title
stringlengths
12
89
date
stringlengths
10
17
paragraphs
list
Khashoggi murder: Body 'dissolved in acid'
2 November 2018
[ { "context": "A top Turkish official, presidential adviser Yasin Aktay, has said he believes Jamal Khashoggi's body was dissolved in acid after being cut up. The \"only logical conclusion\", he said, was that those who had killed the Saudi journalist in Istanbul had destroyed his body \"to leave no trace behind\". Khashoggi, a critic of Saudi rulers, was killed inside the country's consulate on 2 October. No forensic evidence has been provided to prove his body was dissolved. \"The reason they dismembered Khashoggi's body was to dissolve his remains more easily\", Mr Aktay told the Hurriyet Daily newspaper. \"Now we see that they did not only dismember his body but also vaporised it.\" The claims came as Khashoggi's fiancee, Hatice Cengiz, called on world leaders to \"bring the perpetrators to justice\", in an editorial for five newspapers, including the Guardian and the Washington Post. Meanwhile, reports quote Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman as telling the US he considered Khashoggi to be a dangerous Islamist. The reported phone call to the White House came before Saudi Arabia admitted Khashoggi had been killed. Saudi Arabia has denied the comments were made or that its royal family was involved in the killing, and says it is \"determined to find out all the facts\". Istanbul's prosecutor confirmed on Wednesday that the writer had been strangled. During the call with President Donald Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner and national security adviser John Bolton, Prince Mohammed said Khashoggi had been a member of the Muslim Brotherhood, a transnational Islamist organisation, the Washington Post reports. The phone call is reported to have taken place on 9 October, a week after Khashoggi disappeared. Prince Mohammed also reportedly urged the White House to preserve the US-Saudi alliance. In a statement to the newspaper, Khashoggi's family denied he had been a member of the Muslim Brotherhood and said the murdered writer had himself denied this repeatedly in recent years. \"Jamal Khashoggi was not a dangerous person in any way possible. To claim otherwise would be ridiculous,\" the statement said. There is still no consensus on how Khashoggi died. He entered the consulate to sort out documents for his marriage. But on Wednesday Turkey said he had been strangled immediately after entering the consulate and his body dismembered \"in accordance with plans made in advance\". Turkish media had previously quoted sources as saying Turkey had audio recordings proving that Khashoggi had been tortured before being murdered. Saudi Arabia has changed its account of what happened to Khashoggi. When he first disappeared, it said Khashoggi had walked out of the building alive. It later admitted he had been murdered, saying the killing was premeditated and a result of a \"rogue operation\". It has arrested 18 suspects who, it says, will be prosecuted in Saudi Arabia. Turkey wants the suspects to be extradited. Turkey has steered away from publicly blaming Saudi Arabia for the killing. President Recep Tayyip Erdogan spoke to Saudi King Salman last week, and the two agreed to continue co-operating in the investigation. Saudi Arabia has faced a backlash over the death, including from its allies, who have called for answers. President Trump has said he is \"not satisfied\" with the Saudi account. However, he also said he was unwilling to sacrifice lucrative arms deals with the country. Although their US visas have been revoked, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said it would be a \"handful more weeks\" before the US knew enough to impose sanctions on individuals involved in Khashoggi's killing. Mr Pompeo said the US had \"deep and long-term strategic relationships\" with Saudi Arabia and said \"we intend to make sure that those relationships remain intact\". On Wednesday, France's Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian said Khashoggi's death was a \"crime\" and \"odious\". He said France was not \"dependent on our economic relations with Saudi Arabia\" and the country would impose sanctions, but no details were given. UK Foreign Secretary Jeremy Hunt also said it was an appalling act, adding that it had \"possibly\" given the US and the UK a chance to put new pressure on Saudi Arabia over other issues. Earlier, the US called for a swift cessation of hostilities in Yemen, where a Saudi-led coalition has been fighting rebels supported by its arch-enemy Iran. In an editorial published in five international newspapers, Ms Cengiz said Khashoggi had just bought a house and wished to start a family. She described the \"anguish\" she had experienced since his \"brutal, barbaric and ruthless\" death. \"We must all send a clear message that authoritarian regimes cannot kill journalists ever again.\" She called on governments around the world to take action to reveal the truth, accusing the United States of taking a position \"devoid of moral foundation.\" \"If the democracies of the world do not take genuine steps to bring to justice the perpetrators of this brazen, callous act - one that has caused universal outrage among their citizens - what moral authority are they left with?\" she asked.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2108, "answer_start": 1352, "text": "During the call with President Donald Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner and national security adviser John Bolton, Prince Mohammed said Khashoggi had been a member of the Muslim Brotherhood, a transnational Islamist organisation, the Washington Post reports. The phone call is reported to have taken place on 9 October, a week after Khashoggi disappeared. Prince Mohammed also reportedly urged the White House to preserve the US-Saudi alliance. In a statement to the newspaper, Khashoggi's family denied he had been a member of the Muslim Brotherhood and said the murdered writer had himself denied this repeatedly in recent years. \"Jamal Khashoggi was not a dangerous person in any way possible. To claim otherwise would be ridiculous,\" the statement said." } ], "id": "0_0", "question": "What was said in the crown prince's alleged phone call?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3128, "answer_start": 2109, "text": "There is still no consensus on how Khashoggi died. He entered the consulate to sort out documents for his marriage. But on Wednesday Turkey said he had been strangled immediately after entering the consulate and his body dismembered \"in accordance with plans made in advance\". Turkish media had previously quoted sources as saying Turkey had audio recordings proving that Khashoggi had been tortured before being murdered. Saudi Arabia has changed its account of what happened to Khashoggi. When he first disappeared, it said Khashoggi had walked out of the building alive. It later admitted he had been murdered, saying the killing was premeditated and a result of a \"rogue operation\". It has arrested 18 suspects who, it says, will be prosecuted in Saudi Arabia. Turkey wants the suspects to be extradited. Turkey has steered away from publicly blaming Saudi Arabia for the killing. President Recep Tayyip Erdogan spoke to Saudi King Salman last week, and the two agreed to continue co-operating in the investigation." } ], "id": "0_1", "question": "What has the investigation found so far?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 4366, "answer_start": 3129, "text": "Saudi Arabia has faced a backlash over the death, including from its allies, who have called for answers. President Trump has said he is \"not satisfied\" with the Saudi account. However, he also said he was unwilling to sacrifice lucrative arms deals with the country. Although their US visas have been revoked, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said it would be a \"handful more weeks\" before the US knew enough to impose sanctions on individuals involved in Khashoggi's killing. Mr Pompeo said the US had \"deep and long-term strategic relationships\" with Saudi Arabia and said \"we intend to make sure that those relationships remain intact\". On Wednesday, France's Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian said Khashoggi's death was a \"crime\" and \"odious\". He said France was not \"dependent on our economic relations with Saudi Arabia\" and the country would impose sanctions, but no details were given. UK Foreign Secretary Jeremy Hunt also said it was an appalling act, adding that it had \"possibly\" given the US and the UK a chance to put new pressure on Saudi Arabia over other issues. Earlier, the US called for a swift cessation of hostilities in Yemen, where a Saudi-led coalition has been fighting rebels supported by its arch-enemy Iran." } ], "id": "0_2", "question": "What do other countries say?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 5097, "answer_start": 4367, "text": "In an editorial published in five international newspapers, Ms Cengiz said Khashoggi had just bought a house and wished to start a family. She described the \"anguish\" she had experienced since his \"brutal, barbaric and ruthless\" death. \"We must all send a clear message that authoritarian regimes cannot kill journalists ever again.\" She called on governments around the world to take action to reveal the truth, accusing the United States of taking a position \"devoid of moral foundation.\" \"If the democracies of the world do not take genuine steps to bring to justice the perpetrators of this brazen, callous act - one that has caused universal outrage among their citizens - what moral authority are they left with?\" she asked." } ], "id": "0_3", "question": "What has his fiancee said?" } ] } ]
Ex-Labour MP Luciana Berger switches to Lib Dems
5 September 2019
[ { "context": "Former Labour MP Luciana Berger has joined the Liberal Democrats, saying the party is \"unequivocal in wanting to stop Brexit\". She said leader Jo Swinson had offered \"a vital, positive alternative\" to Labour and the Conservatives. Ms Berger left Labour in protest at the handling of anti-Semitism allegations. Along with six other MPs she formed Change UK, but left after disappointing results in the European elections earlier this year. Ms Swinson said she was \"delighted\" to welcome Ms Berger to the Liberal Democrats. \"We're thrilled to add her perspective, expertise and skills to our ever-growing parliamentary team,\" she said. Speaking to the BBC, Ms Berger, MP for Liverpool Wavertree, said: \"We need to do everything possible to make sure the country, when the election comes, has a proper choice rather than choosing between the two terrible options of Johnson vs Corbyn.\" \"The two-party system is over,\" she added. Nina Houghton, Labour's constituency chairman in Wavertree, said Ms Berger was \"ignoring the 80% of Wavertree voters who voted Labour\". She accused the MP of lacking the \"courage\" to resign and hold a by-election. Ms Berger is the fourth MP in three months to join the Liberal Democrats - who now have 16 MPs in Parliament. On Tuesday, Conservative Phillip Lee defected to the party, accusing the government of \"pursuing a damaging Brexit in unprincipled ways\", putting lives and livelihoods at risk. Ex-Change UK MPs Chuka Umunna and Sarah Wollaston have also joined the party. Ms Berger has been the MP for Liverpool Wavertree since 2010, where she has a majority of 29,466. As an MP she held a number of posts, including shadow minister for energy and climate, shadow minister for public health and shadow minister for mental health. Before becoming an MP she worked for management consultancy company Accenture and the NHS Confederation, a body representing healthcare organisations. Before leaving the Labour Party, she faced the threat of a no-confidence vote from local Labour members for criticising Jeremy Corbyn, but it was withdrawn after individuals in the constituency party were accused of \"bullying\" her. Shadow chancellor John McDonnell said any attempts to deselect her had been a result of her association with a breakaway party. She attended a protest against anti-Semitism in the Labour Party in Westminster's Parliament Square in March 2018, and has campaigned vigorously on the issue. This is not massively surprising. We have seen a steady trickle of those unaligned, lost MPs moving to the Lib Dems. The Remainers are beginning to shuffle towards the Lib Dems as the most clear, overt force for Remain. There is no doubt that Brexit is now really beginning to play for the party. For everyone who wants to stop Brexit, they are a natural home. And new leader Jo Swinson has injected a bit of energy and colour which frankly Vince Cable was unable to do. They've got a bit of mojo and we've seen that in the polls too.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2432, "answer_start": 1505, "text": "Ms Berger has been the MP for Liverpool Wavertree since 2010, where she has a majority of 29,466. As an MP she held a number of posts, including shadow minister for energy and climate, shadow minister for public health and shadow minister for mental health. Before becoming an MP she worked for management consultancy company Accenture and the NHS Confederation, a body representing healthcare organisations. Before leaving the Labour Party, she faced the threat of a no-confidence vote from local Labour members for criticising Jeremy Corbyn, but it was withdrawn after individuals in the constituency party were accused of \"bullying\" her. Shadow chancellor John McDonnell said any attempts to deselect her had been a result of her association with a breakaway party. She attended a protest against anti-Semitism in the Labour Party in Westminster's Parliament Square in March 2018, and has campaigned vigorously on the issue." } ], "id": "1_0", "question": "Who is Luciana Berger?" } ] } ]
Trump backs off proposed Special Olympics funding cuts
28 March 2019
[ { "context": "President Donald Trump has said he is reversing a budget request to eliminate funding for the Special Olympics. His remarks came a day after education secretary Betsy DeVos was criticised for defending a proposed $17.6m (PS13.5m) cut to the organisation, which is designed for disabled children. The request was included in Mr Trump's $4.75tn federal budget, which was not expected to pass Congress. Mrs DeVos responded she had pushed for funding \"behind the scenes\". \"I heard about it this morning. I have overridden my people. We're funding the Special Olympics,\" Mr Trump said of the world's largest sport organisation for people with intellectual disabilities. Mrs DeVos rushed to clarify the contradiction on Thursday, tweeting: \"I am pleased and grateful the President and I see eye-to-eye on this issue and that he has decided to fund our Special Olympics grant.\" She had earlier told Congress the US Department of Education had to make \"tough choices\" following a 10% cut to her agency's budget, adding that the nonprofit group should be funded through private donations. The cuts came as part of the administration's proposed budget for the 2020 fiscal year, which totals $4.75tn, the largest in federal history. The budget request slashed $17.6m in funding for the Special Olympics, about 10% of the nonprofit organisation's overall revenue. Majority of the group's support comes from individual and corporate donations as well as fundraising campaigns. The spending plan also included more than $1tn in cuts to the Medicaid health programme for the poor and disabled, while allotting $8.6bn for the US-Mexico border wall. But the budget proposal is not expected to pass Congress, which must approve it. Who would the cuts affect? Andrea Cahn, the Senior Director of Unified Champion Schools for Special Olympics who runs the Unified Champion programmes in the United States says the budget cuts would have affected programmes in 6,500 schools. \"The funding we receive from the US Department of Education is specifically for our Unified Champion schools programming,\" says Ms Cahn though the budget cuts would not impact any state games, world games, or any ongoing competitions that are scheduled. Raymond S Kellis High School in Arizona is one of the schools that has adopted this type of programme. It has enabled children with intellectual disabilities to be more outgoing says Michael Wakeford, a special education teacher and Unified Sports coach at the school. \"It helps our society bring faith back to humanity in a divisive world in a place where it's easy to fear what we don't know and to fear what we don't understand,\" Mr Wakeford adds. The Special Olympics, founded in 1968 in Washington DC, provides year-round training, health education, community building and athletic competition for children and adults with intellectual disabilities. It currently serves over five million athletes across 190 countries. The sports organisation is separate from the Paralympics, which are mostly for elite athletes who have physical disabilities. Both groups are recognised by the International Olympics Committee. The US Special Olympics chapter provides trainings and competitions in 18 sports, including soccer, swimming, equestrian and basketball. The Special Olympics World Games, which took place in Abu Dhabi earlier this month, are held every two years. Reporting by Sarah Shaath", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2660, "answer_start": 1080, "text": "The cuts came as part of the administration's proposed budget for the 2020 fiscal year, which totals $4.75tn, the largest in federal history. The budget request slashed $17.6m in funding for the Special Olympics, about 10% of the nonprofit organisation's overall revenue. Majority of the group's support comes from individual and corporate donations as well as fundraising campaigns. The spending plan also included more than $1tn in cuts to the Medicaid health programme for the poor and disabled, while allotting $8.6bn for the US-Mexico border wall. But the budget proposal is not expected to pass Congress, which must approve it. Who would the cuts affect? Andrea Cahn, the Senior Director of Unified Champion Schools for Special Olympics who runs the Unified Champion programmes in the United States says the budget cuts would have affected programmes in 6,500 schools. \"The funding we receive from the US Department of Education is specifically for our Unified Champion schools programming,\" says Ms Cahn though the budget cuts would not impact any state games, world games, or any ongoing competitions that are scheduled. Raymond S Kellis High School in Arizona is one of the schools that has adopted this type of programme. It has enabled children with intellectual disabilities to be more outgoing says Michael Wakeford, a special education teacher and Unified Sports coach at the school. \"It helps our society bring faith back to humanity in a divisive world in a place where it's easy to fear what we don't know and to fear what we don't understand,\" Mr Wakeford adds." } ], "id": "2_0", "question": "What was proposed?" } ] } ]
How African governments block social media
25 April 2016
[ { "context": "A small but increasing group of African governments is blocking social media during elections. Clare Spencer asks why and how this is done and how people get around it. Why are African governments blocking social media? It is safe to say governments aren't blocking social media to cut off the supply of cute kitten pictures. It's political. African tweeters tend to be more political than tweeters in other continents, according to research by Portland Communications. And governments are blocking social media during elections - most recently in Congo-Brazzaville, Chad and Uganda. For an indication of the political impact social media can make, you just need to look at the uprisings during the \"Arab Spring\". \"Social media did not cause the 'Arab Spring' but helped to co-ordinate it,\" Arthur Goldstuck from technology market research company Worldwide Worx, told the BBC. Governments do not say they are worried that social media could pave the way for popular protests or even a revolution. But security is often cited - including in the order for mobile operators to stop services in Congo-Brazzaville. Congolese officials added that they were trying to prevent the \"illegal publication of results\". Newsweek interpreted this as a possible attempt to thwart the efforts of election monitors. The advent of the mobile phone enabled local observer groups to collate the results from individual polling stations around the country and add them up to see if the results were being rigged. If mobile phones don't work, this can no longer be done. However, results spread by opposition parties are also not necessarily accurate and Uganda's President Yoweri Museveni insisted that social media was blocked during the election to \"stop spreading lies\". How do governments block social media? Governments don't have the physical or technical ability to block sites, phones or texts themselves, explains Thecla Mbongue, analyst for trend forecasters Ovum. They issue an order to the companies who do have that power. Congo-Brazzaville's government issued an order to the country's mobile phone operators such as Airtel and MTN. This effectively blocks the internet because very few Congolese use fixed lines to access the web. Ms Mbongue says that the order in Congo-Brazzaville appeared to allow specified numbers to carry on using their mobile phones. This came out when the communications minister denied the communications block - by tweeting. The interesting thing about the tweet for her is that someone replied with what appears to be a copy of the order sent to mobile operators. It shows they were asked not to block specified numbers. Presumably, she says, that is why Mr Moungalla could tweet and others couldn't. Airtel and MTN have not yet confirmed whether the orders that spread through social networks were authentic. In the case of Uganda, the telecoms regulator ordered mobile phone operators just to block certain sites. So people couldn't use Facebook, WhatsApp, Twitter and mobile money services. Danson Njue, also from Ovum, says it is believed that the regulator was advised by top security and government officials to block the sites over security concerns. Technically, this is a relatively easy task. Websites are stored on servers which have IP addresses - a bit like a phone number. The government can force internet service providers and telecoms companies to block access to a specific IP address. Smartphone apps, like WhatsApp, will try to connect to its own server and it won't be able to if your internet service provider is blocking connections. So it is fairly easy to pinpoint a specific site or app and block access. This makes social networks fairly powerless. Twitter did not even condemn the ban when the company noted it was blocked in Uganda. But telecoms companies appear to be powerless too. Ms Mbongue says she cannot think of a single example in sub-Saharan Africa where the telecoms provider has refused to comply with an order. She speculates that phone companies could go to court to demand compensation for lost earnings. But she is unaware of this ever having happened. This is in contrast to the Twitter ban in Turkey which was lifted after two weeks when the constitutional court ruled the ban was a breach of the right to freedom of expression. Mr Goldstruck adds that because mobile operators work under strict licensing conditions, they have to comply with such government directives. It is different where there are numerous service providers and numerous routes out of the country, as in Egypt. Twitter was blocked in Egypt in January 2011, when hundreds of thousands of protestors started to gather in Tahrir Square in the capital Egypt. They had used the hashtag #Jan25 to co-ordinate. But it wasn't long before Twitter was working again. Even in this case, internet access was still reduced dramatically, he says. Many people have found ways to get around government blocks by using internet proxies known as Virtual Private Networks (VPNs). In Uganda an opposition leader even tweeted on the day of the election a recommendation to download a VPN app called Tunnel Bear. The top 12 apps people were downloading in Uganda four days after the election were still VPN apps, according to analysts App Annie. But Congo-Brazzaville and Chad cut off the whole internet and telephone which meant people couldn't use this technique. VPNs get round government censorship by redirecting your internet activity to a computer in a different country, where the blocks have not been imposed. This is also used by people to access content that might be restricted to a certain country - letting a European user watch American Netflix, for example. What next? Zimbabwe has suggested it could go one step further and create its own social networks that the state can monitor. The country's state owned newspaper the Sunday Mail reports that local web developers are \"stitching together\" products similar to Facebook, Twitter and Skype \"to enable great supervision\". The newspaper nods to China, where this has already happened. Are Rwanda's buses first stop towards a cashless future? What difference will Obama's plan to bring power to Africa make? Africa's top Twitter moments of the past decade My life as an internet conman in Ghana", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 6072, "answer_start": 4876, "text": "Many people have found ways to get around government blocks by using internet proxies known as Virtual Private Networks (VPNs). In Uganda an opposition leader even tweeted on the day of the election a recommendation to download a VPN app called Tunnel Bear. The top 12 apps people were downloading in Uganda four days after the election were still VPN apps, according to analysts App Annie. But Congo-Brazzaville and Chad cut off the whole internet and telephone which meant people couldn't use this technique. VPNs get round government censorship by redirecting your internet activity to a computer in a different country, where the blocks have not been imposed. This is also used by people to access content that might be restricted to a certain country - letting a European user watch American Netflix, for example. What next? Zimbabwe has suggested it could go one step further and create its own social networks that the state can monitor. The country's state owned newspaper the Sunday Mail reports that local web developers are \"stitching together\" products similar to Facebook, Twitter and Skype \"to enable great supervision\". The newspaper nods to China, where this has already happened." } ], "id": "3_0", "question": "How do people get around the block?" } ] } ]
How to make phone batteries that last longer
29 November 2019
