Datasets:

DLI-Lab

/

Mind2Web-cleaned-lite-acctree-value-model-w-cot-formatted

like 0

You are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agent effectively complete a given mission on a website based on the user’s intent. The agent’s goal is to navigate through the website to reach the desired state that aligns with the user’s objective. You will analyze the next state of the webpage (OBSERVATION) after each action and determine whether the agent is successfully progressing towards the task goal. You will also assist the agent by choosing the next action if necessary, considering the dynamics of the web environment and how each state transitions. Key Points: 1. Understand the intent: - Identify the user’s goal (e.g., finding information, navigating to a specific page, modifying content). - Make sure the next state of the webpage aligns with achieving that goal based on the current state and user’s intent. 2. Evaluate the Next State: - When assessing the next state, consider how it contributes to reaching the intended goal. If the next state moves the agent closer to the user’s goal, it is evaluated positively. - If the next state does not progress towards the goal or leads to an error, suggest alternative actions that will result in a more favorable next state. 3. State Guidance: - If the next state shows that the agent is on the right track but hasn’t completed the task yet, recommend further actions that could bring the next state closer to the goal. Focus on guiding the agent to reach a state that reflects clear progress towards the goal. 4. Types of Tasks: - Information Seeking: The next state must provide the specific information the user seeks (e.g., product price, reviews). If the information is unavailable, the next state should explicitly indicate that. - Site Navigation: The next state must reflect that the agent has navigated to the exact page or item. Check if the state includes content based on the user’s intent. - Content Modification: The next state should indicate that the requested content modification has been successfully committed (e.g., form submission, comment posting). - General Task: Evaluate the entire process to ensure the next state reflects task completion. Stop actions should only be issued when the objective is met. 5. Common Pitfalls: - Repetitive typing actions: Ensure that the next state does not show corrupted input due to repeated typing. - Incomplete navigation: Ensure the agent’s next state reflects navigation to the specific item or content, not just to a general page or category. Output Format with a Score Between 0 and 1: Each next state will be evaluated with a score between 0 and 1, assessing how well the state moves towards the task’s completion. This score provides nuanced feedback on the state’s effectiveness. 0: The next state is a failure or leads away from the task. Values closer to 0 (e.g., 0.1, 0.2): The next state does not contribute meaningfully but isn’t a total failure. 0.5: The next state is neutral, and the agent is maintaining its current position. Values closer to 1 (e.g., 0.7, 0.8): The next state is helpful and moves the agent closer to the task goal. 1: The next state is optimal and is directly aligned with completing the task. Response Format: 1. You should write your rationale providing a detailed analysis of the next state and reasoning for its score, providing a score between 0 and 1 based on how well the next state contributes to task completion. Output Format: [Rationale] <your thought> [Score] <a value between 0 and 1>

OBJECTIVE: rent a car in Brooklyn - Central, NY on from April 9 to April 15. PREVIOUS ACTION: [] CURRENT OBSERVATION: [1065] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [1088] button ' English - United States$' [1112] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [1134] button 'Menu' [1144] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [1145] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [1148] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [1151] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [1154] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [1157] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [1160] dialog '' modal: False [274] StaticText 'Help' [1203] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [1204] tab 'Book' selected: False [1207] heading 'Book' [1210] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [1213] heading 'Flight status' [1216] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [1219] heading 'Check-in' [1222] tab 'My trips' selected: False [1225] heading 'My trips' [1241] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [1242] tab 'Flight' selected: False [1243] heading 'Flight' [1246] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [1247] heading 'Hotel' [1250] tab 'Car' selected: False [1251] heading 'Car' [1253] tab 'Packages' selected: False [1254] heading 'Packages' [456] StaticText 'Cruise' [481] StaticText 'Roundtrip' [1269] radio 'Roundtrip' checked: false [492] StaticText 'One-way' [1275] radio 'One-way' checked: false [1279] checkbox '' checked: false [509] StaticText 'Book with miles' [1286] checkbox '' checked: false [523] StaticText 'Flexible dates' [1300] combobox 'From*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [1307] combobox 'To*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [592] StaticText 'Dates*' [1325] textbox 'Depart' required: False [611] StaticText 'Youre on a date field. Either type in the date you want in the format month/day/year or press the down arrow key to interact with the calendar. Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar and return to the input field.' [1333] textbox 'Return' required: False [642] StaticText 'Travelers' [650] StaticText '1 Adult' [1346] button '1 Adult' [1348] dialog '' modal: False [1356] button '-' [1358] textbox '' required: False [1359] button '+' [1366] button '-' [1368] textbox '' required: False [1369] button '+' [1376] button '-' [1378] textbox '' required: False [1379] button '+' [1386] button '-' [1388] textbox '' required: False [1389] button '+' [1397] button '-' [1399] textbox '' required: False [1400] button '+' [1407] button '-' [1409] textbox '' required: False [1410] button '+' [1417] button '-' [1419] textbox '' required: False [1420] button '+' [1427] button '-' [1429] textbox '' required: False [1430] button '+' [1434] link 'Travel with a pet' [1438] button 'Clear all' [1440] button 'Close Panel' [1448] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [876] StaticText 'Economy' [1469] button 'Advanced search' [911] StaticText '(Certificates, multi-city and upgrades)' [922] StaticText 'Bag rules' [934] StaticText 'fees for optional services' [1485] button 'Find flights' [1488] button ' Find your travel credits' [1005] StaticText 'TIME TO BUNDLE UP' [1520] link 'Get 1,000 bonus miles when you book with United Packages.' [1521] heading 'Get 1,000 bonus miles when you book with United Packages.' [1523] link 'Build your trip' [1541] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [1550] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [1559] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [1128] StaticText 'Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2' [1142] StaticText 'from $247 Roundtrip*' [1146] StaticText 'per person' [1579] button 'Continue booking' [1169] StaticText '*Availability and pricing are subject to change' [1596] heading 'Explore destinations' [1204] StaticText 'Not sure where to go? Use our interactive map to find flights to great destinations.' [1610] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [1241] StaticText 'Search type*' [1618] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [1619] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [1621] option 'One Way' selected: False [1266] StaticText 'Dates' [1630] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [1296] StaticText '$' [1304] StaticText 'Max price' [1647] textbox '' required: False [1316] StaticText '+' [1653] button 'Search' [1657] link 'Refine search' [1666] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [1675] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [1682] button 'Travel interests' [1696] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [1705] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [1712] link 'Reset filters' [1726] button 'List of search results' [1729] heading 'List of search results' [1502] ListMarker '• ' [1739] button ' Save to favorites ' [1740] image ' Save to favorites ' [1744] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [1547] ListMarker '• ' [1755] button ' Save to favorites ' [1756] image ' Save to favorites ' [1760] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [1592] ListMarker '• ' [1771] button ' Save to favorites ' [1772] image ' Save to favorites ' [1776] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [1637] ListMarker '• ' [1787] button ' Save to favorites ' [1788] image ' Save to favorites ' [1792] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [1682] ListMarker '• ' [1803] button ' Save to favorites ' [1804] image ' Save to favorites ' [1808] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [1727] ListMarker '• ' [1819] button ' Save to favorites ' [1820] image ' Save to favorites ' [1824] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [1772] ListMarker '• ' [1835] button ' Save to favorites ' [1836] image ' Save to favorites ' [1840] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [1817] ListMarker '• ' [1851] button ' Save to favorites ' [1852] image ' Save to favorites ' [1856] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [1862] ListMarker '• ' [1867] button ' Save to favorites ' [1868] image ' Save to favorites ' [1872] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [1907] ListMarker '• ' [1883] button ' Save to favorites ' [1884] image ' Save to favorites ' [1888] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [1952] ListMarker '• ' [1899] button ' Save to favorites ' [1900] image ' Save to favorites ' [1904] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [1997] ListMarker '• ' [1915] button ' Save to favorites ' [1916] image ' Save to favorites ' [1920] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [2042] ListMarker '• ' [1931] button ' Save to favorites ' [1932] image ' Save to favorites ' [1936] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [2087] ListMarker '• ' [1947] button ' Save to favorites ' [1948] image ' Save to favorites ' [1952] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [2132] ListMarker '• ' [1963] button ' Save to favorites ' [1964] image ' Save to favorites ' [1968] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [2177] ListMarker '• ' [1979] button ' Save to favorites ' [1980] image ' Save to favorites ' [1984] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [2222] ListMarker '• ' [1995] button ' Save to favorites ' [1996] image ' Save to favorites ' [2000] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [2267] ListMarker '• ' [2011] button ' Save to favorites ' [2012] image ' Save to favorites ' [2016] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [2028] button "Where I've been" [2031] heading "Where I've been" [2036] heading 'No trips yet' [2047] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [4010] StaticText '$148' [4038] StaticText '$158' [4052] StaticText '$177' [4080] StaticText '$198' [4094] StaticText '$217' [4136] StaticText '$222' [4150] StaticText '$227' [4164] StaticText '$245' [4178] StaticText '$247' [4192] StaticText '$256' [4206] StaticText '$270' [4220] StaticText '$317' [4234] StaticText '$486' [4248] StaticText '$875' [4366] StaticText 'Use ctrl + scroll to zoom the map' [3777] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [3782] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [3787] button 'Tilt map' [3793] button 'Zoom in' [3799] button 'Zoom out' [3804] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [3812] image 'Google' [3822] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [3830] button 'Map Data' [4449] StaticText 'Map data 2023 Google, INEGI' [3837] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [4480] StaticText 'Terms of Use' [4492] StaticText 'Report a map error' [4507] StaticText '*The prices shown are roundtrip fares and have been available within the last 48 hours. Additional baggage fees may apply. Fare prices in miles will include additional taxes and fees.' [3872] heading 'Destinations for you' [4536] StaticText '*Availability and pricing subject to change' [4551] StaticText 'Chicago, IL' [4555] StaticText 'Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30' [4558] StaticText 'Flights from $198 roundtrip* per person' [3890] link 'Book now' [4581] StaticText 'New York/Newark, NJ' [4585] StaticText 'Tue, Apr 25 - Fri, Apr 28' [4588] StaticText 'Flights from $238 roundtrip* per person' [3906] link 'Book now' [4611] StaticText 'Denver, CO' [4615] StaticText 'Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30' [4618] StaticText 'Flights from $158 roundtrip* per person' [3922] link 'Book now' [4641] StaticText 'San Francisco, CA' [4645] StaticText 'Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22' [4648] StaticText 'Flights from $148 roundtrip* per person' [3938] link 'Book now' [3952] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [3964] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [3981] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [3998] heading 'Using travel credits' [4013] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [4023] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [4030] heading 'Keeping you safe' [4046] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [4051] heading 'Touchless check-in' [4063] heading 'Our award-winning app' [4087] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [4094] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [4101] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [4114] heading 'Popular topics' [4118] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [4120] button 'Search' [4175] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [4176] tab 'About United' selected: False [4177] heading 'About United' [4179] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [4180] heading 'Products and services' [4182] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [4183] heading 'Popular destinations' [4439] button ' English - United States$' [4452] link 'Espaol' [4503] button ' Search for a topic' [4507] heading 'Stay Connected ' [4553] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [4556] link 'CoBrowse' [4576] textbox '' required: False [4578] button 'Start CoBrowse' [4611] dialog '' modal: False [4615] heading 'Search' [4620] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [4627] button 'Close dialog' [4644] dialog '' modal: False [4648] heading 'Add to favorites' [4662] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [4669] button 'Close dialog' [4680] dialog '' modal: False [4684] heading 'Add to favorites' [4698] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [4705] button 'Close dialog' [4715] button 'Site Feedback' CURRENT ACTION: click [1250] where [1250] is 'Car' selected: False NEXT STATE PREIDCTION: [10880] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [10900] button ' English - United States$' [10923] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [10939] button 'Menu' [10949] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [10950] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [10953] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [10956] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [10959] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [10962] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [10965] dialog '' modal: False [11005] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [11006] tab 'Book' selected: False [11009] heading 'Book' [11012] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [11015] heading 'Flight status' [11018] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [11021] heading 'Check-in' [11024] tab 'My trips' selected: False [11027] heading 'My trips' [11043] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [11044] tab 'Flight' selected: False [11045] heading 'Flight' [11048] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [11049] heading 'Hotel' [11052] tab 'Car' selected: False [11053] heading 'Car' [11056] tab 'Packages' selected: False [11057] heading 'Packages' [9947] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [11078] checkbox '' checked: false [11095] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [11103] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [11111] checkbox '' checked: false [11119] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [11320] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [9944] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [11521] checkbox '' checked: false [11529] button 'Find cars ' [9982] link 'Your reward is waiting at the finish line with Mile Play.' [9983] heading 'Your reward is waiting at the finish line with Mile Play.' [9985] link 'Register now' [9997] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [11566] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [10001] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [11590] button 'Continue booking' [11603] heading 'Explore destinations' [11616] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [11625] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [11626] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [11628] option 'One Way' selected: False [11638] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [11656] textbox '' required: False [11662] button 'Search' [11666] link 'Refine search' [11676] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [11685] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [11692] button 'Travel interests' [11706] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [11715] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [11722] link 'Reset filters' [11736] button 'List of search results' [11739] heading 'List of search results' [11749] button ' Save to favorites ' [11750] image ' Save to favorites ' [11754] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [11765] button ' Save to favorites ' [11766] image ' Save to favorites ' [11770] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [11781] button ' Save to favorites ' [11782] image ' Save to favorites ' [11786] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [11797] button ' Save to favorites ' [11798] image ' Save to favorites ' [11802] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [11813] button ' Save to favorites ' [11814] image ' Save to favorites ' [11818] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [11829] button ' Save to favorites ' [11830] image ' Save to favorites ' [11834] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [11845] button ' Save to favorites ' [11846] image ' Save to favorites ' [11850] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [11861] button ' Save to favorites ' [11862] image ' Save to favorites ' [11866] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [11877] button ' Save to favorites ' [11878] image ' Save to favorites ' [11882] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [11893] button ' Save to favorites ' [11894] image ' Save to favorites ' [11898] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [11909] button ' Save to favorites ' [11910] image ' Save to favorites ' [11914] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [11925] button ' Save to favorites ' [11926] image ' Save to favorites ' [11930] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [11941] button ' Save to favorites ' [11942] image ' Save to favorites ' [11946] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [11957] button ' Save to favorites ' [11958] image ' Save to favorites ' [11962] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [11973] button ' Save to favorites ' [11974] image ' Save to favorites ' [11978] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [11989] button ' Save to favorites ' [11990] image ' Save to favorites ' [11994] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [12005] button ' Save to favorites ' [12006] image ' Save to favorites ' [12010] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [12021] button ' Save to favorites ' [12022] image ' Save to favorites ' [12026] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [12038] button "Where I've been" [12041] heading "Where I've been" [12046] heading 'No trips yet' [12057] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [13787] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [13792] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [13797] button 'Tilt map' [13803] button 'Zoom in' [13809] button 'Zoom out' [13814] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [13822] image 'Google' [13832] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [13840] button 'Map Data' [13847] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [13882] heading 'Destinations for you' [13900] link 'Book now' [13916] link 'Book now' [13932] link 'Book now' [13948] link 'Book now' [13962] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [13974] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [13991] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [14008] heading 'Using travel credits' [14023] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [14033] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [14040] heading 'Keeping you safe' [14056] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [14061] heading 'Touchless check-in' [14073] heading 'Our award-winning app' [14097] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [14104] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [14111] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [14124] heading 'Popular topics' [14128] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [14130] button 'Search' [14185] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [14186] tab 'About United' selected: False [14187] heading 'About United' [14189] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [14190] heading 'Products and services' [14192] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [14193] heading 'Popular destinations' [14449] button ' English - United States$' [14462] link 'Espaol' [14513] button ' Search for a topic' [14517] heading 'Stay Connected ' [14563] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [14566] link 'CoBrowse' [14586] textbox '' required: False [14588] button 'Start CoBrowse' [14621] dialog '' modal: False [14625] heading 'Search' [14630] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [14637] button 'Close dialog' [14654] dialog '' modal: False [14658] heading 'Add to favorites' [14672] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [14679] button 'Close dialog' [14690] dialog '' modal: False [14694] heading 'Add to favorites' [14708] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [14715] button 'Close dialog' [10010] button 'Site Feedback'

