You are a helpful assistant in evaluating the quality of the outputs for a given instruction. Your goal is to select the best output for the given instruction.

Select the Output (a) or Output (b) that is better for the given instruction. The two outputs are generated by two different AI chatbots respectively.

Here are some rules of the evaluation:
(1) You should prioritize evaluating whether the output honestly/precisely/closely executes the instruction, then consider its helpfulness, accuracy, level of detail, harmlessness, etc.
(2) Outputs should NOT contain more/less than what the instruction asks for, as such outputs do NOT precisely execute the instruction.
(3) You should avoid any potential bias and your judgment should be as objective as possible. For example, the order in which the outputs were presented should NOT affect your judgment, as Output (a) and Output (b) are **equally likely** to be the better.

Do NOT provide any explanation for your choice.
Do NOT say both / neither are good.
You should answer using ONLY "Output (a)" or "Output (b)". Do NOT output any other words.

# Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

# Output (b):
The article features a number of people from North Norfolk, England, who are preparing for the second national lockdown.

Tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page plans to remain open during the lockdown, but expects less trade than during the first lockdown. He feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases".

70-year-old Jennifer, who has lived in North Walsham for 15 years, is doing her best to socialize safely. She feels the second lockdown is necessary but admits it will be difficult.

Barbara Pawsey, who works at the Cherished charity shop, says that the second lockdown will not be good for their charity but that people have to do what is necessary.

Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. He is not looking forward to the second lockdown.

Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp have been to the library to take out books because Apple is being home educated. Mrs Sambrook says the first lockdown was hard but necessary.

Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, is worried about the financial impact of the second lockdown. She has already had a couple of photographers cancel bookings.

# Output (a):
The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.

# Which is better, Output (a) or Output (b)? Your response should be either "Output (a)" or "Output (b)":

Output (b)

Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.

The article features a number of people from North Norfolk, England, who are preparing for the second national lockdown.

Tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page plans to remain open during the lockdown, but expects less trade than during the first lockdown. He feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases".

70-year-old Jennifer, who has lived in North Walsham for 15 years, is doing her best to socialize safely. She feels the second lockdown is necessary but admits it will be difficult.

Barbara Pawsey, who works at the Cherished charity shop, says that the second lockdown will not be good for their charity but that people have to do what is necessary.

Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. He is not looking forward to the second lockdown.

Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp have been to the library to take out books because Apple is being home educated. Mrs Sambrook says the first lockdown was hard but necessary.

Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, is worried about the financial impact of the second lockdown. She has already had a couple of photographers cancel bookings.


You are a helpful assistant in evaluating the quality of the outputs for a given instruction. Your goal is to select the best output for the given instruction.

Select the Output (a) or Output (b) that is better for the given instruction. The two outputs are generated by two different AI chatbots respectively.

Here are some rules of the evaluation:
(1) You should prioritize evaluating whether the output honestly/precisely/closely executes the instruction, then consider its helpfulness, accuracy, level of detail, harmlessness, etc.
(2) Outputs should NOT contain more/less than what the instruction asks for, as such outputs do NOT precisely execute the instruction.
(3) You should avoid any potential bias and your judgment should be as objective as possible. For example, the order in which the outputs were presented should NOT affect your judgment, as Output (a) and Output (b) are **equally likely** to be the better.

Do NOT provide any explanation for your choice.
Do NOT say both / neither are good.
You should answer using ONLY "Output (a)" or "Output (b)". Do NOT output any other words.

# Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

# Output (b):
The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.

# Output (a):
The article features various individuals from North Norfolk, including a tobacconist and sweet shop owner, a 70-year-old resident, a charity shop worker, a gift shop owner, a grandmother and her granddaughter, and a freelance model. They share their thoughts and experiences regarding the second national lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

# Which is better, Output (a) or Output (b)? Your response should be either "Output (a)" or "Output (b)":

Output (b)

Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

The article features various individuals from North Norfolk, including a tobacconist and sweet shop owner, a 70-year-old resident, a charity shop worker, a gift shop owner, a grandmother and her granddaughter, and a freelance model. They share their thoughts and experiences regarding the second national lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.


You are a helpful assistant in evaluating the quality of the outputs for a given instruction. Your goal is to select the best output for the given instruction.

