text
stringlengths 2
633k
| case_details
stringlengths 28
46
| embeddings
sequencelengths 1.02k
1.02k
| citation_number
stringlengths 28
46
|
|---|---|---|---|
SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN
(Appellate Jurisdiction)
PRESENT:
Mr. Justice Gulzar Ahmed, CJ
Mr. Justice Ijaz ul Ahsan
CIVIL APPEAL NO.10 OF 2021
[Against the judgment dated 11.06.2019, passed by the Federal Service
Tribunal, Islamabad in Appeal No.3343(R)CS/2017 with MPs]
Senior General Manager/CEO, Pakistan
Railways
Headquarters,
Lahore
and
others.
…Appellant(s)
Versus
Abdul Rauf Shamoon.
…Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Jawad Mehmood Pasha,
ASC
Naveed
Mubashar
Ch.
D.S.
Multan
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Zubair Hussain Jarral, ASC
Raja Abdul Ghafoor, AOR
Date of Hearing
: 19.04.2021
O R D E R
GULZAR AHMED, CJ.- The respondent was employed
as an Engine Driver in Pakistan Railways. He was issued charge-
sheet and statement of allegations dated 25.10.2016. He
submitted his reply dated 30.10.2016. Enquiry Committee was
constituted, which conducted the regular enquiry and ultimately
gave finding that the respondent was guilty of commission of
offence and recommended awarding of major punishment to the
respondent. The respondent was dismissed from service vide order
dated 15.04.2017. He filed departmental appeal, which came to be
regretted vide order dated 05.07.2017. The respondent filed
CA.10 of 2021
- 2 -
service appeal in the Federal Service Tribunal, Islamabad (the
Tribunal). The service appeal was heard and vide impugned
judgment dated 11.06.2019, the same was partly allowed by
converting penalty of dismissal from service into that of
compulsory retirement from the date of his dismissal.
2.
Leave to appeal was granted on 08.01.2021, relevant
portion of which is as follows: -
“The learned counsel for the petitioners contends
that the train being driven by the respondent
collided with a stationary goods train and
tremendous loss of Rs.120,000,000/- (Rupees
twelve crore) on that account was caused to the
Pakistan Railways and even the operation of
railways on the line was gravely effected. During
this incident, four persons also lost their lives.
Further contends that such collusion was on
account of respondent’s violating the red signal in
that he was required to stop the train when there
was a red signal but instead he continued driving
the
train
and
ultimately
collided
with
the
stationary/goods train.”
3.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and
have also gone through the record of the case.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant has contended that
on account of respondent’s misconduct the accident had taken
place and in this regard in the preliminary enquiry so also in the
regular enquiry the respondent was found responsible for the said
accident and pursuant to the recommendation of the regular
enquiry committee, he was imposed penalty and there was no
CA.10 of 2021
- 3 -
occasion for the Tribunal to have interfered with reducing the
penalty from dismissal to that of compulsory retirement.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent
has supported the impugned judgment and contended that
respondent has denied the charges. He has further contended that
it was a case of contributory negligence as other employees were
also proceeded in the same incident, who were awarded minor
penalties. The learned counsel relied upon the case of Jan
Muhammad vs. The General Manager, Karachi Telecomunication
Region, Karachi and another (1993 SCMR 1440).
6.
The Tribunal in the impugned judgment has noted that
collusion of trains has taken place and the respondent was
admittedly a driver of the train, which collided with the stationary
Goods Train. The Tribunal found that the respondent was bound
to follow the signals and while nothing the fact that the signal
man has also been punished concluded that there was a fault in
the entire system and the case being of a contributory negligence,
the respondent cannot be exonerated from his negligent act, at the
same time interfered with the quantum of penalty imposed upon
the respondent considering his 36 years’ service.
7.
The charge against the respondent, as contained in the
statement of allegations, was that while working on 14 Down
(Awan Express) Train on 15.09.2016, he was responsible for
collusion of 14 Down in the rear of stationary Down ZBKC Special
Goods Train at KM 61/2-3 between SSH-SJB stations on Multan
Cantonment-Lodhran Double Line. He was further charged of
being responsible in running the Train at excessive speed after
CA.10 of 2021
- 4 -
passing LXD-4 signal at danger. He did not even apply emergency
brakes resulting in catastrophic accident. He was further charged
that after stopping at LXD-4, which signal was at danger, he was
required to proceed further upto the next auto signal with a
cautious speed. He was further charged that of failure to have
good lookout and to control his Train. He was further charged that
he violated Rules 6 (a) & (b), 122, 259 (b) and 260 of the General
and Subsidiary Rules. The respondent has submitted his reply
dated 30.10.2016, in which he has not denied the allegations
made against him in the statement of allegation but gave his own
version in the following manner:-
“As far as GR-259(b) is concerned the train
stopped at LXD-4 gate signal and afterward the
LXD-4 gate signal change her aspect and train left
for the next block section ahead. Is this action for
stopping the train at LXD-4 signal being red not
sufficient to declare our vigilancy and good
outlook? So these allegations are not attributable
toward the undersigned as far as the question of
accelerating train speed is concerned no hard and
fast orders were issued from time to time in regard
the LXD/LXU signals because they are not falling
under the definition of an automatic signal.
As far as the violation of GR-6 (a) & (b), it is
pointed out that I observed the LXD-4 signal in
danger position and stopped my train at LXD-4
signal, after availing two minutes stoppage I start
my train on hand signal of the gate man. No
sooner my train move LXD-4 signal changed her
aspect to green, so allegation of violation of GR-6
(a) & (b) does not arise.
CA.10 of 2021
- 5 -
As concerned to application of emergency
brakes it is pointed out that the tail lamp of ZBKC
was not burning and the range of head light of
ZCU locomotives is 180 to 200 metres and 9
seconds will take to cover this distance at the
speed of 80 KMPH. Whereas 2 to 3 second will
take for mentally preparation and the brakes of
ZCU locomotives take place in 3 to 5 seconds,
remaining 4 seconds are not sufficient to stop the
train. The burning spots will only appear when the
train braking power will be extra ordinary tight
otherwise no such sign and symptom will be
appear. This is an unexpected incident and
everything is being assumed.”
8.
It is noted that LXD-4 signal was showing red light
that is danger position and respondent seems to have stopped the
train at the said signal. He stopped the train for only two minutes
and then started the train at hand signal of a gate man. Learned
counsel for the respondent was asked to show as to who was the
gate man who gave the hand signal, he stated that such gate man
has not been examined in the enquiry. We may note that
respondent himself having taken defence that he has started the
train on hand signal of a gate man, it was incumbent upon the
respondent to have positively proved this very aspect of his
defence but the respondent did not produce the gate man, who is
said to have given the hand signal for starting the train.
9.
Further, the respondent has stated that no sooner the
train moved, LXD-4 signal changed her aspect to green. Again the
learned counsel for the respondent was asked to show what is the
evidence on the record, which could establish that when the train
CA.10 of 2021
- 6 -
was moved by the respondent, the signal became green. Learned
counsel for the respondent replied that there is no evidence to
substantiate this defence of the respondent.
10.
We may note that the train, which was being driven by
the respondent, met with a catastrophic accident causing
substantial loss to the property of Pakistan Railways so also the
loss of human lives and the respondent in his reply has merely
taken an evasive stand, rather on its close reading appears to
have admitted that he has moved the train while signal was red in
the danger position.
11.
The factum of two defences taken by the respondent of
hand signal of a gate man and signal turning to green having not
been established, it becomes clear that the respondent violated
the red danger signal. Further, the respondent has accelerated the
train to the speed of 80 kilometres per hour and that he did not
apply emergency brakes, these charges have not been denied by
the respondent. The Tribunal in the impugned judgment has not
considered these very important aspects of the matter, which the
respondent has admitted in his reply to the charge-sheet.
12.
As noted in the leave granting order the accident has
caused direct monetary loss of Rs.120,000,000/- (one hundred
and twenty million) to the Pakistan Railways and it also took lives
of four innocent persons and looking at the conduct of the
respondent, there was no ground on the basis of which the
Tribunal could have interfered with the imposition of penalty of
dismissal imposed upon the respondent. No ground whatsoever
were available to the Tribunal for doing so. The judgment relied
CA.10 of 2021
- 7 -
upon by the learned counsel for the respondent deals with the
procedure of holding of an enquiry, to which there is no cavil, but
here the case is one where the respondent in his reply to the
charge-sheet has admitted the facts that he has stopped the train
on the red signal for two minutes and then moved the train when
the signal was red and accelerated it to a speed, where it could not
be stopped by him nor did he apply the brakes. The Tribunal has
also found the respondent responsible for such accident and has
not exonerated him from the same but converted the penalty from
dismissal to compulsory retirement.