[ { "context": "When Professor Akira Yoshino was developing a new battery technology in his laboratory in the early 1980s, he didn't think it would amount to much. \"At the time, we thought it mainly would be used in 8mm video cameras,\" he laughs. He was well off the mark. These days you are never more than a few feet away from a lithium-ion battery, as they power mobile phones and all sorts of other electronics, from toothbrushes to electric scooters. In recognition of that success, Prof Yoshino was awarded the 2019 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. But despite improvements, even the most advanced lithium-ion batteries can only store a fraction of the energy of a similar weight of petrol or jet fuel. And that is curbing ambitions for even smaller and lighter devices - and more ambitious projects like electric powered aviation. Batteries need to make progress, admits Prof Yoshino, but thankfully, \"there's a lot of interesting approaches\". And \"the solid state battery, I think, is a promising one,\" he says. Solid state batteries can store 50% more energy than lithium-ion, says Douglas Campbell, chief executive of Solid Power, a Colorado university spin-off. They are more stable as well. In lithium-ion batteries the gel inside, the electrolyte, can combust. In 2016, Samsung recalled 2.5 million Galaxy Note 7 handsets after fires involving their lithium-ion batteries. Solid state batteries replace that gel with less flammable solid polymers or ceramics. But the batteries being developed by Mr Campbell's firm still require lithium in its metallic form and that's a problem because it is a hard metal to work with. Another problem is that lithium metal isn't yet refined on an industrial scale, so just getting enough could be difficult, according to Mr Campbell. But despite those worries, solid state batteries have \"had the breakthrough in basic research, and research and development for mass production techniques is progressing,\" says Prof Yoshino. He thinks it could take another 10 years for solid state batteries to compete with lithium-ion in terms of price. The big prize in the market is batteries for electric cars. The number of electric vehicles in the world will balloon to 125 million by 2030, the International Energy Agency forecasts. Battery innovation is \"pretty much driven by whatever's happening in the electric vehicle market\", says Rory McCarthy, an analyst at energy research firm Wood Mackenzie. More Technology of Business Mr McCarthy says the challenge for solid state and other new technologies is to compete with lithium-ion plants, which are getting bigger and bigger, making their batteries cheaper. It takes a new battery factory four to five years to get close to full capacity and 10 years to make its money back, he adds. Lithium-ion technology itself is not a dead end. \"We're learning some new principles we haven't thought of before,\" says Prof Yoshino. That includes the movement of lithium-ions inside batteries. \"We thought we understood that,\" he adds. But now scientists are having to revisit their understanding, since it \"is not what we expected\". \"Yes, it goes on and on it never ends\", he laughs. Gene Berdichevsky says that it's only lithium-ion batteries that can make a \"meaningful\" impact on batteries in the near future and spur the mass adoption of electric vehicles. His California-based company, Sila Nanotechnologies, is developing lithium-ion batteries that can potentially deliver a 40% improvement in energy density. They are doing that by by replacing the graphite anodes (the part of the battery where the current flows in) with silicon. \"We need continued investment and innovation in lithium-ion batteries,\" he says. Better battery density could make big differences in the way we live. Aeroplanes release 500 million tonnes of CO2 into the atmosphere each year. But with better batteries, aircraft can use cleaner power and that revolution is already underway. This year's Paris air show saw a working all-electric prototype commercial aircraft, made by the Israeli start-up, Eviation. US regional airline Cape Air has placed a double-digit order. Meanwhile Canada's Harbour Air said in March it aims to become the world's first all-electric airline. With 30% of flights under 300 miles, short haul flight should be easy to electrify, says Los Angeles start-up Wright Electric. And much denser batteries could also electrify big lorries that today rely on fossil fuels. Meanwhile, for some better batteries could change their lives. \"I have an off-road chair with six wheels,\" says Curt Oswalt, a former US air force translator who uses a battery-powered wheelchair after a 2002 injury. \"My batteries first started acting up roughly two years ago,\" he says. One night, unable to sleep, he went for a 01:00 stroll around his neighbourhood in the Texan countryside. \"My battery indicator went from reading three-quarters full to dead, in under three seconds,\" he says. Stranded, he had to wait under a street light until 04:30, when a sheriff found him and helped him home. A more recent battery failure has meant he's been unable to leave his house unassisted for nine days. \"So yes,\" he says, \"looking forward to better batteries!\"", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 5195, "answer_start": 3680, "text": "Better battery density could make big differences in the way we live. Aeroplanes release 500 million tonnes of CO2 into the atmosphere each year. But with better batteries, aircraft can use cleaner power and that revolution is already underway. This year's Paris air show saw a working all-electric prototype commercial aircraft, made by the Israeli start-up, Eviation. US regional airline Cape Air has placed a double-digit order. Meanwhile Canada's Harbour Air said in March it aims to become the world's first all-electric airline. With 30% of flights under 300 miles, short haul flight should be easy to electrify, says Los Angeles start-up Wright Electric. And much denser batteries could also electrify big lorries that today rely on fossil fuels. Meanwhile, for some better batteries could change their lives. \"I have an off-road chair with six wheels,\" says Curt Oswalt, a former US air force translator who uses a battery-powered wheelchair after a 2002 injury. \"My batteries first started acting up roughly two years ago,\" he says. One night, unable to sleep, he went for a 01:00 stroll around his neighbourhood in the Texan countryside. \"My battery indicator went from reading three-quarters full to dead, in under three seconds,\" he says. Stranded, he had to wait under a street light until 04:30, when a sheriff found him and helped him home. A more recent battery failure has meant he's been unable to leave his house unassisted for nine days. \"So yes,\" he says, \"looking forward to better batteries!\"" } ], "id": "4_0", "question": "Electric flight?" } ] } ]
Plague deaths: Quarantine lifted after couple die of bubonic plague
7 May 2019
[ { "context": "A quarantine imposed in Mongolia after two people died from the bubonic plague has been lifted, allowing a number of tourists to leave the area. The Mongolian couple contracted the illness after eating the raw meat of a marmot, a type of rodent. Following their deaths, a six-day quarantine was declared on 1 May in Mongolia's western Bayan Olgii province bordering both China and Russia. In previous centuries plague outbreaks killed millions in Europe and Asia. Human cases are now rare but can still be deadly unless treated with antibiotics. The couple had eaten raw marmot meat and kidney, thought to be a folk remedy for good health, Ariuntuya Ochirpurev of the World Health Organisation (WHO) in Ulaanbaatar told the BBC. Suspicion the two victims had developed the highly contagious pneumonic plague led to the decision to impose the quarantine, Ms Ochirpurev added. The rodent is a known carrier of the plague bacteria and it is commonly associated with plague cases in the country. Hunting the rodent is illegal. According to Ms Ochirpurev, 118 people had come into contact with the couple and were isolated and treated with antibiotics for prophylaxis. Among those were seven foreign tourists from Switzerland, Sweden, Kazakhstan and South Korea. Media reports, however, put the number of tourists much higher, saying travellers from Russia, Germany and the US were barred from leaving the area due to the quarantine. \"After the quarantine [was announced] not many people, even locals, were in the streets for fear of catching the disease,\" Sebastian Pique, a US Peace Corps volunteer living in the region, told the AFP news agency. While rare, the plague still continues to be a threat to humans. The disease - typically transmitted from animals to humans by fleas - has a 30%-60% fatality rate if left untreated. In Mongolia, one case was reported in 2017 but it was not fatal. In 2016, no cases were reported. From 1989 to 1997, there were 69 cases in the country and 22 deaths, according to the WHO's Ms Ochirpurev. The US also still has annual cases of the disease and 12 recorded fatalities since 2000. In 2015, parts of the Yosemite National Park had to be closed due to an outbreak of the plague. Symptoms of the plague include high fever, chills, nausea, weakness and swollen lymph nodes in the neck, armpit or groin. It can be hard to identify in its early stages because symptoms, which usually develop after three to seven days, are flu-like. There are three main types of plague depending on how the infection manifests. The bubonic plague is characterised by swollen lymph nodes. Pneumonic plague affects the respiratory system. It becomes septicaemic if it is found in the bloodstream. The Black Death, as it was known at the time, caused about 50 million deaths across Africa, Asia and Europe in the 14th Century. Its last terrifying outbreak in London was the Great Plague of 1665, which killed about a fifth of the city's inhabitants. In the 19th Century there was a plague outbreak in China and India, which killed more than 12 million.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1643, "answer_start": 546, "text": "The couple had eaten raw marmot meat and kidney, thought to be a folk remedy for good health, Ariuntuya Ochirpurev of the World Health Organisation (WHO) in Ulaanbaatar told the BBC. Suspicion the two victims had developed the highly contagious pneumonic plague led to the decision to impose the quarantine, Ms Ochirpurev added. The rodent is a known carrier of the plague bacteria and it is commonly associated with plague cases in the country. Hunting the rodent is illegal. According to Ms Ochirpurev, 118 people had come into contact with the couple and were isolated and treated with antibiotics for prophylaxis. Among those were seven foreign tourists from Switzerland, Sweden, Kazakhstan and South Korea. Media reports, however, put the number of tourists much higher, saying travellers from Russia, Germany and the US were barred from leaving the area due to the quarantine. \"After the quarantine [was announced] not many people, even locals, were in the streets for fear of catching the disease,\" Sebastian Pique, a US Peace Corps volunteer living in the region, told the AFP news agency." } ], "id": "5_0", "question": "What happened?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3066, "answer_start": 1644, "text": "While rare, the plague still continues to be a threat to humans. The disease - typically transmitted from animals to humans by fleas - has a 30%-60% fatality rate if left untreated. In Mongolia, one case was reported in 2017 but it was not fatal. In 2016, no cases were reported. From 1989 to 1997, there were 69 cases in the country and 22 deaths, according to the WHO's Ms Ochirpurev. The US also still has annual cases of the disease and 12 recorded fatalities since 2000. In 2015, parts of the Yosemite National Park had to be closed due to an outbreak of the plague. Symptoms of the plague include high fever, chills, nausea, weakness and swollen lymph nodes in the neck, armpit or groin. It can be hard to identify in its early stages because symptoms, which usually develop after three to seven days, are flu-like. There are three main types of plague depending on how the infection manifests. The bubonic plague is characterised by swollen lymph nodes. Pneumonic plague affects the respiratory system. It becomes septicaemic if it is found in the bloodstream. The Black Death, as it was known at the time, caused about 50 million deaths across Africa, Asia and Europe in the 14th Century. Its last terrifying outbreak in London was the Great Plague of 1665, which killed about a fifth of the city's inhabitants. In the 19th Century there was a plague outbreak in China and India, which killed more than 12 million." } ], "id": "5_1", "question": "How dangerous is the plague now?" } ] } ]
Is China-Pakistan 'silk road' a game-changer?
22 April 2015
[ { "context": "China has announced a $46bn investment plan which will largely centre on an economic corridor from Gwadar in Pakistan to Kashgar in the Chinese region of Xinjiang. The BBC's M Ilyas Khan looks at the significance of the plans. The money China is planning to pour into Pakistan is more than twice the amount of all foreign direct investment (FDI) Pakistan has received since 2008, and considerably more than the entire assistance from the United States, Pakistan's largest donor until now, since 2002. Pakistani officials say most projects will reach completion in between one and three years, although some infrastructure projects could take from 10 to 15 years. So the investment is not going to be spread too thin over a longer period of time, as happened with the US assistance. Also, this investment will be heavily concentrated in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), a combination of transport and energy projects and the development of a major deep-sea port offering direct access to the Indian Ocean and beyond. Experts say this will create jobs and spark economic activity in Pakistan which over the last three decades has become a cranky, rent-seeking military power torn by armed insurgencies and a failing system of service delivery. But as defence analyst Professor Hasan Askari Rizvi warns, the real game changer is not the signing of deals, but their timely execution. Officials admit that some deals already signed by China and Pakistan in 2010 might not reach completion. If that turns out to be the case, they admit it will mostly have been due to incompetence, corruption and lack of transparency. So if anything is to come out of the present deals, the Pakistanis will need to work harder to fulfil their part of institutional, legal, financial and logistical commitments. Some level of corruption is expected at both ends, and neither country is known for encouraging transparency. So we may not know until much later how much of this money is coming in the form of loans, how much in grants and how much in the shape of public or private investment. There is also a political dispute brewing in Pakistan, with some politicians threatening to oppose the corridor if its route is not planned along some specific areas. Economic expert Dr Kaisar Bengali says that while Pakistan has many problems to overcome, its move to end militant sanctuaries in the north-west has created an air of expectancy, and the arrival of Chinese investment at this time suggests Pakistan has a once-in-a-lifetime chance to make an economic turnaround. \"This is Pakistan's first opportunity since the 1960 Indus Water Treaty to change its economic geography,\" he says. The economic corridor starts at Gwadar and ends at Kashgar. Gwadar is located on the Arabian Sea coast of Balochistan, a province in south-west Pakistan which is wracked by a decade-old separatist insurgency. Kashgar is located at the centre of China's only Muslim-majority, Turkic-speaking Xinjiang region. It is populated mainly by ethnic Uighur Muslims, and has been home to a separatist movement since the mid-1990s. There has been a recent upsurge in violence which China blames on separatist \"terrorists\". Between Gwadar and Kashgar, the corridor passes through areas that are within striking range of Pakistan's Taliban insurgents. Until recently they controlled territory along Pakistan's north-western border with Afghanistan, and hosted the largest concentration of Uighur militants outside China. They still have a presence in the border region, though their sanctuaries have been disrupted by a Pakistani military operation that began last June. Both Uighur and Pakistani Taliban militants have been targeting Chinese nationals in Pakistan. The Baloch insurgents have their roots in socialist ideology, but they too dismiss the Chinese as allies of Punjab, Pakistan's most populous province which they accuse of \"robbing\" Balochistan's resources. A former diplomat, Ashraf Jehangir Qazi, said in a TV debate that the Pakistani army has decided to raise a special force to safeguard this 3,000km corridor. Many are sceptical because the army previously failed to ensure a trouble-free supply to Nato troops in Afghanistan. But some believe the military is likely to treat the Chinese corridor differently because the economic benefits accruing from it could help isolate Baloch insurgents. Pakistanis have long described their \"friendship\" with China as higher than the Himalayas, deeper than the oceans, and as information minister Pervez Rashid put it more recently, sweeter than honey. But behind these lofty words lie some hard-core interests. China has been a more reliable and less meddlesome supplier of military hardware to Pakistan than the US, and is therefore seen by Pakistanis as a silent ally against arch-rival India. Friendly exchanges with China also help Pakistan show to its \"more volatile\" allies in the west, notably the US, that it has other powerful friends as well. For the Chinese, the relationship has a geo-strategic significance. The corridor through Gwadar gives them their shortest access to the Middle East and Africa, where thousands of Chinese firms, employing tens of thousands of Chinese workers, are involved in development work. The corridor also promises to open up remote, landlocked Xinjiang, and create incentives for both state and private enterprises to expand economic activity and create jobs in this under-developed region. China could also be trying to find alternative trade routes to by-pass the Malacca straits, presently the only maritime route China can use to access the Middle East, Africa and Europe. Apart from being long, it can be blockaded in times of war. This may be the reason China is also pursuing an eastern corridor to the Bay of Bengal, expected to pass through parts of Myanmar, Bangladesh and possibly India. Experts say much of Chinese activity is geared towards boosting domestic income and consumption as its previous policy of encouraging cheap exports is no longer enough to sustain growth. On the external front, it is investing in a number of ports in Asia in an apparent attempt to access sources of energy and increase its influence over maritime routes. There are indications the Americans have been encouraging China to play a stabilising role in Afghanistan. And few in Pakistan believe that American influence is likely to significantly recede from this region in the short run. In the long run, though, the Americans will definitely be working on strategies to cope with the rise of Russia and China, and what that means for the resource-rich regions of Central Asia and the Middle East. Likewise, while the Indians have China as one of their largest trading partners, they may have long-term security concerns about Chinese control of the Pakistani port of Gwadar.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1391, "answer_start": 227, "text": "The money China is planning to pour into Pakistan is more than twice the amount of all foreign direct investment (FDI) Pakistan has received since 2008, and considerably more than the entire assistance from the United States, Pakistan's largest donor until now, since 2002. Pakistani officials say most projects will reach completion in between one and three years, although some infrastructure projects could take from 10 to 15 years. So the investment is not going to be spread too thin over a longer period of time, as happened with the US assistance. Also, this investment will be heavily concentrated in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), a combination of transport and energy projects and the development of a major deep-sea port offering direct access to the Indian Ocean and beyond. Experts say this will create jobs and spark economic activity in Pakistan which over the last three decades has become a cranky, rent-seeking military power torn by armed insurgencies and a failing system of service delivery. But as defence analyst Professor Hasan Askari Rizvi warns, the real game changer is not the signing of deals, but their timely execution." } ], "id": "6_0", "question": "Why has this got people talking?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2674, "answer_start": 1392, "text": "Officials admit that some deals already signed by China and Pakistan in 2010 might not reach completion. If that turns out to be the case, they admit it will mostly have been due to incompetence, corruption and lack of transparency. So if anything is to come out of the present deals, the Pakistanis will need to work harder to fulfil their part of institutional, legal, financial and logistical commitments. Some level of corruption is expected at both ends, and neither country is known for encouraging transparency. So we may not know until much later how much of this money is coming in the form of loans, how much in grants and how much in the shape of public or private investment. There is also a political dispute brewing in Pakistan, with some politicians threatening to oppose the corridor if its route is not planned along some specific areas. Economic expert Dr Kaisar Bengali says that while Pakistan has many problems to overcome, its move to end militant sanctuaries in the north-west has created an air of expectancy, and the arrival of Chinese investment at this time suggests Pakistan has a once-in-a-lifetime chance to make an economic turnaround. \"This is Pakistan's first opportunity since the 1960 Indus Water Treaty to change its economic geography,\" he says." } ], "id": "6_1", "question": "But what will happen to all that money?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 6218, "answer_start": 4376, "text": "Pakistanis have long described their \"friendship\" with China as higher than the Himalayas, deeper than the oceans, and as information minister Pervez Rashid put it more recently, sweeter than honey. But behind these lofty words lie some hard-core interests. China has been a more reliable and less meddlesome supplier of military hardware to Pakistan than the US, and is therefore seen by Pakistanis as a silent ally against arch-rival India. Friendly exchanges with China also help Pakistan show to its \"more volatile\" allies in the west, notably the US, that it has other powerful friends as well. For the Chinese, the relationship has a geo-strategic significance. The corridor through Gwadar gives them their shortest access to the Middle East and Africa, where thousands of Chinese firms, employing tens of thousands of Chinese workers, are involved in development work. The corridor also promises to open up remote, landlocked Xinjiang, and create incentives for both state and private enterprises to expand economic activity and create jobs in this under-developed region. China could also be trying to find alternative trade routes to by-pass the Malacca straits, presently the only maritime route China can use to access the Middle East, Africa and Europe. Apart from being long, it can be blockaded in times of war. This may be the reason China is also pursuing an eastern corridor to the Bay of Bengal, expected to pass through parts of Myanmar, Bangladesh and possibly India. Experts say much of Chinese activity is geared towards boosting domestic income and consumption as its previous policy of encouraging cheap exports is no longer enough to sustain growth. On the external front, it is investing in a number of ports in Asia in an apparent attempt to access sources of energy and increase its influence over maritime routes." } ], "id": "6_2", "question": "Why is China doing this?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 6834, "answer_start": 6219, "text": "There are indications the Americans have been encouraging China to play a stabilising role in Afghanistan. And few in Pakistan believe that American influence is likely to significantly recede from this region in the short run. In the long run, though, the Americans will definitely be working on strategies to cope with the rise of Russia and China, and what that means for the resource-rich regions of Central Asia and the Middle East. Likewise, while the Indians have China as one of their largest trading partners, they may have long-term security concerns about Chinese control of the Pakistani port of Gwadar." } ], "id": "6_3", "question": "What do the US and India think?" } ] } ]
Tajiks vote in referendum on banning religious parties
22 May 2016
[ { "context": "The people of mainly Muslim Tajikistan have voted on a proposal to ban religion-based parties, in a poll set to strengthen the president's power. Emomali Rakhmon has ruled the ex-Soviet Central Asian republic since 1992, surviving a civil war which ended in a deal with the Islamist opposition. Moves to ban the opposition Islamic Renaissance Party began last year. The results of the referendum, which also asks for presidential term limits to be lifted, are due on Monday. According to state news agency Khovar, turnout had reached 88.3% two hours before polling stations closed at 20:00 (15:00 GMT). Elections in Tajikistan have long been criticised by outside observers for failing to meet basic democratic standards. The referendum also proposes lowering the age limit for running for president from 35 to 30 - a move that would theoretically allow Mr Rakhmon's son Rustam, who is 29, to run for office in 2020. The three points are contained in a parliamentary bill on amendments to the constitution. The single question on the ballot form was \"Do you support the amendments and additions to the constitution of the country?\" Tajikistan is one of the poorest countries in the region and relies heavily on Russia, with remittances from citizens working abroad - mainly in Russia - making up half of the country's GDP. Since the power-sharing agreement that ended the bloody civil war in 1997, Islamists have been gradually pushed out of the government. Fears have also grown that the Afghan conflict could spill across Tajikistan's border. Emomali Rakhmon has been in power since 1992, and has managed to increase his power by cracking down on political dissent and freedom of expression. Mr Rakhmon has substantial public support - and his rather serious face can be seen on posters across Tajikistan. People sing his praises and dedicate poems to him. And huge crowds turn up to presidential rallies - although attendance is obligatory for state employees. Mr Rakhmon's supporters are grateful the civil war of the 1990s is over - but life is not easy for most Tajiks. Read more", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1545, "answer_start": 722, "text": "The referendum also proposes lowering the age limit for running for president from 35 to 30 - a move that would theoretically allow Mr Rakhmon's son Rustam, who is 29, to run for office in 2020. The three points are contained in a parliamentary bill on amendments to the constitution. The single question on the ballot form was \"Do you support the amendments and additions to the constitution of the country?\" Tajikistan is one of the poorest countries in the region and relies heavily on Russia, with remittances from citizens working abroad - mainly in Russia - making up half of the country's GDP. Since the power-sharing agreement that ended the bloody civil war in 1997, Islamists have been gradually pushed out of the government. Fears have also grown that the Afghan conflict could spill across Tajikistan's border." } ], "id": "7_0", "question": "Son as successor?" } ] } ]