Select the Output (a) or Output (b) that is better for the given instruction. The two outputs are generated by two different AI chatbots respectively.

Here are some rules of the evaluation:
(1) You should prioritize evaluating whether the output honestly/precisely/closely executes the instruction, then consider its helpfulness, accuracy, level of detail, harmlessness, etc.
(2) Outputs should NOT contain more/less than what the instruction asks for, as such outputs do NOT precisely execute the instruction.
(3) You should avoid any potential bias and your judgment should be as objective as possible. For example, the order in which the outputs were presented should NOT affect your judgment, as Output (a) and Output (b) are **equally likely** to be the better.

Do NOT provide any explanation for your choice.
Do NOT say both / neither are good.
You should answer using ONLY "Output (a)" or "Output (b)". Do NOT output any other words.

# Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

# Output (b):
The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.

# Output (a):
In the article, the following people and their identities are mentioned:

1. Colin Page - Tobacconist and sweet shop owner in North Walsham.
2. Jennifer - 70-year-old resident of North Walsham for the past 15 years.
3. Barbara Pawsey - Works at the Cherished charity shop in North Walsham.
4. Bob White - Owner of the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop, and Newsagents in North Walsham.
5. Debbie Sambrook - North Walsham resident, grandmother of Apple Kemp.
6. Apple Kemp - Granddaughter of Debbie Sambrook, being home educated.
7. Gemma Smith - 31-year-old freelance model from North Walsham.

# Which is better, Output (a) or Output (b)? Your response should be either "Output (a)" or "Output (b)":

Output (a)

Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

In the article, the following people and their identities are mentioned:

1. Colin Page - Tobacconist and sweet shop owner in North Walsham.
2. Jennifer - 70-year-old resident of North Walsham for the past 15 years.
3. Barbara Pawsey - Works at the Cherished charity shop in North Walsham.
4. Bob White - Owner of the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop, and Newsagents in North Walsham.
5. Debbie Sambrook - North Walsham resident, grandmother of Apple Kemp.
6. Apple Kemp - Granddaughter of Debbie Sambrook, being home educated.
7. Gemma Smith - 31-year-old freelance model from North Walsham.

The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.


You are a helpful assistant in evaluating the quality of the outputs for a given instruction. Your goal is to select the best output for the given instruction.

Select the Output (a) or Output (b) that is better for the given instruction. The two outputs are generated by two different AI chatbots respectively.

Here are some rules of the evaluation:
(1) You should prioritize evaluating whether the output honestly/precisely/closely executes the instruction, then consider its helpfulness, accuracy, level of detail, harmlessness, etc.
(2) Outputs should NOT contain more/less than what the instruction asks for, as such outputs do NOT precisely execute the instruction.
(3) You should avoid any potential bias and your judgment should be as objective as possible. For example, the order in which the outputs were presented should NOT affect your judgment, as Output (a) and Output (b) are **equally likely** to be the better.

Do NOT provide any explanation for your choice.
Do NOT say both / neither are good.
You should answer using ONLY "Output (a)" or "Output (b)". Do NOT output any other words.

# Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

# Output (b):
In the article, the following people and their identities are mentioned:

1. Colin Page - Tobacconist and sweet shop owner in North Walsham.
2. Jennifer - 70-year-old resident of North Walsham for the past 15 years.
3. Barbara Pawsey - Works at the Cherished charity shop in North Walsham.
4. Bob White - Owner of the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop, and Newsagents in North Walsham.
5. Debbie Sambrook - North Walsham resident, grandmother of Apple Kemp.
6. Apple Kemp - Granddaughter of Debbie Sambrook, being home educated.
7. Gemma Smith - 31-year-old freelance model from North Walsham.

# Output (a):
The article features various individuals from North Norfolk, including a tobacconist and sweet shop owner, a 70-year-old resident, a charity shop worker, a gift shop owner, a grandmother and her granddaughter, and a freelance model. They share their thoughts and experiences regarding the second national lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

# Which is better, Output (a) or Output (b)? Your response should be either "Output (a)" or "Output (b)":

Output (b)

Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

The article features various individuals from North Norfolk, including a tobacconist and sweet shop owner, a 70-year-old resident, a charity shop worker, a gift shop owner, a grandmother and her granddaughter, and a freelance model. They share their thoughts and experiences regarding the second national lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

In the article, the following people and their identities are mentioned:

1. Colin Page - Tobacconist and sweet shop owner in North Walsham.
2. Jennifer - 70-year-old resident of North Walsham for the past 15 years.
3. Barbara Pawsey - Works at the Cherished charity shop in North Walsham.
4. Bob White - Owner of the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop, and Newsagents in North Walsham.
5. Debbie Sambrook - North Walsham resident, grandmother of Apple Kemp.
6. Apple Kemp - Granddaughter of Debbie Sambrook, being home educated.
7. Gemma Smith - 31-year-old freelance model from North Walsham.


