id
stringlengths
16
27
vector
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
$meta
stringlengths
239
38.7k
10.1101/19008342
[ -0.1553773432970047, 0.3241288363933563, 0.7677397131919861, 0.2773454189300537, -0.6364169716835022, 0.45623618364334106, 0.2510751485824585, 0.1822628527879715, -0.1992073953151703, 1.3817906379699707, -0.6503612399101257, -0.9380173683166504, 0.1788395345211029, -0.27541783452033997, -0.5902382135391235, -0.994682252407074, 0.1438392996788025, 0.21370382606983185, -0.992067277431488, 0.12215033173561096, 0.9164235591888428, 0.5339986085891724, -0.8339900374412537, 0.0891198143362999, -0.5656012296676636, 0.7471288442611694, -0.14368173480033875, -0.635863184928894, 1.841224193572998, 0.6935822367668152, 0.6718962788581848, -0.17201846837997437, 0.3890347480773926, -0.6181914210319519, -0.07547210901975632, 0.25622043013572693, 0.5456653833389282, -0.43615615367889404, -0.18738354742527008, 0.25697389245033264, 1.232055425643921, -0.7426116466522217, 1.0980080366134644, -0.5813794732093811, -0.4184465706348419, -0.3371494710445404, -0.8175012469291687, 0.5433640480041504, -0.4553845226764679, -0.3212956190109253, -0.29601532220840454, 0.013571706600487232, 0.7488294839859009, -0.6987881064414978, -0.6374743580818176, -0.37385594844818115, 0.18850436806678772, -0.4356371760368347, -0.34879082441329956, 0.7484012246131897, 0.1841539740562439, -0.19184571504592896, 0.1421593427658081, -0.13439425826072693, 0.2604835331439972, 0.8822969198226929, -0.3422052264213562, -0.5059594511985779, -0.05205448716878891, -0.2754121720790863, 0.07665113359689713, -0.5906215310096741, -0.2908385992050171, -0.6479726433753967, -0.021870823577046394, -0.7261552810668945, -0.37792375683784485, -0.12093831598758698, 0.054715465754270554, 0.3280770480632782, 0.7413254976272583, 0.4823165237903595, 0.7372804284095764, -0.358053058385849, -1.115601897239685, 0.6515324711799622, -0.3217480778694153, 0.4111253023147583, 0.20900750160217285, 0.43377846479415894, -0.47015511989593506, 1.198604702949524, 0.19542406499385834, -0.5568636059761047, 0.4241706430912018, 1.6143909692764282, -0.13142910599708557, 0.5632723569869995, 0.8654384613037109, -0.006902838591486216, 0.7846342325210571, -0.05037255585193634, -0.07733312249183655, 0.7541459202766418, -0.5920795202255249, 0.5995725989341736, 1.1505862474441528, 0.2845848798751831, -0.8520775437355042, -0.8821544051170349, 0.10871843993663788, -0.20794565975666046, -0.8175995349884033, 0.1697433739900589, 0.5041202306747437, -0.39258942008018494, -0.08884456753730774, 0.424706369638443, -0.9475489258766174, -0.2905263900756836, 0.7735976576805115, -0.7012767791748047, 0.08666028082370758, 0.03474995866417885, 0.3960018455982208, 0.4390726387500763, -0.10235414654016495, 0.6458607316017151, -0.5250989198684692, 0.0703568235039711, -0.10760166496038437, -0.44132664799690247, -0.027844740077853203, 0.49420443177223206, 0.3033228814601898, 0.3613412082195282, 1.157508134841919, 1.234398365020752, -0.8007350564002991, -0.18816176056861877, -0.09711961448192596, 1.029291033744812, -0.7167041897773743, 1.2502710819244385, -0.5443406105041504, 1.5426294803619385, -0.500962495803833, -0.2710893452167511, -0.48083558678627014, 0.28041917085647583, -0.2591818571090698, 0.1528940498828888, -0.4463086426258087, 0.06235029920935631, -0.1538163274526596, 0.4706907272338867, -0.06929953396320343, 0.6424774527549744, -1.1829376220703125, -0.027097465470433235, -0.32706621289253235, 0.009682701900601387, 0.2993415296077728, 0.14804202318191528, -0.7716374397277832, 1.306714415550232, -0.2782350182533264, 0.5014544725418091, 0.28340405225753784, -0.7324841618537903, 0.9785222411155701, 0.22327062487602234, -0.8357036113739014, 0.41400599479675293, 0.6244578957557678, 1.1578075885772705, 0.7053322792053223, -0.42830926179885864, 0.3629657030105591, 0.5561699271202087, 0.2902167737483978, 0.5064564943313599, 0.625019371509552, 0.28333401679992676, 0.4506020247936249, 1.0178494453430176, 0.2205030471086502, -0.5854223370552063, 0.39406031370162964, -0.6237464547157288, -0.22221006453037262, 0.9114630818367004, -1.5583245754241943, 0.6447071433067322, 0.02998475730419159, 0.043405354022979736, -0.6200364828109741, 0.7738004922866821, 0.6886603832244873, 0.2570919692516327, -0.2601552903652191, 0.8379477262496948, -0.5883855819702148, 0.47853830456733704, 0.007871745154261589, -0.40322405099868774, -0.2803836762905121, 0.49027717113494873, 0.011077030561864376, 0.561842679977417, 0.8455713391304016, -0.6886369585990906, -0.5185978412628174, -0.3935284912586212, 0.08786166459321976, -0.655171811580658, -0.31139418482780457, 1.0019031763076782, -1.0057547092437744, -0.5777366757392883, -0.0881480947136879, -0.8757970929145813, 0.6611754298210144, 0.3558470606803894, 0.2816552519798279, 1.0359495878219604, 0.3244993984699249, 0.7707471251487732, -0.8105091452598572, -0.429852694272995, 0.07692978531122208, 0.8507108092308044, -0.6607099175453186, 0.7579526305198669, 0.17351287603378296, -0.4410346448421478, 0.5485495328903198, 0.6368929147720337, -0.08487430959939957, 0.5715448260307312, 0.13009917736053467, 1.2987581491470337, 0.03554166480898857, 0.21091468632221222, -0.14706002175807953, 0.7087054252624512, -1.126462697982788, -0.13550221920013428, -0.24427831172943115, 1.0314204692840576, -0.40096932649612427, 0.732117235660553, 0.8776146769523621, 0.5780895948410034, -0.7026792764663696, -0.2597091495990753, -0.29416605830192566, -0.21385186910629272, -0.5303863883018494, 0.03511250391602516, -0.8830584287643433, 0.7736045718193054, -1.4666234254837036, 0.05065621808171272, 0.8461893200874329, -0.25441113114356995, -0.14536046981811523, 0.25892409682273865, 1.1797888278961182, -0.315886527299881, -0.9141490459442139, -0.2080821394920349, -0.6945685744285583, -1.3757373094558716, -0.3556549847126007, 0.07097720354795456, -0.19220612943172455, 0.3568201959133148, -0.3764757215976715, 0.9034510850906372, -0.48534244298934937, -0.19983665645122528, 0.48812294006347656, 0.6059431433677673, -0.0556936077773571, 0.2971462905406952, -0.6013102531433105, 0.5075163245201111, 0.1950075626373291, 0.4896928071975708, -0.1754080206155777, -0.43514004349708557, -0.5448168516159058, -0.5990362167358398, 0.6178143620491028, -0.03496808558702469, 0.2699527144432068, 0.5635921359062195, 0.3262278139591217, -0.280565083026886, -0.8236499428749084, -0.4100470244884491, -0.013705936260521412, -0.14402185380458832, -0.4189302623271942, 0.3374578058719635, -0.26317185163497925, 0.3504110276699066, 0.4726490080356598, 0.32590386271476746, -0.39363616704940796, 0.3829163610935211, -0.4607059061527252, 0.4596822261810303, -0.7922189831733704, -0.007870598696172237, 0.38164961338043213, -0.070799320936203, -0.3311226963996887, -0.47345808148384094, -0.6332627534866333, 0.2902832627296448, -0.13349680602550507, -0.26394280791282654, -0.6930789351463318, 1.3909497261047363, -0.1712697148323059, -1.5797158479690552, 0.5031593441963196, -0.4361158609390259, -0.15835872292518616, 0.6654292345046997, -0.13567715883255005, 0.311759889125824, -0.15655124187469482, -0.11115417629480362, -0.8942962884902954, -0.30114874243736267, -0.3050532042980194, 0.23900644481182098, 0.24345220625400543, 0.5107232928276062, -0.7472584843635559, 0.3686423599720001, -0.018717162311077118, 0.018570542335510254, -0.2736073136329651, -0.3402059078216553, -0.1669878512620926, -0.2899579703807831, -0.010430864058434963, 0.272892564535141, 0.15187308192253113, 0.6735188364982605, -0.15285831689834595, 0.7690671682357788, -0.2641713619232178, -0.17557786405086517, 0.47757038474082947, -0.13893292844295502, 0.7199211120605469, -0.6598580479621887, -0.39085617661476135, 0.5000061392784119, -0.6392320990562439, -0.6323654651641846, 0.9157724976539612, 0.2784275412559509, 1.5491787195205688, 0.7063498497009277, 0.6745550632476807, -0.5538539290428162, -0.886135995388031, 0.32712075114250183, -0.6354130506515503, 0.07053595036268234, 1.0012476444244385, -0.08361195027828217, 1.1802164316177368, -1.0244247913360596, 0.4795053005218506, 0.14520181715488434, 1.0264410972595215, 0.5608959197998047, -0.7915434241294861, 1.20426607131958, -1.5061748027801514, 0.11635683476924896, 0.0153456199914217, 0.2349061518907547, -0.25250956416130066, -0.5424056053161621, 0.4830937087535858, -0.6712135672569275, -0.25589147210121155, -0.7620328068733215, 0.05954800918698311, 0.5814622044563293, 0.02609584666788578, 0.4571567177772522, 0.5144640803337097, 0.0952381044626236, 0.344585120677948, 0.6697287559509277, 1.0551183223724365, 0.5612495541572571, -0.9591845870018005, -0.09919168055057526, -0.058184899389743805, -0.2524470090866089, -0.06578868627548218, -0.2821092903614044, -0.31234011054039, -0.41843271255493164, 0.005987938493490219, 0.08105196803808212, -0.1101699024438858, 0.17405202984809875, 0.34111151099205017, -0.2188093364238739, -0.4560891091823578, 0.015142189338803291, -0.7099090814590454, -0.46158909797668457, 0.19391568005084991, 0.054116882383823395, -0.23328909277915955, -0.5849885940551758, 0.1433842033147812, 0.7283298373222351, -0.11124195903539658, -0.22761879861354828, -1.1084336042404175, -0.9340370297431946, -0.5969043374061584, 0.2650719881057739, 0.8982748985290527, -0.5765121579170227, -0.08216419070959091, -0.39542728662490845, -0.19538356363773346, -0.11998870968818665, 0.017511025071144104, -0.2929418981075287, 0.2630903720855713, 0.4255737364292145, 0.5855969190597534, 0.9079020023345947, 0.6150780916213989, 0.34931623935699463, -0.3077658414840698, -0.5179560780525208, 0.4364648461341858, -0.26532718539237976, -0.7470812797546387, 0.43085822463035583, -0.481466680765152, -0.4509787857532501, 0.06610581278800964, 0.060962043702602386, -0.28698915243148804, 0.05304883047938347, 0.36137324571609497, -0.22156007587909698, -0.7168671488761902, 0.6638121604919434, -0.41657301783561707, 0.14117702841758728, 1.7926207780838013, -0.23371516168117523, -0.0157465822994709, -0.019061995670199394, 0.680671751499176, -0.2588500678539276, 0.8538488745689392, -0.80567467212677, -0.6919711232185364, 0.5274279117584229, -0.5236314535140991, -0.019416989758610725, -0.9785662889480591, 0.3108294904232025, -0.04960331320762634, 0.1516895294189453, -0.1680445522069931, 0.19186004996299744, -0.25114405155181885, 0.4830506145954132, -1.4568930864334106, 0.38561439514160156, -0.1113133653998375, -0.6477560997009277, -0.0526706799864769, -0.1153981015086174, -0.7133970856666565, -0.3494512140750885, 0.04416365548968315, 0.4405515789985657, -0.04331804811954498, 0.7096941471099854, 0.1664373278617859, 0.02646961808204651, -1.6317678689956665, 0.03614061325788498, 0.1505589336156845, -0.7401072978973389, -0.6482354998588562, -0.45255592465400696, 0.07505550980567932, -0.4622098207473755, -0.19700029492378235, 0.4723883271217346, 0.06787087768316269, -0.8938144445419312, -0.03088243491947651, -0.2944256365299225, 1.0621070861816406, -0.45311030745506287, -0.15317854285240173, 0.3310498297214508, -0.3816045820713043, -1.0376930236816406, -0.2014889419078827, 0.19606570899486542, -0.21791206300258636, 0.8346501588821411, 0.9396647214889526, -0.621918261051178, 0.4347812533378601, -1.013059139251709, 0.22933238744735718, -0.3235777020454407, 0.02731243334710598, -0.6875802278518677, -0.14517024159431458, -0.6287413835525513, 0.7739285230636597, -0.1889662891626358, 0.7173669934272766, -0.504814624786377, -0.5788996815681458, 0.15824003517627716, 0.3140984773635864, -0.8486021161079407, -0.15815317630767822, -0.6543775796890259, -0.5992060899734497, 0.4894292950630188, -0.1900056004524231, -0.48442718386650085, 0.3777777850627899, 0.5513299703598022, 0.4200046956539154, 0.16981732845306396, -0.1742371767759323, 0.3288825750350952, -0.20294010639190674, 0.7695766091346741, -0.7765641808509827, -0.17143476009368896, -1.704576849937439, 0.7305086255073547, -0.9110696911811829, -0.1331702321767807, 0.18990878760814667, 0.049789026379585266, 1.2433781623840332, -0.43917545676231384, 1.1532022953033447, -0.4003855884075165, -0.12439430505037308, 0.11153294891119003, -0.6910574436187744, 0.18874479830265045, 0.054518505930900574, -0.6509837508201599, -0.22948983311653137, -0.9743938446044922, -0.4193284809589386, 0.2541819214820862, -0.4566728174686432, -0.003918871749192476, 0.712829053401947, 0.35452038049697876, 0.005045304074883461, -0.889962911605835, 1.2646465301513672, 0.3620188236236572, -0.5892151594161987, -0.2532881200313568, 0.031980596482753754, 0.6157950758934021, -0.017133107408881187, -0.46807560324668884, -0.10438968986272812, -0.03548846021294594, 0.23379558324813843, -0.03268975391983986, 0.4767442047595978, -0.011201226152479649, 0.09730425477027893, 0.40775471925735474, 0.9857949018478394, -0.129632830619812, 0.5849265456199646, 0.13997487723827362, -1.3221449851989746, -0.07931528240442276, 0.852785587310791, 0.3874635100364685, 0.3120426535606384, 0.891560435295105, 0.10219557583332062, -1.022842526435852, 0.5806881189346313, 0.14740051329135895, -0.24016736447811127, -0.35376086831092834, 1.3381822109222412, 0.047142393887043, -1.2228749990463257, 0.8367639780044556, 0.3832837641239166, -0.7189950942993164, -0.472842812538147, -0.30484434962272644, -0.3087272346019745, -0.48480919003486633, 0.02762845903635025, 0.25369027256965637, 0.5436394810676575, -0.20613673329353333, 0.5330665111541748, -0.07776406407356262, -0.24316595494747162, 0.8881316184997559, -0.4815972149372101, -0.03731447085738182, -0.3723169267177582, 0.26174530386924744, 0.7113300561904907, -0.7188074588775635, 0.1690809279680252, 0.03392643481492996, -0.28525060415267944, 0.6776551008224487, 0.09295065701007843, 0.2586233615875244, -0.6373410224914551, -0.7740574479103088, -0.16845260560512543, -0.25202348828315735, -0.017723457887768745, 0.557869017124176, -0.10198474675416946, 0.228544682264328, -0.17284876108169556, -0.8059813380241394, 0.15124674141407013, -0.1939336657524109, 0.4254264831542969, 0.3573395311832428, -0.36555421352386475, 0.3833730220794678, 0.40196797251701355, 0.09143973141908646, -0.24247416853904724, -0.5453605055809021, -0.5929372310638428, -1.4379323720932007, -0.35850077867507935, -0.7664406895637512, -0.13181942701339722, 1.0205423831939697, 0.3433501720428467, -0.4135776162147522, -0.49014216661453247, -0.8979980945587158, -0.06248525530099869, 0.47354570031166077, -0.7974138855934143, -0.6713165640830994, -0.34162455797195435, -1.255186676979065, -0.3380485773086548, -0.7753219604492188, -0.8450433015823364, -0.16925373673439026, 0.4595685601234436, -0.8971749544143677, -0.044215988367795944, 0.06468377262353897, 0.1271142214536667, -0.26816508173942566, 0.7232351899147034, 0.028994884341955185, -0.32448244094848633, 0.35218876600265503, 0.711903989315033, -0.4761624038219452, 0.07566369324922562, 0.49223724007606506, -0.4143623113632202, 0.7768003940582275, 0.750980794429779, -0.5590123534202576, -0.37266358733177185, -0.6758787631988525, 0.43142661452293396, -0.7639561891555786, -0.11312291771173477, 0.09383849799633026, -0.01826709881424904, -1.3353641033172607, -0.10901569575071335, -0.16148275136947632, -1.0331671237945557, 0.21799515187740326, 0.39098861813545227, 0.03424936532974243, 0.2500355839729309, 0.15123248100280762, 0.5720419883728027, -0.4400147795677185, 0.5689696073532104, 0.09308051317930222, -0.2719477415084839, 1.1229338645935059, 0.2417721450328827, -0.02891320362687111, -0.8530517816543579, 0.3587868809700012, 0.8292716145515442, 0.13493745028972626, 0.39674893021583557, 0.10067020356655121, 0.7995073199272156, -0.01735692471265793, -0.39779186248779297, -0.05471314117312431, 0.0733843594789505, 0.7118223905563354, 0.3413373529911041, -0.3100595474243164, -0.18260835111141205, -0.3172975182533264, 0.18279646337032318, -1.014365553855896, -0.6311922669410706, 0.716697633266449, -0.6469500660896301, -0.5537156462669373, -0.40087243914604187, -0.681581437587738, -0.028199926018714905, -0.5351482033729553, 0.09578942507505417, 0.4659520983695984, 0.015943821519613266, 0.17968562245368958, 1.0206905603408813, -0.12314882129430771, 0.024836530908942223, -0.13489115238189697, 0.19169723987579346, -1.0399349927902222, -0.20627181231975555, 0.2179793119430542, 0.31155985593795776, 0.4802934527397156, -0.41692522168159485, -0.7496335506439209, 0.28456634283065796, 0.2369350641965866, -0.6963280439376831, -0.5624324083328247, -0.06096895411610603, -0.762836754322052, 0.5181370973587036, 0.256233274936676, -0.6188850402832031, -0.5396579504013062, 0.7624935507774353, 0.16769494116306305, -0.7138558030128479, -0.5296108722686768, 0.6826494932174683, 1.1921272277832031, -0.2466304451227188, 0.8523625731468201, 0.3763335347175598, 0.3502058684825897, -0.05389430746436119, 0.04332002252340317, 0.7666471004486084, 0.3252814710140228, 0.05878602713346481, 0.5060234069824219, 0.47566846013069153, 0.10135377943515778, 0.9823267459869385, -0.2873324751853943, -0.22412820160388947, 0.2075084149837494, 0.023201480507850647, 0.03732505068182945, 0.5288969874382019, -0.3487957715988159, 0.3288930654525757, -0.7299739122390747, 0.22543491423130035, -0.3570442199707031, 0.3875470459461212, 0.23252102732658386, 0.7186552286148071, -0.09276551008224487, -0.44403737783432007, -0.458796888589859, -0.2702685296535492, 0.32388657331466675, 0.9135121703147888, 0.3353637754917145, 0.6056201457977295, -0.4962890148162842, -0.46674224734306335, 1.2294957637786865, 0.027466733008623123, 0.22396337985992432, 0.6990448236465454, -0.6830419301986694, -0.2850916087627411, -1.1108790636062622, 1.0379042625427246, 0.5570709705352783, 0.29135066270828247, 0.5383666753768921, -0.47151365876197815, -0.015887456014752388, 0.5354726910591125, -0.3001061975955963, 0.5137984156608582, 1.319632649421692, 0.07344455271959305, -0.2358158975839615, 0.2082866132259369, -0.014693216420710087, -0.20865876972675323, -0.07467260211706161, 0.7271039485931396, 0.007499276660382748, 0.2537012994289398, -0.8216263055801392, 0.0041289073415100574, 0.5668833255767822, 0.6489664912223816, 0.45640048384666443, -0.3773120045661926, 0.875241219997406, 0.49330008029937744, 0.2701999843120575, -0.4942784309387207, 0.5523806810379028, -0.7014782428741455, 0.10732980817556381, -0.4827316999435425, 0.01838437095284462, 0.5104363560676575, 0.01813361793756485, -0.49813270568847656, 0.9033243060112, -0.032824527472257614, -0.12091755121946335, -0.4895137846469879, -0.2892235815525055, -0.19801951944828033, 0.08890807628631592, -0.3827972412109375, 1.1544965505599976, -0.4485025107860565, 0.3088749647140503, -0.5013706088066101, -0.5862939357757568, 0.028902549296617508, 0.19656740128993988, 0.034161705523729324, 0.49671292304992676, -0.12688951194286346, -0.0693369209766388, 0.5309793949127197, -1.345564603805542, -0.5566921234130859, 0.2212745100259781, -0.5396400690078735, -1.105252742767334, -0.0004965070402249694, 0.1910402774810791, 0.5781325101852417, -0.015407055616378784, 0.050635937601327896, -0.5751009583473206, -0.5677715539932251, 0.6343477368354797, 0.006261525209993124, 0.5318375825881958, -0.6627237200737, -0.5576508045196533, 0.35278958082199097, -0.09416335076093674, -0.055066417902708054, -0.20156745612621307, -0.8448570370674133, -0.31706830859184265, -0.058651287108659744, -0.2186533510684967, -0.581901490688324, 0.5498444437980652, 1.0174615383148193, 0.07956163585186005, -0.36401012539863586, -1.2831171751022339, -0.7288642525672913, -0.8390281200408936, 0.06544596701860428, -0.8361700177192688, -0.0883418619632721, 0.10343632102012634, -0.028374675661325455, 0.9384006857872009, -0.6300246119499207, 3.6098861694335938, 0.8691692352294922, 0.8420013785362244, -0.53542160987854, 0.3367684483528137, 0.26077550649642944, 0.5280953645706177, -0.42643940448760986, -0.21984973549842834, -0.05077784135937691, 0.4140441417694092, 0.6729295253753662, 0.6071155071258545, 0.29257261753082275, 0.33639779686927795, -0.40250054001808167, -0.9525455236434937, 0.23931792378425598, -0.01765945740044117, -0.4585128724575043, -0.38925623893737793, -0.5101925730705261, -0.8483127355575562, -0.2519912123680115, -0.17280516028404236, -0.08317575603723526, 0.9282265305519104, -0.4334583878517151, -0.20061330497264862, -0.9792097210884094, 0.7375409603118896, -0.38442400097846985, 0.5277847647666931, -1.0488088130950928, -0.7160974740982056, -0.1131611242890358, 0.141526460647583, -0.45880576968193054, 0.506224513053894, 0.2537422776222229, -0.07871824502944946, 0.24083085358142853, -0.40038803219795227, 0.026465076953172684, -0.6730492115020752, 0.40156373381614685, -0.4332035183906555, -0.32070159912109375, 0.5235593318939209, -0.22767513990402222, 0.8260347843170166, -0.9462091326713562, 0.16813264787197113, -1.0098323822021484, -1.7919162511825562, -0.5516982674598694, -0.5053881406784058, -1.062671422958374, 0.2186669558286667, 0.16670677065849304, 0.20214742422103882, -0.09335147589445114, -0.07821156084537506, -0.03274832293391228, -0.037184882909059525, -0.8537288308143616, 0.37198737263679504, 0.13521645963191986, 0.23835442960262299, -0.5192108750343323, 0.23554855585098267, -0.577141284942627, 0.36122238636016846, -0.6020797491073608, 1.0843455791473389, -0.2678256034851074, -0.5701535940170288, 0.9459075331687927, 0.5718085765838623, -0.49541687965393066, 0.3565494418144226, 0.2504267394542694, -0.1950448453426361, -0.7896574139595032, 0.7504863739013672, 0.547807514667511, -0.0919438824057579, -0.149420827627182, -0.6808139681816101, 0.15082475543022156, 0.3914007842540741, -0.15107515454292297, 0.2260432243347168, 0.21739646792411804, -0.47939226031303406 ]
{"Title": "Genetic determinants of trehalose utilization are not associated with severe Clostridium difficile infection", "Authors": "Saund Katie, Rao Krishna, Young Vincent B., Snitkin Evan S.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT In a case-control study of patients with C. difficile infection we found no statistically significant association between the presence of trehalose utilization variants in infecting C. difficile strains and development of severe infection. These results do not support trehalose utilization conferring enhanced virulence in the context of human C. difficile infections.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008342"}
10.1101/2019.12.10.19014423
[ -0.13599561154842377, 0.2074715793132782, -1.149092674255371, 0.7268822193145752, -0.5950620174407959, -0.700585663318634, 0.06457103043794632, 0.05866329371929169, -0.026961583644151688, 0.3723013401031494, -0.631236732006073, -0.541475772857666, 0.1450090855360031, -0.7745863199234009, -0.016573041677474976, -0.31517621874809265, -1.0692706108093262, -0.7282690405845642, -0.6086449027061462, -0.4734001159667969, 0.8448543548583984, 0.3110242486000061, -0.7046036124229431, -0.38466960191726685, -1.1279242038726807, 0.10052545368671417, -0.24463923275470734, -0.2688226103782654, 1.4953954219818115, 0.9964596629142761, 0.19353146851062775, -0.6607187986373901, 0.8911593556404114, -1.379487156867981, 0.3806617259979248, -0.6577075719833374, 1.1649038791656494, -0.4830887019634247, -0.03315990790724754, -0.6326054334640503, 0.1754748523235321, 0.30962619185447693, 0.5622164607048035, -0.3803075850009918, -0.43487170338630676, -0.6503867506980896, -0.7268748879432678, -0.4520900547504425, 0.42790600657463074, -0.39386996626853943, -0.4550490975379944, -0.29212212562561035, 0.2830457389354706, 0.12178545445203781, 0.004039021208882332, -0.06505416333675385, 0.033538490533828735, -0.12745486199855804, -0.756140410900116, -0.09778150171041489, 0.8117231726646423, -0.01856577955186367, 0.6215723752975464, -1.1560639142990112, 0.0472196564078331, 0.8987643122673035, -0.13474880158901215, -0.2771255671977997, -0.7498526573181152, -0.5026950240135193, -0.18792298436164856, 0.48630666732788086, -0.1726691871881485, -0.4755558967590332, 0.13247153162956238, 0.3732086718082428, -0.10944180935621262, -0.38967058062553406, -0.20702655613422394, -0.5744642615318298, -0.42678338289260864, -0.5667722821235657, -0.2711401581764221, 0.24721983075141907, 0.7076348662376404, 0.08350520581007004, -0.03526400029659271, -0.8151583075523376, 0.5581691861152649, -0.6090714931488037, 0.37977534532546997, 0.66774582862854, 0.029175473377108574, 0.48624804615974426, 0.24092744290828705, 0.4014036953449249, -0.8415765762329102, -0.5252563953399658, 1.1011154651641846, 0.11747191846370697, -0.2493235170841217, 1.427714228630066, 0.21298646926879883, 1.2845739126205444, 0.048598408699035645, 0.29435405135154724, -0.2792290151119232, 0.5796334743499756, -0.446290522813797, -1.3618719577789307, -0.5849183201789856, 0.9175534248352051, 0.06456376612186432, 0.04242446646094322, -0.3741909861564636, 0.23661738634109497, -0.6774007081985474, 0.22448314726352692, -0.1845121532678604, 0.17667189240455627, -0.3234482407569885, -0.003170437179505825, 0.62587970495224, -0.4403190314769745, 0.28664666414260864, -0.02115965634584427, 0.6313061714172363, 0.30365344882011414, -0.5146545767784119, -1.4325909614562988, -0.45577460527420044, -0.13436108827590942, -0.5393321514129639, 0.7272478342056274, -0.0108716432005167, 0.5591034889221191, 0.19101034104824066, 0.4150511920452118, -0.13331961631774902, -0.6351887583732605, -1.1420921087265015, -0.43509501218795776, -0.3083861768245697, 0.9454272389411926, -0.05365515872836113, 0.26013731956481934, 0.10486173629760742, -0.7840710878372192, 0.20493990182876587, -0.34671932458877563, 0.6426870822906494, -0.41279613971710205, -0.7565404772758484, 0.3760530650615692, 0.1261547952890396, -0.7436379194259644, -0.6892982125282288, 1.2217106819152832, -0.8158226013183594, 0.7888150215148926, 0.29497450590133667, 0.8431824445724487, -0.26113155484199524, 0.6997753381729126, -0.2718910276889801, 0.0595926009118557, 0.2697453200817108, -0.40024423599243164, 0.3763393759727478, -0.24859745800495148, 0.11918621510267258, 0.3249327540397644, -0.6321326494216919, -0.3152669072151184, -0.38417482376098633, 1.027374267578125, 1.3893030881881714, 0.8572596311569214, -0.31711363792419434, -0.1957356035709381, 0.036464087665081024, -0.46682479977607727, 0.7532821893692017, 0.8092682957649231, -0.30304214358329773, 0.39065563678741455, -0.3868010342121124, -0.5233119130134583, 0.7192828059196472, 0.10714035481214523, 0.17659316956996918, 1.0830146074295044, -1.360959529876709, -0.1717459261417389, -0.8974756002426147, 0.23060134053230286, -0.1360466629266739, 0.22005091607570648, -0.010415229015052319, -1.1044368743896484, 0.06602837145328522, 1.2688183784484863, -0.6763406991958618, 0.8378652334213257, -0.5118575692176819, -0.04623657837510109, 0.7961742877960205, -0.24725376069545746, -0.15456795692443848, -0.1808048039674759, 0.3009796142578125, 0.3558973968029022, -0.19134871661663055, 0.8385477066040039, 0.795849084854126, -0.5805040001869202, -0.22844873368740082, 0.19284604489803314, 0.15036414563655853, 0.3293616771697998, 0.02539661154150963, 0.23961174488067627, 0.5643046498298645, 0.3112269937992096, 0.15199251472949982, 0.6869256496429443, 0.5723427534103394, 0.26221907138824463, 0.04489310085773468, -0.007509084418416023, -0.6205934882164001, 0.5839089751243591, 0.1748526245355606, 0.00964062474668026, 1.2242192029953003, 0.17068345844745636, 0.49659982323646545, 0.10729317367076874, 0.640403687953949, -1.1313813924789429, -0.13649378716945648, 0.34613046050071716, 1.1378824710845947, 0.3307981789112091, 0.2591933608055115, -0.05707908794283867, 0.2324802130460739, 0.1436363309621811, -0.8039101958274841, -0.16009411215782166, -1.2296851873397827, 0.8220041394233704, 0.30428436398506165, 0.23092031478881836, -0.3045462369918823, -0.20107392966747284, 0.4849822223186493, 1.4672433137893677, 0.10357624292373657, -0.8689694404602051, -0.28591158986091614, -0.09798106551170349, -0.07259169220924377, 0.9182882905006409, 0.4868602752685547, 0.5535793304443359, -0.013668950647115707, -0.11287330836057663, -0.28469133377075195, -0.9178133010864258, -1.4984556436538696, -0.5453136563301086, -0.39582139253616333, -0.3388187885284424, -0.7659739851951599, 0.07470760494470596, -0.14711858332157135, -0.7695861458778381, 1.0823447704315186, 0.4395151436328888, 0.3700655698776245, -0.2304571121931076, 0.4077417850494385, 0.805300772190094, 0.13009682297706604, -0.04826514422893524, -1.4545167684555054, 0.46501678228378296, -0.3975912630558014, 0.9685981273651123, -0.19441580772399902, -0.37252292037010193, -0.6459096670150757, -0.9316614866256714, 0.9433225393295288, 0.18941539525985718, -0.5930252075195312, 0.244419127702713, -0.7259204387664795, 0.3341960310935974, -0.08004509657621384, 0.19763408601284027, 0.6135678887367249, 0.4853740334510803, -0.16903375089168549, 0.9480093717575073, 0.6687424182891846, -0.5801510810852051, 0.8784748315811157, 0.11910326033830643, -0.6866033673286438, 1.2306996583938599, -0.318023145198822, 0.10336191952228546, -0.5254746675491333, 0.07200518995523453, 0.8329550623893738, -0.195193350315094, 0.08142545819282532, -0.218666672706604, -0.46143731474876404, -0.2328680157661438, 0.027621783316135406, -0.8349689245223999, -0.3279684782028198, 0.7608123421669006, 0.0756809264421463, -0.7640618085861206, 0.4267650842666626, -1.1958694458007812, -0.8895975947380066, -0.17101626098155975, -0.5327568650245667, 0.7449619770050049, -0.0017045763088390231, 0.2543819844722748, -0.46634960174560547, 0.2140328735113144, 0.3077312707901001, 0.19015824794769287, 0.13171035051345825, -0.45059728622436523, -0.6933900713920593, 0.74730384349823, -0.44205719232559204, 0.6598765254020691, 0.6195371747016907, -0.3491242527961731, -0.4340153932571411, -0.17373940348625183, -0.6271780729293823, -0.3180575966835022, 0.48103731870651245, 0.23616300523281097, 0.7553492188453674, -0.03562800958752632, -0.8064741492271423, -0.22721557319164276, -0.08092815428972244, 0.1585284322500229, -0.2885001301765442, -0.9889131784439087, 0.5720709562301636, 0.7969863414764404, -1.1313151121139526, -0.3028694987297058, 0.6876039505004883, 0.8785606622695923, 0.806208610534668, -1.0741289854049683, 0.41431981325149536, -0.3844810724258423, -0.6422482132911682, -0.4777901768684387, -0.7045333981513977, -0.6145886778831482, 0.7104150652885437, -0.03933347761631012, 1.0616576671600342, -1.5008574724197388, 0.30932608246803284, 0.5419026613235474, 0.8019006848335266, 0.3949435353279114, 0.15440119802951813, -0.4720403552055359, -0.37100309133529663, 0.27850908041000366, 0.46750959753990173, -0.623793363571167, -0.07599686086177826, -0.2691188156604767, -0.002008496318012476, -0.006857840344309807, -0.9969059228897095, 0.09620282799005508, -0.028947075828909874, -0.0871383398771286, 0.4705316126346588, -0.7783865332603455, 1.343709111213684, -0.15456974506378174, 1.1728715896606445, 0.6907591223716736, -0.5520590543746948, -0.08366203308105469, -0.287570983171463, 0.18841394782066345, 0.3992658257484436, 0.009139848873019218, -0.2075648307800293, 0.3651888072490692, -0.882838785648346, 0.060717713087797165, 0.12883783876895905, -0.03613588213920593, 0.5038734674453735, 0.5384843349456787, 0.46166592836380005, -0.02952042780816555, -0.747281014919281, 0.7777730822563171, -0.48357394337654114, 0.3327282667160034, -0.014348605647683144, -0.5373631715774536, 0.1557290405035019, -1.3457403182983398, 0.9548740983009338, 1.0327777862548828, 0.3443536162376404, -0.913867175579071, 0.5391642451286316, 0.3829505741596222, 0.03004581481218338, -0.2233186662197113, 0.3931315541267395, -0.22510336339473724, -0.32026344537734985, 0.4585152268409729, -0.25459763407707214, -0.5442700386047363, -0.476156622171402, -0.10177256166934967, -0.20692594349384308, 0.18383441865444183, 0.09247554838657379, -0.46101418137550354, -0.0549357645213604, 0.2424512505531311, 0.49288830161094666, -1.0711103677749634, 0.5870022773742676, -0.2860093414783478, -0.95976322889328, 0.4494290351867676, 0.12618082761764526, -0.1800544708967209, 0.015708548948168755, -0.6036468148231506, -0.5480897426605225, 0.04818279296159744, 0.943342924118042, -0.11297158896923065, -0.8437862992286682, 0.8927080631256104, -0.020671172067523003, 0.4212837219238281, 0.6920040249824524, -0.3803492784500122, -0.28762421011924744, 0.36165162920951843, -0.8585683107376099, -0.0166106466203928, 0.14191937446594238, -0.7286491394042969, 0.1915329247713089, 0.08014650642871857, -0.6529299020767212, -0.27128493785858154, -0.5166912078857422, 0.35367774963378906, 0.18078602850437164, 0.2951223850250244, 0.12791770696640015, 0.23252072930335999, 0.45461684465408325, 0.015958912670612335, -0.2041667252779007, 0.6651849150657654, 0.18954336643218994, -0.12541747093200684, 0.5786228179931641, 0.12757523357868195, -0.3454299867153168, -0.3831213414669037, -0.8818263411521912, -0.09004661440849304, 0.5326728224754333, 0.4853401780128479, -0.14316055178642273, -0.15329840779304504, -0.2051752358675003, 0.7881864905357361, 0.5483808517456055, -0.7153080701828003, -0.10223187506198883, -0.018550554290413857, -0.6616324186325073, 0.11003338545560837, -0.37153276801109314, 0.018043434247374535, -0.2450595200061798, 0.21455974876880646, -0.00707571767270565, -0.3907686471939087, -0.06415026634931564, 0.37000688910484314, -0.7090284824371338, 1.18705415725708, -0.10104816406965256, -0.7462261319160461, -0.1547074019908905, 0.5696359872817993, -0.1848548799753189, 0.19309812784194946, -0.5278120636940002, -0.8657851219177246, -0.0386984646320343, -0.8750990033149719, 0.8978559970855713, -0.9521529674530029, -0.08917585760354996, -0.8750439882278442, -0.3664805591106415, -0.68291175365448, 0.298475444316864, 0.4047989845275879, -0.38822436332702637, -0.19759441912174225, -0.4489927887916565, -0.33503592014312744, -0.5371336936950684, -0.02833716943860054, -0.10340876877307892, -0.6576781272888184, -0.2764646112918854, 1.0366361141204834, 0.3423541784286499, -0.301378458738327, 0.33207422494888306, 0.2184770256280899, 0.15938949584960938, 0.6857553720474243, -0.2151205837726593, -0.3897992670536041, 0.09312509745359421, 1.2073088884353638, 0.10597478598356247, 0.18983151018619537, -0.4267224073410034, 0.25624045729637146, -0.976668655872345, 0.4361569881439209, -0.2134794443845749, 0.13369549810886383, 0.09690788388252258, -0.6624235510826111, 0.6375535130500793, -0.052692074328660965, 0.4499642848968506, 0.7463415265083313, 0.44883981347084045, 0.45768997073173523, -0.12569667398929596, -1.3975703716278076, -1.0994882583618164, -0.3022615909576416, -0.988394021987915, 0.3155616223812103, -0.3418182134628296, 0.38307732343673706, 0.12111739069223404, 0.4987829625606537, -0.5845851302146912, -0.9344513416290283, 0.6158798933029175, -0.17869389057159424, 0.43775132298469543, -1.0470365285873413, -0.303191214799881, -0.13871309161186218, -0.0009651876171119511, 0.6766415238380432, -0.1219368427991867, -0.4577345550060272, -0.22934986650943756, -0.7108058929443359, -0.5665225982666016, -1.6436684131622314, -0.6309738159179688, 0.25058606266975403, 0.34521621465682983, -0.6368215084075928, 0.37088313698768616, -0.12297429889440536, 0.4854029715061188, -0.5697388648986816, 1.0381178855895996, -0.4717392027378082, -0.4622155427932739, 1.4192243814468384, 0.179844468832016, -0.8508283495903015, -0.700562059879303, 0.17211176455020905, -0.5276241898536682, 0.286637544631958, -0.13570937514305115, 0.6145471334457397, -0.31494173407554626, 0.20139877498149872, 0.30746203660964966, -0.4483461081981659, -0.6205601096153259, -0.10072765499353409, -0.5049539804458618, -0.39177122712135315, -0.7403032779693604, -0.25575679540634155, -0.21046915650367737, 0.24687111377716064, 0.17406533658504486, 0.63932865858078, 0.23082207143306732, 0.10406742244958878, -0.34190142154693604, -0.07097496837377548, -1.1249240636825562, -0.30827850103378296, 0.7210261821746826, -0.1850694715976715, -0.09388650953769684, -0.647469699382782, -0.33673185110092163, 0.1302756816148758, -0.19967323541641235, -0.24314972758293152, -0.8077489137649536, 1.2036056518554688, 0.6872616410255432, 0.6003450155258179, 0.39809080958366394, 0.44213995337486267, -0.4490477442741394, 0.8742260932922363, 0.07604029029607773, -0.7334537506103516, -0.22303423285484314, 0.09676778316497803, 0.4278339147567749, 0.07263986766338348, -1.3431785106658936, -0.9337335824966431, 0.4424826502799988, 0.8097301125526428, 0.036321528255939484, 0.13172337412834167, -0.9957156777381897, -1.000436782836914, -0.8169783353805542, 0.18125464022159576, -0.40743544697761536, -0.8174313902854919, -0.004252722021192312, -0.8184196352958679, -0.23141297698020935, -0.29318565130233765, -0.145187646150589, -0.4927281141281128, 0.32137101888656616, -0.4530988335609436, -0.2270248681306839, -1.1879512071609497, 0.4151785373687744, 0.09026818722486496, -0.9917637705802917, -0.0406845360994339, -0.4168601930141449, 0.19446371495723724, 0.16239655017852783, -0.13939237594604492, 0.2593235671520233, -0.8334555625915527, 0.7323815822601318, -0.613396942615509, 0.08746890723705292, -0.06306595355272293, 1.073317289352417, 0.4077491760253906, 0.2352946698665619, 0.10351884365081787, 0.34128618240356445, 1.3457777500152588, 0.2802715599536896, 0.1455424278974533, 0.23506538569927216, -0.7088375091552734, 0.09561236202716827, 0.171150803565979, 0.15904437005519867, 0.22256574034690857, 0.816635012626648, -0.3673209249973297, 0.4928312301635742, -0.06496305018663406, 0.5441545844078064, 0.2369445115327835, -0.4931684732437134, -0.11906362324953079, 0.4020206332206726, -0.21033181250095367, -0.06370825320482254, -0.08767342567443848, 0.22267581522464752, -0.27385959029197693, 0.0821923315525055, 0.18083171546459198, -0.16527630388736725, -0.1673092097043991, -0.5374363660812378, 0.5047226548194885, 0.3516063690185547, -0.42337867617607117, 0.22350886464118958, -1.1803399324417114, 0.6292820572853088, 0.020147176459431648, -0.3019115626811981, 1.0686336755752563, 0.5455926656723022, 0.14994245767593384, 0.004218809772282839, 0.11239167302846909, -0.33132365345954895, -0.3722197711467743, 0.1882118284702301, -0.6798150539398193, -0.1072382852435112, 0.30765053629875183, -0.08887261897325516, 0.26767995953559875, -0.283470094203949, -0.37772661447525024, 0.7233813405036926, 0.14189748466014862, 0.4607752859592438, 0.34943750500679016, 0.7497633099555969, 0.44372138381004333, 0.9584086537361145, -0.23290976881980896, 0.34204748272895813, -0.3525308668613434, 0.4080531895160675, -0.06828102469444275, -0.9809008836746216, -0.40450772643089294, 0.14646020531654358, 0.26659414172172546, -0.2354527711868286, -0.32000547647476196, 0.5092736482620239, 0.22248563170433044, -0.3386198580265045, -0.12468218058347702, -0.6175159215927124, -0.33714109659194946, 0.06800846755504608, -0.5828180909156799, 0.10042628645896912, -0.15433987975120544, 0.24295608699321747, 0.6487606167793274, -0.07210619002580643, -1.2348144054412842, 0.3904143273830414, 0.24284780025482178, -0.4610317349433899, 0.45606353878974915, 0.05809492990374565, 0.90653395652771, 0.23240862786769867, 0.007604360580444336, 0.3295733630657196, 0.47647741436958313, 1.0340274572372437, 0.3024592995643616, -0.4106663465499878, 0.7065410017967224, 0.7123826742172241, 0.4167579114437103, 0.8701913356781006, 0.33160316944122314, -0.3286043405532837, -0.5742522478103638, 0.3372078835964203, -0.11960266530513763, 0.7804675698280334, 0.12290798872709274, 0.512103259563446, 0.4915851950645447, 0.1456468552350998, -0.10540862381458282, -0.5996026992797852, -0.06191582605242729, 0.4041520059108734, -0.4560377299785614, -0.7728787660598755, -0.21300075948238373, 0.8156779408454895, 0.06775954365730286, -0.13504312932491302, -0.35770246386528015, -0.08904659748077393, -0.05800623074173927, 0.966517448425293, 0.16688209772109985, -0.22836408019065857, 0.2758450508117676, -0.07980889081954956, 0.30284854769706726, 1.0043818950653076, 0.4390661120414734, 0.7394269108772278, -0.11468242108821869, -0.5048375725746155, -0.8815169334411621, 0.5688981413841248, -0.5013324618339539, -0.5593961477279663, 0.38850319385528564, -0.17997460067272186, 0.3244101405143738, -0.41589465737342834, -0.2142922580242157, -1.3344664573669434, -0.08394752442836761, 0.06472643464803696, -0.5380335450172424, -0.5366078019142151, 0.43288326263427734, -0.48276287317276, 1.0267407894134521, 1.1251503229141235, 0.4830425977706909, -0.6894950866699219, 1.3889191150665283, 0.8196870684623718, 0.028072737157344818, -0.07826283574104309, 0.2587917447090149, -0.5745101571083069, 0.5746239423751831, -0.03988763689994812, 0.5289543867111206, 0.3238990604877472, 0.48908695578575134, -0.28593477606773376, 0.38561418652534485, 0.09628811478614807, -0.15161745250225067, -0.6178421974182129, 0.3048994243144989, 0.2574457824230194, 0.4262850284576416, 0.386616587638855, 0.23579546809196472, -0.22782832384109497, 0.17772595584392548, -0.4715573489665985, -0.39957183599472046, -0.5693859457969666, -0.31019213795661926, -0.2861768901348114, 0.403705358505249, -0.24973534047603607, 0.009675320237874985, -1.0869052410125732, -0.7246044874191284, -0.09870005398988724, -0.17877666652202606, -0.35600000619888306, -0.16701601445674896, 0.40688884258270264, 0.8189767003059387, 0.2346673160791397, -0.15781641006469727, -0.19992594420909882, 0.1995583325624466, -0.3445385694503784, 0.9893332719802856, -0.2857048511505127, 1.2200133800506592, 0.024800878018140793, 0.30419138073921204, 0.006374054588377476, 0.3736739158630371, 0.5213741064071655, -0.7285944223403931, -0.12003912031650543, -0.1984889805316925, -0.41577643156051636, -0.14031235873699188, -0.6893746256828308, 0.12316400557756424, 0.7854241132736206, -0.6240275502204895, -0.09490501880645752, -0.6413472294807434, 0.00673709437251091, -0.23421825468540192, 0.38655778765678406, 0.10814791172742844, 0.6429750323295593, 0.5082123279571533, -0.17705138027668, -0.49298226833343506, -0.563301682472229, 3.766871929168701, 1.179304599761963, 0.5509020090103149, -0.03381942957639694, -0.00409082043915987, 0.4471897780895233, 0.8191726207733154, -0.018672382459044456, -0.5762090086936951, -0.03835912048816681, 0.017841331660747528, 0.696614146232605, 0.32395708560943604, -0.008124081417918205, 0.37956276535987854, 0.8883886337280273, -0.14410758018493652, -0.12954756617546082, 0.17535299062728882, -0.6495321989059448, -0.5439789891242981, 0.2952827215194702, 0.01165501493960619, -0.27495142817497253, -0.13929280638694763, -0.2441742718219757, -0.3073016405105591, 0.016830790787935257, -1.1553058624267578, -0.6529654264450073, 0.1914213001728058, -1.0810638666152954, 0.7482196092605591, -0.43363457918167114, -0.6439306735992432, 0.4112094044685364, 0.6944361925125122, -0.13181598484516144, 0.4505818486213684, -0.0004470928688533604, -0.28066152334213257, -0.25430193543434143, -0.23260575532913208, 0.16441881656646729, -0.8470343351364136, 0.9509842395782471, 0.17985215783119202, 0.9523141384124756, 0.8075925707817078, -0.6910384297370911, 1.090063214302063, -0.4510616362094879, -0.3998716473579407, 0.23543216288089752, -1.0788984298706055, -0.25416460633277893, -0.2831290066242218, -1.4203301668167114, -0.20550435781478882, -0.08515625447034836, 1.4911730289459229, 0.41524168848991394, -0.5065902471542358, 0.08107047528028488, 0.1953236311674118, 0.5315250158309937, 0.10267721116542816, 0.48306769132614136, -0.1537233144044876, 0.33326277136802673, -0.5694558024406433, -0.03463936224579811, -0.37029215693473816, 0.24407532811164856, 0.8500387668609619, 0.5743406414985657, 0.019255103543400764, 0.07048836350440979, -0.5664370059967041, -0.3788108825683594, -0.24049751460552216, 0.6281557083129883, 0.6605036854743958, 0.7517107129096985, 0.16444425284862518, 0.7054976224899292, -0.2688790559768677, -0.25595590472221375, -1.5109190940856934, 0.79109126329422, 1.2777384519577026, 0.10367516428232193, -0.3240801990032196, -0.15941089391708374, -0.13441291451454163 ]
{"Title": "Optically Pumped Magnetoencephalography in Epilepsy", "Authors": "Vivekananda Umesh, Mellor Stephanie, Tierney Tim M, Holmes Niall, Boto Elena, Leggett James, Roberts Gillian, Hill Ryan, Litvak Vladimir, Brookes Matthew J., Bowtell Richard, Barnes Gareth R, Walker Matthew C", "Abstract": "Abstract Our aim was to demonstrate the first use of Optically Pumped Magnetoencephalography (OP-MEG) in an epilepsy patient with unrestricted head movement. Current clinical MEG uses a traditional SQUID system for recording MEG signal, where sensors are cryogenically cooled and housed in a helmet in which the patient\u2019s head is fixed. Here we use a different type of sensor (OPM), which operates at room temperature and can be placed directly on the patient\u2019s scalp, permitting free head movement. We performed two 30 minute OP-MEG recording sessions in a patient with refractory focal epilepsy and compared these with clinical scalp EEG performed earlier. OP-MEG was able to identify analogous interictal activity to scalp EEG, and source localise this activity to an appropriate brain region. This is the first application of OP-MEG in human epilepsy. Future directions include simultaneous EEG/OP-MEG recording and prolonged OP-MEG telemetry.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.10.19014423"}
10.1101/19003814
[ -0.25772809982299805, 0.10245409607887268, -0.6176844239234924, 0.07562697678804398, -0.30906808376312256, -0.4565452039241791, 0.25639981031417847, -0.11216679215431213, 0.4446282684803009, 0.5695505142211914, 0.11786144971847534, -0.5010644793510437, 0.2505839169025421, 0.05063609406352043, 0.131806418299675, -0.3832176625728607, -1.293204426765442, -0.2221868634223938, -0.09905867278575897, 0.45555081963539124, 0.5282769203186035, 0.8365868330001831, -0.8314594030380249, -0.18313492834568024, -0.17209798097610474, 0.5203306674957275, 0.43083837628364563, -0.08359375596046448, 1.2593703269958496, 0.6343222260475159, -0.10668948292732239, -0.5450107455253601, 0.18046744167804718, -0.918626070022583, -0.1934303641319275, 0.03910020738840103, 0.41899412870407104, -0.925390362739563, -0.5167535543441772, -0.12737815082073212, 0.2608589828014374, -0.3490632474422455, 0.6167271733283997, -0.055847134441137314, -1.220780372619629, -0.42879393696784973, -0.4934510588645935, -0.3317115306854248, 0.3093525469303131, -0.21406404674053192, -1.0167587995529175, -0.18534018099308014, 0.5608787536621094, -0.42519286274909973, -0.036146681755781174, 0.17565448582172394, -0.005135272163897753, 0.2991631031036377, -1.2081769704818726, 0.46457451581954956, 0.08560135215520859, -0.739861011505127, 0.6165271401405334, -1.0611841678619385, 0.9420400857925415, 1.2600620985031128, 0.3754907548427582, -0.3459419310092926, -0.1351030468940735, -0.3354535698890686, -0.3775078356266022, -0.2340172827243805, -0.6946716904640198, -0.7444377541542053, -0.4741140604019165, -0.9074078798294067, 0.6957988142967224, -0.252081036567688, 0.19622480869293213, -0.33773183822631836, 0.42413002252578735, 0.27223047614097595, -0.3227804899215698, -0.10840130597352982, -0.4254840016365051, -0.051464878022670746, 0.23006926476955414, 0.07256702333688736, 0.2826535105705261, 0.3529431223869324, -0.5547437071800232, 0.23642516136169434, 0.2782710790634155, 0.10944995284080505, -0.10024707019329071, 1.3711647987365723, -0.5339255928993225, 0.15276068449020386, 0.0959092453122139, -0.12034334242343903, 1.02176034450531, 1.1395630836486816, -0.3910793662071228, 1.4113587141036987, -0.6943407654762268, 0.39083045721054077, 0.2165556252002716, -0.6844615936279297, -0.07902847975492477, -0.905044674873352, 0.170690655708313, 0.027071235701441765, -0.8630643486976624, -0.07363452017307281, 0.2761790454387665, 1.0257925987243652, -0.6295682787895203, 1.0735231637954712, -0.5225257873535156, 1.2126202583312988, -0.6086893677711487, -0.02171662449836731, 0.6456312537193298, -0.23547479510307312, 0.6118292212486267, 0.011510097421705723, 0.5207010507583618, 0.51373291015625, -0.9376369714736938, -0.19416402280330658, 0.8107906579971313, -0.5548053979873657, -0.13470159471035004, 0.3277040123939514, -0.5952568054199219, -0.15340258181095123, 0.39695650339126587, 0.4396405518054962, 0.025705529376864433, 0.32754865288734436, -0.5112677216529846, 0.1369672566652298, -0.6653527021408081, 1.225624442100525, -0.06810864806175232, 1.1004760265350342, -0.6912115812301636, -0.8954038619995117, -0.5388773083686829, -0.6211985349655151, 0.5662647485733032, 0.37339532375335693, -0.04445614665746689, 0.02445714734494686, 0.34374263882637024, 0.5189909934997559, -0.15038087964057922, 0.12190727889537811, -0.2149191051721573, -0.2967681288719177, -0.2999099791049957, -0.25409287214279175, -0.18313398957252502, 0.6349337100982666, -0.4395914375782013, 0.5706806182861328, -0.06006526201963425, 0.012489867396652699, 0.5714149475097656, -0.1474193036556244, 0.5053006410598755, -0.2570117712020874, -0.2648507356643677, 0.004457490053027868, -0.050291649997234344, 1.5476315021514893, 0.5683316588401794, -0.5835981369018555, 0.5645967721939087, 0.3834555447101593, -0.4853886067867279, 0.0369248129427433, 0.02405194379389286, 0.7512813210487366, -0.334513396024704, 0.24027664959430695, -0.23054920136928558, -0.10915985703468323, -0.46626925468444824, -0.689057469367981, -0.09932690858840942, 0.8057568669319153, -0.5120570063591003, 0.792273759841919, -0.3180197775363922, -0.24405328929424286, -0.09255091100931168, 0.39327090978622437, 0.04953364282846451, -0.2548508644104004, -0.1748933047056198, 0.011325059458613396, 0.1120956689119339, 0.9152456521987915, -0.5124487280845642, 0.5795957446098328, 0.20369069278240204, 0.3404492437839508, -0.5740970969200134, 0.25806325674057007, 0.6946651935577393, 0.22499434649944305, 0.1756054311990738, 0.145097553730011, 0.8333386182785034, 0.43107834458351135, 0.3284703195095062, 0.4016411304473877, -0.35493409633636475, 0.5917183756828308, -0.03467407450079918, -0.2160269170999527, 0.10023007541894913, 0.042111024260520935, 0.46328845620155334, -0.4624585211277008, 0.6156659722328186, 0.30479198694229126, -0.25661149621009827, -0.37594231963157654, 0.31640759110450745, 0.5850086808204651, -0.07803422957658768, 0.94852215051651, 1.0332266092300415, 0.24166321754455566, 0.005480316001921892, 0.4654698967933655, 0.4904711842536926, -0.10165136307477951, 0.5107823610305786, 0.7545069456100464, 1.0900434255599976, 0.26612257957458496, -0.2415374517440796, 0.29839667677879333, -0.5129575729370117, -0.03276600316166878, -0.5373098850250244, 0.748558521270752, -0.5607789158821106, 0.9212414026260376, 1.150613784790039, 0.9579625129699707, -0.7272891402244568, -0.10550345480442047, 0.47375041246414185, 0.32456642389297485, 0.057830147445201874, -1.091872215270996, 0.09749680757522583, 0.6293213963508606, 0.3391234278678894, -0.5143227577209473, 0.9381545186042786, 0.7189997434616089, -0.29400748014450073, 0.1146695464849472, 0.3505170941352844, -0.2742193937301636, -0.5642077326774597, -0.5326433181762695, -1.0506768226623535, -0.8447218537330627, -1.000098466873169, 0.5738554000854492, 0.25006890296936035, -0.6178033947944641, 0.5099537372589111, -0.4031620919704437, -0.1290571540594101, 0.01296434085816145, 0.29133912920951843, 0.3847881555557251, 0.35077372193336487, 0.08991247415542603, -1.2608890533447266, -0.009008094668388367, 0.016013668850064278, 0.18063178658485413, 0.34490013122558594, -0.4018270671367645, 0.0835275650024414, -0.7925218343734741, 0.6057351231575012, -0.4644152522087097, -0.3683939576148987, 0.46940457820892334, -0.047266267240047455, 0.04067889600992203, -0.12314113229513168, 0.1830882728099823, -0.3710837662220001, -0.14816707372665405, -0.06720684468746185, 1.057973027229309, 0.5592667460441589, 0.28404614329338074, 0.8860910534858704, 0.6106886863708496, -0.12684780359268188, 0.3576708436012268, -0.012519067153334618, 0.2716524004936218, -0.6510313749313354, -0.217054545879364, 0.11297846585512161, -0.6721636652946472, 0.16124245524406433, -0.3696732819080353, -0.8840879201889038, -0.03420750051736832, -0.3471316695213318, -0.37600043416023254, 0.02549915760755539, 0.2132684737443924, 0.14526744186878204, -1.1243960857391357, 0.08417929708957672, -0.36937057971954346, -0.937168300151825, -0.3611087501049042, 0.043546367436647415, -0.05176825448870659, -0.05816016346216202, -0.3093789219856262, -0.5277531743049622, 0.09125237166881561, 0.3428332209587097, 0.5595312118530273, 0.7089929580688477, -0.226027250289917, 0.29301193356513977, 0.20915234088897705, 0.4028060734272003, 0.30781009793281555, -0.13042722642421722, -0.09544449299573898, 0.11655250191688538, 0.4948083460330963, -0.5420305132865906, 0.6171790957450867, 0.8254156708717346, 0.3469341993331909, -0.25507062673568726, 0.38794881105422974, 0.0462295226752758, 0.14677247405052185, 0.08021016418933868, 0.26387521624565125, 0.02564329281449318, 0.4036969542503357, -0.21763435006141663, 0.5146428346633911, -0.9193146824836731, -0.3223269283771515, 0.0855422243475914, 0.20371182262897491, 0.4940064549446106, -0.3775958716869354, 1.0220799446105957, 0.06063057854771614, -0.3771849572658539, 0.08486513793468475, 0.002022204454988241, -0.44127726554870605, 1.043538212776184, 0.9433377981185913, 0.9841228723526001, -1.0553206205368042, 0.6632614135742188, 1.0195775032043457, 1.400468349456787, 0.45053011178970337, 0.33307692408561707, 0.6654045581817627, -0.8473299145698547, 0.4586044251918793, 0.2190249264240265, -0.5797022581100464, -0.6532350182533264, 0.48455098271369934, 0.23652689158916473, 0.029117127880454063, 0.08709963411092758, -0.1949051022529602, -0.024327227845788002, 0.23932206630706787, 0.5433014035224915, -0.4434715509414673, 0.571599006652832, 0.13419584929943085, 0.19804909825325012, 0.20720212161540985, 0.9161529541015625, -0.44567543268203735, -1.0012648105621338, 0.12956687808036804, -0.8062756061553955, -0.37949472665786743, -0.531596302986145, -0.24364322423934937, -0.34493306279182434, -0.43963679671287537, 0.18450340628623962, -0.04427364096045494, -0.3828180134296417, -0.6451612710952759, -0.1806202530860901, 0.5117648839950562, 0.23713089525699615, 0.30251118540763855, -0.39510372281074524, 0.29134708642959595, -0.24958032369613647, -0.4287806749343872, 0.0650017037987709, -0.8801417946815491, 0.6651397347450256, 0.5646737813949585, -0.45588743686676025, -0.6259270310401917, -0.8067111372947693, -0.1715753972530365, -0.20882895588874817, -0.2530885636806488, -0.03482974320650101, -0.39045196771621704, 0.3733687698841095, -0.5511270761489868, -0.19928063452243805, -0.11954312026500702, 0.2951209247112274, -0.7596809267997742, 0.3210950791835785, 0.05287691950798035, 0.5653361082077026, 0.20831313729286194, 0.41445231437683105, 0.18754875659942627, -0.4508303701877594, -1.1565197706222534, -0.07945824414491653, -0.2754734456539154, -0.7437719106674194, -0.6573783755302429, 0.3197759985923767, -0.3909783661365509, -0.268401563167572, -0.18520168960094452, -0.9287275075912476, 0.11431906372308731, 0.15730105340480804, 0.23834876716136932, -0.7342640161514282, 0.8730019927024841, -0.6972399353981018, 0.170865997672081, 1.2621197700500488, -0.8431878685951233, -0.4143938720226288, -0.0679156556725502, 0.054548148065805435, -0.4909855127334595, 0.7734615802764893, 0.17980334162712097, 0.02153390645980835, -0.16150526702404022, -0.32945355772972107, 0.09218571335077286, -0.028538987040519714, 0.10734742134809494, -0.6753188967704773, -0.3707822263240814, -0.7427951097488403, -0.6008402109146118, -0.4506404995918274, 0.18225336074829102, -1.0035121440887451, 0.4056975245475769, 0.23652096092700958, -0.692406415939331, -0.28796353936195374, -0.19005563855171204, -0.04321292042732239, -0.9787083864212036, -0.37666431069374084, -0.6408576369285583, -0.01248873770236969, 0.10985220223665237, 0.8515365719795227, -0.38194045424461365, -0.6731587648391724, -0.43798601627349854, 0.3865339756011963, -1.3678468465805054, -0.616108238697052, -0.5713856220245361, -0.11818938702344894, -0.6605133414268494, 0.30876943469047546, 0.10839489847421646, -0.9158183932304382, 0.3934265077114105, -0.222235307097435, 0.16812744736671448, 1.0055729150772095, -0.601026177406311, -0.0529467798769474, 0.7113779187202454, -0.34634777903556824, -0.5915135145187378, -0.16232910752296448, 0.17712877690792084, 0.0872291848063469, -0.3539273142814636, -0.453917920589447, -0.5423874258995056, -0.49799802899360657, -1.3457272052764893, 0.0022729882039129734, -0.5505080819129944, 0.09413543343544006, -0.17121359705924988, -0.5911408066749573, -0.07162588089704514, 0.17975914478302002, 0.17041146755218506, 0.14026986062526703, -0.22296583652496338, -0.49018043279647827, 0.8510657548904419, 0.29747748374938965, -0.3360302150249481, 0.09022533893585205, -0.4871771037578583, 0.4625571072101593, 0.9315338134765625, 0.2353263646364212, -0.1544596254825592, -0.055709660053253174, 0.23042140901088715, -0.05151987820863724, 0.36630216240882874, -0.31086963415145874, -0.5564203262329102, 0.10665205121040344, 0.9010388255119324, 0.575596034526825, -0.6127632856369019, -0.8357797265052795, 0.4643801152706146, -0.748978853225708, 0.014495797455310822, -0.5772528052330017, -0.33814921975135803, 0.49517977237701416, -0.8490766286849976, 1.1015949249267578, 0.13797196745872498, 0.03938727080821991, -0.12936818599700928, -0.14134731888771057, 0.1273210197687149, -0.22744445502758026, -0.5659698843955994, -0.8818442821502686, -0.442460834980011, -0.8797341585159302, 0.3726658225059509, 0.24553462862968445, -0.1778864562511444, -0.07373406738042831, -0.5772684216499329, -0.008849717676639557, -0.011996223591268063, 0.3041890859603882, 0.8034395575523376, -0.2932168245315552, -0.694461464881897, 0.22481030225753784, 0.22030746936798096, -0.19968284666538239, 0.6264470219612122, 0.10505107790231705, -0.4079263210296631, 0.2820188105106354, -0.4057478904724121, -0.2473161667585373, -0.5427030324935913, -0.26612886786460876, 0.3792785704135895, 0.9423462748527527, -0.5516993403434753, 0.06333226710557938, 0.36386433243751526, -0.37066882848739624, -0.4950670897960663, 0.6184613108634949, 0.22096006572246552, 0.2603754997253418, 1.145656704902649, -0.03670286014676094, -0.4182458221912384, 0.5060051083564758, -0.2644071877002716, 0.7812677025794983, 0.03556778281927109, 0.4802139401435852, -0.046928584575653076, -1.1423500776290894, 0.7976733446121216, 0.3026463985443115, -1.0921237468719482, -0.6251075267791748, -0.21287131309509277, -0.016851268708705902, -0.10250886529684067, -0.787053644657135, -0.27099084854125977, 0.5449602603912354, -0.19501559436321259, 0.6977953314781189, -0.15599824488162994, -0.10821656882762909, -0.21233795583248138, -0.1333923637866974, 0.6412000060081482, -0.39709725975990295, -0.3326799273490906, 0.5793123245239258, -0.4892445206642151, 0.5209314823150635, 0.0683700367808342, 0.5321654081344604, 0.28884032368659973, 0.4427393078804016, 0.4983791708946228, -0.7260968685150146, -0.027045272290706635, -0.1795884519815445, 0.39467552304267883, -0.1665361374616623, 0.22993174195289612, 0.10253170132637024, 0.759901225566864, 0.44402843713760376, -1.12791907787323, -0.6603552103042603, 0.6057430505752563, 0.2834244966506958, 0.3575514554977417, 0.14100170135498047, -0.1009703055024147, 0.8022232055664062, 0.31912320852279663, 0.23646818101406097, -0.5892392992973328, -1.053084135055542, -0.7337368726730347, -0.3751356899738312, -0.16099320352077484, -0.8746058344841003, -0.14610490202903748, 0.19275812804698944, 0.03743633255362511, -0.7553204298019409, -0.494343638420105, 1.0942189693450928, 0.05366828665137291, -0.4690961539745331, -0.11312100291252136, 0.4334043562412262, 0.2975664734840393, -0.35631242394447327, -0.15979687869548798, -0.828330934047699, -0.2605690062046051, 1.0924543142318726, -0.5422747731208801, -0.08875267207622528, -0.3836030960083008, -0.08522797375917435, 0.1102830171585083, 0.36284777522087097, -0.43739962577819824, -0.46852922439575195, 0.27561861276626587, 0.6649979948997498, 0.8931978344917297, -0.05284915119409561, 1.5895909070968628, -0.2197742611169815, 0.26863330602645874, -0.21322372555732727, 0.0566139817237854, 0.03442388400435448, 0.5617467164993286, 0.12787732481956482, -0.8255729675292969, -0.4085327386856079, -1.27927827835083, 0.4964228570461273, -0.8612078428268433, -0.5767618417739868, -0.4454532265663147, -0.21703997254371643, -0.4427739679813385, 0.21457916498184204, 0.04498453438282013, 0.16326114535331726, -0.4304907023906708, 0.19059635698795319, -0.3535225987434387, 0.8815174698829651, -0.06417930871248245, -0.3831326961517334, 0.7776052951812744, 0.09477083384990692, 0.23545929789543152, -1.0752850770950317, 0.13132651150226593, 0.19791007041931152, -0.19951137900352478, 0.7463517785072327, -0.6155567169189453, 0.0451323427259922, -0.13557322323322296, -0.5801287293434143, 0.17153070867061615, 1.0611436367034912, 0.3477028012275696, 1.204244613647461, 0.11875852197408676, -0.17499583959579468, -0.5766480565071106, -0.7867356538772583, -0.8987934589385986, -0.6464813351631165, 0.4895518124103546, -0.7043315172195435, 0.014932951889932156, 0.07408173382282257, -0.632066547870636, 0.5209096074104309, 0.14689858257770538, 0.2225833684206009, 0.3808364272117615, 0.7500849366188049, 0.2362934947013855, 0.29122307896614075, 0.3044271469116211, 0.35849329829216003, 0.6986895799636841, 0.05595855042338371, -0.3934706151485443, -0.223517507314682, -0.2195807844400406, 0.1960383951663971, 0.5569605231285095, -0.31267157196998596, 0.12149863690137863, -0.10443443804979324, 0.02468724362552166, 0.12331049144268036, -0.5925833582878113, 0.20072196424007416, -0.8094074726104736, -0.05101051181554794, 0.40918096899986267, 0.34489279985427856, -0.552488386631012, 0.2341793030500412, 0.4412989020347595, -1.3010181188583374, -0.5909202694892883, 0.7206847667694092, 0.44860976934432983, 0.3532377779483795, 0.44646987318992615, -0.4811035096645355, -0.1303437501192093, 0.049915943294763565, -0.6759909987449646, 0.502382218837738, 0.8945106863975525, 0.5517799258232117, -0.15920065343379974, -0.43264102935791016, -0.28851455450057983, 0.9449538588523865, 0.1291561722755432, -0.14954745769500732, 0.4982706606388092, 0.4410991370677948, 0.24212564527988434, -0.39728519320487976, -0.790745735168457, 0.07668612897396088, 0.147013857960701, -0.6234923601150513, -0.1647403985261917, 0.05245192348957062, 1.0424885749816895, 0.14917343854904175, -0.7000548243522644, 0.12362036108970642, -0.3332613706588745, -0.5098236203193665, 0.4376313388347626, 0.10027234256267548, 0.6124818921089172, -0.19886738061904907, 0.47161242365837097, 0.41731980443000793, 0.5120527744293213, -0.16454219818115234, 0.11936364322900772, 0.7063348889350891, -0.45285534858703613, -0.07323449105024338, -0.22144770622253418, 0.6683749556541443, -0.14438271522521973, -0.46737149357795715, 0.29182538390159607, 0.26033034920692444, 0.6300879716873169, 0.735522449016571, -0.3211670219898224, -0.018542509526014328, 0.5627195835113525, -0.7496411800384521, -0.49056875705718994, -0.3969395160675049, -0.08095395565032959, -0.46316781640052795, -0.5173435211181641, 0.3023031949996948, -0.13128718733787537, 0.2889432907104492, 0.3141217827796936, 0.24568840861320496, 0.3365781307220459, 0.26105794310569763, 0.24822376668453217, -0.41978564858436584, 0.016840990632772446, 0.4756433665752411, 0.20027950406074524, -0.00976084265857935, -0.4160713255405426, -0.46441131830215454, 0.5190461874008179, -0.3772505223751068, 0.17864637076854706, -0.030217353254556656, -0.21999680995941162, -0.08309153467416763, -0.0340561717748642, 0.30070918798446655, -0.017744701355695724, -1.2963570356369019, -0.08329682797193527, -0.14775323867797852, 0.14797855913639069, 0.0896836444735527, -0.3063220679759979, -0.19943174719810486, -0.5175392031669617, -0.10766562074422836, -0.4880554676055908, -0.3952684700489044, 0.5871966481208801, -1.0640029907226562, 0.9908835887908936, -0.012803570367395878, -0.32832223176956177, -0.400647908449173, -0.9914542436599731, -0.1736910492181778, -0.18379268050193787, 0.2827846109867096, -0.7680210471153259, -0.2948724329471588, 0.8459753394126892, 0.24993112683296204, -0.07776106894016266, -0.3427678048610687, -0.38391682505607605, 0.23253744840621948, 1.1835737228393555, -0.10315027832984924, 0.627633273601532, -0.10674939304590225, 0.42612385749816895, -0.08574662357568741, -0.3312476873397827, -0.3041469156742096, 0.14267310500144958, -0.23004265129566193, -0.6486549377441406, 0.05993279442191124, -0.2149437665939331, -1.0262099504470825, 0.45209842920303345, 0.18848977982997894, -0.3942818343639374, -0.06977370381355286, -0.6277933120727539, -0.7959094643592834, -0.7277972102165222, 0.8984684944152832, -0.43571603298187256, 0.1637490689754486, 0.03263632208108902, 0.46692392230033875, 0.6115959286689758, -1.0448795557022095, 4.156504154205322, 0.6803064942359924, 0.5355879664421082, 0.13833123445510864, 0.8746019601821899, 0.29909586906433105, 0.4877229630947113, 0.0311911441385746, 0.05435524880886078, -0.09536135196685791, -0.23422138392925262, 0.2983413636684418, 0.027610866352915764, -0.18634136021137238, -0.005367307458072901, 0.5747439861297607, -0.661546528339386, 0.19601617753505707, 0.10468358546495438, -0.739065408706665, -0.7773733735084534, 0.13626958429813385, 0.04517713934183121, 0.503836989402771, 0.6258413195610046, 0.000804609851911664, -0.1131606325507164, -0.16776561737060547, -0.04236835241317749, 0.2264217883348465, -0.17897099256515503, -0.7457291483879089, 0.4751772880554199, -0.4311228096485138, -0.5654773116111755, 1.3154371976852417, 0.3108123242855072, -0.7006944417953491, -0.29045724868774414, -0.3236246407032013, -0.024353088811039925, 0.2840149402618408, -0.23178881406784058, -0.4347172975540161, -0.22585703432559967, 0.4447086453437805, -0.4805375635623932, 0.13938339054584503, -0.1831713318824768, -0.528928279876709, 0.7881955504417419, -0.7416393160820007, -0.025332583114504814, 0.0035315898712724447, -0.8079676032066345, -0.19201329350471497, -0.17208074033260345, -0.46170690655708313, 0.25086602568626404, 0.40881720185279846, 0.7546852231025696, 0.3642989695072174, 0.18755678832530975, -0.3072623014450073, 0.13207760453224182, 0.9857682585716248, 0.5971782803535461, 0.30174368619918823, 0.7148613929748535, -0.05348885804414749, -0.006269301753491163, -0.3239455223083496, -0.5337559580802917, 0.022511586546897888, 0.09235145896673203, 0.3139692544937134, -0.2890580892562866, 1.0565342903137207, -1.0091694593429565, -0.6503939628601074, 0.17779441177845, 0.05129878595471382, 0.09017159789800644, -0.19184713065624237, -0.10105130076408386, 0.5394125580787659, -0.216044619679451, -0.5379058122634888, -1.0653406381607056, 0.12380479276180267, 0.6946311593055725, -0.041998717933893204, -0.11143101751804352, 0.26448407769203186, -0.046936918050050735 ]
{"Title": "Measuring Baseline Health with Individual Health-Adjusted Life Expectancy (iHALE)", "Authors": "Johansson Kjell Arne, \u00d8kland Jan-Magnus, Kr\u00fcger Skaftun Eirin, Bukhman Gene, Norheim Ole Frithjof, Coates Matthew M., Haaland \u00d8ystein Ariansen", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objectives At any point of time, a person\u2019s baseline health is the number of healthy life years they are expected to experience during the course of their lifetime. In this article we propose an equity-relevant health metric, illness-specific individual Health Adjusted Life Expectancy (iHALE), that facilitates comparison of baseline health for individuals at the onset of different medical conditions, and allows for the assessment of which patient groups are worse off. A method for calculating iHALE is presented, and we use this method to rank four conditions in six countries according to several criteria of \u201cworse off\u201d as a proof of concept. Methods iHALE measures baseline health at an individual level for specific conditions, and consists of two components: past health (before disease onset) and future expected health (after disease onset). Four conditions (acute myeloid leukemia (AML), acute lymphoid leukemia (ALL), schizophrenia, and epilepsy) are analysed in six countries (Ethiopia, Haiti, China, Mexico, United States and Japan). Data for all countries and for all diseases in 2017 were obtained from the Global Burden of Disease Study database. In order to assess who are the worse off, we focus on four measures: the proportion of affected individuals who are expected to attain less than 20 healthy life years (T20), the 25 th and 75 th percentiles of healthy life years for affected individuals (Q1 and Q3, respectively), and the average iHALE across all affected individuals. Results Even in settings where average iHALE is similar for two conditions, other measures may vary. One example is AML (average iHALE=58.7, T20=2.1, Q3-Q1=15.3) and ALL (57.7, T20=4.7, Q3-Q1=21.8) in the US. Many illnesses, such as epilepsy, are associated with higher baseline health in high-income settings (average iHALE in Japan=64.3) than in low-income settings (average iHALE in Ethiopia=36.8). Conclusion iHALE allows for the estimation of the distribution of baseline health of all individuals in a population. Hence, baseline health can be incorporated as an equity consideration in setting priorities for health interventions.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003814"}
10.1101/19010843
[ 0.03952736034989357, 0.11057914793491364, -0.5445644855499268, 0.8295099139213562, -0.30988988280296326, -0.37108078598976135, 0.10907036066055298, -0.5727455615997314, 0.24425436556339264, 0.01188251655548811, 0.31906822323799133, 0.2562365233898163, 0.9433792233467102, -0.4398305416107178, 0.1893814355134964, 0.292058527469635, -0.7871697545051575, -0.27030062675476074, -0.32609474658966064, 0.11866505444049835, 0.09227702766656876, 0.39226552844047546, -1.1768277883529663, 0.484596848487854, -0.7755088210105896, 0.9954515099525452, 0.6354328989982605, -0.06358281522989273, 1.1254180669784546, 0.6993972063064575, -0.23396681249141693, -0.410258024930954, -0.085230253636837, -0.11606007069349289, -0.2862599492073059, -0.466089129447937, 0.5501466989517212, -0.37485602498054504, -0.35729509592056274, -0.34634608030319214, -0.10537459701299667, -0.08954023569822311, 0.21525485813617706, -0.289359450340271, -0.8675109148025513, -0.11990461498498917, 0.5080235600471497, -0.20220983028411865, 0.5254343152046204, -0.34445303678512573, -1.1600964069366455, 0.23586273193359375, -0.7872373461723328, -0.34001970291137695, 0.29917722940444946, -0.08342215418815613, 0.06270334124565125, -0.6943762898445129, -0.866095781326294, -0.24597814679145813, -0.14494851231575012, -0.6418755054473877, 0.553969144821167, -0.981344997882843, 0.5267044305801392, 0.2943563759326935, -0.1540132462978363, 0.1004234179854393, -0.21757754683494568, -0.2674003839492798, 0.5815403461456299, 0.2915361523628235, -0.7288402318954468, -0.6222662329673767, 0.2619030773639679, -0.39936813712120056, 0.03236875683069229, 0.3029175400733948, -0.2667444050312042, -0.6524258852005005, 0.06971612572669983, -0.18243911862373352, 0.2482198178768158, -0.031225306913256645, -0.372427761554718, -0.15132911503314972, 0.6585292220115662, 0.4115997850894928, 0.6089366674423218, 0.2932544946670532, -0.22154641151428223, -0.10199742019176483, -0.2579069435596466, 0.038946814835071564, -0.2919992208480835, 1.2579565048217773, -0.5516827702522278, -0.2167523205280304, 0.42788073420524597, 0.12394672632217407, 0.017482025548815727, 0.40803995728492737, -0.049280233681201935, 1.0965113639831543, -0.9120740294456482, 0.2813635766506195, 0.747911810874939, -0.9554621577262878, -0.5266913771629333, -0.48702412843704224, 0.07438397407531738, -0.0445767380297184, -0.47719457745552063, -0.34636634588241577, 0.1649305671453476, 0.393756240606308, -0.23797740042209625, -0.24301405251026154, -0.347538024187088, 0.8127228617668152, 0.310609370470047, -0.2588852643966675, 0.48640066385269165, -0.9349181056022644, 0.4350503981113434, 0.39564165472984314, 0.8681174516677856, 0.2299937754869461, -1.0502076148986816, -0.42246726155281067, 0.9745158553123474, -0.06544208526611328, -0.12755726277828217, 0.48877766728401184, 0.670207142829895, -0.1478482484817505, 0.3412386476993561, 0.5477380752563477, 1.0233851671218872, 0.9878626465797424, -0.25760456919670105, 0.18314802646636963, -0.2080020159482956, 1.4543768167495728, 0.20410144329071045, 0.7946575880050659, -0.5733135938644409, -1.375671148300171, -0.14831005036830902, -0.02282388135790825, 0.5977286696434021, 0.7204847931861877, 0.46987709403038025, -0.05706707760691643, 0.21389459073543549, 0.3502742052078247, -0.4951094090938568, -0.13953782618045807, -0.7983970046043396, 0.07072506844997406, -0.5614830255508423, 0.29693204164505005, 0.15011820197105408, 0.5074023008346558, -0.7918963432312012, 1.0557984113693237, -0.160755455493927, 0.5780718922615051, 0.09687615931034088, -0.16650095582008362, 1.072723150253296, 0.28939181566238403, -0.5551550388336182, -0.37134698033332825, 0.321097195148468, 0.8100460171699524, 0.4736786186695099, -0.15109843015670776, -0.0962090864777565, 0.10721850395202637, -0.5710218548774719, -0.3807951509952545, 0.12064941227436066, 0.8568655848503113, -0.5538433194160461, 0.6101476550102234, 0.283113032579422, -0.505312979221344, -0.27060654759407043, -0.4250715374946594, 0.3438355624675751, -0.28895998001098633, -0.391929566860199, 0.328204482793808, -0.22531871497631073, -0.35314977169036865, 0.1192072331905365, -0.18145622313022614, 0.8528001308441162, -0.4737848937511444, -0.42913293838500977, -0.39082932472229004, -0.09967947006225586, 0.3348539471626282, -0.5604024529457092, 0.34378302097320557, 0.3627864420413971, 0.06026795506477356, -0.8587416410446167, 0.6137758493423462, 0.8759871125221252, 0.2745276093482971, -0.41196873784065247, 0.5836839079856873, 0.7039388418197632, 0.11072346568107605, 0.17216047644615173, 0.558917224407196, -0.08332318812608719, -0.09699159860610962, -1.1049165725708008, 0.0424877367913723, -0.04410095512866974, -0.22512497007846832, 0.19089527428150177, -0.2822679281234741, 0.5434564352035522, 0.22340120375156403, -0.7757847309112549, -0.42016783356666565, 0.4373382329940796, 0.3324665427207947, -0.16403762996196747, 0.2169959992170334, 0.5570242404937744, 0.6671969294548035, 0.16789129376411438, 0.35745754837989807, 0.3740161061286926, 0.23938070237636566, 0.24401551485061646, 0.2189456671476364, 0.06542487442493439, -0.04379844665527344, -0.6446921229362488, 0.7006576657295227, -0.2307017743587494, -0.4554782807826996, -0.23600420355796814, 0.375796377658844, -0.4316287636756897, 1.080931305885315, 0.6458855271339417, 1.0771763324737549, -0.8028558492660522, 0.06193392723798752, 0.02014080435037613, 0.5173255801200867, -0.5317986607551575, -0.7053451538085938, -0.2770567834377289, 0.8009404540061951, -0.11009224504232407, -0.5270347595214844, 0.7795742750167847, 0.035475775599479675, -0.6997396945953369, 0.204630047082901, 0.12924106419086456, 0.01886974833905697, -0.8306889533996582, 0.06566951423883438, -0.8792309761047363, -0.6733022928237915, -0.31697288155555725, 0.27386268973350525, 0.5839563608169556, 0.008411107584834099, -0.20707015693187714, -0.0818135142326355, -0.7708976864814758, -0.09509897232055664, -0.10479067265987396, 0.8154038786888123, 0.11167602986097336, -0.1639431267976761, -1.3715946674346924, 0.1384204924106598, 0.1342138797044754, -0.08606182783842087, 0.7206393480300903, -0.268481969833374, -0.0736112892627716, -0.5578612089157104, 0.4051090180873871, -0.6536833643913269, -0.18277941644191742, -0.32434242963790894, -0.3896501362323761, -0.478039026260376, -0.20093201100826263, -0.7342118620872498, 0.12517568469047546, -0.18482071161270142, -0.8416707515716553, 0.9455447196960449, -0.09213855117559433, 0.3025156855583191, 0.5005757808685303, 0.1297556608915329, -0.2807038426399231, 0.49481427669525146, 0.04331861063838005, -0.04842159152030945, -0.36596202850341797, 0.6208706498146057, -0.03515242412686348, -0.887079119682312, -0.18480448424816132, 0.24934841692447662, -0.35357919335365295, -0.23187191784381866, -0.487771213054657, -0.04381987452507019, 0.3684358298778534, -0.1743258386850357, 0.09338856488466263, -1.49188232421875, 0.1574818640947342, -1.2868410348892212, -0.6140227913856506, -0.04083595797419548, 0.12341047078371048, -0.03185364231467247, -0.07661730796098709, -0.18406759202480316, -0.1952960193157196, 0.05546380579471588, 0.2959638237953186, 0.6362135410308838, 0.6234163641929626, 0.19588568806648254, 0.09174658358097076, -0.27928391098976135, -0.25251662731170654, 0.5657235980033875, -0.6688348650932312, -0.14761503040790558, -0.41154205799102783, -0.2517738938331604, -0.29014623165130615, 0.49414119124412537, 0.10046554356813431, 0.0551302433013916, -0.04345754161477089, 0.37398600578308105, -0.21189160645008087, 1.0336883068084717, -0.1589774787425995, 0.9130892753601074, 0.17618125677108765, 0.6011556386947632, -0.531629741191864, -0.5848909616470337, -0.6611530184745789, -0.30023130774497986, 0.07784780114889145, 0.2914794683456421, 0.9933077096939087, -0.19231288135051727, 0.6240454912185669, -0.5633165240287781, -0.15551935136318207, 0.4757215976715088, -0.5399147272109985, -0.42179566621780396, 0.35477229952812195, -0.42009982466697693, 0.2974071502685547, -0.1265047937631607, -0.34798070788383484, 0.8979702591896057, 0.4191626012325287, 0.20116503536701202, -0.10594139993190765, -0.12127988040447235, -0.5140897035598755, 0.2658116817474365, -0.062435947358608246, -0.6389628648757935, 0.34115591645240784, -0.4317967891693115, 0.14607477188110352, 0.47995293140411377, -0.052274852991104126, 0.1020241230726242, -0.044487327337265015, 0.15620361268520355, -0.23955829441547394, 0.10246244817972183, 1.1543021202087402, -0.7886803150177002, 0.6917386651039124, -0.027047917246818542, 0.4623655676841736, -0.13211879134178162, -0.09828212857246399, 0.02534039132297039, -0.3308078646659851, -0.09581296890974045, -0.6443242430686951, -0.9011388421058655, 0.3144404888153076, 0.09845851361751556, -0.1135450080037117, 0.21166746318340302, -0.15086007118225098, -0.5441489219665527, -0.09365478157997131, 0.02708207070827484, 0.7750260233879089, -0.11563188582658768, -0.5610407590866089, 0.5249052047729492, -0.00508791534230113, -0.8322265148162842, -0.24635852873325348, 0.4000306725502014, -0.2560376226902008, 0.8205918073654175, -1.3760802745819092, -1.227736234664917, 0.18649764358997345, -0.547742486000061, 0.03979875147342682, 0.6794441938400269, -0.1929137408733368, -0.8333287835121155, -0.06941495835781097, -0.7723701000213623, 0.06499645859003067, 0.531625509262085, 0.06366822123527527, 0.31755274534225464, 0.4839399755001068, -0.35164254903793335, 1.0294381380081177, 0.055139001458883286, 0.689681351184845, 0.5414373278617859, 0.3425820767879486, -1.0073199272155762, 0.6090923547744751, 0.38209429383277893, -0.5034853219985962, -0.03808710724115372, 0.09335832297801971, -0.4653938412666321, 0.1262494921684265, -0.6222674250602722, -0.26758265495300293, 0.170761838555336, 0.02399412915110588, -0.19687944650650024, -0.08448919653892517, 0.860914409160614, 0.07530499994754791, 0.6453747153282166, 0.9644778966903687, -0.23231831192970276, -0.5875438451766968, 0.16668707132339478, 0.03811071068048477, -0.5243541598320007, 1.2916476726531982, 0.009483249858021736, -0.0010218019597232342, -0.2483058124780655, -0.5704358816146851, -0.005910314619541168, 0.04537379369139671, 0.3401896059513092, -0.638279914855957, -0.08808266371488571, -0.39208143949508667, 0.03103756532073021, -0.30033478140830994, -0.15277624130249023, -1.1394902467727661, 0.38419225811958313, -0.2493453472852707, -0.051241517066955566, -0.13340920209884644, -0.03566177189350128, -0.000992144225165248, -0.09612952172756195, -0.20852169394493103, -0.0636671632528305, 0.07973353564739227, 0.46717357635498047, -0.15054099261760712, -0.8086495995521545, -0.5371597409248352, -0.19067929685115814, 0.024234170094132423, -0.7391057014465332, 0.19006769359111786, -0.525772750377655, -0.21501663327217102, -1.2271804809570312, -0.17994198203086853, -0.04404570534825325, -0.14513370394706726, 0.2742128372192383, 0.21244296431541443, -0.37251779437065125, 0.41479840874671936, -0.4271135926246643, 0.8075106739997864, 0.10195216536521912, -0.300194650888443, -0.15013009309768677, -0.5161510705947876, 0.2473202496767044, 0.16440817713737488, 0.9456575512886047, -0.6547712087631226, -0.3302421271800995, -0.17439749836921692, -1.2497854232788086, 0.1916305422782898, -0.2858380675315857, -0.36253219842910767, 0.23673392832279205, -0.7176551222801208, -0.5566517114639282, -0.09847304224967957, 0.3906531035900116, 0.4996695816516876, 0.02122911438345909, -0.35187289118766785, 0.1351342648267746, 0.20730791985988617, 0.12709033489227295, 0.6735132336616516, -1.0553109645843506, 0.36334094405174255, 1.0663492679595947, 0.2550256550312042, -0.5445891618728638, -0.2199389487504959, -0.06307101249694824, 0.48650479316711426, 0.1945565640926361, 0.3559357225894928, -0.5475079417228699, 0.15429286658763885, 0.28454506397247314, 0.48487046360969543, -0.2065710574388504, -0.6329455375671387, 0.8037397861480713, -0.23285707831382751, 0.32808178663253784, -0.46451592445373535, 0.04852902144193649, 0.053795285522937775, -1.3059990406036377, 0.9713048338890076, -0.33926627039909363, 0.2890903651714325, 0.3579231798648834, -0.9170969724655151, -0.49618270993232727, 0.20859798789024353, -0.6406185626983643, -1.157614827156067, 0.06285502761602402, -0.29309043288230896, -0.1550072729587555, 0.21699772775173187, 0.020034184679389, 0.4128025770187378, -0.530870258808136, -0.07278688251972198, -0.4206354022026062, 0.2554019093513489, 0.43547144532203674, -0.6692780256271362, -0.5078595876693726, -0.17258746922016144, 0.1145702376961708, 0.6104523539543152, 0.09474921971559525, 0.4251537024974823, 0.2972061336040497, -0.011310486122965813, -0.5056595206260681, -0.3283884525299072, -0.8417715430259705, 0.1642523556947708, -0.003426001174375415, -0.07591142505407333, 0.028071530163288116, -0.0052159568294882774, -0.059199489653110504, -0.17198868095874786, 0.12264441698789597, 1.1454839706420898, 0.010364503599703312, -0.20296715199947357, 0.560908854007721, -0.19707906246185303, -0.6586064696311951, 0.3569601774215698, -0.27115383744239807, 0.3397771418094635, -0.5083115100860596, 0.3382459580898285, 0.06154419854283333, -1.322847843170166, 0.9118331074714661, 0.3589733839035034, -0.6206085085868835, 0.40987154841423035, -0.20506101846694946, -0.6621982455253601, 0.5780823230743408, -0.3923625349998474, -0.8501800298690796, 1.049925684928894, 0.179463729262352, 0.9053179621696472, -0.7516458630561829, -0.4278305768966675, -0.6696456074714661, -0.4989995062351227, 0.6494402885437012, -0.17511866986751556, 0.016454923897981644, 0.28708767890930176, -0.0577484555542469, 0.322858065366745, 0.2861296534538269, 0.09831640124320984, -0.06155068054795265, 0.41963788866996765, 0.6161942481994629, -0.34101492166519165, -0.47529634833335876, -0.33146932721138, 0.0656721442937851, 0.5956061482429504, -0.26297223567962646, 0.2974148094654083, 0.40412411093711853, 0.01778159849345684, -0.610137939453125, -0.5341924428939819, 0.214922696352005, 0.5188714265823364, 0.8190348744392395, -0.1714123636484146, 0.48541197180747986, 0.9397817850112915, 0.2822844982147217, 0.5953667163848877, -1.0273826122283936, -0.35683131217956543, -0.16124339401721954, -0.1970500499010086, 0.08125796914100647, -0.47247812151908875, 0.1821848452091217, 0.7701996564865112, -0.2579253613948822, -0.5951166749000549, -0.1940615177154541, 1.0217785835266113, -0.22694653272628784, -0.43375933170318604, 0.21888567507266998, 0.058346204459667206, -0.017155339941382408, -1.1006039381027222, -0.3207930028438568, -0.35716819763183594, 0.4183717966079712, 1.018944501876831, -0.5588011741638184, -0.1295078843832016, 0.4485054910182953, 0.0047505637630820274, 0.35782167315483093, 0.35930657386779785, -0.17117463052272797, 0.016042910516262054, 0.6561026573181152, 0.30441081523895264, -0.0307720098644495, -0.0746929943561554, 0.7220054268836975, -0.20763181149959564, 0.2858904004096985, 0.5672571659088135, -0.1301349699497223, 0.604473352432251, -0.10205090790987015, -0.04594230279326439, -0.16029787063598633, -0.34320470690727234, -0.6386865973472595, -0.3238659203052521, -0.891330897808075, 0.20276935398578644, -0.18358725309371948, -1.2813719511032104, 0.3934088349342346, 0.02464698813855648, -0.5026302933692932, 0.1378551870584488, -0.2416352480649948, 0.49160832166671753, 0.025925137102603912, 0.7472083568572998, -0.22027036547660828, 0.03920639678835869, 0.15444207191467285, -0.20733720064163208, -0.06320933997631073, -0.793268084526062, 0.3295188546180725, 0.7626866102218628, 0.37733232975006104, 0.4626231789588928, -0.17488187551498413, 0.004923314321786165, 0.08266784995794296, -0.5789955854415894, -0.6121411919593811, 1.4734745025634766, 1.1489092111587524, 0.5202884674072266, 0.36443576216697693, -0.5055854916572571, -0.6028653383255005, -0.3578978478908539, -0.643735945224762, -1.0202335119247437, 0.7738132476806641, -0.1701795607805252, 0.0883375033736229, -0.48335596919059753, -0.5443453192710876, -0.21078316867351532, -0.0918402224779129, 0.13342376053333282, -0.15918003022670746, 0.64677894115448, 0.17063750326633453, 0.264782577753067, 0.5301235318183899, 0.20099709928035736, 0.8668281435966492, 0.2539540231227875, -1.1609419584274292, -0.4229884743690491, 0.26920953392982483, 0.3602708578109741, -0.12417244911193848, 0.19169479608535767, 0.3767887353897095, 0.14831775426864624, 0.36293429136276245, 0.7440571188926697, -0.5108417272567749, 0.3612385392189026, -1.0155062675476074, -0.7206065058708191, -0.3641681373119354, 0.6261872053146362, -0.45540904998779297, 0.3033839762210846, -0.044336795806884766, -1.252665638923645, -1.0745898485183716, 0.3407943546772003, 0.6988705396652222, -0.6658624410629272, 0.07957174628973007, -0.16984575986862183, 0.09709258377552032, 0.6060620546340942, -0.6714397072792053, 0.6142950057983398, 0.6113953590393066, 0.23021215200424194, 0.45688512921333313, 0.07316528260707855, -0.5349006056785583, 0.5498900413513184, 0.5081322193145752, -0.12878301739692688, 0.7857462763786316, 0.1959473341703415, 0.4003501534461975, 0.02662293054163456, -0.6924442052841187, 0.4743750989437103, -0.1364409476518631, -0.34414857625961304, 0.26347625255584717, 0.3375868499279022, 0.3482235372066498, 0.5008236765861511, -0.9206664562225342, -0.2937528192996979, -0.6582279205322266, -0.7895649671554565, 0.2704108655452728, 0.21363964676856995, 0.6228397488594055, 0.19207416474819183, 0.12765738368034363, 0.3532222807407379, 0.5600587129592896, -0.29338666796684265, 0.06204549968242645, 0.32726335525512695, 0.06362151354551315, -0.2897447943687439, 0.6293641924858093, -0.5935179591178894, -0.044992104172706604, 0.018710292875766754, 0.8904880285263062, 0.29164770245552063, 0.3639914095401764, 0.46045491099357605, 0.00010087054397445172, 0.4111287295818329, 0.7712746858596802, -0.5887365937232971, -0.22454309463500977, -0.41278472542762756, 0.04888027161359787, -0.8021591305732727, -0.28260499238967896, 0.6054566502571106, 0.15013474225997925, -0.19183015823364258, 0.23551806807518005, 0.9255470037460327, 0.3160477876663208, 0.4169255793094635, 0.6479915976524353, -0.014695458114147186, 0.5884280800819397, 0.4433794319629669, -0.21566341817378998, -0.5071665048599243, -0.41186171770095825, -0.45475518703460693, 0.11553040146827698, -0.5950504541397095, 0.8330515623092651, -0.07029299437999725, -0.18587549030780792, -0.44098198413848877, -0.15923069417476654, -0.7616026997566223, -0.02253025211393833, -0.7102234363555908, -0.5717719793319702, -0.052746325731277466, 0.2375667691230774, 0.4391669034957886, 0.0965501219034195, 0.5767631530761719, -0.4260443150997162, -0.6814979910850525, -0.6104207038879395, -0.6726942658424377, 0.1134365126490593, -0.11015617847442627, -0.15843842923641205, -0.43635499477386475, 0.059964634478092194, -0.60330730676651, -0.5974644422531128, 0.4598068594932556, 0.059194210916757584, 0.23754353821277618, -0.6029060482978821, -0.1261252760887146, 0.2404022067785263, 0.051400020718574524, 0.08105558156967163, -0.6904029250144958, -0.16348300874233246, 0.07019154727458954, 0.8877705335617065, 0.249531090259552, 0.3358350098133087, 0.15998071432113647, -0.03565225377678871, -0.053996261209249496, -0.7545899748802185, -0.3231654167175293, 0.4879525899887085, -0.8127588033676147, 0.07225282490253448, 0.7978087663650513, 0.00030999426962807775, -0.8815317749977112, 0.4718666672706604, 0.312672883272171, -0.12732411921024323, -0.0351971797645092, -0.4663971960544586, -0.47139114141464233, -0.005275509785860777, 1.277018666267395, -0.19283856451511383, 0.2084515243768692, -0.09816311299800873, 0.04103616997599602, -0.05060022324323654, -0.34999826550483704, 4.2605061531066895, 0.1665276437997818, 0.3897262215614319, -0.40135493874549866, 1.4866969585418701, -0.013512466102838516, 0.8300787210464478, 0.771621584892273, 0.8255292177200317, 0.07159294188022614, 0.25908535718917847, 0.27062180638313293, 0.1266171783208847, 0.1858101189136505, -0.08270718157291412, -0.18037648499011993, -0.6872413754463196, -0.20747023820877075, -0.2364359050989151, -0.591671347618103, -0.46084752678871155, 0.0005585370818153024, -0.3323649764060974, 0.5275360345840454, -0.15466082096099854, -0.4551207721233368, 0.08974753320217133, 0.1457224041223526, 0.44716915488243103, 0.15013286471366882, 0.14267826080322266, -0.5896762013435364, 0.5685118436813354, -0.8445864915847778, -0.6810134053230286, 0.13929493725299835, 0.3397151231765747, -0.24390412867069244, -0.4858960509300232, -0.6245449185371399, -0.1623859852552414, 0.2985081970691681, 0.14016279578208923, -0.7855610847473145, -0.3398820757865906, 0.43026554584503174, -0.3991660475730896, -0.3619915246963501, 0.6528829336166382, -0.3626120984554291, 1.2249727249145508, -0.3386494219303131, 0.3136354684829712, 0.5075657963752747, -0.4224852919578552, -0.5650284290313721, -0.6406398415565491, -0.7601645588874817, 0.21671076118946075, 0.17975835502147675, 0.8119831681251526, 0.2967548668384552, -0.4056991636753082, 0.14325253665447235, -0.1674388349056244, 0.9607413411140442, 0.03300895169377327, -0.43857038021087646, -0.25019147992134094, -0.006266079377382994, 0.18622465431690216, 0.26064130663871765, -0.5049722790718079, -0.30746257305145264, 0.7683704495429993, -0.003508308669552207, -0.4078418016433716, 1.0701555013656616, -0.23685309290885925, -0.20095930993556976, 0.026804812252521515, 0.0028675845824182034, 0.3702877163887024, 0.17590473592281342, 0.25412610173225403, 0.7436503171920776, -0.7485724687576294, -1.240195393562317, -0.3228606581687927, 0.30605652928352356, -0.5220289826393127, 0.347562700510025, -0.4116324782371521, 0.7224268913269043, -0.48925232887268066 ]
{"Title": "Quality of care at safety-net hospitals and the impact on pay-for-performance reimbursement", "Authors": "Sarkar Reith R., Courtney Patrick T., Bachand Katie, Sheridan Paige, Riviere Paul, Guss Zachary D., Lopez Christian R., Brandel Michael G., Banegas Matthew P., Murphy James D.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Pay-for-performance reimbursement ties hospital payments to standardized quality of care metrics. The impact of pay-for-performance reimbursement models on safety-net hospitals, which care primarily for uninsured or underinsured patients, remains poorly defined. This study evaluates how standardized quality of care metrics vary by a hospital\u2019s safety-net status, and helps us better understand the potential impact that pay-for-performance reimbursement could have on funding of safety-net hospitals. Methods We identified 1,703,865 bladder, breast, cervix, colon, endometrium, gastric, lung, ovary, or rectum cancer patients treated at 1,344 hospitals diagnosed between 2004 and 2015. Safety-net burden was defined for each hospital as the percentage of uninsured or Medicaid patients cared for by that hospital. Hospitals were grouped into low-, medium-, and high-burden hospitals. We evaluated the impact of safety-net burden on concordance with 20 standardized quality of care measures, adjusting for differences in patient age, gender, stage at diagnosis, and comorbidity. Results Patients seen at high-burden hospitals were more likely to be young, male, black, Hispanic, and to reside in a low-income and low-educated region. High-burden hospitals had lower adherence to 13 of 20 quality measures compared to low-burden hospitals (all p<0.05). Among the 350 high-burden hospitals, the quality measures were lowest for those caring for the highest fraction of uninsured or Medicaid patients, minority serving hospitals, and those caring for less educated patients (all p<0.001). Discussion Cancer care at safety-net hospitals was associated with lower concordance to standardized quality of care measures. Under a pay-for-performance reimbursement model these lower quality of care scores could decrease payments to safety-net hospitals, potentially increasing health disparities for at-risk cancer patients.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010843"}
10.1101/19002972
[ -0.06545710563659668, -0.1494479477405548, -0.6273981928825378, 0.8657907247543335, -0.44946590065956116, -0.9046908020973206, 0.2168639898300171, 0.11560595780611038, -0.15505896508693695, 0.21956796944141388, -0.09058580547571182, -0.0907304584980011, 0.13867232203483582, -0.0930062085390091, 0.25199025869369507, -0.12534582614898682, -0.8099915385246277, -0.63519686460495, -0.18009738624095917, -0.0645388513803482, 0.5081309080123901, 0.3644861876964569, -0.8867109417915344, 0.8261970281600952, -0.5967340469360352, 0.6319099068641663, 0.23881472647190094, 0.18364553153514862, 1.5887216329574585, 0.3437711000442505, 0.1940489411354065, -0.6448377966880798, 0.4781700670719147, -0.7157907485961914, -0.3557246923446655, -0.04401293024420738, 1.1556555032730103, -0.39413586258888245, -0.4048689007759094, 0.322163850069046, 0.42918217182159424, 0.3111874461174011, 0.2648342549800873, -0.8051146864891052, -0.8294036984443665, -0.7612033486366272, 0.2680330276489258, -0.4963701069355011, 0.3998737633228302, -0.42936667799949646, -0.14967836439609528, 0.04830799624323845, -0.12163706123828888, -0.8638578653335571, -0.25447022914886475, -0.11062155663967133, 0.5306788682937622, 0.04681910574436188, -0.32483288645744324, -0.0580168254673481, 0.5720328688621521, 0.05722998082637787, 0.1907723993062973, -1.4832898378372192, 0.6655538082122803, 0.04967278987169266, -0.3400033116340637, -0.2806554436683655, -0.6606739163398743, -0.4366331100463867, -0.7422696352005005, -0.32997339963912964, -1.2767870426177979, -0.7231077551841736, 0.192905992269516, -0.4767686128616333, 0.9463925361633301, -0.4669181704521179, 0.2923547923564911, -0.7302815914154053, 0.562044084072113, 0.03983202204108238, 0.09155125170946121, 0.02004214935004711, -0.25378963351249695, 0.038191575556993484, 0.8073552250862122, -0.47121965885162354, 0.6587926149368286, -0.37996864318847656, -0.0037024382036179304, -0.373968243598938, -0.10110712796449661, 0.009983479045331478, -0.39540696144104004, 0.9888928532600403, -0.3091299831867218, -0.010152850300073624, 0.20056229829788208, -0.2932227551937103, 1.3947772979736328, 1.0388835668563843, -0.13399362564086914, 1.2085816860198975, -1.1886341571807861, -0.16534721851348877, 0.6632922887802124, -0.8285704851150513, 0.09293128550052643, -0.7701751589775085, 0.4590185582637787, 0.5731856822967529, -0.3766801953315735, 0.39017319679260254, -0.4914186894893646, 0.575091540813446, -0.5828685164451599, 0.3857022523880005, -0.6254761815071106, 0.023739492520689964, 0.07799997180700302, -0.2812625765800476, -0.010780517011880875, -0.5197808742523193, 0.48775026202201843, -0.3754316568374634, 0.3979297876358032, 0.3933403789997101, 0.0576326809823513, -0.3158857226371765, 0.13488595187664032, -0.43473193049430847, -0.5679284334182739, 0.8822185397148132, -0.599047064781189, -0.08961121737957001, 0.04015803337097168, 0.3319782018661499, -0.3235178589820862, -0.28650614619255066, -0.7282915115356445, 0.07784182578325272, 0.056009989231824875, 1.041068196296692, 0.10527998208999634, 0.2414848357439041, -0.6795325875282288, -1.6943178176879883, 0.16889987885951996, -0.06151226907968521, 0.5603526830673218, 0.045499224215745926, 0.27181822061538696, 0.562693178653717, -0.517577588558197, -0.4457021951675415, -0.5615530014038086, 0.6880452036857605, -0.8443394303321838, 0.4662456810474396, 0.06012817844748497, 0.7891979217529297, -0.9931718707084656, 1.2102314233779907, 0.09617150574922562, 0.30731454491615295, 0.20962585508823395, 0.060314469039440155, 0.369717001914978, -1.0890567302703857, 0.35574930906295776, 0.1773870885372162, -0.1178266629576683, -0.35618263483047485, 0.2644987404346466, 0.7933788299560547, 1.1199606657028198, 0.6828256845474243, 0.39648035168647766, 0.24548393487930298, -0.4330388903617859, -0.4050953686237335, 0.6123774647712708, 0.8889279961585999, -0.47908151149749756, -0.08732016384601593, -0.8771281838417053, -0.6867977380752563, -0.056006450206041336, -0.2832415997982025, 0.03640536591410637, 0.5304622054100037, -1.4214227199554443, 0.536402702331543, -0.2152797430753708, 0.37847045063972473, 0.035194385796785355, 0.9277492165565491, 0.9679564237594604, -0.06492120772600174, -0.1963808536529541, 0.6537489891052246, 0.08777842670679092, 0.48159515857696533, -0.41888225078582764, 1.0235199928283691, 0.17967358231544495, 0.1294509917497635, -0.05888312682509422, 0.11369363963603973, -0.10998232662677765, -0.12658746540546417, -0.21052896976470947, 0.16600120067596436, 1.1558961868286133, -0.7845296859741211, 0.4680114686489105, 0.08648902177810669, 0.1855042427778244, -0.4998064637184143, 0.3753066956996918, -0.39098697900772095, 0.41147083044052124, -0.43329697847366333, 0.39600473642349243, 0.2946946620941162, 0.546019971370697, 0.5701034665107727, -0.3737468123435974, 0.06099653244018555, 0.23600997030735016, 0.8946118354797363, 0.04561805725097656, 0.30021345615386963, 0.5337947010993958, 0.3796146512031555, 0.6135736107826233, 0.4393419623374939, 0.8791155219078064, -0.3902651071548462, 0.4054824113845825, -0.01746983826160431, 1.1876893043518066, -0.06243990734219551, -0.4539174735546112, 0.3595213294029236, -0.08671453595161438, 0.6274013519287109, -0.529913604259491, -0.05067089945077896, -0.5851271748542786, 0.833358108997345, -0.204521045088768, 0.20582638680934906, -0.8517543077468872, -0.21462777256965637, 0.03552183881402016, 0.8728852868080139, 0.04279943183064461, -0.8919188380241394, -1.1841580867767334, -0.08829721808433533, 0.36311623454093933, 0.1687180995941162, 0.5163432955741882, 0.35549747943878174, 0.14583630859851837, 0.14482004940509796, -0.16726702451705933, -0.4916227161884308, -0.9475181698799133, -0.6723304986953735, -1.6768797636032104, -0.4154258668422699, 0.13895775377750397, -0.2760685980319977, 0.34253233671188354, -0.21126936376094818, -0.16572704911231995, 0.07167045027017593, 0.6217171549797058, 0.13771697878837585, 0.8194960355758667, 0.6765686273574829, -0.19747917354106903, 0.4860658645629883, -1.121269702911377, 0.06068379804491997, -0.817707896232605, 0.4022410809993744, 0.1120855063199997, -0.781315267086029, -0.3405511975288391, -0.4895390272140503, 0.277182936668396, -0.15366406738758087, 0.011845513246953487, 0.3468928337097168, 0.11330994218587875, -0.19690167903900146, 0.4264362156391144, -0.38128048181533813, -0.02978219836950302, -0.06840372830629349, -0.9149320721626282, 0.6535841822624207, 0.17846398055553436, 0.20178261399269104, 0.6306434273719788, 0.38915255665779114, -0.6146848201751709, 0.7711305618286133, 0.34772077202796936, -0.12923753261566162, -0.4682946503162384, 0.07351694256067276, 0.5731209516525269, -0.6560697555541992, 0.0686785876750946, -0.8336449861526489, -1.1602665185928345, -0.358807772397995, 0.09958178550004959, -1.4642754793167114, 0.040344465523958206, -0.16590671241283417, 0.13286930322647095, -1.4458873271942139, -0.3353763818740845, -0.5356884002685547, -0.9816475510597229, 0.18833060562610626, -0.527492880821228, 0.9190443754196167, -0.4120577871799469, -0.20242752134799957, -0.7608535885810852, -0.27064406871795654, 0.18923519551753998, 0.5416814684867859, 1.1258991956710815, -0.5781352519989014, -0.23307901620864868, 0.9301362037658691, -0.25132763385772705, 0.22613875567913055, 1.0988967418670654, -0.5803264379501343, -0.36767637729644775, -0.06623372435569763, -0.42539650201797485, 0.47623711824417114, 0.12839749455451965, -0.5286113619804382, -0.15516486763954163, 0.1348849982023239, -0.9232016801834106, -0.29176536202430725, 0.13274089992046356, 0.4852655231952667, -0.1486610323190689, -0.05841292068362236, 0.17719703912734985, 0.4696481227874756, -1.021682858467102, -0.23981627821922302, 0.45426318049430847, 0.009125780314207077, 0.0035614813677966595, -1.1353063583374023, 0.04233800619840622, -0.3877256512641907, 0.40349093079566956, -0.48506349325180054, -0.31421664357185364, -0.4303484559059143, 1.1180957555770874, 0.16088975965976715, 1.5415209531784058, -1.118662714958191, -0.05026549845933914, 0.7314374446868896, 1.465489149093628, 0.2511996030807495, -0.038395341485738754, 0.778521716594696, -0.23360399901866913, 0.1443658024072647, 0.3997519612312317, 0.40078309178352356, 0.8099414706230164, -0.3399561047554016, -0.29244914650917053, -0.15497978031635284, -0.7265825867652893, 0.005912752356380224, 0.9321462512016296, 0.28683701157569885, 0.42726999521255493, -0.9726579189300537, 1.039527177810669, -0.5149999260902405, 0.2100420743227005, 0.7201551198959351, -0.21052516996860504, -0.4361434578895569, -0.44033750891685486, 0.38011276721954346, -0.34718257188796997, -0.442181795835495, -0.028073666617274284, 0.12234597653150558, 0.4448935091495514, -0.35457441210746765, 0.11488599330186844, 0.1571127474308014, -0.6149746775627136, -0.4005119800567627, -0.0626584067940712, -0.3920072615146637, -0.03942308574914932, 0.8227903842926025, -0.5799829363822937, 0.29224205017089844, -0.16270674765110016, -0.3389757573604584, 0.9225186705589294, -0.21274414658546448, 0.6789458394050598, 1.1924225091934204, -0.590033233165741, -0.6464654207229614, 0.06300673633813858, -0.32496586441993713, -0.19253894686698914, 0.8898621797561646, -0.35734760761260986, -0.3847360908985138, 0.7189797163009644, 0.6251251101493835, -0.5680753588676453, -0.8240070343017578, -0.9355102777481079, 0.021082088351249695, -0.5216785669326782, 0.3878225088119507, 1.017513632774353, 0.402363657951355, 0.5882166624069214, 0.28039297461509705, 1.0678565502166748, -0.8081172108650208, 0.14768734574317932, -0.09202172607183456, -0.20734713971614838, 0.10054124891757965, -0.04286770150065422, -0.059696994721889496, 0.012428018264472485, 0.26597860455513, -0.28208836913108826, 0.2533732056617737, 0.5306017994880676, 0.10881170630455017, -0.37832799553871155, 0.7830619215965271, -0.2533843517303467, 1.0527480840682983, 0.8280438780784607, -0.8060724139213562, -0.3477359712123871, 0.22321689128875732, 0.44855526089668274, -0.5271329879760742, 0.2513618469238281, -0.22398194670677185, 0.4591279625892639, -0.0783805251121521, -0.46671921014785767, -0.08801478147506714, -0.1647014319896698, -0.004526712000370026, -0.8220923542976379, 0.34138965606689453, -0.2972767949104309, 0.02835855633020401, -0.4609565734863281, 0.0056942836381495, -0.8619874119758606, 0.019332649186253548, -0.7140340805053711, -0.166120707988739, 0.16290274262428284, 0.7796806693077087, -1.306574821472168, 0.46934470534324646, -1.0490107536315918, 0.9001863598823547, 0.21786488592624664, 0.05849011242389679, 0.5551849007606506, -0.6013800501823425, -0.42361554503440857, 0.6096991300582886, 0.5148175954818726, -0.22638939321041107, -0.5366342663764954, -0.7471301555633545, -0.4101605713367462, 0.4653697907924652, -0.17541785538196564, 0.5685650110244751, -0.1895468533039093, -0.1926712840795517, -0.262226939201355, 0.11280297487974167, -0.252781480550766, -0.6591539978981018, -0.7567764520645142, 0.38699832558631897, -0.9820026755332947, -0.765913724899292, -0.48898735642433167, 0.2736380696296692, 0.08786574751138687, 0.18593233823776245, -0.20080861449241638, -0.8985365629196167, 0.11363668739795685, -1.2487759590148926, 0.26150456070899963, -0.8945747017860413, 0.12243858724832535, -0.7066610455513, -0.9998114705085754, -0.0025939475744962692, -0.7319083213806152, 0.1962239146232605, -0.25615671277046204, -0.5702159404754639, -0.8157570362091064, 0.1043577492237091, -0.28720027208328247, -0.211040660738945, 0.20735003054141998, 0.1275561898946762, 0.06590456515550613, 1.3525248765945435, 0.8051422238349915, -0.7088519930839539, 0.17270228266716003, 0.24833229184150696, 0.8084663152694702, 0.8222330212593079, -0.22924718260765076, -0.6161329746246338, 0.15236936509609222, 0.15342377126216888, 0.2982633411884308, -0.17398551106452942, -0.7844852805137634, -0.05763005092740059, -0.9454899430274963, 0.25952252745628357, -0.6497154235839844, -0.7306607961654663, -0.5028886198997498, -0.7376571297645569, 1.0039688348770142, -0.2963505685329437, 0.8115132451057434, 0.4525142014026642, 0.372326135635376, -0.24481095373630524, 0.30978015065193176, -0.4608791470527649, -0.6586776971817017, -0.7093443274497986, -1.1476763486862183, -0.04713005945086479, -0.022436754778027534, 0.3881588280200958, 0.518953800201416, -0.37183132767677307, 0.4840742349624634, -1.4863219261169434, 1.1483231782913208, 0.7901973724365234, -0.10456127673387527, -1.144960641860962, -0.4071841835975647, 0.0844351276755333, 0.7163136601448059, -0.2984794080257416, -0.32853808999061584, -0.7555482983589172, 0.0034645223058760166, -0.49753537774086, -0.736129879951477, -1.2327101230621338, -0.38713333010673523, 0.5824103355407715, 0.3828936219215393, -0.17441903054714203, 0.02742290310561657, -0.3095718324184418, 0.3241695761680603, -0.61106938123703, 1.1382343769073486, -0.4735792875289917, -0.3487609326839447, 0.1808919608592987, -0.30502864718437195, -0.2520638406276703, -0.029038168489933014, 0.07537639886140823, 0.12260448187589645, 0.031131409108638763, 0.6980995535850525, 0.7506020069122314, -0.7342880964279175, 0.48207542300224304, 0.15228869020938873, -0.4216037392616272, -0.7377587556838989, 0.0543668158352375, -0.3149910271167755, -0.21803757548332214, -0.17169290781021118, -0.8305047750473022, 0.48680394887924194, -0.1912287026643753, 0.6263604760169983, 0.12412703782320023, 0.04264644533395767, -0.24075113236904144, -0.4598391056060791, 0.07581903040409088, -0.3562575876712799, 0.06054756045341492, 0.8012606501579285, -0.2653159201145172, 0.5582473874092102, -0.375580757856369, -0.023131966590881348, 0.06635905802249908, 0.005698447115719318, 0.08496766537427902, -0.8875055909156799, -0.6111684441566467, 0.28446128964424133, -0.0012826446909457445, 0.0175982266664505, -0.130145862698555, 0.08620616048574448, 0.5761446952819824, 0.00441627437248826, -0.46087002754211426, -0.0003359287802595645, 0.6967541575431824, 0.09323356300592422, 0.9636930227279663, -0.2637903690338135, 0.1985785812139511, 0.6293660998344421, 0.16064094007015228, -0.03574823588132858, -0.801574170589447, -1.3051694631576538, -0.4272351861000061, -0.23318825662136078, 0.07618996500968933, -0.3323485255241394, -0.3496790826320648, 0.49232232570648193, -0.7729825973510742, -0.619100034236908, -0.43796882033348083, 0.8054888844490051, -0.6998093128204346, -0.530926525592804, -0.5629370808601379, 0.6011130213737488, -1.095707654953003, 0.24296927452087402, 0.5710486173629761, -0.9986515045166016, -0.483850359916687, 0.6778937578201294, -0.34004202485084534, -0.3219545781612396, 0.8384513258934021, 0.3304433524608612, -0.032612819224596024, 1.0072945356369019, -0.8729506134986877, -0.33217328786849976, 0.05942758172750473, 0.398349791765213, 0.26333898305892944, 0.21001049876213074, 0.6584954261779785, -0.4510696232318878, 1.2005032300949097, 0.06551296263933182, -0.0867437869310379, -0.6392051577568054, 0.47509631514549255, 0.5996060967445374, -0.5055673122406006, -0.5187365412712097, 0.2816964387893677, 0.34165817499160767, -0.8443523645401001, -0.8313462734222412, -0.2293209731578827, 0.02592211775481701, 0.1330823302268982, -0.029462089762091637, -0.3981976807117462, 0.7625535726547241, -0.04386384040117264, -0.6437134146690369, 0.3889268934726715, 0.26596927642822266, 0.3366025388240814, -0.31338006258010864, 0.19104088842868805, -0.3412902355194092, 0.13371026515960693, -1.3193694353103638, 0.429719477891922, 0.695283830165863, -0.29445627331733704, -0.036264944821596146, -0.2927934229373932, 0.46399208903312683, 0.2966233193874359, 0.18480001389980316, 0.3520009219646454, 1.1244981288909912, 0.00848047249019146, 0.07680647075176239, 0.1357528418302536, 0.3275131285190582, -0.5006985068321228, -0.5221619606018066, -0.3839533030986786, -0.557793378829956, 1.117969036102295, -0.36485132575035095, -0.24130968749523163, -0.37693673372268677, -0.25357604026794434, 0.9901625514030457, 0.24256578087806702, -0.032168783247470856, -0.5865963697433472, 0.33238038420677185, 0.23546858131885529, 0.6629235744476318, 0.0197727233171463, -0.6747869253158569, 0.25950896739959717, 0.23903191089630127, -0.7700843214988708, -0.616632878780365, 0.5526474714279175, 0.8493134379386902, 0.779079258441925, -0.030347174033522606, -0.28570857644081116, 0.22964763641357422, -0.20563122630119324, -0.5633619427680969, -0.16720592975616455, 0.6000963449478149, -0.0737399086356163, -0.09853074699640274, -0.5740517377853394, 0.5780397653579712, 0.15853002667427063, 0.3529282510280609, 0.47791779041290283, -1.0790925025939941, -0.5917801260948181, 0.2012784481048584, 0.16887159645557404, -0.7513911724090576, 0.6087511777877808, -0.29298505187034607, 0.43463677167892456, 0.35139355063438416, 0.30398324131965637, 0.25174590945243835, 0.9170309901237488, 0.39085108041763306, 0.05520596355199814, -0.3697862923145294, 0.9089314937591553, 0.5855026245117188, 0.5288493633270264, 0.21231408417224884, 0.2793876826763153, -0.06087925285100937, -0.35551825165748596, 0.7238839268684387, -0.4766642451286316, 0.6667220592498779, 0.206264927983284, -0.008232804015278816, -0.17427793145179749, 0.23711910843849182, 0.6162036657333374, 0.2545853555202484, -0.753791868686676, 0.04918608441948891, -0.21084578335285187, -0.9204360246658325, 0.026110026985406876, 1.412217617034912, 0.20410145819187164, -0.50511234998703, 0.7772756218910217, 0.21562336385250092, 0.08711248636245728, 0.5273735523223877, 0.1504489779472351, 0.6810570955276489, 0.043094079941511154, -0.32650041580200195, 0.20691844820976257, 0.6751167178153992, 0.8102127909660339, -0.07204654067754745, 0.462318480014801, -0.23294024169445038, -0.45322874188423157, 0.2482992559671402, 0.63266921043396, -0.7353034615516663, 0.9628641605377197, -0.5528212785720825, -0.3259330689907074, -0.3180626630783081, -0.6254439949989319, -1.4002708196640015, -0.24708668887615204, 0.843235433101654, -0.7248275876045227, 0.30557939410209656, 0.021533679217100143, 0.06667201966047287, 0.08207304775714874, 0.03018200956285, 0.47322705388069153, 0.005743274465203285, 0.9864032864570618, 0.6574810147285461, 0.539016604423523, -0.01863669790327549, 0.2217235416173935, 0.037574611604213715, -0.35919198393821716, 0.3490254580974579, 1.074745774269104, 0.5490502119064331, -0.16542227566242218, -0.057416968047618866, 0.25455427169799805, -0.35718539357185364, 0.26932841539382935, -0.8267135620117188, 0.1300821751356125, -0.012897771783173084, 0.20056293904781342, -0.4132968783378601, 0.3804800510406494, -0.05603746697306633, 0.6583091616630554, -0.33037224411964417, -0.39630210399627686, -0.6435385346412659, -0.30539584159851074, -0.22069045901298523, 0.549168586730957, 0.3137272596359253, -0.13215778768062592, -0.3683004677295685, -1.0404925346374512, -0.1575535237789154, -0.07972841709852219, -0.6056978702545166, -0.8412663340568542, 0.6648058295249939, 0.0023163314908742905, 0.699916660785675, 0.04577365145087242, -0.2976144254207611, -0.06343628466129303, 0.19503997266292572, 1.1172723770141602, 0.2742650806903839, 0.7135794162750244, 0.9038160443305969, 0.6081582903862, 0.12920866906642914, 0.14819210767745972, 0.007419939152896404, 0.13512691855430603, -0.07950057089328766, 0.2735536992549896, 0.2479429543018341, 0.30944743752479553, -0.6052730083465576, -0.2958342730998993, 0.755881130695343, -0.15246571600437164, 0.4186932146549225, -0.7336214780807495, -0.5201112627983093, -0.25626707077026367, 0.6365453600883484, -0.22774551808834076, 0.6523848176002502, 0.008857658132910728, -0.4274630844593048, 0.4347204864025116, -0.30777841806411743, 3.886744499206543, 1.2988743782043457, 0.15945538878440857, 0.10225508362054825, 0.04811134934425354, 0.5033608675003052, 1.2757179737091064, -0.0628281757235527, -0.28432756662368774, 0.48580193519592285, -0.650923490524292, 0.41029873490333557, -0.30627232789993286, -0.41292867064476013, 0.7015913128852844, 0.2644975781440735, -0.7532351016998291, -0.28532323241233826, 0.1853211224079132, -0.6036136746406555, -0.25775763392448425, 0.5188443064689636, 0.13757306337356567, -0.5324918627738953, 0.20510652661323547, -0.33246999979019165, 0.08489088714122772, 0.29112547636032104, 0.16682176291942596, -0.32025304436683655, -0.1512533724308014, -0.961448073387146, 0.36534151434898376, -1.2381219863891602, -0.6862096190452576, 0.18880537152290344, 0.08784102648496628, -0.42766183614730835, -0.14047613739967346, -0.27607691287994385, 0.2574485242366791, -0.14225363731384277, 0.5415022969245911, -0.11534978449344635, -0.12938812375068665, 0.3743012547492981, -0.46923840045928955, 0.5391536951065063, 0.4381296634674072, -0.7418504357337952, 0.6930276155471802, -0.6597444415092468, -0.15685200691223145, -0.17508400976657867, -0.9951120018959045, -0.43557208776474, -0.015100113116204739, -1.020265817642212, -0.0463375523686409, 0.1188715472817421, 0.7655788660049438, 0.4514607787132263, 0.2698427736759186, 0.17462018132209778, 0.04568848758935928, 0.4928537905216217, 0.4132396876811981, -0.012652168050408363, 0.42564696073532104, -0.45088180899620056, -0.29592928290367126, 0.5291491746902466, -0.9528921842575073, -0.2295175939798355, 0.24670399725437164, -0.061915986239910126, -0.4561130404472351, 0.42986688017845154, -0.06409767270088196, -0.29388028383255005, -0.3106189966201782, 0.6844193339347839, 0.29173046350479126, 0.5436779856681824, 0.17194044589996338, 0.3468787670135498, -0.0068185459822416306, -0.254232257604599, -1.3141579627990723, 0.6289501190185547, 0.7692691683769226, -0.3379206657409668, -0.3016888499259949, 0.3192228376865387, 0.024722710251808167 ]
{"Title": "fMRI as an outcome measure in clinical trials: A systematic review in clinicaltrials.gov", "Authors": "Sadraee Alaleh, Paulus Martin P., Ekhtiari Hamed", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) is quickly becoming a significant outcome measure for clinical trials and as more than one thousand trials with fMRI as an outcome measure were registered in clinicaltrials.gov at the time of writing this article. However, 93% of these registered trials are still not completed with published results and there is no picture available about methodological dimensions of these ongoing trials with fMRI as an outcome measure. Methods We collected trials that use fMRI as an outcome measure by searching \u201cfMRI\u201d in the ClinicalTrials.gov registry on October 13 2018 and reviewing each trial\u2019s record entry. Eligible trials\u2019 characteristics were extracted and summarized. Results In total, 1386 clinical trials were identified that reported fMRI in their outcome measures with fMRI as the only primary outcome in 33% of them. 82% of fMRI trials were started after 2011. The most frequent intervention was drug (29%). 57% of trials had parallel assignment design and 20% were designed for cross over assignment. For task-based fMRI, cognitive systems (46%) based on RDoC was the most frequent domain of tasks, followed by positive valence systems (19%), systems for social processing (10%) and sensorimotor systems (5%). Less than one-third of trials (28%) registered at least one region of interest for their analysis. Food cue reactivity task, pain perception task, n-back task and monetary incentive delay task were recruited in more than 25 registered trials. Conclusion The number of fMRI trials (fMRI as an outcome measure) with both task and rest protocols is growing rapidly. Different RDoC domains are covered by various tasks in fMRI trials. However, our study suggests the need of greater harmony and better standardization for registration of fMRI details on both methods and analysis which would allow for more effective comparison across studies in systematic reviews and also help the validation of results towards having fMRI as a biomarker in the future.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002972"}
10.1101/19006023
[ 0.33648550510406494, 0.02476964145898819, -0.4248883128166199, 0.5042168498039246, -0.04903506487607956, -0.023009246215224266, -0.3206177055835724, -0.3352856934070587, 0.6641710996627808, 1.2781367301940918, 0.05291128531098366, -0.4996480941772461, 0.4878252446651459, -0.07459982484579086, -0.050744131207466125, 0.40937530994415283, -0.7233760356903076, -0.47913217544555664, 0.24929504096508026, -0.17754477262496948, 0.1530662477016449, 0.9568840265274048, -1.1448293924331665, -0.21703651547431946, -0.731132984161377, 0.8366103172302246, 0.17737674713134766, -0.5962828993797302, 1.4430227279663086, 0.7304494976997375, 0.32310914993286133, -0.3730449974536896, 0.2364359200000763, -0.5598634481430054, 0.07344158738851547, -0.1716766208410263, 0.5742902755737305, -0.30247077345848083, -0.7433510422706604, -0.003102620132267475, 0.5910590291023254, -0.4771994948387146, 0.28460755944252014, -0.904611349105835, -1.2081927061080933, -0.35360369086265564, -0.18824344873428345, 0.39965179562568665, 0.3825472295284271, -0.17859329283237457, -0.2378397136926651, -0.14291366934776306, 0.08105409890413284, -0.4245530664920807, -0.5458657741546631, -0.28097060322761536, 0.2737022340297699, 0.2307204157114029, -0.5244765281677246, 0.31829580664634705, 0.6234953999519348, -0.7724938988685608, 0.9725043177604675, -0.7834113240242004, 0.8736714124679565, 1.0585311651229858, -0.446572482585907, -0.3178299367427826, -0.6059831380844116, -0.1640196293592453, -0.3231380879878998, -0.34101375937461853, 0.13998159766197205, -0.501010000705719, -0.17158235609531403, -0.21959421038627625, 0.16046571731567383, -0.13775484263896942, -0.1462208330631256, 0.1720404177904129, -0.492068886756897, 0.17465002834796906, 0.6110357046127319, 0.03530100733041763, -0.24768808484077454, 0.2711610496044159, 0.1817207783460617, 0.01965157501399517, 0.2017420530319214, 0.0018001262797042727, 0.0886339470744133, 0.0614767000079155, 1.210984706878662, -0.011405222117900848, -0.0376308411359787, 0.980794370174408, -0.0838465541601181, 0.3166983425617218, 0.5568622946739197, 0.42301204800605774, 0.9389656186103821, 1.8450052738189697, -0.23985880613327026, 0.5760083794593811, -0.8447146415710449, 0.44114598631858826, 0.8061966300010681, -0.4506874680519104, -0.9807282090187073, -0.5782933831214905, 0.08589276671409607, 0.04979367554187775, -0.42300641536712646, -0.31571581959724426, 0.34256622195243835, 0.5912820100784302, -0.1526220440864563, 1.052990198135376, -0.6208428740501404, 0.3403654396533966, 0.3098917007446289, 0.13795411586761475, 0.5322392582893372, -0.7721849679946899, 0.4059697091579437, 0.04849737137556076, -0.06921490281820297, 1.2668936252593994, -0.28123340010643005, 0.13015317916870117, -0.04679621011018753, -0.4055131673812866, -0.19915291666984558, 0.5709468126296997, 0.10828928649425507, 0.42779186367988586, 0.9137318730354309, 0.7965347766876221, 0.23471298813819885, -0.24645042419433594, -0.20840288698673248, 0.14307889342308044, -0.6940158605575562, 1.4404627084732056, -0.2608397901058197, 1.1251227855682373, -0.6167716383934021, -1.3629934787750244, -0.452869713306427, 0.27048859000205994, -0.8968890905380249, 0.4165808856487274, -0.4018002152442932, 0.1980317234992981, -0.31259819865226746, 0.5641231536865234, -0.27973899245262146, 0.40583908557891846, -0.9477471113204956, -0.4662370979785919, -0.33687639236450195, -0.1953626424074173, -0.16986560821533203, 0.24916231632232666, -0.639051616191864, 0.3185855746269226, -0.4999033510684967, 0.23191839456558228, -0.5147154331207275, -1.1647028923034668, 1.2444711923599243, -0.07963870465755463, -0.3173370063304901, -0.27733638882637024, 0.5135740637779236, 1.1883125305175781, 0.4349351227283478, 0.10343324393033981, 0.6599796414375305, 0.37660089135169983, -0.09117019921541214, -0.13327758014202118, 0.051145199686288834, -0.48559269309043884, 0.16024844348430634, 0.774894654750824, -0.16907016932964325, -0.39069870114326477, -0.7460134029388428, -0.4121193587779999, 0.4520494043827057, 0.759499192237854, -0.7163372039794922, 0.7600396871566772, -0.1830853819847107, -0.24205580353736877, 0.067163847386837, 0.8388497233390808, 0.47749894857406616, 0.1464998573064804, -0.4533412754535675, -0.14039598405361176, -0.295561283826828, 0.1348155438899994, -0.7744090557098389, 1.366896629333496, -0.5896480083465576, 0.25000491738319397, -0.6858638525009155, 0.5280110836029053, 0.5868370532989502, -0.16744056344032288, -0.4766770601272583, 0.08848624676465988, 1.2550333738327026, -0.5656738877296448, -0.3426739573478699, 0.17127734422683716, -0.10523881018161774, -0.6172710061073303, -0.2667631506919861, -0.004957407712936401, 0.8804808855056763, -0.14755582809448242, 0.5048577785491943, 0.15253834426403046, 1.0001006126403809, 0.9820054173469543, -0.4307998716831207, 0.16580528020858765, 0.7722698450088501, 0.9152255654335022, -0.15323634445667267, 0.7861074805259705, 0.5830342769622803, -0.026274507865309715, 0.5126146078109741, 0.5259398221969604, 0.14498037099838257, 0.13056741654872894, 0.056323569267988205, -0.45404252409935, 0.24587972462177277, 0.10545727610588074, -0.34783226251602173, 0.1783163845539093, -0.12151606380939484, -0.07387839257717133, 0.07668499648571014, 0.5167888402938843, -0.6677976250648499, 0.8345383405685425, 0.23788252472877502, 0.12704148888587952, -0.9573567509651184, -0.13011442124843597, 0.82596755027771, 0.17334741353988647, -0.3490225672721863, 0.14862170815467834, -0.09621327370405197, 0.8031853437423706, -0.41714003682136536, -0.2788684070110321, 0.29209521412849426, 0.6313731074333191, 0.3570593297481537, 0.051086049526929855, -0.05583926662802696, -0.11862833797931671, -0.6029345989227295, -0.5035282969474792, -0.8008401393890381, -0.6478381156921387, -0.7995543479919434, 0.06704093515872955, -0.7068272829055786, -0.3714004158973694, -0.04890035465359688, -0.5401345491409302, 0.5188297033309937, -0.5218361020088196, -0.22680209577083588, 0.7445335984230042, -0.13251343369483948, -0.19016018509864807, -0.7500531673431396, 0.29936137795448303, -0.31713348627090454, -0.05721564218401909, 0.11689595133066177, -0.5617104172706604, -0.9834986925125122, -0.7413383722305298, -0.057337384670972824, -1.0236682891845703, 0.3466154932975769, 0.1448919177055359, 0.12839654088020325, -0.5092931985855103, 0.28472641110420227, 0.15224221348762512, 0.8362514972686768, -0.32565057277679443, -0.7520110607147217, 0.6812281012535095, -0.06347794830799103, -0.08769341558218002, 0.46268385648727417, 0.25556522607803345, -0.8181840181350708, 0.505530834197998, 0.34128057956695557, -0.28774234652519226, -0.7862134575843811, -0.41927143931388855, 0.5245875716209412, -0.46506568789482117, -0.3280652165412903, -0.8944152593612671, -0.868834376335144, 0.38160377740859985, -0.589440107345581, -0.4885852336883545, -0.17267701029777527, 0.7443831562995911, -0.10023976862430573, -1.4911895990371704, 0.26018598675727844, -0.42741042375564575, -0.39423060417175293, 0.15790490806102753, -0.339072585105896, 0.6123917698860168, 0.4427613317966461, -0.08058049529790878, -0.61104416847229, -0.2436058670282364, 0.3364182710647583, 0.1717441976070404, 0.3198409378528595, -0.11834422498941422, 0.16512982547283173, 0.432455837726593, -0.4672800302505493, 0.8847866654396057, 0.7906507253646851, -0.4559107720851898, -0.1166045293211937, -0.07420777529478073, -0.6011635065078735, -0.15548747777938843, 0.6557791829109192, 0.014017552137374878, -0.31367334723472595, 0.6796990036964417, -0.3145884573459625, -0.15757498145103455, -0.2305501401424408, 0.15372177958488464, 0.43031609058380127, -0.005639997310936451, -0.7747647166252136, 0.5040817856788635, -0.05159858614206314, -0.9843828678131104, 0.3318956792354584, 0.1338794231414795, 0.3553297519683838, -0.6161584854125977, 0.9945948719978333, -0.4072820544242859, -0.4068181812763214, 0.11995038390159607, -0.1730010062456131, -0.7863515019416809, 0.5871883630752563, 0.6321678161621094, 0.8907895684242249, -1.0273749828338623, 0.14488963782787323, 0.15188780426979065, 0.7620183229446411, 0.477775514125824, 0.14546850323677063, 0.6471933126449585, -0.22165797650814056, 0.040185388177633286, 0.22734208405017853, -0.3480606973171234, -0.08046044409275055, -0.13526763021945953, 0.23817212879657745, -0.18962633609771729, -0.463400661945343, -0.2773338258266449, 0.48401084542274475, 0.7330020070075989, 0.37904438376426697, 0.14295123517513275, 0.863240122795105, -0.7450305223464966, 0.3199050724506378, 0.8333756327629089, 1.3146474361419678, 0.17579519748687744, -1.0286719799041748, 0.17059671878814697, 0.25949621200561523, 0.4440819025039673, -0.19116179645061493, -0.6742419600486755, 0.18038830161094666, -0.5944127440452576, -0.04322383925318718, 0.17666222155094147, -0.40251514315605164, 0.5635682344436646, -0.420999675989151, -0.06811020523309708, 0.24751339852809906, -0.28092458844184875, -0.8089682459831238, -0.07313841581344604, -0.128512904047966, -0.43792036175727844, -0.16301599144935608, -0.32798290252685547, 0.502254068851471, 0.6366338133811951, -0.37633588910102844, -0.6346377730369568, -0.6608526706695557, -0.05943675711750984, -0.6687372326850891, -0.04566221684217453, 0.36689040064811707, -0.6212780475616455, 0.4681984782218933, -0.672141432762146, -0.05073999986052513, -0.322839617729187, 0.2575322389602661, -0.5025902390480042, 0.28067004680633545, 0.09269262105226517, 1.1124173402786255, 0.40316322445869446, 0.697329580783844, 0.38661178946495056, 0.2216878980398178, -0.25200173258781433, 0.858569860458374, -0.5805932283401489, -0.4889470636844635, 0.1222340315580368, 0.04559173434972763, 0.23379682004451752, -0.10996720939874649, -0.035710278898477554, 0.34323808550834656, -0.6351079344749451, 0.44392767548561096, -0.09909763932228088, -0.1414044201374054, 1.1166259050369263, 0.021563595160841942, -0.4725085198879242, 1.8157352209091187, -0.2547420263290405, -0.1328190267086029, -0.45582306385040283, 0.12594233453273773, -0.1913699507713318, 0.4630768895149231, 0.22255054116249084, 0.10275537520647049, -0.27116116881370544, -0.37787777185440063, -0.23083283007144928, -0.9266577959060669, -0.10016623884439468, -0.29348039627075195, -0.2828541696071625, 0.0627325102686882, -0.8569087386131287, -0.000435823283623904, -0.1479731649160385, -0.9737666845321655, 0.2292298525571823, -0.048581454902887344, -0.40761473774909973, -0.6294621825218201, -0.21566781401634216, -1.0373334884643555, -0.2293291985988617, 0.16163739562034607, 0.18295817077159882, -0.27364200353622437, 0.5517789721488953, 0.1518983244895935, -0.3596506416797638, -0.656661868095398, 0.1723899245262146, 0.3142188489437103, -0.8563571572303772, -0.312711238861084, -0.3064025044441223, -0.2384457290172577, -0.35105326771736145, -0.7249504327774048, 0.13686321675777435, 0.15053357183933258, 0.23161038756370544, -0.08148367702960968, -0.18001288175582886, 0.6026862263679504, 0.24325548112392426, -0.08218251168727875, 0.5218199491500854, -0.5419816970825195, -0.8222749829292297, -0.25057464838027954, 0.08959008008241653, -0.338908314704895, 0.9001915454864502, 0.17798088490962982, -0.7092966437339783, -0.32257723808288574, -1.454934000968933, 0.40170034766197205, -0.5578928589820862, -0.15309952199459076, -0.23431041836738586, -1.3164691925048828, -0.25097528100013733, 0.3369779884815216, -0.005053760949522257, -0.43870025873184204, -0.00484547158703208, 0.05368846282362938, 0.10841384530067444, -0.422624409198761, -0.058946799486875534, 0.20664511620998383, 0.11307946592569351, 0.3254392147064209, 0.5535550117492676, -0.2975582182407379, -0.2740725576877594, -0.556823194026947, 0.1572037786245346, 0.7990618944168091, 0.4251050055027008, -0.5095799565315247, -0.5308324098587036, -0.014972735196352005, -0.051461897790431976, -0.4065466523170471, 0.17554043233394623, -0.33534032106399536, -0.03228159248828888, -0.7553622722625732, 0.034627046436071396, -0.8377332091331482, -0.5059999227523804, -0.0011064467253163457, 0.11539691686630249, 1.30402672290802, -1.170849323272705, 0.14832311868667603, 0.07691004127264023, 0.10063239187002182, 0.15059854090213776, 0.12345970422029495, -0.6931483745574951, -0.6043679714202881, -1.072183609008789, -0.32029837369918823, 0.450552761554718, 0.2558908760547638, -0.484896183013916, 0.32976067066192627, -0.6546127796173096, 0.10412605851888657, -0.4406619668006897, 0.9569981694221497, 0.7885651588439941, -0.8513317108154297, -0.6547980308532715, 0.40684396028518677, -0.306693434715271, -0.3462582528591156, 0.7283734679222107, 0.2697080373764038, -0.18306361138820648, -0.1557251662015915, -0.43128442764282227, -0.23438537120819092, -0.588199257850647, 0.6158299446105957, -0.1176021620631218, 0.12061958014965057, 0.1311364322900772, 0.09920860081911087, 0.5305954813957214, -0.26913949847221375, -0.7674686908721924, 0.2866472601890564, -0.325837105512619, 0.14094218611717224, 1.2677322626113892, -0.3686279058456421, 0.03033619560301304, -0.4099142551422119, -0.4768032729625702, 0.025064751505851746, -0.09161898493766785, 0.2669937014579773, -0.12948326766490936, -0.14723896980285645, 0.6694616675376892, 0.2471771240234375, -0.747239887714386, -0.9618661403656006, 0.12569652497768402, -0.10251165926456451, -0.32181957364082336, -0.7871907353401184, 0.24551233649253845, 0.853649914264679, -0.032314483076334, 0.8629429936408997, -0.5270031690597534, -0.5226054787635803, 0.28138649463653564, -0.12981145083904266, 0.4767318069934845, -0.6083554625511169, 0.11743469536304474, 0.365634560585022, -0.1520417034626007, 0.47701308131217957, -0.4864274859428406, -0.704079270362854, 0.5470020771026611, 0.5155127644538879, 0.019256800413131714, -0.5532262325286865, -0.6353282928466797, 0.30493152141571045, 0.3303990960121155, -0.012767963111400604, 0.4573868215084076, 0.2940455377101898, 0.3029419779777527, 0.5793994069099426, -0.9739360213279724, -0.2298622578382492, 0.32073721289634705, 0.1401597559452057, 0.3067808151245117, -0.20780004560947418, 0.14922311902046204, 0.9139545559883118, 0.22092244029045105, 0.22991566359996796, -0.8211990594863892, -0.715018630027771, -0.32814306020736694, -0.12239490449428558, 0.36553990840911865, -0.37512892484664917, 0.05794771760702133, 0.5124626159667969, 0.13638974726200104, -0.9143273234367371, -0.12747232615947723, 1.0024594068527222, 0.26490217447280884, -0.41483092308044434, -1.0936572551727295, 0.6160373687744141, -0.8228030800819397, -0.29632100462913513, -0.7068039178848267, -0.03250684216618538, 0.25144878029823303, 0.9288347959518433, -0.9082713723182678, -0.4370923340320587, -0.2248406559228897, 0.3023407459259033, 0.11638834327459335, 0.11862019449472427, -0.35847875475883484, -0.5911708474159241, 0.48813655972480774, 0.3043822646141052, 0.19404460489749908, 0.009735533967614174, 0.9696634411811829, -0.7767835259437561, 0.7663047909736633, -0.01894538663327694, 0.0658787190914154, -0.27435818314552307, -0.047794368118047714, 0.4971097409725189, -0.6269143223762512, -0.9279891848564148, -0.26531359553337097, 0.6073904633522034, -0.8545670509338379, 0.06400071829557419, -0.018279796466231346, -0.14885778725147247, 0.31755661964416504, 0.12890967726707458, -0.7454096674919128, 1.2552942037582397, -0.8958980441093445, 0.12682844698429108, -0.09682434797286987, 0.579449474811554, 0.1974256932735443, -0.2944904565811157, 0.2545049786567688, 0.45676884055137634, -0.5154986381530762, -1.5630768537521362, 0.5490071773529053, 0.07182973623275757, 0.07025142759084702, 0.03538256138563156, -0.5878276824951172, 0.49781233072280884, -0.15135596692562103, -0.6878063082695007, -0.17903849482536316, 1.1882765293121338, 0.45751073956489563, 0.6853767037391663, 0.13191384077072144, -0.2344251424074173, -0.4360992908477783, -0.07473697513341904, -0.9998422861099243, -0.7209040522575378, 0.6191840767860413, -0.544020414352417, 0.042050931602716446, -0.43290844559669495, -0.08282465487718582, -0.06713289022445679, 0.6839163303375244, 0.11796586960554123, -0.45407137274742126, 1.0379384756088257, 0.03515440970659256, 1.1598466634750366, 0.388021320104599, -0.7208684086799622, 0.2628059685230255, 0.12141567468643188, -0.7114845514297485, -0.5647570490837097, 0.2661633789539337, 0.07467181235551834, 0.5299224853515625, -0.12739145755767822, -0.21622037887573242, 0.6708518862724304, 0.0892336517572403, -0.2685759663581848, -0.23611685633659363, -0.21930454671382904, -0.5598123073577881, 0.40960776805877686, 0.2891916334629059, 0.15143270790576935, -0.4337120056152344, 0.3668566942214966, 0.5170424580574036, -0.6893831491470337, -0.3201446831226349, -0.007454119622707367, 0.30829328298568726, -0.7449283599853516, 0.16011832654476166, 0.3968679904937744, 0.07452090829610825, 0.13724543154239655, -0.6175513863563538, 0.20362639427185059, 0.5051299333572388, 0.5290417075157166, -0.49567270278930664, -0.03816452994942665, 0.3430195748806, 0.8686181306838989, -0.2205207198858261, 0.30115318298339844, 0.8552554249763489, 0.48076900839805603, 0.22524124383926392, 0.4334252178668976, -0.43783923983573914, 0.37885668873786926, -0.7564353942871094, -0.14318974316120148, 0.4993947744369507, 0.7008229494094849, 0.5073454976081848, 0.20919211208820343, -0.5251204967498779, -0.009935787878930569, 0.11814477294683456, -1.1825158596038818, -0.3402155041694641, 0.31390181183815, 0.6732498407363892, 0.08338727056980133, 0.1250215470790863, -0.1304529458284378, 0.663162350654602, 0.7723264098167419, -0.08053717762231827, 0.943425714969635, 0.08253538608551025, -0.21533960103988647, -0.6223383545875549, 0.22119857370853424, -0.4468756318092346, 0.34411680698394775, 0.27255865931510925, -0.18783937394618988, -0.12308693677186966, 0.03364776819944382, -0.031580984592437744, -0.2521805167198181, 0.734565258026123, -0.04434938356280327, -0.09599623084068298, 0.17038480937480927, -0.21045666933059692, -0.36147013306617737, -0.2783103287220001, 0.9927740693092346, 0.3622102737426758, 0.24254104495048523, 0.19851571321487427, 0.7183473110198975, 0.42534467577934265, 0.8008823990821838, 0.31398147344589233, 0.013351960107684135, 0.8846315145492554, 1.0067931413650513, -0.22769184410572052, 0.22954198718070984, 0.14550964534282684, -0.3985500633716583, 0.11586752533912659, -0.26193201541900635, -0.13633018732070923, -0.32169681787490845, -0.025336433202028275, -0.7876344919204712, 0.029321230947971344, -0.9192636609077454, -0.5698210597038269, -0.7757588028907776, -0.324889600276947, -0.5267404913902283, 0.6053565740585327, -0.2275231033563614, 0.42801642417907715, 1.1012613773345947, -0.18225562572479248, -0.3058158755302429, 0.4507904350757599, -0.990815281867981, 0.32739755511283875, -0.7230061888694763, -0.10182160139083862, -0.353284627199173, -0.030619680881500244, -0.7912130951881409, -0.7794719934463501, 0.11636537313461304, -0.05062979832291603, -0.20885656774044037, 0.01085242722183466, 0.45322608947753906, 0.8059567213058472, 0.8063197135925293, -0.13346780836582184, 0.059570103883743286, 0.21984656155109406, 0.28881627321243286, 0.46708402037620544, 0.5741651058197021, 0.6045757532119751, 0.5405259132385254, 0.4057134687900543, -0.08525867760181427, -0.5469033718109131, -0.037284377962350845, -0.10221797227859497, -0.5465276837348938, -0.23648855090141296, -0.010305270552635193, -0.5991746187210083, -1.090710997581482, 0.15285174548625946, 0.6280003786087036, 0.6022471189498901, -0.6583954095840454, -0.6729058623313904, -0.5592356324195862, -0.8399501442909241, 1.0494577884674072, -0.5940813422203064, 0.5652944445610046, 0.48514556884765625, -0.2672673165798187, 0.32114318013191223, -0.22674192488193512, 4.038536071777344, 0.7865149974822998, 0.34007924795150757, -0.5082506537437439, 1.1258511543273926, 0.5831077098846436, 0.5463503003120422, 0.6691809296607971, 0.2924364507198334, 0.018690962344408035, -0.24836598336696625, -0.22372125089168549, -0.4873555898666382, 0.9757965803146362, -0.12092002481222153, -0.017577048391103745, -0.8212099671363831, 0.3945678174495697, -0.4872187376022339, -1.1804659366607666, -0.6252396106719971, 0.17568251490592957, -0.00004845567309530452, 0.6614974141120911, -0.24943360686302185, -0.00641587981954217, 0.6019432544708252, 0.11039254069328308, 0.30975911021232605, -0.18470370769500732, 0.028634803369641304, -0.6888654828071594, -0.23574800789356232, -0.9636997580528259, -0.4445963203907013, 0.23027865588665009, 0.46079036593437195, -0.14209876954555511, -0.19723382592201233, -0.49319514632225037, 0.7694586515426636, 0.2284690886735916, -0.6690143942832947, -0.63824462890625, -0.37264367938041687, 0.14596806466579437, -0.8685002326965332, 0.35608580708503723, 0.36324697732925415, -0.19109846651554108, 1.0705885887145996, -0.6513458490371704, 0.3324059247970581, -0.7610573768615723, -0.39854860305786133, -0.7091577053070068, -0.021637042984366417, -1.0720328092575073, -0.22968553006649017, 0.778657078742981, 1.015954852104187, 0.13629259169101715, -0.15434056520462036, -0.01660003513097763, -0.20725485682487488, 0.6506845355033875, 0.2461216002702713, -0.181207537651062, -0.17576783895492554, 0.43873047828674316, 0.28710412979125977, -0.605336606502533, -0.633959949016571, -0.0993640199303627, 0.5148600339889526, 0.6153807640075684, -0.6616806387901306, 1.1449027061462402, -0.45682409405708313, -0.4151720404624939, 0.4831424355506897, 0.4159736633300781, 1.200104832649231, -0.3946899473667145, -0.5253276228904724, 0.8528477549552917, -1.1320468187332153, 0.028519513085484505, -0.4564528465270996, 0.30227866768836975, 0.2389882206916809, -0.1978481262922287, -0.3138091266155243, -0.1441289633512497, -0.7124812006950378 ]
{"Title": "Generating Evidence for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) Clinical Guidelines Using EHR Data", "Authors": "Johnson Amber M., Bikak Marvi, Griffin Paul M., Adibuzzaman Mohammad", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objectives The aim of this research was to develop data-driven models using electronic health records (EHRs) to conduct clinical studies for predicting clinical outcomes through probabilistic analysis that considers temporal aspects of clinical data. We assess the efficacy of antibiotics treatment and the optimal time of initiation for in-hospitalized diagnosed with acute exacerbation of COPD (AECOPD) as an application to probabilistic modeling. Materials and Methods We developed a semi-automatic Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) modeling and simulation approach that encodes clinical conditions as computable definitions of health states and exact time duration as input for parameter estimations using raw EHR data. We applied the MCMC approach to the MIMIC-III clinical database, where ICD-9 diagnosis codes (491.21, 491.22, and 494.1) were used to identify data for 697 AECOPD patients of which 25.9% were administered antibiotics. Results The average time to antibiotic administration was 27 hours, and 32% of patients were administered vancomycin as the initial antibiotic. The model simulations showed a 50% decrease in mortality rate as the number of patients administered antibiotics increased. There was an estimated 5.5% mortality rate when antibiotics were initially administrated after 48 hours vs 1.8% when antibiotics were initially administrated between 24 and 48 hours. Discussion Our findings suggest that there may be a mortality benefit in initiation of antibiotics early in patient with severe respiratory failure in settings of COPD exacerbations warranting an ICU admission. Conclusion Probabilistic modeling and simulation methods that considers temporal aspects of raw clinical patient data can be used to adequately generate evidence for clinical guidelines.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19006023"}
10.1101/19008367
[ -0.3451472520828247, 0.519324779510498, -0.2919903099536896, 0.15842796862125397, 0.1643650382757187, -0.7649024128913879, -0.2559942603111267, -0.3364577889442444, 0.43934616446495056, 0.47928059101104736, -0.3304993212223053, -0.5698661208152771, -0.19160708785057068, -0.04298887401819229, -0.19862453639507294, -0.09663699567317963, -0.9018257856369019, -0.5171186923980713, -0.016871783882379532, -0.35952940583229065, 0.09420955926179886, 0.7380459308624268, -1.0910881757736206, -0.21226492524147034, -0.14092087745666504, 0.6239073872566223, 0.6583330035209656, 0.05175161361694336, 1.0645947456359863, 0.41258716583251953, 0.12814511358737946, -0.21875178813934326, 0.17845700681209564, -0.5662056803703308, -0.2522891163825989, 0.21991018950939178, 0.501112163066864, -0.47107571363449097, -0.13581284880638123, -0.570318341255188, 0.2986665368080139, 0.32006484270095825, 0.7584716081619263, -1.2988110780715942, -0.514299213886261, -0.46514347195625305, 0.22925421595573425, 0.34961187839508057, -0.197291761636734, 0.20912952721118927, -0.122721366584301, 0.1652132123708725, 0.1626940369606018, 0.0014635482802987099, 0.21787682175636292, -0.5023587942123413, 0.8499169945716858, -0.045916005969047546, -0.9131770133972168, -0.15679703652858734, 0.09800112992525101, -0.07621573656797409, 0.667110800743103, -0.9931203126907349, 0.5580031275749207, 0.544269323348999, -0.14340046048164368, -0.16846254467964172, -0.3682518005371094, -0.28089359402656555, -0.4474257230758667, 0.465785413980484, -0.3536049425601959, -0.5365132093429565, -0.32874152064323425, -0.6686650514602661, 0.08342814445495605, 0.10353478044271469, 0.16102634370326996, 0.31287238001823425, -0.3032492995262146, 0.3581688404083252, 0.11378544569015503, 0.4087843894958496, 0.4684237837791443, -0.27314409613609314, 0.7679404616355896, 0.5248052477836609, -0.0621400848031044, 0.1464092880487442, -0.04645327851176262, 0.4414913058280945, 0.17463575303554535, 0.49291104078292847, 0.3781232237815857, 0.9667413830757141, -0.21251700818538666, 0.3874783217906952, 0.32761114835739136, -0.17492079734802246, 1.0295473337173462, 0.5928437113761902, 0.3625991642475128, 1.1146820783615112, -0.5810887217521667, 1.047560214996338, 0.3292582929134369, -0.478361040353775, -0.47365477681159973, -0.7983860373497009, 0.17657996714115143, -0.11084739863872528, -0.3326103091239929, -0.35043594241142273, -0.17765426635742188, 0.5301628112792969, -0.22921589016914368, 1.3014603853225708, -0.8327534794807434, 0.22864076495170593, -0.7914347052574158, 0.008163508959114552, 1.1350524425506592, -0.5884144306182861, 0.50956791639328, 0.34079185128211975, 0.037859149277210236, 0.7430104613304138, -0.2790711224079132, 0.06842031329870224, -0.4173057973384857, -0.41567307710647583, -0.21598169207572937, 0.887904167175293, -0.1614203304052353, -0.30375567078590393, 0.1447940319776535, 0.7251195907592773, 0.27535009384155273, -0.5810824036598206, -0.6341617107391357, 0.309414803981781, -0.5678651928901672, 1.1080783605575562, -0.8354249596595764, 0.45857977867126465, -0.11348805576562881, -1.470322608947754, -0.09208082407712936, -0.8022492527961731, -0.1062694638967514, 0.5995954275131226, -0.01660488359630108, 0.06852702051401138, -0.5045110583305359, 0.6685056686401367, -0.326084166765213, -0.46435731649398804, -0.3842819035053253, -0.14380086958408356, -0.19969874620437622, 0.45498326420783997, -0.26035276055336, 0.1324032098054886, -0.6548047065734863, -0.11461766064167023, -0.10168137401342392, 0.2886897921562195, 0.16975317895412445, -0.5226567983627319, 0.6594396233558655, -0.24272006750106812, -0.1648767739534378, 0.32733044028282166, 0.00689760921522975, 0.8320075869560242, 0.9867798686027527, 0.24423253536224365, 0.4172597825527191, 0.08618663251399994, -0.2268800437450409, -0.5179749727249146, 0.3991013467311859, 0.14253586530685425, -0.23344245553016663, 0.24607455730438232, -0.5358665585517883, -0.3024393618106842, 0.050262995064258575, -0.17497363686561584, 0.13847027719020844, 0.2628106474876404, -0.8939815759658813, 0.5193037390708923, -0.35991135239601135, 0.11841346323490143, -0.3321629762649536, 0.6329951286315918, -0.2037920355796814, -0.3761448562145233, -0.941938042640686, 0.49411916732788086, -0.10664376616477966, 0.08043263852596283, -0.25647401809692383, 0.5376890897750854, 0.0926475077867508, -0.057183459401130676, -1.3636285066604614, -0.06970226019620895, 0.18217042088508606, 0.3621048033237457, -0.4451148808002472, 0.0553835853934288, 0.8757714629173279, -0.30361610651016235, -0.2817491888999939, 0.21087469160556793, -0.3351884186267853, 0.05084691941738129, -0.32205304503440857, -0.5944186449050903, 0.4065629541873932, 0.055114779621362686, -0.16045141220092773, 0.0825641080737114, 0.8731978535652161, 0.679643988609314, 0.030349258333444595, -0.21472814679145813, 0.6546850204467773, 0.4998316764831543, -0.6427746415138245, 0.6062612533569336, 0.690895140171051, 0.49940869212150574, -0.13273262977600098, 0.23611176013946533, 0.19965578615665436, 0.3535761833190918, 0.3955352008342743, -0.20354798436164856, 1.396225929260254, 0.5593850016593933, -0.4643424153327942, 0.7895874381065369, -0.0914916843175888, 0.029062025249004364, -0.19209475815296173, 0.22045952081680298, -0.5711905360221863, 0.7771768569946289, 0.2639615833759308, 0.6265169978141785, -0.7708817720413208, -0.13554033637046814, 0.22781944274902344, 0.631777822971344, -0.22414253652095795, -0.6227537393569946, -0.15774640440940857, 0.08538395911455154, -0.07454784959554672, -0.5580608248710632, 0.5787960290908813, 1.3770030736923218, 0.8083860874176025, 0.43217310309410095, -0.36455243825912476, -0.8757501244544983, -1.0959008932113647, -0.9698079228401184, -1.2889492511749268, -0.27611032128334045, -0.8059666156768799, -0.16501745581626892, -0.4269230365753174, -0.9338876008987427, 0.6171683669090271, -0.2721808850765228, 0.2372046858072281, 0.0017117062816396356, 0.30605658888816833, 0.39736419916152954, 0.600119948387146, -0.11807633191347122, -0.4561466872692108, 1.024237871170044, -0.0942363515496254, 0.7064372897148132, -0.23855438828468323, -0.1550293266773224, -0.381112664937973, -1.1273850202560425, 0.4196510910987854, -1.039644718170166, 0.43328168988227844, 0.41682761907577515, -0.5712530612945557, 0.09648582339286804, -0.07269377261400223, 0.05134155973792076, -0.20371131598949432, -0.24576133489608765, -1.3617342710494995, 0.46217676997184753, 0.26798540353775024, -0.13458895683288574, 0.5285220742225647, 0.4809873402118683, -0.6316642165184021, 1.0957262516021729, -0.18882247805595398, -0.6359926462173462, -0.9105657935142517, -0.23934818804264069, -0.33040541410446167, -0.6455963850021362, 0.06844783574342728, -1.217671513557434, -0.9981523156166077, -0.3161638379096985, -0.42394760251045227, -0.15493491291999817, -0.17965160310268402, 0.09843029081821442, -0.3525601625442505, -0.5255132913589478, -0.13696575164794922, -1.0142990350723267, -1.0046597719192505, 0.0691998153924942, 0.0698351114988327, 0.7384189963340759, 0.7148580551147461, 0.07366625219583511, -0.6045525074005127, -0.36044877767562866, 0.5485348105430603, 0.6219589710235596, 0.2812311053276062, -0.4362691342830658, 0.09737551957368851, 0.4558488726615906, 0.21202948689460754, 0.44712501764297485, -0.030488159507513046, -0.02677498199045658, -0.2811266779899597, 0.14691631495952606, 0.034375693649053574, 0.1705024391412735, 0.5152325630187988, -0.20202460885047913, -0.08559812605381012, 0.4110647141933441, -0.25981956720352173, -0.5017042756080627, 1.0321494340896606, -0.04825271666049957, -0.38951075077056885, 0.06465566903352737, -0.008521652780473232, 0.668217122554779, -0.7167551517486572, -0.6626520156860352, 0.3345417082309723, -0.3727208375930786, 0.04545571282505989, -1.0903164148330688, 0.2877480983734131, -0.7697259187698364, -0.11280888319015503, 0.37861326336860657, -0.06449490040540695, -0.602573573589325, 1.0689889192581177, -0.11711716651916504, 1.6981595754623413, -0.967687726020813, 0.5277508497238159, 0.39161694049835205, 0.8066970109939575, 0.2846933603286743, 0.23461967706680298, 0.281849205493927, -0.6807230710983276, 0.6889230608940125, 0.2943934202194214, -0.14724284410476685, -0.23933355510234833, 0.2840382158756256, -0.1634535938501358, 0.13936278223991394, -0.3989368975162506, -1.160101294517517, -0.1370508074760437, 0.17479071021080017, 0.37441056966781616, -0.49416735768318176, 1.5846056938171387, -1.2677778005599976, 0.04762636497616768, 0.42794206738471985, 0.7572961449623108, 0.3452188968658447, -1.0441526174545288, 0.1621760129928589, -0.5068828463554382, -0.2502281963825226, 0.4008970260620117, -0.3530864715576172, 0.08120781928300858, -0.14291056990623474, 0.664298415184021, -0.1614564210176468, -0.4302157163619995, -0.6564894318580627, -0.9226957559585571, 0.6005035042762756, 0.11962854117155075, 0.24631892144680023, -0.6660685539245605, -0.21260260045528412, 0.060862455517053604, -0.4473375380039215, -0.023145606741309166, -0.7872307300567627, 0.9643062949180603, 0.7610015273094177, -0.4257219135761261, -0.5840561985969543, -0.1694226861000061, -0.1424693763256073, 0.6955345273017883, -0.4979988634586334, 0.8339347839355469, -0.26567402482032776, 0.281638503074646, -0.5607849359512329, -0.5809146165847778, -0.2218233197927475, 0.018267717212438583, -0.22594082355499268, 0.21380454301834106, -0.07246866822242737, 0.7181634306907654, 0.7938258051872253, 0.024673545733094215, -0.6183609366416931, 0.5325537919998169, -1.0056949853897095, 0.7489311099052429, -0.5617122054100037, -0.10555274784564972, -0.40841978788375854, 0.2267492562532425, -0.14587971568107605, -0.5977104306221008, -0.36773616075515747, -0.30689477920532227, 0.25844287872314453, 0.6078734993934631, -0.015460214577615261, -0.6544811725616455, 0.7501286268234253, -0.5298659801483154, 0.32692191004753113, 0.7091789245605469, -0.14222437143325806, -0.24846094846725464, -0.5630874633789062, -0.18033744394779205, -0.70433509349823, 0.7342863082885742, 0.9624524116516113, 0.21300268173217773, -0.4532909393310547, -0.7070006132125854, -0.27077674865722656, -0.6432825326919556, -0.3019446134567261, -0.734215259552002, -0.357719749212265, -0.7335055470466614, -0.2547387182712555, -0.8031362891197205, -0.4257056415081024, -0.44135013222694397, 0.6973555088043213, -0.039297424256801605, -0.3279455304145813, -0.16515646874904633, -0.011058162897825241, -0.4964655041694641, -0.02147265337407589, -0.7706747651100159, -0.16183750331401825, -0.04030803218483925, 0.22733712196350098, 1.2273176908493042, -0.5310352444648743, -0.12259488552808762, 0.4787541925907135, 1.0447814464569092, -0.40190526843070984, -0.560279905796051, -0.05984899029135704, -0.932718813419342, -0.7390190958976746, -0.1331086903810501, 0.3670929968357086, -0.28974011540412903, -0.09217497706413269, -0.37565523386001587, -0.41023316979408264, 0.45018553733825684, 0.27303463220596313, -0.5886343717575073, 0.5826874375343323, 0.02114333026111126, -0.7256345748901367, -0.5098646283149719, 0.7638529539108276, 0.011916960589587688, 0.16351249814033508, 0.18673573434352875, -0.9112105965614319, -0.5987350940704346, -0.8665489554405212, 0.16512838006019592, -0.6744362711906433, -0.03298579156398773, -0.09947169572114944, 0.11612693220376968, 0.08558972179889679, 0.49381911754608154, 0.5214477777481079, -0.2816147804260254, -0.414749413728714, 0.030823230743408203, 0.07029101252555847, -0.6274789571762085, -0.4126737117767334, 0.14893807470798492, -0.47943973541259766, 0.3879472613334656, 0.8725528120994568, 0.4963984191417694, -0.6510301232337952, 0.014333166182041168, 0.2072756290435791, 0.27517426013946533, 0.878961443901062, -1.068954348564148, -0.41039273142814636, -0.12297067046165466, 0.4025368392467499, 0.029296301305294037, -0.4442421495914459, -0.24660059809684753, 0.2599833309650421, -0.6137030720710754, -0.33125630021095276, -0.2560485303401947, -0.6540727615356445, 0.33320024609565735, -0.11025463044643402, 0.8585900068283081, -0.4428195357322693, 0.7231481671333313, -0.17513686418533325, 0.041288767009973526, 0.24796126782894135, 0.31755879521369934, -1.1721251010894775, -0.42809149622917175, -0.5964241027832031, -0.42602232098579407, 0.028423961251974106, -0.1988564431667328, 0.08761484920978546, 0.36527714133262634, -0.25966835021972656, -0.1656474769115448, -0.3697223663330078, 0.7996249198913574, 0.8416962623596191, -0.12163841724395752, -0.26487594842910767, 0.5111388564109802, 0.01742268167436123, -0.4468632638454437, 0.2787112891674042, 0.11442956328392029, -0.21769391000270844, 0.5104913711547852, -0.4321395456790924, -0.3889515995979309, -0.6569974422454834, -0.30071309208869934, 0.050917644053697586, 0.6834846138954163, -0.262652188539505, 0.738865852355957, 0.774238646030426, -0.04421114921569824, -0.8068583607673645, 0.04584541916847229, -0.577165424823761, 0.21821723878383636, 1.4147824048995972, 0.17613454163074493, -0.42087021470069885, 0.1046781986951828, -0.2546539306640625, -0.15792983770370483, -0.26685255765914917, 0.26551273465156555, -0.22085310518741608, -0.6769354343414307, -0.2652299702167511, 0.7889365553855896, -0.1407301276922226, -0.5178887248039246, 0.5150548815727234, -0.42411482334136963, 0.39869004487991333, -0.33169394731521606, -0.40463295578956604, 0.6258847117424011, -0.13227640092372894, 0.25672054290771484, 0.27009356021881104, 0.12216241657733917, 0.1930084526538849, 0.30635008215904236, 0.5434333086013794, -0.6108086705207825, 0.3596091568470001, 0.9118185043334961, -0.37081053853034973, 0.04077795520424843, -0.13650986552238464, 0.3148815333843231, -0.2955690324306488, -0.1905442476272583, 0.38168299198150635, 0.30209118127822876, 0.18287934362888336, 0.6977745294570923, 0.3364059627056122, -0.08328557014465332, -0.3935234844684601, -0.5192094445228577, 0.7555525302886963, 0.17164401710033417, -1.410636305809021, -0.7565889358520508, 0.2955660820007324, 0.40755409002304077, 0.06946028769016266, 0.5687474608421326, 0.2812177538871765, 1.0666416883468628, 0.7742061018943787, 0.48368555307388306, -0.3692172169685364, -0.10999477654695511, -0.7190825343132019, -0.49290910363197327, 0.6297106146812439, -0.49570217728614807, -0.3994838297367096, 0.14731541275978088, 0.16591677069664001, -0.31362423300743103, 0.28046268224716187, 1.2353712320327759, -0.790560781955719, -0.7784642577171326, -0.7415220141410828, 0.2573105990886688, -0.7345362901687622, -0.36517783999443054, 0.09045600146055222, -0.2896727919578552, 0.4952259063720703, 0.8750671148300171, -0.47133225202560425, -0.018833976238965988, -0.16117510199546814, 0.6387248039245605, -0.2475263774394989, 0.12285685539245605, -0.7001262307167053, -0.38707607984542847, 0.22962984442710876, 0.35697638988494873, 0.6004412770271301, -1.0124895572662354, 0.7630112171173096, -0.5799652338027954, 0.5221967697143555, 0.31748342514038086, 1.0577070713043213, -0.620727002620697, 0.33312880992889404, 0.3545265197753906, -0.4064685106277466, 0.006719569675624371, -0.17862659692764282, 1.6892647743225098, -0.9459556341171265, -0.5187261700630188, -0.22423073649406433, 0.3048865795135498, 0.19848306477069855, -0.24834099411964417, 0.33799487352371216, 0.3209214508533478, 0.6280773282051086, 0.02213248610496521, 0.0644170492887497, 0.4778820276260376, 0.5126134157180786, 0.04889528825879097, 0.5459059476852417, 0.023453235626220703, -0.2320452779531479, -1.180100440979004, 0.3780648410320282, 0.15734562277793884, -0.4358293116092682, 0.2755519151687622, -0.10504660755395889, 0.31447723507881165, -0.020911406725645065, 0.006098110228776932, 0.7167249917984009, 0.5127944946289062, -0.08202411234378815, 0.02790249139070511, 0.16747748851776123, -0.26422011852264404, -0.2355235069990158, 0.19620564579963684, -0.9638751149177551, -0.6396816372871399, 0.8824808597564697, -0.3740653693675995, -0.29117876291275024, -0.6318249702453613, -0.5911998152732849, 0.5419467091560364, 0.47375813126564026, 0.35009586811065674, 0.21964386105537415, 0.8528696894645691, 0.19908592104911804, 0.695918619632721, 0.4403083920478821, 0.06143469363451004, -0.15258339047431946, 0.211406871676445, -0.35278385877609253, -0.5391661524772644, 0.14678558707237244, 0.28970569372177124, 0.017135221511125565, -0.2131403535604477, -0.4589743912220001, 0.3199896812438965, -0.022458719089627266, -0.39275234937667847, -0.3618212938308716, -0.008859367109835148, -0.7370572686195374, 0.10156704485416412, -0.414909303188324, 0.5419204831123352, 0.2266812026500702, 0.5246910452842712, 0.3255888819694519, -0.5018424391746521, -0.7120697498321533, -0.08997399359941483, 0.5419551730155945, -0.4730195701122284, 0.2744349241256714, 0.09322869032621384, 0.5444228649139404, -0.37373003363609314, 0.054815612733364105, 0.9673477411270142, 0.7173280119895935, -0.225427508354187, -0.15836629271507263, -0.6380128264427185, 0.6203245520591736, 0.8396608829498291, 0.23084735870361328, -0.011090696789324284, 0.43950632214546204, 0.21109507977962494, 0.37402111291885376, 0.007893575355410576, -0.3361716866493225, 0.7674931883811951, -0.20072536170482635, -0.4038735032081604, -0.10667096823453903, 0.5025272369384766, -0.13131356239318848, -0.14250899851322174, -0.8247698545455933, 0.6491612195968628, -0.26629015803337097, -0.7614789009094238, -0.07556161284446716, 0.7018386125564575, 0.8803451657295227, -0.5020291805267334, 0.5630794763565063, -0.2112131118774414, 0.7138417363166809, 0.5544794797897339, 0.8462690114974976, 0.6661853194236755, -0.33654800057411194, -0.1771475225687027, 0.009021502919495106, 0.6003037691116333, -0.618983268737793, 0.07893668115139008, 0.39312252402305603, -0.14089594781398773, -0.4813333749771118, 0.7762767672538757, 0.5832860469818115, -0.39582252502441406, 0.7127231359481812, -0.8802579641342163, -0.37547147274017334, 0.012663112953305244, 0.18396350741386414, -0.8267084956169128, -0.26988276839256287, 1.1183228492736816, -0.606738269329071, 0.42081090807914734, 0.5956106781959534, 0.18218396604061127, 0.3225291073322296, 0.7399733662605286, -0.01878032647073269, 0.16357213258743286, 1.2737349271774292, 1.1499613523483276, 0.19887319207191467, -0.0531628243625164, 0.14971034228801727, -0.3906608521938324, -0.17627765238285065, 0.010880560614168644, 0.1755182296037674, -0.09326037019491196, -0.5777428150177002, -0.6703519821166992, -0.6716741323471069, -0.621053159236908, -0.5357781648635864, -0.543469250202179, -0.36030903458595276, -0.1547282189130783, -0.566922664642334, -0.23652149736881256, 0.3302249610424042, 0.2608429491519928, 0.3477593958377838, 0.247136652469635, 0.36031049489974976, -0.8884407877922058, 0.16850998997688293, -0.4413142204284668, 0.7849113941192627, -0.0007913979352451861, -0.6538745760917664, 0.1814708262681961, -1.0667062997817993, -0.537229597568512, -0.5279858112335205, 0.32202649116516113, -0.6055459380149841, -0.37256696820259094, 0.527738094329834, -0.06741321831941605, -0.024476533755660057, -0.32914188504219055, -0.1359349936246872, 0.396104633808136, 1.0045512914657593, -0.6732475161552429, 1.0399792194366455, 0.10286235064268112, -0.14352935552597046, 0.07510986179113388, 0.19821444153785706, 0.11854875087738037, -0.030504135414958, -0.07056095451116562, -0.33930471539497375, 0.4940794110298157, 0.09326652437448502, -0.45483502745628357, 0.31976521015167236, 0.6930869221687317, 0.21354089677333832, -0.5917088389396667, -1.0972044467926025, 0.6680963635444641, -1.2172420024871826, 1.1896370649337769, 0.11280103772878647, 0.3504362106323242, -0.17334957420825958, -0.1730201095342636, 0.3284800350666046, -0.653615415096283, 4.040408134460449, 1.3387891054153442, 0.5777628421783447, 0.26537129282951355, 0.8788076639175415, 1.3134065866470337, 0.9184581637382507, -0.0593457855284214, 0.3160438537597656, 0.12142755836248398, -0.44874003529548645, 0.12637141346931458, 0.08566630631685257, 0.07509418576955795, -0.19318003952503204, 0.1249573677778244, -1.2083606719970703, -0.15936079621315002, -0.34576982259750366, -0.9958351254463196, -1.436882734298706, 0.9369814395904541, 0.2852860689163208, -0.08618625998497009, 0.06577987968921661, -0.42290356755256653, 0.009458998218178749, 0.28399866819381714, -0.31029197573661804, -0.360053688287735, -0.36804449558258057, -0.32659468054771423, 0.42006024718284607, -0.3224394619464874, 0.3788955807685852, 0.17360258102416992, 0.24575157463550568, -0.2201763391494751, 0.18086466193199158, -0.030900681391358376, -0.06091718748211861, -0.607154369354248, 0.13372507691383362, -0.3798927366733551, -0.28971582651138306, -0.4341204762458801, -0.6670501828193665, 0.06021847575902939, 0.089762844145298, -0.5610818266868591, 0.8527613878250122, -1.5709929466247559, 0.523414671421051, 0.017418580129742622, -1.0769391059875488, -0.1384841948747635, -0.8389008045196533, -0.9507901072502136, -0.08608517050743103, 0.7228423357009888, 0.5829365253448486, 0.4706965982913971, -0.6416928768157959, 0.2969290018081665, 0.3903632164001465, 0.427486389875412, 0.048368994146585464, -0.017601042985916138, 0.13877230882644653, 0.41069504618644714, -0.054704390466213226, 0.28529268503189087, -0.9375405311584473, -0.006583160720765591, 0.346214234828949, -0.18335780501365662, -0.44691044092178345, 0.6392731666564941, -0.4361645579338074, -0.8574760556221008, -0.024360384792089462, 0.4514482319355011, 0.6237623691558838, -0.05043305829167366, 0.4636196196079254, 0.5176429748535156, -0.7427820563316345, -0.45976522564888, -0.6826142072677612, 0.7322360873222351, 0.8413054347038269, -0.3625537157058716, 0.430916428565979, 0.3114972412586212, -0.28443458676338196 ]
{"Title": "Identification of newborns at risk for autism using electronic medical records and machine learning", "Authors": "Rahman Rayees, Kodesh Arad, Levine Stephen Z, Sandin Sven, Reichenberg Abraham, Schlessinger Avner", "Abstract": "Abstract Importance Current approaches for early identification of individuals at high risk for autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in the general population are limited, where most ASD patients are not identified until after the age of 4. This is despite substantial evidence suggesting that early diagnosis and intervention improves developmental course and outcome. Objective Develop a machine learning (ML) method predicting the diagnosis of ASD in offspring in a general population sample, using parental electronic medical records (EMR) available before childbirth Design Prognostic study of EMR data within a single Israeli health maintenance organization, for the parents of 1,397 ASD children (ICD-9/10), and 94,741 non-ASD children born between January 1st, 1997 through December 31st, 2008. The complete EMR record of the parents was used to develop various ML models to predict the risk of having a child with ASD. Main outcomes and measures Routinely available parental sociodemographic information, medical histories and prescribed medications data until offspring\u2019s birth were used to generate features to train various machine learning algorithms, including multivariate logistic regression, artificial neural networks, and random forest. Prediction performance was evaluated with 10-fold cross validation, by computing C statistics, sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, false positive rate, and precision (positive predictive value, PPV). Results All ML models tested had similar performance, achieving an average C statistics of 0.70, sensitivity of 28.63%, specificity of 98.62%, accuracy of 96.05%, false positive rate of 1.37%, and positive predictive value of 45.85% for predicting ASD in this dataset. Conclusion and relevance ML algorithms combined with EMR capture early life ASD risk. Such approaches may be able to enhance the ability for accurate and efficient early detection of ASD in large populations of children. Key points Question Can autism risk in children be predicted using the pre-birth electronic medical record (EMR) of the parents? Findings In this population-based study that included 1,397 children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and 94,741 non-ASD children, we developed a machine learning classifier for predicting the likelihood of childhood diagnosis of ASD with an average C statistic of 0.70, sensitivity of 28.63%, specificity of 98.62%, accuracy of 96.05%, false positive rate of 1.37%, and positive predictive value of 45.85%. Meaning The results presented serve as a proof-of-principle of the potential utility of EMR for the identification of a large proportion of future children at a high-risk of ASD.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008367"}
10.1101/2019.12.11.19014431
[ -0.07306299358606339, 0.6698037385940552, -0.16967400908470154, 0.9578392505645752, -0.28495118021965027, 0.33564913272857666, 0.2682008147239685, 0.40203532576560974, 0.3127981126308441, 0.4834291934967041, -0.04505951330065727, -0.7515774965286255, 0.04327990859746933, -0.3517594039440155, -0.4140373766422272, 0.520878255367279, -0.1924796998500824, -0.12080173939466476, -0.4045381247997284, 0.012936863116919994, 0.27053266763687134, 0.7514367699623108, -1.1450209617614746, 0.10584922134876251, -0.5739184617996216, 0.12074805796146393, 0.18937525153160095, -0.49179309606552124, 1.1172447204589844, 0.7864649295806885, -0.00604894757270813, -0.060621388256549835, 0.8827617168426514, -1.0720582008361816, -0.3433057963848114, 0.2611693739891052, 0.6019322872161865, -0.05924706906080246, 0.25664153695106506, -0.0017571855569258332, 0.8976302146911621, -0.039302144199609756, 0.35435545444488525, -0.11805897206068039, 0.10955466330051422, -0.18845121562480927, -0.32893621921539307, -0.36649832129478455, 0.3863665461540222, 0.27365031838417053, 0.0018059385474771261, 0.10339762270450592, 0.36129051446914673, 0.4539506435394287, 0.3309069275856018, 0.39953747391700745, -0.290424644947052, 0.5529336929321289, -0.6500882506370544, 0.4380834400653839, 0.4067966043949127, 0.43171805143356323, 0.564813494682312, -1.3479397296905518, 0.8102288246154785, 0.915848433971405, 0.04729030281305313, -0.2609908878803253, -0.25763121247291565, -0.02465992420911789, 0.08235114067792892, 0.03367115184664726, -0.7365053296089172, -0.1340460479259491, -0.40665045380592346, 0.11588053405284882, -0.3223738670349121, 0.2839024066925049, -0.15890692174434662, 0.15046565234661102, 0.4028559625148773, 0.334867388010025, 0.45591944456100464, 0.7841479778289795, -0.7829540371894836, 0.06570162624120712, 0.1746050864458084, 0.884671151638031, 0.06617796421051025, 0.27920764684677124, -0.09318003058433533, 0.6086872816085815, 0.3624921441078186, 0.35158970952033997, 0.0796513482928276, 1.037763237953186, -0.32426291704177856, 0.17311131954193115, -0.03544064611196518, -1.005128026008606, 1.0070581436157227, 0.1425059288740158, -0.24086757004261017, 0.47078457474708557, -0.7361065149307251, 1.21097731590271, 0.17896626889705658, -0.30310139060020447, -0.797994077205658, -0.33123502135276794, 0.2984122931957245, 0.1507597118616104, -0.40909963846206665, -0.5878968834877014, 1.0923423767089844, 0.656233012676239, -0.6371031403541565, 1.0348941087722778, -0.6805593967437744, -0.44090956449508667, -0.30025649070739746, 0.3461935520172119, 0.007814368233084679, -0.10875055938959122, -0.13948053121566772, 0.06705544888973236, -0.6644312739372253, 0.2753092050552368, -0.36114972829818726, 0.5142720341682434, -0.6269610524177551, -0.18498431146144867, -0.2225327044725418, 0.10582926869392395, -0.3595605492591858, 0.3090225160121918, 0.3199980556964874, 1.3290826082229614, -0.09342512488365173, -0.8789510130882263, 0.08816012740135193, 0.8587659597396851, -0.7108184099197388, 0.871434211730957, -0.5214905142784119, 0.9806975722312927, -1.2672345638275146, -1.5361032485961914, -0.7773703336715698, 0.15889346599578857, 0.10916741192340851, 0.774831235408783, -0.0008047627052292228, -0.6304593086242676, 0.138985738158226, 1.0487531423568726, -0.07131673395633698, 0.26403194665908813, 0.3625207841396332, -0.7452998161315918, -0.5779196619987488, -0.14614582061767578, -0.46454691886901855, 0.690678596496582, -0.8914098739624023, 0.9482787251472473, -0.08279022574424744, 0.2646542489528656, 0.2925654351711273, -0.551957368850708, 0.32730579376220703, -0.09381606429815292, -0.256716251373291, -0.1173236072063446, -0.03883998095989227, 0.9290832877159119, 0.28343647718429565, -0.4802592992782593, 0.5248191356658936, 0.4604429304599762, -0.039190828800201416, 0.017385894432663918, 0.17485590279102325, 0.6559575200080872, -0.6637898087501526, 0.006295099854469299, -0.6013504862785339, -0.4194503426551819, -0.2285369336605072, -0.4196195602416992, -0.16428567469120026, 0.26632434129714966, -0.41829466819763184, 0.627795398235321, -0.04281480610370636, -0.2178715616464615, -0.15423105657100677, 0.25958824157714844, -0.22128181159496307, -0.42350462079048157, -0.6303122043609619, 1.6456892490386963, 0.47618335485458374, -0.07960010319948196, -0.4103149175643921, 1.1985822916030884, 0.05486033111810684, 0.3791528046131134, -1.0680843591690063, 0.4970201253890991, 1.1842291355133057, 0.03252192959189415, -0.006157747935503721, 0.3519774079322815, 0.044287312775850296, -0.30073457956314087, -0.119820736348629, 0.5048848986625671, -0.8278158903121948, -0.23998233675956726, -0.3841797113418579, -0.2566237151622772, 0.5435072183609009, -0.13158024847507477, 0.3152233064174652, 0.44804856181144714, 0.9081640839576721, 0.9064420461654663, -0.27795881032943726, -0.08145350962877274, 0.3469710052013397, 0.4387701451778412, 0.2792101502418518, 0.9719259738922119, 0.6732122898101807, 0.5736687779426575, 0.44700321555137634, 0.23171453177928925, 0.1527584344148636, 0.3222538232803345, 0.8011632561683655, 0.10910753160715103, 0.5783441662788391, 0.033722661435604095, 0.17295391857624054, 0.253557413816452, -0.23503857851028442, 0.6512874960899353, 0.15090309083461761, 0.6435413956642151, -0.7165660262107849, 0.18452231585979462, 0.2619364559650421, 0.502141535282135, -0.6513187289237976, -0.08524002134799957, -0.025104502215981483, 0.06325642019510269, -0.02263895608484745, -0.4903288781642914, -0.19210754334926605, 0.4921600818634033, -0.34780871868133545, -0.06214738264679909, 0.48686841130256653, 1.2959293127059937, 0.30258291959762573, 0.5140515565872192, 0.5181822180747986, 0.08994562923908234, -0.8677329421043396, -0.810232937335968, -1.5017807483673096, -0.8391373753547668, -1.2392568588256836, -0.05521669238805771, -0.4805256724357605, -0.5685914754867554, 0.04016326367855072, 0.5677928924560547, 0.20063459873199463, -0.0657203420996666, 0.10776498913764954, 0.9893296360969543, 0.8616411685943604, -0.01844751462340355, -0.5876257419586182, 0.6207992434501648, -0.6604106426239014, -0.33591946959495544, 0.041949424892663956, -0.3727937340736389, -0.38608232140541077, -1.0578315258026123, 0.9282064437866211, -0.9385761022567749, -0.5344117879867554, 0.04519535228610039, 0.6813304424285889, -0.08857966959476471, 0.6004310250282288, 0.4850521385669708, 0.6864235401153564, 0.4467732310295105, -0.9619724750518799, 0.5560548305511475, 0.34133896231651306, 0.20605620741844177, 0.3660886585712433, 0.36377838253974915, -0.006006763782352209, 0.8382366895675659, -0.21015433967113495, 0.12355952709913254, -0.6834985017776489, -0.253172904253006, 0.6001904606819153, 0.22667600214481354, 0.12880849838256836, -0.16216078400611877, -1.0449869632720947, -0.41863733530044556, -0.2810349464416504, -0.1922939270734787, 0.14819841086864471, -0.06833574175834656, 0.06604990363121033, -1.32917058467865, 0.5499023795127869, -0.5618780255317688, -1.0002065896987915, -0.10266091674566269, -0.22806161642074585, 0.47130924463272095, -0.06860435009002686, -0.00665220245718956, -0.09990818053483963, 0.34200170636177063, 0.04913845658302307, 0.6336700916290283, 0.049072738736867905, 0.3442462086677551, 0.38427671790122986, 0.5572723150253296, -0.15938200056552887, 0.7398843169212341, 0.19269666075706482, 0.04880014806985855, -0.07186107337474823, 0.1371201127767563, 0.09726138412952423, 0.24214811623096466, 0.8250105381011963, 0.3337481617927551, -0.23052199184894562, 0.577597439289093, 0.36784932017326355, 0.4306456744670868, 0.8506708741188049, 0.058904048055410385, 0.06483245640993118, -0.1899888813495636, -0.08584176748991013, 0.05659256502985954, -0.7224975228309631, -0.10424888879060745, 0.6488511562347412, 0.15202213823795319, 0.2048826515674591, -0.6959649920463562, 1.0851881504058838, 0.36707863211631775, -0.6243399381637573, 0.2912721633911133, 0.34180036187171936, -0.16721205413341522, 1.029903769493103, 0.8421921730041504, 1.2579972743988037, -1.7327885627746582, 0.3218061029911041, 0.504918098449707, 0.9854291081428528, 0.1780569702386856, 0.22327934205532074, 0.3393247425556183, -0.6621125340461731, 1.0086969137191772, -0.15148717164993286, -0.47692474722862244, 0.2627957761287689, 0.3428228795528412, 0.6686186790466309, 0.03670118749141693, -1.1153316497802734, -0.5803438425064087, -0.18963952362537384, 0.5368537306785583, -0.07888863980770111, -0.18881464004516602, 0.734209418296814, -0.7149941325187683, 0.26403936743736267, 0.10118557512760162, 0.9178900718688965, 0.4256962835788727, -0.7652808427810669, -0.09414972364902496, 0.29307103157043457, -0.9516928195953369, 0.4475835859775543, -0.716786801815033, -0.3164263069629669, -0.32816454768180847, 0.22131642699241638, -0.07499285042285919, -0.7945683598518372, 0.04876763001084328, -0.6732323169708252, 0.5105981826782227, 0.239537313580513, 0.039137765765190125, -0.504767119884491, 0.05158698931336403, 0.04870707541704178, -0.6631567478179932, -0.5305935740470886, -0.578923225402832, 0.007033227477222681, 0.929648220539093, -0.3710671067237854, -1.1781835556030273, -1.0827407836914062, -0.1207793727517128, -0.305539608001709, -0.11696106195449829, 0.596969723701477, -0.8162597417831421, 0.5490915179252625, -0.026992563158273697, -0.39697983860969543, 0.01057908684015274, 0.12698331475257874, -0.3907022774219513, 0.14715054631233215, 0.33627772331237793, 0.6998352408409119, 0.720986008644104, 0.5580791234970093, -0.5018600225448608, 1.1415085792541504, -0.6944102644920349, 0.12019076198339462, -0.5292086005210876, -0.6641192436218262, 0.03209410235285759, -0.675999641418457, -0.2598741352558136, 0.45897218585014343, -0.7706863284111023, -0.563846230506897, 0.13380572199821472, 0.5104783177375793, -0.08518081158399582, -0.8376913666725159, 0.6218791604042053, -1.1166996955871582, 0.1505305916070938, 1.4529191255569458, -0.2899613082408905, -0.4748228192329407, -0.25838953256607056, 0.40132609009742737, -0.8485921621322632, 0.688106894493103, 0.20582152903079987, -0.027250345796346664, 0.25904130935668945, -0.13650275766849518, 0.05881836265325546, 0.02748938649892807, 0.1928105354309082, -0.9765347838401794, -0.1966157704591751, -0.4011605679988861, -0.4757600426673889, -0.19387951493263245, -0.17788851261138916, -0.667150616645813, 0.6418778896331787, -0.14941465854644775, -0.5448009967803955, -0.3245930075645447, -0.17563879489898682, -0.4596763253211975, -0.48465096950531006, -0.25112318992614746, 0.2725464701652527, -0.10316566377878189, 0.2349136769771576, 0.8945397138595581, -0.2928115725517273, -0.7578349113464355, 0.04180748760700226, 0.7671764492988586, -0.9238414764404297, -0.4514639377593994, 0.2273131012916565, -0.06281733512878418, -1.1598427295684814, -0.23758138716220856, -0.15861937403678894, -0.49196338653564453, -0.5085992813110352, -0.0837845578789711, -0.24541208148002625, 0.015023668296635151, 0.2023281306028366, -0.24344243109226227, 0.34005114436149597, -0.19127607345581055, -0.753336489200592, -0.7360650300979614, 0.6738249659538269, 0.48441532254219055, -0.1299213320016861, -0.10326900333166122, -0.8839954137802124, -1.0807323455810547, -0.6413701176643372, -0.4280998408794403, -0.7867299914360046, 0.3125148415565491, -0.3195936977863312, -0.9277076125144958, -0.10612749308347702, 0.8065010905265808, -0.026497431099414825, 0.4097726047039032, 0.5410078763961792, -0.5582570433616638, 0.4267217516899109, -0.2878531515598297, -0.15171198546886444, -0.5770550966262817, -0.023712098598480225, 0.10117955505847931, 0.757186770439148, -0.30786415934562683, -0.583297610282898, 0.2469768524169922, 0.204710453748703, 0.5223155617713928, 0.8732964992523193, -0.7273304462432861, -0.36646202206611633, 0.2216653823852539, 0.22321155667304993, -0.9331914186477661, -0.12901528179645538, -0.8408302664756775, 0.6628900170326233, -0.2330082803964615, 0.27106937766075134, -0.27982473373413086, -0.48130106925964355, 0.5593460202217102, -0.07233119010925293, 1.047592282295227, -0.40181979537010193, -0.056294944137334824, 0.5409749746322632, 0.12542001903057098, 0.013842955231666565, 0.1417037695646286, -0.8893250823020935, -0.4319922626018524, -1.0407642126083374, -0.9203318953514099, 0.642048716545105, -0.04389243200421333, 0.37918633222579956, 0.06323813647031784, 0.031597208231687546, 0.25147348642349243, -0.11248956620693207, 1.291343331336975, 0.3145900070667267, -0.6076952815055847, -0.5955918431282043, -0.2076997607946396, 0.43006983399391174, -0.32993805408477783, -0.3219200074672699, 0.9521170854568481, -0.24701352417469025, 0.047856636345386505, -0.390489786863327, -0.25150907039642334, -0.8632359504699707, -0.32711273431777954, 0.5204415917396545, 0.10728443413972855, 0.07691360265016556, -0.2174510955810547, -0.10354404151439667, -0.09458322823047638, -0.058645546436309814, 0.37787485122680664, -0.09976718574762344, 0.8835524916648865, 0.6427476406097412, -0.17989619076251984, -0.34228771924972534, 0.6293993592262268, 0.3658413589000702, 0.0735638439655304, -0.30461233854293823, 0.3824458718299866, 0.15132412314414978, -0.9806578159332275, 0.22802454233169556, 0.20038825273513794, -0.21978448331356049, -0.24449200928211212, 0.1381625384092331, -0.449921578168869, -0.11771900206804276, -0.03704323247075081, -0.04177086427807808, 0.9518067836761475, 0.049673642963171005, 0.21708102524280548, -0.3474089503288269, -0.05202827230095863, -0.004060830920934677, -0.5596297979354858, 0.5940186381340027, -1.1737436056137085, -0.11488847434520721, 0.5411661863327026, -0.2801857590675354, 0.21752606332302094, 0.344896525144577, 0.35455039143562317, 0.19776029884815216, 0.09075004607439041, 0.3820635676383972, -0.49292391538619995, -0.2777944803237915, 0.24599263072013855, 0.4200192391872406, -0.041360799223184586, 0.024672772735357285, -0.017381880432367325, 0.5602552890777588, -0.21499685943126678, -1.057929277420044, -0.9702121615409851, -0.24374671280384064, 0.5652937293052673, -0.035029225051403046, -0.020024936646223068, -0.08061850070953369, 0.49287858605384827, 0.01645699329674244, 0.19482947885990143, 0.03694424405694008, 0.08939654380083084, -0.49017322063446045, -0.9075854420661926, 0.12529723346233368, -0.6380157470703125, 0.07926206290721893, 1.0112643241882324, -0.26181647181510925, -0.47774019837379456, -0.48394709825515747, 0.49049997329711914, -0.1002049446105957, 0.15600864589214325, -0.433428555727005, 0.3713977634906769, -1.1440616846084595, -0.45524924993515015, -0.17327426373958588, -0.37135255336761475, 0.24977107346057892, 0.29288703203201294, -0.08721613138914108, -0.009257271885871887, -0.10989789664745331, 0.664604127407074, -0.02446366660296917, 0.9285575747489929, -0.8021177053451538, -0.6817992329597473, -0.7114194631576538, 0.6085512638092041, 0.20255501568317413, -0.6371898055076599, 1.069989800453186, -0.03316805511713028, 0.05129069834947586, 0.7848120331764221, -0.5239880681037903, -0.7645788788795471, 0.2734149396419525, 0.7904954552650452, -0.5589959025382996, -0.9729847311973572, -0.37159109115600586, 0.3747463822364807, -0.8735965490341187, -0.3123590350151062, -0.604786217212677, -0.1959599256515503, 0.3936247229576111, 0.3766983151435852, 0.04789784550666809, 0.7299099564552307, -0.013714559376239777, 0.07854490727186203, -0.1265910118818283, 1.0185312032699585, 0.42789703607559204, 0.061825335025787354, 0.2712230384349823, 0.24030013382434845, 0.042728491127491, -1.3444716930389404, 0.3060515820980072, 0.8678786754608154, -0.7663623690605164, 0.1014862135052681, 0.09315730631351471, 0.4947540760040283, 0.051982369273900986, -0.00621529808267951, 0.3813219368457794, 0.015342900529503822, 0.022526485845446587, 0.1982986181974411, -0.5530997514724731, -0.5478434562683105, -0.7869088649749756, -0.4756448268890381, -1.134468913078308, -0.10748540610074997, 0.8728647232055664, -0.7229368686676025, -0.10584180057048798, -0.9012720584869385, -0.4227597415447235, 0.5509106516838074, 0.09299929440021515, -0.05455173924565315, 0.37201574444770813, 0.23645998537540436, 0.6997502446174622, 0.11271832138299942, 0.6945974826812744, -0.5082659125328064, 0.17395427823066711, 0.07150403410196304, -0.9660000801086426, -0.1599886417388916, -0.1714930683374405, 0.23788851499557495, 0.02350444905459881, -0.4729554057121277, -0.3945809006690979, 0.1739208996295929, 0.256664514541626, -0.2338535189628601, -0.11167970299720764, -0.06593798846006393, -0.4541338384151459, 0.21863877773284912, -0.8512915968894958, -0.30392593145370483, -0.7254848480224609, 0.28733620047569275, -0.6293777227401733, -1.0598121881484985, -0.13532298803329468, 0.3986886739730835, 0.8936951756477356, -0.1972924917936325, 0.9798696637153625, -0.34384751319885254, 0.9173362255096436, -0.34237703680992126, -0.1883460283279419, 0.21424303948879242, 0.6195759177207947, -0.19149263203144073, -0.12896902859210968, -0.5321765542030334, -0.107120580971241, 0.6559732556343079, 0.35774797201156616, 0.20615440607070923, 0.598148763179779, 0.1957576721906662, 0.547116756439209, 0.3523951768875122, -0.6465910077095032, 0.134745255112648, 0.6724192500114441, -0.627651572227478, 0.03745954856276512, 0.44054165482521057, 0.23759490251541138, 0.009209654293954372, -0.5909029245376587, 0.09941641241312027, -0.8598671555519104, -0.5225175619125366, 0.09555374830961227, 0.7405264377593994, 0.9155906438827515, 0.18470712006092072, 0.3661450147628784, 0.4226410686969757, 0.6699195504188538, -0.11477739363908768, -0.08016665279865265, 0.6327754259109497, -0.7353438138961792, -0.18295840919017792, -0.44744163751602173, 0.21323105692863464, -0.19344373047351837, -0.3143288493156433, 0.22404691576957703, -1.0816274881362915, 0.13761644065380096, 0.740430474281311, -0.10374825447797775, 0.03526008129119873, 0.8097295761108398, 0.028097551316022873, -0.46572330594062805, -0.10630393773317337, -0.1585443615913391, -0.9848875999450684, -0.6011235117912292, 0.5291778445243835, -0.7236514091491699, 0.6546575427055359, 0.4479798376560211, 0.24723264575004578, 0.9673041701316833, 0.27995750308036804, 0.3715544641017914, -0.18420110642910004, 0.5669592618942261, 1.1722874641418457, -0.06551039963960648, 0.08189065754413605, -0.16744089126586914, -0.41973304748535156, 0.2908756732940674, -0.6362690329551697, 0.12065242230892181, 0.3378629684448242, -0.37353307008743286, -0.8130190968513489, 0.15249860286712646, 0.2295254021883011, -0.4786393940448761, -0.5620819926261902, -0.685882568359375, 0.15716466307640076, 0.002480771392583847, -0.8622695207595825, 0.31435027718544006, 0.49540433287620544, -0.16184256970882416, 0.5048109292984009, -0.11357807368040085, -0.6797400712966919, -0.29524877667427063, -0.6015198230743408, 0.5605916976928711, -0.5974350571632385, -0.21771495044231415, -0.2893150746822357, -1.4838300943374634, 0.05516897514462471, 0.10014050453901291, 0.24294112622737885, -0.5662447214126587, 0.04324554651975632, 0.38256576657295227, -0.010797793976962566, 0.1422826200723648, -0.07327777147293091, 0.34137818217277527, 0.15757982432842255, 1.12753427028656, -0.47802698612213135, 0.26569172739982605, -0.48459339141845703, -0.05397142097353935, 0.20450273156166077, 0.05799534544348717, 0.003576386719942093, -0.33523279428482056, 0.04946489259600639, -0.821283757686615, -0.14800219237804413, 0.08813081681728363, -0.8674437999725342, 0.28462281823158264, 1.0196454524993896, 0.033975645899772644, -0.6958060264587402, -1.1354104280471802, -0.5524346232414246, -0.6018235087394714, 0.9789103269577026, -0.15247581899166107, 0.02017311006784439, 0.24933168292045593, -0.21399861574172974, 0.5489030480384827, -1.1663613319396973, 3.998241901397705, 1.0459768772125244, 0.8349825739860535, -0.44451773166656494, 0.5359739065170288, 0.1707233041524887, 0.4595116078853607, 0.4254664480686188, 0.25927162170410156, 0.28631770610809326, -0.20269273221492767, 0.7742635011672974, 0.17478489875793457, -0.10063577443361282, 0.8499063849449158, 0.6670189499855042, -1.201660394668579, -0.05682562664151192, -0.25355273485183716, -0.8518761992454529, -0.9977052807807922, 0.10318544507026672, 0.18822439014911652, -0.45238593220710754, 0.17764253914356232, -0.12430787831544876, -0.2370961308479309, 0.07797210663557053, -0.21587419509887695, -0.7596250176429749, -0.07885546237230301, -0.5668432712554932, 0.3617786169052124, -0.9257401823997498, -0.23213346302509308, 0.2529657781124115, -0.2972632944583893, -0.5814159512519836, -0.14974990487098694, -0.63499516248703, 0.2088058888912201, -0.7607735991477966, -0.028784943744540215, -0.4509028196334839, -0.1294301152229309, -0.04807151481509209, -0.644237756729126, 0.3347172737121582, -0.02618441917002201, -0.27452895045280457, 0.5802566409111023, -0.7762889862060547, 0.28602030873298645, -0.7758712768554688, -0.7911460995674133, -0.5795670747756958, 0.44725385308265686, -0.797663688659668, -0.26905590295791626, 0.8459585905075073, 0.5661389231681824, -0.6015218496322632, -0.5384641289710999, 0.2298070788383484, 0.577837347984314, 0.43307459354400635, 0.3082328736782074, 0.4257797300815582, -0.044320132583379745, -0.30410242080688477, -0.43968918919563293, -0.7591750621795654, -0.03996628522872925, -0.29891958832740784, 0.8347920775413513, 0.3969898223876953, 0.049575429409742355, 0.2274191975593567, -0.4084688425064087, -0.5614486932754517, 0.3774484694004059, -0.07847549766302109, 0.6352879405021667, -0.6217795610427856, 0.6510158777236938, 0.9929239153862, -0.502999484539032, -0.2942671775817871, -1.0179824829101562, 0.8577378392219543, 0.16523434221744537, -0.5667737722396851, -0.1774238646030426, -0.7590735554695129, -0.6680748462677002 ]
{"Title": "Genetic Polymorphisms, Adherence to Mediterranean Diet and Microbiota-Associated Urolithin Metabotypes: A Complex Cocktail to Predict the Obesity in Childhood-Adolescence", "Authors": "Cort\u00e9s-Mart\u00edn Adri\u00e1n, Colmenarejo Gonzalo, Selma Mar\u00eda Victoria, Esp\u00edn Juan Carlos", "Abstract": "Environmental and genetic factors are associated with pandemic obesity since childhood. However, the association of overweight-obesity with these factors, acting as a consortium, has been scarcely studied in children. We aimed here to assess the probabilities of being overweighed-obese in a randomly recruited cohort of Spanish children and adolescents ( n =415, 5\u201317 years-old) by estimating the odds ratios for different predictor variables, and their relative importance in the prediction. The predictor variables were ethnicity, age, sex, adherence to the Mediterranean diet (KIDMED), physical activity, urolithin metabotypes (UM-A, UM-B and UM-0) as biomarkers of the gut microbiota, and 53 single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) from 43 genes mainly related to obesity and cardiometabolic diseases. A proportional-odds logistic ordinal regression, validated through bootstrap, was used to model the data. While every variable was not independently associated with overweight-obesity, however, the ordinal logistic model revealed that overweight-obesity prevalence was related to being a young boy with either UM-B or UM-0, low KIDMED score and high contribution of a consortium of 24 SNPs, being rs1801253- ADRB1 , rs4343- ACE , rs8061518- FTO , rs1130864- CRP , rs659366- UCP2 , rs6131- SELP , rs12535708- LEP , rs1501299- ADIPOQ , rs708272- CETP and rs2241766- ADIPOQ the top-ten contributing SNPs. Additional research should confirm and complete this model by including dietary interventions and the individuals\u2019 gut microbiota composition.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.11.19014431"}
10.1101/19010850
[ -0.23904672265052795, 0.026930000633001328, -0.23270678520202637, -0.11298912018537521, -0.08672536909580231, 0.1332165002822876, 0.20847761631011963, -0.3132731318473816, -0.10182851552963257, 0.3547895848751068, -0.16803590953350067, 0.0990866869688034, 0.746914267539978, 0.4111209809780121, -0.481840580701828, -0.01192645262926817, 0.2236168384552002, -0.018061768263578415, -1.1300309896469116, -0.05256924778223038, 0.6768679022789001, 0.004383750259876251, -0.29930076003074646, 0.06453272700309753, -0.41230928897857666, 0.3753325939178467, 0.3205704987049103, 0.03519729524850845, 1.8225592374801636, 0.950545608997345, -0.18130938708782196, -0.3816069960594177, -0.03457118943333626, -0.5246065258979797, -0.8578923940658569, -0.5136443972587585, 0.9258219599723816, -0.5432469844818115, -0.17614734172821045, -0.6367452144622803, 0.5506735444068909, -0.009954845532774925, 1.1318433284759521, -0.5189096331596375, 0.1594272404909134, 0.0980975553393364, 0.5202268958091736, 0.07908342033624649, -0.13208718597888947, -0.7586912512779236, -0.1516411155462265, 0.6524369716644287, -0.0007302077719941735, -0.6745190024375916, -0.3736223578453064, -0.15137851238250732, -0.14197573065757751, -0.19751499593257904, -0.3613908588886261, -0.06252960115671158, 0.02953232452273369, -0.40074166655540466, 0.6708579659461975, -1.0767848491668701, 0.5447118282318115, 0.2160588800907135, 0.2115669846534729, -0.5411219000816345, 0.0636434406042099, -0.44838908314704895, -0.5596522092819214, 0.30817171931266785, -0.2442590892314911, 0.25394055247306824, -0.6692792773246765, -0.45889461040496826, 0.2454228550195694, -0.8422453999519348, 0.23634777963161469, 0.6694355010986328, 0.4323258399963379, 0.34617751836776733, 1.0712391138076782, 0.07053547352552414, -0.02327357605099678, 0.11940036714076996, 0.7541118264198303, 0.29730838537216187, 0.26585400104522705, 0.4974421560764313, -0.07862221449613571, 0.46869972348213196, -0.554460883140564, 0.5205883383750916, 0.33699536323547363, 0.9184252619743347, -0.2196970283985138, 0.023786107078194618, -0.058104537427425385, -0.14429089426994324, 0.9995163679122925, 0.7858705520629883, -0.4836770296096802, 1.0380643606185913, -0.557127058506012, 0.8878242373466492, 1.3314355611801147, -0.6822737455368042, -0.26736006140708923, -0.27604466676712036, -0.40886715054512024, -0.10016216337680817, -0.5006711483001709, -0.7896910309791565, 0.44543394446372986, -0.0068885828368365765, -0.2410639077425003, -0.021290551871061325, -0.04556271433830261, -0.2643788158893585, -0.5517609119415283, 0.19983598589897156, -0.5066589117050171, 0.43012791872024536, -0.16911369562149048, -0.31188541650772095, 0.4775884747505188, 0.4428778886795044, -0.5366892218589783, -0.42424654960632324, 0.0618521124124527, -0.7500663995742798, -0.4139610230922699, 0.32691746950149536, -0.1150474026799202, 0.018005432561039925, 0.5134018063545227, 1.259971261024475, 0.8038046956062317, -0.5870916247367859, -0.4379635155200958, 0.13470469415187836, -0.3265898823738098, 1.2561076879501343, -0.5348743796348572, 0.4070906639099121, -0.9091461300849915, 0.2705516219139099, -0.9827204346656799, 0.46733689308166504, 0.014796216040849686, -0.12519767880439758, 0.6490602493286133, 0.9472101926803589, -0.2612365186214447, 0.03724224120378494, 0.05640773847699165, 0.4347367584705353, 0.10231868177652359, 0.17913424968719482, -0.47358059883117676, 0.5206193923950195, -0.14070065319538116, 0.08042022585868835, -0.5028963685035706, 1.1865506172180176, -0.23002777993679047, -0.47302690148353577, 0.8765062093734741, 0.03554525226354599, 0.2077157199382782, 0.12516207993030548, -0.5140316486358643, 0.5823615193367004, 0.46778354048728943, 0.0379229299724102, 0.4719409644603729, -0.19229891896247864, 0.4879908859729767, 0.7604559659957886, 0.21188925206661224, 0.34199661016464233, 0.20193560421466827, 1.2255463600158691, -0.7122626304626465, 0.6982458233833313, -0.024176018312573433, -0.38552576303482056, -0.3661799430847168, -0.1795855462551117, 0.07894867658615112, 1.0123506784439087, -0.49687260389328003, 0.3213275074958801, -0.04975555092096329, -0.6979767084121704, -0.408225953578949, 0.4601971507072449, 1.0274999141693115, -0.17127157747745514, -0.45988690853118896, 0.2762615978717804, -0.44540858268737793, -0.1027211919426918, -0.2825285792350769, -0.43580111861228943, 0.20161712169647217, 0.5145531892776489, -0.6121130585670471, -0.11790138483047485, 0.9943753480911255, 0.7964034080505371, -0.30791357159614563, 0.3911397159099579, 0.6166467666625977, -0.834733784198761, -0.09158995747566223, 0.15230649709701538, 0.34358105063438416, 0.09751204401254654, -0.6249468326568604, -0.49562475085258484, -0.12169214338064194, 0.848565399646759, -0.1134112998843193, -0.20171360671520233, 0.826997697353363, 0.23787452280521393, -0.38361063599586487, -0.771611213684082, 0.3464448153972626, 1.1715420484542847, -0.032730117440223694, 0.13903078436851501, 0.6518213152885437, 0.05121655762195587, 0.5239957571029663, 0.688223659992218, -0.12114390730857849, 0.15895718336105347, 0.49559223651885986, 0.8894169926643372, 0.3255763053894043, 0.4960283637046814, 0.10658655315637589, 0.4257362484931946, 0.5136228203773499, -0.09177682548761368, -0.6059046983718872, 0.7097368836402893, -0.4849156141281128, 0.8053457736968994, 0.017827723175287247, 0.3084823787212372, -0.9437979459762573, -0.2521078586578369, 0.3579542934894562, 0.17956392467021942, -0.28270038962364197, -0.6897976398468018, -0.1439990997314453, -0.25188639760017395, -0.5991610288619995, -0.33923405408859253, 0.6031192541122437, -0.08719290047883987, 0.030353765934705734, 0.7630559206008911, -0.5257959365844727, -0.14580278098583221, -0.8330367207527161, -0.6655492186546326, -2.1493561267852783, -0.4134373366832733, -1.0388319492340088, 0.08666890859603882, 0.21414333581924438, -0.7652570009231567, 0.3077940046787262, 0.013250515796244144, 0.2114332914352417, 0.8113445043563843, 0.11616433411836624, -0.07289200276136398, 0.24936030805110931, 0.6099280714988708, -1.254661202430725, 0.42047134041786194, -0.29875659942626953, 0.102422334253788, -0.2641628384590149, 0.37460827827453613, -0.5826358199119568, -0.5680344700813293, 1.0233685970306396, 0.05020635575056076, 0.19982102513313293, -0.38362470269203186, -0.7676309943199158, -0.5144844651222229, -0.16365070641040802, -0.5593661665916443, -0.12202267348766327, -0.5536415576934814, 0.056614529341459274, 0.6447991728782654, -0.3366238474845886, 0.5095632672309875, 0.8360560536384583, -0.6686801314353943, -0.710102379322052, 0.3690148890018463, -0.02209489606320858, -0.07115323841571808, -0.7483470439910889, 0.41896557807922363, 0.5302467346191406, -1.2428926229476929, 0.1282237023115158, -0.18666495382785797, -0.08687489479780197, -0.7246670722961426, 0.6604652404785156, -0.855448305606842, 0.19133812189102173, 0.3264780044555664, 0.9732728004455566, -1.6320947408676147, -0.08986539393663406, -0.3554530441761017, -0.7729716300964355, 0.16546015441417694, 0.5178453326225281, -0.25138741731643677, 0.19727809727191925, 0.13189488649368286, -0.37992238998413086, -0.43562406301498413, -0.1430370956659317, -0.23501315712928772, 0.40324655175209045, -0.7921620011329651, 0.04968053102493286, 0.21448910236358643, -0.5105182528495789, 0.032871704548597336, -0.22905991971492767, -0.16435180604457855, -0.8576762080192566, -0.5439533591270447, -0.17876067757606506, 0.5576249361038208, 0.04717869311571121, 0.13340096175670624, 0.11802706122398376, 0.7332841753959656, -0.027041293680667877, -0.05577436089515686, 0.19663375616073608, 0.5440416932106018, 0.0446242094039917, 0.7517164349555969, -0.4709285795688629, -0.540818452835083, -0.11388818174600601, -0.3627326190471649, -0.18301470577716827, 0.6715582013130188, 1.2278423309326172, -0.10963770002126694, 0.32532230019569397, -1.1195156574249268, 0.15742425620555878, 0.5882551074028015, -0.5458769202232361, -0.26178428530693054, 1.0155317783355713, 0.24166521430015564, 0.7623881697654724, -0.8643074631690979, -0.7011959552764893, 0.04907824099063873, 0.5396783351898193, 0.8989177346229553, 0.2024564892053604, 0.3056086301803589, -0.2662105858325958, 0.1850401610136032, 0.3892265856266022, -0.5362932085990906, -0.7226933836936951, -0.07136222720146179, -0.20705226063728333, 0.12342695146799088, -0.9137222766876221, -0.8514537215232849, 0.3767682611942291, 0.7424973845481873, 0.9164242148399353, 0.06174617260694504, 1.4923566579818726, 0.06338788568973541, 0.5890448689460754, 0.25529423356056213, 0.4681013226509094, 0.408377081155777, -0.8596826195716858, 0.1234159842133522, -0.6311111450195312, -0.3180641233921051, -0.15689140558242798, -0.15973877906799316, -0.5606822371482849, 0.0939142256975174, 0.01807595044374466, 0.6357377171516418, 0.00033771846210584044, -1.2116094827651978, 0.679286777973175, 0.49807313084602356, -0.005687421187758446, -0.2293212115764618, -0.4598298966884613, 0.230941042304039, -0.23004589974880219, 0.42769280076026917, 0.02951989136636257, -0.12780232727527618, -0.01266409270465374, 1.1063917875289917, -0.25673502683639526, -0.7362263798713684, 0.4853481650352478, -0.20595614612102509, -1.5486080646514893, 0.5519875884056091, -0.08435117453336716, -0.023091789335012436, -0.39553889632225037, -0.29181236028671265, 0.4958975315093994, -0.18406377732753754, -0.7759514451026917, -1.3041729927062988, -0.2191145420074463, -0.0909242257475853, 0.8557448983192444, 1.1219367980957031, 0.16031081974506378, -0.07805956900119781, -0.4908429682254791, -0.3210970163345337, 0.41730549931526184, -0.30667349696159363, -0.08780301362276077, 0.10170438140630722, 0.3328840732574463, -0.26574376225471497, -0.24328352510929108, -0.4405394494533539, 0.03395481035113335, 0.1905101239681244, 0.22150331735610962, 0.05390029400587082, -1.300014615058899, 1.1570520401000977, 0.002942093648016453, -0.24141144752502441, 0.6716620326042175, 0.021546585485339165, -0.9118797779083252, 0.2310125082731247, -0.9037277102470398, -0.5181996822357178, 0.21183615922927856, -1.3588788509368896, -0.2167372703552246, 0.44649794697761536, -1.015486478805542, 1.1398733854293823, 0.28199899196624756, 1.0541749000549316, -0.12187724560499191, -0.7821910381317139, -0.958573043346405, -0.4785479009151459, -0.058164481073617935, -0.022262103855609894, -0.7480084896087646, 0.30685707926750183, -0.7174495458602905, 0.360025018453598, -0.3735550045967102, 0.6702101230621338, -0.8141016364097595, 0.4438338279724121, 0.07131165266036987, -0.505471408367157, -0.2849123775959015, 0.9938597679138184, 0.2903284728527069, -0.414169043302536, -0.7157647013664246, 0.1079847440123558, 0.4604446589946747, -0.5672831535339355, -0.6917168498039246, -0.339114785194397, 0.5290820598602295, 0.0022178550716489553, 0.3980390429496765, -0.12354719638824463, -0.2795369327068329, -0.06580473482608795, 0.22530798614025116, 0.35734012722969055, 0.8150372505187988, 0.2114628404378891, -0.25241732597351074, -0.3003367483615875, 0.18802373111248016, -0.8259331583976746, -0.6697473526000977, 0.5132099986076355, -0.18029852211475372, 0.18220992386341095, -0.042827919125556946, -0.6934784054756165, -0.43760961294174194, -0.5105271339416504, -0.15352429449558258, -0.8383258581161499, -0.4307830333709717, -0.577212393283844, -0.17108356952667236, -0.4762599766254425, 0.3607181906700134, 0.449037104845047, -0.10418973118066788, -0.0450616292655468, -1.190683364868164, -0.13991469144821167, 0.19843028485774994, 0.3477914035320282, -0.4843721389770508, -0.8776320219039917, 0.34546157717704773, 1.6515873670578003, 1.2472937107086182, -0.33149874210357666, -0.8316553235054016, 0.5340608358383179, 0.5417599678039551, 0.7154417037963867, -0.1198028102517128, -0.07120420783758163, 0.18309086561203003, 0.17339561879634857, 0.16021235287189484, -0.12161543220281601, -1.0062841176986694, 0.7635385990142822, -1.1254403591156006, -0.11384905874729156, 0.1986832320690155, -0.3551461398601532, -0.41366317868232727, -0.28553587198257446, 0.6085071563720703, -0.2026897668838501, 1.1236897706985474, -0.17654797434806824, 0.4408509433269501, -0.0411609411239624, 0.14196962118148804, -0.6032162308692932, -0.06323859095573425, -0.45926472544670105, -0.6058167219161987, 0.2947476804256439, -0.345611572265625, 0.1717841923236847, 0.507059633731842, -0.5797336101531982, 0.3241121470928192, -1.052415132522583, 0.5535162091255188, 0.584467887878418, 0.2090756744146347, -0.5086604356765747, 0.0549323633313179, 0.3068302273750305, 0.26071637868881226, -0.6693415641784668, 0.668128252029419, -0.21495553851127625, 0.21795213222503662, -0.007412281818687916, 0.019700825214385986, 0.20217405259609222, -0.8302236795425415, 0.4519471228122711, 0.7764506340026855, -0.9715210795402527, 0.10078924149274826, -0.47919610142707825, -0.6430423259735107, -0.3676428496837616, 0.3743303120136261, -0.04813673347234726, 0.04069695249199867, 0.5010111927986145, -0.29073622822761536, 0.17011085152626038, 1.228354573249817, 0.047234926372766495, 0.4313591420650482, -0.6362729668617249, 0.7442247271537781, 0.3204632103443146, -0.41095811128616333, 0.12878544628620148, 0.8068770170211792, -0.3860064744949341, 0.011643148958683014, -0.1625252068042755, 0.4787258207798004, 0.572950541973114, -0.4045886993408203, 0.012736260890960693, 0.2535794675350189, -0.07234114408493042, 0.5251082181930542, 0.6196277141571045, -0.3166322708129883, -0.4795948266983032, -0.5952786803245544, 0.8330912590026855, -0.5628012418746948, 0.9169484376907349, 0.5878535509109497, -0.2513541877269745, -0.2892410159111023, 0.0786883607506752, 0.3016580641269684, 0.5855820178985596, 0.09498331695795059, 0.656795084476471, -0.5296717882156372, 0.5770707726478577, 0.2076621949672699, -0.16049060225486755, 0.5136455297470093, -0.622601330280304, -0.66492760181427, 0.5106568336486816, -0.23403328657150269, -1.1214394569396973, -0.8056068420410156, 0.18208305537700653, 0.173982173204422, -0.020587529987096786, -1.0193144083023071, 0.017400743439793587, 1.0928927659988403, 0.020089248195290565, 0.033071547746658325, -0.8916423916816711, 0.29546961188316345, -0.7670804262161255, -0.10109995305538177, -0.5738402605056763, 0.023192010819911957, -0.09001366794109344, -0.14019927382469177, 0.07572196424007416, -0.25495442748069763, -0.8148043155670166, 0.9210818409919739, -0.11400949209928513, 0.2768321931362152, -0.41426074504852295, 0.609043538570404, -0.726401150226593, -1.1371222734451294, -0.2883358597755432, 0.26601752638816833, -0.17848913371562958, 0.4688890874385834, -0.5121538639068604, 0.11078746616840363, -0.21757249534130096, -0.13051284849643707, 0.46886947751045227, 0.5743588805198669, -1.7195091247558594, -0.05220973491668701, -0.30369114875793457, 0.418255090713501, -0.297335147857666, -0.11608613282442093, 0.24774837493896484, -0.4607942998409271, 0.28569796681404114, 0.3010099530220032, -0.5324987173080444, 0.18023936450481415, -0.15739598870277405, -0.10705027729272842, -0.18861621618270874, -0.5416665077209473, -0.2981646955013275, 0.4599057137966156, -0.9009801745414734, -0.5235912203788757, -0.9071803689002991, -0.1953662633895874, 0.12386526167392731, -0.44388073682785034, -1.0525703430175781, 0.2076043039560318, 0.9439678192138672, 0.969082772731781, -0.6200807690620422, 0.6181651949882507, 0.028941407799720764, 0.0444670096039772, 0.5330384969711304, -0.09840015321969986, 0.030692506581544876, -0.5590485334396362, 0.29612618684768677, 0.4528772532939911, 0.05678356811404228, -0.1555420607328415, -0.24140644073486328, -0.026441393420100212, -1.274997353553772, -0.0005651559913530946, -0.47353681921958923, 1.0018362998962402, -0.04375622794032097, 0.5070100426673889, 0.20749697089195251, 0.05948828533291817, -0.7637701034545898, -0.1381182074546814, -0.033637069165706635, -0.5834432244300842, 0.6391837000846863, -0.08626513928174973, -0.45790377259254456, -0.003771727904677391, -0.2747807800769806, 0.42662131786346436, -0.3800114095211029, -0.3239480257034302, 0.25728893280029297, 0.5650745630264282, 0.2555484473705292, 0.7345176339149475, 0.006647216156125069, 0.21574778854846954, -0.7454171180725098, 0.1756584197282791, -0.07769186794757843, 0.29014840722084045, 0.42060133814811707, 1.13144052028656, -0.14290010929107666, 0.05879415571689606, -0.45291396975517273, -0.40277254581451416, 0.060088448226451874, 0.4855673909187317, 0.5018401741981506, 0.930817723274231, -0.4319162368774414, 0.05649527162313461, 0.3453438878059387, 0.8426843881607056, -0.9433651566505432, 0.2607695460319519, 0.04757048189640045, -0.32037097215652466, -0.4212741553783417, 0.15575562417507172, 0.15705610811710358, -0.10271149128675461, 0.043231140822172165, -0.3078191876411438, 0.6529872417449951, -0.042384982109069824, -0.07567012310028076, -0.019866641610860825, 1.2188305854797363, -0.46975797414779663, -0.09626773744821548, -0.37120068073272705, 0.4740869402885437, 0.49646931886672974, 0.21317198872566223, 0.4695042371749878, 0.3252659738063812, -0.6039601564407349, -0.5737630128860474, -0.3398759067058563, -1.295986294746399, -0.25192999839782715, -0.37454134225845337, -0.6808848977088928, 0.5508379340171814, -0.7390472292900085, 0.4780619442462921, 0.12574104964733124, -0.14767251908779144, 0.706483006477356, -0.279693603515625, -0.9576546549797058, -0.5986834764480591, 0.10234521329402924, 1.100895881652832, 0.5021932125091553, 0.9735048413276672, 0.546951413154602, 0.7862282395362854, 0.3286670744419098, -0.8952001929283142, 0.031619489192962646, 0.43266761302948, 0.2993282675743103, -0.4283904433250427, 0.38863667845726013, -0.6540593504905701, 0.7702490091323853, 0.03212733566761017, -0.5373242497444153, 0.4997671842575073, 0.44080010056495667, -0.29222750663757324, -0.024680420756340027, 0.3275177478790283, -0.46938690543174744, 0.11409115791320801, -0.2615901529788971, 0.47840026021003723, -0.8058558106422424, -0.605503499507904, 0.5061405301094055, -0.5240408778190613, -0.2816545069217682, -0.05522256717085838, 0.5384814739227295, -0.007013689260929823, 0.39293012022972107, 0.7568302750587463, -0.3308458924293518, -0.27278372645378113, 0.5428981184959412, -0.09147514402866364, 0.014561639167368412, -0.1562040150165558, 0.36182451248168945, -0.04492977634072304, -0.13483981788158417, 0.17798802256584167, 0.2820827066898346, 0.5132753252983093, -0.3892920911312103, 0.46785110235214233, -0.31668663024902344, 0.21681180596351624, 0.12824015319347382, 0.06929782032966614, -0.05829145386815071, 0.35010647773742676, -0.12419815361499786, 0.14611154794692993, -0.11687251925468445, 0.3553321361541748, -0.3352009654045105, 0.3728216588497162, -0.8699100613594055, 0.31852102279663086, -0.9299830198287964, -0.031875476241111755, 0.07091625779867172, -0.6069127321243286, -0.18279218673706055, -1.3257722854614258, 0.15467965602874756, -0.18453289568424225, 0.1627676635980606, -0.40736129879951477, 0.24423974752426147, -0.1747058629989624, 0.6804554462432861, -0.808480978012085, 0.1672310084104538, -0.18223197758197784, 0.8491188883781433, 0.6887598633766174, 0.32922613620758057, 0.3464932441711426, 0.17551767826080322, 0.20448505878448486, 0.4219346344470978, -0.8702377676963806, -0.08044563978910446, 0.1772727221250534, -0.364002525806427, 0.06783730536699295, -0.2695259749889374, 0.31918254494667053, -0.951018750667572, -0.2743026614189148, 1.106957197189331, 0.8143895268440247, -0.3379467725753784, -0.5844805240631104, 0.20479871332645416, -0.8235650062561035, 0.5643264651298523, -0.5909239649772644, -0.06652805954217911, 0.1653045415878296, 0.15027448534965515, 0.2827551066875458, -0.5501397848129272, 3.9741249084472656, 1.2937653064727783, 0.7251632809638977, -0.11350749433040619, 0.20988579094409943, 0.15282754600048065, 0.5305995345115662, -0.4859750270843506, 0.10253670066595078, 0.253984272480011, 0.7764871120452881, -0.5816261172294617, 0.2891464829444885, -0.1757623255252838, -0.12885682284832, 0.32948121428489685, -1.21584153175354, -0.35344868898391724, -0.31999990344047546, -0.8648554682731628, -0.6825361251831055, -0.13662637770175934, 0.21141782402992249, -0.09836244583129883, -0.00691257044672966, -0.5995199084281921, 0.7895766496658325, 0.24990837275981903, 0.6735895872116089, -0.4212360978126526, -0.6549931764602661, -0.1883751004934311, 0.38103529810905457, -0.6093572378158569, -0.9869795441627502, 0.04377586022019386, -0.5193331837654114, -0.9148321151733398, -0.2310468703508377, 0.09776213765144348, 0.488485187292099, 0.10088008642196655, 0.2290533035993576, 0.09746309369802475, 0.12228742241859436, 0.13965646922588348, -0.3627409040927887, -0.4972018003463745, 0.7560483813285828, -0.3696938157081604, 0.3907291889190674, -0.7330882549285889, -0.2676094174385071, 0.14893567562103271, -0.9773488640785217, -0.03470968082547188, -0.264104962348938, -0.9172219038009644, -0.07033103704452515, 0.19309718906879425, 0.059215545654296875, 0.26448220014572144, -0.10766879469156265, -0.27259770035743713, -0.1534135341644287, 0.7358287572860718, 0.2795964777469635, -0.1768324226140976, 0.2975890040397644, -0.39424848556518555, -0.6692932844161987, 0.045514337718486786, -0.6385459899902344, -0.3403416872024536, -0.1480434238910675, 0.84886234998703, -0.08569828420877457, 0.7218577861785889, 0.37749701738357544, -0.32269150018692017, 0.09089081734418869, 0.051663246005773544, -0.2599494457244873, 0.3272073566913605, 0.7460491061210632, 1.1013243198394775, -0.5654283165931702, -0.4609392285346985, -0.6999910473823547, 0.3573603630065918, 0.8828861713409424, -0.7503371834754944, 0.41031137108802795, 0.05428154394030571, 0.7957848310470581 ]