[Rationale] The agent's current action was to click on the 'Car' tab, which is a logical step towards the objective of renting a car in Brooklyn from April 9 to April 15. However, the next state still does not indicate a significant progression towards fulfilling the user’s goal. While the 'Car' section has been selected, the state does not provide any information about available cars, rental locations, or the ability to input the specified rental details like dates and pickup location. The interface remains largely the same, without substantial changes that would allow the user to proceed with the booking process. Therefore, while the action taken was necessary to access car rentals, the next state does not contribute meaningfully towards completing the task of renting a car, resulting in a low score of 0.14. [Score] 0.14

You are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agent effectively complete a given mission on a website based on the user’s intent. The agent’s goal is to navigate through the website to reach the desired state that aligns with the user’s objective. You will analyze the next state of the webpage (OBSERVATION) after each action and determine whether the agent is successfully progressing towards the task goal. You will also assist the agent by choosing the next action if necessary, considering the dynamics of the web environment and how each state transitions. Key Points: 1. Understand the intent: - Identify the user’s goal (e.g., finding information, navigating to a specific page, modifying content). - Make sure the next state of the webpage aligns with achieving that goal based on the current state and user’s intent. 2. Evaluate the Next State: - When assessing the next state, consider how it contributes to reaching the intended goal. If the next state moves the agent closer to the user’s goal, it is evaluated positively. - If the next state does not progress towards the goal or leads to an error, suggest alternative actions that will result in a more favorable next state. 3. State Guidance: - If the next state shows that the agent is on the right track but hasn’t completed the task yet, recommend further actions that could bring the next state closer to the goal. Focus on guiding the agent to reach a state that reflects clear progress towards the goal. 4. Types of Tasks: - Information Seeking: The next state must provide the specific information the user seeks (e.g., product price, reviews). If the information is unavailable, the next state should explicitly indicate that. - Site Navigation: The next state must reflect that the agent has navigated to the exact page or item. Check if the state includes content based on the user’s intent. - Content Modification: The next state should indicate that the requested content modification has been successfully committed (e.g., form submission, comment posting). - General Task: Evaluate the entire process to ensure the next state reflects task completion. Stop actions should only be issued when the objective is met. 5. Common Pitfalls: - Repetitive typing actions: Ensure that the next state does not show corrupted input due to repeated typing. - Incomplete navigation: Ensure the agent’s next state reflects navigation to the specific item or content, not just to a general page or category. Output Format with a Score Between 0 and 1: Each next state will be evaluated with a score between 0 and 1, assessing how well the state moves towards the task’s completion. This score provides nuanced feedback on the state’s effectiveness. 0: The next state is a failure or leads away from the task. Values closer to 0 (e.g., 0.1, 0.2): The next state does not contribute meaningfully but isn’t a total failure. 0.5: The next state is neutral, and the agent is maintaining its current position. Values closer to 1 (e.g., 0.7, 0.8): The next state is helpful and moves the agent closer to the task goal. 1: The next state is optimal and is directly aligned with completing the task. Response Format: 1. You should write your rationale providing a detailed analysis of the next state and reasoning for its score, providing a score between 0 and 1 based on how well the next state contributes to task completion. Output Format: [Rationale] <your thought> [Score] <a value between 0 and 1>

OBJECTIVE: rent a car in Brooklyn - Central, NY on from April 9 to April 15. PREVIOUS ACTION: ["click [1250] where [1250] is 'Car' selected: False"] CURRENT OBSERVATION: [10880] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [10900] button ' English - United States$' [10923] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [10939] button 'Menu' [10949] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [10950] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [10953] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [10956] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [10959] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [10962] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [10965] dialog '' modal: False [11005] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [11006] tab 'Book' selected: False [11009] heading 'Book' [11012] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [11015] heading 'Flight status' [11018] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [11021] heading 'Check-in' [11024] tab 'My trips' selected: False [11027] heading 'My trips' [11043] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [11044] tab 'Flight' selected: False [11045] heading 'Flight' [11048] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [11049] heading 'Hotel' [11052] tab 'Car' selected: False [11053] heading 'Car' [11056] tab 'Packages' selected: False [11057] heading 'Packages' [9947] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [11078] checkbox '' checked: false [11095] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [11103] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [11111] checkbox '' checked: false [11119] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [11320] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [9944] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [11521] checkbox '' checked: false [11529] button 'Find cars ' [9982] link 'Your reward is waiting at the finish line with Mile Play.' [9983] heading 'Your reward is waiting at the finish line with Mile Play.' [9985] link 'Register now' [9997] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [11566] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [10001] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [11590] button 'Continue booking' [11603] heading 'Explore destinations' [11616] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [11625] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [11626] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [11628] option 'One Way' selected: False [11638] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [11656] textbox '' required: False [11662] button 'Search' [11666] link 'Refine search' [11676] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [11685] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [11692] button 'Travel interests' [11706] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [11715] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [11722] link 'Reset filters' [11736] button 'List of search results' [11739] heading 'List of search results' [11749] button ' Save to favorites ' [11750] image ' Save to favorites ' [11754] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [11765] button ' Save to favorites ' [11766] image ' Save to favorites ' [11770] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [11781] button ' Save to favorites ' [11782] image ' Save to favorites ' [11786] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [11797] button ' Save to favorites ' [11798] image ' Save to favorites ' [11802] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [11813] button ' Save to favorites ' [11814] image ' Save to favorites ' [11818] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [11829] button ' Save to favorites ' [11830] image ' Save to favorites ' [11834] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [11845] button ' Save to favorites ' [11846] image ' Save to favorites ' [11850] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [11861] button ' Save to favorites ' [11862] image ' Save to favorites ' [11866] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [11877] button ' Save to favorites ' [11878] image ' Save to favorites ' [11882] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [11893] button ' Save to favorites ' [11894] image ' Save to favorites ' [11898] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [11909] button ' Save to favorites ' [11910] image ' Save to favorites ' [11914] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [11925] button ' Save to favorites ' [11926] image ' Save to favorites ' [11930] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [11941] button ' Save to favorites ' [11942] image ' Save to favorites ' [11946] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [11957] button ' Save to favorites ' [11958] image ' Save to favorites ' [11962] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [11973] button ' Save to favorites ' [11974] image ' Save to favorites ' [11978] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [11989] button ' Save to favorites ' [11990] image ' Save to favorites ' [11994] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [12005] button ' Save to favorites ' [12006] image ' Save to favorites ' [12010] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [12021] button ' Save to favorites ' [12022] image ' Save to favorites ' [12026] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [12038] button "Where I've been" [12041] heading "Where I've been" [12046] heading 'No trips yet' [12057] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [13787] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [13792] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [13797] button 'Tilt map' [13803] button 'Zoom in' [13809] button 'Zoom out' [13814] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [13822] image 'Google' [13832] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [13840] button 'Map Data' [13847] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [13882] heading 'Destinations for you' [13900] link 'Book now' [13916] link 'Book now' [13932] link 'Book now' [13948] link 'Book now' [13962] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [13974] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [13991] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [14008] heading 'Using travel credits' [14023] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [14033] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [14040] heading 'Keeping you safe' [14056] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [14061] heading 'Touchless check-in' [14073] heading 'Our award-winning app' [14097] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [14104] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [14111] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [14124] heading 'Popular topics' [14128] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [14130] button 'Search' [14185] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [14186] tab 'About United' selected: False [14187] heading 'About United' [14189] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [14190] heading 'Products and services' [14192] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [14193] heading 'Popular destinations' [14449] button ' English - United States$' [14462] link 'Espaol' [14513] button ' Search for a topic' [14517] heading 'Stay Connected ' [14563] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [14566] link 'CoBrowse' [14586] textbox '' required: False [14588] button 'Start CoBrowse' [14621] dialog '' modal: False [14625] heading 'Search' [14630] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [14637] button 'Close dialog' [14654] dialog '' modal: False [14658] heading 'Add to favorites' [14672] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [14679] button 'Close dialog' [14690] dialog '' modal: False [14694] heading 'Add to favorites' [14708] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [14715] button 'Close dialog' [10010] button 'Site Feedback' CURRENT ACTION: type [9947] [Brooklyn Central] where [9947] is 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False NEXT STATE PREIDCTION: [20900] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [20920] button ' English - United States$' [20943] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [20959] button 'Menu' [20969] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [20970] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [20973] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [20976] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [20979] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [20982] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [20985] dialog '' modal: False [21025] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [21026] tab 'Book' selected: False [21029] heading 'Book' [21032] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [21035] heading 'Flight status' [21038] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [21041] heading 'Check-in' [21044] tab 'My trips' selected: False [21047] heading 'My trips' [21063] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [21064] tab 'Flight' selected: False [21065] heading 'Flight' [21068] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [21069] heading 'Hotel' [21072] tab 'Car' selected: False [21073] heading 'Car' [21076] tab 'Packages' selected: False [21077] heading 'Packages' [21094] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [21098] listbox '' multiselectable: False orientation: vertical required: False [21099] option 'Brooklyn - Central (New York), US' selected: False [19984] button 'Brooklyn - Central (New York), US' [19986] option '309A, 178A, Purv Marg, Industrial Area Phase I, Chandigarh, 160002, India, IN' selected: False [19987] button '309A, 178A, Purv Marg, Industrial Area Phase I, Chandigarh, 160002, India, IN' [19989] option 'Coal Depot Complex, 10D, Sector 10, Chandigarh, 160011, India, IN' selected: False [19990] button 'Coal Depot Complex, 10D, Sector 10, Chandigarh, 160011, India, IN' [21108] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text [21111] checkbox '' checked: false [21128] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [21136] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [21144] checkbox '' checked: false [21152] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [21353] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [19956] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [21554] checkbox '' checked: false [21562] button 'Find cars ' [20002] link 'Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles.' [20003] heading 'Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles.' [20005] link 'Learn more' [20017] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [21599] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [20021] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [21623] button 'Continue booking' [21636] heading 'Explore destinations' [21649] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [21658] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [21659] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [21661] option 'One Way' selected: False [21671] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [21689] textbox '' required: False [21695] button 'Search' [21699] link 'Refine search' [21709] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [21718] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [21725] button 'Travel interests' [21739] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [21748] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [21755] link 'Reset filters' [21769] button 'List of search results' [21772] heading 'List of search results' [21782] button ' Save to favorites ' [21783] image ' Save to favorites ' [21787] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [21798] button ' Save to favorites ' [21799] image ' Save to favorites ' [21803] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [21814] button ' Save to favorites ' [21815] image ' Save to favorites ' [21819] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [21830] button ' Save to favorites ' [21831] image ' Save to favorites ' [21835] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [21846] button ' Save to favorites ' [21847] image ' Save to favorites ' [21851] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [21862] button ' Save to favorites ' [21863] image ' Save to favorites ' [21867] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [21878] button ' Save to favorites ' [21879] image ' Save to favorites ' [21883] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [21894] button ' Save to favorites ' [21895] image ' Save to favorites ' [21899] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [21910] button ' Save to favorites ' [21911] image ' Save to favorites ' [21915] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [21926] button ' Save to favorites ' [21927] image ' Save to favorites ' [21931] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [21942] button ' Save to favorites ' [21943] image ' Save to favorites ' [21947] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [21958] button ' Save to favorites ' [21959] image ' Save to favorites ' [21963] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [21974] button ' Save to favorites ' [21975] image ' Save to favorites ' [21979] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [21990] button ' Save to favorites ' [21991] image ' Save to favorites ' [21995] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [22006] button ' Save to favorites ' [22007] image ' Save to favorites ' [22011] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [22022] button ' Save to favorites ' [22023] image ' Save to favorites ' [22027] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [22038] button ' Save to favorites ' [22039] image ' Save to favorites ' [22043] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [22054] button ' Save to favorites ' [22055] image ' Save to favorites ' [22059] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [22071] button "Where I've been" [22074] heading "Where I've been" [22079] heading 'No trips yet' [22090] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [23820] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [23825] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [23830] button 'Tilt map' [23836] button 'Zoom in' [23842] button 'Zoom out' [23847] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [23855] image 'Google' [23865] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [23873] button 'Map Data' [23880] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [23915] heading 'Destinations for you' [23933] link 'Book now' [23949] link 'Book now' [23965] link 'Book now' [23981] link 'Book now' [23995] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [24007] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [24024] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [24041] heading 'Using travel credits' [24056] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [24066] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [24073] heading 'Keeping you safe' [24089] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [24094] heading 'Touchless check-in' [24106] heading 'Our award-winning app' [24130] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [24137] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [24144] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [24157] heading 'Popular topics' [24161] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [24163] button 'Search' [24218] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [24219] tab 'About United' selected: False [24220] heading 'About United' [24222] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [24223] heading 'Products and services' [24225] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [24226] heading 'Popular destinations' [24482] button ' English - United States$' [24495] link 'Espaol' [24546] button ' Search for a topic' [24550] heading 'Stay Connected ' [24596] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [24599] link 'CoBrowse' [24619] textbox '' required: False [24621] button 'Start CoBrowse' [24654] dialog '' modal: False [24658] heading 'Search' [24663] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [24670] button 'Close dialog' [24687] dialog '' modal: False [24691] heading 'Add to favorites' [24705] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [24712] button 'Close dialog' [24723] dialog '' modal: False [24727] heading 'Add to favorites' [24741] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [24748] button 'Close dialog' [20030] button 'Site Feedback'