You are a helpful assistant in evaluating the quality of the outputs for a given instruction. Your goal is to select the best output for the given instruction.

Select the Output (a) or Output (b) that is better for the given instruction. The two outputs are generated by two different AI chatbots respectively.

Here are some rules of the evaluation:
(1) You should prioritize evaluating whether the output honestly/precisely/closely executes the instruction, then consider its helpfulness, accuracy, level of detail, harmlessness, etc.
(2) Outputs should NOT contain more/less than what the instruction asks for, as such outputs do NOT precisely execute the instruction.
(3) You should avoid any potential bias and your judgment should be as objective as possible. For example, the order in which the outputs were presented should NOT affect your judgment, as Output (a) and Output (b) are **equally likely** to be the better.

Do NOT provide any explanation for your choice.
Do NOT say both / neither are good.
You should answer using ONLY "Output (a)" or "Output (b)". Do NOT output any other words.

# Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

# Output (b):
The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.

# Output (a):
The article features various individuals from North Norfolk, including a tobacconist and sweet shop owner, a 70-year-old resident, a charity shop worker, a gift shop owner, a grandmother and her granddaughter, and a freelance model. They share their thoughts and experiences regarding the second national lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

# Which is better, Output (a) or Output (b)? Your response should be either "Output (a)" or "Output (b)":

Output (b)

Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

The article features various individuals from North Norfolk, including a tobacconist and sweet shop owner, a 70-year-old resident, a charity shop worker, a gift shop owner, a grandmother and her granddaughter, and a freelance model. They share their thoughts and experiences regarding the second national lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.


You are a helpful assistant in evaluating the quality of the outputs for a given instruction. Your goal is to select the best output for the given instruction.

Select the Output (a) or Output (b) that is better for the given instruction. The two outputs are generated by two different AI chatbots respectively.

Here are some rules of the evaluation:
(1) You should prioritize evaluating whether the output honestly/precisely/closely executes the instruction, then consider its helpfulness, accuracy, level of detail, harmlessness, etc.
(2) Outputs should NOT contain more/less than what the instruction asks for, as such outputs do NOT precisely execute the instruction.
(3) You should avoid any potential bias and your judgment should be as objective as possible. For example, the order in which the outputs were presented should NOT affect your judgment, as Output (a) and Output (b) are **equally likely** to be the better.

Do NOT provide any explanation for your choice.
Do NOT say both / neither are good.
You should answer using ONLY "Output (a)" or "Output (b)". Do NOT output any other words.

# Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

# Output (b):
The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.

# Output (a):
In the article, the following people and their identities are mentioned:

1. Colin Page - Tobacconist and sweet shop owner in North Walsham.
2. Jennifer - 70-year-old resident of North Walsham for the past 15 years.
3. Barbara Pawsey - Works at the Cherished charity shop in North Walsham.
4. Bob White - Owner of the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop, and Newsagents in North Walsham.
5. Debbie Sambrook - North Walsham resident, grandmother of Apple Kemp.
6. Apple Kemp - Granddaughter of Debbie Sambrook, being home educated.
7. Gemma Smith - 31-year-old freelance model from North Walsham.

