.884171196e-34,
-0.0092955474,
0.035440661,
-0.0417902358,
-0.0243788864,
0.0278558694,
-0.029001018,
-0.0509440005,
0.0460063815,
-0.0183859859,
-0.0692585632,
-0.0345656201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13840v1 | StackRAG Agent: Improving Developer Answers with Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T21:07:35 | 2024-06-19T21:07:35 | Davit Abrahamyan, Fatemeh H. Fard | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Developers spend much time finding information that is relevant to their
questions. Stack Overflow has been the leading resource, and with the advent of
Large Language Models (LLMs), generative models such as ChatGPT are used
frequently. However, there is a catch in using each one separately. Searching
for answers is time-consuming and tedious, as shown by the many tools developed
by researchers to address this issue. On the other, using LLMs is not reliable,
as they might produce irrelevant or unreliable answers (i.e., hallucination).
In this work, we present StackRAG, a retrieval-augmented Multiagent generation
tool based on LLMs that combines the two worlds: aggregating the knowledge from
SO to enhance the reliability of the generated answers. Initial evaluations
show that the generated answers are correct, accurate, relevant, and useful. | [
0.0579879954,
0.0459414907,
-0.0396036319,
0.0099137248,
0.0006695572,
-0.0468848832,
-0.0080312081,
0.0017225837,
0.0459305122,
-0.0465357266,
0.0051266565,
-0.0115467496,
-0.0337591544,
0.0305142328,
0.0248690639,
-0.0279467609,
0.0131830126,
-0.0039894595,
0.0288267769,
0.0173430275,
0.0175922699,
0.0288285818,
-0.0103110401,
0.0877500549,
-0.0194402933,
-0.0347140729,
0.0114970999,
0.014907605,
0.0204071831,
-0.0130133731,
0.0199476462,
0.0378143862,
-0.0002569106,
0.0108140679,
0.0000021015,
-0.0330373496,
0.0010366635,
0.0030505275,
-0.009541614,
-0.0310798585,
0.0138807427,
0.0517742336,
-0.0210756939,
0.0492391363,
-0.0761464238,
-0.007268677,
0.0422669314,
-0.0215430167,
0.0963625237,
0.0667185858,
0.0013227457,
0.0282311607,
0.0188120548,
0.0150831109,
0.0808415413,
-0.0435768999,
-0.0186865702,
0.0320199355,
0.0630403608,
0.0280141756,
0.0391835012,
0.0172926206,
-0.0063016363,
-0.0314343274,
0.0474268198,
0.033476159,
-0.022495525,
-0.0314971171,
0.0081032356,
0.0518122092,
0.0055176611,
-0.0243065078,
0.0116888573,
0.0085841687,
-0.003365065,
0.0648895055,
-0.0528658591,
0.0234006979,
-0.0306731798,
-0.0277659595,
-0.0097402316,
-0.0053448677,
-0.0057938499,
-0.018609358,
-0.0236363802,
0.0483609289,
0.0052526277,
-0.0076307529,
-0.0547728762,
-0.0089113424,
0.0075879381,
-0.0731747597,
-0.0025927741,
0.0749076456,
-0.0690168515,
0.0097012045,
0.0048275776,
-0.0638183355,
0.0619812012,
-0.0610271282,
-0.0228207409,
0.0253034104,
0.0039294641,
0.0144615872,
-0.0179556198,
0.0246380363,
0.0016695375,
-0.0191805493,
-0.0528244376,
-0.0234241709,
-0.0622941144,
-0.0324736536,
-0.0509849414,
0.052968815,
-0.017471794,
-0.0118521852,
0.0080238227,
0.0622445382,
-0.0034804554,
0.0140362699,
-0.0164600015,
0.033900097,
-0.0497076958,
0.0057419264,
-0.0209834687,
0.010049141,
-0.0556664057,
0.0016656971,
0.0349604897,
-0.0862347633,
0.0123365382,
0.0257861726,
-0.0087994616,
0.0101278825,
-0.0034088485,
0.066687569,
0.0039552557,
0.0274397098,
-0.0220596623,
-0.0669409037,
0.0310821328,
-0.0214853678,
-0.0477895439,
-0.0939683095,
0.0062374403,
0.0142131913,
-0.0408845022,
-0.0472068079,
0.0102705192,
0.0626114681,
0.0033029693,
0.0326566249,
-0.0747558028,
0.0230391622,
0.0881491378,
0.033395905,
0.008839244,
0.0529260226,
0.0190339237,
0.0917714462,
0.0458130613,
-0.0004139195,
0.070604369,
0.0062429947,
-0.0134261316,
0.0189601984,
0.0496352576,
0.0318368077,
0.0105018802,
-0.0070298924,
-0.0358252414,
0.0527431816,
-0.0328587741,
0.0095838951,
0.0305394586,
0.0398604721,
0.0305711217,
0.0172961857,
0.0537391007,
0.0192304589,
-0.0161992088,
-0.024558723,
0.003207203,
0.0529983826,
-0.0250499062,
-0.0183368344,
0.0195038617,
0.0616645887,
-0.0292539243,
-0.0245465003,
-0.0036537999,
0.0038644162,
-0.0065815165,
0.0318804905,
0.0054468759,
-0.0059411805,
-0.0414787047,
0.0273573492,
-0.0007495501,
-0.0585707352,
0.0146231055,
-0.068274729,
0.0485833213,
0.0484506078,
0.0713139996,
-0.0306508839,
-0.0418194681,
0.012249562,
-0.0170504879,
0.0169109609,
0.04174174,
-0.0154793514,
-0.057585232,
-0.0389917754,
-0.0176954623,
-0.0043911119,
0.007299582,
0.0229414757,
0.0209959634,
0.015238937,
0.030403994,
-0.0468967594,
-0.0334813967,
0.0289035924,
-0.0105915545,
-0.0095625175,
-0.0059672096,
-0.0246428698,
0.0110841654,
0.0214718729,
-0.0221586097,
0.056183245,
0.02837063,
-0.0359358005,
-0.0744993091,
-0.0023783124,
-0.0123502975,
-0.003794671,
0.0128332945,
-0.0412418321,
0.0157133434,
-0.0221111141,
-0.0244637057,
-0.022608038,
0.0480102375,
-0.031668447,
0.0201129261,
-0.0407840312,
-0.0213823989,
0.0266108885,
-0.0105437785,
-0.0535175018,
0.0732271001,
0.0427842326,
0.0152709493,
0.0082006622,
0.0638555884,
0.0251957532,
-0.04029705,
0.0406687558,
0.0297749639,
-0.0158448257,
0.0465416871,
0.0527991243,
-0.0055414578,
-0.0406761169,
-0.0631166026,
-0.1009197682,
-0.0189804919,
-0.0132006183,
0.0213657059,
0.0210478678,
0.0424008556,
0.0144188525,
0.0008525576,
-0.0937728211,
0.006875772,
0.0357091203,
0.022408681,
0.0058831223,
-0.0004249663,
0.0005922838,
-0.0370359868,
0.0040510651,
-0.0244982075,
0.0209723096,
0.0327482037,
-0.0441648066,
-0.0711713582,
0.0264789779,
-0.0677281395,
0.0032368363,
-0.0090936758,
-0.0397777334,
0.0454916656,
-0.031297449,
0.0320664793,
0.0200347025,
0.0612209141,
0.0014680637,
-0.0007330705,
-0.0099613834,
-0.0770207942,
0.002443077,
0.0050472282,
-0.0365215354,
0.0107176704,
-0.046283029,
0.0732832476,
0.0476081744,
0.0207126364,
-0.0251979642,
-0.0591556989,
0.0352233574,
-0.0142240552,
-0.0152896456,
0.012899721,
-0.0371127948,
0.0039298628,
0.0195640083,
-0.0126900431,
-0.0333774313,
0.0832744688,
-0.0586567149,
-0.0079239421,
-0.0400016569,
-0.0222502351,
-0.0489907973,
0.0445453972,
-0.0107927863,
0.0295725148,
-0.0271672998,
0.0140089523,
-0.0424963124,
-0.0344238617,
0.0341678932,
-0.0530732013,
-0.0055092466,
-0.0245381519,
0.0284699704,
-0.0101148533,
-0.0142719578,
-0.0384091027,
-0.0489318855,
-0.0105205402,
-0.0011145597,
0.0045224875,
0.0021376356,
-0.0404512249,
0.0068865009,
0.0340734534,
0.0047189989,
0.011542405,
-0.0404000729,
-0.006660399,
-0.0032013685,
0.0660655126,
0.0233144052,
0.0090123536,
-0.0130508663,
0.0035448186,
0.0733053535,
0.041746188,
0.0033705956,
-0.003971878,
-0.056266468,
0.019357767,
-0.0290045198,
-0.0026509578,
0.0218364988,
0.0370262675,
-0.0228598919,
-0.0115054091,
0.0650700256,
0.0413309149,
-0.0343049169,
0.0055730585,
-0.0392767452,
0.037181858,
0.0400857478,
0.0695097223,
-0.0788841769,
-0.0066848523,
-0.0235710721,
0.0160687938,
-0.0187963899,
-0.0036785686,
-0.0188280381,
-0.0885703042,
0.0406347364,
0.0000054895,
-0.0149985719,
0.0403907523,
-0.0332323238,
-0.00064507,
0.0198835563,
-0.0448962748,
0.048028402,
0.0181470811,
0.0308732856,
0.0160970911,
-0.024640061,
0.0309518036,
0.0100557096,
-0.0409244038,
0.0361315608,
0.11340978,
0.0148705384,
0.0321522467,
-0.0367677398,
-0.0064459452,
-0.0340827368,
0.022276409,
0.0001610912,
0.0249860883,
-0.0021821831,
0.0110244434,
0.0186678637,
0.023196429,
-0.0740321577,
-0.0065216003,
0.0424221344,
0.0462111309,
-0.0346791968,
-0.0020143506,
-0.0682448298,
0.0230651163,
0.0347596817,
0.029002836,
0.0238875709,
-0.0255252831,
-0.0560094975,
-0.0501861125,
0.0349685624,
-0.0204595905,
-0.0361518003,
-0.0066844141,
0.0236378945,
0.0031263756,
-0.0937244967,
-0.0491700917,
0.0089475932,
0.0491067357,
-0.0029342929,
0.0192171596,
-0.0108546121,
0.0128002921,
0.0118941739,
0.0016566862,
-0.032926254,
0.022425836,
-0.0092878705,
-0.0231950097,
0.0144576486,
-0.0570982993,
-0.0038527432,
-0.0013326361,
-0.0566228591,
-0.0302806552,
-0.0325996988,
0.0471568853,
0.0285648257,
-0.0323692411,
-0.0550445989,
-0.0238818079,
0.0158802085,
0.076214835,
-0.0848039836,
0.0068701277,
-0.0199777614,
-0.0023772593,
-0.005134745,
-0.015164895,
-0.0963169113,
0.0428656116,
-0.0189671703,
0.0369660072,
-0.0036301175,
-0.0579617471,
0.0185180251,
0.0384720825,
-0.0301213581,
0.0339193791,
-0.0020198345,
-0.0068962849,
0.0017316111,
-0.0027102174,
-0.0195602179,
-0.0403627716,
0.0225600135,
-0.031434603,
-0.0620553307,
0.0663201809,
-0.0006178726,
-0.0486198775,
0.0562635772,
-0.0081808055,
0.0047431304,
0.0073286491,
0.0068687168,
0.024508344,
-0.0088560665,
-0.0319782495,
-0.0139564192,
-0.0272274483,
0.0702108219,
-0.009726244,
0.0231188759,
0.0025025923,
-0.0235032998,
0.0266841445,
0.0245251078,
-0.0995538756,
-0.1104355454,
-0.0254952367,
0.0191232506,
0.0422434174,
0.0772364065,
0.03255409,
-0.0080785956,
0.0263141207,
-0.0274087228,
-0.0059546228,
0.043154221,
-0.0527808443,
-0.0138267754,
0.0125797745,
-0.0250907894,
-0.0620850325,
0.0969563425,
-0.0487694927,
-0.0004924021,
-0.0450916812,
-0.0225617252,
-0.0339684933,
-0.0348940417,
-0.0143467328,
0.015891239,
-0.0069259042,
-0.0124270497,
-0.0350120626,
-0.0369453728,
-0.0205199681,
0.0289153159,
0.0152626652,
0.0132475113,
0.0190471038,
0.1046413183,
0.0313647538,
-0.0129116923,
-0.0701760054,
0.0011383061,
-0.0774014741,
0.001128232,
-0.0102654491,
-5.981884305e-33,
-0.0261915941,
-0.0541013107,
0.0549215078,
0.0091130398,
-0.0157583375,
-0.0193677377,
-0.0338700116,
-0.0054528527,
-0.0292213541,
-0.0338389277,
-0.0034608396,
0.0142945144,
0.0060915179,
0.0056984196,
0.0228137635,
0.0078171557,
0.0405270979,
0.0495166555,
-0.0466666631,
0.0681758374,
0.0133500239,
-0.0015279746,
0.0095195221,
-0.0602184273,
-0.0113976989,
-0.0350427963,
0.0049738139,
0.0212168247,
0.0086664893,
0.0584094785,
0.0009950566,
0.0510404184,
0.0095929438,
-0.0420877747,
-0.0119731613,
-0.0266343262,
-0.013063848,
-0.0405479558,
-0.0014139534,
-0.0342536531,
-0.014560041,
-0.0273331404,
0.0422483347,
-0.0372226276,
0.0149350241,
0.0121173365,
0.0634776577,
-0.0095599387,
-0.0025008323,
-0.0184814762,
-0.0640690327,
0.0125603145,
0.0132859293,
-0.0039558043,
-0.0618090518,
0.0793573633,
0.0166470129,
0.0077788313,
-0.0313359611,
0.0306295902,
-0.014901801,
0.0457601473,
0.0488568805,
0.034335807,
-0.0022564963,
0.0559711903,
0.0112558333,
0.0314344391,
-0.0511670262,
-0.031608019,
-0.0012409546,
0.0398494117,
0.0478292294,
0.0647002459,
0.0132074878,
-0.0124314446,
-0.0274458099,
0.0883603469,
0.0290668719,
0.0452006124,
0.0481270067,
0.013735462,
-0.017258767,
-0.0156755596,
-0.0165725481,
0.0485657044,
-0.02083515,
-0.066646643,
0.0147367949,
0.0278344676,
-0.0069087897,
-0.022802379,
0.0328595862,
-0.0599502996,
0.0249072947,
0.0271300208,
-0.0395430475,
-0.0159923043,
-0.0304479133,
0.0044927262,
-0.0122241257,
0.006385752,
0.0198898353,
0.0323717669,
0.0135388318,
0.0340009145,
-0.0298388898,
-0.0144990645,
-0.0330934525,
-0.0015908536,
-0.0493513122,
0.0277400371,
-0.0368981585,
-0.0423410125,
-0.0037848172,
0.0018055484,
-0.004326479,
0.0229396373,
-0.0011211666,
-0.0207347497,
-0.0323597044,
0.0055963262,
0.0084504429,
0.0042404043,
-0.0461261459,
0.0130342068,
-0.0384799242,
0.0197006427,
-0.0064542503,
-0.0418584645,
-0.042252969,
-0.0042421389,
2.733e-7,
-0.0034894466,
0.0010865885,
0.0272491463,
0.0334757231,
0.0325648673,
0.0298885647,
0.0194173139,
0.0116447099,
0.0480624139,
-0.010079137,
-0.0293665137,
0.0417190455,
0.0259955022,
0.0801250562,
-0.0590484701,
-0.0273957867,
-0.0545475148,
0.0015566149,
-0.06518621,
0.0095910337,
0.0762638599,
0.027631551,
-0.0057444992,
-0.008194793,
0.0032334805,
-0.0592286773,
0.0292940587,
0.0268144328,
0.0088032456,
0.1001750603,
0.0189698208,
0.0182778966,
0.0243743993,
-0.0050959424,
-0.0135919685,
-0.0414333791,
0.0027055449,
-0.0029765312,
-0.015879536,
-0.0173751395,
0.0125608239,
-0.0485676751,
0.0333099738,
-0.0656111762,
0.0322083943,
-0.0184546243,
-0.0049123159,
-0.0170821436,
-0.0373469219,
-0.0454320125,
-0.0127402255,
-0.0105928862,
-0.0130009931,
-0.0081572635,
-0.0118552055,
0.0043357005,
-0.0081132427,
-0.0405459665,
-0.0330661945,
0.0279968157,
-0.066904515,
-0.0676704496,
-0.0256012231,
0.0136708822,
-0.010252458,
-0.0074653579,
0.0306866542,
2.338855625e-34,
0.0061561484,
0.0201406144,
-0.0042062337,
0.0388444476,
0.0672538206,
0.018889172,
0.023206668,
0.0238784105,
0.0224297754,
-0.0463607311,
-0.0293199569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13828v1 | Neuro-symbolic Training for Reasoning over Spatial Language | 2024-06-19T20:47:36 | 2024-06-19T20:47:36 | Tanawan Premsri, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent research shows that more data and larger models can provide more
accurate solutions to natural language problems requiring reasoning. However,
models can easily fail to provide solutions in unobserved complex input
compositions due to not achieving the level of abstraction required for
generalizability. To alleviate this issue, we propose training the language
models with neuro-symbolic techniques that can exploit the logical rules of
reasoning as constraints and provide additional supervision sources to the
model. Training models to adhere to the regulations of reasoning pushes them to
make more effective abstractions needed for generalizability and transfer
learning. We focus on a challenging problem of spatial reasoning over text. Our
results on various benchmarks using multiple language models confirm our
hypothesis of effective domain transfer based on neuro-symbolic training. | [
0.0372516625,
0.0519532748,
-0.0347603038,
0.0297455713,
-0.0402918644,
0.0320657976,
0.028638145,
-0.0115139661,
-0.0187295061,
-0.0356916375,
-0.0080671031,
0.0200919732,
0.0025900435,
0.0481776521,
0.0333743058,
-0.1020494476,
0.0301465373,
-0.0242146552,
0.0297958888,
0.0079691354,
-0.0276072677,
0.015306592,
-0.026131317,
-0.0106052551,
-0.0482580587,
0.0278148875,
0.0047376296,
-0.0376114361,
0.018611379,
-0.0306822285,
-0.0327160135,
-0.0050506433,
0.0691228807,
-0.0371644944,
0.0000019332,
0.0070922524,
-0.0199769605,
0.0233076047,
0.0404397361,
-0.0340969525,
0.0039021501,
-0.061870601,
0.0241453853,
0.0010042039,
-0.0296011902,
-0.015743725,
0.0486502498,
0.0569805317,
0.034726467,
0.0509916358,
-0.0302358791,
-0.0457084887,
0.0274852403,
0.0165610742,
-0.0055818995,
0.028544683,
0.0067524877,
0.0150148971,
0.0161963739,
0.0241504498,
-0.0450188518,
0.025310697,
0.0437523015,
0.0271163564,
-0.0070490059,
0.0395355225,
-0.0075689335,
0.0742848665,
-0.0216003805,
0.0526885986,
-0.0088505028,
-0.0153680509,
0.0325042047,
0.0119393617,
0.0028730389,
0.0287059899,
-0.0727030188,
0.0084166909,
-0.0078931116,
0.0158148371,
-0.0179437157,
0.015759781,
0.0271151066,
-0.0047656484,
-0.0496676192,
0.0839961097,
0.0132217081,
-0.0186705217,
0.0197598804,
-0.0213845111,
-0.0399440825,
-0.0326934718,
0.0132596614,
0.0697631687,
-0.0079492088,
0.0473518446,
-0.0129387137,
0.0169385336,
-0.0324403755,
-0.0431401357,
0.0583061725,
0.045685228,
0.0271531735,
0.0478429087,
-0.0564291663,
0.0477077812,
-0.0240621641,
0.106193535,
-0.005047793,
-0.0385579392,
-0.0693941563,
-0.015210771,
-0.0524425879,
0.0586656071,
-0.0232159663,
-0.0236144606,
0.0167121198,
0.0015154175,
-0.0076033995,
0.0060337456,
-0.0207962804,
0.0398827493,
-0.0086269453,
-0.0397134684,
-0.0073018004,
-0.0064816629,
-0.0298865139,
0.0356728695,
-0.0128262807,
0.0165086221,
-0.0019061496,
0.0115726506,
0.0262988098,
-0.0549412742,
-0.0163854081,
0.0805281326,
0.0077110357,
0.0033240258,
-0.0636646897,
-0.0145653021,
-0.0128770163,
-0.0487238616,
0.0589721724,
-0.0621460676,
-0.0000414911,
-0.0277216975,
-0.0423968807,
-0.0581217259,
-0.0079130856,
0.0017564212,
-0.0072416505,
0.0438891724,
0.0137713347,
-0.0064620934,
0.0695559606,
0.0062932447,
-0.0300363842,
0.0375436619,
0.0562316701,
0.0506685004,
-0.0266355146,
0.0109082116,
0.0032325969,
-0.0005738243,
0.0361448489,
0.0306184199,
-0.0809034854,
-0.0128968256,
-0.0151132718,
0.0396796577,
0.0096283546,
0.073117584,
-0.0403630994,
-0.0436746106,
0.0316812545,
0.0866932571,
-0.0114564607,
-0.0140711535,
0.0789452195,
-0.0151609452,
-0.0018329564,
-0.0337026045,
-0.0624390729,
0.0449182205,
-0.0108275088,
-0.0173730887,
-0.0508517809,
0.0195173156,
-0.0130284615,
-0.0375492871,
-0.0125650978,
0.0008378931,
0.0093692271,
-0.0172493458,
0.0782091841,
0.0312761366,
-0.0040379404,
0.0471895225,
0.020601036,
-0.0000249132,
0.0148467151,
0.0268239845,
0.0201781802,
-0.0164373051,
-0.0008367444,
-0.0073138778,
-0.0166374724,
-0.0361159481,
0.0576129518,
0.0317829549,
0.0517270416,
-0.0076940404,
0.0152238924,
-0.0255653542,
-0.0253579542,
-0.0027956027,
0.0365521945,
0.0059300796,
0.0491728336,
0.0034656366,
0.0102158422,
-0.0677533671,
-0.0177734476,
0.0515895449,
-0.0068002711,
-0.0391020887,
-0.0486092344,
0.040202003,
0.0080218231,
-0.0610115603,
0.0168376584,
0.0033670014,
-0.0000339992,
-0.0415744707,
-0.0436509065,
0.0308948774,
-0.0614047125,
-0.0469304845,
0.0257058535,
-0.0578101799,
0.0020322311,
0.0230484772,
-0.0728715435,
-0.0120606311,
0.0532740429,
-0.0434982665,
0.0023757527,
0.0005170534,
-0.0391372703,
0.0399112739,
-0.0332632959,
-0.028079031,
0.0419804305,
0.0081033846,
-0.0074979616,
-0.0004164592,
0.0157745853,
0.035489738,
-0.0221690908,
0.0522334054,
-0.0110965911,
-0.0436517783,
-0.001604222,
-0.0561003461,
-0.0036967432,
-0.036203742,
-0.003647181,
-0.0241289437,
0.003070489,
0.0144137945,
0.0345693119,
0.0060507241,
-0.0485205539,
0.0036259068,
-0.014243002,
-0.0236978158,
-0.0133075118,
-0.0237787776,
0.0153226973,
0.0566884652,
-0.0230582319,
0.0085833063,
-0.0152815217,
-0.0265080947,
-0.0527414791,
0.062188074,
0.0143772382,
-0.0186980255,
-0.0172128771,
0.0098324744,
-0.0255472288,
0.032035958,
-0.0083468631,
-0.0015236415,
0.0247290432,
-0.044872582,
-0.0531117395,
0.0645547509,
-0.014610826,
-0.0274817925,
0.0114441672,
-0.0075992839,
-0.062322963,
0.0092507992,
-0.041985929,
0.0540969446,
-0.0285694655,
-0.009889585,
0.0140849901,
0.056689512,
-0.0096656987,
-0.0260103326,
-0.0365607142,
0.0260156393,
-0.0375751555,
0.0048555415,
-0.0413384885,
-0.0026428232,
0.0325388275,
0.0382572301,
-0.048391901,
-0.0202901699,
0.0421824828,
-0.0099326763,
0.0286205076,
-0.0514514185,
0.0076409006,
-0.0445940495,
0.0981022343,
0.0017337137,
0.0245364141,
0.022558907,
-0.0318243429,
-0.0289078597,
-0.0578994937,
-0.0263861511,
0.0251048431,
0.0112411054,
-0.0691297129,
0.0287075043,
0.0162196681,
-0.0380706303,
-0.0202292427,
0.0123020289,
-0.0098312087,
0.0146333342,
-0.0320197083,
-0.0308176689,
0.0241020229,
0.0255785026,
-0.0023115547,
0.0455734245,
-0.0370021686,
-0.0292441342,
-0.0336178541,
0.0300884731,
0.0460450947,
0.0533898287,
-0.0285238475,
-0.0112048294,
-0.0838630646,
0.0279493015,
-0.0457374714,
-0.0142918164,
-0.0539297126,
0.072111547,
0.0098761898,
-0.0094919521,
-0.0244922619,
0.0304597188,
0.0411946066,
-0.0760658085,
-0.0743638575,
0.0458158515,
0.0609761477,
0.0383085683,
-0.0072094696,
-0.0233143326,
-0.0089194896,
0.0272186361,
0.0424580127,
-0.030808188,
-0.0371767841,
0.0064486279,
-0.0526140854,
0.0234317984,
-0.0282698795,
-0.0136434287,
-0.1021260992,
0.0314230286,
0.0151209552,
-0.1156603694,
-0.0419508331,
-0.0224292576,
0.0070153098,
0.0092726648,
-0.0514281541,
-0.0462582447,
-0.0096647544,
0.0145140728,
0.0479700305,
0.0072140922,
0.013185096,
0.0049711149,
-0.0621342734,
0.0222619697,
0.0019029137,
0.0627649426,
0.0008881406,
-0.0677071065,
0.0456301048,
0.0369894952,
0.0162148643,
-0.025846513,
0.0589498989,
0.0233755261,
0.0093020089,
0.0161985438,
0.0377810299,
-0.0447726846,
-0.0304953959,
-0.0023712036,
0.0858512074,
0.0037169282,
0.0092235627,
-0.0401226468,
0.0355570689,
0.0022016442,
0.0228898507,
0.0158439707,
0.0295906607,
-0.0653328151,
-0.0438886173,
-0.0401158407,
-0.0464982539,
0.0039258162,
0.0172878318,
0.025051089,
-0.0262524467,
-0.0855941176,
-0.0003925082,
0.0388538055,
0.0741176307,
0.0329127125,
-0.038452927,
0.0272349287,
-0.0496201888,
-0.058649078,
0.0479166992,
-0.0570720211,
0.0328010544,
0.0431139208,
0.03973151,
-0.0139860697,
-0.0514674969,
-0.0272013862,
-0.023716202,
-0.0492178909,
-0.0396967344,
-0.0369271934,
0.0686218739,
0.019394394,
0.0241615772,
-0.0322649218,
0.014054507,
0.037095204,
0.0300264172,
-0.0171985906,
-0.0037693346,
0.0536375381,
0.006416861,
0.0251283217,
-0.0083154375,
0.008779753,
0.046341151,
0.0517789498,
-0.0032971152,
-0.0191935487,
0.0811665654,
0.0068511041,
-0.0366108753,
0.0327120945,
0.0517450646,
-0.0560693331,
-0.0247007161,
-0.0049155378,
-0.0206948798,
0.0079397075,
-0.0365534239,
0.0411389768,
0.0153093645,
0.0567495264,
-0.031238135,
-0.0489718989,
0.0558318831,
0.0314656645,
0.0399784595,
-0.05529093,
0.044051405,
0.0122669358,
0.0062167724,
0.0235746726,
-0.0215753838,
-0.0003440209,
-0.0255460776,
0.0537089668,
-0.0380613506,
-0.0060609649,
0.0720396489,
0.0102461036,
-0.0791255534,
-0.0145236924,
-0.0644541979,
-0.0409794822,
0.0089949472,
-0.0328700319,
0.0380213074,
-0.0123765115,
-0.0129621634,
-0.0214199312,
0.0098768966,
0.035765741,
0.0127706211,
0.0076686032,
-0.010519403,
0.0514141135,
0.0124841379,
0.0185558554,
-0.0233762953,
0.0008452464,
-0.0229307637,
0.0489229932,
-0.0061089057,
0.0010528768,
-0.0109500363,
0.0132750496,
0.00604741,
0.0131483488,
-0.0080266688,
0.0090429736,
-0.0370505527,
-0.0751940906,
0.0128517691,
0.0346536599,
0.0183330737,
0.0277853757,
0.0334419683,
0.0173465926,
-0.0021112249,
-0.0712810755,
-0.0011042504,
-0.0153395534,
0.0285007358,
-0.0293554086,
-0.0341921151,
-5.721058639e-33,
-0.0256204549,
-0.0391077735,
0.076568909,
-0.0067895134,
-0.0013182629,
-0.030904267,
-0.0406359881,
-0.0492261015,
0.0003859969,
0.0086495969,
-0.0112613253,
0.006108575,
-0.000268655,
0.0346162952,
0.0235233735,
-0.0039646188,
0.0117136221,
0.0211989544,
-0.0327094421,
-0.025985226,
0.0519342907,
0.0071635037,
0.0236392207,
-0.0520182475,
-0.0289612021,
0.0772458538,
0.0023440525,
0.0342852101,
-0.0489208698,
0.0280888323,
0.0027452449,
-0.0388317332,
0.0254383031,
-0.0129048144,
-0.0296198521,
0.0305503774,
-0.0953835994,
-0.069671981,
0.0164873619,
-0.0074521857,
-0.0324612074,
-0.0292954277,
0.0526403002,
-0.0089594647,
0.0580684096,
-0.0514575727,
0.0472780876,
-0.025300974,
-0.0512773171,
-0.0121656582,
-0.0795749277,
0.0211863481,
-0.0003353714,
0.0265325811,
-0.0004273762,
-0.0032751397,
0.0035667492,
0.0199141502,
-0.0265844595,
0.0056730229,
0.0095895343,
0.0108424611,
0.0189572815,
-0.004003311,
-0.0093644233,
0.0519149154,
0.019609781,
-0.0395052359,
-0.0496394485,
0.0113790827,
0.052816391,
0.0667451546,
0.0241942387,
0.0207844879,
0.0667040721,
-0.0122807622,
-0.0619442649,
0.025845306,
-0.0811804235,
0.0425827429,
-0.0078367842,
0.0144812185,
-0.0131074768,
-0.0187510382,
-0.0426600389,
-0.0129754366,
-0.0062694605,
-0.0031772912,
0.0288367197,
-0.0131248264,
0.0239978433,
0.033227399,
0.0107697817,
-0.0351103023,
-0.0353522785,
-0.0035017838,
0.0076230629,
0.0270741079,
-0.02200309,
0.0426567607,
-0.0490966886,
-0.0372159034,
-0.0049526463,
0.02168753,
0.031852819,
0.0049250959,
0.0806015283,
0.0584257506,
-0.0427478701,
-0.0241413508,
-0.0544325486,
-0.0348355286,
0.0278224312,
0.0272078086,
0.024246309,
0.0469637141,
-0.0086764507,
0.0373834781,
-0.0383252427,
-0.0403854921,
0.0046602609,
0.0362470448,
-0.0082305502,
0.0294827577,
-0.0155126937,
-0.0182821322,
-0.029615758,
-0.0144584868,
0.0425454229,
-0.0785142705,
-0.0056771319,
0.0245869607,
2.711e-7,
0.0397310741,
0.0386886597,
0.0355475582,
-0.0040343865,
-0.0063360268,
0.0131365042,
-0.0041447566,
0.0026840158,
-0.0058006239,
0.0090198619,
0.0024346116,
0.079192549,
0.0362646393,
0.0427855738,
-0.0683187246,
0.0179610439,
-0.0016799787,
-0.0395090245,
-0.0338983126,
0.0002462907,
0.0936377421,
0.0335526839,
0.0520842299,
-0.0338991955,
0.0199937019,
-0.020047592,
0.0386395082,
-0.0036166145,
0.0710364729,
-0.0049766325,
0.0202516373,
-0.0468110777,
0.0110742226,
0.0197455771,
0.0107377302,
0.0020282217,
-0.0062262919,
0.0656952485,
-0.0136021161,
0.0019834284,
-0.0198942814,
-0.054947488,
-0.0214181468,
-0.0279807262,
0.0580136739,
-0.1209927276,
-0.0187944211,
0.0168955252,
-0.0017550348,
0.0080701271,
-0.0128645543,
0.0183838159,
0.0218179747,
-0.010712103,
0.0313451514,
0.0124940192,
0.0077047837,
-0.0865673199,
-0.0191657413,
0.0231863055,
-0.0180671699,
0.0102923447,
-0.01585049,
0.0223736055,
0.037994381,
-0.0538872927,
-0.0358695425,
2.201321409e-34,
-0.0313862339,
0.0090324469,
-0.0029505133,
-0.0108417906,
0.0273291692,
-0.0185673404,
-0.0548654683,
0.0017188081,
0.0159856007,
-0.0234416742,
0.0009346717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13827v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13827v2 | Fine-Tuning BERTs for Definition Extraction from Mathematical Text | 2024-06-19T20:47:23 | 2024-06-27T22:31:07 | Lucy Horowitz, Ryan Hathaway | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we fine-tuned three pre-trained BERT models on the task of
"definition extraction" from mathematical English written in LaTeX. This is
presented as a binary classification problem, where either a sentence contains
a definition of a mathematical term or it does not. We used two original data
sets, "Chicago" and "TAC," to fine-tune and test these models. We also tested
on WFMALL, a dataset presented by Vanetik and Litvak in 2021 and compared the
performance of our models to theirs. We found that a high-performance
Sentence-BERT transformer model performed best based on overall accuracy,
recall, and precision metrics, achieving comparable results to the earlier
models with less computational effort. | [
-0.0285416823,
0.0874265432,
0.0174545497,
0.0528144911,
-0.0332586542,
0.0110281929,
-0.0027858813,
-0.0079560019,
-0.1003290191,
-0.0836695135,
-0.0225101206,
0.0152437044,
-0.0303921718,
0.0180186797,
0.0222535785,
-0.0299455933,
0.0321961232,
-0.0066373064,
0.0071835653,
0.0086529711,
-0.0060917009,
-0.0349433906,
-0.0200237129,
0.0178031046,
-0.0516088307,
-0.0435649119,
0.0454334281,
-0.0354836509,
0.029980775,
0.0096831853,
0.0292995181,
0.0582444631,
-0.0130322855,
0.0559043512,
0.0000017488,
-0.0688812882,
-0.0749456882,
0.0088897413,
-0.0117291939,
0.0007933506,
-0.0101428591,
-0.0333418399,
0.0209384467,
-0.004168978,
-0.0553723834,
0.0077046561,
0.0327010676,
0.0213777237,
0.0597740561,
0.0431325585,
-0.0309003964,
-0.0909113735,
0.0384431519,
-0.0036766052,
0.0238372386,
-0.0185385272,
0.0296044592,
-0.0107046403,
-0.0216243882,
-0.0406048819,
-0.0222071316,
0.0267495234,
0.0239158217,
0.0077370587,
0.0369594283,
-0.002815228,
-0.0870189667,
-0.00571424,
-0.0074069691,
0.0566704236,
0.0105917566,
-0.0198683292,
0.0145775564,
0.0175326429,
-0.0143682929,
0.0350952595,
-0.036749851,
-0.0016049471,
-0.0425198413,
-0.017549634,
-0.0322577916,
-0.0082149236,
0.0112526072,
0.0253819134,
-0.0879329965,
0.0526715554,
0.0345041864,
-0.0491007939,
-0.0236084089,
0.0050980421,
-0.0990053713,
-0.0105247889,
0.0853708982,
0.0140618458,
0.0688220486,
0.003998348,
-0.0757889822,
-0.1179459468,
-0.0371880867,
-0.0584311113,
0.0236511342,
0.0397455581,
-0.0184865277,
0.0315742008,
-0.0293210465,
0.0378931537,
-0.0046725427,
0.0457264148,
-0.0058147185,
0.0235703513,
-0.0420452096,
-0.009905301,
-0.0636702925,
0.0640638843,
0.0453046784,
-0.0323011726,
-0.0421706364,
0.001787312,
-0.0257479958,
0.0262049101,
0.0086123329,
-0.0403591469,
-0.0326987244,
-0.0025757949,
0.0225267056,
-0.0113057792,
-0.0277432613,
-0.0166905336,
0.0014398746,
-0.0203151088,
-0.0368343964,
0.0374417789,
0.0283590406,
-0.0414849706,
0.0243404806,
0.0212494656,
0.0401774496,
-0.0479971953,
0.0388182066,
-0.0024224347,
0.0019960869,
-0.0197191462,
0.002376375,
-0.055978056,
0.0358889066,
0.0310291816,
-0.0040183873,
0.0062686987,
0.0015890856,
-0.0062546106,
0.0011219205,
0.0549422279,
-0.025954688,
-0.0120054018,
0.040730387,
-0.0162147693,
0.0031993827,
0.0239804741,
0.0620019101,
-0.0049561113,
0.0673938245,
0.0061338702,
0.0083032791,
0.0794132948,
-0.0072338991,
-0.0340549387,
-0.0331863351,
0.0191778783,
0.0009799064,
0.035717573,
0.0029027329,
0.0406387597,
-0.0758955926,
0.0273299795,
0.0068985522,
0.0593612567,
0.0299079828,
0.0119820796,
0.032907594,
0.0236524567,
0.0788357034,
-0.0206860043,
-0.0176682416,
-0.0541544966,
-0.0127826454,
0.0453435443,
-0.0007031683,
-0.0290813427,
0.0069398223,
-0.0390672423,
-0.0202652439,
-0.0547122173,
-0.0369243361,
-0.0304883197,
0.0916649923,
0.0231088661,
-0.0162719395,
0.1299614161,
-0.0118786218,
-0.0200031009,
0.0017772244,
-0.0382886045,
-0.0250863824,
-0.0170949735,
0.0750282034,
-0.070262149,
-0.0502829701,
0.001074162,
-0.0263881236,
0.0298050772,
0.0234817639,
-0.0033347467,
-0.0019364544,
-0.0376502536,
-0.0209413767,
-0.0155547867,
0.0464055948,
-0.0310360733,
0.023679452,
-0.0020079955,
0.0220435672,
-0.0562074035,
-0.0101060877,
0.060067527,
0.0475097038,
-0.0780219808,
0.0011341221,
-0.0070820223,
0.0035086516,
-0.0155664068,
-0.0429448672,
0.0459864549,
-0.0077924537,
-0.0598243102,
0.0167990681,
0.0100463526,
-0.0197452549,
-0.0382680073,
0.0574878678,
-0.021773167,
-0.0095593864,
0.05322605,
-0.0245461855,
-0.0176586024,
-0.000573124,
-0.0518436357,
0.0425877422,
-0.0327994861,
0.0267225374,
-0.0079555344,
-0.0261907838,
-0.0108323786,
0.0698881373,
0.0094649261,
0.0229759086,
-0.0257510114,
-0.0144413467,
0.0191126447,
0.0138954278,
-0.0334130116,
-0.0453387015,
-0.0150528476,
0.0160733797,
0.0024386588,
0.0221934244,
-0.0216988325,
-0.0350968316,
-0.0133098885,
0.0237806607,
-0.0311051216,
0.0812277645,
0.0252636988,
-0.0201639235,
-0.0056230905,
-0.0063424269,
0.0101213055,
-0.0188311376,
-0.0344009139,
-0.0277820043,
0.0637143925,
0.0130154695,
-0.0109948013,
-0.0431542918,
-0.0201008748,
-0.0518122315,
0.0552864522,
0.0286648609,
0.000984277,
-0.0039380277,
0.0014503502,
-0.0331583135,
-0.0025143272,
0.0146409748,
0.0097598415,
0.006325529,
-0.0403449759,
0.0282851141,
0.0250299461,
0.0327989198,
0.034787029,
-0.0245536566,
-0.0255238116,
-0.0352105387,
0.0037828826,
-0.0116258198,
0.0207158495,
0.0050030602,
0.0147705246,
0.0483344756,
0.0766206831,
-0.0127404379,
0.0017556049,
-0.0079427389,
0.016836958,
-0.0106520671,
0.0293904841,
-0.0232212152,
0.0218434557,
-0.0592070222,
0.0196151398,
-0.0103346128,
-0.0297209937,
0.0432700589,
-0.0034399654,
-0.0169557277,
-0.0552649572,
0.0535396263,
-0.0568600819,
-0.0191284847,
0.02463126,
-0.0108578922,
0.0035007282,
-0.0215749107,
0.0073205237,
-0.0082202032,
0.0478215925,
-0.0427951254,
0.0300061963,
-0.0185979046,
0.0462243445,
-0.0448904447,
-0.0216958653,
-0.0326881558,
0.0109975263,
0.0115926452,
0.0449031815,
0.036573071,
-0.0246627498,
-0.0507638417,
0.0073774061,
0.0237055104,
0.0664569065,
-0.0267669428,
-0.0232593566,
-0.0262463186,
0.0539328828,
0.0572473742,
0.0167913996,
0.0067663239,
-0.0787465498,
-0.0159438942,
-0.0243082382,
0.0157857276,
0.0166907404,
-0.0245923139,
-0.0209851507,
0.0182466414,
-0.0996315703,
-0.0197298266,
0.0114873312,
-0.0037281422,
-0.0337945558,
-0.0249754973,
0.0944279358,
0.0402079076,
0.0025476299,
-0.0249766782,
-0.0256149191,
0.011010332,
-0.0225618668,
-0.009803392,
-0.1132825166,
-0.0247133952,
0.0106249489,
0.0345515311,
0.0455472283,
-0.0193733461,
0.0288897343,
-0.0536937229,
0.0051047583,
-0.0074380524,
0.0163284857,
0.013249578,
-0.0303991586,
0.014322429,
-0.0101177869,
0.0030114572,
-0.0059140758,
-0.0291700624,
0.0340722017,
0.0090943547,
-0.0558808409,
-0.0280270632,
-0.0220627412,
-0.0356073081,
-0.0836363807,
0.0191710498,
0.0381207764,
-0.0650003701,
-0.0544929095,
0.0020098665,
-0.0097799199,
-0.0564214624,
0.0140143214,
0.0330193825,
-0.045949243,
0.0046478366,
-0.0065332842,
0.0154737541,
-0.05864406,
-0.0222211648,
0.0138938567,
0.0405463651,
-0.0120997122,
0.0134060271,
-0.0119673386,
-0.0050066682,
-0.0538199544,
0.0416138731,
0.0473882481,
-0.030328922,
-0.058672756,
0.0090399897,
0.0358599573,
-0.0721942633,
-0.0147825712,
-0.0544532798,
-0.0016563761,
-0.0327415392,
-0.0556442589,
-0.0298035704,
0.0293201078,
0.040291857,
-0.0012805586,
-0.0244551059,
-0.0105937812,
-0.0057421853,
-0.0728264377,
0.0618337467,
0.0131017696,
-0.0032548206,
-0.0667382181,
-0.0114125311,
-0.0080913091,
0.032738246,
-0.0634809583,
0.0192793757,
-0.0386084244,
-0.0138150984,
0.0269060265,
0.0538061149,
0.0202193931,
-0.0141914003,
-0.0321929492,
0.0287798904,
0.0510127172,
0.0634418949,
-0.0343601219,
-0.0062289732,
0.0601707809,
0.0194333252,
-0.0127552636,
0.0079983408,
-0.012704053,
0.0157426018,
-0.0053567681,
0.0612699501,
-0.0388529599,
-0.0148342038,
0.0108761424,
0.0625123382,
0.0509782471,
-0.0039463714,
0.0030462847,
0.0208494738,
0.0002590309,
0.006947835,
-0.0125521487,
-0.0390686281,
0.0330495648,
-0.0065676318,
0.0071577472,
-0.0403521694,
0.0503715388,
0.0229807887,
0.0235126317,
-0.0049344194,
0.0908467695,
-0.0117211463,
0.0281921029,
0.0144467959,
-0.0534396917,
0.0064315004,
-0.0237607248,
-0.0071143066,
0.0156443175,
-0.0042199516,
0.0254127439,
0.0278204158,
0.0185166318,
-0.0290917456,
0.0246445164,
-0.011473435,
-0.042486947,
-0.0338180549,
0.0388953686,
0.0204971153,
0.0296582226,
0.0503162444,
-0.0130106723,
-0.0311688464,
-0.018734917,
0.0340491571,
0.017950112,
0.026208356,
0.0215195064,
0.0317624249,
0.0179174989,
-0.070676975,
0.0318190977,
-0.0498837233,
0.0394489877,
0.0063488367,
0.0096367849,
-0.0650407374,
0.0301639549,
0.0212958548,
-0.03771054,
-0.0009341835,
-0.0139739383,
-0.0469911955,
-0.0211571865,
0.0861711428,
0.0188836809,
-0.0105437255,
0.018717248,
0.0314676613,
0.0717678666,
-0.0316533744,
-0.0540695712,
-0.0152549436,
0.0507310443,
0.0160747115,
-0.0166330524,
-0.0433502458,
-5.319032959e-33,
-0.0267584883,
0.0075587006,
-0.0098415306,
0.0407514684,
-0.0178965833,
0.0084744934,
-0.0151366303,
-0.0278798416,
0.0288864747,
0.0053581363,
0.0058890251,
0.0115662757,
0.0200963598,
-0.0046427227,
-0.0086615831,
-0.0026302822,
0.0285417382,
-0.0330823287,
-0.0448495038,
-0.034306854,
0.0018952092,
0.0682754368,
0.0951449424,
-0.0166580863,
0.0080393702,
-0.0001307307,
0.0204473604,
-0.0120994542,
0.0378637426,
0.0513382368,
-0.0347741358,
0.017830383,
0.0007910703,
-0.0040091574,
-0.0159741733,
0.0133954287,
-0.048463501,
-0.0208986644,
-0.0328381434,
0.0399454311,
-0.0260339882,
-0.0332573019,
0.0555626638,
0.0077728461,
-0.0477259085,
0.003964602,
0.0656731948,
-0.0118485522,
-0.0214777905,
-0.0649499595,
-0.0700887144,
0.0704964846,
0.0175743103,
-0.0194369294,
0.0507495739,
0.0174926538,
-0.0284930654,
-0.0046605985,
-0.0186322387,
-0.0458723456,
0.0536858216,
0.032575313,
-0.0116563486,
-0.0195323136,
0.0312331151,
0.03029719,
0.0089444676,
-0.0380715355,
0.036132969,
-0.0320788361,
0.0820183977,
0.0781623051,
0.0191121995,
0.0095628062,
0.0722434819,
0.0382579081,
-0.0133270947,
0.0256026555,
-0.0224794969,
0.0343206637,
0.000491841,
-0.0112174852,
-0.0339359641,
0.0335468315,
-0.0070844367,
0.0225193836,
-0.0330660641,
0.0155573096,
0.0040724142,
-0.0302601904,
-0.0174905583,
0.0264384728,
0.0297280718,
-0.0249137823,
-0.0065195197,
-0.0286045969,
-0.0126894442,
0.0241832379,
-0.0296326894,
0.0174766853,
-0.0540257171,
-0.0604076274,
-0.0168444179,
0.0218003783,
0.0256415606,
-0.0002533159,
0.0204640105,
0.0190123208,
-0.0140551701,
-0.0092020398,
-0.0126395123,
-0.0419808216,
-0.000034851,
0.0670640096,
0.0345812179,
0.0376687385,
0.0295804963,
0.0002425741,
0.0343916453,
0.0080016814,
-0.0407686606,
0.0331694372,
0.0173739884,
0.060905654,
0.0023653305,
-0.0164437797,
0.0018012014,
0.0363298133,
0.0072711315,
-0.0596055947,
0.0191986207,
-0.0189549625,
2.476e-7,
0.0998534858,
0.0734676495,
0.0335130133,
-0.0101341838,
-0.0198973455,
0.002350657,
-0.0185375996,
0.0242066123,
0.0043834369,
0.0198835861,
0.0293994658,
0.0093563572,
0.0214600507,
0.0167107526,
-0.0532183871,
-0.004484769,
-0.0733913258,
0.0106442645,
-0.0375171378,
0.0001466469,
0.0865447372,
0.0486790985,
0.0125481263,
0.0045196554,
-0.0332210548,
-0.0446254201,
0.08268971,
0.0029386319,
0.0103430012,
0.0642986894,
0.0440903492,
-0.0262027308,
0.0222765226,
-0.0145012001,
-0.0101166284,
0.0651581287,
0.0517410934,
0.0504214689,
-0.0131557109,
0.0224924423,
-0.019351963,
-0.0250183418,
-0.0078923116,
-0.0285877734,
0.0355791524,
-0.0839774087,
-0.0225094538,
0.0064421976,
-0.088972941,
0.0168966725,
0.0295502674,
-0.0037679242,
-0.004848408,
0.0328462906,
0.0518264361,
-0.0051613422,
-0.0126333972,
-0.0662591755,
0.0176907517,
0.0368019901,
-0.0486624427,
-0.019426709,
-0.0527075455,
-0.0201195851,
-0.0002969642,
-0.0341271609,
-0.0146564711,
2.295729906e-34,
0.0483513251,
-0.0142633487,
0.0060785916,
0.0683729872,
0.0207649488,
-0.0202199575,
-0.0192390215,
0.0111806849,
-0.0204937849,
-0.0633812621,
0.0216801669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13820v1 | Framing Social Movements on Social Media: Unpacking Diagnostic, Prognostic, and Motivational Strategies | 2024-06-19T20:31:34 | 2024-06-19T20:31:34 | Julia Mendelsohn, Maya Vijan, Dallas Card, Ceren Budak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media enables activists to directly communicate with the public and
provides a space for movement leaders, participants, bystanders, and opponents
to collectively construct and contest narratives. Focusing on Twitter messages
from social movements surrounding three issues in 2018-2019 (guns, immigration,
and LGBTQ rights), we create a codebook, annotated dataset, and computational
models to detect diagnostic (problem identification and attribution),
prognostic (proposed solutions and tactics), and motivational (calls to action)
framing strategies. We conduct an in-depth unsupervised linguistic analysis of
each framing strategy, and uncover cross-movement similarities in associations
between framing and linguistic features such as pronouns and deontic modal
verbs. Finally, we compare framing strategies across issues and other social,
cultural, and interactional contexts. For example, we show that diagnostic
framing is more common in replies than original broadcast posts, and that
social movement organizations focus much more on prognostic and motivational
framing than journalists and ordinary citizens. | [
0.0169021469,
0.072651729,
-0.0072574643,
-0.0110606635,
-0.0222105458,
0.0020687627,
-0.016918445,
0.0127259837,
-0.0384743772,
-0.0337672979,
0.0768510699,
-0.0041347444,
0.0015152585,
0.0087512461,
-0.0015474781,
-0.0170408972,
-0.014872957,
0.0621733516,
0.057507474,
-0.0068392768,
0.0584806837,
0.0683523044,
-0.0148941949,
0.0529977083,
-0.0398585945,
-0.0028087655,
-0.0056020855,
0.0132645313,
0.0274232291,
-0.0189307891,
0.0269258339,
0.039217148,
0.0273208506,
0.0368175469,
0.0000019563,
-0.0195775907,
-0.0051712673,
-0.0477746353,
0.0229489468,
-0.0480227433,
0.0482993349,
-0.08699435,
0.012457286,
0.0122999251,
-0.0462772176,
-0.0303816162,
0.0394654796,
0.010690663,
0.01879026,
0.0613890998,
-0.0065505439,
-0.0203227196,
-0.0075924969,
0.0025353446,
-0.0481569208,
0.031503778,
0.0094955685,
-0.0302273873,
-0.0215007085,
0.0110896574,
0.0158225391,
0.0307708737,
0.0038439725,
-0.0142909521,
-0.0583235435,
-0.0276256055,
0.0141013442,
-0.047319524,
0.0195343364,
0.0371468253,
0.0795869976,
-0.0362970196,
0.0604435839,
-0.0122660035,
0.0031362085,
0.0323924534,
-0.0351958834,
0.0403178371,
-0.0154350642,
0.020409165,
-0.0113442922,
-0.0047663925,
0.028563153,
0.0322030634,
0.0354840271,
0.0079885665,
-0.0360366292,
0.0196494218,
-0.0367013849,
-0.009241241,
0.020370258,
-0.0619112216,
0.0029892854,
-0.0024112924,
-0.0334705375,
0.0561897159,
-0.0130210761,
-0.0394510217,
0.0224602278,
-0.0502875634,
-0.0105118733,
0.0126797631,
0.0249069538,
0.0039470862,
0.0302942451,
-0.0354400165,
-0.0316456221,
0.0157261845,
0.0152053442,
0.0193844736,
-0.0652727336,
0.0063694376,
-0.0189135894,
-0.0241229273,
-0.0270672701,
-0.0038840279,
0.0107495021,
-0.036619287,
-0.01340516,
-0.0170975924,
-0.0784186274,
0.0180035029,
0.0004221839,
0.0271221362,
0.0000752375,
0.0979916379,
-0.0535255037,
0.0306647997,
0.00097401,
-0.0316418894,
0.0071897153,
0.0146094058,
0.0347163379,
0.0060095848,
-0.0252731871,
-0.0227689762,
-0.0152016934,
0.0283605643,
-0.016893154,
-0.057669431,
-0.0280895475,
-0.0440219492,
-0.0153834214,
-0.0647352487,
0.0409445986,
0.0697343796,
0.0278810263,
-0.0405353084,
0.0100443577,
0.0223194379,
0.0142841209,
0.0335058533,
0.0476191118,
0.0326594822,
0.0679386854,
0.0515690446,
0.0279910211,
0.0854699239,
0.0209113769,
0.0173156392,
0.0232522879,
-0.028690435,
0.0187541265,
0.0203265976,
0.0082458984,
0.0335113443,
0.0296953525,
-0.0018416044,
-0.0263051298,
0.0055350629,
-0.0286128242,
0.0385572277,
0.0198038779,
-0.006410094,
0.0132887205,
0.0955327153,
-0.0120094614,
-0.0082097407,
0.0249645077,
0.0485267676,
-0.0283880364,
-0.0372813046,
0.0235363822,
-0.0190517586,
-0.0034609761,
-0.0540994853,
-0.0241594408,
0.0002265018,
-0.0310095642,
-0.0257950965,
-0.0298120752,
0.0423097573,
0.0445550568,
-0.0437732898,
-0.0284493882,
-0.0050167004,
-0.0041641076,
0.0391732268,
0.009453617,
-0.0461431816,
-0.0105204545,
-0.0467628986,
-0.0361793637,
-0.0144268554,
-0.0086448714,
0.0237652622,
-0.0260016453,
-0.0625879988,
0.0661313161,
0.0352140106,
0.0150441136,
0.0137172351,
-0.0811076909,
0.0001871672,
-0.0431796834,
0.0113611389,
0.004313102,
-0.0026259571,
0.0171421506,
0.0337009132,
-0.0089541543,
-0.0249137823,
-0.0609626584,
0.0312250908,
0.0482334942,
-0.0155817112,
-0.0139238043,
0.0242606737,
0.0429934524,
0.0680273622,
0.0136434371,
-0.0196357369,
0.0154504739,
0.0028184324,
-0.062346112,
0.0484189056,
-0.0120178275,
0.0400602371,
0.0068928283,
-0.0522561893,
-0.0593680069,
-0.0041843392,
-0.0166040622,
-0.002621182,
0.1102652997,
-0.0197533146,
-0.0218983032,
-0.0072879931,
-0.0329817869,
-0.0175418407,
-0.0141714597,
0.0139670726,
0.0458145961,
-0.0066672801,
-0.0062598982,
-0.009350677,
-0.020418914,
0.0321844518,
0.0104929535,
0.0028332062,
0.0377790928,
-0.0191093832,
0.0248208735,
0.0231718272,
-0.0522716381,
-0.064185515,
-0.0125311017,
-0.0921988562,
-0.0291152485,
-0.0426215343,
-0.0093536042,
0.035878025,
0.0193799417,
-0.0113573093,
0.0111767203,
-0.0141971158,
-0.0547796935,
0.008429951,
-0.0145650115,
-0.0209604148,
0.0169230346,
-0.0082000345,
-0.0052675367,
-0.0019594871,
-0.0610800274,
0.011872882,
0.0171431061,
-0.1020801887,
0.0182300862,
-0.0195037629,
-0.0411236249,
-0.047217112,
-0.0212764554,
-0.0291754752,
0.0522727147,
0.0138301877,
0.0018892393,
-0.0108672706,
0.0488968939,
0.0932798833,
-0.0126096038,
0.0406374261,
-0.0511850789,
-0.0128791239,
-0.0420632958,
-0.0379709564,
-0.0498230718,
-0.0791623592,
0.0320850275,
0.0360555649,
0.059140157,
0.0315394141,
-0.0363361686,
0.0057833572,
-0.0687033385,
-0.0250125248,
-0.0321288444,
-0.0050311852,
-0.0202840939,
0.0328093395,
-0.0342383906,
0.0042673303,
0.0030573877,
0.0532020107,
0.0274157282,
-0.0186641421,
-0.0336736776,
-0.0092934538,
0.0600141771,
-0.0103691826,
0.0228417758,
0.0303234737,
-0.0267740916,
0.0316880308,
-0.0971016735,
0.0162730031,
-0.0200323164,
0.0134155471,
-0.0180145632,
0.0439885147,
0.0415630192,
-0.0085189072,
0.0036755593,
-0.0992273092,
-0.0498867929,
-0.0004985927,
-0.02673053,
-0.0123066362,
-0.0087325908,
0.0057901065,
0.0228912719,
-0.0222903267,
0.0295038447,
-0.0137941688,
-0.0086592613,
0.0213938858,
-0.030764835,
0.0041851513,
0.0164631959,
-0.0334616229,
-0.016169548,
0.0504887588,
0.0430552401,
0.0183002222,
-0.0176547784,
-0.0269933064,
0.0058008251,
0.0160064474,
0.0212183855,
-0.0325052775,
0.0635503829,
-0.0141645838,
0.0570577346,
0.0511719361,
0.0416444242,
0.0243014917,
0.000754686,
0.0002650365,
0.0219773166,
0.0018768316,
-0.0083081732,
-0.1001067981,
0.0262319352,
0.0013717058,
0.0164906289,
-0.0585191324,
-0.0111343497,
-0.0086554727,
-0.049180802,
0.0310372449,
-0.0049149934,
0.050099276,
0.0366084017,
-0.0380035602,
0.0369673036,
0.0042029084,
-0.0064520654,
-0.0302637722,
0.0190855321,
-0.0025608416,
0.0213488508,
-0.0512753949,
-0.0156306885,
-0.0367349871,
-0.042580124,
0.0272925831,
0.017265914,
0.0845441595,
0.0266895555,
0.0073570814,
0.0318453759,
-0.012762785,
-0.0283371191,
-0.0450264998,
0.0115301032,
-0.0082723629,
0.0020720209,
-0.0133889886,
0.0730188563,
-0.0484171659,
-0.0445799157,
-0.0070617418,
-0.0018240709,
-0.0021641501,
-0.0517560579,
0.0104229096,
0.0532681495,
0.0310015138,
0.0453465991,
0.0618353896,
-0.0056435755,
0.0075502829,
-0.0433076993,
0.0601916164,
-0.0180206038,
-0.054518193,
-0.0602850541,
0.0127182426,
-0.0004334626,
-0.0037451962,
-0.0511297546,
0.0166338161,
0.0107639106,
0.0137984855,
-0.0271919258,
0.0073026279,
-0.0195816495,
-0.0471694246,
0.0487205423,
0.0026812537,
0.0319108292,
0.0125531033,
-0.0511281155,
-0.0213116556,
0.0577859543,
0.00187612,
0.0163140316,
-0.0442387499,
-0.0500015952,
0.0235712565,
-0.0386696383,
0.0166185331,
0.0039300774,
0.0109347021,
-0.0576344617,
0.0130254412,
0.04362325,
0.0064708996,
0.0263102185,
0.0017914594,
0.0260551628,
0.0073818415,
0.024584325,
0.0512437299,
0.0177290831,
0.0437200889,
0.009724238,
-0.0907861292,
0.0256282538,
-0.0039538085,
-0.03302579,
0.0167642273,
-0.0249616038,
-0.0705928952,
-0.0254537407,
-0.0770326033,
-0.0049933288,
-0.0357761905,
0.0081269238,
-0.0078344438,
0.0181720015,
0.019377498,
-0.0461219773,
0.0718048438,
-0.0449378453,
0.024025429,
-0.025157351,
0.0673573762,
0.0039552911,
0.0271294378,
-0.0166517347,
-0.0171685759,
0.0326257758,
0.0411213785,
-0.0150347138,
0.0083976779,
0.010659053,
0.0202590395,
0.033873193,
-0.0022921218,
0.0328250602,
-0.0046071038,
-0.0012798371,
-0.075089179,
0.0159583911,
0.0215014219,
-0.0076910094,
-0.0191055536,
0.0462106951,
0.0025057155,
-0.0137275849,
0.0073559745,
0.0176381432,
-0.0036182732,
-0.0136018181,
0.0420022197,
0.010977543,
-0.0303824469,
-0.0026696732,
-0.0220025443,
-0.0718954727,
0.0273423065,
0.0521890484,
-0.0277063549,
-0.0120741222,
-0.0139227603,
-0.0096025523,
0.0133317774,
0.0357728377,
0.0003217167,
-0.0724961832,
0.0001480897,
0.062616758,
-0.0326079205,
-0.0106838141,
-0.0024969676,
-0.0139930025,
0.040510565,
0.0041086837,
0.0269046966,
-0.0557966977,
0.0063710161,
-0.0244437195,
-0.0417237468,
0.0125844441,
-6.557110262e-33,
0.0252671,
-0.0652578697,
-0.0138544943,
-0.0345132984,
-0.0144300545,
0.0391505547,
-0.0386310704,
0.0306105129,
0.0149434535,
0.0619887225,
0.0030508202,
0.0538633317,
0.0210374519,
0.0110841841,
-0.0228214283,
-0.0191121455,
0.0125092426,
-0.0120240729,
-0.0515215993,
0.0189732015,
0.0416833535,
-0.0181884319,
-0.0297122672,
-0.1044071317,
0.0357319638,
-0.0147379469,
-0.0356495231,
-0.0024454677,
0.0636241734,
-0.0070646023,
-0.0224672426,
0.0378352702,
0.0373598412,
-0.0095075229,
0.0374721251,
0.1337882727,
-0.0340005681,
-0.0256276317,
0.0573972389,
-0.0171317942,
-0.014493783,
-0.0090961419,
-0.0143415593,
-0.0142172221,
-0.0715375021,
0.0359119177,
0.0187313184,
0.0306951981,
0.0913472548,
0.0387177132,
-0.0665512085,
0.018351309,
-0.0534404889,
0.0135840895,
-0.0181144904,
0.004696744,
0.0181402303,
0.043251045,
-0.0766275004,
0.0096794739,
-0.0504630879,
0.0215356797,
0.0667598695,
0.0134775573,
-0.0151866917,
0.0609252229,
0.0135038132,
0.0314963758,
-0.0455496162,
0.0178551897,
0.0189986378,
0.0265778936,
0.0294748656,
0.1079523414,
-0.0072372695,
-0.0332730934,
-0.0425012782,
-0.0164147578,
0.0078482144,
-0.0045546833,
0.0283992495,
-0.0099378703,
-0.0144680692,
-0.0415640064,
-0.070869334,
-0.0671954602,
-0.0227387752,
-0.0083929207,
-0.0329353884,
0.0030985652,
-0.0632797107,
0.0087433662,
0.0370384641,
-0.0029071874,
-0.0330113806,
0.0233199131,
-0.0133074792,
0.0283044111,
0.025197411,
0.0554567352,
-0.0398019329,
0.0240950324,
-0.0014812547,
0.0361555852,
0.054003492,
-0.05277206,
0.0230587516,
0.0004006792,
-0.0317414552,
0.0084766261,
-0.0130452812,
0.0366065204,
-0.0719589815,
-0.0437778682,
0.0362023823,
0.0675646216,
0.0217054021,
-0.0198564176,
0.0616453849,
-0.0066389632,
0.0324624442,
0.0012134163,
-0.0824441016,
0.0229291748,
-0.0552981347,
0.0084937979,
-0.0039877463,
0.0756733492,
0.069558017,
-0.0594401956,
-0.0144209275,
-0.0373880193,
2.685e-7,
0.0711033493,
0.0283078719,
0.0158578288,
-0.0210055653,
0.0248095542,
0.0426368564,
0.0441611968,
0.0259233825,
-0.0258290935,
-0.0854003876,
-0.0246220399,
0.053366296,
0.0416675694,
0.005007009,
-0.0359390825,
0.046155069,
-0.0079199057,
0.0244326647,
-0.0657879189,
0.0678513199,
-0.0205238741,
0.0206051916,
0.0338993929,
0.0047289096,
-0.0394867919,
-0.0219775233,
0.0476506129,
-0.0580572598,
-0.0312274471,
0.0335134752,
-0.018898312,
-0.0473437794,
0.0215112399,
-0.0336028039,
-0.0213677026,
0.0071698925,
-0.0177222714,
0.0267073121,
0.0486190654,
-0.0368435942,
-0.0507575795,
0.0099246828,
-0.0298604742,
-0.0122123677,
0.030062547,
-0.0616180673,
-0.0593529418,
-0.0591657795,
0.0120896334,
-0.0202541687,
-0.0055937003,
-0.0061218091,
-0.0796550661,
0.0237922166,
0.0084548825,
0.011290594,
0.00782324,
-0.0862220898,
-0.0070141605,
-0.0352120921,
-0.0307672713,
-0.0229076799,
0.0151611501,
0.0038840191,
0.0159031823,
0.0097569283,
0.0407350212,
1.916459753e-34,
0.0162738934,
0.0374432914,
-0.022359835,
-0.0317249112,
0.0257205702,
0.0161474254,
-0.0246999264,
-0.0161052421,
0.0234608557,
-0.0210042167,
0.0173499137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13807v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13807v2 | AlanaVLM: A Multimodal Embodied AI Foundation Model for Egocentric Video Understanding | 2024-06-19T20:14:14 | 2024-06-21T09:53:41 | Alessandro Suglia, Claudio Greco, Katie Baker, Jose L. Part, Ioannis Papaioannou, Arash Eshghi, Ioannis Konstas, Oliver Lemon | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | AI personal assistants deployed via robots or wearables require embodied
understanding to collaborate with humans effectively. However, current
Vision-Language Models (VLMs) primarily focus on third-person view videos,
neglecting the richness of egocentric perceptual experience. To address this
gap, we propose three key contributions. First, we introduce the Egocentric
Video Understanding Dataset (EVUD) for training VLMs on video captioning and
question answering tasks specific to egocentric videos. Second, we present
AlanaVLM, a 7B parameter VLM trained using parameter-efficient methods on EVUD.
Finally, we evaluate AlanaVLM's capabilities on OpenEQA, a challenging
benchmark for embodied video question answering. Our model achieves
state-of-the-art performance, outperforming open-source models including strong
Socratic models using GPT-4 as a planner by 3.6%. Additionally, we outperform
Claude 3 and Gemini Pro Vision 1.0 and showcase competitive results compared to
Gemini Pro 1.5 and GPT-4V, even surpassing the latter in spatial reasoning.
This research paves the way for building efficient VLMs that can be deployed in
robots or wearables, leveraging embodied video understanding to collaborate
seamlessly with humans in everyday tasks, contributing to the next generation
of Embodied AI. | [
0.0274926685,
0.0374499597,
-0.0073082033,
0.0485459566,
0.0024504769,
-0.0118996007,
0.0028931175,
-0.0471680276,
0.0018994143,
-0.0642915517,
-0.0431936309,
-0.0154802706,
-0.0130377198,
0.0301428288,
0.030053556,
-0.0481773876,
0.0450554974,
-0.0223537143,
0.0008192721,
0.0046564015,
0.0062046098,
0.0093808109,
-0.0335564278,
0.0341119096,
-0.031228153,
0.0060743215,
-0.0410935357,
0.0068998481,
0.0419489481,
-0.0367554165,
-0.0256458092,
0.0169983618,
0.0572211221,
-0.0163309872,
0.0000019657,
-0.0153766908,
0.0237594843,
-0.0228022728,
0.0125970738,
-0.0059252852,
-0.0308994651,
-0.0250972155,
0.0334421881,
0.0300946441,
-0.0622127764,
-0.0181366131,
0.0308720395,
0.0252882224,
0.0763937309,
0.0245557837,
-0.0153182354,
-0.0003693456,
-0.0088244304,
-0.0061531733,
-0.0059927441,
-0.0298647638,
0.0092539238,
-0.0228219423,
0.0316699818,
0.005105509,
-0.0664782375,
0.0308754463,
0.0597301647,
0.0161373354,
0.0132524315,
0.0570666865,
-0.0677515417,
-0.0271783657,
-0.0173384361,
0.0917054936,
0.0716763288,
0.0053888462,
0.0007323448,
0.0380932912,
0.039253857,
-0.0435045138,
-0.0266165826,
0.0382162407,
-0.0169448443,
-0.008707867,
-0.0546316281,
0.0309585482,
-0.0136714885,
0.0099918069,
-0.0072994558,
0.0002644956,
0.0063949474,
0.0182149671,
-0.0082154619,
-0.0082570314,
-0.0441153273,
-0.0363659263,
-0.013690724,
0.0409077071,
0.0179038271,
-0.0023051782,
-0.0584771447,
0.0508975163,
-0.0541802384,
-0.0127069,
0.0663017482,
0.0214922652,
0.019169569,
0.0421694815,
0.0000940611,
0.0555323437,
-0.0110906996,
0.0520676039,
0.0148423119,
0.012055859,
-0.0576157458,
-0.0005269463,
-0.0602723509,
0.0033960848,
-0.0428433791,
-0.0612606555,
0.0131901484,
0.0199249294,
-0.0238018092,
-0.0064357962,
-0.0122589245,
0.0641634986,
0.0414259098,
-0.026826594,
-0.0244608391,
0.0053025293,
-0.0480238199,
0.0531720221,
-0.0236592256,
-0.0687787831,
-0.0430654772,
0.0160449445,
0.0066442359,
-0.0056474563,
-0.0124336202,
0.0565188229,
-0.0065524946,
-0.0628999621,
0.0391296782,
0.0119840708,
-0.0171944853,
-0.0282336548,
0.0257937741,
-0.0444511063,
0.0411255583,
-0.0530223437,
-0.009826079,
-0.0221387036,
0.0395330042,
-0.0060412614,
0.0110768024,
0.0701093525,
-0.0277485624,
0.038054537,
0.0155628109,
0.0190191269,
0.0368646979,
0.0461721383,
0.0357751399,
0.0005882907,
0.0073945601,
0.0061277896,
0.0408884026,
0.0115480581,
-0.013894381,
0.0145490831,
-0.0147088422,
0.0296996962,
-0.0303002875,
0.0674689263,
0.0207484905,
0.0323191024,
-0.0234742519,
-0.0559429713,
0.0590571091,
0.0081121633,
-0.0806861147,
-0.042765975,
0.0222625509,
0.0058188555,
0.0364445485,
-0.0697240829,
-0.0704901367,
0.0894129053,
0.0504469723,
-0.0183651745,
0.0039065047,
-0.0077067278,
-0.0783033073,
-0.0587698855,
-0.0104744602,
0.0145730879,
-0.0244414173,
0.0217731427,
0.0241760742,
-0.0007011963,
-0.0304980222,
0.0099330498,
-0.0395477638,
-0.0221371166,
0.012798707,
0.0013538222,
0.0109087089,
0.0437107421,
0.014588451,
-0.0056715771,
-0.055533506,
-0.0096812304,
0.0633819997,
0.0399140008,
0.032183785,
-0.0142855607,
0.0445812047,
-0.0390265472,
-0.0453551002,
-0.0243029874,
0.0082545653,
0.0492152013,
0.0057324837,
0.003717673,
-0.0151499072,
0.0139064342,
-0.0312908962,
0.036118187,
-0.0094352756,
-0.0195058882,
-0.0051388438,
0.0278219096,
-0.0048832069,
0.0269581955,
-0.0234397072,
-0.0180061851,
0.0249140859,
-0.0278463215,
-0.0017748396,
0.0408436283,
-0.0358434878,
-0.0280208662,
0.0372252725,
-0.0905915424,
0.0028241212,
0.0534229204,
-0.0114104543,
-0.0565431267,
0.0434685871,
-0.0418755934,
0.0006775273,
-0.0386332907,
-0.0212248862,
0.0622754917,
0.0108852973,
-0.0014576163,
-0.0164274443,
-0.0409997292,
-0.0335238427,
0.0166218095,
0.0230765659,
0.0513410829,
-0.0376750641,
0.0056733694,
-0.0094769085,
0.0016038761,
0.0205920096,
0.0106981285,
0.0074202209,
-0.0451942533,
-0.0328746513,
-0.1225812733,
-0.0187970046,
-0.0146201998,
-0.0017150312,
0.0095030032,
-0.0250192042,
-0.0152725941,
-0.0528774783,
-0.0064045885,
0.0093731163,
-0.0127584897,
0.0030839918,
0.0118706711,
0.0231921244,
-0.0166603513,
-0.0275116302,
0.0321522057,
-0.0018637374,
0.0105386348,
0.0193394758,
0.0156297274,
0.0003805759,
-0.0515776537,
-0.0433277488,
0.0706706345,
-0.0430868939,
-0.0333058387,
0.0291609578,
-0.0339194499,
-0.0226499904,
0.0652299374,
-0.0147427497,
0.034056142,
0.0245726854,
-0.025380576,
-0.0293393061,
0.0220669061,
0.0256369933,
-0.0178891309,
-0.0143257398,
-0.0208096392,
-0.0255224034,
0.0223552659,
-0.0070852283,
0.0172256269,
-0.1026025116,
0.0497282445,
0.0233398695,
-0.0737011284,
-0.0203653518,
0.0585894734,
-0.0130038792,
0.0087326625,
-0.0505727418,
-0.0514543913,
0.0355790891,
-0.0178750083,
-0.0191769321,
0.0203391239,
0.0202010274,
-0.0207692087,
0.0703529641,
0.0288946144,
0.0232092682,
-0.04277955,
-0.0154327312,
-0.0513482206,
0.0218068641,
-0.0227105189,
0.0101283621,
0.0169388913,
-0.0651933998,
0.002844838,
-0.005583188,
-0.0203241147,
-0.026358664,
-0.0016736055,
-0.0585969985,
0.0130251097,
-0.0876964778,
-0.0045069833,
-0.0060772547,
0.0066130534,
0.0099315168,
0.0182958227,
-0.0248581395,
0.002271388,
-0.0289081261,
-0.0130841788,
0.080889903,
0.0410124063,
-0.0313553661,
-0.0413942076,
0.0735240281,
0.0575301833,
0.0324648954,
-0.0106065525,
-0.0514075309,
0.0346320271,
0.0048331576,
0.024450263,
-0.0014646747,
0.0199052803,
0.0788363889,
-0.0086740581,
-0.0068720137,
0.108038418,
0.0147733279,
-0.0388231426,
0.0155344782,
0.0167349316,
0.0089737037,
0.0592014678,
0.023420345,
-0.0585709922,
-0.0502284616,
-0.0088010449,
0.0009248375,
0.0359030068,
-0.0312795416,
-0.0230848007,
-0.115808174,
0.0368201621,
-0.0092689851,
-0.0584571697,
-0.0465519726,
0.0401677638,
0.026446877,
-0.0027176314,
-0.03923475,
0.00094728,
-0.0147790574,
0.0207306035,
0.0095497323,
-0.0092916619,
-0.0133550772,
0.0546455495,
-0.0402073637,
0.0364884958,
-0.0139931152,
0.0193285104,
-0.0255536679,
-0.0535727628,
-0.0291560963,
-0.0160884783,
0.0094057145,
-0.0089772586,
0.0599636659,
-0.0613346808,
-0.0363362841,
0.0407987498,
0.0716022849,
-0.0490523875,
0.000665937,
0.0286420602,
0.0412000492,
-0.0392161831,
0.0060827211,
-0.0277304333,
0.0179063864,
-0.0141285267,
0.0534046069,
-0.0040553287,
-0.0180373155,
-0.0276502632,
0.0194926001,
-0.035950195,
-0.0049858592,
-0.0249473043,
0.0019115825,
0.02092259,
-0.0019929498,
-0.0558574349,
-0.0487374626,
0.0994843543,
0.0713167936,
0.0123524806,
-0.0346774273,
-0.0359630883,
0.058525674,
-0.0821353644,
0.0614604689,
-0.0088151265,
0.0201175865,
-0.0338572301,
0.0142032448,
0.0464948155,
-0.0238640327,
0.0065992931,
0.0197615605,
0.0024561759,
-0.0409708098,
-0.041219607,
0.0881661028,
0.0199491307,
0.0886810571,
0.0015900673,
-0.0109008839,
-0.0259079244,
0.0001268422,
0.0178943053,
0.0577792712,
0.0231232084,
-0.0076465625,
-0.0082928697,
0.0377472416,
-0.018510405,
0.0202173963,
-0.01515608,
0.0147226574,
-0.0187138263,
-0.0350523554,
0.0300434008,
-0.0088891201,
0.038282048,
-0.0161487907,
0.0212422051,
-0.0246895589,
0.0064217406,
-0.0122940559,
0.0251962282,
-0.0798648372,
0.0257945266,
0.0146688959,
0.0276895948,
0.0066369553,
0.0008317586,
0.0051289173,
-0.0124574788,
-0.0025916211,
-0.0354951955,
-0.0077018728,
0.004174029,
-0.0292374771,
0.0117973695,
0.0023787217,
0.0157206934,
-0.0116993403,
0.0439619347,
0.0295359548,
0.0721298978,
0.0328257903,
-0.0249469038,
-0.0117004737,
0.0636709109,
-0.0447920747,
-0.057384856,
-0.0037729936,
0.0647249669,
0.0245370492,
-0.0122889439,
-0.0246917866,
0.0011771115,
0.0142637277,
-0.0023425389,
0.0454821549,
-0.0068474105,
-0.0277500413,
0.069421418,
0.0118661532,
0.0038678946,
0.0149429683,
0.0466456115,
-0.0034764365,
0.0574353784,
-0.0195506532,
0.0343653522,
-0.0434429757,
-0.0215541385,
0.0464333743,
0.0234110449,
0.0030131803,
0.0577648841,
-0.018151775,
-0.0594270863,
-0.0321509279,
0.0579340905,
-0.037339177,
-0.0014850826,
0.052007366,
-0.0091113364,
0.0170245208,
-0.0323797204,
-0.0143981613,
-0.0583323687,
-0.0537580401,
-0.0191036686,
0.029074572,
-5.567472221e-33,
-0.0358481482,
0.0197562724,
0.0401202179,
0.008283427,
-0.0341517031,
0.0076832892,
-0.047007814,
0.0360350795,
-0.0185011961,
0.0007606526,
0.0279120319,
0.0145577937,
-0.0086849546,
0.0294336732,
0.0137309209,
-0.0186056215,
-0.0126854219,
-0.0311494432,
-0.0108538195,
0.0091486657,
0.027317306,
0.0193365719,
0.0441907234,
-0.0441906899,
-0.0327482261,
0.0257652514,
-0.0182034783,
0.0388848968,
-0.0285110492,
0.0371557623,
-0.03580961,
-0.0439087525,
0.0079010334,
0.0241165366,
-0.0108487736,
-0.0076215486,
-0.0433992967,
-0.0281730928,
0.0066552986,
0.037481118,
-0.1216116175,
-0.0150046572,
0.003478423,
-0.0085701328,
-0.0243594646,
-0.01707929,
0.0225949995,
-0.0168718006,
0.0076634046,
0.0348860733,
0.0174394678,
0.0008556672,
-0.0154297287,
-0.0516975559,
0.0199979004,
0.0444149151,
-0.005588864,
-0.0265065171,
-0.0120696034,
-0.0073672025,
-0.0624694526,
-0.0110140871,
0.1033891886,
-0.0053687165,
0.0253767688,
0.0537322387,
0.0483678654,
-0.037751019,
-0.0561112314,
-0.0050793607,
0.0214180127,
0.0845972821,
0.0116645126,
0.029064022,
-0.0465863869,
0.0288193095,
-0.0115215741,
0.0435334891,
-0.0639953017,
0.0562060624,
-0.0209935009,
-0.0208243169,
-0.0293484814,
0.0218877885,
-0.0472028032,
-0.0487429723,
-0.0203152318,
0.0089544011,
0.0640166029,
0.0156169403,
-0.009402412,
-0.0252934918,
0.0560110621,
-0.0742925927,
0.0495827161,
0.004312004,
-0.0242423099,
0.0501285829,
0.0186223574,
0.0491318367,
-0.035835918,
0.020368129,
0.0362110846,
0.0166155603,
-0.0102825081,
-0.0096210064,
-0.0296776537,
0.0514697097,
-0.0142065268,
-0.0401089489,
-0.0364570767,
0.029212445,
-0.0166247096,
0.0074902903,
0.0416957512,
0.0329641551,
-0.0553528145,
0.0463177674,
-0.0484641902,
0.0045285556,
-0.0147988126,
0.0036889792,
0.0103115011,
0.0259016398,
-0.0074472064,
-0.003505589,
-0.0569454283,
-0.0553187765,
-0.0124860518,
-0.0676445812,
-0.0022479903,
0.054212518,
2.764e-7,
-0.0185957309,
0.0035750302,
0.0385172814,
-0.0281225573,
0.0322785042,
0.0514432937,
-0.0137177268,
0.0903708264,
-0.0491437428,
-0.0436194949,
0.0281228889,
0.0857085586,
0.0520304777,
-0.0476718917,
-0.0285196174,
0.0079924632,
-0.0158261284,
-0.0222200081,
-0.0578058846,
-0.020736564,
0.0425319225,
0.0739034936,
0.0033416641,
0.0001274138,
0.022810977,
-0.0379277058,
0.074345246,
-0.017220147,
0.0198114049,
-0.0215678159,
0.0408693738,
0.0024662574,
-0.0120898709,
-0.0009308061,
-0.0041033998,
-0.0064057559,
0.0132485107,
0.0848713294,
-0.0462932028,
-0.0304976143,
-0.0022026026,
0.0380736478,
-0.0191026125,
-0.0206070933,
0.0752144083,
-0.0446681455,
-0.0123265488,
0.0062635648,
-0.0279668607,
0.0107844351,
0.0029230462,
0.0242413245,
0.0034637873,
0.0204562135,
0.0062274323,
-0.0655047596,
-0.0214312673,
-0.1111433506,
0.0156815238,
-0.0508483127,
-0.0468531214,
0.0521749668,
-0.0180487614,
0.0247376189,
0.0262599736,
0.0050963708,
-0.0606499426,
1.535669149e-34,
-0.0040428499,
-0.0117801903,
-0.0042184326,
-0.003985751,
0.0047459351,
-0.0375170186,
-0.0282601081,
0.0123331919,
0.0223777406,
-0.0613938794,
-0.00895782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13805v1 | WikiContradict: A Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs on Real-World Knowledge Conflicts from Wikipedia | 2024-06-19T20:13:42 | 2024-06-19T20:13:42 | Yufang Hou, Alessandra Pascale, Javier Carnerero-Cano, Tigran Tchrakian, Radu Marinescu, Elizabeth Daly, Inkit Padhi, Prasanna Sattigeri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a promising solution to
mitigate the limitations of large language models (LLMs), such as
hallucinations and outdated information. However, it remains unclear how LLMs
handle knowledge conflicts arising from different augmented retrieved passages,
especially when these passages originate from the same source and have equal
trustworthiness. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
LLM-generated answers to questions that have varying answers based on
contradictory passages from Wikipedia, a dataset widely regarded as a
high-quality pre-training resource for most LLMs. Specifically, we introduce
WikiContradict, a benchmark consisting of 253 high-quality, human-annotated
instances designed to assess LLM performance when augmented with retrieved
passages containing real-world knowledge conflicts. We benchmark a diverse
range of both closed and open-source LLMs under different QA scenarios,
including RAG with a single passage, and RAG with 2 contradictory passages.
Through rigorous human evaluations on a subset of WikiContradict instances
involving 5 LLMs and over 3,500 judgements, we shed light on the behaviour and
limitations of these models. For instance, when provided with two passages
containing contradictory facts, all models struggle to generate answers that
accurately reflect the conflicting nature of the context, especially for
implicit conflicts requiring reasoning. Since human evaluation is costly, we
also introduce an automated model that estimates LLM performance using a strong
open-source language model, achieving an F-score of 0.8. Using this automated
metric, we evaluate more than 1,500 answers from seven LLMs across all
WikiContradict instances. To facilitate future work, we release WikiContradict
on: https://ibm.biz/wikicontradict. | [
0.0659253523,
0.0458745137,
-0.0132398196,
0.0525739565,
-0.0552660041,
0.0005952808,
-0.0383245163,
0.0193296149,
0.034682285,
-0.0632268712,
0.0123086637,
-0.0328339152,
-0.0107218344,
-0.0254246201,
0.0353171825,
-0.0225378331,
0.0631094277,
0.002517943,
-0.0107099432,
-0.0312282871,
-0.0042842217,
0.0186074357,
-0.0256082732,
0.0139755867,
-0.011730006,
-0.0226542894,
-0.0100236852,
0.0049840556,
0.057636559,
-0.0083567621,
0.0409501866,
0.0582042783,
0.0058315289,
0.0515930243,
0.0000021592,
-0.0571195744,
0.0153901335,
-0.0070716608,
-0.0388801321,
0.0496456511,
-0.0168520696,
0.0277459621,
0.0167618152,
-0.0101477541,
-0.0415165499,
0.0078187743,
-0.0045266137,
0.0546960831,
0.0886572748,
0.080595687,
0.0331754535,
0.006504653,
0.015400935,
-0.0209827144,
0.0601317398,
-0.0253270306,
0.0259938911,
0.0022846248,
-0.0269353017,
0.0007230858,
0.0161813255,
0.0163884424,
0.0217963699,
-0.0023166107,
-0.0023551839,
-0.002417665,
-0.0813443363,
0.0078558959,
0.0048537748,
0.0649881586,
0.0527812988,
-0.0192754921,
-0.0004091724,
0.0060418169,
0.0212078411,
0.060678985,
-0.0093734497,
0.0159517266,
-0.0374476947,
-0.0124354018,
0.0019802311,
-0.0210751146,
0.0257985443,
0.0318881311,
-0.0026279353,
0.0939891934,
0.0296526216,
-0.0211903155,
0.0079584122,
0.0079985242,
-0.0345606506,
-0.0599012747,
-0.007160007,
0.0606659465,
-0.0467539914,
0.0128648262,
-0.0401037596,
-0.0175192505,
0.0781882256,
-0.062324103,
-0.0259829592,
0.0249295328,
-0.0263883974,
0.0186559316,
-0.002652477,
0.0401793718,
-0.0283827893,
0.0215122309,
-0.0139843784,
0.0145749329,
-0.020250449,
-0.0299541503,
0.0020180019,
0.0255649909,
-0.0445592292,
0.0224002339,
-0.0312507302,
-0.0011749605,
-0.0462675244,
0.0215982124,
-0.0084691728,
0.0214849524,
-0.0108791683,
-0.0050992607,
-0.0828464106,
0.0220488552,
-0.0380309448,
0.0381931923,
0.0031550233,
-0.0387553871,
-0.008573507,
0.0093725733,
-0.0142913377,
-0.0013137211,
0.0165271573,
0.0717464089,
-0.0062924763,
0.0419171564,
-0.0470260344,
-0.0565493107,
-0.008495722,
-0.0572647639,
-0.0101041058,
-0.0806028694,
0.0533483513,
0.0144780064,
-0.0405566692,
-0.0380274616,
0.0337369107,
0.0488120876,
-0.0191628542,
0.0380111635,
-0.0366161838,
0.0072594457,
0.0695668608,
0.0356768295,
-0.0248599648,
0.038525071,
0.0170032997,
-0.0036060545,
0.0611741841,
0.0423249789,
-0.0110462634,
0.0008627197,
0.0310765449,
0.0166773703,
0.0229529832,
0.049050536,
0.0006759663,
0.0291066281,
0.0024583747,
0.0680320933,
-0.0477537401,
-0.0593230873,
0.0331821479,
-0.0038337738,
-0.0020228371,
0.013368981,
0.0319568142,
0.0060435319,
0.0530622154,
0.0493979007,
-0.0267627947,
0.0010301508,
-0.067387864,
0.0048298454,
0.0321770422,
0.0478544533,
0.0023329756,
-0.0241255127,
-0.0133434441,
-0.0002607313,
-0.0058034579,
-0.0057416046,
-0.010017952,
-0.0030288,
-0.0421226472,
0.1034455821,
0.0221128631,
-0.0705732778,
0.0291614719,
-0.0241662171,
0.0348770991,
0.0485292599,
0.0565517582,
-0.0420584194,
-0.0348017924,
-0.0142851984,
0.0022196639,
0.0427680947,
0.0681552142,
-0.0426960886,
-0.0248197112,
-0.0316901505,
-0.0192129109,
-0.0418008789,
0.0098845661,
-0.0048156371,
0.0321709812,
0.0392941758,
0.0430136137,
-0.061344184,
-0.0100774122,
0.0428459756,
-0.0210379362,
-0.0077804341,
-0.0439689234,
-0.0016217029,
-0.0001454939,
0.0233958829,
-0.0173791796,
0.0294811763,
0.0344501138,
-0.0188932735,
-0.034094736,
0.0069026966,
-0.033395607,
-0.0240601916,
0.0549662523,
-0.02143161,
-0.0284859352,
0.0044019641,
-0.0398525745,
-0.012508885,
-0.017684849,
-0.0392550267,
0.01187253,
-0.0284289494,
0.0033202025,
-0.0044687702,
-0.0115994308,
-0.0405074507,
0.092450045,
-0.0276685506,
0.0329309739,
0.0495878607,
-0.0105645237,
0.0246388726,
-0.0085895425,
-0.0113024535,
0.0061387247,
-0.0001796368,
0.0346583202,
0.0201523714,
-0.0190582443,
-0.0753373802,
-0.022050323,
-0.0413969718,
0.0023988672,
-0.0333872214,
0.0315124504,
0.0269188546,
-0.063368842,
0.0036877317,
0.0236040279,
-0.0342646874,
0.0249995589,
0.0187142901,
0.018409742,
0.017509792,
0.0170738716,
0.04387822,
-0.0336784385,
0.0025737705,
-0.0203820989,
0.0253290776,
0.0161332544,
0.011779733,
-0.082073465,
0.0511355102,
-0.0791485459,
-0.0098278299,
-0.0132797901,
-0.0030598533,
0.0310239419,
0.0011418881,
0.047878094,
0.0035907966,
0.0468902513,
-0.0235195421,
0.0471859351,
-0.0458561257,
-0.068971321,
0.0019045704,
0.0073639303,
-0.0257491488,
-0.024177501,
-0.0576641858,
0.0134139564,
0.0042662169,
0.0077273841,
-0.0152572924,
-0.0477469452,
0.0505955704,
-0.0291216373,
-0.0313886516,
-0.0124908946,
-0.0585148782,
-0.0143160094,
0.059553843,
-0.0179742165,
-0.0201137289,
0.0804750472,
-0.0073891096,
0.0610256158,
-0.0404253975,
0.0533098057,
-0.0293463785,
0.0232726224,
-0.0276116207,
0.0075062099,
-0.006791967,
0.0239341576,
-0.0662286207,
0.0043485668,
0.0284602623,
-0.0790104792,
0.0476082824,
-0.0357692428,
0.0066299564,
-0.0172322281,
-0.0084405961,
-0.077472195,
-0.0494816862,
0.0230837148,
-0.0225200616,
-0.0146331107,
0.0084344614,
-0.00746678,
-0.0471974388,
0.0294076074,
-0.0147872558,
0.0060696499,
-0.0130319763,
0.0028150061,
0.031324137,
0.0647534803,
0.0376061797,
0.0735440031,
-0.0312193073,
-0.0150928041,
0.0599763468,
0.0347691365,
-0.0180005394,
0.0354131944,
-0.0365165807,
0.0081777833,
-0.0599461533,
0.0009476723,
0.011114764,
0.0460434966,
-0.0682384521,
-0.0030998301,
0.0664483979,
0.0346643813,
-0.0095725218,
-0.0080365976,
-0.0719350651,
0.0165989455,
0.0125854965,
0.023241872,
-0.0942566842,
-0.0010822535,
-0.0130342534,
0.0413723178,
-0.0203910246,
-0.0450540259,
0.0108163776,
-0.1275804341,
-0.0001439066,
0.0226780865,
-0.0056860456,
-0.0171293784,
-0.0033792139,
0.0045316541,
0.0183380041,
0.0194539521,
0.0534139574,
0.0178300776,
0.0134238219,
-0.0043979879,
0.0214055032,
-0.013694834,
0.0271627586,
-0.0095848041,
0.0335696675,
0.0224479679,
0.0229759123,
-0.0043016104,
-0.0708724186,
-0.0026930692,
-0.0360328108,
-0.0146527328,
0.0010329374,
0.0548273735,
0.0052969637,
0.0092496239,
-0.0410410613,
0.0188701414,
-0.0036043848,
-0.0642773658,
0.0192724261,
0.0567184873,
-0.006013731,
0.0041264957,
-0.0351463743,
0.0212033205,
0.0265620481,
0.0654030815,
0.0111866714,
0.0082604671,
-0.0212205332,
-0.0173060242,
0.0196291339,
-0.0397534445,
-0.036035303,
0.0300385207,
0.0532888025,
0.0455024615,
-0.101561442,
-0.0457078442,
-0.0423361212,
0.0027860785,
0.001732407,
0.014567378,
-0.0072689531,
-0.027362138,
-0.0519901551,
0.0253672935,
-0.0321762785,
0.0064273356,
0.0082400832,
0.029174231,
0.0002955218,
-0.0279324614,
-0.0081305364,
0.0402046815,
-0.0527031124,
-0.0769103691,
0.0160754658,
0.0562551282,
0.0234203096,
0.0354347974,
-0.0004416399,
-0.0098148035,
0.026230799,
0.0749645606,
-0.0332379192,
0.0451436304,
0.0064075594,
0.0412484407,
-0.0124639366,
0.0353928395,
-0.0624774545,
-0.0335793048,
-0.0104035884,
0.0551721007,
0.0063518058,
-0.0500472263,
0.0150287431,
0.015858572,
-0.0173585303,
0.0039479518,
-0.0072429697,
-0.0219191313,
0.0175129063,
-0.0247110166,
-0.0298750643,
0.0132638654,
-0.0149793653,
-0.0202299021,
-0.0498528332,
0.0068713967,
0.0123197669,
-0.0018874044,
0.0500106439,
-0.0347558968,
-0.0258926321,
0.0380537733,
0.0083165225,
0.0093330396,
-0.0286055952,
-0.029832717,
-0.0286451634,
-0.0152236708,
0.0678250045,
-0.0046019987,
0.0760817677,
0.0234738067,
-0.0271301307,
0.0134886624,
-0.0098744985,
-0.0668769702,
-0.0486769453,
-0.023001641,
0.0201445743,
0.0211060941,
0.0106244376,
0.0844546407,
-0.0046775374,
-0.0268277805,
-0.0123849995,
-0.0192507766,
0.0186984949,
-0.0051546623,
0.0385386422,
0.038722273,
-0.0235294309,
0.0536457747,
0.0544123128,
-0.053926032,
0.0578101873,
-0.028063735,
-0.0303845443,
-0.0176770817,
-0.0695236474,
-0.0478964746,
0.0061688148,
-0.0351145267,
-0.0324195586,
-0.0954049081,
-0.0518290624,
0.0274478421,
0.0490017086,
-0.0036013231,
-0.0047938856,
-0.0017817767,
0.0652934685,
0.0258951746,
-0.0211797468,
-0.0165923033,
0.064655073,
-0.0415738076,
0.0030931558,
-0.0189621225,
-6.437755708e-33,
-0.0350349657,
-0.0507743545,
0.014348262,
-0.0317660421,
-0.0464186333,
-0.0038405419,
-0.0134760141,
-0.0157740377,
-0.0486456491,
0.0100464784,
0.0147950212,
0.0003695646,
-0.0021564681,
-0.008824206,
-0.0033952091,
-0.0225094426,
0.0182270072,
0.031576287,
-0.0595125891,
0.0234605707,
0.0529022589,
-0.0132989278,
0.0398382545,
-0.0583625399,
0.0686821342,
-0.0601531528,
-0.0030179224,
0.0114881517,
-0.067622304,
0.0408042893,
-0.0217605419,
0.076288037,
0.0088171354,
-0.0182504728,
-0.0002442628,
-0.0167470165,
-0.0379374176,
-0.0472593158,
0.0246249717,
-0.0190022364,
-0.0471950956,
-0.0294558872,
0.0626580864,
0.0063695214,
-0.0162293073,
-0.016925294,
0.0266322494,
-0.0226501059,
0.0080187172,
-0.0034276149,
-0.07351695,
0.0189209729,
0.0100934431,
-0.000291778,
-0.0655171722,
0.0736502856,
0.0314131752,
0.000510991,
-0.1187326983,
0.0030142246,
0.0014007998,
0.0177052971,
0.0388615169,
-0.0665064603,
-0.0183262788,
0.0732695162,
0.0023871199,
0.0081346622,
-0.0292887688,
-0.0309296101,
-0.0239743609,
0.0454112776,
0.0617071204,
0.1266285926,
0.0166843496,
-0.0313409492,
-0.0952693298,
0.0303067677,
-0.0054367497,
0.0573021211,
0.0187251978,
-0.0272602942,
-0.012298,
0.0089893909,
-0.0666618049,
-0.0163898058,
-0.0435413569,
-0.0165136606,
0.0348174758,
0.0129696829,
-0.0303603224,
-0.0178468619,
-0.0007506668,
-0.0330310687,
0.002840491,
0.0252589192,
-0.0489408933,
-0.0118255801,
-0.0033912922,
0.0380666479,
-0.012092093,
0.0153307952,
0.0248715449,
-0.0016809216,
0.0318787284,
0.0109687615,
0.0272451136,
-0.0052365051,
-0.0323779806,
0.0280770417,
-0.0230950415,
0.0315401778,
-0.0253861919,
-0.0497206114,
0.0482111983,
0.0236318633,
-0.010031173,
-0.0097797066,
0.033653371,
0.000005594,
-0.0286990404,
-0.0537147708,
0.0112724546,
0.0202251188,
-0.0059228186,
0.0387006886,
0.0092992205,
0.0477541536,
-0.0171286035,
-0.0090843793,
-0.0059431889,
0.0184771921,
2.866e-7,
0.0348811261,
0.0264483597,
0.0285312179,
-0.002688061,
0.0193557795,
0.0227157958,
-0.0056818882,
0.0178986248,
0.0244484879,
-0.0645434931,
-0.0161235072,
0.0157592464,
0.0377465151,
0.0550960563,
-0.0289510321,
-0.0220367108,
-0.052239947,
-0.0202671494,
-0.0548457876,
-0.0230271667,
0.0909737945,
0.0073868716,
0.0147878136,
-0.0270320345,
-0.0344610661,
-0.0145396655,
0.0703666285,
-0.0034838098,
-0.0416578874,
0.0298637412,
0.0617104508,
0.0025973027,
0.0363043994,
0.036773324,
-0.0284864418,
-0.0029966887,
0.0005302213,
0.0393237025,
0.0007583196,
-0.0587241612,
-0.0210292581,
-0.0261524543,
0.0358743481,
-0.0678077713,
0.0617488138,
-0.0077084629,
-0.0056009684,
-0.0163063612,
-0.0448386595,
-0.0151428198,
0.0543192998,
-0.0211287513,
-0.0258873701,
0.0248240996,
-0.0151239932,
0.0651074275,
-0.0161389709,
-0.0449595563,
-0.0375802144,
0.0072181239,
-0.0472116396,
-0.056930691,
-0.0224971399,
-0.0035068325,
-0.0160748381,
-0.0646715388,
0.029245548,
2.63304352e-34,
0.0170203187,
-0.003381982,
0.0166416075,
0.0041624354,
0.0381901972,
0.020565372,
-0.0214330405,
0.0061066728,
-0.0116215888,
-0.0333059058,
-0.0104508027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13803v1 | Semantic Structure-Mapping in LLM and Human Analogical Reasoning | 2024-06-19T20:07:37 | 2024-06-19T20:07:37 | Sam Musker, Alex Duchnowski, Raphaël Millière, Ellie Pavlick | cs.CL | cs.CL | Analogical reasoning is considered core to human learning and cognition.
Recent studies have compared the analogical reasoning abilities of human
subjects and Large Language Models (LLMs) on abstract symbol manipulation
tasks, such as letter string analogies. However, these studies largely neglect
analogical reasoning over semantically meaningful symbols, such as natural
language words. This ability to draw analogies that link language to
non-linguistic domains, which we term semantic structure-mapping, is thought to
play a crucial role in language acquisition and broader cognitive development.
We test human subjects and LLMs on analogical reasoning tasks that require the
transfer of semantic structure and content from one domain to another. Advanced
LLMs match human performance across many task variations. However, humans and
LLMs respond differently to certain task variations and semantic distractors.