Sri Lanka crisis: Supreme Court suspends dissolution of parliament
13 November 2018
[ { "context": "Sri Lanka's Supreme Court has suspended the president's move to dissolve parliament, as a political crisis in the island nation deepens. President Maithripala Sirisena shocked the nation by sacking parliament and calling snap elections on Friday. The dramatic decision came two weeks after Mr Sirisena fired his prime minister and replaced him with the country's former leader. But his actions have been called unconstitutional. Ranil Wickremesinghe, the ousted PM, had refused to give way to his named successor, Mahinda Rajapaksa, and had called for MPs to vote on who they believed was the rightful premier. Correspondents said the president and Mr Rajapaksa decided to called the snap election because they did not have enough support in parliament for their new government. Mr Wickremesinghe's United National Party (UNP) said the move was illegal and it and other parties filed petitions with the Supreme Court. Its order means that elections, announced for 5 January, have been put on hold. Hundreds of heavily-armed police had been deployed to the court ahead of Tuesday's decision and UNP supporters set off firecrackers in celebration as news of the order filtered out. \"The people have won their first victory. Let's go forward and re-establish the sovereignty of the people in our beloved country,\" tweeted Mr Wickremesinghe. Namal Rajapaksa, an MP and son of Mahinda Rajapaksa, responded by saying the court had not made a \"final decision\". Mr Sirisena, the president, and Mr Wickremesinghe, the sacked prime minister, joined forces in the 2015 election to defeat the then long-time president, Mr Rajapaksa. But their uneasy coalition has since fractured and on 26 October Mr Sirisena announced he was sacking the PM and replacing him with Mr Rajapaksa. The pair had reportedly clashed in cabinet recently over government plans to lease a port to India. The sacking left the country with two people claiming to run the government, and Mr Wickremesinghe refused to leave his residence, Temple Trees. President Sirisena had agreed to convene parliament on 14 November but then dramatically reversed course last Friday, when he said he was dissolving parliament. It's unclear if parliament will now convene on Wednesday as originally planned but senior UNP officials have told the BBC that its MPs will show up. Mahinda Rajapaksa is a popular but controversial figure. As president, he ended the decades-long civil war in 2009, but faced criticism for the means by which he achieved victory - many thousands of Tamil civilians are thought to have been killed by government forces in the final months of the fighting. The military has always denied this, but it has remained a bitterly contentious issue and been the subject of intense scrutiny. Mr Rajapaksa also signed several large infrastructural deals with China when he was in office - saddling Sri Lanka with billions of dollars in debt. The former president and his inner circle are also accused of corruption, which they deny.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2321, "answer_start": 1454, "text": "Mr Sirisena, the president, and Mr Wickremesinghe, the sacked prime minister, joined forces in the 2015 election to defeat the then long-time president, Mr Rajapaksa. But their uneasy coalition has since fractured and on 26 October Mr Sirisena announced he was sacking the PM and replacing him with Mr Rajapaksa. The pair had reportedly clashed in cabinet recently over government plans to lease a port to India. The sacking left the country with two people claiming to run the government, and Mr Wickremesinghe refused to leave his residence, Temple Trees. President Sirisena had agreed to convene parliament on 14 November but then dramatically reversed course last Friday, when he said he was dissolving parliament. It's unclear if parliament will now convene on Wednesday as originally planned but senior UNP officials have told the BBC that its MPs will show up." } ], "id": "8_0", "question": "What's the background?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2994, "answer_start": 2322, "text": "Mahinda Rajapaksa is a popular but controversial figure. As president, he ended the decades-long civil war in 2009, but faced criticism for the means by which he achieved victory - many thousands of Tamil civilians are thought to have been killed by government forces in the final months of the fighting. The military has always denied this, but it has remained a bitterly contentious issue and been the subject of intense scrutiny. Mr Rajapaksa also signed several large infrastructural deals with China when he was in office - saddling Sri Lanka with billions of dollars in debt. The former president and his inner circle are also accused of corruption, which they deny." } ], "id": "8_1", "question": "Who is Rajapaksa?" } ] } ]
Ethiopian 18th Century crown returns home from Netherlands
20 February 2020
[ { "context": "An 18th Century Ethiopian crown has been returned home after being hidden in a Dutch flat for more than 20 years. Ethiopian Sirak Asfaw, who fled to the Netherlands in the late 1970s, found the crown in 1998 in the suitcase of a visitor and realised it was stolen. The management consultant protected it until he alerted a historian and Dutch police of his discovery last year. On Thursday, Ethiopia's Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed received the crown, thought to be one of just 20 in existence. The crown has depictions of Jesus Christ, God and the Holy Spirit, as well as Jesus' disciples, and was probably given to a church by the powerful warlord Welde Sellase hundreds of years ago. In a tweet, Mr Abiy said he was grateful to Mr Sirak and the Dutch government for the return of the \"precious crown\". Mr Sirak left his home country in 1978 to escape the political repression of the Communist government, or Derg, which had come to power in 1974. The regime unleashed a wave of violence known as the Red Terror, which killed hundreds of thousands and forced many to leave. The former refugee used to host Ethiopians who had left the country in his Rotterdam flat throughout the 1980s and 1990s. \"Friends, refugees, whoever,\" he said. It was one of these visitors staying at his home in 1998 who was carrying the crown in his bag. \"Most people don't really care about this cultural heritage. I'm loyal to Ethiopia,\" he told the BBC in an interview last year. Mr Sirak confronted the man and insisted the crown was not leaving unless it could be returned to its home. After asking for help on internet forums - which yielded no useful answers - he decided the best course of action was to hold onto the crown until he knew it would be safe. \"You end up in such a suffocating situation, not knowing who to tell or what to do, or to hand over,\" he said. \"And of course afraid that the Dutch government might confiscate it.\" \"I had fire alarms all over my house, eight or something like that. Really scared!\" But after the reforming Mr Abiy becoming prime minister in 2018, Mr Sirak felt the time was right to have a piece of Ethiopia's history return to Addis Ababa. He contacted Arthur Brand, known as the \"Indiana Jones of the art world\", for help returning it home. \"I explained to him, look, either the crown will disappear or you [will], if you continue like this,\" Mr Brand told the BBC. \"I said if the people who were involved at the time got knowledge of it, the risk was that they would come back and would take the crown from him.\" With the consent of the Dutch police, the art hunter placed the artefact in a secure facility. An expert confirmed it was genuine, and Mr Brand decided the best course of action was to announce it publicly. \"It's an amazing piece. It's very big, I feel pity for the people who had to wear it on their heads because when you wear this for a couple of hours your neck hurts,\" he said. Both men waited for the Ethiopian government to get in touch with the Dutch authorities to plan the return of the crown. \"I want this crown to be a symbol of unity and togetherness,\" Mr Sirak said. \"The crown will be celebrated by all of us Ethiopians, even Africans.\"", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2002, "answer_start": 801, "text": "Mr Sirak left his home country in 1978 to escape the political repression of the Communist government, or Derg, which had come to power in 1974. The regime unleashed a wave of violence known as the Red Terror, which killed hundreds of thousands and forced many to leave. The former refugee used to host Ethiopians who had left the country in his Rotterdam flat throughout the 1980s and 1990s. \"Friends, refugees, whoever,\" he said. It was one of these visitors staying at his home in 1998 who was carrying the crown in his bag. \"Most people don't really care about this cultural heritage. I'm loyal to Ethiopia,\" he told the BBC in an interview last year. Mr Sirak confronted the man and insisted the crown was not leaving unless it could be returned to its home. After asking for help on internet forums - which yielded no useful answers - he decided the best course of action was to hold onto the crown until he knew it would be safe. \"You end up in such a suffocating situation, not knowing who to tell or what to do, or to hand over,\" he said. \"And of course afraid that the Dutch government might confiscate it.\" \"I had fire alarms all over my house, eight or something like that. Really scared!\"" } ], "id": "9_0", "question": "What's the story of the crown?" } ] } ]
Are Iran’s Sunni neighbours about to race for The Bomb?
30 June 2015
[ { "context": "The holy month of Ramadan could never be described as a time of feverish activity in the Gulf states that sit between Shia Iran and Sunni Saudi Arabia. It is brutally hot even after the fasting daylight hours give way to the feasting hours of the humid evening. The sound of Koran readings in the ancient mosques drifts across the modern skyline - a reminder of the energies devoted to prayerful contemplation. But this year the atmosphere feels a little different. In the Gulf there is a keen awareness that the deadline is approaching in the talks between the US-led world powers and the government of Iran over that country's nuclear ambitions. The Sunni monarchies of the region follow the issue as closely as it is followed in Israel - which of course considers itself the likeliest target for any future Iranian nuclear bomb. The fears in the Gulf are slightly more complex. Many of the conflicts raging in the Middle East, from Yemen to Iraq to Syria, are defined to some extent by the ancient division between the two main traditions of Islam - Shia and Sunni. Iran sees itself as a protector of the Shia wherever they may be found and also believes in the right to export its brand of revolution. Its regional rivals led by Saudi Arabia therefore regard it as a dangerous and destabilising power - ever ready to blow on the flames of political dissent through its proxy armies like Hezbollah in Lebanon. Most of the Gulf states are Sunni with Shia minorities but Bahrain has a Shia majority ruled by a Sunni monarchy. It is no stranger to political unrest and reports that members of that Shia majority are abused, even tortured, in prison - something the authorities deny. Add to that the uncomfortable fact that historically Iran once regarded Bahrain as its own territory and that some at least of the Kingdom's Shia population have their roots in Persia and you can see why Bahrain views Iran with particular anxiety. The Chief of Police in Bahrain, Major-General Tariq al-Hassan, showed me an impressive collection of guns, ammunition and explosives recovered on anti-terrorist operations in recent years. He says it is clear that Iran is inspiring, inciting and attempting to arm extremist groups in the Kingdom. \"There's no doubt there's overwhelming evidence of Iranian interference, direct and indirect,\" he told me. \"We have evidence the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps or elements within it have been involved in training, funding and recruiting terrorists in Bahrain.\" Model state: Lebanon pivotal to Iran's reach across Middle East Iranian ambitions breed scepticism and fear in Israel The problem for the Gulf states is that it is possible to see a downside to the outcome of the nuclear negotiations with Iran however they end. If there is no deal the Iranians may emerge from the talks as an embittered adversary of the Sunni world, readier than ever to support their powerful proxies around the region - that means not just Lebanese Hezbollah but the heavily-armed and well-trained Shia militias of Iraq too. If there is a nuclear deal and the global economic sanctions are lifted then the Iranians would have much more money to spend on those paramilitary forces if they chose to do so. And of course there is the over-arching question of Iran's nuclear ambitions themselves. Tehran adamantly denies that it intends to use its increasing nuclear expertise to build a bomb - to weaponise that knowledge, in the jargon of diplomacy. Its adversaries are united in scepticism but divided about the best way to react if it becomes clear that Iran is seeking to acquire The Bomb. Israel has been debating for years the possibility of launching pre-emptive air strikes on Iranian nuclear infrastructure - a repeat on a larger scale of the type of air operations undertaken against nuclear targets in both Iraq and Syria in the past. That carries with it the risk of triggering retaliation from the Iranians of course (perhaps via Hezbollah) and may only delay the project by three-to-five years, according to some experts. Israel of course already has nuclear weapons of its own - although its strict policy of not acknowledging that fact in public means they are often not discussed as a factor in this equation. The Gulf states do not have The Bomb - but when I discussed all of this with the foreign minister of Bahrain, Sheikh Khaled bin Ahmad al-Khalifa, he offered a gloomy warning about the dangers of nuclear proliferation in the Middle East. He said simply: \"A nuclear programme that is unchecked, that would produce a nuclear weapon, would no doubt cause an arms race. It wouldn't only be Saudi Arabia but many other countries in the region would want to hire that capability.\" The prospect of a nuclear arms race in the Middle East is a disturbing one - particularly given the almost limitless financial resources that a country like Saudi Arabia could afford to spend on such a project. It is fair to say though that not everyone in the Middle East - and indeed not everyone in Bahrain - sees things in quite the same way. Dr Jasim Husain is a senior figure in the Shia al-Wefaq movement which is Bahrain's largest political movement and which boycotted last year's elections here. He says it is too easy for non-Shia to demonise Iran and makes the point that there are plenty of other risks and dangers in the Middle East too. \"I think this is really an unfair characterisation of Iran,\" he told me, \"I think it's way too much to describe one country as being very unbalanced and a danger. I think the real problems are the problems we're having with Isis [Islamic State] - they are the real threats in the region.\" The world powers negotiating with Iran clearly accept to some extent at least that the government in Tehran is dangerous - both in its readiness to fund paramilitary forces outside its borders and possibly in its nuclear ambitions. There seems to be a general sense that some sort of deal is likely in which Iran will agree to limits on its nuclear programme in return for an easing of sanctions. In the Middle East when people feel free to speak off the record they worry a little that America is too keen to make the deal because the Obama administration is desperate for some kind of diplomatic agreement that will be seen as a historical legacy of his presidency. Managing a process that sees Iran re-integrated into global politics and trade might fit the bill but there are deep fears in the Middle East about the price that Iran might extract in return. There is much at stake as these talks climax in the Ramadan of 2015 - it will be interesting to see how stable things look when Ramadan rolls round again next year.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 6676, "answer_start": 4710, "text": "The prospect of a nuclear arms race in the Middle East is a disturbing one - particularly given the almost limitless financial resources that a country like Saudi Arabia could afford to spend on such a project. It is fair to say though that not everyone in the Middle East - and indeed not everyone in Bahrain - sees things in quite the same way. Dr Jasim Husain is a senior figure in the Shia al-Wefaq movement which is Bahrain's largest political movement and which boycotted last year's elections here. He says it is too easy for non-Shia to demonise Iran and makes the point that there are plenty of other risks and dangers in the Middle East too. \"I think this is really an unfair characterisation of Iran,\" he told me, \"I think it's way too much to describe one country as being very unbalanced and a danger. I think the real problems are the problems we're having with Isis [Islamic State] - they are the real threats in the region.\" The world powers negotiating with Iran clearly accept to some extent at least that the government in Tehran is dangerous - both in its readiness to fund paramilitary forces outside its borders and possibly in its nuclear ambitions. There seems to be a general sense that some sort of deal is likely in which Iran will agree to limits on its nuclear programme in return for an easing of sanctions. In the Middle East when people feel free to speak off the record they worry a little that America is too keen to make the deal because the Obama administration is desperate for some kind of diplomatic agreement that will be seen as a historical legacy of his presidency. Managing a process that sees Iran re-integrated into global politics and trade might fit the bill but there are deep fears in the Middle East about the price that Iran might extract in return. There is much at stake as these talks climax in the Ramadan of 2015 - it will be interesting to see how stable things look when Ramadan rolls round again next year." } ], "id": "10_0", "question": "US sell-out?" } ] } ]
Nigerian elections: Has Boko Haram been defeated?
8 February 2019
[ { "context": "The Islamist militant group Boko Haram has been active in north-eastern Nigeria for well over a decade. President Buhari says its activities have been largely brought under control since he assumed office in 2015. His political opponents disagree and say the situation has recently deteriorated both in terms of the number of attacks and kidnappings by the group. Ahead of Nigeria's elections on 23 February, BBC Reality Check examines the competing claims over the security situation in the country. Formed around 2002 as a non-violent organisation with the aim of purifying Islam in northern Nigeria, it became increasingly radicalised and eventually adopted militant tactics in pursuit of its aims. It has been active not only in Nigeria, but also in the neighbouring countries of Chad, Niger and Cameroon. Tens of thousands of civilians have been killed and more than two million displaced over the past decade. Boko Haram has been notorious for kidnapping schoolchildren and attracted global media attention in 2014 following the abduction of almost 300 girls from a school in the town of Chibok, in Borno, the state where the militant group has been most active. In 2015, Boko Haram was ranked the world's deadliest terror group by the Institute for Economics and Peace. Since then, territory controlled by the group has declined and it has splintered into competing factions. However, the Islamist militants remain active in the region, defying attempts by the army to bring the insurgency to an end. To underline this continued activity, in 2018 more than 100 schoolgirls were kidnapped from the northern town of Dapchi. Most of the girls were eventually released. The former Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo, who is supporting main opposition candidate, Atiku Abubakar, has strongly criticised President Muhammadu Buhari's record on tackling Boko Haram. \"The security situation has deteriorated, with kidnapping everywhere,\" said Mr Obasanjo in January. But President Buhari's view of the security situation is very different. He says the militants have been \"decimated\" since 2015 in their stronghold of Borno State. So what are the available facts regarding both attacks on civilians and on kidnappings? Insecurity and poor communications in rural areas make assessment both for the government and independent organisations particularly difficult and many incidents go unreported. The Nigerian government's National Bureau of Statistics provides public access to economic, social and general security data gathered within Nigeria but a spokesman told BBC News it did not collect data on the activities of Boko Haram. However, research by the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED) tracks information by monitoring local media and other reports. From a peak in 2015 of more than 5,000, the number of deaths attributed to Boko Haram has fallen off significantly to below 1,000 a year for the past three years. This decline followed a military campaign launched against Boko Haram in 2015 by the Nigerian government, with international support. Large areas of territory previously controlled by Boko Haram were recaptured during this offensive. So, President Buhari is right to say killings by militants have declined substantially since he came to office in 2015. But these attacks have not ended completely and there have been several in the early weeks of 2019. \"In terms of the current situation, I do think the current trend line is quite dangerous and that they are far from defeated,\" says Alex Thurston, a visiting assistant professor of political science and comparative religion at Miami University of Ohio. The Nigeria Security Tracker, a product of the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), in Washington, monitors kidnappings through local media reports. These indicate a peak in the number of kidnappings in 2014 and 2015, when Boko Haram was at its strongest militarily. However, despite a dramatic fall in reported kidnappings in 2016, the level has risen since then, with 310 reported last year. One theory put forward for this increase is that as Boko Haram has lost territory and military influence, its tactics have shifted away from direct confrontation with security forces. Instead, the militants have turned their attention to soft targets such as schools and rural villages, taking hostages from these locations. So, when Mr Obasanjo says \"the security situation has deteriorated with kidnapping everywhere\", he's right in the sense that the level of kidnapping is on the increase and that major incidents such as the kidnapping of more than 100 schoolgirls in Dapchi, in 2018, do give serious cause for concern. This fear is particularly heightened given Boko Haram's use of children as suicide bombers. In 2017 and 2018, there were 77 and 26 incidences respectively of children being used in this way by the militants. In 2016 this figure was nine, according to Unicef. Looking at the distribution of all kidnappings across Nigeria, this is clearly not the case, with Boko Haram operating largely in the far north-east of the country. Kidnappings have also been regularly reported in the country's oil-rich southern Niger Delta region - but these are unrelated to the activities of Boko Haram. So, looking at the overall picture of kidnappings, not just by Boko Haram, you can see that the distribution is more geographically widespread - but it's certainly not the case as Mr Obasanjo says that kidnappings have been taking place \"everywhere\" across the country. Overall, the picture of Boko Haram activity in the north-east of Nigeria appears to be one of declining military activity. But along with this has come a recent rise in kidnappings although it's not clear whether this indicates a resurgence in the strength of the group or a re-focusing on softer targets. Amendment: The Nigerian presidential election has been delayed until 23 February and this has been reflected in the article. Read more from Reality Check Send us your questions Follow us on Twitter", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1673, "answer_start": 501, "text": "Formed around 2002 as a non-violent organisation with the aim of purifying Islam in northern Nigeria, it became increasingly radicalised and eventually adopted militant tactics in pursuit of its aims. It has been active not only in Nigeria, but also in the neighbouring countries of Chad, Niger and Cameroon. Tens of thousands of civilians have been killed and more than two million displaced over the past decade. Boko Haram has been notorious for kidnapping schoolchildren and attracted global media attention in 2014 following the abduction of almost 300 girls from a school in the town of Chibok, in Borno, the state where the militant group has been most active. In 2015, Boko Haram was ranked the world's deadliest terror group by the Institute for Economics and Peace. Since then, territory controlled by the group has declined and it has splintered into competing factions. However, the Islamist militants remain active in the region, defying attempts by the army to bring the insurgency to an end. To underline this continued activity, in 2018 more than 100 schoolgirls were kidnapped from the northern town of Dapchi. Most of the girls were eventually released." } ], "id": "11_0", "question": "What is Boko Haram?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3171, "answer_start": 2220, "text": "Insecurity and poor communications in rural areas make assessment both for the government and independent organisations particularly difficult and many incidents go unreported. The Nigerian government's National Bureau of Statistics provides public access to economic, social and general security data gathered within Nigeria but a spokesman told BBC News it did not collect data on the activities of Boko Haram. However, research by the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED) tracks information by monitoring local media and other reports. From a peak in 2015 of more than 5,000, the number of deaths attributed to Boko Haram has fallen off significantly to below 1,000 a year for the past three years. This decline followed a military campaign launched against Boko Haram in 2015 by the Nigerian government, with international support. Large areas of territory previously controlled by Boko Haram were recaptured during this offensive." } ], "id": "11_1", "question": "Have attacks by Boko Haram declined?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 4921, "answer_start": 3645, "text": "The Nigeria Security Tracker, a product of the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), in Washington, monitors kidnappings through local media reports. These indicate a peak in the number of kidnappings in 2014 and 2015, when Boko Haram was at its strongest militarily. However, despite a dramatic fall in reported kidnappings in 2016, the level has risen since then, with 310 reported last year. One theory put forward for this increase is that as Boko Haram has lost territory and military influence, its tactics have shifted away from direct confrontation with security forces. Instead, the militants have turned their attention to soft targets such as schools and rural villages, taking hostages from these locations. So, when Mr Obasanjo says \"the security situation has deteriorated with kidnapping everywhere\", he's right in the sense that the level of kidnapping is on the increase and that major incidents such as the kidnapping of more than 100 schoolgirls in Dapchi, in 2018, do give serious cause for concern. This fear is particularly heightened given Boko Haram's use of children as suicide bombers. In 2017 and 2018, there were 77 and 26 incidences respectively of children being used in this way by the militants. In 2016 this figure was nine, according to Unicef." } ], "id": "11_2", "question": "What about kidnappings?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 5946, "answer_start": 4922, "text": "Looking at the distribution of all kidnappings across Nigeria, this is clearly not the case, with Boko Haram operating largely in the far north-east of the country. Kidnappings have also been regularly reported in the country's oil-rich southern Niger Delta region - but these are unrelated to the activities of Boko Haram. So, looking at the overall picture of kidnappings, not just by Boko Haram, you can see that the distribution is more geographically widespread - but it's certainly not the case as Mr Obasanjo says that kidnappings have been taking place \"everywhere\" across the country. Overall, the picture of Boko Haram activity in the north-east of Nigeria appears to be one of declining military activity. But along with this has come a recent rise in kidnappings although it's not clear whether this indicates a resurgence in the strength of the group or a re-focusing on softer targets. Amendment: The Nigerian presidential election has been delayed until 23 February and this has been reflected in the article." } ], "id": "11_3", "question": "Are kidnappings 'everywhere'?" } ] } ]