{"Title": "Defining predatory journals and responding to the threat they pose: a modified Delphi consensus process", "Authors": "Cukier Samantha, Lalu Manoj M., Bryson Gregory L., Cobey Kelly D., Grudniewicz Agnes, Moher David", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Posing as legitimate open access outlets, predatory journals and publishers threaten the integrity of academic publishing by not following publication best practices. Currently, there is no agreed upon definition of predatory journals, making it difficult for funders and academic institutions to generate practical guidance or policy to ensure their members do not publish in these channels. Methods We conducted a modified three-round Delphi survey of an international group of academics, funders, policy makers, journal editors, publishers and others, to generate a consensus definition of predatory journals and suggested ways the research community should respond to the problem. Results A total of 45 participants completed the survey on predatory journals and publishers. We reached consensus on 18 items out of a total of 33, to be included in a consensus definition of predatory journals and publishers. We came to consensus on educational outreach and policy initiatives on which to focus, including the development of a single checklist to detect predatory journals and publishers, and public funding to support research in this general area. We identified technological solutions to address the problem: a \u2018one-stop-shop\u2019 website to consolidate information on the topic and a \u2018predatory journal research observatory\u2019 to identify ongoing research and analysis about predatory journals/publishers. Conclusions In bringing together an international group of diverse stakeholders, we were able to use a modified Delphi process to inform the development of a definition of predatory journals and publishers. This definition will help institutions, funders and other stakeholders generate practical guidance on avoiding predatory journals and publishers.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010850"}
10.1101/19007047
[ 0.2433035522699356, -0.09354639053344727, 0.05298528075218201, 0.15344318747520447, -0.6708798408508301, 0.23684263229370117, -0.1968730092048645, 0.3626074194908142, -0.026959428563714027, 0.18097472190856934, -0.0489618144929409, -0.4140947759151459, -0.0015464562457054853, -0.17607195675373077, 0.38447996973991394, 0.45437049865722656, -0.30286848545074463, -0.15867511928081512, 0.3720245659351349, 0.34932205080986023, 0.032965607941150665, 1.2169079780578613, -0.6868786811828613, -0.2680817246437073, -0.387229859828949, 0.6774306297302246, -0.03899895027279854, -0.42534929513931274, 1.180470585823059, 0.47437766194343567, 0.13160490989685059, -0.7284955978393555, 0.46898093819618225, -0.5491125583648682, -0.7941225171089172, -0.15129537880420685, 0.6986356973648071, 0.03511239215731621, -0.2767275273799896, -0.0992184728384018, 0.4898931384086609, -0.1832815408706665, 0.009253839030861855, -0.5571231245994568, -0.9237937331199646, -0.875624418258667, 0.44757577776908875, -0.5661928653717041, 0.16640476882457733, -0.05919748544692993, -0.5505478382110596, 0.33208492398262024, 0.24645818769931793, -0.1982850879430771, -0.22497427463531494, -0.009986096061766148, 0.45589369535446167, -0.10589219629764557, 0.09164412319660187, 0.6626973748207092, -0.16278675198554993, -0.29662081599235535, 0.29274752736091614, -0.9086380004882812, 1.1286388635635376, 0.5994482636451721, -0.35313597321510315, -0.5210433602333069, -0.37150195240974426, -0.4267495274543762, -0.6040762662887573, 0.18055997788906097, -0.5222644805908203, -0.9347946643829346, -0.5422641634941101, -0.9528332948684692, 1.505539059638977, -0.29139113426208496, 0.05588088184595108, -0.479221373796463, -0.27789705991744995, 0.40802353620529175, 0.5556071400642395, -0.3608534038066864, -0.6063981056213379, 0.919883668422699, 0.16595123708248138, 0.15597182512283325, 0.2110387682914734, 0.24716252088546753, 0.008213307708501816, -0.1608983278274536, -0.3946102559566498, -0.418317586183548, -0.6024128794670105, 1.2896451950073242, -0.11114614456892014, -0.20182015001773834, 0.46027207374572754, -0.22478099167346954, 0.8750423192977905, 1.1673753261566162, -0.23212827742099762, 0.8844625949859619, -0.9699358344078064, 0.8671598434448242, 0.8732960820198059, -0.4115507900714874, -0.10270476341247559, -0.7432617545127869, 0.13197360932826996, 0.26172593235969543, -1.2404283285140991, -0.2388346940279007, -0.20242096483707428, 0.8139641284942627, -0.26548805832862854, 0.6878060102462769, -1.094616174697876, 0.3806977868080139, -0.05400627851486206, -0.9577316045761108, -0.12053702771663666, -0.2845616936683655, 0.11493594944477081, -0.03591017797589302, -0.07674720883369446, 1.124215006828308, -0.44433295726776123, -0.24814008176326752, 0.2124999761581421, -0.029904717579483986, -0.06195647642016411, 1.489646315574646, -0.23306742310523987, 0.5099819898605347, 0.1824006736278534, 0.30082303285598755, 0.2079615741968155, -0.7015098929405212, -0.3714122772216797, -0.10370124131441116, -1.0010849237442017, 1.1336321830749512, 0.15311667323112488, 0.11701875180006027, -0.558917224407196, -1.4301979541778564, -0.3264774680137634, -0.08044474571943283, -0.03777257725596428, 0.43098869919776917, -0.43181613087654114, 0.05040072277188301, -0.2496740072965622, 0.03312142193317413, -0.07808750122785568, -0.28624412417411804, 0.062364887446165085, -0.11261483281850815, -0.44520819187164307, 0.513871431350708, 0.014943481422960758, 0.7087368369102478, -1.012344479560852, 0.37267783284187317, -0.23948732018470764, 0.07030307501554489, 0.18472431600093842, -0.4613567888736725, 0.6165090203285217, -0.07999340444803238, -0.26451998949050903, -0.1349925994873047, 0.2041151374578476, 0.7104608416557312, 1.3783644437789917, 0.6890552639961243, 0.3057948648929596, 0.305212140083313, -0.6290105581283569, 0.10912534594535828, 0.37142279744148254, 0.7008237838745117, -0.10817597061395645, 0.38930657505989075, -0.4483183026313782, -0.6013282537460327, -0.23486855626106262, -0.6685311794281006, -0.1443394422531128, 0.5382929444313049, -0.1336321383714676, 0.4625526964664459, -0.38036394119262695, -0.2827635109424591, 0.0773199126124382, 0.7017216086387634, 0.7226426005363464, 0.01651710458099842, -0.46697986125946045, 0.6261158585548401, -0.010591501370072365, 0.21669749915599823, -0.6545156836509705, 1.140487551689148, -0.04723634943366051, 0.34655994176864624, -0.04704861342906952, 0.20099467039108276, 0.39867648482322693, -0.24284727871418, -0.5227592587471008, -0.011693194508552551, 0.4217630624771118, -0.14400556683540344, -0.6720989942550659, 0.3972730040550232, 0.7350104451179504, 0.3869696855545044, -0.4595111012458801, -0.6801068186759949, 0.5791845321655273, 0.3098888397216797, 0.26809218525886536, 0.4268855154514313, 0.517980694770813, 0.9103034734725952, -0.5079535245895386, -0.4558037519454956, 0.19275711476802826, 0.8180035352706909, -0.293129563331604, 0.5640394687652588, 0.9048984050750732, 0.560064435005188, 0.08572119474411011, 0.40128064155578613, 0.1793442815542221, -0.07601140439510345, 0.5313387513160706, -0.006712816655635834, 0.474249005317688, 0.2878545820713043, -0.6826668977737427, 0.6311696171760559, -0.16247045993804932, -0.05720566585659981, 0.1518453061580658, 0.17565599083900452, -0.567014753818512, 1.0571801662445068, 0.2116813212633133, 0.11793647706508636, -0.7253658175468445, -0.2265969067811966, 0.6070203185081482, -0.1047355905175209, -0.3246532082557678, -0.0581461638212204, 0.41147512197494507, 0.19970999658107758, -0.8336984515190125, -0.17773565649986267, 0.36047667264938354, 0.3235264718532562, -0.4979364573955536, 0.6217098832130432, -0.20927177369594574, -0.15825144946575165, -0.9629756808280945, -1.242014765739441, -1.070321798324585, -0.39191317558288574, -0.160779669880867, -0.15528836846351624, -0.1561134308576584, -0.5132293701171875, 0.6645742058753967, -0.6653240919113159, 0.46129390597343445, 0.03567462041974068, 0.43056759238243103, 0.2809944748878479, -0.39932870864868164, 0.7822471857070923, -0.8127397298812866, 0.5303322672843933, -0.2966860234737396, 0.8392304182052612, -0.23079721629619598, 0.015874512493610382, -0.4423538148403168, -0.41543906927108765, 0.2885831296443939, -0.6045123934745789, 0.01850528083741665, -0.011802645400166512, -0.5858677625656128, 0.2478291392326355, 0.10275066643953323, -0.28633007407188416, -0.3621617555618286, 0.1566324084997177, -0.3290446102619171, 0.5864929556846619, -0.13372451066970825, 0.2283838391304016, 0.7043311595916748, 0.022586101666092873, -0.2805597484111786, 0.30209779739379883, 0.6232194900512695, -0.29469507932662964, -1.4056799411773682, 0.1822635382413864, 0.2601061463356018, -0.19252276420593262, 0.18381063640117645, -1.0452165603637695, -0.10168702155351639, -0.16828538477420807, -0.16490203142166138, -0.5617275238037109, -0.059755779802799225, 0.37394025921821594, 0.8357301950454712, -1.5092147588729858, 0.21708305180072784, -0.22564108669757843, -0.6152060031890869, 0.17771360278129578, 0.10980207473039627, 0.10305503755807877, 0.3638922870159149, 0.20420199632644653, -0.018715323880314827, -0.43887510895729065, 0.17359858751296997, 0.39751511812210083, 0.6488378643989563, -0.22579491138458252, 0.14854590594768524, -0.0755467638373375, 0.06680837273597717, 0.9354246258735657, 0.3990650475025177, -0.4841463565826416, -0.3611554801464081, 0.10931111872196198, -0.5577601194381714, 0.6228691935539246, 0.7156316637992859, -0.14765387773513794, 0.2405291646718979, 0.35979896783828735, 0.043483342975378036, -0.639767587184906, -0.17030981183052063, 0.34676992893218994, -0.23502515256404877, 0.2618996202945709, -0.5499595999717712, 0.22841347754001617, -0.8613958358764648, -0.4409381151199341, -0.12610283493995667, 0.07963365316390991, 0.14417286217212677, -0.3178805708885193, 0.7399947047233582, 0.1700924038887024, -0.01229647733271122, -0.2337600439786911, 0.1329372525215149, -0.4413463771343231, 1.0484298467636108, 0.3994045555591583, 1.0015400648117065, -0.43106311559677124, -0.42235517501831055, 0.7974869012832642, 1.0596318244934082, -0.05784253031015396, 0.027345646172761917, 0.8441962003707886, -1.1319764852523804, 0.4273071885108948, 0.5588593482971191, 0.08118977397680283, 0.5187036991119385, -0.09946832805871964, -0.5851770043373108, 0.22873255610466003, -0.5928002595901489, 0.3563140034675598, 0.3015349507331848, 0.7708341479301453, 0.1436428725719452, 0.10226118564605713, 1.2312239408493042, 0.04863542690873146, 0.3925169110298157, -0.06392361968755722, 0.4029240012168884, -0.05245549604296684, -0.43237823247909546, -0.03506749868392944, -0.1959037482738495, 0.10679411143064499, -0.44515401124954224, -0.06854230910539627, 0.111818328499794, -0.2107548713684082, 0.08597878366708755, 0.09793519973754883, -0.535609245300293, -0.3151024878025055, 0.03369666263461113, -0.28665292263031006, -0.028802650049328804, -0.1722249686717987, -0.3878289759159088, 0.20996153354644775, -0.36011576652526855, -0.21610838174819946, -0.16953973472118378, -0.7979106307029724, 0.12476957589387894, 1.2222719192504883, -1.3091782331466675, -0.2535638213157654, 0.38180938363075256, 0.06964658945798874, -0.7247931957244873, 0.810276210308075, -0.15372449159622192, -0.24168919026851654, 0.3483937680721283, -0.13483181595802307, -0.34608885645866394, 0.052311256527900696, -0.7685500383377075, 0.017194587737321854, 0.4975384473800659, 0.0847369059920311, 1.260762333869934, 0.19927257299423218, 0.5620365142822266, 0.3931346833705902, 0.648197591304779, -0.2824702560901642, 1.1217283010482788, -0.3595660328865051, -0.6339479088783264, -1.0441155433654785, 0.2797931432723999, -0.12075150012969971, -0.22517579793930054, 0.3805057108402252, -0.5200238823890686, 0.0557614266872406, -0.03364425525069237, -0.4454376697540283, -0.6048865914344788, 0.7600952982902527, -0.7593966722488403, 0.42917418479919434, 1.223664402961731, -0.7793740630149841, 0.2622959613800049, 0.20481202006340027, -0.07574237138032913, -0.45746320486068726, 0.175214946269989, -0.22890716791152954, 0.4032600224018097, 1.5541040897369385, -0.7272639274597168, 0.17771753668785095, -0.3157445192337036, -0.2720527648925781, -0.4480220079421997, 0.22878709435462952, -0.17176467180252075, -0.44149115681648254, -0.5084120631217957, -0.15658771991729736, -0.9012061953544617, -0.07239849865436554, -0.4868892431259155, 0.009719112887978554, 0.10939236730337143, 0.5483062863349915, -1.582932710647583, -0.1260177046060562, -0.503790020942688, -0.23000207543373108, -0.03736835718154907, -0.1665445864200592, 0.4993123710155487, -0.744759202003479, -0.12338847666978836, 0.04592084139585495, 0.3687106668949127, -0.6631333231925964, 0.007901942357420921, -0.1964838057756424, 0.019954394549131393, 0.22820809483528137, -0.17530891299247742, 0.29127857089042664, -0.6553592681884766, 0.1979753077030182, -0.5958894491195679, -0.21192574501037598, 0.12132573127746582, 0.09309443086385727, -0.5878331661224365, 0.4440993368625641, 0.08471012115478516, -0.7620744109153748, -0.38787662982940674, 0.6925508975982666, -0.9207741618156433, 0.19091875851154327, -0.019367527216672897, -0.686723530292511, -0.5502330660820007, -0.9471812844276428, 0.7175654768943787, -0.5632586479187012, -0.3855026066303253, -0.07500649243593216, -0.31755104660987854, 0.017752667888998985, -0.17585846781730652, 0.6445087194442749, -0.14235994219779968, -0.3085760772228241, -0.7317271828651428, -0.13452847301959991, -0.525233805179596, -0.32891297340393066, 0.4353844225406647, -0.941018283367157, -0.06282064318656921, 0.9428027272224426, 0.05754275619983673, -0.9355937242507935, 0.18910135328769684, -0.09981372952461243, 0.5269984602928162, 0.7211247682571411, -0.3960011899471283, -0.8316196203231812, 0.08012501150369644, 0.706688404083252, -0.22415441274642944, 0.1525546759366989, -0.9071454405784607, -0.20781727135181427, -1.0420693159103394, 0.471363365650177, 0.4837542474269867, -0.7424112558364868, 0.4029318392276764, -0.7413316965103149, 0.9257277846336365, -0.37865662574768066, 0.14958623051643372, 0.34521347284317017, -0.03994658961892128, 0.27381232380867004, 0.28600385785102844, -0.07320914417505264, 0.019378142431378365, -0.592917799949646, -0.936508297920227, 0.2877991795539856, -0.0073982649482786655, 0.15013274550437927, 0.5088106393814087, -0.6610172986984253, 0.2712153494358063, -1.178767442703247, 0.8668230772018433, 0.8650304675102234, -0.3028566539287567, -0.4426099359989166, 0.0707685798406601, 0.24533532559871674, 0.9774450063705444, -0.30224037170410156, 0.24705764651298523, -0.5553156733512878, -0.007516726851463318, -0.3211316168308258, -0.5101351737976074, -0.4321572780609131, -0.33904197812080383, 0.3682420253753662, 0.49987247586250305, -0.24731937050819397, -0.3753988742828369, -0.18942923843860626, -0.2557945251464844, -0.33898141980171204, 0.9587030410766602, -0.10725712776184082, 0.7322168946266174, 0.3240184187889099, -0.709266722202301, -0.6755451560020447, 0.7343869209289551, -0.1822165697813034, 0.26782333850860596, 0.12049605697393417, 0.4643287658691406, 0.06677466630935669, -1.463978886604309, 0.4853045344352722, 0.21640388667583466, -0.752024233341217, -0.5025302767753601, 0.22445715963840485, -0.44847506284713745, 0.7923851013183594, -0.043230876326560974, -0.5404738783836365, 0.9846609234809875, -0.8875620365142822, 0.647589385509491, -0.765856146812439, -0.2377038598060608, 0.23009037971496582, -0.5287006497383118, 0.23702815175056458, 0.15965977311134338, 0.17642219364643097, 0.600867509841919, -0.37945470213890076, 0.018173905089497566, -0.31346166133880615, 0.04744499921798706, -0.18170253932476044, -0.01957097090780735, -0.3216700255870819, -0.3678169548511505, 0.10433484613895416, -0.06886392086744308, 0.326532781124115, 0.08781834691762924, -0.5200920701026917, -0.38124433159828186, 1.3309974670410156, 0.6030126214027405, -0.9086402058601379, -0.5172718167304993, 0.1703162044286728, -0.07440836727619171, 0.1672404259443283, -0.20235690474510193, -0.5665972232818604, 0.9969615340232849, -0.1479920744895935, 0.19991226494312286, -0.6971195936203003, -1.1777271032333374, -0.13573478162288666, -0.13037890195846558, -0.0032602364663034678, -0.21035495400428772, 0.13690830767154694, 0.7882651090621948, -0.5558730959892273, -0.30058854818344116, -0.6521884799003601, 0.7541887164115906, -0.4198319911956787, -0.2035594880580902, -0.26898902654647827, 0.42415058612823486, -0.6719849109649658, -0.4526682496070862, -0.32428061962127686, -0.5155889987945557, -0.23038199543952942, 1.1173673868179321, -0.6645318865776062, 0.14146240055561066, 0.5695997476577759, 0.06276334077119827, 0.09736011922359467, 0.33282947540283203, -0.5244954228401184, -0.7726521492004395, -0.05047880485653877, 0.3267539143562317, 0.10258247703313828, 0.3883458971977234, 0.5955988764762878, -0.43360868096351624, 0.8650496602058411, -0.5530309677124023, -0.25799673795700073, 0.2631998658180237, 0.461137980222702, 0.3212822377681732, -0.7044457793235779, -0.6798637509346008, -1.038182020187378, 0.5434589385986328, -0.49176761507987976, -0.04634172469377518, -0.32121771574020386, -0.060545116662979126, 0.3989812731742859, -0.2795124053955078, -0.9837691783905029, 0.62063068151474, 0.17997144162654877, 0.11348458379507065, -0.008269144222140312, 0.24583052098751068, 0.1451084315776825, 0.13258643448352814, -0.2562790513038635, -0.06952688097953796, -0.04625333845615387, -1.0616109371185303, 0.6208287477493286, 0.46936047077178955, 0.2079179435968399, 0.07191600650548935, 0.5529978275299072, 0.7136176228523254, 0.40485629439353943, -0.5790008306503296, -0.5047198534011841, 1.4352800846099854, 0.20064020156860352, 1.006915807723999, 0.08997711539268494, -0.6035414338111877, -0.5984082221984863, -0.7901238799095154, -0.762823760509491, -0.5786623954772949, 0.5746129155158997, -0.3596673607826233, -0.3741310238838196, -0.7342061400413513, -0.09867484122514725, 0.04013504087924957, 0.6191667318344116, 0.5339335799217224, -0.37247568368911743, 0.06764575839042664, 0.40838623046875, 0.9170270562171936, -0.31913042068481445, -0.20691685378551483, 0.41791489720344543, -0.17647263407707214, -0.27612000703811646, -0.09819873422384262, -0.06903226673603058, 0.7047933340072632, 0.674031138420105, -0.06159919872879982, -0.41007664799690247, -0.1660306751728058, -0.022003082558512688, -0.020624076947569847, -0.27896764874458313, 0.5017208456993103, -0.9683981537818909, -0.34812283515930176, -0.21861879527568817, -0.09547734260559082, -0.31086406111717224, 0.025956856086850166, 0.09060636907815933, -0.6004071235656738, -1.16688072681427, 0.12241591513156891, 0.03256602585315704, -0.5185151100158691, 0.47007814049720764, -0.2584519386291504, 0.594199001789093, -0.1262856125831604, -0.3506777584552765, 0.7505940794944763, 0.5966911911964417, 0.5147850513458252, 0.020384950563311577, -0.019257832318544388, -0.12738165259361267, 0.9442114233970642, 0.4700225293636322, 0.13347525894641876, 0.8998243808746338, -0.08978898823261261, -0.5855852961540222, 0.15433642268180847, -0.7335403561592102, 0.8374295234680176, -0.6160048246383667, -0.3904593288898468, 0.08516581356525421, 0.3311830163002014, 0.4345676600933075, 0.4877602458000183, -0.48740702867507935, 0.187763050198555, -1.083663821220398, -0.5594391822814941, 0.4706709682941437, 0.19148321449756622, 0.5442841053009033, -0.029854588210582733, 0.28159788250923157, 0.29773402214050293, 0.5656476616859436, -0.33161672949790955, 0.5277515649795532, 1.1225024461746216, -0.17613589763641357, -0.5277844667434692, -0.07178337872028351, 0.14613954722881317, 0.043073542416095734, 0.3783530294895172, 0.5587185025215149, -0.11517146974802017, 0.14590229094028473, 0.1857309639453888, -0.08201438188552856, -0.36431819200515747, 0.5092340111732483, -0.07377330958843231, 0.18927331268787384, -0.29538577795028687, 0.18517239391803741, -0.7246608734130859, -0.5555925965309143, 0.6224766969680786, -0.5448305606842041, 0.11556866019964218, 0.31848058104515076, 0.5083682537078857, 0.058427345007658005, 0.1451997607946396, 0.36808767914772034, -0.8195757269859314, 0.5482956171035767, 0.8703121542930603, 0.30770036578178406, 0.06150425598025322, 0.20841310918331146, 0.1036996841430664, -0.5529139637947083, -0.26307177543640137, 0.42511701583862305, -0.06685170531272888, 0.22497238218784332, 0.0525830015540123, 0.11298020929098129, -0.08426492661237717, -0.22346282005310059, -0.9518401026725769, -0.16878657042980194, -0.015255657024681568, 0.15376627445220947, -0.3897452652454376, 0.33466026186943054, 0.9592698216438293, 0.26575547456741333, 0.16063068807125092, -0.7411829829216003, -0.7937837839126587, 0.14428892731666565, -0.3362111747264862, 0.3317403495311737, 0.6622252464294434, -0.2421647012233734, -0.4339744448661804, -0.7561923265457153, 0.3321360647678375, -0.3853468596935272, -0.7503951787948608, -0.5239509344100952, 0.5482707023620605, 0.25500917434692383, 1.3390992879867554, 0.21791572868824005, 0.028735265135765076, 0.09434428811073303, -0.45147445797920227, 0.7523044943809509, 0.3024406135082245, 0.7738733887672424, 0.39141252636909485, 0.6521518230438232, 0.25160208344459534, -0.36289337277412415, -0.022936100140213966, -0.6052546501159668, -0.16694681346416473, -0.27463194727897644, 0.5938630700111389, 0.10299257189035416, -0.526746392250061, 0.14916427433490753, 0.740333080291748, 0.08792009949684143, 0.180555060505867, -0.4901288151741028, -0.04037953168153763, -0.6741800904273987, 0.42505282163619995, -0.2753024697303772, -0.6609453558921814, -0.10151342302560806, -0.06840220838785172, 0.9231235384941101, -0.21929344534873962, 4.126342296600342, 0.9449998140335083, 0.6540492177009583, 0.04647832363843918, 0.5942608714103699, 0.325555682182312, 1.0505266189575195, -0.46095016598701477, -0.03878052532672882, -0.31059324741363525, -0.22636133432388306, -0.43097707629203796, 0.14630769193172455, 0.0003880120348185301, 0.2863723337650299, -0.3348791301250458, -1.2593226432800293, -0.5912335515022278, -0.19851921498775482, -0.8615302443504333, -0.5691958069801331, -0.20522236824035645, -0.27452245354652405, 0.13937591016292572, 0.20775191485881805, 0.21158890426158905, 0.4277395009994507, 1.081101417541504, 0.4583384394645691, -0.10320661216974258, -0.5195661187171936, -0.31137800216674805, 0.4539266526699066, -0.10700929164886475, -0.5501959323883057, 0.3702499568462372, -0.08484452962875366, -0.2325904220342636, -0.588464617729187, 0.14626003801822662, 0.8051415085792542, 0.681504487991333, -0.2670617997646332, 0.005644126329571009, -0.290894478559494, -0.02002500556409359, -0.5299754738807678, -0.2917215824127197, -0.07698114961385727, -0.45715269446372986, 0.757352352142334, -0.6985846757888794, 0.44690024852752686, 0.11085519939661026, -0.5218002796173096, -0.11264033615589142, 0.16159623861312866, -0.8474078178405762, 0.7543916702270508, 0.2908143103122711, 1.3009988069534302, 0.1976792812347412, -0.13490574061870575, -0.20283091068267822, -0.43496355414390564, 0.3736881911754608, 0.13080179691314697, 0.26494887471199036, 0.26430079340934753, -1.0855973958969116, -0.07373339682817459, -0.19797106087207794, -0.3521578311920166, 0.2755245566368103, 0.920573353767395, 0.14936122298240662, 0.1550702601671219, 0.9178351759910583, -0.16445080935955048, -1.1743718385696411, 0.20511513948440552, 0.25827252864837646, -0.5456889867782593, 0.19708357751369476, 0.20013660192489624, 0.3465524911880493, -0.8681150674819946, -0.07351990789175034, -0.8227694034576416, -0.14492668211460114, 0.04628120735287666, -0.17323586344718933, 0.21744383871555328, 0.31395912170410156, -0.061907559633255005 ]
{"Title": "Clinical Trial Evidence Supporting FDA Approval of Novel Therapeutic Agents Over Three Decades, 1995-2017: Cross-Sectional Analysis", "Authors": "Zhang Audrey D, Puthumana Jeremy, Downing Nicholas S, Shah Nilay D, Krumholz Harlan M, Ross Joseph S", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objective To evaluate whether characteristics of pivotal efficacy trials supporting US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of novel therapeutic agents have changed over the past three decades. Design Cross-sectional study. Setting and population Publicly available data on novel therapeutics approved by the FDA between 1995-1997, 2005-2007, and 2015-2017. Main outcome measures Use of randomization, blinding, types of comparators and primary endpoints, number of treated patients, and trial duration in pivotal trials supporting novel therapeutic approval, both individually and aggregated by each indication approval. Analyses were repeated stratifying by use of orphan designation and use of special regulatory programs. Results There were 273 novel therapeutics approved by the FDA in these 3 periods (107 in 1995-1997, 57 in 2005-2007, 109 in 2015-2017), representing 339 indications (157, 64, and 118, respectively). Overall, the proportion of indication approvals supported by at least 2 pivotal trials decreased (80.6% in 1995-1997, 60.3% in 2005-2007, 52.8% in 2015-2017; p<0.001). The proportion supported by only single-arm pivotal trials increased (4.0% in 1995-1997, 12.7% in 2005-2007, 17.0% in 2015-2017; p=0.001), as did the proportion supported by at least one pivotal trial of 6 months\u2019 duration (25.8% in 1995-1997, 34.9% in 2005-2007, 46.2% in 2015-2017; p=0.001). When stratified by use of special regulatory programs, pivotal trial characteristics changed over time in divergent ways, both individually and when aggregated by indication approvals. Conclusion More recent FDA approvals of novel therapeutics were based on fewer pivotal trials, with less rigorous designs but longer trial durations. These findings reinforce the importance of FDA\u2019s strategy for requiring ongoing evaluation of therapeutic safety and efficacy after approval. What is already known on this topic - Pivotal trial characteristics supporting US Food and Drug Administration approval of novel therapeutic agents vary widely across therapeutic characteristics. - A growing number of approvals make use of special regulatory programs that expedite the development and review of potentially transformative drugs, such as Fast Track, Priority Review, Accelerated Approval, and Breakthrough Designation. - Special regulatory programs often offer more flexible requirements for approval, such as requiring only a single pivotal trial or trials using surrogate endpoints. What this study adds - Over the past three decades, the characteristics of the aggregate pivotal trials supporting new drug approvals has changed, with more recent approvals requiring fewer trials of less rigorous design. - Differences in pivotal trial characteristics over time persist after accounting for the increasing use of special regulatory programs. - Divergent patterns are observed among approvals making use of special regulatory programs, for which more recent approvals have required fewer trials of less rigorous design, as compared to approvals using the standard pathway, for which more recent approvals have required trials of more rigorous design.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007047"}
10.1101/19012104
[ -0.4180622398853302, 0.3440832793712616, -0.2308150976896286, 0.30271321535110474, -0.710161030292511, -0.9879100322723389, 0.1567758470773697, 0.6670531630516052, -0.27099674940109253, 0.6051567792892456, -0.08426853269338608, -0.2818938195705414, 0.6233797669410706, 0.4216763973236084, 0.24152716994285583, -0.720431923866272, -0.9523842930793762, -0.6135281920433044, -0.39137002825737, -0.1582898497581482, 0.10304906219244003, 0.41495129466056824, -0.7393245100975037, -0.5056645274162292, -0.06718769669532776, 0.580528199672699, 0.15575642883777618, 0.040696632117033005, 1.1159391403198242, 0.3920726478099823, -0.07220030575990677, -0.789015531539917, 0.6998353004455566, -0.49411752820014954, -0.2779068350791931, 0.039118364453315735, 0.40255066752433777, -1.0271726846694946, -0.3543260097503662, -0.18179701268672943, 0.45089903473854065, -0.038556408137083054, 0.2767048478126526, -0.48117804527282715, -0.49669933319091797, -0.09581512957811356, -0.3986108899116516, -0.5654124021530151, 0.13724423944950104, -0.20129621028900146, -0.13478319346904755, -0.6006106734275818, 0.4068441390991211, -0.3672386705875397, 0.4019862413406372, 0.26916539669036865, 0.7724537253379822, -0.12445232272148132, -0.8223623633384705, 0.3785632848739624, 0.6271743774414062, -0.11439499258995056, 0.5682088732719421, -0.875519871711731, 1.0301954746246338, 0.005659046582877636, -0.11192940175533295, -1.0038524866104126, -0.31785866618156433, -0.3322276175022125, -0.08281167596578598, -0.16719691455364227, -0.6596401929855347, -0.6031538844108582, -0.6930673718452454, -0.13037428259849548, 0.36091750860214233, -0.4749448299407959, -0.3609710931777954, -0.2627963423728943, -0.3007996082305908, 0.33374089002609253, 0.4611106514930725, -0.2141811102628708, -0.6286997199058533, 0.007415681146085262, 1.0969609022140503, 1.0149835348129272, 0.6932530999183655, -0.06409075111150742, 0.45306649804115295, 0.04272637888789177, -0.1048964112997055, 0.7977734208106995, 0.12204108387231827, 1.511366844177246, -0.19500857591629028, 0.07730765640735626, -0.5509580969810486, -0.42607787251472473, 1.0917818546295166, 0.2643122673034668, -0.26494330167770386, 1.075360655784607, -0.7512969970703125, 0.6902730464935303, 1.3353238105773926, -0.2633383572101593, -0.01913348026573658, -0.3510982394218445, -0.5339594483375549, 0.21896661818027496, -0.19469976425170898, -0.7333585619926453, -0.3198639154434204, 0.8148460984230042, -0.4518428146839142, 0.8877569437026978, -0.7256350517272949, 0.5077905058860779, 0.05477915704250336, 0.1904025673866272, 0.6989153027534485, -0.22879700362682343, 0.17433175444602966, -0.45990103483200073, 0.5535531044006348, 0.3497322201728821, -0.8638702630996704, -0.3063996136188507, 0.47273868322372437, -0.7543583512306213, -0.6482002139091492, 0.40801551938056946, -0.4529178738594055, 0.1270250380039215, 0.0706433430314064, 1.326792597770691, 0.28962284326553345, -0.06737208366394043, -0.23781178891658783, 0.718997061252594, 0.2977212071418762, 1.3227187395095825, -0.1220741868019104, -0.1428476721048355, -0.6651735305786133, -0.33214840292930603, -0.5737218260765076, -0.0017537754029035568, 0.005140210967510939, 0.1896514743566513, 0.5132119655609131, 0.33188575506210327, 0.3377850651741028, -0.5400933027267456, -1.044006586074829, 0.37910157442092896, 0.3390362858772278, -0.09230807423591614, -1.2846932411193848, -0.06971053779125214, -0.5526767373085022, 0.9788855910301208, -0.07581238448619843, 0.01175990141928196, 0.10231932252645493, -0.04051864519715309, 0.9005701541900635, -0.43691983819007874, 0.7966458201408386, 0.016811801120638847, -0.24281582236289978, -0.18585045635700226, 0.5149258375167847, 1.0194392204284668, 0.93341064453125, -0.5087049603462219, 0.5095103979110718, 0.3871137797832489, -0.1214018315076828, 0.5708232522010803, 0.06015424430370331, 1.4449316263198853, -0.05822861194610596, -0.23607172071933746, -0.6474021673202515, -1.3458195924758911, -0.39983057975769043, -0.26464807987213135, 0.1889844536781311, 0.21778452396392822, -0.5328096747398376, 0.7846583724021912, 0.6000389456748962, 0.1567293107509613, -0.12098690122365952, 0.5375282764434814, 0.32063180208206177, -0.5292466282844543, -0.49523061513900757, 0.2314089834690094, -0.25624972581863403, 0.3422233760356903, 0.37309885025024414, 0.7967424988746643, -0.07859773188829422, 0.5437448024749756, -0.9279265999794006, -0.47135403752326965, 0.4898717403411865, 0.29185688495635986, -0.4480553865432739, -0.15357093513011932, 0.34927651286125183, -0.28550827503204346, -0.5896304845809937, -0.09679284691810608, -0.1282050609588623, -0.38589322566986084, -0.48901399970054626, 0.05690427124500275, 0.10572027415037155, -0.13940712809562683, -0.3754180669784546, -0.7178449034690857, 0.4121897220611572, -0.010691583156585693, 0.1472313553094864, 0.05083198472857475, 0.2091803401708603, 0.9262523651123047, 0.800438404083252, 0.36524221301078796, 1.1420749425888062, 0.4739636480808258, 0.2824647128582001, -0.348206102848053, 0.2083016037940979, 0.2575940191745758, 0.4477670192718506, 1.009561538696289, 0.5221962332725525, 0.32876357436180115, -0.12942056357860565, 0.4424948990345001, -0.28785768151283264, 0.45549434423446655, -0.10735108703374863, 0.17049193382263184, -0.6708081364631653, 0.7604566216468811, -0.07364867627620697, 0.6085252165794373, -1.0345114469528198, 0.16756442189216614, 0.9301140308380127, 0.22410866618156433, -0.41473034024238586, -0.5541089773178101, -0.7170504927635193, -0.11424989998340607, 0.1696132868528366, -0.022207560017704964, 1.1469954252243042, 0.364862322807312, 0.31163489818573, 0.563339114189148, -0.43915173411369324, -0.4194749593734741, -0.348065048456192, -0.6798154711723328, -1.3091745376586914, -0.803695797920227, -0.9797758460044861, 0.381818950176239, 0.5231882929801941, 0.07345755398273468, 0.2641433775424957, -0.015940459445118904, 0.19611594080924988, 0.09199605137109756, 0.21402651071548462, 0.841408371925354, 0.3429546654224396, 0.14239199459552765, -1.2197538614273071, -0.5592663884162903, 0.361657977104187, 0.13748416304588318, 0.34033191204071045, 0.08472233265638351, -0.5018529295921326, -0.4737837016582489, 0.9858073592185974, -0.5428954362869263, 0.15806955099105835, -0.3901705741882324, 0.10821027308702469, -0.8577627539634705, 0.4409763514995575, -0.44701430201530457, 0.0371890552341938, 0.1318294256925583, -0.976556122303009, 0.622316300868988, 1.0497756004333496, 0.24759145081043243, 0.23822440207004547, 0.12365630269050598, -0.11291759461164474, -0.08092958480119705, 0.04541032016277313, 0.387898713350296, -0.8677583932876587, -0.17708948254585266, 0.15720851719379425, -0.4340501129627228, 0.14176610112190247, -0.5861002802848816, -0.5427499413490295, -1.2213380336761475, 0.53011554479599, -0.41093793511390686, -0.5461090207099915, -0.28396984934806824, 1.0405194759368896, -1.7365667819976807, 0.11083287000656128, -0.48741698265075684, -0.7185138463973999, 0.3054306209087372, -0.5964340567588806, 0.11933407932519913, 0.1420634388923645, -0.012834317982196808, -0.19079828262329102, -0.8730226755142212, 0.06176663562655449, -0.1701316237449646, 0.06334573030471802, -1.224429726600647, 0.41288119554519653, -0.2941414713859558, 0.10677358508110046, 0.48245587944984436, 0.22553670406341553, -0.19966524839401245, -0.30173641443252563, -0.23778092861175537, -0.44900646805763245, 0.5087336897850037, 1.2192617654800415, -0.4218190014362335, 0.3467260003089905, 0.9451003670692444, -0.04994896054267883, 0.4303326904773712, 0.48567572236061096, 0.17942704260349274, 0.06624752283096313, 0.5205674171447754, -0.32890549302101135, -0.19375339150428772, -0.36637359857559204, -0.8172219395637512, 0.5711926817893982, -0.5262941718101501, 1.059815526008606, -0.15972189605236053, 0.38359835743904114, -0.8492182493209839, 0.6859357357025146, 0.4535104036331177, 0.16422036290168762, 0.15887659788131714, 1.3228226900100708, 0.13312670588493347, 1.323182225227356, -1.4352847337722778, 0.5685350298881531, 0.323897123336792, 0.9790881276130676, 0.17286068201065063, 0.07913897931575775, 0.4795874357223511, -0.45466309785842896, -0.024298692122101784, -0.0714593455195427, 0.026564588770270348, -0.028798861429095268, -0.15042538940906525, 0.07601403445005417, 0.15706080198287964, -0.8308312296867371, -0.10265263170003891, 0.12471923232078552, 0.48685845732688904, 0.7495476603507996, -0.5170779228210449, 1.1244748830795288, -0.6851258277893066, 0.49298572540283203, 0.5599964261054993, -0.15350578725337982, -0.011341406032443047, -0.2701573967933655, 0.13441894948482513, 0.14309591054916382, -0.6540204286575317, -0.21251878142356873, 0.1629885733127594, -0.7787075638771057, -0.028531670570373535, 0.39582985639572144, -0.38131389021873474, -0.6771828532218933, -0.5180171728134155, -0.806996762752533, 0.15036432445049286, 0.04354199394583702, -0.05474042892456055, -0.1245097815990448, 0.29160648584365845, 0.3596237897872925, -0.3392210900783539, -0.17580489814281464, -0.565234899520874, 1.0363688468933105, 0.8446686863899231, 0.12339870631694794, -0.910048246383667, -0.5311533212661743, -0.6032464504241943, -0.5944381952285767, -0.02033010683953762, 0.1471989005804062, 0.28196799755096436, 0.2802317142486572, -0.6203426718711853, 0.24835895001888275, -0.9181716442108154, -0.19243574142456055, 0.5188924074172974, 0.055473946034908295, 0.4119488000869751, 0.44816914200782776, -0.21517932415008545, 0.5218390226364136, 0.10558394342660904, 0.29334357380867004, -0.2924652099609375, 0.507070779800415, -0.03844573348760605, -0.7643120288848877, -0.13625116646289825, 0.31317660212516785, 0.014562765136361122, -0.8345516920089722, -0.7375006675720215, -0.30343788862228394, -0.246636301279068, -0.05283448100090027, 0.012246963568031788, 0.19613173604011536, 0.9661521911621094, -1.2321972846984863, -0.32455000281333923, 1.0982000827789307, -0.44412481784820557, -0.39512795209884644, -0.059523336589336395, -0.27474352717399597, -0.626085102558136, 0.08763211965560913, -0.0220955740660429, 0.4966432452201843, -0.3313101828098297, 0.21895310282707214, -0.19204676151275635, 0.5438054203987122, 0.6150546073913574, -0.4768085777759552, -0.16671232879161835, -0.6587722301483154, -1.0858947038650513, -0.3864331841468811, -0.45096948742866516, -0.7926892638206482, 0.7023150324821472, -0.3435416519641876, -0.7803352475166321, 0.029368635267019272, 0.09386194497346878, -0.18892242014408112, 0.3690812289714813, -0.16160063445568085, 0.1162857934832573, -0.48876699805259705, 0.20521202683448792, 0.4983232617378235, -0.4210774004459381, -0.2980688810348511, -0.6058724522590637, 1.00237238407135, -0.33528420329093933, -0.6675823926925659, 0.062162477523088455, 0.32955801486968994, 0.3094625174999237, -0.5968965888023376, 0.5207896828651428, -0.8155837059020996, 0.45831525325775146, 0.11034856736660004, -0.022199207916855812, 0.9317838549613953, -0.37273848056793213, -1.0003753900527954, 0.5922009944915771, -0.06471113115549088, -0.8182892799377441, -0.6165525317192078, 0.4496190845966339, 0.35269391536712646, -0.269408643245697, -0.5331499576568604, -0.24280217289924622, -1.1106288433074951, -1.5626020431518555, 0.19542115926742554, -0.6295906901359558, 0.3786305785179138, -0.8187614679336548, -0.4774489402770996, -0.17377232015132904, 0.15240107476711273, 0.20187485218048096, 0.18374356627464294, -0.3266487121582031, -0.7005199790000916, 0.9870851039886475, 0.18472768366336823, 0.15668390691280365, 0.15713036060333252, -0.6124870181083679, 0.4473056197166443, 1.027816653251648, 1.3556969165802002, 0.4301266372203827, -0.01854001171886921, 0.3220825791358948, 0.6241084933280945, 0.20339404046535492, -0.07795780897140503, 0.0457918643951416, -0.567573606967926, 0.463704377412796, -0.3283853232860565, -0.2903953790664673, -1.1991294622421265, 1.2661381959915161, -0.5373458862304688, -0.2030407041311264, 0.18372075259685516, -0.7213989496231079, 0.030626237392425537, -0.5460153222084045, 0.77594393491745, -0.4820038378238678, 0.6353921294212341, -0.03131125867366791, -0.18007375299930573, 0.32750049233436584, -0.12613803148269653, -0.5124790668487549, -0.34604009985923767, -0.986686110496521, -0.9088693261146545, 0.3999637961387634, -0.0064085121266543865, 0.18874943256378174, -0.02887779287993908, -0.1938566118478775, 0.6952064633369446, -0.18326503038406372, 0.9846917390823364, 0.9156390428543091, -0.761905312538147, -0.49207261204719543, 0.11381297558546066, 0.3080686032772064, 0.19301831722259521, 0.48547276854515076, 0.4516220986843109, 0.05724598467350006, 0.03494173660874367, -0.6256526708602905, -0.7136031985282898, -0.7882901430130005, -0.37359774112701416, -0.19742342829704285, 0.8011366128921509, -0.4395499527454376, 0.32792189717292786, -0.12644989788532257, -0.30490055680274963, -1.4242112636566162, 0.5025940537452698, -0.034889981150627136, 0.6631656885147095, 1.4893885850906372, -0.1012917309999466, -0.43577584624290466, 0.4096090793609619, 0.3446439504623413, 0.7043172121047974, -0.5227054953575134, 0.673504650592804, 0.5888822078704834, -0.6315244436264038, 0.38937824964523315, 0.2364543229341507, -1.0321778059005737, -0.3459455966949463, -0.6305273175239563, -0.6051200032234192, 0.3152042627334595, -0.5074355006217957, -0.7374969720840454, 0.20259439945220947, -0.1543528139591217, 0.8399254679679871, 0.04722670838236809, -0.30209851264953613, 0.4875996708869934, -0.4771248996257782, 0.20104125142097473, -0.7276540398597717, -0.18196532130241394, 0.4353107810020447, 0.02245531789958477, 0.8038221597671509, 0.09691786020994186, 0.31705811619758606, 0.7126116156578064, -0.43360137939453125, 0.5435189604759216, -0.8925389051437378, 0.2907833755016327, -0.307573139667511, -0.10834841430187225, 0.024973783642053604, -0.22834515571594238, -0.5995213389396667, 0.5130535960197449, -0.23878547549247742, -0.03515464439988136, -0.9930471181869507, -0.5314436554908752, 0.3811812102794647, 0.6887233853340149, -0.3782159388065338, 0.33913537859916687, 0.9199000597000122, 0.6665416359901428, 0.2105061411857605, -0.0028883826453238726, -0.3892037570476532, -0.989474892616272, -0.9141352772712708, -0.19615286588668823, -0.39352402091026306, -0.9064693450927734, 0.47328099608421326, -0.14392884075641632, -1.3077512979507446, -0.744735836982727, 0.9314826130867004, -0.5229294896125793, 0.15020066499710083, -0.8547441363334656, 0.9353757500648499, -0.6549745202064514, -0.4570092260837555, -0.27140942215919495, -0.5526432394981384, -0.17265234887599945, 0.9121344089508057, -0.6116562485694885, -0.2529653012752533, -0.19036628305912018, -0.3839511573314667, 0.36167895793914795, 0.7407445311546326, -0.2765595614910126, -0.7085782885551453, -0.5336189866065979, 0.2973979413509369, -0.494038462638855, -0.294417142868042, 0.8903651237487793, -0.19451270997524261, 0.6284830570220947, 0.4497204124927521, -0.1834794580936432, -0.0008263385389000177, 0.4037627875804901, 0.037054192274808884, -0.46877923607826233, -0.7716661691665649, 0.2001664936542511, 0.5903528332710266, -0.6453893780708313, -0.3387034833431244, -0.9338481426239014, -0.5032083988189697, -0.7063546180725098, -1.0753846168518066, -0.027633512392640114, 0.23921068012714386, -0.3502821922302246, 0.532550573348999, 0.3671938180923462, 0.8203643560409546, 0.0399426594376564, 0.22653499245643616, 0.49106764793395996, 0.3798966705799103, 0.2757732570171356, -0.6196492314338684, -0.038587138056755066, -0.061637625098228455, -0.07500340789556503, 0.5610019564628601, -0.10084281116724014, -0.20602580904960632, 0.45705804228782654, -0.12472200393676758, 0.30476656556129456, 0.41764190793037415, 0.004860428627580404, 0.5838229656219482, 0.3465568423271179, -0.688216507434845, -0.6329852342605591, -0.368144154548645, -1.0841848850250244, 0.14298442006111145, 0.6330612897872925, -0.5474131107330322, -0.26209568977355957, -0.5561437010765076, -0.7933340668678284, 1.0806185007095337, 0.15200011432170868, 0.023413674905896187, 0.2930985391139984, 1.1079113483428955, -0.46438926458358765, 0.5103330016136169, 0.9640437960624695, 0.3515571653842926, -0.027890542522072792, 0.017599841579794884, 0.06393039226531982, -0.37197524309158325, 0.1294887512922287, 0.4596512019634247, -0.005405941512435675, 0.3650185465812683, -0.8848301768302917, -0.29923805594444275, 0.2090141773223877, -0.544708788394928, 0.7350349426269531, 0.31712502241134644, -0.2788451313972473, 0.14020726084709167, -0.16072921454906464, 0.2935637831687927, -0.963026225566864, 0.5274822115898132, 0.6466981768608093, -1.2940751314163208, -0.69640052318573, 0.5392818450927734, 0.6535225510597229, 0.307262659072876, 0.16378241777420044, -0.8885104656219482, 0.4702000617980957, -0.5334908366203308, 0.15939174592494965, 0.1625223457813263, 0.48799368739128113, 0.3324691653251648, -0.007636673748493195, -0.02560952492058277, 0.2588653862476349, 0.4806361198425293, 0.49315178394317627, 0.5322737097740173, 0.370733380317688, -0.13360460102558136, -0.005870610475540161, 0.3792458474636078, -0.8059764504432678, 0.6045151948928833, -0.17649124562740326, -1.0422216653823853, -0.13364695012569427, -0.016231929883360863, 0.7563945055007935, 0.03623771294951439, -0.7977924942970276, 0.4355457127094269, -0.10297855734825134, -0.4451765716075897, -0.4651389420032501, 0.5042659044265747, 0.639768123626709, -0.039405595511198044, 0.02199322171509266, 0.07409115135669708, 0.09260772168636322, -0.32235798239707947, -0.026599854230880737, 0.506337583065033, -0.2408151775598526, -0.3470955789089203, -0.24972063302993774, 0.7868564128875732, -0.2226400524377823, -0.39350423216819763, -0.16084665060043335, -0.21611563861370087, -0.44153517484664917, 0.7210187911987305, 0.062069423496723175, 0.27714842557907104, 0.7227323055267334, -0.7802882790565491, 0.1852787286043167, 0.40549200773239136, -0.2276032716035843, -0.25142937898635864, -0.3205990195274353, 0.6053598523139954, 0.31716760993003845, 0.25060272216796875, 0.14981822669506073, -0.1244237869977951, -0.050184380263090134, -0.4080435335636139, 0.8705222606658936, -0.4758751094341278, 0.04472663253545761, 1.1159694194793701, -0.32108771800994873, -0.10090876370668411, -0.15195687115192413, -0.03019816055893898, 0.007293354719877243, -0.5535854697227478, 0.4184190630912781, 0.4306500554084778, 0.20637734234333038, -0.1830061972141266, -0.0036937599070370197, -0.05468900501728058, 0.2499929815530777, -0.7536658644676208, -0.12338390946388245, -0.2967522442340851, 0.5340434312820435, -0.06039432808756828, 0.01897999458014965, -0.35249099135398865, 0.039816707372665405, 0.2959323227405548, -0.33974555134773254, -0.5804309248924255, 0.5699544548988342, -0.3964954912662506, 0.030917078256607056, -0.3044086992740631, -0.5289527773857117, -0.39032450318336487, -0.648975133895874, -0.4163437485694885, 0.023009156808257103, -0.308096319437027, -0.5362616181373596, 0.5897814035415649, 0.42537879943847656, 0.22457121312618256, 0.141830176115036, 0.27699291706085205, -0.7498059272766113, 0.8133949041366577, 1.062532901763916, -0.9509207010269165, 0.7191938757896423, -0.06298832595348358, -0.17991967499256134, 0.40227729082107544, -0.271079957485199, -0.37265926599502563, 0.5539063811302185, -0.5636273622512817, -0.1266290545463562, 0.34995898604393005, -0.16296635568141937, -0.5821408033370972, 0.03317887336015701, 0.5817764401435852, -0.037716906517744064, 0.3062629699707031, -0.3684152066707611, -0.41739997267723083, -0.24356235563755035, 1.2675328254699707, -0.3678945302963257, 0.03441028296947479, 0.27747732400894165, 0.004668875597417355, 0.3523058593273163, -1.1239171028137207, 3.9847571849823, 0.21328231692314148, 0.5690279006958008, -0.015320409089326859, 0.6239882111549377, 0.17760737240314484, 0.8904553651809692, 0.232322558760643, 0.8437812924385071, 0.7696689963340759, -0.36385130882263184, 0.2783098518848419, 0.19603680074214935, -0.5010898113250732, 0.7606039643287659, 0.6989126801490784, -1.2044872045516968, 0.21248683333396912, -0.030330296605825424, -0.8976718187332153, 0.5186046957969666, 0.0692378431558609, 0.028572753071784973, 0.05376914143562317, 0.3025665581226349, 0.09099307656288147, 0.635956883430481, 0.15812399983406067, 0.31277039647102356, -0.2024429589509964, 0.09245619177818298, -0.4576749801635742, 0.2713787257671356, 0.1915426403284073, -0.42643460631370544, 0.6217411160469055, -0.26284298300743103, -0.46532443165779114, -0.09674984216690063, 0.0949268639087677, 0.31622689962387085, -0.10480883717536926, -0.18415598571300507, -0.6981825232505798, 0.12826642394065857, 0.0761982649564743, -0.5552116632461548, 0.2599630057811737, 0.15293489396572113, -0.19357284903526306, -0.12202684581279755, -0.6257471442222595, 0.48649367690086365, -0.09456951171159744, -1.1187477111816406, -0.29186388850212097, -0.3612525165081024, -1.0946462154388428, 0.47781074047088623, 0.3704628050327301, 0.5447933673858643, -0.17737330496311188, -0.37203434109687805, 0.13802936673164368, -0.005163067951798439, 0.5446570515632629, 0.000029149763577152044, -0.5719315409660339, 0.3465050458908081, 0.02142384648323059, -0.2976687252521515, 0.0974726751446724, -0.3464367985725403, -0.503646194934845, 0.2222023606300354, 1.0210365056991577, -0.03855329751968384, 0.7383144497871399, 0.10034556686878204, -0.46606698632240295, -0.4031967520713806, 0.1448618322610855, 0.35785606503486633, 0.251098096370697, 0.3619976043701172, 0.7214459180831909, -0.8097383379936218, 0.17571572959423065, -1.0866901874542236, 0.10244579613208771, 0.38413792848587036, -0.22090981900691986, 0.5275757312774658, 0.19569312036037445, -0.03551902249455452 ]
{"Title": "Is There a Health Inequality in Gambling Related Harms? A Systematic Review", "Authors": "Raybould J. N, Larkin M, Tunney R. J", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objective Here we present a systematic review of the existing research into gambling harms, in order to determine whether there are differences in the presentation of these across demographic groups such as age, gender, culture, and socioeconomic status, or gambling behaviour categories such as risk severity and play frequency. Primary and Secondary Outcome Measures: Inclusion criteria were: 1) focus on gambling harms; 2) focus on harms to the gambler rather than affected others; 3) discussion of specific listed harms and not just harms in general terms. Exclusion criteria were: 1) research of non-human subjects; 2) not written in English; 3) not an empirical study; 3) not available as a full article. Search We conducted a systematic search using the Web of Science and Scopus databases in February 2020. Assessment of quality took place using Standard Quality Assessment Criteria. Results 56 studies published between 1994 and 2019 met the inclusion criteria. These were categorised into thematic groups for comparison and discussion. There were replicated differences found in groups defined by age, socioeconomic status, education level, ethnicity and culture, risk severity, and gambling behaviours. Conclusion Harms appear to be dependent on specific social, demographic and environmental conditions that suggests there is a health inequality in gambling related harms. Further investigation is required to develop standardised measurement tools and to understand confounding variables and co-morbidities. With a robust understanding of harms distribution in the population, Primary Care Workers will be better equipped to identify those who are at risk, or who are showing signs of Gambling Disorder, and to target prevention and intervention programmes appropriately.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012104"}
10.1101/19002998
[ 0.6130892038345337, 0.6718680262565613, 0.5219969749450684, 1.1428124904632568, -0.6080549359321594, -0.31490981578826904, 0.10919080674648285, -0.01861359179019928, 0.7737991809844971, 0.5708484053611755, -0.10431269556283951, -0.17558574676513672, 0.3313979208469391, -0.10683437436819077, -0.5736687183380127, 0.6134477257728577, 0.018895208835601807, -0.5051817297935486, -0.29551175236701965, -0.4032733738422394, 0.12363830208778381, 0.8276098966598511, -0.7198535203933716, 0.24175342917442322, -0.9928672313690186, 0.6518410444259644, 0.17841899394989014, 0.14537392556667328, 1.0641862154006958, 0.38525769114494324, 0.023418745025992393, -0.6554042100906372, 0.09388051927089691, -0.7715980410575867, -0.13614870607852936, 0.008446176536381245, 0.9300400614738464, -0.3790016770362854, -0.19528579711914062, -0.37090635299682617, 0.3330657184123993, 0.2522231340408325, 0.3016022741794586, -0.3417680263519287, -0.6370537877082825, -0.9042040109634399, -0.43912217020988464, 0.15046943724155426, -0.06787455081939697, -0.09827864170074463, -0.5179409980773926, -0.11962445080280304, 0.01973019726574421, -0.26597335934638977, 0.0152265140786767, -0.02060929872095585, -0.018766166642308235, -0.1528892070055008, -0.8798969388008118, 0.4197278916835785, 0.35481441020965576, -0.42007797956466675, -0.2206345647573471, -0.869949996471405, 0.7519258260726929, 0.6566975712776184, -0.011553807184100151, -0.1250690072774887, 0.27456405758857727, -0.6763824820518494, -0.10941826552152634, 0.34784528613090515, -0.36397701501846313, -0.19727098941802979, -0.07783310115337372, -0.5805284976959229, 0.5905816555023193, 0.542857825756073, 0.06592143326997757, -0.4236176609992981, -0.30056315660476685, 0.05631280690431595, -0.007317321375012398, 0.34474411606788635, -0.20310086011886597, -0.1809016764163971, 0.05690076947212219, -0.26248258352279663, 0.8953515291213989, -0.18930716812610626, -0.2274249792098999, 0.321265310049057, -0.4529091715812683, -0.3302692174911499, -0.24856114387512207, 0.44138896465301514, -0.7110286355018616, 0.12403437495231628, -0.15048642456531525, -0.39943674206733704, 0.6963826417922974, 0.49280431866645813, 0.12776468694210052, 0.4782487154006958, -0.6729869842529297, 0.8526052236557007, 1.1594847440719604, 0.051638033241033554, -0.5001252293586731, -0.6406090259552002, 0.1534961760044098, 0.07510168105363846, -0.7466424107551575, 0.4448094666004181, -0.21034538745880127, 0.20276790857315063, -0.47754183411598206, 0.72626793384552, 0.26176515221595764, 0.2497084140777588, -0.23388756811618805, -0.1489003747701645, 0.8508196473121643, -0.07434504479169846, -0.5416526794433594, -0.45659151673316956, -0.578540563583374, 0.6457913517951965, -0.20823299884796143, -0.07765822112560272, 0.2615402936935425, -0.6464811563491821, -0.49007341265678406, 0.6307904720306396, -0.4969806671142578, 0.19287344813346863, 0.01643996872007847, 0.4082202911376953, 0.08291149139404297, -0.5923412442207336, 0.08064822107553482, 0.29634687304496765, -0.6419626474380493, 1.2575699090957642, -0.3879474103450775, 0.9824381470680237, -0.43571004271507263, -1.2297488451004028, 0.36436665058135986, 0.13912977278232574, -0.8210269808769226, 0.4097695052623749, 0.1673460304737091, 0.08674707263708115, -0.20445984601974487, 0.3673512637615204, -0.33295491337776184, 0.20742419362068176, -0.29442211985588074, 0.3932749032974243, -0.21268802881240845, 0.1454511135816574, -0.3241490423679352, 0.26569321751594543, -0.377983957529068, 0.9550831317901611, 0.3326997756958008, 0.3933984935283661, 0.5544285774230957, -0.4175688624382019, 0.5537854433059692, -0.2631544768810272, -0.0614173449575901, 0.1391967535018921, 0.4673795998096466, 0.7254635691642761, 1.2094216346740723, 0.7422413229942322, 0.08226237446069717, 0.6119764447212219, -0.046768926084041595, -0.20291796326637268, 0.03139583021402359, 0.8676864504814148, 0.011680963449180126, 0.6943826079368591, -0.05414143577218056, -0.39963969588279724, 0.028813714161515236, -0.7781499624252319, -0.2976627051830292, 0.2814546823501587, -0.9845527410507202, 0.8118454813957214, -0.8208930492401123, -0.2640823721885681, -0.3553032875061035, 0.46564868092536926, 0.2801317274570465, -0.03750317916274071, -0.24917759001255035, 0.03292052447795868, -0.4550679326057434, 0.12927784025669098, -0.1501532346010208, 0.8745371699333191, 0.4591505527496338, 0.13149353861808777, -0.43239203095436096, 0.3460092544555664, 0.5512735247612, -0.4839475154876709, -0.5846778154373169, -0.0013698387192562222, 0.227773055434227, -0.740716814994812, -0.40944069623947144, 0.589302122592926, 0.11465442180633545, 0.16865384578704834, 0.3087214231491089, -0.49042844772338867, 0.6508026719093323, 0.24925866723060608, 0.33709555864334106, -0.17279882729053497, -0.1860891878604889, -0.05648953095078468, 0.047748975455760956, -0.5170927047729492, -0.05239841341972351, 1.0632573366165161, -0.2825380861759186, 0.8769093751907349, 0.5423896312713623, 0.1645413190126419, 0.2532612383365631, 0.4813854396343231, -0.5642653107643127, -0.23435530066490173, 0.295646607875824, 0.298221617937088, 0.2336818128824234, 0.27894386649131775, -0.48134177923202515, 0.5725142955780029, -0.5201655626296997, -0.3372231423854828, -0.2565544843673706, 0.5664054751396179, -0.3002675771713257, 0.7804498076438904, 1.004946231842041, 0.12335564196109772, -1.033766508102417, -0.044757917523384094, 0.08455373346805573, 0.23712310194969177, -0.005040579475462437, 0.05871112644672394, 0.24725933372974396, 0.7264160513877869, -0.21380384266376495, 0.18136833608150482, 0.9284997582435608, 0.2274434119462967, 0.16339099407196045, 0.044092755764722824, 0.335161954164505, -0.17533355951309204, -0.25294721126556396, -0.8416820764541626, -1.15984308719635, -0.7006535530090332, -0.5637611746788025, -0.8449805974960327, 0.5179765224456787, -0.537586510181427, 0.6694239377975464, -0.004699337296187878, 0.3074529767036438, -1.3089286088943481, 0.326472669839859, 0.40176934003829956, 0.36377620697021484, 0.5231742262840271, -0.8803792595863342, -0.2724650502204895, -0.3763723075389862, 0.47893449664115906, -0.4047165513038635, -0.5022720098495483, -0.4713509678840637, -0.39048296213150024, -0.06399250775575638, -0.20901277661323547, 0.26833149790763855, -0.8055047392845154, -0.2860803008079529, -0.1567898541688919, -0.48953956365585327, 0.05597599968314171, -0.2171199470758438, -0.32650765776634216, -0.48077520728111267, 0.35290616750717163, -0.11922913789749146, 0.15161222219467163, 0.4034106731414795, 0.5954218506813049, -0.6801036596298218, 0.6458708047866821, 0.7227653861045837, -0.21268761157989502, -0.6883885264396667, 0.10052032023668289, 0.9865624308586121, -0.2866813540458679, -0.09785141050815582, -1.1660248041152954, -1.2710195779800415, -0.19101524353027344, 0.16547535359859467, -0.8362027406692505, 0.16512681543827057, 0.10819263756275177, -0.46388328075408936, -1.115328311920166, 0.04699196293950081, -0.19181941449642181, -1.2980802059173584, 0.004953301046043634, 0.35005709528923035, -0.0829944834113121, -0.5040881037712097, 0.2190975397825241, 0.15110398828983307, -0.6791269183158875, 0.11888939142227173, -0.07669331878423691, 0.571829617023468, -0.4483073353767395, -0.12644726037979126, 0.8306312561035156, 0.5705236196517944, 0.9034666419029236, 0.6855901479721069, -0.2705596089363098, 0.16917480528354645, -0.11709179729223251, -0.6518749594688416, 0.01771731860935688, 0.4136698842048645, -0.031047845259308815, 0.35663682222366333, 0.058383919298648834, 0.806617796421051, 0.3586709797382355, -0.11922355741262436, 0.35926491022109985, -0.7486079335212708, 0.18282490968704224, 0.31955042481422424, 0.016310591250658035, -1.0263700485229492, -0.39010846614837646, -0.3128262162208557, 0.09042946249246597, 0.5748389959335327, -1.2765768766403198, 0.15184910595417023, 0.6363419890403748, 0.27753281593322754, 0.3586745858192444, 0.35701221227645874, -0.03402356803417206, 1.2632299661636353, -0.4303189516067505, 1.424847960472107, -0.9873130917549133, 0.5460830926895142, 0.7643130421638489, 1.178505778312683, 0.17963626980781555, -0.06844325363636017, 0.3318701982498169, -0.4032187759876251, 0.23121705651283264, -0.18138320744037628, 0.20548422634601593, 0.2722945511341095, -0.5027574300765991, -0.4559739828109741, 0.4624790847301483, -0.3353734314441681, 0.03808043524622917, 0.0045402138493955135, 0.7842748761177063, 0.0898936539888382, 0.3559465706348419, 1.24313485622406, -0.3667460083961487, 0.4185338318347931, 0.1053110659122467, 0.3859710693359375, -0.2522759437561035, -0.3506576120853424, 0.3975799083709717, 0.2989807426929474, 0.015540774911642075, 0.12096831202507019, 0.24880161881446838, -0.0673479214310646, 0.3387390673160553, 0.07223082333803177, 0.19152763485908508, -0.17720600962638855, 0.026678314432501793, -0.8895845413208008, -0.1012132316827774, 0.39453020691871643, 0.12756983935832977, -0.5203337073326111, -0.4511774182319641, 0.9151585102081299, 0.14108125865459442, 0.2101098597049713, -0.5834891200065613, 0.46162188053131104, 1.0874091386795044, -0.6712700128555298, -0.21649675071239471, -0.4866710305213928, 0.12109673768281937, -0.12199097126722336, -0.17703717947006226, 0.36027005314826965, 0.48219722509384155, 0.1937892735004425, -0.46489012241363525, -0.35933756828308105, -0.8253763914108276, -0.316732257604599, -0.23839080333709717, -0.1094297394156456, 0.6574547290802002, 1.2646164894104004, -0.06268375366926193, 0.29082539677619934, 0.03915480896830559, 0.6813910603523254, -1.314490556716919, 0.748802661895752, -0.11234478652477264, -1.1153740882873535, -0.1491796374320984, -0.259949266910553, 0.6654432415962219, 0.5898780822753906, -0.002943693660199642, -0.8764752149581909, -0.21157680451869965, 0.5781508088111877, -0.979862630367279, -0.15642577409744263, 1.235344409942627, -0.19347316026687622, -0.01156698353588581, 1.7359837293624878, -0.3955132067203522, -0.25780928134918213, 0.20654474198818207, 0.5130903720855713, -1.0093092918395996, 0.40411049127578735, 0.11443088948726654, 0.2230868935585022, -0.11775103211402893, -0.7090688347816467, -0.4140631854534149, -0.03811819478869438, 0.43625596165657043, -0.4012320041656494, -0.45471909642219543, 0.143714040517807, -0.6648880243301392, -0.7236904501914978, -0.832697868347168, -0.42391327023506165, 0.9009440541267395, -0.004786691628396511, -0.20318973064422607, 0.2009935826063156, -0.03257278725504875, -0.7763249278068542, -0.03586656600236893, -0.1436137706041336, 0.3055049777030945, -1.0567796230316162, -0.4414379596710205, 0.5398315191268921, -1.439152717590332, -0.3671400547027588, 0.9153906106948853, 0.3084469437599182, -0.3332349359989166, 0.14020071923732758, -0.3866351544857025, -0.7141214609146118, -0.4530164301395416, 0.1600123941898346, 0.3602413535118103, -0.5760629177093506, 0.03499128669500351, -0.4057377278804779, -0.2550707757472992, 0.2901386022567749, 0.771298885345459, -0.07001392543315887, 0.7920264601707458, -0.13829340040683746, -0.43074679374694824, -0.7742664813995361, 0.35054099559783936, 0.2915191352367401, 0.5382363200187683, 0.18418902158737183, -0.4448525905609131, -0.018810681998729706, -0.7191657423973083, 0.30717265605926514, 0.02667836658656597, 0.1018211618065834, -1.0244234800338745, -0.12390318512916565, -0.29152631759643555, 0.03622863441705704, 0.17673692107200623, -0.5196791887283325, 0.011703536845743656, -0.35522669553756714, 0.07411311566829681, 0.10713796317577362, -0.47218000888824463, -0.8500729203224182, -0.5340842604637146, -0.07604126632213593, 1.0969793796539307, 0.4117330312728882, -0.4232219457626343, -0.25148487091064453, -0.23769283294677734, 0.27711933851242065, 0.2165840119123459, -0.30499786138534546, -1.1188932657241821, 0.23823897540569305, 0.7748781442642212, -0.01617576740682125, -0.6257891654968262, -0.2625265419483185, -0.1556502878665924, -0.5462172031402588, 0.4400930106639862, -0.35613033175468445, -0.9873759150505066, 0.10353097319602966, -0.3402750790119171, 1.0621626377105713, -0.13796283304691315, 0.29325026273727417, 0.4898902475833893, 0.48291686177253723, 0.12186602503061295, 0.6729069948196411, -0.6523653864860535, 0.05829838663339615, -0.942829966545105, -1.2245304584503174, 0.6136777997016907, -0.20139962434768677, 0.2087000161409378, 0.24195349216461182, 0.165114164352417, 0.014135999605059624, -0.9788171648979187, 1.1692097187042236, 0.5298212766647339, -0.5387458801269531, -0.36958006024360657, -0.2516862750053406, 0.271499365568161, 0.5580794811248779, 0.058779824525117874, -0.3936227262020111, -0.17875374853610992, -0.058168720453977585, 0.08188901096582413, 0.163545161485672, -1.275361180305481, -0.47431638836860657, 0.4370955228805542, 0.3866099715232849, 0.1745832860469818, 0.41425997018814087, 0.266415536403656, -0.6738141775131226, -0.3168849050998688, 0.6579986810684204, -0.20237846672534943, 0.5721381902694702, 1.1854761838912964, -0.05944542959332466, -1.0860108137130737, 0.489775151014328, -0.10860542207956314, -0.2852092981338501, -0.2496698498725891, 0.9707631468772888, 0.06025872752070427, -0.3231378197669983, 0.814586341381073, 0.16679362952709198, -0.30379748344421387, -1.0623472929000854, 0.14338640868663788, -0.3329429030418396, 0.367938756942749, 0.19779953360557556, -0.16171419620513916, 0.1249249279499054, -1.2713576555252075, -0.11827410012483597, -0.45929479598999023, 0.16040562093257904, 0.3901282250881195, -0.39389702677726746, -0.4013909697532654, -0.5885676741600037, -0.2554463744163513, 0.24822048842906952, -0.10708175599575043, 0.4538096785545349, -0.19706133008003235, 0.4644707441329956, -0.44169551134109497, -0.8810173273086548, 0.621940016746521, -0.30730971693992615, 0.30697205662727356, 0.46341875195503235, 0.2325906604528427, 0.4440476596355438, -0.19087423384189606, -0.5950101017951965, 0.633122980594635, 0.7822909951210022, -0.14638164639472961, 0.06442632526159286, 0.9359127283096313, 0.284681499004364, 0.4175328016281128, -0.2519153952598572, -0.44048741459846497, 0.6919010877609253, 0.8174526691436768, 0.8506081104278564, -0.7176522612571716, -0.6868980526924133, -0.4925145208835602, -0.034474778920412064, 0.07373315095901489, -0.45325204730033875, -0.37464192509651184, 1.3560670614242554, -0.7178613543510437, -0.02826135791838169, -0.27638402581214905, 0.8576424717903137, 0.1492176353931427, -0.5146335959434509, -0.7379615306854248, 0.016829006373882294, -0.5836208462715149, -0.7669806480407715, -0.06035127490758896, -0.6288195252418518, 0.041103921830654144, 0.2764168083667755, -0.07068407535552979, -0.7910652160644531, 0.7451076507568359, -0.28501808643341064, 0.2919716238975525, -0.08312121033668518, -0.19490639865398407, -0.7379058599472046, -0.5028936862945557, 0.3198115825653076, -0.10778879374265671, 0.09425986558198929, 0.8568926453590393, -0.8646941184997559, 0.4853892922401428, 0.24276095628738403, -0.08776793628931046, -0.1454186588525772, 0.5687228441238403, 0.1918090134859085, -1.0332590341567993, -0.5540452003479004, -0.3952102065086365, 0.5255978107452393, -0.6578782796859741, -1.093224287033081, -0.4828556776046753, 0.6150043606758118, 0.48793235421180725, 0.17270760238170624, -0.4579624831676483, 0.48514053225517273, 0.08097203075885773, -0.6933049559593201, -0.10232752561569214, 0.21395699679851532, 0.7109290361404419, 0.20358331501483917, 0.7873319983482361, 0.38311436772346497, 0.7944873571395874, -1.2137926816940308, 1.0384280681610107, 0.5076830387115479, -0.4664952754974365, 0.23088914155960083, -0.06951003521680832, 0.25614088773727417, -0.05434644594788551, 0.181759312748909, 0.3400218188762665, 0.8589868545532227, 0.5727224946022034, -0.1379019320011139, -0.47024983167648315, -0.38382768630981445, -0.8123741149902344, -0.4776342511177063, -1.2006064653396606, -0.7104202508926392, 0.3954063355922699, -0.7830413579940796, -0.2760329842567444, -0.17408862709999084, -0.4881683588027954, 0.41243886947631836, 0.4307456314563751, 0.3722565174102783, -0.41922062635421753, -0.22016102075576782, 0.25004997849464417, 0.233109250664711, -0.35647398233413696, -0.752407431602478, 0.31881198287010193, -0.3397669196128845, -0.539996862411499, -0.6232572793960571, 0.2101988047361374, 0.37113428115844727, 0.18549573421478271, -0.3954826593399048, 0.262871652841568, 0.08937627822160721, 0.3736708164215088, -0.06343454867601395, -0.2846524715423584, -0.27204543352127075, -1.093916654586792, 0.10397086292505264, -0.20154841244220734, -0.7037294507026672, -0.35228264331817627, 0.23126158118247986, 0.3301425278186798, -0.5985667109489441, -0.6866121292114258, -0.2023213654756546, 0.5754340887069702, -0.6901363134384155, 0.335577130317688, 0.19518961012363434, 0.10541678220033646, -0.3343474566936493, -0.31571346521377563, 0.8872193694114685, 0.5784730911254883, 0.6045300960540771, 0.18728777766227722, -0.19540268182754517, 0.4908667802810669, 0.6567729115486145, 0.1050909087061882, 0.1449369192123413, -0.4073307514190674, 0.08140812069177628, -0.6610587239265442, 0.3020080029964447, -0.3934607207775116, 0.5691425204277039, 0.3568452000617981, 0.5407642126083374, 0.48585283756256104, 0.17416106164455414, -0.006734568625688553, -0.21198034286499023, 0.10148659348487854, 0.4298858642578125, -0.7378636598587036, -0.7314996123313904, 0.5441222786903381, 0.7663965821266174, 0.8899019956588745, 0.18798288702964783, -0.5131703615188599, 0.2883952558040619, 0.2529277205467224, -0.2015364021062851, -0.0762651339173317, 0.8221299648284912, -0.3940991163253784, -0.3252999186515808, -0.6195885539054871, 0.5397517085075378, -0.2795548141002655, 0.5909304618835449, -0.018971676006913185, 0.41613754630088806, -0.43945440649986267, 0.3546896278858185, 0.41297855973243713, -0.551314115524292, 0.4243033230304718, -0.5655080080032349, 0.5652986764907837, -0.22617921233177185, 0.46288570761680603, -0.2634935975074768, -0.18797145783901215, 0.4898480176925659, -0.5332408547401428, 0.6275105476379395, 0.4635528028011322, 0.41873636841773987, 0.6242628693580627, 0.0696108415722847, 0.5047063231468201, -0.48228609561920166, 0.8817923069000244, 0.6394467353820801, 0.4297927916049957, 0.24530060589313507, -0.3283076584339142, -0.6934594511985779, -0.5847210884094238, -0.0023949460592120886, 0.5165634155273438, 0.15688398480415344, -0.36366838216781616, -0.015643185004591942, -0.08589340001344681, 0.17134231328964233, -0.4538222551345825, -1.128564476966858, 0.13645653426647186, -0.2255041003227234, -0.04555703327059746, -0.45119768381118774, 0.930849015712738, 0.27167683839797974, 0.2620101273059845, -0.06564946472644806, -0.290294349193573, -0.7302692532539368, -0.9044484496116638, -0.1323346644639969, 0.6082807183265686, 0.020259585231542587, -0.08564882725477219, -0.40922269225120544, -1.1668517589569092, 0.3051195740699768, -0.6252089142799377, -0.59014493227005, -0.8901739716529846, 0.03058389015495777, 0.39515024423599243, 0.7397851943969727, 0.3284148871898651, 0.14361068606376648, 0.0544949471950531, 0.037677958607673645, 0.6969580054283142, -0.3806787133216858, 0.2835559844970703, 0.06375974416732788, -0.19275689125061035, 0.40887489914894104, 0.6274207830429077, 0.21135833859443665, -0.5476408004760742, -0.4045908451080322, -0.5197011232376099, 0.879287600517273, 0.11861146986484528, -1.040574312210083, 0.4185267388820648, 0.5682463049888611, -0.19074633717536926, 0.000930028036236763, -0.6565382480621338, -0.6397719383239746, -0.31812813878059387, 0.6783697009086609, 0.029192842543125153, -0.30894264578819275, 0.010057752020657063, -0.028122063726186752, 0.5593433380126953, -0.8498064279556274, 4.161416530609131, 0.618363082408905, -0.04724371060729027, -0.5818303823471069, 0.28769198060035706, -0.29965394735336304, 0.6057246923446655, -0.12099038064479828, 0.28648775815963745, 0.9086094498634338, -0.09433871507644653, 0.4620029330253601, 0.026968948543071747, 0.06504901498556137, 0.4132692515850067, 0.40853437781333923, -0.8834754228591919, -0.14513283967971802, -0.005047057755291462, -1.253889799118042, -0.4421018064022064, -0.1987610012292862, 0.02247411012649536, -0.1492961049079895, 0.753527820110321, 0.4126673936843872, -0.019316058605909348, 0.2025681436061859, 0.07453124225139618, 0.3067084550857544, 0.3104800879955292, -0.3634381592273712, 0.04323524609208107, -0.29480040073394775, -0.6921882033348083, 0.7399196028709412, 0.05557071417570114, -0.3645623028278351, 0.08343120664358139, -0.05299604311585426, 0.19589650630950928, -0.7370253801345825, -0.13849405944347382, -0.3421565890312195, 0.023864056915044785, -0.4100901782512665, -0.2528497874736786, 0.4619119465351105, 0.5618374943733215, -0.4265338182449341, 0.7659547328948975, -0.6903674006462097, -0.3140406310558319, 0.08976001292467117, -0.9025765061378479, 0.22511477768421173, -0.31839755177497864, -0.8669499158859253, 0.17730234563350677, 0.5612213015556335, 0.6429893374443054, 0.42335426807403564, -0.2439124882221222, -0.05492649972438812, 0.3327547013759613, 0.42622196674346924, 0.09913063049316406, 0.276607483625412, -0.2479640692472458, -0.9866712093353271, 0.1264553815126419, -0.34774962067604065, -0.4524732828140259, 0.05701770260930061, 0.46538910269737244, 0.6941098570823669, -0.581645667552948, 0.7035530805587769, -0.9699786901473999, -0.5057939887046814, 0.4046921730041504, 0.3612748980522156, 0.13152514398097992, -0.7958002686500549, 0.4695731997489929, 0.7537373304367065, -0.4345012903213501, 0.13997825980186462, -0.9216580390930176, 0.14854136109352112, 0.4600725471973419, -0.3564884662628174, -0.16492663323879242, -0.42319637537002563, -0.1438901424407959 ]
{"Title": "Validation of Serum Neurofilaments as Prognostic & Potential Pharmacodynamic Biomarkers for ALS", "Authors": "Benatar Michael, Zhang Lanyu, Wang Lily, Granit Volkan, Statland Jeffrey, Barohn Richard, Swenson Andrea, Ravits John, Jackson Carlayne, Burns Ted M, Trivedi Jaya, Pioro Erik P, Caress James, Katz Jonathan, McCauley Jacob L, Rademakers Rosa, Malaspina Andrea, Ostrow Lyle W, Wuu Joanne", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective Identify preferred neurofilament assays, and clinically validate serum NfL and pNfH as prognostic and potential pharmacodynamic biomarkers relevant to ALS therapy development. Methods Prospective, multi-center, longitudinal observational study of patients with ALS (n=229), primary lateral sclerosis (PLS, n=20) and progressive muscular atrophy (PMA, n=11). Biological specimens were collected, processed and stored according to strict standard operating procedures (SOPs) 1 . Neurofilament assays were performed in a blinded manner by independent contract research organizations (CROs). Results For serum NfL and pNfH measured using the Simoa assay, missing data (i.e. both technical replicates below the lower limit of detection (LLD) was not encountered. For the Iron Horse and Euroimmun pNfH assays, such missingness was encountered in \u223c4% and \u223c10% of serum samples respectively. Mean coefficients of variation (CVs) for pNfH in serum and CSF were \u223c4-5% and \u223c2-3% respectively in all assays. Baseline NfL concentration, but not pNfH, predicted the future ALSFRS-R slope and survival. Incorporation of baseline serum NfL into mixed effects models of ALSFRS-R slopes yields an estimated sample size saving of \u223c8%. Depending on the method used to estimate effect size, use of serum NfL (and perhaps pNfH) as pharmacodynamic biomarkers, instead of the ALSFRS-R slope, yields significantly larger sample size savings. Conclusions Serum NfL may be considered a clinically validated prognostic biomarker for ALS. Serum NfL (and perhaps pNfH), quantified using the Simoa assay, have potential utility as pharmacodynamic biomarkers of treatment effect.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002998"}
10.1101/19008383
[ 0.20768634974956512, -0.2829795777797699, -0.5887035131454468, 0.5021308064460754, -0.44473573565483093, -0.2023390680551529, -0.19528737664222717, -0.5389111638069153, 0.6568500995635986, 0.11200817674398422, 0.2874295711517334, -0.13150781393051147, 0.05879823490977287, -0.10140509903430939, -0.4180758595466614, 0.2866290807723999, -0.26687896251678467, -0.8637773990631104, 0.15085060894489288, 0.31957003474235535, 0.15101860463619232, 0.19135238230228424, -1.2158476114273071, -0.27555397152900696, -0.06322870403528214, 0.8378108143806458, 0.3186160624027252, -0.08236455172300339, 0.841945469379425, 0.6089381575584412, 0.1616663634777069, -0.14092746376991272, 0.8421704173088074, -0.675464391708374, -0.9775285720825195, -0.39472025632858276, 0.15456309914588928, -0.4450005292892456, -0.08725475519895554, -0.040917765349149704, 0.5093164443969727, 0.11801867932081223, 0.8887200951576233, -0.6122170090675354, -1.0180937051773071, -0.1306820809841156, 0.03976795822381973, -0.38929224014282227, -0.23839522898197174, 0.14171132445335388, -0.5661565661430359, 0.4793083369731903, 0.3949025869369507, -0.6534980535507202, 0.015851469710469246, 0.3195725381374359, -0.09689737111330032, 0.6518816351890564, -0.7151278853416443, 0.024431684985756874, 0.003904428333044052, -0.9496872425079346, 0.9815447926521301, -0.972906768321991, 1.228853702545166, 0.8139783143997192, 0.10868941247463226, -0.4727410674095154, 0.14510731399059296, -1.1352260112762451, -0.39736953377723694, 0.049854576587677, -0.2523224651813507, -0.3130894601345062, -0.42133828997612, -0.6719263792037964, 0.5279698967933655, -0.3053484261035919, -0.6328012347221375, -0.518149197101593, 0.4259195625782013, -0.041124455630779266, 0.38903504610061646, 0.36498379707336426, -0.7101326584815979, 0.5699111223220825, 0.16210666298866272, 0.17179328203201294, -0.5707530379295349, 0.2806850075721741, 0.16546745598316193, 0.5781436562538147, 0.21848167479038239, 0.07436888664960861, 0.3014264404773712, 0.8920760750770569, -0.654218316078186, 0.8565811514854431, 0.7933654189109802, 0.06504963338375092, 0.7130728960037231, 1.0088081359863281, -0.3631563186645508, 0.8804864287376404, 0.012000656686723232, 0.08349547535181046, 0.5613718628883362, -0.7334284782409668, -0.3733953833580017, -0.6151196956634521, 0.17269733548164368, -0.021941449493169785, -0.8480276465415955, -0.13753047585487366, 0.3012455999851227, 0.4466078281402588, -0.5455003976821899, 0.6366651654243469, -0.08988271653652191, 0.5731683373451233, 0.42833250761032104, -0.6234233379364014, 0.2571549713611603, -0.3006063997745514, 0.38472384214401245, 0.2774353325366974, 0.3898877203464508, 0.8946581482887268, -0.9577778577804565, -0.6468786597251892, 0.44307079911231995, -0.42998725175857544, 0.054105911403894424, 0.6127037405967712, -0.12746725976467133, -0.4990338683128357, -0.0683388039469719, 0.26668116450309753, 0.6755693554878235, 0.18464121222496033, -0.19166402518749237, 0.11126138269901276, -0.41520941257476807, 1.0596420764923096, 0.3851558268070221, 0.433101624250412, 0.02961871027946472, -1.7364284992218018, -0.4434404969215393, -0.272509902715683, 0.04511771723628044, -0.1962413489818573, -0.19040487706661224, 0.4275672137737274, -0.000497911823913455, 0.11591707170009613, -0.3560495376586914, 0.802208662033081, -0.3933934271335602, 0.15704205632209778, -0.08456645160913467, 0.5407545566558838, 0.43562382459640503, 0.8664692640304565, -0.24599282443523407, 0.7481513619422913, -0.005039512645453215, 0.7081311345100403, 0.3465895354747772, -0.07081712782382965, 0.6082019209861755, -0.39214324951171875, -0.6603553891181946, -0.11028151214122772, 0.1808413714170456, 0.8025030493736267, 1.0279096364974976, 0.684569239616394, 0.22337938845157623, 0.44930246472358704, 0.25891467928886414, 0.022327836602926254, 0.8466888070106506, 0.5536816716194153, -0.3608713448047638, 0.06491471081972122, 0.15938691794872284, -0.5427074432373047, 0.032946016639471054, -0.8903934359550476, -0.09088913351297379, 0.13253700733184814, -0.5574532151222229, 0.41493260860443115, -0.3253830373287201, 0.25337401032447815, -0.16044817864894867, 0.19708994030952454, 0.8088070154190063, 0.3704428970813751, -0.28463444113731384, 0.048683930188417435, -0.41064363718032837, 0.2587631642818451, -0.11836080998182297, 0.8124075531959534, 0.5553241968154907, -0.4650174081325531, -0.7095204591751099, -0.03496839106082916, 1.0181267261505127, -0.3768855929374695, -0.4791017174720764, -0.5704635381698608, 1.106797695159912, -0.2971673607826233, -0.3318047821521759, 0.2694849371910095, -0.33281615376472473, 0.266754686832428, -0.22471782565116882, -0.018771225586533546, 0.12790194153785706, 0.2597402334213257, -0.26672375202178955, 0.3624717891216278, -0.008183280006051064, 0.4271474778652191, -0.4319760203361511, -0.23792825639247894, 0.21180130541324615, 0.6324172019958496, -0.23959511518478394, 1.244669795036316, 0.46251559257507324, 0.24402175843715668, 0.12918561697006226, 0.3816840946674347, 0.5782681703567505, 0.18514512479305267, -0.262591153383255, 0.21061468124389648, 0.5140197277069092, 0.23368549346923828, -0.4294455945491791, 0.8450772762298584, -0.8332273364067078, 0.13760820031166077, -0.8134499788284302, -0.04784875735640526, -0.27638357877731323, 0.6798416972160339, -0.023533064872026443, -0.06995315849781036, -1.0918045043945312, -0.2311168909072876, 0.6410506963729858, -0.3422953486442566, -0.20352289080619812, -0.4776727259159088, 0.18086254596710205, -0.19279371201992035, -0.7314825057983398, -0.19507592916488647, 0.939862072467804, 1.2119323015213013, -0.780880331993103, 0.38751375675201416, 0.4317672848701477, -0.11645112186670303, -1.3323925733566284, 0.03218062222003937, -0.8153558373451233, -0.915838897228241, -0.6202396750450134, -0.024881871417164803, 0.09614313393831253, 0.0942823514342308, 0.7613186240196228, 0.1545148640871048, 0.5115415453910828, -0.042146552354097366, -0.23000656068325043, 0.19452843070030212, -0.3368627429008484, 0.6831689476966858, -0.7234479784965515, -0.08235165476799011, -0.24380455911159515, 0.358712762594223, -0.3834660053253174, 0.2003755271434784, 0.17013601958751678, -0.5690255165100098, -0.12996183335781097, -0.3059532642364502, -0.2162836790084839, -0.6293383240699768, -1.3168219327926636, -0.11844281852245331, -0.03736291825771332, 0.7051344513893127, 0.7062571048736572, 0.0829920694231987, 0.006886964198201895, 0.6029402613639832, 0.022840004414319992, 0.07363944500684738, 0.5204366445541382, 0.1718386709690094, -0.5399118661880493, 0.3513612449169159, -0.1513528972864151, 0.28457969427108765, -1.0336922407150269, 0.020206831395626068, 0.285767138004303, -0.4335232973098755, 0.12655377388000488, -0.7549689412117004, -0.21008534729480743, 0.22417563199996948, -0.6312559247016907, -0.0873560979962349, 0.3384474515914917, 0.42838573455810547, 0.8115930557250977, -1.7062201499938965, 0.08638393878936768, 0.03690771013498306, -1.0516513586044312, -0.41468387842178345, 0.2724391520023346, -0.029308585450053215, 0.20079773664474487, -0.20630589127540588, -0.6881042122840881, -0.024666953831911087, 0.3918900489807129, -0.24707047641277313, -0.010437679477036, -0.5992358922958374, 0.1842060685157776, -0.31596916913986206, -0.012374241836369038, 0.3082959055900574, 0.5778203010559082, -0.18653693795204163, -0.2250770777463913, 0.10055279731750488, -0.4905632734298706, 0.2818591892719269, 0.13128384947776794, 0.1610376089811325, -0.2848320007324219, -0.20273913443088531, 0.8172386288642883, -0.17725910246372223, 0.1669555902481079, 0.38295409083366394, 0.5607261061668396, 0.5877091884613037, -0.3089831471443176, 0.04224866256117821, -0.7565603256225586, -0.7412473559379578, -0.012617520987987518, 0.10622148215770721, 0.13372807204723358, 0.09500487893819809, 1.1017173528671265, 0.04213376343250275, -0.6471918821334839, 0.23833683133125305, 0.2129509598016739, -0.6537824273109436, 0.5272811651229858, 0.7225501537322998, 0.358718603849411, -0.35818806290626526, -0.38943108916282654, 0.6329666972160339, 0.40300077199935913, 0.01843598298728466, 0.9782831072807312, 0.10012400150299072, -1.2952666282653809, 0.6005963683128357, -0.04641030728816986, -0.11281890422105789, -0.17295892536640167, 0.1381906121969223, 0.24496592581272125, 0.5988249182701111, 0.07936912029981613, 0.178203746676445, -0.27332213521003723, 0.4968755841255188, -0.49039679765701294, -0.48690614104270935, 1.7070451974868774, -0.23431850969791412, 0.5119035840034485, 0.6743571162223816, 0.7360972166061401, -0.18416740000247955, -0.006516723427921534, 0.42759451270103455, -0.12638349831104279, 0.3240680694580078, -0.715499758720398, -0.19547757506370544, 0.05373430252075195, 0.05668361112475395, -0.20580628514289856, 0.08908217400312424, 0.003753148950636387, -0.2600598633289337, -0.5864210724830627, 0.2671826481819153, 0.13044187426567078, -0.18120300769805908, -0.13389034569263458, -0.24029642343521118, -0.07503247261047363, -0.3859492242336273, -0.42967742681503296, -0.5157635807991028, -0.10784908384084702, 1.0293068885803223, -0.4427337348461151, -0.29815852642059326, -0.43680039048194885, -0.04648667201399803, 0.05875740200281143, 0.6855897307395935, -0.6222133040428162, -0.6935708522796631, -0.21019728481769562, -0.19186212122440338, 0.05666745826601982, -0.3296740651130676, 0.15170226991176605, 0.11628887057304382, 0.5400475263595581, -0.32877808809280396, 0.939832329750061, 0.10528271645307541, 0.8156954050064087, 0.4426438510417938, 0.26819607615470886, -0.5905656218528748, 0.21347500383853912, -0.5283603072166443, -0.5806336998939514, -0.39753028750419617, -0.09407482296228409, -0.4415544271469116, 0.1417754590511322, 0.4591544568538666, -0.14721247553825378, -0.34968820214271545, 0.10598254948854446, -0.17887496948242188, -0.01298894826322794, 1.1080431938171387, -0.038384463638067245, 0.7877386808395386, 1.1480052471160889, -0.37571999430656433, 0.19928649067878723, 0.46625152230262756, -0.008296618238091469, -0.24006037414073944, 0.37651580572128296, 0.12173358350992203, 0.11858035624027252, 0.4080745577812195, -0.8820251226425171, 0.24509206414222717, -0.9404424428939819, -0.3442854583263397, -0.2974001169204712, -0.20529362559318542, -0.4729800522327423, -0.6143952012062073, -0.6938848495483398, -0.013922102749347687, -0.8582938313484192, 0.10815941542387009, -0.14768020808696747, -0.4632877707481384, -0.29822778701782227, 0.6849227547645569, -0.7610255479812622, -1.1334329843521118, -0.4646227955818176, 0.036573536694049835, 0.07041161507368088, -0.3712631165981293, 0.15552055835723877, -0.40137386322021484, -0.06590263545513153, 0.5660445094108582, 0.34711045026779175, -0.6840571761131287, -0.484100878238678, -0.6312938928604126, -0.0833037942647934, -0.00839325226843357, -0.406723290681839, -0.08410189300775528, -0.2663733661174774, -0.4563150107860565, 0.2556713819503784, -0.0960187241435051, 0.1406802237033844, -0.27495819330215454, 0.020928140729665756, 1.0395722389221191, 0.09979180991649628, -0.39373597502708435, -0.18121886253356934, 0.23477622866630554, 0.03633071854710579, 0.18081897497177124, -0.14016617834568024, -0.2447437345981598, -0.5262349843978882, -0.7951101660728455, 0.20196183025836945, -0.39849668741226196, -0.16901497542858124, -0.05091308057308197, -0.8006358742713928, -0.8556598424911499, 0.17903755605220795, 0.43061476945877075, -0.35134217143058777, 0.5501015782356262, -0.3860551416873932, 0.2482561469078064, 0.008789872750639915, 0.5082768201828003, 0.03332902491092682, -1.1754049062728882, -0.31542566418647766, 0.4959043264389038, 0.7032293081283569, -0.5791594982147217, -0.5079714059829712, -0.021147051826119423, 0.6347268223762512, 1.1905003786087036, -0.08305138349533081, -0.9568405151367188, 0.6733115315437317, 0.2549898326396942, -0.1962360441684723, -0.21333535015583038, -0.6804914474487305, 0.45233607292175293, -0.36591243743896484, 0.37534791231155396, 0.3605788052082062, -0.8452666401863098, -0.05411576107144356, -1.2598949670791626, 0.8505474328994751, -0.518183708190918, 0.4468705952167511, 0.23976005613803864, -0.5524792075157166, 0.081302709877491, 0.339724063873291, -0.0022635573986917734, -0.6826058030128479, -0.43002521991729736, -0.7161693572998047, 0.34273236989974976, 0.11739465594291687, 0.08828113973140717, 0.13574230670928955, -0.3721427023410797, 0.19012095034122467, -0.34451770782470703, 0.5766133069992065, 0.8192170858383179, -0.2273341417312622, -0.7881391644477844, -0.27245742082595825, 0.2599424123764038, -0.19152198731899261, 0.05656321346759796, 0.27548786997795105, 0.2022613137960434, 0.46598267555236816, 0.21583735942840576, -0.22775530815124512, -0.6116094589233398, -0.6617750525474548, 0.3710101544857025, 0.12958523631095886, -0.5424838066101074, -0.18682458996772766, -0.43730366230010986, 0.14909090101718903, -0.3539719879627228, 0.26305270195007324, -0.16495665907859802, 0.24893629550933838, 0.4095926284790039, 0.21572254598140717, -0.5731220245361328, 0.42932426929473877, -0.09752850234508514, -0.3305579125881195, -0.6240853071212769, 0.716401994228363, 0.0007663923315703869, -0.3890474736690521, 0.7094188928604126, 0.7822244763374329, -0.2910274863243103, -0.5473842620849609, 0.11658991128206253, -0.17961078882217407, -0.3454349935054779, -0.8751862645149231, -0.17874030768871307, 0.796034038066864, -0.03939317539334297, 0.7728365659713745, -0.5010859966278076, 0.03440984711050987, 0.05521034821867943, -0.811113178730011, 0.4838870167732239, -0.18678374588489532, -0.7732892036437988, 0.054648809134960175, -0.5314371585845947, 0.07806026190519333, -0.7417840361595154, -0.2039746642112732, -0.17070907354354858, 0.12326247990131378, 0.3572905659675598, -0.13126683235168457, -0.11676865816116333, 0.09943857789039612, 1.0052721500396729, 0.5927940607070923, -0.025056805461645126, -0.16386549174785614, 0.42345064878463745, 0.42370694875717163, -0.24329276382923126, -0.6170036792755127, -0.10721928626298904, 0.4712572991847992, 0.28084513545036316, 0.2579905688762665, -0.1625356674194336, 0.8071338534355164, 0.015223062597215176, 0.6988488435745239, -0.6936827898025513, -0.8059993982315063, -0.49910110235214233, 0.12218963354825974, -0.10296371579170227, -0.32838669419288635, 0.42659392952919006, 0.6755244731903076, -0.9095020294189453, -0.6829464435577393, -0.45276203751564026, 1.043049693107605, -0.36031463742256165, -1.0099656581878662, -0.445234477519989, 0.3061923682689667, -0.6208330392837524, -0.9129904508590698, -0.1347712278366089, -0.7430888414382935, 0.1861063539981842, 0.6925632357597351, -0.44271567463874817, -0.059570230543613434, 0.31756386160850525, -0.2595345377922058, -0.6046136021614075, 0.26978036761283875, -0.005854748655110598, -0.5049644708633423, -0.0013073267182335258, 0.130625382065773, 0.39749717712402344, 0.36157241463661194, 1.1752184629440308, -0.08444017916917801, 0.28106871247291565, 0.0126041229814291, 0.20625892281532288, -0.46270909905433655, -0.19757179915905, 0.6702863574028015, -0.3816656172275543, -0.8163330554962158, -1.120070457458496, -0.21284207701683044, -0.8653387427330017, 0.014904440380632877, -0.5874532461166382, -0.3572370409965515, 0.5341026782989502, 0.6264066100120544, -0.4606412351131439, 0.4794282913208008, -0.3640088140964508, 0.4205091893672943, 0.054164379835128784, 1.0740057229995728, -0.865699291229248, 0.18431757390499115, 0.19901014864444733, -0.07790149748325348, 0.09023663401603699, -0.6880873441696167, 0.14314372837543488, 0.566120445728302, -0.12999852001667023, -0.17056703567504883, 0.38532280921936035, 1.017499327659607, 0.15655417740345, -0.9861184358596802, 0.1243353933095932, 1.0385856628417969, 1.0908513069152832, 0.8199261426925659, -0.199794739484787, -0.541643500328064, -0.372428297996521, -1.641855001449585, -1.2000508308410645, -0.8097214102745056, 0.8274032473564148, -0.562479555606842, 0.5984777212142944, -0.32084670662879944, -0.42613622546195984, 0.5606527924537659, 0.2579089105129242, 0.3192944824695587, -0.30951276421546936, 0.5400682687759399, 0.6452740430831909, 0.1732243150472641, -0.13047879934310913, -0.3773782551288605, 0.6225282549858093, -0.07724907994270325, -0.5407742261886597, -0.5154844522476196, -0.48822033405303955, 0.10567089170217514, 0.09324581921100616, -0.3406064808368683, -0.2386472076177597, 0.002194613916799426, 0.1956152319908142, 0.6011374592781067, -1.4047493934631348, 0.07553259283304214, -1.005598545074463, -0.2007596790790558, 0.04304288327693939, 0.09057440608739853, -0.10256046056747437, 0.23667877912521362, 0.3313409686088562, -0.6125308871269226, -0.616277277469635, 0.1703486293554306, 0.21292778849601746, -0.8412392139434814, 0.6504113674163818, -0.25455087423324585, 0.20738723874092102, -0.4016834497451782, -0.6214816570281982, 0.692131757736206, 0.9153695106506348, 0.2815481126308441, -0.2700309157371521, -0.3304874897003174, -0.06796716153621674, 0.8470128774642944, 0.7778554558753967, 0.03932855278253555, 0.545962929725647, -0.34152939915657043, -0.4950215220451355, -0.5085131525993347, -0.15963678061962128, 1.2026468515396118, -0.3521730899810791, 0.19400043785572052, 0.3033883571624756, 0.32318776845932007, 0.2667689323425293, 0.4089263081550598, -0.3503445088863373, -0.15583397448062897, -1.0157368183135986, -0.04467248171567917, 0.7471087574958801, -0.26923057436943054, 0.7106410264968872, 0.06531568616628647, 0.5032711625099182, 0.09130991250276566, 0.4886495769023895, -0.7503810524940491, 0.267718106508255, 0.5181814432144165, -0.22315014898777008, -0.2512471377849579, -0.46015027165412903, 0.6061449646949768, -0.41580018401145935, 0.35893192887306213, 0.9014042615890503, 0.035049546509981155, 0.11289717257022858, -0.02318817749619484, -0.7374185919761658, -0.09111632406711578, -0.23197534680366516, -0.4289591908454895, 0.1566210240125656, -0.5683266520500183, 0.7922956943511963, -0.48506680130958557, -0.15499798953533173, 0.6441512703895569, -0.6401744484901428, -0.2722165286540985, -0.29808464646339417, 0.5289485454559326, 1.2293370962142944, 1.1946536302566528, 0.2280689775943756, -0.5523912906646729, 0.354567289352417, 0.6797333359718323, -0.1658167690038681, 0.25992220640182495, 0.347418874502182, -0.5206735730171204, 0.6375256180763245, 0.4752941131591797, 0.32032281160354614, -0.236104354262352, -0.27275726199150085, -0.4019245505332947, -0.2312559336423874, -0.12495972961187363, 0.22598592936992645, -1.147077202796936, -0.3751981854438782, 0.18268319964408875, 0.3078519105911255, -0.2581337094306946, 0.3118619918823242, 1.3439710140228271, 0.01804986409842968, 0.0654807910323143, -0.09514199197292328, -0.5771210193634033, 0.039361074566841125, -1.328653335571289, 0.6948958039283752, 0.31074461340904236, 0.4447798728942871, -0.9866701364517212, -0.5298383235931396, 0.38981226086616516, -0.3603353202342987, -0.5087266564369202, -1.1284195184707642, 0.047702204436063766, 0.12184377759695053, 0.918829619884491, -0.1724763810634613, -0.4497443437576294, -0.006725338753312826, 0.16007331013679504, 0.40333032608032227, 0.0774880200624466, 0.2385789006948471, 0.46761178970336914, 0.6049700975418091, 0.13107417523860931, 0.25847747921943665, -0.06632805615663528, -0.19557341933250427, -0.04701472446322441, 0.09898024797439575, -0.12604385614395142, -0.5644939541816711, -0.6959158182144165, 0.67591792345047, 0.7768519520759583, 0.32697373628616333, -0.3571716248989105, -0.2911151051521301, -0.3452003598213196, -0.6040279269218445, 0.9879677891731262, -0.22747494280338287, -0.29572394490242004, 0.04798184707760811, -0.021099766716361046, 0.9414278864860535, -1.0034799575805664, 4.145332336425781, 1.5889796018600464, 0.4783913195133209, 0.11132766306400299, 0.4767787754535675, 0.5612002015113831, 0.3610338866710663, -0.5142282843589783, -0.006976064760237932, -0.7813007235527039, 0.39667367935180664, 0.10766077041625977, 0.18537576496601105, 0.29230228066444397, -0.24286414682865143, -0.1608005166053772, -0.6248086094856262, -0.08600685000419617, -0.21003998816013336, -1.3194462060928345, -0.4824553430080414, 0.07827233523130417, -0.2959102690219879, 0.21801768243312836, 0.9059332013130188, -0.0717531144618988, 0.016798755154013634, 0.1512966752052307, 0.17245648801326752, 0.03336511552333832, -0.6105099320411682, -0.8285567164421082, 0.2618081569671631, -0.04538017883896828, -0.6460260152816772, 0.04255429655313492, -0.2036859691143036, -0.6078162789344788, -0.07747877389192581, 0.5220035314559937, 0.24247704446315765, -0.16698896884918213, -0.3178236782550812, -0.7782144546508789, -0.6999248266220093, 0.04300607368350029, -0.9459776878356934, 0.7940006256103516, -0.16871358454227448, -0.3650721609592438, 1.0368690490722656, -0.45496320724487305, 0.0857941135764122, -0.2465236783027649, -0.8002699613571167, -0.38071709871292114, -0.3256174623966217, -0.9498587846755981, 0.6280215978622437, 0.3551563322544098, 1.0365633964538574, 0.3713892698287964, -0.5255059003829956, -0.00746835395693779, 0.24330078065395355, 0.9615200757980347, 0.26497921347618103, 0.28036192059516907, -0.1559361070394516, -0.48999056220054626, 0.07806605845689774, -0.591906726360321, -0.4837392568588257, 0.6189627647399902, 0.3145659565925598, 0.21735450625419617, -0.20043480396270752, 0.701278567314148, -0.04471401870250702, -0.18708276748657227, 0.3374009430408478, 0.43292760848999023, 0.05710039287805557, -0.13946501910686493, -0.027042577043175697, 0.6175434589385986, -0.14020633697509766, 0.058855410665273666, -0.5954383015632629, 0.39279472827911377, 0.48315805196762085, -0.4036182463169098, -0.17007577419281006, 0.45257896184921265, 0.5254340171813965 ]
{"Title": "Real-world Drug Regimens for Multiple Myeloma in a Swiss Population (2012 to 2017): cost-outcome description", "Authors": "Eichler Klaus, Rapold Roland, Wieser Simon, Reich Oliver, Blozik Eva", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Novel drugs are dynamically changing current treatment regimens for multiple myeloma (MM). Novel drugs have improved prognosis of MM patients in clinical studies but are expensive. Little is known about up-to-date real-world application and costs. Methods We performed a retrospective observational cohort analysis (cost-outcome description; 2012-2017) in a claims database of a major Swiss health insurance company which covers 14% of the Swiss population (Helsana Versicherungen AG).We used primary (MM diagnoses via ICD-10) and secondary features (prescribed MM-specific drugs) as inclusion criteria and defined a hierarchy of drug regimens to classify treatments as: 1) proteasome inhibitor (PI)-based regimen (e.g. bortezomib); 2) IMID-based regimen (e.g. lenalidomide); 3) chemotherapy (CHEMO)-based regimen (e.g. bendamustin); 4) monoclonal antibody (MAB)-based regimen (e.g. daratunumab). Direct medical costs of mandatory health insurance were analysed in 2017 Swiss Francs (CHF; third party payer perspective). Results Overall, we identified n=1054 prevalent MM patients (2012-2017) and n=378 incident MM patients (2015-2017; men: 47.1%; age group <=75 years: 48.7%). The number of prevalent patients per year increased over time (from n=314 in 2012 to n=645 in 2017). PI-based regimens were the most frequent first line approach for incident patients (76.0%), followed by IMID-based (21.9%) and CHEMO-based regimens (2.1%). Only four patients were treated with MAB-drugs. For later lines, IMID-based regimens were most often used (2 nd line: 56.4%; 3 rd line: 2 of 3 patients), followed by PI-based regimens (43.6% and 1 of 3 patients, respectively). 161 of 1054 prevalent MM patients (15.3%) were treated with autologous hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT), 4 patients with allogeneic HSCT. Average costs per patient per treatment line varied considerably (reliable data available from 2012 to 2014; mean duration of lines between 112 and 388 days): PI-based regimens: CHF 81\u2019352; IMID-based: CHF 73\u2019495; CHEMO-based: CHF 683. Mean daily costs under MM treatment stepwise increased from CHF 209 in 2012 to CHF 254 in 2017 (relative increase: 21.5%). Annual direct medical costs in Switzerland for seven novel MM drugs were extrapolated to be 60.1 Mio CHF in 2012 and 118.6 Mio CHF in 2017 (relative increase: 97.3%), corresponding to mean annual outpatient MM drug costs per patient of CHF 28\u2019000 in 2017. Annual death rates decreased systematically from 18.6% in 2012 to 15.5% in 2017 (p for trend: 0.03). No statistically significant difference in death rates emerged for 2017 compared with 2012 (risk ratio: 0.83; 95%-CI: 0.63 to 1.10; absolute risk reduction: 3.1%). Conclusions Current treatment patterns for MM patients in Switzerland show variation concerning applied drug regimens as well as costs. An increasing prevalent population of MM patients in combination with increasing costs per day under treatment lead to a substantial and growing budget impact for the Swiss social insurance system.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008383"}
10.1101/2019.12.11.19014449
[ -0.19165028631687164, 0.050218645483255386, -0.43731680512428284, 0.3698812425136566, -0.17709334194660187, -0.10173049569129944, -0.2827727198600769, 0.1038036197423935, -0.5649316906929016, 0.5255433320999146, -0.6792400479316711, 0.15935766696929932, 0.210991770029068, 0.061072275042533875, -0.9954055547714233, -0.18869881331920624, -0.7999857664108276, 0.20278671383857727, 0.8172318935394287, 0.09255275130271912, -0.40637916326522827, 1.1876733303070068, -1.2446144819259644, -0.20316122472286224, -0.16951113939285278, 0.2884422838687897, -0.29067257046699524, 0.08811844140291214, 1.8009964227676392, 1.1444215774536133, 0.7171085476875305, 0.24771565198898315, 0.13598161935806274, -0.4930438995361328, -0.14987483620643616, -0.35925811529159546, 0.6452571749687195, -0.3223155736923218, 0.35181301832199097, -0.10002344101667404, 0.5360535383224487, 0.3140804171562195, 0.2273140847682953, -0.8449606895446777, -0.2845824658870697, -0.83216792345047, -0.23273497819900513, 1.25164794921875, -0.2932596802711487, 0.1407577395439148, 0.22303690016269684, -0.3771277368068695, 0.05972728878259659, -1.0214225053787231, -0.6267295479774475, -0.7844033241271973, -0.08071895688772202, -0.05313533917069435, -0.7126924395561218, 0.9479905962944031, 0.26882484555244446, -0.7172937989234924, 0.5609462857246399, -0.4373033344745636, 0.5202876329421997, 0.23899295926094055, -0.0528942234814167, 0.0659198984503746, -0.3686515986919403, -0.764946699142456, -0.5330606698989868, -0.33247479796409607, -0.5808041095733643, -0.5450324416160583, -0.6006084680557251, -0.13026301562786102, -0.35796740651130676, -0.4648967683315277, -0.5513241291046143, 0.6484348773956299, -0.22772063314914703, -0.053829487413167953, 0.14128361642360687, 0.013003580272197723, -0.7986347675323486, 0.42610177397727966, 0.012765026651322842, 0.4973891079425812, 0.5901519060134888, 1.0699998140335083, -0.34554523229599, 0.11359640210866928, -0.16206182539463043, -0.016240116208791733, 0.7590771317481995, 1.2223267555236816, 0.3622797727584839, -0.06554116308689117, 0.3276464641094208, -0.3477945029735565, 0.8089818954467773, 0.22864052653312683, 0.38114413619041443, 0.8848118185997009, -0.7630181312561035, 0.9685830473899841, 0.8020594716072083, 0.3571208417415619, -0.45872762799263, -0.13009877502918243, 0.17496037483215332, -0.6696823835372925, -0.9172676801681519, -1.2527766227722168, 0.5547927618026733, 0.517987847328186, 0.5234240293502808, 1.0475651025772095, -0.3263741135597229, 1.0238008499145508, -0.8290285468101501, 0.23759372532367706, 0.25623950362205505, 0.278522789478302, 0.0017920270329341292, 0.15497180819511414, 0.46109744906425476, 0.44200995564460754, -0.2589697539806366, -0.21613958477973938, -0.18684121966362, -0.24408605694770813, 0.012672611512243748, 0.1760251671075821, 0.13554084300994873, 0.1491011083126068, 0.5131483674049377, 0.8392055034637451, -0.2378869652748108, -0.507809042930603, -0.033316388726234436, 0.30434709787368774, 0.015525145456194878, 1.0968023538589478, -1.0453143119812012, 0.4904402494430542, -1.0616562366485596, -0.605534017086029, -0.4362580180168152, 0.008611089549958706, -0.07131961733102798, 0.23222550749778748, 0.2573733925819397, 0.20772036910057068, 0.1354980170726776, 0.08775030821561813, 0.08575817942619324, -0.7901870012283325, -0.3956640362739563, 0.249161496758461, -0.8832029700279236, 0.09622525423765182, -0.5069864392280579, 0.6571463942527771, -0.9810730218887329, 0.06765568256378174, 0.14851054549217224, 0.2626131772994995, 0.08101632446050644, -0.7161583304405212, 0.6994222402572632, 0.22960737347602844, 0.3122444152832031, 0.7323947548866272, 0.16337010264396667, 0.7134450078010559, 0.2866169214248657, 0.027354946359992027, 1.0204867124557495, 0.7013784646987915, 0.41936588287353516, -0.037378210574388504, 0.1960761845111847, 0.6260058879852295, 0.37224921584129333, 0.4742197096347809, -0.4128303527832031, -0.689784049987793, -0.42074522376060486, -0.6533685326576233, -0.249338299036026, 0.5902578830718994, -0.026973186060786247, 0.40882769227027893, 0.00888512097299099, 0.21846356987953186, -0.05769551172852516, 0.513443648815155, 0.20459023118019104, -0.2967228591442108, -0.8765078186988831, 0.763999879360199, 0.10064402222633362, 0.24299301207065582, -0.5955292582511902, 0.6296039819717407, -0.18597227334976196, 0.6006472706794739, -0.4274541735649109, -0.17759983241558075, 0.8176111578941345, -0.32297182083129883, -0.3781602680683136, -0.11361432075500488, 0.9241241216659546, -0.5798077583312988, -0.8990505337715149, 0.2926173210144043, -0.48587509989738464, 0.29714614152908325, -0.22332194447517395, -0.5149599313735962, 1.1174830198287964, 0.6171553134918213, 0.200910747051239, -0.024587418884038925, 0.42764508724212646, 0.1756298691034317, -0.3302643895149231, -0.052359987050294876, 0.4593433439731598, 0.6828415393829346, -0.2849805951118469, 1.1888498067855835, 0.763410747051239, 0.5800168514251709, 0.20210178196430206, -0.15702016651630402, -0.15866674482822418, 0.17209464311599731, 0.7458066940307617, 0.24100150167942047, 0.9306138753890991, 0.0314638651907444, -0.39970189332962036, 0.9310299754142761, -0.11577555537223816, 0.7127224206924438, 0.20229573547840118, 0.6149001717567444, -0.17066940665245056, 0.465205579996109, 1.1112971305847168, 0.8941633105278015, -0.3674880266189575, -0.23555225133895874, 0.3010845482349396, -0.3679865002632141, -0.2841923236846924, 0.016342714428901672, 0.21444746851921082, 0.09001804143190384, -0.2245849221944809, -0.4345334768295288, 0.7195380926132202, 0.978517472743988, -0.15913131833076477, 0.38150554895401, 0.29791995882987976, -0.4546574056148529, -0.7289517521858215, -0.46463438868522644, -1.2098469734191895, -0.5752003788948059, -0.9699887633323669, -0.2753121256828308, -0.16411451995372772, -1.0301234722137451, 1.1596931219100952, -0.3638148605823517, 0.23849953711032867, 0.6331091523170471, -0.2664419114589691, 0.4497481882572174, 0.09036018699407578, 0.035479020327329636, -0.5818069577217102, 0.9746844172477722, 0.04029122740030289, 0.2631819546222687, -0.16925695538520813, 0.3860219717025757, -0.6689531803131104, -0.7249478101730347, 0.7170674204826355, -0.639301598072052, 0.8236452341079712, 0.5379053354263306, -0.3589278757572174, -0.3314967751502991, 0.290122926235199, 0.7820032835006714, 1.213093638420105, 0.5280675292015076, -0.8101842999458313, 0.5014989376068115, -0.26874735951423645, 0.21198418736457825, 0.35541486740112305, -0.10533741861581802, -1.227968454360962, 0.45440176129341125, 0.034904781728982925, -0.052096087485551834, -1.1391880512237549, 0.1275085061788559, 0.23735298216342926, -0.3753354549407959, 0.0954659953713417, -0.5837871432304382, -0.8556817173957825, 0.003680795431137085, 0.14008313417434692, 0.15099091827869415, 0.07668497413396835, 0.30512359738349915, -0.14919455349445343, -1.1851764917373657, 0.06754829734563828, -1.0467214584350586, -1.0326852798461914, 0.05236301198601723, 0.48241275548934937, 0.5235525965690613, 0.06475462019443512, -0.03430594503879547, -0.6311897039413452, -0.0901283472776413, 0.7121418714523315, -0.31306785345077515, 0.0004548270080704242, 0.24820341169834137, -0.30133238434791565, -0.0635971948504448, -1.154472827911377, 1.0087188482284546, 0.26524388790130615, -0.0993104800581932, -0.15611447393894196, -0.5385233759880066, 0.23446591198444366, 0.35847970843315125, 0.7888568639755249, -0.40192562341690063, -0.5083568096160889, 0.4413924217224121, 0.07488710433244705, -0.3110584020614624, -0.03799039497971535, -0.05539102107286453, -0.530219554901123, 0.08964238315820694, -0.49326860904693604, 0.5319908261299133, -0.6865552663803101, -0.4938275218009949, 0.558179497718811, 0.7673417329788208, 0.469745934009552, -0.683689296245575, 0.4560084044933319, -0.42889195680618286, -0.6220253705978394, 0.7899230718612671, 0.02014116570353508, -0.1909969300031662, 1.0230140686035156, 1.0515694618225098, 1.4062453508377075, -1.0312598943710327, 0.18990033864974976, -0.14168408513069153, 0.6667116284370422, 0.4625982642173767, 0.679958164691925, 0.7699288129806519, -0.2175583839416504, 0.6915274262428284, -0.31585946679115295, -0.5216298699378967, -0.3010534346103668, -1.0360746383666992, -0.43765905499458313, 0.1479906588792801, -0.39199069142341614, -1.0645416975021362, -0.2685670256614685, 0.05097063630819321, 0.7570866346359253, 0.34272196888923645, 0.9420818090438843, 0.0258627962321043, 0.26363733410835266, 0.544787585735321, 0.8503414392471313, 1.0643516778945923, -0.6891112327575684, 0.3199709951877594, -1.049775242805481, 0.16809049248695374, 0.0828714668750763, -0.5397882461547852, 0.12446573376655579, -0.010842391289770603, -0.2637452483177185, -0.038271285593509674, -0.7243772745132446, -0.9994111657142639, 0.021080084145069122, 0.022023610770702362, -0.061370834708213806, 0.4346681535243988, -0.1635623723268509, 0.3734853267669678, -0.6662358641624451, -0.5276880860328674, -0.3216923475265503, -0.6498194336891174, 1.0710936784744263, 0.4125669002532959, -0.13388465344905853, -0.9710009098052979, -0.5221711993217468, -0.3450394570827484, -0.5909138917922974, -0.6299562454223633, 0.23700150847434998, -0.14457444846630096, 0.5080417394638062, -0.9385048747062683, -0.5734075903892517, 0.14114093780517578, -0.22066739201545715, -0.5422930717468262, -0.2198069989681244, 0.15212786197662354, 0.9620136618614197, 0.5500372052192688, 0.15347060561180115, -0.5152600407600403, 0.17083196341991425, -0.6396605968475342, 0.3538953363895416, -0.6295128464698792, -0.4839189350605011, -0.5985450148582458, -0.03169025853276253, -0.1680479794740677, 0.49132728576660156, -0.4573095142841339, -0.08923293650150299, 0.07747043669223785, -0.2715275287628174, -0.6740003228187561, -0.4468654692173004, 1.1779922246932983, -0.2071431577205658, -0.0016226100269705057, 0.5594034194946289, -0.6591863632202148, 0.23493829369544983, -0.45681580901145935, 0.06093880161643028, -1.4037166833877563, 0.16840152442455292, 0.16254381835460663, 0.4825310707092285, 0.28692054748535156, -1.0106652975082397, 0.33534225821495056, -0.12808454036712646, -0.2801675498485565, -0.43721601366996765, -0.1632463037967682, -0.5741481781005859, -0.2632848620414734, 0.1344480961561203, -0.5709100961685181, -0.8150625228881836, 0.5300382375717163, 0.26517146825790405, -0.0714796781539917, -0.2872472405433655, -0.9005441665649414, -0.795034646987915, -0.17331059277057648, 0.13579072058200836, 0.4031462073326111, 0.03794486075639725, -0.3705947697162628, 1.4336153268814087, -0.09188386797904968, -0.06444664299488068, 0.06920070946216583, 0.546028733253479, -0.3931964039802551, -0.4146030843257904, 0.08600472658872604, -0.1163160502910614, -0.45053035020828247, 0.37563636898994446, 0.11042189598083496, -1.0138776302337646, 0.5717469453811646, -0.2648831605911255, -0.7665477991104126, 0.23296834528446198, -0.1387372463941574, -0.04781195521354675, 0.1748151034116745, -0.45776882767677307, -0.7162600159645081, -0.7697412967681885, 0.25657010078430176, 0.2332848310470581, -0.15046918392181396, 0.35104718804359436, -0.644848108291626, -0.8417194485664368, -1.2608931064605713, -0.3621672987937927, -0.9602118730545044, 0.35649535059928894, -0.43266552686691284, -0.21869540214538574, 0.303208589553833, 0.6079444289207458, -0.11357789486646652, 0.20649562776088715, -0.0657603070139885, -0.5272042155265808, 0.04768287390470505, -0.26649948954582214, -0.8549420833587646, 0.10982708632946014, -0.7665544152259827, 0.35640594363212585, 1.1477985382080078, 0.11777852475643158, -0.7398903369903564, -0.6953493356704712, 0.38355231285095215, 0.563717782497406, 0.4925563335418701, -0.2925514876842499, -0.9046489000320435, 0.02720140665769577, 1.2974019050598145, -0.40254002809524536, -0.2777600586414337, -0.7510486245155334, 1.0838121175765991, -0.5898106098175049, 0.35990530252456665, 0.0034715537913143635, -0.8287516236305237, 0.3720620274543762, -0.285674512386322, 1.224023699760437, -0.054857444018125534, 0.20604954659938812, -0.08607616275548935, -0.2510616183280945, 0.7545318007469177, 0.14356455206871033, -1.0305956602096558, 0.17985278367996216, -0.7805686593055725, -0.8639659285545349, 0.817034900188446, 0.005440626293420792, -0.3513339161872864, 0.3853352665901184, -0.02582162246108055, 0.6836438775062561, -0.4119049608707428, 1.0417370796203613, 0.48535671830177307, -0.7242094874382019, 0.049327898770570755, 0.016184475272893906, 0.20978444814682007, -0.10080298781394958, 0.5639778971672058, 0.3236713707447052, -0.1657084971666336, 1.246677041053772, -0.0597175732254982, -0.3705674409866333, -0.539864182472229, -0.7159125208854675, 0.206427663564682, 0.6726140975952148, -0.43164050579071045, 0.0305160004645586, 0.1340600550174713, -0.7748884558677673, -0.18004265427589417, 0.720812201499939, -0.17581842839717865, 0.6692466139793396, 0.9412207007408142, -0.6010963320732117, -0.719176709651947, 0.013096677139401436, 0.2859390377998352, 0.31577029824256897, -0.05855080485343933, 0.52034991979599, 0.2090573012828827, -1.1759592294692993, -0.22679458558559418, 0.46831849217414856, -0.11432649195194244, 0.09967958182096481, 0.41225242614746094, -0.42971548438072205, 0.4757123589515686, -0.32310745120048523, 0.5153089761734009, 0.4487689137458801, -0.2621738612651825, 0.7234013080596924, -0.4154556691646576, -0.03977605700492859, 0.15092021226882935, 0.19871880114078522, 0.7400009036064148, -0.40761056542396545, 0.20121777057647705, 0.21339280903339386, -0.5312637686729431, -0.07888609915971756, 0.04399742931127548, 0.6585970520973206, 0.46319419145584106, -0.318342000246048, 0.6654058694839478, -0.2558969259262085, 0.2655895948410034, 0.7262457609176636, -0.08194833993911743, 0.1327766478061676, -0.2883734703063965, -0.3839324116706848, 0.6931955218315125, -0.017223237082362175, -0.6565358638763428, -0.5112703442573547, 0.6315016150474548, -0.2458643615245819, -0.18644222617149353, 0.36950433254241943, -0.11093083769083023, 0.4011150598526001, 0.6080431938171387, 0.9264553189277649, -0.09803032875061035, -0.4526732265949249, -0.5898716449737549, -0.006798237096518278, -0.3256628215312958, 0.3230680823326111, 0.43602287769317627, 0.5965607166290283, -0.4369608461856842, 0.07551566511392593, 0.29080551862716675, 0.42014479637145996, -0.29847389459609985, 0.044041212648153305, -0.8213992118835449, 0.07540836930274963, -0.35599473118782043, -1.1118040084838867, 0.23542723059654236, -0.10693713277578354, -0.642637312412262, 0.7736113667488098, -0.6089679002761841, 0.13413368165493011, -0.07652274519205093, 0.2993738055229187, 0.4018007516860962, 0.43363848328590393, -0.8508275747299194, -0.8253588080406189, -0.2937062084674835, 0.48457586765289307, 0.49723029136657715, 0.0831938162446022, 0.6265034079551697, -0.9756547808647156, -0.05127773433923721, 0.3397558927536011, -0.3373726010322571, 0.2556404769420624, -0.39547574520111084, 0.5382483005523682, -0.5555317401885986, -0.7230573296546936, -0.29403263330459595, 0.6791980266571045, -1.0427922010421753, -0.044161152094602585, -0.24374675750732422, 0.6446008682250977, 0.00602020975202322, 0.1744188815355301, -0.373113751411438, 0.21462436020374298, 0.0909205973148346, 0.8525381684303284, 0.5392349362373352, 0.5461652874946594, 0.544075071811676, -0.10706061124801636, 0.11506663262844086, 0.30609235167503357, -0.10311498492956161, -0.6927877068519592, 0.33817410469055176, 0.19076964259147644, -0.1345224678516388, 0.1287647783756256, -0.2581731677055359, 0.11824594438076019, -0.18392254412174225, -0.0670100599527359, 0.04008505120873451, 0.6866031885147095, 0.2121131867170334, -0.413788378238678, -0.012510915286839008, -0.3218883275985718, -0.22234956920146942, -0.04588290676474571, -0.8979914784431458, -0.1928553581237793, 1.0910829305648804, -0.3673582673072815, -0.7656489610671997, -0.6847295761108398, -0.8592240214347839, -0.008258366957306862, 0.5162829756736755, -0.05495009571313858, -0.020937740802764893, 0.8528461456298828, 0.23982810974121094, 0.9063193798065186, 0.45384544134140015, 0.13610294461250305, -0.267769455909729, -0.059141550213098526, -0.772997260093689, -0.3273307681083679, 0.6952267289161682, 0.6327027082443237, -0.02461356669664383, -0.07521233707666397, -0.15038812160491943, -0.36363306641578674, 0.06609956920146942, -0.3567430377006531, -0.24129118025302887, 0.19240529835224152, -1.2370429039001465, -0.4264221787452698, -0.011401797644793987, -0.12068331241607666, -0.6525385975837708, 0.8274301886558533, -0.16349411010742188, -0.3967130780220032, -1.1534456014633179, 0.4181478023529053, 0.26494690775871277, -0.1485171914100647, -0.2846810817718506, 0.2557988166809082, 0.8834879398345947, 0.17713020741939545, -0.1967349648475647, 0.5919594168663025, 0.5882713198661804, -0.020139966160058975, -0.5218812227249146, -0.16772998869419098, 0.3079715371131897, 0.26742276549339294, -0.487319678068161, 0.20856010913848877, 0.4479619860649109, 0.05500870570540428, -0.644634485244751, -0.028460606932640076, 0.01873665675520897, 0.1561644971370697, -0.4070553779602051, -0.25934121012687683, 0.4686763286590576, 0.3472747504711151, 0.42673930525779724, 0.04008616879582405, -0.7837905287742615, 0.5355148315429688, 0.13201159238815308, -1.194266438484192, 0.6040616035461426, 0.0033783784601837397, 0.6795948147773743, 0.9737018942832947, 0.3506591022014618, 0.2877941429615021, 0.6252406239509583, -0.2964774966239929, 0.2873837351799011, 0.5456494092941284, -0.2866900861263275, 0.09230279177427292, 0.17823678255081177, 0.17012432217597961, -0.8318209052085876, 0.35646742582321167, -0.6392766237258911, -0.06710544973611832, 0.00773630803450942, 0.6835364699363708, -0.9597539901733398, -0.054582804441452026, 0.8167603015899658, 0.17641864717006683, -0.032988887280225754, -0.01979001797735691, 0.2628846764564514, -0.5271364450454712, -0.1672571301460266, 0.38817670941352844, -0.22661954164505005, -0.4394396245479584, 0.38503509759902954, 0.16112729907035828, -0.032808564603328705, 0.7593657374382019, 0.5788036584854126, -0.628947913646698, 0.8530718088150024, 0.16830749809741974, 0.4136594533920288, 0.07846041768789291, -0.24906140565872192, -0.17350053787231445, -0.3004414439201355, 0.192215234041214, -0.624443531036377, -0.20260053873062134, -0.19293828308582306, -0.6324638724327087, 0.06618981063365936, 0.1310722827911377, -0.5678465366363525, -0.9258424639701843, -0.7411741018295288, -0.01440239604562521, 0.4864904284477234, -0.8738155961036682, 0.43053874373435974, 0.2626214921474457, -0.33018958568573, 0.4571858048439026, 0.11409122496843338, -0.4082654118537903, 0.13911817967891693, -0.7243775129318237, 0.11623266339302063, 0.19805502891540527, -0.5027334690093994, -0.6248341202735901, -1.138866901397705, -0.09678605943918228, -0.02836032584309578, -0.24264150857925415, -0.2371879667043686, -0.041503652930259705, 0.14277400076389313, 0.7737310528755188, -0.21875739097595215, -0.2147151529788971, -0.15761606395244598, -0.23564210534095764, 0.6109057068824768, 0.24320130050182343, 0.49195438623428345, -0.31079232692718506, 0.2216050773859024, 0.6270172595977783, -0.811026930809021, 0.36418047547340393, -0.24086739122867584, -0.7311536073684692, -0.795838475227356, 0.21652472019195557, 0.46190863847732544, -0.40398600697517395, 0.525250256061554, 0.9346995949745178, -0.046303678303956985, -0.1781643182039261, -1.05668044090271, 0.056489937007427216, -1.0535047054290771, 1.2324649095535278, -0.04606136679649353, -0.2987027168273926, 0.4599551558494568, 0.0031061177141964436, 0.3728410601615906, -0.8221927881240845, 3.9643092155456543, 1.0423780679702759, 0.49678510427474976, 0.10456036031246185, 1.288784384727478, 0.1981431096792221, 0.6119257211685181, -0.36946460604667664, 0.694034218788147, -0.3863680958747864, -0.547055184841156, -0.4689224362373352, 0.09231425076723099, -0.012986546382308006, 0.3585057854652405, 0.061521608382463455, -0.8686000108718872, 0.017808130010962486, -0.4601326584815979, -0.5429283976554871, -0.9110976457595825, 0.8050422668457031, -0.26435500383377075, 0.6648241281509399, -0.32585254311561584, -0.07096944004297256, 0.2867039442062378, 0.5493332743644714, 0.9582340121269226, -0.16027122735977173, -0.1604444980621338, -0.9992165565490723, 0.1513766199350357, -0.07530243694782257, -0.35830405354499817, -0.032191429287195206, -0.6451094150543213, -0.4947950839996338, -0.3684682846069336, 0.19748617708683014, 0.09701605141162872, 0.1594059020280838, 0.17205794155597687, 0.20563174784183502, 0.262602835893631, -0.17107875645160675, -0.5914586782455444, -0.3002334237098694, 0.9861391186714172, -0.611190915107727, 0.9348140954971313, -1.3697093725204468, 0.4779331684112549, -0.20705917477607727, -1.014288067817688, -0.5580739378929138, 0.07292327284812927, -0.8904776573181152, 0.11502337455749512, -0.03501732274889946, 0.1461634784936905, -1.081836223602295, -0.03919374197721481, -0.09938876330852509, -0.1581226885318756, -0.07459358125925064, 0.1359035223722458, 0.6556705236434937, 0.2205803543329239, -0.2619294822216034, 0.13813605904579163, -0.46373772621154785, -0.22083881497383118, 0.4388308525085449, 0.1686890423297882, 0.3833796977996826, 0.49379539489746094, 0.12551739811897278, -0.3736139237880707, -0.9157883524894714, 0.1190318912267685, 0.26313120126724243, 0.4098486006259918, -0.17169804871082306, 0.044266123324632645, 1.1008288860321045, -0.8878092169761658, -0.37280043959617615, -0.9075108766555786, 0.3673652708530426, 0.01467344630509615, -0.6661593914031982, -0.22096019983291626, 0.03171949461102486, -0.02194070629775524 ]
{"Title": "Determining factors for pertussis vaccination policy: A study in 5 EU countries", "Authors": "Wong Anabelle, Opinel Annick, Combes Simon Jean-Baptiste, Toubiana Julie, Brisse Sylvain", "Abstract": "Abstract Pertussis vaccination policy varies across Europe, not only in the type of vaccine \u2013 whole cell (wP) vs. acellular (aP1/2/3/5) \u2013 but also in the schedule and recommendation for parents. This study aims to investigate the determining factors for the type of vaccine, immunization schedule and maternal immunization recommendation. From March to May 2019, experts in national health agencies and major academic or research institutions from Denmark, France, Poland, Sweden and the UK were invited to a semi-structured interview. Thematic analysis was performed on the transcripts using a codebook formulated by 3 coders. Inter-coder agreement was assessed. Fifteen expert interviews were conducted. The identified driving factors for pertussis vaccine policy were classified into three domains: scientific factors, sociological factors, and pragmatic factors. The determining factors for the type of vaccine were prescriber\u2019s preference, concern of adverse events following immunization (AEFI), effectiveness, and consideration of other vaccine components in combined vaccines. The determining factors for infant schedule were immunity response and the potential to improve coverage and timeliness. The determining factors for maternal immunization were infant mortality and public acceptability. To conclude, socio-political and pragmatic factors were, besides scientific factors, important in determining the vaccine type, schedule of childhood immunization and recommendations for parents.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.11.19014449"}
10.1101/19003004
[ -0.19908292591571808, 0.1415877342224121, -0.36919572949409485, 0.14059947431087494, -0.4869224727153778, 0.0021689250133931637, 0.08469023555517197, 0.8360159397125244, -0.5420036315917969, 0.9740909934043884, -0.056825075298547745, -0.7151021361351013, 0.5259877443313599, -0.5281276702880859, -0.02308025397360325, -0.040476635098457336, -0.5665973424911499, -0.46862292289733887, -0.23740440607070923, 0.6289894580841064, 0.2427564412355423, 0.3229786157608032, -0.915911853313446, 0.04644979164004326, -0.2593417763710022, 0.4343316853046417, 0.16628330945968628, -0.3222966194152832, 1.1316804885864258, 0.7883041501045227, 0.2517422139644623, -0.6142349243164062, 0.4811033606529236, -0.9843356013298035, -0.11697323620319366, -0.30332595109939575, 0.4259979724884033, -0.6763898134231567, 0.13360536098480225, -0.21696722507476807, 0.41417673230171204, -0.8201872110366821, 0.03188640624284744, -0.33144304156303406, -0.18129634857177734, 0.5438619256019592, -0.1303720474243164, -0.3238690495491028, -0.1979272961616516, -0.15869957208633423, -0.38472482562065125, -0.20362092554569244, -0.17285844683647156, -0.21044719219207764, 0.29734116792678833, 0.03676285967230797, -0.828361988067627, -0.19776013493537903, -0.6123829483985901, 0.5368982553482056, 0.10395514219999313, 0.3234553337097168, 1.0955475568771362, -0.6697028279304504, 0.7584226131439209, 0.8051730990409851, 0.5478242039680481, -0.31680941581726074, -0.446763277053833, -0.3186091184616089, -0.16484472155570984, -0.6550649404525757, -0.4404178559780121, -0.4878740608692169, -0.6888178586959839, 0.04889824613928795, 0.06012766808271408, 0.013181998394429684, -0.07994084060192108, 0.35369524359703064, 0.2574913799762726, 0.08187735080718994, 0.5127202272415161, 0.1297522932291031, -0.35135766863822937, 0.25235626101493835, 0.08743239939212799, 0.9486135244369507, -0.2685730755329132, 0.801397979259491, -0.20292004942893982, 0.2447168380022049, -0.3455437421798706, 0.6613983511924744, 0.7603867650032043, 0.7196720242500305, -0.06101398169994354, -0.16446362435817719, 0.23227523267269135, -0.8303490281105042, 0.6440887451171875, 1.0368863344192505, -0.4349370002746582, 1.2216911315917969, -0.6656516194343567, 1.1773383617401123, 0.1351936310529709, -0.46798691153526306, -0.5470390915870667, -0.625754714012146, -0.31621694564819336, -0.07755468040704727, -0.11207237094640732, -0.38098764419555664, 0.505395770072937, 1.1125798225402832, -0.13974392414093018, 0.661103367805481, -0.6505458354949951, 0.5203883647918701, -0.4394020140171051, 0.34965962171554565, 0.08903282880783081, 0.16123247146606445, 0.5241267085075378, 0.04088319465517998, 0.32512491941452026, 0.5398243069648743, -0.8170354962348938, -0.26896965503692627, -0.5799049735069275, -0.5021291375160217, -0.08599631488323212, 0.11713185161352158, -0.5312212109565735, 0.356589138507843, -0.01068885438144207, 1.4973822832107544, -0.10781728476285934, -0.21371202170848846, -0.08473185449838638, 0.6828041076660156, -0.8738850951194763, 0.9620952606201172, 0.0756395235657692, 0.5215234160423279, -1.0751246213912964, -0.7650285363197327, -0.5440481305122375, -0.42408129572868347, 0.4201493263244629, 0.5065557360649109, 0.2403506636619568, -0.166717067360878, 0.20586755871772766, 0.09579003602266312, 0.15421342849731445, 0.4016004800796509, 0.4036480486392975, -0.28329434990882874, -0.8206276893615723, -0.2540948688983917, -0.4738389253616333, 0.94144207239151, -0.6615614891052246, 0.7632998824119568, 0.008853772655129433, -0.042612455785274506, 1.041102409362793, -0.5123804211616516, 0.5889108180999756, -0.21933522820472717, -0.6621891260147095, -0.23189222812652588, 0.22214870154857635, 0.6928667426109314, 0.7311478853225708, -0.7002496123313904, 0.5864996314048767, 0.6910296082496643, -0.2432974874973297, 0.05182896554470062, -0.04471564665436745, 0.44664841890335083, -0.2567039728164673, 0.457508385181427, -0.5872047543525696, -0.36179864406585693, -0.40605607628822327, -0.18173019587993622, 0.0005465810536406934, 0.5355225205421448, -0.2395137995481491, 0.912173330783844, 0.7166022658348083, 0.2674453854560852, -0.5597501397132874, 0.7253787517547607, 0.6260449886322021, -0.4351480007171631, -0.23910857737064362, 0.7357658743858337, 0.020996633917093277, 0.39252081513404846, -0.1085895374417305, 0.972603976726532, -0.16160143911838531, 0.4283965826034546, -0.9848079681396484, 0.016503652557730675, 0.9174342751502991, 0.6697651147842407, -0.6064260601997375, 0.449878990650177, 0.10813447833061218, 0.31663772463798523, -0.3456543982028961, 0.27753132581710815, -0.24373634159564972, 0.4550449252128601, 0.04319092258810997, -0.2307528555393219, 0.5970045924186707, -0.33328914642333984, 0.25482872128486633, 0.4215458631515503, 0.7383161783218384, 0.7340143322944641, -0.3145938813686371, 0.35236984491348267, 0.22955544292926788, 0.7815943360328674, 0.17080675065517426, 0.08626370131969452, 0.8784341812133789, 0.5345535278320312, 0.17338824272155762, 0.8479684591293335, 0.8992434144020081, 0.5841468572616577, 0.9764758944511414, 0.9180557727813721, 0.94474858045578, 0.09312262386083603, -0.30030015110969543, 0.4579963684082031, -0.5410156846046448, 0.018034735694527626, -0.604917049407959, 0.2529631555080414, 0.0862235352396965, 0.6048333048820496, 0.6588044762611389, 0.9530027508735657, -0.7909369468688965, 0.19592085480690002, 0.7863672971725464, 0.39268404245376587, -0.1672125607728958, -0.5960931777954102, -0.3402373194694519, 0.1740894615650177, 0.3775637447834015, 0.2225007861852646, 0.8251076340675354, 0.7492110729217529, 0.20409084856510162, 0.5996174812316895, 0.290994256734848, -0.09715254604816437, -0.6591339707374573, -0.2869015038013458, -1.1944538354873657, -1.0954692363739014, -0.9734317064285278, 0.408364474773407, -0.35025355219841003, -0.4741188585758209, 0.012031485326588154, 0.37021395564079285, -0.5483814477920532, 0.12131530791521072, -0.061027202755212784, 0.5204875469207764, 0.5962979197502136, 0.19609950482845306, -1.078590750694275, 0.08368624746799469, -0.059569377452135086, 0.10473930835723877, 0.04892923682928085, -0.268372118473053, -0.5933040380477905, -0.5689181685447693, 0.6579198837280273, -0.6176350712776184, -0.4190283715724945, 0.08469236642122269, -0.43554744124412537, -0.31473204493522644, 0.4917178153991699, 0.3147221505641937, 0.22358441352844238, 0.10802601277828217, -0.41699281334877014, 1.2228844165802002, -0.13581040501594543, 0.1999037116765976, 0.673240065574646, -0.035068802535533905, -0.012260882183909416, 0.20783968269824982, 0.24262981116771698, 0.44944867491722107, -0.2727099657058716, -0.11108945310115814, 0.6604467630386353, -0.8345438241958618, 0.34721460938453674, -0.5758848786354065, -0.5677551627159119, -0.65792316198349, 0.5166378021240234, -0.3245505690574646, 0.3277817666530609, -0.490012526512146, -0.07882516831159592, -1.6174445152282715, -0.02513364516198635, -0.9030556082725525, -1.3732613325119019, -0.09680317342281342, -0.3188718855381012, 0.5643568634986877, 0.6183093190193176, -0.16126489639282227, -0.12802141904830933, 0.1665954440832138, -0.1187630146741867, 0.06744490563869476, 0.41565951704978943, -0.1292751580476761, 0.19387425482273102, 0.4905577003955841, -0.9549066424369812, 0.6628832221031189, -0.09861873090267181, 0.19385910034179688, -0.25650545954704285, -0.04260634630918503, 0.5129356384277344, 0.2276814877986908, 1.1423399448394775, 0.5639395117759705, -0.5758013725280762, 0.7092905044555664, 0.3983606994152069, 0.41478076577186584, 0.5268843173980713, 0.37121257185935974, -0.5668339133262634, 0.4694853723049164, -0.7052920460700989, 0.28798940777778625, -0.7030936479568481, 0.00013485108502209187, 0.41060787439346313, 0.16268731653690338, 0.48531362414360046, 0.09033964574337006, 0.5976880788803101, -0.15388694405555725, -0.15691924095153809, 0.020313505083322525, 0.010428613983094692, -0.1822696030139923, 1.092516541481018, 0.7370638251304626, 1.2227767705917358, -1.9998821020126343, 0.7757402062416077, -0.10042707622051239, 0.7956898808479309, 0.6073278784751892, 0.10598226636648178, 0.38030728697776794, -0.7178099751472473, 0.5941131711006165, -0.2260046899318695, -0.7140204906463623, 0.0892500951886177, -0.002617104211822152, 0.19366058707237244, -0.3571910858154297, -0.651610255241394, -0.8420724868774414, 0.3877454996109009, 0.7143080830574036, 0.25982466340065, -0.07393788546323776, 0.4545101225376129, -0.5409235954284668, 0.6880310773849487, 0.17903518676757812, 0.21027567982673645, 0.14281348884105682, -0.6833329796791077, -0.17554733157157898, -0.5467526316642761, -0.3802318274974823, 0.12874960899353027, -0.6372942328453064, -0.0997832715511322, -0.6041135191917419, 0.535851001739502, 0.13471968472003937, 0.27504706382751465, -0.48795753717422485, 0.07204153388738632, 0.7777315974235535, -0.02181648090481758, 0.23125341534614563, -0.7032091617584229, 0.2982688546180725, -0.20001603662967682, -0.5116986036300659, 0.25687292218208313, -1.3172168731689453, 0.5611323714256287, 0.6838522553443909, -0.9544316530227661, -0.6782205700874329, -0.7127232551574707, 0.017010992392897606, -0.4140031039714813, -0.21215085685253143, -0.2411492019891739, -0.47606873512268066, 0.3059433698654175, -0.5275750160217285, -0.07370317727327347, -0.18428602814674377, -0.3168635666370392, -0.23405030369758606, 0.2184109389781952, -0.091830313205719, 0.8762224912643433, 0.3474903702735901, 0.38285577297210693, -0.222042977809906, 0.8906042575836182, -0.677430272102356, 0.46498775482177734, -0.4080851972103119, -0.37687617540359497, -0.7636815905570984, -0.5948010087013245, -0.15109966695308685, 0.03248259797692299, -1.0438464879989624, -0.7565900683403015, -0.016129877418279648, 0.11389132589101791, -0.05368412286043167, -0.5864070057868958, 0.9503166079521179, -0.9843053817749023, -0.16478808224201202, 0.6820690631866455, -0.31420624256134033, -0.23584847152233124, 0.08688739687204361, -0.46390441060066223, -0.7150139212608337, 0.8420953154563904, 0.13325972855091095, 0.14973184466362, 0.5447884202003479, -0.41657036542892456, 0.6072598099708557, 0.31188201904296875, 0.417010098695755, -0.4367389380931854, -0.8750709891319275, -0.670134961605072, -0.3163871169090271, -0.3109288811683655, 0.032825883477926254, -0.6481090188026428, 0.7560576796531677, 0.3066777288913727, -0.3199200928211212, -1.1936246156692505, 0.5278354287147522, -0.2349899858236313, -0.5059109926223755, -0.06407521665096283, -0.7406620979309082, -0.24460932612419128, 0.4294080138206482, 0.22214530408382416, -0.8900545835494995, -0.39045262336730957, -0.5406011939048767, 1.136253833770752, -0.7095848321914673, -0.793179988861084, -0.23447285592556, -0.22038380801677704, -0.662446141242981, -0.3111262321472168, -0.08899377286434174, -0.5489605665206909, -0.04947487264871597, 0.014708910137414932, 0.5098037719726562, 0.4023597836494446, -0.4135521352291107, 0.25852394104003906, 0.6364858746528625, -0.6165946125984192, -0.5308246612548828, -0.31271663308143616, 0.5974507331848145, -0.11747884005308151, 0.16259410977363586, -0.33907783031463623, -0.7537429928779602, -1.0530688762664795, -0.8381327390670776, -0.6077049374580383, -0.47054386138916016, 0.3716351389884949, -0.09836234897375107, -0.3134622871875763, 0.07234691083431244, 0.8797010779380798, 0.29935726523399353, 0.6681594252586365, 0.3597516417503357, -0.8207136392593384, 0.763300359249115, 0.09745389968156815, -0.33568862080574036, -0.14264902472496033, -0.42688554525375366, 0.07546627521514893, 1.0317233800888062, 0.4092821776866913, -0.06496992707252502, 0.30672216415405273, 0.09029708057641983, 0.014626875519752502, 0.18437445163726807, -0.7395349144935608, -0.5497670769691467, 0.40501710772514343, 0.757087767124176, -0.45994630455970764, -0.20896439254283905, -1.2184278964996338, 1.0061572790145874, -0.44210579991340637, 0.48110610246658325, 0.43837594985961914, -0.49621444940567017, 0.8712397813796997, -0.8118785619735718, 0.7379138469696045, -0.18409869074821472, -0.23088377714157104, -0.0817687064409256, -0.08528933674097061, 0.2797728180885315, 0.059198349714279175, -0.741409957408905, -0.23035487532615662, -0.5757241249084473, -1.4161251783370972, 0.6425893902778625, 0.5413781404495239, 0.4558669924736023, 0.005688127130270004, -0.3963363468647003, 0.5589660406112671, -0.6055256724357605, 0.776318371295929, 0.4608507752418518, -0.8411226272583008, -0.6864737868309021, -0.32753637433052063, 0.6207401156425476, 0.042251039296388626, 0.5062381625175476, 0.6437009572982788, -0.34024274349212646, -0.29631590843200684, -0.34189456701278687, -0.40134522318840027, -0.3769342303276062, -0.4704343378543854, 0.28140613436698914, 0.36613747477531433, -0.0032650555949658155, 0.0317651592195034, -0.2536308765411377, -0.4723578691482544, -0.1568022221326828, 0.3632335960865021, -0.13964629173278809, 0.8634039163589478, 0.6113219261169434, 0.1735832244157791, -0.23886753618717194, 1.2660144567489624, 0.20912104845046997, 0.00027928611962124705, 0.2746391296386719, -0.06415487825870514, 0.03236908093094826, -0.9203609228134155, 0.5800858736038208, 0.6011151671409607, -1.1013609170913696, 0.03312257304787636, -0.3420577943325043, -0.46303457021713257, 0.30463746190071106, -0.08029252290725708, -0.14566285908222198, 0.7029518485069275, 0.2297113686800003, 0.7077532410621643, -0.34457889199256897, -0.14288848638534546, -0.28063875436782837, -0.21090370416641235, 0.40628790855407715, -0.8447784781455994, -0.24028339982032776, 0.21625271439552307, -0.8040758371353149, 0.3218421936035156, 0.6412076354026794, 0.1360788345336914, 0.18576884269714355, -0.11589308828115463, 0.27146685123443604, -1.172294020652771, -0.5057529211044312, -0.5228844285011292, 0.09432931244373322, -0.22929790616035461, -0.001999493921175599, -0.2851974070072174, 0.5386751294136047, -0.07146847248077393, -0.9251405596733093, -1.1427620649337769, 0.2900422215461731, -0.03372592478990555, 0.5884506106376648, 0.24129179120063782, -0.11766240000724792, 0.4069708287715912, -0.4757034182548523, 0.04367881268262863, -0.2242390364408493, -0.8447912335395813, -1.4361721277236938, -0.7270587086677551, -0.46708157658576965, -0.5467246770858765, -0.0379641056060791, 1.308689832687378, 0.6675812602043152, -0.6068858504295349, -0.3869766294956207, 0.6102427840232849, -0.5620380640029907, 0.05494935065507889, 0.10748051851987839, 0.4938364326953888, -0.21987256407737732, -0.6873154640197754, 0.13684263825416565, -0.27810022234916687, -0.09835215657949448, 0.24686330556869507, -0.8239173889160156, 0.24470792710781097, -0.10543791204690933, 0.08249982446432114, 0.12412720173597336, 0.4544278383255005, -0.9447548985481262, -0.2518994212150574, -0.34204575419425964, 0.5060287117958069, 0.5655154585838318, 0.31401169300079346, 0.8470619320869446, -0.3890031576156616, 0.01674644649028778, 0.3498455882072449, -0.8781271576881409, -0.5048909187316895, 0.4091320037841797, 0.12135524302721024, -0.30658549070358276, -0.8236970901489258, -0.183503195643425, 0.36342036724090576, -0.8129442930221558, -0.7845905423164368, -1.0134001970291138, 0.6259233951568604, -0.16881494224071503, -0.221797376871109, -0.08947513997554779, 0.6391043066978455, -0.07008610665798187, 0.6827571988105774, -0.6710927486419678, 0.6479929685592651, -0.07561041414737701, 0.22528161108493805, 0.26179519295692444, 0.04762636125087738, 0.43636250495910645, -0.7498843669891357, 0.015701577067375183, 0.2287464141845703, -0.44766494631767273, 0.4069131314754486, 0.025789866223931313, -0.5358785390853882, 0.2615946829319, 0.2651852071285248, 0.35664960741996765, 0.9034449458122253, 0.028327126055955887, 0.32075151801109314, -0.2892003059387207, -0.4377245604991913, -0.9285967946052551, -0.6373850107192993, -1.0463372468948364, 0.02534383162856102, 0.08728237450122833, -0.7778679728507996, -0.03379154950380325, -0.3633936643600464, -0.8658314943313599, 0.562556266784668, -0.8192729353904724, 0.706499457359314, 0.10549669712781906, 0.6482101082801819, 0.016101907938718796, 0.1889439970254898, -0.18451844155788422, -0.5399576425552368, 0.41429027915000916, -0.05727069079875946, -0.4069342613220215, -0.7145991325378418, -0.30239975452423096, 0.6827160120010376, 0.20207080245018005, -0.3849638104438782, -0.32078444957733154, -0.37568148970603943, 0.2119714468717575, 0.147208109498024, -0.030580686405301094, -0.08476246148347855, -0.4740146994590759, -0.07447859644889832, -0.32314467430114746, 0.03219392150640488, -0.9100815057754517, 0.17674732208251953, -0.5134572386741638, -1.2880537509918213, -0.21657328307628632, 0.0648408830165863, 0.6943601369857788, -0.1264183670282364, 0.5438236594200134, -1.184869647026062, 0.19505324959754944, 0.38658806681632996, -0.0582379549741745, -0.3140786588191986, 1.0869415998458862, 0.11934807151556015, -0.3929583430290222, -0.4727381765842438, -0.11113420873880386, 0.6625339388847351, 0.1374645084142685, -0.02051105722784996, 0.36110711097717285, 0.14133979380130768, 0.3781871795654297, 0.04052168130874634, -0.5407536625862122, 0.032532550394535065, 0.5091884732246399, -0.7720668315887451, -0.5421703457832336, 0.14942260086536407, 0.947210431098938, 0.09591786563396454, -0.572659432888031, 0.8048374056816101, -0.5523550510406494, -0.8254953622817993, -0.09478521347045898, 0.19184646010398865, 0.6786869168281555, 0.19813910126686096, 0.47874587774276733, 0.8222110867500305, 0.3940030038356781, -0.4638655185699463, -0.6295024752616882, 0.3723732531070709, -0.2480141669511795, -0.36504217982292175, -0.1688014715909958, 0.26430195569992065, -0.6638811826705933, -0.6852706670761108, -0.03177649900317192, -0.5766979455947876, 0.31946539878845215, 0.8145162463188171, -0.5594693422317505, 0.42357757687568665, 1.0376391410827637, -0.4390197694301605, -0.9108282327651978, -0.47595688700675964, 0.08877567201852798, -0.23552434146404266, -0.1320178508758545, 0.5212103724479675, -0.3833083212375641, 0.6456788182258606, 0.004715961869806051, 0.23546771705150604, 0.3313179612159729, 0.833652138710022, 0.4824943542480469, -0.17601242661476135, 0.65851891040802, 0.7113989591598511, -0.15889300405979156, 0.25698140263557434, -0.6813004016876221, -0.2051485925912857, 0.41002157330513, -0.8969752788543701, 0.12847919762134552, -0.09692835807800293, -0.495955228805542, -0.34581735730171204, 0.5200651288032532, 0.30278775095939636, 0.1559523493051529, -0.6655313968658447, -0.43161076307296753, 0.10195077955722809, 0.7500301003456116, -0.5622895359992981, -0.3559738099575043, 0.10855863988399506, -0.12420641630887985, 0.21876069903373718, -0.20735521614551544, 0.057011596858501434, 0.504081666469574, -0.8615183234214783, 1.0425922870635986, -0.26345905661582947, 0.1572742760181427, -0.34543704986572266, -1.5285422801971436, -0.18097011744976044, 0.6033841371536255, 0.5880451202392578, -0.9607754349708557, -0.28330472111701965, 0.12387470155954361, 0.591253399848938, -0.2200038731098175, 0.19475091993808746, -0.34771963953971863, 0.26513952016830444, 1.0312341451644897, -0.5851673483848572, 0.3952997028827667, 0.14522111415863037, 0.13495028018951416, 0.17763490974903107, 0.011933820322155952, -0.4493523836135864, 0.3622586131095886, -0.6640084385871887, -0.819392740726471, -0.06350815296173096, 0.0005811990704387426, -0.4482739269733429, 0.039030540734529495, 0.4864842891693115, -0.5335637927055359, -0.18359078466892242, -0.8055150508880615, -0.41250094771385193, -0.7302338480949402, 1.181299090385437, -0.35545992851257324, 0.3942853808403015, 0.4582670331001282, 0.4119584858417511, 0.6425794363021851, -0.8327070474624634, 4.0016913414001465, 0.9564104080200195, 0.563918948173523, -0.033282749354839325, 1.0064940452575684, 0.10752066969871521, 1.4087425470352173, -0.2641999125480652, 0.36697453260421753, 0.4671221375465393, -0.5698028206825256, 0.35712921619415283, 0.7886853218078613, -0.06999000161886215, 0.07911277562379837, 0.2190982699394226, -0.7313538193702698, 0.029989497736096382, 0.13709647953510284, -0.506254255771637, -1.1337523460388184, 0.106318399310112, 0.27008000016212463, -0.04663250222802162, 0.33654800057411194, -0.15336766839027405, 0.12055044621229172, -0.5843936800956726, -0.01637337915599346, -0.32878077030181885, 0.17687363922595978, -0.7778950929641724, 0.5061567425727844, -0.5988005995750427, -0.2817772328853607, 0.5018316507339478, -0.12028153240680695, -0.9024267196655273, -0.09850453585386276, -0.030989956110715866, -0.09400460124015808, 0.04433392733335495, -0.1404106467962265, -0.19127854704856873, -0.24872329831123352, 0.5737857818603516, 0.39503052830696106, 0.6101564764976501, 0.802478015422821, -0.2943231761455536, 0.15933078527450562, -0.6244381666183472, 0.4196387827396393, 0.08365172147750854, -0.43847793340682983, 0.1761481761932373, -0.280364990234375, -0.7657266855239868, -0.37626802921295166, 0.5602526664733887, 0.3220655024051666, -0.163792684674263, -0.24402888119220734, 0.38422250747680664, 0.5856978297233582, 0.4883575439453125, 0.08104938268661499, -0.14593364298343658, 0.10518541187047958, -0.014610372483730316, 0.11175350099802017, -0.7880094647407532, -1.001665711402893, 0.17096611857414246, 0.7513418197631836, 0.44334977865219116, -0.06023934856057167, 0.8600926995277405, -0.7979840636253357, -0.6897402405738831, 0.484328031539917, 0.07037997245788574, 0.002823709510266781, -0.1887982338666916, 0.5197818279266357, 1.3761711120605469, -0.7630125880241394, -0.3969936966896057, -1.0687432289123535, 0.47452983260154724, 0.5012707114219666, -0.10267727822065353, -0.06281373649835587, -0.3283608555793762, 0.15805546939373016 ]
{"Title": "Analyzing the Reversal Hypothesis of Obesity with Education: A Cross-Sectional Study of Adult Females in 34 Low- and Lower-Middle-Income Countries", "Authors": "Tang Cynthia Y., Woldu Henok G., Sheets Lincoln R.", "Abstract": "Abstract Setting Obesity, once considered an epidemic of the developed world, is now becoming an even more prominent problem than underweight in low and lower middle income countries (LLMICs). Ample literature has shown that as a country\u2019s income increases, the burden of obesity shifts from the rich to the poor. This is known as the \u201cReversal Hypothesis.\u201d Many studies have explored the effects of various social determinants of health on obesity, but few have studied education as an independent variable on female obesity across LLMICs. Objective Globally, adult females have a higher prevalence of obesity and the obesity shift occurs more quickly for women than for men. We aim to address this disparity and contribute towards the reversal hypothesis by exploring the association of education and obesity in women in LLMICs. Design In this cross-sectional study, we used a multi-national and multi-year database from the publicly available Demographic and Health Surveys program with data from 34 LLMICs. Education levels are standardized across countries during survey collection. Results Our age-adjusted prevalence ratio (AA-PR) analysis shows that women in LLMICs with higher education have a significantly greater prevalence of obesity than women with no education. We analyzed this phenomenon by individual nations, continents, and income classifications. Educated women living in low income countries are 5.12 times more obese than uneducated women (AA-PR, 95% CI=4.75, 5.53) and 3.42 times more obese in lower middle income countries (AA-PR, 95% CI=3.31, 3.54). Conclusion These findings highlight a need for more studies and policy attention focusing on female education levels, among other factors, to understand, predict, and prevent obesity in LLMICs. ARTICLE SUMMARY Strengths and limitations of this study A rigorous sample size of 943,947 adult females in 34 LLMIC countries was utilized to study the association between adult female obesity and education level. Age-adjusted and age-and-wealth-adjusted prevalence ratios of obesity were analyzed based on 34 individual nations, three continents, and two major income categories. This study includes the most recent data available through the Demographic and Health Surveys program, which standardizes education levels during data collection, allowing for comparison between all surveyed countries. This study is limited by the relatively small number of countries for which data is available through the DHS dataset, and thus, further research will be needed to show whether these results are generalizable to other LLMICs.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003004"}
10.1101/19010876
[ -0.12503375113010406, -0.11683927476406097, -0.1662396788597107, -0.21786744892597198, -0.31263628602027893, -0.35873210430145264, 0.04839831963181496, 0.2605535686016083, 1.0410264730453491, 0.4870641231536865, 0.05596227943897247, 0.2959533929824829, 0.2784286141395569, -0.4353271722793579, 0.5642053484916687, 0.08184987306594849, -0.10426522046327591, 0.11843524128198624, -0.19896633923053741, 0.4899592697620392, 0.23477233946323395, 0.5377715826034546, -0.9493213295936584, -0.07687351852655411, -0.38827863335609436, 0.1545724719762802, 0.26519355177879333, 0.00004533069295575842, 0.814911425113678, 1.0781220197677612, 0.34329754114151, -0.3408862054347992, 0.757522702217102, -0.8234187960624695, -0.21235370635986328, -0.015431140549480915, 1.191833734512329, -0.34067144989967346, 0.0135778384283185, -0.12176195532083511, -0.4769655168056488, -0.34321272373199463, 0.4018515646457672, -0.7583044171333313, -0.6462200284004211, -0.3462579548358917, -0.13917618989944458, -0.18090404570102692, 0.3227086067199707, -0.278070330619812, -0.7165598273277283, -0.3388573229312897, 0.2718152701854706, -0.8765652179718018, 0.053210195153951645, 0.12182546406984329, 0.6207869052886963, 0.24925683438777924, -0.24503351747989655, -0.01842990331351757, 0.1228993758559227, -0.3049581050872803, 0.4969058036804199, -1.0437027215957642, 1.1614817380905151, -0.23345331847667694, 0.04574935510754585, -0.5206379294395447, -0.37920650839805603, -0.49089515209198, -0.4753001928329468, -0.15321390330791473, -0.1322227418422699, -1.0556143522262573, 0.02269698679447174, -0.6484671235084534, 1.0681357383728027, 0.01838182471692562, -0.0842057466506958, -0.22709684073925018, 0.17006954550743103, 0.14875678718090057, 0.8922342658042908, 0.0206453874707222, -0.4846857190132141, -0.1571807712316513, 0.8581083416938782, 0.27561578154563904, 0.5794395804405212, 0.1570260226726532, 0.03296959400177002, 0.0588117279112339, -0.10563229769468307, -0.27267658710479736, 0.09103215485811234, 1.6115174293518066, -0.09360095113515854, 0.3076516091823578, 0.37668320536613464, -0.019031614065170288, 0.8070574402809143, 1.1810907125473022, -0.10802099853754044, 1.0271694660186768, -0.8155175447463989, 0.173772931098938, 1.2902189493179321, -0.8150603175163269, -0.18138614296913147, -0.9964637756347656, 0.484087735414505, 0.3132226765155792, -0.8127784132957458, 0.17351680994033813, 0.674037754535675, 0.8965475559234619, -0.5855181813240051, 0.5451260209083557, -0.3486887514591217, -0.5801941156387329, 0.3095515966415405, -0.3683336079120636, 0.239791139960289, -0.7218990921974182, 0.7608649730682373, 0.1928836852312088, -0.043449126183986664, 0.5439853668212891, -0.4377717077732086, -0.5740984082221985, 0.2332797646522522, -0.05654629319906235, 0.34589672088623047, 0.4856218099594116, 0.08861812949180603, 0.14296981692314148, 0.1568034291267395, 0.709683358669281, 0.020940212532877922, -0.32187172770500183, -0.5624321103096008, 0.8795285224914551, -0.25115928053855896, 1.1313283443450928, 0.1758199781179428, 0.4800122380256653, -0.34034669399261475, -1.1823625564575195, -0.5229805111885071, -0.44701439142227173, 0.07129829376935959, 0.5450004935264587, -0.26944229006767273, -0.40670305490493774, 0.3618236184120178, 0.246566042304039, 0.42539384961128235, 0.11230257898569107, -0.17943932116031647, -0.10605307668447495, -0.8565698862075806, 0.532687246799469, 0.02119814045727253, 0.8983848094940186, -0.5297761559486389, 0.8664501309394836, 0.0131803248077631, 0.5599848628044128, 0.027316773310303688, -0.47316545248031616, 0.7317900061607361, -0.012035206891596317, -0.5855157971382141, -0.2699339687824249, 0.9146340489387512, 0.8893958330154419, 0.45794156193733215, 0.16012997925281525, 0.299071729183197, 0.43955421447753906, -0.4926864206790924, -0.16016793251037598, 0.10207456350326538, 0.3280346989631653, -0.48835673928260803, -0.07429810613393784, 0.035482343286275864, -0.8791205883026123, -0.38621318340301514, -0.5460573434829712, -0.11698172241449356, 0.4696016311645508, 0.05014527216553688, 0.28864577412605286, -0.009320906363427639, 0.14563727378845215, 0.23864910006523132, 0.06486731767654419, 0.35765278339385986, 0.4647354781627655, -0.8305152058601379, -0.1217346116900444, 0.18017441034317017, 0.5386310815811157, -0.2877696454524994, 0.4881841242313385, 0.274905800819397, -0.276446670293808, -0.4853934943675995, 0.4184531569480896, 1.0427894592285156, -0.11582507938146591, -0.28951495885849, -0.18139542639255524, 0.8193858861923218, 0.21836383640766144, -0.02427501790225506, 0.27188441157341003, 0.1876228302717209, 0.440673291683197, -0.5504323840141296, 0.15053199231624603, 0.41526293754577637, -0.04797288775444031, -0.01509898528456688, 0.18862372636795044, 0.6770849227905273, 0.37531259655952454, -0.7452878355979919, 0.036390528082847595, 0.47369852662086487, 1.067633867263794, -0.3605813980102539, 0.5204606056213379, 0.5736974477767944, 0.1064552366733551, 0.33247143030166626, -0.034271590411663055, 0.12954695522785187, 0.030575454235076904, 0.66977459192276, 0.20625343918800354, 0.429618775844574, 0.7203977108001709, -0.7537276744842529, 0.5297210812568665, -0.35812366008758545, 0.3960024416446686, 0.2169468253850937, 0.2432188242673874, -0.5536754727363586, 0.5917163491249084, 0.436470091342926, 0.5714401006698608, -1.077866792678833, -0.6439863443374634, 0.07523209601640701, 0.14800713956356049, -0.7934864163398743, -0.13966140151023865, -0.5235797762870789, 0.7453593015670776, -0.6486502289772034, -0.49918249249458313, 0.44053342938423157, 0.24740120768547058, 0.19530516862869263, -0.10228271037340164, 0.10965767502784729, -0.3457498550415039, -1.5894279479980469, -0.26010701060295105, -0.921667218208313, -0.765764057636261, -0.7312884330749512, -0.1765809804201126, 0.24459531903266907, -0.5355541706085205, -0.09986452758312225, -0.4545402526855469, -0.02329227328300476, 0.6133055090904236, -0.05591220781207085, 0.14169412851333618, -0.03873281925916672, 0.4211268723011017, -1.0810867547988892, -0.04363652318716049, 0.07746709138154984, 0.42903053760528564, 0.1406782567501068, -0.3101009726524353, -0.595615565776825, 0.053260624408721924, -0.044606227427721024, -1.0935744047164917, 0.5008706450462341, -0.43665075302124023, -0.5115378499031067, -0.6580054759979248, 0.2559000253677368, -0.35289373993873596, 0.16854327917099, -0.1031675785779953, -0.33475491404533386, 0.7970728874206543, -0.248383566737175, -0.1762172430753708, 0.5903234481811523, 0.37848687171936035, -0.5930024981498718, 0.36685749888420105, 0.14500653743743896, -0.5268407464027405, -0.9381434321403503, 0.4246141314506531, 0.326109915971756, -0.6030820608139038, -0.009003853425383568, -0.5345253944396973, -0.4483335018157959, -0.06507604569196701, -0.0919271856546402, -0.1137629896402359, -0.32908153533935547, 0.5524252653121948, 0.26548901200294495, -1.4821873903274536, -0.17326444387435913, -0.045917801558971405, -0.9538512229919434, 0.44663941860198975, -0.2691178619861603, 0.44257819652557373, 0.42034265398979187, -0.15504921972751617, -0.17201590538024902, -0.1365763396024704, 0.13852155208587646, 0.38389071822166443, -0.13330377638339996, -0.2621803879737854, -0.1800030767917633, -0.1038486510515213, 0.0011562943691387773, 0.1851949691772461, -0.4373528063297272, -0.0025703837163746357, -0.3278859555721283, 0.07624856382608414, -0.3931675851345062, 0.21912191808223724, 0.2914450466632843, -0.07960254698991776, -0.17800375819206238, 0.30275312066078186, 0.001565855578519404, 0.0036688861437141895, 0.02445838414132595, 0.6337235569953918, 0.830566942691803, 0.7486679553985596, -0.5609298944473267, -0.09258288145065308, -1.014134407043457, 0.021894589066505432, 0.19513371586799622, 0.07508524507284164, -0.12533845007419586, -0.5282205939292908, 0.8939591646194458, -0.2968635559082031, -0.02295592799782753, 0.6719450354576111, -0.21572938561439514, -0.7313968539237976, 0.7818016409873962, 0.4408080577850342, 0.48720404505729675, -0.9239145517349243, -0.2538166344165802, 0.6977219581604004, 1.173561930656433, -0.0175201166421175, -0.2631426155567169, 1.204744815826416, -0.20412637293338776, 0.4596661329269409, 0.2528925836086273, -0.308646023273468, 0.20457474887371063, -0.5805357098579407, -0.237100750207901, -0.1866338849067688, -0.19291168451309204, 0.2689054310321808, 0.8626711368560791, 0.3934342563152313, -0.130873441696167, -0.17342984676361084, 0.5119217038154602, 0.023166142404079437, -0.008479590527713299, 0.2274501770734787, 0.10132890194654465, 0.4177762567996979, -0.46284106373786926, 0.06656958907842636, -0.38654473423957825, 0.1488112062215805, -0.9076887965202332, -0.5582508444786072, 0.09110213071107864, -0.07990892976522446, 0.541894257068634, 0.09860780835151672, -0.3948351740837097, -0.7419990301132202, -0.6538479924201965, 0.006409372203052044, 0.6235463619232178, 0.13779935240745544, -0.8977157473564148, 0.11445349454879761, -0.685818612575531, -0.13715341687202454, -0.17489196360111237, 0.08983725309371948, 0.380052387714386, 0.5407676696777344, -1.0827980041503906, -0.3314635455608368, -0.4892566204071045, -0.4670204818248749, -0.4307554364204407, 0.6940020322799683, -0.5470291376113892, 0.08904880285263062, 0.49745282530784607, -0.4472868740558624, -0.7214763760566711, -0.40686309337615967, -0.46020519733428955, -0.11119205504655838, 0.6461580395698547, 0.2584301233291626, 1.5793665647506714, 0.5013085603713989, 1.2813371419906616, 0.636898398399353, 0.8416614532470703, -0.3038965165615082, 0.4427645802497864, -0.5328094959259033, -0.24980735778808594, -0.1544846147298813, 0.09434902667999268, -0.9496146440505981, 0.3905402719974518, -0.25562646985054016, -0.48197153210639954, -0.29554423689842224, 0.23991265892982483, -0.39180272817611694, -0.6585795283317566, 1.2708394527435303, -0.6972203254699707, 0.7245345711708069, 1.9910578727722168, -1.0964609384536743, 0.045213133096694946, 0.3131438195705414, 0.17717257142066956, -0.22855043411254883, 0.7166290879249573, -0.22058777511119843, 0.1218830868601799, -0.05019669979810715, -0.14695888757705688, 0.16747699677944183, -0.26181867718696594, 0.2548925280570984, -0.7323097586631775, 0.3013576567173004, -0.3502233922481537, -0.8068252205848694, -0.7688074111938477, -0.25202712416648865, -0.8089978098869324, -0.1939401775598526, -0.6045709848403931, 0.2338906228542328, -0.18986141681671143, 0.08737917244434357, -1.0515230894088745, -0.2051651030778885, -0.20878510177135468, -0.07674025744199753, -0.3074548840522766, 0.1366182565689087, -0.43451571464538574, -1.1605876684188843, -0.6613878607749939, -0.045599304139614105, 0.6485016345977783, -0.8294708132743835, -0.6121898293495178, -0.4744635820388794, 0.3788470923900604, -0.7233383655548096, -0.29179519414901733, 0.054997753351926804, -0.3926433324813843, 0.0017555691301822662, -0.557396411895752, -0.31455180048942566, 0.4885868728160858, 0.30352458357810974, -0.5082781314849854, 0.47263044118881226, -0.0662456601858139, -0.6966593265533447, -0.33707213401794434, 0.19242890179157257, 0.039096806198358536, 0.29070034623146057, -0.3219178318977356, -0.5561164021492004, -0.34542402625083923, -0.7390219569206238, 0.49623119831085205, 0.08219322562217712, -0.44228115677833557, -0.15900099277496338, -0.47753024101257324, 0.026473818346858025, -0.09976304322481155, 0.32725194096565247, 0.3391399681568146, -0.23102474212646484, -0.6522623896598816, 0.36116892099380493, -0.19781593978405, 0.4604951739311218, 0.054411597549915314, -0.385789155960083, -0.21120776236057281, 1.125030279159546, 0.23537269234657288, -0.13881555199623108, -0.23860350251197815, -0.39850854873657227, 0.41714635491371155, 0.09883006662130356, -0.307101309299469, -0.5636469721794128, 0.04543397203087807, -0.09543465822935104, 0.224291130900383, -0.6410965919494629, -0.8367851972579956, -0.09131484478712082, -0.9001638889312744, 0.48681992292404175, -0.09350436180830002, -0.7007861733436584, -0.00473241601139307, -0.5461587309837341, 1.0886175632476807, -0.5954970717430115, 0.37509024143218994, 0.35870471596717834, -0.4142785966396332, -0.6703324913978577, 0.30750229954719543, -0.11342515051364899, -0.24413849413394928, -0.7084387540817261, -0.6854425668716431, 0.027237197384238243, 0.2614774703979492, 0.08848872035741806, 0.3473960757255554, -0.655575156211853, 0.36717861890792847, -0.9501520395278931, 0.4605574905872345, 0.6497393250465393, -0.19371622800827026, -0.12985168397426605, -0.33788496255874634, 0.5754154920578003, 0.31821209192276, -0.47862958908081055, 0.11488388478755951, -0.2978235185146332, -0.3829335570335388, -0.42866578698158264, -0.45243334770202637, -1.1407341957092285, 0.17695416510105133, 0.06865371018648148, 0.4766388535499573, 0.0987800657749176, -0.15880738198757172, 0.5267695188522339, -0.3117174506187439, -0.09770133346319199, 0.6213367581367493, -0.18957801163196564, 0.039873186498880386, 0.4540645182132721, -0.39556536078453064, -0.3407418131828308, 0.2193932682275772, -0.20431894063949585, 0.4730306565761566, -0.17373140156269073, 0.11685671657323837, -0.029784275218844414, -0.8268789649009705, 0.9239606857299805, -0.21345238387584686, -0.6213407516479492, 0.10445965081453323, -0.03197801858186722, -0.24331770837306976, 0.3034423291683197, 0.03904900327324867, -0.3624427914619446, 1.1475025415420532, -0.3056359887123108, 0.771125853061676, -1.0022364854812622, -0.286663293838501, -0.5674697756767273, -0.6395848989486694, 0.41899919509887695, -0.33740293979644775, 0.11168967187404633, 0.6897118091583252, -0.4478076696395874, 0.7626603841781616, -0.1717715561389923, -0.34504541754722595, 0.1737806797027588, -0.15955707430839539, -0.2127653956413269, -0.32769978046417236, -0.00018649708363227546, -0.14641062915325165, -0.3589307963848114, 0.1529567688703537, 0.04948277026414871, -0.5111769437789917, 0.7634908556938171, 0.3750866949558258, -0.6129137873649597, -0.2927889823913574, -0.277280330657959, 0.2483830451965332, 0.33290186524391174, 0.532517671585083, 0.42799606919288635, 0.9105523824691772, 0.1621568650007248, 0.021007154136896133, -0.6529092788696289, -0.5815923810005188, 0.010653938166797161, -0.5626523494720459, -0.03820258751511574, -0.4266161024570465, 0.0764290913939476, 0.5590730309486389, -0.33231237530708313, -0.452584445476532, -0.13227351009845734, 0.964777946472168, 0.1162814274430275, -0.1744711548089981, -0.6129121780395508, 0.47083261609077454, -1.3248001337051392, -0.3280193507671356, -0.09922932088375092, -0.3888402581214905, 0.5945178270339966, 0.6425662040710449, -0.7458139657974243, -0.4956720769405365, 0.5090858340263367, -0.33901292085647583, -0.02620033547282219, 0.5556029677391052, -0.5687420964241028, -0.47898975014686584, 0.6169134378433228, -0.07121877372264862, 0.11702186614274979, -0.09371596574783325, 1.474765658378601, -0.2885439991950989, 0.6358168721199036, 0.3060208261013031, -0.4527302086353302, 0.5543469786643982, 0.013155782595276833, 1.1220698356628418, -0.2533103823661804, -0.7376859784126282, -0.7869358062744141, 0.4996095299720764, -0.7603656053543091, -0.5586032271385193, -0.21746976673603058, -0.7466815710067749, -0.2662922441959381, -0.286528617143631, -0.12825806438922882, 0.735188901424408, -0.28933998942375183, -0.11977005749940872, -0.178609237074852, 0.406331330537796, -0.13497968018054962, 0.06835681200027466, 0.14544463157653809, 0.540043830871582, 0.1012781485915184, -0.8082646131515503, 0.47532302141189575, 0.44855228066444397, -0.010227499529719353, 0.3660278618335724, -0.028503162786364555, 0.4946652352809906, 0.36389052867889404, -0.7858743667602539, -0.5982104539871216, 1.034274935722351, 1.0715316534042358, 1.2527570724487305, 0.18688267469406128, -0.9127522706985474, -0.8079423308372498, -0.11006184667348862, -1.0663635730743408, -0.8208033442497253, 1.1977250576019287, 0.017042746767401695, -0.2770283818244934, -0.44960203766822815, -0.3240574598312378, 0.35960981249809265, 0.7023698687553406, 0.296354740858078, -0.6410131454467773, 0.11259927600622177, -0.13214194774627686, 0.4478168487548828, 0.4098612070083618, 0.11762845516204834, 0.050798192620277405, 0.31701406836509705, -0.39352571964263916, -0.4163013994693756, 0.047331418842077255, 0.5307111144065857, 0.5525122880935669, 0.2749098837375641, -0.33212870359420776, 0.21644560992717743, 0.8965906500816345, 0.13322648406028748, -0.6639953255653381, 0.07914378494024277, -0.5645232200622559, -0.112124003469944, 0.3792991042137146, 0.12877309322357178, -0.5282027721405029, 0.3032809793949127, 0.17472533881664276, -0.6454821825027466, -0.5407339930534363, 0.168997123837471, 0.3468673527240753, -0.614717423915863, 0.19277578592300415, 0.4343164563179016, 0.10371449589729309, 0.14042748510837555, -0.7500030398368835, 1.125118613243103, 0.6880534291267395, 0.03369251266121864, 0.12001201510429382, -0.40562736988067627, 0.02177824079990387, 0.9786230325698853, 0.9286677241325378, -0.01889951154589653, 0.5296617150306702, 0.06519899517297745, -0.21316640079021454, 0.08984504640102386, -0.2641579508781433, 0.3166745901107788, 0.01497071236371994, 0.278875470161438, 0.3652646243572235, 0.6669154167175293, 0.739664614200592, 0.23563407361507416, -0.6564332246780396, -0.08360875397920609, -0.527436375617981, -0.8983278870582581, 0.0057429419830441475, 0.7792090773582458, 0.5786727070808411, 0.08391866087913513, 0.5817158818244934, 0.0903424471616745, 0.5882115364074707, -0.17930985987186432, -0.11485099047422409, 0.7774934768676758, 0.07997125387191772, -0.2536018490791321, -0.330214262008667, 0.08609053492546082, -0.10451645404100418, 0.7878084182739258, 0.4247160255908966, -0.2412770539522171, 0.5263218879699707, 0.054221440106630325, -0.2771247327327728, -0.26826080679893494, 1.044751524925232, -0.35740146040916443, -0.42551249265670776, -0.5148345828056335, -0.1698429137468338, -0.8706053495407104, -0.5484301447868347, 0.8954384922981262, -0.72490394115448, 0.20888186991214752, -0.02393644116818905, 0.9577707648277283, 0.2234661728143692, -0.024225961416959763, 1.133112907409668, -0.5731072425842285, 0.6983523368835449, 0.6683861613273621, -0.14474603533744812, -0.28328534960746765, 0.030961444601416588, -0.057329196482896805, -0.7724133729934692, -0.20878475904464722, 0.579703688621521, 0.26517701148986816, 0.16882206499576569, -0.0983951985836029, 0.5959992408752441, -0.881340742111206, 0.04498259723186493, -0.8620163798332214, -0.3688456118106842, -0.5009973049163818, 0.3081684708595276, -0.1950758546590805, 0.5866813659667969, 0.35231706500053406, 0.17285631597042084, -0.0898362472653389, -0.44200795888900757, -0.46274444460868835, 0.3554733097553253, -0.6069977283477783, 0.15076929330825806, 0.01897195354104042, -0.014669074676930904, -0.02507329173386097, -1.077787160873413, 0.4852808713912964, -0.006906297989189625, -0.38743868470191956, -0.6536176800727844, 0.827774167060852, -0.006201871670782566, 1.0485914945602417, -0.44000089168548584, -0.6095351576805115, -0.12229696661233902, -0.1482105851173401, 0.25784075260162354, 0.13219186663627625, 0.784809947013855, 0.23387403786182404, 0.3449663817882538, 0.4354802370071411, -0.45579686760902405, -0.12045091390609741, 0.2181430160999298, -0.5010935068130493, 0.2705330550670624, 0.3379659950733185, -0.23766189813613892, -0.8105966448783875, 0.2892252206802368, 0.7406526207923889, 0.0744924545288086, -0.2033853828907013, -0.7608610987663269, -0.3587716817855835, -0.30605804920196533, 0.7257736921310425, -0.7113367319107056, 0.20679910480976105, 0.20865000784397125, -0.15758651494979858, 0.5764755606651306, -0.5460122227668762, 4.131262302398682, 0.7803367376327515, 0.5373272895812988, -0.3730626106262207, 1.0990185737609863, 0.18880793452262878, 1.146624207496643, 0.21432621777057648, 0.10590053349733353, -0.13335326313972473, 0.0519983135163784, -0.6403724551200867, -0.21798662841320038, 0.10628111660480499, -0.14684361219406128, 0.018263978883624077, -1.1796261072158813, -0.4123980700969696, 0.737818717956543, -1.1547088623046875, -0.39508166909217834, 0.07687785476446152, -0.1732170134782791, 0.22294190526008606, 0.4315774738788605, -0.03145920857787132, -0.20254655182361603, -0.20750345289707184, 0.06300082057714462, -0.5093796253204346, -0.5348080396652222, -1.0910286903381348, 0.5908269286155701, -0.10102379322052002, -0.5150173306465149, 0.3593177795410156, -0.014950934797525406, -0.23195500671863556, -0.15781475603580475, -0.2546727955341339, 0.3561885952949524, 0.20095133781433105, -0.5178937315940857, 0.04413394257426262, -0.2605499029159546, 0.12547451257705688, -1.235927700996399, 0.5481249094009399, -0.04255879670381546, -0.8497909903526306, 1.0660899877548218, -0.8071957230567932, 0.6273280382156372, -0.6988015174865723, -0.4263019561767578, -0.47883641719818115, -0.033891379833221436, -1.1130114793777466, 0.24290405213832855, 0.9104222655296326, 1.1785128116607666, 0.42315614223480225, -0.32902097702026367, 0.45061254501342773, -0.12370418757200241, 0.7133851051330566, -0.0235908105969429, -0.11969085782766342, 0.06416980922222137, -0.7927693128585815, 0.23906870186328888, -0.3301289677619934, -0.6078335046768188, -0.05558941140770912, 0.937158465385437, 0.5345064401626587, -0.29287058115005493, 0.8520651459693909, -0.9671772122383118, -0.6413086652755737, 0.28402718901634216, 0.42422568798065186, 0.21317388117313385, -0.08365726470947266, 0.14482346177101135, 1.0164670944213867, -0.7999770641326904, -0.3691485524177551, -0.6098872423171997, 0.37195155024528503, 0.12405476719141006, -0.601280152797699, -0.23694971203804016, 0.8474952578544617, -0.3107202649116516 ]
{"Title": "Validity of using cancer registry data for comparative effectiveness research", "Authors": "Kumar Abhishek, Guss Zachary D, Courtney Patrick T, Nalawade Vinit, Sheridan Paige, Sarkar Reith R, Banegas Matthew P, Rose Brent S, Xu Ronghui, Murphy James D", "Abstract": "Abstract Purpose Researchers often analyze cancer registry data to assess for differences in survival among cancer treatments. However, the retrospective non-random design of these analyses raise questions about study validity. The purpose of this study was to determine the extent to which comparative effectiveness analyses using cancer registry data produces results concordant with randomized clinical trials. Methods We identified 141 randomized clinical trials referenced in the National Comprehensive Cancer Network Clinical Practice Guidelines for 8 common solid tumor types. For each trial we identified subjects from the National Cancer Database (NCDB) matching the eligibility criteria of the randomized trial. With each trial we used three Cox regression models to determine hazard ratios (HRs) for overall survival including univariable, multivariable, and propensity score adjusted models. Multivariable and propensity score analyses controlled for potential confounders including demographic, comorbidity, clinical, treatment, and tumor-related variables. Each NCDB survival analysis was defined as discordant if the HR for the NCDB analysis fell outside the 95% confidence interval of the corresponding randomized trial. Results NCDB analyses produced HRs for survival discordant with randomized trials in 62 (44%) univariable analyses, 43 (30%) multivariable analyses, and 51 (36%) propensity score models. NCDB analyses produced p-values discordant with randomized trials in 83 (59%) univariable analyses, 76 (54%) multivariable analyses, and 78 (55%) propensity score models. We did not identify any clinical trial characteristic associated with discordance between NCDB analyses and randomized trials including disease site, type of clinical intervention, or severity of cancer. Conclusion Comparative effectiveness research with cancer registry data often produces survival outcomes discordant to randomized clinical data. These findings help provide context for providers interpreting observational comparative effectiveness research in oncology.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010876"}
10.1101/19012112
[ 0.440807044506073, 0.6323843002319336, -0.18612495064735413, 1.2242351770401, -0.9157991409301758, -0.9882055521011353, -0.05274979770183563, 0.24971306324005127, 0.4933866858482361, 0.19767895340919495, -0.496199369430542, -0.32209715247154236, 0.036056481301784515, -0.40259405970573425, -0.25783637166023254, -0.24226108193397522, -0.3293904960155487, -0.686777651309967, -0.19474846124649048, 0.22096848487854004, -0.21725507080554962, 0.9183945655822754, -0.7017408609390259, -0.1103382408618927, -0.2571639120578766, 1.109657645225525, -0.37397730350494385, 0.0371503047645092, 1.3730692863464355, 0.05376998335123062, 0.1389921009540558, -0.045984186232089996, 0.37594130635261536, -0.8240064382553101, -0.2942962646484375, -0.3475465476512909, 0.5116487145423889, -0.5623615980148315, 0.18664264678955078, -0.5934512615203857, 1.055917739868164, -0.08836313337087631, 0.0516982227563858, -1.2278339862823486, -0.9160894155502319, -0.5663896203041077, -0.4531971514225006, 0.01297811046242714, -0.26866796612739563, -0.03139195591211319, -0.3907342553138733, 0.1973113864660263, 0.028263414278626442, 0.2514522969722748, 0.19638098776340485, -0.11490432918071747, 0.753804624080658, 0.15293456614017487, -0.6653496026992798, 0.5157054662704468, 0.04257607460021973, 0.5258859992027283, 0.33072158694267273, -0.8614474534988403, 0.5997958779335022, 0.8955870270729065, -0.2970631718635559, -0.1739540994167328, -0.45054349303245544, -0.3745323717594147, -0.6009714603424072, -0.09316785633563995, -0.32416459918022156, -0.9226045608520508, 0.17683914303779602, -0.6497576236724854, 0.3760070502758026, -0.6064885854721069, -0.017381485551595688, -0.12321805953979492, -0.4559887647628784, 0.002981437835842371, 0.21376702189445496, 0.4295518398284912, -0.15400050580501556, 0.3554135262966156, 0.06539738923311234, 0.18514959514141083, 0.4226168990135193, 0.2700120210647583, 0.16357645392417908, 0.03520137071609497, -0.2271842211484909, -0.21737933158874512, -0.039348501712083817, 0.8551539182662964, -0.4532391428947449, 0.044542182236909866, 0.062350671738386154, -0.5688692927360535, 1.041178822517395, 0.09869545698165894, 0.4733050763607025, 0.5152887105941772, -0.9651166796684265, 0.8709577322006226, 0.8191635608673096, -0.47111544013023376, -0.4672449231147766, -0.8162723183631897, -0.20892798900604248, -0.49882352352142334, -0.27686700224876404, 0.0022421195171773434, -0.2754916548728943, 0.6037592887878418, -0.10650687664747238, 0.6213668584823608, -0.8525241017341614, -0.26822465658187866, -0.037295933812856674, -0.045815881341695786, 0.6557945013046265, -0.20877912640571594, 0.45307374000549316, -0.40187308192253113, 0.1972535401582718, 0.1635866016149521, 0.030615540221333504, -0.42943206429481506, -0.10155095160007477, -0.47140592336654663, 0.07908674329519272, 1.2884656190872192, -0.1576182246208191, -0.29958826303482056, 0.3761712312698364, -0.10919924080371857, 0.41359156370162964, -0.9216316938400269, -0.489840567111969, 0.37834423780441284, -0.37349143624305725, 1.0919935703277588, -0.3710411489009857, 0.8572049140930176, -0.17793585360050201, -1.041284441947937, -0.12644046545028687, -0.33346718549728394, -0.22062639892101288, 0.842187762260437, -0.1651543378829956, -0.15283456444740295, -0.1938929557800293, -0.31657522916793823, -0.8250981569290161, 0.2349039912223816, -0.19418305158615112, -0.28858816623687744, -0.016063425689935684, 0.3242132067680359, -0.80473792552948, 0.837886393070221, -0.42168334126472473, -0.1541859358549118, -0.03787791356444359, 0.6232352256774902, 0.644291877746582, -0.42951706051826477, 0.5993062853813171, 0.3458414375782013, -0.894732654094696, 0.2796562612056732, 0.06487737596035004, 1.1539369821548462, 1.019271731376648, 0.8035323619842529, 0.3063569664955139, -0.08140197396278381, -0.06948965042829514, -0.2369665503501892, 0.34165698289871216, 1.536827802658081, 0.6515674591064453, -0.11241491883993149, -0.46697568893432617, -0.838501513004303, 0.1568632870912552, -0.6044023036956787, -0.2126334011554718, 0.5792514085769653, -1.0465480089187622, 0.46290743350982666, 0.23700425028800964, 0.5610591173171997, 0.17837704718112946, 0.7540454864501953, 0.08646463602781296, -0.21673038601875305, -0.3284904658794403, 0.8587349057197571, -0.33879905939102173, 0.7276434898376465, -0.09708784520626068, 0.05036440119147301, 0.9220835566520691, 0.26172691583633423, 0.0728766992688179, 0.2353111356496811, 0.28929874300956726, 0.08838173002004623, -0.38549527525901794, 0.1929040402173996, 0.8648350834846497, -0.8456099629402161, -0.4430701732635498, 0.35187336802482605, -0.08690449595451355, -0.18243253231048584, 0.045982830226421356, -0.77578204870224, 0.2866099178791046, 0.07546396553516388, 0.005989486817270517, 0.20135259628295898, 0.7922652959823608, 0.2633248567581177, -0.21988648176193237, 0.14127928018569946, -0.0006849600467830896, 0.7688588500022888, 0.2364143282175064, 0.49989399313926697, 0.17682544887065887, 0.4111376106739044, 0.30682894587516785, 0.4511036276817322, 0.3493785262107849, -0.26026642322540283, -0.05025774613022804, 0.17751441895961761, 0.8101550340652466, -0.09422428160905838, -0.2801911234855652, 0.825007975101471, -0.7186440229415894, 0.2837508022785187, -0.20036092400550842, 0.4181596338748932, -1.0501961708068848, 1.1914907693862915, 0.12643186748027802, 0.5916755199432373, -0.4797108471393585, -0.19081343710422516, 0.23604030907154083, 0.12688083946704865, 0.19236570596694946, -0.28870970010757446, -0.09430889040231705, -0.519675612449646, 0.14321760833263397, -0.03528257831931114, 0.7778872847557068, 0.5760021805763245, 0.2623865008354187, 0.43474435806274414, -0.3238445520401001, -0.6148165464401245, -0.9283409118652344, -0.7241721153259277, -0.6370646357536316, -0.8974987268447876, -0.8511242866516113, -0.2708277404308319, -0.08356363326311111, -0.6324532628059387, 0.8171491026878357, -0.33575910329818726, 0.4287869334220886, -0.6630575060844421, 0.24980144202709198, 0.5004297494888306, 0.5904751420021057, 0.27000436186790466, -0.7042859792709351, -0.029156185686588287, -0.47783032059669495, 0.3569737374782562, -0.21050910651683807, -0.11021789163351059, -0.554097592830658, -0.9316325187683105, 0.5625139474868774, -0.0018565993523225188, 0.2520991563796997, 0.46943092346191406, -0.06264767795801163, -0.05193490907549858, 0.847852885723114, -0.06798185408115387, -0.44571444392204285, 0.37340688705444336, -1.4753774404525757, 0.18583828210830688, 0.0623357854783535, 0.13555637001991272, 0.22106803953647614, 0.2724338471889496, -0.00023989089822862297, 0.7399683594703674, -0.053926754742860794, -0.023498326539993286, -1.0008455514907837, 0.2858061194419861, 0.5263777375221252, 0.5856582522392273, 0.17028343677520752, -1.3816983699798584, -1.0018157958984375, 0.22983132302761078, 0.22602646052837372, -0.8618543744087219, -0.10983844846487045, 0.18464797735214233, -0.10699689388275146, -1.2649707794189453, 0.005341393873095512, -1.5485786199569702, -1.1332343816757202, -0.0902191773056984, -0.2877938151359558, 0.581545889377594, 0.5133010745048523, 1.0596861839294434, -0.2246055155992508, -0.6072147488594055, 0.693426251411438, 0.3180367350578308, 0.5615936517715454, -0.184782475233078, -0.26147302985191345, 0.5141526460647583, 0.1568342000246048, 1.0419214963912964, 0.6115798354148865, -0.7397671937942505, -0.13942503929138184, 0.5204183459281921, -0.6079290509223938, 0.0991038978099823, 0.25038403272628784, -0.6910664439201355, 0.3770997226238251, 0.688502311706543, -0.7555046677589417, -0.14248274266719818, 0.4467196464538574, -0.005051634274423122, -0.5254590511322021, -0.522674024105072, -0.2120068371295929, 0.16883349418640137, -0.8706104159355164, -0.21684330701828003, 0.17028968036174774, 0.03391473367810249, 0.09640340507030487, -1.2859854698181152, 0.30157384276390076, -0.6301374435424805, -0.24463027715682983, -0.08174207806587219, 0.3264199495315552, -0.22286225855350494, 0.9845954179763794, -0.14125525951385498, 1.4449654817581177, -0.6803257465362549, 0.45957374572753906, 0.40609127283096313, 1.067752480506897, -0.07274187356233597, -0.019088350236415863, -0.12035434693098068, -1.477272868156433, 0.27611517906188965, 0.3007502555847168, -0.33964666724205017, 0.07719665765762329, 0.2794959247112274, 0.06648935377597809, 0.41398733854293823, -0.43747061491012573, -0.35868966579437256, 0.33003783226013184, 0.21440351009368896, 0.4497552812099457, 0.27729615569114685, 0.9873550534248352, -1.0637098550796509, 0.08455996215343475, 0.2318682074546814, 0.4374020993709564, 0.1420169323682785, -0.4660782814025879, 0.4027530252933502, 0.012424183078110218, -0.4765070080757141, 0.22642168402671814, 0.6729435920715332, -0.7984307408332825, 0.48851093649864197, 0.027780866250395775, -0.22916662693023682, -0.5230990648269653, 0.39583978056907654, -0.5646501779556274, -0.3780521750450134, 0.08288803696632385, 0.1451558768749237, 0.0056774914264678955, -0.05584196373820305, 0.5330374240875244, -0.2046375721693039, -0.058128684759140015, -0.5148562788963318, 0.6683934330940247, 1.022980809211731, -0.02425641193985939, -0.4497893452644348, 0.2177949696779251, 0.18554450571537018, -0.21257665753364563, -0.020101221278309822, 0.38804125785827637, 0.08442217856645584, -0.06369594484567642, -0.35663825273513794, 0.14841684699058533, -0.533126175403595, -0.8631850481033325, -0.12247548252344131, -0.19240687787532806, 0.15303073823451996, 0.15064969658851624, 0.1574133187532425, 1.0732976198196411, -0.0780595988035202, 1.0974102020263672, -0.7365033626556396, 0.6407850384712219, -0.3251042664051056, -0.39168012142181396, -0.2439243346452713, 0.37923914194107056, 0.49064400792121887, 0.02574385143816471, 0.20296257734298706, -0.2008160948753357, 0.2689131796360016, 0.3044317364692688, -0.21366097033023834, 0.14877334237098694, 0.5710647106170654, -0.5526140928268433, 0.27742984890937805, 0.4098086953163147, -0.2452673614025116, -0.0922771692276001, -0.016616694629192352, -0.25734657049179077, -0.559973955154419, -0.24455881118774414, -0.257255882024765, 0.4923149347305298, 0.08224215358495712, -0.6027942299842834, -0.3524691164493561, -0.36908239126205444, -0.4883905351161957, -0.7526459693908691, -0.2009166181087494, -0.499337762594223, -0.46377691626548767, -0.3488597273826599, -0.6676697134971619, -0.23609288036823273, 0.6390929818153381, 0.21449337899684906, -0.21758246421813965, 0.011636940762400627, 0.3171808123588562, -0.36027559638023376, -0.35315823554992676, -0.4080914556980133, 0.2383730411529541, -0.3299701511859894, -0.061733655631542206, 1.5910686254501343, -0.6333778500556946, -0.41731420159339905, 0.3412170708179474, 1.0391950607299805, -0.1528959423303604, -0.846295177936554, 0.4125881493091583, -1.2769572734832764, -0.30312180519104004, 0.08362527191638947, 0.5374544858932495, -0.6943598985671997, 0.19175295531749725, -0.2840114235877991, 0.05787491425871849, 0.34672868251800537, -0.006936306599527597, -0.6592773795127869, 0.4160442054271698, -0.49220845103263855, -0.6983346343040466, 0.2528069019317627, 0.3379209339618683, -0.02151130512356758, 0.9802352786064148, -0.11815541237592697, -0.7862319946289062, -0.9396849870681763, -0.9835304617881775, -0.37083709239959717, -0.49762019515037537, -0.1791573166847229, -0.16272473335266113, 0.35088682174682617, -0.020208312198519707, 0.2351461946964264, 0.16919860243797302, -0.48174217343330383, -0.36944708228111267, -0.3346746563911438, -0.2219616323709488, 0.2009221613407135, 0.12855318188667297, 0.6209120154380798, -0.7933259010314941, 0.5913052558898926, 1.228103756904602, 0.46451911330223083, -0.16354334354400635, 0.031102227047085762, 0.2761935591697693, 0.09149059653282166, 0.6735493540763855, -0.320342093706131, -0.22021888196468353, 0.8291956782341003, 0.7168284058570862, -0.2073918581008911, 0.27957072854042053, -0.2177310436964035, 0.4455026090145111, -0.2664504647254944, 0.663994550704956, -0.11364690214395523, -0.5185645222663879, -0.04752442240715027, 0.14525645971298218, 0.8013447523117065, -0.26701533794403076, 0.5492140054702759, 0.039673615247011185, 0.1617342233657837, 0.3732149302959442, 1.0243644714355469, -0.5609070658683777, -0.08359519392251968, -1.1480540037155151, -1.2945261001586914, 0.22965657711029053, -0.028643889352679253, -0.010756668634712696, 0.5762655735015869, 0.38240063190460205, 0.3298524022102356, -1.1928374767303467, 0.9478355050086975, 0.9011633396148682, -0.6496076583862305, -0.3408760130405426, 0.3732873499393463, 0.5709496736526489, 0.469441682100296, 0.6830185055732727, 0.18536065518856049, -0.17459258437156677, 0.4862152636051178, 0.042416419833898544, -1.1141729354858398, -0.6592034697532654, -0.2513693571090698, 0.02025219425559044, 0.8543165922164917, -0.19217805564403534, 0.4347028434276581, 0.37892505526542664, -0.04319174215197563, -0.9980766177177429, 0.631227433681488, 0.17480424046516418, 0.3002541661262512, 1.05112624168396, 0.3373285233974457, -1.0905888080596924, -0.5858520269393921, -0.17664864659309387, -0.030752381309866905, -0.24576351046562195, 0.3632130026817322, 0.11210533231496811, -0.9039140939712524, 0.036798592656850815, 0.4884471893310547, -0.30984312295913696, -0.8155477643013, 0.028246304020285606, -0.2937164008617401, -0.1429164558649063, -0.3620767295360565, -0.3644655644893646, 0.3198750913143158, -0.12301293015480042, 0.3618113398551941, 0.39134839177131653, 0.31480494141578674, 0.3848128318786621, 0.12917092442512512, -0.391946017742157, -0.14358100295066833, -0.3699517846107483, 0.5839877724647522, -0.14903700351715088, 0.08954373747110367, -0.08030533045530319, 0.4397639334201813, -0.1394779235124588, -0.6521530151367188, 0.11536400020122528, -0.6201377511024475, 0.2712208926677704, -0.0022734447848051786, 0.39697498083114624, 0.5494293570518494, -0.28207141160964966, 0.05500727891921997, 1.0261439085006714, -0.1853061318397522, -0.9692081212997437, -0.20071670413017273, 0.7568455338478088, -0.46186670660972595, 0.4142974019050598, 0.05384854972362518, -0.7916865348815918, 0.013131776824593544, 0.3550229072570801, 0.36509832739830017, -0.6342718601226807, -0.831764280796051, -0.7140734195709229, -0.6780180335044861, -0.1788322776556015, -0.834055483341217, -0.07237690687179565, 0.24602434039115906, -0.4896107017993927, -0.7749888300895691, -0.4910188913345337, 1.2155147790908813, -0.48916471004486084, -0.6508843302726746, -0.559259295463562, 0.7533093094825745, -1.1996833086013794, -0.12737861275672913, 0.3975003659725189, -0.6521000266075134, -0.1130765825510025, 0.6337156295776367, -0.4429541230201721, -0.08066254109144211, -0.6662657260894775, 0.2587675154209137, -0.5090862512588501, 0.22229701280593872, -0.18425557017326355, -0.40290915966033936, -0.11267649382352829, 0.6078485250473022, 0.537969172000885, -0.3604636490345001, 1.0313091278076172, -0.2769787609577179, 0.2755739688873291, 0.14177009463310242, 0.5472733974456787, -0.005641913041472435, 0.7100921273231506, 0.6852754950523376, -0.24522151052951813, -0.08943137526512146, 0.08217934519052505, 1.2677252292633057, -0.4848565459251404, -0.21723514795303345, -0.7299295663833618, 0.7630208134651184, 0.09291759133338928, -0.4948827922344208, -0.09318990260362625, 0.4789363741874695, 0.6656190752983093, -0.23835605382919312, 0.3303224444389343, 0.2599794268608093, 0.4503392279148102, 0.19551298022270203, -0.23178596794605255, -0.8359782695770264, -0.03745466098189354, -1.4027405977249146, 0.563533365726471, 0.19513452053070068, -0.33528438210487366, 0.43539467453956604, 0.017171399667859077, 0.22847236692905426, 0.6506311893463135, 0.5613612532615662, 0.28661659359931946, 1.0064762830734253, -0.4043959081172943, -0.016067486256361008, 0.015232802368700504, 0.1779022067785263, -0.3034900724887848, -0.5452571511268616, -1.0033183097839355, -0.5914078950881958, 1.018065333366394, -0.6966756582260132, -0.3242332935333252, -0.7950480580329895, -0.19856509566307068, 0.8111141324043274, 0.1698548048734665, 0.5095234513282776, -0.5176475644111633, -0.22320668399333954, -0.3379769027233124, 0.8335617780685425, 0.19201798737049103, 0.04633967578411102, -0.018124910071492195, -0.14445742964744568, -0.33689746260643005, -0.394858181476593, 0.18355214595794678, 0.3231668770313263, -0.13335487246513367, -0.41001012921333313, -0.5148290991783142, 0.33772948384284973, 0.22383078932762146, -0.20401211082935333, -0.6682367324829102, -0.08780889213085175, -0.4852566421031952, -0.15753157436847687, -0.34672001004219055, -0.18045009672641754, 0.4123096466064453, -0.07686875015497208, 0.29321974515914917, -1.1496882438659668, -0.8711085319519043, 0.32563742995262146, 0.09550735354423523, -0.18602579832077026, 0.5211852788925171, -0.5730144381523132, -0.16932252049446106, 0.11048635095357895, 0.04888176918029785, 0.2350330799818039, 0.6636816263198853, 0.32859763503074646, -0.06002819538116455, 0.1626405268907547, 0.26130297780036926, 0.05731362849473953, 0.11559148877859116, -0.09360712021589279, 0.6965678334236145, 0.14449205994606018, -0.05211653932929039, 0.4938342571258545, -0.8062243461608887, 0.2928464114665985, 0.0351104810833931, -0.6014068722724915, 0.20501264929771423, 0.19781740009784698, 0.07522720098495483, -0.19853343069553375, -0.5514177083969116, -0.1697985976934433, -0.3804170489311218, -0.596950113773346, 0.5280876755714417, 0.6613529920578003, 0.9569177031517029, -0.5609104633331299, 0.23778845369815826, 0.10210834443569183, 0.4940516948699951, -0.08048505336046219, 0.3262019455432892, 1.1435707807540894, -0.6309269070625305, -0.5194977521896362, -0.23005816340446472, 0.4939499497413635, 0.5598028898239136, -0.5623078346252441, 0.46120500564575195, 0.09349790960550308, -0.8336296677589417, 0.935178279876709, -0.3499648869037628, -0.48542115092277527, 0.43030673265457153, -0.8643814921379089, -0.48292723298072815, 0.5668460726737976, 0.4057248532772064, -0.8857824206352234, -0.49185773730278015, 0.8704830408096313, -0.5810030698776245, -0.23613163828849792, 0.6540710926055908, -0.15670521557331085, 0.30357086658477783, 0.24702253937721252, 0.2515176236629486, -0.34350886940956116, 0.6323806047439575, 0.972423791885376, 0.06260465830564499, 0.07595941424369812, -0.0360243134200573, -0.22024786472320557, -0.18589414656162262, -0.5137447118759155, -0.1249890998005867, 0.5299825668334961, -0.7201416492462158, -0.14838576316833496, -0.7378215193748474, 0.07113572210073471, -0.7965051531791687, -1.0069639682769775, -0.012187028303742409, -0.6128996014595032, 0.010268990881741047, 0.20747193694114685, 0.12617966532707214, 0.10708389431238174, 0.1614931970834732, 0.2157638967037201, -0.21826115250587463, -0.4305461645126343, -0.008782492950558662, 0.08790901303291321, 0.42905059456825256, 0.571928083896637, -0.9573927521705627, 0.05003025382757187, -0.8878889083862305, -0.053907107561826706, -0.33695733547210693, -0.5585558414459229, -0.6978318095207214, 0.17318673431873322, 0.035548772662878036, 0.6622299551963806, 0.617293119430542, -0.5180598497390747, -0.37893223762512207, -0.34948694705963135, 0.9846066236495972, 0.2317829430103302, 0.9066455364227295, 0.6028175354003906, -0.6903808116912842, -0.03733668103814125, -0.27955830097198486, 0.9348347187042236, -0.42506158351898193, 0.17980840802192688, -0.5490759015083313, 0.7704147696495056, 0.3705595135688782, -0.31715622544288635, 0.37545183300971985, 0.306452214717865, 0.42554187774658203, -0.06069725751876831, -1.138735294342041, -0.20761243999004364, -1.2872453927993774, 0.8326846361160278, -0.3412478566169739, -0.34830960631370544, 0.0033902020659297705, -0.5498711466789246, 0.5629844069480896, -0.9275696277618408, 4.059194564819336, 1.37598717212677, 0.6249111890792847, -0.2179129272699356, 0.39662766456604004, 0.846149742603302, 1.4572218656539917, -0.4477534890174866, -0.25514671206474304, 0.42349427938461304, -0.2220616340637207, 0.17360052466392517, -0.0679289698600769, -0.298822820186615, 1.1360772848129272, 0.5304207801818848, -0.7182910442352295, -0.35158392786979675, -0.345954030752182, -0.39150989055633545, -0.6059012413024902, -0.1455201655626297, 0.26028555631637573, 0.814895749092102, 0.8664505481719971, -0.39784106612205505, -0.16087879240512848, 0.3157641291618347, -0.6371786594390869, -0.08256632089614868, -0.1629382222890854, -0.067539282143116, 0.9472447037696838, -1.1099880933761597, -0.48672664165496826, 0.5123071074485779, 0.249833881855011, 0.30838748812675476, 0.58165442943573, -0.3424084186553955, 0.39729663729667664, 0.15659213066101074, 0.1285313367843628, -0.527269184589386, -0.0076319994404911995, -0.0981406420469284, -0.15450474619865417, 0.18256217241287231, 0.26539233326911926, -0.4195716679096222, 0.5387769341468811, -1.199707269668579, 0.8345946073532104, -0.9094423651695251, -0.9500347971916199, -0.05717919021844864, 0.36065056920051575, -1.0794392824172974, 0.48692527413368225, -0.023600298911333084, 0.7110723257064819, 0.2397443950176239, -0.005685917567461729, -0.17390625178813934, 0.053184874355793, 0.851067066192627, -0.30122506618499756, 0.9660374522209167, -0.3176908791065216, -0.5464009642601013, -0.26773539185523987, -0.6367334723472595, -0.23362496495246887, -0.3668212294578552, 0.8134099841117859, 0.20582473278045654, 0.3418198227882385, 0.3550877273082733, 0.057804517447948456, -0.7326120734214783, -0.04440831393003464, -0.13299663364887238, -0.2796819508075714, -0.33676677942276, -0.21220409870147705, 0.7459973096847534, -0.2796608507633209, -0.2758370041847229, -0.7192673683166504, 0.3669644594192505, 0.9701647758483887, -0.5339652299880981, -0.3451147675514221, -0.12038424611091614, -0.4578903913497925 ]
{"Title": "Behavioral effects of multiple-dose oxytocin treatment in autism: A randomized, placebo-controlled trial with long-term follow-up", "Authors": "Bernaerts Sylvie, Boets Bart, Bosmans Guy, Steyaert Jean, Alaerts Kaat", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Intranasal administration of the \u2018prosocial\u2019 neuropeptide oxytocin is increasingly explored as a potential treatment for targeting the core characteristics of autism spectrum disorder (ASD). However, long-term follow-up studies, evaluating the possibility of long-lasting retention effects are currently lacking. Methods Using a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled, parallel design, this pilot clinical trial explored the possibility of long-lasting behavioral effects of four weeks of intranasal oxytocin treatment (24 International Units once daily in the morning) in 40 adult men with ASD. To do so, self-report and informant-based questionnaires assessing core autism symptoms and characterizations of attachment were administered at baseline, immediately after four weeks of treatment (approximately 24 hours after the last nasal spray administration), and at two follow-up sessions, four weeks and one year post-treatment. Results No treatment-specific effects were identified in the primary outcome assessing social symptoms (Social responsiveness scale, self- and informant-rated). In particular, with respect to self-reported social responsiveness, improvements were evident both in the oxytocin and in the placebo group, yielding no significant between-group difference (p= .37). Also informant-rated improvements in social responsiveness were not significantly larger in the oxytocin, compared to the placebo group (between-group difference: p= .19). Among the secondary outcome measures, treatment-specific improvements were identified in the Repetitive Behavior Scale and State Adult Attachment Measure, indicating reductions in self-reported repetitive behaviours (p= .04) and reduced feelings of avoidance towards others (p= .03) in the oxytocin group compared to the placebo group, up to one month and even one year post-treatment. Treatment-specific effects were also revealed in screenings of mood states (Profile of Mood States), indicating higher reports of \u2018vigor\u2019 (feeling energetic, active, lively) in the oxytocin, compared to the placebo group (p= .03). Conclusions While no treatment-specific improvements were evident in terms of core social symptoms, the current observations of long-term beneficial effects on repetitive behaviors and feelings of avoidance are promising and suggestive of a therapeutic potential of oxytocin treatment for ASD. However, given the exploratory nature of this pilot study, future studies are warranted to evaluate the long-term effects of OT administration further. Trial Registration The trial was registered with the European Clinical Trial Registry (Eudract 2014-000586-45) on January 22, 2014 ( https://www.clinicaltrialsregister.eu/ctr-search/trial/2014-000586-45/BE ).", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012112"}
10.1101/19008391
[ 0.19776703417301178, 0.38706734776496887, 0.07004044950008392, 0.48534321784973145, -1.044525146484375, -0.2866664230823517, 0.0852973461151123, 0.2182919681072235, -0.5033551454544067, 0.3420202136039734, 0.40877893567085266, 0.10325202345848083, 0.438726544380188, -0.05324804037809372, -0.31869783997535706, -0.26268884539604187, -0.42317286133766174, 0.10728783160448074, -0.013649662025272846, 0.31678706407546997, -0.40667957067489624, 0.33626627922058105, -0.13196633756160736, 0.3018348217010498, -0.632180392742157, 0.42793789505958557, 0.16796329617500305, -0.3035006821155548, 0.8655446767807007, 0.6833379864692688, 0.004623096901923418, -0.43814635276794434, 0.14829431474208832, -0.2619858384132385, -0.6199243664741516, -0.5181252956390381, 0.6558851599693298, -0.33291730284690857, -0.31850507855415344, 0.2230517566204071, -0.2913007438182831, 0.02231263555586338, -0.1110110878944397, -0.8493171334266663, -0.8441705107688904, -0.5674126148223877, -0.735137403011322, -0.90430748462677, 0.10783344507217407, -0.4316841959953308, -0.19663016498088837, 0.09260841459035873, 0.015521290712058544, -0.5495337843894958, -0.029108799993991852, -0.39932939410209656, 0.2207835614681244, -0.4111051857471466, -0.26511192321777344, 0.19292932748794556, 0.12799742817878723, -0.9145799875259399, 0.6174215078353882, -0.4300212264060974, 0.5669363737106323, 0.5179994106292725, -0.4617292582988739, 0.04414907097816467, -0.46782588958740234, 0.22320441901683807, -0.6952260732650757, -0.012609210796654224, 0.06558141857385635, -0.6211824417114258, 0.14018996059894562, -0.3821251690387726, 0.697572648525238, -0.08878655731678009, -0.7971215844154358, -0.7382844090461731, 0.09591913223266602, -0.21949400007724762, 0.35022881627082825, 0.11377181112766266, -0.5893803238868713, 0.4581287205219269, 0.9060859084129333, 0.14538444578647614, 0.42015010118484497, 0.2988746166229248, 0.09257102012634277, 0.3934205174446106, -0.1928289830684662, -0.09899383783340454, -0.10791590809822083, 0.7823653817176819, 0.0743660181760788, -0.27757135033607483, 0.7096043229103088, 0.04195321723818779, 0.4418048858642578, 0.3791729807853699, -0.9459503889083862, 0.5066473484039307, -0.6068212985992432, 1.405390977859497, 0.6637003421783447, -0.5614506006240845, -0.5355851054191589, -0.7865026593208313, -0.01910649985074997, -0.2239590287208557, 0.2643100619316101, -0.27112123370170593, -0.6736283302307129, 0.6921576857566833, -0.4690505862236023, 0.725703775882721, -0.36438050866127014, 0.19266483187675476, -0.07195685058832169, -0.3883606791496277, 0.40379461646080017, -1.0821104049682617, -0.12573866546154022, 0.18369747698307037, 1.163190484046936, -0.2292625606060028, -1.2340351343154907, -0.9446278214454651, 0.19235612452030182, 0.382962703704834, 0.010623919777572155, 0.3193361759185791, -0.043576691299676895, -0.5060092210769653, 0.3570549786090851, 0.4395597279071808, 0.11830643564462662, 0.4912216365337372, -0.11642884463071823, 0.6550011038780212, -0.5897469520568848, 0.8194167613983154, 0.28515419363975525, 0.5730220079421997, -0.371624231338501, -1.518005609512329, -0.3926645517349243, 0.41807860136032104, -0.15336792171001434, 0.7952609658241272, 0.324072927236557, 0.3515963554382324, -0.23357315361499786, -0.022502543404698372, -0.3942447304725647, 0.3857244551181793, -0.5025601387023926, -0.0051210299134254456, -0.34743422269821167, 0.7055203914642334, -0.6221505999565125, 0.8253657221794128, -0.35363495349884033, 0.6704601049423218, 0.2003912627696991, 0.20206336677074432, 0.5030077695846558, -0.6272447109222412, 0.809464156627655, 0.30057424306869507, -0.45230111479759216, -0.6093541383743286, 0.20981034636497498, 0.48162412643432617, 1.6577134132385254, -0.08480574190616608, 0.307289719581604, 0.6602770090103149, -0.8370432257652283, 0.28073105216026306, 0.4981856346130371, 0.35758984088897705, 0.12062083929777145, 0.39956796169281006, -0.20383283495903015, -0.1846611350774765, -0.4434567093849182, -0.19069145619869232, -0.06305858492851257, 0.0012020585127174854, -0.789813220500946, 0.5909234285354614, 0.1430770456790924, 0.09508834779262543, -0.04500911384820938, 0.4660050868988037, 0.5627076029777527, -0.38109686970710754, -0.5016040205955505, -0.1430417150259018, -0.3246152102947235, 0.23921026289463043, -0.5480124950408936, 0.21317625045776367, 0.042452648282051086, 0.18256008625030518, -0.3817119598388672, 0.22319820523262024, 0.44443196058273315, 0.4352773427963257, -0.6809471845626831, 0.16304688155651093, 0.4751388728618622, -0.1238166093826294, 0.20332086086273193, 0.11365228146314621, 0.11325719207525253, 0.24210888147354126, -0.5564959645271301, -0.5328840613365173, 0.30879122018814087, 0.5346000790596008, 0.376982182264328, 0.4981257915496826, 0.5037044882774353, 0.0937548577785492, -0.5924583673477173, -0.395583838224411, 0.11180447787046432, 0.8905534744262695, 0.012143325060606003, 0.9127061367034912, 0.5990852117538452, 0.5847281217575073, 0.002308961935341358, 0.06687509268522263, 0.4081571698188782, 0.7035654187202454, 0.297998309135437, 0.3072654902935028, 0.8505842089653015, 0.058588121086359024, -0.6231179237365723, 0.30514422059059143, -0.05009590461850166, -0.15536469221115112, -0.03870786726474762, -0.057012662291526794, -0.44567400217056274, 0.5328826904296875, 0.25669577717781067, 0.38415032625198364, -0.6961669921875, 0.24601580202579498, 0.5873357653617859, -0.1344211846590042, -0.4096604883670807, -0.25411257147789, 0.0038567755836993456, 0.4682654142379761, 0.09927045553922653, 0.0984334796667099, 0.713026225566864, -0.13702426850795746, -0.34767088294029236, 0.090682253241539, 0.39501747488975525, -0.3504355847835541, -0.8778667449951172, -0.44987940788269043, -1.2793461084365845, -0.3922477662563324, -0.3905777037143707, -0.16271869838237762, 0.15204918384552002, -0.8761441111564636, 0.11551374942064285, -0.8950177431106567, -0.48096877336502075, -0.1662646234035492, -0.25887542963027954, 0.6435298919677734, 0.22727860510349274, 0.41036656498908997, -1.5016692876815796, 0.010756139643490314, -0.24695664644241333, 0.07227148115634918, -0.02044943906366825, -0.5837020874023438, -0.08616142719984055, -0.6129800081253052, 0.48634830117225647, -0.9603885412216187, 0.02282603085041046, -0.49840644001960754, -0.7655333280563354, -0.6499324440956116, 0.7524091005325317, 0.09160072356462479, 0.8678963780403137, 0.13129304349422455, -0.5588529109954834, 0.5665470361709595, -0.13450272381305695, 0.4242292046546936, 0.4475255012512207, 0.37881579995155334, -0.09615680575370789, 0.24407632648944855, -0.21391938626766205, 0.23108017444610596, 0.019946398213505745, -0.6295439600944519, 0.1497482806444168, -1.2296409606933594, -0.22774559259414673, -0.015193076804280281, -0.5991676449775696, -0.10604290664196014, -0.6401340961456299, 0.2018786370754242, 0.10326988995075226, 0.3818965256214142, 0.1336876004934311, -1.7055081129074097, -0.32110780477523804, -0.8912345170974731, -0.9615420699119568, 0.09442879259586334, -0.04488828405737877, 0.7631148099899292, -0.25689831376075745, -0.6047362685203552, -0.2718155086040497, -0.16099663078784943, 0.6458413600921631, 0.2614912986755371, 0.08176048845052719, -0.6168637871742249, -0.24006257951259613, 0.09092672169208527, -0.1053769513964653, 0.30273735523223877, -0.8167265057563782, -0.6509539484977722, -0.5194040536880493, -0.4353015422821045, -0.12911269068717957, 0.4256298542022705, -0.029983265325427055, 0.07297331094741821, -0.04466874152421951, 0.7301323413848877, 0.22904488444328308, 0.1828945428133011, 0.24552397429943085, 0.25561463832855225, -0.3686303198337555, 0.18961457908153534, -0.5379505753517151, 0.21802832186222076, -0.29468053579330444, -0.774591863155365, -0.07363250851631165, 0.0525193065404892, 0.8568161129951477, -0.19413618743419647, 0.8314034938812256, -0.6998946666717529, 0.18473032116889954, -0.2795757055282593, 0.04809298738837242, -0.23859113454818726, 0.3861232399940491, 0.10967811942100525, 0.8320540189743042, -1.0125335454940796, -0.1619022637605667, 0.07219421118497849, 0.6940948963165283, 0.1829995959997177, 0.2226928174495697, 0.2981990575790405, 0.14784330129623413, 0.7690926790237427, -0.24341295659542084, -0.5224343538284302, 0.3354441523551941, 0.0470617301762104, 0.6000550389289856, 0.473114937543869, -0.6273261904716492, -0.20551231503486633, 0.3428420424461365, 0.04593558982014656, -0.3284185826778412, 0.22366777062416077, 0.7600525617599487, -0.34497377276420593, 0.7045559883117676, 0.017687959596514702, 0.5921562910079956, -0.17936913669109344, -0.3463991582393646, -0.3435767889022827, -0.8879194259643555, -0.48681819438934326, -0.7097963690757751, -0.3779422342777252, -0.15100814402103424, -0.06705870479345322, 0.3065842390060425, 0.006607092451304197, 0.10093192756175995, -0.19162482023239136, -0.36406439542770386, -0.052302077412605286, 0.22627846896648407, -0.2086828202009201, -1.033666729927063, 0.4644823968410492, 0.23807591199874878, -0.47480422258377075, 0.0765458345413208, 0.19267460703849792, 0.1666233390569687, 0.9524128437042236, -0.5822658538818359, -0.8557614088058472, -0.14033068716526031, -0.7704755067825317, -0.6306415796279907, 0.033319056034088135, 0.4602011442184448, -0.5714063048362732, 0.16525010764598846, 0.07631023973226547, -0.1936388611793518, -0.06481972336769104, 0.1827019304037094, -0.2496194690465927, -0.06674201041460037, -0.47514909505844116, 0.543315052986145, 0.21681538224220276, 0.1783580780029297, -0.23641464114189148, 0.9000777006149292, -1.1458684206008911, 0.9473593831062317, -0.31571611762046814, -0.7295110821723938, -0.11440081894397736, 0.2298034280538559, -0.28311678767204285, -0.07744409888982773, -0.5852361917495728, 0.2309739738702774, 0.10304226726293564, 0.2888723611831665, -0.32566705346107483, 0.1527106761932373, 0.6152263879776001, -0.37422439455986023, 0.5111308097839355, 1.6671909093856812, -0.40806496143341064, 0.4389943480491638, 0.2009158432483673, -0.4149846136569977, -0.8816968202590942, 0.5288645029067993, 0.3694482147693634, -0.29266685247421265, -0.3895210027694702, -0.4890933334827423, 0.17484299838542938, -0.36256203055381775, 0.5130223631858826, -0.15893591940402985, 0.09526043385267258, -1.2042585611343384, -0.17602694034576416, -0.5013450384140015, -0.3095977008342743, -0.8328968286514282, 1.120700716972351, -0.5687859058380127, -0.36524727940559387, -0.3578258156776428, -0.02563895843923092, -0.8134182691574097, 0.22585389018058777, -0.47555628418922424, 0.16336634755134583, 0.450103223323822, 0.6820389628410339, -0.19591017067432404, -1.0877432823181152, -0.6082231402397156, 0.4863203167915344, 0.6711691617965698, -0.8149349093437195, -0.06882771849632263, -0.15861442685127258, 0.05447503551840782, -0.394024521112442, -0.3579588234424591, 0.08678874373435974, -0.7391273975372314, 0.5850840210914612, -0.14985622465610504, 0.0026617676485329866, 0.287605345249176, 0.21645843982696533, -0.04810087010264397, 0.8065246939659119, -0.5800842046737671, -0.31723546981811523, -0.5486536026000977, 0.2643578350543976, -0.021972522139549255, 0.3288758099079132, 0.023787962272763252, -0.47451919317245483, -0.12297742813825607, -1.4284368753433228, 0.08367566019296646, -0.1539117395877838, 0.03736833855509758, -0.6182114481925964, -0.6007724404335022, 0.1447785347700119, 0.12454260140657425, -0.25769445300102234, 0.03681598976254463, -0.12051353603601456, -0.2581930458545685, 0.10554267466068268, -0.18151798844337463, -0.056873973459005356, 0.21746040880680084, -1.0101882219314575, 0.1491248458623886, 0.6405149102210999, 0.5006537437438965, -0.16071981191635132, -0.08261650055646896, 0.5800697803497314, 0.1994020789861679, 0.44821828603744507, -0.23986433446407318, -0.4256943166255951, 0.1757984310388565, 0.6379426717758179, -0.1403956562280655, 0.29448920488357544, -0.8766061663627625, 0.24430999159812927, -0.9294524788856506, 0.07785330712795258, 0.3087945580482483, -0.41535624861717224, 0.28648877143859863, -0.6863049268722534, 0.6390485763549805, -0.5219050049781799, 0.4444141089916229, -0.18340221047401428, -0.16121841967105865, -0.08534610271453857, 0.5463123321533203, -1.1171058416366577, -0.766078531742096, -0.29130327701568604, -0.43542781472206116, 0.23894532024860382, 0.16477343440055847, -0.33310940861701965, -0.39143791794776917, -0.6553788781166077, 0.11198115348815918, -0.6495480537414551, 0.1527426689863205, 1.0789772272109985, -0.48766058683395386, -0.8819031119346619, -0.09969808906316757, 0.4069938063621521, 0.8037695288658142, 0.3702733814716339, 0.436722993850708, -0.06310424953699112, 0.5171396732330322, -0.6077447533607483, -0.2952791154384613, -0.49210309982299805, -0.008613524958491325, 0.4367968440055847, 0.24050964415073395, -0.13831953704357147, -0.28438499569892883, -0.10255144536495209, -0.5909589529037476, 0.0955287516117096, 0.5953157544136047, -0.34739071130752563, 0.2275601178407669, 1.0346038341522217, 0.23890985548496246, -0.563294529914856, 0.5372772812843323, -0.568867027759552, -0.16121308505535126, -0.2610514760017395, 0.666535496711731, 0.7189416289329529, -0.5987913608551025, 0.8853842616081238, 0.9697651267051697, -0.4050501883029938, 0.042613495141267776, 0.350035697221756, -0.2895553410053253, 0.44462069869041443, -0.05726148188114166, -0.4320438802242279, 1.2171971797943115, -0.5209778547286987, 0.9260777831077576, -0.1365298628807068, -0.3270127475261688, -0.07870373129844666, -0.10176528245210648, 0.791939914226532, -0.5503126978874207, -0.10735049098730087, 0.2381104677915573, 0.07662395387887955, 0.6284030079841614, 0.121488057076931, -0.033931128680706024, 0.3684515953063965, -0.16247452795505524, 0.36124610900878906, -0.7834494709968567, -0.9966611266136169, -0.059727419167757034, 0.005307727959007025, 0.6482019424438477, 0.04066412150859833, -0.12114353477954865, 0.9020284414291382, -0.3457913398742676, -0.371017187833786, -0.21671782433986664, -0.10184319317340851, 0.10180185735225677, 0.5561732649803162, 0.06861629337072372, 0.1956683099269867, 0.4327055513858795, 0.3631918430328369, 0.4206307828426361, -0.24317015707492828, -0.38369429111480713, -0.5487892627716064, -0.38953936100006104, -0.02889816090464592, -0.5937781929969788, -0.037758029997348785, 1.026558518409729, -0.3910757303237915, -0.15165598690509796, 0.2292996197938919, 0.4169718623161316, 0.22566156089305878, -0.48865774273872375, -0.410953551530838, 0.3295566141605377, 0.032312724739313126, -1.0971834659576416, -0.37071147561073303, -0.675085186958313, 0.41656583547592163, 1.189837098121643, -1.0443201065063477, -0.38383570313453674, 0.19668030738830566, 0.37295210361480713, -0.20686057209968567, 0.007622911594808102, -0.6502349376678467, -0.4901013970375061, 0.5830886960029602, 0.06496042758226395, -0.15468041598796844, 0.06385140866041183, 1.230709195137024, -0.2152741551399231, 0.3504778742790222, 0.28687185049057007, 0.08386638015508652, -0.14640896022319794, 0.5679198503494263, 0.08390427380800247, -0.32930752635002136, -0.25281840562820435, -0.5528103113174438, 0.16666144132614136, -0.9838355779647827, 0.018701868131756783, -0.00365409255027771, -0.09888000041246414, 0.5471580624580383, 0.15191827714443207, -0.3259480893611908, 0.6774255037307739, -0.0017142118886113167, 0.23930129408836365, 0.30310067534446716, 0.7331831455230713, 0.7282574772834778, 0.08690348267555237, 0.3111515939235687, 0.00842931680381298, -0.20230145752429962, -0.6248753666877747, 0.029975058510899544, 0.05589589476585388, -0.008827229961752892, -0.14557881653308868, -0.014369861222803593, 0.3744237422943115, -0.09436005353927612, -0.1324169933795929, -0.6667605042457581, 0.7865554094314575, 1.0707778930664062, 0.7312077879905701, 0.7965502142906189, -0.16877011954784393, -0.5160354375839233, -0.5661935210227966, -0.6955013871192932, -0.8582462072372437, 0.16313327848911285, -0.08847211301326752, -0.37810128927230835, -0.4851130545139313, 0.13286703824996948, 0.014507399871945381, 0.4122633635997772, -0.2138853669166565, -0.28176525235176086, 1.0939760208129883, 0.5234131217002869, 0.7889333963394165, 0.8108552098274231, 0.2963401973247528, 0.08364743739366531, 0.1560414731502533, -0.3073995113372803, -0.4691263437271118, 0.5894010663032532, 0.23128847777843475, 0.12130503356456757, -0.16707845032215118, -0.04239913076162338, 0.3709258437156677, 0.0702492818236351, -0.10590102523565292, -0.3920046389102936, 0.6497895121574402, -0.924751877784729, -0.08190563321113586, 0.09504622220993042, 0.7246266007423401, -0.45413902401924133, 0.28170180320739746, 0.13677482306957245, -0.8714043498039246, -0.7277529239654541, -0.034062448889017105, 0.4483564496040344, -0.4756075441837311, 0.010597665794193745, 0.03527739271521568, 0.10022136569023132, 0.10721908509731293, -0.36469584703445435, 0.8458071351051331, 0.6909075975418091, 0.15831078588962555, 0.3557993471622467, 0.4997999966144562, 0.008411990478634834, 0.9670122861862183, 0.3777240812778473, 0.15643350780010223, 0.39186349511146545, 0.20819467306137085, 0.10557262599468231, 0.13439330458641052, -0.020758727565407753, 1.0052577257156372, -0.26333388686180115, -0.7647584080696106, 0.0433991439640522, 0.09820427000522614, 0.42961347103118896, 0.0939360111951828, -1.077289342880249, 0.1339053362607956, -1.1547489166259766, -1.0327515602111816, 0.04905504733324051, 0.1947014182806015, 0.6871579885482788, 0.2484491467475891, 0.42806360125541687, -0.5527045130729675, 0.6544344425201416, 0.18159577250480652, 0.06527350097894669, 0.735214352607727, -0.49118950963020325, -0.47815078496932983, -0.384244441986084, -0.07373800873756409, -0.2926844656467438, 0.4440847635269165, 0.5095334649085999, -0.12532447278499603, 0.24822580814361572, 0.5103592872619629, 0.09118033945560455, 0.38026270270347595, 0.5085580945014954, -0.3800969123840332, 0.08860071003437042, -0.05780518054962158, 0.07728233188390732, -0.5725570321083069, -0.45139408111572266, 0.963505208492279, -0.09863706678152084, -0.6255837082862854, 0.009176371619105339, 0.7029637098312378, 0.2663494050502777, 0.23655308783054352, 0.1164177805185318, -0.6121602058410645, 0.30324769020080566, 0.4729001522064209, 0.03074120730161667, -0.0878862738609314, 0.1298525333404541, -0.41497623920440674, 0.2498665452003479, 0.1614319533109665, -0.017187535762786865, 0.10516145080327988, 0.6515495181083679, 0.2110920399427414, 0.24711671471595764, -0.3048192858695984, 0.06739197671413422, -0.747859001159668, -0.40340685844421387, -0.19589152932167053, 0.4801422357559204, 0.06427404284477234, -0.01914587803184986, 0.19922281801700592, -0.22832946479320526, -0.5296276211738586, -0.2404940128326416, -0.3987995982170105, 0.2089259922504425, -0.2032919079065323, -0.03452169895172119, -0.05758792534470558, -0.23632340133190155, -0.6466056108474731, -0.9957361221313477, 0.049447059631347656, 0.1429716795682907, -0.18678472936153412, -1.4082844257354736, -0.1680590659379959, -0.46612441539764404, 0.11863613873720169, 0.08009511977434158, 0.6093188524246216, 0.24744191765785217, 0.031182939186692238, 0.5897650718688965, 0.07385168969631195, 0.4656367599964142, 0.47210484743118286, 0.4696798324584961, 0.23758277297019958, -0.4319893419742584, -0.6616780161857605, 0.18113422393798828, -0.6002347469329834, -0.1791830211877823, 0.40545210242271423, -0.2128620594739914, -0.5951452851295471, 0.5422829985618591, 0.6827154159545898, 0.08604788035154343, 0.006853302009403706, 0.11276853084564209, -0.31827545166015625, -0.36579933762550354, 0.8640692234039307, -0.2811466157436371, -0.037200938910245895, 0.1268777996301651, 0.21803906559944153, 0.33588793873786926, -0.8602357506752014, 4.402705669403076, 0.6175441741943359, 0.46840211749076843, -0.11657017469406128, 1.135177731513977, -0.04008189216256142, 0.31802448630332947, -0.010165921412408352, 0.19608622789382935, 0.29699763655662537, -0.38877543807029724, -0.12386739253997803, 0.03403613343834877, 0.004500874783843756, 0.44178277254104614, 0.05153871700167656, -0.8235229849815369, -0.0031653051264584064, 0.052263788878917694, -0.26719072461128235, -0.40055716037750244, 0.32912784814834595, -0.16929848492145538, 0.2859359383583069, -0.059684209525585175, 0.0668230801820755, 0.3270009756088257, 0.09442907571792603, -0.2744515538215637, -0.7277958989143372, 0.4142102599143982, -0.8018258213996887, 0.12567056715488434, -0.23101016879081726, -0.8174211978912354, 0.220866397023201, -0.11854686588048935, -0.3751899302005768, 0.05735967308282852, 0.25669771432876587, 0.640509307384491, 0.778874933719635, -0.14221711456775665, -0.4622114598751068, -0.5227265357971191, -0.19008931517601013, -0.496330201625824, 0.7307634353637695, 0.22543151676654816, -0.563918948173523, 0.7650547623634338, -0.3112294673919678, 1.1066045761108398, 0.5873898267745972, -0.821685254573822, -0.3060398995876312, 0.159123957157135, -0.752321183681488, 0.21962325274944305, 0.42550164461135864, 0.8243223428726196, -0.4711337983608246, -0.2861160635948181, -0.40336525440216064, 0.6098273992538452, 0.45633336901664734, 0.4983607530593872, 0.22227564454078674, -0.1126377061009407, -0.14601318538188934, -0.13088956475257874, -0.3931431770324707, -0.622016191482544, 0.3970077335834503, 0.9490599632263184, 0.09885229915380478, -0.39043185114860535, 0.6914173364639282, -0.3416779041290283, -0.3671780526638031, 0.28382664918899536, 0.40208700299263, 0.27099382877349854, -0.15081042051315308, 0.17522193491458893, 0.5145798921585083, -0.5953791737556458, -0.30964305996894836, -1.189630150794983, 0.48729753494262695, -0.23093312978744507, 0.020672865211963654, 0.22618970274925232, -0.07085520774126053, -0.36048275232315063 ]