Overall, our data suggest that LLMs are approaching human-level performance on
these important cognitive tasks, but are not yet entirely human like. | [
0.0080238404,
0.0231245272,
-0.052015461,
0.0377113223,
-0.01670832,
0.044423487,
-0.0263662655,
0.0132063171,
-0.0232778676,
-0.0297103245,
-0.0557680354,
-0.0217280276,
0.0014899572,
-0.0358789191,
0.046510879,
-0.0446376204,
0.0374564789,
-0.0648412779,
-0.012269903,
0.0204019155,
-0.0506495237,
0.00766407,
-0.0030843329,
-0.0264089834,
0.0158370789,
-0.0137941809,
0.0214036983,
-0.030685015,
0.0038674728,
-0.0300386325,
-0.07484366,
0.0109542692,
0.0087764803,
-0.0102216629,
0.0000019453,
-0.0783888176,
0.0642619208,
-0.0064020548,
-0.0225386154,
0.0227760226,
0.0557904206,
-0.0025608609,
-0.0189692024,
-0.004073693,
-0.0087875472,
0.0042557139,
0.0544762872,
0.0221417919,
-0.0163365602,
0.0085777221,
-0.0060875574,
-0.0428480059,
0.019305503,
0.0013610685,
0.0408529602,
-0.0281266626,
0.0263569728,
0.0415578559,
0.0209571309,
-0.0047985846,
-0.0332789868,
0.0134146959,
0.0052479338,
0.0356362313,
-0.0171900038,
0.0475371256,
0.0344187841,
-0.0025380296,
0.0489368066,
0.032904882,
0.0057588359,
-0.0594171323,
-0.0046608243,
0.0121464003,
0.0200101044,
0.0698942617,
-0.0503950268,
0.0595997088,
0.0091092661,
0.0383859314,
0.0431369357,
-0.0485498011,
0.0246936269,
0.0438439287,
-0.0125931241,
0.0627289861,
-0.0112126321,
-0.0083719548,
0.053892497,
-0.0077861594,
-0.0000868109,
-0.0380634777,
-0.0028450785,
0.0086534712,
-0.005055889,
0.0460408032,
-0.0589158945,
-0.0219886787,
0.0009780414,
-0.0772497654,
0.0722489059,
0.0476399697,
-0.0011790062,
0.0343711562,
-0.1100582629,
0.0544548221,
-0.0392035693,
0.110713765,
-0.0438155383,
-0.0001130362,
-0.049846027,
-0.0454478301,
0.0072765145,
0.0396334752,
-0.0058111106,
-0.0112241944,
-0.0085693998,
0.0347833373,
-0.0013961885,
-0.0722887069,
-0.0373024754,
-0.0112652434,
-0.0036722275,
-0.0183678009,
-0.0974791944,
-0.0328656919,
-0.0309101678,
0.0737778321,
-0.0348972566,
-0.0174358487,
-0.0039869095,
0.0083060265,
-0.0245755799,
-0.0413220897,
0.0010211371,
0.0821112245,
-0.0301642139,
-0.0037566395,
-0.0453467406,
-0.0006287948,
0.0574057586,
-0.0217470061,
0.0530224591,
-0.0247240756,
-0.003499185,
0.0449433848,
-0.0115965353,
-0.068866536,
-0.0001739229,
0.0495173596,
-0.065187186,
0.0623961091,
0.0284691621,
0.0319813341,
-0.0013689963,
-0.0094460165,
-0.0360160545,
0.0100631258,
0.0254631788,
-0.0040452983,
-0.0394740365,
-0.0087404074,
-0.0541000813,
-0.011510713,
-0.036310032,
-0.0268184841,
-0.0390979648,
-0.0240490064,
-0.0073790108,
0.0603471212,
0.0801448822,
0.072902292,
-0.0092257392,
-0.0682439506,
0.0596450903,
0.0640213639,
0.0378163531,
0.012609303,
0.0112587987,
-0.0053895982,
0.0079295738,
-0.0067557357,
-0.0844955519,
0.0433830768,
-0.0075223874,
0.017655028,
-0.0276331101,
0.027430119,
-0.011259268,
0.0201938841,
-0.0409599319,
0.0148299867,
0.0005165673,
-0.020828994,
0.0285798851,
0.0300287977,
-0.0295672491,
0.0413794369,
0.020328436,
0.0000054663,
0.0213767961,
-0.0426755659,
0.01575277,
0.0160647593,
-0.0203123502,
0.0081151724,
0.0016453924,
0.0116126388,
0.027414754,
0.0602447726,
0.0151818609,
0.0085927527,
-0.0301420689,
0.0054785111,
0.0170592219,
-0.0144289872,
-0.018033307,
-0.0079609379,
-0.0440053307,
-0.003765722,
-0.0045676995,
-0.0729831308,
-0.0110609839,
0.0799090415,
-0.0640900135,
-0.0253114831,
-0.0542336516,
0.0277903508,
0.0081219599,
-0.0372345187,
0.0075397231,
0.0533310845,
-0.0130492682,
-0.032091938,
-0.0157595854,
0.0320374556,
-0.0486696362,
0.0159199573,
0.0161218569,
-0.0717560202,
-0.0164446738,
0.0352115557,
0.0273950696,
-0.01092239,
0.0456484817,
-0.0357012004,
0.0822190642,
-0.0018010369,
0.0268655326,
-0.0042912452,
0.0053090099,
-0.0087076621,
0.079647541,
0.0143659255,
0.0082305158,
0.0076839342,
0.0391800813,
-0.029684823,
0.0241633952,
0.0150290895,
-0.0087275691,
-0.0033539794,
-0.0471370406,
-0.0538871549,
-0.0499724336,
-0.0844663605,
0.0088270092,
0.0006221741,
0.0023829835,
0.0549833104,
0.0404090099,
0.0507087074,
-0.0446047597,
-0.0124959648,
0.0047886791,
0.018308891,
0.0051511214,
-0.0546475016,
0.0597111769,
0.0370250195,
-0.0365715735,
-0.012724285,
-0.0218456518,
0.0143018886,
-0.0608464815,
0.0413068943,
0.0200150441,
-0.0083773416,
-0.0449980274,
0.0501983352,
-0.0118455794,
-0.0100063141,
0.0042357724,
-0.0019155791,
0.0413626917,
0.0236321222,
0.0567313395,
0.0814001709,
0.0087831803,
0.0118841995,
0.077800326,
-0.0002832982,
-0.0394696295,
-0.0307416636,
0.016785847,
0.0120053841,
-0.0244595427,
-0.0386990942,
-0.0103332773,
0.0885580927,
0.0074116234,
0.0092814108,
-0.0190402381,
0.0641316175,
-0.018960841,
-0.0033806285,
-0.0240109134,
-0.039134305,
-0.0761227757,
0.024576813,
-0.0382461213,
-0.0068333279,
0.0354870632,
0.0088409651,
0.0193616338,
-0.0054256567,
0.0186153036,
0.0003489378,
0.0581177473,
-0.0201414209,
0.0127507392,
0.0040842998,
-0.0232597739,
-0.0632425845,
0.0031592033,
0.01266832,
-0.0070904908,
0.0516543128,
-0.0593215935,
0.0100602759,
0.0034333095,
-0.005133043,
-0.0161159392,
0.0477801859,
-0.056760516,
0.0240868628,
-0.025745891,
0.036340937,
-0.0662692338,
-0.0051145302,
0.0258131288,
-0.0143852532,
0.0269133076,
-0.0200946983,
0.0008216546,
-0.003071791,
0.018284902,
0.0074667335,
0.0052900799,
-0.0396748148,
0.0218787901,
0.0301138591,
-0.0156646241,
-0.0007229769,
-0.0096096722,
0.0287073925,
0.0339641869,
-0.0390189141,
-0.0208601169,
0.0285880733,
0.0123270582,
-0.0222362615,
-0.0065935184,
0.0523924194,
0.0488555729,
0.0085350918,
0.0494429171,
-0.0395449512,
0.0033267639,
0.0529724993,
-0.0024468999,
-0.0449151099,
-0.0374910757,
0.0366074108,
-0.0519276299,
-0.0045624198,
-0.045346465,
0.0116574382,
-0.0807131901,
-0.0065641971,
-0.0065340288,
-0.1074081138,
-0.021297954,
-0.0160577465,
0.0662006587,
0.0332526825,
-0.0009555528,
0.0071604559,
-0.0434956439,
0.0007326867,
0.0263474043,
0.0291351452,
-0.0181545969,
-0.0025761491,
-0.0315307826,
0.0479350649,
0.0095640868,
0.0127106681,
-0.014318727,
-0.0407274701,
0.0644916371,
0.0313991569,
0.0231403019,
-0.0018602019,
-0.0045152511,
0.0314284973,
0.0166256372,
-0.0458664745,
0.0261096507,
-0.0389976278,
-0.0743098482,
-0.0239564721,
0.0943639055,
0.0071653235,
-0.0429904386,
-0.015554809,
0.0109647652,
-0.0980205312,
0.0710884631,
0.0427218527,
-0.0353915542,
0.0144240698,
0.0074565187,
-0.0280664228,
0.0049075172,
-0.0703698695,
0.0381579734,
-0.0376519896,
0.0248534456,
-0.084238857,
-0.010985706,
0.0233427696,
-0.0155370384,
0.0103126178,
-0.0021430552,
0.0254601575,
-0.0707303435,
-0.0191747434,
0.0251520406,
-0.043661017,
0.0340745933,
-0.0087606646,
-0.0364052653,
0.0316538587,
-0.0656104311,
-0.0325881988,
0.0103658391,
-0.0328505524,
-0.0340039358,
0.0344898552,
-0.0271735638,
0.019960044,
-0.0138455601,
0.0241071749,
-0.0269233342,
-0.0154954605,
0.010161696,
0.0145175811,
0.0422441363,
-0.065954864,
0.0064620441,
0.0303481668,
0.0088124042,
-0.0154982619,
0.0109717241,
0.0461415499,
0.0199449863,
0.0117984843,
0.0268682465,
0.0288887937,
0.0262994003,
0.0353176929,
0.0318550356,
-0.0178581271,
-0.0427153148,
-0.023344256,
0.0130771613,
0.0017105368,
0.0274778064,
-0.0520276837,
0.0367130972,
0.0480673462,
-0.0072907386,
-0.080625914,
0.0070645371,
0.0524409078,
0.0405645072,
0.0207030121,
-0.0101755494,
0.0466488898,
0.0068378202,
0.0504087321,
0.0337169804,
0.0112825343,
-0.0278255846,
0.0635903031,
-0.0110524539,
0.0300663542,
0.0078907628,
0.0018516358,
-0.0197478905,
-0.0270852521,
-0.0427917689,
-0.0590091422,
-0.0160622802,
-0.0062774424,
0.0048101889,
-0.0591943823,
-0.0008308782,
-0.0680122524,
0.0268463921,
0.0082502337,
-0.0381208919,
-0.0309374668,
-0.0040449174,
0.0600273423,
0.0336737894,
0.0330027901,
-0.0174376648,
0.014659537,
-0.0401888676,
0.0385766029,
-0.0319457166,
-0.033291813,
-0.002263699,
-0.0107983407,
0.0245301053,
-0.0014870407,
-0.0153831039,
-0.0018975604,
-0.0461132601,
-0.0692004561,
-0.0001303149,
0.015264214,
0.0226057991,
-0.0291931871,
0.0445708036,
0.0311479382,
-0.0097983088,
-0.0196828414,
0.0072124847,
0.0139049916,
-0.0117911343,
-0.0047592469,
-0.0271861292,
-6.202723694e-33,
-0.0367997698,
-0.0031650993,
0.0126736052,
-0.0089778472,
-0.0330703408,
-0.0285589844,
-0.0406688116,
0.0268209763,
-0.0328582935,
0.0249633212,
0.0216792468,
-0.0161488019,
0.005969319,
-0.0256708991,
0.0149232196,
-0.0234479364,
-0.0127436677,
-0.011720065,
-0.0042290539,
-0.0657604262,
0.0102796517,
-0.021965038,
0.0500098579,
-0.0544390492,
0.0005703814,
0.0415151678,
0.0571320057,
-0.0090526491,
-0.0070811571,
0.0409814827,
-0.0045472812,
0.0502987728,
0.0569293797,
0.0046428791,
-0.0186170675,
0.0281733423,
-0.0357116498,
-0.0451520681,
0.0902969092,
-0.0009637523,
0.0003098278,
-0.0296316426,
0.0923129097,
-0.0007149224,
-0.0180987474,
-0.0166832972,
0.0450054742,
-0.0282385591,
-0.0099275233,
0.0178619325,
-0.1056406498,
-0.0271369163,
0.0041582379,
0.012064537,
-0.0104385773,
-0.0053867809,
-0.0485176481,
0.0397026204,
-0.0401940607,
0.0396844149,
-0.0243002549,
0.001658375,
0.0425959751,
0.0385270901,
0.0035672607,
0.0564712435,
0.0375208408,
0.0037782099,
-0.0123885684,
-0.003686032,
0.0599352047,
0.0362965055,
0.0072196694,
0.0145958252,
0.0576356128,
-0.0131323058,
0.0040536346,
-0.0280617345,
0.0132332668,
0.0701912418,
0.026923947,
0.0457722545,
0.024292184,
0.0065627256,
-0.0447387248,
0.0151882293,
-0.0532931983,
-0.040371716,
0.0359557755,
-0.0593997948,
0.0256783161,
0.0116577549,
0.005275209,
-0.0115964729,
-0.005444339,
-0.0787603632,
0.0166264623,
0.0197070614,
-0.043998491,
-0.0364743769,
-0.0662834048,
-0.0640287548,
0.0119138146,
0.0008524634,
0.0488005094,
0.0174822006,
-0.0103575354,
-0.0371184163,
-0.0484410524,
-0.0348023996,
-0.0610416718,
-0.0807243809,
0.0375473686,
-0.043529544,
0.038480673,
0.0069858064,
-0.0116399983,
-0.0081174271,
-0.0038549004,
-0.0529323481,
-0.0305746049,
0.0177619923,
-0.0719987899,
-0.0022453011,
-0.0196702648,
-0.0013704711,
-0.0404929258,
0.0180200376,
0.0543117858,
-0.0630587563,
-0.0195376612,
0.030066235,
2.902e-7,
0.0631035492,
0.0797766671,
-0.0238290001,
0.0269352123,
-0.0063706264,
-0.0156200714,
-0.0036042256,
-0.016579045,
0.0584637038,
0.0126709575,
-0.0301729236,
0.0342733264,
0.0129040144,
0.0096267713,
-0.0710681304,
0.0279294886,
-0.0245434456,
0.016156584,
-0.0139553137,
0.0175749864,
0.050006602,
0.0272186771,
0.0163777824,
-0.0258622337,
-0.0041381032,
-0.0464219078,
0.0221974887,
-0.0647869334,
0.0531714521,
-0.042133633,
-0.0411949269,
0.0058045709,
0.018090833,
0.0791221857,
0.0139108431,
0.002746379,
0.0399322174,
-0.0062248888,
0.0093427915,
0.0307411123,
-0.0318207964,
-0.0123869991,
0.0031325491,
-0.0484499224,
0.0444332734,
-0.0776088089,
-0.0260642096,
0.0271523949,
-0.0313936844,
0.0305811781,
-0.020495683,
0.0294225775,
-0.020504348,
0.001711428,
0.0356668644,
0.0197312329,
-0.0242280122,
-0.0523739867,
-0.0097661046,
0.0237426125,
-0.0441883504,
-0.0030245674,
-0.0371442512,
0.0022620913,
0.0373639539,
-0.0289890617,
-0.0350197665,
1.717959509e-34,
-0.0257609598,
0.014535863,
0.0536395982,
0.0312071554,
0.040887434,
0.0105877565,
0.0243611671,
0.0381811261,
0.0172051229,
-0.0696636811,
0.0124103473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13791v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13791v2 | IoT-Based Preventive Mental Health Using Knowledge Graphs and Standards for Better Well-Being | 2024-06-19T19:35:14 | 2024-06-29T15:29:56 | Amelie Gyrard, Seyedali Mohammadi, Manas Gaur, Antonio Kung | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) give the UN a road map for development
with Agenda 2030 as a target. SDG3 "Good Health and Well-Being" ensures healthy
lives and promotes well-being for all ages. Digital technologies can support
SDG3. Burnout and even depression could be reduced by encouraging better
preventive health. Due to the lack of patient knowledge and focus to take care
of their health, it is necessary to help patients before it is too late. New
trends such as positive psychology and mindfulness are highly encouraged in the
USA. Digital Twin (DT) can help with the continuous monitoring of emotion using
physiological signals (e.g., collected via wearables). Digital twins facilitate
monitoring and provide constant health insight to improve quality of life and
well-being with better personalization. Healthcare DT challenges are
standardizing data formats, communication protocols, and data exchange
mechanisms. To achieve those data integration and knowledge challenges, we
designed the Mental Health Knowledge Graph (ontology and dataset) to boost
mental health. The Knowledge Graph (KG) acquires knowledge from ontology-based
mental health projects classified within the LOV4IoT ontology catalog (Emotion,
Depression, and Mental Health). Furthermore, the KG is mapped to standards
(e.g., ontologies) when possible. Standards from ETSI SmartM2M, ITU/WHO, ISO,
W3C, NIST, and IEEE are relevant to mental health. | [
0.0013625683,
0.0244728699,
-0.0311887804,
-0.0485687554,
-0.0010842991,
-0.0035985948,
0.0214477628,
0.02631725,
0.1014675945,
0.0093126036,
0.0482345074,
0.044566378,
-0.0060342066,
0.0434637219,
-0.0119130109,
-0.040261846,
0.0185167175,
0.0608716272,
0.0136474064,
0.0089587215,
0.0064539923,
0.0168532357,
-0.021032393,
-0.0010743269,
-0.0343881138,
-0.0143583948,
0.0361986496,
0.0377142429,
0.0409866385,
-0.1088960916,
-0.0115566365,
0.0035386658,
-0.047959283,
0.009696912,
0.0000024755,
-0.0175267458,
-0.0385245606,
0.0354979858,
-0.0226726513,
-0.1055347696,
0.0400332585,
-0.0745537952,
0.0310577881,
0.0234794542,
-0.0253303498,
-0.0268102027,
0.0445563272,
0.0643656552,
0.0153930811,
0.0107043236,
-0.032961566,
0.0504011251,
0.0293371063,
0.0018176794,
0.0074289157,
0.0623660013,
0.0149389608,
0.0442139693,
0.0520400293,
-0.0385741629,
0.0171713438,
0.0162705015,
-0.0513874888,
0.096968323,
0.0239043999,
-0.0122039234,
-0.0095361331,
-0.0166631769,
-0.0132401101,
0.0565784574,
0.0745414495,
0.0235798638,
0.0727779046,
-0.0027728942,
-0.0153195644,
-0.0130483247,
-0.0116939079,
-0.0521119088,
-0.0129252076,
0.0382726416,
0.0119344899,
0.0212849025,
0.0260335393,
-0.0096702203,
0.0349373221,
0.0865128115,
-0.0083983243,
-0.0238516089,
0.0132244946,
-0.0241604336,
-0.031905584,
-0.0090472056,
-0.0028492091,
0.0078263944,
-0.0133634303,
-0.0269580819,
-0.0349083319,
-0.0729033425,
0.0072582136,
0.0128506524,
-0.0057181204,
0.0356149934,
-0.0118789701,
-0.022243062,
0.0835157335,
-0.0240384918,
-0.0083796745,
-0.0102895256,
-0.0460986309,
-0.013940094,
-0.0691461712,
0.0290768538,
0.0114241438,
0.0219831374,
0.0177846085,
-0.0311198942,
-0.0673947558,
0.0120694861,
-0.0519237891,
-0.0148268174,
0.0110641811,
0.004275661,
0.0566402562,
0.0033706874,
0.0300839599,
0.0305324327,
0.0001635692,
-0.0161384027,
-0.0106614856,
-0.045521073,
0.0414124839,
-0.0278680976,
0.0148669099,
-0.0169271696,
0.0269451272,
0.0426034816,
0.0767681003,
-0.0141073056,
-0.0294899419,
-0.0427845046,
0.0208527818,
0.0031967808,
0.0303630177,
-0.0128158815,
0.0221938025,
-0.0188706275,
0.0409799777,
-0.0498510376,
0.0272533763,
-0.0235063359,
-0.0640922934,
0.0309926532,
-0.1267739832,
-0.010656653,
0.0082700998,
0.0450542793,
0.0013535193,
0.0014497931,
0.0024750922,
-0.053930521,
0.067542918,
-0.0264336467,
-0.0418228097,
-0.0067136879,
0.0496395342,
-0.0681515634,
0.0718140304,
-0.0284491982,
-0.0340087451,
0.0345045552,
-0.0743819922,
0.0043571517,
-0.0045598848,
0.0792301446,
0.0734144896,
0.0144993505,
0.0532412827,
0.0220225863,
-0.098434113,
0.040745303,
-0.0290061571,
-0.0651286095,
-0.0348969288,
0.0523245446,
-0.005371612,
-0.0074087065,
-0.0134290224,
-0.0263122208,
-0.0329028554,
-0.0419558026,
-0.0468917117,
-0.0462290235,
0.0162241254,
-0.008861661,
-0.0096920449,
-0.0619770661,
0.0490487739,
0.0482763685,
0.0274684988,
-0.0126481326,
-0.022197308,
-0.0315456167,
0.0210108869,
0.0557125956,
0.0051734322,
-0.0299791452,
-0.0520115234,
0.0023266643,
-0.0212178789,
-0.0212130286,
0.0209785961,
0.0066571068,
0.0050367555,
-0.0258107353,
0.0002398918,
0.0348698534,
0.0089085856,
-0.0073950822,
-0.0247896854,
0.0899453908,
-0.027789155,
-0.0024202208,
0.0223905258,
-0.0012249657,
-0.0255155154,
0.0258776583,
0.0003354722,
0.0076623643,
0.0756568685,
0.0625253618,
0.0226539876,
0.0166558065,
0.0355465002,
-0.0335999168,
-0.0284012612,
0.0464129373,
0.0198675748,
0.0640534312,
0.0251937807,
-0.0105872564,
0.0519516878,
0.0586496666,
-0.0106916064,
-0.0169493388,
-0.002974059,
0.0121686039,
0.0267253816,
0.0256279465,
-0.0390165113,
0.0246174969,
0.0437793285,
0.0306390952,
-0.028250441,
-0.0130726919,
-0.0238230955,
-0.0316110887,
-0.0757672191,
0.0155776059,
-0.0131316772,
-0.0047055939,
-0.0304871351,
-0.0276645683,
0.033063639,
-0.0201081876,
0.0065706754,
-0.052119568,
0.0427335426,
-0.1193661094,
0.0209298339,
0.0151415756,
0.0132077467,
0.0007823862,
0.0152002582,
-0.0217895042,
-0.0287919659,
-0.0379537679,
0.0575455576,
0.0571318865,
0.0035162615,
-0.0055539184,
0.0108104488,
0.0353249721,
0.0160570946,
0.012274839,
-0.0359328687,
-0.0157898832,
-0.0295814965,
-0.0029464832,
0.0147890057,
-0.0192054678,
-0.0666947961,
0.0067652995,
0.0050066514,
-0.0004281561,
0.0219913162,
0.0046278057,
0.0042982614,
0.0084662559,
-0.0403894186,
0.0104449326,
0.0182328634,
-0.0379098244,
0.0184174925,
0.0045351181,
0.0024519651,
0.0359940603,
-0.0069212196,
-0.0004932217,
-0.0399348997,
0.0068926443,
0.0210603867,
-0.0057393219,
0.00271205,
0.0014713248,
0.0002275547,
0.0393556617,
-0.0056891069,
0.0340909548,
0.0146484105,
0.0129055968,
0.0052819191,
-0.0361770876,
-0.0321468338,
0.026136348,
0.0384926051,
-0.0282070749,
-0.0119805941,
0.0005719222,
0.0499383584,
-0.0298845172,
0.0031156177,
0.0105302911,
0.0244535822,
0.0263396241,
-0.0795475468,
-0.0529488884,
-0.0508054644,
-0.0537297651,
-0.0711027458,
-0.0214053448,
-0.0132259792,
-0.0117790196,
-0.0057954579,
0.0906977504,
-0.0863084197,
0.004421989,
-0.0492992736,
0.0276485011,
-0.009856835,
-0.0306678284,
0.0094360057,
0.0239197146,
0.0403905027,
-0.0138198733,
0.0285492484,
-0.0047400668,
0.0484949052,
0.0048646573,
0.020821102,
0.0665350929,
0.0019344374,
0.0316702947,
-0.016642902,
0.0247882642,
0.0206664037,
-0.0070076613,
-0.0036852243,
-0.000481946,
-0.039074678,
-0.0041188481,
0.0238316078,
0.0121250339,
0.0488701463,
0.0811537132,
-0.0148770083,
-0.0059775822,
0.030928351,
-0.0271904059,
-0.0976502225,
-0.0186071247,
-0.0417163111,
-0.0587191693,
-0.0167789329,
-0.0345492586,
0.0487828329,
-0.0390660055,
-0.0176411755,
0.0086326767,
0.0284294672,
0.0018033907,
0.0237615742,
-0.0084076626,
-0.0200230144,
0.0353799015,
0.0270725023,
-0.0054698102,
-0.0251165032,
-0.0822208524,
0.0081442352,
0.0104658715,
-0.0023870354,
-0.0689365938,
0.0031378339,
0.0381233431,
-0.0103170527,
0.0748731121,
-0.0011113089,
0.1000598967,
0.0218682662,
-0.0209676661,
-0.0503909476,
0.0212728977,
0.0076145665,
-0.0490165055,
0.0272331256,
0.0083165439,
0.0130605493,
-0.0733702034,
0.0700060204,
-0.0630270764,
-0.0171727464,
-0.0009093613,
0.0315319076,
-0.0204533115,
-0.0380581357,
-0.051130563,
0.0108462656,
0.0208703391,
0.0094840182,
-0.0461229458,
-0.0021013042,
0.0298111401,
0.0343608335,
0.0664334074,
0.0244567152,
-0.0143435169,
0.0380555205,
-0.0324331038,
-0.046197366,
-0.0261201244,
-0.0371071883,
-0.015429128,
0.0065739467,
0.0129030496,
-0.0206986852,
0.0850513503,
0.015110842,
-0.0772175193,
0.001457358,
0.0138636902,
0.012749128,
-0.0079047335,
-0.0223798826,
-0.009589863,
-0.0004186138,
0.0032341536,
0.0487816408,
-0.0333578177,
0.0288619511,
0.0407840237,
0.0298205651,
0.0178342313,
-0.0030177422,
0.0160881355,
0.0260550715,
0.0114432694,
0.0530231185,
-0.0659267306,
-0.0237559322,
0.0059220144,
0.050172016,
-0.0200862773,
0.0114785843,
0.0176129155,
0.0158071127,
0.0203793608,
-0.0055985707,
-0.0184501726,
0.0096112769,
-0.01023704,
0.0793459862,
0.0282260142,
0.0036201128,
0.0101282001,
0.0143449325,
-0.0201135855,
-0.0120246243,
0.0189089831,
-0.0389989316,
-0.0369827002,
-0.0361127183,
0.0164007246,
-0.0364841707,
-0.0103041064,
0.0199460983,
-0.0690955222,
-0.0566505753,
0.0053759413,
-0.0438803397,
0.0483205244,
-0.0140566481,
-0.0225921404,
0.0131011438,
0.0350245908,
-0.0166636761,
0.0089603802,
-0.0421262346,
0.0477026626,
-0.022564752,
-0.0127975363,
0.0238708146,
0.067528367,
0.0062058717,
-0.0757015571,
0.0241764877,
-0.0312822871,
0.0329218246,
0.038111683,
0.0586799197,
-0.0568900332,
-0.0046447371,
-0.0282138884,
0.011726276,
-0.0590933077,
0.0291173737,
-0.0103632575,
-0.0321145169,
-0.0251715332,
-0.0389462374,
0.0193339679,
-0.0464275368,
0.0034636322,
0.0242232475,
-0.0285689663,
-0.0377352536,
0.0612278841,
0.0610209666,
0.0306163356,
-0.0473381877,
0.0080334842,
-0.0235958751,
-0.0488893837,
0.1082941368,
-0.0098508867,
-0.0337002128,
-0.0385506302,
0.0398314893,
-0.020798333,
0.0026849753,
-0.0495396927,
-0.0041551557,
-0.002925718,
-0.1065767556,
-0.0049104849,
0.0139464047,
-6.492281014e-33,
0.0204171855,
0.0235312358,
-0.0051542092,
0.0361461341,
-0.0521882996,
0.0094579104,
0.0063645211,
0.0139591601,
-0.0144719901,
0.0216280185,
0.0275336448,
0.0395484418,
-0.0018854073,
0.0116270529,
0.0178575069,
-0.0405619256,
-0.0099577606,
0.011264394,
0.0137188854,
-0.0022742534,
0.0080335541,
0.044446025,
0.0612673126,
-0.0808504149,
0.0013447811,
0.0222434532,
-0.0079769809,
-0.0035884827,
0.0080136592,
0.013823892,
-0.0220473912,
0.0651927888,
0.0309567563,
0.0517894067,
0.0235400703,
0.0207334999,
-0.0741519108,
-0.0786454082,
-0.007279817,
-0.0166773219,
-0.0198537,
-0.0255239047,
0.0064507737,
-0.0060526012,
-0.0072118514,
-0.0362649299,
0.0078746155,
-0.0365549102,
-0.0152959311,
-0.0228530951,
0.0366565287,
-0.0042540967,
0.0110467952,
0.0085260523,
-0.0239390563,
-0.0379803255,
-0.0451929532,
-0.0148428669,
-0.120903261,
0.0207554884,
-0.041424498,
-0.0179201048,
-0.0131979808,
-0.0840661749,
0.0404344425,
0.0197053049,
-0.0415167846,
-0.0449563302,
0.0149617214,
0.0539545417,
-0.0070931483,
0.0664134845,
0.0190698467,
-0.0040580044,
-0.0039476329,
-0.0882937014,
-0.0714728832,
0.0326637402,
0.0111961756,
-0.0275608078,
-0.0166507456,
0.0185989104,
0.0120512722,
0.0113475565,
0.0254858844,
-0.0194542333,
-0.026268851,
-0.0259624645,
-0.015238964,
-0.0261368062,
0.0186760463,
0.050788451,
-0.039496731,
-0.040799994,
0.0266753156,
-0.0304338578,
0.0660682917,
-0.0063624699,
-0.0004429287,
-0.0409824364,
-0.0190556739,
-0.029613398,
-0.0151406182,
0.0630740598,
0.0519850664,
0.0028753451,
0.0027293137,
-0.0020271365,
-0.0120521281,
-0.0125910062,
0.0331461467,
0.0336298347,
-0.0044813617,
-0.0789180994,
-0.0026464062,
0.0002003142,
0.0414876752,
0.0275621042,
0.0358152054,
0.006833388,
-0.0760035887,
0.0276954211,
0.010896367,
-0.0095593873,
0.0259575192,
-0.0045324839,
-0.0757146701,
-0.0527833514,
0.0099976473,
-0.0050146976,
-0.0139241302,
-0.0139458375,
3.317e-7,
-0.0293896217,
0.0404377617,
-0.0030290731,
-0.0014047212,
0.0416351408,
0.0133995973,
0.0001955446,
0.0218597632,
-0.0304092932,
-0.0147095323,
0.0320101082,
0.0024735173,
0.0455371588,
0.034857247,
0.0419959351,
-0.0517665595,
0.0477801897,
-0.0351802669,
-0.0093047731,
0.0365518369,
0.0715156645,
-0.0009065948,
0.0303313117,
0.005547022,
0.0242173113,
0.0286281761,
-0.0074858591,
-0.0304380395,
0.0426152572,
-0.0106764836,
0.0268944837,
-0.0263457019,
-0.0200627409,
0.0030828388,
0.0124143353,
-0.0490118861,
0.0006620768,
0.024957303,
-0.0421711281,
0.044487264,
-0.0087610716,
-0.0130909095,
-0.0126935234,
-0.0033308628,
0.0729232579,
-0.0510297604,
-0.0819877759,
0.0008292917,
-0.0444983765,
-0.0243533179,
0.0053646136,
0.0052272887,
-0.0158574916,
0.011458057,
0.0351051502,
0.038734924,
0.0113804704,
-0.0044961404,
0.0176102035,
0.022118967,
-0.006563311,
-0.058763735,
-0.013987164,
-0.0106333327,
0.0063081193,
-0.0541684702,
-0.0089321313,
2.42542229e-34,
-0.0127027892,
0.0416044965,
-0.02650184,
-0.0701939911,
-0.0017182056,
-0.0155199617,
-0.0310293138,
-0.0037088993,
-0.029389061,
-0.034480527,
-0.009381853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13781v1 | A Primal-Dual Framework for Transformers and Neural Networks | 2024-06-19T19:11:22 | 2024-06-19T19:11:22 | Tan M. Nguyen, Tam Nguyen, Nhat Ho, Andrea L. Bertozzi, Richard G. Baraniuk, Stanley J. Osher | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Self-attention is key to the remarkable success of transformers in sequence
modeling tasks including many applications in natural language processing and
computer vision. Like neural network layers, these attention mechanisms are
often developed by heuristics and experience. To provide a principled framework
for constructing attention layers in transformers, we show that the
self-attention corresponds to the support vector expansion derived from a
support vector regression problem, whose primal formulation has the form of a
neural network layer. Using our framework, we derive popular attention layers
used in practice and propose two new attentions: 1) the Batch Normalized
Attention (Attention-BN) derived from the batch normalization layer and 2) the
Attention with Scaled Head (Attention-SH) derived from using less training data
to fit the SVR model. We empirically demonstrate the advantages of the
Attention-BN and Attention-SH in reducing head redundancy, increasing the
model's accuracy, and improving the model's efficiency in a variety of
practical applications including image and time-series classification. | [
0.0196881872,
0.0317265019,
-0.0096325045,
0.0205405969,
-0.0064996607,
0.0101023,
0.0287562665,
-0.031089941,
-0.0424840637,
-0.0016010882,
-0.0010537542,
-0.063527666,
0.014022694,
0.0089536151,
0.0435671583,
-0.0465775914,
0.0273780096,
-0.0011610639,
-0.0005488144,
0.0108827855,
0.0051236814,
-0.0442138053,
0.0431644022,
0.0605472066,
-0.0356412679,
0.0102022449,
-0.0170570686,
-0.0259999093,
0.0494487807,
-0.0191512909,
0.001707974,
0.0308648478,
0.0502509922,
0.0464305878,
0.0000018371,
-0.0008776613,
0.0125104459,
0.0104515953,
-0.0072622811,
-0.0060934275,
-0.0213422664,
-0.0394122526,
0.0096506048,
0.0212284606,
-0.0324094258,
0.0275512822,
0.0788197815,
0.0816427693,
0.0576251037,
0.0532790273,
-0.0083142966,
-0.0609354153,
-0.0050132712,
-0.0573137514,
-0.0049223378,
0.0317511149,
0.0013174035,
-0.0691036284,
-0.0259306896,
-0.0167920459,
-0.0210995153,
0.0667340159,
0.0187782329,
-0.004094223,
0.0518089719,
0.0347145163,
-0.0583708547,
-0.0050131963,
-0.0124910213,
0.0156704634,
-0.0447862819,
-0.0103967339,
0.0042721932,
0.0059425533,
-0.0340688378,
0.0040606651,
-0.0541687943,
0.0071704248,
0.0169664547,
0.0221521966,
0.0071421536,
0.00011067,
0.0070392257,
-0.0527142696,
0.0057801795,
0.0317407995,
-0.0178863928,
-0.0335075408,
-0.036567945,
0.027807232,
-0.0338083059,
0.0061015682,
0.0242936704,
0.0735692307,
0.0085513759,
-0.004986912,
-0.0411166325,
-0.0830193684,
-0.0011723328,
-0.0516593307,
0.0847762674,
0.0143575929,
-0.0303291064,
0.0063174348,
0.0052659856,
0.0682917163,
-0.0295413751,
0.0070714192,
-0.0259813964,
0.0449367948,
-0.0276736598,
0.0126614403,
-0.0456283875,
0.0205540974,
0.0009653135,
-0.0258341711,
-0.0537964404,
0.0134634227,
0.0260209963,
-0.0311614741,
0.0331335962,
0.0137418024,
-0.055046998,
0.0335609801,
0.0349329449,
0.0586186536,
0.0016345582,
0.0089643076,
-0.0261430163,
-0.030484939,
-0.0713623911,
0.0381101593,
0.0117033776,
0.0060784929,
-0.0203855578,
0.0680993795,
-0.0093280263,
-0.0476145111,
-0.0401387438,
-0.0094028143,
-0.0401273072,
-0.0341515541,
0.0167373475,
-0.0214396268,
0.0024392004,
-0.0084171733,
-0.0048610512,
0.0128147416,
0.0107160378,
0.0179407485,
0.0010906418,
0.0278904326,
0.0264676344,
-0.018030379,
0.0088848779,
-0.0189686045,
-0.0012773875,
0.0069935885,
0.0239898823,
0.0102648698,
-0.0140375942,
-0.0683184117,
0.0353053845,
0.0280300714,
0.0154681429,
-0.0291202385,
-0.0286859181,
-0.025841115,
-0.0344104469,
-0.0251851007,
0.0202515721,
0.0337827466,
0.0028127704,
-0.0305279139,
0.0604073182,
0.0476166904,
0.0339685977,
0.0719957128,
0.0552107058,
0.0212636273,
-0.0200172774,
0.0276324823,
-0.0610601492,
0.0703904256,
-0.0249020513,
0.0060184142,
-0.0730957463,
0.0085487049,
-0.0512215011,
-0.0262268726,
-0.0014041488,
0.0209652036,
-0.022750482,
0.0134339202,
0.0644532815,
-0.0232128967,
-0.0417449847,
0.0957433432,
-0.0153155196,
-0.0415290892,
0.0012622168,
-0.0384549834,
-0.0180263091,
0.0019401646,
0.031806007,
-0.0460446142,
-0.0247491449,
-0.0444294885,
-0.0289374422,
0.0381370746,
-0.0061790901,
0.0230311118,
0.0013380136,
-0.0216653738,
-0.0220404379,
0.0347710252,
0.0012580722,
-0.0043639224,
-0.0307905208,
-0.0161485728,
0.0325744636,
0.0122575499,
-0.032064762,
0.042746678,
0.0110404938,
-0.026798727,
0.0068888674,
0.0302316044,
0.0580997653,
0.0281925164,
0.0034244554,
0.0196869634,
0.0644281581,
-0.0607810654,
-0.0267121084,
0.0147760157,
-0.0413692258,
-0.0241526235,
0.0280594509,
-0.039394442,
0.0348646939,
0.0998990461,
-0.0211627614,
-0.0590524971,
0.0281585455,
-0.0885530412,
0.0004098192,
-0.0320231207,
0.0427161008,
0.0029884118,
0.071560353,
-0.0113309706,
0.0131500158,
-0.0148557844,
-0.0018769091,
-0.0010681996,
-0.0391471647,
-0.0084702661,
-0.0677393079,
-0.0320725292,
-0.020400878,
-0.0667645931,
0.005176805,
0.0309086815,
-0.0338197351,
-0.0089652417,
0.0016329389,
-0.0036994896,
-0.068707332,
-0.0570610948,
0.052456107,
-0.0365751311,
-0.0164450146,
0.0300451797,
-0.0369516909,
-0.0360655114,
0.0266941804,
0.0097789494,
-0.0278068557,
0.0301307347,
-0.0214612335,
-0.0422384739,
-0.0274971165,
-0.0384366699,
0.0096592391,
0.0412077606,
-0.0009222421,
-0.0075933291,
-0.0788023919,
-0.0455618501,
0.0006422162,
0.0370526761,
-0.0292960834,
-0.0471461639,
-0.037913084,
-0.0104680527,
-0.0018960141,
0.0603604391,
0.0557637103,
0.0115855103,
0.0384164974,
0.0299201943,
0.0204142872,
0.0237759724,
-0.0635736063,
0.0380444862,
-0.0385863669,
0.0017182896,
0.0284948926,
0.0969794989,
-0.0283194631,
0.0001534487,
-0.0396795981,
-0.0358755663,
0.0191491265,
-0.0263735019,
0.0317316204,
-0.0309531447,
-0.0246979799,
-0.0080148354,
-0.0112707159,
-0.0528251976,
0.0757164061,
-0.0331142172,
-0.0168822687,
-0.0097287884,
-0.0333031379,
-0.0353241675,
0.0111416373,
0.0207527447,
-0.0042866683,
0.0002660973,
-0.0260165296,
-0.0167124923,
0.0163128097,
0.0206217282,
-0.0124755343,
0.075109154,
-0.0131908758,
-0.000390499,
-0.0332338177,
-0.0098659266,
-0.053698089,
-0.0487359799,
-0.0462691188,
0.0191941205,
0.0110073704,
-0.0166878644,
-0.1028931588,
0.0654527247,
0.0169099066,
0.0506412834,
-0.011356879,
-0.0005278726,
0.0039624372,
0.0519248694,
0.0560257919,
0.0439641401,
0.0230986569,
-0.0127406921,
0.0486562811,
0.0226445962,
0.0610486567,
0.0175106302,
-0.0410393439,
-0.0093862303,
0.0270305928,
-0.0448315404,
-0.0052490206,
0.0095504308,
0.0046778079,
-0.0487370044,
-0.0185517967,
0.1011442915,
-0.0155292992,
-0.0575934462,
-0.009638289,
-0.0032997883,
0.0257006828,
0.0346409567,
0.0267102309,
-0.0006471538,
-0.0142904809,
-0.0057911715,
0.0342990495,
0.0131579963,
-0.0145040723,
-0.0110709621,
-0.0371892676,
0.044928059,
0.0292001255,
-0.0945480913,
-0.0533266068,
-0.0334243588,
0.0000751545,
-0.0349627398,
-0.0045856251,
-0.0120589035,
-0.031433925,
-0.0268016011,
0.0392566696,
-0.0122118695,
-0.0323248245,
-0.0056512337,
-0.0286541041,
-0.012912388,
0.0647918954,
0.0052241902,
0.0105351573,
-0.036274571,
-0.0148770893,
-0.0156441219,
0.0419097617,
-0.012625251,
0.0582585149,
-0.0216734298,
-0.0364792682,
-0.0042703729,
0.0193044115,
-0.0354734883,
0.0394967534,
-0.0192951225,
0.0754553825,
-0.0095855016,
-0.0564700961,
-0.0478827767,
0.008215161,
0.0014050434,
0.0374295563,
0.0371305123,
-0.0342570618,
-0.0126182828,
0.025487991,
0.0163342226,
-0.0017802916,
-0.063680023,
0.0184818916,
0.013748358,
-0.1018747687,
-0.02542492,
-0.0232694466,
-0.0103100305,
0.0409094766,
0.0161962472,
-0.013348205,
0.0571327545,
-0.0021860413,
-0.0663581714,
0.0268131718,
0.0124865705,
0.0233646054,
-0.0549286529,
0.0486557148,
0.0425322317,
-0.0299059208,
-0.0083681438,
-0.0151071455,
-0.1092596278,
-0.0417809561,
0.0274118818,
0.0652435645,
0.0152340084,
0.0101640364,
-0.0059463321,
-0.0636525452,
0.0315321423,
0.0515441298,
-0.0012899331,
-0.0061936537,
0.042099189,
-0.0597951971,
-0.0232761633,
0.021816384,
-0.0136190727,
0.0781496018,
-0.0020258175,
0.0315158106,
-0.0285340995,
-0.021102963,
0.0238677002,
0.0047134832,
0.08975631,
-0.003445578,
0.0230177678,
0.0075717936,
0.0315528587,
0.0447778963,
0.0134373112,
-0.0476836339,
-0.0095545594,
-0.0192246102,
0.0085228849,
-0.0088206278,
0.0375369452,
-0.0202687643,
-0.02680346,
-0.0458435416,
0.0388370417,
0.0138939684,
-0.0086859791,
0.0011597897,
0.0327726789,
0.0073537193,
-0.0232982673,
0.0360217243,
-0.0114870341,
0.0153284892,
0.0420178175,
-0.0060164635,
0.0809807554,
-0.0221235268,
-0.0036291601,
-0.0912629813,
-0.0012574272,
-0.0102768205,
-0.0227433294,
0.0395754389,
-0.0498141311,
0.0349773392,
0.0227745026,
-0.0044081081,
-0.0354012549,
0.0361729972,
-0.0204329845,
-0.0079056965,
0.0355661996,
0.014366203,
-0.0018669987,
-0.0033661753,
0.0523418188,
-0.0145469317,
-0.0049276366,
-0.0080186259,
-0.0337698311,
-0.0404013768,
-0.0157175325,
0.0070183626,
-0.0067191422,
-0.0028548161,
-0.020164175,
-0.0398596562,
-0.0849168748,
0.038656421,
-0.0582831614,
0.058619421,
-0.0270399135,
0.032248199,
0.0345212296,
-0.0041952152,
0.008569154,
0.0158642977,
0.0206852332,
-0.0402794145,
-0.0181884095,
-0.0016947435,
-6.082539315e-33,
0.0003951578,
-0.0369356498,
-0.0109973708,
0.0322704874,
-0.0390477702,
0.0084248995,
-0.0251620673,
-0.000891196,
-0.007534272,
-0.0169372782,
-0.0283014029,
0.0033512064,
0.0134491324,
0.0325881504,
0.0393955596,
-0.0130812228,
0.0957081318,
-0.0105927885,
0.0038673927,
-0.0030296193,
0.0111705717,
0.046723105,
0.083192721,
-0.0236976836,
-0.0534354076,
0.0059850523,
0.0091103576,
0.0064277221,
0.03009714,
0.0642905608,
-0.0164183322,
0.0414380357,
0.0375319421,
-0.072963126,
-0.0095257191,
0.0480704643,
-0.0752948895,
0.0008047635,
-0.0370738804,
0.0116381515,
-0.0374365337,
0.000852962,
0.0644452572,
-0.0191156473,
-0.0023463573,
-0.0327147059,
0.0624880567,
0.005152199,
-0.0513829254,
-0.0492395312,
-0.0451755151,
-0.0010484428,
-0.010987035,
-0.0312229954,
0.0560364947,
0.1057439595,
0.0074077477,
0.0509959422,
-0.0515956245,
0.0165136214,
0.0280903652,
0.0333809517,
0.0689135417,
0.0580977015,
-0.0311530009,
-0.0210774876,
0.0095760236,
-0.0493284613,
-0.0544514619,
-0.0307664648,
0.0151033122,
0.0219364315,
0.0704814792,
-0.0214259215,
0.0495380238,
-0.0240481142,
-0.0600210316,
-0.0114160497,
0.0054800734,
0.0757961124,
0.0183273423,
0.01719472,
-0.0015538262,
-0.0024363303,
-0.0111496253,
-0.0420319885,
-0.0259416271,
0.0071895262,
0.0168481171,
0.0526914224,
-0.0250859056,
0.0240639728,
0.0225398764,
-0.022065144,
0.0466708057,
0.0203290079,
0.037061803,
0.0074784826,
0.0132123288,
-0.0134215709,
-0.044808194,
0.0040871808,
0.0148753691,
0.0170932598,
-0.0053272522,
-0.044157736,
0.0515437797,
0.0494743623,
-0.0343773849,
-0.0283941906,
-0.0225812271,
0.0258786418,
-0.010850911,
0.0635570213,
0.0482822806,
-0.0317150243,
-0.0010476924,
0.0605471432,
-0.038286034,
0.0110298879,
0.008395792,
0.0578938425,
0.0360084549,
0.0309574828,
-0.0104409158,
0.0133224763,
-0.027321307,
0.0221292246,
0.0146976635,
-0.0633603707,
-0.0213641226,
0.0253269989,
2.597e-7,
-0.0024577503,
0.009891402,
0.009309168,
-0.0033514912,
0.0490518212,
0.0288712606,
0.0127653396,
0.054444328,
-0.0228818413,
0.0255902931,
0.0273344032,
-0.0059950915,
0.0457871892,
-0.0232431982,
-0.0763247758,
-0.0712722689,
-0.0813851655,
0.0291844625,
0.0069294018,
0.0186071619,
0.0258353762,
0.0912057534,
-0.0084388964,
-0.0312084388,
-0.0160987303,
0.0159900915,
0.0379523151,
0.0390532091,
0.0235422701,
-0.0051063909,
0.0340831839,
0.0109376777,
-0.0494380184,
0.0121648693,
-0.0235669129,
0.0423115715,
0.0142843612,
0.0375108235,
-0.0155026093,
-0.0498511903,
0.0156418718,
0.0654926151,
0.020122705,
-0.017703386,
-0.0020498994,
-0.0830604807,
-0.0376607552,
-0.0102823703,
-0.0577056706,
0.0056393105,
-0.0031813101,
-0.0127720665,
0.0355952084,
0.0194094069,
0.0265902095,
-0.041491814,
-0.0092277098,
-0.0838559791,
0.0023326646,
0.0059817815,
-0.0375682898,
0.0461385772,
-0.0516935438,
-0.028323574,
0.0405924395,
0.0171537027,
-0.0321377963,
1.967168215e-34,
0.049827259,
-0.0184778403,
-0.0004294646,
0.0215786882,
-0.0207553301,
-0.0272107199,
-0.0036967713,
0.0179020595,
0.0347579196,
-0.0962797776,
-0.0410604365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13779v1 | FoRAG: Factuality-optimized Retrieval Augmented Generation for Web-enhanced Long-form Question Answering | 2024-06-19T19:06:36 | 2024-06-19T19:06:36 | Tianchi Cai, Zhiwen Tan, Xierui Song, Tao Sun, Jiyan Jiang, Yunqi Xu, Yinger Zhang, Jinjie Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has become prevalent in
question-answering (QA) tasks due to its ability of utilizing search engine to
enhance the quality of long-form question-answering (LFQA). Despite the
emergence of various open source methods and web-enhanced commercial systems
such as Bing Chat, two critical problems remain unsolved, i.e., the lack of
factuality and clear logic in the generated long-form answers. In this paper,
we remedy these issues via a systematic study on answer generation in
web-enhanced LFQA. Specifically, we first propose a novel outline-enhanced
generator to achieve clear logic in the generation of multifaceted answers and
construct two datasets accordingly. Then we propose a factuality optimization
method based on a carefully designed doubly fine-grained RLHF framework, which
contains automatic evaluation and reward modeling in different levels of
granularity. Our generic framework comprises conventional fine-grained RLHF
methods as special cases. Extensive experiments verify the superiority of our
proposed \textit{Factuality-optimized RAG (FoRAG)} method on both English and
Chinese benchmarks. In particular, when applying our method to Llama2-7B-chat,
the derived model FoRAG-L-7B outperforms WebGPT-175B in terms of three commonly
used metrics (i.e., coherence, helpfulness, and factuality), while the number
of parameters is much smaller (only 1/24 of that of WebGPT-175B). Our datasets
and models are made publicly available for better reproducibility:
https://huggingface.co/forag. | [
0.071014449,
-0.0034310289,
-0.0002703635,
0.0161425564,
-0.0187892541,
-0.0302958786,
-0.0178496223,
-0.0141853895,
0.0151743451,
-0.0610203743,
-0.007478958,
-0.0427500568,
-0.0074352329,
0.0182556659,
0.0172698162,
-0.0419440754,
0.0293687563,
0.0106388833,
0.020235626,
-0.010829363,
0.0403109528,
-0.0014790737,
-0.0157243256,
0.0332302265,
-0.0237378571,
-0.009462825,
-0.0194674358,
0.0126854442,
0.0225608759,
-0.0165707003,
0.0344157144,
0.0459115282,
-0.0043708757,
0.0073509831,
0.0000020196,
-0.0676053762,
-0.0163152069,
0.0001385056,
-0.0116392318,
0.018258024,
-0.0014909994,
0.0580452532,
0.0121641131,
0.0595893264,
-0.0274016093,
0.0249627791,
0.0243892986,
0.0735153332,
0.0882190689,
0.0670388341,
0.0070747496,
-0.0221484024,
0.0312626325,
-0.0141379461,
0.0461304858,
-0.0152640017,
-0.023451563,
0.029330153,
0.0156766344,
0.021866668,
0.0040447055,
0.0118016759,
0.0061036805,
-0.0258353855,
0.0372808203,
0.0248215441,
-0.0553781576,
-0.0132626407,
0.0314740092,
0.0921526179,
0.0345020778,
-0.0204662792,
0.017478805,
0.0209096242,
0.0228672586,
-0.0017451212,
-0.0358037353,
0.0394544043,
-0.0226913262,
-0.0045444798,
0.0237956941,
-0.007370722,
-0.0199585501,
0.0398569442,
-0.0003457279,
0.0409162231,
0.0064760731,
-0.0419552475,
-0.0419947058,
0.0101655936,
-0.003623642,
-0.0541423969,
-0.0062875501,
0.054187987,
-0.0428202562,
0.0138682453,
-0.0268128403,
0.0067251227,
0.0515795462,
-0.0426969714,
0.004397444,
0.0314112678,
-0.0234773401,
0.0134468786,
-0.0572346114,
0.0367215872,
-0.000258037,
-0.0158889014,
-0.0551878922,
0.0043089725,
-0.0333225019,
-0.0272456892,
-0.0539443642,
0.061105445,
-0.0104451384,
-0.0223155264,
-0.0427152179,
0.006815521,
0.0070602261,
-0.0118795549,
0.0179162044,
0.0339000337,
-0.0475557335,
0.0351182818,
-0.0557337031,
0.02115307,
-0.0672455132,
0.0158224907,
0.0508970208,
-0.0499895588,
-0.0039227395,
0.0396042988,
0.0272817295,
-0.0130757391,
0.0093120746,
0.0126423845,
-0.0381527022,
0.0020006602,
-0.0445671976,
-0.0685196891,
-0.0168274473,
-0.0374061167,
0.0098094149,
-0.0688243508,
0.0290517975,
-0.0140985074,
-0.0381258018,
0.0324065611,
0.0332989804,
0.0598952435,
-0.0075844107,
0.0219955146,
-0.0458840691,
-0.0011545563,
0.0555729344,
0.0098233838,
0.0041598231,
0.0475812405,
0.0322171412,
0.052582968,
0.0584743209,
0.0235001035,
0.0045854175,
-0.013785813,
0.0318129286,
0.0004887024,
0.0496197939,
0.0462715402,
-0.0315069333,
0.0225849953,
0.0214447286,
0.0460183248,
-0.0365943573,
0.0185740534,
0.0417971574,
0.000495917,
0.0497591011,
0.0325727873,
0.0201135483,
0.0081818253,
0.0376292728,
0.0473208278,
-0.0029681728,
0.0513795987,
-0.0659214109,
0.0420865491,
0.0396061353,
0.0254017748,
-0.0331976227,
-0.0540127121,
-0.0022587855,
0.0125861662,
0.0019853888,
0.0073240465,
-0.0119717419,
0.0227962527,
-0.0387210548,
0.0450630337,
0.0079542883,
-0.0733962208,
0.0276218485,
-0.0546080731,
0.0584424436,
0.0603121631,
0.0503621958,
-0.0174205564,
-0.0540205389,
-0.005223644,
0.0195829887,
0.0671118647,
0.0248119738,
-0.0052035069,
-0.0269082356,
-0.0433336385,
-0.0081690494,
-0.0188244563,
-0.0158437528,
-0.0132450387,
0.0270502642,
0.0129427658,
0.0500107408,
-0.0246794578,
-0.012956595,
0.0066850777,
0.0214639585,
0.0037131261,
0.0223942306,
-0.0024356591,
0.0071763941,
0.0299187973,
-0.0257823784,
0.0411530994,
-0.0042134486,
-0.0175235793,
-0.0691253766,
-0.0264791083,
-0.0062518734,
-0.0461090133,
0.0274603814,
-0.0113818143,
0.0300274882,
0.021203462,
-0.0341210663,
-0.0407405458,
-0.0214148965,
-0.0757008865,
0.0089130392,
-0.0665484071,
0.0004888616,
0.0460232235,
0.0087397946,
-0.0537542142,
0.070091635,
0.0157159213,
-0.0022353416,
-0.0060242964,
-0.0137251709,
0.0205157101,
-0.0847781077,
0.0051199794,
0.0209321082,
-0.0232015122,
0.0458905436,
0.0538536124,
0.0407126583,
-0.0711807907,
-0.0337871201,
-0.0906512737,
0.0233863629,
-0.0234884899,
0.0258638244,
0.0394000039,
0.0028728307,
0.004877714,
0.0119455485,
-0.1018956527,
-0.0134301297,
0.018172605,
0.0163273755,
0.0570768565,
0.0069186306,
-0.0038063128,
-0.0472456925,
-0.0200390052,
0.0062599657,
-0.0101077184,
0.0304382145,
0.0190905966,
-0.0609599277,
0.0019680248,
-0.0983535424,
-0.017188454,
0.0142647298,
-0.0722596869,
-0.0029313313,
-0.0042590541,
0.0295122825,
0.0419323146,
0.0813381523,
-0.0062694871,
0.0247799531,
0.0287113935,
-0.0356536508,
0.0326276943,
-0.0412087366,
-0.0144358883,
0.0371057615,
-0.0656734183,
0.030526014,
-0.0107200956,
0.0147793302,
0.0041690124,
-0.0528343618,
-0.0044324421,
-0.0000480531,
-0.0322966017,
-0.036693085,
0.0201735962,
-0.0128501849,
0.0337814316,
-0.0085342806,
-0.0196475834,
0.0632330701,
-0.0320691057,
0.0082206624,
-0.0660069063,
0.0113329738,
-0.0524409413,
0.0205276497,
-0.0312764719,
0.0404535756,
-0.003494872,
-0.0090462193,
-0.0476757996,
0.0009369571,
0.0440462157,
-0.0757749826,
0.0369429961,
0.000007633,
0.0135536902,
-0.0184623711,
-0.0348363072,
-0.047417216,
-0.0523066856,
0.0382419974,
0.0028977972,
-0.0128669366,
-0.0142694702,
0.0123224379,
0.0053954567,
0.049427487,
-0.0110545326,
-0.0591090173,
-0.0138591733,
0.0066768643,
0.0713446662,
0.111730054,
0.0391038097,
0.0224376619,
0.0115503957,
0.011396477,
0.058156088,
0.014287455,
-0.0301135574,
0.0371942706,
-0.0408541262,
0.0314918347,
-0.0407033525,
-0.0239257887,
0.0116111264,
0.0485963188,
-0.055829104,
-0.020673085,
0.100462392,
0.0458701886,
0.0409888625,
-0.0114176916,
-0.0557465926,
0.0620921217,
-0.0060525858,
0.0521161705,
-0.068559669,
-0.028091928,
-0.0095230788,
0.0551897287,
-0.0200675745,
-0.0001829217,
0.0232368801,
-0.1183355972,
0.0386103466,
-0.0154931592,
-0.0193162244,
-0.0253902134,
-0.0096740564,
-0.0101447394,
0.017286351,
-0.01432944,
0.0306597631,
-0.0251510255,
0.0310641341,
0.0250657294,
-0.0267561842,
0.0159311816,
-0.0040827724,
-0.017570341,
0.0091344481,
0.0627406016,
0.0355499536,
0.0034958853,
-0.0263465848,
-0.0233609378,
-0.0402902626,
0.0210985765,
-0.0161342639,
0.0418933704,
0.0042042783,
0.0008402612,
-0.049909398,
0.021465404,
0.0202930383,
0.0028996989,
0.032062076,
0.0402906165,
-0.0167481154,
0.0027244338,
-0.0292098019,
0.0339420252,
0.0066266232,
0.098573029,
0.0320216306,
-0.0291306525,
-0.0374515057,
-0.0262135528,
0.0136100342,
-0.0538078025,
-0.0133525813,
0.0041348273,
-0.00400005,
0.0208876804,
-0.1324622184,
-0.047814019,
-0.0067457492,
0.0301488824,
-0.0516361482,
0.0060106348,
-0.0145600867,
0.0161871854,
-0.0349943936,
-0.0147889536,
-0.035016086,
0.0146341799,
-0.0527940094,
-0.0134893982,
0.022991823,
-0.0884899199,
0.003414521,
0.017518416,
-0.0312788747,
-0.0311434064,
-0.01708767,
0.0307521801,
0.0126695959,
0.0135611994,
-0.0188167356,
-0.0288960095,
0.0552863441,
0.0240674652,
-0.0286314152,
0.0223341379,
0.0221035816,
0.0244239159,
-0.0084460145,
0.0205106046,
-0.074188605,
-0.0136742648,
-0.0368876047,
0.1056586727,
0.0257014409,
-0.0516459011,
0.0218421351,
0.0701802596,
-0.0184676573,
-0.0079369899,
0.0069025522,
-0.0151141109,
0.030445328,
-0.0375900753,
-0.024920214,
-0.0320896469,
0.0161136556,
-0.0068122032,
-0.0202306993,
0.0306937378,
0.0061954567,
-0.0457787253,
0.0582986362,
-0.0173033718,
-0.0123245781,
-0.0364421085,
-0.0124933394,
-0.0110422224,
-0.0050590197,
-0.0480771475,
-0.0221480615,
0.0235732179,
0.0384534262,
-0.0139888907,
0.082063742,
0.0134888235,
-0.0035987932,
0.0013031601,
0.0354367048,
-0.059625145,
-0.0206879545,
-0.0300312787,
0.0046649873,
0.0472236164,
0.0343083628,
0.0667291209,
0.0025636277,
-0.0091172196,
-0.0123620508,
0.047331281,
0.0171111207,
-0.0387691632,
0.0229314547,
0.0185691603,
-0.0271661784,
-0.0371490903,
0.0886308625,
-0.0232624449,
0.0087067103,
-0.0228061322,
-0.0227887034,
-0.0251813754,
-0.0828822926,
-0.0051763053,
0.0307980962,
0.0062637078,
-0.0285231657,
-0.0551858395,
-0.0422081463,
-0.0098886983,
0.0067365854,
-0.002894005,
-0.0132802418,
0.0486269929,
0.0657496676,
0.0095553352,
-0.0378649905,
-0.0743988901,
0.0144824171,
-0.0600011013,
0.0218679495,
-0.0083275298,
-6.729630955e-33,
-0.0268155131,
-0.0290040001,
0.0117840748,
-0.0078228284,
-0.0354485139,
0.0253051575,
-0.0287132356,
-0.0006658917,
-0.0374208875,
0.0005177403,
-0.0120037002,
-0.0124157984,
0.0053229006,
0.0450710766,
-0.0402365625,
-0.0296649467,
0.028347183,
0.0071917069,
-0.0605000854,
0.0409124829,
0.048484046,
-0.0112080472,
-0.0028584593,
0.0166340079,
-0.0018681488,
-0.0249369666,
-0.0319187678,
0.0410796441,
-0.01891388,
0.0916887522,
0.0134129161,
0.0530578718,
0.0423393361,
-0.0218231212,
0.0116942162,
0.0253377147,
-0.0750553459,
-0.0538756736,
0.0241770316,
-0.043064639,
-0.0779713094,
-0.010736526,
-0.0036353909,
-0.0150865586,
0.0291492138,
-0.0291575193,
0.0260422714,
-0.0129609723,
0.0088995686,
-0.0604551584,
-0.0407537483,
0.0110209854,
0.0097389491,
-0.0201317165,
-0.0638184398,
0.0531795248,
0.0149324033,
-0.0112307994,
-0.0376906656,
0.0084870923,
-0.008300771,
0.0338174701,
0.0596729368,
0.0161869302,
-0.0120291589,
0.0355501845,
-0.0118164821,
0.0106069641,
-0.0536034219,
-0.0030266617,
-0.0222415421,
0.0164284855,
0.0523055084,
0.0566966981,
0.0222200528,
0.0149828205,
-0.0807446614,
0.0628400967,
0.0078447638,
0.0422858,
-0.002665967,
-0.0236848388,
-0.024542965,
-0.0019026758,
-0.0450773388,
0.0899175331,
-0.0404212624,
-0.0556293279,
0.0311343037,
0.0258793011,
-0.0533071458,
-0.0466198027,
0.0120189199,
-0.0005142787,
0.0408322737,
0.0402958132,
-0.0599160492,
0.0223910268,
-0.0171791445,
-0.0047503789,
-0.0251902547,
0.0115283495,
0.0388304666,
-0.0109018059,
-0.0239018742,
0.030936351,
0.0378057435,
0.0093144486,
-0.0192062408,
0.0358035862,
-0.0338318497,
0.03708864,
-0.0311577767,
-0.0531659722,
0.0019941968,
0.0005491412,
-0.0197070651,
0.0364604704,
0.0173270702,
0.0565767735,
-0.045826111,
-0.0625715703,
0.0304881111,
0.0168853849,
-0.023837626,
0.0655002743,
-0.0183784794,
0.0265337098,
-0.0085494053,
-0.0517004915,
-0.0330715626,
-0.0026702422,
2.772e-7,
0.0155182546,
0.0100015067,
0.0227394141,
0.077265203,
-0.0002254701,
0.0260368865,
0.027232524,
0.0249527842,
0.0178986602,
0.0083456263,
0.0074760341,
0.0309425388,
0.0346531756,
0.0221328866,
-0.0487562455,
-0.0350881256,
-0.0737543926,
-0.0349100642,
-0.0127570834,
-0.0186361186,
0.0997285545,
0.0263473541,
-0.0110140191,
-0.011023134,
-0.0119870985,
-0.0265118945,
0.0469888151,
0.0258948822,
-0.0407232568,
0.067052573,
0.0676463768,
0.0007702854,
0.0122739347,
-0.0285298638,
-0.0174429547,
-0.0123814,
0.0437485985,
0.0387969799,
0.0109929629,
-0.0480873398,
0.002492643,
-0.0242398866,
0.0305785481,
-0.0508733802,
0.0710871071,
0.0006346774,
-0.0095977671,
-0.0035681655,
-0.0361976251,
-0.0063217324,
-0.0165142883,
-0.056053374,
-0.0369008631,
0.0236067697,
-0.0152908964,
0.0298480205,
-0.0022689842,
-0.0306971557,
-0.0424986407,
0.0093332063,
-0.0221230742,
-0.0582430363,
-0.0327578038,
0.0063672322,
-0.0238526892,
-0.0781069174,
-0.0092510087,
2.579003841e-34,
0.0286484081,
-0.0143168559,
0.0044034515,
0.0006700172,
0.0377271362,
0.0191991832,
-0.0135330837,
-0.0169480909,
0.0220754202,
-0.0547130592,
-0.0235402286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13777v1 | Game of LLMs: Discovering Structural Constructs in Activities using Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T19:02:44 | 2024-06-19T19:02:44 | Shruthi K. Hiremath, Thomas Ploetz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Human Activity Recognition is a time-series analysis problem. A popular
analysis procedure used by the community assumes an optimal window length to
design recognition pipelines. However, in the scenario of smart homes, where
activities are of varying duration and frequency, the assumption of a constant
sized window does not hold. Additionally, previous works have shown these
activities to be made up of building blocks. We focus on identifying these
underlying building blocks--structural constructs, with the use of large
language models. Identifying these constructs can be beneficial especially in
recognizing short-duration and infrequent activities. We also propose the
development of an activity recognition procedure that uses these building
blocks to model activities, thus helping the downstream task of activity
monitoring in smart homes. | [
-0.0357793756,
0.0058117909,
-0.0226236694,
0.0392244309,
-0.0430461168,
0.0200805571,
0.0121810883,
0.0011383677,
0.0101767601,
-0.0736121237,
0.0157389436,
-0.0266663339,
0.0199853275,
0.020634871,
0.0041058632,
0.0204132739,
0.0440911576,
-0.0275453161,
-0.004181392,
0.0499787442,
-0.0146338744,
-0.0375872403,
-0.0051713279,
0.0195409805,
-0.0020777585,
-0.0143943559,
-0.0268461108,
-0.0459727906,
0.0534824096,
-0.0351745859,
-0.0371715091,
0.0102016702,
0.0278759208,
0.0101848682,
0.0000016573,
-0.0375547372,
0.0033311886,
-0.0143242842,
-0.0270847827,
-0.0674939528,
0.0258860737,
0.0191347636,
0.0240543652,
0.0057769436,
-0.0187060498,
-0.0077677262,
0.0244204663,
0.0217094775,
-0.024822047,
0.074290432,
-0.0071953116,
-0.0063430867,
0.0049069226,
0.0137276454,
0.0641272366,
-0.016221622,
0.0506036505,
0.001776237,
0.0602336228,
-0.0078848228,
-0.015926972,
-0.0409432873,
-0.0231541451,
0.0295717996,
0.0236329306,
0.0279092509,
0.0206390955,
0.0374136344,
-0.0213404298,
0.0369802751,
0.0066555967,
0.0060304985,
0.0838309526,
0.0051517976,
-0.0265848637,
0.0007869673,
-0.0615388937,
0.0080439504,
-0.0046324991,
0.0159846842,
0.0416467078,
0.0261270907,
0.0303314868,
0.0093990769,
0.0052090986,
0.0526234657,
0.0167017654,
0.0151104657,
-0.0487837829,
-0.0051405258,
0.1131354645,
-0.0663514063,
-0.0039806464,
0.0518391766,
-0.007486572,
0.0062243994,
-0.0235318039,
0.0461428761,
-0.0181303341,
-0.0189607274,
-0.0185324177,
0.0370323956,
0.0371955931,
0.0717238486,
-0.0018097927,
0.0444375314,
-0.0150114307,
-0.0371035933,
-0.0807849914,
0.0427703597,
-0.0589744411,
0.0287983194,
-0.0071911039,
0.0408398844,
-0.0183354188,
-0.0669218674,
-0.0429969206,
0.0392451733,
0.0081418799,
-0.0114764068,
-0.0042294133,
-0.018091388,
0.0259873662,
-0.0239021126,
0.0271285251,
-0.0591310933,
-0.010802527,
0.0648082718,
-0.0484107919,
-0.0490832701,
0.004857522,
0.0635542125,
0.0122296102,
-0.0268123504,
-0.0380499288,
-0.0012432479,
0.026723288,
-0.0451106392,
-0.0219148807,
-0.0466694906,
0.0114688026,
-0.0305602215,
0.0253929887,
-0.0752237812,
-0.0257901009,
-0.0283391494,
0.0048626419,
-0.01969143,
-0.014150314,
-0.0264001694,
0.000269661,
0.0724046379,
-0.0182568841,
0.040231932,
0.0099766217,
0.0164251514,
0.0466049276,
0.0121782627,
0.027721392,
-0.0078544011,
0.0061864839,
-0.0008663465,
0.0162117556,
0.068143703,
-0.0523864217,
-0.0162205268,
-0.0075610289,
0.0045528952,
0.0408868939,
-0.0141901495,
-0.0382298976,
0.0036867671,
0.0088469088,
0.0341071151,
0.0625417307,
0.0753603503,
-0.0187027548,
-0.0105475737,
0.005299238,
-0.0293475594,
-0.0048764092,
-0.009077264,
0.0024956178,
-0.0082783233,
-0.0448548384,
-0.0402675793,
-0.0497500971,
-0.0100337444,
-0.055078011,
-0.0424797647,
-0.0378690101,
-0.0457793176,
0.0580566339,
0.0046505244,
0.0576472394,
-0.0420910455,
0.0067602573,
0.0689729676,
-0.0276998617,
0.0041203904,
0.0161714256,
-0.0779534653,
0.0394343249,
0.0807452276,
0.0123412218,
-0.0503583737,
0.0116693247,
0.0059652654,
0.0513081662,
-0.0484970585,
-0.0006431919,
-0.0063171582,
0.0181992706,
-0.0327411629,
-0.0664363056,
0.0023176849,
0.0436208844,
-0.0074827648,
-0.0531404912,
-0.0160024166,
0.0241542161,
-0.030157404,
-0.0114930496,
0.0440678112,
0.0154739507,
-0.0338594727,
0.0269801989,
0.0210631378,
0.0333932675,
0.0224651229,
0.0211123396,
0.0163699239,
0.0574579984,
-0.0967699736,
0.0104046045,
0.0662788525,
-0.0073781363,
0.0104136616,
0.0485288426,
0.0371876471,
0.0033868554,
-0.0047389795,
-0.0057634301,
-0.0402039886,
0.0281359404,
-0.0433825515,
0.0397776812,
-0.0209770929,
0.0075647449,
0.0162559766,
-0.0348719805,
-0.0348924361,
0.0593314283,
-0.0038051878,
0.0309079643,
0.0213834643,
-0.0007713316,
0.0101729222,
-0.0611070618,
0.0019151891,
-0.0033276384,
-0.0447038859,
-0.0082635256,
0.026253663,
0.0220654048,
-0.0291758273,
0.0364293791,
-0.0679870173,
-0.0224368274,
-0.0135953566,
0.0336475484,
0.0006364493,
0.0141687691,
0.0097734639,
-0.0089716651,
-0.0051572355,
0.0000304553,
-0.0348780043,
0.004462745,
0.0364243574,
0.0076654335,
-0.0970095694,
0.0079121161,
0.0175539777,
-0.0126463538,
0.0295262244,
0.0183752477,
-0.0356214419,
-0.0356957614,
-0.002275238,
0.0592953376,
-0.0088085327,
-0.0191404466,
-0.0153118428,
0.0052410807,
-0.0101696495,
0.0743240714,
0.0604676306,
-0.002567797,
0.0215797275,
0.0434770212,
-0.0655463636,
-0.0032501142,
-0.0080458848,
-0.0196864083,
0.0251165498,
-0.0619715489,
-0.0352210589,
0.0288238544,
0.0360114202,
-0.0116719669,
0.0148168402,
0.0106628193,
0.0069720536,
-0.0418770537,
-0.0043238308,
-0.022392286,
-0.0150856394,
-0.0676126182,
0.0471374914,
0.0229231976,
-0.0511164628,
-0.0202535093,
-0.0090575824,
0.0318487994,
0.0050274376,
-0.044289235,
-0.0328158401,
0.054830607,
0.0067324606,
0.0074335281,
-0.0121181449,
-0.0526674837,
0.0012611001,
-0.0633048639,
0.0261859186,
-0.0367092639,
0.0317288712,
-0.0803743154,
0.0394327864,
-0.0131857991,
-0.0367954336,
-0.0358847529,
0.0261949562,
-0.0399324261,
-0.010747659,
-0.0563939437,
0.0094565386,
-0.0448351242,
0.0119001381,
-0.0420090556,
-0.0078182193,
0.0180359744,
0.026734367,
0.008420554,
0.064722836,
0.0295832269,
0.0205581486,
-0.0714021772,
-0.0179302543,
0.0019294306,
0.0306701586,
0.0056489571,
0.0429213047,
-0.0614791103,
0.0233649537,
0.0276646148,
-0.0198410377,
-0.0392502546,
0.0841341391,
0.0639444441,
-0.02823928,
-0.0090127029,
0.1162508279,
0.0102751302,
-0.0189770386,
0.0182335544,
0.0195444506,
-0.0659709051,
-0.0039852951,
-0.0362777635,
-0.0354116671,
-0.0418088697,
0.0072708647,
-0.0035308604,
-0.0221867822,
-0.0311240107,
0.0002675583,
-0.0709723532,
0.0342926569,
0.0510136522,
-0.0201069526,
-0.0590184927,
-0.0431630872,
0.0206587724,
-0.0519330911,
-0.0453848466,
-0.0412573814,
-0.0075126332,
-0.0127434647,
0.0082857488,
-0.1055745408,
-0.0318937674,
0.0231962521,
-0.0145554859,
0.0666999668,
-0.0182283483,
0.0215692539,
0.0027924983,
-0.0522180274,
0.0257931631,
-0.0248516053,
0.0101847248,
-0.027465798,
-0.0487931073,
0.0401806571,
0.0225986689,
0.011826722,
0.0836033076,
-0.0671693757,
-0.0634779185,
0.0381765403,
0.1133715883,
-0.0495757051,
-0.0032521281,
-0.0268204007,
-0.0318080224,
0.0899973214,
0.0902810842,
-0.0283940863,
-0.0195272733,
-0.0141536947,
0.0069620279,
-0.0464701727,
0.0291929562,
-0.0256223362,
-0.0404755808,
-0.0299342591,
0.0197138153,
-0.0329890735,
0.0043057818,
0.0329474583,
0.0297281891,
0.0026929039,
0.0817945302,
0.0332905576,
0.0272971336,
-0.0642097294,
-0.0158883426,
-0.0206859857,
0.0655196309,
-0.0101516452,
-0.0069335764,
0.0544077605,
-0.0313207805,
0.0083640357,
0.0181790311,
-0.0654752403,
-0.0113160992,
0.000334017,
0.0305424724,
0.0250388514,
0.0154700568,
-0.0077036661,
0.0336693041,
-0.032676775,
-0.006728197,
-0.0077390322,
-0.0087341424,
0.0094815036,
-0.0145938266,
-0.0094292844,
0.0104015842,
-0.0335349478,
0.0233308766,
0.0189901683,
0.03502414,
-0.099084802,
-0.0415463559,
0.0110596437,
-0.0094370209,
0.034630958,
0.0143329296,
-0.0112078944,
-0.0131615326,
0.0053789741,
-0.0197908804,
-0.0046563107,
-0.0461531468,
0.0077293357,
0.0119650401,
0.0194845274,
-0.014691907,
0.0314974859,
-0.0355458893,
-0.0062607634,
-0.0229615699,
0.0363271236,
-0.0312465038,
0.029012192,
0.0139455916,
-0.0186853055,
0.0173555203,
0.0426895097,
0.0018329761,
-0.0198730938,
0.024213085,
-0.0033137517,
-0.0008729938,
0.0224651471,
-0.0877958909,
0.0275374912,
0.0186786577,
0.0247039273,
0.0295020584,
0.0272203907,
0.0557837673,
-0.0208301004,
-0.021167025,
-0.0202935729,
-0.0118876006,
-0.0542011037,
0.0859086439,
-0.0070855748,
0.0163089838,
0.0204572137,
0.029510336,
-0.047798764,
-0.0219947211,
0.073967509,
0.0226337016,
0.0153980711,
0.0254376084,
-0.0342974029,
-0.0363320112,
-0.014928557,
0.0274204127,
0.0319641829,
-0.0469399393,
-0.0112589477,
-0.0483199619,
-0.0359043963,
-0.0015940912,
-0.0355864577,
0.0528468192,
0.0301991478,
0.0721416399,
0.040657308,
-0.0353079736,
-0.0175068881,
-0.0159880146,
-0.0447959155,
-0.0321969725,
-0.0049989661,
-0.0149001041,
-5.247573923e-33,
0.0135275209,
-0.0913672,
0.0327262171,
0.0362382606,
-0.0122098932,
0.0272620264,
0.0089153694,
0.0042522182,
0.0242163278,
-0.0387626514,
0.0258999243,
-0.0109257028,
0.0400833711,
-0.0216234475,
0.059711542,
-0.0097035589,
0.0501888022,
-0.0205079485,
0.0085427389,
-0.0160141662,
0.0101625221,
-0.0174497776,
0.029488435,
-0.0703206658,
-0.0103883557,
0.0065789213,
-0.0156917889,
0.0195282251,
0.0356949233,
0.0136229126,
-0.0407925732,
0.0140243899,
0.0421515256,
0.0222736765,
-0.014113158,
0.0437381268,
-0.0389636233,
-0.0303034,
0.044214081,
0.0205364581,
-0.0329549499,
-0.0611196533,
-0.0132051324,
0.0341536701,
-0.0817724541,
0.0120728463,
0.0552817546,
-0.064225167,
-0.0174475592,
-0.0035775013,
-0.0355143659,
0.0355865769,
-0.0093821995,
0.0069183307,
0.0250127614,
-0.0670231283,
-0.0307983086,
-0.0144802835,
-0.0748459324,
0.065971598,
-0.0122110182,
0.0160128027,
0.0551770478,
0.0402189009,
0.0370919667,
0.0416890047,
0.0228515919,
-0.012359052,
0.0055467822,
0.0109328451,
-0.0141946236,
0.073639527,
-0.0010410581,
-0.0032857303,
0.038972225,
-0.0031621878,
-0.0919152424,
0.015706107,
0.0524912812,
0.0517984256,
-0.0156388953,
0.0470259115,
0.0032102368,
0.0052103456,
0.0008950481,
0.0404417999,
-0.0131008178,
0.0046996945,
0.0207651574,
0.0350448191,
-0.030299155,
-0.0312039219,
0.0116681885,
-0.0395704918,
0.0118002174,
-0.0113570029,
0.0421585962,
-0.0161147732,
-0.0007925322,
0.0013401379,
-0.0290604904,
-0.092964448,
0.0040025096,
0.033967007,
0.0192041192,
-0.0285097919,
-0.0335087441,
0.0810309947,
0.0013631764,
-0.0289149005,
0.034811493,
-0.0224794708,
0.0041226773,
0.0537592471,
0.0562989302,
-0.020963667,
-0.0108034471,
0.0977072418,
-0.0525387488,
-0.0302275978,
-0.0133013846,
0.0078082741,
0.0127230324,
0.0029294945,
-0.0193971302,
-0.0103848167,
-0.0636210665,
0.0130422432,
0.0808273852,
-0.0007321585,
-0.0152223343,
0.0025347269,
2.551e-7,
-0.026237743,
0.0276366174,
-0.0251407828,
0.0252975281,
0.0162171274,
0.018367352,
-0.0181038119,
0.0397381298,
0.001110156,
0.0111935604,
0.0647941083,
-0.0054029962,
0.075529106,
0.0080648288,
-0.0431817248,
0.0244153962,
0.023559561,
0.0056489189,
-0.0670783371,
0.0246434882,
0.0280179475,
0.0225182921,
0.0062530418,
0.0189569816,
0.0116651803,
-0.1169057935,
0.0184582993,
-0.0478143059,
0.0011564214,
0.0128755337,
0.0212475676,
0.0174138676,
-0.0090132048,
-0.0247638319,
-0.0329196118,
0.0403515436,
-0.0033825554,
0.0528339222,
-0.0199144389,
-0.0102189612,
-0.0355089419,
-0.0326941535,
0.001438032,
0.0080747409,
0.0653789192,
-0.0458640195,
-0.0291434228,
-0.0088626174,
0.0164038371,
-0.0317517221,
0.0014358903,
0.0334890261,
0.0309115741,
0.0208232682,
0.005667239,
-0.0356045477,
-0.0051935799,
-0.0468170717,
0.0159286782,
-0.0349270478,
-0.0841262639,
-0.0360755026,
-0.010086366,
-0.0004033542,
0.0045292666,
-0.0249498896,
-0.025327526,
1.881340597e-34,
-0.013319226,
-0.0121118864,
-0.0166508146,
0.0527235344,
-0.0273228716,
0.0059760702,
-0.0321020484,
0.0352876894,
0.0281123109,
-0.0850777104,
0.0134421689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13770v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13770v1 | Elliptical Attention | 2024-06-19T18:38:11 | 2024-06-19T18:38:11 | Stefan K. Nielsen, Laziz U. Abdullaev, Rachel Teo, Tan M. Nguyen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Pairwise dot-product self-attention is key to the success of transformers
that achieve state-of-the-art performance across a variety of applications in
language and vision. This dot-product self-attention computes attention weights
among the input tokens using Euclidean distance, which makes the model prone to
representation collapse and vulnerable to contaminated samples. In this paper,
we propose using a Mahalanobis distance metric for computing the attention
weights to stretch the underlying feature space in directions of high
contextual relevance. In particular, we define a hyper-ellipsoidal neighborhood
around each query to increase the attention weights of the tokens lying in the
contextually important directions. We term this novel class of attention
Elliptical Attention. Our Elliptical Attention provides two benefits: 1)
reducing representation collapse and 2) enhancing the model's robustness as the
Elliptical Attention pays more attention to contextually relevant information
rather than focusing on some small subset of informative features. We
empirically demonstrate the advantages of Elliptical Attention over the
baseline dot-product attention and state-of-the-art attention methods on
various practical tasks, including object classification, image segmentation,
and language modeling across different data modalities. | [
0.0157307684,
0.0247424096,
0.0047023417,
0.050303854,
-0.0056487485,
0.0091690402,
0.0152923726,
0.0010825283,
-0.0341562405,
-0.0549961887,
-0.0427376553,
-0.0206713527,
-0.0104327276,
0.0285403803,
0.0367275029,
-0.0578684025,
0.0244389996,
-0.0025212581,
-0.0412394218,
0.0077835405,
-0.018886108,
-0.0106336912,
0.0195308607,
0.0430567153,
-0.0664697737,
-0.0257682521,
-0.0184958652,
0.0272551756,
0.0378739685,
-0.010662308,
-0.0186490305,
0.0511135496,
-0.0013303311,
0.0191637538,
0.0000020228,
-0.0251352321,
-0.0186872743,
0.0129263997,
0.0057889083,
-0.0066900463,
0.0299826153,
-0.0372191258,
0.0326933488,
-0.0277708434,
-0.0200559162,
-0.0259149447,
0.0719545186,
0.0748115256,
0.051264897,
0.0527556837,
-0.0230463874,
-0.032148052,
0.0001248584,
-0.0383755676,
0.0202933047,
-0.0450339317,
0.0219291858,
-0.0539984256,
-0.0324644595,
0.0507543385,
-0.0276750885,
0.057591863,
0.0027085405,
0.0063626487,
0.0633414313,
0.0393323861,
-0.0377648622,
-0.0041092304,
0.012889104,
0.0810655877,
-0.0488898195,
-0.0227657128,
-0.008775631,
0.0150665939,
0.0015132965,
-0.0102737462,
-0.0346324183,
-0.0108672259,
0.0245586131,
0.0082797464,
-0.0356277935,
0.011686299,
0.0139259547,
-0.0106020533,
-0.0489411578,
0.0184280779,
0.0102392649,
-0.0206889212,
-0.0184763707,
-0.0099240011,
-0.0430826358,
-0.0315823145,
0.0219362639,
0.0317167267,
0.0293668937,
-0.015948955,
-0.0134855779,
-0.0596365407,
0.0029398729,
-0.0432907268,
0.0316804275,
0.0070907339,
-0.0610476173,
0.0676577389,
-0.0108778467,
0.07468687,
-0.0475096814,
0.0705122799,
-0.0409701467,
-0.0185507946,
-0.0122455852,
0.0175779685,
-0.0767475963,
0.0267771613,
-0.0306031089,
-0.0299689695,
-0.0075241793,
0.0379584096,
-0.0034431636,
-0.0592034645,
0.0250365511,
0.0231489241,
-0.0320776291,
-0.0214069393,
0.0247330237,
0.0320599154,
-0.0297421142,
-0.0247704647,
-0.0047459318,
-0.0336667076,
-0.0511810705,
0.0571338274,
0.0137535352,
-0.0411766879,
-0.0146997543,
0.0761124045,
0.0110504301,
-0.0992797539,
0.0037229299,
0.012791804,
-0.0626092628,
-0.0282263868,
0.033964742,
-0.0269853845,
0.0197631102,
0.002930532,
-0.0187617615,
-0.0121120336,
-0.0048297271,
0.0057107285,
-0.0022729966,
0.0736737549,
0.043697346,
0.0148101421,
0.0215651132,
-0.0019245393,
0.0089710448,
0.0465499498,
0.0331304148,
0.0351170599,
0.0185462274,
0.0124863163,
0.0385453142,
-0.0000963937,
0.0073451689,
0.0023716129,
-0.0470399149,
0.0223638844,
-0.026587829,
0.0126148071,
0.0391437225,
0.0407130942,
0.0014271882,
-0.0556735471,
0.0580059253,
0.0394621491,
0.0014051591,
0.0548767261,
0.0262808744,
-0.0104374001,
-0.075207144,
-0.0045807008,
-0.079313159,
0.0657458678,
-0.0024202575,
-0.028451968,
0.0116235064,
-0.0021406005,
-0.0474563837,
-0.0354140848,
0.011352391,
-0.0065845195,
0.013868222,
0.0215334762,
0.0513696782,
-0.0094047925,
-0.028125044,
0.0781184658,
-0.0038392716,
-0.0541285239,
-0.0101644304,
-0.0774773806,
0.0172140207,
0.01447614,
-0.0058975164,
-0.0658279955,
-0.0198134799,
0.0004648235,
0.0461541638,
0.0201128386,
0.00025566,
0.0468592681,
0.0362557806,
-0.0171519499,
-0.0422384776,
-0.0163095724,
0.0062033948,
0.0128406174,
-0.018831959,
0.014467922,
0.0268654693,
-0.0851992667,
0.028293971,
0.0465630405,
0.0785861611,
-0.0365147367,
0.0087752836,
0.0693821013,
0.0079302117,
0.0253389161,
0.0230983142,
0.0169761106,
0.0424628854,
-0.0488615334,
0.0036770226,
-0.0127022257,
-0.0338257104,
-0.0117227342,
0.0146698738,
-0.0708124936,
-0.0104897674,
0.0381930843,
-0.0201537572,
-0.0196750518,
0.0391530171,
-0.0504323579,
0.04801156,
-0.0283858851,
0.009899145,
0.0064102635,
0.0652779043,
-0.0494848639,
0.0560422167,
-0.0076756235,
0.0039903647,
0.0029046612,
0.0167289935,
0.0193364266,
-0.0315574706,
-0.0261326898,
-0.0024535174,
-0.0101370877,
0.0112680271,
0.0021803249,
-0.0194964353,
-0.020026274,
-0.0554386638,
-0.0330989622,
-0.0385458395,
-0.0577166714,
0.0103713581,
0.001204491,
0.0076083113,
-0.0036644205,
-0.0362494029,
-0.0190139282,
-0.0130614052,
-0.0421767421,
0.0075270412,
0.0354471803,
-0.0122533822,
-0.001027259,
-0.0103423325,
-0.037720006,
0.01988093,
0.0583355986,
0.0179902408,
-0.0321098194,
-0.0589614436,
-0.0045880345,
-0.0027519041,
0.0294499025,
-0.0000440865,
-0.0273622889,
-0.0191513803,
-0.0280674268,
0.0354297347,
0.1285857856,
0.0247969646,
0.0023135836,
0.0531780533,
-0.0020931896,
-0.0305100381,
0.0162515249,
-0.0332073979,
0.0100288959,
-0.0126412101,
-0.0068254964,
0.0443241894,
0.0465738028,
-0.0462993309,
-0.0292892884,
-0.0655140281,
-0.0238385294,
0.0229121912,
-0.0288483184,
0.008442658,
0.0179354008,
-0.0223646574,
0.0038805015,
-0.0202480778,
-0.046205949,
0.0567885488,
-0.0138093717,
-0.01097083,
-0.0021362714,
0.0114702079,
-0.0346625745,
0.0404095873,
0.0396131948,
0.030566277,
-0.0047390051,
-0.0696718544,
-0.0405474789,
0.0346360728,
-0.0127334259,
-0.008688624,
0.085947305,
0.0173019301,
0.0316543467,
-0.0150193889,
-0.0077613047,
-0.0235312283,
-0.0103974761,
0.0041010575,
0.016744623,
-0.0058183498,
-0.0013204572,
-0.082484737,
0.0490373522,
0.0127212191,
0.0290883016,
-0.0104756011,
-0.0187635776,
0.0056302231,
0.0239568241,
0.0339929312,
0.0693653971,
0.0211423207,
-0.0449849926,
-0.0346022621,
0.0562814474,
0.031864088,
-0.0367369168,
-0.0329326466,
-0.0067761051,
0.0246950462,
0.0058674426,
-0.0163459666,
-0.0054455977,
0.0522429235,
-0.0273346175,
-0.029570803,
0.073180005,
0.0006804626,
-0.0731231347,
-0.0000829652,
-0.0124368696,
0.0230636988,
0.0480614081,
0.0166664273,
-0.018517362,
-0.0337803401,
-0.0088215871,
0.0265658554,
0.0497949384,
-0.0034688683,
0.0122164767,
-0.0368059315,
0.0382059664,
-0.0057304944,
-0.0697395205,
-0.0921402052,
-0.0160195492,
0.0545523316,
-0.0385596342,
-0.0055180029,
-0.0038696709,
-0.0285355169,
-0.0344138853,
0.0132415583,
0.0212473031,
0.0028949201,
0.0220672879,
-0.0185707491,
-0.0361212082,
0.0293207094,
0.0022393549,
0.0206522811,
-0.0550206155,
-0.0193854608,
-0.0356244855,
-0.002344131,
0.0034848889,
0.0660687834,
-0.051835116,
-0.0317974091,
0.0218386725,
0.0015412036,
-0.0267776698,
-0.0086088562,
-0.0413209163,
0.0701980889,
-0.0113788694,
-0.0008995214,
-0.0478597619,
-0.0217933115,
-0.0175350551,
0.050821621,
0.0407524481,
-0.0051761088,
-0.0284940004,
0.0085075665,
0.0493890606,
-0.0115207899,
-0.0281823054,
0.014634015,
0.0235731639,
-0.072500594,
-0.0487230644,
-0.0236940868,
0.0026061542,
0.0346671604,
-0.0140006235,
-0.0645315796,
0.0039472911,
-0.0005829785,
-0.0351195969,
0.0574590042,
-0.0227246992,
-0.0028400216,
-0.0457013845,
0.0342869163,
0.0166240726,
-0.0017553348,
-0.0247400682,
0.006142104,
-0.1252180189,
-0.0377568044,
0.0044099363,
0.0477184877,
0.0084857969,
0.034467753,
-0.0289665721,
-0.0492376387,
0.0232970286,
0.0398129895,
-0.0076993238,
0.0241763871,
0.0419638827,
-0.0253291447,
-0.0079293139,
0.0533698313,
-0.0490964726,
0.0255776122,
0.0308200587,
0.0163598545,
-0.0639769882,
-0.0538787358,
0.0029693104,
0.0064409603,
0.089165844,
-0.0066890623,
0.0332887433,
-0.0214980226,
0.0401329361,
0.0122481715,
0.0186305679,
-0.0646276399,
0.0217020176,
-0.0346316881,
-0.015076926,
0.0057911826,
0.0423324518,
-0.0048018652,
-0.0098771313,
-0.0646304265,
0.0379618146,
-0.0514250845,
-0.034782324,
0.0062623597,
0.0453393348,
-0.008337995,
-0.0383372307,
0.0459115133,
0.0190085378,
-0.0130508784,
0.040761698,
0.0305123106,
0.0080058919,
-0.047491055,
0.0258926749,
-0.0750071183,
0.0144818472,
-0.0261504743,
0.0318233296,
0.014830295,
-0.0500863791,
0.0303893555,
0.0060684676,
-0.0240202695,
-0.028340416,
0.0335889086,
0.0089300806,
0.0047089416,
0.0269086063,
0.0232655145,
0.0103878686,
-0.0020705499,
0.0673277304,
-0.0594605766,
0.0013390225,
0.0139645869,
0.004422877,
-0.0556832999,
-0.0159679428,
-0.0007992312,
-0.0046169939,
-0.0147973327,
0.0311382767,
-0.0273125526,
-0.0800296143,
0.0152283972,
-0.0483760834,
-0.0403831527,
0.0106732007,
0.0605134331,
0.0578318536,
0.0172018278,
-0.0265126079,
0.0024150147,
0.0098597528,
0.0284722541,
0.0128562571,
0.0088983942,
-6.58027999e-33,
0.0047243671,
-0.0232305191,
-0.0249195509,
0.0092101395,
-0.0446674302,
0.018619284,
-0.015263252,
0.0200999882,
-0.0412170291,
0.0169909671,
-0.0062904586,
0.0168574117,
0.0070060729,
0.0373016261,
-0.0155954091,
-0.0492343977,
0.0370045081,
0.0175828282,
-0.0104522435,
0.0363782048,
-0.0042837607,
0.0384558141,
0.0824042186,
-0.0637949184,
-0.0314339697,
0.011885114,
-0.0092376582,
0.0468882211,
0.0098385382,
0.0795520023,
-0.0042247386,
0.0329382084,
0.0053927284,
-0.0439207368,
-0.0268534813,
0.0135442382,
-0.063357234,
-0.0176717434,
-0.0436114594,
0.0192429703,
-0.0511194356,
-0.0204206035,
0.0943243653,
0.0190579556,
0.0203642417,
-0.0693889931,
0.0506380796,
-0.0207634736,
-0.0651643574,
0.0297705512,
-0.0164292119,
0.034821365,
-0.0410361364,
-0.0380829573,
0.0675570369,
0.0442406237,
0.0298072118,
0.0539425462,
-0.0318925083,
0.0205403287,
-0.01562622,
0.0357882865,
0.0539849065,
0.0334040634,
0.0001925651,
0.039368581,
0.0699606985,
-0.0439906232,
-0.0152305067,
-0.0682058781,
0.0192352422,
0.0558392331,
0.0316293575,
-0.0153892338,
-0.0000390284,
0.0172152296,
-0.0654512197,
-0.0268729888,
-0.0763646066,
0.071320422,
0.0068890727,
0.0122527378,
-0.03352594,
0.01870092,
0.0126969945,
-0.010330637,
-0.0702182204,
0.0021064419,
0.0116742104,
0.0266360193,
-0.0233076736,
0.0612130277,
0.0350325294,
-0.0165826958,
0.0044801598,
-0.0054641725,
0.0065985704,
0.013175467,
0.0227950346,
0.0162578654,
-0.0069925403,
0.0070530404,
0.0021075157,
0.0068726162,
-0.0060372059,
-0.0229361113,
0.0427431874,
0.0028501111,
-0.0799200907,
-0.0467207991,
-0.0274176206,
-0.0192199331,
-0.0394275971,
0.0269483123,
0.0364138968,
0.0051813219,
-0.0050866045,
0.1001107246,
0.0187205598,
0.0154812699,
-0.0210459195,
0.0122123184,
0.0218930393,
0.0462239906,
-0.0344177969,
-0.0102178296,
-0.014833496,
0.0081804991,
0.0539820641,
-0.0688787624,
-0.043175526,
0.0383629426,
2.848e-7,
0.0693871006,
0.0667172521,
0.0086910948,
-0.0142778503,
-0.0108327838,
0.0512535833,
0.0137062278,
0.0592059977,
-0.000345441,
-0.0235080812,
-0.0009332832,
0.039932061,
0.0166098941,
-0.012017102,
-0.0646401644,
0.068583779,
-0.0524746738,
-0.0064912322,
-0.0266338084,
0.004043126,
0.0592923649,
0.1218079329,
-0.0150446426,
0.0073931804,
0.0095024081,
-0.0212098546,
0.0496315807,
-0.0206746981,
0.0212959088,
0.0061125522,
0.0149973929,
0.0097448733,
-0.0140905948,
0.0169695392,
-0.006077365,
0.011944999,
0.0687977448,
0.053578224,
-0.0281629879,
-0.0654410124,
0.0072396682,
0.0265879985,
-0.0136005813,
-0.0455984026,
0.0745972916,
-0.0770142302,
-0.0124617442,
-0.032420963,
-0.0036233948,
0.0314401835,
0.0243326686,
0.0031568471,
-0.0179964267,
0.0253570657,
0.0218606573,
-0.0497550927,
0.0038658483,
-0.0949452221,
-0.0140123442,
-0.0073739626,
-0.0544447526,
0.030889757,
-0.0560799874,
-0.0083030965,
0.0565320551,
0.0368720144,
-0.044515226,
2.359479582e-34,
0.0379807465,
-0.0138927884,
-0.0081424974,
0.002022353,
-0.0372377858,
-0.0411768481,
-0.0208692085,
-0.0281532742,
-0.0056368127,
-0.0617799535,
-0.0265986081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13764v1 | Can LLMs Reason in the Wild with Programs? | 2024-06-19T18:26:19 | 2024-06-19T18:26:19 | Yuan Yang, Siheng Xiong, Ali Payani, Ehsan Shareghi, Faramarz Fekri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown superior capability to solve
reasoning problems with programs. While being a promising direction, most of
such frameworks are trained and evaluated in settings with a prior knowledge of
task requirements. However, as LLMs become more capable, it is necessary to
assess their reasoning abilities in more realistic scenarios where many
real-world problems are open-ended with ambiguous scope, and often require
multiple formalisms to solve. To investigate this, we introduce the task of
reasoning in the wild, where an LLM is tasked to solve a reasoning problem of
unknown type by identifying the subproblems and their corresponding formalisms,
and writing a program to solve each subproblem, guided by a tactic. We create a
large tactic-guided trajectory dataset containing detailed solutions to a
diverse set of reasoning problems, ranging from well-defined single-form
reasoning (e.g., math, logic), to ambiguous and hybrid ones (e.g., commonsense,
combined math and logic). This allows us to test various aspects of LLMs
reasoning at the fine-grained level such as the selection and execution of
tactics, and the tendency to take undesired shortcuts. In experiments, we
highlight that existing LLMs fail significantly on problems with ambiguous and
mixed scope, revealing critical limitations and overfitting issues (e.g.
accuracy on GSM8K drops by at least 50\%). We further show the potential of
finetuning a local LLM on the tactic-guided trajectories in achieving better
performance. Project repo is available at
github.com/gblackout/Reason-in-the-Wild | [
0.0266390685,
0.0701626912,
-0.0054686423,
0.0535306148,
-0.0396892056,
0.0306808036,
0.0073173181,
-0.0063776323,
-0.0297021251,
-0.0484804846,
0.0030816586,
0.0017914972,
-0.0186696723,
0.0162851475,
0.0287259873,
-0.0322321802,
0.0365367383,
-0.0818330124,
0.0197893083,
-0.0074590198,
-0.0258058552,
0.0328781791,
-0.0195999537,
0.0417686068,
0.0096282307,
-0.0251451787,
-0.0314577818,
0.0158592332,
0.0058029387,
-0.0066037341,
-0.0211170502,
-0.0064397375,
0.0561574325,
0.023061214,
0.0000020409,
-0.0538427606,
0.0045859916,
0.005997322,
-0.0564039312,
-0.0096195471,
-0.0198311135,
0.0131733324,
0.0064503816,
0.0269628465,
-0.045304995,
-0.0105636232,
-0.0048694657,
0.0291859936,
0.0760517642,
0.0930736437,
0.0237174649,
-0.0563435704,
-0.0059645684,
-0.008394191,
0.0259152148,
-0.064316757,
0.0039281049,
0.0254676025,
0.0242248289,
-0.0029197182,
0.0113130864,
0.0041826349,
0.0389489569,
-0.0080831554,
-0.0457860231,
0.0216317046,
-0.0607904904,
-0.0022139398,
0.0060445401,
0.0405524895,
-0.0070284894,
-0.0494400263,
0.0177590996,
0.0045354343,
-0.0115892179,
-0.014706552,
-0.0437660217,
0.0464455783,
-0.0115548968,
0.0227137059,
0.0324241593,
-0.0324128121,
0.052368883,
0.0241090879,
-0.0734065846,
0.1049261764,
-0.025490405,
-0.0159166194,
0.0301275812,
-0.0254264232,
-0.0280380007,
-0.0823603272,
0.0061754845,
0.1037121043,
-0.0401976295,
0.0396660306,
-0.0147643946,
0.0312357061,
-0.0080872765,
-0.0115403589,
0.0198695399,
0.0636013448,
0.0211724043,
0.064477697,
-0.0195100289,
0.0171701182,
-0.0314047858,
0.0400303379,
-0.0170302335,
-0.0220758058,
-0.0798959509,
-0.0256375261,
-0.0054992423,
0.0556449518,
-0.0004010758,
0.0123918261,
-0.0174874458,
0.0331828147,
-0.0151580349,
0.0714379102,
-0.0065402221,
0.0147236707,
-0.0132077429,
-0.0447971933,
-0.0442359969,
-0.0110051883,
-0.0476050265,
0.0225783437,
0.0250369478,
-0.013372018,
-0.0105950832,
0.0188217554,
-0.0293726213,
-0.0312247816,
0.0415595844,
0.0901967883,
-0.0035378393,
0.0124762617,
-0.0671663955,
-0.0574930161,
0.0006214784,
-0.095714435,
-0.0165003799,
-0.094171755,
0.0181479398,
0.0303524062,
-0.0251749773,
-0.0295084957,
0.0043301065,
-0.0043392233,
-0.0156969372,
0.0864450485,
0.0231338218,
0.0136194369,
0.0162274931,
0.0311126616,
-0.0268645473,
0.0739642754,
0.041702833,
0.0131485388,
0.0005491675,
0.006432646,
-0.0052545746,
0.0243392382,
0.0015716329,
-0.0152538093,
-0.0432697795,
0.023704024,
-0.0358512439,
0.0394327454,
-0.0140660321,
0.032746356,
-0.0142682455,
0.0034091778,
0.0033339611,
0.071147345,
0.0387906097,
0.00216583,
0.0593216196,
-0.0274326447,
0.0194457583,
-0.0015538351,
-0.0692287683,
0.0191168636,
-0.0548181906,
0.0042803898,
-0.0170840994,
0.0038194309,
-0.0259432252,
-0.0699767545,
-0.0387803689,
0.0023874568,
-0.0340930633,
0.0151274903,
0.080637373,
0.0002763195,
-0.0099115754,
0.0354895517,
-0.0005988853,
-0.0248392988,
-0.0155586507,
-0.0538244024,
0.0461408421,
0.0380120873,
0.0564985834,
-0.0541392155,
-0.0500655882,
-0.0111588417,
0.0013591071,
0.0142570604,
0.0406986549,
-0.020072747,
0.0079197763,
-0.0338296033,
-0.0132931583,
-0.0412909463,
-0.0011643078,
-0.0060563055,
0.0200341716,
-0.016937647,
-0.0013373616,
-0.0666664094,
0.0320709758,
0.0411212668,
0.0080533642,
-0.007675583,
-0.0185464602,
-0.0008366566,
0.0350017846,
-0.0052716816,
-0.0091642933,
0.0216091666,
0.0233582743,
-0.0164467283,
-0.0189893264,
0.0001105628,
-0.028115062,
-0.0107887257,
0.0511679277,
-0.0217684843,
-0.0520997718,
0.001809184,
-0.0644307658,
-0.032083191,
0.0404029675,
0.0004182826,
0.0186105035,
0.0001508373,
0.0063352091,
0.02069626,
-0.0418974571,
-0.0147624733,
0.0741418749,
0.0089526298,
-0.0312843882,
0.0017948638,
0.0035441162,
0.0173133221,
-0.0145780919,
0.0118589848,
0.0201728828,
-0.0142186088,
-0.0080094095,
-0.0155276321,
0.0116672199,
-0.0391159207,
-0.0439840443,
-0.0486894548,
0.023277007,
-0.001122389,
0.0350472778,
0.0049287435,
-0.0394545346,
0.0123766903,
0.0010279329,
-0.011896166,
-0.0008114179,
0.0170250051,
-0.0054416652,
0.0433557332,
0.0042033158,
-0.0137760034,
-0.0255271941,
-0.009943678,
-0.0560722947,
0.0243181176,
-0.0084160464,
0.0361484885,
-0.0503066182,
0.0344303437,
-0.0579916909,
0.0137124415,
-0.0276561808,
0.0107375709,
0.0534906387,
-0.0317575634,
-0.0304299835,
0.0965528861,
-0.0175185073,
0.0115472386,
0.0660096034,
-0.0237838421,
-0.056235671,
0.0344217382,
0.014452491,
-0.0217569415,
-0.0697262436,
-0.0003656227,
-0.0396697,
0.0397086106,
-0.0283051208,
0.0131814815,
-0.0177995544,
0.0448505171,
0.0272572897,
0.0172548816,
-0.042979233,
-0.0061723576,
0.0053334888,
0.0768002421,
-0.0001482271,
-0.0265238397,
0.0921904668,
-0.0016272998,
-0.0058544469,
0.0024341345,
-0.01513978,
-0.0433307849,
0.0942478105,
-0.0499733314,
-0.0338474475,
-0.0137237553,
0.0018673567,
-0.039480485,
-0.0693688989,
0.0353246145,
-0.0220301114,
0.1076546982,
-0.0788609535,
0.0162844062,
-0.0095688496,
-0.0396372601,
-0.0512741879,
0.0033065423,
-0.0588968769,
0.0099674957,
-0.0568050705,
-0.0223735478,
-0.0293375496,
-0.0160705838,
0.0168423317,
0.0079976339,
0.0037257024,
-0.0393354185,
-0.0346950516,
-0.0156442039,
0.000469373,
0.0278717,
0.0201251246,
-0.0368877128,
0.0198333953,
0.0143507207,
0.0298063345,
-0.0270194151,
-0.0344721191,
0.0257198792,
-0.0057918071,
-0.0128355296,
-0.0259845443,
0.0409196056,
0.0708518401,
-0.0908098891,
-0.0233066902,
0.1108279601,
0.0396398269,
0.0145960255,
0.0009800858,
-0.0339803994,
0.0227966756,
0.0358183607,
0.0471753627,
-0.0541854501,
-0.0660424531,
0.0402702466,
0.0261883065,
-0.0097388858,
-0.0270554069,
-0.0136667024,
-0.109554939,
0.0300085023,
0.0170958079,
-0.0156231262,
0.0033270142,
-0.0306403078,
-0.0170162842,
-0.0255956817,
-0.0033437933,
0.0158621948,
0.0150993485,
0.0012977873,
0.0058320393,
-0.0079206377,
-0.0158473756,
0.0527155548,
0.0074852379,
0.0405543521,
0.0281963982,
0.0195748843,
0.01040651,
-0.0562107377,
0.0440649018,
0.0282851849,
0.02202015,
-0.0286005586,
-0.010810148,
0.0000752376,
-0.0097287884,
0.0038446365,
0.0437212139,
-0.0632359609,
-0.0499430113,
0.0367759801,
0.0881230757,
-0.0410538092,
-0.0303963851,
-0.0078471126,
-0.0094690202,
-0.0513594747,
0.0610962436,
0.0068369401,
0.0207204353,
-0.08066497,
-0.0707418025,
-0.0766306147,
-0.0465552583,
-0.0231758263,
0.0025436676,
0.0470858999,
-0.0091205398,
-0.0133538712,
0.0117595168,
0.0486005172,
0.0684178472,
-0.0183434822,
-0.0192444567,
-0.0019298369,
0.0105205486,
-0.0395493843,
0.0545476824,
-0.0470763668,
0.0216521099,
-0.0341374651,
0.0008420359,
-0.011336768,
-0.0344642624,
-0.025308134,
0.0170291793,
-0.0694005117,
-0.0791492984,
-0.0214359462,
0.0495249219,
0.038511809,
0.025054574,
-0.0097049605,
-0.0251047481,
0.009721159,
0.0437699109,
-0.0210009124,
-0.0045077321,
0.0583404452,
0.0094211744,
0.0097830519,
0.037216831,
-0.0251733772,
0.0186694022,
0.0404349677,
0.0228417218,
-0.0312477611,
0.0316855498,
0.0204149652,
0.0111593623,
0.0107036186,
0.0167240351,
-0.0382598527,
-0.0114497337,
0.0378221422,
0.0015042297,
-0.0304383989,
-0.0216081217,
0.0130647765,
-0.0111920768,
-0.0239771083,
0.0367941223,
-0.038217891,
-0.0195063055,
0.0232543759,
0.0264069587,
0.0280766506,
0.0345832855,
0.0389544442,
0.0316980109,
-0.0407752283,
-0.0008655035,
0.0417113453,
-0.0182935353,
0.0454749949,
-0.009446702,
0.0500866659,
0.0406346731,
0.0346135944,
-0.0436885394,
-0.0227932483,
-0.0756667405,
-0.107900165,
0.0547623336,
0.040430218,
0.0581430271,
0.0068864049,
-0.0166740082,
-0.0411848277,
0.0026772053,
0.0161261521,
0.0290534813,
0.0389262177,
-0.002793421,
0.0576495118,
0.0525277518,
-0.0045840889,
-0.004154128,
0.0413421877,
-0.0431685895,
0.0509622693,
0.0198579673,
-0.0069356766,
-0.0372409075,
-0.0424721427,
0.0000402053,
0.0229620021,
-0.0168190692,
0.0012079213,
-0.0572113469,
-0.0895000473,
-0.019512061,
0.0532120764,
-0.0185968671,
-0.0030299311,
0.0145948287,
0.0589277893,
0.0206266791,
-0.0268366821,
0.0022071407,
0.0074648201,
-0.001411349,
-0.0038666106,
-0.0152917132,
-5.979434501e-33,
-0.0346653871,
-0.0283581372,
0.0581499636,
-0.0162794497,
0.0187876858,
-0.02262876,
-0.0484265946,
0.0110253207,
-0.0375573896,
0.0020572846,
-0.0264920853,
0.031751167,
0.0060670292,
-0.0077624531,
0.007176864,
-0.0219097901,
-0.0034542545,
0.0254053939,
-0.0469940342,
0.003733285,
0.0445858203,
-0.0245144237,
0.0169033315,
-0.0246308502,
0.0092811855,
0.006668984,
-0.0271182731,
0.0582203567,
-0.0932774767,
0.0678319559,
0.0086171003,
0.004544789,
0.0046102544,
0.0086825741,
-0.0117254984,
0.0036618847,
-0.0394831896,
-0.0302059073,
0.0422651209,
-0.012968068,
-0.0196927041,
-0.0323192962,
0.0596418642,
0.0271096397,
-0.0108160004,
-0.0050229006,
0.0204368327,
-0.0230667274,
0.0186946336,
0.0230723768,
-0.0124584856,
0.0285053533,
-0.0485544689,
-0.0372866988,
-0.0050548622,
-0.0146089075,
-0.0177162737,
0.0141027234,
-0.0191683359,
0.0013771706,
0.0203507431,
0.0014283577,
0.0860963091,
-0.0036396647,
-0.0069676782,
0.0357716717,
-0.0033833468,
-0.008929925,
-0.045751188,
-0.0308553949,
0.0059133307,
0.0838725194,
0.0417145528,
-0.0044044792,
0.0315154232,
0.0242886115,
-0.0813247859,
-0.0092838518,
0.0131798917,
0.0649101511,
0.0171200391,
0.0261425581,
-0.0179255195,
0.0119222794,
-0.0466511399,
0.0260927565,
-0.0411329865,
-0.0074957125,
0.0175299346,
-0.0134344734,
0.0063272598,
-0.0366237797,
0.0052226023,
-0.0413233042,
0.0033181247,
0.0075730444,
-0.0016292421,
0.0085694026,
-0.0113712521,
0.0350422747,
-0.0239785593,
-0.0442084931,
0.0161862671,
-0.0216467232,
0.0355917215,
0.0169539619,
0.0165017825,
0.0065456186,
-0.0388299786,
-0.0123905912,
-0.0725439787,
-0.000997614,
-0.0065379785,
0.0080405856,
0.0516970493,
0.0321644284,
0.0050490364,
0.045010969,
-0.0411975011,
-0.0570893735,
-0.0129673593,
0.0224776715,
-0.0102983331,
0.0181897692,
-0.0211717933,
-0.0192228332,
-0.0191730279,
-0.0124809723,
0.0073715267,
-0.0143542998,
-0.0005550998,
0.05804234,
2.733e-7,
0.0458907075,
0.033262264,
0.0078484789,
0.0546636693,
0.0069400663,
0.0509240255,
-0.064771913,
-0.0320681371,
0.0014168307,
-0.0494952016,
-0.0181306284,
0.0791466907,
0.0364461169,
0.0406065136,
-0.0239362661,
0.0407052301,
0.0081813708,
-0.0391423926,
-0.0761030614,
0.0328901596,
0.0736586228,
0.0879822299,
0.0446585976,
-0.0105293225,
0.0086526806,
-0.042004656,
0.030099744,
-0.0054702922,
-0.002892083,
-0.0054922849,
-0.0055269818,
0.0219484791,
0.0069055348,
0.0559040084,
0.0194416009,
0.0029783321,
-0.0478924029,
0.087264277,
-0.0085700434,
-0.0192018915,
-0.0552148409,
-0.0431039184,
0.0153543949,
-0.0509468615,
0.0929216295,
-0.0503160395,
-0.0478394069,
-0.0055705709,
0.0353014246,
-0.030781012,
-0.0221835338,
0.0048583285,
0.0129640698,
0.0042471248,
-0.0094824247,
-0.0146985603,
0.0021634083,
-0.1021572649,
-0.004089362,
0.0354544595,
-0.0307242069,
-0.0251356997,
-0.0229402687,
0.0276376624,
0.0525483936,
-0.0395842865,
-0.0198043659,
2.705451447e-34,
0.0305369999,
0.0022894868,
-0.0006308599,
0.0224492624,
0.0528848693,
0.0126018384,
-0.0547545142,
0.0146576893,
0.0452037714,
-0.0478454232,
-0.0092391344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13762v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13762v1 | Unveiling the Hidden Structure of Self-Attention via Kernel Principal Component Analysis | 2024-06-19T18:22:32 | 2024-06-19T18:22:32 | Rachel S. Y. Teo, Tan M. Nguyen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | The remarkable success of transformers in sequence modeling tasks, spanning
various applications in natural language processing and computer vision, is
attributed to the critical role of self-attention. Similar to the development
of most deep learning models, the construction of these attention mechanisms
rely on heuristics and experience. In our work, we derive self-attention from
kernel principal component analysis (kernel PCA) and show that self-attention
projects its query vectors onto the principal component axes of its key matrix
in a feature space. We then formulate the exact formula for the value matrix in
self-attention, theoretically and empirically demonstrating that this value
matrix captures the eigenvectors of the Gram matrix of the key vectors in
self-attention. Leveraging our kernel PCA framework, we propose Attention with
Robust Principal Components (RPC-Attention), a novel class of robust attention
that is resilient to data contamination. We empirically demonstrate the
advantages of RPC-Attention over softmax attention on the ImageNet-1K object
classification, WikiText-103 language modeling, and ADE20K image segmentation
task. | [
0.0228312854,
0.0466647111,
-0.0282038413,
0.0539464317,
0.0047300807,
0.0253212042,
-0.0069045443,
-0.0447398163,
-0.0228752028,
-0.0149240484,
-0.0172392223,
-0.028204659,
0.0184883568,
0.0339134969,
0.0362256877,
-0.0310559142,
0.0377883352,
-0.0048048422,
-0.0392858014,
-0.0019067464,
-0.0052921367,
-0.0309343226,
0.0279885065,
0.0315277539,
-0.0625738204,
-0.0342390649,
-0.0138271889,
-0.0387558416,
0.0042211851,
-0.0360335112,
-0.002303466,
0.0623835549,
0.0137947593,
-0.0154076349,
0.0000022321,
-0.0115418602,
0.014205589,
-0.0072076521,
0.0132430326,
0.0416781418,
-0.0002866486,
-0.0153208394,
0.0110097881,
-0.033925429,
-0.004289032,
0.0004270933,
0.0677640885,
0.0891816393,
0.0512908325,
0.0496180244,
0.000264408,
-0.0254845582,
0.0032677269,
-0.0333298109,
0.0089821946,
-0.0205124076,
0.0313829109,
-0.0774911344,
-0.0254088026,
0.0099138897,
-0.0315339379,
0.0511465929,
0.0016204679,
-0.0425958782,
0.0581915677,
0.046681039,
-0.0351552665,
-0.0486589335,
0.0232070554,
0.0716142505,
-0.0303147547,
-0.0001877745,
0.0351440981,
-0.0084559247,
0.017913213,
0.010509789,
-0.0313285999,
-0.0092658224,
0.0619905218,
0.0115092276,
-0.0108419117,
0.0054489351,
-0.0008321982,
-0.0352815352,
0.003557255,
0.039402131,
0.0030067654,
-0.0221970081,
-0.021893831,
0.0424962342,
-0.0114048403,
-0.0219027959,
0.0088632824,
0.0327730365,
0.0522203185,
-0.0168523304,
-0.0497483946,
-0.0466448851,
-0.0009910597,
-0.0889154077,
0.0239881594,
-0.0015792849,
-0.0784367397,
-0.0131176077,
-0.0038435296,
0.042992793,
-0.0602692775,
0.0655726418,
-0.0342559442,
0.0260537826,
-0.0027617272,
0.0137320347,
-0.0129440809,
0.0550735369,
0.040106155,
0.0020427753,
-0.0412704647,
0.0340348929,
-0.0172762871,
-0.060832873,
0.0165659245,
0.0661284998,
-0.0244220719,
0.0088186003,
0.028566068,
0.0488935336,
-0.0004314653,
-0.0139728691,
-0.0588490479,
-0.0310453922,
-0.0648508593,
0.0452092141,
0.0300707482,
-0.0338956527,
-0.0203331914,
0.0479438938,
0.0035554213,
-0.0691017359,
-0.0094801243,
-0.0159184188,
-0.0671043172,
-0.0247827023,
0.0015168274,
-0.0201636795,
-0.023506131,
-0.0039719106,
-0.0212404877,
-0.0323331915,
0.00816241,
0.005611537,
-0.0364506394,
0.0744787976,
0.0638415813,
-0.0023801883,
0.0403583311,
0.0057167937,
0.0233874004,
0.0237062797,
0.0116565349,
0.0080869012,
0.0136629688,
-0.0494104512,
0.0511770844,
0.0229990408,
0.003820837,
-0.0306406152,
-0.0104955137,
-0.0033882523,
0.0037227839,
-0.0191712342,
0.0449305624,
0.0184652023,
0.0292375386,
-0.0509892404,
0.0585180186,
0.0524391346,
-0.0371124074,
0.0427669175,
-0.0006570296,
0.0244833324,
-0.0451783724,
0.0417222194,
-0.0761042312,
0.0523962229,
0.0360304043,
-0.0317351669,
-0.0345606618,
-0.0044604084,
-0.0367538221,
-0.0303517021,
-0.0012518885,
0.0110949194,
-0.0455423743,
0.0067587616,
0.054145433,
-0.0265584681,
-0.0075483308,
0.0498711802,
-0.0251185149,
-0.0387323834,
0.033327762,
-0.0289485008,
0.0399432667,
0.0144983754,
0.0091791786,
-0.0525151752,
0.0057359072,
-0.0303386468,
-0.0095229037,
-0.019338835,
0.0076134396,
0.0196568966,
0.0001691246,
-0.004522854,
-0.0503823049,
-0.0281902887,
0.0017240436,
0.0115877967,
-0.0599469803,
0.0113668982,
0.0337513201,
-0.0225944649,
-0.005519208,
0.0502764657,
0.0325947516,
-0.0374841727,
0.0361089148,
0.0418440327,
0.0234377906,
0.0267637502,
-0.0026219201,
0.0191699676,
0.073647581,
-0.0349336676,
0.0061132358,
-0.0086668571,
-0.0474063158,
0.0265277475,
0.0333795995,
-0.0550797544,
-0.0204904079,
0.0492728651,
-0.001456383,
-0.040496774,
0.069694154,
-0.0522302203,
-0.081854485,
-0.0402183011,
0.0085502453,
-0.0181157142,
0.106081225,
-0.0120723555,
0.02935257,
-0.0045867357,
-0.0187123287,
0.0064160191,
-0.0112049375,
0.0137455594,
-0.0420519151,
-0.0472198464,
0.0000412337,
-0.0162756797,
0.0033762504,
0.0274557732,
-0.0466787778,
0.0114955474,
0.014014014,
-0.0052672531,
-0.0414733216,
-0.0438841656,
0.0071851197,
-0.0014357718,
-0.0284410305,
0.0264293216,
-0.0184317306,
-0.0159021281,
0.0300984904,
0.0144261876,
0.0112161664,
0.0415203944,
-0.0227389447,
0.0113394205,
-0.0443092994,
-0.0384136625,
0.0078256261,
0.0520942956,
0.0020166996,
-0.0448144823,
-0.0367023498,
-0.0163991991,
0.0126001472,
0.0386596806,
0.0039282385,
-0.0432848446,
-0.0043580821,
-0.0474992469,
0.0179597363,
0.085608542,
0.0305788368,
0.0486189201,
0.0610060245,
-0.0006980262,
0.0174542405,
0.004119576,
-0.0565077886,
0.0205135364,
0.0016577587,
-0.0004047688,
0.0201953016,
0.0764439777,
-0.0117500685,
-0.0392384417,
-0.0588275418,
-0.0445974879,
-0.0094561884,
-0.0429521166,
0.0090964502,
-0.014748686,
-0.0348761044,
0.0152393952,
-0.0009410301,
-0.0125012295,
0.0705010891,
0.0037925737,
0.0158500168,
0.0365690701,
-0.0181132667,
0.0015161994,
0.0275198724,
0.0458465554,
-0.0127845202,
0.0139671378,
-0.045112595,
-0.020039022,
-0.006709347,
0.0047390088,
-0.0182133205,
0.1030366123,
-0.0219736397,
0.0107212113,
0.005145357,
-0.0101622632,
-0.0639743209,
-0.030649215,
0.0193872936,
-0.021231832,
-0.0415306911,
0.004303141,
-0.0631954819,
0.0288851298,
0.0387631729,
0.0328398086,
-0.0023414118,
0.0213830918,
0.0114972042,
0.0894184411,
0.0496885031,
0.037440151,
0.0193348341,
-0.0162107348,
0.0213622265,
0.0590926595,
0.0303263888,
0.0081552882,
0.0158391707,
0.0023596771,
0.0107853962,
-0.0078069866,
-0.0482816771,
0.0346958153,
0.0008823102,
-0.0626633912,
-0.0664252117,
0.0610121116,
-0.0116627822,
-0.0590604581,
0.0008092996,
0.0052857818,
-0.0049232985,
0.0529177412,
0.0322127342,
0.0060014264,
0.0038240999,
-0.0286146086,
0.0483780839,
0.0183676686,
-0.047011409,
0.0090364525,
-0.0581231751,
0.0643891916,
-0.0025369178,
-0.0301308259,
-0.0866939574,
-0.0418093912,
0.0076495241,
-0.0482120328,
0.0052459575,
-0.0115806283,
0.0097490232,
-0.012457991,
0.0443584695,
-0.0026377114,
-0.0415900424,
-0.01046055,
-0.0115878712,
-0.0067610173,
0.0212749075,
-0.0093754046,
-0.0361422524,
-0.0636282489,
-0.0241942704,
-0.0592349619,
0.0099298181,
0.0384715237,
0.0533813164,
-0.0248873122,
-0.0611804835,
0.0205196906,
0.0282113347,
-0.0526298918,
0.0214212965,
-0.0369820707,
0.0870061368,
-0.0221476406,
-0.0410448425,
-0.0418153405,
-0.0234981421,
-0.0298679192,
0.0426616184,
0.033550445,
-0.0332600735,
-0.031619139,
0.0184408408,
0.0625683069,
-0.0052839452,
-0.0477061309,
0.0134787746,
0.0262314696,
-0.0858241916,
-0.0548431799,
-0.0385286063,
0.0105361789,
-0.0066076806,
0.0008935828,
-0.0360456854,
0.0119197126,
-0.0046524112,
-0.0744877309,
0.0451035164,
-0.0064411522,
-0.0235281736,
-0.0472863093,
0.0312433075,
0.0449576788,
-0.0283571053,
-0.0035541898,
0.0265761092,
-0.0648939684,
-0.0687038302,
0.0625813305,
0.0520733036,
-0.0039773295,
0.0088769151,
-0.0054118726,
-0.077038534,
0.0248874258,
0.0532202683,
-0.0189585816,
0.0253751017,
0.0131096672,
-0.0875600427,
-0.0304910019,
0.0304233357,
-0.0336551107,
0.0598183423,
0.0084686484,
0.0028425273,
0.0015901054,
-0.0707127824,
0.0186908133,
0.010862153,
0.0908079296,
0.0097084465,
0.056862615,
-0.0301892385,
0.003969925,
0.0323498733,
-0.0115043726,
-0.0328410119,
0.0091001876,
0.0131815989,
0.0263654776,
-0.0147684384,
0.0120792668,
-0.0462664105,
0.0239429493,
-0.0369215906,
-0.0068613822,
-0.0199463516,
-0.0194647983,
-0.0033200406,
0.0432530567,
0.0149805984,
0.0090273395,
0.0038968211,
0.0253767408,
-0.011079384,
0.0094891693,
-0.0068026329,
0.0677691251,
-0.0380334109,
-0.0038754966,
-0.0877129585,
0.0037876756,
-0.0267482344,
0.0093257772,
0.027123807,
-0.054055579,
0.0314458087,
0.0088878339,
-0.0332929567,
-0.0353536271,
0.0082504358,
-0.0097524403,
0.0090769213,
0.0374345928,
0.0197563749,
0.0089548277,
-0.008841401,
0.0513147414,
-0.0260835327,
0.0157596711,
-0.0284554809,
-0.0391098298,
-0.0381688178,
-0.0015885874,
0.0087369047,
-0.0007732066,
-0.0251712576,
0.0109866299,
0.0089123202,
-0.0706050694,
0.0139555512,
-0.0463436171,
-0.0106920209,
-0.0158520546,
0.0388623774,
0.0401619487,
0.0218091942,
0.0163194556,
0.0001729328,
0.0217933469,
-0.0028115751,
-0.0226377565,
0.0320435315,
-6.940782802e-33,
0.0191161204,
-0.0368377417,
-0.0650144592,
0.0523851514,
-0.020854963,
-0.0054713506,
-0.0073863897,
0.0159847084,
0.0006110362,
0.0240600072,
-0.017238982,
0.0084718885,
0.0008222726,
0.0420200415,
0.0409844257,
-0.0373977162,
0.0635242239,
-0.0239114538,
0.018346671,
0.0422098488,
0.0217539985,
0.0447568186,
0.0811243951,
-0.0633550808,
-0.0028014972,
0.0104511101,
0.015819585,
-0.0025268872,
0.0080901533,
0.0579863973,
-0.0364585333,
0.0436353646,
0.0334018059,
-0.0368660837,
-0.0023591521,
0.0146926763,
-0.0664052293,
-0.0252750553,
-0.0662072301,
0.0076292823,
-0.0372548811,
-0.0172679052,
0.0870132372,
-0.0027646408,
-0.0099878768,
-0.0135972863,
0.063446641,
0.0071293102,
-0.0361755267,
0.0098527595,
-0.0132628959,
-0.0029182835,
-0.041676715,
-0.006032872,
0.0664810315,
0.0293296296,
0.0145851001,
0.0579918288,
-0.0566361919,
-0.0044240826,
-0.023386905,
0.0450097397,
0.0616073534,
0.0323996581,
-0.0066824057,
0.0161628705,
0.058063522,
-0.0169342086,
-0.0167194922,
-0.0645515844,
-0.0072301123,
0.0173483454,
0.0561333261,
0.0276460536,
-0.0047979653,
-0.0254465826,
-0.0670317486,
0.0081434296,
-0.0698642135,
0.0367263965,
0.0176229179,
-0.0090685859,
0.0028540364,
-0.0040508471,
-0.0239501595,
-0.0294052456,
-0.0536545217,
0.0278838724,
0.0232208073,
-0.0060478076,
-0.054751832,
0.0641845912,
0.0237804092,
-0.0230320711,
0.015147048,
0.0074422439,
-0.0019308215,
0.0152016878,
0.0331478119,
0.0088218143,
-0.0545723587,
0.0057525379,
0.0092416452,
0.0028869589,
-0.0041249152,
-0.0389228612,
0.0135287056,
0.0334229507,
-0.0418856256,
-0.0322507694,
-0.0231774636,
0.0411630608,
-0.0122639332,
0.0840980336,
0.044691544,
-0.0211766958,
0.0006090016,
0.0705650896,
0.023097625,
0.0340728499,
-0.0208276417,
0.0108709102,
0.0264761243,
0.0163453873,
-0.0086311586,
0.0009760793,
-0.0319477133,
0.0447024442,
0.0532289185,
-0.1037571877,
0.0046232119,
0.0237252377,
3.122e-7,
0.034736231,
0.0343963467,
-0.0011342693,
-0.0521577448,
0.0391684249,
0.0670034289,
-0.0044423067,
0.0770759806,
-0.0270241108,
-0.073315464,
0.035966143,
0.0221095216,
0.0018928078,
-0.0093304971,
-0.0190743301,
0.0256991126,
-0.0484427288,
0.0527904034,
-0.0096689137,
0.0057178042,
0.0315791331,
0.0915060863,
-0.0197152738,
-0.0230537131,
0.0201344304,
0.0009766831,
0.055137977,
0.0225775298,
0.0229434893,
-0.029449556,
0.0412028618,
0.015758343,
-0.0249373149,
0.0285286549,
-0.0286648087,
0.0323597565,
0.0360142514,
0.0198461935,
-0.0122262202,
-0.0744256526,
0.0141626615,
0.0353193022,
0.0241107717,
-0.0797767863,
0.0662784502,
-0.0813018456,
-0.0341418758,
-0.0253713187,
-0.0201091394,
0.0081758071,
0.039602872,
-0.0161528513,
0.0252137613,
0.0269404072,
0.0138141261,
-0.0264504142,
-0.0189238228,
-0.0914743096,
0.0158486515,
-0.028185945,
-0.0529606938,
0.0532076359,
-0.0706726015,
-0.0530771464,
0.0678119138,
0.0382362604,
-0.0241866317,
2.138340396e-34,
0.0076288385,
-0.0209690593,
-0.0154335611,
-0.040449366,
-0.0192061849,
-0.0446134694,
-0.0175634213,
-0.0020865547,
0.0002428826,
-0.0629347414,
-0.0412107222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13748v1 | Every Language Counts: Learn and Unlearn in Multilingual LLMs | 2024-06-19T18:01:08 | 2024-06-19T18:01:08 | Taiming Lu, Philipp Koehn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper investigates the propagation of harmful information in
multilingual large language models (LLMs) and evaluates the efficacy of various
unlearning methods. We demonstrate that fake information, regardless of the
language it is in, once introduced into these models through training data, can
spread across different languages, compromising the integrity and reliability
of the generated content. Our findings reveal that standard unlearning
techniques, which typically focus on English data, are insufficient in
mitigating the spread of harmful content in multilingual contexts and could
inadvertently reinforce harmful content across languages. We show that only by
addressing harmful responses in both English and the original language of the
harmful data can we effectively eliminate generations for all languages. This
underscores the critical need for comprehensive unlearning strategies that
consider the multilingual nature of modern LLMs to enhance their safety and
reliability across diverse linguistic landscapes. | [
0.0247846544,
0.076518096,
-0.0291666891,
0.0731492788,
-0.0402085744,
0.0199080184,
0.0227975361,
0.0161384344,
0.0181882288,
-0.0068610986,
-0.017187776,
-0.0447313562,
0.0058023566,
0.0019274158,
0.0316295289,
0.0026293891,
0.0576910228,
-0.0388914198,
-0.024999002,
-0.0431235917,
0.0177388024,
0.0137340641,
0.0619360097,
0.0032189081,
-0.0236717556,
-0.0337683484,
0.0149350148,
-0.0230246279,
0.0199915897,
-0.0025779018,
0.0084946714,
0.0101316581,
0.0149399284,
0.0746624693,
0.0000017374,
-0.0298206154,
-0.019375369,
0.0063402229,
-0.0254524443,
0.0326795578,
0.0490890592,
-0.01547579,
-0.0390912555,
0.0019603651,
-0.0210473482,
-0.0034765752,
0.0275529083,
0.018938167,
0.0584995039,
0.0612811856,
0.001453922,
-0.0268086884,
0.023652371,
-0.0136015331,
0.0247998573,
-0.0060233469,
0.0694558695,
-0.00218329,
-0.0619318485,
-0.0066320281,
-0.0200907215,
0.0462392531,
0.0128232492,
-0.0137192309,
-0.0326736867,
-0.0011279021,
0.0140581792,
-0.0457771979,
0.0064426684,
0.0554812849,
-0.018052632,
-0.0345356055,
0.0119469501,
-0.0002219076,
-0.0026553608,
-0.000498503,
-0.0200454723,
0.0588575676,
-0.0101287272,
0.0197546165,
0.0274763387,
-0.0447796583,
0.0807696208,
0.0247039404,
0.0177729055,
0.0557754226,
0.0174232908,
-0.031900797,
0.0105893929,
0.0074337884,
0.0348765329,
-0.0438090637,
0.0008818512,
-0.0010291942,
-0.0043489309,
0.0385254472,
-0.014573711,
-0.0214499272,
0.0391578712,
-0.0968844295,
-0.0102165937,
-0.0052710567,
-0.0321812071,
0.0419488139,
-0.0001227484,
0.0178979952,
-0.0302138552,
0.028379973,
-0.0148711801,
-0.0132820774,
0.0215603337,
-0.0072401711,
0.0492689162,
0.0265479088,
0.0238196589,
0.0512931123,
-0.035633944,
0.0169697292,
-0.0474209785,
0.0252858978,
-0.0362908691,
-0.0237102322,
-0.0271074586,
-0.0050972174,
-0.0164539963,
0.0527583361,
-0.0169064626,
0.0042960849,
-0.0137255955,
-0.0596231408,
-0.0000446084,
0.0265007541,
-0.0458090901,
-0.0100525226,
0.0226487201,
0.0662922934,
0.0022038664,
0.0067005842,
-0.0714449584,
-0.0434490815,
-0.0313052498,
-0.0788623616,
0.0272634793,
-0.0698279738,
0.011484785,
-0.0302563235,
-0.0095386235,
-0.0739898756,
0.0104538566,
0.0011231489,
-0.0890606344,
0.0166250244,
-0.0221740399,
0.0072854669,
0.0310797859,
0.027126519,
-0.0074316398,
0.0812075958,
-0.0052631446,
0.0385017656,
0.0570835434,
-0.0244993679,
0.0097501138,
0.0737867802,
0.0339850672,
0.0610106625,
-0.014886735,
-0.0051410045,
0.044131007,
-0.0220127366,
0.0268869568,
0.0408562757,
-0.0217771027,
-0.0204658099,
0.0755134225,
-0.0284197759,
-0.0714782774,
0.0410553031,
0.0223516747,
-0.0211006589,
-0.0148078697,
0.0603998601,
-0.0443256833,
-0.0205825139,
-0.0324602127,
-0.015020757,
-0.0066948431,
0.072080113,
-0.0150115388,
-0.0103831831,
0.0076561645,
-0.0240118019,
0.0340891145,
0.0258810725,
0.0237794667,
0.0529967956,
0.0053220834,
0.0458446629,
0.0853372142,
-0.0547052808,
0.0475844704,
-0.0259039719,
0.0365066268,
0.0445508622,
0.0471344888,
0.0077312961,
-0.0040476918,
-0.0456201211,
0.0279844664,
0.0326697566,
0.026488876,
-0.0306792818,
0.0160255004,
-0.0363149643,
-0.0316699371,
0.0129981935,
-0.0001950805,
0.0231028646,
0.0188897774,
0.00908898,
0.0019905737,
-0.0044776849,
-0.0673873499,
0.0159997959,
-0.0747518763,
-0.0110857161,
-0.0115084304,
0.0139151104,
0.0173995644,
0.0172956977,
-0.0290860273,
-0.037097238,
0.0419683568,
0.0125750341,
-0.0094989985,
0.011369626,
-0.0389250331,
0.0171025302,
0.0516743287,
-0.040018864,
-0.0324205048,
0.0141632678,
-0.0157309826,
0.0243636053,
0.0228283685,
-0.0180704873,
0.0269173384,
-0.0226648953,
0.0288904514,
-0.0601696149,
0.005594512,
0.012125724,
0.0655385852,
-0.0231650174,
0.0098206941,
0.0270793606,
-0.0480532609,
0.0029800048,
-0.0061405841,
-0.0338873677,
0.0248565078,
0.0035872599,
0.0108726965,
0.0413282216,
0.0077692177,
-0.0163837932,
-0.0042926855,
-0.0223071203,
-0.0131540215,
-0.0163875129,
0.0131499926,
0.0346263871,
-0.0060202125,
-0.0130026946,
0.0030325069,
-0.0459802076,
0.0108942417,
0.0156662539,
0.0500782281,
-0.0195825957,
-0.0276708882,
-0.000846673,
0.0019002166,
0.0231024977,
0.0011569327,
0.0678590834,
0.0018968933,
-0.0323962159,
-0.0390637815,
0.0347632803,
-0.0799511299,
0.0187884066,
-0.0212431327,
-0.0386431031,
-0.0080418754,
0.0169071387,
0.0178246107,
0.03287521,
-0.0053719166,
0.0286158472,
0.0792618468,
-0.0100377072,
-0.0437557399,
-0.0284747053,
-0.0354604721,
-0.0250581577,
-0.0314808413,
-0.065194957,
-0.0238516722,
0.034277834,
0.0300258119,
-0.019094076,
-0.0222792495,
0.0330231525,
-0.0649107695,
-0.0665040612,
-0.0147314798,
-0.0583861619,
-0.0273228213,
0.0036978568,
-0.025372183,
-0.0676701739,
0.0567133576,
0.0065436261,
0.0401383825,
-0.0223954786,
-0.0005180339,
0.0100779133,
0.0161828194,
-0.0126845129,
0.0611424819,
0.025242798,
-0.0115532158,
-0.0471422225,
0.0010202888,
0.0637557134,
-0.0230626892,
0.0136454199,
-0.047929354,
-0.0099639324,
0.0170934275,
-0.0553863682,
-0.0517492183,
-0.0428952426,
0.0173942875,
-0.0367191657,
0.0137655921,
-0.0088216178,
-0.0308696721,
-0.067150481,
0.0879242346,
-0.0320066027,
-0.011624543,
0.018403139,
0.0008123039,
0.0166977253,
0.0528125875,
-0.0466573164,
0.0482256413,
-0.0574424118,
0.0055514155,
0.0733144879,
-0.0279366914,
-0.0160204023,
0.0358669981,
0.0086969445,
0.0265242849,
0.0293174479,
-0.0162292365,
0.0121476315,
0.0284019187,
-0.0409551114,
-0.0067877932,
0.0610918365,
0.0025068303,
-0.0249172337,
-0.0049285656,
-0.0155328512,
0.0054591103,
0.0166394487,
-0.0150643848,
-0.1040632501,
0.0201184563,
0.0124239149,
-0.0043590055,
-0.0258090738,
-0.0374015048,
0.0034061263,
-0.1099466905,
0.0106997686,
0.0481890589,
-0.0587545522,
-0.0292945802,
-0.0407862104,
-0.0430843532,
0.0069933478,
0.0393835679,
-0.0222168807,
0.0078675039,
-0.0412315987,
0.0006895412,
-0.0136472825,
-0.0525099151,
-0.0043903911,
-0.0349943526,
0.0423460193,
0.0425862335,
0.0284133591,
-0.0364050195,
-0.0368643031,
0.0450385101,
0.0119319567,
-0.0380851068,
-0.0081313811,
0.040202789,
0.0203421619,
-0.0181526523,
-0.0137628298,
0.0144679928,
0.0297209229,
-0.012214168,
0.0116675096,
0.1061333045,
0.0184958819,
-0.0643968955,
-0.0020156545,
-0.0154449437,
0.0211524628,
0.0803751051,
-0.009780094,
-0.034948945,
0.0179707333,
-0.0569385961,
0.0009855765,
0.0235549696,
-0.0434383564,
0.0473475978,
-0.0390547141,
-0.0591647886,
-0.0615307316,
-0.0272234641,
-0.0093486644,
-0.0233638603,
0.0705633312,
0.0066046207,
-0.0086401971,
-0.032114055,
0.010019565,
-0.0211759135,
-0.0668457299,
-0.0014260107,
-0.0302736424,
0.0108525977,
-0.0022366298,
-0.0289257653,
0.0189997219,
0.0262778308,
-0.0779099539,
-0.1082609221,
0.0258319434,
0.0659250319,
0.0207383819,
0.0645290092,
0.0212329924,
-0.0553560741,
0.0845970735,
0.0212268699,
-0.0233800691,
0.0104158893,
0.0212148353,
-0.0169491172,
0.0230399352,
0.0498538353,
-0.0485658906,
-0.0085090157,
0.0611849278,
-0.0264039133,
-0.056407921,
0.0062468527,
0.0131694553,
0.0383153558,
0.0101591321,
-0.0518994778,
-0.0171229299,
-0.0452891998,
-0.0042754966,
-0.0343968607,
-0.0332386643,
0.0166458338,
0.0184679683,
0.0414664857,
0.0244376846,
0.0317326188,
0.0310151633,
0.0134620834,
0.0121715879,
-0.0287406016,
-0.0026351307,
0.0255282763,
0.0287035666,
0.0572778918,
0.0335317142,
-0.0080247587,
0.0383321531,
0.0059298775,
0.035593126,
0.0093267299,
0.0320626013,
0.0039009084,
-0.0267289672,
0.0490396544,
-0.0268471409,
-0.0135200787,
-0.0475667939,
-0.0277154651,
0.002593061,
0.0627684146,
0.0055152345,
0.0575369373,
0.0017331612,
-0.0240100697,
-0.0232062489,
-0.0099185174,
-0.0091654658,
-0.0714917704,
-0.0005308961,
-0.0147054736,
-0.0511479117,
0.0557897314,
0.07819096,
-0.0179168005,
0.0743725151,
0.003106345,
-0.0210929513,
-0.020620279,
-0.0185452979,
0.0157930758,
-0.0097455932,
-0.0334510393,
-0.0142679289,
-0.0483984351,
-0.0795967057,
-0.0114879189,
0.0000915249,
0.0071604718,
-0.0000157389,
-0.0049766931,
0.065222092,
0.0010774687,
0.0056358012,
-0.0562955961,
0.0252121408,
0.010535039,
-0.022971848,
0.0144993225,
-5.976080302e-33,
0.0411746018,
-0.0204430558,
-0.0093431585,
0.0197415613,
0.0038740602,
0.0011958581,
-0.0078286482,
-0.0030902312,
-0.0379276872,
0.0394424833,
0.0215335842,
-0.008495667,
-0.0021054475,
-0.0007226667,
-0.0163280591,
-0.0275938064,
0.0474590324,
-0.007999015,
-0.0177035667,
0.0444276296,
0.0642064512,
0.0139271934,
0.0939118266,
-0.0753216147,
0.0674813911,
-0.0195001643,
-0.0275984164,
0.0329190493,
-0.0233298708,
0.0250075422,
-0.0152154444,
0.0414146371,
0.0056848577,
-0.0262346026,
-0.0153241446,
0.0106683783,
-0.0085480362,
-0.0153981689,
0.0412248857,
0.0146453511,
0.0036015988,
-0.0655144155,
0.0625602677,
-0.0254854802,
-0.0339769498,
0.0031488519,
0.0216275547,
-0.0039329152,
-0.0100794882,
-0.0166056436,
-0.0580502301,
-0.005335364,
0.00095338,
0.0194408409,
-0.0028470394,
0.0518033803,
0.0186908282,
-0.0055934796,
-0.1005266681,
0.0488432944,
0.0159429777,
0.0044447309,
0.0705510899,
-0.0425054021,
0.0162020177,
0.0891921297,
0.0342203006,
0.0458601676,
0.0030816752,
-0.0117260935,
0.0256078579,
0.000300304,
0.0442748703,
0.1008076891,
-0.0146651203,
-0.0588075221,
-0.0995257571,
0.0121863149,
0.0160835572,
0.0296128858,
-0.0121084927,
-0.0121037727,
-0.0130873574,
-0.0227003675,
-0.0291238483,
-0.0204493701,
-0.0191128105,
-0.0231989697,
0.0040026531,
-0.0192206614,
-0.0280739255,
-0.0025328018,
0.0241787024,
-0.0528301559,
-0.0383613333,
0.0344012864,
-0.0039667701,
-0.0255230144,
0.0354830883,
0.0373762548,
-0.0582164787,
0.0092188288,
-0.0361729115,
-0.0508990437,
0.0250742547,
0.0324327871,
0.0654169396,
0.0364642628,
-0.0581641607,
0.0253393967,
-0.0429072864,
0.037303593,
0.0604694933,
-0.0084729139,
0.0350244828,
-0.0060353004,
0.0053354022,
-0.011900085,
0.1147512496,
0.0309130047,
-0.0356452502,
0.0167035516,
-0.0112796901,
0.0302175116,
-0.0194678474,
-0.0206668843,
-0.0265044551,
0.0537142456,
0.0620270371,
-0.0876124501,
-0.0117164347,
-0.0181280728,
2.517e-7,
-0.0151034072,
0.0488855802,
-0.0041214726,
0.0110849533,
0.03667989,
0.0511592291,
-0.0274887364,
0.0236856062,
0.0017297604,
-0.0342967808,
-0.022098152,
-0.0044627208,
0.046284914,
0.066956684,
-0.082675077,
0.0245535411,
-0.0689816698,
-0.017398132,
-0.0574904568,
-0.0303616207,
-0.0273760725,
0.078679949,
0.0288516656,
-0.0318496898,
-0.0094252266,
-0.0198721364,
0.0492893457,
-0.0374721549,
-0.0431656428,
0.0003059288,
0.0098540038,
0.0081638759,
-0.0021693476,
0.0012383545,
-0.0302806366,
-0.0181529969,
-0.0258178096,
0.0137212118,
0.0229948964,
-0.0167382378,
-0.0142285293,
-0.048659876,
-0.0129611064,
-0.068428576,
0.0631993786,
0.0243141018,
-0.0239211712,
-0.0367318057,
-0.0145410914,
-0.0125035755,
0.0513824038,
-0.0351254605,
-0.0358102955,
0.0139180068,
0.0090345284,
0.0365071446,
-0.0014252824,
-0.0092137968,
-0.0135351922,
-0.0192415286,
-0.040705584,
-0.0777916387,
0.012392425,
0.0069623985,
-0.0414327383,
-0.0598465316,
0.0590090305,
2.044078147e-34,
0.0081126355,
-0.0490728393,
0.0181786641,
-0.023993196,
0.0202007536,
-0.0153802354,
-0.0074692084,
-0.0071756435,
-0.0043997425,
0.0057173907,
-0.0026778404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13743v2 | GenAI-Bench: Evaluating and Improving Compositional Text-to-Visual Generation | 2024-06-19T18:00:07 | 2024-06-21T19:09:36 | Baiqi Li, Zhiqiu Lin, Deepak Pathak, Jiayao Li, Yixin Fei, Kewen Wu, Tiffany Ling, Xide Xia, Pengchuan Zhang, Graham Neubig, Deva Ramanan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | While text-to-visual models now produce photo-realistic images and videos,
they struggle with compositional text prompts involving attributes,
relationships, and higher-order reasoning such as logic and comparison. In this
work, we conduct an extensive human study on GenAI-Bench to evaluate the
performance of leading image and video generation models in various aspects of
compositional text-to-visual generation. We also compare automated evaluation
metrics against our collected human ratings and find that VQAScore -- a metric
measuring the likelihood that a VQA model views an image as accurately
depicting the prompt -- significantly outperforms previous metrics such as
CLIPScore. In addition, VQAScore can improve generation in a black-box manner
(without finetuning) via simply ranking a few (3 to 9) candidate images.