13.
In view of the above, we allow the appeal and restore
the order of imposition of penalty of dismissal from service upon
the respondent.
14.
Above are the reasons of our short order of even date.
CHIEF JUSTICE
Bench-I
Islamabad
19.04.2021
‘APPROVED FOR REPORTING’
Rabbani/*
JUDGE
| {'id': 'C.A.10_2021.pdf', 'url': ''} | [
-0.4961879849433899,
-0.6167483329772949,
-0.053613293915987015,
0.7833247780799866,
-0.08741553127765656,
-0.4947423040866852,
-0.4629880487918854,
-0.13732880353927612,
-0.41308465600013733,
0.4347272217273712,
1.2109103202819824,
-0.2846054434776306,
-0.048119064420461655,
-0.3948644995689392,
-0.2791005074977875,
-1.105443000793457,
-0.3011443614959717,
0.32252293825149536,
0.6086701154708862,
-0.30511775612831116,
0.004964128136634827,
0.48451876640319824,
-0.08693624287843704,
-0.3611670136451721,
-0.5965151786804199,
0.07527313381433487,
-0.9923124313354492,
-0.0934930294752121,
0.3365432918071747,
0.16110381484031677,
-0.5842433571815491,
-0.021095002070069313,
0.14129631221294403,
-0.8071567416191101,
0.6737139225006104,
0.21986818313598633,
0.3165440559387207,
-0.7851628661155701,
-0.04371102154254913,
-0.39938807487487793,
0.11321981996297836,
0.026650985702872276,
-0.06793714314699173,
-0.6101176738739014,
-0.25389736890792847,
-0.5967659950256348,
-0.17278537154197693,
0.1708293855190277,
-0.43779078125953674,
-0.7544511556625366,
0.09728015959262848,
0.6561111807823181,
-0.08363176137208939,
-0.6926631927490234,
0.16706915199756622,
-0.5995790958404541,
-0.4816487729549408,
-0.8129595518112183,
0.07820210605859756,
0.3123004734516144,
0.3586616516113281,
-0.2093043029308319,
-0.0013620025711134076,
-0.292375385761261,
-0.10409270972013474,
0.6183218955993652,
-0.506737232208252,
0.24932388961315155,
-0.39389467239379883,
0.09002441167831421,
-0.4686642289161682,
0.4602277874946594,
-0.3541922867298126,
0.31725844740867615,
-0.623865008354187,
0.06843020766973495,
-0.16713516414165497,
-0.4735167622566223,
0.4328407347202301,
0.7294406890869141,
-0.01027616672217846,
0.08332091569900513,
-0.09602735191583633,
-0.8684022426605225,
-0.5489037036895752,
0.9944649934768677,
0.49648815393447876,
0.8160444498062134,
-0.34841984510421753,
0.7918598055839539,
-0.10616564005613327,
0.6753636002540588,
-1.7342227697372437,
-0.5970507264137268,
-0.062181007117033005,
0.08355864137411118,
-0.6270217299461365,
-0.6559619903564453,
0.4286746084690094,
-0.36597082018852234,
0.39547500014305115,
0.7750360369682312,
0.04507018253207207,
1.1640843152999878,
-0.3981938362121582,
0.368262380361557,
-0.6775979399681091,
0.16893388330936432,
-0.5925339460372925,
-0.2972085475921631,
0.9405447244644165,
-0.3334672749042511,
-0.1055087149143219,
-1.4099591970443726,
-0.3393901586532593,
0.4289185404777527,
-0.42285215854644775,
-0.2685456871986389,
-0.2653384804725647,
-0.16317172348499298,
0.4981083273887634,
0.5489852428436279,
0.813920259475708,
0.567691445350647,
-0.39840880036354065,
-0.11157163977622986,
0.5653645396232605,
0.7931609749794006,
-0.30014556646347046,
0.39929765462875366,
0.3657452166080475,
-0.4343326687812805,
-0.2566192150115967,
0.22019167244434357,
0.6522402763366699,
0.4921857714653015,
0.2403251826763153,
-0.24538221955299377,
0.11301268637180328,
0.3420521318912506,
0.22590608894824982,
0.6350592374801636,
0.275983601808548,
1.1685965061187744,
0.1936291754245758,
0.7208160758018494,
0.4097169041633606,
-0.1262124478816986,
-0.08706601709127426,
-0.07995589077472687,
0.27277421951293945,
0.2171119600534439,
0.7158737778663635,
-0.7970402836799622,
0.8086101412773132,
-0.5494656562805176,
0.4416919946670532,
-0.24025213718414307,
0.4051329791545868,
0.9442310929298401,
0.21535012125968933,
0.36843714118003845,
-0.625469446182251,
0.5166611671447754,
0.26848292350769043,
0.016147451475262642,
0.670742392539978,
-0.13314391672611237,
-0.7184739708900452,
-0.6706005334854126,
0.8808719515800476,
0.2811574935913086,
0.12837205827236176,
0.2825583219528198,
0.45613807439804077,
0.4639943242073059,
0.6354414820671082,
-0.05235832929611206,
-0.08450817316770554,
0.2115776538848877,
-0.39190977811813354,
0.8197017312049866,
0.5546153783798218,
0.22509360313415527,
-0.07154867798089981,
0.27947553992271423,
0.5100728869438171,
-0.09795939922332764,
-0.06535761058330536,
-1.0397228002548218,
0.07305950671434402,
-0.06222602352499962,
0.3398934304714203,
0.3134150803089142,
-0.4425172209739685,
0.3569493293762207,
-0.562836229801178,
-0.8321719169616699,
0.6903528571128845,
0.10413482785224915,
-0.008926390670239925,
-0.1672469675540924,
-0.30421802401542664,
1.2120673656463623,
-0.5886057615280151,
-0.2601774036884308,
0.41039517521858215,
0.6030036211013794,
0.17804276943206787,
0.0066633885726332664,
-0.07762593775987625,
0.44969964027404785,
-0.26046022772789,
-1.2036737203598022,
0.7116789221763611,
0.3128773272037506,
-0.5146722197532654,
-0.05411425977945328,
0.24645216763019562,
-0.5570071935653687,
-0.4161958694458008,
0.6742941737174988,
0.05265640839934349,
0.48227301239967346,
-0.0688713937997818,
-0.016668980941176414,
-0.5166171789169312,
0.4046311378479004,
0.06036059930920601,
0.4171440303325653,
0.20269569754600525,
-0.2629738450050354,
0.07265332341194153,
0.9485213756561279,
0.09997271746397018,
-0.9450328350067139,
0.7784176468849182,
-0.3592640161514282,
0.47446954250335693,
-0.14701256155967712,
0.09243142604827881,
0.3306238651275635,
1.0823866128921509,
-0.24966534972190857,
-0.01243688352406025,
0.2847306430339813,
0.022099973633885384,
-0.6189725995063782,
-0.8309423923492432,
0.07835429161787033,
0.0981847271323204,
0.31570419669151306,
0.6342923641204834,
0.20245465636253357,
0.10216116160154343,
-0.15518900752067566,
1.1418594121932983,
-0.061808519065380096,
-0.6125786900520325,
-0.2674764394760132,
0.4899437129497528,
0.4194313585758209,
0.3625774383544922,
0.16154547035694122,
0.6211216449737549,
-0.4051807224750519,
0.10138097405433655,
-0.0597933791577816,
-0.15214766561985016,
-0.6698635220527649,
-0.4513072073459625,
-0.07479920238256454,
-0.012226366437971592,
-0.42692244052886963,
-0.18624454736709595,
-0.21942956745624542,
0.9875239133834839,
-0.07669508457183838,
1.17372727394104,
-0.028593558818101883,
0.45758894085884094,
0.5015802383422852,
-0.9018411636352539,
-0.17959123849868774,
-0.9851554036140442,
0.4842260479927063,
-0.30066654086112976,
0.11368314921855927,
0.22715571522712708,
0.13587865233421326,
-0.4274740517139435,
-0.0372004434466362,
-0.29329952597618103,
0.5626328587532043,
-0.21369899809360504,
-0.18932217359542847,
0.4463837444782257,
0.6655465364456177,
-0.483876496553421,
-0.3953824043273926,
0.5018505454063416,
-0.3185507357120514,
-0.013888665474951267,
0.17404140532016754,
-0.07556886225938797,
0.774487316608429,
-0.4608611464500427,
0.026951149106025696,
0.009883979335427284,
0.508894681930542,
0.1365746706724167,
0.06417549401521683,
0.8566096425056458,
-0.09619385749101639,