[Rationale] The agent's action of typing "Brooklyn Central" into the 'Pickup location*' field represents a step towards fulfilling the user's objective of renting a car in Brooklyn from April 9 to April 15. However, the current observation shows that the desired location option "Brooklyn - Central (New York), US" is not yet selected, indicating that the agent has not completed the necessary step of selecting this location from the list that appears. This lack of selection means that the agent is still not ready to proceed to the next stage of finding available cars, which is essential for completing the task. The state does show progress in that it has moved to a point where the location can be specified, but it has not yet achieved a definitive action that contributes to task completion. Therefore, while the action does move the agent closer to the goal, it does not fully satisfy the requirements necessary for task advancement, leading to a score of 0.29. This score suggests that the agent should take further action to select the desired location from the presented options before progressing. [Score] 0.29

You are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agent effectively complete a given mission on a website based on the user’s intent. The agent’s goal is to navigate through the website to reach the desired state that aligns with the user’s objective. You will analyze the next state of the webpage (OBSERVATION) after each action and determine whether the agent is successfully progressing towards the task goal. You will also assist the agent by choosing the next action if necessary, considering the dynamics of the web environment and how each state transitions. Key Points: 1. Understand the intent: - Identify the user’s goal (e.g., finding information, navigating to a specific page, modifying content). - Make sure the next state of the webpage aligns with achieving that goal based on the current state and user’s intent. 2. Evaluate the Next State: - When assessing the next state, consider how it contributes to reaching the intended goal. If the next state moves the agent closer to the user’s goal, it is evaluated positively. - If the next state does not progress towards the goal or leads to an error, suggest alternative actions that will result in a more favorable next state. 3. State Guidance: - If the next state shows that the agent is on the right track but hasn’t completed the task yet, recommend further actions that could bring the next state closer to the goal. Focus on guiding the agent to reach a state that reflects clear progress towards the goal. 4. Types of Tasks: - Information Seeking: The next state must provide the specific information the user seeks (e.g., product price, reviews). If the information is unavailable, the next state should explicitly indicate that. - Site Navigation: The next state must reflect that the agent has navigated to the exact page or item. Check if the state includes content based on the user’s intent. - Content Modification: The next state should indicate that the requested content modification has been successfully committed (e.g., form submission, comment posting). - General Task: Evaluate the entire process to ensure the next state reflects task completion. Stop actions should only be issued when the objective is met. 5. Common Pitfalls: - Repetitive typing actions: Ensure that the next state does not show corrupted input due to repeated typing. - Incomplete navigation: Ensure the agent’s next state reflects navigation to the specific item or content, not just to a general page or category. Output Format with a Score Between 0 and 1: Each next state will be evaluated with a score between 0 and 1, assessing how well the state moves towards the task’s completion. This score provides nuanced feedback on the state’s effectiveness. 0: The next state is a failure or leads away from the task. Values closer to 0 (e.g., 0.1, 0.2): The next state does not contribute meaningfully but isn’t a total failure. 0.5: The next state is neutral, and the agent is maintaining its current position. Values closer to 1 (e.g., 0.7, 0.8): The next state is helpful and moves the agent closer to the task goal. 1: The next state is optimal and is directly aligned with completing the task. Response Format: 1. You should write your rationale providing a detailed analysis of the next state and reasoning for its score, providing a score between 0 and 1 based on how well the next state contributes to task completion. Output Format: [Rationale] <your thought> [Score] <a value between 0 and 1>

OBJECTIVE: rent a car in Brooklyn - Central, NY on from April 9 to April 15. PREVIOUS ACTION: ["click [1250] where [1250] is 'Car' selected: False", "type [9947] [Brooklyn Central] where [9947] is 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False"] CURRENT OBSERVATION: [20900] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [20920] button ' English - United States$' [20943] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [20959] button 'Menu' [20969] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [20970] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [20973] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [20976] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [20979] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [20982] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [20985] dialog '' modal: False [21025] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [21026] tab 'Book' selected: False [21029] heading 'Book' [21032] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [21035] heading 'Flight status' [21038] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [21041] heading 'Check-in' [21044] tab 'My trips' selected: False [21047] heading 'My trips' [21063] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [21064] tab 'Flight' selected: False [21065] heading 'Flight' [21068] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [21069] heading 'Hotel' [21072] tab 'Car' selected: False [21073] heading 'Car' [21076] tab 'Packages' selected: False [21077] heading 'Packages' [21094] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [21098] listbox '' multiselectable: False orientation: vertical required: False [21099] option 'Brooklyn - Central (New York), US' selected: False [19984] button 'Brooklyn - Central (New York), US' [19986] option '309A, 178A, Purv Marg, Industrial Area Phase I, Chandigarh, 160002, India, IN' selected: False [19987] button '309A, 178A, Purv Marg, Industrial Area Phase I, Chandigarh, 160002, India, IN' [19989] option 'Coal Depot Complex, 10D, Sector 10, Chandigarh, 160011, India, IN' selected: False [19990] button 'Coal Depot Complex, 10D, Sector 10, Chandigarh, 160011, India, IN' [21108] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text [21111] checkbox '' checked: false [21128] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [21136] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [21144] checkbox '' checked: false [21152] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [21353] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [19956] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [21554] checkbox '' checked: false [21562] button 'Find cars ' [20002] link 'Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles.' [20003] heading 'Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles.' [20005] link 'Learn more' [20017] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [21599] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [20021] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [21623] button 'Continue booking' [21636] heading 'Explore destinations' [21649] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [21658] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [21659] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [21661] option 'One Way' selected: False [21671] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [21689] textbox '' required: False [21695] button 'Search' [21699] link 'Refine search' [21709] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [21718] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [21725] button 'Travel interests' [21739] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [21748] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [21755] link 'Reset filters' [21769] button 'List of search results' [21772] heading 'List of search results' [21782] button ' Save to favorites ' [21783] image ' Save to favorites ' [21787] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [21798] button ' Save to favorites ' [21799] image ' Save to favorites ' [21803] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [21814] button ' Save to favorites ' [21815] image ' Save to favorites ' [21819] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [21830] button ' Save to favorites ' [21831] image ' Save to favorites ' [21835] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [21846] button ' Save to favorites ' [21847] image ' Save to favorites ' [21851] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [21862] button ' Save to favorites ' [21863] image ' Save to favorites ' [21867] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [21878] button ' Save to favorites ' [21879] image ' Save to favorites ' [21883] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [21894] button ' Save to favorites ' [21895] image ' Save to favorites ' [21899] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [21910] button ' Save to favorites ' [21911] image ' Save to favorites ' [21915] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [21926] button ' Save to favorites ' [21927] image ' Save to favorites ' [21931] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [21942] button ' Save to favorites ' [21943] image ' Save to favorites ' [21947] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [21958] button ' Save to favorites ' [21959] image ' Save to favorites ' [21963] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [21974] button ' Save to favorites ' [21975] image ' Save to favorites ' [21979] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [21990] button ' Save to favorites ' [21991] image ' Save to favorites ' [21995] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [22006] button ' Save to favorites ' [22007] image ' Save to favorites ' [22011] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [22022] button ' Save to favorites ' [22023] image ' Save to favorites ' [22027] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [22038] button ' Save to favorites ' [22039] image ' Save to favorites ' [22043] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [22054] button ' Save to favorites ' [22055] image ' Save to favorites ' [22059] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [22071] button "Where I've been" [22074] heading "Where I've been" [22079] heading 'No trips yet' [22090] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [23820] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [23825] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [23830] button 'Tilt map' [23836] button 'Zoom in' [23842] button 'Zoom out' [23847] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [23855] image 'Google' [23865] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [23873] button 'Map Data' [23880] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [23915] heading 'Destinations for you' [23933] link 'Book now' [23949] link 'Book now' [23965] link 'Book now' [23981] link 'Book now' [23995] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [24007] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [24024] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [24041] heading 'Using travel credits' [24056] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [24066] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [24073] heading 'Keeping you safe' [24089] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [24094] heading 'Touchless check-in' [24106] heading 'Our award-winning app' [24130] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [24137] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [24144] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [24157] heading 'Popular topics' [24161] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [24163] button 'Search' [24218] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [24219] tab 'About United' selected: False [24220] heading 'About United' [24222] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [24223] heading 'Products and services' [24225] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [24226] heading 'Popular destinations' [24482] button ' English - United States$' [24495] link 'Espaol' [24546] button ' Search for a topic' [24550] heading 'Stay Connected ' [24596] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [24599] link 'CoBrowse' [24619] textbox '' required: False [24621] button 'Start CoBrowse' [24654] dialog '' modal: False [24658] heading 'Search' [24663] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [24670] button 'Close dialog' [24687] dialog '' modal: False [24691] heading 'Add to favorites' [24705] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [24712] button 'Close dialog' [24723] dialog '' modal: False [24727] heading 'Add to favorites' [24741] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [24748] button 'Close dialog' [20030] button 'Site Feedback' CURRENT ACTION: click [19984] where [19984] is 'Brooklyn - Central (New York), US' NEXT STATE PREIDCTION: [30920] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [30940] button ' English - United States$' [30963] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [30979] button 'Menu' [30989] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [30990] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [30993] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [30996] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [30999] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [31002] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [31005] dialog '' modal: False [31045] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [31046] tab 'Book' selected: False [31049] heading 'Book' [31052] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [31055] heading 'Flight status' [31058] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [31061] heading 'Check-in' [31064] tab 'My trips' selected: False [31067] heading 'My trips' [31083] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [31084] tab 'Flight' selected: False [31085] heading 'Flight' [31088] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [31089] heading 'Hotel' [31092] tab 'Car' selected: False [31093] heading 'Car' [31096] tab 'Packages' selected: False [31097] heading 'Packages' [31114] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [31119] checkbox '' checked: false [29987] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [31143] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [31151] checkbox '' checked: false [31159] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [31360] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [29984] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [31561] checkbox '' checked: false [31569] button 'Find cars ' [30022] link 'Showing you the world, working to reduce our impact on it.' [30023] heading 'Showing you the world, working to reduce our impact on it.' [30025] link 'See how' [30037] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [31606] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [30041] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [31630] button 'Continue booking' [31643] heading 'Explore destinations' [31656] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [31665] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [31666] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [31668] option 'One Way' selected: False [31678] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [31696] textbox '' required: False [31702] button 'Search' [31706] link 'Refine search' [31716] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [31725] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [31732] button 'Travel interests' [31746] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [31755] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [31762] link 'Reset filters' [31776] button 'List of search results' [31779] heading 'List of search results' [31789] button ' Save to favorites ' [31790] image ' Save to favorites ' [31794] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [31805] button ' Save to favorites ' [31806] image ' Save to favorites ' [31810] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [31821] button ' Save to favorites ' [31822] image ' Save to favorites ' [31826] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [31837] button ' Save to favorites ' [31838] image ' Save to favorites ' [31842] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [31853] button ' Save to favorites ' [31854] image ' Save to favorites ' [31858] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [31869] button ' Save to favorites ' [31870] image ' Save to favorites ' [31874] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [31885] button ' Save to favorites ' [31886] image ' Save to favorites ' [31890] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [31901] button ' Save to favorites ' [31902] image ' Save to favorites ' [31906] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [31917] button ' Save to favorites ' [31918] image ' Save to favorites ' [31922] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [31933] button ' Save to favorites ' [31934] image ' Save to favorites ' [31938] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [31949] button ' Save to favorites ' [31950] image ' Save to favorites ' [31954] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [31965] button ' Save to favorites ' [31966] image ' Save to favorites ' [31970] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [31981] button ' Save to favorites ' [31982] image ' Save to favorites ' [31986] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [31997] button ' Save to favorites ' [31998] image ' Save to favorites ' [32002] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [32013] button ' Save to favorites ' [32014] image ' Save to favorites ' [32018] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [32029] button ' Save to favorites ' [32030] image ' Save to favorites ' [32034] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [32045] button ' Save to favorites ' [32046] image ' Save to favorites ' [32050] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [32061] button ' Save to favorites ' [32062] image ' Save to favorites ' [32066] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [32078] button "Where I've been" [32081] heading "Where I've been" [32086] heading 'No trips yet' [32097] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [33827] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [33832] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [33837] button 'Tilt map' [33843] button 'Zoom in' [33849] button 'Zoom out' [33854] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [33862] image 'Google' [33872] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [33880] button 'Map Data' [33887] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [33922] heading 'Destinations for you' [33940] link 'Book now' [33956] link 'Book now' [33972] link 'Book now' [33988] link 'Book now' [34002] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [34014] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [34031] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [34048] heading 'Using travel credits' [34063] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [34073] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [34080] heading 'Keeping you safe' [34096] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [34101] heading 'Touchless check-in' [34113] heading 'Our award-winning app' [34137] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [34144] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [34151] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [34164] heading 'Popular topics' [34168] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [34170] button 'Search' [34225] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [34226] tab 'About United' selected: False [34227] heading 'About United' [34229] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [34230] heading 'Products and services' [34232] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [34233] heading 'Popular destinations' [34489] button ' English - United States$' [34502] link 'Espaol' [34553] button ' Search for a topic' [34557] heading 'Stay Connected ' [34603] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [34606] link 'CoBrowse' [34626] textbox '' required: False [34628] button 'Start CoBrowse' [34661] dialog '' modal: False [34665] heading 'Search' [34670] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [34677] button 'Close dialog' [34694] dialog '' modal: False [34698] heading 'Add to favorites' [34712] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [34719] button 'Close dialog' [34730] dialog '' modal: False [34734] heading 'Add to favorites' [34748] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [34755] button 'Close dialog' [30050] button 'Site Feedback'

[Rationale] The current state reflects a partial progression towards the user's objective of renting a car in Brooklyn. The agent has successfully clicked on the correct pickup location, "Brooklyn - Central (New York), US," which is a necessary step in the car rental process. However, while this action leads to a page that still appears to be set up for booking, there is no confirmation that the pickup location has been set successfully. The next state does not indicate any further actions taken to select the rental dates (April 9 to April 15) or to initiate the search for available cars. This lack of progress in setting the required dates and obtaining search results suggests that the user is still somewhat away from achieving their goal. Therefore, while the interaction is moving in the right direction, it is not yet sufficient to meet the task completion criteria, resulting in a score of 0.43. This score reflects the need for additional actions to further advance towards the completion of the car rental task. [Score] 0.43