San Francisco homeless: New plan to clear tents off streets
21 October 2016
[ { "context": "Tent camps have become one of the most prominent and controversial symbols of San Francisco's problem with homelessness. The camps have sprung up along streets and under overpasses, swelling in some cases to 30 or 40 tents. They have divided opinion in a city which has seen an influx of well-paid tech workers in recent years but struggled to house its poorer citizens. Now a new ballot measure, backed financially by tech investors and to be voted on by residents next month, is proposing to introduce laws against the tent camps. Proposition Q would give the city the right to tear down camps and remove residents' belongings. Police would have to give 24 hours notice and find a shelter for anyone they turf out. Supporters say the measure prioritises housing over dangerous camp environments. Opponents say it is yet another move to criminalise the homeless. Here's what you need to know about Prop Q. In theory, a police officer or other city worker would offer someone sleeping in a tent a room in a shelter for the night, or a paid bus ticket out of the city to a family member or friend, under the city's existing \"Homeward Bound\" programme. If the homeless person refused, they would be given 24 hours notice to dismantle their tent and vacate the site. If they failed to comply, the city would remove the tent and store the owner's possessions for up to 90 days. Prop Q was drawn up and sponsored by Mark Farrell, a San Francisco city supervisor. Mr Farrell told the BBC that the camps had become \"the symbol of the city's homeless problem\" and were \"some of the most dangerous places you can imagine\". \"From documented rapes, to fires, to tonnes and tonnes of waste - these camps are a significant strain on our public safety resources,\" he said. Mr Farrell and Prop Q's other advocates say no one will be moved on from a camp unless there is a guaranteed bed for them that night. He said that allowing the camps to remain and providing water or other assistance would encourage homeless people to come to the city. \"If word got out... we would see a massive influx of tent camps in the city,\" he said. Mr Farrell said he \"completely rejected\" the accusation that the law would criminalise the homeless. \"This is about rejecting dangerous living environments and prioritising shelter and housing,\" he said. In the other corner is San Francisco city supervisor John Avalos, Prop Q's official opposition. Mr Avalos called Prop Q \"a political move\". \"Police already have all the powers they need to move encampments,\" he said in an interview. \"This measure is on the ballot so voters can vote with their anger about homelessness.\" He said the key to solving homelessness was to focus resources on supportive housing. \"This measure does not do anything to increase supportive housing, it pushes people from sidewalk to sidewalk, from block to block, in the hope of housing that doesn't exist.\" \"This is kind of like a tough love measure,\" he said. \"But we know from the past, they tend to operate on very little love and mostly toughness.\" Also opposing the law is San Francisco's Coalition on Homelessness charity. Jennifer Friedenbach, the charity's executive director, called it \"an incredibly deceptive measure\" and warned it would stir up hate against the homeless. \"It's already illegal for tents to be on the sidewalks,\" she said. \"So it bears the question why put it on the ballot? The only reason is to have the homeless vilified to draw out more conservative voters.\" Not exactly. San Francisco has a lower homelessness rate than many major US cities including LA, Seattle, and Washington DC. But San Francisco does have a significantly higher proportion of unsheltered homeless people - 511 per 100,000 people, according to 2015 data from the city's Housing Department. That's more than five times the rate of unsheltered homeless than Washington DC, which has twice the overall rate of homelessness. And San Francisco's homelessness rate is slowing growing, according to the Housing Department's biannual survey. One of the central arguments against Prop Q is that there aren't enough rooms in shelters to move people to, so the homeless will just get pushed around. Mr Farrell says that a new so-called Navigation Centre under development, plus the city's existing sheltered housing, will total 1,500 rooms, against just 600 people believed to be in tent camps. But opponents point to the total number of homeless in the city, thought to be at least 6,500 but possibly as high as 9,500, and say there is already a long daily waiting list for a room. \"We have over 800 people waiting for shelter,\" said Ms Friedenbach, \"and the city would hold shelter beds empty in order to offer them to people in encampments, putting other elderly people and people with disabilities who are in those shelter beds out on the streets.\" Is San Francisco tougher on homelessness than other cities? According to a 2015 study by California's University of Berkeley, the average city in the state has nine homelessness laws - significantly more than in other states. San Francisco has the most - 23 laws. San Francisco's include so called \"sit-lie\" - a 2010 measure which bans sitting or lying on the sidewalk during daytime hours and is punishable by up to six months in prison. And a 2015 measure against begging which set a 20ft perimeter around cash machines and made it illegal to ask for money again from someone who had refused. That measure did also include provisions to get more homeless people into drug or mental health programmes instead of prison. According to a report by the Guardian, wealthy tech investors have donated significant amounts of money to the campaign for Prop Q. The newspaper reported that Sequoia Capital chairman Michael Moritz, tech angel investor Ron Conway, and hedge-fund investor William Oberndorf donated $49,999 each to a war chest totalling $270,000. Mr Farrell said the campaign had also had large numbers of small donations from ordinary voters, but the news that rich investors putting up most of the funds has angered many. \"These are people who spend more money in a year than homeless people have for a budget for food for six years... I mean how awful to have a billionaire funding a campaign to take away people's tents,\" Ms Friedenbach said. Anti-homelessness legislation has typically been popular among voters in San Francisco and proponents say they are confident of it passing. The measure needs more than 50% of the vote to pass. Voting is on 8 November.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1373, "answer_start": 907, "text": "In theory, a police officer or other city worker would offer someone sleeping in a tent a room in a shelter for the night, or a paid bus ticket out of the city to a family member or friend, under the city's existing \"Homeward Bound\" programme. If the homeless person refused, they would be given 24 hours notice to dismantle their tent and vacate the site. If they failed to comply, the city would remove the tent and store the owner's possessions for up to 90 days." } ], "id": "12_0", "question": "How would it work on the street?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2318, "answer_start": 1374, "text": "Prop Q was drawn up and sponsored by Mark Farrell, a San Francisco city supervisor. Mr Farrell told the BBC that the camps had become \"the symbol of the city's homeless problem\" and were \"some of the most dangerous places you can imagine\". \"From documented rapes, to fires, to tonnes and tonnes of waste - these camps are a significant strain on our public safety resources,\" he said. Mr Farrell and Prop Q's other advocates say no one will be moved on from a camp unless there is a guaranteed bed for them that night. He said that allowing the camps to remain and providing water or other assistance would encourage homeless people to come to the city. \"If word got out... we would see a massive influx of tent camps in the city,\" he said. Mr Farrell said he \"completely rejected\" the accusation that the law would criminalise the homeless. \"This is about rejecting dangerous living environments and prioritising shelter and housing,\" he said." } ], "id": "12_1", "question": "Who's supporting it, and why?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3485, "answer_start": 2319, "text": "In the other corner is San Francisco city supervisor John Avalos, Prop Q's official opposition. Mr Avalos called Prop Q \"a political move\". \"Police already have all the powers they need to move encampments,\" he said in an interview. \"This measure is on the ballot so voters can vote with their anger about homelessness.\" He said the key to solving homelessness was to focus resources on supportive housing. \"This measure does not do anything to increase supportive housing, it pushes people from sidewalk to sidewalk, from block to block, in the hope of housing that doesn't exist.\" \"This is kind of like a tough love measure,\" he said. \"But we know from the past, they tend to operate on very little love and mostly toughness.\" Also opposing the law is San Francisco's Coalition on Homelessness charity. Jennifer Friedenbach, the charity's executive director, called it \"an incredibly deceptive measure\" and warned it would stir up hate against the homeless. \"It's already illegal for tents to be on the sidewalks,\" she said. \"So it bears the question why put it on the ballot? The only reason is to have the homeless vilified to draw out more conservative voters.\"" } ], "id": "12_2", "question": "So who's opposing it, and why?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 4032, "answer_start": 3486, "text": "Not exactly. San Francisco has a lower homelessness rate than many major US cities including LA, Seattle, and Washington DC. But San Francisco does have a significantly higher proportion of unsheltered homeless people - 511 per 100,000 people, according to 2015 data from the city's Housing Department. That's more than five times the rate of unsheltered homeless than Washington DC, which has twice the overall rate of homelessness. And San Francisco's homelessness rate is slowing growing, according to the Housing Department's biannual survey." } ], "id": "12_3", "question": "Is homelessness particularly bad in San Francisco?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 5561, "answer_start": 4033, "text": "One of the central arguments against Prop Q is that there aren't enough rooms in shelters to move people to, so the homeless will just get pushed around. Mr Farrell says that a new so-called Navigation Centre under development, plus the city's existing sheltered housing, will total 1,500 rooms, against just 600 people believed to be in tent camps. But opponents point to the total number of homeless in the city, thought to be at least 6,500 but possibly as high as 9,500, and say there is already a long daily waiting list for a room. \"We have over 800 people waiting for shelter,\" said Ms Friedenbach, \"and the city would hold shelter beds empty in order to offer them to people in encampments, putting other elderly people and people with disabilities who are in those shelter beds out on the streets.\" Is San Francisco tougher on homelessness than other cities? According to a 2015 study by California's University of Berkeley, the average city in the state has nine homelessness laws - significantly more than in other states. San Francisco has the most - 23 laws. San Francisco's include so called \"sit-lie\" - a 2010 measure which bans sitting or lying on the sidewalk during daytime hours and is punishable by up to six months in prison. And a 2015 measure against begging which set a 20ft perimeter around cash machines and made it illegal to ask for money again from someone who had refused. That measure did also include provisions to get more homeless people into drug or mental health programmes instead of prison." } ], "id": "12_4", "question": "So presumably there aren't enough shelter beds?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 6292, "answer_start": 5562, "text": "According to a report by the Guardian, wealthy tech investors have donated significant amounts of money to the campaign for Prop Q. The newspaper reported that Sequoia Capital chairman Michael Moritz, tech angel investor Ron Conway, and hedge-fund investor William Oberndorf donated $49,999 each to a war chest totalling $270,000. Mr Farrell said the campaign had also had large numbers of small donations from ordinary voters, but the news that rich investors putting up most of the funds has angered many. \"These are people who spend more money in a year than homeless people have for a budget for food for six years... I mean how awful to have a billionaire funding a campaign to take away people's tents,\" Ms Friedenbach said." } ], "id": "12_5", "question": "What's the funding controversy around Prop Q?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 6510, "answer_start": 6293, "text": "Anti-homelessness legislation has typically been popular among voters in San Francisco and proponents say they are confident of it passing. The measure needs more than 50% of the vote to pass. Voting is on 8 November." } ], "id": "12_6", "question": "Finally, will it pass?" } ] } ]
EU Withdrawal Bill: A guide to the Brexit repeal legislation
13 November 2017
[ { "context": "It's crunch time for the government's EU Withdrawal Bill - the bill which aims to ensure European law will no longer apply in the UK after Brexit. This key plank of legislation, once known as the Great Repeal Bill, has reached committee stage in the House of Commons, which is the bit where there will be hundreds of attempts by MPs to change its wording. As its informal name suggests, the repeal bill will repeal the 1972 European Communities Act, which took Britain into the EU and meant that European law took precedence over laws passed in the UK Parliament. It will also end the power of the European Court of Justice in the UK. All existing EU legislation will be copied across into domestic UK law to ensure a smooth transition on the day after Brexit. The government says it wants to avoid a \"black hole in our statute book\" and avoid disruption to businesses and individual citizens as the UK leaves the EU. The UK Parliament can then \"amend, repeal and improve\" individual laws as necessary. Ensuring the continuity of EU rules and regulations is also meant to aid trade negotiations with the EU because the UK will already meet all of its product stands. The bill is likely to be \"one of the largest legislative projects ever undertaken in the UK\", a report by the House of Commons library predicts, with \"major swathes of the statute book\" needing to be examined to see how they will work after Brexit. This is because working out which bits of UK law came from the EU is not as simple as it may sound. In fact, it presents a \"unique challenge\", a House of Lords committee warned, because \"the body of EU law is found in a number of different places, and in a number of different forms\". Simply transposing all EU law into UK legislation will not be enough, the government's White Paper on the bill says. Swathes of UK law \"will no longer work\" on exit, for example because they refer to EU institutions. Not all of this can be done through the repeal bill, so the government plans to create powers to \"correct the statute book where necessary\" - without full Parliamentary scrutiny. This power - known as Henry VIII power - is the one of the most controversial features of the bill (see below). More complications are presented by the government's negotiations with the EU, which will be taking place while the bill is passing through Parliament. Those talks could shape what the UK's post-Brexit laws look like - but the repeal bill will need to be done and dusted by the day the UK leaves. The government plans to enact its \"corrections\" to the statute book using what are known as Henry VIII powers, after the Statute of Proclamations 1539 which gave him the power to legislate by proclamation. Given that this will not involve the usual Parliamentary scrutiny process, opposition parties have protested, with Labour claiming ministers were being handed \"sweeping powers\" to make hasty, ill thought-out legislation. Ministers have attempted to reassure critics by saying such measures will be time-limited and not used to make policy changes. In total, the government estimates that 800 to 1,000 measures called statutory instruments will be required to make sure the bill functions properly. A lot. The government's White Paper says there is \"no single figure\" for this, but that there are believed to be 12,000 EU regulations (one type of EU law) in force, while Parliament has passed 7,900 statutory instruments implementing EU legislation and 186 acts which incorporate a degree of EU influence. The total body of European law, dating back to 1958, is known as the Acquis Communautaire. It binds all member states and in 2010 was estimated to consist of about 80,000 items, covering everything from workers' rights to environment and trade. As well as regulations, this includes EU treaties, directions and European Court of Justice rulings. New EU legislation is being created all the time and will continue to apply to the UK until it leaves. Different types of EU legislation work in different ways, and will be treated differently by the bill. So regulations, which apply automatically in the UK, will be converted into UK law. But directives require a new UK law to come into force - this legislation will be preserved by the bill. Reality check: How much UK law comes from the EU? MPs have already voted to approve the second reading of the bill, by 326 votes to 290. But there are many hurdles ahead and on Tuesday the line-by-line scrutiny of how it will operate begins. As tends to happen with legislation deemed to be of constitutional importance, this 'committee stage' is taking place on the floor of the House of Commons, so all MPs can take part. Eight days have been allocated for this process, which will be followed by more stages including the bill's passage through the House of Lords. The plan is for it to be passed ahead of the UK's exit from the EU but to become law only when it actually leaves, in March 2019. Read more: A guide to the EU bill's journey through Parliament Labour, the SNP and the Lib Dems all opposed the bill at second reading, and MPs from all parties - with the exception of the DUP - are now trying to amend it at committee stage. Labour's suggested changes include trying to maintain a role for the European Court of Justice during the transition phase planned after March 2019. There is also a cross-party attempt to prevent the UK from leaving the EU without a deal in place. Until the UK actually leaves, EU law will continue to apply. But after leaving, the European Union (Withdrawal) Act (as it will be by then) comes into force. The government says having the legislation in place will ensure a \"calm and orderly exit\". Then begins the long-term process of the government, and Parliament, choosing what it wants to do with the laws it has incorporated from the EU. With so many pieces of legislation to be considered, this could turn out to be a \"major drain on resources\" and should not \"crowd out\" other government policies, the Institute for Government think tank has warned. Some of the EU laws are in areas that are controlled by the devolved administrations - so do they now become part of Westminster law, or will they be added to the statute book in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland? It is not entirely clear how this will work, although the government says it will work closely with the devolved administrations. It also predicts the repeal process will result in a \"a significant increase in the decision-making power of each devolved administration\", as powers in devolved areas are repatriated from Brussels. But the bill has been described by the Scottish government as an \"executive power grab\". Ministers have confirmed the devolved administrations will be asked to consent to the bill - but this does not amount to a veto. The UK government has warned that blocking the bill could have \"very significant consequences\", leaving \"a hole in our law\".", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3209, "answer_start": 2506, "text": "The government plans to enact its \"corrections\" to the statute book using what are known as Henry VIII powers, after the Statute of Proclamations 1539 which gave him the power to legislate by proclamation. Given that this will not involve the usual Parliamentary scrutiny process, opposition parties have protested, with Labour claiming ministers were being handed \"sweeping powers\" to make hasty, ill thought-out legislation. Ministers have attempted to reassure critics by saying such measures will be time-limited and not used to make policy changes. In total, the government estimates that 800 to 1,000 measures called statutory instruments will be required to make sure the bill functions properly." } ], "id": "13_0", "question": "What's Henry VIII got to do with it?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 4307, "answer_start": 3210, "text": "A lot. The government's White Paper says there is \"no single figure\" for this, but that there are believed to be 12,000 EU regulations (one type of EU law) in force, while Parliament has passed 7,900 statutory instruments implementing EU legislation and 186 acts which incorporate a degree of EU influence. The total body of European law, dating back to 1958, is known as the Acquis Communautaire. It binds all member states and in 2010 was estimated to consist of about 80,000 items, covering everything from workers' rights to environment and trade. As well as regulations, this includes EU treaties, directions and European Court of Justice rulings. New EU legislation is being created all the time and will continue to apply to the UK until it leaves. Different types of EU legislation work in different ways, and will be treated differently by the bill. So regulations, which apply automatically in the UK, will be converted into UK law. But directives require a new UK law to come into force - this legislation will be preserved by the bill. Reality check: How much UK law comes from the EU?" } ], "id": "13_1", "question": "How much EU law is there?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 5445, "answer_start": 5019, "text": "Labour, the SNP and the Lib Dems all opposed the bill at second reading, and MPs from all parties - with the exception of the DUP - are now trying to amend it at committee stage. Labour's suggested changes include trying to maintain a role for the European Court of Justice during the transition phase planned after March 2019. There is also a cross-party attempt to prevent the UK from leaving the EU without a deal in place." } ], "id": "13_2", "question": "What do other parties say?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 6942, "answer_start": 6054, "text": "Some of the EU laws are in areas that are controlled by the devolved administrations - so do they now become part of Westminster law, or will they be added to the statute book in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland? It is not entirely clear how this will work, although the government says it will work closely with the devolved administrations. It also predicts the repeal process will result in a \"a significant increase in the decision-making power of each devolved administration\", as powers in devolved areas are repatriated from Brussels. But the bill has been described by the Scottish government as an \"executive power grab\". Ministers have confirmed the devolved administrations will be asked to consent to the bill - but this does not amount to a veto. The UK government has warned that blocking the bill could have \"very significant consequences\", leaving \"a hole in our law\"." } ], "id": "13_3", "question": "How about Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland?" } ] } ]
2016: The year the car industry's revolution moved into top gear
29 December 2016