Ranking by VQAScore is 2x to 3x more effective than other scoring methods like
PickScore, HPSv2, and ImageReward at improving human alignment ratings for
DALL-E 3 and Stable Diffusion, especially on compositional prompts that require
advanced visio-linguistic reasoning. We will release a new GenAI-Rank benchmark
with over 40,000 human ratings to evaluate scoring metrics on ranking images
generated from the same prompt. Lastly, we discuss promising areas for
improvement in VQAScore, such as addressing fine-grained visual details. We
will release all human ratings (over 80,000) to facilitate scientific
benchmarking of both generative models and automated metrics. | [
0.0129101686,
0.0494224802,
0.0155718252,
0.0026976326,
-0.0130474092,
0.0121709583,
0.0216040332,
-0.0041755652,
-0.0081387172,
-0.021949077,
-0.0169845521,
-0.058358252,
0.0477924831,
0.0600315481,
0.0436098054,
-0.0893609375,
-0.0181202684,
-0.0149077121,
0.0097665833,
0.0177745651,
0.0033541403,
0.0158149879,
-0.0113182059,
0.0392884426,
-0.0405015945,
-0.0310741346,
-0.0163068604,
0.030471107,
0.0615435168,
-0.0344116129,
-0.0369053744,
0.0578432865,
-0.0065470254,
-0.0167424213,
0.0000020493,
-0.0210718308,
0.0456990413,
0.005910344,
0.0301960912,
-0.0052023153,
0.0352798514,
0.0037011511,
-0.0079509718,
-0.0056227301,
-0.0336170346,
0.0337160714,
0.0660265088,
0.0282758605,
0.082187742,
0.0398769714,
-0.0271541625,
-0.0238941144,
-0.0086171357,
-0.0407502651,
0.0387417264,
0.0009014386,
-0.0184131227,
0.017709801,
0.0145382211,
0.0109076789,
-0.0204014443,
0.0314592719,
0.0390616134,
-0.031080693,
0.023139691,
0.066993624,
-0.0005976142,
-0.0282582827,
-0.0052378913,
0.0860257894,
-0.0035056921,
0.0025534015,
-0.0327132493,
-0.0209362768,
0.0193903558,
-0.0230266117,
-0.0274979901,
0.0300203431,
-0.0122000277,
0.0055778283,
-0.0458265841,
0.0518057868,
0.0019040931,
-0.0200836379,
0.0415243022,
-0.0237128511,
0.0399953835,
0.005856399,
0.0002589024,
0.0323826,
0.0043756096,
-0.0750356764,
0.0287465863,
0.0225509405,
-0.017717205,
-0.0070091947,
-0.0633726716,
-0.0126789957,
-0.011552332,
-0.0194984861,
0.0689946562,
0.0409864895,
-0.02383532,
0.0268357508,
-0.0368125476,
0.0801554248,
0.0148660131,
0.0246153735,
-0.0615684651,
0.0282274615,
-0.0196741931,
-0.0194777809,
-0.0077553801,
-0.0263475627,
-0.0353911333,
-0.0578150898,
-0.054783497,
-0.0088618193,
-0.0264734831,
0.0218813419,
0.0249174703,
0.0537948422,
-0.0486715175,
0.0079361405,
-0.0648188815,
0.00635267,
-0.0419241004,
0.0112987645,
0.0515017249,
-0.0148823196,
-0.0150166973,
0.0119882328,
0.0074336031,
-0.0181940403,
-0.0276936013,
0.0429546908,
-0.0752776414,
0.0000321334,
0.0183840897,
-0.0098668477,
-0.0302705765,
-0.0555418395,
0.0144001273,
-0.0459051244,
0.0459202677,
-0.0220872238,
-0.0020667044,
-0.0401064754,
0.0027605963,
0.0432954766,
0.0178348925,
0.0544903353,
0.0264070667,
0.0004649221,
0.0062726848,
0.0129140196,
-0.0164147802,
0.023441961,
0.0248344336,
0.0788910985,
-0.0207541548,
0.0278859455,
0.0062345597,
0.0065957145,
0.0088485014,
-0.0128330803,
-0.0383785591,
-0.0035011843,
-0.0105056465,
0.063249141,
0.054214865,
0.0631404817,
-0.0124963252,
-0.0044913879,
0.0926808044,
0.0088659422,
0.0296490118,
-0.0123509662,
0.0710061863,
0.0081914579,
-0.0077703842,
0.0224224851,
-0.0131691927,
0.0990249887,
0.0205981359,
0.0471802503,
0.0363947041,
0.0546297692,
-0.0302164368,
-0.0508710742,
0.0091872411,
0.0035378884,
-0.0166945215,
-0.0403633788,
-0.0083585894,
0.0496627502,
-0.0659901947,
-0.0125347106,
-0.0223919619,
-0.0541889742,
0.0285139382,
-0.0293540452,
0.0412922204,
0.1014486402,
0.0330354497,
0.0520707704,
-0.0107439337,
0.0185945686,
0.0172590688,
0.070265241,
0.0025712114,
-0.0026976408,
0.0095823789,
-0.0516477972,
-0.0255519915,
-0.0483938567,
-0.0077352943,
0.0191702172,
-0.0052471696,
0.0242018793,
0.0252044071,
-0.029536549,
-0.0217919964,
0.0518353023,
0.0265494343,
-0.0029840129,
-0.0118048675,
0.0444035158,
-0.0158028565,
-0.0229687933,
-0.0152697116,
0.0366577357,
-0.0244808663,
-0.0189095959,
0.0087401783,
0.0246830583,
-0.0537025705,
-0.0479800738,
0.0004832087,
-0.0790608749,
-0.0187842604,
-0.0148410983,
-0.0233703591,
-0.0401436016,
-0.0295883734,
-0.0336146168,
-0.052825287,
-0.0482258946,
-0.0073261787,
0.0565776564,
0.0013322651,
0.0078068045,
0.087714985,
-0.0109127741,
-0.0201447979,
0.0311469231,
0.036736697,
-0.0113539807,
-0.0505447462,
0.0051846527,
-0.0250188913,
-0.0026385603,
0.010413832,
0.0046521858,
0.0455088317,
-0.0502666272,
-0.0326275826,
-0.0587903298,
-0.0158493537,
0.0094466275,
-0.0158807002,
0.0033383225,
-0.0169027615,
0.0007248691,
0.0078979749,
-0.0682605952,
0.0187883507,
-0.0007457805,
-0.0042577414,
0.0599580556,
-0.0019604638,
0.0469843,
-0.0414468162,
0.0034210966,
0.0196814239,
0.0554150827,
0.0399905145,
0.0205657966,
-0.0344273858,
0.0265314933,
-0.0447060242,
-0.0242106654,
0.0194386132,
-0.0377959535,
0.0367673561,
0.0170983505,
0.0656146184,
0.0910320431,
0.0366721675,
0.0051079332,
0.023047071,
0.0009526106,
-0.0346958861,
0.0041063419,
-0.0058781328,
0.0017512668,
0.0398447961,
-0.0475522541,
-0.00112327,
0.0077534569,
-0.0036374298,
0.0330204293,
-0.0962895527,
0.0612104647,
0.0023567104,
-0.0492451787,
-0.0372833423,
0.0120200189,
-0.011754835,
0.0362356007,
-0.0631608516,
-0.0412385985,
0.07113868,
-0.0482229553,
-0.0010845057,
0.0087754074,
0.041310478,
-0.0020606366,
0.0536641069,
0.0233896561,
0.0473360941,
0.0103514977,
0.012172278,
-0.0746061653,
0.0162538998,
0.0254255217,
-0.0069171116,
0.0021206639,
-0.0422493406,
0.0000113326,
-0.0269037504,
-0.0329533741,
-0.0340038911,
0.0279335938,
0.0065910709,
-0.0003768236,
-0.0157501977,
-0.0056002405,
0.0043056291,
0.0265683401,
0.0023324466,
0.0056353882,
-0.0356352627,
-0.0312320348,
-0.0129001094,
0.0591867752,
0.0571518727,
-0.0172547642,
-0.0191727504,
-0.0537157468,
0.0224650521,
0.0464254357,
-0.0085856458,
0.0014851905,
-0.0343829691,
0.0177847408,
-0.0132938037,
0.0363016315,
0.0174423195,
0.0537430011,
0.0649759471,
-0.046520222,
-0.0330793485,
0.0604840592,
0.005823025,
-0.003233752,
-0.0152609171,
0.0439082831,
0.0551264882,
0.00328209,
0.0231860504,
-0.0996433571,
-0.0207882598,
0.000910983,
0.0042183725,
-0.0015477478,
0.0054787667,
-0.0450088978,
-0.1116807535,
0.0789991319,
0.0180327203,
-0.0218806863,
-0.0054187747,
0.0261027236,
0.0044421908,
0.0036345394,
-0.009959504,
-0.0070226286,
0.0007186633,
0.0354129896,
0.0012066739,
0.0543541647,
-0.053759262,
0.0050518173,
-0.0370054506,
0.008280118,
0.0684103817,
0.0610859543,
0.0306292437,
-0.0835172087,
-0.0119669,
0.0163042881,
0.031943474,
0.020247072,
0.0601696372,
-0.0022013122,
-0.0119147841,
-0.0321263783,
0.0394786596,
0.0216853637,
-0.0323564634,
-0.0173989944,
0.0136854379,
-0.0151305478,
-0.0342818461,
-0.0622320361,
0.0444971547,
0.0082826661,
0.0541823097,
0.0583412573,
-0.0536661409,
-0.0495013818,
-0.0162375476,
0.0359801874,
-0.1018088013,
-0.0345196985,
0.011368122,
0.0034544878,
-0.0450295694,
-0.1064466164,
-0.0217535421,
0.0275013801,
0.0723198429,
-0.0018199586,
-0.0432896018,
-0.026382355,
0.0036711469,
-0.0408230536,
0.0352031775,
-0.0004471187,
0.0331230089,
-0.0446046703,
0.0102956984,
-0.0106865019,
-0.0416384153,
-0.0298729613,
0.0075862161,
-0.0448134877,
-0.0195282586,
-0.0467624851,
0.1148810908,
0.018439129,
0.0024859766,
0.0128865419,
-0.0312579162,
0.0293850247,
0.0540391169,
0.0341480039,
0.0034868191,
-0.0406878404,
-0.0127404332,
-0.0067212302,
0.0003445379,
-0.0249790568,
0.0077456478,
0.0048962357,
0.0391828753,
0.0391396806,
-0.030613644,
0.0318583101,
-0.0142689198,
-0.0233679712,
-0.0607071109,
0.0171235539,
-0.0424897298,
-0.016864283,
-0.0293799136,
-0.022726357,
-0.0753299743,
-0.0000625057,
0.0345203057,
0.0349597782,
0.0031348958,
-0.0183149986,
0.0054187714,
0.0414235443,
-0.0591852367,
-0.0469517596,
0.0225403234,
0.020585252,
0.0147854192,
0.0020531812,
-0.0156994332,
0.0209715869,
-0.0489686206,
0.0506396331,
-0.0023676064,
0.0579006672,
0.0315967314,
-0.0156624485,
0.0130357128,
0.0588920787,
-0.0078415321,
-0.0284220707,
-0.0656380728,
0.0200893637,
0.0541497581,
0.0077520218,
0.0210780874,
0.0019969821,
-0.0133188721,
0.0093515115,
0.0284396093,
0.0095217424,
-0.0576834157,
0.0277037788,
-0.0049337931,
0.0219844505,
-0.0387729965,
0.0597409382,
-0.0277133062,
0.0019808847,
-0.0308435913,
-0.0006759587,
-0.0239235256,
-0.0301358774,
-0.0110337315,
-0.0136144739,
0.0139982319,
-0.0112194195,
-0.0559282489,
-0.0589376129,
-0.0076198811,
0.0618101507,
-0.0007113499,
0.0241200794,
0.0621580742,
0.0217484366,
-0.0160013735,
-0.0168374628,
0.0085368427,
-0.0213661604,
-0.052571293,
-0.0014397489,
-0.0349454768,
-5.891265813e-33,
-0.0739829764,
-0.0476661138,
0.0179336369,
-0.0183659699,
-0.0282688458,
-0.0068284543,
-0.063189283,
0.0011924038,
0.0154057145,
0.0351950601,
0.0217762496,
-0.0307883415,
0.0080703348,
0.0322658978,
-0.0125051849,
0.0142795714,
0.0467226394,
-0.0011780532,
-0.0667182654,
0.0386888683,
0.0172183104,
-0.0074134492,
-0.0080435583,
-0.0388502218,
-0.0203766748,
0.0157585498,
-0.0611493327,
-0.0043589193,
-0.0078752162,
0.0388796814,
0.0007244159,
-0.015072396,
0.0070331334,
-0.0113225868,
-0.020972034,
0.0309426952,
-0.0329692997,
-0.009941644,
-0.0009857411,
-0.0160231125,
-0.0879056677,
-0.0324445143,
0.020411294,
-0.0277526844,
-0.0241545644,
-0.0546455234,
0.0539358594,
-0.031088233,
0.0176733062,
-0.0702902675,
-0.068055667,
-0.0236568935,
-0.0414451584,
-0.0639802814,
-0.0057760533,
0.049429033,
0.011315383,
0.0257241037,
-0.0561594479,
0.0388274044,
0.0028708652,
0.014753799,
0.0791451484,
0.0243788455,
-0.0214042775,
0.0566154495,
0.0214558206,
-0.025255831,
-0.0362552479,
-0.0043791006,
-0.0097922618,
0.0648036078,
0.0446794741,
0.0485066772,
0.0029351434,
-0.0070668817,
-0.0188674908,
0.0804842189,
-0.0627987757,
0.023926245,
0.0208549406,
0.0038375165,
-0.008573235,
0.0054922793,
-0.0337865278,
-0.0413072668,
-0.0455477424,
-0.0358371697,
0.0457078964,
-0.0009023839,
-0.0051403227,
-0.023762919,
0.0320761018,
0.0234167166,
0.0215335339,
-0.0107063372,
-0.0602018833,
0.0563767999,
-0.0190257356,
0.0019119815,
-0.0323275775,
-0.0095274057,
0.0770452917,
0.0628850162,
0.01798236,
0.0304534771,
0.0209696125,
0.0012561859,
-0.031510856,
0.0084950561,
-0.0489793494,
0.0234821793,
0.0047760336,
0.0161483902,
0.0141263725,
-0.0028028269,
-0.0629279464,
0.0236977376,
-0.0317009725,
0.0192627609,
-0.009673534,
-0.0183199737,
0.0225098412,
0.0085220225,
-0.0437762029,
0.0345410556,
-0.0404588431,
-0.0166543759,
0.0256271102,
-0.0377391614,
-0.0392126553,
0.0559779368,
2.661e-7,
0.029423371,
0.0099856164,
0.0144123361,
0.0202378165,
-0.0162663218,
0.0467172489,
-0.0266987011,
0.0217660628,
0.0323599353,
-0.0143359741,
0.0145603707,
0.0312925912,
0.0529620349,
-0.013889214,
-0.042912975,
0.0451273546,
-0.0682043284,
-0.00323421,
-0.0411400311,
-0.026513109,
0.0980488509,
0.0201676525,
-0.0377077162,
-0.0197749883,
0.062343955,
-0.0074147433,
0.1007477194,
0.0058230441,
-0.0046717692,
-0.0078338329,
0.0269539785,
-0.0267975423,
-0.0322070606,
0.002319912,
-0.0188265573,
-0.0421136543,
0.0686679259,
0.0323584974,
-0.0161906797,
-0.0268164948,
-0.0115002478,
0.0373957679,
0.0102407234,
-0.0749590695,
0.0530106202,
-0.0506833531,
-0.0162583347,
-0.0229500644,
-0.0323027074,
0.0307634305,
0.0330025777,
-0.0303939879,
-0.0311685707,
0.018589627,
0.0363333151,
0.0119706895,
-0.0256295502,
-0.031118352,
-0.0636878684,
-0.0243322775,
-0.0139961718,
-0.0125713889,
-0.0723242834,
0.0285859723,
0.0035516419,
-0.0202846378,
-0.0666976199,
2.166056578e-34,
0.003535378,
-0.0069360128,
0.0330331512,
-0.0437837839,
0.0461561196,
0.0173405446,
-0.0016901206,
-0.0066776816,
0.0050763167,
-0.0428186022,
-0.0483474247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13720v1 | On the Utility of Domain-Adjacent Fine-Tuned Model Ensembles for Few-shot Problems | 2024-06-19T17:24:36 | 2024-06-19T17:24:36 | Md Ibrahim Ibne Alam, Parikshit Ram, Soham Dan, Horst Samulowitz, Koushik Kar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been observed to perform well on a wide
range of downstream tasks when fine-tuned on domain-specific data. However,
such data may not be readily available in many applications, motivating
zero-shot or few-shot approaches using domain-adjacent models. While several
fine-tuned models for various tasks are available, finding an appropriate
domain-adjacent model for a given task is often not straight forward. In this
paper, we study DAFT-E, a framework that utilizes an Ensemble of
Domain-Adjacent Fine-Tuned Foundation Models for few-shot problems. We show
that for zero-shot problems, this ensembling method provides an accuracy
performance close to that of the single best model. With few-shot problems,
this performance improves further, at which point DEFT-E can outperform any
single domain-adjacent model while requiring much less data for domain-specific
fine-tuning. | [
-0.0042723399,
0.0618413389,
-0.0051981118,
0.0298733842,
-0.0457639098,
0.0224008821,
0.0349856019,
-0.0105189383,
-0.0572455972,
-0.0883847997,
-0.0325225666,
-0.0743903145,
0.0159791149,
0.0106038805,
0.0251505785,
-0.031296324,
0.0231429376,
-0.0510900021,
-0.0382197946,
-0.0216670372,
-0.0114458287,
0.0069227433,
-0.0112945354,
0.0491902456,
0.0479204357,
-0.0051915939,
-0.0252847336,
0.0349589065,
-0.003805368,
0.0295443591,
0.0234260429,
0.0872729197,
0.034013398,
0.0477306284,
0.0000019904,
-0.0192221403,
-0.0321255177,
0.0130773783,
-0.0351706482,
0.0010760396,
0.0258547738,
0.0059571285,
-0.0206116568,
0.0271484088,
0.0001204454,
-0.0439828634,
0.0545009933,
0.0169225205,
0.0503033437,
0.0828823,
0.0038357198,
-0.0662328303,
-0.0028715807,
-0.0332513936,
-0.0589998513,
-0.0414098836,
0.0350494832,
-0.0142285759,
0.011943303,
-0.0164070185,
-0.0401625447,
0.012568702,
-0.0117235612,
0.0298476424,
0.0024562671,
0.0016265163,
-0.0369019322,
-0.0156585015,
0.0129193682,
0.0703563616,
-0.0544254407,
-0.0003300495,
0.011336985,
-0.0185297728,
-0.0453985892,
0.0180369467,
-0.0355816968,
-0.0125137214,
0.0028633329,
0.0132393287,
-0.0054378784,
0.0001539715,
0.0302015804,
0.0317665711,
-0.02880821,
0.0444833562,
0.0364884734,
0.011918921,
-0.0431877561,
-0.0054966123,
-0.0502519608,
-0.0484820195,
-0.0252590459,
-0.0084344614,
-0.0271830503,
0.0170811694,
-0.0689118505,
-0.02870542,
-0.0114985844,
0.0419858657,
0.0733535513,
0.0493523553,
0.0004781961,
0.0451103076,
-0.0135170622,
0.0247155856,
-0.0136867538,
-0.031012034,
-0.0470839478,
-0.0117138345,
-0.066488117,
0.008416527,
-0.0479070693,
0.0323366709,
-0.0466741584,
-0.0386553593,
-0.0517754257,
-0.0001693826,
0.0266368371,
-0.0214088224,
0.0277278423,
-0.0217216685,
-0.0363976583,
-0.0311789904,
0.03196235,
0.0433324203,
-0.0281437337,
0.0323838964,
0.022007741,
-0.0471322611,
-0.0130486926,
0.0021413309,
-0.0088980412,
-0.0382744707,
0.0101648178,
0.0636888593,
0.0255185757,
-0.0506409518,
-0.0138771255,
0.0056792093,
-0.0304650534,
-0.0744467005,
-0.0187837817,
-0.078471154,
0.0100670578,
0.0207756162,
0.0303779393,
-0.081931673,
-0.0134174814,
-0.0183676109,
-0.0298094191,
0.07974457,
-0.015469946,
0.039556101,
0.0277200714,
-0.0056310808,
-0.012143882,
0.1176696792,
0.0009271892,
0.0122668482,
0.0063960506,
-0.0131622236,
-0.0045944718,
0.0430946723,
0.0070801396,
0.0137619795,
-0.0722947791,
0.0175793078,
0.0076307561,
-0.0148741389,
-0.0049470211,
0.0153592601,
-0.0445860997,
0.0211263765,
0.0487397052,
0.0180785488,
0.0683379695,
0.0161405131,
0.0111832144,
-0.0128190871,
-0.0046687862,
-0.0121504273,
-0.0447922349,
-0.0010706203,
-0.0313906111,
0.0105486074,
0.0427680239,
0.0638096482,
-0.0382391401,
-0.0117379408,
-0.0019951288,
-0.007864275,
-0.0461486615,
0.0039292178,
0.0915565193,
-0.0293591339,
-0.0495313406,
0.0311599486,
0.0371904634,
-0.0093729934,
-0.0227482822,
-0.0380367115,
-0.0402159914,
0.0789701268,
0.0537499636,
-0.0147466389,
-0.0607922785,
-0.0181001723,
0.0525005646,
0.0204528067,
0.0215982608,
-0.0012976332,
0.0338900127,
-0.0455270186,
-0.0600596033,
-0.0035351098,
0.0290026721,
0.0120226564,
0.0156697463,
0.0002480687,
0.0206832271,
-0.0184372123,
0.0055669709,
0.0206477754,
-0.0160067659,
0.0222279467,
0.0251253303,
0.0179226026,
0.0401497036,
0.0101778843,
-0.0395319462,
0.0053329975,
-0.0084797759,
-0.0290265996,
-0.0256391633,
-0.0519736186,
-0.0082729664,
-0.0312909633,
0.031845808,
0.0069536795,
0.0270366184,
0.0020998935,
-0.0552225485,
-0.0656446666,
0.0311556235,
-0.023033008,
-0.014446673,
-0.0228949729,
0.0492347069,
-0.0421113595,
0.006701218,
-0.0487236418,
0.0391923375,
0.0092206309,
0.0191149712,
-0.0205917042,
0.0003953898,
0.0194695462,
-0.0153375464,
-0.0428163409,
-0.0082990369,
0.0023866508,
0.0161513593,
0.018024575,
-0.0187610257,
-0.013422708,
-0.015079855,
-0.0579784289,
0.0298989862,
-0.0289162602,
0.0148721198,
0.0125896856,
0.0400067903,
-0.0135839209,
0.009218201,
0.0124812098,
-0.0045834519,
0.0001708421,
0.0190790612,
-0.0019256732,
0.0040753735,
-0.0821992308,
-0.0273636878,
-0.0336898156,
0.0141447252,
0.0413469784,
-0.0470933802,
-0.0355892852,
-0.0677177161,
0.0344647989,
-0.0069471514,
0.0354107544,
-0.0083940765,
-0.0356045738,
-0.0358905159,
-0.004891946,
-0.0049751243,
0.0479265302,
-0.0153588289,
0.0097646872,
0.0269398317,
-0.0153859779,
-0.0258048158,
-0.0081133759,
-0.0282352865,
0.0138290953,
-0.0131426137,
0.0350720324,
-0.0352182686,
0.0799196437,
-0.0241541956,
-0.0114890104,
-0.0524599515,
0.0376992524,
-0.0145405168,
0.0161769092,
-0.0266996697,
-0.0079995552,
0.0254385248,
0.0329275578,
-0.0136831971,
-0.0462121516,
0.0787283182,
-0.0281054173,
0.0012067988,
-0.0297918357,
-0.0057782512,
-0.0347978584,
0.0108754802,
0.0061464761,
0.004755727,
0.0581541024,
-0.0133707728,
-0.0662200302,
-0.0215547346,
0.0400361829,
-0.0236117523,
0.0650294572,
-0.0291009285,
0.0427092351,
-0.0278240163,
-0.0544048771,
-0.0374226272,
-0.0412875749,
-0.0379926302,
0.0455707721,
-0.0218332168,
-0.020955503,
-0.1012008488,
0.0418874249,
-0.0180702098,
0.0372351035,
-0.0262519401,
0.0124845449,
-0.0149179688,
0.035183955,
0.0773550868,
-0.0094813425,
0.0063789906,
-0.040446382,
0.0699241683,
-0.0130379954,
0.0354610197,
0.0246064141,
-0.0520592369,
0.0004561453,
0.0277123768,
-0.0111169042,
-0.054159224,
0.0112629654,
0.0349544138,
-0.0252324864,
-0.0155285224,
0.1424971074,
0.0057030609,
0.0046276441,
-0.002914571,
0.0248712525,
0.0461778119,
0.0331994109,
0.0262566768,
-0.0696249828,
-0.0758250132,
0.0233064741,
0.0234533809,
0.0154466778,
0.003863849,
0.0023935176,
-0.1279130727,
0.0309927613,
0.0500609241,
-0.0124436198,
0.0046977885,
-0.0183916353,
0.0304768197,
-0.0264211912,
0.0030483927,
0.0194115229,
0.0142758535,
-0.0064189597,
0.0403586663,
0.0110162515,
-0.1203439012,
0.0204427559,
-0.0492192954,
0.0529640578,
0.0643931851,
-0.0179235246,
0.0228082556,
0.0342546254,
0.0238661692,
-0.034123227,
0.0217129588,
-0.0060182838,
0.0416149944,
-0.0009354201,
-0.0078429021,
0.0486682467,
0.0293608345,
-0.0536966771,
-0.0113140149,
-0.008075051,
0.05800879,
-0.0412756465,
0.0072972099,
-0.004668165,
-0.0514396019,
0.0049937651,
0.0468601696,
0.0265432931,
-0.0399667323,
-0.0167676341,
-0.0008340803,
-0.0310643315,
-0.0420614183,
0.0063168281,
-0.0156818815,
-0.0004604058,
-0.0302943811,
-0.042990569,
0.0213265847,
0.0583028086,
0.0571769029,
-0.0073314919,
0.024693504,
0.0023588696,
0.0381704457,
-0.0469147936,
0.0017653594,
-0.031623479,
0.0464307107,
-0.0764350966,
-0.0015772007,
0.0703060031,
-0.0103860162,
-0.0300883222,
0.0013790878,
-0.0939444974,
-0.0646634549,
0.0179178379,
0.0366489813,
0.0260124952,
0.0117958691,
-0.0433491468,
-0.0688191056,
0.0329733416,
0.0593037829,
-0.0327817723,
-0.0010395892,
0.0139602413,
-0.0841638446,
-0.0169830285,
0.0407085903,
-0.0557949282,
0.072317794,
0.0496825129,
0.0329197235,
-0.0085539902,
-0.0164916813,
0.000645432,
0.0077130501,
0.0950299427,
-0.0312561095,
-0.0372304358,
-0.0042879051,
0.0325434655,
-0.0028955203,
-0.026530046,
-0.0462828763,
-0.0133683588,
0.0147764999,
-0.0075808098,
-0.0074542109,
-0.0012320508,
-0.0170108881,
0.0327097289,
-0.0345541835,
0.0229112711,
0.016715629,
0.0321914628,
0.0493319817,
-0.0095184231,
0.0213101469,
0.0238583311,
0.0356143601,
0.0119349752,
-0.0394332297,
0.039293725,
0.0057601118,
0.0469184965,
-0.0592362061,
0.0378650017,
-0.0257408936,
-0.0352293886,
-0.0618163794,
0.0305439979,
0.0791867152,
0.0057000467,
0.0358997136,
0.0107138278,
-0.0031862648,
-0.0544223711,
0.0470504016,
0.0288144257,
-0.0061306218,
0.0510095581,
0.026546685,
-0.0245567188,
0.0172447823,
0.0917169228,
0.0163134318,
0.0469552837,
0.0261760168,
0.0076286537,
-0.0231482293,
-0.0338484012,
-0.0073815337,
0.0062484746,
-0.0203178823,
0.0253567509,
-0.0559542216,
-0.0503299832,
0.0093402369,
-0.043963749,
0.0016237238,
-0.0043650609,
0.0448201522,
0.0205277782,
-0.0144265695,
0.0242570024,
-0.0330996625,
-0.0235112272,
-0.0248862412,
-0.0048052147,
0.001745316,
-6.008017749e-33,
-0.0501014143,
0.0129218223,
-0.0036179686,
-0.038054619,
-0.0195335262,
-0.0212771781,
-0.0134410337,
0.0204148144,
-0.0154316416,
-0.0228794031,
-0.0095905783,
0.0101019675,
0.0196123701,
0.0330592841,
0.0006331769,
-0.0027328818,
0.0575761236,
-0.0226018913,
-0.0265607052,
-0.0013628438,
0.0198134258,
0.0524110384,
0.0105404472,
0.000524934,
-0.0626159608,
-0.0198959466,
-0.0359136239,
0.0140926754,
0.020851884,
0.0601603799,
0.01186598,
0.0157604031,
-0.0104544181,
-0.057895571,
-0.0512268431,
-0.0183059201,
-0.0369690917,
-0.0053348984,
0.0126156891,
0.0117233405,
0.0531593263,
0.0005861631,
0.0397626534,
0.0100623099,
-0.0028272416,
-0.0127278082,
0.0114696166,
-0.0678150579,
-0.0116204824,
-0.0198914651,
-0.0373776592,
0.0347416885,
0.0044417144,
-0.05477079,
0.0451435111,
0.0264188144,
-0.0037965903,
0.0279922672,
-0.0095048826,
0.0120461527,
0.0413410962,
0.0792312175,
0.0827372298,
0.0237065535,
-0.0035800722,
0.0495604984,
0.0155693647,
-0.0213574227,
0.0132725686,
-0.0187942777,
0.0381538309,
0.0624867976,
0.0157833789,
0.0410398319,
0.0405378789,
0.0050855554,
-0.0794683248,
0.0156617817,
-0.0016355948,
0.0132567594,
0.0475998223,
0.0463305227,
-0.0270576477,
-0.0393747054,
-0.030573722,
-0.0141325155,
-0.0371824056,
-0.0164276194,
0.022654837,
0.0060831774,
-0.0498192757,
-0.0130446646,
0.0573139563,
-0.0580655299,
-0.003575224,
0.0238248743,
-0.0360183679,
0.0162063409,
0.0058221119,
0.0304996576,
-0.0263581555,
-0.0772271529,
0.0149102826,
0.0421348661,
0.0030411393,
-0.0310933124,
0.019366825,
0.0329124071,
-0.0574995093,
-0.0193648487,
-0.029943794,
0.0039575705,
-0.0124163767,
0.0686010495,
0.0274578836,
0.0159464478,
-0.0015135903,
0.0374829471,
0.0052677547,
-0.069913879,
0.0152049586,
0.0226308089,
0.0222905669,
0.0334768258,
-0.0165966172,
-0.0043273456,
-0.010310079,
-0.0513610877,
0.0363617539,
-0.0071848775,
-0.0244602524,
0.007670464,
2.648e-7,
0.0475429371,
0.0488879681,
0.0070759738,
-0.0108493622,
0.0214489326,
0.0429739952,
-0.0466557369,
-0.0120914001,
0.0136962663,
0.0151896663,
0.025695879,
0.0175877307,
0.0827882439,
0.0108127752,
-0.0691162497,
0.049652651,
-0.0085744169,
0.0487940013,
-0.0337610543,
-0.0241348799,
-0.0160461087,
0.1184969991,
0.0330112912,
-0.0133562237,
-0.0205126908,
-0.001448369,
0.0551768318,
-0.0064137885,
0.0089586386,
0.0276021566,
-0.0566771403,
0.0314357169,
-0.0293683894,
0.0434070043,
-0.005160504,
0.0591825061,
0.0181749631,
0.0649488941,
-0.0207202937,
0.0357361361,
-0.0009312066,
-0.0025626388,
-0.0072089289,
-0.0244262572,
0.0653841794,
-0.0806717277,
-0.0345067978,
-0.0280816499,
-0.0503554456,
-0.009311174,
0.0075866953,
-0.0082350234,
0.0127569688,
0.0187912975,
0.0220176261,
-0.0274355486,
-0.0027766069,
-0.0688676611,
-0.0063406099,
0.0372997858,
-0.0583141223,
-0.0246718228,
-0.0068569733,
-0.0275167115,
0.061909683,
-0.0419740379,
-0.0052826214,
2.690335783e-34,
0.0523286536,
-0.0028739495,
-0.0082374541,
0.0390928686,
-0.009154574,
-0.0194552429,
-0.0296057407,
-0.0005983821,
-0.0016722754,
-0.0687223896,
-0.0058322004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13718v1 | Evaluating Large Language Models along Dimensions of Language Variation: A Systematik Invesdigatiom uv Cross-lingual Generalization | 2024-06-19T17:20:28 | 2024-06-19T17:20:28 | Niyati Bafna, Kenton Murray, David Yarowsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models exhibit certain cross-lingual generalization
capabilities, they suffer from performance degradation (PD) on unseen
closely-related languages (CRLs) and dialects relative to their high-resource
language neighbour (HRLN). However, we currently lack a fundamental
understanding of what kinds of linguistic distances contribute to PD, and to
what extent. Furthermore, studies of cross-lingual generalization are
confounded by unknown quantities of CRL language traces in the training data,
and by the frequent lack of availability of evaluation data in lower-resource
related languages and dialects. To address these issues, we model phonological,
morphological, and lexical distance as Bayesian noise processes to synthesize
artificial languages that are controllably distant from the HRLN. We analyse PD
as a function of underlying noise parameters, offering insights on model
robustness to isolated and composed linguistic phenomena, and the impact of
task and HRL characteristics on PD. We calculate parameter posteriors on real
CRL-HRLN pair data and show that they follow computed trends of artificial
languages, demonstrating the viability of our noisers. Our framework offers a
cheap solution to estimating task performance on an unseen CRL given HRLN
performance using its posteriors, as well as for diagnosing observed PD on a
CRL in terms of its linguistic distances from its HRLN, and opens doors to
principled methods of mitigating performance degradation. | [
-0.0125239883,
0.0852626711,
-0.0218143724,
0.0458856709,
-0.0483869053,
0.0234817173,
0.011901076,
0.0004178345,
-0.0455355681,
0.0003883468,
-0.0490502752,
-0.0699490458,
0.0381547846,
-0.0168085583,
0.0515912361,
-0.0375057347,
0.0322644114,
-0.0878414735,
-0.0075615533,
-0.0351823792,
-0.0003245194,
-0.0128327087,
0.0142778931,
0.0429852046,
0.001398558,
0.0050154156,
-0.0030037123,
-0.0098108025,
-0.0026610929,
0.0197651628,
-0.0133729205,
0.0304545276,
-0.0264235958,
0.061384201,
0.00000198,
-0.0598605797,
0.0268787574,
0.0122034717,
0.00853315,
0.0326348506,
0.0541214161,
-0.0179348961,
-0.032173723,
0.0086353347,
0.0194507428,
-0.0477641858,
0.0745175183,
-0.014551634,
-0.0172108319,
0.055946108,
-0.0048943348,
-0.0009172215,
0.0045432393,
-0.0315318592,
-0.0053398721,
-0.0363059975,
-0.0026004547,
0.0020384437,
0.0001397995,
-0.043895524,
-0.0510040708,
0.0359208249,
0.003838975,
0.0251779351,
-0.0342648253,
0.0287728012,
0.0192409009,
-0.029948011,
0.0177517477,
0.0236287378,
-0.0802354962,
-0.0342592411,
0.0099398121,
-0.0020808622,
-0.016485773,
0.0115691805,
-0.0344278254,
0.0213183481,
-0.0034202933,
0.0037615099,
0.0435999781,
-0.0221014023,
0.0517011173,
-0.0132346014,
-0.0171710514,
0.0637316778,
0.0597044751,
-0.051521223,
-0.0097691193,
0.0294396393,
0.0073939539,
-0.0523280874,
-0.0032215493,
-0.0214730725,
-0.0506482646,
0.0239805169,
-0.0087142931,
-0.0478747562,
0.0103175193,
-0.0727021471,
0.0664599165,
0.0327021442,
-0.0264429059,
-0.0080185495,
-0.011459507,
0.0510413498,
-0.0332462117,
-0.0090089943,
-0.0326122865,
-0.0316681787,
-0.0197938159,
0.0261575934,
0.0013572427,
-0.0167884231,
-0.0356632657,
0.0128515763,
-0.0318396278,
0.0052790432,
-0.0063007306,
-0.011663761,
0.0586826652,
-0.0239472706,
-0.0612944365,
-0.018453164,
-0.0015974885,
0.0057632257,
-0.0401293114,
0.0002101581,
-0.0055574947,
-0.0432446413,
0.0106190657,
0.0106257489,
-0.0033150881,
-0.0299280435,
0.0051888586,
0.0863737017,
0.005565085,
-0.0102707529,
-0.0223047733,
0.0105970418,
-0.049027618,
-0.0688322112,
-0.0202170499,
-0.0607771985,
0.0050255917,
-0.0055842549,
0.0011080366,
-0.0485114679,
-0.0302631594,
-0.0216902811,
-0.0371500738,
0.0437150523,
-0.0001629936,
0.0289895851,
0.0182744619,
-0.0285330787,
-0.0001249106,
0.0880276114,
0.0445605144,
-0.0406814814,
0.0516769961,
-0.0309091043,
-0.0413670242,
0.067063719,
0.0059961919,
0.0278963763,
-0.0298235305,
-0.0270373244,
0.0394731127,
0.013747287,
0.0616278164,
0.0509316213,
-0.0252429135,
-0.0163063947,
0.0646328405,
0.0430149175,
0.0024913256,
0.0128943361,
0.0729340613,
0.007872751,
-0.0462847687,
0.0325304493,
-0.013335973,
-0.0457985625,
-0.0100005055,
0.0327785425,
0.0489434451,
0.0658080429,
-0.0286583547,
-0.0442535952,
-0.0084898835,
-0.0413607247,
0.0138317198,
0.0302439872,
0.0941672176,
0.0031735448,
0.0006241077,
0.0351789854,
0.0857007876,
-0.0408569798,
0.0348801948,
-0.0342884548,
0.0257713813,
0.0392313041,
-0.0135124475,
-0.0081096599,
-0.0113681182,
0.0282109678,
-0.0251722634,
0.0555534363,
0.0365510583,
-0.0073904488,
0.0737104714,
-0.0250145365,
-0.0095679834,
0.0123052057,
0.027491441,
0.0659820214,
-0.0268110596,
0.0015640786,
-0.0035932593,
-0.0705273449,
-0.0279511958,
0.0044375416,
-0.0589056201,
0.011233232,
0.0408399887,
-0.0088985367,
0.0470995419,
0.011833814,
-0.0329926871,
0.0101427268,
-0.0086584212,
-0.0407284051,
0.020408446,
0.0389048271,
-0.0234400705,
-0.0179455653,
0.0515006706,
0.0134541597,
0.0212001745,
-0.0067237383,
0.0045925584,
-0.0637176931,
0.0911361799,
-0.0202054996,
0.0426109098,
-0.0241228119,
0.0449003652,
-0.0228959452,
0.019137647,
-0.0190514922,
0.0419464521,
-0.0058374829,
0.050708279,
0.008215812,
0.0187798906,
0.0277347416,
-0.0463731512,
-0.0121666947,
0.0175228398,
-0.0151910707,
0.0085180122,
0.0316461213,
0.00096218,
0.0022640941,
-0.0132893752,
-0.070419997,
-0.0127926003,
-0.0417576507,
0.0425701067,
0.0221194625,
0.0328000151,
-0.0140213612,
-0.0111903735,
-0.0189738274,
-0.0121777942,
0.0308330022,
0.0362119339,
-0.0258075204,
0.0135180838,
-0.0426229797,
-0.0521147475,
-0.0368795022,
0.0413236469,
0.0389622264,
-0.0067185899,
-0.0011526616,
-0.0941312015,
0.0227090884,
-0.0425670855,
0.0477562435,
0.0057258699,
-0.0330749266,
0.0033248221,
-0.0283395778,
0.078444548,
0.040200863,
-0.0571523085,
-0.0291961599,
0.0828701481,
-0.0384925306,
-0.0501717404,
-0.0091984123,
-0.0324572884,
-0.0091259973,
-0.0914933458,
-0.0573976375,
-0.0380528532,
0.0984045491,
0.0086081186,
-0.0331000984,
-0.0656760931,
-0.0055316119,
-0.0430720039,
-0.0471247882,
0.003158048,
0.0119063528,
-0.0217610318,
0.0765155479,
-0.0231731422,
-0.0569603555,
0.0488761216,
-0.0744235814,
0.0046917093,
-0.0457061641,
-0.025167942,
-0.0033121661,
0.0335604139,
0.0150420861,
0.0185407773,
0.0155187035,
-0.0382181667,
-0.0517590083,
0.0364642739,
0.0295835789,
-0.009066483,
0.0301347319,
-0.0567241535,
0.0039182128,
0.0105663817,
-0.0377848074,
-0.0126860011,
0.0269719269,
0.0022317111,
0.0099856853,
0.0329350829,
-0.0513581894,
0.0452243835,
0.0042911442,
-0.0011164624,
0.0320599303,
-0.0055266619,
0.0225664452,
-0.0173846148,
0.0274332855,
0.0423239619,
-0.004819856,
0.008856304,
-0.036940828,
-0.0009895199,
-0.0241266061,
0.0642647296,
0.0164503939,
-0.0325741991,
0.0057731932,
0.0356909968,
0.014969836,
-0.0477712266,
0.0361071751,
0.0593986847,
-0.0214531515,
-0.0607014,
0.0990844294,
-0.0016962874,
-0.0321111232,
0.0365528017,
-0.0101926764,
0.0770539492,
0.0047312761,
0.0321027003,
-0.0046140244,
0.0161402002,
0.0289010964,
0.0110056056,
-0.0104891565,
-0.0122605264,
0.0055649416,
-0.1372419298,
0.0090264017,
0.0017329952,
-0.0379960537,
-0.0277024116,
-0.0547135733,
0.0028751739,
-0.0282528494,
0.0532120429,
-0.0149286333,
0.0141610317,
-0.0076815458,
0.0559543557,
-0.0414022505,
-0.0999612287,
-0.0047421283,
-0.0404058285,
0.0522806607,
0.0421652645,
-0.0154490909,
-0.0075010411,
-0.0383473076,
0.0372239873,
-0.0097048478,
-0.022180127,
-0.008276077,
0.0137864351,
0.070062615,
-0.0374972858,
0.0363279842,
-0.0201020055,
-0.0259170253,
0.0335314348,
0.0052809566,
0.0767543539,
0.0083585978,
-0.0098279854,
0.044331044,
-0.0077451197,
0.0184051134,
0.0397388227,
0.0390952639,
-0.0607955791,
-0.0310344175,
-0.0186482668,
-0.0008395803,
-0.0208028518,
-0.0107705342,
0.0131047228,
-0.0285893194,
-0.0790621862,
-0.0624302514,
-0.0501763672,
-0.0123459334,
0.0412904471,
0.0267357752,
0.022417143,
0.002557809,
0.0012674996,
-0.0162540656,
0.013046396,
-0.0088359592,
0.0062990803,
-0.0317618512,
-0.0095439656,
-0.0074178227,
-0.0123046562,
-0.0251553804,
-0.0058912169,
-0.1103832051,
-0.1004430875,
0.0064730942,
0.0424535163,
0.0208771508,
0.0569669232,
-0.0193691086,
-0.1070324257,
0.0098384842,
-0.0258546975,
-0.0142228995,
0.0279253982,
0.0672778338,
-0.0343541354,
0.0031493686,
0.0527619123,
-0.0475767702,
0.0139993662,
0.0540582649,
0.0364181809,
-0.05123524,
-0.0131877186,
-0.0004869767,
-0.0104429312,
0.0455905832,
-0.0767676905,
-0.0326016769,
-0.0427613445,
-0.0106568895,
-0.0306286365,
0.0155494828,
-0.0501502939,
-0.0325255059,
0.0475109331,
0.0142117059,
0.0151974801,
0.0291076712,
-0.0109618027,
-0.0002222274,
-0.0212107394,
-0.0103103667,
0.0319451243,
0.0603554957,
0.0296733398,
0.0385203511,
0.0104383659,
0.019551985,
-0.0024623531,
0.0254251827,
-0.0159325693,
0.0118654547,
-0.0205570888,
0.0087526133,
0.0066106902,
-0.0140728112,
-0.0260100793,
-0.0512420125,
-0.0044175722,
0.030867599,
0.0645069778,
-0.013809395,
0.0871641263,
-0.0182690173,
0.0121485218,
-0.0475225188,
0.0293640178,
0.0022079065,
-0.0165407695,
0.0097280778,
-0.0003878368,
-0.0228433441,
0.0067492826,
0.1086811125,
0.0532528087,
0.0154157123,
-0.0241759904,
0.0170184206,
-0.0195840336,
-0.0408442989,
0.0035617817,
0.0141306948,
-0.0366458334,
-0.0002206052,
-0.0333350785,
-0.1097811386,
-0.0159113538,
0.0122740977,
0.0260141678,
0.0016548738,
0.02209826,
0.0551475026,
-0.0390666947,
0.0299926512,
-0.0354267992,
-0.0387733877,
0.0292279311,
-0.0202235468,
0.0013479617,
-6.344953368e-33,
-0.0065494133,
0.0126335928,
-0.0172376037,
-0.0514990725,
0.018810384,
0.0113042342,
-0.0408074781,
0.0424750596,
-0.0044138739,
0.0132345995,
0.0097067952,
-0.0164922569,
0.0185021758,
0.0394557267,
0.0276566874,
0.0103723602,
0.0570133105,
-0.0200049393,
0.0297809336,
0.0153541444,
0.0324350372,
0.0376524329,
0.0655054078,
-0.0550883114,
0.0436851792,
-0.0132793663,
-0.0055317199,
0.0124708116,
0.0165133905,
0.0495963618,
-0.0412681215,
0.0656403676,
-0.0011550986,
-0.0188620519,
-0.0635041445,
-0.0349975824,
-0.0479677618,
-0.0181420967,
0.0215023812,
0.0160513353,
-0.0290858671,
-0.0111803627,
0.0274791121,
0.0200642738,
-0.0540324338,
-0.0097722029,
0.0195756834,
-0.0143003026,
-0.0148612401,
0.0078189326,
-0.061648529,
0.0438106842,
-0.0025645213,
-0.000583382,
0.0500323027,
0.0159228332,
-0.016737625,
-0.0111558009,
-0.0220396742,
0.0178830922,
-0.0039216233,
0.0731501505,
0.0929133892,
0.0528405458,
0.0065199272,
0.0159039665,
0.0858379379,
0.011330626,
0.06946446,
-0.0010258564,
0.0587992445,
0.0012327144,
0.0263545532,
0.0484967828,
0.0413599387,
0.0130335046,
-0.0739099607,
-0.0272190217,
0.0453761593,
-0.0125045246,
0.0114653567,
0.0214654077,
-0.0453790016,
-0.0436905809,
-0.0168565679,
-0.0548114665,
-0.0281196199,
-0.0199656766,
0.0407494307,
0.0005428669,
0.013297745,
-0.0407127254,
0.0460513458,
-0.0145378411,
-0.0066713877,
-0.0018408429,
-0.0093696881,
0.0135873286,
0.006796699,
0.029234102,
-0.0423110537,
-0.0336257443,
-0.0367716774,
0.027641682,
-0.0038867237,
-0.0136462757,
0.0155779151,
0.0049891793,
-0.0481712073,
0.0253687669,
-0.0365191288,
0.0166504141,
0.017673431,
0.0641600713,
0.0609262921,
-0.0193731971,
-0.0096036764,
0.055562526,
0.0523489378,
-0.0034533434,
0.0052343043,
-0.0138620315,
-0.0023989691,
0.0255925376,
-0.0207246281,
-0.0223520491,
-0.0272215866,
0.0026062173,
0.0444470458,
-0.0206442066,
-0.0229122527,
-0.0014204616,
2.773e-7,
0.0281208232,
0.0194476768,
0.0014088413,
0.0262456685,
0.0220398288,
0.0036257091,
-0.0208149832,
-0.0163816996,
0.008401352,
-0.0137496069,
-0.0118624112,
0.0024609144,
0.0699525252,
0.0265462957,
-0.0491570719,
-0.0218291674,
-0.0764668956,
0.0314455703,
-0.0317655578,
0.008585142,
-0.0358403586,
0.0865687728,
-0.0097537609,
-0.0152006363,
-0.0032576197,
-0.0432513207,
0.0456813127,
-0.0535535775,
-0.0393391587,
0.0152028771,
-0.0071920473,
-0.0199717805,
0.0182205234,
0.002526487,
-0.0269020312,
0.0094224988,
0.0181930717,
0.0265566483,
-0.0129314801,
-0.0111335218,
0.0098252986,
0.0037526563,
-0.0251420606,
-0.0443945155,
0.0374992341,
0.0259777103,
-0.0150889689,
-0.0178604163,
0.009662102,
0.0195037257,
0.0169555005,
-0.0336805657,
-0.0350984745,
-0.0059466865,
0.0342904255,
-0.023840636,
-0.0263353605,
-0.031796623,
-0.0467649698,
0.0672149435,
-0.0494584553,
-0.0504139997,
0.0086791711,
-0.0097277425,
0.020016944,
-0.0129184444,
0.0034174097,
2.684004874e-34,
0.0601645075,
0.0235657189,
0.0397261083,
-0.0065041748,
-0.0026777983,
-0.0335327871,
-0.029555425,
0.0171462875,
0.0236353017,
-0.0444111712,
-0.0248423591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13714v1 | BEACON: Balancing Convenience and Nutrition in Meals With Long-Term Group Recommendations and Reasoning on Multimodal Recipes | 2024-06-19T17:14:41 | 2024-06-19T17:14:41 | Vansh Nagpal, Siva Likitha Valluru, Kausik Lakkaraju, Biplav Srivastava | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | A common, yet regular, decision made by people, whether healthy or with any
health condition, is to decide what to have in meals like breakfast, lunch, and
dinner, consisting of a combination of foods for appetizer, main course, side
dishes, desserts, and beverages. However, often this decision is seen as a
trade-off between nutritious choices (e.g., low salt and sugar) or convenience
(e.g., inexpensive, fast to prepare/obtain, taste better). In this preliminary
work, we present a data-driven approach for the novel meal recommendation
problem that can explore and balance choices for both considerations while also
reasoning about a food's constituents and cooking process. Beyond the problem
formulation, our contributions also include a goodness measure, a recipe
conversion method from text to the recently introduced multimodal rich recipe
representation (R3) format, and learning methods using contextual bandits that
show promising results. | [
0.0084511545,
0.0588083938,
0.0193249099,
-0.020693766,
-0.0069541917,
0.0070761368,
-0.01540998,
0.0287162047,
0.0073865196,
-0.0335457548,
0.0008148954,
-0.0047807628,
-0.0098466128,
0.0376757793,
0.0054826508,
-0.0412664041,
0.0165972859,
0.0039418056,
-0.0184158105,
0.0224958062,
0.0243107527,
-0.0165262427,
-0.0040556737,
0.0114944223,
-0.02608441,
0.026208641,
-0.0072854944,
0.0014267153,
0.0192740057,
-0.0756377056,
0.0288664009,
0.0566636808,
-0.0149767613,
-0.0513307601,
0.0000020247,
-0.0075585926,
-0.0468238778,
0.0023336832,
-0.007035017,
0.0150964297,
0.0595030449,
0.0262229424,
0.0077328179,
-0.0056628673,
-0.0381578654,
0.0635984316,
0.0280248728,
0.054320626,
-0.0094291382,
0.0012707933,
0.0118357036,
-0.061219953,
-0.0506006517,
0.0114185363,
0.0814222097,
0.0182391759,
-0.0092437891,
-0.0366285518,
0.0189340934,
-0.0413101092,
0.0215774681,
-0.0145829245,
0.0165756475,
0.0408728123,
0.013622799,
0.045515094,
-0.0025912584,
-0.0230004229,
-0.0102299824,
0.0600940324,
-0.0002232429,
0.0288809314,
0.0042223246,
0.0039649135,
-0.0186274759,
-0.0188161936,
0.0066188737,
-0.0508482978,
-0.0253163353,
0.0497550927,
-0.0105110593,
0.0127213113,
0.0248123407,
-0.0045503336,
0.0478661619,
0.1042185053,
-0.0139583759,
0.018062111,
0.0119045721,
0.0181537494,
-0.0303153209,
-0.033841271,
0.0061281091,
-0.0002220623,
-0.039225217,
-0.0105534717,
0.0148542402,
0.0580088422,
0.004894237,
0.0005551779,
0.0605837591,
0.0222121719,
-0.0316482075,
0.0013350032,
0.0280153416,
-0.0103592062,
-0.0313371345,
-0.008356302,
-0.0655939877,
0.0495707802,
-0.0297389645,
0.0155581022,
0.0098984018,
0.0046017333,
-0.0348394252,
-0.0377480276,
-0.0219767671,
0.039399337,
-0.010752379,
-0.0214852374,
-0.0174440593,
0.0862790123,
0.0202629641,
0.0638386682,
-0.1120944694,
0.0119962785,
-0.0456016734,
0.0058429739,
0.0085115246,
0.0655791536,
0.0411775745,
-0.0007329511,
0.0165054742,
-0.0042095557,
0.0450171642,
0.0607520528,
-0.0265117306,
-0.0312645994,
-0.045934312,
-0.042685274,
-0.0808060989,
-0.0448683165,
-0.0297989417,
-0.0740834028,
0.0319147073,
-0.0089009861,
0.0131294997,
0.0119621269,
0.0492539182,
0.0284937229,
-0.0038165392,
0.0626400933,
0.1218146607,
-0.0324203521,
0.0444819108,
0.0110976892,
-0.0273281392,
0.0321150012,
0.0337690897,
0.0758631006,
0.0363698639,
0.006377758,
-0.027050253,
-0.0026666014,
-0.0043435064,
0.0440348871,
-0.009179879,
0.0025581175,
0.0176775586,
0.0351346284,
-0.0284053776,
0.0428950228,
-0.0528176427,
0.000503677,
0.0997855514,
0.0118350973,
0.0358099639,
0.038685143,
-0.0039516757,
-0.0023860184,
-0.0403221622,
0.0070988564,
0.0145487608,
0.0885312185,
-0.0879070684,
-0.0429125838,
0.0413909666,
0.0188456234,
-0.0100992266,
-0.0389915965,
0.0319113508,
-0.0241824649,
0.0815420747,
-0.0023379328,
0.0241370127,
-0.0700570568,
-0.029014416,
-0.0547660254,
0.0122880554,
-0.0141471643,
-0.0042161159,
0.0210414249,
0.1079059094,
0.0530392565,
0.0347060971,
-0.0080238199,
0.0367298871,
0.0004358386,
0.017170867,
-0.0797492266,
0.0530039109,
-0.0329363868,
0.051879622,
-0.015943028,
-0.0875792354,
-0.0012010901,
0.0020305307,
-0.0253344197,
0.0170715954,
0.0072530564,
-0.0226980597,
0.0139628649,
0.0164387599,
-0.0170006361,
0.02075666,
-0.03178012,
0.0737676099,
0.0089796744,
-0.0085940445,
-0.0030695291,
0.0405917205,
0.0375205018,
-0.0298930369,
-0.0398947001,
-0.0067403018,
0.0383749679,
0.0128907068,
-0.0108152786,
-0.0172212422,
-0.0492617153,
0.0255097654,
-0.0173030291,
-0.0010301402,
-0.0207076259,
0.0128117716,
-0.0401708521,
-0.038224034,
-0.0291376468,
-0.0432509929,
0.0561067499,
0.033872027,
-0.0247664768,
0.0648104548,
-0.003045606,
0.0016390162,
-0.0492878482,
-0.0108588077,
0.0097421715,
-0.0555526465,
0.0445583798,
-0.0451182835,
0.0374775678,
0.0410295427,
0.0278057307,
0.0377902575,
-0.0521945693,
-0.009586555,
-0.076847516,
0.0258171596,
-0.0066817733,
0.0109482296,
-0.0187497716,
0.0040051071,
0.0282204207,
-0.0222605001,
-0.0447702073,
0.0394724682,
-0.0444385149,
0.027500866,
-0.0216267649,
0.0351543427,
0.0396773741,
-0.0206433497,
-0.0048358291,
-0.0089280307,
0.0193702597,
-0.0201453641,
0.0231641661,
-0.0001117182,
-0.1366868615,
-0.0338767208,
-0.0190957729,
0.0136162639,
0.0347143039,
-0.0217360351,
0.0096754283,
0.0364465527,
0.0305607487,
0.0524456464,
0.0295458958,
0.0501975529,
-0.0111100003,
-0.0659541562,
0.0004768244,
-0.0551144481,
0.0535155721,
0.0186755266,
-0.0765147954,
0.0235018879,
-0.0019586992,
0.0072460449,
0.0566461571,
-0.0346932523,
0.0190397296,
0.0097258128,
-0.0484693088,
-0.0702193081,
0.0578067191,
-0.01342999,
0.0615290962,
0.0068193204,
-0.008055767,
0.0614165589,
-0.0003806366,
0.0288293306,
-0.0397479013,
-0.0407616049,
-0.0143614747,
-0.0300332848,
0.0042773676,
0.0420980193,
0.0254689474,
0.0408989079,
-0.0420894213,
0.009029163,
0.0482445285,
-0.0508477949,
0.0479833521,
-0.0374671295,
-0.0431530364,
0.0165550094,
-0.0274930485,
-0.0217314437,
-0.0369658992,
0.0168007221,
-0.0152310375,
0.0241019316,
0.0141241495,
-0.0744036064,
-0.0097075282,
-0.0069707357,
0.0059511159,
0.0087080896,
-0.0407318994,
0.0203055236,
0.0491016507,
0.0232678745,
-0.0025076617,
0.0063505401,
-0.0435348786,
0.0184396543,
0.0562509708,
0.0053800871,
-0.0248160977,
-0.0074942331,
0.0669647604,
0.0314040184,
0.0117876939,
0.00530355,
0.0432478078,
0.0089625111,
0.0377006084,
0.0019725305,
0.0295348335,
0.0214360226,
-0.0971284732,
0.0361481309,
0.0139434198,
0.0001629645,
0.013931754,
0.0396834463,
-0.1084842458,
-0.0292796567,
-0.0150481267,
0.0442657731,
-0.06173205,
-0.0271493923,
-0.0353009775,
-0.0143989213,
0.0025789589,
-0.0129200714,
-0.0592790917,
0.0017750018,
-0.0316082202,
-0.0221621227,
-0.0381384939,
0.0016090026,
-0.0136564905,
-0.023708852,
0.021018846,
0.0217733141,
0.0188661329,
0.0088347252,
0.0351479687,
-0.0659667253,
0.0007045601,
0.0779313147,
0.0213995092,
0.0340671651,
-0.0237952955,
-0.0224009268,
0.0130837355,
0.0183933564,
-0.0116505045,
0.0460343584,
-0.0087965792,
0.0138003007,
-0.0412396938,
0.0615658313,
-0.0075900718,
-0.0598044433,
0.0091864001,
0.0422854535,
-0.0017255893,
-0.0132861184,
-0.0451227836,
0.0007687213,
0.07749933,
0.0275658816,
-0.0221917722,
-0.0111760618,
-0.0172689613,
-0.0436892882,
-0.0519413762,
-0.0333564207,
0.0113920914,
0.0755856708,
-0.0534495041,
-0.0010464995,
-0.0526086874,
0.0424555205,
-0.017414974,
0.0701934546,
-0.052955512,
0.0007201253,
-0.0437533595,
0.0142737916,
-0.0151172196,
-0.0115106283,
0.0340388268,
0.0182303917,
-0.0714134723,
-0.0122497529,
0.0016716056,
-0.0283668544,
0.0016265138,
0.0333945826,
-0.0890155062,
-0.0298804063,
-0.056929145,
0.0817718059,
0.0151991853,
0.0433731601,
0.003534415,
-0.0296527445,
0.0245094933,
0.02810679,
0.0189237706,
0.0000949033,
-0.0110959737,
0.0036539,
0.0040032812,
-0.0258359555,
-0.0313673727,
0.0181583986,
-0.0466890633,
-0.006301702,
-0.0028785511,
-0.0029473957,
0.0258408301,
-0.0527355224,
-0.0287534986,
-0.0215173103,
0.0026072152,
-0.0024122791,
-0.006703415,
-0.0026387009,
-0.031676963,
-0.0324354954,
-0.0327180438,
0.0184390768,
0.0136484765,
-0.0047976659,
-0.0296892375,
0.0093562482,
0.0245359577,
-0.0613051951,
0.012293838,
0.0359859541,
-0.0208996311,
0.0016745365,
0.0201459657,
0.0163787585,
0.0282322802,
-0.0280236397,
0.0029771393,
-0.030267654,
0.0762439147,
0.0016041658,
0.0232226886,
-0.0624119341,
0.0216995962,
-0.0288184211,
-0.0212923996,
0.0075633824,
-0.0343064144,
-0.0088391891,
-0.0622820631,
0.012586832,
-0.0298851505,
-0.0037029351,
-0.0394503102,
0.0559070371,
-0.0226007625,
-0.0076606912,
0.0608123057,
0.0119983293,
0.0254894029,
0.0052444586,
0.0677982271,
-0.0389041677,
0.0136781037,
0.0203331169,
-0.0455932245,
-0.0158109032,
0.0066671865,
0.0152742378,
0.0712849125,
-0.0378021039,
-0.0713856369,
-0.0366325527,
0.0024289906,
0.0071982294,
0.0057214443,
0.0245866477,
-0.0294485595,
0.0142735671,
0.0284449589,
-0.0027934755,
-0.0051672873,
-0.0145567982,
0.0238116365,
-0.054107774,
-0.0200265795,
-0.0048557646,
-6.01296107e-33,
0.0309049748,
-0.0432819836,
0.0399980024,
-0.0207143929,
0.0279711261,
-0.0171696078,
-0.0122109614,
-0.0142173041,
0.0730776936,
-0.0280281641,
0.0283569265,
-0.0533202626,
-0.0004759974,
0.0009461103,
0.0103614926,
-0.0559998602,
-0.0042578727,
0.0289891977,
-0.0554414243,
-0.0177998561,
0.0271507129,
0.0288735162,
-0.0367857702,
-0.0274816025,
-0.0125097847,
0.0213304926,
-0.002883574,
-0.016248934,
-0.0011326689,
0.0513973907,
-0.0554788932,
0.0565957688,
0.0085910093,
-0.0206856187,
0.0094691049,
0.0274186153,
-0.0527718887,
-0.0196480621,
-0.0140024992,
-0.0494112596,
-0.0709500462,
-0.0271324478,
0.0035595153,
0.006171091,
-0.0140512846,
0.0410638489,
0.0595550686,
-0.0108103808,
-0.0253225286,
0.0121726757,
-0.0081457254,
0.0208822228,
-0.0154738938,
0.0147121968,
0.0187228452,
0.0655092075,
0.0157504696,
0.0245020781,
0.000003142,
0.0713652894,
-0.0354901664,
-0.0219879299,
-0.0035860543,
-0.0019404062,
0.0077716778,
0.0298136249,
-0.0083821341,
-0.0287328716,
0.011273521,
-0.0262129717,
-0.0338197239,
0.0679653212,
0.0240948405,
0.0637415573,
0.0269999243,
-0.0217552353,
0.0003710773,
0.0470302179,
0.0277641527,
-0.1043449342,
0.0042265048,
0.044874493,
0.0310607217,
-0.0274907257,
-0.0156868268,
-0.0245286822,
-0.0415999144,
-0.0559206232,
0.0204709154,
0.0297482535,
-0.0237021744,
0.0226291176,
0.0281315837,
0.0437655933,
0.0093995109,
-0.0156342965,
0.0225634035,
-0.0114697274,
-0.0007715788,
-0.0157806408,
-0.0868011564,
-0.0164083093,
0.0141009493,
-0.0309216809,
0.0166411102,
-0.0073589436,
-0.0123922396,
0.0228054263,
0.0216894746,
-0.0121448711,
-0.0029343357,
-0.0068185669,
0.0294932891,
0.003587893,
0.0194562804,
-0.0058618733,
-0.0064879982,
0.0523171537,
-0.005380569,
-0.0036009052,
-0.0509402491,
-0.07327874,
0.0216274951,
-0.0216511674,
0.0096389093,
-0.0054254546,
-0.0384066328,
-0.0387497395,
0.0475452766,
-0.0471169353,
0.0213910472,
-0.0082901753,
2.61e-7,
0.0280845277,
0.0102900276,
-0.0000651743,
-0.0866372436,
-0.0210427344,
0.0594014749,
0.0454768054,
0.0468923375,
-0.0279208403,
0.0363377333,
0.0382811911,
-0.0135386297,
-0.0104475291,
0.0763056949,
0.0663861111,
0.0123376679,
-0.0298045836,
0.0245954301,
-0.0232467409,
-0.006410609,
0.0185911786,
0.0279939324,
0.0637230277,
-0.024332853,
-0.0073893685,
0.0351465493,
0.0414198972,
-0.0830961615,
-0.0146283899,
-0.0568641797,
-0.0048877066,
-0.0304211564,
0.0113147898,
-0.0421678871,
-0.0447065011,
-0.0689126849,
0.0243333988,
-0.0083811386,
-0.0013161828,
-0.0659286082,
-0.0289443657,
0.0195698291,
-0.0163596049,
-0.0564066283,
0.0612915829,
-0.0540787652,
-0.0152148549,
0.0292408615,
-0.0060589025,
-0.0318123363,
-0.0101346141,
0.0127515234,
0.0174079575,
0.0150282606,
-0.008666819,
0.0563173965,
0.0171057004,
-0.045244772,
-0.0197963919,
0.0196371991,
-0.0049723089,
-0.0049624266,
-0.0234694947,
0.0471399128,
-0.0375721864,
-0.103716217,
-0.0387262069,
2.149974805e-34,
0.0138615808,
0.061682526,
-0.006757292,
-0.0347665176,
0.0084260469,
0.0257876236,
-0.0205199551,
-0.0326842219,
0.0442248508,
-0.0369453505,
-0.0484494604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13713v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13713v1 | Benchmarking Open-Source Language Models for Efficient Question Answering in Industrial Applications | 2024-06-19T17:11:51 | 2024-06-19T17:11:51 | Mahaman Sanoussi Yahaya Alassan, Jessica López Espejel, Merieme Bouhandi, Walid Dahhane, El Hassane Ettifouri | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the rapidly evolving landscape of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Large
Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in tasks such
as question answering (QA). However, the accessibility and practicality of
utilizing these models for industrial applications pose significant challenges,
particularly concerning cost-effectiveness, inference speed, and resource
efficiency. This paper presents a comprehensive benchmarking study comparing
open-source LLMs with their non-open-source counterparts on the task of
question answering. Our objective is to identify open-source alternatives
capable of delivering comparable performance to proprietary models while being
lightweight in terms of resource requirements and suitable for Central
Processing Unit (CPU)-based inference. Through rigorous evaluation across
various metrics including accuracy, inference speed, and resource consumption,
we aim to provide insights into selecting efficient LLMs for real-world
applications. Our findings shed light on viable open-source alternatives that
offer acceptable performance and efficiency, addressing the pressing need for
accessible and efficient NLP solutions in industry settings. | [
0.0264042318,
0.0526873469,
0.0155499391,
0.0679602697,
-0.0803048909,
-0.0032703259,
0.017390864,
-0.0000728411,
0.0352224261,
-0.0475159883,
0.0042743455,
-0.002187493,
-0.0315268822,
0.0132985637,
-0.0207391139,
0.030008113,
0.0690239072,
-0.0354079343,
-0.0156857781,
-0.0116542839,
0.0030281204,
0.0387351252,
-0.0262747053,
0.030332176,
0.0410893224,
-0.0223965012,
-0.0002762161,
-0.0085166954,
-0.0065679569,
-0.0012490563,
0.0097012017,
0.0209374148,
-0.0048051346,
0.0533336513,
0.0000017872,
-0.0673592761,
-0.0114081055,
0.0188629106,
-0.0318135768,
0.0233295579,
0.0284056962,
-0.0044879741,
0.0192222502,
0.045875255,
-0.0304717869,
0.0074557341,
0.0443581045,
0.0220786631,
0.0555023067,
0.0308392514,
0.0138507625,
-0.0257754344,
-0.0082908534,
0.0063779764,
-0.0215351954,
-0.0545843765,
0.0331026241,
-0.009404988,
0.0272276383,
-0.0259867329,
-0.0077814599,
0.0398121588,
0.0216502864,
0.030306235,
-0.0201920811,
0.0194165278,
-0.0688089207,
0.0034453443,
-0.0248021539,
0.0922873691,
0.0143063357,
-0.0262051839,
0.002062646,
-0.0040067816,
-0.017351348,
0.0075231907,
-0.043456018,
0.036536511,
-0.0183047578,
0.0116979815,
0.0155526297,
0.005446713,
-0.0096779577,
0.0635945722,
-0.0038533681,
0.0831368193,
0.0197493229,
-0.0374581888,
0.0282792449,
-0.016015267,
-0.0374734998,
-0.0532437935,
0.0181490872,
0.0474339202,
0.0069342656,
0.0355438776,
-0.0379629768,
-0.0047750464,
0.0317717455,
-0.0641759932,
0.000970996,
0.040519733,
-0.0102423681,
0.0757958144,
-0.056406267,
0.0363435373,
-0.0375148319,
0.0198061187,
-0.0579970293,
-0.0423931628,
-0.0200546011,
-0.0210183822,
-0.0493166745,
0.0445485786,
-0.0660678372,
-0.0641634837,
-0.0216689669,
0.0456640199,
0.0242483616,
0.0067408006,
0.0466393158,
0.0443097837,
0.0265277196,
0.007311332,
-0.0515226349,
0.029456554,
-0.0557066016,
0.0061232396,
-0.0295765754,
-0.0928677171,
-0.0262729619,
0.0370648056,
0.0152424546,
-0.0422681831,
0.0403436534,
0.0561326295,
0.0195738655,
-0.0333494805,
-0.0434219912,
-0.015210255,
0.0107361348,
-0.055122219,
-0.0408166908,
-0.0689671487,
0.0267186537,
0.049102325,
0.0018245587,
-0.025043441,
0.0231379792,
0.0434622318,
-0.0456601009,
0.037758138,
-0.0289097484,
-0.0025350247,
0.0264010131,
-0.0132982954,
0.0219661165,
0.0509609506,
0.0054668114,
-0.0136109721,
0.0552323014,
-0.0119848484,
0.0104877278,
0.0316012762,
-0.0266397186,
-0.0186008401,
0.0067195264,
0.0812713727,
-0.0147460522,
0.0504257046,
0.0134804808,
0.0677067786,
0.0264433026,
-0.0398504809,
0.0487631708,
0.0882600099,
-0.0073213223,
-0.0127324481,
0.0267325975,
0.0379969813,
0.0219077729,
-0.0517550819,
-0.0024337885,
0.0154662998,
-0.0573487654,
0.0167364627,
0.0282907616,
-0.0031226454,
-0.0153747611,
-0.0364829451,
-0.0407304838,
-0.0079637682,
-0.025360385,
0.0335372724,
0.059043888,
-0.0173329897,
-0.0394876227,
0.0656835735,
0.0300923381,
-0.0258691702,
-0.0433783159,
-0.0421936363,
0.0499886423,
0.0652009696,
0.0453447998,
-0.0387437269,
0.0018872176,
-0.0243349653,
-0.0033698976,
0.0459868647,
0.0344561301,
0.0024429304,
0.0224589352,
-0.0434370525,
0.0236655455,
-0.0025811389,
-0.0097446218,
-0.0016183787,
0.0505853668,
0.0018795691,
0.0083159059,
-0.0372334383,
-0.0122913048,
0.0330554843,
0.0050539402,
-0.0345241949,
-0.0095357159,
-0.012041145,
0.0135667222,
0.027461106,
-0.0065820469,
0.0299316254,
0.0494446084,
-0.0356377922,
-0.0372437313,
-0.0071145496,
-0.0049160155,
-0.0166181717,
0.0375154391,
0.0069762855,
-0.0117495013,
0.0477035977,
-0.0416219346,
-0.0465132855,
0.0132670943,
-0.0482903086,
0.0363009423,
-0.0380573794,
-0.0474303849,
0.0143858781,
0.0099802474,
-0.0460792668,
0.0484786667,
-0.0081611993,
0.0516426116,
0.0277282503,
0.0020364439,
0.0346342511,
-0.0481496006,
-0.0292882808,
0.0082804179,
-0.025391968,
0.002202438,
-0.0223205071,
-0.0157000925,
-0.0484807491,
0.0108090574,
-0.079348743,
0.027303936,
-0.022369042,
0.0228934065,
0.0233410578,
0.018920999,
-0.0304980837,
-0.0271703396,
-0.0163435582,
-0.0093876254,
0.0373937227,
0.0196889807,
0.0447739922,
0.0150505407,
-0.0117996167,
-0.0390477441,
-0.0127373384,
0.0082442872,
0.0642413944,
-0.0056590135,
0.0242784824,
-0.0423240587,
-0.0122600235,
-0.0442569442,
0.045225352,
0.0114089344,
-0.0064146416,
-0.0247924179,
-0.01276749,
0.0157099068,
0.0545165092,
-0.0003368378,
-0.0237284023,
0.017472202,
0.0044358796,
-0.0503655784,
0.0211183652,
-0.0177739393,
-0.0458214283,
0.0019025392,
-0.0193987042,
0.0121351294,
0.0438672937,
0.0077335667,
-0.0085065328,
-0.0020721427,
0.0269058291,
-0.0100273527,
-0.0083786724,
-0.0470338874,
0.0102809751,
-0.0074653272,
0.0398186706,
0.0015455553,
-0.0378717631,
0.0585420989,
-0.0575478338,
0.0042155944,
-0.0434119888,
-0.0374535769,
-0.0781668574,
0.0455047823,
-0.0213582162,
0.0245969016,
0.0096568801,
0.0059438301,
-0.0002976253,
0.0356935263,
0.0172183607,
-0.0357138626,
0.0346043855,
-0.0581654571,
0.0642935112,
-0.0242675822,
-0.0160018355,
-0.0291310456,
-0.0399295017,
-0.0792328641,
0.0133653432,
0.0078747254,
0.0164051168,
-0.0056333453,
0.053112112,
0.0130397426,
0.0348593108,
0.0014951744,
0.0005324992,
-0.0271352306,
0.0576319136,
0.0593143888,
0.0265600719,
0.043737676,
0.0171108823,
0.0063130837,
0.0613394827,
0.0577961057,
-0.0204446521,
-0.0575217493,
-0.0123432362,
0.0224715155,
-0.0725824609,
0.0131910108,
0.0019659922,
0.0209265873,
-0.041889634,
0.0111954613,
0.1066883728,
0.0271900278,
0.0010941601,
-0.0054372922,
-0.0098718582,
0.0122090364,
0.0398341902,
0.0317272432,
-0.0815984085,
-0.0698466599,
-0.0087284315,
0.0586149842,
-0.0064300303,
-0.0410447456,
-0.0129824439,
-0.1498278379,
0.0152868517,
-0.0478299223,
-0.0393153876,
-0.0220294409,
-0.0729631931,
-0.0021937764,
-0.0434128456,
-0.0102388924,
0.0158189554,
-0.0110722529,
0.0004826206,
-0.0004357313,
-0.0393404476,
-0.0189535189,
0.0386133566,
-0.0235680249,
0.0230281819,
0.034068428,
-0.0278802942,
-0.0063218228,
-0.0223932546,
0.0373619311,
-0.0563707985,
0.013616276,
-0.0437365212,
0.0339392722,
-0.0153250061,
-0.0206435435,
-0.0456939451,
0.0085286116,
-0.0593513474,
0.0183769688,
0.0219459347,
0.069445692,
0.0183890834,
0.0090488307,
-0.0300711729,
0.0032119043,
-0.017328646,
0.0877457485,
-0.0187927037,
-0.0316381268,
-0.093067795,
-0.0097617963,
-0.0518425927,
-0.0231078789,
-0.0133064436,
-0.007054117,
0.0178524647,
-0.0115357982,
-0.0415016711,
-0.0287913494,
0.0342747383,
-0.0010335004,
-0.0345667712,
0.0375819802,
0.005917164,
0.0297148451,
-0.0597102903,
0.0475603789,
-0.0356425717,
0.0515492223,
-0.0658976808,
0.006012179,
0.0342746377,
0.0151525149,
-0.0508665293,
0.0423959717,
-0.0978837758,
-0.0488149412,
-0.0276784562,
0.0502250418,
0.0274677146,
-0.018004952,
-0.0185632259,
-0.0219278727,
-0.033314243,
0.0097088628,
-0.0459261574,
0.0352252088,
-0.0064632432,
0.0204163212,
-0.009936342,
0.0348761678,
-0.0485638045,
0.00868004,
-0.006808829,
0.0458818488,
0.0049501536,
-0.0925654918,
0.0216125399,
0.0396354795,
-0.0071415706,
0.0127153983,
0.0158277471,
-0.0025528264,
0.0472915359,
0.0173605978,
-0.0370558538,
-0.0181248672,
0.0121194348,
0.0228488706,
-0.0356296897,
-0.0025044938,
0.0200272091,
-0.0104949754,
0.0329857543,
-0.0439237431,
0.007098393,
0.0330976918,
-0.0042110062,
0.0179861765,
-0.0246968828,
-0.0488261841,
-0.0112525774,
-0.0041772183,
0.0632903725,
-0.0096757077,
0.0641259477,
-0.008055171,
-0.0226175115,
-0.0140016032,
0.031652011,
-0.0742267892,
-0.0603393987,
-0.004887816,
0.0432516485,
0.037649028,
0.0163267851,
0.0335875377,
-0.0072113215,
-0.0236537606,
-0.021003373,
0.0221237522,
0.0287518688,
-0.0146582434,
0.0700060949,
0.0298263915,
-0.0073929648,
0.0355507769,
0.0783842653,
0.017750524,
0.0451627932,
0.0011505112,
-0.0168860089,
-0.0582288019,
-0.0336345211,
-0.0317251049,
0.0036127549,
-0.0198603794,
0.0057069561,
-0.0721739829,
-0.0437182635,
-0.0074337428,
0.0118565708,
0.0116248783,
-0.0284692403,
0.0552961417,
0.0628057942,
0.075523451,
-0.0317982882,
-0.0284376889,
0.0372901782,
-0.0881342888,
-0.0059764502,
-0.0163354203,
-6.012303895e-33,
-0.0036966426,
-0.0180190802,
0.0151087046,
-0.027194351,
-0.0071594901,
0.0000929247,
-0.0044337567,
-0.0089836242,
-0.0578294098,
-0.0455772392,
-0.0042312131,
0.0138671389,
0.0177770853,
0.018180985,
0.0087773316,
-0.0469146632,
-0.0088321827,
0.0071553397,
-0.0179366972,
-0.0073254793,
0.0233651772,
0.0416540354,
0.0211642627,
0.007038177,
0.002833378,
-0.0218911227,
0.0222297348,
0.0189242624,
-0.0331612453,
0.0472163148,
-0.0413936935,
0.0508721285,
0.024345113,
-0.0245985724,
0.0177339632,
0.0457762852,
-0.0737819746,
0.0115346946,
0.0249159634,
-0.0029053926,
-0.0386425257,
0.0375258774,
0.0058731702,
0.0321958549,
0.0139218951,
0.0240156204,
0.0098451683,
-0.0274198242,
-0.0134009896,
0.0048016836,
-0.0163289737,
0.0322201252,
-0.0123687238,
-0.0045425445,
-0.0070316382,
0.0563140325,
-0.0244750828,
0.0419267714,
-0.0100649763,
-0.0325449854,
0.0105268527,
0.0270655006,
0.0952051654,
0.0227115471,
-0.0044444362,
0.006312761,
0.0073678787,
-0.0658368394,
-0.0266720243,
-0.0090723149,
-0.0289114453,
0.0365726911,
0.0687738508,
0.0274556149,
0.0407984182,
0.0455566905,
-0.0850514695,
0.0085965022,
0.0100623211,
0.0411512069,
0.0355859622,
0.0143215107,
-0.0275060702,
-0.0044636545,
-0.0423921272,
0.0447603166,
-0.0491514578,
0.0045148777,
0.0543565154,
0.0199220162,
-0.0439548045,
0.0071762218,
0.0100465184,
-0.0495312735,
0.0088720573,
0.0111491857,
0.013673149,
0.0240661148,
0.0070694699,
0.0430107825,
-0.0766014978,
0.0206846502,
-0.0322871581,
-0.0176157132,
0.0150379464,
-0.009364564,
-0.0261548571,
-0.0115180686,
-0.0594036765,
0.0167207494,
-0.0551396832,
0.0303983949,
-0.0699972883,
-0.0008262002,
0.0227378625,
0.0087406691,
0.0119565576,
0.052233357,
-0.0048504728,
0.0172098093,
-0.0376627818,
-0.0473657623,
0.0233887509,
-0.0121468678,
-0.0274656657,
0.0271642078,
-0.0057837451,
0.0690836832,
-0.0295371655,
-0.0552537367,
-0.0057799364,
0.0423622914,
2.445e-7,
0.0790463537,
0.0106699951,
0.0494104736,
0.0409144089,
-0.0124893179,
0.0021932616,
0.0094621144,
0.0379700735,
-0.0062033576,
0.0130452458,
-0.0354412533,
0.0163422916,
0.0428993478,
0.0394855253,
-0.0602447465,
-0.0089144446,
-0.0805173591,
-0.0039897426,
-0.0688753724,
-0.0088307597,
0.0735204071,
0.064273119,
-0.0121885939,
0.0064588361,
-0.0285352077,
-0.0647820458,
0.0442658104,
-0.0158137623,
0.0152055426,
-0.0021987169,
0.0336375013,
0.048443716,
0.003143471,
0.0085451817,
0.013823377,
0.0119256275,
0.0196453016,
0.0504132323,
0.0057102297,
-0.0563813969,
-0.0123441238,
-0.0768740922,
0.0114752455,
-0.0546722934,
0.1239220425,
-0.0244725011,
-0.0061611924,
-0.0192128159,
-0.0127839781,
-0.023559697,
-0.0137386722,
-0.0190835111,
-0.0172201302,
-0.0147280395,
0.0145002697,
-0.0604139119,
-0.0088036424,
-0.0665670261,
-0.0217478797,
-0.0188805088,
-0.0377648063,
-0.041202791,
-0.0538718179,
0.0080981264,
0.0244605374,
0.0016803807,
-0.004698616,
2.055419372e-34,
0.038315583,
0.0106309988,
0.0001913207,
0.0668038279,
0.0247345194,
-0.0029025681,
0.0076637156,
-0.0211109389,
-0.0218667816,
-0.12318331,
-0.0007932378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13706v1 | Breaking News: Case Studies of Generative AI's Use in Journalism | 2024-06-19T16:58:32 | 2024-06-19T16:58:32 | Natalie Grace Brigham, Chongjiu Gao, Tadayoshi Kohno, Franziska Roesner, Niloofar Mireshghallah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Journalists are among the many users of large language models (LLMs). To
better understand the journalist-AI interactions, we conduct a study of LLM
usage by two news agencies through browsing the WildChat dataset, identifying
candidate interactions, and verifying them by matching to online published
articles. Our analysis uncovers instances where journalists provide sensitive
material such as confidential correspondence with sources or articles from
other agencies to the LLM as stimuli and prompt it to generate articles, and
publish these machine-generated articles with limited intervention (median
output-publication ROUGE-L of 0.62). Based on our findings, we call for further
research into what constitutes responsible use of AI, and the establishment of
clear guidelines and best practices on using LLMs in a journalistic context. | [
0.0847245455,
0.0895075649,
-0.0249766596,
-0.0119808996,
-0.0561236069,
0.0112515893,
0.0524747707,
0.00672876,
0.0324247628,
-0.0253793281,
0.010013571,
0.0088897701,
-0.0158897396,
0.0495012216,
-0.0134281553,
0.0255565215,
0.0065167183,
-0.0013372749,
0.0595042408,
-0.0100905895,
0.0217586812,
0.0757276714,
0.0032549247,
0.0593561083,
-0.0214096438,
-0.0345333479,
0.0116842361,
0.0116147613,
-0.0070137405,
-0.002089801,
-0.0389145985,
0.0642705783,
0.038004078,
0.0617124401,
0.0000015662,
-0.0387926176,
0.0009030084,
0.0056021134,
-0.0190026537,
-0.0213260781,
0.0635203794,
-0.0747084767,
-0.0303853527,
0.0043640379,
-0.0745557845,
0.0062981066,
0.0427448489,
-0.0196464695,
0.0456685349,
0.1125858575,
-0.0310961902,
0.0010188589,
0.0569863617,
-0.0043466296,
-0.0093562556,
-0.0303729866,
0.0195888188,
-0.0031907556,
-0.0167051256,
0.0034702609,
0.0344045237,
0.0337642804,
0.0385104269,
-0.0365539417,
-0.0318206623,
0.0353710018,
-0.0098021282,
-0.0495355092,
0.0115455911,
0.0084124086,
0.0422766358,
-0.0198665708,
0.0239284988,
0.012337978,
-0.0063214409,
0.0239898618,
-0.0328955576,
0.0787607953,
-0.0497399196,
-0.0142194051,
0.0244924016,
-0.0478945263,
0.0043082982,
0.0424672142,
0.0266404282,
0.02048577,
0.0198928285,
0.0029065744,
-0.0011202508,
0.0118997209,
0.0423026867,
-0.0864420682,
0.019651141,
0.014797247,
-0.0272558834,
0.0344641134,
-0.0492583439,
-0.0285324156,
0.0009092892,
-0.0518994555,
0.0141130621,
0.0031339442,
0.0219965894,
0.0296877138,
0.0213706885,
-0.011646633,
-0.0032373457,
0.026116455,
0.0169808213,
0.019916214,
-0.0127416942,
-0.0264943074,
-0.0011870973,
0.0122291502,
-0.0081190029,
-0.0438132174,
-0.016023377,
0.0229302309,
-0.003993995,
0.0448559374,
-0.0055467635,
0.0295309145,
-0.0631790459,
-0.0423275605,
0.0001234869,
0.0024453797,
-0.033354938,
0.050318528,
0.0091274465,
-0.0131026022,
0.008284579,
0.0138440896,
0.0014641592,
0.0111746909,
-0.0279506389,
0.0762078017,
-0.0300578382,
-0.0053001489,
-0.0298498794,
-0.0327474028,
0.0200332142,
-0.0707056373,
-0.0001261625,
-0.0457717068,
0.0289251916,
0.0085997405,
-0.0244082101,
-0.0854914635,
-0.0064803232,
0.0147215705,
-0.0310868844,
0.035104569,
0.0101167429,
0.042713847,
0.0541564152,
0.0389373861,
0.0216827914,
0.0769606307,
0.0503871962,
0.0879086107,
0.0380546935,
-0.0049120486,
0.0644502565,
0.0279760007,
-0.0146193532,
0.0356156901,
-0.0419195741,
-0.0074745179,
-0.0608748868,
0.0167853627,
0.0337548703,
0.0552015901,
-0.0157748889,
0.0277065393,
0.1089977399,
0.0596213527,
-0.0148740178,
0.0317091048,
0.0679374784,
-0.0012948659,
0.0109602204,
0.0313087218,
-0.0144064054,
0.0155648608,
-0.0510503389,
-0.0372381024,
-0.008545165,
0.0530228838,
-0.0216023661,
-0.0241941661,
0.0199311599,
-0.0237444211,
0.0079951994,
0.0015250642,
0.0065972051,
0.0233872496,
-0.0263829529,
-0.0191148855,
0.0098207826,
-0.0301164035,
0.0191684179,
-0.0717949569,
0.0295503736,
0.0800844282,
0.0518986322,
0.0183982141,
0.0330800638,
-0.0303955916,
0.0214805938,
0.061018642,
0.0070116734,
0.0002509762,
-0.0358899757,
-0.005688482,
-0.0142844161,
-0.0290449541,
0.0300025903,
0.0160823669,
0.011364216,
0.0576380491,
-0.0109063331,
-0.0015888792,
-0.0678166449,
0.0109683583,
-0.0792371854,
-0.048524797,
-0.0259014089,
0.0038155855,
-0.0036303981,
0.0456152,
-0.0232304204,
-0.0120113846,
0.0172693599,
0.0012060967,
-0.0198851395,
-0.0073856171,
-0.003693796,
0.0497541763,
-0.031127153,
-0.0501934141,
-0.0104796123,
0.0143373972,
-0.0145490244,
0.0064723715,
0.0429463312,
-0.0151302917,
0.0304215103,
-0.0440848656,
0.0022240335,
-0.0274953339,
0.0072741099,
-0.0030223136,
0.0499141552,
-0.0265828613,
-0.0119507676,
0.0056442777,
-0.0178416446,
-0.0282696895,
-0.001583589,
0.0022031688,
0.0284966417,
0.0049202456,
0.0510772243,
0.034688171,
-0.0164965969,
-0.0317671858,
-0.0474954918,
-0.0453998037,
0.012463402,
-0.0319236815,
-0.0012712161,
0.0451178737,
0.0026407854,
-0.0292939041,
0.0250756852,
-0.0191655792,
-0.0451365858,
0.0186524615,
0.0323276781,
-0.0122744525,
-0.0013717818,
0.0036295196,
-0.019401392,
0.0158138759,
-0.0236339886,
0.0359233171,
0.0480676293,
0.0100589581,
-0.0551674366,
0.0569635443,
-0.0454615355,
-0.004780883,
-0.0268789381,
-0.0473215133,
0.0368784256,
-0.0104695121,
-0.0247287247,
0.1009124368,
0.0525087453,
0.0734962523,
0.0358939469,
0.02763962,
-0.0384080783,
-0.0178405736,
0.0001392246,
-0.0281870048,
-0.0600358732,
-0.04365623,
0.0260969996,
-0.0309734028,
0.0254324693,
0.0414894372,
0.0005086138,
0.0960041583,
0.0003191295,
-0.0713889375,
0.0630174279,
-0.0479197912,
-0.0004322156,
0.0687667355,
-0.010489895,
-0.0522082373,
0.0500869974,
0.0000533379,
0.0545465015,
-0.0138963358,
-0.0258469619,
0.001013763,
0.0687651932,
-0.0203417968,
0.0525187366,
-0.0035760407,
-0.0208006408,
-0.0412710831,
-0.0181945954,
0.043437764,
-0.0306590572,
0.0032636502,
-0.0139497789,
0.0035954684,
0.0304854345,
-0.0108443191,
-0.0360238068,
-0.0732063726,
-0.0324837491,
-0.0188913681,
0.0461302213,
-0.0596056618,
-0.035492301,
-0.0094077149,
0.066749841,
0.0188739561,
-0.0177388042,
-0.0067302058,
-0.0017481686,
0.0155001702,
0.0667264238,
-0.0165611301,
0.0057090977,
0.0200650841,
0.0189453382,
0.0089379195,
-0.0235557724,
0.0497502498,
-0.0141162146,
-0.0047558383,
0.0224008225,
-0.0010334477,
-0.0161092505,
0.0025059599,
0.0254484266,
-0.0234365501,
0.002416553,
0.0852163956,
0.036693655,
-0.1059237942,
-0.0109079806,
0.0092479466,
-0.0241305456,
0.0062850146,
0.0241707936,
-0.1124405861,
0.044394996,
0.0133810313,
0.0090090539,
-0.062474478,
-0.0415414125,
-0.0482584387,
-0.113844879,
0.0435448103,
-0.0042492296,
-0.0235788077,
-0.0047582686,
-0.0620350316,
-0.0202899538,
0.0025711844,
0.003451407,
-0.024481643,
-0.0119455848,
-0.0124714598,
-0.0010218025,
-0.0245291404,
-0.0735050887,
-0.0024208978,
-0.0234287754,
0.0581214614,
0.0716904849,
0.044257246,
-0.0239680689,
0.0056597521,
-0.0400715545,
0.0809647664,
-0.0000861369,
-0.0054657953,
0.0551302582,
-0.0160513278,
0.0028204287,
-0.036181014,
0.0500930622,
0.0139529286,
0.0205310192,
0.0093575697,
0.0147983003,
-0.0280197859,
-0.0369048752,
-0.0045441189,
0.0113994153,
0.0686691999,
0.0435309298,
0.0349160247,
-0.0578728169,
-0.0081219468,
-0.0331073366,
0.0367389955,
-0.0457718708,
-0.0246979706,
0.0046228259,
-0.0111477878,
-0.0688097775,
-0.0739725828,
-0.0542527661,
-0.0097747175,
0.0103845447,
0.0270062443,
-0.0191718526,
-0.0058687865,
-0.0057219551,
0.0095572872,
-0.0284436587,
-0.0054257489,
0.002248591,
-0.0080361068,
-0.0095327897,
-0.0127330273,
-0.0203140359,
0.0028824366,
0.0337267481,
-0.0456016362,
-0.0554668605,
0.0328840017,
0.0200746711,
0.0282638185,
0.0251351427,
-0.0038921209,
-0.0507028624,
0.0178588908,
0.0938427672,
-0.0591636747,
0.0170358568,
0.0156689808,
-0.0015258252,
0.0099013317,
0.0151844546,
-0.0162729137,
0.0314354822,
0.0096570021,
-0.0236674435,
-0.0453189537,
-0.0180588085,
0.0198412631,
0.0046601826,
-0.0480098613,
-0.0324640535,
0.0209192894,
-0.0552313961,
-0.0339158699,
-0.050512109,
-0.0147304358,
-0.0293350089,
-0.0094407629,
0.0203407425,
0.0363672674,
-0.0178951062,
0.0338181779,
-0.0449090935,
0.0323925465,
-0.05909729,
0.0183586068,
0.0342111439,
0.0140910558,
-0.0041280296,
0.0045501273,
-0.0150377592,
0.0631678179,
-0.0268994793,
0.0381832905,
-0.0066745635,
0.0172517952,
0.008884904,
0.0097280201,
0.0304689445,
0.0218537785,
-0.089649424,
-0.0842214525,
0.010901059,
0.0480374508,
0.066798985,
-0.0162292141,
0.034892574,
-0.0071217516,
0.0045149247,
0.005637804,
0.0006109982,
0.0267201215,
-0.0540293083,
-0.0229852069,
0.0172651634,
-0.0378281474,
0.0286507364,
0.0656779855,
-0.0024745958,
0.0513499342,
0.0068187984,
-0.0458493121,
-0.0117014404,
-0.0348682441,
0.0419193283,
-0.006994667,
0.0252963807,
-0.0349679068,
-0.031694252,
-0.0672199801,
-0.0169891547,
-0.0199758895,
-0.010030468,
-0.028909361,
-0.0361097679,
0.0831321478,
0.0278051775,
0.0215702672,
-0.0544641949,
0.003903192,
-0.0538608469,
-0.0664968938,
0.0157679636,
-5.903212509e-33,
0.0304238927,
-0.0488153249,
0.0083639193,
-0.0079477616,
-0.01793731,
0.0430958159,
-0.0260295477,
-0.0134941693,
-0.0407690071,
0.003782083,
-0.0557923131,
0.0190563742,
0.0019772882,
-0.022077946,
0.0095285177,
0.0119569302,
0.0398028418,
-0.0308835171,
-0.0340434201,
0.0422961898,
0.0189719349,
-0.0094481865,
0.0079139415,
-0.0869613141,
0.0438085683,
-0.0260035414,
-0.0754021406,
-0.0226666313,
0.0052994387,
0.0499277711,
0.0021450091,
0.0161880907,
0.0264032949,
-0.0237250496,
0.0000647378,
0.0760232806,
-0.0228472427,
-0.0051256311,
0.0369180292,
-0.0088011213,
-0.0036554202,
-0.0350753143,
0.0455630459,
-0.0374523997,
-0.0067206016,
0.00480837,
0.0266914759,
-0.0297302399,
-0.0107334014,
-0.0386644676,
-0.0584916547,
-0.0250830874,
-0.0293346532,
0.0028072847,
-0.0217982307,
-0.0202845968,
0.0107546644,
-0.0010342951,
-0.0417556129,
0.0090983929,
0.000763273,
0.0112798773,
0.0693054646,
-0.008487327,
-0.0038986704,
0.0418661125,
0.0275027417,
0.029557975,
-0.0618001781,
0.0006289139,
0.0250018686,
0.0388220511,
-0.0122385984,
0.0685602948,
-0.0160970669,
-0.090068236,
-0.0576556958,
0.0145602431,
0.0440347083,
0.0215119496,
0.0434510373,
-0.0203703512,
-0.0283409618,
-0.0193676539,
-0.0106810648,
-0.0414549746,
-0.0403249525,
-0.070449017,
-0.0030549956,
0.006687582,
-0.0184848532,
0.0252382476,
0.0138489576,
-0.0439032167,
0.0108190058,
0.0553046726,
-0.0315702744,
0.0036821559,
-0.0134447701,
0.0169848558,
-0.0694243461,
0.0098577887,
0.0229361337,
0.030751802,
0.0383393653,
0.0111667812,
0.0474094264,
0.0435606837,
-0.0296801087,
0.0032630141,
-0.0069898022,
0.0508772507,
0.0368612595,
-0.0036629038,
0.0242125522,
-0.0150196357,
-0.0172743835,
-0.0294918083,
0.0262123123,
0.0138957547,
-0.0255987067,
-0.0113902297,
-0.0262645967,
0.0200602934,
-0.0438492484,
-0.0034619358,
-0.0294246916,
0.0386943631,
0.0530942492,
-0.0553535074,
-0.0111551601,
-0.051517535,
2.538e-7,
0.0089627076,
0.0282915942,
-0.0292168483,
0.0463482626,
0.0101832869,
0.0000867645,
0.0300659426,
0.0307620913,
-0.0151820425,
-0.037545152,
0.0320350267,
0.0457940586,
0.0515179373,
0.0708442852,
-0.07096605,
0.0257316325,
-0.0955085456,
-0.0122805089,
-0.0878777802,
-0.0101973386,
0.039719604,
0.0080948994,
0.0330872722,
-0.0300218053,
-0.0274148844,
-0.069119744,
0.0220894385,
0.0090121282,
-0.0237665102,
0.0092598898,
0.0402590036,
0.0468221232,
-0.0128642479,
0.0010119128,
-0.0157523137,
-0.0099932281,
-0.0195736885,
0.0539370291,
-0.0049112132,
-0.0040730732,
0.020767387,
-0.0391218774,
0.0013659392,
-0.0331150889,
0.0647125095,
-0.0265051797,
-0.041052673,
-0.075739257,
-0.0145155564,
-0.0553433225,
0.0220781956,
-0.0472727902,
0.0020741774,
0.0297686402,
-0.0229509175,
0.0178143084,
0.0299822856,
-0.0219434742,
0.0012170932,
-0.0172816832,
-0.0221293177,
-0.0356977433,
-0.0055680056,
0.0071048262,
-0.0230785664,
-0.03356326,
0.0712874234,
1.829294896e-34,
0.0224490613,
0.0263225771,
-0.0133808898,
0.03179802,
0.0361109823,
0.052689828,
-0.0024678432,
-0.0149290124,
-0.0033552076,
-0.047161866,
-0.0120618269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13698v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13698v1 | MMTE: Corpus and Metrics for Evaluating Machine Translation Quality of Metaphorical Language | 2024-06-19T16:52:22 | 2024-06-19T16:52:22 | Shun Wang, Ge Zhang, Han Wu, Tyler Loakman, Wenhao Huang, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation (MT) has developed rapidly since the release of Large
Language Models and current MT evaluation is performed through comparison with
reference human translations or by predicting quality scores from human-labeled
data. However, these mainstream evaluation methods mainly focus on fluency and
factual reliability, whilst paying little attention to figurative quality. In
this paper, we investigate the figurative quality of MT and propose a set of
human evaluation metrics focused on the translation of figurative language. We
additionally present a multilingual parallel metaphor corpus generated by
post-editing. Our evaluation protocol is designed to estimate four aspects of
MT: Metaphorical Equivalence, Emotion, Authenticity, and Quality. In doing so,
we observe that translations of figurative expressions display different traits
from literal ones. | [
0.0435478985,
0.0145582641,
-0.0394886211,
0.0290632267,
-0.0292499755,
-0.0018281755,
-0.035421446,
0.0088198064,
-0.0287582036,
-0.0402637385,
-0.0355884172,
-0.0093575446,
0.0539606549,
-0.0222837292,
-0.0027176999,
-0.0622780733,
-0.0044057714,
0.0393370464,
-0.0156502519,
-0.0025893962,
-0.0207540356,
0.0441334434,
0.0105503807,
0.0706134588,
-0.0008913535,
-0.0109002469,
0.0208968613,
0.0718080103,
0.0501559488,
-0.0259360261,
-0.0425020158,
0.0043135067,
-0.0048553944,
0.0265125893,
0.0000018882,
-0.0535342507,
-0.013442805,
-0.0125095462,
0.0423972607,
-0.0036807708,
0.1355695575,
-0.0383161232,
-0.0083573423,
-0.0143025508,
-0.0105367014,
0.0224241968,
0.0498807095,
0.0170880109,
0.0521433242,
0.051000867,
-0.014309858,
-0.0194705948,
-0.0189180654,
-0.004892861,
-0.0338380523,
0.0120662358,
-0.0172196794,
0.0273435079,
-0.026995685,
-0.0426277146,
-0.0170402136,
0.037866015,
0.016710544,
0.016798703,
-0.0389462411,
0.0030499359,
-0.0432849564,
0.0158771649,
-0.0028033503,
0.0386431329,
0.0162572116,
-0.0124107013,
-0.0468437001,
-0.0039654579,
-0.0195533521,
0.0227034129,
-0.0046482687,
0.0108011421,
0.0332643911,
0.0227637403,
0.002369059,
0.0479091294,
-0.013905202,
0.0060683852,
0.008507181,
-0.023447739,
0.020735113,
-0.0066617769,
-0.0185142066,
-0.0424498208,
-0.0463582873,
-0.0280989204,
0.0035422547,
-0.0249698665,
-0.002951547,
0.0011975026,
-0.0343266986,
-0.047802031,
0.0057907291,
-0.0776461661,
0.0755152404,
0.0598782897,
-0.0092240144,
0.039157711,
-0.0112883821,
0.0305021182,
0.0180280227,
0.0480647311,
-0.0623345152,
-0.0153773902,
-0.0472894236,
0.0535777025,
-0.0725412443,
-0.0152502367,
-0.0297913123,
-0.0000314212,
-0.0494625382,
-0.0188975986,
-0.0306236651,
-0.0366965085,
-0.0259681437,
0.0032150315,
-0.0513364747,
-0.023826668,
-0.0566515997,
-0.0093134213,
-0.0492013507,
0.0140529517,
-0.0458495803,
-0.0708674639,
0.018293757,
0.0385630727,
-0.0112323137,
-0.0481659025,
0.0126723219,
0.076382257,
0.0160917826,
-0.0273501556,
-0.0078447219,
-0.0305931568,
-0.0027761948,
-0.0341680497,
-0.0432330966,
-0.0125947567,
0.0725069642,
-0.0334718153,
0.0295420028,
-0.0563915558,
-0.0038519558,
-0.0189248268,
-0.0010674977,
0.0470233709,
-0.0108308708,
0.0144845536,
-0.0124836331,
-0.0018784563,
-0.0986557305,
0.0069179623,
0.0792984366,
0.0511269607,
0.0485421754,
0.0020706279,
-0.0272424202,
0.004511286,
-0.0421790667,
0.0182362646,
-0.072206445,
0.0146788331,
-0.0123954639,
0.0753094181,
0.007495834,
0.0661908686,
-0.0280680582,
0.0221006535,
0.0597762652,
0.0545097664,
-0.0129577471,
0.0076513686,
0.0964198411,
0.0213485695,
0.0252674744,
0.0162584726,
-0.0037538735,
0.0104811629,
0.0388584659,
-0.0043925918,
0.0211798176,
0.0601216182,
0.0286699235,
-0.0084116887,
-0.0190778114,
-0.0121650035,
-0.0129886586,
-0.0449451879,
-0.0188081767,
-0.0019473837,
-0.0035362639,
0.0093537085,
-0.0042692185,
-0.0191652495,
-0.0118990596,
-0.0159982685,
-0.0549548268,
0.0704478323,
0.0444209836,
0.0028028234,
0.0179575346,
-0.0315089189,
-0.01640963,
0.0442667082,
0.0079766,
0.0200045593,
0.0232744347,
-0.0049564554,
0.0308519937,
-0.0056846146,
0.0304744784,
0.0170498695,
-0.03624814,
0.0681216642,
0.021038048,
-0.0548510849,
-0.0622870438,
0.0364607982,
-0.0187667608,
0.0115957195,
0.0066900924,
-0.0044680145,
0.0317929797,
-0.0264071934,
-0.0492133126,
0.0074814218,
0.0185738038,
-0.0482135043,
-0.0274855811,
0.1290480644,
-0.0175274666,
0.0136570381,
0.0498993136,
-0.1059966981,
-0.0142268939,
0.0273009539,
0.0066409656,
-0.0094575277,
0.0049745436,
-0.0512260124,
0.0556126162,
-0.0500618145,
0.0144739309,
-0.0372060128,
0.0188505407,
0.0202820599,
-0.0008483994,
-0.0054363827,
0.0302882735,
-0.0166553408,
-0.0369518846,
0.0075599002,
0.0452325903,
-0.0163336303,
0.0112419361,
0.0216203127,
0.02093409,
-0.0068024192,
-0.0166788753,
-0.0540867969,
-0.0397212356,
-0.0789297074,
0.0217349567,
-0.0014968372,
0.0081090266,
0.0680821612,
-0.0222874433,
-0.0325089656,
0.0200714134,
0.0091254124,
-0.0234477054,
-0.0072313072,
-0.0068086195,
0.0347803123,
-0.0388622507,
0.0032585855,
-0.0174800251,
0.0399676003,
-0.0080386922,
0.0653479174,
0.0132939583,
0.0256366692,
0.011615782,
0.0026136178,
-0.0669668987,
-0.0514640249,
0.0147528937,
-0.0840046555,
-0.0079599973,
0.0421794541,
0.0676698983,
0.0251337402,
0.0110016726,
0.0154222362,
0.055686675,
-0.0154456329,
0.0001357549,
-0.0460067652,
0.0279531721,
-0.0366316475,
-0.0196294431,
-0.0931859091,
0.0318830758,
0.0212020352,
0.052135624,
-0.0080462722,
-0.0395662561,
0.0515591726,
-0.0198165253,
-0.0221409239,
0.0377556197,
0.0404912606,
0.0005650574,
0.044507388,
-0.0135892164,
-0.0240536369,
0.0751175135,
-0.030360667,
0.0031534233,
-0.0123151913,
0.0009362252,
-0.0052383989,
0.0683577806,
-0.036934305,
0.043957945,
-0.0173195638,
0.0469230562,
-0.0096917748,
-0.0254060924,
0.0299784038,
-0.0372921117,
0.0144373095,
-0.0547103882,
-0.0262250397,
0.013387342,
0.0319387428,
0.0224387534,
-0.0297471266,
-0.0253158305,
0.0111206481,
0.0086250501,
-0.0152115189,
-0.0323345028,
-0.0285616852,
0.0031228308,
0.0165457148,
0.001453434,
-0.0313190445,
-0.0217504911,
-0.0054548904,
0.0089705912,
0.0056229518,
0.0169160534,
-0.0071097361,
0.0561965518,
0.0329665393,
-0.070759587,
-0.0202123225,
-0.0309074055,
0.0053574224,
-0.0179528594,
-0.0225378312,
0.0319196694,
-0.0130190076,
0.0569696985,
-0.0118770292,
-0.003320344,
0.0714877769,
0.0449302383,
0.0128078992,
0.0331736691,
-0.0288695004,
0.0218136217,
0.0138729801,
0.0061671771,
-0.0802898481,
-0.026154574,
0.013085939,
0.0232151654,
-0.0161494762,
-0.0329421498,
-0.0180431809,
-0.0671475753,
0.0379812196,
0.014760647,
-0.0129041458,
-0.0055125267,
0.0200812928,
-0.0110748746,
0.0012015318,
0.0007914336,
-0.0204061251,
0.0170030594,
0.0152421333,
-0.0244915523,
0.0508296676,
-0.0418144166,
0.037560042,
-0.0431790203,
0.0147580188,
-0.024440594,
0.0981213897,
-0.0157882292,
-0.0388230048,
-0.0607782416,
-0.0038473888,
-0.008556488,
0.0379983298,
-0.0241544433,
-0.000120371,
0.0298704933,
0.0008249368,
-0.003392902,
0.0300544258,
-0.0371247083,
0.0206423588,
0.0476648398,
-0.0434281752,
0.0034821003,
-0.003915824,
-0.0003785117,
-0.0293936655,
0.0802279338,
0.0558165722,
-0.0473929271,
0.0401448309,
-0.0307502393,
-0.009522954,
-0.0309456028,
-0.0148613118,
-0.0074253795,
-0.0932448953,
-0.0053410023,
-0.1128009483,
-0.0295830555,
0.0036243631,
0.0274042152,
0.0286117792,
-0.0368420668,
-0.0459649302,
-0.0255270544,
-0.0629258975,
0.0606960282,
0.0013145347,
0.0201781448,
-0.0142807523,
0.0314150676,
0.0303513054,
-0.0548604429,
0.0042502652,
0.0414620079,
-0.0278579835,
-0.0465922877,
-0.0138939479,
0.0147496015,
0.0209583249,
0.0044521769,
-0.0130394865,
-0.0125363488,
0.0143520553,
0.0133300647,
-0.0491094813,
0.0427172557,
0.0042548962,
0.0217296835,
0.0061276066,
0.0451791547,
0.0084446389,
0.0301356148,
-0.0005648183,
0.0367000997,
0.0341186151,
-0.0039907913,
0.0371260531,
0.0262693167,
0.010586598,
-0.0444845445,
-0.0856251642,
-0.0091371862,
-0.0327405371,
-0.0311662965,
-0.055987481,
-0.0296380408,
-0.0019953246,
0.0390859209,
0.0444622301,
-0.0460872799,
-0.0520279668,
-0.0473622195,
-0.0296960212,
0.0540580116,
-0.0101650218,
0.013753497,
0.0268112496,
-0.0224526636,
0.0459481329,
-0.0234016292,
-0.0378519706,
-0.0620300286,
0.0331054926,
-0.0280579776,
-0.0255831145,
0.0200501382,
-0.0055232421,
0.0110938894,
0.0579509325,
0.0112444488,
-0.0113413585,
-0.0066963374,
-0.0069573629,
0.0482649095,
-0.0096936179,
0.0694320574,
-0.0341835357,
0.0055185165,
0.0116082691,
0.0519377999,
0.017279299,
-0.0051633655,
-0.0429326631,
-0.0128993588,
-0.0058660032,
0.0283781812,
-0.0135304062,
-0.1193483174,
0.0196588542,
-0.0000898793,
-0.0496303737,
-0.002387603,
0.0109234415,
-0.0419214182,
-0.0217247326,
0.0260031633,
-0.0166294742,
-0.0825024173,
-0.0613863617,
0.0751170889,
0.0422335826,
0.0090619754,
-0.0039022886,
0.0012516861,
0.0463260226,
-0.0044210893,
0.0482737757,
-0.073637329,
-0.0069425232,
-0.041661758,
0.0347600915,
-0.0476718992,
-5.571924773e-33,
-0.0328461044,
-0.0111188507,
-0.0408349894,
-0.0422547422,
-0.0487372912,
0.0126696071,
-0.0579430498,
-0.0134116672,
0.0257343948,
0.0378344618,
0.0183136743,
-0.0221334677,
-0.0011423983,
-0.0445923582,
0.0267719422,
0.060423892,
0.0191751104,
0.0160207972,
-0.0622878373,
-0.0504887216,
0.0415731929,
-0.0058909967,
0.0865966082,
-0.0261504054,
0.056737598,
0.0115400963,
-0.0460981652,
-0.0133539457,
0.0294779371,
0.0415422879,
0.003680408,
0.0403837264,
0.003294447,
0.0286360513,
-0.0022615166,
-0.0486688279,
-0.0040079295,
-0.0111353006,
0.0429801978,
0.0036797454,
-0.0103354044,
-0.0261484645,
0.0499575958,
-0.0310088433,
-0.0356729999,
-0.0045835883,
0.0222731065,
-0.030918818,
0.0371534936,
-0.0298294574,
-0.0406901389,
0.0069583296,
-0.0262276642,
-0.0215476193,
0.0009387068,
0.0580202937,
-0.0096269296,
0.0594052821,
-0.0814141259,
0.0184760503,
-0.0727136657,
-0.0138321379,
0.0055262344,
-0.0608603023,
0.01332819,
0.0686609149,
0.0139549179,
-0.0048919031,
0.0042888899,
0.0673625097,
0.0492248349,
0.0071004354,
0.0589264743,
0.0836361423,
0.0595821328,
-0.023508314,
0.0166395288,
0.0290484037,
-0.0131341908,
0.0306877811,
0.0114352945,
0.0143733323,
-0.0103065381,
0.0333862901,
-0.060724631,
-0.0276213996,
0.0059433971,
-0.0353886485,
-0.0017703412,
-0.0308944508,
-0.012721994,
-0.0019953558,
0.0238577798,
-0.0076378682,
0.016415637,
-0.0414160974,
-0.0565668158,
0.0561808422,
0.0059096711,
0.0274007041,
0.0566757098,
0.0015558577,
0.0089272233,
0.0228338428,
0.0649728104,
-0.0298163071,
0.0438162126,
0.0145601723,
-0.0544516295,
0.0365889929,
-0.0134016695,
-0.0346917026,
-0.0402417034,
-0.0625766218,
-0.0175570138,
0.0186938662,
-0.0257503223,
-0.0162349902,
0.0398401245,
-0.0055793854,
-0.0377970263,
0.051049877,
0.0108033754,
0.0347403102,
-0.0421283841,
0.0283423793,
-0.0313837491,
-0.0481480993,
0.0403872989,
-0.0412715636,
-0.0276296735,
-0.0252080467,
2.704e-7,
0.0352714136,
0.0372676253,
0.0084659606,
0.0306899622,
-0.0057769269,
0.0432646833,
-0.0301235672,
0.0236494541,
-0.0086046457,
0.0105906921,
0.0087695876,
0.0240445025,
0.0482468344,
0.0522534288,
-0.0801361352,
0.0162253492,
-0.0452917963,
0.0128541887,
-0.0386969596,
-0.0011829083,
0.0748954937,
0.0193775538,
0.0407346562,
0.006512695,
-0.0064086854,
-0.0446251705,
0.0474872142,
-0.0651639625,
0.0130021907,
0.0133825038,
0.0340395533,
-0.0108614909,
-0.0004411578,
0.0013692802,
-0.0012770547,
-0.0014008619,
0.0427277423,
0.0315397456,
-0.024917772,
0.0093696667,
0.000070066,
-0.0574961379,
-0.0136270123,
-0.0446860269,
0.0176598188,
-0.0249115061,
-0.0259723812,
-0.0230291784,
-0.0196974128,
0.0182479303,
0.0911279321,
-0.0366667174,
-0.0542592779,
0.0452647805,
0.0539157875,
0.0166155584,
-0.0041889665,
-0.0062045055,
-0.0353997089,
0.0016728427,
0.0099119749,
-0.0085099675,
0.0188271664,
0.008161677,
0.0058154985,
-0.0870093778,
0.0039805681,
1.768624808e-34,
0.0347423926,
0.0012648228,
0.0356500894,
-0.0078271739,
0.0860948339,
0.0028093352,
0.0429182462,
-0.020988252,
-0.0219139326,
0.003478324,
-0.0164000783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00071v1 | Combinatorial Reasoning: Selecting Reasons in Generative AI Pipelines via Combinatorial Optimization | 2024-06-19T16:47:44 | 2024-06-19T16:47:44 | Mert Esencan, Tarun Advaith Kumar, Ata Akbari Asanjan, P. Aaron Lott, Masoud Mohseni, Can Unlu, Davide Venturelli, Alan Ho | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.ET, cs.LG | Recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities
at tasks that require human intelligence and are a significant step towards
human-like artificial intelligence (AI). Yet the performance of LLMs at
reasoning tasks have been subpar and the reasoning capability of LLMs is a
matter of significant debate. While it has been shown that the choice of the
prompting technique to the LLM can alter its performance on a multitude of
tasks, including reasoning, the best performing techniques require human-made
prompts with the knowledge of the tasks at hand. We introduce a framework for
what we call Combinatorial Reasoning (CR), a fully-automated prompting method,
where reasons are sampled from an LLM pipeline and mapped into a Quadratic
Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) problem. The framework investigates
whether QUBO solutions can be profitably used to select a useful subset of the
reasons to construct a Chain-of-Thought style prompt. We explore the
acceleration of CR with specialized solvers. We also investigate the
performance of simpler zero-shot strategies such as linear majority rule or
random selection of reasons. Our preliminary study indicates that coupling a
combinatorial solver to generative AI pipelines is an interesting avenue for AI
reasoning and elucidates design principles for future CR methods. | [
0.0381025523,
0.0823661163,
-0.0076986453,
0.0097232061,
-0.0732791424,
0.0375516973,
0.0538725629,
-0.0051353131,
0.0126999943,
-0.0252943747,
0.0432232991,
-0.0451448411,
-0.0082127061,
0.0088651879,
0.015210174,
-0.016999485,