You are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agent effectively complete a given mission on a website based on the user’s intent. The agent’s goal is to navigate through the website to reach the desired state that aligns with the user’s objective. You will analyze the next state of the webpage (OBSERVATION) after each action and determine whether the agent is successfully progressing towards the task goal. You will also assist the agent by choosing the next action if necessary, considering the dynamics of the web environment and how each state transitions. Key Points: 1. Understand the intent: - Identify the user’s goal (e.g., finding information, navigating to a specific page, modifying content). - Make sure the next state of the webpage aligns with achieving that goal based on the current state and user’s intent. 2. Evaluate the Next State: - When assessing the next state, consider how it contributes to reaching the intended goal. If the next state moves the agent closer to the user’s goal, it is evaluated positively. - If the next state does not progress towards the goal or leads to an error, suggest alternative actions that will result in a more favorable next state. 3. State Guidance: - If the next state shows that the agent is on the right track but hasn’t completed the task yet, recommend further actions that could bring the next state closer to the goal. Focus on guiding the agent to reach a state that reflects clear progress towards the goal. 4. Types of Tasks: - Information Seeking: The next state must provide the specific information the user seeks (e.g., product price, reviews). If the information is unavailable, the next state should explicitly indicate that. - Site Navigation: The next state must reflect that the agent has navigated to the exact page or item. Check if the state includes content based on the user’s intent. - Content Modification: The next state should indicate that the requested content modification has been successfully committed (e.g., form submission, comment posting). - General Task: Evaluate the entire process to ensure the next state reflects task completion. Stop actions should only be issued when the objective is met. 5. Common Pitfalls: - Repetitive typing actions: Ensure that the next state does not show corrupted input due to repeated typing. - Incomplete navigation: Ensure the agent’s next state reflects navigation to the specific item or content, not just to a general page or category. Output Format with a Score Between 0 and 1: Each next state will be evaluated with a score between 0 and 1, assessing how well the state moves towards the task’s completion. This score provides nuanced feedback on the state’s effectiveness. 0: The next state is a failure or leads away from the task. Values closer to 0 (e.g., 0.1, 0.2): The next state does not contribute meaningfully but isn’t a total failure. 0.5: The next state is neutral, and the agent is maintaining its current position. Values closer to 1 (e.g., 0.7, 0.8): The next state is helpful and moves the agent closer to the task goal. 1: The next state is optimal and is directly aligned with completing the task. Response Format: 1. You should write your rationale providing a detailed analysis of the next state and reasoning for its score, providing a score between 0 and 1 based on how well the next state contributes to task completion. Output Format: [Rationale] <your thought> [Score] <a value between 0 and 1>

OBJECTIVE: rent a car in Brooklyn - Central, NY on from April 9 to April 15. PREVIOUS ACTION: ["click [1250] where [1250] is 'Car' selected: False", "type [9947] [Brooklyn Central] where [9947] is 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False", "click [19984] where [19984] is 'Brooklyn - Central (New York), US'"] CURRENT OBSERVATION: [30920] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [30940] button ' English - United States$' [30963] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [30979] button 'Menu' [30989] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [30990] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [30993] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [30996] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [30999] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [31002] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [31005] dialog '' modal: False [31045] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [31046] tab 'Book' selected: False [31049] heading 'Book' [31052] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [31055] heading 'Flight status' [31058] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [31061] heading 'Check-in' [31064] tab 'My trips' selected: False [31067] heading 'My trips' [31083] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [31084] tab 'Flight' selected: False [31085] heading 'Flight' [31088] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [31089] heading 'Hotel' [31092] tab 'Car' selected: False [31093] heading 'Car' [31096] tab 'Packages' selected: False [31097] heading 'Packages' [31114] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [31119] checkbox '' checked: false [29987] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [31143] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [31151] checkbox '' checked: false [31159] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [31360] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [29984] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [31561] checkbox '' checked: false [31569] button 'Find cars ' [30022] link 'Showing you the world, working to reduce our impact on it.' [30023] heading 'Showing you the world, working to reduce our impact on it.' [30025] link 'See how' [30037] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [31606] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [30041] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [31630] button 'Continue booking' [31643] heading 'Explore destinations' [31656] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [31665] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [31666] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [31668] option 'One Way' selected: False [31678] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [31696] textbox '' required: False [31702] button 'Search' [31706] link 'Refine search' [31716] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [31725] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [31732] button 'Travel interests' [31746] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [31755] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [31762] link 'Reset filters' [31776] button 'List of search results' [31779] heading 'List of search results' [31789] button ' Save to favorites ' [31790] image ' Save to favorites ' [31794] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [31805] button ' Save to favorites ' [31806] image ' Save to favorites ' [31810] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [31821] button ' Save to favorites ' [31822] image ' Save to favorites ' [31826] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [31837] button ' Save to favorites ' [31838] image ' Save to favorites ' [31842] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [31853] button ' Save to favorites ' [31854] image ' Save to favorites ' [31858] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [31869] button ' Save to favorites ' [31870] image ' Save to favorites ' [31874] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [31885] button ' Save to favorites ' [31886] image ' Save to favorites ' [31890] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [31901] button ' Save to favorites ' [31902] image ' Save to favorites ' [31906] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [31917] button ' Save to favorites ' [31918] image ' Save to favorites ' [31922] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [31933] button ' Save to favorites ' [31934] image ' Save to favorites ' [31938] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [31949] button ' Save to favorites ' [31950] image ' Save to favorites ' [31954] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [31965] button ' Save to favorites ' [31966] image ' Save to favorites ' [31970] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [31981] button ' Save to favorites ' [31982] image ' Save to favorites ' [31986] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [31997] button ' Save to favorites ' [31998] image ' Save to favorites ' [32002] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [32013] button ' Save to favorites ' [32014] image ' Save to favorites ' [32018] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [32029] button ' Save to favorites ' [32030] image ' Save to favorites ' [32034] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [32045] button ' Save to favorites ' [32046] image ' Save to favorites ' [32050] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [32061] button ' Save to favorites ' [32062] image ' Save to favorites ' [32066] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [32078] button "Where I've been" [32081] heading "Where I've been" [32086] heading 'No trips yet' [32097] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [33827] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [33832] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [33837] button 'Tilt map' [33843] button 'Zoom in' [33849] button 'Zoom out' [33854] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [33862] image 'Google' [33872] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [33880] button 'Map Data' [33887] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [33922] heading 'Destinations for you' [33940] link 'Book now' [33956] link 'Book now' [33972] link 'Book now' [33988] link 'Book now' [34002] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [34014] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [34031] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [34048] heading 'Using travel credits' [34063] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [34073] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [34080] heading 'Keeping you safe' [34096] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [34101] heading 'Touchless check-in' [34113] heading 'Our award-winning app' [34137] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [34144] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [34151] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [34164] heading 'Popular topics' [34168] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [34170] button 'Search' [34225] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [34226] tab 'About United' selected: False [34227] heading 'About United' [34229] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [34230] heading 'Products and services' [34232] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [34233] heading 'Popular destinations' [34489] button ' English - United States$' [34502] link 'Espaol' [34553] button ' Search for a topic' [34557] heading 'Stay Connected ' [34603] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [34606] link 'CoBrowse' [34626] textbox '' required: False [34628] button 'Start CoBrowse' [34661] dialog '' modal: False [34665] heading 'Search' [34670] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [34677] button 'Close dialog' [34694] dialog '' modal: False [34698] heading 'Add to favorites' [34712] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [34719] button 'Close dialog' [34730] dialog '' modal: False [34734] heading 'Add to favorites' [34748] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [34755] button 'Close dialog' [30050] button 'Site Feedback' CURRENT ACTION: click [29987] where [29987] is 'Pickup' required: False NEXT STATE PREIDCTION: [41312] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [41332] button ' English - United States$' [41355] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [41371] button 'Menu' [41381] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [41382] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [41385] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [41388] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [41391] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [41394] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [41397] dialog '' modal: False [41438] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [41439] tab 'Book' selected: False [41442] heading 'Book' [41445] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [41448] heading 'Flight status' [41451] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [41454] heading 'Check-in' [41457] tab 'My trips' selected: False [41460] heading 'My trips' [41476] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [41477] tab 'Flight' selected: False [41478] heading 'Flight' [41481] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [41482] heading 'Hotel' [41485] tab 'Car' selected: False [41486] heading 'Car' [41489] tab 'Packages' selected: False [41490] heading 'Packages' [41507] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [41512] checkbox '' checked: false [41529] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [41601] button '1' [41603] button '2' [41605] button '3' [41607] button '4' [41610] button '5' [41612] button '6' [41614] button '7' [41616] button '8' [41618] button '9' [41620] button '10' [41622] button '11' [41625] button '12' [41627] button '13' [41629] button '14' [41631] button '15' [41633] button '16' [41635] button '17' [41637] button '18' [41640] button '19' [41642] button '20' [41644] button '21' [41646] button '22' [41648] button '23' [41650] button '24' [41652] button '25' [41655] button '26' [41657] button '27' [41659] button '28' [41661] button '29' [41663] button '30' [41665] button '31' [41682] button '1' [41685] button '2' [41687] button '3' [41689] button '4' [41691] button '5' [41693] button '6' [41695] button '7' [41697] button '8' [40377] button '9' [41701] button '10' [41703] button '11' [41705] button '12' [41707] button '13' [41709] button '14' [41711] button '15' [41714] button '16' [41716] button '17' [41718] button '18' [41720] button '19' [41722] button '20' [41724] button '21' [41726] button '22' [41729] button '23' [41731] button '24' [41733] button '25' [41735] button '26' [41737] button '27' [41739] button '28' [41741] button '29' [41744] button '30' [41761] button '1' [41763] button '2' [41765] button '3' [41767] button '4' [41769] button '5' [41771] button '6' [41774] button '7' [41776] button '8' [41778] button '9' [41780] button '10' [41782] button '11' [41784] button '12' [41786] button '13' [41789] button '14' [41791] button '15' [41793] button '16' [41795] button '17' [41797] button '18' [41799] button '19' [41801] button '20' [41804] button '21' [41806] button '22' [41808] button '23' [41810] button '24' [41812] button '25' [41814] button '26' [41816] button '27' [41819] button '28' [41821] button '29' [41823] button '30' [41825] button '31' [41842] button '1' [41844] button '2' [41846] button '3' [41849] button '4' [41851] button '5' [41853] button '6' [41855] button '7' [41857] button '8' [41859] button '9' [41861] button '10' [41864] button '11' [41866] button '12' [41868] button '13' [41870] button '14' [41872] button '15' [41874] button '16' [41876] button '17' [41879] button '18' [41881] button '19' [41883] button '20' [41885] button '21' [41887] button '22' [41889] button '23' [41891] button '24' [41894] button '25' [41896] button '26' [41898] button '27' [41900] button '28' [41902] button '29' [41904] button '30' [41914] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [41922] checkbox '' checked: false [41930] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [42131] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [40374] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [42332] checkbox '' checked: false [42340] button 'Find cars ' [40414] link 'Showing you the world, working to reduce our impact on it.' [40415] heading 'Showing you the world, working to reduce our impact on it.' [40417] link 'See how' [40429] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [42377] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [40433] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [42401] button 'Continue booking' [42414] heading 'Explore destinations' [42427] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [42436] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [42437] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [42439] option 'One Way' selected: False [42449] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [42467] textbox '' required: False [42473] button 'Search' [42477] link 'Refine search' [42487] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [42496] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [42503] button 'Travel interests' [42517] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [42526] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [42533] link 'Reset filters' [42547] button 'List of search results' [42550] heading 'List of search results' [42560] button ' Save to favorites ' [42561] image ' Save to favorites ' [42565] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [42576] button ' Save to favorites ' [42577] image ' Save to favorites ' [42581] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [42592] button ' Save to favorites ' [42593] image ' Save to favorites ' [42597] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [42608] button ' Save to favorites ' [42609] image ' Save to favorites ' [42613] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [42624] button ' Save to favorites ' [42625] image ' Save to favorites ' [42629] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [42640] button ' Save to favorites ' [42641] image ' Save to favorites ' [42645] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [42656] button ' Save to favorites ' [42657] image ' Save to favorites ' [42661] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [42672] button ' Save to favorites ' [42673] image ' Save to favorites ' [42677] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [42688] button ' Save to favorites ' [42689] image ' Save to favorites ' [42693] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [42704] button ' Save to favorites ' [42705] image ' Save to favorites ' [42709] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [42720] button ' Save to favorites ' [42721] image ' Save to favorites ' [42725] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [42736] button ' Save to favorites ' [42737] image ' Save to favorites ' [42741] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [42752] button ' Save to favorites ' [42753] image ' Save to favorites ' [42757] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [42768] button ' Save to favorites ' [42769] image ' Save to favorites ' [42773] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [42784] button ' Save to favorites ' [42785] image ' Save to favorites ' [42789] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [42800] button ' Save to favorites ' [42801] image ' Save to favorites ' [42805] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [42816] button ' Save to favorites ' [42817] image ' Save to favorites ' [42821] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [42832] button ' Save to favorites ' [42833] image ' Save to favorites ' [42837] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [42849] button "Where I've been" [42852] heading "Where I've been" [42857] heading 'No trips yet' [42868] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [44598] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [44603] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [44608] button 'Tilt map' [44614] button 'Zoom in' [44620] button 'Zoom out' [44625] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [44633] image 'Google' [44643] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [44651] button 'Map Data' [44658] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [44693] heading 'Destinations for you' [44711] link 'Book now' [44727] link 'Book now' [44743] link 'Book now' [44759] link 'Book now' [44773] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [44785] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [44802] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [44819] heading 'Using travel credits' [44834] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [44844] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [44851] heading 'Keeping you safe' [44867] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [44872] heading 'Touchless check-in' [44884] heading 'Our award-winning app' [44908] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [44915] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [44922] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [44935] heading 'Popular topics' [44939] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [44941] button 'Search' [44996] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [44997] tab 'About United' selected: False [44998] heading 'About United' [45000] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [45001] heading 'Products and services' [45003] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [45004] heading 'Popular destinations' [45260] button ' English - United States$' [45273] link 'Espaol' [45324] button ' Search for a topic' [45328] heading 'Stay Connected ' [45374] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [45377] link 'CoBrowse' [45397] textbox '' required: False [45399] button 'Start CoBrowse' [45432] dialog '' modal: False [45436] heading 'Search' [45441] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [45448] button 'Close dialog' [45465] dialog '' modal: False [45469] heading 'Add to favorites' [45483] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [45490] button 'Close dialog' [45501] dialog '' modal: False [45505] heading 'Add to favorites' [45519] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [45526] button 'Close dialog' [40442] button 'Site Feedback'

[Rationale] In the current observation, the agent has successfully navigated to the car rental section of the website, as indicated by the presence of the "Pickup location*" combobox and the "Find cars" button. However, it appears that the agent has not yet filled in the required fields for the rental, specifically the "Pickup" and "Drop off" locations. The user’s objective is to rent a car from April 9 to April 15 in Brooklyn, which means the next actions should focus on providing this information. While the agent is in the right section and has made progress, the task is not yet completed since the necessary information has not been fully inputted. Therefore, the score of 0.57 reflects a state that is somewhat beneficial but not optimal, as the agent has not yet fulfilled the user’s goal of completing the car rental process. [Score] 0.57