0.11360175907611847,
0.9762170910835266,
0.441031277179718,
0.17488519847393036,
-0.24618498980998993,
-1.1931320428848267,
-0.6680510640144348,
-0.29179567098617554,
-0.2718839645385742,
-0.2180866003036499,
0.8805291056632996,
-0.028734352439641953,
0.4217241704463959,
-0.4688666760921478,
0.2292511910200119,
-0.33365073800086975,
-0.4195273816585541,
0.05501393973827362,
-0.7674977779388428,
0.06167927384376526,
-0.3010258376598358,
-0.1378609985113144,
-0.3422110378742218,
0.3418167531490326,
-0.03839915618300438,
-0.8126036524772644,
1.0740714073181152,
-0.3482874631881714,
0.13830623030662537,
0.02990277297794819,
-0.03500187397003174,
0.7236394286155701,
0.9389827251434326,
0.0674496591091156,
-0.0605577677488327,
-0.18659234046936035,
-0.7461674809455872,
0.07984472811222076,
0.6946339011192322,
-0.5799565315246582,
-0.3896041214466095,
0.7815362811088562,
0.36545950174331665,
-0.8923743367195129,
-0.3146984279155731,
0.8191103339195251,
0.03365989029407501,
-0.09449315816164017,
0.05613823980093002,
0.031487271189689636,
0.13996607065200806,
-0.4228792190551758,
-1.0204291343688965,
-0.08048462867736816,
-0.4093130826950073,
-1.4718836545944214,
0.9738070368766785,
-0.46038275957107544,
0.5132107138633728,
0.08863981813192368,
-0.4140433967113495,
-0.5790623426437378,
0.5575159192085266,
-0.0786779448390007,
0.8390582799911499,
0.17269779741764069,
0.2676727771759033,
-0.9018839597702026,
-0.2583276629447937,
-0.36024969816207886,
0.5249619483947754,
-0.1782105416059494,
-0.7423699498176575,
0.5080028176307678,
-0.389812707901001,
0.2966471314430237,
-0.20319126546382904,
-0.6228194832801819,
0.5790959596633911,
-0.28901568055152893,
-1.289770483970642,
-0.20284707844257355,
-0.06550447642803192,
0.6937414407730103,
1.052868366241455,
0.7199740409851074,
0.8695431351661682,
0.02971377596259117,
0.1550317108631134,
0.40816769003868103,
-0.9361967444419861,
-0.18125669658184052,
-0.3905065059661865,
0.5745760202407837,
-0.23316693305969238,
0.3909594714641571,
0.1003991961479187,
-0.3128390908241272,
0.2455025315284729,
0.4161091148853302,
0.9734500646591187,
-0.5950638055801392,
-0.9442166686058044,
0.5582377910614014,
-0.18102732300758362,
0.23097537457942963,
0.6595810055732727,
-0.5596554279327393,
0.9882710576057434,
0.9922872185707092,
0.4122411906719208,
-0.41781648993492126,
0.7900219559669495,
-0.749634861946106,
1.131351113319397,
0.08623360097408295,
0.7378866672515869,
-0.684465765953064,
-0.04797188937664032,
-0.41493138670921326,
-0.619701623916626,
0.19832241535186768,
0.4664475917816162,
-0.7561028599739075,
-0.3503740131855011,
-0.6425235271453857,
-0.14244157075881958,
0.4339217245578766,
-0.07284018397331238,
-0.561341404914856,
-0.9653084874153137,
-0.29626259207725525,
-0.4845869839191437,
0.17782390117645264,
-0.1512593924999237,
-0.11516901105642319,
0.16415560245513916,
-1.0075427293777466,
0.8824608325958252,
-0.18153992295265198,
-0.6097223162651062,
-0.33635976910591125,
-0.24683962762355804,
0.7269551753997803,
0.9748971462249756,
-0.04768875986337662,
0.5883703231811523,
-0.27456134557724,
0.13732768595218658,
-0.2288539707660675,
0.13445672392845154,
0.07967869937419891,
0.04133785888552666,
0.7184218168258667,
1.1973713636398315,
-0.5581588745117188,
-0.2756451368331909,
0.48674067854881287,
-0.6073483824729919,
-0.23483949899673462,
0.44359609484672546,
-0.5349429845809937,
0.276263028383255,
-0.08309188485145569,
-0.11381076276302338,
0.05321870371699333,
-0.08896602690219879,
0.6541094779968262,
-0.4871128797531128,
-0.2090909332036972,
-0.6857382655143738,
-1.0138128995895386,
-0.34019535779953003,
0.276585191488266,
0.09460917860269547,
0.589330792427063,
-0.6151169538497925,
0.4066973626613617,
-0.14418302476406097,
-0.1926126778125763,
0.07851476222276688,
0.36806488037109375,
-0.5877076387405396,
-0.6289074420928955,
-0.33611032366752625,
-0.4571276605129242,
-0.16268892586231232,
-0.13914215564727783,
-0.003959649242460728,
-0.29900649189949036,
-0.332399845123291,
-0.2806890308856964,
-0.4133349061012268,
-0.1296030431985855,
0.403516948223114,
-0.1777201145887375,
0.07734116911888123,
0.7943530678749084,
0.683903157711029,
0.20671339333057404,
0.2565620541572571,
0.7407587170600891,
-0.6379754543304443,
0.4017397165298462,
0.6228907108306885,
0.019588595256209373,
0.9353885650634766,
-0.4122002124786377,
0.16458572447299957,
0.22932304441928864,
-0.6319265961647034,
0.4530753493309021,
-0.3048325181007385,
-0.4690762460231781,
0.4161299467086792,
-1.6050236225128174,
0.389635294675827,
-0.6649675369262695,
0.027383536100387573,
-0.3817523121833801,
-0.4749675989151001,
0.5449804663658142,
0.5690133571624756,
0.01758989505469799,
0.3354138433933258,
-0.4260672628879547,
-1.3784364461898804,
0.21950648725032806,
-1.0586622953414917,
-0.7461679577827454,
-0.5009512305259705,
-1.0875731706619263,
-0.21926435828208923,
0.6677208542823792,
0.41909000277519226,
0.7687757015228271,
0.6018442511558533,
-0.00500823650509119,
0.30486780405044556,
-0.41459721326828003,
-0.6309107542037964,
-1.1759092807769775,
0.02907974272966385,
0.9226825833320618,
0.24007609486579895,
-0.02006032131612301,
-0.28200584650039673,
0.3338734805583954,
0.07588428258895874,
0.25102174282073975,
-0.12606753408908844,
-1.3899480104446411,
-0.8546397089958191,
-0.30952221155166626,
0.9197970032691956,
-0.7267213463783264,
0.6968352198600769,
0.020427759736776352,
0.3542085289955139,
-0.05663163214921951,
0.4443203806877136,
-0.343100905418396,
0.25956201553344727,
-0.440498024225235,
-1.423317313194275,
-0.06231001019477844,
-0.12505987286567688,
-0.7211653590202332,
-0.554364800453186,
0.13511528074741364,
-0.1560344696044922,
-0.6015466451644897,
0.4751167893409729,
0.8930933475494385,
-0.34436607360839844,
0.6060351133346558,
-0.6483412981033325,
0.45983320474624634,
0.4444637596607208,
-0.6005376577377319,
-0.7991856336593628,
-0.07531467080116272,
-0.3001382648944855,
-0.11679917573928833,
-0.5482853651046753,
0.18127338588237762,
-0.07234648615121841,
0.0016150508308783174,
-0.10274986922740936,
0.17934677004814148,
0.8990498781204224,
0.2578677833080292,
-0.49525195360183716,
-0.5073505640029907,
0.3840853273868561,
0.2384849488735199,
0.4537811577320099,
0.48424091935157776,
-0.7937451004981995,
0.25603845715522766,
0.4921407401561737,
0.10441700369119644,
-0.0626964122056961,
-0.6654114723205566,
0.6479804515838623,
-0.8998154997825623,
-1.1501600742340088,
0.4195044934749603,
0.34482479095458984,
-0.2180163413286209,
-0.9895691871643066,
-0.7643404603004456,
-0.28912419080734253,
-0.5616503953933716,
0.07803144305944443,
-0.3113611340522766,
0.41998401284217834,
0.1946616768836975,
-0.17989380657672882,
0.6314489841461182,
0.5333950519561768,
0.7163759469985962,
-0.6024555563926697,
0.8597444295883179,
-0.5737344026565552,
-0.2800951898097992,
1.1872806549072266,
0.3403048515319824,
0.8372852802276611,
-0.6932145357131958,