-0.000680761,
-0.0839488879,
0.0301045272,
-0.0254688151,
-0.0305556264,
0.0588386282,
-0.0560930185,
0.0254694428,
-0.0293635279,
-0.0072906851,
-0.0087876888,
-0.0215430409,
-0.0035044176,
-0.0118803652,
-0.0410965644,
0.0298118219,
0.0202132296,
-0.0174864065,
0.0000025753,
-0.0549467243,
-0.0088182166,
0.0049282978,
-0.0946062282,
-0.0206269529,
-0.0258520897,
0.0414939933,
-0.0131030828,
0.0476017259,
-0.0371610187,
0.0039240746,
0.0431703515,
0.0416407399,
0.0245387778,
0.0536273941,
-0.0006990337,
-0.0325767323,
0.0142587414,
-0.013183252,
0.0102133825,
-0.0422593728,
-0.000400844,
-0.02710527,
0.0388239101,
-0.0076321051,
-0.0017558197,
0.0171364415,
0.0300842822,
-0.0444652848,
0.0078590652,
0.0298613962,
-0.0208473261,
-0.031796813,
0.0072394805,
0.0701040402,
-0.0275924765,
-0.0349583924,
0.0031704446,
-0.0139455888,
-0.0116230566,
-0.0059104906,
-0.035979595,
0.0656961948,
-0.0340465382,
0.0455311202,
0.0209740326,
-0.0141276438,
0.02486258,
0.0079246592,
-0.0524425954,
0.0897377953,
0.0032718086,
-0.0206140261,
0.0503732935,
0.0063938648,
0.0120060751,
-0.0844835266,
-0.0267211143,
0.0599216521,
-0.0747450292,
0.0146883447,
0.0303180777,
0.0223013349,
-0.0037448911,
0.021349933,
0.0567385778,
0.0493260846,
0.0286977477,
0.0511360466,
-0.0171362851,
0.0394341312,
-0.021745909,
0.0176704172,
-0.0278742537,
-0.0241334252,
-0.0629265383,
-0.0125669455,
-0.028357299,
0.0456262603,
-0.0586416982,
0.004992045,
-0.0115284706,
0.0413960293,
-0.0244409181,
0.0329745486,
0.0269301943,
0.0233361851,
0.0331939571,
-0.0539629981,
-0.0309970398,
0.0009306062,
-0.0799729154,
0.0062691271,
0.0249371063,
-0.0560614131,
-0.0332497321,
0.0248276386,
0.0107370745,
-0.0440736227,
0.0053804978,
0.0784679502,
-0.0132415919,
-0.0014974739,
-0.0381406732,
-0.0248333719,
-0.0298850704,
-0.078437157,
0.0075740027,
-0.0520621613,
0.0037045453,
0.011005383,
-0.0031566855,
-0.0248035789,
0.0163180362,
0.0080691511,
-0.0066317772,
0.057606291,
0.0149763944,
0.0228591338,
0.0098108398,
-0.0297059491,
-0.0317065679,
0.0644892454,
0.0316940062,
0.0134529881,
0.0007097273,
0.0118687088,
0.0195886753,
-0.037592791,
0.0034637842,
-0.0055237659,
-0.0077376543,
-0.018577354,
-0.0249448009,
0.0400282219,
-0.00910707,
0.0556138344,
-0.0129030589,
0.0148925837,
0.0170514788,
0.0577312708,
0.0238568559,
0.0107702361,
0.0474592149,
0.0046128081,
-0.029102657,
0.0028359483,
-0.0324886031,
0.0806675106,
-0.0389343649,
-0.0103910994,
0.0100039821,
0.0381054319,
-0.0294999182,
-0.0721568167,
-0.0147317909,
0.0291027855,
0.0021331448,
0.036195159,
0.0363885388,
-0.0258635655,
-0.0413521454,
-0.0178368799,
0.0067847795,
-0.0457081497,
-0.0493078157,
-0.0629551634,
0.06266509,
0.0664821565,
0.0533679165,
0.0090372553,
-0.0211728066,
-0.0044817487,
-0.0064827153,
0.0256270524,
0.023782067,
-0.0265767127,
0.0089191813,
-0.0656463206,
-0.0316403024,
-0.0270918701,
-0.0046166033,
0.0302783996,
-0.0180378631,
-0.0121134305,
-0.0157488827,
0.0131071191,
-0.0162704494,
0.0310237613,
-0.0025650004,
-0.0192980301,
0.0595776998,
0.0303980578,
0.0324845947,
-0.0005486206,
0.0018409481,
0.0364344008,
0.0026197743,
-0.0609814227,
-0.0397025123,
0.0018964545,
-0.0322086364,
-0.0264868345,
0.0178270414,
-0.0207495485,
-0.0070909248,
-0.0037903551,
-0.0393618941,
-0.0441024527,
0.0406700708,
-0.0204442944,
0.0104894517,
-0.0373287275,
0.0036708713,
0.0078251967,
-0.0030446709,
-0.0329091772,
0.0882532373,
0.0232105013,
-0.0258387234,
0.0238264743,
-0.0088285813,
0.0417240635,
-0.0604641214,
0.0257386174,
0.0532295704,
-0.0070135933,
-0.0083735818,
0.0258409716,
-0.0078942142,
-0.021195963,
-0.0203483105,
-0.0796297714,
-0.0015683679,
-0.0161731578,
-0.0040157135,
-0.0363694541,
-0.0169437546,
0.0181062445,
0.0076497383,
-0.0492656454,
0.0021923231,
0.0088167125,
0.002141491,
0.0526031777,
-0.0121813044,
-0.0183047224,
-0.0139298514,
-0.0129512409,
-0.0358319357,
0.042512998,
0.0231535006,
0.0132257063,
-0.01354005,
0.0172441658,
-0.0128682088,
0.0069529028,
0.0069013364,
0.0119899549,
0.0218910314,
-0.0388646163,
0.0171658099,
0.10983897,
0.0182449464,
0.013026461,
0.0643272027,
-0.0119051915,
-0.0547994152,
0.0511093959,
-0.0164561775,
-0.0112424167,
0.0152149377,
-0.0327403359,
0.0079145059,
0.0311189592,
-0.0081090378,
-0.0290512387,
-0.0696072504,
0.0672744736,
0.0340482555,
0.0061271428,
-0.0684115738,
-0.0356580652,
0.0031470761,
0.1040007696,
-0.0107660387,
-0.0137611274,
0.0959006324,
-0.0129172588,
0.0126561206,
-0.0427666828,
0.0098409234,
-0.057735879,
0.0317241177,
-0.0396449789,
0.0166289043,
-0.0200953726,
0.0216192547,
-0.0416346155,
-0.0159740914,
0.0164157432,
-0.011276762,
0.0110958898,
-0.0677898899,
0.026482366,
0.0147782536,
-0.0598491728,
-0.0561289936,
0.0082472106,
-0.0266569778,
0.001712799,
0.0336457156,
0.0010888808,
0.0025419269,
0.0224461518,
0.0078681028,
0.0147445602,
-0.0019567334,
-0.0161394943,
0.0033646545,
0.0147763193,
0.0152171627,
0.0045195441,
0.0543173291,
0.0077725127,
0.0649608523,
0.0010163637,
0.041061759,
0.0447393879,
0.0051005278,
0.0506602898,
0.0154388035,
-0.007575389,
-0.0107649378,
0.0284592602,
0.0397341289,
-0.0258876253,
-0.0180202164,
0.092700921,
0.0526196323,
-0.0325961486,
0.00814992,
-0.0304799248,
0.013760631,
0.0021268285,
0.0624590218,
-0.0556391031,
-0.0437540635,
0.0303107053,
0.0379914641,
-0.0368757248,
-0.0305200983,
-0.0221611578,
-0.1382793933,
0.0540967882,
-0.0031308373,
0.0069867447,
-0.0098768556,
-0.0382685252,
-0.0116101541,
-0.0190325491,
-0.0353759676,
0.0260581486,
0.0389771499,
0.0073924628,
0.0215769615,
0.0317207985,
-0.0296266321,
0.0384533182,
0.0130119286,
0.0399185866,
0.0677223653,
0.047572799,
0.0443502106,
-0.0564328693,
0.0146094942,
-0.0107789794,
0.0089940997,
-0.0100258878,
0.0022272298,
0.0315517895,
-0.0101378746,
-0.0165877398,
0.0509359688,
-0.04564685,
-0.035241276,
0.0153454179,
0.0782207251,
-0.0353782289,
-0.0400924012,
-0.0137909437,
0.0185742415,
-0.0050057522,
0.0795374662,
0.0351603851,
-0.0235556699,
-0.057206165,
-0.070224382,
-0.0202456973,
-0.0936880335,
-0.0003849241,
-0.0043758927,
0.0552406237,
-0.0243544783,
-0.0811884254,
0.0044671968,
0.0340278409,
0.0762130842,
0.0071746162,
-0.0333037339,
0.0107507557,
0.0174477566,
0.0182069447,
-0.0085685309,
-0.0174963325,
0.019104803,
-0.0547033325,
-0.0131315934,
-0.0039589861,
-0.0517344847,
-0.004588353,
0.0366729423,
-0.0500448272,
-0.066349566,
-0.0342898034,
0.0435672775,
0.0305202734,
0.0301184524,
-0.0171235818,
-0.0311510507,
0.024754392,
0.0420867763,
0.0411079898,
-0.0121705066,
0.0121274153,
0.0022044179,
-0.0042667692,
0.0321805626,
-0.0210590959,
0.0486244038,
0.0210232232,
0.0619957224,
-0.0424312428,
-0.0119153718,
0.0432011336,
0.0334259942,
-0.0132395746,
-0.0145101445,
-0.0308323503,
-0.0377394855,
0.0300837439,
-0.0079842452,
-0.0251480676,
-0.0401600786,
0.0332394317,
-0.0051783123,
-0.04959796,
0.0277793873,
-0.0779695362,
-0.0077570775,
0.0452804118,
0.0221879724,
-0.0173742287,
0.0157742649,
0.017556617,
0.0158684794,
0.0044697584,
0.0011675983,
0.0568966642,
-0.0110940859,
0.066449821,
-0.0087151676,
0.0973740816,
0.0375508256,
-0.0035842841,
-0.0288225934,
-0.0208830889,
-0.0716883466,
-0.0930987597,
0.0255327001,
0.0231669918,
0.0502572209,
-0.0005549956,
-0.0017280773,
-0.0252665021,
-0.0070705228,
0.0129169347,
0.0229471177,
0.0400005169,
-0.0343851335,
-0.0214516576,
0.0513249226,
-0.0023868165,
-0.0395016447,
0.0383451618,
-0.0403854065,
0.0140838176,
-0.017199859,
0.0184075255,
-0.0420694612,
-0.0437904298,
-0.0179207157,
0.0388320014,
0.0298568793,
0.0358659513,
-0.0763052851,
-0.0476137213,
-0.0217496008,
0.0113258744,
0.00778569,
-0.0191135928,
0.0477664247,
0.0403608792,
-0.0138535211,
-0.00662131,
-0.0353373103,
-0.0040100627,
-0.017287299,
-0.0137443701,
-0.0455038808,
-7.162034348e-33,
-0.0224311594,
-0.0406633615,
0.0240564831,
-0.0254969429,
0.0458482727,
-0.0298536215,
-0.057742402,
-0.0205014162,
-0.0401517041,
0.0142336879,
-0.0380075648,
-0.019339459,
-0.0001904727,
0.0166189447,
0.0121225305,
0.0060797743,
0.0003718257,
0.0086951908,
-0.0517606661,
0.0396555997,
0.0523988642,
-0.0346086435,
-0.0440273397,
-0.0014215099,
-0.025459772,
0.0299235024,
-0.0246422123,
0.0566504113,
-0.059655901,
0.0166298766,
-0.0226470064,
0.01077516,
0.006458573,
-0.0659388378,
0.0314426534,
0.0206087232,
-0.0465801023,
-0.0397355147,
0.0327582881,
-0.0463257059,
-0.0189474784,
-0.0662560463,
-0.0141353635,
-0.0017916997,
-0.0223999489,
-0.0085028578,
0.0007828798,
-0.0154034812,
-0.0132493395,
-0.0346034504,
-0.0149029437,
-0.0105476622,
-0.0544850715,
-0.0277638398,
-0.004531838,
0.0381303318,
-0.0184700917,
0.022338884,
-0.0111948941,
0.0548283085,
0.0271822307,
-0.0315459818,
0.0753131658,
-0.031923987,
-0.0028756806,
0.0277308282,
0.0243986044,
-0.0180893503,
-0.0806840882,
0.020370258,
-0.0206161365,
0.0268006325,
0.0674726367,
0.0133229708,
0.0375379957,
0.0169082265,
-0.0690570101,
0.000227164,
0.0068471478,
0.0261812378,
0.088665992,
0.0222250521,
-0.0470291227,
-0.0600807257,
-0.0418838523,
-0.0418411121,
-0.0473240688,
-0.00450631,
0.0290844217,
0.0015480695,
-0.0551534854,
-0.0432549603,
0.034167774,
-0.0224973205,
0.0139748966,
0.0610359013,
-0.0140277361,
0.0103412848,
0.0037751633,
0.0080965478,
-0.0335534774,
0.0104398364,
0.0359845087,
0.0127144773,
0.0268330853,
0.0315271281,
0.0035020099,
-0.0041369996,
-0.0327473767,
-0.0098945433,
-0.095411256,
0.0496483557,
0.0012283833,
0.0041659973,
-0.0095909722,
0.0371279456,
0.0125016868,
0.0368554778,
-0.0105948541,
0.0086506894,
-0.012470115,
0.0409202017,
-0.0583247021,
0.0163125955,
-0.0203925818,
-0.0037558293,
0.0001816869,
-0.0127994586,
0.03469887,
-0.0404075868,
-0.023071833,
0.0479692779,
3.197e-7,
-0.0092422003,
0.0573442504,
0.0218602512,
0.0087379897,
-0.0043264856,
0.0388271473,
0.0167500954,
-0.043431744,
0.0046878853,
-0.0159598552,
0.0013707436,
0.0874885917,
0.0368093029,
0.0415051319,
-0.0648316815,
0.0098576546,
-0.0092117088,
-0.0394271351,
-0.0435832143,
-0.005093928,
0.0929233804,
0.0529005229,
0.0164710321,
-0.044309631,
0.0307768974,
-0.0168969482,
0.008481903,
-0.0013411931,
0.0308256652,
0.0290411022,
0.0271199215,
-0.0522920154,
-0.0032968367,
0.0464279689,
0.0092759533,
-0.008751695,
-0.0352061167,
0.0596680157,
-0.0065668277,
-0.0762584433,
-0.0286319405,
0.0020627405,
0.0188320801,
-0.0555462502,
0.1020257026,
-0.0223887302,
-0.0300969444,
-0.0166289452,
0.0146016115,
-0.0128228823,
-0.0168188978,
-0.0177077446,
0.0048963772,
0.0169844124,
-0.0135837458,
-0.0212657377,
0.0482148267,
-0.0855518803,
0.0210051555,
0.0111264978,
-0.0184396915,
0.0024516729,
-0.0169651713,
0.0280526131,
0.0550874248,
-0.0411308743,
-0.0024192187,
3.122659187e-34,
0.0225813054,
0.0149421599,
0.0286400132,
0.0237015244,
0.0516562723,
0.045507323,
-0.0822507441,
-0.0070717991,
0.0464888364,
-0.0913373977,
-0.0277334936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15504v1 | Dr.E Bridges Graphs with Large Language Models through Words | 2024-06-19T16:43:56 | 2024-06-19T16:43:56 | Zipeng Liu, Likang Wu, Ming He, Zhong Guan, Hongke Zhao, Nan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Significant efforts have been directed toward integrating powerful Large
Language Models (LLMs) with diverse modalities, particularly focusing on the
fusion of vision, language, and audio data. However, the graph-structured data,
inherently rich in structural and domain-specific knowledge, have not yet been
gracefully adapted to LLMs. Existing methods either describe the graph with raw
text, suffering the loss of graph structural information, or feed Graph Neural
Network (GNN) embeddings directly into LLM at the cost of losing semantic
representation. To bridge this gap, we introduce an innovative, end-to-end
modality-aligning framework, equipped with a pretrained Dual-Residual Vector
Quantized-Variational AutoEncoder (Dr.E). This framework is specifically
designed to facilitate token-level alignment with LLMs, enabling an effective
translation of the intrinsic `language' of graphs into comprehensible natural
language. Our experimental evaluations on standard GNN node classification
tasks demonstrate competitive performance against other state-of-the-art
approaches. Additionally, our framework ensures interpretability, efficiency,
and robustness, with its effectiveness further validated under both fine-tuning
and few-shot settings. This study marks the first successful endeavor to
achieve token-level alignment between GNNs and LLMs. | [
-0.0197210927,
0.075201042,
0.0085896803,
0.0496410169,
-0.0068858406,
-0.0034400467,
-0.0231911372,
-0.0277320761,
0.0077327634,
-0.0394205414,
-0.0152991833,
-0.0093061412,
0.0034399284,
0.0805294514,
0.0496105887,
-0.0031040765,
0.0336472951,
-0.0139823202,
-0.0049576173,
-0.0128092645,
0.0032277994,
0.0545089021,
0.0275832433,
0.0266639385,
-0.0349990577,
0.0038038576,
-0.0123012094,
0.0515984222,
-0.002571576,
-0.028402973,
-0.04677644,
0.0175382923,
0.0899705589,
0.0360382646,
0.0000017637,
-0.0005807024,
0.0129971104,
0.0043496708,
-0.0482443348,
-0.0044563618,
0.0323169567,
-0.0410799682,
0.021756215,
0.0000992778,
-0.0106558893,
-0.0682760924,
0.0447206534,
0.0054166904,
0.0483303554,
0.0627288073,
-0.0231638718,
-0.0192994308,
0.0548145734,
-0.0416462421,
-0.0078040357,
-0.0430453904,
0.0415574796,
0.0153530454,
0.0028967054,
-0.0128918914,
-0.0862876549,
0.0337811299,
0.0161006488,
-0.0275215432,
0.0436396785,
0.0271996651,
0.0104625095,
-0.0009797685,
-0.0154679008,
0.1240596101,
0.0075211911,
-0.0477057509,
-0.0136278272,
-0.0167327803,
-0.0135642476,
0.0061700358,
-0.0314311273,
-0.015262194,
0.051071763,
0.0366009697,
-0.043450769,
-0.029313514,
0.1084778383,
-0.0107941963,
-0.0212289002,
0.0196150932,
0.0173827987,
0.0098621966,
0.0036119455,
0.0008127987,
-0.0287282839,
-0.0312930085,
-0.0240382981,
0.0276705064,
-0.0443829075,
-0.0009937694,
-0.0554927774,
-0.0138210049,
-0.0329211429,
0.0256656781,
0.0125420969,
0.0189490244,
-0.0224784389,
0.0470361523,
-0.0224694051,
0.0386017971,
-0.0616365112,
0.0602417365,
-0.0478023998,
-0.0412788913,
-0.0151518481,
-0.0081870155,
-0.0121376589,
-0.0077833841,
-0.0259455368,
-0.0974295735,
-0.0366771072,
0.0467934646,
-0.0183175411,
0.0331333205,
0.0170158464,
0.0550867245,
-0.0042976253,
-0.012111919,
0.0432442613,
0.0482576936,
0.0094683832,
0.0354801565,
-0.0309084784,
0.0156456567,
0.0095531233,
0.0402574539,
0.062073525,
-0.0247950144,
0.0069382708,
0.0836544931,
0.020870382,
-0.0032264807,
0.0134393387,
0.0136667779,
-0.0298068095,
-0.0264417585,
0.0095503917,
-0.0695438981,
0.0683684349,
0.020178372,
-0.0006291834,
-0.0438957997,
0.0229957364,
-0.0455336459,
-0.0405984074,
0.0912809148,
-0.0097049288,
0.0253418665,
0.005527623,
-0.0326054543,
0.0353484005,
0.0423076525,
0.0507377125,
0.0265106205,
0.0097095221,
-0.0112944143,
-0.0450155847,
0.0573464669,
0.0322524831,
-0.0066741919,
-0.0487558432,
-0.022507377,
-0.0418391041,
0.0369909815,
0.0510798804,
0.0545828007,
-0.0234330557,
-0.0325035006,
0.0362312794,
0.0401979648,
0.0088834753,
-0.0058071674,
0.0426525548,
0.0295051988,
-0.0369136594,
-0.0350180194,
-0.0539692268,
0.0060091969,
0.0181981064,
0.0271195378,
0.0026315202,
-0.0041324757,
-0.0118454872,
0.01545888,
-0.0103662033,
-0.0396762937,
0.0680498928,
0.0244802516,
0.0623011366,
0.0107262088,
-0.0423184708,
0.0408337638,
0.0448695906,
0.0013254117,
0.045582328,
0.0015648735,
-0.0180329401,
0.0415171161,
0.0236782059,
0.0194259826,
-0.0047202148,
-0.0149099287,
0.0132060228,
0.0075324071,
-0.0032093688,
-0.0150503386,
0.0161358658,
-0.0556582101,
-0.0703733265,
-0.030989591,
-0.0081790127,
0.0490017682,
-0.0320725217,
-0.0040191882,
0.0211474355,
-0.0983015969,
-0.0100002429,
0.019296106,
0.0291681532,
0.0094706155,
-0.0064542973,
0.0157606751,
0.0053490265,
0.0296765678,
-0.0044989674,
0.016484594,
0.033174675,
-0.0272868741,
0.0100771086,
0.0135723995,
-0.0526288673,
-0.0358550362,
0.0316861607,
-0.0179805048,
-0.0410452336,
0.0164730698,
-0.0623414889,
-0.0446279757,
0.0525844358,
-0.0542997271,
0.0258796122,
-0.0060136765,
-0.0145632634,
-0.0044715116,
0.0228349697,
0.0102123255,
0.028104445,
-0.0007011882,
-0.0096008843,
0.0088244444,
0.0268434267,
0.008014705,
-0.0417860374,
-0.021250641,
0.0341199525,
0.017718548,
0.0024115152,
0.010963724,
-0.0353400074,
-0.02965785,
0.0286731459,
-0.1215063184,
-0.0116947265,
-0.0134469159,
0.0087765874,
0.0047954456,
0.0140973246,
0.0063695665,
-0.0205997769,
-0.0531602055,
0.0352371968,
0.0296007004,
-0.002552592,
0.0289758258,
-0.0259660035,
-0.0201885961,
-0.0142287351,
-0.0313234217,
-0.0292493887,
0.0829473585,
-0.0053259153,
-0.0266424492,
0.0020969803,
-0.0215819124,
-0.0308237132,
0.0230744239,
-0.0222014301,
-0.0140065616,
-0.0100084106,
0.0021742268,
0.0616586022,
0.0308469068,
-0.0278381463,
0.0276989285,
0.0294088311,
-0.0231203474,
-0.0439838246,
-0.0088937115,
-0.0298105497,
-0.0095142853,
-0.0656714514,
0.0044432483,
-0.0445111357,
0.0314063393,
0.0178006031,
0.0165886693,
-0.0304036327,
-0.0041900612,
0.0029085923,
-0.0118624046,
-0.0240489934,
-0.0526471809,
-0.0205106642,
-0.0040068114,
-0.0727848709,
-0.0195757262,
0.0711929724,
-0.0306939948,
-0.0228972156,
0.0546496436,
-0.0276852138,
-0.0488635786,
0.0533628874,
0.0604472198,
0.0214450508,
-0.0400305651,
-0.0414207056,
-0.0478197113,
0.0010451111,
0.0008836776,
-0.0227905773,
0.0377800651,
0.0171317775,
0.0264294501,
-0.0015876093,
-0.0244983546,
-0.007979908,
-0.0129435817,
-0.0301499516,
0.0283727162,
0.0135130649,
-0.0348598957,
-0.0196286496,
-0.0068183071,
-0.0150778499,
-0.0106647434,
-0.0178352296,
0.0343542174,
-0.0452845395,
0.0729855075,
0.0642812625,
0.0016926667,
-0.0102201793,
-0.0289135985,
-0.0203331355,
0.0328212269,
0.0100146765,
0.005694475,
-0.0591059588,
0.0242808815,
0.0028138405,
0.0521545671,
0.0105500109,
-0.0125593832,
0.0661568716,
-0.0328921117,
0.0088217976,
0.0680645928,
-0.0089037148,
-0.04711923,
-0.0121039841,
0.0174857602,
0.0276857615,
0.0111874472,
-0.0050251293,
-0.0810035318,
-0.0420580879,
0.0004254025,
0.0122885508,
0.0605711043,
-0.010647255,
-0.0074160374,
-0.0746788606,
-0.0029494665,
0.0392414927,
-0.0137536228,
-0.0429323278,
-0.0292968191,
-0.003335641,
-0.01679313,
0.0431061573,
-0.0560672358,
0.0025234998,
-0.0235696845,
0.0135772498,
0.0151488511,
-0.0308788754,
0.0130480183,
-0.0397262387,
0.0370227993,
0.0202273987,
0.0536070839,
-0.0154350512,
-0.0046766843,
0.0552641302,
-0.0058166506,
-0.0252343304,
0.0182177965,
0.0145460283,
-0.0255204793,
-0.0052522612,
0.004383164,
0.0242136084,
-0.0361272581,
-0.0299930666,
-0.0569360629,
0.0795746967,
0.0117566008,
-0.0242237523,
-0.0199377779,
-0.0388377644,
-0.0123126181,
0.0090350388,
0.0597468503,
0.012317122,
-0.0221565831,
-0.0297705941,
0.038005501,
-0.0466133133,
-0.0361309461,
0.0061314958,
-0.0091474149,
0.0117552588,
-0.020807445,
-0.0146895535,
-0.0016642824,
-0.0115466826,
0.0085794823,
-0.0111657418,
0.0271517672,
-0.0505661257,
-0.1078478768,
0.0611148849,
-0.0340690874,
0.0427583717,
-0.0254655182,
-0.012591972,
0.0197370984,
-0.0250727199,
-0.0081824427,
0.0132207992,
-0.0965680629,
-0.0770944133,
-0.0286435094,
-0.0260613281,
0.0040235673,
0.0693198666,
-0.0265250802,
-0.0067405761,
0.0704009607,
0.0423568338,
-0.0247899033,
-0.0057346374,
0.0026994867,
-0.0210411679,
-0.029255053,
0.0216814708,
-0.0865361094,
0.0175159927,
0.0302177537,
0.0300869029,
0.0032172068,
-0.0436185002,
-0.0084362542,
0.0192119796,
0.0496587567,
-0.0063914568,
0.0067903819,
-0.0728631839,
-0.0389045216,
-0.0051430734,
-0.0158756822,
-0.0288626291,
-0.0275972243,
0.0465362296,
0.0127262175,
-0.0239873193,
0.010697552,
0.0463066399,
0.0137789194,
-0.0318638012,
-0.0073681064,
-0.0057781716,
-0.0495521538,
0.0398369133,
0.0380390249,
-0.0091993092,
0.0421633758,
0.0187589135,
0.0117101902,
-0.0247542337,
0.0159415789,
0.0134720393,
-0.0208164882,
-0.0525781475,
0.0248631276,
-0.0307960287,
-0.0204940941,
-0.0233919341,
0.0166104641,
0.0562469997,
0.0006740902,
0.0407191552,
0.0196760278,
-0.0156743228,
-0.0388532169,
0.0657549724,
-0.0473316871,
-0.0481671095,
0.0749580786,
0.0276801288,
-0.0139365755,
0.034512464,
0.0177187528,
0.0572096556,
-0.0032790564,
-0.0119663551,
-0.0113019366,
-0.0220803339,
-0.0176628176,
0.0155501356,
0.0128816562,
-0.0205812398,
0.0042034741,
0.0015137161,
-0.1093475893,
0.0066873161,
-0.007986702,
-0.0341053344,
0.0247099735,
0.0066116652,
0.0118340729,
0.0164631326,
-0.0118229548,
-0.0028326744,
0.0262981672,
0.0069027334,
-0.0127366809,
0.0056907968,
-6.03490461e-33,
-0.0224471912,
-0.0605555251,
-0.0125902407,
-0.0331720039,
-0.0581328385,
0.0383123755,
-0.0461032428,
-0.0201710742,
-0.0150363604,
0.0195799973,
0.0335464962,
0.0192936193,
0.0019302666,
0.0470366143,
-0.0341934934,
-0.0356810316,
0.0633386821,
0.0119672175,
0.014086022,
0.0172723923,
0.0305575412,
0.0358490497,
0.0458313264,
-0.0740393475,
0.033362031,
-0.0038776384,
0.0269351676,
0.0266137253,
0.0465331897,
0.0418073423,
-0.0138566596,
0.067834273,
0.0077492464,
0.0556437373,
-0.0217271391,
0.0324508063,
-0.0892950743,
-0.0119324056,
0.0044349674,
0.0505226254,
-0.0361072086,
-0.0052344762,
0.0786309466,
-0.0155237857,
0.0245106276,
-0.0382603407,
0.0577016212,
0.0165691637,
-0.0386877246,
-0.0330028236,
-0.0538730584,
0.026628552,
-0.0100398166,
-0.0088620177,
0.0396673121,
-0.0282015391,
0.044083368,
0.0195739269,
-0.0775387362,
0.0201713592,
-0.0554617681,
-0.006088594,
0.0695526749,
0.0636564195,
0.0141486209,
0.0509821363,
0.0312368609,
-0.0562244132,
-0.0408463813,
0.0350300297,
0.0292593185,
0.0457463749,
-0.0062175752,
0.0367068388,
-0.0178699512,
-0.0054341177,
-0.0752601326,
-0.0125638293,
-0.048056569,
0.0403481759,
-0.0118832681,
0.0589509532,
-0.0053754924,
-0.04507697,
-0.0397767909,
-0.0490024984,
-0.0340168513,
-0.0190540962,
-0.0005909973,
-0.0210735165,
-0.0165049434,
0.0185585935,
0.0265328828,
-0.0586201437,
-0.0318647325,
0.0858485848,
0.0133646047,
0.0284335986,
-0.0080776373,
0.0440173708,
-0.047658436,
-0.0229878519,
0.0495654456,
-0.0248912834,
0.0176453441,
-0.0023090506,
0.026218215,
0.0359101892,
-0.0236508008,
-0.0124495719,
-0.0447398871,
-0.0679141134,
-0.0278941449,
0.0101031233,
0.0780386999,
0.0488517731,
-0.0206671134,
0.0608343594,
0.0299824961,
0.0517824292,
-0.0116374521,
-0.0020278126,
0.0102995355,
0.0479282662,
-0.0342966951,
-0.0138108199,
-0.0302467607,
0.0069233817,
0.0588916391,
-0.0635322556,
-0.0112055652,
0.0069849808,
2.571e-7,
0.073600255,
0.0215356965,
0.0715618953,
-0.0040331776,
0.0076574376,
0.0361980163,
-0.0320670716,
0.0374529511,
-0.0062713404,
-0.0238248706,
0.0506836325,
0.0592696406,
0.0086528454,
0.0205426831,
-0.043241784,
0.068940863,
-0.0827223808,
-0.0028437527,
-0.0414169729,
0.022177713,
0.0267434847,
0.1002983749,
0.0188320223,
-0.0048511787,
0.0078394106,
-0.0661703125,
0.0705063343,
-0.0310097579,
-0.0245634187,
-0.011051422,
-0.0329641551,
0.0055936002,
-0.0275179371,
-0.0028925738,
0.0126697356,
0.0504491329,
0.0470123477,
0.0301011689,
-0.0293381959,
-0.0353210568,
-0.0617021136,
-0.0071470304,
-0.0157116745,
-0.0057320567,
0.0424640216,
-0.0789132044,
-0.0606410988,
-0.0572496355,
-0.0390606262,
-0.0094070267,
0.0212258864,
0.0039947573,
-0.0073458599,
0.0168479402,
0.0412544943,
-0.0145652946,
-0.0327446386,
-0.0770738572,
0.0065589668,
0.0042018755,
-0.0467474759,
-0.0070759235,
-0.0160879828,
0.0106202569,
0.0511328354,
-0.0066497107,
-0.0072364477,
2.013580497e-34,
0.0204356983,
0.0129763102,
-0.0214115512,
-0.019954795,
0.0238154829,
-0.047366254,
0.0036795421,
0.0133646652,
0.0037121745,
-0.080100216,
-0.0205131825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13692v1 | Synchronous Faithfulness Monitoring for Trustworthy Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T16:42:57 | 2024-06-19T16:42:57 | Di Wu, Jia-Chen Gu, Fan Yin, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) have shown strong performance and
wide applicability in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, there are significant
trustworthiness concerns as RALMs are prone to generating unfaithful outputs,
including baseless information or contradictions with the retrieved context.
This paper proposes SynCheck, a lightweight monitor that leverages fine-grained
decoding dynamics including sequence likelihood, uncertainty quantification,
context influence, and semantic alignment to synchronously detect unfaithful
sentences. By integrating efficiently measurable and complementary signals,
SynCheck enables accurate and immediate feedback and intervention, achieving
0.85 AUROC in detecting faithfulness errors across six long-form
retrieval-augmented generation tasks, improving prior best method by 4%.
Leveraging SynCheck, we further introduce FOD, a faithfulness-oriented decoding
algorithm guided by beam search for long-form retrieval-augmented generation.
Empirical results demonstrate that FOD outperforms traditional strategies such
as abstention, reranking, or contrastive decoding significantly in terms of
faithfulness, achieving over 10% improvement across six datasets. | [
0.0483672954,
0.0959033892,
-0.0063537476,
0.0241471622,
-0.047784403,
-0.0051981858,
-0.0392686613,
-0.0213437025,
0.0072706584,
-0.0235703308,
-0.0041475906,
-0.0291581992,
0.0257766694,
0.0294921361,
0.0141239977,
0.0303351413,
0.0885636657,
0.0167119894,
0.0251971669,
0.0185018983,
0.0211747587,
0.020774506,
-0.0148540866,
0.0448534265,
-0.0292055663,
-0.0085688112,
0.0008924591,
0.0457910858,
0.0336170755,
-0.0453902669,
0.0124353962,
0.039128229,
-0.0352607816,
0.0872210264,
0.000002232,
-0.0394700542,
-0.0420220569,
-0.0074972515,
-0.0147687197,
-0.0026032378,
-0.0063290838,
-0.0483493805,
-0.0027757145,
0.0225079805,
-0.0308033694,
0.0181491319,
0.0416637398,
0.0031146363,
0.0548257753,
0.0627805069,
0.0131227188,
0.0459810607,
0.0357408188,
-0.0333925672,
0.0066728415,
-0.0245930143,
0.0040941192,
-0.0165296663,
-0.0226181727,
0.049208656,
-0.0171185844,
0.054978773,
0.0205789749,
-0.0245939773,
0.0263997447,
-0.0198801737,
-0.0354476646,
-0.03143261,
-0.0084660705,
0.0176847745,
0.047646448,
-0.0554019436,
-0.0007104183,
-0.0138697913,
0.0021358165,
0.0461037345,
-0.0021233512,
0.0281207506,
-0.0371374041,
0.0035583852,
0.0158137381,
-0.0011998815,
0.0382369459,
0.004907174,
0.0105712963,
0.0555313081,
0.0338872857,
-0.0470519252,
-0.0328994356,
0.0377520695,
-0.0258630477,
-0.0320454799,
0.0141178295,
-0.0051811188,
-0.0621203221,
0.034541782,
-0.0609102845,
-0.0469863415,
0.0301139336,
0.021958394,
-0.0390782766,
0.039655678,
-0.0260683391,
-0.0092201959,
-0.0139448727,
0.0617842786,
0.0163451247,
-0.0128293745,
-0.0682637915,
-0.0044583385,
0.0088281389,
-0.0039124982,
-0.0107158404,
0.0045886803,
-0.0357775353,
-0.0477410592,
-0.0632706583,
0.0120600816,
-0.0234904867,
0.0337301232,
-0.0114766387,
0.0286492519,
-0.0402445272,
0.0088889236,
0.011687994,
0.0305905715,
0.0074679344,
0.0170626603,
0.0430051722,
-0.0746661946,
-0.0477954894,
0.0115918079,
-0.0125324409,
-0.0245593544,
-0.0295912065,
0.0252785683,
-0.0189714711,
-0.0467181727,
-0.0157390255,
-0.0604000203,
-0.0630789846,
-0.0179775022,
-0.0283765476,
-0.0547387004,
0.0440574102,
-0.0034642785,
-0.0140231503,
-0.0255169999,
0.0225205738,
0.0370121785,
-0.0340604708,
0.0313743763,
-0.0232491624,
-0.0084385555,
-0.0308627933,
0.0085035972,
0.0051734885,
0.0237703267,
0.0187876616,
0.0253912378,
0.0513919368,
0.0379079096,
-0.0202361774,
0.0121388491,
0.0441059843,
-0.0064705699,
0.0163966287,
-0.0100788353,
-0.0142390039,
-0.0080197649,
0.0286461227,
0.0439351946,
-0.0354317464,
-0.0014692106,
0.0702679157,
-0.0261349846,
0.0307026487,
-0.0418413654,
0.0252611171,
0.0311109964,
-0.043355681,
0.0430397876,
-0.0588788763,
0.0174119193,
-0.044989422,
0.0240409765,
0.0320468396,
0.0339424163,
0.0120627927,
-0.0259040259,
-0.0263964441,
-0.0202548783,
-0.0098134717,
0.0044703558,
0.0046180305,
0.0477321669,
-0.0549972951,
0.036685925,
0.0111448094,
-0.0764002055,
0.0107931821,
-0.0157823432,
0.0598149858,
0.0618593283,
0.1119458675,
0.0342845246,
-0.0256389491,
0.0153321195,
-0.0300607197,
0.0189253855,
0.030056458,
0.0153295528,
0.0077257105,
-0.0544476323,
-0.0475367159,
0.0295993052,
0.0301946495,
-0.0020909535,
0.0322073475,
0.0279434957,
0.0409264043,
-0.0221095961,
-0.0190407541,
0.0293390471,
-0.0189938694,
-0.0173303764,
-0.0000235223,
0.0112025226,
0.0131681822,
0.023453271,
-0.0129200527,
0.0311089791,
0.0411376022,
-0.008068515,
-0.0009079481,
0.0435372703,
-0.0789292231,
-0.0188684836,
-0.0011217634,
0.0051168944,
-0.0023475136,
0.05053927,
-0.0127146877,
-0.0487442426,
0.0054227719,
-0.0525544323,
0.0121018952,
-0.0556598417,
0.0320667475,
0.0256345477,
0.0376914777,
-0.0319143832,
0.0387695692,
-0.0383303426,
0.0037854572,
0.0247132145,
0.0299288817,
0.0267668292,
-0.0349004641,
-0.0288188122,
-0.0150996186,
-0.0186169222,
0.0052355402,
0.0682614297,
0.0079891803,
-0.0136171682,
-0.0184531063,
-0.017969951,
0.0066111679,
-0.0336358696,
0.013354687,
0.0241403375,
0.0126867881,
0.0113970358,
-0.0045185951,
0.0008692151,
0.0331453606,
0.0678978264,
0.0015416371,
0.0034134763,
-0.0023232771,
-0.0212026518,
-0.035973452,
-0.0009727038,
-0.0001911805,
0.0213969946,
0.0256163701,
-0.0240708776,
-0.0871905908,
0.0314570181,
-0.0512992442,
-0.0123279346,
0.0263189226,
-0.0161909778,
0.0019520201,
0.0126575595,
0.0209177546,
0.0166096389,
0.0299298782,
-0.0140691744,
0.0052944836,
-0.0138402553,
-0.0599971265,
-0.0045214281,
-0.0161794685,
-0.0257364567,
0.027885614,
-0.0274533499,
0.0485768802,
0.0239346102,
0.0648470372,
-0.0084869284,
-0.0379961543,
0.0022295511,
-0.00439825,
-0.0385169424,
0.0038716127,
-0.0637302548,
-0.0236158688,
0.0143077364,
-0.0288111139,
-0.0705072582,
0.075586915,
-0.0508351997,
0.0200875383,
-0.0329696871,
0.0107722813,
0.0185612701,
0.0157349482,
-0.004568228,
0.0153123159,
-0.0134580107,
-0.0224076789,
-0.0121925063,
0.0010539413,
0.0518744886,
-0.0484285094,
0.0254554711,
-0.0522018224,
0.0149166742,
-0.0178351793,
-0.0308162514,
-0.0926810801,
-0.0332134478,
0.0212522727,
-0.0231603812,
0.0126438849,
-0.0059654452,
-0.0349656083,
-0.020700708,
0.0336443223,
0.0032151744,
-0.0192190222,
-0.0069205333,
-0.0352281071,
0.0747842044,
0.063928999,
-0.0230840929,
0.0648913309,
-0.0225298963,
-0.0236662906,
0.0720777661,
0.0122975586,
0.0334147848,
-0.0238378253,
-0.0203857459,
0.0251174644,
0.0169489365,
0.0059601152,
0.0270831045,
0.0377207845,
-0.0572737493,
-0.063192986,
0.0820994377,
0.025663862,
-0.0083376225,
-0.0039212625,
-0.0213430654,
0.0573620722,
0.0020301843,
-0.0069577689,
-0.10445375,
-0.0301283319,
0.0245446432,
0.0700208023,
0.0049634292,
-0.0269529279,
-0.0230920129,
-0.1121969372,
0.0307636894,
0.0357735492,
0.0016441015,
-0.0626825541,
-0.0060893004,
0.0071410709,
0.0175213106,
0.0543695129,
0.0700827986,
0.036270339,
0.0200476535,
-0.0062804534,
0.0040726922,
-0.0359352566,
-0.0363439806,
-0.0391239524,
0.0652704686,
0.0996572375,
0.0061428165,
0.0318795145,
-0.0627227724,
-0.0237982105,
-0.0450887717,
-0.0094224028,
-0.0103711691,
-0.0131613323,
-0.033602234,
0.0016940328,
-0.0352857411,
0.0201284215,
-0.000128076,
-0.0213393793,
-0.0089745326,
0.0476385541,
-0.0330682918,
0.0058839717,
-0.0270006284,
0.0165062901,
0.0433976352,
0.0669478551,
0.0234575979,
-0.0060568172,
-0.0049533485,
0.0083212927,
0.0386983901,
-0.0512289442,
0.0333102718,
0.0221056975,
0.0260107815,
0.0303593334,
-0.1147766933,
-0.0360949636,
-0.0443250164,
0.0023588522,
-0.0074334443,
-0.0029480075,
-0.0010316641,
-0.0527352951,
-0.0501354113,
0.0065450659,
-0.0299009774,
0.0300043412,
-0.0085506523,
0.0406652316,
-0.0187985674,
-0.0527864583,
0.0114750583,
0.0827214792,
-0.0583583936,
-0.0445130393,
0.0099475533,
0.0376610011,
0.01831083,
0.047896184,
-0.0292074401,
0.0066382759,
-0.0123871854,
0.0565255992,
-0.0694292337,
0.0569845922,
0.0005215649,
-0.001569152,
-0.0097886221,
0.0274854414,
-0.0448607169,
-0.0070473542,
-0.0111380424,
0.0831071511,
0.0528982691,
-0.0756458938,
0.0406747684,
0.0332697444,
0.0420528539,
-0.031143764,
0.043984741,
-0.0315382332,
0.0056934175,
0.0019134411,
-0.0061271205,
-0.023155164,
0.050977841,
0.0218514204,
-0.0215116404,
-0.001687464,
0.0017949188,
-0.0149779338,
0.0477111153,
-0.0613960102,
-0.0527941473,
-0.0403958596,
0.001758726,
-0.0010130841,
-0.0075603141,
-0.0035033254,
0.0556875095,
-0.0385906361,
0.0467237718,
-0.030295765,
0.0407397151,
0.0185363516,
-0.0340696163,
0.0037121428,
0.0328767784,
-0.0485314541,
0.0032371175,
-0.0322750807,
-0.0341549329,
0.0398985296,
-0.0016275304,
0.1061228514,
-0.0327181518,
0.0169832055,
-0.0174650382,
0.0236243475,
0.0259044543,
-0.0168698393,
-0.0063624415,
0.0107150795,
-0.0293440558,
0.0384387076,
0.0332191214,
-0.0808850676,
0.001257189,
-0.041966334,
-0.0203621108,
-0.0401275232,
-0.053140685,
0.0144520625,
0.0377987549,
-0.0636963621,
-0.0355580598,
-0.0491917282,
-0.0392712913,
0.0465800837,
0.0259813182,
-0.0055615432,
-0.000035775,
0.0281493235,
0.0572646298,
-0.0217099953,
-0.004135645,
-0.0133669078,
-0.0028716046,
-0.0140351532,
-0.000703012,
-0.0322774276,
-6.720425365e-33,
-0.0302552674,
-0.0427294821,
-0.0110331625,
-0.0532062203,
-0.0347056501,
0.0140875373,
-0.0481045209,
-0.0210653171,
0.0033117563,
0.0061083534,
0.0163593311,
0.0258887969,
0.0076010395,
0.0274791662,
0.0114709167,
0.0300340224,
0.0598441437,
0.0363766924,
-0.0499552712,
0.0228215326,
0.0807471126,
0.014781693,
0.0265890323,
-0.0763683692,
0.0402507074,
-0.0223407354,
-0.0177973583,
-0.0096980864,
-0.0449662767,
0.0415051542,
-0.0002876791,
0.0483183078,
-0.0063412958,
-0.0064129317,
-0.0214681346,
0.0027473988,
-0.0808005035,
0.0102625219,
0.0301732197,
-0.0091833035,
-0.0570895113,
0.0006565201,
0.0386536941,
-0.029523937,
-0.0337352082,
0.0285255183,
-0.0146023827,
-0.039504081,
-0.0231793318,
-0.0182810668,
-0.0458168611,
0.0170237757,
0.0219357852,
-0.0368341021,
-0.0306456331,
0.0763405934,
0.0001773573,
0.0144534772,
-0.0844760016,
0.0115858959,
-0.0320048034,
0.0607201979,
0.0661147684,
-0.0211765282,
-0.0322662219,
0.0668279976,
0.0282695834,
-0.0655615106,
0.0354541577,
-0.0088217091,
0.0161470491,
0.0136671448,
0.0477483869,
0.1104812846,
0.0301045272,
-0.0360358432,
-0.0329135358,
0.0273194481,
-0.0046931515,
0.0398825333,
0.0336917304,
-0.0044818767,
-0.0582133457,
-0.0033037593,
-0.0237028562,
0.0040886193,
-0.0461916327,
-0.0223358069,
0.066544041,
0.0670786276,
-0.0360140614,
-0.0028651354,
0.0511398837,
-0.0051835841,
0.0392822325,
0.0560739674,
-0.0517423078,
-0.0550205819,
-0.0304503366,
0.0403476059,
-0.0192607176,
0.0139522552,
0.051168073,
0.0002964156,
-0.0336407013,
0.0102874329,
0.0247722045,
0.0094171371,
-0.0404148996,
0.0397980176,
-0.0358393677,
0.0590472035,
-0.0458151884,
-0.0578829832,
0.0714113936,
0.0032905324,
-0.0174364038,
0.0683510005,
0.019276984,
0.0074573313,
-0.0487911776,
-0.0028439939,
-0.003014497,
0.006559154,
-0.0071474789,
0.020263508,
-0.0107359905,
0.0209349412,
-0.0242648497,
-0.0578710251,
0.011330517,
0.0272931792,
2.965e-7,
-0.0013628013,
0.0241487511,
0.0718939826,
-0.0118307648,
0.0113205286,
-0.0008167186,
0.0041059293,
0.0537334122,
-0.0222284049,
-0.0202489607,
-0.0186631922,
-0.0164737031,
0.0654561296,
0.0078670448,
-0.0156141305,
0.0098814471,
-0.1292412281,
-0.0089999149,
-0.043249771,
-0.0285457037,
0.0615551136,
0.0412989967,
-0.0132498415,
-0.0163713209,
0.0232329946,
-0.0400095284,
0.0516672134,
0.0349215642,
-0.0466763563,
-0.0261585917,
0.0415731892,
-0.0069605419,
0.01063783,
-0.0087432992,
-0.0231881719,
0.0132052721,
-0.0177677441,
0.0167242419,
0.0237074103,
-0.0613058656,
-0.0317647271,
-0.0029181088,
-0.0162142515,
-0.0336632133,
0.0220111385,
-0.0104513653,
0.0253456645,
-0.0178855434,
-0.0525723659,
0.0240125414,
-0.0076326802,
0.002654288,
-0.0394785479,
0.0202361941,
0.0223556869,
0.0876896456,
-0.0423750058,
-0.0407816879,
-0.0436698273,
-0.034362644,
-0.0258895624,
-0.0436060615,
-0.0246927366,
-0.0065472983,
-0.0154412864,
-0.0886026546,
-0.0033705805,
2.974693377e-34,
0.0334459245,
-0.0161249414,
0.0211543161,
-0.0123551516,
0.0277289338,
-0.0073353341,
-0.0480386615,
0.04416354,
0.0176902805,
-0.0307296403,
-0.0299241748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13677v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13677v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models to Measure Gender Bias in Gendered Languages | 2024-06-19T16:30:58 | 2024-06-19T16:30:58 | Erik Derner, Sara Sansalvador de la Fuente, Yoan Gutiérrez, Paloma Moreda, Nuria Oliver | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Gender bias in text corpora used in various natural language processing (NLP)
contexts, such as for training large language models (LLMs), can lead to the
perpetuation and amplification of societal inequalities. This is particularly
pronounced in gendered languages like Spanish or French, where grammatical
structures inherently encode gender, making the bias analysis more challenging.
Existing methods designed for English are inadequate for this task due to the
intrinsic linguistic differences between English and gendered languages. This
paper introduces a novel methodology that leverages the contextual
understanding capabilities of LLMs to quantitatively analyze gender
representation in Spanish corpora. By utilizing LLMs to identify and classify
gendered nouns and pronouns in relation to their reference to human entities,
our approach provides a nuanced analysis of gender biases. We empirically
validate our method on four widely-used benchmark datasets, uncovering
significant gender disparities with a male-to-female ratio ranging from 4:1 to
6:1. These findings demonstrate the value of our methodology for bias
quantification in gendered languages and suggest its application in NLP,
contributing to the development of more equitable language technologies. | [
0.0286547486,
0.1084767804,
-0.0300640464,
0.0460004359,
0.003726233,
0.0277252831,
0.0148723386,
-0.0408086739,
-0.0103861419,
-0.0857202187,
-0.006346738,
-0.0340196341,
0.0262328349,
-0.0290377811,
0.0240022205,
-0.0128407422,
0.0066733593,
0.0340594053,
-0.0101255784,
-0.0359452739,
0.0358696766,
0.0360140204,
0.0187752098,
0.0518833175,
0.0083782403,
-0.0227622185,
0.0559859909,
-0.000714572,
-0.0146619435,
-0.0052489936,
0.0498433039,
0.0590157546,
-0.0160790849,
0.0382855423,
0.0000017486,
-0.0931435302,
0.0018640785,
0.0401280075,
-0.0035167055,
-0.0112452284,
0.0425325818,
-0.0383374318,
-0.0370405428,
0.0119526945,
-0.013943214,
-0.0119283171,
0.030936487,
0.0025340978,
0.0206248667,
0.0037311488,
-0.0067846426,
-0.0128879873,
-0.0529637039,
-0.0215446353,
-0.033766713,
0.0022954396,
0.0374756977,
-0.0344812907,
-0.0443147533,
-0.0222725309,
-0.0251532607,
0.0029900097,
-0.0037540703,
-0.0102191567,
0.0038060723,
0.0085761975,
-0.02771971,
-0.0533907451,
0.0196914468,
0.0247352794,
0.0030712492,
-0.0067447722,
0.01913248,
0.0051844628,
-0.0107065421,
0.0232486147,
-0.0303250533,
0.0311785936,
0.0026244582,
0.0123409284,
0.0268483516,
-0.022442067,
0.0432544127,
0.0704129711,
-0.0303150881,
0.0907733142,
0.01520936,
-0.0359278806,
0.0429424159,
0.0275524538,
0.0244379733,
-0.0349614508,
0.0182497036,
-0.0096297478,
-0.0002709079,
0.0251291469,
0.0231364239,
-0.0258079953,
0.0505619235,
-0.0873007774,
-0.0233998578,
0.0194937009,
0.0061502028,
0.003434598,
0.000886122,
0.0141139897,
0.0162961464,
-0.0087386938,
-0.0173468944,
-0.0589818247,
-0.0358642451,
-0.0139017152,
-0.0076015685,
-0.0189850256,
-0.0186658427,
0.0629195869,
-0.026623467,
-0.0065298672,
-0.0515025668,
-0.0009172992,
0.0291382466,
0.0327803157,
0.005673076,
0.0251124687,
-0.015490042,
0.0103460709,
-0.042484168,
0.0263781957,
-0.053485997,
-0.1069508269,
0.0229454506,
0.0054880264,
-0.025424907,
-0.0517840646,
0.00721994,
0.0200337619,
0.0265736096,
-0.0319621786,
-0.0008411803,
-0.0153349089,
-0.031701576,
-0.0745424777,
-0.0046401666,
-0.0829406306,
0.0064742416,
0.0389281772,
0.0328261741,
-0.0215509254,
0.0125501854,
0.0178526137,
-0.0189599674,
0.0755767003,
0.0495116301,
-0.014216654,
0.0539696291,
0.001157617,
-0.0063281744,
0.1082695872,
0.0572785586,
-0.0342627726,
0.0503495634,
0.0137302894,
-0.0344220474,
0.0549992919,
0.0177568905,
0.0240377802,
-0.0394003019,
0.0258734021,
-0.0396181047,
0.0368714519,
0.0744152963,
-0.0087223528,
0.0498175807,
0.0069850096,
0.0381583422,
0.0773318931,
0.0114032254,
0.0367524363,
0.0402079523,
-0.0183406696,
-0.0043501342,
-0.0094224224,
-0.0592441261,
-0.0409304574,
0.0085865716,
-0.0441485606,
-0.024609061,
0.0385800265,
-0.0083638029,
-0.0382601619,
-0.0253189839,
0.0268817078,
0.0110020088,
-0.0003850551,
0.0359040201,
0.0208935905,
0.0386024714,
0.0606316179,
0.0451860726,
-0.0574036203,
0.0327601805,
-0.0294920504,
0.0125834728,
0.0274623577,
-0.0114979884,
-0.0420350134,
0.0116274012,
-0.0319098122,
-0.0098689105,
0.024223147,
0.0169815421,
-0.0029567501,
0.0140270032,
-0.0208410099,
-0.0114296004,
0.0567991585,
0.0528069176,
0.0194342192,
0.0408181064,
0.0379222259,
0.013597412,
-0.0605414324,
-0.0589585491,
0.03666633,
-0.0064164191,
-0.0378388241,
0.0412327461,
0.0079259807,
0.0146603361,
0.0298391171,
-0.0349408239,
-0.0212730821,
0.0148242246,
-0.0210372657,
0.0009231007,
0.0296090003,
-0.0182064921,
-0.0068694185,
0.0024066044,
-0.068305321,
-0.0730628073,
0.0270961132,
-0.0195728131,
0.005376494,
0.0503631197,
-0.0236137602,
0.0046770847,
-0.0444961488,
0.008795917,
-0.0111406893,
0.0413689911,
-0.0350381434,
0.0301984791,
-0.0302554667,
0.0131717594,
-0.0128629422,
-0.0227876771,
0.0020486454,
-0.0582611561,
-0.0360466987,
0.028486196,
0.0087246802,
0.0069196783,
0.0410675332,
-0.0079270462,
-0.0191727746,
-0.0266321264,
-0.058545243,
0.0070204353,
-0.014949806,
0.0102954814,
-0.0021186529,
0.0112826908,
-0.0298086982,
-0.0002227122,
0.0013239174,
-0.0450481959,
0.0177893545,
0.0200247299,
0.0528715104,
-0.0184608363,
0.0089403857,
-0.0405502282,
-0.005767927,
-0.0505759306,
0.071126014,
0.0437090434,
-0.0173547361,
-0.0343911387,
-0.0113407765,
0.0057825129,
-0.0018566435,
0.0119114751,
-0.0155537846,
0.0023048758,
0.0432280563,
0.0288075414,
0.0818454549,
0.0118650682,
0.0576232485,
0.055327788,
-0.0052918517,
-0.0385692008,
-0.0316823572,
0.0238407236,
0.0148315588,
-0.0277025383,
-0.0832086727,
0.0042939303,
0.0420517959,
-0.0070302305,
-0.0431824066,
-0.0081949197,
0.0567012243,
-0.0544805266,
-0.0300652571,
-0.0138386078,
0.0079325018,
-0.0174024496,
0.0148727782,
-0.0320484973,
-0.0359439179,
-0.0034385105,
-0.0273981299,
0.0068532135,
-0.0316040479,
-0.0214056745,
-0.0757367015,
0.030922208,
-0.0028342926,
0.0297142882,
0.0297634751,
-0.0298691876,
-0.0489257276,
-0.0321757272,
0.0170177761,
-0.013119569,
0.0404044315,
-0.0562815629,
0.0252798684,
0.0164115634,
-0.0403673612,
-0.0470277853,
0.0000685929,
-0.0273895096,
0.0195830464,
0.0072481679,
-0.0132524706,
0.003959314,
0.002795598,
-0.0255532824,
-0.0099057797,
-0.0000252194,
-0.0201604161,
-0.0170585699,
0.0090073403,
-0.0001102546,
0.0025019899,
0.0406877138,
-0.0225758981,
-0.0208180528,
0.016367346,
0.0115423007,
0.0472076125,
-0.008093779,
0.0180310719,
0.0467162468,
-0.0608498417,
-0.0053794654,
-0.048844099,
0.0121074691,
-0.0596126504,
0.0014383141,
0.1104800552,
0.0292545222,
-0.0679536611,
0.0246079322,
-0.0009206932,
0.010874629,
0.0539402924,
0.0033259729,
-0.0613431819,
0.0063871895,
0.0363455415,
-0.0183596388,
-0.0408890583,
-0.0513154604,
-0.0294365529,
-0.135836333,
-0.0076377573,
-0.0159406755,
-0.0373093076,
-0.0181443468,
-0.0418341048,
0.0233116355,
-0.0653760433,
0.0286524948,
-0.0278597157,
-0.009640119,
0.0112425936,
0.0125471447,
-0.0502763391,
-0.0517632179,
0.0246552378,
-0.08146213,
0.0299652945,
0.0149502251,
0.0787937641,
-0.0377354585,
0.0431039035,
0.037632972,
-0.03543083,
-0.0081286272,
-0.027355453,
-0.0065298043,
-0.0362701304,
-0.0192581806,
-0.0370418131,
0.0350074209,
0.0266141482,
0.0131691461,
0.0019908077,
0.0302099157,
0.0309422035,
0.0058197924,
-0.0388008617,
-0.0369582996,
0.0082368813,
0.0764642581,
0.0268266425,
-0.0398588255,
-0.0228750631,
-0.0586875752,
-0.0113269743,
0.0429430418,
-0.0565879084,
0.0002694664,
0.0085088024,
-0.0277103242,
-0.0112557672,
-0.0559429862,
0.0142014762,
-0.0290682577,
0.0207112003,
-0.0360097662,
0.0328322761,
-0.0094165532,
-0.0643587708,
0.0386196598,
-0.0082804924,
0.0273162369,
0.0149074774,
-0.0280752201,
-0.0194050968,
0.0041004042,
-0.0380384885,
0.0240882598,
-0.0514689535,
-0.0540105067,
0.0277918801,
0.0072785951,
0.0193103757,
0.0484636277,
-0.0152952336,
-0.0703644305,
0.0510642342,
0.0531348251,
-0.0455378667,
0.0248063691,
0.0303397849,
0.0248052552,
0.0169325713,
0.0450776666,
-0.023415748,
0.0051317797,
-0.0198144596,
0.0233617388,
-0.0404524654,
-0.032202296,
-0.0025106813,
-0.0017886617,
0.0137130218,
-0.057185147,
0.0124822184,
-0.0630578622,
-0.0316420346,
-0.007416409,
-0.0369270369,
0.0106287189,
-0.0286613237,
0.0278887302,
0.0314616077,
-0.04348756,
-0.0098064179,
-0.0385897718,
0.0154446075,
-0.0081699649,
0.0355264582,
0.0326402113,
0.0231949408,
-0.0120737171,
0.0185017847,
0.0506528169,
-0.0158994868,
-0.0254464261,
0.0279064197,
0.0132459849,
-0.0266570598,
-0.0009523474,
0.0277682357,
-0.022456836,
0.0018156589,
-0.0170086343,
-0.0004583696,
0.0055782748,
0.0080316151,
0.0387964584,
-0.0647266433,
0.0449095741,
0.0078120446,
-0.0195378456,
-0.0035208517,
-0.0102442019,
0.0051291604,
0.0104611907,
0.0218011774,
0.0026714855,
-0.0090262033,
-0.0164853949,
0.0324316025,
0.0748855919,
0.0487204194,
0.003596745,
-0.0263831504,
-0.0129110264,
-0.0131786568,
0.0089138001,
-0.0632014126,
-0.0295351092,
-0.0081269257,
-0.0991074145,
-0.0585171767,
0.0052533327,
-0.0544792525,
0.0099458555,
-0.0091610905,
-0.0062689953,
0.0657191873,
-0.0337991975,
-0.0326272547,
-0.0493776314,
-0.0141661912,
-0.0111750141,
-0.0251912363,
-0.0080194436,
-5.53590983e-33,
-0.0308694541,
-0.0708304644,
-0.024578413,
-0.0302235782,
0.0051669637,
0.0179866198,
-0.0137187997,
-0.0198126622,
0.0161453411,
0.0299941078,
0.0020040781,
0.0393437631,
0.0189125128,
0.0117225079,
0.0174897723,
0.017814137,
0.047743924,
0.0265361145,
-0.0123198088,
-0.0566572994,
-0.0175102726,
0.0523248129,
0.0581128336,
-0.0792653561,
0.127418384,
0.0131641515,
-0.0239234418,
0.0358542129,
-0.0019631204,
0.0376422219,
-0.0185571071,
0.0870450959,
0.0126271592,
-0.0443060994,
0.043411117,
0.0839926228,
-0.0623335317,
-0.0417848304,
0.0390446484,
0.0597519986,
0.0729384422,
-0.0187798478,
0.0280598328,
0.0210754462,
-0.0510547757,
-0.0129874805,
0.0746639445,
0.0102246292,
0.0752711296,
0.0263774414,
-0.05707426,
0.0343840942,
-0.0357331932,
0.0296719652,
0.0423995219,
-0.003100818,
-0.0194582138,
0.0104814339,
-0.0596847907,
0.010419948,
-0.003254619,
0.0028612458,
0.0191614777,
0.0130740115,
0.0439377651,
0.0601227656,
0.0663948804,
0.003356006,
-0.0286864173,
-0.0327689461,
0.0501314662,
-0.0297003444,
0.009858002,
0.0727896541,
0.0376680717,
0.0295171533,
-0.0909639895,
-0.0467205457,
0.0197676141,
0.0268760249,
0.0148939649,
-0.0392270349,
-0.0586250126,
-0.0403726175,
-0.0524841994,
-0.0920037255,
-0.0013533768,
0.006597992,
0.0135231623,
-0.0145957377,
-0.0553911254,
0.0253111888,
-0.0294640493,
-0.0678682253,
-0.0789757147,
0.0136213759,
0.0134178493,
-0.0492444076,
0.0623124205,
0.0378321931,
-0.0646042973,
0.0075945416,
-0.0136132408,
0.0322148651,
0.0438266061,
-0.0014171705,
0.0095121525,
-0.0030516691,
-0.0557330586,
-0.019340286,
-0.0477558672,
0.0031475159,
-0.0294847861,
0.0711308494,
0.0306640007,
0.0395536609,
-0.0098921144,
0.0220833644,
0.0608292706,
0.0395813473,
-0.0117928628,
0.0029840702,
-0.0352894925,
0.03980783,
-0.0084159821,
-0.0282733664,
0.011872055,
0.0146858562,
0.0705620423,
-0.031327229,
0.0035920721,
-0.0658081621,
2.347e-7,
0.0397360176,
0.0724339113,
-0.0031506175,
0.0330240205,
0.0232553706,
0.0223274361,
0.0153595721,
0.0477063395,
0.0216828324,
-0.0157103315,
-0.0506807454,
0.0435983725,
0.0051768492,
0.0451976471,
-0.0694269389,
0.0091703003,
-0.0421805717,
0.0198376458,
-0.0014982932,
0.0151228048,
-0.0350657217,
0.0809386969,
0.0444808267,
-0.007710245,
-0.0402703248,
-0.0297170337,
0.0407746099,
-0.0251674,
-0.0012405382,
0.0250206478,
-0.0038482347,
0.017699305,
0.0297326148,
0.0178056471,
0.0214098822,
0.0132326111,
0.0087776417,
0.0011317475,
-0.0221419204,
0.0388725214,
-0.0063329623,
-0.0500502102,
-0.0291353744,
-0.0626722425,
0.0562882386,
0.0090442076,
-0.0328072719,
-0.0518888384,
0.008668256,
-0.0126432246,
0.0687449649,
-0.0294384938,
-0.023891164,
0.0222133379,
0.0248451494,
-0.0083092237,
-0.0018653573,
-0.0478373617,
-0.037488997,
-0.0118907299,
-0.0129506039,
-0.0391408876,
0.0164924692,
0.0418947488,
0.0040352689,
-0.0477385297,
0.0558274202,
1.787304263e-34,
-0.0062358868,
0.0483335443,
-0.0068350071,
0.0147052472,
0.0439337566,
0.0034695703,
0.0143719418,
0.0019996702,
0.0382936187,
0.0171248205,
0.0312817879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13663v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13663v2 | Model Internals-based Answer Attribution for Trustworthy Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T16:10:26 | 2024-07-01T12:39:26 | Jirui Qi, Gabriele Sarti, Raquel Fernández, Arianna Bisazza | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Ensuring the verifiability of model answers is a fundamental challenge for
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) in the question answering (QA) domain.
Recently, self-citation prompting was proposed to make large language models
(LLMs) generate citations to supporting documents along with their answers.
However, self-citing LLMs often struggle to match the required format, refer to
non-existent sources, and fail to faithfully reflect LLMs' context usage
throughout the generation. In this work, we present MIRAGE --Model
Internals-based RAG Explanations -- a plug-and-play approach using model
internals for faithful answer attribution in RAG applications. MIRAGE detects
context-sensitive answer tokens and pairs them with retrieved documents
contributing to their prediction via saliency methods. We evaluate our proposed
approach on a multilingual extractive QA dataset, finding high agreement with
human answer attribution. On open-ended QA, MIRAGE achieves citation quality
and efficiency comparable to self-citation while also allowing for a
finer-grained control of attribution parameters. Our qualitative evaluation
highlights the faithfulness of MIRAGE's attributions and underscores the
promising application of model internals for RAG answer attribution. | [
0.0663588569,
0.0087585747,
0.0064260387,
0.0399949662,
0.0009707068,
-0.0302148983,
0.0149347484,
-0.0137387225,
0.0164688136,
-0.0397359952,
-0.0014449556,
0.0432890318,
-0.0435809232,
-0.0284064095,
0.0569934547,
0.0167860873,
0.0460475832,
-0.0259122457,
-0.0033523226,
-0.014954811,
-0.0008780724,
0.0287618246,
0.0334035829,
0.028556291,
-0.004978986,
-0.0261589531,
0.0094102537,
0.0065483563,
0.0280235987,
0.0058071818,
0.0214648619,
0.0578594878,
-0.0112755494,
0.0383803472,
0.000002065,
-0.0480473079,
-0.0093185082,
0.0149378115,
-0.0532464348,
0.0352091789,
0.0016674891,
0.0580068566,
0.0273339599,
0.0101397736,
-0.0304085836,
0.0596919507,
0.0252337921,
0.03078085,
0.0869958028,
0.0146686481,
0.0006763663,
-0.0142144831,
0.0038186517,
-0.0044442639,
0.0341348201,
-0.0247868914,
-0.001911959,
0.0309019722,
0.0035318211,
0.0495021455,
0.0305586308,
0.071461685,
0.0210259855,
-0.0378026627,
0.0726526901,
0.0040951222,
-0.0149763385,
0.0233311262,
0.005869668,
0.0475838706,
0.035604693,
-0.0479159914,
0.0123330494,
0.0174966138,
0.0117887286,
0.0771616399,
-0.0372468382,
0.0029705248,
0.0009201228,
-0.0244710762,
0.0202472527,
0.0046691606,
0.0105178431,
0.0369492397,
0.0298594832,
0.0479278527,
0.0312120151,
-0.0123919891,
-0.0383195095,
0.0178778972,
-0.0069982316,
-0.0888752267,
-0.0061636288,
0.0700348541,
0.0035006097,
0.0122389309,
-0.0079057878,
-0.0276998896,
0.0630300492,
-0.0031751445,
0.001133642,
0.0011231845,
-0.0268669482,
0.0418196693,
-0.050101269,
0.0481909402,
-0.0558988079,
0.0263717193,
-0.0343627445,
-0.0407235809,
-0.0274381377,
-0.0269052908,
-0.0382028334,
0.0391562134,
-0.0553375669,
0.0031186512,
-0.0473330654,
0.0229720771,
-0.0241724476,
-0.0219981857,
0.0033368932,
0.0410274155,
-0.0406678282,
-0.000348834,
-0.0448714085,
-0.0000819564,
-0.0573285818,
0.0184058622,
0.0283136051,
-0.0782288313,
-0.0254642237,
0.0260680709,
0.012696702,
-0.0313649625,
0.0019697289,
0.0515982434,
-0.0033207727,
0.00807977,
-0.037531551,
-0.0849470049,
-0.0155907134,
-0.0285890643,
-0.0281075425,
-0.0790022314,
0.0178486835,
0.0334203206,
-0.0346602164,
-0.0255581364,
0.0124942577,
0.0534426905,
-0.0151355965,
0.0258916039,
-0.0459554419,
-0.0004186157,
0.0274036918,
0.0068500121,
0.0368454009,
-0.0048433547,
0.0077274661,
0.0302226469,
0.0548683107,
0.011823942,
0.0513673387,
-0.0155177331,
0.0586281605,
0.0303273834,
-0.0030452341,
0.068096295,
-0.0007722867,
-0.0318474099,
0.0316022448,
0.0536953807,
-0.0229994338,
-0.0371295288,
0.04065888,
0.0264622718,
-0.0118338978,
0.0393147618,
0.0217301901,
-0.0152892591,
0.0088108797,
0.003364105,
-0.0290835667,
0.072667554,
-0.0352613963,
0.0027078334,
0.0385879166,
0.0213915911,
-0.0348541848,
-0.0193757806,
-0.0090830326,
0.0028341161,
-0.0253411345,
0.059415251,
0.0049626729,
0.0166139528,
-0.0093957214,
0.0580414385,
-0.0254468154,
-0.063352637,
0.0101677654,
-0.0510240309,
0.0779328793,
0.0230327826,
0.04225903,
-0.0060772197,
0.0102458866,
-0.033002194,
0.0005814839,
0.0298642442,
-0.0039002334,
-0.0236467291,
-0.0083850157,
-0.0389084853,
-0.0241653454,
-0.0224637669,
-0.018446926,
0.0126601011,
0.0304148309,
0.0098202694,
0.0411703102,
-0.0535808876,
-0.0313134231,
0.025506461,
-0.0300704595,
-0.0455567017,
0.0210123602,
-0.0019206126,
0.0148294894,
0.0560791641,
0.0018532133,
0.0394240618,
0.0247578956,
-0.0104923723,
-0.000351647,
0.0134482225,
-0.0121550653,
0.0154227782,
0.0240566805,
-0.0024867626,
-0.0045939791,
0.0121251009,
-0.0099060982,
-0.0433225371,
0.00412816,
-0.0482955351,
-0.0162155572,
-0.0883632824,
-0.0286616385,
0.018241981,
0.0282096807,
-0.034138076,
0.056114126,
0.0121893287,
0.0357206538,
0.0363304578,
0.0136588588,
0.0506040342,
-0.0536425821,
0.0249210224,
-0.0262464527,
-0.0206655245,
0.024485372,
0.0597777963,
-0.0236814339,
-0.0622993782,
-0.0024789996,
-0.045464702,
-0.0069781677,
-0.0172676854,
0.0107608456,
0.0236636307,
0.0160887837,
0.0145523092,
-0.0352372527,
-0.070846729,
-0.0550796017,
0.0314881019,
0.010294294,
0.0372995324,
0.01171136,
0.0333880782,
-0.0574358813,
-0.0117694838,
-0.009027658,
0.0166182872,
0.0656156242,
0.0421704166,
-0.1054928079,
-0.0432887785,
-0.0600282699,
0.0026126166,
0.01221547,
-0.0218545478,
-0.0090105673,
0.0084595736,
0.0270867292,
0.0604980886,
0.0332735479,
-0.0244818274,
0.0189855285,
0.0118267871,
-0.081945084,
-0.0037972559,
-0.0200892873,
-0.043168731,
0.0065217246,
-0.0380665734,
0.0325328596,
0.0505552329,
0.0057760538,
-0.0298966803,
-0.0182745513,
0.0443703346,
0.0240937341,
-0.0227603726,
-0.0343521796,
-0.0315018557,
-0.0005121247,
0.0572567806,
-0.0089842305,
-0.0306848101,
0.0865920484,
-0.0503281578,
-0.0100681456,
-0.0227286126,
-0.0027373501,
-0.0422265455,
0.0083132768,
-0.0417099409,
0.0097022783,
0.0338617414,
0.0158514995,
-0.023154607,
-0.0252998415,
0.0561903939,
-0.0431582034,
0.0301889759,
0.0028093574,
0.0345576108,
0.0068971799,
-0.0128348805,
-0.0619848892,
-0.0741367266,
-0.012614592,
0.0260529201,
-0.0374109112,
-0.013438357,
0.0090353573,
-0.0178360902,
0.0858050436,
-0.0209822897,
-0.0380084999,
-0.0160822887,
-0.0178439673,
0.0646860078,
0.0780297816,
0.0005864683,
0.0621322468,
-0.0288187098,
-0.0159253199,
0.046479892,
0.041886244,
-0.0234592482,
0.0120245423,
-0.0464348234,
0.0310344975,
-0.030571511,
0.0060620732,
-0.0005112119,
0.0796951205,
-0.0524138026,
-0.0262977257,
0.0707942322,
0.0272675101,
-0.0327293426,
-0.031327039,
-0.0621750616,
0.018980043,
0.0277028084,
0.0560708866,
-0.0850818157,
-0.018179426,
-0.026792651,
0.051399447,
-0.0009611284,
-0.0119833723,
0.021017408,
-0.1066577807,
0.0502167754,
-0.0130832931,
-0.0027716577,
-0.0124294581,
-0.0601282492,
0.0061097117,
0.0078790076,
-0.0287071988,
0.0133840824,
-0.0109858159,
0.0124577535,
0.0181143526,
0.0517682321,
0.0135874981,
0.0366473049,
-0.0448664725,
0.0072882921,
0.0682314187,
0.0357817933,
0.0167018753,
-0.0693323016,
-0.0151920002,
-0.0756324232,
-0.0012951383,
-0.0097737731,
0.0233214647,
-0.0032438769,
0.0091935107,
-0.0232591387,
0.0495442115,
-0.0211028699,
0.0020364895,
0.0201634653,
0.0565137044,
0.0047440883,
0.0260459688,
-0.0511598811,
-0.0075770132,
0.0275641736,
0.0712129399,
0.0318811201,
0.0096986219,
-0.02062352,
-0.0123370504,
0.009290983,
-0.0195599385,
-0.0421480611,
0.0277184732,
-0.0144543871,
-0.0015056204,
-0.0853380188,
-0.0529457554,
-0.0322127938,
0.0020500126,
-0.002122449,
0.0105913039,
-0.0348825306,
-0.0049545113,
-0.0526649021,
0.0301923174,
-0.0837800801,
0.0314335041,
-0.0155676417,
0.018673934,
0.0022663712,
-0.0478535108,
0.0120399846,
0.023210533,
-0.007106401,
-0.0258655734,
-0.0140632186,
0.0686642528,
0.0215381887,
0.044206243,
-0.0330692008,
-0.0411580093,
0.048243165,
0.0062650023,
-0.0607313514,
-0.013695484,
0.0118793668,
-0.0272216834,
-0.0113767469,
0.0301691033,
-0.0687749684,
0.0254337732,
-0.0221227054,
0.0134305013,
0.011942693,
-0.0513473488,
0.0115460381,
0.0316340029,
0.0146943806,
0.0186401773,
0.0166352373,
0.0021034828,
0.014939216,
-0.0456902757,
-0.0118357679,
-0.0180452801,
0.0444595776,
-0.0292390548,
-0.0394514389,
0.0389289781,
-0.0248634741,
-0.0349445902,
0.0443122014,
-0.0309513547,
0.0057589607,
0.0020970604,
0.0380337089,
-0.0069168168,
-0.0081517622,
-0.0286133438,
-0.0330968983,
0.0135304593,
0.0808240101,
-0.0023206263,
0.0552240722,
0.0120296814,
-0.0188752115,
0.021882331,
0.0073917597,
-0.1107857078,
-0.0075188084,
-0.0332889035,
-0.0447623022,
0.0109455595,
-0.0215775799,
0.0474519134,
-0.0017896044,
-0.0201105718,
-0.012875475,
0.0296674874,
0.0280689746,
-0.0132649178,
0.0137350429,
0.0226891432,
-0.0402079336,
0.0142033454,
0.0478943326,
0.0059474725,
0.0007418387,
-0.0417284667,
-0.0462037735,
-0.021809781,
-0.0234058276,
-0.0624400862,
0.0121652046,
-0.017544223,
0.0003489458,
-0.0531541072,
-0.0816628039,
0.0077317087,
0.0169861019,
-0.0210136864,
-0.0078810751,
0.0118313888,
0.0649588406,
0.025425883,
-0.0395401679,
-0.0774128214,
0.0749920085,
-0.0733721405,
-0.0259428211,
-0.0059293658,
-6.671192723e-33,
-0.0244131312,
-0.0671372265,
0.0093227746,
-0.0346433111,
0.0100726727,
0.0108937519,
-0.0540238991,
-0.0281329788,
-0.0496657528,
0.009354258,
-0.0229764059,
0.0131059345,
0.0035512387,
0.0164321754,
0.0300327558,
-0.0005042161,
0.040931493,
0.0107988622,
-0.0473962985,
0.0375290923,
0.0564093739,
-0.0237559211,
0.0476249643,
-0.08510793,
0.0701374784,
-0.0535182096,
-0.0051014782,
0.0346464962,
-0.01945691,
0.0906018168,
-0.0011154535,
0.0270396266,
0.0131259952,
-0.0447419547,
0.0222321674,
0.0122584961,
-0.1059294865,
-0.016013924,
0.0133521147,
-0.0557074249,
-0.0644542575,
-0.057332553,
0.0220139641,
-0.0242289752,
0.01633019,
-0.0170616154,
0.0475325584,
-0.0192511529,
-0.001580943,
-0.0414101481,
-0.0166365691,
0.0195895787,
0.0101923654,
-0.0079540191,
0.0017016105,
0.0841958001,
0.0176615566,
0.0342085175,
-0.0339785479,
0.001950759,
-0.0138479518,
0.0288550593,
0.0611977465,
0.0001623732,
0.0050175474,
0.0240585059,
0.0114414329,
-0.0305118263,
-0.0261413157,
-0.0473279506,
-0.0357327648,
0.0485056639,
0.0985929295,
0.104496561,
0.0083734896,
0.027724823,
-0.0634622052,
0.0426740348,
0.0143949073,
0.0440853983,
0.0188602768,
-0.0307122562,
-0.0351963416,
0.0209191702,
-0.0395365916,
-0.0076029468,
-0.0585694127,
-0.0494236723,
0.0314197242,
0.0247945972,
-0.050102476,
0.0423194245,
0.0302137863,
-0.0316328667,
-0.0228194855,
0.0467470177,
-0.0012895286,
-0.0185071044,
0.0084664617,
0.0036138056,
-0.0245373789,
0.0492209084,
0.0028452778,
-0.008424676,
0.0032036148,
0.0469775535,
0.0094652725,
-0.0099620856,
-0.0418756977,
0.0074579976,
-0.0392629392,
0.0216941573,
-0.0508953258,
-0.0695783496,
0.0205176603,
0.0318915695,
-0.0150252022,
0.0465291254,
0.014477903,
0.0320968404,
-0.0256933831,
-0.008213155,
0.0162510686,
0.0334085301,
-0.0099992752,
0.0011643699,
-0.0170651898,
0.0348958932,
-0.0049799504,
-0.0115122395,
-0.0124763325,
-0.0064263842,
2.744e-7,
0.017903449,
-0.0034183217,
0.041414272,
-0.0208996758,
0.0077360426,
0.0396345817,
0.0470901616,
0.0088773826,
0.0377497338,
-0.0112582268,
-0.0271034688,
0.0051827319,
0.050984215,
0.0379297882,
-0.059052784,
0.0031160084,
-0.0753563493,
0.0072724433,
-0.0026212987,
-0.0265705399,
0.0014826541,
0.0427718274,
0.0063867765,
-0.0075013833,
-0.0559282564,
-0.0304127708,
0.0460537672,
0.015717851,
-0.0226974152,
0.0359521918,
0.0928054973,
-0.0064600641,
0.0321387351,
-0.0107384659,
-0.0220933296,
0.0168304928,
0.0029666326,
0.0309122913,
-0.0030047628,
-0.0742621943,
-0.0437683873,
-0.0590009913,
0.0625302568,
-0.0958341435,
0.019704625,
-0.0082335342,
0.0130643994,
-0.0426772125,
-0.0622956268,
-0.0208320171,
-0.0082750348,
-0.0068447599,
-0.0306908209,
0.0320938826,
-0.0222490896,
0.0241665021,
0.0078811198,
-0.0357671976,
-0.051958587,
-0.0041158241,
-0.0150809251,
0.0071979151,
-0.0134204114,
-0.036244832,
-0.0102014253,
-0.055815924,
0.0282637551,
2.374769963e-34,
0.0046928143,
0.0154153006,
0.0115563525,
0.0451319516,
0.0610546619,
0.0000674197,
-0.0175868496,
0.0210218672,
0.0610989816,
-0.0429247953,
-0.036718905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13662v1 | ObscurePrompt: Jailbreaking Large Language Models via Obscure Input | 2024-06-19T16:09:58 | 2024-06-19T16:09:58 | Yue Huang, Jingyu Tang, Dongping Chen, Bingda Tang, Yao Wan, Lichao Sun, Xiangliang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention
for their exceptional natural language processing capabilities. However,
concerns about their trustworthiness remain unresolved, particularly in
addressing "jailbreaking" attacks on aligned LLMs. Previous research
predominantly relies on scenarios with white-box LLMs or specific and fixed
prompt templates, which are often impractical and lack broad applicability. In
this paper, we introduce a straightforward and novel method, named
ObscurePrompt, for jailbreaking LLMs, inspired by the observed fragile
alignments in Out-of-Distribution (OOD) data. Specifically, we first formulate
the decision boundary in the jailbreaking process and then explore how obscure
text affects LLM's ethical decision boundary. ObscurePrompt starts with
constructing a base prompt that integrates well-known jailbreaking techniques.
Powerful LLMs are then utilized to obscure the original prompt through
iterative transformations, aiming to bolster the attack's robustness.
Comprehensive experiments show that our approach substantially improves upon
previous methods in terms of attack effectiveness, maintaining efficacy against
two prevalent defense mechanisms. We believe that our work can offer fresh
insights for future research on enhancing LLM alignment. | [
0.0560063347,
0.1042514145,
-0.0215979349,
0.0592703596,
-0.0731363297,
-0.0073218988,
0.0020966351,
-0.0062371991,
0.0062393742,
-0.0314367823,
-0.0308216158,
-0.03550658,
0.027738886,
0.0255765785,
0.0172061715,
0.0247793011,
0.0549971834,
-0.0179177672,
0.0005101886,
-0.000118405,
-0.0016205716,
0.003197317,
0.0449363664,
0.0119083142,
0.0254181307,
-0.018775044,
-0.0164010096,
0.0258999486,
0.0200338438,
-0.0087648313,
-0.0180392954,
0.0342167467,
-0.0197430011,
0.1154000312,
0.0000021008,
-0.0512099713,
-0.0703850165,
0.027339112,
-0.03651122,
0.0405576974,
0.0188601427,
-0.0532704554,
-0.0484016836,
-0.0056842621,
-0.0505889989,
0.0243003592,
0.0539306775,
0.0278300326,
0.0765132532,
0.1083394364,
0.0025160394,
0.0287823118,
0.0308945049,
-0.0361278839,
-0.0020432991,
-0.0481116325,
0.037255343,
-0.0662786514,
-0.0117751248,
0.0398744904,
0.0089310855,
0.0215770882,
-0.0027204759,
0.0029291781,
-0.0703146756,
-0.0186172966,
-0.0401195884,
-0.0353676938,
-0.0131543577,
0.0520325825,
-0.0322274379,
-0.0112919509,
0.0074559203,
-0.007986391,
0.033569254,
0.0313706547,
0.004012106,
0.039040979,
0.0051891357,
0.018501373,
0.0442678779,
-0.0016256586,
0.0598054864,
-0.0042772703,
-0.0146700609,
0.0751551166,
0.0125492001,
-0.0508414358,
-0.0110374503,
-0.042159386,
-0.0476473644,
-0.0691580549,
-0.01167884,
-0.0150547875,
-0.007140595,
0.038732592,
-0.0929183662,
0.0022560004,
0.0356338844,
-0.0270243511,
0.0108644869,
0.0401975736,
-0.0082191695,
0.0282709189,
0.0138590019,
0.0313547254,
-0.0523346961,
0.0197144859,
-0.0158181824,
0.0317394696,
0.025732765,
-0.0299123377,
0.0090918923,
0.0129763652,
-0.0525742993,
-0.0180556607,
-0.0044131004,
0.0237219501,
-0.031277515,
0.0460574813,
-0.0503419973,
0.0057817353,
-0.0022742164,
-0.0090216491,
0.0159349088,
-0.0099554192,
0.009772785,
0.0006946334,
0.0001367881,
-0.0647229254,
-0.0264723394,
0.0083443215,
-0.0572044589,
-0.0289175864,
-0.0100536877,
0.090500243,
0.0173308812,
-0.020034885,
-0.032919541,
-0.0519761518,
-0.0334147215,
-0.0444167703,
-0.0061561549,
-0.0703479275,
0.0071623428,
-0.0091093164,
-0.0160238817,
-0.0858500972,
0.025586471,
0.031174846,
-0.0483431816,
0.0824431777,
-0.0105854124,
-0.0183119178,
-0.028470343,
0.0194583051,
-0.0010481247,
0.0619100519,
0.007018127,
0.0439296626,
0.0707838312,
-0.0079249302,
0.0215980243,
0.0689862221,
0.0028543987,
0.0302934069,
-0.0320432447,
0.004194587,
0.0424740277,
0.012257807,
0.0052260444,
0.0403704755,
0.0214460324,
-0.0411955304,
0.0746059716,
0.0566628836,
-0.0473538935,
0.0292692445,
-0.0196445193,
0.0013761896,
-0.0257041473,
0.0367431715,
-0.0953639895,
-0.0254201833,
-0.0826896876,
-0.0014320338,
-0.0217895452,
0.0462688953,
0.0227747168,
0.0003172888,
-0.0170458313,
-0.0040563573,
0.0011066238,
0.0237779263,
-0.0061913477,
-0.0019580172,
-0.0236806385,
0.0570086874,
0.0439109132,
-0.0218008067,
-0.0255424064,
-0.0452419147,
0.0023670206,
0.0306913778,
0.0605653599,
-0.0152741261,
0.0235566963,
-0.0164884385,
-0.0084369611,
0.0407126844,
0.001470515,
0.0165296141,
0.002162237,
-0.0206452869,
-0.0102719637,
-0.0120423101,
0.0380034558,
0.0310294759,
0.0143547319,
-0.0124639831,
0.0108219618,
-0.0313776322,
0.001636002,
0.0183666088,
0.0000149127,
-0.0403979011,
0.0002633908,
0.0159571469,
0.0345452502,
0.0156680178,
-0.0220686849,
0.0291154571,
0.0543719232,
0.0022952494,
0.020814497,
-0.0261531565,
-0.0316829942,
-0.0280887038,
0.0318602622,
-0.0361504816,
-0.0191653352,
0.0498683713,
-0.0322958007,
-0.0239800196,
0.0099277254,
-0.0282015447,
0.0510495007,
-0.0023589127,
0.0663351566,
-0.0105325067,
0.0238466971,
-0.0510708094,
0.0486136302,
-0.035341762,
0.0353159793,
-0.0049624206,
-0.0092958678,
0.0024764121,
-0.0228585433,
-0.0250029713,
0.0125160506,
-0.0238157362,
-0.0016153621,
0.0061925496,
0.010906185,
-0.0009444021,
-0.0712562948,
-0.0301128179,
0.0148888566,
-0.0051453384,
0.0272688754,
0.0299209058,
0.0280059818,
-0.0318919905,
-0.0107345348,
-0.0260665603,
-0.0426858664,
0.0132970968,
0.0104864892,
0.008880794,
-0.0085333372,
-0.053513892,
-0.0093251579,
-0.0110795144,
-0.0187256318,
0.0543152802,
-0.0263783652,
-0.0267158244,
-0.0702365413,
-0.0076262476,
-0.0184178893,
0.0244145039,
-0.0153967207,
-0.0043223635,
0.0040907348,
0.0234776512,
-0.0044919411,
0.0523939729,
0.0004054789,
0.0204363856,
0.0668989494,
0.0081998128,
-0.035722319,
-0.0314953066,
0.0161393434,
-0.0231718775,
-0.0273806062,
-0.0574071407,
0.019913448,
0.0365520716,
0.0332121775,
-0.0013949003,
-0.0200807657,
0.0401768237,
0.0085108168,
-0.028033955,
0.0109759476,
-0.0287413038,
-0.0470862128,
0.0112618627,
-0.028616257,
-0.0788738355,
0.076344803,
-0.0704571903,
0.0414031036,
-0.0262755044,
-0.0220443383,
-0.0245270096,
0.0534340814,
-0.0171064809,
0.0237637013,
0.0467590019,
-0.0458364747,
-0.0289671291,
0.005148069,
0.0128170848,
-0.0296243466,
0.063599728,
-0.0506762229,
-0.0083861677,
-0.0084410049,
-0.0423755348,
-0.0482422449,
-0.1096533388,
-0.0112629607,
-0.0194932409,
0.0463164859,
-0.0303966478,
-0.04249781,
-0.0251335595,
0.0118762814,
0.0225504376,
-0.0048328722,
0.0322805382,
-0.0553757027,
0.0343780033,
0.0428162739,
-0.0387188904,
0.0382285975,
-0.0099241193,
0.0240060985,
0.0679529384,
0.0441519059,
0.0122368271,
0.0334065221,
0.0193667244,
0.0342387222,
-0.0036412841,
-0.0169432499,
0.0237285811,
0.0372581929,
-0.0336659066,
-0.0037050424,
0.0843712389,
0.0386455804,
-0.0099924626,
0.0348367579,
-0.0063865827,
0.0313177407,
0.0112816058,
0.0119234351,
-0.0763049945,
-0.0301203672,
0.0366105177,
0.0496731661,
-0.0491421297,
-0.0464602672,
-0.0500100814,
-0.1288119853,
-0.0089709871,
0.0551081635,
0.0003750012,
-0.0132115297,
-0.0358728915,
-0.0026090487,
0.0089558931,
0.0440952219,
-0.0061409781,
-0.0143905003,
-0.0260589477,
-0.0186625589,
-0.0028668812,
-0.0222708564,
0.0106466422,
-0.0244338959,
0.0877628326,
0.0769432858,
-0.0032309492,
-0.0157622192,
-0.0000053101,
0.0307913274,
-0.0098213023,
-0.006670787,
0.0008255662,
-0.0038751434,
0.0038477869,
-0.014529977,
-0.0077423691,
0.0565649346,
-0.0133522246,
-0.0135028511,
0.0286449287,
0.0644435063,
-0.007936582,
-0.0123624979,
0.0065626288,
-0.0312247798,
0.0259747896,
0.0761855394,
-0.0030023898,
-0.0351365171,
-0.025893297,
-0.0602193251,
-0.0316308253,
0.0260874219,
-0.0093363291,
0.0476405881,
0.0163358524,
-0.0286572352,
-0.0403394401,
-0.0062908325,
-0.0241777115,
0.0502748266,
0.0493157133,
0.0123966392,
-0.0053892373,
-0.0153203262,
-0.0237308033,
0.0272635967,
-0.038424626,
0.0403690264,
-0.0545371249,
0.0374346301,
-0.0184385013,
-0.0135373985,
0.00095527,
0.0271929819,
-0.0423853807,
-0.1007013023,
0.038558282,
0.0207805522,
0.033811029,
0.0440024287,
-0.0302598141,
-0.0441931039,
0.0463728718,
0.0862869397,
-0.0489217788,
0.0331737995,
0.0355199538,
-0.0141815962,
0.0107453661,
0.0456535034,
-0.0310643893,
-0.041307535,
0.0658698678,
0.0279392805,
-0.0605714247,
-0.0109532541,
0.0451845117,
0.0274550077,
0.0213942695,
-0.0233040713,
0.0123523427,
-0.0042287549,
0.0356510617,
-0.0183849167,
-0.0408571549,
-0.0126749249,
0.0031796978,
0.0436248258,
-0.0014859681,
0.0262046512,
0.0067337067,
-0.0269309338,
0.0282437131,
-0.0328747556,
0.0247355811,
0.0064105983,
0.0308419075,
0.0509046316,
0.0104898289,
-0.017117165,
0.0914830416,
-0.0259611495,
0.0368155316,
0.0015802481,
0.0598985553,
0.0085960627,
-0.0155286165,
-0.0283449292,
0.0497540571,
-0.0732522979,
-0.020187797,
-0.017357327,
0.0592898354,
-0.0169685856,
-0.0270527788,
0.0037299381,
-0.0049171965,
-0.0082085645,
-0.0227479227,
-0.0216364935,
0.0077383695,
-0.0667426363,
0.0405536145,
0.0148561066,
-0.0331923515,
0.0453247055,
0.0418973826,
0.0169657413,
0.0281660724,
0.0046053724,
-0.0162267871,
-0.0384039097,
-0.0301703978,
0.0575061031,
0.0091726221,
-0.0651986822,
-0.0168661755,
-0.0706538856,
-0.075981684,
-0.0218124036,
-0.0056901546,
0.0076094344,
-0.0057211979,
-0.0399978235,
0.0639019608,
-0.0070211375,
0.0295140203,
-0.0487763509,
0.0078509692,
0.0192448366,
-0.0532422699,
-0.0065884315,
-6.363446098e-33,
0.0221927669,
-0.0201849751,
-0.0664115325,
-0.0400000662,
0.0248992797,
0.0172550566,
-0.0085434979,
0.0225471798,
-0.0136118727,
-0.0414636284,
-0.0306901578,
-0.0036915313,
0.0146583728,
0.0156237092,
-0.053375043,
-0.020717077,
0.0124838622,
0.0317394286,
-0.0309838075,
-0.0204178058,
0.045590736,
0.0141270682,
0.0253006388,
-0.0490107127,
0.0810446665,
-0.0373349302,
-0.0456957482,
0.0441305637,
-0.02969715,
0.0523342863,
-0.0053737778,
0.0075162374,
-0.0097963037,
-0.025557654,
-0.003648889,
0.0782744586,
-0.0132706147,
0.0132566914,
0.0502162389,
0.0024753229,
0.0286808778,
-0.0533740558,
0.0323416702,
-0.0247662384,
-0.0160159115,
0.0105624804,
-0.0106860278,
-0.0314428136,
-0.0311520658,
0.0139853405,
-0.0279694274,
0.0191328302,
-0.0245455559,
-0.0008305516,
-0.0082638962,
-0.0012734816,
0.0158854946,
0.0017844638,
-0.0479014479,
0.0188644864,
0.0494417436,
0.020260416,
0.0705309957,
0.0072762715,
0.0050576641,
0.0732643679,
-0.0127321454,
-0.041301731,
-0.006539077,
-0.0216948204,
-0.0067918496,
0.0504981019,
0.0341116525,
0.0689692199,
0.0482329428,
-0.0192026347,
-0.0528605878,
-0.0000409879,
0.0137257036,
-0.0126993684,
0.0329723917,
-0.000906492,
-0.0685309097,
0.0064044255,
-0.0302911755,
-0.0276713017,
-0.0324628875,
-0.0232560132,
0.02275078,
0.0047077406,
-0.0445156991,
-0.0069661536,
0.0064276475,
-0.0602099709,
-0.018802939,
0.0046659852,
-0.0098448228,
-0.0180964172,
-0.0070515005,
0.0498583168,
0.0038787499,
-0.01626442,
0.0244936831,
-0.0494040139,
0.0315519609,
0.0068338695,
0.0282655638,
0.014068543,
-0.0957112387,
-0.0005404896,
-0.0212304685,
0.0484990664,
0.0042027486,
-0.0190271083,
0.0699469224,
-0.0331317559,
0.0001110952,
0.0031521451,
0.0409010872,
0.0210276805,
-0.0450636186,
0.0463032722,
-0.0485735536,
0.0286620613,
-0.0135109024,
0.0009639713,
0.042446956,
0.0156224612,
0.0428559184,
-0.0377300791,
0.0028984365,
0.0075392127,
2.89e-7,
0.0090007288,
-0.006896446,
0.0152458865,
-0.0118106753,
0.0073480732,
0.0669732168,
-0.0321044326,
0.0683595091,
-0.0172393899,
-0.0743261352,
-0.0182399582,
-0.0320709608,
0.0513223521,
0.0149978837,
-0.0782616436,
0.0361900628,
-0.055836305,
0.0034735566,
-0.0719675273,
0.0015819746,
0.0200269315,
0.1334585994,
0.0117602115,
-0.0314741246,
-0.0197091736,
-0.0567800924,
0.0128731979,
-0.0215193778,
-0.0210110657,
-0.0141837299,
0.01735688,
-0.00808826,
0.0084153069,
0.0107920514,
-0.0114418231,
0.0277181175,
-0.0240604542,
0.0738792047,
0.0134162065,
-0.0199594926,
-0.0400638022,
-0.0521784462,
-0.0254289638,
-0.0595033094,
0.0601031221,
-0.0054305457,
-0.0528729409,
-0.0343546197,
-0.0010760654,
-0.0299576037,
0.0029171638,
-0.0071918191,
0.0045115957,
0.0118575767,
0.0165345054,
0.0106461467,
0.0095101362,
-0.0614259951,
-0.0376546644,
-0.003708147,
-0.0326227471,
-0.0380936228,
-0.0128982421,
0.0332076401,
0.0428223833,
-0.0786254108,
0.0213528927,
3.180265528e-34,
0.011337555,
-0.0483086109,
-0.0021381222,
0.0136366701,
0.0384659059,
-0.0018037047,
0.0341047384,
0.0393964648,
0.0160884112,
-0.0647688657,
-0.0215261113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13660v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13660v1 | Towards Minimal Targeted Updates of Language Models with Targeted Negative Training | 2024-06-19T16:06:21 | 2024-06-19T16:06:21 | Lily H. Zhang, Rajesh Ranganath, Arya Tafvizi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative models of language exhibit impressive capabilities but still place
non-negligible probability mass over undesirable outputs. In this work, we
address the task of updating a model to avoid unwanted outputs while minimally
changing model behavior otherwise, a challenge we refer to as a minimal
targeted update. We first formalize the notion of a minimal targeted update and
propose a method to achieve such updates using negative examples from a model's
generations. Our proposed Targeted Negative Training (TNT) results in updates
that keep the new distribution close to the original, unlike existing losses
for negative signal which push down probability but do not control what the
updated distribution will be. In experiments, we demonstrate that TNT yields a
better trade-off between reducing unwanted behavior and maintaining model
generation behavior than baselines, paving the way towards a modeling paradigm
based on iterative training updates that constrain models from generating
undesirable outputs while preserving their impressive capabilities. | [
0.0022106725,
0.0876193121,
-0.005596776,
0.0013453284,
-0.0371352807,
-0.001162691,
-0.0479570813,
0.0146654155,
-0.0752168223,
-0.0062313164,
-0.0240855161,
-0.0454954542,
-0.0008996315,
0.0443524085,
0.0583379678,
-0.0432521999,
0.0531460606,
-0.0107008396,
-0.0178843327,
-0.0303101875,
0.0042883316,
-0.0116166631,
-0.0108481962,
-0.0002667485,
-0.0078618331,
0.0117710726,
-0.0196596347,
0.023190394,
0.0071962075,
-0.0149885332,
0.0049022497,
0.0359307304,
-0.0141332131,
0.0412876271,
0.0000017768,
-0.043637868,
-0.0109878639,
-0.0048679849,
-0.0280418247,
-0.0033209645,
0.0678815916,
-0.0338455327,
-0.0616578571,
0.0280773677,
-0.0246379897,
0.0056639467,
0.0689009726,
0.0217941012,
0.050087288,
0.0802530721,
0.007750378,
-0.0081796506,
0.0200395305,
-0.0611771643,
0.0005993777,
-0.0115299858,
0.0176166836,
-0.0147459833,
-0.0325908288,
-0.0218921229,
-0.0430685952,
0.0369683616,
0.0056819418,
-0.0077839596,
0.020731397,
0.0489342064,
-0.0070426883,
-0.0424478874,
0.0207526442,
0.0327923074,
-0.0281525627,
-0.0621624887,
-0.0188256986,
-0.0231715422,
-0.0050308453,
-0.0367752574,
-0.0205413345,
0.0043511209,
0.0420819595,
0.0440733843,
-0.0108263502,
-0.0327927321,
0.0373822264,
0.0213465802,
-0.0112175941,
0.0056474451,
0.0439113379,
-0.0443523116,
-0.0118819075,
-0.0013721327,
-0.0300972424,
-0.0235182941,
-0.018887911,
0.0195373502,
0.0045700488,
0.0177008845,
-0.0185292792,
-0.0346300863,
0.0115670394,
-0.0543816537,
0.0290481076,
0.0260589533,
0.0039508198,
0.0179198608,
-0.0142717995,
-0.022413671,
0.0080429278,
-0.0019283182,
-0.0192884952,
0.0209253356,
-0.0155391591,
-0.0282596089,
-0.037968386,
0.0168604348,
-0.0198841728,
0.0081684422,
-0.0020491721,
0.0200173333,
-0.0374620445,
-0.0157274306,
-0.0268754233,
0.0188097581,
-0.0779992789,
-0.0121001061,
0.0057620243,
0.0402820297,
-0.0173826534,
-0.0059014563,
-0.00893916,
-0.0491832383,
-0.0375029035,
0.0131527046,
0.0185516514,
0.0308838896,
-0.0070889294,
0.0599609129,
-0.0163587928,
-0.0008100109,
-0.0673995689,
-0.0177505407,
-0.0070319027,
-0.0593168475,
-0.0226822868,
-0.0277387109,
-0.0380439535,
-0.0136321234,
-0.0005218753,
-0.0975624174,
0.0057271682,
-0.0153701482,
0.0136192916,
0.0613208599,
0.0212298352,
0.0017065856,
0.0552230813,
0.0087771881,
-0.0033184041,
0.0894580856,
0.021470027,
-0.0226020571,
0.0109465113,
0.0029454175,
0.0197464786,
0.0625899136,
0.085296303,
0.0486326553,
-0.0556271635,
-0.0407246947,
-0.0065631093,
0.0256092008,
0.0601611435,
0.0325183198,
-0.0333013572,
-0.0218735896,
0.0993864015,
-0.0031048213,
-0.0326272547,
0.0382115133,
0.0185059234,
0.0021642027,
-0.0461545065,
0.0011702586,
-0.0392768644,
0.0078239646,
-0.0490432158,
0.0167255905,
-0.0175707936,
-0.0379340872,
-0.0490155406,
-0.0304291751,
0.0059524653,
-0.0239202473,
0.0280474704,
-0.0475370958,
0.0736373141,
0.0421140045,
-0.0453260094,
0.0476110242,
0.0461323783,
-0.0700918511,
0.0274263322,
-0.0462086573,
0.0453819819,
0.0228493381,
0.0458017811,
-0.0081678918,
-0.0453127846,
0.0022884384,
-0.0440720655,
0.0664167181,
0.0430076346,
-0.0069332174,
0.0411915258,
-0.0137138618,
-0.0181600004,
0.0458923616,
0.0231176615,
0.0102245528,
0.0231149253,
-0.0153313391,
0.0245111957,
-0.0350921527,
-0.0193586368,
0.0265733656,
-0.0625849366,
-0.0057764924,
0.0328256749,
0.0061139017,
0.0404090211,
-0.0223091245,
-0.0114217578,
0.0223965701,
0.0388305709,
-0.0143187921,
-0.0479482673,
0.0181555524,
-0.0599034131,
-0.0090525039,
0.0413550958,
0.0115600694,
0.0540574864,
0.0628600717,
-0.0282595251,
-0.0407283045,
0.0915012509,
-0.0456260219,
0.0551397279,
-0.0465025902,
0.0199267715,
-0.0097849276,
-0.0083588585,
-0.0226113833,
0.0451301038,
-0.0311504118,
-0.0010548424,
0.0031853053,
-0.0067874831,
0.0028835994,
-0.0551796779,
-0.0442776866,
-0.0020199195,
-0.0056440253,
0.0208246,
0.059866596,
-0.0130079836,
-0.0295635983,
-0.0003594076,
-0.0229296219,
-0.003545328,
-0.0298564155,
0.0304905679,
0.0552478507,
-0.0015876732,
-0.0046946937,
-0.0443136245,
-0.0110675776,
-0.0055428427,
-0.0020574846,
0.0176738519,
0.0165132042,
0.0338472873,
-0.0192865245,
-0.0350867808,
0.0003832661,
0.0301946644,
0.0250802115,
-0.0394706354,
-0.0076887002,
-0.0692099854,
0.0259379689,
-0.0465298891,
0.0570564047,
0.0173654705,
-0.0353094228,
0.0025418291,
-0.0150647657,
0.0396106467,
0.0245210137,
0.0071699494,
-0.0157733951,
0.0320017189,
0.033079572,
-0.0585600697,
-0.0177301224,
-0.0478670746,
-0.0315223895,
-0.0194933116,
-0.03539823,
-0.0272307824,
0.0746858716,
0.0000475644,
-0.0288222935,
-0.0928852484,
0.009963695,
-0.0335432403,
-0.0496623404,
-0.0026123,
0.001099846,
-0.0383943543,
-0.0035571086,
-0.0428174399,
-0.0745341852,
0.0517073795,
-0.0208873805,
-0.0116146076,
-0.0185928755,
0.0338600129,
0.0192079991,
0.0604170598,
0.031381283,
0.0405247696,
0.0585968532,
0.012083346,
-0.0684099048,
-0.0128199011,
0.0619202554,
-0.0029985907,
0.0169695057,
-0.0593849495,
0.0201686528,
-0.0129151735,
-0.033817362,
-0.0480918586,
-0.0479129627,
0.0521716624,
0.0021916467,
-0.0111656226,
-0.0064489674,
-0.0236159414,
0.0052490234,
-0.0319438204,
0.0506916642,
-0.0291788317,
-0.0178041067,
-0.0064065489,
0.0218222365,
0.0498413853,
-0.0157308672,
0.0107626095,
-0.0073774513,
-0.0160913374,
0.0422495529,
0.0287630092,
0.0364055037,
-0.0249062162,
-0.0152613577,
0.0370335095,
-0.0020401792,
-0.032093253,
0.0202417951,
0.0275535285,
-0.0162928477,
-0.0570371449,
0.0897196084,
0.0208609588,
-0.0045430115,
0.0186945498,
-0.0010935131,
0.0914024934,
0.0195617005,
0.0048271185,
-0.0509981215,
0.006182998,
0.0009963344,
0.0733741149,
-0.019192731,
-0.0241426677,
-0.028331317,
-0.1432488859,
-0.0039079529,
0.0538507849,
0.0032319471,
0.0046019536,
-0.0116204629,
-0.01155061,
-0.0597963072,
-0.0139372759,
0.0383803025,
0.0138707869,
0.0162834711,
0.0522433519,
0.0053049298,
-0.0612932518,
-0.0165027194,
-0.0290232059,
0.0545348749,
0.0886056572,
-0.0120578725,
-0.0070930086,
-0.0183560681,
0.0532317907,
-0.0193679035,
-0.0177507084,
-0.0116043473,
0.0271721724,
0.0389466546,
0.0082503166,
0.0160952173,
0.0442902446,
-0.0105829006,
-0.0114469444,
-0.0323775634,
0.0510421731,
-0.0122615853,
-0.0050343452,
0.0114333574,
-0.0056488137,
0.0334757529,
0.0796018094,
0.0063564479,
-0.0431290716,
0.0145352827,
-0.0224920139,
0.0683198795,
-0.0278151315,
0.004235073,
-0.036197681,
0.0231540948,
-0.0731888935,
-0.1015866846,
-0.0186893735,
-0.035790585,
0.0340267159,
0.0259196684,
-0.0207188819,
-0.0234914273,
-0.0061092572,
-0.0273650959,
-0.0152711757,
-0.0300460961,
-0.0081193028,
-0.0602314845,
-0.0479789972,
0.0465587415,
-0.0218795631,
-0.0337208323,
-0.0006121194,
-0.0861509517,
-0.0868619308,
-0.0000142658,
0.0560638309,
0.0218942463,
0.0797394216,
-0.0125345271,
-0.0592321977,
0.06810949,
0.0673816353,
0.0096192844,
0.0550010055,
0.0742990524,
-0.0555918477,
-0.0161889531,
0.0627896935,
-0.0221447181,
0.0400161073,
0.0606703386,
0.0367210582,
-0.0379015505,
0.0057272888,
0.0433651432,
-0.0235102642,
0.0458617248,
-0.064675726,
-0.0219569337,
-0.0198981315,
0.0094435308,
0.0014359856,
-0.001560733,
-0.0238494836,
0.0099840527,
0.0487110578,
-0.0094507579,
-0.016064724,
0.0104801096,
-0.0236049481,
0.0704638734,
-0.0165407378,
-0.0212012865,
0.050962124,
0.0156713985,
0.0190616604,
0.0309096184,
0.0040407819,
-0.0044756685,
-0.0125236362,
-0.0015081773,
-0.0522354804,
0.0151266772,
0.0286433194,
0.0254426189,
-0.0189305805,
-0.0085957535,
-0.0265932083,
0.0081212316,
-0.0432171859,
0.0180719029,
0.0427164957,
0.0312819779,
0.0690962523,
-0.0017828156,
-0.0185045935,
-0.0449812785,
0.005714071,
0.000277695,
-0.0443824828,
0.0032697504,
0.0041413642,
0.0023899206,
0.0063900477,
0.0675725713,
-0.0137264337,
0.0869672373,
-0.0441574007,
0.021380119,
-0.0320992135,
-0.0167074893,
-0.0052130679,
0.0072936774,
0.0129690738,
0.0357282162,
-0.0329181068,
-0.0580888428,
-0.0175606534,
0.0268035494,
0.0272041615,
0.0070526651,
0.053534206,
0.0278348438,
-0.054446999,
-0.0052118679,
-0.0300772209,
-0.006640824,
0.0232404023,
0.0088086799,
-0.0309050269,
-5.963494431e-33,
-0.024796607,
0.0259015374,
-0.0097126765,
-0.0125693949,
-0.0049773199,
-0.0298700649,
-0.0360794179,
0.0028907128,
-0.0023871395,
0.0061829039,
-0.0122398036,
0.0004822389,
0.0040836893,
0.038391903,
-0.011218871,
0.0103488602,
0.1037451923,
-0.0286171604,
-0.0439831838,
0.0278121289,
0.0453700647,
0.0294213835,
0.0671745539,
-0.0204499159,
0.0091167716,
-0.0248557832,
-0.0655463859,
0.0328786783,
0.0213298313,
0.0302386917,
-0.0197549704,
0.0350707248,
-0.0058257119,
-0.0813231468,
-0.0465211794,
-0.045997303,
-0.0680407584,
-0.0289050899,
-0.0010789705,
0.0162198227,
-0.0119554177,
-0.0052600149,
0.0673219562,
-0.0020283668,
-0.0360447802,
0.0334735364,
0.0016326366,
-0.031335216,
-0.0226180069,
0.021759171,
-0.0818924159,
0.0284482688,
0.0064797034,
-0.059488792,
-0.0003881956,
-0.0050045522,
-0.0117148319,
-0.0470446013,
-0.0288748778,
0.0173214842,
0.0424854383,
0.0623410195,
0.0553892329,
0.0288688466,
0.007393261,
0.0175166987,
0.0088663911,
-0.0177463777,
0.0482870378,
-0.0385751165,
0.0538952015,
-0.0127652027,
0.0224265456,
0.0400531255,
0.0302227996,
-0.0348148644,
-0.0419007987,
0.004036929,
-0.00005503,
0.0454305522,
0.0094286315,
0.0580958463,
-0.0295194648,
-0.0247032158,
-0.0548879951,
-0.0782733709,
0.004208134,
-0.023266837,
0.020658033,
0.048125267,
-0.0495850593,
0.0227119941,
0.0225195959,
-0.0206164196,
-0.0284927692,
0.0379672609,
-0.0311483946,
-0.0090574799,
0.0076808627,
-0.0096611017,
-0.0475524366,
0.0106825866,
0.0397589542,
-0.0010714302,
-0.0140599925,
-0.0131179215,
0.076145336,
0.0663614646,
-0.0923499092,
0.0060962057,
-0.0335446298,
0.0470397063,
0.0237841941,
0.0221038517,
0.0253444482,
0.0042877756,
0.005846397,
0.0239821058,
0.0460546091,
-0.0035748149,
-0.0334654525,
0.0683264881,
0.0196959488,
0.0305514559,
-0.0257524382,
-0.0082826363,
0.009436558,
0.0149047775,
0.0589592643,
-0.0605383404,
-0.0310653746,
-0.0194467064,
2.412e-7,
0.0289242528,
0.0166451987,
0.0277552903,
0.0160663482,
0.0663259923,
0.0629477873,
-0.0376540124,
0.0188950282,
0.0067776954,
0.0549341589,
0.0206173528,
-0.0075700632,
-0.0020393557,
0.0246146657,
-0.051029902,
0.0451614931,
-0.0944858715,
0.0161006395,
0.0083929673,
-0.0147525985,
0.0344293453,
0.1134641469,
0.0377925746,
-0.0205388814,
0.0097765857,
-0.0313076377,
0.0810761899,
-0.0108703915,
0.0100181494,
-0.0029031937,
-0.0104895514,
-0.0022234044,
0.0015669186,
-0.014410628,
-0.0381054357,
-0.026032947,
-0.0576833934,
0.0387583226,
-0.0532561168,
-0.0200421624,
-0.0019026413,
0.0283447579,
-0.0198663715,
-0.0113612572,
0.0597626641,
-0.0148311453,
-0.0099479565,
-0.0489986539,
-0.0299836956,
0.0237909183,
-0.0059463507,
-0.0348179489,
-0.056090612,
0.0109974397,
0.0151562504,
0.0503477305,
-0.039338138,
-0.0503492132,
-0.0130683519,
-0.0164824817,
-0.0259623453,
-0.0529762208,
-0.0221176744,
0.0353732668,
-0.0014089918,
-0.050018765,
0.0079358676,
2.054003498e-34,
0.035100814,
-0.0097480258,
-0.0197514724,
-0.0162213165,
-0.0074946508,
-0.0060599283,
0.0070761237,
0.0125193149,
0.0194821544,
-0.0019240869,
-0.0142599521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13632v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13632v2 | Can Few-shot Work in Long-Context? Recycling the Context to Generate Demonstrations | 2024-06-19T15:28:29 | 2024-06-23T07:19:22 | Arie Cattan, Alon Jacovi, Alex Fabrikant, Jonathan Herzig, Roee Aharoni, Hannah Rashkin, Dror Marcus, Avinatan Hassidim, Yossi Matias, Idan Szpektor, Avi Caciularu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs), their
performance on tasks involving long contexts remains sub-optimal. In-Context
Learning (ICL) with few-shot examples may be an appealing solution to enhance
LLM performance in this scenario; However, naively adding ICL examples with
long context introduces challenges, including substantial token overhead added
for each few-shot example and context mismatch between the demonstrations and
the target query. In this work, we propose to automatically generate few-shot
examples for long context QA tasks by recycling contexts. Specifically, given a
long input context (1-3k tokens) and a query, we generate additional
query-output pairs from the given context as few-shot examples, while
introducing the context only once. This ensures that the demonstrations are
leveraging the same context as the target query while only adding a small
number of tokens to the prompt. We further enhance each demonstration by
instructing the model to explicitly identify the relevant paragraphs before the
answer, which improves performance while providing fine-grained attribution to
the answer source. We apply our method on multiple LLMs and obtain substantial
improvements (+23\% on average across models) on various QA datasets with long
context, especially when the answer lies within the middle of the context.