{"Title": "Patient Preferences to Undergo Low-Value CT Coronary Angiography in the Emergency Department", "Authors": "Winkels Jessica L., Smith Chelsea Morrow, Iyengar Rahul, Meka Arjun P., Porath Jonathan D., Meurer William J.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Low-value diagnostic testing adds billions of dollars to the cost of health care in the US annually. Addressing patient preference for these tests is one possible strategy to limit overuse. In previous work, we showed that patient preference for testing can be influenced by test benefit, risk, and financial measures. Our objective was to examine the effect of these variables in another clinical scenario involving chest pain. Methods In this cross-sectional survey of patients at the University of Michigan Emergency Department (ED), participants were given a hypothetical scenario involving an ED visit for chest pain, along with information regarding potential benefit (detecting a life-threatening condition; 0.1 or 1%) and risk (developing cancer; 0.1 or 1%) of CTCA, as well as an incentive of $0 or $100 to forego testing. Values for risk, benefit, and financial incentive varied across participants. Our primary outcome was patient preference to undergo testing. We also obtained demographic and numeracy information. Then, we used logistic regression to estimate odds ratios, adjusting for multiple potential confounders. Our sample size was designed to find at least 300 events (test acceptance) to allow for up to 30 covariates in fully adjusted models. We had 85-90% power to detect a 10% absolute difference in testing rate across groups, assuming a 95% significance level. Results 913 patients were surveyed. A $100 financial incentive (adjusted OR [AOR] 0.57; 95% Confidence Interval [CI] 0.42-0.78) and increased test risk (AOR 0.61; 95% CI 0.44-0.84) both significantly decreased test acceptance in fully adjusted models, whereas increased test benefit significantly increased test acceptance (AOR 2.45; 95% CI 1.79-3.36). Conclusions Offering a financial incentive deterred patients from accepting testing despite varying levels of risk and benefit. In the context of previous work, we provide preliminary evidence supporting that financial interventions may impact patient preference more than test risk and benefit.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008391"}
10.1101/2019.12.11.19014472
[ -0.004075936041772366, 0.8919050097465515, 0.1470312625169754, 0.23607444763183594, -1.3115930557250977, -0.03080829791724682, 0.12811477482318878, 0.4804781973361969, 0.33388158679008484, 0.41814175248146057, 0.38736850023269653, -0.6110729575157166, 0.7153319120407104, -0.3338521122932434, 0.03006899729371071, -0.13727720081806183, -0.6256766319274902, -0.1509995311498642, 0.20170263946056366, 0.27602845430374146, 0.5379303097724915, 0.40762487053871155, -0.24244093894958496, 0.04068536311388016, 0.20643556118011475, -0.06916967034339905, -0.6264402866363525, -0.6170266270637512, 1.1206287145614624, 0.6450072526931763, -0.10697061568498611, -0.19838847219944, 1.1122199296951294, -0.4846293032169342, 0.014506676234304905, -0.3421187102794647, 0.827528178691864, -0.3571021854877472, 0.47149306535720825, -0.25069016218185425, 0.4440869390964508, 0.24325744807720184, -0.022331640124320984, 0.13260005414485931, -0.3755668103694916, -0.13813064992427826, -0.4799067974090576, -0.3318321108818054, -0.07390600442886353, 0.36826759576797485, -0.09903799742460251, 0.22489525377750397, -0.004244391806423664, -0.6267756819725037, 0.054247770458459854, 0.6445122957229614, -0.059465501457452774, 0.3207097351551056, -0.4737958610057831, 0.09551233798265457, -0.05893724784255028, -0.6573663949966431, 0.3847981095314026, -1.2744271755218506, 1.257091760635376, 0.5105569362640381, -0.3941180109977722, -0.670567512512207, -0.16582436859607697, 0.20006529986858368, -0.5668749213218689, -0.35796573758125305, 0.14208154380321503, -0.4374070465564728, -0.28519314527511597, -0.4077759385108948, 1.008802890777588, 0.11112098395824432, -0.6071024537086487, -0.5949987173080444, -0.30388376116752625, -0.22673752903938293, 0.4561775028705597, -0.21791279315948486, -0.9830818176269531, 0.42817947268486023, 0.4130846858024597, 0.18793275952339172, 0.44200342893600464, 0.4861602187156677, 0.34296220541000366, 0.1830454170703888, -0.12834210693836212, -0.6269693970680237, -0.4183928072452545, 0.894709050655365, -0.46881091594696045, 0.5527446269989014, -0.21130837500095367, -0.21432805061340332, 0.5491482615470886, 0.2665855586528778, -0.5084213018417358, 0.4322676956653595, -0.521943211555481, 0.7369027733802795, 0.054835498332977295, -0.23117688298225403, -0.2913355529308319, -0.2844763994216919, 0.566831111907959, 0.28735482692718506, -0.12670829892158508, -0.010331658646464348, 0.30158233642578125, 0.4152868092060089, -0.616849958896637, 0.6543496251106262, -0.8264464735984802, 0.3768445551395416, 0.08363217115402222, -0.19608184695243835, 0.6548668742179871, -0.09951458871364594, 0.1624426692724228, -0.09988477826118469, 0.27255678176879883, 0.3080522418022156, -0.9836653470993042, -0.5458343029022217, -0.06366080790758133, -0.6181055903434753, -0.6381512880325317, 1.0415878295898438, -1.1304717063903809, -0.13159555196762085, 0.094784215092659, 0.9478280544281006, 0.07426594942808151, 0.20262542366981506, -0.48178890347480774, 0.6273341178894043, -0.7856743335723877, 0.5898011326789856, -0.38315537571907043, 1.0115443468093872, -0.789928674697876, -0.9546671509742737, -0.3596956133842468, 0.26672205328941345, -0.10925380140542984, 0.5599541664123535, 0.3392139673233032, 0.2448534369468689, 0.4630889296531677, 0.11818554997444153, -0.24593177437782288, 0.4841081500053406, 0.142042338848114, 0.4435235559940338, -0.511481761932373, 0.6295719742774963, -0.038614872843027115, 0.820169985294342, -0.7805389165878296, 0.8448721170425415, -0.2748333811759949, -0.10676498711109161, -0.055642616003751755, -1.34077787399292, 0.1502368003129959, 0.06785934418439865, -0.24057312309741974, -0.39256522059440613, 0.3436218202114105, 0.6075167059898376, 1.2899250984191895, 0.10357341915369034, 0.06365902721881866, 0.22313517332077026, 0.3140578866004944, -0.08704622089862823, 1.0504506826400757, 0.7582818269729614, -0.7855519652366638, 0.672021746635437, -0.5578267574310303, -0.5571268200874329, -0.3062724173069, -0.09484148770570755, -0.6878564357757568, 0.11219417303800583, -0.36419516801834106, 1.047377109527588, 0.011815285310149193, -0.4603571891784668, -0.8356539607048035, 0.17787259817123413, 0.40201422572135925, -0.33641842007637024, -0.6172171831130981, 0.5013852715492249, -0.2887854278087616, 0.46890881657600403, -0.11496327072381973, 0.6130284070968628, -0.2098803073167801, 0.22379308938980103, -0.5310602188110352, 0.10668418556451797, 0.7565497756004333, 0.7629913091659546, -0.28557997941970825, -0.5202895402908325, 0.129660964012146, 0.03874580189585686, -0.5088990926742554, -0.25602418184280396, -0.39136093854904175, 0.2227766066789627, -0.5491129755973816, -0.21528494358062744, 0.3802095353603363, 0.4391351640224457, -0.23084820806980133, 0.1880461722612381, 0.5057885050773621, 0.4592825770378113, -0.3816400468349457, -0.24732239544391632, 0.010896959342062473, 0.3780519664287567, 0.06312577426433563, 0.47097694873809814, 0.6739229559898376, 1.0615681409835815, 0.44704535603523254, 0.2340834140777588, -0.06962398439645767, 0.4488465189933777, -0.028039051219820976, 0.2595193684101105, 0.3726048171520233, -0.34280356764793396, -0.1766623854637146, 0.30066007375717163, -0.098839670419693, 0.23000185191631317, -0.1270638406276703, 0.12388060986995697, -0.5907185673713684, -0.12135463953018188, -0.12152963876724243, 0.06485432386398315, -0.9283878207206726, -0.20596466958522797, 0.5162755250930786, -0.5459557771682739, -0.7014915943145752, -0.7954789400100708, -0.35428693890571594, 0.9784109592437744, -0.14559930562973022, 0.14573174715042114, 1.3654712438583374, 0.3436441719532013, -0.33345019817352295, 0.5775831341743469, 0.5471071600914001, 0.11726546287536621, -0.24634405970573425, -0.7316480278968811, -0.5995685458183289, -0.9016047716140747, -0.22918781638145447, 0.04534382000565529, -0.29385673999786377, -0.7986305356025696, -0.09908349066972733, -0.3441150188446045, 0.2761334478855133, -0.07571333646774292, 0.051733989268541336, 0.4686725437641144, 0.1537221223115921, 0.4099636673927307, -0.6518093943595886, -0.2935549318790436, -0.4445462226867676, 0.03697388246655464, 0.14031511545181274, -0.6557487845420837, -0.6130343079566956, -0.6814966201782227, 0.3809489905834198, -0.9944179654121399, -0.03248903527855873, 0.10376882553100586, -0.09529686719179153, 0.1888832151889801, 0.5382870435714722, 0.3695134222507477, -0.14091989398002625, 0.005122643895447254, -0.4924180209636688, -0.08815179020166397, 0.5660251975059509, 0.4814611077308655, 0.3887394666671753, -0.10044892132282257, 0.08624861389398575, -0.2879176437854767, 0.03875856101512909, 0.6042060852050781, -1.2086501121520996, 0.12790758907794952, 0.8163666129112244, 0.25375470519065857, 0.14492611587047577, -0.9947410821914673, -1.4826406240463257, -0.3300076127052307, 0.08577531576156616, -0.08236218988895416, -0.2782913148403168, 0.5352294445037842, 0.10933918505907059, -1.3100708723068237, 0.3327685594558716, 0.36448124051094055, -1.6402686834335327, 0.02591545134782791, -0.4962134063243866, 0.49569565057754517, -0.10415296256542206, -0.28624019026756287, 0.278879314661026, 0.288601815700531, 0.05060431733727455, -0.030007684603333473, -0.13312873244285583, 0.35585659742355347, -0.09794829785823822, 0.44399598240852356, -0.3669821321964264, 0.6242973208427429, -0.2123664915561676, 0.252297967672348, 0.09191200882196426, -0.0023888181895017624, -1.0432803630828857, 0.5829437971115112, 0.3315669298171997, 0.24751132726669312, 0.29754894971847534, 0.32491421699523926, 0.4504341781139374, -0.09800770878791809, 0.3192673623561859, 0.28674280643463135, -0.15407432615756989, 0.4694344699382782, 0.5365984439849854, 0.21145516633987427, -0.5702136158943176, -0.17854110896587372, -0.08216553181409836, -0.45768246054649353, 0.24026668071746826, -0.47432786226272583, 0.6677664518356323, 0.8487906455993652, -0.2424473911523819, -0.16699016094207764, -0.3291729688644409, -0.4225660562515259, 1.164785623550415, 0.2521432638168335, 0.6149676442146301, -1.36677885055542, 0.2594796121120453, 0.484848290681839, 1.0699878931045532, 0.19966116547584534, -0.4711591899394989, 0.8464866876602173, -0.6506744027137756, 0.800341784954071, -0.37429091334342957, -0.2584269344806671, 0.2200849950313568, 0.21529491245746613, 0.5717251896858215, 0.6022606492042542, -1.2089625597000122, -0.4721755087375641, 0.23664824664592743, 0.22085566818714142, -0.06270326673984528, 0.024613792076706886, 0.7006233930587769, 0.2661963701248169, 0.4407865107059479, -0.31017857789993286, 0.8648027181625366, -0.28255242109298706, -0.3044221103191376, 0.059278279542922974, -0.19251428544521332, -0.817340075969696, 0.10393914580345154, -0.39458274841308594, 0.07488731294870377, -0.2702324390411377, 0.7851348519325256, -0.1446819305419922, -0.6054741144180298, -0.2216368019580841, -0.6426500082015991, 0.18969964981079102, 0.032912477850914, -0.1724315732717514, -0.34575361013412476, 0.22878161072731018, 0.19013340771198273, -0.28943803906440735, 0.1596582978963852, -0.6900081634521484, 0.04827668517827988, 1.1498997211456299, -0.11261609941720963, -0.7510083317756653, -0.0763753354549408, -0.37073105573654175, -0.7751644849777222, 0.36596786975860596, 0.3984212279319763, -0.11816291511058807, -0.0490095317363739, -0.3109803795814514, -0.2886851131916046, 0.25605207681655884, 0.12334302067756653, 0.24602700769901276, -0.31319159269332886, 0.1540553718805313, 0.9178100228309631, 0.04422074556350708, 1.0227802991867065, 0.052373457700014114, 0.5718052387237549, -0.7252390384674072, 0.5285393595695496, -0.8446430563926697, -0.9938815236091614, -0.06530999392271042, -0.46236956119537354, -0.027963098138570786, 0.45551639795303345, 0.35831233859062195, 0.0005690287216566503, 0.05745954439043999, 0.07413239032030106, -0.3583996891975403, -0.04578244313597679, 0.7509464025497437, -1.0316274166107178, 0.20657315850257874, 1.3624839782714844, -0.5716410875320435, -0.06870371103286743, -0.15915994346141815, 0.05531306937336922, -0.4794121980667114, 0.26291459798812866, -0.019569221884012222, 0.22647425532341003, 0.22814328968524933, -0.002272705314680934, -0.1405157595872879, 0.16885222494602203, 0.033623047173023224, -0.6157039403915405, 0.1911585032939911, -0.6085742115974426, -0.1007472425699234, -0.21195165812969208, -0.08483003079891205, -1.1980689764022827, 0.8055769801139832, -0.22519820928573608, -0.5640040040016174, 0.18140923976898193, 0.03555639088153839, -0.4327622652053833, -0.17052043974399567, -0.997657835483551, 0.16902849078178406, -0.32196301221847534, -0.5734472870826721, 0.7729608416557312, -0.43567854166030884, -0.5206521153450012, 0.26430705189704895, 0.523752748966217, -0.5648584365844727, -0.1665533483028412, 0.06388376653194427, -0.06005159020423889, -0.6585921049118042, -0.1471792310476303, 0.9121413230895996, -0.8197454810142517, -0.3470443785190582, -0.0026009571738541126, -0.22813542187213898, 0.9905686378479004, 0.19505222141742706, -0.8266927599906921, 0.5289043188095093, -0.1577732414007187, -0.5129509568214417, -0.5515878200531006, -0.06535902619361877, 0.24724411964416504, -0.044153884053230286, -0.2860279977321625, -0.7149427533149719, 0.03520672395825386, -0.694420576095581, 0.5254115462303162, -0.5533176064491272, -0.12556801736354828, -0.3440215289592743, -1.0290509462356567, -0.11310400813817978, 0.6785054206848145, 0.3498464524745941, 0.5732278823852539, 0.031061116605997086, -0.6771528720855713, 0.3346700072288513, -0.4405997395515442, 0.2574877142906189, -0.1004502922296524, -0.6925122737884521, -0.4828561842441559, 0.9792803525924683, 0.09637735038995743, -0.2604920268058777, -0.06953959167003632, -0.1265794336795807, 0.6335635781288147, 0.7577882409095764, -0.04310576245188713, -0.5766472220420837, -0.45341047644615173, 0.4725634753704071, -0.4308343827724457, -0.6714785695075989, -0.392726868391037, 0.5376962423324585, -0.5443224310874939, 0.6034062504768372, -0.5774368643760681, -0.18201996386051178, -0.4067072868347168, -0.36889445781707764, 0.8791207671165466, -0.6313039064407349, -0.053964901715517044, 0.4402061700820923, -0.19549302756786346, -0.21708303689956665, 0.5018386840820312, -0.4311526417732239, -0.3135838806629181, -0.7767438888549805, -0.9278022050857544, 0.3915401101112366, 0.19011472165584564, -0.24930806457996368, -0.1901407539844513, -0.2773163616657257, -0.019732113927602768, -0.25618138909339905, 1.1232770681381226, 0.5341292023658752, -0.610381007194519, -0.7813717722892761, 0.25912126898765564, 0.48084554076194763, 0.2062581330537796, 0.3423319160938263, -0.07571948319673538, -0.5930142998695374, 0.07453583180904388, -0.4948974847793579, -0.4815896153450012, -1.0458650588989258, -0.06424297392368317, 0.711104691028595, 0.13047367334365845, 0.3475160300731659, 0.2837602198123932, -0.35746100544929504, 0.26546385884284973, -0.28058958053588867, 0.9909380078315735, -0.1671946495771408, 0.8699085712432861, 0.6051594614982605, -0.12449835240840912, -0.2634408175945282, 0.3013879060745239, -0.13231584429740906, -0.18992412090301514, 0.053007837384939194, 0.24756339192390442, 0.16622738540172577, -1.3102749586105347, 1.0777225494384766, 0.5350377559661865, -0.7517990469932556, -0.08209435641765594, 0.27093708515167236, -0.3396587669849396, -0.04003357142210007, 0.013828669674694538, -0.19057613611221313, 0.7700533270835876, -0.7736388444900513, 0.2798416018486023, -0.5119929909706116, -0.4307701289653778, 0.3645939230918884, -0.8062704801559448, -0.11429362744092941, -0.20870037376880646, -0.40043914318084717, 0.7123315334320068, -0.3141227960586548, -0.1802271008491516, 0.4274018108844757, 0.035165946930646896, -0.14036458730697632, 0.6748806834220886, 0.35886889696121216, -0.652271568775177, -0.14520280063152313, 0.06142888590693474, 0.1745993196964264, 0.3379985988140106, -0.02311089262366295, -0.2624981701374054, 0.4584513306617737, -0.02859373949468136, -0.20691463351249695, -0.32064545154571533, -0.12760549783706665, 0.3881855010986328, 0.7141181826591492, 0.5395264029502869, 0.26547005772590637, -0.08416727185249329, 0.23490451276302338, -0.46478381752967834, 0.40274208784103394, -0.2942439317703247, -0.01599675603210926, 0.10843174159526825, 0.3268130123615265, -0.8044597506523132, -0.18427163362503052, 1.292444109916687, -0.5770536065101624, -0.7714701890945435, -0.1066657304763794, 0.7925170660018921, 0.21873898804187775, 0.03460635989904404, -0.1920100450515747, 0.20576228201389313, -0.5608710050582886, -0.8230361342430115, -0.2435387521982193, -0.427731454372406, 0.2553926706314087, 0.8362858295440674, -0.5745203495025635, -0.11507650464773178, 0.35444405674934387, 0.05649077519774437, -0.05666445940732956, 0.4970831274986267, -0.17664401233196259, -0.6191688776016235, -0.06286659836769104, 0.18636274337768555, -0.3294539451599121, 0.2760503590106964, 0.24655862152576447, -0.008030790835618973, 0.10579930245876312, 0.7222620844841003, -0.17820122838020325, -0.5410529375076294, 0.618409276008606, 0.791388213634491, -0.526482880115509, -0.45058155059814453, -0.8134189248085022, 0.5863588452339172, -0.5293277502059937, -0.2764158844947815, -0.5429623126983643, -0.15977990627288818, 0.1531468629837036, 1.0497040748596191, -0.6207984089851379, 0.7163852453231812, 0.32514655590057373, 0.14444324374198914, 0.2495986372232437, 0.147748664021492, 0.24377129971981049, 0.3349883556365967, 1.0553783178329468, -0.2133619785308838, 0.43247470259666443, -1.340917706489563, 0.2543836534023285, 0.573519229888916, -0.05059204250574112, -0.12749068439006805, 0.2203965038061142, 0.21897588670253754, -0.3574269115924835, -0.5459187030792236, -0.6129723191261292, 0.3126341700553894, 0.43953344225883484, 0.6699656844139099, -0.37466955184936523, -0.1105826273560524, -0.32281333208084106, -0.6344130039215088, -0.8993368744850159, -0.43817076086997986, 0.634871244430542, -0.6326702833175659, -0.29116135835647583, -0.455846905708313, -0.9928333163261414, 0.5223743915557861, -0.20889371633529663, 0.0760558545589447, -0.5771419405937195, 0.5072448253631592, 0.21429722011089325, 0.236746683716774, 0.3502520024776459, -0.11074399203062057, -0.027960846200585365, -0.10360338538885117, -0.855939507484436, -0.3783057928085327, 0.03184141963720322, 0.5656601786613464, 0.4766567051410675, -0.4883825480937958, -0.5057777762413025, 0.15267355740070343, 0.28109148144721985, -0.10066336393356323, -0.3645188808441162, -0.017815865576267242, -0.6233958005905151, 0.24712088704109192, -0.582260251045227, 0.23269136250019073, -0.6165494322776794, -0.01685764081776142, 0.013707785867154598, -0.807837963104248, -0.34491419792175293, 0.029300611466169357, 0.9003922343254089, -0.6288488507270813, 0.36568504571914673, -0.0763988047838211, 0.5404459834098816, -0.9380847215652466, -0.5294628143310547, 0.6151254177093506, 0.5015659332275391, -0.014633338898420334, 0.23451726138591766, -0.051688361912965775, 0.10986657440662384, 0.5818817019462585, 0.40837597846984863, -0.14822973310947418, 0.24359586834907532, 0.29170265793800354, 0.5675216317176819, 0.8215348124504089, -0.23770441114902496, 0.5073673725128174, 0.6801061034202576, -0.2596662938594818, -0.14602696895599365, 0.8774635791778564, 0.6336610913276672, -0.019048012793064117, -0.883973240852356, -0.24614909291267395, -0.682720422744751, 0.2510306239128113, -0.16406132280826569, 0.08239202946424484, 0.5446674227714539, 0.6627318859100342, -0.10233207792043686, -0.11254104226827621, 0.7510582208633423, -0.15401507914066315, 0.5445921421051025, 0.688186764717102, -0.7727619409561157, -0.7800795435905457, -0.7502682209014893, 0.0022305743768811226, -0.13469479978084564, 0.40685901045799255, 0.6525869965553284, -0.30405300855636597, 0.02583688125014305, 0.555003821849823, -0.32577139139175415, -0.10545480996370316, 0.2433283030986786, 0.22293949127197266, -0.25978586077690125, -0.1731344312429428, 0.8780292868614197, -0.6447511315345764, -0.8186187148094177, 0.6010475158691406, -0.5928890705108643, 0.36479640007019043, -0.21050183475017548, -0.006524708122014999, 0.46289923787117004, 0.5052453279495239, 0.2678755223751068, -0.7507649660110474, -0.07838714867830276, 0.9318836331367493, 0.29482153058052063, 0.36135101318359375, 0.16779077053070068, -0.5250073075294495, -0.1295696347951889, -0.7573351860046387, 0.09612874686717987, 0.18129482865333557, 0.4769623875617981, -1.094063639640808, 0.06704486161470413, -0.035487689077854156, 0.3229978382587433, -0.6713767051696777, -0.32289406657218933, -0.633557140827179, 0.7166330218315125, -0.4499201774597168, 0.05667642876505852, 0.004998721182346344, -0.19856616854667664, -0.3542812168598175, -0.16626210510730743, -0.05134812742471695, -0.1899784803390503, -0.5344049334526062, -0.1202506572008133, 0.3653269410133362, 0.17217959463596344, -0.398973673582077, -0.5889644622802734, -0.016344040632247925, -0.2092268466949463, 0.12214886397123337, -0.7356799244880676, 0.46101850271224976, 0.052743248641490936, 0.7636772990226746, 0.315807968378067, 0.3201451599597931, 0.20316264033317566, 0.040796779096126556, 0.9506486058235168, 0.013393044471740723, 0.3283873498439789, 0.17308500409126282, 0.19468098878860474, 0.11776342988014221, 0.32272353768348694, 0.049766428768634796, -0.23270350694656372, -0.3233553469181061, -0.6560353636741638, 0.13730280101299286, -0.5412294864654541, -0.17608274519443512, 0.4710247218608856, 0.5760054588317871, -0.46980181336402893, 0.2984164357185364, -0.21936428546905518, -0.5239960551261902, -0.5099563598632812, 0.4288384020328522, -0.02618873119354248, -0.5065869092941284, 0.9295995235443115, -0.03155339136719704, 0.8423271179199219, -1.0539581775665283, 4.282857418060303, 0.9624153971672058, 0.1412685364484787, -0.4099656641483307, 0.31058067083358765, 0.21583133935928345, 0.4953494966030121, -0.3818766176700592, 0.09012655913829803, 0.10443942248821259, -0.06561359763145447, -0.24120062589645386, -0.0149058997631073, -0.5635651350021362, -0.05160677433013916, 0.6377056837081909, -1.11802339553833, 0.28717121481895447, 0.3014618158340454, -0.6504140496253967, -0.16002462804317474, -0.03712891414761543, -0.7872849702835083, -0.05522533133625984, 0.7156486511230469, 0.22204458713531494, 0.2948031425476074, 0.41600677371025085, -0.09083180129528046, -0.021884389221668243, -0.24163781106472015, -0.6675825119018555, -0.12607112526893616, -0.5153639912605286, -0.8006712794303894, 0.4817367494106293, 0.04153605177998543, -0.3257577419281006, 0.04511860013008118, -0.5503383278846741, 0.12885989248752594, 0.41846731305122375, -0.43778282403945923, -0.5506729483604431, -0.5926235914230347, 0.32765457034111023, -0.21235238015651703, 0.16301555931568146, 0.4170994758605957, -0.6784951686859131, 0.9382385015487671, -1.1547847986221313, 0.5438872575759888, -0.45918136835098267, -0.6108478903770447, -0.5575706958770752, 0.171248659491539, -0.4460165202617645, 0.7848814129829407, 0.5935484766960144, 0.7729634642601013, -0.17553360760211945, 0.05439363420009613, 0.14334508776664734, 0.6777902245521545, 0.13068881630897522, 0.3366010785102844, -0.6747463941574097, 0.07436615973711014, -0.2645450532436371, -0.10679935663938522, -0.5737053155899048, -0.2987864911556244, 0.1990886926651001, 0.9875145554542542, 1.2279969453811646, -0.31131500005722046, 0.3647964894771576, -0.5076482892036438, -0.12697315216064453, 0.33119919896125793, -0.031059587374329567, 0.3585215210914612, -0.9372277855873108, 0.5512179732322693, 0.6193031072616577, -0.33234211802482605, 0.3145733177661896, -1.098912000656128, 0.8036956191062927, 0.5020500421524048, 0.20396552979946136, 0.27208074927330017, 0.141463503241539, -0.1294248402118683 ]
{"Title": "Urate, blood pressure and cardiovascular disease: updated evidence from Mendelian randomization and meta-analysis of clinical trials", "Authors": "Gill Dipender, Cameron Alan C., Burgess Stephen, Li Xue, Doherty Daniel J., Karhunen Ville, Abdul-Rahim Azmil H, Taylor-Rowan Martin, Zuber Verena, Tsao Philip S., Klarin Derek, Evangelou Evangelos, Elliott Paul, Damrauer Scott M., Quinn Terence J, Dehghan Abbas, Theodoratou Evropi, Dawson Jesse, Tzoulaki Ioanna", "Abstract": "Abstract Aims To investigate the effect of serum urate on blood pressure and cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk by updating evidence from Mendelian randomization (MR) analysis and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Methods and Results Using recently available data from the Million Veterans Program and UK Biobank, the main MR analyses showed that every 1-standard deviation increase in genetically predicted serum urate was associated with an increased risk of coronary heart disease (odds ratio 1.19, 95% confidence interval 1.10-1.30, P =4\u00d710 \u22125 ), peripheral artery disease (1.12, 95%CI 1.03 to 1.21, P =9\u00d710 \u22123 ), and stroke (1.11, 95%CI 1.05 to 1.18, P =2\u00d710 \u22124 ). In MR mediation analyses, SBP was estimated to mediate approximately one third the effect of urate on CVD risk. Systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTs showed a favorable effect of urate-lowering treatment on SBP (mean difference -2.55mmHg, 95%CI -4.06 to -1.05, P =1\u00d710 \u22123 ) and major adverse cardiovascular events (MACE) in those with previous CVD (OR 0.40, 95%CI 0.22 to 0.73, P =3\u00d710 \u22123 ), but no significant effect on MACE in all individuals (OR 0.73, 95%CI 0.48 to 1.09, P =0.12). Conclusion MR and clinical trial data support an effect of higher serum urate on increasing blood pressure, which may mediate a consequent effect on CVD risk. High-quality trials are necessary to provide definitive evidence on the specific clinical contexts where urate-lowering may be of cardiovascular benefit.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.11.19014472"}
10.1101/19006148
[ -0.20797736942768097, -0.33062759041786194, 0.23985610902309418, 1.152748703956604, -0.589065432548523, 0.19406624138355255, 0.5048142671585083, 0.3237167000770569, 0.6814977526664734, 0.1679353266954422, -0.571517288684845, -0.022504469379782677, 0.1585628241300583, -0.26443296670913696, -0.4719253182411194, 0.4059094488620758, -0.3545626699924469, -0.07049496471881866, 0.038469117134809494, 0.3644668757915497, 0.11018578708171844, 0.3369506299495697, -0.6348850131034851, 0.5267859697341919, -0.41393592953681946, 0.33331188559532166, 0.2697868049144745, 0.04755732789635658, 1.28065025806427, 0.8251712322235107, -0.11179062724113464, 0.3058657646179199, 0.21886281669139862, -1.0983628034591675, 0.3837153911590576, -0.7353712916374207, 0.1931447684764862, -0.514124870300293, 0.32175615429878235, -0.4673849046230316, 0.23649734258651733, 0.25025227665901184, 0.5022733211517334, -0.06714291125535965, -0.9730250835418701, -0.2865009903907776, -0.7082061171531677, -0.558081328868866, 0.5686919689178467, -0.21162740886211395, -0.022074490785598755, 0.0399334654211998, 0.4182398319244385, -0.30130600929260254, 0.6034773588180542, 0.26075735688209534, 0.08377920836210251, 0.2936846911907196, -0.8352319598197937, 0.39218831062316895, 0.7474756836891174, 0.0667954534292221, 0.40949028730392456, -1.479475736618042, 1.0379469394683838, 0.3880373537540436, -0.23602981865406036, -0.30805259943008423, 0.038338903337717056, -0.24894627928733826, -0.2993464767932892, -0.1555425524711609, 0.2944914996623993, -0.45177847146987915, -0.43795403838157654, -0.03448394685983658, 0.4712904989719391, 0.08102687448263168, 0.1673378050327301, -0.31003373861312866, 0.05800057575106621, -0.3447648584842682, -0.26466190814971924, 0.42227762937545776, -0.7410244941711426, 0.517428994178772, -0.1459709256887436, -0.15359072387218475, 0.522063136100769, 0.047172948718070984, 0.4779928922653198, 0.3884779214859009, -0.5823606848716736, -0.2747771143913269, 0.3614679276943207, 0.4559788107872009, -0.8034725189208984, 0.3825282156467438, 0.43696677684783936, 0.1917186975479126, 0.5303635597229004, 0.3338492214679718, 0.24956919252872467, 1.2244958877563477, -0.5585625767707825, 1.0877517461776733, 0.7351561784744263, -0.2698715925216675, -0.5315859913825989, -0.06192268058657646, 0.5809299349784851, 0.173970565199852, -0.36154407262802124, 0.05411738529801369, 0.5309978723526001, 0.7559711337089539, -0.3378313183784485, 1.0586376190185547, -0.4934486150741577, -0.2445869892835617, 0.030772343277931213, -0.06521587073802948, 0.6111319065093994, -0.38394370675086975, 0.05592091754078865, 0.18877924978733063, 0.5010684728622437, 0.18316130340099335, -0.6959282755851746, -0.7704150676727295, -0.2856172025203705, -0.14583933353424072, 0.6687996983528137, 0.5365210175514221, -1.1395330429077148, -0.46241995692253113, 0.3770330846309662, 0.8099178671836853, 1.0975801944732666, -0.2752857208251953, -0.23873913288116455, 0.8773074150085449, 0.012223644182085991, 0.9428560733795166, 0.05081023648381233, 0.1927802413702011, -0.5410869121551514, -1.5328971147537231, -0.56889408826828, 0.323294997215271, -0.25664082169532776, 0.6751675009727478, 0.2915659248828888, -0.4803679585456848, 0.08143032342195511, -0.5052213072776794, -0.2452903389930725, 0.11500370502471924, -0.14550840854644775, -0.1963498592376709, 0.10902741551399231, 0.5989272594451904, -0.5771234035491943, 0.5406010746955872, -0.04324576258659363, 0.7733311057090759, 0.17750906944274902, 0.3663502037525177, -0.00554924039170146, -0.761478841304779, 1.3872061967849731, -0.3258815109729767, -0.41509339213371277, -0.10772421956062317, -0.15500548481941223, 0.8211118578910828, 0.6575865745544434, 0.1937505006790161, 0.5221087336540222, 0.39183008670806885, 0.1823837161064148, -0.27366188168525696, 0.26615607738494873, 0.45713943243026733, -0.4830853343009949, 0.5957521200180054, -0.6312578320503235, -0.8081828951835632, 0.14180898666381836, -0.5772159695625305, 0.09058397263288498, 0.13164784014225006, -0.5143740177154541, 0.7574362754821777, -0.17168422043323517, -0.6488304138183594, -0.685109555721283, 1.0980300903320312, 0.37472155690193176, -0.0868263691663742, -0.4384760856628418, 0.5849160552024841, -0.7347037196159363, 0.24602127075195312, -0.2003004103899002, 0.6009962558746338, -0.24694083631038666, 0.25356030464172363, -1.0338916778564453, 0.47390854358673096, 0.5504682064056396, -0.07193295657634735, -0.4387798011302948, -0.6635255813598633, 0.5631438493728638, -0.3774092197418213, -0.36627519130706787, 0.009695774875581264, -0.3392501771450043, -0.06497247517108917, -0.2726716101169586, -0.10048580169677734, 0.3397446572780609, 0.1368199735879898, 0.22420142590999603, -0.44082510471343994, 0.2655960023403168, 0.5364828109741211, -1.6037482023239136, -0.3665952682495117, 0.42737266421318054, 1.0079866647720337, 0.011894122697412968, 0.8674069046974182, 0.5426722764968872, 1.0261200666427612, 0.39782074093818665, -0.4087579548358917, 1.0008946657180786, 0.6729310154914856, 0.007356408983469009, 0.7906534075737, 0.564982533454895, 0.12277304381132126, -0.0025186475832015276, 0.9665052890777588, -0.258820503950119, -0.021909838542342186, -0.013736508786678314, -0.1443055272102356, -0.5356640815734863, 0.8857119083404541, 0.49125635623931885, 0.9458903074264526, -1.1159796714782715, -0.30044567584991455, 0.484699547290802, 0.17514033615589142, -0.543664813041687, -0.42053666710853577, 0.31496211886405945, 0.21257911622524261, 0.10314856469631195, -0.21278370916843414, 0.26600372791290283, -0.12235096096992493, 0.34200650453567505, 0.2521513104438782, 0.11569056659936905, 0.21205057203769684, -0.6698111295700073, -0.5106561779975891, -1.6426326036453247, -1.0800821781158447, -0.46867144107818604, 0.12992800772190094, 0.048761509358882904, -0.248477503657341, -0.22371728718280792, -0.37182489037513733, 0.34247472882270813, -0.42968863248825073, 0.32520607113838196, 0.43123704195022583, 0.31683552265167236, 0.4144895672798157, -0.7188591957092285, 0.04289551079273224, -0.5094684958457947, 0.07013547420501709, 0.14352259039878845, -0.6734811663627625, -0.26867619156837463, -0.3916347324848175, -0.017645075917243958, -0.7652505040168762, 0.09336639195680618, -0.2998434603214264, -0.6507471799850464, -0.06114068999886513, 0.5643340945243835, 0.2813892364501953, 0.4818080961704254, 0.1059916764497757, -0.44888877868652344, 0.17724591493606567, -0.07834611088037491, 0.45939674973487854, 0.9006288051605225, 0.13666723668575287, -0.304897665977478, 0.6092323660850525, 0.47700923681259155, -0.03770773857831955, -1.0441640615463257, -0.4761650264263153, 0.9932513236999512, -0.2448611855506897, 0.10544890910387039, -0.8528218269348145, -1.3122613430023193, 0.14837421476840973, -0.049890924245119095, -0.024623634293675423, -0.2109081745147705, -0.2348918616771698, -0.09983129054307938, -1.3696846961975098, 0.34405308961868286, -0.7710360884666443, -1.1709392070770264, 0.14883111417293549, -0.3708278238773346, 0.24244120717048645, 0.3734739124774933, -0.039919983595609665, -0.12669405341148376, 0.23112258315086365, -0.06355934590101242, 0.14338713884353638, 0.20930127799510956, 0.13633795082569122, -0.16814422607421875, 0.43946486711502075, -0.4540468156337738, 0.8576081395149231, 0.7582755088806152, -0.21869492530822754, -0.6867176294326782, 0.03795227035880089, -0.5517228841781616, 0.01143025141209364, 0.45422008633613586, 0.8058378100395203, 0.12991981208324432, 0.7489283680915833, 0.3036154508590698, 0.06812577694654465, 0.3341415822505951, 0.4291689395904541, -0.03508596494793892, 0.34305161237716675, -0.23992566764354706, 0.4669357240200043, -0.7539957165718079, -0.5719190835952759, 0.2582297623157501, -0.13524353504180908, 0.6911858916282654, -0.0667082741856575, 0.8651514649391174, -0.3833739757537842, -0.24867750704288483, 0.18241481482982635, 0.06971534341573715, -0.576309084892273, 0.4533606171607971, 0.20534689724445343, 0.8307121992111206, -0.8639295697212219, -0.17330169677734375, 0.4717218279838562, 0.6881528496742249, 0.10806809365749359, -0.00521652540192008, -0.3048107922077179, -0.8057388663291931, -0.08587830513715744, 0.1428167074918747, -0.25476086139678955, -0.5174553394317627, 0.060635898262262344, -0.2977091073989868, 0.463650643825531, -0.7324881553649902, -0.8388915061950684, 0.4076319932937622, 0.2889974117279053, 0.28933244943618774, 0.11093587428331375, 1.179197907447815, -0.14619392156600952, 0.6332392692565918, 0.4847385883331299, 0.1849030703306198, 0.01964588463306427, 0.08596193790435791, -0.2511073052883148, 0.18658073246479034, -0.6737406849861145, -0.7581038475036621, -0.43180614709854126, -0.36616989970207214, -0.46240147948265076, 0.24437761306762695, -0.06817913055419922, 0.19648031890392303, 0.08287476748228073, -0.6063593626022339, 0.09430719166994095, -0.43722790479660034, 0.34537985920906067, -0.38842707872390747, -0.039091236889362335, 0.20666024088859558, -0.51481693983078, 0.3009059727191925, -0.5259788632392883, 0.03088258020579815, 1.1604658365249634, -0.29790249466896057, -0.7982226014137268, -0.8922485709190369, 0.06760960072278976, -0.25213831663131714, -0.3610285818576813, -0.4700547158718109, 0.416734904050827, 1.1097102165222168, -0.5898112058639526, -0.20226143300533295, -0.5461603999137878, -0.9238429665565491, -0.09241580963134766, 0.6389578580856323, 0.3379300832748413, 0.991014838218689, -0.2741176187992096, 0.737450897693634, -0.21601882576942444, 0.7203198671340942, -0.9701005816459656, 0.7351844310760498, -0.4957352578639984, -0.8123137950897217, 0.38874542713165283, -0.28773707151412964, -0.10654256492853165, 0.722210705280304, -0.5635206699371338, -0.028485342860221863, -0.39671790599823, -0.15712153911590576, 0.5558114647865295, 0.43452829122543335, 1.5775514841079712, -0.2979327142238617, -0.10954193770885468, 0.943103551864624, -0.7226016521453857, 0.0074118925258517265, 0.22941797971725464, -0.14401546120643616, 0.2781504690647125, 0.1699109971523285, 0.1064465120434761, 0.16234475374221802, 0.2643459141254425, -0.24444903433322906, 0.49170753359794617, -0.6064620614051819, 0.6097539067268372, -0.3829323351383209, -0.1817690134048462, 0.27392300963401794, -0.3685103952884674, -1.0699583292007446, -0.2586442232131958, -0.44588419795036316, 0.9287731647491455, -0.5043632388114929, -0.9859244227409363, -0.9579088687896729, 0.3962879180908203, -0.7964119911193848, -0.6424525380134583, -0.6806809902191162, 0.1700543612241745, -0.441215842962265, 0.6809391975402832, 0.618446946144104, -0.8269942402839661, -0.4580022096633911, 1.417750597000122, 0.12898074090480804, -0.5744869709014893, -0.4284266233444214, 0.02458212338387966, 0.4556215703487396, -0.5110769271850586, -0.2945314645767212, 0.05311492830514908, -0.5559327006340027, 0.43979060649871826, 0.3369787335395813, -0.2185199111700058, 0.21077653765678406, 0.16123582422733307, -0.5170813202857971, 0.5615115761756897, -0.2779715359210968, -0.4048566520214081, -0.6568355560302734, 0.028044946491718292, 0.24305064976215363, 0.09188222140073776, -0.27968570590019226, -0.5339149236679077, -0.5483689308166504, -0.4910491108894348, -0.20141348242759705, 0.11252918839454651, -0.34515517950057983, -0.7350740432739258, -1.2542228698730469, 0.1339641958475113, 1.101654052734375, 0.5711531639099121, 0.18781152367591858, 0.026844572275877, 0.04986186325550079, 0.2673201858997345, -0.3367920517921448, -0.26363036036491394, 0.40422162413597107, -0.3319314122200012, 0.12901386618614197, 0.8225002288818359, -0.4860434830188751, -0.06803639233112335, 0.009272602386772633, 0.1250951588153839, 0.6577691435813904, 0.4534165859222412, -0.24131499230861664, -1.0122616291046143, 0.6724758148193359, 0.04721756651997566, -0.548264741897583, 0.2539936304092407, -0.44117647409439087, 0.7773688435554504, -0.61479651927948, 0.3561541736125946, -0.27329662442207336, -0.4818374812602997, -0.46757858991622925, -0.45181405544281006, 0.7088567018508911, -0.5461208820343018, -0.4323428273200989, 0.3916552662849426, -0.2594917416572571, -0.10976426303386688, 0.05339467152953148, -0.6244581341743469, -1.167128562927246, -0.9066857695579529, -0.8817302584648132, 0.2474425882101059, 0.4292897582054138, -0.19063721597194672, 0.9382272958755493, -0.4498419761657715, 0.03668491914868355, -0.27011317014694214, 1.202889084815979, 0.48138079047203064, -0.8452685475349426, -0.8676660656929016, 0.1184975653886795, 0.4291197955608368, 0.1815330982208252, 0.3606691360473633, 0.019972799345850945, -0.7339853048324585, -0.12672826647758484, -0.1376137137413025, -0.45904240012168884, -1.1722363233566284, -0.07444467395544052, 0.625137984752655, 0.35629522800445557, -0.3445616364479065, -0.6648999452590942, 0.06237521022558212, -0.16629855334758759, -0.0755481943488121, 0.3253398537635803, -0.5409327745437622, 0.44383007287979126, 0.4613887667655945, -0.31569352746009827, -0.5112158060073853, 0.2206423431634903, 0.19221527874469757, 0.44255098700523376, -0.29008352756500244, 0.18741782009601593, 0.04127570986747742, -0.6714162230491638, 1.1755448579788208, 0.29341503977775574, -0.7919037342071533, -0.41339796781539917, 0.03676191344857216, -0.4475681781768799, -0.13246193528175354, -0.463800311088562, -0.2630414664745331, 0.4422275424003601, -0.5651940107345581, 0.9197645783424377, -0.08960796892642975, -0.0025998391211032867, -0.5000602006912231, -1.3507000207901, 0.1919957399368286, -0.4106055498123169, -0.635282576084137, 0.5568958520889282, -0.18141762912273407, -0.001461393665522337, 0.3479110896587372, 0.7411516904830933, 0.08466977626085281, 0.4808458387851715, 0.18818321824073792, -0.507414698600769, 0.08974006026983261, 0.35402485728263855, 0.4241879880428314, -0.1949440836906433, -0.039631329476833344, 0.1865474283695221, 0.3529244661331177, 0.795035719871521, -0.8176020979881287, -1.084955096244812, 0.9259561896324158, 0.16775161027908325, -0.007680319249629974, 0.25955119729042053, 0.14008362591266632, 1.2540409564971924, 0.48968249559402466, 0.619723916053772, -0.08701037615537643, -0.6886985898017883, -0.41189369559288025, -0.5936294198036194, -0.3160175383090973, -1.0587551593780518, -0.7416410446166992, 0.4171483516693115, 0.05885300412774086, -0.5471505522727966, -0.2156727910041809, 1.5307055711746216, 0.0635765865445137, -0.5442876815795898, -0.5341799855232239, 0.26452943682670593, -0.32754358649253845, -0.9522005915641785, -0.7309279441833496, -0.3341197371482849, 0.5690430402755737, 1.136746883392334, -0.5873531699180603, -0.825328528881073, 0.650854229927063, 0.23495961725711823, -0.31389087438583374, 0.1908893883228302, -0.08302710950374603, -1.67911958694458, 0.70250403881073, 0.14135512709617615, -0.27881890535354614, 0.2218925654888153, 1.0870361328125, -0.44228696823120117, 0.6729915142059326, 0.5289326310157776, -0.24547256529331207, -0.3468964993953705, 0.5197454690933228, 0.4076758325099945, -0.4645313024520874, -0.8417990803718567, -0.42382538318634033, 0.4763031601905823, -0.763372540473938, -0.5578668117523193, -0.4242994487285614, -0.23826704919338226, 0.3990308940410614, 0.2790754437446594, -0.36033135652542114, 0.27014124393463135, 0.025318201631307602, 0.15419505536556244, 0.3075774312019348, 1.2385241985321045, 0.6101000308990479, 0.3120090365409851, 0.4419867694377899, 0.1355113685131073, 0.3606444001197815, -0.9728193283081055, 0.2215901017189026, 0.14625048637390137, -0.7711873054504395, -0.009954716078937054, -0.09775053709745407, 0.6057226061820984, 0.2594051659107208, -0.39541953802108765, 0.1298052966594696, 1.1785842180252075, 0.28685519099235535, 0.3960072696208954, 0.14598533511161804, -0.2845744788646698, -0.6057704091072083, -1.4347844123840332, -0.9253962635993958, 0.10380690544843674, 0.5129754543304443, -0.4049827754497528, -0.1033981665968895, -0.4320424199104309, -0.8181182742118835, 0.7893359065055847, 0.5387899875640869, 0.30777859687805176, -1.0351405143737793, 1.4281493425369263, 0.46957558393478394, 0.2297494262456894, 0.5774579048156738, -0.6680724620819092, 0.5005782246589661, 0.009056499227881432, -0.7094570994377136, -0.2828262746334076, 0.2967272996902466, 0.16937653720378876, 0.24791570007801056, -0.44154882431030273, -0.22441348433494568, 0.3206885755062103, 0.24616973102092743, 0.013661247678101063, -0.060049064457416534, -0.0900634154677391, -0.9195923805236816, -0.04443369805812836, -0.16119630634784698, -0.2560557723045349, -0.5323187708854675, 0.3067665994167328, -0.6015094518661499, -1.2288939952850342, -0.35100260376930237, -0.2748483419418335, 0.24545104801654816, -0.2359151393175125, 0.6860694885253906, -0.11276224255561829, 0.5560438632965088, -0.4384358525276184, -0.10616307705640793, 0.5963553190231323, 1.045224666595459, 0.21585163474082947, 0.34228962659835815, -0.6228371262550354, 0.3537873327732086, 0.9088005423545837, 0.6245940327644348, 0.23175330460071564, 0.13057257235050201, 0.11809434741735458, 0.06118663400411606, -0.0676601305603981, -0.12089903652667999, 0.4658949077129364, 0.8037154078483582, -0.3701823651790619, -0.3497183620929718, 0.8461207151412964, 0.2849887013435364, 0.6086437702178955, -0.6987762451171875, -0.3632999062538147, -1.0282022953033447, -0.4889199733734131, -0.060679737478494644, -0.26733195781707764, 0.9274863600730896, 0.0138565544039011, -0.10131868720054626, 0.23659564554691315, 0.47364166378974915, 0.09884174913167953, 0.7184582352638245, 0.6532355546951294, -0.2595894932746887, -0.019550945609807968, -0.6831422448158264, 0.11075235158205032, -0.10675203055143356, -0.13856008648872375, 0.2404615432024002, -0.38717353343963623, 0.012655587866902351, 0.1469545066356659, -0.6477911472320557, -0.0023604503367096186, 0.6005711555480957, -0.2172372192144394, -0.2137720286846161, -0.22380967438220978, -0.2481856793165207, -0.36499693989753723, -0.5572386980056763, 0.7972922921180725, -0.44792187213897705, 0.5134480595588684, 0.26763108372688293, 0.4163237512111664, 1.064466953277588, 0.5959050059318542, 0.4875941276550293, -0.3281959891319275, 0.21129119396209717, 0.30334755778312683, -0.010657583363354206, 0.07043365389108658, -0.026625778526067734, -0.7785114049911499, 0.01881118305027485, 0.31508469581604004, 1.0181519985198975, 0.053757086396217346, -0.1732194423675537, -0.17128311097621918, 0.11835631728172302, -0.05210002139210701, -0.0868598222732544, -0.8852723240852356, 0.3562479615211487, 0.3981042504310608, 0.36196058988571167, -0.4395066499710083, -0.25651830434799194, 0.18469808995723724, 0.6673404574394226, -0.4483743906021118, -0.2397373765707016, -0.13884355127811432, -0.08720988035202026, -0.8479957580566406, 0.21781589090824127, 0.3539421558380127, -0.3035699725151062, -0.6729789972305298, -1.1774204969406128, -0.23320120573043823, -0.2645527124404907, -0.2059786170721054, -1.212557077407837, -0.43265271186828613, -0.08288674801588058, 0.8945102095603943, 0.1366112381219864, -0.5055426359176636, -0.1608363837003708, 0.22431029379367828, 0.7167054414749146, -0.1277579367160797, 0.32044124603271484, 0.6001893281936646, 0.7324126362800598, 0.0011066608130931854, 0.2940487861633301, -0.15624456107616425, -0.09746494889259338, -0.030462758615612984, 0.033232904970645905, 0.5943198204040527, -0.609942615032196, -1.1770962476730347, 0.09793680906295776, 0.602593183517456, 0.0479787215590477, -0.4545838534832001, 0.056927505880594254, -0.4080566167831421, -0.3934352993965149, 1.0095969438552856, -0.5493865013122559, 0.28404805064201355, 0.5247094035148621, -0.2517164647579193, 0.641139030456543, -0.8477956056594849, 4.000142574310303, 1.1514618396759033, -0.04736894369125366, 0.3619112968444824, 0.870166540145874, 0.14419466257095337, 1.1339119672775269, 0.1502387821674347, 0.29100003838539124, -0.4557310938835144, -0.49897634983062744, 0.33243852853775024, -0.3729154169559479, -0.08772937953472137, -0.2315407395362854, 0.18688344955444336, -0.8538233637809753, -0.08643743395805359, 0.1375262439250946, -1.299247145652771, -0.6263833045959473, 0.06031503155827522, -0.2750178873538971, 0.0826171487569809, 0.25249311327934265, -0.7617741227149963, 0.16350997984409332, 0.4407796561717987, -0.2404068261384964, -0.581628143787384, 0.26885342597961426, -0.2886814773082733, 0.19185632467269897, -1.1452549695968628, -0.3511219620704651, 0.11889558285474777, 0.2721659243106842, -0.4991171956062317, -0.07301224023103714, -0.6853973865509033, -0.10435614734888077, 0.011853483505547047, -0.17594820261001587, -0.0557829774916172, -0.029674261808395386, 0.05188550055027008, -0.43537643551826477, 0.14431478083133698, 0.20123440027236938, -0.7131043076515198, 0.8809270262718201, -1.1161795854568481, 0.46336567401885986, 0.12179546058177948, -0.9901708364486694, -0.6086881756782532, -0.16558793187141418, -0.7652824521064758, 0.5329609513282776, 0.8292520642280579, 0.8624610900878906, 0.2451794147491455, -0.39033833146095276, -0.34163933992385864, 0.5195016860961914, 0.49745917320251465, 0.40340012311935425, 0.25769785046577454, -0.194342240691185, -0.664941132068634, 0.11381993442773819, -0.05402380973100662, -1.0969027280807495, -0.2337384670972824, 0.2803637981414795, 0.6022905707359314, -0.6705546379089355, 0.6277462840080261, -0.424400269985199, 0.19706305861473083, 0.512060284614563, 0.14967334270477295, 0.42402881383895874, -0.3914661705493927, 0.6195101141929626, 1.2034820318222046, -0.1964116245508194, -0.051361434161663055, -0.9144247174263, 0.17873217165470123, 0.39952683448791504, -0.6912704110145569, -0.30420562624931335, 0.1949106603860855, -0.2650807201862335 ]
{"Title": "Self-reported Morisky 8 item medication adherence scale to statins concords with pill count method and correlates with serum lipid profile parameters and Serum HMGCoA Reductase levels", "Authors": "Grover Abhinav, Oberoi Mansi, Rehan Harmeet, Gupta Lalit, Yadav Madhur", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background It is imperative that non-compliance to statins be identified and addressed to optimize the clinical benefit of statins. Patient self-reporting methods are convenient to apply in clinical practice but need to be validated. Objective We studied the concordance of a patient self-report method, MMAS (Morisky eight item medication adherence scale) with pill count method in measuring adherence to statins and their correlation with extended lipid profile parameters and serum HMGCoA-R (hydroxymethylglutaryl coenzyme A reductase) enzyme levels. Methods MMAS and pill count method were used to measure the adherence to statins in patients on statins for any duration. Patients were subjected to estimation of extended lipid profile and serum HMGCoA-R levels at the end of 3 months follow-up. Results Out of a total of 200 patients included in the study, 117 patients had low adherence (score less than 6 on MMAS) whereas 65 and 18 patients had medium (score 6 to less than 8) and high adherence (score of 8) respectively. Majority of patients who had low adherence to statins by MMAS were nonadherent by pill count method yielding concordance of 96.5%. Medium or high adherence to statins by MMAS method had concordance of 89.1% with pill count method. The levels of total cholesterol, low density lipoprotein-cholesterol, apolipoprotein B and HMGCoA-R were significantly negatively correlated with compliance measured by pill count and MMAS with similar correlation coefficients. HMGCoA-R levels demonstrated a plateau phenomenon with levels being 9-10 ng/ml when compliance to statin therapy was greater than 60% by pill count and greater than 6 on Morisky scale. Conclusion In conclusion, MMAS and pill count methods showed concordance in measuring adherence to statins. These methods need to be explored further for their interchangeability as surrogates for biomarker levels.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19006148"}
10.1101/19003012
[ 0.17129945755004883, 0.35982921719551086, -0.0724896565079689, -0.020856285467743874, -0.4843463897705078, -0.5250802040100098, -0.09585513174533844, 0.09237309545278549, 0.22159992158412933, 0.5611064434051514, -0.02742926962673664, -0.626923143863678, 0.5232317447662354, 0.15118297934532166, 0.04740772396326065, -0.0077463253401219845, -0.666688859462738, -0.1722591370344162, -0.4888175427913666, 0.4791656732559204, 0.12309712916612625, 0.7048614025115967, -0.7475107908248901, -0.14375647902488708, -0.5597575902938843, 0.4489164650440216, -0.31301170587539673, 0.15121647715568542, 1.271236777305603, 0.8430373072624207, 0.6031253933906555, -0.2688342332839966, 0.3290115296840668, -0.5304959416389465, 0.12554599344730377, -0.19618861377239227, -0.1140248104929924, -0.9154195189476013, 0.3229905664920807, -0.08501917123794556, 0.3465173542499542, -0.42043399810791016, 1.0048813819885254, -0.0029821707867085934, -0.6139039397239685, 0.23689612746238708, -0.12053677439689636, -0.05119622126221657, -0.20769891142845154, 0.37992438673973083, -0.6834921836853027, -0.33213549852371216, 0.16414088010787964, -1.110588788986206, 0.2706468999385834, 0.17368382215499878, -0.21340438723564148, 0.7117204666137695, -0.7342027425765991, 0.10537731647491455, 0.22000524401664734, -0.40573838353157043, 0.3503832519054413, -0.4721998870372772, 0.9136654138565063, 0.8768696784973145, 0.34054675698280334, -1.20445716381073, -0.32574740052223206, -0.2512458264827728, -0.6548168659210205, -0.5031337141990662, -0.0194240752607584, -0.5374433398246765, -0.34300968050956726, -0.34014892578125, 0.23988571763038635, -0.3201030492782593, -0.7248539924621582, -0.4267435073852539, 0.732174277305603, 0.20109328627586365, 0.0698498785495758, -0.1100078821182251, -0.7950617074966431, 0.29535096883773804, 0.2385961264371872, 0.9057715535163879, 0.20390067994594574, 0.5317129492759705, 0.33189883828163147, 0.3321043848991394, 0.2960357367992401, -0.12244531512260437, 0.14609776437282562, 1.2768346071243286, -0.5329694747924805, -0.18697908520698547, 0.22653545439243317, -0.2588878571987152, 0.27778881788253784, 0.8189898133277893, -0.14618003368377686, 0.6051747798919678, -0.46256548166275024, 0.6955249309539795, 0.3808884918689728, -0.9034127593040466, -0.5074349045753479, -0.5824540853500366, -0.013483804650604725, 0.049804359674453735, -0.09740742295980453, -0.3656077980995178, 1.1747326850891113, 0.8238542675971985, 0.01785857230424881, 0.7705272436141968, -0.6727334856987, 1.3453799486160278, -0.6759634613990784, 0.18623164296150208, 0.4518367052078247, -0.7170892953872681, 0.17250359058380127, -0.01996365748345852, 1.0804346799850464, 0.7767671942710876, -0.5741267204284668, -0.26043152809143066, 0.3361777663230896, -0.827411949634552, -0.19630110263824463, 0.40564215183258057, -0.1867731511592865, -0.19988806545734406, 0.4549744129180908, 1.0081610679626465, 0.16968972980976105, 0.12690049409866333, -0.5781338214874268, 0.6287779808044434, -0.29655784368515015, 1.1313016414642334, -0.39365726709365845, 0.9285693168640137, -0.8561126589775085, -1.502419114112854, -0.8970522284507751, -0.3848606050014496, 0.43547946214675903, 1.0613902807235718, 0.05323725566267967, -0.5340262055397034, -0.11752072721719742, -0.053393006324768066, -0.6997241973876953, 0.24152140319347382, 0.1473885476589203, -0.27614036202430725, -0.6158974766731262, 0.19604019820690155, 0.290376752614975, 0.8865306973457336, -0.7325739860534668, 0.4429120719432831, -0.050494782626628876, 0.3155992329120636, 0.5741246342658997, -0.3154042065143585, 0.5894502401351929, 0.09669128805398941, -0.7174518704414368, -0.18520179390907288, 0.9844925403594971, 1.5538184642791748, 0.7134773135185242, -0.5214073061943054, 0.22798477113246918, 0.4580126702785492, -0.5791082382202148, -0.2965801954269409, 0.341447651386261, 0.2976064383983612, -0.05616974085569382, 0.1687643676996231, -0.17667104303836823, -0.6737493276596069, -0.36446696519851685, -0.7172262668609619, -0.01720592752099037, 0.7395137548446655, -0.5690370798110962, 0.545570433139801, 0.24931089580059052, -0.29862120747566223, 0.048060305416584015, 0.425173819065094, 0.5985257029533386, 0.6318585872650146, -0.5223537087440491, 0.3130934238433838, 0.17826616764068604, 0.43878069519996643, 0.18183782696723938, 0.6715428233146667, 0.2004319727420807, 0.36527276039123535, -0.6905199289321899, 0.0990833193063736, 0.8530025482177734, -0.2858998775482178, -0.42410171031951904, 0.2565711438655853, 0.71043860912323, -0.11599083989858627, -0.5441030859947205, -0.2609705626964569, -0.25530195236206055, -0.19765549898147583, -0.7411082983016968, 0.13116274774074554, 0.8081437349319458, -0.28797999024391174, -0.009969811886548996, 0.22651971876621246, 0.5575656294822693, 0.146471306681633, -0.5353139042854309, 0.12119387090206146, -0.130441814661026, 0.7051240801811218, 0.12324609607458115, 0.6117879748344421, 0.5396521091461182, 0.006155872717499733, -0.012584463693201542, 0.4394782781600952, 0.19432169198989868, 0.21675246953964233, 0.2912537753582001, 0.15725138783454895, 0.4716576635837555, 0.6066620945930481, -0.16469791531562805, 0.5949097871780396, -0.3954201638698578, -0.29478442668914795, 0.1928536742925644, 0.19370219111442566, -0.07563161104917526, 0.7080761790275574, 0.2875867784023285, 0.13183270394802094, -0.9419017434120178, 0.06846243888139725, 0.4620876908302307, 0.1397043615579605, -0.48374679684638977, -0.5791252851486206, -0.4666356146335602, 0.716456949710846, -0.08521170914173126, -0.14802046120166779, 1.0757464170455933, 1.0369977951049805, -0.7189387679100037, 0.3483876883983612, 0.3486722707748413, 0.10345422476530075, -0.43015557527542114, -0.035982705652713776, -0.8234916925430298, -0.6506224274635315, -1.2139685153961182, -0.0247015580534935, -0.17614230513572693, -0.2642973065376282, 0.050841301679611206, 0.1042066365480423, 0.33536145091056824, 0.04290015622973442, -0.1050322875380516, 0.49701830744743347, 0.4500139057636261, -0.15928679704666138, -1.5442454814910889, -0.47664883732795715, -0.6720355749130249, 0.012235588394105434, 0.12979687750339508, -0.029782820492982864, -0.6071281433105469, -0.08454730361700058, 0.2637392580509186, -0.7752928137779236, 0.05113409832119942, -0.3851654529571533, -0.45770183205604553, -0.10919530689716339, 0.4116964638233185, 0.11003005504608154, 0.1958303600549698, -0.3698540925979614, -0.28750720620155334, 0.715589165687561, -0.19134381413459778, 0.07158234715461731, 0.5950435996055603, 0.34534740447998047, -0.4722592532634735, -0.0801866352558136, -0.15486648678779602, 0.21011114120483398, -0.6804929375648499, -0.16198162734508514, -0.03091871365904808, -1.0444860458374023, 0.34160134196281433, -0.35023728013038635, -0.5549815893173218, 0.14747336506843567, 0.12294887006282806, -0.22529929876327515, -0.22328676283359528, 0.6093560457229614, 0.06878039240837097, -1.1483843326568604, 0.0031941565684974194, -0.09365396201610565, -0.9151057600975037, 0.009943381883203983, -0.10444257408380508, 0.15090014040470123, 0.05366428196430206, -0.003618971211835742, -0.12511011958122253, 0.12793444097042084, 0.14331625401973724, 0.6803179979324341, 0.39400428533554077, -0.6275644302368164, -0.03397456184029579, 0.1260230392217636, -0.7098155617713928, 0.5262612104415894, 0.26899901032447815, -0.42750412225723267, -0.15610523521900177, -0.18199044466018677, 0.1668262481689453, 0.9181115031242371, 0.8355048894882202, -0.3109903633594513, -0.1824081391096115, 0.7015824317932129, 0.22359293699264526, 0.4237584173679352, 0.018824806436896324, 0.35807615518569946, 0.47122061252593994, -0.007583933882415295, -0.1687030792236328, 0.9800891280174255, -0.9394410848617554, -0.5519829392433167, 0.5740602612495422, -0.36688825488090515, 0.6111900210380554, -0.2968622148036957, 0.8997078537940979, -0.02587088942527771, -0.2901724576950073, 0.3687191307544708, -0.40040960907936096, 0.07390093803405762, 1.192421793937683, 0.9389796257019043, 0.5056856870651245, -0.926724910736084, 0.5997774004936218, 0.09533244371414185, 0.39522454142570496, 0.21827396750450134, -0.4849632680416107, 0.6044207811355591, -0.6614925861358643, 0.1261008083820343, -0.1737259477376938, -0.6849828958511353, 0.06068387255072594, 0.07129524648189545, 0.20832210779190063, -0.2539956569671631, 0.1708061397075653, -0.35319826006889343, 0.300449937582016, 0.7448360323905945, -0.07380995899438858, -0.34110504388809204, 1.026005506515503, -0.36743125319480896, 0.43865740299224854, 0.6845037341117859, 0.6057137250900269, 0.22757136821746826, -0.7559751868247986, 0.05079667270183563, -0.3619314432144165, 0.14267511665821075, -0.5658507943153381, -0.15657486021518707, -0.005094463936984539, -0.24765342473983765, 0.34563127160072327, -0.6555096507072449, -0.38606786727905273, -1.0382115840911865, -0.5513429641723633, -0.47849729657173157, 0.4029878079891205, 0.017870072275400162, -0.22760915756225586, 0.07024142146110535, -0.5542338490486145, -0.6508162021636963, 0.08584434539079666, -0.4303692579269409, 0.146465003490448, 0.3993567228317261, 0.1654377281665802, -0.5711510181427002, -0.8623548746109009, 0.30732426047325134, -0.04182227700948715, 0.17177776992321014, -0.4153355062007904, 0.44928407669067383, 0.025641614571213722, -0.2648693323135376, -0.22304381430149078, -0.2827301621437073, 0.39422479271888733, -0.15852700173854828, -0.16208575665950775, 0.44574445486068726, 1.0179991722106934, 0.3774047791957855, 1.3229364156723022, -0.2824234664440155, 0.25210124254226685, -0.6819442510604858, 0.42122882604599, -0.836672306060791, -0.7753029465675354, -0.21862542629241943, -0.1587684005498886, 0.1939469873905182, 0.2590346038341522, 0.021605299785733223, -0.37050384283065796, -0.4444137513637543, -0.32440871000289917, -0.1383386105298996, -0.24999184906482697, 1.3692007064819336, -0.6125970482826233, -0.22717949748039246, 1.3822948932647705, -0.7733919024467468, -0.32317426800727844, -0.17943593859672546, -0.20685899257659912, -0.3696179687976837, 0.7916166186332703, 0.03986993804574013, 0.4508245885372162, 0.21079640090465546, -0.42679038643836975, -0.19205497205257416, 0.3511444926261902, 0.18490028381347656, -0.7750304341316223, -0.15326687693595886, -0.6055424213409424, -0.6016210317611694, -0.2513875365257263, -0.042112380266189575, -0.7350994944572449, 0.617372989654541, -0.17505213618278503, -0.4348497986793518, -0.3976813852787018, -0.3598335385322571, -0.6634528636932373, 0.16094695031642914, -0.3415038287639618, -0.5039893388748169, -0.4679276943206787, -0.3187910318374634, 0.15698474645614624, -0.2732638120651245, -0.5620294213294983, -0.15313421189785004, 0.6196767091751099, -1.0877739191055298, -0.5918566584587097, -0.3811282515525818, 0.32921651005744934, -0.5139946937561035, -0.5067743062973022, -0.283238023519516, -0.48729729652404785, -0.19585557281970978, -0.31154879927635193, -0.08744166791439056, 0.9002258777618408, -0.0005209040245972574, -0.3911571800708771, 0.2680496573448181, -0.10412817448377609, -0.642771303653717, -0.11023932695388794, 0.6206364631652832, 0.10747946053743362, 0.2671867609024048, -0.9918707013130188, -0.5540015697479248, -0.20205336809158325, -1.2948077917099, -0.45791757106781006, -0.262734979391098, 0.31842300295829773, 0.24899396300315857, -0.43664294481277466, 0.020673125982284546, 0.12366380542516708, 0.3979542553424835, 0.18850061297416687, -0.6087424159049988, -0.3400042653083801, 0.41689416766166687, 0.20887503027915955, -0.18480929732322693, -0.13429376482963562, -0.6278533935546875, 0.5122811198234558, 0.6182746291160583, -0.17532210052013397, -0.0753084272146225, -0.2759018838405609, -0.07463309913873672, -0.055877722799777985, 0.8429462313652039, 0.050356823951005936, -0.5374094247817993, -0.036585692316293716, 0.6202101111412048, 0.20188450813293457, -0.2717606723308563, -0.3536073863506317, 0.13245339691638947, -0.4023405611515045, 0.3433837592601776, -0.32002800703048706, -0.16336090862751007, 0.3153172433376312, -0.37809836864471436, 1.0096756219863892, -0.8789429068565369, -0.3428848087787628, 0.43480515480041504, 0.16576240956783295, 0.18010452389717102, 0.37322738766670227, -0.4785461127758026, -0.12349313497543335, -0.5444484353065491, -0.40677767992019653, 0.4836507737636566, 0.2179771065711975, -0.14271597564220428, 0.2716139256954193, -0.23595820367336273, 0.4066922068595886, 0.02349557727575302, 0.6868754029273987, 0.41013407707214355, -0.5729839205741882, -0.34439969062805176, -0.29627445340156555, 0.5673434734344482, 0.1546749770641327, 0.5956628322601318, 0.3222649097442627, 0.03095746785402298, 0.16693487763404846, -0.3423802852630615, -0.472243070602417, -1.212221384048462, -0.2281452715396881, -0.2477196604013443, 1.0501210689544678, -0.01765814796090126, 0.10426834970712662, 0.08437559753656387, -0.09639548510313034, -0.663610577583313, 0.5728793144226074, -0.2656475901603699, -0.08566494286060333, 0.8237023949623108, 0.04192407801747322, -0.31871408224105835, -0.1574000120162964, -0.3711566627025604, 0.11789335310459137, -0.500177800655365, 0.3401937782764435, -0.12502367794513702, -0.7505744695663452, 0.9832265377044678, 0.9197117686271667, -0.8886616230010986, -0.5280476212501526, -0.3664371967315674, -0.31639981269836426, 0.5282658934593201, -0.5831233859062195, -0.028558017686009407, 0.3054434061050415, 0.1379028707742691, 0.3496864438056946, -0.26459887623786926, 0.009246968664228916, 0.3410804867744446, -0.4234488308429718, 0.7583256363868713, -0.4365616738796234, -0.38240310549736023, -0.20351873338222504, -0.8405996561050415, 0.395619660615921, 0.5380387306213379, 0.4255717098712921, 0.34851011633872986, 0.36163678765296936, 0.6969128847122192, -0.5950598120689392, -0.2607210576534271, -0.0988268256187439, 0.10246005654335022, -0.08455032110214233, -0.07072548568248749, -0.09089208394289017, 0.8736735582351685, -0.019861239939928055, -0.33001968264579773, -0.45863571763038635, 0.24665863811969757, 0.3260764479637146, 0.48648446798324585, 0.45775479078292847, -0.5191472172737122, 0.6331360340118408, 0.364094078540802, 0.2425532191991806, -0.25915810465812683, -1.4328703880310059, -0.5604612231254578, -0.1797926127910614, -0.43497082591056824, -0.7949782013893127, -0.19880735874176025, 0.34339073300361633, -0.5906757712364197, -0.7817063331604004, -0.593588650226593, 1.0343326330184937, -0.630348801612854, 0.08707735687494278, -0.2522621154785156, 0.5932695865631104, -0.303354412317276, -0.4705696702003479, -0.17043329775333405, -1.0055748224258423, -0.33323797583580017, 0.9109219312667847, -0.6684888601303101, -0.1060670018196106, 0.21276454627513885, 0.1661873161792755, -0.12176676839590073, -0.12493808567523956, -0.5797982811927795, -0.5777209401130676, 0.03481974080204964, 0.427041620016098, 0.5207313895225525, 0.9233455061912537, 1.0592244863510132, -0.3312283158302307, 0.5321895480155945, 0.403186559677124, -0.46588486433029175, -0.09037116169929504, 0.06297918409109116, 0.8833635449409485, -1.0256847143173218, -0.8385521173477173, -0.5936883091926575, 0.8327919244766235, -0.5220497250556946, -0.11185600608587265, -0.4042902886867523, -0.4002882242202759, -0.4338868260383606, 0.5662286281585693, -0.06839285045862198, 0.6410688161849976, 0.09510087221860886, -0.08011089265346527, 0.15718458592891693, 0.8593897819519043, -0.3252929449081421, 0.0266680009663105, 0.40636852383613586, 0.18634667992591858, 0.23510515689849854, -1.139564871788025, 0.0049834540113806725, 0.57660973072052, -0.5412893295288086, 0.3846237361431122, -0.8417609333992004, -0.16237495839595795, 0.35786306858062744, -0.10566525161266327, 0.24877801537513733, 1.179818034172058, 0.4429222345352173, 1.2625584602355957, -0.10481397807598114, -0.35687729716300964, -0.7716100811958313, -0.6074917912483215, -1.5084576606750488, -0.4694674611091614, 0.20231735706329346, -0.27579426765441895, -0.1015508621931076, -0.1428518444299698, -0.510823667049408, 0.3897852599620819, -0.3052177429199219, 0.7410987615585327, 0.6870468258857727, 1.4850457906723022, -0.07205988466739655, 0.8590545654296875, 0.0663670152425766, 0.419926255941391, 0.918886661529541, -0.1535484343767166, -0.47973519563674927, -0.6821766495704651, 0.11614002287387848, 0.20744317770004272, 0.029045820236206055, 0.28377145528793335, 0.11528017371892929, 0.4210699200630188, 0.18631109595298767, 0.27957412600517273, -0.44916173815727234, 0.32530900835990906, -0.6676602363586426, 0.5579545497894287, 0.23966261744499207, 0.1938687562942505, -1.2183665037155151, 0.8313368558883667, 0.2445807307958603, -1.5168366432189941, -0.46412721276283264, 0.5718328952789307, 0.6195616126060486, -0.13191665709018707, 0.04713089019060135, -0.5439279675483704, 0.3544290065765381, 0.4323946535587311, -0.6933329701423645, 0.1327148675918579, 0.8434123992919922, 0.31946608424186707, -0.19021573662757874, -0.025617409497499466, 0.1324053555727005, 0.5947743058204651, 0.5870316624641418, 0.02945396862924099, 0.9590175747871399, 0.7452943325042725, 0.3755809962749481, 0.33075565099716187, -0.8276732563972473, 0.6178603172302246, 0.23809991776943207, -0.4420000910758972, 0.0759773999452591, 0.46483010053634644, 1.0441582202911377, -0.13334430754184723, -0.9798624515533447, -0.11239781230688095, -0.30875900387763977, -0.3958679437637329, 0.12484098225831985, 0.17258097231388092, 0.8716403841972351, 0.20792962610721588, 0.4609384536743164, 0.38081079721450806, 0.44802728295326233, -0.5999467968940735, -0.05132072791457176, 0.5991345047950745, -0.05172642692923546, -0.47337397933006287, 0.06218786910176277, 0.2639169692993164, -0.38008174300193787, -0.19700033962726593, 0.22408056259155273, -0.509579062461853, 0.9090762138366699, 0.21497558057308197, -0.8272456526756287, -0.0988788828253746, 0.9069868326187134, -0.5684030055999756, 0.10021956264972687, -0.4909715950489044, -0.2829352915287018, -0.49431630969047546, -0.6941285133361816, 0.4105887711048126, -0.013128750026226044, 0.04236895591020584, 0.16892528533935547, 0.4518391788005829, 0.4628313183784485, 0.2968026399612427, 0.7077714204788208, -0.391752153635025, -0.42257046699523926, 0.9998088479042053, -0.09067932516336441, -0.42944613099098206, -0.4002481997013092, 0.07085957378149033, 0.3305068910121918, -0.18131230771541595, 0.146314799785614, -0.22341656684875488, -0.18837249279022217, -0.7034989595413208, 0.25833070278167725, -0.22051841020584106, -0.10154798626899719, -0.5049131512641907, -0.663219690322876, -0.0680391937494278, 0.35912981629371643, -0.11360649764537811, -0.2896425127983093, 0.19010788202285767, -0.18235163390636444, 0.09456069022417068, -0.4873015880584717, -0.4096946716308594, 0.3819124102592468, -0.7761043310165405, 0.5503301620483398, -0.5350474715232849, -0.2065102905035019, 0.22248563170433044, -0.9886937141418457, -0.5641319751739502, 0.38185760378837585, -0.15995223820209503, -0.9248065948486328, 0.6223422884941101, 0.10826979577541351, 0.5832564830780029, 0.8929754495620728, -0.09826645255088806, 0.02091224305331707, 0.10534950345754623, 0.7916130423545837, -0.3606436550617218, 0.12000398337841034, -0.2944236397743225, 0.06268437206745148, 0.050004467368125916, -0.5949127674102783, 0.1985546201467514, -0.10622407495975494, -1.220371961593628, -0.6579472422599792, 0.3962436020374298, -0.12384682893753052, -0.6006620526313782, 0.269955575466156, 0.5889730453491211, -0.3035179078578949, -0.20279470086097717, -0.7301701307296753, -0.26743778586387634, -0.8984467387199402, 0.6438394784927368, -0.2181786596775055, 0.02414008229970932, 0.2818944752216339, -0.173665851354599, 0.7218745350837708, -1.095706820487976, 4.207565784454346, 0.7203404307365417, 0.494525283575058, -0.8765580058097839, 1.2337603569030762, -0.02590346522629261, 0.08335604518651962, -0.05833331122994423, 0.03524542599916458, 0.3087897300720215, -0.5760782361030579, 0.41612374782562256, 0.15557828545570374, -0.3339783251285553, 0.3655257821083069, 0.5654569864273071, -0.34165212512016296, 0.5962363481521606, -0.03741640970110893, -0.9982088804244995, -0.5546139478683472, 0.14392858743667603, -0.49408191442489624, 0.04680914804339409, 0.530284583568573, 0.11670687049627304, 0.5942922830581665, -0.24597029387950897, -0.07056337594985962, -0.2797490358352661, 0.07204391062259674, -1.0230542421340942, 0.19397923350334167, -1.0571365356445312, -0.636512279510498, 0.710983157157898, -0.26722410321235657, -0.710002601146698, 0.08304716646671295, -0.06982828676700592, 0.11163293570280075, 0.003293359186500311, -0.24740134179592133, -0.26534050703048706, -0.21231067180633545, 0.6051796674728394, -0.5615081191062927, 0.35065537691116333, 0.3156316876411438, -0.33632907271385193, 0.47254055738449097, -0.3221544325351715, 0.09066727012395859, -0.29477807879447937, -0.6665392518043518, -0.4762125015258789, 0.25429603457450867, -0.5291664600372314, -0.2745159864425659, 0.1794973909854889, 0.5797978639602661, -0.1738269031047821, 0.0911409854888916, 0.34255489706993103, 0.28951457142829895, 0.7857511043548584, 0.19766007363796234, 0.24190136790275574, 0.023939965292811394, -0.24637861549854279, 0.15995623171329498, -0.3605690598487854, -0.3950173854827881, 0.390157550573349, 0.95766282081604, 0.5726463198661804, -0.5301648378372192, 0.8151860237121582, -0.2868654429912567, -0.5880529284477234, -0.167109414935112, -0.05248376354575157, -0.03058662638068199, -0.23800894618034363, -0.19653034210205078, 0.9289749264717102, -0.6492657661437988, -0.6113197803497314, -0.737201452255249, 0.37213507294654846, 0.7404645085334778, 0.24108970165252686, -0.8201772570610046, 0.2817656993865967, -0.18270069360733032 ]
{"Title": "Improvements in the incidence and survival of cancer and cardiovascular but not infectious disease have driven recent mortality improvements in Scotland: nationwide cohort study of linked hospital admission and death records 2001\u20132016", "Authors": "Timmers Paul RHJ, Kerssens Joannes J, Minton Jon W, Grant Ian, Wilson James F, Campbell Harry, Fischbacher Colin M, Joshi Peter K", "Abstract": "Abstract Objectives To identify the causes and future trends underpinning improvements in life expectancy in Scotland and quantify the relative contributions of disease incidence and survival. Design Population-based study. Setting Linked secondary care and mortality records across Scotland. Participants 1,967,130 individuals born between 1905 and 1965, and resident in Scotland throughout 2001\u20132016. Main outcome measures Hospital admission rates and survival in the five years following admission for 28 diseases, stratified by sex and socioeconomic status. Results The five hospital admission diagnoses associated with the greatest burden of death subsequent to admission were \u201cInfluenza and pneumonia\u201d, \u201cSymptoms and signs involving the circulatory and respiratory systems\u201d, \u201cMalignant neoplasm of respiratory and intrathoracic organs\u201d, \u201cSymptoms and signs involving the digestive system and abdomen\u201d, and \u201cGeneral symptoms and signs\u201d. Using disease trends, we modelled a mean mortality hazard ratio of 0.737 (95% CI 0.730\u20130.745) across decades of birth, equivalent to a life extension of \u223c3 years per decade. This improvement was 61% (30%\u201393%) accounted for by improvements in disease survival after hospitalisation (principally cancer) with the remainder accounted for by a fall in hospitalisation incidence (principally heart disease and cancer). In contrast, deteriorations in the incidence and survival of infectious diseases reduced mortality improvements by 9% (\u223c3.3 months per decade). Overall, health-driven mortality improvements were slightly greater for men than women (due to greater falls in disease incidence), and generally similar across socioeconomic deciles. We project mortality improvements will continue over the next decade but will slow down by 21% because much of the progress in disease survival has already been achieved. Conclusion Morbidity improvements broadly explain observed improvements in overall mortality, with progress on the prevention and treatment of heart disease and cancer making the most significant contributions. The gaps between men and women\u2019s morbidity and mortality are closing, but the gap between socioeconomic groups is not. A slowing trend in improvements in morbidity may explain the stalling in improvements of period life expectancies observed in recent studies in the UK. However, our modelled slowing of improvements could be offset if we achieve even faster improvements in the major diseases contributing to the burden of death, or if we improve prevention and survival of diseases which have deteriorated recently, such as infectious disease, in the future. Summary box What is already known on this topic Long term improvements in Scottish mortality have slowed down recently, while life expectancy inequalities between socioeconomic classes are increasing. Deaths attributed to ischaemic heart disease and stroke in Scotland have declined in the last two decades. What this study adds Gains in life expectancy can largely be attributed to improvements in cancer survival and falls in incidence of cancer and cardiovascular disease. The hospitalisation rate and survival of several infectious diseases have deteriorated, and for urinary infections, this decline has been more rapid in more socioeconomically deprived classes. Improvements in morbidity are projected to slow down, with much progress in survival of heart disease and cancer already achieved, and align with the recently observed slow-down in mortality improvements.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003012"}
10.1101/19008409
[ -0.20582419633865356, 0.23176805675029755, -0.44243669509887695, 0.8960258960723877, -0.7272765040397644, -0.6989328265190125, -0.5869839191436768, 0.07135607302188873, -0.3952469825744629, 1.1502490043640137, -0.5082741975784302, -0.1967095136642456, 0.23280689120292664, 0.4698534905910492, -0.2745117247104645, -0.1285678595304489, -0.653507649898529, 0.06461760401725769, -0.3319363296031952, 0.6164305210113525, 0.17863017320632935, 0.6457182765007019, -0.9487218260765076, -0.02656003274023533, -1.079174518585205, 0.8619003891944885, 0.054414279758930206, -0.22256621718406677, 0.9384047985076904, 0.9008903503417969, 0.1449631303548813, -0.4750935733318329, 0.38654017448425293, -0.9154291152954102, -0.04159798473119736, -0.6132399439811707, 0.40419524908065796, -0.8096240162849426, -0.007843926548957825, -0.5254300236701965, 0.33681654930114746, -0.41033685207366943, -0.035638559609651566, -0.49637678265571594, -0.9974797368049622, 0.22018243372440338, 0.0346255861222744, 0.32607394456863403, -0.06369658559560776, -0.04322148859500885, -0.2731356918811798, 0.5659565925598145, -0.1902368813753128, -0.482024610042572, 0.023845907300710678, 0.794480562210083, -0.11175120621919632, -0.536663830280304, -0.48854461312294006, 0.6993278861045837, 0.1406659036874771, -0.5053868293762207, -0.058083027601242065, -0.7837788462638855, 0.4307643175125122, 0.2411893606185913, -0.30808529257774353, -0.23469117283821106, 0.052578553557395935, -0.41505590081214905, -0.25387826561927795, -0.37386220693588257, -1.2124782800674438, -0.514323353767395, 0.07037413120269775, 0.12616980075836182, 0.4549679160118103, -1.002225399017334, 0.3593551516532898, 0.2606256902217865, -0.22837838530540466, 0.4995165765285492, 0.3510720729827881, 0.054624754935503006, -1.0614206790924072, 0.48867693543434143, -0.1741466075181961, -0.5230908989906311, 0.31390756368637085, 0.7926251888275146, -0.06775236874818802, 0.2795170247554779, -0.05801163241267204, 0.28797516226768494, -0.40328559279441833, 0.7572942972183228, -0.34055158495903015, -0.26831144094467163, -0.11424762010574341, 0.07876797765493393, 0.863092303276062, 0.45119789242744446, 0.034014344215393066, 0.8738992810249329, -0.6576480269432068, 0.9502382874488831, 0.9034364819526672, -0.1808415800333023, -0.39436110854148865, -0.83155357837677, -0.18204379081726074, -0.09890154004096985, -0.12225138396024704, -0.034529466181993484, 0.7656195163726807, -0.39707961678504944, 0.3996359705924988, 0.07095479220151901, -0.060650669038295746, 0.9752116203308105, -0.020177142694592476, 0.01898163929581642, 1.35330331325531, -0.5366353392601013, 0.3429288864135742, -0.6844351887702942, 0.7720775604248047, 0.47165730595588684, -0.7608794569969177, -0.5523380041122437, 0.09493369609117508, -0.9787993431091309, -0.19035963714122772, 0.35510388016700745, -0.5723543763160706, 0.5427142977714539, 0.34059226512908936, 1.56419837474823, 1.1393916606903076, 0.33452486991882324, -0.42681437730789185, 0.8231543898582458, -0.503406286239624, 0.9298295378684998, 0.32913151383399963, 0.8725223541259766, -0.8870418667793274, -0.742800772190094, 0.08599769324064255, 0.1743098348379135, -0.2848813533782959, -0.19962282478809357, -0.40259096026420593, 0.26742857694625854, -0.31799501180648804, 0.8403590321540833, -0.2663666307926178, 0.7376465797424316, -1.1733815670013428, 0.7361103296279907, -0.8250080943107605, 0.28194159269332886, 0.3399108648300171, 0.42534878849983215, -0.6553257703781128, 0.27555057406425476, -0.7354750037193298, 0.809890627861023, 0.09635987877845764, -0.6700488328933716, 1.4243346452713013, 0.21635490655899048, -0.22871547937393188, 0.42547646164894104, 0.45158764719963074, 0.9762649536132812, 0.11835215240716934, -0.11439544707536697, 0.8173491954803467, 0.7779244184494019, -0.06235393509268761, 0.789850652217865, 0.39557960629463196, 0.659263551235199, 0.5735884308815002, 0.5911749601364136, -0.3767288327217102, -0.12932144105434418, -0.1707872748374939, -0.24839910864830017, -0.0022882448974996805, 0.6315926313400269, -0.8750535845756531, 0.7898282408714294, -0.03889697790145874, -0.4861935079097748, -0.10406467318534851, -0.04600737616419792, 0.6672530174255371, -0.2582860589027405, -0.6057233214378357, 0.3372505307197571, -0.6151496767997742, 0.3101276159286499, -0.008269371464848518, 0.7223262786865234, 0.0816088542342186, 0.4568699300289154, -0.971633791923523, 0.20213793218135834, 0.5968549847602844, -0.2878741919994354, -0.7209111452102661, 0.16818779706954956, 0.6605491042137146, -0.26694294810295105, 0.322470486164093, 0.1278170347213745, -0.3560883700847626, -0.5232412219047546, -0.2237369865179062, -0.1637309193611145, 0.3548179268836975, -0.0012879937421530485, 0.31534644961357117, 0.09782350808382034, 0.4731082022190094, 0.9936727285385132, -0.16525882482528687, -0.3693799376487732, 0.1475881040096283, 0.474158376455307, 0.234172061085701, 0.8062502145767212, 0.17018447816371918, -0.31436511874198914, 0.2780677378177643, 0.39270317554473877, -0.026440750807523727, 0.8535659313201904, 0.906295895576477, 0.4684414267539978, 0.23926100134849548, -0.18748386204242706, -0.5581793785095215, 0.6984279155731201, -0.17238546907901764, 0.29713141918182373, -0.4293154776096344, -0.03996596485376358, -0.2988220453262329, 0.571014940738678, 0.3074426054954529, 0.44892147183418274, -0.9002578854560852, -0.12471230328083038, 1.0039689540863037, -0.17896343767642975, -0.6555410027503967, 0.2641660273075104, -0.17681440711021423, 0.2553238272666931, -0.3362637460231781, 0.011605456471443176, 0.6539016962051392, 0.9743226170539856, -0.11671126633882523, 0.7506746649742126, -0.27725833654403687, 0.6143237948417664, -0.8155834078788757, -0.2841348350048065, -0.9076549410820007, -0.914073646068573, -1.2041304111480713, 0.5719882249832153, 0.515304446220398, 0.36018937826156616, 0.2085440307855606, -0.07060239464044571, -0.1254974901676178, -0.05760267376899719, 0.48623204231262207, 0.19045603275299072, 0.599994957447052, -0.5547486543655396, -1.0662628412246704, -0.1493290364742279, -0.46409809589385986, 0.28723791241645813, 0.4554259777069092, -0.04128141701221466, -0.6497595906257629, -0.6597052216529846, 0.45869341492652893, -1.190422773361206, 0.16207760572433472, 0.5483739972114563, -0.40863797068595886, -0.195575550198555, 0.5012016892433167, 0.2233273684978485, 0.05334877595305443, -0.4116170406341553, -1.2107449769973755, 0.4221399128437042, -0.1982422024011612, 0.6601769328117371, 0.08758103847503662, -0.08642331510782242, 0.1330529898405075, -0.03972025215625763, -0.4997923970222473, 0.8874557018280029, -0.7914419770240784, -0.2077573835849762, 0.3698151409626007, -0.586763322353363, 0.538292407989502, -0.29939159750938416, -0.991210401058197, -0.049400702118873596, -0.4368687868118286, -0.49519607424736023, 0.04923578351736069, 0.30989760160446167, 0.427890419960022, -1.4943591356277466, 0.15906165540218353, -0.8093258142471313, -0.6273636221885681, -0.15470658242702484, -0.3887700140476227, 0.37141865491867065, -0.06261011213064194, -0.059640176594257355, -1.0730082988739014, 0.43962937593460083, 0.35794711112976074, 0.3708576560020447, 0.0005063657881692052, -0.8227337598800659, -0.17318560183048248, -0.13901545107364655, -0.21311192214488983, 0.6174333095550537, -0.058028534054756165, -0.25505486130714417, -0.37755799293518066, -0.2915760278701782, 0.06807100027799606, 0.005372794345021248, 0.7451350092887878, -0.10658389329910278, -0.4711366891860962, 0.7550945281982422, -0.41586944460868835, 0.12995754182338715, 0.1941952407360077, -0.1487884372472763, 0.2410135418176651, -0.38478076457977295, -0.04501136764883995, 0.6303756833076477, -0.4344451129436493, -0.921534538269043, 0.6874624490737915, 0.13999000191688538, 0.5266721844673157, 0.058199185878038406, 0.281452476978302, -0.14845170080661774, 0.0284119825810194, 0.3368615508079529, -0.06394559890031815, -0.28133976459503174, 0.5003855228424072, 0.4609481394290924, 0.6349412202835083, -0.8897213935852051, 0.13606129586696625, 0.402525395154953, 1.0645849704742432, 0.615670382976532, 0.08067767322063446, -0.3147105872631073, -1.3313506841659546, 0.2463037222623825, 0.2959313690662384, -0.3375576436519623, 0.32542961835861206, 0.06939054280519485, 0.2039446234703064, -0.5080070495605469, -0.9422887563705444, -0.6690129637718201, 0.02290992997586727, 0.8476454615592957, 0.8125399351119995, -0.35789936780929565, 0.9651013016700745, -0.44024744629859924, 0.9062756896018982, 0.5904597640037537, 0.12096232175827026, 0.08879624307155609, -0.725480854511261, 0.32554417848587036, 0.02420276403427124, -0.9779862761497498, -0.69118732213974, -0.46081599593162537, -0.08026252686977386, 0.16580730676651, 0.07277406007051468, -0.33086711168289185, -0.5376643538475037, -0.5841084122657776, -0.8659622073173523, -0.6913217902183533, 0.27777910232543945, -0.06476559489965439, 0.21118777990341187, -0.12813395261764526, 0.8727073669433594, -0.3033340871334076, 0.4277651309967041, -0.662770688533783, 1.0263445377349854, 0.9488745927810669, -0.40532222390174866, -0.7871236801147461, -0.0212401170283556, -0.1002081036567688, -0.7617491483688354, 0.5172045230865479, 0.04075293615460396, -0.2107020914554596, 0.4513334035873413, -1.19953191280365, -0.23517383635044098, -0.26033416390419006, 0.11048717051744461, -0.763909101486206, 0.6524182558059692, 0.399493008852005, 0.9954066276550293, -0.05028968304395676, -0.1311250776052475, -0.7546346783638, -0.0950634628534317, -1.0115572214126587, 0.16565513610839844, -0.2716958522796631, -0.01608860492706299, 0.2685863673686981, 0.120791956782341, 0.30203527212142944, -0.5349259376525879, -0.32441404461860657, -0.42641571164131165, -0.1877516210079193, 0.013779287226498127, 0.08743218332529068, 0.06589263677597046, 1.03397798538208, -0.7806970477104187, -0.3742228150367737, 0.9882399439811707, -0.023389767855405807, -0.6336917281150818, 0.5902977585792542, 0.07071660459041595, -0.6022119522094727, 0.2093750685453415, -0.22562463581562042, 0.12228447198867798, 0.740512490272522, -0.5591392517089844, 0.5479875802993774, 0.18626928329467773, 0.41798579692840576, -0.6402484774589539, 0.7652502655982971, -0.6690744161605835, -0.438664048910141, -0.1177426129579544, -0.07078977674245834, -1.1761337518692017, 0.5869508981704712, 0.02073371224105358, -0.28229373693466187, -0.02685028500854969, 0.22468292713165283, -0.8655936121940613, -0.32691195607185364, -0.3119690418243408, 0.09040779620409012, 0.13068701326847076, 0.2600410282611847, 0.5028441548347473, -0.9903856515884399, -1.060799241065979, -0.01114676147699356, 0.7014421224594116, -0.5979387164115906, -0.36061084270477295, 0.40088286995887756, -0.0329308956861496, 0.08937588334083557, 0.0626271665096283, 0.4703342318534851, -0.1346590220928192, 0.02518923394382, -0.5542387366294861, -0.05683884397149086, 0.16876929998397827, -0.5219297409057617, 0.7034521698951721, 0.17607524991035461, 0.0820523127913475, -0.16662414371967316, 0.092329241335392, 0.2011648416519165, 0.3236449062824249, 0.5829529166221619, 0.00583457900211215, -0.49528640508651733, -0.29767024517059326, -0.7425966858863831, 0.35064518451690674, -1.1312817335128784, 0.07900482416152954, 0.26574957370758057, -0.2958431839942932, -0.24708272516727448, 0.3295441269874573, 0.2852877974510193, 0.4369509518146515, 0.2986816465854645, -0.26077476143836975, 0.05254817381501198, -0.5086281299591064, -0.02628842182457447, 0.029182784259319305, -1.148908257484436, 0.030425772070884705, 0.6766052842140198, 0.004113333765417337, -0.18754372000694275, -0.6732572913169861, 0.640820324420929, 0.7815673351287842, -0.25120481848716736, 0.08105020225048065, -0.6850404739379883, -0.15393775701522827, 0.852052628993988, -0.3091205954551697, -0.3095705509185791, -1.118165373802185, 0.8515840768814087, 0.06339249759912491, 0.5207334160804749, -0.26422399282455444, -0.36378076672554016, 0.36324483156204224, -0.22961238026618958, 1.333258032798767, -0.23277883231639862, 1.0487290620803833, -0.12215718626976013, -0.08981387317180634, 0.43019479513168335, 0.36110246181488037, -0.7425675392150879, -0.8157231211662292, -0.4734429121017456, -0.5563169121742249, 0.5754034519195557, 0.5039100646972656, 0.1424436867237091, 0.5869495272636414, 0.018299207091331482, -0.015001815743744373, 0.025933541357517242, 1.3623656034469604, 0.6541532278060913, -0.6970138549804688, 0.08025489002466202, 0.045283712446689606, 1.039870023727417, -0.019157450646162033, 0.40875786542892456, -0.012835511937737465, 0.0004035340389236808, 0.39267995953559875, -0.4134402871131897, -0.8444291949272156, -0.5072035789489746, -0.012751542031764984, 0.35782262682914734, 0.8415047526359558, -0.1621595025062561, 0.281477153301239, -0.11740042269229889, -0.1944701224565506, -0.2415408194065094, 0.3706442415714264, -0.06539465487003326, 0.5993372797966003, 0.8720211386680603, -0.20518067479133606, -0.5488914251327515, 0.5067740678787231, -0.07552416622638702, 0.1469874531030655, -0.6259116530418396, 0.00486256368458271, 0.685964047908783, -1.3611984252929688, 0.08498355001211166, 0.8330163955688477, -0.21744398772716522, -1.0294193029403687, -0.9868025183677673, -0.37832146883010864, -0.03619571775197983, -0.5339014530181885, -0.36039456725120544, 0.8070496320724487, 0.0788145363330841, 0.6535605192184448, 0.16180460155010223, -0.07622919976711273, 0.9052850008010864, -0.5002407431602478, 0.7356319427490234, -1.1293028593063354, -0.3114277720451355, 0.16056515276432037, 0.4267667531967163, 0.08407145738601685, 0.5202212333679199, 0.021980037912726402, 1.0248759984970093, 0.235873281955719, 0.5441666841506958, -1.070073127746582, -0.4649101793766022, -0.07843629270792007, -0.037892457097768784, 0.23389649391174316, 0.6246553659439087, -0.03415047004818916, 0.6136536002159119, 0.03827197104692459, -0.7058624625205994, -0.17297744750976562, 0.05027231201529503, 0.2361825555562973, 1.1050541400909424, 0.014199717901647091, -0.25936877727508545, 0.7185567617416382, -0.13900843262672424, 0.23708879947662354, -0.568570077419281, -0.9490433931350708, -0.6541048288345337, -0.6230719685554504, -0.03529840335249901, -0.5370257496833801, 0.22672250866889954, -0.44031116366386414, 0.09475887566804886, -0.6319597959518433, -0.5855103731155396, 0.591863751411438, -0.19527602195739746, -0.5159526467323303, -0.30560123920440674, 0.17561174929141998, -0.3305447995662689, -0.7225478291511536, -0.9323340654373169, -0.7744631767272949, -0.15391884744167328, 1.0852470397949219, -0.33078840374946594, -0.634583055973053, 0.4232165217399597, 0.18749460577964783, 0.2660846710205078, 0.04703580215573311, -0.3649285137653351, -0.7909314632415771, 0.102251797914505, 0.9256570935249329, 0.43986210227012634, -0.153952956199646, 1.0708301067352295, -0.12578526139259338, 0.5129864811897278, 0.4582451581954956, -0.24973341822624207, -0.3160370886325836, -0.17483258247375488, 0.10251516103744507, -0.6885520219802856, -0.3255546987056732, -0.5357310175895691, -0.20944732427597046, -1.049959659576416, -0.6367762684822083, -0.3138095736503601, -0.30505549907684326, 0.1295003741979599, -0.2697841227054596, -0.23106202483177185, 0.39778828620910645, -0.5116901993751526, 0.27249687910079956, 0.5252766609191895, 0.8770343065261841, 0.42218655347824097, -0.7325251698493958, 0.2325144112110138, 0.21247607469558716, 0.26368221640586853, -0.7137894630432129, 0.278400719165802, 0.6022269129753113, -0.3513931334018707, 0.7651205658912659, -0.579060971736908, -0.2724652588367462, 0.0033673294819891453, -0.511691153049469, -0.016458535566926003, 0.5509251952171326, -0.05823003500699997, 0.10952076315879822, 0.22121082246303558, 0.33969295024871826, -0.6419426202774048, -0.41295555233955383, -0.8848963975906372, -0.3692918121814728, 0.27074018120765686, -0.15764102339744568, -0.03530222922563553, -0.4580559730529785, -0.21203391253948212, -0.214623361825943, -0.2553423047065735, 0.3917989134788513, -0.5273887515068054, 0.2458292692899704, 0.056795384734869, 0.7823320627212524, 0.4404265284538269, -0.05162220448255539, 0.22391019761562347, -0.024939900264143944, -0.963947594165802, -0.3782010078430176, 0.3046426773071289, 0.7943900227546692, -0.0007264282903634012, -0.37996506690979004, -0.511380136013031, 0.30538395047187805, -0.08494317531585693, -0.663596510887146, 0.02612680196762085, -0.17066705226898193, -0.031572628766298294, 0.07705339044332504, -0.4829503893852234, -0.30215346813201904, -0.11582669615745544, 0.4653785824775696, -0.16975116729736328, -1.374883770942688, -0.6986167430877686, -0.12998121976852417, 0.27496537566185, -0.5188599824905396, -0.1962742954492569, -0.5819095373153687, 0.35976463556289673, -0.014088408090174198, 0.20826654136180878, 0.13711956143379211, -0.14845745265483856, -0.4726735055446625, 0.23478645086288452, 0.26441678404808044, 0.23653095960617065, 0.8795291781425476, 0.4216778576374054, -0.6777907609939575, 0.07299929857254028, 0.1688733696937561, 0.254358172416687, 0.2742345929145813, -0.8529549837112427, 0.5444111227989197, -0.0782620832324028, -0.7669910192489624, 0.7053548097610474, 0.26829174160957336, 1.1349852085113525, 0.4623180627822876, -0.4531453251838684, 0.44284892082214355, -0.7784354090690613, -0.29442092776298523, 0.4311450123786926, 0.13220709562301636, 0.2999934256076813, -0.0740906223654747, 0.27022868394851685, 0.6892557144165039, 0.6395444869995117, 0.16212709248065948, 0.014728818088769913, 0.34051766991615295, 0.0026895031332969666, -0.20902222394943237, -0.33846792578697205, 0.2456948310136795, 0.24068494141101837, -0.1831471472978592, -0.20704318583011627, 0.1011032834649086, -0.26793691515922546, 0.4742845594882965, -0.4835127294063568, 0.3068299889564514, 0.9346728920936584, 0.1305101066827774, -0.2648316025733948, -0.5624968409538269, 0.2804219722747803, -0.6294278502464294, -0.20706863701343536, 1.0544190406799316, 0.5069949626922607, 0.14312244951725006, 0.34011343121528625, 0.07477850466966629, 0.43268099427223206, 0.3983999192714691, 0.6418513059616089, 0.313159316778183, 0.026873525232076645, 0.8563914895057678, -0.20852728188037872, -0.18508018553256989, -0.4618901014328003, -0.012449849396944046, -0.6059070825576782, -0.33602428436279297, -0.04930585250258446, 0.10391812026500702, -0.6679468154907227, -0.7912259101867676, 0.5932778716087341, -0.12828242778778076, -0.3303901255130768, -0.4921756088733673, -0.21394316852092743, -0.6481196284294128, 0.13077877461910248, -0.5870699882507324, 0.6006088256835938, -0.012962818145751953, 0.31120947003364563, -0.18011878430843353, -0.3578583896160126, -0.05642559379339218, 0.02629404328763485, 0.17539839446544647, 0.1852446049451828, -0.6798717379570007, 0.14383071660995483, -0.31083622574806213, -1.121221899986267, -0.27757421135902405, -0.10356012731790543, -0.22335253655910492, -0.658233106136322, 0.030940691009163857, 0.4562455713748932, 0.8047905564308167, 0.19505621492862701, 0.16419656574726105, 0.05941266566514969, 0.5456656217575073, 0.1134980246424675, -0.4785701036453247, 0.6251095533370972, 0.28798919916152954, -0.13260608911514282, -0.372909277677536, 0.056737713515758514, 0.5525476336479187, -0.013544654473662376, -0.9741551280021667, -0.36733686923980713, 0.3146526515483856, 0.16430562734603882, -0.7157950401306152, -0.707314133644104, 0.3896777033805847, 0.2922288179397583, -0.362623929977417, -0.7253515720367432, -0.6023940443992615, -0.5046701431274414, 0.8789702653884888, -0.10643959790468216, -0.1609676480293274, 0.16019383072853088, -0.03203357383608818, 0.28470665216445923, -1.050657033920288, 4.103306770324707, 0.2724224627017975, 0.835244357585907, -0.30171141028404236, 0.26273855566978455, -0.3357153534889221, 0.7378947138786316, 0.12497545778751373, -0.12905974686145782, -0.027987394481897354, -0.5161834359169006, -0.0051845065318048, 0.10630114376544952, -0.4495431184768677, 1.0924241542816162, 0.314236044883728, -0.6064445376396179, 0.6051296591758728, -0.13310746848583221, -0.9031370878219604, -1.025673270225525, -0.00893755815923214, -0.19686830043792725, 0.5102159976959229, 0.22187550365924835, -0.13321362435817719, 0.6813687086105347, -0.013193037360906601, 0.18752777576446533, -0.23066985607147217, 0.31110215187072754, -0.6320245265960693, 0.6422524452209473, -1.4724535942077637, -0.6836639642715454, -0.03934941813349724, 0.5521771311759949, -0.4750981628894806, -0.11235130578279495, 0.051579102873802185, 0.23859207332134247, 0.23596782982349396, 0.1945626437664032, -0.08070522546768188, -0.3282882273197174, 0.6352783441543579, -0.708720862865448, 0.4457232654094696, 0.8841794729232788, -0.05895006284117699, 0.07873748987913132, -0.3256099224090576, 0.272184282541275, 0.3167654275894165, -0.8337798118591309, -0.31424546241760254, -0.23612752556800842, -0.7653960585594177, 0.10368461161851883, -0.041649360209703445, 1.1192883253097534, -0.5089398622512817, -0.04669969901442528, -0.06410183757543564, 0.9832277297973633, 0.22581976652145386, -0.19619818031787872, 0.1208813339471817, -0.6168668270111084, -0.7376247048377991, -0.14511698484420776, -0.17597775161266327, 0.10892432183027267, -0.8463143706321716, 1.018943428993225, 0.3971676528453827, -0.25912025570869446, 0.3799140751361847, -0.3988666832447052, -0.7848106622695923, 0.33963194489479065, 0.3652227818965912, 0.41216179728507996, -0.22542215883731842, 0.13020914793014526, 0.7931113839149475, -0.34188225865364075, -0.2349340319633484, 0.021540535613894463, -0.03318920359015465, 1.0198644399642944, -0.16091199219226837, 0.03313596546649933, 0.7044759392738342, -0.3075050711631775 ]
{"Title": "The role of prison-based interventions for hepatitis C virus (HCV) micro-elimination among people who inject drugs in Montr\u00e9al, Canada", "Authors": "Godin Arnaud, Kronfli Nadine, Cox Joseph, Alary Michel, Maheu-Giroux Mathieu", "Abstract": "Abstract Background In Canada, hepatitis C virus (HCV) transmission primarily occurs among people who inject drugs (PWID) and people with experience in the prison system bare a disproportionate HCV burden. These overlapping groups of individuals have been identified as a priority populations for HCV micro-elimination in Canada, a country currently not on track to achieve its elimination targets. Considering the missed opportunities to intervene in provincial prisons, this study aims to estimate the population-level impact of prison-based interventions and post-release risk reduction strategies on HCV transmission among PWID in high HCV-burdened Canadian city, Montr\u00e9al. Methods A dynamic HCV transmission model among PWID was developed and calibrated to community and prison bio-behavioural surveys in Montr\u00e9al. The, the relative impact of prison-based testing and treatment or post-release linkage to care, alone or in combination with risk reduction strategies, was estimated from 2018 to 2030, and compared to counterfactual status quo scenario. Results Testing and linkage to care interventions implemented over 2018-30 could lead to the greatest declines in prevalence (23%; 95% Credible interval(CrI):17\u201331%), incidence (20%; 95%CrI: 10\u201328%), and prevent the most new chronic infections (8%; 95%CrI: 4\u201311%). Testing and treatment in prison could decrease prevalence, incidence, and fraction of prevented new chronic infections. Combining test and linkage to care with risk reduction measures could further its epidemiological impact, preventing 10% (95%CrI: 5\u201316%) of new chronic infections. When implemented concomitantly with community-based treatment scale-up, both prison-based interventions had synergistic effects, averting a higher fraction of new chronic infections. Conclusion Offering HCV testing and post-release linkage to care in provincial prisons, where incarcerations are frequent and sentences short, could change the course of the HCV epidemic in Montr\u00e9al. Integration of post-release risk reduction measures and community-based treatment scale-up could also increase the impact of these interventions.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008409"}
10.1101/2019.12.14.19014506
[ -0.6084615588188171, -0.029106231406331062, 0.16941332817077637, 0.5083367228507996, -0.5114578604698181, -1.072871208190918, -0.1479032188653946, -0.03616476058959961, -0.8649396896362305, 0.7092856764793396, -0.4273563623428345, -0.644827663898468, 0.33758118748664856, -0.43857598304748535, -0.4470444619655609, 0.04489266872406006, -0.8967931866645813, 0.08907274156808853, 0.2754574716091156, -0.08752857148647308, 0.5372061729431152, 0.9180105924606323, -0.6857903599739075, 0.05509035661816597, -0.30850428342819214, 0.6252201795578003, 0.20920498669147491, -0.41092973947525024, 1.0310319662094116, 0.10330860316753387, -0.17495355010032654, -0.1389174908399582, 0.5617636442184448, -0.53394615650177, -0.5269370079040527, -0.0014288777019828558, 0.7515324950218201, -1.2078675031661987, 0.22396521270275116, 0.0772581696510315, 0.2998785972595215, 0.1699385941028595, 0.14797671139240265, -0.9742194414138794, -0.3477984666824341, -0.20463773608207703, -0.1269495040178299, -0.4297909140586853, -0.03601054474711418, -0.46172669529914856, -0.7864865064620972, -0.3727455735206604, 0.2207450568675995, -0.5434298515319824, 0.15510471165180206, -0.3305267095565796, 0.7629101276397705, -0.27366548776626587, -0.6465539932250977, -0.2567606568336487, -0.16575616598129272, 0.087127685546875, 0.4020276963710785, -0.8015998601913452, 0.8173609972000122, 0.6634408831596375, 0.15138643980026245, -0.05270642042160034, -0.5982479453086853, 0.8179547786712646, -0.5176830291748047, -0.37603598833084106, -0.18524691462516785, 0.1702900230884552, -0.19595855474472046, -0.11368677765130997, -0.14578965306282043, -0.6041818261146545, 0.5939387083053589, -0.3044201135635376, -0.049008097499608994, -0.47535789012908936, 0.38506850600242615, 0.474816232919693, -0.7736092209815979, 0.23320473730564117, 0.17992962896823883, 0.3516715466976166, -0.16392382979393005, 0.7666414976119995, 0.5300040245056152, -0.17715610563755035, 0.7303832173347473, 0.26478293538093567, 0.43245673179626465, 1.2835570573806763, -0.06195436418056488, -0.40840408205986023, 0.350130170583725, -0.30128052830696106, 0.1156705841422081, -0.01582048460841179, -0.12041966617107391, 0.4768843650817871, -0.8699530363082886, 0.6154600977897644, 0.5171008110046387, -0.2675900161266327, -0.14195352792739868, -0.6566191911697388, -0.16663388907909393, -0.23247429728507996, -0.009338445030152798, -0.20062464475631714, 0.47473257780075073, 0.3782515823841095, 0.11846248060464859, 0.11020568013191223, -0.7155272960662842, 0.38175177574157715, -0.17295494675636292, 0.4585331082344055, 0.3139309287071228, -0.3540218770503998, 0.0034734925720840693, -0.12326550483703613, 0.6758637428283691, 0.5895374417304993, -0.4870120584964752, -0.3070067763328552, -0.10808009654283524, -0.7505094408988953, 0.2630891501903534, 1.1805669069290161, -0.11226993054151535, -0.19051027297973633, -0.0287651214748621, 0.6008018851280212, 0.09149394929409027, -0.7723683714866638, -0.4311141073703766, 0.1754874736070633, -0.13774491846561432, 1.0910303592681885, -0.518436849117279, 0.872532844543457, -0.8421041369438171, -0.6357899904251099, -0.8273899555206299, -0.5063844919204712, -0.3673233687877655, 0.10430695861577988, 0.21540704369544983, -0.24149169027805328, 0.41604024171829224, -0.2702375054359436, -0.41973787546157837, 0.09946775436401367, 0.18514542281627655, 0.17766085267066956, 0.33643874526023865, 0.6249263286590576, -0.339073121547699, 1.363242268562317, -0.24724066257476807, 0.08689728379249573, 0.09745366126298904, -0.04193714261054993, 0.0445108562707901, -0.7285996079444885, 0.7455759048461914, 0.17369908094406128, -0.755362331867218, 0.0188398826867342, 0.7619554996490479, 0.46010226011276245, 0.4868229031562805, 0.08137789368629456, 0.3633260726928711, 0.08471956849098206, -0.5618678331375122, 0.131272554397583, 0.7978036403656006, 0.7512709498405457, 0.04570463299751282, -0.6463675498962402, -0.5409266352653503, -1.0173313617706299, -0.16851864755153656, 0.09544702619314194, 0.48325762152671814, 0.3859378695487976, -0.8835556507110596, 1.377060890197754, 0.647105872631073, 0.5449222326278687, -0.328690767288208, 0.24904698133468628, 0.8838094472885132, -0.3161666989326477, -0.3271465003490448, 0.7296473979949951, -0.6904323101043701, 0.47983017563819885, 0.5775139927864075, 0.9490922689437866, 0.8375808596611023, 0.7131808996200562, 0.16354236006736755, -0.057223305106163025, 0.3903518617153168, -0.2843265235424042, -0.010848360136151314, -0.08346696197986603, 0.6653693914413452, -0.6502395868301392, 0.3407045304775238, 0.41894271969795227, -0.4586130380630493, 0.29382219910621643, 0.19579245150089264, -0.2685222625732422, 0.24659381806850433, 0.49061304330825806, -0.5073294043540955, 0.14682607352733612, 0.16760338842868805, -0.3347037434577942, 0.3423554003238678, -0.2505953907966614, 0.3802284002304077, 0.510870635509491, -0.015458439476788044, 0.46321097016334534, 0.4273110032081604, 0.22096073627471924, 0.33885815739631653, 0.32864630222320557, 0.15614941716194153, 0.2649373710155487, 0.31864070892333984, 0.24801991879940033, 0.8737417459487915, 0.22213158011436462, -0.053683433681726456, 0.325947642326355, -0.7393866777420044, -0.1509396731853485, 0.2796150743961334, 0.24933871626853943, -0.7570602297782898, 0.5536240339279175, 0.41212916374206543, -0.3422054052352905, -0.8681236505508423, -0.06439681351184845, -0.13130244612693787, 0.40393418073654175, 0.18697239458560944, -0.6719202995300293, -0.23001763224601746, 0.804680585861206, 0.17286337912082672, -0.27017948031425476, 0.8364450931549072, 0.6071791052818298, -0.1941780149936676, 0.9138569235801697, 0.32084935903549194, -0.3272936940193176, -0.08513142168521881, -0.46782928705215454, -1.249599814414978, -0.48817187547683716, -1.0251790285110474, 0.37473180890083313, 0.11686526983976364, -0.39113175868988037, 0.2083059549331665, 0.07994022965431213, 0.4999517798423767, -0.3828364312648773, 0.2504673898220062, 0.5472751259803772, 0.6826481223106384, -0.2135688215494156, -0.5767910480499268, 0.050371281802654266, 0.05998916178941727, 0.2563418447971344, -0.23448406159877777, -0.5982999801635742, -0.4780064523220062, -1.6157344579696655, 1.1795827150344849, -0.8558054566383362, -0.11199639737606049, -0.33907800912857056, -0.09957960247993469, -0.39042389392852783, 0.21596090495586395, -0.6355873346328735, 0.013562977313995361, 0.043921761214733124, -1.3755452632904053, 0.1965036541223526, 0.34216633439064026, 0.6780624389648438, 0.8277360200881958, 0.22636747360229492, -0.29580679535865784, 0.6312690377235413, 0.1985127478837967, -0.18698927760124207, -1.0768359899520874, 0.5379614233970642, 0.260271281003952, -0.28739482164382935, 0.43322014808654785, -0.9520959258079529, -0.4624954164028168, 0.055778488516807556, -0.09145236760377884, -0.41330012679100037, -0.21362675726413727, 0.37282896041870117, 0.5632219314575195, -0.8652714490890503, -0.022254204377532005, -0.4986996650695801, -0.8424058556556702, 0.24540215730667114, -0.26849567890167236, 0.32827866077423096, 0.04084727168083191, 0.35086748003959656, -0.7607068419456482, -0.4913226366043091, 0.3702029287815094, 1.0205649137496948, 0.08926213532686234, 0.29974135756492615, 0.039881568402051926, -0.3194981813430786, 0.10377227514982224, 0.5663251280784607, 0.25435158610343933, -0.5077131986618042, -0.24946993589401245, -0.4641428291797638, -0.31103071570396423, -0.45287469029426575, 0.6085109114646912, -0.585279107093811, -0.10795309394598007, 0.7303504943847656, -0.509455680847168, 0.15645849704742432, -0.3309280276298523, 0.07776971906423569, -0.47072634100914, 0.14944100379943848, -0.4571525752544403, 0.37731462717056274, -0.5007628798484802, -0.6688827872276306, 0.9660847783088684, -0.8712649941444397, 0.6408373713493347, 0.014906457625329494, 0.4867410361766815, -0.10898089408874512, -0.026857074350118637, -0.04124103859066963, 0.48017266392707825, -0.29728397727012634, 1.4963217973709106, -0.0812242329120636, 0.9618930816650391, -0.48310282826423645, 0.15275448560714722, 1.070107102394104, 1.1121618747711182, 0.10609875619411469, -0.1374434381723404, 0.23220230638980865, -0.9423531889915466, 0.8709887862205505, 0.03663043677806854, -0.3395872712135315, 0.3303872346878052, -0.08607498556375504, 0.39892634749412537, -0.022108664736151695, -0.842941164970398, -0.25616368651390076, 0.1138082817196846, 0.3128660023212433, 0.0860442966222763, -0.22494636476039886, 0.7838770747184753, -0.43690913915634155, 0.05370635539293289, 0.5783240795135498, 0.36678406596183777, 0.12035419791936874, -0.3537479043006897, 0.9762791395187378, -0.04676895961165428, -0.7468989491462708, 0.016246182844042778, 0.5662202835083008, -0.7757025361061096, 0.24726590514183044, 0.3446103632450104, -0.1306384652853012, -1.276427149772644, -0.1403670310974121, 0.09503261744976044, 0.8036007881164551, 0.17397058010101318, 0.25424012541770935, 0.010252261534333229, 0.11132340878248215, -0.24189433455467224, -1.0788592100143433, 0.3444339632987976, -1.039623737335205, 0.8899434804916382, 0.9732663035392761, -0.6022976040840149, -0.8969129323959351, -0.39672333002090454, -0.015458264388144016, -0.47147440910339355, -0.3025490343570709, 0.11616212129592896, -0.1308692842721939, 0.14436520636081696, 0.47547149658203125, -0.3265773057937622, -0.921061098575592, -0.391419917345047, -0.3760649561882019, -0.2749856114387512, 0.5072417855262756, 0.5364885330200195, 0.22865906357765198, 0.9384950399398804, -0.0417250394821167, 0.23648081719875336, -1.1283133029937744, 0.11993435025215149, -0.03068235144019127, -0.3294939696788788, 0.0628412663936615, -0.3939841389656067, -0.09466376155614853, 0.19248005747795105, -0.8088939189910889, -0.9463405013084412, -0.14096511900424957, 0.4079349935054779, 0.1265021562576294, -0.18994660675525665, 0.5410792827606201, -0.44851991534233093, -0.023209907114505768, 0.5045501589775085, -0.16505129635334015, -0.17042657732963562, -0.0424361377954483, -0.5779502987861633, -0.6734784245491028, 0.3882942795753479, 0.3315666913986206, -0.0051908972673118114, 0.22885599732398987, -0.5513343214988708, 0.09263086318969727, 0.334944486618042, 0.2220611423254013, -1.145796775817871, 0.03623485192656517, -0.4897027909755707, 0.3430090844631195, 0.23433803021907806, -0.8877028822898865, -0.6582890152931213, -0.12628507614135742, -0.11027393490076065, -0.7965788245201111, 0.0928429439663887, 0.12290465086698532, -0.07863634824752808, -0.4489762783050537, -0.6171542406082153, 0.026792561635375023, -0.6803582310676575, 0.374999463558197, 0.8607368469238281, -0.4206581711769104, -0.23745030164718628, 0.28062090277671814, 0.9715309739112854, -0.058689963072538376, -0.8869640827178955, 0.3409709930419922, 0.29513323307037354, -0.234178826212883, 0.026858430355787277, 0.03873482346534729, -0.6829339861869812, -0.009927836246788502, -0.25456780195236206, 0.18780608475208282, 0.15562279522418976, -0.1905183494091034, 0.09818911552429199, 0.4227696359157562, -0.8814113140106201, -0.23225097358226776, -0.10881531983613968, 0.20701660215854645, -0.7227566242218018, 0.10501474887132645, -0.3841923773288727, -1.4705110788345337, -0.9436390995979309, -1.2141032218933105, 0.05273880437016487, -0.9835143089294434, -0.17495548725128174, -0.17656345665454865, 0.07897858321666718, 0.4216233491897583, -0.03911317512392998, 0.8248202204704285, 0.0948217362165451, 0.4424821138381958, -0.6601028442382812, 0.5835651755332947, -0.1183280348777771, -0.6435350179672241, 0.03349900245666504, -0.28820207715034485, 0.716943085193634, 1.2551724910736084, 0.8539543747901917, 0.6908755302429199, 0.4910814166069031, 0.23035897314548492, 0.552244246006012, 0.17097413539886475, -0.8253023624420166, -0.13967424631118774, 0.4339006543159485, 0.772551417350769, -0.19273431599140167, 0.00520827854052186, -1.077056884765625, 0.16840888559818268, -0.5473490953445435, 0.48603492975234985, -0.7762556672096252, -0.33345115184783936, 0.17356738448143005, -0.10107167065143585, 0.6318032145500183, -0.3777989447116852, 0.0246267169713974, 0.3485915958881378, 0.13602419197559357, -0.36875009536743164, 0.8035380840301514, -0.7666938900947571, 0.07307333499193192, -0.9728763699531555, -1.0795564651489258, -0.48716896772384644, 0.0038898903876543045, -0.2197413444519043, 0.4561392068862915, 0.18488530814647675, 0.6156699657440186, -0.6812134981155396, 1.4158884286880493, 0.3604944944381714, -0.6313483119010925, -0.09754493832588196, 0.18481557071208954, -0.19073322415351868, 0.2280670553445816, 0.22905443608760834, 0.20840293169021606, -0.5065066814422607, 0.06394485384225845, -0.3670717775821686, -0.8230023384094238, -0.43047574162483215, -0.7813528180122375, 0.27917352318763733, 0.8013063073158264, -0.5872059464454651, 0.09772882610559464, 0.2170994132757187, 0.6332637071609497, -0.1533522605895996, 0.4158935546875, 0.027767987921833992, 0.8252622485160828, 0.4973246157169342, -0.6550966501235962, -0.5444538593292236, -0.1385825276374817, -0.12791649997234344, 0.41541150212287903, -0.5039141178131104, 0.5054722428321838, 0.7904027700424194, -0.9612420797348022, 0.19883760809898376, 0.3282701373100281, -0.36316484212875366, -1.3774101734161377, -0.05367356538772583, -0.1602969616651535, 0.06671533733606339, -0.9070804119110107, -0.3702279329299927, -0.1498062014579773, -0.0011025062995031476, 0.2857758700847626, -0.02488958090543747, -0.296419620513916, -0.030470088124275208, -0.11170225590467453, -0.2516826391220093, -0.9600089192390442, 0.21199646592140198, 0.7836892604827881, 0.11488175392150879, -0.04120339825749397, 0.27299684286117554, 0.025951189920306206, -0.003894924884662032, 0.25632551312446594, 0.46043661236763, -0.5776323080062866, 0.28942131996154785, -0.1969725638628006, 0.033503782004117966, 0.31489306688308716, 0.025561006739735603, -0.31702208518981934, 0.9802247881889343, -0.3176880478858948, -1.3703477382659912, -0.28195539116859436, 0.20604762434959412, 0.47242501378059387, 0.27636808156967163, -0.2968662977218628, -0.673633337020874, 0.07196656614542007, 0.428505539894104, 0.5062968134880066, -0.31161069869995117, -1.0451436042785645, -0.8382171392440796, -1.0610833168029785, 0.5172244310379028, -0.31977197527885437, -0.29572975635528564, 0.11470647156238556, -0.7119153141975403, -0.9945428967475891, 0.2089441418647766, 0.8456673622131348, -0.37575745582580566, -0.24375683069229126, -0.653247594833374, 0.15618525445461273, -0.8988837599754333, -0.01552733313292265, -0.10527960956096649, -0.9897646903991699, 0.5456766486167908, 0.7211440801620483, -0.3813857436180115, -0.23198582231998444, -0.33819785714149475, 0.3163689970970154, 0.20308811962604523, 0.10336574912071228, -0.26100942492485046, -0.9128848314285278, 0.2236114740371704, 0.7706698775291443, -0.07185287028551102, -0.9427424073219299, 0.6907399296760559, -0.18567773699760437, 0.3426685035228729, 0.30006980895996094, 0.5863882899284363, -0.34846800565719604, 0.5207381248474121, 0.5399771332740784, -0.17304518818855286, -0.6764847636222839, -0.3503412902355194, 0.33252736926078796, -1.152518391609192, -0.4861446022987366, -0.569336473941803, 0.6124277114868164, -0.12251342087984085, -0.28221672773361206, 0.8253678679466248, 0.06259332597255707, 0.32936903834342957, 0.9003475308418274, 0.40671825408935547, 0.6549857258796692, 0.08508601784706116, 0.3990861177444458, 0.06342703104019165, 0.195778027176857, 0.6602579355239868, -0.013813767582178116, 0.05959149822592735, -0.6987621784210205, -0.42927712202072144, 0.20608390867710114, -0.04047369211912155, 0.39049410820007324, 0.0052878642454743385, 0.5603979229927063, 0.4981457591056824, 0.887648344039917, -0.23060837388038635, -0.07118328660726547, -0.10156282782554626, -0.4516288936138153, -0.3356212377548218, 0.12100420147180557, -0.6696123480796814, -0.5380538105964661, 0.589089572429657, -0.5912079215049744, -0.7907786965370178, -0.9710882306098938, -0.6415955424308777, 0.5993569493293762, 0.00021102186292409897, 0.3977663516998291, -0.46634772419929504, 0.576310396194458, 0.4619136452674866, 0.3654734492301941, 0.6833631992340088, 0.14035671949386597, 0.09179096668958664, 0.043271105736494064, -0.4462093710899353, 0.01474730297923088, -0.22675414383411407, 0.41378092765808105, 0.6418137550354004, -0.7532616853713989, -0.4507933259010315, -0.2645263373851776, 0.13655118644237518, -0.3259938359260559, -0.05396033450961113, 0.06490610539913177, -0.6975104212760925, 0.021674934774637222, -0.507878303527832, -0.6389102339744568, -0.288895845413208, 0.18943873047828674, 0.45596247911453247, -0.8985515832901001, -0.8881851434707642, 0.3657490313053131, 0.778109073638916, 0.23471471667289734, 0.2693457007408142, -0.34388086199760437, 0.8945876359939575, -0.0527874231338501, 0.22253209352493286, 0.649272620677948, 0.9030879139900208, -0.2799164950847626, 0.033768557012081146, -0.11617010831832886, 0.928254246711731, 0.6316678524017334, 0.2951687276363373, -0.15525031089782715, 0.47937893867492676, -0.05366181954741478, -0.3368922472000122, -0.06357360631227493, -0.669138491153717, 0.5610374808311462, 0.17012274265289307, -0.6873865723609924, 0.7133305072784424, 0.001700960798189044, 0.3893415629863739, -1.0585778951644897, -0.07783807814121246, 0.23994797468185425, -0.40869638323783875, -0.5965508222579956, -0.34737783670425415, 0.15738147497177124, 0.9484136700630188, -0.12380042672157288, 0.9233730435371399, 0.7135850191116333, 0.48947179317474365, 0.17755627632141113, -0.23407813906669617, 0.7883809208869934, -0.5033100247383118, -0.3767640292644501, -0.452890008687973, 0.28812938928604126, 0.6591020226478577, -0.12255395203828812, 0.6191592812538147, 0.3026869595050812, 0.08638651669025421, 0.4772816598415375, 0.16846174001693726, -0.3039730489253998, 0.8378832936286926, -0.14119462668895721, -0.5747582316398621, 0.5760327577590942, 0.11186828464269638, -0.6558241248130798, -1.1040575504302979, 0.7279080152511597, -0.14031840860843658, 0.5000234246253967, -0.5389028191566467, 0.211493581533432, 0.6644290685653687, -0.5180104970932007, 0.5778331160545349, -1.1368926763534546, 0.004512177314609289, 0.7154143452644348, 0.014298814348876476, 0.2337181270122528, -0.21999786794185638, -0.2711697518825531, -0.837124228477478, -0.025661073625087738, 0.28661662340164185, 0.6105656623840332, -0.5957802534103394, -0.05125821381807327, 0.09081284701824188, 0.4505968689918518, -0.6505147814750671, -0.5342408418655396, -0.014533694833517075, 0.05708565562963486, 0.19823701679706573, -0.21666231751441956, 0.2375078648328781, 0.125302255153656, -0.3539387285709381, 0.5586907863616943, -0.11409857869148254, -0.15060660243034363, 0.4031623899936676, -0.2675917446613312, 0.6147996783256531, 0.20424498617649078, -0.3720799684524536, -0.15040260553359985, -0.8465861678123474, -0.26153305172920227, 0.03594262897968292, 0.11864138394594193, -0.5121198892593384, 0.06651246547698975, 0.41048726439476013, -0.2397109717130661, 0.03961639478802681, -0.18557195365428925, 0.13859298825263977, 0.1258360892534256, 0.5258090496063232, -0.5919740200042725, 0.4511141777038574, -0.06136201694607735, -0.4991609752178192, -0.27893540263175964, -0.1054469421505928, 0.42041200399398804, -0.11518749594688416, -0.7412494421005249, -0.8722220063209534, 0.5371431708335876, 0.2451716959476471, -0.06121153011918068, 0.6784918308258057, 0.45410388708114624, 0.06874949485063553, -0.09760039299726486, -1.088582992553711, -0.30973148345947266, -0.7003875970840454, 1.4037940502166748, -0.6179767847061157, 0.049555446952581406, 0.2918238043785095, -0.4990111291408539, 0.5881713032722473, -0.49409085512161255, 4.0959272384643555, 1.1114256381988525, 0.8242054581642151, -0.471540242433548, 0.4291503131389618, 0.8173523545265198, 0.6929298043251038, 0.22878558933734894, 0.417314350605011, -0.21928468346595764, -0.7333375215530396, 1.089918851852417, -0.47421279549598694, 0.35630834102630615, 1.0050277709960938, 0.8258078098297119, -1.4803987741470337, 0.5784236192703247, -0.45615944266319275, -0.8566446900367737, -0.01744418404996395, 0.3163019120693207, 0.12815356254577637, 0.2761228680610657, 0.0200029443949461, 0.1686994880437851, 0.3868815302848816, 0.11943589895963669, -0.2700141966342926, -0.2540092468261719, -0.49227645993232727, -0.2961975932121277, 0.6720950603485107, -1.2567378282546997, -0.2292603850364685, 0.5120394229888916, -0.2953072488307953, -0.0844922661781311, 0.09322905540466309, -0.1019294410943985, 0.21694327890872955, -0.07587960362434387, -0.10128702968358994, -0.6552282571792603, 0.25982552766799927, -0.32431918382644653, -0.7773023247718811, -0.056582365185022354, -0.3230019211769104, -0.6925677061080933, 0.8639833331108093, -1.2528053522109985, 0.05719595029950142, -0.10837142169475555, -0.7903136014938354, -0.26136794686317444, 0.12298169732093811, -0.61506187915802, 0.5214706063270569, 0.2079075276851654, 0.7933013439178467, 0.1960398554801941, -0.5172030329704285, -0.17250292003154755, 0.8702290058135986, 0.7297959327697754, 0.38266777992248535, 0.43001943826675415, -0.001912396983243525, -0.4528651535511017, -0.23989781737327576, -0.3685568869113922, 0.03780244663357735, -0.2840021550655365, 0.4843105375766754, 0.4841156601905823, 0.39327430725097656, 0.17855723202228546, -0.49495404958724976, -0.39433419704437256, 0.26342207193374634, 0.398355633020401, 0.5204913020133972, -0.5249820351600647, 0.08492773771286011, 0.9736468195915222, 0.005412808153778315, -0.29613375663757324, -1.0325716733932495, 0.57736736536026, 0.3854863941669464, 0.21584586799144745, 0.6478086113929749, 0.017829570919275284, 0.28177958726882935 ]
{"Title": "A Systematic Review on Psychological and Biological Mediators Between Adversity and Psychosis: Potential Targets for Treatment", "Authors": "Alameda Luis, Rodriguez Victoria, Carr Ewan, Aas Monica, Trotta Giulia, Marino Paolo, Vorontsova Natasha, Herane-Vives Andr\u00e9s, Spinazzola Edoardo, Di Forti Marta, Morgan Craig, Murray Robin M", "Abstract": "Abstract Various psychological and biological pathways have been proposed as mediators between childhood adverse events (CA) and psychosis. A systematic review of the evidence in this domain is needed. The aim of this work is to systematically review the evidence on psychological and biological mediators between CA and psychosis across the psychosis spectrum. This systematic review followed Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines (registration number: CRD42018100846). Articles published between 1979 and July 2019 were identified through a literature search in OVID (PsychINFO; Medline and Embase). The evidence by each analysis and each study results are presented by group of mediator categories found in the review. The percentage of total effect mediated was calculated. 47 studies were included, with a total of 79,668 from general population (GP) and 3,189 from clinical samples. The quality of studies was judged as \u201cfair\u201d. Our results showed (i) solid evidence of mediation between CA and psychosis by negative cognitive schemas about the self, the world, and others (NS); by dissociation and other PTSD symptoms; (ii) evidence of al mediation through an affective pathway (affective dysregulation, anxiety, and depression) in GP; (iii) lack of studies exploring biological mediators. To conclude, we found evidence suggesting that various overlapping and not competing pathways contribute partially to the link between adversity and psychosis. Experiences of adversity, along with relevant mediators such as PTSD and mood related symptoms and NS, should be routinely assessed in patients with psychosis. Targeting such mediators through cognitive behavioural aproaches using trauma-focused therapy and/or pharmacological means could be a useful addition to the traditional treatment of positive symptoms.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.14.19014506"}
10.1101/19010900
[ 0.4384382963180542, -0.05484314262866974, 0.2586061358451843, 0.19206424057483673, -0.615621030330658, -0.14437466859817505, -0.1917324662208557, -0.7781236171722412, 0.44732585549354553, 0.40416058897972107, -0.05413858965039253, -0.37995919585227966, 0.45699411630630493, -0.4092349708080292, -0.31085529923439026, 0.25257351994514465, -0.4829609990119934, -0.086277075111866, -0.08756460249423981, -0.4408368468284607, 0.3735966086387634, -0.3654843270778656, -1.103851556777954, 0.3438034951686859, -0.2893400490283966, 0.548295259475708, -0.02691785804927349, -0.2895786762237549, 1.0684915781021118, 0.09203357249498367, 0.07138274610042572, -0.7186099290847778, 0.934737503528595, -1.1829118728637695, -0.5215877294540405, 0.09253279119729996, 0.97134929895401, 0.4288811683654785, -0.14800412952899933, -0.5626214146614075, 0.43397223949432373, 0.2573651075363159, 0.38357317447662354, -0.5801194310188293, -0.5429328083992004, -0.10876461863517761, -0.5205219388008118, 0.19709503650665283, 0.1645057052373886, -0.01765473559498787, -0.8297227025032043, 0.18327470123767853, 0.05188707634806633, 0.43132802844047546, 0.029184777289628983, 0.6480583548545837, 0.43511441349983215, -0.326318621635437, -1.2386728525161743, 0.0525551475584507, -0.2119300663471222, -0.255441278219223, 0.8354414105415344, -1.4718282222747803, 0.7262204885482788, 0.729455292224884, -0.24197569489479065, -0.6663162708282471, -0.06841589510440826, -0.34620755910873413, -0.2823781669139862, 0.33355575799942017, -0.3124917149543762, -0.405568927526474, -0.2766392230987549, -0.7808330059051514, 0.04466630145907402, 0.052812106907367706, -0.3833589553833008, 0.01213002111762762, 0.18030226230621338, 0.5622467398643494, -0.2787456214427948, 0.13920997083187103, -0.5478649139404297, -0.3223606050014496, -0.12204272300004959, 0.4393184185028076, -0.37935248017311096, 0.25820261240005493, -0.017447151243686676, 0.38530251383781433, 0.09789710491895676, 0.3264228403568268, 0.23034797608852386, 1.4146380424499512, -0.7168241739273071, 0.48708224296569824, -0.05314427241683006, -0.47988536953926086, 0.9740111827850342, 0.5689905881881714, -0.9010014533996582, 0.40624508261680603, -0.5270954370498657, 0.5304458141326904, 0.23980924487113953, -0.14170077443122864, -0.8344143629074097, -0.19777025282382965, 0.43487972021102905, 0.0955442264676094, 0.09750459343194962, 0.40707412362098694, 0.1979074329137802, 0.6551917195320129, -0.3986315131187439, 0.5452273488044739, -0.29166895151138306, -0.22128362953662872, -0.32151493430137634, -0.17949290573596954, 0.9002916812896729, -0.40086817741394043, 0.06137276440858841, 0.38854679465293884, -0.06602898985147476, 0.3562929928302765, -0.36319202184677124, -0.07226236164569855, 0.06046880781650543, -0.43420132994651794, -0.43924832344055176, 1.099927544593811, -0.7427719235420227, -0.3848867416381836, 0.49916595220565796, 0.6600834131240845, -0.11512414366006851, -0.8722276091575623, 0.2520509362220764, 0.23109711706638336, -0.8696507811546326, 1.2899963855743408, 0.23264415562152863, 0.36250945925712585, -0.6843907237052917, -1.3265981674194336, -0.7428553700447083, 0.04558316618204117, -0.22353282570838928, 0.8405911922454834, 0.15599901974201202, -0.7533231377601624, -0.6804928183555603, 0.4482206106185913, -0.4861808717250824, 0.24657364189624786, 0.42517900466918945, -0.09626971185207367, -0.32596680521965027, -0.06496696919202805, -0.2533578872680664, 0.4573734700679779, -0.24230071902275085, 0.4060629606246948, 0.29463836550712585, 0.6082899570465088, 0.7164566516876221, -0.7465234398841858, 0.3282983899116516, 0.37291184067726135, -0.5001314282417297, 0.09202029556035995, 0.0186679195612669, 0.4101981222629547, 1.0439850091934204, -0.3878936469554901, 0.9128824472427368, 0.16704070568084717, 0.12011506408452988, -0.12894847989082336, 0.10215631127357483, 0.5443183779716492, -0.25599125027656555, 0.26358848810195923, 0.04689181223511696, 0.01607617549598217, -0.15877288579940796, -0.11538667976856232, -0.48328840732574463, 0.7365594506263733, -0.7604504823684692, 0.4561992287635803, -0.5398231744766235, -0.0829836055636406, -0.5268338918685913, 0.318041056394577, -0.21713382005691528, -0.21960753202438354, -0.3932320177555084, 0.9723749160766602, -0.4338764548301697, -0.20805014669895172, -0.17914530634880066, 0.4651004672050476, -0.05712934583425522, 0.22523297369480133, -0.6897778511047363, 0.8879885673522949, 0.5688802003860474, -0.7059801816940308, 0.0012703542597591877, 0.8352892398834229, -0.05139566585421562, -1.5275365114212036, 0.43583810329437256, 0.08711355179548264, -0.34649658203125, 0.17408102750778198, -0.007741560228168964, -0.33759427070617676, 0.8326351046562195, 0.1250293254852295, 0.08753586560487747, 0.38835859298706055, 1.0088329315185547, 0.4316929280757904, -0.22721289098262787, -0.6945656538009644, 0.26165658235549927, 0.6821256875991821, -0.20414327085018158, 1.2462265491485596, 0.5395057797431946, 0.4461815059185028, 0.0885816290974617, 0.4662816524505615, -0.2298007309436798, 0.1876046061515808, 0.4944799840450287, -0.16988927125930786, 0.6740793585777283, 1.146300196647644, -0.0050965044647455215, -0.22192400693893433, -0.6186161041259766, -0.24016501009464264, -0.28440412878990173, 0.7209157347679138, -0.8100554943084717, 0.7516143321990967, 0.591932475566864, -0.16693910956382751, 0.03663404658436775, -0.5516104102134705, -0.12328533828258514, -0.12014736235141754, 0.234699085354805, 0.07971668243408203, 0.6278975009918213, -0.2673031687736511, -0.08745593577623367, 0.339203417301178, 1.0604298114776611, 1.1830278635025024, 0.17826060950756073, 0.4082459807395935, 0.26084089279174805, -0.14977335929870605, -1.118554711341858, -1.131369709968567, -1.9258829355239868, -0.7297207713127136, -0.8643848896026611, -0.14573149383068085, 0.6221745014190674, -0.24651314318180084, 0.7984135746955872, 0.7232823967933655, 0.15329208970069885, -0.2767183780670166, -0.4457029104232788, 0.5665977001190186, 0.6645330190658569, 0.05226770043373108, -0.4578094482421875, 0.30987799167633057, -0.7611211538314819, 0.08411095291376114, -0.3561186194419861, -0.6984556913375854, -0.5306930541992188, -0.5786430835723877, 0.47862279415130615, -0.7523777484893799, 0.3610880970954895, -0.3682556748390198, -0.41887107491493225, 0.09710115194320679, -0.3051435649394989, -0.3325788676738739, -0.022749630734324455, -0.04696543887257576, -0.7219621539115906, 0.568294107913971, 1.1158456802368164, 0.0737781822681427, 0.515381395816803, 0.8170596957206726, -0.312187522649765, 0.7523635029792786, -0.08909107744693756, -0.18515603244304657, -0.5137917399406433, 0.3869531452655792, 0.5972887277603149, -0.1259346455335617, 0.12338868528604507, -0.9307624697685242, -1.5493204593658447, 0.2987688183784485, -0.24974019825458527, -0.5558217167854309, 0.12293314933776855, 0.6726430058479309, -0.16995885968208313, -1.6922789812088013, -0.3147509694099426, -0.6572065353393555, -0.8118253946304321, 0.4145275354385376, 0.2560676038265228, 0.30431821942329407, 0.10624227672815323, 0.2727491855621338, -0.2534146308898926, -0.3351823687553406, 0.5203055739402771, 0.26037076115608215, -0.3335370719432831, -0.5140650868415833, 0.2279600203037262, 0.43179744482040405, 0.29794055223464966, 0.5880033373832703, 0.3451251983642578, -0.4757317006587982, 0.23766571283340454, -0.1752767711877823, -0.01491245161741972, -0.36277881264686584, 0.47118136286735535, 0.0940060243010521, -0.27139249444007874, 0.7561483383178711, -0.162677600979805, -0.3137868642807007, 0.0927044153213501, 0.2072647362947464, -0.34747233986854553, -0.0648425742983818, -0.8949931263923645, -0.08906973898410797, -0.9031727313995361, -0.8402262330055237, 0.29702049493789673, 0.1799703687429428, 0.5680921077728271, -0.45942872762680054, 0.4797182083129883, -0.11702874302864075, -0.12928210198879242, 0.2585911452770233, 0.45663145184516907, 0.34440138936042786, 0.6556834578514099, 0.028668953105807304, 1.442399263381958, -1.0973119735717773, -0.23497162759304047, 0.5717218518257141, 0.7940294146537781, 0.27327027916908264, 0.8370703458786011, 0.5587214827537537, -0.23127497732639313, 0.3122820258140564, -0.570418119430542, 0.49972108006477356, 0.6397475004196167, 0.46287861466407776, 0.16337068378925323, 0.597206175327301, -0.8841783404350281, -0.1943996548652649, 0.5855481624603271, 0.6037267446517944, -0.12659795582294464, 0.05732960253953934, 1.2985395193099976, -0.608189046382904, 0.010694458149373531, 0.5135094523429871, 0.4147936701774597, -0.20330820977687836, -0.4266228973865509, -0.39099588990211487, 0.05876197665929794, -0.5892251133918762, 0.3203865885734558, -0.29614585638046265, -0.4665210247039795, -0.2248634397983551, 0.5409843921661377, -0.2608907222747803, -0.3328235447406769, -0.32079175114631653, 0.7058652639389038, -0.11889766901731491, -0.0073929764330387115, 0.6314644813537598, -0.796440601348877, -0.14069104194641113, 0.2723845839500427, -0.6697453260421753, -0.2481357902288437, -0.6386244297027588, 0.8590313196182251, 0.6931949853897095, -0.5932356119155884, -0.9921379089355469, -0.009789569303393364, 0.26783275604248047, -0.05792434886097908, 0.40696635842323303, -0.02168065309524536, -0.6391463279724121, 0.7041962146759033, 0.35112234950065613, -0.09074899554252625, -0.6432323455810547, -0.633049726486206, -0.45752719044685364, 0.10481882095336914, -0.02992810681462288, 0.9659295678138733, 0.47447529435157776, 0.221013143658638, 0.06135530397295952, 0.694290816783905, -0.9000170230865479, 0.4012407660484314, -0.9259546399116516, -0.51247239112854, -0.329161137342453, -0.22351376712322235, -0.1784956157207489, 0.06982862204313278, 0.32679814100265503, -0.12022411078214645, -0.2980656921863556, 0.2539476752281189, -0.05207422003149986, -0.7595183253288269, 1.0282167196273804, -0.690815806388855, 0.2524701952934265, 0.886633574962616, 0.17863886058330536, -0.49367284774780273, -0.41890546679496765, 0.34163522720336914, -0.8737828731536865, 0.5114681720733643, 0.021611513569951057, 0.3172384202480316, -0.20774835348129272, -0.48405763506889343, -0.23149435222148895, -0.3847511410713196, 0.4611968696117401, -0.5832153558731079, -0.09594456851482391, -0.1797000914812088, -0.1927889883518219, -0.6249302625656128, 0.13628463447093964, -0.36182308197021484, 0.04906824603676796, 0.20002612471580505, -0.340665727853775, -0.2681686580181122, -0.10198303312063217, -0.5505847930908203, -0.5964032411575317, -0.5150367021560669, -0.13522382080554962, -0.0013255428057163954, 0.02345370501279831, 1.1517847776412964, -0.13508924841880798, -1.0035513639450073, 0.5279922485351562, 0.37911173701286316, -0.2853573262691498, -0.7835109233856201, -0.09009944647550583, 0.5058817863464355, -0.8900960087776184, -0.03161822631955147, -0.34567350149154663, -0.5000139474868774, -0.5187477469444275, -0.9614748358726501, 0.10155469179153442, 0.45312467217445374, -0.14163349568843842, -0.339656800031662, 0.4552762508392334, 0.4235627055168152, -1.0397216081619263, -0.9789102077484131, 0.33931171894073486, -0.06464459747076035, 0.23728090524673462, -0.3074248433113098, -0.7554336190223694, -0.3773582875728607, 0.07555647939443588, 0.15251021087169647, -0.7566326260566711, 0.31896087527275085, -0.3721412718296051, -0.29034319519996643, -0.2615845203399658, 0.6638652682304382, 0.6203541159629822, 0.14401204884052277, -0.4984804093837738, -0.5008459091186523, 0.08404682576656342, -0.09401803463697433, -0.4727526009082794, -0.5668054819107056, -0.12004579603672028, 0.08841762691736221, 1.0034927129745483, 0.08505558222532272, -0.8722519874572754, 0.4965659976005554, 0.4345448911190033, 0.5199740529060364, 0.6000535488128662, -0.5662472248077393, -0.08267156034708023, 0.5741775035858154, 0.30982735753059387, -0.3321327865123749, 0.6218578219413757, -0.8572683930397034, 0.09757262468338013, -0.6882543563842773, -0.053025975823402405, 0.003243912709876895, -0.42069926857948303, 0.37993425130844116, -0.16975776851177216, 0.8458879590034485, -0.7699376940727234, 0.14436963200569153, 0.18059980869293213, -0.11006254702806473, -0.34006890654563904, -0.028097771108150482, -0.8779493570327759, -0.1859859824180603, -1.0277726650238037, -0.8763828277587891, 0.5725725293159485, -0.5847855806350708, 0.21187429130077362, 1.0693254470825195, -0.08990192413330078, 0.452639102935791, -0.8726679086685181, 0.38341641426086426, 0.6025874614715576, 0.09681405872106552, -0.8323544263839722, 0.7701505422592163, -0.10911693423986435, 0.08127298951148987, -0.49652543663978577, 0.35039833188056946, -0.15016303956508636, -0.2894476056098938, 0.1295967549085617, -0.2832753360271454, -1.0271261930465698, -0.2411353886127472, 0.37458667159080505, 0.3965059816837311, 0.3018566370010376, 0.3756996691226959, 0.22809474170207977, -0.2505830228328705, 0.13665974140167236, 0.03066016174852848, -0.7136330604553223, -0.2069847285747528, 1.2151734828948975, 0.2209070920944214, 0.056856848299503326, 0.877987802028656, -0.49036768078804016, -0.3939189612865448, -0.3680965304374695, 0.5943796634674072, 0.17155571281909943, -1.0150761604309082, 0.2409709244966507, 0.46176308393478394, -0.5100854635238647, -0.6023290753364563, 0.10163173079490662, 0.08950014412403107, -0.07188090682029724, -0.5372580885887146, -0.9190953373908997, 0.16614118218421936, -0.8227909207344055, 0.5581117868423462, -0.38087987899780273, 0.24958568811416626, 0.20780424773693085, -0.7760645151138306, 0.1471598595380783, -0.9799996614456177, 0.9230121374130249, 1.0443496704101562, -0.5700731873512268, 0.006175880786031485, 0.16500277817249298, 1.0425612926483154, 0.5170547962188721, -0.13853386044502258, -0.10350797325372696, 0.40961208939552307, -0.29615116119384766, 0.1073678508400917, 0.6664994359016418, 0.1210353896021843, 0.20720274746418, -0.15982137620449066, 1.03352689743042, 0.4784886837005615, -0.529567539691925, -0.2346646934747696, 0.5410456657409668, 0.7009108066558838, 0.4335812032222748, 0.5843589901924133, 0.6354100704193115, 1.2049717903137207, 0.40616661310195923, 0.19017350673675537, -0.37959834933280945, -0.5746272206306458, -0.7714419960975647, 0.04221782088279724, -0.3162360191345215, -0.29051387310028076, 0.0799887627363205, 0.9187071919441223, 0.2630408704280853, -0.5258015394210815, -0.5340989232063293, 0.217518612742424, -0.22506025433540344, -0.28507664799690247, -0.32513171434402466, 0.07202878594398499, -0.13415434956550598, -1.0585025548934937, -0.6439690589904785, -0.6027182340621948, -0.036167316138744354, 1.0534400939941406, -0.9072045087814331, -0.18046417832374573, 0.4141535758972168, 0.1433219313621521, -0.4769302308559418, 0.5326331257820129, -1.0133122205734253, -0.5205774903297424, -0.9380085468292236, 0.7281402349472046, 0.37484654784202576, -0.043866708874702454, 1.0492300987243652, -0.08563532680273056, 0.08228850364685059, 0.7746280431747437, -0.230825737118721, -0.9323886036872864, -0.057491835206747055, -0.00800104346126318, -0.9430950284004211, -0.27977368235588074, 0.06851062178611755, 0.9892788529396057, -1.4925850629806519, -0.2982447147369385, -0.8775262236595154, 0.12211309373378754, 0.16681741178035736, 0.41125252842903137, 0.060846444219350815, 1.2837458848953247, 0.051238883286714554, -0.14845842123031616, -0.025606686249375343, 0.2622263729572296, 0.6892969012260437, 0.10848307609558105, 0.855435848236084, 0.4834161698818207, -0.29603609442710876, -0.7539626359939575, 0.048396654427051544, 0.5664021372795105, -0.846900224685669, -0.10842978209257126, -0.26914700865745544, 0.5066843032836914, 0.051192816346883774, -0.16157135367393494, 0.18532201647758484, 0.3218608498573303, 0.7609685659408569, -0.2921501696109772, -0.15809886157512665, -0.4631548225879669, -0.9784890413284302, -1.176382303237915, -0.9523701071739197, -1.1497375965118408, 0.8889793753623962, -0.39411136507987976, 0.004319670610129833, -0.9484233856201172, -0.585375189781189, 0.226210355758667, 0.7309619784355164, 0.393905371427536, -0.008028879761695862, 0.22074685990810394, -0.0341678261756897, -0.03996139392256737, 0.08729759603738785, 0.2960224151611328, 0.4420127272605896, -0.3289741277694702, -0.42201489210128784, -0.33545148372650146, 0.16485200822353363, 0.7085266709327698, 0.36579427123069763, -0.15029890835285187, -0.668503999710083, 0.05256890505552292, 0.053968194872140884, -0.4690851867198944, -0.07751591503620148, 0.268594354391098, -0.6755266189575195, 0.008004843257367611, -0.6893766522407532, 0.16355837881565094, -0.3232583999633789, 0.6033656001091003, 0.21224470436573029, -0.2853773832321167, -0.5192596912384033, 0.3073381781578064, 0.6570437550544739, -0.7571113705635071, 1.518741250038147, -0.294307142496109, 0.54692143201828, -0.27509745955467224, -0.8080775141716003, 0.7746462821960449, 0.49065619707107544, 0.23840618133544922, -0.3299853801727295, -0.07567247003316879, 0.2805121839046478, 0.965218722820282, 0.9890592694282532, -0.5723658204078674, 0.9468702673912048, 0.8731083273887634, 0.20001713931560516, 0.5736823678016663, -0.08902116864919662, 0.5973051190376282, -0.35231006145477295, 0.01951674185693264, -0.06466846168041229, 0.48691147565841675, -0.3358555734157562, 0.219439297914505, -0.26035887002944946, 0.004968270659446716, -0.9017776846885681, -0.8594794869422913, 0.29910364747047424, 0.8530985116958618, 1.151031732559204, 0.20655736327171326, -0.06200096383690834, 0.23414577543735504, 1.174017071723938, 0.24009937047958374, 0.5716682076454163, 1.1205577850341797, -0.7263223528862, -0.5635128617286682, -0.21936599910259247, 1.1677062511444092, -0.5696588754653931, 0.1583590805530548, 0.4538394510746002, -0.8510927557945251, -0.010204310528934002, 0.553654134273529, -0.17191462218761444, -0.49217289686203003, 0.5500816106796265, -0.12660808861255646, 0.1087648794054985, -0.7612122297286987, 0.7277093529701233, -0.8201949596405029, -0.057555124163627625, 1.4513652324676514, -1.0623458623886108, 0.47905203700065613, 0.25217971205711365, 0.18181172013282776, 0.5057649612426758, -0.29763445258140564, 0.2707952558994293, -0.24809733033180237, 1.056064248085022, 0.23277877271175385, 0.6054279208183289, -0.6044350266456604, -0.2642812430858612, 0.07435158640146255, -0.03273947909474373, -0.2365620732307434, 0.17987386882305145, 0.33873188495635986, -0.6944126486778259, -0.39379361271858215, 0.08802685886621475, -0.22946377098560333, -0.6438553333282471, -0.6137661933898926, -0.05656217411160469, 0.6706585884094238, -0.4755207598209381, -0.20058226585388184, 0.4296553134918213, 0.5955535173416138, 0.02714555524289608, 0.4120623767375946, -0.2823268473148346, -0.5206883549690247, -0.21943636238574982, -0.5373778343200684, 0.7189289927482605, -0.15015128254890442, 0.24625717103481293, -0.18315783143043518, -1.6587753295898438, -0.02552926540374756, -0.6883438229560852, -0.5015740990638733, -0.3532842993736267, -0.2806423008441925, 0.21143607795238495, 0.7741028666496277, -0.013029629364609718, -0.4236133098602295, 0.28618037700653076, 0.20826265215873718, 1.1007143259048462, -0.7576823830604553, 0.722774088382721, 0.35319069027900696, -0.026981886476278305, -0.02523561380803585, 0.19938211143016815, -0.5793307423591614, -0.2555469274520874, -0.07088379561901093, -0.33707648515701294, -0.034192319959402084, 0.1771530956029892, -0.6146206855773926, 0.9272857308387756, 0.8296777606010437, -0.4560796022415161, -0.06805690377950668, -0.47068363428115845, 0.5112341642379761, -0.48797571659088135, 0.5326708555221558, -0.269223153591156, 0.44581785798072815, 0.26953139901161194, -0.05087244510650635, 0.48922187089920044, -1.2448954582214355, 3.8786404132843018, 1.8411394357681274, 0.726468563079834, -0.1128389984369278, 0.6676192879676819, 0.2127159982919693, 0.7970004081726074, 0.10518492758274078, 0.024687448516488075, -0.4895957410335541, 0.15940852463245392, 0.4321137070655823, -0.05431327223777771, -0.11274795979261398, 0.5194280743598938, 0.33107712864875793, -1.1844265460968018, 0.15290652215480804, -0.08207487314939499, -1.3128758668899536, -1.105471134185791, 0.4939334988594055, -0.1727733165025711, -0.1996508240699768, 0.21275192499160767, -0.10396448522806168, 0.42161399126052856, 0.6658439040184021, -0.7506660223007202, -0.2502053678035736, -0.21472282707691193, -0.9041733145713806, 0.20009943842887878, -0.11818670481443405, -0.4527769982814789, 0.37924185395240784, 0.8396197557449341, -0.5581610202789307, 0.03150200471282005, 0.30063149333000183, 0.34614649415016174, -0.661841869354248, -0.24460369348526, 0.28053346276283264, -1.0407599210739136, 0.02674606256186962, -0.04594065621495247, -0.30178457498550415, 0.42067569494247437, -0.049682240933179855, 0.763206958770752, -1.2637189626693726, 0.5897486209869385, -0.5054894685745239, -0.3843916654586792, -0.14783649146556854, -0.5853871703147888, -1.1544374227523804, -0.5561375617980957, 0.33906659483909607, 0.5017066597938538, 0.1969374418258667, -0.39250078797340393, 0.1609523445367813, -0.15243417024612427, 0.346598356962204, 0.11696045845746994, 0.7870890498161316, 0.1935971975326538, -0.7401159405708313, -0.11464736610651016, -0.3911844491958618, 0.11377904564142227, 0.05508558452129364, 0.4389798641204834, -0.21047163009643555, -0.83139568567276, 0.8449724316596985, -0.491288959980011, -0.6578530669212341, 0.7877616882324219, 0.7287424206733704, 0.507790744304657, -0.3884178400039673, -0.24772775173187256, 0.4284813106060028, -0.38681143522262573, -0.05966171994805336, -0.5554483532905579, 0.00552573474124074, 0.7433223724365234, 0.01722029782831669, 0.2660578787326813, 0.1635347306728363, -0.03494159132242203 ]
{"Title": "Unsupervised clustering of missense variants in the HNF1A gene using multidimensional functional data aids clinical interpretation", "Authors": "Althari Sara, Najmi Laeya A., Bennett Amanda J., Aukrust Ingvild, Rundle Jana K., Colclough Kevin, Molnes Janne, Kaci Alba, Nawaz Sameena, van der Lugt Timme, Hassanali Neelam, Molven Anders Prof., Ellard Sian Prof., McCarthy Mark I. Prof., Bj\u00f8rkhaug Lise Prof., Nj\u00f8lstad P\u00e5l Rasmus Prof., Gloyn Anna L. Prof.", "Abstract": "Summary Background Exome sequencing in diabetes presents a diagnostic challenge as depending on frequency, functional impact and genomic and environmental contexts, HNF1A variants can cause Maturity-onset Diabetes of the Young (MODY), increase type 2 diabetes risk, or be benign. A correct diagnosis matters as it informs on treatment, progression, and family risk. We describe a multi-dimensional functional dataset of 73 HNF1A missense variants identified in exomes of 12,940 individuals. Our aim was to develop an analytical framework for stratifying variants along the HNF1A phenotypic continuum to facilitate diagnostic interpretation. Methods HNF1A variant function was determined by 4 different molecular assays. Structure of the multi-dimensional dataset was explored using principal component analysis, k-means, and hierarchical clustering. Weights for tissue-specific isoform expression and functional domain were integrated. Functionally annotated variant subgroups were used to re-evaluate genetic diagnoses in national MODY diagnostic registries. Findings HNF1A variants demonstrated a range of behaviours across the assays. The structure of the multi-parametric data was shaped primarily by transactivation. Using unsupervised learning methods, we obtained high-resolution functional clusters of the variants which separated known causal MODY variants from benign and type 2 diabetes risk variants and led to reclassification of 4% and 9% of HNF1A variants identified in the UK and Norway MODY diagnostic registries, respectively. Interpretation Our proof-of-principle analyses facilitated informative stratification of HNF1A variants along the continuum, allowing improved evaluation of clinical significance, management and precision medicine in diabetes clinics. Transcriptional activity appears a superior readout supporting pursuit of transactivation-centric experimental designs for high-throughput functional screens. Funding Wellcome Trust, National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Oxford Biomedical Research Centre (BRC), European Research Council, Norwegian Research Council, Stiftelsen Kristian Gerhard Jebsen, Western Norway Regional Health Authority, Novo Nordisk Fonden, Royal Norwegian Diabetes Foundation. Research in context Evidence before the study Molecular characterisation pipelines for studying the function of transcription factors consist primarily of in vitro cellular assays which interrogate transcriptional activity, protein abundance, localisation of the transcription factor to the nucleus, and binding to relevant DNA recognition sequences. The experimental techniques used to explore these mechanisms in vitro vary in robustness and reliability. There exist a wide variety of reported functional consequences of HNF1A variants in the literature, a gene causing the most common form of Maturity-onset Diabetes of the Young (HNF1A-MODY). The standard approach for analysing multi-tiered functional datasets has been to evaluate each functional parameter independently. Data from functional characterisation efforts of the HNF-1A protein encoded by the HNF1A gene, support that the degree of HNF-1A disruption tends to correlate positively with phenotypic severity: MODY-causing protein-altering variants impair HNF-1A transcriptional activity more severely (\u226430% vs . wild-type) than HNF1A variants associated with increased risk for developing type 2 diabetes in population-specific contexts (40-60% vs . wild-type). Rare variants which demonstrated intermediate function (between MODY-casual and wild-type) in transactivation and nuclear localisation assays were shown to be associated with a 6-fold increase in type 2 diabetes predisposition. Added value of this study We have developed a proof-of-principle analytical framework for robust and unbiased variant stratification using multi-dimensional functional follow-up data from a large number of exome-identified missense variants in HNF1A . Through our analytical approach we were able to perform a comprehensive assessment of molecular function by utilising data from as many mechanistic dimensions as possible, avoiding arbitrarily determined cut-offs based on 1D functional data. Our method facilitated informative spatial organization of variants along the HNF1A molecular-phenotypic spectrum and an exploration of the contributions of each in vitro molecular mechanism on meaningful functional, and therefore clinical, stratification. Further, we were able to perform sensitive mapping of variant effects on molecular function with phenotypic outcome using clinical and genetic data from national MODY diagnostic registries of UK and Norway. This effort allowed us to annotate functional clusters with clinical knowledge and identify discordant classifications between functional genotype and clinical phenotype. Implications of all the available evidence Our novel approach towards analysing large functional datasets enables sensitive variant-phenotype mapping and multi-layered variant annotation. It also assists in prioritisation of functional elements and signatures for Multiplexed Assays of Variant Effects (MAVEs) whilst they largely remain limited to a single functional readout. Indeed, comprehensively annotated HNF1A variant clusters can aid in the interpretation and clinical classification of variants, and can also be utilised to calibrate supervised variant classification models built with high-throughput-derived experimental data.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010900"}
10.1101/19006189
[ 0.09521643072366714, -0.24461643397808075, -0.3508231043815613, 0.31632566452026367, -0.2703830897808075, -0.7796639800071716, 0.04310107231140137, -0.059361472725868225, 0.0560837984085083, 1.1430953741073608, 0.18329647183418274, -0.8443012237548828, 0.023323846980929375, -0.7551333904266357, -0.23789407312870026, 0.09843406826257706, -1.228575348854065, 0.10966082662343979, -0.510246992111206, 0.11947514861822128, 0.4125048518180847, 0.5209100842475891, -0.55182945728302, 0.39124760031700134, -0.3757709860801697, 0.9827426075935364, 0.3888551592826843, 0.4850378930568695, 1.486373782157898, 0.6806023716926575, 0.21848955750465393, -0.812594473361969, 0.04214315488934517, -0.5292624831199646, -0.44456151127815247, -0.027099287137389183, 0.555541455745697, -0.44887858629226685, -0.2367732971906662, -0.19322584569454193, 0.3400590121746063, -0.3805774450302124, 0.43585413694381714, -0.8721608519554138, -0.7379922866821289, -0.2659352421760559, -0.3809073567390442, -0.498112291097641, -0.14025406539440155, -0.04469076916575432, -0.288381427526474, -0.09431079030036926, -0.5064041614532471, -0.6052713990211487, 0.2865299582481384, -0.3103628158569336, 0.43729427456855774, 0.40650850534439087, -0.4380567669868469, -0.5236231684684753, 0.2948843836784363, 0.11491601914167404, 0.21718212962150574, -1.747992753982544, 0.3819074034690857, 0.7292072176933289, 0.14456890523433685, -0.5854734182357788, -0.4327033460140228, -0.003343014745041728, -0.9876825213432312, -0.44269993901252747, 0.13674011826515198, -1.0673303604125977, 0.012278895825147629, -0.42863526940345764, 0.1793096661567688, 0.0844205841422081, -0.20801493525505066, -0.27797678112983704, 0.7074999213218689, 0.1095794066786766, -0.34383028745651245, 0.610421359539032, -0.1787879765033722, -0.34883373975753784, 0.7699753046035767, 0.5108271241188049, 0.3575918972492218, -0.21990251541137695, -0.2435026466846466, 0.09499204903841019, 0.16856570541858673, 0.7480220198631287, 0.06851844489574432, 0.8598004579544067, -0.4206975996494293, -0.12172559648752213, 0.7577977180480957, 0.2096560150384903, 0.8261949419975281, 0.5755185484886169, -0.19872409105300903, 1.238189697265625, -0.887500524520874, 0.7530516982078552, 0.4518977701663971, -0.1515885442495346, -0.4708932638168335, -1.0404688119888306, 0.00608067587018013, 0.21846474707126617, 0.15944789350032806, -0.01934538595378399, 0.11161047965288162, 0.6823772192001343, -0.0704275369644165, 0.5024704933166504, -0.2873680889606476, 0.8555024266242981, -0.4468230605125427, 0.15718711912631989, 0.45475417375564575, 0.07897204160690308, 0.7825619578361511, 0.3187917172908783, 0.11858686059713364, 0.9492325186729431, -0.48821327090263367, 0.08941179513931274, -0.07474615424871445, -0.7352427840232849, 0.23610958456993103, 0.4227065443992615, -0.3462432026863098, -0.2016001045703888, 0.7004241347312927, 1.1197417974472046, -0.5546387434005737, -0.30344855785369873, -0.3789985775947571, 0.007416127249598503, -0.43794241547584534, 1.2472515106201172, -0.243956059217453, 0.6154900789260864, -0.8882892727851868, -1.4249142408370972, -0.2928811013698578, -0.010486661456525326, -0.000754127511754632, 0.7337348461151123, 0.646658182144165, -0.2718461751937866, -0.2338845580816269, -0.17262011766433716, -0.5220445394515991, 0.8163499236106873, -0.14844217896461487, -0.3060069680213928, -0.367850661277771, -0.004383144900202751, -0.03049820102751255, 0.515156626701355, -0.5866906046867371, 0.511500358581543, -0.1721673309803009, -0.23011645674705505, 0.1717480570077896, -0.471098929643631, 1.0073606967926025, 0.7992234230041504, -0.13568605482578278, -0.222787007689476, -0.014089641161262989, 1.4435529708862305, 0.88301682472229, 0.0293241236358881, 1.0359333753585815, -0.15827789902687073, -0.19232572615146637, -0.9423142671585083, 0.49963468313217163, 0.817158579826355, -0.09505297243595123, -0.0500892698764801, -0.19928871095180511, -0.7472958564758301, -0.12746156752109528, -0.047527801245450974, -0.13676919043064117, 0.48484477400779724, -0.6688444018363953, 1.1891727447509766, 0.4005471169948578, -0.06672165542840958, -0.14475426077842712, 0.6548869609832764, 0.461979478597641, -0.09067365527153015, -0.6477240324020386, 1.0685818195343018, -0.42539629340171814, 0.21460828185081482, -0.10802946239709854, 0.6733856797218323, 0.39601388573646545, 0.630112886428833, -0.5312398672103882, 0.261429101228714, 0.04750586673617363, 0.11138130724430084, -0.23065105080604553, 0.06902192533016205, 0.8634862303733826, -0.44028130173683167, -0.22788019478321075, -0.11109444499015808, -0.48482897877693176, -0.5422768592834473, 0.2241043895483017, -0.604953944683075, 0.4343307614326477, 0.3134686052799225, -0.029714006930589676, -0.009034140966832638, 0.4013821482658386, 0.1842803806066513, 0.10511671751737595, -0.08562710881233215, 0.743885338306427, 0.5198805332183838, -0.016657022759318352, 0.6112494468688965, 0.28230199217796326, 0.5177077651023865, 0.4166240692138672, 0.4141237437725067, 0.4488743245601654, 0.008508974686264992, 0.32726114988327026, 0.6419900059700012, 0.9860357046127319, 1.2504109144210815, -0.1335192322731018, 0.21709638833999634, -0.4763234555721283, 0.003861787263303995, 0.38229936361312866, 0.19184510409832, -0.5133633613586426, 0.7392477989196777, -0.21789070963859558, 0.32956358790397644, -0.7256644368171692, -0.04647083207964897, 0.34162044525146484, 0.26738858222961426, -0.0034450525417923927, -1.1158565282821655, -0.9226944446563721, 0.5695153474807739, -0.23639553785324097, -0.0977180004119873, 0.806253969669342, 1.2147574424743652, 0.10853612422943115, 0.7549070119857788, 0.48503801226615906, -0.333903431892395, -0.4756539762020111, -0.4779911935329437, -1.7591098546981812, -1.1036369800567627, -0.9439189434051514, 0.19438277184963226, -0.16675321757793427, -0.5439289212226868, 0.050190191715955734, 0.31394249200820923, 0.7465215921401978, -0.3756089508533478, 0.5825441479682922, 1.1042622327804565, 0.22923776507377625, -0.24952402710914612, -1.1259477138519287, 0.36950740218162537, -0.6860882639884949, -0.12044651806354523, 0.3954360783100128, -0.3739354908466339, -0.516639769077301, -0.6139110326766968, 0.5205420851707458, -0.7030117511749268, -0.1682995706796646, -0.048252612352371216, -0.7318841218948364, -0.25378888845443726, -0.28616541624069214, -0.2795553505420685, -0.3561786711215973, 0.08123603463172913, -0.5405231714248657, 0.3410033583641052, 0.5376026630401611, 0.5442966818809509, 1.0503851175308228, 0.41623976826667786, -1.0393788814544678, 0.7494008541107178, 0.17949184775352478, 0.005291580688208342, -0.963881254196167, -0.025448191910982132, 0.26406195759773254, -0.39842692017555237, 0.3993273973464966, -0.7530167698860168, -0.7294745445251465, -0.49198049306869507, -0.29698535799980164, -0.12335497885942459, 0.022709451615810394, 0.23527319729328156, -0.07524275034666061, -0.584380030632019, -0.3449186682701111, -0.5424644351005554, -0.9992530941963196, 0.593101441860199, -0.5383293032646179, 0.8062716126441956, 0.24834851920604706, -0.12275895476341248, -0.476277619600296, 0.11134228855371475, 0.2000531107187271, 1.1794110536575317, 0.5086666941642761, -0.5401622653007507, -0.30756619572639465, 0.2968008816242218, 0.1876203417778015, 0.6446492075920105, 0.6867607831954956, -0.4883681833744049, -0.33856549859046936, -0.24643279612064362, -0.3903995156288147, 0.27769631147384644, 0.6310119032859802, -0.3074253499507904, 0.735897958278656, -0.16322657465934753, -0.5581409335136414, -0.2635692358016968, 0.4563785493373871, -0.06252574920654297, 0.016076259315013885, 0.4264672100543976, -0.033868663012981415, 1.0918503999710083, -0.5934910178184509, -0.5443934798240662, 0.6444159150123596, -0.6242682933807373, 0.5908743739128113, -0.5970091819763184, 0.7017542123794556, -0.04707984998822212, -0.6459130048751831, -0.4991893470287323, -0.23277322947978973, -0.11444300413131714, 1.4244434833526611, 0.19376163184642792, 1.3889505863189697, -1.4533404111862183, 0.4807828366756439, 1.0464297533035278, 0.9561742544174194, -0.027908291667699814, -0.0646640881896019, 0.31620025634765625, -1.060030460357666, 0.4548795521259308, 0.061278335750103, 0.18056517839431763, 0.12984412908554077, 0.45441174507141113, -0.6525612473487854, -0.39093825221061707, -0.6623062491416931, -0.33820706605911255, 0.3457027077674866, 0.23314374685287476, -0.22051940858364105, -0.37149062752723694, 1.284938931465149, -1.1218098402023315, -0.2633417546749115, 0.42144715785980225, 0.666662335395813, -0.4674270451068878, -0.49405068159103394, 0.4117015302181244, -0.7263769507408142, -0.42362532019615173, -0.14372995495796204, 0.24575798213481903, -0.5825298428535461, -0.03687788546085358, 0.49984174966812134, -0.3067460358142853, -0.38924112915992737, -0.5114002823829651, -0.3953157663345337, 0.3956926465034485, 0.3272123336791992, 0.8711238503456116, -0.6212173104286194, -0.08514612913131714, -0.33878031373023987, -0.7847769856452942, 0.13936203718185425, -0.9134638905525208, 0.374901682138443, 0.7930528521537781, -0.15459126234054565, -0.7475072145462036, 0.0474371612071991, -0.18886680901050568, 0.1991262286901474, 0.10925903916358948, -0.5258046388626099, -0.5312150120735168, 0.7065349221229553, 0.044995132833719254, -0.09344899654388428, -0.3705736994743347, -0.250731498003006, -0.20042860507965088, 0.3901337683200836, 0.44924288988113403, 0.7296107411384583, 0.31588125228881836, 1.1296292543411255, 0.4789769947528839, 0.554486870765686, -0.7209054231643677, 0.1312391757965088, -1.115932822227478, -0.2846461832523346, -0.37048467993736267, -0.22900567948818207, -0.20794843137264252, -0.048921339213848114, -0.15725252032279968, -0.0014665391063317657, -0.16419532895088196, 0.2643246650695801, 0.10799475759267807, -0.18524624407291412, 0.38557353615760803, -0.24179019033908844, -0.3358660042285919, 1.275723934173584, -0.010620052926242352, -0.3825160264968872, -0.5629228949546814, 0.18661707639694214, -0.5940898060798645, -0.07116564363241196, 0.39435580372810364, 0.36138734221458435, -0.2611813545227051, -0.37398332357406616, -0.2747652232646942, 0.32633495330810547, 0.13035918772220612, -0.6012941002845764, -0.21864929795265198, -1.0551072359085083, -0.6627360582351685, -0.7413346767425537, -0.5700865983963013, -1.0525065660476685, 0.4513670802116394, 0.018940679728984833, -0.8562676310539246, -0.5300899744033813, -0.10395962744951248, -0.1885593682527542, -0.18943458795547485, -0.7571873664855957, -0.033709339797496796, -0.8934743404388428, 0.026751821860671043, 0.8726905584335327, 0.1954808235168457, -0.3428821563720703, 0.5828604698181152, 0.2540840804576874, -0.5960983037948608, -0.5634239912033081, -0.27235788106918335, 0.38354581594467163, -0.5819783806800842, -0.008726030588150024, 0.252208948135376, 0.18619868159294128, -0.0711050033569336, 0.2554852068424225, -0.5234591960906982, 0.271599143743515, -0.7147667407989502, -0.5592080354690552, 1.2568490505218506, -0.5207170844078064, -0.6722058653831482, -0.4575853645801544, 0.3990113437175751, 0.1500081866979599, 0.369731605052948, -0.5329062342643738, -0.7646589875221252, -0.30705392360687256, -0.8431826233863831, 0.14532826840877533, -0.863796591758728, 0.34771692752838135, -0.2583654224872589, 0.2140050232410431, 0.6569420099258423, 0.24950537085533142, 0.3403012752532959, -0.18006832897663116, 0.04755254462361336, 0.32203570008277893, 0.7632821202278137, -0.40545690059661865, -1.0166596174240112, 0.1492004245519638, -0.02976488508284092, 0.1652708500623703, 0.9971659183502197, 0.5087475776672363, -0.2527391314506531, -0.007521788123995066, -0.35123297572135925, 0.6446047425270081, 0.4268587529659271, -0.5946387648582458, -0.06467873603105545, 0.255573570728302, 0.4370940327644348, 0.34367766976356506, -0.11446138471364975, -0.9265128970146179, 0.43858519196510315, -0.21017411351203918, 0.07725337892770767, -0.8592432737350464, 0.19375625252723694, -0.3397207260131836, -0.29060646891593933, 1.3535877466201782, -0.8165953159332275, 0.01905754767358303, 0.4173028767108917, 0.04276449605822563, -0.09471740573644638, 0.1914559304714203, -0.6724530458450317, -0.8057027459144592, -1.0713117122650146, -1.0152981281280518, -0.05069940164685249, 0.006652492564171553, 0.4714539051055908, 0.5711768865585327, 0.0017932301852852106, -0.3906320035457611, -0.5396511554718018, 0.7959235906600952, 0.3029423654079437, -0.4390321671962738, -0.6280418634414673, 0.4462931454181671, -0.30592015385627747, 0.6298801898956299, -0.09141124784946442, -0.4398376941680908, -0.8219446539878845, 0.4211655855178833, -0.18412275612354279, -0.8918691277503967, -1.0837875604629517, -0.11428298056125641, -0.043572697788476944, 1.017812728881836, 0.0513865128159523, -0.05153920501470566, 0.6340630054473877, 0.3453713059425354, -0.6038816571235657, 0.473779559135437, -0.45019033551216125, -0.011478167958557606, 0.8792871236801147, -0.7025269269943237, -0.09991706162691116, -0.047318898141384125, -0.049118854105472565, 0.23117393255233765, 0.2440013736486435, 0.08556215465068817, 0.3177737593650818, -0.9694733023643494, 0.9067504405975342, 0.28080764412879944, -0.20936647057533264, -0.6287858486175537, 0.28651565313339233, 0.2330876737833023, 0.057736288756132126, -0.7046194672584534, -0.5053507685661316, 0.2378668636083603, -0.2567199468612671, 1.0888371467590332, -0.15603743493556976, -0.35667961835861206, 0.024894827976822853, -0.160687655210495, -0.14419738948345184, -0.9882769584655762, 0.03315412998199463, 0.5577183365821838, -0.6409631967544556, 0.6827804446220398, 0.5096302628517151, 0.7598613500595093, 0.4666801691055298, 0.47685563564300537, 0.7011001110076904, -0.3560045063495636, -0.4095882773399353, 0.01752629317343235, 0.692310094833374, -0.30122148990631104, 0.025733791291713715, -0.4389699697494507, 0.7859163284301758, 0.09952769428491592, -0.7312528491020203, -0.1393275260925293, 0.5399974584579468, 0.8304190039634705, 0.9934386610984802, -0.34063372015953064, -0.11092493683099747, 0.9229626655578613, 1.0802116394042969, -0.3064905107021332, -0.302059143781662, -0.9519748687744141, -1.0461195707321167, -0.6255469918251038, 0.5745665431022644, -0.55412358045578, -0.7830184698104858, 0.7379586100578308, -0.03165334090590477, -1.111872673034668, -0.19886523485183716, 1.2529312372207642, -0.6761696338653564, -0.6538470983505249, -0.5276407599449158, 0.3554024398326874, -1.0836257934570312, -0.2670881450176239, -0.2103070169687271, -0.9475113153457642, -0.2211829423904419, 1.3854396343231201, -0.4037180542945862, 0.04663868248462677, -0.04221143200993538, 0.26119115948677063, -0.4589206874370575, 0.15848565101623535, -0.3207876980304718, -0.632830798625946, -0.19257128238677979, 0.7626978158950806, 0.0848437175154686, 0.22626447677612305, 0.5918484330177307, -0.2889658510684967, 0.4868606626987457, 0.3012086749076843, 0.3952670097351074, -0.5254577398300171, 0.029700729995965958, 0.2760371267795563, -0.570597767829895, -0.3916304111480713, -0.17671608924865723, 0.8856696486473083, -1.1356658935546875, -0.36571192741394043, -0.7206361293792725, -0.34626856446266174, 0.018757523968815804, 0.2987760901451111, 0.244178906083107, 0.8774136304855347, 0.11962620168924332, 0.08741455525159836, -0.15492253005504608, 0.500129759311676, 0.018088525161147118, 0.12698237597942352, 0.44818124175071716, -0.1756262481212616, 0.254169762134552, -1.1640950441360474, 0.5439574718475342, -0.12922634184360504, -1.1961878538131714, -0.17972485721111298, -0.6879869103431702, 0.21301499009132385, 0.55134516954422, 0.40341755747795105, 0.299138605594635, 0.9262668490409851, -0.24705851078033447, 0.5908846259117126, 0.27117249369621277, 0.06790871918201447, -0.6926809549331665, 0.16493667662143707, -0.8039674758911133, -0.8404649496078491, 0.5056555271148682, -0.3420989215373993, -0.3988933563232422, -0.5166662335395813, -0.6241240501403809, 0.605095624923706, -0.2557692527770996, 0.645850419998169, 0.2667396664619446, 0.7624261379241943, -0.10097266733646393, -0.003374649677425623, 0.1941981464624405, -0.5700920820236206, 0.6216904520988464, -0.44724753499031067, -0.5457112193107605, -0.6109346151351929, 0.09351321309804916, 0.2824406027793884, 0.40969836711883545, 0.05289847403764725, -0.40330970287323, 0.37327107787132263, 0.2503584325313568, -0.33638009428977966, -0.23787277936935425, 0.664332389831543, -0.5127697587013245, 0.2612876296043396, -0.5279533267021179, -0.5176787972450256, -0.5158413648605347, 0.4676740765571594, 0.2502727508544922, -0.9097161293029785, -0.43158262968063354, -0.07848528772592545, 0.7064415216445923, -0.6564815640449524, -0.0168848168104887, -0.5918720960617065, 0.5612824559211731, -0.1810440868139267, -0.0518115758895874, -0.10453493893146515, 0.7066167593002319, 0.2825688421726227, -0.44664835929870605, -0.2271127700805664, 0.8250953555107117, 1.1679277420043945, 0.6302974820137024, 0.06134414300322533, 0.7480867505073547, -0.29178038239479065, 0.660132646560669, -0.3747164309024811, -0.540337860584259, 0.7014232277870178, 0.35731491446495056, -0.3323454260826111, 0.2355143427848816, 0.3110547661781311, 0.8032200336456299, -0.199982151389122, -0.5878652930259705, 0.36864495277404785, 0.23178957402706146, -0.34909674525260925, -0.624062716960907, 0.47367173433303833, 0.7988977432250977, 0.020433899015188217, 0.8424519300460815, 0.16315796971321106, 0.0632937103509903, 0.21494872868061066, 0.27464959025382996, 0.6368001699447632, 0.16833409667015076, -0.6736558675765991, -0.20590433478355408, 0.29618948698043823, 0.26596999168395996, 0.04760860651731491, 0.6486960053443909, -0.3013709783554077, -0.24226918816566467, 0.6665012836456299, 0.18614469468593597, -0.5919995903968811, 0.22553205490112305, -0.26088571548461914, -0.15014801919460297, -0.2972790598869324, -0.3742351830005646, -0.30957451462745667, -0.32765698432922363, 0.5080232620239258, -0.6804437041282654, 0.08439213037490845, 0.13445833325386047, -0.05250810459256172, 0.47228044271469116, 0.1829395741224289, 0.7967233657836914, -0.43294408917427063, 1.1179592609405518, 0.3458312153816223, -0.05895795300602913, -0.38412997126579285, -0.08609084784984589, -0.19775718450546265, 0.2837322950363159, 0.00036308614653535187, 0.34237900376319885, 0.6845127940177917, -0.5398462414741516, -0.45009899139404297, 0.02038504369556904, -0.8158897161483765, -0.6903072595596313, -0.44298550486564636, -0.29264968633651733, -0.016095802187919617, 0.6690830588340759, -0.11382532119750977, -0.3754313886165619, 0.02615370973944664, 0.33370113372802734, -0.2775086462497711, -0.588503897190094, -0.2068767547607422, 0.7666701674461365, -0.6796513795852661, 0.056500185281038284, -0.5086755752563477, -0.39676105976104736, -0.5090923309326172, -0.7355772852897644, -0.5773335099220276, 0.3728792071342468, 0.0399489663541317, -0.9590218663215637, 0.4867027699947357, 0.14713174104690552, 0.5716711282730103, 0.14453470706939697, -0.35732153058052063, -0.270049124956131, 0.30630308389663696, 0.8547173738479614, -0.5621947646141052, 0.31131798028945923, 0.4152975380420685, 0.33743980526924133, -0.06786397099494934, 0.18831440806388855, 0.315687894821167, 0.2738952040672302, -0.6104005575180054, 0.09742569923400879, 0.45088738203048706, 0.2437051385641098, -0.3801489472389221, 0.4812923073768616, 0.6521689295768738, -0.11375325173139572, -0.05666712671518326, -0.8311359286308289, -0.37231504917144775, -0.47865504026412964, 1.7581799030303955, 0.09439107775688171, 0.1642690896987915, 0.1751507967710495, -0.7631102204322815, 0.5593348145484924, -1.197387933731079, 3.917527198791504, 1.6359491348266602, 0.4971674382686615, -0.3108060359954834, 0.5005518198013306, 0.22180406749248505, 0.47036680579185486, -0.3273269236087799, 0.11728440970182419, 0.4741259813308716, -0.2617749869823456, 0.672196090221405, -0.27471959590911865, -0.6262425780296326, 0.6167712211608887, -0.21829339861869812, -0.7780126333236694, 0.17213153839111328, -0.2141430824995041, -0.6159491539001465, -0.3850272297859192, 0.7951251864433289, -0.1508631408214569, -0.5887309312820435, -0.03967077657580376, -0.21943403780460358, 0.5697987079620361, -0.24914772808551788, -0.25690901279449463, -0.39016473293304443, -0.26113539934158325, -1.0248452425003052, -0.23219797015190125, -0.8657224774360657, -0.2992258369922638, 0.4419321119785309, -0.4353507459163666, -0.32601991295814514, -0.12596137821674347, -0.38895827531814575, 0.09570124000310898, -0.006607661023736, -0.5305837988853455, -0.045743320137262344, -0.45902031660079956, 0.4002247452735901, -0.5015197992324829, 0.4016340374946594, 0.8012955784797668, -0.6189066171646118, 1.0392650365829468, -1.168666958808899, 0.20933988690376282, 0.17701338231563568, -0.7443585991859436, -0.3639550507068634, -0.4775333106517792, -1.047532558441162, 0.5713114142417908, 0.23849749565124512, 0.34236574172973633, 0.054734837263822556, -0.02484539896249771, 0.3275551199913025, 0.4058818221092224, 0.6482114791870117, 0.658027708530426, 0.0838722363114357, 0.026840852573513985, -0.09297508746385574, 0.24192212522029877, 0.4501636028289795, -0.7305529117584229, 0.45632821321487427, 0.7030652165412903, 0.400027334690094, -0.6062873005867004, 0.5924381613731384, -0.010189597494900227, -0.39512044191360474, 0.14410531520843506, 0.6437662243843079, 0.006745527498424053, -0.006646967958658934, 0.019002852961421013, 1.0732933282852173, -0.18939699232578278, -0.047603532671928406, -1.3494120836257935, 0.6804099678993225, 0.559716522693634, -0.382744163274765, 0.37656065821647644, -0.6520274877548218, 0.05408114939928055 ]
{"Title": "Psychiatric comorbid disorders of cognition: A machine learning approach using 1,175 UK Biobank participants", "Authors": "Li Chenlu, Gheorghe Delia A., Gallacher John E.J., Bauermeister Sarah", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Conceptualising comorbidity is complex and the term is used variously. Here, it is the coexistence of two or more diagnoses which might be defined as \u2018chronic\u2019 and, although they may be pathologically related, they may also act independently 1 . Of interest here is the comorbidity of common psychiatric disorders and impaired cognition. Objectives To examine whether anxiety and/or depression are important longitudinal predictors of cognitive change. Methods UK Biobank participants used at three time points (n= 502,664): baseline, 1 st follow-up (n= 20,257) and 1 st imaging study (n=40,199). Participants with no missing data were 1,175 participants aged 40 to 70 years, 41% female. Machine learning (ML) was applied and the main outcome measure of reaction time intraindividual variability (cognition) was used. Findings Using the area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curve, the anxiety model achieves the best performance with an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.68, followed by the depression model with an AUC of 0.63. The cardiovascular and diabetes model, and the covariates model have weaker performance in predicting cognition, with an AUC of 0.60 and 0.56, respectively. Conclusions Outcomes suggest psychiatric disorders are more important comorbidities of long-term cognitive change than diabetes and cardiovascular disease, and demographic factors. Findings suggest that psychiatric disorders (anxiety and depression) may have a deleterious effect on long-term cognition and should be considered as an important comorbid disorder of cognitive decline. Clinical implications Important predictive effects of poor mental health on longitudinal cognitive decline should be considered in secondary and also primary care. Summary Box What is already known about this subject? 3-4 bullet points Poor mental health is associated with cognitive deficits. One in four older adults experience a decline in affective state with increasing age. ML approaches have certain advantages in identifying patterns of information useful for the prediction of an outcome. What are the new findings? 3-4 bullet points Psychiatric disorders are important comorbid disorders of long-term cognitive change. Machine-learning methods such as sequence learning based methods are able to offer non-parametric joint modelling, allow for multiplicity of factors and provide prediction models that are more robust and accurate for longitudinal data The outcome of the RNN analysis found that anxiety and depression were stronger predictors of change IIV over time than either cardiovascular disease and diabetes or the covariate variables. How might it impact on clinical practice in the foreseeable future? The important predictive effect of mental health on longitudinal cognition should be noted and, its comorbidity relationship with other conditions such as cardiovascular disease likewise to be considered in primary care and other clinical settings", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19006189"}
10.1101/19012138
[ -0.1340702921152115, -0.6622700691223145, 0.1108492985367775, -0.09118923544883728, -0.4714373052120209, 0.9549543857574463, -0.1683356612920761, 0.4495609402656555, -0.40303394198417664, 0.41577407717704773, -0.14441056549549103, -0.2151537388563156, -0.19982272386550903, -1.0473324060440063, -0.4321715831756592, 0.325248658657074, 0.7226456999778748, 0.08665836602449417, 0.3515692353248596, -0.7477169632911682, 0.9303218722343445, 0.33379846811294556, -0.9489441514015198, -0.7107072472572327, -0.30523940920829773, 0.2453262209892273, 0.4640890061855316, 0.1258656084537506, 1.0706859827041626, 0.7246564030647278, 0.34972628951072693, -0.4344702959060669, -0.3965078294277191, -0.5519230961799622, -0.2525275647640228, -0.6281309723854065, 1.1400943994522095, -0.37370565533638, 0.370662122964859, -0.23535509407520294, -0.22977794706821442, 0.38919970393180847, -0.19072984158992767, -0.5237156748771667, -0.05899466201663017, -0.7826525568962097, -1.0548876523971558, -0.09071570634841919, 0.5544918775558472, -0.5052077770233154, 0.06681004166603088, 0.22592325508594513, 0.06090458482503891, -0.1129266694188118, 0.17638902366161346, 0.017724087461829185, 0.9908143281936646, -0.10728573799133301, -0.16321581602096558, 0.37435492873191833, 0.1428138017654419, 0.14948773384094238, 0.8701903820037842, -0.9935786724090576, 0.608532190322876, 0.8560391664505005, -0.07644565403461456, -0.33746790885925293, 0.045092739164829254, -0.13399818539619446, -0.005354069638997316, 0.019636953249573708, -0.9246465563774109, -0.27453240752220154, -1.0448863506317139, 0.3168599009513855, 0.704239010810852, 0.20227937400341034, -0.28463754057884216, 0.819473385810852, 0.44739943742752075, 0.570942759513855, 0.5706731081008911, 0.01754872314631939, 0.050727929919958115, -0.15883617103099823, 1.2294481992721558, 0.04596511274576187, 0.500661313533783, -0.11277572065591812, 0.18025903403759003, 0.7457130551338196, -0.6216136813163757, -0.03203492984175682, 0.10379637777805328, 0.5986844301223755, -0.8609546422958374, 0.3984450697898865, 0.16645804047584534, -0.6105301380157471, 0.653407096862793, 0.7521679997444153, -0.30908939242362976, 0.7824715971946716, -0.8024024367332458, 0.6862190961837769, 0.8122310638427734, 0.7750762104988098, -0.6359046697616577, -0.1651126593351364, 1.1089649200439453, -0.09797392785549164, -0.8718087673187256, 0.3071797788143158, -0.3817542493343353, 0.12864981591701508, 0.4803906977176666, 0.016024792566895485, 0.019347108900547028, -0.5242888927459717, 1.0475718975067139, 0.0859563872218132, 0.21218638122081757, 0.8189424276351929, 0.06968175619840622, -0.6879936456680298, -0.041426241397857666, 0.6156577467918396, -0.8052008152008057, 0.20386524498462677, 0.0018879998242482543, -0.47768738865852356, -0.4076237082481384, 0.6987568140029907, 0.5465115904808044, -0.914043664932251, 0.7429311275482178, 0.2057075947523117, 0.019083259627223015, -0.1492767035961151, -0.3341732919216156, 0.264602392911911, -0.32205790281295776, 1.341260313987732, -0.3709111213684082, 0.09898795932531357, -0.2495441734790802, 0.37352612614631653, -0.11350994557142258, -0.15374213457107544, -0.9592688679695129, -0.4958168864250183, 0.2539980113506317, 0.6306054592132568, -0.1125582903623581, 1.0835456848144531, -0.48512765765190125, -0.36735349893569946, 0.3209637701511383, 0.9301022887229919, -0.517062246799469, 1.1910083293914795, -0.206823468208313, 0.8802490830421448, 0.1183856651186943, 0.041442785412073135, -0.27146899700164795, 0.3818163275718689, 0.5586977005004883, -0.22585433721542358, 0.5053057670593262, 0.6236362457275391, -0.4963013827800751, -0.19369567930698395, 0.19530312716960907, 0.6776390671730042, 0.502483069896698, 0.3435334861278534, 0.31718847155570984, 0.5936383008956909, 0.03025623969733715, 0.0901094600558281, 1.2002737522125244, 1.392730474472046, -0.6809737086296082, 0.3848194479942322, 0.007195012643933296, -0.278774231672287, -0.38456180691719055, 0.12169651687145233, -0.4993935823440552, 0.8125132322311401, 0.3613540828227997, 0.2590809762477875, -0.3821025490760803, 0.4084851145744324, -0.11969683319330215, 0.2724565863609314, 0.18415236473083496, -0.7260110378265381, 0.21116310358047485, 0.11025459319353104, -0.2886154353618622, 0.09861444681882858, -1.0691293478012085, 0.5005661249160767, 0.7006625533103943, 0.9771952629089355, -0.4581112563610077, 0.28667205572128296, 1.4753836393356323, 0.5504400730133057, 0.5674861073493958, -0.6365236043930054, 0.5807706713676453, -0.3732273280620575, -0.6076095700263977, 0.4741072952747345, 0.27242788672447205, 0.7152040004730225, 0.2621026635169983, 0.008814973756670952, -0.3489307761192322, -0.23104658722877502, 0.09334331005811691, -0.2984048128128052, 0.9686613082885742, 0.910071849822998, -0.11545545607805252, -0.7955724000930786, -0.09515299648046494, 0.6506986618041992, -0.36658647656440735, 0.012144004926085472, 0.8004606366157532, -1.2611411809921265, 0.15894825756549835, 1.4624534845352173, 0.04925582557916641, -0.2200300544500351, 0.34033286571502686, 0.3345997929573059, 0.3251551687717438, 0.539697527885437, -0.15582428872585297, 0.07569169253110886, -0.2589184641838074, 0.061081986874341965, -0.17045223712921143, 0.7473171353340149, -0.1672285497188568, 0.4272927939891815, 0.5091087818145752, -0.26134824752807617, -1.030914306640625, -0.6161670088768005, 0.2232753038406372, -0.30140018463134766, -0.14502589404582977, -0.15743383765220642, 0.5435319542884827, 0.7409834861755371, -0.0429709330201149, -0.15568260848522186, 0.6966316103935242, 0.00015463537420146167, 0.21990318596363068, 0.48605993390083313, 0.35296499729156494, -0.7191777229309082, -1.0135483741760254, -0.8250664472579956, -2.0569536685943604, -0.33868375420570374, -0.25397515296936035, 0.5222039222717285, 0.23855070769786835, -1.4256021976470947, 0.6641252636909485, -0.15615896880626678, -0.2008606195449829, 0.032650429755449295, 0.20541054010391235, -0.04164222627878189, 0.12552155554294586, 0.9744395613670349, -0.6738426089286804, 0.38655728101730347, -0.16439121961593628, 0.9151284694671631, -0.8202109336853027, -0.11405430734157562, -0.4621249735355377, -0.3523280918598175, 0.38307130336761475, -0.4867212474346161, -0.175674170255661, 0.31688088178634644, -0.6488210558891296, -1.1174044609069824, 0.1520138829946518, 0.01953805424273014, -0.3806859850883484, -0.6974998712539673, -0.42138898372650146, 0.12682579457759857, -0.4070853590965271, 0.05034644156694412, 0.9556584358215332, -0.6155627369880676, -0.3423141539096832, 0.9832912683486938, -0.23705995082855225, 0.9676040410995483, -0.7199432849884033, 0.8264747262001038, 0.16855710744857788, 0.008177218958735466, 0.3458191454410553, -1.242777943611145, -0.6172693967819214, -0.6969617009162903, -0.2578642964363098, -0.8154751062393188, -0.4144585132598877, -0.25751587748527527, 0.904817521572113, -1.3960423469543457, 0.5835922360420227, -1.0182815790176392, -0.22254332900047302, 0.602080762386322, -0.09590895473957062, 1.2653063535690308, -0.18042969703674316, 0.23721319437026978, -0.2422737181186676, -0.6524133682250977, -0.0697367861866951, -0.26645195484161377, 0.7891005277633667, -1.0378426313400269, -0.47291693091392517, 0.45220133662223816, -0.2299058586359024, 0.25073397159576416, -0.10131282359361649, -0.3111518621444702, 0.30928000807762146, 0.24886564910411835, -0.30427515506744385, 0.1780906617641449, -0.09800548851490021, 0.4086975157260895, -0.2162708193063736, 0.4961012899875641, -0.2038084864616394, -0.7338871359825134, -0.2973945736885071, 0.21977700293064117, -0.8166615962982178, 0.556885302066803, 0.2525947391986847, -0.6681320071220398, 0.3055075705051422, -0.7642861604690552, -0.6822617650032043, -0.026804646477103233, 0.2983885109424591, -0.9426482915878296, -0.047023043036460876, 0.13631531596183777, -0.5532464981079102, 0.37291309237480164, 0.20457220077514648, 0.005168258678168058, 0.695917546749115, -0.7597926259040833, 0.5861833095550537, -0.926807701587677, -0.8563748002052307, 0.029761554673314095, 1.1142313480377197, 0.9282628893852234, -0.5134223699569702, 0.1640329360961914, -0.8675753474235535, 0.28782209753990173, -1.1815823316574097, -0.20798756182193756, -1.000104308128357, 0.022201817482709885, -0.33872151374816895, -0.013506997376680374, -0.8194751143455505, -0.7850963473320007, 0.7915831804275513, 0.2794833183288574, 0.4501723051071167, 0.7835124731063843, 1.0953336954116821, -0.18504194915294647, -0.05209336802363396, 0.41697612404823303, -0.1336931586265564, -0.2809004783630371, -0.4606758654117584, 0.5577873587608337, -0.2817296087741852, -0.5649897456169128, -0.3464639484882355, -0.11626891046762466, 0.12329600006341934, 0.4925527274608612, 0.792264997959137, -0.012637941166758537, -0.21789434552192688, 0.33003997802734375, 0.759486973285675, -0.3998926281929016, -0.999945878982544, 0.7148847579956055, -0.8205924034118652, 0.46496888995170593, 0.7569135427474976, 0.10771523416042328, 0.38958844542503357, -0.6824797987937927, 1.1877163648605347, 0.3995250165462494, 0.5666100382804871, -1.0300205945968628, 0.5684046149253845, -1.0197603702545166, -0.4563855528831482, 0.6929230690002441, -0.22168485820293427, -0.3243260383605957, -0.17807523906230927, 0.19743254780769348, 0.4787120223045349, 0.3324046730995178, -0.52813720703125, -0.4010789394378662, -0.42527246475219727, -0.45215386152267456, 0.7754325866699219, 0.9214093089103699, -0.6927139163017273, 0.26521357893943787, 0.6185552477836609, -0.5305482745170593, 0.9785479307174683, -0.3039843738079071, -0.7888798713684082, 0.25555485486984253, 0.2264152616262436, -1.1082576513290405, -0.4249172806739807, -0.07015527784824371, 0.31851279735565186, 0.08939241617918015, 0.09460237622261047, -0.313516765832901, -1.1558345556259155, 1.284109115600586, -0.0479520708322525, 0.7889730930328369, 0.11792168766260147, 0.37499046325683594, 0.490389883518219, 0.29263460636138916, -0.8182657957077026, -0.8116968870162964, -0.09543172270059586, -0.9642854332923889, -0.25001847743988037, 0.22469744086265564, 0.2522834539413452, 0.680772602558136, 0.10509581118822098, -0.010978225618600845, -0.13701438903808594, -0.045109376311302185, -0.3800501823425293, -0.497717946767807, 0.15668222308158875, -0.1857866495847702, -0.556857705116272, 0.5085296630859375, -0.5660260319709778, 0.15548019111156464, -0.11929810792207718, 0.4747175872325897, -0.9399985074996948, -0.32193565368652344, -0.3002697825431824, -1.0228328704833984, -0.22786223888397217, 0.9948296546936035, 0.3656911849975586, -0.17548714578151703, -0.2312547117471695, -0.07671236246824265, 0.9234591722488403, -0.6790940165519714, -0.7984944581985474, -0.7376134991645813, 0.043267615139484406, 0.31384578347206116, 0.043291155248880386, 0.29221034049987793, -0.2288602888584137, 0.29715675115585327, -0.367997407913208, 0.1869252324104309, 0.7473470568656921, 0.5561621189117432, 0.11953481286764145, 0.7415181398391724, 0.25903913378715515, -1.0758239030838013, -0.7849957346916199, -0.2561419904232025, -0.3112231492996216, 0.21740564703941345, 0.3799412250518799, -1.4365160465240479, -0.7627295255661011, -0.08111712336540222, 0.39372363686561584, -0.846338152885437, -0.3073514401912689, -1.243747591972351, -0.11331304162740707, -0.5157862901687622, 0.8093395233154297, 0.0759706050157547, -0.16646432876586914, 0.08256019651889801, -0.4916735589504242, 0.23172424733638763, 0.6508061289787292, 0.2676110565662384, -0.6621875762939453, -0.9397268295288086, -0.7124423980712891, 1.7001985311508179, 0.10811195522546768, -0.5354512929916382, -0.6087167263031006, -0.26186028122901917, 0.13802966475486755, 0.17212355136871338, -0.32676976919174194, -0.4919990599155426, 0.21145978569984436, -0.9936304688453674, 0.23670253157615662, -0.2576681971549988, -1.3493367433547974, 0.3258519768714905, -0.44942641258239746, 0.3364960849285126, 0.48011651635169983, -0.7335190773010254, 0.053671710193157196, -0.25791633129119873, 1.0536483526229858, -0.134329691529274, 0.9223739504814148, 0.298685759305954, 0.12761837244033813, -0.6934717297554016, 1.322645902633667, -0.29428184032440186, -0.023092105984687805, -1.09134042263031, -0.6888967752456665, 0.29583409428596497, -0.06552710384130478, -0.2545597553253174, -0.005316352006047964, -0.0685306042432785, 0.2817334830760956, -0.5469828844070435, 0.7977920174598694, 1.1134852170944214, -0.11566738784313202, -0.7997767925262451, -0.16738224029541016, 0.5289381742477417, 0.32887470722198486, -0.9347895383834839, 0.4238012135028839, -1.0207972526550293, -0.46854472160339355, 0.1795467585325241, 0.040879279375076294, -0.13643671572208405, -0.28886380791664124, 0.16022291779518127, 0.7327179908752441, -0.2375447303056717, 0.8771213293075562, -0.5145074725151062, -1.0324592590332031, 0.1441214382648468, 0.5738523006439209, 0.1436586230993271, 0.7358850240707397, 0.330523282289505, -0.7025102376937866, -0.11187898367643356, 0.2889499366283417, 0.3825039863586426, -0.5853322744369507, -0.1614498794078827, 1.2299319505691528, 0.20438896119594574, -0.8679645657539368, -0.15655909478664398, 0.30310875177383423, -1.177506446838379, -0.7206462025642395, 0.17723974585533142, -0.5174350738525391, 0.35207733511924744, -0.03686013072729111, 0.11870891600847244, 0.8877943158149719, 0.044119108468294144, 0.023919781669974327, 0.6532472968101501, -0.15921367704868317, 0.2288254350423813, -0.4451545774936676, 0.3345855176448822, -0.4184931814670563, 0.8170020580291748, 1.6873003244400024, 0.06826591491699219, -0.7726753354072571, 0.05022037774324417, 0.5846103429794312, -0.002153163542971015, -0.17041924595832825, 0.5232992768287659, -0.23342148959636688, 0.4639015793800354, 0.3354642689228058, 0.16986823081970215, 0.4331480860710144, -0.1668032854795456, -0.4304848611354828, 0.40246284008026123, 0.5755914449691772, -1.2657470703125, -0.2193889170885086, 0.019900262355804443, -0.178641676902771, 0.2396942377090454, -0.7191805243492126, 0.15411823987960815, 0.2566189765930176, 0.2989228069782257, -0.4527665972709656, -0.2378934621810913, -0.7321453094482422, -0.41858938336372375, -0.1516946405172348, 0.16035155951976776, -0.1536078155040741, -0.528765857219696, -0.47414982318878174, 0.06900886446237564, 0.3575930595397949, -0.4368405044078827, -0.28186729550361633, -0.7616123557090759, 0.40375182032585144, -0.1025562733411789, -0.3578781187534332, -0.08192571252584457, -1.1283882856369019, -0.28518611192703247, -0.5517157912254333, -0.044595081359148026, 0.13498243689537048, -0.49844682216644287, 0.37195274233818054, 0.040950920432806015, 0.12123669683933258, 0.44353851675987244, -0.3026182949542999, 0.19455933570861816, 0.14459776878356934, -0.5765596032142639, 0.6958979964256287, -0.318844735622406, 0.6733733415603638, 0.373226135969162, 0.22730721533298492, 0.8559901714324951, -0.38636162877082825, -0.8801822066307068, 0.23943693935871124, -0.035452522337436676, -0.04172338545322418, -0.6653397083282471, -0.7460841536521912, 0.28036466240882874, 0.10819105803966522, -0.7306947708129883, -0.6711531281471252, -0.09037228673696518, -0.018932973966002464, 0.7346178293228149, -0.46105244755744934, -1.2339611053466797, 0.013310502283275127, -0.2745458483695984, 0.3312920033931732, -0.22507596015930176, 0.17783744633197784, 0.2654383182525635, 0.18012897670269012, 0.4310981035232544, -0.1401011198759079, 0.007696868386119604, 0.015101682394742966, -0.7372334599494934, 0.5352813005447388, 0.07898174226284027, 0.25834810733795166, 0.4495967924594879, 0.3894570469856262, -0.7683284282684326, -0.14236842095851898, -0.269611656665802, 0.4084475636482239, 0.11411646008491516, -0.23194825649261475, 0.9117971658706665, -0.06746016442775726, -0.655570924282074, 0.04962270334362984, -0.40094804763793945, -0.5914198756217957, 0.21616025269031525, -0.2647017538547516, 0.011735626496374607, -0.7245284914970398, 0.18072135746479034, 0.12098462879657745, 0.47748488187789917, 1.3884600400924683, 0.8029478192329407, -0.7130857110023499, 0.1446474939584732, 0.6768540143966675, -0.1704789102077484, -0.09422870725393295, -0.7631407380104065, 0.10575973987579346, -0.2977346181869507, -0.47490638494491577, 0.6809421181678772, 0.7713057398796082, 0.08869459480047226, 0.25108572840690613, -0.587797999382019, 0.19749978184700012, 0.08981681615114212, -0.05527360364794731, 0.5697947144508362, -0.455952525138855, -1.0850833654403687, 0.31842470169067383, -0.30193960666656494, 0.09366737306118011, -0.2630467414855957, -0.542411744594574, 0.5667311549186707, 0.22569206357002258, -0.8703773617744446, -0.45190584659576416, 0.6991514563560486, -0.20627224445343018, 0.1958034336566925, -0.44960036873817444, -0.10877705365419388, -0.2871643304824829, 0.09883138537406921, 0.3329741954803467, 0.5721942186355591, 0.6572737097740173, 0.06771909445524216, -0.2282988578081131, 0.757216215133667, 0.3359294831752777, -0.626437246799469, -0.4753747582435608, 0.3540186583995819, -0.4334258437156677, -1.223251223564148, -0.19893509149551392, -0.22518925368785858, 0.2347755879163742, -0.12723903357982635, -0.34100696444511414, 0.7670442461967468, -0.2584892809391022, -0.5643465518951416, 0.19993045926094055, 0.4133732318878174, 1.3105398416519165, -0.08304646611213684, -0.38429754972457886, -0.7049906253814697, 0.4155959486961365, 0.49778223037719727, 0.4525183141231537, 0.5367798805236816, 0.5460695624351501, 0.5546206831932068, -0.18995346128940582, 0.06613431125879288, 0.8536310195922852, -0.19186659157276154, -0.39859244227409363, -0.5447136759757996, 0.3492032289505005, -0.37484902143478394, 0.7851657867431641, 0.5692722201347351, -0.8778489828109741, -0.07500467449426651, 0.38484084606170654, -0.17145952582359314, -0.2584269642829895, 0.018400054425001144, -0.26420632004737854, -0.6714001893997192, -0.5803678035736084, 0.8187062740325928, -0.7084866762161255, -0.041324399411678314, 1.0630409717559814, -0.08298154175281525, -0.5196698307991028, -0.4166862964630127, 0.17343246936798096, 0.5915237665176392, 0.3653120994567871, 1.3101481199264526, 0.011864003725349903, 0.7041798233985901, 0.968542754650116, 0.10655295103788376, 0.0028329300694167614, -0.10854548960924149, -0.06536690890789032, -0.8436796069145203, 0.6089234948158264, -0.70229172706604, 0.24737492203712463, -0.20687547326087952, -0.21376463770866394, 0.4098339378833771, -0.18378522992134094, -0.2895877957344055, -0.018374787643551826, 0.737849235534668, 0.004708610009402037, 0.48506444692611694, 0.22363221645355225, -0.46273073554039, 0.43045496940612793, 0.09656114876270294, -0.23698636889457703, 0.47054651379585266, -0.8244041800498962, -0.6289185881614685, -0.4862425923347473, 0.6981043815612793, 0.3208918869495392, -0.8985849618911743, 0.021731257438659668, -0.9124699831008911, -0.21329428255558014, 0.015897240489721298, -0.6367686986923218, -0.39482036232948303, 0.606791079044342, 0.2642247974872589, 0.08759665489196777, -0.0006701257661916316, 0.2793997526168823, 0.4335423707962036, 0.25474101305007935, 0.06786278635263443, 0.7682512998580933, 0.5569897890090942, 0.1889175921678543, 0.7237451076507568, 0.24847961962223053, -0.18144558370113373, 0.17523407936096191, -0.6665428876876831, -1.1274383068084717, -0.5604816675186157, 0.07504939287900925, -1.4378550052642822, -0.3703725337982178, -0.8684043884277344, 0.33116012811660767, 0.8530586957931519, -0.3787490725517273, -0.8508052229881287, 0.03285567834973335, -0.5434104204177856, -0.0334462895989418, -0.6206455826759338, -0.8309674263000488, -0.17939457297325134, 0.202936053276062, -0.11983564496040344, -1.261865496635437, 3.682584524154663, 1.8022698163986206, 0.19861850142478943, -0.10677061229944229, 0.13908010721206665, 0.8231300711631775, 0.4747936725616455, -0.6202961206436157, -0.11875548958778381, -0.2948051989078522, 0.15972840785980225, -0.15375694632530212, 0.37148144841194153, 0.5297330617904663, 0.8759429454803467, 0.5820761919021606, -0.2766193449497223, -0.27516570687294006, 0.40462639927864075, -0.6163445115089417, -0.12273706495761871, 0.23391805589199066, -0.8236533999443054, 0.4414810538291931, 0.22953267395496368, -0.434660941362381, -0.34591010212898254, 0.2975194454193115, -0.21777640283107758, -0.22879990935325623, -0.11103487014770508, 0.3001765012741089, -0.3611361086368561, -0.851565420627594, -0.5342689752578735, 0.16813424229621887, 0.24337570369243622, -0.3318949043750763, 0.05334201082587242, 0.36541128158569336, 0.26190000772476196, -0.5422568321228027, 0.02066194638609886, -1.3169926404953003, 0.16886067390441895, 0.1591869443655014, 0.2013283520936966, 0.45379209518432617, 1.1875405311584473, -0.7748642563819885, 0.48884129524230957, -0.07247741520404816, 0.31341689825057983, -0.4912315905094147, -1.1951022148132324, -0.06322557479143143, -0.2963046133518219, -1.0775578022003174, 0.8834110498428345, 0.06254603713750839, 0.1754569262266159, 0.248647078871727, -0.06582808494567871, 0.24385282397270203, -0.6060305833816528, 0.54862380027771, 0.18646712601184845, -0.06436265259981155, -0.24274103343486786, -0.8250401020050049, 0.039332129061222076, 0.0517052561044693, -0.6743357181549072, 0.18953576683998108, 0.10942187160253525, 1.2261991500854492, 0.1600198745727539, 0.21098342537879944, -0.41505345702171326, -0.6925193667411804, 0.18538518249988556, -0.31597161293029785, -0.5963426828384399, -0.3029969334602356, 0.9727200269699097, 1.4899437427520752, -0.4480311870574951, 0.8188863396644592, -0.9507924318313599, 0.2233927696943283, 0.4872171878814697, -0.9997295141220093, 0.2207893282175064, 0.14668703079223633, 0.2776889204978943 ]
{"Title": "Phylodynamics of pertussis in the vaccine era: transition to re-emergence", "Authors": "Bento Ana I., Taujale Rahil, Schot Corrie, Bosch Thijs, Mariman Rob, King Aaron A., Rohani Pejman", "Abstract": "This manuscript has been withdrawn following a formal investigation by the Indiana University Research Integrity Office.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012138"}
10.1101/19003053