0.18157300353050232,
-0.9159523844718933,
-0.08745156228542328,
0.8416925072669983,
-0.8429081439971924,
0.3540087938308716,
0.04109106957912445,
0.6251479387283325,
0.785945475101471,
-0.07789350301027298,
0.09238488227128983,
0.1591823399066925,
0.8200106024742126,
-0.6673615574836731,
0.029765186831355095,
-0.5961575508117676,
-0.22906537353992462,
-0.1851445883512497,
-0.7194087505340576,
-0.24158035218715668,
0.46733665466308594,
0.07070765644311905,
0.29092562198638916,
-0.2108890414237976,
-0.5489938259124756,
-0.4671091139316559,
0.09281083941459656,
-0.7284983992576599,
0.4783397614955902,
0.17372232675552368,
1.1851130723953247,
-0.2771745026111603,
-0.5551843047142029,
-0.5501483082771301,
0.3089783489704132,
-0.27087166905403137,
0.554158627986908,
-0.9470061659812927,
-0.5724021196365356,
-0.49578896164894104,
-0.6582765579223633,
-0.6269645690917969,
-0.43103674054145813,
0.22210855782032013,
0.6348248720169067,
-0.35156145691871643,
0.042560674250125885,
0.283877968788147,
-0.3820191025733948,
0.05993735417723656,
-1.3003931045532227,
0.07800091058015823,
-0.09993340075016022,
-0.8003195524215698,
0.36223456263542175,
0.6807842254638672,
-0.0200202539563179,
0.09019362926483154,
0.266139954328537,
0.06987153738737106,
0.351838082075119,
-0.23509874939918518,
0.31511083245277405,
0.4885658621788025,
1.090898871421814,
0.6087474822998047,
-0.9492174983024597,
-0.3917224705219269,
0.13847745954990387,
-0.14022400975227356,
0.20267631113529205,
-0.3524117171764374,
0.43978849053382874,
-0.5460218191146851,
-0.4487638771533966,
-0.3089323043823242,
0.21350359916687012,
-0.35328027606010437,
-0.15465444326400757,
0.18321792781352997,
0.14672231674194336,
0.36638009548187256,
0.002814959967508912,
-0.10840468853712082,
0.0585482157766819,
0.4622945487499237,
0.4726335406303406,
0.03463008999824524,
1.3390589952468872,
0.13691523671150208,
0.6086139678955078,
-1.4448508024215698,
0.10326544940471649,
-1.2313278913497925,
-0.19058649241924286,
0.4101056158542633,
0.4450298547744751,
0.10620254278182983,
0.445629358291626,
0.25042545795440674,
-0.030610982328653336,
-0.008650285191833973,
0.43112364411354065,
-0.24256396293640137,
-1.3598930835723877,
-0.22249960899353027,
0.020859939977526665,
-0.10665759444236755,
-0.017028547823429108,
-0.44267821311950684,
0.5076800584793091,
0.4423460066318512,
-0.3531116247177124,
-0.22253896296024323,
0.571577250957489,
-0.23530177772045135,
0.8034482598304749,
-0.8343896865844727,
0.1416224092245102,
0.3454856276512146,
-0.004808774683624506,
-0.42473649978637695,
-0.568679928779602,
0.7895331382751465,
0.639220118522644,
0.19129204750061035,
0.4407689869403839,
-1.1095236539840698,
0.2569543719291687,
-0.9356977343559265,
-0.0921928733587265,
1.1647980213165283,
0.39979031682014465,
-0.5117825865745544,
0.009169003926217556,
-0.8158578276634216,
0.2530241012573242,
-0.3694285750389099,
0.31962013244628906,
0.5713295340538025,
-0.9709652066230774,
-1.3146312236785889,
-0.9233490228652954,
0.20081296563148499,
-0.41985562443733215,
0.2983652949333191,
-0.05669696629047394,
-0.15149137377738953,
-0.46441560983657837,
-0.8460200428962708,
-0.2852506935596466,
0.8179989457130432,
0.3747383952140808,
0.2438504546880722,
-0.4763867259025574,
0.5607092976570129,
0.1878366768360138,
-0.07769634574651718,
0.23950733244419098,
-0.11853115260601044,
0.4347706735134125,
0.07970044761896133,
0.560296893119812,
-0.3616459369659424,
-0.12371901422739029,
-0.24414360523223877,
-0.5071816444396973,
0.2980324625968933,
-0.9143561720848083,
-0.025240397080779076,
0.06494701653718948,
-0.45593971014022827,
0.5501781105995178,
-0.5408374667167664,
-0.1211119219660759,
0.37870556116104126,
0.0892229974269867,
0.7655968070030212,
0.5681090950965881,
0.4368598163127899,
-0.010683011263608932,
0.3413258492946625,
1.369728922843933,
0.3628470301628113,
0.4397505521774292,
0.4952400326728821,
0.5289208889007568,
-0.9724700450897217,
0.43760043382644653,
0.9157902002334595,
-0.38932180404663086,
-0.2676223814487457,
0.31498801708221436,
-0.2206690013408661,
0.1308337301015854,
-0.38253453373908997,
0.13054205477237701,
-0.27533724904060364,
-0.589270830154419,
-0.20406199991703033,
-0.27862900495529175,
0.8787712454795837,
-0.6645339727401733,
-0.004790663253515959,
-0.17354059219360352,
-0.31259363889694214,
-0.28760090470314026,
0.8285626769065857,
-0.21786382794380188,
-0.32214757800102234,
0.3782055079936981,
-0.029325047507882118,
0.5039293766021729,
0.19963105022907257,
0.42269062995910645,
-0.7470370531082153,
0.3145388960838318,
0.23555253446102142,
-0.6599443554878235,
0.5005253553390503,
-0.18258817493915558,
-0.5871875882148743,
-1.027527093887329,
-1.0042537450790405,
-0.2742929756641388,
-0.23608236014842987,
1.1440290212631226,
0.4190966784954071,
-1.492300033569336,
0.2196296602487564,
-0.4627906084060669,
-0.2534230053424835,
0.4181741774082184,
0.03046467714011669,
1.124251365661621,
-0.09409646689891815,
-0.2836094796657562,
-0.8812947273254395,
0.10170792788267136,
-0.02126813866198063,
-1.1489958763122559,
0.13039566576480865,
-0.019705677404999733,
-0.8372007608413696,
-1.9304242134094238,
-0.508806049823761,
0.2197273075580597,
0.10186468064785004,
-0.2785012722015381,
0.27518582344055176,
-0.10967158526182175,
0.4374014735221863,
-0.3176209032535553,
-0.39998167753219604,
0.030560940504074097,
0.7478246688842773,
0.32004880905151367,
1.105739712715149,
0.0837697982788086,
-0.7540022730827332,
0.3006522059440613,
0.8041250109672546,
0.40044552087783813,
-0.36965373158454895,
-0.42395246028900146,
0.5441311001777649,
-0.671025276184082,
0.03695366159081459,
-0.18954241275787354,
-0.9702752828598022,
-0.22575053572654724,
0.9378262758255005,
0.4548707902431488,
-0.10819515585899353,
0.8919203281402588,
-0.3386968970298767,
-0.2138330638408661,
-0.5635860562324524,
0.25795629620552063,
0.0899350717663765,
0.32970792055130005,
-0.543839693069458,
0.41250574588775635,
-0.28459128737449646,
-0.8133436441421509,
3.9177186489105225,
-0.10374680906534195,
-0.2904472351074219,
0.5923880934715271,
-0.7498787045478821,
0.7502173781394958,
0.3394775688648224,
-0.9041919112205505,
-0.2361491173505783,
-0.39925262331962585,
0.32331761717796326,
-0.7615062594413757,
-0.4395747780799866,
-0.15855605900287628,
0.31284910440444946,
1.0001271963119507,
-0.6706835627555847,
-0.03813060745596886,
1.3399966955184937,
-0.9207180738449097,
0.004099597223103046,
0.15243832767009735,
-0.5424480438232422,
0.851954996585846,
0.7357757091522217,
0.5523346662521362,
-0.24415047466754913,
-0.7977655529975891,
0.49782776832580566,
-0.5651724338531494,
-0.4354759752750397,
-0.8894283771514893,
0.021407516673207283,
-0.6842669248580933,
-0.3285304307937622,
0.9141470789909363,
0.035635076463222504,
-1.0366655588150024,
-0.22026099264621735,
-0.9508285522460938,
0.2904215157032013,
0.47860369086265564,
0.41458573937416077,
-0.00033532772795297205,