[ { "context": "It's been a year that should dispel doubts the car industry is going through a technological revolution. The convergence of traditional motor manufacturing and new digital technologies has been shifting slowly through the gears for a couple of years. But in 2016, things hit top speed. A string of deals, strategic announcements and investments has even left some experts wondering if a bubble is growing. \"Manufacturers finally really understood the need for change,\" says Martin Benecke, Frankfurt-based analyst at IHS Automotive. \"They see the competitive threat from Google and Apple. They know they cannot respond by doing everything themselves, so have to form alliances and partnerships,\" he says. Barely a week has gone by without reports of a new taxi-hailing partnership, a connected-car development, or another advance in driverless technology. \"Carmakers have essentially followed the same business model for 100 years,\" says Phil Harrold, automotive partner at PricewaterhouseCoopers. \"Technology firms knew it was a market they could enter and disrupt. \"Old-fashioned OEMs [original equipment manufacturers] came to the realisation that if they are not to become irrelevant they have to embrace the technology and new services,\" he says. When German giant VW announced in November a huge 30,000 job cuts programme, less attention was paid to the 9,000 jobs it vowed to create under its \"Future Pact\" strategy to develop electric and self-driving cars. VW was engulfed in the diesel emissions scandal, but it gave the company the incentive, and shield, to begin a change in direction that might otherwise have taken years, says Benecke. As the saying goes - never let a good crisis go to waste. In the future, Volkswagen will be making fewer engines and gearboxes, and more batteries, sensors and software. There has also been a shift in consumer attitudes, although there remains particular unease about the introduction of driverless vehicles, according to surveys. Even so, scepticism about the viability of new transport technologies is being replaced by a real understanding of their potential, says Martyn Briggs, senior consultant at Frost & Sullivan. And there is now evidence of consumers deferring car buying because of the growth of taxi-hailing and car-sharing services, he says. Briggs recalls the Red Flag safety laws of the late 19th Century when people were required to walk ahead of a revolutionary new machine - the motor car. There has been a lot of flag waving about future transport services. \"But people now see it becoming reality,\" he says. The millennial generation no longer regards car ownership as a necessity, while the ageing generation sees taxi-hailing and driverless technology as the way to keep them mobile, Briggs says. For years, carmakers and tech firms, with their different cultures and pace of development, eyed each other with mutual suspicion. Now they see each other as potential partners, not adversaries. The shift was evident at the start of the year. January's lacklustre North American Auto Show, in Detroit, had already been upstaged days earlier in Las Vegas, at the Consumer Electronics Show (CES). Forbes magazine reported CES as \"a high water mark in terms of the scale and significance of car technology unveiled\". Twelve months later and 2016 has ended with major developments from Silicon Valley titans Apple and Google-owner Alphabet. The former confirmed for the first time that it is developing a driverless car. The latter announced the creation of an independent company to exploit its already advanced transport and autonomous tech. Between the bookends of January and December were major deals that underlined the new adapt-or-die approach sweeping across motor manufacturing. General Motors bought a small three-year-old San Francisco company specialising in autonomous driving technology, Cruise Automation, for more than $1bn. GM also invested $500m in on-demand taxi-hailing business Lyft, a rival to Uber, and reportedly tried to buy the whole thing for $6bn. Fiat Chrysler Automobiles teamed up with Alphabet to collaborate on the development of self-driving minivans. Ford, whose chief executive Mark Fields now refers to the company that made the first mass-produced vehicle as a \"mobility services provider\", pushed deeper into connected-car technology. This included investment in a San Francisco cloud-based software and data analytics company, Pivotal, in which Microsoft also has a stake. Ford, which has a growing R&D presence in Silicon Valley, is testing connected cars in the UK that can communicate with each other to help speed up journeys and reduce accidents. Meanwhile, Jaguar Land Rover, which is testing similar connected technology in the UK, launched an independent start-up, InMotion, to develop smartphone apps and on-demand services. In future, you may not need to buy a Jaguar or a Land Rover. You'll be able to access the car you want, when you want it, at the swipe of a smartphone. There were more - many more - deals done during the year in the rush to secure competitive advantage or recover lost ground. In China, Didi Chuxing Technology took over Uber's taxi-hailing operation, and also received a $1bn investment from Apple. And China's biggest carmaker, Shanghai Automotive, launched what it claimed is the first internet-connected car, the Roewe RX5, fitted with the YunOS operating system (used in mobile phones) owned by Alibaba, better known as the company behind a huge online marketplace. There has been a sort of technological land grab. \"The competitive challenge galvanised rival companies into action,\" says Frost & Sullivan's Martyn Briggs. \"The challenge now for car companies (and tech firms) is how they use their systems on a global scale,\" he says. \"Partnerships are the key.\" He predicts more of the same in 2017, but in particular expects greater investment in artificial intelligence systems and an expansion in major cities of car-sharing schemes. But there will need to be a reckoning. \"The consumer only needs so many taxi-hailing and car-sharing apps. There will eventually need to be some consolidation,\" says Briggs. In 1908, the Ford Model T ushered in a mass market industry that at its core has remained the same for decades. But with the death of the internal combustion engine in sight, and the end of mass private ownership on the horizon, it's looking increasingly like 2016 was the year when some major players laid the groundwork for a new era.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 5510, "answer_start": 4042, "text": "Fiat Chrysler Automobiles teamed up with Alphabet to collaborate on the development of self-driving minivans. Ford, whose chief executive Mark Fields now refers to the company that made the first mass-produced vehicle as a \"mobility services provider\", pushed deeper into connected-car technology. This included investment in a San Francisco cloud-based software and data analytics company, Pivotal, in which Microsoft also has a stake. Ford, which has a growing R&D presence in Silicon Valley, is testing connected cars in the UK that can communicate with each other to help speed up journeys and reduce accidents. Meanwhile, Jaguar Land Rover, which is testing similar connected technology in the UK, launched an independent start-up, InMotion, to develop smartphone apps and on-demand services. In future, you may not need to buy a Jaguar or a Land Rover. You'll be able to access the car you want, when you want it, at the swipe of a smartphone. There were more - many more - deals done during the year in the rush to secure competitive advantage or recover lost ground. In China, Didi Chuxing Technology took over Uber's taxi-hailing operation, and also received a $1bn investment from Apple. And China's biggest carmaker, Shanghai Automotive, launched what it claimed is the first internet-connected car, the Roewe RX5, fitted with the YunOS operating system (used in mobile phones) owned by Alibaba, better known as the company behind a huge online marketplace." } ], "id": "14_0", "question": "Why buy?" } ] } ]
German terror suspect Jaber al-Bakr's jail death a scandal, says lawyer
13 October 2016
[ { "context": "The death in a prison cell of a Syrian refugee suspected of planning a bomb attack in Germany is a judicial scandal, his lawyer has said. Jaber al-Bakr, 22, strangled himself in a jail in Leipzig with his shirt and the government has demanded an immediate inquiry. His lawyer said the prison was aware Bakr was a suicide risk after he was captured on Monday. However, regional authorities said he had not been considered an acute risk. Jaber al-Bakr was detained on Monday on suspicion of plotting to bomb an airport in Berlin, possibly in the coming days. When police raided his flat in the eastern city of Chemnitz early on Saturday, they found 1.5kg of TATP, a home-made explosive used in the deadly jihadist attacks in Paris last year and in Brussels last March. Sebastian Gemkow, justice minister in the eastern state of Saxony, told reporters a psychological assessment of the prisoner had been made and safety measures had been taken. And the head of the prison described Bakr during the day as \"calm and on an even keel\". \"It shouldn't have happened, but it did,\" the justice minister said, adding that he took responsibility for the suicide but would not resign. Prison officials rejected reports that Bakr was only being checked on an hourly basis. Originally, he was given top-level supervision, involving 15-minute intervals, but a panel of experts agreed hours before he died to lower the regular checks to every 30 minutes. There is no video monitoring of prisoners held in remand cells in Saxony, said prison governor Rolf Jacob. A guard stationed outside the cell door would have been more appropriate, he acknowledged. Jabr al-Bakr's body was found at 19:45 (17:45 GMT) on Wednesday evening, 15 minutes after a regular check, the prison governor said. Attempts to resuscitate him failed. Defence lawyer Alexander Huebner was adamant his client was a risk as he had already broken light bulbs and tampered with power sockets. He had also been refusing food and drink. The prison governor said later that the damage had been assessed as vandalism rather than an indication of potential suicide. \"How could this happen?\" Mr Huebner asked. \"He must have been the best-guarded prisoner in Germany.\" German Interior Minister Thomas de Maiziere demanded a \"rapid and comprehensive inquiry\". He told German TV that Bakr's death had made the task of investigating the possible Berlin airport bomb plot much harder. Centre-right CDU politician Wolfgang Bosbach said it was a tragedy to lose such an important source of intelligence. Leading centre-left SPD politician Burkhard Lischka blamed the Saxony authorities for the death in custody and said years of underfunding were to blame. Family Affairs Minister Manuela Schwesig simply tweeted: \"What on earth's going on?\" Granted asylum last year after coming to Germany in February 2015, he had been under surveillance for months on suspicion of being linked to jihadist group Islamic State. But when police raided his flat early on Saturday, he escaped. Police fired a warning shot but were wary of harming neighbours. After a two-day manhunt Bakr made his way to Leipzig, where he asked three Syrian asylum seekers for help. The three told police they had heard about the manhunt and tied him up while one of them knelt on him. One of the men took a photo of the captive to a police station, and he was detained in the early hours of Monday. Widely hailed as heroes in Germany, the three men were apparently implicated by Bakr in the bomb plot, German media reported, citing security officials in Leipzig. Call to reward Syrian refugees who arrested fugitive", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2210, "answer_start": 767, "text": "Sebastian Gemkow, justice minister in the eastern state of Saxony, told reporters a psychological assessment of the prisoner had been made and safety measures had been taken. And the head of the prison described Bakr during the day as \"calm and on an even keel\". \"It shouldn't have happened, but it did,\" the justice minister said, adding that he took responsibility for the suicide but would not resign. Prison officials rejected reports that Bakr was only being checked on an hourly basis. Originally, he was given top-level supervision, involving 15-minute intervals, but a panel of experts agreed hours before he died to lower the regular checks to every 30 minutes. There is no video monitoring of prisoners held in remand cells in Saxony, said prison governor Rolf Jacob. A guard stationed outside the cell door would have been more appropriate, he acknowledged. Jabr al-Bakr's body was found at 19:45 (17:45 GMT) on Wednesday evening, 15 minutes after a regular check, the prison governor said. Attempts to resuscitate him failed. Defence lawyer Alexander Huebner was adamant his client was a risk as he had already broken light bulbs and tampered with power sockets. He had also been refusing food and drink. The prison governor said later that the damage had been assessed as vandalism rather than an indication of potential suicide. \"How could this happen?\" Mr Huebner asked. \"He must have been the best-guarded prisoner in Germany.\"" } ], "id": "15_0", "question": "What went wrong at the jail?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2777, "answer_start": 2211, "text": "German Interior Minister Thomas de Maiziere demanded a \"rapid and comprehensive inquiry\". He told German TV that Bakr's death had made the task of investigating the possible Berlin airport bomb plot much harder. Centre-right CDU politician Wolfgang Bosbach said it was a tragedy to lose such an important source of intelligence. Leading centre-left SPD politician Burkhard Lischka blamed the Saxony authorities for the death in custody and said years of underfunding were to blame. Family Affairs Minister Manuela Schwesig simply tweeted: \"What on earth's going on?\"" } ], "id": "15_1", "question": "How serious is the blow to German intelligence?" } ] } ]
North Korean diplomat in Pakistan suspected of bootlegging booze
9 November 2017
[ { "context": "A burglary at the residence of a North Korean diplomat in Pakistan has raised suspicion that the envoy might have been involved in large-scale booze bootlegging. Either that or the diplomat drinks a hefty amount himself, as the burglars took off with thousands of bottles of whisky, beer and wine from his Islamabad residence. Alcohol is illegal for Muslims in Pakistan and hence hard to get. Diplomats, though, have permission for a personal allowance and there is a suspicion that some of their quota often ends up on the black market. In early October, the residence of North Korean diplomat Hyon Ki-yong was broken into. He reported to the police that the burglars took off with two diamonds, several thousand US dollars, and a hefty hoard of liquor, beer and wine. The reports are conflicting. While Reuters news agency and Pakistan Today suggest the three robbers happened to be police officers and the authorities put out arrest warrants for them, other media suggest the whole thing was a police operation to begin with. Inspector Asjad Mehmood, the head of the Kohsar police station where the complaint was registered, told the BBC that three policemen were charged because they entered the diplomat's residence \"illegally\" and, upon finding the alcohol, did not report it back to superiors and instead \"tried to keep the stash for themselves\". The three men have been released on bail. A regular burglary would probably not be newsworthy. But this one involved alcohol - and lots of it. Again there are confusing reports but Reuters put the number well above 1,000 bottles of Johnnie Walker Black Label - said to be worth about $80 each on the black market Police are reported to have been told the robbers also took off with: - 200 cases of wine - 60 cartons of beer - Dozens of bottles of tequila Pakistan is a country where the majority-Muslim population is by law not allowed to drink alcohol. Some still drink, but alcohol is notoriously hard to come by. That has created a lucrative black market across the country. Foreign diplomats have a quota of how much alcohol they are allowed to bring in, and the booze has to stay in the embassy compound, not in the envoy's private residence. According to Reuters, the quarterly allowance for Mr Hyon would have been 120 litres of various spirits, 18 litres of wine and 240 litres of beer, far short of the amount of alcohol reportedly taken from his residence. This could mean two things: North Korean diplomats have been able to import a lot more than they are meant to and, unless they spend most of their days utterly drunk, they might have been selling the excess booze on the black market. North Korea's embassy has not commented on the allegations. The entire stash lifted from Mr Hyon could be worth more than $150,000 (PS115,000), Reuters estimates. North Koreans would not be the only diplomats selling their quotas to the growing market in Islamabad, says the BBC's Ilyas Khan, who is in Pakistan's capital. Pakistan has a few breweries of its own that produce for the country's non-Muslim population. But traditionally there has been a vast demand for imported drinks, particularly Scotch whisky and vodka. However, over the last 10 years or so, with the growth of Islamist militancy and its influence along the smuggling routes, western parts of the country have completely run dry, our correspondent says. This has boosted the business of Islamabad's bootleggers, and incentivised staffers of foreign diplomatic missions to make an extra buck on the black market. \"It certainly seems very plausible that this was for the black market,\" Andray Abrahamian of the Pacific Forum CSIS think-tank and the Griffith Asia Institute told the BBC. \"There's a track record of such illicit actions at North Korean missions abroad involving ivory, gold and alcohol.\" It would not be the first time that North Korean diplomats have been caught in the act. In 2015, there were allegations other diplomats had sold illegal liquor on the black market in Karachi. Also that year a North Korean diplomat was caught trying to smuggle $1.4m worth of gold into Bangladesh. And most recently, North Korean diplomats have been accused of smuggling ivory in Africa to earn cash that can be sent back to the regime in Pyongyang. The case of the gold in Bangladesh is particularly interesting because it illustrates the effect of tougher sanctions, Mr Abrahamian explains. Gold exports from North Korea used to be legal, but now Pyongyang has to find partners willing to falsify the origins of the precious metal. \"There's been something of a gangsterisation happening with many of their normal export goods having to use illicit paths,\" says Mr Abrahamian. UN imposes new sanctions on North Korea He adds that the proceeds of gold and arms' sales will likely be channelled back to the heart of the regime in Pyongyang, while smaller cases such as the liquor in Pakistan are probably for private gain or to fund the work of the diplomatic mission. With a sense that the entire world is out to get them, \"North Korean officials really feel like they are under siege, so it's a matter of survival\".", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2031, "answer_start": 1396, "text": "A regular burglary would probably not be newsworthy. But this one involved alcohol - and lots of it. Again there are confusing reports but Reuters put the number well above 1,000 bottles of Johnnie Walker Black Label - said to be worth about $80 each on the black market Police are reported to have been told the robbers also took off with: - 200 cases of wine - 60 cartons of beer - Dozens of bottles of tequila Pakistan is a country where the majority-Muslim population is by law not allowed to drink alcohol. Some still drink, but alcohol is notoriously hard to come by. That has created a lucrative black market across the country." } ], "id": "16_0", "question": "Why is it strange?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3536, "answer_start": 2032, "text": "Foreign diplomats have a quota of how much alcohol they are allowed to bring in, and the booze has to stay in the embassy compound, not in the envoy's private residence. According to Reuters, the quarterly allowance for Mr Hyon would have been 120 litres of various spirits, 18 litres of wine and 240 litres of beer, far short of the amount of alcohol reportedly taken from his residence. This could mean two things: North Korean diplomats have been able to import a lot more than they are meant to and, unless they spend most of their days utterly drunk, they might have been selling the excess booze on the black market. North Korea's embassy has not commented on the allegations. The entire stash lifted from Mr Hyon could be worth more than $150,000 (PS115,000), Reuters estimates. North Koreans would not be the only diplomats selling their quotas to the growing market in Islamabad, says the BBC's Ilyas Khan, who is in Pakistan's capital. Pakistan has a few breweries of its own that produce for the country's non-Muslim population. But traditionally there has been a vast demand for imported drinks, particularly Scotch whisky and vodka. However, over the last 10 years or so, with the growth of Islamist militancy and its influence along the smuggling routes, western parts of the country have completely run dry, our correspondent says. This has boosted the business of Islamabad's bootleggers, and incentivised staffers of foreign diplomatic missions to make an extra buck on the black market." } ], "id": "16_1", "question": "Where's the diplomat link?" } ] } ]
US and China extend trade talks
22 February 2019
[ { "context": "Chinese negotiators have agreed to extend their stay in Washington, as the US and China push to strike a trade deal. The decision was the latest sign that the two countries may be nearing an agreement, as they look for a way out of last year's punishing trade war. In a statement shared by the White House, Chinese President Xi Jinping hailed \"progress\" in the negotiations. US President Donald Trump also said a deal was \"more likely\" than not. \"The fact that they're willing to stay for quite a bit longer... that means something,\" he told reporters at the White House. \"I think there's a good chance that it happens.\" The US and China placed tariffs on billions of dollars worth of the others' goods last year as they faced off on trade. The US had initially threatened to increase tariffs on $200bn worth of goods from 10% to 25% if the two sides could not agree a deal by 1 March. But Mr Trump has appeared more flexible recently, as negotiators meet in Washington for a fourth round of talks. On Friday, Mr Trump did not commit to extending the deadline, but he did note progress, including an agreement on currency manipulation, the details of which were not disclosed. He also said he may meet with Mr Xi in March at his Mar-A-Lago resort. Huawei has not been part of the discussions to date, he added. China's Vice Premier Liu He, who has been leading the talks for the Chinese, said his team was \"ready\" for a deal. \"From China, we believe that it is very likely that it will happen,\" he said. Washington wants Beijing to make changes to its economic policies, which it says unfairly favour domestic companies through subsidies and other support. China has offered to increase purchases of US goods, such as soybeans and semiconductors - a move that could reduce the US trade deficit, a focus for Mr Trump. However, the country is unlikely to embrace broader structural changes, which are seen by some internally as a way to contain its rise. On Friday, US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer, who has been leading talks for the US, warned that \"major hurdles\" remain before a final agreement can be signed.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1503, "answer_start": 621, "text": "The US and China placed tariffs on billions of dollars worth of the others' goods last year as they faced off on trade. The US had initially threatened to increase tariffs on $200bn worth of goods from 10% to 25% if the two sides could not agree a deal by 1 March. But Mr Trump has appeared more flexible recently, as negotiators meet in Washington for a fourth round of talks. On Friday, Mr Trump did not commit to extending the deadline, but he did note progress, including an agreement on currency manipulation, the details of which were not disclosed. He also said he may meet with Mr Xi in March at his Mar-A-Lago resort. Huawei has not been part of the discussions to date, he added. China's Vice Premier Liu He, who has been leading the talks for the Chinese, said his team was \"ready\" for a deal. \"From China, we believe that it is very likely that it will happen,\" he said." } ], "id": "17_0", "question": "Where do talks stand now?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2120, "answer_start": 1504, "text": "Washington wants Beijing to make changes to its economic policies, which it says unfairly favour domestic companies through subsidies and other support. China has offered to increase purchases of US goods, such as soybeans and semiconductors - a move that could reduce the US trade deficit, a focus for Mr Trump. However, the country is unlikely to embrace broader structural changes, which are seen by some internally as a way to contain its rise. On Friday, US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer, who has been leading talks for the US, warned that \"major hurdles\" remain before a final agreement can be signed." } ], "id": "17_1", "question": "What are the two sides discussing?" } ] } ]
Trump attacks Mueller's Russia inquiry as 'absolutely nuts'
15 November 2018
[ { "context": "US President Donald Trump has attacked Robert Mueller's investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 US presidential election, calling it a \"total mess\" and \"absolutely nuts\". He tweeted on Thursday that investigators were \"threatening\" people to provide \"the answers they want\". \"They are screaming and shouting at people,\" Mr Trump wrote, adding that no collusion between his election campaign and Russia had been found. He says the inquiry is a \"witch hunt\". The US president has previously said the special counsel investigation led by Mr Mueller, who is a highly regarded former head of the FBI and a Republican, was unfair and dominated by \"hardened Democrats\". In Mr Trump's latest tweets, he describes Mr Mueller as \"conflicted\" and says that those involved in the long-running probe \"are a disgrace to our nation\". The president later tweeted that Mr Mueller and \"his gang of Democrat thugs\" were destroying people, and blamed social media tech giants for unfavourable coverage towards his administration and the Republicans. \"Check out how biased Facebook, Google and Twitter are in favour of the Democrats,\" he wrote. It is unclear what was behind his latest comments and Mr Trump did not provide any evidence for his claims. Analysis by Anthony Zurcher, BBC Washington Donald Trump is back on the attack against Robert Mueller's special counsel investigation. After a brief mid-term interlude that included dire warnings about refugee caravans in Mexico and mix-and-match endorsements of Republican candidates, the looming Russia investigation is back on the president's mind - and his Twitter feed. Mr Trump may simply be reflecting the growing sense that Mr Mueller is poised for new action after a pre-election quiet period. Rumours and reports have swirled of impending indictments and late nights at the special counsel's office. There's also the possibility that the president knows something new - either passed along from his lawyers or allies under investigation, or from his newly appointed acting attorney general, who the New York Times referred to in September as the White House's \"eyes and ears\" in the justice department. Whatever the explanation, Mr Trump has appeared in a sour mood of late, lashing out at the media and, according to background sources, considering changes to his top staff. There is the feeling in Washington of an impending storm, of threats to the presidency from the outside and within. It's been a quiet few days, but that seems certain to change. It comes just a week after the US president forced the resignation of Jeff Sessions, the US Attorney General who was an early supporter of Mr Trump. Mr Sessions had earlier voluntarily removed himself from the Russia probe after Democrats accused him of failing to disclose contacts with the Russian ambassador during his Senate confirmation hearing. Following this decision, Mr Trump told the New York Times: \"Sessions should have never recused himself, and if he was going to recuse himself, he should have told me before he took the job and I would have picked somebody else.\" Mr Sessions' replacement in charge of the Department of Justice, Matthew Whitaker, now has the power to sack Mr Mueller or end the investigation. Mr Whitaker, who has been appointed acting attorney general, has been open about his concerns over the scope of Mr Mueller's inquiry. In 2016, US intelligence agencies concluded that Russia had used a state-authorised campaign of cyber attacks and fake news stories planted on social media in an attempt to turn the election against Democrat candidate Hillary Clinton. A team of investigators led by Mr Mueller is looking into whether anyone from Mr Trump's campaign colluded in the effort. It has been established that senior members of Mr Trump's team met Russian officials, while several of these meetings were not initially disclosed. The president's son, Donald Trump Jr, met a Russian lawyer during the campaign who was said to have \"dirt\" on Mrs Clinton, and adviser George Papadopoulos has admitted lying to the FBI about meetings with alleged go-betweens for Russia. Four people connected with Mr Trump's campaign and presidency have been charged and further indictments could be issued. However the US president denies any wrongdoing and no solid evidence has emerged to implicate him.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 4329, "answer_start": 3368, "text": "In 2016, US intelligence agencies concluded that Russia had used a state-authorised campaign of cyber attacks and fake news stories planted on social media in an attempt to turn the election against Democrat candidate Hillary Clinton. A team of investigators led by Mr Mueller is looking into whether anyone from Mr Trump's campaign colluded in the effort. It has been established that senior members of Mr Trump's team met Russian officials, while several of these meetings were not initially disclosed. The president's son, Donald Trump Jr, met a Russian lawyer during the campaign who was said to have \"dirt\" on Mrs Clinton, and adviser George Papadopoulos has admitted lying to the FBI about meetings with alleged go-betweens for Russia. Four people connected with Mr Trump's campaign and presidency have been charged and further indictments could be issued. However the US president denies any wrongdoing and no solid evidence has emerged to implicate him." } ], "id": "18_0", "question": "What is behind the Russia investigation?" } ] } ]