[ 0.6819478273391724, 0.4197408854961395, -0.07099265605211258, 0.5915279984474182, -0.9936859607696533, -0.4028104245662689, -0.3109845817089081, 0.2348427176475525, 0.2781292498111725, 1.2781322002410889, -0.06757719814777374, -0.574727475643158, 0.5533004999160767, 0.08178006857633591, 0.6502617597579956, 0.16805310547351837, -0.33345577120780945, 0.11821574717760086, -0.42576533555984497, -0.05785350874066353, -0.34994158148765564, 0.2600167989730835, -0.32258889079093933, 0.28282925486564636, -0.7017436027526855, 0.6117585301399231, 0.33909356594085693, -0.02556571550667286, 1.0973317623138428, 0.1263870894908905, -0.5730599761009216, -0.5539268851280212, 0.1935775876045227, -0.7371633052825928, -0.10046299546957016, 0.0976681187748909, 0.8331280946731567, -0.37348735332489014, -0.4606476128101349, -1.2683844566345215, 0.5683124661445618, -0.8485040664672852, 0.42605772614479065, -0.5769376158714294, -0.3686754107475281, -0.8662385940551758, 0.27310046553611755, -0.35247570276260376, 0.3189045488834381, 0.8021568059921265, -0.774768590927124, 0.22398553788661957, 0.05326203629374504, -0.6794666647911072, -0.3886582553386688, 1.0182603597640991, -0.12242597341537476, -0.014512630179524422, -0.5750359296798706, -0.00926574133336544, 0.09138201922178268, 0.15074022114276886, 0.020617591217160225, -1.7964293956756592, 0.4032820761203766, 0.6502726674079895, -0.307176798582077, -0.48666369915008545, -0.11337461322546005, 0.07874094694852829, -0.28510627150535583, -0.0981522873044014, -0.6937974691390991, -0.45566004514694214, -0.4221968948841095, -0.7869529724121094, 0.3158695101737976, 0.08612257987260818, 0.764525830745697, -0.2773556411266327, -0.17584186792373657, -0.44719624519348145, -0.10735508799552917, 0.19482937455177307, 0.10147358477115631, 0.1120210736989975, -0.16404882073402405, 0.3816128075122833, 0.3057927191257477, 0.17144156992435455, -0.20264478027820587, 0.25698322057724, 0.12284613400697708, -0.023739557713270187, -0.30933326482772827, 0.6566385626792908, -0.6632869839668274, -0.21699367463588715, 0.14441291987895966, 0.30232343077659607, 0.27480238676071167, 0.4136248528957367, -0.37247762084007263, 0.7919201850891113, -0.26975616812705994, 0.9438842535018921, -0.01360782515257597, -0.42803525924682617, -0.5493867993354797, -0.46890494227409363, 0.3734651207923889, 0.21797341108322144, 0.09363025426864624, 0.008180323988199234, 1.1763765811920166, 0.7606156468391418, -0.3095172941684723, 0.6769363880157471, -0.27441099286079407, -0.3230057656764984, 0.13639545440673828, 0.41376933455467224, 0.6041344404220581, -0.26121294498443604, 0.3693360388278961, 0.8057553768157959, 0.37130895256996155, 0.4006042182445526, -1.1030510663986206, -0.14437416195869446, 0.7670518755912781, -0.9796208143234253, -0.7582632899284363, 0.7721460461616516, -0.3004581928253174, -0.5988920331001282, -0.15692944824695587, 0.4747001528739929, -0.15645329654216766, -0.040049806237220764, -0.8223497271537781, 0.31688979268074036, -0.22021770477294922, 1.0583127737045288, -0.14937688410282135, 0.9617551565170288, -1.1079413890838623, -1.321401596069336, -0.7171927690505981, -0.03999299183487892, 0.2602030038833618, 0.28283777832984924, -0.40958109498023987, 0.45310696959495544, -0.9317082762718201, -0.35215169191360474, -0.6772943139076233, 0.8903629183769226, 0.21508625149726868, 0.21214894950389862, 0.0836217924952507, -0.13365307450294495, -0.49508044123649597, 0.5454834699630737, -0.7379982471466064, 1.5115694999694824, -0.07946816831827164, -0.6489450931549072, 0.5203055739402771, -0.04619627818465233, 1.2308728694915771, -0.4725498855113983, 0.16896221041679382, -0.5026018619537354, 0.5404568314552307, 0.49040403962135315, 1.0998461246490479, 0.08909871429204941, 0.0824858620762825, 0.8656728863716125, 0.08768109977245331, -0.38290831446647644, -0.8167500495910645, 0.7024002075195312, -0.04358785226941109, 0.4210176169872284, -0.7530052065849304, -1.204715371131897, -0.10240496695041656, -0.20228412747383118, -0.42939096689224243, 0.39814239740371704, -0.6206547021865845, 0.730221152305603, -0.7574270963668823, -0.058247145265340805, -0.17425747215747833, 0.8151770234107971, -0.0563102662563324, -0.13980230689048767, -0.47877395153045654, -0.0897415354847908, 0.033908579498529434, 0.42025822401046753, -0.3791249394416809, 0.46755319833755493, -0.3296451270580292, 0.4519127309322357, -0.23891769349575043, 0.3450976014137268, 0.8293159604072571, -0.1525282859802246, 0.11515443027019501, 0.03618638217449188, 1.57769775390625, -0.19522473216056824, -0.1607469618320465, -0.2879428267478943, -0.15663014352321625, -0.23254446685314178, -0.6019097566604614, -0.06690327078104019, 0.8761236071586609, -0.055168937891721725, -0.29162490367889404, 0.11455335468053818, 0.23332074284553528, -0.598388135433197, 0.5412189960479736, -0.3557698726654053, 0.41222524642944336, 0.5240854024887085, -0.5094091296195984, 1.0182924270629883, 0.6831589341163635, 1.19752037525177, 0.21707622706890106, 0.13590107858181, -0.5397703647613525, -0.18653447926044464, 0.3402670621871948, 0.4391297698020935, -0.04397079348564148, 0.8634655475616455, -0.6153132319450378, 0.30826541781425476, -0.6597261428833008, 0.244069442152977, 0.11137878894805908, 0.913791298866272, -0.7928016185760498, 0.3825739920139313, 0.07701689004898071, -0.10902879387140274, -0.43135836720466614, -0.30523306131362915, 0.17607031762599945, 0.0437244176864624, 0.43473127484321594, -0.48989537358283997, -0.1253954917192459, 0.4807113707065582, 0.2007807493209839, -0.19318172335624695, 0.3822636306285858, 0.7465311288833618, 0.1958252489566803, -0.23555941879749298, 0.2017984837293625, -0.341399610042572, -0.5670300722122192, 0.03523906692862511, -1.403936743736267, -0.5122693181037903, -0.9892484545707703, -0.2209523767232895, 0.1789175420999527, -0.3616701364517212, 0.4291990101337433, 0.23297861218452454, 0.22598831355571747, -0.6795077323913574, -0.7279697060585022, 0.6811946630477905, -0.4427896738052368, 0.35096612572669983, -0.4655100405216217, 0.2775137722492218, -0.14017678797245026, 0.47166121006011963, -0.017080072313547134, -0.4487266540527344, -1.2931935787200928, -0.29931405186653137, 0.34340381622314453, -0.8181222677230835, -0.44529110193252563, -0.22253820300102234, -0.5112044811248779, -0.4821394085884094, 0.6220563054084778, -0.2240595817565918, -0.20024238526821136, -0.13420695066452026, -0.054913636296987534, 0.45509445667266846, -0.39229533076286316, 0.43575093150138855, 0.8256412744522095, 0.2826923131942749, -0.7175009846687317, 0.8261952996253967, 0.5009012222290039, 0.645079493522644, -0.4989790618419647, 0.4306797385215759, 0.29479947686195374, -0.2932271659374237, 0.590768039226532, -0.7610090970993042, -0.8780851364135742, -0.6027992367744446, 0.06420715153217316, -0.742485761642456, -0.12898936867713928, 0.25008055567741394, 0.19501441717147827, -0.7341541647911072, -0.20356807112693787, -0.3828980028629303, -1.232782006263733, -0.12746600806713104, 0.13661684095859528, 0.38108715415000916, -0.6234128475189209, -0.035791825503110886, -1.1458793878555298, 0.25099310278892517, 0.5576545596122742, -0.2464209347963333, 0.336131751537323, -1.3377876281738281, -0.2841729521751404, 0.931216299533844, 0.025816762819886208, 0.18905194103717804, -0.08635494858026505, -0.4872358441352844, 0.8029183745384216, -0.3402685225009918, -0.9121132493019104, -0.1768178790807724, -0.24542231857776642, -0.002139383228495717, 0.22547711431980133, -0.22853949666023254, 0.08215901255607605, -0.20313622057437897, -0.3251935839653015, -0.1725616157054901, 0.6130542755126953, 0.08437920361757278, 0.3599827289581299, 0.17546187341213226, -0.27450263500213623, -0.5340646505355835, -0.06851629912853241, 0.3635236620903015, 1.1353137493133545, -0.5109358429908752, 0.7128990888595581, 0.11609280854463577, -0.020709939301013947, -0.16699200868606567, 0.14527402818202972, 0.4172976613044739, 0.771203875541687, 0.20210537314414978, 1.234594464302063, -0.9808186292648315, -0.1894920915365219, 0.17111650109291077, 0.2847883403301239, 0.28104814887046814, -0.28918778896331787, -0.3208484351634979, -0.6760739088058472, 0.4010593891143799, -0.4815242290496826, -0.8564320206642151, -0.13577166199684143, 0.220076784491539, -0.5920597910881042, 0.21569207310676575, -0.7200925946235657, -0.4454909861087799, -0.1564912497997284, 0.15980485081672668, 0.1647050827741623, -0.4731147885322571, 0.8734395503997803, 0.09457217901945114, 0.09699759632349014, 0.1357150822877884, 0.026750370860099792, -0.8797261118888855, -0.5262988805770874, -0.12203361839056015, 0.28704386949539185, -1.1137217283248901, 0.08443118631839752, -0.2100137621164322, -0.41347938776016235, -0.0699031725525856, 0.4757167398929596, 0.1327284872531891, -0.38386479020118713, -0.28837311267852783, -0.7951856255531311, -0.2561042606830597, 0.40928488969802856, -0.085188128054142, -0.8607730865478516, -0.007839119993150234, 0.952685534954071, -0.44024938344955444, -0.4544427692890167, -0.7215250134468079, 0.7563005089759827, 0.6599982976913452, -0.6896619200706482, 0.11067632585763931, -0.20345395803451538, -0.0684792697429657, 0.0014583705924451351, 0.3858870267868042, -0.002877157414332032, 0.5336768627166748, 0.3738420903682709, 0.23384158313274384, -0.08099719136953354, -0.7143351435661316, 0.18015722930431366, 0.2536303997039795, 0.1644047200679779, 0.28904691338539124, 1.2401814460754395, 0.3189876973628998, 0.18698593974113464, -0.5304426550865173, 0.33741846680641174, -0.5379109382629395, 1.29896879196167, -0.45812487602233887, -1.2154502868652344, 0.13046401739120483, 0.06835497170686722, 0.22213530540466309, 0.2505510151386261, -0.030200377106666565, 0.08803252875804901, 0.06227078661322594, -0.29032954573631287, -0.3371904492378235, -0.3342020809650421, 0.6529764533042908, 0.024766022339463234, 0.809388279914856, 1.624079942703247, -0.3751094937324524, -0.015274165198206902, 0.211873859167099, -0.05311375483870506, -0.5917187929153442, -0.15375971794128418, -0.5152553915977478, -0.3011244833469391, -0.4076349139213562, -0.5541992783546448, 0.39838117361068726, -0.027325963601469994, 0.2539156973361969, -0.6507298350334167, 0.004980437457561493, -0.2903456389904022, -0.18727736175060272, -0.43067607283592224, -0.1769043207168579, -0.995073139667511, 0.9501451253890991, -0.36587271094322205, 0.06727463006973267, -0.36337485909461975, -0.18693611025810242, -0.039959605783224106, -0.20551252365112305, -0.048173390328884125, -0.3646765649318695, -0.7341647744178772, -0.7257795929908752, 0.411151260137558, -0.7199912667274475, -0.6858475208282471, 0.7339909076690674, 0.3963196277618408, -0.9884881973266602, 0.122190922498703, 0.33984270691871643, 1.2157387733459473, -0.2680076062679291, -0.02251298353075981, -0.40356355905532837, -0.6550403237342834, -0.4359906315803528, -0.4020797908306122, 0.17159956693649292, 0.3931022584438324, -0.03648260608315468, -0.43759581446647644, 1.345693588256836, 0.19074462354183197, -1.2974109649658203, -0.14592351019382477, 0.5634672045707703, 0.630103349685669, -0.045295365154743195, -0.4091935455799103, -0.25235599279403687, 0.2885928750038147, 0.06587156653404236, 0.13101449608802795, -0.742732048034668, 0.05856522172689438, -0.3526757061481476, 0.10573658347129822, 0.279367595911026, 0.8056657910346985, 0.3834560811519623, -0.2712891399860382, 0.5631568431854248, -0.635637640953064, 0.5822865962982178, -0.003991341218352318, -0.3282274007797241, -1.2069838047027588, -0.10172089189291, -0.28513798117637634, 1.136004090309143, -0.013223798014223576, -0.5760529637336731, -0.024857332929968834, 0.3108971118927002, 0.7976303696632385, 0.9681406021118164, -0.4046787917613983, -0.6935830116271973, -0.030000988394021988, 0.09316691011190414, -0.04442403465509415, -0.30479133129119873, -0.6514835357666016, 0.388393759727478, -0.8057340383529663, 0.3792465627193451, 0.476526141166687, -0.4656525254249573, -0.1253305971622467, -0.38362517952919006, 0.871843695640564, -0.7808493375778198, 0.4477376639842987, 0.15728670358657837, -0.1768055558204651, 0.5250378251075745, 0.25138944387435913, -0.13251890242099762, -1.0557178258895874, 0.039055388420820236, -0.7172513008117676, 0.31165850162506104, 0.13305574655532837, 0.20391759276390076, 0.3004226088523865, -0.26875269412994385, -0.2709645926952362, 0.4039202332496643, 1.1333508491516113, 0.9169031381607056, -0.08645323663949966, -0.32044288516044617, -0.4253629744052887, 0.18647031486034393, 0.2850102186203003, 0.17242445051670074, -0.44813138246536255, -0.3785913288593292, -0.2338401824235916, -0.23275341093540192, -0.24538221955299377, -0.6696459054946899, -0.09324614703655243, 0.5752887725830078, 0.32451897859573364, 0.11776715517044067, 0.2423664778470993, 0.04921602085232735, -0.0006572567508555949, -0.14247241616249084, 1.1004621982574463, -0.04736984148621559, -0.0006824033334851265, 0.057930245995521545, -0.6608616709709167, -0.6775881052017212, 1.0062512159347534, -0.4659459590911865, -0.756898820400238, -0.11242582648992538, 1.060888648033142, 0.059786975383758545, -0.5422903895378113, 0.5008719563484192, 0.0917283147573471, -0.17983250319957733, -0.560573399066925, 0.25759410858154297, 0.2920791804790497, -0.3411286175251007, -0.10975381731987, -0.10866453498601913, 0.15681903064250946, -0.20421980321407318, 0.1553478091955185, -0.125163733959198, 0.35470253229141235, 0.07201368361711502, -0.20177243649959564, -0.06714291870594025, -0.4856564700603485, -0.18688085675239563, 0.7438941597938538, -0.15353700518608093, 0.17993173003196716, -0.11431682854890823, 0.5149221420288086, 0.18843378126621246, 0.6109264492988586, 1.0964218378067017, -0.34756365418434143, -0.5007048845291138, 0.16897068917751312, 0.7423970699310303, 0.07207746058702469, 0.5952383875846863, -0.38188832998275757, 0.14610746502876282, 0.5331050753593445, -0.44470012187957764, -1.0507665872573853, 0.626454770565033, 0.818676233291626, 0.455180287361145, 0.09331273287534714, -0.8566901087760925, 1.2104990482330322, -0.34196075797080994, -0.17934992909431458, 0.13098640739917755, -0.7974631190299988, -0.3715289235115051, -0.014689993113279343, -0.4252544343471527, -0.9267805218696594, -0.2934437394142151, 0.6906471848487854, -0.374681293964386, -0.3379722237586975, 0.12173715233802795, 0.854058563709259, 0.1617017239332199, -0.2955889105796814, -0.4382724165916443, -0.035368096083402634, -0.7428009510040283, -0.8793087005615234, -0.23018163442611694, -0.9534570574760437, -0.1436612606048584, 1.2009961605072021, 0.239174485206604, -0.2700452208518982, 0.3981821835041046, 0.24750816822052002, 0.2062508463859558, 0.6324743628501892, -0.23691041767597198, 0.008165528066456318, -0.7577439546585083, 0.6581708788871765, 0.28144633769989014, 0.11146549135446548, 0.6159745454788208, -0.38137346506118774, 0.27050814032554626, 0.8569973111152649, -0.40692439675331116, 0.07346053421497345, -0.15693798661231995, 0.6568381190299988, -0.8033674359321594, 0.13698896765708923, 0.020001526921987534, 0.4655316174030304, -0.7066481113433838, -0.22246798872947693, -0.24629493057727814, 0.22421588003635406, 0.5633906126022339, 0.5851337313652039, -0.15170736610889435, 0.7614994645118713, 0.8017906546592712, -0.242069274187088, 0.11915489286184311, 0.2711077034473419, -0.26865237951278687, 0.3743496537208557, 0.20261059701442719, 0.24899107217788696, 0.5569748282432556, -0.9382613301277161, 1.046329140663147, 0.8192939758300781, -1.2491626739501953, 0.4085577726364136, -0.13631375133991241, 0.06262904405593872, -0.044840119779109955, 0.09620949625968933, 0.14072972536087036, 0.3760313391685486, -0.12889227271080017, 0.7857775092124939, 0.4352504312992096, 0.4811572730541229, -0.556525468826294, -0.28753718733787537, -0.14158152043819427, -0.6745427846908569, 0.37124279141426086, -0.9707480669021606, 0.1478147804737091, -0.44735339283943176, -0.9094865918159485, 0.48802363872528076, 0.5648176670074463, 0.28824949264526367, 0.1545906513929367, 0.47376933693885803, 0.2774224877357483, 0.14602163434028625, -0.7326251864433289, 0.5728557109832764, 0.6634945869445801, -0.5262101888656616, -0.9033781290054321, -0.22664643824100494, -0.24823734164237976, -0.4005949795246124, 0.15773609280586243, -0.5128827095031738, -0.2682262063026428, 0.7320451140403748, -0.26475170254707336, 0.48056507110595703, -0.5761915445327759, 0.2815726101398468, -0.9831582307815552, 0.2614564299583435, 0.3497142493724823, 0.1420724093914032, -0.05211953818798065, 0.8525366187095642, 0.3471875786781311, -0.5046425461769104, -0.5319494009017944, -0.48546332120895386, 0.8795130252838135, -0.20445826649665833, 0.08421972393989563, -0.4368295967578888, 0.5322677493095398, -0.7351112365722656, 0.005668482277542353, -0.12554290890693665, 0.41000258922576904, 0.45977452397346497, -0.572352409362793, 0.31344613432884216, 0.636570155620575, 0.6369375586509705, 0.3034402132034302, 0.483829528093338, 1.0228828191757202, -0.437879741191864, -0.3020628094673157, -0.32384446263313293, -0.6039702892303467, 0.3762301504611969, 0.7907371520996094, -0.042772211134433746, -0.17186231911182404, 0.6643811464309692, 0.30997446179389954, 0.164886936545372, -0.42755669355392456, 0.08104309439659119, -1.0377006530761719, -0.36382243037223816, -0.4586728513240814, 0.6863721609115601, 0.7463627457618713, 0.7012049555778503, 0.7774451971054077, 0.18556731939315796, 1.105116605758667, 0.13510754704475403, 0.14544062316417694, 0.3672923743724823, 0.008991912007331848, -0.516817033290863, -0.13602259755134583, 0.7674747109413147, -0.060673005878925323, -0.5121124982833862, 0.0040600537322461605, -0.5357189774513245, -0.431831955909729, 0.7608129382133484, -0.11046785861253738, -0.3389075696468353, 0.553076982498169, -0.7421225905418396, 0.6151236891746521, -0.8003453016281128, -0.3443051278591156, -0.5182344317436218, -0.2678018808364868, 0.714169979095459, -0.6456072330474854, -0.20511135458946228, 0.26785001158714294, -0.1920607089996338, -0.4859839379787445, 0.8876421451568604, 0.17000077664852142, -0.5261362791061401, 0.4028348922729492, 0.03608553111553192, 0.2591865658760071, -0.26025527715682983, -0.3961661458015442, -0.19617313146591187, 0.5343027114868164, 0.08329270780086517, 0.9206491708755493, 0.40400606393814087, 0.13170060515403748, -0.35825514793395996, 0.06129975616931915, -0.29289165139198303, -0.11112632602453232, -0.8610013723373413, -0.45411503314971924, 0.1930210143327713, 0.21514341235160828, -0.21874620020389557, 0.09172310680150986, 0.4953630566596985, 0.5970991253852844, -0.28846290707588196, -0.13466711342334747, -0.5132983326911926, -0.3483392596244812, -0.04133455082774162, 0.5434920787811279, 0.4199132025241852, -0.20533140003681183, -0.27572014927864075, -0.44721177220344543, 0.30037492513656616, 0.3070591986179352, 0.01684051752090454, -0.6771960854530334, -0.3769577741622925, 0.506988525390625, 1.0523889064788818, 0.4988357424736023, -0.02291097305715084, -0.30219995975494385, 0.25744813680648804, 0.23199699819087982, 0.047187790274620056, 0.2966737747192383, 0.6687109470367432, 0.3347416818141937, 0.6954945921897888, 0.4580167233943939, -0.12916111946105957, 0.38615983724594116, -0.08967605233192444, 0.489106684923172, -0.07044282555580139, -0.569871723651886, -1.0207372903823853, 0.5259759426116943, 1.253045916557312, -0.8716615438461304, -0.2348240613937378, -0.27661916613578796, 0.0771278366446495, -0.14776577055454254, 0.8692948222160339, 0.08493740111589432, 0.10826235264539719, 0.37917283177375793, 0.1688435971736908, -0.004103194456547499, -0.7734251022338867, 4.075679302215576, 0.48785924911499023, 0.7898485660552979, -0.4837954044342041, 0.3701587915420532, -0.05416383966803551, 0.44409123063087463, -0.5318168997764587, -0.4324074983596802, 0.06499719619750977, 0.5369738340377808, -0.20522838830947876, 0.4969468414783478, -0.6938422918319702, 0.45693275332450867, 0.12841303646564484, -0.2116062492132187, 0.12280280143022537, 0.4454260468482971, -1.108154296875, -0.8422418236732483, 0.28219926357269287, -0.21635103225708008, -0.6171217560768127, 0.3532857298851013, -0.1901814341545105, -0.06174759566783905, 0.08208631724119186, -0.47386324405670166, -0.8140534162521362, -0.34766367077827454, -0.4564766585826874, 0.3999728560447693, -0.7846789360046387, -0.2949216365814209, 0.8367969989776611, 0.6286662817001343, -0.6053367257118225, -0.24441073834896088, 0.20713186264038086, 0.2131488174200058, -0.8198909759521484, -0.017899492755532265, -0.4563819169998169, -0.021174313500523567, 0.2946323752403259, -0.3308228552341461, -0.7157739400863647, 0.32672661542892456, -0.3999176323413849, 0.6624606847763062, -1.008527398109436, -0.31826141476631165, -0.15563513338565826, -0.8547532558441162, -0.07418593764305115, -0.5414581894874573, -0.6439383029937744, 0.9368112683296204, 0.16160884499549866, 0.3063368797302246, -0.03860125318169594, -0.36941322684288025, 0.14381083846092224, 0.07868350297212601, 0.7185877561569214, 0.012128190137445927, 0.2349688559770584, 0.2954997718334198, -0.04032691568136215, 0.05753888934850693, -0.44894054532051086, -0.2565787732601166, 0.9579923748970032, 0.09798005223274231, 0.8426941633224487, -0.8122749924659729, 0.43831920623779297, -0.18924547731876373, -0.26841437816619873, -0.7198420763015747, 0.0494898222386837, 0.3433294892311096, -0.6170090436935425, 0.5063062310218811, 0.22330644726753235, -0.5809597969055176, -0.38559073209762573, -1.3191617727279663, 0.6373808979988098, 0.18794278800487518, -0.0965510830283165, -0.3483165502548218, -0.11609792709350586, -0.4950023293495178 ]
{"Title": "Quantification of Optical Coherence Tomography Angiography in Age and Age-related Macular Degeneration using Vessel Density analysis", "Authors": "Vaghefi Ehsan, Hill Sophie, Kersten Hannah M, Squirrell David", "Abstract": "Abstract Purpose To determine whether vessel density (VD) as measured by optical coherence tomography angiography (OCT-A) provide insights into retinal and choriocapillaris vascular changes with ageing and intermediate dry age related macular degeneration (AMD). Methods Seventy-five participants were recruited into three cohorts; young healthy (YH) group, old healthy (OH) and those at high-risk for exudative AMD. Raw OCT and OCT-A data from TOPCON DRI OCT Triton were exported using Topcon IMAGENET 6.0 software, and 3D datasets were analysed to determine retinal thickness and vessel density. Results Central macular thickness measurements revealed a trend of overall retinal thinning with increasing age. VD through the full thickness of the retina was highest in ETDRS sector 4 (the inferior macula) in all the cohorts. Mean VD was significantly higher in the deep capillary plexus than the superficial capillary plexus in all ETDRS sectors in all cohorts but there was no significant difference noted between groups. Choriocapillaris VD was significantly lower in all ETDRS sectors in the in the AMD group compared with the YH and the OH groups. Conclusions Retinal vessel density maps, derived from the retinal plexi are not reliable biomarkers for assessing the ageing macular. Our non-proprietary analysis of the vascular density of the choriocapillaris revealed a significant drop off of VD with age and disease but further work is required to corroborate this finding. If repeatable, choriocapillaris VD may provide a non-invasive biomarker of healthy ageing and disease. Brief Summary In this manuscript, we have studied the potential of retinal vessel density as measured by optical coherence tomography angiography (OCT-A), as a biomarker for detection of high-risk of developing exudative age-related macular degeneration (AMD).", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003053"}
10.1101/19010926
[ 0.22506138682365417, 0.19031265377998352, -0.9218394756317139, 0.3429848253726959, -0.47328582406044006, -0.9371912479400635, -0.2006632685661316, -0.004890464711934328, -0.09343460202217102, 1.0093625783920288, 0.158493772149086, 0.13896594941616058, 0.7545616626739502, 0.30387261509895325, -0.0008910775650292635, -0.244671031832695, -0.4118191599845886, -0.0880461260676384, -0.681418776512146, -0.31081146001815796, 0.0022046477533876896, 0.43288883566856384, -0.7859326004981995, 0.07907218486070633, -0.39670246839523315, 0.8881467580795288, -0.36156201362609863, 0.19122809171676636, 1.121002435684204, 0.532032310962677, 0.037813134491443634, 0.04702591896057129, -0.33392202854156494, -0.823209285736084, -0.5769376754760742, -0.546920895576477, 0.14774079620838165, -0.7735471725463867, -0.39316263794898987, -0.08881767839193344, 0.49189043045043945, 0.2138407677412033, 0.5193673968315125, -1.5299326181411743, -0.9615023136138916, -0.28323718905448914, 0.29900944232940674, -0.10522536188364029, -0.29074177145957947, -0.49501508474349976, 0.5879946351051331, 0.35198163986206055, 0.2054489105939865, -0.1501418948173523, 0.33111193776130676, -0.5432611703872681, -0.17563867568969727, -0.47380682826042175, -0.33886581659317017, 0.12898105382919312, -0.04296164959669113, -0.2773922085762024, 0.1448420286178589, -0.9140000343322754, 0.46462270617485046, 0.31005579233169556, -0.08032436668872833, -0.3481445908546448, -0.8792473077774048, -0.5794487595558167, -1.511487603187561, -0.03992605581879616, 0.31415286660194397, -0.6383299827575684, -0.1526353359222412, -0.06325393915176392, 0.24992425739765167, -0.2659552991390228, -0.21465468406677246, -0.47469907999038696, 1.0972163677215576, 0.6100133061408997, 0.1269170492887497, 0.3187600076198578, -0.11387225240468979, 0.1614057868719101, 0.6160173416137695, 0.14793790876865387, 0.023142293095588684, 0.24569274485111237, 0.8488231897354126, 0.3981373906135559, 0.27778002619743347, 0.44138699769973755, 0.35268497467041016, 1.179487705230713, -0.18287606537342072, 0.29473942518234253, 0.2641224265098572, 0.31809002161026, 0.5603868365287781, 1.6096832752227783, -0.41780954599380493, 0.31862810254096985, -0.8938254117965698, 0.4392365515232086, 0.6245903968811035, -0.10333012044429779, -0.03490088880062103, -0.9459269046783447, -0.8130960464477539, 0.30977529287338257, -0.13146093487739563, -0.5229279398918152, 0.08646533638238907, 0.6879438757896423, 0.9016081094741821, 0.6879309415817261, -0.4932698905467987, 0.6103008985519409, -0.4054904878139496, -0.019395673647522926, -0.27796056866645813, -0.4110575020313263, 0.32964053750038147, 0.17556266486644745, 0.4538910686969757, 0.8493012189865112, -0.292894572019577, -0.12191040068864822, -0.7648698091506958, -0.7459276914596558, 0.16480006277561188, 0.5531917214393616, -0.05231062322854996, 0.12712371349334717, 0.4719131886959076, 0.2996009588241577, 0.262892484664917, -0.4036460518836975, 0.23178806900978088, 0.8869377374649048, -0.28071659803390503, 0.8496828079223633, -0.10517358779907227, 0.3600772023200989, -0.6127939820289612, -1.0541400909423828, -0.8004757165908813, -0.5144897699356079, 0.1555151492357254, 0.1025862991809845, -0.24850334227085114, 0.23697155714035034, 0.021737052127718925, -0.720221221446991, -0.6428937315940857, -0.0011542211286723614, 0.2306641936302185, -0.3657529056072235, -0.3029383718967438, 0.7989640831947327, -0.42629945278167725, 0.7644874453544617, -0.31972211599349976, 0.6991323828697205, -0.0572933554649353, -0.6262640953063965, 0.523572564125061, -0.48647138476371765, 0.8889644742012024, 0.9129848480224609, -0.05751854553818703, -0.28795260190963745, 0.009309104643762112, 0.6328438520431519, 0.6135554909706116, 0.30314016342163086, 0.2847078740596771, 0.14602547883987427, 0.4188750684261322, -0.46504896879196167, 0.4194595217704773, 0.7079208493232727, 0.7755456566810608, 0.3108624517917633, -0.3044379949569702, -0.5576272010803223, -0.5228614211082458, -0.4699016213417053, -0.4093732535839081, 0.6531142592430115, -0.14593230187892914, 0.5893111228942871, 0.6683557629585266, 0.008121171034872532, -0.16757173836231232, 0.3618840277194977, 1.091701626777649, -0.42999234795570374, -0.5645593404769897, 0.9414164423942566, -0.3708239495754242, 0.8190575838088989, -0.28039872646331787, 0.8655492663383484, -0.12096615135669708, 0.21596784889698029, -0.3787235617637634, 0.04501719027757645, 0.1395367830991745, 0.1366615891456604, -1.0844565629959106, 0.22878873348236084, 1.0392488241195679, -0.694269061088562, -0.3974515199661255, -0.007446578703820705, -0.16965897381305695, -0.23365864157676697, -0.2511807382106781, -0.12762705981731415, 0.6731070876121521, -0.37580373883247375, -0.6467687487602234, 0.5579293370246887, 0.5208519697189331, 0.5083786845207214, -0.8467109799385071, 0.056105662137269974, -0.15253818035125732, 0.4100867509841919, -0.2959387004375458, 0.7221691608428955, 0.8784042596817017, 0.5777777433395386, 0.2546757757663727, 1.1700718402862549, 1.020218849182129, -0.2257598638534546, 0.5542054176330566, -0.006229836493730545, 0.7775968909263611, 0.6139669418334961, -0.7947633862495422, 0.7887490391731262, -0.11468510329723358, 0.3448256254196167, -0.21117229759693146, -0.20688916742801666, -0.8450711369514465, 0.39561575651168823, 1.0919609069824219, 0.24430307745933533, -1.3611984252929688, 0.34171995520591736, 0.6955322027206421, 0.7647945284843445, 0.12401210516691208, -0.28042930364608765, 0.1458168625831604, 0.38832011818885803, -0.26499122381210327, 0.5654908418655396, 0.6125299334526062, -0.34880897402763367, 0.37943124771118164, 0.706262469291687, 0.6552294492721558, -0.37068048119544983, -0.6370734572410583, -0.7292855978012085, -0.9685596823692322, -0.07026849687099457, -0.6410064101219177, 0.11977693438529968, -0.22405162453651428, -0.6056495904922485, 0.16647353768348694, -0.1543295681476593, 0.19997777044773102, -0.40814080834388733, -0.7067303657531738, 0.2264280468225479, 0.38002803921699524, 0.4825321137905121, -0.7997332811355591, 0.6120831370353699, -0.2539365291595459, 0.5305734872817993, -0.2942206859588623, -0.08406569063663483, -0.584898829460144, -0.4033137261867523, 1.1837408542633057, -0.24744810163974762, 0.6400744915008545, 0.2350235879421234, -0.8894378542900085, -0.7143601179122925, 0.20993348956108093, 0.05219082161784172, 0.6395647525787354, -0.1726038008928299, -0.8144381642341614, 0.5959838628768921, -0.48649969696998596, 0.1650478094816208, 0.7996445298194885, 0.6463772058486938, -0.435761034488678, 0.7566594481468201, 0.04795518144965172, -0.11977439373731613, -1.1465381383895874, 0.423915296792984, 0.26000088453292847, -0.28034234046936035, 0.19329041242599487, -0.38612300157546997, -0.8202308416366577, -0.06276808679103851, 0.27338361740112305, -0.7523612380027771, -0.5765283107757568, 0.7478099465370178, 0.04492390528321266, -1.3212565183639526, 0.6085277199745178, -1.4849103689193726, -0.8635456562042236, -0.4357619881629944, 0.324569970369339, 0.8069621920585632, 0.33367714285850525, -0.12375282496213913, -0.4285815954208374, -0.4014228582382202, 0.17392008006572723, 0.17946936190128326, 0.07889295369386673, -0.45675987005233765, -0.42752236127853394, -0.1882300078868866, -0.31270208954811096, 0.4400418996810913, -0.7585565447807312, -0.5733007788658142, -0.0859004482626915, -0.43224138021469116, 0.5233522653579712, -0.2068811058998108, 0.48885899782180786, -0.04994624853134155, -0.026331700384616852, 0.48663654923439026, -0.09095583856105804, -0.2581823170185089, 0.2429078072309494, 0.012951251119375229, -0.458774596452713, 0.4457169771194458, -0.6030336618423462, 0.1328994780778885, -0.6867265701293945, -0.5820863842964172, -0.23153096437454224, 0.4804503619670868, 0.14702105522155762, -0.7380648255348206, 0.7536144852638245, 0.10464891046285629, -0.3683331310749054, 0.1847105175256729, -0.8618127703666687, -0.6547656655311584, 0.663723886013031, -0.4896930754184723, 0.3494601845741272, -1.2060885429382324, 0.05184775963425636, 0.0490032359957695, 0.6121766567230225, 0.10184373706579208, 0.05131211131811142, 0.20887690782546997, -0.7755811810493469, 0.5160777568817139, 0.536226749420166, -0.17408312857151031, -0.21932651102542877, -0.057892005890607834, 0.15774478018283844, 0.1033240556716919, -0.27388012409210205, -0.14721304178237915, 0.2133754938840866, 0.4234052300453186, -0.08832777291536331, 0.26164594292640686, 0.3225632905960083, 0.16652248799800873, -0.19370698928833008, 0.34424105286598206, 0.6361608505249023, 0.14408133924007416, -0.3637572228908539, -0.5342730283737183, 0.09813656657934189, 0.2373742312192917, -0.47534483671188354, -0.24373769760131836, -0.19759033620357513, 0.16717688739299774, 0.17516030371189117, -0.04109113663434982, 0.16438184678554535, -0.6139848828315735, 0.5071126222610474, -0.3528216481208801, -0.11578754335641861, -0.3781905472278595, -1.0945940017700195, 0.18782927095890045, -0.02764708548784256, -0.1370643824338913, 0.44443362951278687, -0.34543147683143616, 0.06813336908817291, 0.45616137981414795, -0.380224347114563, -0.8679391145706177, 0.17561903595924377, 0.44239839911460876, -0.05815977230668068, -0.18661917746067047, 0.13001170754432678, -0.435107558965683, 0.28570741415023804, -0.2977541983127594, -0.17526280879974365, -0.043169453740119934, 0.27446213364601135, -0.30741244554519653, 0.3808198869228363, 0.22898487746715546, 0.54035484790802, 0.6220065951347351, -0.34102681279182434, -0.0673627257347107, 0.2699246406555176, -0.02444973587989807, 0.7192544341087341, -0.2729986906051636, -0.05237646773457527, -0.11778941750526428, 0.22976215183734894, -0.013655247166752815, -0.08948057144880295, -0.017413215711712837, -0.34553954005241394, 0.0015595839358866215, 0.11529778689146042, 0.26964056491851807, -0.052205152809619904, 0.424396276473999, -0.22304852306842804, -0.7766731977462769, 0.4461641311645508, 0.5277131199836731, -0.0936499536037445, -0.5965905785560608, -0.24848586320877075, -0.9045059084892273, 0.45793217420578003, -0.48774582147598267, -0.013886287808418274, 0.4183686375617981, -0.6868191361427307, 0.3809211552143097, -0.16420961916446686, 0.29804688692092896, -0.5516901612281799, -0.3442921042442322, -0.8976158499717712, -0.001496724202297628, -0.5287284851074219, -0.14296230673789978, -0.5835152864456177, 0.03952879458665848, -0.5865208506584167, -0.7379612326622009, -0.689002513885498, -0.24533751606941223, -0.7957997918128967, -0.14029596745967865, -0.23478467762470245, -0.1530550718307495, 0.014936779625713825, 0.2431717962026596, 0.5901587605476379, -0.3356558382511139, -0.8716340661048889, -0.4079589545726776, 0.26381030678749084, -0.4004211127758026, -0.4464867115020752, -0.300408273935318, -0.014899407513439655, 0.0459425263106823, -0.8406201601028442, 0.1253688484430313, -0.19411998987197876, 0.6114813685417175, 0.27980732917785645, -0.04774712398648262, -0.20565034449100494, -0.3436710834503174, 0.09123978763818741, 0.6237178444862366, -0.4930262565612793, -0.7009599208831787, -0.37633422017097473, 0.20129011571407318, -0.6706752181053162, 0.42433738708496094, -0.571004331111908, 0.07018749415874481, -0.5620849132537842, -1.0816291570663452, -0.14271973073482513, 0.40732237696647644, 0.10378488153219223, 0.11491493135690689, 0.3804439306259155, 0.5802984237670898, 0.6381864547729492, -0.16017352044582367, 0.25421658158302307, 0.32908815145492554, 0.33111572265625, 0.06544959545135498, -0.08894769102334976, -0.33185338973999023, 0.7301716208457947, -0.6400106549263, 0.17231813073158264, 0.8121330142021179, 1.1367583274841309, -0.02676340378820896, -0.05580711364746094, -0.25655555725097656, 0.5815390944480896, 0.016684962436556816, -0.4924657642841339, -0.6072714328765869, -0.12111187726259232, 0.5075575113296509, 0.09372685849666595, 0.19016996026039124, -0.5862348079681396, 1.1131328344345093, -0.4713558256626129, 0.7191312909126282, -0.6395863890647888, -0.022069845348596573, -0.25713643431663513, -0.3358267545700073, 1.4079246520996094, -0.32891905307769775, 0.38087430596351624, -0.47083377838134766, 0.13947005569934845, 0.5907460451126099, -0.19634795188903809, -1.3099031448364258, -0.5254693627357483, -1.011874794960022, -0.7036539912223816, -0.657849907875061, 0.128567174077034, -0.1677880585193634, 0.30067119002342224, -0.2055775672197342, 0.3569047451019287, -0.20113115012645721, 0.6555403470993042, 0.12489879876375198, -0.6455592513084412, -0.15704013407230377, -0.031140780076384544, 0.4696783125400543, 0.14528080821037292, 0.8803820610046387, -0.007071650121361017, -0.23062042891979218, 0.14005538821220398, -0.45952892303466797, -0.1625685691833496, 0.10180173814296722, -0.1263718158006668, -0.05560615658760071, 0.27727487683296204, -0.10903173685073853, -0.036209769546985626, 0.34859737753868103, -0.41897615790367126, -0.22591695189476013, 0.20167990028858185, -0.05965025722980499, 0.321416437625885, 0.7080560326576233, -0.7414953708648682, -0.22226320207118988, -0.37843796610832214, -0.4351474940776825, -0.1297176629304886, -0.09788837283849716, 0.4437311887741089, 0.6020180583000183, -0.48668837547302246, -0.3993803858757019, 0.5855971574783325, -1.023810863494873, -0.11101724207401276, 0.1988837718963623, 0.5382338762283325, 0.7375377416610718, -0.545527994632721, -0.35800471901893616, 0.6272037029266357, 0.2684306502342224, 0.7357192635536194, -0.1706453561782837, -0.4480041265487671, -0.2262764424085617, -0.4137921631336212, -0.17612794041633606, -0.4661884903907776, 0.5842512249946594, 0.7178041338920593, -0.5572414398193359, 0.6220899820327759, -0.07896530628204346, 0.20232616364955902, 0.513169527053833, 0.13885992765426636, 1.0934243202209473, -0.7624887228012085, -0.255170077085495, -0.29939547181129456, -0.0025825451593846083, 0.5250406265258789, -0.2494591921567917, -0.3600800931453705, 0.898198127746582, -0.9939107298851013, -0.5105510950088501, 0.08385184407234192, 0.8625569939613342, -0.5891501903533936, 0.4263913333415985, -0.24361036717891693, -0.4784877300262451, 1.0125428438186646, 0.817324697971344, 0.581647515296936, -0.599608838558197, -0.8035248517990112, -1.0433138608932495, -0.03730688616633415, 0.03714611008763313, 0.09489815682172775, 0.1668812334537506, 0.3235529661178589, 0.7398464679718018, -0.5437002778053284, 0.053246110677719116, 1.2117702960968018, -0.3130596876144409, -0.055858105421066284, -0.7749041318893433, 1.0194135904312134, -0.4251060485839844, -0.3320697844028473, -0.3850230574607849, -0.5745793581008911, -0.6195687055587769, 0.695478618144989, -0.2216441035270691, -0.007159404456615448, -0.4641239643096924, 0.44445571303367615, -0.2913237512111664, 0.39179590344429016, -0.48475801944732666, -0.4605850279331207, 0.2003938853740692, 1.1531689167022705, -0.2546486556529999, -0.030785851180553436, 0.08411647379398346, -0.6412180066108704, 0.15447568893432617, 0.2911495566368103, -0.75120609998703, -0.08195503801107407, 0.4312680959701538, 0.45632413029670715, -0.8990693688392639, -0.7675091028213501, -0.07015646249055862, 0.08713403344154358, -0.3648138642311096, 0.18703271448612213, 0.1326783448457718, 0.22269974648952484, 0.24579119682312012, 0.18802672624588013, 0.677942156791687, 1.0685391426086426, 0.32360896468162537, 0.7480935454368591, 0.04221053794026375, 0.6568400263786316, 0.3693307340145111, 0.21077223122119904, -0.14293040335178375, 0.4364679157733917, -0.18965354561805725, -0.6322576403617859, 0.46216732263565063, 0.7192939519882202, -0.6610418558120728, 0.34865283966064453, -0.7497307062149048, 0.605236291885376, -0.39166060090065, -0.1408553421497345, -0.069149911403656, 1.4118608236312866, 0.47825565934181213, -0.11710310727357864, 0.08722971379756927, -0.2133781909942627, -0.13034822046756744, 0.27116894721984863, -1.3354871273040771, -0.715388834476471, 0.2678016424179077, -0.7396085262298584, -0.3832284212112427, -0.4566024839878082, -0.29512661695480347, 0.3245401084423065, 0.12331186980009079, 0.5991173982620239, -0.7888962030410767, 0.7783408761024475, 0.07723519951105118, 0.6304537653923035, 0.13831858336925507, -0.03012729622423649, -0.03937828913331032, 0.3041089177131653, -0.41914641857147217, -0.2954092025756836, 0.3638751208782196, -0.17247727513313293, 0.504660964012146, -0.21196205914020538, -0.5112020373344421, 0.49397334456443787, -0.11839718371629715, 0.2766391336917877, -0.4158811569213867, 0.26203790307044983, -0.23474347591400146, -0.767829418182373, 0.19090700149536133, 0.4707607328891754, -0.6247971057891846, 0.48355090618133545, 0.6784725189208984, -0.6886314153671265, -0.8971689939498901, 0.5316092371940613, 0.5440900325775146, -0.8210312128067017, 0.5164273977279663, 0.047895342111587524, 0.1240357756614685, -0.0037321830168366432, 0.05871147662401199, 0.9186578989028931, -0.11780707538127899, 0.5889685153961182, 0.19688574969768524, -0.34651005268096924, -0.059317365288734436, 0.5833396911621094, -0.27462366223335266, 0.5304273366928101, 0.49408572912216187, 0.22189411520957947, -0.33594805002212524, -0.257454514503479, -0.5017293095588684, 0.7570790648460388, -0.09047900140285492, 0.11317520588636398, 0.04822629317641258, -0.18381863832473755, 0.22777937352657318, -0.06074343994259834, -0.8947727084159851, 0.316561222076416, -0.05265233665704727, -0.24395160377025604, 0.14651301503181458, 0.0742265060544014, 0.5331404209136963, 0.4962817132472992, 0.8434616923332214, 0.3097955584526062, 0.5366902351379395, 0.08063316345214844, -0.6158050298690796, 0.7277560830116272, 0.12046097964048386, -0.6186364889144897, -0.3095366358757019, -0.012598157860338688, 0.10456228256225586, -0.12234367430210114, -0.6403161287307739, -0.2931370139122009, 0.4708051383495331, 0.32870668172836304, -0.5314142107963562, -0.051705989986658096, 0.545306384563446, -0.5485408306121826, 0.1766224354505539, -0.11836551129817963, -0.10618987679481506, 0.15407399833202362, -0.37368670105934143, 0.13558390736579895, -0.30099552869796753, -0.47049862146377563, 0.2423131912946701, 0.7848477959632874, 0.431986004114151, 0.36015090346336365, 0.21516382694244385, -0.3554675579071045, 0.17551320791244507, 0.8058632612228394, 0.2063811719417572, -0.3322632610797882, 0.1377953141927719, -0.17732954025268555, -0.07711750268936157, 0.7039339542388916, -0.505829393863678, -0.3420667052268982, -0.32529106736183167, -0.4765736162662506, 0.0406084768474102, 0.10493140667676926, -0.7285258173942566, -0.39512544870376587, -0.5504359006881714, 0.033698469400405884, 0.11334199458360672, -0.22538408637046814, 0.41095203161239624, -0.10766217112541199, 0.006566235329955816, -0.48298904299736023, 0.08541621267795563, -0.18024517595767975, 0.27284640073776245, -1.1646218299865723, 0.14811764657497406, -0.10407208651304245, -0.7554715871810913, -0.5606846809387207, -1.4532277584075928, 0.47822102904319763, 0.7983948588371277, -0.4791877269744873, -0.7406283617019653, 0.20529980957508087, -0.25052401423454285, 0.6914675235748291, -0.27187955379486084, -0.3633881211280823, -0.06382233649492264, 0.3603963553905487, 0.2635902464389801, 0.21754226088523865, 0.6453189253807068, 0.5748738050460815, -0.20049040019512177, -0.3219681978225708, -0.5005446076393127, 0.3668471872806549, 0.05352596566081047, -0.37596070766448975, -0.24790748953819275, 0.3107970356941223, -0.006589507684111595, -0.6160048842430115, 0.13931724429130554, 0.6652937531471252, -0.03204725682735443, 0.010851592756807804, -0.7474831342697144, -0.7469371557235718, -1.1681461334228516, 0.6406764984130859, -0.2847869098186493, 0.7340409755706787, 0.10035858303308487, -0.44792690873146057, 0.38890236616134644, -0.5797731876373291, 4.236024856567383, 1.219523310661316, 0.13746891915798187, -0.6141098141670227, 0.6404558420181274, 0.7588062286376953, 0.6650675535202026, -0.0340571403503418, 0.9101628065109253, -0.6075719594955444, -0.39039263129234314, 0.11389588564634323, 0.10720717906951904, 0.41843870282173157, 0.37392857670783997, 0.523929238319397, -0.8827634453773499, -0.2254853993654251, -0.6858500838279724, -0.5539016127586365, 0.09356077015399933, 0.557030200958252, -0.15382836759090424, 0.4112768769264221, -0.245939239859581, -0.4732891619205475, 0.14756374061107635, 0.10593415796756744, 0.2923111021518707, -0.5229018330574036, -0.073220394551754, -0.25197094678878784, -0.024600552394986153, -1.0567851066589355, -0.34959954023361206, 0.13188940286636353, -0.07843715697526932, -0.6715068817138672, 0.18481135368347168, 0.5456666350364685, 0.3558070659637451, 0.3762834966182709, -0.059669893234968185, 0.6382095813751221, -0.3569122552871704, -0.3252602517604828, -0.2070947289466858, 0.3126662075519562, 0.16429127752780914, -0.399838924407959, 0.9381383061408997, -0.8813926577568054, 0.2728045880794525, 0.24377794563770294, 0.1495492309331894, -0.3878847658634186, -0.02743891254067421, -0.8484750986099243, -0.3156450092792511, 0.8129145503044128, 0.5033177733421326, -0.5049080848693848, -0.06690123677253723, -0.4428199231624603, 0.45556333661079407, 0.9360719323158264, 0.7680743932723999, 0.12882982194423676, -0.5515422821044922, 0.3390883207321167, 0.11185149848461151, 0.1052340716123581, -0.6358597278594971, -1.1595573425292969, 0.609821081161499, 0.09313014149665833, -0.49245908856391907, 0.5434128046035767, 0.2849908769130707, -0.9051635265350342, -0.01911046914756298, 0.18567748367786407, 0.10868159681558609, 0.12228823453187943, -0.3373771607875824, 0.6666233539581299, -0.9415409564971924, -0.14459700882434845, -1.1688857078552246, 0.5037094950675964, 0.34277552366256714, -0.5817881226539612, -0.30054259300231934, -0.14356212317943573, 0.5912733674049377 ]
{"Title": "Physicians\u2019 learning in the workplace: use of informal feedback cues in daily practice", "Authors": "Sehlbach Carolin, Teunissen Pim W, Driessen Erik W, Mitchell Sharon, Rohde Gernot GU, Smeenk Frank WJM, Govaerts Marjan JB", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Purpose We expect physicians to be lifelong learners. Learning from clinical practice is an important potential source for that learning. To support physicians in this process, a better understanding of how they learn in clinical practice is necessary. This study investigates how physicians use informal feedback as learning cues to adjust their communication from interactions with patients in the outpatient setting. Methods To understand physicians\u2019 use of informal feedback, we combined non-participant ethnographic observations with semi-structured interviews. We enrolled 10 respiratory physicians and observed 100 physician-patient interactions at one academic and one non-academic hospital in the Netherlands. Data collection and analysis were performed iteratively according to the principles of constructivist grounded theory. Our conceptual model describes how physicians use cues to reflect on and adjust their communication as well as to further develop their adaptive expertise. Results In addition to vast variations within and across patient encounters, we observed recurring patterns in physicians\u2019 communications in reaction to specific learning cues. Physicians had learnt to recognise and use different cues to adjust their communication in patient encounters. They established a \u2018communication repertoire\u2019 based on multiple patient interactions, which many saw as learning opportunities, contributing to the development of adaptive expertise. Our findings show differences in physicians\u2019 sensitivity to recognising learning opportunities in daily practice which was further influenced by contextual, personal and interpersonal factors. Whereas some reported to have little inclination to change, others used critical incidents to fine-tune their communication repertoire, while others constantly reshaped it, seeking learning opportunities in their daily work. Conclusions There is a large variation in how physicians use learning cues from daily practice. Learning from daily practice is a collaborative effort and requires a culture that promotes lifelong learning. Raising physicians\u2019 awareness of experiences as potential learning opportunities might enhance their development of adaptive expertise.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010926"}
10.1101/19008417
[ -0.6402570009231567, 0.9093373417854309, -0.6676473617553711, 0.3690309226512909, 0.6201421022415161, -0.5763256549835205, -0.6900763511657715, 0.3188245892524719, -0.498546302318573, 0.6488590240478516, -0.04160457104444504, 0.14396290481090546, -0.5059407949447632, -0.17825913429260254, -0.6842514872550964, -1.1308494806289673, -0.8075730204582214, -0.16512247920036316, 1.0997180938720703, 0.2368975430727005, -0.08556196093559265, 0.9366822242736816, -1.166653037071228, -0.35852712392807007, -0.5120193362236023, 0.9836249947547913, 0.21412059664726257, -0.3752290904521942, 1.4959717988967896, 0.5298836827278137, 0.5716497898101807, -0.0009795216610655189, 0.5644083023071289, -1.0124082565307617, 0.30658769607543945, 0.13879045844078064, 0.06895579397678375, -0.8483871221542358, -0.2522377073764801, -0.6070852875709534, 0.22261662781238556, -0.5452160835266113, 0.5940915942192078, -0.2345447987318039, -0.5939698815345764, -0.129614919424057, 0.1100831851363182, 1.540399193763733, 0.7357556819915771, 0.21272696554660797, 0.17438958585262299, 0.1440466046333313, -0.34709620475769043, -0.8162719011306763, -0.766631543636322, -0.2726559042930603, -0.0930170789361, -0.4222019612789154, -0.5448564291000366, 0.37229013442993164, -0.48248735070228577, 0.20118831098079681, 1.2569328546524048, -0.2231103628873825, 0.12502990663051605, 0.7636719942092896, 0.1756066530942917, -0.3295450806617737, 0.13404178619384766, -0.2876008450984955, -0.03252967447042465, -1.0848195552825928, -0.8537702560424805, -0.647666871547699, -0.7821642756462097, 0.17813457548618317, -0.08591001480817795, -0.731054961681366, -0.133683443069458, -0.09465239197015762, 0.9247004985809326, 0.7860500812530518, 0.1708413064479828, -0.32968589663505554, -0.8050166368484497, 0.7193729281425476, 0.945603609085083, 0.6166747212409973, -0.06753699481487274, 0.6547876000404358, -0.4106053113937378, 0.15342094004154205, 0.49599364399909973, 0.34323129057884216, 0.47255897521972656, 0.9931653738021851, -0.2394358068704605, -0.2455924153327942, -0.08711905032396317, 0.17193974554538727, 0.4430232346057892, 0.8209986686706543, 0.36067092418670654, 1.3656821250915527, -0.1224803626537323, 0.747083842754364, 0.5484814643859863, -0.306805282831192, -0.559122622013092, -0.7557100653648376, -0.33172252774238586, -0.31839507818222046, -0.974327027797699, -0.599433183670044, 1.0375221967697144, 0.22960257530212402, 0.3049207031726837, 0.11117053776979446, -0.5589032173156738, 0.9706636667251587, -0.6895537376403809, 0.3724792003631592, 0.40417763590812683, 0.6559944748878479, 0.4525580406188965, -0.029101556167006493, 0.9466950297355652, 0.36160698533058167, -0.6959402561187744, -0.26544395089149475, -0.6500824689865112, -1.515701174736023, 0.1939045786857605, 0.49022209644317627, 0.0945310890674591, -0.17442743480205536, 0.6274650692939758, 0.5784335136413574, 1.0916725397109985, -0.21114632487297058, 0.10264979302883148, -0.18161845207214355, -0.2635038495063782, 1.5435266494750977, -0.5937881469726562, 1.1147840023040771, 0.21866238117218018, -0.5981776118278503, -0.4620830714702606, -0.2035648226737976, 0.1939302235841751, 0.05758828669786453, -0.8908311128616333, 0.12590259313583374, 0.43933364748954773, 0.5848969221115112, -0.407620370388031, -0.08449602872133255, -0.8148006796836853, -0.023592457175254822, -0.5124800801277161, -0.193129301071167, 0.33114489912986755, 0.36747655272483826, -0.5558153986930847, 0.27507099509239197, -0.2123357355594635, -0.0360444039106369, -0.7522112727165222, -0.850762128829956, 1.3597242832183838, -0.6253237128257751, 0.3238261640071869, 0.7216850519180298, 0.5129349827766418, 1.2181320190429688, -0.07626063376665115, 0.11080422252416611, 0.6791662573814392, 0.17307481169700623, 0.3246399760246277, 0.6887500286102295, 0.46901607513427734, 0.1623373180627823, -0.1544242799282074, 0.7185508608818054, 0.08055350929498672, 0.12652893364429474, -0.17762088775634766, -0.23642636835575104, 0.08614473789930344, 0.5444318652153015, -0.9704456925392151, -0.02437734417617321, 0.2089281529188156, 0.01742548495531082, -0.7061459422111511, 0.04424648359417915, -0.1148860901594162, -0.4728568196296692, -0.009184975177049637, 0.12694211304187775, -0.35794100165367126, 0.06969008594751358, -1.1285269260406494, 0.6669420003890991, 0.1569419503211975, 0.6956419944763184, -0.9539981484413147, 0.15210862457752228, 0.5830879211425781, 0.12852038443088531, -0.343507319688797, -0.22095444798469543, 0.9968008995056152, 0.2025671899318695, -0.8768756985664368, 0.2036251723766327, -0.4471619427204132, -0.5435790419578552, -0.35040876269340515, -0.34870073199272156, 0.38660889863967896, 0.9751595258712769, 0.269992470741272, -0.036030832678079605, 0.4475421905517578, 0.7783799767494202, -0.20256569981575012, 0.05871095508337021, 0.8332476019859314, -0.05616510659456253, -0.4591708779335022, 1.1881598234176636, 0.6665442585945129, 0.04232017323374748, -0.8233175873756409, 0.357688844203949, 0.28772446513175964, 0.309104859828949, 1.0173002481460571, 0.7779018878936768, 0.5047767162322998, 0.2933654487133026, -0.353179007768631, 1.3388208150863647, 0.13288000226020813, -0.2938518226146698, -0.42471200227737427, 1.0765600204467773, 0.3727428913116455, 0.8852149248123169, 0.7566518783569336, 0.5181246995925903, -0.9098295569419861, 0.15221600234508514, 0.002010252559557557, -0.196241095662117, -0.4499259293079376, -0.40339329838752747, -0.39668339490890503, 0.04392712563276291, -0.12496919184923172, -0.12459152191877365, 0.9342179894447327, 1.4139556884765625, -0.7258700728416443, -0.12049301713705063, 0.3754841983318329, -1.0327445268630981, -0.5523159503936768, 0.12473425269126892, -0.7819865345954895, -0.8240249752998352, -1.0911580324172974, 0.020022252574563026, 0.10913047939538956, -0.03591715544462204, 0.4281769394874573, 0.017205292358994484, -0.47613370418548584, 0.7423264384269714, 0.11635766178369522, 0.2626793384552002, 0.22665131092071533, -0.7334450483322144, -0.5145703554153442, -0.08154406398534775, -0.06370548903942108, 0.28679028153419495, -0.3946216106414795, -0.09546176344156265, -0.5543845295906067, -0.1883629411458969, -0.05595720559358597, -0.5319899320602417, 0.7548880577087402, 0.9082996845245361, 0.12010090053081512, -0.3007950484752655, 0.3147934079170227, 0.22060313820838928, 0.25089776515960693, -0.8688719868659973, -0.3363707363605499, 0.3767417371273041, -0.10946520417928696, 0.14832544326782227, 0.9545089602470398, 0.45046767592430115, -0.6516684889793396, 0.20461136102676392, -0.7464281320571899, -0.17220564186573029, -0.6127889752388, -0.06655919551849365, 1.037915825843811, 0.025704335421323776, -0.28290411829948425, -1.1144202947616577, -0.5106506943702698, 0.1979025900363922, 0.05045123025774956, -0.2480458915233612, -0.35116738080978394, 0.6084651947021484, 0.4908791184425354, -1.6920030117034912, 0.014707300812005997, -0.06468044966459274, -0.32023462653160095, -0.11182177066802979, 0.2908855676651001, 0.34064987301826477, 0.43589136004447937, 0.4126754701137543, -0.57846999168396, -0.16646166145801544, 0.6286795139312744, -0.011938095092773438, 0.8830459713935852, 0.14878804981708527, -0.33632954955101013, 0.13990984857082367, -0.5870892405509949, 0.516455888748169, 0.22719378769397736, 0.2979236841201782, -0.8922673463821411, 0.26209449768066406, 0.08487096428871155, 0.6603773236274719, 0.6064009070396423, -0.11398252844810486, -0.40482667088508606, 0.8664188385009766, -0.3527469336986542, 0.5239322781562805, -0.24339264631271362, 0.45949575304985046, -0.49565690755844116, 0.13253389298915863, -0.6199301481246948, 0.9039620161056519, -0.868415892124176, -0.6595830917358398, 0.43796440958976746, 0.6041468977928162, 0.037723835557699203, -0.7263046503067017, 0.7807764410972595, -0.8153111934661865, -0.3175826966762543, 0.20209461450576782, -0.14748570322990417, 0.06967633962631226, 0.3736715614795685, 0.5199776887893677, 1.2294808626174927, -0.806968629360199, 0.7102017998695374, 0.26338842511177063, 0.4734385907649994, 0.5221472978591919, -0.05380020663142204, 0.32028642296791077, -0.24288788437843323, -0.39941659569740295, 0.29163047671318054, -0.8952154517173767, -0.5905873775482178, -0.7437644004821777, -0.531823992729187, -0.18202753365039825, -0.537158727645874, -1.1053760051727295, -0.560258686542511, 0.09186293184757233, 1.0898189544677734, -0.3219626843929291, 1.1032599210739136, -0.03808682784438133, -0.14388225972652435, 1.0229814052581787, 1.0855368375778198, 0.4190680682659149, -0.34445634484291077, 0.6244481205940247, -0.48484674096107483, -1.1678178310394287, 0.024167612195014954, -0.7253632545471191, 0.14450444281101227, -0.26371318101882935, -0.22380635142326355, -0.7550533413887024, -0.7105163335800171, -0.1793520599603653, -0.42189329862594604, 0.5016199946403503, 0.5694838762283325, -0.08818789571523666, -0.1076262891292572, -0.002820379566401243, 0.08162476867437363, -0.5015397667884827, 0.22954393923282623, -1.3896288871765137, 1.323096513748169, 0.5425933003425598, 0.35975778102874756, -1.1632071733474731, -0.4925132989883423, 0.030870135873556137, -0.17451466619968414, 0.19595006108283997, -0.008673349395394325, -0.13183285295963287, 0.4572795033454895, -1.3815088272094727, -0.36902546882629395, 0.08256381750106812, -0.13286487758159637, -0.3331126570701599, -0.2878935933113098, -0.26566681265830994, 1.0636167526245117, 1.0866641998291016, 0.05767744779586792, -0.3870726227760315, 0.027353666722774506, -0.3302881419658661, 0.4708707928657532, -0.7616970539093018, -0.5117754936218262, -0.3143170177936554, -0.2715454399585724, 0.39278629422187805, -0.16093763709068298, -0.26006704568862915, -0.543210506439209, -0.36531129479408264, -0.29480817914009094, -0.8345025777816772, -0.8725146651268005, 1.2089040279388428, -0.020889604464173317, -0.23703444004058838, 0.40595731139183044, -0.46535250544548035, -0.3798416256904602, -0.19463486969470978, -0.1703987568616867, -0.08233194053173065, 0.8656618595123291, 0.5145083665847778, 0.5042503476142883, 0.47129133343696594, -0.5571874976158142, 0.4146976172924042, -0.38790950179100037, -0.385143905878067, -0.6258102655410767, -0.4321918487548828, -0.8032031655311584, -0.24709655344486237, 0.13339000940322876, 0.6828912496566772, -0.6461214423179626, 0.8091936111450195, -0.14189298450946808, 0.07099874317646027, -0.11609283834695816, 0.26281118392944336, -0.2347641885280609, -0.2918899953365326, -0.3411385118961334, 0.31843894720077515, -0.24137809872627258, -0.2583051919937134, 0.7302643060684204, 0.17425501346588135, -0.4368137717247009, 0.07959622144699097, 0.3010662794113159, -0.1322803497314453, -0.6382759213447571, -0.800666332244873, -0.6583608984947205, 0.028361491858959198, -0.28030332922935486, 0.07771165668964386, -1.3504571914672852, -0.20687434077262878, 0.17916162312030792, -0.24341098964214325, 0.3159942328929901, -0.6048302054405212, 0.5039318203926086, 0.17841528356075287, -0.2782590687274933, -0.626797080039978, -0.27523884177207947, -0.060920871794223785, 0.3497501015663147, 0.3994697332382202, -0.1945473998785019, -0.9655380249023438, -0.47525763511657715, -0.6677265167236328, -0.035794127732515335, -1.029542326927185, 0.2529074251651764, -0.18121418356895447, -0.02850067988038063, 0.026160160079598427, -0.01039139274507761, 0.5404401421546936, 0.318854957818985, 0.15942230820655823, -1.0819721221923828, 0.6341740489006042, 0.3638837933540344, -0.8144094944000244, 0.2814464569091797, -1.201921820640564, 0.5295732617378235, 0.9865736365318298, -0.35055503249168396, -0.9637129902839661, 0.35107070207595825, 0.24024876952171326, -0.0022607536520808935, 0.5477110743522644, -0.5676659345626831, -0.3131844699382782, -0.6738276481628418, 0.6085291504859924, 0.0332147479057312, -0.3060993552207947, -0.9645583033561707, 0.9811114072799683, -0.10640205442905426, 0.3107684254646301, -0.9521114826202393, -0.4546965956687927, 0.3141608238220215, -0.6664201617240906, 0.5999262928962708, -0.22642235457897186, 0.9749159812927246, -0.02823236584663391, -0.1125638335943222, 0.26394596695899963, 0.21940988302230835, -0.8971810340881348, -0.46098920702934265, -0.31471359729766846, -0.4337705373764038, 0.7083938121795654, -0.3249610960483551, -0.07298920303583145, 0.954727292060852, -0.5711867213249207, 0.24079063534736633, 0.08745615184307098, 1.018204927444458, 1.165765643119812, -0.7415265440940857, 0.7643710374832153, 0.6298282742500305, 0.06608262658119202, -0.7878068685531616, 0.48724421858787537, 0.2119467556476593, -0.08111747354269028, -0.006597405299544334, 0.4619279205799103, -0.5264220833778381, -0.6103420853614807, -0.2962378263473511, 0.1420399248600006, 0.4776318073272705, -0.1509438455104828, 0.9635558128356934, -0.15488913655281067, -0.5643765330314636, -0.6022249460220337, -0.13553486764431, 0.8720224499702454, 0.11548052728176117, 0.9003461003303528, -0.07774998992681503, -0.11420397460460663, -0.009660028852522373, 0.39242056012153625, 0.5335785150527954, 0.3975389301776886, 0.7027975916862488, -0.3024928867816925, -1.613123893737793, -0.262728750705719, 0.5944343209266663, -0.25235116481781006, -0.672842800617218, -0.40554121136665344, -0.5732091665267944, 0.6257570385932922, -0.5177597999572754, -0.43529507517814636, -0.16215398907661438, -0.16400082409381866, 0.8725345730781555, -0.11705415695905685, -0.03930852562189102, 0.040584009140729904, 0.1581972986459732, 0.6771103739738464, -0.5264599919319153, 0.348520427942276, 0.22770263254642487, -0.07386388629674911, -0.06553175300359726, -0.3917924761772156, -0.6230915784835815, 0.12534476816654205, 0.08490365743637085, -0.01046697050333023, -0.5932252407073975, 0.39412248134613037, 0.8168526291847229, -0.20520727336406708, 0.0905701145529747, 0.13081957399845123, 0.12105340510606766, 0.7536261081695557, 0.18210932612419128, -0.7902387976646423, -0.37215685844421387, 0.35821038484573364, 0.20749039947986603, 0.007475865073502064, -0.22352582216262817, -0.38154539465904236, -0.3214521110057831, -0.6460063457489014, 0.6512253880500793, -0.7129008173942566, -0.7131471037864685, -1.1982475519180298, -0.7745137810707092, -0.16779795289039612, 0.05664324760437012, 0.3941015303134918, -0.20336325466632843, -0.645556628704071, -0.5902348756790161, 0.10664431750774384, 0.5830343961715698, -0.37675538659095764, 0.6532883048057556, 0.16564315557479858, -0.3493117094039917, -0.6404776573181152, -0.6427839398384094, -0.5417280197143555, -0.6696968078613281, -0.03362064063549042, 0.47873857617378235, -0.6334477663040161, 0.968847393989563, -0.55820232629776, 0.0884544625878334, 0.029869109392166138, 0.39271649718284607, -0.5543854236602783, -1.0033929347991943, -0.3833252489566803, 0.802939236164093, -0.1421370655298233, 0.2730872333049774, 0.36431801319122314, -0.7540158033370972, -0.14561136066913605, 0.42585289478302, 0.48518022894859314, -0.29384395480155945, -0.39632460474967957, 0.43024373054504395, -0.35550904273986816, -0.544239342212677, 0.5786213874816895, 0.6012897491455078, -1.0937403440475464, -0.3612027168273926, -0.5059195160865784, -0.0025846888311207294, 0.12274688482284546, -0.5357998013496399, 0.3362448215484619, 0.20329926908016205, 0.0376291461288929, 1.531312346458435, -0.07471930235624313, 0.7754396796226501, 0.16770319640636444, 0.1977190375328064, 0.3642803728580475, 0.5601211786270142, 0.24401697516441345, -0.9965605735778809, 0.3609805107116699, 0.549615740776062, 0.29493090510368347, 0.4878644347190857, -0.2159479409456253, 0.1435094177722931, -0.1328083574771881, -0.13884103298187256, -0.01978888362646103, 0.6571261286735535, -0.4816780090332031, 0.7545313239097595, -0.4347410798072815, -0.13654521107673645, 0.5952325463294983, -0.5244043469429016, -1.27436101436615, -0.4325539469718933, 0.30326396226882935, -0.17828072607517242, -0.41724327206611633, -0.8364230394363403, -0.8192495107650757, -0.06595660746097565, -0.3934355080127716, -0.33821409940719604, 0.6935522556304932, 0.37421855330467224, -0.2175968736410141, 1.268287181854248, -0.16485300660133362, 0.315939724445343, -0.1590016484260559, 0.5533022284507751, -0.7830947041511536, -0.2918027639389038, -0.2770795524120331, 0.5412566065788269, -0.40835246443748474, 0.0735902413725853, -0.02623698301613331, 0.07680239528417587, -0.20244824886322021, -0.3990119397640228, -1.0077621936798096, 0.2046629786491394, -0.4217223823070526, -0.0911429151892662, 0.07785358279943466, 0.4520425796508789, -0.0602908693253994, 0.06501602381467819, -0.23815838992595673, -0.6449365615844727, -0.7478516101837158, -0.37267404794692993, 0.3764752149581909, -0.38449564576148987, -0.33867916464805603, -0.002336414996534586, 0.5708178877830505, -0.03773384541273117, 0.11329402029514313, 0.3035162389278412, 0.7811954021453857, 0.0022629359737038612, 0.013176125474274158, 0.02025074139237404, 0.3115736246109009, 0.4620896875858307, -0.33763954043388367, -0.9813928008079529, 0.37044745683670044, -0.20859022438526154, -0.24443072080612183, 0.6513316035270691, -0.5776136517524719, 0.0945746898651123, -0.4775567948818207, -0.11338233202695847, -0.12507368624210358, 0.1575838029384613, 1.002578616142273, 0.4020933508872986, -0.7472506761550903, 0.5504530072212219, -0.17683878540992737, -0.823955774307251, 0.12459444254636765, -0.08986590057611465, 0.7237746715545654, 0.2502152621746063, -0.13575267791748047, 0.7324687242507935, 1.4414538145065308, -0.288178026676178, 0.1366899013519287, 0.42823293805122375, -0.32448944449424744, 0.09696325659751892, -0.8722262382507324, 0.6480484008789062, -0.5698273181915283, -0.579179584980011, -0.005979853682219982, 0.3280058205127716, -0.379551500082016, 0.3511512577533722, -0.3447543978691101, 0.24130640923976898, 0.6891505718231201, 0.00846095010638237, -0.3359512686729431, -0.6433975100517273, 1.0235613584518433, -0.32467684149742126, 0.00498570129275322, 0.04055250436067581, 0.48676303029060364, -0.0689600482583046, -0.17630183696746826, 0.18624217808246613, 0.5237377285957336, 1.0853577852249146, 1.0805855989456177, -0.06379245221614838, 0.338141530752182, 0.971881091594696, 0.4542871415615082, 0.3140520751476288, -0.743831992149353, -0.13385465741157532, 0.5746303200721741, -0.00213617249391973, -0.27262958884239197, 0.8505004048347473, -1.4618319272994995, -0.45864754915237427, -0.20876643061637878, 0.6821234822273254, -0.5493406057357788, -0.9076266288757324, 0.2544577419757843, -0.15808315575122833, 0.15506084263324738, -0.8999735713005066, 0.5774558782577515, 0.1576271802186966, 0.2712646424770355, 0.5811586976051331, -0.07107362896203995, -0.009285111911594868, 0.5605263113975525, -1.0501941442489624, 0.5558690428733826, -0.24310073256492615, -0.5522655844688416, -0.34741848707199097, -1.125723958015442, -0.37199878692626953, 0.05326467379927635, -0.007124331314116716, -0.37358802556991577, -0.007887221872806549, 1.42959463596344, 0.42645692825317383, -0.14348281919956207, -0.037719834595918655, -0.4145722985267639, 0.7230898141860962, 1.1457345485687256, -0.36893025040626526, 0.13492822647094727, -0.7320683002471924, -0.016803842037916183, -0.15519161522388458, -0.38600292801856995, 0.690272331237793, -0.17664816975593567, -0.9387107491493225, -1.2347453832626343, 0.34647831320762634, -0.35641613602638245, -0.6611920595169067, 0.11385628581047058, 0.24957315623760223, -0.060725875198841095, -0.5016759037971497, -0.8100475668907166, -0.636670708656311, -0.8778238892555237, 0.3648861348628998, -0.6074552536010742, 0.029960235580801964, 0.12660294771194458, 0.29807785153388977, 0.5645483136177063, -0.5132700204849243, 3.7690465450286865, 0.8760458827018738, 0.6471468210220337, -0.5286104083061218, 1.1099497079849243, 1.0298689603805542, 0.979868471622467, -0.05649302154779434, 0.3373006582260132, 0.04067379981279373, 0.3333353102207184, 0.17478980123996735, 0.2004302442073822, -0.5549913644790649, 0.25071069598197937, -0.22361181676387787, -0.3040960133075714, 0.41543370485305786, -0.20390105247497559, -0.7280294299125671, -0.714832603931427, 0.07534556835889816, -0.12353893369436264, 0.35354599356651306, 0.5162807703018188, 0.1964225023984909, 0.4417385160923004, -0.19839194416999817, 0.5310720801353455, -0.1913144439458847, -0.1391764134168625, -0.2132515013217926, 0.19886405766010284, -0.42024916410446167, -0.7291637063026428, 0.1866973489522934, 0.4444555342197418, -0.474668025970459, -0.1890944540500641, -0.2085643857717514, -0.15892693400382996, -0.2038833349943161, 0.48483026027679443, -0.06527674943208694, -0.3925827443599701, 0.8228245973587036, 0.04830530285835266, -0.1347791850566864, 0.7893462777137756, -0.5686203241348267, 0.15731105208396912, -1.1445015668869019, 0.7848587036132812, -0.27123332023620605, -0.9064429402351379, -0.34073156118392944, -0.6232483983039856, -1.1732901334762573, -0.11616618931293488, 0.3365788757801056, 0.5559850931167603, -0.010279692709445953, 0.5534896850585938, 0.15664663910865784, -0.08963347971439362, 0.3109165132045746, 0.22456790506839752, -0.5215522050857544, -0.25226160883903503, -0.03501833230257034, 0.125573992729187, -0.6100746393203735, -0.7582926154136658, 0.0914667397737503, 0.39973729848861694, 0.19485926628112793, -0.1394193321466446, 0.5835105776786804, -0.5579995512962341, 0.024212859570980072, -0.35466083884239197, 0.7380512356758118, 0.20196813344955444, 0.061452776193618774, -0.11801932007074356, 0.8947163224220276, 0.2711060345172882, 0.07213504612445831, -0.16712786257266998, 0.24900171160697937, 0.7298712730407715, 0.4797365069389343, 0.06948031485080719, 0.7865350842475891, 0.3114512264728546 ]
{"Title": "Quantifying the success of measles vaccination campaigns in the Rohingya refugee camps", "Authors": "Chin Taylor, Buckee Caroline O., Mahmud Ayesha S.", "Abstract": "Abstract In the wake of the Rohingya population\u2019s mass migration from Myanmar, one of the world\u2019s largest refugee settlements was constructed in Cox\u2019s Bazar, Bangladesh to accommodate nearly 900,000 new refugees. Refugee populations are particularly vulnerable to infectious disease outbreaks due to many population and environmental factors. A large measles outbreak, with over 2,500 cases, occurred among the Rohingya population between September and December 2017. Here, we estimate key epidemiological parameters and use a dynamic mathematical model of measles transmission to evaluate the effectiveness of the reactive vaccination campaigns in the refugee camps. We also estimate the potential for subsequent outbreaks under different vaccination coverage scenarios. Our modeling results highlight the success of the vaccination campaigns in rapidly curbing transmission and emphasize the public health importance of maintaining high levels of vaccination in this population, where high birth rates and historically low vaccination coverage rates create suitable conditions for future measles outbreaks.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008417"}
10.1101/2019.12.11.19014522
[ -0.19832931458950043, 0.17832449078559875, -0.4446216821670532, 0.7130246758460999, -0.03175893425941467, -0.23272714018821716, -0.026774374768137932, 0.22035524249076843, 0.4388963580131531, 0.5832844972610474, 0.20990519225597382, -0.45520690083503723, 0.4442497193813324, -0.37404289841651917, -0.04234827309846878, 0.13243044912815094, -1.015864372253418, 0.38473910093307495, 0.186233788728714, 0.5234192609786987, 0.3911993205547333, 0.8005172610282898, -0.862741231918335, 0.6181485056877136, -0.13117817044258118, 0.7192580699920654, 0.023744182661175728, 0.3396371603012085, 1.4479671716690063, 0.6168352365493774, 0.18287840485572815, -0.8461005687713623, 0.6206682324409485, -0.7077997326850891, -0.3246833384037018, -0.1158546730875969, 0.4911767244338989, -0.2976500988006592, -0.05932627245783806, 0.16766688227653503, -0.006352220196276903, -0.05309078097343445, 0.8625674843788147, -0.37682414054870605, -0.755783200263977, -0.18927113711833954, -1.3588556051254272, -0.8696902990341187, -0.3606274127960205, 0.08995922654867172, 0.08104769885540009, -0.006504867225885391, 0.5830565094947815, -0.7322733402252197, 0.01583775505423546, -0.0754547119140625, 0.13617725670337677, 0.4263112246990204, -0.8610971570014954, -0.15645283460617065, 0.2369682341814041, 0.111701101064682, 0.4620583653450012, -1.324766755104065, 0.8647298812866211, 0.6115108728408813, -0.34295716881752014, -0.7088891267776489, -0.5795762538909912, 0.6912786364555359, -0.7449495196342468, -0.8843740820884705, -0.10392332822084427, -0.11470136791467667, 0.02159816212952137, -0.026865944266319275, 0.3193485736846924, 0.11177511513233185, -0.06104784458875656, 0.014828882180154324, 0.41123324632644653, -0.08543506264686584, 0.13692991435527802, 0.5780834555625916, -0.7771802544593811, -0.0015100432792678475, 0.49987682700157166, 0.6184379458427429, 0.3034370243549347, 0.37623047828674316, -0.17405851185321808, -0.00999381858855486, 0.2969874441623688, -0.09632254391908646, 0.0792367234826088, 0.8422558903694153, -0.7868808507919312, 0.38055041432380676, -0.30599159002304077, -0.378898948431015, 1.1648691892623901, 0.513529896736145, -0.3671494424343109, 1.0973199605941772, -0.39562490582466125, 0.5374279022216797, 0.8339496850967407, -0.0004944209940731525, -0.6844923496246338, -1.3224589824676514, 0.5788128972053528, 0.0013397764414548874, -0.8820372819900513, 0.21611671149730682, 0.5561792850494385, 0.6648350954055786, -0.2875519096851349, 1.1949317455291748, -0.5148967504501343, 0.33217960596084595, -0.5187669396400452, 0.02331143245100975, 0.2758536636829376, -0.04906421899795532, 0.3137146532535553, 0.1334102302789688, 0.31187865138053894, 0.6712932586669922, -0.4120768904685974, -0.00821505207568407, -0.07217033952474594, -0.613787055015564, 0.10834846645593643, -0.1983071118593216, -0.3623293340206146, -0.2257876694202423, 0.08484721183776855, 1.2456296682357788, -0.7076600790023804, -0.18921789526939392, 0.06014174968004227, 0.3156561255455017, -0.9307600855827332, 0.9741595983505249, 0.7678841352462769, 1.1050196886062622, -1.2610912322998047, -0.9264466762542725, -0.4720281958580017, -0.37760302424430847, 0.11538834124803543, 0.8202558755874634, 0.20895616710186005, -0.6206441521644592, -0.5273747444152832, 0.21098312735557556, -0.014184770174324512, 0.40061408281326294, 0.030376728624105453, 0.10139487683773041, -0.7568479180335999, -0.06050253286957741, -0.16655418276786804, 0.8222817778587341, -0.5597324967384338, 0.6261102557182312, 0.016366958618164062, 0.2060389518737793, 0.06555994600057602, -0.6135905981063843, 0.7528615593910217, 0.5245681405067444, -0.3362516462802887, -0.7170537710189819, 0.42208993434906006, 0.6106439232826233, 0.6633487939834595, -0.2587365210056305, 0.44764015078544617, 0.199240043759346, 0.28265857696533203, 0.19811491668224335, 0.24474921822547913, 0.8191022872924805, -0.0059069921262562275, 0.07504032552242279, -0.5964530110359192, -0.5884126424789429, -0.5508117079734802, -0.35907384753227234, 0.20390848815441132, 0.16171395778656006, 0.022611863911151886, 0.8952363729476929, -0.01026704628020525, 0.3821931481361389, -0.7909824252128601, 1.0395275354385376, 0.23322704434394836, -0.6650233864784241, -0.4825427830219269, 0.5663347840309143, 0.20564767718315125, 0.10088960826396942, -0.1861305683851242, 1.0345796346664429, -0.412019282579422, 0.5306448936462402, -0.8456099629402161, -0.2517646849155426, 0.6930803656578064, 1.0424216985702515, -0.05153162404894829, 0.13582584261894226, 1.014477252960205, -0.1133517250418663, -0.23896414041519165, -0.5239961743354797, -0.49275216460227966, 0.11179916560649872, 0.4615311920642853, -0.5038376450538635, 0.4974863827228546, 0.28580862283706665, 0.34512752294540405, 0.08641314506530762, 0.6682336330413818, 0.4117428660392761, -0.47316741943359375, -0.7045284509658813, -0.004105830565094948, 0.9622145295143127, 0.44986873865127563, 0.45854827761650085, 0.4293741285800934, 0.4200451076030731, 0.6927306056022644, 0.07369261234998703, 0.44649946689605713, 0.7010911703109741, 0.8602095246315002, 0.6510769724845886, 0.671233057975769, 0.7455894351005554, -0.5874782204627991, 0.22524011135101318, -0.6719945073127747, 0.7149071097373962, -0.2511080205440521, 0.6159245371818542, -0.9188206791877747, 0.274422824382782, -0.23324432969093323, 0.41505199670791626, -0.6475784778594971, -0.4090004861354828, 0.0652330070734024, 0.05528830736875534, 0.006468221079558134, -0.43845856189727783, -0.20758837461471558, -0.0015162762720137835, -0.2913167476654053, -0.16941727697849274, 0.4692094027996063, 0.5819727778434753, 0.10478972643613815, 0.45156535506248474, 0.5777071118354797, -0.0796033963561058, -0.264584481716156, -0.8082821369171143, -1.35916268825531, -1.318261742591858, -1.3146743774414062, 0.14822496473789215, 0.3274838626384735, -0.5971999168395996, -0.2657686471939087, -0.02143789455294609, 0.5469603538513184, -0.5597346425056458, -0.05515946075320244, 1.1477895975112915, 0.7570657134056091, 0.5027137994766235, -1.029700756072998, 0.24403899908065796, -0.3292228579521179, -0.03170984610915184, -0.3772926926612854, -0.26127755641937256, -0.4607757329940796, -0.9525186419487, 0.6824151873588562, -0.8576579093933105, 0.236174076795578, 0.13450556993484497, 0.6763470768928528, -0.9138468503952026, 0.16255000233650208, 0.26351115107536316, -0.3737298548221588, 0.07608484476804733, -0.813431441783905, 0.3584566116333008, 0.33917438983917236, 0.2310643196105957, 0.0996343195438385, 0.6621645092964172, -0.6764471530914307, 0.505947470664978, -0.18787245452404022, 0.34545156359672546, -1.0132970809936523, -0.012749557383358479, 0.5541149377822876, 0.12189260125160217, -0.32957035303115845, -0.4973878264427185, -1.123068928718567, -0.4607120454311371, -0.2526419162750244, 0.15638595819473267, -0.19808052480220795, -0.00012197828618809581, 0.14066174626350403, -1.1888647079467773, 0.6791442632675171, -0.0990336537361145, -1.1079442501068115, -0.09762488305568695, -0.5438185334205627, 0.7535445094108582, 0.2597540616989136, -0.44358348846435547, -0.5959830284118652, -0.12810851633548737, 0.24709784984588623, 0.4628395140171051, 0.17055368423461914, -0.005269442684948444, -0.3560449182987213, -0.05339943245053291, 0.3446162939071655, 0.15063826739788055, 0.5553784966468811, -0.3165076673030853, 0.12727537751197815, -0.03974681720137596, 0.024875536561012268, 0.688798725605011, 1.0583575963974, -0.21181340515613556, 0.06502071768045425, 0.5650067329406738, -0.42624861001968384, -0.20104071497917175, 0.3374429941177368, 0.6028173565864563, -0.2542365789413452, 0.7486480474472046, 0.19311855733394623, 0.9213247895240784, -0.20848220586776733, -0.6782853007316589, 0.7043100595474243, -0.4229130148887634, 0.3482646048069, -1.5342973470687866, 0.5236024856567383, 0.33037373423576355, -0.4245307147502899, -0.15036720037460327, -0.037530317902565, 0.4478304088115692, 1.0223978757858276, 0.2087089568376541, 1.0100698471069336, -1.4658353328704834, 0.5905993580818176, 0.7704934477806091, 1.3431910276412964, 0.3011928200721741, -0.3754159212112427, 0.12837180495262146, -0.5296577215194702, 0.6793097257614136, -0.4738280773162842, -0.30637359619140625, 0.03409579396247864, 0.13089658319950104, -0.40049177408218384, 0.5563236474990845, -0.5348077416419983, -0.2606406509876251, 0.4075320363044739, 0.18933703005313873, -0.213057741522789, -0.17958587408065796, 0.9470271468162537, -0.8973144292831421, -0.12417502701282501, -0.3529103100299835, 0.63315349817276, -0.3808693587779999, -0.3779298961162567, 0.02388155832886696, -0.023782573640346527, -0.7638879418373108, 0.14455021917819977, -0.06218211352825165, -0.7143077254295349, 0.250336229801178, 0.8909724354743958, -0.30530473589897156, -1.0132211446762085, -0.03784628212451935, -0.3438660800457001, 0.1375436931848526, 0.41474130749702454, 0.7702866792678833, -0.388487845659256, 0.6756604313850403, 0.3490745425224304, -1.174852967262268, -0.125566765666008, -0.46917811036109924, 0.7708202004432678, 0.9352540373802185, -0.09730782359838486, -0.742508053779602, -0.3974534869194031, -0.2848173677921295, -0.8033034801483154, 0.1518518030643463, -0.2326820194721222, -0.5574228763580322, 0.09283784031867981, 0.21894341707229614, -0.3039269745349884, -0.4116646647453308, 0.21302762627601624, -0.14639660716056824, 0.5196753740310669, -0.08531367778778076, 0.3496212065219879, 0.17505782842636108, 0.8574337363243103, -0.2759205400943756, 0.5565990209579468, -0.6560235023498535, 0.14160269498825073, -0.42089226841926575, -0.8771262764930725, -0.5035629272460938, 0.14971230924129486, 0.10992375761270523, -0.5159747004508972, -1.1158641576766968, -0.18523208796977997, 0.296138197183609, -0.13208173215389252, -0.1695532649755478, -0.36206549406051636, 0.999640166759491, -0.1443885713815689, 0.000908692367374897, 1.3793481588363647, 0.27910906076431274, -0.28002992272377014, -0.07157900929450989, 0.04511220008134842, -1.0178618431091309, -0.0026549568865448236, 0.1266820728778839, 0.22716262936592102, -0.6552022695541382, 0.06867412477731705, -0.28581246733665466, 0.011081648990511894, 0.4188239574432373, -0.4347530007362366, -0.2818928360939026, -0.31962016224861145, -0.9276403784751892, -0.2578975260257721, -0.33782175183296204, -1.197360634803772, 0.3068626821041107, 0.6275871396064758, -0.8118526339530945, -0.08401306718587875, -0.01864427886903286, -0.745736300945282, -0.8998404145240784, -1.445772409439087, 0.11923405528068542, -0.27239248156547546, 0.507344126701355, 1.232740879058838, -0.5748057961463928, -0.29118433594703674, 0.608607828617096, 0.30602917075157166, -1.1609090566635132, -0.13103321194648743, 0.2806749939918518, -0.08450714498758316, -0.6836497783660889, -0.0037616328336298466, 0.15274088084697723, -0.29657289385795593, -0.015436242334544659, 0.012752298265695572, 0.15809959173202515, 0.428406298160553, -0.578382670879364, -0.31436434388160706, 1.1969372034072876, -0.209747776389122, -1.2800331115722656, -0.31909823417663574, 0.3073223829269409, 0.44255656003952026, -0.055984094738960266, -0.3302971422672272, -0.9662535190582275, -0.8691186904907227, -1.0984113216400146, -0.08282899856567383, -1.109144926071167, 0.1959240734577179, -0.3397176265716553, 0.0038189685437828302, 0.630313515663147, 0.36097288131713867, 0.11574093252420425, 0.18650896847248077, 0.2693936824798584, -0.19893403351306915, -0.03808256611227989, -0.6807348132133484, 0.07481597363948822, -0.006859569810330868, -0.3776243031024933, 0.6630886793136597, 0.7809221744537354, 0.580268383026123, -0.26149222254753113, 0.6456936597824097, -0.03489292412996292, 0.41488540172576904, 0.15937599539756775, 0.12273503094911575, 0.1969984471797943, -0.20096831023693085, 0.7943159937858582, -0.0035404351074248552, -0.25130394101142883, -1.510242223739624, 0.4456455111503601, -0.4568658769130707, 0.4895607531070709, -0.25175046920776367, -0.1234804317355156, -0.2847411036491394, -0.25571995973587036, 1.148897647857666, -0.46289926767349243, 0.21461078524589539, 0.02899164892733097, -0.32746773958206177, 0.1483423262834549, 0.5140078067779541, -0.15956827998161316, -0.5529301762580872, -0.894298255443573, -0.6814243197441101, 0.3717348873615265, -0.3716319501399994, 0.20253877341747284, 0.12425128370523453, 0.1852685958147049, 0.019389519467949867, -0.4392929673194885, 0.8438600301742554, 0.4960840344429016, -0.5593054294586182, -0.7923452258110046, 0.05612868815660477, 0.46116286516189575, -0.028040574863553047, -0.09604507684707642, 0.05452908203005791, -0.31814923882484436, -0.2115396112203598, -0.14144524931907654, -0.6787378787994385, -0.5363584160804749, -0.3060939610004425, 0.4231630563735962, 0.7829676270484924, 0.36294394731521606, 0.19422341883182526, -0.3271350562572479, -0.11618652194738388, -0.39329394698143005, 1.1082226037979126, -0.31803759932518005, 0.6712955236434937, 0.8449987173080444, -0.9509003758430481, -0.4147488474845886, 0.7733292579650879, -0.2712964415550232, -0.5711203813552856, -0.4380260109901428, 0.4230026602745056, 0.5043440461158752, -0.6462472677230835, 0.6393229365348816, 0.006504750810563564, -0.7040117979049683, -0.36658066511154175, 0.5616286396980286, -0.35036876797676086, -0.061461079865694046, -0.15026207268238068, 0.1487247794866562, 0.4850742220878601, 0.0030590591486543417, 0.35259732604026794, -0.0387401208281517, 0.06653832644224167, -0.28889140486717224, -0.6010015606880188, 0.18119029700756073, -0.6626813411712646, -0.3059960603713989, 0.2769281268119812, -0.45766374468803406, 1.0488084554672241, 0.3977036774158478, 0.7255463600158691, 0.22519496083259583, 0.1358838975429535, 0.35197916626930237, -0.9458109140396118, -0.5922930836677551, -0.16738533973693848, 0.09657954424619675, -0.11399728804826736, 0.005400205031037331, -0.6534692049026489, 0.8061181306838989, 0.019021375104784966, -0.3643316626548767, -0.30555346608161926, -0.48132652044296265, 0.9151850938796997, 0.4699130058288574, -0.09143329411745071, -0.07421160489320755, 0.9055619239807129, 0.7045846581459045, -0.36152300238609314, -0.23252815008163452, -0.7034293413162231, -0.966268002986908, -0.6418516635894775, 0.393793523311615, -1.4099009037017822, 0.43823114037513733, 0.938934326171875, -0.24148277938365936, -0.7617208957672119, -0.6524490118026733, 0.7302128672599792, -0.1498216986656189, -0.3138238787651062, -0.5600184202194214, 0.5300481915473938, -0.643490195274353, -0.1174975112080574, -0.3808416426181793, -1.0183185338974, 0.02299720235168934, 1.0581389665603638, -0.38847804069519043, 0.2746414244174957, 0.4951642155647278, -0.032245323061943054, 0.3291168510913849, 0.31037822365760803, -0.6811428070068359, -0.7320587635040283, -0.25366127490997314, 1.0005775690078735, 0.08420850336551666, 0.03297358751296997, 1.3495112657546997, -0.3545423746109009, 0.7873384952545166, -0.09372285008430481, 0.08158628642559052, -0.05867643654346466, 0.3655463457107544, 0.39206191897392273, -1.0586473941802979, -1.010067343711853, -0.14404407143592834, 0.5676140189170837, -0.793208122253418, -1.1279406547546387, -1.0978935956954956, -0.10718823224306107, -0.5407190322875977, 0.09497576206922531, -0.5898810625076294, 0.877716064453125, 0.3562433123588562, 0.22783370316028595, 0.5709375143051147, 0.2795064151287079, 0.18915800750255585, 0.4966594874858856, 0.14607524871826172, -0.06474937498569489, 0.018154878169298172, -0.5961850881576538, 0.014017716981470585, -0.08505424112081528, -0.7298793196678162, 0.5760921239852905, -0.09001564234495163, 0.41172856092453003, 0.12377797067165375, 0.4358859062194824, -0.1495019495487213, 0.4864044487476349, 0.2758183181285858, 0.3306715190410614, 0.31347668170928955, -0.49708476662635803, -0.5850388407707214, -0.2466360330581665, -1.0427308082580566, -0.3676689565181732, 0.338419109582901, -0.531844437122345, 0.19205342233181, -0.37642017006874084, -0.3713492155075073, 0.44233834743499756, 0.27989041805267334, 0.3585949242115021, -0.22123491764068604, 0.5614669919013977, 0.45782139897346497, 0.8187008500099182, 0.6123756170272827, 0.3866773545742035, 0.6366792321205139, 0.12365463376045227, -0.8428841233253479, -0.7548521161079407, 0.08205269277095795, 0.13515357673168182, 0.2614118456840515, -0.6217347979545593, -0.5768465399742126, -0.3419186472892761, 0.23424820601940155, -0.08083462715148926, 0.16291792690753937, -0.09519095718860626, -0.3290940523147583, 0.07816178351640701, -0.5383698344230652, 0.15774200856685638, -0.33146965503692627, 0.4089633822441101, 0.15254175662994385, -0.935020923614502, -0.3287157118320465, 0.35919758677482605, 1.0818206071853638, -0.055238183587789536, 0.4568987190723419, -0.5241999626159668, 0.23386386036872864, -0.5142626762390137, -0.1899486482143402, 0.19090929627418518, 0.9283364415168762, -0.1662694662809372, 0.0002698154712561518, 0.5218843221664429, 0.16214488446712494, 0.9926421046257019, 0.017844824120402336, 0.6344717144966125, 0.5961593985557556, 0.2577859163284302, 0.4453681409358978, 0.16833443939685822, -0.8100824356079102, 0.7179731130599976, 0.6000558733940125, -0.1812596321105957, -0.2701680660247803, 0.26821181178092957, 0.5719735026359558, -0.5722676515579224, -0.368956059217453, 0.39996618032455444, -0.3521535396575928, -0.5480889081954956, 0.09028751403093338, 0.7193936705589294, 0.7668942213058472, 0.3648998439311981, 0.4487438499927521, 0.25246769189834595, 0.16327817738056183, -0.08704513311386108, -0.28529074788093567, 0.5073900818824768, -0.44434434175491333, -0.4373835623264313, -0.6605921983718872, 0.4046551585197449, 0.19147779047489166, 0.10790354013442993, -0.01574777252972126, -0.31601759791374207, -0.4610291123390198, 0.9380772113800049, -0.35248857736587524, -0.4985654652118683, 0.7048265337944031, -0.5332854390144348, -0.6004114151000977, 0.004852032754570246, -0.1576720029115677, -0.6060330867767334, -0.6570106148719788, 0.5669816732406616, -0.5688192248344421, 0.16871565580368042, 0.39575308561325073, 0.17540648579597473, 0.6100677847862244, -0.46558934450149536, 0.9186339974403381, -0.18720147013664246, 0.5138751268386841, 0.7682026028633118, 0.6300923228263855, 0.12841273844242096, -0.04415734112262726, -0.452888160943985, 0.05198288336396217, -0.484693318605423, -0.42879703640937805, -0.09827183932065964, -0.5669805407524109, -0.7819904685020447, 0.42495542764663696, -0.15707190334796906, -0.5262113809585571, -0.04615923389792442, -0.5433478355407715, -0.3750264346599579, 0.06888337433338165, -0.27653053402900696, -0.05176330730319023, -0.02075125090777874, -0.1361939013004303, -0.5533212423324585, -0.22820919752120972, -0.06261534988880157, 0.14501595497131348, -0.2839561700820923, 0.15598410367965698, -0.14992573857307434, -0.2576037645339966, -0.4476024806499481, -0.9981809854507446, -0.23741371929645538, -0.10624084621667862, 0.028922198340296745, -0.7064660787582397, 0.053687673062086105, -0.0697346031665802, 0.03138044849038124, -0.10976915806531906, -0.4381692111492157, 0.3309014141559601, 0.20113518834114075, 0.18957820534706116, -0.41239508986473083, -0.20502206683158875, 0.013653865084052086, 0.7674778699874878, 0.057614199817180634, 0.1567857563495636, 0.3607370853424072, 0.1279660165309906, -0.5495838522911072, -0.8909172415733337, 0.23272767663002014, 0.220213383436203, -0.6086393594741821, 0.28225839138031006, 0.34421369433403015, -0.2640199363231659, -0.1401337832212448, -1.137039065361023, -0.5750630497932434, -0.392575740814209, 1.1410130262374878, -0.3196510076522827, 0.08298967778682709, 0.35510537028312683, -0.21478281915187836, 0.4589206576347351, -0.8578557968139648, 3.9792561531066895, 1.1465606689453125, 0.6006056666374207, -0.10226594656705856, 0.388807088136673, 0.5491028428077698, 0.18339769542217255, -0.5548809766769409, 0.4809749722480774, 0.7406504154205322, -0.6914482712745667, 0.2971217930316925, 0.11036167293787003, -0.2820947766304016, 0.938408374786377, 0.3125709891319275, -0.9840041995048523, -0.2432236522436142, 0.14472949504852295, -0.8253054618835449, 0.21173064410686493, 0.30502596497535706, -0.1313023567199707, -0.035833265632390976, 0.5951043963432312, 0.04817608371376991, 0.17123599350452423, -0.2972360849380493, -0.11683105677366257, 0.029489023610949516, -0.07057271152734756, -0.9003450274467468, 0.23170390725135803, -0.3193740248680115, -0.2124650478363037, 0.5118904709815979, -0.29704928398132324, -0.5092018246650696, 0.10722723603248596, -0.2785338759422302, 0.028629204258322716, -0.30873680114746094, -0.5636777877807617, -0.12767858803272247, -0.1130344569683075, 0.2655991017818451, -0.4491737484931946, 0.35611361265182495, 0.7300060987472534, -0.6983368992805481, 0.9017629027366638, -1.1725395917892456, 0.6042025089263916, 0.1492159068584442, -0.8057677149772644, 0.29107508063316345, -0.5416521430015564, -0.44245201349258423, 0.18050692975521088, 1.066818118095398, 0.7590950131416321, -0.16425395011901855, -0.24693405628204346, 0.19815662503242493, 0.2601430118083954, 0.3988581895828247, 0.8370709419250488, -0.24215710163116455, -0.09556622058153152, 0.03472224250435829, -0.1057078167796135, 0.10238237679004669, -0.5344495177268982, -0.003188434289768338, 0.9579067826271057, 1.2634519338607788, -0.2881889343261719, 0.018393300473690033, -0.7238354682922363, -0.9440851211547852, 0.40536874532699585, -0.6510332822799683, 0.2587861716747284, -0.4737127721309662, -0.15908873081207275, 1.4031089544296265, -1.042983055114746, -0.20364528894424438, -1.1277565956115723, 0.9817476272583008, 0.029080074280500412, -0.2987925410270691, 0.262914776802063, -0.24564802646636963, 0.30432581901550293 ]
{"Title": "Mendelian randomization of smoking behavior on cognitive status among older Americans", "Authors": "Fu Mingzhou, Faul Jessica D., Jin Yuan, Ware Erin B., Bakulski Kelly M.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Smoking is a likely risk factor for dementia, and smoking behavior has a strong genetic component. In this study, we jointly test the associations between cumulative genetic risk for smoking, smoking behavior, and cognitive status using a Mendelian randomization framework. Methods We conducted a cross-sectional study using the 2010 wave of the Health and Retirement Study database. Individuals aged between 50 and 90 were included. Smoking status was self-reported. Polygenic scores (PGSs) were calculated by weighting participant genotype by published smoking genome-wide association estimates. Cognitive status (normal, impaired, dementia) was measured using multiple assessments. A Mendelian randomization framework was used to infer causal relationships between smoking behavior and cognitive status via genetic instruments. Results Among European ancestry participants (N = 8,735), current smoking behavior was positively associated with cognitive impairment (OR = 1.62, 95% CI: 1.29, 2.01) relative to normal cognition. Using smoking PGS as an instrumental variable, a causal relationship was observed between current smoking and cognitive impairment (OR = 1.53, 95% CI: 1.07, 2.18). There were no associations between smoking PGS, smoking behaviors and cognitive status in the African ancestry study sample (N = 2,511). Conclusions Current smoking is a modifiable risk factor which causes cognitive impairment. Promotion of smoking cessation is important for public health. Further studies on dose and duration of smoking behaviors on cognitive impairment are critically needed, as well as in research other ancestries.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.11.19014522"}
10.1101/19003061
[ -0.20769359171390533, 0.04977486655116081, -0.5902037620544434, 0.10249092429876328, -0.5272263288497925, 0.0231787022203207, 0.70350182056427, 0.12015311419963837, 0.2505105137825012, 0.7786064147949219, 0.2329655885696411, -0.592906653881073, 0.7988083958625793, 0.19591058790683746, 0.02879541553556919, 0.03923589363694191, -0.18789777159690857, -0.2862319350242615, 0.021817130967974663, 0.2100176215171814, -0.20240409672260284, -0.11322269588708878, -0.7303488850593567, 0.36943092942237854, -0.6621775031089783, 0.8434253931045532, -0.27599427103996277, -0.7306013703346252, 0.9745870232582092, 0.4630383253097534, 0.31682097911834717, -0.13471855223178864, 0.6988339424133301, -0.4019853472709656, 0.09989519417285919, -0.26899632811546326, 0.5972261428833008, -0.6769043207168579, -0.13994313776493073, -0.06904236972332001, 1.154857873916626, -0.30592530965805054, 0.5127506256103516, -0.7705865502357483, -0.06533443182706833, 0.030636198818683624, -0.2960384786128998, 0.08941221982240677, -0.13574248552322388, 0.05326732620596886, -0.6518126726150513, -0.24799031019210815, -0.515431821346283, -0.19139455258846283, -0.5433284044265747, 0.3349442481994629, -0.20511800050735474, -0.5046646595001221, -1.5315055847167969, -0.09556430578231812, -0.03188353031873703, 0.21814504265785217, 1.062912106513977, -1.0967777967453003, 0.5552139282226562, 0.0029481458477675915, -0.4496648609638214, -0.1682051122188568, 0.3962443768978119, 0.11568260192871094, -0.5039753317832947, -0.46680644154548645, -0.1829676330089569, -0.5362326502799988, -0.7507844567298889, -0.16565877199172974, -0.29886963963508606, -0.3776421546936035, -0.6881090402603149, 0.07871942967176437, 0.7261992692947388, 0.6541137099266052, 0.3935847282409668, -0.36436423659324646, -0.5640986561775208, 0.10216998308897018, 0.06344695389270782, 0.17050029337406158, -0.12158113718032837, 0.6905553936958313, -0.5280115008354187, 0.514064371585846, -0.022629542276263237, 0.7023594379425049, 0.7513045072555542, 0.9170771241188049, -0.793461799621582, 0.19375792145729065, 0.46950966119766235, 0.40238964557647705, 0.8005918860435486, 0.5946090817451477, -0.12117259204387665, 0.9891214370727539, -0.07246106117963791, 0.5255587100982666, 0.10746874660253525, -1.0864133834838867, -0.41870251297950745, -0.33622196316719055, -0.0937752053141594, -0.11867674440145493, -1.0589306354522705, -0.1922995001077652, 0.5274695158004761, -0.036447543650865555, -0.3045947253704071, 0.6202162504196167, 0.1509711891412735, 0.6699358224868774, 0.1282448172569275, 0.7078114151954651, 0.924534261226654, -0.16850925981998444, -0.06534186750650406, -0.11396748572587967, 0.2266174703836441, 0.7293095588684082, -0.5000476837158203, -0.11382997035980225, 0.1385202556848526, -0.41971880197525024, 0.3145894706249237, 1.0374852418899536, -0.2596896290779114, 0.18435293436050415, 0.5213986039161682, 0.3674112856388092, 0.5156582593917847, 0.23743286728858948, -0.25829747319221497, 0.7587980628013611, -0.5061860084533691, 0.8940848112106323, -0.3497101068496704, 1.0822359323501587, -0.904113233089447, -0.7798662781715393, -0.5987615585327148, -0.3200823664665222, 0.36796456575393677, 0.45970386266708374, 0.28422796726226807, 0.0433182418346405, 0.24675026535987854, 0.48529598116874695, -0.12370947003364563, 0.2193359136581421, 0.566695511341095, -0.06877025961875916, 0.6477925777435303, -0.1346912384033203, -0.25719159841537476, 0.5863979458808899, -0.17703565955162048, 0.6823529005050659, -0.18434198200702667, 0.5006579756736755, 0.7040917873382568, -0.4339440166950226, 0.9599776268005371, 0.2314014583826065, -0.7339004874229431, -0.025431698188185692, 0.35005196928977966, 0.65257328748703, 0.11887434870004654, -0.06573054939508438, 0.014715009368956089, 0.8488808870315552, 0.19221131503582, -0.12978987395763397, -0.13643167912960052, 0.6600486040115356, 0.19708605110645294, 0.8741208910942078, -0.020772701129317284, -1.2366747856140137, -0.2799028754234314, -0.48834553360939026, -0.07150214165449142, 0.5620766878128052, -0.5395053625106812, 0.15066133439540863, -0.27361786365509033, -0.4030326306819916, -0.12475893646478653, 0.21599923074245453, -0.051502007991075516, -0.19529502093791962, -0.5600333213806152, 0.24743007123470306, -0.2194845825433731, 0.7901555895805359, 0.3685753643512726, 0.37214332818984985, 0.17377358675003052, 0.4196859300136566, 0.0006015925901010633, 0.06778710335493088, 0.6282581686973572, -0.08113158494234085, -0.10831037908792496, -0.10013994574546814, 0.7431442737579346, -0.0261312797665596, 0.2064172476530075, 0.19291065633296967, -0.7664809823036194, 0.23542097210884094, -0.4344441294670105, 0.4554293155670166, -0.07624589651823044, -0.24478554725646973, -0.20883092284202576, 0.27614226937294006, 0.8798931241035461, -0.2530197501182556, -0.6911342740058899, 0.058614376932382584, 0.4599156379699707, 0.6971904039382935, 0.2338523119688034, 0.7777385115623474, 1.2075692415237427, 0.46281880140304565, 0.036483924835920334, 0.06696421653032303, 0.11443912982940674, 0.015224437229335308, 0.4917435348033905, 0.32587310671806335, 0.2620420753955841, 0.5746185779571533, -0.7301833033561707, 0.6450479626655579, -0.06896806508302689, 0.20753538608551025, -0.314413458108902, 0.24321924149990082, -0.01479488518089056, 0.7290905714035034, 0.6219092011451721, 0.9117386937141418, -0.7091000080108643, -0.15249863266944885, 0.7711498737335205, -0.35631802678108215, -0.15374034643173218, -0.330195814371109, -0.24146047234535217, 0.4257388710975647, -0.4543903172016144, 0.15250100195407867, 0.878355860710144, 0.4459000527858734, 0.05399557203054428, 0.38238224387168884, 0.7431942224502563, 0.3207657039165497, -0.7746779918670654, -0.27207452058792114, -1.492247223854065, -0.797886312007904, -0.8543426394462585, 0.19583691656589508, 0.01627959869801998, -0.6626336574554443, 0.2584320306777954, 0.5865916609764099, 0.020004775375127792, -0.43062624335289, 0.5140092968940735, 0.28718823194503784, 0.42511987686157227, 0.1740167737007141, -0.24225759506225586, -0.07371719926595688, -0.027918878942728043, 0.5082752704620361, 0.16090650856494904, -1.0748709440231323, -0.418062299489975, -0.3622470498085022, 0.5079004764556885, 0.35181015729904175, 0.3284720480442047, 0.3799639344215393, 0.03583316504955292, -0.02733958326280117, -0.03993810713291168, -0.7103732824325562, -0.4996626079082489, -0.49575841426849365, -0.2975778877735138, 0.6520574688911438, 0.06651628017425537, 0.7555950880050659, 0.7685765624046326, 0.18373756110668182, 0.28408533334732056, 0.48027798533439636, -0.0566314198076725, 0.06882017105817795, -0.9469640254974365, 0.17354314029216766, 0.7628145217895508, -0.07648413628339767, 0.4835505485534668, -0.9288899898529053, -1.2309519052505493, 0.2129283994436264, -0.07963797450065613, -0.4956066906452179, 0.15439537167549133, 0.1850041151046753, 0.4342191219329834, -2.069725751876831, -0.25332126021385193, -0.4436299502849579, -0.47233107686042786, -0.2960435748100281, 0.22613884508609772, -0.17838053405284882, 0.2327188104391098, 0.23977454006671906, -0.4357026219367981, 0.13525749742984772, -0.03150501474738121, -1.135833501815796, 0.018725283443927765, 0.0477835014462471, -0.022631093859672546, 0.153122678399086, 0.564468502998352, 0.6671373248100281, 0.13053646683692932, -0.1557578444480896, -0.3077598512172699, -0.024302219972014427, -0.2265363484621048, -0.10913782566785812, 0.6117119789123535, -0.49416714906692505, -0.7064800262451172, 0.7881069779396057, -0.2639325261116028, -0.22666491568088531, -0.34752336144447327, 0.5463083386421204, -0.24079695343971252, -0.6234005093574524, -0.8008986115455627, -0.17886781692504883, -0.5082176923751831, -1.0591590404510498, 0.5987821817398071, -0.08825507760047913, 0.8284215331077576, 0.17520782351493835, -0.03592987731099129, -0.7099097967147827, -0.06391346454620361, 0.23068709671497345, -0.3706616759300232, -0.30034133791923523, 1.4134372472763062, 0.11276241391897202, 1.047281265258789, -1.5406955480575562, 0.5054084062576294, 0.2455420345067978, 0.5890076160430908, 0.7141653299331665, -0.12745466828346252, 0.633536159992218, -0.6364845633506775, -0.04647274315357208, 0.17931868135929108, -0.5553172826766968, -0.1038823202252388, 0.11741043627262115, 0.5544124245643616, -0.20838606357574463, -0.9140282869338989, -0.13063380122184753, 0.09722413867712021, 0.3232495188713074, 0.3828273415565491, 0.08690150082111359, 0.5461551547050476, -0.27355021238327026, 0.2040213644504547, 0.5831722021102905, 0.3941335678100586, 0.0789043977856636, -0.22315043210983276, 0.05910046026110649, 0.13289324939250946, -0.7705517411231995, 0.452064573764801, -1.6453032493591309, -0.695083737373352, -0.32611626386642456, 0.277243971824646, 0.20998024940490723, -0.12150663882493973, -0.4315008223056793, -0.23463736474514008, -0.40271836519241333, 0.9776257872581482, 0.11785192042589188, -1.5455759763717651, -0.09026318788528442, -0.2892588973045349, 0.31592243909835815, -0.003955761436372995, -0.3936639130115509, 0.17987318336963654, 0.6064820289611816, 0.18576881289482117, -0.5568521022796631, -0.2926720380783081, 0.12735120952129364, 0.15870115160942078, 0.11954168975353241, -0.21396347880363464, -0.4473009407520294, -0.029013343155384064, -0.520952045917511, -0.28973791003227234, -0.16432355344295502, -0.37929168343544006, 0.10564836114645004, 0.03302556648850441, 0.004127608146518469, 1.0627905130386353, 0.43744510412216187, -0.24011927843093872, 0.6867873072624207, 0.3141392171382904, -1.0937855243682861, 0.6169489622116089, -0.5030601024627686, -1.0305227041244507, -0.1374543309211731, -0.2874852120876312, 0.1542537361383438, 0.13031482696533203, -0.25396040081977844, -0.31423914432525635, -0.7331711053848267, -0.3151779770851135, -0.09440840780735016, -1.010632038116455, 1.2442532777786255, -0.45852863788604736, -0.12803328037261963, 1.0838863849639893, -0.5487258434295654, -0.8617750406265259, -0.35400915145874023, 0.4900180697441101, -1.0001646280288696, 0.4384844899177551, 0.2155531346797943, -0.26841792464256287, 0.03232921287417412, -0.8642895817756653, 0.4695538282394409, -0.2441854178905487, -0.42727965116500854, -0.21195268630981445, -0.06891109049320221, -0.039605461061000824, -0.6611056923866272, -0.021783510223031044, 1.0014902353286743, -1.4413654804229736, 0.27156078815460205, 0.050273481756448746, -1.0189101696014404, -0.2418188750743866, 0.0021566892974078655, -0.21161845326423645, -0.1488761603832245, 0.07599503546953201, -0.5071834325790405, -0.09061552584171295, -0.23761636018753052, 0.6587522625923157, 0.02752387337386608, -0.7939774394035339, 0.10674694180488586, 0.8760826587677002, -0.6691346168518066, -0.25475484132766724, 0.41264045238494873, 0.29931849241256714, -0.6771671175956726, -0.3087013363838196, -0.48218345642089844, -0.5783730745315552, -0.02877490594983101, 0.09940946102142334, 0.8293651342391968, 1.1169841289520264, -0.13491538166999817, -0.8775444030761719, 0.12390609830617905, -0.5430455207824707, -1.1128965616226196, -0.7741014361381531, -0.20309315621852875, 0.07723236083984375, 0.4302433729171753, -0.3109476864337921, 0.10191402584314346, -0.6833633184432983, -1.0308047533035278, 0.08098888397216797, -0.7682604193687439, -0.2872595191001892, 0.11594793945550919, -0.6769922375679016, -0.40457776188850403, 0.16209396719932556, 0.3799894452095032, 0.6866937279701233, -0.43748757243156433, -0.6856688261032104, 0.8034008145332336, 0.22936111688613892, -0.03520511835813522, -0.24875299632549286, -0.9859455823898315, 0.1603768765926361, 1.285904049873352, 0.8013259768486023, 0.08520232141017914, 0.4117019772529602, -0.262699156999588, 0.21530142426490784, -0.02790655754506588, -0.2592059075832367, -0.569342315196991, -0.10679993778467178, 0.31846413016319275, -0.562397301197052, 0.051966242492198944, -1.1806272268295288, 1.1341195106506348, -0.5690978765487671, 0.08762609213590622, 0.35778361558914185, -0.29144036769866943, 0.406353235244751, -0.3520562946796417, 0.7603393793106079, -0.8708865642547607, 0.10239279270172119, 0.26471811532974243, 0.008544576354324818, 0.06105218827724457, -0.11102623492479324, -1.1007336378097534, -0.8581600189208984, -1.3541570901870728, -1.414262056350708, 0.4603870213031769, -0.36299940943717957, 0.16963523626327515, 0.07490474730730057, 0.08817945420742035, 0.1994677186012268, 0.05454813688993454, 0.501914918422699, 0.2545188069343567, -0.8485231399536133, -0.10547080636024475, 0.5898255109786987, -0.13217990100383759, -0.09132710844278336, 0.2191191017627716, 0.3793220818042755, -0.04704252630472183, 0.2868137061595917, 0.10589003562927246, -0.0708327665925026, -0.9326500296592712, -0.4810291528701782, 0.49371427297592163, 0.6943873763084412, -0.04124397784471512, 0.5035427808761597, 0.16506434977054596, -0.42052754759788513, -1.0307048559188843, 0.009117844514548779, 0.06651568412780762, 0.2455766797065735, 0.8870379328727722, -0.1312791407108307, -0.34799402952194214, 0.6266352534294128, -0.0715949609875679, -0.00580151192843914, -0.27936065196990967, -0.004739155527204275, 0.2943694591522217, -1.5315264463424683, 0.2269744575023651, 0.4910132884979248, -0.6782031655311584, -0.42783990502357483, -0.42571231722831726, -0.46449315547943115, -0.31084221601486206, -0.3048301041126251, -0.5747994184494019, 0.8521962761878967, 0.27765506505966187, 0.7763618230819702, -0.23530952632427216, -0.08728343993425369, 0.1931389719247818, -0.0841115340590477, 0.947804868221283, -0.417890727519989, 0.2799987196922302, 0.1721903383731842, -0.6594409346580505, 0.7580257058143616, 0.28778719902038574, 0.17467960715293884, -0.10064224153757095, 0.444924920797348, -0.15496709942817688, -0.3535902202129364, -0.2599084675312042, 0.6865730881690979, 0.7205356955528259, -0.3066592812538147, 0.1179678663611412, -0.4742424786090851, 1.225549340248108, 0.8195372819900513, -0.710246741771698, -0.5410212874412537, 0.620313823223114, 0.23428146541118622, 0.34016847610473633, -0.02382773347198963, -0.18483473360538483, -0.01718585565686226, -0.23957128822803497, 0.2387228161096573, -0.08911696076393127, -0.633212685585022, -0.15718337893486023, -0.2541511058807373, -0.22219601273536682, -0.38251546025276184, -0.09186279028654099, 0.7479938268661499, 0.1066373735666275, -0.7271923422813416, -0.08268995583057404, 1.270781397819519, -0.04107416048645973, 0.1066780537366867, -0.3146827220916748, 0.9222875237464905, -0.793767511844635, -1.0100247859954834, -0.8686620593070984, 0.13329997658729553, -0.03800060600042343, 1.0910075902938843, -1.4719226360321045, -0.13476091623306274, 0.39891329407691956, -0.1865909993648529, 0.3378523290157318, 0.6724929213523865, -0.5381096601486206, 0.25485649704933167, -0.15068988502025604, 0.43869489431381226, 0.5497157573699951, -0.35893237590789795, 0.5308883190155029, -0.5147127509117126, 0.04458759352564812, 0.8012661933898926, -0.16156882047653198, -0.9634434580802917, 0.5430791974067688, -0.13050131499767303, -0.31275543570518494, -0.3473956882953644, 0.11676733195781708, 0.3645501732826233, -0.7040021419525146, 0.42481541633605957, -0.6015531420707703, 0.12399856001138687, 0.2822697162628174, 0.38767898082733154, 0.0451052263379097, 0.4156171977519989, -0.14849981665611267, 0.03486347198486328, -0.046782396733760834, 0.7473096251487732, -0.1012660562992096, 0.4285745918750763, 0.7549711465835571, 0.2068592607975006, 0.5887798070907593, -1.2463386058807373, 0.6714719533920288, 0.35325300693511963, -0.026637159287929535, 0.6979230046272278, -0.027143122628331184, 0.03784008324146271, 0.35833173990249634, -0.4196866750717163, -0.11168253421783447, 0.996015727519989, 0.6496520042419434, 0.37681877613067627, 0.11580067127943039, -0.47145453095436096, -0.856752872467041, -0.41877222061157227, -0.3737301826477051, -0.5849636793136597, 0.6737387180328369, -0.34291502833366394, -0.4812113642692566, -0.31588712334632874, -0.3864726424217224, 0.9685434699058533, -0.43742528557777405, -0.20424287021160126, 0.31930476427078247, 0.7241733074188232, -0.11899103969335556, 0.8270778059959412, 0.30772989988327026, 0.12825217843055725, -0.07934174686670303, 0.17607899010181427, -0.6381328701972961, -0.5226244330406189, -0.627480149269104, -0.05345339700579643, 0.8812533617019653, 0.2073751538991928, 0.22708214819431305, -0.24167771637439728, -0.5601339936256409, 0.48685598373413086, 0.0550379753112793, 0.10273847728967667, -1.048409104347229, 0.3154173791408539, 0.09058351069688797, 0.40509504079818726, -0.7503725290298462, -0.09056129306554794, -0.1737317591905594, -0.7505679130554199, -0.5516158938407898, 0.39981764554977417, 0.8107506632804871, -0.15961198508739471, 0.1765642911195755, -0.6542855501174927, 0.09725220501422882, -0.5374571681022644, -0.9571151733398438, 0.6157865524291992, 0.6209336519241333, -0.5363006591796875, 0.43604016304016113, -0.38781172037124634, -0.0037283352576196194, 0.8070513606071472, 0.36543768644332886, 0.056461531668901443, 0.39138421416282654, -0.3036242425441742, 0.011050354689359665, 0.355785071849823, -0.26495134830474854, 0.3428451418876648, 0.5127295851707458, -0.21416787803173065, -0.06463354080915451, 0.616484522819519, 0.660025417804718, 0.752309262752533, -0.10461743921041489, 0.42408236861228943, -0.7444376945495605, -1.0753669738769531, -0.5274890661239624, -0.018052464351058006, 0.9534622430801392, 0.34853437542915344, 0.6489788889884949, 0.1292227804660797, 0.7320192456245422, -0.0742822214961052, -0.6444152593612671, 0.3455711007118225, -0.6844578385353088, -0.4578269422054291, -0.9453332424163818, 0.9325070381164551, -0.8356037735939026, -0.09930793941020966, 0.4753289520740509, -0.24491451680660248, 0.31780606508255005, 0.49400413036346436, 0.059120792895555496, 0.09736606478691101, 0.9558239579200745, 0.12811565399169922, -0.23742346465587616, -0.3268706798553467, -0.1620897352695465, -0.8091615438461304, -0.1905003786087036, 0.154495507478714, 0.19184906780719757, 1.0082118511199951, -0.3135010600090027, 0.2625761032104492, 0.1609094738960266, 0.6325482130050659, 0.4034345746040344, -0.5229105353355408, 0.13386131823062897, -0.019497862085700035, -0.22650812566280365, -0.2487383633852005, -0.3281756341457367, 0.018573274835944176, 0.3676662743091583, -0.44747382402420044, 0.2781839668750763, 0.15600146353244781, -0.5652150511741638, -0.15899313986301422, 0.7597143054008484, 0.43298783898353577, -0.17264509201049805, -1.2307487726211548, -0.27652105689048767, -0.02594950422644615, 0.49094125628471375, -0.12209253013134003, -0.23918838798999786, 0.5621556043624878, -0.4240523874759674, 0.1890517771244049, 0.2648293972015381, -0.6546892523765564, -0.12796610593795776, -0.9838090538978577, 0.7915439009666443, 0.4773729741573334, 0.0797690600156784, -0.4414665400981903, -0.8775830864906311, -0.13520927727222443, 0.37337759137153625, -0.194644033908844, -0.24325068295001984, 0.08902671933174133, 0.35268333554267883, 0.26156362891197205, -0.3931862711906433, -0.18873144686222076, 0.10347427427768707, 0.08960696309804916, 1.3355834484100342, 0.015812480822205544, 0.33031949400901794, 0.18249091506004333, -0.1546860635280609, -0.07708873599767685, 0.19425787031650543, -0.31663355231285095, 0.44705578684806824, -0.4553144574165344, -0.16062907874584198, 0.3208645284175873, -0.44784438610076904, -0.958113968372345, 0.7174146175384521, 0.07177644222974777, -0.07865255326032639, 0.5249204635620117, -0.4385211765766144, -0.4764694273471832, -0.4007376432418823, 1.0109807252883911, -0.2052009254693985, -0.20456163585186005, -0.07239498943090439, 0.05176832154393196, 0.7716163992881775, -0.7474150061607361, 4.026889801025391, 0.5222728848457336, 0.7011558413505554, 0.04075417295098305, 0.48892495036125183, -0.24661973118782043, 0.7789247035980225, 0.23427753150463104, 0.3556937277317047, -0.06513939797878265, -0.07840967923402786, 0.6166813373565674, -0.1770336627960205, 0.1574123203754425, 0.3269205093383789, -0.07575970888137817, -1.2180652618408203, 0.028922349214553833, 0.29091787338256836, -1.085625410079956, -0.6951026916503906, 0.07348783314228058, -0.3203149139881134, -0.11536937206983566, 0.307854562997818, -0.2772124111652374, 0.3440246880054474, 0.35467424988746643, -0.5091740489006042, 0.361645370721817, 0.3612394332885742, -1.268527865409851, 0.08843182772397995, -0.7202507853507996, -0.9890416860580444, 0.27680477499961853, 0.7570772171020508, -0.3338472545146942, -0.6389195322990417, -0.7471227049827576, -0.04033287242054939, 0.49909645318984985, 0.2644713819026947, -0.14921604096889496, 0.266740620136261, 0.45358163118362427, -0.5547855496406555, -0.7354495525360107, 0.02467675320804119, -0.6375153064727783, 0.446034699678421, -1.0509347915649414, -0.2953796982765198, -0.6063374280929565, -0.45833534002304077, -0.45839235186576843, -0.4870564639568329, -0.9698442816734314, -0.06447624415159225, 0.029958441853523254, 0.5632179975509644, -0.04588907212018967, 0.11438646912574768, 0.5546231269836426, -0.6397168636322021, 0.05144044756889343, -0.008708707056939602, -0.14557623863220215, 0.38098132610321045, -0.42622488737106323, 0.5231927633285522, -0.45761838555336, 0.03181120380759239, -0.09118934720754623, 0.7806681394577026, 0.2702464163303375, -0.7883357405662537, 1.4341635704040527, -0.7058215737342834, -0.5363397002220154, 0.9247674942016602, 0.3743741810321808, 0.2780783474445343, -0.5494799613952637, -0.14943134784698486, 0.5169333815574646, -0.5903208255767822, -0.3209499716758728, -0.5638513565063477, 0.36222755908966064, 0.9591518640518188, -0.041847143322229385, -0.224580317735672, -0.6499664187431335, 0.0864727720618248 ]
{"Title": "Prevalence of diabetic foot ulcer and its association with duration of illness and residence in Ethiopia: a systematic review and meta-analysis", "Authors": "Mulugeta Henok, Wagnew Fasil, Zeleke Haymanot, Tesfaye Bekele, Amha Haile, Leshargie Cheru Tesema, Biresaw Henok, Dessie Getenet, Belay Yihalem Abebe, Habtewold Tesfa Dejenie", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Diabetic foot ulcer (DFU), devastating complications of diabetes mellitus, is a major public health problem, and one of the leading reasons for hospital admission, amputations, and even death among diabetic patients in Ethiopia. Despite its catastrophic health consequences, the national burden of diabetic foot ulcer remains unknown in Ethiopia. Hence, the objective of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to estimate the national prevalence of diabetic foot ulcer and investigate the association with duration of illness and patient residence among diabetic patients. Methods We searched PubMed, Google Scholar, Cochrane Library, CINAHL, EMBASE, and PsycINFO databases for studies of diabetic foot ulcers prevalence that published from conception up to June 30, 2019. Quality of each article was assessed using a modified version of the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for cross-sectional studies. All statistical analyses were done using STATA version 14 software for Windows, and meta-analysis was carried out using a random-effects method. The pooled national prevalence of diabetic foot ulcers was presented using a forest plot. Results A total of 10 studies with 3,029 diabetic patients were included. The pooled national prevalence of diabetic foot ulcers among Ethiopian diabetic patients was 11.27% (95% CI 7.22, 15.31%, I 2 =94.6). Duration of illness (OR: 3.91, 95%CI 2.03, 7.52, I 2 =63.4%) and patients\u2019 residence (OR: 3.40, 95%CI 2.09, 5.54, I 2 =0.0%) were significantly associated with a diabetic foot ulcer. Conclusion In Ethiopia, at least one out of ten diabetic patients had diabetic foot ulcers. Healthcare policymakers (FMoH) need to improve the standard of diabetic care and should design effective preventive strategies to improve health care delivery for people with diabetes and reduce the risk of foot ulceration.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003061"}
10.1101/19012146
[ 0.5360181331634521, 0.06264950335025787, -0.3141316771507263, -1.3608269691467285, 0.44919532537460327, 0.092524453997612, -0.1014980599284172, -0.4146827757358551, 0.23020124435424805, 1.3704254627227783, 0.48074012994766235, -0.26615631580352783, 0.975016713142395, -0.37098971009254456, -0.26637786626815796, 0.11810672283172607, -0.49925756454467773, -0.2670556306838989, -0.3384356200695038, -0.34401246905326843, -0.28134000301361084, 0.6255590915679932, -1.131379246711731, -0.4024069309234619, -0.7404026389122009, 0.2391752451658249, 0.8706960082054138, 0.30385300517082214, 1.427574872970581, 0.46704742312431335, -0.5182263851165771, -0.34693968296051025, 0.6286391019821167, -0.4309632182121277, -0.23510800302028656, 0.2877255380153656, 0.5754095911979675, -1.2492423057556152, -0.815451443195343, 0.08917112648487091, 0.2520177364349365, 0.03993985429406166, -0.18560349941253662, -1.2241305112838745, -0.6022114753723145, -0.40847113728523254, 1.0115668773651123, -0.29683899879455566, -0.0173893254250288, -0.4283498525619507, 0.30462491512298584, 0.34088096022605896, 0.010344600304961205, -0.8822048306465149, -0.7499256730079651, -0.3511006236076355, 0.32368195056915283, -0.35467666387557983, -0.17070318758487701, -0.3039483428001404, 0.9711303114891052, -0.026435118168592453, 0.9910236597061157, -0.6667063236236572, 0.4493919610977173, 0.6267372369766235, -0.4087882339954376, 0.24972672760486603, -0.23381038010120392, -0.03557860851287842, -1.1492217779159546, 0.3671695590019226, 0.10042508691549301, -0.4230668842792511, -0.6425685882568359, 0.043000392615795135, 0.009258406236767769, 0.23628033697605133, -0.6580013632774353, 0.789020836353302, 0.8204878568649292, 0.8403481245040894, -0.5940384864807129, 0.1933654546737671, -0.6481569409370422, -0.020397629588842392, 1.6458922624588013, 0.2470560520887375, -0.3235741853713989, -0.15003032982349396, 0.216611847281456, 0.5460299849510193, 0.0254779364913702, 0.3597361147403717, 0.2739326059818268, 0.6239961981773376, -0.13611024618148804, 0.23486536741256714, 0.673037052154541, 0.7644857168197632, 0.4322505593299866, 1.0529621839523315, -0.970281720161438, 1.018830418586731, -0.5891550779342651, -0.0566730722784996, -0.030528796836733818, -1.0793671607971191, -0.17419321835041046, -0.5920764207839966, 0.5830109119415283, -0.4652769863605499, 0.27903521060943604, -0.15926441550254822, 0.409101665019989, 0.49897873401641846, 0.08347558975219727, 0.6239875555038452, 0.14000163972377777, 0.45633143186569214, -0.9420650005340576, 0.5169212222099304, 0.6201887726783752, -0.3627614378929138, 0.39457273483276367, 0.06037823110818863, 0.9712791442871094, 0.18688949942588806, 0.35301855206489563, -0.39608725905418396, 0.4248315691947937, -0.041128430515527725, -1.0805217027664185, 0.6872623562812805, -1.0138665437698364, -0.5601707100868225, 0.22653968632221222, 0.3310806453227997, 0.5043160915374756, 0.2886936366558075, -0.010210690088570118, 0.7380455136299133, -0.20273397862911224, 1.58074152469635, -0.8909627199172974, 0.1338615119457245, -0.1126086637377739, -1.0408737659454346, -1.3398061990737915, -0.24504946172237396, -0.2424185574054718, 0.5045868754386902, -0.25305408239364624, 0.05290443077683449, -0.7192040681838989, 0.2560618221759796, -0.5754590630531311, 0.31281551718711853, -0.5039399266242981, 0.4651036262512207, 0.23034770786762238, -0.5018113851547241, -0.017323000356554985, 0.8181970119476318, -0.3439914882183075, 0.5157060027122498, -0.660647451877594, -0.07955396920442581, -0.31544360518455505, -0.6797142028808594, -0.006914465222507715, 0.27628597617149353, 0.4746580719947815, 0.1640365719795227, 0.05489613115787506, 1.0359798669815063, 0.7555716037750244, -0.31498122215270996, 0.15324310958385468, 0.6028034090995789, -0.4347943365573883, -1.2396081686019897, 0.48511892557144165, -0.22596517205238342, -0.14119026064872742, 0.25838011503219604, -0.6243913769721985, -0.08768406510353088, 0.22826693952083588, -0.0339699387550354, 0.6406756639480591, 0.7411863803863525, -0.7539781332015991, 0.8666438460350037, -0.5873364210128784, 0.2390751838684082, -0.21673014760017395, -0.17637424170970917, 0.845171332359314, -1.1297167539596558, -0.3366418182849884, 0.39170360565185547, -0.12484215199947357, 0.33050042390823364, -0.3837038576602936, 0.36952346563339233, 1.1721628904342651, 1.0123995542526245, -1.3941818475723267, 0.5809903144836426, -0.08452317863702774, 0.6055185198783875, -0.4779776632785797, -0.27225205302238464, 1.1678919792175293, 0.2928953468799591, -0.18020351231098175, 0.025750722736120224, -0.6033452749252319, -0.7833285927772522, -0.17817562818527222, 0.08557082712650299, 0.4641607999801636, -0.4149836599826813, 0.31409844756126404, 0.6027376651763916, -0.2789980471134186, 0.557990312576294, 0.1793290674686432, 0.4796178638935089, -0.28016218543052673, 0.43951743841171265, 0.022206293419003487, 1.1318550109863281, 0.9533082246780396, 0.4155581593513489, 0.4284200668334961, 0.10981791466474533, 0.5427423715591431, 0.5645522475242615, -0.9094113707542419, -0.5238965153694153, 1.375272274017334, -0.09832481294870377, -0.19137147068977356, -0.1041751503944397, 0.07261323183774948, -0.24564985930919647, 0.15304423868656158, -0.12803921103477478, -0.13270914554595947, 1.2320575714111328, -0.005299777258187532, 0.2834569215774536, -0.7571547627449036, 0.11182768642902374, 0.2690194845199585, 1.0492712259292603, -0.33241546154022217, -0.6305977702140808, -0.31852853298187256, 0.5390183925628662, 0.2524528205394745, -0.018754862248897552, 1.072259545326233, 0.3654956817626953, 0.03920981287956238, -0.0261673666536808, -0.2562699317932129, -1.2503471374511719, -1.7868027687072754, -1.282640814781189, -1.725743055343628, -0.3066255748271942, -0.42740294337272644, -0.3638930022716522, -0.08916156738996506, -0.6000555753707886, 0.28626829385757446, -0.2828425467014313, -0.26278162002563477, -0.3111959397792816, -0.8731713891029358, -0.10888691991567612, 0.35639503598213196, 0.5104870200157166, -1.393123745918274, 1.0456786155700684, -0.2513616383075714, 0.2629799544811249, -0.15375854074954987, -0.47145161032676697, -0.269321084022522, -0.731929361820221, -0.14407148957252502, -0.5109113454818726, 0.46120530366897583, 0.011605331674218178, -0.7530398964881897, -0.49048981070518494, 0.7825676798820496, -0.3579515516757965, -0.3446958363056183, -0.6049961447715759, -0.3681968152523041, 0.40695977210998535, -0.2690352201461792, 0.010016126558184624, 0.4876213073730469, 0.8999410271644592, -0.5845592021942139, 1.2035678625106812, -0.05275518819689751, 0.5066025257110596, -0.3690694272518158, 0.4342134892940521, 0.09662102162837982, -0.9434112906455994, 0.060258835554122925, -0.3174561858177185, -0.9775803089141846, 0.17841242253780365, -0.9615901708602905, -0.6820595264434814, -0.40470775961875916, 0.775635838508606, -0.28191208839416504, -1.0967082977294922, -0.07115230709314346, -0.5885201096534729, -1.1636931896209717, 0.159127876162529, -0.2147943675518036, 0.5503237843513489, 0.11631955206394196, -0.23844893276691437, -0.24371035397052765, -0.05181131884455681, 0.30081841349601746, 0.6804513335227966, 0.8126462697982788, -0.6760498881340027, 0.4123833477497101, 0.45268911123275757, -0.19836664199829102, 0.14790016412734985, -0.4133280813694, -0.4073367714881897, -0.43040740489959717, -0.050767406821250916, 0.06502211093902588, 0.32603803277015686, 0.5208308100700378, 0.5586654543876648, -0.10224323719739914, 0.31932970881462097, -0.6855977177619934, 0.19163574278354645, 0.5852664709091187, 0.29306232929229736, 0.8495791554450989, 0.5170463919639587, -0.7417736053466797, 0.5740056037902832, -0.09176965057849884, -0.41254952549934387, -0.621824324131012, -0.3124673664569855, 0.5149924755096436, -0.6635270714759827, 1.0409733057022095, -0.4850563704967499, -0.26861682534217834, 0.1352119743824005, -0.09850174188613892, -1.0530788898468018, 1.1810410022735596, -0.02827593684196472, 1.8059829473495483, -0.8782374858856201, 0.1850084811449051, 0.7226313948631287, 0.0727589875459671, 0.34550023078918457, -0.6684443950653076, 0.5241069197654724, 0.8187838792800903, -0.1865481287240982, -0.32336369156837463, -0.449320912361145, -0.18170633912086487, 0.21128076314926147, -0.4458140432834625, 0.23694609105587006, -0.9412630796432495, -0.14729313552379608, 0.32151100039482117, -0.13831856846809387, 0.6212053894996643, -0.04011951759457588, -0.04473442584276199, -0.5363781452178955, 0.7043989896774292, 0.42793741822242737, 0.15112684667110443, 0.31789344549179077, -0.8584825992584229, 0.2897692322731018, -0.271060049533844, -1.0341023206710815, -0.7985563278198242, -0.28049907088279724, 0.2193242311477661, -0.00021960926824249327, -0.49591749906539917, 0.32379114627838135, -0.04075290262699127, -0.18658997118473053, -0.3064503073692322, 0.45456889271736145, 0.11081001907587051, -0.18798500299453735, -1.1711316108703613, 1.1085163354873657, 0.42404523491859436, -0.8569514155387878, -0.4364469647407532, -1.0748804807662964, 0.571352481842041, 0.18543477356433868, -0.35043060779571533, -0.03023001179099083, 0.4409164786338806, -0.550481915473938, 0.39337795972824097, 0.08530856668949127, 0.31701913475990295, 1.024919033050537, 0.7706095576286316, -0.6245492100715637, -0.2593494653701782, -0.26778820157051086, 0.7172546982765198, -0.29713883996009827, -0.06321486085653305, -0.14607390761375427, 0.5536218881607056, 1.5710911750793457, -0.20127417147159576, -0.6807361245155334, -0.05520927533507347, -0.5367749333381653, 0.3849371671676636, -0.38307949900627136, -0.47239217162132263, -0.09550157189369202, 0.6843271851539612, -0.7147216796875, 0.16182148456573486, -0.23629087209701538, -0.36069563031196594, -0.3125331699848175, 0.24717535078525543, -0.7469095587730408, -0.87324059009552, 0.12229068577289581, 0.5269739031791687, -0.29904279112815857, 0.09037204086780548, -0.22534708678722382, -0.2115928679704666, -0.3988318145275116, 0.16000580787658691, -1.259932041168213, 0.49576154351234436, -0.2961953282356262, 0.14353697001934052, -0.672248899936676, -0.7722640037536621, 0.58058762550354, 0.23593361675739288, 0.8244567513465881, -0.45166048407554626, -0.5830334424972534, -0.547645628452301, -0.524773120880127, -0.19273658096790314, 0.27270615100860596, -0.42236393690109253, 0.30601248145103455, -0.04757289960980415, -0.5575914978981018, -0.34758618474006653, -0.7351739406585693, 0.3833274841308594, 0.403735876083374, -0.9262758493423462, 0.03407856076955795, 0.1997910887002945, 0.19236300885677338, 0.518699586391449, -0.06709840148687363, -0.6919863224029541, -0.28390344977378845, 0.1072329580783844, 0.2081156075000763, -0.6845946907997131, -0.41659271717071533, -0.44513562321662903, -0.4832770824432373, -1.2495732307434082, 0.16595174372196198, -0.7713298201560974, -0.23297393321990967, 0.5013107657432556, 0.37539970874786377, 0.07933725416660309, 0.0676635205745697, -0.26944631338119507, 0.6512914299964905, -0.6608725786209106, -1.0104304552078247, -1.0634738206863403, 0.6734038591384888, 0.1427437961101532, 0.10114782303571701, 0.18393801152706146, -0.731248676776886, 0.14556601643562317, -1.2529579401016235, 0.4385518431663513, -1.1843734979629517, -0.2838425636291504, 0.13868707418441772, 0.13484758138656616, 0.06604751199483871, -0.3380454480648041, 0.44036149978637695, -0.38680747151374817, -0.4742775857448578, -0.6404662132263184, 0.08808249235153198, -0.17872795462608337, -1.1994402408599854, 0.024651557207107544, -0.21656692028045654, -0.4089311957359314, 0.3793152868747711, -0.010036109015345573, -0.6038926243782043, 0.09797453880310059, 0.44307562708854675, 0.31503912806510925, 0.7350187301635742, -1.092981219291687, -0.7894272208213806, -0.06930335611104965, -0.24452435970306396, 0.49599266052246094, -0.0257412176579237, -0.15873856842517853, 0.27623873949050903, -0.11301138252019882, 0.36516380310058594, 0.06803948432207108, 0.24698282778263092, -0.31541261076927185, -0.6517422199249268, 0.577629804611206, -0.6678058505058289, 0.22889797389507294, -0.392794668674469, 0.4571693241596222, -0.004301952663809061, -0.036789216101169586, -0.9190222024917603, -0.9727228879928589, -0.0936691015958786, -0.7245820164680481, -0.351035475730896, -0.26609575748443604, -0.2634716033935547, -0.11480782181024551, 0.22713397443294525, -0.024779312312602997, -0.42577841877937317, 0.7662632465362549, 0.660645067691803, 0.16991113126277924, 0.07038963586091995, 0.09191476553678513, 0.07914658635854721, 0.3327869772911072, 0.276864618062973, -0.44071799516677856, -0.46654850244522095, -0.1074247807264328, -0.2669391334056854, -0.4081655740737915, -0.34938639402389526, 0.06762377172708511, -0.4185197353363037, 0.9886146187782288, -0.374034583568573, 0.42565450072288513, 0.8739571571350098, -0.17483004927635193, -0.5259323120117188, -0.31189435720443726, 0.5673137307167053, -0.40331482887268066, 0.8785872459411621, 0.030859487131237984, 0.21761545538902283, 0.1549566686153412, -0.28679800033569336, -0.2568797767162323, 0.03273168206214905, 1.2036397457122803, -0.30002498626708984, -0.7510281205177307, 0.37450602650642395, 0.6402097344398499, -0.11329540610313416, -0.6354255676269531, 0.42288386821746826, -0.5182960033416748, 0.11265531182289124, -0.4089072048664093, 0.22824835777282715, -0.8418959379196167, -0.09603022783994675, 0.2840867042541504, -0.25352540612220764, 0.25738784670829773, -0.2565816640853882, 0.6102537512779236, 0.6663849353790283, -1.0838037729263306, 0.4274425208568573, 0.30543220043182373, -0.26221299171447754, -0.06576324254274368, -0.48064491152763367, -0.15489935874938965, -0.266771137714386, -0.09749417006969452, 0.5692909955978394, 0.16782349348068237, 0.260206401348114, 0.38859376311302185, 0.5341165065765381, 0.4510684311389923, 0.869769811630249, -0.3930876553058624, 0.24116496741771698, 0.012450778856873512, -1.0058202743530273, -0.5245477557182312, 1.056403636932373, 0.31652694940567017, 0.34361422061920166, -0.01218422595411539, 0.5441898703575134, 0.37444788217544556, 0.5765342116355896, 0.3410879969596863, -0.43058598041534424, -0.0798892229795456, -0.9358177185058594, 0.31858140230178833, -0.00912618450820446, -0.16722765564918518, -0.5353354215621948, -0.29990559816360474, -0.5195420384407043, -0.14408408105373383, 0.7205226421356201, 0.8594716787338257, -1.1840931177139282, 0.05540632829070091, -0.22519245743751526, 0.28123894333839417, -0.15968525409698486, -1.050399899482727, 0.38905540108680725, -0.0005477405502460897, 0.8290628790855408, 0.8533797264099121, -0.4773569107055664, 0.09306931495666504, 0.7741261124610901, 0.15829332172870636, 0.342785507440567, 0.3473823070526123, -0.5466576218605042, -0.8938465714454651, -0.3981088101863861, 0.6307741403579712, -0.16485503315925598, 0.04089296981692314, 0.3981485366821289, -1.1816089153289795, -0.18629848957061768, 0.5010167360305786, 0.23379556834697723, -0.4016799330711365, 0.34815776348114014, 0.5153138637542725, -0.41657736897468567, 0.31361123919487, -0.0023730553220957518, 0.2933516502380371, -0.6754234433174133, -0.23126766085624695, 0.6867730617523193, -0.34491315484046936, -0.10086295753717422, 0.08645103126764297, 0.3788064420223236, 1.1023682355880737, -0.2633311152458191, 0.4639516770839691, -0.4310523271560669, 0.31094619631767273, -0.2748790979385376, 0.08956292271614075, 0.7531094551086426, -0.08476734161376953, -0.733431875705719, -0.9419547915458679, 0.26507434248924255, 0.6388104557991028, -0.6143791675567627, 0.11293096840381622, -0.2067883312702179, -0.41604605317115784, -0.0037095542065799236, 0.4672253429889679, 0.049469832330942154, 0.10551119595766068, -0.08191341906785965, 0.3220466375350952, 0.1960749626159668, 0.33195966482162476, -0.6604016423225403, 0.4505116939544678, -0.8826484084129333, -0.9960876107215881, 0.5770893096923828, -0.34972643852233887, 1.067667007446289, -0.8037139773368835, -1.2705367803573608, 0.7006400227546692, 0.05328691378235817, 0.6543176174163818, 0.24048882722854614, 0.8187286257743835, -0.20967614650726318, 0.9255785346031189, -0.7263447046279907, -0.17702697217464447, -0.09683667868375778, 0.7675067782402039, -0.811423659324646, -0.7482950687408447, 0.506158709526062, -0.22930283844470978, -0.16581818461418152, 0.007974480278789997, -0.836266040802002, 0.1483154445886612, -0.04260784015059471, -0.5158669352531433, -0.29668283462524414, 0.08890846371650696, -1.3901549577713013, 0.862608015537262, 0.35846278071403503, 0.920389711856842, -0.05230478569865227, 1.2177029848098755, 0.7043907642364502, -0.6547467112541199, -0.38239046931266785, -0.535243034362793, 1.0136418342590332, -0.8292995095252991, 0.18784192204475403, -0.012670585885643959, 0.7134537100791931, 0.3435330390930176, -0.6228554248809814, 0.32593587040901184, 0.35229185223579407, -0.0035413848236203194, 0.24251289665699005, -0.3750264644622803, 0.7954886555671692, 1.2080408334732056, -0.5384034514427185, 0.7380977272987366, 0.5288072824478149, -0.2794506251811981, 0.27399370074272156, 0.013063810765743256, -0.4521752595901489, 0.042557939887046814, 0.17170973122119904, -0.2262261062860489, -0.38065165281295776, -0.1614825427532196, -0.5166128277778625, -0.023872410878539085, -0.7966935038566589, 0.5616529583930969, -0.12978719174861908, -1.0920039415359497, -0.37510713934898376, -0.1895492672920227, 0.27030858397483826, 0.054115038365125656, 0.14833059906959534, -0.7385139465332031, -0.2322710156440735, 0.824623703956604, 0.018283862620592117, 0.7026890516281128, 0.17410369217395782, -0.1952260434627533, 0.30007806420326233, -0.16702312231063843, -0.28369492292404175, 0.0774548351764679, 0.1826213002204895, -0.21056348085403442, -0.6662249565124512, 0.22244049608707428, 0.43305084109306335, -0.6000120043754578, 1.4230104684829712, -0.3429579436779022, -0.27945441007614136, -0.3336561918258667, -0.010560253635048866, -0.566658616065979, 0.3409862220287323, 0.16577021777629852, 0.10304493457078934, -0.8337991833686829, 0.5874954462051392, 0.044689811766147614, -0.1721470057964325, 1.0555578470230103, 0.6556370854377747, 0.7963137030601501, 1.0478416681289673, 0.5624114871025085, 0.17454038560390472, 0.5912410020828247, 0.25568097829818726, -0.18634893000125885, 0.4011648893356323, -0.2882932722568512, -0.36397796869277954, -0.3231154978275299, -0.5890082716941833, -0.7840401530265808, 0.08824498951435089, 0.20391464233398438, -0.2935980260372162, 0.28781938552856445, 0.6924282312393188, -0.3073829710483551, -0.29616057872772217, -0.0555695965886116, 0.23388949036598206, 0.0077498978935182095, 0.1141577959060669, -0.5452708005905151, 0.19375431537628174, -0.6495646238327026, -0.1381838321685791, -0.7925395965576172, 0.5399968028068542, -0.36578214168548584, -0.21985790133476257, -0.5474120378494263, -0.5556977391242981, -0.8524691462516785, 0.4928680956363678, 0.19320079684257507, -0.11591088026762009, 0.48387137055397034, 0.7790123224258423, -0.2364659309387207, 0.4297206699848175, -0.5589414834976196, 0.06941426545381546, 1.1109814643859863, 0.8602887392044067, 0.4181876480579376, 1.511103630065918, 1.310904622077942, 0.015862073749303818, -0.05074717476963997, -0.1455012559890747, -0.20200181007385254, 0.5932663083076477, -0.676232635974884, 0.014090385288000107, 0.0916009470820427, 0.1258113831281662, -0.9016515612602234, 0.724445104598999, 1.1415010690689087, -0.3936207592487335, -0.4102769196033478, -0.5623160600662231, 0.1315922737121582, -0.7748806476593018, 1.1457533836364746, 0.06936454772949219, 1.461470365524292, -0.5085800290107727, -0.2150115668773651, -0.6152451038360596, -0.7749140858650208, 3.690516948699951, 0.6749138832092285, 0.0340857170522213, 1.1402117013931274, 0.4823293089866638, 0.1408279836177826, 0.6478803157806396, 0.11476055532693863, 0.13094688951969147, -0.04352271184325218, 0.07105149328708649, -0.5065428018569946, -0.09043978154659271, -0.03490429371595383, -0.13239994645118713, 0.6294787526130676, 0.257628858089447, 0.16568942368030548, -0.16021113097667694, -0.07900769263505936, -0.47967663407325745, 0.6952400803565979, 0.14185835421085358, 0.5447223782539368, 0.28316545486450195, -0.34287023544311523, 0.2643927037715912, -0.17381197214126587, -0.31917327642440796, -0.15188539028167725, 0.3736487627029419, -0.4463776648044586, 0.791434645652771, -0.20873567461967468, 0.12720228731632233, -0.1728893667459488, 0.04382319003343582, -0.8723068833351135, -0.4371620714664459, 0.15408793091773987, -0.8412843346595764, -0.3720943033695221, 0.5254921317100525, -0.7560333013534546, -0.10816343128681183, 0.803224503993988, -0.005508457310497761, 0.1024659052491188, 0.9724075794219971, -0.6401920914649963, 0.7260090708732605, -0.7481029629707336, 0.39974716305732727, -0.742057740688324, -0.649760365486145, -0.633773922920227, -0.4850280284881592, -0.049137286841869354, -0.07815295457839966, -0.20416826009750366, 0.3668777346611023, 0.07971872389316559, 0.30401611328125, -0.464863657951355, -0.3713262975215912, 0.2896074056625366, 1.036952018737793, -0.3933420181274414, -0.30379146337509155, 0.2551642656326294, 1.1525161266326904, -0.2828332483768463, -0.6239533424377441, 0.2826864719390869, 0.9575281739234924, 0.7866037487983704, -0.4137932360172272, 1.419268012046814, -0.1871296763420105, -0.7557125091552734, -0.5073230266571045, -0.038831837475299835, 0.4178231954574585, 0.34901875257492065, 0.4474608302116394, 0.17827863991260529, -0.7532194256782532, -0.3199211359024048, -1.330564260482788, 1.1773918867111206, 0.50981605052948, 0.8498730063438416, 0.7229727506637573, 0.7195199131965637, 0.08760766685009003 ]
{"Title": "Using Mobile Phones For Computer Aided Detection Of Anomalies On Chest Radiographs: Proof Of Concept", "Authors": "Mitini-Nkhoma Steven", "Abstract": "Abstract Mastering the art of interpreting chest radiographs can be a long and daunting process. We trained a neural network to classify photographs of chest radiographs into 6 groups. The trained model is hosted on a webserver. The model receives and processes photographs of chest radiographs taken using mobile phones. The system then informs the user the most probable diagnosis. Such systems could prove useful in low resource settings which do not have enough highly trained medical personnel and cannot afford the new generation of CAD based radiology equipment.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012146"}
10.1101/19000281
[ 0.21264271438121796, -0.44587016105651855, -0.04684029519557953, 0.7165150046348572, -0.1412886083126068, -0.15595625340938568, -0.29687535762786865, -0.2498237043619156, 0.38964834809303284, 0.9141871333122253, -0.028424642980098724, -0.1330365240573883, 0.8425197005271912, -0.17733150720596313, -0.12814392149448395, -0.7472642660140991, -0.2923363149166107, -0.0840090811252594, -0.2108764350414276, -0.10923293977975845, -0.015575685538351536, 0.8668444156646729, -0.5879533886909485, 0.5817586183547974, -0.45115572214126587, 0.570849597454071, -0.35735073685646057, 0.34145042300224304, 0.9639767408370972, 0.47739267349243164, 0.027568716555833817, -0.8249832987785339, 0.804501473903656, -0.7725121378898621, -0.2688729763031006, -0.017542382702231407, 0.3250507414340973, 0.24659192562103271, -0.4420526623725891, -0.16580139100551605, 0.662198543548584, 0.27861687541007996, 0.5032675266265869, -0.9011437296867371, -0.6307790875434875, -0.8907379508018494, 0.010199678130447865, 1.1958796977996826, 0.1282055675983429, -0.03808676823973656, -0.41138315200805664, 0.2915413975715637, -0.0328892283141613, -0.23834466934204102, -0.38886934518814087, -0.37992438673973083, -0.4989868700504303, -0.37693166732788086, -0.4766175448894501, 0.05886735022068024, 0.326483815908432, -0.7732498049736023, 0.26945823431015015, -0.8857797980308533, 0.5006042718887329, 0.6311073899269104, -0.07359665632247925, -0.35045015811920166, 0.5699042081832886, -0.02802686020731926, -0.5832505822181702, 0.16864757239818573, -0.543673574924469, -0.5650961995124817, -0.5132672786712646, 0.10422496497631073, 0.11226455867290497, -0.37188223004341125, -0.6048912405967712, 0.3444141447544098, 0.2172253131866455, 0.27194124460220337, 0.48069682717323303, 0.0261788722127676, -0.22721616923809052, -0.32792577147483826, 0.23883314430713654, 0.30968326330184937, -0.04786655679345131, 0.45308762788772583, 0.05477843061089516, 0.19556096196174622, 0.3904362618923187, 0.041541922837495804, 0.4781680107116699, 0.6013234853744507, -0.6175485849380493, 0.2705014646053314, 0.3422446846961975, -0.5557120442390442, 0.5983642935752869, 1.395795226097107, -0.45723894238471985, 0.7933727502822876, -0.48098087310791016, 0.9940934181213379, 0.4572736620903015, -0.5536268353462219, -0.888982355594635, -0.8289400339126587, -0.3194837272167206, 0.04270758479833603, -0.6419453024864197, -0.24719642102718353, 0.3886829614639282, 0.7248139381408691, 0.08904248476028442, 0.9740560054779053, -0.1717119663953781, 0.15714575350284576, 0.3771536946296692, -0.4334304630756378, 0.8581468462944031, -0.9148684740066528, 0.5311285853385925, -0.44058099389076233, 0.025959063321352005, 0.37634700536727905, -0.3370169401168823, -0.33759021759033203, 0.16778923571109772, -0.693160355091095, -0.8116026520729065, 0.41742464900016785, -0.5792443156242371, 0.18023920059204102, 0.12272365391254425, 0.409186452627182, 0.2820821702480316, -0.13445626199245453, 0.19920268654823303, 0.14165878295898438, -0.7750654220581055, 1.3388323783874512, -0.2460198849439621, 0.9907017350196838, -0.5796536803245544, -1.4792596101760864, -0.12565532326698303, 0.22119897603988647, 0.14732587337493896, 0.8354255557060242, -0.3774094879627228, 0.372340589761734, -0.24385178089141846, 0.5104295015335083, -0.13026860356330872, 0.24890434741973877, -0.1121315062046051, -0.20875413715839386, -0.03609710559248924, -0.05919511988759041, -0.09169208258390427, -0.015549927018582821, -0.27082961797714233, 0.791471004486084, 0.3619123101234436, 0.2482420802116394, -0.18696783483028412, -0.6904177069664001, 0.644710898399353, -0.04905018210411072, -0.37612196803092957, 0.7925924062728882, -0.015218248590826988, 0.9634369611740112, 1.1885528564453125, -0.5041851997375488, 0.5300161242485046, 0.5258545279502869, 0.594440221786499, -0.06738917529582977, -0.18034867942333221, 0.24969352781772614, 0.035047318786382675, 1.1745071411132812, 0.2872227728366852, -0.5084560513496399, -0.7903133034706116, -0.28551411628723145, 0.2846643626689911, 0.5730761885643005, -0.7701257467269897, 0.7593811750411987, -0.33603814244270325, -0.001142166438512504, -0.9514591097831726, 0.2873479723930359, 0.4296010732650757, -0.39875027537345886, -0.49356216192245483, 0.5538942217826843, -0.3809516131877899, 0.3925437927246094, -0.9308986067771912, 1.4570326805114746, 0.83069908618927, 0.4428301155567169, -0.2751214802265167, -0.07434487342834473, 0.4815959930419922, -0.02638327144086361, -0.15416179597377777, 0.10990048944950104, 0.7210291028022766, -0.05556562915444374, 0.07028945535421371, -0.09087688475847244, -0.6157814264297485, -0.3562963902950287, -0.5408012866973877, -0.06172020733356476, 0.863686203956604, -0.22008270025253296, 0.34387972950935364, 0.7298620939254761, 0.728572428226471, 0.23591208457946777, -0.14264723658561707, -0.21164007484912872, 0.1263699233531952, 0.6366605162620544, -0.8690298795700073, 1.0238196849822998, 1.0174731016159058, -0.10330882668495178, -0.11928684264421463, 0.5422062873840332, 0.5635786056518555, 0.22919833660125732, 0.2490639090538025, -0.4790884256362915, -0.08712862432003021, 0.5384953022003174, -0.36131551861763, 0.09930200129747391, -0.624058187007904, -0.1006016731262207, -0.4859757423400879, -0.027056138962507248, 0.0871536135673523, 0.4117714464664459, 0.9429644346237183, 0.7522299885749817, -0.8939656019210815, -0.2655003070831299, 1.1186825037002563, 0.25261247158050537, -0.3258349299430847, -0.20966453850269318, -0.15656329691410065, 0.6040645241737366, 0.26185867190361023, 0.11304527521133423, 1.5133215188980103, 0.7785266041755676, -0.0008487347513437271, -0.2892085909843445, -0.19006508588790894, -0.3683791756629944, -1.28653883934021, -0.6321530342102051, -1.0186532735824585, -0.09963831305503845, -1.0829358100891113, -0.2870723307132721, 0.6234622001647949, -0.8106922507286072, 0.55739825963974, 0.21359115839004517, 0.12901811301708221, -0.22130027413368225, -0.0511271171271801, 0.6509535312652588, 0.1003890335559845, -0.06882502138614655, -1.374330759048462, 0.2958099842071533, 0.03427647054195404, 0.009575257077813148, -0.500235915184021, -0.42204758524894714, -0.5674414038658142, -0.5225775241851807, 0.05940869823098183, -0.394925594329834, 0.2707764804363251, 0.09995651245117188, -0.1455552726984024, 0.016227280721068382, 0.3965435326099396, 0.5050197243690491, 0.6002870202064514, -0.3320639133453369, -1.0362091064453125, 0.6225165724754333, 0.043439630419015884, 0.44844120740890503, 0.3819100856781006, 0.28051960468292236, -0.5719922184944153, 1.276473045349121, 0.11870496720075607, -0.13013027608394623, -0.3081277310848236, 0.06486879289150238, 0.45696863532066345, -0.04633970931172371, -0.2673434317111969, -0.9668839573860168, -1.075732946395874, -0.13238945603370667, -0.3711320459842682, -0.2135581225156784, 0.46572935581207275, 0.8276285529136658, 0.16694669425487518, -1.206795573234558, 0.08749349415302277, -0.5151488780975342, -0.5628772377967834, 0.03269382566213608, 0.2775368392467499, 0.26164039969444275, 0.056991979479789734, 0.10538877546787262, -0.5115470886230469, -0.33512765169143677, -0.10802441090345383, -0.1797425001859665, 0.4841949939727783, -0.5135562419891357, -0.1747918576002121, 0.4813516438007355, 0.25516724586486816, 0.9524215459823608, -0.19240117073059082, -0.37056243419647217, -0.27199119329452515, -0.039775412529706955, -0.2369704246520996, -0.049860935658216476, 0.5258826017379761, 0.36706089973449707, -0.7437276840209961, 0.4225952625274658, -0.11042013019323349, -0.9983220100402832, 0.1224253699183464, 0.1984347254037857, -0.03684067726135254, 0.5412734746932983, -0.2630150020122528, -0.16885940730571747, -0.39051318168640137, -1.0646559000015259, -0.21535421907901764, 0.15481528639793396, 0.7933903336524963, -0.38607725501060486, 0.4123815894126892, 0.30110225081443787, 0.02865232527256012, -0.0627230852842331, -0.311387300491333, -0.7238283157348633, 0.608391284942627, 0.5897268652915955, 0.9047846794128418, -0.9361765384674072, 0.45365455746650696, 1.0625543594360352, 0.6786123514175415, 0.9297791719436646, 0.337227463722229, 1.069936990737915, -0.9427200555801392, -0.21679455041885376, 0.40869197249412537, -0.2880653142929077, 0.07023557275533676, -0.2686161696910858, 0.2665528953075409, 0.8589080572128296, -0.3820223808288574, 0.2849629819393158, -0.026298943907022476, 0.34852850437164307, 0.015195867046713829, 0.19550345838069916, 0.36846625804901123, -0.1480625718832016, 0.4265446364879608, 0.3949959874153137, 0.7097209692001343, -0.10049920529127121, -0.549286425113678, -0.35973498225212097, -0.5178015232086182, 0.1958140879869461, 0.04277212172746658, 0.24207834899425507, -0.40761953592300415, -0.04722496494650841, -0.020957300439476967, -0.00389979500323534, -0.29640665650367737, -0.00762866111472249, -0.4229237139225006, -0.08834005147218704, 0.5831825137138367, -0.09977508336305618, -0.7107582688331604, -0.26007315516471863, 0.04205905273556709, -0.5868610739707947, -0.10795431584119797, -0.11050912737846375, 0.4964474141597748, 0.7192978858947754, -0.7163770198822021, -0.3435627520084381, -0.6034204363822937, -0.1130417212843895, -0.5010665059089661, 0.11445033550262451, 0.04410524666309357, -0.28842872381210327, 0.3603009283542633, -0.4385022521018982, -0.16846558451652527, -0.17327871918678284, -0.28150808811187744, -0.3828311562538147, -0.23495495319366455, 0.02030990645289421, 1.1539682149887085, -0.05204298719763756, -0.3658145070075989, 0.14095564186573029, 0.2261306494474411, -0.657292366027832, 0.25126394629478455, -0.8412639498710632, -0.11667095124721527, 0.06367740035057068, -0.6029568314552307, 0.5393014550209045, 0.8562328219413757, 0.3076838552951813, -0.4950854778289795, -0.200007826089859, 0.0669185072183609, -0.1268450766801834, -0.655219554901123, 0.17970646917819977, 0.5440016984939575, 0.4474465847015381, 0.7152079939842224, -0.396106481552124, -0.1504390686750412, -0.13009923696517944, 0.1360214501619339, -1.1028560400009155, 0.3487298786640167, 1.4498143196105957, -0.2830672264099121, 0.4529885947704315, 0.03869175910949707, 0.3640684485435486, -0.40071019530296326, 0.2839697003364563, -0.19912424683570862, 0.17907434701919556, 0.1437360644340515, -0.4735637307167053, -0.4888802766799927, 0.2403678148984909, -0.653809130191803, -0.010365280322730541, -0.42535626888275146, -0.5172764658927917, -0.045373834669589996, -0.27013278007507324, -0.7843904495239258, -0.21958497166633606, -0.6400867104530334, -0.27969449758529663, -0.31292590498924255, 0.6353392004966736, 0.3660603165626526, -0.5769569277763367, -0.8864346742630005, 0.2929702699184418, 0.310085266828537, -0.0423232838511467, -0.4438069760799408, 0.13131503760814667, -0.9610843658447266, -0.4920875132083893, -0.7081560492515564, 0.47671809792518616, -1.145402431488037, -0.8030248284339905, -0.3007087707519531, 0.1396344006061554, -0.07140815258026123, 0.3197293281555176, -1.0736738443374634, 0.17869804799556732, -0.35510244965553284, -0.4261855185031891, -0.9025532007217407, 0.5982407331466675, 0.1573636531829834, 0.5369430780410767, -0.10001684725284576, -0.7267401218414307, -0.11885512620210648, -0.889789342880249, 0.5481224656105042, -1.011624813079834, 0.31206461787223816, -0.017289359122514725, -0.30879124999046326, 0.08942999690771103, 0.1983221024274826, 0.34834012389183044, -0.13355261087417603, -0.7383043169975281, -0.4938856363296509, -0.038908783346414566, -0.4410036504268646, -0.6706469655036926, -0.24796944856643677, -1.2066614627838135, 0.21452663838863373, 0.3959670960903168, 0.05183776840567589, -0.8458594679832458, -0.08080676943063736, 0.7247965931892395, 0.8275874257087708, 0.4719960391521454, -0.41480931639671326, -0.5085555911064148, 0.26333457231521606, 0.642874538898468, -0.42567628622055054, 0.2681652009487152, -1.1042637825012207, -0.34867072105407715, -0.6124259233474731, -0.6880043148994446, -0.14749079942703247, -0.4903210401535034, 0.6704825758934021, -0.5522095561027527, 0.9620456099510193, 0.045938801020383835, 0.4379221796989441, -0.08793061226606369, -0.1334695816040039, -0.26835858821868896, -0.19355237483978271, -0.5510231852531433, -0.8876948356628418, -0.051713552325963974, -0.40576884150505066, 0.3437536060810089, -0.3769528269767761, -0.6110023260116577, 0.5560185313224792, -0.1475520133972168, -0.5928928852081299, -0.26528096199035645, 1.1844650506973267, 0.4882860481739044, -0.9399983882904053, -0.7518941760063171, 0.25839635729789734, 0.24214212596416473, 0.24564595520496368, 0.19610166549682617, -0.708940863609314, -0.6662304401397705, 0.49550673365592957, -0.1612309217453003, -0.07711436599493027, -1.0994457006454468, -0.10723909735679626, 0.6187849044799805, 0.2577486038208008, -0.12412938475608826, 0.5132583975791931, 0.4389989972114563, -0.35057497024536133, -0.3665624260902405, 0.6376136541366577, -0.4659513533115387, -0.194823756814003, 1.6829594373703003, 0.04469013586640358, 0.19289349019527435, 0.4957853853702545, -0.7120330929756165, -0.5466596484184265, 0.185885488986969, 0.5794655680656433, 0.32508543133735657, -1.511026382446289, 0.2859492897987366, 0.14771538972854614, 0.09156833589076996, -0.7365809082984924, 0.396322637796402, -0.8998321890830994, 0.26193317770957947, 0.014859163202345371, -0.7667322158813477, 0.39506006240844727, -0.38526320457458496, 0.7211334109306335, -0.2614310383796692, -0.14319486916065216, -0.2076720893383026, -0.6795618534088135, -0.030816441401839256, -0.8633255362510681, 0.8171111941337585, 0.7242994904518127, -0.09544439613819122, 0.6778925061225891, -0.3039601445198059, -0.03329572081565857, 0.08130557835102081, 0.2409748136997223, 0.6393700242042542, 0.411678284406662, 0.44856441020965576, -0.034371353685855865, 0.7733811140060425, 0.352836549282074, 0.017086533829569817, -0.049497105181217194, 0.6267671585083008, 0.6920648217201233, -1.051876187324524, -0.6273648738861084, 0.6739890575408936, 0.8644727468490601, 0.3521127998828888, -0.027092214673757553, 0.5289329290390015, 0.8833078145980835, 0.0793616771697998, 0.6411855220794678, -0.2998415231704712, 0.024067452177405357, -0.944269061088562, 0.07045421004295349, -0.033029526472091675, -0.5527660846710205, 0.24309740960597992, 0.38647446036338806, -0.2440672665834427, -0.3421231508255005, -0.04788826406002045, 0.29492753744125366, -0.09549511969089508, 0.051851578056812286, -0.4019268751144409, 0.6479442119598389, -0.7256797552108765, -0.5887078642845154, 0.33296042680740356, -0.11202286183834076, 0.4072568416595459, 1.3797645568847656, -0.8024011254310608, -0.5478324890136719, 0.5500887632369995, -0.23792903125286102, 0.02318631298840046, 0.38314196467399597, -0.8394169211387634, -0.10486908257007599, -0.1777067482471466, 0.6610537171363831, 0.5803005695343018, 0.39080995321273804, 0.7579674124717712, -0.4373331367969513, -0.15795406699180603, 0.720891535282135, -0.5200679898262024, -0.9636077880859375, -0.3959595859050751, 0.4104810357093811, -0.809207558631897, 0.2003375142812729, -0.4754359722137451, 0.5734567046165466, -1.0782382488250732, 0.004877025261521339, -0.12203352153301239, -0.19577209651470184, 0.3807274401187897, 0.7719359397888184, -0.03812970593571663, 0.8160632252693176, -0.34420377016067505, 0.12307138741016388, -0.6631746888160706, 0.7182214260101318, 0.9193009734153748, 0.042651765048503876, 1.0211691856384277, -0.19214436411857605, 0.18334944546222687, -0.6698147654533386, 0.9707627892494202, 0.5818857550621033, -0.8342430591583252, 0.12712422013282776, -0.45977309346199036, 0.4860599935054779, 0.38204705715179443, -0.31547224521636963, -0.2778587341308594, 0.4789845943450928, 0.42302459478378296, 0.5656226277351379, 0.597829282283783, -0.1604510247707367, -0.0328638069331646, -0.9638105630874634, -1.7134965658187866, -0.4771265983581543, 0.8825288414955139, -0.8775981068611145, 0.17091529071331024, -1.0089424848556519, -0.6547186374664307, 0.47306057810783386, 0.7062175869941711, 0.6771900653839111, -0.42331621050834656, -0.13385286927223206, -0.37920069694519043, 0.784091055393219, -0.42289748787879944, -0.14119426906108856, -0.1956665813922882, -0.022149860858917236, -0.5447678565979004, -0.9179576635360718, 0.304322749376297, -0.052285488694906235, 0.08970123529434204, 0.14042039215564728, -0.8927354216575623, 0.24612393975257874, -0.32011333107948303, -0.592289388179779, -0.34090951085090637, 0.2688201665878296, -1.0418041944503784, 0.17910927534103394, 0.23294271528720856, 0.29659971594810486, -0.1663231998682022, 0.6273156404495239, 0.025558490306138992, -0.13616108894348145, -0.9651650786399841, -0.7555040121078491, 0.9717814326286316, -0.6134464144706726, 0.9119722247123718, 0.25369009375572205, 0.3202182352542877, -0.05242184177041054, -0.574700117111206, 1.2826595306396484, 0.6105149388313293, -0.3151712715625763, 0.36829423904418945, -0.5430417656898499, 0.18138544261455536, 0.8563815951347351, 0.08314340561628342, -1.0278804302215576, 1.0568708181381226, 0.22236672043800354, 0.1940561980009079, 0.6847515106201172, -0.02930896170437336, 0.5000951886177063, -0.03342656046152115, 0.3229300379753113, -0.26642775535583496, 0.3532947897911072, 0.24430079758167267, 0.19863033294677734, 0.01988840661942959, 0.9460493326187134, 0.10526011884212494, -1.1396193504333496, -0.5770862698554993, -0.5909610390663147, 1.0969369411468506, 0.38164880871772766, -0.44995349645614624, -0.3608238995075226, 0.8589677214622498, -0.36857637763023376, -0.2858124077320099, 1.1235110759735107, -0.9585373997688293, -0.4652476906776428, -0.9125598073005676, 0.5182967185974121, -0.5888651013374329, 0.6163349151611328, 0.028470240533351898, -0.1616591215133667, -0.06340141594409943, 0.5634808540344238, -0.04952468350529671, -0.21835994720458984, 0.9800533056259155, 0.04987383261322975, -0.0419282540678978, -0.4041258990764618, -0.34471023082733154, -0.5782002210617065, -0.47984063625335693, 0.6375372409820557, -0.2823258936405182, 0.27153798937797546, 0.24610815942287445, 0.4843851923942566, 0.44605863094329834, -0.005771423690021038, 0.11082842946052551, -0.3955304026603699, 0.435176819562912, 0.006344453431665897, 0.10885459184646606, -0.2345157414674759, -0.37222719192504883, 0.08210676908493042, -0.10319671034812927, 0.19564057886600494, -0.36139774322509766, -0.09287776798009872, 0.01111751701682806, -0.48713165521621704, 0.6774430274963379, -0.2865290641784668, -0.31452515721321106, -0.701447069644928, 0.23542675375938416, -0.21341104805469513, -0.09354902803897858, -0.25157099962234497, 0.21267026662826538, 0.4108630120754242, -0.3717282712459564, -0.1855473518371582, -0.2994288504123688, -0.6580385565757751, -0.21344542503356934, -0.9033830165863037, 0.5624104142189026, -0.37001943588256836, -0.13075067102909088, -0.6448854804039001, -1.3009002208709717, -0.5080138444900513, 0.013115164823830128, -0.27904871106147766, -0.6149133443832397, 0.3316238224506378, 0.4743545949459076, 0.594284176826477, -0.5224847793579102, 0.14415211975574493, -0.04322471842169762, -0.29323193430900574, 0.563096284866333, -0.1384454071521759, 0.9629755616188049, 0.3667601943016052, 0.36778637766838074, -0.06920648366212845, -0.30138787627220154, 0.06152588129043579, 0.1658950299024582, -0.3440428674221039, -0.5314794182777405, 0.04776669666171074, -0.1884554922580719, -0.2883765995502472, 0.6541371941566467, 1.1244897842407227, -0.012679653242230415, -0.15327422320842743, -0.5001955628395081, -0.6391396522521973, -0.3297419548034668, 0.6630269289016724, 0.5859719514846802, 0.7676512598991394, -0.35887378454208374, -0.14698615670204163, 0.5403842329978943, -0.8317849040031433, 3.9806108474731445, 1.0437729358673096, 0.8740271329879761, 0.33725640177726746, 0.2599828839302063, -0.2333851456642151, 0.48184821009635925, -0.16208180785179138, 0.30124807357788086, 0.1316944658756256, -0.517734169960022, 0.27053478360176086, 0.2093089073896408, 0.2241581529378891, 0.22846341133117676, 0.8150821924209595, -1.0562801361083984, 0.37857404351234436, -0.2900107204914093, -1.1942061185836792, -0.9229490160942078, 0.8909538388252258, 0.27068838477134705, 0.3851029872894287, -0.2922356426715851, 0.22826068103313446, 0.08531852811574936, 0.31325122714042664, 0.3587224781513214, 0.3030628561973572, -0.037885162979364395, -0.4592244327068329, -0.006979931145906448, -0.6049838662147522, -0.1857997179031372, 0.003584767458960414, -0.03251902386546135, -0.25270459055900574, 0.17049045860767365, 0.4207090735435486, 0.19371342658996582, -0.4639386236667633, -0.4903341233730316, 0.07728341221809387, -0.6212153434753418, -0.3791790008544922, -0.4646909832954407, 0.08120600134134293, 0.5829837918281555, 0.10220487415790558, 1.1050498485565186, -0.4544238746166229, -0.048408228904008865, -0.44450029730796814, -0.6976863145828247, -0.6063668727874756, -0.6747469902038574, -0.8625504970550537, -0.1394433081150055, 0.7053955793380737, 0.8275514245033264, 0.21286986768245697, -0.32636475563049316, -0.7630239129066467, 0.5154028534889221, 0.8512731194496155, -0.17802856862545013, 0.24443452060222626, -0.043495651334524155, -0.775397539138794, 0.5973904728889465, -0.40896424651145935, -0.3375526964664459, 0.25274887681007385, -0.07075918465852737, 0.2824712097644806, -0.5287990570068359, 0.8993312120437622, -0.7294219732284546, -0.6786378026008606, 0.29331016540527344, 0.46368205547332764, 0.5250577926635742, 0.16044548153877258, 0.2077217847108841, 0.6158679723739624, -0.09991901367902756, 0.16483327746391296, -1.62002432346344, 0.2370666116476059, 0.8078492283821106, -0.6001492738723755, 0.27585601806640625, -0.11128593981266022, 0.2850756049156189 ]
{"Title": "LncRNA and predictive model for improving the diagnosis of clinically diagnosed pulmonary tuberculosis", "Authors": "Hu Xuejiao, Zhang Jingwei, Liao Shun, Bai Hao, Gupta Shubham, Zhou Yi, Zhou Juan, Wu Qian, Meng Zirui, Jiao Lin, Wu Lijuan, Wang Minjin, Chen Xuerong, Zhou Yanhong, Lu Xiaojun, Zhang Zhaolei, Ying Binwu", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Clinically diagnosed pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) patients lack Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) pathogenic evidence, and misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis often occurs in clinical practice. We aimed to investigate the potential of lncRNAs and corresponding predictive models to diagnose these patients. Methods and Findings We totally enrolled 1372 subjects in three cohorts and conducted this study through a prospective four-step approach. In the Screening Step, we discovered five lncRNA candidates from blood samples using microarray on a small cohort. In the Selection Step, we used qRT-PCR to test five lncRNAs on the Selection Cohort (141 clinically diagnosed PTB patients, 159 non-TB disease controls, 578 healthy subjects) and determined three differentially expressed lncRNAs ( ENST00000497872, n333737, n335265 ). In the Model Training Step, we developed logistic regression models to distinguish clinically diagnosed PTB cases from suspected patients of the Selection Cohort, by combining these three lncRNAs with patients\u2019 electronic health records (EHRs). The model with the best c-statistic of 0.91 was presented as a Web-based nomogram (nine variables: ENST00000497872, n333737, n335265 , age, hemoglobin, weight loss, low-grade fever, CT calcification, TB-IGRA; available at https://xuejiao.shinyapps.io/shiny/ ). In the Validation Step, the nomogram was evaluated in the independent Validation Cohort, with good calibration and discrimination (c-statistic: 0.89, sensitivity: 0.80 and specificity: 0.85). A higher clinical net benefit was observed in the nomogram as compared with the EHR model using decision curve analysis. Additionally, The biological function of the most significant lncRNA was interrogated using ELISA, lactate dehydrogenase release analysis and flow cytometry. The results indicated that ENST00000497872 may involve in regulating inflammatory cytokine production, cell death and apoptosis during MTB infection. Conclusions LncRNAs ( ENST00000497872, n333737, n335265 ) could be potential diagnostic biomarkers for clinically diagnosed PTB. The nomogram incorporating lncRNAs and EHRs showed good performance in identifying clinically diagnosed PTB patients. Utilizing the user-friendly nomogram could facilitate the rapid identification of PTB cases among highly suspected patients with negative MTB pathogenic evidence, and thereby help to optimize TB diagnostic procedure.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000281"}
10.1101/2019.12.11.19014530
[ 0.011631118133664131, 0.2211182713508606, 0.15165987610816956, -0.4889011085033417, -0.18375612795352936, -1.0479917526245117, 0.238711416721344, 0.21632350981235504, -0.22107301652431488, 0.4802858233451843, 0.5100075006484985, -0.9728824496269226, 0.37819263339042664, -0.9441854953765869, -0.038004301488399506, -0.9626504778862, -1.1454685926437378, -0.10449002683162689, 0.6119722127914429, 0.6563695073127747, 0.7130311131477356, 0.5307940244674683, -0.8413853645324707, 0.945643424987793, -0.04942019283771515, 0.5615848302841187, 0.18412409722805023, 0.2987440526485443, 1.4434123039245605, 0.25722751021385193, 0.46371933817863464, -0.7046851515769958, 0.09100817888975143, -1.133533239364624, -0.41132882237434387, -0.14026756584644318, 0.6101396083831787, -0.5885153412818909, -0.19907450675964355, 0.3961232006549835, 0.1847621351480484, -0.12009869515895844, -0.06817717850208282, -0.5983068943023682, -0.544944167137146, 0.18908536434173584, -1.015789270401001, -0.8612735867500305, -0.11216828972101212, 0.1328100860118866, -0.035575609654188156, -0.025661028921604156, 0.8102064728736877, 0.003939924295991659, 0.2942429780960083, -0.3018382787704468, 0.4945990741252899, 0.6375504732131958, -0.17593634128570557, 0.3566979169845581, 0.4316824674606323, 0.6358717083930969, 0.7191308736801147, -1.143628478050232, 0.9333041310310364, 0.564261257648468, -0.3070160448551178, -0.4937775433063507, -0.7089636921882629, 0.9582018256187439, -0.5864599943161011, -0.9608358144760132, 0.39283278584480286, -0.19953301548957825, -0.04754837229847908, -0.4403362274169922, 0.37744319438934326, -0.3301470875740051, -0.18522703647613525, 0.0182834193110466, 0.7497499585151672, -0.029163341969251633, -0.15622544288635254, 0.6217123866081238, -0.5837677121162415, 0.25274738669395447, 0.6660564541816711, 1.002016305923462, 0.18545839190483093, 0.13659900426864624, 0.20056472718715668, 0.18770724534988403, 0.38270944356918335, -0.006129875313490629, 0.39770427346229553, 0.670421302318573, -0.29297277331352234, 0.06109434366226196, -0.46730196475982666, -0.3536226451396942, 1.3731281757354736, 0.6371542811393738, -0.04179958254098892, 1.1025371551513672, -1.120293378829956, 0.5322885513305664, 0.6005361080169678, 0.47439607977867126, -0.059279099106788635, -1.0477142333984375, 0.48458483815193176, 0.20473462343215942, -0.40581855177879333, 0.21526886522769928, -0.0600566491484642, 0.5822736024856567, -0.4072473645210266, 1.2180302143096924, -1.3453682661056519, 0.4052237868309021, -0.39714306592941284, 0.1965729147195816, -0.3285224735736847, -0.38691386580467224, 0.3484857678413391, 0.24258551001548767, -0.034459974616765976, 0.6517015695571899, -0.09280133247375488, -0.0026374415028840303, -0.24947018921375275, -0.005060567986220121, 0.3727280795574188, 0.09928913414478302, -0.43837541341781616, -0.32491225004196167, -0.5947540402412415, 1.3403338193893433, -0.6350642442703247, -0.6555728912353516, 0.0033556302078068256, 0.7382749319076538, -0.7465633153915405, 1.3597559928894043, -0.07272268086671829, 0.5434225797653198, -0.9579241871833801, -0.9736295342445374, 0.03571576997637749, -0.04818495362997055, -0.2087647020816803, 0.4232994019985199, 0.0049470155499875546, -0.5386636853218079, -0.6563195586204529, 0.199416846036911, 0.02487107180058956, 0.4360792338848114, 0.19961290061473846, -0.14493988454341888, -0.4365618824958801, 0.3385469615459442, -0.36339235305786133, 1.1485575437545776, -0.7277680039405823, 0.16229714453220367, -0.6307250261306763, -0.1462220996618271, -0.1150883138179779, -0.984735369682312, 0.2776930630207062, 0.08710192888975143, -0.2721482515335083, -0.6615316867828369, 0.6500952243804932, 0.7896925806999207, 0.6859499216079712, -0.8765473365783691, 0.3556685745716095, -0.38325318694114685, -0.09463208168745041, 0.44760310649871826, 0.8680102825164795, 1.052785038948059, -0.19671519100666046, -0.3266977369785309, -0.4947097897529602, -1.1691408157348633, -0.7681043744087219, -0.32144972681999207, 0.5180009603500366, 0.21335048973560333, -0.47563281655311584, 0.3674723505973816, 0.2551383972167969, 0.24247653782367706, -0.4350092113018036, 1.1790499687194824, 0.7373149991035461, -1.0344995260238647, -0.4778420031070709, 0.8193619251251221, 0.16487260162830353, 0.5418186187744141, -0.55302894115448, 0.8220049142837524, -0.4012184739112854, 1.0301203727722168, -1.2149264812469482, -0.34674209356307983, 0.8420412540435791, 1.1589102745056152, 0.019489141181111336, -0.30702468752861023, 0.7992223501205444, -0.13759568333625793, -0.3264012038707733, -0.7553943991661072, -0.3589842915534973, 0.09277510643005371, -0.14085589349269867, -0.7686203122138977, 0.690086305141449, -0.09933912754058838, -0.048158638179302216, 0.26351073384284973, 0.11692985892295837, 1.0750960111618042, -0.5005016922950745, -0.2941216230392456, -0.13705003261566162, 0.6183175444602966, 0.2442980855703354, 0.14894665777683258, 0.4506736993789673, 0.5655813813209534, 0.5844284892082214, 0.028799744322896004, 0.27270185947418213, -0.052690982818603516, 0.07331997156143188, 0.6586066484451294, 1.323662519454956, 0.8596983551979065, -0.7262214422225952, 0.7095088958740234, -0.5394627451896667, 0.8897811770439148, 0.32203397154808044, 0.9506266713142395, -0.42746156454086304, 0.5321757197380066, 0.059817615896463394, 0.3805689215660095, -0.572456419467926, -0.34524792432785034, 0.578069806098938, 0.11656021326780319, 0.200800821185112, -1.1734716892242432, -0.882351279258728, -0.024422716349363327, -0.1786709576845169, -0.26279109716415405, 0.16421030461788177, 0.4017082452774048, -0.2089015543460846, 1.1638505458831787, 0.7273697853088379, -0.22134807705879211, -0.9777334332466125, -0.9473016858100891, -1.5022727251052856, -1.406285047531128, -0.8559322953224182, 0.005498815793544054, 0.5423812866210938, -0.7803954482078552, 0.0376761220395565, -0.08723025023937225, 0.2517226040363312, -0.8798915147781372, 0.12995189428329468, 1.052827000617981, 0.867191731929779, 0.7542423605918884, -0.6328792572021484, 0.5870602130889893, -0.4469800889492035, 0.32026219367980957, -0.2844904065132141, -0.06070578098297119, -0.20895721018314362, -1.084801197052002, 0.8391361832618713, -0.3805273473262787, 0.5609801411628723, 0.3773295283317566, -0.0755363181233406, -1.1355243921279907, 0.3296746611595154, 0.054180193692445755, -0.30323144793510437, 0.04785078763961792, -1.073747992515564, 0.09955724328756332, 0.31102651357650757, 0.2875261902809143, -0.036631111055612564, 0.6393125057220459, -0.8250446319580078, 0.3750036656856537, -0.00733067374676466, 0.8576136231422424, -0.7396575808525085, -0.17726899683475494, 0.22596071660518646, -0.22171002626419067, -0.4031694829463959, -0.6716734170913696, -0.9619908332824707, -0.7799823880195618, -0.15684737265110016, -0.2411620318889618, -0.35030215978622437, -0.035300806164741516, -0.009539484046399593, -1.3229738473892212, 0.11562582850456238, -0.3764156997203827, -1.2964359521865845, 0.27768024802207947, -0.8262450695037842, 0.8756808042526245, 0.23600925505161285, -0.30939507484436035, -0.33009159564971924, -0.25558730959892273, 0.8315329551696777, 0.7053290009498596, -0.00421569449827075, 0.00638402858749032, -0.3016836643218994, 0.18257549405097961, 0.48470640182495117, 0.34368133544921875, 0.6145532727241516, -0.07950370758771896, -0.12652209401130676, -0.18494173884391785, 0.11891958117485046, 0.3831874132156372, 0.9243173003196716, -0.1661633551120758, -0.1788138598203659, 0.5047719478607178, -0.2321697473526001, 0.03893875703215599, 0.5177318453788757, -0.2883335053920746, -0.43825292587280273, 0.9261250495910645, 0.30338120460510254, 0.8168593645095825, -0.5307355523109436, -0.6852871775627136, 0.7416449189186096, -0.4579516351222992, 0.5106595158576965, -1.828415036201477, 0.8501790761947632, 0.44611966609954834, -0.5052645802497864, 0.07808612287044525, 0.31588423252105713, 0.2839953303337097, 0.7446793913841248, 0.37911802530288696, 1.0989824533462524, -1.7387712001800537, 0.5229995250701904, 0.26074329018592834, 1.6256924867630005, 0.6073590517044067, -0.27706179022789, 0.3923628032207489, -0.2848474383354187, 0.770657479763031, -0.5315864682197571, -0.44098517298698425, -0.35847774147987366, 0.40361154079437256, -0.561486005783081, 0.4992610812187195, -0.9076839685440063, 0.07322787493467331, 0.397629052400589, 0.2988804280757904, -0.07109695672988892, -0.30449190735816956, 0.6631985306739807, -0.8150209784507751, -0.14141952991485596, 0.1290852427482605, 0.2915705740451813, -0.6718897819519043, -0.7848286032676697, 0.41881367564201355, -0.050310734659433365, -0.620027482509613, 0.158450648188591, 0.39488905668258667, 0.14237529039382935, 0.3857620060443878, 1.1792203187942505, -0.8000358939170837, -0.9925470948219299, 0.0379849374294281, -0.011751433834433556, -0.14400418102741241, 0.5772879719734192, 0.7841086983680725, -0.06259899586439133, 0.9961273074150085, 0.2383822798728943, -1.1181271076202393, 0.055731743574142456, -0.2615637183189392, 0.8265691995620728, 0.6293543577194214, -0.3511373698711395, -0.8768357634544373, 0.03318653628230095, -0.5510666370391846, -0.8359614014625549, -0.3296439051628113, 0.41172197461128235, -0.7058446407318115, 0.1830955296754837, 0.4099883437156677, -0.1812993437051773, 0.21105341613292694, -0.6452447772026062, -0.31760460138320923, 0.04725014790892601, 0.18941298127174377, 0.4184977412223816, 0.45432159304618835, 0.48626482486724854, -0.09391909092664719, 0.5473006367683411, -0.712575376033783, 0.0037396627012640238, -0.1717897206544876, -0.46892601251602173, -0.6829005479812622, -0.5697203278541565, -0.08374865353107452, -0.06924423575401306, -0.5581164956092834, -0.1961335688829422, 0.5527724027633667, 0.19618630409240723, -0.376097708940506, -0.4555351138114929, 0.7225469350814819, -0.5770705938339233, -0.1553647369146347, 0.9489461779594421, 0.5759972333908081, 0.4128517806529999, -0.6340924501419067, -0.5120803713798523, -0.889232873916626, 0.24372433125972748, -0.17260901629924774, 0.5761668086051941, -0.6361116170883179, 0.11492138355970383, -0.18352551758289337, 0.7003634572029114, 0.01398481335490942, -0.3572191596031189, -0.3275613784790039, -0.6188552975654602, -0.8610243797302246, -0.18416446447372437, -0.19908815622329712, -1.0779249668121338, 0.13763298094272614, 0.3720259964466095, -0.5808423757553101, 0.06301949918270111, -0.4578067362308502, -0.5437374114990234, -0.22390028834342957, -1.2626734972000122, -0.17211183905601501, -0.5631557703018188, 0.2471322864294052, 0.7159571051597595, -0.39788684248924255, -0.2958241105079651, 0.388169527053833, 0.49601271748542786, -0.9506337642669678, -0.40684470534324646, 0.2459746152162552, -0.06596935540437698, -0.31179144978523254, -0.019897909834980965, 0.28580793738365173, -0.0842742994427681, 0.15532134473323822, -0.05838073790073395, 0.022274697199463844, -0.09194038808345795, -0.12150495499372482, -0.480383962392807, 0.40850338339805603, -0.2105327695608139, -1.221028447151184, -0.26466891169548035, 0.8044326901435852, -0.02832014486193657, 0.018432030454277992, -0.29786837100982666, -1.2135282754898071, -0.5364452004432678, -1.0913962125778198, -0.022480681538581848, -1.2405658960342407, 0.28461459279060364, -0.7278726100921631, 0.4462408125400543, 0.4246356189250946, 0.45387786626815796, -0.2427871972322464, 0.033614374697208405, -0.04659392684698105, -0.23678673803806305, 0.08552969992160797, -0.30078408122062683, 0.07222345471382141, 0.3000720143318176, -0.35741132497787476, 0.47356054186820984, 1.2100580930709839, 0.43821367621421814, -0.39214926958084106, 0.37065571546554565, 0.22404628992080688, 0.47741469740867615, 0.24590447545051575, -0.8403940200805664, 0.1208098754286766, -0.10449185967445374, 0.34207722544670105, 0.24790652096271515, 0.36733174324035645, -1.245176911354065, 0.39354461431503296, -0.26627305150032043, 0.27489492297172546, -0.653910756111145, 0.1074022501707077, -0.31614401936531067, 0.3146795928478241, 1.1378824710845947, -0.5886394381523132, 0.40545418858528137, -0.21850617229938507, -0.5760960578918457, 0.4014654755592346, 0.5892661809921265, -0.45390087366104126, -0.1454087644815445, -0.8649832606315613, -0.8539942502975464, 0.3926905691623688, 0.0538405142724514, -0.12214081734418869, 0.011400660499930382, -0.14266346395015717, 0.622941792011261, -0.7126429677009583, 1.2825945615768433, 0.646770179271698, -0.28097590804100037, -0.7819353342056274, -0.13964927196502686, 0.26321619749069214, -0.04421408101916313, -0.25088879466056824, 0.3057223856449127, -0.057408250868320465, -0.09780336916446686, -0.017169708386063576, -0.6657293438911438, -0.09389226883649826, -0.6068659424781799, 0.6957117915153503, 0.8014718294143677, 0.32524630427360535, 0.10772883892059326, -0.44438037276268005, -0.21467025578022003, -0.5468745827674866, 0.7509016394615173, 0.01168091781437397, 0.40275946259498596, 0.5645182728767395, -0.9123098850250244, -0.665412962436676, 0.33496472239494324, 0.18632113933563232, -0.6724919080734253, -0.22665710747241974, 0.47415974736213684, 0.5612937211990356, -0.4719697833061218, 0.5677947998046875, 0.5210251808166504, -0.9097224473953247, -0.5823416709899902, 0.18926459550857544, -0.38863515853881836, 0.3120684325695038, -0.5562665462493896, 0.03508094325661659, 0.4432511031627655, 0.053385719656944275, 0.2243601381778717, 0.3497717082500458, -0.15689556300640106, -0.15111978352069855, -0.5298776626586914, -0.09253295511007309, -1.0074936151504517, -0.004541640169918537, 0.6494815349578857, -0.1547090858221054, 0.8915047645568848, 0.10756805539131165, 0.8495694994926453, 0.41695377230644226, 0.009920123033225536, 0.7847812175750732, -0.7660919427871704, -0.8039814233779907, -0.42806532979011536, -0.084614098072052, -0.07279246300458908, -0.22604618966579437, -0.09333324432373047, 0.6157101988792419, -0.4403548240661621, -0.3893994688987732, -0.616051435470581, -0.19663071632385254, 0.1763981729745865, 0.5825365781784058, -0.15437792241573334, -0.34226271510124207, 0.6338090300559998, 0.5604426264762878, 0.031764160841703415, -0.42543163895606995, -0.5074470043182373, -0.9346797466278076, -0.6241607069969177, 0.13038800656795502, -1.1831414699554443, 0.01829558052122593, 0.7657814621925354, 0.2253875434398651, -0.48192697763442993, -0.8928490281105042, 0.3711795508861542, -0.20909461379051208, -0.026897232979536057, -0.47641339898109436, 0.16758081316947937, -0.37944290041923523, 0.2853916883468628, 0.206846222281456, -1.2880468368530273, 0.16459079086780548, 0.6309691667556763, -0.28092387318611145, 0.12974223494529724, 0.38392776250839233, 0.8358913660049438, 0.2118760347366333, 0.2567201852798462, -0.7966428399085999, -0.8495458364486694, -0.12906739115715027, 0.41959887742996216, 0.038413770496845245, -0.14515890181064606, 1.3454607725143433, -0.418140172958374, 0.2586394250392914, -0.0029808038379997015, 0.1032772958278656, 0.2863272726535797, 0.5128021836280823, 0.4621116518974304, -0.504193902015686, -0.8701744675636292, 0.19980110228061676, 0.7391647100448608, -0.8186215162277222, -0.9642903208732605, -1.1391328573226929, 0.21649275720119476, -0.6534056663513184, -0.3671533763408661, -0.08285177499055862, 1.138807773590088, 0.2538526952266693, 0.3957767188549042, 0.7431570291519165, 0.784277617931366, 0.16160687804222107, -0.01383287739008665, 0.2837543785572052, -0.4756075143814087, 0.3620821237564087, -0.7668666839599609, -0.5243613719940186, -0.36969494819641113, -0.3895816504955292, 0.4582916498184204, 0.20053647458553314, -0.02968205325305462, 0.29326578974723816, 0.7783551216125488, -0.5337290167808533, 0.4253596067428589, -0.1200985237956047, 0.5653179883956909, 0.531078040599823, -1.0643329620361328, -0.835437536239624, 0.380371630191803, -0.796475887298584, 0.005813081748783588, 0.6975054144859314, -0.582148551940918, 0.7230761647224426, -0.6732043623924255, -0.4390227496623993, 0.6608389019966125, 0.06661111861467361, 0.7324123382568359, -0.04627484455704689, 0.2731112539768219, 0.3072274923324585, 0.8248162269592285, 0.5985847115516663, -0.38150036334991455, 0.18212991952896118, 0.4708084166049957, -0.48016947507858276, -0.8373278975486755, 0.32324057817459106, -0.058885879814624786, 0.20266568660736084, -0.8117055892944336, -0.49577978253364563, -0.3729245066642761, 0.639894425868988, -0.10823693871498108, 0.6844447255134583, -0.2802635431289673, 0.1117158830165863, -0.027437863871455193, -0.5670803785324097, 0.23543696105480194, -0.0786219909787178, 0.26208487153053284, 0.14139266312122345, -0.6891883015632629, -0.6413838863372803, 0.3746162950992584, 1.0984747409820557, -0.19202646613121033, 0.8483870029449463, -0.6966121792793274, 0.19875624775886536, 0.19163648784160614, 0.488807737827301, -0.1548658162355423, 0.87807697057724, -0.20265009999275208, -0.08736614882946014, 0.31418734788894653, 0.314165323972702, 1.3401410579681396, -0.0786052793264389, 0.3123539090156555, 0.4572187662124634, 0.1700570285320282, 0.09663109481334686, 0.023301806300878525, -0.597529947757721, 0.8037385940551758, 0.5597236156463623, -0.5423529148101807, -0.09964777529239655, -0.0668417364358902, 0.43949830532073975, -0.39364027976989746, -0.7576769590377808, 0.40162310004234314, -0.4417652189731598, -0.8222455382347107, 0.11464619636535645, 0.6416404247283936, 0.7624918818473816, 0.012653926387429237, 0.929934024810791, -0.23949851095676422, 0.3718377351760864, -0.5200291872024536, -0.027322780340909958, 0.7640436887741089, -0.31668680906295776, -0.9436455965042114, -0.4007161855697632, 0.38208210468292236, 0.6792256832122803, -0.2908768355846405, 0.15295153856277466, -0.5495160222053528, -0.9759294986724854, 0.7004601359367371, -0.39646148681640625, -0.24379131197929382, 0.8596895933151245, -0.9157066941261292, -0.12762878835201263, 0.3953401744365692, 0.053278665989637375, -0.7381976842880249, -0.9468359351158142, 0.8986585736274719, -0.5182430744171143, -0.11155322194099426, 0.5298250317573547, 0.05747690796852112, 0.8578605055809021, -0.7743856310844421, 0.8474413156509399, -0.01532090362161398, 0.7895900011062622, 1.2006639242172241, 0.596270740032196, 0.2597557604312897, -0.016849935054779053, -0.427223265171051, -0.508523166179657, -0.2827003598213196, -0.31974583864212036, 0.47800689935684204, -0.8460904359817505, -0.20064905285835266, 0.0726701021194458, -0.6562520265579224, -0.8414674997329712, 0.2356010526418686, -0.9955556392669678, 0.05934811383485794, -0.0767693892121315, -0.48344796895980835, -0.15186943113803864, 0.03491897135972977, -0.36541998386383057, -0.17572173476219177, 0.04101143777370453, 0.29875749349594116, 0.06492659449577332, -0.39635559916496277, -0.07291235774755478, -0.000765741104260087, -0.45919421315193176, -0.4095924496650696, -0.8275941014289856, -0.7871609330177307, -0.2042200118303299, 0.05396824702620506, -0.5797426700592041, 0.45549672842025757, 0.023134049028158188, -0.06051333621144295, -0.07258810102939606, -0.19844552874565125, -0.14400500059127808, 0.27992016077041626, 0.7148846983909607, -0.479143351316452, 0.6488162875175476, 0.2555598020553589, 0.002782713621854782, -0.1505286991596222, -0.3478449583053589, 0.2882111668586731, -0.12190768122673035, -0.23215918242931366, -1.4513911008834839, 0.3090561330318451, 0.23418137431144714, -0.4110504388809204, 0.8754740953445435, 0.5818390250205994, -0.28840288519859314, 0.055099863559007645, -2.2662601470947266, -0.8125121593475342, -0.3957645893096924, 1.134028673171997, -0.6067497730255127, 0.1776779741048813, 0.6652616858482361, -0.02075166255235672, 0.5684245824813843, -0.893545389175415, 3.66373610496521, 0.6395936012268066, 0.43060246109962463, 0.10040408372879028, 0.4997895658016205, 0.7619565725326538, 0.5331682562828064, 0.2816774845123291, 0.4466598331928253, 0.5976419448852539, -0.6116681694984436, 0.12897557020187378, 0.007587710861116648, -0.23009450733661652, 0.765357255935669, 0.5575622916221619, -1.0676641464233398, -0.47652339935302734, 0.06209582835435867, -0.6994282007217407, -0.17338401079177856, 0.25925159454345703, 0.8175352811813354, -0.060590289533138275, 0.8115360736846924, -0.200930655002594, 0.1673760861158371, -0.08166944980621338, -0.2858574390411377, -0.058979619294404984, -0.3191983103752136, -0.9155421257019043, 0.420958936214447, -0.8231256604194641, 0.0697743371129036, 0.7314075827598572, 0.17847687005996704, 0.16909246146678925, 0.2141675055027008, 0.24285385012626648, -0.05271903797984123, -0.0027993142139166594, -0.41989508271217346, -0.033234093338251114, -0.1675742119550705, 0.3405108153820038, -0.591639518737793, -0.016591930761933327, 0.05963093787431717, -0.47978517413139343, 1.3706576824188232, -1.0883448123931885, 0.24187695980072021, 0.4130401015281677, -0.7973151803016663, 1.0158921480178833, -0.40865734219551086, -0.13716787099838257, -0.018656263127923012, 0.796318531036377, 0.5683091878890991, -0.5768613219261169, 0.10547323524951935, 0.546749472618103, 0.32833343744277954, 0.4495837688446045, 1.2259540557861328, -0.11626335233449936, -0.13652227818965912, -0.08045744150876999, 0.2492872029542923, 0.02559264935553074, -0.5982398390769958, -0.2782900035381317, 0.9526236653327942, 0.9656026363372803, 0.006709041073918343, 0.3552549481391907, -0.27606549859046936, -0.3891967236995697, -0.33176901936531067, -0.6776995062828064, 0.014692544005811214, -0.636407196521759, -0.06119159236550331, 0.885452926158905, -0.6823161244392395, 0.04796180874109268, -1.456726312637329, 0.9564821720123291, -0.06884187459945679, -0.0965803787112236, 0.8225893974304199, -0.055674660950899124, 0.03650191053748131 ]
{"Title": "Mendelian randomization analysis of smoking behavior and cognitive ability on the Big Five", "Authors": "Adams Charleen D.", "Abstract": "Abstract Tobacco smoke, a mutagen that can thin the brain\u2019s cortex, might influence the Big Five (neuroticism, conscientiousness, agreeableness, extraversion, and openness). Cognitive ability, however, is a potential confounder, since it is associated with who smokes and with personality. Mendelian randomization (MR), which uses genetic variants as instrumental variables, can be used to probe the causal nature of these factors on personality. Here, MR was used to appraise smoking and cognitive ability on the Big Five and cognitive ability and neuroticism on social disparity. The results seem to suggest that smoking, independent of cognitive ability, leads people to be more neurotic and less extraverted and conscientious. Higher cognitive ability appears to make people less neurotic and more open, when accounting for smoking. Neuroticism appears to increase disparity, and higher cognitive ability appears to decrease it. Smoking may enhance disparity between those of lower and higher cognitive ability by exacerbating personality differences.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.11.19014530"}
10.1101/19003087
[ 0.30623507499694824, 1.0290699005126953, 0.1309802383184433, 0.8207457065582275, 0.11309349536895752, -0.5423398017883301, -0.46258822083473206, -0.19841444492340088, -0.11560545861721039, 0.8015527129173279, -0.47808530926704407, -0.44664502143859863, 0.04689307138323784, -0.2188418060541153, -0.06972439587116241, -0.3294815719127655, 0.21475720405578613, 0.04702497646212578, -0.18413308262825012, 0.21578851342201233, 0.16185717284679413, 0.2956284284591675, -1.1001752614974976, 0.7270879745483398, -0.03131679818034172, 1.0549296140670776, -0.12518377602100372, 0.15265974402427673, 1.1366713047027588, -0.04810081794857979, 0.3626876175403595, -0.07351254671812057, 0.3118971288204193, -1.127317190170288, -0.9156501889228821, -0.7258703708648682, 0.48745614290237427, -0.5451087951660156, -0.1237616315484047, -0.1427074670791626, 1.128415584564209, -0.05670635774731636, -0.21994271874427795, 0.15247522294521332, -0.5637450218200684, 0.33819371461868286, -0.29936090111732483, 0.0501461997628212, -0.28668516874313354, -0.30885809659957886, -0.3880602717399597, -0.09095468372106552, 0.45804765820503235, -0.2741585969924927, 0.30731910467147827, -0.5285419821739197, -0.1277732402086258, -0.2853991687297821, -1.2136619091033936, 0.1560860276222229, 0.7322407364845276, -0.6187011003494263, 0.3757013976573944, -1.1505322456359863, 0.43609389662742615, 1.0031940937042236, 0.5562193393707275, -0.7134531736373901, -0.5504239201545715, 0.10634507238864899, -0.5651315450668335, -0.3035604655742645, -0.5987594127655029, -0.1612802892923355, -0.5778337121009827, -0.3077552616596222, 0.6387979984283447, -0.6085100769996643, -0.22428607940673828, 0.19571495056152344, -0.20126405358314514, -0.11006143689155579, 0.06047249212861061, -0.5511641502380371, -0.5009018182754517, 0.34003663063049316, 0.1518082171678543, 0.9429169297218323, -0.11151834577322006, 1.1070784330368042, 0.3471398949623108, 0.7319610714912415, 0.26382142305374146, 0.07888614386320114, 0.6073470711708069, 1.532431960105896, -0.12122483551502228, -0.37369680404663086, 0.3436282277107239, -0.6492171883583069, 0.25923413038253784, 0.23845788836479187, -0.8940998315811157, 0.9017757177352905, -0.08523073047399521, 0.26140087842941284, 0.4548661708831787, -0.20369663834571838, -0.4075997471809387, -0.5377622246742249, 0.1412101835012436, -0.6768433451652527, -0.7364091277122498, -1.1326645612716675, 0.6851904392242432, 0.820073127746582, -0.010515873320400715, 0.8324481248855591, -0.9743703007698059, 0.3066057860851288, 0.08666907995939255, 0.02481679990887642, 0.9339170455932617, -0.19936247169971466, -0.3004450798034668, 0.07777202874422073, 0.3329910933971405, 0.022962629795074463, -0.5798171758651733, 0.5404535531997681, -0.2353549748659134, -0.3248688578605652, -0.145354762673378, 0.8065587878227234, -0.03425465524196625, 0.1693955808877945, 0.1274593025445938, 0.41645798087120056, 0.7666743397712708, -1.023026704788208, -0.3770214915275574, 0.20354846119880676, -0.5447945594787598, 0.9145720601081848, -0.4472557604312897, 0.6164602041244507, -0.29574254155158997, -1.510430097579956, -1.1172599792480469, 0.4983924627304077, -0.4931136965751648, 0.7960638999938965, -0.2881767153739929, -0.6492403149604797, 0.48023533821105957, 0.4531323313713074, 0.05694073438644409, 0.39749085903167725, -0.2659255266189575, 0.4100834131240845, -0.5460321307182312, -0.04184088110923767, 0.17282401025295258, 0.7378464937210083, -0.35616809129714966, 0.7670629620552063, 0.145168736577034, 0.005448815878480673, -0.1271825134754181, -0.34441444277763367, 0.3904099762439728, 0.14580349624156952, 0.09661056846380234, 0.6171858310699463, 0.7085024118423462, 0.8118212223052979, 0.9514200687408447, -0.19610920548439026, 0.527012825012207, 0.9258845448493958, 0.4603624641895294, 0.642443060874939, 0.4377460479736328, 0.7307863235473633, 0.3049328327178955, 0.456133097410202, -0.2979115843772888, -0.5480488538742065, -0.35057681798934937, -0.49836498498916626, -0.31666797399520874, 0.5798768997192383, 0.003807171480730176, 0.230647474527359, 0.4365174174308777, 0.7298880219459534, -0.39028099179267883, 0.002116684801876545, 0.6504181623458862, -0.5120246410369873, -0.2251962423324585, 0.8870648741722107, 0.10212850570678711, 0.38325995206832886, 0.15147878229618073, 0.5345833897590637, 0.5055922269821167, 0.47644588351249695, -0.6499189734458923, -0.4351342022418976, 0.8595887422561646, -0.5889905691146851, -0.46416863799095154, 0.3103947043418884, 0.3209593892097473, -0.9484837055206299, -0.7570421099662781, 0.6856502890586853, -0.854763388633728, -0.09591680765151978, -0.03178141638636589, -0.16084237396717072, 0.3805578649044037, 1.1975388526916504, 0.4524175226688385, 0.6022117733955383, 0.6838505864143372, 0.6720845103263855, -0.3275974988937378, -0.2554532289505005, 0.15340077877044678, 0.4437200725078583, 0.0693497359752655, 1.1852359771728516, 0.6995896697044373, 0.07712022215127945, 0.2802554965019226, 0.5020287036895752, -0.4014255106449127, 0.13883884251117706, 0.6629648804664612, 0.6331044435501099, 0.6491261124610901, 0.6115484833717346, -0.643053412437439, 0.7060876488685608, -1.0861879587173462, 0.19419050216674805, -0.6037720441818237, 0.6226890683174133, -0.12238346040248871, 0.3638058304786682, 0.4724460542201996, 0.4942212700843811, -0.24079389870166779, -0.3528165817260742, 0.23810726404190063, 0.33765164017677307, -0.3599098324775696, 0.1564801186323166, -0.4438338279724121, -0.02288338728249073, -0.6016771197319031, 0.5637523531913757, 0.5970845222473145, 0.5948585867881775, -0.38979434967041016, -0.3246918022632599, 0.24498248100280762, -0.5143789052963257, -0.9067040085792542, -0.5511950254440308, -0.6302202939987183, -0.6608346104621887, -0.8531062602996826, -0.594586968421936, -0.1927693486213684, 0.012593535706400871, 0.5755655765533447, -0.3423212170600891, 0.1359197497367859, -0.13320180773735046, -0.8266475796699524, 0.6377350091934204, 0.29092705249786377, 0.25662070512771606, -0.8466336131095886, 0.568586528301239, -0.5962783694267273, 0.12367764115333557, -0.37303635478019714, -0.4578773081302643, -0.24252557754516602, -0.43865564465522766, 0.9275869727134705, -0.41768771409988403, -0.15161611139774323, -0.5963916182518005, 0.5679827928543091, -0.42824891209602356, 0.3240671753883362, 0.4577842354774475, 0.2332422137260437, -0.07837020605802536, -0.8425254821777344, 0.5041239857673645, 0.24424101412296295, 0.1132032722234726, 0.33902567625045776, 0.14713339507579803, -0.12865743041038513, 0.22490164637565613, -0.5191360712051392, 0.3145381212234497, -0.6913892030715942, 0.6851380467414856, 0.6452874541282654, 0.1879424750804901, -0.0940658375620842, -0.6920520663261414, -1.0010175704956055, 0.3395213484764099, 0.0876041054725647, -0.7483816742897034, 0.24763981997966766, 1.1488701105117798, -0.6138633489608765, -1.1305005550384521, 0.1746893674135208, -0.47362014651298523, -0.853873074054718, 0.04631485417485237, -0.1410178393125534, 0.4533378779888153, 0.4095403552055359, 0.06151646003127098, -0.7808405756950378, 0.3284810185432434, 0.5571758151054382, 0.4019136428833008, 0.19256789982318878, -0.4310927987098694, 0.5288142561912537, 0.3986288905143738, -0.6235845685005188, 0.300304651260376, 0.49831855297088623, 0.08311116695404053, 0.06611640006303787, 0.104570671916008, -0.17317840456962585, 0.22841784358024597, 1.1356042623519897, 0.20744088292121887, -0.040420617908239365, 0.47795477509498596, 0.0022916551679372787, 0.44389015436172485, 0.16217434406280518, 0.06065629795193672, 0.050860434770584106, 0.1830664575099945, -0.28905192017555237, -0.16227449476718903, -0.4592081308364868, -1.4413814544677734, -0.10375957936048508, -0.2696836590766907, 0.9226692914962769, -0.15412290394306183, 0.9262281060218811, 0.6945453882217407, -0.23841743171215057, 0.01164279505610466, -0.24661682546138763, 0.6971819996833801, 0.7039973735809326, 0.32106196880340576, 1.6181341409683228, -0.9248048067092896, 0.43602728843688965, 0.870086133480072, 0.8577243685722351, 0.23706457018852234, 0.433231383562088, 1.0299617052078247, -0.10450870543718338, 0.5548309087753296, -0.5288899540901184, 0.2744505703449249, -0.17768381536006927, -0.6843299269676208, -0.10879092663526535, 0.17176714539527893, -0.4320736527442932, -0.5549912452697754, -0.9385389685630798, 0.2762974202632904, -0.11648555099964142, 0.43052688241004944, 0.4117324948310852, -1.0640064477920532, 0.5092831254005432, 0.31741392612457275, 0.9505517482757568, 0.21377335488796234, -0.9158432483673096, 0.15438999235630035, 0.06167139112949371, -0.22005826234817505, 0.7558789849281311, -0.16576023399829865, -0.1988719403743744, 0.011089288629591465, 0.3619050979614258, -0.9108560085296631, -0.7858439087867737, -0.13994164764881134, -0.0087478281930089, -0.2173263430595398, -0.4315683841705322, -0.30910515785217285, -0.2783617675304413, 0.5634052157402039, -0.047017693519592285, -1.0026419162750244, -0.461798757314682, -0.49379444122314453, -0.12425679713487625, 0.7412043213844299, 0.21280613541603088, -0.8762724995613098, -0.2734493911266327, -0.07222823053598404, -0.3596619665622711, -0.41274091601371765, 0.5577414631843567, 0.11725892871618271, 0.38167604804039, -0.5989769101142883, 0.060681119561195374, -0.6374154090881348, 0.18080680072307587, -0.25127044320106506, -0.44041958451271057, -0.30383238196372986, 0.5549978017807007, 0.47189345955848694, 0.3913213014602661, -0.5225883722305298, 0.4688052833080292, -0.7198124527931213, 0.46537190675735474, 0.11127620190382004, -0.32451772689819336, -0.4256751537322998, -0.3778480887413025, 0.3568727374076843, 0.5529584884643555, -0.17758947610855103, -0.6079204678535461, -0.049166057258844376, 0.6004905104637146, -0.5158503651618958, -0.6508992314338684, 0.6443635821342468, -0.46668383479118347, 0.2154272049665451, 0.7164135575294495, -0.5637629628181458, 0.05917767435312271, -0.2562599778175354, -0.48811638355255127, -0.6965367794036865, 0.7971858382225037, -0.3216065764427185, 0.44842293858528137, 0.48388922214508057, -0.7369796633720398, -0.4983481764793396, -0.41296935081481934, -0.18895426392555237, -0.7251578569412231, -0.963789701461792, -0.714634895324707, -0.21270059049129486, -0.33518731594085693, 0.2444261908531189, -0.8966116309165955, 0.18797153234481812, 0.36650270223617554, -0.2549309730529785, 0.40795713663101196, -0.34348171949386597, -0.09992876648902893, -0.5428330302238464, -0.16486194729804993, 0.03496657311916351, 0.5864173769950867, -0.3434019684791565, 0.8843113780021667, -0.10945983976125717, -1.0605930089950562, -0.04345246031880379, -0.23064585030078888, -0.3515563905239105, -0.7035002708435059, -0.15977059304714203, -0.6824272871017456, -0.8294283151626587, 0.23932525515556335, -0.2820781171321869, -0.5203597545623779, -0.20857249200344086, 0.2651703357696533, 0.1019890308380127, 0.07589544355869293, 0.04184635356068611, -0.04991916939616203, 0.6417316198348999, -0.12702852487564087, -0.6548008322715759, -0.5742084383964539, 0.8314176797866821, 0.0017175587126985192, -0.10128500312566757, -0.05433540791273117, -1.2189639806747437, -0.3716804087162018, -0.9796916246414185, 0.4396587312221527, -0.8190277814865112, 0.4290849566459656, -0.4290572702884674, -0.576603353023529, -0.17633606493473053, 0.668928325176239, 0.36646732687950134, 0.006361203268170357, -0.28641942143440247, -0.8945140838623047, 0.037931881844997406, 0.22561874985694885, -0.6800335645675659, -0.4219623804092407, -1.2119481563568115, -0.3794412612915039, 1.1598471403121948, -0.2492155134677887, 0.05664272606372833, 0.5084842443466187, 0.3973553478717804, 0.4445898234844208, 0.6019940376281738, -0.28736379742622375, -0.6245926022529602, -0.07970317453145981, 1.2219834327697754, -0.27626681327819824, -0.05760372802615166, -1.1466692686080933, 0.917126476764679, -0.3795609176158905, 0.8091524243354797, -0.539726972579956, -0.11530829221010208, -0.20997296273708344, -0.31667155027389526, 0.6215311288833618, -0.6242052316665649, 0.09011994302272797, -0.24856433272361755, -0.19905917346477509, -0.19395574927330017, 0.7707634568214417, -0.3474329710006714, -0.5909127593040466, -1.1835569143295288, -0.8640472292900085, 0.5797014236450195, -0.3546047806739807, 0.09506168961524963, 0.7217320203781128, 0.09585414826869965, 0.31484612822532654, -0.4590568542480469, 0.8302270770072937, 0.5601065754890442, -0.6640204191207886, 0.15304933488368988, 0.44232067465782166, 0.15167871117591858, -0.30770158767700195, 0.15321435034275055, 0.34778669476509094, -0.15042774379253387, -0.6357954740524292, 0.2848909795284271, -0.5586027503013611, -0.7047224044799805, 0.1335219442844391, -0.21277181804180145, 0.9053195118904114, -0.05603184923529625, 0.5331307649612427, -0.04899333044886589, -0.07059036195278168, -0.3205645978450775, 0.66417396068573, 0.34612056612968445, 0.5199950337409973, 1.2381199598312378, 0.07034280896186829, -0.1372140794992447, -0.5160874724388123, -0.7557637691497803, 0.04451034218072891, -0.036248497664928436, 0.6672847270965576, 0.4160725772380829, -0.6451385617256165, 0.8805167078971863, 0.9415153861045837, -0.7964893579483032, -0.6819323301315308, 0.12122944742441177, -0.8064653277397156, -0.1425832211971283, -0.4759254455566406, 0.011599388904869556, 0.2935464680194855, 0.09830767661333084, -0.25968655943870544, 0.2813604772090912, 0.41689997911453247, 0.8348645567893982, -0.4556153416633606, -0.3401724100112915, -0.25403332710266113, 0.8238933086395264, 0.6944407820701599, -0.008959363214671612, 0.009814796969294548, -0.04246676713228226, 0.4777035713195801, -0.34875455498695374, -0.41009530425071716, 0.46806374192237854, -0.09779740869998932, -0.2929633855819702, -0.09960021823644638, 0.3876173496246338, -0.050203271210193634, 0.1744888722896576, -0.5006092190742493, 1.3611270189285278, 0.07312007248401642, -0.8035542368888855, -0.3316693603992462, -0.22373420000076294, 0.9386026859283447, 0.8667668700218201, 0.08423242717981339, 0.3225472867488861, 0.3607547879219055, -0.15213823318481445, 0.6480175852775574, -0.6678066253662109, 0.27485138177871704, -0.42183026671409607, -0.18701483309268951, -0.4093504250049591, -0.5479322671890259, 0.8472490906715393, 0.9134398698806763, -0.255153626203537, -0.16640207171440125, -0.37763354182243347, -0.25468918681144714, -0.020659012719988823, -0.12049311399459839, -0.44078344106674194, 0.6296316385269165, -0.5835310220718384, -0.4337349236011505, -0.029038332402706146, -0.4383750855922699, 0.04894110560417175, 0.8248669505119324, -0.43087461590766907, 0.17253310978412628, 0.39952343702316284, 0.0390610471367836, 0.3622993528842926, 0.05907020717859268, -0.7295230031013489, -0.6898378729820251, -0.3493000566959381, 0.5577589273452759, -0.38335007429122925, -0.2570839822292328, 0.5139772891998291, -0.898796796798706, 0.39243701100349426, 1.0575107336044312, -0.24606196582317352, -0.3998509645462036, -0.17931707203388214, 0.5688102841377258, -0.8840097784996033, -0.10998932272195816, -0.31124067306518555, 0.8978829979896545, -0.8413450717926025, -0.011344016529619694, -0.258665531873703, -0.23974788188934326, -0.23570777475833893, 0.005462021101266146, 0.36485031247138977, -0.10261479020118713, 0.30464085936546326, -0.32210573554039, -0.1365768164396286, 0.8899788856506348, 0.7918559312820435, -0.13701695203781128, 0.5461980700492859, -0.2431710809469223, -0.01658373698592186, -1.2213761806488037, 0.04787169769406319, 0.5336273908615112, 0.3951406180858612, 0.21261778473854065, 0.17190948128700256, 0.6203122138977051, -0.561598539352417, 0.003697973443195224, -0.7757281064987183, 0.04381007328629494, 0.22016990184783936, 1.0530421733856201, 0.15068306028842926, -0.41748055815696716, -0.458016037940979, -0.7118266820907593, -1.4898440837860107, -0.6227869987487793, 0.0397154837846756, -0.5893086791038513, -0.014611328952014446, -0.7795316576957703, -0.2665782570838928, 0.5571399927139282, -0.07113682478666306, -0.14384405314922333, -0.09672246873378754, -0.09526732563972473, 0.5591368079185486, 0.9696013331413269, 0.42337343096733093, -0.22188317775726318, 0.3376425802707672, 0.06528335064649582, -0.28595229983329773, -0.009724224917590618, -0.09473014622926712, -0.20837286114692688, 0.10222917795181274, -0.29804110527038574, -0.49037593603134155, -0.22808879613876343, -0.07546080648899078, -1.37896728515625, -0.273512065410614, -0.14498907327651978, -1.4682536125183105, -0.15464824438095093, -0.7389136552810669, 0.04167835786938667, -0.44355207681655884, -0.05937976390123367, -0.254913866519928, -0.5118863582611084, -0.6610532402992249, 0.1972837746143341, 1.4445862770080566, 0.25536981225013733, 0.6840643882751465, 0.3334313631057739, 0.08399266749620438, -0.5987673401832581, -0.7960696220397949, 0.788080096244812, 0.4627479016780853, 0.021598679944872856, 0.16864702105522156, 0.11012358963489532, 0.8508357405662537, 0.20918314158916473, 0.446781724691391, -0.5199359059333801, 0.48253464698791504, 0.4691954255104065, -0.47270166873931885, -0.034246791154146194, -0.08658494055271149, 0.29163694381713867, 0.15750041604042053, -0.5843971371650696, -0.22864097356796265, 0.10596799850463867, 0.388668954372406, -0.12157303094863892, -1.0245894193649292, 0.38464096188545227, -0.3006283640861511, -0.5949851274490356, 0.10133635252714157, 0.19409000873565674, 0.9952071905136108, 0.3679475486278534, 0.1283804327249527, 0.2816539406776428, 0.9507318735122681, -0.20527344942092896, 0.3717747628688812, 0.9264239072799683, -0.9358838796615601, -0.3411741554737091, -0.24294370412826538, 0.06901055574417114, 0.17798173427581787, 0.26466166973114014, 0.03170914947986603, -0.4319111108779907, -0.32516106963157654, 0.7697962522506714, -0.4416969418525696, 0.36036795377731323, 1.053257703781128, 0.14566670358181, -0.43042171001434326, 0.2679098844528198, 0.31761735677719116, -0.3593256175518036, -0.4058481454849243, 1.445481538772583, -0.3568733334541321, -0.12312548607587814, 0.32597750425338745, 0.3097536563873291, 0.885979950428009, 0.3781029284000397, 0.5383841395378113, -0.4723905026912689, 0.17778992652893066, 0.5476256012916565, 0.9259814023971558, 0.04462404176592827, -0.20708438754081726, -0.6782795190811157, -0.2705858647823334, -0.9052330851554871, -1.1459126472473145, 0.29351553320884705, -0.6173995733261108, -0.2679881751537323, 0.9282162189483643, -0.06606617569923401, -0.441857248544693, -0.31277984380722046, -0.6580413579940796, 0.2059875726699829, -0.015980910509824753, -0.3298388719558716, 0.9324954748153687, 0.7495200037956238, -0.2946777939796448, -0.054085973650217056, -0.677645206451416, -0.3345640003681183, 0.1875024139881134, -0.6434977650642395, 0.676468014717102, -0.27954182028770447, -0.25963297486305237, -0.5795680284500122, -1.5061328411102295, -0.7232688069343567, -0.22659261524677277, 0.19888733327388763, -0.9322245717048645, -0.729946494102478, 0.249505877494812, 0.3755190074443817, 0.3885917663574219, 0.16160833835601807, 0.45900046825408936, -0.06636442989110947, 0.542798638343811, -0.32707932591438293, 0.9945957064628601, -0.5911166071891785, 0.0747484415769577, -0.08371535688638687, -0.3420411944389343, 0.1153237372636795, 0.053293924778699875, 0.23559775948524475, -0.6411618590354919, 0.3743234872817993, -0.05563633143901825, -0.09488030523061752, 0.7143601179122925, 0.38308385014533997, -0.6893877983093262, -0.5216020345687866, -1.0773515701293945, -0.5413957238197327, -0.6176140904426575, 0.4987271726131439, -0.40212616324424744, -0.23336581885814667, 0.3863948583602905, -0.002420457312837243, 0.4944435954093933, -1.1039810180664062, 3.920086145401001, 1.663656234741211, 0.8347252011299133, -0.44497936964035034, 0.7214329838752747, 0.936527669429779, 0.2505793273448944, -0.12074156850576401, -0.15967389941215515, -0.1606566160917282, 0.16321605443954468, 0.6213141083717346, 0.6990193128585815, -0.02648940682411194, 0.7695077061653137, -0.24415934085845947, -0.973230242729187, 0.3727606236934662, -0.6718124747276306, -0.7721341848373413, -0.5738738775253296, 0.375473290681839, -0.5308142900466919, 0.4041766822338104, 0.49385538697242737, 0.19014324247837067, -0.205776184797287, -0.3118363916873932, -0.3492315113544464, -1.0151594877243042, 0.4356957674026489, 0.15738116204738617, 0.533937931060791, -0.7194710373878479, -0.1055179312825203, 0.37864717841148376, -0.6871599555015564, -1.0025602579116821, -0.002300549764186144, 0.5203456878662109, -0.1116897314786911, -0.3781334161758423, -0.06222469359636307, -0.25997382402420044, 0.013972938992083073, 0.06097571179270744, -0.7530457377433777, -0.2000119537115097, 0.5597586035728455, 0.12459690868854523, 0.5432898998260498, -1.2018011808395386, 0.6536993384361267, -0.6871318221092224, -1.008697748184204, -0.3472914397716522, -0.06331527233123779, -1.2501541376113892, 0.01957719959318638, 0.36375102400779724, 0.419546514749527, 0.2529372274875641, -0.23298221826553345, -0.4439905285835266, 0.7950074672698975, 0.9877022504806519, 0.4542998671531677, 0.8280670046806335, -0.1591528356075287, -0.38338321447372437, -0.24103139340877533, -1.305745005607605, -0.39777708053588867, -0.14235228300094604, 0.5022519826889038, 0.027344757691025734, 0.5561649799346924, 0.6240249872207642, -0.25683122873306274, -0.3707580864429474, 0.15703541040420532, -0.18532180786132812, -0.15844376385211945, -0.08109336346387863, 0.28221532702445984, 0.627058207988739, -0.5430086851119995, -0.6443198919296265, -0.574231743812561, 1.0705680847167969, 0.12360766530036926, 0.5854160785675049, 0.3352053463459015, 0.15119825303554535, -0.2789781987667084 ]
{"Title": "Host genetic variants near the PAX5 gene locus associate with susceptibility to invasive group A streptococcal disease", "Authors": "Parks Tom, Auckland Kathryn, Lamagni Theresa L., Mentzer Alexander, Elliott Katherine, Guy Rebecca, Cartledge Doreen, Strakova Lenka, O\u2019Connor Daniel, Pollard Andrew J, Chapman Stephen J., Thomas Matthew, Brodlie Malcolm, Colot Julien, D\u2019Ortenzio Eric, Baroux No\u00e9mie, Mirabel Mariana, Gilchrist James J., Scott J. Anthony G., Williams Thomas N., Knight Julian, Steer Andrew C., Hill Adrian V. S., Sriskandan Shiranee", "Abstract": "Abstract We undertook a genome-wide association study of susceptibility to invasive group A streptococcal (GAS) disease combining data from distinct clinical manifestations and ancestral populations. Amongst other signals, we identified a susceptibility locus located 18kb from PAX5 , an essential B-cell gene, which conferred a nearly two-fold increased risk of disease (rs1176842, odds ratio 1.8, 95% confidence intervals 1.5-2.3, P=3.2\u00d710 \u22127 ). While further studies are needed, this locus could plausibly explain some inter-individual differences in antibody-mediated immunity to GAS, perhaps providing insight into the effects of intravenous immunoglobulin in streptococcal toxic shock.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003087"}
10.1101/19012153