-0.3818534314632416,
-0.0003144947113469243,
-0.9013731479644775,
0.8931712508201599,
0.8384682536125183,
-0.6988900899887085,
0.6473919153213501,
0.2605012357234955,
0.3340555727481842,
0.23112258315086365,
-0.45843496918678284,
0.5703206658363342,
-0.5013880133628845,
-0.15543434023857117,
-0.40148475766181946,
-0.2189810574054718,
0.28387317061424255,
0.07659730315208435,
0.6426650285720825,
0.5406706929206848,
-0.3568864166736603,
0.13052555918693542,
0.8431063294410706,
0.5463032722473145,
-0.34733662009239197,
0.780965268611908,
0.7753108143806458,
-0.35143178701400757,
-0.5581427216529846,
-0.18480618298053741,
-0.44742321968078613,
0.9753498435020447,
-0.10875570774078369,
0.35524946451187134,
0.9946438074111938,
-0.530167281627655,
0.5270692110061646,
0.39171841740608215,
0.0004934260505251586,
0.2665066123008728,
1.1472078561782837,
0.792312741279602,
-0.6191667914390564,
-0.1579422503709793,
-0.23127713799476624,
-0.33541908860206604,
0.5331666469573975,
-0.09944825619459152,
0.28877022862434387,
0.2922242283821106,
-0.2979503273963928
] | {'id': 'C.A.10_2021.pdf', 'url': ''} |
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN
(Appellate Jurisdiction)
PRESENT:
MR. JUSTICE GULZAR AHMED
MR. JUSTICE DOST MUHAMMAD KHAN
MR. JUSTICE TARIQ PARVEZ
Civil Appeal Nos.1109 of 2013 to 1111 of 2013 and
Civil Appeal Nos.1424 of 2014 to 1428 of 2014
Nematullah
(in C.A.1109/2013)
Najeebullah
(in C.A.1110/2013)
Faridullah Khan
(in C.A.1111/2013)
Miss Sherin
(in C.A.1424/2014)
Miss Zar Afshan
(in C.A.1425/2014)
Johar Shah & others
(in C.A.1426/2014)
Miss Asfa Gul
(in C.A.1427/2014)
Matiullah
(in C.A.1428/2014)
… Appellants
Versus
Chairman Govt. Body WWB/Secy. To Govt. of KPK Labour Dept. & others
(in C.As.1109/2013 and 1111/2013)
Workers Welfare Fund thr. Chairman, Islamabad & others
(in C.As.1424/2014 to 1428/2014)
...Respondents
For the appellants:
Barrister Masood Kausar, Sr. ASC.
For the respondent:
Nemo.
Mr. Umar Khan, Law Officer, W.W.B.
Date of hearing:
9.3.2016
ORDER
Learned counsel for the respondent has sent an application for
adjournment on the ground that his aunt has expired and he has to
attend her funeral. Adjourned. Let it be fixed after two weeks.
Judge
Judge
Judge
Islamabad, the
9th March, 2016
Naveed Ahmad
| {'id': 'C.A.1109_2013.pdf', 'url': ''} | [
-0.16000983119010925,
-0.3579729497432709,
0.07821965962648392,
0.4789053201675415,
0.04617401212453842,
-0.3180961608886719,
-0.23957672715187073,
-0.4622860848903656,
-0.39529040455818176,
0.07808677107095718,
1.1607365608215332,
-1.0316790342330933,
0.40886157751083374,
-0.2750016152858734,
-0.2985368072986603,
-1.1161046028137207,
-0.5484589338302612,
0.17700962722301483,
0.8445826172828674,
0.4322093725204468,
0.03888849914073944,
0.5742566585540771,
-0.333431601524353,
-0.16057933866977692,
-0.278283029794693,
0.1612250804901123,
-0.711014986038208,
-0.07798851281404495,
0.8818439245223999,
0.2833409905433655,
-0.5586420297622681,
-0.4472663402557373,
0.04271713271737099,
-0.563714861869812,
0.17932340502738953,
0.17650321125984192,
0.6741315722465515,
-0.7877268195152283,
0.2122945487499237,
-0.6375766396522522,
-0.2744130790233612,
0.08395752310752869,
0.3280995488166809,
-1.030540943145752,
-0.5292020440101624,
-0.6195715665817261,
-0.28203922510147095,
0.07992382347583771,
0.1410667449235916,
-0.39014118909835815,
-0.38306745886802673,
-0.07242049276828766,
0.03960198536515236,
-0.7412070035934448,
0.28664419054985046,
-0.58000248670578,
-0.4321729242801666,
-0.9817484617233276,
-0.028819097205996513,
0.21113723516464233,
0.8274365663528442,
0.11176951229572296,
0.4166720509529114,
-0.21244800090789795,
0.234599307179451,
0.8295037150382996,
-0.36053743958473206,
0.12432828545570374,
-0.08202741295099258,
-0.6475257277488708,
-0.10993891209363937,
0.3307870924472809,
-0.45480814576148987,
0.039350785315036774,
-0.4073575735092163,
0.15578068792819977,
-0.058691300451755524,
-0.8346878886222839,
0.39652764797210693,
0.8400731086730957,
0.459625780582428,
0.09485594928264618,
0.2735329270362854,
-0.1545739471912384,
-1.4650038480758667,
0.2796793282032013,
0.3297998905181885,
1.0419892072677612,
0.1919642686843872,
0.37596288323402405,
-0.4880753457546234,
1.0794016122817993,
-1.618812918663025,
-0.47810623049736023,
0.2773887813091278,
-0.045087262988090515,
-0.18614785373210907,
-0.4308977723121643,
-0.08414432406425476,
-0.288259357213974,
0.32918092608451843,
0.4942180812358856,
-0.03307585045695305,
1.4591469764709473,
0.040796417742967606,
0.4242117404937744,
-0.8744728565216064,
0.7659081816673279,
-0.3039390444755554,
-0.4410054683685303,
1.0407769680023193,
-0.012737775221467018,
0.3655589818954468,
-0.5656071305274963,
-0.5104789137840271,
0.6334412097930908,
-0.27846628427505493,
0.0713355541229248,
-0.2663803696632385,
-0.20236751437187195,
0.657753586769104,
1.1200083494186401,
0.5878199338912964,
0.3635231852531433,
-0.18331018090248108,
0.03990656137466431,
0.8637071251869202,
0.8829517960548401,
0.21594291925430298,
0.2464345097541809,
0.5253784656524658,
-0.21373465657234192,
-0.32518085837364197,
-1.2757304906845093,
0.3738553524017334,
0.6686674952507019,
0.2691999077796936,
-0.3480501174926758,
-0.11880776286125183,
0.2716744542121887,
0.4862292408943176,
0.6408801078796387,
-0.47566330432891846,
0.565557599067688,
0.7966013550758362,
1.1775301694869995,
0.3078118860721588,
-0.28730309009552,
-0.1760462373495102,
-0.15814919769763947,
0.027834750711917877,
0.013075142167508602,
0.41964662075042725,
0.13471181690692902,
0.9975807070732117,
-0.794073760509491,
0.4235759377479553,
-0.3008296489715576,
-0.21546532213687897,
0.7774251103401184,
0.2352123260498047,
0.06758907437324524,
-0.8461511731147766,
0.7232959270477295,
0.32002779841423035,
-0.016251342371106148,
0.2976625859737396,
0.37859809398651123,
-0.7394556999206543,
-0.9288607239723206,
0.9999865889549255,
0.04650198668241501,
-0.4199784994125366,
0.11188384145498276,
-0.064426489174366,
0.30123263597488403,
0.7792472243309021,
-0.23529118299484253,
0.8649281859397888,
0.286655992269516,
-0.17773272097110748,
0.3970094323158264,
0.9055589437484741,
0.026462186127901077,
0.0042741382494568825,
1.0153506994247437,
-0.2029915601015091,
-0.2807791233062744,
0.4760136008262634,
-1.0575815439224243,
-0.16173714399337769,
-0.34433430433273315,
0.055365703999996185,
0.30913081765174866,
0.14056377112865448,
-0.004211176186800003,
-0.6027789115905762,
-0.8781116008758545,
0.6496990323066711,
-0.24947062134742737,
-0.3793468475341797,
0.3896567225456238,
0.031939927488565445,
0.7756279706954956,
-0.21967998147010803,
-0.2971535921096802,
0.6733417510986328,
-0.24670952558517456,
-0.06361733376979828,
-0.2747141718864441,
0.37468522787094116,
1.019673466682434,
0.030482959002256393,
-0.8846079111099243,
0.47373801469802856,
0.40322837233543396,
-0.10845523327589035,
-0.04629721865057945,
-0.9418864250183105,
-0.2656162977218628,