# Which is better, Output (a) or Output (b)? Your response should be either "Output (a)" or "Output (b)":

Output (a)

Instruction:
Here is an article:
North Norfolk has one of the lowest coronavirus infection rates in the country, with a total of 25 cases reported in the most recent week for which data is available. What do the residents and businesses there make of being plunged into a second national lockdown from Thursday? By Laurence Cawley and Laura DevlinBBC News "I think it is a shame for us around here because we don't have that many cases," says tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page. His North Walsham shop remained open throughout the first lockdown and he plans to remain open throughout the second. Mr Page feels the second lockdown was "inevitable given the rise in cases". Across England, the most recent weekly figures are 202 cases per 100,000 people. In north Norfolk, the rate is 40.1 per 100,000. "We stayed open all the way through the first lockdown but there was definitely less trade and fewer people about," he says. "Hopefully this time it will not be so bad. "It seems busier today - I think people are stocking up on things." By mid morning on Monday, queues had formed outside some stores in the town. A few doors down the road from Mr Page, 70-year-old Jennifer emerges from the Showcase Gallery with a gift for her son. She has lived in North Walsham for the past 15 years but had not stepped out into the market town, which sits near both the Norfolk Broads and the coast, for quite some time. "It is busier than I expected," she says. "It is quite frightening to actually try to socialise outside but everybody seems to be sensible and keeping their distance with masks. "It is a worrying time but I think it is the best thing to do for four weeks to try to nip it in the bud." Asked about the second lockdown, she says she feels it is "fair for everybody to do the same thing" but adds: "Lockdown the first time was very hard. Not to cuddle your grandchildren is very, very hard. I'm quite a positive person but it is hard for everybody." Barbara Pawsey, at the Cherished charity shop, says "obviously" the second lockdown would not be good for their charity because they will still have to pay overhead costs. "There are a lot of people who think it is unfair," she says. "But we've just got to do it." She says Christmas decorations are selling fast in the shop so far this week as people stock up in advance of the lockdown. Bob White, who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, says North Walsham has experienced a very difficult year. It began, he says, in January with major gas works in the town which caused "real problems as there was no traffic allowed in the market place". "We were just about out of the gas works when Covid hit. And that really did make us wonder what next was going to happen. "It decimated the town. There was nobody out and about anywhere in the town. It was not really worth any of the shops opening." He tells how there were further issues in the town when a decision was made to ban parking in the town in an effort to control the spread of coronavirus. "The last thing we wanted was four weeks more [of lockdown]," he says. "Local people should do what they can to support the local businesses." The town's library was doing swift business on Monday. Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp had been into the library to take out a number books because Apple is being home educated. "It was hard but it was needed," says Mrs Sambrook of the first lockdown. "We were isolating because my husband has disabilities. "It was the silly things you miss, like my son not being able to visit or hugging the grandchildren. That's what you miss rather than going to the shops and so on." She says she "could not quite get her around" why Norfolk was subject to the second lockdown. "I can understand it in areas where cases are high, but I don't quite understand the whole country-wide bit. But if they say it is needed then we will just have to go with it. What can you do?" Apple says the next lockdown would be "hard" educationally because her grandmother sets her work. "It will be hard not seeing her for a while," says Apple. The pair plan to stay in touch - and set and complete studying assignments - during lockdown using an online messaging application. Freelance model Gemma Smith, 31, was hit hard financially during the first lockdown when her earnings roughly halved. "I was pretty miffed about the lockdown, though I did understand it and went along with all of the rules," she says. "From what I can tell, people here feel similarly miffed about another lockdown and the disruption to normality. "I'm most worried about the financial side this time around and that the government won't help. I'm worried about what will happen. I've already had a couple of photographers cancel and say they will have to see me in the new year. "But I suppose it affects everybody pretty badly. It is just one of those things." Find BBC News: East of England on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. If you have a story suggestion email eastofenglandnews@bbc.co.uk

Here is an summary requirement:
Summarize all people and their identities in the article.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

In the article, the following people and their identities are mentioned:

1. Colin Page - Tobacconist and sweet shop owner in North Walsham.
2. Jennifer - 70-year-old resident of North Walsham for the past 15 years.
3. Barbara Pawsey - Works at the Cherished charity shop in North Walsham.
4. Bob White - Owner of the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop, and Newsagents in North Walsham.
5. Debbie Sambrook - North Walsham resident, grandmother of Apple Kemp.
6. Apple Kemp - Granddaughter of Debbie Sambrook, being home educated.
7. Gemma Smith - 31-year-old freelance model from North Walsham.

The article features various people from North Walsham, North Norfolk, including tobacconist and sweet shop owner Colin Page, 70-year-old Jennifer, Barbara Pawsey from the Cherished charity shop, Bob White who owns the Showcase Gallery, Gift Shop and Newsagents, Debbie Sambrook and her granddaughter Apple Kemp, and freelance model Gemma Smith.