[ -0.2763884663581848, 0.08743064105510712, -0.9407626390457153, 0.2029804289340973, -0.8170061111450195, -0.5433603525161743, 0.4480728805065155, 0.09611488878726959, 0.04493115097284317, 0.5787511467933655, 0.1732141375541687, -0.06743431091308594, 0.8194695711135864, 0.3356863558292389, 0.31867173314094543, 0.19400979578495026, -0.6242479085922241, -0.24606718122959137, -0.39050719141960144, 0.21159663796424866, -0.1876816600561142, 0.4321880638599396, -1.2506625652313232, -0.10037370771169662, -1.0542821884155273, 1.2043567895889282, 0.05400800704956055, -0.23077189922332764, 1.3429498672485352, 0.6675629019737244, -0.5643064379692078, -0.2139088213443756, 0.9245806932449341, -0.030495621263980865, -0.03120744414627552, -0.239961639046669, 0.7952470183372498, 0.026560040190815926, 0.24698670208454132, -0.5325377583503723, 0.1948944479227066, 0.3972751200199127, 0.6823906302452087, -0.5903500914573669, -0.5787737965583801, -0.5947514772415161, 1.0323810577392578, 0.23106947541236877, 0.04975118115544319, -0.628043532371521, -0.479096919298172, 0.23324592411518097, 0.13051065802574158, -0.9551244378089905, -0.19898219406604767, -0.043907999992370605, 0.4305027425289154, -0.38890910148620605, -0.6503552794456482, 0.8633884787559509, 0.46762099862098694, -0.4122956395149231, 0.6422497034072876, -1.3930439949035645, 0.7060359716415405, 0.33244311809539795, 0.03209487348794937, -0.23169922828674316, -0.37316471338272095, -0.23294758796691895, 0.23118709027767181, 0.6485576629638672, -0.563675045967102, -0.8231588006019592, -0.5856152176856995, -0.29700011014938354, 0.7172955274581909, 0.06708995252847672, -0.4137258529663086, -0.20394369959831238, -0.002863341709598899, 0.5564666390419006, 0.8311794996261597, -0.06230873242020607, -0.14011764526367188, 0.04174418747425079, 0.24387356638908386, 0.5044699907302856, 0.11767683923244476, 0.3699631094932556, 0.9457586407661438, -0.18151021003723145, 0.07379550486803055, -0.030457021668553352, -0.07029081881046295, 1.2784819602966309, -1.0600842237472534, -0.16877581179141998, 0.0799437016248703, -0.04358852654695511, 0.5971946716308594, 0.7563480138778687, -0.05580409988760948, 0.38228482007980347, -0.985047459602356, 0.5466009378433228, 0.9313803315162659, -0.9276635646820068, -0.03591251000761986, -0.41108348965644836, -0.7179879546165466, 0.4130832552909851, -0.9700506925582886, -1.0550559759140015, 0.22122742235660553, 0.08627179265022278, 0.655090868473053, 0.952025294303894, -0.7252103090286255, 0.844165563583374, 0.21827690303325653, 0.527887761592865, 0.277098685503006, -0.3869057595729828, 0.2144424170255661, -0.22403556108474731, 0.9641965627670288, 0.7482192516326904, -0.24642592668533325, -0.3780459463596344, -0.018690451979637146, -0.8142090439796448, 0.11635139584541321, 0.7228471040725708, -0.3835523724555969, -0.14488469064235687, 0.37506067752838135, 0.1618013232946396, 1.0016816854476929, -0.11402960866689682, -0.4833667576313019, 0.41543129086494446, -0.14973297715187073, 1.2835636138916016, -0.7300913333892822, 0.9557412266731262, -0.8240709900856018, -0.44252365827560425, -0.2347860485315323, -0.3327958583831787, -0.051258184015750885, 0.4488234221935272, 0.8165755867958069, -0.02073359116911888, 0.29422613978385925, -0.5065682530403137, -0.5089407563209534, -0.2635646164417267, -0.660082221031189, 0.17562292516231537, -0.8220139145851135, 0.5028085112571716, -0.09480233490467072, 0.6351702809333801, -0.686669647693634, -0.06406023353338242, -0.13968829810619354, 0.30921226739883423, 0.33081355690956116, -0.6342350244522095, 0.8054134845733643, 0.22227399051189423, -0.8398748636245728, -0.37015199661254883, 0.6028730869293213, 0.2000035047531128, 0.45917046070098877, 0.18120405077934265, -0.16176575422286987, 0.6764611601829529, -0.30946606397628784, -0.25386109948158264, -0.27216407656669617, 1.2754830121994019, -0.1846930831670761, 0.8753708004951477, -0.09529983997344971, -0.4444849193096161, -0.3739330470561981, -0.2810336649417877, 0.15570853650569916, 0.5576902627944946, -0.3605460822582245, 0.33932262659072876, 0.2046186476945877, -0.1364331990480423, -0.709166944026947, 0.5511849522590637, 1.2137856483459473, -0.16673725843429565, -0.3936883211135864, 0.030366037040948868, -0.26372048258781433, -0.013788930140435696, -0.633834958076477, 0.6204040050506592, -0.571730375289917, -0.42522409558296204, -0.4231038987636566, -0.1310351938009262, 1.3701629638671875, 0.4148670434951782, -1.0944527387619019, 0.23413008451461792, 0.2527482211589813, -0.5571504235267639, -0.3864721655845642, 0.17337088286876678, -0.8860124945640564, 0.09452126920223236, -1.091735601425171, -0.09468032419681549, 0.7440435886383057, -0.3213093876838684, 0.0739397257566452, -0.07749153673648834, 0.8933498859405518, 0.6644367575645447, -0.595941960811615, -0.42323434352874756, 0.683973491191864, 0.4758116602897644, 0.6692468523979187, 0.5490983724594116, 0.9779891967773438, 0.378743439912796, 0.30740392208099365, 0.3643171489238739, 0.4420298635959625, 0.08136216551065445, 0.6967681050300598, 0.6361874341964722, 0.7922064661979675, 0.20952674746513367, -0.5916311144828796, 0.587548017501831, 0.5555217266082764, -0.3031240403652191, 0.09380664676427841, 0.280196875333786, -0.19496716558933258, 1.0821369886398315, 0.43200021982192993, 0.3687359392642975, -1.1580134630203247, 0.0000027018613764084876, 0.4389532506465912, 0.7424995303153992, -0.6514685750007629, -0.11750845611095428, 0.059617772698402405, 0.44990402460098267, -0.4622909128665924, 0.07998602837324142, 0.8220511078834534, 0.22023005783557892, -0.2396157830953598, 0.5140369534492493, -0.5322708487510681, -0.6428866982460022, -0.26369214057922363, -0.27700409293174744, -1.144633412361145, -0.5984590649604797, -1.1143087148666382, 0.5867906212806702, 0.16300730407238007, -0.5303957462310791, 0.32714471220970154, 0.2862188220024109, 0.11037500947713852, -0.058929719030857086, -0.012318805791437626, 0.5290398597717285, 0.32466745376586914, 0.17811007797718048, -1.2972793579101562, 0.6420049071311951, -0.24781496822834015, 0.40943849086761475, -0.4378027319908142, -0.11478902399539948, -1.160767674446106, -0.9099788069725037, 0.7226793766021729, -0.8821111917495728, 0.09116777777671814, -0.20732522010803223, -0.969848096370697, -1.2201759815216064, -0.1757148802280426, -0.6776641607284546, 0.6945061087608337, -0.03749118000268936, -0.5301116108894348, 0.7523069977760315, -0.45637422800064087, 1.342422604560852, 0.7947245836257935, -0.012185011059045792, -0.22484363615512848, 0.2710086405277252, -0.3426584303379059, -0.43933993577957153, -1.2178356647491455, -0.2169206291437149, 0.6715995073318481, -0.2274431735277176, 0.26260554790496826, 0.5583443641662598, -1.153327226638794, -0.29438385367393494, 0.34075406193733215, -0.49659544229507446, -0.4255155622959137, -0.01996314339339733, 0.4963977634906769, -1.7060052156448364, 0.5291786789894104, -0.7270306944847107, -0.4097597897052765, -0.08900226652622223, 0.07171879708766937, -0.119266077876091, 0.045858316123485565, -0.06012969836592674, -0.48062998056411743, -0.09958353638648987, -0.3797716796398163, -0.020515237003564835, 0.4236665964126587, -0.48488649725914, 0.16223861277103424, -0.4204697012901306, -0.9652820229530334, 0.7876002192497253, 0.057099517434835434, -0.29120782017707825, -0.6545324325561523, -0.04708949849009514, -0.47924819588661194, 0.29976385831832886, 1.0296181440353394, 0.07196914404630661, -0.5103737711906433, 0.6527457237243652, -0.5089868307113647, 0.5581396818161011, 0.48203209042549133, 0.8904491662979126, -0.5747710466384888, 0.17022554576396942, -0.3348911702632904, 0.0380035936832428, -0.8562735915184021, -1.2801814079284668, 0.34155869483947754, -0.09665919095277786, 0.5080870985984802, -0.2881603240966797, 0.738762617111206, -0.7446143627166748, 0.2592163383960724, 0.2220000922679901, -0.5395525693893433, -0.7441455125808716, 1.1090387105941772, 0.04533524811267853, 0.8167047500610352, 0.09270336478948593, -0.0445743128657341, -0.3002205789089203, 0.6378597617149353, 0.19383470714092255, -0.8403308391571045, 0.2056432068347931, -0.48720428347587585, 0.5772479176521301, -0.4105638265609741, -0.4823504388332367, -0.46142396330833435, 0.04417751729488373, 0.4022296369075775, 0.25888946652412415, -0.8817226886749268, -0.5551196932792664, -0.3809584677219391, 0.7181588411331177, 0.2471729964017868, 0.01280912384390831, 0.5590634346008301, 0.040954165160655975, 0.1898179054260254, 0.4442685544490814, 0.23282113671302795, 0.5208898186683655, -0.7543224096298218, 0.3762919008731842, -0.18680869042873383, -0.17206646502017975, -0.12022189795970917, -0.5241634845733643, -0.024127045646309853, 0.3504836857318878, -0.17213785648345947, 0.16534601151943207, -0.5771201252937317, -0.7482615113258362, -0.3335426151752472, -0.4572139382362366, -0.2181556671857834, 0.02708500251173973, -0.1609237939119339, 0.06002744287252426, 0.07270026206970215, 0.43493807315826416, 0.22146475315093994, 0.030877279117703438, 0.8605602383613586, 0.8778911232948303, -1.474745512008667, -0.6735324859619141, 0.258268803358078, -0.07684727013111115, -0.3600233495235443, -0.01504718977957964, 0.4852072298526764, 0.2332775592803955, 0.2792086899280548, -0.5600751638412476, 0.1309165209531784, -0.3906416594982147, -0.0531671941280365, -0.05503016337752342, -0.1952584832906723, 0.48708441853523254, 1.234042763710022, -0.04573120176792145, -0.033346086740493774, 0.2256823182106018, 0.3597676455974579, -0.6520792841911316, 0.9602910876274109, 0.23155046999454498, -0.46857568621635437, 0.040964920073747635, 0.5512376427650452, 0.13389712572097778, -0.5511443614959717, -0.42485764622688293, -0.06630509346723557, -0.050915345549583435, 0.2053740918636322, 0.08633968979120255, -0.28521856665611267, 0.672706127166748, 0.20142106711864471, -0.47777706384658813, 1.2019031047821045, -0.3178502023220062, -0.3126872479915619, 0.2931925654411316, 0.16162090003490448, -0.7301942110061646, 0.9179436564445496, -0.7279776334762573, -0.10927129536867142, 0.645556628704071, -0.9334160685539246, 0.39986884593963623, 0.21423068642616272, 0.26066210865974426, 0.006885944399982691, -0.28246280550956726, -0.10901957005262375, -0.18249647319316864, -0.9081718921661377, -0.24421070516109467, -0.6861820220947266, 0.4090910851955414, -0.09385073184967041, -0.21589604020118713, -0.0657571405172348, -0.4047318696975708, -0.08033574372529984, -0.06893226504325867, 0.27331870794296265, -0.263971209526062, 0.04976576194167137, 0.40007734298706055, 0.24434922635555267, -0.05406966060400009, -1.0102421045303345, -0.5631787776947021, 0.23814080655574799, -0.965487003326416, -0.2405303418636322, -0.45151612162590027, -0.11651382595300674, -0.17128592729568481, -0.35445985198020935, 0.43574845790863037, -0.17689020931720734, -0.014888065867125988, -0.8033396601676941, -0.21628980338573456, 0.7574422955513, 0.01803220622241497, 0.2826404869556427, 0.8063158988952637, 0.043889883905649185, -1.0721527338027954, -0.784035325050354, 0.3933414816856384, -0.23065544664859772, 0.17672331631183624, -0.4283693730831146, -0.7204504013061523, -0.5285483598709106, -1.7804187536239624, -0.061214856803417206, 0.12958481907844543, -0.007606367114931345, 0.4643932580947876, -0.4089145362377167, -0.3564196228981018, -0.2558125853538513, 0.38596537709236145, -0.149957537651062, 0.03785013407468796, -0.5552286505699158, 0.005836352240294218, 0.1814557909965515, 0.016385642811655998, 0.7147283554077148, -1.292904019355774, 0.680382490158081, 1.2771550416946411, 0.8473867177963257, 0.4081856310367584, 0.08188901096582413, -0.14526915550231934, 0.24029366672039032, -0.422191321849823, 0.5464041829109192, -0.4385257065296173, -0.2709144055843353, 0.602767288684845, -0.4612347185611725, -0.026418983936309814, -0.7903643250465393, 1.0545754432678223, -0.9285107851028442, 0.6353934407234192, -0.015288865193724632, -0.2524404227733612, -0.15817074477672577, -0.9640879034996033, 1.1480449438095093, -0.5308128595352173, 0.5211203694343567, 0.9492551684379578, -0.24481786787509918, 0.44035103917121887, -0.0008750217384658754, -0.7642422914505005, -0.6649622321128845, -0.4034672677516937, -0.8514198660850525, 0.2880806624889374, 0.3493342697620392, 0.2832651436328888, -0.09800328314304352, -0.14840982854366302, 0.19435511529445648, -0.5498196482658386, 0.7864056825637817, 0.4105430543422699, -0.7660090923309326, -0.7068930268287659, -0.14712539315223694, 0.12299363315105438, 0.6391652822494507, 0.4198181927204132, 1.083547830581665, -0.06308715045452118, 0.37055012583732605, -0.46143677830696106, -0.5600324869155884, -0.33459019660949707, -0.2158040702342987, -0.0784880593419075, 0.913436770439148, -0.04033931717276573, 0.5353102684020996, 0.06237787380814552, -0.45561137795448303, -0.7433199286460876, 0.9943764209747314, -0.18079155683517456, 0.35588550567626953, 0.37639597058296204, -0.5513984560966492, -0.38720032572746277, -0.32536959648132324, 0.00843631848692894, -0.04284992814064026, -0.4954633116722107, 0.23149266839027405, 0.01353899110108614, -1.3913975954055786, 0.29697364568710327, 0.5992695093154907, -0.4956885576248169, -0.4227149486541748, 0.23891207575798035, -0.11273293197154999, 0.40572234988212585, -0.16887477040290833, -0.8549310564994812, 0.8143712878227234, -0.0004113140166737139, 0.4513140618801117, -0.28487569093704224, -0.6749876737594604, 0.05037304759025574, -0.5646412372589111, 0.040081024169921875, -0.4208814799785614, -0.05532858893275261, 0.5871959924697876, -0.23687824606895447, 0.6324865818023682, 0.07893182337284088, 0.1341036856174469, 0.13656257092952728, 0.1622452586889267, 0.5211653709411621, -0.3191092908382416, 0.07518750429153442, 0.31301161646842957, -0.5081247687339783, 0.6310141086578369, -0.4125615060329437, -0.22001734375953674, 0.7550246119499207, 0.2928652763366699, -0.8266124129295349, -0.9769628047943115, 0.4078390598297119, 0.437553346157074, 0.22464647889137268, 0.12861111760139465, 0.00953119620680809, 0.8239778876304626, 0.47892481088638306, 0.10595505684614182, -0.8389589190483093, -0.16876162588596344, -0.5758554935455322, -0.24476978182792664, -0.2516768276691437, -0.32718518376350403, -0.6022971868515015, 0.24157291650772095, -0.17308557033538818, 0.1295776069164276, 0.2808245122432709, 0.9042072892189026, -0.8362508416175842, -0.3503293991088867, -0.5524488687515259, 0.6038193702697754, -0.6424896717071533, -0.7734706401824951, -0.5778454542160034, -0.2951563596725464, 0.2660250961780548, 0.9341549277305603, -0.9182092547416687, -0.4006694257259369, 0.06074433773756027, 0.1792575865983963, 0.36717405915260315, 0.4774780571460724, -0.7883429527282715, -0.2217811644077301, 0.25073903799057007, 0.6059831380844116, 0.4448806643486023, -0.09332986921072006, 0.3146970570087433, -0.008332286030054092, 0.5079823732376099, 0.7699204683303833, 0.2036680281162262, 0.07703229784965515, -0.14549599587917328, 0.5650893449783325, -1.1096076965332031, -0.7960196733474731, -0.4336065948009491, -0.1332436501979828, -0.6387204527854919, 0.591533899307251, -0.5224291682243347, -0.6211833357810974, -0.16102078557014465, 0.06043791398406029, -0.7528359889984131, -0.0030069490894675255, 1.065780520439148, 0.7972992658615112, 0.3818175792694092, 0.2541131377220154, 0.5883890986442566, 0.34168320894241333, 0.4705076515674591, 0.6204770803451538, -0.21452867984771729, -0.626367449760437, 0.1623862236738205, 0.9210861325263977, 0.6713831424713135, 0.33642929792404175, -0.7830231189727783, 0.006888114847242832, 0.22043120861053467, -0.29915064573287964, -0.3492114841938019, 1.6133008003234863, 0.587878406047821, -0.10709986835718155, 0.07551503926515579, -0.443074107170105, -0.9436025023460388, -0.5113793611526489, -0.6182957887649536, -0.4106983244419098, 0.6193068623542786, 0.05149915814399719, 0.05585995689034462, -0.06794964522123337, -0.6728152632713318, -0.6877779960632324, -0.12261541187763214, 0.8140538334846497, -0.2586677372455597, 0.7366151213645935, -0.5433986783027649, 1.4387794733047485, -0.014468647539615631, 0.22091521322727203, 0.6354336738586426, -0.05584615096449852, -0.50620037317276, -0.18151147663593292, 0.0998479574918747, 0.158730611205101, 0.4379200041294098, -0.07834331691265106, 0.23661088943481445, 0.014377429150044918, 0.07021840661764145, 0.3058233857154846, 0.4267277717590332, 0.20164215564727783, -0.9100505113601685, -0.30993539094924927, 0.16819266974925995, 0.493437260389328, -0.9820519089698792, 0.5157568454742432, 0.6095734238624573, -0.7946881055831909, -0.9301484823226929, -0.04672090336680412, 0.31025877594947815, -0.14077821373939514, -0.17117927968502045, 0.5091105699539185, 0.6988952159881592, -0.43878963589668274, -1.1352863311767578, 0.6936438083648682, 0.6020143628120422, -0.12808479368686676, 0.20380733907222748, -0.4446832239627838, -0.1493334025144577, 0.06640303134918213, -0.07047881186008453, 0.16231834888458252, -0.10474895685911179, 0.21260859072208405, -0.5011835694313049, 0.21814149618148804, -0.48031288385391235, 0.39767464995384216, 0.04478142410516739, -0.2776610553264618, 0.41416943073272705, -0.022804075852036476, 0.48670893907546997, 0.32972604036331177, -0.7412029504776001, 0.3000141978263855, -0.20378725230693817, -1.2341200113296509, -0.14210860431194305, 0.05103569105267525, 0.6953149437904358, 0.5203422904014587, -0.17507866024971008, 0.12713944911956787, 0.10363983362913132, 0.4010152220726013, -0.5302058458328247, 0.4928978681564331, 0.41699135303497314, -0.3905908763408661, 0.43813517689704895, -0.11774589121341705, -0.5971561074256897, 0.29926392436027527, -0.17020457983016968, 0.23690550029277802, 0.46213552355766296, 0.8881844282150269, 0.026731066405773163, -0.051821351051330566, 1.1501411199569702, -0.7588599324226379, -0.151724711060524, 0.19802603125572205, 0.12771639227867126, -0.1271337866783142, -0.007075215689837933, 1.2716878652572632, 0.6771966814994812, -0.026562808081507683, 0.027006344869732857, 0.6401473879814148, 0.37088847160339355, 0.5860227942466736, 0.39064469933509827, -0.5503940582275391, 0.009876970201730728, 0.7211923599243164, -0.21733909845352173, -0.16675446927547455, -0.23488382995128632, -0.20501203835010529, -0.31878504157066345, -0.7455418109893799, 0.696959912776947, -0.20738433301448822, 0.22220541536808014, -0.822553277015686, 0.20977583527565002, -0.5008941292762756, -0.08466316014528275, -0.5670470595359802, -0.1824347823858261, -0.07081201672554016, 0.34552380442619324, -0.00890961941331625, -0.36656883358955383, 0.32788074016571045, -0.0066068111918866634, 0.16156604886054993, 0.3528607487678528, -0.7488523125648499, 0.5914405584335327, -0.40299108624458313, -0.01434397604316473, -0.4510073959827423, -0.5339992046356201, -0.4427490830421448, -0.779611349105835, 0.4407636523246765, -0.4318172335624695, -0.2668217122554779, -0.18265150487422943, -0.21771593391895294, 0.22788076102733612, 0.8136297464370728, -0.35143759846687317, -0.8112385869026184, -0.8169194459915161, 0.2569182217121124, 0.8419679403305054, 0.004811623599380255, 0.5147265791893005, 0.3359232246875763, 0.154510498046875, -0.32381394505500793, -0.8731392025947571, -0.3193269968032837, 0.227260023355484, -0.5485416650772095, 0.041604768484830856, 0.5664438605308533, 0.2791343331336975, -1.0695631504058838, -0.4400207996368408, -0.24667638540267944, -0.054046452045440674, 0.030278323218226433, -0.6923850774765015, -0.4541330933570862, -1.056178092956543, 1.322730541229248, -0.4457639455795288, -0.04389354586601257, 0.6665870547294617, -0.23402269184589386, 0.03154592961072922, -0.8111168742179871, 3.8969340324401855, 0.7432147264480591, 0.12326010316610336, 0.0031176065094769, 0.9612365961074829, 0.3655316233634949, 0.20638172328472137, 0.09139077365398407, 0.9426984786987305, 0.20168878138065338, -0.3395830988883972, -0.05426875874400139, -0.1574820876121521, 0.524529755115509, 0.2927735447883606, 0.2539547383785248, -1.3963046073913574, -0.28681591153144836, -0.26252153515815735, -1.409886360168457, -0.3743049204349518, 0.5827295780181885, -0.2166108340024948, 0.24514999985694885, -0.286131352186203, 0.3449189066886902, 1.1182633638381958, 0.8376222848892212, 0.6820803284645081, -0.29300153255462646, -0.30143898725509644, -0.03939812257885933, 0.5883885622024536, -0.7397205829620361, 0.04658523574471474, 0.25392234325408936, 0.23602862656116486, -0.44071000814437866, -0.14260676503181458, 0.1235392838716507, 0.30840274691581726, 0.23975026607513428, -0.11565268039703369, -0.31381282210350037, -0.13138525187969208, 0.44964122772216797, -0.08297225832939148, -0.07742158323526382, 0.5163776278495789, -0.32959258556365967, 0.49022987484931946, -0.8086145520210266, -0.02472887746989727, -0.214689701795578, -0.8078176975250244, -0.339415043592453, -0.5814254879951477, -0.6705328226089478, 0.24072280526161194, -0.09403643757104874, 0.7904018759727478, -0.05340370163321495, 0.34963399171829224, -0.2145078033208847, -0.24782048165798187, 0.44289258122444153, 0.4112912118434906, -0.18761128187179565, -0.6716682314872742, 0.2689473330974579, 0.1104174330830574, 0.8497539162635803, -0.3968487083911896, -0.8064044713973999, 0.9816898107528687, 0.615210771560669, -0.1676829606294632, 0.7001110315322876, -0.7124494314193726, -1.030113935470581, 0.6377078890800476, 0.3774343729019165, 0.47330453991889954, -0.10839829593896866, 0.6724449396133423, 1.0045950412750244, -1.3054760694503784, -0.7671397924423218, -0.3190111517906189, 0.1260576695203781, -0.20998230576515198, -0.8929927945137024, 0.02779935672879219, 0.28183451294898987, 0.279155969619751 ]
{"Title": "Obstetrical safety indicators for preventing hospital harms: a scoping review protocol", "Authors": "Conway A, Reszel J, Walker MC, Grimshaw JM, Dunn SI", "Abstract": "Abstract Introduction Optimizing the safety of obstetric patient care is a primary concern for many hospitals. Identifying performance indicators that measure aspects of patient care processes related to preventable harms can present opportunities to improve health systems. In this paper, we present our protocol for a scoping review to identify performance indicators for obstetric safety. We aim to identify a comprehensive list of obstetric safety indicators which may help reduce the number of preventable patient harms, to summarize the data and to synthesize the results. Methods and analysis We will use the methodological framework described by Arksey and O\u2019 Malley and further expanded by Levac. We will search multiple electronic databases such as Medline, Embase, CINAHL and the Cochrane Library as well as websites from professional bodies and other organisations, using an iterative search strategy. We will include indicators that relate to preventable harms in the process of obstetric care. Two reviewers will independently screen titles and abstracts of search results to determine eligibility for inclusion. For records where eligibility is not clear, the reviewers will screen the full text version. If reviewers\u2019 decisions regarding eligibility differ, a third reviewer will review the full text record. Two reviewers will independently extract data from records that meet our inclusion criteria using a standardized data collection form. We will narratively describe quantitative data, such as the frequency with which indicators are identified, and conduct a thematic analysis of the qualitative data. We will compile a comprehensive list of patient safety indicators identified during our scoping review and organise them according to concepts that best suit the data such as the Donabedian model or the Hospital Harm Framework. We will discuss the implications of the indicators for future research, clinical practice and policy making. We will report the conduct of the review using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA ScR) Checklist. Ethics and Dissemination The sources of information included in this scoping review will be available to the public. Therefore, ethical review for this research is not warranted. We will disseminate our research results using multiple modes of delivery such as a peer-reviewed publication, conference presentations and stakeholder communications. Strengths and limitations of this study We will use systematic methods to conduct and report this scoping review based on established methods introduced by Arksey and O\u2019 Malley and further developed by Levac. We will report the conduct of the review using guidance from the PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR). We will limit the focus of this review to patient safety indicators from English language resources aimed at health system processes in developed countries. We will not assess the risk of bias or certainty of the evidence in the included records because this is a scoping review to identify potential obstetrical safety indicators. After the scoping review, we will present the identified indicators to key informants in a consensus process to create a shortlist that may not be suitable for inclusion in a future obstetrical safety dashboard for BORN (Better Outcomes Registry and Network) Ontario. BORN collects and safeguards data, and shares information to improve the delivery of maternal, neonatal and child healthcare across the province.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012153"}
10.1101/19008433
[ -0.015702420845627785, -0.2946273386478424, -0.1339515894651413, 0.6314681172370911, -0.4614761471748352, -0.18901167809963226, -0.07848498970270157, -0.429736852645874, 0.29894348978996277, 0.953981876373291, -0.5760437846183777, -0.28493523597717285, 0.30624306201934814, 0.4975912272930145, -0.5282738208770752, -0.19451868534088135, -0.769566535949707, -0.05697024613618851, 0.030702078714966774, -0.06358954310417175, 0.023881878703832626, 0.5660632848739624, -1.2632087469100952, -0.2415928989648819, -1.1583062410354614, 1.0136923789978027, -0.01638057827949524, -0.17192013561725616, 1.5472924709320068, 1.2345964908599854, -0.5625087022781372, -0.15572695434093475, 1.0872483253479004, -0.6354458332061768, 0.011523226276040077, -0.324771523475647, 0.7532557249069214, -0.1971886307001114, -0.6513275504112244, 0.001761631341651082, 0.556885838508606, -0.23520982265472412, 0.31954631209373474, -0.8133056163787842, -0.5520212054252625, -0.238511860370636, 0.48383185267448425, -0.11907760798931122, 0.1713070571422577, -0.3199067711830139, -0.42848849296569824, 0.6184654235839844, 0.07819917052984238, -0.7416560053825378, -0.8432571291923523, 0.11061681061983109, 0.11256897449493408, -0.3035396337509155, -0.8868768811225891, -0.32874998450279236, -0.07563037425279617, -0.44508102536201477, 0.8538725972175598, -0.7578598260879517, 0.13152654469013214, 0.36377325654029846, -0.004553306382149458, 0.12366751581430435, 0.5057457685470581, -0.5066102743148804, -0.5113422870635986, 0.4423818290233612, 0.10415749996900558, -0.8141427040100098, -0.024053778499364853, -0.07610537111759186, 0.24885298311710358, -0.5265277028083801, -0.44900208711624146, 0.07295133918523788, 0.29915574193000793, 0.4595739245414734, 0.15425866842269897, 0.012122048065066338, -0.24849875271320343, 0.24489513039588928, 1.0297527313232422, 0.11202750355005264, 0.28198307752609253, 0.4229525625705719, 0.33694368600845337, 0.38092032074928284, 0.18781597912311554, 0.05568560212850571, 0.32946062088012695, 1.0161972045898438, -0.18762853741645813, -0.1650138795375824, 0.4957217574119568, 0.3632449507713318, 0.4684499502182007, 1.1501058340072632, -0.5861296653747559, 0.8377017974853516, -0.3330114185810089, 0.6743356585502625, 0.5552040934562683, -1.0546070337295532, -0.13728034496307373, -0.8820486068725586, 0.22734259068965912, 0.1271454244852066, -0.5699190497398376, -0.6963098645210266, 0.428822785615921, 0.5416319966316223, 0.23206256330013275, 0.7574555277824402, -0.08371279388666153, 0.4223991930484772, -0.27758708596229553, 0.26440754532814026, 0.8481028079986572, -0.3952873945236206, -0.21723729372024536, -0.11798921227455139, 1.2419251203536987, 0.17879317700862885, -0.219972163438797, -0.7913339138031006, 0.2714959681034088, -0.6115601062774658, -0.1921057254076004, 0.5196635127067566, 0.18674400448799133, -0.3756605386734009, 0.4256220757961273, 0.44470855593681335, 0.7246566414833069, 0.4787607491016388, -0.5187397003173828, 0.35747069120407104, -0.22642458975315094, 1.5588874816894531, -0.4822717308998108, 0.6681903600692749, 0.03127705678343773, -0.659032940864563, -1.3188390731811523, 0.281566858291626, 0.18473698198795319, 0.47691839933395386, -0.21104027330875397, 0.38315942883491516, 0.3321610689163208, 0.08782283961772919, -0.18325400352478027, 0.15368761122226715, -0.24125228822231293, 0.23866653442382812, -0.6661040782928467, -0.1781841218471527, 0.2130107283592224, 0.2840999960899353, -0.5034555792808533, 0.6300141215324402, 0.2379387617111206, 0.07564543932676315, 0.1914096623659134, -0.5655967593193054, 0.5062376260757446, -0.1259000152349472, -0.7074358463287354, -0.22454988956451416, 0.031667809933423996, 1.1871308088302612, 1.1921600103378296, 0.012869425117969513, 0.013654662296175957, 0.39268752932548523, -0.23430456221103668, -0.02271847054362297, 0.10419277846813202, 0.03943808376789093, -0.08211961388587952, 1.0264474153518677, -0.2706325054168701, -0.24672280251979828, -0.38236236572265625, -0.6019945740699768, -0.11646532267332077, 0.6437509059906006, -1.1469032764434814, 0.7047695517539978, 0.06911001354455948, -0.9662845730781555, -0.5985408425331116, 0.3310396671295166, 0.7900500893592834, -0.47793567180633545, -0.59806227684021, -0.045449987053871155, -0.09465010464191437, -0.015411516651511192, -0.071378193795681, 0.6661513447761536, -0.1417970508337021, 0.04855022951960564, -0.7268995642662048, 0.32300931215286255, 0.3964911699295044, 0.4466276168823242, -0.6227366328239441, -0.23120303452014923, 0.8392298817634583, -0.21222485601902008, -0.2716047465801239, 0.1009218767285347, -0.4778173863887787, 0.06856460869312286, -0.5751845240592957, 0.11673765629529953, 0.4982326626777649, -0.19225053489208221, 0.024666637182235718, 0.4425349533557892, -0.1219339668750763, 0.5970973372459412, -0.4055356979370117, -0.13061237335205078, -0.060398172587156296, 0.6127244830131531, 0.02647325024008751, 0.7692770957946777, 0.9830440878868103, 0.4176549017429352, -0.07563718408346176, 0.1709514558315277, 0.17332753539085388, -0.08664188534021378, -0.1854230761528015, 0.008641604334115982, 0.11383061110973358, 0.35784831643104553, -0.011922494508326054, 0.5321832895278931, 0.3286243677139282, -0.5870200991630554, -0.10319245606660843, 0.2611134946346283, -0.7926216721534729, 1.2371612787246704, 0.596243143081665, 0.42772743105888367, -0.8129646182060242, -0.038571957498788834, 0.3653082251548767, 0.5408620834350586, -0.6941146850585938, -0.4986851215362549, 0.5173853039741516, 0.6135672926902771, -0.11129981279373169, 0.4588770270347595, 0.7355749011039734, 0.38240256905555725, -0.37768787145614624, -0.005476714577525854, 0.2529257535934448, -0.5245121717453003, -0.9943475723266602, -0.2707517445087433, -1.2876956462860107, -0.5676510334014893, -1.0442330837249756, 0.13703982532024384, 0.2366262972354889, -0.2652895450592041, 0.11846231669187546, -0.5610117316246033, -0.16633109748363495, -0.2927479147911072, 0.24393321573734283, -0.04383502155542374, 0.0918559730052948, -0.19905944168567657, -1.3021032810211182, 0.11791867017745972, 0.650022566318512, 0.1479741483926773, 0.24547338485717773, -0.03697402775287628, -0.8219998478889465, -0.9754794239997864, 0.7149335741996765, -0.9847244024276733, 0.5325491428375244, 0.5535019040107727, -0.5622976422309875, -0.17563961446285248, 0.08037818223237991, -0.03152061626315117, -0.1039867028594017, -0.1768929362297058, -0.03730902075767517, 0.3034796714782715, -0.401499480009079, 0.6568563580513, 0.6542783379554749, 0.5816001296043396, -0.46167847514152527, 0.4601995050907135, -0.1795644462108612, -0.5828809142112732, -1.0541813373565674, -0.3895971179008484, 0.4691150188446045, -0.8892331123352051, -0.20695629715919495, -0.2676716148853302, -0.9124026298522949, 0.8033558130264282, -0.023637985810637474, -0.08905978500843048, -0.6948047280311584, 0.23358199000358582, -0.6650757789611816, -1.6126556396484375, 0.13663232326507568, -0.17623689770698547, -0.5686402916908264, 0.03369350731372833, 0.19136953353881836, 0.06187990680336952, 0.5412452220916748, -0.17416775226593018, -0.1546924114227295, 0.2217959314584732, 0.24855317175388336, -0.1623733788728714, 0.22395817935466766, -0.6387695074081421, -0.1295950710773468, -0.022346466779708862, -0.5796528458595276, 0.42977750301361084, 0.10663879662752151, -0.04018126428127289, -0.531700849533081, -0.15028733015060425, -0.275007963180542, -0.028217080980539322, 0.7225351333618164, -0.12157449871301651, -0.08272282779216766, 0.8855383396148682, -0.0808849111199379, -0.855354368686676, 0.13499805331230164, 0.36140215396881104, 0.506172776222229, 0.30486735701560974, -0.7602294087409973, 0.01321575976908207, -0.7246952056884766, -0.9858178496360779, -0.1009305939078331, 0.3291684687137604, 0.8205280303955078, -0.21395888924598694, 0.5372424125671387, -0.6374810934066772, -0.26745739579200745, 0.27904948592185974, -0.45348140597343445, -0.7723371386528015, 1.29571533203125, 0.3954627513885498, 1.3423069715499878, -0.9366187453269958, -0.007938355207443237, 0.4835475981235504, 0.6933133602142334, 0.4009973704814911, -0.5552551746368408, 0.14193421602249146, -0.21785257756710052, 0.5936223268508911, 0.5283200144767761, -0.9283704161643982, 0.17804110050201416, -0.11444903165102005, -0.2328709065914154, 0.378475546836853, -0.3299276530742645, -0.27780866622924805, -0.2516406774520874, 0.24765688180923462, 0.6012158989906311, 0.06211497262120247, 0.49479618668556213, 0.2880097031593323, 0.7111908197402954, 0.26012277603149414, 0.9250565767288208, 0.8219138383865356, -0.8672532439231873, -0.4782310724258423, -0.22908462584018707, -0.504808783531189, -0.7406625747680664, -1.1171274185180664, 0.025873679667711258, 0.08193624019622803, 0.025956597179174423, 0.2013264149427414, -0.2861672341823578, -0.20347322523593903, -0.25403109192848206, -0.11991974711418152, 0.08926169574260712, -0.20559456944465637, -1.1245843172073364, 0.2804982662200928, 0.03962556645274162, -0.04259102791547775, -0.4975130259990692, -0.41021034121513367, 0.22220978140830994, 0.701793909072876, -0.6733657121658325, -0.39582833647727966, -0.3148048520088196, 0.1375795304775238, -0.46950995922088623, 0.18579860031604767, 0.5123878717422485, -0.41437339782714844, 0.7300583124160767, -0.9372884631156921, -0.16899944841861725, -0.3844800889492035, -0.20535998046398163, -0.41017845273017883, 0.12144595384597778, -0.036385923624038696, 1.5784854888916016, 0.2720339000225067, -0.04874287545681, 0.19000425934791565, -0.2999533712863922, -0.8343276977539062, 0.5161311626434326, -0.6118456125259399, -0.23506665229797363, -0.15927337110042572, -0.18677924573421478, -0.08022867143154144, -0.36720010638237, -0.47531431913375854, 0.0269449595361948, -0.23961320519447327, 0.16808873414993286, -0.005555311217904091, -0.3033294677734375, 1.1110358238220215, 0.24517738819122314, -0.3191660940647125, 1.0280063152313232, -0.2582840621471405, -0.7418509721755981, 0.6676695942878723, -0.5053110718727112, -0.8161377906799316, 0.5661142468452454, 0.002178688533604145, -0.09869173169136047, 0.2219676822423935, -0.607063353061676, -0.7213525772094727, -0.2674296498298645, 0.6200291514396667, 0.1906690001487732, -0.08864723145961761, 0.36971646547317505, -0.37026217579841614, -0.6917449235916138, 0.6324580311775208, -0.8114656209945679, 0.6489014029502869, -0.23942488431930542, -0.7075034379959106, -0.3775397539138794, -0.016607312485575676, -1.0244321823120117, -0.19203835725784302, 0.14913180470466614, -0.38706281781196594, 0.013484939001500607, 0.6372485756874084, 0.26149457693099976, -0.25646698474884033, -0.920977771282196, -0.009330583736300468, 0.6684533357620239, -0.8870449662208557, -0.2930164933204651, 0.40076497197151184, -0.35684964060783386, 0.04308425262570381, -0.5308287739753723, -0.05649401247501373, -0.29234346747398376, -0.7433611750602722, -0.07952342927455902, 0.21110092103481293, 0.9266276359558105, 0.24702811241149902, -0.8530049920082092, 0.9214736819267273, 0.2220817506313324, -0.8184187412261963, -1.0586222410202026, 0.5999741554260254, -0.09742286801338196, 0.31971243023872375, -0.21789796650409698, -0.34977617859840393, 0.18674705922603607, -1.122985601425171, 0.24338991940021515, -0.27591249346733093, 0.12210390716791153, -0.024450011551380157, -0.5337367057800293, 0.17090751230716705, 0.033393844962120056, 0.35232895612716675, 0.20305094122886658, -0.7703515887260437, -0.10606657713651657, 0.3043854832649231, -0.10199929028749466, -0.10945892333984375, -0.13920624554157257, -0.3365306854248047, 0.3554389476776123, 0.5425276160240173, 0.14974632859230042, -0.5537775158882141, -0.10802450031042099, 0.8055168986320496, 0.4086383581161499, 0.6382502913475037, -0.7978633642196655, -0.5633506178855896, 0.08109776675701141, 0.3148428797721863, 0.036891065537929535, -0.3397800922393799, -0.726717472076416, 0.6358915567398071, -0.5770642757415771, 0.18882043659687042, -0.003861084347590804, -0.4067167341709137, -0.14973659813404083, -0.1349117010831833, 0.9478787779808044, -0.24606561660766602, 0.32918792963027954, -0.05241550877690315, -0.5818049907684326, 0.521040141582489, -0.07491248100996017, -0.9290822744369507, -0.6622704863548279, 0.13855750858783722, -0.8336754441261292, -0.31645482778549194, 0.15753839910030365, -0.0837300717830658, 0.5223161578178406, -0.2773004174232483, -0.19414019584655762, -0.3085078299045563, 0.8485627770423889, 0.6577069759368896, -0.8026179671287537, -0.6338664293289185, 0.34986522793769836, -0.17035913467407227, 0.04113181307911873, 0.1312210112810135, 0.04853185638785362, -0.4555882215499878, 0.2317616194486618, -0.31141436100006104, -0.33372700214385986, -0.24449726939201355, 0.318011075258255, 0.03370886668562889, 0.40724900364875793, -0.3138737976551056, 0.03890741989016533, 0.3034348785877228, -0.5863426327705383, -0.29517123103141785, 0.5413839221000671, -0.23915863037109375, -0.11148577183485031, 0.8144223690032959, 0.3292354643344879, -0.29489144682884216, 0.39001938700675964, -0.0875670462846756, 0.47877389192581177, -0.09864195436239243, 0.14847254753112793, 0.26774996519088745, -0.980725109577179, 0.5199771523475647, 1.00270414352417, -0.8143860697746277, -0.722095787525177, 0.3002301752567291, -0.39357566833496094, -0.02491362951695919, -0.37401703000068665, -0.5494412779808044, 0.5528454184532166, -0.5983978509902954, 0.5019051432609558, -0.1940382719039917, -0.4141024053096771, -0.052638743072748184, -0.7238599061965942, 0.6870571970939636, -0.6543675661087036, 0.036671508103609085, 0.9364026784896851, -0.4909844696521759, 0.5975888967514038, -0.5501627922058105, -0.7143748998641968, 0.08044587075710297, -0.18722200393676758, 0.27057021856307983, -0.3408518433570862, 0.12317918986082077, 0.6660060286521912, 0.4762474596500397, 0.58380526304245, -0.011238130740821362, -0.7486228346824646, 1.372459053993225, 0.6389349699020386, -0.7628462910652161, -0.8746674656867981, 1.1784369945526123, 0.2517586648464203, -0.2926681637763977, -0.5814400315284729, -0.011142903007566929, 0.4008352756500244, 0.49202877283096313, 0.6795859336853027, -0.40139007568359375, -0.8554951548576355, -0.5546603798866272, -0.30218109488487244, -0.3184395730495453, -0.5549924373626709, -0.0090862438082695, 0.14032088220119476, -0.2617606222629547, -0.040124859660863876, -0.3132987916469574, 0.7767553329467773, -0.7171775698661804, -0.6103977560997009, -0.3277832567691803, 0.4435347318649292, -0.7425979971885681, -0.8257561922073364, -0.6256253719329834, 0.23307672142982483, 0.07600490003824234, 1.2566118240356445, -1.1385880708694458, -0.7757878303527832, 0.7014479637145996, 0.2421235889196396, -0.22268177568912506, 0.8316603899002075, -0.9143640995025635, -0.11536005884408951, 0.039293255656957626, 0.1529502123594284, -0.4415046274662018, 0.3278791606426239, 0.5573439002037048, -0.5138635039329529, 0.815401554107666, 0.2573402523994446, 0.2423998862504959, -0.2224489003419876, 0.0003073461994063109, -0.3134514391422272, -1.3226516246795654, -0.15756630897521973, -0.5323926210403442, 0.7525617480278015, -0.8868916034698486, -0.14153024554252625, -0.0595267154276371, -0.410841166973114, 0.512729287147522, 0.2505410611629486, 0.2678897976875305, 0.17410585284233093, -0.2743631899356842, 0.33330753445625305, 0.32094234228134155, 0.6145266890525818, 0.33589205145835876, 0.42458558082580566, 0.5993543863296509, 0.3214418888092041, -0.27853578329086304, -1.2645561695098877, 0.557466447353363, 0.39499956369400024, 0.6084907650947571, 0.10710221529006958, -0.5985644459724426, 0.09748608618974686, 0.49629420042037964, -0.6947195529937744, 0.34283745288848877, 0.5026316046714783, 0.31164032220840454, 0.8700219392776489, 0.08505690842866898, 0.1847863346338272, -0.31925705075263977, -1.242633581161499, -0.8190025091171265, -0.5252287983894348, 0.48873937129974365, -0.07751878350973129, -0.11787360161542892, 0.14497719705104828, -0.3359302878379822, 0.17814978957176208, 0.17675034701824188, 0.411587655544281, 0.36285850405693054, 1.1344151496887207, -0.17441034317016602, 0.6374961733818054, -0.16128939390182495, -0.4021996557712555, 0.19349795579910278, 0.46327027678489685, -0.3154512941837311, -0.4487607181072235, 0.6518165469169617, 0.5614201426506042, 0.6378787755966187, -0.02815818227827549, -0.8584177494049072, 0.13356104493141174, 0.48967698216438293, -0.4610690474510193, 0.18192806839942932, 0.06909757107496262, -1.020582914352417, 0.3342759609222412, -0.0052061243914067745, 1.3278799057006836, -0.11636421084403992, 0.1795254647731781, 0.609432578086853, -0.7924342155456543, -0.368106871843338, -0.16728977859020233, 0.4599664807319641, -1.149221658706665, 0.29632568359375, -0.22940188646316528, 0.15162158012390137, -0.2204630970954895, -0.5108197331428528, 0.9999403953552246, 0.6781578063964844, 0.023925211280584335, 0.18601858615875244, -0.6344053745269775, -0.08452039957046509, 1.0513191223144531, 0.14304876327514648, 0.29652491211891174, 0.6159922480583191, 0.21697817742824554, 0.44747278094291687, 0.21708151698112488, -0.6206902861595154, 0.029595186933875084, -0.4402349293231964, -0.09045395255088806, 0.5723175406455994, 0.17378979921340942, 0.5322572588920593, 0.31960538029670715, -0.3528299331665039, 0.438272625207901, -0.4578000605106354, -0.9597116112709045, -0.33217087388038635, -0.26622501015663147, 0.7301620841026306, -0.19690990447998047, 0.14782439172267914, -0.39322391152381897, 0.8310030102729797, 0.6590953469276428, -0.3319145441055298, 0.11230684816837311, -0.010035732761025429, -0.5367076396942139, -0.3059941530227661, 0.017626719549298286, -0.44627469778060913, 0.29657530784606934, 0.5283277034759521, -0.3303893506526947, -0.009937799535691738, 0.6476638317108154, 0.10075270384550095, -0.7691630125045776, 0.5808379650115967, -0.2112102508544922, -0.05960071459412575, 0.512432873249054, -0.1741391122341156, -0.21190346777439117, 0.23880809545516968, 0.5165110230445862, -0.21779698133468628, -0.04003189876675606, 0.3429676294326782, 0.5903757214546204, 0.3831201195716858, 1.071002721786499, 0.3003667891025543, -0.33458730578422546, 0.11966267228126526, 0.36967766284942627, -0.403054803609848, 0.36634010076522827, 0.09214134514331818, -0.13949479162693024, 0.2970980107784271, -0.4681345224380493, 0.1415134072303772, 0.0997977927327156, 0.32053571939468384, -0.548721194267273, 0.2816731929779053, -0.24903540313243866, -0.5143224000930786, -0.16078896820545197, 0.19288764894008636, -0.4058898985385895, 0.6002858281135559, 0.14745575189590454, -0.3719981908798218, 0.36000072956085205, -0.2729860842227936, -0.1485196202993393, -0.547185480594635, -0.7375549077987671, 0.34847790002822876, -0.15352074801921844, 0.06437341868877411, -0.22276268899440765, 0.004580960609018803, -0.4269312918186188, -0.6736873984336853, -0.38362252712249756, -0.20264549553394318, 0.06451702117919922, -0.2979702651500702, -0.05531080439686775, 0.6214593648910522, 0.5797299146652222, -0.38015276193618774, 0.285697340965271, 0.20495113730430603, 0.6184674501419067, 0.9042431116104126, -0.20150524377822876, 0.6198071837425232, 0.5705158710479736, -0.022033723071217537, 0.10896455496549606, 0.011489913798868656, -0.7011206746101379, -0.04113670811057091, -0.40541762113571167, 0.0036190494429320097, -0.48042914271354675, -0.3816346824169159, -0.6868236064910889, 0.5635977387428284, 0.3148213326931, -0.5310073494911194, 0.17276935279369354, -0.06080682948231697, -0.39014410972595215, -0.644012987613678, 1.2504419088363647, -0.7196099162101746, 0.5520641803741455, -0.22708162665367126, -0.21939995884895325, 0.2896728217601776, -0.8893096446990967, 4.133394241333008, 0.3217419981956482, 0.15446209907531738, 0.31874707341194153, 0.7798979878425598, 0.014867420308291912, 0.4375404715538025, -0.1336798518896103, 0.43019428849220276, -0.4692527651786804, -0.1546839028596878, -0.022578928619623184, -0.403757244348526, 0.4115474820137024, -0.5666103959083557, 0.029974130913615227, -0.6759048700332642, 0.15653392672538757, 0.21314465999603271, -1.2252585887908936, -0.5232340693473816, 0.44746145606040955, -0.8146762847900391, 0.2021285742521286, 0.12640707194805145, -0.36759328842163086, 0.47083979845046997, 0.650195300579071, 0.0951327309012413, -0.3420822024345398, 0.24999894201755524, -0.3393020033836365, -0.34317049384117126, -0.4902520179748535, -0.29802268743515015, -0.10736342519521713, 0.1962171494960785, -0.44741129875183105, -0.02225414849817753, -0.038485150784254074, 1.1830625534057617, 0.6418145298957825, -0.11658962815999985, -0.012549003586173058, -0.003907138016074896, 0.14455997943878174, -0.24570752680301666, 0.01797902025282383, 0.7184199690818787, -0.6152259707450867, 0.860547661781311, -0.9283745288848877, 0.5457992553710938, -0.1727127730846405, -0.33929306268692017, -0.49407637119293213, -0.05291173234581947, -1.0456771850585938, 0.5928231477737427, 0.09186645597219467, 0.6213030219078064, 0.04974089935421944, -0.06911328434944153, -0.11650552600622177, -0.33282700181007385, 0.061250824481248856, 0.8860197067260742, -0.03685013949871063, -0.1248391717672348, 0.006601673550903797, 0.4307541251182556, -0.10937779396772385, -0.330613911151886, 0.06669002771377563, 0.5688798427581787, 0.16524763405323029, -0.39560019969940186, 1.1997902393341064, -0.4774623215198517, -0.8915253281593323, 0.32838189601898193, 0.3634149730205536, 1.1893032789230347, 0.10510481894016266, 0.5097953081130981, 0.6346442103385925, -0.7196768522262573, 0.014111857861280441, -0.777847945690155, 0.45724231004714966, 0.7293106913566589, -0.231606587767601, 0.007460926193743944, -0.005609754007309675, 0.13514217734336853 ]
{"Title": "A target product profile for electronic clinical decision support algorithms combined with point-of-care diagnostic test results to support evidence-based decisions during patient consultations by health workers", "Authors": "Pell\u00e9 Karell G., Rambaud-Althaus Clotilde, D\u2019Acremont Val\u00e9rie, Moran Gretchen, Sampath Rangarajan, Katz Zach, Moussy Francis, Mehl Garrett L., Dittrich Sabine", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Health workers in low-resource settings often lack the support and tools to follow evidence-based clinical recommendations for diagnosing, treating and managing sick patients. Digital technologies, by combining patient health information and point of care diagnostics with evidence-based clinical protocols, can help improve the quality of care, the rational use of resources (humans, diagnostics and medicines) and save patient lives. The development of a target product profile for electronic clinical decision support algorithms (CDSAs) aimed at guiding preventive or curative consultations, and that integrate diagnostic test results will help align developer and implementer processes and specifications with the needs of end-users, in terms of quality, safety, performance and operational functionality. To identify characteristics for a CDSA, experts from academia, research institutions, and industry as well as policy makers with expertise in diagnostic and CDSA development, and implementation in LMICs were convened. Experts discussed the critical characteristics of a draft TPP which was revised and finalised through a Delphi process to facilitate consensus building. Experts were in overwhelming agreement that, given that CDSAs provide patients\u2019 management recommendations, the underlying clinical algorithms should be available in human readable format and evidence-based. Whenever possible, the algorithm output should take into account pre-test disease probabilities, diagnostic likelihood ratios of clinical or laboratory predictors and disease probability thresholds to test and to treat. Validation processes should at a minimum ensure the CDSA are implementing faithfully the evidence-based algorithm they are based on (internal validation through clinical association and analytical validation). Additionally, clinical validation, bringing practice evidence about the impact of the CDSA use on health outcomes, was recognized as a good to have. The CDSAs should be designed to fit within clinic workflows, connectivity challenges and high volume settings. Data collected through the tool should conform to local patient privacy regulations and international data standards.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008433"}
10.1101/19010934
[ -0.1151086762547493, 0.30893775820732117, 0.15290330350399017, -0.2293895184993744, -0.23580124974250793, 0.3084638714790344, -0.2720473110675812, -0.05372313782572746, 0.2740035653114319, 0.8749116659164429, -0.046620406210422516, -0.10150153189897537, -0.5270747542381287, 0.5023938417434692, -0.737636387348175, -1.1325231790542603, 0.252593457698822, -0.08044423162937164, -0.41672390699386597, 0.17091749608516693, -0.6783215999603271, 0.27522534132003784, -0.7585235834121704, 0.0838126614689827, -0.376168429851532, 0.5348843336105347, -0.40690189599990845, 0.23341593146324158, 1.0088894367218018, 0.9467121362686157, 0.19716157019138336, -0.3501245975494385, 0.6978769302368164, -1.2762941122055054, -0.06137639656662941, -0.1140824481844902, 0.5013487339019775, 0.05419880896806717, -0.20724733173847198, -0.2317887544631958, -0.033160608261823654, 0.22896690666675568, 0.7241684198379517, -0.5152996182441711, -0.44010189175605774, 0.12683625519275665, -0.6495347023010254, 0.5088261961936951, -0.45204195380210876, 0.2947427034378052, -0.033140283077955246, 0.4313710629940033, -0.03456909954547882, 0.19348232448101044, -0.4477951228618622, -0.04337082430720329, -0.0484885573387146, -0.42307791113853455, -0.23181378841400146, 0.298923134803772, 0.47887536883354187, -0.3508298993110657, 0.14932385087013245, -1.155798316001892, 0.21930266916751862, 0.680192232131958, -0.39259621500968933, -0.4678608179092407, 0.6247488260269165, -0.8429650664329529, -0.6094844937324524, -0.031955912709236145, -0.061677828431129456, -0.29911622405052185, -0.602719247341156, 0.05706091970205307, 1.1226946115493774, -0.45206281542778015, -0.38433101773262024, 0.8540278673171997, 0.33054327964782715, 0.23670057952404022, 0.4664474129676819, 0.352897584438324, -0.7941445708274841, 0.4931182265281677, -0.33339595794677734, -0.19078053534030914, 0.6918098330497742, -0.02387235313653946, 0.02833324484527111, 1.239893913269043, -0.10064048320055008, 0.3505605459213257, 0.29851800203323364, 0.3540910482406616, -0.28600481152534485, -0.039850059896707535, 0.03168898820877075, -0.3563508987426758, 0.1539633572101593, 0.697050929069519, -0.32734033465385437, 1.2979059219360352, -0.10528546571731567, 0.6587931513786316, 0.779684841632843, -0.09438610821962357, -0.8541610240936279, -1.5499167442321777, -0.495792955160141, 0.38377436995506287, -0.5367113351821899, -0.20080125331878662, -0.1333816945552826, 1.067107081413269, -0.34091800451278687, 0.6051637530326843, -0.3492606282234192, -0.20440131425857544, -0.00037611511652357876, -0.31025922298431396, 1.3187036514282227, -0.32598787546157837, -1.0102726221084595, -0.331001877784729, -0.012343964539468288, -0.14814649522304535, -0.6003939509391785, 0.32528015971183777, -0.2585161328315735, -0.7941982746124268, -0.033297520130872726, -0.037173766642808914, -0.6087619066238403, -0.2292613685131073, -0.014919907785952091, 0.2175639420747757, 0.7729366421699524, -0.23135994374752045, 0.06627599149942398, 0.93608158826828, -0.37032389640808105, 1.1380789279937744, -0.12081430852413177, 0.7086037993431091, -0.08892736583948135, -0.9767819046974182, -0.15764230489730835, 0.4298432469367981, 0.42076534032821655, 0.23517213761806488, -0.3337346613407135, 0.07374013215303421, 0.3926052749156952, 0.5666919946670532, -0.2609466016292572, 0.28882482647895813, -0.16448475420475006, 0.17452365159988403, -0.5208691358566284, 0.4080374538898468, 0.33283567428588867, -0.10587094724178314, -0.2523821294307709, 0.8747467398643494, 0.3587923049926758, 0.15077586472034454, -0.11398450285196304, -0.4867926239967346, 0.6031457781791687, -0.6555704474449158, 0.0365651436150074, 0.5722782611846924, 0.5182895064353943, 0.3608592450618744, 1.011808156967163, 0.6895398497581482, -0.023074256256222725, 0.5163866877555847, -0.139588862657547, 0.08014804869890213, 0.22950530052185059, 1.0463294982910156, 0.7643530368804932, 0.21870650351047516, -0.484280526638031, -0.6721802949905396, -0.2277095764875412, -0.40812546014785767, -0.1633400321006775, 0.6279146075248718, -0.9699243307113647, -0.17335136234760284, -0.33593031764030457, -0.5523360967636108, -0.6440533399581909, -0.6721239686012268, 0.2525518834590912, -0.8921054005622864, -0.44944626092910767, 0.8099331855773926, -0.4393208920955658, 0.3878090977668762, -0.8734229207038879, 1.168828010559082, 0.06368891894817352, 0.4741499722003937, -1.1631379127502441, 0.581074595451355, 1.0744532346725464, -0.3772226870059967, -0.1366620808839798, 0.05370388180017471, -0.46675294637680054, -0.5342674851417542, 0.0859346017241478, -0.2327219694852829, -0.4390959143638611, 0.32342004776000977, -0.6469020247459412, -0.6732479929924011, 0.644035816192627, 0.11466176807880402, 0.8242948055267334, 0.7189861536026001, 0.17643140256404877, 0.4846959710121155, -0.10344104468822479, -0.3007553815841675, -0.3622148633003235, 0.3210298717021942, -0.5623986124992371, 0.9299894571304321, 0.8328872919082642, 0.47998055815696716, 0.075049489736557, -0.0587657131254673, 0.12596242129802704, 0.17925378680229187, 0.35156017541885376, 0.5547142028808594, 0.5511167049407959, 0.32518792152404785, -0.063996821641922, 1.1873561143875122, -0.10185414552688599, -0.17738577723503113, -0.7255631685256958, 0.25470495223999023, -0.15619629621505737, 0.32009223103523254, 0.8573780655860901, 0.34722229838371277, -0.5242075324058533, -0.3574461042881012, 0.9651289582252502, 0.6170251965522766, -0.2582678198814392, -0.3166271448135376, -0.5547564029693604, 0.4422610402107239, -0.13731688261032104, 0.6163244843482971, 1.089991569519043, 0.6935910582542419, -0.19551388919353485, 0.20181281864643097, -0.055344387888908386, -0.710839033126831, -1.563822865486145, -0.39150965213775635, -0.4891270399093628, -0.9398841857910156, -0.7340031862258911, -0.9016250967979431, 0.5365625619888306, -0.2561713457107544, 0.9982645511627197, -0.2061404585838318, -0.5993003249168396, -0.5155994296073914, -0.2486022561788559, 0.3687340319156647, 0.26663994789123535, 0.2850792706012726, -1.40940260887146, -0.18003912270069122, 0.114369697868824, 0.3169013261795044, -0.703228235244751, -0.04478028044104576, -0.2232872098684311, -0.5539477467536926, 0.48740068078041077, -0.01489260047674179, 0.08702870458364487, -0.17217840254306793, -0.47744521498680115, -0.2637054920196533, 0.040425725281238556, 0.5095956325531006, 0.49063819646835327, -0.18352378904819489, -0.35982590913772583, 0.8662200570106506, 0.19773301482200623, 0.38483163714408875, 0.6393566131591797, 0.17145858705043793, -0.22089581191539764, 0.5107724070549011, -0.5512822866439819, 0.7732967138290405, -0.65339595079422, 0.2817096412181854, 0.44462570548057556, -0.5259280204772949, 0.19136019051074982, -0.27110227942466736, -0.5530878305435181, 0.21732358634471893, -0.4410705268383026, -0.36068180203437805, -0.28300559520721436, 0.6647789478302002, -0.12110418826341629, -0.9228192567825317, 0.31480976939201355, -0.5457608699798584, -0.8468143939971924, 0.09200899302959442, 0.48175960779190063, 0.2850934863090515, -0.06506071984767914, 0.7382459044456482, -0.8892268538475037, 0.06464651972055435, -0.02931852638721466, -0.10485614836215973, 0.48510265350341797, -0.837710440158844, -0.7045615315437317, 0.26060983538627625, 0.21093466877937317, -0.1835302859544754, 0.29652488231658936, -0.2853003442287445, -0.8300649523735046, 0.33668866753578186, -0.7801764607429504, -0.05505964159965515, 0.9122413396835327, 0.1659095734357834, 0.014019195921719074, 0.26426124572753906, 0.0971333459019661, -0.03324083983898163, 0.21362505853176117, 0.1984177827835083, 0.0020196137484163046, 0.16443146765232086, -0.08371731638908386, -0.17337863147258759, -0.33717626333236694, -0.7363268136978149, -0.3351157009601593, 0.791750967502594, 0.7261214852333069, -0.1293567717075348, 1.0992364883422852, -0.08178535103797913, -0.7640945911407471, 0.053370218724012375, -0.5970662832260132, -0.4887329339981079, 0.2943139970302582, 1.1227941513061523, 1.4595298767089844, -1.5722248554229736, 0.4662426710128784, 0.27978333830833435, 0.871575117111206, 0.1268036663532257, 0.27688270807266235, 0.025999225676059723, -0.4990200400352478, -0.6235278248786926, 0.14604419469833374, -0.25038307905197144, -0.2297525256872177, 0.19995084404945374, 0.3881760835647583, 0.8882447481155396, -0.2479395568370819, -0.2404811978340149, -0.16564014554023743, 0.5763756632804871, 0.6593878865242004, 0.09791046380996704, 0.07222326099872589, -0.08456515520811081, 0.9993082284927368, 0.31170853972435, 0.5026176571846008, -0.07999220490455627, 0.036158546805381775, -0.12582959234714508, -0.2436947524547577, -0.36845284700393677, -0.0965912938117981, -0.48270976543426514, -0.08850637078285217, 0.08343915641307831, 0.6371604204177856, -0.10256248712539673, 0.19019360840320587, 0.31490960717201233, -0.21398094296455383, -0.5315269231796265, 0.37176549434661865, -0.04754132032394409, -0.5698593258857727, 0.15829303860664368, 1.1784312725067139, -0.7961658835411072, 0.27524083852767944, -0.16637615859508514, 0.35699477791786194, 0.7775346636772156, 0.35905519127845764, -0.2583690285682678, -0.09158019721508026, 0.17832224071025848, 0.12480170279741287, 0.08048191666603088, 0.887388288974762, -0.26299163699150085, 0.13879987597465515, -0.0585152767598629, -0.12780237197875977, -0.11217251420021057, -0.17325903475284576, -1.0663317441940308, 0.06489710509777069, 0.23591749370098114, 1.4148262739181519, 0.06513972580432892, -0.22882616519927979, -0.5235384106636047, 0.47792795300483704, -1.4236668348312378, 0.2443036586046219, -0.6147358417510986, -0.8030104041099548, -0.3803452253341675, 0.10655344277620316, 0.24192094802856445, 0.5123324990272522, -0.4656500220298767, -0.9288259744644165, -0.5438299179077148, 0.2952277660369873, -0.4332682192325592, -0.6593993306159973, 0.8567060828208923, -0.431086927652359, 0.36106061935424805, 0.5509313941001892, -0.15807746350765228, -0.1022837907075882, 0.1026032418012619, -0.20956386625766754, -1.1841785907745361, 0.3844277262687683, -0.2942362427711487, -0.15661239624023438, 0.7116685509681702, -0.45270252227783203, 0.1683325618505478, -0.4241589307785034, -0.040840502828359604, -0.048132188618183136, -0.46559739112854004, 0.02127797156572342, -0.5613727569580078, -0.5223209261894226, -0.22928109765052795, -1.2290815114974976, 0.3544852137565613, 0.12278502434492111, -0.14029312133789062, -0.3285273015499115, 0.8696263432502747, -0.4969467520713806, 0.27782997488975525, -0.45037034153938293, -0.38436275720596313, -0.12575305998325348, 0.018502332270145416, 1.2560111284255981, -0.5756425857543945, -0.7446123361587524, 0.7791654467582703, -0.1760508269071579, -0.7861753702163696, -0.6762586832046509, 0.2613944411277771, -0.4056021571159363, -0.32799169421195984, -0.17343515157699585, 0.6049303412437439, -0.42285898327827454, -0.7317032217979431, 0.4396914541721344, 0.2748298943042755, -0.25454097986221313, -0.14360779523849487, -0.4408990740776062, 0.1447400003671646, 0.15338288247585297, -0.38480374217033386, -1.0552376508712769, 0.6836062073707581, 0.7758893966674805, -0.19640271365642548, 0.2548351287841797, -0.867631733417511, 0.08845304697751999, 0.2187996208667755, 0.49584051966667175, -0.5364092588424683, 0.8339765071868896, -0.5984330177307129, -0.26088058948516846, -0.22819755971431732, 0.3737645745277405, 0.4375089704990387, 0.2848758399486542, -0.44901707768440247, -0.75323086977005, 0.01946716196835041, -0.24031555652618408, -0.7101352214813232, -0.6205012202262878, -0.7620176076889038, -0.03916831687092781, 0.7814569473266602, -0.5819646120071411, -0.6346479654312134, -0.3103478252887726, 0.5343284606933594, 0.7161833047866821, 0.36722123622894287, -0.022830020636320114, -1.1453237533569336, 0.22362269461154938, 0.6283932328224182, -0.30118662118911743, 0.5822608470916748, -1.1327388286590576, 0.23018944263458252, 0.24093131721019745, 0.24268043041229248, -0.06480206549167633, -0.2952817976474762, 0.3720574378967285, 0.4396035671234131, 0.5813924074172974, -0.01722445897758007, 0.19040749967098236, -0.1108117625117302, 0.19615599513053894, 0.2549433708190918, 0.15452323853969574, -0.3063655197620392, -0.6705470085144043, -0.2644749581813812, -1.054587721824646, 0.46869662404060364, -0.4589864909648895, 0.07814602553844452, 0.9928376078605652, 0.28170451521873474, -0.36541980504989624, -0.07099951803684235, 0.621274471282959, 0.9620535373687744, -0.4302409291267395, -0.2651342451572418, -0.3135797679424286, 0.14164385199546814, 0.23828372359275818, -0.22774939239025116, -0.21169377863407135, 0.10384564101696014, -0.4245060682296753, -0.06046132370829582, -0.35036444664001465, -1.471687912940979, -0.45807188749313354, 0.27802395820617676, 0.5231141448020935, -0.19579075276851654, 0.21779830753803253, 0.3140563368797302, -0.6588355302810669, -0.9285963773727417, 0.6079822778701782, -0.09365230053663254, 0.1941939741373062, 1.157995581626892, -0.027559462934732437, -0.6980851292610168, -0.01892937533557415, -0.5571362972259521, 0.2052343487739563, 0.208229199051857, 0.8149060010910034, 0.6643785238265991, -0.868202805519104, 0.31982606649398804, 0.5125817656517029, -0.2646341621875763, -0.7697404026985168, -0.1456167846918106, -0.4531450569629669, 0.3762907385826111, 0.3778022825717926, -0.5393672585487366, 0.3059990406036377, -0.6703565120697021, -0.0006743613630533218, -0.030507776886224747, 0.3035830557346344, 0.23764385282993317, -0.03415318951010704, 0.6287220120429993, -0.5025476813316345, -0.3818979561328888, 0.31060555577278137, -0.3714732825756073, 0.16842426359653473, -0.13856162130832672, -0.5545454621315002, 0.3366803526878357, -0.13660527765750885, 0.2510426640510559, 0.2522115707397461, 0.48878422379493713, 0.18809743225574493, 0.8304263353347778, 0.22915592789649963, 0.22118140757083893, -0.9102211594581604, 0.9732725620269775, 0.18337379395961761, -0.7795497179031372, -0.3726915419101715, 0.6801491975784302, -0.41564249992370605, 0.2555232346057892, -0.8653073310852051, 0.041690558195114136, 0.4666023552417755, 0.4020492732524872, 0.6907862424850464, -0.6895765066146851, -1.038101077079773, -0.8066226243972778, -0.27925047278404236, -0.6338145136833191, -0.8377506136894226, -0.36231473088264465, 0.3235412836074829, -0.5136985778808594, -0.1519804447889328, -0.5183261036872864, 0.38572657108306885, -0.47031062841415405, -0.07929126918315887, -0.8017956614494324, -0.008508258499205112, -0.42460140585899353, -1.0044842958450317, -0.5724281072616577, -0.47999677062034607, 0.09576302766799927, 0.804639458656311, -0.19969940185546875, -0.26353713870048523, -0.2521280348300934, -0.06581230461597443, 0.1874324530363083, 0.852764904499054, -0.35493704676628113, -0.524914562702179, -0.5407052040100098, 0.6670196652412415, 0.14575330913066864, 0.5203554630279541, 0.9981684684753418, -0.8392187356948853, 1.0792816877365112, 0.7039116621017456, -0.05372077226638794, -0.8382401466369629, -0.41870784759521484, -0.463771253824234, -0.5207595825195312, -0.2741971015930176, -0.3658895194530487, 0.09383749216794968, -1.2659250497817993, -0.7969202399253845, 0.20283709466457367, -0.4926607608795166, 0.5070440173149109, 0.4508064389228821, 0.23007774353027344, 0.6256389021873474, -0.11051078140735626, 0.324911892414093, -0.47026658058166504, 0.9236745834350586, 0.5769612789154053, 0.45617979764938354, 0.892943799495697, -0.46908965706825256, -0.3941686749458313, -0.5079763531684875, 1.0275071859359741, 0.6827081441879272, -0.4944804906845093, 0.20974408090114594, 0.09094538539648056, 0.16674120724201202, -0.12162066251039505, -0.44296589493751526, -0.18791794776916504, -0.09282620251178741, 0.01989012584090233, 0.996717631816864, 0.3675755560398102, -0.2362440973520279, -0.20217393338680267, -0.4306374192237854, -1.619856595993042, -0.31808990240097046, 0.2695353031158447, -0.5460028648376465, -0.10472126305103302, -0.8075977563858032, -0.7518016695976257, 0.6699451208114624, 0.059077005833387375, 0.5386362075805664, 0.1259964406490326, 0.601713240146637, 0.07116960734128952, 0.16212794184684753, -0.17172491550445557, 0.5562959909439087, -0.3300553560256958, -0.22456254065036774, -0.2347480058670044, -0.9561437368392944, -0.2530061602592468, 0.4856155812740326, 0.0928414836525917, -0.1461445540189743, 0.029385989531874657, 0.611057698726654, 0.07464814931154251, 0.5017217397689819, -0.20299343764781952, -0.07889224588871002, -0.4984075725078583, 0.5879865884780884, -0.5883158445358276, -0.08894281834363937, -0.0651637390255928, 0.2744481861591339, -0.08869118988513947, -0.15839098393917084, -0.2699339687824249, -0.43265217542648315, 0.5378654599189758, -0.46407777070999146, 1.1960800886154175, 0.3429616391658783, 0.461216002702713, -0.18700534105300903, -0.4720830023288727, 0.5411666035652161, 0.21923699975013733, 0.4370739758014679, 0.7500900626182556, -0.35317716002464294, 0.7889139652252197, 1.0548456907272339, 0.3950558006763458, -0.9596049785614014, 0.14997565746307373, 0.20021943747997284, -0.08973291516304016, 0.3033839464187622, -0.9181762933731079, 0.4350128471851349, -0.005401981994509697, -0.023816192522644997, -0.636925220489502, -0.0634799599647522, 0.6154988408088684, 0.7534180879592896, -0.16607613861560822, 0.8103240132331848, -0.48404642939567566, 0.3363417685031891, -0.1938861906528473, 0.29134267568588257, 0.6416893601417542, 0.2238561511039734, -1.0959850549697876, -0.013847015798091888, 1.500981330871582, 0.1911846399307251, -0.24017958343029022, 0.301399290561676, -0.8995686173439026, -0.14016856253147125, -0.8810974359512329, 0.3444601893424988, -0.05395429953932762, 0.4103957414627075, -0.3167836368083954, -0.33449360728263855, -0.565579891204834, 0.39379361271858215, -0.5425844192504883, 0.0747351348400116, 0.3614931106567383, 0.42772382497787476, 0.6921107172966003, 0.05183706060051918, 0.3003492057323456, -0.7558440566062927, -0.028742752969264984, 0.8177838921546936, -0.6143509149551392, -0.13346947729587555, 0.31088709831237793, 0.18381482362747192, 0.5118772983551025, 0.12193088978528976, 0.5093961358070374, -0.5312011241912842, 0.8522785902023315, 0.4203803837299347, -0.07207838445901871, -0.14117302000522614, 0.2814299166202545, -0.0822320282459259, 0.045825399458408356, -0.5916054248809814, -0.6437810659408569, 0.3237965404987335, 0.049778807908296585, 0.049388337880373, 0.18908312916755676, 0.18329450488090515, -0.6257642507553101, -1.037772536277771, 0.17984886467456818, 0.19931863248348236, 0.40545564889907837, 0.3514919579029083, 0.6064649820327759, 0.3754708468914032, 0.24070024490356445, -0.8591804504394531, -0.4744383990764618, -0.23512797057628632, 0.23039953410625458, -0.48828354477882385, 0.24666477739810944, -0.4065706729888916, -0.3882470428943634, -0.5406427979469299, -0.9320170879364014, -0.08544453978538513, -0.6027536392211914, -0.2265120893716812, -1.0168249607086182, -0.003261319827288389, 0.25618475675582886, 0.6608121991157532, 0.35918259620666504, 0.02835073508322239, -0.21071594953536987, 0.3998225927352905, 0.9459169507026672, -0.06252818554639816, 0.5743870139122009, -0.038933124393224716, 0.10371776670217514, -0.27640843391418457, 0.25892239809036255, -0.40207144618034363, 0.2868611216545105, -0.18287046253681183, -1.2025772333145142, 0.016347121447324753, 0.05002744123339653, -0.18540583550930023, 0.28658849000930786, 1.0461117029190063, 0.11006785184144974, -0.13135196268558502, -0.18565507233142853, -0.012931172735989094, -0.3920087218284607, 0.5113261938095093, -0.1436476707458496, 0.5219194889068604, -0.5127345323562622, -0.6064921021461487, 0.5191353559494019, -1.0188803672790527, 4.05030632019043, 0.38268840312957764, 0.7788198590278625, -0.08693528175354004, 0.4182623624801636, 0.13242994248867035, 0.13707450032234192, -0.018656516447663307, -0.25146427750587463, 0.30515599250793457, 0.27544182538986206, 0.12371507287025452, 0.5433900356292725, 0.11768996715545654, 0.41190460324287415, 0.2678488492965698, -0.5234025716781616, -0.2584476172924042, 0.13281342387199402, -0.6619274020195007, -0.5907811522483826, 0.4860447347164154, -0.48956266045570374, 0.17918305099010468, 0.7197849750518799, 0.7424877285957336, 0.01893226057291031, 0.04584047570824623, -0.5096617341041565, -0.4290711283683777, 0.02471846528351307, -0.2945614457130432, 0.20110057294368744, -0.5604086518287659, -0.5550445318222046, -0.4639284312725067, 0.3067072033882141, -0.295404851436615, 0.11115635186433792, 0.8702889680862427, 0.45847734808921814, 0.00889045000076294, 0.10797704011201859, -0.5425987243652344, -0.9109799861907959, -0.19270946085453033, -0.8573945760726929, 0.23568949103355408, 0.8167752623558044, -0.08501885086297989, 0.7288790345191956, 0.16497454047203064, 0.12752635776996613, -0.21235312521457672, -1.3097271919250488, -0.23297470808029175, -0.05870448797941208, -1.1885721683502197, -0.039366140961647034, 0.43516552448272705, 0.2232687622308731, 0.27503249049186707, 0.21203169226646423, -0.08562485128641129, 0.4784362316131592, 0.517594039440155, 0.3617468476295471, 0.5659834146499634, -0.36319684982299805, -0.4893815815448761, 0.08215701580047607, -0.695305585861206, 0.31180843710899353, -0.7465788722038269, 0.6433343291282654, 0.6605116724967957, -0.2697681188583374, 0.727599024772644, -0.9906046390533447, -0.8900954723358154, -0.2754887044429779, -0.4174381196498871, -0.21988020837306976, -0.15913160145282745, 1.073490858078003, 0.726533055305481, 0.4424450099468231, -0.48570898175239563, -0.754190981388092, 0.27515825629234314, 1.324892282485962, -0.17263104021549225, 0.2081158608198166, 0.3294129967689514, -0.3367577791213989 ]
{"Title": "Detection of parasite-derived transrenal DNA for the diagnosis of chronic Trypanosoma cruzi infection", "Authors": "Madrigal Ana G., Marcus Rachel, Gilman Robert, Scott Alan L., Shiff Clive", "Abstract": "Abstract Chagas disease, caused by the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma cruzi , is a potentially life-threatening infection endemic to Latin America that has emerged as a global public health issue due to globalization and emigration patterns. Diagnosis of T. cruzi infection is complex, especially for the chronic phase of the disease that is characterized by a low to moderate burden of the difficult to detect, tissue-dwelling, intracellular form of the parasite. Diagnosis relies on a multistep indirect serological detection approach that requires positive results in at least two independent anti- T. cruzi antibody tests. With no gold standard diagnostic method for chronic T. cruzi , new approaches are needed that can more directly test for the presence of the parasite. Here, we report on of the potential utility of a noninvasive diagnostic approach that specifically detects T. cruzi -derived cell-free repeat DNA in the urine of patients who are both serologically positive and negative.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010934"}
10.1101/2019.12.08.19014167
[ 0.45616939663887024, -0.17048761248588562, -0.20119860768318176, -0.3225165903568268, 0.03280729055404663, -0.3945392966270447, -0.5081377625465393, 0.2985711395740509, 1.0470185279846191, 0.7399316430091858, 0.09258562326431274, -0.33091914653778076, 0.5146068930625916, -0.2095128446817398, 0.20575886964797974, -0.4528477191925049, 0.052761439234018326, 0.2341865450143814, -0.04947393760085106, 0.14239023625850677, 0.032463692128658295, 0.12288250029087067, -0.9463747143745422, 0.3891528844833374, -0.5522908568382263, 0.5086311101913452, -0.010447535663843155, 0.11904075741767883, 0.9480748772621155, 0.41482284665107727, -0.5995368957519531, -0.8794200420379639, 0.22133716940879822, -1.7649325132369995, -0.054548829793930054, -0.32669585943222046, 0.5525515079498291, -0.01806754246354103, -0.7322628498077393, -0.5365230441093445, 0.8831979036331177, -0.4317266047000885, 0.5048063397407532, -0.4483596086502075, 0.16184625029563904, -0.8771494030952454, 0.006352749187499285, -0.11482642590999603, 0.18143311142921448, 0.3786829710006714, 0.3321133852005005, 0.16295738518238068, -0.12048650532960892, -0.15795764327049255, 0.21692076325416565, 0.41635310649871826, -0.021831564605236053, -0.12411554902791977, -0.6564825773239136, 0.04843581095337868, 0.30198222398757935, -0.16998867690563202, 0.3771176040172577, -0.5439662933349609, 0.9194009304046631, 0.9793161153793335, -0.3013656735420227, 0.4790881872177124, -0.10514374822378159, 0.11430248618125916, -0.24949200451374054, 0.3481069505214691, -0.08889303356409073, -0.6129423975944519, -0.28072619438171387, -0.8616063594818115, 0.7980706691741943, 0.3477218449115753, -0.2803700566291809, 0.5168426036834717, 0.49614036083221436, 0.20150233805179596, 0.6380150318145752, -0.14612211287021637, -0.6900215744972229, 0.013919457793235779, 0.2654763460159302, 0.9268727898597717, 0.08958978950977325, 0.5353050231933594, 0.5173684358596802, 0.3928378224372864, 0.2956417500972748, -0.22796916961669922, -0.07012438774108887, 0.8133007884025574, -0.3111731708049774, -0.32186758518218994, 0.08337505906820297, -0.3203834891319275, 0.7484644651412964, 1.1369218826293945, -0.19201456010341644, 0.5372094511985779, -0.7290595173835754, 0.8981170058250427, 0.9848395586013794, -0.37538036704063416, -0.3238353729248047, -1.3793753385543823, 0.491161584854126, 0.9426996111869812, -0.6142081022262573, 0.37134888768196106, 0.8087549805641174, 0.1707248091697693, 0.06253350526094437, 0.5557653307914734, -0.47132378816604614, -0.25457683205604553, 0.5501495599746704, -0.33906227350234985, 0.9779481291770935, -0.6599808931350708, -0.024890577420592308, 0.1481655389070511, 0.2345900982618332, 0.3719891309738159, 0.3483562171459198, 0.7677386403083801, 0.34761035442352295, 0.03280109912157059, -0.47113561630249023, 0.21706724166870117, -0.1887497454881668, 0.07057936489582062, 0.10628007352352142, 0.8818693161010742, 0.5837419033050537, -0.845007598400116, -0.21570192277431488, 0.31936195492744446, -0.7500898838043213, 1.154974102973938, -0.13868027925491333, 0.9209577441215515, -0.5684975981712341, -1.6761385202407837, -0.5009912252426147, -0.127211794257164, -0.8486067652702332, 0.131992906332016, -0.0053128148429095745, -0.3432966470718384, -0.6141358017921448, 1.1098847389221191, -0.4295140504837036, 0.3553425073623657, 0.5475542545318604, 0.21360346674919128, -0.4322751760482788, 0.7963702082633972, 0.19760827720165253, 0.718366801738739, -0.8440923094749451, 0.33749067783355713, -0.06623094528913498, 0.19229739904403687, -0.29810819029808044, -0.6008027791976929, 0.8723131418228149, -0.2698917090892792, -0.45362478494644165, 0.14222724735736847, 0.3676457107067108, 0.6464856863021851, 0.9495176672935486, -0.6166489720344543, -0.0007708928897045553, 0.3059711754322052, 0.555784285068512, 0.6228659152984619, -0.2692398130893707, 0.5582476854324341, 0.0508505254983902, 0.2536594867706299, 0.046126384288072586, -0.10432026535272598, -0.16301560401916504, -0.8954148888587952, 0.2650447189807892, -0.057297464460134506, -0.10412511974573135, 0.33134645223617554, -0.8197203874588013, 0.05328977480530739, -0.7384681701660156, 0.2577700912952423, 0.354890376329422, -0.45909202098846436, -0.7027270793914795, -0.23330098390579224, -0.08549042046070099, 0.01139246579259634, 0.0180928036570549, 0.4030230939388275, -0.23991668224334717, 0.510990560054779, -0.7017583250999451, 0.5401782989501953, 0.8499962687492371, -0.37553027272224426, -0.5284176468849182, -0.23618994653224945, 0.8564275503158569, -0.8389554023742676, -0.13980527222156525, -0.19775749742984772, 0.1353093683719635, 0.07454579323530197, -0.922093391418457, -0.7649528384208679, 0.9696414470672607, 0.28571802377700806, 0.2592960596084595, 0.23233187198638916, 0.8330039381980896, 0.3421735167503357, -0.6486784219741821, -1.0500227212905884, -0.056441910564899445, 0.5135752558708191, -0.389946311712265, 1.0280042886734009, 0.7280246019363403, 0.18464455008506775, 0.341396301984787, 0.34174835681915283, 0.05782244727015495, 0.26388171315193176, 0.591962456703186, -0.18502993881702423, 0.029941435903310776, 0.7941191792488098, -0.38687843084335327, 0.38718897104263306, -0.9974043965339661, 0.18142162263393402, -0.5901662111282349, 1.002816081047058, 0.18004432320594788, 0.7198784947395325, 0.756712019443512, -0.04871514439582825, -0.3234029710292816, -0.33638039231300354, 0.4030725657939911, 0.5894103050231934, -0.4560786783695221, -0.11605986207723618, 0.011384137906134129, 0.327350914478302, -0.6807408332824707, -0.4683041274547577, 0.6830710768699646, 0.9107064604759216, -0.49673691391944885, -0.10186340659856796, -0.2523432970046997, -0.6474573612213135, -1.2050690650939941, -0.6026206016540527, -0.9506831169128418, -0.7428882122039795, -0.756658136844635, -0.6884936690330505, 0.4818419814109802, -0.41223570704460144, 0.8064380884170532, -0.09670853614807129, -0.2072174996137619, -0.7252277135848999, -0.23080974817276, -0.016388313844799995, 0.16987912356853485, 0.8661078214645386, -0.923979640007019, 0.01358628086745739, -0.7274222373962402, 0.0806790441274643, -0.4751419126987457, -0.17464235424995422, -1.0749659538269043, -0.23982185125350952, 0.13947215676307678, -0.4346545934677124, 0.0755874514579773, -0.05400708317756653, -0.21560989320278168, -0.12758956849575043, 0.11855503916740417, 0.21791188418865204, -0.11250755935907364, -0.29203835129737854, 0.16652053594589233, 0.6465542316436768, 0.08105069398880005, -0.041379112750291824, 0.21767877042293549, 0.3501651883125305, -0.865932822227478, 0.38374391198158264, -0.004606971982866526, 0.6213988661766052, -0.930570662021637, -0.022615844383835793, 0.5009758472442627, 0.05237199738621712, 0.15331973135471344, -0.7239480018615723, -0.6065132021903992, -0.05908910930156708, -0.5975186824798584, -0.4535994231700897, 0.04973085597157478, 1.090450644493103, 0.20668461918830872, -1.2433851957321167, 0.05484316125512123, 0.2522371709346771, -0.8563995957374573, -0.0014962746063247323, 0.22061482071876526, 0.2780289053916931, 0.8063496947288513, -0.39553314447402954, -0.6919118762016296, 0.18518635630607605, 0.1891237050294876, 0.5033738017082214, 0.09620968252420425, -1.0931060314178467, -0.28452545404434204, -0.0022833417169749737, 0.2892627418041229, -0.3981022834777832, 0.523385226726532, -0.5278863906860352, -0.34542179107666016, -0.260030061006546, -0.6298584342002869, -0.3065374493598938, -0.05622204393148422, 0.6645328402519226, -0.5327097177505493, 0.46523720026016235, 0.07805783301591873, -0.1343165785074234, 0.5041453242301941, 0.25748929381370544, -0.05699489638209343, 0.5700209140777588, 0.1265084147453308, 0.4765729308128357, -0.3192213177680969, -0.8650139570236206, 0.2378610223531723, 0.03379696607589722, 0.4417418837547302, -0.7708385586738586, 0.9471004605293274, 0.15651829540729523, 0.10542590916156769, 0.08911392092704773, 0.18430545926094055, -0.780034601688385, 0.5681225657463074, -0.4441187381744385, 0.7349520921707153, -0.776458740234375, 0.07583368569612503, 0.24011188745498657, 0.8762566447257996, 0.32023629546165466, 0.07109624892473221, 0.474924772977829, -0.011489874683320522, 0.07512829452753067, -0.4670308530330658, -0.24652646481990814, 0.07452785968780518, -0.09315264970064163, 0.1539376676082611, 0.373918354511261, -0.17072850465774536, 0.2245205193758011, 0.3984261751174927, 0.5353081226348877, -0.2076372653245926, 0.5489655137062073, 0.5134708285331726, 0.10773556679487228, 0.3749006688594818, -0.20485107600688934, 0.2745477557182312, -0.28998300433158875, -0.37906739115715027, 0.25861242413520813, 0.021454058587551117, 0.092920683324337, -0.07781517505645752, 0.12108604609966278, 0.01503195334225893, 0.3343389332294464, -0.3389156758785248, -0.9380505681037903, -0.304316908121109, 0.19566570222377777, 0.82439124584198, -0.26241084933280945, 0.379109263420105, -0.897960901260376, -0.3784973621368408, -0.08105512708425522, 0.48790353536605835, -1.2015130519866943, -0.49388256669044495, -0.40650877356529236, -0.6075010299682617, 0.45740798115730286, -0.5614463686943054, -0.26996269822120667, -0.4220266342163086, -0.38689738512039185, -0.21719838678836823, 0.3269103169441223, -0.015604926273226738, 0.16087308526039124, 0.6502712368965149, -0.33655014634132385, -0.364410936832428, 0.11973995715379715, -0.3860500752925873, -0.5868774056434631, 0.5481910109519958, 0.5075827240943909, 2.124664068222046, 0.29328784346580505, -0.3490823209285736, -0.6026520133018494, 0.6395439505577087, -0.47343847155570984, 0.7604710459709167, -0.3519097566604614, -0.2522144615650177, -0.3118102550506592, -0.3557604253292084, -0.24938935041427612, 1.1862058639526367, 0.6706055402755737, -0.4890071451663971, -0.2421160638332367, 0.4284704327583313, -0.819099485874176, -0.702926754951477, 0.6116318106651306, -0.08019908517599106, -0.0763169676065445, 1.611651062965393, -0.07679741829633713, 0.49357283115386963, -0.0314633771777153, 0.22158312797546387, -0.4718096852302551, 0.4036124646663666, -0.18998144567012787, 0.11551333218812943, 0.7438591122627258, -0.1903001368045807, -0.15229618549346924, 0.0006253288593143225, 0.9555051922798157, -0.743549644947052, -0.4823586046695709, -0.4796947240829468, -0.4097663462162018, -0.4657662808895111, -0.39601343870162964, -0.5444586277008057, -0.2883695065975189, -0.1831430196762085, -0.09293705224990845, 0.558703601360321, 0.05924897640943527, -0.37536782026290894, -0.3609231114387512, -0.16398131847381592, -0.08300496637821198, -0.2040182203054428, 0.18702547252178192, 0.8268440365791321, -0.6670951843261719, -0.9779202938079834, 0.7656947374343872, 0.04000362008810043, -1.041568398475647, -0.5436609983444214, 0.2171405702829361, 0.11849971115589142, -0.47050565481185913, -0.1978018581867218, 0.36839669942855835, -0.36898401379585266, -0.697670042514801, -0.20437133312225342, -0.4150300920009613, 0.480670690536499, 0.2991202473640442, -0.5096980929374695, 0.7994461059570312, 0.37914225459098816, -0.7329198122024536, -0.00084247428458184, 0.3411515951156616, 0.42282339930534363, 0.45733070373535156, 0.04708080738782883, -0.8863222599029541, -0.8830885291099548, -0.40893372893333435, 0.8601795434951782, -0.6439448595046997, 0.02394779771566391, -0.6157286763191223, -0.17828118801116943, -0.28052234649658203, 0.020312655717134476, 0.045363202691078186, -0.022442471235990524, 0.17275604605674744, -0.502120852470398, -0.11770790815353394, -0.6361565589904785, -0.5885833501815796, 0.03034120611846447, -0.14431951940059662, 0.043810270726680756, 0.6348950266838074, 0.000501838163472712, -0.3911784291267395, -0.05240900069475174, 0.7617204785346985, 0.4739929735660553, 0.4865155518054962, -0.6581045985221863, -1.0209548473358154, -0.09802012145519257, 0.04446069896221161, 0.1097327396273613, 0.24271994829177856, -0.9585033059120178, -0.47947874665260315, -0.5925502777099609, -0.1327175348997116, -0.31792929768562317, -0.7276099324226379, 0.014259262010455132, -0.8399658203125, 0.9543664455413818, -0.1750476211309433, 0.9118229746818542, 0.10627621412277222, 0.11836053431034088, 0.18283796310424805, 0.28505584597587585, -0.4448991119861603, 0.18714410066604614, -0.5986897349357605, -0.15084446966648102, 0.834705650806427, -0.4023813307285309, -0.23152369260787964, 1.2383536100387573, -0.4163488447666168, 0.12825949490070343, -0.8947595953941345, 1.3677268028259277, 0.8347140550613403, -0.5426329970359802, -0.11972760409116745, -0.9338111281394958, -0.20867565274238586, 0.7891032695770264, -0.23282566666603088, 0.39453059434890747, -0.2725357115268707, 0.40909114480018616, -0.653048574924469, 0.05637253820896149, -1.1510764360427856, 0.2036023736000061, 0.15759097039699554, 0.8250331282615662, 0.18248207867145538, 0.15136241912841797, 0.7072498798370361, -0.15327699482440948, -0.7679609656333923, 0.6866956949234009, -0.12617118656635284, 0.4753517806529999, 0.7002578973770142, -0.3092520833015442, -0.011774271726608276, 0.32224416732788086, -0.39008983969688416, -0.42511504888534546, -0.2986612915992737, 0.6980859041213989, 0.27806714177131653, -1.3187617063522339, 0.04474330320954323, 0.16309408843517303, -0.9118630886077881, -0.5336599946022034, 0.511525571346283, -0.04233821853995323, 0.17729482054710388, 0.10049381852149963, -0.6003947257995605, 0.02996983379125595, -1.0639688968658447, 0.7213858962059021, -0.21082353591918945, 0.2058805227279663, 0.0783766508102417, -0.5114447474479675, -0.26316767930984497, -0.9872786998748779, 0.14992497861385345, 0.8973460793495178, -0.712845504283905, 0.24843688309192657, -0.47373270988464355, -0.12261725217103958, 0.1875898689031601, 0.17135758697986603, 0.023293055593967438, 0.030205877497792244, 0.5369424223899841, -0.07132818549871445, 0.6275016665458679, 0.4370235502719879, 0.8545151948928833, -0.3980410695075989, 1.515975832939148, 0.7981817722320557, -0.4691612124443054, -0.2783656120300293, 0.3298461139202118, 0.5346534848213196, 0.7334114909172058, 0.10774623602628708, -0.4507468342781067, 1.0202302932739258, 0.3928088843822479, 0.907130777835846, -0.661766767501831, -0.5551841259002686, -0.033887360244989395, -0.010842492803931236, 0.05404200404882431, -0.5773568749427795, -0.054677173495292664, 0.3480851948261261, -0.7791498899459839, 0.21482151746749878, -0.5086467266082764, 0.35779181122779846, -0.29777854681015015, 0.28571584820747375, -0.10184726119041443, 0.8740136623382568, -0.39556634426116943, -0.970666766166687, -0.6216757893562317, -0.7525333762168884, -0.016761157661676407, 0.6369708776473999, -1.043825387954712, -0.3928605616092682, -0.057171210646629333, 0.03835881128907204, 0.013599036261439323, -0.2518838942050934, 0.04685863107442856, -0.8302742838859558, -0.8248526453971863, 0.19040954113006592, 0.008159278891980648, -0.08984638750553131, 0.8173978328704834, -0.7161391377449036, 0.4667383134365082, 0.17387858033180237, -0.06822124123573303, 0.022229602560400963, 0.03556498885154724, 0.3198513686656952, -1.0234761238098145, -0.6089428663253784, -0.5595583319664001, 0.9773372411727905, -0.7684829235076904, 0.4386600852012634, -0.36477693915367126, -0.5035881400108337, 0.4842472970485687, 0.14257514476776123, 0.14347752928733826, 1.2028571367263794, 0.28004932403564453, 0.3313785493373871, 0.11009322106838226, 0.8352104425430298, 0.5356664657592773, 0.14992813766002655, -0.0339730866253376, 0.10105480998754501, 0.4158194363117218, -0.821712851524353, -0.04717446118593216, 0.6170411705970764, -0.4067141115665436, 0.150621697306633, 0.05969885736703873, 0.5157851576805115, -0.010709811933338642, -0.44803544878959656, -1.0379438400268555, 0.21766997873783112, 0.6157299876213074, 0.2614413797855377, 0.18094249069690704, -0.1646062433719635, -0.6845172643661499, -0.013374574482440948, -0.5636751055717468, -0.5122280120849609, 0.10612437129020691, -0.438973069190979, 0.6715289354324341, -0.687855064868927, -0.3724404573440552, 0.3622813820838928, 1.0572537183761597, 0.2596009075641632, -0.07847089320421219, 0.1008671447634697, 0.6701353192329407, 0.8914400935173035, 0.065672367811203, 0.48006463050842285, -0.01568528078496456, 0.27281463146209717, -0.5384243726730347, -0.23259593546390533, -0.08621086180210114, 0.4115877151489258, -0.29605981707572937, 0.22583183646202087, -0.6091694235801697, 0.37348464131355286, 0.15167252719402313, -0.6342307329177856, -0.019443977624177933, -0.432545006275177, -0.7374939322471619, -0.1645757108926773, -0.346996545791626, 0.8289335370063782, 0.0030016652308404446, 0.45628219842910767, 0.5819827914237976, -0.7369963526725769, -0.6718112230300903, -0.5981630682945251, 0.2923543453216553, -0.7281897068023682, 0.1290637105703354, -0.24293501675128937, 0.5264326333999634, -0.187029168009758, -1.0777729749679565, 0.6985090970993042, 0.4504545331001282, 0.1533275842666626, 0.6388580203056335, 0.4345051050186157, 0.6121246218681335, 1.1924864053726196, -0.5136380195617676, -0.10156867653131485, 0.5768347978591919, 0.7265908122062683, 0.2695331275463104, -0.0024857826065272093, -0.939409077167511, 0.5634965300559998, -0.16762354969978333, -0.5691050291061401, -0.21134966611862183, 0.046365756541490555, 0.16867315769195557, 0.5568912625312805, 0.08558744192123413, 1.079105019569397, -1.17702317237854, -0.613078236579895, -0.37922415137290955, -0.2955304682254791, 1.1503429412841797, -0.16775260865688324, 0.00958507601171732, -0.3745260238647461, 0.43793708086013794, -0.40440043807029724, -0.11573606729507446, 0.7095310688018799, -0.5874844789505005, -0.5816256403923035, -0.3061314821243286, 0.17235830426216125, -0.2245231717824936, -0.08170448243618011, -0.6436248421669006, -0.5853272080421448, 0.2221723347902298, -0.06120240315794945, -0.4789692163467407, -0.6688171625137329, 0.9279597997665405, -0.40656086802482605, 0.6565454006195068, -0.6827727556228638, 0.11351613700389862, -0.578495442867279, -0.024419326335191727, 0.46605560183525085, -0.671657145023346, 0.08045292645692825, 0.6208177208900452, 0.8023566007614136, 0.6919247508049011, -0.3178088963031769, 0.7254366278648376, -0.1755802184343338, 0.040097080171108246, 1.2408547401428223, 0.2910616099834442, 0.008034170605242252, 0.5474671721458435, 0.160580575466156, 0.17864082753658295, -0.3120114207267761, -0.3481750786304474, 0.2982861399650574, -0.3934495747089386, -0.08568695187568665, -0.027566879987716675, 0.0007129731238819659, -0.5369482636451721, -0.7925885319709778, -0.3751354515552521, -0.048308681696653366, -0.9129957556724548, -0.5088526010513306, 0.7256077527999878, 0.8963757753372192, 0.1663663685321808, -0.5452015995979309, 0.16126090288162231, -0.10726240277290344, -0.2597125470638275, -0.2999888062477112, 0.8099953532218933, -0.900041937828064, -0.3901466131210327, -0.5003702640533447, -0.6477161049842834, 0.20076912641525269, -0.6500231027603149, -0.09887518733739853, -0.3064531981945038, 0.5035635828971863, 0.733957827091217, 1.5303136110305786, 0.547465980052948, -0.14350077509880066, 0.19307252764701843, 0.3846798539161682, 0.22644037008285522, 0.23333480954170227, 0.7532960772514343, -0.023194940760731697, -0.17310255765914917, 0.5697521567344666, -0.3963273763656616, 0.509160578250885, -0.39943727850914, -0.684305727481842, -0.4209488034248352, 0.2129259705543518, -0.18496738374233246, -0.7083647847175598, -0.08560407161712646, 0.3433591425418854, 0.06571397185325623, -0.34705719351768494, -0.6851317882537842, 0.3759847581386566, -0.22539450228214264, 0.04247394576668739, -0.011714271269738674, -0.09798042476177216, 0.08942139893770218, -0.10830173641443253, 0.4230957627296448, -1.2513222694396973, 3.993147611618042, 0.6310110688209534, 0.5269760489463806, -0.3143758177757263, 0.2009650021791458, -0.21572233736515045, 0.16791722178459167, -0.28018903732299805, 0.10223589837551117, 0.15678438544273376, -0.34268975257873535, -0.4314797818660736, 0.148722842335701, -0.10531585663557053, 0.2603343427181244, 0.6958165168762207, -1.5272833108901978, 0.211077019572258, 0.07134708762168884, -0.9549864530563354, -0.8553934097290039, 0.42074522376060486, -0.45309892296791077, 0.13269245624542236, 0.586175799369812, -0.0751560628414154, -0.38108575344085693, 0.9169180989265442, -0.23557327687740326, -0.5600064396858215, -0.135092630982399, -0.9108489751815796, 0.4438740611076355, -0.08274909108877182, -0.4278543293476105, 0.4224734306335449, 0.19201035797595978, 0.14612123370170593, -0.23598726093769073, 0.7325994968414307, 0.526696503162384, -0.5090016722679138, -0.21172162890434265, -0.5876570343971252, 0.1785663515329361, -0.1941801756620407, -1.0499211549758911, 0.7841240763664246, 0.1098545491695404, -0.19028285145759583, 1.0619322061538696, -0.4150921106338501, -0.047185562551021576, -0.21927839517593384, -1.4100847244262695, 0.1312977373600006, 0.1380959451198578, -1.239075779914856, -0.45030683279037476, 0.5817423462867737, 0.9266362190246582, -0.4609742760658264, -0.21009008586406708, -0.13432210683822632, -0.07706400752067566, 1.0426676273345947, 0.5908486247062683, 0.33406028151512146, -0.4383496642112732, -0.43429699540138245, 0.46440589427948, -0.4546425938606262, -0.45319563150405884, -0.21343694627285004, 0.09599550813436508, 0.7396461367607117, 0.1227061077952385, 0.7403229475021362, -0.7275900840759277, -0.5924147963523865, 0.3689272701740265, 0.6419206261634827, 0.11269817501306534, 0.06988922506570816, 0.38051512837409973, 0.14964614808559418, -1.101033329963684, -0.42852213978767395, -0.6893106698989868, -0.05720039829611778, 0.23906521499156952, 0.4959842264652252, -0.08170296996831894, 0.07284896075725555, -0.2179592102766037 ]
{"Title": "High frequency of Exon 20 S768I EGFR mutation detected in malignant pleural effusions: a poor prognosticator of NSCLC?", "Authors": "D\u2019Souza George, Dhar Chirag, Kyalanoor Vishal, Yadav Lokendra, Sharmra Mugdha, Nawaz S Mohammad, Srivastava Sweta", "Abstract": "Abstract Lung cancer is the cause of a fourth of all cancer-related deaths. About a third of all lung adenocarcinoma tumours harbour mutations on exons 18, 19, 20 and 21 of the epidermal growth factor receptor ( EGFR ) gene. Detection of these mutations allows for targeted therapies in the form of EGFR Tyrosine kinase inhibitors. In our study, we utilized malignant pleural effusions (MPEs) as \u201cliquid biopsies\u201d to detect EGFR mutations when tissue biopsies were unavailable. We showed that a direct sequencing approach was likely to miss SNVs in MPEs. We then optimized an EGFR mutant-specific quantitative polymerase chain reaction-based assay and piloted it on n=10 pleural effusion samples (1 non-malignant pleural effusion as a negative control). 5/9 (55.55%) samples harboured EGFR mutations with 2/9 (22.22%) being exon 19 deletions and 3/9 (33.33%) had the S768I exon 20 mutation. The frequency of the S768I SNV in our study was significantly higher than that observed in other studies (\u223c0.3%). Utilizing publicly available cBioPortal data, we report that patients with the S768I SNV had a shorter median survival time, progression-free survival time and lower tumor mutation count compared to patients with other EGFR mutations. These data suggest that this point mutation predicts poor prognosis as a result of aggressive disease, though studies in larger cohorts are necessary to confirm these findings. The high frequency of S768I mutations seen in our study also suggests that cancer cells harbouring these mutations may be superior in their ability to migrate, home or reside in pleural fluid.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.08.19014167"}
10.1101/19003129
[ -0.017244046553969383, -0.5579926371574402, -0.7052212357521057, -0.1287076473236084, 0.07266216725111008, -0.36065980792045593, -0.25712117552757263, 0.5479931235313416, -0.23806875944137573, 0.5973421335220337, -0.5869746208190918, -0.7522026300430298, 0.2926940321922302, 0.9625274538993835, -0.4377255439758301, -0.02884577587246895, -0.7544687986373901, -0.3731857240200043, 0.07383324950933456, -0.05511835590004921, 0.3185488283634186, 0.3174689710140228, -0.7454661726951599, -0.22407260537147522, -0.6763629913330078, 0.6569059491157532, -0.2239459902048111, 0.41466137766838074, 1.365889072418213, 0.9000278115272522, 0.23550672829151154, 0.1502569317817688, 0.29830402135849, -0.7847890257835388, 0.2166907638311386, -0.22330014407634735, 0.23106734454631805, -0.7476283311843872, -0.48353978991508484, -0.4277323782444, 0.39857369661331177, 0.17237769067287445, 0.24079245328903198, -0.5279127955436707, -1.0260095596313477, 0.6773520112037659, 0.020941492170095444, -0.08546480536460876, -0.44610390067100525, 0.42072808742523193, 0.17746224999427795, -0.15849779546260834, -0.5232194662094116, -0.7088264226913452, -0.21707579493522644, -0.24381864070892334, -0.4533751606941223, -0.07077108323574066, -0.411808580160141, 0.5007972121238708, 0.3666142523288727, -0.06219859793782234, 1.005935549736023, -0.8448790311813354, -0.22800281643867493, 0.4367278516292572, -0.24940823018550873, 0.046014755964279175, -0.22603516280651093, -0.6966580152511597, -0.34538137912750244, -0.11235906183719635, -0.6717092394828796, -1.015579104423523, -0.2601708173751831, -0.21853357553482056, -0.13691453635692596, -0.5548809766769409, -0.3464820086956024, 0.7004354000091553, -0.08482228964567184, 0.41487836837768555, 0.8504182696342468, -0.1065378487110138, -0.7526310682296753, 0.3601192831993103, 0.11779513955116272, 0.2136690467596054, 0.6848521828651428, 0.5985287427902222, 0.3892934024333954, 0.27302953600883484, 0.1582435518503189, 0.4059502184391022, 0.7257403135299683, 1.4599331617355347, -0.3491151034832001, 0.5155683755874634, -0.7030693292617798, 0.37543556094169617, 0.6421485543251038, 0.7442582249641418, -0.18196645379066467, 1.142356038093567, -0.4002249240875244, 0.6736561059951782, 0.627061128616333, -0.5655798316001892, 0.2912309765815735, -1.125290036201477, -0.0916132852435112, -0.3876549303531647, -0.2282983362674713, -0.6322299242019653, 0.5102035999298096, 0.28476354479789734, 0.3681260049343109, 0.4563462436199188, -0.1613510251045227, 1.3410471677780151, -0.23930519819259644, -0.07190221548080444, 0.7538502812385559, -0.3896450400352478, -0.14558568596839905, 0.14860886335372925, 0.7280380725860596, -0.1937570869922638, -0.7645478844642639, -0.8406342267990112, 0.3804806172847748, -0.8952261805534363, -0.32139042019844055, 0.0985691100358963, 0.29578155279159546, -0.13758563995361328, 0.16520079970359802, 0.9305922985076904, 0.7129713296890259, 0.6244163513183594, 0.22509559988975525, 0.8437453508377075, -0.9517678618431091, 1.254913330078125, 0.01914443075656891, 0.4812891483306885, -0.2828028202056885, -0.3091242015361786, -0.7195453643798828, 0.589245080947876, 0.5131434202194214, 0.1511785387992859, -0.5976743102073669, 0.23602403700351715, -0.11629173904657364, 0.5972976088523865, 0.1768302619457245, -0.06759649515151978, -0.1311016082763672, 0.16642054915428162, -0.9473838806152344, 0.23698793351650238, -0.14674729108810425, 0.2903047800064087, -1.0857670307159424, 0.19628219306468964, -0.6083824634552002, 0.04968267306685448, 0.7313097715377808, -0.8385996222496033, 0.8945335149765015, -0.060617923736572266, -0.1971568465232849, -0.01875332184135914, 0.26759523153305054, 0.8257169723510742, 0.3214648962020874, -0.6445905566215515, 0.49294301867485046, 0.6522188186645508, 0.3054286539554596, 0.04691854119300842, 0.10659312456846237, 1.2307652235031128, -0.07308266311883926, -0.07862836867570877, -0.593441903591156, 0.07725352793931961, -0.17006786167621613, 0.18945591151714325, -0.03564862906932831, 0.7711865901947021, -0.6440122723579407, 0.17548665404319763, 0.668385922908783, 0.10391054302453995, -0.5917720198631287, -0.17012923955917358, 0.11382607370615005, -1.0246636867523193, -0.30898311734199524, -0.059290897101163864, 0.06307286024093628, 1.101003646850586, 0.22701409459114075, 1.0528199672698975, 0.0046011945232748985, 0.3786211907863617, -0.6053284406661987, 0.3035290241241455, 0.7265456318855286, -0.005704726092517376, -0.20152801275253296, -0.002238976303488016, 0.9234371185302734, -0.9874414205551147, -0.5919291973114014, 0.42502361536026, -0.5460927486419678, -0.0970398485660553, -0.4955398738384247, -0.3796745836734772, 0.722741425037384, 0.07307897508144379, -0.043892379850149155, -0.19661535322666168, 0.3602096736431122, 0.3395516276359558, -0.48349934816360474, -0.14692099392414093, -0.6287450790405273, 0.06901494413614273, -0.28578853607177734, 0.9108597636222839, 0.9256789684295654, 0.24540077149868011, 0.05849475413560867, 0.4228653907775879, 0.4784776270389557, 0.07290536165237427, 0.7149049639701843, 0.2872489392757416, 0.7627891302108765, 0.3240654468536377, -1.294848918914795, 0.6505755186080933, -0.28744906187057495, 0.22575417160987854, 0.17711018025875092, -0.2848093807697296, -0.4837110638618469, 0.4991864264011383, 0.7097474336624146, 0.8087850213050842, -0.8582521677017212, -0.058311522006988525, 0.7437538504600525, 0.37810778617858887, -0.47599291801452637, -0.5376956462860107, -0.6123985052108765, 0.3712446093559265, -0.042862944304943085, 0.511013925075531, 0.7814404964447021, 0.2787061035633087, -0.6840560436248779, 0.6354798674583435, 0.3979039490222931, -0.24599815905094147, -1.0132274627685547, 0.1465267688035965, -0.7046231031417847, -0.19016756117343903, -0.8022083044052124, 0.5266145467758179, -0.19524206221103668, 0.02935778722167015, -0.10920105874538422, 0.266417533159256, -0.3971635401248932, -0.10736837983131409, 0.6778302788734436, 0.665351927280426, 0.28966930508613586, -0.1099151223897934, -0.7168369293212891, 0.7329439520835876, -0.17268694937229156, 0.2301281839609146, -0.08263125270605087, -0.15815851092338562, -0.9263817071914673, -0.9640188813209534, 0.5022091269493103, -0.12212063372135162, -0.34355929493904114, 1.0702537298202515, -0.5965911746025085, -1.014395833015442, 0.6352428197860718, 0.10788540542125702, 0.07795662432909012, -0.2534315586090088, -1.3560899496078491, 0.8325846195220947, 0.3041420876979828, 0.3915061950683594, 0.3099375367164612, 0.0028217441868036985, -0.6562822461128235, 0.6121106743812561, -0.2780671715736389, 0.16309519112110138, -1.0174870491027832, 0.11221817880868912, 0.6462740898132324, 0.01839013397693634, 0.28487011790275574, -0.6156162619590759, -0.9226869344711304, -0.11580609530210495, 0.22719953954219818, -0.8585600256919861, 0.0370853953063488, 0.38166138529777527, 0.25557515025138855, -1.577475666999817, -0.19775497913360596, -0.6665694117546082, -1.1528199911117554, 0.09974102675914764, -0.3864171802997589, 0.5648607611656189, 0.6222934126853943, -0.15827609598636627, -0.49492546916007996, 0.051841456443071365, -0.12516674399375916, -0.1386037915945053, 0.23116588592529297, -0.3917706608772278, 0.026858888566493988, 0.61036217212677, -0.1217488944530487, 0.4176321029663086, -0.29404008388519287, -0.3609878420829773, -0.3069681227207184, 0.19601325690746307, 0.2572081685066223, -0.1587952822446823, 0.9331904053688049, 0.13430091738700867, -0.7149139642715454, 0.5046936273574829, -0.7481048703193665, -0.017616037279367447, 0.2801121175289154, 0.43839287757873535, -0.7367377877235413, 0.32325196266174316, -0.5503695011138916, 0.2617429792881012, -0.32587453722953796, -1.4101730585098267, 0.3535192906856537, 0.7120712995529175, 0.5560061931610107, -0.2999270558357239, 0.5585634112358093, -0.5479177236557007, 0.04612800106406212, 0.7376202344894409, -0.37610405683517456, -0.20552992820739746, 0.6296719908714294, 0.6914403438568115, 1.2307567596435547, -1.0117295980453491, 0.3127157688140869, 0.36967191100120544, 1.5355405807495117, 0.474330335855484, -0.0016231389017775655, 0.19277280569076538, -0.6793094873428345, -0.15468010306358337, 0.20438948273658752, -0.5691616535186768, -0.14788946509361267, -0.30285006761550903, 0.5402730107307434, 0.34875187277793884, -0.6217786073684692, -0.6479570269584656, -0.0903557613492012, 0.3088041841983795, 1.0769158601760864, -0.09040677547454834, 0.6526225209236145, -0.20893172919750214, 0.27214232087135315, 0.45639345049858093, 0.3482799232006073, 0.8196094632148743, -0.486100435256958, -0.13641126453876495, -0.41294601559638977, -0.806204080581665, -0.028089147061109543, -0.7174308896064758, -0.29029881954193115, 0.17817212641239166, -0.20732781291007996, -0.10506349802017212, -0.340550035238266, -0.41785070300102234, 0.4507693350315094, -0.5056195855140686, 0.1011035144329071, -0.36001887917518616, -0.28519633412361145, 0.01589297689497471, 0.26809531450271606, -0.6552504301071167, 0.25290238857269287, -0.7199068069458008, 1.4212124347686768, 0.18772977590560913, -0.4082767367362976, -0.5941892266273499, -0.07657831162214279, 0.15645265579223633, -0.3996596336364746, 0.40155768394470215, -0.25702089071273804, -0.1363793909549713, 0.15798448026180267, -1.0180851221084595, -0.1397840976715088, -0.18565785884857178, 0.00896985363215208, -0.5627959370613098, -0.3804868757724762, -0.010050569660961628, 1.004062533378601, 1.0373775959014893, -0.04372549057006836, -0.5366619229316711, 0.23501290380954742, -0.9831458330154419, -0.1844160109758377, -0.7321597933769226, -0.1794850081205368, -0.1650005429983139, -0.008822674863040447, 0.2894158959388733, -0.5253798961639404, 0.19750984013080597, -0.5587770938873291, 0.02215404622256756, 0.1020844355225563, 0.2799714505672455, -0.1580941081047058, 1.010562777519226, -0.28191274404525757, -1.0486960411071777, 0.8645241260528564, -0.19640445709228516, -0.34755975008010864, 0.4003579020500183, -0.6107969880104065, -0.9464422464370728, 0.17198331654071808, -0.4633634090423584, 0.08045534789562225, 0.49748679995536804, -0.3400588929653168, 0.08700880408287048, 0.8907335996627808, 0.5738014578819275, 0.5400407910346985, 0.24375015497207642, -0.5414363741874695, -0.3405541777610779, -0.35993504524230957, -0.06023341044783592, -0.6229732632637024, 0.24002841114997864, -0.6168820858001709, -1.0091837644577026, -0.386626660823822, 0.11786704510450363, -0.7357102632522583, -0.19502311944961548, -0.3823851943016052, -0.25857192277908325, -0.14359082281589508, 0.1794041246175766, 1.3894165754318237, -0.7064918875694275, -0.6269621849060059, -0.45704540610313416, 0.643089234828949, -0.6910203099250793, -0.7066173553466797, 0.5124543309211731, -0.1369510442018509, 0.3974994122982025, -0.21008621156215668, 0.3134203255176544, -0.8692348003387451, -0.008255179971456528, -0.11888708919286728, 0.09935180097818375, 0.5075564980506897, -0.3623235523700714, -0.009215140715241432, -0.056705690920352936, 0.06440752744674683, -0.4399464428424835, -0.6187218427658081, -0.06638643890619278, 0.012462041340768337, 0.3953131139278412, -0.2736048400402069, -0.40655994415283203, 0.08124501258134842, -1.4197736978530884, -0.008534968830645084, -0.9103049635887146, 0.1480540931224823, 0.25260430574417114, -0.056182924658060074, 0.09823574125766754, 0.3377079665660858, 0.16010776162147522, 1.0200070142745972, -0.3088259696960449, -0.5826581120491028, 0.23012050986289978, 0.5819442868232727, -0.07183655351400375, -0.1792837232351303, -1.2225356101989746, -0.05213946849107742, 0.5986533164978027, 0.4443778991699219, -0.33109050989151, -0.9296470880508423, 0.1616310328245163, 0.5885865092277527, -0.24974261224269867, -0.03434690833091736, 0.199288010597229, -0.16701450943946838, -0.016902705654501915, -0.42727646231651306, -0.4590875208377838, -0.8211062550544739, 1.6927396059036255, -0.25541117787361145, 0.0026473684702068567, -0.20429278910160065, -0.7263329029083252, 0.10624562203884125, -0.14039082825183868, 1.5487550497055054, -0.08876237273216248, 0.5360831022262573, -0.3236486315727234, 0.3350619077682495, 0.719800591468811, -0.6973753571510315, -0.8192167282104492, -0.9741924405097961, -0.6506540775299072, -0.40534916520118713, 0.31935784220695496, -0.15432125329971313, -0.4306845963001251, 0.9153809547424316, -0.03418492525815964, -0.29939255118370056, 0.09559464454650879, 1.515757441520691, 0.9383347034454346, -1.1822428703308105, -0.34748631715774536, 0.08266662806272507, 1.0472567081451416, 0.024099018424749374, 0.5935251712799072, 0.5237082839012146, -0.6892026662826538, 0.4030468165874481, 0.03708371892571449, -0.4411765933036804, -0.1828860193490982, 0.2187218964099884, -0.8111878633499146, 1.3848341703414917, -0.6396778225898743, 0.13521786034107208, 0.16804911196231842, -0.1104721873998642, -0.7343053817749023, 0.060094185173511505, 0.23836898803710938, -0.267252117395401, 0.9863325357437134, -0.1759743094444275, 0.15728753805160522, 0.484222412109375, 0.13884350657463074, -0.137828528881073, -0.12546175718307495, 0.5668296813964844, 0.9963890910148621, -1.35321843624115, 0.5810801982879639, 0.15318559110164642, -0.7369317412376404, -0.6621235013008118, -0.17527101933956146, -0.3966134786605835, 0.25597575306892395, -0.2183956503868103, -0.9893256425857544, 0.3386986255645752, 0.020512480288743973, 0.22571781277656555, -0.13896429538726807, 0.3710380494594574, 0.478109747171402, -0.27805206179618835, 0.46990084648132324, -0.6833431720733643, -0.04591870307922363, 0.4380826950073242, -0.3659760653972626, 0.06727529317140579, 0.5175928473472595, 0.10844973474740982, 0.5081417560577393, -0.2116614431142807, 0.8066569566726685, -0.8748494982719421, -0.20191951096057892, -0.10846195369958878, -0.2809160053730011, 0.27554526925086975, 0.1865975558757782, -0.7436614036560059, 0.6138789653778076, -0.3264751136302948, -0.7125765085220337, 0.030495941638946533, 0.4690440595149994, 0.27118170261383057, 0.10298816114664078, -0.5192880630493164, -0.37257713079452515, 0.47656312584877014, -0.028272783383727074, 0.8431390523910522, -0.4116252660751343, -0.3728559911251068, -0.5227203369140625, -0.2138144075870514, -0.5983120203018188, -0.644339382648468, 0.3343750238418579, -0.3624477684497833, -0.20746418833732605, -0.8679755926132202, -0.3292732834815979, 0.7735336422920227, -0.5163432955741882, 0.15558402240276337, -0.2867237627506256, 0.8677113056182861, -0.37133631110191345, -0.9713796973228455, -0.28622013330459595, 0.07971882075071335, -0.6092166900634766, 1.014190673828125, -0.9954836964607239, 0.5319420099258423, -0.25414344668388367, 0.5053082704544067, 0.8449950218200684, 0.6669382452964783, -0.4131152331829071, -0.38467127084732056, 0.32307854294776917, 1.0493862628936768, 0.07981555908918381, 0.15424884855747223, 0.9336550831794739, -0.9071314334869385, 0.028829511255025864, 0.1894548535346985, -0.047621067613363266, -0.12400598078966141, -0.26508083939552307, -0.12419041991233826, -0.9795883893966675, -0.08623703569173813, -0.09019242972135544, -0.0050439913757145405, -1.2586158514022827, -0.3470666706562042, -0.6064180731773376, -0.07576208561658859, -0.3370198905467987, 0.025992536917328835, 0.7319846153259277, 0.2891120910644531, -0.027382742613554, 0.6362094879150391, 0.10725033283233643, 0.8234199285507202, 0.43685197830200195, 0.4327321946620941, 0.036642611026763916, 0.3579908609390259, -0.06931301206350327, -0.3763594329357147, 0.2356264889240265, 0.947097659111023, -0.44449886679649353, 0.2679709792137146, -0.8225522637367249, 0.29945865273475647, 0.5140661597251892, -0.15167684853076935, 0.33090001344680786, 0.8002297282218933, 0.05517992749810219, 0.26694485545158386, 0.41263195872306824, -0.45901355147361755, -0.19777435064315796, -0.5055416226387024, -1.2046934366226196, -0.004252647515386343, 0.28130480647087097, -0.7117382287979126, -0.4451785683631897, -0.8552785515785217, -1.081078290939331, 0.7631734013557434, 0.14280958473682404, 0.14738799631595612, -0.27305734157562256, 0.5819925665855408, -0.6450721621513367, 0.9867032766342163, 0.18470415472984314, 0.28135010600090027, -0.5272447466850281, 0.23807689547538757, 0.1482418328523636, -0.7905864119529724, 0.48026105761528015, 0.05537674203515053, 0.20990636944770813, -0.27541595697402954, -0.5864375233650208, -0.08061761409044266, -0.21934425830841064, -0.47781798243522644, 0.0011379725765436888, 0.19655925035476685, -0.27028319239616394, 0.2504725754261017, 0.29314541816711426, 0.8065147995948792, -0.6710881590843201, -0.14015083014965057, -0.17898444831371307, -0.9919297099113464, -0.6350307464599609, 0.6142416596412659, 0.09158860146999359, 0.09485062956809998, 0.2483571171760559, -0.057882651686668396, 0.23666423559188843, 0.4241729974746704, -0.09566368907690048, 0.6998355388641357, 0.5770752429962158, -0.29529690742492676, -0.005132629536092281, -0.1090816780924797, 0.06445927172899246, 0.6113904118537903, 0.21507598459720612, -0.08623561263084412, 0.5705999732017517, 0.07349305599927902, -0.041205406188964844, -0.3009145259857178, -0.7028388977050781, 0.2372290939092636, -0.16326148808002472, -0.5271580815315247, 0.20587368309497833, 0.021725965663790703, 0.49897387623786926, 0.1037757620215416, -0.5039873719215393, 0.5055363774299622, -0.20677606761455536, -0.5355820059776306, 0.036432262510061264, -0.37414318323135376, 0.22965744137763977, 0.06384381651878357, 0.147409588098526, -0.00626402348279953, 0.8308889865875244, -0.20634908974170685, -0.7880035042762756, 0.19062939286231995, -0.6113355755805969, -0.07571673393249512, -0.1612118035554886, 0.1442279815673828, -0.2824864685535431, 0.09723430126905441, -0.24016062915325165, 0.1532452255487442, -0.05831253528594971, 0.3369399309158325, -0.39896702766418457, 0.5120078921318054, 1.4342306852340698, -0.3396408259868622, -0.4308161437511444, -0.06961307674646378, -0.10538774728775024, -0.6254802346229553, -0.0036917414981871843, 0.5796474814414978, -0.23706890642642975, -0.14439572393894196, -0.0957990363240242, 1.0592308044433594, 0.4899306893348694, 0.4847005605697632, 0.4646269381046295, 0.280252605676651, -0.221352681517601, 0.5106775164604187, 0.026104962453246117, 0.4507928788661957, -0.37304797768592834, 0.08624924719333649, -0.4499269723892212, 0.01464934553951025, -0.013499625958502293, -0.5481942892074585, -0.4817419648170471, -0.5096349120140076, 0.3540891408920288, 0.5285905003547668, -0.1429319828748703, -0.8064287304878235, -0.044372159987688065, -0.46337953209877014, -0.12338518351316452, -0.21794351935386658, 0.06564706563949585, -0.18943209946155548, -0.3923589587211609, 0.24028201401233673, -0.6677794456481934, -0.18733036518096924, -0.18884484469890594, -0.5964267253875732, 0.5372986197471619, 0.015266211703419685, -0.2261306792497635, -0.1958169788122177, -1.0939662456512451, -0.362719863653183, 0.15837499499320984, 0.11868783831596375, -0.23524990677833557, 0.0241200253367424, 0.561761200428009, 0.6532902717590332, -0.45210301876068115, -0.02655929885804653, -0.2744176685810089, 0.7431519031524658, 0.8485881090164185, -0.6062119603157043, 1.0248911380767822, -0.3604162931442261, -1.061899185180664, 0.3179875910282135, -0.5059975981712341, -0.014796553179621696, 0.4574824869632721, -1.1493375301361084, -0.11015597730875015, 0.49183389544487, -0.1403857320547104, -1.1232695579528809, 0.019443577155470848, 0.6740078330039978, -0.38525980710983276, -0.402851939201355, -0.7149822115898132, 0.2451893836259842, -0.7747949957847595, 0.8670617938041687, -0.22921352088451385, 0.11001851409673691, -0.13971100747585297, 0.4050624668598175, 1.1559251546859741, -1.6680184602737427, 3.9599251747131348, 1.1476644277572632, 0.8507991433143616, 0.2185084968805313, 0.5627419948577881, 0.34758371114730835, 0.9676845669746399, 0.3050404489040375, 0.32167065143585205, -0.241702139377594, 0.255634069442749, -0.1653851568698883, 0.5227031111717224, -0.220333531498909, 0.517072856426239, 0.2476506382226944, -0.3916492164134979, 0.23156853020191193, -0.4812840521335602, -0.5208843350410461, -0.6791272163391113, 0.0415215902030468, -0.7248945236206055, 0.6390464305877686, 0.2536270022392273, 0.10766077041625977, 0.5259696245193481, 0.1653914451599121, 0.5479379296302795, 0.04030650854110718, 0.6206651926040649, -0.2691538631916046, 0.5453778505325317, -0.9320537447929382, -0.7006831169128418, 0.41162124276161194, 0.5760660767555237, -0.836664080619812, 0.946744441986084, 0.12336596846580505, 0.3788091838359833, 0.04815717414021492, 0.4050646126270294, 0.03479756787419319, -0.8408060073852539, 0.5811018347740173, -0.5143686532974243, -0.3116297125816345, -0.28968268632888794, 0.16385962069034576, 0.8963205814361572, -0.6855699419975281, 0.4108392298221588, -0.12350998818874359, -0.7742024660110474, -0.4256308078765869, -0.10463079810142517, -1.0925880670547485, -0.07866605371236801, 0.416479229927063, 0.9819236993789673, -0.4546970725059509, -0.02337411232292652, -0.8291051387786865, 0.4056868553161621, 0.5979605317115784, 0.71479332447052, 0.19649897515773773, 0.027795687317848206, -0.6180925369262695, -0.22410285472869873, -0.025085898116230965, -0.035782188177108765, -0.1511102318763733, 0.7199480533599854, 0.12258534878492355, -0.3733668029308319, 0.4906957447528839, 0.03945573791861534, -0.6580153703689575, -0.2319490760564804, -0.5997785925865173, 0.2816954553127289, -0.14522287249565125, -0.05634734034538269, 0.6325303912162781, 0.012675892561674118, -0.07879383862018585, -0.9983464479446411, 0.9629349708557129, 1.2262413501739502, -0.08675200492143631, 0.19435898959636688, 0.16300344467163086, 0.20767512917518616 ]
{"Title": "A study of knowledge, experience and beliefs about hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection in south western Uganda", "Authors": "Mugisha Joseph, Mokaya Jolynne, Bukenya Dominic, Ssembajja Fatuma, Mayambala Denis, Newton Robert, Matthews Philippa C, Seeley Janet", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Introduction United Nations sustainable development goals aim for the elimination of viral hepatitis as a public health threat by 2030, leading to efforts to upscale the availability and accessibility of hepatitis B virus (HBV) vaccination, diagnosis and treatment globally. However, a variety of societal factors, including beliefs, traditions, and stigma, can be a major obstacle to all of these interventions. We therefore set out to investigate how HBV is understood and described in communities in Uganda, and whether there is evidence of potential stigma. Method We carried out a qualitative formative study in two sites in South Western Uganda: a village in Kalungu district (site A) and an area on the outskirts of Masaka town (site B). We undertook a rapid assessment to investigate how adults describe HBV infection and their perceptions about the infection. We collected data by conducting a transect walk, observations, community group discussions, and in-depth interviews, sampling a total of 131 individuals. We used inductive content analysis to extract key themes associated with HBV. Results There is no specific word for HBV infection in local languages, and knowledge about this infection is varied. While some individuals were completely unfamiliar with HBV infection, some had heard of HBV. Radio was a common source of information. There was awareness of HBV as a cause of liver disease, limited knowledge regarding the cause, mode of transmission and treatment. Stigma in HBV may be rare in this community due to limited understanding and experience of HBV. Conclusion There is an ongoing need to improve awareness and understanding of HBV in this community. Careful dissemination of accurate information is required to promote acceptance of interventions for prevention, diagnosis and treatment.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003129"}
10.1101/19000422
[ 0.05320221930742264, -0.1020016223192215, 0.034200191497802734, 0.8605629801750183, -0.24767270684242249, -0.9051303267478943, 0.1395682692527771, 0.12584829330444336, 0.7055087685585022, 0.9092994332313538, -0.08280103653669357, -0.6233119964599609, 0.5514768958091736, 0.03979958966374397, 0.20203617215156555, 0.24667342007160187, -0.8209896683692932, 0.1259559839963913, -0.17377278208732605, 0.3540647625923157, 0.3663333058357239, 0.443572461605072, -0.596661388874054, -0.38363873958587646, -0.2200840413570404, 0.8700230717658997, 0.12800233066082, 0.4160122871398926, 1.148626446723938, 0.8408872485160828, -0.016804901883006096, -0.3734394907951355, 0.35775110125541687, -0.6406328082084656, -0.4788302183151245, -0.17812339961528778, 0.6846759915351868, -0.7810359001159668, 0.1321154683828354, -0.25476738810539246, 0.17258219420909882, -0.4819331765174866, 0.6598011255264282, -0.6166775822639465, -0.5794200301170349, -0.24141721427440643, -0.19375714659690857, -0.1456170380115509, 0.1980062872171402, -0.24964533746242523, -0.3849523365497589, 0.16177482903003693, -0.4006322920322418, -0.3993161916732788, -0.21788053214550018, -0.03843022510409355, -0.05176687240600586, 0.5440951585769653, -0.3378821313381195, -0.48402684926986694, 0.4861493408679962, -0.21783040463924408, 0.28294122219085693, -1.0016437768936157, 0.29072171449661255, 0.9747356176376343, 0.12278261035680771, -0.46008071303367615, -0.2164900004863739, -0.2826040983200073, -0.401233047246933, -0.15886849164962769, -0.43159401416778564, -0.4367975890636444, -0.3498286306858063, -0.16582421958446503, 0.005451406352221966, -0.14399811625480652, -0.14611399173736572, -0.6714913845062256, 0.24220196902751923, 0.3606029748916626, 0.031655196100473404, 0.23983648419380188, -0.39747190475463867, -0.02210298366844654, 0.09646496921777725, 0.4968423545360565, 0.3328928053379059, 0.162274569272995, 0.1494545191526413, 0.1715417504310608, -0.0550452396273613, 0.809320867061615, 0.2786144018173218, 1.2132527828216553, -0.5491175651550293, -0.08513304591178894, 0.32888832688331604, 0.3391871452331543, 0.7341803908348083, 0.8946846723556519, -0.3915311396121979, 1.1449623107910156, -0.7156179547309875, 0.4007699489593506, 0.2834203541278839, -0.698847234249115, -0.09582933038473129, -0.6780579090118408, 0.007114174775779247, 0.16463595628738403, -0.5589618682861328, -0.5098901987075806, 0.8535268306732178, 0.2515382766723633, 0.023980489000678062, 0.8855122923851013, -0.24959714710712433, 1.3182753324508667, -0.29362958669662476, -0.10889160633087158, 0.6122403144836426, -0.5910206437110901, 0.4354511797428131, 0.08764570951461792, 0.10111427307128906, 0.8207594156265259, -1.1027778387069702, -0.0011558745754882693, 0.49799782037734985, -0.7061688899993896, -0.03296174854040146, 0.49214857816696167, 0.12382251024246216, -0.4705580770969391, 0.8832496404647827, 1.527038812637329, -0.26154765486717224, -0.08849667757749557, -0.6292892098426819, 0.12288425117731094, -0.42395734786987305, 0.9628021121025085, -0.15299491584300995, 0.8893086314201355, -0.9101967811584473, -1.2762967348098755, -0.5405536890029907, -0.014439612627029419, 0.6522287726402283, 0.48548978567123413, 0.5516775846481323, 0.12242640554904938, -0.5080757141113281, -0.02475830540060997, -0.509695827960968, 0.6919913291931152, -0.24696162343025208, -0.21319624781608582, -0.7508095502853394, 0.006040157284587622, 0.10751346498727798, 0.6204516291618347, -0.8097532391548157, 0.38886386156082153, -0.29330071806907654, 0.3447110652923584, 0.7552681565284729, -0.2927309274673462, 0.6307144165039062, 1.1368403434753418, -0.08653926849365234, 0.00967288389801979, 0.3536527752876282, 1.011438012123108, 0.954985499382019, -0.08347067981958389, 0.6169387698173523, 0.48977798223495483, 0.4047137200832367, -0.4605315625667572, 0.34310877323150635, 0.8425906300544739, -0.043294887989759445, 0.002147809835150838, -0.44430646300315857, -0.9851682782173157, -0.6792611479759216, -0.36144256591796875, -0.02363119274377823, 0.13372458517551422, -0.6929224133491516, 1.0751971006393433, 0.12206809967756271, -0.20493857562541962, -0.36855757236480713, 0.5177320837974548, 0.5357682704925537, 0.1493518203496933, -0.6526045799255371, 0.4883612394332886, -0.07931113243103027, -0.06955184042453766, -0.1974126100540161, 0.6938670873641968, 0.1876385360956192, 0.43928107619285583, -0.25296449661254883, -0.04435700550675392, 0.9530617594718933, -0.10141065716743469, -0.09759169071912766, -0.2767989933490753, 0.7419189810752869, -0.25954657793045044, -0.15781059861183167, -0.2123706042766571, -0.8625035285949707, -0.41064128279685974, -0.5511619448661804, 0.5515791773796082, 0.6481354236602783, -0.6166607737541199, -0.447926789522171, -0.02007427252829075, 0.31300419569015503, -0.09164240211248398, -0.1501922756433487, 0.05061522126197815, 0.07729106396436691, 0.45628127455711365, 0.17144231498241425, 1.1319267749786377, 0.713853657245636, 0.1256345808506012, -0.11547882854938507, 0.9413008093833923, 0.28756535053253174, 0.5394725203514099, 0.6005799174308777, 0.518410325050354, -0.05769582837820053, 0.0888148620724678, -0.24072295427322388, 0.5036153197288513, -0.45078152418136597, 0.2556399405002594, -0.14319449663162231, 0.17554813623428345, -0.39930975437164307, 0.724743664264679, 0.14782705903053284, 0.38994282484054565, -1.3149502277374268, -0.2116350531578064, 0.4954833686351776, -0.23992794752120972, -0.14266765117645264, -0.24885383248329163, -0.3014669418334961, 0.47130513191223145, -0.1603943556547165, 0.08252658694982529, 0.9331678152084351, 0.5173320770263672, -0.054817695170640945, 0.1846821904182434, 0.8294864296913147, 0.47943153977394104, -1.1148945093154907, -0.19683292508125305, -1.4674972295761108, -0.9212990999221802, -1.0943636894226074, 0.5512996315956116, -0.2504640817642212, -0.194377601146698, 0.23044036328792572, 0.5195674300193787, 0.7721525430679321, 0.39604198932647705, 0.5924655795097351, 0.3847958445549011, 0.17474202811717987, 0.11710503697395325, -1.105112910270691, 0.3447791337966919, -0.7205104231834412, 0.1457035392522812, -0.2592281699180603, -0.3544744551181793, -0.5077610611915588, -0.1852388232946396, 0.150577113032341, -0.7325427532196045, -0.1872236579656601, -0.12343770265579224, -0.7384198904037476, -0.21320848166942596, 0.2437337338924408, -0.16015316545963287, 0.18949560821056366, -0.20505291223526, -0.5103169679641724, 0.6173759698867798, 0.009811547584831715, 0.4196489155292511, 0.5035061240196228, 0.3400905728340149, -0.4480840265750885, -0.11215037852525711, 0.6032100319862366, -0.24658480286598206, -0.9617090225219727, -0.4703463315963745, 0.36075398325920105, -0.502400815486908, 0.5310312509536743, -0.22508861124515533, -0.5866735577583313, -0.25362178683280945, -0.06566669046878815, 0.40566036105155945, -0.35973966121673584, 0.15987324714660645, 0.15604594349861145, -1.139532208442688, 0.48989421129226685, -0.3187626004219055, -0.8516744375228882, 0.41320276260375977, 0.07970850169658661, 0.5185112357139587, -0.3194218873977661, -0.35035088658332825, -0.6484342813491821, -0.18893814086914062, -0.0851641520857811, 0.5728942155838013, 0.3106914758682251, -0.4190601706504822, -0.2941552996635437, -0.01385473646223545, -0.49307408928871155, 0.16744080185890198, 0.09050630778074265, -0.5255641341209412, -0.3077930808067322, -0.37587979435920715, -0.22148121893405914, 1.0039411783218384, 0.674368679523468, 0.38581421971321106, -0.0004649171023629606, 0.6353675127029419, -0.39955607056617737, -0.14163075387477875, 0.3364024758338928, 0.32207730412483215, 0.17074929177761078, 0.17877715826034546, -0.8536367416381836, 0.5292044281959534, -0.5975145697593689, -0.9831658601760864, 0.8249757289886475, -0.23163269460201263, 0.4005064368247986, -0.037393052130937576, 0.8737074136734009, 0.09932295233011246, 0.12716911733150482, 0.032746821641922, -0.3346624970436096, -0.8852432370185852, 1.003257155418396, 0.3767760396003723, 1.2411367893218994, -1.1405811309814453, 0.5282042622566223, 0.0715513750910759, 0.9506750106811523, 0.4123401939868927, -0.02633890137076378, 0.519058883190155, -1.3225107192993164, 0.6978802680969238, 0.055148035287857056, -0.19232051074504852, 0.714693009853363, 0.12713730335235596, -0.21488405764102936, -0.32831668853759766, -0.4610035717487335, 0.016888685524463654, 0.23231717944145203, 0.17928098142147064, -0.2894168198108673, -0.5633096694946289, 1.418807864189148, 0.06939354538917542, 0.3104942739009857, 0.38805821537971497, 0.5636734366416931, 0.3105023205280304, -0.4033295512199402, 0.23767392337322235, 0.23116673529148102, -0.3880913257598877, -0.5409935712814331, -0.7646726965904236, -0.29615136981010437, -0.1916230022907257, 0.680449903011322, -0.06350681185722351, -0.5422195792198181, -1.2846393585205078, -0.42170414328575134, 0.42009323835372925, 0.24870331585407257, 0.4924981892108917, -0.6401530504226685, 0.39090535044670105, -0.32500576972961426, -0.5422968864440918, -0.32680073380470276, -0.2812829315662384, 0.3215208649635315, 1.0002890825271606, -0.7675243020057678, -0.69670170545578, -0.30389001965522766, -0.3047867715358734, -0.00779251242056489, 0.25288912653923035, -0.656644880771637, -0.22384989261627197, 0.34013739228248596, -0.30477264523506165, -0.41611236333847046, -0.5185328125953674, 0.40486425161361694, 0.10298187285661697, 0.12425603717565536, 0.6018915176391602, 0.5207714438438416, 0.7812275886535645, 1.2308785915374756, -0.0011455832282081246, -0.00022866814106237143, -0.7092905640602112, 0.3799155652523041, -0.30840784311294556, -0.5837501287460327, -0.18807390332221985, 0.06922979652881622, 0.18409335613250732, 0.13287580013275146, -0.550339937210083, 0.16386869549751282, -0.3399249017238617, -0.17047534883022308, -0.10154126584529877, -0.4351039230823517, 0.8060604929924011, -0.9626674056053162, -0.1009405255317688, 1.400973916053772, -0.38606202602386475, -0.32332780957221985, -0.6642216444015503, -0.05418311432003975, -0.9903790354728699, 0.5833964943885803, 0.26281502842903137, 0.3510057032108307, -0.2958782911300659, -0.5228193402290344, 0.10759861022233963, 0.2082871049642563, 0.5764110088348389, -0.6595842838287354, 0.26334521174430847, -1.0052725076675415, -0.8236278295516968, -0.4087071120738983, -0.47899460792541504, -0.5888971090316772, 0.4778856933116913, 0.2156347632408142, -0.7219585180282593, -0.4715729355812073, -0.09172803908586502, -0.10476565361022949, -0.12398910522460938, -0.3589632213115692, -0.008667894639074802, -0.8672757148742676, 0.2978809177875519, 1.0463162660598755, -0.13731814920902252, -1.2121206521987915, 0.005090679507702589, 0.3743530511856079, -0.46782901883125305, -0.41790878772735596, 0.10214155912399292, 0.2351030856370926, -0.023351512849330902, -0.4891078472137451, 0.09399320185184479, -0.42684346437454224, 0.12077908962965012, -0.11776135116815567, -0.23061293363571167, 0.5986478924751282, -0.05795268714427948, -0.5870329737663269, 0.23425409197807312, 0.255433589220047, -0.49560844898223877, -0.007847370579838753, 0.1980246603488922, -0.11861313879489899, -0.1510709673166275, -0.010205063968896866, -0.8319712281227112, 0.1135459914803505, -1.0922611951828003, -0.16407927870750427, -0.6923795938491821, 0.3305172622203827, 0.07719389349222183, -0.505662202835083, 0.15416665375232697, 0.61219722032547, 0.13669821619987488, -0.09113724529743195, -0.3162664473056793, 0.05466834828257561, 0.47155025601387024, 0.1958066076040268, -0.5246331691741943, -0.27087491750717163, -0.2052970677614212, 0.3496873676776886, 0.5568476915359497, 0.2950681746006012, -0.35070207715034485, -0.2005414366722107, -0.15320135653018951, 0.3143866956233978, 0.20748978853225708, -0.26095953583717346, 0.03217059373855591, 0.05623841658234596, 0.5069698095321655, -0.12404955923557281, 0.2883346378803253, -0.7889594435691833, 0.14233510196208954, -0.6408271789550781, 0.4014674723148346, -0.6592741012573242, -0.37558650970458984, -0.18856024742126465, -0.30706438422203064, 1.4098315238952637, -1.0101895332336426, 0.10000314563512802, 0.1499251425266266, -0.3480697274208069, -0.010134858079254627, 0.28156721591949463, -0.5928874015808105, -0.676578164100647, -0.44765427708625793, -0.29871565103530884, -0.08762963861227036, -0.021037673577666283, -0.22428974509239197, 0.4223250150680542, -0.13209837675094604, 0.06487207859754562, -0.1533799171447754, 0.5502124428749084, 0.10429609566926956, -0.7160857319831848, -0.7533736824989319, 0.4451170861721039, 0.04447568580508232, 0.12232368439435959, 0.4507001042366028, 0.23374298214912415, -0.5402141213417053, 0.3149412274360657, -0.5370776653289795, -0.5236428380012512, -0.8024040460586548, 0.14196042716503143, 0.16364334523677826, 0.9373980164527893, -0.35822153091430664, -0.12245578318834305, 0.3771485686302185, -0.1714422106742859, -0.5753660202026367, 0.44022881984710693, -0.9020988941192627, 0.09506811201572418, 0.9800580739974976, -0.45739927887916565, 0.01965712010860443, -0.2678512632846832, -0.3602992296218872, 0.12133632600307465, -0.04877563938498497, 0.02069089747965336, 0.29411885142326355, -0.5678967237472534, 0.6430376172065735, 0.6097925901412964, -0.6678234338760376, -0.07985015213489532, -0.0470513179898262, 0.33756697177886963, 0.228448748588562, -0.3776446282863617, -0.5784958600997925, 0.1805301308631897, -0.14021232724189758, 1.1950736045837402, -0.6719894409179688, 0.42521509528160095, 0.1587919145822525, -0.6863539814949036, 0.6737394332885742, -0.5121139287948608, -0.09944294393062592, 0.5192463397979736, -0.49490559101104736, -0.0411628857254982, 0.578018069267273, 0.44162240624427795, 0.3502606451511383, 0.4052866995334625, 0.49791327118873596, -0.5494250059127808, -0.13934846222400665, -0.18119961023330688, 0.6067217588424683, 0.2327440232038498, -0.04568757116794586, -0.20366917550563812, 0.20435689389705658, -0.11673127859830856, -0.5686513781547546, -0.9576019644737244, 0.16475698351860046, 0.12766200304031372, 0.680890679359436, -0.039977967739105225, 0.2157026082277298, 0.8504722118377686, 0.24220138788223267, 0.24410805106163025, -0.3458300530910492, -1.4143948554992676, -0.5262359380722046, 0.12504322826862335, 0.02980515919625759, -0.5769001841545105, -0.3693424165248871, 0.25029799342155457, -0.32422471046447754, -0.5899968147277832, -0.37596774101257324, 0.6334518790245056, -0.5295121669769287, -0.221960186958313, -0.4861252009868622, 0.7955653667449951, -0.6047911643981934, -0.4620320498943329, -0.2856815755367279, -0.5272414684295654, 0.003841649740934372, 0.8309796452522278, -1.1954481601715088, -0.4447353780269623, 0.12955047190189362, -0.2884391248226166, -0.25642120838165283, 0.21271561086177826, -0.3640058636665344, -0.6136803030967712, -0.23130911588668823, 0.49194005131721497, 0.3001824617385864, 0.43285855650901794, 1.0638110637664795, 0.2092152237892151, 0.282597154378891, 0.0994323119521141, -0.0095295999199152, -0.30150139331817627, -0.39101481437683105, -0.045812588185071945, -0.49119436740875244, -0.8325928449630737, -0.32820549607276917, 1.1253808736801147, -0.7695836424827576, 0.13917392492294312, -0.4793446958065033, -0.5579240918159485, -0.07892849296331406, -0.20961645245552063, -0.35415327548980713, 0.8030505776405334, -0.3583083152770996, 0.7081109881401062, 0.07006784528493881, 0.7655107378959656, -0.25373050570487976, -0.010379510000348091, 0.06852008402347565, -0.09076394140720367, -0.3477316200733185, -1.0011494159698486, -0.7759948968887329, 0.5317067503929138, -0.827701210975647, 0.017351388931274414, -0.5254276990890503, 0.17350035905838013, 0.36799779534339905, -0.3615514636039734, 0.09890511631965637, 1.1952781677246094, 0.26483723521232605, 0.8940022587776184, 0.17810989916324615, -0.05371585115790367, -0.6781710386276245, -0.872755229473114, -1.2912451028823853, -0.46780842542648315, 0.6474602222442627, -0.017911551520228386, -0.18437552452087402, -0.41463980078697205, -0.5076069235801697, 1.0047591924667358, -0.030920730903744698, 0.5081287026405334, -0.027398519217967987, 1.1764928102493286, -0.2563973367214203, 0.14851705729961395, 0.20155847072601318, -0.023407796397805214, 0.497721791267395, 0.20369550585746765, -0.6450873613357544, -0.0959707573056221, 0.44970136880874634, 0.5160274505615234, 0.19032569229602814, 0.867915689945221, -0.05012596771121025, 0.2139948457479477, -0.4409838616847992, -0.3418889045715332, 0.06017773225903511, 0.09459807723760605, -1.0595041513442993, 0.11508546769618988, 0.3549889922142029, 0.013331298716366291, -0.8719081282615662, 0.68185955286026, 0.19737263023853302, -0.88045334815979, -0.7680250406265259, 0.5312157869338989, 0.723206102848053, -0.5540106296539307, 0.17581723630428314, -0.4767170250415802, 0.1535792350769043, 0.06883595883846283, -0.8887725472450256, -0.20143857598304749, 0.5575332045555115, -0.12214939296245575, -0.09279701858758926, -0.3613993525505066, 0.14800964295864105, 0.9554596543312073, 1.1615946292877197, 0.18146738409996033, 0.4375957250595093, 0.3860012888908386, 0.4761546850204468, 0.2568076252937317, -0.45797231793403625, 0.6168477535247803, 0.13664130866527557, -0.6273730993270874, -0.043646782636642456, 0.5867032408714294, 0.3968900740146637, -0.03455955162644386, -0.8262561559677124, 0.4121302366256714, -0.4250149428844452, -0.8707565665245056, -0.5136452317237854, 0.43862441182136536, 0.7831251621246338, 0.38448092341423035, 0.7078860998153687, 0.21743713319301605, 0.20843765139579773, -0.33541736006736755, 0.5767704844474792, 0.8309922814369202, -0.04395820572972298, -0.47747352719306946, 0.2594873905181885, 0.4183880388736725, -0.34897667169570923, 0.3398470878601074, 0.7415832877159119, 0.04970728978514671, 0.4781542420387268, 0.7115964293479919, -0.05911115184426308, -0.3713831901550293, 0.5291305780410767, -0.3654046356678009, -0.11125290393829346, -0.5666322112083435, 0.06164334714412689, -0.32374492287635803, -0.39336442947387695, 0.7644100785255432, -0.025029432028532028, -0.1232619360089302, -0.3811032474040985, 0.03518169745802879, 0.23524513840675354, 0.20650358498096466, 0.1625298261642456, -0.6474341750144958, 0.15974120795726776, 0.42343154549598694, -0.17247554659843445, -0.058089178055524826, -0.3640037775039673, -0.045728396624326706, 0.43290582299232483, -0.28689339756965637, 0.45350736379623413, -0.08962449431419373, 0.21144461631774902, -0.5761474967002869, 0.4416538178920746, -0.8786894679069519, -0.34533634781837463, -0.6230223178863525, -0.44548994302749634, 0.4765815734863281, 0.49725615978240967, -0.4029861092567444, -0.10245087742805481, -0.30604591965675354, -0.41385555267333984, -0.26645520329475403, -0.5755552053451538, -0.5699486136436462, 0.34438851475715637, -0.6417369246482849, 0.5313777923583984, 0.24943232536315918, -0.0053061372600495815, -0.2626371681690216, -1.1338367462158203, -0.34252917766571045, -0.2790679931640625, -0.15038661658763885, -0.673056423664093, 0.09689964354038239, 0.10050550848245621, 0.7418617010116577, 0.6036820411682129, -0.13312436640262604, 0.06889268755912781, 0.5325657725334167, 0.5870851874351501, -0.4012245535850525, 0.04869646206498146, 0.18603482842445374, 0.5740790963172913, 0.4714306890964508, -0.5353954434394836, 0.06391257047653198, 0.02108006738126278, -0.8733358979225159, 0.1131645068526268, 0.21897444128990173, 0.3847794830799103, -0.7805886268615723, 0.43389609456062317, 0.374769002199173, 0.1522543728351593, 0.04304478317499161, -0.6747634410858154, -0.22225235402584076, -0.6603168845176697, 1.3335306644439697, -0.24401289224624634, 0.09232944995164871, 0.504252016544342, 0.08179274201393127, 0.6834214329719543, -0.7172804474830627, 4.174802780151367, 0.7445275783538818, 0.1932523399591446, -0.4348052740097046, 0.7447987794876099, 0.23488394916057587, 0.5595187544822693, -0.031173747032880783, 0.6662104725837708, 0.4395442008972168, -0.5908600091934204, 0.15729501843452454, 0.317430704832077, -0.205499067902565, 0.12536489963531494, 0.5597831010818481, -0.9785320162773132, 0.48495322465896606, -0.4800947606563568, -0.8657517433166504, -0.1809687316417694, -0.06769828498363495, -0.1288766711950302, -0.15959541499614716, -0.4509876072406769, -0.1527637243270874, 0.4159676432609558, 0.05666213855147362, 0.2854502499103546, -0.030790286138653755, 0.0801975354552269, -0.9173089861869812, 0.30283769965171814, -0.8381754159927368, -0.9393213987350464, 0.2750830054283142, -0.2703143358230591, -0.46545374393463135, -0.08417471498250961, -0.2722046673297882, 0.256104052066803, 0.01588280312716961, -0.3138446509838104, -0.24642108380794525, -0.29363980889320374, 0.6437994241714478, -0.582011878490448, -0.0242396742105484, 0.6153287291526794, -0.2430564910173416, 1.1997110843658447, -1.0185894966125488, 0.4831862151622772, -0.2995365560054779, -0.6897451877593994, -0.7759041786193848, 0.09014227986335754, -0.6826110482215881, 0.6584738492965698, -0.41720083355903625, 1.0172255039215088, -0.22972789406776428, 0.13411875069141388, -0.1372021734714508, -0.0637880340218544, 0.47231823205947876, 0.5383931994438171, -0.5508667826652527, 0.5274298787117004, -0.22944581508636475, -0.21592484414577484, 0.2549789845943451, -0.44977807998657227, 0.06221165880560875, 0.9019985198974609, 0.52005535364151, -0.7006384134292603, 0.8499662280082703, 0.08481403440237045, -0.4693458378314972, -0.4334607422351837, 0.4282057285308838, 0.14346501231193542, -0.08655663579702377, -0.1712217628955841, 0.8982966542243958, -0.44177499413490295, -0.553462028503418, -1.037304401397705, -0.01241392269730568, 0.6056463718414307, -0.4669882655143738, 0.29179760813713074, -0.10778416693210602, 0.3455520570278168 ]
{"Title": "Characteristics, service use and mortality of clusters of multimorbid patients in England: a population-based study", "Authors": "Zhu Yajing, Edwards Duncan, Mant Jonathan, Payne Rupert A, Kiddle Steven", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Multimorbidity is one of the principal challenges facing health systems worldwide. To help understand the changes to services and policies that are required to deliver better care, we used a novel approach to investigate which diseases co-occur and how combinations are associated with mortality and service use. Methods Linked primary and secondary care electronic health records contributed by 382 general practices in England to the Clinical Practice Research Datalink (CPRD) were used. The study included a representative set of multimorbid adults (18 years old or more) with two or more long-term conditions (N=113,211). A random set of 80% of the multimorbid patients (N=90,571) were stratified by age and clustered using latent class analysis. Consistency between obtained disease profiles, classification quality and associations with demographic characteristics and primary outcomes (hospitalisation, polypharmacy and mortality) was validated in the remaining 20% of multimorbid patients (N=22,640). Findings We identified twenty patient clusters across four age strata. The clusters with the highest mortality comprised psychoactive substance and alcohol misuse (aged 18-64), coronary heart disease, depression and pain (aged 65-84) and coronary heart disease, heart failure and atrial fibrillation (aged 85+). The clusters with the highest service use coincided with those with highest mortality for people aged over 65. For people aged 18-64, the cluster with the highest service use comprised depression, anxiety and pain. The majority of 85+ year olds multimorbid patients belonged to the cluster with the lowest service use and mortality for that age range. Pain featured in thirteen clusters. Interpretation This work has highlighted patterns of multimorbidity that have implications for health services. These include the importance of psychoactive substance and alcohol misuse in people under the age of 65; of co-morbid depression and coronary heart disease in people aged 65-84, and of cardiovascular disease in people aged 85+. Funding UK Medical Research Council Research in context Evidence before this study We searched PubMed using the keyword list \u201cmultimorbidity, co-morbidity, disease patterns, clusters, service use, long-term conditions, chronic conditions\u201d for studies published in English. We also reviewed multiple systematic reviews of multimorbidity patterns, and the policy report of multimorbidity research issued by the Academy of Medical Sciences in 2018. Most studies have focused on older populations (aged 60+) and often used a small list of long-term conditions. Multimorbidity clusters composed of more than two conditions have not been well profiled mostly due to non-representative and small samples. There is substantial heterogeneity in the number of conditions considered (often less than 20) and in the statistical methods. Most studies focused on grouping diseases rather than patients, making it less straightforward to relate patients to outcomes in order to facilitate patient-centred care. Added value of this study This study is the first to describe and validate clusters of multimorbid patients across the adult lifecourse using a patient-centred probabilistic clustering approach. This leads to a more nuanced understanding of the relationship between age, multimorbidity and mortality and new insights into the importance of different clusters. For example, contrary to perceived wisdom, we show that the majority of 85+ year old multimorbid patients belong to a cluster with relatively low service use and mortality for that age group. We identify a cluster of younger multimorbid patients with psychoactive substance misuse that have a mortality rate 18 times higher than their non-multimorbid peers. Implications of all the available evidence We have validated and added to the list of disease combinations where tailored approaches could be attempted to better manage multimorbid patients and develop effective interventions. For example, the high mortality of younger multimorbid patients with psychoactive substance misuse might be reduced by addressing risk factors (e.g. drug use, smoking, deprivation) which are amenable to intervention.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000422"}
10.1101/19010975
[ 0.19090348482131958, 0.3746704161167145, -0.514748752117157, -0.24349606037139893, -0.03763457015156746, -0.11266230791807175, 0.35169005393981934, -0.14836353063583374, 0.270380437374115, 1.03498113155365, -0.14981497824192047, -0.41901442408561707, 0.11008326709270477, -0.49885982275009155, 0.09486069530248642, 0.4801461100578308, -0.982111930847168, 0.03839603066444397, 0.021475933492183685, -0.2172738015651703, 0.3860315680503845, 0.2974916994571686, -0.9571202397346497, -0.21361468732357025, -1.1704753637313843, 0.037655893713235855, 0.16143015027046204, -0.027190279215574265, 1.5534688234329224, 0.8542502522468567, -0.3765198588371277, -0.4177306890487671, 0.49160006642341614, -0.3275127708911896, -0.34455743432044983, 0.16277369856834412, 0.27170518040657043, -0.21464474499225616, -0.278825581073761, -0.5158794522285461, 0.15141764283180237, 0.4827992916107178, -0.02951795980334282, -0.6831628084182739, -0.6295843124389648, -0.5411901473999023, 0.06905148923397064, -0.14963367581367493, -0.5771960616111755, -0.5331531167030334, -0.6990630626678467, -0.24789594113826752, -0.1954270452260971, -0.58381587266922, 0.08420306444168091, 0.3821561932563782, 0.6346613168716431, 0.6621265411376953, -0.560816764831543, 0.18431106209754944, 0.48323842883110046, -0.33424875140190125, 0.36461010575294495, -0.7248716354370117, 0.4902079999446869, 0.6225734353065491, -0.3641447126865387, -0.5700360536575317, -0.1365714967250824, -0.6773330569267273, -0.9638132452964783, 0.618399977684021, -0.16397374868392944, -0.6862040758132935, -0.9816573858261108, -0.05472517013549805, 0.013169816695153713, 0.7924160361289978, -0.680857241153717, -0.3814196288585663, 0.1869627833366394, 0.32193318009376526, -0.32391026616096497, 0.33952465653419495, -0.03836141899228096, -0.5237318277359009, 1.001497507095337, 0.13201454281806946, -0.07618019729852676, 0.21525436639785767, 0.20129606127738953, 0.15459585189819336, 0.16637209057807922, 0.4065499007701874, 0.03255216032266617, 0.9914959669113159, -0.5579701066017151, -0.1740511804819107, -0.08471136540174484, -0.1347363144159317, 1.4961601495742798, 1.4457882642745972, -0.008671908639371395, 0.8362153768539429, -1.1727432012557983, 0.6969794034957886, 0.5941994190216064, -0.4624769687652588, -0.25159752368927, -0.7929976582527161, -0.3018321692943573, 0.7051695585250854, -0.6330327987670898, -0.4706851541996002, -0.09702751040458679, 0.1826774775981903, 0.18468554317951202, 0.1267293095588684, -0.3588971793651581, 0.4283080995082855, -0.31758207082748413, -0.033421508967876434, 0.4698112905025482, -0.3727959990501404, 0.7756112813949585, 0.1512497514486313, 0.5663787722587585, 0.7609314322471619, -0.31027060747146606, -0.5807487368583679, 0.03436320647597313, -0.228099063038826, -0.36421966552734375, 0.8139369487762451, -0.36644652485847473, -0.43017956614494324, 0.039688147604465485, 0.45878633856773376, 0.2271323949098587, 0.2239314615726471, -0.014997421763837337, 0.2430412322282791, -0.4192216098308563, 1.4660685062408447, -0.4403284788131714, 0.049848150461912155, -0.20196019113063812, -1.7754943370819092, -0.5775099396705627, -0.28983020782470703, 0.21414703130722046, 0.9578882455825806, -0.015637272968888283, -0.27533039450645447, -1.0213569402694702, 0.2850818932056427, -0.23803064227104187, 0.23822835087776184, -0.20307877659797668, 0.2910692095756531, -0.28884536027908325, -0.25755631923675537, -0.2524406611919403, 0.49373266100883484, -0.26844799518585205, 0.31864967942237854, -0.49545273184776306, -0.21690334379673004, 0.43050339818000793, -0.3263229429721832, 0.4817451238632202, 0.0041446746326982975, -0.03924188017845154, -0.17575474083423615, 0.4284543991088867, 0.685355007648468, 0.9097522497177124, 0.21734018623828888, 0.1046745628118515, 0.3395852744579315, -0.3888986110687256, -0.4705457091331482, 0.27193254232406616, 0.27957814931869507, -0.20105664432048798, 0.46686968207359314, -0.2616432309150696, -0.33123329281806946, 0.015396629460155964, -0.1598716527223587, 0.16754965484142303, 0.266543984413147, -0.8918572068214417, 0.8226057291030884, -0.2474345713853836, -0.3505919277667999, -0.3765142858028412, 0.5776698589324951, 0.8287888765335083, -0.1161753386259079, -0.4291246235370636, 0.6432719230651855, -0.3157593309879303, 0.2165984958410263, -0.9139604568481445, 0.9223567843437195, -0.05935177952051163, 0.3761257827281952, -0.6081774830818176, 0.3296397924423218, 0.31869471073150635, -0.08986914157867432, -0.155934676527977, -0.013034399598836899, 0.7291759252548218, -0.497254341840744, -0.23321405053138733, -0.16645775735378265, 0.1480337530374527, 0.11633919179439545, -0.26954543590545654, 0.2221500277519226, 0.748439610004425, 0.16290050745010376, 0.518966794013977, -0.5483170747756958, 0.503397524356842, -0.08609005063772202, -0.21510082483291626, 0.01820775493979454, 0.49891340732574463, 0.8870641589164734, -0.7184005975723267, 0.5984166264533997, 1.1237561702728271, 0.800113320350647, 0.31556394696235657, 0.32445454597473145, 0.19584082067012787, -0.2825142741203308, 0.3070649206638336, 0.12361257523298264, 0.8598024249076843, 0.9175204634666443, 0.0021217437461018562, 0.5484164953231812, 0.024566397070884705, -0.029009362682700157, 0.1516612023115158, 0.29206371307373047, -0.37604328989982605, 0.680330753326416, 0.6213241219520569, -0.08314722031354904, -1.0086928606033325, 0.18259507417678833, 0.44728127121925354, 0.13842439651489258, -0.3118215799331665, -0.36428987979888916, -0.22456547617912292, 0.40435609221458435, -0.1177506223320961, 0.026239696890115738, 0.5901869535446167, 0.3644336462020874, 0.2154439240694046, 0.17312969267368317, -0.01537713035941124, -0.728134274482727, -1.1850529909133911, -1.017081618309021, -1.4838711023330688, -1.0374598503112793, -0.7591301202774048, -0.5464463233947754, -0.7024632096290588, -0.4191242456436157, 0.4652048349380493, -0.246917724609375, 0.06845781952142715, -0.036097414791584015, 0.32903599739074707, 0.6680175065994263, 0.0005347596015781164, 0.3501366674900055, -1.251274585723877, 0.698479950428009, -1.0074905157089233, 0.24934211373329163, -0.11191681772470474, -0.20327399671077728, -0.594054102897644, -0.3731191158294678, 0.0961749404668808, -0.826303243637085, 0.27867746353149414, -0.05914939194917679, -0.8041572570800781, -0.4948825538158417, 0.18194137513637543, -0.2086692452430725, 0.5299713611602783, 0.41553056240081787, -0.3895080089569092, 0.7163481712341309, 0.12761078774929047, 0.06353017687797546, 0.9279929399490356, 0.4024363160133362, -0.7385389804840088, 0.9280847907066345, 0.3477146029472351, -0.08025803416967392, -0.6598920822143555, 0.7480168342590332, 0.09597102552652359, -0.9119945764541626, -0.15955859422683716, -0.9978334903717041, -0.8909118175506592, 0.1735692173242569, 0.059748075902462006, -0.6077017188072205, 0.034032031893730164, 0.7433984875679016, -0.44869109988212585, -0.9920578598976135, 0.007528991438448429, -0.4690777063369751, -1.0804479122161865, 0.5312308669090271, -0.1323029100894928, 0.411880761384964, 0.617236316204071, 0.16564662754535675, 0.014038019813597202, -0.23257414996623993, -0.013465574942529202, 0.4001517593860626, -0.07648488879203796, -0.5823929905891418, -0.40863901376724243, 0.31309106945991516, -0.08101974427700043, 0.7668545842170715, 0.13929927349090576, -0.11708017438650131, -0.3669824004173279, 0.025595810264348984, -0.1788424253463745, -0.0180552639067173, 0.3652666509151459, -0.47612008452415466, -0.36888837814331055, 0.24959440529346466, -0.2970794439315796, -0.0528377965092659, 0.19379398226737976, 0.29199331998825073, -0.2266763597726822, 0.14926421642303467, -0.3753499984741211, 0.5897731184959412, -0.6108676195144653, -0.6964492797851562, 0.4873213768005371, 0.18995064496994019, 0.36261802911758423, -0.7369567155838013, 0.6586415767669678, -0.14258326590061188, -0.4255506694316864, 0.25628355145454407, -0.021535281091928482, -1.1898378133773804, 0.5791096687316895, 0.2251695692539215, 0.9236749410629272, -0.9350197911262512, 0.14355705678462982, 0.21860583126544952, 0.7816388010978699, 0.018769599497318268, 0.5892294049263, 0.881769061088562, 0.047506749629974365, -0.0747503712773323, 0.4210425317287445, 0.06234945356845856, -0.3549630641937256, 0.30472633242607117, -0.29801928997039795, -0.13011574745178223, -0.7896702289581299, -0.42773520946502686, -0.06288612633943558, 0.26282161474227905, -0.23512518405914307, -0.4337117373943329, 1.1768999099731445, -0.4754296541213989, 0.2946334481239319, 0.26922065019607544, 0.8951669335365295, -0.008156593888998032, -1.2107409238815308, -0.25468361377716064, -0.07589748501777649, -0.21943506598472595, -0.18621474504470825, -0.33219707012176514, 0.570399820804596, 0.1754932999610901, 0.47531309723854065, 0.18338429927825928, -0.10413769632577896, -0.8551185727119446, -0.5417381525039673, 0.16937623918056488, 0.6902540922164917, -0.26608559489250183, -1.163093090057373, 0.04987502098083496, -0.23731791973114014, -0.5453333258628845, -0.20128804445266724, -0.38705310225486755, 0.359698623418808, 0.6160268187522888, -0.23148781061172485, 0.1045040488243103, 0.17362816631793976, -0.15295305848121643, 0.03785921260714531, 0.4631616175174713, -0.03644638881087303, -0.5404883027076721, 0.5717027187347412, -0.7351970672607422, -0.72359699010849, -0.24000310897827148, 0.2735588252544403, 0.31893977522850037, 0.17447935044765472, -0.10225115716457367, 1.3009400367736816, 0.2844574451446533, 0.0852629616856575, 0.1255517601966858, 0.958260715007782, -1.0039033889770508, 0.7758938074111938, -0.43273791670799255, -0.4571082890033722, 0.13125313818454742, -0.3302724063396454, -0.506589412689209, 0.2551615238189697, 0.18496999144554138, 0.088374063372612, 0.014753369614481926, 0.1452886164188385, 0.007125562522560358, -0.6582813262939453, 0.8520766496658325, 0.2372647374868393, 0.31396737694740295, 1.3839333057403564, -0.5060222744941711, -0.20908260345458984, -0.27163001894950867, 0.2856409549713135, -0.5344663858413696, 0.3800402879714966, 0.06448367238044739, 0.24207453429698944, -0.09048718214035034, -0.511139452457428, -0.048689089715480804, -0.41220787167549133, 0.06074365973472595, -0.037315983325242996, -0.23981812596321106, -0.41820377111434937, -0.3216020166873932, -0.5514289140701294, -0.2653254270553589, -0.24590043723583221, 0.2324088215827942, -0.3458420932292938, -0.27796950936317444, 0.18687468767166138, -0.6577839255332947, -0.8299813866615295, 0.12040107697248459, -0.3737456500530243, -0.2905566692352295, 0.15195423364639282, -0.1792784184217453, 0.7811380624771118, -0.5855535268783569, -0.5564077496528625, 0.48743903636932373, 0.038806524127721786, -0.9282472729682922, -0.06251448392868042, -0.3950696587562561, 0.1498262733221054, -0.4010670781135559, -0.48155146837234497, 0.20779269933700562, -0.08013148605823517, 0.03733617439866066, -0.612082302570343, -0.2965971529483795, 0.12035015225410461, 0.02735116146504879, -0.29528138041496277, 0.8666712045669556, -0.45636120438575745, -1.046229600906372, -1.1456515789031982, 0.614526093006134, 0.37662044167518616, 0.28680840134620667, -0.48037832975387573, -0.5991904139518738, -0.17277409136295319, -0.8876338601112366, 0.48420631885528564, -0.6612210273742676, -0.08529942482709885, -0.05673627927899361, -0.584082305431366, -0.13373689353466034, 0.44045165181159973, 0.08967208862304688, -0.030744442716240883, -0.6369611620903015, -0.13552406430244446, 0.4047960042953491, -0.7043892741203308, -0.9897788166999817, -0.5988277792930603, -0.09456900507211685, -0.23762959241867065, 0.7331317663192749, 0.3614005446434021, -0.5195497274398804, -0.16605144739151, -0.4136268198490143, 0.5451902747154236, 0.6808071136474609, -0.5206279158592224, -0.502591609954834, 0.05961870029568672, -0.29720795154571533, 0.3941906988620758, 0.2801533639431, -0.21871419250965118, 0.09666546434164047, -0.5654743313789368, 0.08131417632102966, -0.8079994320869446, -0.38617515563964844, -0.06273071467876434, -0.3139369785785675, 0.9927558302879333, -1.032104253768921, 0.16803471744060516, 0.24516162276268005, -0.4972582459449768, -0.06768355518579483, 0.17091073095798492, -1.0433717966079712, -0.19705317914485931, -0.27575042843818665, -0.8383746147155762, 0.4143350422382355, -0.5500420331954956, 0.18450865149497986, -0.47493699193000793, 0.01156674139201641, 0.04345173016190529, -0.2998255789279938, 0.7613348364830017, 0.634028971195221, -0.29874834418296814, -0.5839019417762756, 0.10432890057563782, -0.24582915008068085, 0.5503234267234802, 0.2035253345966339, -0.20408502221107483, -0.6757025718688965, 0.29697251319885254, -0.5390979647636414, -0.33026769757270813, -0.881378710269928, -0.013995491899549961, 0.20937742292881012, 0.5808427929878235, -0.09654092788696289, 0.6877539753913879, -0.05695008113980293, 0.18614180386066437, -0.8186894655227661, 0.19342249631881714, 0.08628647029399872, 0.04550594836473465, 0.9065932631492615, -0.3138595223426819, -0.030879030004143715, 0.265938937664032, -0.13263452053070068, -0.16104882955551147, 0.06543575972318649, -0.037642695009708405, -0.13412301242351532, -0.8250206112861633, 0.05084007978439331, 0.29104334115982056, -0.300014853477478, -0.6045148968696594, 0.42921334505081177, -0.0883922278881073, 0.3576735854148865, -0.5369005799293518, -0.3881271481513977, 0.66176837682724, -0.052354585379362106, 0.2950238883495331, -0.2706931233406067, -0.21164707839488983, -0.21617981791496277, 0.38595789670944214, 0.32126927375793457, -1.102192759513855, 0.3317982852458954, 0.8649728298187256, -0.0921468734741211, 0.3856562077999115, 0.5164551734924316, 0.48163560032844543, 0.5199990272521973, -0.3442652225494385, 0.7947374582290649, -0.250908762216568, -0.3827756345272064, 0.5570380091667175, 0.0036636805161833763, 0.0006138654425740242, -0.22635596990585327, -0.24465391039848328, 0.918360710144043, 0.9531519412994385, 0.00610688328742981, -0.6771288514137268, 0.3730252981185913, 0.46190592646598816, 0.4445919394493103, -0.016471797600388527, 0.3670442998409271, 0.6614654064178467, 0.8834471106529236, 0.14210814237594604, -0.15689119696617126, -0.620758593082428, -0.7457693815231323, -0.6391435265541077, 0.3033471703529358, -0.23468101024627686, -0.47881829738616943, 1.0083961486816406, -0.4375256299972534, -0.6874695420265198, 0.34229397773742676, 1.1652933359146118, -0.5201530456542969, -0.21445690095424652, -0.7580881714820862, 0.578698456287384, -0.6491795778274536, -0.602922797203064, -0.11946821957826614, -0.3190290033817291, 0.5319920182228088, 1.2099071741104126, -0.3107587397098541, 0.15620581805706024, 0.5938239693641663, 0.16783396899700165, -0.3828527331352234, -0.14193668961524963, -0.4095728099346161, 0.05899906903505325, 0.07005856931209564, 0.44259920716285706, -0.24165107309818268, 0.7294013500213623, 0.5342592000961304, -0.8699243068695068, 0.198098286986351, 0.33274269104003906, 0.16885624825954437, -0.4569854736328125, 0.02162652648985386, 0.22469261288642883, -0.5710529088973999, -0.04972420260310173, -0.3966341018676758, 0.7225690484046936, -0.5584462881088257, -0.0793367549777031, 0.32108238339424133, -0.1903577297925949, 0.22401775419712067, -0.04467783123254776, 0.3677731454372406, 0.8962289690971375, 0.014267219230532646, 0.14360032975673676, -0.08610215783119202, 0.34403151273727417, 0.018379222601652145, -0.07859903573989868, 0.9211545586585999, -0.22090205550193787, 0.03594215586781502, -1.5416141748428345, 0.6738658547401428, 0.3059100806713104, -0.44360411167144775, -0.24884313344955444, -0.4323734939098358, 0.03509606420993805, -0.008960487321019173, 0.015542651526629925, 0.39040160179138184, 0.6125912666320801, 1.0161296129226685, -0.03214064612984657, 0.2767401933670044, -0.25723475217819214, -0.5722752213478088, -0.3027491569519043, -0.9416521787643433, -0.28321659564971924, 0.37049150466918945, 0.13070958852767944, -0.07155193388462067, -0.46374326944351196, -0.440822035074234, 0.11229506880044937, 0.5969563722610474, 0.23121562600135803, 0.16922414302825928, 0.71378493309021, 0.07370427995920181, 0.08987591415643692, -0.2949531376361847, -0.2108483910560608, 0.21409852802753448, -0.179817795753479, -0.42189812660217285, -0.3970422148704529, 0.6036456227302551, 0.41542044281959534, 0.49497196078300476, -0.1515774130821228, -0.34809863567352295, 0.3220001459121704, 0.6861954927444458, 0.10740412026643753, -0.887316882610321, 0.16722789406776428, -0.49164071679115295, 0.23692640662193298, -0.2646176218986511, 0.33087053894996643, -0.2165205478668213, 0.2790973484516144, 0.15616865456104279, -0.48680129647254944, -0.5714977979660034, -0.29189029335975647, 0.40406322479248047, -1.1363967657089233, 0.5068266987800598, 0.3990941047668457, 0.45817771553993225, -0.6116284728050232, 0.057544250041246414, 0.5934110283851624, 0.07780224084854126, -0.3493229150772095, -0.29749590158462524, -0.41479307413101196, 0.10879059880971909, 0.8970963954925537, 0.2587953507900238, 0.21737465262413025, 1.0785636901855469, -0.11332888901233673, 0.12331244349479675, 0.14419133961200714, -0.019697699695825577, 1.248512625694275, 0.13971540331840515, 0.440618097782135, -0.14377887547016144, 0.8142154812812805, -0.12487156689167023, 0.049760472029447556, -0.3203938901424408, -0.008829307742416859, -0.3667426109313965, -1.0122636556625366, -0.10807397961616516, 0.10079289972782135, 0.828848659992218, -0.0037593385204672813, 0.2409147173166275, -0.09087733179330826, 0.5297929644584656, 0.09761497378349304, 0.3436236083507538, 0.9462749361991882, 0.21850045025348663, -0.29575514793395996, -0.31298190355300903, 0.25849902629852295, -1.0136409997940063, 0.4617440104484558, 0.38486766815185547, -0.10381855815649033, 0.09991332143545151, 0.8577796816825867, 0.33698639273643494, -0.5911902785301208, 0.6988736391067505, -0.14764362573623657, 0.095961794257164, -1.0297565460205078, 0.44391700625419617, -0.4546579420566559, 0.0034672727342694998, 0.5611327886581421, -1.2507312297821045, 0.1677740067243576, 0.2744094431400299, 0.23302355408668518, 0.16529233753681183, 0.33210569620132446, 0.3352474272251129, -0.17676132917404175, 0.9980384707450867, 0.5507875680923462, 0.193827286362648, 0.11335228383541107, 0.16308915615081787, -0.3449106812477112, -0.2562659680843353, -0.33375367522239685, 0.865702748298645, 0.39917612075805664, 0.14319610595703125, -0.7793669104576111, 0.12394916266202927, -0.4238354563713074, 0.007282134611159563, -0.555442750453949, -0.2977161109447479, -0.169877290725708, 0.28986188769340515, -0.1580679565668106, 0.35785600543022156, -0.019072122871875763, 0.510425865650177, -0.2162083238363266, -0.1858774721622467, -1.0036952495574951, -0.2531919777393341, -0.7107133269309998, 0.3912779986858368, -0.8870730996131897, -0.6183553338050842, -0.27386531233787537, -0.7381073832511902, -0.20831596851348877, 0.3150586485862732, 0.10120844095945358, -0.5148371458053589, 0.3239177465438843, 0.3935605585575104, 0.7608000040054321, 0.02428513951599598, -0.2441042810678482, 0.151805579662323, 0.548516035079956, 0.0784539058804512, -0.14974483847618103, 0.5819635987281799, 0.469429075717926, -0.03861832991242409, 0.23964573442935944, 0.10740706324577332, -0.0638514906167984, 0.39028623700141907, -0.6098583340644836, -0.25518161058425903, 0.32247114181518555, -0.5729032754898071, -0.9192760586738586, 0.998306930065155, 0.423789381980896, 0.03302396461367607, -0.2857057452201843, -0.5442088842391968, 0.23277637362480164, -0.6870273947715759, 1.379712700843811, -0.34040477871894836, 0.8969793915748596, -0.07365157455205917, 0.16156592965126038, -0.02985362522304058, -0.8312860727310181, 4.268786907196045, 1.0279961824417114, 0.26615020632743835, 0.22629494965076447, 1.0670315027236938, 0.18034082651138306, 0.6089017987251282, -0.03838839754462242, 0.04369596764445305, -0.06807263195514679, 0.12112459540367126, 0.33352264761924744, -0.07965654134750366, 0.07203711569309235, 0.15625743567943573, 0.007013895083218813, -0.7319742441177368, 0.2763597071170807, 0.016142982989549637, -0.8825821876525879, -0.5646350383758545, 0.5032915472984314, -0.31178632378578186, -0.03238512948155403, 0.20188942551612854, -0.15978065133094788, 0.2153606414794922, 0.13504484295845032, 0.6148640513420105, -0.12412673979997635, -0.800408124923706, -0.9554420709609985, 0.2099130004644394, -0.1488572508096695, -0.03560108691453934, 0.2212686836719513, 0.50521320104599, -0.6372645497322083, -0.4886394739151001, 0.18197503685951233, -0.0009401937131769955, -0.040445297956466675, 0.0014956245431676507, 0.018952757120132446, -0.8514991998672485, -0.1850210279226303, 0.14185865223407745, 0.048405811190605164, 0.5460973381996155, -0.8256535530090332, 0.9590489268302917, -0.9403229355812073, 0.25278642773628235, -0.3293602168560028, -0.27298393845558167, -0.18388450145721436, -0.7479631900787354, -0.6942145228385925, 0.3728376626968384, -0.09480365365743637, 0.49871301651000977, -0.03214665874838829, -0.49000003933906555, 0.3236830234527588, -0.016836272552609444, 0.5888190269470215, 0.5053958296775818, 0.0396132692694664, 0.13460658490657806, 0.09327266365289688, 0.13898912072181702, 0.3171626031398773, -0.966025173664093, 0.6410666704177856, 1.0437580347061157, 0.5166844129562378, -0.5054025650024414, 0.5758300423622131, -0.13561919331550598, -0.6467862129211426, -0.006592916790395975, 0.5054556131362915, 0.4312555491924286, -0.1266271024942398, 0.2830071449279785, 0.05371978506445885, -0.739930272102356, 0.11324027180671692, -0.8457821607589722, 0.80327308177948, 0.4197104275226593, -0.13936260342597961, 0.2319776564836502, -0.11419358849525452, -0.4151739478111267 ]
{"Title": "Opening the Black Box of Artificial Intelligence for Clinical Decision Support: A Study Predicting Stroke Outcome", "Authors": "Zihni Esra, Madai Vince Istvan, Livne Michelle, Galinovic Ivana, Khalil Ahmed A., Fiebach Jochen B., Frey Dietmar", "Abstract": "Abstract Background State-of-the-art machine learning (ML) artificial intelligence methods are increasingly leveraged in clinical predictive modeling to provide clinical decision support systems to physicians. Modern ML approaches such as artificial neural networks (ANNs) and tree boosting often perform better than more traditional methods like logistic regression. On the other hand, these modern methods yield a limited understanding of the resulting predictions. However, in the medical domain, understanding of applied models is essential, in particular, when informing clinical decision support. Thus, in recent years, interpretability methods for modern ML methods have emerged to potentially allow explainable predictions paired with high performance. Methods To our knowledge, we present in this work the first explainability comparison of two modern ML methods, tree boosting and multilayer perceptrons (MLPs), to traditional logistic regression methods using a stroke outcome prediction paradigm. Here, we used clinical features to predict a dichotomized 90 days post-stroke modified Rankin Scale (mRS) score. For interpretability, we evaluated clinical features\u2019 importance with regard to predictions using deep Taylor decomposition for MLP, Shapley values for tree boosting and model coefficients for logistic regression. Results With regard to performance as measured by AUC values on the test dataset, all models performed comparably: Logistic regression AUCs were 0.82, 0.82, 0.79 for three different regularization schemes; tree boosting AUC was 0.81; MLP AUC was 0.81. Importantly, the interpretability analysis demonstrated consistent results across models by rating age and stroke severity consecutively amongst the most important predictive features. For less important features, some differences were observed between the methods. Conclusions Our analysis suggests that modern machine learning methods can provide explainability which is compatible with domain knowledge interpretation and traditional method rankings. Future work should focus on replication of these findings in other datasets and further testing of different explainability methods.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010975"}
10.1101/19012161
[ -0.0622594840824604, 0.611477255821228, -0.6818062663078308, 0.34336695075035095, 0.03097447007894516, -0.04464520141482353, -0.6536526679992676, -0.2849001884460449, 0.35063594579696655, 0.7708216905593872, -0.1229095458984375, -0.26559722423553467, 0.1087210401892662, -0.7136680483818054, -0.2600860893726349, -0.5014010667800903, -0.8192184567451477, -0.29964032769203186, -0.016839124262332916, 0.0015381919220089912, 0.07086104154586792, 1.4115849733352661, -0.6121952533721924, 0.05696630850434303, -0.5323057174682617, 0.4580966830253601, 0.22387966513633728, -0.36839622259140015, 1.1071077585220337, 0.7252292633056641, 0.15406125783920288, -0.36825650930404663, 0.06469189375638962, -0.24626176059246063, -0.3831822872161865, -0.05595022439956665, 0.6291181445121765, -0.5700249671936035, -0.45294538140296936, -0.4770895838737488, -0.09585873782634735, 0.19291380047798157, 0.53110671043396, -1.3311866521835327, -0.964632511138916, -0.514011025428772, -0.471181184053421, 0.511328399181366, 0.15874607861042023, 0.001732177217490971, -0.27458107471466064, 0.034184668213129044, 0.33754774928092957, -0.06761480867862701, -0.284380167722702, -0.7518638968467712, 0.5621017813682556, 0.12684117257595062, -0.5164135098457336, -0.061239421367645264, 0.08009562641382217, -0.2637817859649658, 0.23127368092536926, -0.8986756205558777, 0.767797589302063, 0.748397707939148, 0.18447762727737427, -0.7025691866874695, -0.2346961349248886, -0.048060379922389984, -1.2174856662750244, -0.16889554262161255, 0.2168911099433899, -0.9074371457099915, -0.7239919304847717, -0.13936296105384827, -0.35623612999916077, 0.26366570591926575, -0.12122751027345657, -0.06597059965133667, -0.5608590841293335, 0.5469295978546143, -0.04986373707652092, 0.05494437366724014, -0.7184417247772217, 0.11669266223907471, 0.3900379538536072, -0.010407540015876293, 0.16806843876838684, 0.002355861244723201, -0.1606326848268509, -0.4517246186733246, 0.9445345401763916, 0.7921072244644165, 0.32905638217926025, 0.8433055877685547, -0.8391314744949341, 0.37424296140670776, 0.27398478984832764, -0.16001716256141663, 0.324963241815567, 0.8150981068611145, -0.21440128982067108, 0.7947999835014343, -1.2708450555801392, 1.4224467277526855, 1.060048222541809, -0.34742608666419983, -0.434174120426178, -0.7386441230773926, -0.3255022466182709, 0.4465288817882538, -0.6347334384918213, -0.35124069452285767, 0.31822890043258667, 0.7372607588768005, 0.14821363985538483, 0.6078534722328186, -0.9188147187232971, 0.6901782751083374, -0.7477956414222717, -0.5727927088737488, 0.3102133274078369, -0.6067520976066589, 0.687044620513916, -0.11861258745193481, 0.17117761075496674, 0.3836451768875122, -0.39634811878204346, -0.09340837597846985, -0.2428017407655716, -0.4025147259235382, 0.03838617354631424, 0.9280086159706116, -0.17560702562332153, -0.524430513381958, 0.5776660442352295, 0.10517627000808716, -0.04878313094377518, -0.6935446858406067, 0.1966789960861206, -0.4054107367992401, -0.2855128347873688, 1.5383950471878052, -0.8763297200202942, 0.7192131876945496, -0.42839789390563965, -1.2591553926467896, -0.5687648057937622, -0.5247102975845337, -0.15990126132965088, 1.020666480064392, -0.5231126546859741, 0.04249349609017372, -0.6150653958320618, 0.6050519943237305, -0.23557858169078827, -0.18888424336910248, -0.03009016066789627, -0.11399567127227783, 0.20709849894046783, -0.10752592980861664, -0.6541446447372437, 0.7362815141677856, -0.26814284920692444, 0.5783804655075073, -0.43722984194755554, 0.07161972671747208, 0.3323027193546295, -0.711685061454773, 0.650459349155426, -0.11146750301122665, -0.3180745542049408, 0.4907940626144409, 0.1760941445827484, 0.8518510460853577, 0.5467984080314636, 0.5103741884231567, 0.4299349784851074, 0.7461413741111755, -0.06247173994779587, -0.9105890989303589, 0.12156736850738525, 0.17040102183818817, 0.29496803879737854, 0.12175021320581436, -0.08758516609668732, -0.45278891921043396, -0.7597126364707947, -0.22555255889892578, 0.3689137101173401, 0.4201458990573883, -0.3475712239742279, 0.809700071811676, -0.6313285231590271, 0.03187337517738342, -0.41664138436317444, 0.741001307964325, 0.933780312538147, -0.5183497667312622, -0.21327780187129974, 0.3128717839717865, -0.31264957785606384, 0.46191567182540894, -0.2940346300601959, 1.3566498756408691, 0.07666779309511185, 1.0628751516342163, -0.10150143504142761, 0.4926927983760834, 0.13489533960819244, -0.0743875652551651, -0.34610554575920105, 0.06519478559494019, 0.25211670994758606, -0.45818349719047546, -0.38846054673194885, 0.6443084478378296, 0.046491947025060654, 0.12819194793701172, -0.04377402737736702, -0.4875889718532562, 0.8061386346817017, 0.297268271446228, 0.26937177777290344, -0.15233264863491058, 1.0989621877670288, 0.16671410202980042, -0.07563883066177368, -0.03207702189683914, 0.43720921874046326, 0.6728087067604065, -0.5315074324607849, 0.9947609305381775, 1.073285460472107, 0.5325142741203308, 0.15530261397361755, 0.46137985587120056, 0.8572450876235962, 0.12226825207471848, 0.019069664180278778, -0.2455589771270752, 1.0399763584136963, 1.2934447526931763, -0.39387279748916626, 0.5239344835281372, -0.04966995492577553, 0.25128820538520813, -0.3583492040634155, 0.24328847229480743, -0.18824297189712524, 0.7962335348129272, 0.9788203239440918, 0.26163649559020996, -1.293768286705017, -0.15137024223804474, -0.1686725914478302, 0.23342369496822357, 0.20737524330615997, -0.65593022108078, 0.14006821811199188, 0.6158481240272522, -0.5046678185462952, -0.6786689758300781, 0.7353098392486572, 0.5593149065971375, 0.06453587114810944, -0.11127424240112305, 0.05487625673413277, -0.29968300461769104, -0.7122366428375244, -0.6396688222885132, -1.3900560140609741, -0.6224166750907898, -1.3204959630966187, -0.07936734706163406, -0.3272755742073059, -0.7166262269020081, 0.3952169120311737, -0.3111317455768585, 0.22712001204490662, -0.26873376965522766, -0.39174625277519226, 0.8758406043052673, 0.5102475881576538, 0.02600526437163353, -0.7556042671203613, 0.4676898419857025, -0.21885713934898376, -0.38021501898765564, -0.1235385537147522, -0.5067726969718933, -0.3067411184310913, -0.566115140914917, 0.34021684527397156, -0.5439398288726807, 0.7369999289512634, 0.2319629043340683, -0.5547189712524414, -0.26943862438201904, 0.5724526047706604, 0.15903306007385254, 0.35792285203933716, -0.06532163172960281, -0.13840946555137634, 1.119975209236145, 0.08564190566539764, -0.016209134832024574, 0.7845222353935242, 0.381841778755188, -0.6164822578430176, 0.757109522819519, 0.3330972194671631, -0.29100537300109863, -0.9474590420722961, 0.26368024945259094, 0.5364323258399963, -0.32036247849464417, 0.17631162703037262, -1.3122950792312622, -1.0581929683685303, 0.3673062026500702, -0.5311698317527771, -0.9139643311500549, 0.14034612476825714, 0.7126703262329102, -0.06344950199127197, -1.1102392673492432, 0.2106863111257553, -0.8761380910873413, -0.8951581120491028, 0.05771467834711075, 0.3417508900165558, 0.34182271361351013, 0.1581791341304779, 0.4976276457309723, -0.19006383419036865, -0.10614927113056183, 0.7855019569396973, 0.47390249371528625, 0.6573258638381958, -0.5861958265304565, -0.3757677376270294, 0.537679135799408, 0.29111263155937195, 0.9988951683044434, 0.38108882308006287, -0.28736191987991333, -0.1763463169336319, 0.35945308208465576, -0.10765105485916138, -0.07694818824529648, 0.3918810188770294, -0.38397425413131714, 0.044905271381139755, -0.2199479192495346, 0.1572209894657135, 0.418781578540802, 0.4285743832588196, 0.051641371101140976, 0.18460559844970703, 0.20490312576293945, -0.3082154393196106, 0.23916776478290558, -0.3094797134399414, -0.8584752678871155, 0.25330138206481934, -0.14723573625087738, 0.31273454427719116, -0.5783002376556396, 0.873832106590271, 0.07155882567167282, -0.24993988871574402, -0.17061202228069305, 0.4308938682079315, -0.34701207280158997, 0.9104502201080322, 0.42120566964149475, 1.1318739652633667, -0.7631330490112305, 0.8231020569801331, 0.8529372215270996, 1.2143528461456299, -0.3684276044368744, 0.6135741472244263, 0.7410078048706055, -0.3959694802761078, 0.30650168657302856, 0.0715610682964325, -0.3548508882522583, -0.06114360690116882, 0.5013350248336792, -0.28043133020401, 0.03215423971414566, -0.3214055597782135, -0.6721017956733704, -0.05716944485902786, 0.2560828626155853, 0.3094345033168793, 0.12244077771902084, 1.5354207754135132, -1.2287362813949585, 0.3450537919998169, 0.5959479212760925, 1.1990406513214111, -0.17003068327903748, -1.1180890798568726, 0.46686166524887085, -0.03599156439304352, -0.14907878637313843, -0.24611680209636688, -0.23344998061656952, 0.07630742341279984, -0.6832064986228943, 0.09675513952970505, 0.06456030160188675, -0.04466037079691887, -0.49808788299560547, -0.185231551527977, 0.5570363998413086, 0.39998915791511536, -0.2087530940771103, -1.0090116262435913, 0.40373218059539795, 0.17959928512573242, -0.6086136102676392, -0.4503301978111267, -0.46549683809280396, 0.5473650097846985, 0.9896144866943359, -0.49614831805229187, -0.20820863544940948, -0.11102814227342606, -0.12692205607891083, -0.4281504452228546, 0.6250549554824829, -0.21761085093021393, -0.27381300926208496, 0.21654284000396729, -0.01738414168357849, -0.16879597306251526, 0.3346593677997589, -0.016475658863782883, -0.41416800022125244, 0.06374438107013702, 0.15759430825710297, 1.1157835721969604, 0.2073649764060974, 0.8365013599395752, 0.17341287434101105, 0.45665422081947327, -0.5867344737052917, 0.8032000660896301, -0.5845096707344055, -0.5420300960540771, -0.32433804869651794, 0.2305254340171814, 0.35926568508148193, 0.33499962091445923, 0.5844979286193848, -0.30728083848953247, -0.48113253712654114, 0.04374747350811958, 0.30630651116371155, -1.1253656148910522, 0.09144933521747589, -0.2674846351146698, -0.033792540431022644, 1.1072585582733154, -0.4997658431529999, -0.4270671606063843, -0.25575003027915955, 0.0015991195105016232, -0.9645416140556335, 0.44368892908096313, 0.5406647324562073, -0.05995890870690346, 0.16303841769695282, -0.606931209564209, 0.33906736969947815, -0.36985477805137634, 0.16604015231132507, -0.6738809943199158, -0.26579391956329346, -0.2722773253917694, -0.6475542187690735, 0.004911384079605341, -0.1751561015844345, -0.827421247959137, 0.3597836494445801, 0.07674731314182281, -1.0811760425567627, -0.17550593614578247, -0.11499199271202087, -0.5168926119804382, -0.10825971513986588, -0.4903596043586731, -0.17648491263389587, -0.44748908281326294, -0.01313532330095768, 0.6726971864700317, -0.7954297065734863, -0.2975381016731262, 0.023593496531248093, 0.243983656167984, -0.02011076919734478, -0.6038756966590881, -0.5815844535827637, -0.39864134788513184, -0.5882130265235901, -0.5905764102935791, 0.36658719182014465, -0.3254045248031616, 0.18145067989826202, 0.0755382776260376, -0.6621304154396057, 0.13306264579296112, 0.24935588240623474, 0.1800055354833603, 0.6476096510887146, -0.59138423204422, -0.6942222118377686, -0.9375171661376953, 0.2716841399669647, 0.37397500872612, 0.22100554406642914, 0.012735198251903057, -0.8810224533081055, -0.2580595314502716, -1.0156868696212769, 0.8142138123512268, -1.1824504137039185, 0.013386140577495098, -0.4461069703102112, -0.4417681097984314, 0.17744660377502441, 0.2112012505531311, 0.05828593298792839, 0.1999264359474182, -0.2153942584991455, -0.36881446838378906, 0.4229632616043091, -0.569645345211029, -0.5581363439559937, -0.5889429450035095, -0.08156159520149231, 0.3334119915962219, 0.7078144550323486, -0.10618278384208679, 0.16009171307086945, -0.4427533447742462, 0.31333860754966736, 0.17945948243141174, 0.5149946212768555, -0.9857049584388733, -0.5661817193031311, -0.04873330146074295, 0.18171948194503784, 0.9363197684288025, 0.20133532583713531, -0.7497400641441345, -0.023258186876773834, -0.3824459910392761, 0.025220930576324463, -0.37469032406806946, 0.11578795313835144, 0.37066373229026794, -0.41870853304862976, 0.9108123779296875, -0.8083941340446472, 0.17692221701145172, 0.31460291147232056, 0.01673276163637638, -0.2041957974433899, 0.18837246298789978, -0.32161903381347656, -1.1389437913894653, -1.3476054668426514, -0.7850347757339478, -0.26431289315223694, -0.35534733533859253, -0.14202994108200073, -0.03859001398086548, -0.25225022435188293, 0.20703446865081787, -0.37922507524490356, 0.7335954904556274, 0.839473307132721, -0.3278781473636627, -0.387099951505661, 0.12556929886341095, -0.4499056935310364, 0.1352899968624115, 0.6742245554924011, -0.02633001282811165, -0.5944404602050781, 0.055686503648757935, -0.7005220651626587, -0.43760979175567627, -0.6528058648109436, 0.10743837803602219, -0.09568990021944046, 0.27048787474632263, -0.3208385705947876, 0.1790645569562912, 0.9196810126304626, -0.0003832734073512256, -0.9839000105857849, 0.7523639798164368, -0.2781869173049927, 0.2257305085659027, 1.0475192070007324, -1.1642796993255615, -0.48849812150001526, -0.03334662690758705, 0.26511481404304504, -0.04237847775220871, 0.11847332119941711, 0.47288382053375244, -0.5828739404678345, -0.44196122884750366, 0.2333141565322876, 0.6008450388908386, -0.28650495409965515, -0.46791723370552063, 0.6050476431846619, 0.007440747693181038, 0.17947803437709808, -0.805891215801239, -0.05520894378423691, 0.11757414788007736, 0.032035671174526215, 0.24570123851299286, -0.8520907759666443, -0.2502148449420929, -0.1817343384027481, 0.4949227273464203, 0.4190865457057953, -1.0482208728790283, 0.5512819290161133, 0.2954350411891937, -0.4705972969532013, 0.4990813434123993, 0.09079402685165405, 0.24293068051338196, 0.22739353775978088, 0.11424918472766876, 0.6773256659507751, -0.07659919559955597, 0.03915755823254585, 0.7304220795631409, -0.05651581659913063, 0.05708634853363037, -0.1672573834657669, -0.1659391224384308, 0.4788524806499481, 0.7520884275436401, -0.8610843420028687, -0.2792048454284668, 0.3185827434062958, 0.06698364019393921, 0.0002263483766000718, 0.5688798427581787, 0.11080022901296616, 0.46165287494659424, 0.4464223384857178, 0.10480692237615585, -0.6673824191093445, -0.7830139398574829, -1.069474458694458, -0.48580923676490784, -0.0339462086558342, -0.3411691188812256, -0.4891863465309143, 1.123008131980896, -0.25833845138549805, -0.6609296798706055, 0.17269669473171234, 1.0349997282028198, -0.295389324426651, -0.22164097428321838, -0.6053866744041443, 0.3142804205417633, -0.3457792401313782, -0.671015202999115, -0.18422721326351166, -0.48766276240348816, 0.31331658363342285, 1.223806619644165, -0.3627667725086212, 0.20307818055152893, -0.21627363562583923, 0.06911534816026688, 0.04986773058772087, 0.2646962106227875, -0.43987420201301575, 0.13940800726413727, -0.4414178729057312, 0.6387041211128235, 0.25244665145874023, -0.384211003780365, 0.7813766002655029, -0.8105381727218628, 0.40629833936691284, -0.1279219686985016, 0.389309823513031, -0.30837881565093994, 0.056834954768419266, 0.5747652649879456, -0.43924152851104736, -0.49501875042915344, -0.5652280449867249, 0.5103667974472046, -0.9751479625701904, -0.4360281527042389, -0.41371989250183105, -0.08799326419830322, -0.047393374145030975, 0.22280387580394745, 0.2803348898887634, 0.9026843905448914, -0.5561442375183105, 0.6150006055831909, -0.11776227504014969, 0.2324403077363968, 0.4485178589820862, 0.5027539134025574, 0.45354413986206055, -0.09222468733787537, -0.20904791355133057, -1.1265790462493896, 0.47136983275413513, 0.006152769085019827, -0.47485366463661194, 0.509484052658081, 0.04816069453954697, 0.27488982677459717, -0.6043276786804199, 0.29099854826927185, 0.24104511737823486, 0.9280672669410706, 0.541655957698822, 0.6889225840568542, 0.022178204730153084, -0.0344809889793396, -0.7395724058151245, -0.18483169376850128, -0.7504247426986694, -0.8206803798675537, 0.2895910441875458, -0.6070364117622375, -0.44234830141067505, -0.42351776361465454, -0.6089422702789307, 0.47709575295448303, 0.46212679147720337, 0.2221011370420456, -0.01788262650370598, 0.014860951341688633, 0.2752363085746765, 0.9177185297012329, 0.5161270499229431, -0.19421951472759247, -0.34100618958473206, 0.11465022712945938, -0.9710537791252136, -0.03822501003742218, -0.13232195377349854, 0.1233641654253006, 0.2943844795227051, -0.43798139691352844, -0.40073472261428833, 0.7550092339515686, 0.8449224829673767, 0.10767248272895813, -0.6538888216018677, 0.04005534201860428, -1.0769450664520264, 0.09720703214406967, -0.14606988430023193, 0.22940827906131744, -0.08900346606969833, 0.20672106742858887, 0.06392952054738998, -0.46278849244117737, -0.2555353343486786, -0.052804626524448395, 0.5920755863189697, -0.8032640814781189, 0.25689011812210083, 0.15390938520431519, 0.3666924238204956, -0.12907689809799194, -0.5934374332427979, 0.3040168285369873, 0.4221702516078949, 0.11030502617359161, -0.7006662487983704, -0.2548450827598572, 0.44988712668418884, 0.8048500418663025, -0.573962926864624, 0.45120769739151, 0.8773486018180847, 0.2153995931148529, 0.23143558204174042, 0.4024728238582611, -0.7091549634933472, 0.9780081510543823, -0.5034574270248413, -0.10836488008499146, -0.08446890860795975, 0.5908440351486206, 0.6272357106208801, 0.2592863142490387, -0.8325531482696533, -0.13043652474880219, 0.11229297518730164, -1.2330156564712524, 0.49250471591949463, -0.07746236026287079, 0.6375868916511536, 0.2830296456813812, 0.5806377530097961, 0.035830382257699966, 0.2844831645488739, 0.18380814790725708, 0.20669560134410858, 0.951807975769043, -0.6225617527961731, 0.09147731959819794, -0.5004606246948242, 0.38320088386535645, -0.37615466117858887, -0.264261394739151, 0.3219456970691681, 0.2641480565071106, -0.10202285647392273, 0.2738214135169983, 0.2392539381980896, -0.5205634236335754, 0.7408416271209717, -0.422074556350708, -0.6797513961791992, -0.4291856288909912, -0.05306403711438179, -0.3848383128643036, -0.2589356303215027, 0.7024642825126648, -0.7593722939491272, 0.3133401870727539, 0.5307379961013794, -0.029456723481416702, 0.23668129742145538, 0.1786753088235855, 0.44212058186531067, -0.15339739620685577, 1.1503729820251465, 1.0373668670654297, 0.6287476420402527, 0.631615400314331, -0.19028519093990326, -0.8787038922309875, -0.023713424801826477, -0.299643337726593, -0.09629828482866287, 0.03998861834406853, -0.24160635471343994, -0.4795578122138977, -0.24224069714546204, -0.5016354918479919, -0.5650594830513, -0.7684972286224365, -0.405719131231308, 0.05293651297688484, 0.1923610121011734, -0.4334087073802948, 0.0941394567489624, 0.5531352758407593, -0.26403525471687317, -0.6288504600524902, -0.21215692162513733, -1.0534721612930298, 0.31304991245269775, -0.8273661732673645, 0.352475106716156, -0.5788335800170898, -0.6724423766136169, -0.48735857009887695, -0.19534650444984436, -0.32891592383384705, 0.3258558511734009, 0.210967019200325, -0.20593324303627014, 0.22213061153888702, 0.6574152708053589, 0.5730999112129211, 0.051008936017751694, -0.3189243674278259, 0.1518104076385498, 0.754106879234314, 0.7040690183639526, 0.47234946489334106, 0.769969642162323, 0.2856777608394623, 0.4140709936618805, -0.053802259266376495, -0.2280222624540329, -0.30110815167427063, -0.35489317774772644, -0.9861074090003967, -0.9410809278488159, 0.6616588234901428, -0.3623691201210022, -0.758945107460022, 0.6256749033927917, 0.06402751803398132, 0.10287176817655563, -0.34827351570129395, -0.6889099478721619, -0.2621782422065735, -0.761027991771698, 1.729736328125, -0.1348726898431778, 0.447801411151886, 0.3278786242008209, -0.5966779589653015, 0.30687087774276733, -0.5866256356239319, 4.030004501342773, 1.46660578250885, 0.3650974631309509, 0.17136767506599426, 1.104095458984375, 0.45060962438583374, 0.8087734580039978, 0.5412307977676392, -0.03336850553750992, 0.6088640689849854, -0.26717886328697205, 0.28219231963157654, -0.06832437217235565, 0.42639777064323425, 0.2590924799442291, 0.24141749739646912, -0.843000054359436, 0.23387405276298523, -0.6387949585914612, -0.586582601070404, -0.4969789683818817, 0.20004278421401978, 0.057154200971126556, 0.4467063248157501, 0.04639938473701477, -0.2679203748703003, -0.18022406101226807, 0.24653181433677673, -0.21181240677833557, 0.14748406410217285, -0.7644075751304626, -0.501671314239502, 0.3001321256160736, -0.2809346616268158, -0.26923367381095886, 0.30802425742149353, -0.2616792619228363, -0.5335687398910522, -0.031045740470290184, -0.5573233962059021, 0.06826360523700714, -0.05813906341791153, -0.5688543915748596, -0.05083226412534714, 0.19479632377624512, 0.11865388602018356, 0.053132690489292145, -0.06597777456045151, 0.4440917670726776, -0.60275799036026, 0.7556236982345581, -1.365455150604248, 0.6425409317016602, 0.309742271900177, -0.4010542035102844, -0.6304605007171631, -0.9875585436820984, -0.9419894218444824, 0.40654173493385315, 0.7902414798736572, 0.16743789613246918, 0.5622546672821045, -0.5142112970352173, 0.10466914623975754, 0.44367191195487976, 0.5739561915397644, 0.39011067152023315, 0.08117948472499847, -0.15508192777633667, 0.3564181625843048, 0.2612147033214569, -0.4648899734020233, -0.8056114912033081, 0.2341357320547104, 0.9131980538368225, 0.4695134460926056, -0.1449384242296219, 0.8001117706298828, -0.5259050130844116, -0.7449090480804443, 0.48651236295700073, 0.7572641372680664, 1.1244663000106812, -0.30267417430877686, -0.09227609634399414, 0.5620555877685547, -0.21494297683238983, 0.16198976337909698, -1.052700161933899, 0.44764477014541626, 0.22888655960559845, 0.21712179481983185, 0.4344349503517151, -0.4864270091056824, -0.26620641350746155 ]
{"Title": "Asthma Exacerbation Prediction and Interpretation based on Time-sensitive Attentive Neural Network: A Retrospective Cohort Study", "Authors": "Xiang Yang, Ji Hangyu, Zhou Yujia, Li Fang, Du Jingcheng, Rasmy Laila, Wu Stephen, Zheng Wenjin.Jim, Xu Hua, Zhi Degui, Zhang Yaoyun, Tao Cui", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Asthma exacerbation is an acute or sub-acute episode of progressive worsening of asthma symptoms and can have significant impacts on patients\u2019 daily life. In 2016, 12.4 million current asthmatics (46.9%) in the U.S. had at least one asthma exacerbation in the previous year. Objective The objectives of this study were to predict the risk of asthma exacerbations and to explore potential risk factors involved in progressive asthma. Methods We proposed a time-sensitive attentive neural network to predict asthma exacerbation using clinical variables from electronic health records (EHRs). The clinical variables were collected from the Cerner Health Facts\u00ae database between 1992 and 2015 including 31,433 asthmatic adult patients. Interpretations on both the patient level and the cohort level were investigated based on the model parameters. Results The proposed model obtains an AUC value of 0.7003 through 5-fold cross-validation, which outperforms the baseline methods. The results also demonstrate that the addition of elapsed time embeddings considerably improves the performance on this dataset. Through further analysis, it was witnessed that risk factors behaved distinctly along the timeline and across patients. We also found supporting evidence from peer-reviewed literature for some possible cohort-level risk factors such as respiratory syndromes and esophageal reflux. Conclusions The proposed time-sensitive attentive neural network is superior to traditional machine learning methods and performs better than state-of-the-art deep learning methods in realizing effective predictive models for the prediction of asthma exacerbation. We believe that the interpretation and visualization of risk factors can help the clinical community to better understand the underlying mechanisms of the disease progression.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012161"}
10.1101/2019.12.11.19014571
[ -0.19492897391319275, 0.746157169342041, -0.7292392253875732, 0.5604861974716187, -0.8824611306190491, -0.2704941928386688, -0.09308008849620819, 0.1702124923467636, -0.32388758659362793, 0.6458953022956848, -0.581036388874054, 0.21786341071128845, -0.31452932953834534, -0.4709278345108032, 0.1285119503736496, 0.06741098314523697, -0.28501397371292114, -0.1706325262784958, -0.7536229491233826, -0.41319090127944946, 0.8698611855506897, 0.7006762623786926, -0.5252912044525146, -1.0316399335861206, -0.9789395332336426, 0.6311206221580505, -0.14655813574790955, -0.6578981876373291, 1.0176002979278564, 0.6113267540931702, 0.3234500288963318, -0.6681655049324036, 0.6855523586273193, -0.6800675392150879, -0.6178954243659973, -0.5840175747871399, 0.39073309302330017, -0.15733449161052704, -0.5415881276130676, -0.17606109380722046, 0.004083700478076935, -0.008361120708286762, -0.06394784152507782, -0.653735339641571, -0.5577760934829712, 0.022873491048812866, -0.038794297724962234, -0.9360813498497009, -0.5332351922988892, -0.6829147934913635, -0.38486236333847046, 0.30494073033332825, 0.14000943303108215, -0.2625579833984375, -0.42263078689575195, -0.22609874606132507, -0.06356588751077652, -0.21946436166763306, -0.563538134098053, 0.4708554446697235, 1.0244550704956055, -0.2740023732185364, 0.5009738802909851, -0.6870814561843872, 0.36727169156074524, 0.8357580900192261, 0.12319406121969223, -0.18036293983459473, -0.4462403953075409, -0.6145351529121399, -1.0836533308029175, 0.030416186898946762, -0.5785608887672424, -0.7492143511772156, 0.04339364543557167, -0.06930718570947647, 0.05699366703629494, -0.12249206006526947, -0.3627961277961731, -0.7769660949707031, 0.0750843808054924, -0.194728285074234, -0.595352053642273, 0.05482332035899162, -0.16549000144004822, 0.11466117948293686, -0.06806854903697968, -0.253557950258255, 0.01681986264884472, -0.30739733576774597, 0.5720196962356567, 0.019681034609675407, -0.1233135461807251, 0.5536781549453735, 0.010241932235658169, 0.3294990360736847, -0.5119462013244629, -0.30755266547203064, 0.25056400895118713, 0.029802879318594933, 0.6237537264823914, 1.2599350214004517, 0.1579034924507141, 1.023871660232544, -0.8263156414031982, -0.27172794938087463, 0.04872773960232735, 0.05724438652396202, 0.11849849671125412, -0.5655738115310669, -0.06359636038541794, 0.8537809252738953, -0.08653473854064941, 0.8054128885269165, -0.1687164306640625, 0.49029868841171265, 0.43327561020851135, 0.08493929356336594, -0.07091262936592102, 0.7301103472709656, -0.3731977939605713, 0.6079193949699402, 0.12741906940937042, -0.936965823173523, 0.7313379645347595, -0.5619306564331055, 0.29191306233406067, -0.1080256998538971, 0.19461965560913086, 0.11455556005239487, 0.6566532254219055, 0.3167681097984314, -0.4267885386943817, 0.25860291719436646, -0.9272769093513489, 0.21843937039375305, 0.11989029496908188, 0.47491538524627686, -0.47260215878486633, 0.017816901206970215, -0.7623997330665588, -0.07371712476015091, -0.3316141664981842, 1.0533974170684814, 0.05972956120967865, 0.42272645235061646, -0.7885551452636719, -0.44540828466415405, 0.03810740262269974, -0.0881146490573883, 0.23961380124092102, 0.7027406692504883, -0.2121560275554657, 0.4408688545227051, 0.10370789468288422, -0.8618985414505005, -0.32741206884384155, 1.0481579303741455, -0.4996396601200104, 0.9249376654624939, 0.2510020136833191, 0.6986837387084961, -0.5762010216712952, 0.5881375670433044, -0.3201228082180023, 0.8655314445495605, 0.20396670699119568, 0.13967810571193695, 0.1510070562362671, -0.6708129644393921, 0.5178096890449524, 0.45028844475746155, -0.1274513602256775, -0.7211951017379761, -0.11389994621276855, 0.6990051865577698, 1.062930941581726, 0.838077187538147, -0.04179050773382187, 0.21798351407051086, -0.8037928342819214, -0.5988389849662781, 0.41342291235923767, 0.9984952807426453, -0.20769481360912323, -0.06755110621452332, -0.37579962611198425, -0.6773813366889954, 0.28099629282951355, 0.41887366771698, 0.018947716802358627, 1.44282066822052, -1.2203798294067383, 0.5711924433708191, -0.5213097929954529, 0.6936449408531189, 0.1522124707698822, 0.5000321269035339, 0.21615387499332428, -0.42815345525741577, -0.5375695824623108, 0.7521848678588867, -0.15329717099666595, 0.6134306192398071, -0.25952163338661194, 0.4436415433883667, 0.8132901787757874, 0.228379026055336, -0.43943679332733154, 0.3632974326610565, -0.0998607948422432, -0.26464715600013733, 0.11711054295301437, 0.002544526709243655, 0.7301629781723022, -0.7904627919197083, 0.19067655503749847, 0.15477658808231354, 0.35958433151245117, -0.3735595941543579, 0.5476291179656982, 0.4622347354888916, 0.39439302682876587, -0.19937191903591156, -0.3345620930194855, 0.03494120389223099, 0.779193103313446, 0.10021845251321793, 0.24717628955841064, -0.26355084776878357, 0.3643603026866913, 0.7685075402259827, 0.10723762959241867, -0.10474275797605515, -0.049805592745542526, 0.646514892578125, 0.027145925909280777, -0.1762901097536087, 1.3246101140975952, -0.3796813488006592, 0.1682390719652176, 0.12895017862319946, 0.8879688382148743, 0.12825728952884674, -0.21087783575057983, -0.13720150291919708, -0.2557624876499176, 0.2444046437740326, -0.10791070014238358, -0.5188008546829224, -1.1855382919311523, 0.6203550696372986, -0.5236076712608337, 0.43973395228385925, -0.6340363025665283, 0.30214056372642517, 0.7307423949241638, 0.5026122331619263, 0.10960861295461655, -0.9297648668289185, -0.47431233525276184, -0.175896555185318, 0.30478405952453613, -0.11112669855356216, 0.7642860412597656, 0.48555347323417664, -0.022391309961676598, 0.5571447610855103, -0.2038070112466812, -0.23182430863380432, -0.9481868743896484, -0.3535171449184418, -1.2122337818145752, -0.024302158504724503, -0.9491384625434875, -0.5142878890037537, -0.1469213366508484, -0.5543440580368042, 0.7075647115707397, -0.25435903668403625, 0.2643454074859619, -0.7388511300086975, 0.45313990116119385, 0.5642921328544617, 0.7865386605262756, 0.22767965495586395, -1.3715647459030151, -0.12628936767578125, -0.5916615724563599, 0.3359260559082031, 0.46720877289772034, -0.2715889811515808, -0.6250486373901367, -0.598926842212677, 0.629642903804779, -0.4153920114040375, -0.3169485926628113, 0.28147152066230774, -0.6477401852607727, -0.1829804927110672, 0.16155007481575012, -0.23521187901496887, 0.0877944827079773, -0.09962999820709229, -0.7904890775680542, 1.18064546585083, 0.32363271713256836, -0.280190646648407, 0.6605714559555054, -0.27323079109191895, -0.654794454574585, 0.9251492023468018, -0.43395042419433594, 0.14632269740104675, -0.8110800385475159, 0.8400633335113525, -0.034584905952215195, -0.5437469482421875, -0.6870130896568298, -0.41519591212272644, -0.6430460810661316, 0.031749073415994644, 0.03154369071125984, -0.7745927572250366, 0.4517015218734741, 0.11938190460205078, -0.2442152202129364, -0.8825380802154541, 0.12578773498535156, -0.6981763243675232, -1.0613467693328857, 0.013639953918755054, -1.1835143566131592, 0.8485057353973389, -0.07983550429344177, 0.18606308102607727, 0.4383446276187897, -0.300954669713974, 0.17334741353988647, 0.07171472162008286, 0.5883519649505615, -0.5972062349319458, -0.19188496470451355, 0.5040414333343506, -0.46073776483535767, 0.5329338312149048, 0.5147367715835571, -0.11670134216547012, -0.05065394565463066, -0.12939949333667755, -0.5961799621582031, -0.3659086227416992, 0.032891761511564255, -0.8110478520393372, 0.7485780119895935, 0.45198720693588257, -0.7637495398521423, 0.22426646947860718, -0.29057222604751587, 1.3483151197433472, -0.3062698543071747, -0.4187796711921692, 0.06847697496414185, 0.6200962066650391, -1.0327885150909424, -0.30878373980522156, 0.7214614748954773, 0.5265946388244629, 0.31477728486061096, 0.05944519862532616, 0.5188090801239014, -0.15831702947616577, 0.18910574913024902, -0.49188530445098877, -0.23311087489128113, -0.5979474186897278, 0.4480723440647125, -0.17782384157180786, 0.544603705406189, -1.823357343673706, -0.2575225830078125, 0.5686595439910889, 1.1232061386108398, -0.22528629004955292, -0.16018906235694885, -0.5338789820671082, 0.21812200546264648, 0.24534374475479126, 0.4497050344944, 0.026926515623927116, 0.08217000216245651, -0.1457480490207672, -0.2470918893814087, -0.4624265730381012, -0.868739664554596, -0.012742909602820873, 0.33630281686782837, -0.230233833193779, 0.3802804946899414, -0.5581742525100708, 0.9509245753288269, -0.17562729120254517, 0.29530200362205505, 0.702846884727478, -0.3423648774623871, -0.22454620897769928, -0.5720738768577576, 0.605882465839386, 0.23117037117481232, -0.3992607295513153, -0.5856461524963379, 0.3771405518054962, 0.044040579348802567, 0.3133862614631653, 0.0892493799328804, -0.044056132435798645, -0.29531747102737427, 0.13086789846420288, -0.4348551034927368, 0.3336506187915802, 0.07725662738084793, -0.06091660261154175, -1.092474341392517, 0.6731845736503601, 0.5970757007598877, 0.12917402386665344, -0.3531420826911926, -1.0888242721557617, -0.0006589376134797931, 0.22082720696926117, -0.2300093024969101, -0.16726422309875488, 0.22998830676078796, 0.3535429537296295, 0.25516313314437866, 0.28014063835144043, 0.20681290328502655, -0.5216988325119019, 0.010141570121049881, 0.2433108389377594, -0.1026870384812355, -0.9574770331382751, -0.18135862052440643, -0.15989601612091064, -0.31903672218322754, 0.39669257402420044, 0.16019481420516968, -0.06612920761108398, 0.2899458408355713, -0.2911028563976288, 0.7771577835083008, -0.2396523803472519, -0.12210138142108917, -0.20860062539577484, 0.033054910600185394, -0.03482183814048767, 0.23168885707855225, 0.20237354934215546, 0.03982854261994362, -0.3097028136253357, -0.5074459910392761, -0.12093935161828995, 0.877246081829071, 0.2222336381673813, 0.18137811124324799, 0.7241753935813904, -0.015070440247654915, 0.4472464621067047, 0.5597769618034363, -0.8059014678001404, -0.3585030436515808, 0.16561883687973022, -0.08714152872562408, -0.669945478439331, -0.12355059385299683, -0.690288782119751, 0.08757080882787704, 0.558428168296814, -0.06961680948734283, 0.10710224509239197, -0.45097750425338745, 0.25522521138191223, 0.0034508893731981516, 0.10697704553604126, -0.048797715455293655, -0.22797143459320068, -0.06514069437980652, 0.289236456155777, -0.6339271068572998, -0.16817428171634674, 0.18165193498134613, -0.6374316215515137, 0.3682843744754791, 0.534605860710144, -0.3549272418022156, 0.0545949749648571, -1.2176443338394165, 0.5552088618278503, -0.6753745675086975, -0.07303600013256073, 1.083864688873291, -0.8074624538421631, -0.5364258289337158, 0.2752608060836792, 0.23777958750724792, -0.7503177523612976, -0.442355751991272, 0.46574538946151733, -0.45278283953666687, 0.175294890999794, -0.5141667723655701, 0.5398663878440857, -0.11968062818050385, 0.8578726649284363, -0.4893679618835449, -0.155950129032135, 0.27772361040115356, 0.26471632719039917, -0.4523748457431793, 0.8243105411529541, -0.6081776022911072, -0.6746792197227478, -0.3249494433403015, 0.5283287167549133, -0.4418356418609619, 0.3659866750240326, -0.31988003849983215, -0.09314630180597305, -0.16438299417495728, -1.2509137392044067, 0.5994911789894104, -1.1516720056533813, 0.12704585492610931, -0.2448851317167282, -0.6986080408096313, -0.31684696674346924, -0.5429436564445496, -0.21967563033103943, 0.10424306988716125, -0.5534248948097229, -0.5289536118507385, 0.5133096575737, -0.5445361137390137, 0.07774876058101654, -0.13374468684196472, -0.6227394342422485, -0.3327154517173767, 0.7499731183052063, 0.9117531180381775, 0.3511224687099457, 0.8237674236297607, -0.4276086390018463, 0.6069125533103943, 0.6597208380699158, 0.20654021203517914, -0.6487317681312561, 0.3394091725349426, 0.17097631096839905, 0.2500971853733063, -0.24434836208820343, -0.2878587245941162, -0.27806979417800903, -0.18879567086696625, 0.41208329796791077, -0.2385881394147873, -0.032916437834501266, -0.1434508115053177, 0.028779873624444008, 0.5779204964637756, -0.3331257700920105, 0.3095366358757019, 0.3726339340209961, 0.6431251168251038, 0.20844921469688416, -0.19453707337379456, -1.0546818971633911, -0.5631372928619385, -0.6948766112327576, -1.27548086643219, -0.15008477866649628, 0.16906514763832092, 0.1758153885602951, 0.17621581256389618, -0.028698178008198738, -0.3731865882873535, -0.7223072052001953, 1.384026050567627, 0.7756534814834595, -0.16911175847053528, -0.4757854640483856, -0.2743344008922577, 0.2081749588251114, 0.34389007091522217, -0.030899694189429283, -0.27961376309394836, -0.26219531893730164, 0.46873313188552856, 0.06714554876089096, -0.6105462908744812, -1.1435421705245972, -0.20900681614875793, 0.6775069236755371, 0.5698143243789673, -0.8142850399017334, 0.7561584711074829, -0.006798521615564823, 0.15225651860237122, -0.8392407298088074, 0.5356165766716003, -0.38319626450538635, -0.5751311779022217, 0.6494483947753906, -0.013628611341118813, -0.5406879186630249, -0.2434796839952469, -0.5137900710105896, -0.049318403005599976, 0.23060716688632965, -0.07187815755605698, 0.9020181894302368, 0.09319997578859329, 0.1016269251704216, 0.4772554337978363, 0.1311367303133011, -0.9237697720527649, -0.12304899096488953, -0.37678107619285583, 0.2834411561489105, -0.2898596525192261, -0.014974811114370823, 0.5161883234977722, 0.16251806914806366, -0.0854782685637474, 0.3562130928039551, 0.048277728259563446, -0.04101404547691345, -0.2784511148929596, 0.24372676014900208, -0.46763622760772705, -0.05705500766634941, 0.552238941192627, 0.1612195372581482, -0.12397806346416473, -0.5658419132232666, -0.4943079352378845, 0.017320146784186363, -0.24188043177127838, 0.7747797966003418, -0.9908376932144165, 0.27591797709465027, 0.28684553503990173, 0.308194637298584, -0.5179675817489624, 0.15395407378673553, 0.1443490982055664, 0.27570104598999023, 0.22936399281024933, -0.5541841387748718, -0.3044126629829407, 0.6064484119415283, 0.13753262162208557, 0.2149486541748047, -0.8450493216514587, -0.8129955530166626, 1.229172945022583, 0.7606588006019592, -0.1741454154253006, -0.011858141981065273, -1.0619587898254395, -0.8383519053459167, -0.4328445494174957, 0.6866302490234375, -0.16697873175144196, -0.23796215653419495, 0.4616606533527374, -0.8223099708557129, -0.7938755750656128, -0.08620142191648483, 1.3233531713485718, -1.3739560842514038, -0.08430682867765427, -0.9052096009254456, 0.705489456653595, -1.0905874967575073, 0.7562628984451294, -0.21249781548976898, -0.2255433052778244, -0.5943264961242676, 0.1628129482269287, -0.05325767397880554, -0.20283351838588715, 0.6825705766677856, 0.3054952919483185, 0.0031041516922414303, 0.5846123099327087, -0.4734533429145813, 0.10128573328256607, -0.04942246899008751, 0.34967678785324097, 0.43764039874076843, 0.31586188077926636, 0.44354045391082764, -0.020434947684407234, 1.0368537902832031, 0.07001993060112, -0.0879625752568245, -1.257401704788208, 0.15332992374897003, 0.6213618516921997, -0.16410748660564423, 0.17930585145950317, 0.250909686088562, 0.4235544800758362, -0.4575813412666321, 0.37365594506263733, 1.0869990587234497, -0.13627594709396362, -0.2272222638130188, -0.2687816321849823, 0.3900739848613739, 0.11250735819339752, -0.08745270222425461, 0.07026257365942001, 0.22848127782344818, 0.536106526851654, -0.3338346779346466, -0.3131093978881836, 0.11147158592939377, -0.36083585023880005, 0.6062562465667725, -1.4778006076812744, 0.9549283385276794, 0.5519238710403442, -0.32687780261039734, -0.17433281242847443, -0.847804069519043, 0.18602246046066284, 0.35131463408470154, -0.24040573835372925, 0.7057710886001587, 0.42048344016075134, 0.33418163657188416, 0.02542029321193695, 0.3682730495929718, 0.49388739466667175, -0.9996015429496765, 0.0371139831840992, -0.7588021755218506, -0.5800944566726685, 0.5656254887580872, -0.3492686152458191, -0.49360689520835876, -0.5449659824371338, -0.33538171648979187, 0.09807651489973068, 0.24771751463413239, 0.5715707540512085, -0.11904594302177429, 0.9264588356018066, 0.13992749154567719, 0.08077902346849442, -0.2807859778404236, -0.4208434820175171, -0.30062970519065857, 0.5547097325325012, -0.37437909841537476, -0.8411980867385864, 0.32798054814338684, 0.6015980243682861, 0.41181302070617676, -0.23887881636619568, 0.17397665977478027, 0.394506573677063, 0.0476403683423996, -0.2042316347360611, -0.4683268070220947, 0.3087466061115265, -0.8305118083953857, 0.19740840792655945, 0.1703753024339676, 0.3909228444099426, -0.3920344114303589, 1.084281325340271, 0.370522677898407, -0.7593292593955994, -1.0450078248977661, 0.3813035786151886, 0.24881653487682343, -0.5705826282501221, 0.09617152065038681, -0.9413394927978516, 0.3496503233909607, 0.2835286855697632, 0.4205205738544464, 0.5493055582046509, 0.17916738986968994, 1.0898884534835815, 0.17201729118824005, -0.20901203155517578, 0.44365614652633667, 0.8691914081573486, 0.4124642014503479, -0.16783976554870605, 0.6085529923439026, 0.0351237915456295, -0.3035898804664612, 0.8797165751457214, -0.4610500633716583, 0.9525654911994934, -0.5233214497566223, 0.26968833804130554, 0.5480960011482239, 0.42750027775764465, 0.3081173896789551, 0.15278378129005432, -1.1054885387420654, 1.182854413986206, -0.058049481362104416, -0.2748385965824127, -0.553930401802063, 0.7342198491096497, 0.21955563127994537, -0.6199018955230713, 0.10778819024562836, 0.21097299456596375, 0.24392928183078766, 0.4583265781402588, 0.5218737125396729, -0.366421639919281, 0.127802774310112, -0.9168526530265808, 0.48749616742134094, 0.828012228012085, 0.07330980151891708, 0.7718867063522339, 0.32184910774230957, 0.20438243448734283, 0.07816753536462784, 1.0935759544372559, -0.26003122329711914, -1.0635119676589966, 0.7509486079216003, -0.32541128993034363, -0.18811668455600739, 0.09871542453765869, -0.24830147624015808, -1.0508410930633545, -0.6853665113449097, 0.302864134311676, -0.4633472263813019, 0.16308464109897614, 0.3494947850704193, -0.07378502190113068, 0.5824986100196838, 0.7701844573020935, 0.5033990144729614, -0.5111780762672424, 1.6367703676223755, 0.8844170570373535, -0.3919113874435425, 0.14689651131629944, 0.5501241087913513, -0.3178230822086334, 0.3760868012905121, -0.19660049676895142, 0.41983649134635925, 0.22586582601070404, -0.5191003680229187, 0.020614393055438995, -0.11304806172847748, 0.06784936785697937, 0.25971946120262146, -0.11855562031269073, 0.16670013964176178, -0.27059441804885864, -0.20565129816532135, 0.21589724719524384, 0.38415080308914185, -0.4384586811065674, 0.5232783555984497, -0.22068749368190765, 0.20609118044376373, -0.8053010702133179, -0.08058218657970428, -0.18794362246990204, 0.29633840918540955, -0.14506904780864716, -0.4820041358470917, -0.7590906620025635, -0.8726077079772949, -0.4572249948978424, 0.16862349212169647, -0.13378463685512543, -0.6234295964241028, 0.294303297996521, 0.5135866403579712, -0.06150634586811066, 0.3907380700111389, 0.07692435383796692, -0.3638802766799927, 0.4786115288734436, 0.534288227558136, -0.11371555179357529, 0.17995116114616394, 0.6355960369110107, -0.025680625811219215, 0.27860039472579956, 0.047291599214076996, 0.34305059909820557, -0.11792512238025665, -0.5696682333946228, -0.2344343215227127, 0.4241348206996918, 0.027545932680368423, -0.2827027440071106, -0.2341776043176651, 0.13795225322246552, -0.5905143618583679, 0.447370707988739, -0.6882684826850891, -0.19467058777809143, -0.3759911060333252, 1.3395955562591553, -0.0675627812743187, 0.9440076351165771, -0.03926752880215645, -0.27666333317756653, 0.1784793585538864, -0.6600630879402161, 4.147738933563232, 0.7448311448097229, -0.05823565274477005, 0.33550313115119934, 0.07908801734447479, 0.5452514290809631, 1.1444177627563477, 0.1042349711060524, -0.27604711055755615, 0.007321542128920555, -0.46907520294189453, 1.1365708112716675, -0.3132362961769104, 0.07853483408689499, 0.35069820284843445, 0.2668030261993408, -0.7499929666519165, -0.40807560086250305, 0.10928168892860413, -1.1934254169464111, -0.20478643476963043, 0.23626382648944855, -0.4070033133029938, -0.18239448964595795, -0.0022452494595199823, 0.0064964983612298965, -0.39048799872398376, 0.12302660197019577, -0.21425177156925201, -0.3007942736148834, 0.14358407258987427, -0.27977117896080017, -0.2380893975496292, -1.1549423933029175, -0.05553625524044037, 0.5286428332328796, 0.14932064712047577, -0.08123675733804703, -0.8997139930725098, -0.446357399225235, 0.45512935519218445, -0.009959239512681961, -0.43424877524375916, -0.4338178038597107, -0.5215550661087036, 0.10757946968078613, 0.5371697545051575, -0.061883632093667984, 0.5044869184494019, -0.7077509760856628, 0.4414318799972534, -0.7385545969009399, 0.03351915627717972, 0.15650618076324463, -0.35534238815307617, -0.04067039489746094, -0.4471527636051178, -0.3262520432472229, -0.1418572962284088, -0.15485072135925293, 0.5619161128997803, 0.23613648116588593, 0.06961322575807571, -0.04130084440112114, -0.16075274348258972, 0.13149014115333557, 0.17852993309497833, 0.5307523012161255, -0.3642154633998871, 0.6287141442298889, -0.26959964632987976, 0.20201192796230316, -0.6099353432655334, 0.18437637388706207, 1.1711214780807495, 1.005012035369873, 0.29143625497817993, 0.43419092893600464, -0.06676318496465683, -0.695746123790741, -0.16612443327903748, 0.2799626290798187, 0.5914050340652466, 0.39720314741134644, -0.35693439841270447, 0.5533836483955383, -0.319787859916687, -0.26709601283073425, -1.4157555103302002, 0.42417991161346436, 0.32248368859291077, -0.19212216138839722, -0.1448395550251007, 0.08204403519630432, -0.5164692997932434 ]
{"Title": "Brain-Computer Interface Robotics for Hand Rehabilitation After Stroke: A Systematic Review", "Authors": "Baniqued Paul Dominick E, Stanyer Emily C, Awais Muhammad, Alazmani Ali, Jackson Andrew E, Mon-Williams Mark A, Mushtaq Faisal, Holt Raymond J", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Hand rehabilitation is core to helping stroke survivors regain activities of daily living. Recent studies have suggested that the use of electroencephalography-based brain-computer interfaces (BCI) can promote this process. Here, we report the first systematic examination of the literature on the use of BCI-robot systems for the rehabilitation of fine motor skills associated with hand movement and profile these systems from a technical and clinical perspective. Methods A search for January 2010-October 2019 articles using Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, PEDro, PsycINFO, IEEE Xplore and Cochrane Library databases was performed. The selection criteria included BCI-hand robotic systems for rehabilitation at different stages of development involving tests on healthy participants or people who have had a stroke. Data fields include those related to study design, participant characteristics, technical specifications of the system, and clinical outcome measures. Results 30 studies were identified as eligible for qualitative review and among these, 11 studies involved testing a BCI-hand robot on chronic and subacute stroke patients. Statistically significant improvements in motor assessment scores relative to controls were observed for three BCI-hand robot interventions. The degree of robot control for the majority of studies was limited to triggering the device to perform grasping or pinching movements using motor imagery. Most employed a combination of kinaesthetic and visual response via the robotic device and display screen, respectively, to match feedback to motor imagery. Conclusion 19 out of 30 studies on BCI-robotic systems for hand rehabilitation report systems at prototype or pre-clinical stages of development. We identified large heterogeneity in reporting and emphasise the need to develop a standard protocol for assessing technical and clinical outcomes so that the necessary evidence base on efficiency and efficacy can be developed.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.11.19014571"}