Surprisingly, despite introducing only single-hop ICL examples, LLMs also
successfully generalize to multi-hop long-context QA using our approach. | [
0.0075423806,
0.0527093522,
-0.0004208172,
0.0446716137,
-0.0458970256,
-0.0015856175,
0.0349445157,
-0.0062223524,
-0.033504229,
-0.057837069,
-0.014664771,
-0.023330817,
-0.0162924342,
-0.0001596432,
0.0440863781,
-0.0428050049,
0.0334440805,
-0.0473436117,
-0.0156410988,
0.0076910211,
-0.0244632848,
0.0105811954,
-0.0110410564,
0.0393406712,
-0.0009109387,
-0.0462745652,
-0.0274729542,
0.0111623602,
0.0077620363,
-0.026194578,
-0.0017351648,
0.0440404862,
0.0339663178,
0.0287440177,
0.0000017689,
-0.0483566523,
-0.0104522649,
0.0231148507,
-0.0703448877,
0.0395633839,
0.0321157314,
0.020909857,
0.0281568803,
0.0272454154,
-0.0460169725,
0.0040959339,
-0.0054969052,
0.0431409404,
0.0425750129,
0.0647166893,
0.0100468248,
-0.0388318263,
-0.0160067324,
-0.0313331112,
0.0621913932,
-0.0741497651,
0.0141799375,
-0.0451045148,
0.0510225445,
0.0380319692,
-0.031898424,
0.0266599581,
0.0634219423,
-0.0167381074,
-0.026680015,
0.0428140685,
-0.0655296445,
0.0355001129,
-0.0021795616,
0.0718915388,
-0.0189095959,
-0.0210334025,
-0.0158291236,
-0.0145512251,
0.0262461118,
-0.0301013459,
-0.0758671835,
-0.0022533357,
0.0234336872,
-0.0033825091,
-0.0053489832,
-0.0104943542,
0.0083815251,
-0.0077813636,
-0.0427722409,
0.0229393393,
0.0075637642,
-0.0273797102,
-0.0208318885,
-0.0073405937,
-0.0351467431,
-0.0495140366,
-0.0421941355,
0.052289255,
-0.0661704987,
0.0315211155,
-0.0327714011,
-0.0344975255,
0.0352869891,
0.0231001116,
0.0217835829,
0.0236245319,
-0.0127501357,
0.0659309477,
-0.0304818209,
0.0422967039,
-0.0014944217,
0.0375454389,
-0.0490929224,
-0.0194726326,
-0.051230032,
-0.0108738337,
-0.0592660233,
0.0329387859,
-0.0440628454,
-0.0252014324,
-0.0281919166,
0.0253940504,
-0.0153732812,
0.0107870772,
-0.014731897,
0.0114821633,
-0.024086047,
-0.0001447133,
0.0144262686,
0.0274054762,
-0.0544342957,
0.0144116636,
0.024629822,
-0.0580438636,
-0.0401576981,
0.0030156074,
0.0255324803,
-0.0277809724,
0.000520156,
0.0677978024,
-0.0214772802,
-0.0785966218,
-0.0178201795,
-0.0359237827,
-0.0016208452,
-0.0410613567,
-0.0389235616,
-0.069634825,
0.0432643965,
-0.0054334882,
-0.0070261923,
-0.0008434195,
0.0056239082,
0.0548016801,
-0.00801971,
0.071931541,
0.039038606,
0.0089762192,
0.030264318,
0.0230291337,
0.015875414,
0.0988883898,
0.0078699859,
0.0054018903,
0.0344473422,
0.0167386308,
0.0195627809,
0.0205526166,
0.0778494179,
0.0276418459,
-0.0253976434,
0.0461092032,
0.0298849083,
0.0492232963,
0.0148644615,
0.0430652797,
-0.0366372615,
-0.0058148382,
0.0084987162,
0.0606849827,
0.0246840864,
-0.0534552559,
0.0424042456,
0.0023539085,
-0.0089460937,
-0.0098299012,
-0.07090538,
0.0147627322,
0.0171314329,
0.0109868757,
0.0412101559,
0.01385858,
-0.0406713262,
-0.0059505301,
0.0126384161,
-0.005832463,
-0.0268270411,
0.03757824,
0.027723426,
0.0372188762,
-0.0420484319,
0.0245618206,
0.0048367819,
-0.0223248266,
0.0191133283,
-0.0568792224,
0.0371916406,
0.0286327936,
0.0390741266,
-0.0315119959,
-0.0311379209,
-0.0172368884,
0.0610556044,
0.014440503,
0.0189996213,
-0.0445438363,
0.0267694555,
-0.0019827986,
-0.0273144133,
-0.0426588096,
0.0081636785,
-0.0099264104,
0.0486952998,
0.0270319823,
0.02069249,
-0.0635830685,
0.0522563383,
0.0301755592,
-0.0426497534,
-0.059991762,
0.0275112372,
0.0086953733,
0.006352142,
0.0300119407,
0.0066868807,
0.0244779158,
0.036744874,
-0.0415441766,
0.0087479865,
-0.0064107813,
-0.0659308657,
-0.0856568664,
0.0107176919,
-0.0009036946,
-0.0160842333,
-0.0258497447,
-0.0636612251,
-0.0308840517,
-0.0175228994,
-0.0088061141,
0.0575673766,
-0.014381391,
-0.0047742021,
0.0032419118,
-0.0028225679,
-0.0476409867,
0.0487481728,
0.016423557,
0.0169546194,
0.0421403758,
0.0391827375,
-0.0194707047,
-0.0499823131,
0.0084528318,
-0.0219270494,
-0.0104549835,
0.0000499497,
-0.0072062938,
0.0346882641,
-0.0562488995,
0.0042687156,
-0.1047443151,
0.0044866884,
-0.0427534506,
0.0109360786,
0.0087411394,
0.0291208569,
-0.0229336414,
-0.017504368,
-0.0480479151,
-0.0426111668,
0.0000626721,
0.0485906713,
0.021010166,
0.0535493009,
0.0016663427,
-0.0147593925,
-0.0082565984,
-0.0124433031,
0.0769410878,
-0.023443006,
0.0382664092,
-0.0394977555,
0.0090237036,
0.0280498192,
0.0037975956,
-0.0133168539,
0.0208615437,
0.0137233501,
-0.0158633459,
0.0294702612,
0.0724154189,
0.013505809,
0.0112833707,
0.0057742922,
0.0071400292,
-0.0745016113,
0.0299909282,
-0.0090836575,
-0.0211491231,
-0.0201618001,
0.0048713991,
0.0235072114,
0.018562315,
-0.0019212059,
-0.0091574844,
-0.0353509448,
0.0468623713,
-0.0118104899,
-0.0315145105,
-0.0653051361,
-0.0111216111,
-0.0138399219,
0.0196527839,
-0.0051999511,
-0.0110526532,
0.0668757856,
-0.0128695853,
0.0111208996,
-0.0166373625,
0.0080994563,
-0.0647809356,
0.071696572,
-0.0168798752,
-0.0047225426,
-0.0246583484,
-0.0324253887,
-0.0448197089,
-0.01982476,
-0.0305993799,
-0.0164314546,
0.0582731813,
-0.031488996,
-0.0004541753,
-0.0166161098,
-0.0621033758,
-0.0516735911,
-0.0318835527,
0.0025227324,
0.0240215007,
-0.0281976201,
0.0125937164,
0.0141816996,
-0.0188893452,
0.0414992273,
0.0523924679,
-0.0231315996,
-0.0059990599,
-0.011714194,
0.0465297513,
0.0758074075,
0.0103543354,
-0.0063034575,
-0.038886562,
0.0495432988,
0.05226456,
0.1087366343,
-0.0072719469,
0.0122906305,
-0.0216180161,
-0.0021413711,
-0.0247351974,
0.0011873269,
0.0451651476,
0.0757972673,
-0.0626669526,
-0.0438295528,
0.0891209841,
0.030769892,
-0.0567015149,
0.0073451907,
-0.0076080766,
0.00813396,
0.0278575886,
0.0476896614,
-0.1179963946,
-0.0380149633,
0.0055286945,
0.0213770512,
0.0076339287,
-0.0233812891,
-0.0190928169,
-0.1706199497,
0.0360645726,
-0.0081691984,
-0.0804648697,
-0.0127640124,
-0.0486651324,
0.0158275831,
0.0115378862,
0.0409499072,
0.040927574,
-0.0289704856,
0.0004429223,
0.0176466201,
0.0506055169,
-0.0571319722,
0.0479177646,
-0.0314673334,
0.024686873,
0.0223747157,
-0.0027052981,
0.0203314498,
-0.0003130457,
0.0322654173,
-0.0595762208,
0.0217103455,
0.0010592925,
0.0326653682,
-0.0256900545,
-0.0063813897,
0.0359436795,
0.0705176666,
-0.0295767076,
-0.0490373187,
0.0338674821,
0.0644051284,
-0.0036436974,
0.006413802,
-0.0476219729,
-0.0399854407,
0.0238984749,
0.075300239,
0.0554809831,
-0.0532461554,
-0.0374383964,
-0.0041653262,
-0.0198475737,
-0.0627302527,
0.0151824746,
-0.0013089975,
0.0075326804,
0.0300366301,
-0.0495603979,
-0.0427650176,
0.0636508539,
0.0709332004,
-0.0280411616,
0.039553564,
-0.0504118763,
0.0094322944,
-0.0389767103,
0.0038670984,
-0.0533523895,
0.0311722849,
-0.0493793786,
0.0341947712,
0.0300009586,
-0.0124039222,
-0.0193928201,
0.0112382555,
-0.1043684557,
-0.0578079671,
-0.0005445603,
0.0230228715,
0.0137596615,
0.063668251,
-0.0071476242,
-0.0282348804,
0.0826813653,
0.0648426935,
-0.0177198481,
0.0174840055,
-0.0038188,
0.0271282159,
-0.0099924076,
0.0377357304,
-0.072957024,
-0.0062278253,
0.0111403288,
0.0530138053,
-0.0445851758,
0.0077069858,
0.020424841,
-0.0117040258,
0.0340268239,
0.0099507561,
-0.0062907892,
0.0032928584,
0.0665147305,
-0.0366255417,
-0.0207277108,
-0.0067007239,
0.0017827991,
-0.0253182389,
-0.0334517397,
0.0069014593,
-0.0150910662,
-0.0060453094,
0.0688558817,
-0.0390786231,
0.0099015292,
0.0232639406,
-0.0257648006,
0.0263370462,
-0.0001790521,
-0.0066572572,
-0.0207873527,
0.0040400904,
0.0427784435,
-0.0398103148,
0.0496856757,
0.0471342914,
0.0006470297,
-0.0266744029,
0.0168544352,
-0.0814794973,
0.0017449419,
-0.0336950161,
0.0325401127,
0.0228494443,
-0.0075813183,
-0.014809709,
-0.0013041394,
-0.0261126943,
-0.0084872255,
0.0100966468,
-0.0111355465,
-0.0369396396,
0.0398836248,
0.0574573614,
0.0166595746,
0.0234103519,
0.0741182044,
0.0031965065,
0.0451939069,
0.0326964185,
0.0407995246,
-0.0372740328,
-0.0146080796,
0.0419138968,
0.0259867255,
0.0137458267,
0.0025360796,
-0.0475039445,
-0.0620700791,
0.0133765126,
-0.0063603376,
-0.0274045244,
-0.0058302204,
0.0394218192,
0.0754203051,
0.0174448118,
-0.0399210118,
-0.032505244,
0.0121805286,
0.0154213225,
-0.0653026253,
0.002564288,
-5.72034673e-33,
-0.0191699062,
-0.0462634638,
0.0406325497,
-0.0276536644,
-0.0152173638,
0.0114551755,
-0.0139778499,
-0.034190584,
-0.0157614015,
-0.0027849581,
-0.0586527735,
0.011572713,
0.0072350935,
0.0479241945,
0.0107128751,
-0.0302054007,
0.0366073139,
-0.0142253693,
-0.017436523,
0.0500657372,
0.01034577,
0.0225356519,
0.0084553314,
0.0058542695,
0.0113606704,
-0.0041126441,
0.0004108924,
0.0286665969,
-0.0293400884,
0.0598422512,
-0.0095655974,
0.0294001605,
0.0344319828,
-0.0389148593,
-0.0069500213,
0.045788832,
-0.0801602602,
-0.0363624915,
-0.0013923474,
-0.0095995246,
-0.0457464904,
-0.0342827775,
0.037985675,
-0.0236046873,
-0.0010120077,
-0.0183202717,
0.001953902,
0.0021352221,
-0.0261468384,
-0.0374105722,
-0.0399979576,
0.0007294354,
0.0002869802,
-0.0286502857,
-0.008346254,
0.0442079976,
0.0119766481,
0.0379225388,
-0.0299521293,
0.0057337233,
0.0096838335,
0.0264196824,
0.0444870591,
0.0135973087,
0.0011370396,
0.0335709937,
0.0086355861,
-0.0030653917,
0.005105861,
-0.034241844,
0.0263750963,
0.0141623411,
0.0305806436,
0.0783291385,
0.0531817377,
0.0116961943,
-0.0602316111,
0.0096659781,
0.0116462372,
0.0260079093,
0.0333671458,
0.0104499348,
-0.0244787354,
-0.0181991346,
-0.0558186732,
0.0152965998,
-0.0421514511,
-0.0172729325,
0.0605369098,
0.027029315,
-0.0333163477,
-0.001892662,
0.0522839092,
-0.0339065827,
-0.030477345,
0.0372234061,
-0.0045201783,
0.0128563121,
-0.0012684651,
0.0172577221,
-0.0441475324,
-0.020312028,
0.0283412635,
0.0158650037,
0.0064751101,
-0.0009679352,
0.0507441685,
0.0224778652,
-0.0894331262,
-0.0106576467,
-0.0229185503,
0.039182473,
-0.0080040265,
-0.0330729522,
0.0272216164,
0.0370951183,
0.0006460617,
0.0621952787,
0.0182884969,
-0.0491972975,
-0.0051635867,
-0.0160185639,
-0.0273167677,
0.0023587802,
-0.0297709089,
0.0015844136,
-0.003736058,
0.0306092929,
0.0287317093,
-0.0525488369,
-0.0105771059,
0.0338464454,
2.412e-7,
0.0297146998,
0.0315970704,
0.0321022905,
0.0363071561,
0.0315425433,
0.0108231371,
-0.0000957594,
0.0398112014,
-0.0023010087,
-0.000317221,
0.0059791165,
0.0115812868,
0.013062886,
0.034091305,
-0.120203279,
0.0389309488,
-0.0687464476,
-0.0150283249,
-0.0618608445,
-0.0139018707,
0.0470111929,
0.1072079241,
-0.0019159259,
-0.0112087168,
-0.0169733614,
-0.0500886478,
0.0457414538,
-0.0155261848,
-0.0321440585,
0.0159739424,
-0.0364154838,
0.0084392019,
0.0414491259,
0.0015627741,
-0.0121374577,
0.0127984239,
-0.008332707,
0.0513204336,
0.0155353425,
-0.0659754574,
-0.0159597583,
-0.0216196515,
0.0012661304,
-0.0442619286,
0.0799431726,
-0.0889205188,
-0.003928463,
-0.0473740883,
-0.0105089517,
-0.039967794,
0.0099544227,
-0.0072871619,
-0.002303703,
0.0219797678,
0.0139860213,
0.0047012949,
0.005431484,
-0.1008453965,
-0.01895939,
0.0092851054,
-0.0336190574,
-0.008367585,
-0.0308476444,
-0.0209952574,
-0.0092364624,
-0.0575390533,
-0.0170836542,
2.301915716e-34,
0.0417256802,
-0.0179276094,
0.0111993663,
0.046197582,
-0.0032660877,
-0.0125245824,
-0.0143793123,
0.0150406212,
0.0562567525,
-0.0667082891,
-0.0285615195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13629v1 | InstructRAG: Instructing Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Explicit Denoising | 2024-06-19T15:25:29 | 2024-06-19T15:25:29 | Zhepei Wei, Wei-Lin Chen, Yu Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has shown promising potential to enhance
the accuracy and factuality of language models (LMs). However, imperfect
retrievers or noisy corpora can introduce misleading or even erroneous
information to the retrieved contents, posing a significant challenge to the
generation quality. Existing RAG methods typically address this challenge by
directly predicting final answers despite potentially noisy inputs, resulting
in an implicit denoising process that is difficult to interpret and verify. On
the other hand, the acquisition of explicit denoising supervision is often
costly, involving significant human efforts. In this work, we propose
InstructRAG, where LMs explicitly learn the denoising process through
self-synthesized rationales -- First, we instruct the LM to explain how the
ground-truth answer is derived from retrieved documents. Then, these rationales
can be used either as demonstrations for in-context learning of explicit
denoising or as supervised fine-tuning data to train the model. Compared to
standard RAG approaches, InstructRAG requires no additional supervision, allows
for easier verification of the predicted answers, and effectively improves
generation accuracy. Experiments show InstructRAG consistently outperforms
existing RAG methods in both training-free and trainable scenarios, achieving a
relative improvement of 8.3% over the best baseline method on average across
five knowledge-intensive benchmarks. Extensive analysis indicates that
InstructRAG scales well with increased numbers of retrieved documents and
consistently exhibits robust denoising ability even in out-of-domain datasets,
demonstrating strong generalizability. | [
0.0290595349,
0.0706753433,
0.0136839217,
0.009070605,
-0.0067695235,
-0.0452267006,
-0.0180106722,
0.008668568,
-0.0138316462,
-0.0372924395,
0.0002554989,
-0.0162931699,
-0.0224897247,
0.0120876413,
0.0253094602,
-0.013944285,
0.0501376726,
-0.0171956569,
0.0394962393,
-0.0060931589,
-0.0016660277,
0.0366677567,
0.0215267688,
0.0215401202,
-0.0194732584,
-0.007207341,
-0.0210671127,
0.0447033048,
-0.0178095754,
0.0131934164,
0.0337963663,
0.0664350539,
0.0485139415,
0.0117576616,
0.0000022142,
-0.037143752,
-0.0343576409,
-0.0032770582,
-0.0265486911,
0.017584987,
0.0179934017,
0.027950285,
0.0172538105,
0.029660305,
-0.0488345399,
-0.0005392748,
0.0090051703,
0.0302178897,
0.0670935884,
0.0817026794,
-0.0045953924,
-0.0144104771,
0.0110719139,
-0.0239507519,
0.0216147397,
-0.0094200075,
-0.0063553378,
0.0301604606,
-0.0044056047,
0.0215240847,
0.0294232462,
0.0467375852,
0.030434208,
-0.0327003077,
0.0376997925,
0.0093611702,
-0.0019362206,
-0.0455768853,
0.0023766074,
0.0664930046,
0.0111581068,
-0.0583791211,
0.0088269897,
0.0049272259,
-0.0000757062,
0.0416871645,
-0.0238351114,
0.0217169337,
-0.0090942932,
0.0305443052,
0.0108845709,
0.008947744,
0.0320283882,
0.0448565893,
0.0020243344,
0.0223895386,
0.0079166982,
-0.0107814921,
-0.0136317126,
0.0025227615,
-0.0060516116,
-0.0332357809,
0.0059745926,
0.0440689549,
-0.0178443324,
0.0209043678,
-0.05925522,
-0.0280856602,
0.0304541271,
0.0100158686,
-0.0005200651,
0.0244250223,
-0.0063973679,
0.0355438516,
-0.0229573306,
0.0063482653,
0.0246532615,
-0.0076248944,
-0.0620696358,
-0.0162768066,
-0.0128908698,
-0.0071846023,
-0.0352200642,
0.058692731,
-0.0849887505,
-0.0133163799,
-0.0397506654,
-0.0111043071,
-0.0097640166,
-0.0094912052,
0.0015791614,
0.0621399432,
-0.0727382675,
-0.0263744798,
-0.0275452659,
-0.0027827625,
-0.0160104875,
0.0265079904,
0.0409986116,
-0.055893831,
-0.0255948622,
0.0229313597,
0.0111226346,
0.0024900767,
0.0056866296,
0.0243268926,
-0.0520335734,
0.0050072344,
-0.0639929622,
-0.0804171041,
0.001498447,
-0.0761351138,
-0.0010133585,
-0.0842703506,
0.0021698026,
0.0082487622,
-0.0321255215,
-0.1024338081,
0.0239823051,
0.0407284051,
-0.0035414216,
0.0555074252,
-0.0289878957,
0.013647181,
0.0602034964,
0.0296715405,
0.0131155746,
0.0711256415,
0.0185268838,
0.0248017944,
0.0289694183,
0.0246367957,
0.0231124032,
0.0070087677,
0.05622603,
0.0160273388,
-0.0596645474,
0.0018558746,
-0.0373409167,
0.0034656161,
0.0580612756,
0.0869448334,
-0.0367803834,
-0.0008537365,
0.0561964326,
-0.0035207761,
0.0447007306,
0.0025664144,
0.0406611748,
0.0376276374,
-0.0029873911,
0.0259722974,
-0.026479641,
0.0056094537,
-0.0510487817,
0.0393915139,
0.0487538539,
0.0194254145,
-0.035089422,
-0.0748580322,
0.0086340932,
-0.0026540766,
0.0197378024,
0.0183464363,
0.0450982712,
0.0563597754,
-0.0488502942,
0.0500699393,
0.0313828848,
-0.0798697025,
0.0313965194,
-0.0563196614,
0.0721668825,
0.0367043577,
0.0699629113,
-0.005748515,
-0.0096784066,
0.0144866519,
-0.0236040279,
0.0482750237,
0.0107964911,
-0.0209758654,
-0.0084097683,
-0.0927238464,
-0.0232561715,
-0.0067994543,
0.0291081555,
-0.0060597132,
0.0609278046,
-0.0164766051,
0.069042474,
-0.0748566389,
-0.0451037437,
0.0302793402,
-0.039436847,
-0.0580680631,
0.0177567322,
-0.0102359541,
-0.0013567973,
0.0387607403,
-0.0007266273,
0.0308156647,
0.0582780242,
-0.0098911291,
-0.0218439661,
-0.0237418432,
-0.0785461888,
-0.0375736579,
0.0274647437,
0.0043536476,
-0.0161266979,
0.0096829133,
-0.0097058676,
-0.0478276201,
0.0179611035,
-0.0353940576,
0.0057129231,
-0.104106456,
-0.0164001249,
0.0464034863,
-0.0017853916,
-0.0383888297,
0.0754722878,
-0.0098020947,
-0.0192828458,
0.0715864152,
0.0237833634,
-0.0050273766,
-0.0407699049,
0.0023310126,
-0.0275003202,
-0.0134127364,
0.0339908414,
0.0316757523,
0.0131713497,
-0.0366821662,
0.0142242098,
-0.0611799844,
-0.0099336905,
-0.0218635648,
-0.0251215026,
0.0160490498,
0.0235932022,
0.005025743,
-0.0268379245,
-0.0355941094,
-0.0136871412,
0.0410404801,
-0.0072608679,
0.0076206625,
0.0126000121,
0.0242980924,
-0.0594794527,
0.009076234,
0.0108159631,
0.0189586766,
0.0114998445,
-0.0025938035,
-0.0292719472,
0.0519494042,
-0.0447551236,
0.0343512148,
-0.014381065,
-0.0379893072,
0.0128417043,
-0.0524699613,
0.016669441,
0.0215586927,
0.0233846102,
0.0253432989,
0.0490321964,
-0.0167291332,
-0.0971700251,
0.0259115342,
-0.0415905192,
-0.0147828655,
-0.001607641,
-0.0385330208,
-0.0075751832,
0.0386544243,
0.020404581,
0.003717646,
-0.0501316264,
0.0296468865,
0.0007367964,
-0.0610417314,
-0.0326597579,
-0.0211117342,
-0.0099578388,
0.0701648667,
-0.0333927535,
-0.0580560379,
0.0888005346,
-0.0391526967,
0.0016643645,
-0.0458018072,
-0.0226411708,
0.0058462396,
0.0249503795,
-0.0368636884,
0.0231017936,
0.036292363,
0.0116847735,
-0.0540107712,
-0.0460205898,
0.0277851075,
-0.0582236946,
0.0450739972,
-0.0838932171,
0.0205306802,
0.012903762,
-0.0176928043,
-0.0665749013,
-0.0592765547,
0.0371936634,
0.0145675568,
-0.0220568236,
-0.0111395316,
-0.0084752599,
-0.0126518328,
0.0393695496,
0.0452212095,
-0.0316842683,
-0.0069734138,
0.0029116918,
0.0633930266,
0.0896438062,
0.0263968371,
-0.0046036774,
-0.0222325176,
0.0166399386,
0.056851957,
0.0250950195,
-0.0362265445,
-0.0212767869,
-0.0140872076,
0.0091382349,
0.0188026894,
0.0180623196,
0.0517131798,
0.0634095222,
-0.0501685627,
-0.0385715105,
0.1009360477,
0.0249379203,
-0.0193994306,
-0.0250110216,
-0.0015461198,
0.0564650297,
0.020138694,
0.0062046838,
-0.0561279058,
-0.0303434711,
0.0148696629,
0.0728913918,
0.0057079294,
0.0093562566,
-0.0038998821,
-0.1355839819,
0.0553339869,
0.0308466367,
-0.0012000692,
-0.0231992714,
-0.0642670766,
-0.0173315257,
0.0118505443,
0.0296687093,
0.0321898572,
0.0016272091,
0.0289747268,
0.0346202813,
0.0176132824,
-0.0569586977,
-0.0293301754,
-0.0074126483,
0.0336620957,
0.022801226,
0.0187483374,
0.0255924203,
-0.0374497883,
0.0127717378,
-0.0193371121,
0.0163298901,
-0.0421771146,
0.053701926,
0.0086473301,
0.0158378761,
-0.0158606898,
0.0523528531,
-0.0209555719,
-0.0165322646,
-0.013148794,
0.0283322185,
-0.0263093598,
0.0214734674,
-0.0551931299,
0.0236145984,
0.0304221474,
0.0602667592,
0.0310619511,
-0.006620626,
-0.0114310859,
-0.0263511352,
0.0335581042,
-0.0422097333,
-0.0112801297,
0.0096997563,
-0.0218400676,
-0.0229560882,
-0.0939085111,
-0.0589351766,
-0.0062644812,
0.0390942954,
0.0022867816,
-0.0192106776,
-0.0120774452,
-0.0211345889,
-0.0482288152,
0.0337327309,
-0.0401060358,
-0.0288257673,
-0.0088136066,
-0.0153799253,
0.0162178054,
-0.0552246459,
0.0008089393,
0.0598338842,
-0.0017601403,
-0.0806838498,
-0.0104456302,
0.0503982343,
0.031690672,
0.0835438967,
-0.0186922904,
-0.0186808351,
0.0604113489,
0.049524229,
-0.08028844,
-0.0025068526,
0.0373957977,
-0.0231013298,
0.0001911315,
0.0319492929,
-0.0566685572,
0.0212676506,
-0.0089382483,
0.0480664149,
-0.0277440213,
-0.0472174771,
0.0524445325,
0.0124727897,
0.048443161,
-0.024992995,
0.0217899363,
-0.0425547659,
-0.0039845333,
-0.0255849846,
-0.0379781649,
-0.047298003,
0.0270463843,
0.0321528018,
-0.0058548776,
0.0089732883,
0.0132902693,
-0.0352814384,
0.0567564406,
-0.0329038724,
-0.0346240997,
-0.0102900714,
-0.0032042942,
0.0082197264,
-0.013594171,
-0.0311062746,
0.0237995628,
-0.0028922861,
0.0351849906,
-0.0012214016,
0.0413447246,
0.0070049255,
0.0259068888,
-0.0186044872,
-0.0086489804,
-0.0364155956,
-0.0339324474,
-0.0675477087,
-0.0417262055,
0.0377602279,
-0.0172827616,
0.0735223442,
-0.0187205542,
-0.0004247126,
-0.0272307154,
0.0284864604,
0.031963177,
-0.023125289,
-0.0004574893,
0.0154869445,
-0.0152642857,
0.0276112594,
0.0900794715,
-0.0085228859,
0.0505714752,
-0.0346881896,
0.0017288292,
-0.0502015948,
-0.0508570261,
0.0067051728,
0.0423009321,
-0.0255703386,
0.0042249556,
-0.0201816503,
-0.0910990164,
-0.013783575,
0.0153293395,
-0.016835155,
-0.0194226876,
0.0723161995,
0.0638313517,
-0.0230254475,
-0.0171885956,
-0.0517974794,
0.0250872727,
-0.0345374309,
-0.0116723804,
-0.0437675752,
-6.982245426e-33,
-0.0454807505,
-0.0508625284,
0.025185585,
-0.059393473,
0.0172930136,
0.0012716016,
-0.0574607328,
0.0065413699,
-0.0201117676,
0.0248537231,
-0.0102717783,
0.0168205779,
0.0183148533,
0.0357683823,
-0.016941471,
0.040866904,
0.0603219531,
0.0006368827,
-0.0201058239,
0.0363118947,
0.0320379846,
0.0215368401,
0.0175605305,
-0.0789261833,
0.0122139435,
-0.0135200461,
-0.0454295725,
0.0404131413,
-0.0002505129,
0.0497613661,
-0.0012745381,
0.056236349,
-0.0124358991,
-0.0237546768,
-0.0289852675,
0.0024012153,
-0.0899800956,
-0.0132915815,
0.0102187907,
-0.0497914255,
-0.0450864732,
-0.0170119442,
0.0558257997,
-0.0152571481,
-0.0113023045,
0.0147780282,
0.0431334712,
-0.0145275919,
-0.0254422482,
-0.0402009785,
-0.0488273762,
0.0245047733,
-0.0063368152,
-0.0541576557,
0.0000606202,
0.0474381261,
-0.0009158985,
-0.0081600212,
-0.0520428903,
0.0246250164,
0.009881326,
0.0631834269,
0.0576063432,
0.0127844252,
-0.0271046199,
0.0443396978,
-0.0165188033,
-0.0351531766,
-0.0194663126,
-0.0108435852,
0.0390885584,
0.0477622487,
0.027685225,
0.0564828888,
0.0159354303,
-0.0060761473,
-0.0595542826,
0.0777571574,
-0.0227462277,
0.0567404069,
0.026233241,
-0.004767389,
-0.0218803007,
-0.0209593531,
-0.0371891186,
-0.0154660111,
-0.0297957677,
-0.0289627779,
0.0197634809,
0.0457348265,
-0.0406040922,
-0.0585244969,
0.0187002942,
-0.0140801845,
0.0353107899,
0.0199620165,
-0.0334794521,
-0.0276359208,
-0.0186052099,
0.0073418799,
-0.045963753,
-0.0252376441,
0.0394824445,
0.0377562717,
-0.0408295356,
0.020342486,
0.0029488979,
0.0175386313,
-0.0295421556,
0.0311927088,
-0.0515400171,
0.0516287871,
-0.006312863,
0.0003786122,
0.0208213739,
0.0056961342,
-0.0332607627,
0.0183662288,
-0.0065340125,
0.0363222696,
-0.0138523448,
-0.0373615623,
0.0237076189,
0.0115709221,
-0.039265167,
0.0073796595,
-0.0160909593,
-0.0036952565,
0.0259790886,
-0.0157177597,
-0.006840819,
0.0318923853,
2.854e-7,
0.0255859401,
0.0345940515,
0.0444547459,
0.0160014126,
-0.02301961,
0.0291689876,
0.0166101456,
-0.0179994758,
0.0311354622,
-0.0551238135,
0.0125355003,
0.0306288227,
0.055369474,
0.0317355655,
-0.0801673681,
0.0122575583,
-0.0699723065,
-0.0077775531,
-0.0202204566,
-0.0055236854,
0.0321677588,
0.0575093552,
-0.0035730435,
-0.0239659697,
-0.0005831132,
-0.0340067185,
0.0609711111,
0.00887811,
-0.0474911071,
0.033839833,
0.0753524601,
0.0158784613,
0.0010960948,
-0.0274884105,
-0.0385597982,
0.0208612941,
-0.0072900988,
0.0608032085,
-0.0108247427,
-0.0686502159,
-0.0103895543,
0.0105607975,
0.0196736883,
-0.0567906722,
0.0505237952,
-0.0021695106,
0.0000529881,
-0.0125592155,
-0.049557101,
0.0079226214,
-0.0081948536,
-0.0287981275,
-0.0424431935,
0.0070000668,
0.007392847,
0.0331493877,
-0.0228398237,
-0.0591640733,
-0.0561341345,
0.0041705617,
-0.0567448065,
-0.03621592,
-0.0112722041,
-0.0131016672,
-0.0087201046,
-0.0429477356,
0.0272001792,
2.730893093e-34,
0.0494017228,
0.0247246288,
-0.0084788427,
0.0243147817,
0.0291655064,
0.0123738665,
-0.0484661609,
0.0181629471,
0.0159678757,
-0.0634694099,
-0.0301420204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13626v1 | Fine-Tuning Gemma-7B for Enhanced Sentiment Analysis of Financial News Headlines | 2024-06-19T15:20:19 | 2024-06-19T15:20:19 | Kangtong Mo, Wenyan Liu, Xuanzhen Xu, Chang Yu, Yuelin Zou, Fangqing Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we explore the application of sentiment analysis on financial
news headlines to understand investor sentiment. By leveraging Natural Language
Processing (NLP) and Large Language Models (LLM), we analyze sentiment from the
perspective of retail investors. The FinancialPhraseBank dataset, which
contains categorized sentiments of financial news headlines, serves as the
basis for our analysis. We fine-tuned several models, including
distilbert-base-uncased, Llama, and gemma-7b, to evaluate their effectiveness
in sentiment classification. Our experiments demonstrate that the fine-tuned
gemma-7b model outperforms others, achieving the highest precision, recall, and
F1 score. Specifically, the gemma-7b model showed significant improvements in
accuracy after fine-tuning, indicating its robustness in capturing the nuances
of financial sentiment. This model can be instrumental in providing market
insights, risk management, and aiding investment decisions by accurately
predicting the sentiment of financial news. The results highlight the potential
of advanced LLMs in transforming how we analyze and interpret financial
information, offering a powerful tool for stakeholders in the financial
industry. | [
0.0443321876,
0.0774765983,
0.0135458233,
0.0221188478,
-0.0181809217,
-0.0025868723,
0.0005888994,
0.0399025492,
0.0204759743,
-0.0984758884,
-0.0246309191,
-0.0067592291,
-0.0447524041,
0.0401055627,
-0.0108542116,
-0.0105936462,
0.0164540801,
0.0220791176,
0.0731091574,
0.003478582,
0.0190074649,
0.0303056985,
0.0348440371,
0.0109311575,
-0.0099658817,
-0.0203889608,
0.0224768408,
0.0139805768,
-0.0016931555,
-0.024783792,
0.0136055946,
0.0270361397,
0.0136793647,
0.0015000238,
0.0000017848,
-0.0525712594,
-0.0096337125,
-0.0040654852,
0.0248096529,
0.0223714616,
0.0849002153,
-0.0660180449,
0.032971561,
0.014728413,
-0.0713535547,
-0.0187393185,
0.0255165249,
0.1031735837,
0.070695892,
0.062650837,
-0.028122792,
-0.0747661963,
0.005759174,
-0.0385015085,
-0.0050810501,
-0.055020716,
0.0381495319,
0.0144686038,
-0.0296541061,
0.019645093,
0.0139561072,
0.0087681077,
-0.0491450243,
0.0081286784,
0.0094872005,
-0.0130467061,
-0.0248654541,
-0.0195973348,
-0.0350176655,
0.0076819919,
0.0138855809,
0.0290186759,
0.0013034607,
-0.019110404,
-0.0063259611,
0.0085059842,
-0.0283662137,
0.0306482185,
-0.0122549403,
0.0429820903,
0.0161886606,
0.0203186218,
0.0137810064,
0.0334262103,
-0.010862899,
0.0244885404,
-0.0257718712,
-0.0138167869,
0.0351844467,
0.0373943746,
-0.0267262626,
-0.0179044958,
0.0106852641,
-0.0067664594,
0.0453874245,
0.0116260992,
0.0169815458,
0.0157385301,
0.0199937131,
-0.1441666931,
-0.006405747,
0.0067235804,
-0.0000558346,
0.0611765981,
-0.0476843044,
0.0000699524,
0.0324190408,
-0.0386960693,
0.0193597581,
0.0215773657,
-0.057956297,
0.0155117204,
0.01566438,
0.0864965692,
-0.0386128388,
-0.0445347615,
-0.0853730589,
-0.0086241998,
0.0168362539,
0.021798186,
0.0321436934,
0.0008004433,
0.042107448,
-0.0061324937,
-0.0341569185,
0.0046313261,
-0.034080334,
0.0357078686,
-0.0476054735,
-0.028666744,
0.0213127043,
0.0077862847,
-0.023727851,
0.0043061916,
0.0240513254,
0.0763688982,
0.0507844836,
-0.0689658448,
-0.0606252514,
-0.0316518061,
-0.0041227536,
-0.0408434533,
-0.0266806856,
-0.0042992351,
-0.0171746649,
0.0061884397,
-0.0009044879,
-0.0045836191,
0.0270808339,
0.0000737967,
-0.0406329893,
0.0669709519,
0.0094841057,
-0.0381515101,
0.0143019939,
-0.0341503061,
0.0375194587,
0.0562220737,
-0.0075958399,
0.0257622283,
0.0445189029,
-0.0096029649,
0.0004723293,
0.0071815378,
-0.0121204518,
-0.0610154867,
-0.0098858504,
0.0285497867,
-0.0348486491,
-0.0052293562,
0.053667184,
0.024950847,
0.006059492,
-0.01654521,
0.0468043163,
0.0384109318,
0.024311075,
0.0667484999,
-0.0516673103,
0.0191503353,
0.0287878308,
-0.0571383387,
-0.0157141332,
-0.0185755845,
-0.048432339,
0.0173657611,
-0.0074271229,
0.0209619328,
-0.0225244612,
-0.053596843,
-0.026128741,
-0.0266685672,
0.0263961256,
-0.0181655008,
0.0320049636,
-0.0634829402,
-0.0707984045,
0.0425286591,
0.0629175454,
-0.0473754629,
-0.0172522794,
-0.0305204447,
0.0456959419,
0.0876308233,
0.0035010681,
-0.0003105937,
0.0141789997,
-0.0221531354,
-0.034674108,
0.032053031,
0.0092474623,
0.0374883115,
-0.0562267937,
-0.0562479869,
0.0198670831,
-0.0043681883,
0.0405831337,
0.0064261984,
-0.0197301377,
0.0168446638,
-0.0070307874,
0.0351485983,
-0.0171971172,
0.0289870724,
0.0600367449,
-0.0404636599,
0.00087531,
-0.0564533211,
0.0077441796,
0.0319920219,
-0.0059347316,
-0.0034252477,
0.0161751248,
-0.0042178845,
-0.0549472012,
-0.0152758136,
-0.0253255237,
-0.0102399802,
-0.009149584,
-0.0003099706,
0.024158027,
0.0258387998,
-0.0263972636,
0.0122504616,
0.0047582686,
-0.0108151278,
0.0202986524,
-0.0721751973,
-0.0242369454,
-0.0168832336,
0.0207557939,
-0.0182399265,
0.0746268928,
-0.0234293826,
0.0033079365,
-0.0732483789,
-0.0321326777,
0.0016148688,
0.0067910799,
-0.0149423536,
0.022223698,
0.0195775293,
0.0654564276,
0.0386764035,
-0.0118218511,
0.0052559911,
-0.0696184486,
-0.0959919095,
-0.0233527273,
0.0126147894,
0.0296777878,
-0.0014691561,
0.0060857614,
-0.0283977203,
0.0172662977,
-0.0159131512,
-0.0374629572,
-0.0017438324,
0.0010383916,
0.0442700461,
0.0052980836,
0.0071157734,
-0.051847361,
0.0062443749,
-0.0068168398,
0.0378750153,
0.0641567409,
-0.0242639799,
-0.0133284833,
0.0116217695,
-0.0181546584,
0.0003470658,
-0.0003735653,
0.006495514,
-0.0199865811,
-0.0054388633,
-0.0343970135,
0.0622003935,
0.026527008,
0.06454923,
-0.0508877635,
0.0087420121,
-0.0277181212,
0.0105303172,
-0.0340122804,
-0.0081046941,
-0.0355949625,
-0.007760311,
-0.0099280216,
0.0544822961,
-0.0199271571,
-0.0128403548,
-0.0716286674,
0.015102081,
-0.0174356885,
0.0450413004,
-0.0136360684,
-0.0162665155,
0.0093823709,
0.0210360941,
0.0283533465,
-0.0466746651,
0.0410968922,
-0.0048310431,
-0.0078860363,
-0.05891091,
-0.0351764485,
-0.0963386297,
0.0145110767,
-0.0437957793,
-0.0065688421,
-0.0219983775,
-0.0130061023,
0.0333988965,
-0.0601175465,
-0.0090827225,
-0.0341002755,
0.035034325,
-0.0154819824,
0.0346766636,
0.0071268263,
-0.0003901458,
0.0187301673,
-0.0697068274,
-0.0736176521,
0.008364113,
0.0782047063,
-0.0366315655,
-0.0374084897,
0.0233957078,
-0.0413541719,
-0.0669194534,
-0.0286073275,
-0.0278040469,
0.0343153998,
0.0218605641,
0.0506232269,
-0.0210126434,
0.042430792,
-0.008173245,
0.0058390321,
0.0262365323,
0.0026149743,
0.0234258957,
-0.0420385003,
-0.0052842246,
-0.003129551,
-0.0250419155,
-0.0163324643,
-0.0117860548,
-0.0106322858,
-0.0197305847,
0.0196730457,
0.1150833815,
0.0132675087,
-0.0115024578,
-0.0104683917,
0.0188555028,
0.0082581136,
0.0060426374,
0.0219418891,
-0.0331019461,
-0.0444387905,
-0.040767666,
0.0128758727,
0.0235892516,
-0.0444940999,
-0.0004136115,
-0.1190409362,
0.0366859324,
-0.0130452979,
-0.0016578861,
-0.0294535104,
-0.0358416252,
-0.020494977,
-0.0444727913,
0.0223854333,
-0.0202972274,
-0.0436263643,
0.0332354642,
0.0097555704,
-0.0946818739,
-0.0187771209,
0.0286798179,
-0.0068951743,
-0.0259780809,
0.0270322636,
0.0202949923,
-0.0364035219,
0.0071971281,
-0.0141782146,
-0.0391974486,
0.0250796694,
-0.0094039273,
0.0587307997,
-0.0520838238,
-0.0278300103,
-0.0017552775,
0.0090532592,
-0.0532398932,
0.0579525046,
-0.020258503,
-0.0217889808,
-0.0263611097,
-0.0486776121,
-0.020313371,
0.0673063248,
0.0061720926,
0.0671269596,
0.0012801157,
-0.0490976088,
-0.0422108769,
-0.0231141932,
0.0053591179,
-0.0227438733,
-0.0222161002,
-0.0160637796,
0.0063393777,
-0.012730957,
-0.0949600041,
-0.0653466359,
0.0050257863,
0.0133143542,
-0.0222553127,
0.0226619802,
0.0408715494,
0.0113665275,
-0.0351327881,
0.0516151935,
0.0206265226,
-0.0032340814,
-0.0153633375,
0.0333582722,
0.0852346048,
0.0250384901,
-0.0503952429,
0.0326305665,
-0.0585149936,
-0.034477476,
-0.0098157041,
0.0132924877,
0.0224833731,
-0.0468576662,
0.0080326824,
0.0036680244,
0.0334943719,
0.0626746491,
-0.059396334,
0.006924348,
0.047985442,
0.0685103014,
0.0048773806,
0.0086618699,
-0.0091202874,
0.0196201392,
-0.0249867421,
0.0128983483,
-0.0268207844,
-0.0002856395,
-0.0182284676,
-0.0085669206,
0.0548158549,
0.035493236,
-0.0258857701,
-0.0069684098,
-0.0263592731,
0.0175648779,
0.0200100429,
-0.0357048027,
-0.0419596881,
0.0011515048,
-0.0137818018,
-0.0775602832,
0.0404601395,
-0.0380542502,
0.0041169012,
-0.0100102611,
0.0520508438,
0.0158648845,
0.00349093,
-0.0095236711,
0.0022315113,
-0.0080667734,
-0.0439392217,
0.0266786832,
-0.0311521143,
0.0089415256,
-0.0100193685,
0.023937067,
0.0245026518,
-0.0250933971,
-0.0116407266,
-0.0255480669,
-0.0138351899,
-0.0020476151,
0.0412224568,
0.0141889593,
-0.0085385395,
0.0135883512,
-0.0370647721,
0.0221357793,
0.0168363415,
0.0309281722,
-0.016100185,
-0.0178128835,
0.0316866972,
-0.0109908842,
-0.0499368832,
-0.0234410465,
0.0673160627,
-0.0101513425,
0.057403516,
0.0038277109,
-0.0079621868,
-0.0524019115,
-0.0543215312,
0.0904094577,
0.0089697335,
0.0177837051,
0.0036187703,
-0.0496615469,
-0.0370143428,
0.0821715742,
-0.0343069248,
0.0106957061,
-0.0190003961,
0.036390271,
0.0582816787,
0.0106183169,
0.0408051237,
-0.0367821455,
-0.01878535,
-0.0462221503,
-0.0178531073,
-0.0715982616,
-6.075752304e-33,
0.002970577,
0.0087157479,
-0.0062777451,
0.0316339843,
0.0108076138,
0.0093404036,
-0.0102185905,
0.0170483608,
-0.01081408,
0.0283798445,
0.0209816266,
0.0475451536,
-0.0018191964,
0.0156901293,
0.0356534012,
-0.0206797123,
0.0148234265,
-0.0268095639,
0.0176739376,
-0.0100988382,
0.0044134408,
0.0590273067,
0.062499132,
-0.069797866,
0.0398783535,
-0.0119205425,
-0.0643743798,
-0.030592557,
0.0509946384,
0.0291275661,
-0.008824965,
0.0764738843,
0.028399881,
-0.0379453972,
0.0076058349,
0.0362376571,
0.0376942866,
-0.0353481509,
0.02009115,
0.0143786836,
0.0225074328,
0.0081754802,
0.0409164354,
0.012394404,
-0.0432094559,
0.0368227214,
0.0260129888,
-0.0065523428,
-0.0150292842,
-0.073507078,
-0.0434017144,
0.027473744,
-0.0091877943,
0.039588768,
0.0176380239,
0.0337665118,
0.0031404092,
0.0513857864,
-0.0132764978,
0.012212025,
-0.0000775782,
-0.0000231263,
-0.0151676973,
-0.0200100504,
-0.0159652214,
0.0737793222,
-0.0067026871,
-0.0319821984,
-0.0089413365,
0.0616811216,
0.0328552127,
0.0389209986,
0.0386100151,
0.0417231582,
0.0000486083,
-0.0118750809,
-0.0529280007,
0.0237788409,
0.0089514637,
0.0319872983,
0.0635824054,
0.013660769,
-0.0459763221,
-0.0342774093,
0.0091392994,
0.001896286,
-0.0234109424,
-0.0138535742,
-0.011237232,
0.0011110548,
-0.019972641,
0.0340607688,
-0.0014194931,
-0.0517283008,
-0.0832566097,
0.0373310186,
-0.0135407615,
0.0358418524,
-0.0050039124,
-0.0134185031,
-0.0264928043,
-0.0336867236,
-0.023105789,
-0.0013521794,
-0.0203383211,
-0.0496365204,
0.0154808359,
0.023535898,
-0.0631962717,
-0.0272155888,
0.0298907887,
0.027140433,
0.0145267462,
0.0367711484,
-0.0200407375,
0.0117649743,
0.0066004158,
0.0299813263,
-0.0065633897,
0.0713061467,
0.0152508346,
0.0010373762,
0.012677975,
0.0360543653,
0.014176121,
-0.0174716916,
0.0422495902,
0.0350481011,
-0.0040771128,
-0.0279622246,
-0.0063212537,
0.0219766516,
2.542e-7,
0.0774299055,
0.124773562,
-0.0456390232,
-0.0120245935,
-0.0021125281,
0.0536165684,
-0.0016709459,
0.0375250652,
0.0098197637,
-0.0121127432,
0.0233207904,
0.018285865,
0.020765489,
0.0120521337,
-0.069923833,
-0.0230447408,
-0.0449441485,
0.0383454375,
-0.0585235432,
0.0594441444,
0.0552727841,
0.0997859985,
0.0143636176,
-0.0285840444,
-0.0233433153,
-0.0402974226,
0.0598046035,
-0.0842045024,
-0.0252821837,
0.0173961744,
0.0001330072,
0.0305691212,
-0.0050953571,
-0.0108992504,
0.007706238,
0.0190669708,
0.0167847369,
0.0224582683,
-0.00220534,
0.0106608551,
0.0308212936,
0.0258100778,
-0.0223957077,
-0.0216860659,
0.0362971276,
-0.0868748128,
-0.0420487188,
-0.0892832056,
-0.0322745368,
-0.0144250114,
0.0700531974,
-0.004110341,
-0.0142506454,
0.0262172092,
0.0098222634,
-0.0367366076,
-0.0073782103,
-0.0689037517,
-0.0011676706,
0.0407692157,
-0.0505107529,
0.0362315625,
-0.0080057392,
0.0396524929,
0.0359411128,
-0.0296842698,
0.0449658632,
2.01576136e-34,
0.0664236471,
-0.0300284177,
-0.0377657935,
0.052978728,
0.0690227672,
0.0268350318,
-0.0606359355,
0.0490243025,
-0.0064866925,
-0.0858758092,
0.0447708592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13621v1 | Improving Visual Commonsense in Language Models via Multiple Image Generation | 2024-06-19T15:17:10 | 2024-06-19T15:17:10 | Guy Yariv, Idan Schwartz, Yossi Adi, Sagie Benaim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Commonsense reasoning is fundamentally based on multimodal knowledge.
However, existing large language models (LLMs) are primarily trained using
textual data only, limiting their ability to incorporate essential visual
information. In contrast, Visual Language Models, which excel at
visually-oriented tasks, often fail at non-visual tasks such as basic
commonsense reasoning. This divergence highlights a critical challenge - the
integration of robust visual understanding with foundational text-based
language reasoning. To this end, we introduce a method aimed at enhancing LLMs'
visual commonsense. Specifically, our method generates multiple images based on
the input text prompt and integrates these into the model's decision-making
process by mixing their prediction probabilities. To facilitate multimodal
grounded language modeling, we employ a late-fusion layer that combines the
projected visual features with the output of a pre-trained LLM conditioned on
text only. This late-fusion layer enables predictions based on comprehensive
image-text knowledge as well as text only when this is required. We evaluate
our approach using several visual commonsense reasoning tasks together with
traditional NLP tasks, including common sense reasoning and reading
comprehension. Our experimental results demonstrate significant superiority
over existing baselines. When applied to recent state-of-the-art LLMs (e.g.,
Llama3), we observe improvements not only in visual common sense but also in
traditional NLP benchmarks. Code and models are available under
https://github.com/guyyariv/vLMIG. | [
0.0382182375,
0.038953945,
-0.0066092159,
0.0498199128,
-0.0178612974,
0.0039799353,
0.0067029791,
-0.0058732787,
0.0392519012,
-0.0644391477,
-0.0180666242,
0.0174436513,
0.0256537143,
0.0278682001,
0.0458409674,
-0.0596861094,
0.0141795138,
-0.0278328005,
-0.0199606456,
0.0017523217,
0.0373487324,
0.0483945832,
-0.0098680528,
0.0501767956,
-0.033841949,
-0.023797214,
0.0141052743,
0.0008170073,
0.029795818,
-0.0156811792,
-0.0305687636,
0.0395118482,
0.0588185042,
-0.0103562037,
0.0000018431,
0.0025520101,
0.0344864242,
-0.0334591642,
0.0443969257,
-0.0008715196,
0.0251224469,
-0.0377561562,
0.0383786969,
-0.0094308434,
-0.0563579202,
0.0338295512,
0.0358307809,
0.0576021597,
0.0826557204,
-0.0104412315,
-0.0187445823,
-0.0183925014,
0.0052552293,
-0.0022369437,
0.0220238548,
-0.0352587141,
-0.0238871537,
0.0517385937,
0.0000782026,
-0.0076907491,
-0.0422017463,
0.057293199,
0.0396743417,
-0.0469459109,
-0.0002340616,
0.0701928362,
-0.0059995456,
-0.03593155,
-0.051978346,
0.1037971303,
-0.0191914663,
-0.0223756712,
-0.0436923467,
-0.0068315361,
0.0106157688,
0.005139194,
-0.0260410495,
0.0330528915,
-0.000363239,
0.0380530804,
-0.0163173825,
-0.0079705417,
0.003473399,
0.0484599732,
0.0118723344,
0.0026286487,
0.0059810178,
0.0326738097,
0.0047072037,
0.0394028574,
-0.0606818572,
-0.0222850963,
0.0057147122,
0.0551514253,
-0.0056583374,
0.024310587,
-0.0375873931,
-0.0227648281,
0.0096981032,
-0.0507362448,
0.0523773581,
0.0362193175,
-0.0721465424,
0.0826572701,
-0.0427262336,
0.0392436795,
-0.0108320992,
0.0574364066,
-0.0044159121,
-0.0049393871,
-0.0284426324,
-0.0246210061,
-0.0191703737,
-0.0111153536,
-0.0728508681,
-0.0577387959,
-0.0248435885,
-0.0045882794,
-0.0080652907,
0.0061790445,
0.0240666792,
0.0503324121,
-0.0315964893,
-0.0280761085,
-0.052604977,
0.0475034714,
-0.0257324371,
0.0496546812,
0.0017921893,
-0.0291808601,
-0.0009221747,
0.0319748968,
0.0035324302,
-0.0238980185,
-0.0005445602,
0.0307864491,
-0.0765140355,
-0.0248664767,
-0.0468628556,
-0.0325739682,
-0.0257572345,
-0.0330309384,
0.0248973165,
-0.0513236783,
0.0121912565,
-0.0147599205,
-0.0030536896,
-0.0087415883,
0.0074177384,
0.0081616882,
-0.0068467529,
0.1133929342,
-0.0184517354,
-0.014791904,
0.0186559539,
0.0363545194,
0.0185571145,
0.0691505745,
0.0067957835,
0.0116489055,
0.0333098881,
0.0159213413,
-0.0039446838,
0.0304505341,
0.001999137,
-0.0079963431,
-0.0418466628,
-0.0145479571,
-0.0414250381,
0.0202013105,
0.0642779395,
0.0260899607,
-0.0386457928,
-0.0066712229,
0.0816006064,
0.0570582226,
-0.0086863367,
-0.0018612953,
0.0133463955,
0.0027235528,
0.0026842614,
0.0027772496,
-0.0620388873,
0.0780552551,
-0.023646988,
-0.002067076,
-0.0178237911,
0.0503419042,
-0.0121262399,
-0.0101377834,
0.004034902,
-0.0088969693,
0.0215163548,
-0.0078690741,
0.0144454278,
0.0344206765,
-0.0433721393,
0.0513277166,
0.0255127549,
-0.0647142604,
0.0012789482,
-0.0164644178,
0.0381307304,
0.0559387766,
0.04671482,
0.0280339383,
-0.0074053332,
0.0251915678,
0.0235663112,
0.0746746436,
-0.0107222404,
0.0013314076,
0.0383751206,
-0.0688562319,
-0.0387679227,
-0.0034296259,
-0.0092176795,
0.0037232181,
0.0059286575,
-0.0112291388,
0.0091166096,
-0.0308181886,
0.0261770952,
0.0319123566,
0.019190928,
0.0068067107,
-0.0547831394,
0.0173267107,
0.0116041983,
-0.0150377285,
0.0101957805,
-0.0079221902,
-0.0042214165,
-0.0457739942,
-0.0008497664,
0.0457237512,
-0.0502954572,
-0.0786687136,
0.0472263061,
-0.0616299361,
-0.037039768,
0.0111641074,
-0.0410800949,
-0.0180945899,
-0.0006722797,
-0.0115291774,
-0.00347508,
-0.0816292316,
-0.0311853606,
0.0287063997,
0.017302962,
-0.0180312563,
0.0745512694,
-0.0493467227,
-0.0346280001,
0.0118258493,
0.0031599659,
-0.0005624236,
0.0003950274,
-0.0034588091,
0.0007404267,
0.0082081072,
0.0290327258,
-0.0145615414,
0.0550215133,
-0.0422991104,
-0.0094445786,
-0.0954013616,
-0.0417150371,
-0.0077276197,
-0.048487898,
-0.0105193872,
-0.0304649547,
0.0174590033,
-0.0317225717,
-0.0271995459,
0.0378643051,
0.0187811907,
0.0054186,
0.038925264,
-0.0025419956,
0.0307232775,
-0.0201030336,
0.0089469068,
0.0202577133,
0.0605837367,
0.0259046555,
0.0295153819,
-0.0123362318,
-0.0079890741,
-0.0472297631,
0.0325653553,
-0.0134737752,
-0.0439325385,
0.0314957686,
-0.0292736012,
0.0434967428,
0.048447676,
0.0090756407,
0.040293809,
0.0312870853,
-0.0152769051,
-0.0320530944,
0.0100399395,
0.0081679393,
0.0224069115,
-0.0073169256,
0.0009212071,
-0.0614783876,
0.0132976165,
0.0016081121,
0.012821923,
-0.0799715221,
0.0268332195,
0.0157262143,
-0.0497689173,
-0.0727137774,
0.0209474824,
0.0095758894,
0.0402979031,
-0.0637832284,
-0.0691507086,
0.0696260631,
-0.0561701618,
-0.0058021522,
-0.0025572774,
0.0063299271,
-0.019239964,
0.0827570781,
-0.010473948,
0.0123728793,
-0.0477662943,
0.001078064,
-0.0622602999,
-0.0349255614,
0.0308186058,
-0.0072478461,
0.0788864195,
-0.0727671757,
0.0094515467,
-0.0235767271,
-0.0372578539,
-0.0224379357,
-0.0370917358,
-0.0453661159,
-0.0164146312,
-0.0430964231,
-0.009010097,
-0.012548103,
0.0025163074,
0.0359978974,
0.0255416967,
0.0064531062,
-0.016127795,
-0.0194782428,
0.0491381548,
0.0470898263,
0.0562179945,
-0.0219513346,
-0.0240538456,
0.0024738738,
0.0554864369,
0.018567048,
-0.0374921262,
-0.0402057208,
0.0561410934,
0.0262410175,
0.0645994172,
0.0032030384,
0.042767629,
0.0615732558,
-0.0497100428,
-0.0007385593,
0.0574051738,
0.0167509429,
0.0010127861,
-0.0271049179,
-0.010771594,
0.0461465716,
0.0176531207,
0.0064344043,
-0.0514286533,
-0.0785286799,
-0.0127029978,
-0.022796955,
0.0190952905,
-0.019415034,
-0.0216191951,
-0.0905162469,
0.0383215994,
-0.0070592389,
-0.0217839647,
-0.0467907488,
0.0028961385,
-0.0172320604,
0.0208858587,
-0.0018138079,
-0.0071143536,
0.0113680977,
0.0012133229,
-0.0027527879,
0.048582565,
-0.0415435135,
0.0150899785,
-0.0340624899,
-0.0058300262,
0.0447686426,
0.0502187312,
0.0045447568,
-0.1171361506,
0.0090612425,
-0.0298830178,
0.0360810906,
-0.0273527987,
0.035219904,
-0.0036792152,
-0.0349554792,
-0.008638327,
0.0494976528,
-0.0179308094,
-0.0495482795,
-0.0360423774,
0.0558447689,
-0.0303253084,
-0.0189617928,
-0.0416166782,
0.0398671702,
0.0088220574,
0.0517805256,
0.0479857251,
-0.0100125335,
-0.0426388085,
-0.0142430766,
-0.0116110733,
-0.062487416,
-0.030071523,
-0.000793233,
0.0273306947,
-0.0000446795,
-0.0525124483,
-0.0040939166,
0.0457050614,
0.0638881922,
0.0020148668,
-0.0032065203,
-0.0121898064,
0.0178528354,
-0.0288761705,
0.0686301291,
-0.0270380396,
0.0210848488,
-0.0123007381,
0.0438754335,
0.0132215852,
-0.0451638438,
-0.0416657701,
0.0401750132,
-0.0476992205,
-0.0457628779,
-0.0506834053,
0.0719768032,
0.0169161763,
0.0053420952,
0.0053315456,
-0.0592032224,
0.0392097868,
0.0551660061,
0.0164198298,
0.0116142575,
0.0041204593,
-0.0240739882,
0.0201284513,
0.0332841724,
-0.003929399,
-0.0008650412,
0.0030154197,
0.0304091927,
-0.0268205553,
-0.0181476027,
-0.0185301322,
0.0002517664,
0.030118024,
-0.0465650968,
0.0363378599,
-0.0501719043,
-0.0179598965,
0.0059321541,
-0.0221508518,
-0.066797331,
0.030640088,
0.0064410968,
-0.023540765,
-0.0069485465,
0.0152745731,
0.0070685055,
0.0634976476,
-0.0089955572,
-0.0119852973,
0.0536616966,
0.008044403,
-0.0092543866,
-0.0052690669,
-0.0087000802,
0.0008065042,
-0.058625266,
0.0112822633,
0.0100664161,
0.0967048705,
0.038916979,
-0.0564432777,
-0.0129842339,
0.0243376903,
-0.0230444986,
0.0005936613,
0.0053638741,
0.0710743368,
0.0469072834,
0.0099913497,
0.0271129664,
-0.0206204392,
-0.0249373298,
0.014930699,
0.0761402622,
0.0031356516,
-0.0573716909,
0.0879101381,
0.0037469072,
0.0077061709,
-0.0338307135,
0.0569019727,
-0.0323195457,
0.006470934,
-0.0060766633,
-0.0107477643,
-0.0407897271,
-0.041435644,
0.0245337095,
0.0161804724,
0.0177122373,
0.0652553365,
-0.0628518686,
-0.0572142154,
0.0197845865,
0.0450762324,
-0.0194829758,
0.0161827113,
0.0160787739,
0.0648938194,
0.0171554741,
-0.0229369886,
0.0036597031,
-0.0078059887,
-0.0445914306,
0.0210300852,
-0.010219356,
-6.087044764e-33,
-0.0429669991,
-0.069605723,
0.0451583974,
-0.0560580567,
-0.0039367238,
0.017453244,
-0.0476392992,
-0.0023214938,
-0.0087734982,
0.023667641,
0.0050500324,
0.0150182443,
0.0054587037,
0.041334942,
-0.0237810221,
0.0088317469,
0.0252882857,
0.0190009326,
-0.0103272339,
0.0000786044,
0.0451098196,
-0.0001657558,
0.0310505331,
-0.0067895656,
-0.018254675,
0.0267660022,
-0.0517057069,
0.0322341099,
-0.009603126,
0.063283965,
-0.0309541319,
0.0246834066,
0.0151891448,
0.014687812,
-0.0213284083,
0.0530643389,
-0.0658105537,
-0.0386676118,
0.0448321514,
0.0068983822,
-0.0773512721,
0.0107921762,
0.018463783,
-0.0091228159,
0.0247371551,
-0.0334215611,
0.0564609319,
-0.033884313,
-0.0142057883,
-0.0068412116,
-0.0207230467,
0.0087641571,
-0.0137059754,
-0.0272098333,
-0.005912506,
0.0225271359,
0.0193338934,
0.0496274419,
-0.0568058938,
0.0176110882,
-0.0108389752,
-0.0153520945,
0.0950876549,
0.0190029964,
0.0022478951,
0.0658710599,
-0.064496398,
-0.0453385636,
-0.0849315375,
-0.0036412459,
0.0281267222,
0.0757854357,
0.0639961511,
0.0739564896,
-0.0036969918,
0.0104226759,
-0.0371199511,
0.0312480833,
-0.0479275659,
0.0699717626,
0.0174815822,
-0.0019850146,
0.0171087347,
0.0042340653,
-0.0572603047,
-0.0348451585,
-0.0371729657,
0.0182822887,
0.0307672843,
0.013400631,
-0.0325262174,
0.0269730929,
0.0519669764,
-0.0076005491,
-0.0178989545,
0.046504423,
-0.0254189707,
0.0327163339,
-0.0038625489,
0.0249352306,
-0.0192015786,
-0.0160971005,
0.0714322701,
0.0003910001,
-0.0156738255,
0.0168355089,
0.0524612665,
-0.0024721147,
-0.0291302968,
-0.0071294652,
-0.0363972187,
0.0125111677,
-0.0114601916,
0.0298449975,
0.0209403094,
0.0040687616,
-0.0723170713,
-0.0109329624,
-0.0238255896,
-0.0096468003,
-0.0029319657,
-0.022556968,
-0.0051319548,
0.0275641736,
-0.0383515842,
0.0182736348,
-0.0535319112,
-0.0630402714,
0.0393360294,
-0.0532642305,
-0.0157388058,
0.0699444786,
2.407e-7,
0.0225315746,
-0.0029156886,
-0.0080803484,
0.0072066402,
-0.012549012,
0.0692726374,
-0.025671944,
0.0240092836,
-0.0077386633,
-0.073059164,
-0.0218500402,
0.0794773027,
0.0475664176,
0.0066446476,
0.0028752808,
0.0166962706,
-0.0363066718,
-0.0121594649,
-0.0415019728,
-0.0148174707,
0.0680456683,
0.0657095909,
-0.0021949771,
-0.0570696481,
0.0557009988,
-0.0588925481,
0.0715512633,
-0.0211737789,
0.0028034181,
-0.0481445119,
0.0430343486,
0.0088122291,
-0.015613934,
0.0138986632,
-0.0062780404,
-0.0248049777,
0.0255162753,
0.0406909958,
-0.008000236,
-0.0233887788,
-0.0318224505,
-0.0052191969,
-0.0226973966,
-0.048667483,
0.0749776438,
-0.0494897328,
-0.0099410852,
-0.0285577886,
-0.0153857796,
-0.01161406,
0.0349519886,
-0.0307173114,
-0.0370004848,
0.0185280759,
0.0206668526,
-0.0426835492,
-0.0311806519,
-0.0941978619,
-0.0375173241,
-0.0184758846,
-0.0208266769,
-0.0145221604,
-0.050356932,
-0.0309989881,
0.0581414998,
-0.0691328496,
-0.0481046624,
1.919878789e-34,
0.0058271666,
-0.0224984996,
0.0032789682,
-0.0022098839,
0.032853622,
0.004954183,
-0.0103674671,
-0.0090642311,
0.0142684598,
-0.060825929,
-0.0053564906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13618v1 | In-Context Former: Lightning-fast Compressing Context for Large Language Model | 2024-06-19T15:14:55 | 2024-06-19T15:14:55 | Xiangfeng Wang, Zaiyi Chen, Zheyong Xie, Tong Xu, Yongyi He, Enhong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rising popularity of Transformer-based large language models (LLMs),
reducing their high inference costs has become a significant research focus.
One effective approach is to compress the long input contexts. Existing methods
typically leverage the self-attention mechanism of the LLM itself for context
compression. While these methods have achieved notable results, the compression
process still involves quadratic time complexity, which limits their
applicability. To mitigate this limitation, we propose the In-Context Former
(IC-Former). Unlike previous methods, IC-Former does not depend on the target
LLMs. Instead, it leverages the cross-attention mechanism and a small number of
learnable digest tokens to directly condense information from the contextual
word embeddings. This approach significantly reduces inference time, which
achieves linear growth in time complexity within the compression range.
Experimental results indicate that our method requires only 1/32 of the
floating-point operations of the baseline during compression and improves
processing speed by 68 to 112 times while achieving over 90% of the baseline
performance on evaluation metrics. Overall, our model effectively reduces
compression costs and makes real-time compression scenarios feasible. | [
-0.0126699768,
0.0671007708,
0.010396488,
0.0606850497,
-0.0326750688,
0.0088295722,
0.0037943088,
0.0038906578,
-0.0425062031,
-0.0292551108,
-0.0431236587,
-0.0199163649,
0.0064623267,
-0.0042533642,
0.0332074389,
0.0047671092,
0.031924434,
-0.039441891,
-0.0518838018,
0.01289762,
-0.019334998,
0.0006722836,
0.0540772565,
0.0457083955,
-0.0055520721,
-0.040069662,
-0.0119806621,
0.0046209316,
-0.0082484074,
-0.0126096876,
-0.0122399013,
0.0535648316,
0.0518365055,
0.0343064293,
0.0000020891,
-0.0186287221,
-0.0242481921,
0.0078193909,
-0.0511237383,
0.0411064848,
0.056210801,
-0.0346494876,
-0.0107227564,
0.0239203144,
-0.0041674981,
-0.0326365642,
0.0320357159,
0.0418822095,
0.0316286162,
0.0529398173,
-0.0033725409,
-0.0406139493,
0.0084747653,
-0.0642849505,
-0.0186173841,
-0.0653813705,
0.0113044688,
-0.0254492424,
-0.0244689882,
0.0329987034,
-0.0386600941,
0.0497852415,
0.0571940616,
0.0116581023,
-0.0314773917,
0.0394770205,
-0.001432988,
0.0115649067,
-0.0072979438,
0.0416656286,
-0.0242186841,
-0.0397411659,
-0.0231285114,
0.0232510548,
0.0004532187,
-0.0426715426,
-0.0509792268,
0.0417536125,
0.009120998,
0.0398830064,
0.040962752,
0.0478325263,
0.036517106,
-0.0001133023,
-0.0640540645,
0.030707296,
0.0290574208,
-0.0114137568,
-0.0253080446,
0.0008015744,
-0.0147333071,
-0.0431506,
-0.0051845522,
0.0287281927,
-0.0092981188,
0.0038793054,
-0.0703433752,
-0.0165633429,
0.0108072599,
-0.0110751325,
0.0028359618,
0.037096072,
-0.0070179831,
0.0699710846,
-0.0357379653,
0.0300546736,
-0.0336805694,
-0.0191994142,
-0.0450456105,
-0.0386357196,
0.0281479545,
0.0197352152,
-0.0474880598,
0.0310159288,
-0.0452585965,
-0.034720093,
-0.0214307196,
0.0416176133,
0.0071653244,
-0.0172278341,
0.0290757362,
-0.0178167317,
-0.0309070125,
-0.0058731856,
0.0578049645,
0.0311126783,
-0.0283234268,
-0.0009831362,
-0.0057971119,
-0.0385764502,
-0.0447287224,
0.0351756737,
0.022746874,
-0.028552385,
-0.0085856915,
0.0360350385,
0.0116127627,
-0.048395738,
-0.0296144728,
0.0013891431,
-0.0167261437,
-0.0441698097,
-0.0201001558,
-0.074470073,
0.0325061306,
-0.0000543438,
0.0033005653,
-0.0235304572,
-0.0026535364,
0.0403808877,
-0.0299759619,
0.0679196194,
0.0336747095,
0.0036127784,
0.0045926417,
0.0136383008,
0.0223375559,
0.076109916,
0.0118212048,
0.0242221393,
0.0203624591,
-0.0232209358,
-0.0225977078,
0.0623321533,
0.0720923692,
0.025244467,
-0.0404451601,
-0.0031577332,
-0.0108102998,
0.0227470361,
0.0707128048,
0.0682542324,
-0.0416243039,
-0.0286434386,
0.0368462019,
0.0539537519,
0.0520453788,
0.0517188981,
0.0388887823,
0.0139458282,
-0.0334158577,
-0.0094587579,
-0.057480514,
0.0361273736,
-0.0290416442,
0.021998914,
0.0755910501,
0.0328531414,
-0.0345500931,
-0.0037294135,
-0.0143865384,
-0.0213266332,
0.0202233996,
0.0188622009,
0.0220445227,
0.0126427263,
-0.0517481901,
0.0822844729,
0.0345332623,
-0.0611279756,
-0.0290630478,
-0.0399311632,
0.0140101416,
0.022264136,
0.0425387584,
0.0031055335,
-0.0018418975,
-0.0119286831,
0.0211257972,
0.025591284,
0.0031801329,
0.0080799647,
0.0068553975,
-0.0428908281,
0.0009291904,
0.0068985312,
0.0036042742,
-0.0126412362,
0.0549873263,
0.0180373378,
0.031139439,
-0.0185088906,
0.0307016615,
0.0338656902,
-0.0533452556,
-0.0258415081,
-0.0031839069,
0.0087450603,
0.0304261036,
-0.0073017823,
0.0018546438,
0.0239618961,
0.0575072952,
-0.0708339363,
0.0033182199,
-0.0030145077,
-0.0886184946,
-0.0806491971,
0.0279065762,
-0.0042218012,
0.0077353022,
0.0190492067,
-0.0314947478,
-0.0152945807,
0.0065897545,
-0.0472327881,
0.0874091461,
-0.0436594673,
0.012936322,
0.0022147617,
0.0597383082,
-0.0208259113,
0.0530110821,
-0.0399497487,
0.0004290234,
0.0351316519,
0.0370102152,
-0.0305357259,
-0.0055783936,
-0.0335054286,
-0.0143661089,
-0.0164806396,
-0.0100467335,
0.0090853693,
-0.0026631479,
-0.0026212486,
-0.0248349439,
-0.1044006348,
0.0067089186,
-0.0245896801,
0.0183526687,
0.0146391336,
0.0356729589,
0.011791667,
0.0174653511,
-0.0159950703,
0.0045029502,
-0.02399108,
0.0200976934,
-0.0062938598,
-0.0173712242,
-0.0047521908,
-0.0379640236,
-0.0311931018,
0.0061954306,
0.1053661481,
-0.0444304198,
-0.0278520603,
-0.0506259054,
0.0537826866,
0.0383937322,
0.0195850674,
-0.0199604537,
-0.0272027124,
-0.0135868005,
-0.0305002108,
0.0536529608,
0.0667435601,
0.0299461596,
0.0426165313,
0.039737951,
-0.0156811923,
-0.0514709055,
0.0055958154,
-0.0042204075,
-0.0280179363,
-0.0218716301,
-0.0376318432,
-0.0103417486,
0.0923850238,
-0.0194947384,
-0.0025288104,
-0.0463988855,
-0.0398217849,
-0.0029946568,
-0.0167578477,
-0.0196698718,
0.0013175437,
-0.0291181002,
0.0025487689,
-0.0197565556,
-0.0291203465,
0.0504411422,
-0.0627501681,
0.0012786899,
0.0014754478,
-0.0071948459,
-0.0484943464,
0.0631123036,
-0.0107156495,
0.0230473634,
-0.0165996905,
-0.0214203596,
-0.0294925589,
0.0302563068,
-0.0348523818,
-0.0344241336,
0.0817462504,
-0.000059401,
0.0176658612,
-0.0342043713,
-0.0248395633,
-0.0212421883,
-0.0268059969,
-0.0094778091,
0.0264620464,
0.0398769267,
-0.0164070223,
-0.0353291519,
0.0384081751,
0.0180060994,
0.0802196637,
0.0151260188,
0.0100635951,
-0.009056407,
0.0246893633,
0.0338810049,
0.0174601134,
0.0360692777,
-0.0023172093,
0.0397490747,
0.0858712867,
0.0601437278,
0.0146870641,
-0.0337577462,
-0.0328481644,
0.0470923185,
0.0074643907,
-0.0015511913,
0.0091366088,
0.0286273602,
-0.0576105155,
-0.0269721132,
0.1224184334,
0.0183782559,
-0.076826714,
0.0066942903,
-0.0042093527,
0.0191006158,
0.0135777388,
0.0245948564,
-0.0641432479,
-0.0584600568,
0.0233720504,
-0.0056348369,
0.0286620166,
-0.0278139487,
-0.0048593781,
-0.1117892191,
0.0208003949,
0.0126326652,
-0.0521943606,
-0.0371580757,
-0.0443837792,
0.0146306269,
0.0129884342,
0.0293804351,
0.0255468376,
-0.02259399,
-0.0288130939,
-0.0132682668,
-0.0067840084,
-0.0296759978,
0.0288363341,
-0.0294042118,
0.0336853005,
0.0086472686,
0.0099652549,
0.023301715,
-0.0191352852,
0.0481628403,
-0.0447524786,
-0.0221024379,
-0.0242830738,
0.0052610496,
-0.040216431,
0.009565562,
0.0192043874,
0.0386355519,
-0.0491098762,
-0.0245056637,
-0.015115845,
0.0814361721,
0.0275245234,
0.0082112178,
-0.0261206832,
-0.0231743455,
-0.0079649501,
0.1062737405,
0.0580820814,
-0.0454934761,
-0.0141748739,
-0.011076075,
-0.0198537093,
0.0044859238,
-0.0434697233,
-0.0087528937,
0.0222248025,
-0.0548985377,
-0.0469306372,
-0.002899552,
0.0296144914,
0.045538567,
-0.0398846269,
0.0123634068,
-0.0060907933,
-0.0034072592,
-0.0926907435,
0.0173754431,
-0.0537046492,
0.0189059731,
-0.0745325163,
0.0524767712,
0.0347761847,
0.0041759089,
-0.0053999033,
0.063430436,
-0.1154676303,
-0.0331153832,
-0.0183228292,
0.0122251268,
0.0084148655,
0.0573088005,
-0.0202102158,
-0.0409781337,
0.050394062,
0.009019292,
-0.033057183,
0.0575368553,
0.013825506,
0.0070356699,
0.0304979663,
0.0656842813,
-0.0435863845,
0.0008781967,
0.0036287871,
0.0456721373,
-0.0386435911,
-0.0155482236,
-0.0009428904,
-0.0113548767,
0.0276137684,
-0.0237456299,
0.0130864168,
0.0089839958,
0.0348840468,
-0.0380719118,
-0.0095986947,
-0.0454745144,
0.008804257,
0.0115173059,
-0.0072809067,
0.0200701095,
0.0242203213,
0.0272558331,
-0.0083346218,
-0.0270657111,
0.0291800462,
-0.0142739639,
0.0063603497,
0.0370661765,
0.0066959583,
-0.0351148732,
-0.0783984214,
-0.0078000943,
0.0163987745,
-0.0719409585,
0.0287159234,
0.0065474524,
-0.0096653514,
-0.0416800939,
0.0415172838,
-0.0370654762,
0.0053268373,
-0.0252308138,
0.0266552363,
0.0188998841,
-0.0308096781,
0.0325076692,
-0.001644257,
-0.020783307,
-0.0254364293,
0.0257099606,
-0.0286071487,
-0.0448749363,
0.031850744,
0.020134408,
-0.0023510249,
0.0263031144,
0.0853567198,
0.0023217632,
0.0181278549,
-0.0035066616,
0.0024689217,
-0.0202232841,
-0.0162420273,
-0.0351778492,
0.0307699647,
-0.0101745082,
0.0102582406,
-0.0384710208,
-0.0745725259,
0.0044958754,
-0.0163550973,
-0.0406543612,
-0.0009321254,
0.0263149943,
0.0521636084,
0.0076323086,
-0.021994561,
-0.0119541055,
0.0454617552,
0.0251988173,
-0.0535879061,
-0.0140670612,
-6.469144346e-33,
-0.0384507552,
-0.0221671611,
0.0124796005,
-0.0487153344,
-0.0424340181,
0.0432270989,
-0.0423543975,
-0.0179671589,
-0.017113084,
-0.0241891108,
-0.035694059,
0.0197031703,
-0.0021385616,
0.056869898,
-0.0422448367,
-0.0034027484,
0.0482028946,
0.0081201205,
-0.0052399281,
0.0319730379,
0.0196638647,
0.0203164592,
0.0407610275,
-0.0403979272,
-0.0409634449,
0.0047850562,
0.0203732643,
0.0151161468,
0.0160340425,
0.0588227957,
-0.0435520783,
0.0108987689,
0.0186100118,
-0.0695125833,
-0.0031433892,
0.0674805641,
-0.0842439383,
0.0001026126,
0.0232820809,
-0.0183637235,
-0.0154242497,
-0.0587029234,
0.0401842073,
0.0132890986,
0.0090091471,
-0.037069343,
-0.0254777335,
-0.0079152286,
-0.0596496277,
-0.0298986807,
-0.0746241808,
0.0204417389,
0.0049831811,
0.0043136557,
0.0433923565,
0.0210346319,
-0.0064120735,
0.065030843,
-0.0600952171,
-0.0080429427,
-0.032970462,
0.0616040267,
0.0783315524,
0.0079371268,
0.0272641499,
0.0349405557,
-0.0104175936,
-0.0288803633,
-0.0617359392,
-0.0276956894,
0.0343144424,
0.0312708057,
0.0338948667,
0.0391694196,
0.0320306197,
-0.0098233316,
-0.0691943839,
-0.014309627,
0.007656177,
0.0520748273,
0.0507699326,
0.0260655899,
-0.0153982956,
-0.0153706027,
-0.0450395681,
-0.0158542003,
-0.0392069928,
0.0083401715,
0.0207529012,
0.0325160325,
-0.0264219828,
-0.0145961251,
0.062991865,
-0.0576477312,
-0.010554377,
0.0417363308,
0.0214292482,
0.0221699253,
-0.0046594087,
0.0500753187,
-0.0331286043,
0.0127040455,
0.0163972117,
-0.0248391517,
0.0044113477,
-0.0040313867,
0.0446769223,
0.0263769906,
-0.0737880915,
-0.0368944369,
-0.0484379455,
-0.0037720029,
-0.0324141756,
-0.0125318356,
0.0631281361,
0.0129385311,
0.0162290707,
0.0416222811,
0.0231602136,
-0.0055784043,
-0.0129432706,
-0.0231182165,
0.0309312847,
0.0279965959,
-0.0156257804,
-0.0063665798,
-0.0339488871,
0.0341321193,
0.0690489858,
-0.0543271229,
-0.0229314733,
0.0462724082,
2.713e-7,
0.043129351,
0.0327418596,
0.016397601,
-0.0168396346,
0.0344925746,
0.0177137684,
0.0368887112,
0.0267762393,
0.0039777686,
0.0043910244,
0.0035638195,
0.0195356868,
0.0460900776,
0.0123231495,
-0.0884656087,
-0.0076505174,
-0.0577759854,
-0.0016457208,
-0.0274755992,
-0.0110227112,
0.0060166712,
0.1499599516,
-0.0103984578,
-0.005799965,
0.0138952481,
-0.0118096834,
0.0447646007,
-0.055428315,
0.0011161263,
-0.0030877548,
-0.0208381284,
0.0113889547,
0.0050002625,
-0.0384173319,
-0.0036327115,
0.0302933306,
-0.0014221778,
0.0775270835,
0.0095076654,
-0.0459607951,
0.0027370807,
-0.0302543622,
-0.0316038616,
-0.0556450859,
0.0726660416,
-0.0505867898,
-0.0069814157,
-0.0693042204,
0.0008324439,
0.0126160979,
-0.0269619748,
0.0125190783,
0.0153055433,
0.0288795233,
0.0427868478,
-0.0167335868,
-0.0297507588,
-0.1096559316,
-0.0390112959,
-0.0083504533,
-0.0602756143,
-0.0111528486,
-0.0548912212,
-0.0343785137,
0.0502012745,
-0.0342950597,
-0.0034933372,
2.959889036e-34,
0.0259557832,
-0.0080167046,
0.0134140719,
0.0450728759,
0.0085720392,
-0.0219578836,
-0.0072703483,
0.0156394336,
-0.0031306222,
-0.1056784242,
-0.0225199852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13617v1 | Optimizing Psychological Counseling with Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T15:13:07 | 2024-06-19T15:13:07 | Wenjie Li, Tianyu Sun, Kun Qian, Wenhong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of large language models (LLMs) has significantly advanced various
fields, including natural language processing and automated dialogue systems.
This paper explores the application of LLMs in psychological counseling,
addressing the increasing demand for mental health services. We present a
method for instruction tuning LLMs with specialized prompts to enhance their
performance in providing empathetic, relevant, and supportive responses. Our
approach involves developing a comprehensive dataset of counseling-specific
prompts, refining them through feedback from professional counselors, and
conducting rigorous evaluations using both automatic metrics and human
assessments. The results demonstrate that our instruction-tuned model
outperforms several baseline LLMs, highlighting its potential as a scalable and
accessible tool for mental health support. | [
0.0930648074,
0.0257261824,
-0.0142500028,
0.0175985377,
-0.0461100042,
0.0305104963,
0.0312588252,
-0.0038634224,
0.0660385191,
-0.0529995523,
-0.023692498,
-0.04554566,
-0.0060406886,
0.0051487815,
-0.0211129859,
-0.0846704394,
-0.0033415691,
0.0008098725,
0.0719715655,
0.0032619659,
0.0029607154,
0.0298476759,
-0.0379198007,
0.0405409075,
-0.0014085267,
-0.0230703615,
0.0374991782,
0.0300828628,
-0.0000922198,
-0.0694044381,
0.0076417387,
0.0464007594,
-0.0154501023,
-0.0456786789,
0.0000019591,
-0.0589258038,
0.0142476698,
-0.0147093497,
-0.0311238673,
-0.0050180722,
0.0559485704,
-0.0423248224,
0.0030693358,
0.0364702903,
0.011141466,
-0.0115490463,
0.0290684681,
0.056478925,
0.095556125,
0.0638925135,
-0.0090334006,
-0.0104780272,
0.0076264697,
0.0035952416,
-0.061541196,
-0.0352153666,
0.0257703103,
0.0142746074,
0.0452208258,
-0.0066130576,
-0.0033191508,
0.021528922,
-0.0408529676,
-0.0003912646,
-0.0092488797,
-0.0161254052,
-0.017807344,
-0.0181164034,
-0.0168622751,
0.0861643404,
0.0469223931,
0.0431643911,
-0.0087306807,
-0.0305952895,
0.0095257759,
-0.0190262441,
-0.0234871395,
0.0278139673,
0.0087342579,
-0.0185980089,
0.0181292184,
0.0039393986,
-0.0285663158,
0.0230342429,
0.0345735587,
0.0404148847,
0.0066808243,
-0.0424448699,
0.0461235344,
0.0114347767,
-0.0616401322,
-0.0762257278,
0.0377793051,
0.0484522171,
-0.0857630149,
0.0164666045,
-0.0344992541,
-0.0150471702,
0.0170457326,
-0.0114101833,
0.0561333634,
0.062212687,
-0.0283801034,
0.0043081022,
0.0612748079,
0.0421044193,
0.037931893,
-0.0105335722,
-0.0344819352,
0.0300367158,
-0.0800292194,
0.0120195728,
-0.0452427641,
-0.0037678238,
-0.0467824601,
-0.0192152504,
-0.0677174628,
0.0201294404,
-0.0137728332,
0.0040396014,
-0.0101870615,
-0.0227864664,
-0.0134960953,
-0.0097020669,
-0.0313588642,
0.0264408644,
-0.0444518104,
0.0022925348,
-0.0002883082,
-0.0589238741,
0.0320888422,
0.0218873117,
-0.010498045,
-0.0142708309,
0.0213511828,
0.035732381,
0.004941741,
-0.0214491971,
-0.0450444631,
-0.0287970677,
-0.0593010783,
-0.0380116403,
-0.029933963,
-0.019752197,
0.0213498604,
0.0159018226,
0.0249973796,
-0.0134561416,
0.0330309942,
0.010189116,
-0.0638920516,
0.0676108599,
-0.0096370531,
0.0323947482,
0.0312545821,
0.0036964288,
0.0257015191,
0.0432069898,
-0.0016175611,
0.0089518419,
0.0336415283,
-0.0361998901,
0.0033486795,
0.0099988254,
-0.0416376144,
-0.0279872585,
-0.0309406389,
0.0042123455,
-0.0183914173,
0.0637726486,
-0.0183746237,
0.0488881059,
0.0020547169,
0.0146136917,
0.0474326015,
0.0839142129,
0.004082181,
0.0437844023,
0.0420774259,
0.0620782077,
0.0034586452,
-0.0191106088,
-0.0618479103,
-0.0133288521,
-0.0408235341,
-0.0113784485,
0.026182998,
0.0042588986,
-0.0275131445,
-0.051338274,
-0.0442181677,
-0.0144289071,
-0.0342532359,
0.0287302323,
-0.0188329462,
-0.0137461554,
-0.0244401246,
0.0259458404,
0.0408080183,
-0.0045791445,
-0.0376146249,
-0.0314208753,
0.019198047,
0.1262598485,
0.0347298421,
-0.0327397324,
-0.0234863646,
-0.0238747392,
0.0366196334,
0.0475331433,
0.0218982194,
0.0158528909,
0.011298446,
-0.0520579554,
-0.0134640941,
0.0334217511,
0.010461458,
-0.0073616221,
0.0044085537,
-0.0101738954,
-0.0035745152,
0.0368699729,
-0.0720770434,
0.0494499542,
0.0020210997,
-0.0562988967,
0.0293455888,
0.0010828007,
0.0269547366,
0.0350959636,
-0.0187331215,
0.0141034173,
0.0134293046,
-0.0178697482,
-0.0139017962,
-0.0028263887,
-0.0650797263,
-0.0109836766,
0.024360517,
0.0092825824,
-0.0067781205,
-0.0179202519,
-0.0302439705,
-0.0239854362,
0.0122917248,
-0.0663970262,
0.0218374748,
0.0063187061,
0.0278502628,
-0.0038908175,
-0.0001579681,
-0.054220967,
0.0142826512,
0.0022396711,
0.0366485305,
0.033712551,
-0.0066944165,
-0.0491940677,
-0.0335989781,
-0.0072102151,
-0.0157099888,
-0.0104039609,
0.0038945067,
0.0097545916,
0.0402339958,
-0.035641931,
-0.0631192103,
-0.1214572191,
0.0220075175,
-0.0013964061,
-0.0174771491,
0.0208498575,
-0.0337310955,
-0.0463356078,
-0.0089034205,
-0.034729667,
-0.0093249083,
0.0474686809,
0.0032393679,
0.017889386,
0.0268869046,
-0.0270227473,
-0.0453646891,
-0.015430551,
-0.0205054358,
-0.0005355497,
0.0035509754,
0.0042953631,
-0.076005429,
0.0313625522,
-0.0280814935,
-0.0005088902,
-0.0001817156,
-0.0443925969,
-0.006202193,
0.0249212887,
0.0610243939,
0.0416308306,
0.0125153586,
0.0227707811,
0.0140866265,
-0.003742683,
-0.0474337041,
0.0106860092,
-0.0083091734,
-0.0597664118,
-0.0551922061,
-0.0434778519,
-0.0050205705,
0.042449601,
0.0339611694,
0.0142795676,
-0.0414820388,
-0.0178900901,
-0.0167702008,
0.0209462997,
-0.0248732865,
-0.0225259792,
-0.0060970746,
0.0040864996,
0.0142937051,
-0.0191368777,
0.0774187297,
-0.0133050671,
-0.0177647024,
-0.0608014874,
-0.0524283908,
-0.0370601937,
0.0247752983,
-0.0168687291,
0.022593597,
0.0277054217,
-0.0196923222,
0.0172775611,
-0.0503377393,
-0.0148167349,
-0.0251643062,
0.0375061929,
-0.08227171,
-0.0078764893,
0.0387341715,
-0.008755995,
-0.0622987375,
-0.0538540334,
-0.0462572277,
-0.0153151387,
0.0285308063,
0.0168865938,
-0.0565316491,
-0.0351099931,
0.0288672354,
0.0295699239,
-0.0318402685,
-0.0351416096,
-0.0173319578,
-0.0039054987,
0.0290294439,
-0.0032115092,
0.0297832768,
-0.0332595706,
0.0671973228,
0.0100284545,
-0.0269426331,
0.0367603973,
0.0095195323,
0.02005977,
0.0100041069,
-0.0040950412,
0.0309479982,
0.0599712506,
0.0436868891,
-0.032338798,
-0.0300941449,
0.152257666,
0.0375111997,
-0.0374857597,
0.0141253099,
-0.0333893709,
-0.0120647969,
0.0266785286,
-0.0037341437,
-0.0344357006,
-0.0429375805,
-0.030986473,
0.0489231497,
-0.0454242341,
-0.0014345933,
-0.0051590689,
-0.078514874,
0.0310376752,
0.0050730831,
0.0353589728,
-0.0343699791,
-0.0091192685,
0.0023060262,
0.0127617829,
0.0194557011,
-0.0131710144,
-0.0247447509,
-0.0037345209,
0.0278660767,
-0.0582041107,
-0.0585931204,
0.0594909154,
-0.0159420073,
0.0904776454,
0.0345422812,
0.0200738348,
-0.0110302186,
-0.0184863191,
-0.0028972265,
0.0439176485,
-0.0055710725,
0.0109767579,
0.0228987318,
-0.0039373487,
0.0063551702,
-0.0483041257,
0.0580449626,
-0.0387401879,
0.0140378382,
0.0490853786,
0.0644857511,
-0.0124206804,
0.0110278567,
-0.0006032035,
0.0633395687,
0.0470736325,
0.0878468752,
0.030351337,
-0.0715844184,
0.0224737432,
-0.0126137165,
0.0151413893,
0.0153495418,
-0.0302647986,
0.0271509271,
-0.0491262786,
0.0354861133,
-0.0504186228,
-0.0463196933,
0.056705378,
-0.0288672093,
0.0134134348,
-0.0388482213,
-0.0008022594,
0.0333835036,
-0.0219379589,
0.0700482354,
-0.0281045083,
0.0448452868,
-0.0912410095,
0.0100725386,
0.0477787703,
-0.0127471276,
-0.0212458391,
0.0545820817,
-0.02222066,
-0.0401990749,
0.0282221511,
0.0271025356,
0.0078319171,
-0.0319206305,
0.0227731299,
-0.0766899139,
-0.0130173666,
0.0357474834,
-0.0315664373,
-0.0123461485,
-0.0013198069,
0.0702285692,
-0.001202391,
0.0442631654,
0.0045888,
0.0772232637,
0.0353095531,
0.0416280776,
-0.0077295429,
-0.0812962875,
0.0101521686,
0.0566618592,
0.0180149283,
-0.0112621635,
-0.039909102,
-0.0011525424,
-0.0222368948,
-0.0178873613,
-0.024969222,
-0.0342532881,
0.0129151773,
0.024499448,
-0.0381399207,
-0.0137577699,
-0.0759199634,
-0.0659574568,
-0.0106706303,
-0.0491679758,
0.0140979597,
-0.0186271165,
-0.0020372972,
-0.0006541713,
0.0078931004,
-0.0284433961,
0.022815356,
-0.0043491069,
0.0332442634,
0.001116674,
0.1210636273,
-0.004442526,
0.0089666657,
0.0081509268,
0.017601693,
0.001943421,
-0.0975440964,
-0.0193723477,
0.0243035182,
0.0495299175,
0.0196714178,
0.0178258792,
-0.0378116667,
0.0114254095,
-0.0256793462,
0.0199535079,
0.0161084328,
-0.0246865824,
0.0508373193,
0.0097129699,
-0.0176810529,
-0.009187215,
0.0100793839,
-0.0270488877,
0.0265635625,
0.0288305413,
-0.0178246703,
-0.0505258627,
-0.0045697917,
-0.0051819086,
0.0417556837,
-0.0319623761,
0.0415137708,
-0.0666164607,
-0.0265644398,
0.0069965986,
-0.0083137499,
-0.0167112481,
-0.0391993113,
0.0426098108,
0.0041364953,
-0.0155596184,
-0.0430886373,
-0.0457374342,
0.0422956571,
-0.0099843973,
-0.0266434737,
-0.0467514694,
-5.664028796e-33,
-0.0222591031,
-0.0299058333,
-0.0029957457,
-0.0058310386,
0.0009118756,
-0.0241718125,
0.0095836567,
0.0408823043,
0.006589076,
0.0242967494,
0.0253503621,
0.0389081277,
0.0052778879,
0.0334770717,
0.0153835434,
0.0043986333,
0.0197639465,
-0.0101362793,
-0.0345019102,
0.0027961126,
-0.0165152736,
0.0413431264,
0.0440324135,
-0.0781712458,
0.0501374565,
0.0058930367,
-0.0037986625,
0.0408192985,
0.0351352952,
0.0352553576,
-0.0433430783,
0.067098476,
0.0323021933,
-0.0323704518,
0.0129633406,
0.0349322148,
-0.0133248763,
-0.0285255667,
0.0655492544,
-0.0284080114,
-0.0446429253,
-0.0231550783,
-0.0138810016,
-0.02476977,
-0.0240152571,
-0.0167988632,
0.0147499749,
-0.0588502884,
0.0299146976,
0.0224107336,
-0.0233349949,
0.0023076211,
-0.0353413038,
-0.0357629955,
-0.0298343878,
0.0529666841,
-0.0515785962,
0.0248432457,
0.0164874289,
0.0166594572,
0.0506873876,
0.0177520663,
0.000015242,
-0.0297682956,
-0.0463690422,
0.0373614021,
-0.0038044981,
-0.0160056837,
-0.0061190319,
-0.0201614406,
-0.0236989111,
0.0225095283,
0.0465725623,
0.0321391486,
-0.008809316,
-0.0061137867,
-0.0459406041,
-0.0134565271,
0.0297693275,
0.0145545853,
0.0369432904,
-0.014597984,
-0.0462977961,
-0.0191376247,
-0.0620926544,
-0.0116961403,
-0.0224006418,
-0.011130387,
0.0534765013,
0.0012858069,
-0.0339337885,
-0.0007701978,
-0.0119925309,
-0.0121579776,
0.0079809455,
-0.0039492943,
0.004077679,
0.0192067754,
-0.0107642477,
0.0045836391,
-0.0613362342,
-0.0116462987,
0.01850757,
-0.0395639949,
0.0412088186,
-0.0162718892,
0.0129273813,
-0.019468721,
-0.0568506457,
0.0061230874,
0.0116083035,
0.0529112108,
-0.0234654527,
0.0053260345,
-0.0309612788,
0.02466386,
-0.0295830835,
0.0881488472,
-0.0071039521,
-0.033229176,
-0.0410269387,
-0.0381192267,
0.017223727,
0.0242674965,
-0.0368517227,
-0.0152916284,
0.0002580047,
-0.0113893598,
0.0348592699,
0.0002334793,
0.0068531325,
-0.0064111059,
2.605e-7,
0.0106836446,
0.0911380053,
-0.0062506692,
0.0311474856,
0.0046329396,
0.0329880305,
0.0128674349,
0.0352096036,
0.0586278364,
-0.0125733474,
-0.0060468628,
0.0250663217,
0.0536951311,
0.0034895071,
-0.0244136769,
-0.0234706756,
-0.0302018225,
-0.0251153074,
-0.0736069903,
0.0104634594,
0.0980057493,
0.0747028813,
0.0081995223,
-0.005997485,
-0.0073671937,
-0.0110660819,
0.0314772204,
-0.0622115619,
-0.0229433756,
0.0618552081,
0.0490979068,
-0.0034039246,
0.0262133442,
0.0487475693,
0.0181424543,
0.0162802301,
-0.0321538821,
0.1240542904,
-0.026591612,
-0.0107340021,
0.0011539675,
0.0530026257,
-0.0102175986,
-0.0170136709,
0.0175507255,
-0.0852680951,
-0.0149713,
-0.0324263349,
-0.0082516465,
-0.0613407679,
0.0270145666,
-0.0368559845,
-0.0259709153,
0.0459174402,
0.0385725051,
-0.0100552132,
0.0271463711,
-0.0458654165,
0.0123942029,
0.0379789583,
-0.0252419282,
-0.0183559358,
-0.0073036263,
0.008380915,
-0.0163698141,
-0.079202123,
0.0454835407,
2.164984629e-34,
0.0312710591,
0.0295630023,
0.0521960892,
0.010726681,
0.0575557314,
0.0531947687,
-0.033581391,
0.0335528553,
-0.0002065804,
-0.1133164912,
-0.0017357129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13578v1 | Enhancing Distractor Generation for Multiple-Choice Questions with Retrieval Augmented Pretraining and Knowledge Graph Integration | 2024-06-19T14:12:05 | 2024-06-19T14:12:05 | Han-Cheng Yu, Yu-An Shih, Kin-Man Law, Kai-Yu Hsieh, Yu-Chen Cheng, Hsin-Chih Ho, Zih-An Lin, Wen-Chuan Hsu, Yao-Chung Fan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we tackle the task of distractor generation (DG) for
multiple-choice questions. Our study introduces two key designs. First, we
propose \textit{retrieval augmented pretraining}, which involves refining the
language model pretraining to align it more closely with the downstream task of
DG. Second, we explore the integration of knowledge graphs to enhance the
performance of DG. Through experiments with benchmarking datasets, we show that
our models significantly outperform the state-of-the-art results. Our
best-performing model advances the F1@3 score from 14.80 to 16.47 in MCQ
dataset and from 15.92 to 16.50 in Sciq dataset. | [
0.0161249973,
-0.0098649878,
-0.0048433035,
0.0228978526,
-0.0002668074,
-0.0077094729,
0.0149642676,
-0.0104286037,
0.0953197479,
-0.0619867593,
-0.0097311018,
-0.008514042,
-0.0766545907,
-0.0163507592,
0.0369861722,
-0.0420528799,
0.0719167069,
-0.0152308112,
0.0210527275,
0.0047946558,
-0.0032777626,
-0.0136168888,
-0.0079320697,
-0.0197719894,
-0.0011336285,
-0.0246482845,
-0.0170371514,
0.0096184248,
0.0056968313,
-0.0574720912,
0.0431974977,
0.0789794698,
0.0076922029,
0.007786958,
0.0000022222,
-0.0579481162,
-0.025032308,
-0.0308247712,
-0.0443708189,
-0.0175569821,
-0.0304866303,
0.0765067711,
0.0718942732,
0.0118485112,
-0.0506966338,
-0.0063011646,
0.0033788858,
0.0397544354,
0.0624440871,
0.0535284169,
0.0058642556,
0.022321118,
0.0351469852,
0.0111471415,
0.0551370494,
-0.016338896,
-0.007822644,
0.0397877581,
-0.0384537317,
0.052612491,
-0.0363455191,
0.0327997617,
0.010640162,
0.0557266884,
0.047241874,
0.0089588286,
-0.0588101,
-0.0116830319,
-0.0415666439,
0.0932288021,
-0.0153720491,
-0.0125931967,
-0.0321199782,
-0.0148504451,
0.0436648242,
0.0500376262,
-0.0508259386,
-0.0278897397,
-0.0280087199,
-0.0237285271,
0.0104326466,
-0.012209625,
0.0032152433,
0.0046214149,
-0.0106084719,
0.0217085294,
0.0430533439,
-0.0447542332,
0.0538525842,
0.0083553642,
-0.0035372153,
-0.0239454452,
0.0328753926,
0.0433898531,
-0.0816545784,
0.0289243422,
-0.0436213128,
-0.0785826668,
0.0323542766,
-0.0105760312,
0.0014106439,
0.0289449655,
-0.0273974296,
0.0270758532,
-0.0405842401,
0.0426120199,
-0.0161765069,
0.0301313642,
-0.0429391861,
0.0219803676,
-0.0149134845,
-0.0288056303,
-0.0598458052,
0.0422682911,
-0.0233212858,
-0.0338460281,
-0.0153760426,
0.0371044166,
0.0037533522,
-0.0222607702,
0.0057388376,
0.0317568928,
-0.014872794,
0.0061289286,
-0.0401872285,
0.0566558912,
-0.0252822861,
-0.0044624317,
0.0329319984,
-0.020794889,
-0.0187196657,
0.0274457447,
0.026579028,
-0.0626278594,
0.0243540108,
0.0322599635,
-0.032340236,
-0.0330982171,
-0.006474162,
-0.050761167,
-0.004610301,
-0.0403789766,
0.0336735435,
-0.0460487492,
0.0199100263,
0.0223774295,
0.0002349277,
-0.0179175362,
0.0403143428,
0.0409365036,
0.012053187,
0.0151686426,
-0.0403892659,
-0.0233871378,
0.0236786734,
0.0011425909,
-0.0010853013,
0.0502480045,
-0.001466757,
0.0150903352,
0.0702103302,
-0.0361460112,
0.0036784073,
0.0156723,
0.0125321634,
-0.0298168976,
0.0407932959,
0.0227388293,
0.007116735,
0.0072648958,
0.0067538195,
0.0528993234,
-0.0294134151,
0.0130990213,
0.0262521934,
0.0194901172,
0.0308385417,
-0.0030560915,
0.0203712843,
0.0243129786,
-0.0038120036,
0.046661891,
-0.0306865424,
0.0180753861,
-0.0611532889,
0.0440748371,
0.0293755662,
0.0402539819,
-0.0297599565,
-0.0427809507,
0.0121328598,
0.0216878094,
0.0173798893,
0.0399377458,
0.0564402379,
0.0238270648,
-0.0946865156,
0.0394797549,
-0.0078822859,
-0.0746797845,
0.006507114,
-0.0302874297,
0.0532839559,
0.038156189,
0.0507944264,
-0.0481246859,
-0.0981236696,
0.0273432098,
-0.0090413103,
0.0064424896,
0.069513239,
-0.0306679178,
-0.0166225228,
-0.0793212578,
-0.0332766026,
-0.0296706595,
-0.0008423536,
-0.0010449025,
0.0430121869,
-0.0034729918,
0.0270451121,
-0.0209758021,
-0.0402721241,
0.0293937232,
-0.0078486912,
-0.0489284359,
-0.0316679664,
-0.0013587035,
-0.0023903246,
0.0075615519,
0.0086947288,
0.0364537127,
0.0367425121,
-0.006740551,
0.0212751366,
-0.0073181856,
-0.0557491481,
-0.0636989921,
0.0402112529,
-0.0024859784,
-0.0287324172,
0.0294817761,
-0.0055714669,
-0.0408289619,
-0.0078607397,
-0.0245672483,
0.0366975069,
-0.0119799543,
0.0085715884,
0.017198801,
-0.0288710706,
-0.0463659652,
0.1034110263,
0.0193219036,
0.0471190847,
0.0261505116,
0.0378505401,
0.0489244945,
-0.0324654318,
0.0063983062,
-0.0281764157,
-0.0263439082,
0.0285803135,
0.0237917304,
0.020823231,
-0.1425736994,
0.0074861892,
-0.0668282062,
0.0476190411,
-0.0295880847,
0.0198049229,
0.003242597,
0.0101395482,
-0.0079053519,
-0.0208870098,
-0.0610926375,
0.029585775,
0.0280111004,
0.0275872163,
-0.0094820419,
-0.0275511146,
0.0349574387,
-0.0243802089,
-0.0066768136,
-0.0115495268,
0.0310737286,
0.020741934,
-0.0153566459,
0.0157976113,
0.0673035905,
-0.0304435566,
-0.0138693899,
0.0046090488,
0.0297841597,
0.0472736433,
-0.0401020385,
0.1101466715,
0.0423753671,
0.0149354944,
0.0007380329,
0.0242817607,
-0.0352681428,
-0.0668900907,
0.0404268391,
-0.0416503698,
-0.0308350772,
0.0099375919,
-0.0175580438,
0.0355898626,
0.0345133021,
0.0311916154,
-0.0420649014,
-0.0195852667,
0.0119186919,
-0.0104391538,
-0.022042226,
-0.0713513792,
0.0180144962,
-0.0274240896,
0.0235563237,
-0.0382353812,
-0.0273682121,
0.069258146,
0.0042761974,
0.0195696652,
-0.0692290738,
0.040016152,
-0.0055246693,
0.031769067,
-0.0021298397,
0.0011346425,
0.0030728667,
-0.0199529994,
-0.072157748,
0.0075058178,
0.0028786212,
-0.0537508726,
0.0507056192,
-0.0222203042,
-0.0254062973,
0.0346174948,
0.0058035012,
-0.0679920837,
-0.0165848602,
0.0021936619,
-0.0119067561,
0.0241667945,
0.0179406684,
-0.014384198,
-0.0195538569,
0.0597667582,
0.0137903895,
-0.0434458777,
-0.0149007691,
-0.0127657438,
0.0889256224,
0.0514325649,
0.0356223211,
0.0080886446,
-0.0471300744,
-0.0077256314,
0.0532300547,
0.0818143487,
-0.0579405129,
0.0372287109,
0.0122617083,
0.0287057478,
-0.0503889918,
0.0052476367,
0.0171319619,
0.0785356015,
-0.0516372249,
-0.0358755738,
0.0842758194,
0.0447648354,
0.0033460932,
-0.0432150513,
-0.0263739638,
0.0151261454,
0.0481426045,
0.0087961815,
-0.0539167523,
-0.0444884934,
-0.0382469557,
0.0093669752,
0.0172107406,
-0.0106416773,
0.020590283,
-0.1019248515,
0.0087555191,
0.0151673425,
-0.0496071316,
-0.0251673125,
-0.0222889557,
-0.0331656821,
0.0291550569,
-0.0181021187,
0.0286831334,
0.0037271006,
0.0350981019,
0.0351843834,
0.0196693372,
0.0219698194,
-0.0385077782,
-0.0294682514,
-0.0206265207,
0.0039030076,
0.0015907753,
0.0036550469,
-0.0362882204,
-0.0024463225,
-0.0538691133,
-0.0134165855,
-0.0017120076,
0.0433567576,
-0.0143737486,
0.0121195391,
-0.0697314292,
0.0186850037,
-0.0190679394,
-0.0383596197,
0.0695478842,
0.054952912,
-0.0106939487,
-0.0219254829,
0.0093803462,
0.0086612692,
-0.0065307282,
0.0456964932,
0.0353857726,
-0.0400158651,
0.0218719039,
-0.050714422,
0.0634676293,
-0.0866170973,
-0.005506854,
0.0303524379,
-0.035560187,
0.0420791879,
-0.0360622369,
-0.0641618967,
0.0525270775,
0.0290038995,
-0.0193137787,
0.0155752096,
-0.0024768584,
-0.0013027064,
-0.0368811116,
0.0609632432,
-0.0121167293,
-0.0339368097,
-0.008751139,
-0.0505523458,
-0.0215572715,
-0.0117155593,
-0.009362028,
0.0610133335,
-0.0484970249,
-0.0262513813,
-0.0073652565,
0.0564031303,
0.0094869006,
-0.0109939883,
0.0266838595,
0.010764963,
-0.0117583023,
0.0024809209,
-0.0317525603,
-0.0101666031,
-0.0256515201,
-0.0502267517,
-0.0173035432,
-0.0152836815,
-0.0371135846,
-0.0127536515,
0.0153239956,
0.0765841082,
-0.0507688448,
-0.0416378863,
0.0493512228,
0.0504903421,
0.0186865833,
-0.0246249326,
0.0115770986,
-0.0582133085,
-0.0041091694,
-0.0109465485,
-0.0449067354,
-0.0130434344,
-0.0265112594,
0.0222621653,
-0.0376246087,
0.0175725464,
-0.0317565762,
-0.0110618649,
0.0347522944,
-0.026925398,
-0.0266553089,
0.0239686128,
0.0063035693,
0.0600173883,
-0.0169957913,
-0.0570802726,
0.0128283892,
0.0286075845,
0.0414825939,
-0.0015054677,
0.0806020275,
-0.0014084933,
-0.0303268339,
0.0146572804,
-0.0188980754,
-0.0391282737,
-0.0367332175,
-0.0227693934,
0.0073151058,
0.0251230393,
-0.0061163488,
0.0338252224,
0.0115347169,
-0.0130665852,
-0.0173575804,
0.029626064,
0.0160860512,
-0.021407662,
0.02478268,
0.0363468379,
0.0071587213,
-0.013494947,
0.0576029718,
-0.0089962212,
-0.0050998791,
0.023067873,
-0.0448621586,
-0.0689907148,
-0.0220691618,
-0.0083848331,
0.0787860677,
-0.006175525,
0.0250036493,
-0.0508597866,
-0.0608787723,
0.0107994387,
0.0225609355,
0.0098954635,
0.0081566675,
0.0592440404,
0.0603464916,
-0.0535185337,
-0.0546444319,
-0.0022593411,
0.0666359887,
-0.0888944417,
-0.010837839,
-0.015129704,
-6.188386336e-33,
-0.0389503501,
-0.0602362454,
0.0551606379,
-0.0485574901,
-0.0159799885,
-0.0302861296,
-0.0549918972,
0.0244103149,
-0.0220382661,
-0.0124377795,
0.0037584603,
-0.0197888091,
-0.0060785525,
0.0548625924,
-0.020024715,
-0.0238654725,
0.0118631516,
-0.0021163949,
-0.0016363813,
0.0416658409,
0.0556264929,
0.0265068281,
0.0278207045,
-0.0083828485,
0.0037062378,
-0.0417765938,
0.0424436517,
-0.0093687708,
-0.0363047644,
0.0471476875,
-0.0295042507,
0.0790086538,
0.0232506562,
-0.0254607815,
-0.0140528912,
0.0277560316,
-0.0564353429,
-0.0788379908,
-0.0087812962,
0.0127738621,
-0.0604435392,
-0.0467342027,
0.0277667157,
-0.0113584315,
0.020645529,
-0.0152933439,
0.0443311036,
0.0245600194,
-0.058829315,
-0.0212765615,
-0.0853077546,
0.0016013919,
-0.0157189742,
-0.0050950828,
-0.0226973668,
0.0660300329,
0.0093651414,
-0.0068489523,
-0.0390042588,
0.0322617032,
0.0110464301,
0.0127750318,
0.0292964522,
0.0570170507,
-0.0127311172,
0.044633694,
0.0127733257,
-0.0176304542,
0.0337714627,
-0.0031296562,
0.0036779239,
0.0470455699,
0.0432277173,
0.0188939944,
0.0156365335,
-0.0123633966,
-0.0704143792,
0.0456789061,
-0.0317134857,
0.0107909711,
-0.0041989121,
-0.0260039568,
0.0016950445,
-0.0160672944,
-0.0409528911,
0.0284766257,
-0.0296331644,
-0.0148920724,
0.0627070814,
-0.0143928276,
0.0012469572,
-0.0039794305,
0.0325360186,
0.0047003636,
0.0415149145,
0.0456060246,
-0.0153175071,
0.029405633,
-0.0395951681,
0.03496987,
-0.0394932292,
-0.0050295442,
0.0198759045,
-0.0201773029,
-0.0074540419,
0.0285572018,
-0.0010232599,
-0.0315478407,
-0.0514976382,
-0.0003628995,
-0.0532791764,
-0.0075582298,
0.031365592,
-0.0046414728,
0.0419713184,
0.0366736576,
-0.0159213226,
0.0478266254,
0.0259871259,
-0.0264261905,
-0.0395873152,
-0.0484714657,
0.0188906137,
0.0122243362,
0.0113144843,
0.0090643251,
-0.0475129969,
0.0163252298,
0.0055321567,
-0.0671747476,
-0.0007662372,
-0.0020845223,
2.763e-7,
0.0630553365,
0.0350360982,
-0.00347763,
0.0348360427,
-0.0312157385,
0.0140221268,
0.0202074274,
-0.0029301108,
0.0687707737,
-0.0018266278,
-0.0002506425,
0.043311175,
-0.0297841653,
0.0182338972,
-0.0638218895,
-0.0401545949,
0.0089311469,
-0.0097582862,
-0.0382920429,
0.0111135533,
0.0637235194,
0.0233396292,
-0.0022270835,
-0.0065161334,
-0.0180189535,
-0.0336270444,
0.0392813869,
-0.0025289641,
-0.0402058624,
0.0334050767,
0.0630704686,
0.0273329243,
-0.0232522227,
0.0579285659,
-0.0226410273,
-0.014894099,
0.0364474505,
0.0056034196,
0.0052590962,
-0.0614673235,
-0.0040394217,
0.018435033,
-0.0070948415,
-0.0393796191,
0.0429107286,
-0.0426774397,
0.0233620107,
0.0533712097,
-0.064849101,
-0.0078452947,
-0.0116041731,
-0.0172316935,
0.0055658687,
-0.036458768,
-0.0052769952,
0.0337735377,
0.0031234636,
-0.0354218483,
0.0006336914,
0.0608400516,
-0.0246577859,
-0.0662883446,
-0.0387608409,
-0.0444551669,
0.0038402323,
-0.017569853,
-0.0018376767,
2.333525264e-34,
0.0075147771,
0.0156254619,
0.0698411465,
0.0148622449,
0.024394514,
-0.0463627689,
-0.0030393021,
0.0087641543,
0.0427573174,
-0.1141277626,
-0.0086237583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13560v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13560v1 | Lexically Grounded Subword Segmentation | 2024-06-19T13:48:19 | 2024-06-19T13:48:19 | Jindřich Libovický, Jindřich Helcl | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present three innovations in tokenization and subword segmentation. First,
we propose to use unsupervised morphological analysis with Morfessor as
pre-tokenization. Second, we present an algebraic method for obtaining subword
embeddings grounded in a word embedding space. Based on that, we design a novel
subword segmentation algorithm that uses the embeddings, ensuring that the
procedure considers lexical meaning. Third, we introduce an efficient
segmentation algorithm based on a subword bigram model that can be initialized
with the lexically aware segmentation method to avoid using Morfessor and large
embedding tables at inference time. We evaluate the proposed approaches using
two intrinsic metrics and measure their performance on two downstream tasks:
part-of-speech tagging and machine translation. Our experiments show
significant improvements in the morphological plausibility of the segmentation
when evaluated using segmentation precision on morpheme boundaries and improved
R\'enyi efficiency in 8 languages. Although the proposed tokenization methods
do not have a large impact on automatic translation quality, we observe
consistent performance gains in the arguably more morphological task of
part-of-speech tagging. | [
0.0031729974,
0.0507317409,
0.000083834,
0.0739810988,
-0.0667992756,
0.0119575309,
0.0097696921,
0.037523035,
-0.0356468335,
-0.010589554,
-0.0143095162,
-0.0597328581,
0.0028757181,
-0.0083013773,
0.0337128043,
-0.0495116003,
0.0684458464,
-0.0512588881,
-0.0313368738,
0.0233882647,
0.0451453961,
-0.0124064162,
-0.0186273009,
0.0009664987,
-0.0520460531,
0.0056385556,
-0.0053506312,
-0.0174576566,
0.0183727164,
0.0103380773,
-0.0252783727,
-0.0149423284,
-0.0245448593,
0.0373033807,
0.0000019661,
-0.0383438207,
-0.0667548627,
-0.0137891425,
0.0058970894,
0.0237148944,
0.0812960938,
-0.0475721806,
-0.0370634533,
0.0067513795,
0.0265036002,
-0.0087090302,
0.0283323359,
0.0272811688,
0.0043952875,
0.0394188054,
-0.0302534774,
-0.0810863748,
0.0514796749,
0.0253942702,
-0.0583832301,
0.013324446,
0.0014107868,
0.0037180576,
-0.0307668708,
-0.0522967279,
-0.0220263675,
0.0138697345,
-0.0615053959,
-0.005258326,
0.0272918157,
0.0201012548,
-0.0570752136,
-0.0601024851,
0.022146849,
0.0375436619,
-0.0600485876,
0.0017939236,
0.0277891532,
-0.0267852563,
-0.0308876,
-0.0104780272,
-0.0194786582,
0.0184515417,
0.0034474225,
0.0215397626,
0.0722770095,
0.04290938,
0.0142000681,
0.0066522853,
-0.0837868378,
0.0796126425,
0.0666853189,
-0.0345839076,
-0.0350069404,
-0.0280782152,
-0.0424363874,
0.0003106348,
0.0537125356,
-0.0257366933,
-0.0120458333,
0.0486286059,
-0.0139621887,
-0.0428792201,
-0.0056990026,
0.0098656258,
-0.0068671,
0.0070613758,
0.0366748199,
0.0219242219,
-0.0394519307,
-0.0245092716,
-0.018217653,
-0.0287594106,
-0.0482298397,
-0.0292099193,
0.0107329087,
0.0122514945,
-0.0639284998,
0.0153159462,
-0.0222584531,
-0.0106014982,
-0.0411313549,
-0.0022439731,
0.0300313644,
-0.0359155089,
-0.0180128273,
-0.0361262336,
-0.0174977481,
-0.0136112245,
0.0109997662,
-0.001077565,
-0.0573783591,
-0.031424541,
-0.01619903,
-0.0256016124,
-0.002159392,
0.0321127363,
0.0468966141,
-0.0091438051,
0.0033039637,
0.0436544009,
-0.0042686844,
-0.076658532,
-0.0316523537,
-0.048115626,
-0.047345385,
-0.0327194929,
0.0139061837,
-0.0613902286,
0.0102204019,
-0.018526094,
-0.0000946025,
0.0210204534,
-0.0214919373,
-0.0140259601,
-0.0188234933,
0.0959721059,
-0.0331741981,
-0.017483009,
-0.0085729156,
-0.0117822401,
0.0655585974,
0.0507833064,
0.0597409196,
0.0369197913,
0.0751408488,
-0.0148911281,
-0.0513298698,
0.0386430509,
-0.0057799383,
-0.0369157903,
-0.0447310098,
-0.0515316464,
0.0111787906,
0.0278883483,
0.0135577694,
0.071867317,
-0.0001445959,
0.0353995003,
-0.0202909242,
0.1112017706,
-0.0316649787,
0.0418206416,
0.0062799007,
0.0303102452,
-0.0192344729,
0.0533046797,
0.0557331368,
-0.0485175401,
-0.003361478,
0.0343850292,
0.0347104482,
0.0449500941,
0.0125433104,
-0.0360746123,
-0.0327472091,
-0.0076819919,
0.0173897017,
-0.0489389189,
0.061301589,
0.0238765329,
-0.0707130879,
0.0267973077,
0.0092676617,
-0.0657960847,
0.0292763934,
-0.0450653359,
0.0039245808,
0.0077405069,
0.053196758,
-0.0552422963,
0.0019333176,
0.0264427122,
0.0446073078,
0.0499982685,
-0.0254012309,
-0.011730033,
-0.0266020801,
-0.0723368973,
0.0218260996,
0.0473042578,
0.014195065,
-0.0412212573,
-0.0171659254,
0.0123319151,
0.0011580612,
-0.0442417488,
0.0246654786,
0.0455099195,
-0.0109737841,
-0.0040646144,
-0.0335679427,
0.026609052,
0.0094950907,
0.0105089666,
-0.0323042199,
0.0118759843,
0.0321062952,
-0.0275722481,
0.0341776088,
0.0124645382,
-0.0214082561,
-0.0305116195,
0.0328405835,
-0.0111438455,
-0.0193034895,
-0.0673554018,
0.0133530879,
-0.0227132551,
0.0330038257,
-0.023601843,
0.1179453582,
-0.0615756549,
0.0749668255,
0.0072575598,
-0.0022557827,
-0.019351311,
0.0340426452,
-0.0112043079,
0.0265176464,
-0.0035485055,
-0.0811837465,
0.0081831971,
0.0118192015,
-0.0098107709,
0.0373450704,
-0.0170257464,
-0.030002242,
-0.0163447987,
-0.0191533305,
-0.0231048074,
-0.0303939208,
-0.0681384802,
-0.0009381653,
-0.0187477358,
0.0575981736,
-0.0095640877,
0.0634114668,
-0.0056084301,
0.0345833786,
0.0456922613,
0.0185591504,
-0.0092422878,
-0.0138398381,
0.038800966,
-0.0498023927,
-0.0044387365,
-0.0451514758,
-0.0069279517,
-0.0083602527,
0.0601853691,
0.0030171904,
-0.0196771156,
-0.0260229558,
-0.0200525671,
-0.0122365793,
0.0051567391,
0.016069198,
-0.0729318112,
0.0031438726,
-0.0281907786,
0.1002875865,
0.0283571444,
-0.0011762863,
0.0034722073,
0.0125301294,
-0.0299902987,
0.0176979974,
-0.0511219278,
0.012350115,
0.0221210457,
0.0178615581,
-0.0197094306,
0.005148185,
0.1006619781,
-0.0195130371,
-0.0031096234,
0.0147437304,
-0.0126073863,
-0.0634889677,
-0.0106102815,
0.0457473621,
0.0204324331,
-0.0554967374,
0.0294818524,
-0.0092558106,
-0.0220017396,
0.0278808065,
-0.0510939993,
-0.0119070159,
-0.0627077743,
-0.0329201147,
-0.0080474615,
0.0165592488,
0.0033563187,
0.0335799865,
0.0437078848,
-0.0552628413,
0.0129847005,
0.0089999968,
-0.0317016207,
0.0011511156,
0.0355713144,
-0.0308284927,
-0.0144146681,
0.0080883,
0.024429623,
-0.0152697247,
-0.013312785,
-0.0356529318,
0.0407924578,
0.0691586137,
-0.0170257371,
0.0344126783,
0.035573151,
-0.0169487596,
0.0373152234,
0.020763319,
0.022242181,
-0.0108588766,
0.0679504275,
-0.0022260409,
-0.0436177105,
-0.0167932939,
0.0088029429,
0.0331787951,
0.0085981926,
0.0387384817,
-0.0556735694,
-0.0113250427,
-0.0241625942,
0.0038867788,
-0.0630568862,
-0.0194693673,
-0.0366180763,
0.0350037739,
-0.0057518911,
-0.0262919012,
0.1153512076,
0.0733619183,
0.0201925673,
0.0126786111,
0.0116444957,
0.0214499086,
-0.0103219394,
-0.0370233282,
-0.016114926,
-0.0326418392,
0.0365229547,
0.007938805,
0.0351881124,
-0.0233394001,
0.0395151377,
-0.07601621,
0.0372510366,
0.0047990228,
-0.0323012322,
0.0030779957,
-0.0153411478,
-0.0057878569,
-0.0010779238,
-0.0211157221,
-0.002572472,
-0.0377645642,
-0.0210831296,
0.0407338925,
-0.0743580759,
0.0098904725,
-0.0462442152,
-0.0769114494,
-0.0191769935,
0.0174789988,
0.0642461479,
-0.0270932056,
-0.028042281,
0.0546906479,
-0.0367747881,
-0.0153993685,
-0.0180717558,
0.0076574334,
-0.0258704275,
-0.0253190268,
-0.0030852028,
-0.0193007868,
0.0176874548,
-0.0140339164,
-0.0298581328,
0.0574709103,
0.0160479452,
0.017877236,
-0.0089436788,
0.0154719613,
-0.0286459606,
0.0294863116,
0.0316044092,
-0.0157294106,
-0.0076588462,
0.0437161699,
0.026807284,
0.0054110866,
0.001654204,
-0.0595054887,
-0.0476101488,
0.0196103789,
-0.0909572914,
-0.0104609691,
0.0642267689,
0.0460018404,
-0.0105378907,
-0.0034188933,
0.0085665779,
-0.0167628378,
-0.0822430849,
-0.0096771521,
-0.0121644456,
0.0199283995,
-0.0785364956,
-0.0005291573,
0.0752637163,
0.0155064836,
-0.0113705825,
0.0056659118,
-0.0319649428,
-0.0384558253,
0.0117454119,
-0.0106826965,
0.0113788117,
-0.0062906076,
-0.0525721721,
-0.0402703956,
0.0420521572,
-0.0123453047,
-0.0062025553,
-0.0007222522,
0.0451593064,
0.0018265061,
-0.0151031585,
0.0144958561,
0.0083638374,
0.0023325321,
-0.000441382,
0.0274170227,
-0.0069282246,
0.033877857,
-0.0183228496,
0.0225097761,
0.0721594393,
-0.0558704548,
0.0414076932,
-0.0514545515,
-0.0099604046,
-0.0159804318,
0.0130310096,
-0.0132646458,
0.0138783781,
0.0408116542,
0.0050859209,
-0.0468255244,
0.0380460471,
-0.0744549111,
-0.0038687561,
0.0655587241,
0.0559632927,
0.0226545818,
-0.004870113,
-0.0041961907,
0.016482925,
0.0116893984,
-0.0383338854,
-0.0319937021,
-0.0179105978,
-0.0543157309,
-0.0009897156,
-0.0427570418,
0.0007110363,
-0.0836665854,
0.0630277917,
0.0040940573,
0.0411608554,
-0.0241997913,
0.0877810568,
0.0299079306,
-0.059560962,
0.0134640113,
-0.0011675053,
-0.0184144676,
0.0141361551,
0.0448543169,
-0.0194959622,
-0.0248175059,
0.0240253564,
0.035218671,
-0.0543557182,
-0.0010252593,
0.0073288935,
0.0144066401,
0.0233700071,
0.0274815299,
-0.0101285363,
-0.0183645245,
0.0075884899,
0.0246017128,
0.0415431261,
-0.0584862791,
-0.0071486244,
-0.0608754754,
-0.0759793967,
-0.0096344063,
0.0455860645,
0.0063881055,
0.0308418889,
0.0154550476,
0.0432519875,
0.0213551912,
0.0049938532,
-0.0224522576,
0.0021277424,
0.0246895663,
-0.0363078341,
0.0364468805,
-6.202841244e-33,
-0.0083620381,
-0.0292413402,
-0.0434990115,
-0.0264347568,
-0.0158590488,
0.0425565653,
-0.0155782811,
0.0200647488,
0.0142181115,
-0.0118406871,
-0.0281124134,
-0.0118953036,
0.0371859446,
-0.0137673132,
-0.0053318664,
0.0119320462,
0.0381897166,
-0.0354934223,
0.0047658496,
-0.0263944436,
-0.0025222646,
0.0428538062,
0.0744947642,
0.0197072718,
0.0277399663,
-0.0052784039,
0.0027339468,
0.0279558543,
0.034188427,
0.0489775203,
-0.0548597351,
0.0307812821,
0.0038454642,
0.0147280907,
-0.0046217819,
0.01138872,
-0.0951444432,
-0.0148231378,
0.0562021099,
0.0107008833,
-0.0407112874,
-0.0016001161,
0.022864718,
-0.0154005401,
0.0058957175,
0.0262875129,
0.0105024483,
0.0005552183,
-0.0230121799,
0.0147011718,
-0.1142539755,
0.0344255865,
0.0106680915,
0.0027769632,
0.1257489026,
-0.0706505477,
0.0416792966,
-0.0292190667,
0.0223027673,
0.0106543908,
0.0186586902,
0.0203847401,
0.0565915368,
0.0293887202,
-0.0229668096,
0.051906772,
0.0540636517,
-0.0402530991,
0.0730569959,
0.0364327133,
0.0421302579,
0.0358145684,
0.0131527651,
-0.000186875,
0.0424203947,
-0.0075988313,
-0.0225709565,
-0.0160785131,
0.0414076596,
-0.002206417,
-0.0102514038,
0.061965365,
-0.0569759421,
-0.0135263456,
0.0304808356,
-0.0863594487,
-0.0121401018,
-0.0155775528,
-0.0205128547,
0.0055591799,
-0.0746625662,
0.0311850682,
0.0479929112,
-0.0071420521,
0.0038440193,
-0.0274812486,
0.0079998514,
0.0457027256,
-0.0367097221,
0.0312854089,
-0.032262668,
-0.0493185557,
0.00397225,
0.0106850406,
0.0189241841,
-0.0051517631,
-0.0147107001,
-0.005578144,
-0.0438480414,
0.0147685008,
-0.0067484681,
-0.0137124639,
-0.0407319069,
0.0640787408,
0.0398165509,
-0.0070243892,
0.0075355601,
0.0289450884,
0.0675730482,
-0.0030312373,
-0.0043829349,
-0.0033523689,
-0.0309101846,
0.0386090651,
-0.0392120034,
0.0247901212,
0.0070859976,
0.0112402951,
0.0246569142,
-0.0339656696,
-0.0278974324,
-0.0065922872,
2.75e-7,
0.0440015905,
0.0688881427,
0.0790374354,
-0.0386142246,
-0.005652348,
-0.010577647,
0.0038019519,
0.0123290271,
-0.0281493235,
-0.0129922992,
0.030421,
-0.0229392778,
0.0336939655,
0.0150074866,
-0.0889843181,
0.0131473932,
-0.0193805378,
-0.0038834745,
-0.056235522,
-0.0194456801,
0.0424000993,
0.0762395561,
0.0010765517,
-0.0042113261,
-0.0398352891,
-0.0203577224,
-0.0164128505,
-0.0248725284,
-0.0391035303,
-0.0022341986,
0.0251592863,
0.0566388704,
-0.0259105805,
-0.0093949437,
-0.0223279949,
0.0101983761,
0.0803570896,
0.0332240723,
-0.0352499448,
0.0626327321,
0.0271180887,
-0.0343498886,
0.0150454519,
-0.0150152929,
0.073998481,
0.0212862045,
0.0146952374,
-0.0340885296,
-0.0009563676,
0.019964302,
-0.0032009659,
-0.0314977914,
-0.0505589843,
0.0408947952,
0.0421485528,
0.0002398967,
-0.0582226254,
-0.0426831841,
0.0181773081,
0.010307705,
-0.0328509137,
-0.0321953893,
0.0272793509,
0.0305177327,
0.0313970409,
-0.0158475135,
-0.0595831238,
2.65439711e-34,
0.0410889685,
0.0196374562,
-0.0045679533,
0.0427266806,
0.053273499,
-0.0117262043,
-0.0086307731,
0.0086507807,
-0.0405936465,
-0.0320557319,
-0.0099407192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13556v1 | Evaluating Short-Term Temporal Fluctuations of Social Biases in Social Media Data and Masked Language Models | 2024-06-19T13:45:21 | 2024-06-19T13:45:21 | Yi Zhou, Danushka Bollegala, Jose Camacho-Collados | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social biases such as gender or racial biases have been reported in language
models (LMs), including Masked Language Models (MLMs). Given that MLMs are
continuously trained with increasing amounts of additional data collected over
time, an important yet unanswered question is how the social biases encoded
with MLMs vary over time. In particular, the number of social media users
continues to grow at an exponential rate, and it is a valid concern for the
MLMs trained specifically on social media data whether their social biases (if
any) would also amplify over time. To empirically analyse this problem, we use
a series of MLMs pretrained on chronologically ordered temporal snapshots of
corpora. Our analysis reveals that, although social biases are present in all
MLMs, most types of social bias remain relatively stable over time (with a few
exceptions). To further understand the mechanisms that influence social biases
in MLMs, we analyse the temporal corpora used to train the MLMs. Our findings
show that some demographic groups, such as male, obtain higher preference over
the other, such as female on the training corpora constantly. | [
0.0509590209,
0.091410853,
-0.0504026525,
0.009390776,
-0.0106955571,
0.0194852576,
0.0489834882,
-0.0015668356,
0.029877672,
-0.0712631419,
0.0138719361,
-0.0615992285,
0.0275840443,
0.0260563511,
0.0139841037,
-0.0558151305,
0.0517780222,
0.0318506472,
0.0109651135,
-0.0760664493,
0.019395873,
0.0206597205,
0.0401246808,
0.0224045478,
0.0066170911,
0.003325311,
0.0462272912,
-0.0272973198,
-0.0003443644,
-0.0092307264,
0.051255472,
0.0762384087,
-0.0085059628,
0.0580962524,
0.0000017634,
-0.0695887879,
-0.0065215132,
-0.0135236038,
0.0014243309,
-0.0004993678,
0.0731405243,
-0.0248854551,
-0.0149786798,
0.025662683,
-0.083723031,
0.0012820206,
0.0146512985,
-0.0147298332,
0.0242820494,
0.036808297,
-0.0195354111,
-0.031943541,
-0.0544286892,
-0.0331713147,
-0.0266292188,
-0.0051342673,
0.0565900207,
-0.0647957847,
-0.0559255145,
-0.0194222983,
0.0044361306,
0.0196804553,
-0.0070626857,
0.0171170086,
0.0359704755,
0.050877925,
0.0053609037,
-0.0167509131,
-0.0097628618,
0.0268011354,
0.0024242075,
-0.0357360877,
0.0154565722,
0.0046196734,
0.0059637628,
0.0310928579,
-0.0111368028,
0.0081253732,
0.0141507164,
0.0342381708,
0.0049686106,
0.0171037894,
0.0400783829,
0.0652161613,
-0.0105355782,
0.0791355669,
-0.0026206989,
-0.0388397872,
-0.0161635783,
0.0184067357,
0.0450486876,
-0.0565913208,
0.041469451,
0.0050788186,
0.0283175949,
0.0157755744,
-0.0564263016,
-0.0242264196,
0.0187256541,
-0.0891374946,
-0.0164549425,
0.0017475779,
0.008812842,
0.0242260862,
0.0062588062,
0.0043547493,
0.0208192337,
-0.0103588682,
0.0063358927,
-0.0143704871,
-0.0197818466,
-0.0070683635,
0.0221970621,
-0.0092976801,
0.004280901,
0.0579790138,
-0.0500068665,
-0.0119120441,
-0.0438186452,
-0.0082110474,
-0.0413466282,
-0.0050171074,
-0.0273935944,
0.0057424796,
-0.0471361838,
-0.0182490982,
-0.0203406475,
0.0102117658,
-0.0563317798,
-0.0627117828,
0.0212955344,
-0.0221981667,
0.0287620407,
-0.0469069518,
-0.0086157816,
0.0163152684,
-0.0151558826,
-0.0158739351,
-0.0351694115,
-0.0210112538,
-0.000242544,
-0.0280352663,
-0.0218466166,
-0.0321065411,
0.0341945179,
0.0447243303,
0.0097977426,
-0.0196486078,
-0.0181640312,
0.0429439805,
-0.0809839442,
0.0599250793,
0.0285230968,
0.0317755044,
0.0532611124,
0.0025585878,
0.0257747322,
0.0982198268,
0.0297893714,
-0.0163565893,
0.0519640557,
-0.0311777908,
-0.0045288745,
0.0470039509,
0.0340050273,
0.0317194834,
-0.0503838956,
-0.0068122111,
-0.0075936504,
-0.0283658784,
0.0550657921,
0.0234155636,
0.0275530946,
-0.0565498546,
0.0574428365,
0.0471426472,
-0.0119797625,
0.0202933252,
0.0104222493,
0.0084146941,
0.0018585625,
0.0112730702,
-0.0627069548,
-0.0189766884,
-0.0449736752,
-0.0567480214,
-0.041238483,
0.056665916,
-0.0069419076,
0.0018253222,
-0.0120795332,
0.013710239,
0.0747351646,
-0.000177987,
0.0224180333,
-0.0067704013,
0.01147178,
0.0727601573,
0.050770171,
-0.0025702955,
0.0077764075,
-0.0176046658,
0.0131677035,
0.0374083258,
-0.0249666441,
-0.0034518137,
0.0198950134,
-0.023501439,
-0.0028682672,
0.031208992,
0.0655889362,
-0.0064309197,
-0.0022653323,
-0.0214055683,
0.0120045291,
0.0595135018,
0.0118299546,
0.0140421465,
0.0655504242,
0.0643480569,
0.0017458848,
-0.0059336517,
-0.0439666919,
0.0300580002,
-0.0146142012,
-0.0076870914,
-0.0192738231,
0.0046146931,
0.0430336893,
0.0255348496,
-0.0122390809,
-0.0296099428,
-0.0140737584,
0.0083855446,
-0.0066940091,
0.0352050923,
-0.0589914955,
-0.0079327244,
0.0326845534,
-0.0026002037,
-0.0582942702,
0.0741810873,
-0.0333387554,
0.0003375969,
0.0808364749,
0.0112980204,
0.0676878542,
0.0017214294,
-0.0155914323,
-0.0484118611,
0.0601034388,
-0.0218228903,
0.0318074487,
-0.0407165065,
-0.0244653225,
-0.0204966534,
-0.0289628115,
-0.0090112025,
-0.0367213525,
-0.0031028087,
0.0103111528,
0.0061904732,
-0.0255669616,
0.0172990914,
-0.0383600965,
-0.0480500869,
-0.0204532333,
-0.0738890171,
-0.0421742685,
-0.032833185,
-0.0335252956,
-0.0046197642,
-0.0092632016,
-0.0385791957,
-0.0256033801,
-0.0352091566,
-0.0087609934,
0.0124531966,
0.0424101166,
0.0105622075,
-0.0298657436,
0.0163828302,
-0.0591599643,
-0.0364669114,
-0.0411971882,
0.0690720305,
0.0298322979,
-0.0781879351,
-0.0112177255,
-0.013842281,
-0.0556080043,
0.0451071151,
-0.0279120002,
-0.0143015785,
0.0068024695,
0.0249517672,
0.0420615189,
0.0614878796,
0.0607791133,
0.0483931974,
0.0624474585,
-0.0054077888,
-0.0591182411,
-0.0250582602,
-0.0164753422,
0.0132178161,
-0.0348634198,
-0.0726282746,
-0.0085952543,
0.0624785274,
0.0277418885,
-0.0145602757,
-0.0374614,
0.051245939,
-0.0584759302,
-0.0528733693,
-0.002808169,
-0.0123000834,
-0.02201996,
0.015415757,
-0.0505418666,
-0.0846217573,
0.0416893922,
0.0326459073,
0.0130325817,
0.0153726712,
-0.0501362793,
-0.0288424455,
0.021390805,
0.0363331325,
0.0114648761,
0.0316369273,
-0.0172519796,
-0.0486050099,
-0.0299255401,
0.0217809658,
-0.0367692672,
-0.0111105377,
-0.0121635925,
0.0205305684,
0.0285971556,
-0.0142182782,
-0.0331418291,
-0.1096004173,
-0.0466824658,
-0.0326529555,
-0.0020448503,
-0.0250100624,
0.0060948175,
-0.0085998429,
-0.03214119,
-0.0104549183,
-0.0258987825,
0.0021224243,
0.0100797564,
-0.0175055899,
0.0438080318,
0.0018429811,
0.0254476313,
-0.0441642255,
0.0083363885,
-0.0112343282,
0.0597361177,
-0.0104027214,
-0.0207077526,
0.0147018479,
0.0260823388,
-0.0173786506,
-0.0106305722,
0.0063323253,
0.0354996808,
-0.018203469,
0.0432840362,
0.1017255634,
0.0110133113,
-0.0448060371,
0.0143303722,
0.0082863225,
0.0267845336,
0.0296166725,
0.0160022639,
-0.0769132972,
0.0387555733,
0.0126898754,
0.0317836925,
-0.0343089923,
-0.0383760408,
-0.0397242233,
-0.121818766,
-0.0089031095,
0.0210069939,
-0.0357171819,
0.0243579634,
-0.0245192442,
0.0122673996,
-0.0260506012,
0.0375159904,
-0.0288882125,
-0.0017508079,
0.0040238271,
0.0202142298,
-0.0696502104,
-0.0546106771,
0.025909001,
-0.041004926,
0.0712350905,
0.0056823958,
0.0460311286,
-0.0281671099,
-0.0252767392,
0.0451378152,
0.0485198461,
0.0052551283,
-0.0633821413,
0.0583981872,
-0.0501729362,
-0.0081765279,
-0.0081236437,
0.0184163041,
0.0091430666,
0.0090220217,
-0.0200281423,
0.009581333,
0.0333387479,
-0.0728472471,
-0.0238275472,
-0.0038635652,
0.0042427853,
0.0657117739,
0.0097600454,
-0.0386432111,
0.0128245596,
-0.0545562357,
0.0253091007,
0.0087351771,
-0.0565445051,
-0.0030587481,
-0.0172550734,
-0.036956612,
-0.0157543961,
-0.0502936207,
-0.0089753512,
0.0164203811,
0.0076856087,
-0.020968698,
0.0584172793,
-0.0263557173,
-0.0537099317,
0.0401120856,
-0.0228665788,
0.0336555317,
0.0080749206,
-0.0545450076,
0.0053502242,
-0.0201182924,
-0.001273283,
-0.025790384,
-0.0746040568,
-0.0604752526,
0.0784684047,
0.0135364439,
0.028488135,
0.0731669366,
0.0051246653,
-0.0977784991,
0.0790899768,
0.0170984156,
-0.0111902552,
0.0422243662,
0.0249079596,
0.0162025727,
0.0192247368,
0.0331465676,
-0.0228099041,
0.0202014092,
0.0230861846,
-0.0484028831,
-0.0583358146,
0.0082886275,
-0.0180960428,
-0.0239654928,
0.0588341169,
-0.0185394716,
0.0040825144,
-0.0287616327,
-0.0504501499,
-0.0103188343,
-0.0426985882,
0.0101389596,
-0.0475665666,
0.0236661732,
0.0379539058,
-0.0463766642,
-0.0253839362,
-0.0371814743,
0.0144369183,
-0.0431258716,
0.0252270866,
-0.0065305098,
0.0348330624,
0.0277719013,
0.037208911,
0.0185672548,
0.028475197,
-0.0213030186,
0.0163534526,
0.0427939482,
0.0026176728,
-0.0023542002,
0.0100862747,
-0.0156401694,
-0.0111196628,
-0.0515742265,
-0.0022503026,
0.0087196529,
-0.0370772295,
0.031441804,
-0.0596941225,
0.0734732822,
0.0265500322,
0.0035641075,
0.0120326448,
-0.0064717694,
-0.0077533885,
-0.0392808765,
0.029100975,
-0.0189425778,
-0.0370158404,
0.0721036717,
0.0829406157,
0.0460294858,
0.028180059,
-0.0038969829,
-0.0431822352,
0.0063946126,
0.0138198016,
0.0174317993,
0.0087168952,
-0.0046637557,
-0.0293851588,
-0.0727073103,
-0.064850688,
0.0224301703,
-0.0490901135,
0.036079593,
-0.0019249873,
-0.004018418,
0.0531399734,
-0.0210411083,
-0.0105088474,
-0.0317204669,
0.0287887249,
0.0285012722,
-0.0376725197,
-0.0215809736,
-6.519958028e-33,
0.0082455203,
-0.0383478701,
-0.0407893024,
-0.0072446363,
-0.0137327947,
0.0075605274,
-0.0299682319,
0.0122285681,
-0.0072485283,
-0.0040286519,
-0.0226262473,
0.030782694,
0.0312612057,
-0.0118667316,
0.0241639372,
-0.0140349632,
0.0471716523,
-0.0251529198,
0.0076797828,
-0.0332190953,
-0.0008642233,
0.0430811606,
0.0407096893,
-0.0664629787,
0.0748251826,
0.0217895377,
0.0062619913,
0.0078566559,
0.0273454152,
0.019960789,
-0.0215284973,
0.0574364699,
0.0342090651,
-0.0184656419,
-0.0125769228,
0.0543756336,
-0.0471666679,
-0.0322752073,
0.0039975084,
0.0396217816,
0.0225117896,
-0.015210052,
0.0378510095,
0.0001226728,
-0.072948575,
0.0183507986,
0.0538326465,
0.010258982,
0.0322352313,
0.0180374999,
-0.0093223918,
0.0449631847,
-0.0099055814,
0.0482540205,
0.0006516769,
0.0157280266,
0.0393822305,
0.0308407992,
-0.0670358241,
0.0422687866,
-0.0026320983,
-0.0187343247,
0.0474245362,
0.0390680134,
0.0374173969,
0.0533741415,
0.0679225326,
0.0886339098,
-0.0211170278,
-0.000423658,
0.0713239983,
-0.0432349145,
0.0066617411,
0.0335287973,
0.0300460458,
-0.0571562201,
-0.0106809055,
-0.0241621435,
0.0458270088,
-0.018784469,
0.0337442867,
-0.0008860836,
-0.0476947464,
-0.0602437556,
-0.0255700275,
-0.0614484176,
-0.0120644681,
0.0013736547,
-0.0049698856,
0.0179107282,
-0.033538729,
0.0189211965,
0.0232495517,
-0.0473335795,
-0.0909115449,
-0.028261954,
-0.0225569271,
-0.0135323433,
0.0276875254,
0.021096671,
-0.0644038245,
0.0105574233,
-0.0056078457,
0.0207584631,
0.0070845997,
-0.0166399498,
-0.0171728376,
0.0298917685,
-0.0566728562,
0.0006237761,
-0.0003858909,
-0.0052634603,
0.0190306585,
-0.0099198101,
0.048443716,
0.0122127188,
-0.0038068728,
0.001999462,
0.0611731894,
0.0177594647,
-0.0272068474,
0.0010156559,
-0.0142833069,
0.0391857401,
-0.0263893604,
-0.0271606892,
-0.0045699244,
0.0302234124,
0.0734315291,
-0.0130840093,
0.0010767739,
-0.0595516153,
2.399e-7,
0.0011940299,
0.0852594525,
-0.0306072328,
0.0302573349,
0.0441341773,
0.0275763702,
0.0331841521,
0.0383666679,
0.0335775688,
-0.0044722478,
-0.0571101904,
0.0284498092,
0.0287821386,
0.0318212509,
-0.0315858498,
-0.0361358449,
-0.0690198615,
0.0073237801,
-0.0298318341,
0.016544845,
-0.0338710658,
0.0614833646,
0.0736165941,
-0.0108419778,
-0.0554871745,
-0.0379600599,
0.0487684757,
-0.030064106,
-0.0133753335,
0.0122623444,
0.0266774539,
0.0181155913,
0.0074801007,
0.0123765878,
-0.0200583413,
0.046220053,
-0.018051587,
-0.0121932076,
-0.0054272148,
0.0218085162,
-0.007914301,
0.0036401711,
-0.053021457,
-0.066121161,
0.0634425133,
-0.0098442165,
-0.0410082377,
-0.0731099099,
-0.0103118727,
0.0016093791,
0.0479849502,
-0.0105532706,
-0.0451163463,
0.0216515753,
0.0264022592,
-0.0124043217,
-0.0338629484,
-0.0831341669,
-0.037079107,
-0.0255306195,
-0.0287452303,
-0.0281980466,
0.0000457646,
0.0424254537,
0.004679665,
0.0022625348,
0.0478555523,
1.92678631e-34,
0.019086875,
0.0085095614,
-0.0027346897,
-0.027775798,
0.0387940258,
0.0210175794,
-0.0101029836,
0.0123702222,
0.05799032,
-0.0240958072,
0.0193081629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13555v1 | BiLD: Bi-directional Logits Difference Loss for Large Language Model Distillation | 2024-06-19T13:44:56 | 2024-06-19T13:44:56 | Minchong Li, Feng Zhou, Xiaohui Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional
capabilities across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However,
such impressive performance often comes with the trade-off of an increased
parameter size, posing significant challenges for widespread deployment.