Home Office investigated over student visa cheat claims
27 April 2019
[ { "context": "The government is being investigated over its decision to cancel 36,000 student visas due to accusations of cheating on English language tests. The Home Office has also deported more than 1,000 people after its own probe into exam fraud began in 2014. Spending watchdog the National Audit Office (NAO) said the Home Office's response would be reviewed after its decisions came under \"public scrutiny\". The Home Office says it is \"supporting\" the investigation. In a statement the NAO said: \"The Home Office revoked student visas where there was evidence of cheating, but its decisions have come under renewed public and parliamentary scrutiny in the wake of the Windrush scandal. \"The NAO is looking at the information held by the Home Office on the number of people alleged to have cheated and the action the Home Office has taken to date.\" The cheating scandal came to light in an undercover BBC Panorama investigation into fraud at two centres administering the mandatory language tests. The then government-approved Test of English for International Communication (TOEIC) involves a written and oral section and a separate multiple-choice question paper. Following the report, Theresa May, then home secretary, said the evidence was \"very shocking\". As a result, the Home Office ordered the US firm providing the exams, Educational Testing Service (ETS), to check more than 58,000 tests taken between 2011 and 2014. It said voice-recognition software suggested that proxy test-takers were used in more than 30,000 cases. The technology extracts biometric features from an individual's speech to create a voice print, the vocal equivalent of a fingerprint. It then looked for possible matches which indicated the same individual took multiple tests, before auditors verified suspected matches. So far, the Home Office says, 25 people have been convicted over \"facilitating\" the exam fraud. But Labour MP Stephen Timms has said many students were falsely accused, and had been given no opportunity to clear their name. On Thursday, Mr Timms, MP for East Ham, told Victoria Derbyshire the treatment of the students had been \"a disgrace\". \"They trusted Britain to provide them with a decent education. Instead, they've been falsely accused of cheating and been given no chance to appeal.\" Foreign students accused of cheating by officials have told the BBC they have been left in limbo for years. Fatema Chowdhury came to the UK from Bangladesh in 2010 and finished her law degree in 2014 at the University of London. Speaking on Thursday's Victoria Derbyshire programme, she said at one stage she was detained for a week after being accused of cheating. She denies the accusation. Ms Chowdury has not been told to leave the UK, but while she remains in the country she is prevented from working and cannot use the NHS for free. \"During my delivery last year they charged me PS14,000 just to have a baby,\" she said. - .Nine guilty over student visa plot She said her \"dreams and hopes\" were now gone, and she was \"desperate\" to speak to someone at the Home Office to prove her innocence. But after four years of trying she said \"there is no hope\". Nidhin Chand, an Indian woman living in Scotland, spoke to BBC Scotland earlier this month about her fight to clear her name over fraud allegations. She has been accused of using a stand-in to sit an English language test for her visa application. She said: \"I have been crying every day... It is painful when someone calls you a fraud and arrests you in front of the public and humiliates you.\" The Home Office has said it welcomes \"genuine international students\" and that there is no limit on the number who study in the UK. In response to the new watchdog investigation, a spokesman said: \"We have been supporting the National Audit Office in its work on this investigation since the start of the year. We will consider the findings of the report once it is published.\"", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1797, "answer_start": 1526, "text": "The technology extracts biometric features from an individual's speech to create a voice print, the vocal equivalent of a fingerprint. It then looked for possible matches which indicated the same individual took multiple tests, before auditors verified suspected matches." } ], "id": "19_0", "question": "How did they look for cheating?" } ] } ]
Trump names Lt Gen HR McMaster as national security adviser
21 February 2017
[ { "context": "US President Donald Trump has named Lt Gen HR McMaster as his national security adviser. He will replace Lt Gen Michael Flynn who was fired after just three weeks and three days in the job. A lieutenant general with the US Army, HR McMaster served in Iraq and Afghanistan, where he worked on a government anti-corruption drive. Mr Trump's first choice, retired Vice Admiral Robert Harward, turned down the role, citing \"personal reasons\". Mr Trump has praised Herbert Raymond McMaster as \"a man of tremendous talent and tremendous experience\" who is \"highly respected by everybody in the military\". Gen McMaster served in Afghanistan and Iraq, and is known as a thoughtful, if straight-talking, military strategist, the BBC's Aleem Maqbool reports from Washington. He does not appear to have close ties to Moscow, and was recently commissioned to study the ways the US could counter some of Russia's military advances, our correspondent adds. Gen McMaster is no stranger to questioning authority. In a 2014 interview, he said: \"The commanders that I've worked for, they want frank assessments, they want criticism and feedback.\" Profile: The new national security adviser How much has Trump achieved so far? Russia: The scandal Trump can't shake Time magazine named him as one of its 100 most influential people in the world in 2014, saying he \"might be the 21st Century Army's pre-eminent warrior-thinker\". He criticised the US military's involvement in the Vietnam War in his book Dereliction of Duty. He has a PhD in US history from the University of North Carolina. Gen McMaster has said it is \"a privilege... to be able to continue serving our nation\" and that he looks forward to joining the national security team. The role involves serving as an independent adviser to the president on issues of national security and foreign policy. It is one of the most senior roles in the US government. Observers say the role's influence varies from administration to administration, but the adviser is seen as one of the president's key confidantes. The adviser attends the National Security Council, and may act as a broker between different government departments. The role is not subject to US Senate confirmation. Gen Flynn stepped down after misleading Vice-President Mike Pence over his conversations with Russia's ambassador to the US. Mr Flynn is alleged to have discussed US sanctions with Russia's ambassador in calls before his own appointment. It is illegal for private citizens to conduct US diplomacy. However, Mr Trump wrote on Twitter that the intelligence leaks about Mr Flynn's conversations were \"the real scandal\". Mr Flynn's short tenure led critics to describe Mr Trump's administration as chaotic. Keith Kellogg, who took over as acting national security adviser after the resignation, will now serve as the National Security Council chief of staff. The other candidates in the running were Robert Caslen, an Army lieutenant general who is the superintendent of the US Military Academy at West Point, and career diplomat John Bolton, who served as George W Bush's ambassador to the UN from August 2005 to December 2006. Mr Trump says Mr Bolton will also serve his government \"in another capacity\". Mr Trump held interviews with the four men at Mar-a-Lago where he spent the third weekend in a row. He has called Mar-a-Lago, a private property, the \"Southern White House\".", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1128, "answer_start": 439, "text": "Mr Trump has praised Herbert Raymond McMaster as \"a man of tremendous talent and tremendous experience\" who is \"highly respected by everybody in the military\". Gen McMaster served in Afghanistan and Iraq, and is known as a thoughtful, if straight-talking, military strategist, the BBC's Aleem Maqbool reports from Washington. He does not appear to have close ties to Moscow, and was recently commissioned to study the ways the US could counter some of Russia's military advances, our correspondent adds. Gen McMaster is no stranger to questioning authority. In a 2014 interview, he said: \"The commanders that I've worked for, they want frank assessments, they want criticism and feedback.\"" } ], "id": "20_0", "question": "Who is Lt Gen HR McMaster?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2215, "answer_start": 1723, "text": "The role involves serving as an independent adviser to the president on issues of national security and foreign policy. It is one of the most senior roles in the US government. Observers say the role's influence varies from administration to administration, but the adviser is seen as one of the president's key confidantes. The adviser attends the National Security Council, and may act as a broker between different government departments. The role is not subject to US Senate confirmation." } ], "id": "20_1", "question": "What will his role as national security adviser involve?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2718, "answer_start": 2216, "text": "Gen Flynn stepped down after misleading Vice-President Mike Pence over his conversations with Russia's ambassador to the US. Mr Flynn is alleged to have discussed US sanctions with Russia's ambassador in calls before his own appointment. It is illegal for private citizens to conduct US diplomacy. However, Mr Trump wrote on Twitter that the intelligence leaks about Mr Flynn's conversations were \"the real scandal\". Mr Flynn's short tenure led critics to describe Mr Trump's administration as chaotic." } ], "id": "20_2", "question": "Why did his predecessor step down?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3392, "answer_start": 2719, "text": "Keith Kellogg, who took over as acting national security adviser after the resignation, will now serve as the National Security Council chief of staff. The other candidates in the running were Robert Caslen, an Army lieutenant general who is the superintendent of the US Military Academy at West Point, and career diplomat John Bolton, who served as George W Bush's ambassador to the UN from August 2005 to December 2006. Mr Trump says Mr Bolton will also serve his government \"in another capacity\". Mr Trump held interviews with the four men at Mar-a-Lago where he spent the third weekend in a row. He has called Mar-a-Lago, a private property, the \"Southern White House\"." } ], "id": "20_3", "question": "Who else was considered for the job?" } ] } ]
WhatsApp's privacy protections questioned after terror attack
27 March 2017
[ { "context": "Chat apps that promise to prevent your messages being accessed by strangers are under scrutiny again following last week's terror attack in London. On Sunday, the home secretary said the intelligence services must be able to access relevant information. Her comments followed the discovery that Khalid Masood appeared to have used WhatsApp minutes before carrying out his killings. There are doubts about whether that action was related to the atrocity. BBC home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw has highlighted that the police had declared that they believed Masood had acted alone on the day, and would not have done so unless they had accessed and read messages stored on his phone. Even so, the home secretary has summoned WhatsApp's owner, Facebook, and other technology companies to a meeting on Thursday to discuss ways to ensure that security officers get the data they need in the future. Several chat apps have adopted a technique called end-to-end encryption. This digitally scrambles their messages' contents when it leaves a sender's device, and then reassembles it on the recipient's computer using a shared key. The technology company running the service is not made privy to the key, so is unable to make sense of the conversation even though it passes through its computer servers. Some apps, including WhatsApp, Apple's iMessage, Signal and Threema, use end-to-end encryption by default. Others, such as Telegram, Line and Google's Allo, offer it as an option. If end-to-end encryption is active, the technology company running the app is limited in what useful information it can remotely disclose. But if a phone, tablet or PC is not passcode-protected - or if the authorities find a way to bypass the code - the physical device itself will provide access. Not necessarily. When someone sends or reads a message, they generate what's known as \"metadata\" - information about their interaction that is distinct from the chat's contents. This can include: - the time a message was written - the telephone number or other ID of the person it was sent to - the physical locations of the sender and recipient at the time WhatsApp has shared such details with law enforcement officers in the past and has said it has been co-operating with authorities over last week's incident. In addition, if Apple users subscribe to the company's iCloud Backup service, the firm may be able to recover messages copied to its servers for safe-keeping and it has co-operated with investigators in the past. It is not exactly clear. The Home Secretary, Amber Rudd, told the BBC that chat apps must not \"provide a secret place\" for terrorists to communicate, and that when a warrant had been issued, officers should be able to \"get into situations like encrypted WhatsApp\". On Sky News, she later added that she supported end-to-end encryption as a cybersecurity measure, but said it was \"absurd to have a situation where you can have terrorists talking to each other on a formal platform... and it can't be accessed\". How this would work in practice is uncertain. WhatsApp, for example, does not store messages on its servers after they have been delivered. So, even if there was a way to retrospectively unencrypt the chats, it is unclear how this would work without significant changes to its systems. At one point, there had been speculation that the Investigatory Powers Act - which came into effect last year - might ban chat app's use of end-to-end encryption outright. Instead, it stated that technology companies could be compelled to \"provide a technical capability\" to remove \"electronic protection\" within their products - which has been interpreted by some to mean app-makers might be compelled to secretly create backdoors or other security weaknesses to let messages be unscrambled. Files leaked by rogue US National Security Agency (NSA) contractor Edward Snowden and Wikileaks suggest that even the most closely guarded hacking secrets can be revealed. And even if the tech companies did not share the technical details of the backdoors with the authorities - instead limiting themselves to passing on unscrambled chats - the very fact vulnerabilities existed means someone else might sniff them out. As a consequence, public trust in their software might be undermined. \"The encryption debate always rages after a terror incident, regardless of how effective backdoors would have been,\" said security consultant Troy Hunt. \"Even if, say, the UK was to ban encryption or mandate weaknesses be built into WhatsApp and iMessage, those with nefarious intent would simply obtain encryption products from other sources. \"These responses are kneejerk reactions by those who have little understanding of the efficacy and implications of what they're actually proposing.\" The TechUK lobby group said other hacking powers and a move to make internet providers keep a record of their customers' internet habits - which were also outlined in the Investigatory Powers Act - meant counter-terrorism officers already had strong powers to tackle threats. \"From storing data on the cloud to online banking to identity verification, end-to-end encryption is essential for preventing data being accessed illegally in ways that can harm consumers, business and our national security,\" said its deputy chief executive, Antony Walker.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 1776, "answer_start": 898, "text": "Several chat apps have adopted a technique called end-to-end encryption. This digitally scrambles their messages' contents when it leaves a sender's device, and then reassembles it on the recipient's computer using a shared key. The technology company running the service is not made privy to the key, so is unable to make sense of the conversation even though it passes through its computer servers. Some apps, including WhatsApp, Apple's iMessage, Signal and Threema, use end-to-end encryption by default. Others, such as Telegram, Line and Google's Allo, offer it as an option. If end-to-end encryption is active, the technology company running the app is limited in what useful information it can remotely disclose. But if a phone, tablet or PC is not passcode-protected - or if the authorities find a way to bypass the code - the physical device itself will provide access." } ], "id": "21_0", "question": "What has this got to do with encryption?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2504, "answer_start": 1777, "text": "Not necessarily. When someone sends or reads a message, they generate what's known as \"metadata\" - information about their interaction that is distinct from the chat's contents. This can include: - the time a message was written - the telephone number or other ID of the person it was sent to - the physical locations of the sender and recipient at the time WhatsApp has shared such details with law enforcement officers in the past and has said it has been co-operating with authorities over last week's incident. In addition, if Apple users subscribe to the company's iCloud Backup service, the firm may be able to recover messages copied to its servers for safe-keeping and it has co-operated with investigators in the past." } ], "id": "21_1", "question": "Does that mean the technology companies have made it impossible for themselves to help investigators?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3793, "answer_start": 2505, "text": "It is not exactly clear. The Home Secretary, Amber Rudd, told the BBC that chat apps must not \"provide a secret place\" for terrorists to communicate, and that when a warrant had been issued, officers should be able to \"get into situations like encrypted WhatsApp\". On Sky News, she later added that she supported end-to-end encryption as a cybersecurity measure, but said it was \"absurd to have a situation where you can have terrorists talking to each other on a formal platform... and it can't be accessed\". How this would work in practice is uncertain. WhatsApp, for example, does not store messages on its servers after they have been delivered. So, even if there was a way to retrospectively unencrypt the chats, it is unclear how this would work without significant changes to its systems. At one point, there had been speculation that the Investigatory Powers Act - which came into effect last year - might ban chat app's use of end-to-end encryption outright. Instead, it stated that technology companies could be compelled to \"provide a technical capability\" to remove \"electronic protection\" within their products - which has been interpreted by some to mean app-makers might be compelled to secretly create backdoors or other security weaknesses to let messages be unscrambled." } ], "id": "21_2", "question": "What more does the government want?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 5326, "answer_start": 3794, "text": "Files leaked by rogue US National Security Agency (NSA) contractor Edward Snowden and Wikileaks suggest that even the most closely guarded hacking secrets can be revealed. And even if the tech companies did not share the technical details of the backdoors with the authorities - instead limiting themselves to passing on unscrambled chats - the very fact vulnerabilities existed means someone else might sniff them out. As a consequence, public trust in their software might be undermined. \"The encryption debate always rages after a terror incident, regardless of how effective backdoors would have been,\" said security consultant Troy Hunt. \"Even if, say, the UK was to ban encryption or mandate weaknesses be built into WhatsApp and iMessage, those with nefarious intent would simply obtain encryption products from other sources. \"These responses are kneejerk reactions by those who have little understanding of the efficacy and implications of what they're actually proposing.\" The TechUK lobby group said other hacking powers and a move to make internet providers keep a record of their customers' internet habits - which were also outlined in the Investigatory Powers Act - meant counter-terrorism officers already had strong powers to tackle threats. \"From storing data on the cloud to online banking to identity verification, end-to-end encryption is essential for preventing data being accessed illegally in ways that can harm consumers, business and our national security,\" said its deputy chief executive, Antony Walker." } ], "id": "21_3", "question": "Why might technology companies resist?" } ] } ]
Austria presidential poll result overturned
1 July 2016
[ { "context": "Austria's highest court has annulled the result of the presidential election narrowly lost by the candidate of the far-right Freedom Party. The party had challenged the result, saying that postal votes had been illegally and improperly handled. The Freedom Party candidate, Norbert Hofer, lost the election to the former leader of the Greens, Alexander Van der Bellen, by just 30,863 votes or less than one percentage point. The election will now be re-run. Announcing the decision, Gerhard Holzinger, head of the Constitutional Court, said: \"The challenge brought by Freedom Party leader Heinz-Christian Strache against the 22 May election... has been upheld.\" He added: \"The decision I am announcing today has no winner and no loser, it has only one aim: to strengthen trust in the rule of law and democracy.\" Austria's politics have been thrown into confusion. One of the most controversial and polarising presidential elections in recent history will have to be re-run. This is a moral victory for the far-right, anti-immigrant and Eurosceptic Freedom Party, which launched the legal challenge last month after alleging \"terrifying\" irregularities. The Freedom Party is hoping that the decision by the court will help its candidate Norbert Hofer win in the new election this autumn. Hanging over the vote is the shadow of \"Brexit\" - the UK's decision to leave the EU. Will Mr Hofer choose to make Austria's future membership of the EU a campaign issue? Some Austrians think the vote by the United Kingdom to leave the EU could boost populist and nationalist sentiment in Austria. Others believe the political turbulence in Britain may make people more cautious about Eurosceptic parties. Mr Hofer said on Friday he was pleased that the court had taken \"a difficult decision\", adding: \"I have great trust in the rule of law.\" Mr Van der Bellen said he was \"very confident\" he would emerge the winner. \"Austria needs to be well represented in Europe and the world. If we can do it once, we can do it again,\" he told reporters. Austrian Chancellor Christian Kern said the court ruling showed that the country's democracy was strong and he called for \"a short campaign, a campaign without emotions\". In two weeks of hearings, lawyers for the Freedom Party argued that postal ballots were illegally handled in 94 out of 117 districts. It alleged that thousands of votes were opened earlier than permitted under election rules and some were counted by people unauthorised to do so. The party also claimed to have evidence that some under-16s and foreigners had been allowed to vote. In its ruling, the court said election rules had been broken in a way that could have influenced the result. But it said there was no proof the count had been manipulated. If elected, Mr Hofer would become the first far-right head of state of an EU country. His party has based its election campaigns around concern over immigration and falling living standards for the less well-off. After Britain voted to leave the EU, Mr Hofer said he favoured holding a similar referendum in Austria if the bloc failed to stop centralisation and carry out reforms \"within a year\". Last Sunday, he told the Oesterreich newspaper (in German): \"If [the EU] evolves in the wrong direction, then in my opinion the time has come to ask the Austrians if they still want to be part of it.\" His opponent, Mr Van der Bellen, is strongly pro-EU and has spoken of his dream for a border-free \"United States of Europe\". The two men went forward to a run-off when, for the first time since World War Two, both the main centrist parties were knocked out in the first round of voting. Following the court's order to re-run the vote, President Heinz Fischer will be replaced on a temporary basis by three parliamentary officials, including Mr Hofer. The new election is expected to be held in September or October. It is a mostly ceremonial post. But the president does have the power to dissolve the National Council - the more powerful lower house of parliament. That triggers a general election. The president can only do that once for a particular reason - he cannot use the same grounds to dissolve it again. It is the chancellor's job to appoint government ministers. And the chancellor has the power to dismiss the government. But ministers have to be formally sworn in by the president. Norbert Hofer - Age: 45 - Background: Aeronautical engineer - Politics: Far-right Freedom Party - Campaign soundbite: \"To those in Austria who go to war for the Islamic State or rape women - I say to those people: 'This is not your home'.\" Alexander Van der Bellen - Age: 72 - Background: Economics professor - Politics: Former Green Party leader - Campaign soundbite: \"I've experienced how Austria rose from the ruins of World War Two, caused by the madness of nationalism.\"", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 4346, "answer_start": 3867, "text": "It is a mostly ceremonial post. But the president does have the power to dissolve the National Council - the more powerful lower house of parliament. That triggers a general election. The president can only do that once for a particular reason - he cannot use the same grounds to dissolve it again. It is the chancellor's job to appoint government ministers. And the chancellor has the power to dismiss the government. But ministers have to be formally sworn in by the president." } ], "id": "22_0", "question": "What powers does the Austrian president have?" } ] } ]