10.1101/19003160
[ 0.06362545490264893, 0.8198201656341553, 0.30285361409187317, 0.7018336653709412, -0.45053577423095703, -0.3829037845134735, 0.0005749144474975765, -0.2921769917011261, -0.21367134153842926, 0.5074673295021057, -0.5411321520805359, -0.15105962753295898, 0.029912244528532028, -0.2368444949388504, -0.6839898824691772, -0.31481438875198364, -0.19208002090454102, -0.016336264088749886, 0.13727085292339325, 0.1325618028640747, 0.09859015047550201, 0.513295590877533, -0.705730140209198, 0.1810329407453537, 0.2898785471916199, 0.7260840535163879, -0.17042861878871918, 0.12326157838106155, 1.2394124269485474, 0.34062227606773376, -0.5380146503448486, -0.3878594934940338, 0.2383946031332016, -0.7515090107917786, -0.633567214012146, -0.01664709486067295, 0.5349897742271423, -0.2952456474304199, -0.4796353280544281, -0.5397318005561829, 0.5018050074577332, -0.3575195074081421, -0.13458587229251862, -0.23531866073608398, -0.2611302137374878, 0.2158033400774002, -0.275294691324234, 0.1341342031955719, -0.15518318116664886, -0.03331125155091286, -0.34650930762290955, -0.2707805633544922, -0.21825404465198517, -0.513866662979126, -0.4671174883842468, 0.41972941160202026, -0.4895191490650177, -0.7307961583137512, -1.037916660308838, -0.05032745376229286, 0.10066037625074387, -0.5714707970619202, 1.0622367858886719, -1.4127751588821411, 0.767318069934845, 1.0695167779922485, -0.23128648102283478, -0.4912290573120117, -0.4748063087463379, -0.29650354385375977, -0.17500494420528412, -0.10691031068563461, -0.6252511143684387, -0.39003312587738037, -0.7646489143371582, -0.7620778679847717, -0.14059273898601532, -0.18919341266155243, -0.29206427931785583, -0.36872050166130066, 0.391970157623291, 0.2303473949432373, -0.1783498376607895, 0.10072710365056992, -0.6383891701698303, 0.013657690025866032, 0.3046884536743164, 0.9169700741767883, -0.4392717480659485, 0.9175150394439697, -0.052512720227241516, 0.4576207399368286, 0.12911036610603333, 0.11141934245824814, -0.022170906886458397, 0.9111838936805725, -0.03831557556986809, -0.3738503158092499, -0.10925251990556717, -0.2663472592830658, 0.31456947326660156, 0.2106546312570572, -0.7270348072052002, 0.7842350602149963, -0.3243563175201416, 0.6235715746879578, 0.029377341270446777, -0.19279949367046356, -0.4339655935764313, -0.6471716165542603, 0.479800283908844, -0.3259415328502655, -0.9319722652435303, 0.07996128499507904, 1.4217913150787354, 0.6984473466873169, -0.31340181827545166, 1.0538004636764526, -0.624898374080658, 0.3195642828941345, -0.5201520323753357, -0.08107966184616089, 0.6803723573684692, 0.08729205280542374, 0.2632025182247162, 0.23343753814697266, 0.18782763183116913, 0.2960718274116516, -0.28877392411231995, 0.6892747282981873, 0.2849462628364563, -0.17874479293823242, -0.7479443550109863, 0.7546371221542358, -0.4759247899055481, -0.4810587465763092, 0.44562286138534546, 0.6546424031257629, 0.21474643051624298, -0.5723609328269958, -0.21405205130577087, 0.1985645890235901, -0.4053899645805359, 1.2599862813949585, -0.36715447902679443, 0.5218971967697144, -0.5462855100631714, -1.2901109457015991, -1.2614047527313232, 0.4213298261165619, 0.1345987319946289, 0.8460411429405212, 0.2372724562883377, -0.7146977782249451, 0.26942890882492065, 0.314602792263031, -0.34260085225105286, 0.06325379014015198, -0.4548696279525757, -0.0685204342007637, -0.565635085105896, 0.03366817533969879, 0.011211485601961613, 0.7537528276443481, -0.579594075679779, 0.9855636358261108, 0.14485587179660797, -0.44271034002304077, 0.3671933710575104, -0.7667255401611328, 0.6309947371482849, 0.43383708596229553, -0.13767600059509277, -0.07290098071098328, 0.2927209436893463, 0.8117189407348633, 0.9493513107299805, -0.04469511657953262, 0.8156255483627319, 1.0268899202346802, 0.21072335541248322, 0.5652292370796204, 0.6344591379165649, 0.11208657175302505, 0.040693946182727814, 0.10005152225494385, -0.193135067820549, 0.33421891927719116, -0.08936446905136108, -0.2635089159011841, -0.020368609577417374, -0.24413131177425385, -0.5571985244750977, 0.9778240919113159, 0.27413514256477356, 0.2073744535446167, -1.022095799446106, -0.5244885087013245, 0.3554145395755768, -0.5769773721694946, -0.16089007258415222, 0.9337236881256104, -0.0006021409062668681, 0.3315054178237915, -0.8843299746513367, 0.5765676498413086, 0.21584980189800262, 0.2839595675468445, -0.34194517135620117, 0.17505739629268646, 0.7182255983352661, 0.10134666413068771, -0.23998327553272247, -0.1711316555738449, 0.13943928480148315, -0.30430707335472107, -0.13540297746658325, 0.35869163274765015, -0.901339590549469, -0.6098452210426331, -0.05534304678440094, 0.9627213478088379, 0.34284722805023193, 0.4343150556087494, -0.3440943658351898, 0.36928224563598633, 0.523468554019928, 0.35201457142829895, -0.29923015832901, -0.7054039835929871, 0.43281790614128113, 0.7940322160720825, -0.022191783413290977, 1.1420879364013672, 0.8377116322517395, 0.20427940785884857, 0.025352193042635918, 0.5330288410186768, 0.21703289449214935, 0.4210722744464874, 0.46704477071762085, 0.2908781170845032, 0.6577013731002808, 0.2731504738330841, -0.19656716287136078, 0.7115994095802307, -0.22876916825771332, -0.1927070915699005, -0.31143712997436523, 0.4842863976955414, 0.07783312350511551, 0.10309179872274399, 0.28963831067085266, 0.9035345911979675, -0.34367290139198303, -0.732795774936676, 0.35349372029304504, -0.4072793126106262, -0.3116450011730194, -0.17050255835056305, -0.41885948181152344, 0.15630969405174255, -0.1197664737701416, -0.20842085778713226, 0.7845357656478882, 0.575793981552124, -0.30682530999183655, 0.2501146197319031, 0.2925739586353302, -0.2741686999797821, -0.6446797847747803, -0.8501244187355042, -0.5171692967414856, -0.3820900022983551, -0.5872675180435181, -0.8565158247947693, 0.18568585813045502, -0.29324421286582947, 0.724271297454834, 0.2608707547187805, 0.2100858986377716, -0.2175929844379425, -0.5378269553184509, 0.5627150535583496, 0.818200945854187, 0.5716329216957092, -0.47319886088371277, 0.11752466857433319, -0.072538360953331, 0.6605707406997681, 0.06670048087835312, -0.550893247127533, -0.5497049689292908, -0.5946559906005859, 0.8887435793876648, -0.6245207190513611, -0.115106001496315, -0.5373491048812866, -0.006694376468658447, -0.3310702443122864, 0.18140165507793427, 0.5370015501976013, -0.03982120752334595, -0.2594860792160034, -0.6371768712997437, 0.2358493059873581, -0.006977836601436138, 0.3679000437259674, 0.07502762973308563, 0.39027175307273865, 0.017504097893834114, -0.06007058918476105, 0.17258457839488983, 0.13522334396839142, -0.8186271786689758, 0.4593096077442169, 0.21022911369800568, 0.03802357614040375, -0.32328560948371887, -0.7629258036613464, -1.082053780555725, 0.15154965221881866, -0.32542866468429565, 0.0374046228826046, -0.12597376108169556, 0.684434711933136, -0.03082653321325779, -1.134177803993225, 0.342399001121521, -0.6102598905563354, -1.2234001159667969, 0.21105505526065826, -0.1809423267841339, 0.4588596820831299, 0.242372065782547, -0.35209476947784424, -0.18713587522506714, 0.6042710542678833, 0.5419169664382935, -0.10773410648107529, 0.16688302159309387, -0.3551473617553711, 0.6007348299026489, 0.42447429895401, -0.14250756800174713, 0.33992838859558105, -0.15446166694164276, -0.5193000435829163, -0.05047416314482689, 0.19578219950199127, -0.05578621104359627, -0.16934987902641296, 0.42487895488739014, 0.16896721720695496, 0.08652812987565994, 0.3148230314254761, 0.00837678276002407, 0.13520236313343048, 0.007434557657688856, 0.3411000370979309, 0.0806499645113945, 0.4420567750930786, -0.504881739616394, 0.37480679154396057, -0.1931896209716797, -0.7272288203239441, -0.10039902478456497, -0.2410731315612793, 0.6439099311828613, -0.1347339153289795, 1.153503179550171, 0.29026973247528076, -0.06439318507909775, -0.08286430686712265, -0.331978976726532, 0.5669286847114563, 0.39496085047721863, 0.36241310834884644, 1.368554949760437, -0.8610095381736755, 0.3887765109539032, 0.4480684995651245, 0.8527331352233887, 0.2303781807422638, 0.6170666217803955, 0.8300822377204895, -0.6989750862121582, 0.4791216552257538, -0.0973115786910057, 0.31220147013664246, 0.43574512004852295, 0.10344476997852325, 0.0916057825088501, 0.3321525454521179, -0.554722249507904, -0.13420575857162476, -0.4141997694969177, 0.24596138298511505, -0.2985796332359314, 0.24318747222423553, 1.2647298574447632, -0.30481258034706116, 0.2616029977798462, -0.03294406458735466, 0.6061084866523743, 0.5461497902870178, -0.21415841579437256, -0.1510315090417862, -0.07362042367458344, -1.006784439086914, 0.45035794377326965, -0.4549001157283783, -0.42926526069641113, -0.548096239566803, 0.6654850244522095, -0.2886715531349182, -0.5376742482185364, -0.7603721618652344, -0.6229498386383057, -0.20072372257709503, -0.03726483881473541, -0.026083530858159065, -0.4351319968700409, 0.6348322033882141, 0.114323191344738, -0.9368230104446411, 0.13970960676670074, -0.7010986804962158, -0.42033258080482483, 0.7157636880874634, 0.5043444633483887, -1.3983267545700073, -0.3773970603942871, 0.005471677519381046, -0.026511313393712044, -0.0693071261048317, 0.06530117243528366, 0.46139997243881226, 0.6527670621871948, -0.6055953502655029, 0.15943275392055511, -0.4609734117984772, 0.2568499743938446, -0.1578158736228943, -0.0763469859957695, 0.06163398548960686, 0.7244211435317993, 0.6140523552894592, 0.5719544291496277, -0.5559671521186829, 0.5051953792572021, -0.8016371130943298, 0.5161487460136414, -0.14873729646205902, -0.22752858698368073, -0.5335002541542053, -0.6222893595695496, -0.0006185882375575602, -0.06507836282253265, -0.5876315832138062, -0.3307131826877594, -0.4925602376461029, 0.256614089012146, -0.07578667253255844, -0.5222965478897095, 0.570214033126831, -0.21128493547439575, 0.5775182843208313, 1.1591813564300537, -0.6160144209861755, 0.7055452466011047, -0.4143608510494232, -0.1993778795003891, 0.2260749340057373, 0.08917495608329773, 0.2806561589241028, 0.468025267124176, -0.2299538254737854, -0.5888305306434631, 0.09963654726743698, -0.13516449928283691, 0.4343797266483307, -1.1080152988433838, -0.4297550916671753, -0.39918383955955505, -0.5188555717468262, -0.7377364635467529, -0.29584142565727234, -0.9144564867019653, 0.7704908847808838, -0.3368775248527527, -0.48919612169265747, -0.008874231949448586, -0.5752833485603333, -0.15055108070373535, -0.008855516090989113, -0.4041248559951782, 0.18147124350070953, 0.1331278681755066, -0.40592125058174133, 1.2336702346801758, -0.20687304437160492, -1.2177692651748657, 0.2468627691268921, 0.09471737593412399, -0.5989364981651306, -0.35714802145957947, -0.6206912398338318, -0.4933786988258362, -0.4113765060901642, 0.04742911085486412, -0.363411009311676, -0.9267155528068542, -0.07911445200443268, -0.537160336971283, 0.8167563080787659, 0.6407360434532166, -0.48750248551368713, -0.2934437692165375, 0.6214503049850464, 0.35889434814453125, -0.7799897789955139, -0.4875384271144867, 0.1257370412349701, 0.5666820406913757, -0.38431310653686523, -0.3137316107749939, -0.668738842010498, -0.04303641617298126, -1.030032992362976, 0.7350450158119202, -0.8844015598297119, 0.3445306420326233, -0.3614025413990021, -0.49700504541397095, 0.5732258558273315, 0.4418528079986572, 0.37096455693244934, 0.38078105449676514, -0.9445896744728088, -0.8810154795646667, 0.5575850009918213, 0.5878243446350098, -0.32118284702301025, -0.6792351603507996, -0.38390985131263733, 0.15936179459095, 0.5453802943229675, -0.2556125223636627, -0.6808408498764038, 0.4763641953468323, 0.11099833250045776, 0.7523449063301086, 0.5540275573730469, -0.43237534165382385, -0.7778691053390503, 0.18827860057353973, 1.145592451095581, -0.5990201830863953, 0.1989382803440094, -1.0736546516418457, 0.5147829055786133, -0.154596209526062, 0.791318953037262, -0.3533533811569214, -0.03534442186355591, 0.3283878564834595, -0.8798308372497559, 0.6619336009025574, -0.5895974636077881, 0.27612632513046265, 0.13584290444850922, -0.23671358823776245, -0.6076875329017639, 0.09720657765865326, -0.7398014068603516, -0.6149001121520996, -0.6674044728279114, -0.5467630624771118, 0.47065314650535583, -0.2006041407585144, -0.3312055170536041, 0.3468678891658783, 0.02638154663145542, 0.8173179626464844, -0.37464699149131775, 1.29971444606781, 0.21236978471279144, -0.4928169548511505, 0.29095637798309326, 0.35484185814857483, 0.04876900464296341, 0.08682861179113388, -0.25330835580825806, -0.024595078080892563, -0.24973703920841217, -0.251323401927948, 0.46465644240379333, 0.045521751046180725, -0.40826550126075745, 0.6495664715766907, 0.42878758907318115, 0.441679447889328, 0.19448673725128174, 0.3968835175037384, -0.293262243270874, -0.9603994488716125, 0.2534731328487396, 0.6463800072669983, -0.39201483130455017, -0.06866689771413803, 1.4186480045318604, -0.136372908949852, -0.082939013838768, 0.16402721405029297, -0.7874859571456909, 0.29156166315078735, 0.3586171269416809, 0.5642102360725403, -0.24535073339939117, -1.0846725702285767, 0.7200124859809875, 0.4263743460178375, -0.7408889532089233, -1.1326980590820312, -0.2514779269695282, -0.43016430735588074, 0.04013390466570854, 0.35398542881011963, -0.35176488757133484, -0.12212205678224564, -0.19093358516693115, -0.15746033191680908, 0.025712596252560616, 0.6319171190261841, -0.1613311916589737, -0.5189922451972961, -0.1048130914568901, -0.5898780226707458, 0.31704801321029663, 1.0731024742126465, 0.4321511387825012, 0.33715149760246277, 0.1448567807674408, -0.06267350912094116, -0.35172897577285767, 0.18669094145298004, 0.07949169725179672, -0.6439114212989807, -0.17164090275764465, -0.33428481221199036, 0.3384503424167633, 0.03976903110742569, 0.4212873578071594, 0.26223209500312805, 0.6457160711288452, 0.4574974477291107, -0.8499271869659424, -0.03243366628885269, 0.802183985710144, 0.2507689893245697, 0.6678393483161926, 0.44409307837486267, 0.2408520132303238, 0.3931547999382019, 0.17933489382266998, 0.8754178881645203, -0.5326265096664429, -0.342157781124115, -0.061151206493377686, 0.3631962239742279, 0.07866189628839493, -0.48841848969459534, 0.1001092791557312, 0.5347132086753845, -0.7148498296737671, -0.4990335702896118, -0.09146018326282501, 0.43634092807769775, 0.28077441453933716, 0.050818197429180145, -0.43083450198173523, -0.07247965037822723, -0.4910900294780731, -0.8842756748199463, -0.3592645525932312, -0.6161545515060425, 0.054876696318387985, 1.04734468460083, -0.3268708884716034, -0.3984954059123993, 0.5224847197532654, 0.564427375793457, 0.02093539759516716, 0.6888573169708252, -0.45974400639533997, -0.38949549198150635, -0.8469955921173096, 0.3582023084163666, 0.23879273235797882, 0.5241852402687073, 0.8193838000297546, -0.2660865783691406, 0.2663975954055786, 1.0170704126358032, -0.3152463436126709, -0.8234245777130127, -0.07434222102165222, 0.5751082897186279, -0.4498155415058136, -0.30477043986320496, -0.43941739201545715, 0.9029416441917419, -1.1583638191223145, -0.4357854127883911, 0.06320294737815857, -0.2805732488632202, -0.29452255368232727, 0.329234778881073, -0.0751514658331871, 0.47905224561691284, 0.3142351508140564, 0.18234075605869293, -0.0753759816288948, 0.1913846731185913, 0.6396051645278931, 0.06533464044332504, 0.5848804116249084, -0.2217194139957428, 0.2840772867202759, -0.9840871095657349, -0.4710485637187958, 0.1758992075920105, -0.26792338490486145, 0.014104620553553104, -0.296235591173172, 0.5517517924308777, -0.398301899433136, 0.030847903341054916, 0.09208237379789352, -0.14403654634952545, 0.08492964506149292, 0.7350513339042664, -0.10189539194107056, -0.4356001317501068, -0.6616637110710144, -0.1861710548400879, -1.33897066116333, -0.8011358976364136, 0.3512759208679199, -0.4333575963973999, 0.03075500577688217, -1.0025882720947266, -0.8737191557884216, -0.013273467309772968, 0.2671685814857483, -0.5452548861503601, -0.6579388380050659, 0.9163137674331665, 0.5406701564788818, 0.5568679571151733, 0.18714433908462524, 0.046391893178224564, 0.1837349534034729, 0.43290945887565613, -0.9979611039161682, -0.15827642381191254, 0.010117311030626297, 0.6909345984458923, 0.034057360142469406, 0.5298932194709778, -0.6422884464263916, -0.3462080657482147, -0.6830318570137024, -0.6681491732597351, -0.21178781986236572, -0.01727757230401039, -1.0888622999191284, -0.13267654180526733, -1.05948805809021, 0.048385366797447205, -0.40484920144081116, 0.9231168031692505, 0.10202081501483917, -0.8556182384490967, -0.23382391035556793, 0.02390696108341217, 1.7581849098205566, -0.2576991021633148, 0.8910072445869446, 0.24039581418037415, 0.288075715303421, -0.41954851150512695, -0.5800715088844299, 0.8246079087257385, 0.39934611320495605, -0.14456050097942352, -0.21652770042419434, -0.46333250403404236, 1.069973111152649, 0.3130000829696655, 0.5981444716453552, -0.2854960262775421, 0.9177004098892212, 0.5239582657814026, 0.2751246690750122, 0.8953555822372437, 0.03208846226334572, 0.2320876568555832, 0.3888019919395447, -0.6196187138557434, 0.04223316162824631, 0.299820214509964, 0.20233620703220367, 0.013319958001375198, -0.27514198422431946, 0.5994722247123718, -0.6470723152160645, -0.0015876332763582468, 0.08629415929317474, 0.4678516983985901, 1.5603805780410767, 0.2603066563606262, 0.287143349647522, 0.3343351185321808, 0.7696658372879028, -0.23093411326408386, 0.5265940427780151, 1.3288335800170898, -0.46306973695755005, -0.40488725900650024, -0.6702292561531067, 0.10476089268922806, 0.20129266381263733, 0.1303945779800415, 0.28848835825920105, -0.15675128996372223, -0.10113639384508133, 0.8336038589477539, -0.23602983355522156, 0.3648856282234192, 0.4920518398284912, 0.28937387466430664, 0.04823262616991997, -0.0046771797351539135, 0.3245827257633209, -0.163221076130867, -0.8450518846511841, 0.803467869758606, -0.9348116517066956, -0.31232064962387085, 0.44549065828323364, 0.0226037185639143, 0.5589751601219177, 0.1448313146829605, -0.19194529950618744, -0.6697789430618286, -0.05558795854449272, 0.1995023787021637, 0.3764665424823761, -0.1403043270111084, -0.6602529287338257, 0.04436017572879791, -0.36450278759002686, -0.2781555652618408, -0.3136908710002899, 0.35920220613479614, -0.6675751805305481, -0.16555428504943848, 0.2718059718608856, -0.3217298984527588, -0.34170350432395935, -0.881924569606781, -0.29265883564949036, 0.03621947765350342, -0.22161491215229034, -0.2458294928073883, 0.36581942439079285, 0.6473904252052307, -0.31150534749031067, 0.3798174560070038, -0.42884546518325806, -0.5968639254570007, 0.35710540413856506, -1.5270726680755615, 0.6622662544250488, -0.015215322375297546, -0.4473552107810974, -0.7632537484169006, -1.1859652996063232, -0.9947176575660706, -0.3834751844406128, -0.14604754745960236, -0.7873021960258484, 0.25189781188964844, 0.34424784779548645, 0.3026127517223358, 0.48199713230133057, 0.42969074845314026, 0.8876407742500305, 0.6782172918319702, 0.5817809700965881, -0.016027139499783516, 0.3674839437007904, -0.06190316006541252, 0.4723483622074127, -0.3985063433647156, -0.21259909868240356, -0.5223364233970642, 0.14405322074890137, 0.27769193053245544, -1.0144425630569458, 0.20311087369918823, -0.4417220652103424, -0.8279745578765869, 0.42911356687545776, 0.44016963243484497, -0.558020830154419, -0.1305895894765854, -0.44099709391593933, 0.24781499803066254, -0.13297612965106964, 0.3439261317253113, -0.6333133578300476, -0.038480423390865326, 0.10335628688335419, 0.41765284538269043, 0.19695423543453217, -0.9297229051589966, 4.106612682342529, 1.0960861444473267, 0.6328339576721191, -0.37403205037117004, 0.7445369958877563, 0.8069149255752563, 0.2998785376548767, -0.5176512598991394, -0.07786526530981064, -0.06954317539930344, -0.3398800790309906, 0.8024885654449463, 0.4160291254520416, -0.3679535388946533, 0.08613856881856918, 0.34747880697250366, -0.975641131401062, 0.6867008805274963, -0.27843987941741943, -1.222918152809143, -0.4920547306537628, -0.14410927891731262, -0.29640093445777893, -0.07920708507299423, 0.3810475766658783, -0.11950048804283142, 0.4362291693687439, 0.6296361684799194, -0.3353079855442047, -0.4904229938983917, -0.017687363550066948, -0.5374733805656433, 0.511193573474884, -0.5007718205451965, -0.2700350284576416, 0.18090884387493134, -0.4417075514793396, -1.0993045568466187, 0.007324934937059879, 0.08218319714069366, -0.05006333813071251, -0.590709388256073, 0.2994963526725769, -0.3713078796863556, -0.7610536217689514, 0.2569543421268463, -0.5804315805435181, 0.17190496623516083, 0.8870471715927124, -0.31589433550834656, 0.4692332446575165, -0.8433793187141418, 0.4799158573150635, -0.19338035583496094, -0.7383668422698975, -0.4609958529472351, -0.2789554297924042, -0.6772052645683289, -0.17097145318984985, 0.029744796454906464, 0.011727161705493927, -0.13796280324459076, -0.14942818880081177, -0.43500182032585144, 0.3409110903739929, 0.6344739198684692, 0.7807114124298096, 0.5567783117294312, -0.3697128891944885, -0.4334529936313629, -0.10505349934101105, -0.6642594933509827, -0.6058409214019775, 0.8209625482559204, 0.737179696559906, 0.6969522833824158, -0.36354580521583557, 0.7698003053665161, -0.45671066641807556, 0.08476468920707703, 0.5518985390663147, 0.3835568130016327, 0.3615204095840454, -0.5729740858078003, 0.7317412495613098, 0.3244304656982422, -0.2265198528766632, -0.28031495213508606, -1.262992024421692, 0.8085867762565613, 0.1870824694633484, 0.39874765276908875, 0.28945979475975037, 0.18888254463672638, -0.4927976131439209 ]
{"Title": "The Human Leukocyte Antigen Locus and Susceptibility to Rheumatic Heart Disease in South Asians and Europeans", "Authors": "Auckland Kathryn, Mittal Balraj, Cairns Benjamin J, Garg Naveen, Kumar Surendra, Mentzer Alexander J, Kado Joseph, Perman Mai Ling, Steer Andrew C, Hill Adrian V S, Parks Tom", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Rheumatic heart disease (RHD) remains an important cause of morbidity and mortality globally. Several reports have linked the disease to the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) locus but with negligible consistency. Methods We undertook a genome-wide association study (GWAS) of susceptibility to RHD in 1163 South Asians (672 cases; 491 controls) recruited in India and Fiji. We analysed directly obtained and imputed genotypes, and followed-up associated loci in 1459 Europeans (150 cases; 1309 controls) from the UK Biobank study. For fine-mapping, we used HLA imputation to define classical alleles and amino acid polymorphisms. Results A single signal situated in the HLA class III region reached genome-wide significance in the South Asians, and replicated in the Europeans (rs201026476; combined odds ratio 1.81, 95% confidence intervals 1.51-2.18, P =3.48\u00d710 \u221210 ). While the signal fine-mapped to specific amino acid polymorphisms within HLA-DQB1 and HLA-B , with conditioning, the lead class III variant remained associated with susceptibility ( P =3.34\u00d710 \u22124 ), suggesting an independent effect. Conclusions A complex HLA signal, likely comprising at least two underlying causal variants, strongly associates with susceptibility to RHD in South Asians and Europeans. Crucially, the involvement of the class III region may partly explain the previous inconsistency, while offering important new insight into pathogenesis.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003160"}
10.1101/19008458
[ -0.02513030730187893, -0.28313693404197693, -0.5558453798294067, 0.399787962436676, -0.6722510457038879, -0.9003904461860657, 0.3905409276485443, 0.7519323229789734, 0.9589196443557739, 0.4450905919075012, -0.07991219311952591, -0.6746237874031067, 0.18426841497421265, -0.18346965312957764, -0.13259488344192505, -0.27208411693573, -0.563336968421936, -0.03756686672568321, -0.5356312990188599, 0.4326362907886505, 0.49898484349250793, 0.7455931305885315, -0.3900938332080841, 0.10444257408380508, -0.2175588756799698, 0.513914167881012, -0.22442902624607086, 0.14583343267440796, 0.4372154176235199, 0.8272908926010132, 0.4719817638397217, -0.35777074098587036, 0.3851097524166107, -0.9115664958953857, -0.04216701537370682, -0.011204556562006474, 0.39973184466362, -0.9020535349845886, -0.18496111035346985, -0.4067140221595764, 0.7603237628936768, -0.10193122178316116, 0.6874083876609802, -0.31676366925239563, -0.13773229718208313, 0.2450428605079651, -0.21839149296283722, -0.18532226979732513, -0.4796393811702728, -0.461830198764801, -0.14353905618190765, -0.6310145854949951, 0.35203489661216736, -0.28516727685928345, 0.41175124049186707, -0.42661163210868835, 0.21337822079658508, 0.42652860283851624, -0.5670371651649475, -0.06024864315986633, 0.056695595383644104, -0.277660995721817, -0.03594544902443886, -1.380470871925354, 0.45108845829963684, 0.7551279067993164, 0.4082282483577728, -0.1459069848060608, -0.1630975753068924, -0.20452706515789032, -0.42734602093696594, -0.7121297717094421, -0.6054969429969788, -0.4116622805595398, 0.08835674822330475, -0.4575696587562561, 0.3287118077278137, 0.06662614643573761, -0.18419449031352997, -0.4809620976448059, 0.531134307384491, 0.3666136860847473, -0.6010235548019409, 0.5020557641983032, -0.812581479549408, -0.10050246864557266, -0.3771699368953705, 0.7621680498123169, 0.20183327794075012, 0.520698606967926, 0.15159720182418823, 0.5592962503433228, 0.3146119713783264, 0.11377622187137604, 0.7765774726867676, 1.2223223447799683, -0.3072715103626251, -0.20361602306365967, 0.023078924044966698, -0.029064446687698364, 1.026160717010498, 0.06709068268537521, -0.2722601890563965, 0.5590086579322815, -0.4133604168891907, 0.8851755261421204, 1.0544477701187134, -0.4592588245868683, 0.2770935595035553, -1.4824386835098267, 0.4609086811542511, 0.33571040630340576, -0.4449402391910553, 0.33816543221473694, -0.2506919801235199, 0.5773116946220398, -0.6392451524734497, 0.37751689553260803, -0.7238577604293823, 0.5862855315208435, -0.3099551498889923, 0.7319387197494507, 0.26777032017707825, -0.9690375924110413, 0.6405506730079651, -0.01626335084438324, 0.5241854786872864, 0.9014290571212769, -0.478878378868103, 0.007545026484876871, 0.07118534296751022, -0.8052365183830261, 0.05737665668129921, 0.6260040998458862, -0.5202986001968384, -0.6144668459892273, 0.31946516036987305, 1.0586000680923462, 0.38539549708366394, -0.8536929488182068, -1.0587379932403564, 0.5911744236946106, -0.18283294141292572, 1.143221139907837, -0.4470890760421753, 0.7011531591415405, -0.27959388494491577, -1.4319212436676025, -0.2649479806423187, 0.07361051440238953, 0.34435251355171204, 0.9962230324745178, -0.2195744812488556, -0.20744822919368744, 0.041566330939531326, -0.40304359793663025, -0.5520973801612854, 0.3056284189224243, 0.46918821334838867, -0.17877449095249176, -0.07422354817390442, 0.21047089993953705, 0.18417838215827942, 1.1877371072769165, -0.3062953054904938, 0.7010869979858398, -0.6600485444068909, 0.5903530716896057, 0.6024900078773499, -0.5646635890007019, 0.316435307264328, 0.4016224145889282, -0.5562054514884949, 0.0881122276186943, 1.1139953136444092, 1.5205661058425903, -0.06441906094551086, -0.2852396070957184, 0.44027331471443176, -0.295855849981308, 0.012610966339707375, 0.16532714664936066, 0.12793248891830444, 1.1365852355957031, -0.13644149899482727, 0.6010518670082092, -0.09564848989248276, -1.1890357732772827, 0.03467017412185669, -0.3747045397758484, 0.02321971394121647, 0.6380560398101807, -0.7136001586914062, 0.6852922439575195, 0.5490541458129883, -0.21599438786506653, -0.028098825365304947, 0.48997339606285095, 0.354140967130661, -0.13989390432834625, 0.07238561660051346, 0.2601519823074341, 0.08316691219806671, 0.3830137550830841, 0.3348880708217621, 0.15001539885997772, 0.5649186968803406, 0.61439049243927, 0.12425501644611359, -0.009652641601860523, 1.2742505073547363, 0.02887064777314663, -1.0125735998153687, -0.6743676662445068, 0.6085459589958191, -0.40448519587516785, -0.9177123308181763, 0.19139358401298523, -0.5380392670631409, -0.06928488612174988, -0.9595839381217957, 0.16434858739376068, -0.31278225779533386, -0.46492132544517517, -0.6073338389396667, -0.2612355053424835, 0.21209703385829926, -0.2842395305633545, -0.48483046889305115, 0.05280110612511635, 0.44124191999435425, 0.6199166774749756, 0.30351749062538147, 0.23742277920246124, 0.9444178342819214, 0.6339374780654907, -0.05886000767350197, 0.4932868182659149, 0.696465253829956, 0.7804918885231018, 0.040767230093479156, 0.9869223833084106, 0.6179774403572083, 0.6699293255805969, -0.06303206086158752, -0.17699436843395233, -0.032764732837677, 0.137073814868927, 0.078329898416996, 0.30469658970832825, -0.7777995467185974, 0.8959304094314575, 0.20075950026512146, 0.4026418626308441, -1.2805346250534058, -0.19821248948574066, 0.2827128767967224, -0.02113363891839981, -0.5590111613273621, -0.7179591655731201, -0.5540215969085693, 0.41260555386543274, 0.2991851568222046, -0.0368524044752121, 1.374522089958191, 1.0267295837402344, -0.5979259610176086, 0.38071951270103455, 0.09276480227708817, 0.13050149381160736, -0.6562290191650391, -0.5304177403450012, -1.1388988494873047, -1.106583833694458, -0.9526568651199341, 0.6438926458358765, 0.3973933458328247, -0.021607033908367157, -0.2852587103843689, 0.3912144899368286, 0.6258115172386169, -0.5555664896965027, -0.10921266674995422, 0.1944655328989029, 0.005199205130338669, -0.10468006134033203, -0.846738874912262, 0.041839826852083206, -0.7299997210502625, 0.23388582468032837, -0.14813894033432007, -0.457300066947937, 0.20472972095012665, -0.9795763492584229, 0.5539537072181702, -0.7991309762001038, -0.16486351191997528, -0.37436842918395996, -0.5834078788757324, -0.6018676161766052, 0.4811338782310486, -0.447115957736969, -0.27801457047462463, 0.3594643771648407, -1.1225184202194214, 0.7789210677146912, -0.057328399270772934, 0.4135841429233551, 0.46117106080055237, 0.19467486441135406, -0.7417608499526978, 0.1369752734899521, -0.4931546151638031, -0.04330367222428322, -0.44582515954971313, 0.1308397352695465, 0.633665919303894, 0.09164733439683914, 0.2621650695800781, -0.23999160528182983, -0.814051628112793, -0.8338833451271057, 0.014356397092342377, 0.14946356415748596, -0.20519039034843445, 0.16932876408100128, 0.29657602310180664, -0.9090895652770996, -0.09989853948354721, 0.12342006713151932, -1.0668102502822876, 0.5255936980247498, -0.2908107340335846, 0.7293609380722046, 0.4106321930885315, -0.2786462903022766, -0.5555415749549866, 0.05919681116938591, 0.29594099521636963, -0.11784081906080246, -0.09775803238153458, -0.8000375032424927, -0.30346354842185974, 0.10185032337903976, -0.6370829939842224, 0.12836334109306335, 0.6416380405426025, -0.04542308673262596, -0.45447081327438354, 0.17484495043754578, -0.21078184247016907, 0.2804696559906006, 0.3882812261581421, -0.17514371871948242, -0.6359350681304932, 0.8938459157943726, -0.38491082191467285, -0.1837318241596222, 0.21295307576656342, -0.16026891767978668, -0.3511490523815155, -0.00833974964916706, -0.6714339852333069, 0.39059606194496155, -0.7607297897338867, -0.8440073132514954, 0.755255937576294, -0.5274698734283447, 0.9167280793190002, -0.1468878835439682, 0.8026168942451477, -0.11118263006210327, -0.12730726599693298, -0.08675094693899155, -0.046724189072847366, 0.16037558019161224, 1.4002262353897095, 0.4720311462879181, 0.8044628500938416, -1.2260583639144897, 0.14159555733203888, 0.7639328837394714, 1.1486161947250366, 0.46062320470809937, -0.11671227961778641, 0.5681502819061279, -1.206900954246521, -0.2570835053920746, 0.3560052812099457, -0.5691525936126709, 0.03176221624016762, -0.5927727818489075, -0.16756831109523773, -0.5508480668067932, -0.46762293577194214, 0.20746544003486633, -0.3591099977493286, 0.32359933853149414, 0.1113739088177681, -0.5879703760147095, 1.3526602983474731, 0.3567661941051483, 0.06718115508556366, 0.16990506649017334, 0.6397963166236877, 0.26459547877311707, -0.6869184970855713, 0.11492268741130829, -0.516076922416687, -0.9447555541992188, -0.5950270295143127, -0.07353003323078156, -0.30563613772392273, -0.20519641041755676, 0.3766625225543976, -0.11172808706760406, -0.22129087150096893, -0.628929853439331, -0.6151073575019836, 0.01123979315161705, 0.6498225331306458, -0.21229146420955658, 0.5354018211364746, 0.13788363337516785, -0.2782835364341736, 0.16344498097896576, 0.12558531761169434, -0.7228654026985168, 0.441123366355896, 1.254079818725586, -0.20203523337841034, -0.9532272815704346, -1.0054858922958374, 0.07725097239017487, -0.10360727459192276, -0.2203076183795929, -0.4700896143913269, -0.07717350870370865, -0.1696239411830902, -0.7355557680130005, 0.024352911859750748, -0.5284714698791504, 0.1252804845571518, 0.05314340442419052, -0.07044076919555664, 0.5826207995414734, 0.05641911178827286, 0.23112383484840393, 0.5769330263137817, -0.3572327494621277, 0.22830720245838165, -0.7204915881156921, 0.1903955638408661, -0.08846622705459595, -0.4867464303970337, -0.17420436441898346, 0.10095767676830292, -0.07119119167327881, 0.314175546169281, -0.7696875929832458, -0.19919808208942413, 0.26528722047805786, -0.11922518163919449, 0.26780053973197937, -0.8497795462608337, 1.0159562826156616, -0.9596701860427856, -0.1250510960817337, 0.9574987292289734, -0.39884287118911743, -0.38994643092155457, -0.5892695188522339, -0.2873668670654297, -0.4147374927997589, 0.36648592352867126, -0.28446099162101746, -0.012010795995593071, 0.5292489528656006, -0.03850480541586876, 0.24833743274211884, -0.06712068617343903, 0.22646144032478333, -0.11655393242835999, 0.18752145767211914, -1.0388617515563965, -0.2872258722782135, 0.02048618160188198, -1.0670974254608154, -0.4739019572734833, 0.5923941731452942, -0.1344784051179886, 0.01634260080754757, -0.010733269155025482, 0.07695446908473969, 0.07293137907981873, 0.2827942967414856, -0.6729089021682739, -0.005337964743375778, -0.8650250434875488, -0.0816468745470047, 0.8425643444061279, -0.07377668470144272, -0.924899160861969, 0.2227841466665268, 1.389688491821289, -0.8927436470985413, -0.4804629683494568, 0.1979319006204605, 0.5879514813423157, -0.42559313774108887, 0.37950730323791504, -0.01814865507185459, -0.7372471690177917, -0.18681664764881134, -0.2792198956012726, -0.14855840802192688, -0.019607773050665855, -0.2744864225387573, -0.0025851542595773935, 0.5266888737678528, -0.1830451935529709, -0.30172857642173767, 0.5097011923789978, 0.9889464378356934, -0.07389742881059647, 0.3524762690067291, -0.26773592829704285, -1.0525763034820557, -1.0224546194076538, -1.1912904977798462, 0.019832467660307884, -0.7982117533683777, -0.11547011137008667, -0.6682915687561035, 0.3769111931324005, 0.17862525582313538, 0.42536869645118713, -0.20363016426563263, 0.1705620288848877, -0.39016538858413696, -0.1567094773054123, 0.7102660536766052, -0.034776926040649414, 0.12343816459178925, -0.21157461404800415, -0.0495317317545414, 0.3640952408313751, 1.2377747297286987, -0.22872039675712585, 0.40008604526519775, -0.29044049978256226, -0.06927978992462158, 0.45333513617515564, 0.007548917084932327, 0.15100817382335663, -0.32242143154144287, 0.0750361979007721, 0.4847729504108429, -0.08747217059135437, -0.08415263891220093, -1.2030656337738037, 0.40065357089042664, -0.6522397398948669, 0.2636834979057312, -0.5131531357765198, -0.5815913081169128, -0.22447095811367035, 0.5409515500068665, 1.132362723350525, -0.5178647041320801, 0.16647744178771973, 0.5040157437324524, -0.8454799652099609, 0.1936393529176712, 0.11739611625671387, -0.5953580737113953, -0.08505253493785858, -0.520634114742279, -0.8711708784103394, 0.3426562547683716, 0.08103087544441223, -0.13288038969039917, -0.15408170223236084, -0.037596944719552994, -0.17271968722343445, -1.0055187940597534, 1.1538355350494385, 0.5143903493881226, -0.7574945092201233, -0.20349016785621643, -0.13970541954040527, 0.7980728149414062, 0.22870849072933197, 0.17099562287330627, 0.3902573883533478, -0.9372356534004211, 0.08883784711360931, -0.09416230022907257, -0.7817512154579163, -0.8284043073654175, -0.44964462518692017, -0.07672540843486786, 0.9276134967803955, -0.08388040959835052, 0.13823075592517853, 0.2173382192850113, 0.0061906673945486546, -0.9269663691520691, 0.8300914168357849, -0.4058949947357178, 0.004830008838325739, 0.3807656466960907, 0.12873339653015137, -0.14035727083683014, 0.09262032061815262, -0.4028950035572052, 0.5848431587219238, -0.30913540720939636, 0.338981568813324, 0.17157474160194397, -0.8265483379364014, 1.145092248916626, 0.005292381625622511, -0.4195655584335327, -0.19913753867149353, -0.529049277305603, -0.3029577136039734, 0.5802212357521057, -0.3438973128795624, 0.07912111282348633, 0.5119881629943848, 0.24784810841083527, 1.5557639598846436, -0.12130998820066452, 0.11196743696928024, 0.20224200189113617, -0.21918196976184845, 0.2536084055900574, -0.6585565805435181, 0.06324567645788193, 0.7305316925048828, -0.35821622610092163, 0.12876102328300476, 0.5850788950920105, 0.23325271904468536, 0.46187981963157654, -0.012081813998520374, 0.7158384323120117, -0.6234612464904785, 0.2823118269443512, -0.48119693994522095, -0.12866206467151642, 0.07730726152658463, 0.15162593126296997, 0.15768839418888092, 0.3834908902645111, -0.11740388721227646, -0.3097877502441406, -0.18701739609241486, 0.2778908908367157, 0.07130234688520432, 1.0105443000793457, 0.006603521760553122, 0.017615022137761116, 0.5810023546218872, 0.8228647708892822, -0.08942471444606781, -0.4717343747615814, -0.9219443798065186, -0.2975335121154785, -0.23412980139255524, 0.3304169178009033, -0.634566068649292, -0.19576823711395264, 0.23926801979541779, -0.4635879397392273, -0.8519884943962097, -0.4729740619659424, 0.7684316039085388, -0.3315425217151642, 0.22429271042346954, -1.0098916292190552, 0.11587286740541458, -0.36022207140922546, 0.05553105100989342, -0.10594040900468826, -1.0948485136032104, -0.48357006907463074, 0.5759995579719543, -0.8940715193748474, -0.1676856279373169, -0.11394918709993362, 0.39451873302459717, 0.1180608868598938, 0.33484145998954773, -0.25560981035232544, -0.4585629403591156, -0.26046475768089294, 0.33631378412246704, 0.10703501850366592, -0.12597866356372833, 0.7098312973976135, -0.12747815251350403, 0.562415361404419, 0.2934272289276123, -0.3447563648223877, 0.3842538595199585, -0.15529638528823853, 0.36214858293533325, -0.14849501848220825, -0.6467860341072083, 0.30977022647857666, 1.0072336196899414, -0.47147664427757263, -0.5788620114326477, -1.325100064277649, -0.2429252415895462, -0.3872438669204712, 0.06179194897413254, -0.07462544739246368, 0.2480141520500183, 0.08507002890110016, -0.2769196927547455, 0.2255965620279312, 1.063841700553894, -0.42206132411956787, -0.22414663434028625, 0.10561101138591766, -0.11417371779680252, 0.6697312593460083, -1.0846660137176514, -0.14792588353157043, -0.04856816679239273, -0.42203396558761597, 0.41388294100761414, -0.5101937055587769, -0.3144571781158447, 0.6458561420440674, 0.1449705809354782, 0.2049589306116104, 0.7724802494049072, -0.1227291002869606, 0.5146876573562622, -0.01180201768875122, -0.3349126875400543, -0.3508610427379608, -0.8190262913703918, -1.8215773105621338, -0.17585569620132446, 1.1471748352050781, -0.033252015709877014, -0.14119581878185272, -0.42182284593582153, -0.43377912044525146, 0.7734166979789734, 0.24509552121162415, 0.4972768723964691, 0.28999853134155273, 0.06216103211045265, -0.1244741827249527, 0.1502123773097992, 0.46176281571388245, 0.7040390372276306, -0.06310947239398956, 0.4161633253097534, -0.5746271014213562, -0.9195674061775208, 0.14447909593582153, 1.1620773077011108, -0.25738799571990967, -0.1288929283618927, 0.2986171245574951, -0.4020507037639618, 0.5594040155410767, -0.5983132719993591, 0.6856973171234131, 0.5374539494514465, -0.29341423511505127, 0.12909644842147827, 0.09705299139022827, 0.4644162654876709, -0.27272137999534607, 0.4445004165172577, 0.002496497007086873, -1.222017526626587, -0.6408657431602478, 0.6111966967582703, 0.4127441942691803, 0.6211138367652893, 0.18781034648418427, -0.7221212983131409, 0.8347135186195374, -0.12006058543920517, 0.10010094195604324, 0.0026999888941645622, 1.2780954837799072, -0.1819806694984436, -0.5186426043510437, 0.07521546632051468, 1.0240422487258911, 1.201590657234192, 0.5800471901893616, -0.23998324573040009, 0.47090062499046326, 0.6587483882904053, 0.04443234205245972, -0.07500109821557999, -0.5105713605880737, 0.8846529722213745, 0.6586321592330933, -0.14413025975227356, 0.5490937829017639, -0.17349381744861603, 1.3040934801101685, -0.37481653690338135, -0.13594922423362732, 0.6803825497627258, 0.02478809654712677, -0.7115088701248169, -0.0965345948934555, 0.3042770028114319, 0.9820060133934021, -0.0950566828250885, 0.4706111252307892, -0.10387303680181503, 0.45461684465408325, -0.43012019991874695, 0.1703546792268753, 0.5655045509338379, -0.26263612508773804, -0.48738864064216614, -0.25113868713378906, 0.4792696237564087, -0.06338216364383698, 0.22856400907039642, 0.335046648979187, -0.5709368586540222, 0.4142376482486725, 0.4098043739795685, -0.359654039144516, -0.3254493474960327, 0.7850219011306763, -0.5651519298553467, -0.3613922595977783, 0.20187069475650787, -0.11292225122451782, -0.2521754503250122, -0.8623868823051453, 0.9905043244361877, -0.11413519829511642, 0.08198314905166626, -0.18274934589862823, 0.3271881639957428, 0.5224961042404175, -0.13396775722503662, 0.4116423428058624, -0.9305799007415771, 0.3264522850513458, 0.7350416779518127, -0.6586776375770569, -0.4661542475223541, -0.9244709610939026, 0.2955940365791321, -0.055993322283029556, -0.6994875073432922, 0.1075071394443512, -0.10805989056825638, -0.5291325449943542, -0.527742862701416, 0.06845413148403168, -0.5115386843681335, -0.11768023669719696, -0.589605450630188, -0.5344082713127136, -0.06191454082727432, 0.19553814828395844, -0.32165032625198364, -0.35618942975997925, -0.08325831592082977, -0.01796789839863777, -0.4582395851612091, -0.3319811224937439, -0.10886627435684204, 0.12013755738735199, -0.28408172726631165, 0.7753479480743408, 0.22116072475910187, -0.5860621333122253, -0.19765222072601318, -0.49659258127212524, -0.47050637006759644, 0.2866547703742981, 0.20771248638629913, -0.7257066369056702, 0.3653405010700226, -0.3883826732635498, 0.483717679977417, 0.05950159952044487, -0.6398335695266724, -0.40119504928588867, 0.14895053207874298, 0.4772583842277527, -0.7880285978317261, 0.8492541313171387, 0.2308623492717743, 0.40537118911743164, 0.5948125123977661, 0.06369366496801376, 0.8514900207519531, -0.656220555305481, -0.31504181027412415, -0.13500471413135529, 0.3449883460998535, 0.1914968192577362, -0.12409466505050659, 0.6546122431755066, 0.4822370111942291, -0.033184826374053955, -0.20499414205551147, -0.6101884841918945, -1.0829474925994873, -0.8808155059814453, 1.3960909843444824, -0.07049379497766495, 0.1537613570690155, 0.6464160680770874, -0.3926025629043579, 1.0606533288955688, -1.529312252998352, 3.9921417236328125, 0.4888634979724884, 0.46438878774642944, -0.1896178275346756, -0.038311149924993515, 0.5689395070075989, 0.37534722685813904, -0.004683717619627714, 0.1906549632549286, 0.25053396821022034, -0.7055712342262268, 0.11359837651252747, 0.27921369671821594, -0.0861007496714592, 0.931285560131073, 0.5749688744544983, -0.7667389512062073, 0.3612731695175171, 0.23928605020046234, -1.0197473764419556, -0.13512249290943146, -0.3751775622367859, 0.6763015389442444, 0.544556200504303, 0.22838792204856873, 0.1754300445318222, 0.12223946303129196, 0.2909277379512787, -0.03424624353647232, -0.17070548236370087, 0.10602078586816788, -1.0525323152542114, 0.20815534889698029, -0.9606103301048279, -0.7032347321510315, 0.7266252636909485, 0.02387784980237484, -0.25455036759376526, -0.12425721436738968, -0.16394509375095367, -0.25395795702934265, 0.6459057927131653, -0.5090928077697754, -0.37609565258026123, -0.13842511177062988, 0.19265200197696686, -0.6851971745491028, 0.17118984460830688, 0.5584791302680969, -0.6923934817314148, 0.8364909887313843, -0.8750861883163452, 0.15189309418201447, 0.11315663158893585, -1.2972112894058228, -0.2428470402956009, 0.056195490062236786, -0.7471091151237488, 0.23489059507846832, -0.06754136085510254, 0.7971875667572021, -0.30864042043685913, -0.1822984218597412, 0.14383234083652496, 0.7359312176704407, 0.8497962951660156, 0.08015719801187515, 0.20149463415145874, -0.04707035422325134, -0.2377418726682663, -0.6088767051696777, -0.054229263216257095, -0.12318175286054611, -0.4834675192832947, 1.0705822706222534, 0.46733859181404114, -0.16328556835651398, 0.8242263793945312, 0.05587349459528923, -0.7436179518699646, 0.18009161949157715, -0.38837283849716187, -0.035004664212465286, 0.13476446270942688, -0.05080442503094673, 1.191333532333374, -0.6433122158050537, -1.0626846551895142, -0.2721450924873352, 0.31968316435813904, 0.8043993711471558, -0.39997151494026184, -0.24946686625480652, -0.08481544256210327, -0.11742665618658066 ]
{"Title": "Living alone, loneliness and lack of emotional support as predictors of suicide and self-harm: a nine-year follow up of the UK Biobank cohort", "Authors": "Shaw Richard J., Cullen Breda, Graham Nicholas, Lyall Donald M., Mackay Daniel, Okolie Chukwudi, Pearsall Robert, Ward Joey, John Ann, Smith Daniel J.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background The association between loneliness and suicide is poorly understood. We investigated how living alone, loneliness and emotional support were related to suicide and self-harm in a longitudinal design. Methods Between 2006 and 2010 UK Biobank recruited and assessed in detail over 0.5 million people in middle age. Data were linked to prospective hospital admission and mortality records. Adjusted Cox regression models were used to investigate relationships between living arrangements, loneliness and emotional support, and both suicide and self-harm as outcomes. Results For men, both living alone (Hazard Ratio (HR) 2.16, 95%CI 1.51-3.09) and living with non-partners (HR 1.80, 95%CI 1.08-3.00) were associated with death by suicide, independently of loneliness, which had a modest relationship with suicide (HR 1.43, 95%CI 0.1.01-2.03). For women, there was no evidence that living arrangements, loneliness or emotional support were associated with death by suicide. Associations between living alone and self-harm were explained by health for women, and by health, loneliness and emotional support for men. In fully adjusted models, loneliness was associated with hospital admissions for self-harm in both women (HR 1.89, 95%CI 1.57-2.28) and men (HR 1.74, 95%CI 1.40-2.16). Limitations Loneliness and emotional support were operationalized using single item measures. Conclusions For men - but not for women - living alone or living with a non-partner increased the risk of suicide, a finding not explained by subjective loneliness. Overall, loneliness may be more important as a risk factor for self-harm than for suicide. Loneliness also appears to lessen the protective associations of cohabitation. Highlights First cohort study to investigate loneliness\u2019s relationship with deaths by suicide Loneliness is associated with a modest increased risk of death by suicide for men For men, living with a partner reduces the risk of death by suicide Loneliness increases the risk of hospitalization for self-harm for men and women", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008458"}
10.1101/2019.12.12.19014555
[ -0.15762680768966675, 0.4212810695171356, 0.4069441556930542, 0.4266476333141327, 0.012408845126628876, -0.5873544812202454, -0.12189522385597229, -0.21270981431007385, 0.6034947633743286, 0.3343770205974579, -0.6254891157150269, -0.5281276106834412, -0.0930059477686882, -0.3252713978290558, -0.3931012451648712, -0.5620386004447937, -0.5936238765716553, -0.003134923754259944, -0.8361213803291321, -0.09586414694786072, 0.17048856616020203, 0.3682780861854553, -0.4154224991798401, 0.07634855806827545, 0.22208699584007263, 0.6946200132369995, 0.03366866707801819, 0.3726179301738739, 1.05829656124115, -0.07361208647489548, -0.26474255323410034, -0.7356051206588745, 0.030648263171315193, -0.8835551738739014, -0.25614285469055176, 0.34023424983024597, 0.5189377069473267, -0.02407759428024292, 0.2454529106616974, -0.1655379682779312, 0.07917855679988861, -0.1118050292134285, 0.6121417284011841, -1.0932101011276245, -0.7216750383377075, -0.46438658237457275, -0.5063754320144653, -0.04448236897587776, 0.23285304009914398, 0.42857375741004944, -0.37153127789497375, 0.11836332082748413, 0.104684978723526, 0.3112249970436096, 0.19740280508995056, -0.1505414843559265, 0.3139178156852722, 0.3607913553714752, -0.8573101162910461, -0.18396185338497162, 0.2398042529821396, 0.35852983593940735, 0.9676141142845154, -1.1972233057022095, 0.11347053945064545, 0.6223771572113037, -0.8317486047744751, -1.006137490272522, 0.07077012956142426, 0.23290079832077026, -0.33238139748573303, 0.32925722002983093, -0.20748090744018555, -0.23885193467140198, -0.05370586737990379, -0.46064260601997375, 0.2891461253166199, -0.02098400704562664, 0.014355091378092766, 0.02815643511712551, 0.2503322660923004, 0.333344429731369, 0.11954671144485474, 0.5102419257164001, -0.08225956559181213, -0.12480688840150833, 0.7099012136459351, 0.6599469780921936, 0.10720999538898468, 1.164347529411316, -0.3712034821510315, 0.2539910674095154, 0.07496757805347443, 0.2599393427371979, 0.4600886106491089, 0.7876647710800171, -0.47033634781837463, -0.08156590163707733, 0.03986681252717972, -0.5456092953681946, 0.9626095294952393, 0.12229444086551666, 0.07940507680177689, 0.35692670941352844, -0.28465768694877625, 0.570547342300415, 0.5709088444709778, 0.06374933570623398, -0.6235374212265015, -0.6130499243736267, 0.7977238297462463, 0.40935567021369934, -0.2455253005027771, 0.3004362881183624, 0.6996670961380005, 0.703524112701416, -0.22158044576644897, 0.8168274164199829, -0.8690739274024963, -0.03309629485011101, -0.13596147298812866, 0.36183711886405945, 0.5338648557662964, 0.09215898811817169, 0.2890699505805969, 0.24169336259365082, -0.5524078011512756, 0.32479971647262573, -0.31504136323928833, 0.31367799639701843, -0.5973138213157654, -0.6363477110862732, -0.4663732945919037, 0.722568690776825, 0.0986344963312149, -0.43778958916664124, 0.15192095935344696, 1.3603063821792603, -0.13439594209194183, -0.9682313203811646, -0.5152427554130554, 0.0978965163230896, -0.8954874873161316, 0.8963068127632141, 0.4418635070323944, 0.9360823631286621, -0.5894614458084106, -0.9505539536476135, -0.18972891569137573, -0.016576146706938744, -0.036026980727910995, 0.3263537585735321, 0.3339291512966156, -0.32343754172325134, -0.4991236627101898, 0.26508718729019165, -0.31984496116638184, 0.392102986574173, -0.032721057534217834, 0.18543139100074768, -0.036047130823135376, 0.5733813643455505, 0.5013611316680908, 0.5914003252983093, -1.2012909650802612, 0.5039372444152832, -0.052850883454084396, 0.3334640562534332, 0.37003809213638306, -0.5116048455238342, 0.5528510212898254, 0.46083828806877136, -0.03342769667506218, 0.35594791173934937, 0.32874903082847595, 0.11504536122083664, 0.6662534475326538, 0.022056078538298607, 0.2780315577983856, 0.4236885905265808, 0.6906693577766418, 0.050352662801742554, 0.6501909494400024, 0.01591028831899166, -0.5127226710319519, 0.1547994762659073, -0.5166455507278442, -0.7815368175506592, -0.25337716937065125, 0.08254659920930862, 0.13935284316539764, 0.3228411078453064, -1.0186095237731934, 0.46657446026802063, -0.3615879714488983, 0.2852082848548889, -0.25639867782592773, 0.5365673899650574, 0.32412189245224, -0.8713789582252502, -0.5157591700553894, 1.0447721481323242, 0.0823749527335167, -0.052845217287540436, -0.4645000994205475, 0.8621885776519775, 0.3443193733692169, 0.6733494997024536, -0.7506638765335083, 0.01745593547821045, 1.1075738668441772, -0.007221858017146587, -0.06464599072933197, 0.513942301273346, 0.30341213941574097, -0.41748422384262085, 0.01046318281441927, -0.3078517019748688, -0.5810855627059937, -0.5137730836868286, 0.12528032064437866, -0.17680466175079346, 0.8907012939453125, 0.19865833222866058, 0.042204588651657104, 0.23219682276248932, 1.1083171367645264, 0.5501477122306824, -0.35438963770866394, -0.6054211854934692, 1.0229589939117432, 0.6502640247344971, -0.47194358706474304, 0.25035610795021057, 0.26649412512779236, 0.3748485743999481, 0.10621717572212219, 0.15815506875514984, 0.013248300179839134, 0.6466932892799377, 0.5991848707199097, 0.013349665328860283, 0.9415233731269836, 0.03497640788555145, -0.1983821839094162, 1.086252212524414, -0.6944229006767273, 0.06255143880844116, -0.3885233700275421, 0.4580313563346863, -0.5095837116241455, 0.7324001789093018, 0.19032534956932068, -0.21092624962329865, -0.46431154012680054, -0.4074278175830841, 0.2156572937965393, 0.5516528487205505, 0.2999076545238495, -0.7231418490409851, -0.5016331076622009, -0.2587440311908722, -0.19372934103012085, -0.2697136402130127, 0.29821428656578064, 0.9691110253334045, 0.18361817300319672, 0.5155791640281677, -0.1973356455564499, -0.24209174513816833, -0.6283181309700012, -0.712300717830658, -1.6957030296325684, -0.4054637849330902, -1.1015053987503052, -0.3383205831050873, 0.3768296241760254, -0.2268746793270111, 0.6393871903419495, 0.5720104575157166, -0.19163982570171356, -0.2140502631664276, 0.14653469622135162, 0.569392740726471, 0.5836043357849121, 0.36139369010925293, -0.46535637974739075, 0.6666485667228699, -0.13761001825332642, 0.48035928606987, -0.20400388538837433, -0.25028616189956665, -0.1168828010559082, -0.9301071166992188, 0.594828188419342, -0.07833634316921234, -0.02847844734787941, 0.1578674018383026, -0.04183328151702881, -0.36986538767814636, -0.35244545340538025, 0.18763837218284607, -0.17092283070087433, -0.05475955456495285, -1.0383414030075073, 0.25427770614624023, 0.41946491599082947, 0.1131683960556984, -0.351530522108078, 0.5808496475219727, -0.3621096611022949, 0.404691606760025, -0.2268626093864441, 0.1127944216132164, -1.0222307443618774, 0.002828530501574278, 0.21437448263168335, 0.05481334403157234, 0.052612774074077606, -0.23139001429080963, -1.399323582649231, -0.6855590343475342, -0.3058343827724457, -0.28340989351272583, -0.4661567211151123, 0.25868213176727295, 0.11914246529340744, -0.9926409721374512, 0.2435479462146759, -0.8930769562721252, -0.9717817902565002, 0.646685004234314, 0.04022505506873131, -0.3268236517906189, 0.5200924873352051, 0.10798785090446472, -0.33194461464881897, -0.12401124835014343, 0.2917950749397278, 0.4648800790309906, -0.18347890675067902, 0.20545262098312378, -0.39514705538749695, 0.2594621777534485, 0.8775143027305603, 0.08025109767913818, 0.0776783749461174, -0.47606581449508667, 0.049830012023448944, 0.2602183520793915, -0.0024159683380275965, 0.35432571172714233, 0.31806275248527527, -0.0035143503919243813, 0.5666603446006775, 0.10187453031539917, -0.34198659658432007, -0.34060874581336975, 0.26554688811302185, -0.08298265188932419, -0.4395498037338257, 0.37059536576271057, 0.35350915789604187, -0.13102610409259796, -0.7828917503356934, -0.5288248658180237, 1.1053342819213867, 0.06149394437670708, 0.42151716351509094, -0.8278596997261047, 0.08695437014102936, 0.7208701372146606, -0.22081047296524048, 0.3730452358722687, -0.10769834369421005, -0.07606399804353714, 0.7714240550994873, -0.5103200674057007, 1.3898423910140991, -1.4926522970199585, 0.2607998251914978, 0.7708148956298828, 0.5385422110557556, 0.19173304736614227, 0.2949378192424774, 0.12718409299850464, -0.5482448935508728, 0.5439369678497314, 0.19678109884262085, 0.37633636593818665, 0.4154769480228424, -0.09359372407197952, -0.06439673155546188, -0.22947368025779724, -0.8218517303466797, -0.7291545271873474, -0.048646558076143265, 0.48468345403671265, -0.1990347057580948, -0.5851535201072693, 1.0641257762908936, -0.787263810634613, 0.23419317603111267, 0.23643508553504944, 0.8215019702911377, 0.237253338098526, -0.6564416289329529, 0.16506248712539673, 0.7145209312438965, -0.4653097689151764, 0.4992734491825104, 0.34564515948295593, -0.38176411390304565, 0.0510539636015892, 0.3972959816455841, -0.11278481781482697, -0.6028528809547424, -0.3420071303844452, -0.5316650867462158, 0.4130741357803345, -0.4362751841545105, 0.6990349292755127, -0.9157472252845764, -0.4133191704750061, 0.4743752181529999, -0.7158344984054565, -0.2512775659561157, -0.3911525011062622, -0.013287559151649475, 1.234531283378601, -0.3592032790184021, -0.6477380990982056, 0.11194203048944473, -0.2415095865726471, 0.2625636160373688, -0.29689186811447144, 0.0591096468269825, -0.1256890445947647, 0.2532634139060974, 0.3545909523963928, -0.4794639050960541, -0.509644627571106, -0.8272931575775146, 0.36603084206581116, 0.42825981974601746, 0.23490576446056366, 0.9770705103874207, 0.26179784536361694, 0.5798841118812561, -0.3187755346298218, 1.014130711555481, -0.653945803642273, 0.6210264563560486, 0.05358315631747246, -0.19504886865615845, -0.6972792148590088, -0.5368188619613647, 0.32401856780052185, -0.1954004168510437, -0.5427030920982361, -0.5119410753250122, 0.009712450206279755, 0.8639582991600037, -0.2954140603542328, -0.562370777130127, 0.5912871360778809, -0.44361498951911926, 0.3445499837398529, 0.6768876910209656, 0.3963952660560608, -0.0923520103096962, -0.5359095335006714, 0.11376183480024338, -0.7905822396278381, 0.7021914720535278, 0.6055774092674255, 0.6501824259757996, 0.21658657491207123, -0.14366888999938965, -0.29706862568855286, -0.1252434104681015, 0.1513257920742035, -1.243752360343933, -0.3127182722091675, -0.3180217146873474, -0.3116273283958435, -1.0148288011550903, 0.0726594626903534, -0.9305239915847778, 0.53089839220047, 0.31231045722961426, -0.6453186273574829, -0.001352772582322359, -0.25796133279800415, -0.607837975025177, -0.7279393076896667, -0.5659032464027405, 0.27485838532447815, -0.31052321195602417, 0.2839464545249939, 0.9679973125457764, -0.40176692605018616, -0.20006592571735382, 0.7133862972259521, 0.9161372780799866, -0.4466732442378998, -0.48924967646598816, 0.3309440016746521, -0.4770236313343048, -0.4820789098739624, -0.07075463980436325, 0.45223268866539, -0.24141497910022736, 0.17491774260997772, -0.13407711684703827, 0.24245552718639374, 0.25270867347717285, 0.025847038254141808, -0.27734339237213135, 0.5111772418022156, 0.1838836967945099, -0.9511929154396057, -0.6409560441970825, 0.6579940319061279, 0.011609734036028385, 0.3737988770008087, -0.4299088418483734, -0.9968688488006592, -1.1888747215270996, -0.24233996868133545, 0.35776853561401367, -0.8500512838363647, 0.17145121097564697, -0.28269150853157043, 0.2681242525577545, 0.10622426122426987, 0.04197630286216736, -0.21519020199775696, -0.35147106647491455, 0.09304645657539368, -0.5553616881370544, 0.7343130707740784, -0.43004310131073, -0.2397272139787674, -0.12904122471809387, -0.4564443528652191, 0.295213520526886, 0.9136546850204468, 0.6649190783500671, -0.923149585723877, 0.5663787126541138, 0.43776237964630127, 0.6132579445838928, 0.32704129815101624, -0.8813113570213318, 0.2095339000225067, 0.12381920963525772, 0.5991380214691162, -0.14219264686107635, 0.19404985010623932, -0.6914395093917847, 0.17389288544654846, -0.5657160878181458, -0.2002221792936325, 0.4475895166397095, -0.44035664200782776, 0.027216056361794472, 0.009506541304290295, 0.5652468204498291, -0.689816415309906, 0.5961179733276367, 0.21857231855392456, -0.08667123317718506, 0.0078006163239479065, 0.6018622517585754, -0.010780032724142075, -0.41180506348609924, -0.7684678435325623, -0.3400092124938965, -0.05467449501156807, -0.26684603095054626, 0.36998388171195984, 1.0766035318374634, 0.10410020500421524, -0.07686035335063934, -0.6405436396598816, 1.1866085529327393, 0.03278202936053276, -0.03467944264411926, -0.4654499888420105, 0.1382494568824768, 0.02498025633394718, -0.4537842273712158, -0.37918972969055176, -0.05713491514325142, -0.020100565627217293, -0.08884352445602417, 0.2250266671180725, -0.5262029767036438, -0.9032102823257446, 0.14774547517299652, 0.885003924369812, 0.7810887098312378, -0.16558349132537842, 0.46872472763061523, 0.29042696952819824, -0.41284966468811035, -0.669008731842041, 0.5839718580245972, -0.8415023684501648, 0.459475040435791, 1.1051149368286133, -0.26459571719169617, -0.548373818397522, 0.21020430326461792, -0.06314367800951004, -0.6138304471969604, -0.4102022051811218, 0.35555368661880493, 0.401109516620636, -0.9599677324295044, -0.5670111179351807, -0.007336483336985111, -0.18177710473537445, -0.8295902609825134, 0.3703196346759796, 0.13468250632286072, 0.11054503917694092, -0.469046413898468, -0.36494922637939453, 0.5250611901283264, -0.5026989579200745, 0.5951250195503235, 0.3908037543296814, -0.031377699226140976, 0.011746440082788467, -0.33562320470809937, -0.8925060629844666, -0.37001749873161316, 0.5021323561668396, 0.6915309429168701, 0.03283340111374855, -0.09661119431257248, -0.419942170381546, 0.06307169795036316, -0.05186384171247482, -0.06333551555871964, 0.4785067141056061, 0.2396523654460907, -0.22364453971385956, -0.32298967242240906, 0.8243019580841064, 0.25402921438217163, 0.18993939459323883, -0.33882296085357666, 1.1345402002334595, -0.16332696378231049, -0.8614913821220398, -0.7336800694465637, -0.24653476476669312, 0.35322558879852295, 0.273225873708725, 0.414986252784729, 0.059559937566518784, 0.8829014301300049, 0.3853145241737366, 0.2731589078903198, -0.3401755690574646, -0.19761990010738373, -0.46405690908432007, -0.662513256072998, 0.9393789172172546, -0.9742780923843384, 0.3922731280326843, 0.40481090545654297, -0.06146911159157753, -0.3511822819709778, -0.803102433681488, 0.6379992961883545, -0.37793514132499695, -0.05181756243109703, -0.6303814053535461, -0.5528503060340881, -1.0553711652755737, -0.05108063668012619, -0.15586824715137482, -1.004622459411621, -0.12794141471385956, 0.3574739396572113, -0.5063058733940125, -0.4445500671863556, -0.18507711589336395, 0.6181274056434631, -0.502682089805603, 0.9074193835258484, -0.9689562916755676, -0.7080163359642029, -0.4734715223312378, 0.362554132938385, 0.39366528391838074, -0.34197014570236206, 1.4749144315719604, -0.44816264510154724, 0.5259062647819519, 0.5780752301216125, -0.2759203016757965, -0.14767172932624817, 0.796669602394104, 0.5054221153259277, -0.9603353142738342, -0.6249620318412781, -0.16202908754348755, 0.7080962061882019, -1.3549163341522217, -1.083591103553772, -0.5740169286727905, 0.36329472064971924, -0.042618051171302795, -0.25727030634880066, -0.7079243659973145, 1.235906958580017, -0.04747306555509567, 0.8442921042442322, 0.11849065870046616, -0.11515764892101288, 0.8449530005455017, 0.4769318699836731, 0.010200927034020424, -0.1514228880405426, 0.3884502053260803, -0.4965377449989319, -0.6450796723365784, 0.1362307071685791, -0.5633788108825684, 0.17927515506744385, -0.12251973897218704, 0.74526047706604, 0.12096987664699554, 0.3359300196170807, 0.23781004548072815, 0.05615190044045448, 0.18770731985569, 0.16798768937587738, -0.11703582108020782, -0.7511259317398071, -0.47096145153045654, -0.10324620455503464, -0.6905255317687988, -0.8117916584014893, 0.6265693306922913, -0.42352181673049927, -0.014814028516411781, -0.4898030161857605, -0.38087859749794006, 0.26686224341392517, 0.29451194405555725, 0.7291507124900818, -0.5116645097732544, 0.419820100069046, 0.5129292011260986, 0.4437570869922638, 0.474789559841156, -0.13076914846897125, 0.3459678292274475, -0.003300242591649294, -0.5890664458274841, -1.0840535163879395, -0.6490092277526855, 0.5119611024856567, 0.22000649571418762, -0.29659736156463623, -0.37569329142570496, -0.19499503076076508, -0.136875718832016, -0.08524207025766373, -0.23989039659500122, 0.1459793895483017, -0.3328080177307129, -0.11526299268007278, -0.8267521858215332, -0.1950237900018692, 0.2698114514350891, 0.5301430821418762, 0.8406507968902588, -0.41887199878692627, -0.5837468504905701, 0.1471356600522995, 0.6545774936676025, -0.18071533739566803, 0.5687277317047119, 0.16375671327114105, 0.38843175768852234, -0.3322722911834717, 0.12637676298618317, 0.9336284399032593, 0.3051261305809021, -0.07328233867883682, -0.26984870433807373, -0.29044920206069946, 0.23046927154064178, 0.7572940587997437, 0.5984162092208862, -0.07385369390249252, -0.0008780648931860924, -0.08631690591573715, 0.17825472354888916, -0.07076875120401382, -0.38328805565834045, 0.5975213050842285, 0.7758557200431824, -0.21809501945972443, -0.35050299763679504, -0.19735151529312134, 0.381512314081192, 0.25573626160621643, -0.5860320329666138, 0.5862974524497986, -0.8892035484313965, -0.23160968720912933, -0.20690970122814178, 1.257953405380249, 0.5350449681282043, 0.1379375159740448, 0.10323604941368103, -0.0046244156546890736, 0.644462525844574, 0.17722199857234955, 0.6735313534736633, 0.8344686627388, -0.2654249966144562, -0.35037437081336975, -0.09664564579725266, 0.3752019703388214, 0.594402015209198, 0.037508007138967514, 0.10776834934949875, 0.16177575290203094, -1.083325982093811, 0.8508168458938599, -0.1528683751821518, -0.21903866529464722, 1.0063587427139282, -0.35004833340644836, -0.8754823207855225, -0.1104506105184555, -0.10129866003990173, -1.1681991815567017, 0.2537730038166046, 0.6439274549484253, -0.5952814221382141, -0.31740468740463257, 0.2920880615711212, -0.24561165273189545, 0.4629206955432892, 0.12504331767559052, 0.23510129749774933, 0.007838228717446327, 1.4730640649795532, 0.8681535124778748, 0.3057723343372345, 0.2720264196395874, -0.044821545481681824, -0.3907667100429535, 0.05554472655057907, -0.36739033460617065, -0.20503383874893188, 0.16397452354431152, -0.5728756189346313, -0.4739533066749573, 0.32142630219459534, -0.3320397138595581, -0.7569501996040344, -0.428841769695282, -0.37856152653694153, 0.392185240983963, -0.4790054261684418, -0.39739200472831726, 0.8593227863311768, 0.3479125499725342, 0.1130666732788086, 0.26264068484306335, 0.24419046938419342, -0.30928802490234375, 0.22409924864768982, -0.44270214438438416, 0.3186759054660797, -0.4055415987968445, -0.3207041025161743, -0.35367250442504883, -1.224774718284607, -0.6294257044792175, -0.6570290327072144, 0.050448670983314514, -1.3061888217926025, 0.1359456479549408, 0.41455480456352234, 0.32004496455192566, 0.6267766952514648, -0.5378459095954895, 0.2867674231529236, 0.44475847482681274, 1.2630373239517212, -0.4085087478160858, 0.1385447233915329, -0.07690555602312088, 0.26757097244262695, -0.10322660207748413, 0.45550328493118286, -0.44793713092803955, -0.18053576350212097, -0.29542648792266846, -0.4790218770503998, 0.335443377494812, 0.17270773649215698, -1.040295124053955, 0.02572682313621044, 0.5872632265090942, 0.21713463962078094, -0.5953131914138794, -1.3659826517105103, 0.35031020641326904, -0.7033950090408325, 0.2307172417640686, -0.28076544404029846, -0.13392862677574158, -0.2612954080104828, -0.1667436808347702, 0.482416570186615, -0.8520907163619995, 4.11646032333374, 1.1226838827133179, 0.17468810081481934, -0.36122268438339233, -0.04833365976810455, 0.779473066329956, 0.8817699551582336, -0.5590721964836121, 0.18053801357746124, 0.3003184497356415, -1.17043936252594, 0.653376042842865, 0.5193226337432861, -0.6528149247169495, 0.14229591190814972, 0.2954598367214203, -1.2487318515777588, -0.12385042756795883, -0.29892203211784363, -0.8587608337402344, -0.8916771411895752, 0.610946536064148, 0.20083282887935638, -0.12426413595676422, -0.040802620351314545, 0.08913041651248932, -0.2895136773586273, 0.1940951645374298, -0.7307570576667786, -0.05027471110224724, -0.23477458953857422, -0.5842759609222412, 0.7060773372650146, 0.15164659917354584, -0.31347841024398804, 0.15416431427001953, -0.25724175572395325, -0.01111113466322422, 0.2701401710510254, -0.009505431167781353, 0.3281598687171936, -0.8271254897117615, -0.5215801000595093, -0.5286202430725098, -0.1770835816860199, 0.2214137315750122, -0.5755932331085205, -0.14445362985134125, -0.008402201347053051, -0.7563797831535339, 1.0988868474960327, -0.9598562121391296, 1.3203908205032349, 0.34802907705307007, -1.2439974546432495, -0.15733478963375092, -0.39139407873153687, -0.9479560256004333, -0.2003108561038971, 0.5349175930023193, 0.2402568906545639, -0.23311835527420044, -0.49608084559440613, 0.5276249647140503, 0.38378819823265076, -0.09207548201084137, 0.22500848770141602, 0.1668976992368698, -0.3883034288883209, -0.11122837662696838, 0.27246129512786865, -0.04703756421804428, -0.6400609016418457, -0.04665699228644371, 0.8161281943321228, 0.6150705218315125, 0.026087040081620216, 0.5696464776992798, -0.2521820068359375, -0.5943381190299988, 0.5496619343757629, -0.4775010049343109, 0.6635908484458923, -0.29619356989860535, 0.19964250922203064, 0.7371768951416016, -0.8505105376243591, -0.13148710131645203, -1.0116441249847412, 0.6679834127426147, 0.18804121017456055, -0.10472197085618973, 0.4311497211456299, 0.2893046736717224, -0.27699610590934753 ]
{"Title": "A brief report: de novo copy number variants in children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder", "Authors": "Martin Joanna, Hosking Grace, Wadon Megan, Agha Sharifah Shameem, Langley Kate, Rees Elliott, Owen Michael J, O\u2019Donovan Michael, Kirov George, Thapar Anita", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Recent case-control genetic studies of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) have implicated common and rare genetic risk alleles, highlighting the polygenic and complex aetiology of this neurodevelopmental disorder. Studies of other neurodevelopmental disorders, such as autism spectrum disorder (ASD), Tourette disorder, developmental delay/intellectual disability, and schizophrenia indicate that identification of specific risk alleles and additional insights into disorder biology can be gained by studying non-inherited de novo variation. In this study, we aimed to identify large de novo copy number variants (CNVs) in children with ADHD. Methods Children with a confirmed diagnosis of ADHD and their parents were genotyped and included in this sample. We used PennCNV to call large (>200kb) CNVs and identified those calls that were present in the proband and absent in both biological parents. Results In 305 parent-offspring trios, we detected 14 de novo CNVs in 13 probands, giving a mutation rate of 4.6% and a per individual rate of 4.3%. This rate is higher than published reports in controls and similar to those observed for ASD, schizophrenia and Tourette disorder. We also identified de novo mutations at 4 genomic loci (15q13.1-13.2 duplication, 16p13.11 duplication, 16p12.2 deletion and 22q11.21 duplication) that have previously been implicated in other neurodevelopmental disorders, two of which (16p13.11 and 22q11.21) have also been implicated in case-control ADHD studies. Conclusions Our study complements ADHD case-control genomic analyses and demonstrates the need for larger parent-offspring trio genetic studies to gain further insights into the complex aetiology of ADHD.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.12.19014555"}
10.1101/19000430
[ -0.6517794728279114, 0.7364656329154968, -0.3368191719055176, -0.08298037201166153, -0.037790294736623764, -0.20336292684078217, -0.39423954486846924, -0.06251112371683121, -0.6950011253356934, 0.144416943192482, 0.01268246490508318, -0.6556084752082825, 0.4875410795211792, -1.1045702695846558, -0.39162665605545044, -0.2945108711719513, -1.3714450597763062, -0.9683389663696289, -0.20520725846290588, -0.8510294556617737, 0.6020345091819763, 0.17782258987426758, -1.0971734523773193, -0.8800889253616333, -0.8664424419403076, 0.4307754635810852, 0.196851909160614, -0.8333914875984192, 1.3507081270217896, 0.9305932521820068, 0.5085695385932922, -0.978645920753479, 0.34857484698295593, -0.40743890404701233, 0.09060906618833542, -0.3339790999889374, 0.7433397769927979, 0.12278151512145996, -0.6044068336486816, -0.4728105366230011, -0.1407545953989029, 0.88334721326828, -0.06705355644226074, -0.7807102203369141, -0.3970024883747101, -0.3460802435874939, -0.4498582184314728, -0.015137027017772198, 0.2827421724796295, -0.4856760501861572, -0.5252609252929688, -0.15791243314743042, 0.15382729470729828, 0.30299094319343567, 0.21563515067100525, 0.005517749581485987, 0.5873057246208191, -0.5611878633499146, -0.9587140679359436, -0.5022481083869934, 0.8053820729255676, -0.5081356763839722, 0.30243393778800964, -0.8780912160873413, 0.6692482233047485, 0.5217113494873047, -0.6559426784515381, -0.1195605918765068, -0.27451252937316895, -0.3689349591732025, -0.4373893141746521, -0.3776935338973999, -0.25008076429367065, -0.14664694666862488, 0.08857119083404541, 0.4148051142692566, -0.0018123246263712645, 0.43061602115631104, -0.26259931921958923, -0.3811473846435547, -0.006383854430168867, 0.16396671533584595, -0.46854889392852783, 0.5804444551467896, -0.10703008621931076, -1.0234007835388184, 0.11776984483003616, -0.004268955439329147, -0.23979561030864716, -0.4069492518901825, -0.06550376862287521, 0.12555453181266785, -0.33987265825271606, 0.5964105129241943, 0.2551020681858063, 0.4357598125934601, 0.14867135882377625, -0.07501990348100662, 1.117887020111084, 0.3020295202732086, 0.21433916687965393, 1.2169508934020996, -0.011149582453072071, 1.3443326950073242, -0.3022647202014923, 0.8099459409713745, 0.7964296936988831, 0.2435261309146881, -0.5824518203735352, -0.6694229245185852, -0.21298010647296906, -0.2165173888206482, 0.46018558740615845, -0.02384447492659092, -0.18271657824516296, 0.10420028865337372, -0.18934300541877747, 0.43300050497055054, -0.3701421320438385, 0.692886233329773, -0.19450436532497406, 0.7761402726173401, 0.46169015765190125, -0.5025150775909424, 0.5569953322410583, -0.577277421951294, 0.41977182030677795, 0.5480610728263855, -0.5227764248847961, -0.8160487413406372, -0.392982542514801, -0.3694823980331421, -0.4519113302230835, 0.31976425647735596, -0.18000656366348267, 0.11794392764568329, 0.39475467801094055, 0.2799811065196991, 0.0752309262752533, -0.28799015283584595, -0.4532739818096161, 0.22650781273841858, -0.8381847143173218, 1.1980007886886597, -0.64033043384552, 0.08431845158338547, 0.2519685626029968, -0.8750602602958679, 0.04385138675570488, -0.11406216770410538, -0.14021547138690948, 0.745730996131897, -0.39098623394966125, 0.11627856642007828, 0.5469856262207031, -0.6989684700965881, -0.16587568819522858, 0.4069385230541229, -0.7138431668281555, 0.5744660496711731, 0.5356495380401611, -0.11177945137023926, -0.6986041069030762, 0.8808862566947937, -0.034678637981414795, 0.29676005244255066, 0.5832549929618835, 0.09428920596837997, -0.6827490329742432, -0.554258406162262, 0.018615424633026123, 0.11518806964159012, -0.1216229572892189, -0.036424670368433, -0.07579540461301804, 0.5465976595878601, 0.6707643866539001, -0.2794029712677002, 0.8300086855888367, -0.14156752824783325, -0.8285061120986938, -0.6386130452156067, 0.9079057574272156, 0.3911322057247162, -0.46120429039001465, 0.7643307447433472, 0.17082294821739197, 0.06971509754657745, -0.04291745647788048, 0.42104026675224304, 0.22119803726673126, 1.330442190170288, -0.4107147455215454, 0.09953922033309937, -0.9913693070411682, -0.39543572068214417, -0.3404301702976227, 0.30071431398391724, -0.22790440917015076, -0.7523244023323059, -0.46645665168762207, 0.5807396769523621, -1.0538488626480103, 0.5989461541175842, -0.4546300768852234, -0.194203183054924, 0.2865355908870697, 0.46209049224853516, -0.18304343521595, 0.5918865203857422, -0.22470296919345856, 0.5603417754173279, 0.09652318060398102, 0.22199025750160217, 0.09555871784687042, 0.14751501381397247, -0.7873709201812744, 0.17697766423225403, 0.5158230066299438, -0.09221097081899643, 0.37489983439445496, -0.22102081775665283, 0.1790570467710495, 0.22171735763549805, 0.20151323080062866, 0.3585793077945709, 0.36318543553352356, 0.5985927581787109, 0.19589316844940186, -0.06751634925603867, -0.21009892225265503, 0.7787927389144897, -0.6682767868041992, 0.820885956287384, 1.1598303318023682, -0.2100939005613327, 0.9683230519294739, 0.1990213841199875, 1.145377278327942, 0.041790008544921875, -0.22814098000526428, -0.21481719613075256, 1.110640287399292, 1.4035632610321045, 0.28411850333213806, -0.2492619901895523, 0.0722714215517044, -0.0772581622004509, -0.2547902762889862, 0.11918006092309952, -0.8864617347717285, 1.0677860975265503, 0.9260100722312927, 0.5132781267166138, -0.7623934149742126, -0.1446043998003006, 0.24879682064056396, 1.391404390335083, -0.17099182307720184, -0.4888441860675812, -0.31090301275253296, -0.31800147891044617, 0.20839467644691467, 0.47690773010253906, -0.06825509667396545, 0.9519987106323242, 0.6411694884300232, 0.0752284973859787, -0.9782286286354065, -0.1395559012889862, -1.3271715641021729, -1.1034235954284668, -0.832170844078064, -0.23029722273349762, -1.0795315504074097, 0.11195100098848343, -0.06787744164466858, -0.939357340335846, 0.5565001964569092, -0.16642425954341888, -0.43080365657806396, -0.26973679661750793, -0.02995956689119339, 0.6888622641563416, 0.4661965072154999, 0.17139814794063568, -1.1977909803390503, 1.2309006452560425, 0.2531130015850067, 0.29195138812065125, 0.4147149324417114, -0.4606332778930664, -0.29305776953697205, -1.2636563777923584, 0.5084165334701538, -0.8391576409339905, -0.1613612323999405, 0.21403451263904572, -1.0501676797866821, 0.7956427335739136, 0.10756073147058487, 0.5003153085708618, 0.058664947748184204, -0.19319552183151245, -0.28735867142677307, 0.7701246738433838, 0.775015115737915, -0.09394968301057816, 0.5675010085105896, 0.20939357578754425, -1.0838044881820679, 0.9730803966522217, -0.24333371222019196, -0.05976152792572975, -0.8616428375244141, 0.2752302289009094, 0.4655906558036804, -0.5951992869377136, -0.25131502747535706, -0.6011958718299866, -1.1182725429534912, -0.10706163942813873, -0.7245252132415771, -0.4416356384754181, 0.5016149878501892, 1.000158667564392, 0.22765246033668518, -0.993059515953064, 0.07493438571691513, -0.7852827906608582, -1.1735949516296387, -0.10617244243621826, -0.14496111869812012, 0.6853310465812683, 0.5438356399536133, 0.3475077748298645, -0.4009750783443451, -0.15731574594974518, 0.5151988863945007, 0.38117384910583496, 0.07641676813364029, -0.7402187585830688, -0.3013874292373657, 0.7641220092773438, 0.13515864312648773, 0.8888418674468994, 0.17910686135292053, 0.3261514902114868, -0.6257860064506531, 0.2710265517234802, -0.4117404818534851, 0.022275861352682114, 0.7722347378730774, -0.22009378671646118, 0.6503739953041077, 0.07866435497999191, -0.8621589541435242, 0.8248046040534973, 0.6197963953018188, -0.1821856051683426, -0.12117928266525269, -0.229433074593544, -0.049543596804142, 0.678281307220459, -0.8067389726638794, -0.9667034149169922, 0.7046879529953003, 0.4867972731590271, 0.2675166428089142, -1.6458975076675415, 0.5027806758880615, -0.5164773464202881, -0.08668692409992218, 0.32960250973701477, 0.0235892403870821, -0.9716987013816833, 0.3711281418800354, 0.039134759455919266, 1.4695707559585571, -1.8494291305541992, 0.3380190134048462, 0.43979594111442566, 0.852671205997467, 0.26093846559524536, 0.7108051776885986, -0.08133146911859512, -0.7445896863937378, 0.07760464400053024, -0.07497753202915192, 0.0801459401845932, -0.16818247735500336, 0.31912288069725037, -0.8864176273345947, -0.4123072922229767, -1.6452171802520752, -0.3641926050186157, 0.02609049156308174, -0.1594073474407196, 0.32814764976501465, 0.10921253263950348, 0.5736386775970459, -0.11958923935890198, 0.14016292989253998, 0.7359231114387512, 0.09298749268054962, 0.11369720846414566, -0.6868487000465393, 0.5763882994651794, 0.12945108115673065, -0.1442660093307495, -0.20893888175487518, 0.40500137209892273, -0.11834686249494553, 0.0871015191078186, 0.2370775043964386, -0.22074095904827118, -0.20944927632808685, 0.35552722215652466, -0.3495977818965912, 0.9815977811813354, -0.3905009925365448, 0.7257745862007141, -0.8604548573493958, 0.7666434645652771, -0.03198326379060745, -0.24892017245292664, -0.7497310638427734, -1.1703554391860962, 1.0922985076904297, 0.9290382266044617, -0.3103756606578827, -0.6544036865234375, 0.20604835450649261, 0.0022725353483110666, 0.2499951422214508, -0.2097344547510147, 0.7180145382881165, -0.7839519381523132, 0.25862202048301697, -0.46497368812561035, -0.34998464584350586, -0.297707736492157, 0.41755300760269165, -0.23001740872859955, 0.4756907820701599, 0.07037054002285004, -0.5543367862701416, -0.45217716693878174, 0.581179141998291, -0.33095261454582214, -0.027267979457974434, -1.4577324390411377, 0.14769414067268372, -0.5321353673934937, -0.6229287385940552, -0.11071091145277023, 0.6481326818466187, -0.6586199402809143, 0.012150034308433533, -0.25683900713920593, 0.07739459723234177, -0.6754644513130188, 0.059343673288822174, 0.3180875778198242, -1.2779927253723145, 0.9182412028312683, 0.4262963533401489, 0.2561827003955841, 0.6305585503578186, -0.11370009928941727, 0.06383415311574936, -0.02469901368021965, 0.40618497133255005, -1.0450241565704346, 0.9345808625221252, -0.10799650102853775, -0.35872682929039, 0.5454599261283875, -0.4494301676750183, -0.0383426770567894, -1.2098199129104614, 0.060144245624542236, -0.11535400152206421, -0.343299925327301, -0.3018200695514679, 0.2626841962337494, 0.1152336597442627, -0.37250375747680664, -0.6547042727470398, -0.15042071044445038, 0.5443668365478516, 0.4631119668483734, 0.13250569999217987, -0.13826876878738403, 0.6570742726325989, 0.14511601626873016, -0.3861960470676422, -0.036333102732896805, -0.0844135507941246, 0.32217642664909363, 0.8716294765472412, -0.36104634404182434, -0.5321806073188782, 0.0857279971241951, 0.6163862347602844, 0.031600236892700195, -0.18805021047592163, -0.09304293245077133, -0.6137359738349915, -0.8378478288650513, -0.2354574352502823, 0.0016062227077782154, -0.3311597406864166, 0.8126944899559021, -0.1698928326368332, -0.34448662400245667, -0.8135355710983276, -0.11650147289037704, -0.46302223205566406, 0.5378844738006592, -0.019502734765410423, -1.3522580862045288, -0.41868746280670166, 0.8562270402908325, -0.6002549529075623, 0.5168877243995667, 0.09400174766778946, -0.7754372954368591, -0.20223891735076904, -1.1365221738815308, 0.215330109000206, -1.2168558835983276, 0.26241055130958557, -0.41172856092453003, -0.18811942636966705, -0.2459648996591568, 0.3668173849582672, 0.5828571915626526, 0.017101464793086052, -0.7099971771240234, -0.5830775499343872, 0.28085091710090637, -1.0717025995254517, -1.1693235635757446, 0.04289456084370613, 0.02034318819642067, -0.14327220618724823, 0.740267276763916, 0.09224338084459305, -0.24252989888191223, 0.4051291346549988, 0.1355706751346588, 0.17140929400920868, 0.8420960307121277, -0.6521474719047546, -1.1310914754867554, 0.28449442982673645, 0.7085502743721008, 0.560129702091217, -0.10824394971132278, -0.19591476023197174, 0.4047689139842987, -0.9485548734664917, -0.33006900548934937, -0.33327215909957886, 0.22035393118858337, 0.5107482075691223, -0.1838938593864441, 0.08161834627389908, -0.1457112580537796, -0.06398473680019379, 0.11030235886573792, -0.08520567417144775, 0.20476506650447845, -0.6576252579689026, -1.041111707687378, -0.6727255582809448, -0.5399801135063171, -1.5060023069381714, 0.4248908758163452, -0.5523194074630737, 0.10761338472366333, 0.3003125786781311, 0.3053154945373535, -0.5589389801025391, -0.2715989351272583, 1.1952977180480957, 0.7446218729019165, 0.39494192600250244, -0.3201417028903961, 0.8033201694488525, -0.27560704946517944, 0.32117149233818054, -0.3742692172527313, 0.34065669775009155, -0.31328609585762024, 0.18620261549949646, 0.15621091425418854, -0.4790237843990326, -1.3738945722579956, -0.1643945425748825, 0.5973914861679077, 0.5139772891998291, -0.7055206894874573, 0.4756597578525543, 0.13336531817913055, 0.02368076704442501, -0.5518314838409424, 0.20045022666454315, -0.5185745358467102, -0.32755130529403687, 1.4656505584716797, 0.17369422316551208, -0.10305573791265488, -0.004649837501347065, 0.12427908182144165, -0.07074630260467529, -0.04104030504822731, 0.1474764347076416, 0.03918159380555153, -0.4744514524936676, -0.5077031254768372, 0.21077775955200195, -0.33344459533691406, -0.9627286195755005, 0.45055845379829407, -0.49254634976387024, -0.040980905294418335, -1.118980050086975, 0.08492608368396759, -0.05918615683913231, -0.41908612847328186, 0.4256044030189514, -0.11698627471923828, -0.3327648937702179, 0.3891974091529846, 0.6244750022888184, 0.6698800921440125, -0.71335768699646, 1.0125468969345093, 0.6299639344215393, -0.6186733841896057, 0.29503515362739563, -0.4987982511520386, -0.06312936544418335, 0.38964521884918213, 0.2563190758228302, 0.16541951894760132, 0.6023150682449341, 0.08806361258029938, 0.8203920125961304, 0.4374254047870636, -0.1521914154291153, -0.06530976295471191, 0.12608574330806732, 0.5872258543968201, 0.6883566379547119, -0.940353274345398, -0.4533499777317047, 0.4512214660644531, 1.163430094718933, 0.554998517036438, -1.1411792039871216, 0.20718182623386383, 0.5087670683860779, 0.9601392149925232, -0.3228907883167267, -0.17428630590438843, -0.37074267864227295, -0.8291203379631042, -0.7054732441902161, -0.16655780375003815, 0.6075143218040466, -0.9311025738716125, -0.013095183297991753, 0.13343390822410583, -0.5143100619316101, 0.599051296710968, 0.859752893447876, -0.6697778701782227, 0.3987463116645813, -0.3368456959724426, 0.005199747160077095, -0.8774517178535461, -0.3817296326160431, -0.4702285826206207, -0.3576887547969818, -0.17741121351718903, 0.9299505949020386, 0.519116222858429, 0.28470030426979065, 0.34171825647354126, 0.03031148947775364, 0.18671967089176178, 0.03966451808810234, -0.32047826051712036, -0.44407495856285095, -0.22336290776729584, 0.9764291048049927, -0.16103783249855042, 0.5587272047996521, -0.1435549110174179, -0.2065105140209198, 0.3850417733192444, 0.5577304363250732, 1.1002529859542847, -0.8871422410011292, -0.5186141133308411, 0.426372230052948, 0.24425482749938965, -0.5028469562530518, -0.3690270781517029, 0.02090916968882084, -0.6487244367599487, 0.11724134534597397, 0.8175885081291199, 0.41543883085250854, -0.577548623085022, -0.3572293221950531, 0.5022162199020386, 0.30740004777908325, -0.6172258853912354, 0.013551319018006325, -0.1794479489326477, -0.0741109549999237, -0.759806752204895, -0.4071069061756134, 0.16877810657024384, 0.005642981268465519, 0.2928278148174286, -1.0878065824508667, 0.33301591873168945, 0.22891363501548767, 0.18419994413852692, -0.3096737265586853, -1.0651875734329224, -0.3633197247982025, -0.4270322024822235, -0.49327191710472107, 1.1820802688598633, 0.5454079508781433, -0.08079221844673157, -0.4662434160709381, 0.04514797031879425, 0.3376308083534241, -0.30826616287231445, -0.057459622621536255, -1.4450268745422363, -0.5235254764556885, 0.6382355690002441, -0.17263707518577576, 0.08895555138587952, -0.028943249955773354, -0.556488573551178, 0.2291334718465805, 0.372275173664093, 1.0791648626327515, 0.7623408436775208, 0.21363213658332825, 0.4999271333217621, 0.11452136933803558, -0.06640086323022842, 0.257942795753479, -0.37232810258865356, 0.6023401618003845, 0.07594866305589676, -0.40706199407577515, 1.0416656732559204, 0.6680834889411926, 0.5473176836967468, 0.1354922205209732, -0.30196988582611084, 0.36150920391082764, 0.7590471506118774, -0.27133870124816895, -0.24770177900791168, 0.3449530601501465, -0.5593994855880737, -0.6944066882133484, -0.2699715197086334, 0.15010713040828705, -0.5593936443328857, 0.7078195214271545, 0.09182122349739075, -0.2629874348640442, -1.0540660619735718, 0.5553213357925415, 0.8925791382789612, -0.4630134701728821, 0.638759434223175, 0.5001417398452759, 0.8560611009597778, -0.337784081697464, 0.013691715896129608, 0.47271278500556946, 0.07200482487678528, 1.1885639429092407, -0.14663493633270264, -0.34726107120513916, 0.37931597232818604, 1.2535021305084229, 0.5163218379020691, 0.5689455270767212, 0.5044654607772827, -0.06948630511760712, 0.23791705071926117, 0.24744516611099243, -0.10896697640419006, 0.33594316244125366, -0.2904728651046753, 0.0652557834982872, 0.3481510281562805, 0.20208901166915894, 0.15897144377231598, 0.4072210490703583, 0.45916375517845154, 0.3070560395717621, -0.6592869162559509, -0.7120442986488342, -0.2648440897464752, 1.04642915725708, 0.36636802554130554, 0.05609935149550438, -0.05524072051048279, -0.3315003216266632, 0.2812137305736542, 0.5850279927253723, 0.6110879182815552, 0.18724672496318817, 0.45113980770111084, 0.05815677344799042, 0.04470326006412506, 1.0899163484573364, -0.2522396147251129, 0.5236625671386719, -0.11424645036458969, 0.2771798372268677, -0.616580069065094, 0.48669469356536865, 0.04677671566605568, -0.6663187146186829, 0.46235203742980957, 0.3798297643661499, 0.007659738417714834, -0.7073090672492981, -0.1639993041753769, -0.4557836353778839, -0.030391795560717583, 0.40004512667655945, -1.0836949348449707, -0.43026021122932434, 0.7649814486503601, 0.030033910647034645, 0.26258522272109985, 0.7552819848060608, 0.37845882773399353, -1.110334038734436, 2.547983407974243, 0.38567063212394714, 0.10904720425605774, -0.15330339968204498, 0.3073655962944031, -0.20984207093715668, -0.40431854128837585, -0.9436078071594238, -0.1950007826089859, 0.3931683599948883, 0.352720707654953, -0.9016432166099548, -0.21706974506378174, 0.24792397022247314, 0.12792658805847168, -1.054064154624939, 0.9484544396400452, 0.494200736284256, -0.30740317702293396, 0.6038153171539307, 0.19008226692676544, -0.10786330699920654, -0.3169654905796051, 0.028668327257037163, 0.05552142485976219, -1.0828227996826172, 0.03423788398504257, -1.3280506134033203, 1.038486361503601, -0.5097218751907349, -0.7917846441268921, -0.8549408316612244, -0.6206353902816772, -0.14946036040782928, 0.28860875964164734, -0.49544718861579895, 0.1490991711616516, 0.8151996731758118, 0.8230327367782593, 0.2726757228374481, -0.22324195504188538, -0.5614928007125854, -0.014585708267986774, 0.1757676601409912, 0.8401157855987549, -0.3718952238559723, 1.3010096549987793, 0.2053336799144745, 0.036461398005485535, 0.19429908692836761, 0.14754299819469452, 0.49273842573165894, -0.13053598999977112, -0.8768174648284912, -0.41072946786880493, -0.15102526545524597, -1.0692635774612427, -1.3921254873275757, 0.9830289483070374, 0.3580230176448822, -0.44614192843437195, -0.3401789367198944, -0.09403368085622787, 0.28416740894317627, -0.6381896138191223, 1.2075037956237793, 0.07271313667297363, 0.22115907073020935, 0.006053665652871132, -0.5353686213493347, -1.045803427696228, -0.5451574325561523, 3.598775625228882, 1.6766328811645508, 0.9661446809768677, -0.3956552743911743, 0.6404707431793213, 0.21466472744941711, 0.3648390471935272, 0.3409374952316284, -0.03509450703859329, -0.2834513187408447, -0.1866043657064438, 0.6361771821975708, -0.24199743568897247, 0.38752058148384094, 0.03651174157857895, 1.006570816040039, -0.5790786147117615, 0.2703699767589569, 0.2628805339336395, -1.3342463970184326, -1.4946351051330566, 0.6018537878990173, -0.23073677718639374, -0.2982001006603241, -0.5427438616752625, -0.056873857975006104, -0.13672824203968048, 0.003911115694791079, -0.8400346040725708, 0.8583874106407166, -0.1605188548564911, -1.5460673570632935, 0.32420656085014343, 0.3515027165412903, -0.3592381179332733, 0.280762255191803, 0.4631989002227783, -0.08908934891223907, -0.44462350010871887, -0.09268303215503693, 0.036655817180871964, -0.17177627980709076, 0.10227251052856445, 0.06778600066900253, -0.5735762119293213, 0.2968028485774994, -0.016921496018767357, 0.08757133036851883, 0.5074055194854736, -0.5081050395965576, 0.3417918086051941, -0.6182388067245483, 0.19479820132255554, 0.36641839146614075, -1.349186658859253, -0.2642125189304352, -1.1285979747772217, -0.4384124279022217, 0.9760202765464783, 0.25552383065223694, 0.940627932548523, 0.3944432735443115, -0.4183197617530823, -0.23615668714046478, 0.21380484104156494, -0.15420754253864288, 0.35666072368621826, 0.18229791522026062, -0.4846022427082062, 0.5435656905174255, 0.5297111868858337, 0.35921961069107056, -0.34609973430633545, 1.0384248495101929, 0.7429625988006592, 0.8122428059577942, -0.3963768780231476, 0.3680940270423889, -0.9127734899520874, -0.5331593751907349, 0.2862623333930969, 0.10881707072257996, 0.86273193359375, 0.08785129338502884, -0.4185927212238312, 0.8217499256134033, -0.30724141001701355, -0.01759684644639492, -1.5308284759521484, 0.39862313866615295, 0.8390807509422302, -0.07889076322317123, 0.09382933378219604, -0.010790509171783924, 0.10436013340950012 ]
{"Title": "Predicting epileptic seizures using nonnegative matrix factorization", "Authors": "Stojanovi\u0107 Olivera, Pipa Gordon", "Abstract": "Abstract This paper presents a procedure for the patient-specific prediction of epileptic seizures. To this end, a combination of nonnegative matrix factorization (NMF) and smooth basis functions with robust regression is applied to power spectra of intracranial electroencephalographic (iEEG) signals. The resulting time and frequency components capture the dominant information from power spectra, while removing outliers and noise. This makes it possible to detect structure in preictal states, which is used for classification. Linear support vector machines (SVM) with L1 regularization are used to select and weigh the contributions from different number of not equally informative channels among patients. Due to class imbalance in data, synthetic minority over-sampling technique (SMOTE) is applied. The resulting method yields a computationally and conceptually simple, interpretable model of EEG signals of preictal and interictal states, which shows a good performance for the task of seizure prediction.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000430"}
10.1101/19010991
[ 0.28100261092185974, 0.873989462852478, -0.005114044062793255, 0.9905474185943604, -0.46924954652786255, -0.6401373744010925, 0.16785696148872375, 0.11942698806524277, 0.4976332485675812, 0.8853229880332947, -0.08062296360731125, -0.12408977746963501, -0.14816220104694366, -0.5474490523338318, 0.05523032695055008, -0.2389366179704666, -0.47122329473495483, 0.05432061478495598, -0.02900274656713009, -0.2831747233867645, 0.7187463045120239, -0.14877469837665558, -0.6393214464187622, 0.29811906814575195, -0.10860031843185425, 0.689937174320221, -0.15431495010852814, 0.2779255509376526, 1.2428090572357178, 0.13329888880252838, 0.3427489995956421, -1.0707964897155762, 0.40987440943717957, -0.8321937918663025, -0.2739879786968231, -0.2244516909122467, 0.2956829369068146, -0.49847960472106934, 0.05049044266343117, -0.44999027252197266, 0.8593732714653015, 0.0971984714269638, 0.6116698980331421, -0.07707521319389343, -1.1146236658096313, -0.49514853954315186, -0.4057318866252899, 0.3128548860549927, 0.04543057084083557, -0.20062255859375, -0.5378320813179016, 0.08711344003677368, 0.2564145028591156, 0.3115186095237732, 0.07936286926269531, 0.12172263860702515, 0.6936662793159485, -0.41515710949897766, -0.4842316210269928, 0.28326278924942017, 0.7693837881088257, -0.19078539311885834, 0.8783760070800781, -1.2535338401794434, 0.5148652791976929, 1.406728982925415, -0.5071249604225159, -0.553267240524292, -0.6223635077476501, 0.18555164337158203, 0.2374729961156845, -0.0968218445777893, 0.1398731917142868, -0.03869113698601723, -0.005986735224723816, -0.7137681841850281, 0.5156006813049316, -0.12171811610460281, 0.0688377395272255, 0.41920801997184753, -0.009321902878582478, -0.20388537645339966, 0.5425555109977722, 0.31160834431648254, -0.14835400879383087, 0.002086627995595336, 0.4407256543636322, 0.5165327191352844, 0.11010787636041641, 0.08667069673538208, -0.277837872505188, 0.4360419511795044, 0.06772694736719131, 0.0780286192893982, -0.43857792019844055, 0.5276058316230774, -0.48883286118507385, -0.08609822392463684, 0.26289618015289307, -0.49305835366249084, 0.6196750402450562, -0.09105896204710007, -0.643439769744873, 0.7764315009117126, -0.05387284234166145, 0.11492732912302017, 0.7914727330207825, -0.015983082354068756, -0.7898545265197754, -0.7267515063285828, 0.2084469497203827, -0.00019017886370420456, -0.029298100620508194, 0.4510546922683716, 0.49405577778816223, 0.9011644124984741, -0.716917097568512, 0.927524209022522, -0.8565492033958435, 0.18150824308395386, -0.44306766986846924, -0.3897246718406677, 1.0163865089416504, -0.4126380980014801, 0.8360080718994141, 0.07591874897480011, 0.08171334862709045, 0.7231531143188477, -0.7638019919395447, 0.42378687858581543, 0.370503306388855, -0.27409228682518005, -0.3903021216392517, 0.33562541007995605, 0.09892817586660385, -0.2293304055929184, -0.04905926063656807, 0.9723368287086487, -0.019947130233049393, -0.8403549194335938, -0.20898452401161194, 0.4604121446609497, -0.35013577342033386, 0.8414021134376526, -0.1689070612192154, 0.5154727697372437, -0.3269538879394531, -0.9190084338188171, -0.10098398476839066, -0.1736535131931305, -0.013751484453678131, 0.5557538866996765, -0.0670643076300621, -0.421958863735199, 0.10717839747667313, 0.09045004099607468, -0.8660445213317871, 0.98245769739151, -0.415502667427063, -0.061107128858566284, -0.28259700536727905, 0.48050740361213684, 0.43742427229881287, 1.3709115982055664, -0.5787085890769958, 0.9789000153541565, 0.0682356134057045, 0.192093625664711, 0.4801734983921051, -0.2816419303417206, 0.2522929310798645, 0.03057030774652958, -0.2524968385696411, -0.3792318105697632, 0.08016681671142578, 0.46173471212387085, 0.8589695692062378, 0.033116407692432404, 0.5412605404853821, 0.530561625957489, 0.25367188453674316, 0.026480861008167267, 1.1105715036392212, 0.6395053863525391, -0.07363098859786987, 0.2853344678878784, -0.582682192325592, 0.016235671937465668, 0.2042924463748932, -0.09145641326904297, -0.14754925668239594, 0.1459784060716629, -0.5254853963851929, 0.8687156438827515, -0.6128639578819275, 0.4438483417034149, -0.5917317271232605, -0.33247750997543335, 0.2318691611289978, -0.1867939829826355, -0.03893468901515007, 0.7394918203353882, -0.01671426370739937, 0.40056079626083374, -0.14073017239570618, 0.0356425978243351, 0.029162811115384102, 0.23628000915050507, -0.6132842898368835, 0.877315878868103, 0.47870495915412903, -0.47864723205566406, -0.4782320559024811, 0.0744563415646553, 0.6415585279464722, -0.2971726059913635, -0.3321296274662018, 0.05336308106780052, -0.731154203414917, 0.07489412277936935, 0.4331229031085968, -0.2820337414741516, 0.6011989712715149, 0.6094092130661011, 0.2855123281478882, 0.17583288252353668, 1.369310736656189, -0.11931654810905457, -0.18461720645427704, -0.35168948769569397, 0.6734198927879333, 0.7836063504219055, 0.2749115526676178, 0.6589011549949646, 0.31443697214126587, 0.17344091832637787, -0.07924415916204453, 0.8445844650268555, 0.4524799883365631, 0.49934151768684387, 0.4445559084415436, 0.4300171732902527, 1.051184892654419, 0.33879995346069336, -0.17912699282169342, 0.43697991967201233, -0.8477197885513306, -0.5572360157966614, -0.4217166304588318, 0.714073657989502, -0.8376573920249939, 0.45316123962402344, -0.01687549240887165, 0.30168333649635315, 0.3173932135105133, -0.6227619647979736, 0.527838945388794, 0.025424109771847725, -0.06109379604458809, -0.5770023465156555, -0.07026432454586029, -0.3678680956363678, -0.35129085183143616, 0.05025657266378403, 0.9918122291564941, 0.7001317739486694, 0.2003556191921234, -0.016281381249427795, -0.3605113625526428, -0.42854171991348267, -0.6478418707847595, -0.5325170159339905, -0.5675082802772522, -0.5673872828483582, -0.7758756279945374, -0.2984420359134674, 0.5368244051933289, -0.3669721186161041, 0.5606285333633423, 0.1597103774547577, 0.3497151732444763, -0.2277955263853073, 0.058118902146816254, 0.4689687192440033, -0.01448865421116352, 0.06597829610109329, -0.6854555606842041, 0.5571528673171997, -0.7589103579521179, 0.4354704022407532, -0.2364247739315033, 0.06158788874745369, -0.2717108130455017, -0.6157401204109192, 0.4021396338939667, -0.2971515357494354, -0.7423183917999268, 0.1310834139585495, -0.21481050550937653, 0.031357541680336, 0.3449973165988922, 0.19174861907958984, 0.40333235263824463, -0.3306015133857727, -0.732162356376648, 0.7169067859649658, 0.34884902834892273, 0.1518917977809906, 0.3477975130081177, 0.8877089023590088, -0.9313690662384033, 0.050936151295900345, -0.022285137325525284, 0.13569431006908417, -0.5410187840461731, -0.16508543491363525, 0.2748973071575165, 0.05980523303151131, 0.6861734390258789, -0.9252147078514099, -1.3955100774765015, -0.3460146486759186, 0.04102209582924843, -0.11937564611434937, 0.28151389956474304, 0.39100828766822815, 0.03564266860485077, -0.8985050320625305, 0.5388375520706177, -0.6453201770782471, -0.7768307328224182, 0.15158642828464508, -0.04800845682621002, 0.40716832876205444, 0.6619184613227844, 0.13499587774276733, -0.09719254076480865, -0.48882564902305603, -0.08161306381225586, 0.5425276756286621, -0.14894568920135498, -0.028752073645591736, -0.5042343139648438, 0.08232049643993378, 0.10943620651960373, 0.6974911093711853, 0.6662772297859192, -0.3129113018512726, 0.2720034122467041, 0.1866801381111145, -0.7549030780792236, 0.31952863931655884, 0.6071932911872864, -0.035131338983774185, 0.8466832041740417, 0.2706514000892639, -0.05485137179493904, 0.04491419345140457, 0.5940043926239014, 0.3048700988292694, -0.03914874792098999, 0.4944150149822235, 0.3332056701183319, 0.5557469129562378, -0.530563235282898, -0.8257369995117188, 0.1396639049053192, -0.09975581616163254, 0.6099174618721008, -0.34325093030929565, 0.633656919002533, 0.1389203816652298, -0.28565672039985657, 0.08425123244524002, 0.09569568186998367, 0.1674976944923401, 0.6624181866645813, -0.15346908569335938, 0.8628671765327454, -1.5321145057678223, 0.5664659738540649, 0.9856292605400085, 0.5819412469863892, 0.024360567331314087, 0.198586106300354, -0.16680894792079926, -0.851590096950531, 0.26952841877937317, -0.05793580412864685, 0.23157522082328796, 0.27837514877319336, 0.05161057040095329, -0.05509263649582863, -0.09892860054969788, -0.8092696070671082, -0.34396448731422424, -0.011594866402447224, 0.1404944211244583, -0.07467740774154663, -0.41759341955184937, 1.0884850025177002, -0.008535128086805344, 0.37720730900764465, 0.30451491475105286, 0.5928292274475098, -0.34759047627449036, -0.4934212267398834, -0.013506127521395683, -0.7868142127990723, -0.7782814502716064, 0.24841226637363434, -0.318098783493042, -0.1027008518576622, 0.1579744815826416, 0.2743852734565735, -0.36475130915641785, -0.5968936085700989, -0.07568829506635666, -0.11516217887401581, -0.1371176689863205, -0.0725058987736702, 0.518505334854126, -0.824164628982544, 0.21721233427524567, 0.2807507812976837, -0.5244914293289185, -0.06634204089641571, -0.523082971572876, 0.41817381978034973, 1.2306135892868042, -0.1554340422153473, -0.4871450364589691, -0.44409462809562683, -0.41166865825653076, 0.5329700708389282, -0.08167292922735214, 0.4758990705013275, -0.10655809193849564, 0.24551065266132355, 0.19399790465831757, 0.4575059711933136, -0.42273879051208496, -0.3014651834964752, 0.11203090101480484, 0.25369858741760254, 0.036822810769081116, 0.6566293835639954, 0.10788612067699432, 0.9350689053535461, -0.4468643367290497, 0.8696945905685425, -0.30057230591773987, 0.6740949749946594, -0.9352747797966003, -0.32659900188446045, -0.34016153216362, -0.24507632851600647, -0.008433479815721512, 0.00718157971277833, -0.10115490108728409, -0.601152777671814, -0.5488420128822327, 0.5203444361686707, -0.36994248628616333, -0.5652756690979004, 0.4303474724292755, -0.20835845172405243, 0.20998603105545044, 1.072909951210022, 0.1302892416715622, -0.5614277124404907, -0.21394389867782593, -0.11549663543701172, -0.49465081095695496, 0.3827185332775116, -0.06496606767177582, 0.6359448432922363, 0.09511839598417282, -0.8718628287315369, -0.45948222279548645, -0.7361196875572205, 0.45266851782798767, -1.031398057937622, -0.22278273105621338, -0.8118588328361511, -0.29766610264778137, -0.7970165610313416, -0.5399435758590698, -0.7543898820877075, 0.09431400150060654, 0.08779673278331757, -0.20729419589042664, 0.22905786335468292, 0.7899803519248962, -0.8114121556282043, -0.09746956825256348, -1.0188124179840088, 0.14581672847270966, 0.0752045065164566, -0.28136467933654785, 1.3230533599853516, -0.3657943904399872, -0.5879747271537781, 0.30900049209594727, 0.5541528463363647, -0.4089095890522003, -0.35141056776046753, -0.37940362095832825, 0.0243515707552433, -0.4686133563518524, 0.06244901567697525, 0.44359084963798523, -1.080306053161621, -0.20241165161132812, -0.06548068672418594, -0.5483106374740601, 0.8766025900840759, -0.7445491552352905, -0.5764898061752319, 1.080566167831421, 0.4679950475692749, -0.9545978307723999, -0.5210328698158264, -0.009440681897103786, 0.3961470425128937, 0.26455721259117126, -0.6344252228736877, -0.7630938291549683, -0.5679141283035278, -0.7889454960823059, 0.4189392030239105, -1.011757731437683, 0.46951982378959656, -0.37716835737228394, -0.11011850833892822, -0.3946632444858551, -0.16977041959762573, 0.8503385782241821, -0.18366502225399017, 0.1951444298028946, -0.2778119146823883, 0.5225248336791992, -0.4678085446357727, -0.23346945643424988, 0.039431434124708176, -0.4801182150840759, -0.5320801138877869, 0.98166424036026, 0.25767606496810913, -0.8418149352073669, 0.9031851887702942, 0.021722711622714996, 0.4552597403526306, 0.295356422662735, -0.10065223276615143, -0.40418824553489685, 0.3068370819091797, 0.6941917538642883, -0.9167545437812805, -0.07327459007501602, -0.9882837533950806, 0.14696334302425385, -0.2749535143375397, 0.25959494709968567, -0.24336770176887512, -0.137508824467659, -0.0963132381439209, -0.39568591117858887, 0.5108592510223389, -0.22981050610542297, 0.5332116484642029, 0.4500398635864258, -0.7097589373588562, 0.206895649433136, 0.3377707004547119, -0.10202261060476303, -0.5945313572883606, -0.8740395903587341, -0.8336997032165527, 0.3504706621170044, -0.34803828597068787, 0.46042656898498535, 1.084193229675293, -0.1719694584608078, -0.00010022579226642847, -0.627099871635437, 0.49428436160087585, 0.6659572720527649, -0.8195709586143494, -0.47495096921920776, 0.17046618461608887, 0.1881112903356552, 0.1807575225830078, 0.14407214522361755, -0.25927233695983887, -0.358175128698349, -0.31015732884407043, 0.21066759526729584, -0.6149590611457825, -1.0099115371704102, -0.18787029385566711, 0.5456656217575073, 0.3946739435195923, 0.19916008412837982, 0.43550512194633484, -0.2029656320810318, -0.04943872615695, -0.6595302224159241, 0.9446242451667786, -0.13115587830543518, -0.2805542051792145, 1.1515721082687378, -0.06468571722507477, -0.4681907892227173, 0.13250607252120972, -0.42256009578704834, -0.285180926322937, -0.25726592540740967, 0.5549477934837341, 0.08362994343042374, -1.3782336711883545, 0.09791132807731628, 0.42751404643058777, -0.503338098526001, -0.8673115372657776, -0.34058794379234314, -0.21423009037971497, -0.38485610485076904, 0.018542034551501274, -0.025586530566215515, 0.4957115948200226, -0.40091899037361145, 0.0754089504480362, -0.06758223474025726, 0.5503675937652588, 0.25704607367515564, -0.21942083537578583, -0.1827608197927475, -0.32463014125823975, 0.2614816427230835, 0.42342865467071533, 0.2892296612262726, 0.4438167214393616, -0.31630387902259827, 0.2151353359222412, -0.1830328106880188, 0.02678852714598179, 0.5184212923049927, -0.3503160774707794, -0.2889050245285034, -0.39813849329948425, 0.6410990357398987, -0.18448877334594727, 0.47984397411346436, -0.4351595938205719, -0.01491413451731205, 0.13154959678649902, -0.4011024534702301, -0.7786972522735596, 0.04212665930390358, 0.8886688947677612, 0.7545359134674072, 0.13877391815185547, 0.19154979288578033, 0.5864360332489014, 0.6148274540901184, 0.12259145081043243, -0.6087136268615723, -0.35999977588653564, -0.6773331761360168, 0.420291543006897, -0.12671959400177002, -1.3200567960739136, 0.3517378866672516, 0.8830984234809875, -0.49783051013946533, -0.3742220401763916, 0.3960070013999939, 0.6062824130058289, 0.05554169416427612, -0.6241288781166077, -0.5853266716003418, -0.24154213070869446, -0.6549016833305359, -0.44351157546043396, -0.2356247454881668, -1.3673397302627563, 0.3641722500324249, 0.8123608827590942, -0.20273363590240479, 0.138766810297966, -0.3119114339351654, 0.853314220905304, 0.08223669230937958, 0.43382883071899414, -0.06624684482812881, -0.2682618498802185, -0.6922246813774109, 0.28658634424209595, 0.23122023046016693, -0.37008336186408997, 1.076646089553833, -0.32447031140327454, 0.6617512702941895, 0.08485342562198639, -0.2891727089881897, -0.6558323502540588, -0.10638470202684402, 0.43757861852645874, -0.8614354729652405, -0.6547413468360901, 0.001978605054318905, 0.9247944951057434, -0.6355751752853394, -0.49265894293785095, -0.4573301374912262, -0.26075226068496704, -0.5496318340301514, 0.09189074486494064, -1.198333740234375, 0.42816904187202454, 0.2666837275028229, -0.49735742807388306, -0.06872974336147308, 0.15745608508586884, 0.6100494861602783, 0.1799653023481369, 0.38971224427223206, -0.3472227454185486, -0.029836425557732582, -1.1107838153839111, 0.2910711169242859, 0.21972912549972534, -0.07894384115934372, -0.03351148962974548, -0.3491557836532593, 0.36021387577056885, 0.23113320767879486, -0.12196668982505798, -0.17153647541999817, 0.19642354547977448, -0.05140449106693268, -0.009016599506139755, 0.18566417694091797, -0.152690589427948, -0.47288838028907776, -0.5964276194572449, -1.051558017730713, -0.956827700138092, 0.177759051322937, -0.20109602808952332, 0.6808674931526184, -0.5974397659301758, -0.37930330634117126, 0.8922340273857117, 0.3421298563480377, 0.29968228936195374, 0.3368004560470581, 0.34676867723464966, 0.2957572042942047, 1.1133157014846802, -0.4079171121120453, 0.37349817156791687, 0.43935665488243103, 0.1254124939441681, -0.36302682757377625, -0.5168020129203796, -0.271510511636734, 0.14130322635173798, -0.2501430809497833, -0.31799137592315674, -0.02915453352034092, -0.26152077317237854, 0.07934752851724625, -0.5881795883178711, -0.6608206033706665, 0.23029907047748566, -0.31587138772010803, 0.43910446763038635, -0.7316073775291443, -0.10770819336175919, -0.2778348922729492, -0.0727422758936882, 0.6275367736816406, -1.0966832637786865, -0.7066571116447449, -0.0020457282662391663, 1.309309720993042, -0.3708968162536621, 0.610724687576294, 0.07366961240768433, 0.35833248496055603, -0.4144856333732605, 0.08284135162830353, 0.7477408647537231, 0.4451335072517395, 0.36887648701667786, 0.0062104095704853535, 0.24087940156459808, 0.567916750907898, -0.061469320207834244, 0.14637905359268188, -0.3711165189743042, 0.7698876857757568, 0.2341354340314865, -0.31353873014450073, -0.09659994393587112, -0.41757357120513916, 0.16663646697998047, -0.039905302226543427, -0.12373017519712448, -0.08742207288742065, 0.14434531331062317, -0.1017998531460762, 0.16601623594760895, -0.605212926864624, 0.40588563680648804, -0.342520147562027, -0.22345973551273346, 0.11877661198377609, 0.8796231746673584, 0.797028124332428, -0.0670807957649231, 0.011576558463275433, -0.37205541133880615, 0.2327614277601242, -0.3193308711051941, 0.3773695230484009, 0.755238950252533, -0.1644584685564041, -0.7194643020629883, -0.32292410731315613, 0.4136483669281006, -0.21029679477214813, -0.36690694093704224, 0.1064826026558876, 0.17704574763774872, -0.706660807132721, 0.7891966700553894, -0.11101116985082626, -0.36807501316070557, 0.9665552973747253, -0.7276664972305298, -0.10947704315185547, -0.07070807367563248, 0.2673078179359436, -0.3144533038139343, -0.26177579164505005, 1.2823807001113892, -0.7997468709945679, 0.0687268003821373, 0.11655067652463913, -0.37734296917915344, 0.245658740401268, 0.5809137225151062, 0.7367393374443054, -0.91996169090271, 0.6333305835723877, 0.7762827277183533, 0.5263051986694336, -0.09763499349355698, -0.4460020363330841, -0.11464614421129227, -0.08774904161691666, -0.618809700012207, -0.2451142519712448, 0.24828316271305084, -0.4594554305076599, -0.2028590440750122, 0.07577915489673615, -0.3025057315826416, -0.6020520925521851, -0.4900444746017456, 0.2159641534090042, 0.08019986748695374, -0.6088090538978577, 0.035559091717004776, 0.43402382731437683, 0.037821900099515915, 0.3430142104625702, -0.09734739363193512, -0.004924432840198278, -0.5724415183067322, -0.10024271160364151, -0.9786630868911743, 1.0206447839736938, 0.12427317351102829, -0.7647834420204163, -0.74660325050354, -1.2376735210418701, -0.3042958080768585, -0.7527868747711182, -0.1648472547531128, -1.104393482208252, -0.0901278555393219, 0.35506924986839294, 0.24400360882282257, 0.786080539226532, -0.22970706224441528, 0.08669951558113098, 0.28624382615089417, 1.2221912145614624, -0.6522736549377441, -0.27302315831184387, -0.20272958278656006, 0.601771354675293, 0.2626767158508301, -0.03223404660820961, -0.23923251032829285, -0.3940541744232178, 0.11720602959394455, -0.1303446739912033, 0.2261446863412857, -0.2975821793079376, -0.9467693567276001, -0.4528115391731262, 1.010299801826477, -0.6426231861114502, -0.5493712425231934, -1.0945862531661987, -0.31643858551979065, -0.9408803582191467, 0.5351870059967041, 0.08145881444215775, -0.11264380812644958, 0.16057470440864563, 0.11059226840734482, 0.23823237419128418, -1.1828792095184326, 4.169556140899658, 1.7570714950561523, 0.6015434265136719, -0.427074670791626, 0.10429738461971283, 0.5993832945823669, 0.5671757459640503, -0.12070607393980026, 0.24776557087898254, 0.2959495186805725, -0.4093029499053955, 0.6949501633644104, 0.6415269374847412, -0.27780500054359436, 0.5893115997314453, 0.18911638855934143, -1.1106178760528564, 0.678063154220581, 0.3064284920692444, -0.7104396820068359, -1.22144615650177, 0.32233089208602905, -0.01320715993642807, -0.576088547706604, 0.30386602878570557, 0.5391601920127869, 0.2337467223405838, 0.4028511643409729, -1.0169118642807007, -0.05384017527103424, -0.14342458546161652, -0.12850987911224365, 0.7192869186401367, 0.15057575702667236, 0.32182928919792175, 0.37110820412635803, -0.15432673692703247, 0.4230332672595978, 0.3945921063423157, 0.16427776217460632, 0.21305055916309357, -0.8036967515945435, -0.753993570804596, -0.5820926427841187, -0.032453104853630066, 0.008715987205505371, -0.27378419041633606, 0.14667703211307526, 0.40394461154937744, -0.2379191368818283, 0.6098463535308838, -1.0184454917907715, 0.7868382334709167, -0.5421807169914246, -0.8056108355522156, -0.0892072319984436, -0.6608613729476929, -1.1647279262542725, 0.425722599029541, -0.1434428095817566, 0.8052904605865479, -0.03280362859368324, -0.5605592727661133, -0.2863381803035736, 0.5707231760025024, 0.8869913220405579, -0.1454063504934311, 0.43102505803108215, -0.6736887693405151, -0.23251762986183167, -0.4248674809932709, -0.6374561786651611, -0.7634057998657227, 0.23891732096672058, 1.0325871706008911, 0.6980115175247192, -0.3487105667591095, 0.16662538051605225, -0.48131313920021057, -0.09274905174970627, 0.4096766710281372, -0.3041718900203705, 0.293061226606369, -0.011939162388443947, 0.7162055969238281, 0.4730243980884552, -0.7427300214767456, 0.00801553949713707, -0.8271089196205139, 0.8042368292808533, 0.38170912861824036, -0.1562807708978653, 0.026871100068092346, -0.2398870587348938, -0.9577944278717041 ]
{"Title": "GBA variants in REM sleep behavior disorder: a multicenter study", "Authors": "Krohn Lynne, Ruskey Jennifer A., Rudakou Uladzislau, Leveille Etienne, Asayesh Farnaz, Hu Michele T.M., Arnulf Isabelle, Dauvilliers Yves, H\u00f6gl Birgit, Stefani Ambra, Monaca Christelle Charley, Beatriz Abril, Plazzi Giuseppe, Antelmi Elena, Ferini-Strambi Luigi, Heidbreder Anna, Boeve Bradley F., Espay Alberto J., De Cock Val\u00e9rie Cochen, Mollenhauer Brit, Sixel-D\u00f6ring Friederike, Trenkwalder Claudia, Sonka Karel, Kemlink David, Figorilli Michela, Puligheddu Monica, Dijkstra Femke, Viaene Mineke, Oertel Wolfgang, Toffoli Marco, Gigli Gian Luigi, Valente Mariarosaria, Gagnon Jean-Fran\u00e7ois, Desautels Alex, Montplaisir Jacques Y., Postuma Ronald B., Rouleau Guy A., Gan-Or Ziv", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective To study the role of GBA variants in the risk for isolated rapid-eye-movement (REM)-sleep behavior disorder (iRBD) and conversion to overt neurodegeneration. Methods A total of 4,147 individuals were included: 1,061 iRBD patients and 3,086 controls. GBA was fully sequenced using molecular inversion probes and Sanger sequencing. We analyzed the effects of GBA variants on the risk for iRBD, age at onset (AAO) and conversion rates. Results GBA variants were found in 9.5% of iRBD patients compared to 4.1% in controls (odds ratio [OR]=2.45, 95% CI=1.87\u20133.22, p =1\u00d710 \u221210 ). The estimated OR for mild p.N370S variant carriers was 3.69, 95% CI=1.90\u20137.14, p =3.5\u00d710 \u22125 , while for severe variant carriers it was 17.55, 95% CI=2.11\u2013145.9, p =0.0015. Carriers of severe GBA variants had an average AAO of 52.8 years, 7-8 years earlier than those with mild variants or non-carriers ( p =0.029). Of the GBA variant carriers with available data, 52.5% had converted, compared to 35.6% in non-carriers ( p =0.011), with a trend for faster conversion among severe GBA variant carriers. However, the results on AAO and conversion were based on small numbers and should be taken with caution. Conclusions GBA variants robustly and differentially increase the risk of iRBD. The rate of conversion to neurodegeneration is also increased and may be faster among severe GBA variant carriers, although confirmation will be required in larger samples. Screening for RBD in healthy carriers of GBA variants should be studied as a potential way to identify GBA variant carriers who will develop a synucleinopathy in the future.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010991"}
10.1101/19003194
[ -0.22345486283302307, 0.28839462995529175, -0.3574087619781494, 0.2515415549278259, 0.19120359420776367, -0.6861974000930786, 0.16827760636806488, -0.013161887414753437, 0.06311239302158356, 0.5618886947631836, -0.08808282017707825, -0.3348858058452606, 0.26834118366241455, -0.6424911022186279, -0.19200550019741058, -0.5624331831932068, -0.6891017556190491, 0.05728105455636978, -0.10150888562202454, -0.4769345819950104, -0.154892235994339, 0.38898491859436035, -0.2774532735347748, -0.41557154059410095, -0.827510416507721, 0.6392143964767456, 0.12286240607500076, -0.0046106670051813126, 0.5765456557273865, 0.7274823188781738, -0.012981138192117214, -0.489444375038147, 0.07849182188510895, -1.0849238634109497, -0.12804226577281952, -0.252193808555603, 0.5326755046844482, -0.8696309328079224, 0.04938029125332832, 0.017563454806804657, 0.27857574820518494, 0.2363785356283188, 0.6856250166893005, -0.5553219318389893, -0.24251239001750946, -0.1629299819469452, -0.689311146736145, -0.13777458667755127, 0.017539335414767265, -0.17863701283931732, 0.09979132562875748, 0.24176125228405, -0.41436660289764404, 0.3808952271938324, 0.23282521963119507, -0.21429438889026642, 0.5117435455322266, 0.08829279989004135, -0.32737305760383606, 0.39565780758857727, 0.4750029742717743, 0.06098305061459541, 0.687283992767334, -0.6595789194107056, 0.9447706937789917, 0.848039984703064, 0.004888876806944609, 0.2545984387397766, -0.3979876637458801, 0.24023491144180298, -0.5195291638374329, -0.24865217506885529, -0.3699515163898468, 0.14189280569553375, 0.020692532882094383, -0.1389569342136383, -0.40024274587631226, -0.6295269131660461, 0.013547270558774471, -0.46664002537727356, -0.06394044309854507, -0.2189093381166458, 0.4172224700450897, 0.189631849527359, -1.0276463031768799, 0.4620122015476227, 0.23232237994670868, 0.7007008194923401, 0.6609954833984375, 0.023155471310019493, -0.34819528460502625, 0.4794110655784607, 0.0966896340250969, 0.3872303068637848, 0.1387438029050827, 0.6491951942443848, -0.08478108048439026, -0.19026337563991547, -0.13941757380962372, -0.40523824095726013, 0.696398138999939, 0.27402183413505554, 0.35190796852111816, 0.7603121399879456, -1.0024534463882446, 0.8465254306793213, 0.5758824348449707, -0.14164802432060242, -0.45080238580703735, -0.7615922689437866, 0.004422876983880997, 0.017913952469825745, 0.1995607167482376, 0.09183284640312195, -0.06738308817148209, 1.015239953994751, 0.15292809903621674, 0.7985918521881104, -0.5517476201057434, 0.4564794898033142, -0.009743367321789265, 0.01100305188447237, 1.0491809844970703, -0.1297864466905594, 0.7495546936988831, -0.6633529663085938, 0.2492045760154724, 0.9949380159378052, -0.782518208026886, 0.1458459198474884, 0.004435967653989792, -0.21409817039966583, -0.3750219941139221, 0.2284974753856659, -0.3033527433872223, 0.006889006122946739, 0.6898554563522339, 0.669701874256134, -0.17027926445007324, -0.47879737615585327, -0.3035678267478943, 0.9626580476760864, 0.22188706696033478, 1.4098467826843262, -0.4062502384185791, 0.23001965880393982, -0.6987527012825012, -0.1429212987422943, -0.31863337755203247, -0.20822948217391968, 0.29862239956855774, 0.634251058101654, 0.14447836577892303, -0.08103158324956894, -0.04743735119700432, -1.0641251802444458, -0.5385931730270386, 0.47327542304992676, -0.06601610034704208, -0.22602683305740356, -0.38057512044906616, 0.021559644490480423, 0.12121666222810745, 1.1608476638793945, -0.27698448300361633, 0.4414704740047455, -0.23632299900054932, 0.10819078981876373, 0.1579730212688446, -0.7336424589157104, 0.7505550980567932, -0.05557900294661522, -0.42644932866096497, -0.19388453662395477, 0.16762708127498627, 0.29713547229766846, 0.8364667296409607, -0.23556089401245117, 0.5554865002632141, 0.2149103581905365, -0.7193211317062378, -0.6256300806999207, 0.6392971873283386, 1.207432508468628, 0.0548851415514946, 0.12629052996635437, -0.058045193552970886, -1.1989725828170776, -0.001344684511423111, -0.07062628120183945, 0.39346539974212646, 0.29402875900268555, -0.26933810114860535, 0.9240515828132629, -0.040332455188035965, 0.06716421991586685, -0.6959099173545837, 0.08318036049604416, 0.42345213890075684, -0.1852477639913559, -0.4423336982727051, 0.9075849652290344, -0.4628778398036957, 0.596420407295227, -0.11706657707691193, 0.6911649703979492, 0.35575029253959656, 0.6187248229980469, -0.1267775297164917, 0.2804805636405945, 1.0765151977539062, -0.06570757925510406, -0.7933147549629211, -0.5643303394317627, 0.6139019727706909, -0.2828385531902313, -0.7108998894691467, -0.27487775683403015, -0.5456790328025818, -0.6574963927268982, 0.2621570825576782, -0.17701242864131927, -0.17236921191215515, 0.3554896414279938, 0.09648928046226501, 0.286190003156662, 0.28201162815093994, 0.3288840651512146, -0.08176160603761673, 0.05229951813817024, 0.38461798429489136, 0.25203025341033936, 0.7232279777526855, 0.3121543824672699, 0.2514699399471283, 0.42186933755874634, 0.8870463967323303, 0.2945500910282135, 0.8371037840843201, 0.25692006945610046, 0.037774138152599335, 0.4220047891139984, 1.317004919052124, 0.41797778010368347, -1.0099252462387085, 0.44993194937705994, -1.0287816524505615, -0.22947049140930176, -0.2640933096408844, 0.48127275705337524, -0.2497992068529129, 0.6872947812080383, 0.09034650772809982, 0.7459754347801208, -0.8638115525245667, -0.15176409482955933, 0.5272720456123352, 0.5094518065452576, -0.24487818777561188, -0.7802111506462097, -0.46911078691482544, 0.19018349051475525, 0.4594031274318695, 0.2616497576236725, 1.4039053916931152, 0.14207550883293152, 0.3196834325790405, 0.4140247702598572, 0.14421655237674713, -0.6484664082527161, -0.6111194491386414, -0.6443513035774231, -0.7303531765937805, -0.5350332260131836, -0.8989519476890564, 0.49586567282676697, 0.5831971764564514, -0.6219337582588196, 1.1571251153945923, -0.15637309849262238, -0.20718955993652344, -0.29983165860176086, -0.14257556200027466, 0.4979686141014099, -0.1440785527229309, -0.15029095113277435, -0.5933520793914795, -0.23520883917808533, -0.6798431277275085, -0.10296349972486496, 0.12323442101478577, 0.10140405595302582, -0.47138485312461853, -0.3991125524044037, 0.5905461311340332, -0.9070305228233337, -0.19906878471374512, 0.6427567005157471, -0.9280237555503845, -0.018116053193807602, 0.1656012237071991, -0.0744672566652298, -0.2684280574321747, -0.015569121576845646, -1.419783115386963, 0.452039897441864, -0.12308003753423691, 0.25010383129119873, 0.3267733156681061, 0.028351496905088425, -0.5070348978042603, 0.07906993478536606, 0.16670182347297668, 0.19455663859844208, -0.7340923547744751, -0.3749127984046936, 0.6722851991653442, -0.28303059935569763, 0.9262669682502747, -0.46574071049690247, -0.911898672580719, -0.32615751028060913, 0.14306598901748657, 0.5437108278274536, 0.010957485996186733, 0.17431411147117615, -0.18162141740322113, -0.8481387495994568, 0.5049719214439392, -1.454807996749878, -0.5604844093322754, -0.18385891616344452, -1.0636767148971558, 0.5074683427810669, -0.13051320612430573, 0.5281438827514648, -0.171306312084198, -0.4015607237815857, 0.008680782280862331, 0.4223819077014923, -0.19440674781799316, -0.19548536837100983, -0.6880756616592407, 0.5529641509056091, -0.26771166920661926, 0.5636063814163208, 0.6840581893920898, -0.9735446572303772, -0.19494733214378357, -0.34786197543144226, -0.09349039942026138, 0.20457158982753754, 0.7039089798927307, -0.5169879198074341, 1.0968329906463623, 1.1117504835128784, 0.137984961271286, -0.01897837221622467, 0.01174340769648552, 0.10381081700325012, -0.15248142182826996, -0.3236883878707886, -0.009967325255274773, 0.18120312690734863, -1.1351089477539062, -0.3226166367530823, 0.6255144476890564, -0.4977480173110962, 1.058495283126831, -0.761732280254364, 0.7367297410964966, -0.38097092509269714, -0.23404905200004578, 0.0848076194524765, 0.1346430480480194, -0.2546180188655853, 1.146152377128601, -0.2466750293970108, 0.8818408846855164, -0.7909140586853027, 1.4850080013275146, 0.12013786286115646, 1.1848174333572388, -0.33821994066238403, -0.4802432358264923, 0.19394870102405548, -1.2132987976074219, 0.5644596815109253, -0.11461502313613892, -0.09022925049066544, 0.055343981832265854, 0.27280712127685547, -0.1557818353176117, 0.03093256987631321, -0.9731879830360413, -0.6111403107643127, 0.3481534421443939, -0.013338699005544186, 0.5919626951217651, -0.019183281809091568, 0.7853182554244995, -0.9260704517364502, 0.4585801661014557, 0.820217490196228, 0.4053339660167694, -0.1343860924243927, -0.7217808365821838, 0.5448960065841675, 0.07487760484218597, 0.05900692939758301, -0.3788386583328247, 0.1847023367881775, -0.3041957914829254, 0.5922428965568542, -0.21722981333732605, -0.3675163686275482, -0.17598073184490204, -0.14750920236110687, -0.014056329615414143, 0.7950659990310669, -0.2804107666015625, 0.3831169903278351, -0.6488620638847351, 0.5716365575790405, 0.13933613896369934, -0.20028363168239594, 0.12521640956401825, -0.5762482285499573, 0.8814752101898193, 1.1628680229187012, -0.6359389424324036, -1.3553742170333862, -0.13045598566532135, -0.4263641834259033, -0.5534040331840515, -0.45619863271713257, 0.16457268595695496, -0.35763901472091675, 0.08486490696668625, -0.1851726472377777, 0.028313685208559036, -0.5875293016433716, -0.2776561677455902, -0.622663676738739, 0.20503491163253784, 0.5720340013504028, 0.33794206380844116, 0.1458745300769806, 0.9295223951339722, -0.3019251227378845, -0.08934926986694336, -1.1000274419784546, 0.2710324227809906, -0.3649057149887085, -0.19539888203144073, -0.12094175815582275, 0.41719189286231995, 0.10408484190702438, 0.0988447442650795, -0.35799673199653625, -0.2824309170246124, -0.2897007167339325, 0.8125448226928711, 0.5636460185050964, -0.1054045706987381, 1.006820559501648, 0.06218234822154045, 0.15720118582248688, 0.4649835526943207, 0.18333084881305695, -0.4107360541820526, -0.8745373487472534, 0.21341842412948608, -0.1759229451417923, 0.37752166390419006, -0.5124081373214722, 0.055493324995040894, -0.22572997212409973, -0.48271098732948303, 0.05488167703151703, -0.3052222430706024, -0.10001299530267715, -0.5047281980514526, -0.3253200352191925, -1.1854851245880127, -0.4302751123905182, 0.07527785003185272, -0.8875729441642761, -0.9924399852752686, 1.0310369729995728, -0.008043558336794376, -0.3075006306171417, -0.7138817310333252, 0.25389447808265686, -0.2786210775375366, -0.21201416850090027, -0.7131432294845581, 0.16916799545288086, -0.7423897385597229, -0.26912105083465576, 0.7711735367774963, -1.0612833499908447, 0.1742083877325058, 0.11971430480480194, 0.9602909684181213, -0.8617225289344788, -1.1360855102539062, -0.5096518993377686, -0.22428388893604279, -0.5022544860839844, -0.6743593811988831, 0.613371729850769, -0.4046887457370758, 0.6873576045036316, 0.07078058272600174, -0.023590566590428352, 0.2663644254207611, 0.19546188414096832, -0.19662198424339294, 0.13441883027553558, -0.4257478415966034, 0.09445815533399582, -0.32946300506591797, 0.6456510424613953, 0.19489631056785583, 0.6681825518608093, -0.802781343460083, -1.069333553314209, -0.6686689853668213, -1.0459887981414795, -0.1575237512588501, -0.6422954797744751, 0.6193728446960449, -0.3137815296649933, -0.041864063590765, 0.13728584349155426, 0.4998534023761749, 0.3909666836261749, 0.30511415004730225, -0.2723572850227356, -0.07353991270065308, 0.9181382060050964, -0.4286564886569977, -0.34179240465164185, 0.06284530460834503, -0.4986479878425598, -0.18086053431034088, 1.5432031154632568, 0.8484930396080017, -0.03670113533735275, 0.16309358179569244, -0.2715728282928467, 0.305864542722702, -0.17332477867603302, -0.8226521611213684, 0.14677827060222626, 0.14505280554294586, 0.8452984690666199, 0.31989869475364685, -0.26476559042930603, -1.246062159538269, 0.6035458445549011, -0.4684717655181885, 0.2780429422855377, 0.1151847168803215, -0.34803909063339233, 0.07210519909858704, 0.4438389837741852, 1.0440198183059692, -0.3187570571899414, -0.5653412342071533, 0.12519977986812592, -0.09249132871627808, 0.39578837156295776, 0.0462944321334362, -0.17545895278453827, -0.8086177706718445, -1.143423080444336, -0.6819658279418945, -0.5404055714607239, 0.12178592383861542, 0.2633936405181885, 0.7356545925140381, -0.029645342379808426, -0.2815949022769928, -1.1760941743850708, 1.5283406972885132, 0.21862120926380157, -0.540275514125824, -0.1939149647951126, 0.6784693002700806, 0.43912187218666077, 0.03790447488427162, 0.5285954475402832, 0.26013606786727905, -0.8459745645523071, -0.17354048788547516, -0.33940210938453674, -0.5256021022796631, -1.046426773071289, -0.24700935184955597, 0.4463348686695099, 0.5637609362602234, -0.09393619745969772, -0.1493651568889618, 0.35963451862335205, 0.036103203892707825, -0.41836240887641907, 1.124622106552124, -0.5945438742637634, 0.06479586660861969, 1.0654520988464355, -0.06263856589794159, -1.1788033246994019, -0.28781625628471375, -0.7316798567771912, 0.3996606171131134, -0.17899365723133087, 0.7272581458091736, 0.8061819672584534, -0.43201133608818054, 0.33161652088165283, 0.4971295893192291, -0.4470130503177643, -0.9009708166122437, -0.06305626034736633, -0.029995061457157135, -0.2468520998954773, -0.6197805404663086, -0.5764141082763672, 0.17656627297401428, -0.17147411406040192, 0.7553842663764954, -0.5652065873146057, -0.2709238529205322, 0.21579377353191376, -0.27775847911834717, 0.1354842483997345, -0.8946614861488342, 0.042107533663511276, 0.09872182458639145, -0.4382491707801819, 0.49918046593666077, 0.1995607167482376, -0.11866109818220139, 0.07897114008665085, 0.48402905464172363, 1.0420210361480713, -0.47863665223121643, -0.27386221289634705, 0.0606144554913044, 0.21003961563110352, 0.60386723279953, 0.43698829412460327, -0.30814826488494873, 0.47965511679649353, -0.43732064962387085, -0.4739036560058594, -1.000954270362854, 0.23718973994255066, 0.4009232819080353, 0.5229955911636353, -0.14649604260921478, -0.025454897433519363, 0.8197158575057983, 0.7962977886199951, 0.2819620668888092, -0.5633887052536011, -0.7848608493804932, -0.7676207423210144, -0.3112565279006958, 0.02033822238445282, -1.0244554281234741, -0.38476744294166565, 0.654137372970581, -0.23676618933677673, -0.484611451625824, -0.9277501702308655, 0.07859180867671967, -0.38200539350509644, -0.5746855139732361, -0.05103510245680809, 0.9250776767730713, -0.28617438673973083, -0.5180622339248657, -0.11768877506256104, -0.34951406717300415, -0.19245585799217224, 0.7483793497085571, -0.6175855994224548, -0.3003389239311218, -0.48604175448417664, 0.2937873899936676, 0.22830058634281158, 0.2765589654445648, -0.10854554176330566, -0.5721262097358704, -0.3571161925792694, 0.6935448050498962, -0.32968467473983765, 0.03403627872467041, 1.081105351448059, -0.21342720091342926, 0.3255952298641205, 0.36230599880218506, 0.4925745725631714, -0.007827631197869778, -0.026176713407039642, -0.16038738191127777, -0.1475905179977417, -0.5326125025749207, -0.6961405277252197, 0.6977453827857971, -0.592796802520752, -0.14309366047382355, -0.21759074926376343, -0.16084305942058563, 0.16111108660697937, -0.20926767587661743, 0.28073540329933167, 0.6641156077384949, -0.015570912510156631, -0.008096142672002316, 0.00478438101708889, 0.6980909109115601, 0.43786031007766724, -0.1586160808801651, 0.23628032207489014, -0.010574042797088623, 0.41750437021255493, -1.0099848508834839, 0.3806355893611908, -0.046857304871082306, -0.7717933654785156, -0.01523983757942915, -0.792104959487915, -0.5031430125236511, -0.2868979871273041, -0.2931068241596222, 0.66612708568573, 0.9842684268951416, 0.43571510910987854, 0.14264065027236938, 0.2806943953037262, 0.008604747243225574, -0.5978788137435913, 0.04205848276615143, -0.9805560111999512, -0.7049387097358704, 0.3833385109901428, -0.4714992344379425, -0.20694786310195923, -0.7746816277503967, -1.0705657005310059, 1.1997809410095215, -0.30075469613075256, 0.017498599365353584, -0.0008586752228438854, 0.36852821707725525, 0.12353893369436264, 0.4365641176700592, -0.08341195434331894, 0.0996205061674118, 0.1586897224187851, 0.4751339852809906, -0.0032806373201310635, -0.9669982194900513, 0.09024540334939957, 0.6568891406059265, 0.05008707940578461, -0.5044629573822021, -0.42107394337654114, 0.03547392413020134, 0.18592935800552368, 0.18229766190052032, 0.24576103687286377, 0.018727874383330345, -0.3398686647415161, 0.12947379052639008, -0.3668018877506256, 0.17126546800136566, -0.465528279542923, 0.2736412286758423, 0.1799786239862442, -1.171677827835083, -1.049947738647461, -0.11960265040397644, 1.2834025621414185, -0.1934998780488968, -0.025666242465376854, -0.31930115818977356, 0.15286685526371002, -0.14898745715618134, -0.6057100296020508, -0.2677340805530548, 0.7221928834915161, 0.2123168706893921, 0.06244494393467903, -0.2698096036911011, 0.32033053040504456, 0.3973611295223236, 0.15720318257808685, -0.07728687673807144, 0.4260186553001404, 0.7258603572845459, 0.18473580479621887, -0.4494362771511078, -0.3979061543941498, 0.34067314863204956, 0.29987916350364685, -0.6609095931053162, -0.044756945222616196, 0.2368263453245163, 0.813046932220459, -0.2634095847606659, -0.4012106657028198, 0.6401952505111694, 0.32790255546569824, -0.7150024175643921, 0.07136516273021698, 0.3052752912044525, 0.2364230901002884, 0.39921289682388306, 0.5045090913772583, 0.06045715510845184, -0.05102550610899925, -0.2395390272140503, 0.539305567741394, 0.7443011999130249, 0.05398855730891228, -0.619753897190094, 0.07342468202114105, 0.2693444788455963, 0.3273480236530304, -0.46536728739738464, 0.16404329240322113, 0.28925082087516785, -0.8338261246681213, 1.0822367668151855, 0.24482505023479462, 0.4158707857131958, 0.735795259475708, -0.9535034894943237, -0.2171897441148758, 0.13744086027145386, -0.11843381077051163, -0.31093868613243103, -0.050893139094114304, 0.7229527831077576, -0.6173655986785889, -0.5487952828407288, 0.424361914396286, -0.282061368227005, 0.3081321716308594, 0.13667358458042145, 0.22539022564888, -0.48281699419021606, 0.7718008160591125, 0.6626221537590027, 0.1406213343143463, -0.4463409185409546, -0.4322510063648224, -0.38756659626960754, -0.15975157916545868, -0.4619733393192291, 0.05776438117027283, -0.19873155653476715, -0.26927611231803894, -0.0925769954919815, 0.0750531330704689, 0.45710304379463196, -0.33332979679107666, -0.22958533465862274, -0.20087288320064545, -0.28404149413108826, 0.45723602175712585, 0.15399080514907837, -0.3193467855453491, 0.08880327641963959, -0.054141364991664886, -0.3380511403083801, -0.45750460028648376, -0.31239739060401917, 0.14069388806819916, -0.2955276072025299, 0.37182655930519104, 0.6220368146896362, -0.47064006328582764, -0.5971787571907043, -0.5679432153701782, -0.696720540523529, -0.02618911676108837, -0.3603971302509308, -1.1656856536865234, 0.4576316475868225, 0.13170354068279266, 0.33385592699050903, -0.10676278918981552, -0.6714761257171631, -0.19194990396499634, 0.6468532681465149, 1.2854218482971191, -0.5945380330085754, 0.6833775043487549, -0.07418591529130936, 0.16365841031074524, -0.027144858613610268, -0.18042726814746857, -0.251002699136734, 0.10520805418491364, -0.37956270575523376, -0.044926632195711136, 0.016667012125253677, -0.30324167013168335, -0.40273338556289673, 0.5136532187461853, 0.22145375609397888, 0.49359288811683655, -0.10449794679880142, -0.9357184171676636, -1.0034656524658203, -0.7715678215026855, 1.5739660263061523, -0.4790990650653839, 0.4996309280395508, 0.4824415445327759, 0.2364693582057953, 0.1435905545949936, -1.2633533477783203, 4.091345310211182, 1.1333158016204834, 0.7935667634010315, -0.06409870088100433, 0.7454256415367126, 0.7621172666549683, 0.760875403881073, -0.07196101546287537, 0.6874218583106995, 0.2579805552959442, -0.7582986354827881, 0.26077553629875183, 0.1282615214586258, 0.10087499767541885, 0.5942720174789429, 0.39813724160194397, -1.064477562904358, -0.3141370117664337, 0.16300229728221893, -0.33506283164024353, -0.48278626799583435, 0.29743027687072754, 0.3835847079753876, 0.3618362843990326, 0.4450552761554718, 0.08047784864902496, 0.5350193381309509, -0.3217214345932007, -0.6291733980178833, -0.08806838095188141, 0.17863047122955322, -0.9462109208106995, 0.20988066494464874, -0.04316715896129608, 0.4995177388191223, 0.5698003768920898, -0.2886368930339813, 0.160047248005867, -0.4598993957042694, -0.2911647856235504, -0.5238199830055237, 0.3460313379764557, -0.22309081256389618, -0.5369232296943665, -0.061465438455343246, 0.2867003083229065, -0.29938483238220215, -0.264325886964798, 0.24136561155319214, -0.057981353253126144, 1.308781623840332, -0.8939658403396606, 0.5331204533576965, 0.7460139393806458, -0.8131889700889587, 0.18428348004817963, 0.06939729303121567, -0.8577424883842468, 0.27652350068092346, -0.16955901682376862, 0.643044650554657, -0.11543843150138855, -0.0889374315738678, 0.2560749053955078, 0.6391380429267883, 0.6154977083206177, -0.42378032207489014, 0.04101315885782242, -0.0483037568628788, -0.13118089735507965, -0.04645710811018944, 0.022609129548072815, -0.8029448390007019, -0.23580923676490784, 1.0867552757263184, 0.662964403629303, -0.2337384968996048, 0.6369833946228027, -0.14024098217487335, -0.3629586696624756, -0.0090814009308815, 0.54673171043396, 0.07814175635576248, -0.1953420490026474, 0.2304612398147583, 1.4978280067443848, -0.3666839599609375, 0.28389373421669006, -1.559626579284668, 0.10730068385601044, 0.7037038803100586, 0.14035235345363617, 0.6253839731216431, -0.9147410988807678, -0.3168072998523712 ]
{"Title": "Insomnia, excessive daytime sleepiness, anxiety, depression and socioeconomic status among customer service employees in Canada", "Authors": "Sosso FA Etindele", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objectives The present study alerts on the potential effect of working full time in a call center as a risk factor for neuropsychiatric illnesses. It is the first study investigating deeply presence of anxiety, depression, insomnia and excessive daytime sleepiness among a large population of customer service employees. It has 3 specifics goals which were (1) document presence of sleep disorders among customer service advisors (2) document presence of anxiety and depression in this population (3) determine the influence of the socioeconomic status, duration in position and full time or part-time shift on the diseases above. Findings It was found that the majority of people working in customer service are undergraduate students or at a secondary/high school degree. They worked full time, are single and have reported at least two of the neuropsychiatric disorders assessed in the present study. Among customer service advisors enrolled in this study, all neuropsychiatric disorders investigated were present and significantly higher for those working full time. Perceived socioeconomic status (pSES) was almost similar for full time and part time workers with a mean score of 4.8 on the MacArthur scale of subjective social status. Results revealed that duration in position was an excellent predictor of insomnia, sleepiness and anxiety (respectively with R2=91,83%, R2=81,23% and R2=87,46%) but a moderate predictor of depression (R2=69,14%). The pSES was a moderate predictor of sleep disorders (respectively R2=62,04% for insomnia and R2=53,62% for sleepiness) but had a strong association with anxiety and depression (R2=82,95% for anxiety and R2=89,77% for depression). It was found that insomnia and anxiety are more prevalent for immigrants and international students compared to Canadians, while depression was similarly higher for Canadian and immigrants compared to international students. It was found that sleepiness has the same trend in the three subgroups. Conclusion Customer service employees are exposed to a continuous stimulation of their cognitive functions in addition to different stressors which can progressively and silently damage the nervous system. Investigations on mental and physical health of customer service advisors are worthy of interest, and understanding how their work, their rotating shifts and their socioeconomic status influence their resilience and their performance at work; may help comprehension of similar health issues emerging in similar populations with similar occupations.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003194"}
10.1101/19008474
[ -0.08045462518930435, 0.8280292749404907, 0.1357385814189911, -0.17259585857391357, -0.42933881282806396, -0.1380651295185089, 0.07742839306592941, 0.37324002385139465, 0.4607240855693817, 0.6189279556274414, -0.15078796446323395, -0.8187641501426697, 0.09551072865724564, -0.48962971568107605, 0.021797876805067062, 0.7183790802955627, -1.184367060661316, -0.24631842970848083, -0.28647011518478394, 0.15111324191093445, 0.3034324645996094, 0.2626357972621918, -0.8084449172019958, -0.0767335519194603, -0.3594526946544647, 0.5817010402679443, 0.44439613819122314, -0.0809292122721672, 1.3628523349761963, 0.8296518325805664, 0.2318166047334671, -0.17419397830963135, 0.32166972756385803, -0.7217029333114624, -0.14646416902542114, 0.1577102541923523, 0.6929028034210205, -0.6044175624847412, -0.1819029152393341, -0.8325526714324951, 0.4083041250705719, -0.3542180359363556, 0.13808976113796234, -0.15127871930599213, -0.2730332314968109, -0.2259945124387741, -0.4086618721485138, -0.42889368534088135, 0.41148918867111206, -0.3258233666419983, -0.18940718472003937, -0.12368988245725632, 0.12873508036136627, -0.08780364692211151, 0.18107342720031738, -0.03649025410413742, -0.07424148917198181, 0.1566685140132904, -0.3532324433326721, 0.4081394076347351, -0.3785116672515869, 0.12935684621334076, 0.8600690364837646, -1.4189784526824951, 0.9179630875587463, 0.6149633526802063, 0.01842966489493847, -0.6101526618003845, -0.5423346161842346, -0.3089236319065094, -0.6183271408081055, -0.21020616590976715, -0.007548084016889334, -0.4353581666946411, -0.24868015944957733, -0.18680094182491302, 0.3998848497867584, 0.18225052952766418, -0.4290896952152252, -0.2614365220069885, -0.034252773970365524, 0.34864604473114014, 0.10528045147657394, 0.3559236526489258, -0.775174617767334, 0.15940289199352264, 0.23349381983280182, 0.15497365593910217, 0.287156879901886, 0.340767502784729, 0.6449684500694275, 0.0540536493062973, 0.22705504298210144, 0.2849050760269165, -0.19638913869857788, 0.8059035539627075, -0.5675526261329651, -0.0746268630027771, -0.34191954135894775, -0.2240270972251892, 0.6815138459205627, 0.7246496081352234, -0.3315024971961975, 0.530829906463623, -0.7827950119972229, 1.4191957712173462, 0.5044464468955994, -0.3547836244106293, -1.0674889087677002, -0.6327974200248718, 0.1892976611852646, 0.3773854076862335, -0.20619061589241028, -0.08751316368579865, 0.8941119909286499, 0.5876274108886719, 0.2821252942085266, 1.0295988321304321, -0.719997763633728, 0.0359070859849453, -0.4911063015460968, 0.7888066172599792, 0.5219112038612366, -0.33952561020851135, 0.8065205216407776, 0.35501474142074585, 0.052189938724040985, 0.2232714295387268, -0.9300979375839233, -0.38845953345298767, -0.6915971040725708, -0.7419919371604919, -0.2617771029472351, 0.5680772662162781, -0.5549151301383972, 0.08433578163385391, 0.2326052039861679, 1.2413132190704346, 0.040176015347242355, -0.40645521879196167, -0.15724757313728333, 0.1966199278831482, -0.5761685371398926, 0.7526800632476807, -0.5280625820159912, 0.8150801062583923, -0.02551356516778469, -1.5592806339263916, -0.5137584209442139, -0.06073097139596939, 0.416403204202652, 0.4892703890800476, 0.0013359691947698593, 0.1934213638305664, 0.2716081142425537, 0.3784135580062866, -0.5941287875175476, -0.05226533114910126, -0.16202887892723083, -0.0619918517768383, -0.7599387168884277, -0.019408589228987694, -0.7957556247711182, 0.49067455530166626, -0.7702611088752747, 0.9393804669380188, -0.03793151304125786, 0.32793596386909485, 0.4838554561138153, -0.9460111260414124, 0.3025367856025696, 0.6337475776672363, 0.03068457543849945, -0.43054258823394775, 0.7987518906593323, 1.0378745794296265, 0.33045607805252075, -0.19482791423797607, 0.7476919293403625, 0.30644482374191284, -0.07719545811414719, 0.052071209996938705, 0.39525699615478516, 0.878677487373352, -0.009108629077672958, -0.10009421408176422, -0.5205715894699097, -0.17843984067440033, -0.050063811242580414, 0.06567694246768951, -0.7621946930885315, 0.44441068172454834, -0.4777996242046356, 1.059735655784607, -0.036306802183389664, -0.4137515425682068, 0.07468459010124207, 0.48397374153137207, -0.34391066431999207, -0.27678182721138, -0.3097838759422302, 0.6862002611160278, -0.6591756343841553, 0.7461295127868652, -0.2541292607784271, 1.052571415901184, 0.1683155596256256, 0.3767753541469574, -0.49443304538726807, -0.009122323244810104, 1.03877854347229, 0.2894436717033386, -0.40467461943626404, 0.11033159494400024, 0.44785118103027344, 0.01808486133813858, -0.20615501701831818, 0.10446944087743759, -0.7621790766716003, 0.27465254068374634, 0.14003634452819824, -0.896450936794281, 0.4405703544616699, 0.2406834065914154, 0.020312074571847916, 0.5087560415267944, 0.38518479466438293, 0.5718554258346558, 0.14462025463581085, -0.1614348590373993, 0.3964991271495819, 0.6746981143951416, 0.15817652642726898, 0.6097368597984314, 1.161840796470642, 0.7337033152580261, -0.009695553220808506, 0.581238865852356, -0.2839147746562958, 0.48931336402893066, 0.7091612219810486, 0.6362329125404358, 0.3386366665363312, 0.8152672052383423, -0.2447865754365921, 0.5765469670295715, -0.3472972512245178, 0.2418844997882843, 0.02083820290863514, 0.4940744936466217, -1.0332602262496948, 0.6502379179000854, 0.6390141248703003, 0.2634919285774231, -0.7979472279548645, -0.16940666735172272, 0.3283933699131012, -0.4499572813510895, -0.40318024158477783, -0.5440481305122375, 0.05577858164906502, 0.67672199010849, -0.7206826210021973, -0.14688590168952942, 0.68610680103302, 0.7635660171508789, 0.019850047305226326, 0.48328736424446106, 0.3186023235321045, -0.7378123998641968, -0.22322358191013336, -0.8420059680938721, -1.4865206480026245, -1.2960368394851685, -0.9247126579284668, -0.05026046559214592, -0.26775112748146057, -0.46448779106140137, 0.0012640106724575162, -0.38998761773109436, 0.02469078078866005, 0.08696942031383514, -0.07108451426029205, 0.5377198457717896, 0.628133237361908, -0.2225862741470337, -0.9818296432495117, 0.43383947014808655, -0.02612396329641342, 0.27394530177116394, 0.2805165946483612, -0.21539470553398132, -0.5382675528526306, -0.5177852511405945, 0.30708491802215576, -0.6874328851699829, 0.015371725894510746, -0.4599325954914093, -0.5554559826850891, -0.6596363186836243, 0.5428677797317505, -0.039276182651519775, -0.02881636656820774, 0.2784368097782135, -0.7802397608757019, 0.751369297504425, 0.4237458109855652, -0.05537905916571617, 0.48634475469589233, 0.3683282434940338, -0.07269690185785294, 0.3362903594970703, -0.24587057530879974, 0.25042909383773804, -1.2319871187210083, 0.255854994058609, 0.4215029180049896, -0.4204518496990204, -0.07324502617120743, -0.2521050274372101, -1.1895689964294434, -0.2382250875234604, 0.12195349484682083, 0.13555562496185303, -0.47463393211364746, 0.6518802046775818, 0.07583565264940262, -1.0884605646133423, 0.03277900069952011, -0.7802531719207764, -0.9189832806587219, -0.2795316278934479, -0.43565842509269714, 0.25245603919029236, 0.36734968423843384, -0.6416584849357605, 0.05345575511455536, -0.03716672211885452, 0.28587034344673157, 0.8214983940124512, 0.3715561628341675, 0.09286531805992126, 0.13035917282104492, 0.11939851939678192, -0.6221680045127869, 0.5118069648742676, 0.24970421195030212, -1.0910449028015137, -0.1976005882024765, 0.31859880685806274, 0.2589905261993408, 0.012878844514489174, 0.7736883163452148, -0.16705094277858734, -0.2671947479248047, 0.5626681447029114, 0.16561107337474823, 0.4751734733581543, 0.2423751801252365, -0.0068840510211884975, -0.4437447190284729, 0.21915683150291443, -0.23518341779708862, 0.3641393780708313, -1.0468084812164307, -0.18898123502731323, 0.0483536571264267, -0.28528061509132385, 0.36211591958999634, -0.5480350852012634, 0.807854413986206, -0.02927265129983425, -0.22220203280448914, 0.12747904658317566, -0.19879204034805298, -0.07389665395021439, 1.1457407474517822, 0.8760128021240234, 1.257047176361084, -1.4226934909820557, 0.431162029504776, 0.2853693664073944, 0.18898896872997284, 0.15414166450500488, 0.34648966789245605, 0.415364533662796, -0.6751235723495483, 0.38125646114349365, 0.14861345291137695, -0.2493363469839096, -0.18049108982086182, 0.2721846103668213, -0.36264124512672424, -0.07509995996952057, -0.8584732413291931, -0.5113070011138916, -0.26298364996910095, 0.5805909037590027, -0.27944836020469666, -0.13827766478061676, 0.9742427468299866, -0.6744548678398132, 0.2856001853942871, 0.4070810377597809, 0.6782957315444946, 0.2926451861858368, -0.5243682265281677, -0.06932594627141953, -0.47341445088386536, -0.5172308683395386, 0.09793578833341599, -0.2924010455608368, -0.05161735787987709, -0.2699694335460663, 0.5807319283485413, -0.0680759996175766, -0.6062514781951904, -0.688626766204834, -0.7481714487075806, 0.5255826115608215, -0.07701890915632248, -0.02466794103384018, -0.43275314569473267, 0.16379348933696747, -0.42082130908966064, -0.623482346534729, 0.22245873510837555, -0.9019106030464172, 0.7845455408096313, 0.9656394720077515, -0.23912334442138672, -0.7972469329833984, -0.3520428240299225, -0.12307463586330414, 0.18079112470149994, -0.11527935415506363, 0.20915241539478302, -0.09296402335166931, 0.5323912501335144, -0.29969537258148193, -0.27812105417251587, -0.47852304577827454, -0.1861407458782196, 0.012278645299375057, 0.5293928384780884, 0.5111401677131653, 0.9115148782730103, 0.07929252088069916, 0.6634922623634338, -0.07851281017065048, 0.765747606754303, -0.9317331910133362, 0.5356103777885437, -0.8244202733039856, -0.6832547783851624, -0.2813878655433655, -0.24238638579845428, -0.26884785294532776, 0.009346391074359417, -0.26202327013015747, -0.13024158775806427, 0.05960780382156372, 0.2232673466205597, -0.39636120200157166, 0.14231181144714355, 0.4866936206817627, -0.847861111164093, -0.331019788980484, 1.660914659500122, -0.3993362486362457, -0.12436451762914658, -0.08036776632070541, -0.5613949298858643, -1.0212156772613525, 0.6896978616714478, 0.32407262921333313, 0.4065505564212799, -0.046183858066797256, -0.3007511794567108, -0.09360554069280624, 0.4266466796398163, 0.04472732171416283, -0.5195652842521667, 0.10507481545209885, -0.7017743587493896, -0.6107099652290344, -0.5508116483688354, -0.840834379196167, -0.5303443670272827, 0.742192804813385, 0.15130336582660675, -0.5212785005569458, -0.3742140531539917, -0.8049835562705994, 0.05760613828897476, 0.15094976127147675, -0.5535911917686462, -0.0547754131257534, -0.457109659910202, -0.20870235562324524, 0.75874263048172, -0.7376633882522583, -0.6170134544372559, -0.014483562670648098, 0.3636978566646576, -0.5191702842712402, -0.30734753608703613, 0.06446242332458496, 0.03908943757414818, -0.6435421109199524, -0.4448930025100708, 0.015799641609191895, -0.46772804856300354, -0.14227771759033203, -0.36302247643470764, -0.25242236256599426, 0.3354300260543823, 0.09162887185811996, 0.18869435787200928, 0.21952097117900848, 0.0005145500181242824, -1.1511210203170776, -0.1981009691953659, 0.2412608116865158, -0.0941983014345169, 0.2355029284954071, -0.5367987751960754, -0.883016049861908, -0.35304880142211914, -0.8769122958183289, -0.0820951983332634, -0.3147786855697632, -0.15171612799167633, -0.4932072162628174, -0.6945663690567017, -0.3939906656742096, 0.3761773705482483, 0.2919897735118866, 0.338614284992218, 0.045062050223350525, -0.08658846467733383, 0.9507013559341431, 0.032514143735170364, -0.2320604771375656, -0.05937974154949188, -0.22791366279125214, 0.5714486241340637, 0.9242194890975952, -0.10147958248853683, -0.6121805310249329, 0.2741272747516632, 0.18245209753513336, 0.24057963490486145, 0.7711474895477295, -0.6322059631347656, -0.6425856351852417, 0.041548952460289, 0.6685591340065002, 0.03872041031718254, -0.7449455857276917, -0.4940827190876007, 1.0198184251785278, -0.5254110097885132, 0.7590374946594238, 0.014987488277256489, -0.2479735165834427, 0.26515817642211914, -0.20884381234645844, 1.1919869184494019, -0.6866976022720337, 0.3590874969959259, 0.03738103806972504, -0.5131196975708008, -0.3514511287212372, 0.17523029446601868, -0.7082661986351013, -0.3278164863586426, -0.8896459341049194, -0.6135600805282593, 0.3963988721370697, 0.5073381066322327, 0.20087185502052307, -0.11667817831039429, -0.08660578727722168, 0.2329091876745224, 0.05263358727097511, 1.2642836570739746, 0.6934847831726074, -0.1395248919725418, -0.4408663213253021, 0.017853816971182823, 0.23579205572605133, 0.09757398813962936, 0.5875791907310486, 0.5881358981132507, -0.7756149172782898, -0.4410564601421356, -0.419154554605484, -0.47139430046081543, -0.6369955539703369, -0.25165554881095886, -0.06574651598930359, 0.5123640894889832, 0.12097690254449844, 0.2654433250427246, 0.02920125424861908, -0.2423413097858429, 0.16152667999267578, 0.14760349690914154, -0.23352454602718353, 0.8284176588058472, 0.7818036675453186, -0.1519908308982849, -0.1943199336528778, 0.7807260751724243, -0.058052320033311844, -0.1144338846206665, 0.012468811124563217, -0.5405359864234924, 0.15640850365161896, -0.30196037888526917, 0.7765461802482605, 0.17526087164878845, -0.6945788860321045, -0.03210042417049408, -0.12059196829795837, -0.13305717706680298, -0.05704900249838829, -0.21158410608768463, -0.7326411008834839, 0.4857715666294098, -0.8819556832313538, 0.3009912967681885, -0.25790226459503174, -0.020889587700366974, -0.027159780263900757, -0.2106429487466812, -0.4066130816936493, -1.0864206552505493, 0.32179221510887146, 0.4759397804737091, -0.9208937883377075, 0.4455718994140625, 0.41085708141326904, 0.3131125867366791, 0.26081499457359314, -0.3053646385669708, 0.039480023086071014, -1.0417497158050537, -0.3142985701560974, 0.37943726778030396, -0.16479532420635223, 0.18728786706924438, 0.31831982731819153, 0.5734982490539551, 0.7018812298774719, -0.43858468532562256, -1.295045018196106, -0.8691933155059814, 0.408516526222229, 0.5176311731338501, 0.4679405689239502, 0.07137224823236465, 0.39836639165878296, 0.3958842158317566, 0.7646582126617432, 0.06168016791343689, 0.11403500288724899, -0.4514079689979553, -0.7089296579360962, -0.8086599111557007, -0.48499441146850586, -0.8250783085823059, 0.15362440049648285, 1.2743459939956665, -0.4573209583759308, -0.46188151836395264, -0.08279906213283539, 0.9370101094245911, 0.1944689303636551, 0.016233155503869057, -0.3256475031375885, 0.20293515920639038, 0.0313267856836319, -0.3740410804748535, -0.5202499628067017, -0.22039176523685455, -0.239888533949852, 0.8998779058456421, -0.19284281134605408, -0.15101689100265503, -0.12771928310394287, 0.17038321495056152, 0.24886614084243774, 0.4564621150493622, -0.280082643032074, 0.021275648847222328, 0.3404037654399872, 0.3708081841468811, -0.2885679006576538, 0.3879952132701874, 0.5080605149269104, -0.012678482569754124, 0.1551574021577835, 0.33695095777511597, -0.01972675696015358, 0.0944257527589798, 0.4309154748916626, 0.3815191090106964, -0.4839078187942505, -0.5759252905845642, -0.2276712954044342, 0.9076605439186096, -0.7331205606460571, -0.17276142537593842, -0.8022124767303467, 0.22278447449207306, 0.27559930086135864, 0.217240571975708, 0.00788081530481577, 0.7943575978279114, 0.5184535384178162, 0.7540323138237, 0.011309315450489521, 0.1694275438785553, 0.6160104870796204, 0.14623001217842102, 0.5971525311470032, 0.2505446672439575, 0.23414719104766846, -1.4739075899124146, -0.16862206161022186, 0.521072506904602, -0.9207219481468201, 0.2599245309829712, -0.35020607709884644, 0.22824741899967194, 0.44112345576286316, 0.09184598922729492, 0.05462346598505974, 1.1853764057159424, 0.4290885329246521, 1.0572081804275513, -1.0193456411361694, -0.2088039517402649, -0.4543853998184204, -0.5818997025489807, -1.4551512002944946, -0.5949006676673889, 0.596555233001709, -0.3417667746543884, -0.1994801163673401, -0.6883227229118347, -1.244443416595459, 0.6784645318984985, 0.4048999547958374, 0.20413292944431305, 0.01997036300599575, 0.36634013056755066, 0.08376651257276535, 0.033758241683244705, 0.7262731194496155, -0.0958302915096283, 0.5237579345703125, -0.16960911452770233, -0.9109054803848267, -0.2358010709285736, -0.23621338605880737, 0.5875774621963501, 0.46621382236480713, -0.8292628526687622, -0.173368901014328, 0.4201180040836334, 0.2091064304113388, -0.1308879256248474, -0.09677033871412277, 0.004943499341607094, -0.5663211345672607, -0.04569876566529274, -0.22930654883384705, -0.3312666714191437, -0.392061322927475, 0.24709396064281464, -0.20164600014686584, -0.6059504747390747, -0.03504142910242081, 0.7358997464179993, 0.4813290536403656, -0.5014035701751709, 0.05202905833721161, 0.07126293331384659, 0.6309321522712708, -0.28747403621673584, -0.0008057610248215497, 0.2871195673942566, 1.0652446746826172, 0.5659223198890686, -0.33053943514823914, -0.055698905140161514, -0.04447285085916519, 1.0966967344284058, 0.7648499608039856, 0.7648385167121887, 0.29215240478515625, 0.25533366203308105, 0.1761901080608368, -0.15717756748199463, -0.9811199307441711, 0.5286234617233276, 0.13454456627368927, -0.3398246765136719, -0.335919052362442, 0.5765011310577393, 0.72206050157547, -0.1803622990846634, -0.7976848483085632, 0.17636889219284058, -0.7573319673538208, -0.17482595145702362, -0.1925438791513443, 0.9165472984313965, 0.8429761528968811, 0.10129967331886292, 0.6291665434837341, 0.06156282126903534, 0.40815266966819763, 0.026583433151245117, 0.18250733613967896, 0.758202850818634, -0.3559880256652832, -0.8581105470657349, 0.1497643142938614, 0.5176644921302795, 0.14758075773715973, -0.6231678128242493, 0.09679784625768661, -0.0944943055510521, -0.29318302869796753, 0.43534594774246216, -0.373565137386322, 0.20001398026943207, 1.0113191604614258, -0.6214824318885803, -0.14128631353378296, -0.2676927149295807, 0.3971642255783081, -0.3686084449291229, -0.5103541016578674, 0.7871793508529663, -0.33246949315071106, 0.1646357625722885, 0.49545127153396606, 0.5366369485855103, 0.6887159943580627, 0.6301512122154236, 0.3380395174026489, -0.5836480259895325, 0.36115944385528564, 0.6914879083633423, 0.18737328052520752, -0.14761137962341309, -0.10307101905345917, -0.38739755749702454, 0.03734453395009041, -0.431744247674942, 0.2828705906867981, 0.6266428828239441, -0.6149019002914429, -0.7269783020019531, 0.34170711040496826, -0.4040345251560211, 0.342778742313385, -0.9441268444061279, -0.2855844497680664, 0.07107992470264435, -0.00492191594094038, -0.5769646763801575, 0.28348082304000854, 0.35409367084503174, -0.469682514667511, -0.05261435732245445, -0.5036153793334961, -0.27023011445999146, 0.10528556257486343, -0.9250228404998779, 0.4282606244087219, -0.014699118211865425, -0.4545077681541443, -0.9451379776000977, -0.796931266784668, -0.12225762009620667, -0.28162235021591187, 0.10941969603300095, -0.9382886290550232, -0.1695784479379654, 0.2717267572879791, 0.7670955061912537, -0.17936913669109344, -0.10423501580953598, 0.2049730122089386, 0.5255993008613586, 0.6363908052444458, -0.4734937250614166, 0.1850336641073227, -0.34874415397644043, -0.014999852515757084, -0.5113948583602905, -0.47433367371559143, 0.12147613614797592, -0.08706973493099213, -0.2701525390148163, -0.6238346695899963, 0.1435544341802597, -0.17574767768383026, -0.45438337326049805, 0.23627860844135284, 0.5398464798927307, -0.7811084985733032, -0.0044120741076767445, -0.32453441619873047, -0.09186342358589172, -0.7892764806747437, 1.4224683046340942, -0.14689071476459503, 0.019398892298340797, 0.8395079374313354, -0.28085628151893616, 0.31207579374313354, -0.7421280145645142, 4.119474411010742, 1.121588110923767, 0.7129905223846436, -1.0360528230667114, 1.1609858274459839, 0.6828041076660156, 0.40249404311180115, 0.19160081446170807, 0.11713887006044388, 0.09924939274787903, -0.7887383699417114, 0.7861714363098145, -0.5245929956436157, -0.3095022141933441, 0.49807363748550415, 0.12819047272205353, -0.4687982201576233, -0.1556590050458908, 0.22059611976146698, -0.4561644494533539, -0.7047754526138306, 0.49360015988349915, -0.12791652977466583, 0.31540173292160034, 0.03405548259615898, 0.2698845863342285, -0.14198635518550873, -0.4887484312057495, 0.5159119367599487, -0.2734234631061554, -0.23162393271923065, -0.26228126883506775, 0.39059993624687195, -1.1429702043533325, -0.3169458210468292, 0.45311835408210754, -0.47025662660598755, -0.2804822623729706, -0.0733867734670639, -0.9619284272193909, -0.10123804211616516, 0.2265126258134842, -0.25277474522590637, -0.0637718215584755, -0.7448513507843018, 0.3922402858734131, -0.14980179071426392, 0.23805689811706543, 0.24505189061164856, -0.6768801212310791, 1.1007956266403198, -0.9960212707519531, 0.431228905916214, -0.11932527273893356, -1.0261666774749756, -0.10511017590761185, -0.31289103627204895, -1.3443052768707275, 0.5075072646141052, 0.5920478701591492, 0.877702534198761, -0.17080572247505188, -0.46384093165397644, 0.7859322428703308, 0.6813404560089111, 0.9203779697418213, 0.38042792677879333, -0.49005812406539917, -0.13646145164966583, -0.1713702231645584, -0.2683413624763489, -0.0774027481675148, -0.1554913967847824, -0.41495636105537415, 0.9589150547981262, -0.1549852192401886, -0.4013364315032959, 0.2859399616718292, -0.2588087022304535, -0.2934381365776062, 0.1611052006483078, -0.05844876915216446, 1.0491026639938354, -0.9321889281272888, 0.538825273513794, 0.941373348236084, -0.6423474550247192, -0.35806983709335327, -0.8623742461204529, 0.6791127324104309, 0.3173726201057434, 0.007425006479024887, -0.18702028691768646, -0.09006168693304062, -0.2570769488811493 ]
{"Title": "Joint modelling of individual trajectories, within-individual variability and a later outcome: systolic blood pressure through childhood and left ventricular mass in early adulthood", "Authors": "Parker Richard M.A., Leckie George, Goldstein Harvey, Howe Laura D., Heron Jon, Hughes Alun D., Phillippo David M., Tilling Kate", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Within-individual variability of repeatedly-measured exposures may predict later outcomes: e.g. blood pressure (BP) variability (BPV) is an independent cardiovascular risk factor above and beyond mean BP. Since two-stage methods, known to introduce bias, are typically used to investigate such associations, we introduce a joint modelling approach, examining associations of both mean BP and BPV across childhood to left ventricular mass (indexed to height; LVMI) in early adulthood with data from the UK\u2019s Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC) cohort. Using multilevel models, we allow BPV to vary between individuals (a \u201crandom effect\u201d) as well as to depend on covariates (allowing for heteroscedasticity). We further distinguish within-clinic variability (\u201cmeasurement error\u201d) from visit-to-visit BPV. BPV was predicted to be greater at older ages, at higher bodyweights, and in females, and was positively correlated with mean BP. BPV had a positive association with LVMI (10% increase in SD(BP) was predicted to increase LVMI by mean = 0.42% (95% credible interval: \u22120.47%, 1.38%)), but this association became negative (mean = \u22121.56%, 95% credible interval: \u22125.01%, 0.44%)) once the effect of mean BP on LVMI was adjusted for. This joint modelling approach offers a flexible method of relating repeatedly-measured exposures to later outcomes.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008474"}
10.1101/2019.12.12.19014738
[ 0.22072099149227142, 0.44039386510849, 0.658848226070404, 1.6973628997802734, -0.10157488286495209, -0.47745373845100403, -0.8124989867210388, 0.36573198437690735, 0.3839995265007019, 0.8027309775352478, -0.07900885492563248, -0.3848479092121124, -0.31427472829818726, -0.2721673250198364, -0.03433026000857353, 0.6242477297782898, -0.145022451877594, 0.19137930870056152, 0.3492974042892456, 0.3079642355442047, -0.12015330791473389, 0.368976891040802, -0.8433645963668823, -0.8250912427902222, -0.6763401031494141, 0.13394880294799805, 0.2222105860710144, -0.0924999862909317, 0.48778149485588074, 0.8414230942726135, 0.6613190770149231, -0.5955551862716675, 0.41552460193634033, -0.6400704979896545, 0.10599758476018906, 0.4769670069217682, 1.2391374111175537, -0.8606035113334656, 0.4647623896598816, 0.509040117263794, 0.20585589110851288, 0.30519917607307434, 0.8055409789085388, -0.9065806865692139, -0.2347308248281479, -0.6347768902778625, -0.09915293753147125, 0.16407988965511322, -0.010346922092139721, 0.46056509017944336, -0.3090611398220062, -0.5257700681686401, -0.016907230019569397, -0.777733325958252, -0.29939979314804077, -0.2049235850572586, -0.38759663701057434, -0.7923418879508972, 0.38818222284317017, 0.5614147782325745, 0.7189463973045349, 0.20421336591243744, 0.5472255349159241, -0.6996719837188721, -0.05325406789779663, 0.5628643035888672, 0.13083641231060028, -0.3424627482891083, -0.0399511456489563, -0.507007360458374, -0.09898807108402252, -0.5170794129371643, -0.8788927793502808, 0.5323570370674133, -0.11364296078681946, -0.08201216161251068, -0.08385715633630753, -0.7122718095779419, 0.02076714113354683, -0.3617468774318695, -0.4247021973133087, 0.22639091312885284, 0.40916943550109863, -0.1877526342868805, -0.5170283317565918, 0.17823071777820587, 0.33040305972099304, -0.26339688897132874, 0.11698820441961288, -0.14547684788703918, -0.04936704784631729, 0.5921311378479004, -0.4057494103908539, 0.35095450282096863, 0.6876276135444641, 1.0911493301391602, 0.23160669207572937, -0.03730980306863785, 0.07756378501653671, -0.00958345364779234, 0.34416428208351135, 0.2235552817583084, -0.2302347868680954, 1.1084064245224, -0.5718061923980713, 0.21118776500225067, 0.42660579085350037, -0.46690261363983154, 0.6411433815956116, -0.9500066637992859, 0.22696036100387573, 0.12660637497901917, -0.03695358708500862, 0.031885601580142975, 0.36979758739471436, 0.30097144842147827, 0.3208320438861847, 0.5093420743942261, -0.36179351806640625, 1.4141727685928345, -0.5942272543907166, 0.2672359049320221, 0.5525614619255066, -0.606318473815918, 0.18437369167804718, -0.5450823903083801, 0.13756223022937775, 0.8455365300178528, -0.4319511950016022, -0.01716090366244316, -0.21420863270759583, -0.5887032151222229, 0.22020447254180908, 0.4892697036266327, -0.3745129406452179, -0.27495044469833374, 0.6417436599731445, 1.1228978633880615, 0.5810253620147705, -0.21417392790317535, -0.46787163615226746, 0.325889527797699, -0.37328270077705383, 0.54388028383255, -0.4614635407924652, 1.0503959655761719, -0.34899279475212097, -0.22233730554580688, 0.06299066543579102, 0.19006754457950592, -0.5592920184135437, 0.4559178352355957, -0.12713907659053802, 0.03287351131439209, -0.327755868434906, -0.22569967806339264, -0.13048222661018372, 0.4059739410877228, -0.7558857202529907, 0.30548253655433655, -0.6659143567085266, -0.1784447282552719, 0.05189328268170357, -0.5229562520980835, -0.6116084456443787, 0.42185887694358826, -0.3135203421115875, -0.3178090453147888, -0.6226353049278259, -0.634070873260498, 0.17245365679264069, 0.14332202076911926, 0.04432025924324989, 0.1512988656759262, 1.2617268562316895, 0.5952768921852112, 0.31446176767349243, -0.1509927213191986, 0.43155720829963684, 0.3081895411014557, -0.12189848721027374, 0.19574891030788422, 0.4762617349624634, 0.7321814298629761, -0.3383074700832367, 0.1759374588727951, -0.5449928641319275, -1.0551189184188843, 0.18566380441188812, -0.3791823983192444, 0.1831372231245041, 0.25511685013771057, -0.6229891777038574, 0.3873443305492401, 0.5284726023674011, 0.01962810941040516, -0.35307759046554565, -0.02276545763015747, 0.4790899157524109, -0.4489801824092865, 0.1710629016160965, -0.03607621416449547, -0.09347463399171829, -0.3868058919906616, -0.841073215007782, 0.6356578469276428, 1.0652259588241577, 1.2312450408935547, -0.47732362151145935, -0.16874513030052185, 0.7136548757553101, 0.2606879770755768, -0.3153846859931946, 0.036125317215919495, 0.2859312891960144, 0.1281036138534546, -0.8565528988838196, 0.33857184648513794, -0.8040493726730347, 0.029040222987532616, -0.6597800850868225, -0.867124617099762, 0.33888599276542664, 0.5990875959396362, 0.7964941263198853, -0.4055659770965576, 0.43934959173202515, 0.025740595534443855, -0.8982435464859009, -0.006753567140549421, 0.9881186485290527, -0.04685785993933678, -0.15293556451797485, 0.1310756504535675, 0.5287820100784302, -0.013584918342530727, 0.31603044271469116, 0.2487572580575943, 0.33619096875190735, 0.5670555830001831, 0.35657408833503723, 0.46511110663414, 0.7680198550224304, 0.44895344972610474, 0.18495582044124603, 0.707136869430542, 0.13187013566493988, -0.39484408497810364, 0.16824297606945038, 0.3387911021709442, -0.14740385115146637, 0.3046991229057312, -0.15931358933448792, 0.6989849209785461, -0.6348280906677246, 0.2032778263092041, 0.07222144305706024, -0.16349996626377106, -0.655236005783081, 0.056697648018598557, -0.11279413849115372, 0.26892855763435364, -0.10633181780576706, -0.5286315679550171, 0.04031328856945038, 1.3896199464797974, -0.22847338020801544, 0.4322819113731384, 0.03206389769911766, 0.4703811705112457, -0.45947009325027466, -0.3657265901565552, -0.6705532670021057, -0.3484143614768982, 0.29245641827583313, -0.009637434035539627, 0.02426677569746971, -0.4215054512023926, 0.086399145424366, -0.33873388171195984, 0.18574810028076172, 0.28417617082595825, 0.10435757040977478, -0.2781015634536743, -0.004626680165529251, -0.3702404499053955, -1.3225748538970947, -0.03872782737016678, 0.6561247706413269, 0.1456533819437027, -0.14208737015724182, -0.3468554615974426, -0.2424493134021759, -0.09283820539712906, -0.13432832062244415, -0.5550442337989807, 0.337618350982666, -0.5678750276565552, 0.12488465756177902, -0.5823310613632202, 0.2797856330871582, -0.07183485478162766, 0.12550760805606842, -0.6912240982055664, -0.5431365370750427, 0.3837754726409912, 0.1885083019733429, 0.17903879284858704, 0.3289796710014343, -0.15448088943958282, -0.40968236327171326, 0.6792620420455933, 0.03224024549126625, 0.31522756814956665, -0.5435798764228821, 0.34669607877731323, 0.5642605423927307, -0.4739665389060974, -0.0543433353304863, 0.1995456963777542, -0.187771737575531, -0.6303843259811401, -0.35306432843208313, -0.8000519275665283, -0.41765424609184265, 0.15428684651851654, 0.6302447319030762, -0.8134558796882629, 0.15610061585903168, -0.8623342514038086, -0.43452760577201843, -0.24953573942184448, -0.32659071683883667, 0.08634398132562637, -0.44064968824386597, -0.41896212100982666, -0.2920415699481964, -0.490399032831192, 0.16307592391967773, 0.6386378407478333, 0.7446704506874084, -0.8251433968544006, 0.13077905774116516, 0.26221364736557007, -0.09625444561243057, 0.6111165881156921, 0.1542007327079773, 0.49806928634643555, -0.5907506346702576, -0.08743498474359512, 0.11040254682302475, 0.4020802974700928, 0.35949596762657166, -0.17611189186573029, -0.0459803082048893, -0.0020896124187856913, -0.1907452791929245, 0.5085422992706299, 0.6001516580581665, -0.24675527215003967, 0.27150169014930725, 0.9859706163406372, -0.9921071529388428, 0.44515281915664673, -0.21271955966949463, -0.40882229804992676, 0.27313607931137085, -0.3127094805240631, 0.4906283915042877, -0.25664424896240234, 0.44790118932724, -0.5645879507064819, -0.2030113935470581, 0.541152834892273, -0.09703779220581055, -0.14495709538459778, 1.089111566543579, 0.4105471670627594, 1.166186809539795, -0.7977278232574463, 0.5242812633514404, 0.4295307397842407, 1.133411169052124, -0.04595358297228813, 0.35646843910217285, 0.282718300819397, 0.11785759776830673, -0.4903327524662018, 0.10422962158918381, -0.09502248466014862, -0.06592147797346115, -0.7093316316604614, -1.0372934341430664, -1.2068544626235962, -0.5559748411178589, -0.7955374121665955, -0.4842454493045807, 0.40152662992477417, 0.39735928177833557, 0.0021668823901563883, 1.1854887008666992, -0.7315172553062439, 0.3458043336868286, 0.028112120926380157, 0.7668641209602356, -0.2361985146999359, -1.194984793663025, 0.7203227877616882, -0.4736174941062927, -0.7526999711990356, -0.32418301701545715, -0.4100981056690216, 0.10055805742740631, -0.021627278998494148, 0.17545925080776215, 0.2790399491786957, -0.4125969409942627, -0.984840452671051, 0.30822232365608215, 0.5057292580604553, -0.13816101849079132, -0.11055734753608704, 0.18793386220932007, 0.4412144124507904, 0.004307344555854797, -0.8344588279724121, -0.03524404391646385, -0.4104898273944855, 0.12169193476438522, 0.6931700110435486, 0.5973713994026184, -0.7047621011734009, -0.011965504847466946, -0.48802000284194946, -0.9326470494270325, -0.1126236766576767, -0.43309131264686584, -0.27116116881370544, 0.612903356552124, -0.816461980342865, -0.13357175886631012, -0.6247667074203491, -0.26585307717323303, -0.5839402079582214, 0.8222914338111877, 0.28925731778144836, 0.41780805587768555, 0.9152117371559143, 0.19894887506961823, 0.16665922105312347, 0.17314235866069794, -0.5721573233604431, 0.549105703830719, -0.6277943253517151, -1.0580040216445923, 0.4029865860939026, 0.5967965722084045, -0.8061662912368774, 0.21387065947055817, -0.3669051229953766, 0.13917048275470734, -0.12217213213443756, -0.04243617132306099, -0.4626232981681824, -0.33278772234916687, 1.0894891023635864, -1.3717961311340332, -0.41152989864349365, 0.9917858839035034, -0.9413409233093262, 0.7271747589111328, -0.3566747307777405, -0.7916939854621887, -0.6445190906524658, 0.2541452944278717, -0.04114009439945221, 0.9524261951446533, 0.35478800535202026, -0.44215887784957886, 0.35211822390556335, 0.3399369716644287, 0.039747413247823715, -0.4041455090045929, -0.016591090708971024, -1.0178111791610718, -0.7151622176170349, -0.10106317698955536, 0.4638555347919464, 0.16583409905433655, 0.44785937666893005, 0.3172190189361572, 0.03414396941661835, -0.6161251068115234, -0.5772883892059326, -0.7462680339813232, 0.3684328496456146, -0.4886871576309204, 0.16003267467021942, -0.33286046981811523, -0.05959010869264603, 0.01889192871749401, -0.8814947605133057, -0.6872321367263794, -0.08262518048286438, 0.33814480900764465, -0.3242701590061188, -0.6367546319961548, 0.03318540006875992, -0.4199772775173187, 0.45643341541290283, -0.2691250443458557, 0.07296498864889145, -1.3885183334350586, 0.7011514902114868, -0.24244867265224457, -0.9117801785469055, 0.05496075749397278, -0.4326961040496826, 0.09148171544075012, 0.06833858788013458, 0.1077323779463768, -0.9884269833564758, -0.10771811753511429, 0.7474383115768433, 0.0875139981508255, -0.06286895275115967, 0.07873256504535675, -0.13393664360046387, -0.31041374802589417, -0.6429871916770935, -0.06969387829303741, -0.4612495005130768, -0.6307886242866516, -0.07965527474880219, 0.2554048001766205, 0.4248209595680237, 0.06221385672688484, -0.003864363767206669, 0.44097474217414856, 0.5647450089454651, 0.07439260184764862, -0.034158963710069656, 0.34865817427635193, -0.4115689992904663, -0.023180659860372543, -1.0070348978042603, 0.35441598296165466, 0.19141563773155212, 0.7824873328208923, -0.09403136372566223, -0.37766963243484497, -0.2528672218322754, 0.2601820230484009, 0.22024574875831604, -0.23617713153362274, -0.4376121759414673, 0.03483129292726517, 0.343487948179245, -0.23743294179439545, -0.24838805198669434, -0.6829169392585754, 1.0829081535339355, -0.5250324606895447, 0.454231858253479, -0.17636612057685852, -0.7028988003730774, 0.018435386940836906, -0.5828306078910828, 0.741213321685791, -1.0646971464157104, 0.1082732081413269, 0.22885768115520477, -0.049483977258205414, -0.40546125173568726, 0.42135265469551086, -0.5308792591094971, 0.2696019113063812, 0.13720741868019104, -0.5998098254203796, 0.7460258603096008, 0.14538343250751495, -0.0018603324424475431, 0.11167169362306595, 0.5024901628494263, 0.9312173128128052, -1.1255741119384766, 0.7934850454330444, 1.3417850732803345, -0.19124318659305573, 0.12383459508419037, -0.3373055160045624, 0.6775131225585938, 0.5243027210235596, 0.42550840973854065, 0.40264999866485596, 0.08477853238582611, 0.146210178732872, 0.1820763647556305, -1.005327820777893, -0.7416814565658569, -0.3663497567176819, -0.06346786022186279, 0.9355888366699219, 0.1784546822309494, 0.5204852819442749, -0.0635635107755661, -0.5134351849555969, -0.4101385176181793, 0.23719115555286407, -0.373310923576355, 0.6800094842910767, 0.4600781798362732, -0.3038642108440399, -0.5312831401824951, -0.03724931925535202, 0.18465091288089752, 0.2822805345058441, -0.5014590620994568, 0.3428778648376465, -0.5027412176132202, -0.9440140128135681, -0.17320232093334198, -0.05066881701350212, 0.3411925137042999, 0.0027376224752515554, 0.1347314417362213, -0.4134857952594757, 1.23524808883667, -0.35320162773132324, -0.8419293761253357, -0.5372888445854187, -0.2278519868850708, 0.19346483051776886, 0.10674835741519928, -0.17934930324554443, 0.17993412911891937, -0.3458716869354248, 0.1876792460680008, -0.756227970123291, 0.19398100674152374, -0.29546424746513367, -0.07129917293787003, 0.482553094625473, -0.4068204462528229, -0.33455514907836914, 0.6297835111618042, -0.5416133403778076, 0.724989652633667, -0.6898501515388489, -0.1639896035194397, -0.09892269223928452, -0.5499228239059448, 0.2885246276855469, 0.39168691635131836, 0.010276646353304386, 0.3098965287208557, -0.09035283327102661, -0.46078652143478394, -0.17492109537124634, -0.39196908473968506, -0.04050501063466072, 1.0137094259262085, -0.7551460266113281, -0.18049676716327667, 0.7946591973304749, 0.4124067425727844, 0.8035085797309875, -0.9936583042144775, -0.674491822719574, -0.345410019159317, 0.27704957127571106, 0.37480321526527405, 0.21500110626220703, -0.6496129631996155, 0.64325350522995, 0.282105028629303, -0.6762731671333313, -0.4057176411151886, 0.8569763898849487, -0.807385265827179, 0.29981985688209534, -0.16254307329654694, -0.5118513107299805, 0.3647271692752838, -0.2846952974796295, 0.4444124698638916, -0.1931474208831787, 0.12378468364477158, 0.2597377598285675, -0.4705302119255066, 0.16260577738285065, 0.3061228096485138, 0.26371896266937256, 0.2809320390224457, -0.10025230795145035, -0.30463534593582153, -0.8889194130897522, 0.7408789992332458, -0.059371206909418106, -0.13814625144004822, 0.17258015275001526, 0.6210557818412781, -0.9905761480331421, -0.20434071123600006, 0.11478640884160995, -0.12394572794437408, 0.0587068572640419, -0.00037343858275562525, 0.4837692677974701, 0.004371945280581713, -1.3316015005111694, 0.21653519570827484, 0.15250460803508759, -0.9762696027755737, -0.3432528078556061, -1.117618441581726, 0.661363959312439, -0.6295053958892822, -0.25223833322525024, -0.028871668502688408, 0.2836824357509613, 0.428026407957077, 0.6082558035850525, -0.4893411099910736, 0.9877049922943115, 0.5546864867210388, -0.13004665076732635, 0.9915906190872192, -0.11497557163238525, 0.2961287796497345, -1.296779990196228, 0.3336957097053528, 0.40074169635772705, -0.5425379872322083, 0.5775936841964722, -0.2488989382982254, -0.541139543056488, 0.2149890512228012, -0.42813071608543396, -0.63116455078125, 0.5689504146575928, -0.2993370592594147, 0.7039130330085754, 0.09691279381513596, -0.1100950762629509, -0.40365028381347656, -0.603144109249115, -1.1879421472549438, 0.14459948241710663, 0.6244803071022034, -0.22025416791439056, 0.1755622923374176, -0.30782464146614075, -0.9187287092208862, 0.3690255582332611, -0.1278344988822937, 0.39291107654571533, 0.31364768743515015, 0.34162238240242004, -0.06353673338890076, 0.8216134309768677, 0.47320830821990967, 0.191211998462677, 0.38397490978240967, -0.053537942469120026, -1.0695838928222656, -0.44490107893943787, 0.6404808759689331, 1.2831827402114868, -0.2148982733488083, 0.10691221058368683, -0.33240047097206116, -0.6492645144462585, -0.004397641401737928, -0.22501729428768158, 0.04403502866625786, 0.21158823370933533, -0.8961876630783081, 0.20551644265651703, -0.08491738140583038, 0.10492222011089325, -0.5265369415283203, 0.27062326669692993, -0.3449380099773407, -0.5000783205032349, -0.7401778697967529, -0.6360973119735718, 1.2326070070266724, -0.10779853165149689, 0.2324511557817459, 0.39344358444213867, 0.27671825885772705, -0.4431818425655365, 0.333088219165802, -0.01416375394910574, 1.0188322067260742, 0.08827842026948929, 0.5256796479225159, 0.11969343572854996, 0.6489723324775696, 0.5836525559425354, 0.693885087966919, 0.3629506230354309, 0.18901188671588898, -0.1483735740184784, -0.32477790117263794, -0.18887603282928467, -0.795028805732727, 0.4961678385734558, -0.5881823897361755, -0.04983091726899147, -0.019261697307229042, -0.5810141563415527, 0.8133763670921326, -0.20922249555587769, -0.28760483860969543, 0.4291130304336548, -0.8834443688392639, -0.5909233689308167, -0.09331897646188736, 0.5860472321510315, 0.3013298213481903, 0.480806827545166, 0.16125068068504333, 0.6290760636329651, 0.682034432888031, -0.16021862626075745, 0.11697077006101608, 0.33598995208740234, -0.23911939561367035, -0.06294682621955872, 0.145979642868042, 0.4033747613430023, -0.3956364393234253, 0.016969425603747368, -0.4097937345504761, 0.07178335636854172, 0.2817210555076599, 0.768482506275177, -0.4521147608757019, 0.8035758137702942, 0.7931210398674011, 0.33293506503105164, -0.2876879572868347, 0.17857259511947632, 0.820002019405365, -0.31469276547431946, -0.8892949223518372, 0.8719757795333862, 0.17190854251384735, -0.5561313033103943, 0.41605299711227417, 0.1556641012430191, 0.1531691998243332, 0.3308474123477936, 0.49450406432151794, -0.2996695637702942, 1.0618618726730347, 0.7010648846626282, -0.5337244272232056, 0.2880404591560364, -0.3560656011104584, -0.4082217216491699, -0.06062167137861252, -0.619565486907959, 0.06787902861833572, 0.03665908798575401, -0.22058959305286407, -0.09095890820026398, 0.7806900143623352, -0.48325422406196594, -0.07429122924804688, -0.3111228942871094, 0.5058562755584717, -0.32312512397766113, 0.5784062147140503, -1.2082396745681763, 0.7237899899482727, -0.4170966148376465, -0.4162231981754303, -0.1038617417216301, -0.28558599948883057, 0.20648856461048126, 0.10648731887340546, -0.0739540159702301, 0.6192038655281067, -0.27139735221862793, -0.8520939350128174, -0.7920074462890625, -1.45661461353302, -0.07553232461214066, 0.14717042446136475, -0.668272852897644, -0.6734782457351685, -0.07920684665441513, 0.13292279839515686, 0.5040889382362366, 0.30645570158958435, 0.46256929636001587, -0.263100802898407, 0.7657399773597717, 0.5852195024490356, 0.0787753090262413, 0.46679219603538513, 0.7372256517410278, 0.18750697374343872, 0.2827353775501251, 0.18565447628498077, 0.28630444407463074, -0.6330912709236145, -0.24768590927124023, -0.5422834753990173, -0.03165459260344505, -0.28224918246269226, -0.5398349761962891, 0.3601471185684204, 0.7874568104743958, -0.25162631273269653, -0.17143034934997559, -0.9848502278327942, -0.5690234303474426, -0.5471267104148865, 1.4848695993423462, 0.1935698539018631, 0.11713797599077225, -0.2890911400318146, 0.024160847067832947, -0.06177670508623123, -0.5196774005889893, 4.174402713775635, 0.26327791810035706, 0.005175954662263393, 0.12890183925628662, 0.42073854804039, -0.13301712274551392, 1.3118747472763062, 0.22307856380939484, 0.365810364484787, 0.25023728609085083, -0.7590208649635315, -0.9991708397865295, 0.5327199697494507, 0.040601130574941635, 0.7562808394432068, 0.33782845735549927, -0.672532856464386, 0.14826644957065582, 0.005474621430039406, -1.3366299867630005, -0.30937644839286804, 0.10924416035413742, -0.0811924934387207, 0.6418870687484741, 0.19061551988124847, -0.14042218029499054, 0.5344945192337036, -0.37304213643074036, 0.8215664029121399, -0.32701799273490906, -0.03814342990517616, -0.9007683992385864, -0.3653302788734436, -0.7151508331298828, -0.9760500192642212, 0.611629068851471, 0.1877661645412445, -0.4923373758792877, -0.4454900920391083, -0.4024845063686371, -0.10539589822292328, 0.4093145430088043, -0.5400288105010986, -0.21269814670085907, -0.1423591673374176, 0.7008545994758606, -0.59854656457901, 0.23162254691123962, 1.1126028299331665, -0.4980096220970154, 1.072677731513977, -0.30806782841682434, 0.43614402413368225, 0.6746683716773987, -1.0166363716125488, 0.08866142481565475, -0.2035541534423828, -0.8394019603729248, 0.008410862646996975, -0.16301091015338898, 0.706585168838501, -0.2109689861536026, 0.2565799355506897, 0.014651752077043056, 0.5679094791412354, -0.04081180319190025, 0.5906790494918823, -0.6446983218193054, 0.5520273447036743, -0.21251428127288818, -0.033033981919288635, -0.08332256972789764, 0.026797544211149216, -0.1602802872657776, 0.14345017075538635, 0.2486926019191742, -0.43328869342803955, 0.3071861267089844, -0.29679030179977417, -0.4895431697368622, -0.09570753574371338, -0.8776510953903198, -0.40965133905410767, 0.12203007191419601, -0.01775924488902092, 0.8392107486724854, -0.12799301743507385, -0.4678364098072052, 0.07038664072751999, 0.4024280607700348, -0.3113541603088379, -0.0724499449133873, -0.27673929929733276, -0.12686040997505188, -0.19518356025218964 ]
{"Title": "Temporal trends in public mass shootings: high-capacity magazines significantly increase fatality counts, and are becoming more prevalent", "Authors": "Towers Sherry, Wallace Danielle, Hemenway David", "Abstract": "Abstract Background There has been disagreement in the literature regarding whether public mass shootings are becoming more frequent, or more deadly, and whether high-capacity magazine (HCM) weaponry is associated with increased fatalities. Objective We examined the 85 non-felony- and non-gang-related mass shootings with at least four people shot and killed that occurred in public places between 1995 to 2018 to examine the frequency and deadliness of public mass shootings, as well as the role of HCM weaponry in fatalities. Findings The per-capita rate of public mass shootings with at least four people killed has not significantly increased since 1995 (Negative Binomial linear regression p=0.20), but public mass shootings with at least six people killed have been increasing by 6.9% per year (p=0.01). Public mass shootings are becoming significantly more deadly, with fatalities per incident increasing by 4.5% per year (truncated Negative Binomial log-linear regression p<0.001). Use of HCM weaponry banned during the 1994 to 2004 Federal Assault Weapons Ban (FAWB) increased fatality counts on average by 1.9 times, and total number shot by 3.3 times (non-parametric bootstrap comparison of means (NPBCM), p < 0.001 in both cases). In these incidents, HCM pistols were as deadly as assault rifles. The fraction of firearms involving HCMs used by perpetrators more than doubled after the lapse of the federal ban, from 25% during the ban to 59% after (Binomial factor regression, p<0.001). Our online visual analytics application, https://mass-shooting-analytics.shinyapps.io/mass_shootings/ , allows interested parties to examine and download our data, replicate our analysis results and explore the analysis with alternate selections. Policy recommendations A re-instatement of the federal ban on high-capacity magazines in pistols and rifles, or special taxes on such weaponry, may reduce public mass shooting fatalities.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.12.19014738"}
10.1101/19012179
[ -0.03197265416383743, 0.18515494465827942, -0.4210531711578369, 0.334713876247406, -0.9960470199584961, -0.07063236087560654, -0.6773291826248169, 0.5198334455490112, 0.2687917947769165, 1.0058451890945435, -1.1151890754699707, -0.5713174939155579, 0.4965747594833374, 0.2415454238653183, -0.014572624117136002, -0.36249783635139465, -0.6438153982162476, -0.29024559259414673, -0.3979669213294983, 0.48747560381889343, 0.22224213182926178, 1.2222862243652344, -0.21758131682872772, -0.19380944967269897, -0.7879196405410767, 0.33876684308052063, -0.22744359076023102, -0.2308725267648697, 0.9257224202156067, 1.1196013689041138, -0.01218768022954464, -0.3462674021720886, 0.7158606052398682, -0.7098180651664734, -0.37305355072021484, -0.09474088251590729, 0.02169877104461193, -0.07415661215782166, -0.25661012530326843, -1.2051162719726562, 0.5037893652915955, -0.4918387234210968, 0.40866994857788086, -0.7910177111625671, -0.07359839975833893, -0.30507421493530273, -0.8234769701957703, -0.7410202026367188, 0.25054731965065, 0.418693482875824, -0.3542749583721161, 0.3118564784526825, 0.6135087013244629, -0.057966671884059906, -0.6499667167663574, -0.03128490224480629, -0.22473205626010895, -0.07389473170042038, -0.3864973783493042, -0.36201223731040955, -0.04944207891821861, 0.04777166619896889, 0.2253233939409256, -0.9099006056785583, 0.9097137451171875, 1.1543337106704712, 0.24639101326465607, -0.5162670612335205, 0.38419046998023987, 0.7993069887161255, -0.2828373610973358, -0.0010797115974128246, -0.41901740431785583, -1.2356889247894287, -0.7049998044967651, -0.43617528676986694, 0.3292723298072815, -0.05942049250006676, 0.353288471698761, -0.22663195431232452, 0.2647818326950073, 0.3712964355945587, 0.35360604524612427, 0.01059694029390812, -0.597933828830719, 0.7899116277694702, 0.15885744988918304, 0.7902811765670776, -0.16787859797477722, -0.08369230479001999, 0.670329213142395, 0.008787755854427814, 0.621013343334198, -0.3738653063774109, 0.20515750348567963, 0.917249858379364, -0.3788246214389801, 0.6757140159606934, 0.32253298163414, 0.004406220279633999, 0.6299081444740295, 0.30183732509613037, -0.3502970337867737, 0.7438839077949524, -0.3149726688861847, 0.7498337626457214, 0.6307539343833923, -0.3388392925262451, -0.3855612576007843, 0.00415989151224494, 0.6338546872138977, -0.2443763166666031, -0.5667179822921753, -0.06874489039182663, 0.6008887887001038, -0.1516748070716858, -0.22231082618236542, 0.3285652995109558, -0.2603684961795807, -0.05777684226632118, 0.006270322948694229, -0.4864874482154846, 0.010046533308923244, -0.5184527039527893, -0.13069409132003784, 0.6165717840194702, 0.06755150109529495, 0.3046533167362213, -0.7951319217681885, -0.0004712537338491529, -0.2568291425704956, -0.42776232957839966, -0.1423061639070511, 1.3137279748916626, -0.03554517775774002, -0.1816091388463974, 0.15418653190135956, 0.5121576189994812, 0.12419147789478302, -0.7686737775802612, -0.1439324915409088, 0.36268964409828186, -1.0551453828811646, 1.261303186416626, -0.015090267173945904, 1.0586644411087036, -0.4003744125366211, -1.7831958532333374, -0.38256579637527466, 0.11264748871326447, -0.6448309421539307, 0.47348108887672424, -0.08537560701370239, -0.2902158200740814, 0.17658783495426178, 0.8621604442596436, 0.14812743663787842, 0.1087113469839096, -0.5229900479316711, -0.15749110281467438, 0.08409202098846436, 0.01797161065042019, 0.07358933985233307, 0.5636881589889526, -0.31737756729125977, 0.34689462184906006, -0.17103607952594757, -0.10324177145957947, 0.3912440538406372, -0.7498599886894226, 1.3309857845306396, -0.4282888174057007, -0.686672568321228, 0.17483878135681152, 0.28507664799690247, 0.8558894991874695, 0.7828205227851868, -0.10271145403385162, 0.4681675434112549, 0.4208749234676361, 0.35466238856315613, 0.051854219287633896, 0.13160821795463562, 0.11111350357532501, -0.06454961746931076, 0.325874000787735, -0.23445084691047668, -1.1527988910675049, 0.04866601899266243, -0.05974752455949783, -0.1619529277086258, -0.04030768945813179, 0.36262208223342896, 0.028708089143037796, -0.10874683409929276, -0.05880320444703102, -0.4586707353591919, 0.7558255195617676, -0.32884228229522705, -0.5847240090370178, -0.4734303653240204, 0.7016063928604126, -0.07549294084310532, 0.029566729441285133, 0.208593487739563, 0.9008408784866333, 0.1470416635274887, -0.03631303831934929, -0.4657632112503052, 0.5428500771522522, 0.39589032530784607, -0.4774581789970398, -0.2810060381889343, -0.2558111250400543, 0.74062579870224, -0.41927844285964966, -0.5690444707870483, 0.6710918545722961, -1.2460644245147705, 0.4501931071281433, -0.304120808839798, -0.23439384996891022, 0.5538839101791382, 0.36855295300483704, -0.26833653450012207, 0.13851168751716614, 1.152929425239563, 0.2807987630367279, 0.09830199182033539, -0.3176107704639435, -0.10208231955766678, 1.0098209381103516, -0.2471405267715454, 0.8499589562416077, 0.43028706312179565, 0.1403343826532364, -0.1518511176109314, 0.09294865280389786, 0.2966766655445099, 0.3245105445384979, 0.1685694307088852, -0.12039786577224731, 0.5698900818824768, 0.671274721622467, -0.23847602307796478, 1.2161790132522583, 0.08182231336832047, -0.4331008195877075, -0.14966535568237305, 0.19502680003643036, -1.0694643259048462, 0.9778895974159241, 0.430309534072876, -0.19729195535182953, -0.5864327549934387, 0.6951020956039429, 0.877907395362854, 0.09359873086214066, -0.411257266998291, -0.4694940745830536, -0.5385614633560181, 0.4608885645866394, -0.8565313816070557, -0.4137342870235443, 0.4636188745498657, 1.064004898071289, 0.017175370827317238, 0.47484853863716125, 0.08209396153688431, -0.11790809035301208, -1.1192803382873535, -0.34934666752815247, -1.3589565753936768, -0.49234893918037415, -1.2286700010299683, 0.29639995098114014, 0.4419037103652954, -0.13575492799282074, 0.09277267009019852, -0.2508760094642639, 0.31874704360961914, -0.21290084719657898, -0.5390315055847168, 0.6553288698196411, 0.6572492718696594, 0.07440365105867386, -0.25578543543815613, 0.03530488535761833, 0.08862699568271637, 0.24619267880916595, -0.3428388833999634, -0.7054165601730347, -0.9450234770774841, -0.4660780131816864, 0.8662585020065308, -0.8463596701622009, 0.3354926109313965, 0.003686552634462714, -0.14692983031272888, 0.1525837928056717, 1.058872103691101, -0.15516957640647888, 0.6856937408447266, 0.032812658697366714, -0.42212918400764465, 0.8590185046195984, 0.061773765832185745, 0.10470158606767654, 0.29095908999443054, 0.2489369958639145, -0.35865703225135803, 0.688471794128418, 0.24943983554840088, -0.10866253077983856, -0.8330691456794739, 0.19083869457244873, 0.5762309432029724, 0.20208752155303955, 0.014458248391747475, -1.0620086193084717, -1.0791252851486206, 0.3721219301223755, -0.18442264199256897, -0.7005597352981567, 0.16687576472759247, 0.09864241629838943, -0.028404010459780693, -1.6632332801818848, 0.5320137739181519, -0.4795907437801361, -0.8529534935951233, -0.19905009865760803, 0.269601434469223, 0.9447718858718872, 0.1280817687511444, 0.5782325267791748, -0.42609483003616333, 0.0576850064098835, 0.06691398471593857, -0.0010105733526870608, -0.28987783193588257, -0.41467463970184326, 0.4288054406642914, 0.37030357122421265, -0.13444118201732635, 0.6238940358161926, -0.007759592495858669, -0.11950050294399261, -0.29302501678466797, -0.005025969352573156, -0.22385923564434052, 0.504774808883667, 0.13358032703399658, 0.6645587682723999, -0.27610883116722107, 0.5530917048454285, 0.2508937120437622, 0.2333783507347107, 0.42087721824645996, 0.14316581189632416, 0.04978594183921814, 0.5848227143287659, 0.18141959607601166, 0.4735058546066284, -0.8631376624107361, -0.48480427265167236, 0.0165555477142334, 0.1461905688047409, 0.20860813558101654, -0.1422201693058014, 0.43625563383102417, 0.0791466161608696, -0.33853840827941895, -0.1441454440355301, -0.04671809822320938, 0.05060621351003647, 0.5757370591163635, 0.5388770699501038, 1.2758753299713135, -0.4040461480617523, 0.4553643763065338, 0.7913787364959717, 0.5275507569313049, 0.07363719493150711, -0.3330061435699463, 0.48678138852119446, -1.4622821807861328, 0.5251714587211609, 0.45436617732048035, -0.20031745731830597, -0.3323041796684265, -0.5142338275909424, 0.012726334854960442, 0.41242149472236633, -0.5541991591453552, -0.5147822499275208, -0.9716324806213379, 0.4094555675983429, 0.5829845070838928, 0.37354612350463867, 1.0835286378860474, -0.024312134832143784, 0.2372206300497055, 0.5650489926338196, 0.6401656866073608, 0.23395833373069763, -0.5993545651435852, 0.22820354998111725, -0.1788058876991272, -1.1282655000686646, 0.5500026345252991, -0.40568435192108154, 0.04477999731898308, -0.8415302038192749, 0.22447967529296875, -0.36079803109169006, 0.06532228738069534, 0.4625348150730133, -0.9869166016578674, 0.15599425137043, 0.11215928196907043, -0.2994823157787323, 0.05809034779667854, 0.025918398052453995, 0.020943742245435715, -0.20772087574005127, -0.3066176772117615, -0.4047648310661316, 0.5032957792282104, 1.087973952293396, -0.6906143426895142, -1.118577241897583, -0.7342629432678223, -0.6488361358642578, -0.11721158027648926, 0.39430946111679077, 0.498722106218338, 0.07938168942928314, 0.028473081067204475, 0.20602300763130188, -0.06515126675367355, -0.1890062838792801, -0.5231622457504272, -0.056123051792383194, -0.3740762770175934, 0.04763176292181015, 0.7435758709907532, 0.43632033467292786, 0.8975501656532288, -0.3227025866508484, 0.4483535885810852, -0.8827971816062927, 0.4399578869342804, -0.9532508850097656, -0.41213536262512207, -0.6230740547180176, -0.35506629943847656, 0.27270376682281494, 0.3343939185142517, -0.22563132643699646, -0.7932671308517456, -0.1957099735736847, 0.33318743109703064, 0.18478171527385712, -0.2842070758342743, 0.36586448550224304, -0.9146775007247925, 0.37077102065086365, 1.7054764032363892, -0.516121506690979, -0.027810854837298393, 0.5570170879364014, 0.6539368033409119, -1.0495171546936035, -0.06402617692947388, 0.11114075034856796, 0.6042260527610779, 0.6040096879005432, -0.4734123647212982, 0.404051810503006, -0.5722107291221619, 0.2842753529548645, -0.9395968317985535, 0.1711938977241516, 0.09473929554224014, -0.41579708456993103, -0.20996879041194916, 0.18737535178661346, -0.9006438851356506, 0.24537329375743866, -0.7350608706474304, -0.9575710296630859, -0.0249673780053854, 0.1575605720281601, -0.1761378049850464, -1.0697110891342163, -0.28095000982284546, -0.12513577938079834, -0.08360787481069565, -0.21724247932434082, 0.2458399087190628, -0.6414366364479065, -0.7294872403144836, 0.3244886100292206, 0.4749750792980194, -0.5426450371742249, -0.265127569437027, -0.1400488168001175, -0.06990909576416016, -0.4539600610733032, -0.7096107602119446, 0.199046328663826, -0.30204901099205017, -0.4523475468158722, 0.05116249993443489, -0.519193172454834, 0.4403764307498932, -0.08870840072631836, -0.15458793938159943, 1.2410098314285278, 0.13418112695217133, -0.9663353562355042, -0.07879776507616043, 0.710359513759613, 0.19442808628082275, 0.4816913604736328, -0.04951153323054314, 0.024449702352285385, -0.48958465456962585, -0.5788639783859253, 0.6555045247077942, 0.08422016352415085, 0.332296758890152, -0.01738583669066429, -0.4236251413822174, -0.31945255398750305, 0.24997462332248688, -0.2695724666118622, 0.08945002406835556, -0.2931317090988159, -0.7380528450012207, 0.8084763884544373, -0.1926184743642807, -0.09541827440261841, -0.19888541102409363, -1.1274725198745728, 0.8922895789146423, 0.27840667963027954, -0.1600138545036316, -0.39121538400650024, -0.09591302275657654, 0.49270927906036377, 0.495841383934021, -0.3909739553928375, -0.5268227458000183, -1.1569918394088745, -0.18863995373249054, 0.33704087138175964, -0.12511523067951202, -0.2445303201675415, -0.7313935160636902, 0.3740379810333252, -0.38151291012763977, 0.04548799991607666, -0.17662015557289124, 0.0745006799697876, 0.6875743865966797, -0.05456370860338211, 0.9294363856315613, -0.5423616766929626, 0.865965723991394, 0.3655930757522583, 0.18001477420330048, -0.797646701335907, 0.8138015270233154, 0.04018980264663696, -1.027408242225647, -1.0788925886154175, -0.7241965532302856, 0.5918318033218384, -0.5927262902259827, 0.068680040538311, 0.48659747838974, -0.5404133200645447, -0.15511998534202576, -0.2677680552005768, 1.2564846277236938, 1.141681432723999, -0.3417850732803345, -0.4023726284503937, 0.43600642681121826, 0.327804297208786, 0.32359108328819275, 0.22632357478141785, 0.21105249226093292, -0.30334728956222534, -0.0873785987496376, -0.5669721961021423, -0.23435312509536743, -0.7688663601875305, -0.09616965800523758, 0.20734409987926483, 0.11741907894611359, -0.3179996907711029, 0.10330844670534134, 0.47816771268844604, -0.3127721846103668, -0.7125183343887329, 0.8941709399223328, 0.050623174756765366, 1.0990252494812012, 0.8675246238708496, -0.9799731969833374, -0.4925398528575897, 0.752225399017334, 0.2428419589996338, -0.3351433575153351, -0.06531114876270294, 0.1522616595029831, 0.4014095366001129, -1.1207860708236694, 0.17655225098133087, 0.15426285564899445, -0.3796742856502533, -0.016271503642201424, 0.5423688292503357, -0.3043799102306366, -0.28959140181541443, -0.026282792910933495, -0.8092845678329468, 1.1808115243911743, 0.1483398973941803, 0.8004919290542603, -0.06084364652633667, 0.2972671389579773, 0.09729927033185959, -0.8441526889801025, -0.6592058539390564, -0.2197880893945694, 0.09896838665008545, 0.36230403184890747, 0.03641914576292038, -0.4033660590648651, 0.4445554316043854, 0.33727917075157166, -0.1535215824842453, 0.7243883609771729, 0.05149783939123154, -0.3669760525226593, -0.08069923520088196, -0.15841911733150482, 0.45999443531036377, -0.23628561198711395, -0.06702709197998047, -0.5391896963119507, 0.502033531665802, 0.7744174003601074, -0.7214176654815674, -0.7996426820755005, 0.13092541694641113, 0.3504728674888611, -0.0180891752243042, 0.393698126077652, -0.03801361098885536, 0.6695731282234192, -0.08860266953706741, 0.061200160533189774, -0.12761612236499786, -0.37213581800460815, -0.14043083786964417, -0.17073626816272736, 0.039145052433013916, 0.5988141894340515, 0.058995358645915985, 0.36096304655075073, -0.06850595027208328, -0.5345277190208435, 0.457032173871994, 0.7367599606513977, 0.019927265122532845, 0.34727942943573, -0.3896511495113373, 0.5421819090843201, -0.9470807313919067, -1.0942648649215698, -0.4178299903869629, 0.14268074929714203, 0.05286276340484619, 0.65484619140625, -0.6746683120727539, -0.22113406658172607, -0.19151951372623444, 0.09339301288127899, -0.16745416820049286, 0.5347872972488403, -0.24218758940696716, -0.26391682028770447, -0.7359662652015686, 0.05360788479447365, 0.26319319009780884, -0.6966136693954468, 1.0652509927749634, -0.2328825742006302, 0.2373354732990265, 0.15648315846920013, 0.34960347414016724, 0.04708738252520561, 0.21917569637298584, 0.9312070608139038, -0.39165008068084717, -0.2811373472213745, -0.6123565435409546, 0.04268811270594597, -0.9511064291000366, 0.6545711159706116, -0.48075515031814575, -0.3448347747325897, 0.09950391948223114, 0.9696470499038696, -0.11688954383134842, 0.42962929606437683, -0.12819048762321472, -0.16808658838272095, 0.049923352897167206, 0.6394661068916321, 1.0689998865127563, 0.06750427186489105, 0.48742201924324036, 0.4473865330219269, 0.02662367932498455, -0.892779529094696, 0.7780645489692688, 0.80240398645401, -0.04138212651014328, 0.41986656188964844, 0.11131812632083893, 0.7674810290336609, 0.31916582584381104, -0.11269040405750275, -0.11813255399465561, 0.7960737943649292, 0.270138680934906, 1.1564114093780518, -0.23644377291202545, -0.06604357063770294, -0.36261844635009766, -0.27487924695014954, -0.9482098817825317, 0.016565484926104546, 0.5192073583602905, -0.34722164273262024, -0.9719482660293579, -0.9649993777275085, -0.9808969497680664, 0.7960991859436035, 0.6017714142799377, 0.03567211702466011, -0.34157460927963257, -0.08845079690217972, 0.48676642775535583, 0.5846413373947144, 0.02287621796131134, -0.7464439868927002, -0.9367807507514954, 0.38789892196655273, -0.01892269402742386, -0.3191816806793213, 0.31637245416641235, -0.22994068264961243, 0.789713978767395, -0.5459606051445007, -0.44188469648361206, 0.36430731415748596, 0.34218499064445496, -0.645298957824707, -0.6285809278488159, -0.41331762075424194, -1.148510217666626, -0.11597302556037903, 0.1443641632795334, 0.37237805128097534, -0.8596563935279846, 0.22765862941741943, -0.44296616315841675, -0.7675063610076904, -0.23877713084220886, 0.27402549982070923, 0.3425242602825165, -0.6271616816520691, 0.09082628786563873, -0.1353600174188614, 0.31076014041900635, -0.49451595544815063, -0.7283626794815063, 1.16608464717865, 0.0789828896522522, 0.24309265613555908, -0.4030954837799072, -0.49144163727760315, 0.3153769075870514, 1.1494503021240234, 0.41879478096961975, 0.3556447923183441, 0.9790005087852478, -0.7056494951248169, 0.4717548191547394, 0.2879801094532013, -1.3848437070846558, 0.5197275280952454, -0.3310779631137848, -0.1983158141374588, 0.05773729085922241, 0.7813282012939453, 0.3727762699127197, 0.0148899732157588, -0.9187390208244324, 0.43867743015289307, -0.9281839728355408, -0.2976527810096741, -0.13478559255599976, 0.07259165495634079, 0.7036399841308594, 0.43864259123802185, 0.9808155298233032, 0.4637956917285919, 0.8561804294586182, 0.24210688471794128, -0.2818160355091095, -0.29265454411506653, -0.9664608240127563, -0.4969747066497803, -0.6940271854400635, 0.6623554229736328, 0.3448956608772278, 0.5053434371948242, 0.6200576424598694, 0.1481642872095108, 0.13188745081424713, -0.32204461097717285, 0.05205204337835312, -0.06506539136171341, 0.7266514301300049, -0.29172638058662415, -0.3428255021572113, 0.2028823047876358, 0.054638780653476715, -0.4860001504421234, -0.8338987827301025, 0.20349183678627014, -0.7325811386108398, 0.15996815264225006, -0.37743958830833435, 0.5282413959503174, 0.3511315584182739, -0.04247003793716431, 0.5711691379547119, 0.0019989325664937496, 0.7440084218978882, 1.095296859741211, 0.10681639611721039, 0.45608973503112793, -0.1425648331642151, -0.05079726129770279, -0.30076372623443604, -0.36615443229675293, -0.12450093775987625, 0.540836751461029, 0.017973527312278748, 0.20838795602321625, -0.08705829083919525, -0.6042641401290894, -0.3676779568195343, -0.6965557336807251, -0.13398241996765137, -0.035007186233997345, 0.3498799502849579, -0.4873010814189911, 0.017055751755833626, 0.2512418329715729, -0.34811797738075256, -0.36776402592658997, -0.41284000873565674, -0.9290915131568909, 0.8586695790290833, -0.5984549522399902, 0.10012630373239517, -0.793058454990387, 0.05513515695929527, -0.5633625388145447, -0.6531045436859131, 0.11270880699157715, -0.3841230571269989, 0.14828401803970337, -0.4637371003627777, -0.3720202147960663, 0.7232245206832886, 0.26949042081832886, 0.2955019772052765, 0.015602584928274155, -0.12393832951784134, 0.26080021262168884, 0.6434029936790466, 0.2573108673095703, 0.6761182546615601, 0.0782548263669014, 0.3626287281513214, 0.2560541033744812, -0.036796364933252335, 0.135287344455719, -0.30866867303848267, -0.7847334146499634, -0.6507220268249512, 0.8303225636482239, -0.5231833457946777, -0.5013768672943115, 0.40779241919517517, 0.9989370107650757, 0.15310949087142944, -0.08668272942304611, -0.9745712280273438, -0.3064402937889099, -0.450027734041214, 0.47905001044273376, -0.01383237261325121, -0.5772085785865784, -0.11540064215660095, -0.22255299985408783, 0.6940515637397766, -1.2189997434616089, 3.9801385402679443, 1.114842414855957, 1.0834596157073975, -0.5293387174606323, 0.370852530002594, 1.1146820783615112, 0.3735724091529846, 0.9155806303024292, -0.3219255208969116, -0.5194991230964661, 0.6225691437721252, -0.1761404573917389, -0.11179133504629135, 0.4277633726596832, 0.31874746084213257, 0.34447723627090454, -0.997604489326477, 0.2907240092754364, 0.1772599071264267, -1.2425696849822998, -0.2829006016254425, -0.3559103310108185, 0.000558067113161087, 0.13030047714710236, -0.19124846160411835, 0.15313515067100525, 0.023776067420840263, 0.4851035177707672, 0.09726864844560623, 0.2664901316165924, -0.3485961854457855, -0.7853754758834839, 0.019773175939917564, -0.8689851760864258, -0.7364688515663147, 0.4465566575527191, -0.45069703459739685, -0.5340664982795715, -0.3062114119529724, -0.5990829467773438, 0.317862331867218, -0.3278799057006836, -0.4081907868385315, -0.7049793601036072, 0.214721217751503, 0.27901941537857056, -0.7048560380935669, -0.020775284618139267, 0.32967281341552734, -0.6940611600875854, 0.5916658043861389, -1.4044636487960815, 0.19030393660068512, -0.4427255392074585, -0.6837993860244751, -0.31776487827301025, -0.34380125999450684, -0.9276468753814697, 0.6464231014251709, 0.9776957035064697, 0.2640676200389862, -0.15606847405433655, -0.6851875185966492, -0.43747028708457947, 0.4054190218448639, 0.8104888200759888, 0.5666828155517578, 0.07155051827430725, 0.15751855075359344, -0.8444758057594299, 0.09658900648355484, -0.8965539932250977, 0.37997448444366455, -0.2365264594554901, 0.620002031326294, 0.45035040378570557, -0.3893914222717285, 0.036283284425735474, 0.032156750559806824, -0.006149562541395426, 0.30292484164237976, 0.677357017993927, 0.32062605023384094, -0.13573327660560608, -0.10815796256065369, 0.08480566740036011, -0.6943808197975159, -0.5517208576202393, -0.9383289813995361, -0.07605244964361191, -0.05372588336467743, -0.0119094243273139, 0.672558605670929, 0.0012948682997375727, 0.013011617586016655 ]