You are a helpful assistant in evaluating the quality of the outputs for a given instruction. Your goal is to select the best output for the given instruction.

Select the Output (a) or Output (b) that is better for the given instruction. The two outputs are generated by two different AI chatbots respectively.

Here are some rules of the evaluation:
(1) You should prioritize evaluating whether the output honestly/precisely/closely executes the instruction, then consider its helpfulness, accuracy, level of detail, harmlessness, etc.
(2) Outputs should NOT contain more/less than what the instruction asks for, as such outputs do NOT precisely execute the instruction.
(3) You should avoid any potential bias and your judgment should be as objective as possible. For example, the order in which the outputs were presented should NOT affect your judgment, as Output (a) and Output (b) are **equally likely** to be the better.

Do NOT provide any explanation for your choice.
Do NOT say both / neither are good.
You should answer using ONLY "Output (a)" or "Output (b)". Do NOT output any other words.

# Instruction:
Here is an article:
Playboy magazine is stopping publishing pictures of totally nude women because the internet has made them outdated, its US owners say. It's a break with a 62-year format that has had a significant impact on American culture. By Vanessa BarfordBBC News Magazine, Washington Every month since 1953, fold-out spreads of fully nude women have filled Playboy. The glossy adult men's magazine boasts a plethora of celebrity conquests in its portfolio. Madonna, Sharon Stone and Naomi Campbell were photographed at the peak of their fame. Kate Moss posed for its front cover in a bunny outfit. Lindsay Lohan and Pamela Anderson have also graced it. The magazine may have offended some who see it as sexist and demeaning to women, but the idea of Playboy dispensing with nudity would once have been unthinkable. But in March 2016, that will happen. "You're now one click away from every sex act imaginable for free. And so it's just passe at this juncture," Playboy chief executive Scott Flanders is quoted by the New York Times as saying. The redesigned Playboy will still feature "sexy, seductive pictorials of the world's most beautiful women," but full nudity will be banished. It ends a cultural phenomenon that was a rite of passage for a generation of American men - an illicit thrill in adolescent bedrooms or garden sheds - and helped spark America's sexual revolution. From its beginnings editor-in-chief Hugh Hefner founded the magazine on full nudity. Marilyn Monroe famously appeared on the magazine's first cover and centrefold. Hefner didn't hide the magazine's intentions. "If you're a man between the ages of 18 and 80, Playboy is meant for you," he wrote in the first issue. "We want to make it clear from the very start, we aren't a 'family magazine.' If you're somebody's sister, wife or mother-in-law and picked us up by mistake, please pass us along to the man in your life and get back to your Ladies Home Companion." He also described the "pleasure-primer" he wanted to create. "Most of today's 'magazines for men' spend all their time out-of-doors - thrashing through thorny thickets or splashing about in fast-flowing streams. We enjoy mixing up cocktails and an hors d'oeuvre or two, putting a little mood music on the phonograph, and inviting in a female acquaintance for a quiet discussion on Picasso, Nietzsche, jazz, sex," it said. The 50,000 copies - which were sold for 50 cents each - flew off the shelf. Dian Hanson, author of a six-volume history of men's magazines and an editor for Taschen, says Hefner tapped into a new consumer attitude that emerged at the end of World War Two. "America came out the war relatively unscathed, it did not suffer like Europe. Many young men didn't see battle but had experienced more adventurous things, more nudity, and wanted something different when they came back. "It wasn't the first nude magazine, but rather than showing a macho Hemingwayesque way of life that many men didn't relate to, it showed scrawny intelligent guys they didn't have to be rough, tough guys to be a playboy. It was a nerds' way to sexuality - which is what Hefner himself did to get girls," she says. During Playboy's heyday, readers could plausibly claim they read it for its writing and journalism. The magazine published stories by Jack Kerouac, Joseph Heller, Haruki Murakami and Margaret Atwood among others, and interviewed culturally and politically significant figures such as Frank Sinatra, Malcolm X and Jimmy Carter. But nudity was always a big selling point of the magazine, which attracted or coaxed well-known female public figures into gracing its pages. "Some of the pictures were pretty amazing and became pop culture references. Naomi Campbell in her white trap outfit. American actress Bo Derek," says Hanson. "Esquire magazine was the template. They had painted pin-ups but they didn't have nudes. Hefner basically reconfigured a magazine made by older men to fit a younger man's need, and then took it a step further," she says. Playboy's circulation peaked at more than 7.16m copies in 1972, with a quarter of all American male college students reportedly reading it in the 1970s. It literally explained sex to a generation of American men. The success of Playboy magazine gave way to the rise of the Playboy lifestyle, allowing Hefner to build a Playboy mansion, create Playboy clubs with cocktail waitresses decked out in Bunny outfits and endless Playboy merchandise. The rise of feminism led to some criticism that women were being objectified. US feminist and journalist Gloria Steinem worked undercover at the New York Playboy Club to write "A Bunny's Tale," which showed conditions waitresses faced in 1963. But Hanson argues Playboy magazine was a respectable, even desirable, place for women to "show themselves off". "It was a poor girl's pageant, grandmothers would approve," she says. It also ushered in a new era of women's magazine publishing. Cosmopolitan famously published a nude photo of Burt Reynolds as a centrefold in 1972 and the debut issue of Playgirl appeared in June 1973. More raunchy US competitors like Hustler and Penthouse soon arrived, while so-called lad mags such as Maxim, Stuff and FHM followed later. But it was the internet era - which made pornography more readily available - which the magazine blamed for the circulation plummeting to its current 800,000. The company no longer makes most of its money from its racy photos. Instead it's made from licensing its logo on merchandise. Playboy's website has already banished nudity, and web traffic has quadrupled. Magazine executives hope the print version will follow in its footsteps. But Hanson isn't convinced. "Unless a new breed of hipster manages to get retro magazines back in fashion like vinyl records, without nudity Playboy is a limping beast," she says. More from the Magazine Burt Reynolds nude: 10 facts about the Cosmo centrefold (April 2012) Subscribe to the BBC News Magazine's email newsletter to get articles sent to your inbox.