You are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agent effectively complete a given mission on a website based on the user’s intent. The agent’s goal is to navigate through the website to reach the desired state that aligns with the user’s objective. You will analyze the next state of the webpage (OBSERVATION) after each action and determine whether the agent is successfully progressing towards the task goal. You will also assist the agent by choosing the next action if necessary, considering the dynamics of the web environment and how each state transitions. Key Points: 1. Understand the intent: - Identify the user’s goal (e.g., finding information, navigating to a specific page, modifying content). - Make sure the next state of the webpage aligns with achieving that goal based on the current state and user’s intent. 2. Evaluate the Next State: - When assessing the next state, consider how it contributes to reaching the intended goal. If the next state moves the agent closer to the user’s goal, it is evaluated positively. - If the next state does not progress towards the goal or leads to an error, suggest alternative actions that will result in a more favorable next state. 3. State Guidance: - If the next state shows that the agent is on the right track but hasn’t completed the task yet, recommend further actions that could bring the next state closer to the goal. Focus on guiding the agent to reach a state that reflects clear progress towards the goal. 4. Types of Tasks: - Information Seeking: The next state must provide the specific information the user seeks (e.g., product price, reviews). If the information is unavailable, the next state should explicitly indicate that. - Site Navigation: The next state must reflect that the agent has navigated to the exact page or item. Check if the state includes content based on the user’s intent. - Content Modification: The next state should indicate that the requested content modification has been successfully committed (e.g., form submission, comment posting). - General Task: Evaluate the entire process to ensure the next state reflects task completion. Stop actions should only be issued when the objective is met. 5. Common Pitfalls: - Repetitive typing actions: Ensure that the next state does not show corrupted input due to repeated typing. - Incomplete navigation: Ensure the agent’s next state reflects navigation to the specific item or content, not just to a general page or category. Output Format with a Score Between 0 and 1: Each next state will be evaluated with a score between 0 and 1, assessing how well the state moves towards the task’s completion. This score provides nuanced feedback on the state’s effectiveness. 0: The next state is a failure or leads away from the task. Values closer to 0 (e.g., 0.1, 0.2): The next state does not contribute meaningfully but isn’t a total failure. 0.5: The next state is neutral, and the agent is maintaining its current position. Values closer to 1 (e.g., 0.7, 0.8): The next state is helpful and moves the agent closer to the task goal. 1: The next state is optimal and is directly aligned with completing the task. Response Format: 1. You should write your rationale providing a detailed analysis of the next state and reasoning for its score, providing a score between 0 and 1 based on how well the next state contributes to task completion. Output Format: [Rationale] <your thought> [Score] <a value between 0 and 1>

OBJECTIVE: rent a car in Brooklyn - Central, NY on from April 9 to April 15. PREVIOUS ACTION: ["click [1250] where [1250] is 'Car' selected: False", "type [9947] [Brooklyn Central] where [9947] is 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False", "click [19984] where [19984] is 'Brooklyn - Central (New York), US'", "click [29987] where [29987] is 'Pickup' required: False"] CURRENT OBSERVATION: [41312] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [41332] button ' English - United States$' [41355] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [41371] button 'Menu' [41381] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [41382] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [41385] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [41388] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [41391] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [41394] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [41397] dialog '' modal: False [41438] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [41439] tab 'Book' selected: False [41442] heading 'Book' [41445] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [41448] heading 'Flight status' [41451] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [41454] heading 'Check-in' [41457] tab 'My trips' selected: False [41460] heading 'My trips' [41476] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [41477] tab 'Flight' selected: False [41478] heading 'Flight' [41481] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [41482] heading 'Hotel' [41485] tab 'Car' selected: False [41486] heading 'Car' [41489] tab 'Packages' selected: False [41490] heading 'Packages' [41507] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [41512] checkbox '' checked: false [41529] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [41601] button '1' [41603] button '2' [41605] button '3' [41607] button '4' [41610] button '5' [41612] button '6' [41614] button '7' [41616] button '8' [41618] button '9' [41620] button '10' [41622] button '11' [41625] button '12' [41627] button '13' [41629] button '14' [41631] button '15' [41633] button '16' [41635] button '17' [41637] button '18' [41640] button '19' [41642] button '20' [41644] button '21' [41646] button '22' [41648] button '23' [41650] button '24' [41652] button '25' [41655] button '26' [41657] button '27' [41659] button '28' [41661] button '29' [41663] button '30' [41665] button '31' [41682] button '1' [41685] button '2' [41687] button '3' [41689] button '4' [41691] button '5' [41693] button '6' [41695] button '7' [41697] button '8' [40377] button '9' [41701] button '10' [41703] button '11' [41705] button '12' [41707] button '13' [41709] button '14' [41711] button '15' [41714] button '16' [41716] button '17' [41718] button '18' [41720] button '19' [41722] button '20' [41724] button '21' [41726] button '22' [41729] button '23' [41731] button '24' [41733] button '25' [41735] button '26' [41737] button '27' [41739] button '28' [41741] button '29' [41744] button '30' [41761] button '1' [41763] button '2' [41765] button '3' [41767] button '4' [41769] button '5' [41771] button '6' [41774] button '7' [41776] button '8' [41778] button '9' [41780] button '10' [41782] button '11' [41784] button '12' [41786] button '13' [41789] button '14' [41791] button '15' [41793] button '16' [41795] button '17' [41797] button '18' [41799] button '19' [41801] button '20' [41804] button '21' [41806] button '22' [41808] button '23' [41810] button '24' [41812] button '25' [41814] button '26' [41816] button '27' [41819] button '28' [41821] button '29' [41823] button '30' [41825] button '31' [41842] button '1' [41844] button '2' [41846] button '3' [41849] button '4' [41851] button '5' [41853] button '6' [41855] button '7' [41857] button '8' [41859] button '9' [41861] button '10' [41864] button '11' [41866] button '12' [41868] button '13' [41870] button '14' [41872] button '15' [41874] button '16' [41876] button '17' [41879] button '18' [41881] button '19' [41883] button '20' [41885] button '21' [41887] button '22' [41889] button '23' [41891] button '24' [41894] button '25' [41896] button '26' [41898] button '27' [41900] button '28' [41902] button '29' [41904] button '30' [41914] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [41922] checkbox '' checked: false [41930] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [42131] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [40374] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [42332] checkbox '' checked: false [42340] button 'Find cars ' [40414] link 'Showing you the world, working to reduce our impact on it.' [40415] heading 'Showing you the world, working to reduce our impact on it.' [40417] link 'See how' [40429] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [42377] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [40433] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [42401] button 'Continue booking' [42414] heading 'Explore destinations' [42427] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [42436] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [42437] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [42439] option 'One Way' selected: False [42449] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [42467] textbox '' required: False [42473] button 'Search' [42477] link 'Refine search' [42487] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [42496] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [42503] button 'Travel interests' [42517] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [42526] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [42533] link 'Reset filters' [42547] button 'List of search results' [42550] heading 'List of search results' [42560] button ' Save to favorites ' [42561] image ' Save to favorites ' [42565] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [42576] button ' Save to favorites ' [42577] image ' Save to favorites ' [42581] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [42592] button ' Save to favorites ' [42593] image ' Save to favorites ' [42597] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [42608] button ' Save to favorites ' [42609] image ' Save to favorites ' [42613] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [42624] button ' Save to favorites ' [42625] image ' Save to favorites ' [42629] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [42640] button ' Save to favorites ' [42641] image ' Save to favorites ' [42645] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [42656] button ' Save to favorites ' [42657] image ' Save to favorites ' [42661] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [42672] button ' Save to favorites ' [42673] image ' Save to favorites ' [42677] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [42688] button ' Save to favorites ' [42689] image ' Save to favorites ' [42693] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [42704] button ' Save to favorites ' [42705] image ' Save to favorites ' [42709] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [42720] button ' Save to favorites ' [42721] image ' Save to favorites ' [42725] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [42736] button ' Save to favorites ' [42737] image ' Save to favorites ' [42741] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [42752] button ' Save to favorites ' [42753] image ' Save to favorites ' [42757] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [42768] button ' Save to favorites ' [42769] image ' Save to favorites ' [42773] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [42784] button ' Save to favorites ' [42785] image ' Save to favorites ' [42789] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [42800] button ' Save to favorites ' [42801] image ' Save to favorites ' [42805] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [42816] button ' Save to favorites ' [42817] image ' Save to favorites ' [42821] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [42832] button ' Save to favorites ' [42833] image ' Save to favorites ' [42837] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [42849] button "Where I've been" [42852] heading "Where I've been" [42857] heading 'No trips yet' [42868] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [44598] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [44603] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [44608] button 'Tilt map' [44614] button 'Zoom in' [44620] button 'Zoom out' [44625] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [44633] image 'Google' [44643] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [44651] button 'Map Data' [44658] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [44693] heading 'Destinations for you' [44711] link 'Book now' [44727] link 'Book now' [44743] link 'Book now' [44759] link 'Book now' [44773] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [44785] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [44802] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [44819] heading 'Using travel credits' [44834] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [44844] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [44851] heading 'Keeping you safe' [44867] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [44872] heading 'Touchless check-in' [44884] heading 'Our award-winning app' [44908] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [44915] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [44922] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [44935] heading 'Popular topics' [44939] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [44941] button 'Search' [44996] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [44997] tab 'About United' selected: False [44998] heading 'About United' [45000] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [45001] heading 'Products and services' [45003] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [45004] heading 'Popular destinations' [45260] button ' English - United States$' [45273] link 'Espaol' [45324] button ' Search for a topic' [45328] heading 'Stay Connected ' [45374] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [45377] link 'CoBrowse' [45397] textbox '' required: False [45399] button 'Start CoBrowse' [45432] dialog '' modal: False [45436] heading 'Search' [45441] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [45448] button 'Close dialog' [45465] dialog '' modal: False [45469] heading 'Add to favorites' [45483] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [45490] button 'Close dialog' [45501] dialog '' modal: False [45505] heading 'Add to favorites' [45519] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [45526] button 'Close dialog' [40442] button 'Site Feedback' CURRENT ACTION: click [40377] where [40377] is '9' NEXT STATE PREIDCTION: [52105] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [52125] button ' English - United States$' [52148] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [52164] button 'Menu' [52174] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [52175] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [52178] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [52181] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [52184] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [52187] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [52190] dialog '' modal: False [52231] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [52232] tab 'Book' selected: False [52235] heading 'Book' [52238] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [52241] heading 'Flight status' [52244] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [52247] heading 'Check-in' [52250] tab 'My trips' selected: False [52253] heading 'My trips' [52269] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [52270] tab 'Flight' selected: False [52271] heading 'Flight' [52274] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [52275] heading 'Hotel' [52278] tab 'Car' selected: False [52279] heading 'Car' [52282] tab 'Packages' selected: False [52283] heading 'Packages' [52300] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [52305] checkbox '' checked: false [52322] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [52392] button '1' [52394] button '2' [52396] button '3' [52398] button '4' [52401] button '5' [52403] button '6' [52405] button '7' [52407] button '8' [52409] button '9' [52411] button '10' [52413] button '11' [52416] button '12' [52418] button '13' [52420] button '14' [52422] button '15' [52424] button '16' [52426] button '17' [52428] button '18' [52431] button '19' [52433] button '20' [52435] button '21' [52437] button '22' [52439] button '23' [52441] button '24' [52443] button '25' [52446] button '26' [52448] button '27' [52450] button '28' [52452] button '29' [52454] button '30' [52456] button '31' [52473] button '1' [52476] button '2' [52478] button '3' [52480] button '4' [52482] button '5' [52484] button '6' [52486] button '7' [52488] button '8' [52491] button '9' [52493] button '10' [52495] button '11' [52497] button '12' [52499] button '13' [52501] button '14' [51171] button '15' [52505] button '16' [52507] button '17' [52509] button '18' [52511] button '19' [52513] button '20' [52515] button '21' [52517] button '22' [52520] button '23' [52522] button '24' [52524] button '25' [52526] button '26' [52528] button '27' [52530] button '28' [52532] button '29' [52535] button '30' [52552] button '1' [52554] button '2' [52556] button '3' [52558] button '4' [52560] button '5' [52562] button '6' [52565] button '7' [52567] button '8' [52569] button '9' [52571] button '10' [52573] button '11' [52575] button '12' [52577] button '13' [52580] button '14' [52582] button '15' [52584] button '16' [52586] button '17' [52588] button '18' [52590] button '19' [52592] button '20' [52595] button '21' [52597] button '22' [52599] button '23' [52601] button '24' [52603] button '25' [52605] button '26' [52607] button '27' [52610] button '28' [52612] button '29' [52614] button '30' [52616] button '31' [52633] button '1' [52635] button '2' [52637] button '3' [52640] button '4' [52642] button '5' [52644] button '6' [52646] button '7' [52648] button '8' [52650] button '9' [52652] button '10' [52655] button '11' [52657] button '12' [52659] button '13' [52661] button '14' [52663] button '15' [52665] button '16' [52667] button '17' [52670] button '18' [52672] button '19' [52674] button '20' [52676] button '21' [52678] button '22' [52680] button '23' [52682] button '24' [52685] button '25' [52687] button '26' [52689] button '27' [52691] button '28' [52693] button '29' [52695] button '30' [52705] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [52715] checkbox '' checked: false [52723] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [52924] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [51168] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [53125] checkbox '' checked: false [53133] button 'Find cars ' [51207] link 'Explore Japan for as low as $825 roundtrip.' [51208] heading 'Explore Japan for as low as $825 roundtrip.' [51210] link 'Book now' [51222] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [53170] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [51226] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [53194] button 'Continue booking' [53207] heading 'Explore destinations' [53220] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [53229] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [53230] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [53232] option 'One Way' selected: False [53242] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [53260] textbox '' required: False [53266] button 'Search' [53270] link 'Refine search' [53280] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [53289] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [53296] button 'Travel interests' [53310] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [53319] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [53326] link 'Reset filters' [53340] button 'List of search results' [53343] heading 'List of search results' [53353] button ' Save to favorites ' [53354] image ' Save to favorites ' [53358] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [53369] button ' Save to favorites ' [53370] image ' Save to favorites ' [53374] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [53385] button ' Save to favorites ' [53386] image ' Save to favorites ' [53390] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [53401] button ' Save to favorites ' [53402] image ' Save to favorites ' [53406] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [53417] button ' Save to favorites ' [53418] image ' Save to favorites ' [53422] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [53433] button ' Save to favorites ' [53434] image ' Save to favorites ' [53438] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [53449] button ' Save to favorites ' [53450] image ' Save to favorites ' [53454] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [53465] button ' Save to favorites ' [53466] image ' Save to favorites ' [53470] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [53481] button ' Save to favorites ' [53482] image ' Save to favorites ' [53486] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [53497] button ' Save to favorites ' [53498] image ' Save to favorites ' [53502] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [53513] button ' Save to favorites ' [53514] image ' Save to favorites ' [53518] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [53529] button ' Save to favorites ' [53530] image ' Save to favorites ' [53534] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [53545] button ' Save to favorites ' [53546] image ' Save to favorites ' [53550] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [53561] button ' Save to favorites ' [53562] image ' Save to favorites ' [53566] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [53577] button ' Save to favorites ' [53578] image ' Save to favorites ' [53582] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [53593] button ' Save to favorites ' [53594] image ' Save to favorites ' [53598] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [53609] button ' Save to favorites ' [53610] image ' Save to favorites ' [53614] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [53625] button ' Save to favorites ' [53626] image ' Save to favorites ' [53630] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [53642] button "Where I've been" [53645] heading "Where I've been" [53650] heading 'No trips yet' [53661] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [55391] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [55396] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [55401] button 'Tilt map' [55407] button 'Zoom in' [55413] button 'Zoom out' [55418] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [55426] image 'Google' [55436] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [55444] button 'Map Data' [55451] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [55486] heading 'Destinations for you' [55504] link 'Book now' [55520] link 'Book now' [55536] link 'Book now' [55552] link 'Book now' [55566] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [55578] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [55595] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [55612] heading 'Using travel credits' [55627] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [55637] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [55644] heading 'Keeping you safe' [55660] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [55665] heading 'Touchless check-in' [55677] heading 'Our award-winning app' [55701] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [55708] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [55715] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [55728] heading 'Popular topics' [55732] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [55734] button 'Search' [55789] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [55790] tab 'About United' selected: False [55791] heading 'About United' [55793] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [55794] heading 'Products and services' [55796] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [55797] heading 'Popular destinations' [56053] button ' English - United States$' [56066] link 'Espaol' [56117] button ' Search for a topic' [56121] heading 'Stay Connected ' [56167] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [56170] link 'CoBrowse' [56190] textbox '' required: False [56192] button 'Start CoBrowse' [56225] dialog '' modal: False [56229] heading 'Search' [56234] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [56241] button 'Close dialog' [56258] dialog '' modal: False [56262] heading 'Add to favorites' [56276] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [56283] button 'Close dialog' [56294] dialog '' modal: False [56298] heading 'Add to favorites' [56312] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [56319] button 'Close dialog' [51235] button 'Site Feedback'