-0.40017402172088623,
1.3509176969528198,
-0.24753598868846893,
-0.3647187352180481,
-0.9066773653030396,
0.21553629636764526,
-0.1660306304693222,
0.03863539919257164,
0.30557137727737427,
0.664116382598877,
0.31611716747283936,
-0.17394773662090302,
-0.28547173738479614,
0.8244251608848572,
0.7795973420143127,
0.03448984771966934,
0.21224188804626465,
-0.09638361632823944,
0.6052067279815674,
-0.02290402539074421,
-0.5723291039466858,
0.5334409475326538,
0.8337236642837524,
0.16890476644039154,
0.06396985799074173,
0.7945933938026428,
0.25055035948753357,
-0.19750820100307465,
-0.4632965922355652,
0.37129610776901245,
0.9109982252120972,
0.6130571365356445,
1.1288410425186157,
1.062061071395874,
0.2682030498981476,
-0.017701515927910805,
0.9175135493278503,
0.36958828568458557,
-0.5669736862182617,
-0.45494768023490906,
0.48630478978157043,
0.0866181030869484,
0.0611400380730629,
-0.1633344441652298,
0.3601437211036682,
-0.27748987078666687,
0.2941027581691742,
-0.2221519649028778,
-0.2294199913740158,
-0.04501829668879509,
-1.0633481740951538,
-0.15224339067935944,
0.21466925740242004,
-0.5387057662010193,
-0.06763031333684921,
-0.5274301767349243,
0.9491422772407532,
-0.6375153064727783,
0.821232795715332,
-0.5909754633903503,
-0.37253865599632263,
0.8207011818885803,
-1.2865073680877686,
-0.19195324182510376,
-0.47934871912002563,
0.5926027297973633,
-0.7995681166648865,
-0.0905744731426239,
0.20313052833080292,
0.5068146586418152,
-0.8168318271636963,
0.6180607676506042,
-0.5381079912185669,
0.3324355185031891,
0.4089208245277405,
-0.758716881275177,
-0.0941598117351532,
0.8350210189819336,
-0.5708259344100952,
-0.1012381762266159,
0.028777649626135826,
-0.24091555178165436,
0.39007025957107544,
-0.25119051337242126,
-0.283099889755249,
0.6434136629104614,
-0.3288860321044922,
0.2493094801902771,
0.016424525529146194,
-0.19359132647514343,
0.3898286819458008,
0.1844901144504547,
0.6436010003089905,
0.2922786772251129,
-0.2550990879535675,
1.3075612783432007,
0.16661520302295685,
0.29462572932243347,
-0.24633291363716125,
-0.8319980502128601,
-0.27161240577697754,
-0.07631224393844604,
-0.20748841762542725,
-0.1788630187511444,
0.23765727877616882,
0.1517152041196823,
0.5959374308586121,
-0.41620537638664246,
0.1842087358236313,
-0.4650194048881531,
-0.9146592617034912,
-0.5138646960258484,
-0.3208175301551819,
-0.32846519351005554,
0.5085393786430359,
-0.18269838392734528,
-0.16118714213371277,
0.06977126747369766,
-0.8401299715042114,
-0.6934468150138855,
1.2777570486068726,
-0.6946858763694763,
0.7549702525138855,
-0.11953642219305038,
-0.17510201036930084,
0.6852891445159912,
-0.016488343477249146,
0.00889157596975565,
-0.14182144403457642,
0.02816789038479328,
-0.5724522471427917,
0.48461613059043884,
0.3869323432445526,
0.24789518117904663,
-0.8881726264953613,
0.6077488660812378,
-0.45966291427612305,
-0.5269728302955627,
-0.4176071882247925,
0.7639698386192322,
0.2066156417131424,
0.1212160661816597,
0.04677721485495567,
-0.1759013533592224,
-0.34432700276374817,
-0.29784539341926575,
-0.6677910685539246,
-0.4203118085861206,
-0.24296724796295166,
-1.456897497177124,
0.586937665939331,
-0.1155741810798645,
0.23684270679950714,
-0.23355956375598907,
-0.3911116123199463,
-0.5207915902137756,
0.6343400478363037,
0.43292897939682007,
0.6436923146247864,
-0.07749221473932266,
0.2905707061290741,
-0.563802182674408,
-0.4482061564922333,
-0.11512164026498795,
0.41425636410713196,
-0.28977519273757935,
-0.16143865883350372,
1.04108726978302,
0.2213451862335205,
-0.4123174250125885,
0.4172464907169342,
-0.37717390060424805,
-0.08652613312005997,
0.16696813702583313,
-0.7684506177902222,
0.19203856587409973,
-0.14893321692943573,
0.29439303278923035,
1.0127772092819214,
0.6758131384849548,
0.02585931122303009,
0.9469413161277771,
0.3313797414302826,
0.20115023851394653,
-1.2309300899505615,
0.38910380005836487,
-0.8113064765930176,
0.7216728329658508,
0.7800113558769226,
0.32760876417160034,
0.3279375433921814,
-0.1687391996383667,
-0.3100825250148773,
0.5352925062179565,
0.5271115303039551,
-0.1449306458234787,
-1.0059547424316406,
0.07955386489629745,
-0.1673952341079712,
0.25905632972717285,
0.7326105833053589,
-0.8814851641654968,
1.1331769227981567,
0.5692006349563599,
0.1335478276014328,
-0.35201191902160645,
0.910168468952179,
-0.9825050234794617,
0.9949682950973511,
-0.5132900476455688,
-0.8009119629859924,
-0.19616565108299255,
0.2124720811843872,
-0.07856866717338562,
-0.27972444891929626,
0.5480411648750305,
0.5920575857162476,
-0.8044627904891968,
-0.0949435606598854,
-0.739260733127594,
0.003314053639769554,
0.6260480284690857,
-0.3515012860298157,
-0.475518137216568,
-0.3395531475543976,
-0.1988777220249176,
-0.28662583231925964,
-0.13047803938388824,
0.08194830268621445,
0.19176079332828522,
0.3895203471183777,
-0.7954930067062378,
0.6666980981826782,
-0.41821154952049255,
-0.2531656324863434,
-0.6050953269004822,
0.5686706900596619,
0.25368958711624146,
0.6438512802124023,
0.08048729598522186,
0.1580355018377304,
-0.13417963683605194,
-0.3090609014034271,
-0.5118670463562012,
0.40292033553123474,
0.19549061357975006,
-0.34801819920539856,
0.2638604938983917,
1.359540343284607,
-0.21556584537029266,
-0.35911741852760315,
0.32054421305656433,
-0.022485939785838127,
-0.2912365794181824,
0.35563692450523376,
-0.6391474604606628,
0.5980308651924133,
0.3537040054798126,
0.259543240070343,
-0.40804046392440796,
-0.04468072950839996,
0.8663306832313538,
-0.8951125741004944,
0.06803523749113083,
-0.41918447613716125,
-0.5694146156311035,
-0.7699832916259766,
0.028198668733239174,
0.04373285174369812,
0.4380243420600891,
-0.16491861641407013,
-0.15174992382526398,
-0.22897693514823914,
-0.07960005849599838,
0.307547003030777,
-0.5272092819213867,
-0.8287148475646973,
-0.8044224381446838,
-0.016558149829506874,
-0.3666762411594391,
-0.02749863639473915,
0.3870279788970947,
-0.06996401399374008,
-0.5449592471122742,
-0.16366474330425262,
-0.5642639994621277,
-0.6062548160552979,
-0.13033947348594666,
0.3360389769077301,
0.16142529249191284,
-0.37863320112228394,
1.0390105247497559,
0.5200028419494629,
0.6638626456260681,
-0.39584583044052124,
1.1343821287155151,
0.5342593193054199,
0.6717880368232727,
0.9029805660247803,
0.25431543588638306,
1.1965574026107788,
-0.5912357568740845,
0.09991847723722458,
0.243203803896904,
-0.47653815150260925,
0.649562656879425,
0.3316989839076996,
-0.25646770000457764,
0.034836966544389725,
-1.724308729171753,
-0.5026811957359314,
-0.6304845213890076,
-0.30830585956573486,
-0.24272248148918152,
-0.3965394198894501,
0.7083215713500977,
0.029017429798841476,
0.07205623388290405,
0.09054363518953323,
-0.11359784752130508,
-1.2617862224578857,
0.9978314638137817,
-0.6551982164382935,
-0.2575679123401642,
-0.40056052803993225,
-0.7699020504951477,
-0.21078120172023773,
0.5853360295295715,
0.2939845323562622,