Google claims 'quantum supremacy' for computer
23 October 2019
[ { "context": "Google says an advanced computer has achieved \"quantum supremacy\" for the first time, surpassing the performance of conventional devices. The technology giant's Sycamore quantum processor was able to perform a specific task in 200 seconds that would take the world's best supercomputer 10,000 years to complete. Scientists have been working on quantum computers for decades because they promise much faster speeds. The result appears in Nature journal. In classical computers, the unit of information is called a \"bit\" and can have a value of either 1 or 0. But its equivalent in a quantum system - the qubit (quantum bit) - can be both 1 and 0 at the same time. This phenomenon opens the door for multiple calculations to be performed simultaneously. But the qubits need to be synchronised using a quantum effect known as entanglement, which Albert Einstein termed \"spooky action at a distance\". However, scientists have struggled to build working devices with enough qubits to make them competitive with conventional types of computer. Sycamore contains 54 qubits, although one of them did not work, so the device ran on 53 qubits. In their Nature paper, John Martinis of Google, in Mountain View, and colleagues set the processor a random sampling task - where it produces a set of numbers that has a truly random distribution. Sycamore was able to complete the task in three minutes and 20 seconds. By contrast, the researchers claim in their paper that Summit, the world's best supercomputer, would take 10,000 years to complete the task. \"It's an impressive device and certainly an impressive milestone. We're still decades away from an actual quantum computer that would be able to solve problems we're interested in,\" Prof Jonathan Oppenheim, from UCL, who was not involved with the latest study, told BBC News. \"It's an interesting test, it shows they have a lot of control over their device, it shows that they have low error rates. But it's nowhere near the kind of precision we would need to have a full-scale quantum computer.\" IBM, which has been working on quantum computers of its own, questioned some of Google's figures. \"We argue that an ideal simulation of the same task can be performed on a classical system in 2.5 days and with far greater fidelity,\" IBM researchers Edwin Pednault, John Gunnels, and Jay Gambetta said in a blog post. \"This is in fact a conservative, worst-case estimate, and we expect that with additional refinements the classical cost of the simulation can be further reduced.\" They also queried Google's definition of quantum supremacy and said it had the potential to mislead. \"First because... by its strictest definition the goal has not been met. But more fundamentally, because quantum computers will never reign 'supreme' over classical computers, but will rather work in concert with them, since each have their unique strengths.\" Follow Paul on Twitter.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2905, "answer_start": 2041, "text": "IBM, which has been working on quantum computers of its own, questioned some of Google's figures. \"We argue that an ideal simulation of the same task can be performed on a classical system in 2.5 days and with far greater fidelity,\" IBM researchers Edwin Pednault, John Gunnels, and Jay Gambetta said in a blog post. \"This is in fact a conservative, worst-case estimate, and we expect that with additional refinements the classical cost of the simulation can be further reduced.\" They also queried Google's definition of quantum supremacy and said it had the potential to mislead. \"First because... by its strictest definition the goal has not been met. But more fundamentally, because quantum computers will never reign 'supreme' over classical computers, but will rather work in concert with them, since each have their unique strengths.\" Follow Paul on Twitter." } ], "id": "23_0", "question": "Worst-case scenario?" } ] } ]
Zimbabwe troops accused of 'systematic torture' of protesters
23 January 2019
[ { "context": "A government-appointed human rights group in Zimbabwe has accused soldiers of using \"systematic torture\" in a crackdown on protests. The Zimbabwe Human Rights Commission strongly criticised authorities for using troops to quell demonstrations. Unrest broke out more than a week ago following a sharp rise in fuel prices. A government spokesman defended the crackdown, telling the BBC: \"When things get out of hand, a bit of firmness is needed.\" Reports have emerged of assaults allegedly carried out by the military in various parts of the capital, Harare. Soldiers in Harare were seen beating a large group of minibus drivers on Tuesday. The BBC's Andrew Harding in Harare spoke to a man who said he and about 30 others had been rounded up and beaten by soldiers for \"more than two hours\". The continuing violence raises further questions about President Emmerson Mnangagwa's control over the military, which helped bring him to power 14 months ago, our correspondent adds. President Mnangagwa has promised that abuses against civilians will not be tolerated. In a blunt statement, the commission said at least eight deaths had been reported since last week, \"mostly attributed to use of live ammunition\". \"Armed and uniformed members of the Zimbabwe National Army and the Zimbabwe Republic Police instigated systematic torture.\" It said the torture was \"organised\" in that security forces targeted men close to where barricades had been erected, and near areas torched by protesters or looted. The commission detailed reports of security forces entering houses at night and making men, and even boys as young as 11, lie on the ground where they were then beaten. \"The deployment of the army in quelling civilian disturbances leads to loss of life and serious bodily injuries and other human rights violations, yet the government continues to make such deployments,\" the statement said. Other reports say at least 12 people have been killed and scores treated for gunshot injuries. More than 600 people have been arrested in relation to the protests - with rights groups and opposition lawmakers saying many have been detained arbitrarily. Pastor Evan Mawarire, a prominent activist who led the 2016 protests against Robert Mugabe, was arrested on 16 January and remains in detention. On Monday Mr Mnangagwa, 76, broke off a trip to Europe to deal with the continuing unrest. He had been due to attend the Davos economic summit where he was expected to seek investment for Zimbabwe. Back in Harare, he took to Twitter to urge all sides to work together to fix a broken economy. In a series of tweets, he said violence or misconduct by security forces was \"unacceptable and a betrayal of the new Zimbabwe\", adding: \"If required, heads will roll.\" Mr Mnangagwa announced a steep increase in the fuel price earlier this month. The price rises were meant to tackle fuel shortages, but mean that Zimbabwe now has the most expensive fuel in the world, according to GlobalPetrolPrices.com. Many Zimbabweans, worn down by years of economic hardship, have suddenly found they cannot even afford the bus fare to work. This led to angry protests in Harare and the south-western city of Bulawayo. Ellen Ngwenia, a pre-school teacher in Epworth, told the BBC: \"I'm not afraid to protest, because we are hungry.\" Her mother, the school's headteacher, was killed in last week's protests after being hit by an army truck. Ms Ngwenia, who blames the government for her mother's death, said \"we will continue protesting until things [are] settled.\" It accuses the opposition MDC party of using the protests for political means. Presidential spokesman George Charamba said on Sunday: \"The MDC leadership has been consistently pushing out the message that they will use violent street action to overturn the results of [last year's] ballot.\" The opposition rejected a court ruling in August 2018 that confirmed President Mnangagwa had defeated MDC leader Nelson Chamisa The MDC said on Tuesday that five of its MPs had been detained and refused bail. Party official Morgen Komichi dismissed Mr Mnangagwa's announcement of an investigation into security forces, saying: \"We don't trust his word. We don't regard him as an honest leader.\" The Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions, the umbrella group that called the protests, says its leader, Japhet Moyo, has also been arrested. Mr Chamisa told the BBC there was \"no justification whatsoever of having soldiers with live ammunition, with guns, machine guns, AK47 on the streets, beating up citizens\". \"People are being approached in their homes, they are being taken out of their homes with their families even if they are sleeping... a lot of people have been arrested for no apparent reason,\" he said.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2285, "answer_start": 1061, "text": "In a blunt statement, the commission said at least eight deaths had been reported since last week, \"mostly attributed to use of live ammunition\". \"Armed and uniformed members of the Zimbabwe National Army and the Zimbabwe Republic Police instigated systematic torture.\" It said the torture was \"organised\" in that security forces targeted men close to where barricades had been erected, and near areas torched by protesters or looted. The commission detailed reports of security forces entering houses at night and making men, and even boys as young as 11, lie on the ground where they were then beaten. \"The deployment of the army in quelling civilian disturbances leads to loss of life and serious bodily injuries and other human rights violations, yet the government continues to make such deployments,\" the statement said. Other reports say at least 12 people have been killed and scores treated for gunshot injuries. More than 600 people have been arrested in relation to the protests - with rights groups and opposition lawmakers saying many have been detained arbitrarily. Pastor Evan Mawarire, a prominent activist who led the 2016 protests against Robert Mugabe, was arrested on 16 January and remains in detention." } ], "id": "24_0", "question": "What has been alleged?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2747, "answer_start": 2286, "text": "On Monday Mr Mnangagwa, 76, broke off a trip to Europe to deal with the continuing unrest. He had been due to attend the Davos economic summit where he was expected to seek investment for Zimbabwe. Back in Harare, he took to Twitter to urge all sides to work together to fix a broken economy. In a series of tweets, he said violence or misconduct by security forces was \"unacceptable and a betrayal of the new Zimbabwe\", adding: \"If required, heads will roll.\"" } ], "id": "24_1", "question": "What is President Mnangagwa doing?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 3532, "answer_start": 2748, "text": "Mr Mnangagwa announced a steep increase in the fuel price earlier this month. The price rises were meant to tackle fuel shortages, but mean that Zimbabwe now has the most expensive fuel in the world, according to GlobalPetrolPrices.com. Many Zimbabweans, worn down by years of economic hardship, have suddenly found they cannot even afford the bus fare to work. This led to angry protests in Harare and the south-western city of Bulawayo. Ellen Ngwenia, a pre-school teacher in Epworth, told the BBC: \"I'm not afraid to protest, because we are hungry.\" Her mother, the school's headteacher, was killed in last week's protests after being hit by an army truck. Ms Ngwenia, who blames the government for her mother's death, said \"we will continue protesting until things [are] settled.\"" } ], "id": "24_2", "question": "How did the protests start?" }, { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 4731, "answer_start": 3952, "text": "The MDC said on Tuesday that five of its MPs had been detained and refused bail. Party official Morgen Komichi dismissed Mr Mnangagwa's announcement of an investigation into security forces, saying: \"We don't trust his word. We don't regard him as an honest leader.\" The Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions, the umbrella group that called the protests, says its leader, Japhet Moyo, has also been arrested. Mr Chamisa told the BBC there was \"no justification whatsoever of having soldiers with live ammunition, with guns, machine guns, AK47 on the streets, beating up citizens\". \"People are being approached in their homes, they are being taken out of their homes with their families even if they are sleeping... a lot of people have been arrested for no apparent reason,\" he said." } ], "id": "24_3", "question": "What has the opposition said?" } ] } ]
Australia fires: New South Wales declares week-long emergency
2 January 2020
[ { "context": "The leader of Australia's eastern New South Wales state has declared a week-long state of emergency in response to the escalating bushfire threat. High temperatures and strong winds are forecast for the weekend, leading to \"widespread extreme fire danger\". Troops are also preparing to evacuate some of the 4,000 people trapped by fires in neighbouring Victoria state. Since September, bushfires have killed 18 people and destroyed more than 1,200 homes across NSW and Victoria. At least 17 people remain missing after fires this week alone. Thousands of people are already fleeing a vast \"tourist leave zone\" in NSW, with supplies running low in some cut-off towns. It's been called \"the largest relocation out of the region ever\". In Victoria, a naval vessel has arrived off the coastal town of Mallacoota, near the NSW border. Victoria Premier Daniel Andrews said the ship would take up to 800 people early on Friday. He said it could do \"multiple trips\". Defence Minister Linda Reynolds tweeted that the HMAS Choules was in position. The state of emergency will kick in at 08:00 on Friday (21:00 GMT on Thursday) and last for seven days. It will allow local authorities to carry out forced evacuations, road closures \"and anything else we need to do as a state to keep our residents and to keep property safe\", NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian said on Thursday. \"We don't take these decisions lightly but we also want to make sure we're taking every single precaution to be prepared for what could be a horrible day on Saturday.\" The state government has warned that conditions are likely to be \"at least as bad\" as New Year's Eve, when hundreds of homes were destroyed. Earlier, fire officials told holidaymakers to urgently leave a 260km (160-mile) stretch of NSW coast before Saturday. Long lines of cars have clogged highways leading back towards Sydney and Canberra. Local media reported hour-long queues for petrol in the town of Batemans Bay, while fuel was being trucked in to the region as supplies dwindled. Many roads remained closed due to continuing fires and other dangers, such as unstable or fallen trees. Workers were clearing roads, restoring power, and conducting \"backburning\" operations to thin out bushland near fire fronts. NSW Transport Minister Andrew Constance urged people to drive slowly amid thick smoke. This week's fires have destroyed at least 381 homes in NSW and 43 in Victoria, but officials say that number will grow. The seven deaths in NSW include: - Two people found in separate cars on Wednesday morning - A father and son who stayed behind to defend their home and farm equipment - A 28-year-old volunteer firefighter who was killed when wind flipped his fire engine Family members of Mick Roberts, a 67-year-old Victorian missing since Monday, confirmed that he had been found dead in his home in Buchan, East Gippsland. \"Very sad day for us to (start) the year but we're a bloody tight family and we will never forget our mate and my beautiful Uncle Mick,\" his niece Leah Parson said on Facebook. Mr Andrews said there were \"significant fears\" for 17 people unaccounted for in his state. Fire services in Victoria and NSW warned they had been unable to reach some people in remote areas. In the capital Canberra - an administrative region surrounded by NSW - bushfire smoke meant air quality there was rated worse than any major global city on Thursday, according to Swiss-based group AirVisual. An elderly woman died after being exposed to the smoke as she exited a plane at Canberra airport, local reports say. Australia Post has suspended deliveries in the city \"until further notice\". - Are you affected by the fires? Let us know by emailing haveyoursay@bbc.co.uk Under the NSW 1994 State Emergency and Rescue Management Act, the premier can issue a state of emergency when there is considered to be \"a significant and widespread danger to life or property\". - A state of emergency cuts the red tape, making it quicker and easier for emergency services to act - It puts the premier in direct command of all agencies and the allocation of resources and significantly increases the powers of the Rural Fire Service commissioner - Authorities can order people to evacuate from at-risk places or to \"do all such things as are reasonably necessary\" to make them leave, including through reasonable force - Emergency workers may be cleared to use force to get inside a property or take possession of it if needed - Authorities can open and close roads as needed, shut down utilities and pull down infrastructure - Financial assistance can be made available to volunteers Two regions of Western Australia (WA) were also facing catastrophic fire danger on Thursday, and parts of South Australia were expected to see extreme conditions on Friday. The ABC reported that bushfires had forced the closure of a 330km stretch of a highway in WA, causing traffic jams. Emergency supplies including water and toilet paper were flown in to a remote guesthouse located about 1,000km (620 miles) east of Perth which has been cut off from the city by bushfires. About 120 people were on the Caiguna Roadhouse site, where temperatures were forecast to reach 48 degrees. In Tasmania a fire burning on the outskirts of the state capital Hobart was downgraded from emergency to watch and act status. On Thursday, Prime Minister Scott Morrison repeated his calls to people not to panic and to trust emergency workers. \"I understand the fear that is there for many and the frustration, but this is a natural disaster, and natural disasters are best dealt with through the methodical, well-co-ordinated response that we are seeing today,\" he told a press conference. Amid criticism that he had \"gone missing\" during the crisis, Mr Morrison added that cabinet would meet on Monday to consider a long-term bushfire response. Meteorologists say a climate system in the Indian Ocean, known as the dipole, is the main driver behind the extreme heat in Australia. However many parts of Australia have been in drought conditions, some for years, which has made it easier for the fires to spread and grow.", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 6119, "answer_start": 4614, "text": "Two regions of Western Australia (WA) were also facing catastrophic fire danger on Thursday, and parts of South Australia were expected to see extreme conditions on Friday. The ABC reported that bushfires had forced the closure of a 330km stretch of a highway in WA, causing traffic jams. Emergency supplies including water and toilet paper were flown in to a remote guesthouse located about 1,000km (620 miles) east of Perth which has been cut off from the city by bushfires. About 120 people were on the Caiguna Roadhouse site, where temperatures were forecast to reach 48 degrees. In Tasmania a fire burning on the outskirts of the state capital Hobart was downgraded from emergency to watch and act status. On Thursday, Prime Minister Scott Morrison repeated his calls to people not to panic and to trust emergency workers. \"I understand the fear that is there for many and the frustration, but this is a natural disaster, and natural disasters are best dealt with through the methodical, well-co-ordinated response that we are seeing today,\" he told a press conference. Amid criticism that he had \"gone missing\" during the crisis, Mr Morrison added that cabinet would meet on Monday to consider a long-term bushfire response. Meteorologists say a climate system in the Indian Ocean, known as the dipole, is the main driver behind the extreme heat in Australia. However many parts of Australia have been in drought conditions, some for years, which has made it easier for the fires to spread and grow." } ], "id": "25_0", "question": "What is happening elsewhere?" } ] } ]
Weight loss surgery 'cuts risk' of diabetes and heart attacks
23 December 2015
[ { "context": "Weight-loss surgery can cut the risk of diabetes and heart attacks as well as keep fat off, a UK study suggests. It is the largest comprehensive investigation of bariatric surgery - spanning around four years in nearly 8,000 patients. The health benefits of the surgery are clear and substantial for people who are severely overweight, the authors told PLoS Medicine. They say 1.4m people in England could benefit. Currently, around 8,000 people a year receive the treatment on the NHS. If all 1.4m were offered bariatric surgery, the researchers estimate it would avert nearly 5,000 heart attacks and 40,000 cases of type 2 diabetes over four years. All surgery carries risks, however, and so people should only be offered surgery if attempts to lose weight through healthy eating and physical activity have already been tried and not worked, they add. Experts said surgery should not be seen as a 'quick fix'. Bariatric surgery, also known as weight loss surgery, is used as a last resort to treat people who are dangerously obese (having a body mass index of 40 or above or 35 plus other obesity-related health conditions). Guidelines for the NHS all patients with a BMI of 35 or over who have recent-onset type 2 diabetes should be assessed for surgery. Patients must have tried and failed to achieve clinically beneficial weight loss by all other appropriate non-surgical methods and be fit for surgery. The two most common types of weight loss surgery are: - Sleeve gastrectomy or gastric bypass, where some of the stomach is removed or the digestive system is re-routed past most of the stomach - Gastric band, where a band is used to reduce the size of the stomach so a smaller amount of food is required to make someone feel full NHS Choices Calculate your BMI For the study, the researchers compared 3,882 patients who underwent weight loss surgery with an identical number who did not. They looked at gastric bypass, sleeve gastrectomy and gastric banding. All led to a dramatic and sustained weight loss of between 20kg and 48kg. And the weight stayed off. This, in turn, significantly lowered the person's risk of developing type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, angina and heart attacks. Among those who already had diabetes, their condition improved substantially and many (60%) were able to come off medication altogether. Lead researcher Dr Ian Douglas, from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, said: \"The results are really encouraging. Obviously we would love to help people lose weight in other ways, through exercise and healthy diets, but that's difficult. Diets do not always work well for everyone. \"We are not saying surgery is right for everyone, but it can be really effective.\" Dr Alasdair Rankin of Diabetes UK warned bariatric surgery should not be seen as a one-stop solution for type 2 diabetes and obesity. \"It should be offered along with ongoing support and clear plans for long term follow up.\"", "qas": [ { "answers": [ { "answer_end": 2946, "answer_start": 912, "text": "Bariatric surgery, also known as weight loss surgery, is used as a last resort to treat people who are dangerously obese (having a body mass index of 40 or above or 35 plus other obesity-related health conditions). Guidelines for the NHS all patients with a BMI of 35 or over who have recent-onset type 2 diabetes should be assessed for surgery. Patients must have tried and failed to achieve clinically beneficial weight loss by all other appropriate non-surgical methods and be fit for surgery. The two most common types of weight loss surgery are: - Sleeve gastrectomy or gastric bypass, where some of the stomach is removed or the digestive system is re-routed past most of the stomach - Gastric band, where a band is used to reduce the size of the stomach so a smaller amount of food is required to make someone feel full NHS Choices Calculate your BMI For the study, the researchers compared 3,882 patients who underwent weight loss surgery with an identical number who did not. They looked at gastric bypass, sleeve gastrectomy and gastric banding. All led to a dramatic and sustained weight loss of between 20kg and 48kg. And the weight stayed off. This, in turn, significantly lowered the person's risk of developing type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, angina and heart attacks. Among those who already had diabetes, their condition improved substantially and many (60%) were able to come off medication altogether. Lead researcher Dr Ian Douglas, from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, said: \"The results are really encouraging. Obviously we would love to help people lose weight in other ways, through exercise and healthy diets, but that's difficult. Diets do not always work well for everyone. \"We are not saying surgery is right for everyone, but it can be really effective.\" Dr Alasdair Rankin of Diabetes UK warned bariatric surgery should not be seen as a one-stop solution for type 2 diabetes and obesity. \"It should be offered along with ongoing support and clear plans for long term follow up.\"" } ], "id": "26_0", "question": "What is bariatric surgery?" } ] } ]