[Rationale] In the previous state, the user was in the process of selecting a pickup date for their car rental in Brooklyn. The action taken was to click on the button representing the date '9', which corresponds to the desired pickup date of April 9. The next state, after this action, retains the overall structure of the booking form, indicating that the car rental section remains active and that the user is still engaged with the booking process. This is a positive step as it indicates continuity towards completing the rental process. However, while the action does select the correct date, the next state does not indicate that the subsequent critical fields (like 'Drop off' date) have been addressed yet, which are necessary for completing the car rental booking. The presence of the 'Find cars' button suggests that the next logical action would be to interact with it after entering the drop-off date to proceed with the search for available cars. The score of 0.71 reflects that while progress has been made with the selection of the pickup date, the overall task of renting a car is still incomplete as further actions are required to finalize the booking. Therefore, a moderate score indicates that the agent is on the right track but still has work ahead to reach the task goal fully. [Score] 0.71

You are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agent effectively complete a given mission on a website based on the user’s intent. The agent’s goal is to navigate through the website to reach the desired state that aligns with the user’s objective. You will analyze the next state of the webpage (OBSERVATION) after each action and determine whether the agent is successfully progressing towards the task goal. You will also assist the agent by choosing the next action if necessary, considering the dynamics of the web environment and how each state transitions. Key Points: 1. Understand the intent: - Identify the user’s goal (e.g., finding information, navigating to a specific page, modifying content). - Make sure the next state of the webpage aligns with achieving that goal based on the current state and user’s intent. 2. Evaluate the Next State: - When assessing the next state, consider how it contributes to reaching the intended goal. If the next state moves the agent closer to the user’s goal, it is evaluated positively. - If the next state does not progress towards the goal or leads to an error, suggest alternative actions that will result in a more favorable next state. 3. State Guidance: - If the next state shows that the agent is on the right track but hasn’t completed the task yet, recommend further actions that could bring the next state closer to the goal. Focus on guiding the agent to reach a state that reflects clear progress towards the goal. 4. Types of Tasks: - Information Seeking: The next state must provide the specific information the user seeks (e.g., product price, reviews). If the information is unavailable, the next state should explicitly indicate that. - Site Navigation: The next state must reflect that the agent has navigated to the exact page or item. Check if the state includes content based on the user’s intent. - Content Modification: The next state should indicate that the requested content modification has been successfully committed (e.g., form submission, comment posting). - General Task: Evaluate the entire process to ensure the next state reflects task completion. Stop actions should only be issued when the objective is met. 5. Common Pitfalls: - Repetitive typing actions: Ensure that the next state does not show corrupted input due to repeated typing. - Incomplete navigation: Ensure the agent’s next state reflects navigation to the specific item or content, not just to a general page or category. Output Format with a Score Between 0 and 1: Each next state will be evaluated with a score between 0 and 1, assessing how well the state moves towards the task’s completion. This score provides nuanced feedback on the state’s effectiveness. 0: The next state is a failure or leads away from the task. Values closer to 0 (e.g., 0.1, 0.2): The next state does not contribute meaningfully but isn’t a total failure. 0.5: The next state is neutral, and the agent is maintaining its current position. Values closer to 1 (e.g., 0.7, 0.8): The next state is helpful and moves the agent closer to the task goal. 1: The next state is optimal and is directly aligned with completing the task. Response Format: 1. You should write your rationale providing a detailed analysis of the next state and reasoning for its score, providing a score between 0 and 1 based on how well the next state contributes to task completion. Output Format: [Rationale] <your thought> [Score] <a value between 0 and 1>

OBJECTIVE: rent a car in Brooklyn - Central, NY on from April 9 to April 15. PREVIOUS ACTION: ["click [1250] where [1250] is 'Car' selected: False", "type [9947] [Brooklyn Central] where [9947] is 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False", "click [19984] where [19984] is 'Brooklyn - Central (New York), US'", "click [29987] where [29987] is 'Pickup' required: False", "click [40377] where [40377] is '9'"] CURRENT OBSERVATION: [52105] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [52125] button ' English - United States$' [52148] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [52164] button 'Menu' [52174] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [52175] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [52178] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [52181] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [52184] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [52187] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [52190] dialog '' modal: False [52231] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [52232] tab 'Book' selected: False [52235] heading 'Book' [52238] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [52241] heading 'Flight status' [52244] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [52247] heading 'Check-in' [52250] tab 'My trips' selected: False [52253] heading 'My trips' [52269] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [52270] tab 'Flight' selected: False [52271] heading 'Flight' [52274] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [52275] heading 'Hotel' [52278] tab 'Car' selected: False [52279] heading 'Car' [52282] tab 'Packages' selected: False [52283] heading 'Packages' [52300] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [52305] checkbox '' checked: false [52322] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [52392] button '1' [52394] button '2' [52396] button '3' [52398] button '4' [52401] button '5' [52403] button '6' [52405] button '7' [52407] button '8' [52409] button '9' [52411] button '10' [52413] button '11' [52416] button '12' [52418] button '13' [52420] button '14' [52422] button '15' [52424] button '16' [52426] button '17' [52428] button '18' [52431] button '19' [52433] button '20' [52435] button '21' [52437] button '22' [52439] button '23' [52441] button '24' [52443] button '25' [52446] button '26' [52448] button '27' [52450] button '28' [52452] button '29' [52454] button '30' [52456] button '31' [52473] button '1' [52476] button '2' [52478] button '3' [52480] button '4' [52482] button '5' [52484] button '6' [52486] button '7' [52488] button '8' [52491] button '9' [52493] button '10' [52495] button '11' [52497] button '12' [52499] button '13' [52501] button '14' [51171] button '15' [52505] button '16' [52507] button '17' [52509] button '18' [52511] button '19' [52513] button '20' [52515] button '21' [52517] button '22' [52520] button '23' [52522] button '24' [52524] button '25' [52526] button '26' [52528] button '27' [52530] button '28' [52532] button '29' [52535] button '30' [52552] button '1' [52554] button '2' [52556] button '3' [52558] button '4' [52560] button '5' [52562] button '6' [52565] button '7' [52567] button '8' [52569] button '9' [52571] button '10' [52573] button '11' [52575] button '12' [52577] button '13' [52580] button '14' [52582] button '15' [52584] button '16' [52586] button '17' [52588] button '18' [52590] button '19' [52592] button '20' [52595] button '21' [52597] button '22' [52599] button '23' [52601] button '24' [52603] button '25' [52605] button '26' [52607] button '27' [52610] button '28' [52612] button '29' [52614] button '30' [52616] button '31' [52633] button '1' [52635] button '2' [52637] button '3' [52640] button '4' [52642] button '5' [52644] button '6' [52646] button '7' [52648] button '8' [52650] button '9' [52652] button '10' [52655] button '11' [52657] button '12' [52659] button '13' [52661] button '14' [52663] button '15' [52665] button '16' [52667] button '17' [52670] button '18' [52672] button '19' [52674] button '20' [52676] button '21' [52678] button '22' [52680] button '23' [52682] button '24' [52685] button '25' [52687] button '26' [52689] button '27' [52691] button '28' [52693] button '29' [52695] button '30' [52705] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [52715] checkbox '' checked: false [52723] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [52924] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [51168] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [53125] checkbox '' checked: false [53133] button 'Find cars ' [51207] link 'Explore Japan for as low as $825 roundtrip.' [51208] heading 'Explore Japan for as low as $825 roundtrip.' [51210] link 'Book now' [51222] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [53170] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [51226] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [53194] button 'Continue booking' [53207] heading 'Explore destinations' [53220] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [53229] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [53230] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [53232] option 'One Way' selected: False [53242] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [53260] textbox '' required: False [53266] button 'Search' [53270] link 'Refine search' [53280] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [53289] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [53296] button 'Travel interests' [53310] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [53319] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [53326] link 'Reset filters' [53340] button 'List of search results' [53343] heading 'List of search results' [53353] button ' Save to favorites ' [53354] image ' Save to favorites ' [53358] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [53369] button ' Save to favorites ' [53370] image ' Save to favorites ' [53374] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [53385] button ' Save to favorites ' [53386] image ' Save to favorites ' [53390] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [53401] button ' Save to favorites ' [53402] image ' Save to favorites ' [53406] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [53417] button ' Save to favorites ' [53418] image ' Save to favorites ' [53422] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [53433] button ' Save to favorites ' [53434] image ' Save to favorites ' [53438] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [53449] button ' Save to favorites ' [53450] image ' Save to favorites ' [53454] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [53465] button ' Save to favorites ' [53466] image ' Save to favorites ' [53470] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [53481] button ' Save to favorites ' [53482] image ' Save to favorites ' [53486] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [53497] button ' Save to favorites ' [53498] image ' Save to favorites ' [53502] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [53513] button ' Save to favorites ' [53514] image ' Save to favorites ' [53518] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [53529] button ' Save to favorites ' [53530] image ' Save to favorites ' [53534] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [53545] button ' Save to favorites ' [53546] image ' Save to favorites ' [53550] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [53561] button ' Save to favorites ' [53562] image ' Save to favorites ' [53566] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [53577] button ' Save to favorites ' [53578] image ' Save to favorites ' [53582] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [53593] button ' Save to favorites ' [53594] image ' Save to favorites ' [53598] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [53609] button ' Save to favorites ' [53610] image ' Save to favorites ' [53614] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [53625] button ' Save to favorites ' [53626] image ' Save to favorites ' [53630] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [53642] button "Where I've been" [53645] heading "Where I've been" [53650] heading 'No trips yet' [53661] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [55391] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [55396] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [55401] button 'Tilt map' [55407] button 'Zoom in' [55413] button 'Zoom out' [55418] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [55426] image 'Google' [55436] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [55444] button 'Map Data' [55451] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [55486] heading 'Destinations for you' [55504] link 'Book now' [55520] link 'Book now' [55536] link 'Book now' [55552] link 'Book now' [55566] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [55578] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [55595] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [55612] heading 'Using travel credits' [55627] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [55637] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [55644] heading 'Keeping you safe' [55660] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [55665] heading 'Touchless check-in' [55677] heading 'Our award-winning app' [55701] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [55708] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [55715] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [55728] heading 'Popular topics' [55732] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [55734] button 'Search' [55789] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [55790] tab 'About United' selected: False [55791] heading 'About United' [55793] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [55794] heading 'Products and services' [55796] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [55797] heading 'Popular destinations' [56053] button ' English - United States$' [56066] link 'Espaol' [56117] button ' Search for a topic' [56121] heading 'Stay Connected ' [56167] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [56170] link 'CoBrowse' [56190] textbox '' required: False [56192] button 'Start CoBrowse' [56225] dialog '' modal: False [56229] heading 'Search' [56234] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [56241] button 'Close dialog' [56258] dialog '' modal: False [56262] heading 'Add to favorites' [56276] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [56283] button 'Close dialog' [56294] dialog '' modal: False [56298] heading 'Add to favorites' [56312] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [56319] button 'Close dialog' [51235] button 'Site Feedback' CURRENT ACTION: click [51171] where [51171] is '15' NEXT STATE PREIDCTION: [62499] heading 'Welcome to United.com' [62519] button ' English - United States$' [62542] button 'Hi, James0 miles' [62558] button 'Menu' [62568] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [62569] tab 'BOOK' selected: False [62572] tab 'MY TRIPS' selected: False [62575] tab 'TRAVEL INFO' selected: False [62578] tab 'MILEAGEPLUS PROGRAM' selected: False [62581] tab 'DEALS' selected: False [62584] dialog '' modal: False [62624] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [62625] tab 'Book' selected: False [62628] heading 'Book' [62631] tab 'Flight status' selected: False [62634] heading 'Flight status' [62637] tab 'Check-in' selected: False [62640] heading 'Check-in' [62643] tab 'My trips' selected: False [62646] heading 'My trips' [62662] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [62663] tab 'Flight' selected: False [62664] heading 'Flight' [62667] tab 'Hotel' selected: False [62668] heading 'Hotel' [62671] tab 'Car' selected: False [62672] heading 'Car' [62675] tab 'Packages' selected: False [62676] heading 'Packages' [62693] combobox 'Pickup location*' hasPopup: listbox required: False [62698] checkbox '' checked: false [62715] textbox 'Pickup' required: False [62723] textbox 'Drop off' required: False [62731] checkbox '' checked: false [62739] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [62940] combobox '' hasPopup: listbox required: False [61566] image 'Avis Budget car rental' [63141] checkbox '' checked: false [61569] button 'Find cars ' [61601] link 'Explore Japan for as low as $825 roundtrip.' [61602] heading 'Explore Japan for as low as $825 roundtrip.' [61604] link 'Book now' [61616] link 'Advertisement by United: Advertisement: Offers up to 80,000 bonus miles with a United MileagePlus Card.' [63185] heading 'Pick up where you left off' [61620] heading 'Phoenix to Miami' [63209] button 'Continue booking' [63222] heading 'Explore destinations' [63235] combobox 'Flying from' hasPopup: listbox required: False [63244] combobox '' hasPopup: menu expanded: False [63245] option 'Roundtrip' selected: True [63247] option 'One Way' selected: False [63257] button 'Flexible dates Use the arrow keys to navigate between days and weeks. Use page up, page down to move between months and years. Press enter to select the date, and escape to close the calendar.' [63275] textbox '' required: False [63281] button 'Search' [63285] link 'Refine search' [63295] checkbox 'Book with miles' checked: false [63304] checkbox 'Non-stop' checked: false [63311] button 'Travel interests' [63325] checkbox 'United airports' checked: false [63334] checkbox "Where I've been" checked: false [63341] link 'Reset filters' [63355] button 'List of search results' [63358] heading 'List of search results' [63368] button ' Save to favorites ' [63369] image ' Save to favorites ' [63373] link 'Los Angeles, CA, US (LAX) Fri, Apr 28 - Mon, May 1 from $148 ' [63384] button ' Save to favorites ' [63385] image ' Save to favorites ' [63389] link 'San Francisco, CA, US (SFO) Tue, Apr 18 - Sat, Apr 22 from $148 ' [63400] button ' Save to favorites ' [63401] image ' Save to favorites ' [63405] link 'Denver, CO, US (DEN) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $158 ' [63416] button ' Save to favorites ' [63417] image ' Save to favorites ' [63421] link 'Las Vegas, NV, US (LAS) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [63432] button ' Save to favorites ' [63433] image ' Save to favorites ' [63437] link 'San Diego, CA, US (SAN) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $177 ' [63448] button ' Save to favorites ' [63449] image ' Save to favorites ' [63453] link 'Chicago, IL, US (ORD) Fri, Apr 28 - Sun, Apr 30 from $198 ' [63464] button ' Save to favorites ' [63465] image ' Save to favorites ' [63469] link 'Dallas/Fort Worth, TX, US (DFW) Sat, Apr 29 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [63480] button ' Save to favorites ' [63481] image ' Save to favorites ' [63485] link 'Seattle, WA, US (SEA) Wed, Apr 19 - Mon, Apr 24 from $217 ' [63496] button ' Save to favorites ' [63497] image ' Save to favorites ' [63501] link 'Tampa, FL, US (TPA) Fri, Apr 28 - Tue, May 2 from $217 ' [63512] button ' Save to favorites ' [63513] image ' Save to favorites ' [63517] link 'Atlanta, GA, US (ATL) Sat, Apr 22 - Tue, Apr 25 from $222 ' [63528] button ' Save to favorites ' [63529] image ' Save to favorites ' [63533] link 'Orlando, FL, US (MCO) Sat, Apr 22 - Sat, Apr 29 from $227 ' [63544] button ' Save to favorites ' [63545] image ' Save to favorites ' [63549] link 'New Orleans, LA, US (MSY) Fri, Apr 21 - Mon, Apr 24 from $245 ' [63560] button ' Save to favorites ' [63561] image ' Save to favorites ' [63565] link 'Miami, FL, US (MIA) Tue, Apr 25 - Tue, May 2 from $247 ' [63576] button ' Save to favorites ' [63577] image ' Save to favorites ' [63581] link 'Fort Lauderdale, FL, US (FLL) Wed, May 3 - Wed, May 10 from $256 ' [63592] button ' Save to favorites ' [63593] image ' Save to favorites ' [63597] link 'Toronto, ON, CA (YYZ) Sat, Apr 8 - Tue, Apr 11 from $270 ' [63608] button ' Save to favorites ' [63609] image ' Save to favorites ' [63613] link 'Boston, MA, US (BOS) Mon, May 1 - Wed, May 3 from $317 ' [63624] button ' Save to favorites ' [63625] image ' Save to favorites ' [63629] link 'Cancun, MX (CUN) Sun, Apr 30 - Tue, May 2 from $486 ' [63640] button ' Save to favorites ' [63641] image ' Save to favorites ' [63645] link 'San Jose, CA, US (SJC) Tue, May 2 - Thu, May 4 from $875 ' [63657] button "Where I've been" [63660] heading "Where I've been" [63665] heading 'No trips yet' [63676] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [65406] button 'Rotate map clockwise' [65411] button 'Rotate map counterclockwise' [65416] button 'Tilt map' [65422] button 'Zoom in' [65428] button 'Zoom out' [65433] button 'Toggle fullscreen view' [65441] image 'Google' [65451] button 'Keyboard shortcuts' [65459] button 'Map Data' [65466] button '500 km Click to toggle between metric and imperial units' [65501] heading 'Destinations for you' [65519] link 'Book now' [65535] link 'Book now' [65551] link 'Book now' [65567] link 'Book now' [65581] heading 'Trip planning made easier' [65593] heading 'COVID-19 requirements' [65610] heading 'Travel-Ready Center' [65627] heading 'Using travel credits' [65642] heading 'What to expect when you fly' [65652] image 'United CleanPlus | Clorox ' [65659] heading 'Keeping you safe' [65675] heading 'Changing the way you travel' [65680] heading 'Touchless check-in' [65692] heading 'Our award-winning app' [65716] link 'Advertisement by United: Get more with Avis and Budget. Save up to 35% off base rates and earn up to 1,250 miles per rental. Plus, rent bu 04/15 to earn up to 1,000 more miles.' [65723] link 'Advertisement by United: Plan your next adventure. Reveal your exclusive offer when you buy miles by April 28th.' [65730] link 'Advertisement by United: Soar above the rest. Earn 2x miles on IHG hotels and resorts stays. Offer ends 4/30.' [65743] heading 'Popular topics' [65747] combobox 'Search United' hasPopup: listbox required: False [65749] button 'Search' [65804] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [65805] tab 'About United' selected: False [65806] heading 'About United' [65808] tab 'Products and services' selected: False [65809] heading 'Products and services' [65811] tab 'Popular destinations' selected: False [65812] heading 'Popular destinations' [66068] button ' English - United States$' [66081] link 'Espaol' [66132] button ' Search for a topic' [66136] heading 'Stay Connected ' [66182] image 'United is a proud member of Star Alliance' [66185] link 'CoBrowse' [66205] textbox '' required: False [66207] button 'Start CoBrowse' [66240] dialog '' modal: False [66244] heading 'Search' [66249] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [66256] button 'Close dialog' [66273] dialog '' modal: False [66277] heading 'Add to favorites' [66291] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [66298] button 'Close dialog' [66309] dialog '' modal: False [66313] heading 'Add to favorites' [66327] link 'Backto content outside of dialog' [66334] button 'Close dialog' [61629] button 'Site Feedback'