Here is an summary requirement:
List some of the celebrities who have appeared in Playboy magazine.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

# Output (b):
Playboy magazine is stopping publishing pictures of totally nude women because the internet has made them outdated, its US owners say. Some of the celebrities who have appeared in Playboy magazine include Madonna, Sharon Stone, Naomi Campbell, Kate Moss, Lindsay Lohan, and Pamela Anderson.

# Output (a):
Some of the celebrities who have appeared in Playboy magazine include Madonna, Sharon Stone, Naomi Campbell, Kate Moss, Lindsay Lohan, Pamela Anderson, and Marilyn Monroe.

# Which is better, Output (a) or Output (b)? Your response should be either "Output (a)" or "Output (b)":

Output (a)

Instruction:
Here is an article:
Playboy magazine is stopping publishing pictures of totally nude women because the internet has made them outdated, its US owners say. It's a break with a 62-year format that has had a significant impact on American culture. By Vanessa BarfordBBC News Magazine, Washington Every month since 1953, fold-out spreads of fully nude women have filled Playboy. The glossy adult men's magazine boasts a plethora of celebrity conquests in its portfolio. Madonna, Sharon Stone and Naomi Campbell were photographed at the peak of their fame. Kate Moss posed for its front cover in a bunny outfit. Lindsay Lohan and Pamela Anderson have also graced it. The magazine may have offended some who see it as sexist and demeaning to women, but the idea of Playboy dispensing with nudity would once have been unthinkable. But in March 2016, that will happen. "You're now one click away from every sex act imaginable for free. And so it's just passe at this juncture," Playboy chief executive Scott Flanders is quoted by the New York Times as saying. The redesigned Playboy will still feature "sexy, seductive pictorials of the world's most beautiful women," but full nudity will be banished. It ends a cultural phenomenon that was a rite of passage for a generation of American men - an illicit thrill in adolescent bedrooms or garden sheds - and helped spark America's sexual revolution. From its beginnings editor-in-chief Hugh Hefner founded the magazine on full nudity. Marilyn Monroe famously appeared on the magazine's first cover and centrefold. Hefner didn't hide the magazine's intentions. "If you're a man between the ages of 18 and 80, Playboy is meant for you," he wrote in the first issue. "We want to make it clear from the very start, we aren't a 'family magazine.' If you're somebody's sister, wife or mother-in-law and picked us up by mistake, please pass us along to the man in your life and get back to your Ladies Home Companion." He also described the "pleasure-primer" he wanted to create. "Most of today's 'magazines for men' spend all their time out-of-doors - thrashing through thorny thickets or splashing about in fast-flowing streams. We enjoy mixing up cocktails and an hors d'oeuvre or two, putting a little mood music on the phonograph, and inviting in a female acquaintance for a quiet discussion on Picasso, Nietzsche, jazz, sex," it said. The 50,000 copies - which were sold for 50 cents each - flew off the shelf. Dian Hanson, author of a six-volume history of men's magazines and an editor for Taschen, says Hefner tapped into a new consumer attitude that emerged at the end of World War Two. "America came out the war relatively unscathed, it did not suffer like Europe. Many young men didn't see battle but had experienced more adventurous things, more nudity, and wanted something different when they came back. "It wasn't the first nude magazine, but rather than showing a macho Hemingwayesque way