Dataset Card for "NLQuAD"

Dataset Summary

This is a copy of the original NLQuAD dataset distributed via Github.

NLQuAD is a non-factoid long question answering dataset from BBC news articles. NLQuAD’s question types and the long length of its context documents as well as answers, make it a challenging real-world task. NLQuAD consists of news articles as context documents, interrogative sub-headings in the articles as questions, and body paragraphs corresponding to the sub-headings as contiguous answers to the questions. NLQuAD contains 31k non-factoid questions and long answers collected from 13k BBC news articles. See example articles in BBC 1, 2. We automatically extract target answers because annotating for non-factoid long QA is extremely challenging and costly.

Dataset Structure

Data Instances

An example of 'train' looks as follows.

{
    "title": "Khashoggi murder: Body 'dissolved in acid'",
    "date": "2 November 2018",
    "paragraphs":[
        {
            "context": "A top Turkish official, presidential adviser Yasin Aktay, has said ....",
            "qas":[
              {
                  "question":"What was said in the crown prince's alleged phone call?",
                  "id":"0_0",
                  "answers":[
                    {
                      "text":"During the call with President Donald Trump\'s son-in-law Jared Kushner and national ....",
                      "answer_start":1352,
                      "answer_end": 2108,
                    }
                  ]
              },
              {
                  "question":"What has the investigation found so far?",
                  "id":"0_1",
                  "answers":[
                    {
                      "text":"There is still no consensus on how Khashoggi died. He entered ....",
                      "answer_start":2109,
                      "answer_end": 3128,
                    }
                  ]
              },
            ]
        }
    ]
}

Data Fields

The data fields are the same among all splits.

  • title: a string feature.
  • date: a string feature.
  • paragraphs: a list feature containing dictionaries:
    • context: a string feature.
    • qas: a list feature containing dictionaries:
      • question: a string feature.
      • id: a string feature.
      • answers: a list feature containing dictionaries:
        • text: a string feature.
        • answer_start: a int32 feature.
        • answer_end: a int32 feature

Data Splits

name train test validation
10259 1280 1280

Additional Information

Licensing Information

This dataset is distributed under the CC BY-NC licence providing free access for non-commercial and academic usage.

Citation Information

BibTeX:

@inproceedings{soleimani-etal-2021-nlquad,
    title = "{NLQ}u{AD}: A Non-Factoid Long Question Answering Data Set",
    author = "Soleimani, Amir  and
      Monz, Christof  and
      Worring, Marcel",
    booktitle = "Proceedings of the 16th Conference of the European Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Main Volume",
    month = apr,
    year = "2021",
    address = "Online",
    publisher = "Association for Computational Linguistics",
    url = "https://aclanthology.org/2021.eacl-main.106",
    doi = "10.18653/v1/2021.eacl-main.106",
    pages = "1245--1255",
    abstract = "We introduce NLQuAD, the first data set with baseline methods for non-factoid long question answering, a task requiring document-level language understanding. In contrast to existing span detection question answering data sets, NLQuAD has non-factoid questions that are not answerable by a short span of text and demanding multiple-sentence descriptive answers and opinions. We show the limitation of the F1 score for evaluation of long answers and introduce Intersection over Union (IoU), which measures position-sensitive overlap between the predicted and the target answer spans. To establish baseline performances, we compare BERT, RoBERTa, and Longformer models. Experimental results and human evaluations show that Longformer outperforms the other architectures, but results are still far behind a human upper bound, leaving substantial room for improvements. NLQuAD{'}s samples exceed the input limitation of most pre-trained Transformer-based models, encouraging future research on long sequence language models.",
}
Downloads last month
50
Edit dataset card

Models trained or fine-tuned on LLukas22/NLQuAD