[Rationale] The next state reflects a significant step towards the user's objective of renting a car in Brooklyn from April 9 to April 15. The agent is currently on the car rental section of the website, as indicated by the presence of the "Car" tab and the relevant input fields for pickup location and dates. By clicking on the button for the 15th, the user is likely selecting the drop-off date, which is a crucial part of the car rental process. While the state does not yet display the results or confirmation of the rental, it shows that the agent has correctly navigated to the point where they can finalize the selection of dates and proceed to find available cars. This progress aligns closely with the user’s goal and indicates that the agent is on the right track. The interface is responsive, and the next logical steps would involve confirming the drop-off date and then clicking the 'Find cars' button to display available rental options. Given the substantial alignment with the user’s intent and the clear progression towards completing the task, the score of 0.86 is justified. This reflects a strong positive movement towards the goal, though it stops short of task completion as the agent has not yet received the available car options. [Score] 0.86

You are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agent effectively complete a given mission on a website based on the user’s intent. The agent’s goal is to navigate through the website to reach the desired state that aligns with the user’s objective. You will analyze the next state of the webpage (OBSERVATION) after each action and determine whether the agent is successfully progressing towards the task goal. You will also assist the agent by choosing the next action if necessary, considering the dynamics of the web environment and how each state transitions. Key Points: 1. Understand the intent: - Identify the user’s goal (e.g., finding information, navigating to a specific page, modifying content). - Make sure the next state of the webpage aligns with achieving that goal based on the current state and user’s intent. 2. Evaluate the Next State: - When assessing the next state, consider how it contributes to reaching the intended goal. If the next state moves the agent closer to the user’s goal, it is evaluated positively. - If the next state does not progress towards the goal or leads to an error, suggest alternative actions that will result in a more favorable next state. 3. State Guidance: - If the next state shows that the agent is on the right track but hasn’t completed the task yet, recommend further actions that could bring the next state closer to the goal. Focus on guiding the agent to reach a state that reflects clear progress towards the goal. 4. Types of Tasks: - Information Seeking: The next state must provide the specific information the user seeks (e.g., product price, reviews). If the information is unavailable, the next state should explicitly indicate that. - Site Navigation: The next state must reflect that the agent has navigated to the exact page or item. Check if the state includes content based on the user’s intent. - Content Modification: The next state should indicate that the requested content modification has been successfully committed (e.g., form submission, comment posting). - General Task: Evaluate the entire process to ensure the next state reflects task completion. Stop actions should only be issued when the objective is met. 5. Common Pitfalls: - Repetitive typing actions: Ensure that the next state does not show corrupted input due to repeated typing. - Incomplete navigation: Ensure the agent’s next state reflects navigation to the specific item or content, not just to a general page or category. Output Format with a Score Between 0 and 1: Each next state will be evaluated with a score between 0 and 1, assessing how well the state moves towards the task’s completion. This score provides nuanced feedback on the state’s effectiveness. 0: The next state is a failure or leads away from the task. Values closer to 0 (e.g., 0.1, 0.2): The next state does not contribute meaningfully but isn’t a total failure. 0.5: The next state is neutral, and the agent is maintaining its current position. Values closer to 1 (e.g., 0.7, 0.8): The next state is helpful and moves the agent closer to the task goal. 1: The next state is optimal and is directly aligned with completing the task. Response Format: 1. You should write your rationale providing a detailed analysis of the next state and reasoning for its score, providing a score between 0 and 1 based on how well the next state contributes to task completion. Output Format: [Rationale] <your thought> [Score] <a value between 0 and 1>