of life that many men didn't relate to, it showed scrawny intelligent guys they didn't have to be rough, tough guys to be a playboy. It was a nerds' way to sexuality - which is what Hefner himself did to get girls," she says. During Playboy's heyday, readers could plausibly claim they read it for its writing and journalism. The magazine published stories by Jack Kerouac, Joseph Heller, Haruki Murakami and Margaret Atwood among others, and interviewed culturally and politically significant figures such as Frank Sinatra, Malcolm X and Jimmy Carter. But nudity was always a big selling point of the magazine, which attracted or coaxed well-known female public figures into gracing its pages. "Some of the pictures were pretty amazing and became pop culture references. Naomi Campbell in her white trap outfit. American actress Bo Derek," says Hanson. "Esquire magazine was the template. They had painted pin-ups but they didn't have nudes. Hefner basically reconfigured a magazine made by older men to fit a younger man's need, and then took it a step further," she says. Playboy's circulation peaked at more than 7.16m copies in 1972, with a quarter of all American male college students reportedly reading it in the 1970s. It literally explained sex to a generation of American men. The success of Playboy magazine gave way to the rise of the Playboy lifestyle, allowing Hefner to build a Playboy mansion, create Playboy clubs with cocktail waitresses decked out in Bunny outfits and endless Playboy merchandise. The rise of feminism led to some criticism that women were being objectified. US feminist and journalist Gloria Steinem worked undercover at the New York Playboy Club to write "A Bunny's Tale," which showed conditions waitresses faced in 1963. But Hanson argues Playboy magazine was a respectable, even desirable, place for women to "show themselves off". "It was a poor girl's pageant, grandmothers would approve," she says. It also ushered in a new era of women's magazine publishing. Cosmopolitan famously published a nude photo of Burt Reynolds as a centrefold in 1972 and the debut issue of Playgirl appeared in June 1973. More raunchy US competitors like Hustler and Penthouse soon arrived, while so-called lad mags such as Maxim, Stuff and FHM followed later. But it was the internet era - which made pornography more readily available - which the magazine blamed for the circulation plummeting to its current 800,000. The company no longer makes most of its money from its racy photos. Instead it's made from licensing its logo on merchandise. Playboy's website has already banished nudity, and web traffic has quadrupled. Magazine executives hope the print version will follow in its footsteps. But Hanson isn't convinced. "Unless a new breed of hipster manages to get retro magazines back in fashion like vinyl records, without nudity Playboy is a limping beast," she says. More from the Magazine Burt Reynolds nude: 10 facts about the Cosmo centrefold (April 2012) Subscribe to the BBC News Magazine's email newsletter to get articles sent to your inbox.

Here is an summary requirement:
List some of the celebrities who have appeared in Playboy magazine.

Please summarize the above article based on the given requirement:

Some of the celebrities who have appeared in Playboy magazine include Madonna, Sharon Stone, Naomi Campbell, Kate Moss, Lindsay Lohan, Pamela Anderson, and Marilyn Monroe.

Playboy magazine is stopping publishing pictures of totally nude women because the internet has made them outdated, its US owners say. Some of the celebrities who have appeared in Playboy magazine include Madonna, Sharon Stone, Naomi Campbell, Kate Moss, Lindsay Lohan, and Pamela Anderson.