{"Title": "Risk of Inflammatory Bowel Disease in Psoriasis Patients Treated with Anti-Interleukin-17 Agents: A Bayesian Metaanalysis", "Authors": "Gill N., Pietrosanu M., Gniadecki R.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Use of interleukin-17 inhibitors (IL-17i) in psoriasis has been associated with an increased risk of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). However, the clinical significance of this association is not understood. Objectives To quantify the absolute risk of IBD in patients with psoriasis treated with IL-17i, stratified by known IBD risk factors. Methods Literature searches were performed to identify known IBD risk factors and the prevalences were quantified by a meta-analysis of proportions. The Bayesian model was used to estimate the probability of a new-onset or a flare of IBD in patients with psoriasis. Results The prevalence of Crohn\u2019s disease (CD) or ulcerative colitis (UC) in the general psoriasis population was 0.0010. Use of IL-17i increased the risk of CD to 0.0037 and UC to 0.0028, translating to a number needed to harm (NNH) of 373 for CD and 564 for UC. In patients who had concomitant hidradenitis suppurativa, the use of IL-17i was associated with a decrease in NNH for CD and UC to 18 and 76, respectively, whereas for patients with a family history of IBD, the NNH values were 6 (for CD) and 10 (for UC). Conclusions In patients with no risk factors, the probability of IBD flare or onset during IL-17i treatment is negligible and additional IBD screening procedures are not indicated. In contrast, the patients with psoriasis who have hidradenitis suppurativa or first-degree family history of IBD as risk factors should be monitored for signs and symptoms of CD and UC during IL-17i therapy.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012179"}
10.1101/19001834
[ 0.09771554917097092, 0.9865843057632446, 0.4899180829524994, -0.08615423738956451, 0.1658952832221985, -0.7414663434028625, -0.5304425358772278, 0.01459552813321352, 0.21358266472816467, 1.0063424110412598, -0.25829172134399414, -0.6205940246582031, 0.0077805533073842525, 0.24378255009651184, -0.32727375626564026, -0.49210187792778015, -0.4189760386943817, -0.03712981566786766, 0.28337371349334717, -0.1936783492565155, -0.08619643747806549, 0.6600871682167053, -1.3743706941604614, -0.3190191984176636, -0.6735415458679199, 0.7935711741447449, -0.08206364512443542, -0.16834014654159546, 1.4458577632904053, 0.8059734106063843, 0.45847639441490173, -0.8132254481315613, 0.486177533864975, -1.3716890811920166, -0.6516522765159607, -0.3767787516117096, 0.7452095746994019, -0.5396329164505005, 0.23114725947380066, -0.5457448959350586, 1.196790099143982, -0.7078472971916199, 0.20511876046657562, -0.32083529233932495, -0.9132011532783508, 0.11213035881519318, -0.23871898651123047, 0.45949822664260864, 0.02429315447807312, 0.1861114650964737, 0.11275376379489899, 0.038282446563243866, 0.21102683246135712, -0.4324852228164673, -0.33928269147872925, 0.16350533068180084, 0.26967981457710266, -0.32555559277534485, -0.5396019220352173, 0.20803984999656677, -0.23888495564460754, -0.06197350472211838, 0.7836369276046753, -0.6677179932594299, -0.04725951701402664, 0.935265302658081, 0.47208964824676514, 0.16352765262126923, -0.35848239064216614, 0.03643679991364479, -0.010973294265568256, -0.6513019800186157, -1.0302461385726929, -0.19931505620479584, -0.7011423110961914, -0.03329109027981758, -0.39790913462638855, -0.12565664947032928, -0.3283383548259735, -0.36713796854019165, -0.24736765027046204, 0.5996658205986023, 0.07654347270727158, 0.09503590315580368, -0.47776976227760315, -0.4116487503051758, 0.08803011476993561, 0.6675817966461182, 0.4766308069229126, 1.0950483083724976, -0.1693682074546814, 0.2849965989589691, 0.4302823841571808, -0.24265947937965393, 0.047086652368307114, 0.9872877597808838, 0.1362125277519226, 0.0630585178732872, 0.212838277220726, -0.6839120984077454, 1.208949089050293, 0.5934574604034424, -0.13183416426181793, 1.1708345413208008, -1.044213056564331, 0.8626167178153992, 0.45595407485961914, -0.23142194747924805, -0.9544745683670044, -0.7465614080429077, 0.4911462664604187, 0.04798285290598869, -0.9983593225479126, -0.2774290144443512, 0.9724810123443604, 0.46725597977638245, 0.5626893043518066, 1.1733801364898682, -0.8775374889373779, 0.3616505563259125, -0.4851491153240204, -0.06022224575281143, 0.16295789182186127, -0.3159230947494507, -0.019264478236436844, 0.010895793326199055, 0.02005745656788349, 0.2900559902191162, -0.6982345581054688, 0.4601242244243622, -0.07177809625864029, -0.20951387286186218, -0.31535959243774414, 1.2169904708862305, -0.005136034917086363, 0.24826589226722717, 0.2541912794113159, 0.7500593066215515, 0.6995381116867065, -1.08989417552948, 0.2359440177679062, 0.1165875792503357, -0.5229008197784424, 1.2728538513183594, -0.3724542260169983, -0.053534697741270065, -0.5515414476394653, -1.048071265220642, -0.3244044780731201, 0.10969161987304688, -0.5072135329246521, 0.6110153198242188, -0.12762591242790222, -0.5014961361885071, -0.1114291325211525, 0.402814656496048, -0.4720042943954468, 0.21567310392856598, -0.625715970993042, -0.35538074374198914, -1.0321227312088013, -0.3630543053150177, -0.30264636874198914, 0.8835169076919556, -0.9932321310043335, 0.6310503482818604, -0.33592092990875244, 0.39128726720809937, -0.5262047052383423, -0.6929506659507751, 0.8113246560096741, 0.10018271952867508, 0.03929024934768677, 0.2548436224460602, 0.38991886377334595, 1.2659363746643066, 0.8277162313461304, -0.49465590715408325, 0.9210805296897888, 0.45413291454315186, -0.04325925186276436, 0.4432840347290039, 0.08594194054603577, 0.4606717824935913, 0.3739016056060791, -0.22559566795825958, -0.6117975115776062, -0.3974492847919464, -0.04435529559850693, -0.18165497481822968, -0.4583006501197815, 0.42183545231819153, 0.0424196682870388, 0.41524767875671387, 0.4897017776966095, 0.5045688152313232, -0.23429186642169952, 0.13453561067581177, 0.3459326922893524, -0.2528281509876251, -0.15999417006969452, 0.794725239276886, -0.3746422827243805, -0.14876866340637207, -0.8011773824691772, 0.5061480402946472, 0.6207203269004822, 0.556709885597229, -1.0021982192993164, 0.44606295228004456, 0.4525258541107178, -0.8655017614364624, 0.41552460193634033, 0.17314743995666504, 0.07456288486719131, -0.10346754640340805, -0.3202705681324005, -0.017307832837104797, -0.7726379036903381, -0.15092429518699646, -0.46522146463394165, -0.8207600116729736, 0.8522661924362183, -0.040716178715229034, 0.11486378312110901, 0.26725706458091736, 0.6485437154769897, 0.5649315714836121, -0.24760931730270386, 0.5147134065628052, 0.7799861431121826, 0.12292259931564331, 0.28229326009750366, 1.4623792171478271, 0.5384743809700012, -0.11674920469522476, 0.15413320064544678, 0.46280747652053833, 0.03860858455300331, 0.4963459372520447, 0.9830011129379272, 0.03347720578312874, 0.5924847722053528, 0.11874726414680481, -0.843920111656189, 1.003921389579773, -0.7794173955917358, 0.35663503408432007, -0.21822825074195862, 0.4693356156349182, 0.0913102924823761, 0.31594812870025635, -0.08407524228096008, 0.7076305747032166, -0.5319485068321228, -0.3224097490310669, 0.5603765249252319, 0.03460671007633209, -0.015223002061247826, -0.5665423274040222, -0.21916477382183075, -0.28074607253074646, -0.26228708028793335, -0.5454460382461548, 0.6848701238632202, 1.2465940713882446, 0.44325873255729675, 0.669104278087616, -0.015823686495423317, -0.7100664377212524, -1.214684009552002, -0.10986801236867905, -0.8588795065879822, -0.3654170036315918, -0.7768521308898926, -0.07364651560783386, 0.3845711350440979, -0.8270454406738281, 0.33233994245529175, -0.3590214252471924, 0.2961699366569519, 0.40614554286003113, -0.32612234354019165, 0.0999361127614975, 0.4893604815006256, -0.16032303869724274, -0.6231877207756042, 0.8825583457946777, -0.08079665154218674, 0.2480745017528534, 0.1137746199965477, -0.06774391233921051, -0.7469992637634277, -0.4074561893939972, 0.5862823128700256, -0.08135972172021866, -0.07406220585107803, -0.16601230204105377, 0.1810152381658554, -0.13936713337898254, 0.3039543330669403, 0.20120973885059357, 0.059961676597595215, 0.02190783992409706, -1.2448784112930298, 0.5416749715805054, 0.010049732401967049, -0.23354072868824005, 0.3311997354030609, 0.1693187654018402, -0.4540395140647888, 0.36437755823135376, -0.6868183612823486, 0.7614023685455322, -0.6324999928474426, 0.5067499279975891, 0.0726625919342041, 0.12811505794525146, 0.8277550339698792, -0.7988219261169434, -0.6720538139343262, -0.38315337896347046, -0.08306965976953506, -0.1399756520986557, -0.3557264506816864, 0.780033528804779, -0.4862488806247711, -1.2657802104949951, -0.09638757258653641, -0.592337429523468, -0.4903855621814728, 0.43798235058784485, -0.1160670667886734, 0.42963600158691406, 0.31323736906051636, -0.30701956152915955, -0.7394369840621948, 0.2725497782230377, 0.11600916087627411, 1.0112453699111938, 0.1787521243095398, 0.15163066983222961, 0.49844473600387573, 0.8280364871025085, -0.19585148990154266, 0.5173148512840271, 0.8279390335083008, -0.132766991853714, 0.30327731370925903, 0.34735575318336487, 0.40741685032844543, 0.22410660982131958, 0.5801129341125488, -0.5282296538352966, -0.06487958878278732, 0.740922212600708, 0.2655324339866638, 0.40357843041419983, -0.025693081319332123, -0.41119712591171265, 0.3094780743122101, 0.12914033234119415, -0.8038965463638306, 0.2700061798095703, -0.7801096439361572, -0.7479536533355713, 0.8681567311286926, 0.00018396266386844218, 0.10057995468378067, -0.5035607814788818, 0.7584317922592163, 0.6162495613098145, -0.07940308749675751, 0.3211710453033447, 0.27156439423561096, 0.4053027331829071, 0.3075104057788849, 0.7312002182006836, 1.495324730873108, -1.1690902709960938, 0.3882715106010437, 0.4851910471916199, 1.1516032218933105, 0.39539775252342224, -0.11396634578704834, 1.4106122255325317, -0.26096099615097046, 0.46528565883636475, -0.1508600115776062, 0.23282422125339508, -0.28296414017677307, -0.2607502341270447, -0.04834086820483208, -0.1596890687942505, -0.1984800100326538, -0.6985697746276855, 0.44720184803009033, 0.6203743815422058, 0.2776992917060852, -0.004209247883409262, 0.5075455904006958, -0.932655394077301, 0.358216792345047, 0.25106775760650635, 1.0949536561965942, 0.20565873384475708, -0.5566343665122986, 0.39102277159690857, -0.3795904517173767, -0.0644153580069542, 0.2124781459569931, -0.18628473579883575, -0.6732621192932129, -0.21617719531059265, 0.5075258612632751, -0.44589167833328247, -0.6030083298683167, -0.2496616244316101, 0.15805894136428833, -0.02925010770559311, 0.32408860325813293, 0.8574819564819336, -0.6102251410484314, 0.3086688816547394, 0.3602723479270935, -1.198237657546997, 0.180469810962677, -1.0105586051940918, 1.0143275260925293, 0.644024133682251, 0.3010552227497101, -0.9101029634475708, -0.7138619422912598, 0.1801677793264389, 0.08412502706050873, 0.006137100979685783, 0.35877344012260437, -0.5335596203804016, 0.7285752892494202, -0.5705993175506592, -0.21348479390144348, -0.7776055932044983, -0.19113047420978546, -0.782028079032898, 0.3192780315876007, -0.07057947665452957, 0.8248046636581421, 0.36225542426109314, 0.05577525123953819, -0.07521578669548035, 0.4409484267234802, 0.06488783657550812, 0.42626118659973145, -1.0530614852905273, -0.5698300004005432, -0.15317480266094208, -0.30009007453918457, -0.08060093969106674, -0.09325320273637772, -0.5321167707443237, -0.5141744613647461, 0.05295504629611969, 0.38574594259262085, -0.4822896718978882, -0.2777256667613983, 1.1366231441497803, -0.3702232241630554, 0.38039684295654297, 0.35935065150260925, -0.24799442291259766, 0.4285842776298523, -0.3100748360157013, -0.47326672077178955, -0.5368740558624268, 0.553548276424408, 0.1488436907529831, 0.31043776869773865, 0.3482152819633484, 0.042346589267253876, 0.10589952766895294, -0.6646038293838501, -0.6337061524391174, -0.7716602683067322, 0.05737059935927391, -1.2057756185531616, -0.7565652132034302, -0.17313499748706818, 0.29251420497894287, -0.47654640674591064, -0.13581101596355438, 0.2637973725795746, -0.09641861915588379, -0.33034247159957886, 0.7555818557739258, -0.42844295501708984, -0.3517158627510071, -0.7967004179954529, -0.7521912455558777, -0.3623543381690979, -0.2895652651786804, 1.2947946786880493, -0.3550514578819275, -0.923515796661377, 0.1788640320301056, 0.36441123485565186, -0.28345322608947754, -0.5745318531990051, -0.5453476309776306, -0.9348934888839722, -0.2952234148979187, -0.5621362924575806, -0.2266809642314911, -0.5366184115409851, -0.11569884419441223, 0.10471682250499725, 0.009309678338468075, 0.9025578498840332, -0.22895683348178864, -0.5208222270011902, 0.29726892709732056, -0.07401377707719803, 0.11611172556877136, -0.13185863196849823, 0.7286171913146973, -0.386538565158844, 0.005829363130033016, -0.18399971723556519, -1.3524094820022583, -1.3075333833694458, -0.8154522180557251, 0.0915340781211853, -0.9685487747192383, 0.48851507902145386, -0.21551495790481567, 0.29550403356552124, -0.18955250084400177, 0.8061097264289856, 0.09640992432832718, 0.11796057224273682, -0.6476903557777405, -0.4588834345340729, 0.6323100328445435, 0.18298110365867615, -0.4398355484008789, -0.2961629629135132, -1.0331672430038452, 0.0771326869726181, 0.7765990495681763, -0.6008538603782654, -0.8533052802085876, 0.3491758704185486, 0.7621718049049377, 0.42329731583595276, 0.6896962523460388, -1.114335060119629, 0.019552182406187057, 0.4295772612094879, 0.8546435832977295, -0.6898643970489502, -0.24050304293632507, -0.8739506602287292, 0.39013612270355225, 0.15060706436634064, 0.16032323241233826, -0.22006815671920776, 0.09973390400409698, 0.1667468398809433, 0.031841251999139786, 1.196548342704773, -0.5908747911453247, -0.1656329184770584, -0.43097203969955444, 0.30940136313438416, 0.45728278160095215, 0.5176270008087158, -0.7165974974632263, -0.2844635546207428, -0.6829457879066467, -0.5987493395805359, 0.8964892625808716, -0.2473517656326294, 0.5318653583526611, 0.835808515548706, -0.6881651282310486, 0.636389970779419, -0.6150971055030823, 0.4321657717227936, 1.305997371673584, -0.6382130980491638, 0.11733835190534592, 0.7177107930183411, 0.0290587916970253, -0.7066828012466431, 0.5166558623313904, 0.3768845200538635, 0.5033062696456909, -0.6393721699714661, -0.3435646891593933, -0.39498454332351685, -0.8785977959632874, -0.24843372404575348, 0.7159190773963928, 0.8273944854736328, 0.08217595517635345, 0.8276807069778442, -0.12748278677463531, -0.3444192409515381, 0.02949322760105133, 0.43425267934799194, 0.28156501054763794, 0.532401978969574, 1.2225943803787231, 0.2956368625164032, -0.5486710667610168, 0.030041120946407318, -0.41424599289894104, 0.4393388330936432, -0.04969673231244087, 0.5797246098518372, 0.408059686422348, -0.3384130597114563, 0.21880914270877838, 0.33404991030693054, -0.6909862160682678, -0.7008427977561951, -0.15746399760246277, -0.47017931938171387, 0.4502358138561249, -0.25404584407806396, -0.38514038920402527, 0.26618409156799316, -0.7656577825546265, 0.019387580454349518, -0.19818072021007538, 0.598794162273407, -0.3481234014034271, -0.40504512190818787, 0.2594678997993469, -0.9649439454078674, 0.9504236578941345, 0.5229061841964722, -0.2489306479692459, -0.23745578527450562, 0.6573539972305298, 0.2790701985359192, 0.5857418775558472, 0.20646077394485474, 0.37584054470062256, -0.39654815196990967, 0.07754507660865784, 0.2632141411304474, 0.19008538126945496, -0.12371904402971268, -0.043605394661426544, -0.15245932340621948, 0.1339987963438034, 0.4152211546897888, -0.8398602604866028, -0.5768654346466064, 0.0937742069363594, -0.029081514105200768, 0.28903114795684814, 0.6186465620994568, 0.08228891342878342, 0.43756401538848877, 0.12703213095664978, 0.20103608071804047, -0.469200074672699, -0.6236752271652222, -0.8437482118606567, -0.20128145813941956, -0.14657509326934814, -0.4378487765789032, 0.36304786801338196, 0.35132524371147156, -0.11907768994569778, -0.7709177732467651, -0.32885026931762695, 0.6392537355422974, -0.7733355164527893, 0.3130720853805542, 0.16293002665042877, 0.38160914182662964, -0.7093169093132019, -0.2410118579864502, -0.600271463394165, -0.545452356338501, -0.627679169178009, 0.06582862138748169, -0.6752086281776428, -0.11191423237323761, -0.6287696957588196, 0.7635043859481812, 0.24581709504127502, 0.28668734431266785, -0.05838654562830925, -0.8958050608634949, -0.4070512056350708, 0.7163179516792297, -0.5125325322151184, 0.0301362294703722, 0.8787577152252197, -0.14422990381717682, 0.3195782005786896, -0.17650097608566284, -0.36302080750465393, -0.06122712418437004, 0.11927180737257004, 0.4777822196483612, -0.3366447389125824, -0.4533427953720093, -0.5275940299034119, 0.9804839491844177, -1.3779323101043701, -0.6454089283943176, -0.46946415305137634, 0.3084735870361328, 0.16041657328605652, -0.291800856590271, 0.5004125833511353, 1.122196912765503, 0.13291852176189423, 0.5508272051811218, -0.4784483015537262, 0.49069005250930786, 0.6620298624038696, 0.2351216971874237, 0.04335357993841171, 0.5696234703063965, 0.5387808084487915, -0.7571755051612854, 0.02890522964298725, 0.1577092409133911, -0.5180258750915527, 0.4749878942966461, -0.4296935498714447, 0.5281749367713928, -0.01957210712134838, 0.3890158236026764, 0.05194006860256195, 0.5045605897903442, 0.6832165122032166, 0.6974473595619202, -0.04518135264515877, -0.7475681304931641, -0.3818741738796234, -0.2176452875137329, -1.0156559944152832, -0.23403438925743103, 0.30450350046157837, -0.7382054924964905, -0.0008018202497623861, -0.9352030158042908, -0.7424873113632202, 0.09373239427804947, 0.3540935218334198, 0.03399483114480972, 0.13469170033931732, 0.8444058299064636, -0.12528976798057556, 0.8162956833839417, 0.1285843700170517, 0.15205542743206024, 0.3476249575614929, -0.20607440173625946, -0.689139187335968, -0.3336106240749359, 0.0973747968673706, 0.07025842368602753, -0.7991101741790771, -0.4382576048374176, -0.6240788102149963, 0.5444382429122925, -0.5811924934387207, -0.7131160497665405, -0.8351104855537415, -0.06822504848241806, -0.7505083084106445, -0.1789446771144867, 0.016976628452539444, -0.6645141243934631, -0.08332881331443787, 0.047453925013542175, 0.11276062577962875, -0.9047529697418213, -0.5274157524108887, 0.18584682047367096, 0.6667600870132446, 0.2571161389350891, 0.5207635164260864, -0.233440563082695, 0.36561545729637146, -0.15147393941879272, -0.16432927548885345, 0.26106369495391846, 0.6438637971878052, -0.07788202166557312, -0.14595487713813782, 0.4299289584159851, 0.6974565982818604, 0.35699477791786194, -0.10920149832963943, -0.4030662178993225, 0.5532029271125793, 0.06786418706178665, -0.45801568031311035, -0.4289720058441162, -0.40006136894226074, 0.6746874451637268, -0.16225305199623108, -0.22820444405078888, -0.09492596983909607, 0.4674634039402008, 0.16803030669689178, -0.26610109210014343, -0.5620632171630859, 0.7805982828140259, -0.8212239742279053, -0.6171392202377319, 0.10084107518196106, 0.49966880679130554, 0.8444156646728516, 0.05349266156554222, 0.23018750548362732, 0.48826879262924194, 1.3475521802902222, 0.11567576974630356, -0.4656142294406891, 0.5844378471374512, -0.45576900243759155, 0.33036237955093384, -0.038305122405290604, 0.4875970184803009, -0.21358664333820343, -0.7013781666755676, 0.04692260921001434, -0.8966903686523438, -0.08280797302722931, 0.506912350654602, -0.8021551966667175, 0.3597470223903656, 0.6786632537841797, -0.2859363853931427, -0.2773183584213257, -0.8810504674911499, 0.24821017682552338, -0.05973219871520996, -0.1356155425310135, 1.0806094408035278, -0.5581961870193481, 0.2797762453556061, -0.006118479650467634, 0.6200901865959167, 1.2332005500793457, 0.08893842995166779, -0.2033662647008896, -0.3125315010547638, 0.13218124210834503, 0.8731339573860168, 0.06912010908126831, -0.12747135758399963, -0.9533811807632446, 0.10205888003110886, -0.6515177488327026, 0.34791648387908936, -0.6789942383766174, 0.29655036330223083, -0.2582026720046997, -0.5589033365249634, -0.057275157421827316, 0.1492394357919693, -0.6589215993881226, -0.7602089643478394, -0.11577170342206955, -0.3090287446975708, -0.501990020275116, -0.24677520990371704, 0.9029994606971741, 0.003737975610420108, -0.24978519976139069, 0.4918520450592041, -0.0737532526254654, -0.4847714900970459, 0.0539855994284153, -0.6390895247459412, 0.6936941146850586, -0.42160746455192566, -0.14145444333553314, -0.3653292953968048, -1.3463172912597656, -0.7833009362220764, 0.07729332149028778, -0.08007505536079407, -0.5667352676391602, 0.14212682843208313, 1.0023207664489746, 0.497305303812027, 0.4900290071964264, -0.22058500349521637, 0.2824917137622833, 0.20578311383724213, 0.6022455096244812, 0.028782464563846588, 0.12265542894601822, -0.7631281614303589, 0.3978288173675537, 0.37778589129447937, -0.4202527403831482, 0.3206767141819, 0.03059173747897148, -0.14458589255809784, -0.9712526798248291, -0.1235356330871582, -0.2976932227611542, -0.8678327798843384, 0.7961204051971436, 0.6228583455085754, -0.19069527089595795, -0.8694032430648804, -0.43944793939590454, 0.009004360996186733, -0.23766502737998962, 1.1462318897247314, -0.2686622738838196, 0.2656668424606323, 0.10186868160963058, -0.17724663019180298, 0.6760954856872559, -0.6800352931022644, 3.9621195793151855, 1.2639868259429932, 0.48390695452690125, -0.4514029622077942, 1.3424769639968872, 1.1947611570358276, 0.6165503859519958, 0.19761136174201965, 0.11374908685684204, 0.23872673511505127, -0.3532406687736511, 0.17059701681137085, -0.20063599944114685, -0.4581355154514313, 0.9610159397125244, 0.010743005201220512, -0.5988434553146362, 0.409059077501297, -0.6370309591293335, -0.9844469428062439, -0.6256990432739258, 0.8876497745513916, 0.03443015739321709, -0.10584522038698196, 0.7477400898933411, -0.13937239348888397, 0.5656553506851196, -0.11212357878684998, -0.4048566222190857, -0.3153001070022583, 0.45210057497024536, -0.31107428669929504, 0.33801138401031494, -0.626059889793396, -0.36314237117767334, 0.017944207414984703, -0.018156351521611214, -0.706682562828064, 0.05208171531558037, 0.22243136167526245, -0.5295692682266235, -0.013889778405427933, -0.2941879630088806, -0.7123709321022034, -0.6487703919410706, -0.19579610228538513, -0.29851841926574707, 0.1458742320537567, 0.6995533108711243, -0.2122792750597, 0.5817312002182007, -0.9673921465873718, 0.6965776681900024, -0.3392186164855957, -0.813986599445343, -0.1964169591665268, 0.0716288760304451, -0.9248741269111633, -0.04260892793536186, 0.04212336242198944, 0.35900160670280457, -0.3036787211894989, -0.03078697808086872, 0.4849919080734253, 0.26223188638687134, 0.6127347946166992, 0.2922937572002411, 0.31042763590812683, -0.08172847330570221, -0.6262152194976807, -0.15905852615833282, -0.6030592322349548, -0.21519891917705536, -0.14501804113388062, 0.4274359345436096, -0.531478226184845, -0.016834156587719917, 0.4864450693130493, -0.3542911112308502, -0.7370379567146301, -0.5116368532180786, -0.4200838506221771, -0.00011311451089568436, -0.5477675795555115, 0.0913996696472168, 0.636906623840332, 0.08876333385705948, -0.22887186706066132, -0.7844650149345398, 0.3159472942352295, 0.7421591281890869, 0.1459166705608368, -0.07992907613515854, 0.3260800838470459, -0.09323292970657349 ]
{"Title": "Childhood immune imprinting to influenza A shapes birth year-specific risk during seasonal H1N1 and H3N2 epidemics", "Authors": "Gostic Katelyn M, Bridge Rebecca, Brady Shane, Viboud C\u00e9cile, Worobey Michael, Lloyd-Smith James O", "Abstract": "Abstract Across decades of co-circulation in humans, influenza A subtypes H1N1 and H3N2 have caused seasonal epidemics characterized by different age distributions of cases and mortality. H3N2 causes the majority of relatively severe, clinically attended cases in high-risk elderly cohorts, and the majority of overall deaths, whereas H1N1 causes fewer deaths overall, and cases shifted towards young and middle-aged adults. These contrasting age profiles may result from differences in childhood exposure to H1N1 and H3N2 or from differences in evolutionary rate between subtypes. Here we analyze a large epidemiological surveillance dataset to test whether childhood immune imprinting shapes seasonal influenza epidemiology, and if so, whether it acts primarily via immune memory of a particular influenza subtype or via broader immune memory that protects across subtypes. We also test the impact of evolutionary differences between influenza subtypes on age distributions of cases. Likelihood-based model comparison shows that narrow, within-subtype imprinting shapes seasonal influenza risk alongside age-specific risk factors. The data do not support a strong effect of evolutionary rate, or of broadly protective imprinting that acts across subtypes. Our findings emphasize that childhood exposures can imprint a lifelong immunological bias toward particular influenza subtypes, and that these cohort-specific biases shape epidemic age distributions. As a result, newer and less \u201csenior\u201d antibody responses acquired later in life do not provide the same strength of protection as responses imprinted in childhood. Finally, we project that the relatively low mortality burden of H1N1 may increase in the coming decades, as cohorts that lack H1N1-specific imprinting eventually reach old age. Author Summary Influenza viruses of subtype H1N1 and H3N2 both cause seasonal epidemics in humans, but with different age-specific impacts. H3N2 causes a greater proportion of cases in older adults than H1N1, and more deaths overall. People tend to gain the strongest immune memory of influenza viruses encountered in childhood, and so differences in H1N1 and H3N2\u2019s age-specific impacts may reflect that individuals born in different eras of influenza circulation have been imprinted with different immunological risk profiles. Another idea is that H3N2 may be more able to infect immunologically experienced adults because it evolves slightly faster than H1N1 and can more quickly escape immune memory. We analyzed a large epidemiological data set and found the clearest signal that birth year-specific differences in childhood immune imprinting, not differences in evolutionary rate, explain differences in H1N1 and H3N2\u2019s age-specific impacts. These results can help epidemiologists understand how epidemic risk from specific influenza subtypes is distributed across the population and predict how population risk may shift as differently imprinted birth years grow older. Further, these results provide immunological clues to which facets of immune memory become biased in childhood, and then later play a strong role in protection during seasonal influenza epidemics.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19001834"}
10.1101/19011007
[ -0.008355589583516121, 0.5693574547767639, 0.3630831241607666, 0.3135897219181061, -0.35120588541030884, -0.3599741756916046, 0.09172864258289337, -0.6502651572227478, 0.4128694534301758, 0.7874387502670288, 0.09220558404922485, -0.9675122499465942, 0.4169486463069916, -0.650560736656189, -0.033430662006139755, -0.29146379232406616, -0.3684466481208801, 0.17102590203285217, -0.38557231426239014, 0.30021944642066956, 1.0032132863998413, 0.46699732542037964, -0.8128992915153503, 0.4849725663661957, -0.3392515182495117, 0.755801260471344, 0.34539422392845154, -0.1949538290500641, 1.5398879051208496, -0.30220460891723633, -0.4965020418167114, -0.48270371556282043, 0.6850883960723877, -1.4972174167633057, -0.17221173644065857, -0.03816236928105354, 0.4741823077201843, -0.3453032076358795, 0.3424113094806671, 0.008387084119021893, 0.43547677993774414, 0.3282960057258606, 0.11023043096065521, -0.02228553779423237, -0.48207807540893555, -0.9417769908905029, -0.20333418250083923, -0.22550618648529053, -0.4545094072818756, -0.043822407722473145, -0.5719822645187378, -0.04590747132897377, 0.1523003876209259, -0.05392482876777649, 0.06462836265563965, -0.11662355065345764, 0.3186887800693512, 0.00879069697111845, -1.262495517730713, -0.0501728318631649, 0.2802678048610687, 0.31497570872306824, 0.7555226683616638, -1.123826503753662, 0.9238126277923584, 1.4173740148544312, -0.22702375054359436, -0.22512954473495483, -0.5943543910980225, 0.6281930208206177, 0.038678016513586044, 0.2563837468624115, -1.031261682510376, -0.600330114364624, -0.29910600185394287, -0.9205670952796936, 0.5589475631713867, -0.3171747922897339, -0.20132127404212952, -0.4952550232410431, -0.40566158294677734, 0.2282618135213852, -0.1752936989068985, 0.057106614112854004, -0.4159001111984253, -0.08000697940587997, 0.25365474820137024, 0.4756321907043457, -0.6463049650192261, 1.1326038837432861, 0.026351798325777054, 0.4438822567462921, 0.02987004816532135, 0.3628051280975342, 0.35867345333099365, 1.0620131492614746, -0.7546530961990356, -0.20979873836040497, -0.14953617751598358, -0.8859806060791016, 0.28709763288497925, 0.28133711218833923, -0.7486575841903687, 1.146355152130127, -0.23200808465480804, 0.323541522026062, 0.14234907925128937, 0.29848381876945496, -0.8994420170783997, -0.5306390523910522, 0.7242772579193115, -0.1976361870765686, -0.5247213244438171, 0.539764404296875, 0.8200557231903076, 0.9342933297157288, -0.001248552929610014, 0.5233980417251587, -1.0840576887130737, -0.1436510980129242, -0.09467543661594391, -0.18473361432552338, 0.8804142475128174, 0.032526012510061264, 0.813942015171051, 0.3291950225830078, -0.1955420821905136, 0.7457712292671204, -0.41407719254493713, 0.16256162524223328, -0.008048911578953266, -0.46351689100265503, -0.20644573867321014, 0.6032301187515259, -0.4737768769264221, -0.4545340836048126, -0.3605823218822479, 0.8185623288154602, -0.2426358014345169, -1.0034794807434082, 0.15950265526771545, 0.3212699890136719, -1.1079366207122803, 1.5021675825119019, -0.1701326072216034, 1.1990007162094116, -0.6928120851516724, -1.0126020908355713, -0.504690945148468, 0.2037232369184494, 0.2685232162475586, 0.23850737512111664, -0.21452417969703674, -0.6644284129142761, 0.178732767701149, -0.055209871381521225, -0.7229572534561157, 0.6951830983161926, 0.29988932609558105, 0.4050840139389038, 0.14848914742469788, 0.5831983089447021, 0.523353636264801, 0.9099413752555847, -0.8849628567695618, 0.32592496275901794, -0.19253399968147278, 0.3188032805919647, -0.20314201712608337, -0.5406429171562195, 0.07117104530334473, 0.05951833352446556, -0.46461936831474304, 0.08565733581781387, 0.07167865335941315, 0.3433285653591156, 0.4062739908695221, 0.039001334458589554, 0.5713145136833191, 0.22451657056808472, 0.6383863687515259, -0.06006256490945816, 0.3709169328212738, 0.4749310612678528, -0.3388257920742035, 0.23984602093696594, 0.11004357039928436, -0.4112367331981659, -0.5761072039604187, 0.03570975735783577, -0.1314515918493271, 0.7475910782814026, -0.77211594581604, 0.9679859280586243, 0.058884188532829285, 0.8183682560920715, -0.47170665860176086, 0.5584529042243958, 0.5909795761108398, -0.7545652389526367, -0.3776916563510895, 1.2691961526870728, -0.1082080528140068, 0.5232083797454834, 0.1628483086824417, 0.2945862412452698, 0.11981360614299774, 0.686768651008606, -0.37687948346138, -0.09232352674007416, 0.3047943711280823, 0.2387869656085968, -0.07042201608419418, 0.22611179947853088, 0.6526349782943726, -0.7137390375137329, 0.2468472570180893, -0.25608348846435547, -0.6786810755729675, -0.05277049168944359, 0.05165774002671242, -0.12660099565982819, 0.9950746297836304, 0.2520166337490082, 0.4643532335758209, 0.5643227696418762, 1.152181625366211, 0.11599121242761612, -0.11543209850788116, -0.8197829723358154, 0.6757872700691223, 0.09450571984052658, -0.008841531351208687, 0.5137179493904114, 0.08483362942934036, 0.38611018657684326, 0.2918362021446228, 0.7246713638305664, 0.23418602347373962, 0.26780012249946594, 0.03348221257328987, 0.1785283088684082, 0.8428853154182434, 0.5660642385482788, 0.40706515312194824, 0.2832246720790863, -1.0861506462097168, 0.19759021699428558, -0.42540889978408813, 0.5077401399612427, -0.21310295164585114, 0.45780715346336365, 0.6825451850891113, 0.4262714684009552, -0.3873717784881592, -1.0756839513778687, 0.26600560545921326, 0.2037385106086731, 0.3813578188419342, -0.6773690581321716, -0.43439358472824097, 0.300284743309021, -0.2671224772930145, -0.4778168499469757, 0.94574373960495, 1.2345672845840454, -0.4307822287082672, 0.3438987731933594, -0.2365926206111908, -0.4653938114643097, -0.2857963442802429, -0.9881238341331482, -1.4476350545883179, -0.16813981533050537, -1.0599451065063477, -0.047180112451314926, 0.2850872278213501, 0.010981340892612934, 0.3747241199016571, 0.7521722912788391, 0.35387203097343445, -0.7581173181533813, 0.1701299399137497, 0.382456511259079, 1.0056030750274658, -0.2209663987159729, -0.3584437668323517, 0.8210344314575195, -0.6340558528900146, 0.5748611092567444, -0.3149081766605377, 0.12402401864528656, -0.28689253330230713, -0.7837757468223572, 0.6818510890007019, -0.4939636290073395, -0.1062462329864502, -0.209331676363945, 0.11493799090385437, 0.6559967398643494, -0.2820186913013458, 0.026299545541405678, 0.1874677985906601, -0.550912618637085, -0.8491432666778564, 0.4284905791282654, 0.46666696667671204, 0.10864018648862839, 0.25672978162765503, 0.8228105306625366, -0.15480227768421173, 0.6055228114128113, -0.20283791422843933, -0.34576210379600525, -1.173496127128601, 0.21461904048919678, 0.3781404495239258, 0.5218484401702881, 0.5624280571937561, -0.6079868674278259, -1.432746171951294, -0.4706650972366333, -0.3431984484195709, -0.7075287699699402, 0.4843350052833557, 0.3735850751399994, 0.10635656118392944, -0.9295870065689087, -0.2148607224225998, -0.17632350325584412, -0.9648754000663757, 0.4855608642101288, 0.17446143925189972, -0.38361626863479614, 0.7346349954605103, 0.36364975571632385, -0.6337306499481201, 0.0016506826505064964, -0.07797010987997055, 0.409342497587204, -0.38151881098747253, -0.22707952558994293, -0.062464505434036255, 0.2396889179944992, 0.8390218615531921, 0.46600767970085144, 0.2897438406944275, -0.22334150969982147, 0.43174898624420166, -0.09729602932929993, -0.6304553747177124, 0.03215106204152107, 0.41868436336517334, 0.6198999285697937, 0.11020929366350174, 0.3787277936935425, -0.35473743081092834, -0.023852240294218063, 0.6424775123596191, 0.11203166097402573, -0.4916076958179474, 0.12009738385677338, 0.02792106382548809, -0.03189779818058014, -0.6508769392967224, -0.75630784034729, 0.509952962398529, -0.2637191712856293, 0.5345390439033508, -0.5466580986976624, 0.37887462973594666, 0.7444546818733215, -0.6576151251792908, 0.5654043555259705, 0.057467956095933914, -0.24681992828845978, 0.7075160145759583, -0.4811277985572815, 1.2096030712127686, -1.0229533910751343, 0.36572524905204773, 0.5816810131072998, 1.0140756368637085, 0.1608799248933792, 0.5674018859863281, 0.4399679899215698, -1.0304278135299683, 0.48359939455986023, -0.06119830161333084, 0.5585238337516785, 0.6487438678741455, -0.24250753223896027, -0.05333349481225014, -0.04996464028954506, -0.5341766476631165, -0.38062137365341187, -0.03142969310283661, 0.08057898283004761, -0.26498663425445557, -0.7407782673835754, 0.5176817774772644, -0.550480306148529, 0.1312176138162613, -0.3596506118774414, 0.12804624438285828, -0.23798877000808716, -0.8951804637908936, 0.3793417513370514, 0.1716373860836029, -0.5718599557876587, 0.3448227643966675, 0.2794544994831085, -0.5239830613136292, 0.4922317564487457, 0.7196741104125977, -0.2472788691520691, -0.9769865870475769, -0.02532569132745266, 0.2998286783695221, -0.32453814148902893, -0.305651992559433, 0.7884307503700256, -0.5430473685264587, -0.4001588225364685, 0.06740754842758179, -1.1659319400787354, -0.3003488779067993, -0.8194875121116638, -0.09580538421869278, 0.8015339970588684, -0.544374406337738, -0.9214775562286377, -0.2731187641620636, 0.21495258808135986, -0.17266078293323517, -0.18904349207878113, 0.0919138640165329, -0.6281403303146362, 0.2043740153312683, 0.2049884796142578, -0.13389194011688232, -0.4489659070968628, 0.22409740090370178, -0.1406661421060562, 0.45070043206214905, -0.2643800973892212, 0.8621296882629395, 0.2566573917865753, 0.5272064805030823, -0.558297872543335, 0.2720213532447815, -0.8348398804664612, 0.4207721948623657, -0.7208554744720459, -0.3371502161026001, -0.6232693195343018, -0.6736115217208862, -0.18609389662742615, -0.07757484912872314, -0.3640372157096863, -0.5653667449951172, -0.7651201486587524, 0.2565881311893463, -0.23988571763038635, -1.0757018327713013, 0.8431434035301208, -0.39689505100250244, 0.4198482930660248, 0.6173269152641296, 0.16262945532798767, -0.01820347085595131, -0.16704913973808289, 0.28530868887901306, -0.781696081161499, 0.6614541411399841, 0.35676825046539307, 0.41335034370422363, 0.6447864174842834, -0.8249976634979248, -0.44295966625213623, -0.9334635734558105, 0.6859274506568909, -0.6047528982162476, -0.8709815144538879, -0.21787096560001373, -0.2869982421398163, -0.5544019937515259, -0.047302186489105225, -0.7059839367866516, -0.41794252395629883, 0.22356295585632324, -0.8833184838294983, 0.6278952956199646, -0.07344377785921097, -0.28096720576286316, -1.0485498905181885, -0.3582319915294647, 0.35732778906822205, 0.05149466171860695, 0.4833173453807831, 1.3019132614135742, -0.18044136464595795, -0.47992584109306335, 0.8770352602005005, 0.2027861624956131, -0.21699801087379456, -0.16862235963344574, 0.11020504683256149, 0.054952796548604965, -0.45737335085868835, -0.06312604248523712, -0.042348816990852356, -0.5780291557312012, -0.5540412068367004, -0.5264045596122742, 0.30410251021385193, 0.6293684244155884, 0.12413189560174942, -0.3154655694961548, 0.47887617349624634, 0.4796500504016876, -0.6505722403526306, -0.21440568566322327, 0.8470138907432556, -0.3828418552875519, 0.4231714606285095, -0.06044891104102135, -1.339460849761963, -0.6757708787918091, -0.3864891231060028, 0.5974830985069275, -0.8968074917793274, 0.37270450592041016, -0.5993731617927551, 0.32175445556640625, 0.10293488949537277, 0.08572252839803696, 0.566571831703186, 0.035281483083963394, 0.06187430024147034, -0.41833996772766113, 0.40942978858947754, -0.5166348814964294, -0.6114914417266846, -0.2953406870365143, -0.2485221028327942, -0.08477745950222015, 0.965850293636322, 0.8268150091171265, -0.5560992360115051, 0.1690538227558136, 0.3147727847099304, 0.3362038731575012, 0.1622198224067688, -0.6524337530136108, -0.0005892429035156965, 0.028626248240470886, 1.0192781686782837, 0.038036517798900604, -0.04408988356590271, -1.5731182098388672, 0.11159844696521759, -0.6673855781555176, -0.28539398312568665, -0.2080671787261963, -0.27678975462913513, 0.5608314275741577, -0.04457079991698265, 0.5185123682022095, -0.5270715951919556, 0.508378803730011, 0.2965604066848755, -0.153558611869812, -0.27496469020843506, 0.3719448745250702, -0.7811230421066284, -0.18314075469970703, -1.087549090385437, -0.7100880742073059, 0.5871027708053589, -0.29334723949432373, 0.05859173834323883, 0.9966843724250793, 0.361560195684433, -0.053863562643527985, -0.5173566937446594, 0.7410470843315125, 0.23538906872272491, -0.5042756795883179, -0.252848744392395, -0.11047808080911636, -0.07718592137098312, -0.00621049664914608, -0.5745936632156372, 0.2187289595603943, 0.12157578021287918, 0.42941421270370483, 0.39413779973983765, -0.5641640424728394, -1.2214890718460083, 0.01740383543074131, 0.6308987140655518, 0.9142508506774902, 0.24953745305538177, 0.424481600522995, -0.15110990405082703, 0.30953720211982727, -0.7206376194953918, 0.6315933465957642, -0.3903292715549469, 0.2880554497241974, 0.9101671576499939, 0.0638749822974205, 0.1796102523803711, 0.14204742014408112, -0.32259881496429443, -0.5453920364379883, -0.3184235692024231, 0.5548830628395081, 0.5949552655220032, -1.2642767429351807, 0.16310900449752808, 0.28041326999664307, -0.02121846191585064, -0.9683382511138916, 0.08975415676832199, -0.16794829070568085, -0.14933472871780396, -0.7768675088882446, -0.3926447629928589, -0.13313016295433044, -0.6583631634712219, 0.5588021874427795, -0.07609985023736954, 0.2849665880203247, 0.06432035565376282, 0.002164336619898677, -1.095232367515564, -0.8157052397727966, 0.69542396068573, 1.3516874313354492, -0.019822243601083755, -0.03190004453063011, 0.1579517126083374, 0.917436420917511, 0.2619076073169708, -0.4317416548728943, 0.5458799004554749, 0.00526821194216609, -0.021604178473353386, -0.5391644239425659, 0.6918706297874451, 0.42912647128105164, 0.2880159318447113, -0.5545276403427124, 1.1342378854751587, -0.09270063787698746, -0.8073034882545471, -0.3387421667575836, 0.23537714779376984, 1.1398860216140747, 0.6038194894790649, 0.20285728573799133, 0.13203822076320648, 0.7469101548194885, 0.3007119596004486, 0.33206412196159363, -1.0670382976531982, -0.0005491606425493956, -0.27990028262138367, 0.3079739809036255, 0.3552832007408142, -0.9231180548667908, 0.1813638061285019, 0.7606557607650757, -0.23879505693912506, -0.24046075344085693, -0.6646426320075989, 0.9375253915786743, -0.13981471955776215, -0.2499936819076538, -0.7576099634170532, -0.003474477445706725, -0.9603779315948486, -0.4222964942455292, -0.12466380000114441, -1.0169684886932373, -0.15760661661624908, 0.7498220801353455, -0.8194738626480103, -0.3940475583076477, 0.3863820433616638, 0.7725337147712708, 0.20724818110466003, 0.129862979054451, -0.576943576335907, -0.43917059898376465, -0.4016406238079071, 0.3911466598510742, 0.29741570353507996, -0.5482283234596252, 0.9911085367202759, -0.13803572952747345, 0.631585419178009, 0.5106632709503174, -0.4209921360015869, -0.5376080274581909, -0.12868787348270416, 0.1759100705385208, -1.073363184928894, -0.5329427719116211, -0.25826963782310486, 0.9279154539108276, -1.3349497318267822, -0.7535409331321716, -0.6025543212890625, -0.008784810081124306, -0.25747814774513245, 0.23354314267635345, 0.12419415265321732, 0.5476782321929932, 0.1618974208831787, 0.031516220420598984, 0.3232640027999878, 0.6067866086959839, 0.3552321493625641, -0.28179123997688293, 0.3966611623764038, -0.15453197062015533, 0.04045878350734711, -0.5523874163627625, -0.13545091450214386, 0.16660772264003754, -0.2024296671152115, 0.5017144083976746, 0.13443028926849365, 1.0372521877288818, -0.13255265355110168, -0.4197094738483429, -0.26618942618370056, 0.19330556690692902, 0.2098979353904724, -0.4065479636192322, -0.06793643534183502, -0.8417223691940308, -0.09154786914587021, -0.17858877778053284, -0.7694857120513916, -0.9291186332702637, 0.5303810238838196, -0.800712525844574, -0.005937353242188692, -1.043259859085083, -0.4970540702342987, 0.5032498240470886, 0.21598190069198608, 0.6607311964035034, -0.48130741715431213, -0.14631259441375732, 0.5542184114456177, 0.3510114848613739, 0.36364254355430603, 0.25823578238487244, 0.443145215511322, 0.12961621582508087, -0.4037396013736725, -0.4743249714374542, -0.1408621221780777, 0.5598121881484985, 0.44421014189720154, -0.9564511775970459, -0.7320285439491272, -0.0028617798816412687, 0.16203603148460388, -0.4555385708808899, -0.958919107913971, 0.00135909509845078, -0.8675656914710999, 0.03130096569657326, -0.8532560467720032, -0.26410409808158875, -0.011257636360824108, 0.8462855815887451, 0.5924213528633118, -0.18847617506980896, -0.24200783669948578, 0.20395250618457794, 0.8289954662322998, -0.24408982694149017, 0.5294005870819092, 0.36084094643592834, 0.4355027973651886, -0.40955594182014465, -0.007482045330107212, 1.0930181741714478, 0.6005375385284424, 0.06932070851325989, 0.1934327483177185, -0.08847638219594955, 0.35456761717796326, 0.44581449031829834, 0.3640309274196625, -0.6323601007461548, 0.11618929356336594, 0.28879502415657043, -0.08568789809942245, -0.029600083827972412, -0.6059302687644958, 0.3893578350543976, 0.6806678771972656, 0.05842708796262741, 0.22122488915920258, 0.40816161036491394, 0.056348737329244614, 0.11569079756736755, -0.2613215744495392, 0.5018832087516785, -1.054046630859375, -0.4455765187740326, -0.29372531175613403, 1.3960094451904297, 0.7682539820671082, 0.24041308462619781, 0.31875088810920715, 0.07924631983041763, 0.26043635606765747, 0.03177434206008911, 0.35841256380081177, 0.5973705649375916, -0.6823705434799194, -0.7336015701293945, -0.39856746792793274, 0.485002726316452, 0.5892849564552307, 0.2009846419095993, 0.24810495972633362, -0.07593270391225815, -0.5619211792945862, 1.1156061887741089, -0.5528239607810974, -0.33816057443618774, 0.3561028838157654, -0.094283327460289, -0.25709789991378784, -0.6029331684112549, 0.19160903990268707, -0.9933252334594727, -0.7602917551994324, 0.7887924909591675, -0.4158311188220978, 0.23397618532180786, 0.07844215631484985, -0.5351158976554871, 0.6444671154022217, 0.12682345509529114, 0.38805288076400757, -0.8621886968612671, 0.40906891226768494, 0.3094364106655121, 0.3228028416633606, 0.08770990371704102, -0.5934528112411499, 0.04682551324367523, -0.25408273935317993, -0.4813188314437866, -0.2865195870399475, 0.4685600996017456, -0.6594046354293823, -0.5892580151557922, -0.5062716603279114, 0.14122894406318665, -0.3630647659301758, -0.3158665597438812, -0.5968649387359619, 0.6400606036186218, -0.07585877180099487, 0.4128930866718292, 0.8179611563682556, 0.5280784368515015, -0.011433690786361694, -0.06612851470708847, 0.33933693170547485, -0.5164920687675476, 0.016160238534212112, -1.2655121088027954, 0.46774938702583313, -0.10987155884504318, -0.2576025724411011, -0.44344672560691833, -1.0867539644241333, -0.05307423695921898, -0.4611174762248993, 0.0997653380036354, -0.9963821768760681, -0.12937027215957642, 0.1757751852273941, 0.4901798367500305, 0.33963000774383545, -0.16195577383041382, 0.4469008445739746, 0.22846874594688416, 0.804190456867218, -0.6632131934165955, 0.5462819933891296, -0.07963407784700394, 0.655592679977417, 0.28209188580513, 0.6386405825614929, 0.21824003756046295, 0.06335284560918808, -0.10914628207683563, -0.5735233426094055, 0.07879610359668732, 0.12280891090631485, -0.9868026375770569, 0.07735354453325272, 0.4722203016281128, -0.3451036214828491, -0.8841356635093689, -1.2240177392959595, -0.006243979092687368, -0.5149514079093933, 0.5331899523735046, -0.39068907499313354, -0.21384197473526, 0.24571271240711212, 0.25008752942085266, 0.48278751969337463, -0.9856881499290466, 3.9013097286224365, 1.188521146774292, 0.5311726331710815, -0.06362182646989822, 0.27780207991600037, 0.8438290953636169, 0.31648311018943787, -0.9088668823242188, 0.1817856878042221, -0.33783599734306335, -1.0245620012283325, 1.0829390287399292, 0.1445673704147339, 0.050867289304733276, 0.31196659803390503, 0.3004893362522125, -1.2877697944641113, 0.9461174011230469, -0.5376325845718384, -0.9133076071739197, -1.0543056726455688, 0.7801164984703064, 0.0943380817770958, -0.3350830674171448, 0.5039761066436768, 0.5381162762641907, -0.3487277626991272, 0.3658308684825897, -0.7720763087272644, -0.3612328767776489, -0.44788700342178345, -0.39950674772262573, 0.7565825581550598, -0.1366240382194519, -0.3009372055530548, 0.2673155665397644, -0.193389430642128, 0.05071588233113289, 0.1647181212902069, 0.20680539309978485, 0.4540739953517914, -0.5936630964279175, -0.2903295159339905, -0.7045431137084961, -0.09618261456489563, 0.3385046422481537, -0.5532076358795166, -0.29054805636405945, 0.11945556849241257, -0.3256499469280243, 1.0148590803146362, -0.8927574753761292, 0.8324639797210693, -0.11718795448541641, -0.7403959035873413, -0.031441256403923035, -0.41613805294036865, -0.8314091563224792, -0.057106103748083115, -0.006720063276588917, 0.9743819236755371, 0.35785162448883057, -0.6270226836204529, -0.20861826837062836, 0.485985666513443, 0.729726254940033, 0.15296530723571777, 0.7739034295082092, -0.3604862093925476, -0.39270922541618347, 0.3754197955131531, -0.2889994978904724, -0.6149283647537231, -0.006878822576254606, 0.7296521663665771, 0.4013442099094391, -0.015806077048182487, 0.6960038542747498, -0.010377527214586735, -0.3379228115081787, 0.7541040182113647, 0.1157536581158638, -0.19898702204227448, -0.3564303517341614, 0.6938537955284119, 0.13901379704475403, -0.6266877055168152, -0.36022457480430603, -0.7525770664215088, 0.7927244305610657, 0.3458999991416931, -0.16064810752868652, 0.698734700679779, -0.3421817123889923, 0.3222886621952057 ]
{"Title": "Identification of de novo mutations in prenatal neurodevelopment-associated genes in schizophrenia in two Han Chinese patient-sibling family-based cohorts", "Authors": "Jiang Shan, Zhou Daizhan, Wang Yin-Ying, Jia Peilin, Wan Chunling, Li Xingwang, He Guang, Cao Dongmei, Jiang Xiaoqian, Kendler Kenneth S., Tsuang Ming, Mize Travis, Wu Jain-Shing, Lu Yimei, He Lin, Chen Jingchun, Zhao Zhongming, Chen Xiangning", "Abstract": "Abstract Schizophrenia (SCZ) is a severe psychiatric disorder with a strong genetic component. High heritability of SCZ suggests a major role for transmitted genetic variants. Furthermore, SCZ is also associated with a marked reduction in fecundity, leading to the hypothesis that alleles with large effects on risk might often occur de novo. In this study, we conducted whole-genome sequencing for 23 families from two cohorts with matched unaffected siblings and parents. Two nonsense de novo mutations (DNMs) in GJC1 and HIST1H2AD were identified in SCZ patients. Ten genes ( DPYSL2, NBPF1, SDK1, ZNF595, ZNF718, GCNT2, SNX9, AACS, KCNQ1 and MSI2 ) were found to carry more DNMs in SCZ patients than their unaffected siblings by burden test. Expression analyses indicated that these DNM implicated genes showed significantly higher expression in prefrontal cortex in prenatal stage. The DNM in the GJC1 gene is highly likely a loss function mutation (pLI = 0.94), leading to the dysregulation of ion channel in the glutamatergic excitatory neurons. Analysis of rare variants in independent exome sequencing dataset indicates that GJC1 has significantly more rare variants in SCZ patients than in unaffected controls. Data from genome-wide association studies suggested that common variants in the GJC1 gene may be associated with SCZ and SCZ-related traits. Genes co-expressed with GJC1 are involved in SCZ, SCZ-associated pathways and drug targets. These evidence suggest that GJC1 may be a risk gene for SCZ and its function may be involved in prenatal and early neurodevelopment, a vulnerable period for developmental disorders such as SCZ.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19011007"}
10.1101/19000661
[ -0.13706398010253906, 0.06625146418809891, 0.43534934520721436, 1.12586510181427, -0.7954146862030029, -0.07981165498495102, -0.4870186150074005, -0.5412375330924988, 0.3442588746547699, 0.49429556727409363, -0.06712570786476135, -0.18480777740478516, -0.05339536815881729, -0.35682904720306396, -0.16902977228164673, -0.434387743473053, -0.4016749858856201, 0.0960809513926506, -0.256027489900589, -0.1337215006351471, 0.0014116502134129405, -0.15660983324050903, -0.6374312043190002, 0.5994946956634521, -0.058982133865356445, 0.42850202322006226, 0.2071087807416916, -0.31936559081077576, 1.2115418910980225, 0.30219846963882446, 0.04035163298249245, -1.021863341331482, 0.747391402721405, -0.8961020708084106, -0.5062421560287476, -0.20306581258773804, 1.100325345993042, 0.39736056327819824, -0.39746972918510437, -0.5107758641242981, 0.17831183969974518, 0.46355733275413513, 0.16215337812900543, -0.254304975271225, -0.5815140008926392, -0.7990916967391968, -0.4103102385997772, 0.515255868434906, -0.10219652950763702, 0.017154511064291, -0.5221051573753357, 0.030786223709583282, 0.3141781985759735, -0.3219785690307617, 0.14934386312961578, 0.1362829953432083, -0.07174462825059891, -0.40089014172554016, -0.5794968008995056, -0.26306819915771484, 0.1722445785999298, -0.2708964943885803, 0.3792543411254883, -1.0542465448379517, 0.7447217702865601, 0.6752573847770691, -0.4307064712047577, -0.9529644846916199, -0.1368279755115509, -0.16083924472332, -0.11670384556055069, 0.7025906443595886, -0.4589533507823944, -0.33644500374794006, -0.3884945511817932, -0.9605401754379272, 0.6901515126228333, -0.4225562810897827, 0.40798404812812805, -0.037008125334978104, -0.16496974229812622, 0.25377708673477173, 0.3343486487865448, -0.18600773811340332, -0.31288790702819824, -0.3068002164363861, 0.3792400658130646, 0.2584022581577301, 0.07533708959817886, 0.43180251121520996, -0.2516838312149048, 0.4136553406715393, -0.1473124623298645, -0.1701720654964447, -0.6491142511367798, 1.1739050149917603, -0.07824860513210297, -0.07205696403980255, -0.02712918631732464, -0.5850221514701843, 0.8488966822624207, 0.7237673401832581, -0.8632716536521912, 0.5044761896133423, -0.6753151416778564, 0.4488990008831024, 0.5118749737739563, 0.10984405875205994, -0.7921748161315918, -0.9494025111198425, 0.47964125871658325, 0.13206833600997925, -0.6992844939231873, -0.16283878684043884, 0.0699458047747612, 0.4273589253425598, 0.04163690656423569, 0.5533616542816162, -0.7347820997238159, -0.7841123938560486, 0.06973312795162201, -0.5319961905479431, 0.5067660808563232, -0.34842681884765625, 0.20324906706809998, -0.08366688340902328, -0.11780864000320435, 0.32457834482192993, -0.406179279088974, -0.033713340759277344, 0.11603497713804245, -0.17320680618286133, -0.20113512873649597, 0.9264773726463318, -0.16168005764484406, -0.04593653976917267, -0.07169992476701736, 0.6077759265899658, 0.1276206374168396, -0.2945862412452698, -0.08349326252937317, 0.21518433094024658, -1.0056390762329102, 1.3316848278045654, 0.32343679666519165, 0.5069645047187805, -0.06393184512853622, -1.4285707473754883, -0.5688114166259766, 0.24723345041275024, 0.18799695372581482, 0.3437507152557373, -0.19723577797412872, -0.8294437527656555, -0.29369649291038513, 0.5825082659721375, -0.16964663565158844, 0.15072286128997803, -0.08352255821228027, 0.5461781620979309, -0.6590178608894348, 0.6521190404891968, 0.03224785253405571, 0.04221734404563904, -0.6213882565498352, 0.40258342027664185, 0.45850348472595215, 0.1865256279706955, 0.4850507080554962, -0.6731016635894775, 0.4517955183982849, 0.1037631705403328, -0.3792405426502228, 0.4072851538658142, -0.0128241665661335, 0.24373872578144073, 1.1419137716293335, 0.3756566345691681, 0.3967664837837219, 0.1879517287015915, -0.07703197747468948, 0.1903122365474701, 0.67701256275177, 0.6470650434494019, -0.4815598726272583, 0.20969173312187195, -0.4210244119167328, -0.018861306831240654, -0.20104435086250305, -0.5898113250732422, -0.42159372568130493, 0.5275054574012756, -0.4840236306190491, 0.02062111720442772, -0.45081213116645813, 0.5936015844345093, -0.30978158116340637, 0.18716096878051758, 0.6920403242111206, -0.14154303073883057, -0.859139084815979, 1.0826067924499512, -0.4197194576263428, -0.42353197932243347, -0.14999514818191528, 0.24730320274829865, 0.49386313557624817, 0.4054411053657532, -0.7109584808349609, 0.8707717061042786, 0.5717183947563171, -0.3337221145629883, -0.1305994689464569, 0.7631816267967224, 0.9446865916252136, -1.0844465494155884, -0.2469683140516281, 0.3324280381202698, -0.11029811948537827, 0.5594968795776367, -0.5518537163734436, -0.23098696768283844, 0.802436351776123, 0.1380969136953354, 0.35501816868782043, 0.46073079109191895, 0.6484473943710327, 0.9741864800453186, -0.35227909684181213, -0.8827381134033203, 0.6393754482269287, 0.8917796015739441, -0.09555946290493011, 1.0632630586624146, 0.518810510635376, 0.2571832835674286, 0.6001455783843994, 0.3522053062915802, -0.18376263976097107, -0.0746069997549057, 0.8590303659439087, 0.4279335141181946, 0.5416868329048157, 0.4880932867527008, -0.19393602013587952, -0.0337161086499691, -0.2361428141593933, 0.10066524147987366, 0.049152523279190063, 0.9205594062805176, -1.0081838369369507, 0.5386533141136169, 0.7779895663261414, 0.42433977127075195, 0.03446979820728302, -0.7590658068656921, 0.26649269461631775, 0.3345493674278259, -0.12231842428445816, 0.15710169076919556, 0.456122487783432, -0.6282712817192078, -0.6755501627922058, 0.16320981085300446, 0.990976870059967, 0.9524381160736084, 0.20816199481487274, -0.16679759323596954, 0.17884086072444916, -0.633817195892334, -0.6193857192993164, -0.835342288017273, -1.735384464263916, -0.4447070062160492, -0.8480918407440186, 0.14282777905464172, 0.44757041335105896, 0.03951641544699669, 0.8902352452278137, 0.0028969068080186844, 0.4448908567428589, 0.03373891860246658, 0.05640989542007446, -0.005374860484153032, 0.5001055002212524, 0.30889618396759033, -0.8613331317901611, 0.36088815331459045, 0.3802505135536194, -0.01385969016700983, -0.46430763602256775, -0.1784805804491043, -0.5457789897918701, -0.8067478537559509, 0.30548593401908875, -0.955208957195282, 0.1915677785873413, -0.05271953344345093, -0.07283160835504532, -0.195913165807724, 0.04046580567955971, 0.5098476409912109, 0.24136316776275635, -0.12345954030752182, -0.3156511187553406, 0.5275489687919617, 0.5538104772567749, 0.04752584546804428, 0.4792957603931427, 0.576029360294342, -0.49186110496520996, 0.6640153527259827, 0.32529741525650024, -0.23594829440116882, -1.1271722316741943, 0.6395350098609924, 0.6086808443069458, -0.5044503808021545, 0.038376692682504654, -0.8253188133239746, -1.2260392904281616, -0.5694437026977539, -0.2404613345861435, 0.0831664502620697, -0.13466687500476837, 0.7716325521469116, -0.004766932688653469, -1.417049765586853, 0.21410547196865082, -0.8928177952766418, -0.6847928762435913, 0.3722836375236511, 0.4868663549423218, -0.24995841085910797, 0.29362916946411133, 0.18669764697551727, -0.5100379586219788, 0.43054771423339844, 0.37203142046928406, 0.37613797187805176, 0.39081671833992004, -0.5389057993888855, -0.4264967143535614, -0.028035776689648628, 0.4291048049926758, 0.3781041204929352, -0.008859099820256233, -0.3938196301460266, -0.00890559982508421, -0.41692572832107544, -0.3287302851676941, 0.1905054897069931, 0.664587140083313, 0.47445032000541687, 0.13259902596473694, 0.38054409623146057, -0.26851344108581543, -0.5307188034057617, 0.32617437839508057, 0.14256827533245087, -0.8898376822471619, 0.6356734037399292, -0.22282233834266663, 0.5029016733169556, -0.801957905292511, -0.5576290488243103, -0.07270985096693039, 0.5737847089767456, 0.1829204261302948, -1.1020605564117432, 0.48716816306114197, -0.16658596694469452, -0.41504335403442383, 0.1642313152551651, 0.23396214842796326, -0.024602970108389854, 0.8348644375801086, 0.1513281911611557, 1.5933575630187988, -1.2649548053741455, -0.34841006994247437, 0.46558240056037903, 0.5339842438697815, 0.2832280397415161, 0.4531944692134857, 0.20601488649845123, -0.4801601767539978, 0.49068590998649597, -0.5106396675109863, 0.4151073098182678, 0.15706895291805267, -0.06986168026924133, 0.19566567242145538, 0.34599190950393677, -0.5906189680099487, -0.15116193890571594, -0.23638367652893066, 0.18300539255142212, -0.17375577986240387, 0.38578009605407715, 0.41159993410110474, -0.3305060565471649, 0.19529296457767487, 0.00886393990367651, 0.4986105263233185, 0.11908023059368134, -0.5123428106307983, -0.05281117558479309, -0.09493990987539291, 0.2404823899269104, -0.02605332061648369, 0.057273756712675095, -0.44250521063804626, 0.012647251598536968, 0.1436682939529419, -0.00002566492184996605, -0.8823204040527344, -0.10574448108673096, 0.3551636338233948, 0.08455220609903336, 0.08323361724615097, 0.08747215569019318, -0.6163321137428284, -0.06598702073097229, 0.2503582239151001, -0.7323195338249207, -0.15484215319156647, -0.255341112613678, 0.30251115560531616, 0.8345233201980591, -0.5375097393989563, -0.9916695952415466, -0.24455763399600983, -0.35370075702667236, -0.5729474425315857, -0.03467259928584099, 0.4497149884700775, -0.562227189540863, 0.7633503675460815, 0.3500820994377136, -0.1663902848958969, -0.5937507152557373, 0.061250511556863785, -0.5330711007118225, 0.1378890424966812, 0.10493063181638718, 1.884325623512268, 0.027623439207673073, 0.1790754497051239, -0.39792147278785706, 0.37618839740753174, -0.7672731876373291, 0.6448746919631958, -0.2586883008480072, -0.319779634475708, -0.2464948445558548, 0.01599140837788582, -0.15172602236270905, 0.03677944466471672, 0.2709588408470154, 0.12978419661521912, -0.1662607342004776, 0.442409485578537, -0.6642429232597351, -0.13706719875335693, 1.326108455657959, -0.3228786885738373, 0.6198478937149048, 1.2049893140792847, -0.31440410017967224, -0.004784265998750925, 0.27139753103256226, 0.1555282473564148, -0.8070610761642456, -0.009240909479558468, -0.2251812070608139, -0.10356023162603378, 0.33973249793052673, -0.4194883108139038, -0.25936341285705566, -0.41347625851631165, 0.6270841956138611, -0.6928455233573914, -0.5322307348251343, -0.5497928261756897, -0.08138725906610489, -0.44750314950942993, -0.3169086277484894, -0.7102309465408325, 0.11207833141088486, -0.16465969383716583, 0.039125632494688034, 0.16033586859703064, -0.6020023822784424, -0.9805172681808472, -1.147029161453247, -0.6574533581733704, -0.2275496870279312, 0.2585808336734772, 0.08984556049108505, 1.3454434871673584, -0.4351511597633362, -0.5698973536491394, 0.591783344745636, 0.39268815517425537, -0.8100906610488892, -0.5779373645782471, -0.09663441777229309, -0.004580051638185978, -0.5412478446960449, -0.36876380443573, -0.24281485378742218, -0.8343361020088196, -0.07599494606256485, -0.8716080188751221, 0.10481169819831848, 0.531963050365448, 0.21388974785804749, -0.10835891962051392, 0.6439297199249268, 0.7741093039512634, -1.267478585243225, -1.0026123523712158, 0.1402227133512497, 0.10307306796312332, 0.23278744518756866, -0.3762168288230896, -0.19943998754024506, -0.22359542548656464, -0.6827539205551147, 0.41841211915016174, -0.886313259601593, 0.4919378161430359, -0.6039267778396606, -0.20482513308525085, 0.0921279788017273, 0.44154953956604004, 0.5275158286094666, -0.15297232568264008, 0.031705934554338455, -0.7313563227653503, 0.2593468427658081, -0.08746501803398132, -0.09161733835935593, -0.07960604876279831, -0.24682334065437317, 0.42021557688713074, 1.2051923274993896, 0.13588127493858337, -0.2645992338657379, 0.3224642276763916, 0.7136886715888977, 0.8339787721633911, 0.4292558431625366, -0.6271041631698608, -0.393180251121521, 0.032446205615997314, 0.5710359811782837, -0.025344472378492355, 0.1002984568476677, -1.4672821760177612, 0.07010263949632645, -0.9635835886001587, -0.4124912917613983, 0.36509373784065247, -1.0409852266311646, 0.3115275502204895, -0.006256707012653351, 0.8516444563865662, -0.28416863083839417, 0.43496251106262207, -0.37348899245262146, -0.08339226990938187, -0.010044785216450691, 0.6142557263374329, -0.7474509477615356, -0.6831092238426208, -0.4714702367782593, -0.3789028823375702, 0.862931489944458, -0.13630250096321106, -0.19075675308704376, 0.9515107870101929, 0.15388311445713043, 0.2758849263191223, -0.44549572467803955, 0.7611486911773682, 1.0947164297103882, -0.11435487866401672, -0.23436324298381805, 0.03931690379977226, 0.14666348695755005, 0.35720857977867126, -0.16389240324497223, -0.07694466412067413, -0.2783767879009247, 0.17445185780525208, -0.12285473197698593, -0.18385931849479675, -1.1589860916137695, -0.34507471323013306, 0.2951608896255493, 0.4977754056453705, 0.6953256726264954, 0.5968118906021118, 0.22840842604637146, -0.4764396548271179, 0.04629296809434891, 0.4879145324230194, -0.08520794659852982, -0.03055739216506481, 0.6598945260047913, 0.10856426507234573, -0.4416486918926239, 0.9989920854568481, -0.49104055762290955, -0.4112219214439392, 0.008534828200936317, 0.52188640832901, 0.4550221860408783, -0.8923231363296509, 0.23596595227718353, 0.20087537169456482, -0.6997079849243164, -0.5985577702522278, 0.31586623191833496, -0.25348278880119324, -0.17271098494529724, -0.22458268702030182, -0.447022944688797, 0.7489625215530396, -0.4196133613586426, 0.31846922636032104, 0.008966919966042042, -0.20642605423927307, 0.03126620128750801, -0.5542622804641724, -0.08952377736568451, -0.8481749296188354, 1.1159354448318481, 1.199882984161377, -0.11509767174720764, 0.2755599319934845, -0.031842805445194244, 0.38693967461586, 0.5225358605384827, -0.1610265076160431, 0.2080356478691101, -0.09581082314252853, -0.3213167190551758, 0.3108464181423187, 0.6740930676460266, -0.011359849013388157, 0.6007210612297058, -0.09033961594104767, 1.5095436573028564, 0.3795696496963501, -0.9850503206253052, -0.45122992992401123, 0.1305076628923416, 0.8402404189109802, 0.25611352920532227, 0.289192259311676, 0.13302423059940338, 1.0805238485336304, 0.6868693828582764, 0.4000548720359802, -0.4858930706977844, -0.7046821117401123, -0.7627137303352356, 0.17391610145568848, 0.3699359893798828, -0.5665348768234253, 0.3141821026802063, 0.6935129761695862, -0.36893230676651, -0.5299838781356812, -1.1647950410842896, 0.6035557389259338, -0.31865423917770386, -0.22533991932868958, -0.6977973580360413, 0.3537864089012146, -0.8253185153007507, -1.142808198928833, -0.18047784268856049, -1.0380654335021973, 0.3514733612537384, 0.8739519715309143, -0.9077761769294739, -0.47815775871276855, 0.38171306252479553, -0.09345757961273193, 0.06284648180007935, 0.1603795289993286, -0.888552725315094, -0.229225754737854, -0.852758526802063, 0.6833809614181519, 0.3547787070274353, -0.30172765254974365, 0.7026386857032776, -0.18920524418354034, 0.6517911553382874, 0.45827794075012207, -0.31818467378616333, -0.3613928258419037, -0.06684891134500504, 0.47208839654922485, -1.0626009702682495, -0.29840654134750366, -0.6229208111763, 0.5826608538627625, -1.514105200767517, 0.3114244043827057, -0.5430134534835815, -0.014397132210433483, 0.38457775115966797, 0.23626671731472015, -0.5668472647666931, 0.7148412466049194, 0.37490710616111755, 0.40127626061439514, 0.07125461101531982, 0.09300525486469269, 0.722097635269165, 0.47014904022216797, 0.21771478652954102, -0.1566070318222046, -0.2692796289920807, -0.7860950231552124, 0.2278202623128891, 0.6647048592567444, -0.5994254350662231, 0.17809493839740753, -0.09531284123659134, 0.37674710154533386, -0.19528581202030182, -0.7832813858985901, -0.13985295593738556, 0.30948835611343384, 0.9461300373077393, 0.22396224737167358, 0.23904448747634888, -0.08919575065374374, -0.49129045009613037, -0.6431660652160645, -0.8000401258468628, -1.375089168548584, 0.40586134791374207, -0.3523195683956146, 0.2755115330219269, -0.6697672009468079, -0.44433829188346863, -0.03816821798682213, 0.6654309630393982, 0.1529916375875473, 0.5443518161773682, 0.7562666535377502, 0.5332837104797363, 0.4364979565143585, 0.3973757028579712, 0.41295790672302246, 0.5244354009628296, 0.24330446124076843, -1.117429494857788, -0.047225579619407654, -0.040471151471138, 0.5947530269622803, 0.3027980625629425, -0.03542381525039673, -0.9043101668357849, 0.10734783858060837, -0.11007997393608093, -0.3004242777824402, -0.6283403038978577, -0.08673302829265594, -0.8870025277137756, -0.10954900085926056, -0.4840780198574066, -0.23917339742183685, 0.06936279684305191, 0.31915920972824097, 0.6499632596969604, -0.059313543140888214, -1.006630301475525, -0.20175635814666748, 0.5843982696533203, -0.831465482711792, 1.0165778398513794, -0.0011346573010087013, 0.5776156187057495, -0.36911875009536743, -0.29191499948501587, 0.669488251209259, 0.1624547392129898, 0.5545876622200012, 0.2913614511489868, 0.14812825620174408, 0.5300015807151794, 0.7668680548667908, 0.25610625743865967, -0.17785844206809998, 0.8234386444091797, 0.10493418574333191, 0.08428643643856049, 0.27144771814346313, -0.27105000615119934, 0.2322511523962021, 0.1683032065629959, 0.16987758874893188, -0.05960310995578766, -0.2690195143222809, -0.021797461435198784, 0.37491288781166077, -0.19371894001960754, 0.781322181224823, -0.4661548435688019, -0.8402844667434692, 0.3559640944004059, 0.920488178730011, 0.9462884664535522, -0.05487651005387306, 0.13834379613399506, -0.09340851753950119, 0.9627903699874878, 0.38212668895721436, 0.6648804545402527, 0.9742308259010315, -0.4700150489807129, -0.2634302079677582, -0.4421142637729645, 0.2626434564590454, -0.12229874730110168, 0.08327648788690567, 0.16001564264297485, -0.5115418434143066, 0.03992607817053795, 0.8744205236434937, -0.1655324101448059, -0.6642813682556152, 0.8440237641334534, 0.06007417291402817, 0.04437877982854843, -0.21498839557170868, 0.6080812811851501, -0.9449257254600525, -0.07314209640026093, 0.6618082523345947, -1.1921815872192383, -0.03431230038404465, 0.44874808192253113, 0.1627940982580185, 0.5235186815261841, 0.2338208556175232, 0.11819761246442795, -0.907238781452179, 0.7571820616722107, 0.5812008380889893, 0.8617807030677795, -0.3820321261882782, 0.3387106955051422, -0.15812724828720093, -0.07048691809177399, -0.39738479256629944, 0.3091326951980591, 0.20913392305374146, -0.3894892632961273, -0.31623512506484985, 0.13238440454006195, -0.4942130148410797, -0.4500589668750763, -0.5459200143814087, -0.793103039264679, 0.603499174118042, -0.4135974049568176, 0.002320460509508848, 0.9543241858482361, 0.5767991542816162, 0.4622209966182709, -0.19643348455429077, -0.2554323077201843, -1.1385632753372192, -0.753231406211853, 0.0696086436510086, 0.19751037657260895, -0.07347702980041504, -0.19710677862167358, -0.798662543296814, -1.1244313716888428, 0.0732450932264328, -0.9180023670196533, -0.4662005603313446, -0.5725199580192566, 0.08020433038473129, 0.22525706887245178, 0.9881329536437988, 0.4376412630081177, 0.2370416671037674, 0.47280722856521606, -0.22375881671905518, 1.0501238107681274, 0.07653956860303879, 0.6394514441490173, 0.13658057153224945, 0.05374734103679657, 0.327389657497406, 0.43175190687179565, -0.617462158203125, -0.2985515296459198, -0.33727341890335083, -0.7116190195083618, 0.3521502912044525, -0.2095753699541092, -0.46948981285095215, 0.49215707182884216, 0.7870749235153198, -0.27779608964920044, 0.06347738206386566, -1.1819170713424683, 0.3614567816257477, -0.2303331345319748, 0.38962164521217346, -0.4714697599411011, -0.2072475701570511, -0.21751946210861206, -0.10767947137355804, 0.1937759667634964, -0.860898494720459, 3.946079969406128, 1.4164057970046997, 0.5715024471282959, -0.20311616361141205, 0.417043536901474, 0.4681250751018524, 0.3148062825202942, -0.8050069808959961, -0.2114485651254654, -0.5922836661338806, -0.07411111891269684, 0.04430796578526497, 0.3617163300514221, 0.18466515839099884, 0.5033062100410461, 0.24487832188606262, -1.9554954767227173, 0.13824918866157532, -0.32974135875701904, -1.176127314567566, -1.1130752563476562, 0.5725081562995911, -0.37012261152267456, -0.15269659459590912, 0.17571155726909637, 0.40680938959121704, -0.03857085853815079, 0.8399266600608826, -0.026248285546898842, -0.9235038161277771, -0.20266546308994293, -0.4046626389026642, 0.5561350584030151, 0.28281086683273315, -0.3321080207824707, 0.34761619567871094, 0.05065229535102844, -0.11099421232938766, -0.2624925374984741, 0.230372354388237, 1.1024422645568848, -0.637622058391571, -0.601349413394928, 0.21356478333473206, -0.8360677361488342, -0.22163335978984833, -0.6847456097602844, -0.20386028289794922, 0.1545001119375229, -0.15570910274982452, 0.9208776950836182, -0.9350823760032654, 0.8708325624465942, -0.3131456971168518, -0.9610788226127625, -0.2471804916858673, -0.20430485904216766, -1.6403977870941162, -0.2221214473247528, 0.44120514392852783, 0.5164701342582703, -0.13953448832035065, -0.17535518109798431, -0.28857988119125366, 0.0424036867916584, 0.4363069534301758, 0.5730202198028564, 0.2867451012134552, -0.009842793457210064, -0.8596198558807373, -0.039160847663879395, -0.41356363892555237, -0.18643611669540405, -0.3197181820869446, 0.34953573346138, 0.8164644837379456, -0.32693690061569214, 1.0026426315307617, -0.6117786765098572, -0.9474657773971558, 0.614632248878479, 0.32404622435569763, -0.08742627501487732, -0.5727052688598633, 0.706303060054779, 0.417147159576416, -1.0190110206604004, 0.5021349787712097, -1.0167917013168335, 0.545437216758728, 0.07200165838003159, -0.4280608594417572, -0.11145692318677902, -0.1519395262002945, -0.49698972702026367 ]
{"Title": "Comparative analysis of functional assay evidence use by ClinGen Variant Curation Expert Panels", "Authors": "Kanavy Dona M., McNulty Shannon M., Jairath Meera K., Brnich Sarah E., Bizon Chris, Powell Bradford C., Berg Jonathan S.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background The 2015 American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) and Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) guidelines for clinical sequence variant interpretation state that \u201cwell-established\u201d functional studies can be used as evidence in variant classification. These guidelines articulated key attributes of functional data, including that assays should reflect the biological environment and be analytically sound; however, details of how to evaluate these attributes were left to expert judgment. The Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) designates Variant Curation Expert Panels (VCEPs) in specific disease areas to make gene-centric specifications to the ACMG/AMP guidelines, including more specific definitions of appropriate functional assays. We set out to evaluate the existing VCEP guidelines for functional assays. Methods We evaluated the functional criteria (PS3/BS3) of six VCEPs ( CDH1 , Hearing Loss, Inherited Cardiomyopathy- MYH7, PAH, PTEN , RASopathy). We then established criteria for evaluating functional studies based on disease mechanism, general class of assay, and the characteristics of specific assay instances described in primary literature. Using these criteria, we extensively curated assay instances cited by each VCEP in their pilot variant classification to analyze VCEP recommendations and their use in the interpretation of functional studies. Results Unsurprisingly, our analysis highlighted the breadth of VCEP-approved assays, reflecting the diversity of disease mechanisms among VCEPs. We also noted substantial variability between VCEPs in the method used to select these assays and in the approach used to specify strength modifications, as well as differences in suggested validation parameters. Importantly, we observed discrepancies between the parameters VCEPs specified as required for approved assay instances and the fulfillment of these requirements in the individual assays cited in pilot variant interpretation. Conclusions Interpretation of the intricacies of functional assays often requires expert-level knowledge of the gene and disease and current VCEP recommendations for functional assay evidence are a useful tool to improve the accessibility of functional data. However, our analysis suggests that further guidance is needed to standardize this process and ensure consistency in the application of functional evidence.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000661"}
10.1101/19003210
[ 0.4814698100090027, -0.34901705384254456, -0.13522478938102722, -0.38483497500419617, 0.381131112575531, -0.6985392570495605, 0.17329838871955872, -0.09441140294075012, 0.7299923896789551, 0.49035876989364624, 0.34081611037254333, -0.7730337977409363, 0.702401876449585, -0.5537779927253723, -0.03330010920763016, -0.4470566511154175, -0.251288503408432, -0.20589908957481384, -0.4696071445941925, 0.29139795899391174, 0.2980670630931854, 0.3832781910896301, -0.34592121839523315, 0.07053441554307938, -0.889583170413971, 0.4925292432308197, -0.09848655015230179, -0.2151237428188324, 1.479817271232605, 0.27439332008361816, -0.8765451312065125, -0.7675175666809082, 0.14968830347061157, -0.7743657827377319, 0.08046020567417145, -0.05442095175385475, 0.6633328795433044, -0.5413954854011536, -0.31928443908691406, -0.9534903764724731, 0.7675226330757141, -0.23852525651454926, 0.19670386612415314, -0.21745863556861877, -0.4098888635635376, 0.17647522687911987, -0.5811159014701843, -0.5275717377662659, -0.23463985323905945, -0.3737529516220093, -0.14876891672611237, 0.33276811242103577, -0.48302870988845825, -0.0943964347243309, 0.08462110161781311, 0.7850211262702942, 0.06230175867676735, -0.15406590700149536, -0.423988938331604, -0.2846386432647705, 0.3725810945034027, -0.1700391322374344, 0.41780999302864075, -0.5679076313972473, 0.864885151386261, 0.9229912757873535, 0.19314995408058167, -0.41295620799064636, -0.08581629395484924, 0.46207889914512634, -0.20401963591575623, 0.1868126094341278, -0.323019415140152, -0.38926708698272705, -0.6575337052345276, -1.0473624467849731, 0.26921021938323975, 0.33176350593566895, 0.029167894273996353, -0.11400103569030762, 0.07647915184497833, -0.04292379319667816, 0.3055016100406647, 0.608742892742157, -0.6837016344070435, 0.22017355263233185, 0.6497324705123901, 0.5939229130744934, 0.041457999497652054, -0.09223823249340057, -0.1965237408876419, 0.16110315918922424, -0.6090706586837769, -0.0678936243057251, -0.6643964648246765, 1.2700493335723877, -0.2589680552482605, 0.25674882531166077, -0.06078324466943741, -0.5860434770584106, 0.41235625743865967, 1.6458570957183838, -1.4976012706756592, 0.4940105676651001, -0.2784650921821594, 0.6932540535926819, 1.0368071794509888, -0.535496711730957, -0.2994539141654968, -0.992247998714447, 0.940710723400116, 0.8655537962913513, -0.4488958716392517, 0.7566978335380554, 0.8994772434234619, 1.1923725605010986, 0.22233250737190247, 0.5173706412315369, -0.38977301120758057, -0.3045925796031952, -0.14614328742027283, -0.5160989165306091, 0.46318674087524414, -0.42055225372314453, 0.41646233201026917, 0.20355956256389618, -0.3256683647632599, 0.727243959903717, -0.000057291552366223186, -0.07398368418216705, 0.02607315219938755, -0.10922259092330933, 0.27051329612731934, 0.42929086089134216, -0.04656294733285904, -0.14561523497104645, -0.16674324870109558, 0.7030702233314514, 0.8169203400611877, -0.6198300719261169, -0.008560572750866413, 0.5419888496398926, -1.1180427074432373, 1.0893584489822388, -0.15672194957733154, 0.8420179486274719, -0.6476213932037354, -1.5430328845977783, -0.7342878580093384, -0.7438387870788574, 0.06762510538101196, 0.4158906936645508, -0.30484539270401, -0.5054198503494263, -0.4516952931880951, 1.0781619548797607, -0.061119575053453445, 0.29023993015289307, -0.424262672662735, 0.5844133496284485, -0.6991357207298279, 0.3749330937862396, 0.7095426321029663, 0.5798764228820801, -0.5049778819084167, 1.0987193584442139, 0.21186941862106323, -0.012386593967676163, -0.4283239245414734, -0.7645850777626038, 0.9424766898155212, -0.5639154314994812, -0.6872495412826538, -0.5572000741958618, -0.08765703439712524, 0.45486247539520264, 0.710537850856781, -0.5114210247993469, 0.07515964657068253, -0.24278734624385834, 0.2042558193206787, 0.3235774636268616, -0.33470940589904785, 0.2855069935321808, 0.024207336828112602, 0.015913868322968483, -0.35351550579071045, -0.2977798879146576, -0.2883239686489105, -0.7019591331481934, -0.023022055625915527, 0.14584438502788544, 0.0445990264415741, 0.43254944682121277, -0.3436771333217621, -0.06662099063396454, -0.1992727369070053, -0.08065266907215118, 0.022107239812612534, 0.07815942168235779, -0.7118862867355347, 0.609667956829071, 0.2357093244791031, 0.20825737714767456, -0.5918633937835693, 0.6916661858558655, 0.2044268697500229, 0.5465390086174011, -0.953498125076294, 0.4309873580932617, 0.8566772937774658, 0.002420279895886779, -0.5801576972007751, -0.1260853260755539, 0.6151037216186523, -0.2675718069076538, 0.48433998227119446, 0.08110351860523224, 0.17510776221752167, 0.34025195240974426, -0.4481422007083893, -0.06544678658246994, 0.3683525323867798, 0.30885443091392517, 0.6011081337928772, 0.6400940418243408, 0.5223169326782227, 0.22769932448863983, -0.3942651152610779, -0.08466704189777374, 0.2225094437599182, 0.5668080449104309, -0.8284136056900024, 0.36692073941230774, 0.033425841480493546, 0.5714008808135986, 0.2804606854915619, 0.2612966001033783, 0.5947631597518921, 0.793127715587616, 1.022533655166626, 0.01836276240646839, 0.6583547592163086, -0.0860724076628685, -0.021875275298953056, 0.5815337300300598, -0.7357581257820129, -0.01707691140472889, -0.32623833417892456, 0.7258380055427551, 0.212665855884552, 0.8438118696212769, 0.35058867931365967, 0.17307192087173462, -0.6673632264137268, -0.8044842481613159, 0.34007877111434937, 0.5685099959373474, -1.0368497371673584, -0.31664061546325684, -0.4834901988506317, 0.3674635589122772, -0.5952005386352539, -0.9424311518669128, 0.7112791538238525, 0.9069744944572449, -0.3857611417770386, 0.1362222284078598, 0.04259244725108147, -0.6570581197738647, -1.0023072957992554, -0.6229691505432129, -0.9107370376586914, -1.0388513803482056, -0.8960320949554443, -0.2828947603702545, 0.6279281377792358, -0.16325262188911438, 0.1032853052020073, 0.28168392181396484, -0.3633468747138977, 0.3594522178173065, 0.05049027130007744, 0.40298062562942505, -0.3271365761756897, 0.21001768112182617, -0.3273908793926239, -0.38051360845565796, 0.003336080349981785, 0.13981111347675323, -0.3272944688796997, -0.1453186422586441, -0.6204887628555298, -0.19133275747299194, -0.09542600810527802, -0.8933897614479065, 0.522989809513092, -0.30931177735328674, 0.38787007331848145, 0.30642321705818176, 0.4713596701622009, -0.12461839616298676, 0.34953853487968445, 0.07333952933549881, 0.33318668603897095, 0.07660938054323196, -0.25796955823898315, -0.1159997284412384, 0.1820094734430313, 0.31277066469192505, -0.45395293831825256, 0.0996704176068306, -0.006453312002122402, 0.1674988716840744, -0.8294116258621216, 0.18071866035461426, 0.5029188394546509, 0.22251836955547333, 0.4105983376502991, -0.7157287001609802, -0.6443913578987122, 0.3353349566459656, -0.3655352294445038, -0.5937845706939697, 0.3012746572494507, 0.43980205059051514, 0.6692342758178711, -1.1517348289489746, 0.07351097464561462, -0.05619550123810768, -1.5429558753967285, 0.018631773069500923, -0.17090663313865662, 0.2525014579296112, 0.047511644661426544, 0.44268563389778137, 0.018344024196267128, 0.36445122957229614, 0.10069189965724945, 0.5615248680114746, -0.05242988094687462, -0.6845786571502686, -0.6444635987281799, 0.009133323095738888, 0.32549065351486206, -0.22478128969669342, 0.03738401085138321, -0.4980505108833313, -0.34655267000198364, 0.2708466947078705, -0.5221129059791565, 0.5906624794006348, 0.7913681268692017, 0.2080785036087036, 0.1532258540391922, 0.7874293923377991, -0.5524505972862244, 0.2806723713874817, 0.66725093126297, 0.5045924186706543, 0.5198583602905273, 0.6544607877731323, -0.32978352904319763, -0.2006288319826126, 0.05743678659200668, -0.14415301382541656, -0.1815061867237091, 0.3218403160572052, 0.6638101935386658, -0.32303377985954285, 0.5353870391845703, -0.15886975824832916, 0.42022088170051575, 0.04080238193273544, -0.5593315958976746, -0.5315921902656555, 0.7059915065765381, -0.4829634428024292, 0.8500213623046875, -0.8069835305213928, 0.5378886461257935, 0.7068533897399902, 0.7591341137886047, -0.057924143970012665, -0.5908151865005493, 0.31090325117111206, -0.32562336325645447, 0.37885114550590515, -0.03726041689515114, -0.410972535610199, 0.35031574964523315, -0.8466999530792236, 0.2799410820007324, 0.4181317985057831, -0.7886440753936768, 0.250306099653244, 0.30642661452293396, 0.4682547450065613, -0.24113154411315918, 0.12580643594264984, 0.9732912182807922, -0.04048541188240051, -0.34823042154312134, -0.15703992545604706, 0.24938756227493286, -0.17138229310512543, 0.05770024657249451, -0.15729880332946777, 0.10642049461603165, 0.02102644369006157, -0.5592542886734009, 0.2633911371231079, -0.023210659623146057, 0.18287713825702667, 0.5106064081192017, -0.3844236433506012, -0.312086820602417, -0.2304735630750656, 0.09603406488895416, -0.374654084444046, 1.1176421642303467, -0.07535804808139801, -0.6283458471298218, 0.142363041639328, -0.06213327869772911, -1.0775772333145142, -0.57341468334198, 0.0253384318202734, -0.24402835965156555, 0.7900978922843933, -0.25801247358322144, -0.3937858045101166, -0.1108550950884819, -0.22926107048988342, -0.1382911503314972, 0.8914580345153809, 0.19381307065486908, 0.007831118069589138, 0.8083556294441223, -0.1660950630903244, -0.23001129925251007, -0.31488367915153503, -0.5468020439147949, -0.24462001025676727, 0.33380281925201416, 0.22487099468708038, 1.2958418130874634, 0.278923898935318, -0.06625838577747345, -0.30265817046165466, 0.8434981107711792, -0.755710244178772, 0.5272693037986755, -0.17816075682640076, -0.2992378771305084, 0.20463043451309204, -0.05327771231532097, -0.6892025470733643, 0.38705968856811523, -0.13551074266433716, -0.7023783326148987, -0.7708202600479126, 0.10290870815515518, -0.5912900567054749, -0.30390557646751404, 0.3280881345272064, -0.6748719811439514, 0.11466459929943085, 1.3453199863433838, -0.1350531131029129, -0.2623923122882843, -0.33257046341896057, 0.818447470664978, -0.5606592893600464, 0.4819890558719635, 0.2417849749326706, 0.6908935904502869, 0.6217041015625, -0.509828507900238, -0.20261794328689575, -0.44008901715278625, 0.8551205396652222, -0.7529866099357605, -0.46729838848114014, -0.6700707674026489, -0.26482293009757996, -0.5768661499023438, 0.017588336020708084, -1.0508064031600952, 0.23268093168735504, -0.1480219066143036, 0.19344761967658997, -0.07836991548538208, 0.5349113345146179, -0.005045650061219931, -0.44961443543434143, -0.9556791186332703, -0.3095812499523163, 0.29578661918640137, -0.24004219472408295, 0.02502140961587429, -0.47079890966415405, -0.28128957748413086, 0.3212694227695465, -0.262014240026474, -1.0917216539382935, -0.06510806083679199, -0.15815061330795288, 0.5485004782676697, -0.7992186546325684, -0.6477491855621338, -0.28886377811431885, -0.36211007833480835, -0.15512380003929138, -0.4749835133552551, -0.3264234662055969, 0.30170878767967224, 0.314424604177475, -0.7649033069610596, 0.14132918417453766, 0.6861514449119568, -0.8616799712181091, 0.09551851451396942, 0.6171843409538269, 0.09535426646471024, 0.4363361597061157, -0.3205641210079193, -1.1129343509674072, -0.6008337736129761, -0.6857296228408813, 0.5953730344772339, -0.6934681534767151, 0.08722777664661407, -0.3885151743888855, -0.1073666363954544, -0.31152355670928955, 0.21633431315422058, 0.47924569249153137, 0.14790146052837372, 0.1654856950044632, -0.6194949746131897, 0.2117496281862259, -0.40231946110725403, -0.4439651668071747, -0.16898970305919647, -0.2517644762992859, 0.11688943952322006, 0.5691308379173279, 0.2006894052028656, -0.5551986694335938, 0.03539171442389488, 0.2306870073080063, 0.8751822710037231, 0.6452875137329102, -0.9293568730354309, -0.7296879887580872, 0.22601409256458282, 0.35906097292900085, 0.36795347929000854, -0.023658709600567818, -1.0615779161453247, 0.2987036108970642, -0.7698312997817993, 0.35279324650764465, -0.8044936656951904, -0.5903635621070862, 0.10815894603729248, -0.8774869441986084, 0.6702708601951599, -0.34992071986198425, 0.38042590022087097, 0.2898189425468445, -0.5972186923027039, -1.063659429550171, 0.3653383255004883, -0.3099323511123657, -0.8973119854927063, -0.2400144338607788, 0.16297760605812073, 0.7195686101913452, -0.5297917127609253, 0.07214570790529251, 0.4707563519477844, -0.7871032953262329, 0.3641289174556732, -0.558630108833313, 0.45272666215896606, 0.8547071218490601, 0.02965080365538597, -0.2454601228237152, -0.4951818883419037, 0.013818405568599701, 0.07084622979164124, -0.36723363399505615, 0.4542066752910614, 0.6357336640357971, -0.43054860830307007, -0.09256304055452347, -0.2785768210887909, -0.9349427223205566, 0.4458724856376648, 0.2037905901670456, 0.6832226514816284, 0.44068172574043274, 0.2700638175010681, 0.19075699150562286, 0.17007675766944885, -0.16121278703212738, 0.8413873314857483, 0.49883195757865906, 0.5868523120880127, 0.7626620531082153, -0.16815896332263947, 0.512995719909668, 0.7741302847862244, -0.024469688534736633, 0.5786932706832886, -0.3126000761985779, 0.2617862820625305, 0.8662881255149841, -1.531898856163025, 0.6183751225471497, 0.12862029671669006, -0.6808114051818848, -0.16535618901252747, -0.24454058706760406, -0.30724361538887024, -0.37387514114379883, 0.5468194484710693, -1.163802146911621, 0.9442998170852661, -0.22195953130722046, 0.4987293481826782, -0.6659295558929443, 0.29468634724617004, -0.5031995177268982, -0.9037002921104431, 0.02362111769616604, -0.16872185468673706, 0.38371849060058594, 0.9908892512321472, 0.126779705286026, 0.5698647499084473, 0.3867490291595459, -0.13841356337070465, -0.4872690439224243, 0.628105640411377, -0.40456074476242065, -0.26825112104415894, 0.35087087750434875, -0.16920049488544464, 0.4237067997455597, 0.09036564826965332, 0.6186609864234924, -0.10503509640693665, 1.1445008516311646, 0.737197756767273, -0.43441295623779297, 0.027395473793148994, 0.10289211571216583, 0.6094285249710083, 0.9213944673538208, 0.27344614267349243, 0.10701128840446472, 0.6300374269485474, -0.5073395371437073, 0.20191672444343567, -0.3785833716392517, -0.18359552323818207, -0.18337370455265045, -0.7259216904640198, 0.1529199630022049, -0.2708958387374878, 0.057485707104206085, 0.8216155767440796, -0.44035106897354126, -0.9321283102035522, -0.9469141960144043, 1.4296313524246216, -0.17510148882865906, 0.049765750765800476, -0.11709650605916977, 0.7238479852676392, -0.5847790837287903, -0.8744409680366516, -1.1289339065551758, -0.7849069833755493, 0.48361319303512573, 0.7342328429222107, -0.507912814617157, -0.36417531967163086, 0.8927689790725708, -0.017513703554868698, -0.2674611508846283, -0.021241622045636177, -0.1768588274717331, -0.5300164222717285, -0.37920141220092773, 0.7280716300010681, 0.0115615613758564, -0.30658721923828125, 1.1098603010177612, -0.5218979716300964, 0.29317209124565125, 0.9316697120666504, 0.14117808640003204, 0.053750086575746536, -0.09858164191246033, 1.0387539863586426, -0.8111503720283508, -0.8054555654525757, -0.22517840564250946, 1.0764648914337158, -0.9862297177314758, -0.0815301164984703, 0.1871829330921173, -0.615026593208313, 0.1410776972770691, -0.41582512855529785, 0.07449810951948166, 1.0960243940353394, 0.5644222497940063, -0.23128105700016022, -0.13877935707569122, 0.9107992649078369, 0.4823163151741028, -0.13187538087368011, 0.4513553977012634, 0.008711574599146843, 0.5940802693367004, -0.2390187531709671, 0.4442161023616791, 0.7210198044776917, -0.2078903466463089, 0.4185445308685303, 0.11570843309164047, 0.7622911930084229, -0.12627552449703217, -0.4549304246902466, -0.3893531262874603, 0.8078879714012146, 0.49828818440437317, 1.4066082239151, -0.2744857668876648, -0.8814923167228699, -0.2697322368621826, -0.005153588019311428, -0.6772769689559937, -0.710804283618927, 0.19362959265708923, -0.5144779682159424, 0.4028546214103699, -0.8576454520225525, -0.13853998482227325, 0.33447837829589844, 0.9191910624504089, 0.03889008238911629, -0.6528018116950989, -0.16999119520187378, 0.5394718050956726, 0.5473259687423706, 0.5623098611831665, -0.09674131125211716, -0.09042572230100632, -0.018887527287006378, -0.6024845838546753, -0.29879969358444214, -0.45561063289642334, 0.2937450408935547, -0.15613241493701935, -0.536385715007782, -0.8754053115844727, 0.4141567051410675, 0.2611059844493866, -0.3254478871822357, -0.722606897354126, 0.5016323328018188, -0.5037102103233337, -0.14463326334953308, -0.13710056245326996, -0.04453817009925842, -0.5272110104560852, 0.6403253078460693, 0.08118095993995667, -1.0440075397491455, 0.2455793023109436, -0.376722127199173, 0.44930025935173035, -0.9536586999893188, 0.5894597768783569, 0.16287556290626526, 0.28284403681755066, -0.22132998704910278, -0.23726439476013184, 0.5617005228996277, 0.11895307898521423, -0.11868422478437424, 0.3359869122505188, 0.1543540209531784, -0.5071935653686523, 1.0801572799682617, -0.0043755099177360535, 0.3199138343334198, 0.19193989038467407, 0.25231456756591797, 0.4931403696537018, 0.6872740983963013, -0.41838333010673523, 0.23400533199310303, 0.47210922837257385, -0.2813602387905121, -0.4656272828578949, 0.22806185483932495, 0.6235601305961609, 0.44371187686920166, -0.0771288052201271, -0.3269047737121582, -1.1236530542373657, -0.7686722874641418, -0.32203835248947144, 0.2503173351287842, 0.647708535194397, 0.10764892399311066, -0.24515576660633087, -0.20561231672763824, 0.44514456391334534, -0.39353445172309875, -0.16082090139389038, 0.7528939843177795, -0.450254887342453, -0.5523920655250549, -0.2720503509044647, -0.1188676506280899, 0.2270260900259018, -0.3370460271835327, 0.06056922674179077, -0.08831257373094559, 0.11096760630607605, 0.12959080934524536, -0.1133919209241867, -0.0044919271022081375, 0.6642022132873535, -0.4411059617996216, 0.4932986795902252, -0.8473908305168152, -0.35956963896751404, -0.7053309679031372, -0.32264745235443115, 1.078560471534729, -1.0798101425170898, 0.6065936088562012, 0.3909856677055359, 0.5276862978935242, 0.7330584526062012, 0.3625074625015259, 0.597130537033081, -0.28351619839668274, -0.18009305000305176, 1.3489322662353516, -0.29908934235572815, -0.2692538797855377, 0.19397345185279846, -0.1738542914390564, -0.23280863463878632, -0.011254264973104, -0.19998975098133087, 0.2419799417257309, -0.36693230271339417, -0.1775287687778473, -0.02419360540807247, 0.2942412793636322, -0.12386801838874817, -1.261353850364685, 0.15808971226215363, 0.02078532800078392, -0.8262880444526672, 0.1464449167251587, -0.06725282967090607, 0.20168150961399078, 0.030950747430324554, -0.13347646594047546, 0.43071842193603516, -0.12856541574001312, -0.058123908936977386, -0.7564687132835388, 0.3488817811012268, -0.7057404518127441, -0.3559700846672058, -0.5495592951774597, -1.0015681982040405, 0.08074115216732025, 0.5823016166687012, -0.03356512263417244, -0.8302096724510193, 0.5604023933410645, 0.6165290474891663, 1.2839759588241577, 0.2373397946357727, -0.5934751033782959, 0.2767508327960968, 0.059917546808719635, 0.8333467841148376, 0.298290491104126, 0.05890292674303055, -0.11299816519021988, 0.19102150201797485, 0.1992134004831314, 0.13848988711833954, 0.6121334433555603, 0.46006208658218384, -0.4665151536464691, 0.34759029746055603, 0.5591399073600769, -0.6076653599739075, -1.0457264184951782, 0.6225864887237549, 0.9658176898956299, 0.18717768788337708, -0.25377950072288513, -0.38508209586143494, 0.45418253540992737, -0.056885313242673874, 0.0638318881392479, -0.7997463345527649, 0.13381145894527435, -0.15791289508342743, 0.295038104057312, 0.23456712067127228, -0.9068197011947632, 4.0094218254089355, 0.5502194762229919, 0.9314353466033936, -0.2840484082698822, 0.7611483335494995, -0.36945614218711853, 0.913812518119812, -0.06172953173518181, 0.06804122775793076, -0.2387160360813141, 0.12531235814094543, -0.4696922302246094, -0.06810513883829117, -0.2122393399477005, 0.2945210635662079, 0.00459534814581275, -1.5336867570877075, 0.1514454036951065, 0.12483415007591248, -1.2130095958709717, -0.6310233473777771, -0.3715800940990448, -0.08178475499153137, -0.6436087489128113, -0.16016775369644165, 0.3652366101741791, -0.05567720904946327, 0.11020094901323318, -0.19165275990962982, -0.4485796093940735, -0.5724714398384094, -0.7831893563270569, 0.36348846554756165, -1.013117790222168, -0.3616192936897278, -0.0542416051030159, -0.22010381519794464, -0.5095397233963013, -0.1734180599451065, -0.3033873438835144, 0.44189149141311646, -0.3686456084251404, -0.05070546641945839, -0.43339499831199646, -0.11349588632583618, -0.6074068546295166, -1.1046361923217773, 0.575853705406189, 0.09946658462285995, -0.7559958696365356, 0.6199874877929688, -0.20090942084789276, 0.926450252532959, -0.18141138553619385, -0.7328999638557434, -0.38629862666130066, -0.3329721689224243, -1.2399961948394775, 0.0397987887263298, 0.48238033056259155, 0.7743463516235352, 0.3428342640399933, -0.19339825212955475, 0.28913792967796326, 0.42213189601898193, 1.009162187576294, -0.1082741990685463, -0.0764164999127388, 0.01019640639424324, -0.9547497630119324, 0.8167508840560913, -0.043596845120191574, -0.2932679355144501, -0.06597167998552322, 0.7279059290885925, 0.2466333955526352, -0.3599875867366791, 0.7784069180488586, -0.0878644585609436, -0.5267683267593384, 0.30422255396842957, 0.8139991760253906, 0.12838627398014069, -0.5904865860939026, 0.6204237341880798, 0.36146658658981323, -0.7907568216323853, -0.7578752040863037, -1.3538273572921753, 0.3395107090473175, 0.6026412844657898, -0.026705697178840637, 0.08604111522436142, -0.33082708716392517, -0.4665549695491791 ]
{"Title": "Association of Kras mutation with tumor deposit status and overall survival of colorectal cancer", "Authors": "Zhang Meifang, Hu Wenwei, Hu Kun, Lin Yong, Feng Zhaohui, Yun Jing-Ping, Gao Nan, Zhang Lanjing", "Abstract": "Abstract Background The recent staging manual upstages Node-negative tumor-deposit positive colorectal cancer (CRC) from N0 to N1c category, while the development of tumor-deposit presence is poorly understood. Meanwhile, Kras mutation is associated with progression of CRC, but its link to tumor-deposit status is unclear. Method This retrospective cohort study included the patients with incidental CRC diagnosed during 2010-2014 in the National Cancer Database and recorded statuses of Kras and tumor deposit. We conducted multivariable logistic regression and Cox regression analyses to investigate the factors associated with tumor-deposit status and overall-survival, respectively. Results A total of 48,200 CRC patients with Kras status were included in the study (25,407 [52.7%] men, 25,648[46.8%] <65 years old, 18 381 [38.1%] with Kras mutation). Adjusted for microsatellite instability, age, pathologic stage and tumor grade, Kras mutation (versus wild-type) was associated with tumor-deposit presence (n=15,229, odds ratio=1.11, 95% CI 1.02 to 1.20). Kras mutation was also independently linked to a worse overall survival of CRC patients regardless of tumor-deposit status (n=8,110, adjusted Hazard ratio=1.40, 95% CI 1.09 to 1.79 for CRC with tumor deposits, and n=2,618, adjusted HR=1.63, 95% CI 1.16 to 2.28 for CRC without), but a better survival in CRC with no known/applicable tumor-deposit status (n=457, adjusted Hazard ratio =0.32, 95% CI 0.11 to 0.95). Conclusion Kras mutation is independently associated with tumor-deposit presence, and a worse overall survival of CRC with or without tumor-deposit. Therefore, it may play a role in the development of tumor deposits and serve as a target for CRC treatment.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003210"}
10.1101/19003855
[ -0.20375046133995056, 0.42801880836486816, -0.11872323602437973, -0.06184486672282219, 0.17155039310455322, -0.39069947600364685, 0.2761842608451843, -0.06883037835359573, 0.9855108261108398, 0.7562178373336792, 0.4433892071247101, -0.4189956784248352, 0.22785991430282593, -1.0299285650253296, 0.4811331331729889, -0.2477356493473053, 0.17205727100372314, -0.5275350213050842, -0.0010009371908381581, -0.2886766195297241, 0.5492923855781555, 0.043947119265794754, -0.8898146152496338, 0.4451954662799835, -0.27717098593711853, 0.3051283657550812, -0.08626443892717361, -0.06271961331367493, 1.3247873783111572, 0.4124208390712738, -1.3697397708892822, -0.24547447264194489, 0.8348798155784607, -1.771224856376648, -0.706332266330719, -0.09018115699291229, 0.43535295128822327, 0.03719892352819443, -0.8901604413986206, -0.569891631603241, 0.08323848247528076, 0.10631866008043289, 0.7019415497779846, -0.3888509273529053, 0.12956896424293518, -0.1950625628232956, -0.7655109763145447, -0.8641723394393921, 0.11968591064214706, -0.4901295304298401, 0.5144729018211365, 0.08254751563072205, -0.20634691417217255, -0.05786529928445816, -0.15480495989322662, 0.40207943320274353, 0.13742046058177948, -0.06217159703373909, -1.0730876922607422, 0.3224029541015625, 0.02348966896533966, -0.1930140107870102, 0.8725436329841614, -1.5251058340072632, 0.9301428198814392, 0.48007655143737793, 0.45271292328834534, -0.5177050232887268, -0.35146012902259827, 0.33008313179016113, -0.23722858726978302, -0.9616804122924805, -1.1044617891311646, -0.5662451982498169, -0.08336251229047775, -0.8897808790206909, 0.40085095167160034, 0.5494959950447083, -0.5573499798774719, -0.2998582124710083, -0.1943093240261078, 0.609089732170105, 0.2517569661140442, 0.3595181405544281, 0.17580372095108032, -0.04888790473341942, 0.5810917019844055, 0.8256683349609375, -0.6608178019523621, 1.2603517770767212, 0.3343777358531952, 0.33834394812583923, -0.21802212297916412, 0.3123805820941925, 0.055494751781225204, 1.1023502349853516, -0.4577389061450958, -0.0732746496796608, -0.3737117350101471, -0.5371444225311279, 0.277673602104187, -0.03301755338907242, -1.353627324104309, 0.912512481212616, -0.07182178646326065, 0.3637772500514984, 0.4212864637374878, -0.30279508233070374, -0.08574941009283066, -1.1659808158874512, 0.6850124001502991, -0.05669378861784935, -0.4218313992023468, 0.5135998129844666, 1.28659188747406, 0.2974393963813782, -0.1576632708311081, 1.1228383779525757, -0.8820291757583618, -0.5739947557449341, 0.001079385168850422, 0.32298800349235535, 0.8829815983772278, 0.01361336000263691, 0.4388299584388733, 0.6059088110923767, 0.09873948246240616, -0.06837210804224014, -0.46920832991600037, 0.2573302984237671, -0.15539470314979553, 0.38151127099990845, 0.6421283483505249, 0.4364597499370575, -0.1480611115694046, 0.06061888486146927, 0.001954158768057823, 1.1289397478103638, 0.07990241795778275, -0.8421429991722107, -0.030839329585433006, 0.587507426738739, -0.8674783110618591, 1.1928478479385376, 0.19508804380893707, 0.6274694204330444, -0.6472213864326477, -1.7182691097259521, -0.7133926153182983, -0.23093292117118835, 0.259807288646698, 0.9048691391944885, -0.6315343379974365, -1.2653230428695679, 0.2770315110683441, 0.7682226896286011, 0.19923317432403564, 0.5217689275741577, 0.09830205142498016, 0.579137921333313, -0.8442450761795044, 0.5713235139846802, 0.21192815899848938, 0.9292646646499634, -0.27903249859809875, 0.49308067560195923, -0.45651111006736755, 0.2934916615486145, 0.8295941948890686, -1.0187844038009644, 0.18015837669372559, 0.0515916533768177, -0.44828903675079346, 0.007241979241371155, 0.23763224482536316, 0.7160510420799255, 0.5253541469573975, -0.42890509963035583, 0.3499048948287964, 0.33749115467071533, 0.27269354462623596, 0.33140653371810913, -0.11883679777383804, 1.0017225742340088, -0.44387850165367126, 0.10022764652967453, -0.43451768159866333, -0.15675683319568634, -0.060895323753356934, -0.47632431983947754, 0.21917268633842468, -0.2449207901954651, 0.15368524193763733, 0.9375964999198914, -0.18118946254253387, 0.7115215063095093, -0.9281858205795288, 0.519597589969635, 0.3221893012523651, -0.4195490777492523, -0.42377275228500366, 0.8454532027244568, -0.2845914363861084, 0.36768707633018494, 0.03721333295106888, 0.35967063903808594, 0.1723734438419342, 0.8665143847465515, -0.746515691280365, 0.7129756212234497, 0.9622465968132019, 0.10192061960697174, -0.651962399482727, -0.4857662320137024, 0.6926862001419067, -0.6962971091270447, -0.2169445902109146, 0.4202462434768677, -1.0094798803329468, 0.23903927206993103, -0.33033624291419983, -0.03325152024626732, 0.4122450053691864, -0.01301366277039051, -0.45248034596443176, 0.28647151589393616, 1.1283212900161743, 0.412880003452301, 0.09454330056905746, -0.5474196076393127, 0.3968493342399597, 0.0620209202170372, 0.5042092204093933, 0.5043816566467285, 0.5701901912689209, 0.7195183634757996, 0.2971602976322174, 0.6677978038787842, 0.1928449124097824, 0.9345847964286804, 0.8948634266853333, 0.06527435779571533, 0.4404505491256714, 0.7247852087020874, 0.08799494057893753, -0.19558069109916687, -0.36458075046539307, 0.3862616717815399, -0.4359230101108551, 0.39446738362312317, -0.4887147545814514, 0.8893344402313232, 0.32659202814102173, 1.009637713432312, -0.4472889006137848, -0.9759242534637451, 0.06341062486171722, 0.21593928337097168, -0.4127689003944397, -0.6044694185256958, -0.3734898269176483, 0.34411564469337463, -0.014779589138925076, 0.3143456280231476, 0.5547553300857544, 1.0100170373916626, -0.25864163041114807, -0.43232694268226624, 0.010460483841598034, -0.3161894977092743, -0.802902340888977, -0.5697416067123413, -1.361016869544983, -0.7410032153129578, -1.3945599794387817, -0.556164562702179, 0.14404736459255219, 0.028307300060987473, 0.3041333258152008, 0.7484577894210815, 0.1750096082687378, -0.43715399503707886, -0.6492879390716553, 0.4628758728504181, 0.7778611779212952, 0.44112709164619446, -0.5699437260627747, 0.2072085589170456, -0.6037064790725708, 0.12794597446918488, -0.5874173045158386, 0.0419907420873642, -0.6290007829666138, -0.4093644917011261, 0.9022713899612427, -0.31318792700767517, -0.40533119440078735, -0.2309878170490265, 0.50888592004776, -0.3088154196739197, 0.3263375759124756, 0.043816253542900085, -0.09719710052013397, -0.22586874663829803, -0.30384543538093567, 0.5918593406677246, 0.3424794375896454, -0.03469088673591614, 0.13506895303726196, 1.0196380615234375, -0.34244558215141296, 0.4480172395706177, -0.04951709881424904, -0.014997935853898525, -0.8734163045883179, 0.9348719716072083, 1.00688636302948, -0.2920664846897125, 0.11208035051822662, -0.37950772047042847, -1.2407538890838623, -0.5378028750419617, 0.5546896457672119, -0.10995928198099136, -0.13179121911525726, 0.5744407773017883, 0.5124160647392273, -1.1575450897216797, -0.02381723001599312, -0.40730899572372437, -1.687153697013855, 0.19732946157455444, -0.2786998450756073, 0.24196873605251312, 0.3544457256793976, -0.48506104946136475, 0.033803410828113556, 0.6866828203201294, 0.5405554175376892, 0.369232714176178, 0.1594422459602356, -0.5711937546730042, 0.7560110688209534, 0.5716773867607117, 0.1663472205400467, -0.0844668447971344, -0.03132908046245575, -0.25435954332351685, -0.4565061926841736, -0.3631231486797333, 0.4077967405319214, 0.11841529607772827, 0.24951501190662384, 0.7412750124931335, -0.1697854846715927, 0.2669065296649933, 0.0213330015540123, 0.032485391944646835, 0.6708474159240723, 0.49966633319854736, 0.10039331763982773, 0.7592456340789795, 0.12409006804227829, 0.7072396874427795, 0.02885822206735611, -0.21817085146903992, 0.7641209959983826, -0.6653263568878174, 0.7027331590652466, -0.7343782782554626, 0.9748367667198181, 0.4695694148540497, -0.17973396182060242, 0.10206141322851181, -0.23312115669250488, 0.6351668238639832, 0.8386795520782471, -0.11818438768386841, 0.9479172229766846, -1.1089192628860474, 0.4104413092136383, 0.8889036178588867, 1.3835209608078003, 0.37844526767730713, 0.3082895576953888, 0.9487819671630859, -0.5164045095443726, 0.2947984039783478, -0.5643507838249207, 0.2617271840572357, -0.020110251381993294, -0.5832341909408569, -0.13319069147109985, 0.21143677830696106, -0.8751485347747803, -0.2100761979818344, -0.8468765616416931, -0.013886824250221252, -0.23457783460617065, -0.1634882539510727, 0.8075340986251831, 0.059956129640340805, 0.3763962388038635, -0.22595742344856262, 0.22800204157829285, -0.05208073556423187, 0.12698470056056976, 0.03436059132218361, 0.6657822728157043, -0.25952544808387756, -0.24178265035152435, -0.16897808015346527, -0.06890285760164261, 0.08474595099687576, 0.30539992451667786, -0.6901986598968506, -0.8646014928817749, -0.938162088394165, -0.14755752682685852, 0.9187427759170532, -0.12731710076332092, 0.31660524010658264, -0.9477058053016663, 0.4426948130130768, 0.01216462068259716, -0.13777607679367065, -0.38050734996795654, -0.894863486289978, -0.26398664712905884, 0.37017229199409485, -0.7386830449104309, -0.8924776911735535, -0.33453139662742615, -0.042938318103551865, -0.827511727809906, -0.361698716878891, -0.10076746344566345, -0.2595975697040558, 0.058037448674440384, -0.32398414611816406, -0.07344811409711838, -0.6545481085777283, 0.06991682201623917, 0.4253523051738739, 0.04431852325797081, -0.22691231966018677, 0.8948785066604614, -0.012265716679394245, 0.7939904928207397, -0.6585901975631714, 1.17479407787323, -0.524868905544281, 0.733737587928772, -0.19097594916820526, -0.3462148606777191, -0.36798954010009766, -0.663482666015625, -0.6779506802558899, -0.02474040538072586, -0.49078378081321716, -0.511566698551178, -0.10446148365736008, 0.42349332571029663, -0.11400394141674042, -0.8978351354598999, 0.5691988468170166, -0.32941436767578125, 0.5157743692398071, 1.2374961376190186, -0.08799108862876892, 0.16963531076908112, 0.12025956064462662, 0.010073358193039894, -0.5190146565437317, 0.7904691696166992, 0.1990024447441101, 0.17847000062465668, 0.45208287239074707, -0.37031781673431396, -0.30778810381889343, 0.10113288462162018, 0.6786766648292542, -0.6030240654945374, -0.8279947638511658, -0.45977258682250977, -0.27237045764923096, -0.894263505935669, -0.1175307035446167, -0.5369580388069153, 0.07576249539852142, -0.10102911293506622, -0.4921034276485443, 0.515938937664032, 0.05210098996758461, -0.7508040070533752, -0.5574484467506409, 0.04562461003661156, -0.2002323716878891, 0.35454681515693665, 0.21936526894569397, 0.8162792325019836, -0.17825815081596375, -0.690371036529541, 0.33122706413269043, -0.050034601241350174, -0.21819134056568146, -0.16239596903324127, -0.16484932601451874, 0.2026074230670929, -1.2041833400726318, -0.17031891644001007, -0.07182061672210693, -1.2323006391525269, -0.4450483024120331, -0.040739674121141434, 0.34080827236175537, 0.15029276907444, 0.3726881146430969, -0.46997639536857605, 1.0221601724624634, 0.19130939245224, -1.0050708055496216, -0.4387896955013275, 0.6290699243545532, 0.12129969894886017, 0.04860910028219223, -0.3130038380622864, -1.2876298427581787, -1.114184021949768, -0.84981369972229, 0.46105408668518066, -0.9755313992500305, -0.17284445464611053, -0.5555037260055542, 0.020553646609187126, -0.11137701570987701, 0.8274977207183838, 0.23839418590068817, 0.05422612279653549, -0.15904994308948517, -1.0422998666763306, 0.3647438883781433, -0.2852236330509186, -0.12705744802951813, -0.4786709249019623, -0.48163560032844543, 0.5685059428215027, 1.2601263523101807, 0.4186805784702301, -0.575644314289093, 0.6344667673110962, 0.12887431681156158, 0.4395165741443634, 0.2698737680912018, -0.7238103747367859, -0.3091779947280884, 0.16075988113880157, 0.7784336805343628, -0.6801552176475525, 0.07899409532546997, -1.7825891971588135, 0.37346628308296204, -0.4223591387271881, -0.055691130459308624, 0.5498589873313904, -0.505189061164856, 0.10588787496089935, -0.08186222612857819, 0.9617484211921692, -0.5409950613975525, 0.7267242670059204, -0.10677696019411087, -0.48068004846572876, -0.4121531844139099, 0.4828106164932251, -0.013919909484684467, -0.684116542339325, -0.4900026023387909, -0.6634761691093445, 0.752476692199707, -0.005631755106151104, -0.13950809836387634, 0.05523519217967987, -0.17590434849262238, 0.3231744170188904, -1.1331895589828491, 1.387803554534912, 0.7220694422721863, -0.2548850476741791, -0.22926472127437592, 0.10310500860214233, 0.5344371199607849, 0.042544011026620865, -0.9649907350540161, 0.613113522529602, -0.22768741846084595, -0.38377809524536133, -0.5328245162963867, -0.4457046091556549, -1.0925345420837402, 0.13128165900707245, 0.24527426064014435, 0.6464558839797974, 0.2888038158416748, 0.34909406304359436, -0.1878838986158371, -0.1551068127155304, 0.13220298290252686, 1.1507567167282104, -0.5860247015953064, 0.7843067646026611, 1.0672423839569092, 0.3886054754257202, 0.6100013256072998, 0.828713059425354, -0.4346204102039337, -0.5352755188941956, 0.033076800405979156, 0.33668088912963867, 0.3529883325099945, -1.7174928188323975, 0.47958120703697205, -0.03493771702051163, -0.6982283592224121, -0.877962589263916, 0.24315953254699707, -0.2725386917591095, -0.32211631536483765, 0.6121608018875122, -0.015722762793302536, 0.4843301475048065, 0.028136204928159714, 0.8981702923774719, -0.26166194677352905, 0.2544448971748352, -0.19043463468551636, -0.5998347401618958, 0.06437153369188309, -0.930511474609375, 0.295118510723114, 1.3735227584838867, 0.39366409182548523, -0.042888037860393524, 0.20357289910316467, 0.5414775013923645, -0.33111023902893066, -0.45372137427330017, 0.09440717846155167, -0.4023846685886383, 0.11283355206251144, -0.3904145658016205, 0.3907945454120636, 0.31917330622673035, 0.26587462425231934, -0.4582694172859192, 1.00171959400177, 0.49890464544296265, -0.4752996861934662, -0.5024551749229431, 0.08282610028982162, 1.3371585607528687, 0.6895246505737305, 0.4948623776435852, -0.04203110560774803, 0.5158035755157471, -0.465419739484787, -0.17504005134105682, -0.35769790410995483, 0.8071402311325073, -0.7679092884063721, -0.4810987114906311, -0.03980518504977226, -0.5556430220603943, -0.03325352072715759, 0.6078383326530457, -0.20696865022182465, -0.4559331238269806, -0.37641483545303345, 0.5560628175735474, 0.5468594431877136, 0.36917129158973694, -0.27518123388290405, 0.3590891659259796, -0.929897129535675, -0.7013046741485596, -0.08350963890552521, -0.351427286863327, -0.04300994426012039, 0.7079441547393799, -0.5697431564331055, -0.35800886154174805, 0.2946588397026062, 0.213912695646286, -0.27317532896995544, 0.5975774526596069, -0.8256542086601257, -0.21168464422225952, -0.9472061991691589, 0.22477902472019196, 0.09617853909730911, -0.029765667393803596, 1.2613712549209595, 0.14109466969966888, 0.6456559896469116, 0.6784732341766357, -0.38561832904815674, -0.5025757551193237, 0.5323096513748169, 1.0901367664337158, -1.2489935159683228, -0.5358670949935913, -1.0081770420074463, 0.5182442665100098, -1.396499514579773, -0.4978920519351959, -0.5402763485908508, -0.7390778660774231, 0.024426033720374107, 0.6750146150588989, 0.1382877379655838, 0.8616138100624084, 0.45988205075263977, 0.5365797877311707, -0.08658524602651596, 1.0012775659561157, 0.6169390082359314, -0.22446003556251526, 0.19778402149677277, 0.36955100297927856, 0.30869269371032715, -0.3482745885848999, -0.15006235241889954, 0.4272094666957855, -0.6973995566368103, 0.828677237033844, 0.1747487485408783, 0.20528750121593475, 0.6631940007209778, 0.4795630872249603, -0.19078101217746735, -0.08721120655536652, 0.23892052471637726, 0.642516553401947, -0.08301643282175064, -1.130789875984192, -0.8998603820800781, -0.5248196125030518, -0.7603075504302979, -0.9702847599983215, 0.4367873966693878, -0.7246298789978027, 0.5746343731880188, -0.17392787337303162, -0.07817335426807404, 0.5609087347984314, 0.09707430750131607, 0.3378361165523529, -0.25289005041122437, -0.37719693779945374, 0.5706474184989929, 0.9170541167259216, -0.17502865195274353, 0.061794463545084, -0.027521410956978798, 0.3136172294616699, -0.8583973050117493, -0.7774857878684998, -0.48166611790657043, 0.26641255617141724, -0.01936245523393154, -0.36104723811149597, -0.6196668744087219, -0.4692164361476898, 0.5081523060798645, -0.22134047746658325, -0.14600960910320282, -0.36529305577278137, -0.8897302150726318, -0.23531095683574677, -0.5022091269493103, 0.2738628387451172, -0.48784777522087097, 0.010541745461523533, 0.10546725243330002, -0.680212140083313, -0.37619712948799133, 0.40116405487060547, 0.7620042562484741, -0.43259158730506897, 0.8101109862327576, -0.05745032802224159, 0.7925933003425598, -0.06360547989606857, -0.557110607624054, 1.0972336530685425, 0.4811514914035797, -0.09867619723081589, -0.17386844754219055, -0.21450181305408478, 0.09363245218992233, 0.830062210559845, 0.4868225157260895, -0.5369510650634766, 0.8348921537399292, 0.5503496527671814, 0.29290297627449036, 0.22385284304618835, -0.4622952938079834, 0.12926533818244934, 0.5995315313339233, -0.4833501875400543, -0.05196961387991905, -0.2975355386734009, 0.4710306227207184, 0.18092507123947144, -0.5101821422576904, 0.6843118667602539, -1.5859899520874023, -0.6022112965583801, -0.13678322732448578, -0.15006734430789948, 0.9875204563140869, -0.2671862840652466, 0.8897294402122498, -0.36773309111595154, 0.6306449770927429, -0.5122370719909668, 0.22987399995326996, 0.4894861876964569, -0.8380489945411682, -0.6965956687927246, -0.0671224370598793, 0.4387621283531189, -0.3031575083732605, -0.05167964845895767, 0.13227087259292603, -0.4398562014102936, -0.21009032428264618, 1.48150634765625, -0.41216161847114563, -0.01316185761243105, 1.2979943752288818, -0.14404502511024475, -0.5611029863357544, -0.32405567169189453, 0.017243243753910065, -0.8802454471588135, -0.8424046635627747, 0.7475876808166504, -0.7732385993003845, -0.012970696203410625, 0.7455707788467407, 0.40445175766944885, 0.6826900839805603, -0.16589443385601044, 0.5758540034294128, -0.2917669117450714, -0.04289992153644562, 0.9798222780227661, -0.17439015209674835, -0.2905709743499756, -0.8301082253456116, 0.08838237822055817, -0.10156359523534775, -0.9931825399398804, -0.08265881985425949, 0.6439250707626343, -0.6905333399772644, -0.07465357333421707, 0.7733281850814819, -0.30553898215293884, -0.23876219987869263, -0.5476644039154053, -0.8389721512794495, 0.4258216619491577, -0.135266974568367, -0.6247023940086365, 0.6285097002983093, 0.3401271402835846, 0.5103361010551453, 0.19282697141170502, -0.45578718185424805, -0.5133092999458313, 0.2719351351261139, -1.5053253173828125, 0.5207709074020386, -0.5720152258872986, 0.1470710039138794, -0.2763811945915222, -1.321958065032959, 0.0601562075316906, 0.10457625240087509, 0.6945568919181824, -0.6859370470046997, 0.39389559626579285, 0.23244944214820862, 0.8995680809020996, -0.251855731010437, -0.9174779653549194, 0.4620409309864044, 0.5837361812591553, 0.6722940802574158, -0.5263588428497314, 1.1131170988082886, -0.13859376311302185, 0.9169274568557739, -0.7382265329360962, 0.1548537015914917, -0.4093148112297058, 0.14480845630168915, -0.014419318176805973, -1.203766107559204, 0.34958893060684204, -0.22961388528347015, -0.419872909784317, 0.7394549250602722, 0.29341742396354675, -0.4209000766277313, -0.35775139927864075, -0.7780480980873108, 0.026577159762382507, -0.6091476082801819, 0.2605907618999481, -0.23970741033554077, -0.03859516233205795, 0.7035859823226929, 0.33143529295921326, -0.07830119878053665, -0.9981006979942322, 3.563389539718628, 1.562502384185791, 0.674121081829071, -0.1475221812725067, 0.40952062606811523, 0.3289400339126587, 0.3526892364025116, -0.21309208869934082, -0.1912933588027954, -0.017254075035452843, -0.19868148863315582, 0.030517153441905975, 0.8512067794799805, -0.42238739132881165, 0.244246244430542, 0.6652016043663025, -1.4605474472045898, -0.17301127314567566, -0.17114469408988953, -0.6548868417739868, -1.0129259824752808, -0.03254983201622963, 0.2579835057258606, -0.22694438695907593, 0.866421639919281, 0.10450059920549393, -0.5184781551361084, 0.2678968608379364, -0.5679606199264526, -0.6450626850128174, -0.6932742595672607, -0.7187922596931458, 0.3406164050102234, 0.7486287951469421, -0.34504184126853943, 0.07938439399003983, -0.2744887173175812, -0.7392430305480957, -0.037677157670259476, 0.39650797843933105, -0.3068324625492096, -0.8910938501358032, -0.5101329684257507, -0.15385673940181732, -0.2513776421546936, 0.7155865430831909, -0.44729429483413696, 0.1541258841753006, -0.0603896901011467, -0.6377028226852417, 1.0894933938980103, -0.8300672173500061, 1.0279996395111084, -0.508514404296875, -0.718186616897583, 0.02473016455769539, -0.1866297721862793, -0.842250645160675, -0.0025040735490620136, 0.48693904280662537, 0.45344239473342896, 0.46807026863098145, -0.4038858711719513, 0.33730295300483704, 0.20091956853866577, 0.7435131072998047, 0.015570436604321003, -0.17102856934070587, -0.5065562129020691, -0.41663429141044617, -0.30401861667633057, -0.18487468361854553, -0.16204577684402466, 0.5609210729598999, 0.350664347410202, 0.5142031311988831, -0.12204112112522125, 0.8823925852775574, -0.710457980632782, -0.5669798851013184, 0.9116490483283997, -0.26055651903152466, 0.10934674739837646, -0.4969838559627533, 0.404828280210495, 0.36639243364334106, -1.458890438079834, -0.1331755369901657, -1.453731894493103, 1.075216293334961, -0.3357661962509155, 0.059400394558906555, 0.45401880145072937, -0.04962488263845444, -0.3804611563682556 ]
{"Title": "Identifying 31 novel breast cancer susceptibility loci using data from genome-wide association studies conducted in Asian and European women", "Authors": "Shu Xiang, Long Jirong, Cai Qiuyin, Kweon Sun-Seog, Choi Ji-Yeob, Kubo Michiaki, ParK Sue K., Bolla Manjeet K., Dennis Joe, Wang Qin, Yang Yaohua, Shi Jiajun, Guo Xingyi, Li Bingshan, Tao Ran, Aronson Kristan J., Chan Kelvin Y.K., Chan Tsun L., Gao Yu-Tang, Hartman Mikael, Ho Weang Kee, Ito Hidemi, Iwasaki Motoki, Iwata Hiroji, John Esther M., Kasuga Yoshio, Khoo Ui Soon, Kim Mi-Kyung, Kurian Allison W., Kwong Ava, Li Jingmei, Lophatananon Artitaya, Low Siew-Kee, Mariapun Shivaani, Matsuda Koichi, Matsuo Keitaro, Muir Kenneth, Noh Dong-Young, Park Boyoung, Park Min-Ho, Shen Chen-Yang, Shin Min-Ho, Spinelli John J., Takahashi Atsushi, Tseng Chiuchen, Tsugane Shoichiro, Wu Anna H., Xiang Yong-Bing, Yamaji Taiki, Zheng Ying, Milne Roger L., Dunning Alison M., Pharoah Paul D.P., Garc\u00eda-Closas Montserrat, Teo Soo-Hwang, Shu Xiao-ou, Kang Daehee, Easton Douglas F., Simard Jacques, Zheng Wei", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Common genetic variants in 183 loci have been identified in relation to breast cancer risk in genome-wide association studies (GWAS). These risk variants combined explain only a relatively small proportion of breast cancer heritability, particularly in Asian populations. To search for additional genetic susceptibility loci for breast cancer, we performed a meta-analysis of data from GWAS conducted in Asians (24,206 cases and 24,775 controls). Variants showing an association with breast cancer risk at P < 0.01 were evaluated in GWAS conducted in European women including 122,977 cases and 105,974 controls. In the combined analysis of data from both Asian and European women, the lead variant in 28 loci not previously reported showed an association with breast cancer risk at P < 5 \u00d710 \u22128 . In the meta-analysis of all GWAS data from Asian and European descendants, we identified SNPs in three additional loci in association with breast cancer risk at P < 5 \u00d710 \u22128 . The associations for 10 of these loci were replicated in an independent sample of 16,787 cases and 16,680 controls of Asian women ( P < 0.05). Expression quantitative trait locus (eQTL) and gene-based analyses provided evidence for the possible involvement of the YBEY, MAN2C1, SNUPN, TBX1, SEMA4A, STC1, MUTYH, LOXL2 , and LINC00886 genes underlying the associations observed in eight of these 28 newly identified risk loci. In addition, we replicated the association for 78 of the 166 previously reported risk variants at P < 0.05 in women of Asian descent using GWAS data. These findings improve our understanding of breast cancer genetics and etiology and extend to Asian populations previous findings from studies of European women.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003855"}
10.1101/2019.12.12.19014746
[ -0.23692259192466736, -0.05381277948617935, 0.288880854845047, -0.14539235830307007, 0.48162412643432617, 0.4756503403186798, -0.4464128017425537, -0.5115844011306763, 0.7071873545646667, 0.7742577791213989, 0.18556338548660278, -0.19202372431755066, 1.4019862413406372, -0.8576317429542542, -0.1328531801700592, -0.062211234122514725, -0.06263824552297592, 0.04967249557375908, -0.05632919818162918, -0.1809193193912506, 0.3114430606365204, 0.9511660933494568, -0.6118054986000061, 0.2874402701854706, -0.604203999042511, 0.5778990983963013, -0.2889872193336487, 0.3351779878139496, 1.2639787197113037, 0.4778228998184204, -0.4867085814476013, -0.37107276916503906, 0.15585781633853912, -0.6270546317100525, -0.1302356868982315, 0.32622987031936646, 0.6952658891677856, -0.3430910110473633, -0.3580052852630615, -0.6744081974029541, 0.17624801397323608, 0.26035207509994507, 0.7293784618377686, -1.0559808015823364, -0.0644693449139595, -0.5922856330871582, -0.4330084025859833, -0.04359405115246773, -0.34712401032447815, -0.21034874022006989, -0.7262433171272278, -0.19238555431365967, -0.13996832072734833, -0.4845443665981293, -0.4169095754623413, 0.2554379999637604, -0.03664122149348259, -0.2876720428466797, -0.670566976070404, 0.6008365750312805, 0.182174950838089, -0.7150418162345886, 0.6871564984321594, -0.9247520565986633, 1.0218156576156616, 0.992523193359375, -0.5740899443626404, 0.029150106012821198, 0.32584184408187866, -0.03602587804198265, -0.7081505060195923, -0.1571820080280304, -0.46392199397087097, 0.04246816784143448, -0.2489943653345108, -0.11154291033744812, 0.24574683606624603, 0.19283534586429596, -0.2584940493106842, -0.3298895061016083, -0.046444401144981384, 1.0478473901748657, 0.11219049245119095, 0.7071426510810852, -0.9211833477020264, -0.3554897904396057, -0.296795129776001, 0.38443025946617126, -0.32179197669029236, 0.6251818537712097, 0.16686950623989105, 0.2656415104866028, 0.19428858160972595, 0.18668636679649353, -0.4045344293117523, 0.7176355719566345, -0.8863640427589417, 0.1349058598279953, 0.12851276993751526, -0.44757235050201416, 0.892049252986908, 0.9054310917854309, -0.4712327718734741, 0.047083426266908646, -0.3164314925670624, 0.5139323472976685, 0.9383334517478943, 0.14853452146053314, -0.5669100284576416, -0.5382990837097168, 0.2374231368303299, -0.6184671521186829, -1.0220301151275635, 0.4505196213722229, 0.89390629529953, 0.11624425649642944, -0.026991117745637894, 0.8188472390174866, -0.008802114985883236, -0.32341882586479187, -0.04927224665880203, -0.16672275960445404, 0.20286010205745697, -0.6584597826004028, -0.14713436365127563, 0.06936877220869064, 0.08495377749204636, 0.763567328453064, 0.05170344188809395, 0.07767214626073837, 0.4330621361732483, -0.7996933460235596, -0.4677906632423401, 1.1233794689178467, -0.27410897612571716, -0.01938348449766636, -0.043394576758146286, 0.3765738904476166, 0.11688565462827682, -0.32328760623931885, 0.08480959385633469, 0.33389681577682495, -0.7456441521644592, 0.9855515360832214, -0.4491642415523529, 1.2308248281478882, -0.6087084412574768, -1.7140047550201416, -0.13414913415908813, -0.18922856450080872, -0.7019279599189758, 0.9357211589813232, 0.1262536495923996, -0.6175358295440674, -0.2697376012802124, 1.0311559438705444, 0.058206941932439804, 0.7843362092971802, 0.45668619871139526, 0.11282848566770554, 0.2721504271030426, -0.15168768167495728, -0.5808983445167542, 0.22438326478004456, 0.3239929676055908, 0.551276445388794, -0.04637319967150688, 0.6904690265655518, 0.044530004262924194, -0.3868049085140228, 0.7467721104621887, 0.18349966406822205, -0.557060956954956, 0.037162378430366516, -0.19956931471824646, 0.41963067650794983, 0.6503782272338867, -0.2284991443157196, 0.25684112310409546, 0.7948629856109619, 0.12108708918094635, 0.1441807746887207, 0.013896043412387371, 0.6569758653640747, 0.06208207085728645, 1.1558552980422974, 0.2394208014011383, -0.03657050058245659, -0.5275922417640686, -1.4080382585525513, 0.5552220344543457, 0.23755274713039398, -0.746751070022583, 1.0166611671447754, -0.8397605419158936, -0.28634023666381836, -0.5668047666549683, 0.3293633460998535, 0.7993757128715515, 0.11766327172517776, -0.9702139496803284, 0.9040337204933167, -0.5679164528846741, 0.2555130422115326, 0.08340177685022354, 0.791558027267456, 0.10801849514245987, 0.39309874176979065, -0.8108454942703247, -0.15619921684265137, 0.39011743664741516, -0.12975768744945526, -0.28647536039352417, 0.27241793274879456, 0.5070768594741821, -0.5887975692749023, 0.08251120150089264, 0.45137327909469604, 0.05858892574906349, -0.22897228598594666, 0.5210732817649841, 0.23411139845848083, 0.5554893612861633, -0.24271415174007416, -0.15358953177928925, 0.2978845238685608, 0.4607943594455719, 0.18419113755226135, 0.09946524351835251, -0.45309287309646606, -0.16415025293827057, 0.6257761120796204, -0.41880542039871216, 0.6526762247085571, 0.48021674156188965, -0.1804882138967514, 0.4211041331291199, 0.407440185546875, -0.034413713961839676, 0.18536916375160217, 0.25838950276374817, 0.06781122833490372, 0.35232973098754883, 0.5189454555511475, 0.1090206429362297, -0.15517574548721313, -0.14395771920681, -0.32941585779190063, -0.38897904753685, 0.970992386341095, 0.12535429000854492, 1.2488222122192383, 1.0422297716140747, 0.22264420986175537, -0.7829037308692932, 0.22899852693080902, 0.11317369341850281, 0.006573206279426813, 0.11598367989063263, -0.24261899292469025, 0.42892271280288696, -0.39245277643203735, 0.5269110798835754, 0.043407708406448364, 1.1842812299728394, 0.08944593369960785, 0.043773770332336426, -0.09294968843460083, -0.24538889527320862, 0.2485022395849228, -1.2783024311065674, -1.2432321310043335, -1.134634017944336, -0.16204403340816498, -1.4640382528305054, -0.809164822101593, 0.381227046251297, -0.19489021599292755, 0.6578211784362793, 0.718532383441925, -0.18011046946048737, -0.6339515447616577, 0.01714974269270897, 0.3719191253185272, 0.37369102239608765, 0.957548201084137, -0.3565404713153839, 0.17094413936138153, -0.10669448971748352, -0.1456655114889145, -0.13043102622032166, 0.1817123144865036, -0.16747403144836426, -0.6603521108627319, 0.4986295700073242, -0.2662866711616516, 0.5025060772895813, -0.8517923355102539, -0.1539449393749237, 0.13108915090560913, 0.2605001628398895, 0.24036677181720734, -0.34210070967674255, -0.5949687957763672, -0.39225661754608154, 0.5720469355583191, 0.23228523135185242, 0.7451417446136475, 0.31949278712272644, 0.3931850492954254, 0.13160547614097595, 1.1825973987579346, 0.2579895555973053, -0.039244893938302994, -0.9381433725357056, 0.5899092555046082, 0.6353748440742493, -0.23576050996780396, 0.059369590133428574, -1.53669011592865, -1.1279276609420776, -0.22509461641311646, 0.24269212782382965, -0.41543149948120117, 0.1256636530160904, 0.6723538041114807, 0.28549084067344666, -1.377725601196289, 0.21265268325805664, -0.2788597345352173, -0.8387095332145691, 0.14547111093997955, 0.38194742798805237, 0.6678987741470337, 0.20976974070072174, 0.1983308345079422, -0.47430381178855896, 0.13333070278167725, 0.10095227509737015, 0.18066932260990143, 0.5936998128890991, -0.29018634557724, 0.19672845304012299, 0.9045438766479492, 0.08847038447856903, 0.2767180800437927, 0.023165153339505196, 0.4390758275985718, -0.2546731233596802, 0.05021098628640175, -0.5587923526763916, -0.44875624775886536, 0.44556573033332825, -0.050042640417814255, -1.2043296098709106, 0.4219647943973541, 0.29015251994132996, -0.41729462146759033, -0.16359885036945343, 0.6426577568054199, -0.25646695494651794, 0.5317440032958984, 0.2141333669424057, -0.30449968576431274, -0.5235325694084167, -0.8870218992233276, 0.04780924692749977, -0.40347912907600403, 0.11392372101545334, -1.1515018939971924, 0.6879063844680786, 0.7858331799507141, 0.10120309889316559, 0.17039062082767487, 0.4192006289958954, 0.0493374727666378, 0.8818675875663757, 0.6113548874855042, 0.8370530605316162, -0.9056097865104675, -0.051088619977235794, 0.4059719443321228, 1.5992611646652222, 0.6770429015159607, 0.2612437307834625, 0.503006100654602, -1.5556881427764893, 0.24683783948421478, -0.6495427489280701, -0.13824088871479034, -0.04356114938855171, 0.19146153330802917, -0.000649208901450038, 0.3640390932559967, -0.5985701680183411, -0.3048885464668274, 0.9343998432159424, 0.6553546190261841, -0.1545678824186325, 0.5566638112068176, 0.5775368809700012, 0.4774899184703827, 0.1668025106191635, 0.6258010864257812, 0.348906010389328, -0.01256655529141426, -0.2069953978061676, 0.253743052482605, 0.21731145679950714, 0.13862104713916779, 0.024384697899222374, -0.3671841323375702, -0.5779497623443604, -0.2606508731842041, 0.11343635618686676, -0.3004310727119446, -0.8496734499931335, -0.47947391867637634, -0.27825379371643066, 0.062237199395895004, 0.6495361328125, -0.37953856587409973, -0.676070511341095, -0.20513446629047394, 0.12004037946462631, -0.7503518462181091, -0.38874104619026184, -0.2521730065345764, 0.28311216831207275, 0.47332680225372314, -0.8147265315055847, -0.577414870262146, -0.3232707679271698, -0.33727145195007324, -0.37918296456336975, -0.052426569163799286, 0.12558159232139587, -0.47802257537841797, 0.6411094069480896, -0.5450320839881897, -0.16527901589870453, 0.030869649723172188, 0.32574784755706787, -0.06060213968157768, -0.2587408125400543, -0.21664851903915405, 1.01542329788208, 0.6906720399856567, 0.36642682552337646, -0.8445631861686707, 0.2517562508583069, -0.7107575535774231, -0.08004391193389893, -0.17427471280097961, -0.10527107119560242, 0.4030856192111969, -0.5799189805984497, 0.18315647542476654, 1.0649994611740112, 0.09089751541614532, -0.3576834201812744, -0.4475056827068329, 0.06080930680036545, -0.11264288425445557, -0.62378990650177, 0.8861688375473022, 0.1450522094964981, 0.9414783120155334, 1.1992560625076294, 0.09488250315189362, -0.026808500289916992, -0.1709478795528412, 0.3563917279243469, -1.4339253902435303, 0.21818535029888153, -0.011300896294414997, 0.12319951504468918, -0.03315409645438194, -0.11404121667146683, 0.8016879558563232, 0.07769272476434708, 1.008272409439087, -0.3549940586090088, -0.6132951974868774, -0.042644795030355453, -0.4016278088092804, -0.3801974654197693, -0.17691682279109955, -0.9477222561836243, -0.1052914410829544, -0.18098370730876923, -0.8010878562927246, 0.20705050230026245, -0.40400388836860657, 0.24967637658119202, -1.077797532081604, -0.2986845076084137, 0.4219898581504822, -0.31702661514282227, -0.15359938144683838, 1.3880161046981812, -0.30090078711509705, -1.1451472043991089, -0.023976298049092293, 0.358943909406662, -0.3109254240989685, -0.05739736557006836, 0.05458170920610428, -0.5723421573638916, -0.5869883298873901, -0.37953513860702515, -0.01867613196372986, -0.5838753581047058, -0.6986562013626099, -0.22213634848594666, 0.42515045404434204, 0.3079439401626587, 0.33854568004608154, -0.2970699667930603, -0.1898338943719864, 0.2227487415075302, -0.46720972657203674, -0.49544838070869446, 0.4554857313632965, 0.11868128925561905, -0.46877095103263855, 0.076797254383564, -0.29025736451148987, -0.6040024757385254, -0.8436447381973267, 1.051533818244934, -1.5151559114456177, 0.3348548114299774, -0.7707532048225403, 0.15178845822811127, -0.3986739218235016, 0.4324575364589691, 0.6266849040985107, -0.5754289627075195, -0.4015117287635803, -0.7426019906997681, 0.17395934462547302, -0.4546263515949249, -0.979278564453125, -0.6911657452583313, -0.33480721712112427, 0.6659336090087891, 0.519014835357666, 0.41012659668922424, -0.4229901432991028, -0.710891604423523, 0.36296114325523376, 0.9760676622390747, 0.8315035700798035, -0.7773390412330627, -0.6204687356948853, 0.9199159741401672, 0.9020439386367798, 0.7574624419212341, -0.14966148138046265, -1.3039923906326294, -0.4935745894908905, -0.8681929111480713, 0.4238085448741913, -0.22452612221240997, -1.2047263383865356, -0.12130951136350632, -0.0851006880402565, 1.823954701423645, -0.29985782504081726, 0.5058762431144714, -0.7720486521720886, 0.3581007719039917, -0.7184047102928162, 0.221964031457901, -0.31589382886886597, -1.0606118440628052, -1.1246087551116943, -0.771489143371582, 0.3950966000556946, -0.7535421848297119, -0.6163614392280579, -0.06394864618778229, 0.8971114158630371, -0.4162015914916992, -0.20961716771125793, 0.9470817446708679, 0.2504734992980957, 0.07989387959241867, -0.446952760219574, 0.3942492604255676, -0.08041077852249146, 0.5389268398284912, 0.21991010010242462, 0.07791930437088013, -0.32036590576171875, 0.21290139853954315, -1.0962169170379639, -0.221699059009552, -1.6104600429534912, -0.19457468390464783, 0.5240718126296997, 0.3330039083957672, -0.005221120547503233, 0.0771498903632164, -0.06583143025636673, 0.2527517080307007, -0.48717808723449707, 0.3744479715824127, -0.37016761302948, 0.2067110538482666, 0.7210172414779663, -0.3155904710292816, 0.2523461878299713, 0.7686731815338135, 0.3058581054210663, -0.5195827484130859, -0.11623623967170715, 0.30850744247436523, -0.3121528923511505, -0.8001232743263245, 0.33070123195648193, 0.862518846988678, -0.29525190591812134, -0.886763334274292, -0.3035769462585449, -0.03603660687804222, 0.49039003252983093, -0.5077618360519409, -0.54014652967453, 0.2466229647397995, -0.39897972345352173, 0.3898790180683136, -0.14189067482948303, 0.49535050988197327, -0.00353551865555346, -0.22854706645011902, -0.20099110901355743, -0.516834557056427, 0.7430078387260437, 0.8049800395965576, -0.23205162584781647, 0.40769079327583313, -0.20252297818660736, 0.6021643877029419, -0.3243739902973175, 0.6035380959510803, 0.7099620699882507, 0.15709950029850006, 0.6256038546562195, -0.21284912526607513, 0.6241512894630432, -0.16252636909484863, 0.25148987770080566, -0.04710745811462402, 0.47184455394744873, 0.822577714920044, -0.8633603453636169, -0.9437289237976074, 1.077344536781311, 0.6063178181648254, 0.4589398205280304, 0.23680479824543, 0.38667547702789307, 1.0114836692810059, 0.308132141828537, 0.04877089709043503, -0.49042463302612305, -0.6814510822296143, -0.4356580376625061, 0.24089315533638, -0.05650165304541588, 0.05438819155097008, 0.1401890069246292, 0.31447136402130127, -0.1526297926902771, -0.49395641684532166, -0.49565720558166504, 0.49643170833587646, -0.3296835422515869, 0.33689528703689575, -0.5721244215965271, 0.47461679577827454, -0.8784326314926147, -1.581882119178772, 0.25044941902160645, -0.2600635290145874, 0.3433106243610382, 0.8695126175880432, 0.14498533308506012, 0.18066753447055817, 0.652829110622406, 0.17727196216583252, 0.21696597337722778, -0.28751006722450256, -0.5416701436042786, -0.6003764271736145, -0.9778187870979309, 0.4910271167755127, 0.3324769139289856, 0.28413400053977966, 0.8750962615013123, -0.6833713054656982, -0.20578308403491974, 0.5717161893844604, -0.4845682382583618, -0.9490262269973755, -0.20136775076389313, 0.19880276918411255, -0.6660676002502441, -0.18320554494857788, -0.6173661351203918, 0.4588017463684082, -0.5380321741104126, -0.2860068082809448, -0.01351073943078518, -0.2528837323188782, 0.46038633584976196, 0.03396894782781601, -0.40954461693763733, 0.7093884348869324, -0.5514315366744995, 0.2845747172832489, -0.1762646734714508, 0.46648019552230835, -0.01371079869568348, -0.10246963798999786, 0.8213833570480347, 0.3781084418296814, 0.4740350544452667, -1.1070036888122559, 0.490666002035141, 0.5015475153923035, -0.3731880784034729, 0.2835020124912262, -0.10321705788373947, 0.37082022428512573, -0.0362323522567749, 0.04675384238362312, 0.514981746673584, 1.1707963943481445, -0.42199575901031494, -0.16589771211147308, 0.1287592500448227, -0.8468486666679382, -1.0540571212768555, -0.5590913891792297, -0.704105794429779, -0.4731897711753845, 1.0612993240356445, -0.5748491883277893, 0.3099079430103302, -1.0651512145996094, -0.644569993019104, 0.5030019879341125, 1.0036345720291138, 0.47502779960632324, -0.40800994634628296, -0.11497674137353897, 0.13565361499786377, 0.5649566650390625, 0.3281954228878021, -0.5085663795471191, -0.008109066635370255, -0.030345475301146507, -0.5928257703781128, -0.37951162457466125, 0.5846350789070129, -0.13689304888248444, -0.4412687420845032, -0.3194407820701599, -0.02710661292076111, 0.3723917305469513, -0.2229514867067337, -0.4222213923931122, -0.0029718386940658092, -0.43878188729286194, -1.3167108297348022, -0.06644069403409958, -0.2043958306312561, -0.42835143208503723, -0.7050563097000122, 0.529775083065033, -0.08225707709789276, -0.36627501249313354, -0.6068112850189209, -0.6759907007217407, 1.1099095344543457, -1.1690421104431152, 0.4738878905773163, -0.2839633822441101, 0.762262761592865, -0.5693860054016113, -0.6101909279823303, 0.8013423085212708, 0.9531057476997375, -0.03592146560549736, 0.14017494022846222, -0.2847258150577545, 0.7012215852737427, 0.5411483645439148, 0.29566723108291626, -0.28006601333618164, 0.7470649480819702, 0.18521904945373535, -0.09672349691390991, 0.5975311398506165, 0.04969330132007599, 0.46545010805130005, 0.3362046778202057, -0.036938365548849106, 0.3269733786582947, 0.8395430445671082, -0.054470404982566833, 0.1313878744840622, 0.38973361253738403, 0.6082887053489685, -0.569503903388977, -0.8989611268043518, 0.38045814633369446, -0.4727948307991028, 0.7953078746795654, 0.3649822771549225, 0.8237536549568176, -0.12149592489004135, 0.5354287028312683, 0.3672843277454376, -0.5195610523223877, 0.8181372880935669, -0.739279568195343, -0.5192587375640869, -0.6745592951774597, -0.11816394329071045, -0.6646363735198975, 0.05507250875234604, 0.1815585494041443, -0.4112018048763275, 0.3884302079677582, 0.42123180627822876, -0.061967894434928894, -0.22268247604370117, 0.5569345951080322, -0.004979223012924194, -0.053438108414411545, -0.788250207901001, 0.5200639963150024, -0.22382909059524536, 0.2542876601219177, 0.6061949729919434, -1.1133325099945068, 0.5619320869445801, 0.4394787847995758, 0.19789911806583405, 0.2841147482395172, 0.13063085079193115, 0.7906993627548218, -0.25581011176109314, 1.105668544769287, 0.5421295762062073, 0.17490144073963165, 0.7598094940185547, -0.11066450923681259, -0.20656363666057587, -0.4539790153503418, -0.7629058361053467, 0.16049005091190338, 0.22313396632671356, -0.8629780411720276, -0.4827449917793274, 0.35939082503318787, -0.14465509355068207, -0.7274798154830933, -0.977809488773346, 0.14028343558311462, 0.10348568111658096, -0.166053906083107, -0.7268973588943481, 0.2949141263961792, 0.674046516418457, -0.7456953525543213, 0.5391613841056824, 0.1408260613679886, -1.0860098600387573, -0.1672772765159607, -0.9410136938095093, 0.1532295048236847, 0.043583791702985764, -0.12830059230327606, -0.5339937806129456, -0.9435763955116272, -0.16799402236938477, -0.20369374752044678, -0.1596769392490387, -0.8369876742362976, 0.0675361156463623, -0.07912298291921616, 1.1802188158035278, -0.2860880494117737, -0.47919347882270813, 0.8746394515037537, 0.011583558283746243, 0.7260918021202087, 0.6605464816093445, 1.2132441997528076, 0.45327287912368774, 0.7631828784942627, 0.08054491132497787, -0.0005645314231514931, 0.5894395112991333, -0.37427714467048645, 0.1398872584104538, -0.921248197555542, -0.29990386962890625, -0.4453829824924469, -1.110559105873108, 0.4793657064437866, 1.254774570465088, -0.334833025932312, -0.4153423011302948, -0.30072659254074097, -0.11029040068387985, -0.03537296503782272, 0.6696990728378296, -0.0675051137804985, 0.07571244239807129, -0.38646939396858215, -0.042640235275030136, -0.3341003656387329, -0.9645569324493408, 3.8178834915161133, 0.7246824502944946, 0.5487952828407288, -0.4810244143009186, 0.8129444718360901, -0.2796817123889923, 0.30037495493888855, -0.30011144280433655, 0.17100302875041962, -0.5090644955635071, -0.21298807859420776, 0.5447819232940674, 0.12466719001531601, 0.41114315390586853, 0.0217598769813776, 0.7815347909927368, -1.3738999366760254, -0.1830381155014038, -0.3649246394634247, -0.9589732885360718, -0.9878163933753967, -0.0014541546115651727, 0.3383104205131531, -0.3247682750225067, 0.5195363759994507, 0.12278159707784653, -0.5989792943000793, 0.3459445536136627, 0.3167913258075714, 1.0283796787261963, -0.4155161678791046, -0.8841841816902161, 0.1127680242061615, -0.3761262595653534, -0.3305824100971222, 0.32990679144859314, -0.45503342151641846, 0.06623104214668274, 0.05342958867549896, -0.20572641491889954, 0.5031437873840332, -1.0966078042984009, -0.015456879511475563, 0.18369226157665253, 0.418740838766098, 0.08577606081962585, -0.5345221161842346, 0.08273207396268845, 0.7665981650352478, -0.2263563573360443, 0.9344372153282166, -0.6526235938072205, 0.10070036351680756, -0.2566111981868744, -0.8719476461410522, -0.5326375961303711, -0.5172160267829895, -0.6350815892219543, -0.2989121079444885, 0.6715126037597656, 0.21827274560928345, 0.26199451088905334, -0.5976796746253967, -0.22570376098155975, 0.13518528640270233, 0.5609712600708008, -0.03651267662644386, 0.2063693404197693, -0.5622775554656982, -0.18633519113063812, 0.29432958364486694, -0.7789126038551331, -0.37319180369377136, 0.05920172482728958, 0.44863617420196533, 0.45379164814949036, -0.6173565983772278, 0.7264739274978638, -0.4811861217021942, -0.38105908036231995, 0.8473115563392639, 0.24258683621883392, 0.09643606841564178, -0.3884367048740387, -0.06900600343942642, 0.21658599376678467, 0.060045499354600906, -0.2340499758720398, -0.9319642782211304, -0.3532600998878479, 0.2851204574108124, -0.12015620619058609, 0.23587511479854584, -0.16854310035705566, 0.0702207088470459 ]
{"Title": "Integrated Bioinformatic Approach to Identify Potential Biomarkers against Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis", "Authors": "Ullah Md. Asad, Sarkar Bishajit, Araf Yusha, Islam Prottoy Md. Nazmul, Saha Ananna, Jahan Tanjila, Boby Aisha Siddiqua, Islam Md. Shariful", "Abstract": "Abstract Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis (IPF) is a chronic and progressive lung disease that leads to gradual decline in lung function. The molecular mechanism and risk factors of this disease are still obscure. Poorly understood etiology of this disease is the major obstacle in the identification of potential biomarkers and drug targets. In this study, microarray gene expression data of normal and IPF patient has been utilized for the statistical analysis of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) with a view to identifying potential molecular signatures using network-based system. Then their functional enrichment analysis revealed their predominant involvement in transcription, protein acetylation, extracellular matrix organization, apoptic process, inflammatory response etc. Protein-Protein Interaction (PPI) network revealed (UBC, PTEN, SOS1, PTK2, FGFR1, YAP1, FOXO1, RACK1, BMP4 and CD44) as hub proteins in IPF. Subsequent regulatory network analysis suggested (E2F1, STAT3, PPARG, MEF2A, FOXC1, GATA3, YY1, GATA2, NFKB1, and FOXL1) as the best regulatory transcriptional signatures and (hsa-mir-155-5p, hsa-mir-16-5p, hsa-mir-17-5p, hsa-mir-19a-3p, hsa-mir-192-5p, hsa-mir-92a-3p, hsa-mir-26b-5p, hsa-mir-335-5p, hsa-mir-124-3p, and hsa-let-7b-5p) as the best post-transcriptional signatures. This study represents proteome and RNA signatures of IPF which might be useful to uphold the present efforts in the discovery of potential biomarkers and treatments of this disease.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.12.19014746"}
10.1101/2019.12.11.19014597
[ 0.6329994201660156, 0.0835704356431961, -0.2280632108449936, -0.06091761961579323, 0.19579032063484192, -0.2904416620731354, -0.4576205909252167, -0.7039608955383301, 0.887833833694458, 0.32522690296173096, 0.5253403782844543, -0.3914356231689453, 0.5500040650367737, -0.5611441135406494, -0.18281583487987518, -0.8765881061553955, -0.009222948923707008, -0.1264835000038147, -0.46208667755126953, -0.6280683279037476, 0.3094205856323242, 0.11737431585788727, -0.7436270713806152, 0.41280680894851685, -0.24761579930782318, 0.30224308371543884, 0.07132533192634583, -0.022843025624752045, 0.9883689880371094, -0.0888008400797844, -0.4763543903827667, -0.3660969138145447, 0.31037628650665283, -1.2822827100753784, -0.19147704541683197, -0.2368183732032776, 0.8971308469772339, -0.13092388212680817, -0.5063221454620361, -0.7207549810409546, 0.06950139999389648, 0.3569015562534332, 0.21031896770000458, -0.5941647887229919, -0.37671616673469543, -0.014346534386277199, -0.2944980263710022, 0.04258911684155464, -0.06394731253385544, -0.17237621545791626, -0.5416080951690674, 0.4003857970237732, 0.012637384235858917, -0.28191065788269043, -0.15405693650245667, 0.4650895893573761, 0.3641716539859772, 0.014638605527579784, -0.9492802023887634, -0.5628085136413574, 0.5187180638313293, -0.04337943345308304, 0.3599705398082733, -1.1939740180969238, 0.6113729476928711, 0.9158595204353333, -0.04305744171142578, -0.5459542274475098, 0.002384074730798602, 0.0019841636531054974, 0.033375322818756104, 0.15536271035671234, -0.3407345414161682, -0.5219298005104065, -0.19018462300300598, -0.7822348475456238, 1.2146774530410767, 0.08848199993371964, 0.1352800726890564, 0.2751457989215851, 0.2741495370864868, 0.4656505882740021, 0.24320074915885925, -0.71331787109375, -0.2196367233991623, 0.16528922319412231, 0.8136909008026123, 0.706823468208313, -0.18375730514526367, 0.6356485486030579, -0.17010898888111115, 0.37261149287223816, -0.3183028995990753, 0.20839644968509674, -0.21006964147090912, 1.2975345849990845, -0.6717915534973145, 0.25598129630088806, -0.17126429080963135, -0.11052345484495163, 0.20784375071525574, 1.0837202072143555, -0.8296405673027039, 0.7160356640815735, -0.30234789848327637, 0.45367562770843506, 0.4090012311935425, -0.4040519595146179, -1.1678916215896606, -0.30502206087112427, 0.690227210521698, 0.4765271544456482, -1.1326258182525635, 0.6807935237884521, 0.49665436148643494, 0.7925370931625366, -0.2352781593799591, 1.124267578125, -0.7756502032279968, -0.3453078866004944, -0.2112138420343399, -0.16821326315402985, 0.7698078155517578, -0.26215559244155884, 0.18781553208827972, 0.3955928683280945, -0.15572987496852875, 0.26018258929252625, -0.6311456561088562, 0.12052831053733826, 0.07563555240631104, -0.3011210262775421, 0.3388884663581848, 0.2247065305709839, -0.029176922515034676, -0.1901492029428482, 0.07722069323062897, 0.23916132748126984, 0.7465503215789795, -0.33168652653694153, 0.0008976919343695045, -0.07183172553777695, -0.9670455455780029, 1.409757137298584, 0.007535218261182308, 0.33152633905410767, -0.2012394219636917, -1.5363329648971558, -0.8519278764724731, -0.3803750276565552, 0.4561101198196411, 0.26094138622283936, -0.4075247347354889, -0.6116979718208313, 0.01402248628437519, 0.7700391411781311, 0.025310538709163666, 0.2721036672592163, 0.15298908948898315, -0.11726659536361694, -0.4788524806499481, 0.25352296233177185, 1.0309051275253296, 0.6379653811454773, -0.5225297212600708, 0.7348311543464661, 0.06532330065965652, 0.07818180322647095, -0.056179437786340714, -0.17901290953159332, 0.8372468948364258, -0.3281075060367584, 0.15624630451202393, 0.09150911867618561, -0.1828111857175827, 0.24953153729438782, 1.0551930665969849, -0.04072508588433266, 0.3865976929664612, 0.00011147418990731239, 0.293718546628952, -0.0855327770113945, 0.08431798964738846, 0.4154002070426941, -0.1452314555644989, 0.49647781252861023, -0.2726651430130005, 0.006359803024679422, -0.504539966583252, -0.37015923857688904, 0.03820597007870674, 0.16427820920944214, -0.0967218205332756, 0.1679690182209015, -0.34497466683387756, 0.34570491313934326, -0.05481221526861191, -0.07119746506214142, 0.13045625388622284, 0.09541056305170059, -0.4780879318714142, 0.7038035988807678, -0.1920982301235199, -0.04728363826870918, -0.5045639872550964, 0.4533924460411072, 0.38620269298553467, 0.21847930550575256, -1.273535132408142, 0.13467837870121002, 0.77683424949646, -0.18468321859836578, -0.44579097628593445, 0.16747507452964783, 0.5018145442008972, -0.30350813269615173, 0.19522437453269958, -0.5505713224411011, -0.14021116495132446, 0.18813882768154144, -0.5133119821548462, -0.09869384765625, 0.842743992805481, -0.23301395773887634, 0.36923784017562866, 0.6815396547317505, 0.3621787130832672, 0.3769572377204895, -0.2368270456790924, -0.8170543909072876, 0.19250443577766418, 0.38181769847869873, -0.11661779135465622, 0.6877663731575012, -0.10834435373544693, 0.5154565572738647, 0.010188281536102295, 0.5482497811317444, 0.0727834701538086, 0.7090795040130615, 0.9708384275436401, 0.2879796624183655, 0.3333740532398224, 0.5722165703773499, -0.008693023584783077, 0.1935155987739563, -0.23533423244953156, -0.24672763049602509, -0.4019792377948761, 1.0048593282699585, -0.41855910420417786, 0.588247537612915, 0.4690697491168976, 0.9843751788139343, -0.027022922411561012, -0.6169351935386658, 0.6765499114990234, 0.39199450612068176, -0.2567636966705322, 0.07555671036243439, 0.03713011369109154, -0.28147271275520325, -0.48265719413757324, -0.014617200009524822, 0.6377438902854919, 1.322832703590393, 0.30171090364456177, 0.3015124797821045, 0.10809050500392914, -0.43833351135253906, -0.9590551257133484, -0.7681028246879578, -1.2763210535049438, -0.6929993033409119, -0.9861363172531128, -0.2634395956993103, 0.6046289205551147, -0.12463043630123138, 0.24711869657039642, 0.32541996240615845, 0.2469293624162674, -0.04839203879237175, 0.20619195699691772, -0.0010382379405200481, 0.22227491438388824, -0.051169559359550476, -0.8844640254974365, 0.3337289094924927, -0.20163828134536743, 0.563454270362854, -0.7879688739776611, 0.08894790709018707, -0.1404610425233841, -0.7169739007949829, 0.34173980355262756, -0.9092744588851929, -0.1468280404806137, 0.10788601636886597, 0.20003290474414825, -0.13940294086933136, 0.18573270738124847, 0.283748060464859, 0.6999249458312988, -0.4064267575740814, -0.27737927436828613, 0.5561012029647827, 0.26682430505752563, 0.2036757618188858, 0.14738713204860687, 0.8051335215568542, -0.20070898532867432, 0.5171889662742615, -0.2865236699581146, -0.41384389996528625, -0.6907414197921753, 0.46414095163345337, 0.33987492322921753, -0.08553624898195267, 0.1701669692993164, -0.9314459562301636, -1.052596926689148, 0.3145742416381836, -0.48878949880599976, -0.40227988362312317, -0.04801095277070999, 0.9574944972991943, 0.49030572175979614, -1.1756089925765991, 0.33395716547966003, -0.23609425127506256, -1.2432923316955566, 0.17537356913089752, 0.12873126566410065, 0.444886177778244, 0.7220008373260498, 0.24020983278751373, -0.4428029954433441, -0.09050522744655609, 0.07101161777973175, 0.07459262013435364, -0.2502172291278839, -0.1258559376001358, -0.38032376766204834, 0.0890096053481102, 0.5871373414993286, -0.04561447352170944, -0.24548138678073883, -0.40875953435897827, -0.23385906219482422, -0.012965800240635872, -0.16002771258354187, 0.5960638523101807, 0.73342365026474, 0.30118611454963684, -0.16093629598617554, 0.461485892534256, 0.02500452660024166, -0.4595572054386139, 0.7212889790534973, 0.4420066177845001, 0.18888302147388458, 1.0238531827926636, -0.5208894610404968, -0.1138526126742363, -0.6243209838867188, -0.8187952637672424, -0.14866933226585388, -0.12732049822807312, 0.4924473166465759, -0.5089965462684631, 0.6380617022514343, 0.3522726595401764, -0.31538382172584534, 0.5315905809402466, -0.07617117464542389, -0.19871483743190765, 0.4979386627674103, 0.0762319266796112, 1.354183316230774, -0.8805481791496277, 0.2422850877046585, 0.8330681324005127, 0.45506808161735535, -0.17383147776126862, 0.4739881157875061, 0.3722519874572754, -0.8316023945808411, 0.14804299175739288, -0.14413295686244965, -0.25457334518432617, -0.3241138160228729, -0.030856242403388023, 0.042325638234615326, 0.352695107460022, -0.9708484411239624, -0.05213606357574463, -0.2806694805622101, 0.32881057262420654, -0.580470085144043, 0.3739703595638275, 1.105085015296936, 0.03607262670993805, -0.06282117962837219, -0.2199503779411316, 0.5673441290855408, 0.1472545713186264, -0.3456341028213501, -0.3948090672492981, -0.21250782907009125, -0.7288614511489868, -0.6934435963630676, -0.5059773921966553, 0.0438498817384243, 0.24587441980838776, 0.7366132736206055, -0.8976423740386963, -0.36357077956199646, -0.3354590833187103, 0.17997337877750397, 0.01205534115433693, 0.16877445578575134, 0.11316246539354324, -0.6187405586242676, 0.4134221374988556, -0.026820339262485504, -1.1967285871505737, -0.19963236153125763, -0.004557235166430473, -0.32908642292022705, 0.8449499607086182, -0.3856416642665863, -0.21008609235286713, -0.1639702022075653, -1.0034171342849731, -0.1864352524280548, 0.570794403553009, -0.053274791687726974, 0.4184221923351288, 0.9033883213996887, 0.16259729862213135, 0.01342714298516512, 0.05441088229417801, -0.12912105023860931, -0.277072548866272, 0.2685621678829193, 0.23346422612667084, 1.6515436172485352, 0.753304123878479, -0.04561949148774147, -0.8627346754074097, 0.493010938167572, -0.785179615020752, 0.5648463368415833, -0.4247063398361206, -0.26674461364746094, -0.18261821568012238, -0.30243632197380066, -0.1852426379919052, 0.13508331775665283, -0.07114608585834503, -0.15593211352825165, -0.6335148215293884, 0.5424723625183105, -1.140688419342041, -0.7407071590423584, 0.9159103631973267, -0.6814872026443481, 0.42381322383880615, 1.1094781160354614, -0.3819690942764282, -0.43830612301826477, 0.25843098759651184, 0.5458903312683105, -0.6815865635871887, 0.3008759617805481, 0.4657689034938812, 0.4080430269241333, 0.3669687807559967, -0.6899175047874451, -0.17514455318450928, -0.22430163621902466, 0.9235357642173767, -0.8703392744064331, -0.8966014385223389, -0.6030392646789551, -0.41345179080963135, -1.2922817468643188, 0.2567010223865509, -0.43711423873901367, -0.07500193268060684, -0.2340196967124939, -0.1938408613204956, 0.23990970849990845, -0.016583774238824844, -0.5622634291648865, -0.5080527663230896, -0.6050668358802795, -0.3053552210330963, 0.24342119693756104, 0.5216201543807983, 0.8469124436378479, -0.2306351661682129, -0.7679656147956848, 0.7875041961669922, -0.15061761438846588, -0.8395098447799683, -0.4650527238845825, -0.0065539232455194, 0.19300423562526703, -0.3142589032649994, -0.03350265324115753, -0.19802388548851013, -0.7713530659675598, -0.5700017809867859, -0.44838812947273254, 0.38201457262039185, 0.3099416494369507, 0.11002940684556961, -0.11097575724124908, 0.26289886236190796, 0.7103047966957092, -1.2642124891281128, -0.06377127766609192, -0.000003919907612726092, 0.02047750912606716, 0.20446929335594177, 0.08643923699855804, -0.6803609728813171, -0.23832155764102936, -0.4143085777759552, 0.15082108974456787, -0.8379851579666138, 0.2111484706401825, -0.4607025980949402, 0.10976378619670868, 0.18252739310264587, 0.8003446459770203, 0.24969063699245453, 0.004286519717425108, -0.2587551474571228, -0.8306072354316711, 0.626373291015625, -0.10646413266658783, -0.4585742950439453, -0.5300960540771484, -0.7571678757667542, 0.18602439761161804, 0.8038102388381958, -0.27025923132896423, -0.7919268012046814, 0.2228333055973053, 0.7189354300498962, 0.41043949127197266, 0.37806397676467896, -0.5582360029220581, -0.28319013118743896, -0.15304923057556152, -0.03634337708353996, 0.04835409298539162, -0.1973952203989029, -1.3030914068222046, 0.38988617062568665, -0.7496448159217834, -0.23204591870307922, -0.45206964015960693, -0.7656668424606323, -0.1413024365901947, -0.6094609498977661, 0.5931979417800903, -0.40909749269485474, 0.5689882636070251, -0.3164059519767761, -0.5373762845993042, -0.20128868520259857, 0.6760792136192322, -0.05092299357056618, -0.5901737213134766, -0.4181618094444275, -0.13103662431240082, 0.844111442565918, -0.39025217294692993, -0.1873929649591446, 1.2448022365570068, -0.851215660572052, -0.0415482260286808, -0.7320441603660583, 0.23516049981117249, 0.8920875787734985, -0.27551788091659546, -0.4303808808326721, -0.2720319628715515, 0.10869653522968292, -0.26916709542274475, -0.4742433428764343, 0.27321916818618774, 0.32709604501724243, -0.5958337783813477, -0.04561430588364601, -0.2709975242614746, -0.8422824740409851, 0.3491687774658203, -0.1127377450466156, 0.3748752772808075, 0.38878655433654785, 0.3538557291030884, 0.025228681042790413, -0.6296916604042053, 0.4445931911468506, 0.4561512768268585, 0.08354808390140533, -0.4308769702911377, 0.9973151087760925, 0.45148271322250366, 0.34777092933654785, 0.9699930548667908, -0.7861790657043457, 0.18077591061592102, -0.2446696162223816, 0.3155822157859802, 0.38552507758140564, -0.8286365866661072, 0.3594890236854553, 0.6592166423797607, -0.7100369930267334, -0.7305783629417419, 0.26418593525886536, -0.10757602006196976, 0.0631391853094101, -0.1138613224029541, -0.47536587715148926, 0.5687817335128784, -0.523113489151001, 0.28102806210517883, -0.2951468527317047, 0.6370447874069214, 0.18377399444580078, -0.6694945693016052, 0.23189838230609894, -0.4560948610305786, 0.4157975912094116, 1.538496494293213, -0.16596773266792297, 0.2799217700958252, 0.3521287739276886, 0.295846164226532, -0.24310190975666046, -0.01948762871325016, -0.42595213651657104, 0.3031046986579895, -0.08328600227832794, -0.13433122634887695, 0.1857118159532547, -0.1315048635005951, 0.49078482389450073, -0.3658168613910675, 0.9802107810974121, 0.2249317467212677, -0.6779534816741943, -0.0768788605928421, 0.38978496193885803, 0.5617530941963196, 0.34295204281806946, 1.078497052192688, 0.48280325531959534, 0.7446637153625488, -0.47568759322166443, 0.5616369843482971, -0.7688586711883545, -0.21783801913261414, -0.6478757858276367, -0.6137853264808655, -0.25413835048675537, -0.6462969183921814, 0.5494644641876221, 0.17605769634246826, -0.6298090815544128, -0.09553682059049606, -0.7986566424369812, 1.0182602405548096, -0.5127274990081787, -0.1678430587053299, -0.38652750849723816, 0.14369843900203705, -0.40121492743492126, -0.8454467058181763, -0.7559378147125244, -1.2210534811019897, 0.504719614982605, 0.8124703168869019, -0.6644125580787659, -0.13373027741909027, -0.2023135870695114, -0.07484149932861328, -0.4453025162220001, 0.5447194576263428, -0.758185088634491, -0.21859236061573029, -0.744850218296051, 0.8780244588851929, 0.4213440716266632, -0.407837450504303, 1.596737265586853, -0.5910813212394714, 0.747664213180542, 0.9488258361816406, 0.3974286615848541, -0.30741244554519653, -0.06945390999317169, 0.7875421047210693, -1.1735663414001465, -0.07430610060691833, -0.17914073169231415, 0.8379737734794617, -1.2371575832366943, -0.34915590286254883, -0.7453216910362244, -0.2814035415649414, 0.15066558122634888, 0.12236384302377701, -0.3431018888950348, 0.7223387956619263, 0.8397071957588196, 0.35249316692352295, 0.113431915640831, 0.7645005583763123, 0.9178497791290283, -0.021459227427840233, 0.26900601387023926, -0.08089619874954224, 0.10363886505365372, -0.00440322095528245, 0.018401002511382103, 0.9495354890823364, -0.17399273812770844, 0.4845893979072571, -0.08548498153686523, 0.9878534078598022, -0.08786854147911072, -0.40733709931373596, -0.1642368882894516, -0.01704011671245098, 0.15412411093711853, 0.3886052668094635, 0.4303567707538605, -0.10082698613405228, -0.7334234714508057, -0.49130693078041077, -0.6134256720542908, -1.1405110359191895, 0.35725149512290955, -0.9371871948242188, 0.690238893032074, -0.88237464427948, -0.22523102164268494, 0.40309587121009827, 0.1377590149641037, 0.5460447072982788, 0.2434420883655548, 0.3377542793750763, 0.09360270202159882, 0.8064036965370178, 0.1559188812971115, 0.8021025657653809, -0.18863026797771454, -0.18649950623512268, -0.9998692274093628, -0.47253352403640747, -0.3212202489376068, 0.6929230690002441, 0.02449667640030384, -0.4435442090034485, -0.6264796257019043, 0.045221611857414246, 0.1812644600868225, -0.4408375024795532, -0.6056035161018372, 0.1140645295381546, -0.5854858756065369, -0.08431841433048248, -0.43757474422454834, 0.0478786900639534, 0.32342666387557983, 0.8375321626663208, -0.052759163081645966, -0.5746999979019165, -0.7895673513412476, -0.31936410069465637, 0.6689099669456482, -0.4369630217552185, 1.0300679206848145, 0.11632583290338516, 0.5991873145103455, -0.518872857093811, -0.31040191650390625, 0.5616553425788879, -0.0622839517891407, 0.10264228284358978, 0.15598951280117035, -0.23518210649490356, 0.25941598415374756, 0.9269254207611084, 0.13351905345916748, -0.49177104234695435, 0.7096884250640869, 0.2618602216243744, -0.19519072771072388, 0.4520963430404663, -0.41852059960365295, 0.029603520408272743, 0.41518300771713257, -0.5572926998138428, 0.02871730364859104, -0.029380641877651215, 0.013130824081599712, 0.055981747806072235, -0.17922015488147736, 0.06721474975347519, -0.6238409876823425, -0.47147586941719055, -0.3369041085243225, 0.6164800524711609, 0.9224942922592163, 0.04525528475642204, -0.14442038536071777, 0.07613666355609894, 0.6356264352798462, -0.4692552089691162, 0.42922747135162354, 0.923790693283081, -0.6017922163009644, -0.4531354010105133, -0.2522667646408081, 0.45239269733428955, -0.2879347503185272, -0.19420136511325836, 0.08937287330627441, -0.2757112383842468, -0.052805397659540176, 0.6879100203514099, -0.2985053062438965, -0.32632023096084595, 0.5972895622253418, -0.44646626710891724, 0.020826615393161774, -0.23942303657531738, 0.3914170563220978, -0.4491766691207886, -0.4203362464904785, 1.1113603115081787, -1.01980459690094, 0.09355723857879639, 0.5656106472015381, 0.5363253355026245, 0.615416944026947, 0.4435831308364868, 0.33486858010292053, -0.5110192894935608, 0.5656118392944336, 0.21505442261695862, 0.16682280600070953, -0.10389615595340729, -0.424312025308609, -0.2714229226112366, -0.0466555580496788, -0.2514669597148895, 0.21364551782608032, 0.06444893032312393, -1.0247515439987183, -0.04957788437604904, 0.1661776304244995, -0.3010270595550537, -0.30447572469711304, -0.5412825345993042, -0.9096536636352539, 0.35998979210853577, -0.450535386800766, -0.02320072613656521, 0.6418476700782776, 0.67892986536026, 0.5018446445465088, 0.05920794606208801, -0.21588604152202606, -0.21945756673812866, -0.3378724157810211, -0.6538338661193848, 0.3950923979282379, -0.019529568031430244, 0.20843534171581268, -0.6328736543655396, -1.2527432441711426, -0.17469872534275055, -0.5373525619506836, 0.3951690196990967, -0.46514254808425903, 0.13768447935581207, 0.555813193321228, 0.9672120213508606, 0.21752019226551056, 0.06598036736249924, 0.4150208532810211, -0.11628399789333344, 0.5136253833770752, -0.8007044792175293, 0.31451764702796936, -0.5573921799659729, 0.3949478268623352, -0.17822100222110748, -0.2645471394062042, 0.2219608724117279, -0.1043885201215744, 0.1388508826494217, -0.5750806331634521, 0.5400882959365845, -0.28548306226730347, -0.7044872045516968, 0.4739849865436554, 1.3520982265472412, 0.10617008060216904, -0.1913173645734787, -1.41657555103302, 0.10537365078926086, -0.4979943037033081, 0.020427310839295387, -0.5813316106796265, 0.0852515697479248, -0.069940485060215, 0.42638957500457764, -0.2286163717508316, -0.5204756855964661, 4.065517902374268, 1.2940833568572998, 0.6949908137321472, -0.12098746746778488, 0.7838742136955261, 0.17886726558208466, 0.39972278475761414, -0.43759527802467346, 0.3976493775844574, -0.31712770462036133, 0.09229037165641785, -0.468718558549881, 1.1217190027236938, 0.06918710470199585, 0.3241983652114868, -0.04226149246096611, -1.188378095626831, 0.2704554498195648, 0.28457510471343994, -0.9024341702461243, -1.0087796449661255, -0.0647730752825737, 0.26591378450393677, -0.59116131067276, 0.6429913640022278, 0.30445337295532227, 0.0454755537211895, 0.7370832562446594, -0.3183176517486572, -0.6473153233528137, -0.6802969574928284, -0.07529285550117493, 0.8161740303039551, -0.5728973746299744, -0.5698367953300476, 0.4929221272468567, -0.1947464644908905, -0.4334959089756012, 0.2844832241535187, 0.7409340739250183, 0.0767761617898941, -0.8147600889205933, -0.25992369651794434, 0.06513819843530655, -0.3077867329120636, 0.18245626986026764, -0.1635255515575409, 0.0834718644618988, 0.36937740445137024, -0.10505624115467072, 0.5665695667266846, -0.8043118715286255, 0.9502888917922974, -0.3955024182796478, -0.38058391213417053, -0.019998421892523766, -0.7353332042694092, -1.4584699869155884, -0.35974016785621643, 0.14353995025157928, 0.6141369342803955, 0.3636123239994049, -0.38798612356185913, -0.03752574324607849, -0.07115697860717773, 0.9860517978668213, 0.09457322955131531, -0.08278878033161163, 0.1937016248703003, -0.9077712893486023, -0.09304263442754745, -0.5377188920974731, -0.05278990417718887, -0.1142403855919838, 0.7814386487007141, 0.3384794294834137, -0.38227784633636475, 0.6502028107643127, -0.167960524559021, -0.4334402084350586, 0.409991592168808, 0.3576693534851074, -0.1711425632238388, -0.5298129916191101, 0.5156341195106506, 0.14837469160556793, -0.6413983702659607, -0.11362258344888687, -1.107157588005066, 0.5558691620826721, 0.2328762710094452, 0.15528634190559387, 0.25488972663879395, 0.4512271583080292, -0.935063898563385 ]
{"Title": "Evaluating the utility of tumour mutational signatures for identifying hereditary colorectal cancer and polyposis syndrome carriers", "Authors": "Georgeson Peter, Pope Bernard J., Rosty Christophe, Clendenning Mark, Mahmood Khalid, Joo Jihoon E., Walker Romy, Hutchinson Ryan, Preston Susan, Como Julia, Joseland Sharelle, Win Aung K., Macrae Finlay A., Hopper John L., Mouradov Dmitry, Gibbs Peter, Sieber Oliver M., O\u2019Sullivan Dylan E., Brenner Darren R., Gallinger Steve, Jenkins Mark A., Winship Ingrid M., Buchanan Daniel D.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objective Germline pathogenic variants (PVs) in the DNA mismatch repair (MMR) genes and in the base excision repair gene MUTYH underlie hereditary colorectal cancer (CRC) and polyposis syndromes. We evaluated the robustness and discriminatory potential of tumour mutational signatures in CRCs for identifying germline PV carriers. Design Whole exome sequencing of formalin-fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) CRC tissue was performed on 33 MMR germline PV carriers, 12 biallelic MUTYH germline PV carriers, 25 sporadic MLH1 methylated MMR-deficient CRCs (MMRd controls) and 160 sporadic MMR-proficient CRCs (MMRp controls) and included 498 TCGA CRC tumours. COSMIC V3 single base substitution (SBS) and indel (ID) mutational signatures were assessed for their ability to differentiate CRCs that developed in carriers from non-carriers. Results The combination of mutational signatures SBS18 and SBS36 contributing >30% of a CRC\u2019s signature profile was able to discriminate biallelic MUTYH carriers from all other non-carrier control CRCs with 100% accuracy (area under the curve (AUC) 1.0). SBS18 and SBS36 were associated with specific MUTYH variants p.Gly396Asp (p=0.025) and p.Tyr179Cys (p=5\u00d710 \u22125 ), respectively. The combination of ID2 and ID7 could discriminate the 33 MMR PV carrier CRCs from the MMRp control CRCs (AUC 0.99), however, SBS and ID signatures, alone or in combination, could not provide complete discrimination (AUC 0.79) between CRCs from MMR PV carriers and sporadic MMRd controls. Conclusion Assessment of SBS and ID signatures can discriminate CRCs from biallelic MUTYH carriers and MMR PV carriers from non-carriers with high accuracy, demonstrating utility as a potential diagnostic and variant classification tool. SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY What is already known about this subject? Identifying carriers of pathogenic variants (PVs) in moderate/high-risk colorectal cancer (CRC) and polyposis susceptibility genes has clinical relevance for diagnosis, targeted screening and prevention strategies, prognosis, and treatment options. However, challenges still remain in the identification of carriers and the classification of rare variants in these genes. Previous studies have identified tumour mutational signatures that result from defective DNA repair including DNA mismatch repair (MMR) deficiency and base excision repair defects, DNA repair mechanisms that underlie the common hereditary CRC and polyposis syndromes but their diagnostic utility in CRC is unknown. What are the new findings? Single base substitution (SBS)-related mutational signatures derived from whole exome sequencing of formalin-fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE)-derived CRC tissue DNA can effectively discriminate CRCs that developed in biallelic MUTYH PV carriers from CRC-affected non-carriers. CRCs that develop in MMR PV carriers (Lynch syndrome) can be effectively differentiated from sporadic MMR-proficient CRC by a combination of indel (ID) signatures, but the SBS and ID tumour mutational signatures are less effective at discriminating Lynch syndrome-related CRC from sporadic MMR-deficient CRC resulting from MLH1 gene promoter hypermethylation. The SBS and ID mutational signatures associated with biallelic MUTYH PV carriers and MMR PV carriers are robust to changes in experimental settings. We demonstrate the optimal experimental settings for calculating mutational signatures and define thresholds that optimise sensitivity and specificity for classifying CRC aetiology as hereditary or non-hereditary. How might it impact on clinical practice in the foreseeable future? Deriving SBS- and ID-related mutational signatures from CRCs can identify carriers of PVs in hereditary CRC and polyposis susceptibility genes. The application of mutational signatures has the potential to improve the diagnosis of hereditary CRC and aid in variant classification, leading to improved clinical management and CRC prevention.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.11.19014597"}
10.1101/19002022
[ -0.026662062853574753, -0.1585143804550171, -0.3387763798236847, 0.5829514265060425, -0.16588610410690308, -0.6511645913124084, 0.3815394639968872, 0.4186994433403015, -0.0039488812908530235, 0.21542705595493317, -0.40601295232772827, -0.9819263815879822, 0.37051352858543396, -0.4586973786354065, 0.051380060613155365, -0.1312546581029892, -0.5818430185317993, 0.20970182120800018, 0.09534011781215668, 0.3665303885936737, 0.35741493105888367, 0.2638589143753052, -0.24477113783359528, 0.027854543179273605, -0.042731981724500656, 0.7755250930786133, 0.32832273840904236, 0.313384085893631, 0.9432069063186646, 0.2838236093521118, -0.2851020395755768, -0.3363207280635834, 0.010198480449616909, -0.9849852919578552, -0.594903290271759, -0.06578993797302246, 0.6116000413894653, -0.40593841671943665, -0.1838470697402954, 0.3484266400337219, -0.07640630751848221, 0.133928120136261, 0.9015920758247375, -0.46762770414352417, -0.5601804256439209, -0.048561979085206985, -0.586065948009491, 0.09193076938390732, 0.3122877776622772, 0.04326904937624931, -0.28783926367759705, 0.2754649817943573, 0.0359928235411644, -0.025222595781087875, 0.11811513453722, -0.12505805492401123, 0.2858303487300873, 0.7851994037628174, -0.8397952318191528, -0.08161081373691559, 0.20795737206935883, -0.0891706794500351, 0.42226195335388184, -1.0483664274215698, 0.8072842955589294, 0.8279879093170166, -0.34138450026512146, -0.6226534843444824, -0.8430452346801758, -0.07921439409255981, -0.20451030135154724, -0.34181973338127136, -0.4004491865634918, -0.6024082899093628, 0.10989753901958466, -0.1465034931898117, 0.4767339527606964, -0.23929469287395477, -0.03872007131576538, -0.04709181934595108, 0.5545449256896973, 0.13859926164150238, 0.33593830466270447, 0.2731422483921051, -0.5026300549507141, 0.10791163891553879, 0.7200325727462769, 0.7265051007270813, 0.4914688467979431, -0.23705708980560303, 0.235944464802742, 0.23426586389541626, 0.1513405740261078, 0.6129483580589294, -0.008488872088491917, 1.1128289699554443, -0.3776828944683075, -0.048156507313251495, -0.27860990166664124, -0.23638421297073364, 0.8533978462219238, 0.7831884026527405, 0.14816951751708984, 0.9674221277236938, -0.15952534973621368, 0.44334927201271057, 0.7988457679748535, -0.3489525318145752, -0.1970997005701065, -1.0694442987442017, 0.13210640847682953, 0.4687911868095398, -0.6116828322410583, 0.13442644476890564, 0.30524107813835144, 0.42854878306388855, -0.7319785356521606, 0.7981922030448914, -0.7461162209510803, 0.04130952060222626, -0.5855375528335571, 0.16387051343917847, 0.37253648042678833, -0.24537482857704163, 0.34673669934272766, -0.4951719641685486, 0.22048643231391907, 0.34161362051963806, -0.7549574375152588, -0.06881054490804672, -0.5033699870109558, -0.5210047960281372, 0.26596492528915405, 0.5371446013450623, 0.01737506315112114, -0.38037803769111633, 0.7718185782432556, 1.1669129133224487, 0.029232434928417206, -0.6256752610206604, -0.5499839186668396, 0.2039719671010971, -0.5525997877120972, 0.8305778503417969, -0.6571391820907593, 0.9710661172866821, -0.1799534410238266, -1.8042188882827759, -0.24525119364261627, 0.43957415223121643, 0.39621055126190186, -0.030381329357624054, 0.29042544960975647, -0.3742452561855316, 0.11834069341421127, -0.318867951631546, -0.35571157932281494, 0.8781232237815857, 0.4509149193763733, 0.26979681849479675, -0.3948286473751068, 0.4428755044937134, -0.5890347957611084, 0.7128580212593079, -0.2001761496067047, 0.2198742926120758, 0.22714164853096008, 0.4154593050479889, 0.8122602701187134, -0.4235452115535736, 0.7512751221656799, 0.46171674132347107, -0.13750681281089783, 0.15513646602630615, 0.2694530189037323, 0.7921963334083557, 0.9534632563591003, 0.11489325016736984, 0.8949866890907288, -0.07811814546585083, -0.10702132433652878, -0.17269738018512726, 0.7091447114944458, 1.4957311153411865, -0.6888864040374756, -0.17064034938812256, -0.10392577946186066, -0.5622544884681702, -0.28592801094055176, -0.2223454713821411, -0.1058230847120285, 0.20532433688640594, -0.7662528157234192, 0.8211873173713684, 0.32578667998313904, 0.3543648421764374, -0.14899803698062897, 0.10841421782970428, 0.34149783849716187, -0.5599889159202576, -0.44121474027633667, 0.8512624502182007, -0.4942931532859802, 0.3024097681045532, 0.2328556776046753, 0.8273060321807861, 0.30176839232444763, 0.01542026735842228, -0.052068691700696945, -0.2078651785850525, 1.0372464656829834, 0.07913710176944733, -0.2664380371570587, -0.23749834299087524, 0.7297337651252747, -0.6300413608551025, -0.6552252173423767, 0.1482274979352951, -0.6583245992660522, -0.48553693294525146, -0.680289626121521, -0.5338953137397766, 0.20511363446712494, 0.31436577439308167, -0.25811585783958435, 0.4603576064109802, 0.5433391332626343, 0.9282934665679932, 0.056817833334207535, -0.3337264358997345, 0.43842780590057373, 0.8039745688438416, 0.6975046992301941, 0.5410944223403931, 1.1366046667099, 0.37033653259277344, 0.4846692979335785, 0.6108487844467163, 0.4574795365333557, 0.04936905950307846, 0.578417181968689, 0.6848825812339783, 1.193123698234558, 0.09798246622085571, -0.6919839382171631, -0.13933947682380676, -0.5694426894187927, -0.06289250403642654, 0.0406574085354805, 0.5226924419403076, -1.1140919923782349, 0.8515192866325378, 0.03947445750236511, 0.17661596834659576, -1.394596815109253, -0.6240262389183044, 0.5518149137496948, 0.32054755091667175, 0.003380961949005723, -0.6112193465232849, -0.7403240203857422, 0.6702054738998413, 0.1621706187725067, -0.05182110518217087, 0.8467822670936584, 0.798128604888916, -0.0824039950966835, 0.8274151086807251, 0.36754918098449707, -0.46306419372558594, -0.6592085957527161, -0.9062526226043701, -1.5322092771530151, -0.9233033657073975, -0.9604491591453552, 0.6441813707351685, -0.10336580127477646, -0.31666234135627747, 0.4085136651992798, 0.26730209589004517, 0.7704735398292542, -0.22059451043605804, 0.15692614018917084, 0.24194416403770447, 0.41859719157218933, -0.22726388275623322, -1.1224397420883179, -0.12323763221502304, -0.5737000703811646, 0.6807766556739807, 0.24564333260059357, -0.15130707621574402, 0.07217665761709213, -0.9029819369316101, 0.5212165117263794, -0.8463442921638489, -0.7611101269721985, -0.10301636159420013, -0.6168500781059265, 0.2643888294696808, 0.2087538093328476, -0.19479109346866608, -0.6766003966331482, -0.3770199716091156, -1.2119532823562622, 0.5487933158874512, 0.4648267328739166, 0.2974717915058136, 0.3124113380908966, 0.15378771722316742, -0.4296586215496063, 0.5630015134811401, 0.14602039754390717, -0.27780404686927795, -1.031781792640686, -0.10610394924879074, 0.5111493468284607, -0.5489435791969299, 0.45979923009872437, -0.24265937507152557, -0.9892941117286682, -0.9533615112304688, -0.21941252052783966, -0.2547362744808197, -0.3250056207180023, 0.4716377258300781, 0.37711548805236816, -1.0359693765640259, -0.30515387654304504, -0.1978103667497635, -0.9733677506446838, 0.207330584526062, -0.5764655470848083, 0.6214569807052612, -0.3773197531700134, 0.2367585450410843, -0.16419756412506104, -0.08632969856262207, 0.37051329016685486, 0.30309823155403137, 0.4333413243293762, -0.08384278416633606, -0.8168042898178101, 0.24600549042224884, -0.24208635091781616, 0.42847010493278503, -0.050459131598472595, -0.5734328627586365, -0.006007641088217497, -0.3179994523525238, -0.4500344395637512, 0.3704186677932739, 0.6068490743637085, -0.4634282886981964, 0.3875925540924072, 0.3024486005306244, -0.18581852316856384, -0.09679455310106277, 0.27235493063926697, -0.45464855432510376, -0.34823787212371826, 0.41857683658599854, 0.24346433579921722, 0.5691756010055542, -0.719129741191864, -0.9866040349006653, 0.9140959978103638, -0.3427858352661133, 0.7702186107635498, -0.7902044057846069, 1.144331693649292, 0.30013102293014526, -0.15138296782970428, -0.5330806970596313, 0.1839720755815506, 0.06884928792715073, 1.189882755279541, -0.05674850195646286, 1.0804194211959839, -1.5838344097137451, 0.2537327706813812, 0.7951063513755798, 1.6528328657150269, -0.07787619531154633, -0.2706991732120514, 0.7320544123649597, -0.8861762881278992, 0.41726550459861755, -0.1502612680196762, 0.1196516752243042, 0.371122270822525, 0.32921528816223145, -0.2248215526342392, -0.2997537851333618, -0.6412922739982605, -0.5015833377838135, -0.1594986468553543, -0.32335516810417175, 0.31906658411026, -0.3206470310688019, 1.413638949394226, -0.3822745382785797, 0.20513324439525604, 0.2171013355255127, 0.8866721987724304, -0.19008347392082214, -0.2863308787345886, 0.5019434690475464, -0.12330145388841629, -0.8342102766036987, 0.04415277764201164, 0.2814966142177582, -0.029561851173639297, 0.08360353857278824, 0.5825491547584534, -0.6429452896118164, -0.3469865322113037, -0.43441158533096313, -0.3119671642780304, 0.31758055090904236, -0.3783166706562042, -0.0918428897857666, -0.864429771900177, 0.559617280960083, -0.5060582160949707, -0.3004750907421112, 0.6904163956642151, -0.6399089097976685, 0.17679734528064728, 0.9481526613235474, -0.12802959978580475, -1.361720085144043, -0.3210451006889343, 0.013429403305053711, -0.33682531118392944, -0.1914391964673996, -0.46374648809432983, -0.542586624622345, 0.48307621479034424, 0.06656267493963242, 0.040259119123220444, -0.738823413848877, -0.3069228231906891, 0.06858479231595993, 0.06944546103477478, 0.29373201727867126, 0.7654377818107605, 0.7001871466636658, 1.2172662019729614, -0.04631926491856575, 0.7267998456954956, -0.432123064994812, 0.5146526098251343, -0.07241246104240417, -0.6740577816963196, -0.390207439661026, -0.10646092146635056, 0.38036590814590454, -0.3655959367752075, -0.13875097036361694, -0.5042763948440552, 0.10668164491653442, 0.8095654845237732, 0.3685082793235779, -0.494195818901062, 0.8395504355430603, -0.28343337774276733, 0.3180258274078369, 1.282231092453003, 0.11007717251777649, -0.17495609819889069, -0.6050041317939758, -0.11335556954145432, -0.39590778946876526, 0.3693011701107025, -0.12543588876724243, 0.6515182852745056, -0.4216986298561096, -0.5637220144271851, 0.05103594437241554, 0.6225634217262268, 0.4884541928768158, -1.1290351152420044, -0.7323463559150696, -1.0874313116073608, -0.40748584270477295, -0.292692095041275, -0.5906834006309509, -0.772149384021759, 0.46350234746932983, -0.315675288438797, -0.8228412866592407, -0.6781806349754333, -0.016097169369459152, -0.6659511923789978, -0.17386244237422943, -0.41050490736961365, 0.3279990255832672, -0.38369280099868774, -0.08769942820072174, 1.0386521816253662, -0.3331504166126251, -0.33909666538238525, 0.34358206391334534, 0.8651747703552246, -0.39700961112976074, -0.7958712577819824, 0.405925989151001, 0.33242151141166687, -0.49525317549705505, 0.28437504172325134, -0.111750528216362, -0.8896517753601074, -0.10356805473566055, -0.14275933802127838, -0.1212180107831955, 0.13999921083450317, -0.04200832173228264, -0.5069865584373474, 0.20448748767375946, -0.3775462210178375, -0.6162959933280945, -0.6237568259239197, 0.0770346149802208, 0.3287832736968994, 0.14120006561279297, -0.66240394115448, -1.0971479415893555, -0.5790604948997498, -0.7201939821243286, 0.13624927401542664, -1.1548277139663696, 0.35758015513420105, -0.7661609053611755, -0.2057395577430725, 0.05613407492637634, 0.15322183072566986, 0.755743682384491, -0.004080095328390598, -0.059457097202539444, -0.522209644317627, 0.8493219017982483, -0.19357319176197052, 0.03693872317671776, 0.07822252810001373, -0.016218312084674835, 0.1918380856513977, 1.3562628030776978, 0.5787345767021179, -0.43385049700737, 0.10996890068054199, -0.1151333749294281, 0.4656115472316742, 0.8631799817085266, -0.11787842214107513, 0.31803691387176514, 0.10157347470521927, 0.0424591526389122, 0.011148023419082165, 0.08089236915111542, -1.3470773696899414, 0.12860678136348724, -0.6613441705703735, 0.3125166594982147, -0.0788346454501152, -0.31341245770454407, -0.11642005294561386, 0.23344264924526215, 1.5278019905090332, -0.7116401195526123, 0.6569706201553345, 0.31123512983322144, -0.31106463074684143, -0.15078511834144592, 0.706683337688446, -0.17217595875263214, -0.6503245830535889, -1.092961072921753, -0.8116219639778137, -0.16097435355186462, 0.19172310829162598, 0.0576489083468914, 0.8019166588783264, -0.10052606463432312, 0.29992157220840454, -0.9474648833274841, 1.1599701642990112, 0.33800584077835083, -0.271828293800354, -0.7118160724639893, -0.02695613168179989, 0.13251625001430511, 0.024678856134414673, -0.21551784873008728, 0.045562513172626495, -0.8148767352104187, -0.39918220043182373, -0.24425214529037476, -0.6010556221008301, -0.915124237537384, -0.22174018621444702, 0.19376516342163086, 0.705007016658783, -0.058607082813978195, -0.17812839150428772, 0.27328696846961975, 0.16370727121829987, -0.5564441680908203, 0.5414628982543945, -0.13838185369968414, 0.319100946187973, 0.45293954014778137, -0.062213338911533356, -0.5145949125289917, -0.18940113484859467, -0.16308631002902985, 0.7417343258857727, -0.06245506927371025, 0.4288528859615326, 0.7188777923583984, -0.7423408627510071, 0.5371483564376831, 0.19262626767158508, -0.5974767208099365, -0.9957199692726135, 0.023249100893735886, -0.6511488556861877, 0.7385247349739075, -0.4605240523815155, -0.25908929109573364, 0.17914676666259766, 0.01957608573138714, 0.5301144123077393, -0.14928419888019562, -0.32957035303115845, 0.16485266387462616, -0.44481489062309265, -0.5712524056434631, -0.6260606050491333, 0.16375625133514404, 0.8067116141319275, -0.2290528118610382, 0.08595582097768784, -0.12713587284088135, 0.42850154638290405, -0.1315520703792572, 0.280431866645813, 0.21446149051189423, 0.048448726534843445, 0.2404506355524063, 0.1252678483724594, 0.12965278327465057, 0.20619137585163116, 0.25120145082473755, -0.6731400489807129, 0.2564392685890198, -0.4412115514278412, -0.5848093628883362, -0.208327054977417, 0.1655774861574173, 0.4111456573009491, 0.36634770035743713, -0.26764291524887085, 0.257282555103302, 0.21904247999191284, 0.9316721558570862, 0.17739686369895935, -0.7165641784667969, -0.4082282483577728, -0.6575218439102173, -0.41951510310173035, 0.4587815999984741, -1.3111275434494019, -0.4292908012866974, 0.37251192331314087, -0.21017131209373474, -0.9085996150970459, -0.5552548766136169, 0.019925471395254135, -0.16320231556892395, -0.3194468021392822, -0.9131883978843689, 0.6256130933761597, -0.8753040432929993, 0.16379109025001526, 0.2175731658935547, -0.95810866355896, 0.16323018074035645, 0.7846522331237793, -0.3544901907444, -0.19178375601768494, -0.3992442190647125, 0.6687967777252197, -0.3728938698768616, 0.513192892074585, -0.9536223411560059, -0.7562097311019897, -0.3540463447570801, 0.8968911170959473, 0.12593230605125427, -0.3660929799079895, 1.2449510097503662, -0.24236497282981873, 0.3095226287841797, 0.6346880197525024, 0.3350522816181183, -0.9622811675071716, 0.47600966691970825, 0.435723215341568, -0.5182739496231079, -0.08560067415237427, -0.23932963609695435, 0.9446924328804016, -0.9944419264793396, -0.566844642162323, -0.7911671996116638, -0.4944774806499481, 0.09018480777740479, 0.47214213013648987, -0.39604127407073975, 1.1867420673370361, 0.36221548914909363, 0.25473326444625854, 0.6344434022903442, 0.44101443886756897, 0.25865304470062256, -0.10869202762842178, -0.11306699365377426, -0.4537351131439209, 0.3362503945827484, -0.7457342743873596, 0.16588856279850006, -0.08127975463867188, -0.8257560133934021, -0.32243528962135315, -0.11906710267066956, -0.013508239760994911, 0.17310944199562073, 0.08685259521007538, -0.05913391336798668, 0.5619333982467651, 0.03683881089091301, 0.7016802430152893, -0.25320470333099365, -0.6120177507400513, -0.6360401511192322, -0.2740509808063507, -1.2481054067611694, -0.6982805728912354, 0.7267807126045227, -0.01630348339676857, -0.1287345290184021, -0.9694843888282776, -0.49598073959350586, 0.702399492263794, -0.36315467953681946, 0.053502120077610016, 0.007571729831397533, 0.24491600692272186, 0.2660485804080963, 0.1382550597190857, 0.18628932535648346, 0.0833505317568779, -0.20138609409332275, 0.2276177555322647, -0.24574029445648193, -0.6582154035568237, -0.6107668280601501, 0.4220196008682251, 0.591166079044342, -0.029531599953770638, 0.1516726315021515, 0.1952357441186905, -0.2747402787208557, -0.18872755765914917, -0.10817577689886093, 0.3772401809692383, 0.04697664827108383, 0.3999515175819397, -0.336724191904068, 0.472199946641922, -0.34097617864608765, 0.30568042397499084, 0.30472519993782043, -1.1260936260223389, -0.8057960867881775, 0.44039562344551086, 0.4456756114959717, -0.4657863974571228, 0.4539616107940674, -0.6101170778274536, 0.33175450563430786, 0.1574227213859558, 0.2852649688720703, 0.19100680947303772, 0.8853705525398254, 0.09374652802944183, -0.039995163679122925, -0.44113966822624207, 0.7386175394058228, 0.4639727771282196, 0.5759590864181519, -0.9006482362747192, 0.05811244994401932, 0.5241966843605042, 0.12653177976608276, -0.11499054729938507, -0.35567203164100647, 0.5432647466659546, 0.7760400772094727, -0.3913572430610657, 0.4552058279514313, -0.09114939719438553, 0.7470121383666992, 0.18329651653766632, -0.6973685026168823, 0.6883043050765991, 0.12437031418085098, -0.5350801944732666, 0.036085255444049835, 0.793001115322113, 0.6295770406723022, -0.1909932643175125, 0.8358197212219238, 0.690069317817688, 0.3115801215171814, 0.19968092441558838, 0.16580459475517273, 1.3548285961151123, -0.13716131448745728, -0.7255544662475586, -0.38757869601249695, 0.7103144526481628, -0.0015707409474998713, 0.03777250647544861, 0.22651417553424835, 0.007921767421066761, -0.5463907122612, 0.648406445980072, -0.17385761439800262, -0.43333104252815247, 0.7969022989273071, -0.5600551962852478, -0.17551302909851074, -0.1630055159330368, 0.04424280673265457, -0.9736003875732422, -0.4539400041103363, 0.5980302691459656, -0.5685288906097412, -0.049274589866399765, -0.08446960151195526, -0.3246738016605377, 0.6717797517776489, -0.6067988276481628, 0.7049805521965027, -0.9904477596282959, 0.5627742409706116, 0.8033891916275024, 0.37258005142211914, 0.0042371442541480064, -0.2653004825115204, 0.12510982155799866, -0.023439988493919373, 0.05828222632408142, 0.3095483183860779, 0.5082095265388489, -0.7448683381080627, -0.04323161393404007, 0.15142317116260529, -0.6245350241661072, -0.7787731885910034, -0.7321871519088745, 0.24730567634105682, 0.09086684882640839, 0.3710964322090149, -0.2648674547672272, -0.04053045064210892, -0.19276271760463715, 0.43802377581596375, -0.034479547291994095, -0.5387324094772339, -0.15452934801578522, -0.031609393656253815, -0.946188747882843, 0.478273868560791, 0.4458785355091095, -0.6284900903701782, -0.5128843188285828, -1.1572195291519165, -0.4887040853500366, -0.06888715922832489, -0.03770526126027107, -0.44532909989356995, 0.4453025460243225, 0.17763660848140717, 0.8330070376396179, 0.3704717457294464, -0.470964640378952, 0.15709824860095978, 0.5725579261779785, 0.5029913187026978, -0.17859475314617157, 0.97890704870224, -0.12862275540828705, 0.22033654153347015, -0.07258865237236023, -0.1462550163269043, 0.043898820877075195, 0.14955858886241913, -0.4575277268886566, -0.8489574193954468, 0.3805652856826782, -0.1862582564353943, -0.016051480546593666, -0.08121564239263535, 0.9284604787826538, 0.5795274376869202, -0.304351270198822, -0.868423342704773, -0.1549973338842392, -0.45068255066871643, 0.7421146035194397, -0.21100492775440216, -0.41253870725631714, 0.5217185616493225, 0.008804380893707275, 0.5742248296737671, -1.3338024616241455, 3.96833872795105, 1.1613448858261108, 0.08658298850059509, -0.11122431606054306, 0.1133638322353363, 0.6280672550201416, 0.9417253732681274, -0.08477965742349625, 0.770839273929596, -0.03470887616276741, -0.8675954937934875, 0.8735045790672302, 0.42655637860298157, -1.0284258127212524, 0.5422267317771912, 0.48272621631622314, -1.3486294746398926, -0.2969258427619934, 0.41477644443511963, -0.28412142395973206, 0.03292577713727951, 0.04526422917842865, 0.1363794356584549, 0.21168732643127441, 0.2764306366443634, -0.16222138702869415, 0.4441836476325989, 0.027290891855955124, -0.3217545747756958, -0.10289087891578674, -0.14740273356437683, -0.5495582222938538, 0.7671328186988831, -0.8659244775772095, -0.4302031099796295, 0.33551493287086487, -0.5240468978881836, -0.09679420292377472, -0.06163434311747551, -0.10264167934656143, 0.3141755163669586, 0.31773945689201355, -0.04170656576752663, -0.3943275511264801, -0.08276583254337311, 0.04098649322986603, -0.7025486826896667, 0.09496709704399109, 0.03951600193977356, -0.2857646346092224, 0.8909609913825989, -1.354225516319275, 0.6933181881904602, 0.3473126292228699, -0.8574618697166443, -0.22603915631771088, 0.01999525912106037, -1.3536574840545654, 0.024402445182204247, 0.6424973607063293, 0.7072581648826599, 0.038080088794231415, 0.11683815717697144, -0.059573110193014145, 0.3634369671344757, 0.7550966143608093, 0.41532185673713684, -0.07851304858922958, 0.27239295840263367, -0.505389392375946, -0.5119923949241638, 0.05526125058531761, -0.28440219163894653, -0.7514855861663818, 0.9024012088775635, 0.18499405682086945, -0.3083489239215851, 0.6744349598884583, -0.2173348218202591, -0.4618293344974518, -0.3303080201148987, 0.4093341529369354, -0.026282120496034622, -0.425044447183609, 0.12458640336990356, 0.9317635893821716, -0.5820087194442749, -0.27455148100852966, -1.6159906387329102, 0.6705905795097351, 0.6992994546890259, -0.0680747926235199, 0.09215865284204483, -0.06397008150815964, 0.011084333062171936 ]
{"Title": "The Genetic Links to Anxiety and Depression (GLAD) Study: online recruitment into the largest recontactable study of depression and anxiety", "Authors": "Davies Molly R., Kalsi Gursharan, Brailean Anamaria, Cleare Anthony J., Coleman Jonathan R.I., Curtis Charles J., Curzons Susannah C.B., Davis Katrina A.S., Goldsmith Kimberley A., Bennett Megan Hammond, Hotopf Matthew, H\u00fcebel Christopher, Leng Jennifer, Mason Bethany D., McAtarsney-Kovacs Monika, Monssen Dina, Palaiologou Elisavet, Pariante Carmine, Parikh Shivani, Peel Alicia J., Rimes Katharine A., Rogers Henry C., Skelton Megan, Spaul Anna, Suarez Eddy L.A., Sykes Bronte L., White Katie M., Young Allan H., Vassos Evangelos, Veale David, Wingrove Janet, Eley Thalia C., Breen Gerome", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Anxiety and depression are common, debilitating and costly. These disorders are influenced by multiple risk factors, from genes to psychological vulnerabilities and environmental stressors but research is hampered by a lack of sufficiently large comprehensive studies. We are recruiting 40,000 individuals with lifetime depression or anxiety, with broad assessment of risks to facilitate future research. Methods The Genetic Links to Anxiety and Depression (GLAD) Study ( www.gladstudy.org.uk ) recruits individuals with depression or anxiety into the NIHR Mental Health BioResource. Participants invited to join the study (via media campaigns) provide demographic, environmental and genetic data, and consent for medical record linkage and recontact. Results Online recruitment was effective; 41,892 consented and 26,877 participants completed the questionnaire by July 2019. Participants\u2019 questionnaire data identified very high rates recurrent depression, severe anxiety and comorbidity. Participants reported high rates of treatment receipt. The age profile of sample is biased toward young adults, with higher recruitment of females and the better educated, especially at younger ages. Discussion This paper describes the study methodology and descriptive data for GLAD, which represents a large, recontactable resource that will enable future research into risks, outcomes and treatment for anxiety and depression. Highlights Online recruitment of 40,000 individuals with lifetime depression or anxiety (77 characters) Detailed online phenotyping combined with genetic and clinical data (66 characters) The study sample is severe, highly comorbid, with chronic psychopathology (62 characters) The study protocol enables recall of participants for future research and trials (82 characters)", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002022"}
10.1101/19012195
[ -0.21611812710762024, 0.11419175565242767, -0.1325434148311615, 0.1875731199979782, -0.48660552501678467, 0.2004399597644806, 0.13439258933067322, 0.32082751393318176, 0.2959495186805725, 0.3824522793292999, 0.020109102129936218, -0.6551885604858398, 0.09471046924591064, -0.5334615707397461, -0.12025674432516098, 0.22539673745632172, -0.62296462059021, -0.5529124736785889, -0.1606183499097824, 0.2655077576637268, 0.44205787777900696, 0.2956780195236206, -0.5248692035675049, 0.3133069574832916, 0.0825173407793045, 0.49805355072021484, 0.09233171492815018, 0.24623490869998932, 1.107058048248291, 0.44502031803131104, -0.14492622017860413, -0.12445264309644699, 0.35433027148246765, -0.583045482635498, -0.34871023893356323, 0.33518731594085693, 0.41784727573394775, -0.6603557467460632, -0.052102793008089066, -0.4361577332019806, 0.3323495388031006, -0.3571930229663849, 0.18622492253780365, -0.016473226249217987, -0.10233861207962036, 0.2893643379211426, -0.42268040776252747, -0.43028923869132996, 0.22871707379817963, -0.025370748713612556, -0.32669538259506226, -0.32042255997657776, 0.03078530728816986, 0.03909870237112045, 0.2569577991962433, 0.3940664231777191, 0.2059076577425003, 0.5874928832054138, -0.837340235710144, 0.28685426712036133, -0.22457943856716156, 0.10887923091650009, 0.5255774259567261, -1.5023598670959473, 1.1136939525604248, 0.7986111640930176, 0.22359339892864227, -0.09448600560426712, -0.11393393576145172, -0.6564440131187439, -0.3955032229423523, -0.19857144355773926, 0.176333948969841, 0.2990310788154602, -0.7500573992729187, -0.2326592057943344, 0.31353142857551575, 0.18910309672355652, -0.11333269625902176, -0.31816601753234863, 0.18878807127475739, 0.35431599617004395, 0.09363361448049545, -0.01009179838001728, -0.6309337615966797, 0.43440380692481995, 0.28790411353111267, 0.6839134097099304, 0.41741231083869934, 0.11136968433856964, 0.47049862146377563, 0.25335273146629333, 0.040720995515584946, 0.13627085089683533, 0.34420469403266907, 0.46217596530914307, -0.07827068120241165, 0.036161817610263824, -0.20909258723258972, -0.20324818789958954, 0.4953663945198059, 0.41872820258140564, -0.5112927556037903, 0.6908149719238281, -0.7576291561126709, 0.9086892008781433, 0.1325152963399887, -0.2460678517818451, -0.5345965027809143, -0.45743000507354736, 0.5351909399032593, 0.12212635576725006, -0.30536672472953796, -0.4916982054710388, 0.7164753079414368, 0.4959988296031952, -0.48318952322006226, 1.1583482027053833, -0.5614813566207886, 0.33382922410964966, -0.4905799925327301, 0.21621936559677124, 0.8171366453170776, -0.27310261130332947, 0.35566455125808716, -0.22118084132671356, -0.08935774117708206, 0.3642183840274811, -0.5814442038536072, -0.0862741693854332, -0.1383887380361557, -0.5841853022575378, 0.21324867010116577, 0.35231903195381165, -0.6292492747306824, -0.4189939796924591, 0.29755699634552, 1.6016900539398193, -0.21351158618927002, -0.5562795400619507, -0.28603455424308777, 0.8711790442466736, -0.5030402541160583, 0.7742040157318115, -0.3571326434612274, 0.5191101431846619, -0.46137866377830505, -1.6010743379592896, -1.0579179525375366, -0.25332748889923096, 0.15385349094867706, 1.043195366859436, 0.3823288083076477, -0.3669086992740631, -0.1575053334236145, 0.06412665545940399, -0.4663856625556946, 0.08227446675300598, 0.2736711800098419, -0.2690891623497009, -0.46082422137260437, -0.41255903244018555, -0.15462690591812134, 0.7437465786933899, -0.2474125474691391, 0.9295204877853394, 0.038962509483098984, 0.16578757762908936, 0.5566636323928833, -0.8960304856300354, 0.42182204127311707, -0.17282231152057648, -0.24659912288188934, -0.27805376052856445, -0.12986525893211365, 0.8520012497901917, 0.6770975589752197, -0.4381152093410492, 0.7329196929931641, 0.2407226860523224, -0.22248072922229767, 0.05650319531559944, 0.4695427119731903, 0.736150324344635, 0.03710287809371948, 0.44999828934669495, -0.4842626750469208, -0.32445186376571655, -0.44988954067230225, -0.18739427626132965, -0.37225142121315, 0.4177025556564331, -0.5093464255332947, 1.1642087697982788, 0.14940695464611053, -0.3634186387062073, -0.6437187194824219, 0.3040841817855835, 0.019555475562810898, -0.14522331953048706, -0.22842320799827576, 0.9711411595344543, -0.7680845260620117, -0.26028695702552795, -0.47821739315986633, 1.2731751203536987, -0.36535248160362244, 0.8195974826812744, -1.1313531398773193, 0.5726448893547058, 1.0133851766586304, 0.16756881773471832, -0.14427737891674042, -0.11488492041826248, 0.18712104856967926, -0.004135981202125549, -0.4247998297214508, 0.2556484639644623, -0.6596680879592896, -0.16414062678813934, -0.39995554089546204, -0.3137947618961334, 0.2806340456008911, -0.1604263335466385, 0.4007589817047119, 0.25568944215774536, 0.25275272130966187, 0.4802573025226593, -0.5958448052406311, -0.3450022339820862, 0.13925687968730927, 0.7832382917404175, -0.21935883164405823, 0.823199987411499, 0.19304879009723663, 0.7822116613388062, 0.13404421508312225, 0.7017192244529724, 0.3439010977745056, 0.7566381692886353, 0.9566112160682678, 0.6707603931427002, 0.7175855040550232, 0.293639600276947, 0.21108345687389374, 0.5118279457092285, -0.26753056049346924, -0.01861634850502014, -0.23698268830776215, 0.6846094727516174, -0.5121710896492004, 0.23862123489379883, 0.6876470446586609, 0.4623207747936249, -0.7428202629089355, -0.38350558280944824, 0.6326805353164673, -0.20597462356090546, -0.13491910696029663, -0.6297972798347473, 0.09412439912557602, -0.13324809074401855, -0.3652481436729431, -0.01102255005389452, 0.5353058576583862, 0.645962119102478, -0.01439660880714655, 0.26174646615982056, 0.17855238914489746, 0.25564777851104736, -0.7795279622077942, -1.0376667976379395, -1.679789423942566, -0.8289187550544739, -0.521939754486084, -0.10690197348594666, -0.4392291307449341, -0.46960118412971497, 0.043552644550800323, 0.5300219655036926, 0.12937815487384796, -0.12831982970237732, -0.12204093486070633, 0.18252672255039215, 0.7866771221160889, 0.32756316661834717, -0.35081538558006287, 0.36200040578842163, -0.8304188847541809, 0.024039115756750107, -0.08634363859891891, -0.35895928740501404, -0.2644267678260803, -0.30038708448410034, 0.919730007648468, -1.0761935710906982, 0.14506623148918152, -0.5911419987678528, -0.3325081765651703, -0.5315330028533936, 0.5338050127029419, -0.044181909412145615, 0.23230832815170288, 0.06514781713485718, -0.7245494723320007, -0.014527985826134682, 0.17077849805355072, 0.0902867242693901, 0.5372733473777771, 0.36484718322753906, 0.16441570222377777, 0.2923847436904907, 0.12021966278553009, -0.42496997117996216, -0.8126682639122009, 0.14067283272743225, 0.7123289704322815, -0.33610665798187256, -0.07007182389497757, -0.8396967053413391, -1.1866319179534912, -0.2740596532821655, 0.46788108348846436, -0.15200191736221313, 0.30507349967956543, -0.2973185181617737, 0.27854299545288086, -1.0066360235214233, 0.6723533272743225, -0.5787070393562317, -1.6062461137771606, 0.12872594594955444, -0.22220374643802643, -0.15064185857772827, 0.29223763942718506, 0.19405202567577362, 0.11122870445251465, 0.04404136538505554, 0.29620561003685, 0.5489572882652283, -0.20439133048057556, 0.37236353754997253, -0.02447139285504818, 0.41386380791664124, -0.3033062219619751, 0.4370388090610504, 0.3979191482067108, -0.4759106934070587, -0.5916429758071899, 0.4621945321559906, -0.10156990587711334, 0.44587281346321106, 1.0282032489776611, 0.36111199855804443, -0.14923933148384094, 1.0660557746887207, 0.45683255791664124, 0.4716160297393799, 0.22658436000347137, 0.29560980200767517, -0.362824410200119, 0.3983232378959656, -0.5523312091827393, -0.013181429356336594, -0.3947090804576874, -0.2470918595790863, 0.07754745334386826, -0.4744727611541748, 0.32026034593582153, -0.08123303204774857, 0.7141156792640686, -0.2937066853046417, -0.17222191393375397, 0.2534452974796295, -0.04620528221130371, -0.0983685851097107, 1.2404536008834839, 0.7550576329231262, 1.2839080095291138, -1.4292011260986328, 0.604793131351471, 0.2361690104007721, 1.323014259338379, 0.15302444994449615, -0.0646178275346756, 0.8117625713348389, -0.638950526714325, 0.06640192866325378, 0.08615810424089432, -0.18682317435741425, 0.17022661864757538, 0.7864229679107666, 0.195071280002594, 0.36531323194503784, -0.9360649585723877, -0.7088668346405029, 0.30513665080070496, 0.883242130279541, -0.4545450806617737, -0.0817938968539238, 0.8169546127319336, -0.67039555311203, 0.03088054247200489, 0.286196768283844, 0.5929492712020874, -0.09887700527906418, -0.19483301043510437, -0.413030743598938, -0.09877374768257141, -0.5647832751274109, -0.3981250524520874, -0.7966566681861877, 0.34270569682121277, -0.13595624268054962, 0.7364497184753418, -0.19676397740840912, -0.44316962361335754, -0.20332247018814087, -0.6586315631866455, 0.8390461206436157, 0.5007080435752869, 0.29598382115364075, -0.7117617726325989, 0.2087022364139557, -0.1701013743877411, -0.5215691924095154, -0.23970486223697662, -0.8068569302558899, 0.531621515750885, 0.8022193908691406, 0.05780377238988876, -1.3175727128982544, -0.5272595286369324, 0.12752766907215118, -0.46278566122055054, -0.22452019155025482, 0.08097770065069199, -0.22532358765602112, 0.5020620822906494, -0.45165330171585083, -0.34215137362480164, -0.7754791975021362, 0.05560962110757828, -0.6932871341705322, 0.07395206391811371, 0.44790196418762207, 0.9266387820243835, 0.16702698171138763, 0.6363224387168884, -0.47913509607315063, 1.011621356010437, -0.8566837906837463, 0.4849165976047516, -0.24461792409420013, -1.0179095268249512, -0.22854208946228027, -0.7177473902702332, -0.32690152525901794, -0.06101085990667343, -0.8478013277053833, -0.47813597321510315, -0.30116328597068787, -0.1662285029888153, 0.4985280930995941, -0.3653692603111267, 0.9750111103057861, -1.344280481338501, -0.1572079211473465, 1.5503203868865967, -0.35924649238586426, -0.2556677758693695, -0.03765660151839256, -0.20141878724098206, -0.5354111790657043, 0.6316229701042175, -0.18304459750652313, 0.2082040160894394, -0.1409643292427063, 0.10033199936151505, -0.18263906240463257, -0.19818347692489624, 0.5937948822975159, -0.9424949884414673, -0.18957820534706116, -0.22371692955493927, -0.5017821192741394, -0.8688027858734131, -0.6338901519775391, -0.6330584287643433, 0.7485106587409973, 0.24679240584373474, -0.39899495244026184, -0.20756365358829498, -0.37728437781333923, -0.23886001110076904, -0.6344240307807922, -0.6061084866523743, 0.04262026771903038, -0.523146390914917, 0.02900143340229988, 0.95530766248703, -0.702523946762085, -0.8400241732597351, 0.5704861879348755, 0.32220014929771423, -0.6092486381530762, -0.4016437232494354, 0.30682262778282166, 0.42185544967651367, -0.28350386023521423, -0.4911629259586334, -0.2376500517129898, -0.4922882318496704, -0.29217329621315, -0.07889964431524277, 0.0703364759683609, -0.08409959822893143, -0.16742363572120667, -0.20484301447868347, 0.41074076294898987, 0.23353828489780426, -1.0519837141036987, -0.8046225309371948, 0.21447168290615082, 0.5135614275932312, -0.04737976938486099, -0.07327557355165482, -1.120105266571045, -0.38807934522628784, -0.7152761220932007, 0.303239107131958, -0.5247371792793274, 0.28393781185150146, -0.2921575605869293, -0.624774158000946, 0.26977264881134033, 0.3426532745361328, 0.5590564012527466, 0.8030639886856079, -0.30024030804634094, -0.45183417201042175, 0.9603110551834106, 0.0077764010056853294, 0.22069743275642395, -0.5170628428459167, 0.13964533805847168, -0.009621982462704182, 0.8677026033401489, 0.019260574132204056, -0.5392662882804871, 0.41345420479774475, -0.13337498903274536, 0.5334633588790894, 0.464321106672287, -0.5389370918273926, -0.620248556137085, 0.20734015107154846, 0.48734205961227417, -0.36198827624320984, -0.06376337260007858, -0.9182502031326294, 0.9149214029312134, -0.32873305678367615, 0.5677096247673035, -0.007156699895858765, -0.00878478866070509, 0.44412747025489807, -0.24642127752304077, 0.8967011570930481, -0.6798210740089417, -0.3367472290992737, 0.36691492795944214, -0.4372788071632385, -0.4018551707267761, 0.09060518443584442, -1.1739459037780762, -0.5550042390823364, -0.3617785573005676, -1.1054004430770874, 0.7209026217460632, 0.014407404698431492, 0.28626200556755066, 0.5930761694908142, -0.0905018076300621, 0.390465646982193, -0.3198483884334564, 0.837128221988678, 0.7014567852020264, -0.5877650380134583, -0.9428557753562927, 0.3246459662914276, -0.006084379740059376, -0.2960134446620941, 0.2241358608007431, 0.3852687180042267, -0.509006679058075, -0.7236539125442505, -0.05196275934576988, -0.3020228147506714, -0.6266950368881226, 0.016603520140051842, 0.23805126547813416, 0.15348607301712036, 0.0005924924043938518, 0.097457654774189, -0.13191160559654236, -0.0888654887676239, -0.23929236829280853, 0.11001969873905182, -0.517305850982666, 0.16889338195323944, 0.9970707893371582, -0.11733441054821014, -0.2753709852695465, 0.3792879283428192, -0.0246652252972126, -0.16945426166057587, -0.36973437666893005, 0.12902379035949707, -0.08946630358695984, -0.6233770251274109, 0.7290330529212952, 0.4007483124732971, -1.0072529315948486, -0.4912096858024597, 0.046485401690006256, -0.02768709696829319, 0.3393721282482147, 0.2965119481086731, -0.020290706306695938, 0.2880207300186157, -0.3044799268245697, 0.31203165650367737, -0.1832183450460434, 0.21067214012145996, -0.05855671316385269, -0.33372339606285095, 0.10689001530408859, -1.3234381675720215, 0.21777993440628052, 0.8232816457748413, -0.6794769167900085, 0.13348060846328735, 1.0264146327972412, 0.7222882509231567, 0.24382653832435608, -0.09907280653715134, 0.4083004593849182, -0.7667233943939209, -0.20643755793571472, -0.26175615191459656, 0.23280656337738037, -0.27448388934135437, -0.28477686643600464, 0.2807425856590271, 0.5415836572647095, 0.12247048318386078, -0.7912343740463257, -1.3655614852905273, 0.02037785016000271, 0.3897034525871277, 0.4121814966201782, 0.15709035098552704, 0.8915429711341858, 1.4312264919281006, 0.2957157790660858, 0.693422794342041, -0.08351345360279083, -0.7117563486099243, -0.7301982045173645, -0.5386407971382141, -0.3337952792644501, -0.9753857254981995, -0.25818341970443726, 1.21624755859375, -0.05257383733987808, -0.6376619338989258, -0.21160639822483063, 0.8146491050720215, 0.04234226793050766, 0.427836149930954, -0.4631040692329407, -0.1366833597421646, -0.4315105676651001, -0.7316688895225525, -0.35073286294937134, -0.5687798857688904, 0.14241155982017517, 1.365144968032837, -0.5331911444664001, -0.5952668190002441, -0.17630235850811005, 0.030339989811182022, 0.12308640033006668, 0.6226597428321838, -0.22179333865642548, -0.4696784019470215, -0.45553475618362427, 0.47362783551216125, -0.000007262744475156069, 0.08951704204082489, 1.3729127645492554, -0.28295329213142395, 0.24450941383838654, 0.8591050505638123, 0.1645692139863968, -0.42811328172683716, 0.1337573528289795, 0.887744665145874, -0.36935925483703613, -1.1168060302734375, 0.07832826673984528, 0.944664716720581, -0.9767837524414062, -0.274334579706192, -0.6678271889686584, -0.24881231784820557, 0.43241527676582336, 0.328307569026947, -0.10175517946481705, 0.7267914414405823, 0.47160738706588745, 0.09376028180122375, -0.0886681005358696, 1.0009576082229614, 0.37877896428108215, -0.04132093861699104, 0.5773041844367981, -0.07546733319759369, 0.002541625639423728, -1.4431873559951782, 0.0945524051785469, 0.4068453311920166, -0.7636038661003113, 0.06009278446435928, 0.2363615185022354, 0.22567741572856903, -0.15988248586654663, 0.040885262191295624, 0.2712884545326233, -0.12658973038196564, 0.15645095705986023, 0.7042231559753418, 0.0604318231344223, -0.619972825050354, -1.0436525344848633, -0.6391302347183228, -0.8813900947570801, 0.120651975274086, 0.7558597326278687, -0.1930128037929535, 0.19452521204948425, -0.7930806875228882, -0.7950350642204285, 0.7852599024772644, -0.1342039704322815, 0.048427145928144455, -0.026508409529924393, 0.9805312752723694, 0.09790515154600143, -0.06419672816991806, 0.16915754973888397, -0.16066332161426544, 0.24318067729473114, -0.27859944105148315, -0.9083845019340515, -0.43788185715675354, 0.3853742480278015, 0.4312968850135803, 0.2063547521829605, -0.34447962045669556, -0.359698086977005, -0.28108251094818115, 0.2899459898471832, -0.16308064758777618, -0.18870563805103302, -0.3762257993221283, -0.6243765950202942, -0.004605626221746206, -0.49491551518440247, -0.06151024252176285, -1.0292999744415283, 0.33384156227111816, -0.33863624930381775, -1.1528820991516113, 0.16142602264881134, -0.19688713550567627, 0.7398881316184998, -0.3233153522014618, 0.6149901747703552, -0.4641276001930237, 0.8539506196975708, -0.2863924205303192, -0.4048013985157013, 0.18444539606571198, 0.6775481104850769, 0.2851252853870392, -0.19364161789417267, -0.23275849223136902, -0.06142357736825943, 0.7874982357025146, 0.6441729664802551, 0.12835174798965454, 0.38006219267845154, 0.3067997694015503, 0.4999283254146576, -0.002657103119418025, -0.3140787184238434, 0.3356315791606903, 0.5687167644500732, -0.7360292077064514, -0.35737669467926025, 0.20351022481918335, 0.6942114233970642, -0.10319173336029053, -0.19305303692817688, -0.14505153894424438, -0.8115898966789246, -0.5012131929397583, -0.12848949432373047, 0.21987560391426086, 0.9904281497001648, 0.3410879671573639, 0.527239203453064, 0.6373504996299744, 0.30554088950157166, -0.11220130324363708, 0.28855767846107483, 0.7621074318885803, -0.28215011954307556, -0.46152451634407043, -0.4007987678050995, 0.47077542543411255, 0.21317294239997864, -0.6847569942474365, 0.16179241240024567, -0.27011996507644653, 0.057223476469516754, 0.5539646148681641, -0.497450590133667, 0.2874663472175598, 0.38902178406715393, -0.2924838662147522, -0.06951633095741272, -0.21501179039478302, -0.02863037958741188, -0.04624456167221069, -0.7496427297592163, 0.8902162313461304, -0.3289934992790222, 0.4510685205459595, 0.18649417161941528, 0.3896881937980652, 0.8566657304763794, 0.2404792159795761, 0.25510984659194946, -0.38254812359809875, 0.5342200398445129, 0.587827205657959, 0.16290906071662903, 0.6556813716888428, -0.344870001077652, -0.3880182206630707, 0.2542748749256134, -0.2905851900577545, 0.7572166919708252, 0.14939427375793457, -0.8493818044662476, -0.6208478212356567, 0.36848631501197815, -0.006384869106113911, 0.1973063051700592, -0.49471738934516907, 0.15953095257282257, 0.5960873961448669, 0.41208016872406006, -0.7754524946212769, -0.1831461489200592, 0.4873864948749542, -0.5305261611938477, 0.4757983088493347, -0.40899404883384705, -0.7312009334564209, -0.0015129512175917625, -1.0573234558105469, 0.3738226294517517, 0.19450446963310242, -0.3454413115978241, -0.25981903076171875, -1.4079266786575317, -0.4473622739315033, -0.17586834728717804, 0.4865705072879791, -0.7557860016822815, 0.28894463181495667, 0.31165578961372375, 0.5988914966583252, -0.4166017770767212, -0.021746259182691574, -0.4982614815235138, 0.2620072662830353, 1.0922507047653198, -0.7401148080825806, 0.03502796217799187, -0.23047858476638794, 0.49399057030677795, -0.0752764344215393, -0.10523571074008942, -0.7499035000801086, 0.12346073240041733, 0.0997718870639801, -0.8932035565376282, 0.2071201652288437, -0.08003879338502884, -0.44251540303230286, 0.4353492856025696, 0.6215583682060242, -0.472078800201416, 0.17011764645576477, -0.4873844087123871, -0.2478310912847519, -0.4842342436313629, 1.0193595886230469, -0.48254185914993286, 0.08758829534053802, 0.47685763239860535, -0.28230226039886475, 0.07200878113508224, -0.6360640525817871, 4.104942321777344, 1.0218966007232666, 0.6792534589767456, -0.28462934494018555, 0.7666635513305664, 0.42070648074150085, 0.6433583498001099, -0.030611738562583923, 0.3332255780696869, 0.07872327417135239, -0.10807571560144424, 0.4104284942150116, 0.01802603341639042, -0.08836319297552109, 0.025247003883123398, 0.2657887041568756, -1.140102744102478, -0.15438497066497803, 0.02296924777328968, -0.7708057165145874, -0.42625290155410767, 0.0826873928308487, -0.13663579523563385, 0.2592427730560303, 0.3831811249256134, -0.11520379036664963, 0.5042127370834351, -0.02806464582681656, -0.10835185647010803, -0.12957240641117096, -0.1477339267730713, -0.8613489270210266, 0.39665475487709045, -0.5544085502624512, -0.1909620463848114, 0.45895206928253174, -0.058270469307899475, -0.7056912779808044, -0.0032197763212025166, -0.5146834850311279, -0.665378987789154, -0.1026289239525795, -0.040885187685489655, -0.445044606924057, -0.7941206097602844, 0.3334156274795532, -0.32225239276885986, 0.3255561590194702, 0.7294230461120605, -0.6935112476348877, 0.6804192662239075, -1.1735295057296753, 0.4400573968887329, 0.11105506122112274, -1.0323277711868286, -0.433783620595932, -0.21498212218284607, -0.8679678440093994, 0.3816525340080261, 0.3767573833465576, 0.6881623268127441, -0.22466878592967987, -0.3689321279525757, 0.400464802980423, 1.0578190088272095, 0.6652541756629944, 0.8758150339126587, -0.09299635142087936, 0.2679765820503235, -0.3897370994091034, 0.09385910630226135, -0.17328563332557678, -0.23889464139938354, 0.09977278858423233, 0.5271046161651611, 0.7706581950187683, -0.4261992871761322, 0.8098437786102295, -0.43115606904029846, -0.3670208752155304, 0.009321382269263268, -0.03280709311366081, 0.3602975308895111, -0.3195017874240875, -0.010261671617627144, 1.2719378471374512, -0.04194383695721626, -0.05705223232507706, -1.3573803901672363, 0.32728156447410583, 0.4109986424446106, -0.37331753969192505, 0.15020789206027985, -0.07999393343925476, -0.4420551359653473 ]