OBJECTIVE: Show computer game reviews sorted by score. PREVIOUS ACTION: [] CURRENT OBSERVATION: [365] button 'Focus Reset' [367] button 'Toggle Sidebar' [376] image ' IGN Logo ' [159] StaticText 'Home' [395] button 'Search' [402] button 'Reviews' [409] button 'News' [213] StaticText 'Guides' [424] button 'Discover' [240] StaticText 'Store' [251] StaticText 'Rewards' [444] button 'Videos' [454] button 'More' [295] StaticText 'Playlist' [469] button 'Add to Library' [316] StaticText 'Browse Playlist' [485] status 'Backlog' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text [489] status 'Playing' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text [492] status 'Paused' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text [495] status 'Beat' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text [498] status 'Quit' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text [353] StaticText 'Register for free or log in to build your IGN game library.' [359] StaticText 'Browse Playlist' [508] button 'More' [513] heading 'Site Themes' [517] radio 'Classic' checked: false [529] radio 'Dark Mode' checked: false [541] radio 'Automatic Based on system preferences' checked: false [551] button 'More' [556] heading 'Change Region' [463] StaticText 'Africa (opens in a new window)' [472] StaticText 'Adria' [481] StaticText 'Australia (opens in a new window)' [490] StaticText 'Benelux (opens in a new window)' [499] StaticText 'Brazil (opens in a new window)' [508] StaticText 'Canada (opens in a new window)' [517] StaticText 'China (opens in a new window)' [526] StaticText 'Czech / Slovakia (opens in a new window)' [535] StaticText 'France (opens in a new window)' [544] StaticText 'Germany (opens in a new window)' [553] StaticText 'Greece (opens in a new window)' [562] StaticText 'Hungary (opens in a new window)' [571] StaticText 'India (opens in a new window)' [580] StaticText 'Ireland (opens in a new window)' [589] StaticText 'Israel (opens in a new window)' [598] StaticText 'Italy (opens in a new window)' [607] StaticText 'Japan (opens in a new window)' [616] StaticText 'Latin America' [625] StaticText 'Middle East - English' [634] StaticText 'Middle East - Arabic' [643] StaticText 'Nordic' [652] StaticText 'Pakistan (opens in a new window)' [661] StaticText 'Poland (opens in a new window)' [670] StaticText 'Portugal (opens in a new window)' [679] StaticText 'Romania (opens in a new window)' [688] StaticText 'Southeast Asia' [697] StaticText 'Spain (opens in a new window)' [706] StaticText 'Turkey (opens in a new window)' [715] StaticText 'United Kingdom (opens in a new window)' [724] StaticText 'United States (opens in a new window)' [651] button 'Home' [656] heading 'More' [756] StaticText 'IGN on social' [661] button 'Site Themes' [667] button 'Change Region' [793] StaticText 'About Us' [802] StaticText 'Accessibility' [679] button 'AdChoices' [820] StaticText 'Privacy Policy' [829] StaticText 'Terms of Use' [838] StaticText 'Editorial Standards' [847] StaticText 'Do Not Sell My Personal Information' [856] StaticText 'Site Map' [865] StaticText 'Boards' [874] StaticText 'Contact Support' [884] StaticText '1996-2023 IGN Entertainment, Inc. a Ziff Davis company. All Rights Reserved. IGN is among the federally registered trademarks of IGN Entertainment, Inc. and may only be used with explicit written permission.' [710] button 'Home' [715] heading 'News' [915] StaticText 'All News' [924] StaticText 'Columns' [933] StaticText 'PlayStation' [942] StaticText 'Xbox' [951] StaticText 'Nintendo' [960] StaticText 'PC' [969] StaticText 'Mobile' [978] StaticText 'Movies' [987] StaticText 'Television' [996] StaticText 'Comics' [1005] StaticText 'Tech' [753] button 'Home' [758] heading 'Reviews' [1037] StaticText 'All Reviews' [1046] StaticText "Editor's Choice" [1055] StaticText 'Game Reviews' [1064] StaticText 'Movie Reviews' [1073] StaticText 'TV Show Reviews' [1082] StaticText 'Tech Reviews' [781] button 'Home' [786] heading 'Discover' [791] button 'Home' [796] heading 'Videos' [1137] StaticText 'Original Shows' [1146] StaticText 'Popular' [1155] StaticText 'Trailers' [1164] StaticText 'Gameplay' [1173] StaticText 'All Videos' [816] button 'Home' [821] heading 'Account' [1205] StaticText 'Settings' [1214] StaticText 'Security' [1223] StaticText 'Subscription' [1232] StaticText 'Email Preferences' [837] button 'Register / Login' [845] button 'Collapse Sidebar' [235] image 'The Mandalorian Season 3 Episode 3 Review' [867] heading 'The Mandalorian Season 3 Episode 3 Review' [236] image 'The Last of Us: Predicting Season 2' [874] heading 'The Last of Us: Predicting Season 2' [237] image "Quentin Tarantino's Final Movie Revealed in New Report" [881] heading "Quentin Tarantino's Final Movie Revealed in New Report" [238] image 'John Wick: Chapter 4 Review' [888] heading 'John Wick: Chapter 4 Review' [894] region '3rd party ad content' [898] heading "Today's Top Stories" [904] button 'Scroll Right' [911] image 'Marvel Is Chasing Down an Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania Leaker' [920] image 'Only One Copy Will Be Printed of Special Lord of the Rings Magic: The Gathering Card' [929] image 'Bayonetta Origins: Cereza and the Lost Demon Review' [938] image "The CW's Gotham Knights: Season 1, Episodes 1-6 Review" [947] heading 'Latest News' [950] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [951] tab 'Latest' selected: False [954] tab 'Videos' selected: False [957] tab 'Games' selected: False [960] tab 'Movies' selected: False [963] tab 'TV' selected: False [966] tab 'PlayStation' selected: False [969] tab 'Xbox' selected: False [972] tab 'Nintendo' selected: False [975] tab 'PC' selected: False [978] tab 'Tech' selected: False [989] image 'The Mandalorian Season 3, Episode 3 Review' [1641] StaticText '14m ago' [1653] StaticText '14m ago - The Mandalorians take a backseat as the show reveals the dysfunction at the heart of the New Republic.' [1000] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1002] image ' TV Show ' [1007] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [1683] StaticText 'Samantha Nelson' [1013] image ' Comments ' [1699] StaticText '4' [1022] image 'How The Last of Us Could Adapt Part 2' [1723] StaticText '16m ago' [1735] StaticText '16m ago - We give our best shot at guessing how season 2 of the hit TV show will adapt The Last of Us Part 2.' [1033] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1035] image ' Game ' [1754] StaticText 'The Last of Us Part 1' [1040] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [1765] StaticText 'Simon Cardy' [1046] image ' Comments ' [1781] StaticText '2' [1826] StaticText 'Autoplay setting: ' [1832] StaticText 'On' [1847] StaticText "Fortnite Tips & Tricks With 100 Thieves' CouRage and SydSoGood" [1137] image "Atlas Fallen - Official 'Rise from Dust' Gameplay Reveal Trailer" [1869] StaticText '1:23' [1880] StaticText '18m ago' [1886] StaticText "Atlas Fallen - Official 'Rise from Dust' Gameplay Reveal Trailer" [1892] StaticText "18m ago - Here's your look at action-packed combat and more from this upcoming action RPG." [1151] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1153] image ' Game ' [1911] StaticText 'Atlas Fallen' [1162] image "Off the Grid: Check Out the First Episode of a Miniseries Set in the Battle Royale's World" [1931] StaticText '2:25' [1941] StaticText '1h ago' [1947] StaticText "Off the Grid: Check Out the First Episode of a Miniseries Set in the Battle Royale's World" [1953] StaticText '1h ago - Just Deal with Delia is a miniseries set in the game itself.' [1176] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1178] image ' Game ' [1972] StaticText 'Off The Grid' [1184] image ' Comments ' [1987] StaticText '3' [1193] image 'The Last of Us Season 1 is Getting a Blu-ray Release This Summer' [2007] StaticText '2h ago' [2019] StaticText "2h ago - There's even a new Steelbook to collect." [1204] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1206] image ' TV Show ' [2038] StaticText 'The Last of Us' [1211] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [2049] StaticText 'Robert Anderson' [1217] image ' Comments ' [2065] StaticText '22' [1226] image 'How Resident Evil 4 Revolutionised Survival Horror' [2084] StaticText '4:19' [2094] StaticText '2h ago' [2100] StaticText 'How Resident Evil 4 Revolutionised Survival Horror' [2106] StaticText '2h ago - With the remake launching soon, discover how RE4 changed the game in 2005' [1240] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1242] image ' Game ' [2125] StaticText 'Resident Evil 4' [1248] image ' Comments ' [2164] StaticText 'IGN Deals' [2170] StaticText 'Metroid Prime Remastered in Stock at Walmart ' [2200] StaticText 'IGN Rewards: Lil Gator Game Nintendo Switch Giveaway ' [1289] region '3rd party ad content' [1294] heading 'Trending Topics' [1300] button 'Scroll Right' [1307] image 'Lord of the Rings MTG Crossover Officially Revealed' [1316] image "Why Can't Anyone Stay Dead in Star Wars?" [1325] image 'Transformers: Rise of the Beasts Reveals New Character Posters' [1334] image 'Scream 6 Ending Explained Ghostface: Hunter or Hunted?' [1343] image "Did HBO's The Last of Us Just Reveal Its Most Terrifying Monster Yet?" [1352] image 'Ayaneo 2 Review' [1363] region '3rd party ad content' [1371] image 'Resident Evil 4 Remake Demo: How to Unlock the Secret Hard Mode' [2422] StaticText '4h ago' [2434] StaticText "4h ago - Take the Resident Evil 4 Remake's Chainsaw Demo to the extreme with this hard mode cheat code." [1385] image 'Ted Lasso Season 3 Premiere Review' [2454] StaticText '6h ago' [2466] StaticText '6h ago - Believe.' [1396] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1398] image ' TV Show ' [2485] StaticText 'Ted Lasso' [1403] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [2496] StaticText 'Amelia Emberwing' [1409] image ' Comments ' [2512] StaticText '29' [1418] image '10 Movies to Watch If You Like Harry Potter' [2533] StaticText '12h ago' [2545] StaticText '12h ago - More than just Fantastic Beasts.' [1429] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1431] image ' Movie ' [2564] StaticText 'Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them' [1436] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [2575] StaticText 'Connor Sheppard' [1445] image 'Metroid Prime Remastered Physical Edition Is Back In Stock' [2597] StaticText '12h ago' [2609] StaticText "12h ago - Get it before it's gone (again)." [1456] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1458] image ' Game ' [2628] StaticText 'Metroid Prime: Remastered' [1463] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [2639] StaticText 'Chris Reed' [1469] image ' Comments ' [2655] StaticText '472' [1478] image 'The New Dead Space Remake Is on Sale on Console for the First Time' [1489] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1491] image ' Game ' [1496] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [1502] image ' Comments ' [1511] image 'Mario Day Is Over, but the Switch Bundle Is Still Available' [1522] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [1524] image ' Game ' [1529] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [1541] region '3rd party ad content' [1543] heading 'Out This Week' [1552] image 'Dead By Daylight Mobile' [1572] image 'Flooded' [1588] image 'Wolcen: Lords of Mayhem' [1623] image 'Anno 1800 Console Edition' [1643] image 'Defend the Rook' [1671] image 'Cheez-It logo' [1673] PluginObject 'Sponsored' disabled: True [1674] button ' Disclosure ' disabled: True [1675] image ' Disclosure ' [1679] button 'Presented By Cheez-It' [1684] heading 'History of Star Wars Games' [1774] image ' IGN Logo ' [1856] image ' Group Black ' [2191] dialog '' modal: False [2215] image 'IGN logo' [2229] textbox 'Enter Email Here' required: False [2233] button 'Get my FREE Deals Newsletter' [2236] button 'No Thanks' [2238] textbox '' required: False [2256] button 'Back to IGN' CURRENT ACTION: click [402] where [402] is 'Reviews' NEXT STATE PREIDCTION: [6755] button 'Focus Reset' [6757] button 'Toggle Sidebar' [6766] image ' IGN Logo ' [6785] button 'Search' [6792] button 'Reviews' [6800] button 'News' [6815] button 'Discover' [6835] button 'Videos' [6845] button 'More' [6860] button 'Add to Library' [6891] button 'More' [6899] heading 'Site Themes' [6903] radio 'Classic' checked: false [6915] radio 'Dark Mode' checked: false [6927] radio 'Automatic Based on system preferences' checked: false [6937] button 'More' [6945] heading 'Change Region' [7040] button 'Home' [7048] heading 'More' [7053] button 'Site Themes' [7059] button 'Change Region' [7071] button 'AdChoices' [7102] button 'Home' [7110] heading 'News' [7148] button 'Home' [7156] heading 'Reviews' [7178] button 'Home' [7186] heading 'Discover' [7191] button 'Home' [7199] heading 'Videos' [7219] button 'Home' [7227] heading 'Account' [7244] button 'Login' [7246] button 'Register' [6633] button 'Collapse Sidebar' [6624] image 'The Mandalorian Season 3 Episode 3 Review' [7269] heading 'The Mandalorian Season 3 Episode 3 Review' [6625] image 'The Last of Us: Predicting Season 2' [7276] heading 'The Last of Us: Predicting Season 2' [6626] image "Quentin Tarantino's Final Movie Revealed in New Report" [7283] heading "Quentin Tarantino's Final Movie Revealed in New Report" [6627] image 'John Wick: Chapter 4 Review' [7290] heading 'John Wick: Chapter 4 Review' [7296] region '3rd party ad content' [7300] heading "Today's Top Stories" [7306] button 'Scroll Right' [7313] image 'Marvel Is Chasing Down an Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania Leaker' [7322] image 'Only One Copy Will Be Printed of Special Lord of the Rings Magic: The Gathering Card' [7331] image 'Bayonetta Origins: Cereza and the Lost Demon Review' [7340] image "The CW's Gotham Knights: Season 1, Episodes 1-6 Review" [7349] heading 'Latest News' [7352] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal [7353] tab 'Latest' selected: False [7356] tab 'Videos' selected: False [7359] tab 'Games' selected: False [7362] tab 'Movies' selected: False [7365] tab 'TV' selected: False [7368] tab 'PlayStation' selected: False [7371] tab 'Xbox' selected: False [7374] tab 'Nintendo' selected: False [7377] tab 'PC' selected: False [7380] tab 'Tech' selected: False [7391] image 'The Mandalorian Season 3, Episode 3 Review' [7402] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7404] image ' TV Show ' [7409] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [7415] image ' Comments ' [7424] image 'How The Last of Us Could Adapt Part 2' [7435] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7437] image ' Game ' [7442] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [7448] image ' Comments ' [7539] image "Atlas Fallen - Official 'Rise from Dust' Gameplay Reveal Trailer" [7553] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7555] image ' Game ' [7564] image "Off the Grid: Check Out the First Episode of a Miniseries Set in the Battle Royale's World" [7578] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7580] image ' Game ' [7586] image ' Comments ' [7595] image 'The Last of Us Season 1 is Getting a Blu-ray Release This Summer' [7606] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7608] image ' TV Show ' [7613] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [7619] image ' Comments ' [7628] image 'How Resident Evil 4 Revolutionised Survival Horror' [7642] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7644] image ' Game ' [7650] image ' Comments ' [7691] region '3rd party ad content' [7696] heading 'Trending Topics' [7702] button 'Scroll Right' [7709] image 'Lord of the Rings MTG Crossover Officially Revealed' [7718] image "Why Can't Anyone Stay Dead in Star Wars?" [7727] image 'Transformers: Rise of the Beasts Reveals New Character Posters' [7736] image 'Scream 6 Ending Explained Ghostface: Hunter or Hunted?' [7745] image "Did HBO's The Last of Us Just Reveal Its Most Terrifying Monster Yet?" [7754] image 'Ayaneo 2 Review' [7765] region '3rd party ad content' [7773] image 'Resident Evil 4 Remake Demo: How to Unlock the Secret Hard Mode' [7787] image 'Ted Lasso Season 3 Premiere Review' [7798] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7800] image ' TV Show ' [7805] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [7811] image ' Comments ' [7820] image '10 Movies to Watch If You Like Harry Potter' [7831] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7833] image ' Movie ' [7838] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [7847] image 'Metroid Prime Remastered Physical Edition Is Back In Stock' [7858] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7860] image ' Game ' [7865] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [7871] image ' Comments ' [7880] image 'The New Dead Space Remake Is on Sale on Console for the First Time' [7891] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7893] image ' Game ' [7898] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [7904] image ' Comments ' [7913] image 'Mario Day Is Over, but the Switch Bundle Is Still Available' [7924] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True [7926] image ' Game ' [7931] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True [7943] region '3rd party ad content' [7945] heading 'Out This Week' [7954] image 'Dead By Daylight Mobile' [7974] image 'Flooded' [7990] image 'Wolcen: Lords of Mayhem' [8025] image 'Anno 1800 Console Edition' [8045] image 'Defend the Rook' [8073] image 'Cheez-It logo' [8075] PluginObject 'Sponsored' disabled: True [8076] button ' Disclosure ' disabled: True [8077] image ' Disclosure ' [8081] button 'Presented By Cheez-It' [8086] heading 'History of Star Wars Games' [8176] image ' IGN Logo ' [8258] image ' Group Black ' [8593] dialog '' modal: False [8617] image 'IGN logo' [8631] textbox 'Enter Email Here' required: False [8635] button 'Get my FREE Deals Newsletter' [8638] button 'No Thanks' [8640] textbox '' required: False [8658] button 'Back to IGN'

[Rationale] In this next state, the agent has successfully clicked the 'Reviews' button, which is a step towards the user's goal of displaying computer game reviews sorted by score. However, the next state does not show any specific reviews or allow for immediate sorting options; it merely indicates that the reviews section has been reached without confirming that the user can view reviews or sort them by score. The presence of headings and buttons suggests that the navigation has taken place, but the lack of specific content related to game reviews means that the task is not fully progressing toward completion. This state is more of a transition than a meaningful advancement toward the goal, hence a score of 0.25, reflecting some progress but insufficient to meet the objective. [Score] 0.25

"\nYou are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agen(...TRUNCATED)

"OBJECTIVE: Show computer game reviews sorted by score.\nPREVIOUS ACTION: [\"click [402] where [402](...TRUNCATED)

"[Rationale] The next state after clicking on 'Game Reviews' has brought the agent to a page that li(...TRUNCATED)

"\nYou are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agen(...TRUNCATED)

"OBJECTIVE: Show computer game reviews sorted by score.\nPREVIOUS ACTION: [\"click [402] where [402](...TRUNCATED)

"[Rationale] The next state shows that the agent has successfully navigated to the 'Reviews' section(...TRUNCATED)

"\nYou are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agen(...TRUNCATED)

"OBJECTIVE: Find the address and store hours for the Armageddon Shop record store in Boston.\nPREVIO(...TRUNCATED)

"[Rationale] In this scenario, the user is trying to find the address and store hours for the Armage(...TRUNCATED)