Knowledge distillation (KD) provides a solution by transferring knowledge from
a large teacher model to a smaller student model. In this paper, we explore the
task-specific distillation of LLMs at the logit level. Our investigation
reveals that the logits of fine-tuned LLMs exhibit a more extreme long-tail
distribution than those from vision models, with hidden "noise" in the long
tail affecting distillation performance. Furthermore, existing logits
distillation methods often struggle to effectively utilize the internal ranking
information from the logits. To address these, we propose the Bi-directional
Logits Difference (BiLD) loss. The BiLD loss filters out the long-tail noise by
utilizing only top-$k$ teacher and student logits, and leverages the internal
logits ranking information by constructing logits differences. To evaluate BiLD
loss, we conduct comprehensive experiments on 13 datasets using two types of
LLMs. Our results show that the BiLD loss, with only the top-8 logits,
outperforms supervised fine-tuning (SFT), vanilla KL loss, and five other
distillation methods from both NLP and CV fields. | [
0.0283151101,
0.0500716902,
0.0098488489,
0.0539850257,
-0.0008072431,
0.0216275156,
-0.0199535619,
-0.0064663817,
-0.0200705621,
-0.0323014855,
-0.0172623619,
-0.0250357036,
0.0017259454,
0.0111561427,
0.0349221267,
-0.0322075151,
0.0223014988,
-0.0637208298,
-0.0098069292,
-0.0047303787,
0.0009252038,
0.0186034702,
0.0003286703,
0.0209556054,
0.0457874462,
-0.0137088317,
-0.0040849452,
0.0129615972,
0.0450007208,
0.0093825273,
0.0405925326,
0.0433451869,
0.0378377028,
0.0124976616,
0.0000022534,
-0.0510747917,
0.014502232,
0.0023710534,
-0.0522160977,
0.0383326411,
-0.0042225285,
-0.0009149403,
0.0092554856,
0.0061843242,
-0.0157524124,
-0.0007629893,
0.052281905,
0.0153049063,
0.0535932705,
0.0462723784,
0.0192623138,
-0.0724373385,
0.0289318506,
-0.041607365,
-0.0091493707,
-0.0343501084,
0.0357376598,
-0.0063250316,
-0.0485905595,
-0.0247243438,
-0.030046571,
0.0358344279,
-0.0010057939,
-0.001660464,
-0.0065067341,
0.0285406969,
-0.0393229872,
-0.0349642299,
0.0049112514,
0.0749864802,
-0.0512278117,
-0.0001053263,
0.0245889183,
-0.0100262901,
-0.0035196273,
-0.0457029194,
-0.0286069009,
0.0179598127,
0.0213566646,
0.034842588,
0.0066304859,
-0.01259665,
0.0231908318,
0.0346993953,
-0.0327565596,
-0.023568863,
0.0013729576,
-0.0224705283,
0.0342557542,
0.0236495063,
-0.0682813302,
-0.0131779872,
0.0158853829,
0.0074850628,
0.0017260757,
-0.00850322,
-0.0188432746,
-0.0155575471,
-0.0105743604,
0.0095425723,
0.0451893434,
0.0034180186,
0.0097610839,
0.0418144949,
-0.0063895248,
0.0690739155,
0.0211849231,
0.0736846924,
-0.0138541181,
0.0052692043,
-0.0801678002,
0.0033624643,
-0.0090297507,
0.0079366527,
-0.0357337035,
0.0135273198,
-0.015362801,
-0.0136748012,
-0.0449085161,
-0.0240347274,
0.0723157674,
0.0168603249,
-0.0357726887,
-0.0044547841,
-0.0150336325,
0.0944569409,
-0.0077593164,
0.0030283611,
0.0286899693,
-0.0376275033,
-0.0361387618,
0.0061100563,
0.0050224755,
-0.0195366424,
0.0061737527,
0.0310217049,
-0.0217281636,
-0.0546873137,
-0.0247245226,
-0.0112913307,
-0.0456553362,
-0.1004984975,
-0.0037739477,
-0.0738417581,
0.0598432422,
-0.0129252262,
0.0185932741,
-0.0725139678,
0.0124421716,
-0.0244856328,
-0.0159379113,
0.0488589965,
0.006814226,
0.0193143245,
0.0077960542,
0.0232068077,
0.0060768179,
0.0842777342,
0.0228277929,
0.0278029963,
0.0192676075,
0.0093547115,
-0.0245683491,
0.0206376165,
0.0153377308,
0.0314777978,
-0.042933587,
-0.0255043972,
-0.0330758952,
0.006171653,
0.0667895526,
0.048245959,
-0.0565242991,
0.0008520066,
0.0878689364,
0.00186054,
0.0751402304,
-0.0189311188,
-0.0003520431,
0.0303455889,
0.0052679032,
0.0090006739,
-0.0504793189,
-0.0274145119,
0.0180736277,
-0.0181733314,
0.061245285,
0.0644511208,
-0.0264300965,
-0.0462043695,
0.0150236394,
-0.0127789117,
0.008954512,
0.0051728035,
0.0481842197,
0.0285759922,
0.0154373758,
0.0771959201,
0.0612876378,
-0.0334940329,
0.041745849,
-0.0538928807,
-0.0360872857,
0.0581408441,
0.0153799755,
-0.0195002928,
-0.0001485222,
-0.0095098792,
0.0155277755,
-0.0010039493,
0.0327723511,
-0.0192817822,
0.0782610327,
-0.0606601313,
-0.0314988978,
0.0034242061,
0.0260193497,
-0.024741089,
0.0165794548,
0.0234474391,
0.036473643,
-0.0802225322,
-0.0408872738,
0.0229946356,
-0.0342933983,
-0.0608654842,
-0.0142566729,
0.0068401354,
0.0046269568,
-0.0048744455,
-0.0175210349,
-0.0031564326,
0.0258947685,
-0.0301825423,
0.0133164693,
-0.0593053289,
-0.0135178892,
-0.0750631914,
0.0465129763,
-0.0184186846,
0.0207769722,
0.0768979862,
-0.0790321305,
-0.0239234474,
0.0012672393,
0.0167326573,
0.0194681045,
-0.0117165428,
0.0408310592,
0.0347578004,
0.0121232206,
-0.0410384983,
0.035061039,
-0.0254846141,
-0.0031060912,
-0.0313019529,
-0.0314552039,
-0.0436096378,
0.0107800169,
-0.036706496,
0.0447026975,
-0.0359520465,
0.039828416,
0.0089575667,
0.0076048933,
-0.0348705202,
-0.0523602366,
-0.0337213613,
0.0251114722,
-0.0469587743,
0.0238711312,
0.02142681,
0.0196811631,
0.013331838,
-0.0063457713,
-0.0148426509,
-0.030860072,
-0.0181142148,
0.016736716,
-0.0001172296,
0.0178425182,
0.0034703249,
-0.0197857376,
-0.038792491,
0.0265653245,
0.0302617569,
-0.0574772954,
0.005485089,
-0.0634696707,
0.0552848428,
-0.0329674445,
0.0254672337,
-0.000820905,
-0.0316994563,
-0.0067313723,
-0.0253598336,
0.0405604057,
0.0593794473,
-0.003609892,
0.0340336896,
0.0700578168,
-0.0325770639,
-0.0609945245,
0.0078080203,
-0.0120638199,
-0.026846027,
-0.0422498733,
-0.0084419344,
-0.0389745608,
0.0647921711,
-0.0262986161,
-0.0157226026,
-0.0310945679,
0.0018838057,
-0.0051655094,
-0.0287334025,
-0.0430167094,
0.0253623649,
-0.0298248548,
0.0069490373,
-0.0268106163,
-0.029972313,
0.0316281542,
-0.015931353,
0.0236097015,
-0.0555343516,
-0.0159944911,
0.0000332241,
0.0464422293,
0.0015218578,
-0.003775879,
-0.0143341767,
0.0021611312,
-0.0824554563,
-0.0137856789,
0.0252667777,
-0.0488242917,
0.0631276518,
-0.0728054494,
-0.0172067098,
-0.0444959253,
-0.0193760488,
-0.0198252518,
-0.0262271203,
0.0077186027,
0.0205432251,
0.0360232703,
0.0040098238,
-0.0365774259,
-0.0331657492,
-0.0030948706,
0.0399429314,
-0.0001374044,
-0.0008410558,
-0.0397976711,
0.0389208831,
0.0480322503,
0.0197894666,
0.0185935926,
-0.0256908443,
0.026389502,
0.0669589788,
0.0486849248,
0.0034113284,
-0.0101656169,
-0.0375096165,
0.0423322991,
0.000449695,
-0.0239409078,
0.0132809151,
0.0840234607,
-0.0894534886,
-0.0031635365,
0.0822839215,
-0.0003284364,
-0.028166296,
0.0006437976,
0.0729562193,
0.0741693005,
0.0051192152,
-0.0209142249,
-0.0668046921,
-0.0471032895,
0.0078200391,
0.0312544554,
0.023165619,
-0.0169891175,
-0.0241566822,
-0.0928999484,
0.0088240262,
0.0397650711,
0.0168571081,
-0.0419025384,
-0.0305523276,
0.0063928738,
-0.038283959,
0.0243434869,
-0.0048518376,
-0.0208668429,
-0.0028808287,
0.0454644673,
-0.0143856974,
-0.0810907334,
0.0157442875,
-0.0359400101,
0.0327900834,
0.0310480427,
0.035827402,
0.0171269998,
-0.0267592371,
0.0248388126,
-0.0396559909,
-0.0068930807,
0.0116664777,
0.0732129514,
0.0003408957,
-0.0155153619,
0.0162279606,
0.015846001,
-0.0339162834,
-0.015440546,
0.0056086257,
0.0247103609,
0.008441844,
-0.0460461453,
0.0096892053,
-0.0288613569,
0.0038793881,
0.0709475279,
0.0319494046,
-0.0332648605,
-0.0599167421,
-0.0066748722,
-0.0057194722,
-0.0042175022,
-0.0229415372,
-0.0040772841,
-0.0165974572,
-0.0328975469,
-0.0363077335,
-0.0101345042,
0.0121651161,
0.0158080906,
-0.0195566379,
0.0039062607,
0.0145226084,
0.0177013688,
-0.0525239259,
0.0279586874,
-0.0418367423,
0.0185138676,
-0.058128424,
0.0068167597,
0.001982217,
0.0073090158,
-0.0410813652,
0.03658209,
-0.1520191133,
-0.0987121686,
0.0199316069,
0.0024398353,
0.0157623328,
0.0669685379,
-0.0122115863,
-0.0743910819,
0.0306368507,
0.0398730002,
0.0083865095,
0.0388443656,
0.0411394015,
-0.0313484669,
-0.0035656381,
0.0518723838,
-0.0329550989,
0.0237089042,
0.0337231345,
0.0420695618,
-0.0152801648,
-0.0256215837,
-0.0234739278,
0.0254209638,
0.0775022656,
0.0080358582,
-0.001512213,
-0.0393200628,
0.0300195497,
0.0451803133,
-0.0002475654,
-0.0375223905,
-0.0081999879,
0.0629018471,
0.000754141,
-0.0081009464,
0.0568895452,
0.0516533293,
0.0002160848,
-0.0766063854,
0.005641697,
-0.0076792012,
-0.0082120616,
0.0620471239,
0.0138369473,
-0.0154614989,
0.0357801467,
0.0367555991,
0.0336455368,
-0.0325611979,
0.0426320769,
0.0135360761,
0.0265893396,
0.0000701924,
0.046863351,
-0.0558804721,
-0.0660854504,
-0.0444896668,
-0.0046617682,
0.0146963419,
-0.0070541459,
0.0693857521,
-0.0021061832,
-0.0189583972,
-0.0391022339,
-0.0104942098,
-0.0182060432,
0.0474668555,
0.0204906054,
0.0184669625,
0.003239959,
0.0320725851,
0.088646166,
0.0292031318,
0.0484988391,
-0.0123451026,
0.021283254,
-0.0120227644,
-0.0414022021,
-0.000335392,
0.0235957168,
0.0265643485,
0.0091969827,
-0.0002736744,
-0.0550778173,
-0.0186333805,
-0.0514937565,
0.0013533125,
-0.0252142083,
0.0273245331,
0.0217609182,
-0.0304572731,
-0.0189821385,
-0.0245105699,
-0.0526379198,
0.0347069874,
-0.0266192276,
0.0021053087,
-7.013034562e-33,
-0.0095298616,
0.0436360314,
-0.0122850146,
0.0062548942,
-0.0433219709,
0.0122621935,
0.0096645709,
-0.0096458709,
-0.0538240336,
0.0362923965,
-0.0017506998,
0.0316876471,
0.0303900354,
0.0395229161,
-0.009454878,
-0.0260569695,
0.0924777538,
0.0053993436,
-0.0123473508,
0.0417136736,
0.0317737199,
0.0295104254,
0.0650716871,
-0.0649661198,
-0.0036117951,
-0.0019825411,
-0.0159980245,
-0.0004566416,
-0.0207316019,
0.03797438,
-0.0250822827,
0.0914157405,
0.0163971353,
-0.0300075077,
-0.0564180911,
-0.0107498243,
-0.0736333281,
-0.0237768311,
-0.0033864384,
-0.0028441949,
-0.0198266078,
-0.0220667962,
0.0652530864,
0.0129646352,
0.0098169195,
-0.0672230199,
0.0140719935,
-0.0232456159,
-0.0279141963,
-0.0343215056,
-0.0236234292,
0.0196190178,
-0.0258172192,
-0.0666545108,
0.0559301972,
-0.0164242778,
-0.0109909205,
0.0031514051,
-0.0974011645,
0.015804993,
0.06250754,
0.0966470242,
0.0472120009,
0.0299840067,
-0.0312686451,
0.0558689535,
0.0171206091,
0.0019608748,
0.0084009869,
-0.0682129562,
0.0468555279,
0.0855034292,
0.0104226395,
0.0169960354,
0.0730397552,
-0.0180156082,
-0.0636672601,
-0.0213363506,
-0.0323734283,
0.0455844291,
0.0086201131,
0.0201891456,
-0.0049225809,
-0.0485266708,
-0.0616767108,
-0.0318816118,
-0.0200777836,
0.02876186,
0.0510398597,
0.0349343941,
-0.0352711529,
-0.0138633726,
0.0058009573,
-0.0745656714,
-0.0038323496,
0.0360076092,
-0.0119041018,
-0.0009604234,
0.0030970953,
-0.0319174044,
-0.0781107545,
-0.0226186663,
0.0250572171,
0.0165942572,
-0.0036141984,
-0.0108872754,
0.0357217565,
0.0241302736,
-0.0439808778,
-0.0022855736,
-0.0448651351,
0.0202208385,
0.0188396387,
0.0512616746,
0.0296905208,
-0.0293750297,
-0.0098692542,
0.044235684,
0.0467756428,
-0.0200037695,
-0.0015189138,
0.0194327962,
0.0395324193,
0.0362902582,
-0.0131961899,
0.0157849491,
-0.0143148601,
-0.043259941,
0.055513747,
-0.0111685451,
-0.012136722,
-0.0241756681,
2.904e-7,
0.0285503101,
0.0319450274,
-0.0012759365,
-0.0387938321,
0.0156568009,
0.0240177661,
0.0053413017,
0.0024335284,
0.0195613131,
-0.0420201719,
-0.021393735,
0.0508770309,
0.0586498156,
0.0072779367,
-0.0517244041,
0.0163554084,
-0.0484524071,
-0.0057330239,
-0.0193683505,
-0.0636596605,
0.042864453,
0.0677589402,
0.0103057632,
-0.0234231092,
-0.0149175543,
-0.0204299968,
0.017711632,
-0.0132115744,
0.032402698,
0.0411928035,
0.0307955258,
-0.0088753188,
0.0140580526,
0.0123363407,
-0.0458213538,
0.0157385115,
0.0177626144,
0.0905812308,
-0.0295095891,
-0.0029343863,
-0.011573622,
0.0256758295,
0.0009240487,
-0.0447848625,
0.0709677562,
-0.0550497063,
0.0106958142,
-0.045105055,
-0.0263863299,
-0.0280850586,
0.0517905876,
-0.0189259015,
0.0132380258,
0.0195474885,
-0.0097757028,
-0.0011669275,
-0.0606787838,
-0.1074193493,
-0.009705212,
0.0092817983,
-0.0121339653,
-0.0607904755,
-0.0318176858,
-0.0280812774,
-0.0040111258,
-0.0193680339,
0.0004536318,
2.630874595e-34,
0.02845826,
0.0116693908,
0.0288319457,
-0.0208659973,
0.0281400457,
0.0031271516,
-0.0824139863,
0.0273082871,
-0.0261238273,
-0.0649780408,
-0.0070685185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13553v1 | Mining United Nations General Assembly Debates | 2024-06-19T13:43:27 | 2024-06-19T13:43:27 | Mateusz Grzyb, Mateusz Krzyziński, Bartłomiej Sobieski, Mikołaj Spytek, Bartosz Pieliński, Daniel Dan, Anna Wróblewska | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This project explores the application of Natural Language Processing (NLP)
techniques to analyse United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) speeches. Using
NLP allows for the efficient processing and analysis of large volumes of
textual data, enabling the extraction of semantic patterns, sentiment analysis,
and topic modelling. Our goal is to deliver a comprehensive dataset and a tool
(interface with descriptive statistics and automatically extracted topics) from
which political scientists can derive insights into international relations and
have the opportunity to have a nuanced understanding of global diplomatic
discourse. | [
0.0610462613,
0.0908798054,
0.0128199384,
0.0446088985,
-0.033033438,
0.0308219865,
-0.0204445552,
-0.0184806734,
0.0118578114,
-0.0629347265,
0.0456422195,
-0.0156592969,
0.0212959088,
0.0354924761,
0.0066875326,
-0.0637709647,
0.0459205173,
0.01118882,
0.0854806975,
0.0205259062,
0.0202408843,
0.011865343,
-0.05163344,
0.0418876223,
-0.0069829114,
0.0351548195,
-0.048576735,
-0.0075501883,
-0.0100460621,
-0.0239762254,
-0.0058175316,
0.0190255623,
-0.0210256279,
-0.0345185474,
0.0000015112,
-0.0334121659,
-0.0168910939,
-0.0303170811,
0.0264005046,
-0.001935136,
0.0981567055,
-0.0196046904,
-0.0386717245,
0.0360910594,
-0.0670938343,
-0.0012283757,
0.0316166468,
0.0367104188,
0.0597200058,
0.0712935552,
-0.0237991847,
-0.0454952605,
-0.0243931115,
0.0122519191,
-0.0614981614,
-0.0105313566,
0.0178650841,
-0.0236279778,
-0.0604351424,
0.012267096,
0.0521928407,
-0.0256376378,
-0.0755376816,
-0.000468926,
-0.0387318134,
-0.0162309743,
-0.0833672583,
-0.0243174154,
-0.0104018031,
0.0102785723,
0.0606624894,
-0.0086604077,
0.0434943214,
-0.0101517225,
-0.0106654819,
0.0141982967,
-0.0088219801,
0.0377143398,
-0.0298970249,
0.037966799,
0.0486310683,
0.0398788974,
-0.0233979374,
0.0006184905,
-0.0144256549,
0.0554035529,
-0.0217861328,
-0.0287892465,
0.0191005748,
0.0056260503,
-0.0145152099,
-0.0343348198,
0.0088465093,
0.000498282,
0.0106025701,
0.0390358083,
0.033254303,
0.0014112756,
0.0278687384,
-0.08903642,
0.0049329759,
0.004095959,
-0.0141301546,
0.0583576486,
0.0661985576,
-0.0317570195,
0.0387214608,
-0.003534076,
0.0116418414,
-0.0251492504,
-0.0633312836,
-0.0036000668,
-0.0091400286,
0.0332243592,
-0.0407989994,
0.0070588826,
-0.0271123573,
-0.0027235171,
-0.0022951481,
0.0396754481,
0.0129225077,
0.0095475977,
0.015822785,
0.0328657404,
-0.0675103813,
0.0488433726,
-0.0406823531,
0.0168150254,
-0.0381939448,
-0.0328194238,
0.042555213,
0.0199005175,
0.0130088674,
0.0421041846,
-0.0047886795,
0.0698523298,
0.0121211121,
0.0014595815,
-0.0371823534,
-0.0320815034,
-0.0105895419,
-0.0072030826,
0.0237229038,
-0.0561058,
0.049348373,
-0.0067225066,
-0.01331235,
-0.0323419608,
0.013992955,
0.0095247682,
-0.0135437492,
0.00701871,
-0.0194217656,
-0.0017213175,
0.0245865192,
-0.0096075926,
0.0525016524,
0.0262004584,
-0.0100974217,
0.0052525722,
0.0718856081,
-0.019237062,
0.0012014313,
0.0065987767,
-0.0381018706,
0.0270491615,
-0.0200254451,
0.0066384375,
-0.0493306555,
-0.0245867334,
-0.0136530511,
0.037723884,
-0.0037520253,
-0.0386808366,
0.0108334413,
0.081626378,
-0.0697420835,
0.0291288048,
-0.0257240795,
0.0515305214,
0.0380598642,
0.0314727016,
0.0241363831,
-0.0226703528,
0.0077055437,
-0.0304517951,
0.0494810827,
0.0316028297,
0.0110499999,
-0.0643795356,
-0.0013603145,
-0.0008945037,
0.0370622575,
-0.0275173467,
0.0309406724,
-0.003535863,
-0.0462651774,
-0.0180728082,
0.0744621083,
-0.0872156993,
-0.0318316221,
-0.0124153476,
0.0024817083,
0.0203002505,
0.0119047379,
-0.0330187827,
-0.0414477363,
-0.0402656868,
0.0164048281,
0.0501438715,
0.0210353583,
-0.0149488198,
0.0036687586,
0.0081966165,
-0.0107978061,
0.0153051885,
-0.0000625973,
0.0341330357,
-0.0304484405,
0.0124342702,
-0.0123002054,
0.023072442,
-0.0424773581,
0.0472640768,
0.0312747285,
-0.0033482413,
0.0118809808,
-0.0011201578,
0.0605674423,
0.0610445328,
-0.0041302894,
-0.0264313873,
0.0327558964,
-0.0054489821,
0.0201612432,
-0.0043876697,
0.0147485333,
0.0238788538,
0.0334759615,
-0.0591514334,
-0.0177118201,
0.0081326338,
-0.0124974903,
-0.0195807852,
0.0725013614,
0.0108648604,
0.0134378606,
-0.0024140733,
-0.0018365744,
-0.0149053419,
0.0039837654,
-0.0332248919,
0.0514502116,
0.0199252646,
0.0148852542,
-0.0197643992,
-0.0565338619,
0.071042724,
-0.004314417,
-0.0121968389,
0.0269249734,
-0.0035072169,
0.0099539841,
0.0605863221,
-0.0421539322,
-0.0170223173,
-0.0323601328,
-0.1099451333,
0.0046987846,
-0.0110121192,
0.0529248379,
0.0626003891,
-0.01790791,
-0.0134704513,
0.0376565792,
0.0027729433,
-0.0683795437,
-0.0074528074,
-0.0444889665,
0.0501637533,
0.0236514919,
0.0431534015,
-0.0504672825,
0.0102352193,
-0.0418489315,
0.0261556357,
0.0198392998,
-0.0362304524,
-0.005407834,
0.0137247201,
-0.0241654441,
0.0310349073,
-0.0353711322,
-0.0538010597,
0.0346143134,
0.0104392525,
-0.0184059013,
0.0316855684,
0.0628347397,
0.0801910087,
0.0257309973,
-0.0400304236,
-0.0001982135,
0.0051650805,
-0.0498558655,
0.0617064349,
-0.0290933829,
0.003223038,
0.0655908287,
0.037571609,
0.0297195073,
0.0186926052,
0.0327372663,
0.0239265747,
-0.0198441874,
0.0134765767,
-0.0371598899,
-0.0242067818,
0.0098245405,
0.0327766314,
0.0600143895,
0.0004496727,
0.0304596871,
-0.0284598228,
0.0223612245,
-0.0896790549,
-0.0230476614,
-0.0531265959,
0.0646294951,
-0.0228926204,
-0.0164058115,
0.0052448339,
-0.0057313824,
0.0159564056,
-0.0703610852,
0.0379002839,
-0.0201754998,
0.0108122481,
-0.0683651417,
0.00218413,
-0.0342411175,
-0.0011384977,
-0.0030656436,
-0.0470571481,
-0.0350645892,
-0.0012469427,
0.034576986,
-0.0332361162,
-0.0264162179,
0.0214652494,
0.0370990708,
-0.0239326935,
0.0265025906,
-0.0014716799,
-0.0024373652,
0.0174052119,
-0.0082663866,
-0.0227831081,
-0.0093718935,
0.0367099158,
-0.0362337902,
0.0472908504,
-0.0751401037,
0.0275229253,
-0.0342083797,
-0.033445213,
0.0125245638,
-0.0273118205,
0.0063390676,
-0.0248078685,
-0.0038579472,
-0.0506430753,
0.0526341237,
0.0758386925,
0.0611991473,
-0.0233883858,
-0.0062481062,
0.0020981389,
-0.0226612091,
0.0006434969,
0.0161435213,
-0.0646895394,
-0.0023085573,
-0.0202187095,
-0.0054612802,
-0.0939464718,
-0.0398533233,
-0.0050334954,
-0.0642040521,
0.026143223,
-0.0065786359,
-0.0138145359,
-0.0151303448,
-0.0539555065,
-0.0249465406,
-0.0231788047,
-0.0354509056,
-0.0415157527,
0.0003218652,
0.0155985989,
0.0324515961,
-0.1090539247,
-0.0552870035,
0.0109150149,
0.0138031123,
0.0154381273,
0.0248451307,
0.09814246,
0.0053604189,
0.0188454874,
0.0357527584,
-0.0258247368,
-0.0198128391,
0.0008953943,
0.0440608338,
0.0252378602,
-0.0482085496,
-0.0302966665,
0.0072639864,
-0.0302856695,
0.0007362606,
0.0575582869,
0.031958323,
-0.0655893683,
0.0382826813,
-0.0139456345,
0.0066756005,
0.0423730798,
0.0251304526,
-0.0115642976,
0.024542572,
-0.0478776768,
-0.0295629818,
0.0549748503,
-0.0571877733,
-0.0594394207,
0.0076480373,
-0.0032403586,
-0.0406791866,
-0.0531878732,
-0.0537415855,
0.0203666408,
0.0157829244,
-0.0034100765,
0.0117780119,
0.0953103006,
0.0451184623,
-0.0397529565,
0.0068695704,
-0.0044238353,
-0.0098063732,
-0.0152075319,
-0.1070341766,
0.0038744593,
0.0606319457,
-0.0168175008,
0.0466775745,
-0.0137683768,
-0.0411489233,
-0.0134095233,
-0.0335457288,
0.0141165648,
-0.013376005,
0.014472967,
-0.0000551956,
-0.0104017146,
0.0427361727,
-0.0102710193,
-0.0302192457,
0.0318678468,
0.0595751405,
0.0159373302,
-0.014590201,
0.0516640432,
0.0101511413,
-0.0290039349,
-0.0547523983,
-0.0519896224,
-0.0199276507,
0.011463644,
-0.0285133775,
0.0829191729,
0.020320639,
-0.068939127,
-0.0611837283,
-0.0227597896,
-0.0376795083,
-0.0062071676,
-0.0245414153,
0.0166660752,
-0.0273332056,
-0.009392675,
-0.0418908074,
0.0474868119,
-0.0906570181,
0.0106120845,
0.0094536599,
0.1098327637,
0.0373840481,
0.0475670062,
-0.0118074669,
-0.0101471795,
-0.0008374959,
-0.0200203676,
-0.0068110544,
0.0028658097,
-0.0118732769,
-0.0196514595,
0.0231559463,
-0.0029666245,
0.0512553453,
0.0199242495,
-0.0177162755,
-0.0132786501,
-0.0127767641,
-0.0000744261,
0.0241664313,
-0.0170901325,
0.0105657224,
-0.0124157295,
0.0142088151,
-0.0114283655,
0.0326842368,
-0.0337929167,
-0.0334145278,
0.0103366422,
-0.0056550037,
-0.0819492191,
0.017043449,
0.0437973328,
-0.0424008705,
-0.0154639157,
0.0958186984,
-0.0318918116,
-0.0109205749,
-0.0674372092,
0.0184425209,
-0.0006079108,
-0.0106650777,
0.0063620037,
-0.0511155017,
0.0196950473,
-0.0069675394,
-0.0025230416,
0.0215798169,
0.007434593,
0.013098741,
0.0513947308,
0.0023262056,
0.0662306324,
-0.1014191434,
-0.0091355778,
-0.0414685011,
-0.0066536614,
0.0062353113,
-5.715673038e-33,
-0.0186442528,
-0.0352429673,
-0.0015548141,
0.0439345129,
0.0105297901,
-0.0431644358,
-0.0149986055,
0.0245047901,
-0.0458586924,
0.0101005519,
-0.0099664219,
0.0271297209,
0.0333554782,
0.0008846771,
0.0236795153,
0.0060917628,
0.0230018515,
0.013695538,
-0.0251063891,
0.0003701424,
0.0878765061,
-0.0144016314,
0.0745450407,
-0.1298335344,
0.0401306748,
0.0192497373,
0.0026404299,
-0.0412399396,
0.0940049663,
0.0056040059,
-0.0402852558,
0.0202637389,
-0.0024144801,
-0.0281070173,
-0.0075419792,
0.0355445258,
-0.0258572809,
-0.0270074047,
0.0145009542,
0.002203604,
0.015166916,
-0.0000941594,
0.0112624075,
0.0276407599,
-0.0183170997,
0.0292834882,
0.0526577048,
-0.0194404703,
-0.0011216796,
-0.0259809867,
-0.0682801232,
0.0578366481,
-0.0484625399,
0.0490968525,
-0.0144771114,
0.0057228254,
0.0170967262,
0.0102197006,
-0.0241350681,
0.0381062143,
-0.0242265221,
0.0192639288,
-0.0213908385,
-0.0512203947,
0.0146805588,
0.0945226476,
0.0110413991,
0.0269627403,
-0.0099453423,
0.0212699901,
-0.006659898,
-0.0041873702,
0.0145392986,
0.0624268539,
0.0618155226,
-0.0350383297,
-0.1056469902,
0.0100604082,
0.0507110469,
0.0356727913,
-0.0077351299,
-0.0037179196,
0.0321602374,
-0.0118566267,
0.0258340705,
-0.0348761939,
0.0117121106,
-0.0211579092,
-0.0016811889,
-0.0417160802,
-0.0215419289,
0.0418158062,
0.0254011322,
-0.0286464058,
0.0087715834,
0.0375899337,
-0.0135824857,
0.0244612768,
-0.0120695829,
-0.0381958783,
-0.0399401486,
-0.0385448858,
-0.017608555,
-0.0046809404,
0.0424335897,
-0.0119703896,
-0.0241825115,
-0.0064137457,
-0.0365908332,
-0.0036189067,
-0.0005476565,
0.0386861525,
-0.0314821228,
0.0119303269,
-0.0250052512,
0.0145633128,
0.0108043263,
0.032596264,
-0.0097490819,
0.0190559644,
0.0250091497,
0.0024487232,
-0.0311073326,
0.0027271376,
-0.0094087366,
-0.0425571427,
-0.018144317,
0.0409165733,
0.0037867553,
0.0176214557,
0.0000309895,
-0.0453108251,
2.325e-7,
0.0458429009,
0.0763921738,
0.0196278151,
-0.0154916327,
0.0015638827,
0.0095357578,
-0.0057231667,
0.0362602286,
-0.0277541112,
-0.0440966599,
0.0114991134,
-0.0200262666,
0.0429655649,
0.0755757987,
-0.1074938998,
-0.0032564304,
-0.0085664345,
-0.0594134554,
-0.0642105192,
0.0473560914,
0.0529937185,
0.0681241155,
0.0268362984,
0.0016915567,
-0.0646575615,
-0.0065404647,
0.013820298,
-0.0205966737,
-0.0657521188,
0.0285647195,
0.0615157485,
-0.0156389028,
0.0031947736,
-0.0085101714,
-0.0341061205,
0.0040735435,
-0.017028125,
0.0350532793,
0.0046643326,
-0.0069758808,
-0.0129385469,
-0.0247400962,
-0.0171073899,
0.0362930298,
0.0441850349,
-0.0593079925,
-0.0373028554,
-0.0510603078,
-0.0142401969,
0.0198903196,
0.0099579347,
0.0185022149,
-0.0054179346,
0.043121431,
-0.0077443249,
-0.0544464365,
0.0138231013,
-0.044150319,
-0.004864932,
0.0356500037,
-0.0124115758,
-0.0257421527,
0.0349676497,
0.0155620445,
0.0400505885,
0.0218297951,
0.0366412625,
1.624670372e-34,
0.0344240442,
-0.004494098,
-0.0131393746,
0.0099379057,
0.0579699352,
-0.0066886302,
-0.0560930669,
0.0043370118,
-0.0107066752,
-0.0090762442,
0.0412736796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13551v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13551v1 | Mitigating Social Biases in Language Models through Unlearning | 2024-06-19T13:38:34 | 2024-06-19T13:38:34 | Omkar Dige, Diljot Singh, Tsz Fung Yau, Qixuan Zhang, Borna Bolandraftar, Xiaodan Zhu, Faiza Khan Khattak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mitigating bias in language models (LMs) has become a critical problem due to
the widespread deployment of LMs. Numerous approaches revolve around data
pre-processing and fine-tuning of language models, tasks that can be both
time-consuming and computationally demanding. Consequently, there is a growing
interest in machine unlearning techniques given their capacity to induce the
forgetting of undesired behaviors of the existing pre-trained or fine-tuned
models with lower computational cost. In this work, we explore two unlearning
methods, (1) Partitioned Contrastive Gradient Unlearning (PCGU) applied on
decoder models and (2) Negation via Task Vector, to reduce social biases in
state-of-the-art and open-source LMs such as LLaMA-2 and OPT. We also implement
distributed PCGU for large models. It is empirically shown, through
quantitative and qualitative analyses, that negation via Task Vector method
outperforms PCGU in debiasing with minimum deterioration in performance and
perplexity of the models. On LLaMA-27B, negation via Task Vector reduces the
bias score by 11.8% | [
0.0065531586,
0.050779555,
-0.0126268771,
0.072348386,
-0.013371788,
0.0343867615,
0.0324376039,
-0.0273598675,
0.0156675708,
-0.015843302,
-0.0883895457,
-0.0287026968,
0.032625407,
0.0044780881,
0.0280113649,
-0.0309891086,
0.0297591146,
-0.004039974,
0.0395275019,
-0.0651174784,
-0.0005365978,
0.0221983995,
0.0023837809,
0.0002889625,
0.0300285257,
-0.026268322,
0.012461463,
0.0247919802,
-0.005547334,
-0.0069762887,
0.0454035737,
0.0588283129,
-0.0023342748,
0.034960147,
0.0000019544,
-0.0410382859,
-0.0162005257,
-0.0198936369,
-0.0120528303,
0.0134845609,
0.0782030225,
-0.0243934672,
0.0003751049,
0.0396772996,
-0.043478433,
-0.0390790589,
0.0608578064,
0.0312153846,
0.0295058507,
0.0664556101,
-0.005508801,
-0.0541625433,
-0.0348732471,
-0.0478029661,
-0.0260394104,
-0.0120460866,
0.0329924151,
-0.0308192447,
-0.0678504631,
-0.0310925823,
-0.0499605015,
0.0510746054,
0.0176510047,
0.0491552763,
0.021232985,
0.0397940688,
0.0010999717,
-0.0347751714,
-0.0149268406,
0.0748426244,
-0.0233843904,
-0.045073431,
0.0089836959,
-0.0105095683,
-0.0111820037,
0.0004617431,
-0.0114028379,
-0.0122065907,
0.0038405068,
0.0695345998,
0.0437147729,
-0.0031940038,
0.0400235765,
-0.0069590691,
0.0081025995,
0.0625901446,
0.0254927818,
-0.0143268853,
0.0072794799,
0.0395978168,
0.0229612701,
-0.0333111249,
0.0197087266,
-0.0084504383,
-0.0262233336,
0.006592962,
-0.0146355405,
-0.0416828245,
0.0015374818,
-0.0444569029,
0.0383347347,
0.0237722173,
-0.0216649119,
0.0292375963,
0.0022753912,
-0.0063925912,
0.0021403357,
0.0283500459,
-0.0358650014,
-0.0104138032,
0.0137958005,
-0.0030275867,
0.011084524,
0.0333847664,
-0.0401279554,
0.0527929962,
0.0033059698,
-0.0100514125,
-0.040430367,
-0.0328564569,
0.0521197468,
0.0318730064,
-0.0672417879,
0.0001942929,
-0.0192181282,
0.0507060811,
-0.0287594311,
0.0450744815,
-0.043282263,
-0.1015597358,
-0.0195666924,
-0.0098692803,
0.0295637064,
-0.0362198092,
0.0111912694,
0.0308283512,
-0.0357807912,
-0.0260300264,
-0.0377966389,
-0.0090154624,
-0.0199115127,
-0.0839188397,
0.0123442477,
-0.0444006324,
0.0389561057,
0.0111742029,
-0.0013274277,
-0.0888479128,
-0.0204010364,
-0.0199049301,
-0.0541993044,
0.0506937988,
-0.00232103,
0.0119740386,
0.0338125601,
0.0091104396,
-0.010372974,
0.0966885015,
-0.0264249593,
-0.0059420499,
0.0268384498,
-0.0022899015,
0.0283499099,
0.0383262597,
0.0748737231,
-0.0154011045,
-0.0222482085,
-0.0351331346,
0.0057318751,
-0.0351024307,
0.0896527767,
0.0723187923,
-0.0176721979,
-0.0558950193,
0.0801969767,
-0.0016230366,
-0.0207556989,
0.0321834348,
-0.0100969393,
0.0193813723,
0.0007550134,
0.0476059541,
-0.0536610745,
0.0231710691,
-0.031558264,
-0.0212360006,
0.0349975154,
0.0483803526,
-0.0669234917,
-0.0293046907,
0.0524960943,
-0.0302569661,
0.0678720847,
0.0188467484,
0.0705029517,
0.0247180182,
-0.0425897203,
0.0490735918,
0.0663646013,
-0.0558016151,
0.0239904188,
-0.0361743979,
0.0575778224,
0.02377134,
0.0432253778,
-0.0211749487,
-0.018500872,
0.0152026918,
-0.02260671,
0.0342086554,
0.0435891636,
-0.0288293995,
0.0563883856,
-0.075331226,
-0.0250433404,
0.0274861343,
0.0192454066,
0.0214594882,
0.036683023,
-0.0051516281,
0.0196881834,
-0.0473848358,
-0.0315671936,
0.0281362534,
-0.0176937263,
-0.0422727875,
0.0087941699,
-0.002452198,
0.0396366343,
0.027911948,
-0.0125960652,
-0.0052756299,
0.0292844158,
-0.0329362638,
0.0205406733,
0.0206112098,
-0.0772031397,
-0.0868425146,
0.0241183564,
-0.0228011478,
-0.0016082629,
0.1204748973,
-0.03756015,
-0.016219154,
0.06592381,
-0.0033499745,
0.0631245598,
-0.0171432402,
0.0188515279,
-0.0394615307,
0.0434557535,
-0.0233157091,
0.0481349491,
-0.0261403807,
-0.0308167096,
-0.0036788743,
-0.0346363895,
-0.028698625,
-0.065512754,
-0.0326099508,
0.008507885,
0.0131838918,
-0.0077177063,
-0.0006622061,
-0.0310354903,
-0.0077390214,
0.007769668,
-0.0767912567,
-0.039724946,
-0.0446054377,
0.0217803512,
0.0098112589,
0.0109949298,
0.005690801,
-0.0560987256,
-0.0212187953,
-0.0036344936,
-0.0060783355,
0.0152935479,
-0.0123428609,
-0.0283854622,
-0.0311476439,
-0.0396373309,
-0.0393832698,
-0.0007622786,
0.0356210656,
-0.007261904,
-0.0254090391,
-0.0396104157,
0.0502676703,
-0.026509542,
0.0378270634,
-0.0037461489,
0.003823508,
-0.0109609244,
0.0311379898,
0.0392225571,
0.0892068222,
-0.0340292566,
0.008243327,
0.0568593778,
-0.002606693,
-0.0336865708,
-0.0241646226,
-0.0153909316,
-0.0089525441,
-0.0219713617,
-0.0436972156,
-0.0248862039,
0.0766609833,
0.037142273,
-0.0117302658,
-0.0497029833,
0.0092893429,
-0.0169756524,
-0.0725346953,
0.0085035106,
-0.012835633,
-0.0236840248,
0.0060889171,
-0.0564668104,
-0.0803871676,
0.0618688241,
-0.023917878,
-0.0165431835,
-0.0578211807,
0.0031971035,
-0.0150152743,
0.0286030825,
-0.0207409132,
0.0226617623,
0.0025480459,
-0.0328145102,
-0.0415290743,
-0.0457324199,
0.0289216451,
-0.0428260304,
0.0240302812,
-0.0504005738,
-0.0149811599,
-0.0129762897,
-0.0319673382,
-0.0309082195,
-0.0341651589,
-0.031313248,
-0.0160851181,
0.0412320569,
-0.0040976838,
0.0299109686,
-0.017697392,
-0.0174656212,
0.0113461195,
-0.01033914,
0.0291891508,
-0.0174425654,
0.0346404314,
0.0284520127,
-0.0053145327,
0.019201234,
-0.0308025517,
-0.0143751474,
0.0236847401,
0.0534291156,
-0.018581463,
-0.0176473763,
0.0091501335,
0.0400304347,
0.0280950237,
-0.0131804654,
0.015920857,
0.0498317182,
-0.0111171389,
-0.0083330804,
0.1091379896,
0.0035770047,
-0.0835976228,
0.0123406891,
0.0037449626,
0.0355041586,
0.0122158546,
-0.0021936554,
-0.0531573929,
-0.0293156169,
0.0104236314,
0.0327580906,
0.0254584644,
-0.025086306,
-0.0038757101,
-0.1308173686,
0.0169209931,
0.045863539,
-0.0015024694,
-0.0388032272,
-0.0436428562,
-0.0071326899,
-0.0466720685,
0.0317327753,
0.0261472948,
0.0073979143,
0.0064709969,
0.0407901853,
-0.0385758691,
-0.0762355477,
0.006102466,
-0.0525464453,
0.1007781848,
0.0441777073,
0.021356849,
-0.0287069678,
-0.0259260517,
0.0388359986,
0.0100455172,
-0.0116734719,
-0.0426768735,
0.0444794558,
-0.036824882,
-0.016559707,
-0.013413352,
0.041217085,
-0.0342250764,
0.0095347911,
-0.0434756465,
0.0522462316,
0.0107794562,
-0.0427717976,
0.0109327976,
-0.0275529716,
0.0047553475,
0.08983621,
0.0336971618,
-0.0216496252,
-0.022501003,
-0.0080632912,
0.0153069189,
0.0129649332,
-0.0031299123,
-0.0146440221,
0.0034572694,
-0.0480525568,
-0.0409214795,
-0.0204666443,
0.020876294,
0.0016624338,
0.0155838169,
0.0202226229,
0.0428015999,
-0.0070658112,
-0.053305842,
-0.0143026281,
-0.038843479,
0.0250057206,
0.0032937888,
-0.0267166551,
-0.0003253287,
-0.0239836033,
-0.0003510533,
0.0004456542,
-0.0532074682,
-0.099497132,
0.0347421505,
0.0247291494,
0.0222543161,
0.0670520663,
-0.0123803159,
-0.0828262642,
0.0749801025,
0.0433748029,
-0.0162928347,
0.0686984882,
0.0349025391,
-0.0282222014,
0.0231868792,
0.0503448397,
-0.0374579094,
0.0199139155,
0.048115667,
0.0237831064,
-0.0213589668,
-0.0101153012,
-0.0159199387,
-0.006407626,
0.0822848305,
-0.0173795037,
-0.0058685024,
-0.0494496934,
-0.0082595963,
-0.0213278625,
-0.0077455016,
-0.0242021102,
-0.032345891,
0.0274538696,
0.0327341221,
-0.0194987282,
0.0093018431,
-0.0349399261,
0.0373283327,
-0.0203624256,
0.0255408045,
0.0160088334,
0.0010982229,
0.0007179183,
0.0152911255,
-0.0065366328,
0.0220087282,
0.004901574,
0.0247951522,
0.0156356171,
0.0071336888,
0.0130984634,
0.0191365369,
-0.0535621494,
0.0219314322,
-0.013250852,
0.0000236362,
-0.0388155952,
-0.0134115303,
0.0472362302,
-0.0227794424,
0.0605667271,
0.0316576958,
0.0153812058,
-0.0292590875,
0.0038697158,
-0.0183420926,
0.0094224429,
0.051131662,
-0.0035795951,
-0.0400121883,
0.0327623598,
0.1078459099,
0.0061203614,
0.0313851684,
-0.0063076373,
0.0087041939,
-0.0126986476,
-0.0266723968,
0.0235091168,
-0.0054516159,
-0.0530632809,
-0.0220504124,
-0.0362619124,
-0.0850003287,
-0.0129082277,
-0.0149725042,
0.0182603449,
-0.0320787318,
0.0442206413,
0.0460549779,
-0.0463854596,
-0.0398574807,
-0.0194855873,
-0.0148152616,
-0.0098303137,
-0.0190339703,
-0.0213113427,
-7.036330656e-33,
-0.0111547206,
0.0031406644,
-0.0202328954,
0.0025711311,
0.0117546432,
0.003855075,
-0.045667246,
-0.0063033896,
-0.0327312648,
0.0242861137,
-0.0167435296,
0.0381618515,
0.0286716595,
-0.0062423167,
-0.008036688,
-0.0223674905,
0.0949780792,
-0.0209042598,
-0.0178683512,
0.0158131104,
0.0128198722,
0.0446842238,
0.0491836481,
-0.0823550895,
0.0307227746,
-0.0142027419,
-0.0006734894,
0.0216216892,
0.0187249072,
-0.0048805801,
-0.0480562039,
0.0460760593,
0.0282911565,
-0.0388932191,
-0.0221672039,
0.0184763428,
-0.0740032792,
-0.003372045,
0.0160484388,
0.0201230422,
-0.0299969949,
-0.028089961,
0.0377506912,
0.0343289673,
-0.0672464445,
0.0160716921,
0.007255449,
0.016491076,
0.0077908128,
0.0305685867,
-0.0422983877,
0.0098432498,
-0.0025196846,
-0.0239310693,
0.039899569,
-0.025512334,
-0.004596903,
0.0258518904,
-0.0708819032,
0.0268144775,
0.0054007503,
-0.0020420298,
0.0886654779,
0.0388625786,
0.0186677352,
0.0543576442,
0.0867815539,
0.0148451803,
-0.0123314587,
-0.0494297296,
0.0477510691,
0.0145141305,
0.018064823,
0.0224974323,
0.0340029709,
-0.0301127937,
-0.047329478,
0.0160133243,
0.034476541,
0.0197248459,
0.0349356979,
0.0351999104,
-0.0434641354,
-0.0640029311,
-0.0157686267,
-0.0832205266,
-0.0151425209,
-0.0018090473,
0.0024143911,
0.0283685923,
-0.0454468913,
0.0120812505,
0.0322929397,
-0.050525941,
0.0029536546,
0.0333293974,
0.0169389602,
-0.013578523,
0.0042403187,
-0.0167125668,
-0.1080577001,
0.0016132734,
0.0134942811,
0.0280436594,
-0.0029985146,
-0.0047853715,
0.0097339125,
0.0408859625,
-0.05138335,
0.0002176939,
-0.0333839729,
-0.0118167996,
0.0492954403,
0.0489130877,
0.0361194685,
0.0085578775,
-0.0037373996,
0.0065932414,
0.0406401828,
0.0251169503,
-0.0687147826,
0.0031493388,
0.0049891835,
0.0124125155,
-0.0228650812,
-0.0260755699,
-0.0030369626,
-0.0058135926,
0.0490440018,
-0.0232322887,
-0.0240490083,
-0.0175991841,
2.612e-7,
0.0004804894,
0.0481895767,
0.0270378646,
0.0059140418,
0.0288788863,
0.0563830249,
-0.0007807353,
0.0441095978,
0.0075401105,
-0.0005586131,
-0.0016897131,
0.0549239665,
0.0303101093,
0.0309269167,
-0.0604855344,
0.0296805277,
-0.0725295916,
0.0193443056,
-0.0060035991,
-0.0551943891,
-0.013626351,
0.0993907452,
0.0124416063,
-0.0089427568,
0.0032405921,
0.0065768152,
0.0357172415,
-0.0213992316,
0.0055535603,
0.0095301326,
0.0168941766,
-0.0079600764,
0.0079071652,
0.0169907026,
0.0025923871,
0.0115057426,
-0.0114088422,
0.0461693555,
-0.0295377411,
-0.0567975417,
-0.0039517358,
0.0200403538,
-0.0236463603,
-0.0374292992,
0.07736101,
-0.0030300822,
-0.0468663834,
-0.0137211969,
-0.0131507851,
0.018472949,
0.0223058239,
0.0078668268,
-0.0249469113,
0.0086625824,
0.0215484463,
-0.0135948835,
-0.0413488038,
-0.0603715815,
-0.032351125,
-0.0095723746,
-0.0246347133,
-0.0692762434,
0.0275022518,
0.0468939878,
0.013170355,
-0.044910077,
0.0655285567,
2.1887714e-34,
0.0293744504,
-0.0049462854,
0.0102735618,
0.0140657527,
0.0083676185,
-0.0444970876,
-0.0854270831,
0.0073896488,
0.0298427865,
-0.0634931326,
0.0070515699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13542v1 | Self-play with Execution Feedback: Improving Instruction-following Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T13:29:53 | 2024-06-19T13:29:53 | Guanting Dong, Keming Lu, Chengpeng Li, Tingyu Xia, Bowen Yu, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | One core capability of large language models (LLMs) is to follow natural
language instructions. However, the issue of automatically constructing
high-quality training data to enhance the complex instruction-following
abilities of LLMs without manual annotation remains unresolved. In this paper,
we introduce AutoIF, the first scalable and reliable method for automatically
generating instruction-following training data. AutoIF transforms the
validation of instruction-following data quality into code verification,
requiring LLMs to generate instructions, the corresponding code to check the
correctness of the instruction responses, and unit test samples to verify the
code's correctness. Then, execution feedback-based rejection sampling can
generate data for Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from
Human Feedback (RLHF) training. AutoIF achieves significant improvements across
three training algorithms, SFT, Offline DPO, and Online DPO, when applied to
the top open-source LLMs, Qwen2 and LLaMA3, in self-alignment and
strong-to-weak distillation settings. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/QwenLM/AutoIF. | [
0.0142989112,
0.041497834,
-0.0193108302,
0.0219535921,
0.0073331711,
0.01141176,
-0.0472013503,
-0.0168803241,
0.0156354066,
-0.0226276461,
-0.0665123016,
0.0012811164,
-0.0039957957,
0.0065831495,
0.048948653,
-0.0082180398,
0.0498412922,
-0.0647210032,
-0.0351244994,
-0.0124407001,
-0.0055400687,
0.0144703127,
-0.0269400328,
0.0282949228,
0.0517074242,
-0.0327735916,
-0.0297954548,
0.0135438731,
-0.0190132502,
-0.0644193143,
0.0207240656,
0.0703965724,
0.0314729735,
0.025647331,
0.0000021573,
-0.0459039733,
-0.0087592676,
-0.0137887327,
-0.0154552776,
0.0280165244,
0.0141357658,
-0.0036780096,
-0.0407267995,
0.0424519181,
-0.0162196681,
0.0023174176,
0.0433916859,
-0.0092175193,
0.1150733903,
0.0890095383,
0.0384599566,
-0.0081898803,
0.0291151013,
-0.0077067129,
0.0017317639,
-0.0087887859,
0.002223195,
0.0320150107,
0.0316948481,
0.0214491263,
-0.0227123853,
0.0096420776,
0.0274929535,
-0.0087079704,
-0.0581310876,
0.0295594055,
-0.0343276076,
-0.006299255,
-0.0244381819,
0.0716969296,
-0.00716933,
-0.039281182,
-0.0051632128,
-0.0130914655,
-0.011420086,
-0.0260585528,
-0.0244778339,
0.0329077579,
0.0227282234,
0.0372953936,
0.0237377826,
-0.0453728661,
0.0105104679,
-0.003441744,
0.0038531781,
0.0650529414,
-0.0014492167,
-0.048356358,
0.0082157077,
0.0006539575,
-0.0274258759,
-0.0498957522,
-0.0298585072,
0.0411869138,
-0.0599081703,
0.0150345936,
-0.0696635693,
-0.0071516284,
0.0315555073,
-0.0037397791,
0.0841988102,
0.0344728418,
-0.0158304982,
-0.0078178048,
-0.0194057673,
0.0641201437,
-0.0132583091,
0.0550965406,
-0.0138441911,
0.0504907258,
-0.0548195317,
0.0149981771,
-0.0364527293,
0.042575229,
-0.0291157309,
0.0122971181,
-0.0570367128,
0.0328554101,
-0.0337645784,
0.060371317,
0.0051732874,
-0.0159302838,
-0.0687989891,
0.0222731344,
-0.0328192227,
0.0165190697,
-0.0404245891,
-0.0194165111,
0.0032447565,
-0.0582616702,
-0.0120578865,
-0.0030599034,
-0.0284272619,
-0.0230345577,
0.0407751426,
0.0648363456,
0.0041293181,
-0.012377182,
-0.0387250036,
-0.0213302244,
-0.0173329897,
-0.0686264336,
0.0097100539,
-0.0812664032,
-0.0009332192,
-0.030105114,
0.0062787523,
-0.0173121598,
0.0227313787,
0.0218968354,
0.0122214453,
0.0534096472,
-0.0226578973,
0.0115428437,
-0.0161962826,
-0.0335933007,
0.025763832,
0.075331755,
0.0643871725,
-0.0138717331,
0.017946953,
-0.0199015364,
0.0100228032,
0.048667524,
0.0344731659,
0.0412370451,
-0.0154001173,
-0.0056078197,
-0.0115122581,
0.0389913581,
0.051393494,
0.0412770398,
-0.0077391621,
0.009926754,
0.0271597691,
0.0246254448,
0.021318851,
-0.0211216789,
0.0548872352,
0.0456919931,
-0.0011793317,
0.0155538153,
-0.0719274059,
0.0295995381,
0.003973424,
0.0373186395,
0.0200820714,
0.0263892338,
-0.0235207081,
-0.0529580154,
0.0165223703,
-0.0046872399,
-0.0120959589,
0.0108943405,
0.0496395752,
0.0174348745,
-0.0555906296,
-0.0043973471,
0.0555216409,
-0.026105633,
-0.0051554427,
-0.0730916709,
0.0275118109,
0.0579725318,
0.0523726977,
-0.0346338898,
-0.028593054,
-0.0210199151,
-0.0009722509,
0.0268924776,
0.0356822796,
-0.009691271,
-0.0031418318,
-0.0170180816,
-0.025671931,
-0.0251784213,
-0.0010408314,
0.0061712158,
0.0253707301,
-0.0170301404,
-0.0078289276,
0.018902583,
-0.0858004987,
0.0635849535,
-0.0017286491,
-0.0758651346,
-0.0028305801,
0.013019681,
0.03852465,
0.0216434766,
-0.0114653073,
0.0061964979,
0.041511748,
0.0093126465,
0.0302430633,
-0.0463576168,
-0.0459739231,
-0.0677892864,
0.0382069163,
0.0140664512,
-0.0354770347,
0.0320166759,
-0.0524100512,
-0.0347528271,
0.0056702681,
-0.030933734,
0.0040700939,
-0.0078564566,
0.0331861787,
-0.0082739834,
-0.0039739748,
-0.0385772362,
0.0121848192,
-0.0121733369,
0.0195241887,
0.0073885075,
0.0367124751,
0.0012611675,
-0.03499832,
-0.0308824535,
0.0094733005,
-0.0250854753,
0.025841007,
0.0121096913,
0.0692079365,
-0.0476040952,
-0.023651842,
-0.0525082387,
0.045465339,
-0.0380181484,
0.0183161255,
0.0360520035,
-0.0027052858,
-0.0168688055,
-0.0299299937,
0.0004468495,
-0.0413372219,
0.0231374893,
0.0017615595,
0.043041423,
0.0095253633,
-0.0446384437,
-0.0570492186,
-0.0228176918,
-0.0332584009,
-0.017054202,
-0.0218990725,
0.0653099492,
-0.0950151905,
0.0320098922,
-0.0054748924,
0.0710009784,
0.0111188805,
-0.0825087726,
0.0517364778,
-0.0128618469,
-0.0050824108,
0.0972261876,
-0.0226947963,
0.0079360595,
0.0707625374,
-0.0008893776,
-0.0890173987,
0.0326184779,
-0.0219999198,
-0.0784315616,
-0.034487877,
-0.0062340135,
0.0215425547,
0.0875899494,
0.0016548247,
0.0055741244,
-0.0738155171,
-0.0175806209,
0.0016767132,
-0.0124238124,
0.0282831993,
0.0021051357,
-0.0611546598,
-0.0067452248,
-0.0264936574,
-0.0840910524,
0.093943499,
-0.0511487238,
-0.0163970813,
-0.0407226495,
-0.0004546219,
-0.006171592,
0.0336330533,
0.0207865071,
0.0032512783,
0.0061333883,
-0.0227791648,
-0.0398625098,
-0.0092483517,
0.0288139991,
-0.0418538339,
0.0373197719,
-0.0517921038,
-0.0090562394,
0.014725754,
-0.0339295603,
-0.048160959,
-0.0097569497,
-0.0175908431,
-0.0169585235,
0.0168578345,
-0.0151219051,
0.0168225858,
-0.004965723,
0.0195211098,
0.0381782353,
-0.0253169648,
-0.0175179876,
-0.0525042787,
-0.0290431827,
0.0444302484,
-0.0043712151,
-0.0078825792,
-0.0465847142,
0.0283679441,
0.0057268548,
0.0562315173,
0.0093428716,
-0.0364886001,
0.0224977247,
0.0331218392,
-0.036340639,
0.0088432552,
0.0622872338,
0.0811019316,
-0.0627096221,
-0.0318839699,
0.1109202355,
0.0344856977,
-0.0148177473,
0.0217030477,
0.0037882454,
0.0631923601,
0.0403608158,
0.0654063895,
-0.078921847,
-0.0290519521,
-0.004381469,
0.0799215063,
-0.0019868172,
-0.0076198108,
-0.0081324894,
-0.1565995067,
0.030438263,
0.0256543383,
-0.0260486789,
-0.0607232638,
-0.0329357609,
-0.000749095,
-0.0037521718,
0.01684816,
0.0326027758,
-0.0197550561,
0.0052355677,
0.0301127918,
-0.0071099796,
-0.0433934554,
0.045118928,
-0.0622482672,
0.1086375713,
0.1065963581,
-0.0000478816,
0.007886176,
-0.0219101477,
0.0185560547,
-0.0249011945,
0.0022352953,
-0.0225032959,
0.0569234416,
-0.0255222358,
-0.0123616941,
0.0133092701,
0.0539284274,
-0.0206634048,
0.0165389534,
0.0135723967,
0.0596011132,
-0.0184921511,
-0.0153995734,
0.0013305439,
0.0068455744,
0.0098206243,
0.0252699908,
0.0077734175,
-0.0467292182,
-0.0155579932,
-0.0313487798,
-0.0229348484,
-0.0660792366,
-0.0201242343,
0.0123696206,
-0.0461327061,
0.0099568302,
-0.0559730865,
-0.0406734012,
0.0242189504,
0.0366660766,
0.007525851,
-0.0213042684,
0.0376847908,
-0.0024564113,
-0.0052925153,
0.015294739,
-0.0373515673,
0.0146228867,
-0.0924454331,
-0.0417568907,
0.0301952343,
0.0049210596,
0.0068012583,
0.0252375621,
-0.0643819794,
-0.0761176273,
0.0034968592,
0.1065522656,
0.0122447442,
0.08192157,
-0.0088755377,
-0.0199870635,
-0.017576728,
0.0151129393,
-0.0531142056,
-0.0013955954,
0.0244516544,
0.0071623735,
0.0044772327,
0.0281455778,
-0.0393592007,
0.0304407459,
0.008606269,
0.0419923626,
0.0064852126,
-0.0161265098,
0.0432212353,
0.0096711228,
0.0400653929,
-0.0244337842,
0.0048382194,
-0.0271489322,
0.0213650055,
-0.007325198,
-0.0173034742,
-0.0384306237,
0.0299140289,
-0.0037969013,
-0.0530386232,
0.0047826618,
-0.0308257341,
-0.0232577641,
0.020053586,
-0.0189238954,
0.0323527642,
0.0074971085,
0.0343307741,
0.0261399057,
0.0132521922,
0.0099634659,
0.042384021,
0.0378808118,
0.0658724383,
0.0046925046,
0.0740850344,
0.0256218109,
0.0240002554,
-0.0249837395,
0.0137096737,
-0.0139766596,
-0.02237189,
-0.0479252487,
-0.0024862222,
0.0524369739,
0.001253786,
0.0368183032,
-0.0116115361,
0.0157021713,
0.0021103893,
0.029622132,
-0.0467465594,
-0.0011049222,
0.0203844104,
0.0402517505,
-0.0016451408,
-0.0170598924,
0.0473648012,
0.0184218623,
0.0375144705,
0.0004334156,
0.0390966535,
-0.0374300666,
-0.0086564692,
0.0141608957,
0.0011178091,
-0.0411999263,
-0.0112108178,
0.0001327972,
-0.0718494803,
-0.0405582637,
0.0789140835,
0.0012356822,
-0.0261174738,
0.0458662063,
0.0239929855,
-0.0183447227,
-0.0187911838,
-0.0362390317,
-0.0088574067,
0.0217624232,
-0.0423248373,
-0.0089949146,
-6.494239681e-33,
-0.0590858497,
-0.0122556239,
0.0333730616,
0.0035142163,
-0.0358821414,
-0.0281968527,
-0.0437447615,
-0.0127082737,
0.0042925132,
0.0018593272,
-0.007714876,
0.0166082997,
0.0124011552,
-0.0004316533,
0.042514246,
0.0089036478,
0.0514846407,
-0.0446399003,
-0.0675526708,
0.0310810022,
-0.007770062,
0.000971014,
0.0317889154,
-0.0375513956,
0.0309773516,
0.0034695482,
-0.0126717808,
0.0216372609,
-0.034075927,
0.0722530186,
0.018910829,
0.0077678403,
-0.0113486368,
-0.027177684,
-0.0250789225,
0.0005515569,
-0.0654684752,
-0.0474272221,
-0.0009225422,
-0.0094019957,
-0.0455660447,
-0.0058729742,
0.0562424548,
-0.0302682333,
-0.0447838716,
0.0190555938,
0.0021034768,
0.0060848473,
0.0116946669,
0.0166349038,
-0.0608957671,
0.0019793794,
-0.0283670388,
-0.0547323599,
0.0130090294,
0.0016585618,
0.011351021,
-0.0045368266,
-0.0104883071,
0.02646745,
0.0621617548,
0.0566879362,
0.0715114921,
0.0214242879,
0.0225804262,
0.0271316897,
0.0033384592,
0.011169265,
0.0252420846,
-0.0052489107,
0.0809610635,
0.0330889188,
-0.0016718417,
0.0136478562,
0.0287419558,
-0.0057193995,
-0.0208946131,
0.0106721399,
-0.0137682715,
0.0548890084,
0.0070410166,
-0.0091385702,
-0.0702692494,
-0.0092616174,
-0.0459427088,
-0.0065059233,
-0.002966749,
-0.0419326574,
0.0450304858,
0.0186048485,
-0.0426161028,
-0.037000291,
0.0133564398,
-0.0323082693,
-0.0318779573,
-0.0264284816,
-0.0476012826,
0.0180413462,
-0.0298199486,
-0.0012663554,
-0.0502143688,
-0.0479612909,
0.0021772424,
-0.0476100519,
0.0396108963,
0.0120331226,
0.0165429972,
0.0286027528,
-0.0825778916,
0.0268077776,
-0.0322497636,
0.0355318785,
0.0059968866,
-0.0019397119,
0.0195639618,
-0.0077989502,
0.0012174938,
0.0650007874,
0.0103248376,
-0.0632986203,
-0.0543224253,
0.0106197055,
0.010962557,
0.0316063464,
-0.0352213681,
0.005920277,
-0.0577812865,
0.0405033417,
-0.0149349095,
-0.0526414067,
-0.0224973299,
0.0060531767,
2.906e-7,
0.0240496881,
0.0713243484,
0.0288069062,
0.0507965833,
-0.0162758604,
0.0352349132,
-0.0392525233,
0.0137942014,
0.0116910096,
-0.0192719959,
0.015039633,
0.0420214832,
0.0248391479,
0.0272257067,
-0.0467741042,
0.0294567831,
-0.0371894203,
0.0273652915,
-0.0563412234,
-0.0292891357,
0.0022131591,
0.0909250528,
0.004496715,
0.0100602722,
0.0238774922,
0.0023084108,
0.0058389953,
0.0166413151,
0.0143718515,
0.0476955809,
-0.0403766669,
0.0098339282,
-0.0228066295,
-0.0173177719,
-0.0282474197,
0.0313107707,
-0.0671947226,
0.0761471018,
-0.0128042344,
0.0092095546,
0.0253605712,
-0.0252032075,
0.0059036636,
-0.0324337445,
0.0354966074,
-0.0751495138,
0.0097205825,
-0.0337199494,
0.0112089282,
-0.050498914,
0.0035604041,
-0.0457309484,
0.0000788854,
0.0190458428,
0.0126509173,
-0.0132113779,
-0.0168768261,
-0.0381602459,
-0.0169476215,
0.0307383705,
0.0004817083,
-0.0372797027,
-0.0401497856,
0.006117607,
-0.0272241384,
-0.0585002378,
0.0143073453,
2.885135171e-34,
0.0299897846,
-0.0399332196,
0.0410134383,
0.0177910365,
0.0338190272,
0.000547327,
-0.0323799141,
0.035642121,
0.0508637652,
-0.0295587238,
-0.0410515815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13502v1 | ManWav: The First Manchu ASR Model | 2024-06-19T12:47:34 | 2024-06-19T12:47:34 | Jean Seo, Minha Kang, Sungjoo Byun, Sangah Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This study addresses the widening gap in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)
research between high resource and extremely low resource languages, with a
particular focus on Manchu, a critically endangered language. Manchu
exemplifies the challenges faced by marginalized linguistic communities in
accessing state-of-the-art technologies. In a pioneering effort, we introduce
the first-ever Manchu ASR model ManWav, leveraging Wav2Vec2-XLSR-53. The
results of the first Manchu ASR is promising, especially when trained with our
augmented data. Wav2Vec2-XLSR-53 fine-tuned with augmented data demonstrates a
0.02 drop in CER and 0.13 drop in WER compared to the same base model
fine-tuned with original data. | [
-0.0015321505,
0.0464848988,
0.0378339663,
0.0395111777,
0.0229095481,
0.0205256734,
0.0101764509,
-0.028416466,
-0.0053179525,
0.0180701856,
-0.0307008699,
-0.0330978557,
0.0736060664,
-0.0001577028,
0.0296607856,
-0.0242695939,
0.0171312075,
-0.0703089386,
0.0133864768,
-0.0214342102,
0.0076654898,
0.0068891179,
0.006073609,
0.0437937267,
-0.0061973492,
0.0281424094,
-0.0046959664,
0.0397933125,
0.0449547507,
-0.0209817961,
0.0134431953,
0.0091206394,
0.0086538363,
0.03264587,
0.0000021973,
-0.0467204042,
-0.0116814431,
0.0075952979,
-0.0513017289,
0.0520091541,
0.008603395,
-0.0115386341,
-0.0546627529,
0.0393852964,
-0.0212991443,
0.0013112858,
0.0501544438,
0.0265399609,
0.0189963859,
0.0336726382,
-0.0051552625,
-0.0359206796,
-0.0048181508,
0.0049322061,
-0.0451423079,
-0.0485103615,
0.0322024859,
-0.0307147261,
-0.0308732558,
-0.0255962107,
-0.0136419823,
0.0413076282,
0.0124581503,
-0.0094729168,
-0.0258294027,
0.0239662416,
-0.0596523508,
-0.0657675192,
-0.0102154473,
0.0549084134,
0.0007156176,
-0.0289601982,
-0.0025318589,
0.0208410565,
-0.0631529987,
-0.0240013674,
-0.0200546011,
-0.018033728,
0.0072751404,
-0.0048248181,
0.037950255,
0.0131614087,
0.0185859706,
0.0024398055,
0.0024656418,
-0.0078285132,
-0.005077349,
-0.0226239339,
0.0073864665,
-0.0580119342,
-0.0026017795,
0.0213830136,
0.039065741,
0.0079588583,
-0.0194871761,
0.0027798053,
0.0319371,
-0.0077906186,
-0.0027491106,
-0.0554169007,
0.0180137027,
0.0577690303,
-0.0722580776,
-0.0028884499,
-0.0317114852,
0.0421004966,
0.0038794221,
-0.0063644475,
-0.0376008973,
-0.0300299395,
-0.0043972596,
-0.0229751132,
-0.0649707541,
-0.0106518986,
-0.0364655033,
-0.0090135951,
-0.0044205366,
-0.0061829304,
0.0026228949,
-0.005371531,
0.0443316922,
-0.0037801045,
-0.0508214943,
0.0137471501,
0.0312298387,
0.0570753813,
0.002154337,
0.0455270857,
-0.0171797238,
-0.0862120092,
-0.0018759238,
0.0136357294,
0.0149599258,
-0.0070985053,
0.0134251891,
0.0681462139,
-0.0019906794,
-0.0226597432,
-0.053093642,
0.0498114862,
-0.0746811181,
-0.0380376466,
0.0129456986,
-0.023052495,
-0.0057408442,
0.0327727273,
0.0351523906,
0.0098482212,
-0.0024717771,
-0.0605145916,
0.0285971407,
0.0532050282,
-0.0277569164,
0.0080616632,
0.0457444675,
-0.0130238105,
0.0284065772,
0.0758909881,
0.0400385745,
-0.0221309252,
0.0163380951,
-0.0213391501,
-0.0206717402,
0.0376227722,
-0.022657048,
0.008424174,
-0.0225976706,
-0.0007545415,
0.022228431,
-0.021892162,
0.062056385,
0.0455127619,
-0.0172885172,
-0.0437302142,
0.0344250277,
0.0330270715,
0.0169615913,
0.0238811467,
0.0095960163,
0.0035212764,
-0.0031002313,
-0.0091272388,
0.0006900298,
0.0238364004,
-0.0445110649,
0.0208972581,
0.0244564284,
0.0383316241,
-0.0424114577,
-0.0445150807,
-0.036792051,
0.0088507729,
0.0396880023,
0.0055087986,
0.0546845868,
-0.0066895965,
-0.0086622518,
-0.0058486802,
0.0420649722,
-0.0251631327,
0.0361890793,
-0.0801761895,
0.0123948166,
0.0545999929,
0.0379910171,
-0.0168864969,
0.0360031687,
-0.0146190403,
-0.0263325106,
0.0391427316,
0.0561936609,
0.021522142,
0.0594560951,
-0.0674655959,
-0.026205942,
0.0379512608,
-0.0045389719,
0.0705113932,
-0.0130676441,
0.0001758864,
-0.0023286538,
-0.0476102456,
-0.0397887491,
-0.0144435754,
-0.0358484015,
-0.0080808168,
0.0229106881,
0.0192419179,
0.0823866576,
0.0627719611,
-0.0364071615,
0.0102779055,
0.0308588222,
-0.0213109478,
-0.0031751771,
0.0378374159,
-0.0472322814,
-0.0087226564,
0.0716392398,
-0.0137995146,
0.0152438581,
0.0417972617,
0.0013975895,
-0.0780597925,
0.0121619692,
0.0029314242,
0.0335620753,
-0.092656374,
0.0498551056,
0.0392302275,
0.0457704253,
0.0301295295,
0.0173280202,
0.0017095014,
-0.0068478137,
0.0345264636,
-0.0010851012,
0.0092885103,
-0.0679216757,
-0.0307770278,
-0.0006131851,
-0.0031051799,
0.0200357269,
0.012006755,
-0.0167242773,
0.0113070607,
0.0351114124,
-0.0803440735,
-0.031930808,
-0.0481398292,
-0.0048170942,
-0.0489718057,
0.0147698503,
-0.0072672125,
-0.0234621037,
-0.0175794996,
-0.0439400636,
-0.0717026442,
-0.001338903,
-0.0424763337,
-0.0161678772,
-0.0044674361,
-0.0187745374,
-0.0262693018,
0.0140205575,
-0.0354550891,
-0.0141657144,
-0.0619051121,
-0.0405569971,
-0.0378761329,
0.0198195037,
0.027005069,
-0.0349830687,
-0.0675736517,
-0.0274707004,
0.0110618956,
0.0304167271,
0.0100039458,
0.0049971803,
0.0281860065,
0.0147246839,
0.0361198187,
-0.0060781622,
0.0071972371,
0.0019550992,
-0.0110429097,
0.015780665,
0.004636318,
-0.0721185356,
0.0563444346,
0.0300060082,
0.0118553732,
-0.0459492765,
-0.0655734167,
-0.01085281,
-0.0444249399,
-0.0201093089,
-0.0191124417,
-0.0635007024,
-0.0197210256,
-0.0473991521,
-0.0077800183,
0.0508976281,
-0.08775042,
-0.0496075414,
-0.0567725599,
-0.0313546658,
-0.0185377933,
-0.0046274285,
0.0033974873,
-0.0001747082,
-0.02579326,
-0.0436270647,
0.0056622508,
0.0142509118,
-0.0033709332,
-0.0495365411,
-0.02234165,
0.0039815456,
0.0484463908,
-0.0318195596,
0.0085515007,
0.0009875827,
0.0392438732,
-0.0521139987,
0.0957060754,
0.0008038031,
-0.023617994,
0.0293899886,
0.079130128,
0.0241592471,
0.0774920359,
-0.0100073013,
0.0503094904,
-0.0579418652,
0.0401434563,
0.0294239037,
0.0446376689,
0.009923731,
-0.0292347707,
0.057901822,
-0.0262531061,
0.0369241647,
0.0052730008,
-0.0197333861,
0.0069352542,
0.0217249282,
0.0214226674,
0.0367053375,
-0.0019917684,
0.0604718849,
-0.0288440082,
0.0313528553,
0.046133332,
0.0056802216,
0.0061339396,
0.0010094499,
0.0046514045,
0.0494625568,
0.0196652338,
-0.0505442545,
-0.0743747279,
-0.0228104349,
0.0498865284,
0.0570572466,
0.0144388601,
0.043979995,
0.0164719354,
-0.1123536229,
0.052553039,
0.0395946763,
-0.0431165099,
-0.0152947018,
-0.0975057483,
-0.0242368747,
-0.0570701063,
0.0960200578,
0.0315144248,
-0.0070732301,
-0.0734913796,
0.0570905879,
-0.0451992601,
-0.0790972635,
0.0137007078,
-0.0143364081,
0.0512843952,
0.0474965274,
0.004573415,
-0.0239182487,
-0.0111318622,
0.0260411743,
-0.0191334821,
0.0179473422,
-0.0196493343,
-0.0009831588,
0.0304915365,
-0.0159799661,
0.0086350394,
0.0506286733,
0.0167263374,
0.011840011,
0.0074994331,
-0.002028374,
-0.0024815029,
-0.0299967472,
0.0302917901,
-0.007077049,
-0.0413867384,
0.0843914673,
0.0312111117,
-0.0275263172,
0.0192455109,
-0.0061523775,
0.0310895424,
0.0014306143,
-0.0247345958,
0.0370683223,
-0.0190611742,
-0.0781409964,
-0.0504374504,
-0.0137358233,
-0.0063517862,
-0.0034201951,
0.0027516142,
0.0315236859,
-0.0419499278,
0.0437330753,
-0.0492775366,
0.0240909159,
0.0062265238,
0.032354977,
-0.0387175344,
-0.0097518228,
0.0135823442,
-0.0784028843,
-0.0132189384,
0.0072937827,
-0.0265067108,
-0.0694506839,
0.0239485614,
0.0146582462,
0.0197895635,
0.0175416041,
-0.016197877,
-0.0223990902,
0.043935135,
0.0169742219,
-0.017575454,
0.0149985924,
0.0178339817,
-0.0046503139,
-0.0355201103,
-0.0055226921,
-0.0205381308,
0.0129525,
-0.0426749289,
0.0502278097,
-0.0187387522,
-0.0175752137,
0.0012394,
0.0059139295,
0.044805184,
-0.0346813053,
-0.032929346,
-0.0493387841,
0.0602382272,
0.0132221403,
0.0571998581,
-0.0226282645,
-0.0181454755,
-0.0143388268,
0.0270720385,
-0.0205359757,
0.0223446786,
-0.0296928715,
-0.0252065808,
-0.0191623475,
0.0553014986,
0.0182849895,
0.0696469545,
0.0061940905,
-0.0176269934,
-0.0234179236,
0.0928315967,
0.0240605492,
-0.0130152358,
-0.0000975675,
0.0350628048,
-0.0216771644,
0.0256961491,
0.0498374961,
0.017773442,
-0.0260991082,
-0.0645770356,
-0.0432898588,
0.0504648052,
0.0311111659,
0.0063555553,
0.0615792274,
0.0057727732,
0.0064410954,
-0.0604216792,
-0.0207015201,
-0.0061271335,
0.0189234484,
0.0069281929,
0.0055758888,
-0.037616834,
0.0435133241,
0.0161056705,
0.0305781439,
0.0459403507,
-0.0193131808,
0.0557300858,
-0.0115582151,
-0.0648237839,
0.0299655292,
-0.025888931,
-0.0723402426,
-0.009368225,
-0.0193095319,
-0.0779169947,
-0.0016287152,
0.015378125,
0.0031348534,
0.0170145109,
-0.0106034884,
-0.0282966513,
-0.0675504953,
-0.0059972173,
0.0082377438,
-0.0645318106,
-0.001618107,
0.0015646531,
0.0711495951,
-7.087184745e-33,
0.0024778736,
0.0296954792,
-0.0098755602,
-0.0353209712,
0.0098268874,
0.0047552241,
-0.035365358,
0.0034945509,
-0.038038522,
-0.0317469053,
0.0070246002,
-0.0063062408,
0.0488946028,
0.0094030434,
-0.0179882348,
0.0246897079,
0.0936306193,
0.008646341,
0.0272694919,
-0.044882495,
0.0507097244,
0.0302336086,
0.0134862252,
-0.0575112551,
0.0036464797,
-0.005919002,
-0.0145625202,
-0.0131528666,
0.0231321957,
0.0487217829,
-0.0088227279,
0.0571699478,
-0.0041345037,
0.0086774621,
0.0026245578,
-0.0062235366,
-0.1536497176,
0.0469735824,
0.0060057212,
0.0473855957,
-0.0021793542,
-0.0038238061,
0.0023163422,
0.0310218949,
-0.0063889776,
-0.0116971685,
0.0248695072,
-0.0419848077,
-0.0216268599,
-0.0281324834,
0.0073514795,
0.046079535,
-0.0080538727,
0.0018732675,
0.0530790538,
0.0096412953,
-0.0470304154,
-0.0156413186,
-0.0844090208,
0.0004561754,
0.028295733,
0.0618018396,
0.033136908,
0.0377539434,
0.0007466634,
-0.0084021362,
0.0738787428,
-0.0955683887,
0.0476026498,
-0.0612387322,
0.0641003028,
-0.0013656651,
0.0065389285,
0.0089543788,
0.0379014127,
-0.0616242588,
-0.0341912135,
-0.0210254937,
0.0496276878,
0.0437310524,
0.0212458875,
0.0169036053,
-0.0233744234,
0.0050080917,
-0.0176173095,
-0.0552392714,
-0.0634460002,
-0.009220303,
0.0572620593,
0.0249866769,
-0.0070505021,
-0.0144286212,
0.0576971397,
-0.0241378471,
0.0169831812,
0.038216725,
0.0167163834,
-0.0289498903,
-0.0279454514,
0.034949515,
-0.0570829287,
-0.0546327233,
0.0372140147,
-0.0000284297,
-0.0203150287,
-0.0261369664,
0.0331208855,
0.0540317073,
-0.0326080769,
-0.0052017993,
0.003059288,
-0.0205124542,
0.0217526387,
0.0656355768,
0.0450150669,
-0.0189962834,
0.0119983042,
0.0281644501,
0.0047532842,
0.0373429321,
-0.0174615048,
0.004043207,
-0.006476691,
0.0373026095,
-0.0426805541,
0.0296330377,
0.0438713916,
-0.007208691,
0.0066964775,
-0.0165231507,
-0.0044817789,
0.0080723204,
2.943e-7,
-0.0274603292,
-0.0157175902,
0.0524888076,
-0.0531563982,
-0.0085399346,
-0.0131889153,
-0.0337081812,
0.000328062,
-0.0003536961,
0.0217197351,
0.0168793034,
0.0345849469,
0.112668395,
0.008023398,
-0.0640582666,
-0.0012518413,
-0.0571669452,
0.0341493636,
-0.0080809528,
0.0456173941,
-0.0142563172,
0.0974099636,
-0.033426065,
-0.0095481789,
-0.005979341,
-0.0158326384,
0.0169849209,
0.0015873638,
0.0092462655,
0.0046875416,
0.003984069,
0.0002455364,
-0.0275905039,
-0.0213471223,
-0.045459073,
0.0883075371,
0.0247634184,
0.0492134914,
-0.0562132113,
-0.0889999568,
0.0311491527,
0.0585067235,
-0.0248596184,
-0.0334152021,
0.0457589626,
0.0448280722,
-0.0157942958,
0.0039339941,
-0.0377824306,
0.0114799878,
0.0010726099,
-0.0151766399,
0.0041241511,
0.0257620588,
0.0094728423,
-0.0303581264,
-0.032158412,
-0.0561216287,
-0.0152397789,
-0.0204754658,
-0.0427150391,
-0.0389046445,
0.0096474243,
0.0180173591,
0.0107821682,
0.0268682744,
-0.0129519422,
2.0153318e-34,
0.0593414083,
-0.0287915338,
-0.0293740947,
0.0257465541,
-0.0244379546,
-0.0525840819,
-0.0072157597,
0.0313076377,
-0.0430066586,
-0.0275242738,
-0.0821190849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13476v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13476v3 | LLMs Are Zero-Shot Context-Aware Simultaneous Translators | 2024-06-19T11:57:42 | 2024-06-25T04:45:19 | Roman Koshkin, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of transformers has fueled progress in machine translation. More
recently large language models (LLMs) have come to the spotlight thanks to
their generality and strong performance in a wide range of language tasks,
including translation. Here we show that open-source LLMs perform on par with
or better than some state-of-the-art baselines in simultaneous machine
translation (SiMT) tasks, zero-shot. We also demonstrate that injection of
minimal background information, which is easy with an LLM, brings further
performance gains, especially on challenging technical subject-matter. This
highlights LLMs' potential for building next generation of massively
multilingual, context-aware and terminologically accurate SiMT systems that
require no resource-intensive training or fine-tuning. | [
0.0035035694,
0.023522649,
0.00771594,
0.0557672456,
-0.0305145197,
0.0156230507,
0.0536454432,
-0.0211623553,
-0.0463401452,
-0.0225483067,
-0.0761542097,
-0.0572063848,
-0.0004208824,
-0.0278218463,
0.0270528179,
-0.0150093529,
0.0303325914,
-0.0326362364,
-0.0757756457,
0.0019882901,
-0.0172961857,
0.0398761332,
0.0164484568,
0.0285687372,
0.0035737257,
-0.01483477,
0.0050134389,
0.0522717275,
0.0433887355,
-0.0112572899,
0.0000309439,
0.0263026599,
0.0447535738,
0.1047099456,
0.0000019729,
-0.0285736788,
-0.0504067987,
0.0097451806,
0.0103515089,
0.0385605954,
0.058462739,
-0.0596427806,
-0.0304179192,
0.0327652693,
-0.0185051356,
-0.0080097178,
0.0598812625,
-0.0118740527,
0.0681476966,
0.0695400238,
-0.0166037064,
-0.0347413681,
0.0195023026,
-0.0756770596,
-0.0105069159,
-0.0463520102,
-0.0025913743,
-0.0031892494,
-0.0218235571,
0.0314312391,
0.0055690445,
0.0692881569,
0.0288459603,
-0.0039038947,
-0.049041789,
0.0160118304,
-0.0220209323,
-0.004979942,
-0.0083247349,
0.0646338314,
-0.0515872017,
-0.0068734265,
-0.0148867788,
-0.0056438586,
-0.0501377247,
-0.0372538231,
-0.0482142679,
0.035585694,
-0.0042802831,
0.0022757447,
0.0384833366,
0.0128420629,
0.0421612412,
0.0009892356,
-0.0657909214,
0.0271908194,
0.0564013459,
-0.0228945613,
-0.0327785276,
0.0195384733,
-0.0255218595,
-0.032186877,
0.0291137751,
0.0131887645,
-0.0180368815,
0.0273568816,
-0.0433964767,
-0.0466153473,
-0.0038785315,
-0.0337421298,
0.0073722159,
0.0742166713,
-0.0031834284,
0.0602996089,
-0.0169117413,
0.0500209369,
-0.0664886013,
0.016983252,
-0.0754556432,
-0.0400158875,
-0.0236085113,
0.0217231605,
-0.0365976915,
-0.0148844225,
-0.0729783848,
-0.0074074985,
-0.027406767,
0.0479192361,
0.016456997,
0.0019660401,
0.0269820075,
-0.0435765833,
-0.0796475112,
-0.0467162952,
0.0416423418,
0.0704554021,
0.02472464,
-0.011981247,
-0.0192795545,
-0.0615047365,
-0.0339034311,
0.0302205049,
-0.0070722722,
-0.0506394506,
-0.0104515878,
0.0836664438,
-0.0136745851,
-0.0521473065,
-0.0218634922,
-0.0015263612,
-0.0008350966,
-0.0553757362,
-0.0291675832,
-0.0576810986,
0.0479733869,
0.0237423684,
0.0445855856,
-0.0277380142,
0.0103609692,
0.0112703005,
-0.0142642371,
0.0852873921,
0.0191584304,
0.0004510357,
0.0136267468,
0.0071698884,
-0.0067374031,
0.0778157339,
0.0253051054,
0.0115090525,
0.0191113763,
0.0154695343,
-0.0052392092,
0.0979285762,
-0.0064815041,
0.0594261363,
-0.0189164355,
0.0005939224,
0.0167752206,
0.0234964006,
0.0340797678,
0.0604177974,
-0.0167920589,
0.0129830753,
0.0697400123,
0.0302826948,
0.0123086041,
0.0562333241,
0.0834803656,
0.0138103087,
-0.0242024474,
-0.017876694,
-0.0192309897,
0.0190553144,
0.0029621513,
0.0038863828,
0.0268119238,
0.0345565341,
-0.0307152867,
0.0033947579,
-0.0229598042,
-0.028048791,
-0.04802664,
-0.0150807379,
0.0605039857,
-0.0177020673,
-0.0629758835,
0.0685587674,
0.004844788,
-0.0589802675,
0.0112538738,
-0.0140808998,
-0.0373536572,
0.0695451945,
0.0516518764,
-0.0034335314,
-0.0525958501,
-0.0401160121,
0.0147514185,
0.071114786,
0.0604497641,
0.0191258192,
0.0363205783,
-0.0448671058,
-0.0057539474,
-0.0004708093,
0.0156911146,
0.0327832364,
0.0378849208,
0.0356724188,
0.0491143987,
0.0058987984,
-0.003539958,
0.024304498,
-0.0859293789,
-0.0273681171,
0.0244588014,
-0.0090184454,
0.0199115798,
0.0115356958,
-0.0374543704,
-0.0000704481,
0.0210497975,
-0.0571764633,
-0.015986152,
0.0395672992,
-0.0337561853,
-0.0376845151,
0.0358670838,
-0.0191297866,
-0.0072425208,
0.0105510289,
-0.0440741479,
-0.0400656946,
-0.0114046084,
-0.007853522,
0.0000281867,
-0.0419384837,
0.0296082459,
0.0115958955,
0.0261440463,
-0.0329581276,
0.0134652257,
0.0047808751,
-0.0066980673,
0.0573156849,
-0.0009195929,
0.024688147,
-0.0382672735,
-0.0513861068,
0.0198031738,
0.022048641,
0.0374070778,
0.0087938346,
0.0222388767,
-0.0026661446,
-0.0458825901,
-0.1016385406,
0.0416473374,
-0.0277310275,
0.0369402915,
0.0469418764,
0.0426615775,
-0.0038236217,
0.0063078972,
-0.0013596099,
0.0025011227,
0.0110607399,
0.0114949234,
-0.0078805527,
-0.0207107607,
-0.0122316526,
-0.0191107523,
-0.0149013903,
0.0076439437,
0.0411050469,
0.0068941517,
-0.0074131992,
-0.0622650869,
0.0410996005,
-0.0088420454,
0.0099109532,
-0.0035333128,
-0.0433033481,
-0.0130516915,
-0.0551152118,
0.0359804146,
0.0279684532,
-0.0070896316,
0.0038721981,
0.0262951311,
-0.0202095471,
-0.0498032942,
0.0119013498,
-0.0155570274,
-0.0659888163,
-0.0300132781,
-0.0316833928,
-0.0071324878,
0.0755087137,
-0.0238193199,
-0.0132204182,
-0.0586480051,
-0.0147807728,
-0.0096892817,
-0.0107877599,
-0.013863137,
0.0244637448,
-0.001331432,
0.0224323086,
-0.0239558667,
-0.0315030701,
0.0439419486,
-0.0577687211,
-0.0181353111,
-0.0304972902,
-0.0078851022,
-0.0680674762,
0.0589981414,
-0.0413014218,
0.0129293445,
-0.0322220549,
-0.0070582791,
-0.0380479582,
0.0289486181,
-0.0190025512,
-0.0214384291,
0.0481275544,
-0.0727125257,
0.0276456308,
-0.0410649665,
-0.0203291532,
-0.0319452733,
-0.0088824807,
-0.0408310294,
0.0046228324,
0.0149756251,
-0.034093786,
-0.0423933752,
0.018082194,
0.030814996,
0.0834327489,
0.0001334857,
-0.0000341696,
-0.0252448041,
0.0326030888,
0.0060875597,
-0.0012628185,
0.0001017376,
-0.0674264804,
0.0171614289,
0.0283030551,
0.0243853554,
-0.0199175868,
-0.039173238,
-0.0409185253,
0.0454778895,
-0.0096646752,
-0.0227710232,
-0.0415514857,
0.0225816704,
-0.0358373597,
-0.0093796123,
0.1231147349,
0.0187406652,
-0.0844496414,
-0.0203354359,
-0.0076890546,
0.0146383811,
0.024159776,
0.0302345622,
-0.1258237362,
-0.0455030017,
0.0010970768,
0.0001418223,
0.0362588577,
0.0113373436,
-0.0499321967,
-0.0884897262,
0.0159726664,
0.0413249284,
-0.066896081,
-0.0136554744,
0.0093956748,
-0.0194394346,
-0.0508538261,
0.017934002,
-0.0049356972,
0.015371548,
-0.0136458315,
-0.0074227001,
0.0504726805,
-0.0551428311,
0.0149708241,
-0.0422194339,
0.0363022536,
0.0355421528,
0.0043093148,
0.0130344527,
-0.0087861037,
0.0488924533,
-0.0281112902,
-0.0093632052,
-0.0113475947,
-0.0019491566,
-0.0342213176,
-0.0239207745,
0.0418157801,
-0.0081271585,
-0.0659371167,
0.0041147047,
0.0201216433,
0.057146199,
0.0071853329,
0.0332750976,
0.0087464992,
-0.0336568169,
0.0010295975,
0.0507454909,
-0.0005944613,
-0.045154009,
-0.0053559784,
-0.0264004096,
-0.0168485418,
-0.0438635908,
-0.0223849248,
-0.0082309684,
-0.0387465619,
-0.0793452188,
-0.0435781889,
-0.0124393236,
0.0201514326,
0.027013056,
0.0165114086,
-0.0028407385,
0.0043303589,
0.0025089614,
-0.0410153866,
0.0344432555,
-0.0589700639,
0.0435337313,
-0.0763394907,
0.045637399,
0.0575712398,
-0.0331137702,
0.0060289381,
0.0313834623,
-0.0999609455,
-0.0747119635,
-0.023344839,
0.0393012427,
0.0257117003,
0.0295056663,
-0.0456192046,
-0.0331338979,
0.0155351749,
0.0273693558,
-0.0153358802,
0.0244835485,
0.0267301947,
0.0095161553,
-0.0101079568,
0.0549586415,
-0.0205399711,
0.0130075663,
-0.0071643926,
0.0650125444,
-0.0234472975,
-0.0450613946,
0.0167504773,
0.0004419035,
0.0199654009,
-0.0217330866,
0.0186839774,
-0.0044247345,
0.0300879609,
-0.0279488917,
-0.0091018565,
-0.0510410517,
-0.0184549578,
0.0447271205,
-0.0212608054,
0.0076795057,
0.0264763068,
-0.0115733333,
0.0089541981,
0.0022708487,
-0.0133850938,
-0.0410336144,
0.0039487579,
0.0379372984,
0.0196875129,
-0.0157807749,
0.0027514864,
-0.0116371121,
0.0050328728,
-0.0513277017,
0.0456930771,
-0.0063818479,
-0.0061998321,
-0.0036481416,
0.0480448678,
-0.0484089814,
-0.0214541797,
-0.0153901363,
0.0365940928,
0.1073303521,
0.035598103,
0.114190571,
-0.0255295616,
-0.0210433118,
-0.0329622664,
0.0581759177,
0.0072773313,
0.0043501607,
-0.0036236655,
0.005170262,
0.0105400048,
0.0339333378,
0.082354106,
-0.0080984458,
0.0163741354,
-0.016354898,
-0.0269376114,
-0.0070317551,
-0.0173114948,
-0.0130541809,
-0.0226454809,
-0.0190735832,
0.0057626045,
-0.0523797944,
-0.051244732,
0.0265339836,
0.0140125724,
-0.0204085745,
-0.0342638642,
0.0039375541,
0.0731633604,
-0.0311154556,
0.0207953565,
-0.031220099,
0.0250553265,
0.0022436506,
-0.0327384248,
-0.0196924899,
-6.185612905e-33,
-0.0220245998,
-0.0052756746,
0.0405448303,
-0.0232980642,
-0.0388369821,
0.0202667359,
-0.0368115157,
0.0025668936,
0.0026326627,
-0.0102231773,
-0.0168206971,
0.0126476064,
0.0139013473,
0.0128830001,
-0.0118344026,
0.0009467856,
0.0583571941,
0.0120493993,
-0.0026813839,
0.0186473299,
0.0405173339,
0.0201156493,
0.0845521018,
-0.0454834439,
0.0187315159,
-0.0285772476,
-0.0135561358,
0.0168054271,
-0.0017357901,
0.0315894261,
-0.0013577344,
0.022896409,
0.0082917353,
-0.0334115624,
-0.0098958323,
-0.0224915687,
-0.0637634397,
0.041007895,
0.0162947811,
0.0190617163,
-0.0011407683,
-0.0651664138,
0.0329228714,
-0.0269981734,
-0.0038606771,
-0.0259722676,
-0.01180101,
-0.0283658244,
-0.022444874,
-0.0189004168,
-0.0541686788,
0.0247640088,
0.0010351051,
-0.0105200615,
0.0473576188,
0.0527307875,
-0.0013663343,
0.048641976,
-0.038999211,
0.0238662679,
-0.0029167302,
0.0355935767,
0.1041916013,
-0.0019775815,
-0.0147405155,
0.0025434436,
0.00581457,
-0.0100546693,
0.0114994571,
-0.0325634107,
0.0098227467,
0.0165740903,
0.0439377837,
0.0561982282,
0.0146175623,
0.007017436,
-0.0429522842,
0.0192950442,
0.0036971387,
-0.0017593659,
0.0388635471,
0.0228712987,
-0.0073983441,
0.0095639005,
-0.0371027328,
-0.0147618875,
-0.0390401408,
-0.016918717,
0.0124462657,
0.0276910383,
-0.014525055,
0.0053131226,
0.0848443285,
-0.0319853351,
0.025517866,
0.004556566,
-0.0163275469,
0.0232275967,
-0.03144335,
0.0683356375,
-0.0282331463,
-0.0312667191,
-0.0127428891,
0.0104675367,
-0.009194158,
-0.0133263208,
0.020847721,
0.0378449708,
-0.0342010371,
-0.0007595649,
-0.0617125072,
-0.0060023451,
-0.0402459502,
0.0242273957,
0.0138193527,
0.0176944155,
-0.0004100051,
0.0518463105,
0.0379227847,
-0.0055312347,
0.0032541386,
-0.0028257419,
0.0133204171,
0.0412280522,
-0.0308532417,
0.0345951542,
-0.0169755369,
0.0096597429,
0.057035774,
-0.0528639741,
-0.0321612619,
0.013020589,
2.644e-7,
0.0521465391,
0.0442483462,
0.0067625418,
0.0190321468,
0.0347020626,
0.03199872,
-0.0320024155,
0.0377249792,
-0.0039056814,
0.0588262379,
0.0226643197,
0.0366833247,
0.0736970231,
0.0136941662,
-0.0815352648,
-0.0528179221,
-0.0391714014,
0.0458729155,
-0.0603106134,
0.011235646,
0.0464702472,
0.1044669971,
-0.0025823335,
0.0108632157,
-0.0148897739,
-0.0363703445,
0.1021264642,
-0.0203683767,
-0.0251068491,
0.0174739175,
0.0026349281,
0.0238589626,
-0.0432772301,
-0.018551968,
-0.019482227,
0.0128928078,
0.0477494597,
0.1063591316,
0.0262248609,
-0.0151679786,
0.036843773,
-0.0219095219,
-0.0230779555,
-0.0312447455,
0.0669268444,
-0.0598256402,
0.0091328137,
-0.0033680657,
-0.02845544,
0.0253963042,
0.0230390653,
-0.0332918726,
-0.0417337939,
0.0189160686,
0.0458277911,
-0.0172847304,
-0.0475338697,
-0.0447535552,
-0.0322856493,
-0.0385452062,
-0.0337296538,
-0.0433730148,
-0.0244270824,
-0.0149886152,
0.0149110248,
-0.0212468132,
0.0126612801,
2.598421768e-34,
0.0583090261,
-0.0046817083,
0.0018431371,
0.02063765,
0.009892093,
-0.0291398373,
-0.0201569311,
0.0071517723,
-0.0190304462,
-0.0639387071,
-0.032019686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13469v1 | Encoder vs Decoder: Comparative Analysis of Encoder and Decoder Language Models on Multilingual NLU Tasks | 2024-06-19T11:50:09 | 2024-06-19T11:50:09 | Dan Saattrup Nielsen, Kenneth Enevoldsen, Peter Schneider-Kamp | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | This paper explores the performance of encoder and decoder language models on
multilingual Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks, with a broad focus on
Germanic languages. Building upon the ScandEval benchmark, which initially was
restricted to evaluating encoder models, we extend the evaluation framework to
include decoder models. We introduce a method for evaluating decoder models on
NLU tasks and apply it to the languages Danish, Swedish, Norwegian, Icelandic,
Faroese, German, Dutch, and English. Through a series of experiments and
analyses, we address key research questions regarding the comparative
performance of encoder and decoder models, the impact of NLU task types, and
the variation across language resources. Our findings reveal that decoder
models can achieve significantly better NLU performance than encoder models,
with nuances observed across different tasks and languages. Additionally, we
investigate the correlation between decoders and task performance via a UMAP
analysis, shedding light on the unique capabilities of decoder and encoder
models. This study contributes to a deeper understanding of language model
paradigms in NLU tasks and provides valuable insights for model selection and
evaluation in multilingual settings. | [
0.0223760474,
0.023116529,
-0.0110152587,
0.0735868067,
-0.0249571111,
0.0399739966,
0.0091775153,
-0.0646879822,
-0.0651540309,
-0.0366570093,
-0.0071437671,
-0.056473814,
0.0364136249,
0.0021303457,
0.0066170106,
-0.0659639314,
0.0516225994,
-0.074123621,
-0.011424806,
0.0059864903,
-0.0123334648,
-0.0018922052,
-0.0115487631,
0.0503438041,
0.0481303893,
-0.0084555279,
-0.0172473155,
0.0052119219,
-0.0073162164,
-0.0085427538,
-0.0152879516,
0.0159995295,
0.0472220778,
0.0162100643,
0.0000018976,
-0.0529567525,
0.0110184178,
-0.0249696746,
-0.0324324444,
0.0311728828,
0.0580221526,
-0.0797707438,
0.0078956671,
-0.0041484553,
0.0055335392,
-0.0453977808,
0.0427468121,
0.0142986141,
0.0136353057,
0.02304806,
0.0007411066,
-0.0575634204,
0.0110365972,
-0.0280339941,
-0.0523183309,
-0.0526334234,
-0.0111281294,
0.0635922998,
-0.0201171208,
-0.0040592868,
-0.0768751428,
0.049582988,
0.0174876414,
0.0422731042,
-0.0256266799,
0.0278830659,
0.0134652173,
-0.0543486625,
-0.028029928,
0.0448141284,
-0.0398500152,
-0.0100762807,
-0.0517299995,
0.0102613391,
-0.0257497467,
0.0101499595,
-0.0340265669,
0.0241873302,
-0.0342283882,
0.0289092269,
0.0512733459,
0.024002891,
0.0230188053,
-0.0092773624,
-0.0105668809,
0.0811447427,
0.0058461912,
-0.0191265661,
0.0419127047,
0.031775821,
0.0264956206,
-0.0396983624,
0.0158827435,
0.0226849634,
0.0083536124,
0.0210793372,
0.0056366278,
-0.0623555966,
-0.0039701383,
-0.0355198644,
0.0123582957,
0.0591318496,
-0.0427035913,
0.0331815518,
-0.0193415992,
0.0899536088,
-0.0161559023,
0.0004853161,
-0.060908895,
-0.0407311395,
-0.0347372666,
-0.0098543717,
-0.0209877361,
0.0119281104,
-0.0467738695,
-0.0020681049,
-0.0007829018,
-0.0104032522,
0.0433181934,
-0.0143013112,
0.0109743811,
-0.0196632221,
-0.0425899476,
0.0168470945,
-0.0203576535,
0.0838881657,
-0.0353337079,
0.004184844,
-0.0597322583,
-0.0591399148,
0.0069991993,
0.0211085174,
-0.0029420191,
-0.0459295101,
0.0024593552,
0.0573925488,
-0.0232406445,
-0.015118558,
-0.0196525492,
0.0100349793,
0.0077547892,
-0.0686466172,
0.0060271537,
-0.04445979,
0.0651872158,
0.042797368,
0.0280979928,
-0.0616205409,
-0.0053957235,
-0.0315491594,
-0.0367028937,
0.0636768639,
-0.0085974392,
0.0443201512,
0.0057030651,
-0.0181180518,
-0.0111369109,
0.0650385469,
-0.0059692897,
-0.0217480231,
0.0246531274,
-0.0252788533,
-0.0041840011,
0.0524709113,
-0.0245261043,
-0.0299714077,
0.0004340722,
0.0233167261,
0.0029977947,
0.0049494677,
0.080434002,
0.0316972919,
-0.0353394188,
-0.0025757919,
0.0177773684,
0.0320954509,
0.0078900261,
0.0003296929,
0.0426441431,
-0.0085612116,
0.0011323675,
0.014482649,
0.0138021428,
0.0002803069,
-0.0037999628,
-0.0025656556,
0.0085820276,
0.0397764407,
-0.0170649458,
-0.0345271379,
-0.0059597054,
-0.0376456305,
0.0437552072,
0.0191487987,
0.045490928,
0.0088555589,
-0.0332511179,
0.0460174829,
-0.0047236625,
-0.0461810827,
0.0523820408,
-0.0076626297,
-0.0154863652,
0.070366472,
0.0263449792,
0.0376563109,
-0.0353493206,
-0.0145377722,
-0.0288899392,
0.0229123607,
0.0464344062,
-0.0312470775,
0.0612206087,
-0.0519380346,
-0.0073449677,
-0.0422552675,
0.007824054,
0.0697357506,
-0.0439424738,
0.0056194351,
-0.0098554632,
-0.0912811533,
-0.0444315337,
0.0231358241,
-0.0398450643,
-0.0022756357,
-0.0296799988,
-0.0016538317,
-0.0002665049,
0.0431619547,
-0.0059547713,
0.013374879,
-0.0036221847,
-0.0770617649,
0.0241325032,
0.0539724082,
-0.0036715588,
-0.0812000483,
0.0198723394,
-0.0405659825,
-0.0245813951,
0.0412185714,
-0.0018675867,
-0.0513254367,
0.0352528319,
-0.0417684205,
0.0153310206,
-0.0080816979,
-0.0089776069,
-0.0309443418,
0.0125059774,
-0.0058143046,
0.0655155405,
-0.0174583141,
0.0466876626,
0.0238314625,
-0.0116353175,
0.0329760015,
-0.0360747762,
-0.0385593958,
0.0632309243,
-0.0220250972,
-0.0139679406,
0.0288369376,
-0.013194154,
0.0168385282,
-0.003836344,
-0.0545453504,
-0.0010580291,
-0.0516608283,
0.0624744631,
0.0482852273,
0.0167307649,
-0.0042038318,
-0.0393272489,
-0.027990913,
-0.0389972962,
0.0124820834,
0.026680503,
0.005230071,
0.0029428029,
-0.0240879543,
-0.0312332604,
-0.0181239266,
0.0180907324,
0.0661610216,
-0.0029667737,
-0.0706212819,
-0.0524612777,
0.0454073325,
-0.0090421895,
-0.0074062999,
-0.0157899149,
-0.0283692405,
0.0070886146,
0.0419398248,
0.048207134,
0.0314153358,
-0.0328601189,
0.0469603464,
0.0307095647,
-0.0193521194,
-0.0432426371,
0.0009985084,
-0.021987183,
-0.0287222173,
-0.0682264045,
-0.071361661,
0.0330078341,
0.0975556448,
0.0270316936,
0.0219987575,
-0.059064623,
-0.022060357,
-0.0489166938,
-0.0388088226,
-0.050010439,
-0.0446150638,
0.0331310816,
0.0934505165,
-0.039662499,
0.0038933426,
0.0628492162,
-0.0403741486,
-0.0379311778,
-0.0474171564,
0.014337345,
-0.0637554377,
0.060203772,
-0.0079483725,
0.0338704623,
-0.0252228826,
-0.0719776005,
0.0141465785,
0.0258945022,
0.0310118143,
-0.0220475737,
0.0333331227,
-0.0555836782,
-0.0102667334,
-0.0108900368,
-0.0151224928,
-0.0281727836,
0.0197609477,
-0.0364650823,
0.0291505456,
-0.0090070199,
0.0321299769,
-0.0307086874,
0.0567944832,
0.0025309795,
-0.0046899705,
-0.0046164896,
0.0145597355,
-0.0415235497,
0.0239013992,
0.0054525076,
0.0221014824,
0.013914288,
-0.0430977382,
0.0289520733,
-0.0028301582,
0.0080998167,
0.0063817962,
-0.0284605473,
0.0352458768,
0.0519228652,
-0.0078318613,
-0.053853415,
0.0092016831,
0.0657946393,
-0.0574891008,
-0.009478597,
0.0864328593,
0.0283929333,
-0.002525805,
0.0016388604,
-0.0387433395,
0.0073755016,
0.0267577227,
0.0020102204,
-0.0488022938,
-0.0493066311,
-0.0155325811,
0.0176199991,
0.0338848308,
-0.019529162,
0.006624592,
-0.1023926139,
0.0004076292,
0.0170590971,
-0.070160009,
-0.0390605181,
-0.0578673109,
-0.0207272228,
-0.0441791564,
0.0406104736,
0.0134683289,
0.0206211228,
0.022788763,
0.0328898951,
-0.0330912955,
-0.0915269181,
0.0213853177,
-0.0312678441,
0.0221243091,
0.0773365274,
0.0192856472,
-0.0202989429,
-0.0222354978,
0.0155664068,
-0.0433965996,
0.0200012941,
0.0005211718,
0.0430351794,
0.0000682126,
0.0013888658,
-0.0212331526,
0.0067442115,
-0.0679983348,
-0.0035763877,
-0.0263490062,
0.0582024567,
-0.0095307529,
-0.035742145,
0.0261403508,
-0.0428218432,
0.016475901,
0.0801413059,
0.0310912784,
-0.0159704201,
-0.058063101,
-0.0574755333,
0.0275401641,
-0.0595616102,
0.0009828527,
0.0469133146,
0.0398361534,
-0.0362722985,
-0.0125949346,
-0.0797680318,
0.0173148364,
-0.0309743546,
0.0453497879,
0.0339845829,
0.0537386574,
-0.0252027679,
-0.0514849462,
0.0238023493,
0.0124066882,
0.0214186497,
-0.0125494907,
-0.0003840998,
0.0256501213,
0.0130292512,
-0.0046125669,
-0.0021225486,
-0.0466143861,
-0.0550042801,
0.0011299193,
0.0271410383,
0.0262207258,
0.0531082302,
-0.0033487941,
-0.0431445353,
-0.0831649601,
-0.0434838347,
-0.018261319,
0.0083878962,
0.021537466,
0.0025387285,
0.0026617511,
0.0332713053,
-0.0156612508,
0.0161374584,
-0.0215077102,
0.0417800844,
-0.0031127366,
-0.0325653739,
0.0251742322,
0.0390288047,
-0.0115146758,
-0.017866876,
-0.0077286614,
-0.0290828142,
0.0047584847,
-0.0007789302,
0.00326924,
-0.0327426232,
-0.0017797014,
0.0599584356,
0.0224379897,
0.006385732,
0.013336896,
-0.0067639886,
0.0009975304,
-0.0178863648,
0.0434473604,
0.0611403324,
0.0089725116,
0.001276523,
0.0121554537,
-0.016205769,
0.038482476,
-0.0016355222,
0.0548238605,
-0.0304793846,
0.0505108908,
-0.0141931036,
0.03131124,
0.0094925892,
-0.0038794496,
-0.019140156,
-0.0268037543,
0.0141768428,
-0.0403986573,
0.0404792093,
-0.0075186766,
0.088120833,
-0.0087039359,
0.0464705043,
-0.002521317,
0.0401383229,
0.003587909,
-0.0478743501,
0.0642635226,
0.0003935339,
-0.0159324892,
-0.024190655,
0.0703344345,
-0.0185823645,
0.0389337242,
-0.0206191316,
0.00648994,
-0.020500049,
-0.0120551875,
-0.0076183733,
-0.009404094,
-0.04011859,
0.0433303937,
-0.0652055591,
-0.0208986085,
-0.0143191824,
-0.0084594078,
0.0242382418,
-0.0206761677,
0.0141115068,
0.0694693252,
0.0003933325,
-0.0087296488,
-0.0389320776,
0.0125041641,
-0.0536596403,
0.0027275088,
-0.0396898687,
-6.004194821e-33,
-0.036419794,
0.0144868912,
0.0043337466,
-0.0452746823,
0.0042404481,
-0.0226496384,
-0.0515315719,
0.0035256469,
-0.0337674245,
-0.0037550635,
0.0334248468,
-0.0116724074,
0.0121352794,
0.0128692724,
0.0071915016,
-0.0542856194,
0.0476787239,
0.0172181595,
-0.0249896217,
-0.0301405285,
0.0390671007,
0.0208790246,
0.0708866715,
-0.0151517224,
0.0545325056,
-0.0057949959,
0.0321546793,
0.0192766991,
0.0553082824,
0.0348387659,
-0.0290287789,
0.0374292843,
0.050953608,
-0.0383031927,
-0.0263009537,
0.0231052823,
-0.0953423604,
-0.0271388814,
0.0564349033,
0.0757581815,
-0.0356652252,
-0.0527044795,
0.0135136247,
0.0127017135,
-0.0221843552,
0.0244621094,
0.0038723429,
-0.0045588692,
-0.0066383537,
0.0048383442,
-0.0422988944,
0.013123529,
-0.0645973831,
-0.006521489,
0.0905972719,
0.0812272877,
-0.0264285933,
-0.0074675945,
-0.0707359985,
0.0126278494,
-0.0061060251,
0.0099148061,
0.0941695869,
-0.0230008289,
-0.0276258513,
0.0440663621,
-0.0025274695,
-0.0139155351,
-0.0324741639,
0.0203424674,
0.028576646,
0.0260257665,
0.0217876676,
0.026885068,
0.0500718169,
-0.0038450081,
-0.0360166766,
0.0134962276,
-0.0052225473,
0.0269313231,
0.0128221642,
0.0054107658,
-0.0348475762,
-0.0402043201,
-0.0675623491,
-0.0429553278,
-0.0186660327,
-0.0470237881,
0.0730111077,
-0.0443813652,
0.0091053788,
-0.0048280335,
0.0776265264,
-0.0373531319,
0.0066137849,
0.0161316395,
0.0171043016,
0.0408555977,
0.0032957632,
0.0631338954,
-0.0313296951,
-0.0262289923,
0.0143398745,
0.0204553101,
0.0358471237,
0.0025519591,
0.0050813667,
-0.0118357986,
-0.0251355711,
-0.0001540824,
-0.0558478422,
0.0134002334,
-0.0378108956,
0.0315677077,
0.0463311449,
0.0203542393,
-0.0460842438,
0.0003247486,
0.0021159193,
-0.0180948339,
-0.0640120506,
-0.0192523152,
-0.0045399326,
0.0365860686,
-0.0190440286,
-0.0099227428,
-0.0373257995,
-0.0143498154,
0.0348938331,
-0.0172270183,
-0.0154314395,
0.0502083823,
2.476e-7,
0.0841491893,
0.0397836864,
0.0409657694,
-0.0007805141,
0.039176438,
0.0039170883,
-0.0390324481,
0.0049444111,
0.0099032093,
-0.0361698307,
-0.0419829972,
0.0199634973,
0.0305579379,
0.0505636446,
-0.0383384638,
-0.0186840203,
-0.0027053608,
0.0416451469,
-0.0344807692,
0.0178491306,
0.065851979,
0.0643928424,
-0.0711549446,
0.0215584598,
-0.0392399691,
-0.0248847622,
0.0662734285,
-0.0039790305,
0.0106124338,
0.0270737782,
0.0102757728,
0.0268211029,
0.0377985686,
0.0435242355,
0.0205371585,
0.0186240729,
0.0442660227,
0.0470016189,
-0.0164799709,
-0.035963431,
0.0079630716,
0.0088864127,
-0.0440143496,
-0.0703794286,
0.0703905746,
-0.0439893529,
-0.060294278,
0.0180647857,
-0.0332843252,
0.0624088868,
-0.0057455162,
0.0069662477,
0.0145917041,
0.0568510406,
0.0442064442,
-0.0368381441,
-0.031013621,
-0.0092861829,
-0.0394393355,
0.0347317383,
0.0103152813,
-0.0012162058,
-0.0217612348,
-0.0120422244,
0.0224461891,
-0.0544112325,
-0.0223471187,
1.606396256e-34,
0.0410036035,
0.0092717446,
0.0227142852,
0.0592456833,
0.0149949733,
-0.0595381856,
-0.0364776552,
0.0276181512,
-0.0292056259,
-0.0347093642,
-0.0083246185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13444v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13444v2 | VDebugger: Harnessing Execution Feedback for Debugging Visual Programs | 2024-06-19T11:09:16 | 2024-06-27T17:09:24 | Xueqing Wu, Zongyu Lin, Songyan Zhao, Te-Lin Wu, Pan Lu, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual programs are executable code generated by large language models to
address visual reasoning problems. They decompose complex questions into
multiple reasoning steps and invoke specialized models for each step to solve
the problems. However, these programs are prone to logic errors, with our
preliminary evaluation showing that 58% of the total errors are caused by
program logic errors. Debugging complex visual programs remains a major
bottleneck for visual reasoning. To address this, we introduce VDebugger, a
novel critic-refiner framework trained to localize and debug visual programs by
tracking execution step by step. VDebugger identifies and corrects program
errors leveraging detailed execution feedback, improving interpretability and
accuracy. The training data is generated through an automated pipeline that
injects errors into correct visual programs using a novel mask-best decoding
technique. Evaluations on six datasets demonstrate VDebugger's effectiveness,
showing performance improvements of up to 3.2% in downstream task accuracy.