0.6040763854980469,
0.5668699741363525,
-0.43026798963546753,
-0.44197073578834534,
-0.8027596473693848,
-0.28698161244392395,
-1.3445287942886353,
0.3985411822795868,
0.9314531683921814,
0.77792888879776,
0.5295882225036621,
-0.3649110198020935,
0.5901386737823486,
-0.08759378641843796,
0.2444050908088684,
-0.3543328046798706,
-1.1039189100265503,
-0.9938308000564575,
-0.6520962715148926,
0.5855985879898071,
-0.3663349151611328,
0.5655155181884766,
0.28468334674835205,
0.10547644644975662,
0.23761166632175446,
0.3909415006637573,
-0.24862295389175415,
-0.17617084085941315,
-0.2688463628292084,
-1.0657341480255127,
0.2048100084066391,
0.23353856801986694,
-1.0452241897583008,
-0.43165889382362366,
0.25767144560813904,
0.5229935050010681,
-0.7435452938079834,
0.07049687206745148,
1.2843046188354492,
-0.17645098268985748,
0.1277136355638504,
-0.9148868322372437,
0.5221465229988098,
-0.2168044000864029,
-0.5637173056602478,
-1.0606082677841187,
-0.6866235733032227,
-0.1664336770772934,
-0.07512832432985306,
-0.14343927800655365,
-0.40086543560028076,
0.18904075026512146,
0.4334840178489685,
0.5013667941093445,
-0.5282025933265686,
0.338883638381958,
0.35262537002563477,
-0.02390751615166664,
-0.8603986501693726,
0.40318775177001953,
0.05911162495613098,
-0.4485958218574524,
0.6895251274108887,
-0.8432233929634094,
-0.3858606815338135,
0.11324626207351685,
-0.46639856696128845,
-0.10059870034456253,
-0.9393298029899597,
0.8698009848594666,
-0.356050968170166,
-0.8998196125030518,
0.2967599034309387,
0.6087850332260132,
-0.0903821811079979,
-0.7652656435966492,
-0.718887209892273,
0.0038951041642576456,
-0.08955959230661392,
-0.22748082876205444,
0.37078672647476196,
0.5827252864837646,
-0.25572022795677185,
0.5127073526382446,
0.5896158218383789,
0.9884143471717834,
0.5438024997711182,
-0.3873533308506012,
0.5225139260292053,
-0.18305189907550812,
-0.4090019464492798,
0.8978162407875061,
-0.058180730789899826,
0.8509374260902405,
-0.3596709668636322,
-0.06500418484210968,
-0.7670937776565552,
0.06901782006025314,
0.48922693729400635,
-0.807659387588501,
0.2697065472602844,
-0.5293451547622681,
0.2986052632331848,
0.35988649725914,
0.27687498927116394,
0.3363388478755951,
0.39731207489967346,
1.2262482643127441,
-0.7482001185417175,
0.6285516023635864,
-0.5152097344398499,
0.23128075897693634,
0.03950655087828636,
-1.2976957559585571,
-0.47411078214645386,
0.2587892413139343,
-0.09072238951921463,
0.6489848494529724,
0.11681828647851944,
-0.5815932154655457,
-0.32369399070739746,
0.1515539586544037,
-0.11020161211490631,
0.6231745481491089,
0.5695156455039978,
1.3480714559555054,
-0.539097785949707,
-0.6266417503356934,
-0.7075223326683044,
0.24427396059036255,
-0.38612914085388184,
0.2483852505683899,
-0.8976780772209167,
-0.4741417467594147,
0.1486654132604599,
-0.6816052198410034,
-0.4103582501411438,
-0.39547356963157654,
-0.11551491171121597,
-0.09711465984582901,
-0.33959323167800903,
0.006549698766320944,
-0.04824432358145714,
0.0013856026344001293,
-0.4359641969203949,
-0.676361083984375,
-0.21875596046447754,
-0.6532944440841675,
0.13565334677696228,
0.8433781266212463,
0.8475766777992249,
-0.2251158356666565,
0.32055288553237915,
0.8152713179588318,
0.49666866660118103,
0.48805922269821167,
0.49209579825401306,
0.23274573683738708,
0.17054027318954468,
0.8870348930358887,
-0.1885555237531662,
-0.8894249200820923,
-0.9140592217445374,
-0.33153656125068665,
-0.22214427590370178,
-0.1588839590549469,
-0.5288928151130676,
0.5397140383720398,
-0.5484392642974854,
-0.34015047550201416,
-0.21280281245708466,
-0.09467598050832748,
-0.48214277625083923,
-0.49039697647094727,
0.9216475486755371,
0.17604054510593414,
0.39466288685798645,
0.08072126656770706,
-0.2823939025402069,
0.039382196962833405,
0.7360736131668091,
0.03838452696800232,
-0.00874068308621645,
0.5029518604278564,
0.4569973051548004,
0.29194375872612,
-0.8456810712814331,
0.03676803410053253,
-0.6645838618278503,
-0.2538820803165436,
0.5448051691055298,
0.5663158893585205,
0.32195040583610535,
0.31577223539352417,
0.2998387813568115,
0.1904338300228119,
0.04882519692182541,
0.17213237285614014,
-0.7005259394645691,
-1.398951530456543,
0.17879977822303772,
-0.05258604511618614,
-0.1057659387588501,
-0.3551931381225586,
-0.8531031012535095,
-0.08545169979333878,
0.5396356582641602,
-0.36919140815734863,
-0.10612516850233078,
0.4778445363044739,
-0.3136483430862427,
0.664283812046051,
-0.6902210712432861,
0.7284677624702454,
0.28288915753364563,
-0.1488277018070221,
-0.5262987017631531,
-0.9339153170585632,
0.9216781258583069,
0.22765062749385834,
0.44563063979148865,
0.2868427038192749,
-0.8585282564163208,
0.49771973490715027,
-0.9918026328086853,
-0.021290432661771774,
0.46439141035079956,
0.06256744265556335,
-0.36955001950263977,
-0.39851582050323486,
-0.5737518668174744,
-0.04087280109524727,
-0.6572572588920593,
0.7440532445907593,
0.6539559364318848,
-1.0297234058380127,
-1.4153802394866943,
-0.5215485692024231,
0.01218172162771225,
-1.0734885931015015,
0.6775826215744019,
0.04544955864548683,
-0.4975607693195343,
0.10592170059680939,
-0.815226674079895,
-0.5243044495582581,
0.5546838641166687,
0.49026790261268616,
-0.32341229915618896,
-0.8340820074081421,
0.2108549326658249,
0.7558805346488953,
0.14424772560596466,
0.12322717905044556,
-0.10665449500083923,
0.719329297542572,
0.26895037293434143,
0.4045240879058838,
-0.4793487787246704,
0.06991671025753021,
-0.6170606017112732,
-0.6414373517036438,
0.23494237661361694,
-0.38772082328796387,
0.07052862644195557,
-0.013790333643555641,
-0.871059238910675,
0.41221883893013,
-0.1605839729309082,
0.07995451241731644,
0.028734395280480385,
0.3394257128238678,
0.3692282736301422,
1.088892936706543,
0.510627806186676,
-0.03541748970746994,
0.3019416034221649,
0.31462544202804565,
0.29843276739120483,
0.2756248414516449,
0.2470339834690094,
0.2701006829738617,
-1.0965712070465088,
-0.45995092391967773,
0.06252728402614594,
-0.006452756468206644,
0.02580389752984047,
0.19645072519779205,
0.08239109814167023,
0.4280862510204315,
-0.7831085920333862,
0.04489714279770851,
-0.7264103889465332,
-0.416461318731308,
0.49767735600471497,
-0.5739039182662964,
1.3486236333847046,
-0.573710560798645,
0.0453919880092144,
-0.8110809326171875,
-0.17990602552890778,
-0.15498968958854675,
0.7365378141403198,
-0.19172492623329163,
0.48308035731315613,
0.20288126170635223,
0.17106305062770844,
0.34436142444610596,
-0.10120487958192825,
0.36607998609542847,
-0.951664924621582,
0.9367432594299316,
-0.2543339133262634,
0.18894368410110474,
0.4240715503692627,
-0.1285584717988968,
-0.20831385254859924,
-0.5054461359977722,
-0.9125463962554932,
-0.04320273548364639,
-0.24397696554660797,
0.6073253154754639,
0.318843811750412,
-1.5534441471099854,
0.14381571114063263,
-0.651947021484375,
-0.19132477045059204,
0.24486669898033142,
0.19309882819652557,
0.9164060950279236,