Further studies show VDebugger's ability to generalize to unseen tasks,
bringing a notable improvement of 2.3% on the unseen COVR task. Code, data and
models are made publicly available at https://github.com/shirley-wu/vdebugger/ | [
0.0042472202,
0.0423057526,
-0.0074828211,
0.0500385053,
0.0211341828,
0.0430901907,
-0.0064223344,
-0.0065606786,
-0.015375929,
-0.0356894732,
-0.0070403647,
0.0374702141,
-0.0028645098,
0.0359674171,
0.0421821959,
-0.0705604032,
0.0330710039,
-0.0299217217,
0.0263910815,
0.0319480747,
0.0099243456,
0.0029830828,
-0.0079690497,
0.0643250123,
-0.0351230316,
-0.0426725484,
-0.0326674767,
0.0337263234,
0.0308715478,
-0.0144996615,
-0.0277704243,
0.0124715203,
0.0476686582,
0.0131558925,
0.0000021018,
0.0164226908,
-0.0187621582,
-0.0040032873,
-0.011791327,
-0.0145101054,
-0.0238381252,
-0.062174432,
-0.0071766758,
0.0272986684,
-0.0237761736,
-0.0651396289,
0.0347727276,
0.012239865,
0.1020270288,
0.0494573787,
0.0079509234,
-0.0064464035,
-0.0309323538,
-0.00245733,
0.0161734056,
-0.0373661481,
-0.0206045061,
0.0829260349,
-0.0390605927,
-0.0233046766,
-0.063298136,
0.0191342533,
0.0382007845,
-0.0332806371,
-0.0023726043,
0.0075850454,
-0.0047450201,
-0.0378591418,
-0.003759183,
0.0348126143,
-0.0482558087,
-0.0057895756,
-0.0096439142,
0.0116153704,
0.0037969593,
-0.0441616215,
-0.051721666,
0.028654132,
-0.0275623649,
-0.0071963132,
-0.0325557403,
-0.0255847573,
-0.0080613922,
-0.0262738802,
-0.0251459479,
-0.0257529486,
-0.0488423593,
0.0155084943,
-0.019117916,
0.0288207568,
-0.0414748043,
-0.0440241136,
-0.0039424943,
0.0334980525,
-0.0507323705,
0.0048652841,
-0.0288349316,
-0.0307121836,
-0.0353265181,
0.0233714189,
0.0654689968,
0.0355206355,
-0.0190762673,
0.0431541167,
-0.016315436,
0.0852790326,
-0.0098844524,
0.0489430912,
-0.0170568377,
-0.0046293596,
-0.0498609059,
-0.0113540478,
-0.0416975915,
-0.0239810795,
-0.0254448503,
0.004066241,
-0.0026933108,
0.0011224758,
-0.0417814851,
0.0762499869,
-0.0622610301,
0.0192089044,
-0.0233698189,
0.0278943926,
-0.0283466987,
0.0213835742,
-0.030928025,
-0.0235508848,
-0.00548374,
-0.0349267721,
-0.0504607968,
0.0274134856,
-0.0275148209,
-0.021923827,
0.0009520127,
0.0432126559,
-0.0089893835,
0.0175356623,
-0.0084299631,
-0.0469159,
0.0002993175,
-0.0367720835,
0.0156616904,
-0.0739220977,
-0.0002008709,
-0.0165995546,
0.0000400913,
-0.0382317863,
0.0282506701,
0.0143243065,
0.0042317803,
0.0858518034,
-0.0360760503,
-0.0255299676,
-0.0076109706,
0.0156026566,
-0.0098463874,
0.049935922,
0.0136702983,
0.0379045568,
0.0086484998,
-0.0210462362,
0.0505634211,
-0.0090400083,
0.028315248,
-0.0164616723,
-0.0592580214,
0.0123016238,
-0.0130119603,
-0.0000915233,
0.0615853332,
0.0148567725,
-0.0519410074,
-0.0195815153,
-0.0072983699,
-0.0050451956,
-0.0122810099,
-0.0093991021,
0.0674156323,
-0.0124829598,
0.0050440733,
-0.0002947137,
-0.0931502655,
0.0468949154,
0.0263136383,
-0.0266150944,
-0.0360720493,
-0.0129222795,
-0.0134613644,
-0.0718372092,
0.0123441648,
0.0278516263,
0.0016205983,
0.0126459235,
0.0487876423,
0.0455073565,
-0.0311727058,
-0.0017592452,
-0.0188838206,
-0.0147701744,
-0.0516211092,
-0.0318951756,
0.0403338373,
0.0751610845,
0.0279623102,
-0.0169827305,
-0.0285792891,
-0.0010303243,
-0.0033076019,
-0.0541703925,
0.057878755,
-0.0045198444,
0.0065464322,
-0.0281079765,
-0.0264716744,
-0.0696496964,
0.0174245425,
0.0313821547,
0.0348552652,
-0.0211446639,
0.0050858706,
-0.0083213132,
0.0013671487,
0.0286188927,
0.095188126,
-0.0131033249,
-0.0216843504,
0.0054303268,
-0.0222100988,
-0.0239132978,
-0.0203964021,
-0.0063211941,
0.0141925486,
-0.0215107426,
0.0061915843,
0.0142462617,
-0.0147099141,
-0.0782016367,
0.0203723647,
-0.0614165887,
-0.0609006286,
0.0495315902,
-0.0742007792,
0.0013662347,
0.0660794601,
-0.0290023983,
-0.0513047911,
0.0038329025,
-0.0021850532,
-0.0083628809,
-0.0344556682,
-0.0335665494,
0.0414689071,
-0.0114201922,
-0.029878743,
-0.0210177507,
0.046547249,
0.0223950315,
-0.0396101698,
0.022150496,
-0.0178529304,
-0.0225525573,
0.001746422,
-0.0261547528,
0.0205900483,
-0.0306618791,
0.0112836622,
-0.076622799,
0.0123908222,
-0.0301635694,
-0.0105088251,
0.0017427512,
-0.035467647,
0.0185666457,
-0.0461034514,
0.008951013,
0.0309238099,
0.0213129502,
-0.0240086876,
0.0264264699,
-0.0029036568,
-0.0126236081,
-0.0457926989,
-0.0157302525,
-0.030052945,
0.028361911,
0.0063942671,
-0.0043300455,
-0.0604991168,
0.0204957668,
0.0069038766,
0.0626993403,
-0.0175700709,
-0.0006633049,
0.0383514129,
-0.012150825,
-0.0178144779,
0.0930999294,
-0.0573451109,
0.0710769743,
0.0177615639,
0.003337899,
-0.0702079386,
0.0451573618,
0.0596771426,
-0.0394439287,
-0.0002897897,
-0.0183575861,
-0.0577637404,
0.0682950839,
-0.0163406264,
0.01884095,
-0.0446139611,
0.0732693598,
0.0020346274,
-0.0227442905,
-0.0281600691,
-0.0287217163,
0.0444116928,
0.0505997352,
-0.0474556126,
-0.0776595995,
0.0581862107,
-0.0088448264,
-0.01598645,
0.0335151218,
-0.0021559533,
-0.0150399078,
0.0878117457,
0.0353495777,
0.0028988614,
-0.0205627792,
-0.0298665334,
-0.0183259752,
-0.0218795575,
0.0218252968,
-0.0182374418,
0.0699820444,
-0.0745351836,
-0.0372003801,
-0.0231683291,
-0.0346330032,
-0.0413641408,
0.013500887,
-0.0475224219,
-0.0198564176,
-0.0066331849,
-0.0165301785,
-0.0219680332,
-0.012497535,
0.0047180932,
0.0193885528,
0.0132442703,
-0.0411845632,
-0.0271294583,
-0.039144624,
0.0219926797,
0.0141937807,
0.0094920658,
-0.0454501398,
0.0177967269,
0.0804085284,
0.0291803945,
0.0075166109,
-0.0778259411,
0.0252271891,
-0.0110542281,
0.0432688072,
-0.0147169018,
-0.0136798685,
0.0971386507,
-0.1024164706,
-0.0453093648,
0.0377876498,
0.0231465027,
-0.0089507392,
0.0044293869,
0.0002892719,
0.0233807527,
0.0815269202,
0.060944479,
-0.1026613042,
-0.0712682083,
0.0107167158,
0.0419339687,
0.0286264941,
0.0030114197,
0.0005323007,
-0.0811996162,
0.0655680075,
0.0082772598,
0.0105215628,
-0.0360410661,
0.0014783787,
-0.0286247507,
-0.0202523116,
-0.0225800369,
0.0089489464,
0.0262234993,
0.0376360342,
0.0189945959,
0.016752556,
0.0158979762,
0.030960029,
-0.0183436051,
0.0010897774,
0.0641053468,
-0.0432776287,
0.0262749642,
0.0018074565,
0.0159457829,
0.0338793658,
0.0324673615,
-0.0192465223,
0.0866784006,
0.0090031121,
-0.0434767865,
0.0079913689,
-0.0083893193,
-0.0257533342,
-0.037177667,
0.0246701818,
0.049501311,
-0.0174501222,
-0.0140936095,
-0.0230470002,
-0.0012520601,
-0.0222914312,
-0.0134877358,
0.0511068814,
0.0139998496,
-0.0884048343,
-0.0528144464,
-0.0023361298,
-0.0993744433,
-0.0326184146,
0.0184793957,
0.0373613276,
-0.0288453382,
-0.0127760544,
-0.0124062113,
0.054959666,
0.054440815,
-0.0243274644,
-0.108279191,
-0.0053936229,
-0.0015560314,
-0.0844800174,
0.0727500767,
0.0050931531,
0.0467945449,
0.0136994999,
0.018357059,
-0.0406101421,
0.0164200924,
-0.0139961373,
0.0532193966,
-0.0579777136,
0.0025311236,
-0.0422408506,
0.1041635349,
0.0113705788,
0.0661791191,
-0.0132115921,
-0.0141113233,
-0.0581153631,
-0.0140693253,
0.0179913137,
-0.0160478037,
0.0239890516,
-0.0638501495,
0.0031334283,
-0.014572069,
-0.0237997398,
0.0069945185,
0.0151528595,
-0.0036964472,
-0.0243413318,
0.0330837071,
0.0309775919,
0.0015474003,
0.044597581,
0.0263851304,
0.0286029652,
0.0132060144,
0.0216096733,
0.0083608991,
-0.0233333837,
-0.076610446,
0.0394517668,
0.0191848073,
-0.0515839197,
0.0420213193,
-0.0252790153,
0.0042931936,
0.0070883152,
-0.0331189558,
0.0311797466,
0.0287337676,
0.024007462,
0.0106186932,
0.0165961031,
0.009817319,
0.0291564967,
0.0374682248,
0.0734425858,
-0.0024016448,
0.0674777552,
0.0510183647,
0.0389419757,
-0.0093508475,
-0.0088801067,
-0.0184028111,
-0.0531659573,
0.022236621,
-0.0020028565,
0.0641641244,
0.0229995903,
0.0108233467,
0.01427045,
-0.0040345723,
0.0214290097,
0.0230749063,
0.0005225884,
-0.0502993278,
0.0254775826,
0.0533257239,
0.0178080313,
-0.0838898793,
0.0383028872,
-0.0024962989,
0.030080203,
-0.0181091353,
-0.0299021825,
-0.0388474353,
-0.0139719108,
0.0282925479,
-0.0254037436,
0.0241179187,
0.0057550631,
-0.0106413197,
-0.0953814611,
-0.0165455714,
0.0680232346,
0.0058909995,
0.022725692,
0.0098840762,
0.0229176693,
0.0234496184,
-0.0640931576,
0.0054680579,
0.0083040409,
0.0057684649,
-0.0269483719,
-0.0149020525,
-5.439459784e-33,
-0.0470467508,
-0.0646047816,
0.0405886285,
-0.008254665,
-0.0238369722,
-0.0123905931,
-0.0412931256,
0.0221536364,
0.0081518907,
0.0363661423,
0.0225270335,
0.0355676487,
0.0012552864,
-0.0188728012,
0.0188898668,
-0.0080510844,
0.0449693054,
0.0466931015,
-0.0633225143,
-0.0028262364,
0.0080278646,
0.0127882306,
0.0273727961,
-0.0877806023,
-0.0160366539,
0.0442675725,
-0.0353685617,
0.0512943454,
-0.0057721459,
0.0336330682,
0.0207583942,
-0.0093230736,
-0.0147044156,
-0.0277540553,
-0.0315589085,
-0.0276008043,
-0.093530558,
-0.0134088118,
-0.0018603508,
0.0768925771,
-0.0771866068,
-0.0005448017,
0.0309907328,
0.021316709,
0.0340016298,
-0.0301949419,
0.0175957456,
-0.0195031073,
0.0340731703,
0.0415798537,
-0.0277876537,
-0.0027624872,
-0.0706952363,
-0.041344665,
0.0328448191,
0.0334405527,
0.0281330291,
-0.0007105347,
-0.0503063053,
-0.0197776388,
0.0354328528,
-0.0211155489,
0.0804129615,
0.0455810986,
-0.0084374296,
0.0353683978,
0.0403786898,
0.0114968903,
-0.0505162962,
0.0060129026,
0.0047694114,
0.0635758936,
0.0659747571,
0.0110313427,
0.037972562,
0.0301137269,
-0.0384648703,
0.0017095626,
-0.0728537515,
0.0715541616,
-0.0152334739,
0.0003703111,
-0.0023893185,
-0.0062231096,
-0.0448990799,
0.0102687003,
-0.0333304852,
0.0038471778,
0.0515230149,
0.0431057513,
-0.0130294329,
0.013218672,
0.0033746224,
-0.0422192104,
0.029490117,
-0.0156303048,
-0.0210233349,
0.0160590727,
-0.0289169904,
0.0139420005,
0.0101134116,
-0.0044043725,
0.0292106681,
-0.0012826504,
0.0748110414,
0.0081387255,
0.0668000579,
0.0160524696,
-0.033934325,
0.0071065947,
-0.0501520224,
0.0412350893,
-0.0113989012,
0.0343263224,
-0.0041518696,
-0.0147350151,
-0.0495865121,
0.0163818467,
0.0079253837,
-0.0019047627,
-0.0233258009,
-0.0032407651,
0.0043150098,
0.0120083503,
-0.0368447229,
-0.0354809836,
-0.0369746052,
-0.015335002,
-0.0057417355,
-0.0612435527,
-0.0106915701,
0.0350819789,
2.592e-7,
0.0377986953,
0.0414783917,
0.0303107761,
0.0508966818,
0.0061453059,
0.0769546852,
0.0009206188,
-0.0137662068,
0.0322138444,
-0.0372000188,
0.0024380593,
0.0550057553,
0.0225205608,
0.0357870646,
0.019567281,
0.0307689402,
0.017463807,
-0.0083201863,
-0.0323267207,
0.0153804086,
0.050192602,
0.0642656684,
0.014934659,
-0.0210296512,
0.1025403142,
-0.0163291041,
0.0138536133,
0.0147798806,
0.006384247,
-0.0179340374,
-0.0130012231,
0.0445427559,
-0.0019874587,
0.0218075216,
-0.00335959,
-0.0424156897,
-0.02141927,
0.0423050597,
-0.0392483436,
0.0163605604,
-0.0228401385,
0.0235529616,
-0.0007220196,
-0.0446550958,
0.0402905755,
-0.0531699173,
-0.0026618328,
0.0018001979,
0.0051196832,
-0.0235973056,
0.0163789,
0.0088425204,
0.0228826702,
0.0108217737,
0.0261186864,
-0.0066240188,
-0.0171699654,
-0.0452305935,
-0.0283773802,
0.0081873843,
0.0158205498,
0.0261897855,
-0.0255467147,
-0.0018223769,
-0.0041060271,
0.0096887667,
-0.0483197533,
2.422212639e-34,
0.0279677361,
0.0013311594,
0.0234233439,
-0.0180402398,
0.0816722587,
-0.0165984463,
-0.0664306656,
0.0095049059,
0.0325240754,
0.007519328,
-0.0377493948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13443v1 | Dual-Phase Accelerated Prompt Optimization | 2024-06-19T11:08:56 | 2024-06-19T11:08:56 | Muchen Yang, Moxin Li, Yongle Li, Zijun Chen, Chongming Gao, Junqi Zhang, Yangyang Li, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Gradient-free prompt optimization methods have made significant strides in
enhancing the performance of closed-source Large Language Models (LLMs) across
a wide range of tasks. However, existing approaches make light of the
importance of high-quality prompt initialization and the identification of
effective optimization directions, thus resulting in substantial optimization
steps to obtain satisfactory performance. In this light, we aim to accelerate
prompt optimization process to tackle the challenge of low convergence rate. We
propose a dual-phase approach which starts with generating high-quality initial
prompts by adopting a well-designed meta-instruction to delve into
task-specific information, and iteratively optimize the prompts at the sentence
level, leveraging previous tuning experience to expand prompt candidates and
accept effective ones. Extensive experiments on eight datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed method, achieving a consistent accuracy gain over
baselines with less than five optimization steps. | [
0.0465662517,
0.0517733321,
-0.0011603301,
0.0273132864,
-0.0383759849,
-0.0062851757,
0.0313805118,
-0.0384832062,
-0.0021063569,
-0.0223760512,
-0.0421046652,
-0.0533496924,
0.0259059668,
-0.0044642496,
0.0160066169,
-0.0195576232,
0.0633281097,
-0.0658906475,
-0.0190383419,
-0.0295740627,
0.008508998,
0.00477657,
-0.0178976469,
0.0422167704,
0.0245458148,
-0.0378825366,
-0.011924183,
0.0284952652,
0.0223005954,
-0.022408586,
0.0306980405,
0.0768745169,
-0.0137738148,
0.0427633561,
0.0000021421,
-0.0572779067,
-0.0043947371,
-0.0189033207,
-0.0516816936,
0.0477690175,
0.055364538,
0.0033479924,
-0.0090917042,
0.0457997657,
-0.0092568705,
-0.0102193803,
0.0276603904,
-0.0092937937,
0.0650243759,
0.0712265,
0.0107748853,
-0.0021335317,
-0.0011130662,
-0.0436397828,
-0.0233942587,
-0.044771608,
0.0415892117,
-0.0568012334,
0.0066599897,
0.0320791379,
-0.0154380742,
0.0436423868,
0.0016892717,
-0.0159429591,
0.0125744818,
0.0163318291,
-0.0272300038,
-0.0401361287,
-0.0579152294,
0.0867421031,
-0.0093613425,
-0.0103283664,
0.0076980968,
-0.0475487746,
0.0067324284,
-0.015964536,
-0.0135642206,
0.0388208963,
-0.0000517306,
0.0097193904,
-0.0066303322,
-0.0202319939,
0.0042657321,
0.0081322389,
-0.0222874936,
0.0747760758,
0.0299975537,
-0.0372878872,
0.0449222736,
-0.0156501196,
-0.0522711277,
-0.0424480513,
0.0109271817,
0.0256774202,
-0.0901125893,
0.0145793194,
-0.0334561281,
-0.0381559432,
0.0105649112,
0.0331922695,
0.0874748006,
0.0355264321,
-0.0118308691,
0.0399538353,
0.0027422553,
0.0538386442,
-0.0058852383,
-0.0097149769,
-0.0479653031,
0.0221233852,
-0.0169623867,
0.007430146,
-0.0539774746,
0.0030103317,
-0.045268137,
-0.0188532341,
-0.0189744234,
0.0453053527,
0.0158710033,
0.002303791,
0.0408404022,
-0.0085875532,
-0.0178428888,
-0.0045977081,
-0.0045018354,
0.0239550825,
-0.0390548781,
0.0185151473,
0.0036075413,
-0.0337142944,
-0.0195997451,
0.0292511079,
0.0042738914,
-0.018170096,
-0.0087797465,
0.0027867274,
-0.0293856002,
-0.0191221517,
-0.0151081849,
-0.0061088698,
-0.0147266509,
-0.0637304932,
-0.0189923439,
-0.0376071073,
0.0236179791,
-0.0053610993,
-0.0017450344,
-0.0023671333,
0.0054332269,
0.0164372325,
-0.0124891102,
0.0621443316,
-0.0338905416,
0.0342253074,
0.0156899169,
-0.0007788572,
0.009747697,
0.0733669847,
-0.0012072163,
0.0420365855,
0.0124853337,
0.0095850062,
-0.0210455507,
0.0594366603,
0.0297430661,
0.018944487,
0.0119368667,
0.0041555986,
0.039541211,
0.0439237058,
0.0139724994,
0.0550024807,
-0.0158685129,
0.0223164167,
0.0601099208,
0.0150609743,
-0.0033541047,
-0.0200744234,
0.0565407313,
0.0458778888,
-0.0031874692,
-0.0019946059,
-0.0476835184,
-0.0334572978,
-0.0260986239,
0.0235882159,
0.0341869593,
0.0479029529,
-0.0294374172,
-0.0093897805,
0.0080630928,
-0.003641153,
-0.0477650985,
0.0391046181,
-0.0049917181,
0.0077261012,
-0.0866286084,
0.0046332045,
0.0256875865,
-0.0238577537,
-0.0136696137,
-0.0303575657,
0.0306234807,
0.0643439963,
0.0322411507,
-0.012735148,
-0.0278448462,
-0.0235082339,
0.04626026,
0.0584001169,
0.0188471228,
-0.0158211663,
0.0120839169,
-0.0753863826,
-0.039333649,
0.0285097342,
-0.0046404023,
0.0406458154,
0.011648885,
-0.0062726373,
0.0317847244,
0.0367128737,
-0.0127693247,
0.0344791859,
-0.0417988971,
-0.0165425502,
0.0352596492,
0.013751776,
0.0247658435,
0.0223872121,
-0.0123635009,
-0.0037133943,
0.0098217027,
-0.0383554287,
-0.0048712883,
-0.032830283,
-0.0765927881,
-0.0566117391,
0.0238413867,
0.0091028493,
-0.0207583364,
0.0364553966,
-0.0224729981,
-0.0503206253,
-0.0424365774,
-0.0084195612,
0.0053887041,
-0.0531339385,
0.0361355506,
-0.0132399909,
0.0381172672,
-0.065107666,
0.0340530984,
-0.005817465,
0.0127798654,
0.0924977884,
0.0233305469,
-0.0144129852,
-0.0611761473,
-0.0431944653,
-0.0072175357,
-0.0021365047,
0.0210761428,
0.0302714054,
0.0343219526,
-0.0285112727,
-0.0336593464,
-0.1060675383,
0.0442638434,
-0.0413287468,
-0.0066637476,
0.0028125406,
0.0236088224,
-0.0480470583,
-0.0006772929,
-0.0075611509,
0.0129293231,
-0.0092843166,
0.0276930369,
0.0232266895,
0.0203585923,
-0.0268160366,
-0.0250907056,
-0.0095018456,
0.0029322421,
0.0119986096,
0.0017574723,
0.0053938115,
-0.0424982905,
0.0491240844,
0.0132939657,
0.0143156014,
0.0009039753,
-0.0093671335,
-0.0229283758,
-0.0068240953,
0.08197736,
0.0601547547,
0.0220488422,
-0.0168607496,
0.0144530125,
0.002177591,
-0.0714108348,
0.0227793455,
-0.0377196819,
-0.0444318391,
-0.0144604836,
-0.010079138,
0.0282950234,
0.092780076,
0.0241404101,
-0.0192865152,
-0.0406429954,
0.0053969189,
-0.0110797519,
-0.0209883098,
-0.0658182129,
-0.0042080493,
-0.0402094685,
0.0175927393,
-0.0232173428,
-0.036550995,
0.0805881992,
-0.0564489476,
-0.0122343739,
-0.0413404182,
-0.0017742595,
-0.0392130353,
-0.0051594693,
-0.0095649818,
-0.021435231,
0.0315370969,
-0.0398411341,
-0.0391521566,
0.0235027932,
0.0393744782,
-0.0085244682,
0.0302971136,
-0.00595407,
-0.000224674,
-0.0275465958,
-0.0550953895,
-0.0528589301,
-0.0770414099,
-0.0013997505,
0.0030743501,
0.0335205644,
0.0121456115,
-0.0367541425,
-0.0014549232,
-0.0024991841,
0.0635512248,
-0.0517923906,
0.0194775146,
-0.0461038053,
0.0157067254,
0.0741507411,
0.0167763345,
-0.0082493927,
-0.0364892781,
0.0632282943,
-0.0153120421,
0.0449215248,
0.0035909507,
-0.0200084373,
-0.0028418894,
0.0550533421,
-0.0297623742,
-0.0103740608,
0.0430785567,
0.0521250479,
-0.0364377089,
-0.0106225852,
0.1197877079,
0.0282942243,
-0.0725210831,
-0.0158316735,
0.008953834,
0.0526005663,
0.022607306,
0.0134324878,
-0.0650608167,
-0.0515175164,
0.0196816772,
0.056555327,
0.0021031282,
-0.0126089584,
-0.0219158661,
-0.1340091079,
0.0294114351,
-0.0103671458,
-0.0070313266,
0.0050548567,
-0.0465582535,
-0.0003763243,
-0.0091143223,
0.0524864979,
0.0341893584,
-0.0243270602,
0.0112723252,
0.0102598136,
-0.0214719251,
-0.0499319434,
0.0073415698,
-0.0241548549,
0.0626255423,
0.0805398226,
-0.011851741,
0.0183365904,
-0.0246293694,
0.0746489242,
-0.0138438605,
-0.018781215,
-0.027739739,
-0.0125440117,
-0.0259881113,
-0.0035587482,
-0.0041882191,
0.0473707393,
-0.0200103689,
-0.0062157819,
0.0472466797,
0.0706506744,
-0.0032173651,
0.0087069282,
-0.0096712774,
0.0057421611,
0.0659356117,
0.0899836347,
0.0397813916,
-0.0931856632,
-0.0178037416,
-0.0063239285,
-0.0111696208,
-0.0568678342,
-0.0173282735,
0.0231550373,
0.0117259696,
0.0014428055,
-0.0427725129,
-0.0260935687,
0.0113913259,
0.0311960522,
0.015528691,
0.0159341227,
-0.0336231515,
0.0015685766,
-0.0379445329,
0.0492260642,
-0.0392762907,
0.0170284957,
-0.1188094839,
-0.008906831,
0.0170392394,
-0.0369739085,
-0.0203942787,
0.0478814878,
-0.0945547968,
-0.0745161697,
-0.0113976365,
0.036210604,
0.0118204467,
0.0462101512,
-0.026795214,
-0.0579974465,
0.0635089725,
0.0210109539,
-0.0126954308,
0.0056558838,
0.0068779243,
0.0183078721,
-0.0300799385,
0.0352060013,
-0.0253095794,
0.0248417798,
0.0381380282,
0.0592095815,
0.0370959677,
-0.0692901015,
0.0096891634,
0.068371512,
0.0691943243,
-0.0352706946,
-0.0409806818,
-0.0561528169,
0.0352329127,
0.0123486826,
-0.0097008143,
-0.0330281258,
0.0319823027,
0.0296877492,
-0.046455171,
0.0084836232,
0.0112451036,
-0.0074866586,
0.0300648585,
-0.0696720332,
0.0227823723,
-0.0285859127,
0.0268176384,
0.0556648895,
-0.0003627636,
-0.0061365287,
0.0389559269,
0.0401261747,
0.0019199345,
-0.0133723198,
0.0577392206,
0.0317817032,
0.0139394281,
-0.0195827708,
0.0292310789,
-0.0449394286,
-0.0383332409,
-0.0190177225,
0.0430455357,
0.0554679483,
0.0240909494,
0.020100221,
0.00812326,
-0.0041361144,
-0.0509772338,
0.0417704731,
0.0214320198,
-0.047421515,
0.0369024351,
0.0122030145,
-0.0250822604,
0.0248836856,
0.0625611842,
-0.0321574919,
0.0229839329,
-0.0051784874,
0.021976009,
-0.0658784583,
-0.0261172708,
-0.006157422,
0.0065839263,
-0.0591359995,
0.0141803194,
-0.0260959081,
-0.0280587506,
0.0169003271,
0.003028268,
-0.0298871994,
0.0139036272,
0.0566580892,
0.0335646234,
-0.0400765091,
-0.0065162606,
-0.0360819213,
0.0004724154,
-0.0175580811,
-0.0400626957,
-0.0022357823,
-6.463512993e-33,
-0.0289871097,
0.0157030281,
0.0130614145,
-0.0169457477,
-0.0419053063,
0.0118513256,
-0.0176809356,
0.0128612556,
-0.0024502883,
-0.0146609051,
-0.0501938164,
-0.0130643388,
0.0291308705,
0.0368012339,
-0.0253134649,
0.0041660578,
0.0509092622,
-0.0138399834,
-0.0643277094,
0.0247458816,
-0.0051618833,
0.0555524305,
-0.0163888168,
0.0235017259,
0.0172760133,
-0.011012909,
-0.0267414991,
0.0256935712,
-0.0025735265,
0.0457485951,
-0.0371347144,
0.0570984259,
-0.0005850334,
-0.071599111,
-0.0347593576,
0.0689259619,
-0.0519633628,
-0.0153170601,
0.0387765318,
-0.0000996861,
-0.0504377112,
-0.0468881838,
-0.0274985433,
-0.0167029593,
-0.029099131,
0.009087136,
0.0222728737,
-0.008951325,
-0.0293560326,
-0.031110948,
-0.0331683792,
0.0019974867,
-0.0128328726,
-0.030289907,
0.0257887896,
0.0453963876,
-0.0039907931,
0.0235279091,
-0.0036922649,
0.0213170014,
0.021500282,
0.0564659275,
0.0555459149,
0.0534044355,
0.003864503,
0.0238598604,
0.039022103,
-0.0006435054,
0.003299817,
-0.0090357689,
0.0329980962,
-0.0150153209,
-0.0029755102,
0.0343523286,
-0.0261907391,
-0.020223707,
-0.0579401515,
0.0122312894,
0.0433219485,
-0.0164568648,
0.039594382,
-0.0114239193,
0.0097520025,
-0.0271786209,
-0.0782442093,
0.0043541519,
-0.0431635641,
0.0244340356,
0.0496379398,
0.0303533338,
-0.0291030034,
-0.0311719049,
0.0632101297,
-0.0228794087,
0.014457413,
0.0212566834,
-0.0018487587,
0.0048254877,
-0.0020076337,
0.0550869554,
-0.0800292864,
-0.0263118912,
0.0137853436,
-0.0084613012,
0.0160101019,
0.0106073963,
-0.0029932188,
0.0109489691,
-0.0610217117,
0.0057540638,
-0.0248088427,
0.0473377369,
-0.0155586265,
0.0205043051,
0.0350957215,
-0.0130919982,
0.007076581,
0.0894639865,
0.0163847227,
-0.0214697476,
-0.0201605354,
-0.0296799745,
0.0092696203,
0.0287356619,
-0.01761516,
0.0305902492,
0.0062544825,
0.0102682887,
0.0006782464,
-0.0341513045,
-0.0102761537,
0.0165519454,
2.682e-7,
0.0090109846,
0.0594901964,
0.0183921009,
0.0381543711,
-0.0019492966,
0.0041953297,
-0.0115387226,
0.0075151194,
-0.0026530924,
-0.010355534,
0.0277653746,
0.0122247059,
0.0642596707,
-0.0375555493,
-0.132350862,
0.001224733,
-0.0589438938,
0.04790546,
-0.0851571634,
0.0095554609,
0.01389468,
0.0945517942,
-0.0215691347,
-0.0097120814,
-0.01606928,
0.0097928345,
0.0374870375,
-0.032355804,
-0.0203120783,
0.0536189154,
0.035184104,
-0.0254457965,
-0.0196330082,
0.0205051601,
-0.0072077536,
0.0380202644,
-0.0023342087,
0.0851244181,
0.0363965891,
-0.0266613811,
0.0047510811,
-0.0037744085,
-0.0117594581,
-0.0263512451,
0.0792675689,
-0.0366572328,
0.0042680474,
-0.0407625064,
-0.0048044859,
-0.0476172902,
0.0197921991,
-0.0611196309,
-0.0000662678,
0.0114342617,
0.0260671731,
-0.0015064516,
-0.0197883844,
-0.0695132092,
0.0108705685,
-0.0086953696,
-0.0549959168,
-0.05283482,
-0.0336395539,
-0.0074930531,
0.0320343226,
-0.0901031792,
0.01172949,
2.71111586e-34,
0.0645188689,
-0.0387776271,
0.0260825697,
0.007996154,
0.0097652962,
-0.0229156911,
-0.0127051612,
0.0166550782,
0.0237364881,
-0.1263290793,
-0.0427734666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13439v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13439v1 | Finding Blind Spots in Evaluator LLMs with Interpretable Checklists | 2024-06-19T10:59:48 | 2024-06-19T10:59:48 | Sumanth Doddapaneni, Mohammed Safi Ur Rahman Khan, Sshubam Verma, Mitesh M. Khapra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly relied upon to evaluate text
outputs of other LLMs, thereby influencing leaderboards and development
decisions. However, concerns persist over the accuracy of these assessments and
the potential for misleading conclusions. In this work, we investigate the
effectiveness of LLMs as evaluators for text generation tasks. We propose FBI,
a novel framework designed to examine the proficiency of Evaluator LLMs in
assessing four critical abilities in other LLMs: factual accuracy, instruction
following, coherence in long-form writing, and reasoning proficiency. By
introducing targeted perturbations in answers generated by LLMs, that clearly
impact one of these key capabilities, we test whether an Evaluator LLM can
detect these quality drops. By creating a total of 2400 perturbed answers
covering 22 perturbation categories, we conduct a comprehensive study using
different evaluation strategies on five prominent LLMs commonly used as
evaluators in the literature. Our findings reveal significant shortcomings in
current Evaluator LLMs, which failed to identify quality drops in over 50\% of
cases on average. Single-answer and pairwise evaluations demonstrated notable
limitations, whereas reference-based evaluations showed comparatively better
performance. These results underscore the unreliable nature of current
Evaluator LLMs and advocate for cautious implementation in practical
applications. Code and data are available at https://github.com/AI4Bharat/FBI. | [
0.0153447445,
0.0364791229,
-0.012929474,
0.0141716562,
-0.0454955772,
-0.012109844,
0.0245501716,
-0.0126805315,
0.0159161687,
-0.0789098144,
-0.0074221664,
-0.0414070897,
0.0110162571,
0.020253472,
0.0294307489,
0.0029769272,
0.0451703705,
-0.0389882512,
0.0303781405,
0.0089198686,
0.001383143,
0.0147359464,
-0.0054138992,
0.0398828164,
0.0317709148,
-0.0411596932,
-0.002480153,
-0.0109899454,
0.0219094753,
-0.0190210268,
0.0087840194,
0.0624527894,
-0.0326720551,
0.0040452108,
0.0000022643,
-0.0482678562,
-0.0127167189,
0.0011009157,
0.0044937031,
0.0623739995,
0.0085131917,
0.0341581292,
-0.0193114094,
0.0322348587,
-0.0464484841,
0.006306638,
-0.0007633484,
-0.0090975566,
0.0914795846,
0.0533662774,
0.0213090684,
0.0293186605,
0.0280950312,
0.002499941,
0.0307045504,
-0.0095387865,
-0.004521268,
0.0376939178,
0.0226128958,
0.0023878999,
-0.0091613214,
0.0173226967,
0.0344363376,
-0.0300479326,
0.0230665989,
0.0200689174,
-0.0272865742,
-0.0180991888,
0.0039642649,
0.0368373692,
0.0030228659,
-0.0245759189,
-0.0106212422,
-0.0208515748,
0.0060514472,
-0.0022024005,
-0.0342937782,
0.0489921197,
-0.0071543264,
-0.0059229918,
0.0269876532,
0.0033903562,
0.0195476189,
0.0153586641,
-0.0056470851,
0.0658308789,
-0.007421914,
-0.0404348783,
-0.0302123073,
0.0201280136,
-0.013111895,
-0.0885858312,
0.0206330009,
0.0509420708,
-0.0429465584,
0.0252142213,
-0.0443927683,
0.0097059095,
0.0554997921,
-0.0196719244,
0.0572623126,
0.0129098054,
-0.0019079908,
0.0039729541,
-0.0363903642,
0.1168514192,
0.025083553,
0.0342988297,
-0.0500964671,
0.034077201,
-0.0441031866,
-0.0377985463,
0.0333061144,
0.033526428,
0.0051675094,
-0.0015779865,
-0.0658625662,
-0.0032009517,
-0.0305428654,
0.0325053744,
0.006654663,
0.0096176555,
0.014205344,
0.0168119594,
-0.040317893,
0.0164211318,
-0.0129972193,
0.0219297912,
0.0366015658,
-0.0519890338,
0.0176859684,
0.0315393582,
-0.0060654967,
-0.0013816038,
0.0126608852,
0.0574939623,
-0.01278501,
0.0073906737,
-0.0332837328,
-0.055422321,
-0.0349495821,
-0.0766008571,
-0.0169429369,
-0.0891673788,
-0.0261523537,
0.0244978629,
-0.0036703362,
-0.0490412824,
0.0174973328,
0.0520906933,
0.0289038308,
-0.0127230724,
-0.0130669428,
0.0164149832,
0.0118472399,
0.0240316838,
0.0007212154,
0.0341055878,
0.0689767525,
0.0292934626,
0.0168089326,
-0.0296182185,
0.0388294011,
0.0290793832,
0.0027398763,
-0.0152438581,
0.0036708475,
0.0038956814,
-0.0296101011,
0.0236099903,
0.0016136926,
0.0606089942,
-0.009252931,
0.0495573245,
0.0597288944,
0.0252854154,
0.0353003517,
0.0114634391,
0.0705552697,
0.0188774988,
0.020403862,
0.0312950425,
-0.0300817396,
0.0190960392,
0.0005621114,
0.0131043773,
0.0231161881,
0.0363605358,
0.0118522849,
-0.0989879742,
-0.0107830856,
0.0117648765,
-0.003261192,
0.0182750095,
0.0190331861,
0.0100706145,
-0.0390436426,
0.0390143096,
-0.0192659292,
-0.0742258579,
0.0508036911,
-0.0446727015,
0.0468306169,
0.0890721157,
0.0667338744,
0.002052729,
-0.012200742,
-0.0150822392,
0.0021988414,
0.0230427273,
0.0312898532,
-0.0053321752,
-0.0188572723,
-0.0493586995,
-0.0042364872,
-0.0332770459,
0.0265052225,
-0.0076795444,
-0.0055135172,
0.0008929571,
0.0507289246,
-0.0565397479,
-0.0909663439,
0.0398759618,
-0.0270604715,
-0.0197317954,
-0.0088909017,
-0.0161264632,
0.0110500054,
0.024548335,
-0.0175688248,
0.0547276288,
0.0106923832,
-0.0323292799,
-0.0045370585,
-0.0156622268,
-0.0270089339,
-0.0091495533,
0.0422090925,
-0.0454623289,
0.0110400803,
0.0327516533,
-0.0194956549,
-0.0451909527,
0.0110332584,
-0.0500910282,
-0.0198887307,
-0.0196308009,
0.0318895914,
-0.0158379078,
-0.0213482231,
-0.0447547212,
0.0554290563,
-0.0081151593,
0.048585806,
0.0137287881,
0.0259815212,
0.0165928584,
-0.032606326,
-0.0205502007,
0.0016882888,
-0.0251141004,
0.0314382836,
0.0230184514,
0.057604149,
-0.0475552604,
-0.047841236,
-0.0746856853,
0.0107079167,
-0.0274977442,
0.0368600711,
0.0379463546,
-0.0498422012,
0.0036127726,
0.0591298863,
-0.0649913028,
-0.0377804823,
0.0507500507,
0.0032425658,
0.0306351781,
-0.0194774289,
-0.007852084,
-0.0384834968,
-0.0106906416,
-0.0350784212,
0.0369814895,
0.0460944809,
0.0166682471,
-0.0602883622,
0.0530779846,
-0.0538323261,
-0.0471053682,
0.0193496179,
-0.0376698785,
0.0270503182,
0.0079728449,
0.0239329319,
0.0426685959,
0.0249558538,
0.0179590601,
0.0507235043,
-0.0387889519,
-0.0573646165,
-0.0106249182,
0.0267232936,
0.0043293159,
-0.0125247566,
-0.1033219397,
0.0162911508,
0.0553307384,
0.0331943035,
-0.0037336391,
-0.0530276857,
0.0432706773,
-0.0766524225,
-0.0336451158,
-0.0230631866,
-0.0155478315,
-0.0195294116,
0.0484544747,
-0.0115350597,
-0.0611229688,
0.0635088608,
-0.0656111166,
0.0050236578,
-0.0275515728,
0.0021279443,
-0.0640497133,
0.0327016599,
-0.0019180302,
0.0060937684,
-0.0094336597,
0.0116077773,
-0.0556934327,
0.0143046258,
0.0105497269,
-0.0699567348,
0.0378459729,
-0.0800460428,
-0.0136947893,
0.0001555245,
-0.0045659747,
-0.0249147844,
-0.0248066317,
0.0106671927,
0.0151901422,
0.0265173689,
0.009525694,
-0.0131878294,
0.0043952726,
0.0410706252,
0.014606148,
-0.0479739681,
-0.0016035653,
-0.0313349441,
0.0172816366,
0.0460367389,
-0.0173519067,
0.0489733256,
-0.0656056032,
0.0104137948,
0.0577833727,
-0.0028671729,
0.0360952504,
-0.0045768898,
-0.0024573652,
0.0138350232,
-0.0218749885,
-0.0308409557,
0.0481319726,
0.0755304992,
-0.0808187574,
-0.0409460366,
0.1050850749,
0.0292981975,
0.0162317604,
0.0204747021,
-0.0190316364,
0.0297701526,
0.017414473,
0.0379087888,
-0.0600821115,
-0.018440865,
-0.0201667454,
0.0638729036,
-0.0433780588,
-0.0176506937,
-0.026218066,
-0.1171654314,
0.0512544326,
0.0183400363,
0.0066284039,
-0.0040955138,
-0.0101077743,
-0.0266225282,
0.0039629918,
0.0049790996,
0.0377897024,
-0.0066554369,
0.0328659266,
0.0410997793,
-0.0700198263,
-0.0448184386,
0.0302785616,
-0.0109540708,
0.0406097993,
0.064133361,
0.0179420039,
-0.0099630347,
-0.0535388179,
0.019644497,
-0.0548375174,
0.0066791922,
0.0043758294,
-0.003736347,
0.0110850316,
0.0203102361,
-0.0456508771,
0.0169432759,
-0.0159546789,
-0.016133897,
0.0402437896,
0.0781204104,
-0.0162756499,
-0.0263179764,
-0.0211570133,
0.0315940976,
-0.013909285,
0.0649013221,
0.04925818,
-0.0570759773,
-0.0624758266,
-0.0470298566,
-0.0168429296,
-0.0870459005,
-0.0379321389,
0.0376081914,
0.0103515089,
0.0039528506,
-0.0790799558,
-0.0489987582,
0.0226496737,
0.0184473265,
0.0065728975,
0.0180215053,
-0.0145580526,
-0.0265661106,
0.0007870918,
0.0122541264,
-0.008684624,
0.0352309868,
-0.0601380654,
0.0140558155,
-0.0048172101,
-0.0342678502,
-0.0161999632,
0.0099384887,
-0.0721703023,
-0.0529593565,
-0.0172746032,
0.0618637986,
0.0246568937,
-0.0174487773,
0.0078631938,
-0.0518772751,
0.0289189406,
0.0122181782,
-0.0371641405,
0.0564580858,
-0.009261664,
-0.0082734693,
-0.0014433931,
-0.0083925705,
-0.0317488648,
0.0107860165,
0.0084597617,
0.0588509738,
-0.0066336901,
-0.0088893771,
0.0252108797,
0.0418643095,
-0.0087575726,
-0.0199548621,
-0.0022626386,
-0.0213158689,
0.0056425272,
-0.0271651,
-0.0399403349,
-0.0475822277,
0.0009651054,
0.0119589027,
-0.0331274681,
0.0114385122,
0.0058680652,
-0.0372839533,
0.0450703353,
-0.0310201924,
0.0509373695,
-0.0129456995,
0.0141954236,
0.0101743117,
-0.0343106166,
-0.0491298772,
-0.0042565856,
-0.0441709235,
0.0539102033,
0.0283492468,
0.060174033,
-0.0210769493,
0.0113424398,
0.0277852714,
0.0379708298,
-0.0457758233,
-0.037142355,
-0.0173338894,
0.0124663375,
0.0345796458,
0.0412947424,
0.0702985525,
-0.0200812276,
0.0285260603,
-0.0438199826,
0.0344363935,
0.0341513306,
-0.0475304052,
0.0176065546,
0.0224076007,
-0.0153134698,
-0.0492723659,
0.0700472072,
0.017754823,
-0.0039983382,
-0.0273426119,
0.0007325725,
-0.0465655364,
-0.0518793501,
-0.0155218085,
0.0007622246,
-0.0114064869,
-0.0353278667,
-0.0838972926,
-0.0574040413,
0.0156779978,
0.0661276504,
0.0371261425,
-0.0486672893,
-0.0167743135,
0.0705618188,
-0.0294838119,
-0.0091676321,
-0.0729352087,
-0.0179007407,
-0.0234989952,
0.0130300149,
-0.0353256278,
-6.273128459e-33,
-0.0524889491,
-0.0783723071,
0.0437850058,
-0.023348147,
-0.0048841261,
0.0293237511,
-0.0444227383,
0.016155567,
0.0229407586,
-0.0022649162,
0.0086038876,
-0.0129260225,
0.0000741002,
0.0247741174,
0.012358224,
-0.0173682682,
0.0328602158,
0.0345012583,
-0.0708653405,
0.0242613964,
0.0119402083,
-0.0236732922,
0.0297254995,
-0.0340462476,
0.0522483401,
-0.0153707275,
-0.0408877283,
-0.0141328704,
-0.0587093122,
0.0649708286,
0.0152397929,
0.0452875979,
0.0296532772,
-0.0329352282,
-0.0306406915,
0.0015409882,
-0.0144349793,
-0.0098881591,
0.034876164,
-0.0132763768,
-0.0416962206,
-0.0492531992,
0.0632994398,
0.0130385114,
-0.0475747697,
-0.0101336567,
0.0381412394,
-0.0262689162,
-0.0077075609,
-0.0196642596,
-0.0509672165,
0.0480979122,
-0.0148303322,
0.0004339942,
-0.0503341258,
0.1128568724,
-0.0285557751,
-0.0009322568,
-0.0417802632,
0.0265671574,
0.0502632037,
0.0407909714,
0.1068216786,
0.0010213057,
-0.031987045,
0.0658113211,
-0.0023743121,
0.0142911328,
-0.0134769911,
-0.0281560458,
0.0182874277,
0.0275357049,
0.0857979953,
0.0597400516,
0.0021865319,
-0.0006456991,
-0.0562541671,
0.0402448885,
0.0013664563,
0.0261575822,
0.0376485996,
-0.0327405632,
-0.0403723046,
-0.0388056748,
-0.0586871058,
0.0388648473,
-0.0210661516,
-0.0316049419,
0.0658246875,
-0.0190596394,
-0.0378683396,
-0.0457908548,
0.0285793226,
-0.0133411577,
-0.0085969465,
-0.0001424434,
-0.0403331555,
0.0564602166,
-0.0254078675,
0.0288025308,
-0.0668459311,
0.0001225929,
0.0085576447,
0.007465153,
0.0429469012,
0.0200779997,
0.0078095701,
-0.0033991651,
-0.0411847569,
0.0088840313,
-0.0390249863,
0.0306102429,
0.001914854,
-0.0035610143,
0.0200108103,
-0.024839405,
-0.0215834603,
0.0417066216,
-0.0096826712,
-0.0142356697,
-0.0169282984,
-0.0285325088,
0.0090621794,
0.0097938543,
-0.0492926762,
0.0034335868,
-0.0245770961,
0.0301900413,
-0.0003205056,
-0.025452042,
0.0017310105,
0.027344536,
2.812e-7,
0.0511924811,
0.0516586974,
-0.0221305043,
0.0264630597,
0.0171890855,
0.0223592073,
-0.008954349,
-0.0074740513,
0.0423227027,
0.0027534617,
-0.0092876488,
0.0153069338,
0.0622857772,
0.0504011735,
-0.0320328884,
0.0209297277,
-0.0646510199,
0.0062175184,
-0.0571388081,
0.0045424765,
0.0817207247,
0.0070241382,
-0.0278896522,
-0.0026911569,
-0.0060160747,
-0.0452329256,
0.0464008078,
-0.0014128576,
-0.0195417255,
0.0488922521,
0.0416581333,
-0.0228562187,
0.0158206206,
0.0383127183,
-0.0143248616,
-0.023294121,
0.0170577373,
0.0741546676,
0.0180110671,
0.002782576,
0.0087238885,
-0.025384983,
0.0035424132,
-0.0947611034,
0.0774908066,
-0.0193669479,
-0.0187445804,
-0.0372570902,
-0.0247463919,
-0.0259272195,
0.0005393098,
-0.0119585339,
0.0021461807,
0.0227177851,
-0.0100340089,
-0.0199389923,
-0.011842344,
0.0029583029,
-0.0597272627,
0.0042562997,
-0.0151741821,
-0.0690138191,
-0.0732592493,
0.0208863765,
-0.0254951045,
-0.0813605338,
-0.0034144637,
2.975589462e-34,
0.0229216553,
-0.0259234924,
0.042183131,
-0.0002375269,
0.0536595993,
0.0430002362,
-0.0280256737,
0.0128951073,
-0.004509801,
-0.0466576815,
-0.0189421661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13431v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13431v2 | Children's Speech Recognition through Discrete Token Enhancement | 2024-06-19T10:45:12 | 2024-06-24T15:31:59 | Vrunda N. Sukhadia, Shammur Absar Chowdhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Children's speech recognition is considered a low-resource task mainly due to
the lack of publicly available data. There are several reasons for such data
scarcity, including expensive data collection and annotation processes, and
data privacy, among others. Transforming speech signals into discrete tokens
that do not carry sensitive information but capture both linguistic and
acoustic information could be a solution for privacy concerns. In this study,
we investigate the integration of discrete speech tokens into children's speech
recognition systems as input without significantly degrading the ASR
performance. Additionally, we explored single-view and multi-view strategies
for creating these discrete labels. Furthermore, we tested the models for
generalization capabilities with unseen domain and nativity dataset. Results
reveal that the discrete token ASR for children achieves nearly equivalent
performance with an approximate 83% reduction in parameters. | [
-0.0219840091,
0.0474035405,
-0.0043502515,
0.0125892684,
-0.014779239,
-0.005440467,
0.0962159634,
-0.0320720337,
-0.0460124426,
-0.0205712337,
-0.0244776141,
-0.0278272964,
0.0290089156,
0.0068559381,
-0.0045217657,
-0.0627044737,
0.0322071612,
-0.0855516121,
0.045289468,
-0.008184527,
-0.0356334448,
0.0046447036,
-0.0162678901,
0.0630981624,
-0.0690021217,
0.0071501029,
0.0058581885,
0.0230566077,
0.0271070432,
-0.031020768,
-0.037239138,
0.006358278,
0.0346922949,
0.0525628999,
0.0000017547,
-0.0409866534,
-0.0448488817,
0.0360140391,
-0.0524776503,
-0.0304879807,
0.031836886,
0.0081580216,
0.0080928141,
0.0114894006,
0.0027540913,
-0.0284532756,
0.0739636719,
0.0758967772,
0.0207834058,
0.0407755002,
-0.0190218575,
-0.0368204638,
-0.0069898092,
0.0238798466,
-0.0099075036,
-0.0232615229,
-0.0004390427,
-0.0462209731,
0.0368122086,
-0.0286083538,
0.016121015,
0.0486466624,
0.0049754223,
-0.0280910004,
0.0200112239,
0.0054128869,
-0.0387483239,
-0.0489648953,
-0.0351432823,
0.0286646169,
0.0218957216,
0.0067482358,
0.0256915297,
-0.0003759807,
0.0011664182,
-0.0210934691,
-0.0288096201,
0.0138986632,
-0.0235786717,
0.0236451142,
-0.0336850695,
0.0032394982,
0.0190405436,
-0.0216318313,
-0.0005496097,
0.0637008548,
-0.0132531021,
0.0079174079,
-0.0066091651,
-0.0362496339,
0.0117564304,
-0.0227776431,
0.0483755544,
-0.0156636927,
0.0019680299,
0.0092640473,
-0.083956331,
-0.0405037627,
-0.035187941,
0.0104130134,
0.0054722051,
0.0090543628,
-0.0609999932,
0.0290424731,
0.0108041801,
0.0353924893,
0.0162427109,
0.0719855577,
-0.0436748303,
-0.0206686538,
-0.0054734317,
0.0031756898,
-0.0618837103,
0.1003995016,
-0.023385061,
-0.0181331113,
-0.0289642364,
0.0100894114,
-0.0253146514,
-0.0141007425,
0.0401926525,
0.0010756108,
-0.0238127038,
-0.0234929826,
0.0401526429,
0.0057645803,
-0.0142489942,
0.0362310149,
0.0116353547,
-0.0772841722,
-0.0236821808,
-0.0347868428,
0.0652976111,
0.0177639369,
-0.0309920646,
0.0537489019,
0.0083156768,
-0.0085796714,
-0.0097969016,
-0.0008341742,
-0.0186450668,
-0.0328773372,
0.0076483153,
-0.0607954338,
-0.0100358296,
-0.0078554768,
0.0088161072,
-0.0359238759,
0.0043026102,
-0.029346237,
0.0123904925,
0.0402403176,
-0.022592213,
-0.0098874047,
-0.0143975718,
0.0093481811,
0.0254392885,
0.0722248778,
0.0439216234,
-0.0520611405,
0.0455376767,
-0.0362976268,
-0.0167553201,
0.0293841232,
-0.0077124531,
-0.0162669253,
-0.0289873853,
-0.0323938318,
0.0170132164,
-0.010658022,
-0.0169271342,
0.0360594615,
-0.0270297658,
-0.0251212846,
0.046420671,
0.0741663426,
-0.0187757872,
0.0095663015,
-0.0093152765,
-0.0171508752,
0.0150831416,
-0.0084085502,
-0.0446363203,
0.0028024826,
0.0577624179,
-0.0201816596,
0.0266717616,
0.021219518,
-0.0219342615,
-0.0215616245,
-0.0285631996,
-0.0317439437,
0.0039138123,
0.0325491726,
0.0542292036,
0.0015352534,
-0.0138998721,
0.0156760644,
-0.0130221024,
-0.0681903362,
0.0236357022,
-0.0671253875,
0.0136560518,
0.0165900644,
0.0013106196,
-0.0513126105,
-0.0241307542,
-0.0016587118,
-0.0438978411,
0.0141213443,
-0.0429716669,
0.0075798575,
0.0910784826,
-0.0075199595,
-0.0307639819,
0.0412385203,
0.0249516461,
0.0629677474,
-0.0246667713,
-0.0057276445,
0.0136235906,
-0.0613804981,
0.0480606109,
0.0118728206,
0.0458284616,
-0.0149051761,
0.0902895331,
0.0150050167,
0.0619469956,
0.081076853,
0.0074509522,
-0.0179755185,
0.0523761138,
-0.0034721671,
0.0388888046,
0.0250940211,
-0.0295883846,
-0.0066478578,
0.0352040678,
-0.0469795167,
0.0081155356,
0.0221437123,
-0.0174887329,
-0.0384540893,
0.0346524268,
-0.0402072221,
0.0733697489,
-0.0042528445,
0.0348621868,
0.0009755237,
-0.0044856318,
0.0238739904,
-0.0125573119,
0.0202670544,
-0.025928339,
-0.0237391535,
-0.0564022884,
-0.0203644931,
-0.07023637,
0.0084003974,
-0.0012091129,
-0.0549141467,
0.0316206403,
0.0078680841,
-0.0609540083,
-0.0390509889,
0.0358448364,
-0.1036276743,
-0.0598012917,
-0.001527206,
0.0066393646,
-0.0184490159,
0.0069973865,
0.0431167558,
-0.0132944956,
-0.0201897901,
-0.0406701006,
-0.0577436797,
0.0304749794,
-0.0426484756,
-0.0181110092,
-0.0864826515,
0.0175370071,
0.0055122408,
-0.0056292536,
-0.0029582556,
-0.0226473622,
-0.0595733523,
-0.0174251273,
-0.0371210352,
-0.0159249753,
0.0394668132,
-0.0171305388,
0.0395206325,
0.0285490435,
0.0095103933,
0.006468867,
0.0582023226,
-0.0301519055,
-0.019233726,
-0.0012162457,
-0.001152033,
-0.0434800498,
0.0093343705,
0.0417784564,
0.0431049652,
0.0234349128,
0.010167012,
-0.0028199982,
0.0071089878,
0.0342306308,
-0.0138439937,
-0.0040024966,
0.0165273007,
-0.0292991493,
-0.0559868813,
-0.0487055369,
-0.0589691103,
-0.0336682238,
-0.0109337857,
0.00576805,
-0.0324607268,
0.0011353478,
-0.0587815046,
-0.024366267,
-0.0110659357,
-0.0329520106,
0.0095710084,
0.0215525348,
0.0012956636,
0.0188495126,
0.0123571875,
-0.0634401217,
-0.000588575,
0.0041172756,
0.026547838,
-0.050455559,
0.0639981776,
-0.0071575344,
0.0077977371,
-0.0092165638,
0.0003047679,
-0.0392122753,
-0.0119975181,
0.0154338693,
0.0695576891,
-0.0148323746,
-0.0393607244,
-0.0303753242,
0.0292753745,
0.0307340417,
0.0741336197,
-0.0038066418,
0.0334637314,
-0.0206023939,
0.0155221233,
0.0201696064,
0.0007795562,
-0.0148651386,
-0.0091105504,
0.020969484,
0.0277082417,
0.0990941823,
0.0049378937,
-0.0058925725,
-0.0307164174,
0.0177554842,
0.020472819,
-0.0045335805,
0.0265612714,
0.0705122575,
-0.0349158347,
0.0124896662,
0.048806455,
-0.0006443657,
-0.0079869805,
-0.0167743657,
0.005182208,
-0.0218770839,
0.0080379425,
-0.0846404508,
-0.0118991565,
0.0078851739,
0.0881552622,
0.0415430814,
-0.0192389302,
-0.0092096189,
-0.0262604505,
-0.0407988764,
0.0121263685,
0.0227954667,
-0.0697878227,
-0.0398961939,
-0.0672268942,
-0.0008484591,
0.0280187503,
0.0667850673,
-0.015044353,
-0.0167589262,
-0.0730822161,
0.0160214081,
-0.0146696419,
-0.0374373719,
-0.0056569148,
-0.0034939703,
0.0684291273,
0.0230801739,
0.0071146358,
-0.0209316928,
-0.0161199458,
0.0465513356,
0.0527712144,
-0.0167711657,
-0.0216622502,
-0.0081720026,
-0.0071668006,
0.0101028532,
0.0466661714,
0.0498210415,
0.0255965572,
0.0088658165,
0.0145973172,
0.0313523449,
-0.005180703,
0.0074580689,
0.0110005746,
-0.0170074608,
-0.0059734154,
0.0562418923,
-0.0050601899,
-0.0234657377,
0.0199427474,
0.0103006037,
0.0487659872,
0.001865649,
0.0355086662,
0.0155131174,
-0.0488549992,
-0.0905330703,
-0.0642998144,
0.0717826113,
0.0172928609,
0.0702870041,
0.0362546891,
0.008247843,
-0.0002721976,
0.0427877009,
-0.0181153901,
0.0033362091,
-0.0459036827,
0.0096767163,
-0.0811016411,
-0.0304815285,
-0.0300827213,
-0.0684436038,
-0.0375649072,
0.0131202955,
-0.0557965823,
-0.0606641285,
0.0213836692,
-0.0419904366,
0.022559287,
0.0454308391,
-0.0279912315,
-0.0261928272,
0.1138688922,
0.0562927052,
-0.0122731449,
-0.0474256314,
0.0737678483,
-0.0058213403,
0.0000235883,
0.010012636,
-0.060242597,
0.0292624664,
0.0121298824,
-0.0143247005,
-0.0235679094,
-0.0020191423,
-0.0250305589,
0.0361360908,
0.097094439,
-0.0121031394,
-0.0122626629,
-0.0235197954,
0.063206397,
-0.0638076738,
0.0612878911,
-0.0354385749,
-0.0188096315,
0.0088974778,
0.0285339616,
0.0007095616,
0.0024024532,
-0.0090025607,
-0.0273454245,
0.0179866534,
0.0691648051,
0.0153086865,
0.0285529867,
0.0063802497,
-0.0000985944,
-0.0542482324,
0.0365924723,
0.0336560346,
0.0068814075,
-0.0011350513,
-0.0051950174,
-0.0108675668,
0.0274964087,
-0.0106286155,
0.0435441881,
-0.0082504367,
-0.0097354185,
-0.0412923805,
0.0201252643,
-0.021218352,
0.03741863,
0.0049490416,
-0.0013987977,
0.0281570274,
-0.0457717776,
0.0078088944,
0.0033474874,
-0.0386702344,
0.0173730738,
-0.0128421085,
-0.0082232459,
0.0333226696,
0.0449694321,
-0.0100987647,
-0.029154731,
-0.0537589751,
0.0295098219,
-0.0296041388,
-0.0244743489,
-0.0007715738,
0.0225590505,
-0.0196199566,
0.0066681667,
0.0173204057,
-0.0483495668,
-0.0060330518,
-0.0252905246,
0.0027858696,
-0.0175061673,
0.0129117761,
-0.0212776586,
-0.0453870632,
-0.0330934636,
0.0157967266,
-0.0581316948,
0.0567822941,
-0.010114098,
0.0203271657,
-5.891161488e-33,
-0.0111594675,
-0.0207065158,
-0.0451626927,
0.0012296409,
0.0026804756,
0.0475161634,
0.0051091821,
0.0366487838,
0.0126295118,
-0.0494048223,
-0.0155103737,
-0.0340084471,
0.0488621034,
0.0137656415,
-0.0284907669,
-0.0122391721,
0.100773178,
-0.0120247686,
-0.0071996208,
-0.0173496474,
0.0616922192,
-0.0042479392,
0.0392225683,
-0.0379893929,
0.0140104303,
0.0186895747,
-0.0346073844,
-0.0012418044,
0.0132948803,
0.0556901656,
0.0249232724,
0.0292929914,
0.0029400305,
-0.0338519737,
-0.0076878201,
0.0497411601,
-0.1006232351,
-0.0155324908,
0.0205958895,
0.0416669957,
0.0058158212,
-0.052173283,
0.0370651707,
0.0041469983,
-0.0088219224,
-0.0350318551,
0.0119094495,
-0.0030574847,
-0.0122316303,
-0.0493420847,
-0.0027168549,
0.0128855743,
0.0042266385,
0.0244448278,
0.1110480055,
0.0441141315,
-0.0207483042,
-0.046576988,
-0.0626784191,
0.0361187719,
0.0468173064,
0.0305973776,
0.0307161734,
0.0304507688,
0.0231914725,
0.0299060754,
0.1038654894,
-0.0714651793,
0.0015161555,
-0.0227528978,
0.0307614859,
0.023270797,
0.0264120139,
-0.0095093511,
0.0593238622,
-0.0161217134,
-0.0505965464,
-0.0235675443,
-0.0146300793,
0.0037651523,
0.052336324,
0.0299452506,
-0.0313234553,
0.0419546999,
-0.0501781628,
-0.0325410217,
-0.0504566021,
0.0228696615,
0.0301228277,
0.0205556899,
-0.0663767084,
-0.0068171294,
0.0536350757,
-0.0042299358,
-0.0189035796,
0.0107978797,
0.1031453833,
0.0063833753,
-0.0147074293,
-0.0224117227,
-0.0477418117,
-0.0350095332,
0.0800423324,
-0.0041813985,
0.0310897753,
-0.0317751169,
0.039909035,
0.0231470782,
-0.0856560171,
-0.0175117888,
0.0210219137,
0.05003855,
0.0064572506,
0.0181270614,
0.0735639632,
-0.0267896634,
-0.009402818,
0.0201915447,
0.00847595,
0.0171776079,
-0.004456419,
0.0808773786,
-0.0046105748,
-0.0088852933,
-0.0212818291,
-0.0079589365,
0.0251236502,
-0.038323082,
0.0535979047,
0.0236680638,
-0.0131519521,
-0.0013018217,
2.533e-7,
-0.101542078,
0.0195993334,
0.0114929527,
-0.0501783527,
0.0499014147,
0.0300589427,
0.0201058611,
0.0014246228,
0.0317042395,
0.0070412531,
0.0078247059,
-0.0471831448,
0.0664624497,
0.0485221893,
-0.1111599058,
0.014294751,
0.0153212193,
0.036734134,
-0.0115049733,
0.0546329021,
0.0279131737,
0.0744455755,
0.0225260109,
-0.040372178,
-0.0009976599,
-0.0314063542,
-0.0262684338,
-0.0340686999,
0.0405835323,
-0.0435582176,
-0.0160735007,
0.0089320568,
0.0359551273,
0.0350414328,
-0.0309950374,
0.0504208207,
0.0064684735,
0.0199664012,
-0.0460287742,
-0.053076461,
-0.0206329841,
0.0353661925,
-0.0277470537,
-0.0221601911,
0.0877218619,
-0.003146223,
0.0001133349,
0.0208979733,
-0.0279500149,
0.0016792894,
-0.0282357316,
0.010158808,
0.0156363621,
0.0430090018,
-0.0047699208,
-0.0320422836,
-0.0159854144,
-0.032194417,
0.0319884755,
-0.0592261143,
-0.0445086807,
-0.055899173,
-0.0006031979,
0.0270976238,
-0.0496721826,
0.0010708148,
0.0249164831,
1.767739514e-34,
0.0117800673,
-0.0724610686,
0.0287132636,
-0.0012419332,
0.0090396563,
-0.0370703861,
-0.0166841988,
0.0027777452,
0.0151268542,
-0.0294864625,
-0.039375525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13415v1 | Factual Confidence of LLMs: on Reliability and Robustness of Current Estimators | 2024-06-19T10:11:37 | 2024-06-19T10:11:37 | Matéo Mahaut, Laura Aina, Paula Czarnowska, Momchil Hardalov, Thomas Müller, Lluís Màrquez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) tend to be unreliable in the factuality of their
answers. To address this problem, NLP researchers have proposed a range of
techniques to estimate LLM's confidence over facts. However, due to the lack of
a systematic comparison, it is not clear how the different methods compare to
one another. To fill this gap, we present a survey and empirical comparison of
estimators of factual confidence. We define an experimental framework allowing
for fair comparison, covering both fact-verification and question answering.
Our experiments across a series of LLMs indicate that trained hidden-state
probes provide the most reliable confidence estimates, albeit at the expense of
requiring access to weights and training data. We also conduct a deeper
assessment of factual confidence by measuring the consistency of model behavior
under meaning-preserving variations in the input. We find that the confidence
of LLMs is often unstable across semantically equivalent inputs, suggesting
that there is much room for improvement of the stability of models' parametric
knowledge. Our code is available at
(https://github.com/amazon-science/factual-confidence-of-llms). | [
0.0330364779,
0.0698464736,
-0.0006499727,
0.0534785651,
-0.048920501,
-0.0264759678,
-0.0182941481,
-0.0076419665,
0.0020986577,
-0.058883477,
-0.0308330953,
-0.0626106858,
0.0248788819,
0.012907532,
0.0285239387,
0.0276596546,
0.0636424646,
-0.0434376039,
0.0075279078,
-0.0224094931,
-0.0173074622,
-0.0197268073,
-0.0212680046,
0.0280522313,
-0.022330828,
0.0000321645,
0.0188748464,
-0.0216906331,
0.0092218425,
-0.015525437,
0.0188603327,
0.0412079357,
0.030795062,
0.0544178039,
0.0000016394,
-0.0494199768,
0.011016543,
0.0011695642,
-0.0439777076,
0.0224997308,
-0.0096033774,
-0.0271115284,
-0.0011714048,
0.0257088449,
-0.0323955677,
0.0329366252,
0.0131596662,
-0.0031458258,
0.0573942922,
0.059298031,
0.0287855957,
0.0045221727,
0.0248933528,
-0.002785095,
-0.0121121695,
-0.0218546987,
0.0547067225,
0.0187822189,
-0.0410301015,
0.0224675052,
-0.0238119382,
0.0554062948,
0.0192245562,
0.0054273312,
-0.0323144831,
0.0553515591,
-0.0108700115,
-0.0243803486,
-0.0046381024,
0.0491608381,
0.019451214,
-0.0358162448,
-0.0266465861,
-0.011721909,
-0.0193873066,
0.0152254095,
-0.0328365415,
0.0351040661,
0.0062659173,
0.0265147127,
0.006478563,
0.0170312822,
0.0304787811,
0.0281841028,
0.0254249256,
0.1089509502,
0.0168859977,
-0.0520435981,
-0.0249828678,
0.0212649833,
-0.0173876248,
-0.0542776436,
0.0086086662,
0.0418536291,
-0.0181997623,
0.0698880255,
-0.0304194633,
-0.0003963051,
0.0449053831,
-0.0416699946,
0.0038002839,
0.0355038755,
-0.0444619432,
0.0555340722,
-0.0255154409,
0.0665231273,
0.0031053771,
0.0091259042,
0.0312182512,
-0.022540329,
-0.0031980702,
0.0056383009,
0.0113109509,
0.0296894927,
0.0104821976,
-0.0079355882,
-0.054611519,
-0.0035230697,
-0.0132084927,
0.0651062578,
-0.0070665292,
0.0360246338,
0.0120517975,
0.0003356688,
-0.0706148744,
0.0333779603,
-0.0093158865,
0.0399242528,
0.0016370413,
-0.0759902671,
-0.0301939547,
0.0107975136,
-0.0137700178,
-0.0124233961,
0.0090795374,
0.0005933255,
0.0007973919,
-0.0352018252,
-0.0338808522,
-0.0139096109,
-0.0363738425,
-0.0697582364,
-0.0377529599,
-0.0836018026,
0.0219838768,
0.0001209915,
0.0051789279,
-0.0602432154,
0.0393065847,
0.0370872207,
-0.0103715137,
0.0853179023,
0.0053346241,
-0.0089553287,
-0.0082979016,
0.0199567322,
-0.0155460266,
0.0370541662,
0.0458116755,
0.0060999752,
0.0901328698,
0.0264927316,
0.0195440743,
-0.0019608408,
0.0324870721,
0.0074432194,
0.007919848,
0.0378243215,
-0.0009237386,
0.0259243269,
-0.0021447423,
0.0637560934,
-0.0204544049,
-0.0678273216,
0.1030444205,
0.0407958664,
-0.0224576835,
-0.0086572627,
0.0268735066,
-0.0190196037,
0.0736729056,
0.0064429427,
-0.0267331675,
0.0064863786,
-0.0676107258,
0.0219581816,
0.049104806,
0.018755462,
-0.0131459115,
-0.0692228675,
-0.0604655966,
-0.0241021998,
-0.0244805217,
0.0316124298,
0.0376349464,
-0.030766055,
-0.0208062921,
0.0377858207,
0.0157334916,
-0.0259014983,
0.0121139148,
-0.0587605238,
0.0539289452,
0.0216145646,
0.0566946194,
-0.0179936308,
-0.0104620447,
-0.0091908118,
-0.0125938263,
0.0361760743,
0.0424761139,
0.0024708181,
0.0488493741,
-0.0114613231,
0.0380743593,
-0.0289372504,
0.0367087834,
-0.0207893178,
0.0486047752,
0.0383290835,
0.0107782884,
-0.0704300553,
0.0104912035,
0.0275229067,
-0.0022730229,
0.0035747476,
0.0164489672,
-0.0390063971,
0.0336626768,
-0.0162543226,
-0.0252040476,
0.0256713908,
0.0228662379,
0.0297004189,
-0.0216522068,
-0.0321775228,
-0.0083168056,
-0.0384342074,
0.0549368113,
0.0033279657,
-0.0351493061,
0.0496354699,
-0.020565277,
-0.0295064114,
-0.0042563691,
-0.039185442,
-0.014332871,
-0.0566445887,
0.0214107987,
0.0160462782,
0.0475050807,
-0.0397817977,
0.0445014574,
-0.023843484,
0.0337488353,
-0.014649841,
0.0077417148,
0.0288852025,
-0.0322253853,
-0.0304999202,
0.0036529026,
-0.0003784798,
0.0132134892,
0.0278482474,
-0.0353837907,
-0.0518169105,
-0.0273457598,
-0.0534923449,
0.0102752252,
-0.0264617987,
0.0321191214,
0.0135731753,
-0.0364695638,
-0.0018597067,
-0.0092086764,
-0.0360493362,
-0.033189524,
0.0139519013,
0.0057310248,
0.0581540838,
-0.0114309229,
0.0060876505,
-0.0684849992,
0.0090156458,
-0.0324697718,
0.0352228954,
-0.0202130079,
-0.0226145796,
-0.0521918051,
0.0260590445,
-0.0544784069,
0.0463373624,
-0.0029568786,
-0.0435656086,
0.0277674384,
0.0427350737,
0.004247007,
0.0840378329,
0.0246971436,
0.0149783958,
0.0879492685,
0.00872231,
-0.042699188,
0.0172728002,
-0.0396439098,
-0.006711022,
-0.024603501,
-0.0545486733,
0.0302144475,
0.0323124379,
0.0232470538,
-0.0438072756,
-0.0287986007,
-0.0026346303,
-0.0158707201,
-0.0329500623,
0.0070380173,
0.0215363167,
-0.0371217094,
0.0469156504,
-0.0176047646,
-0.0361425132,
0.0787731409,
-0.0776093751,
0.0075213979,
-0.0250133853,
-0.0307302848,
-0.0228070728,
0.0464784466,
0.0168737844,
-0.024197815,
0.0077183261,
0.0309175327,
0.0021994645,
-0.0342208035,
0.023570247,
-0.0621275678,
0.0196706615,
-0.0694344342,
0.0288718808,
0.0299939346,
-0.0293216184,
-0.0668204948,
-0.064659372,
-0.0462885164,
0.006145305,
-0.0535579734,
-0.0355895609,
0.0004794656,
-0.0376982987,
0.0596016757,
0.0193796251,
-0.0205355082,
-0.0203243606,
-0.0177246109,
0.0304668359,
0.0824365541,
0.0211407635,
0.0692421496,
-0.0020420882,
-0.0005336129,
0.093016088,
0.0020396691,
0.0722059086,
-0.0485435426,
-0.0396009646,
0.0240552556,
-0.0104530919,
-0.0035041887,
0.0241869651,
0.0510155037,
-0.0219840594,
-0.033465527,
0.1242369115,
0.0481144935,
0.0053816345,
0.0054213358,
0.0086996751,
0.0147503689,
0.0031019731,
0.0062913736,
-0.0738378242,
-0.0250524562,
-0.0172795057,
0.0338739716,
-0.0590757914,
-0.0183725134,
-0.0335650556,
-0.1154575348,
-0.008465128,
-0.035992261,
0.0204006415,
-0.0443957746,
-0.0662682429,
0.0690447167,
-0.0067857471,
0.0457347333,
-0.0081654601,
0.0036338887,
0.0042277058,
0.0302480515,
-0.0485360473,
-0.0707534179,
0.0335354432,
-0.0254212189,
0.0601327568,
0.0308118016,
0.0331825875,
-0.0126564503,
-0.0571748652,
0.007778849,
-0.0169945862,
-0.0192005094,
-0.0070635206,
0.0353391543,
-0.0332324989,
-0.0013139715,
-0.0200659875,
0.0128208557,
-0.0059654536,
-0.0323778987,
-0.0178377964,
0.0354787596,
-0.0180396307,
-0.0534924679,
-0.0093523655,
-0.0011242668,
-0.0139613682,
0.0959876105,
0.0282237642,
0.0116549525,
-0.0015170767,
-0.0359020606,
0.0130574964,
0.0034514826,
-0.0290403962,
0.0252456777,
0.0293168649,
0.0209015161,
-0.074011527,
-0.0056975749,
0.0172279272,
0.0355411246,
-0.0530577414,
0.0047012544,
0.0571508072,
-0.0119769732,
0.0068560168,
0.0154490145,
-0.0762728974,
0.0437783487,
-0.0230431892,
0.0230630916,
0.055685319,
0.0045561409,
-0.0199409593,
-0.0213021692,
-0.1135095432,
-0.0845062956,
0.0039933478,
0.0392957516,
0.0274129715,
0.0101770405,
-0.0459140018,
-0.0387787521,
0.02473028,
-0.0010856158,
-0.0146421781,
0.0238312911,
0.041528143,
0.0110882306,
-0.0038269358,
0.0225872342,
-0.0219126195,
-0.0479769222,
0.0175066795,
0.05515901,
-0.0389474221,
-0.0606966428,
0.0241415109,
0.0176447332,
0.0350250155,
0.026719315,
0.033250194,
0.0026947467,
0.015889002,
-0.0179247186,
-0.0074334862,
-0.0118495058,
0.0317032076,
0.0238455124,
-0.0256232787,
-0.0482346155,
-0.0263800882,
-0.0256950017,
0.0331249796,
-0.0153830489,
-0.0429573245,
0.0170338545,
-0.0014016005,
0.0032661541,
-0.0291364826,
-0.0633319542,
0.0175207071,
-0.0129787121,
0.0635247156,
0.040336255,
0.001301403,
0.0265663695,
-0.0548306592,
-0.008463989,
-0.0238655973,
-0.0986815766,
0.0103614684,
-0.0095065432,
0.0706176013,
0.0416247845,
0.0231712069,
0.013944814,
-0.05546581,
-0.006803432,
-0.012742809,
-0.0067493091,
0.0148690389,
0.0115290284,
0.0636844486,
-0.0037044503,
-0.01459629,
0.0494469553,
0.0872706845,
0.0259494837,
0.0557426587,
-0.0143960733,
-0.0394509211,
-0.0001131962,
-0.0206815507,
-0.0482290909,
0.0207711291,
-0.0248157959,
0.0339354612,
-0.0542660095,
-0.0693029091,
0.0189032629,
0.0246991497,
0.0043796399,
-0.0440279581,
-0.0147991963,
0.0499121025,
0.0454334319,
-0.0025323767,
-0.0494345836,
-0.0015539184,
0.0262372307,
0.0075140907,
-0.0371955559,
-6.359564763e-33,
-0.0160086211,
-0.0679171532,
-0.0207384173,
-0.0126448479,
0.0168727227,
0.0061081499,
-0.0223381165,
0.0181323364,
-0.051035367,
0.0134315481,
-0.0230896026,
0.0265677907,
0.0280530602,
0.0267427973,
-0.0272905435,
-0.0390826166,
0.002808071,
0.0245984215,
-0.0512498692,
-0.0451489352,
0.0033978967,
-0.0231472068,
0.0702715814,
-0.039236661,
0.0576039366,
0.0217204392,
-0.0163523741,
0.0688977689,
-0.085032098,
0.0518092327,
-0.007254201,
0.0624135695,
0.0025562986,
-0.0293615852,
0.0055652009,
-0.0382441953,
-0.0357968174,
-0.0570725985,
0.0669882521,
0.0152514409,
-0.0502077453,
-0.0042894105,
0.0145610953,
-0.0153637547,
-0.0228987951,
0.0193672869,
0.0054800147,
-0.0010964288,
-0.024133632,
-0.0430556722,
-0.0166763626,
0.0338278487,
0.0316647962,
-0.0019412595,
-0.0288286749,
-0.0034922939,
0.0198556408,
-0.0088309953,
-0.0669818223,
-0.0270109195,
0.0098593142,
0.0295475498,
0.0606165379,
-0.0222742595,
0.0133815045,
0.0631726533,
-0.0254679639,
0.0234586969,
-0.0483636968,
-0.0395116173,
0.0219852366,
-0.0135509968,
0.0559346341,
0.0530655198,
0.0022489214,
0.0228617359,
-0.0614842214,
-0.0092144767,
0.0600853637,
0.0211280379,
0.0358112082,
-0.0071955835,
-0.0446460582,
-0.0171068311,
-0.0704123899,
0.0289627183,
-0.0188099761,
-0.0039349291,
0.0081820646,
0.0175967757,
-0.0206215549,
-0.032595139,
-0.0078725014,
-0.0461670831,
-0.0167397838,
0.0109850531,
0.0116314013,
0.0167041738,
0.0070455046,
0.0513066947,
-0.0431844331,
0.0250626355,
-0.0017090671,
-0.004452304,
-0.0003967211,
-0.0019359809,
0.004581626,
-0.0088659683,
-0.0405622758,
0.0232382361,
-0.035037037,
0.0060332068,
-0.0065131462,
-0.0470145196,
0.0191796888,
0.011893278,
-0.0311295148,
0.0313440636,
-0.0170428474,
0.0363054834,
-0.0189275891,
0.0128687518,
-0.0003464048,
0.0359044597,
-0.0376652181,
-0.0105922567,
-0.0396587178,
0.0214290302,
-0.0135260243,
-0.0116338134,
0.007670139,
0.0312097352,
2.489e-7,
0.031686116,
0.0418011546,
0.0026511324,
0.0622659884,
0.0313380919,
0.0353813544,
-0.0315445885,
-0.0170288086,
0.02661076,
-0.0784335732,
-0.0532073043,
0.0308715496,
0.0501007587,
0.0612260401,
-0.0261858292,
-0.0371827222,
-0.0475134775,
-0.0053528235,
-0.0171324238,
-0.021965811,
0.0178890973,
0.0830467641,
0.0363313816,
0.0182908941,
-0.0033244973,
-0.028003864,
0.0533557534,
0.0248265043,
-0.0391293652,
0.0057738265,
0.0630761757,
-0.0006512359,
0.0394137874,
0.0053094355,
-0.0053370264,
0.0165845565,
-0.0280393437,
0.0417982973,
0.0110472394,
-0.0382690206,
-0.0458064228,
-0.0242332518,
0.0271427929,
-0.0518802814,
0.0857356116,
-0.0211114697,
-0.0165391564,
-0.0525768697,
0.0267546922,
-0.0150401704,
0.0570381954,
-0.0020422579,
-0.0264126472,
0.0038891293,
0.0102458093,
0.0162636377,
-0.0191637948,
-0.0443622544,
-0.0339559242,
-0.0385652557,
-0.0385438502,
-0.0781914741,
0.0031026893,
-0.012467999,
0.0342245027,
-0.0758826733,
-0.0107503505,
2.084675176e-34,
0.0357812457,
-0.0073264609,
0.0155563941,
0.0245504417,
0.0507788099,
0.0168435313,
-0.0078634657,
-0.0307915807,
0.0419238359,
-0.0684580803,
-0.0193232633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13408v1 | SQLFixAgent: Towards Semantic-Accurate SQL Generation via Multi-Agent Collaboration | 2024-06-19T09:57:19 | 2024-06-19T09:57:19 | Jipeng Cen, Jiaxin Liu, Zhixu Li, Jingjing Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While fine-tuned large language models (LLMs) excel in generating
grammatically valid SQL in Text-to-SQL parsing, they often struggle to ensure
semantic accuracy in queries, leading to user confusion and diminished system
usability. To tackle this challenge, we introduce SQLFixAgent, an innovative
multi-agent collaborative framework designed for detecting and repairing
erroneous SQL. Our framework comprises a core agent, SQLRefiner, alongside two
auxiliary agents: SQLReviewer and QueryCrafter. The SQLReviewer agent employs
the rubber duck debugging method to identify potential semantic mismatches
between SQL statement and user query. If the error is detected, the
QueryCrafter agent generates multiple SQL statements as candidate repairs using
a fine-tuned SQLTool. Subsequently, leveraging similar repair retrieval and
failure memory reflexion, the SQLRefiner agent selects the most fitting SQL
statement from the candidates as the final repair. We evaluated our proposed
framework on five Text-to-SQL benchmarks. The experimental results show that
our method consistently enhances the performance of the baseline model,
specifically achieving an execution accuracy improvement of over 3\% on the
Bird benchmark. Our framework also has a higher token efficiency compared to
other advanced methods, making it more competitive. | [
0.0487895645,
0.076574333,
-0.0027666735,
0.003107856,
-0.021431027,
0.0152659873,
-0.0392721146,
0.006610957,
-0.0034956953,
-0.0798627734,
0.0367600508,
0.0085314317,
-0.0165779199,
-0.0058817999,
0.0286751222,
-0.0407598801,
0.0502640717,
0.0128788166,
-0.014944545,
0.0318905115,
-0.0057353335,
0.0310425851,
-0.0054950304,
0.0286324974,
-0.0797094554,
-0.0159730539,
-0.0372966379,
0.0459693521,
-0.0201479215,
-0.0099288095,
0.0055003241,
0.0327453092,
-0.0239596218,
0.0236300901,
0.0000022665,
-0.0681954175,
-0.04685333,
0.0263974071,
-0.0289294999,
0.0214206111,
0.0232002661,
-0.0293205827,
-0.0057588136,
0.0459852479,
-0.0334384739,
0.0071411412,
0.0328739919,
0.0027515355,
0.0585369207,
0.0716545656,
0.0014511326,
-0.0058900695,
-0.0227550548,
0.0268580131,
0.0323442854,
-0.0724449754,
0.0036124045,
0.0348680466,
0.0359381922,
-0.0378749296,
-0.0019838454,
0.0080969967,
-0.0061883875,
-0.0557476915,
-0.031226391,
-0.0275853835,
-0.0432048962,
-0.0081500681,
0.0001720323,
0.0082259346,
0.010104931,
-0.0126202619,
0.0140405279,
0.0143122692,
0.0175605156,
0.0097072357,
0.0059685772,
0.0046335235,
-0.0028830417,
0.0029236032,
0.0146464445,
-0.0721131563,
0.0333437622,
0.0068535558,
-0.0606568046,
0.0563490652,
-0.012636913,
-0.0067966748,
-0.0208651908,
-0.009037816,
-0.0224088095,
-0.0028822264,
0.0258773006,
0.0384101681,
-0.1198546514,
0.0210755486,
-0.055404529,
-0.032426998,
0.0290368292,
-0.0535392128,
-0.000690497,
0.0454385057,
0.0315931737,
0.0363425426,
-0.0160755273,
0.0060195648,
0.040045917,
0.0426514074,
-0.0200454853,
-0.0471635498,
-0.0740890056,
0.0077249929,
-0.0689322352,
0.0277251378,
-0.0679097176,
-0.0186638609,
-0.0033575546,
0.0574833602,
-0.0130857546,
0.0791723728,
0.0061525614,
0.0173011106,
-0.0250566658,
-0.0195403211,
-0.0543917343,
-0.0219540726,
-0.0001186256,
0.0080523035,
0.0081255985,
-0.11701563,
-0.0276422072,
0.0039297761,
-0.0072622751,
-0.0213885009,
-0.0172189921,
0.0529186055,
-0.023812633,
0.0258466508,
-0.0992389023,
-0.1003981382,
0.0091836993,
-0.0044537582,
-0.0792946145,
-0.0492702872,
0.0287394896,
-0.00559325,
-0.0113662882,
-0.0556269139,
0.0195163768,
0.0136719169,
0.0111904088,
0.0503586531,
-0.0713762864,
0.0323466137,
0.017019121,
-0.0039514326,
-0.0010199549,
0.0716043562,
0.0221463721,
0.0326949358,
0.0173994228,
0.0123152332,
0.0054024463,
-0.0137410993,
-0.0057671708,
0.014266206,
-0.0594955534,
0.0338460617,
0.0034108176,
0.0707965866,
0.0027753408,
0.0767307207,
0.0007609692,
0.0093422737,
0.0286687948,
-0.009614408,
0.0174367633,
0.0267085284,
0.0622522868,
0.0155566763,
-0.0434638262,
-0.0252464171,
-0.0544409603,
-0.015697943,
0.0068681985,
-0.0021123693,
0.0030955398,
-0.0044412403,
-0.0189729575,
-0.045815587,
0.0025255254,
0.0030795464,
-0.0059651486,
-0.0134085109,
0.0199182611,
0.0252366755,
-0.0375886708,
0.0612513795,
-0.0190560948,
-0.0233703144,
0.0067903516,
-0.0232180562,
-0.0059267962,
0.117068924,
0.0527100712,
-0.0412523448,
-0.037345428,
0.0063006883,
-0.004794322,
-0.0170436352,
0.0601020195,
-0.0231306981,
-0.0385669321,
-0.0198445208,
-0.0034108432,
0.0457996391,
0.0374955945,
0.0027862969,
0.0194050688,
0.0035044018,
0.0468956456,
-0.0058925711,
-0.0596840754,
0.0318484157,
0.0169043858,
-0.0221379474,
-0.0065039727,
-0.0026415444,
0.0156001123,
0.0179229341,
-0.0241945907,
0.0339173526,
0.0205890033,
0.0304572228,
-0.0663746223,
0.0002444051,
0.0119271521,
-0.0230529252,
0.0173608568,
-0.0037709095,
-0.0412123948,
-0.0440490991,
-0.0544691011,
-0.0312798023,
0.0480598882,
-0.050656978,
0.0138389831,
-0.0343081392,
0.0405357406,
0.0017522839,
-0.0594720691,
-0.0233172495,
0.0093590422,
0.0178066269,
-0.0233928747,
-0.0276185665,
-0.0118104741,
-0.0117514087,
-0.0737695023,
0.0426348038,
-0.0012517687,
0.0154813435,
0.060894642,
-0.0252561811,
0.0161362961,
-0.0476343296,
-0.0512676165,
-0.0473010354,
0.0334818549,
-0.0273280963,
0.032052435,
0.0209673606,
0.0364291817,
-0.0081694052,
-0.006404052,
-0.0218750369,
-0.0117420005,
0.0128132496,
0.0213369522,
0.0176744368,
0.0123934755,
-0.0139043173,
-0.0165047999,
0.0071802996,
-0.0655162409,
0.0264571663,
0.001984233,
-0.0273717623,
-0.0397796184,
0.0220078155,
-0.0010269503,
0.0148716308,
0.0390640981,
-0.0103099598,
-0.0108748106,
-0.0287658423,
-0.0282116644,
0.048167821,
-0.0133373793,
-0.0057316739,
-0.0027130542,
-0.033308886,
-0.0467168204,
0.010708916,
0.0109310979,
-0.0164041612,
-0.007148657,
-0.0304565355,
0.0212620459,
-0.0102662072,
-0.0056759287,
-0.0228117313,
-0.0229727942,
0.0198949203,
0.0174064972,
-0.007843798,
-0.0150613822,
-0.0300639104,
0.0213271584,
0.0172725227,
-0.0097630238,
0.0027553826,
0.0531806499,
-0.0138748912,
0.0175013728,
-0.0414374061,
-0.0204354189,
-0.0506693684,
0.0433541723,
0.0015709846,
0.0329461694,
-0.0564183556,
-0.0653741285,
-0.0164483543,
-0.0475045405,
0.0363255888,
-0.0085097812,
0.0837085694,
-0.0727931261,
0.0086397184,
-0.0076320558,
-0.0129461596,
-0.0190631784,
-0.0208496321,
-0.0591625348,
0.0202890765,
0.0607231781,
0.0133875925,
-0.029895775,
-0.0202725586,
-0.020410724,
0.0230659153,
0.0095708743,
-0.0448802933,
-0.0058321222,
-0.0740463957,
-0.0131697897,
0.0376961082,
0.0030562314,
-0.0160787776,
0.0309624281,
0.0617081597,
0.0418741703,
-0.0672046691,
-0.0224939995,
0.0013173156,
-0.0252041873,
-0.0229982845,
-0.0023122407,
0.0142002581,
-0.0116889356,
-0.0781203955,
-0.0138046239,
0.0671064928,
0.0309327506,
0.0380022787,
0.009154181,
0.0225901846,
0.0132259969,
0.0249725357,
0.0487549789,
-0.0747708306,
-0.0436718054,
0.0182302557,
0.0389646702,
0.0366701372,
-0.0321137384,
0.0124354288,
-0.1157830209,
0.0357204936,
-0.0035757474,
-0.0069343457,
0.0219889339,
-0.0175152458,
-0.0280915741,
-0.0371285602,
0.0394945405,
0.1048272327,
-0.0087884152,
0.0036434319,
0.0283954404,
0.0250203647,
-0.0225751791,
-0.0182022639,
-0.0549636222,
0.0259555746,
0.0724644512,
-0.0085535273,
0.0463200361,
-0.0144922081,
0.025412377,
0.0168109685,
0.0327315331,
-0.0176232811,
0.0564019233,
0.002642869,
0.0045575565,
0.0304302853,
-0.0094905626,
-0.0562482364,
0.0313337743,
0.0223935265,
0.0700230151,
-0.0323311873,
0.0385214239,
-0.0054943142,
-0.0288970377,
-0.0055269217,
0.0315577239,
0.0170887206,
0.0203082971,
-0.1117148995,
-0.0355964415,
-0.0354503542,
-0.1069475785,
0.0314176232,
0.0593266748,
-0.0369748287,
-0.0701335371,
-0.0260324385,
-0.0502054207,
0.0701965913,
0.0527798682,
0.0132157123,
-0.0166144855,
0.0147198169,
-0.0153206037,
-0.0230916105,
-0.026810756,
-0.0237892214,
0.0341126844,
-0.0244552381,
0.0429229662,
-0.0149708623,
0.0056212866,
0.0034382672,
-0.0350766219,
-0.0189963244,
-0.0366596021,
0.0314972065,
0.0231444538,
0.0138270017,
-0.0048917951,
-0.02102484,
-0.0731336549,
-0.0540872626,
0.0770852491,
-0.0800253004,
-0.0277187005,
-0.0133299343,
-0.0080282334,
0.0045898571,
0.0389181003,
-0.0593020245,
-0.0463823788,
-0.0595674925,
0.0218648501,
-0.0474052392,
0.0000459145,
0.0770652741,
0.055005312,
-0.0118417582,
0.0582942739,
0.0189399626,
0.0190406349,
0.0393767841,
-0.0540797189,
-0.0529452376,
-0.0211246796,
0.0563795567,
-0.0038594352,
-0.0171303358,
0.0637557581,
-0.0336530246,
-0.0171672218,
0.0526679084,
0.0372634046,
0.0000659693,
0.0106075462,
-0.0095883105,
0.0319338441,
0.0078132749,
-0.0002332482,
0.0178023521,
0.0293393731,
0.0681876689,
-0.0063207988,
-0.0000908015,
0.0410459861,
0.0183690023,
-0.0295356158,
-0.025752021,
-0.0169370286,
-0.0394500121,
0.0338694863,
0.0263269693,
0.0536458418,
-0.0003222884,
0.0303836428,
-0.0094181672,
-0.0207948871,
-0.0396289676,
0.0155734336,
0.0458085351,
-0.0187501963,
0.0125170099,
0.0079632662,
-0.019402368,
-0.0868343562,
0.0561021119,
-0.0165332109,
0.0338902995,
-0.0153170628,
-0.0735746995,
-0.0139881261,
-0.031221265,
0.0162494183,
-0.0311397705,
-0.0357712545,
-0.0675158724,
-0.039729435,
-0.0222146083,
0.0041554444,
0.061934337,
-0.0084797256,
-0.0054973033,
0.0273772515,
0.087103121,
0.0627987236,
-0.0180523954,
-0.0532983504,
-0.0047457721,
-0.0424211212,
-0.0450791419,
-0.0084365532,
-6.038983576e-33,
-0.0457967408,
-0.0411665216,
0.0333980285,
0.0035224727,
0.0010903304,
-0.0487885587,
-0.0390477553,
0.0166065581,
0.0150786107,
0.0439979546,
-0.0055500893,
0.0412336439,
0.0286629107,
0.0129192229,
0.0565104224,
-0.0061956034,
0.058018744,
0.0240041576,
0.0277269315,
-0.0337805673,
0.0649247244,
0.0313531682,
-0.0263949577,
-0.0376910158,
-0.0159043428,
0.0078041926,
-0.0060829069,
0.041586224,
0.0007742536,
0.0171393864,
0.0450180694,
0.0131630776,
-0.0078063859,
0.0330192633,
-0.0280713141,
-0.0694299787,
-0.037070591,
-0.018609317,
0.0076281712,
0.0190438777,
0.0008740061,
-0.0387246162,
0.0754951835,
-0.0198510792,
-0.0447412133,
0.0368284583,
-0.0000650125,
-0.0224502105,
-0.0100970371,
-0.0201494489,
-0.0279454645,
0.0216998756,
0.0012264763,
0.0006018172,
0.0167752057,
-0.0026151945,
0.0235143565,
-0.012680836,
-0.0529481508,
0.0265904851,
-0.0089430818,
0.0510536991,
0.0397471897,
0.0231350586,
-0.0191649925,
-0.0077397674,
0.0182500537,
0.0292229,
-0.0054247282,
0.0746871978,
-0.0344506055,
0.0841712505,
0.0110575724,
0.0858551413,
-0.0084562348,
-0.0570222065,
-0.0493876785,
0.0645619482,
-0.0268399697,
0.0299856234,
-0.0056769946,
0.0450462103,
-0.0556651354,
-0.0390498266,
-0.0377017818,
0.0793548822,
-0.0450935923,
-0.0277880579,
0.0335008055,
0.0043313256,
-0.0012103335,
-0.0133153507,
-0.0147248665,
-0.0233359784,
-0.0238325894,
-0.0405952781,
-0.0481123254,
-0.056483686,
-0.0356639214,
0.016942244,
-0.0057323505,
-0.0323813632,
0.0149888191,
0.0315873213,
0.0194341298,
0.0366364084,
0.0246556085,
0.025814034,
-0.0514275506,
0.0299357045,
-0.0153287826,
0.0318653025,
-0.0366625376,
-0.0370135941,
0.0208335388,
-0.0015550007,
0.0111918328,
0.0165831726,
0.0175291821,
-0.0229322333,
-0.0138860615,
-0.0043568732,
0.008514164,
0.0169545095,
-0.0124755036,
0.011135309,
-0.0245017521,
-0.0279827043,
0.0353862755,
-0.0278214961,
-0.0136246504,
0.0324038975,
3.004e-7,
0.069079347,
0.0416527912,
0.0200170297,
0.0375470929,
0.009974082,
0.0528620295,
0.0069569624,
0.017088471,
0.0005673246,
0.0133591173,
0.0340211429,
-0.0224454813,
0.0364172049,
0.0600212142,
-0.0438340157,
0.015082974,
-0.0118683772,
0.0039784322,
-0.0487167537,
-0.0089597842,
0.0410074517,
0.0292633194,
-0.0095256818,
0.0047697364,
0.0347953662,
-0.0720565096,
0.004002824,
-0.0056909644,
-0.0509526655,
0.0608994216,
0.0210884213,
-0.0017483155,
0.0337661989,
0.0215772223,
-0.016311828,
-0.0221603923,
-0.0148638329,
0.0561667308,
-0.0304407757,
0.0279334076,
0.0092725269,
-0.077947624,
0.0316943862,
-0.0321502574,
0.0186606403,
-0.0098989597,
0.0111386692,
0.09490408,
-0.017673457,
-0.0180324763,
0.0061511588,
-0.0044588773,
0.0019347765,
-0.0147703476,
0.0351513512,
0.0506508984,
-0.0066846479,
-0.0219314247,
-0.0124479523,
0.0191978123,
-0.0380148068,
-0.0183184333,
0.0267133899,
0.0444246121,
-0.0195968077,
-0.0017979394,
-0.027302064,
2.701026583e-34,
0.0409705676,
0.0394419916,
0.0247017443,
-0.0110299867,
0.1070297956,
0.0296983439,
-0.0327950791,
0.0194375888,
0.0057113883,
-0.0208886173,
-0.0452911928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13397v1 | MoreHopQA: More Than Multi-hop Reasoning | 2024-06-19T09:38:59 | 2024-06-19T09:38:59 | Julian Schnitzler, Xanh Ho, Jiahao Huang, Florian Boudin, Saku Sugawara, Akiko Aizawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing multi-hop datasets are extractive answer datasets, where the
answers to the questions can be extracted directly from the provided context.