-0.5033254027366638,
-0.5656879544258118,
-0.14636506140232086,
0.12347399443387985,
-0.012094736099243164,
-1.1322524547576904,
0.25829607248306274,
0.11759623885154724,
-0.5763630867004395,
-1.644469976425171,
-0.3709368109703064,
0.636833667755127,
0.40653130412101746,
0.008031816221773624,
0.11312353610992432,
0.1292884349822998,
0.6800943613052368,
-0.2588536739349365,
-0.7563306093215942,
-0.3674786686897278,
0.27657029032707214,
0.45175448060035706,
0.5297424793243408,
0.5285212993621826,
-0.3802923858165741,
0.11752437800168991,
0.5533824563026428,
0.3668074607849121,
0.15647490322589874,
0.17553120851516724,
0.3426314890384674,
-0.7320756912231445,
-0.04340893030166626,
-0.4045014977455139,
-0.6053704619407654,
-0.07065390050411224,
0.31481313705444336,
0.8163301348686218,
-0.44707903265953064,
0.20205806195735931,
-0.88005530834198,
-0.8586428761482239,
-0.9918444156646729,
-0.29846158623695374,
-0.1753922551870346,
0.8153396248817444,
-1.0794020891189575,
0.6086946129798889,
-0.25918856263160706,
-0.9975674748420715,
3.8357090950012207,
-0.2783879339694977,
-0.3237631618976593,
0.513939619064331,
-0.44691434502601624,
0.21837572753429413,
0.5843493938446045,
-0.529416024684906,
-0.48354119062423706,
-0.12401039898395538,
-0.16735222935676575,
-0.9373677968978882,
0.18481415510177612,
0.03817480430006981,
0.3771788775920868,
1.5656818151474,
-0.49702346324920654,
0.011890214867889881,
0.9481024146080017,
-0.5390607118606567,
-0.12455429136753082,
-0.16816280782222748,
-0.1493890881538391,
1.1951497793197632,
0.6090366840362549,
0.2852695882320404,
-0.093654565513134,
-0.759573757648468,
0.3884320557117462,
-0.6958868503570557,
0.5284615755081177,
-0.983445405960083,
-0.44560691714286804,
-0.929366409778595,
-0.2461540699005127,
0.7898110151290894,
-0.16333289444446564,
-0.9419867396354675,
0.12553183734416962,
-0.1640757918357849,
0.2181176245212555,
0.1266283392906189,
0.006905361544340849,
0.07212496548891068,
-0.8763803243637085,
0.3583119809627533,
-0.6830518245697021,
0.7679897546768188,
1.0188515186309814,
-0.5896427035331726,
0.16794796288013458,
0.4191056191921234,
-0.10351067781448364,
0.040332548320293427,
-0.6666361689567566,
0.25288495421409607,
-0.42561641335487366,
-0.33065053820610046,
-0.8352540135383606,
-0.837584912776947,
-0.13402532041072845,
0.06364501267671585,
0.2902691066265106,
0.7175607085227966,
-0.31056907773017883,
0.22227123379707336,
1.2319445610046387,
-0.1675943285226822,
0.17226481437683105,
0.6077240109443665,
1.0704516172409058,
-0.13077235221862793,
0.34826570749282837,
0.2648809850215912,
-0.3338237404823303,
0.48312100768089294,
-0.1926214098930359,
0.666511058807373,
0.7622654438018799,
-0.58736252784729,
0.5927007794380188,
0.35374316573143005,
-0.46805742383003235,
0.22076646983623505,
0.7154968976974487,
0.9294034242630005,
-0.7190506458282471,
0.12894172966480255,
-0.7474321722984314,
-0.10482143610715866,
0.9837944507598877,
-0.4439113736152649,
-0.3297584354877472,
-0.2689650058746338,
-0.35611099004745483
] | {'id': 'C.A.1109_2013.pdf', 'url': ''} |
"IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN \n(APPELLATE JURISDICTION) \n \nPRESENT: \nMR. JUSTICE MUSHIR ALAM(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1113_2017.pdf', 'url': ''} | [-0.3040406107902527,-0.31058526039123535,0.27005207538604736,0.2103019505739212,0.02156168222427368(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1113_2017.pdf', 'url': ''} |
"IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN \n(APPELLATE JURISDICTION) \n \n \nPRESENT: \nMR. JUSTICE UMAR ATA(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1120_2009.pdf', 'url': ''} | [-0.7395765781402588,-0.1905161589384079,0.14870011806488037,0.36694949865341187,-0.2189891785383224(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1120_2009.pdf', 'url': ''} |
"IN THE SUPREME CO-URT OF PAKISTAN \n(Appellate Jurisdiction) \n \n \n \n \n \n \nPresent: \n \n \n (...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1122_2013.pdf', 'url': ''} | [-0.2232033759355545,-0.7887791991233826,0.35268357396125793,0.48700183629989624,-0.2853319346904754(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1122_2013.pdf', 'url': ''} |
"IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN \n(Appellate Jurisdiction) \n \n \n \n \n \n \nPRESENT: \n \n \n \(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1125_2007.pdf', 'url': ''} | [-0.13694067299365997,-0.27042868733406067,-0.07014770060777664,0.6450828909873962,-0.40436816215515(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1125_2007.pdf', 'url': ''} |
"In the Supreme Court of Pakistan \n(Appellate Jurisdiction) \n \n \nPresent: \nMr. Justice Anwar Za(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1125_2014.pdf', 'url': ''} | [-0.18728205561637878,0.2591976225376129,-0.051660217344760895,0.26248639822006226,-0.36236667633056(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1125_2014.pdf', 'url': ''} |
"IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN \n (APPELLATE JURISDICTION) \n \n \nPRESENT: \nMR. JUSTICE UMAR A(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1127_2011.pdf', 'url': ''} | [-0.1067533940076828,-0.15357497334480286,-0.4508538246154785,0.1523839384317398,-0.2102717310190200(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1127_2011.pdf', 'url': ''} |
"IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN \n(Appellate Jurisdiction) \n \nPRESENT: \n \nMR. JUSTICE MUSHIR A(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1129_2013.pdf', 'url': ''} | [-0.6902849078178406,-0.5465988516807556,0.22698940336704254,0.7990590333938599,-0.06518379598855972(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1129_2013.pdf', 'url': ''} |
"IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN \n(Appellate Jurisdiction) \n \n \nPresent: \nMr. Justice Mian Saq(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1132_2007.pdf', 'url': ''} | [-0.3489389717578888,-0.10111034661531448,0.26713818311691284,0.05593641847372055,-0.134655117988586(...TRUNCATED) | {'id': 'C.A.1132_2007.pdf', 'url': ''} |
End of preview. Expand
in Dataset Viewer.
Dataset Card for Pak-Law Dataset
Description
This dataset contains legal documents related to Pakistani law. It includes text data, case details, embeddings generated using the mixedbread-ai/mxbai-embed-large-v1 model, and citation numbers.
Dataset Structure
The dataset has the following features:
text: The text of the legal documents.case_details: Details about the legal cases.embeddings: Embeddings of the text, generated using themixedbread-ai/mxbai-embed-large-v1model.citation_number: Citation numbers for the legal cases.
The dataset contains 1,414 rows.
Usage
You can load the dataset using the datasets library:
from datasets import load_dataset
dataset = load_dataset("your-username/your-dataset-name")
- Downloads last month
- 42