This often leads models to use heuristics or shortcuts instead of performing
true multi-hop reasoning. In this paper, we propose a new multi-hop dataset,
MoreHopQA, which shifts from extractive to generative answers. Our dataset is
created by utilizing three existing multi-hop datasets: HotpotQA,
2WikiMultihopQA, and MuSiQue. Instead of relying solely on factual reasoning,
we enhance the existing multi-hop questions by adding another layer of
questioning that involves one, two, or all three of the following types of
reasoning: commonsense, arithmetic, and symbolic. Our dataset is created
through a semi-automated process, resulting in a dataset with 1,118 samples
that have undergone human verification. We then use our dataset to evaluate
five different large language models: Mistral 7B, Gemma 7B, Llama 3 (8B and
70B), and GPT-4. We also design various cases to analyze the reasoning steps in
the question-answering process. Our results show that models perform well on
initial multi-hop questions but struggle with our extended questions,
indicating that our dataset is more challenging than previous ones. Our
analysis of question decomposition reveals that although models can correctly
answer questions, only a portion - 38.7% for GPT-4 and 33.4% for Llama3-70B -
achieve perfect reasoning, where all corresponding sub-questions are answered
correctly. Evaluation code and data are available at
https://github.com/Alab-NII/morehopqa | [
0.0325780138,
0.051627215,
-0.0198087003,
0.0410743468,
-0.048011113,
0.0117654409,
-0.0047766767,
-0.0218363591,
0.01954698,
-0.0196379572,
-0.0266065523,
0.0027974802,
-0.0151960161,
-0.0049958201,
0.0437912345,
-0.0309063233,
0.0256605037,
-0.0496178046,
0.0149852037,
-0.0269742217,
-0.0167017505,
0.0453245789,
-0.0237071235,
0.02244436,
-0.0037395072,
-0.0186623782,
-0.0230386909,
-0.0310041141,
0.0059615714,
0.0108244,
-0.0139497556,
0.0514314733,
0.0210956894,
-0.0103650121,
0.0000020101,
-0.048622366,
0.0278754085,
-0.0201161634,
-0.0343984663,
-0.0354004838,
-0.053797584,
0.04474397,
0.0177739579,
0.0393136181,
-0.0600672327,
0.0243248567,
0.0044549317,
0.0546952747,
0.0643910915,
0.0574569739,
0.0094754286,
-0.0846747532,
0.0231322758,
0.0116816172,
0.0549289584,
-0.0397919044,
0.0119749121,
0.0682839677,
0.0486524366,
0.0080683334,
-0.0157896578,
0.0239199884,
0.0589319952,
0.0012114728,
-0.0566977113,
0.0196101703,
-0.0458498746,
-0.0357587524,
-0.0004892978,
0.1011101604,
0.0196590014,
-0.0357809924,
-0.0118055549,
0.0218712986,
0.019112207,
-0.0023717559,
-0.0494782627,
0.0179545749,
-0.0195064135,
0.0004146884,
0.0273332056,
-0.0083676539,
0.0163624715,
-0.0015188321,
-0.0140270321,
0.1061245129,
-0.0118777473,
-0.0290326979,
0.0302595533,
-0.0305391271,
-0.0099751987,
-0.061245732,
0.0067108003,
0.0768809691,
-0.0162132233,
0.0320300385,
-0.006461178,
0.0487563163,
0.0396919325,
-0.0270441901,
0.0126071684,
0.0451121405,
-0.021034563,
0.0839585289,
-0.0140189724,
-0.0086011169,
-0.0255745612,
0.0328783095,
-0.0357724689,
-0.0368537493,
-0.0428709351,
-0.0262160469,
-0.0382431895,
0.0358245969,
-0.0451997221,
0.0106415693,
-0.0002006406,
0.0034436551,
-0.0161366817,
0.0019589232,
0.0365826972,
0.003988517,
0.0210469365,
-0.0019523338,
-0.0301934779,
0.032435637,
-0.1040716097,
0.0658769086,
0.019405283,
-0.0535122901,
-0.0175831188,
0.0028082263,
0.025891114,
-0.0218197946,
0.0378572978,
0.0502366386,
-0.0130301183,
0.0018030693,
-0.0355211198,
-0.0509730838,
0.0151366116,
-0.0978325009,
-0.0187294893,
-0.0775709674,
0.053086333,
0.0068569691,
-0.0365350097,
-0.0260536261,
-0.0013651428,
0.045758646,
-0.0207173433,
0.0732318535,
0.0301529039,
0.0330583565,
0.0429645814,
0.0210716203,
-0.0403710566,
0.0771733373,
0.0390890986,
-0.0123437932,
0.0501057841,
-0.0229612608,
0.016041832,
0.0190145373,
0.041853562,
-0.0205009766,
0.0092419675,
0.0605565235,
-0.0419519804,
0.0161508694,
-0.0027073398,
0.0670173243,
-0.025618095,
-0.0182376225,
0.0181399025,
0.0565536506,
0.0024167572,
-0.006518513,
0.0482391715,
-0.0144914715,
0.0437942594,
0.0259437282,
-0.0485514142,
0.0484498926,
-0.0304237697,
0.0047054538,
0.0221328549,
0.0196364187,
-0.0357854217,
-0.0446081497,
-0.0125462888,
0.033728648,
0.0228219666,
0.0520303324,
0.027598653,
0.0214569271,
-0.0237442814,
0.0480224229,
0.0122119831,
-0.0643573329,
-0.0105949687,
-0.0604690164,
0.0840254351,
0.0178006273,
0.0313362628,
-0.0028289424,
-0.0051133065,
0.0029202655,
0.0137383509,
-0.0039161816,
0.035450954,
-0.0386147834,
0.0070343614,
-0.0224244241,
-0.0040067332,
-0.0152803287,
-0.0025301378,
-0.014922658,
0.001004804,
0.0071470547,
-0.0194373634,
-0.048603639,
0.0554009005,
0.0074771927,
-0.0518936627,
-0.010609502,
-0.0370903797,
0.0036681108,
0.0006003674,
0.0484764203,
0.0250037704,
0.0294405296,
0.0413550213,
-0.0208212268,
-0.0222336836,
0.0101652592,
-0.0403040536,
-0.060198307,
0.0429415815,
-0.0365913697,
-0.0262628812,
0.019469928,
-0.0236879289,
-0.0515559353,
0.0275449622,
-0.0148983635,
0.0073642507,
-0.0529781953,
-0.0205319282,
0.0067288978,
-0.0049497406,
-0.0079400726,
0.0857339129,
-0.0016497902,
0.0291646179,
-0.0206387844,
0.0084628798,
0.0303602256,
-0.0141701195,
0.0120151127,
0.045734182,
-0.0063736574,
0.0081638983,
-0.0131294159,
0.01370712,
-0.0714504868,
-0.0108657433,
-0.0706778392,
0.0094365878,
-0.0377596319,
0.0266508088,
0.0231626201,
0.0004352776,
-0.0176499449,
-0.0289115515,
-0.081565313,
-0.0077536227,
0.0223860778,
0.0125517994,
0.0065109534,
0.0051588365,
-0.0068812827,
-0.0006307296,
-0.0159391519,
-0.0137453536,
0.0133607183,
-0.0150009077,
0.0410721377,
-0.0132452417,
-0.0419881381,
-0.0718031079,
0.0066994526,
0.0011611298,
-0.0148321474,
0.0158559494,
-0.0115919318,
0.0271022972,
0.0240650494,
-0.0342201628,
0.0010219009,
0.0405719504,
-0.008943609,
-0.0356608257,
0.0388924479,
-0.0185732972,
0.0120790796,
-0.0188632496,
-0.0444601104,
-0.0381505229,
0.0606814623,
0.0306614283,
-0.0162694938,
-0.0429446176,
0.0388419479,
-0.0091670202,
-0.0001486164,
-0.0619211271,
-0.0161314551,
-0.0184086524,
0.0927469134,
0.0011514374,
-0.0087525463,
0.1072097793,
-0.0050638579,
-0.0042173839,
-0.0699862763,
-0.0017541414,
-0.0391335376,
0.0784217492,
-0.0446115993,
0.0077373516,
-0.015206391,
-0.0195967685,
-0.0645943582,
-0.0283710677,
0.0297596604,
-0.0565923043,
0.034509901,
-0.0485220365,
0.0021905801,
-0.0035800962,
-0.0514474511,
-0.0265321042,
0.0130947046,
-0.0392610431,
0.0176826511,
-0.0346975252,
0.0033327048,
0.0325705521,
-0.0062147304,
0.0131116984,
0.0363421254,
-0.0175217949,
0.0005696773,
-0.014292378,
0.0668952093,
0.0648941323,
0.0485243089,
0.0187835395,
-0.004105805,
0.0367188752,
0.0504255705,
0.041451551,
-0.0201244354,
0.046798829,
0.0215126015,
0.0228505563,
-0.0065184571,
-0.0098989401,
0.025927566,
0.0573250353,
-0.0485454313,
-0.0180568118,
0.0832320675,
0.0624083392,
0.0060551111,
0.0107276868,
-0.0491357036,
0.0170293488,
0.0016771543,
0.0286821034,
-0.1047009528,
-0.0595781803,
0.0147971855,
0.0145188645,
0.002581175,
-0.0144682098,
-0.0027555623,
-0.1030264571,
0.0369026773,
-0.0105239451,
-0.0615362749,
-0.0359683894,
-0.0356915258,
-0.0075585451,
0.0015552193,
0.0023859676,
0.0281748995,
0.0126028694,
0.004472252,
0.0048032119,
0.0030805832,
-0.0399872474,
0.0759847835,
-0.0076821535,
0.0197276529,
0.0343493558,
0.0369422175,
0.0040037981,
-0.0784381479,
0.0309837982,
-0.0610452332,
-0.0223713592,
0.0056739124,
0.0036807584,
0.0335474722,
0.0002636087,
-0.0273343492,
0.0791288242,
-0.0507268645,
-0.0180687122,
0.0390798077,
0.1071751267,
-0.015771538,
-0.0298069399,
-0.0323712602,
0.0344608016,
-0.0165201463,
0.0985512137,
0.051341407,
-0.0091294628,
-0.0340510271,
-0.0317817777,
-0.0468105599,
-0.0613253638,
-0.0326173566,
0.0322675072,
0.0235843938,
0.0113821505,
-0.0771366954,
-0.0535108186,
0.0467639342,
0.047267545,
-0.0249981266,
0.0107695451,
0.0134013789,
0.0068381149,
-0.0408115089,
0.0074106329,
-0.0148676243,
0.0200915039,
-0.0232397262,
-0.0014953986,
0.011117883,
-0.0279697292,
-0.0313446559,
0.0058392277,
-0.0838479549,
-0.0513125286,
-0.0178441517,
0.0346055254,
0.0317500643,
0.0204644892,
-0.0265420992,
-0.0341429748,
-0.0021868506,
-0.000782678,
-0.0181781743,
-0.0046517099,
0.0059400843,
0.0001830932,
0.0036371718,
0.046509631,
-0.0304787382,
0.0298439357,
-0.0180335306,
0.0533559173,
-0.0185786989,
0.0209541507,
0.0407123305,
0.0130743207,
-0.0062849452,
0.014848941,
0.0339171439,
-0.020565521,
0.0314901024,
-0.0322434157,
-0.0180558022,
-0.024397254,
0.0141562214,
0.0156578161,
-0.0454049297,
-0.0120692998,
-0.0462242253,
-0.0070471331,
0.0142986188,
-0.0323759802,
0.0108830202,
0.0510661751,
0.0122330273,
0.0050791255,
-0.0363931619,
-0.0098112095,
-0.0192482639,
-0.0081045032,
0.0605281554,
0.0082067419,
0.0728339329,
0.0265370682,
-0.0214103255,
-0.0017684093,
0.0059950207,
-0.0530379042,
-0.0451077931,
0.0322893672,
0.0193901714,
0.0401616693,
0.0290596131,
0.0136523349,
0.0186410025,
-0.0179698858,
0.0185116641,
0.0240800548,
0.0260714106,
-0.034519475,
0.0698543787,
0.0383682363,
-0.0122904535,
-0.0083603812,
0.063214533,
-0.0683406591,
0.0305004958,
-0.0204488114,
0.0136410408,
-0.0204076897,
-0.029371528,
-0.0502310842,
-0.0045137703,
0.0009320978,
0.0224189553,
-0.0802031606,
-0.0900965333,
-0.0631865039,
0.0310319681,
-0.0117370589,
-0.0056663109,
0.0164678581,
0.064322181,
0.0244773235,
-0.0575711578,
-0.031254109,
0.0202625524,
-0.0545568205,
-0.0159275308,
-0.0043361876,
-6.52847375e-33,
-0.0108970851,
-0.0352895372,
0.0473573282,
-0.0381304659,
-0.0093056206,
-0.038056314,
-0.050507538,
-0.0150195006,
-0.0726718679,
0.0072008139,
-0.021817442,
0.0230106264,
-0.0011165095,
0.0292064846,
0.0098949363,
-0.0485505648,
-0.0095151672,
0.0016983723,
-0.0441128463,
0.0303754099,
0.0685940161,
-0.0238422398,
0.0317806937,
-0.0001224119,
0.0314104557,
-0.0279154889,
-0.0287724566,
0.0508027636,
-0.0788389295,
0.0752290711,
-0.0087641655,
0.0319913328,
0.0229268186,
-0.0279385168,
0.0123302676,
0.0283694565,
-0.0921395347,
-0.0685243234,
0.0494916551,
-0.0126808342,
-0.0670136437,
-0.0209284201,
0.0186182838,
0.0032364344,
0.0083116991,
-0.0099335369,
0.0005293346,
-0.0079032565,
0.0242538303,
-0.0284948926,
-0.0286023524,
0.0051066442,
-0.0411221385,
-0.0327843875,
-0.0361168981,
0.0942270234,
-0.0234777313,
-0.0099730119,
-0.060436476,
0.0228706356,
0.0333929844,
-0.0288541745,
0.0567770824,
-0.0241982862,
0.0030671372,
0.0101646408,
0.0063323812,
-0.052272208,
-0.0361378379,
0.0185365211,
-0.0043151979,
0.0498750694,
0.0524984673,
0.0259777643,
0.0424703844,
-0.0003499885,
-0.0590610802,
0.0321702696,
0.01395055,
0.0187736396,
0.0051354244,
-0.0219809413,
-0.0447434597,
-0.0234675873,
-0.0449630544,
0.0102143744,
-0.0333737954,
-0.0363451764,
0.0303930007,
-0.0281190593,
-0.007670878,
-0.0088510346,
0.0197512303,
-0.0374326482,
0.0047472054,
0.0398329683,
-0.0243664682,
0.0077060796,
0.0196639039,
0.0513548441,
-0.027040679,
0.0254478958,
0.0239835698,
-0.0032589203,
0.0136554642,
0.032693658,
0.0283099487,
0.0383458324,
-0.0526741743,
-0.0040074275,
-0.0377891287,
0.0325342156,
-0.0082646636,
0.0039655371,
0.0429004356,
0.0415253751,
-0.0048718969,
0.0306640957,
0.0105469516,
0.0169750713,
-0.0418391712,
0.0223425124,
-0.020462174,
0.039007552,
-0.009760187,
0.0109615587,
-0.0458377004,
-0.0058902605,
-0.0072606686,
-0.0485871769,
-0.0049152058,
0.0569681227,
2.73e-7,
0.0319285467,
0.0138028655,
0.0000667925,
0.0404132865,
0.0084485561,
0.0233665388,
-0.0144542577,
0.0023735315,
0.0149085773,
-0.0322809517,
-0.0156315807,
0.0281800739,
0.0384670049,
0.0623099133,
-0.0944877341,
0.003623443,
-0.0498984233,
-0.0321053304,
-0.047339797,
-0.0028753802,
0.094087936,
0.0787248313,
0.0103919907,
-0.0152942846,
-0.029497955,
0.010783135,
0.0197092295,
0.0043223561,
-0.0179875251,
-0.0145214032,
0.017211711,
-0.0259795394,
0.0393155962,
0.0264798831,
-0.0326331444,
0.0250272676,
0.0008391556,
0.0382026583,
0.0119815301,
-0.054118868,
-0.0236329418,
-0.0385000072,
0.0263248514,
-0.0629580095,
0.1151208654,
-0.0224654134,
-0.0547589734,
0.0038904501,
-0.0235565268,
-0.014860006,
0.0071604159,
-0.0149116246,
0.0015971547,
-0.0025496846,
0.0153409289,
-0.0227455869,
0.0374252312,
-0.0694580898,
-0.0059239501,
0.0277202874,
-0.013060675,
-0.0437779538,
0.0143939061,
-0.0424261019,
0.0106095979,
-0.0652715415,
-0.0136982547,
2.215215201e-34,
0.0367898121,
-0.0169987772,
0.0243900139,
0.0061516585,
0.0393259749,
-0.0219621584,
0.0184699167,
-0.0147520304,
0.0310320631,
-0.0686240643,
-0.0155302472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13381v1 | CoAct: A Global-Local Hierarchy for Autonomous Agent Collaboration | 2024-06-19T09:23:53 | 2024-06-19T09:23:53 | Xinming Hou, Mingming Yang, Wenxiang Jiao, Xing Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Wayne Xin Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing LLMs exhibit remarkable performance on various NLP tasks, but still
struggle with complex real-world tasks, even equipped with advanced strategies
like CoT and ReAct. In this work, we propose the CoAct framework, which
transfers the hierarchical planning and collaboration patterns in human society
to LLM systems. Specifically, our CoAct framework involves two agents: (1) A
global planning agent, to comprehend the problem scope, formulate macro-level
plans and provide detailed sub-task descriptions to local execution agents,
which serves as the initial rendition of a global plan. (2) A local execution
agent, to operate within the multi-tier task execution structure, focusing on
detailed execution and implementation of specific tasks within the global plan.
Experimental results on the WebArena benchmark show that CoAct can re-arrange
the process trajectory when facing failures, and achieves superior performance
over baseline methods on long-horizon web tasks. Code is available at
https://github.com/xmhou2002/CoAct. | [
0.0718623325,
0.0234706029,
-0.0104475478,
0.0078140423,
-0.0434793904,
-0.0025034132,
-0.01025414,
-0.006870673,
0.0145455208,
-0.0379695818,
-0.0205502305,
0.0248042606,
-0.0182650015,
0.0501804911,
0.0091123469,
-0.0688192174,
-0.0089917928,
0.0041452046,
-0.0174828563,
-0.006024335,
0.0110991988,
-0.0131850205,
-0.0336346328,
0.0572415292,
0.0028088964,
-0.0010649329,
-0.0591401234,
0.0157116428,
0.0289986376,
-0.0159202795,
-0.0168946087,
0.0029530209,
0.0244505163,
-0.0066192979,
0.0000019728,
-0.0613303632,
-0.0079575311,
-0.0236138273,
-0.0153100481,
-0.0768882707,
-0.0315126628,
0.0103325127,
-0.0243060477,
0.0250276029,
-0.0391175002,
0.0601607487,
0.0172297359,
0.046809908,
0.0533625633,
0.0504361875,
-0.0022673106,
0.0097682411,
0.0185853671,
0.0205277596,
-0.0037955178,
-0.0782408863,
-0.0028024742,
-0.0214582328,
0.0600092635,
-0.017539287,
0.0281003248,
0.0028287643,
0.0051413965,
-0.027841568,
-0.0222185049,
0.00299797,
-0.0211685821,
-0.0490457527,
-0.0322373398,
0.0618490614,
0.0203504059,
0.0285892133,
0.0478096828,
0.0096287495,
-0.0040849848,
0.0275155678,
-0.0328479521,
0.0526279621,
-0.0180981606,
-0.0130967963,
0.0080552669,
-0.0158280004,
-0.0239419788,
-0.001646122,
-0.0349898115,
0.1086887717,
-0.0218572114,
0.0045216507,
-0.0253356807,
0.0075800004,
0.0297131818,
-0.054232154,
0.0563458279,
0.0795643106,
-0.0992881432,
0.0180698335,
0.0257739872,
0.0236098412,
0.0188281592,
-0.0258332938,
0.05551311,
0.0372488983,
0.0055444185,
0.0563841388,
0.0100833522,
0.0640617609,
-0.000679221,
0.002660939,
-0.0217447281,
-0.0174392555,
-0.1149402484,
0.0297407378,
-0.0129779009,
0.046496544,
-0.0515048653,
-0.0096605793,
0.0036791079,
0.0831394419,
-0.0170732085,
0.07558842,
0.0067980755,
0.0140697639,
-0.0189718381,
-0.0240034591,
-0.0824377686,
-0.0106363464,
-0.0511896871,
-0.0096701588,
-0.0062681194,
-0.0274068993,
0.011076293,
0.0131176133,
-0.0023932199,
0.0124713769,
-0.0260470398,
0.1166633517,
0.0096388664,
0.0043374882,
-0.0314056352,
-0.0559439994,
0.036223948,
-0.0266068652,
-0.0274607595,
-0.0515592359,
0.0397853181,
-0.0005949799,
-0.0350665338,
-0.0022625017,
0.0233061109,
0.0203915704,
0.0106484061,
0.0458913594,
-0.0165153798,
0.025949141,
0.0176097527,
0.0343332551,
-0.0363831036,
0.0416935906,
0.0320972763,
0.0878796652,
0.035235662,
0.0719774216,
0.0319368653,
0.0355779231,
-0.0436296016,
-0.0005481298,
0.05586363,
0.0065813214,
-0.0162094478,
0.0589301847,
0.0063312091,
0.0099190949,
0.0019943798,
0.0110509694,
0.0561070889,
0.0675671846,
-0.0058376794,
-0.0005227688,
0.0365861133,
0.0727002025,
-0.0237572957,
-0.030277703,
-0.0545444787,
0.043895442,
-0.0239668768,
-0.0216595642,
-0.0260562822,
0.0151113132,
-0.0164167434,
-0.0290601309,
-0.0091170017,
-0.0066887736,
-0.0206908844,
-0.0128103904,
0.0124113578,
0.0216962975,
-0.0435921699,
0.0017723324,
-0.0294152908,
-0.0153536135,
0.0003966328,
-0.0521914847,
0.0023862722,
0.0958556086,
0.0599366501,
-0.047036346,
-0.0761962831,
0.0187108014,
-0.0132878236,
0.0156693272,
-0.020335529,
-0.0388865881,
-0.0416360386,
-0.0186204892,
-0.0957023799,
-0.0108346399,
-0.0317637734,
0.0021390244,
0.0259854626,
-0.0217700675,
-0.0462196693,
0.000573585,
0.0050218352,
0.0265859589,
-0.0169099439,
0.0166548695,
-0.0293118097,
0.0222653467,
0.0458239689,
0.0295490138,
-0.0025130101,
0.0041379649,
0.0367407538,
-0.0202373415,
-0.0811986625,
-0.0063381181,
0.0186463837,
-0.0273457076,
0.0377728418,
-0.0515061021,
-0.0043334588,
0.0024987794,
-0.0253732484,
-0.0398037545,
0.0099494243,
-0.0203563794,
0.0064299186,
0.0193195753,
0.0176582281,
0.0227579866,
-0.040935766,
-0.0414813049,
0.0403285362,
-0.007534381,
-0.0595097877,
0.0162050314,
0.0371661,
-0.0138403159,
-0.0280735381,
0.0187785961,
0.0277247988,
0.0348476283,
-0.004220834,
0.0328495689,
0.0423787348,
-0.0535772033,
-0.0465701632,
-0.081949845,
0.0238417778,
-0.0168349799,
0.0178345181,
0.0009307294,
0.011426921,
0.0000864424,
-0.0353243724,
-0.0270946119,
0.0810279027,
-0.0290248487,
0.0182512291,
0.0470677428,
0.0350537561,
-0.0536069758,
-0.0165680293,
0.0244780164,
-0.0062851226,
-0.0288015585,
0.0012858264,
-0.0811337158,
-0.0684136599,
0.0423876271,
-0.0517742895,
0.0098969638,
0.0011713122,
-0.0316384248,
0.0170445964,
-0.0128971515,
0.0128992414,
0.0095854159,
-0.0333149098,
0.0397678018,
0.0437753573,
-0.0253756028,
-0.0619462281,
0.0181157868,
-0.026082864,
-0.0357912779,
-0.0580228046,
0.0081240227,
0.0023135811,
0.0659390986,
-0.020666467,
0.0305320825,
-0.0096404105,
-0.0396816432,
0.0157735366,
-0.008186955,
0.010678486,
-0.0305719953,
-0.0225134157,
0.0525204875,
-0.0272572637,
-0.0221526269,
0.0474616401,
0.0190608203,
-0.0203235652,
-0.0118149007,
-0.0511624999,
-0.0616112426,
0.0979366824,
0.0105142184,
0.0063843839,
-0.0375969782,
-0.0431894325,
-0.0312269572,
0.035368938,
-0.0011350629,
-0.0034055491,
0.0201742183,
-0.07725624,
-0.0037268735,
-0.0361764841,
-0.0552672409,
-0.0276663546,
0.0335782915,
-0.0357236937,
0.0311909989,
-0.0088026784,
-0.0466855876,
-0.0422420055,
-0.0256268438,
0.0356719196,
0.0318726711,
0.0182372667,
-0.0472462289,
-0.0521243438,
-0.0294115748,
0.0019811278,
0.0562022328,
0.0021903433,
0.0252731703,
-0.0071969652,
0.0792868212,
0.0455858484,
-0.078240715,
-0.0034850552,
-0.0092490083,
0.0506197289,
-0.0441223122,
-0.0288914368,
0.019054208,
0.0378289521,
-0.034514524,
0.0157994349,
0.0688490495,
0.0425744504,
-0.0515533984,
0.0017388602,
-0.0454123989,
-0.0010659271,
0.0397344567,
0.0332085714,
-0.0290882811,
-0.0038663938,
0.0142559065,
0.0042307037,
0.007026602,
-0.0704287291,
0.0011097257,
-0.0656432137,
0.0434105024,
-0.0368387699,
0.031930469,
0.0504728034,
-0.0576669239,
0.030951364,
0.0014781656,
-0.0090515427,
0.0140341995,
0.006359363,
-0.0348959416,
0.0005240066,
-0.0643713772,
0.013630501,
0.0004007292,
-0.0354305543,
0.057622306,
0.0558137745,
0.0409687385,
0.0367486142,
0.0016396899,
0.0131202945,
0.0556045435,
0.054527726,
-0.0413101502,
0.0149793411,
-0.0130148474,
0.0198806562,
-0.0059475396,
0.0054257819,
-0.0794298649,
-0.0103532718,
0.0375450253,
0.0886587277,
-0.0453106388,
0.0246971957,
-0.0229593832,
0.0181936249,
0.0008286694,
0.0482199006,
-0.0269198604,
-0.0227885991,
-0.0619311407,
-0.0212734435,
-0.04349529,
-0.0418525524,
-0.01239237,
-0.0003081824,
-0.0297083315,
0.0174032636,
-0.0592297837,
-0.0540613644,
0.0743113458,
0.0382026546,
0.0194428768,
-0.022488283,
0.0336068571,
0.0264606904,
-0.0194817409,
-0.0362571068,
-0.0124602625,
0.0046906425,
-0.0202112924,
-0.0211806465,
0.0336403735,
-0.0263307802,
0.0198769141,
0.003516532,
-0.0452939197,
-0.0343410634,
0.005232248,
0.0374482125,
0.0174762327,
0.0015766425,
-0.0174181014,
-0.0618119314,
0.0357747413,
0.0057130018,
-0.0732957944,
0.0182464272,
0.0046957149,
0.0757944211,
0.0041692778,
0.0398198031,
-0.0718988925,
-0.0056483373,
-0.0107620945,
0.0472600497,
-0.0531133898,
-0.041636955,
0.0093605546,
0.019510705,
-0.0237898268,
-0.0179443005,
-0.0335470214,
-0.0009820813,
0.0194089748,
0.0021839226,
-0.012908075,
-0.0533680171,
0.0445640124,
-0.0255329683,
-0.0362322889,
0.0842851922,
0.0512302257,
-0.011987973,
-0.0221167132,
0.0116799437,
0.0373404771,
0.0096062776,
-0.0102889827,
0.0276142936,
0.0351569615,
-0.0031341033,
-0.00718285,
0.0437613316,
0.0409797952,
0.0153717585,
0.019297367,
0.0176087972,
-0.0140172094,
-0.0279637631,
0.0350465737,
-0.0658289194,
-0.0780571923,
0.0406739861,
0.0217309184,
0.0688214526,
0.0701297969,
0.0290414263,
-0.0570747629,
0.0181426555,
0.0167630054,
0.0016727423,
-0.0125430413,
-0.0253301561,
-0.0066621597,
0.0159699358,
0.0011255866,
-0.0039955042,
0.0353105813,
-0.0146820508,
0.0188005194,
-0.0138911819,
-0.0383955315,
-0.0595243163,
-0.03891287,
0.0107755763,
0.03299243,
0.0004334335,
-0.0266254488,
-0.0226421636,
-0.0028309892,
0.0204344299,
0.0276620779,
-0.0234353524,
-0.0198665913,
0.0529558249,
0.0209663119,
0.0317821018,
-0.0199570265,
-0.0481709614,
-0.0275682006,
0.0201715827,
-0.011859173,
-0.0039671962,
-5.422325852e-33,
-0.0226737484,
-0.0823688954,
0.0871185884,
0.0422822461,
0.009198362,
-0.0099490294,
-0.0365687571,
0.0344324447,
0.0188144054,
0.0250166524,
-0.040358033,
0.0079478221,
0.0330378003,
-0.0294789933,
0.0246765967,
-0.0002548366,
0.0248384196,
-0.009205319,
-0.0005205232,
0.0008803286,
0.0332496539,
0.0304599889,
0.0352238081,
-0.04970311,
0.0151161067,
0.0115522686,
-0.001457245,
0.0600477383,
0.0193812959,
0.0385018736,
-0.003221551,
0.0393288285,
0.028295625,
0.0158678778,
-0.0262258109,
-0.0165038481,
-0.0398597755,
-0.0548460074,
-0.007830889,
-0.0088061467,
-0.0757870674,
0.0045298971,
-0.0033738473,
0.0160418004,
-0.0400768779,
0.0018033392,
0.0319438204,
-0.0002676857,
-0.0110936249,
0.0120392544,
-0.0478912778,
0.0170523562,
0.0022242675,
0.0010202156,
0.0390571319,
-0.0188538581,
0.0346580558,
-0.0376933888,
-0.0430738516,
0.0155017264,
-0.0889049098,
0.0017748454,
0.0709127635,
-0.0099232644,
-0.0343171731,
0.07326217,
0.0327356681,
0.0606591739,
-0.0237213541,
0.0041175159,
-0.0551715195,
0.0922886357,
-0.0011700477,
0.0260550398,
-0.0645603612,
0.0453582332,
-0.0052323509,
0.0795291886,
0.0531980991,
0.0605327599,
-0.0057808622,
0.0564268827,
-0.0297060255,
0.0037849206,
0.0083898613,
0.0501666553,
-0.0133863948,
-0.0156923942,
0.0009076015,
0.0287146196,
0.0329107828,
-0.0002199538,
-0.0035443013,
-0.0268644132,
0.0053937603,
-0.0026429405,
-0.0008161049,
0.0156512894,
-0.0008760632,
-0.000322424,
-0.037953075,
-0.0374230742,
-0.0422663353,
0.0095718075,
0.0269405544,
0.0133513669,
-0.0199345425,
0.0231437758,
-0.0244551823,
0.0032728808,
-0.0602343045,
0.0264583454,
0.0122525105,
-0.0427254029,
0.0285611283,
-0.0356867947,
-0.0226874389,
0.050770279,
-0.0049624196,
-0.0724231377,
0.0008020439,
0.0254404787,
0.0076263272,
-0.0193466749,
-0.0355669744,
-0.0145675354,
-0.042557463,
0.0468993597,
0.0060178,
-0.0268951561,
-0.0272050779,
-0.0008255626,
2.744e-7,
-0.0103991283,
0.0553853735,
0.0331548899,
0.0378445014,
0.0386927165,
0.0166019462,
-0.0068519656,
0.0169166997,
-0.0563318655,
-0.015809672,
0.0323333964,
0.0367176794,
0.0178446565,
0.054098729,
-0.0878990516,
-0.0191444755,
0.0161033776,
-0.0154392431,
-0.0645569116,
0.0127775334,
0.0481586456,
0.0128669348,
0.0176333226,
-0.011722452,
0.0122150788,
-0.0267341938,
-0.0052767699,
-0.0325697139,
-0.0210002847,
0.0452168845,
-0.0321064331,
-0.0122074662,
-0.005184955,
0.0068941191,
-0.0038056949,
-0.0156045146,
-0.0077562914,
0.0629581586,
0.0083444165,
-0.0457100607,
-0.0065155653,
-0.0701509267,
0.0358059928,
-0.0052012424,
0.0094907675,
0.0073209452,
-0.0237831492,
0.0557487309,
0.024955105,
-0.0482390858,
-0.0442992747,
0.0070777484,
0.0266716816,
-0.004459349,
-0.0157604907,
-0.0121032437,
-0.0277389809,
-0.0867910385,
0.0375453234,
-0.0098798331,
-0.0442404151,
-0.0553906448,
-0.0197116286,
0.0231074765,
-0.0121756392,
-0.0133519731,
-0.0237259269,
2.51069017e-34,
-0.031731911,
0.0051062456,
-0.0159815699,
0.0784805641,
0.0439976044,
0.0290501285,
-0.0701728016,
0.0240292791,
0.0422536992,
-0.0300028194,
-0.042560678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13375v1 | ALiiCE: Evaluating Positional Fine-grained Citation Generation | 2024-06-19T09:16:14 | 2024-06-19T09:16:14 | Yilong Xu, Jinhua Gao, Xiaoming Yu, Baolong Bi, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can enhance the credibility and verifiability by
generating text with citations. However, existing tasks and evaluation methods
are predominantly limited to sentence-level statement, neglecting the
significance of positional fine-grained citations that can appear anywhere
within sentences. To facilitate further exploration of the fine-grained
citation generation, we propose ALiiCE, the first automatic evaluation
framework for this task. Our framework first parses the sentence claim into
atomic claims via dependency analysis and then calculates citation quality at
the atomic claim level. ALiiCE introduces three novel metrics for positional
fined-grained citation quality assessment, including positional fine-grained
citation recall and precision, and coefficient of variation of citation
positions. We evaluate the positional fine-grained citation generation
performance of several LLMs on two long-form QA datasets. Our experiments and
analyses demonstrate the effectiveness and reasonableness of ALiiCE. The
results also indicate that existing LLMs still struggle to provide positional
fine-grained citations. | [
0.0622511357,
0.0001648689,
-0.0009976253,
0.0173390172,
-0.0430723503,
-0.0110360235,
0.01984437,
-0.0244601723,
0.0295470543,
-0.0931987613,
0.0214302931,
0.0108593544,
0.0122460155,
-0.0212004203,
0.0469797105,
-0.0055025239,
0.0123438295,
0.0182850286,
0.0779595822,
-0.0007383039,
0.0130610373,
0.0065052919,
0.0084060784,
0.0471412167,
0.0204703305,
-0.0430287682,
0.0304584615,
-0.0107364673,
0.0616079532,
-0.0428843908,
0.0236431658,
0.0396056771,
-0.0413119532,
0.035591308,
0.0000017699,
-0.0444150493,
0.0040240334,
0.0463857502,
0.0244017113,
0.0787624642,
0.0156361368,
0.0039782017,
-0.0047924398,
0.0140153756,
-0.0216118526,
0.0154201025,
0.0114476737,
0.0440310799,
0.0564655028,
0.0210924223,
-0.0074512628,
-0.0378124714,
0.0505897664,
-0.0199655127,
-0.0107041774,
-0.0169733781,
0.0269689262,
0.0643896759,
-0.0014629738,
0.0712564141,
0.0533868074,
0.0159833413,
-0.0139624905,
-0.0215974804,
0.0324949138,
-0.0059050205,
-0.0252929851,
0.0229132939,
0.0352275968,
0.040900249,
0.0097568696,
-0.0440901145,
0.0261504743,
-0.0279238466,
0.0067698914,
0.0381308943,
-0.0282921605,
0.0560390987,
0.0048181852,
-0.0224292055,
0.0405571871,
0.0141948322,
0.0203317609,
0.0125339003,
-0.003357735,
0.0490124486,
0.0135334078,
-0.0517392308,
-0.0071139117,
-0.0219785366,
-0.0203489065,
-0.058411859,
-0.0153107354,
0.0130346036,
0.0168564171,
-0.0159175713,
-0.0073399497,
0.0047301692,
0.0868756771,
-0.0253606942,
0.0109081231,
-0.0296310242,
-0.0061076363,
0.0246303938,
-0.037585739,
0.0081889415,
-0.0238342509,
-0.0702442005,
0.0284575801,
-0.0026224132,
-0.0528936125,
0.0041221827,
0.0011498139,
0.0237530395,
-0.0582455285,
-0.0126882773,
-0.0693739355,
0.0030778504,
-0.0635511652,
0.0385011025,
0.0029995949,
0.0064391769,
0.0137164034,
0.0071828277,
-0.0056919418,
0.002356834,
-0.0289729368,
0.0596925206,
-0.0015780297,
-0.0132992212,
0.0086825974,
0.0379470848,
0.0332095996,
-0.033146672,
-0.0049815732,
0.0093415361,
0.0361455195,
-0.017319249,
-0.0461456105,
-0.0546495803,
-0.0251449309,
-0.0566255115,
-0.014058168,
-0.0936113745,
0.0047447686,
0.0378610864,
0.0089093298,
-0.0378081463,
0.0169262569,
0.0448432378,
-0.0393930599,
-0.0081095733,
-0.0126342084,
0.0055782627,
-0.0001370338,
-0.0182568487,
0.0618545003,
0.0157490764,
0.0511271693,
0.0244064052,
0.0325471945,
0.0263516512,
-0.0038130062,
0.0006058403,
0.0175378565,
0.0543683246,
0.0181141812,
-0.0138782598,
-0.0288827661,
0.0007492056,
-0.0142154321,
0.0584657378,
-0.0180298928,
0.0405981913,
0.0776230022,
-0.0008832684,
-0.0041196309,
-0.0094823893,
0.0699340329,
0.0087660234,
0.0290080886,
-0.0106209284,
-0.0058653844,
-0.0034165669,
-0.0313691646,
0.0159737859,
0.0491841249,
0.0233725999,
0.019175034,
-0.0137651069,
-0.0061593512,
-0.0066639949,
-0.0233824123,
-0.0315207168,
0.004561712,
0.0001705396,
-0.0572533868,
0.0575046949,
0.0151103633,
-0.0552963316,
0.004629456,
0.0244695041,
0.0413169898,
0.0040929751,
0.0356990546,
0.0070124217,
0.0193822328,
-0.0104593262,
-0.0161179062,
0.0291171838,
-0.0088045401,
-0.0121077234,
-0.0277075674,
-0.0171124972,
-0.0182938091,
-0.0230513308,
0.022008365,
-0.0296430923,
0.0383328609,
0.001664941,
0.0551016852,
-0.0431503654,
-0.0581347272,
0.0193108562,
0.0067661353,
0.0056480458,
0.0077805133,
-0.0095806755,
0.0408378318,
0.0279024392,
-0.0441389047,
0.0357392542,
0.0468117148,
-0.0311929137,
0.0068299901,
0.0035659489,
0.0438392684,
0.0300790872,
0.0366484746,
-0.0316897146,
0.023130076,
-0.014086985,
-0.0275991838,
-0.0381193087,
-0.0044861296,
-0.014353605,
-0.0389458351,
-0.0193428006,
0.0083785364,
-0.0085708573,
0.0157047547,
-0.0471707769,
0.0922714844,
0.0216779057,
0.0594081953,
0.0150593333,
0.0131855002,
0.0329546332,
-0.0295075569,
-0.0432385728,
-0.0353888907,
-0.0169488173,
0.0067458344,
0.0679173172,
-0.0272224657,
-0.0322591662,
-0.0291703697,
-0.0634742305,
0.0295812245,
0.01053249,
0.0184115097,
0.011253465,
-0.0192933604,
0.0153419208,
0.0333113596,
-0.0116559053,
-0.0398397632,
-0.0025425663,
0.0085031949,
0.0383285694,
0.0064519495,
0.023178041,
-0.0445079468,
0.0129730329,
-0.0143338274,
0.0491830967,
0.0661938637,
0.0274202228,
-0.0801669285,
0.0213196799,
-0.0279800463,
-0.0214681998,
0.0069606672,
-0.0138690639,
-0.0045039272,
0.0417919345,
0.0348833613,
0.0395055637,
0.0194730945,
-0.0225374531,
0.020888852,
0.0191105064,
-0.032934349,
-0.0310543198,
-0.0071757403,
0.0160569455,
-0.0125450408,
-0.0571304522,
0.0281899311,
0.0192877036,
0.0157435127,
-0.0160293113,
-0.0187094212,
0.0272901282,
-0.0123011461,
0.0156293437,
0.0156825669,
-0.0163905565,
-0.0126846451,
0.0482102372,
0.001240343,
-0.0194426943,
0.0041368059,
-0.0709396973,
0.0288101211,
-0.0038995692,
0.0154481754,
-0.0375005938,
0.0426647961,
0.0319826156,
-0.0074178749,
0.0320114382,
0.033213187,
-0.0379302651,
-0.0038108407,
0.0261857081,
-0.0169608332,
0.0155544877,
-0.0136278905,
0.0326260738,
-0.019314751,
0.0016377546,
-0.008638598,
-0.0127701871,
-0.0361135565,
0.0313497074,
0.0302814394,
-0.0249283332,
-0.0160116199,
-0.0071828519,
0.0555206574,
0.0066527333,
-0.0459395796,
-0.0019950562,
-0.0443586409,
0.0541854985,
0.0537712537,
-0.025302792,
0.0507528,
-0.0025064128,
-0.0414821133,
0.0317128301,
-0.0182904173,
0.0476142801,
-0.0612772666,
-0.088929005,
-0.016943749,
-0.0679929852,
-0.024073502,
0.0087988824,
0.0532321483,
-0.0274509285,
0.0115281837,
0.0981801525,
0.0396398082,
0.0008587135,
0.0002091771,
0.0050341734,
0.0414392501,
0.0156415664,
0.0231547467,
-0.1106766909,
-0.001857247,
-0.015043946,
-0.0015349862,
-0.0490044281,
-0.0352855213,
0.0214690007,
-0.1397493184,
0.0658837408,
0.001116082,
0.0603738874,
-0.0254432093,
-0.0467115827,
0.0170307625,
0.0044531291,
-0.0364868008,
0.0280516427,
-0.0290357824,
0.004758873,
0.0096955067,
-0.0264886916,
-0.0532018207,
0.0250884295,
-0.0570428707,
0.0285532083,
0.0110377762,
0.0588898808,
-0.0224659797,
-0.0326738581,
0.0012691357,
-0.0885136127,
-0.043133866,
0.0353628136,
0.0057155592,
0.0171346795,
0.0172490589,
0.0074470164,
0.0231376607,
0.0112791508,
-0.0262322966,
0.050349392,
0.070132181,
0.0025425837,
0.0198784899,
-0.0217447355,
0.0235486459,
0.0043696687,
0.0496698208,
0.0390233286,
-0.0139591591,
-0.0414072759,
-0.0053992025,
0.0110120168,
-0.0608121976,
-0.0210803263,
0.0095749758,
-0.0217110328,
0.0128405411,
-0.1155155897,
-0.029696418,
-0.0137037346,
-0.0128653552,
0.0355611145,
0.0480738357,
0.0446254984,
-0.0152405193,
-0.0452518538,
0.0116482563,
-0.0330353007,
0.0420450605,
-0.0101203518,
0.0234880988,
0.0323180892,
-0.0015335024,
-0.0296602696,
0.0202340931,
0.010182051,
-0.0378959142,
-0.0209478568,
0.0259335116,
0.0172829758,
0.0057600988,
-0.0370451622,
-0.0505611859,
0.03165875,
0.0715790763,
-0.023151882,
0.0163570903,
0.0061577274,
-0.0488092415,
-0.0186507851,
-0.0130766211,
-0.056267567,
0.0224451311,
-0.0456821546,
0.0325148329,
0.0021379122,
-0.0524211824,
0.0064757266,
0.0238290094,
0.029931603,
-0.0118414387,
0.035443496,
0.0050423024,
-0.0049880119,
-0.040940389,
-0.0409877896,
-0.0219031945,
0.0294036437,
-0.0010314438,
0.0171937961,
-0.0079426477,
0.0213651042,
-0.0324373022,
0.0412273593,
-0.0170538686,
0.0208398029,
-0.0596177876,
0.0576523617,
-0.0110992258,
-0.0400959402,
-0.0425039008,
-0.0475708619,
-0.0367312804,
0.0407136381,
0.0009718186,
0.0162517447,
0.0083425883,
0.0008977323,
-0.0098769693,
0.0151011078,
-0.0617194772,
0.0262583047,
-0.0247246884,
-0.054959517,
0.0297155138,
-0.0114128385,
0.0845034942,
-0.0267758761,
-0.0269949399,
-0.0126627302,
0.0572432429,
-0.0009921407,
0.000408649,
-0.0057154479,
-0.000480918,
-0.0306305047,
0.0522282235,
0.058117561,
0.0566288009,
0.0180710871,
-0.0199941974,
-0.0286569353,
-0.029503746,
-0.0723222941,
-0.0701200441,
0.0119641135,
-0.0029029974,
-0.0346575752,
-0.0766271576,
-0.0285210069,
0.0253267717,
0.0293421801,
0.0225980859,
-0.0245583877,
-0.0145100905,
0.0364997648,
-0.0004060397,
-0.0076682889,
-0.0916972011,
0.0210225023,
-0.0192764271,
-0.0350278653,
-0.0288059581,
-6.047452278e-33,
-0.0058531715,
-0.0775728747,
-0.0147532234,
0.0117676156,
-0.0274128746,
0.0079377359,
-0.0511344783,
-0.0277426951,
-0.0136985993,
0.0467686988,
0.0023170034,
-0.0206797738,
0.0019026032,
0.0224569682,
0.0243037194,
0.0631154776,
0.0321743712,
0.0387673192,
-0.0248784516,
0.0383382887,
0.0290409885,
-0.0251900088,
0.0044569494,
-0.0869605318,
0.0806171447,
-0.0481358618,
-0.0440989435,
-0.0468451157,
-0.0054705283,
0.0631894693,
-0.004933306,
-0.0027969701,
0.0154191256,
-0.0455173701,
0.0406125337,
-0.0010964688,
-0.0581069253,
0.0323046707,
0.044680953,
-0.0727704987,
-0.0292151477,
-0.046822615,
0.0392316841,
-0.0106293103,
-0.0171454344,
0.0010711459,
0.07742998,
-0.0530828573,
-0.0282918029,
-0.1092156991,
-0.0776514187,
0.048114147,
0.0028122857,
0.0331771411,
-0.0607233681,
0.0411907732,
-0.0101718213,
0.1115591824,
-0.0338173471,
0.0057305773,
-0.0077104662,
0.0112783359,
-0.0221576821,
-0.0266202521,
-0.0145326909,
0.0448385626,
-0.0371130779,
-0.0159859527,
0.0246513579,
-0.0149499197,
-0.0303321872,
0.0431100801,
0.0587197952,
0.1056055725,
-0.0066967718,
0.0132649699,
-0.0970907509,
0.0262363311,
-0.0056585101,
0.0276784711,
0.037479315,
-0.0559566319,
0.0104306908,
0.0091703236,
-0.0516579375,
-0.0216492247,
-0.0196860116,
-0.0011520031,
-0.0185800195,
0.0044908472,
-0.0534926653,
0.0418145284,
0.0255872179,
-0.0406432711,
-0.0204813797,
0.0459551886,
-0.0537745617,
0.0533404276,
0.0094705503,
0.0047625382,
-0.0744810998,
-0.0099599259,
-0.0176508203,
0.0064616757,
0.0364878848,
0.014041625,
0.0633096695,
-0.0235026907,
-0.0540041439,
0.0147545021,
-0.0057338583,
0.0173544772,
-0.0490693003,
-0.02965682,
-0.0007185863,
0.0270603746,
0.0167401358,
0.0163621251,
0.0324263386,
0.0270346589,
0.0001879125,
0.0020263679,
0.0110586509,
0.0333451852,
-0.0159334019,
-0.0045682439,
-0.0134831043,
0.0746206418,
-0.0156438183,
-0.0311458036,
0.0159439258,
-0.017441418,
2.559e-7,
0.036541339,
0.0511047021,
-0.0368984751,
-0.0250296649,
0.0073765256,
0.0389321856,
0.0167487711,
0.0266817547,
0.0142212836,
0.0186540429,
-0.0323163271,
-0.049392771,
0.0050230599,
0.0065476256,
-0.0747337341,
0.0124560352,
-0.0797610506,
-0.0428958349,
-0.0227532871,
-0.0046661426,
-0.0090264985,
0.0293466207,
0.008294235,
0.0110307708,
-0.0298142619,
-0.0504269488,
0.0967595801,
0.0145721482,
-0.0447411798,
0.0542101786,
0.038280569,
0.0074600605,
0.0147679364,
-0.0048050839,
-0.0210830159,
0.033655867,
-0.0194555968,
0.0405706428,
0.0283622183,
0.021243833,
0.00483318,
-0.0464810617,
0.031829875,
-0.0837458596,
0.0414098091,
-0.0475223772,
-0.0198603198,
-0.0719450712,
-0.0931184515,
0.0275859423,
-0.014893122,
0.0096543916,
-0.0036016591,
-0.0001418598,
-0.0504998751,
0.0146965468,
-0.0384467393,
-0.0286256559,
-0.0251319669,
0.0539159067,
0.0070365728,
-0.0618643165,
0.0266161095,
-0.0773832574,
0.0076653329,
-0.080194883,
0.0457119308,
2.21015231e-34,
0.0549466573,
-0.0246299412,
0.0048649968,
-0.0219007656,
0.0629391745,
0.0222238917,
-0.0595850609,
0.0510237925,
0.0016224403,
-0.0260369778,
0.0249947533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13363v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13363v1 | Evaluating Structural Generalization in Neural Machine Translation | 2024-06-19T09:09:11 | 2024-06-19T09:09:11 | Ryoma Kumon, Daiki Matsuoka, Hitomi Yanaka | cs.CL | cs.CL | Compositional generalization refers to the ability to generalize to novel
combinations of previously observed words and syntactic structures. Since it is
regarded as a desired property of neural models, recent work has assessed
compositional generalization in machine translation as well as semantic
parsing. However, previous evaluations with machine translation have focused
mostly on lexical generalization (i.e., generalization to unseen combinations
of known words). Thus, it remains unclear to what extent models can translate
sentences that require structural generalization (i.e., generalization to
different sorts of syntactic structures). To address this question, we
construct SGET, a machine translation dataset covering various types of
compositional generalization with control of words and sentence structures. We
evaluate neural machine translation models on SGET and show that they struggle
more in structural generalization than in lexical generalization. We also find
different performance trends in semantic parsing and machine translation, which
indicates the importance of evaluations across various tasks. | [
0.0396870561,
0.0611432269,
-0.0073315874,
0.021255048,
0.0004777622,
0.0434086882,
-0.0014221385,
-0.0154780541,
-0.0411445461,
0.0207238793,
-0.009931243,
-0.0652466416,
0.0090979002,
0.02266098,
0.0509436652,
-0.0563786663,
0.0268401299,
0.0092238849,
-0.0237837899,
0.0365188532,
0.003615529,
0.0182982013,
0.0411205478,
0.0350192972,
-0.0265692268,
-0.0093302457,
0.0052367868,
0.0372078866,
0.026664786,
0.0101212803,
0.0040001567,
0.0093267662,
0.0341103189,
0.0366500653,
0.0000017398,
-0.0284351073,
-0.0005587494,
-0.0078211967,
0.0403041355,
-0.0055350121,
0.052425459,
-0.0909121335,
0.0084663304,
0.0021944821,
-0.0463271812,
-0.0429706909,
0.0589283593,
0.0275743231,
0.0650654733,
0.0943793282,
-0.0172379408,
-0.0759394541,
-0.0001105705,
-0.0669818446,
0.0213477705,
-0.0251970459,
-0.0186896548,
0.0034470255,
-0.061953783,
0.0065579093,
-0.0090948623,
0.0427114554,
0.050772205,
-0.0025753763,
0.0039580939,
0.0129986061,
-0.0415457673,
-0.0376064703,
-0.0030493243,
0.0914837793,
-0.0209518112,
-0.0149802417,
-0.0103604039,
0.0000288476,
0.0229492225,
-0.0343665145,
-0.0381947085,
0.026735682,
-0.0155876484,
0.0233004708,
0.0258733705,
0.0092106191,
0.0412167124,
-0.0134589151,
-0.0416344516,
0.0404468067,
0.022654362,
-0.0269895289,
-0.0079621868,
0.0163022317,
-0.0210038442,
-0.0137840072,
0.0186863355,
-0.0148089342,
-0.0349059217,
0.0144390306,
-0.0359170437,
-0.0574625283,
-0.0188455265,
-0.061788559,
0.069779709,
0.067033805,
0.0120932693,
0.0449614748,
-0.0440930091,
0.0876783878,
-0.077588886,
0.0386528261,
-0.1005759761,
-0.0071764817,
-0.0731691942,
0.0072142556,
-0.0433833152,
0.0325972028,
-0.0295884572,
-0.0391130634,
-0.0236570928,
0.0186837576,
0.011211657,
0.0344161168,
0.035495095,
-0.0004896079,
-0.0779003426,
-0.0187781677,
0.0092973048,
-0.0072802845,
-0.0472615622,
-0.0081933346,
0.0213093702,
-0.0122234495,
-0.0352878496,
0.0117543824,
-0.0072034071,
-0.0289112385,
-0.0109577728,
0.0744344518,
-0.020741459,
0.0006583104,
-0.0180944651,
-0.0191789251,
-0.0070985565,
-0.0522121266,
0.030140141,
-0.0335265733,
0.0952254906,
-0.0094952593,
0.0010259206,
-0.0199722517,
-0.0063446425,
0.0133577278,
-0.0226066355,
0.0631600842,
0.030216096,
-0.0155008966,
-0.0200859364,
0.0047801295,
-0.0162414573,
0.0569282658,
0.0154249202,
0.0126755452,
-0.0116747785,
0.0123227984,
-0.0360099263,
0.0211418867,
0.0045338301,
0.0048290021,
-0.0384852327,
0.0145927155,
0.0073929401,
0.0446194969,
0.0093840677,
0.0553918146,
-0.057082925,
-0.0118490681,
0.0404068455,
0.0320528038,
0.0086151855,
0.0589770675,
0.1048127115,
-0.0218531191,
-0.0106935669,
0.0367339626,
-0.0470170826,
0.004415283,
0.0017477978,
0.0031003442,
-0.0255490821,
0.0067885811,
-0.0265782848,
-0.0313002132,
-0.0160275083,
-0.017224092,
0.0543261506,
-0.0515935495,
0.0316655934,
0.073429957,
-0.0326446258,
0.0379104353,
0.0020417634,
-0.0711081102,
0.0146058016,
0.0161006004,
-0.0030489564,
0.0481856056,
0.0354631841,
-0.0067658825,
-0.0348002054,
-0.0209065769,
0.0032221382,
0.0357639901,
0.0489859022,
0.0047782068,
0.0429679863,
-0.0504394919,
0.003216041,
-0.0515059903,
0.0271012373,
0.0400621593,
0.0122450767,
-0.0134792142,
0.0493927225,
-0.0399476103,
-0.04226337,
0.0536094867,
0.0107735051,
-0.0254434142,
0.0287352446,
0.006332221,
0.0407154895,
0.0025989937,
-0.0050598215,
0.0240769722,
0.0116890296,
-0.0445547029,
-0.0614142194,
0.0171409901,
-0.0670596063,
-0.0575036108,
-0.0003291822,
-0.0824553072,
-0.0071339626,
0.0083221346,
-0.0715975761,
-0.0499249585,
0.0382430516,
-0.0290379114,
0.0118981926,
-0.0154407769,
0.0133293262,
0.0077800527,
-0.0092890542,
-0.000337874,
0.0577019192,
-0.001156559,
-0.0174148381,
0.0075587677,
-0.0255455319,
0.0121619971,
-0.0405368768,
-0.0359147266,
0.0389773175,
0.0193983782,
-0.0096358666,
0.0226117503,
0.0271460749,
-0.0287371911,
-0.0178055391,
-0.0489018001,
0.0149709554,
-0.0173212588,
0.0378878154,
0.0803778544,
0.0349309109,
0.040052481,
-0.009457428,
-0.0431094766,
0.0225220155,
-0.0035839851,
0.0096721919,
0.0326184519,
-0.0114339655,
0.003645251,
-0.0352072082,
-0.0279983412,
-0.0252611078,
0.0770464763,
-0.0038787476,
-0.0247102361,
-0.0514972322,
0.0142846555,
-0.0415782668,
-0.0056881551,
-0.0123916483,
-0.0776858032,
0.0078912145,
-0.0534464009,
-0.0047046733,
0.074533388,
-0.0422408618,
-0.0117275165,
0.0224619713,
0.009201319,
-0.0272990577,
0.0125222122,
-0.0370656438,
0.0108801508,
-0.0317211375,
-0.0157446694,
-0.004728423,
0.0890852809,
0.0259103011,
0.0008248835,
-0.0541349016,
0.0063333283,
-0.0232250094,
-0.0206813775,
-0.0215937328,
-0.0050645261,
0.0059796162,
0.0102476524,
-0.0493230745,
-0.0207917038,
0.0684919432,
0.0188579261,
-0.0145777175,
-0.0274971612,
-0.0031643806,
-0.0454788804,
0.0853320658,
0.016600458,
0.017948173,
-0.0064515891,
-0.0352682285,
-0.0420480892,
-0.0073385588,
0.002183411,
0.0076445499,
0.0353268459,
-0.0478284024,
-0.0177925453,
-0.0095662093,
-0.0150456727,
-0.0014906715,
0.0116193993,
-0.0013151794,
-0.0006363002,
0.0315868072,
-0.0191772208,
-0.0186485741,
-0.0274365339,
-0.0112941517,
0.0697165653,
-0.0045141936,
0.0070645409,
-0.0273363646,
0.014579948,
-0.0387857631,
-0.0131366197,
-0.0080942409,
-0.0311012082,
0.0177003555,
0.0280891992,
-0.0156154083,
-0.0068628914,
-0.0704028681,
0.0110352533,
0.0053013358,
0.0109735858,
-0.0305181611,
-0.0260770693,
0.0471055023,
-0.073543027,
-0.0327758417,
0.0768213719,
0.0370822437,
-0.0140747102,
-0.0037238372,
0.0229749028,
0.0256297439,
0.0379247293,
0.0262373555,
-0.0783743113,
-0.0095942542,
0.0164171532,
-0.0339905098,
0.0208258145,
-0.0115161408,
-0.0251523424,
-0.0603018068,
-0.0041540479,
0.039828591,
-0.079651989,
-0.0363815874,
0.0262712464,
-0.0327835456,
-0.0502824001,
0.0174758919,
-0.010257924,
0.0130741894,
-0.0136312079,
-0.0225949921,
0.0035910464,
-0.0295328125,
-0.0061996388,
-0.0484755039,
-0.004971846,
0.1046779603,
0.0415926129,
0.0075736111,
-0.0190863684,
0.075759232,
0.0095729679,
0.0153979771,
0.0084978184,
0.0309553836,
0.0216549803,
-0.0227291454,
0.0341914259,
0.0175679643,
-0.0641085804,
0.0334047042,
0.0005526062,
0.0383007862,
0.0137613183,
-0.0289477874,
-0.0030616317,
0.0019647535,
-0.0309665203,
0.0430407673,
0.0632070601,
-0.0313711278,
-0.0089209983,
-0.0592593178,
-0.0251761358,
-0.0894871876,
0.0117193302,
0.0414726287,
0.0259038135,
0.0180995148,
-0.0988877416,
-0.0578596629,
0.00913502,
0.0106841531,
0.0076638181,
-0.0166362282,
0.0172884949,
-0.0482562445,
-0.0124278907,
0.0361428298,
-0.0136568025,
-0.0001707812,
-0.0082494626,
0.009637408,
-0.0108365593,
-0.0191408452,
-0.0247334335,
-0.0241730791,
-0.1123125926,
-0.0705166161,
-0.0229503214,
0.076232262,
0.0252213813,
0.0263500065,
-0.0513299853,
-0.0360672586,
0.0080121122,
-0.0063029295,
-0.001686633,
-0.0058682393,
0.0250799935,
0.0040762601,
0.0324827358,
0.0587946288,
-0.0163763613,
0.0057104882,
0.0317374319,
0.0357302204,
0.0310994703,
0.0305720121,
0.0461968184,
-0.0066037984,
-0.0033256563,
0.0177051108,
0.0428133681,
-0.0177843478,
0.0273624677,
-0.0204556212,
-0.0241262596,
-0.0839095116,
0.00131467,
0.0895523727,
0.0109189954,
-0.0093745161,
-0.0043229372,
-0.0192104448,
0.0336581841,
-0.0363310017,
-0.0402112827,
0.0208725818,
-0.0200025067,
0.0175255407,
0.0307005122,
-0.0222295057,
0.0460800789,
-0.0574830621,
-0.0180885233,
-0.0318146348,
0.0046504182,
0.0176382028,
0.0350984894,
-0.023326043,
0.0100538023,
-0.0639108494,
-0.0178298485,
-0.0145238629,
-0.0072352937,
0.0411712602,
-0.0065818029,
0.0705833733,
0.0086625023,
-0.0126559762,
0.0120791774,
0.0539550707,
-0.0034732951,
-0.0258034766,
0.0116504971,
-0.0065114484,
0.0187586769,
-0.0205194801,
0.0951243863,
-0.0108050508,
0.0300847441,
-0.0113506466,
0.0084194764,
-0.0241051987,
0.0166095197,
0.00969382,
-0.0007561332,
-0.0172254685,
-0.0052867867,
0.0130600818,
-0.0405459553,
-0.0040148119,
0.0216310024,
0.0214064997,
0.0113187395,
0.0256343279,
0.0877125189,
-0.0223283414,
-0.007364451,
-0.0023934005,
-0.0580272488,
0.0271384548,
-0.0177063979,
-0.071415931,
-6.040835714e-33,
-0.0249483101,
0.0107315555,
-0.0098838778,
-0.0168462843,
-0.020601375,
-0.0019988404,
-0.0303626228,
-0.0198745392,
-0.0174415596,
0.0236238353,
0.0115524093,
0.0435644276,
0.000908015,
0.028745465,
0.0434709936,
-0.0014704621,
0.0528819822,
0.0019278028,
-0.0078243893,
-0.0013041307,
0.0164110325,
0.0307723302,
0.1042565331,
-0.0376144424,
0.0477094054,
0.0130260689,
-0.0281201843,
0.0334594399,
-0.0277597178,
0.0351457782,
0.0147208655,
-0.0089506526,
0.039159812,
0.0013949584,
-0.0433280095,
0.0078514246,
-0.0817428753,
-0.0183983427,
0.0423180275,
0.00686845,
-0.0646383166,
-0.0549139157,
0.0490406901,
-0.0570825003,
0.0227178391,
-0.0340933874,
0.0078074811,
-0.0160826035,
-0.0196985789,
-0.0411790051,
-0.0619570203,
-0.0080215558,
0.0002740525,
0.0271412972,
-0.0295370352,
0.0486055501,
-0.0346787572,
0.0281893369,
-0.054383602,
-0.0032334141,
-0.0433892868,
0.0142842457,
0.0134000145,
0.0091954721,
0.0023449811,
0.0043992549,
0.0203292407,
-0.0003347169,
-0.0502878763,
0.0227891356,
-0.0087577114,
0.0148065239,
0.0433822386,
0.0338655412,
0.0445438512,
0.010147946,
-0.0534673221,
-0.0214521457,
-0.0271795169,
0.0343464836,
0.018665852,
0.0217834823,
0.0106312279,
0.0032389339,
-0.0712898597,
-0.054301668,
-0.0380513966,
-0.0282487348,
0.0221766215,
0.0394714251,
-0.0053656669,
-0.0233433694,
0.0288825277,
-0.0342393927,
0.0484888889,
0.0219660662,
-0.0331053138,
-0.0038690004,
0.0114329671,
0.0307340063,
-0.0350756459,
-0.0655964762,
0.0268001575,
0.0336212441,
0.02756433,
-0.0302373357,
0.0838938206,
0.0197669491,
-0.022523053,
0.0014107288,
-0.0639123991,
-0.0245677363,
-0.0248175729,
0.0204287041,
0.0545253903,
0.0233791713,
-0.0238285698,
0.0743901134,
0.0099694338,
0.0297789611,
-0.0163829699,
0.0053226277,
0.0438781381,
0.0583334304,
-0.0354474038,
0.0036788736,
-0.0170893371,
-0.0180952307,
0.0882890895,
-0.0306752138,
-0.0229366794,
0.0304082893,
2.498e-7,
0.0547153763,
0.0284353718,
0.0154660167,
0.0527494326,
0.0208677799,
0.0100374762,
-0.0298551228,
0.0495067611,
-0.0252802391,
0.0016743082,
0.021735996,
0.0009122689,
0.0700336471,
0.0155111421,
-0.0905785859,
-0.0194963068,
-0.0837889835,
0.0027665393,
-0.0349685997,
-0.0037795778,
0.0467199348,
0.1039670929,
0.0028915261,
0.0172922481,
0.0043547279,
-0.0734173954,
0.0873167068,
-0.0091205239,
-0.02240365,
-0.0102365017,
0.0027952772,
0.0721033514,
-0.0268481709,
-0.014800027,
-0.0274234731,
0.0283557754,
0.0571035929,
0.0626748279,
0.0168599524,
0.0370875373,
0.0237091016,
-0.0387111716,
-0.0012820152,
-0.0487735346,
0.0430480577,
-0.0996442735,
0.004828128,
0.0265526492,
0.0012190735,
0.0289940629,
0.048300378,
-0.0369671769,
0.0072971182,
0.01415837,
0.0593660101,
-0.0012259117,
-0.0165190101,
-0.0471850969,
-0.0546638109,
0.0173106194,
-0.0161869153,
0.0126353595,
-0.0232143719,
-0.0031821972,
0.0106907766,
-0.0266927984,
-0.0258670971,
2.10149324e-34,
0.0374448746,
-0.0152307283,
0.0270072278,
-0.0205347314,
0.0640130192,
-0.0452517644,
-0.0533620939,
-0.0173329785,
-0.0060062157,
-0.048864536,
-0.0333962962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13362v1 | VisualRWKV: Exploring Recurrent Neural Networks for Visual Language Models | 2024-06-19T09:07:31 | 2024-06-19T09:07:31 | Haowen Hou, Peigen Zeng, Fei Ma, Fei Richard Yu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Visual Language Models (VLMs) have rapidly progressed with the recent success
of large language models. However, there have been few attempts to incorporate
efficient linear Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) architectures into VLMs. In
this study, we introduce VisualRWKV, the first application of a linear RNN
model to multimodal learning tasks, leveraging the pre-trained RWKV language
model. We propose a data-dependent recurrence and sandwich prompts to enhance
our modeling capabilities, along with a 2D image scanning mechanism to enrich
the processing of visual sequences. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
VisualRWKV achieves competitive performance compared to Transformer-based
models like LLaVA-1.5 on various benchmarks. To facilitate further research and
analysis, we have made the checkpoints and the associated code publicly
accessible at the following GitHub repository:
\href{https://github.com/howard-hou/VisualRWKV}{https://github.com/howard-hou/VisualRWKV}. | [
0.0277406499,
0.042777665,
-0.0092002321,
0.0463274755,
-0.0418613851,
-0.0165215731,
0.0119379349,
0.0151149752,
0.0166331027,
-0.0582761355,
-0.0182753075,
-0.0425767526,
0.0183036942,
0.0415412039,
0.0288929045,
-0.0852313265,
0.0323130153,
-0.0474871024,
-0.0106960023,
0.0150370076,
-0.0037674981,
0.0084492182,
-0.0245735366,
0.0699264854,
-0.0256701577,
-0.0318647027,
-0.0280864276,
0.014812788,
-0.0046646199,
-0.0443293415,
-0.014387711,
0.0507847108,
0.0383210219,
0.0448375233,
0.0000020992,
0.0005426037,
0.0421286635,
-0.0186199956,
0.0480593182,
0.0169330537,
0.0397520475,
-0.0474765934,
0.0003982789,
0.0063713305,
-0.0269325562,
-0.0642459542,
0.0725596398,
0.0373299047,
0.0633821338,
0.0450093448,
0.0072182026,
-0.0365605727,
0.0075770845,
-0.0434788428,
0.0248473398,
-0.0121327024,
0.0192548037,
-0.0200414266,
0.0099288533,
-0.0006346605,
-0.0666694939,
0.0817741752,
0.0314138904,
-0.0059194439,
-0.0207308903,
0.0330884233,
0.0056109433,
-0.0535944514,
-0.0462278016,
0.0820539892,
-0.0766796097,
-0.0002653248,
0.0000707134,
0.0128313983,
-0.010928221,
0.0110100349,
-0.0462395251,
0.0388154648,
0.0032275817,
0.0044375923,
-0.072684586,
-0.0055691069,
0.025363408,
-0.0098813009,
0.0137243839,
-0.015745597,
0.0236620605,
0.0282599535,
-0.0356475189,
-0.0071956967,
0.0104589248,
-0.0792795718,
-0.0114038754,
0.0550316237,
0.0135829439,
0.013078901,
-0.0150936395,
-0.0237732064,
0.0117658861,
-0.0364498943,
0.0599590018,
0.0242993608,
-0.0635494068,
0.031135818,
-0.0300425515,
0.0697122663,
-0.0364581198,
0.0358851179,
0.0007324872,
0.0027708837,
-0.0456618816,
-0.00500722,
-0.0436191782,
-0.0177227389,
-0.0361007713,
-0.0493500717,
-0.0223066751,
0.0142712453,
0.0093399575,
-0.0162061434,
0.0178215113,
0.0265879147,
-0.0249167047,
0.0007112413,
-0.0399685688,
0.0671698973,
0.0193709861,
-0.0107435538,
-0.0184372794,
-0.0516953841,
-0.0024914155,
0.0221574232,
0.0089637944,
-0.0159402005,
-0.0278211534,
0.0787025616,
-0.0179873593,
-0.0346180536,
-0.0404689573,
0.0128673166,
-0.045526579,
-0.036382392,
0.0485437401,
-0.064475134,
0.0219909512,
-0.0272365585,
-0.0023594033,
-0.0195919648,
0.020431716,
0.0255551115,
-0.0118009672,
0.0886096209,
0.0134434216,
-0.0172363278,
0.0015987526,
0.0038196035,
0.0465083085,
0.0446498506,
0.0437750071,
0.0523345396,
0.0108989859,
-0.0220572185,
0.0347498693,
0.0688678473,
-0.0307509229,
-0.0276111383,
-0.085726954,
-0.0400897563,
0.0236229692,
0.0505748391,
0.0389261208,
0.0650081336,
-0.0288494434,
-0.0307907555,
0.0582294092,
0.027040733,
0.037256863,
0.0260806121,
0.0732387006,
0.0074976059,
-0.0036622225,
-0.0212706104,
-0.0437982343,
0.0639197379,
-0.0042872895,
0.0121711921,
-0.0499630608,
0.0525738671,
-0.0450123996,
-0.0312571935,
-0.0199742969,
-0.0109264422,
0.0455113389,
-0.0156035908,
0.0537328497,
0.0327733047,
-0.0717296824,
0.0016884834,
-0.0216711778,
-0.0528420396,
0.0018893429,
-0.0358538888,
0.0241452288,
0.0703091845,
0.0447944477,
-0.0048179072,
0.0094278362,
-0.0114582907,
0.0235357303,
0.0363539681,
0.0383214541,
0.0060141794,
0.0300179198,
-0.0867147893,
-0.0537448451,
-0.0016816949,
-0.0144146355,
0.0518975928,
0.0023294305,
0.0196513217,
-0.0062251305,
-0.0239224657,
-0.0106037278,
0.043120455,
0.0134252133,
-0.0108908257,
0.0021771465,
0.0218242034,
0.0043469639,
-0.0134982029,
0.0114316344,
0.0040971758,
0.0396781527,
-0.0594574027,
0.0412064977,
0.0254309531,
-0.0316066146,
-0.0716183931,
0.028369952,
-0.0325218029,
0.0234960448,
0.0370025635,
-0.0372071378,
-0.0114522222,
0.0280359816,
-0.0196262505,
0.0192636419,
-0.0335525125,
-0.0042747203,
0.0217235889,
0.0514211282,
-0.0241597723,
0.0156482421,
-0.0368216783,
-0.0161397122,
0.0002348924,
0.0022384017,
-0.0234500952,
-0.0374974683,
-0.0336099938,
0.0093817506,
0.0018264737,
0.0223619547,
-0.0184771642,
0.0320692547,
-0.0263274014,
-0.0260322038,
-0.0644955039,
-0.0189798251,
-0.0314600319,
-0.0407965928,
-0.0179245677,
0.0032001135,
0.0230034683,
-0.0666177422,
-0.0439101979,
0.0316819511,
0.0056639523,
0.0076680519,
0.0423922203,
-0.0046986453,
-0.0251083635,
-0.0245524831,
-0.0442227609,
0.0136218397,
0.0515468717,
-0.0213135518,
-0.0251305401,
-0.0178656559,
-0.0244438648,
-0.0074367058,
0.0293062236,
-0.02848926,
-0.0319966748,
-0.0007944787,
-0.0311906878,
0.0557811409,
0.0594051257,
0.0356359072,
0.031957943,
0.0123228533,
-0.0536360964,
-0.0248471219,
0.017130157,
-0.0199077912,
-0.0361932926,
0.0125799468,
-0.0033866342,
-0.0125527568,
0.0646479651,
-0.0216710791,
0.0301170126,
-0.0790681094,
-0.0065397373,
0.0173414201,
-0.0254652817,
-0.0460082628,
0.0001861923,
-0.0022781296,
0.0243367404,
-0.0417317078,
-0.0552782603,
0.0233333856,
-0.0653339773,
-0.0323780142,
0.0113989152,
0.0090624318,
-0.0324243195,
0.0689182058,
0.0480239838,
-0.015874045,
-0.0141604394,
-0.0111054219,
-0.0410137288,
-0.0107694045,
-0.0305579677,
-0.0185339544,
0.0646385476,
-0.0562067702,
-0.005014698,
-0.0101006599,
0.0152810067,
-0.0468349718,
0.0043856828,
-0.0246855821,
-0.0557926856,
-0.0464660786,
-0.0055683018,
-0.0176327322,
0.0502503403,
0.0241971873,
0.0346820056,
-0.0125802783,
0.0130199352,
-0.0217967518,
0.0502968021,
0.0547463708,
0.0309032891,
-0.0101575144,
-0.0190720502,
0.0134551432,
0.0382451192,
0.0096222507,
0.0119878463,
-0.0672376007,
0.0618115179,
0.0387745872,
0.0258541182,
-0.0192954652,
0.0467912406,
0.0357877314,
-0.0963102803,
-0.015735643,
0.0500489734,
0.0107486015,
-0.0360664465,
-0.0271690097,
0.0273281205,
0.040532425,
0.0217159912,
0.0149089042,
-0.0897925943,
-0.049150534,
0.0003104563,
-0.0060317572,
0.0364288948,
-0.001442374,
-0.0244608764,
-0.081289947,
0.0548743717,
-0.0019241705,
-0.0504527912,
-0.0058081504,
0.0052309777,
-0.0191804357,
-0.0071839415,
0.0195254516,
0.0133856935,
-0.0297010541,
0.0046401708,
0.0085725477,
-0.0046565537,
-0.0325056016,
0.0032516094,
-0.0362767167,
-0.0132402675,
0.0783358216,
0.0137426723,
-0.0056035607,
-0.087583065,
0.0101330904,
-0.0045320489,
0.0344014987,
-0.008372562,
0.0407474637,
-0.0161239039,
-0.0595455877,
0.0089774439,
0.0170795955,
-0.0329399556,
-0.0296478029,
-0.0129077891,
0.0246429872,
0.0100001898,
-0.0321869254,
-0.0246059746,
0.0066400669,
-0.017037617,
0.0389075428,
0.0501721427,
-0.0337477252,
-0.0587128811,
-0.0119923279,
0.0296402797,
-0.0831165761,
-0.079434365,
-0.007029166,
0.003579265,
-0.0324016288,
-0.0655767471,
-0.0364920087,
0.0292973612,
0.0343535095,
0.0006317628,
-0.0166188199,
-0.0037449868,
0.0223707166,
-0.0881135389,
0.0560610555,
-0.0203308892,
0.0390603356,
-0.0614018627,
0.0155735603,
0.0114218919,
-0.03056027,
-0.0136864819,
0.0238787849,
-0.1132023633,
-0.0266310964,
-0.0087116659,
0.095266901,
0.0175441038,
0.0513584875,
0.0022719484,
-0.0333483368,
0.0265942421,
0.0279364791,
0.0230031684,
0.0090696942,
-0.0096305842,
-0.0069962768,
-0.0018546623,
0.0076357052,
-0.0317503437,
0.0190680679,
0.0132799009,
0.0275009926,
0.023900928,
-0.0398986191,
-0.0240937993,
-0.0427132882,
0.0411057509,
-0.0038016753,
-0.0170533713,
-0.01598504,
-0.0002244195,
0.0390932783,
0.019846037,
-0.0781664476,
0.031629838,
0.0233509447,
0.0151398117,
-0.000120211,
-0.0135637699,
0.0282335449,
-0.0007045947,
-0.0205491874,
0.0337324329,
0.035060145,
0.0206141789,
0.0164146088,
0.0263180602,
0.0013916373,
0.0444054082,
-0.0251683928,
0.0145640224,
-0.0066474713,
0.0510899313,
0.0056049544,
-0.0004488009,
-0.0469062217,
0.0513735637,
-0.0355652794,
-0.0256714765,
-0.0094623212,
0.0504297353,
0.0631508827,
-0.0042441539,
0.028506564,
0.0067614843,
0.0044423975,
-0.0222142041,
0.0533512235,
0.0115077142,
-0.0236361306,
0.0681848675,
0.0195268746,
-0.0137918591,
-0.0248268694,
0.0674785897,
0.0023899046,
0.0371982828,
0.0105431825,
0.0350060053,
-0.0394339189,
-0.0126699246,
0.0327746794,
0.0075819124,
-0.0020496838,
-0.002903962,
-0.0157674197,
-0.0606128797,
0.0621045455,
0.0174344666,
-0.0108566219,
0.0058599748,
0.0472014658,
0.046387013,
0.0439021103,
0.0154933659,
-0.0143970642,
-0.0073021208,
0.0329383463,
-0.040706642,
-0.0001967828,
-5.930703281e-33,
-0.0165986232,
-0.0097002722,
0.0298096053,
-0.0002011661,
-0.0195495803,
-0.0001804501,
-0.0316552594,
-0.0012606318,
0.0019170882,
-0.0149446735,
0.0147327147,
-0.0163672734,
0.0273380913,
0.0381564945,
0.0175868552,
-0.0040192264,
0.0570580848,
0.0068438733,
0.003654537,
-0.0010036869,
-0.0053067091,
0.0441447236,
0.0330679081,
-0.0042281118,
-0.0340614058,
0.0080496557,
-0.0061113513,
-0.0056587998,
0.0126824435,
0.0755800083,
-0.0552806295,
0.0182986297,
0.0192464497,
-0.0122968834,
-0.0465419926,
0.0441374257,
-0.0995986834,
-0.0016619292,
0.0044876924,
0.0482731201,
-0.1011436284,
0.0033082638,
0.0848085657,
-0.0186957847,
0.0048701437,
-0.00315656,
0.0539525934,
-0.0332409889,
-0.0482110977,
0.0073049408,
-0.0283055082,
-0.0144790718,
-0.0059211627,
-0.0481372029,
0.06397672,
0.0207273737,
-0.0006976983,
0.0425668284,
-0.0973506644,
0.0104973577,
-0.0215735249,
0.0554145612,
0.0791560784,
0.0701409876,
0.0111243939,
0.0434821546,
0.0447289571,
-0.0677574053,
-0.0262580793,
0.018309271,
0.0627965182,
0.0364694297,
0.0627300739,
0.0449187234,
0.0159529448,
-0.0100415517,
-0.0241960343,
-0.0063420096,
-0.0038548384,
0.0652424917,
0.004554959,
-0.0025791393,
0.0328500308,
-0.0021681879,
-0.0437003821,
-0.0477662049,
-0.0478923172,
-0.0200090092,
0.0728392601,
0.0452385247,
0.0242703538,
0.0053903507,
0.066507332,
-0.0073833056,
-0.0123203201,
0.0206552763,
-0.0199360009,
0.0447776131,
-0.0086153811,
0.019990176,
-0.0204033311,
0.0036614428,
0.0506588854,
-0.0104992716,
-0.0089856228,
0.0137205077,
0.0255832523,
0.0242340639,
-0.0673571229,
-0.0096188076,
-0.0336327963,
0.0239215177,
0.0111076562,
0.0557003766,
0.0472261421,
-0.0197459217,
-0.0374975577,
0.0472317152,
-0.0171832107,
-0.0296752844,
-0.0131530631,
-0.0400774032,
0.0020641729,
0.0495252535,
-0.046747081,
-0.0054918928,
-0.040378917,
-0.0160565246,
-0.0025890057,
-0.0596499816,
-0.011010658,
0.0373261347,
2.648e-7,
0.0190765765,
0.0257859677,
0.0515620783,
-0.0004562963,
-0.0067194947,
0.0112437028,
-0.0360101014,
0.0058084163,
-0.0126358932,
-0.0270205438,
-0.0092476066,
0.0268631577,
0.0505398139,
-0.0274688173,
-0.0349294692,
0.0024321789,
-0.0542634651,
0.0226742662,
-0.0433561206,
-0.0143960007,
0.0536599979,
0.1036688015,
0.0194805991,
-0.0145752551,
0.0280391462,
-0.0198123325,
0.0676410422,
-0.0148240812,
-0.0009110188,
-0.0255200453,
0.0195587613,
0.0148758814,
-0.0236990899,
-0.0074537573,
-0.010968524,
-0.0094095981,
0.0262110606,
0.0376855396,
-0.0188424699,
-0.0347051881,
0.0177122355,
0.0470578223,
-0.054619249,
-0.0471881032,
0.085354656,
-0.0572126657,
0.0190049186,
-0.002375429,
0.0096476581,
0.0080239279,
0.0323883146,
-0.0348074883,
-0.0345610119,
0.0216844995,
0.0534735806,
-0.0147592686,
-0.0213164575,
-0.0912267044,
-0.0309127234,
-0.0357946046,
-0.0490883961,
0.0139972698,
-0.1104867756,
-0.016993979,
0.0121155884,
-0.0136460289,
-0.0606612228,
2.221788556e-34,
0.0336934067,
-0.0362074412,
-0.0001170228,
0.0295085702,
-0.0042589279,
-0.0055126371,
-0.0249674655,
0.0185467079,
-0.0153720137,
-0.0821011364,
-0.0426814519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13361v1 | Improving Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Transfer via Progressive Code-Switching | 2024-06-19T09:06:24 | 2024-06-19T09:06:24 | Zhuoran Li, Chunming Hu, Junfan Chen, Zhijun Chen, Xiaohui Guo, Richong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Code-switching is a data augmentation scheme mixing words from multiple
languages into source lingual text. It has achieved considerable generalization
performance of cross-lingual transfer tasks by aligning cross-lingual
contextual word representations. However, uncontrolled and over-replaced
code-switching would augment dirty samples to model training. In other words,
the excessive code-switching text samples will negatively hurt the models'
cross-lingual transferability. To this end, we propose a Progressive
Code-Switching (PCS) method to gradually generate moderately difficult
code-switching examples for the model to discriminate from easy to hard. The
idea is to incorporate progressively the preceding learned multilingual
knowledge using easier code-switching data to guide model optimization on
succeeding harder code-switching data. Specifically, we first design a
difficulty measurer to measure the impact of replacing each word in a sentence
based on the word relevance score. Then a code-switcher generates the
code-switching data of increasing difficulty via a controllable temperature
variable. In addition, a training scheduler decides when to sample harder
code-switching data for model training. Experiments show our model achieves
state-of-the-art results on three different zero-shot cross-lingual transfer
tasks across ten languages. | [
-0.0180648882,
0.0155121293,
0.0035478559,
0.0428557247,
-0.0321488902,
0.0425072685,
-0.0099149328,
-0.031811092,
-0.028768843,
-0.0344772562,
-0.0570560023,
0.0085715335,
-0.0067960629,
-0.006055187,
0.0321271457,
-0.0340052955,
0.0802189186,
-0.0327912644,
-0.0353681184,
0.0133829024,
-0.0071869828,
-0.0078522339,
-0.0097580636,
-0.0196998119,
0.0307964571,
-0.0197819415,
0.0351635553,
-0.0027158596,
0.0249857847,
-0.0295803323,
0.0012844503,
0.0438791998,
0.0113564301,
0.0175328981,
0.0000019754,
-0.0324843936,
-0.0403833501,
-0.0083055105,
-0.026965918,
-0.0153579302,
0.0624437071,
-0.0857054889,
0.0039450862,
0.0016342013,
-0.0190589167,
-0.0373517945,
0.0964558199,
-0.0053857863,
0.0161590911,
0.0683256835,
-0.0163845103,
-0.004274609,
0.0014011851,
-0.0233265236,
0.0488177799,
-0.0598845594,
0.0321862549,
0.0194927808,
-0.002474129,
0.0123733664,
-0.063236922,
0.0563902259,
0.0077604223,
0.0355989113,
0.015082554,
0.0009085851,
-0.0249231458,
0.008740251,
-0.0202393197,
0.0649047717,
-0.0798199177,
-0.0305427238,
-0.0308886264,
-0.0306405183,
-0.0254080556,
-0.0518218987,
-0.05417189,
-0.0023938576,
0.0123345973,
0.0129149957,
0.0117441593,
0.0004082394,
0.0432711616,
0.0039822194,
-0.0495700911,
0.0214476865,
0.039805226,
-0.0421221294,
0.0498424768,
0.0115064848,
0.0332670361,
-0.0253296997,
-0.0033409079,
0.0023818195,
-0.0369292982,
0.0452611521,
-0.052539777,
-0.0350562111,
0.011615349,
-0.028415801,
0.0460804664,
0.0634267554,
-0.0496638902,
0.0522071905,
-0.0599713437,
0.0120013859,
-0.0024879433,
0.0134767564,
-0.0442059115,
-0.0350081138,
-0.0617257357,
0.0189390276,
-0.0340623371,
-0.0144170076,
-0.0032800427,
0.0018157536,
-0.0435757153,
0.0093777468,
-0.0248447955,
-0.0282906499,
0.007702,
-0.0551844314,
-0.0399432704,
0.0264531206,
0.0278381258,
0.0417108722,
-0.0410309918,
-0.0050178454,
-0.0136210602,
-0.0406054333,
-0.0278487969,
0.000517267,
0.0280792397,
-0.0693830326,
0.0137294196,
0.0694628581,
-0.0715801194,
-0.0318512581,
-0.0621798858,
0.0410065837,
-0.0057287589,
-0.0386412628,
0.0231201369,
-0.0378969647,
0.0280905254,
0.0047210394,
0.0240071714,
-0.0385264754,
-0.0161248557,
-0.0077315676,
-0.0479129516,
0.115833275,
-0.0122944359,
-0.0317320228,
0.0032436009,
-0.0121176755,
-0.0438118167,
0.1260332316,
0.0187139586,
-0.0381097905,
0.0690208599,
-0.0197838843,
-0.0102059701,
0.0365513042,
0.0204653963,
0.0351048373,
-0.0279523544,
-0.0221420079,
0.0885177106,
-0.0054725758,
0.0392048508,
0.0051990259,
-0.0445748977,
0.0179872438,
0.000190802,
-0.0142159034,
0.0388331749,
0.0195256677,
0.0838134736,
-0.0064249146,
-0.0389826447,
0.0285006836,
-0.009397042,
0.0298429746,
-0.0156089114,
0.0018080762,
0.0138456468,
0.0384096764,
-0.0367626026,
0.0044217855,
0.0218816604,
-0.0260221642,
0.0800663158,
-0.0163060185,
0.0547886342,
0.0079722237,
-0.0249737445,
0.0309131294,
0.0669937283,
-0.0364607908,
0.02687262,
-0.0114994394,
-0.0081229489,
0.0641624779,
-0.0198849216,
0.0027384099,
-0.0162845254,
-0.0143114151,
0.0389395989,
-0.0123651801,
0.0517265089,
-0.0039844406,
0.0616294071,
-0.0662538558,
-0.0235943645,
-0.0058004195,
-0.0087276762,
0.0521689393,
0.0083883349,
0.0524614118,
0.0213222094,
0.0207865685,
-0.0075544734,
0.0317881219,
-0.0808250457,
-0.0140218306,
0.028265873,
0.0007767943,
0.0151048647,
-0.0234228875,
0.0057459204,
-0.0068846717,
-0.0062497421,
-0.0514829755,
0.0071068406,
0.0222207028,
-0.0346874036,
-0.039273873,
0.0148462784,
-0.0317437351,
0.0044722175,
-0.0069623226,
-0.0253176019,
-0.0452705026,
0.0353609771,
0.0188771654,
0.0404965393,
-0.0064890124,
0.0240738168,
-0.0023035728,
0.0428320654,
-0.0037643341,
0.0291093476,
0.0450321138,
0.0579276197,
0.0165201891,
0.0080371853,
0.0151183233,
-0.0211415924,
0.0110600581,
0.0193889085,
-0.0243399963,
-0.0151121626,
0.0035287596,
0.0173981749,
-0.0533219576,
-0.0148048606,
-0.0786542967,
0.0127589395,
0.0000954895,
0.0092455298,
0.0086830044,
0.0088643115,
-0.0016205125,
-0.0075123957,
-0.0241422467,
0.033378467,
-0.0323980525,
0.0361049362,
0.0041611744,
0.0001908894,
0.0174346473,
-0.0341547839,
-0.0037836067,
0.0197924804,
0.04315437,
-0.0439213663,
-0.0234284624,
-0.0642295629,
0.0447266325,
-0.0173981208,
0.0008125014,
-0.0032491528,
-0.0392191671,
-0.0111511517,
0.0091817668,
0.0421943292,
0.0441775806,
-0.0049642012,
-0.0467141382,
0.0474737249,
-0.077575095,
-0.036020752,
0.0052032294,
0.039029941,
-0.0437811688,
-0.0347353071,
-0.0340091772,
-0.0142429173,
0.0495414026,
-0.0245500822,
-0.0172163919,
-0.0746742934,
-0.0442613885,
-0.0506179295,
-0.0306135695,
0.0031082195,
0.0162802115,
-0.0174632519,
0.014658303,
-0.0441774093,
-0.0005122977,
0.0354342908,
-0.0302387439,
-0.0185696352,
-0.056598518,
-0.0028396812,
-0.0208650623,
-0.0109772021,
-0.0328645185,
0.0233177803,
0.0111127878,
0.0062946407,
-0.0562689342,
-0.0342761539,
0.0159197822,
-0.0070369095,
0.0223081708,
-0.0411841236,
0.0052502709,
-0.0121883526,
-0.0318762064,
-0.0005542348,
-0.0136497431,
0.0105233518,
0.0072998204,
0.0415591598,
-0.0027368981,
-0.0208662134,
-0.014653095,
0.0376487747,
0.0709989369,
-0.0081005422,
-0.0029410608,
-0.005661285,
0.0056098467,
0.0168595295,
-0.0018253468,
-0.0198529065,
-0.0245225001,
0.0012505719,
-0.0051412568,
0.0328340568,
0.0246139839,
-0.0095181363,
0.0447614305,
0.0408599302,
-0.0100835506,
-0.0408393852,
-0.0239031222,
0.0309319887,
-0.0354573019,
-0.0255221091,
0.0585196279,
0.016536722,
-0.075691551,
-0.0125600807,
-0.045429904,
0.0037723624,
0.0387483686,
0.0525479466,
-0.0993183851,
-0.0311974864,
-0.0092289662,
0.0163594391,
-0.0127740791,
-0.0116040064,
-0.0387116261,
-0.1011970416,
0.0009281075,
0.0354243442,
-0.0925837159,
-0.0164004415,
-0.0343790129,
0.0080557214,
-0.0304953381,
0.0126140444,
-0.0356831849,
-0.0105672544,
-0.0082403887,
0.0081467461,
0.041005224,
-0.0381660797,
0.0085691893,
-0.0151331173,
0.0560048781,
0.0713280141,
0.013050938,
-0.0115060015,
-0.0212584101,
0.0254562236,
-0.0432935879,
-0.0387780815,
-0.0370134041,
0.0447736904,
-0.0123772025,
-0.021492308,
0.0627050549,
-0.0019418084,
0.014524864,
-0.031840656,
0.0035816601,
0.068491675,
0.0698273852,
0.0050261416,
0.023137711,
-0.0076099681,
0.0443916507,
0.0519316792,
0.0183273498,
-0.0501158684,
0.0226392243,
-0.0078209983,
0.0079471748,
-0.0665444583,
0.001844384,
0.0105924997,
-0.0745570436,
-0.0420684628,
-0.0667027831,
-0.0293587688,
0.041026026,
0.0562142022,
0.0117108943,
0.0434630178,
-0.0419526733,
0.0106117325,
-0.0386482067,
-0.0324202143,
-0.0467611663,
0.0171722583,
-0.053412728,
-0.0207701903,
0.0304759163,
-0.0422757901,
0.0044691744,
-0.0213523544,
-0.0585766062,
-0.0439805873,
0.0112216305,
0.0376097634,
0.0090421159,
0.0575599186,
-0.0131895579,
-0.0516853929,
-0.0017906328,
-0.0087931864,
-0.0355633795,
0.0320638046,
0.0754270256,
0.0349350125,
0.0062273797,
0.0270087123,
-0.0457555093,
0.0079824114,
0.018803509,
0.0355275311,
-0.0569336526,
0.0187380593,
0.0004805591,
-0.0241855253,
-0.0013030338,
0.0075858496,
-0.0361522995,
-0.025739802,
0.0396187082,
0.0047810692,
-0.0147167547,
-0.0460348614,
-0.025140414,
0.0430412963,
-0.0360201672,
0.0035818084,
0.0192696825,
-0.0173231568,
-0.0044399854,
-0.0343117006,
0.0231258739,
0.0383778438,
0.0598116033,
0.0048336484,
0.0366119593,
-0.0202966072,
0.0095954156,
0.0167329591,
0.0208450649,
-0.0728962272,
0.0420097709,
0.0116880136,
-0.0088701164,
-0.0052557793,
-0.0025421532,
-0.0522922277,
0.0221877135,
-0.005945533,
-0.0072285109,
0.040158961,
-0.0148470402,
0.0979389176,
0.0181931946,
-0.0282045119,
-0.0057655177,
0.0081190588,
-0.0353556313,
-0.0015453079,
0.0182824545,
0.0243989415,
0.015687719,
0.0057427678,
0.068625778,
-0.0079597263,
0.0265026446,
-0.0288738925,
0.0032324058,
-0.0162799116,
0.0254492424,
0.0762005001,
-0.0076971781,
0.0065389145,
0.0000978829,
-0.009065886,
-0.0640525222,
0.0161181036,
-0.0213864464,
-0.0026350152,
0.0102027413,
0.0064820498,
0.0855716318,
-0.027600104,
0.0286703352,
-0.04642592,
0.0062992447,
0.1259070337,
-0.0233756118,
0.0023028462,
-6.48676721e-33,
-0.0357142128,
0.0292771067,
0.0136376424,
-0.0280663501,
-0.042620495,
-0.0130121969,
-0.0258767698,
-0.0057382039,
-0.0303120315,
-0.0127112502,
0.0081474697,
0.0026649637,
0.0302645247,
0.0070492211,
0.0349684358,
0.0019601467,
0.0487704687,
0.0049029011,
-0.0118231252,
0.0330179371,
0.052942425,
0.0602494366,
0.0612024181,
-0.033397045,
0.0431195907,
0.0287238359,
0.023004381,
-0.0115620214,
0.0572175831,
0.0347042046,
0.0126370685,
0.0195905473,
0.018633673,
-0.0410879366,
-0.0166113153,
-0.0038584077,
-0.0896828324,
-0.0377863869,
0.0346751474,
0.0297326259,
0.0104012331,
-0.0646105111,
0.0220370479,
-0.0412115641,
0.0520414934,
-0.017717516,
0.005887134,
-0.0553786382,
-0.0439333282,
0.0129738282,
-0.1202227697,
0.0248701926,
-0.0032071364,
0.0013275647,
0.0604528561,
0.0705960914,
-0.000644944,
0.0194923896,
-0.0585222505,
0.0123286415,
-0.0172124375,
0.0420241691,
0.0569430105,
0.0342511199,
-0.0181469265,
0.0084312214,
0.0447294265,
-0.0302287508,
0.0763316005,
-0.0045032231,
0.0838211626,
-0.0097929966,
0.0072218501,
0.0750584379,
0.0776613727,
-0.0353538953,
-0.0382929184,
-0.0240509138,
0.0154658202,
0.0125135249,
0.0223802906,
0.0407592282,
0.0114421789,
-0.0398460999,
-0.0346321538,
-0.0450272523,
-0.0419091135,
-0.0650960281,
0.0358764678,
0.017094655,
-0.0318631381,
0.0117074857,
0.0726139098,
-0.0098839235,
-0.0156348404,
0.0220268834,
0.0108970096,
0.0446128584,
0.0070474348,
0.0385549739,
-0.0893442929,
-0.0547528788,
0.0259464644,
0.0050650244,
0.0338940062,
0.0063862349,
0.0682922453,
0.0279481597,
-0.0477493852,
-0.0132367248,
-0.0193114541,
-0.0083869062,
-0.0113240825,
0.0469065122,
-0.0008514452,
0.0285914671,
-0.0142428586,
0.0188383721,
0.0354503468,
-0.0537390783,
-0.0120177651,
-0.0574540831,
-0.007338549,
0.045234073,
-0.0202565789,
-0.0072285794,
-0.0029495216,
0.0416793376,
0.0265300032,
-0.0639024749,
-0.0118329264,
0.0387002341,
2.804e-7,
0.050658714,
0.0275358818,
-0.0499277674,
-0.0092673087,
-0.0232764836,
-0.0096337721,
-0.0610310733,
0.0064670038,
0.0237532053,
0.0075444914,
-0.0048358287,
0.0469015166,
0.0541307516,
0.062102098,
-0.0424951352,
-0.0411442928,
0.0340758264,
0.0221180245,
-0.0197215397,
-0.0070613297,
0.052267395,
0.0867440924,
-0.0024560222,
0.0113581009,
0.0284195039,
-0.0099440888,
0.0624353401,
-0.0429094546,
0.0177500229,
-0.0159578696,
-0.0449199416,
0.0206243284,
-0.023729356,
0.0254153293,
-0.0440032743,
0.0080960961,
0.0415374823,
0.026518723,
-0.0152465943,
-0.03970116,
0.0164379794,
0.0094612399,
-0.0379781649,
-0.0398884937,
0.0881451368,
-0.066806078,
0.0136491526,
-0.0114786932,
-0.0255604628,
0.0603325441,
0.0344606899,
-0.0339215659,
-0.0483520515,
0.0117223291,
0.0473313965,
0.0544738919,
-0.0731773302,
-0.0516356975,
0.0009733927,
0.0136578884,
0.0027852391,
-0.0304536279,
-0.0440252721,
-0.034971647,
0.0099588158,
-0.0318803862,
0.0342375189,
2.314084608e-34,
0.0206914768,
-0.0126544889,
0.0262128878,
0.0003309973,
0.0033595464,
-0.0192708485,
0.0035339263,
0.0303693172,
-0.0228524897,
-0.0416247733,
-0.0110111097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13357v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13357v1 | Transferable speech-to-text large language model alignment module | 2024-06-19T09:04:43 | 2024-06-19T09:04:43 | Boyong Wu, Chao Yan, Haoran Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | By leveraging the power of Large Language Models(LLMs) and speech foundation
models, state of the art speech-text bimodal works can achieve challenging
tasks like spoken translation(ST) and question answering(SQA) altogether with
much simpler architectures. In this paper, we utilize the capability of Whisper
encoder and pre-trained Yi-6B. Empirical results reveal that modal alignment
can be achieved with one layer module and hundred hours of speech-text
multitask corpus. We further swap the Yi-6B with human preferences aligned
version of Yi-6B-Chat during inference, and discover that the alignment
capability is applicable as well. In addition, the alignment subspace revealed
by singular value decomposition(SVD) also implies linear alignment subspace is
sparse, which leaves the possibility to concatenate other features like
voice-print or video to expand modality. | [
-0.0118325939,
0.0831439719,
0.0064901249,
0.0567164347,
-0.0325461701,
-0.0187967923,
0.0376297235,
-0.0333029404,
-0.0211106502,
-0.0278674271,
-0.0792991146,
-0.0287785158,
-0.0063717361,
0.0349682383,
0.045011241,
0.0111895557,
0.0646325201,
-0.0334706567,
-0.0276548229,
0.0001559451,
0.0462526977,
0.0153327426,
-0.0398234949,
0.016196901,
-0.0112853562,
-0.0381536074,
-0.032024879,
0.0025318253,
0.0158900972,
-0.0001313774,
-0.0068343277,
0.0430359691,
0.0593702719,
0.0523271784,
0.0000017312,
-0.0355147421,
-0.0113999965,
0.017480446,
-0.0315860137,
-0.0058554239,
0.0416795164,
0.018587077,
-0.0218518544,
0.0160749834,
-0.009933617,
0.0109060239,
0.0444479883,
0.030951472,
0.07519418,
0.0793437585,
-0.0222617593,
-0.0164542664,
0.0498908274,
-0.0083617484,
-0.0199536365,
-0.0672915727,
-0.0022973279,
-0.0125533799,
-0.016485326,
0.0067966226,
-0.0137670878,
0.0731462687,
-0.0088735484,
-0.0167787895,
-0.017713936,
-0.0152002145,
-0.0057331938,
-0.0439701006,
-0.0134054478,
0.0878353417,
0.0077032032,
-0.0114717754,
0.0015894832,
0.0459501073,
0.0037962922,
0.0023394709,
-0.0463970676,
0.0071985526,
0.0238973685,
0.0033807065,
0.0050750785,
-0.0180063285,
0.00963917,
-0.0232298095,
0.0063523315,
0.0033102618,
0.0401172228,
0.0022018794,
-0.0396351367,
-0.0131878918,
-0.0093138656,
-0.0354079343,
0.0147006717,
0.0404088534,
-0.063410297,
-0.0005374225,
-0.0742016137,
-0.047866337,
-0.0294758976,
-0.0502890348,
0.024087023,
0.0494236201,
-0.049017027,
0.0526231118,
0.0018016369,
0.040472988,
-0.0397277437,
0.0269694421,
-0.0665660203,
-0.0539024994,
0.0221425034,
-0.0038151206,
-0.0218034089,
-0.0104861222,
-0.0499892309,
-0.0470371544,
-0.0359299481,
0.0280188955,
-0.0030917604,
0.0248065908,
-0.0033925187,
0.0272044614,
-0.0370808393,
-0.0307985954,
0.0051883138,
0.0651432127,
0.0006356391,
0.0574928299,
-0.0057098186,
-0.0114822071,
-0.0172026232,
0.0562715456,
0.0229168665,
-0.0068639396,
-0.0166281089,
0.0663585216,
-0.0611100644,
0.0096135903,
-0.0140369432,
0.0077362377,
-0.0186882112,
-0.0691462457,
0.0133055737,
-0.0378630571,
0.0735602155,
-0.0008256726,
-0.0227012839,
-0.030215973,
-0.0069173379,
-0.0059690289,
-0.0076049068,
0.0857357681,
-0.0012864639,
0.0368339196,
0.034979213,
-0.0207530577,
0.0050991466,
0.0481895022,
0.0406783074,
0.0103090703,
0.027711153,
-0.0316178501,
-0.0012131245,
0.0718384236,
0.0293123964,
0.019035425,
-0.0260386821,
0.0364153609,
0.0245343111,
0.0229624901,
0.0323570296,
0.031092342,
-0.0049653817,
-0.0400973707,
0.0777619928,
0.0643544495,
0.0276767164,
0.0280772932,
-0.0041068709,
0.0344770066,
0.0001258184,
-0.022938244,
-0.0505094156,
0.0479744077,
-0.0726904869,
-0.0009344775,
0.0578897335,
0.0611361749,
-0.0421709344,
0.0034511066,
0.0083638523,
-0.016425034,
0.0246035848,
0.0310770851,
0.0362347104,
-0.0091096228,
-0.0432949662,
0.055966869,
0.0197784491,
-0.0403888337,
-0.0025758266,
-0.0194939133,
0.050785251,
0.0170484148,
-0.0097031714,
-0.0090264203,
-0.030665949,
-0.0084186904,
0.0023546594,
0.0486812443,
-0.0071669086,
-0.0096241189,
0.0235406682,
-0.0563717671,
-0.0020472894,
0.0219225176,
-0.0127837546,
-0.0193070341,
0.0224787258,
0.0088537922,
-0.0101488521,
-0.032472305,
0.0076485774,
0.0010505102,
-0.0123419492,
0.0217383001,
-0.0249132495,
0.0156286154,
0.052220989,
0.0029459354,
-0.0238805022,
-0.0089813974,
0.0148849357,
-0.0291146412,
0.0002152809,
0.0414470546,
-0.0409815833,
-0.0467756838,
0.0466397852,
0.0061803306,
-0.0037339504,
0.0546295717,
-0.0190915614,
-0.0578849167,
0.0151538607,
-0.0486979,
-0.0002648579,
-0.0460479595,
0.0324338488,
0.0146372616,
0.018098304,
-0.0183116589,
0.0094928537,
0.0374850854,
-0.0261285249,
-0.0080602411,
0.0228709057,
0.0138186039,
-0.0157626551,
-0.0410341807,
0.0163269788,
-0.0202268437,
0.0422160625,
-0.0029307404,
-0.0341464095,
-0.0126108229,
-0.0451372042,
-0.1163237318,
0.0307630468,
-0.0052329809,
0.0345752835,
0.0374023952,
0.0182665847,
-0.0038545493,
-0.0044152229,
-0.0782949328,
0.0297646206,
0.0345546566,
-0.0185885858,
0.0286011845,
-0.0283062216,
-0.0114390329,
-0.0528108515,
0.0167506598,
0.0101719676,
0.0188777428,
-0.0120426118,
0.0225716233,
-0.0577205457,
0.0182349086,
-0.0078091999,
0.0437860787,
-0.023350697,
-0.0796189606,
-0.0289673395,
0.0020533679,
0.0475146957,
0.0783991218,
0.0346400663,
0.023002265,
-0.001033669,
0.0027649605,
-0.045489382,
0.0178602468,
-0.0015747489,
-0.0083857421,
-0.0571447872,
0.0125270765,
-0.0203558039,
0.0611980408,
-0.0013331289,
0.0234467052,
-0.0231234133,
-0.0113143399,
0.0320391692,
-0.0120437667,
0.0269272458,
0.016951751,
-0.0290414449,
0.0262729842,
-0.0271062721,
-0.0222783815,
0.0468474329,
-0.059625458,
-0.0493061952,
-0.0315404572,
-0.0509947091,
-0.0345156938,
0.0252586845,
-0.028069295,
0.021717513,
-0.0162856113,
-0.0351106562,
-0.0617404841,
-0.021382466,
0.0012869294,
-0.0501482636,
0.0326760113,
-0.0054672104,
0.0311671235,
-0.0383748598,
-0.0577395037,
-0.030470537,
-0.0400450118,
-0.0389177054,
-0.0097194947,
-0.0024276611,
-0.0413610749,
-0.0755814686,
0.024323063,
0.0345991366,
0.0341530889,
-0.0139505314,
0.0543655008,
-0.0272212941,
0.0537783131,
0.0736130774,
0.0746626034,
-0.0310023893,
-0.0220511481,
0.0530593991,
0.0373199284,
0.0130619165,
0.0183158666,
-0.0455301628,
-0.0170224309,
0.050515946,
0.0197790209,
0.0009450716,
-0.0128556229,
0.1073993593,
-0.0201525353,
0.0100618871,
0.1078743786,
-0.018860491,
-0.0175493136,
-0.0201102514,
-0.0043758843,
0.0251736585,
0.0033074594,
0.0217754748,
-0.078087084,
-0.0611401945,
0.0128211593,
0.0050258012,
0.0474973805,
0.0236453749,
-0.0025784303,
-0.0956084058,
0.0282196663,
0.0185806155,
-0.0547541343,
-0.0389111973,
0.0030458679,
0.0217831433,
-0.0313528478,
0.0419464558,
0.0121265873,
-0.0020327265,
-0.035115391,
0.0001904162,
0.0041165454,
-0.0061802547,
0.0187987573,
-0.0442685373,
0.0743400082,
0.0348836966,
0.0409357212,
0.0071057132,
-0.0320923664,
0.018869983,
0.045166295,
-0.0418723263,
0.0469667129,
0.0413668863,
-0.0434001945,
-0.0193490218,
-0.0467808694,
0.076974757,
-0.0081926771,
-0.0014671941,
-0.0036233773,
0.0619916022,
0.005093053,
0.0218479447,
-0.0086402725,
0.045452185,
-0.0151646156,
0.0832386017,
-0.0209426042,
-0.0617074743,
-0.0087299841,
0.0055724038,
-0.0189541057,
-0.0120743858,
-0.0447374247,
0.0090269949,
-0.0282287672,
0.0094882175,
-0.0585891008,
-0.0010653542,
0.018535316,
0.0470129363,
0.0033174481,
0.0141090322,
0.0351678394,
-0.0121828495,
-0.0277892239,
0.0365360901,
-0.0309305638,
0.0227608886,
-0.0527877472,
0.0028827169,
0.0466640033,
-0.0599088147,
0.0026992497,
0.0021668058,
-0.1254453957,
-0.0636015758,
-0.0412041433,
-0.0043661105,
0.0164429471,
0.082344085,
-0.0407321192,
-0.0112740789,
0.0328079946,
-0.0102954311,
-0.0814646333,
0.0117593333,
0.0233130455,
0.0137999412,
-0.0104849059,
0.0385225266,
-0.034496583,
-0.0134730795,
-0.0107516432,
0.0365988277,
-0.0209218711,
-0.0804281831,
0.0010357684,
0.0232086387,
0.0079574492,
0.0239087641,
0.0250310469,
-0.0380978659,
0.0245187208,
-0.0079839369,
-0.014688245,
-0.048550535,
-0.0000936414,
0.0239835102,
-0.0221147239,
0.0155829554,
0.0188983418,
0.0223939195,
0.0167277306,
-0.025917314,
0.0320453607,
0.0131576695,
0.0061627966,
0.0104363598,
0.0158773307,
-0.0148458136,
0.0338999592,
0.0161882788,
0.0563645735,
-0.0190513376,
0.0607648045,
0.0169521123,
-0.0197750162,
-0.0013901163,
0.0277426504,
-0.042000927,
-0.0639698729,
-0.0226603895,
0.0548526496,
0.0474893749,
0.0059771384,
0.0705805197,
0.0169632155,
-0.011605816,
-0.016103087,
0.0678222924,
-0.0406784415,
0.0131827341,
0.0397853442,
-0.0034952583,
-0.02219663,
0.0254550148,
0.0164889041,
0.019152876,
0.0327863805,
-0.0121616488,
0.0161160119,
-0.0334969163,
-0.0381082222,
0.0429356769,
0.0242705718,
-0.0285953674,
0.0032265673,
-0.0063484809,
-0.0591620132,
0.012873278,
-0.0078480961,
-0.0420280099,
-0.0293051694,
0.0104274238,
0.0543355793,
-0.0312696658,
-0.0166800134,
-0.0100457082,
-0.0237823185,
0.0105709741,
-0.029989453,
0.0231433325,
-6.421861555e-33,
-0.0477123372,
0.0075027612,
0.0382975526,
-0.0285827164,
-0.0637102425,
-0.0254322235,
-0.029471254,
0.0012932833,
-0.0472931303,
0.0023982211,
-0.0029508229,
-0.007180864,
0.0126128495,
0.0593063831,
-0.0057144761,
-0.0023355032,
0.0372990333,
-0.0167726055,
-0.0145919416,
-0.0062276078,
0.0321298912,
0.0171468742,
0.0498109199,
-0.0804828703,
-0.0231543183,
-0.0116891805,
-0.012566057,
0.0210081637,
0.0087206131,
0.0406996608,
-0.0262387898,
0.0119380271,
-0.0087310011,
-0.0084934421,
-0.0057844897,
0.0475653037,
-0.0829262137,
0.0461430065,
0.056248866,
0.0402709059,
-0.026759373,
-0.0127347643,
0.0089860167,
-0.0217353888,
-0.0012026313,
-0.0259882417,
0.02857049,
-0.0190345272,
0.0311528724,
0.006100894,
-0.0754709542,
0.006766791,
-0.0201350525,
-0.0675622299,
0.0183913317,
0.0528655834,
0.0070138457,
-0.0093824184,
-0.0774581209,
-0.0121303014,
-0.0295987278,
0.0163912736,
0.0887763798,
0.0582801551,
-0.0326924846,
0.0492013544,
0.033216618,
-0.0639925823,
-0.0108273746,
-0.0062667956,
0.0109627163,
0.046338249,
0.0127874333,
0.0596365817,
-0.0320348591,
0.0118045928,
-0.0380601697,
-0.0019425781,
0.0182055198,
0.0064101238,
0.0291582476,
0.0324280001,
-0.0094577912,
-0.0082645873,
-0.0518104024,
-0.0057163155,
-0.032119073,
-0.0168283042,
0.0355453007,
0.0036458347,
0.0089286296,
0.006925453,
0.0898992196,
-0.0329128318,
0.0172122605,
0.005186901,
0.0014628485,
0.010540463,
-0.0359925479,
0.0632649884,
-0.0377807878,
-0.012006294,
0.0512438267,
0.0023218845,
-0.0033994778,
0.0306739975,
-0.0038424321,
-0.0017469689,
-0.0465220883,
0.0055515855,
-0.0212988872,
-0.0388181917,
-0.0233194083,
0.05373336,
0.0431377999,
-0.0044904705,
-0.0222064741,
0.0769946203,
-0.0410881005,
0.0533338413,
-0.0381393358,
-0.056742534,
-0.0113455588,
0.003850614,
-0.0495180823,
0.0303279292,
-0.0507881269,
-0.0315313302,
-0.0038960706,
-0.0560547262,
0.01003851,
0.0149402823,
2.686e-7,
0.0113777341,
0.001551767,
0.0355696827,
-0.0028886634,
0.0085306354,
0.063005127,
-0.0156598929,
0.038625259,
0.0363245532,
0.0027448307,
-0.0094389776,
0.0129505526,
0.0971163884,
0.0167279877,
-0.0601113625,
-0.0609411523,
-0.0708995163,
0.0019739622,
-0.0335547253,
0.0282387994,
0.044218529,
0.1310685277,
0.0120057091,
-0.0096059078,
0.0014939398,
-0.0424901359,
0.0435754247,
-0.0106242187,
-0.0494070947,
0.0315212198,
-0.0223717224,
-0.020805439,
-0.0400701761,
-0.0135057392,
0.0031572615,
0.0500888079,
0.0262953248,
0.0842675567,
-0.0018335348,
-0.0529570617,
-0.0546260588,
0.0223695263,
-0.0192137305,
-0.0436753966,
0.0577403866,
-0.0430478267,
-0.0605307259,
-0.0436020233,
-0.0418200418,
0.0114887841,
-0.0210207105,
-0.0007751645,
0.0258198939,
0.0238810908,
0.0360007361,
-0.0115285413,
-0.0308201592,
-0.0605192892,
-0.0292772874,
-0.004805644,
-0.0669753104,
-0.0407932326,
-0.0114997532,
-0.0299035795,
0.0486893617,
-0.0671490654,
0.0068373508,
2.001243316e-34,
0.0022745626,
-0.0069806334,
0.0224875994,
0.0514687821,
0.0311443508,
-0.0251385178,
-0.0017051087,
0.0099448757,
0.019091377,
-0.0836124048,
-0.0241959281
] |