{"Title": "Does the metabolic syndrome exist? The identification of cardio-metabolic profiles in a South Asian population study", "Authors": "Harber-Aschan Lisa, Bakolis Ioannis, Glozier Nicholas, Ismail Khalida, Jayaweera Kaushalya, Pannala Gayani, Pariante Carmine, Rijsdijk Fruhling, Siribaddana Sisira, Sumathipala Athula, Zavos Helena M.S., Zunszain Patricia, Hotopf Matthew", "Abstract": "Abstract OBJECTIVE Research testing the validity of the metabolic syndrome (MetS) as a clinical construct associated with cardiovascular disease risk has produced inconsistent results. This study tested the existence of the MetS, explored alternative cardiometabolic risk characterisations, and examined the relative influence of genetic and environmental factors in a South Asian sample. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS Data came from the Colombo Twin and Singleton follow-up Study, CoTaSS-2 (N=3969). Latent class analysis tested the clustering of MetS indicators (waist circumference, high-density-lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C), triglycerides (TG), blood pressure, fasting plasma glucose (FPG), medications and diabetes). Regression analyses tested cross-sectional associations between identified latent classes and covariates. Structural equation modelling estimated genetic and environmental influences on these classes. Analyses were stratified by gender (n=1681 men, n=2288 women). RESULTS Three classes were identified in men: 1) \u201cHealthy\u201d (52.3%), 2) \u201cCentral obesity, high TG, high FPG\u201d (40.2%), and 3) \u201cCentral obesity, high TG, diabetes\u201d (7.6%). Four classes were identified in women: 1) \u201cHealthy\u201d (53.2%), 2) \u201cVery high central obesity, low HDL-C, raised FPG\u201d (32.8%), 3) \u201cVery high central obesity, diabetes\u201d (7.2%) and 4) \u201cCentral obesity, hypertension, raised FPG\u201d (6.8%). Older age in men and women, and high socioeconomic status in men, was associated with cardiometabolic risk categories, compared to the \u201cHealthy\u201d classes. In men, individual differences in cardiometabolic class membership were due to environmental effects. In females, genetic differences significantly predicted class membership. CONCLUSIONS The findings did not support the MetS construct. Instead, distinct clinical profiles were identified in men and women, suggesting different aetiological pathways.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012195"}
10.1101/19008482
[ -0.17719657719135284, 0.2559426426887512, -0.5704036355018616, 1.4407342672348022, -0.7414755821228027, -0.7533729672431946, -0.8070737719535828, 0.29419445991516113, 0.3683684766292572, 0.5056492686271667, 0.041877057403326035, -0.5594351291656494, 0.5007782578468323, 0.42905211448669434, -0.3184003531932831, 0.3276989161968231, -0.7308897376060486, 0.027286868542432785, -0.34738215804100037, 0.32905909419059753, -0.019306769594550133, 0.5497078895568848, -0.214943990111351, -0.023922253400087357, -0.8670493960380554, 0.5717310309410095, -0.15545031428337097, 0.16172684729099274, 0.9317569136619568, 0.8155235648155212, 0.32953599095344543, -0.4395388066768646, 0.517572820186615, -0.5282655358314514, -0.4561600387096405, 0.02289455011487007, 0.7700951099395752, -0.48984745144844055, -0.0892060250043869, -0.2862986624240875, 0.1661573052406311, 0.058132197707891464, 0.2519502639770508, -0.2804090678691864, -0.931079089641571, 0.10569292306900024, -0.6288275718688965, -0.31704631447792053, -0.03296266868710518, -0.008970838971436024, -0.2227877378463745, -0.26853814721107483, -0.21358008682727814, -0.18420827388763428, -0.0806191936135292, 0.0806824266910553, 0.144999697804451, -0.42708468437194824, -0.20500732958316803, -0.43979412317276, 0.054467566311359406, -0.25306224822998047, 0.6031442284584045, -1.1045678853988647, 0.6333048343658447, 0.907341480255127, -0.6321110129356384, 0.09608397632837296, -0.24355126917362213, -0.23338019847869873, -0.07294213771820068, -0.08996222913265228, -0.9684816598892212, 0.1450037658214569, -0.3693447411060333, -0.18251505494117737, 0.4905034005641937, -0.18238060176372528, 0.2867160439491272, 0.13643796741962433, -0.037721939384937286, 0.6142717599868774, 0.5683528780937195, 0.12481922656297684, -0.6455305814743042, 0.6025269031524658, -0.5041150450706482, 0.21890684962272644, 0.6240883469581604, 0.12972082197666168, 0.08604816347360611, -0.29805654287338257, 0.15026243031024933, -0.03102979250252247, -0.4115244746208191, 1.067870855331421, -0.7310489416122437, -0.37641486525535583, 0.9975095987319946, -0.41445237398147583, 0.7177016735076904, 0.580112099647522, -0.04190732166171074, 0.4005621373653412, -0.6648325324058533, 0.20240582525730133, 1.3122432231903076, -0.43679341673851013, -0.184592142701149, -0.9611253142356873, 0.06962430477142334, 0.03511709347367287, -0.4629427492618561, -0.42588528990745544, 0.26057758927345276, -0.18223808705806732, -0.23038475215435028, 0.44313955307006836, -1.1169697046279907, 0.988610565662384, 0.17628885805606842, -0.15660636126995087, 0.5337508320808411, -0.5836468935012817, 0.6201251149177551, -0.1261080652475357, 0.024098142981529236, 0.5554617643356323, -0.6531147360801697, -0.12939727306365967, -0.1179906353354454, -0.5718145370483398, 0.017461149021983147, 0.6339167356491089, -0.4839712381362915, 0.14087800681591034, 0.5358081459999084, 0.7883961796760559, 0.3682743012905121, 0.25553351640701294, -0.08952498435974121, 0.7131636738777161, 0.049708299338817596, 1.338192343711853, 0.37494149804115295, 0.7253836989402771, -0.24962683022022247, -0.25164535641670227, -0.09682215005159378, 0.3813052773475647, -0.22156338393688202, 0.510138988494873, 0.14832432568073273, 0.40932536125183105, 0.17789898812770844, 0.5709267258644104, -0.46058475971221924, 0.6484675407409668, -1.0228979587554932, 0.27503371238708496, -0.3654692769050598, 0.20717988908290863, 0.08342061191797256, 1.005237102508545, -0.5533320307731628, 0.4283555746078491, -0.7346689701080322, 0.41783103346824646, 0.24010446667671204, -0.1441369652748108, 1.2995202541351318, 0.4851563572883606, -0.777308464050293, -0.24365343153476715, 0.15872181951999664, 0.5325088500976562, 0.4598780870437622, 0.48823118209838867, 0.021575987339019775, 0.741725742816925, -0.3785145878791809, 0.5190696120262146, 0.6051632165908813, 0.7275416254997253, 0.31080225110054016, -0.007247045170515776, -0.10273189097642899, -0.7477481961250305, -0.327609658241272, -0.21910400688648224, 0.21330562233924866, 0.06436294317245483, -0.8947538733482361, 0.9262435436248779, 0.3381911814212799, -0.13907697796821594, -0.002852358855307102, 0.24214132130146027, 0.6453058123588562, 0.012821261771023273, -0.5717620253562927, 0.21282732486724854, 0.2073550969362259, 0.2505367696285248, 0.2937634587287903, 0.3702702820301056, 0.024045979604125023, 0.6016646027565002, 0.2666581869125366, -0.24384798109531403, 1.2191847562789917, 0.2989846467971802, -0.31590735912323, 0.06342025846242905, 0.5371828675270081, -0.5621152520179749, 0.21767909824848175, 0.5045039653778076, -0.5507258176803589, -0.24028180539608002, -0.3760465681552887, 0.7615727186203003, 0.6414983868598938, 0.026720654219388962, -0.6222896575927734, -0.5541894435882568, 0.3690067231655121, 0.7591803073883057, -0.5289118885993958, -0.33276334404945374, 0.3267616331577301, 0.35488879680633545, 0.24587835371494293, 0.4840492904186249, 1.2232556343078613, -0.05347594991326332, -0.00613576453179121, 0.4493855834007263, -0.09937848150730133, 0.35403209924697876, 0.3890240490436554, 0.8499191999435425, 0.16294099390506744, 0.09770799428224564, -0.533349335193634, 0.019988933578133583, -0.6337593197822571, -0.13423196971416473, -0.24214394390583038, -0.1655561774969101, -0.5230522155761719, 0.5344280004501343, -0.03840121999382973, 0.3235696852207184, -0.8139891624450684, 0.17096388339996338, 1.1047792434692383, -0.03358365222811699, -0.6690816879272461, 0.3373121917247772, 0.0048621054738759995, 0.20346100628376007, -0.27658218145370483, 0.6572155952453613, 0.6732594966888428, 0.04541035741567612, -0.05931396037340164, 0.04756229370832443, -0.19597798585891724, 0.26781758666038513, -1.138209581375122, -0.25404486060142517, -0.6028028726577759, -0.8342344164848328, -0.17944301664829254, -0.1476886123418808, -0.8854054808616638, 0.22697250545024872, 0.014281932264566422, 0.2174878716468811, 0.21831607818603516, -0.39384064078330994, 0.3382357656955719, 0.5866321921348572, -0.15163245797157288, -0.1254788190126419, -1.0851125717163086, 0.06993486732244492, -0.04990405961871147, 0.1139979287981987, 0.04579946771264076, -0.8793190717697144, -0.9425325393676758, -1.2162069082260132, 0.43468183279037476, -0.5957805514335632, -0.1114201620221138, -0.1391073614358902, 0.042655620723962784, -0.43429842591285706, 0.3038212060928345, -0.4612025320529938, -0.32416948676109314, 0.02348286844789982, -0.3691347539424896, 0.7379382252693176, 0.13227632641792297, 0.15244464576244354, 0.04173353686928749, -0.395718514919281, -0.20658665895462036, -0.02805442176759243, 0.4123237729072571, 0.4033380448818207, -0.43239080905914307, -0.012067735195159912, -0.009745524264872074, -0.23971571028232574, 0.03456086292862892, -0.13977715373039246, -0.46389153599739075, -0.18691666424274445, -0.8569158911705017, -0.4887859523296356, -0.11425638943910599, 0.20264621078968048, 0.4120340347290039, -1.2826602458953857, 0.45794323086738586, -0.5663869976997375, -0.7538045644760132, -0.14481587707996368, -0.46206238865852356, 0.8296449184417725, -0.37469080090522766, 0.05872916430234909, -0.549611508846283, -0.23835378885269165, -0.37106558680534363, 0.2589053511619568, 0.042187537997961044, -0.6871529221534729, 0.10700550675392151, -0.1903226375579834, -0.3339027762413025, 0.11171208322048187, 0.02738283760845661, -0.46191200613975525, 0.32629698514938354, -0.4551814794540405, 0.1539248526096344, -0.10763117671012878, 0.42807289958000183, -0.32255566120147705, -0.13463343679904938, 0.36698582768440247, -0.3206768035888672, 0.37832438945770264, 0.2980683147907257, 0.127154141664505, 0.002081718295812607, 0.445920467376709, -0.6464571356773376, -0.25832122564315796, 0.04011362046003342, -1.442846417427063, 0.7809650301933289, 1.0793356895446777, 0.395733505487442, -0.006372092757374048, 0.6100291609764099, -0.4166293740272522, -0.3921247124671936, -0.08306070417165756, -0.14189718663692474, -0.007275031413882971, 0.6294119358062744, -0.04654717445373535, 0.7090208530426025, -0.864285409450531, 0.05996265634894371, 0.20823848247528076, 1.1708195209503174, 0.37133336067199707, -0.22737710177898407, 0.22508130967617035, -0.7900614142417908, 0.3145356774330139, 0.19532053172588348, -0.040517862886190414, 0.36957213282585144, -0.2369670867919922, 0.7178953289985657, -0.724956750869751, -0.47689035534858704, -0.5899503231048584, 0.5332155823707581, 0.3637199401855469, 0.18773913383483887, -0.313806414604187, 1.1136571168899536, -0.7339648008346558, 0.5047438740730286, 0.309416800737381, 0.5190091133117676, 0.40461477637290955, -0.7163435816764832, 0.6061471104621887, 0.3753982484340668, -0.5251967906951904, -0.6173385977745056, -0.7012940645217896, -0.47429728507995605, -0.07254425436258316, -0.033040739595890045, 0.7457739114761353, -0.19390559196472168, -0.08348345011472702, -0.6181142330169678, -0.7116777300834656, 0.23436957597732544, 0.0007987117278389633, -0.7426823377609253, 0.04902270808815956, 0.4651632010936737, -0.28842633962631226, 0.11751417815685272, -0.15515214204788208, 0.09987244009971619, 0.9890329837799072, -0.11275684088468552, -0.6184095740318298, -0.1104288399219513, -0.08263810724020004, -0.8610718250274658, 0.18508484959602356, -0.29575997591018677, -0.2773798704147339, 0.4110247790813446, -0.11653635650873184, 0.06577974557876587, -0.12610094249248505, -0.1668219268321991, 0.04788469895720482, 0.004027806222438812, 0.3405100107192993, 0.8882635235786438, 0.2702629268169403, 0.8561273813247681, 0.27818235754966736, 0.5698168277740479, -0.6840037703514099, 0.4578937888145447, 0.19532042741775513, -0.29199960827827454, 0.765099048614502, -0.4901565611362457, 0.014072963036596775, -0.5299955606460571, -0.5372134447097778, -0.14408712089061737, -0.5155847072601318, -0.34673580527305603, 0.0597740113735199, -0.12755011022090912, 0.8251527547836304, -0.6623107194900513, -0.5039421319961548, 0.9456607699394226, -0.7282367944717407, -0.0071117025800049305, 0.014885351061820984, -0.23145416378974915, -0.09302244335412979, 0.12952224910259247, -0.27613934874534607, -0.12434116005897522, 0.6521776914596558, -0.5213212966918945, 0.06540147215127945, -0.07149368524551392, 0.03312772884964943, 0.2919010818004608, 0.3372774124145508, -0.1875368058681488, -0.7653799057006836, -0.3113022446632385, 0.06151614338159561, -1.2397037744522095, 0.26355260610580444, -0.21122094988822937, -0.8209109306335449, 0.13538871705532074, -0.20369242131710052, -0.5296542644500732, -0.5031101703643799, -0.27189454436302185, -0.1091226264834404, -0.2802896797657013, 0.5088950991630554, 0.39719367027282715, -1.0264731645584106, -1.0435519218444824, -0.08980949968099594, 0.13650180399417877, -0.6602364778518677, -0.43776795268058777, 0.13683995604515076, -0.48838841915130615, 0.3431471288204193, -0.9705177545547485, 0.7885516881942749, -0.5484073162078857, 0.19866424798965454, -0.08093658834695816, -0.15847350656986237, 0.2898296117782593, -0.24594545364379883, 0.33827027678489685, 0.2958136796951294, 0.05959209054708481, -0.5478081107139587, 0.16267170011997223, 0.1934981644153595, -0.38523855805397034, 0.1946297287940979, 0.1307496428489685, -0.20271927118301392, -0.37660032510757446, -1.3665895462036133, 0.3654417097568512, -0.932200014591217, -0.5234335064888, 0.1107611283659935, -0.5515994429588318, -0.17829595506191254, 0.36245352029800415, -0.5804615020751953, -0.29568472504615784, 0.18956996500492096, -0.12716418504714966, 0.11441727727651596, -0.05862412974238396, -0.20324738323688507, 0.17359985411167145, -0.5810941457748413, 0.007562119979411364, 0.48634466528892517, 0.6221858263015747, 0.24451753497123718, -0.462449848651886, 0.1727926880121231, 0.47240546345710754, -0.27339017391204834, 0.24458281695842743, -0.0899820551276207, 0.05017780885100365, 0.258841872215271, -0.4207063615322113, -0.014896005392074585, -1.173351526260376, 0.6770570278167725, -0.3632509410381317, 0.021881436929106712, -0.23761795461177826, -0.3790089786052704, -0.38077032566070557, -0.5348631143569946, 1.0463932752609253, -0.5607059597969055, 0.05536391958594322, 0.5947249531745911, 0.0683504268527031, 0.01652849279344082, -0.08915942907333374, -0.23293711245059967, -0.6040375232696533, -0.3801071047782898, -0.5870577096939087, 0.25025030970573425, 0.19379526376724243, -0.045101359486579895, 0.31992241740226746, -0.3272034823894501, -0.030197080224752426, -0.9405064582824707, 0.7762501835823059, 0.5008645057678223, -0.9868805408477783, -0.15688292682170868, 0.057724855840206146, -0.01374148204922676, 0.6242170929908752, 0.48584988713264465, 0.15980246663093567, -0.3327845633029938, -0.16341657936573029, -0.2484763115644455, -0.26984700560569763, 0.03337445855140686, 0.38457190990448, 0.2421841323375702, 0.8298553228378296, -0.12560707330703735, 0.05051760375499725, -0.40916311740875244, -0.28267282247543335, 0.0696636363863945, 0.5609143376350403, 0.09978552907705307, 0.1642996370792389, 0.4585219919681549, -0.04416580870747566, -0.756520688533783, -0.15314415097236633, 0.07360953837633133, 0.1729772388935089, 0.15294209122657776, 0.3927096128463745, 0.13532301783561707, -0.7392126321792603, 0.6826621890068054, 0.28079092502593994, -0.5524628758430481, -0.23481838405132294, 0.53901606798172, -0.4269055724143982, 0.01814776286482811, -0.3762285113334656, -0.8444176912307739, 0.30254682898521423, 0.24459987878799438, 0.5412806868553162, -0.26479190587997437, -0.08123049885034561, 0.23655246198177338, -0.6826224327087402, 0.8333316445350647, -0.476847767829895, 0.18661311268806458, 0.5960126519203186, 0.34630608558654785, 0.24820534884929657, -0.07502330839633942, -0.9807957410812378, 0.7443956732749939, 0.4476158916950226, 0.2091120183467865, -0.5591827630996704, -0.22107209265232086, -0.15219829976558685, -0.5383517146110535, 0.3178746998310089, 0.23174525797367096, 0.011156595312058926, 0.2890077531337738, -0.31566497683525085, -0.5663892030715942, 0.007548337336629629, -0.6736578345298767, -0.6967037320137024, 0.524121105670929, -0.684234619140625, 0.15712302923202515, 0.9185217618942261, 0.14638832211494446, 0.588366687297821, -0.2669430375099182, -1.2607536315917969, -0.38463011384010315, -0.2502920925617218, 0.029074830934405327, -0.2884446084499359, -0.004744967445731163, 0.70501309633255, -0.5126266479492188, -0.7767298817634583, -0.40343034267425537, 0.4016481339931488, -0.7145224809646606, -0.678836464881897, -0.586081326007843, 0.6283942461013794, -0.41143956780433655, -0.7878817319869995, -0.4401148557662964, -0.444336473941803, -0.2626209557056427, 0.18936355412006378, -0.4834763705730438, -0.36678287386894226, -0.001566087594255805, 0.4276576042175293, 0.10311458259820938, 0.2045302838087082, 0.18457184731960297, -0.3813791275024414, 0.6334174871444702, 0.29172763228416443, -0.1149122416973114, 0.6726256608963013, 0.5978494882583618, -0.924091637134552, 0.9504611492156982, -0.00545102683827281, -0.7295141220092773, 0.3956338167190552, -0.3776075541973114, -0.315471887588501, -0.10520938038825989, -0.592721164226532, -0.22704632580280304, 0.0447031669318676, -0.8608317971229553, -0.17400391399860382, 0.31099507212638855, -0.04667758196592331, 0.3889211118221283, -0.8228181600570679, -0.44024065136909485, 0.31691330671310425, -0.2594177722930908, 0.22211895883083344, 0.5968902707099915, 0.5864442586898804, 0.7277988791465759, 0.1217072606086731, 0.3120047450065613, -0.21834707260131836, -0.5203726291656494, -1.035447359085083, -0.7189001441001892, 0.8338416814804077, -0.040731944143772125, 0.4880412518978119, -0.5111231207847595, -0.04561036825180054, -0.3582504093647003, -0.5405535101890564, -0.2342294305562973, 0.7576248049736023, 0.14846450090408325, 0.32960519194602966, 0.2737827003002167, -0.2731133997440338, -0.3976777493953705, -0.465364545583725, -0.3700273334980011, -0.4786752462387085, 0.44468894600868225, -0.3627943992614746, 0.038936860859394073, -0.7285159230232239, -0.1005980595946312, -0.12982642650604248, 0.239679217338562, 1.003591775894165, -0.9332245588302612, 0.813987672328949, 0.11971282213926315, 0.3405126631259918, 0.537524938583374, -0.016214264556765556, 0.6778148412704468, 0.22786255180835724, -0.42674189805984497, -0.5998498797416687, 0.8188068270683289, 0.3965878188610077, 0.6259952187538147, 0.1970072090625763, -0.4915652573108673, 0.39933767914772034, -0.5033613443374634, -0.17122411727905273, -0.028746839612722397, -0.1280665546655655, -0.7182993292808533, -0.37887486815452576, -0.24398919939994812, 0.5868770480155945, -0.43261271715164185, -0.04515897482633591, -0.18149802088737488, -0.8295093774795532, -0.5991100072860718, 0.11456944048404694, 1.121894359588623, -0.3480095863342285, 0.2626551687717438, -0.24223066866397858, 0.12359167635440826, -0.06785815209150314, -0.03827746957540512, 0.6171677112579346, 0.42681968212127686, 0.15083298087120056, 0.6726809144020081, 0.3060799241065979, 0.17469272017478943, 0.7110304832458496, 0.4975542426109314, 0.8780224323272705, 0.656673014163971, 0.09816288203001022, -0.17295528948307037, 0.1290433555841446, -0.684094250202179, 0.4097270965576172, -0.5847238302230835, -0.5002162456512451, 0.40951526165008545, 0.9435750842094421, 0.3139030337333679, 0.40287792682647705, -0.41453343629837036, 0.16879458725452423, -0.9746068716049194, -0.5973377227783203, -0.47009140253067017, 0.11054487526416779, 1.0238275527954102, 0.05028819665312767, -0.1610189527273178, 0.16311557590961456, 0.45908838510513306, 0.041107140481472015, -0.23205189406871796, 0.5205257534980774, 0.1089632511138916, -0.1813589185476303, 0.016135146841406822, 0.3371574580669403, -0.09892501682043076, 0.21948812901973724, 0.6269534230232239, -0.0008336710743606091, 0.13905420899391174, 0.2355591207742691, -0.10054389387369156, -0.3328666388988495, 1.1777381896972656, -0.0035276159178465605, -0.31626826524734497, -0.051155395805835724, 0.017895076423883438, -0.18001243472099304, -0.164704367518425, 0.8648417592048645, -0.22585521638393402, -0.1850328892469406, -0.4606723189353943, 0.3796658217906952, 0.39854487776756287, 0.42837631702423096, 0.6226010918617249, -0.6060863137245178, 0.6458289623260498, 0.39762648940086365, -0.33379849791526794, 0.31131044030189514, -0.43998032808303833, 0.11746010184288025, -0.3890019357204437, -0.7683107852935791, 0.17766043543815613, 0.08418279886245728, 0.16292423009872437, -0.3308570384979248, 0.6396421790122986, -0.5142806768417358, -0.02218451164662838, -0.570880651473999, -0.2274310290813446, -0.8226640820503235, 0.5680733323097229, -0.12314232438802719, 0.03721729665994644, 0.20952069759368896, -0.3875361680984497, -0.11144238710403442, -0.3701474368572235, -0.800919771194458, 0.6723126769065857, 0.011952747590839863, 0.09277628362178802, -0.3467864692211151, 0.005702298134565353, -0.1963043063879013, -0.603640615940094, 0.24383777379989624, 0.2757178544998169, -0.3192698061466217, -1.0289678573608398, 0.15200164914131165, 0.09785278141498566, 0.09185284376144409, 0.8801723718643188, 0.19497649371623993, 0.31624799966812134, 1.0973751544952393, 0.3938077986240387, -0.2203712910413742, 0.2523881196975708, -0.38996806740760803, 0.13836510479450226, -0.004805687349289656, 0.37053799629211426, 0.11099464446306229, -0.4061797857284546, -0.9116415977478027, 0.0018139195162802935, 0.33570730686187744, 0.133991539478302, -0.570811927318573, 0.17019374668598175, 0.27702608704566956, 0.3874073326587677, -0.0569806732237339, -0.4484783709049225, -0.736946165561676, -0.33394235372543335, 1.1066020727157593, -0.2133699655532837, -0.07644213736057281, -0.3050941228866577, 0.5644933581352234, 0.4385596811771393, -0.6104639172554016, 4.405265808105469, 0.8508427143096924, 0.07686369121074677, -0.18254272639751434, 0.33926883339881897, 0.2619645297527313, 0.35160398483276367, 0.01583840139210224, 0.08370614796876907, -0.21940147876739502, -0.30033746361732483, 0.004528780467808247, 0.6077418923377991, -0.019544169306755066, 1.0946820974349976, 0.10098111629486084, 0.06568662822246552, 0.41131412982940674, -0.22304390370845795, -0.7652556300163269, -0.2181277722120285, 0.18524332344532013, -0.31198441982269287, -0.09847170114517212, 0.03345560282468796, -0.21235185861587524, 0.701217770576477, 0.4203707277774811, 0.7688770890235901, -0.24156922101974487, 0.33273807168006897, -0.652645468711853, 0.5528861880302429, -1.5182123184204102, -0.5442887544631958, 0.15253718197345734, 0.19624127447605133, -0.1751527488231659, 0.18319304287433624, -0.08942600339651108, 0.4760024845600128, -0.0424768440425396, -0.05826059356331825, -0.6027674078941345, -0.17581628262996674, 0.5699551701545715, -0.47028636932373047, -0.0467323362827301, 0.9075918793678284, -0.174238920211792, 0.5310892462730408, -0.8511642217636108, -0.04396696016192436, 0.020224567502737045, -0.7693859934806824, -0.39743348956108093, 0.24924923479557037, -0.472217321395874, 0.5182825922966003, 0.046166546642780304, 1.1404364109039307, -0.32496798038482666, -0.2651151716709137, -0.13433076441287994, 0.6811919808387756, 0.7184539437294006, 0.4452783465385437, -0.010382026433944702, -0.5237500071525574, -0.7437872886657715, -0.3028824031352997, -0.5180517435073853, -0.29942554235458374, -0.2503681480884552, 1.174668788909912, 0.6100509762763977, -0.033739231526851654, 0.4914967715740204, -0.1626233011484146, -0.8486316204071045, 0.06845033168792725, 0.6299330592155457, 0.3554459512233734, -0.2803051471710205, -0.3337375819683075, 0.45755869150161743, -0.27978649735450745, -0.15046505630016327, -0.542418897151947, 0.1565762460231781, 0.5972691774368286, -0.39763951301574707, -0.13472747802734375, -0.2888656258583069, -0.0599631704390049 ]
{"Title": "Inconsistent Addiction Treatment for Patients Undergoing Cardiac Surgery for Injection Drug Use-Associated Infective endocarditis", "Authors": "Tiako Max Jordan Nguemeni, Hong Seong, Mahmood Syed Usman Bin, Mori Makoto, Mangi Abeel, Yun James, Juthani-Mehta Manisha, Geirsson Arnar", "Abstract": "Abstract Introduction Cases of injection drug use-related infective endocarditis (IDU-IE) requiring surgery are rising in the setting of the current U.S. opioid epidemic. We thus aimed to determine the nature of addiction interventions in the perioperative period. Methods This is a retrospective review of surgical IDU-IE from 2011 to 2016 at a tertiary care center in New Haven, Connecticut. The data collected included substances consumed recreationally, consultations by social work (SW), psychiatry, pharmacotherapy for addiction, and evidence of enrollment in a drug rehabilitation program upon discharge. Among patients with active drug use (ADU), we compared the 24-month survival of those who received at least one form of addiction intervention to that of those who did not. Results Forty-two patients (75%) had active drug use. Among them, 22 used heroin. Forty-one patients (73.2%) saw SW, 17 (30.4%) saw psychiatry; 14 (25%) saw neither SW nor psychiatry. Twenty-one patients (37.5%) received methadone, 6 (10.7%) received buprenorphine, 1 (0.02%) received naltrexone; 26 (46.4%) did not receive any pharmacotherapy. Fifteen patients (26.8%) attended a drug rehabilitation program, 13 (86.7%) of whom had seen SW and 8 (53%) psychiatry. Among patients with ADU, there was no statistically significant difference in survival between those who received at least one intervention and those who did not (p=0.1 by log rank). Conclusion Addiction interventions are deployed inconsistently for patients with surgical IDU-IE. Untreated substance use disorder and recurrent endocarditis are the leading cause of death in this population. Studying best-practices for perioperative interventions in IDU-IE and establishing protocols are of the upmost importance.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008482"}
10.1101/19000687
[ -0.2328554391860962, 0.5215603709220886, 0.1758926659822464, 0.656476616859436, -0.7648066282272339, 0.33587998151779175, 0.30785179138183594, -0.035525113344192505, 0.22835233807563782, 0.8148995637893677, 0.06669206917285919, -0.264884889125824, -0.17485114932060242, -1.0257691144943237, -0.34266892075538635, -0.3548014461994171, -0.6889877319335938, -0.8877690434455872, -0.8278661370277405, 0.5523796677589417, -0.38435640931129456, 0.40539342164993286, -0.615641713142395, -0.6909516453742981, -0.8684902787208557, -0.146528959274292, -0.07529716193675995, -0.7552357316017151, 0.5971091389656067, 0.752678632736206, 0.23827412724494934, -0.6922123432159424, 0.3725751042366028, 0.04649711772799492, 0.026295045390725136, 0.08889095485210419, 0.6399769186973572, -0.8397518992424011, -0.7849698662757874, -0.4620729982852936, -0.22348780930042267, -0.45560765266418457, 0.15997840464115143, -0.11675544828176498, -0.8255926370620728, -0.3000865578651428, -0.5002462863922119, -0.1495397835969925, 0.21781767904758453, -0.39561450481414795, 0.0834796354174614, 0.5523235201835632, 0.017699280753731728, -0.30721262097358704, -0.30641424655914307, 0.241292804479599, 0.028904246166348457, -0.1304340362548828, -0.4364240765571594, 0.39420047402381897, 0.2749904692173004, -0.18719086050987244, 0.3663458228111267, -0.6885808706283569, 1.0230247974395752, 0.47592490911483765, -0.32300159335136414, -0.20702117681503296, 0.4331943392753601, -0.1620764285326004, -0.5344740152359009, -0.07656728476285934, -0.00020383187802508473, 0.0530640110373497, -0.04625827446579933, 0.2241220474243164, 0.2748093008995056, -0.003981675487011671, -0.305515855550766, -0.5999957919120789, -0.3816573917865753, 0.3455563485622406, 0.25789037346839905, -0.4218778610229492, -0.5227828621864319, -0.032964788377285004, -0.4420841932296753, 0.19825272262096405, -0.005779902450740337, -0.44348782300949097, 0.11072453111410141, 0.39322057366371155, -0.6554492115974426, -0.36483487486839294, 0.510161280632019, 0.48837271332740784, -0.23798450827598572, -0.526943564414978, -0.6264252662658691, -0.3524312973022461, 0.29492732882499695, 0.30364665389060974, -0.08784415572881699, 1.027763843536377, -1.0765471458435059, 1.1814862489700317, 0.06407950073480606, -0.05420900508761406, 0.15203048288822174, -0.3780582547187805, 0.574340283870697, 0.6264054775238037, -0.4131411612033844, -0.0404418408870697, 0.6028841137886047, 0.04682460427284241, 0.06771458685398102, 0.32093098759651184, 0.2180771678686142, 0.3394521176815033, 0.026698868721723557, 0.26022452116012573, 0.6142059564590454, -0.2824842929840088, 0.24308112263679504, -0.21188178658485413, 0.5002884268760681, 0.6551833748817444, -1.1100540161132812, -0.6306698322296143, -0.24477747082710266, -0.6801394820213318, -0.16889040172100067, -0.26101547479629517, -0.8036173582077026, -0.1589219570159912, 0.14603905379772186, 0.9948891401290894, 0.4709843397140503, -0.5256751775741577, -0.054853927344083786, 0.3520362973213196, 0.5333265066146851, 0.9656992554664612, -0.25155919790267944, 0.4765225946903229, 0.19873619079589844, -0.5792776346206665, -0.806439995765686, 0.11249259859323502, -0.4150407314300537, 0.5174952149391174, -0.06548295170068741, -0.19253602623939514, -0.025582315400242805, -0.2678288519382477, -0.27245375514030457, 0.04300994798541069, -0.18500454723834991, 0.5936914086341858, -0.592326819896698, 0.2208034247159958, -0.011584017425775528, 0.7390636801719666, -0.7492743730545044, 0.6697713732719421, 0.17834576964378357, -0.7587277889251709, 0.5196047425270081, -0.6987389922142029, 0.146788090467453, 0.05919410660862923, -0.03245227038860321, -0.17983175814151764, 0.12176491320133209, 0.9594623446464539, 0.5955344438552856, 0.24052369594573975, 0.12258092314004898, 0.9757550954818726, -0.020108791068196297, 0.5445579886436462, 1.5404969453811646, 0.6938357949256897, -0.03187057375907898, 0.5735946297645569, -0.4597790241241455, -0.40928834676742554, -0.18134047091007233, -0.3832721412181854, -0.11803800612688065, 0.4200906455516815, -0.5472926497459412, 0.26042357087135315, -0.12844273447990417, -1.1811331510543823, -0.3891851305961609, 0.46710166335105896, 0.012807486578822136, -0.5458115935325623, -0.240777388215065, 0.4647303819656372, -0.7684487104415894, 0.8572461605072021, -0.9497626423835754, 0.6512654423713684, 0.6635017395019531, 1.2531588077545166, 0.019906120374798775, 0.7287706136703491, 0.9625346064567566, 0.12446215003728867, 0.02233680710196495, 0.01308186911046505, 0.22030006349086761, 0.08638017624616623, 0.15585070848464966, 0.14809858798980713, -0.5110722184181213, -0.4661121964454651, -0.8424040675163269, -0.18809987604618073, 0.8816022872924805, 0.010843506082892418, 0.14469680190086365, -0.14700908958911896, -0.017664583399891853, 0.8947413563728333, 0.09060539305210114, 0.0411086268723011, 0.2506716251373291, 0.5317974090576172, -0.027476081624627113, 0.09547561407089233, 0.689588189125061, -0.1895095258951187, 0.5126129984855652, 0.5608528256416321, 0.7876094579696655, 0.5466105341911316, 0.36745986342430115, 0.38473254442214966, 1.2805156707763672, 0.07017499953508377, 0.23419219255447388, -0.19669252634048462, -0.4917524456977844, -0.6202267408370972, 0.11113963276147842, 0.2063787877559662, -0.3730984032154083, 0.27848607301712036, 0.8214660286903381, 0.27803072333335876, -0.7079083323478699, 0.12664398550987244, 0.8148162961006165, -0.021773306652903557, -0.17966550588607788, -0.22581814229488373, 0.23609954118728638, -0.04126570001244545, 0.2159842699766159, -0.26990216970443726, 0.5304434895515442, 0.7453490495681763, 0.7837780117988586, 0.46594804525375366, 0.44644269347190857, -0.30208173394203186, -0.3733077049255371, -0.772561252117157, -1.5113699436187744, -0.9331685900688171, -0.9969483017921448, -0.023251963779330254, -0.22504346072673798, -0.6027956604957581, 0.881956934928894, -0.16859550774097443, 0.27398228645324707, -0.15288950502872467, -0.05796121805906296, 0.9013987183570862, -1.1224126815795898, -0.133318692445755, -1.3589000701904297, 0.0899745523929596, 0.14087718725204468, 0.32355889678001404, -0.3041253983974457, -0.2953968048095703, -0.1471136510372162, -0.5035877823829651, 0.0589938685297966, -0.8319661021232605, 0.6831381916999817, -0.3355492949485779, -0.45982322096824646, -0.21613527834415436, 1.097783088684082, 0.043294865638017654, 0.9500734210014343, 0.047842659056186676, -0.4829435348510742, 0.6199572086334229, -0.23846180737018585, 0.26409345865249634, 0.06692972779273987, -0.01142806839197874, 0.17578917741775513, 0.38956865668296814, -0.1469321846961975, 0.48631706833839417, -0.9713007807731628, 0.23567184805870056, 0.2562108635902405, -0.8302959203720093, -0.01328064501285553, -0.39296045899391174, -0.5228484869003296, -0.471932590007782, -0.32004839181900024, -0.7775829434394836, -0.29265210032463074, 0.7007742524147034, -0.15332746505737305, -1.196783423423767, -0.037297289818525314, -0.6005322933197021, -0.5383536219596863, 0.47078022360801697, -0.745169997215271, 0.46110597252845764, 0.24457290768623352, 0.18651318550109863, 0.3451734185218811, 0.21476180851459503, -0.0003551640547811985, 0.41402196884155273, -0.23646898567676544, -0.24197377264499664, 0.2767811715602875, 0.5213006138801575, -0.5497143268585205, 0.7371441125869751, -0.42180681228637695, 0.22225849330425262, -0.672207772731781, -0.06623558700084686, -1.0356413125991821, 0.6483408212661743, 0.5641652941703796, -0.5070450901985168, -0.00625617103651166, 0.3466498851776123, -0.4662908911705017, -0.060368143022060394, 0.32948020100593567, 0.755725622177124, -0.38722410798072815, 0.17291474342346191, 0.250347763299942, 0.6891524791717529, -0.8947102427482605, -0.42037367820739746, 0.0023005763068795204, 0.3284367620944977, 0.6169814467430115, -0.1198425367474556, 1.0081309080123901, -0.2857048809528351, -0.04825840890407562, -0.10407456755638123, 0.14432847499847412, 0.465130090713501, 1.1206893920898438, 0.8733396530151367, 1.1244527101516724, -0.5667799711227417, 0.0326089970767498, 0.9388762712478638, 0.47268006205558777, -0.16401487588882446, 0.17407552897930145, 0.14471828937530518, -0.46191543340682983, 0.36008480191230774, 0.23273956775665283, -0.48519277572631836, 0.2197141796350479, 0.5133779644966125, 0.33780980110168457, 0.06897830218076706, -1.296773076057434, -0.0034770185593515635, -0.12122217565774918, 0.6055284142494202, 0.08614809066057205, 0.08473651856184006, 0.7437217235565186, 0.10707464814186096, 0.5222691297531128, -0.12802496552467346, 0.08436215668916702, -0.0381770096719265, -0.07412464916706085, -0.38301751017570496, 0.05310196056962013, -0.41361281275749207, -0.9361184239387512, -0.5936095118522644, 0.06682875752449036, -0.2759020924568176, 0.5664113163948059, -0.3479537069797516, -0.6305413246154785, 0.5895447731018066, -0.9606727957725525, 0.12188950181007385, 0.37736770510673523, -0.43996644020080566, -0.7381924986839294, 0.14566737413406372, -0.49912402033805847, -0.513684868812561, 0.2521933317184448, -0.8861662149429321, 0.1259598284959793, 0.42168372869491577, -0.42689549922943115, -0.9428020715713501, -0.023473156616091728, -0.3515150547027588, -0.14944657683372498, 0.5650296807289124, 0.21884095668792725, 0.1131880134344101, 0.25124692916870117, -0.38923490047454834, -0.8325661420822144, -0.6242372393608093, 0.0029700661543756723, -0.34668174386024475, -0.9037829041481018, 0.0759793296456337, 0.5959579944610596, 0.037806324660778046, 0.6080698370933533, 0.023482443764805794, 0.31415319442749023, -1.5071426630020142, 0.7501559257507324, -0.5903489589691162, -0.8486753702163696, -0.19032783806324005, -0.029991649091243744, -0.1542166918516159, -0.2911585867404938, 0.48363029956817627, -0.5316745638847351, -0.49413466453552246, 0.1324649155139923, -0.024297691881656647, -0.8092396259307861, 1.2197051048278809, -0.8253565430641174, -0.09632670134305954, 1.5419011116027832, -0.4953472316265106, 0.22668825089931488, -0.8588544726371765, -0.22508254647254944, -0.328362375497818, 0.1328832507133484, -0.29364314675331116, -0.10410910099744797, 0.04494404047727585, -0.045058418065309525, -0.27423495054244995, -0.9741010069847107, -0.3464147448539734, -0.7602155208587646, -0.14558956027030945, -0.9330286383628845, -0.026894211769104004, -0.769757866859436, -0.2308891862630844, 0.21704471111297607, 1.038920283317566, 0.7155418395996094, 0.31948527693748474, -0.126051127910614, 0.4719628393650055, -0.7761451601982117, -0.3757875859737396, -0.49139562249183655, 0.164169579744339, 0.21169625222682953, -0.3599407970905304, 0.04011871665716171, -1.5120856761932373, -0.45780041813850403, 0.591465175151825, 0.9847297072410583, -1.053295612335205, -0.46284133195877075, -0.4535713195800781, -0.10135649889707565, -0.5899382829666138, -0.13660189509391785, 0.6134628653526306, -0.7352068424224854, 0.9566633701324463, 0.16000357270240784, 0.4492133855819702, -0.017578329890966415, -0.014755558222532272, -0.6960132122039795, 0.21705704927444458, 0.07774212956428528, -0.9872644543647766, -1.0005228519439697, 0.2132917195558548, 0.2657794654369354, 0.4912458658218384, 0.18989962339401245, -0.9422820210456848, 0.207975372672081, -1.0552141666412354, -0.014136928133666515, -0.40662631392478943, 0.05396876484155655, -0.4966488778591156, -0.20523595809936523, 0.061453886330127716, 0.3863648474216461, -0.2760961651802063, -0.6458227038383484, 0.20192007720470428, -0.821495532989502, 1.1495444774627686, -0.1546674370765686, -0.3906177580356598, 0.1279611587524414, -0.013833519071340561, 0.7858469486236572, 0.7491077184677124, 0.28613898158073425, 0.17990423738956451, 0.808118462562561, 0.21461361646652222, 0.30823490023612976, 0.394264280796051, -0.6036701202392578, -0.839733898639679, 0.5874558687210083, -0.004938212689012289, -0.47648414969444275, 0.2516303062438965, -0.1404118537902832, 0.7623592019081116, -0.6678725481033325, 0.07235658913850784, 0.5285434722900391, 0.18914315104484558, 0.932091236114502, -0.41821059584617615, 0.721516489982605, -0.5862423181533813, 0.487003356218338, 0.6789475083351135, 0.11123142391443253, -0.7330951690673828, 0.10052375495433807, -0.8803990483283997, -0.11330731213092804, 0.2049245983362198, -0.9219746589660645, 0.1353474259376526, 0.11273928731679916, -0.6215792298316956, -0.11452247202396393, 0.22522607445716858, 0.15291853249073029, -0.3703467845916748, 1.1976510286331177, 0.970804750919342, -0.020710796117782593, -0.6232907772064209, -0.015867095440626144, 0.4341684877872467, 0.1848931610584259, 1.0088815689086914, 0.09164948016405106, -0.07969524711370468, 0.49794018268585205, -0.13243751227855682, 0.1633855700492859, -1.1500482559204102, 0.10060141235589981, 0.5994927883148193, 0.6862295866012573, -0.27354520559310913, 0.6442779302597046, 0.33326029777526855, -0.3030586242675781, -0.4929584264755249, 0.2539076805114746, 0.026497982442378998, -0.05481059476733208, 0.9451256990432739, -0.13737612962722778, 0.0456928126513958, -0.35878050327301025, -0.141658753156662, -0.0813537985086441, 0.07947079092264175, 0.366525262594223, 0.3365878462791443, -1.023520827293396, 0.8420696258544922, 1.1168713569641113, -0.6382638812065125, -1.1678999662399292, -0.38846513628959656, -0.6933860182762146, 0.5344641208648682, -0.5323337912559509, -0.5081883072853088, 0.5033059120178223, -0.14976537227630615, -0.05498038977384567, -0.17262382805347443, -0.13276717066764832, 0.18130388855934143, -0.7576817274093628, 0.26344478130340576, -0.288455069065094, 0.5684405565261841, 0.2981897294521332, -0.23770783841609955, 0.024947447702288628, -0.7328454256057739, 0.31264734268188477, -0.5704541802406311, -0.1522127091884613, 0.5158410668373108, -0.1402425318956375, -0.013547522015869617, 0.35777801275253296, 0.12276268005371094, 0.06588035076856613, 0.16084125638008118, -0.038536906242370605, 0.6897581219673157, -0.22733823955059052, -0.6456904411315918, -0.7805142998695374, 0.2892223596572876, -0.133225217461586, 0.5947384834289551, -0.16625362634658813, -0.02278635837137699, 0.947676956653595, -0.0014395263278856874, 0.5760378837585449, -0.04724039509892464, -0.6023023128509521, -0.3947484493255615, -0.22676485776901245, 0.23887670040130615, 0.013398181647062302, -0.8026663064956665, 0.774263322353363, -0.34403154253959656, -0.4561308026313782, -0.03970634937286377, 0.6868347525596619, 0.019156236201524734, 0.10186698287725449, -0.49170273542404175, 1.1300299167633057, -0.9346732497215271, -0.5636439323425293, -0.010868878103792667, -1.0193732976913452, -0.03020460158586502, 0.8831509351730347, -0.4070710837841034, -0.723898708820343, 0.47430455684661865, -0.038386352360248566, 0.32761886715888977, 0.98088538646698, -0.28699469566345215, -0.5257729887962341, 0.2725273668766022, 0.6059300303459167, -0.09974445402622223, -0.00027706511900760233, 0.6817846298217773, -0.29639342427253723, 0.38482415676116943, 0.34050124883651733, 0.010630935430526733, -0.33240970969200134, -0.1985255479812622, 0.3346579074859619, -0.2929019629955292, -0.9175540208816528, 0.19416798651218414, 0.1597689390182495, -0.8002782464027405, 0.16646742820739746, -0.08122963458299637, -0.10308067500591278, 0.5558153390884399, -0.08617933839559555, -0.20113955438137054, 1.0947606563568115, -0.3347342312335968, -0.35031938552856445, -0.388978511095047, 0.5436469316482544, 0.3245268166065216, 0.3514455258846283, 0.6878445148468018, 0.45049795508384705, -0.019540537148714066, -1.257580280303955, 0.4778918921947479, -0.1501084268093109, -0.8416406512260437, 0.01440329011529684, -0.11107946932315826, 0.4374939203262329, -0.29134905338287354, -0.8844967484474182, 0.6689199805259705, -0.06058501452207565, 0.13200458884239197, 1.2326054573059082, 0.18294896185398102, 0.5296180248260498, -0.7291894555091858, 0.19023525714874268, -1.2594455480575562, -0.2978556156158447, 0.4277850389480591, -0.22755776345729828, -0.2436600625514984, 0.07440219074487686, -1.1805839538574219, 0.878700852394104, -0.4183414578437805, -0.3806091547012329, -0.4453274607658386, 0.24061374366283417, 0.51655513048172, 0.6239637732505798, 0.08201278746128082, -0.14072421193122864, 0.13316215574741364, -0.32522767782211304, -1.0801310539245605, -0.34536755084991455, 0.9823993444442749, 0.9883918762207031, 0.3176098167896271, 0.2024259716272354, -0.23659726977348328, -0.12747164070606232, 0.21408461034297943, -0.07979370653629303, -0.43629908561706543, -0.29675135016441345, -1.0169093608856201, -0.23486383259296417, 0.08642393350601196, 0.18922525644302368, -0.23320753872394562, 0.5438640117645264, 0.483504056930542, -1.4080369472503662, -0.251519113779068, 0.07971473783254623, 0.6771098971366882, -0.5050776600837708, 0.12047721445560455, -0.3164632320404053, 0.4555533826351166, -0.39730745553970337, -0.2523171901702881, 0.4457755982875824, 0.26590317487716675, 0.11543857306241989, 0.43194612860679626, 0.20323684811592102, 0.6126480102539062, 0.6644309163093567, 0.0507529079914093, 0.11965032666921616, 0.41048285365104675, -0.10928476601839066, 0.4023797810077667, 0.37762483954429626, -0.2884157598018646, 0.4762060344219208, 0.1539781540632248, -0.32807645201683044, 0.15750285983085632, 0.3629857003688812, -0.01600838638842106, 0.0902099460363388, -0.2902234196662903, 0.41273221373558044, -0.47815561294555664, 0.19037550687789917, -0.5355377197265625, -0.1908131092786789, 0.73625648021698, 0.8959813117980957, -0.3611001670360565, -0.35268455743789673, 0.9430528283119202, 0.05530434474349022, 0.3104035556316376, 1.514639973640442, 0.050904806703329086, -0.2645494043827057, -0.7177057266235352, 0.9101622700691223, -0.2907068133354187, -0.0944066271185875, 0.08275120705366135, 0.7441885471343994, -0.041142649948596954, 0.18745847046375275, 0.1657407581806183, 0.2878694534301758, 0.6748097538948059, -0.08887681365013123, -0.18506725132465363, -0.0995025485754013, -0.2640279233455658, -0.8174396753311157, -0.45785701274871826, 0.7995513081550598, -0.4009653329849243, -0.14523275196552277, 0.8131422400474548, 0.11522319167852402, 0.48580679297447205, 0.0313711054623127, 0.03503786772489548, -0.5570336580276489, 0.017972493544220924, 0.7130990624427795, 0.036154378205537796, -0.5073772072792053, 0.07988965511322021, 0.1677759736776352, -0.400699257850647, -0.8160853385925293, -0.1244417056441307, 0.16195328533649445, 0.824671745300293, -0.5672222375869751, 0.21638406813144684, 0.11814720928668976, -0.17343980073928833, -1.0290864706039429, 0.5772186517715454, -0.03864552825689316, 0.09307341277599335, -0.4078860580921173, -0.3798481523990631, 0.011440183036029339, -0.03757733851671219, -1.1345490217208862, -0.6953670978546143, -0.37372633814811707, 0.1954076886177063, -0.772148609161377, 0.4017421305179596, -0.588030993938446, -0.2058677226305008, 0.01153430063277483, -0.8352345824241638, -0.5103740096092224, 0.5780211687088013, -0.5135917663574219, -1.0401041507720947, 0.37511739134788513, 0.6957831978797913, 0.5832867622375488, 0.22060105204582214, -0.12810412049293518, 0.3989099860191345, 0.3666471838951111, 1.096034288406372, -0.5551925897598267, 0.09455355256795883, -0.13965754210948944, -0.015399123542010784, -0.28389686346054077, -0.9426710605621338, -0.7732354402542114, 0.43019941449165344, -0.24013011157512665, -0.41442397236824036, -0.027884546667337418, -0.518244743347168, -0.9198825359344482, 0.011866186745464802, 0.34121519327163696, -0.10453089326620102, -0.05319492891430855, -0.3628740906715393, -0.22330191731452942, -0.47516560554504395, 0.6268925070762634, 0.06085926666855812, -0.07232657074928284, 0.6819124817848206, 0.2312004119157791, -0.2421325445175171, -0.7215156555175781, 4.07224702835083, 0.6195037364959717, 0.8078701496124268, -0.657707929611206, 0.791205883026123, 0.7001462578773499, -0.5610347390174866, -0.14414279162883759, -0.032236047089099884, 0.3258889615535736, 0.1917339712381363, 0.016916275024414062, 0.28071948885917664, -0.30956631898880005, 0.6643686890602112, 1.179068922996521, -0.180433452129364, -0.0364975780248642, 0.4658467471599579, -0.9346600770950317, -0.49688413739204407, -0.14611326158046722, -0.09729284793138504, 0.6268115043640137, 0.46883270144462585, 0.1485474556684494, 0.17708365619182587, -0.23580878973007202, -0.03862716257572174, -0.23206545412540436, -0.10782057046890259, 0.0835597813129425, -0.35760438442230225, -0.3467946946620941, -0.07134305685758591, 0.2927958369255066, -0.03741190955042839, -0.29175087809562683, -0.5178648829460144, -0.45883479714393616, 0.47445911169052124, -0.1270781308412552, 0.3842109739780426, -1.2062640190124512, -0.6216550469398499, 0.691279947757721, 0.17803704738616943, -0.14641474187374115, 0.31602174043655396, -0.5898318886756897, 0.676293134689331, -0.9654735326766968, 0.3021986186504364, 0.43679001927375793, -0.636885404586792, -0.10743273049592972, -0.5683695077896118, -0.6126338243484497, 0.8010366559028625, 0.11422818899154663, 0.8612185716629028, -0.31939011812210083, -0.3844459056854248, 0.594793975353241, -0.41648733615875244, 0.9335618019104004, -0.22790862619876862, -0.3175498843193054, -0.22388039529323578, -0.653786838054657, 0.11036497354507446, -0.01948918215930462, -0.49269065260887146, 0.21945826709270477, 0.6635051965713501, 0.7805255055427551, 0.2115277498960495, 0.4937056601047516, -0.20322488248348236, -0.01508850697427988, 0.11928685009479523, -0.19063948094844818, 0.9491872787475586, -0.31629639863967896, 0.2501050531864166, 0.4804510474205017, 0.8571751713752747, -0.06487035006284714, -1.3277246952056885, 0.964745044708252, 0.549859344959259, 0.323134183883667, 0.10973542183637619, 0.5113965272903442, -0.7427640557289124 ]
{"Title": "Electrocardiographic Changes After Completion of a Triathlon", "Authors": "Hosatte-Ducassy Caroline, Correa Jos\u00e9 A., Lalonde Fran\u00e7ois, Mohindra Rohit, Marton Gregory, Chetrit Michael, Marcotte Audrey, Tournoux Fran\u00e7ois, Bridges Eileen", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objectives Given the increasing popularity of long-distance triathlon events amongst amateur athlete and the difficulty for emergency physician to address cardiovascular complaints in the context of exercise, this study aims to: - Identify the prevalence of electrocardiographic abnormalities before and after a long distance triathlon in a cohort of participants using the Seattle criteria. - Identify the acute changes that occur on their ECGs at the finish line of a long-distance triathlon. Methods This prospective observational study examines the prevalence of selected standard 12-lead ECG findings, the Seattle criteria, in asymptomatic athletes before and after the completion of a long-distance triathlon. Results Of 99 ECGs obtained prior to the race, 28 were abnormal, for a pre-race prevalence of 28.3% (95% CI (20.4, 37.8)). Of the 72 ECGs post-race, 12 were abnormal, for a post-race prevalence of 16.7% (95% CI (9.8, 26.9)). We did not observe any athletes with marked repolarization abnormalities. Common findings were increased QRS voltage significant for left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) (24 (24.2%) pre-race, 10 (14.1%) post-race), early repolarization (21 (21.2%) pre-race, 19 (26.8%) post-race) and incomplete right bundle branch block (RBBB) (8 (8.1%) pre-race, 11 (15.5%) post-race). McNemar\u2019s test showed no agreement between the ECG pre and post results (Chi-square =6.54, p = 0.01), suggesting a possible effect of the race on ECG findings. We observed a trend to normalization of athlete\u2019s ECGs with acute exercise. Conclusion Long-distance endurance exercise might acutely affect the ECGs findings in asymptomatic athletes and abnormal ECG findings were common in our cohort of athletes. Physicians providing care to long-distance athletes should interpret ECGs in this population prudently. SUMMARY BOX The acute effect of exercises on athlete\u2019s electrocardiograms has not been well studied. In our cohort of long-distance triathlon finishers, 28.3% of athletes had abnormal ECGs pre-race and 16.7% had abnormal ECGs post-race according to the Seattle Criteria. We observed a trend toward normalization of athlete\u2019s ECGs with acute exercise. Common ECGs abnormalities found in those asymptomatic athletes were left ventricular hypertrophy, early repolarization and right bundle branch block. Physicians involved in the care of athletes should be prudent when interpreting ECGs in this population.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000687"}
10.1101/2019.12.12.19014761
[ 0.24414239823818207, 0.11160089075565338, -0.009351745247840881, 0.22811363637447357, -0.9569916725158691, 0.07663413882255554, 0.3439313471317291, -0.15600624680519104, 0.7722898721694946, 0.1900816261768341, 0.44755783677101135, -0.7375029921531677, 0.4988727569580078, -0.8219695687294006, -0.2800910770893097, -0.014163598418235779, -0.2540065348148346, 0.036546483635902405, -0.3673478662967682, -0.07814853638410568, 0.476702481508255, -0.02332191728055477, -0.7605928182601929, 0.5519537925720215, -0.27720141410827637, 0.8430202007293701, -0.09625411778688431, -0.5198702812194824, 1.2467968463897705, 0.25379037857055664, -0.852594256401062, -0.8052121996879578, 0.5434378385543823, -1.412951111793518, -0.5265514850616455, 0.31793588399887085, 0.6575244069099426, 0.0997094064950943, -0.47717753052711487, -0.1799994558095932, -0.12537601590156555, -0.32436469197273254, 0.299079567193985, -1.0151749849319458, -0.12365438789129257, -0.11331001669168472, 0.15055212378501892, 0.21368451416492462, 0.3061429262161255, -0.06523717194795609, -0.46553492546081543, 0.32659438252449036, 0.21944506466388702, -0.15439759194850922, 0.40747174620628357, 0.41433870792388916, 0.5745335221290588, 0.11246971040964127, -0.9534950256347656, -0.06254441291093826, -0.009444192051887512, 0.15107089281082153, 0.6789334416389465, -1.102824330329895, 1.342431664466858, 0.6164854764938354, 0.11997425556182861, -0.4868803024291992, 0.1621178686618805, -0.48727837204933167, -0.4232497811317444, -0.20846407115459442, -0.6651611924171448, -0.7916941046714783, 0.2787052392959595, -0.7511427402496338, 0.5867356657981873, 0.07950126379728317, 0.10928917676210403, -0.12098474055528641, -0.06950628012418747, 0.3223380744457245, 0.18667294085025787, 0.20150761306285858, 0.02240546979010105, -0.23470084369182587, 0.2351078987121582, 0.9682947993278503, -0.5816017985343933, 0.991904079914093, -0.11423029005527496, 0.3843182325363159, -0.22303426265716553, 0.2983965277671814, -0.14242048561573029, 1.0141675472259521, -0.5081861615180969, -0.11414269357919693, 0.06397103518247604, -0.582189679145813, 0.5451732873916626, 0.7074224948883057, -1.3920807838439941, 0.869862973690033, -0.2534734010696411, 0.8503826856613159, 0.10549761354923248, 0.15944194793701172, -0.8771087527275085, -0.36021313071250916, 0.6087213754653931, 0.13820688426494598, -0.5425578951835632, 0.8601841330528259, 0.7175167202949524, 0.5606940388679504, -0.37011051177978516, 0.7296455502510071, -0.6639429330825806, -0.7398725748062134, 0.11260708421468735, 0.518101155757904, 0.6050902605056763, 0.08775915205478668, 0.5499485731124878, 0.2312750518321991, -0.09088768064975739, 0.7533124685287476, -0.7094963788986206, -0.16836120188236237, -0.3920077979564667, -0.3407483696937561, 0.3026679754257202, 0.38192641735076904, 0.2569587826728821, 0.07686162739992142, 0.15025296807289124, 0.5888997316360474, 0.3189455270767212, -0.8487382531166077, -0.13823798298835754, 0.2155218869447708, -1.815778374671936, 1.2643800973892212, 0.6503699421882629, 0.6787325143814087, -0.4498351216316223, -1.4343205690383911, -0.8900660276412964, 0.07031063735485077, 0.285636305809021, 0.3525654971599579, -0.08969917893409729, -0.9332294464111328, -0.3217569887638092, 1.1212091445922852, -0.23983730375766754, 0.20564055442810059, 0.17434731125831604, -0.12066631019115448, 0.20889106392860413, 0.4039742052555084, 0.04773125424981117, 0.5950584411621094, -0.6033243536949158, 0.7481293678283691, 0.4187421500682831, -0.13130484521389008, 0.3263106644153595, -0.7497527003288269, 0.4870944321155548, -0.02812996879220009, -0.6813152432441711, 0.2878579795360565, 0.19514645636081696, 0.3221603035926819, 0.35909876227378845, -0.3627721667289734, 0.446058988571167, 0.05924057960510254, 0.4845881462097168, -0.4309701919555664, -0.09074419736862183, 0.5303547978401184, -0.6050441861152649, 0.8289111256599426, -0.3565824627876282, -0.2672367990016937, -0.7913635969161987, -0.5827271938323975, -0.28235653042793274, 0.15317276120185852, -0.5777135491371155, 0.5441552996635437, -0.14026613533496857, 0.08659934252500534, -0.34233948588371277, 1.1382956504821777, 0.6025072336196899, -0.14478695392608643, -0.11601093411445618, 1.0239038467407227, -0.321500688791275, -0.06001713126897812, -0.2989375591278076, 0.5929661393165588, -0.5466344952583313, 0.5505067110061646, -1.0504871606826782, 0.4280691146850586, 0.7600374817848206, 0.22149674594402313, -0.28202250599861145, 0.1939622461795807, 0.6479842662811279, -0.08259876072406769, -0.11387456953525543, 0.25212395191192627, -0.40003424882888794, -0.05754464864730835, -0.22240234911441803, 0.07585926353931427, 0.6660592555999756, -0.2014729231595993, 0.10349181294441223, 0.5512543320655823, 1.146030068397522, 0.19184884428977966, -0.21597550809383392, -0.45577874779701233, 0.4541609287261963, 0.9426231980323792, 0.14012564718723297, 0.6503905057907104, 0.22908614575862885, 0.6719771027565002, 0.7722952365875244, 0.6136846542358398, 0.00400950014591217, 0.8863756656646729, 0.8795445561408997, 0.483379065990448, 0.3505564332008362, 0.34775233268737793, -0.1915454864501953, 0.3153330683708191, -0.4264301061630249, 0.2625041604042053, -0.4147298038005829, 0.7433575391769409, -0.28209468722343445, 0.49698352813720703, 0.08708960562944412, 0.664541482925415, -0.728286623954773, -0.6746937036514282, 0.545665442943573, 0.0718444362282753, 0.02089342661201954, -0.0700577050447464, -0.3040525019168854, -0.4242256283760071, -0.21332332491874695, 0.3379751443862915, 0.3874322474002838, 0.8321089148521423, 0.27148187160491943, 0.39217451214790344, -0.03886032477021217, -0.1795034259557724, -0.7007123827934265, -0.33288708329200745, -1.8619691133499146, -0.9782009720802307, -1.0262720584869385, -0.38854676485061646, -0.04982683062553406, -0.10848291963338852, 0.4521608352661133, 0.7653282284736633, 0.04550265893340111, -0.39394691586494446, -0.6129181385040283, 0.09140212833881378, 0.38704514503479004, 0.19018682837486267, -0.7675350904464722, -0.030774284154176712, -0.3369303345680237, 0.9198709726333618, -0.3943275809288025, -0.00514430645853281, -0.34742704033851624, -0.3633981943130493, 0.5731693506240845, -0.6535728573799133, -0.44985902309417725, -0.26633864641189575, -0.1921127289533615, -0.1652829945087433, 0.22567325830459595, 0.04861648380756378, 0.6760140657424927, -0.3782963454723358, -0.7179047465324402, 0.3295421600341797, 0.5750569105148315, 0.3936547338962555, 0.45144984126091003, 0.8512565493583679, -0.14132024347782135, 0.7123703360557556, -0.0235088299959898, -0.07805070281028748, -0.8248658776283264, 0.16353534162044525, 0.7646467089653015, -0.07059454172849655, -0.19961801171302795, -0.6101197004318237, -1.0233768224716187, -0.24004265666007996, -0.3306224048137665, -0.2742014229297638, 0.019248116761446, 0.012818669900298119, 0.32187318801879883, -1.1975951194763184, 0.3737841844558716, -0.5599786043167114, -1.243848443031311, 0.624193012714386, -0.1629461944103241, 0.2710401713848114, 0.49253377318382263, 0.09411688894033432, -0.32541030645370483, 0.0494690015912056, 0.29723846912384033, 0.26446977257728577, -0.07122904807329178, -0.41669002175331116, -0.2709238827228546, 0.38508284091949463, -0.3113861083984375, 0.14955051243305206, -0.004376810044050217, 0.20707175135612488, 0.15817248821258545, 0.024134865030646324, -0.0812378004193306, 0.0030124944169074297, 0.8192622065544128, 0.0772692859172821, -0.28252536058425903, 0.9561544060707092, -0.19236910343170166, -0.18630775809288025, 0.527753472328186, 0.2680831551551819, -0.01379147544503212, 0.7072551846504211, -0.23430725932121277, 0.04634323716163635, -0.700127899646759, -0.7983488440513611, 0.40816545486450195, -0.3214385211467743, 0.6067280173301697, -0.5627737641334534, 0.6021109819412231, 0.4510049819946289, -0.7008787989616394, 0.5382266640663147, 0.10430429875850677, 0.15119725465774536, 1.2426947355270386, 0.536343514919281, 1.7822701930999756, -1.0208827257156372, 0.1341049075126648, 0.874718189239502, 0.7539739012718201, -0.0005563981831073761, -0.13265179097652435, 0.5212960839271545, -1.0156195163726807, -0.05170496925711632, -0.275928258895874, -0.3050481677055359, 0.4178899824619293, 0.23584233224391937, -0.1533253937959671, 0.7694463729858398, -0.81871497631073, -0.4181210398674011, -0.4676775634288788, 0.32814091444015503, 0.162879079580307, -0.24777261912822723, 0.8495656251907349, -0.2742502987384796, -0.3647094666957855, -0.045297957956790924, 0.6155189275741577, -0.2114785760641098, -0.5493994951248169, -0.04261944442987442, 0.10087300837039948, -0.513627290725708, 0.31794777512550354, -0.5113043785095215, -0.1281844526529312, 0.2926887571811676, 0.9234570264816284, -0.6735559105873108, -0.9658257961273193, -0.32182347774505615, -0.10239200294017792, 0.803767740726471, 0.1350296139717102, 0.2966076135635376, -1.1079463958740234, 0.22495998442173004, -0.296316921710968, -0.04265972226858139, -0.3299283981323242, -0.6794504523277283, -0.35475149750709534, 0.5535834431648254, -1.1141111850738525, -1.1963189840316772, 0.06007302924990654, 0.10144259035587311, -0.24310246109962463, -0.1561647206544876, -0.011771670542657375, -0.6739949584007263, 0.07842320948839188, 0.03783649206161499, 0.09466782957315445, -0.2524627447128296, -0.27352556586265564, -0.212620347738266, 0.05912706255912781, 0.5800899267196655, 1.1493743658065796, 0.32926082611083984, 0.18755653500556946, -0.4291231036186218, 0.9672502875328064, -0.6847094893455505, 1.132924199104309, -0.16187889873981476, -0.6054328083992004, -0.8686043620109558, -0.5361562371253967, 0.055165018886327744, -0.13974685966968536, -0.400259792804718, -0.13116362690925598, 0.007531714625656605, 0.2892589271068573, -0.6071184277534485, -1.1224881410598755, 0.9639608263969421, -0.5494137406349182, 0.4206066429615021, 1.533706545829773, 0.4138975739479065, -0.6303701400756836, 0.06297127157449722, -0.09576069563627243, -0.8076425194740295, 0.6947715282440186, -0.0029602102003991604, 0.13731013238430023, 0.252603143453598, -0.7827747464179993, -0.3066200613975525, -0.33760640025138855, 0.7700583934783936, -0.7202706933021545, -0.8444432616233826, -0.6675351858139038, -0.002122072037309408, -0.769985020160675, 0.12428134679794312, -1.1233869791030884, -0.014924950897693634, -0.018117178231477737, -0.37458300590515137, -0.4348476827144623, -0.3314850330352783, -0.8362410664558411, -0.46929144859313965, 0.1203804686665535, 0.25860923528671265, 0.23112927377223969, 0.18362565338611603, 0.9456781148910522, -0.1775961071252823, -1.416412353515625, 0.5903792381286621, 0.8766012191772461, -0.6353693008422852, -0.16930292546749115, 0.6739246249198914, 0.4726463854312897, -0.4157024025917053, -0.46716561913490295, -0.6177361011505127, -0.7113426923751831, -0.11170889437198639, -0.3901272118091583, 0.7017996311187744, 0.05580330640077591, 0.056878600269556046, -0.6672273278236389, 0.46928784251213074, 0.1260143369436264, -1.1348952054977417, -0.6875464916229248, 0.34993845224380493, 0.531370997428894, 0.5000428557395935, -0.05997549742460251, -0.9926249384880066, -1.0044444799423218, -0.20995453000068665, 0.010660712607204914, -0.8161091804504395, -0.08200053870677948, -0.46744856238365173, 0.16309775412082672, -0.3349180221557617, 0.9305148124694824, 0.19969618320465088, 0.08620116859674454, -0.04849841818213463, -0.5094029307365417, 0.6803455948829651, -0.4633011221885681, -0.04216974228620529, -0.5766844153404236, -0.16472861170768738, 0.5046923160552979, 0.7660158276557922, 0.31645667552948, -0.9154224395751953, 0.14459888637065887, 0.06878633052110672, 0.6603845953941345, 0.41133686900138855, -0.5774193406105042, -0.35732632875442505, 0.07026490569114685, 0.030752146616578102, -0.5060150623321533, 0.03189156949520111, -1.359383225440979, -0.10721646249294281, -0.566837728023529, 0.02736176736652851, 0.01556211244314909, -1.030807614326477, 0.004983221646398306, -0.7894322872161865, 0.9060754179954529, -0.6047316193580627, 0.3795836269855499, -0.20073851943016052, -0.5043365359306335, -0.29011428356170654, 0.2939915060997009, -0.5447934865951538, -0.28983670473098755, -1.1889740228652954, -0.7644506692886353, 0.3322109878063202, 0.07274686545133591, 0.2961035966873169, 0.3051513135433197, -0.09422271698713303, 0.12606503069400787, -0.5602715611457825, 0.30624979734420776, 0.22595973312854767, 0.5211886167526245, -0.6477276086807251, -0.1189410462975502, 0.2351391464471817, 0.04674949496984482, -0.14532504975795746, 0.6889238357543945, -0.10475054383277893, -0.3200855255126953, 0.7198966145515442, -0.6387163400650024, -0.6391904950141907, 0.18344001471996307, 0.32684391736984253, 0.6857466697692871, -0.33550798892974854, -0.15379823744297028, -0.3765024244785309, -0.2874211370944977, 0.3543758988380432, 0.6169363856315613, -0.4982401728630066, 0.37988710403442383, 1.2534316778182983, 0.3719038665294647, -0.14669974148273468, 0.7607173323631287, 0.09868957847356796, 0.3446243107318878, -0.4062469005584717, -0.07850218564271927, 0.34025493264198303, -0.7675440311431885, 0.6519092917442322, 0.3674757182598114, -0.949025571346283, -0.8566370010375977, 0.27800455689430237, -0.09099473059177399, -0.1740376055240631, -0.2684449553489685, -0.3729449510574341, 0.9450068473815918, -0.019301481544971466, 0.3867608308792114, 0.11861265450716019, 0.38723161816596985, 0.3484547436237335, -0.8664188981056213, 0.13508856296539307, -0.6106141209602356, 0.5088806748390198, 1.3498953580856323, -0.006613903678953648, 0.15858525037765503, -0.03560884669423103, 0.6138470768928528, -0.07332912087440491, 0.00126119505148381, 0.04422316700220108, -0.3967832326889038, -0.34085583686828613, -0.21871629357337952, 0.9358469247817993, 0.293483704328537, 0.23715244233608246, -0.045650117099285126, 1.3412456512451172, 0.40700840950012207, -1.1625739336013794, -0.7771267294883728, 0.5442013740539551, 0.7027970552444458, 0.414758563041687, 0.40452975034713745, 0.21658490598201752, 1.1989424228668213, -0.20460224151611328, -0.20837506651878357, -0.8074527382850647, -0.2400994449853897, -0.7435773611068726, -0.337356299161911, 0.28965550661087036, -0.31689292192459106, 0.2821253836154938, 0.4741773009300232, -0.18062111735343933, -0.061750419437885284, -0.0904686450958252, 0.3522680401802063, -0.12383002042770386, -0.44236284494400024, -0.9029496908187866, 0.3401429057121277, -0.7529584765434265, -0.7919104695320129, -0.6352003812789917, -0.753866970539093, 0.36961695551872253, 1.2531639337539673, -0.643298864364624, -0.5314950346946716, 0.2523934245109558, 0.015232138335704803, -0.26378339529037476, 0.9010756015777588, -1.3464866876602173, -0.5286239385604858, -0.9827424883842468, 0.4984019696712494, 0.6699988842010498, -0.07314152270555496, 1.2030527591705322, -0.27905628085136414, 0.4099986255168915, 0.5968912839889526, -0.038755979388952255, -0.517508864402771, -0.0731455460190773, 0.19359295070171356, -0.8724284768104553, -0.3039489686489105, -0.22057242691516876, 0.38973894715309143, -1.1484135389328003, -0.21839191019535065, -0.6498889327049255, -0.10965193808078766, -0.2511165142059326, 0.5601434111595154, -0.37986868619918823, 0.6253097653388977, 0.41840001940727234, -0.019995860755443573, -0.21374502778053284, 0.5406308174133301, 0.4107811450958252, -0.17975109815597534, -0.03138858452439308, 0.23965692520141602, 0.2931865155696869, -0.7321054935455322, 0.5876755714416504, 0.19126512110233307, -0.19466076791286469, -0.053185101598501205, 0.00023335267906077206, -0.0067993151023983955, 0.2726410925388336, -0.5293538570404053, 0.0853978767991066, 0.26242488622665405, -0.04319928586483002, 0.32826897501945496, 0.47867268323898315, -0.7404206395149231, -1.1348621845245361, -0.6802942156791687, -0.8507128357887268, -0.7297567129135132, 0.8476969599723816, -0.5204038023948669, 0.9155426025390625, -0.5153325796127319, -0.5960670709609985, 0.45222586393356323, 0.12503525614738464, 0.6940458416938782, -0.3673561215400696, 0.5901698470115662, 0.106431744992733, 0.20136943459510803, 0.23314230144023895, -0.1704912781715393, 0.563780665397644, -0.05196601524949074, -0.5354132056236267, -0.35063961148262024, -0.3694097697734833, -0.03861916437745094, 0.12515796720981598, -0.7092604041099548, -0.08348223567008972, 0.010792135260999203, 0.4719521701335907, -0.5183680057525635, -0.058583252131938934, -0.015573916025459766, -0.5395616888999939, 0.17401739954948425, -0.8857739567756653, 0.15568526089191437, 0.000987395877018571, 0.21538090705871582, 0.36344626545906067, -0.5339370369911194, -0.49492159485816956, -0.020720623433589935, 0.5404370427131653, -0.48667219281196594, 1.2767192125320435, -0.27426525950431824, 0.17666791379451752, -0.2539048492908478, -0.7025625705718994, 0.4050537645816803, 0.5764748454093933, -0.07272491604089737, -0.42123836278915405, -0.24897730350494385, 0.1029503121972084, 1.158048391342163, 0.8495698571205139, -0.774538516998291, 0.431099534034729, 0.3880578279495239, 0.6824068427085876, 0.3203330636024475, -0.042242344468832016, 0.2397986799478531, 0.5880050659179688, -0.6613057255744934, 0.2603694200515747, -0.4406498670578003, 0.21539321541786194, 0.14400865137577057, -0.3411691188812256, 0.3013570010662079, -0.6512187123298645, -0.13379321992397308, -0.026025066152215004, 0.24721387028694153, 1.29232656955719, -0.22578474879264832, 0.6432576775550842, 0.08895520865917206, 0.3560534417629242, -0.21531474590301514, 0.6003740429878235, 0.7726621627807617, -0.3910941481590271, -0.26564788818359375, -0.20130819082260132, 0.22910937666893005, -0.7453978061676025, 0.10923972725868225, 0.3832460641860962, -0.35122010111808777, -0.12099741399288177, 0.8386300206184387, 0.010017088614404202, -0.19533121585845947, 0.5251219868659973, -0.19557371735572815, -0.43388351798057556, 0.06572984158992767, 0.1962900161743164, -0.5590416789054871, -0.49175918102264404, 0.9311612248420715, -0.5831244587898254, 0.41314372420310974, 0.4733226001262665, 0.5231332778930664, 1.0738211870193481, 0.21271534264087677, -0.047448769211769104, -0.5492163896560669, 0.6108358502388, 1.1006290912628174, 0.14726199209690094, -0.1272311508655548, 0.17407068610191345, -0.11918475478887558, -0.13171418011188507, -0.5586762428283691, 0.02042059227824211, 0.34474048018455505, -0.6041406393051147, -0.4508640468120575, 0.45325979590415955, -0.5584391355514526, -0.3710241913795471, -0.26636818051338196, -0.4942808747291565, 0.7265039086341858, -0.13153889775276184, -0.4510895609855652, 0.41957923769950867, 0.4237728416919708, -0.12137410044670105, 0.007779689971357584, -0.03886425867676735, -0.2801192104816437, -0.42384976148605347, -0.8447852730751038, 0.6793603897094727, -0.10490211844444275, 0.4657243490219116, -0.8481812477111816, -1.6506524085998535, -0.14529159665107727, -0.0976782888174057, 0.42329323291778564, -0.4581313133239746, -0.09604069590568542, 0.21547658741474152, 0.8085664510726929, -0.0053411927074193954, 0.05550699681043625, 0.3270888030529022, -0.3001779019832611, 0.575566828250885, -0.07618369907140732, 0.4947367310523987, 0.014331907033920288, 0.7610011100769043, -0.24133896827697754, -0.2074231058359146, -0.08998201787471771, 0.14051750302314758, 0.019279571250081062, -1.0781047344207764, 0.28735464811325073, -0.6692165732383728, -0.4280696213245392, 0.32667240500450134, 1.0465458631515503, -0.28777748346328735, -0.482211709022522, -0.5849956274032593, 0.5054147243499756, -0.257314532995224, 0.5429194569587708, -0.3846602141857147, -0.2209264039993286, 0.5990198850631714, 0.04990328475832939, 0.2730700969696045, -0.8968045711517334, 3.913161039352417, 1.4484575986862183, 0.3297255039215088, 0.021324701607227325, 0.24392330646514893, 0.43666431307792664, 0.710530698299408, -0.09619923681020737, 0.2927827835083008, -0.18633651733398438, -0.10595755279064178, 0.43065929412841797, 0.3290308117866516, 0.08636432886123657, 0.6641280651092529, 0.41882774233818054, -1.749919056892395, 0.17222648859024048, 0.37143105268478394, -0.8941205143928528, -1.362555980682373, 0.4093635678291321, -0.29974764585494995, -0.07072806358337402, 0.28098005056381226, -0.02590029127895832, -0.378427118062973, 0.5513535737991333, -0.3367486596107483, -0.9755881428718567, -0.22261764109134674, -0.16453351080417633, 0.33128437399864197, -0.18998605012893677, 0.09457080066204071, 0.3677577078342438, 0.32740339636802673, 0.21496357023715973, 0.021924737840890884, 0.3086409568786621, 0.4805462062358856, -0.9620694518089294, -0.22774727642536163, -0.09758906811475754, -0.17461475729942322, 0.03434645012021065, -0.352253794670105, -0.191513329744339, -0.03682982549071312, -0.025163793936371803, 0.74383944272995, -1.077013373374939, 0.3143923878669739, -0.0639011561870575, -0.6693897247314453, -0.11395968496799469, -0.36752253770828247, -1.0379233360290527, -0.37327662110328674, 0.6114312410354614, 0.9249197244644165, -0.004853238817304373, -0.1801595836877823, 0.35731565952301025, 0.37402400374412537, 0.7481335401535034, -0.21779078245162964, 0.4418242871761322, -0.3942698836326599, -0.5723149180412292, -0.2787107229232788, -0.1901865154504776, -0.04695560410618782, -0.18253140151500702, 0.6926513910293579, 0.028792820870876312, -1.029248833656311, 0.9984386563301086, -0.5146949291229248, -0.6291077733039856, 0.78264981508255, 0.2526007294654846, -0.07576104998588562, -0.4843584895133972, 0.3727412521839142, 0.599322497844696, -0.9314984083175659, -0.0012409328483045101, -0.9480242729187012, 0.5440294146537781, -0.31812784075737, -0.7084167003631592, 0.284626841545105, 0.11042352765798569, -0.38596516847610474 ]
{"Title": "A genome-wide association study of polycystic ovary syndrome identified from electronic health records", "Authors": "Zhang Yanfei, Ho Kevin, Keaton Jacob M., Hartzel Dustin N., Day Felix, Justice Anne E., Josyula Navya S., Pendergrass Sarah A., Actkins Ky\u2019Era, Davis Lea K., Velez Edwards Digna R., Holohan Brody, Ramirez Andrea, Stanaway Ian B., Crosslin David R., Jarvik Gail P., Sleiman Patrick, Hakonarson Hakon, Williams Marc S., Michael Lee Ming Ta", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) is the most common endocrine disorder affecting women of reproductive age. Previous studies have identified genetic variants associated with PCOS identified by different diagnostic criteria. The Rotterdam Criteria is the broadest and able to identify the most PCOS cases. Objectives To identify novel associated genetic variants, we extracted PCOS cases and controls from the electronic health records (EHR) based on the Rotterdam Criteria and performed a genome-wide association study (GWAS). Study Design We developed a PCOS phenotyping algorithm based on the Rotterdam criteria and applied it to three EHR-linked biobanks to identify cases and controls for genetic study. In discovery phase, we performed individual GWAS using the Geisinger\u2019s MyCode and the eMERGE cohorts, which were then meta-analyzed. We attempted validation of the significantly association loci (P<1\u00d710 \u22126 ) in the BioVU cohort. All association analyses used logistic regression, assuming an additive genetic model, and adjusted for principal components to control for population stratification. An inverse-variance fixed effect model was adopted for meta-analyses. Additionally, we examined the top variants to evaluate their associations with each criterion in the phenotyping algorithm. We used STRING to identify protein-protein interaction network. Results We identified 2,995 PCOS cases and 53,599 controls in total (2,742cases and 51,438 controls from the discovery phase; 253 cases and 2,161 controls in the validation phase). GWAS identified one novel genome-wide significant variant rs17186366 (OR=1.37 [1.23,1.54], P=2.8\u00d710 \u22128 ) located near SOD2 . Additionally, two loci with suggestive association were also identified: rs113168128 (OR=1.72 [1.42,2.10], P=5.2 x10 \u22128 ), an intronic variant of ERBB4 that is independent from the previously published variants, and rs144248326 (OR=2.13 [1.52,2.86], P=8.45\u00d710 \u22127 ), a novel intronic variant in WWTR1 . In the further association tests of the top 3 SNPs with each criterion in the PCOS algorithm, we found that rs17186366 was associated with polycystic and hyperandrogenism, while rs11316812 and rs144248326 were mainly associated with oligomenorrhea or infertility. Besides ERBB4, we also validated the association with DENND1A1 . Conclusion Through a discovery-validation GWAS on PCOS cases and controls identified from EHR using an algorithm based on Rotterdam criteria, we identified and validated a novel association with variants within ERBB4 . We also identified novel associations nearby SOD2 and WWTR1 . These results suggest the eGFR and Hippo pathways in the disease etiology. With previously identified PCOS-associated loci YAP1 , the ERBB4-YAP1-WWTR1 network implicates the epidermal growth factor receptor and the Hippo pathway in the multifactorial etiology of PCOS.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.12.19014761"}
10.1101/19002048
[ -0.2645043134689331, 0.5461006164550781, -0.09427649527788162, 0.6689943075180054, 0.084017813205719, -0.5102816820144653, 0.2801104187965393, 0.3861597180366516, 0.5522022247314453, 0.6984277963638306, -0.14739279448986053, -0.987318217754364, -0.1367231160402298, -0.29619982838630676, 0.4023749530315399, -0.34263312816619873, -1.0009897947311401, 0.07944738864898682, -0.3654249906539917, 0.00957247894257307, 0.6416761875152588, 0.9326222538948059, -0.5175489187240601, 0.3136803209781647, -0.2009977251291275, 0.5514826774597168, 0.5837993025779724, 0.3443739712238312, 1.3862797021865845, 0.28427770733833313, -0.2996472716331482, -0.5781090259552002, 0.3542822599411011, -0.7421128153800964, 0.35554444789886475, 0.30126306414604187, 0.4973496198654175, -0.7999602556228638, -0.21004430949687958, -0.0679057389497757, 0.2674544155597687, 0.04001550003886223, 0.6339717507362366, 0.039157502353191376, -1.0152825117111206, 0.3454347252845764, -0.9023259282112122, -0.9231212735176086, -0.0838780626654625, -0.314797043800354, -0.036948561668395996, -0.6930893659591675, -0.03954216465353966, 0.6426591873168945, 0.425610214471817, -0.2443380057811737, 0.27010923624038696, -0.03397823125123978, 0.0663042813539505, 0.48833996057510376, 0.24274641275405884, 0.21782870590686798, 0.20340685546398163, -1.6435937881469727, 0.5075392723083496, 0.40132880210876465, -0.11200768500566483, 0.03964719921350479, -0.397859126329422, -0.043197326362133026, -0.6751896739006042, -0.8662565350532532, -0.7319603562355042, -0.2759483754634857, -0.446961909532547, -0.14345374703407288, 0.1753493994474411, 0.19914166629314423, 0.37744390964508057, -0.6528795957565308, 0.23443323373794556, 0.8628857731819153, 0.107545405626297, 0.012265115976333618, -0.532568097114563, 0.2648210823535919, 0.23802149295806885, 0.40430670976638794, 0.45880410075187683, 0.18073584139347076, 0.013946414925158024, 0.17463357746601105, -0.3524879515171051, 0.31963691115379333, -0.017814144492149353, 0.8996903300285339, -0.23899321258068085, 0.24430014193058014, -0.2597096562385559, -0.7503424882888794, 1.410082459449768, 0.11128946393728256, -0.16284777224063873, 0.9057978391647339, -0.6879439353942871, 0.6022672057151794, 0.9279022812843323, -0.1821671724319458, 0.08456259965896606, -1.5987392663955688, 0.07091899961233139, -0.40799665451049805, -0.5042068958282471, 0.1718076914548874, 0.1586923748254776, 0.7507894039154053, 0.10746685415506363, 0.8321086764335632, -1.5008548498153687, 0.3649595379829407, -0.16161808371543884, -0.06464087218046188, 0.4650290012359619, -0.5327196717262268, 0.5476160049438477, -0.2427210509777069, -0.16989976167678833, 0.5419589281082153, -1.1958773136138916, 0.416277140378952, 0.5822180509567261, -0.3671990633010864, 0.10590767860412598, -0.28478285670280457, -0.7383111119270325, 0.6200121641159058, 0.3267678916454315, 1.1472229957580566, 0.36977362632751465, -0.34626054763793945, 0.173984095454216, 0.8095571994781494, -0.16291742026805878, 1.344476580619812, 0.19250749051570892, 0.9018828868865967, -0.9809228777885437, -1.0202960968017578, -0.009859710931777954, -0.19938795268535614, 0.19850212335586548, 0.5312929749488831, -0.1577511429786682, 0.00470148166641593, -0.4113657772541046, -0.1059098094701767, 0.22410285472869873, 0.07520074397325516, -0.267194926738739, 0.05438670516014099, -1.2615500688552856, -0.4065892994403839, -0.38231152296066284, 0.8646143674850464, -0.476124107837677, 0.5926907062530518, -0.6895788908004761, 0.3211789131164551, 0.04176239296793938, -0.6840778589248657, 0.3022792935371399, 0.18086549639701843, -0.32392483949661255, -0.06826484203338623, 0.46480703353881836, 0.7286605834960938, 0.7829201221466064, 0.17644348740577698, 0.14509789645671844, 0.5103333592414856, -0.14050394296646118, 0.45296376943588257, -0.2458646446466446, 0.7436689734458923, 0.13865980505943298, 0.07026933878660202, -1.2499866485595703, -1.7524951696395874, -0.46938803791999817, -0.6616433262825012, -0.44742268323898315, 0.19892728328704834, -0.682231068611145, 0.9436420798301697, 0.1225806474685669, 0.4405525326728821, -0.13142767548561096, 0.3601783215999603, 0.3257714807987213, -0.7452232837677002, -0.63669753074646, 0.1437268853187561, -0.31513711810112, 0.3514730930328369, -0.8969441056251526, 0.6425630450248718, 0.3099674880504608, 1.39812433719635, -0.7792900204658508, 0.6479631066322327, 1.1758543252944946, 0.13238836824893951, -0.303061842918396, -0.8047732710838318, 0.8981395363807678, -0.7429599165916443, -0.02431066334247589, 0.7155742049217224, -0.46143588423728943, 0.08270803093910217, 0.18427208065986633, -0.7912423014640808, -0.21970681846141815, -0.28857657313346863, 0.020889654755592346, -0.4570462703704834, 0.7094811797142029, 0.7144811749458313, -0.31113994121551514, -0.2167387157678604, 0.5804976224899292, 0.3181772530078888, 0.6045640707015991, 0.9164735078811646, 1.5037407875061035, 0.5501900911331177, 0.20556405186653137, 0.7968229055404663, 0.2145182192325592, 0.7924498319625854, 1.1627496480941772, 0.3319394290447235, 0.34563112258911133, 0.1030551940202713, -0.4066580832004547, 0.3070123791694641, -0.5335612297058105, 0.08276071399450302, 0.33270999789237976, -0.12709063291549683, -0.2820901870727539, 1.0695489645004272, 0.672084629535675, 0.8411722183227539, -1.0279383659362793, 0.11498910933732986, 0.287824422121048, 0.4118449091911316, 0.21259303390979767, -0.46294939517974854, -0.45553267002105713, 0.06405270844697952, 0.5328865051269531, -0.04247281700372696, -0.031572066247463226, 0.12467090040445328, -0.24892613291740417, 0.700941264629364, -0.09200634062290192, 0.3873358368873596, -1.0302445888519287, -0.4491442143917084, -0.8497058153152466, -0.4900895357131958, -0.2554205060005188, 0.5637932419776917, -0.03623483330011368, -0.4615071713924408, -0.07064101845026016, 0.9499490261077881, 0.002190221333876252, -0.3936983346939087, 0.7956897020339966, 0.6382454037666321, 0.5738937258720398, 0.4431455135345459, -0.4183647632598877, 0.43371379375457764, -0.054290998727083206, 0.9972608685493469, -0.4161283075809479, -0.7238174080848694, -0.3801969885826111, -0.09399593621492386, 0.5604916214942932, -0.723275899887085, 0.10037300735712051, -0.15195836126804352, -0.09959632158279419, -0.9471669793128967, 1.096082329750061, -0.5970990657806396, -0.6084567904472351, -0.06772059947252274, -0.9849556684494019, 0.45920538902282715, 0.7759360671043396, 0.27327442169189453, 0.5951478481292725, 0.2943635880947113, -0.025197280570864677, 0.0038638520054519176, 0.0833277553319931, 0.14343172311782837, -0.7705590724945068, 0.5361376404762268, 0.367180734872818, -0.10433708131313324, 0.24322474002838135, -0.0834427922964096, -1.1343272924423218, -0.7450219988822937, 0.9019042253494263, -0.2612057030200958, -0.5230993628501892, -0.3107822835445404, 0.7280851006507874, -1.0317503213882446, 0.8664023876190186, -1.2866261005401611, -0.7068158984184265, 0.1621839553117752, -0.852676510810852, 0.5340760946273804, -0.4077954888343811, -0.2906852960586548, -0.7474322319030762, -0.3140709102153778, 0.5638017654418945, 0.8622409701347351, 0.8021300435066223, -0.6646847724914551, 0.05090644583106041, 0.36182674765586853, 0.4904220402240753, 0.614496648311615, -0.8454681634902954, -0.7749786376953125, 0.11828429251909256, -0.3278057873249054, 0.15085601806640625, -0.07662135362625122, 0.6036278009414673, -0.1074589416384697, 0.17204216122627258, 0.7878750562667847, -0.20843298733234406, -0.3054814338684082, 0.2697824537754059, -0.11743093281984329, -0.46442529559135437, 0.8086391091346741, -0.7770015001296997, -0.050783418118953705, -0.2959595322608948, -0.2722969651222229, 0.48498088121414185, 0.07308061420917511, 0.7904732823371887, -1.1182655096054077, 1.2063606977462769, 0.029632670804858208, 0.07643719017505646, 0.3316206634044647, 0.06757424771785736, -0.12657895684242249, 1.0668275356292725, 0.6016545295715332, 1.267961859703064, -1.1023917198181152, 0.334396630525589, 0.20738042891025543, 1.8599634170532227, 0.11183451861143112, 0.5786525011062622, 0.019547777250409126, -0.6932446956634521, -0.3041462302207947, 0.12396567314863205, -1.238464117050171, -0.018195219337940216, 0.22184613347053528, -0.15207113325595856, -0.48928943276405334, -0.8310042023658752, -0.40236133337020874, 0.4594801664352417, 0.21836191415786743, 0.32612043619155884, -1.0874377489089966, 0.5284417867660522, -0.04232407733798027, 0.6264049410820007, -0.147878959774971, 0.6964563727378845, -0.17570781707763672, 0.013299061916768551, 0.3350754380226135, 0.3916471004486084, -1.042239785194397, -0.1831052601337433, -0.5501355528831482, -0.4975830614566803, -0.22561457753181458, 0.6209346652030945, 0.6113632917404175, -0.8822581768035889, -0.4446277618408203, -0.11691594123840332, 0.7318921089172363, -0.28098613023757935, 0.575014054775238, -0.5296111106872559, 0.10164950788021088, 0.4269517660140991, 0.01807190105319023, 0.42305517196655273, -0.40738266706466675, 1.050101637840271, 1.0102829933166504, -0.6685423851013184, -1.290677547454834, -0.15904788672924042, -0.3309386968612671, -0.4768844246864319, 0.21489036083221436, -0.06848903745412827, -0.6253824234008789, -0.04969898983836174, -0.06114717572927475, -0.17664389312267303, 0.02481803670525551, 0.12199030816555023, 0.5785885453224182, 0.46913328766822815, 0.02126500941812992, -0.2628009021282196, -0.24988335371017456, 0.8447352051734924, -0.2638223171234131, 0.11268088221549988, -0.4228871464729309, 0.6581029295921326, -0.049640998244285583, -0.6559500098228455, -0.04981791228055954, 0.21969570219516754, -0.3447178602218628, -0.0807986781001091, -0.7197583317756653, 0.1333639919757843, 0.36643069982528687, 0.18476784229278564, 0.4194507896900177, -0.4420154094696045, 0.595088005065918, -0.7482423782348633, -0.334079384803772, 0.6283820271492004, 0.13838507235050201, -0.2783927917480469, -0.10948553681373596, -0.7891449928283691, -0.938992440700531, 0.641602635383606, 0.1576491892337799, 0.5439411997795105, -0.13178126513957977, -0.5123175382614136, 0.32946065068244934, 0.19057443737983704, -0.20895513892173767, -0.982148289680481, -0.4144560694694519, -0.28913015127182007, -1.012218952178955, -0.21914654970169067, -1.0427792072296143, -0.5080883502960205, 0.6359408497810364, -0.08781678974628448, -1.043961524963379, -0.19216129183769226, 0.03506368026137352, -0.2902173399925232, -0.8418477773666382, -0.5326321125030518, -0.4380870461463928, -0.9760972857475281, 0.2801102101802826, 0.7144889235496521, -0.7729887962341309, -0.6415696740150452, -0.16286452114582062, 0.5257503390312195, -0.441435843706131, -0.4728986620903015, 0.3353981375694275, -0.5256162881851196, -0.36976033449172974, -0.6791243553161621, 0.05109179764986038, -1.6370344161987305, 0.25739410519599915, -0.21086643636226654, -0.00256452988833189, -0.1570012867450714, -0.16154128313064575, -0.50970458984375, 0.18161793053150177, 0.6488717198371887, -0.5747636556625366, 0.09543577581644058, 0.3442418873310089, -0.03940635547041893, 0.440220445394516, -0.31455159187316895, -1.0436164140701294, -0.6651837825775146, -1.0115138292312622, 0.5196629166603088, -0.6422536373138428, -0.044244762510061264, -0.047944534569978714, -0.2226220667362213, 0.36840689182281494, 0.739700973033905, 0.5071238279342651, 0.45624491572380066, 0.3825596570968628, 0.025373071432113647, 0.09316917508840561, 0.2205069214105606, -0.34766635298728943, 0.10383213311433792, -0.11103933304548264, 0.6508715748786926, 1.0015982389450073, 0.39585191011428833, 0.06469827145338058, -0.041073672473430634, 0.40393394231796265, 0.13564881682395935, -0.36408135294914246, -0.3196796178817749, -0.0031170574948191643, -0.2792742848396301, 1.0147786140441895, -0.5017807483673096, -0.432442843914032, -1.2212557792663574, 0.720698356628418, -0.5260985493659973, -0.02809816598892212, -0.14856678247451782, 0.22729460895061493, 0.24366495013237, -0.06288876384496689, 1.3910094499588013, -0.4443221390247345, 0.06923194974660873, 0.1338299959897995, 0.2228797972202301, 0.23404578864574432, 0.1457941085100174, -0.4588627815246582, -0.37326550483703613, -0.37949156761169434, -0.3630010783672333, 0.3752720057964325, 0.2504640519618988, 0.27390816807746887, -0.16819632053375244, -0.6945027709007263, -0.14659492671489716, -0.6576259732246399, 1.1866284608840942, 0.9808678030967712, -0.7406585812568665, -0.11180900037288666, 0.3779893219470978, 0.28365015983581543, -0.12297839671373367, -0.001388224889524281, 0.0997079536318779, -0.3701029419898987, -0.42519187927246094, 0.02347686141729355, -0.5856415629386902, -0.417174756526947, 0.16836324334144592, 0.1342988759279251, 0.6940078735351562, -0.13558532297611237, 0.5463391542434692, 0.021685749292373657, -0.36351507902145386, -0.21215085685253143, 0.294951468706131, -0.2389066070318222, 1.2542169094085693, 1.0639848709106445, -0.2954373359680176, -0.2358565628528595, 1.147825837135315, -0.08860445022583008, 0.3240758776664734, 0.2627198398113251, 0.07986125349998474, 0.6182602643966675, -1.3514074087142944, 0.3737953305244446, 0.06351952254772186, -0.5791236162185669, -0.3909231722354889, -0.09525390714406967, -0.6489219069480896, 0.9672141671180725, -0.18772298097610474, -0.4279463291168213, 0.3549377918243408, 0.037561215460300446, 0.07295794785022736, 0.05437709018588066, -0.08561550825834274, -0.5714263916015625, -0.036950595676898956, 0.03883962333202362, -0.8397649526596069, 0.10529585927724838, 1.1777894496917725, -0.22559498250484467, 0.0510849803686142, 0.8460469841957092, -0.12481022626161575, 0.5656630992889404, -0.104668989777565, 0.5742719769477844, -1.0199246406555176, -0.7115877270698547, -0.6909553408622742, -0.4261610805988312, 0.6403267979621887, 0.11072704941034317, -0.37090685963630676, -0.2911529541015625, -0.7878864407539368, -0.7947225570678711, -0.8829156160354614, -0.11586055904626846, -0.16620296239852905, 0.7127547860145569, -0.2559785544872284, 0.39760085940361023, 0.9438869953155518, -0.07378868758678436, 0.42252612113952637, -1.0304597616195679, -0.13663868606090546, -0.9175016283988953, -1.3419663906097412, -0.6373518705368042, -0.7213711738586426, 0.22122617065906525, 0.6844255924224854, -0.04895547777414322, -1.3210623264312744, -0.6480444669723511, 1.0699336528778076, 0.08411990851163864, 0.3236177861690521, -0.44040149450302124, 0.13695365190505981, -0.1450316309928894, -0.23177875578403473, -0.12368439882993698, -0.9159717559814453, -0.0793045312166214, 0.9367465376853943, 0.1174607202410698, 0.4524328410625458, 0.2281406819820404, 0.15376494824886322, 0.2855386435985565, 0.09988461434841156, 0.18056033551692963, -0.6027485728263855, 0.6039041876792908, 0.42265769839286804, 0.2433011680841446, -0.003902082797139883, 1.0902689695358276, -0.05506123602390289, 0.6135258674621582, 0.17955969274044037, -0.3370828628540039, -0.1245553195476532, 0.5411897301673889, 0.18432751297950745, -0.3556666374206543, -0.9066541790962219, -0.47117170691490173, 0.4448978304862976, -0.5577380657196045, -0.7738710641860962, -0.14926351606845856, -0.06473364681005478, -0.40021267533302307, -0.7129613161087036, 0.3947552442550659, 0.9799915552139282, 0.38508033752441406, 1.1583774089813232, -0.014278646558523178, 1.4826828241348267, 0.5920016169548035, 0.20209144055843353, 0.022881947457790375, 0.8616499900817871, -0.47565412521362305, -0.7318310141563416, 0.013051332905888557, 0.2374727427959442, -0.3128233850002289, 1.407367467880249, -0.7075828909873962, -0.458560049533844, -0.1185799166560173, -0.160553440451622, 0.037739772349596024, 0.8552255630493164, 0.014336182735860348, -0.012013735249638557, 0.15205910801887512, -0.3548627197742462, -0.4603796899318695, -0.7965368628501892, -0.9778461456298828, -0.8342752456665039, 0.43415701389312744, -0.9035692811012268, -0.3341061770915985, -0.05597459897398949, 0.39012742042541504, 0.8689543008804321, 0.0035009407438337803, 0.32990163564682007, -0.35336005687713623, -0.22911426424980164, 0.044845711439847946, 0.5399744510650635, 0.7610324621200562, -0.1978689730167389, 0.6360097527503967, 0.12675996124744415, -0.2886204719543457, -1.150748610496521, 0.6232672929763794, 0.7605178356170654, 0.022591622546315193, -0.3602084219455719, -0.8996649384498596, -0.453839510679245, 0.037666212767362595, -0.12166965752840042, 0.18944264948368073, 0.12132687866687775, -0.33105072379112244, -0.34500622749328613, 0.022113433107733727, 0.43124985694885254, -0.6039525866508484, -0.23097121715545654, 0.2322273552417755, -1.5550529956817627, -0.13392125070095062, 0.8700318932533264, 1.097346544265747, 0.13942813873291016, 0.5039243102073669, -0.5957791209220886, 0.19480803608894348, 0.029641292989253998, 0.24081292748451233, 0.5645876526832581, 0.6755228042602539, 0.5399068593978882, 0.4121517539024353, 0.3909229636192322, 0.3818989098072052, 0.7872816324234009, 0.18599538505077362, 0.8142833709716797, 0.4387845993041992, 0.41882628202438354, 0.1991606056690216, -0.1989974081516266, -0.7424135208129883, 0.674807071685791, -0.11811140179634094, -0.5616016387939453, -0.24494940042495728, 0.024509355425834656, 0.16419725120067596, -0.02821478247642517, -0.5542200207710266, 0.28544288873672485, -1.0194804668426514, -0.18064743280410767, -0.23950806260108948, 0.2453765720129013, 0.41605618596076965, -0.09341591596603394, 0.427376389503479, 0.10514748096466064, 0.8179580569267273, -0.49171316623687744, 0.17245414853096008, 0.7761045694351196, -0.5504664778709412, -0.7090308666229248, -0.6109420657157898, 0.6111565828323364, -0.004162266384810209, -0.6863797903060913, 0.06291835755109787, 0.4471830427646637, -0.10524987429380417, 0.9989644289016724, -0.2298586219549179, 0.4821295738220215, 1.2846145629882812, -0.7821959853172302, -0.6799651384353638, -0.334849089384079, 0.2919410169124603, -0.2931756377220154, -0.695547342300415, 1.0479462146759033, -0.14457762241363525, 0.13657130300998688, -0.2199569046497345, -0.6640729308128357, 0.3912665843963623, 0.11478644609451294, 0.9921781420707703, -0.49408528208732605, 0.7607343792915344, 0.7023545503616333, -0.30614492297172546, 0.2975035309791565, -1.0263729095458984, 0.0361933633685112, -0.42647796869277954, -0.47785720229148865, 0.08551289141178131, 0.5442736744880676, -0.2635290026664734, -0.37911713123321533, 0.889759361743927, -0.07581736892461777, -0.4570501446723938, -0.4914075434207916, -0.45074740052223206, -0.45261743664741516, -0.1656290590763092, -0.05777914449572563, -0.012974842451512814, -0.3060193359851837, -0.15208376944065094, -0.18306861817836761, -0.36398831009864807, 0.07777303457260132, 0.10068243741989136, -0.16633345186710358, 0.5062391757965088, -0.15686377882957458, -0.6203784942626953, 0.014548554085195065, -1.0243868827819824, -0.517633318901062, -0.2158728986978531, 0.012635726481676102, -1.129390001296997, -0.12062665820121765, 0.14282768964767456, 0.5633866190910339, -0.1876576542854309, -0.44059449434280396, -0.12258946895599365, 0.9311108589172363, 1.1975942850112915, -0.5417641401290894, 0.7286181449890137, -0.08899392932653427, -0.4276691973209381, 0.10752305388450623, -0.18708540499210358, -0.5068936347961426, -0.4910411834716797, -0.13926075398921967, -0.5089974999427795, 0.18702340126037598, 0.26289188861846924, -1.075372338294983, 0.048512447625398636, 0.27086150646209717, -0.5169767737388611, 0.05052786320447922, -0.6226846575737, -0.8127869367599487, -0.7088909149169922, 1.1816166639328003, -0.7892042994499207, 0.11033018678426743, 0.17112989723682404, 0.45891857147216797, 0.597183346748352, -0.5780794024467468, 3.6673543453216553, 0.8742355108261108, 0.4552183747291565, -0.14240923523902893, 0.7566120624542236, 0.9539026618003845, 1.390311360359192, -0.05832623690366745, 0.5473493933677673, 0.8896709084510803, -0.723310112953186, -0.4254796802997589, 0.2457193285226822, -0.5269505977630615, 0.6305765509605408, 0.8671839833259583, -0.9401141405105591, -0.3330169916152954, -0.15625311434268951, -0.5692883133888245, -0.09494131058454514, -0.7404555082321167, 0.6342580914497375, 0.3667205274105072, 0.18652912974357605, 0.5015009641647339, 0.018425170332193375, -0.43751367926597595, 0.29728254675865173, -0.536485493183136, -0.4210744798183441, -0.8615796566009521, 0.9650763869285583, -0.4815957844257355, -0.41799396276474, 0.18326254189014435, 0.17759713530540466, -0.7434484362602234, -0.024871138855814934, 0.8206543326377869, -0.37357982993125916, -0.5822534561157227, -0.34707796573638916, -0.49279242753982544, -0.2717597186565399, 1.1118756532669067, -0.7018154859542847, -0.03370431065559387, 0.08645100146532059, -0.30382606387138367, 0.8078334331512451, -0.9324709177017212, 0.8204733729362488, 0.25670772790908813, -0.6117380857467651, 0.12641628086566925, -0.32849884033203125, -0.19929106533527374, 0.8998886942863464, 0.2649794816970825, 0.7158374786376953, 0.13632002472877502, -0.530508816242218, -0.2748817205429077, 0.4757845401763916, 0.9074211716651917, 0.5113988518714905, -0.7594846487045288, -0.4391152560710907, -0.37774133682250977, -0.1163499504327774, -0.3577102720737457, -0.25072580575942993, -0.4597276449203491, 0.32933491468429565, 0.3598303198814392, -0.7357370257377625, 0.45672228932380676, -1.1774938106536865, -0.7931997776031494, -0.258741557598114, -0.9165843725204468, 0.2453540712594986, -0.35715213418006897, 0.040126971900463104, 1.1460424661636353, -0.4857632517814636, -0.30021679401397705, -0.8636143803596497, 0.5546287894248962, 0.6905890107154846, -0.1969270259141922, -0.30109158158302307, -0.12308445572853088, -0.26863041520118713 ]
{"Title": "Ethnicity and acculturation: Asian American substance use from early adolescence to mature adulthood", "Authors": "Ahmmad Zobayer, Adkins Daniel E.", "Abstract": "Abstract Research on Asian American substance use has, to date, been limited by monolithic conceptions of Asian identity, inadequate attention to acculturative process, and a dearth of longitudinal analyses spanning developmental periods. Using five waves of the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health, this study addresses these limitations by longitudinally investigating disparities in substance use from early adolescence into mature adulthood among Asian American ethnic groups, including subjects identifying as multiple Asian ethnicities and multiracial Asians. The conditional effects of acculturation indicators (e.g., nativity generation, co-ethnic peer networks, co-ethnic neighborhood concentration) on the substance use outcomes were also examined. Results indicate significant variation across Asian ethnicities, with the lowest probabilities of substance use among Chinese and Vietnamese Americans, and the highest among multiracial Asian Americans. Acculturation indicators were also strongly, independently associated with increased substance use, and attenuated many of the observed ethnic disparities, particularly for multiracial, multiethnic, and Japanese Asian Americans. This study argues that ignoring the diversity of Asian ethnicities masks the presence of high-risk Asian American groups. Moreover, results indicate that, among Asian Americans, substance use is strongly positively associated with acculturation to U.S. cultural norms, and generally peaks at later ages than the U.S. average.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002048"}
10.1101/19008490
[ -0.1865255981683731, -0.5798390507698059, -0.6596720218658447, -0.2172301709651947, -0.21281030774116516, 0.006489866878837347, 0.20018868148326874, 0.3890291750431061, -0.30963870882987976, 0.3255252540111542, -0.26354336738586426, 0.16042426228523254, 0.25215137004852295, 1.0817314386367798, -0.2193809300661087, -0.6001906991004944, 0.14752721786499023, -0.6234239339828491, 0.06527656316757202, 0.018574485555291176, 0.11293895542621613, 0.2960926592350006, -0.7127971053123474, -0.18998880684375763, -0.20332899689674377, 0.6707589030265808, -0.029886096715927124, -0.38890886306762695, 1.0676153898239136, 0.6379759311676025, -0.12498606741428375, 0.0820770189166069, 0.6757767200469971, -0.8798386454582214, -0.18281257152557373, -0.14699408411979675, -0.2486712783575058, -0.26448696851730347, -0.5740517377853394, -0.23521284759044647, -0.04467502236366272, -0.05306587740778923, 0.10757745802402496, -0.3908906579017639, -1.2728772163391113, 0.8301202654838562, 0.2501034140586853, -0.5268503427505493, -0.5068907141685486, 0.015574824996292591, -0.10657190531492233, -0.04654213413596153, -0.6299327611923218, 0.0946788564324379, -0.4144849479198456, -0.42697685956954956, 0.5234034061431885, -0.13226698338985443, -0.4187450408935547, 0.2815077602863312, 0.43729424476623535, 0.13090960681438446, 0.4032004475593567, -0.94938063621521, 0.018469277769327164, 0.6026580333709717, -0.5895950198173523, -0.04174474626779556, -0.27519479393959045, -0.6471026539802551, -0.7697580456733704, -0.2756778299808502, 0.14938965439796448, -0.553104043006897, -0.170088991522789, -0.28535082936286926, 0.41940584778785706, -0.7670407891273499, 0.22214339673519135, -0.5183614492416382, 0.5359542369842529, 0.5541829466819763, 0.41277584433555603, 0.30318841338157654, -0.8553970456123352, 0.47090819478034973, 0.10210338234901428, -0.32491958141326904, 0.44173192977905273, 0.141159787774086, 0.25406819581985474, 0.5066474676132202, 0.2155628651380539, 0.43765875697135925, 0.47371920943260193, 1.3900840282440186, -0.31229376792907715, -0.07718397676944733, 0.07321370393037796, 0.3734075427055359, 1.2249982357025146, 1.1347484588623047, -0.7675074338912964, 0.5776612162590027, -0.6242136359214783, 0.3616224527359009, 0.535740852355957, -0.920181393623352, 0.6913379430770874, -1.320876955986023, -0.17774777114391327, -0.5504381060600281, -0.4860537052154541, -0.33537063002586365, 0.5237809419631958, 0.6078459620475769, -0.09814002364873886, 0.4831514060497284, -0.3941051661968231, 0.8255113363265991, -0.5585761070251465, 0.05459338426589966, 0.5648826360702515, -0.8212788105010986, 0.4931870996952057, -0.3127022981643677, 0.21035929024219513, 0.4988075792789459, -0.8766636252403259, -0.3278844952583313, 0.23978781700134277, -0.9688053131103516, 0.31192705035209656, -0.10134704411029816, -0.6409181356430054, -0.5701961517333984, 0.44499799609184265, 0.6721193790435791, 0.5106984972953796, 0.0638483539223671, 0.10846033692359924, 0.5774715542793274, -0.11749890446662903, 1.3878378868103027, -0.05106478929519653, 0.0023906526621431112, -0.7554524540901184, -0.40912291407585144, -0.9585334062576294, 0.08639650791883469, 0.4308091700077057, -0.35023364424705505, -0.009424041025340557, 0.6146372556686401, 0.13848651945590973, -0.07720000296831131, -0.9715222716331482, 0.16489703953266144, 0.06581425666809082, 0.27544382214546204, -1.0230557918548584, 0.1301194280385971, -0.414780855178833, 0.28352028131484985, -0.37310490012168884, 0.5139122605323792, 0.05254189297556877, -0.44146445393562317, 0.8089351058006287, -0.7272555828094482, 0.7614680528640747, 0.20276592671871185, -0.6030280590057373, -0.015500584617257118, -0.12358217686414719, 0.3852508068084717, 0.022124579176306725, 0.018551241606473923, -0.20065772533416748, 0.16630469262599945, -0.28548622131347656, 0.45167624950408936, -0.18274573981761932, 0.7733519673347473, 0.6907208561897278, -0.1288919299840927, 0.04665743187069893, -0.5926001667976379, -0.13178351521492004, 0.04653065651655197, -0.4602679908275604, 0.8244200944900513, -0.28829729557037354, 0.09076637029647827, 0.612059473991394, -0.22918947041034698, 0.10205037146806717, -0.39536699652671814, 0.003878117073327303, -0.578486979007721, -0.22507786750793457, 0.3417342007160187, -0.6360407471656799, 0.915165901184082, -0.4652425944805145, 0.4370337426662445, 0.06824446469545364, 0.4670078158378601, -0.17316895723342896, 0.29199308156967163, 0.30909302830696106, 0.03474678471684456, -0.043817613273859024, -0.543031632900238, 0.5468634963035583, -0.6929904818534851, -0.09693067520856857, -0.14583274722099304, -0.7341454029083252, -0.06415756791830063, -0.051002826541662216, -0.14325891435146332, 0.5766947865486145, 0.07148680835962296, -0.37659168243408203, -0.038110729306936264, -0.0663612112402916, 0.5970855355262756, -0.8134938478469849, -0.053132642060518265, -0.6959431171417236, 0.40499722957611084, 0.25634270906448364, 1.0365371704101562, 0.48035022616386414, 0.8914334774017334, -0.06345340609550476, 0.840734601020813, 0.7778101563453674, 0.021606072783470154, 0.6478586196899414, 0.5963013768196106, 0.953468918800354, 0.1165684387087822, -0.9218733310699463, 0.3833073079586029, 0.1255609542131424, -0.2817175090312958, -0.2479395568370819, 0.4761594533920288, -0.45153310894966125, 0.22126533091068268, 0.6781436204910278, 0.8906727433204651, -0.8703497648239136, 0.24565792083740234, 0.552170991897583, 0.7839525938034058, -0.6393912434577942, -0.6569387316703796, -0.14657935500144958, 0.27960440516471863, -0.17000730335712433, 0.23576243221759796, 0.67138671875, 0.00899340957403183, 0.03199085220694542, 1.1437791585922241, 0.3198974132537842, -0.3778206408023834, -0.92464280128479, 0.18137192726135254, -0.3830554783344269, -0.4353090226650238, -0.466637521982193, 0.5854634642601013, 0.5439384579658508, -0.06250923871994019, -0.27168941497802734, -0.3404669463634491, -0.35018134117126465, 0.5728004574775696, 0.06929298490285873, -0.09882748872041702, 1.002294898033142, 0.4630074203014374, -1.1255313158035278, -0.059320248663425446, 0.13510283827781677, 0.6328356862068176, 0.22653786838054657, 0.19587139785289764, -0.9279206991195679, -0.7567534446716309, 0.6352938413619995, 0.012898240238428116, 0.265312135219574, -0.0711858868598938, -0.284164160490036, -0.515911877155304, 0.08290939033031464, -0.28010308742523193, -0.33654940128326416, 0.1227530762553215, -0.6466013193130493, 0.41836118698120117, -0.30220356583595276, 0.41291263699531555, 0.8102856874465942, 0.02640705183148384, -0.16077813506126404, 0.72272789478302, -0.25703656673431396, -0.30985915660858154, -0.9582504034042358, 0.252778023481369, 0.8901762366294861, -0.4291233718395233, -0.1997579038143158, 0.09996956586837769, -0.6090023517608643, -0.16291312873363495, -0.1603042483329773, -0.28272974491119385, -0.819869875907898, 0.5268767476081848, 0.46326178312301636, -1.282355546951294, 0.5047085881233215, -0.34174612164497375, -0.6175389885902405, -0.3281223773956299, 0.16666671633720398, -0.13697755336761475, 0.5600749254226685, -0.11580932140350342, -0.4702167212963104, 0.10895697772502899, -0.42142045497894287, -0.36333271861076355, 0.3191882073879242, -0.5238139033317566, 0.7124864459037781, -0.09026939421892166, -0.14827582240104675, -0.24271106719970703, 0.3500094711780548, -0.21305352449417114, -0.3472950756549835, 0.23155976831912994, 0.37340226769447327, 0.14821918308734894, 0.40529003739356995, 0.02190547063946724, -0.2760421633720398, 1.1857185363769531, -0.5917834639549255, -0.2546796500682831, -0.3002234995365143, 0.31779050827026367, -0.0023032461758702993, 0.40895935893058777, -0.4369274079799652, -0.05827366188168526, -0.5835971832275391, -0.4453517496585846, 0.24463751912117004, 0.9035378694534302, 0.8246646523475647, 0.3591371774673462, 0.4899606704711914, -0.052360400557518005, -0.4482420086860657, 0.7092110514640808, -0.6410688161849976, -0.4948655962944031, 1.0766769647598267, 0.31255483627319336, 0.8059612512588501, -0.9109916090965271, -0.20044976472854614, 0.030857054516673088, 1.5246171951293945, 0.5506165623664856, 0.1430061012506485, 0.44226643443107605, -0.5706591606140137, 0.25938019156455994, 0.3561351001262665, -0.7349632978439331, 0.1434781402349472, 0.15431706607341766, 0.29286301136016846, 0.28107911348342896, -0.3088655471801758, 0.03986508399248123, 0.26807349920272827, -0.19554029405117035, 0.4031870365142822, -0.5792137384414673, 0.3660503029823303, 0.3314233720302582, 0.6286635398864746, 0.3128735423088074, 0.24943120777606964, 0.24447257816791534, -0.887436032295227, 0.007547982037067413, 0.07034674286842346, -0.5325779318809509, -0.6712832450866699, -0.41285470128059387, -0.40955907106399536, -0.020604291930794716, 0.0454883798956871, 0.0832439512014389, -0.52338045835495, -0.3589690625667572, 0.34741246700286865, 0.03086102567613125, 0.38004711270332336, -0.4089697301387787, -0.4370099902153015, 0.26415586471557617, 0.6255636811256409, -0.0015715451445430517, 0.011008611880242825, -0.7148290276527405, 0.37472841143608093, 0.3817007541656494, -0.7959915399551392, -0.6441525816917419, 0.25204598903656006, 0.6877930164337158, -0.24820758402347565, -0.27744296193122864, 0.030686939135193825, -0.05407346040010452, -0.3994285464286804, -0.461459219455719, 0.00516133289784193, -0.39521145820617676, -0.09125590324401855, -0.8996911644935608, 0.2115800380706787, 0.26521533727645874, 0.9386663436889648, 0.41652125120162964, -0.11847994476556778, -0.3855508863925934, 0.36469337344169617, -0.9036846160888672, 0.4583521783351898, 0.022730154916644096, -0.3543660342693329, -0.1311998963356018, -0.0625816211104393, 0.1226809099316597, -0.36858218908309937, 0.06280621886253357, -0.27670544385910034, 0.2024238556623459, 0.19454878568649292, -0.002374115400016308, -0.13085399568080902, 0.5582595467567444, 0.1917150467634201, -0.22141988575458527, 0.22366280853748322, -0.23588719964027405, 0.06848089396953583, 0.6095121502876282, -0.16329887509346008, -0.7619684338569641, 0.2740040421485901, -0.15476705133914948, -0.15374888479709625, 0.48174047470092773, -0.29442211985588074, 0.1692333072423935, 0.4168861210346222, 0.3651150166988373, 0.14890141785144806, 0.3153610825538635, 0.046825192868709564, -0.2350008487701416, -0.3726859390735626, -0.045800887048244476, -0.8721761703491211, 0.5877954363822937, 0.023085817694664, -0.3119717240333557, -0.09566182643175125, -0.004819435998797417, -0.28724566102027893, -0.5225937366485596, 0.04472585767507553, -0.2232174128293991, 0.1381312757730484, 0.3181968629360199, 1.239406704902649, -0.701962947845459, -0.8355023860931396, -0.8129676580429077, 0.11171653866767883, -0.799494743347168, -0.7235613465309143, 0.12981076538562775, -0.7152811288833618, 0.11423352360725403, -0.12928517162799835, -0.14371317625045776, -0.3024498522281647, 0.03483280539512634, 0.0021395639050751925, -0.18224532902240753, 0.64290851354599, -0.27825692296028137, 0.0794060006737709, 0.8536134362220764, -0.11502586305141449, -0.7265128493309021, -0.4274272918701172, 0.20196931064128876, 0.4664744734764099, 0.6266518235206604, -0.06149895489215851, -0.37200045585632324, -0.4780719578266144, -1.2642825841903687, -0.16728650033473969, -0.2777199149131775, 0.08673979341983795, 0.2817601263523102, -0.35995766520500183, 0.21511304378509521, 0.39614713191986084, 0.24066951870918274, 1.2451061010360718, 0.046692151576280594, -0.4499686360359192, 0.516396701335907, -0.0688207820057869, -0.33393871784210205, 0.22631919384002686, -0.4906044006347656, 0.06961001455783844, 0.9043977856636047, 0.4326157569885254, -0.27787116169929504, -0.8823044896125793, -0.19727882742881775, 0.30694180727005005, -0.29796963930130005, -0.12397488206624985, 0.14932209253311157, -0.3278547525405884, -0.25315117835998535, -0.0901196077466011, -0.004012222867459059, -0.8969815969467163, 0.9446654915809631, 0.08064624667167664, 0.24902404844760895, 0.0032940914388746023, -0.17950552701950073, 0.1873944252729416, -0.1848645955324173, 1.0542258024215698, 0.1452765166759491, 0.21076388657093048, -0.3046359121799469, 0.12105213850736618, 0.5169456601142883, -0.08504049479961395, -1.2289165258407593, -0.48921120166778564, -0.6291208267211914, -1.213871717453003, 0.3430585265159607, -0.13136425614356995, -0.408054381608963, 0.44652360677719116, -0.1715034544467926, 0.06818210333585739, -0.28644248843193054, 0.7802656292915344, 0.3781126141548157, -0.7953818440437317, -0.18774086236953735, 0.14272454380989075, 1.0210586786270142, 0.06418856978416443, 0.5620224475860596, -0.09740982949733734, -0.6726690530776978, -0.18436364829540253, -0.2973315715789795, -0.3448370397090912, -0.4310839772224426, 0.04890931025147438, -0.6591804027557373, 0.8049612641334534, -0.09360986202955246, -0.11044663190841675, -0.025275954976677895, -0.7411407828330994, -0.5916946530342102, 0.16284047067165375, 0.2182508409023285, -0.20751230418682098, 0.988128662109375, -0.047242749482393265, -0.46775129437446594, 0.44929876923561096, -0.2707272469997406, -0.03424861282110214, 0.03533940762281418, 0.49128279089927673, 0.7455230951309204, -1.1447947025299072, 0.5863710641860962, 0.5976467728614807, -0.928970992565155, -0.2072424292564392, -0.5043015480041504, -0.44605574011802673, 0.1860063523054123, 0.40164250135421753, -0.5355651378631592, 0.2548491358757019, 0.15176644921302795, 0.6452152729034424, 0.5298216342926025, -0.23720113933086395, 0.009242404252290726, 0.26428496837615967, 0.2928408980369568, -0.9178385138511658, -0.3503084182739258, 0.7532618641853333, -0.3199670910835266, -0.33397114276885986, 0.32900989055633545, -0.044109221547842026, 0.024424878880381584, -0.05848676338791847, 0.48324447870254517, -0.8907088041305542, -0.15441583096981049, -0.135610431432724, -0.05461887642741203, 0.41214093565940857, 0.12362320721149445, -0.2831067144870758, 0.3596076965332031, -0.2217758297920227, -0.2763696312904358, 0.03512481972575188, 1.1213726997375488, -0.08502122014760971, 0.20338203012943268, -0.38934043049812317, -0.5439431667327881, 0.6642483472824097, -0.08278921991586685, 1.0913364887237549, -0.1962389498949051, -0.4442161023616791, -0.5151877403259277, -1.0522087812423706, -0.818968653678894, -0.5767534375190735, -0.0008346006507053971, -0.21340902149677277, -0.6872828006744385, -0.7455094456672668, -0.3895965814590454, 0.7101507186889648, -0.662261962890625, -0.32160475850105286, -0.2719990909099579, 0.4311685860157013, -0.6972918510437012, -0.748806893825531, -0.49625736474990845, -0.21399690210819244, -0.1728179007768631, 0.9238641858100891, -0.29964032769203186, 0.21712569892406464, 0.1338479071855545, 0.1954968422651291, 0.06290619820356369, 0.49421510100364685, -0.608472466468811, -0.5681012272834778, 0.3372066915035248, 0.8589659333229065, 0.2842188775539398, 0.21291156113147736, 1.072174072265625, -0.41160351037979126, 0.489400714635849, 0.27663058042526245, -0.3006940186023712, 0.19147750735282898, 0.04699612781405449, -0.35112690925598145, -1.0751210451126099, -0.330276757478714, -0.7364774942398071, -0.012558314949274063, -0.8535651564598083, -0.7754781246185303, -0.6136782765388489, -0.35766807198524475, -0.30989035964012146, 0.5632358193397522, 0.7055384516716003, 0.045836348086595535, -0.20790793001651764, -0.030004482716321945, 0.21840855479240417, 1.3381025791168213, 0.2623365521430969, 0.16599141061306, 0.09017036855220795, 0.06067858636379242, -0.09142174571752548, -0.5945016741752625, 0.4220138192176819, 0.9516081809997559, 0.1677737683057785, 0.4069823920726776, -1.1565947532653809, -0.4517349600791931, 0.502088725566864, -0.6911191344261169, 0.1701027899980545, 0.6091769933700562, 0.12639875710010529, 0.01288642268627882, -0.08812157064676285, -0.3455796241760254, -0.23462669551372528, -0.782439649105072, -1.0952798128128052, -0.4007070064544678, 1.0119295120239258, -0.4913147985935211, -0.19159097969532013, -0.6151025891304016, 0.28014618158340454, 0.280161052942276, -0.47262126207351685, 0.009517001919448376, -0.0021365489810705185, 0.7070598006248474, -0.28619325160980225, 0.19647568464279175, -0.026549963280558586, 0.7105020880699158, -0.6799018979072571, 0.7458488941192627, -0.45238572359085083, -0.6099233627319336, 0.30970922112464905, 0.5431071519851685, 0.4919896125793457, 0.561029851436615, -0.5406302809715271, -0.016152922064065933, -0.3055870234966278, -0.11467277258634567, -0.2751353085041046, -0.09346289187669754, 0.43393421173095703, -0.23508396744728088, 0.09409135580062866, 0.782983660697937, -0.1957070529460907, -0.380037397146225, 0.16365747153759003, -1.4895662069320679, -0.6136512160301208, 0.8393673300743103, 0.547572135925293, -0.016853541135787964, 0.5505057573318481, -0.13313214480876923, 0.0496799573302269, 0.08570631593465805, -0.21527370810508728, 0.506869375705719, 0.17253857851028442, -0.23518367111682892, 0.6023643612861633, 0.0685276910662651, -0.007397289387881756, 0.6669568419456482, 0.6397080421447754, -0.44462254643440247, -0.14769025146961212, 0.5156142711639404, -0.0857372134923935, -0.3369400203227997, -0.483195960521698, 0.06484654545783997, 0.6539053320884705, -0.8042023777961731, 0.7140676975250244, -0.07889705896377563, 0.9546341300010681, 0.16355185210704803, -0.1194218248128891, 0.5612109303474426, -0.9442244172096252, -0.29014092683792114, 0.0070066372863948345, -0.07845316082239151, 0.41934630274772644, 0.14763474464416504, 0.014222017489373684, -0.038271501660346985, 0.9603008031845093, 0.29837748408317566, -0.8504338264465332, 0.013813222758471966, -0.3670022487640381, -0.6982911229133606, -0.011937825940549374, 0.17506855726242065, 0.17474468052387238, -0.06831307709217072, 0.1683139204978943, -0.36764323711395264, 0.4232311248779297, 0.26376861333847046, -0.38641154766082764, -0.13168087601661682, 0.8320945501327515, -0.15855053067207336, -0.25116151571273804, 0.4079650640487671, -0.02479786053299904, -0.14451569318771362, -0.2626342177391052, 0.24663595855236053, 0.3814888298511505, -0.16466327011585236, 0.13339634239673615, 0.5961996912956238, 0.35880762338638306, -0.06602995097637177, 0.2766977846622467, -0.4110964834690094, -0.8337117433547974, 0.636541485786438, -0.05109681934118271, -0.27107909321784973, -0.13572397828102112, 0.5418067574501038, -0.28175899386405945, 0.20565010607242584, 0.002480494324117899, 0.05929183587431908, -0.48244988918304443, -0.08215383440256119, 0.3693445026874542, 0.2881876230239868, -0.08133742958307266, -1.034507393836975, 0.06307082623243332, 0.18835394084453583, 0.2021855264902115, 0.3529606759548187, 0.0066471402533352375, 0.31068095564842224, -0.5362363457679749, 0.09185761958360672, -0.21121907234191895, -0.5494984984397888, 0.3291700482368469, -0.8344444036483765, 0.7008954286575317, 0.2125525176525116, -0.4191976487636566, -0.6877943873405457, -1.1415456533432007, 0.26588889956474304, -0.5274706482887268, -0.040467165410518646, -0.7095993757247925, -0.13560087978839874, 0.15918394923210144, 0.007883180864155293, -0.5932303071022034, -0.6328068375587463, -0.687869131565094, -0.06528852134943008, 0.951562225818634, -0.6980127692222595, 0.8267799019813538, 0.36949366331100464, -0.4888729453086853, -0.12279821187257767, 0.31503230333328247, 0.05442485585808754, -0.14050838351249695, -0.24586929380893707, -0.09700077027082443, 0.00212803459726274, -0.3138863444328308, -0.9705138802528381, 0.22802990674972534, 0.6602998375892639, -0.48219332098960876, -0.33813726902008057, 0.04826110228896141, -0.2380027323961258, -0.3922456204891205, 0.46339520812034607, -0.6646150350570679, -0.15177199244499207, 0.17252124845981598, 0.18066143989562988, 0.8444913029670715, -1.047795295715332, 4.3336310386657715, 0.6249473690986633, 0.41443222761154175, 0.14429280161857605, 0.8130615949630737, 0.8732355833053589, 0.5965575575828552, 0.48615947365760803, 1.4006682634353638, -0.489615261554718, -0.12762676179409027, 0.06936009228229523, 0.8668790459632874, -0.010411305353045464, 0.10421974956989288, 0.3459174633026123, -0.6492012143135071, -0.33782434463500977, 0.09520801901817322, -0.4799889624118805, -0.14155198633670807, 0.46708905696868896, -0.5438973903656006, 0.261814147233963, 0.18112269043922424, 0.1507013887166977, 0.7833947539329529, 0.13291454315185547, 0.18767383694648743, -0.6257381439208984, 0.47779232263565063, -0.24202978610992432, 0.551084041595459, -0.3897266685962677, -0.3466130793094635, 0.4929520785808563, 0.2191370278596878, -1.221858024597168, 0.3729284405708313, 0.2438584715127945, 0.2172042429447174, 0.1771121472120285, 0.41254207491874695, -0.452832967042923, -0.20077085494995117, 0.43207862973213196, -0.40205398201942444, -0.41079264879226685, 0.2533529996871948, 0.26617687940597534, 0.42276203632354736, -0.3368147909641266, -0.24411901831626892, 0.019297383725643158, -0.23097695410251617, -0.06642278283834457, 0.5616441965103149, -1.1087143421173096, 0.1354130506515503, -0.29282885789871216, 0.9331333637237549, -0.17666976153850555, 0.040885474532842636, -0.591759979724884, 0.4334994852542877, 0.24510858952999115, 0.8446357250213623, 0.08486606180667877, -0.30066949129104614, -0.49355533719062805, -0.3530770540237427, -0.23315759003162384, 0.099934883415699, -0.7619777917861938, 0.4892371892929077, 0.4033883213996887, -0.07230595499277115, 0.7102622389793396, -0.3592647910118103, -0.8366864323616028, 0.019304707646369934, 0.3569108247756958, 0.3021075427532196, 0.1245255172252655, -0.2522929906845093, 0.5332565307617188, -0.06182049959897995, 0.031347472220659256, -1.144831657409668, 0.10616946965456009, 1.1696377992630005, -0.2887588143348694, -0.31471842527389526, 0.17043131589889526, 0.07940011471509933 ]
{"Title": "Traditional Healers as Client Advocates in the HIV-endemic Region of Maputo, Mozambique: Results from a qualitative study", "Authors": "Sundararajan Radhika, Langa Patr\u00edcio V., Morshed Trisha, Manuel Sandra", "Abstract": "Traditional healers are commonly utilized throughout sub-Saharan Africa instead of \u2013 and in concert with \u2013 biomedical facilities. Traditional healers are trusted providers and prominent community members, and could be important partners in improving engagement with HIV services in endemic contexts. Our study sought to understand the roles of healers in the urban setting of Maputo, Mozambique, where HIV prevalence is high and testing rates are low. Qualitative data were gathered through minimally-structured interviews with 36 healers. Analysis followed an inductive, grounded theory approach. Data reveal three themes relevant to improving engagement with HIV services in this endemic region: 1) healers have positive attitudes towards biomedicine; 2) healers advocate for their sick clients; and 3) clients are reticent to present to biomedical facilities. Healers describe their roles as \u2018cooperative\u2019 with biomedical providers to provide healthcare for their clients. Results suggest that healers could be considered critical enablers to effective HIV programs in communities. They have social and symbolic capital that positions them to beneficially influence clients, and are natural partners for interventions to improve uptake of HIV services.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008490"}
10.1101/19003228
[ 0.00551683409139514, 0.15227223932743073, 0.1189168319106102, 1.355320930480957, -1.0261867046356201, -0.3091435432434082, -0.5619128942489624, 0.2877456843852997, -0.16410768032073975, 0.4838859438896179, -0.09079152345657349, -0.4344640374183655, 0.831851601600647, -0.5596213936805725, -0.06800371408462524, -0.3033278286457062, -0.5303179025650024, -0.42274966835975647, -0.010006931610405445, 0.19558700919151306, -0.36892756819725037, -0.491288959980011, 0.21033653616905212, 0.2722378969192505, -0.23143307864665985, 0.3278021812438965, -1.2083194255828857, 0.031966883689165115, 0.9757985472679138, 0.6934142708778381, -0.34379085898399353, -0.02376534603536129, 0.5310549736022949, 0.10542189329862595, -0.1721024066209793, -0.025914670899510384, 0.9469603896141052, -0.2268504500389099, -0.5392599105834961, -0.9061375260353088, 0.2181490808725357, 0.34479424357414246, 0.6075642704963684, -0.37934932112693787, -0.1615314781665802, -0.008574681356549263, 0.2615659832954407, 0.11048508435487747, -0.18234457075595856, -0.542159914970398, -0.5020753145217896, 0.40374821424484253, 0.2433895319700241, -0.6578772068023682, 0.4528060555458069, -0.03662123158574104, -0.1366448998451233, -0.23730234801769257, -0.7248892784118652, -0.18516293168067932, 0.32812216877937317, -0.03813207894563675, -0.09491100907325745, 0.038126371800899506, 0.5569050312042236, 1.2108932733535767, -0.848101019859314, 0.6181503534317017, -0.4483467936515808, 0.02477763034403324, -0.04204371199011803, 0.29962801933288574, 0.3302020728588104, -0.4154258966445923, -0.5795437693595886, -0.2889901399612427, 0.43032607436180115, -0.23541249334812164, -0.4935283362865448, 0.21873797476291656, -0.6851741075515747, 0.3876572847366333, 0.48655247688293457, 0.3168005645275116, 0.16027309000492096, -0.18694357573986053, 0.18843770027160645, 0.12740205228328705, 0.27220964431762695, 0.6164014339447021, 0.4054693579673767, 0.4496752917766571, -0.40663620829582214, 0.10201536864042282, 0.10351908206939697, 0.7872711420059204, -0.627251386642456, -0.12032172828912735, 0.5978710055351257, 0.8593917489051819, 0.432437539100647, 0.20056070387363434, 0.11391519010066986, 0.9857796430587769, -0.7023818492889404, -0.06923308968544006, 0.9518529772758484, -0.4381089508533478, 0.640601396560669, -0.9857152104377747, -0.19951193034648895, 0.7869560718536377, -0.8494645357131958, -0.3489159941673279, -0.04747859761118889, -0.5622526407241821, 0.487978994846344, 0.5459125638008118, -0.34281912446022034, 0.7257369160652161, 0.29898783564567566, -0.06715843826532364, 0.8456751108169556, -0.8642987012863159, -0.1682346910238266, 0.22336629033088684, 0.04450543597340584, 0.06151609495282173, -0.2978827655315399, -0.19728758931159973, 0.07642111927270889, 0.04260383918881416, -0.5653418302536011, 1.1048706769943237, 0.12065000087022781, 0.005072044208645821, -0.3396984934806824, 0.7645594477653503, 0.2462410032749176, 0.6982029676437378, -0.6043084263801575, -0.1001690998673439, 0.09640833735466003, 0.9987594485282898, 0.08085773140192032, 0.3333902955055237, 0.18083778023719788, -0.1879817396402359, -0.5986343026161194, 0.33178403973579407, -0.5972439050674438, 0.8355344533920288, 0.08934705704450607, -0.17414218187332153, -0.07818122953176498, 0.6202486753463745, -0.24632899463176727, -0.08882973343133926, -1.0410022735595703, 0.6084117889404297, 0.07340942323207855, -0.017871754243969917, -0.5817631483078003, 0.5298429131507874, 0.2703250050544739, -0.1849345564842224, 0.4712584614753723, -0.36502620577812195, 0.5871156454086304, -0.1551581472158432, 0.9556894302368164, 0.2726214528083801, 0.005008547566831112, -0.150934100151062, -0.1930365264415741, 0.36790409684181213, 0.6892758011817932, -0.07150439918041229, -0.3953811228275299, 0.7452846169471741, -0.1573365181684494, 0.6082784533500671, 1.0170098543167114, 0.4594601094722748, 1.0274988412857056, -0.15701976418495178, -0.935329258441925, -0.273892343044281, 0.32605040073394775, -0.1817157119512558, 0.43393611907958984, 0.34042757749557495, -0.9701564311981201, 0.6233420372009277, -0.3729728162288666, 0.20871339738368988, -0.27618852257728577, 0.5191938281059265, 0.6863782405853271, -0.1842459887266159, -0.13798388838768005, 0.5428755879402161, -0.5326338410377502, 0.047319043427705765, 0.22426843643188477, -0.2866682708263397, 1.1033709049224854, 0.583124577999115, 0.362993448972702, 0.9359317421913147, 0.04112807661294937, 0.15727797150611877, -0.5425236821174622, -0.4816567003726959, 0.2970034182071686, -0.9118462204933167, 0.12408546358346939, -0.4501942992210388, -0.24676813185214996, -0.1446685791015625, 0.1485741287469864, -0.09945140779018402, 0.5352851748466492, 0.5076696872711182, -0.7905548810958862, 0.49289852380752563, -0.12110932171344757, 0.15075451135635376, 0.2010384202003479, -0.5541892647743225, 0.11840429157018661, 0.8507510423660278, -0.05499471351504326, 0.4065013825893402, 0.877691388130188, 0.34980112314224243, -0.026170309633016586, 0.03441312164068222, 0.41235387325286865, -0.22171838581562042, 0.2826913893222809, 0.7412108778953552, 0.5456496477127075, -0.01685205101966858, -0.06590002030134201, 0.5726022124290466, -0.501221239566803, 0.26912206411361694, -0.9279288053512573, 0.07927880436182022, -0.7559906840324402, 0.04608301818370819, 0.123545341193676, 0.4387487471103668, -0.15281060338020325, -0.3208628296852112, -0.0966995432972908, 0.27458205819129944, -0.42055001854896545, -0.778287410736084, 0.23188932240009308, 0.14470382034778595, -0.6812214255332947, 0.14731024205684662, 0.5114555358886719, 0.5796970725059509, 0.025713058188557625, -0.18001116812229156, 0.13574209809303284, 0.06008581444621086, -0.6996656060218811, -0.24124714732170105, -0.14456796646118164, -0.1443486213684082, -0.3788726031780243, -0.6885426640510559, -0.7452999353408813, -0.09507554024457932, 0.9380226135253906, -0.07836449146270752, 0.3412322402000427, 0.15910793840885162, -0.5809491872787476, -0.04720861464738846, -0.04097467288374901, 0.819527804851532, -1.0828276872634888, 0.4355495274066925, 0.20890799164772034, 0.675919234752655, 0.45695167779922485, -0.948721170425415, -0.7221617102622986, -0.8398223519325256, -0.06845445930957794, -0.11281052976846695, 0.019049227237701416, -0.3799017071723938, 0.07019885629415512, -0.4205772578716278, 0.29706433415412903, -0.33646512031555176, 0.4759489595890045, 0.18944884836673737, -0.6987773180007935, 0.5399495959281921, -0.29589036107063293, -0.10169868916273117, 0.5513997077941895, 0.07578287273645401, 0.03275762125849724, 0.3972797095775604, -0.3480130434036255, 0.5250629186630249, -0.6311981081962585, 0.34743866324424744, 0.1420854777097702, 0.29010456800460815, 0.2092134654521942, -0.877898633480072, -0.06681983172893524, -0.07381350547075272, -0.28510811924934387, -1.3367422819137573, -0.31368720531463623, 0.3085707426071167, -0.6569035053253174, -0.8030807375907898, 0.2867739200592041, 0.11747314035892487, -0.696222722530365, -0.672924280166626, -0.8513948917388916, 0.1554507613182068, -0.0019132636953145266, -0.22238101065158844, 0.009237345308065414, 0.5388697385787964, 0.46640267968177795, 0.9022916555404663, 0.5326910018920898, -0.9848095178604126, 0.1289466917514801, 0.47502443194389343, -0.12525762617588043, 0.34801337122917175, 0.34064093232154846, -0.28463900089263916, -1.0269014835357666, -0.6259235143661499, -0.8115119338035583, -0.0013517383486032486, 0.767079770565033, -0.08308656513690948, 0.3584161400794983, 0.05664600804448128, -0.8069847822189331, 0.9548705816268921, 0.8357939720153809, 0.5361672043800354, 0.046942807734012604, 0.17040196061134338, 0.21665211021900177, -0.7087839245796204, -0.5404766201972961, -0.5484892725944519, 0.5964106321334839, 0.1743323653936386, 0.45431825518608093, -0.4977702796459198, -0.03864948824048042, -0.0005155084654688835, 0.06753107905387878, -0.3380548655986786, -0.23093034327030182, 0.5144593715667725, 0.11877879500389099, 0.6113627552986145, 1.07532799243927, -0.3566509187221527, 0.049467556178569794, 0.37425684928894043, 0.8491407036781311, -0.20795753598213196, -0.5422787666320801, 0.7502334117889404, -0.6668628454208374, 0.19127465784549713, -0.1123800203204155, -0.785469651222229, 0.6611612439155579, -0.08366023749113083, 0.3663703501224518, -0.5395482778549194, -0.4779306948184967, -0.3747248351573944, 0.4220442473888397, 0.03643511235713959, 0.1565876305103302, 0.42191019654273987, 1.4522958993911743, -0.5725866556167603, 0.9383783340454102, 0.33577194809913635, 0.48625850677490234, -0.48510921001434326, -0.8240294456481934, 0.9649319648742676, 0.08082129061222076, -0.18910899758338928, 0.04462696239352226, -0.5046774744987488, 0.06831996142864227, -0.2649994492530823, -0.5622135996818542, 0.4029410779476166, -0.29695090651512146, 0.5116482973098755, -0.37433484196662903, 0.20248259603977203, -0.02984548918902874, -0.3692779242992401, -0.6896273493766785, 0.07807508111000061, 0.2782614827156067, -1.1806870698928833, 0.29164743423461914, -0.3636961281299591, 0.03452345356345177, 0.44995030760765076, -0.2354825735092163, -0.022106705233454704, -0.10395580530166626, 0.0841137021780014, -0.5523797869682312, 0.6791782379150391, -0.21621672809123993, 0.42309704422950745, 0.3603898286819458, 0.14793440699577332, -0.33567124605178833, -0.7148541808128357, -0.7992607951164246, -0.28119364380836487, -0.30227163434028625, 0.08770222961902618, 0.2855178117752075, 0.6019625067710876, 0.2503238320350647, 0.02429184317588806, 0.39229902625083923, -0.903217613697052, 1.1735647916793823, -0.08099842071533203, -0.5303903818130493, -0.22271619737148285, -0.22480618953704834, -0.3912268280982971, 0.08988846838474274, 0.13054722547531128, -1.2054057121276855, 0.04776892811059952, -0.251600980758667, -0.5805500745773315, -0.3690085709095001, -0.066097192466259, -0.8853277564048767, 0.026507515460252762, 0.38585788011550903, -0.6867823004722595, 0.8642185926437378, -0.36724868416786194, 0.3281271755695343, -0.4907462000846863, -0.45275557041168213, -0.6547714471817017, 0.15585342049598694, 0.2133484184741974, -0.7118053436279297, 0.09406442195177078, 0.05939868837594986, 0.1304183155298233, -0.5719560980796814, -0.1831415593624115, -0.790113627910614, -0.3861861228942871, 0.15511293709278107, 0.2635563015937805, -0.5053232312202454, 0.36080241203308105, -0.04563523083925247, -0.7981593608856201, 0.45624566078186035, -0.670179009437561, -0.4724629521369934, -0.6563994288444519, -0.4925599992275238, -0.051025182008743286, 0.18789368867874146, -0.2551172077655792, 0.9326626062393188, -0.4964408874511719, -1.088449239730835, 0.026883361861109734, 0.39379575848579407, -0.3967200219631195, -0.18160618841648102, -0.16491594910621643, 0.13148079812526703, 0.19213245809078217, -0.2991914451122284, 0.5780673623085022, -1.0548112392425537, 0.14357911050319672, -0.5366510152816772, -0.1273316890001297, 0.761524498462677, -0.32753217220306396, -0.5287251472473145, 1.3174817562103271, -0.11539553105831146, -1.026116967201233, -0.46158063411712646, 1.1338391304016113, -0.4581472873687744, -0.46064072847366333, 0.5496770739555359, -0.7961098551750183, -0.1843767911195755, -0.34859994053840637, 0.9215688109397888, -1.1775000095367432, -0.7201588153839111, -0.42103448510169983, -0.5863081216812134, -0.06121191382408142, -0.3038214147090912, -0.051873985677957535, -0.5355685949325562, 0.42682012915611267, -0.711933970451355, -0.0023947693407535553, -0.20269036293029785, -0.25181469321250916, -0.10808176547288895, -0.2628701329231262, -0.3534950017929077, 0.7523048520088196, 0.14977234601974487, -0.033017709851264954, 0.08824550360441208, -0.33598557114601135, 0.6592878103256226, 0.3430272936820984, -0.2733859121799469, -0.9673560261726379, -0.07325631380081177, 0.6354132294654846, -0.07473184913396835, 0.07233341783285141, -0.25769656896591187, 0.8936452865600586, -0.7894386053085327, 0.3393513858318329, -0.3692057430744171, -0.00736395874992013, 0.011093041859567165, -0.3739384114742279, 0.8933292031288147, -0.3697122633457184, 0.9505690932273865, 0.43667152523994446, -0.18861640989780426, -0.3203045725822449, 0.19211868941783905, -0.5937684774398804, -0.4299578368663788, -0.5644043684005737, -0.869127631187439, 0.5932040810585022, -0.003679478308185935, -0.24517621099948883, 0.154091939330101, 0.18053755164146423, 0.6998967528343201, -0.43218404054641724, 0.9296562671661377, 1.0209507942199707, -0.26825422048568726, -0.36328238248825073, -0.6269000172615051, 0.346172034740448, 0.7027388215065002, 0.3428685665130615, 0.117796391248703, -0.8221858739852905, 0.6100667715072632, -0.5041064620018005, 0.0016150596784427762, -0.2597876489162445, -0.525887668132782, 0.5340002775192261, 0.7604794502258301, -0.7950000166893005, 0.8084714412689209, -0.12966400384902954, -0.4741673171520233, -0.18744653463363647, 1.254952311515808, 0.4390474855899811, 0.7572339773178101, -0.30168938636779785, -0.839895486831665, -1.2316945791244507, -0.4786187410354614, -0.6291335225105286, -0.25804999470710754, 0.3152458667755127, 0.34632569551467896, 0.3280773162841797, -0.826055109500885, 0.33917781710624695, 0.17583067715168, -0.651852011680603, -0.6341210007667542, 0.313037633895874, -0.6035096645355225, 0.07019782811403275, 0.008866045624017715, -0.9665144681930542, 0.4876408576965332, 0.044723156839609146, 0.11664190143346786, -0.19568784534931183, -0.13783235847949982, 0.3578112721443176, -0.5666801333427429, 0.38323974609375, -0.32826605439186096, -0.1736525297164917, 0.8357218503952026, -0.35791149735450745, -0.4223078787326813, -0.4508719742298126, -0.7359291315078735, 0.09049635380506516, 0.19109490513801575, 0.34627455472946167, -0.548386812210083, 0.7286949753761292, 0.5839622020721436, -0.9297187924385071, 0.3677135705947876, 0.5005189776420593, -0.03089243918657303, 0.32297274470329285, -0.2274148166179657, -0.21439960598945618, -0.1905517876148224, 0.44313207268714905, -0.4450783133506775, 0.7074716687202454, -0.22042687237262726, -0.7695788741111755, 0.27676060795783997, 0.19868451356887817, 0.49743545055389404, 0.15538856387138367, -0.6097612977027893, -0.6870601177215576, -0.5371615290641785, -0.20709484815597534, -0.3529612123966217, -0.2825595438480377, 0.5039282441139221, -0.973397433757782, -0.6778698563575745, 0.4703187048435211, 0.44979581236839294, -0.07010920345783234, 0.09015103429555893, 0.08064673840999603, 0.619533360004425, -0.4293810725212097, -0.7729853987693787, 0.6002549529075623, -0.4035838842391968, -0.6682157516479492, 0.41031739115715027, -0.49769070744514465, -0.5064437389373779, -0.33196473121643066, 0.9669910669326782, -0.1394527554512024, 0.3412418067455292, 0.426131933927536, -0.022252410650253296, 0.3824818432331085, 0.32554224133491516, 0.09361761063337326, 0.26451608538627625, 0.1409580111503601, -0.5104524493217468, 0.5908299684524536, 0.028005631640553474, -0.494023859500885, 0.35289257764816284, 0.26701632142066956, 0.861381471157074, 0.06670910120010376, -0.8036601543426514, -0.17832741141319275, 0.4272999167442322, -0.7126243114471436, 0.38538652658462524, -0.6875635385513306, 0.4288511872291565, 0.21893030405044556, 0.28060945868492126, 0.04310924932360649, 0.13629765808582306, -0.005931738298386335, -0.1924837827682495, 0.5770679712295532, 0.44987860321998596, 0.5073599815368652, -0.408801406621933, 0.6687021851539612, 0.38153889775276184, 0.16763168573379517, -1.3625420331954956, -0.20589694380760193, 0.8580916523933411, -0.5590397715568542, 0.15712276101112366, 0.259033203125, 0.2673201560974121, -0.4738612174987793, 0.5208632946014404, -0.6753814220428467, 1.0027458667755127, 0.22016192972660065, -0.13488730788230896, -0.22423914074897766, 0.19649456441402435, -1.0774002075195312, -0.2215370386838913, 0.2928280234336853, -0.24375508725643158, 0.13284467160701752, -0.26470324397087097, 0.2414010614156723, -0.2278091460466385, -0.7398202419281006, 0.5508507490158081, 0.34404078125953674, 0.834395170211792, -1.0202618837356567, 0.037692878395318985, 0.3581930100917816, 0.8511565923690796, 0.032541174441576004, 0.25653892755508423, 0.10389947146177292, 0.09904784709215164, -0.7295517325401306, -0.2935103178024292, 0.46613678336143494, -0.05252834036946297, 0.001200160593725741, -0.2969468832015991, 0.3913719952106476, 0.2171063870191574, -0.01584358513355255, 0.5125119686126709, -0.9108719825744629, -0.3481837809085846, -1.0435295104980469, -0.35575437545776367, -0.35993656516075134, 0.17791105806827545, -0.4755672216415405, 0.28535959124565125, -0.23710858821868896, -1.1214377880096436, -0.32148781418800354, 0.3758982717990875, 0.41814494132995605, -0.1057337298989296, -0.014832484535872936, -0.4903631806373596, 0.46349450945854187, -0.1494048684835434, -0.5040414929389954, -0.13072778284549713, 0.30407777428627014, 0.28876569867134094, 0.7797918319702148, 0.2658480107784271, 0.31687605381011963, 0.429943323135376, 0.2148846685886383, 0.39871424436569214, 0.9897892475128174, 0.6520742177963257, -1.1408900022506714, 0.20166775584220886, -0.22250470519065857, 0.35289421677589417, -0.09894389659166336, -0.26122650504112244, 0.21997863054275513, 0.3443644940853119, 0.5927524566650391, -0.23775964975357056, -0.5906643867492676, 0.12855227291584015, -0.7775865197181702, -0.7764822840690613, -0.1122780591249466, 0.3196720480918884, 1.0656805038452148, 0.23888233304023743, 0.31227248907089233, 0.12329290062189102, 1.2096643447875977, 0.1724911481142044, 0.17023833096027374, 0.39621469378471375, -0.5384531617164612, -0.5016874670982361, -0.7078990340232849, 0.36605924367904663, 0.1533166915178299, 0.3820083737373352, 0.11951661854982376, 0.12587691843509674, 0.20420576632022858, 0.5347931385040283, -0.4745437800884247, -0.22752004861831665, 0.514685332775116, -0.5700677633285522, 0.42069199681282043, -0.278584748506546, -0.6178336143493652, 0.35279470682144165, -0.03692525252699852, 0.751400887966156, -0.11158334463834763, -0.5084453821182251, 0.15371696650981903, 0.4539240002632141, -0.5442992448806763, 0.621736466884613, 0.44878682494163513, 0.01918766461312771, 0.30306509137153625, 0.022682668641209602, -0.8074488043785095, -0.37771499156951904, 0.06501857191324234, 0.08144077658653259, -0.46942582726478577, -0.42411211133003235, 0.10368121415376663, -0.25936564803123474, 0.6319935321807861, -0.05915702134370804, 0.43984222412109375, -0.2123110443353653, -0.29411423206329346, -0.8416339159011841, -0.03028171695768833, -0.8855198621749878, 0.0008664841298013926, -0.49785488843917847, 0.08427094668149948, 0.7693459391593933, -0.2658317983150482, -0.36793774366378784, -0.31454548239707947, -0.6851081252098083, 0.06288382411003113, -0.1313869059085846, 0.6248475909233093, -1.1975531578063965, -0.48832738399505615, -0.7021331787109375, -0.3972424566745758, -0.20005318522453308, 0.032883431762456894, -0.46720823645591736, -0.5778296589851379, 0.3688857853412628, 0.6794561147689819, 0.6980883479118347, 0.5984088182449341, 0.052830081433057785, 0.2366495132446289, 0.08393685519695282, 0.6584871411323547, 0.28741899132728577, 0.621055543422699, -0.13576099276542664, 0.32110798358917236, 0.7107941508293152, -0.23146934807300568, 0.5919576287269592, 0.057779327034950256, -0.5310552716255188, -0.36898913979530334, 0.08164971321821213, -0.30362966656684875, -0.027024926617741585, -0.11053016781806946, 0.8366184830665588, 0.3140939772129059, -0.03934306651353836, -0.4004756510257721, -0.16546086966991425, -0.42910802364349365, 0.5562316179275513, -0.11643750220537186, -0.7712013721466064, 0.36552372574806213, 0.48330748081207275, -0.4696659445762634, -0.499293714761734, 4.2747602462768555, 0.7015622854232788, 0.01976265199482441, 0.4060821235179901, 0.49459168314933777, -0.12074054777622223, 0.3991701900959015, -0.5133214592933655, -0.43190890550613403, -0.20786325633525848, -0.07803447544574738, -0.3718945384025574, 0.4126320779323578, 0.48465415835380554, 0.9367336630821228, 0.18903003633022308, -0.6462661027908325, -0.3308507800102234, -0.16432693600654602, -1.26860773563385, -0.06070690229535103, -0.49801257252693176, -0.03322859853506088, 0.3435065448284149, 0.20430345833301544, -0.3219493627548218, 0.277841180562973, 0.5291014909744263, 0.20248623192310333, -0.5692999362945557, -0.06894426792860031, -0.44240039587020874, 0.5453729629516602, -1.0910933017730713, -0.10988081991672516, 0.06701380759477615, -0.10728687047958374, -0.04722416773438454, -0.36395198106765747, 0.0014391369186341763, -0.49156221747398376, 0.09248429536819458, 0.33404651284217834, -0.6604886054992676, 0.1529124230146408, 0.37316542863845825, -0.09863921999931335, 0.6749547719955444, 0.6187634468078613, -0.828436017036438, 0.4017336368560791, -0.6575912237167358, 0.3141685724258423, 0.16838513314723969, -0.9103845357894897, -0.2673848867416382, -0.5758714079856873, -1.0612810850143433, 0.16639652848243713, 0.4658529758453369, 0.5426632165908813, 0.18478266894817352, -0.3548113703727722, -0.071853406727314, 0.023389436304569244, 0.5780143141746521, 0.3552797734737396, 0.0709095373749733, -0.3732798099517822, 0.0622546561062336, 0.022613225504755974, -0.4618808627128601, -0.7101032733917236, 0.14880160987377167, 0.5042623281478882, 0.4264156222343445, 0.301311731338501, 0.47190409898757935, 0.6398679614067078, -0.08394073694944382, 0.5281029343605042, -0.028607387095689774, -0.3483961224555969, -0.0019846719224005938, 0.1825009286403656, 0.3830471336841583, 0.05949149653315544, -0.7315111756324768, -0.44946807622909546, 0.8204078078269958, 0.7297940850257874, 0.031086977571249008, -0.21400922536849976, 0.3698834478855133, -0.10582354664802551 ]
{"Title": "Esophageal Cooling For Protection During Left Atrial Ablation: A Systematic Review And Meta- Analysis", "Authors": "Leung Lisa, Gallagher Mark, Santangeli Pasquale, Tschabrunn Cory, Guerra Jose, Campos Bieito, Hayat Jamal, Atem Folefac, Mickelsen Steven, Kulstad Erik", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Thermal damage to the esophagus is a risk from radiofrequency (RF) ablation of the left atrium for the treatment of atrial fibrillation (AF), with the most extreme type of thermal injury resulting in atrio-esophageal fistula (AEF), with a correspondingly high mortality rate. Various approaches have been developed to reduce esophageal injury, including power reduction, avoidance of greater contact-force, esophageal deviation, and esophageal cooling. One method of esophageal cooling involves direct instillation of cold water or saline into the esophagus during RF ablation. Although this method provides limited heat-extraction capacity, studies of it have suggested potential benefit. Objective We sought to perform a meta-analysis of existing studies evaluating esophageal cooling via direct liquid instillation for the reduction of thermal injury. Methods We reviewed Medline for existing studies involving esophageal cooling for protection of thermal injury during RF ablation. A meta-analysis was then performed using random effects model to calculate estimated effect size with 95% confidence intervals, with outcome of esophageal lesions, stratified by severity, as determined by post-procedure endoscopy. Results A total of 9 studies were identified and reviewed. After excluding pre-clinical and mathematical model studies, 3 were included in the meta-analysis, totaling 494 patients. Esophageal cooling showed a tendency to shift lesion severity downward, such that total lesions did not show a statistically significant change (OR 0.6, 95% CI 0.15 to 2.38). For high grade lesions, a significant OR of 0.39 (95% CI 0.17 to 0.89) in favor of esophageal cooling was found, suggesting that esophageal cooling, even utilizing a low-capacity thermal extraction technique, reduces lesion severity from RF ablation. Conclusions Esophageal cooling reduces lesion severity encountered during RF ablation, even when using relatively low heat extraction methods such as direct instillation of cold liquid. Further investigation of this approach is warranted.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003228"}
10.1101/19000877
[ 0.2007473260164261, 0.16979753971099854, -0.3323676288127899, 0.30028221011161804, -0.36130034923553467, -1.107694387435913, 0.17099379003047943, 0.39598193764686584, 0.3922118842601776, 0.06375531107187271, -0.3595487177371979, -0.6258244514465332, 0.28565752506256104, 0.038478706032037735, -0.16171403229236603, -0.30501589179039, -0.6300628781318665, -0.033731576055288315, -0.1852385252714157, -0.17521770298480988, -0.06992495805025101, 0.7276445627212524, -0.4265994429588318, -0.20094619691371918, -0.2018410563468933, -0.02269924245774746, 0.4603484272956848, -0.2025865912437439, 0.9344472289085388, 0.3863852024078369, -0.5044480562210083, -0.6694345474243164, -0.13631084561347961, -0.8881219625473022, -0.3253476023674011, 0.3556213974952698, 0.24767529964447021, -1.3538888692855835, -0.15101879835128784, -0.33726274967193604, 0.39044609665870667, 0.19470062851905823, 1.001129388809204, -0.5959764122962952, -0.7524566650390625, -0.5379969477653503, -0.38247206807136536, -0.03852304071187973, -0.05272438004612923, -0.2806166410446167, -0.5671338438987732, -0.12521442770957947, -0.1136358454823494, -0.39234432578086853, 0.4903455674648285, -0.0622481107711792, 0.374161958694458, 0.0401245653629303, -0.7254436016082764, 0.6118296384811401, 0.7388736605644226, -0.5787482857704163, 0.9273487329483032, -0.7705987691879272, 0.7113040685653687, 1.3862766027450562, -0.9097465872764587, 0.01909521408379078, -0.5623396635055542, 0.4309238791465759, -0.3153517246246338, -0.05906272679567337, -0.26965224742889404, 0.15504509210586548, 0.2535298764705658, -0.49167346954345703, 0.13261933624744415, -0.18688763678073883, 0.05140634626150131, -0.5879058241844177, 0.4907992482185364, 0.2118828445672989, 0.5340622663497925, -0.05295166000723839, -0.5108307003974915, -0.28646475076675415, 0.12348736822605133, -0.08412204682826996, 0.020916638895869255, 0.29059579968452454, 0.13789351284503937, 0.6953884959220886, -0.08598517626523972, 0.3900344669818878, 0.3033435642719269, 1.241105556488037, -0.3181774318218231, 0.15379935503005981, -0.6411974430084229, 0.10670523345470428, 0.8513834476470947, 0.37210163474082947, 0.0596977099776268, 0.47335928678512573, -0.6012082695960999, 0.3913640081882477, 0.41467079520225525, -0.28337761759757996, -0.13708649575710297, -1.0609228610992432, 0.12678435444831848, -0.24193814396858215, -0.3115799129009247, -0.08504607528448105, 0.08110157400369644, 0.8988666534423828, -0.29581770300865173, 1.1041293144226074, -0.7210525274276733, 0.8237881064414978, -0.7656928896903992, 0.08602650463581085, 0.2538675367832184, -1.0704658031463623, 0.1320577710866928, -0.16394910216331482, 0.40504464507102966, 0.5117835402488708, -0.15421715378761292, 0.040190428495407104, -0.046607956290245056, -0.6492363810539246, -0.005706806667149067, 0.9911393523216248, -0.3569830060005188, -0.6724849343299866, 0.3683532774448395, 0.14322663843631744, 0.297362357378006, -0.3775765001773834, -0.6556158065795898, -0.08392909169197083, 0.490439772605896, 0.9896264672279358, 0.06316632777452469, 0.7183425426483154, -0.5093206763267517, -1.0792793035507202, -0.9393621683120728, 0.05651061236858368, 0.2417057901620865, 0.7566580772399902, 0.06301978975534439, 0.07074876129627228, 0.8711005449295044, -0.19899551570415497, -0.8134985566139221, 0.1688309758901596, 0.26781782507896423, 0.054777856916189194, -0.48891913890838623, 0.41920316219329834, 0.16282905638217926, 0.9714180827140808, -0.6998113989830017, -0.018907196819782257, -0.08014342933893204, 0.005593168083578348, 0.14024412631988525, -0.7817363739013672, 0.40628302097320557, 0.7567620277404785, -0.5344554781913757, -0.27063122391700745, 0.5665475726127625, 0.8611212968826294, 0.9748955965042114, 0.3375476598739624, -0.07191170752048492, 0.7044957876205444, 0.45059046149253845, 0.437308669090271, 1.1937276124954224, 0.8185408115386963, -0.24981705844402313, -0.009802631102502346, -0.43286117911338806, -0.4624364376068115, 0.13178882002830505, -0.4749027490615845, -0.18899595737457275, -0.1378406137228012, -0.9730371832847595, 0.8973023891448975, -0.2605833113193512, 0.015971675515174866, 0.40976041555404663, -0.004096065182238817, 0.5667881369590759, -0.06296410411596298, -0.8444722294807434, 1.0879626274108887, -0.08151882886886597, 0.4594759941101074, -0.33676445484161377, 1.0867723226547241, 0.5354490280151367, 0.3048785626888275, -0.4001423120498657, -0.1953820288181305, 1.2740716934204102, 0.24538050591945648, -0.8801566958427429, 0.2640574872493744, 0.23322124779224396, -0.6807841658592224, -0.7982515692710876, 0.05901705473661423, -1.101669430732727, -0.4081149101257324, -0.5107316970825195, 0.7221639752388, 0.6585400104522705, -0.11849012970924377, -0.43298739194869995, -0.1548612415790558, 0.23742665350437164, 0.44889360666275024, -0.760364294052124, -0.8706337213516235, 0.4846745431423187, 0.44070756435394287, 0.17518813908100128, 0.6425296664237976, 1.0774993896484375, 0.8723268508911133, -0.03532014414668083, 0.4590299129486084, 0.1930786520242691, -0.026954758912324905, 0.4953104257583618, 0.28926336765289307, 1.2783317565917969, -0.35499149560928345, 0.07535660266876221, 0.2976127862930298, -0.11345060169696808, -0.14518770575523376, 0.10246436297893524, 0.20374712347984314, -0.5619946122169495, 0.8311790227890015, 0.5162116289138794, 0.20747075974941254, -0.45354965329170227, -0.02538887783885002, 0.5718256235122681, 0.5702167749404907, -0.32140183448791504, -0.4886435270309448, 0.5002984404563904, 0.4407832622528076, 0.0023654138203710318, 0.4253448247909546, 1.0579520463943481, 0.11622108519077301, -0.04363049194216728, 0.2957278788089752, 0.26285359263420105, -0.7508415579795837, -0.17331096529960632, -0.9976022243499756, -1.1521546840667725, -0.9979761838912964, -0.6352991461753845, 0.12140096724033356, 0.4900951087474823, -0.5288131237030029, 0.38936907052993774, -0.24408304691314697, 0.3481709361076355, -0.0974431186914444, 0.04541371017694473, 0.4514399766921997, 0.31333625316619873, -0.22641441226005554, -0.9755952954292297, -0.07943069189786911, 0.056973956525325775, 0.9567093253135681, 0.2665286362171173, -0.3336479365825653, 0.30886176228523254, -1.847916841506958, 0.48228055238723755, -1.073994517326355, 0.07958686351776123, -0.16003070771694183, -0.15256619453430176, -0.5616492033004761, 0.599854588508606, 0.20309031009674072, 0.11287897825241089, 0.11423847079277039, -0.7515764832496643, 0.7443309426307678, -0.36162182688713074, 0.2880484461784363, 0.47025009989738464, 0.2189815640449524, -0.0693654716014862, 0.7667192816734314, -0.03709201514720917, 0.12517991662025452, -0.9009405374526978, 0.5505532622337341, -0.11894229799509048, -1.0311830043792725, -0.17984040081501007, 0.14665880799293518, -0.5499835014343262, -0.36445778608322144, -0.19854438304901123, 0.1273958534002304, -0.30788010358810425, 0.5020180344581604, 0.17698615789413452, -1.1002188920974731, 0.2349792867898941, -0.2894899845123291, -1.1916347742080688, 0.390057772397995, -0.09648621827363968, 0.36099398136138916, 0.1828661859035492, -0.09848135709762573, -0.02976423315703869, 0.24037989974021912, 0.49091657996177673, 0.2659945487976074, 0.7322901487350464, -0.15851587057113647, -0.0986170619726181, -0.01979491300880909, -0.17546413838863373, -0.23212653398513794, 0.4016721546649933, -0.1811225414276123, -0.40665823221206665, 0.1277124434709549, -0.7060952186584473, 0.5874947309494019, 1.0250322818756104, -0.22860434651374817, 0.12506116926670074, 0.9577588438987732, 0.16296900808811188, -0.06387661397457123, 0.057470496743917465, 0.4831766188144684, 0.029288211837410927, 0.16076317429542542, -0.03754820674657822, 0.6334367394447327, -0.8460108637809753, -0.4848417341709137, 0.8231539726257324, -0.8794852495193481, 0.6276832818984985, -0.8158832788467407, 1.1190483570098877, -0.2086065411567688, -0.247236967086792, 0.20726165175437927, -0.0617033950984478, -0.0584552139043808, 0.7410488724708557, 0.6700963973999023, 0.7125081419944763, -0.5133143067359924, 0.5538721680641174, -0.14043202996253967, 0.634967565536499, -0.009024321101605892, -0.006625445559620857, 0.2575441896915436, -0.4764944314956665, 0.8572412729263306, -0.08922935277223587, 0.031134003773331642, 1.147897720336914, -0.02385450154542923, 0.13972102105617523, -0.18648086488246918, -0.8683370351791382, 0.249261274933815, -0.283967524766922, 0.1137857660651207, -0.02282445877790451, -0.26604992151260376, 0.3195415437221527, 0.023257432505488396, -0.06382180005311966, 0.4424498379230499, 0.48971256613731384, 0.31098461151123047, -0.37959063053131104, -0.036859069019556046, 0.14849399030208588, -0.20835520327091217, -0.6936964392662048, -0.29665493965148926, 0.31741249561309814, 0.21788552403450012, 0.41309818625450134, 0.1812296211719513, -0.5533201694488525, -0.541776180267334, -0.32739824056625366, -0.27064815163612366, -0.6328305602073669, 0.059788335114717484, -0.11935293674468994, 0.39759549498558044, 0.02148878388106823, -0.6409572958946228, -0.366099089384079, -0.3425842225551605, -0.22968724370002747, 0.6515180468559265, 0.06602821499109268, -0.9565934538841248, -0.36289656162261963, 0.37630510330200195, -0.03976057469844818, -0.36359384655952454, -0.14984853565692902, 0.36341792345046997, 0.5075099468231201, -0.1324266791343689, -0.34383711218833923, -0.011485246010124683, 0.10141356289386749, 0.042395561933517456, -0.2536318600177765, 0.4245235025882721, 0.6027008295059204, 0.256178617477417, 0.7134001851081848, -0.4898093044757843, 0.517512321472168, -0.35282617807388306, 0.7948237061500549, 0.360350102186203, -0.1326141506433487, -0.23773303627967834, 0.14786259829998016, 0.017621763050556183, -0.393587201833725, -0.6255122423171997, -0.5772852301597595, -0.18177860975265503, 0.3204212188720703, -0.12956686317920685, -0.36988192796707153, 0.8347079157829285, -0.6809617877006531, -0.2941848337650299, 1.3927621841430664, -0.3089020550251007, -0.039438892155885696, -0.5785089731216431, -0.658592700958252, -0.4701523184776306, 0.1569843888282776, 0.1058015376329422, 0.20405369997024536, -0.41437840461730957, -0.3641737699508667, 0.04207170754671097, 0.17908628284931183, 0.5474998950958252, -0.5965035557746887, -0.1802617758512497, -0.58799809217453, -0.09499958157539368, -0.45388200879096985, -0.3387833535671234, -0.22180406749248505, 0.620793342590332, -0.22494231164455414, -0.42588722705841064, -0.5025722980499268, -0.455289751291275, -0.591143012046814, -0.3589615225791931, -0.12065476924180984, 0.13009130954742432, -0.5336558818817139, -0.5456454157829285, 1.0942233800888062, -0.7136616110801697, -0.13243387639522552, 0.4966588616371155, 0.5889489054679871, -1.0180552005767822, -0.41395482420921326, -0.07565730810165405, -0.7664857506752014, -0.42695626616477966, 0.25990891456604004, 0.006659016013145447, -0.877372145652771, 0.14869332313537598, -0.20303712785243988, 0.3322303295135498, 0.09482821822166443, 0.13732919096946716, -0.2999219596385956, 0.2461603432893753, 0.13638728857040405, -0.5534866452217102, -0.8602038025856018, -0.09702359139919281, -0.033114999532699585, -0.06715832650661469, -0.19873321056365967, -0.6273139119148254, -0.6573752760887146, -1.2161259651184082, -0.029329579323530197, -0.6800830960273743, 0.19287188351154327, -0.3926819860935211, -0.39199569821357727, 0.21185803413391113, 0.19408993422985077, 0.18342554569244385, 0.006423769053071737, -0.23533697426319122, -0.46274369955062866, 0.42971035838127136, 0.028666021302342415, -0.5877370834350586, 0.016718106344342232, -0.5313804745674133, 0.7368151545524597, 0.7716653347015381, -0.3495350480079651, 0.030359311029314995, -0.21035785973072052, -0.3309738337993622, 0.04879989102482796, 0.9903916716575623, -0.13410811126232147, -0.5210545659065247, 0.26253706216812134, 0.6672312021255493, -0.1932663917541504, 0.03899644687771797, -0.3347974717617035, 0.9948216080665588, -0.8799284100532532, 0.07302539795637131, -0.4626741111278534, -1.1584484577178955, -0.6235598921775818, 0.21831156313419342, 0.9439164996147156, -0.6910198330879211, 0.15999479591846466, 0.12333741039037704, -0.00964937824755907, 0.14943143725395203, 0.3833399713039398, -0.743883490562439, -0.5004059672355652, -0.4753580689430237, -0.28790199756622314, -0.27094200253486633, 0.657548189163208, -0.23618635535240173, 0.26882222294807434, 0.012162529863417149, -0.3365580439567566, -0.32923081517219543, 0.4208095073699951, 0.6181475520133972, -0.9432570934295654, -0.16542001068592072, -0.13277095556259155, 0.23231779038906097, 0.5066825747489929, 0.06290837377309799, 0.19074314832687378, -0.38621634244918823, 0.3685157299041748, -0.7893680334091187, -0.6459934115409851, -0.8889428973197937, -0.6225599050521851, 0.32157275080680847, 0.8616092801094055, -0.33579716086387634, -0.17757324874401093, 0.6258910298347473, -0.12172224372625351, -0.4767850935459137, 0.7987471222877502, -0.6021699905395508, -0.10225194692611694, 0.7280424237251282, 0.0657869502902031, -0.7047037482261658, -0.4188445210456848, -0.34508490562438965, 0.20696738362312317, 0.09283173829317093, 0.148169606924057, 0.08845451474189758, -0.8757225275039673, 0.21631120145320892, 0.42247864603996277, -0.45827242732048035, -1.2888760566711426, 0.0991261899471283, 0.07062454521656036, 0.13950380682945251, -0.3446977436542511, -0.1030346006155014, 0.6450190544128418, 0.3575950562953949, 0.7233849763870239, 0.1875647008419037, 0.1256193071603775, -0.0012869385536760092, -0.2625868320465088, 0.20074665546417236, -0.10294094681739807, -0.12399209290742874, 0.8093234896659851, -0.041868746280670166, -0.07422150671482086, 0.04186026006937027, -0.07150847464799881, -0.6284841299057007, 0.5693169236183167, 0.3051362633705139, -0.3654099106788635, 0.003589223138988018, -0.10916116088628769, -0.21612662076950073, 0.31135597825050354, 0.7125805616378784, -0.5664635896682739, 0.9718538522720337, -0.218866229057312, -0.7849456071853638, -0.23125140368938446, 0.5587334632873535, 0.38551318645477295, 0.19039221107959747, 0.04035564139485359, 0.14955897629261017, 0.7227600812911987, 0.8294534087181091, 0.3505665361881256, 0.020826537162065506, -0.6419833898544312, -0.5976423025131226, -0.03297053650021553, 0.33257201313972473, -1.1656612157821655, -0.3042115271091461, 0.38010820746421814, -0.4953870177268982, -0.6284038424491882, -0.1796143352985382, 0.8109992742538452, -0.44434013962745667, -0.00259430636651814, -0.9486316442489624, 0.25083401799201965, -0.25200966000556946, -0.64622962474823, 0.08472782373428345, -0.9482417106628418, -0.058863431215286255, 1.0346319675445557, -0.6534998416900635, -0.87419593334198, -0.6430312395095825, 0.5602563619613647, 0.5821294784545898, 0.22764787077903748, -0.6636108160018921, -0.8157150149345398, 0.010816567577421665, 0.9051242470741272, 0.14688831567764282, -0.20734889805316925, 0.5411075353622437, -0.8175699710845947, 0.06512261927127838, 0.43339627981185913, 0.4441039264202118, -0.1182391345500946, 0.49460190534591675, -0.39587002992630005, -0.44437864422798157, -0.5298254489898682, 0.3850327432155609, 1.043286681175232, -0.9286183714866638, -0.6746563911437988, -0.5220898389816284, 0.4866531789302826, -0.10594207793474197, 0.17663614451885223, -0.41665026545524597, 0.2661566436290741, 0.3473217785358429, 0.3110933005809784, -0.08612699806690216, 0.6718730330467224, 0.48221635818481445, 1.0121089220046997, 0.17298771440982819, 0.02587497979402542, -0.017917364835739136, -1.106338620185852, -0.4948245882987976, -0.30017057061195374, -0.720069408416748, 0.1866329312324524, -0.20477356016635895, 0.4148562550544739, -0.22672773897647858, 0.09640573710203171, -0.13034552335739136, 0.9540160894393921, 0.41043516993522644, 0.09195413440465927, 0.2990822196006775, 0.1281733363866806, -0.44345754384994507, -0.24720707535743713, -1.2308486700057983, -0.6099616289138794, 0.4469790756702423, 0.009551431983709335, -0.2961340546607971, -0.8843497037887573, -0.6297644972801208, 0.43269070982933044, -0.3889411985874176, 0.38593825697898865, 0.12753896415233612, 0.8547226190567017, -0.2111736238002777, 0.5885027050971985, 0.5722159147262573, 0.23988887667655945, -0.1858249306678772, 0.5494418144226074, -0.4712439477443695, -0.3718396723270416, 0.5329724550247192, 0.16810084879398346, 0.057521674782037735, 0.043841078877449036, -0.41600412130355835, -0.42919692397117615, -0.2209823578596115, -0.2730998396873474, 0.5366465449333191, 0.3260102868080139, -0.8736457228660583, -0.17042192816734314, 0.2861626446247101, -0.08035413175821304, -0.47423896193504333, 1.010452151298523, 0.37576448917388916, -0.7916692495346069, -0.6715177893638611, 0.5553778409957886, 0.8600178956985474, -0.23518002033233643, 0.574452817440033, -0.026531726121902466, 0.768088161945343, -0.24748459458351135, 0.23236200213432312, 0.38244763016700745, 0.5927006602287292, 0.1788608282804489, 0.4068118929862976, 0.162063330411911, 0.6198369860649109, 0.8800362944602966, 0.6729430556297302, -0.015567861497402191, 0.7015494108200073, 0.33943837881088257, -0.36952096223831177, -0.10303694009780884, -0.17119573056697845, 0.424664169549942, 0.5295175313949585, 0.18387608230113983, 0.3889450132846832, -0.6004748344421387, 0.14766216278076172, -0.312969446182251, -0.6303077936172485, 0.6025498509407043, 0.005071379244327545, -0.5850052237510681, -0.3355359435081482, 0.6140430569648743, 0.8857123255729675, 0.30147358775138855, 0.283223420381546, 0.468109667301178, 0.618691623210907, 0.40361085534095764, 0.6161398887634277, 1.0386147499084473, -0.20088879764080048, -0.9169183969497681, -0.454298198223114, -0.28473228216171265, -0.19526448845863342, -0.13404440879821777, -0.13580217957496643, 0.21626509726047516, 0.1377038061618805, 0.5528576374053955, -0.07169631123542786, -0.42333248257637024, 0.6525667309761047, -0.4608651399612427, -0.08951498568058014, 0.1777772605419159, 0.16081349551677704, -0.07927973568439484, -0.4020202159881592, 0.3499334156513214, 0.2762753367424011, -0.3092128038406372, 0.04755867272615433, 0.05077861621975899, 0.4201608896255493, 0.09299100935459137, 0.01617635041475296, -1.4391708374023438, -0.1806524097919464, 0.5885028839111328, -0.03147190436720848, -0.28189051151275635, -0.30107495188713074, -0.24296070635318756, -0.4835551679134369, 0.5061411261558533, 0.4682185649871826, -0.45599520206451416, -0.23610803484916687, -0.28122949600219727, -0.01224618311971426, -0.412644624710083, -0.7322744131088257, -0.7947983741760254, -0.05110851675271988, -0.6490453481674194, -0.42394042015075684, -0.12218651175498962, -0.020552905276417732, -0.20266251266002655, -0.35869085788726807, 0.04068140685558319, 0.45503923296928406, -0.5399805903434753, 0.24314899742603302, -0.829882025718689, 0.8084033727645874, 0.4829959571361542, -0.5788824558258057, -0.3573191165924072, -1.012959361076355, -0.15482085943222046, -0.043129824101924896, -0.5275745391845703, -0.6809635758399963, 0.33619165420532227, 0.4272928833961487, 0.21550153195858002, 0.37572500109672546, -0.06787092238664627, -0.06133714318275452, 0.2994273900985718, 0.581701397895813, -0.1701732575893402, 0.10590311139822006, 0.2892617881298065, 0.15166233479976654, -0.4849185049533844, -0.2780284583568573, 0.33341413736343384, -0.25377729535102844, -0.11371831595897675, -0.12940029799938202, 0.4781801104545593, -0.21544711291790009, -0.5290318131446838, 0.24738740921020508, 1.07918381690979, 0.2765217423439026, -0.261373370885849, -1.0270582437515259, -0.5423423647880554, -0.8776870965957642, 0.6439093947410583, -0.36616048216819763, 0.034441523253917694, -0.1064164936542511, -0.07407400757074356, 0.2949043810367584, -0.8796255588531494, 4.186635971069336, 0.530123233795166, 0.11890225112438202, -0.5994749665260315, 0.7215073704719543, 0.5751377940177917, -0.16073386371135712, 0.07951483130455017, 0.6107252836227417, -0.11153171211481094, -0.4167245924472809, 0.6627549529075623, -0.15025575459003448, -0.24556276202201843, 0.8983097672462463, 1.1624337434768677, -0.7702062726020813, 0.15234631299972534, -0.6656222343444824, -0.4934225380420685, -0.7625177502632141, 0.10990165919065475, -0.5529517531394958, 0.5077017545700073, 0.003782705869525671, 0.17962367832660675, 0.294603556394577, 0.4713287949562073, 0.16180625557899475, -0.41203755140304565, 0.3284960687160492, -0.772260844707489, 0.25685808062553406, -0.6476500630378723, 0.05133327841758728, 0.9943847060203552, -0.43916815519332886, 0.3554156720638275, -0.15347455441951752, -0.3967123031616211, 0.17886696755886078, 0.005208789836615324, -0.047158800065517426, -0.7107177972793579, -0.205206498503685, 0.20057134330272675, -0.3396594822406769, 0.25941288471221924, 0.4883517622947693, -0.424785315990448, 0.7753180861473083, -1.2055996656417847, 0.4200458824634552, -0.01630769856274128, -0.7908504605293274, -0.5111279487609863, 0.06394844502210617, -1.0387191772460938, 0.0482797771692276, -0.3022189736366272, 0.6147948503494263, 0.343618243932724, -0.4136205315589905, 0.24900570511817932, 0.20573289692401886, 0.6976577639579773, 1.163844347000122, 0.17378221452236176, 0.38913384079933167, -0.1948532611131668, -0.07465919107198715, -0.7609444260597229, -0.36594781279563904, -0.6582927703857422, 1.42056405544281, 0.8624444603919983, 0.1250796914100647, -0.06492400914430618, 0.7684823870658875, -1.052442193031311, 0.019907845184206963, -0.12262505292892456, 0.3678748607635498, -0.842557430267334, 0.1621045470237732, 1.016365647315979, -0.5525513291358948, -0.3668643534183502, -0.4717181324958801, 0.5856611728668213, 0.5637154579162598, 0.2634712755680084, 0.011687956750392914, 0.17584802210330963, -0.42206838726997375 ]
{"Title": "A Needs Analysis of Parents Following Sudden Cardiac Death in the Young", "Authors": "McDonald Kristie, Sharpe Louise, Yeates Laura, Semsarian Christopher, Ingles Jodie", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT The sudden cardiac death (SCD) of a young person is a devastating event for any parent. Inherited heart disease is often either identified or assumed to be the cause. Few studies have explored the psychosocial impact to the surviving at-risk family members. We sought to investigate the needs of parents who have experienced the SCD of their child (\u226445 years). A quantitative needs analysis questionnaire was developed based on semi-structured interviews, including one focus group, and a review of relevant literature. There were 38 parents who completed a cross-sectional quantitative survey. Parents\u2019 perceived needs for information and support spanned medical, psychosocial, spiritual and financial domains. Medical information and support needs were identified as the most important domains, followed by psychosocial, spiritual and financial information and support needs. Importantly, psychosocial information and support needs were reported as the most unmet need, endorsed by 54% of parents. Medical information and support needs were reported as unmet by almost one third of parents. The two most endorsed needs were \u201cTo have the option of whether or not you would pursue genetic testing for yourself or family members\u201d and \u201cTo understand what happened\u201d. This work demonstrates for the first time, the multifactorial needs of parents after SCD in the young. With the greatest unmet need reported as psychosocial needs, there is clear necessity to find ways of integrating psychological support in to the care of families after SCD in the young. KEY QUESTIONS What is already known about this subject? There is currently very little known about the needs of families following a sudden cardiac death due to inherited heart diseases. We know there is significant risk of poor psychological outcomes including posttraumatic stress and prolonged grief, even years after the death, however this is one of the first studies to formally evaluate the needs of parents during this time. What does this study add? We show that medical information and support needs are ranked very highly, but psychosocial support needs are the most unmet. Our findings provide a platform for developing an approach to delivering psychosocial support interventions in this population. How might this impact on clinical practice? Currently clinical and research efforts in this setting focus on clinical and genetic aspects of care. Here we show the critical need to also focus on the psychological care needs in this population. These data will help to guide services in integrating psychological support in to their multidisciplinary clinic models.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000877"}
10.1101/19002089
[ 0.05035119876265526, -0.04273403063416481, -0.0839538499712944, 0.11710154265165329, -0.5706227421760559, -0.6221684217453003, -0.4160042405128479, 0.20255842804908752, -0.4850301742553711, 0.6809056997299194, 0.12860199809074402, -0.7308825850486755, -0.1738571673631668, -0.40218716859817505, -0.022458674386143684, -0.19319188594818115, -0.7157469987869263, -0.03133690357208252, -1.3497825860977173, 0.4212477505207062, 0.7158730626106262, -0.06111820787191391, -0.5712237358093262, 0.23688139021396637, -0.6771140694618225, 0.6312810778617859, 0.04945392534136772, 0.007749949116259813, 0.8877202868461609, 0.5717014670372009, 0.5532801747322083, -0.7110239863395691, 0.15565218031406403, -0.8955113291740417, -0.510936439037323, 0.457797646522522, 0.6009687185287476, -1.2948522567749023, 0.3944661617279053, -0.18892468512058258, 0.7245103716850281, -0.33548274636268616, 0.0830436423420906, -0.9098005890846252, -0.6143162846565247, -0.22955159842967987, -0.4110715389251709, -0.9993786811828613, -0.2749878466129303, -0.659337043762207, -0.3715100884437561, 0.08341927826404572, 0.018884753808379173, 0.09591583907604218, 0.16703669726848602, -0.19797542691230774, 0.9153715968132019, 0.06862042844295502, -0.8050784468650818, -0.2116338312625885, 0.797216534614563, 0.1315905749797821, 0.5941904783248901, -1.4537041187286377, 0.2976049780845642, 1.1130961179733276, -0.1730145812034607, -0.19624580442905426, -0.7044932246208191, -0.16025136411190033, -0.7013538479804993, -0.2062709778547287, -0.4175490140914917, -0.25794732570648193, 0.31878969073295593, -0.14793989062309265, 0.35475170612335205, -0.6036853194236755, 0.3415620028972626, -0.22512409090995789, 0.48106664419174194, 0.1687006652355194, -0.1796165555715561, 1.018314242362976, -0.12409946322441101, 0.030986573547124863, 0.44538962841033936, 0.7257840037345886, 0.3412410020828247, -0.6134744882583618, 0.06021896377205849, 0.2993989586830139, -0.36157581210136414, 0.3232955038547516, 0.5857334136962891, 1.1455624103546143, 0.05417841672897339, 0.2047356814146042, 0.5456930994987488, -0.718056857585907, 0.8065025210380554, 1.0364774465560913, -0.3483864963054657, 1.042052149772644, -1.2467880249023438, 0.3891841471195221, 1.145477533340454, 0.021986501291394234, -0.9468857645988464, -1.0280970335006714, 0.00695071229711175, 0.32780081033706665, -0.10179167985916138, 0.438732773065567, -0.33227938413619995, 1.1181507110595703, -0.4055868089199066, 0.26866722106933594, -0.49918416142463684, -0.6227278709411621, 0.046338725835084915, 0.11427127569913864, 0.12375442683696747, -0.5560229420661926, 0.9152653217315674, 0.4058871865272522, -0.0024897048715502024, 0.3868074119091034, -0.2578769326210022, -0.5139913558959961, -0.48720234632492065, -0.2544918656349182, 0.2628818452358246, 0.35361167788505554, -0.5007820725440979, 0.25363337993621826, -0.7814878821372986, 0.8690174221992493, -0.47912347316741943, -0.4230474829673767, -0.42045316100120544, 0.22379229962825775, -0.3448242247104645, 1.3060946464538574, -0.14446032047271729, -0.23017920553684235, -0.4983350336551666, -1.0674628019332886, -0.012467237189412117, 0.4546503722667694, -0.2503308057785034, 0.09910870343446732, 0.13311976194381714, -0.0472634956240654, 0.13324220478534698, -0.14787960052490234, -0.43189558386802673, 0.7300930619239807, -1.0175597667694092, -0.44407349824905396, -0.4389360845088959, 0.03645293414592743, -0.9988764524459839, 1.3366568088531494, -0.07574887573719025, 0.6079174876213074, -0.1250651776790619, 0.09881734102964401, 0.2958340048789978, -0.3541834354400635, 0.3020642399787903, -0.05228433012962341, -0.526290774345398, -0.02005733922123909, 0.17042818665504456, 1.211545705795288, 0.9709190726280212, 0.2507129907608032, 0.910295844078064, 0.05147342011332512, -0.24436098337173462, -0.22041741013526917, 0.23076468706130981, 1.0770888328552246, 0.27831894159317017, -0.3025491237640381, -0.6890047192573547, -0.5953297019004822, 0.07606840133666992, 0.5116816759109497, -0.23244446516036987, 1.276597261428833, -1.3900121450424194, 0.6836060285568237, 0.37481778860092163, 0.6158282160758972, 0.3972444534301758, 0.5812790989875793, 0.22128550708293915, -0.02079611085355282, -0.4001486599445343, 1.4680652618408203, -0.19980743527412415, 0.5992667078971863, -0.1486312448978424, 0.1519898772239685, 0.15645365417003632, 0.553946316242218, -0.5664104223251343, 0.48735207319259644, 0.09155144542455673, -0.20455840229988098, -0.027582889422774315, 0.13817313313484192, 0.44731491804122925, -0.9576326608657837, -0.23952838778495789, 0.2752832770347595, -0.21199177205562592, -0.33109480142593384, -0.09574925899505615, 0.19211377203464508, -0.07113548368215561, 0.1400083601474762, 0.30488666892051697, -0.06366289407014847, 1.2166471481323242, 0.11224879324436188, -0.228715181350708, 0.3083886206150055, -0.07108260691165924, 0.8756815791130066, 0.16613571345806122, 0.5448256134986877, 0.4422042965888977, 0.5919792056083679, 0.36122092604637146, 0.17382338643074036, 0.9133818745613098, 0.5315791368484497, 0.5785512328147888, 0.4585903584957123, 1.053125262260437, 0.5399876832962036, 0.15622961521148682, 0.7382641434669495, -0.39621761441230774, 0.2627919018268585, -0.08816195279359818, -0.7046810984611511, -0.7262451648712158, 1.0393949747085571, -0.3622046113014221, 0.5458656549453735, -0.9030868411064148, 0.1784447878599167, 0.4311825931072235, 0.3861391842365265, -0.2166430950164795, -0.8612866997718811, -0.451438844203949, -0.46465277671813965, 0.5647943615913391, 0.11355637013912201, 0.5722153782844543, 1.0284695625305176, 0.08145386725664139, 0.6513471603393555, -0.09186700731515884, -0.8049097061157227, -0.6879855394363403, -0.6103007793426514, -1.7442576885223389, -1.0085246562957764, -0.01598558947443962, -0.1866186261177063, 0.28699415922164917, -0.4504762291908264, -0.3325088620185852, 0.4926048815250397, 0.46523499488830566, -0.3008038401603699, 0.08455592393875122, 0.8994523286819458, 0.5150828957557678, -0.0439530685544014, -1.0208781957626343, 0.4833005964756012, -0.5484549403190613, -0.10859047621488571, 0.32782307267189026, -1.3544076681137085, 0.05694137513637543, -0.8306272029876709, 1.0525972843170166, -0.5787712335586548, -0.6977241635322571, -0.1370829939842224, -0.6183330416679382, -0.6780399084091187, -0.08604005724191666, -0.22983373701572418, 0.42422744631767273, 0.61309415102005, -0.6584038138389587, 0.7658664584159851, 0.32368388772010803, 0.04727908596396446, 0.6771277785301208, 0.06539492309093475, -0.47853076457977295, 0.9138550758361816, -1.2645916938781738, 0.12120679020881653, -0.2310769110918045, 0.386009156703949, 1.0552489757537842, -0.7543476223945618, 0.2630164921283722, -0.8909794688224792, -0.5857743620872498, -0.48222583532333374, -0.16494221985340118, -0.4021799564361572, -0.26532137393951416, -0.11078862845897675, -0.6964049935340881, -0.9920409917831421, -0.43686071038246155, -1.0095266103744507, -0.8344728946685791, 0.44974368810653687, -0.009492630138993263, 0.9168961048126221, 0.416731059551239, 0.5513108372688293, -0.5562097430229187, -0.13873878121376038, 0.08053959906101227, 0.41864654421806335, 0.3238216042518616, -0.749853789806366, 0.4727780520915985, 0.39982739090919495, -0.11529604345560074, 0.17260242998600006, 0.4329438805580139, -0.2838599979877472, -0.29518353939056396, -0.17509640753269196, -0.6290298700332642, 0.17931179702281952, 0.32156655192375183, -0.2674407660961151, 0.00532272644340992, 0.038674648851156235, 0.061107438057661057, 0.17954391241073608, 0.1808401644229889, 0.17922556400299072, -0.20780488848686218, -0.13827891647815704, -0.3417697250843048, 0.3591664731502533, -1.0533877611160278, -0.4292120337486267, 0.7677543759346008, 0.07063436508178711, 0.7272058129310608, -0.4453001022338867, 1.0309264659881592, -0.8199099898338318, -0.4260314404964447, -0.35322436690330505, 0.14149893820285797, 0.06942671537399292, 0.7734520435333252, 0.08700984716415405, 1.3837250471115112, -1.366841435432434, 0.3354548215866089, 0.8695471286773682, 1.1314060688018799, 0.40426790714263916, 0.20346857607364655, 0.3717036843299866, -0.5809773802757263, 0.16327141225337982, 0.033769190311431885, 0.10487235337495804, -0.09600949287414551, 0.3645590841770172, -0.1356370896100998, -0.06653844565153122, -0.6282774209976196, -0.7395673394203186, 0.4257873296737671, 0.9180082082748413, 0.3955737352371216, -0.8334294557571411, 0.40788528323173523, -1.2223255634307861, 0.2105809599161148, 0.48485058546066284, 0.5746341347694397, 0.06388483196496964, -0.5286216735839844, 0.5420963764190674, 0.4892623722553253, -0.22745996713638306, 0.26982465386390686, 0.18969950079917908, -0.317127525806427, 0.12170229852199554, 0.10329701006412506, -0.10100587457418442, -0.20157618820667267, 0.017409812659025192, -0.23976805806159973, -0.6551409363746643, -0.6743375658988953, 0.4713336229324341, -0.06923064589500427, 0.7249018549919128, 0.22897972166538239, -1.2257734537124634, 0.022355305030941963, -0.26424479484558105, 0.6951732039451599, 0.9273099899291992, 0.5058116316795349, -0.802451491355896, -0.03975505754351616, 0.4571329355239868, -0.8873700499534607, 0.3886006772518158, 0.1354040950536728, -1.5254449844360352, 0.487998902797699, -0.24440616369247437, -0.12284889817237854, -0.08476260304450989, -0.8372620344161987, 0.3453168272972107, 0.40065068006515503, 0.34405967593193054, 0.6611950397491455, 0.4736325442790985, -0.08260375261306763, -0.03680356591939926, 0.7911032438278198, -1.4623831510543823, 0.31737804412841797, -0.567743718624115, -0.09453065693378448, 0.10334919393062592, 0.6530722975730896, -0.2876659035682678, -0.6978676319122314, -0.9533858895301819, -0.21800638735294342, -0.3513084650039673, 0.6805070638656616, -0.09536130726337433, -0.14776389300823212, 0.8269399404525757, -0.5046308040618896, -0.08861259371042252, 0.738618016242981, 0.20496168732643127, -0.2631159722805023, -0.6406419277191162, 0.43259668350219727, -0.6905009150505066, 0.2836862802505493, -0.17501261830329895, -0.1188211590051651, 0.3016180396080017, 0.0003027951461263001, 0.02586047537624836, -0.5062077045440674, 0.04969592019915581, 0.04305217042565346, -0.21362103521823883, -0.16020746529102325, -0.07463735342025757, -0.6822396516799927, -1.024101734161377, -0.5998472571372986, 0.3229624032974243, -0.05055168271064758, -0.9600302577018738, -0.6681736707687378, 0.5182898640632629, -0.18017585575580597, -0.5680431127548218, -1.021889567375183, 0.46412280201911926, 0.1576588749885559, 1.0072457790374756, 0.504992663860321, -0.677204430103302, -0.6192836761474609, 0.5941746234893799, 0.6702114343643188, -0.47054922580718994, -0.5565796494483948, -0.28973913192749023, 0.1726619154214859, 0.6718984842300415, -0.041494306176900864, -0.1488494873046875, 0.3304183781147003, 0.4158690869808197, 0.23337063193321228, -0.3987450897693634, 0.5983561277389526, -0.45695775747299194, 0.04799335449934006, 0.541263222694397, -0.6654900908470154, -0.6661129593849182, -0.07910218834877014, 0.8606919646263123, -0.5795760750770569, 0.0744493380188942, -0.23185785114765167, -1.1701844930648804, -1.161579966545105, -1.1110570430755615, -0.043758634477853775, -0.8669381141662598, 0.08807623386383057, -0.9563049077987671, -0.3395523428916931, -0.07903555035591125, 0.0725201815366745, 0.42631077766418457, 0.09873346239328384, -0.32514992356300354, -0.4467639625072479, 0.04288448765873909, -0.7555789947509766, -0.3690248131752014, -0.19568006694316864, -0.05835748463869095, 0.6113302707672119, 1.3129520416259766, 0.7076140642166138, -0.1886725127696991, -0.09812789410352707, 0.4719284772872925, 0.9576514959335327, 0.059562865644693375, -0.5949835181236267, 0.1874495893716812, 0.5540084838867188, 0.5691263675689697, -0.2971089780330658, 0.6355943083763123, -1.0744869709014893, 0.5353589653968811, -0.08095888793468475, 0.40440404415130615, -0.4546346366405487, 0.31574225425720215, -0.14536958932876587, 0.055933788418769836, 0.8583109378814697, -0.39837801456451416, 0.8956916332244873, -0.08127768337726593, 0.1052231639623642, 0.036388978362083435, 0.45859217643737793, -0.8535003066062927, -0.4552936851978302, -0.8572474122047424, -0.7942126393318176, 0.47480711340904236, 0.12287017703056335, 0.5358912348747253, 0.23376423120498657, -0.09153532236814499, 0.41448667645454407, -0.6295675039291382, 0.5972689390182495, 0.6983094811439514, -0.33713415265083313, -0.5088732838630676, 0.4548988342285156, 0.13328959047794342, 0.6685858368873596, 0.25562775135040283, 0.25669094920158386, -0.40226346254348755, -0.4092116355895996, -0.11103644222021103, -0.40534883737564087, -0.7394391894340515, -0.08075065910816193, 1.0889942646026611, 0.7215226292610168, 0.14264056086540222, 0.45599880814552307, -0.2324572652578354, -0.22899475693702698, -0.28497591614723206, 0.1702427864074707, -0.20915623009204865, 0.6075853705406189, 0.5249400734901428, -0.04164592921733856, -1.149622917175293, -0.12979041039943695, 0.10930968821048737, -0.2995765507221222, -0.1259632706642151, 0.4072977900505066, 0.18528707325458527, -0.2933955490589142, 0.00943805743008852, 0.16943146288394928, -0.7093906998634338, -0.7637749314308167, -0.07242614775896072, -0.21958360075950623, 0.23852643370628357, -0.1425527036190033, -0.6677597761154175, 0.4460847079753876, 0.253405898809433, 0.8547765016555786, 0.16012603044509888, -0.4449104964733124, -0.28825175762176514, 0.0758277028799057, -0.7073462605476379, -0.9563726186752319, 0.28730106353759766, 0.44384753704071045, -0.019732408225536346, 0.1495196521282196, -0.060244083404541016, 0.22157138586044312, 1.3433572053909302, -0.517677366733551, 0.5488796234130859, -0.8473467826843262, -0.08587147295475006, -0.504227340221405, 0.5104765295982361, -0.6258196234703064, 0.002178070368245244, 0.4062589108943939, 0.8285074234008789, -0.5578494668006897, -0.9847695827484131, -0.38384494185447693, -0.22326654195785522, 0.2762856185436249, 1.1760952472686768, -0.823232114315033, -0.005277921911329031, 0.7811616659164429, 0.5893463492393494, -0.2766508460044861, -1.0019279718399048, -0.9528895616531372, -0.8565990328788757, -0.5848020911216736, 0.4464648365974426, -0.7641459703445435, -0.2713804841041565, 0.4771850109100342, 0.20891021192073822, -0.9037208557128906, -0.9083876609802246, 0.5522937774658203, -0.6746864318847656, -0.7353987693786621, -0.834373950958252, 0.6777629256248474, -1.0249632596969604, 0.1992018073797226, -0.039455778896808624, -0.7763383388519287, 0.02150932140648365, 0.6835975646972656, -0.5497747659683228, 0.4685589671134949, -0.3519913852214813, 0.799425482749939, -0.36940398812294006, 0.8387897610664368, -0.27874886989593506, -0.2297699898481369, -0.3874684274196625, 0.4707283675670624, -0.3217315673828125, 0.4106452763080597, 1.378574013710022, -0.3040613532066345, 0.3993833065032959, 0.3819933831691742, -0.3928835391998291, -0.5651879906654358, 0.12947595119476318, -0.27138063311576843, -0.41813069581985474, -0.19675332307815552, 0.6700989007949829, 0.41400793194770813, -0.7645580172538757, -0.440408855676651, -0.7319141030311584, 0.4058396518230438, 0.17409935593605042, -0.4558434784412384, 0.7220670580863953, 0.8073756098747253, -0.2115635722875595, 0.8198315501213074, -0.350858598947525, 0.3818032741546631, -0.058875810354948044, 0.24086864292621613, 0.1922866851091385, -0.0217733234167099, -0.07220065593719482, -0.7470234632492065, 0.03674819692969322, 0.20007328689098358, -0.2419406622648239, -0.16914501786231995, -0.30095428228378296, -0.10807032138109207, 0.07165015488862991, 0.49773722887039185, -0.012144138105213642, 0.5044645667076111, 0.5391392111778259, 0.004680465906858444, -0.05039048567414284, -0.7380248308181763, -0.655953049659729, -0.4407729506492615, -1.1148308515548706, -0.048390354961156845, 0.10379853844642639, -0.08946216851472855, -0.5391397476196289, -0.6151211857795715, -0.40498387813568115, 0.4410489797592163, -0.0067693451419472694, 0.81486976146698, -0.048474062234163284, 0.08412131667137146, -0.2984122335910797, -0.242391899228096, 0.5418345928192139, -1.2083780765533447, 0.17005065083503723, -0.4960181713104248, 0.2152879238128662, -0.4352268576622009, -0.06593357026576996, 0.043588787317276, -0.1068148985505104, -0.6731151342391968, -0.4834395945072174, -0.1396573781967163, 0.0981265977025032, -0.0943656787276268, -0.43125736713409424, 0.7418035864830017, 0.11444747447967529, 0.1229896992444992, -0.7045708298683167, -0.18151353299617767, -0.3201412260532379, 0.6074548363685608, 0.042872704565525055, -1.1355997323989868, 0.04981832206249237, 0.09374990314245224, 0.5984423160552979, -0.22293949127197266, 0.7789608836174011, -0.549860954284668, 0.8287352919578552, -0.12692277133464813, 0.7873566150665283, 0.6290987730026245, 1.4897233247756958, 0.8312228918075562, 0.24432633817195892, -0.07288718968629837, 0.7910897731781006, 1.1475588083267212, -0.2537459433078766, 0.2402142733335495, 0.2541927099227905, -0.06121903657913208, 0.38583263754844666, -0.0018798715900629759, -0.5723748803138733, 0.582358717918396, -0.394020676612854, 0.027692731469869614, 0.2519536018371582, 0.14577175676822662, 0.7810187935829163, 0.1828261762857437, -0.72784423828125, 0.4488254189491272, -0.5001388192176819, -0.487585186958313, -0.5275151133537292, 1.0300534963607788, 0.6315258145332336, 0.02824314683675766, 0.5783731341362, 0.1654415726661682, 0.35347068309783936, 0.3231586515903473, -0.42887479066848755, 0.5569124221801758, -0.09615948796272278, -0.8403903245925903, -0.07855630666017532, 0.4297863245010376, 0.37611159682273865, 0.1791152060031891, 0.0293839443475008, -0.9992913007736206, -0.17011021077632904, 0.19669024646282196, -0.3787381649017334, -0.21596284210681915, 0.7640852332115173, 0.2213495522737503, -0.30736324191093445, -0.4291515052318573, -0.11498977243900299, -0.19560770690441132, -0.3281458020210266, 1.2215851545333862, 0.1283799260854721, 0.019666092470288277, -0.13116207718849182, 0.1422402411699295, 1.0465080738067627, -0.25862225890159607, 0.7666411995887756, -0.220470130443573, 1.310904860496521, 0.9332146048545837, 0.2248910516500473, 0.3117073178291321, -0.4302923381328583, -0.6538827419281006, 0.13493043184280396, 0.034385036677122116, 0.21746906638145447, -0.022357981652021408, -0.7138626575469971, 0.0961499959230423, 0.3784329295158386, -0.4069429039955139, -0.4925658106803894, -0.2208840698003769, 0.1075267344713211, 0.11731665581464767, 0.1983138471841812, -0.11859327554702759, -0.02676531858742237, -0.48661816120147705, 0.3714493215084076, 0.3449309468269348, -0.19888655841350555, 0.15259824693202972, 0.9550867676734924, -0.25175023078918457, 0.5122652649879456, -0.18088355660438538, -0.18400444090366364, -0.617805540561676, -0.8556486368179321, -0.42831355333328247, -0.32918432354927063, -0.34832289814949036, -0.6149005889892578, 0.26968032121658325, -0.38314563035964966, -0.16257262229919434, 0.5662853121757507, -0.4692825973033905, -0.7685828804969788, 0.7747935056686401, 1.0700340270996094, 0.17059192061424255, 0.6837449073791504, 0.5358928442001343, 0.038536202162504196, 0.053549617528915405, 0.41587790846824646, 0.49073389172554016, 0.08208359032869339, -0.3791418671607971, 0.16945044696331024, 0.08215273916721344, -0.0076022944413125515, -0.6568430066108704, 0.9150972962379456, -0.05741865932941437, 0.03824968636035919, -0.5427714586257935, -1.2993882894515991, -0.6386216282844543, -0.7054187059402466, 1.3924771547317505, -0.41975677013397217, 0.6954204440116882, -0.33472737669944763, -0.42092496156692505, 0.31285062432289124, -0.8765649199485779, 3.826453924179077, 0.8420985341072083, 0.27498552203178406, -0.21450349688529968, 1.1898114681243896, 0.385375440120697, 0.6037082672119141, 0.5999224185943604, 0.011320246383547783, 0.5422446131706238, -0.2802697420120239, 0.7902849912643433, -0.16767072677612305, -0.10369716584682465, 0.592902660369873, 0.1698617786169052, -0.8100616335868835, -0.012914544902741909, -0.44067442417144775, -0.6959958672523499, -0.35033515095710754, 0.7446959018707275, 0.5026066899299622, -0.0028477641753852367, -0.048897452652454376, -0.36822330951690674, -0.1096387580037117, -0.16656474769115448, -0.6227608323097229, -0.8741128444671631, 0.09006097912788391, -1.0118919610977173, 0.14889340102672577, -0.5972955226898193, -0.1946636438369751, 0.5513929128646851, 0.13685066998004913, 0.18568956851959229, 0.30049005150794983, 0.10668738931417465, -0.18583153188228607, -0.11883467435836792, -0.5456584692001343, -0.4121188521385193, 0.10133446753025055, -0.11868087202310562, -0.16184291243553162, 0.18669864535331726, 0.49780601263046265, -0.43959373235702515, 0.36433151364326477, -0.8376004099845886, 0.40671342611312866, -0.22210828959941864, -1.3660560846328735, -0.019040534272789955, -0.07373137027025223, -1.198377251625061, 0.0846109539270401, 0.13420243561267853, 0.5793932676315308, 0.009371603839099407, -0.1857258826494217, 0.4831821620464325, 0.9336196184158325, 0.6967272758483887, 0.26262474060058594, 0.6598756313323975, -0.5009695291519165, -0.38045525550842285, 0.022377291694283485, -0.5924165844917297, -0.8765372037887573, -0.13864107429981232, 0.9426979422569275, 0.14591141045093536, -0.14741864800453186, 0.22135435044765472, -0.364581435918808, -0.7126248478889465, -0.3425971567630768, -0.49132639169692993, -0.26221033930778503, 0.276676744222641, 0.5337469577789307, 0.7283685207366943, -0.3267156481742859, 0.3924941420555115, -0.9806023836135864, 0.5217666029930115, 0.40640464425086975, -0.18049322068691254, 0.3492978811264038, -0.2873607575893402, -0.3179159462451935 ]
{"Title": "Deficient goal-directed control in a population characterized by extreme goal pursuit", "Authors": "Foerde Karin, Daw Nathaniel D., Rufin Teresa, Walsh B Timothy, Shohamy Daphna, Steinglass Joanna E.", "Abstract": "A bstract Computational neuroscience has contributed to understanding compulsive behavior by distinguishing habitual from goal-directed choice through model-free and model-based learning. Yet, questions remain about applying this approach to psychiatric conditions that are characterized by complex behaviors that occur outside the laboratory. Here, we compared individuals with anorexia nervosa (AN), whose self-starvation appears both excessively goal-directed and habitual, with healthy controls (HC) to assess: 1) whether their behavior is characterized by enhanced or diminished model-based behavior, 2) the domain specificity of any abnormalities by comparing learning in a food-specific context as well as in a monetary context, and 3) whether impairments are secondary to starvation by comparing learning before and after initial treatment. Across all conditions, individuals with AN showed an impairment in model-based, but not model-free, learning, suggesting a general and persistent contribution of habitual over goal-directed control, across domains and timepoints.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002089"}
10.1101/19011015
[ 0.10337837785482407, 0.5573899745941162, -0.3794325888156891, 0.8628237843513489, -0.9919482469558716, -0.4895419776439667, 0.05616685748100281, 0.11391154676675797, 0.4999566674232483, 0.4617481529712677, -0.07158786058425903, -1.0588524341583252, 0.24828313291072845, 0.13452522456645966, -0.09694675356149673, 0.1951296180486679, -0.38929328322410583, -0.14805129170417786, -0.2897082269191742, 0.678565502166748, 0.5519164800643921, 0.3039780557155609, -0.8027248978614807, 0.14395014941692352, -0.02354627475142479, 0.485420823097229, 0.21768765151500702, 0.34146377444267273, 1.7346820831298828, 0.379749596118927, -0.37938547134399414, -0.09176145493984222, -0.12572497129440308, -0.9610040187835693, -0.10748419910669327, -0.48067960143089294, 0.19349627196788788, 0.3694441020488739, -0.35455140471458435, -0.32910916209220886, -0.021612856537103653, -0.338016152381897, 0.545089840888977, -0.37683114409446716, -1.1390025615692139, -0.4494769871234894, -1.0143381357192993, -0.151926189661026, -0.11435355991125107, 0.2928902506828308, -0.047489892691373825, 0.20819540321826935, 0.47283458709716797, -0.6886929869651794, 0.4867728650569916, 0.2826961874961853, -0.2902757227420807, 0.5232126116752625, -0.7283997535705566, 0.23178516328334808, -0.16562609374523163, -0.25557440519332886, 0.7298475503921509, -1.0440995693206787, 0.6434529423713684, 1.1813844442367554, 0.06715662777423859, -0.5166531801223755, -0.9512377381324768, 0.29646968841552734, -0.5085210204124451, -0.8354756832122803, -0.2778589725494385, -0.05761820822954178, 0.2282663881778717, -0.8820996284484863, 0.16827553510665894, 0.09065336734056473, -0.1765308380126953, -0.17147718369960785, 0.5237419605255127, -0.28665322065353394, -0.10278303921222687, 0.8629480004310608, -0.30286478996276855, 0.007135539781302214, 0.5802469253540039, 0.7373396754264832, 0.7738962173461914, 0.5874331593513489, -0.1506868302822113, 0.5730639696121216, 0.22331488132476807, 0.018579132854938507, -0.3479699194431305, 0.5461432337760925, -0.1850511133670807, 0.47517701983451843, -0.08234916627407074, -0.01834314502775669, 0.3156333267688751, -0.0689358115196228, 0.2620292603969574, 0.854422926902771, -0.5147373676300049, 0.46374818682670593, 0.2557070255279541, 0.16977675259113312, -0.6176144480705261, -1.0284628868103027, 0.6637779474258423, -0.2751885950565338, 0.05541577190160751, 0.15839144587516785, 0.41312429308891296, 0.6785948872566223, -0.10151294618844986, 0.42299070954322815, -0.523554801940918, 0.39054223895072937, -0.6168269515037537, -0.28999826312065125, 0.4511948525905609, -0.6744701266288757, 0.5560840368270874, 0.46743062138557434, 0.04557948559522629, 0.5274386405944824, -0.5302167534828186, 0.09427133947610855, 0.16902422904968262, 0.41630497574806213, 0.09272364526987076, 0.4622654914855957, -0.3702716827392578, 0.0981430783867836, 0.5269032120704651, 1.263439655303955, -0.30355104804039, -0.27369898557662964, 0.0844048410654068, 0.44429898262023926, -0.41378095746040344, 0.7159722447395325, 0.09380010515451431, 1.468388319015503, -0.6765875816345215, -1.4518488645553589, -0.10734357684850693, 0.1646938920021057, -0.24209867417812347, 0.6058645844459534, 0.25295668840408325, -0.7515231966972351, -0.10766376554965973, 0.17654402554035187, -0.3865835666656494, 0.6965234875679016, 0.04237370565533638, -0.06602191179990768, -0.2271922528743744, 0.4834722578525543, 0.07465511560440063, 0.7498201727867126, -0.9229832887649536, 0.05844193324446678, -0.08006707578897476, 0.3657754957675934, 0.41217300295829773, -0.5218560695648193, 0.8338996171951294, 0.6325860619544983, -0.4392687678337097, 0.06469367444515228, 0.6978013515472412, 0.43410447239875793, 0.72683185338974, -0.06139247119426727, 0.2844429910182953, 0.7224231362342834, 0.09323827177286148, 0.19403645396232605, 0.7484737634658813, 0.408490389585495, -0.4496281147003174, -0.07998837530612946, -0.28820928931236267, -0.3086923062801361, -0.4591781198978424, -0.14292043447494507, 0.08108480274677277, 0.2958182990550995, -0.42010262608528137, 0.6672415137290955, -0.28238457441329956, -0.030534466728568077, -1.1955616474151611, 0.3718785345554352, -0.24137115478515625, -0.5233112573623657, -0.2214813381433487, 0.18804340064525604, -0.2239062339067459, 0.6250109672546387, 0.19489097595214844, 0.8021753430366516, 0.12713606655597687, 0.4436708986759186, -0.2617235481739044, 0.35833418369293213, 0.7651913166046143, 0.5227771997451782, -0.5336469411849976, 0.3969588875770569, 1.2892476320266724, -0.4046226143836975, -0.2878693640232086, -0.7332103848457336, -0.6575435996055603, 0.38758376240730286, 0.2010047882795334, -0.7258380651473999, 0.46161967515945435, -0.2896283268928528, 0.2438827008008957, 0.8631699681282043, 0.48973938822746277, -0.5172631144523621, -0.28223881125450134, -0.9204307198524475, 0.3642057180404663, 0.8647761344909668, -0.42316803336143494, 0.48948556184768677, 0.3454728126525879, 0.7486608624458313, 0.008743020705878735, 0.07906390726566315, -0.2754610776901245, 0.6130469441413879, 0.3106161952018738, 0.6543789505958557, 0.841997504234314, 0.33305224776268005, -0.1455737203359604, -0.03546557202935219, -0.3368994891643524, 0.05157190561294556, -0.9369831085205078, 1.0258476734161377, -0.7532200813293457, 0.6775630116462708, -0.1551104336977005, 0.6809433698654175, -0.4100791811943054, -0.2546798586845398, -0.2684841752052307, -0.03251202031970024, -0.2757151424884796, -0.8879261612892151, -0.7814487218856812, 0.14588011801242828, -0.3087773621082306, -0.13702845573425293, 0.8951050639152527, 1.1299834251403809, 0.3769211173057556, -0.6104593873023987, 0.597914457321167, -0.6215320825576782, -0.527076244354248, -0.3986314833164215, -1.341147780418396, -0.7495672702789307, -0.8315173983573914, -0.24887315928936005, -0.16995713114738464, -0.12969188392162323, 0.5753679275512695, -0.06970430165529251, 0.16758865118026733, -0.33480992913246155, -0.13315442204475403, 0.2745554447174072, 1.061639428138733, 0.7725737690925598, -0.9655684232711792, 0.6225225329399109, -0.3401954174041748, 0.20440104603767395, 0.46393662691116333, -0.8124764561653137, -0.675403892993927, -1.0596733093261719, 0.258511483669281, -0.8555513620376587, 0.1085825115442276, -0.05669688060879707, -0.1439405232667923, -0.016528237611055374, -0.17851614952087402, 0.2943395674228668, -0.07833217829465866, -0.16419142484664917, -0.5933493375778198, 0.4644608199596405, 0.3937801718711853, 0.33765876293182373, 0.4985489845275879, 0.8652298450469971, -0.9098526239395142, 0.5464745759963989, -0.09639979898929596, 0.9790502786636353, -0.5180248618125916, 0.47599726915359497, 0.3262629806995392, 0.18604831397533417, 0.1396499127149582, -0.5035555362701416, -1.0568575859069824, -0.18024469912052155, -0.17721877992153168, 0.1432439088821411, -0.02354719303548336, 0.1868041604757309, -0.4013054668903351, -0.9562956690788269, 0.14825089275836945, 0.19790051877498627, -1.2061278820037842, 0.025315484032034874, -0.13502903282642365, 0.02462957240641117, -0.22371336817741394, -0.5155155062675476, 0.02456897869706154, 0.14099261164665222, -0.06667640805244446, 0.5250709056854248, -0.22248779237270355, -0.44831058382987976, -0.634207010269165, 0.22659847140312195, 0.07234862446784973, 0.043528009206056595, 0.566419243812561, -0.2807628810405731, -0.3100317716598511, 0.24660849571228027, 0.11040667444467545, 0.30117300152778625, 0.17048512399196625, 0.04255529120564461, 0.4648905396461487, 0.0638248473405838, 0.23699676990509033, 0.331514835357666, 0.5631405711174011, 0.5776146054267883, -0.6251800656318665, 0.8018506765365601, 0.6085021495819092, 1.0350099802017212, -0.48099085688591003, -0.9329922199249268, 0.8318858742713928, -0.582625150680542, 0.2591554522514343, -0.845866322517395, -0.07034974545240402, 0.3541685938835144, -0.3907325565814972, 0.5805677771568298, 0.16214925050735474, -0.17271719872951508, 0.8616882562637329, -0.11155103147029877, 0.8969711065292358, -1.6542811393737793, 0.5489179491996765, 0.7350404262542725, 1.1093170642852783, 0.5288501381874084, -0.534306526184082, 0.035452742129564285, -0.1420552283525467, 0.6950935125350952, -0.037110958248376846, 0.35956352949142456, 0.06296601891517639, -0.10473645478487015, -0.860508382320404, 0.1982640027999878, -0.42647671699523926, -0.3631846010684967, 0.26832905411720276, -0.12405940145254135, -0.8212434649467468, -0.40013551712036133, 1.213815689086914, 0.05301738157868385, -0.29508277773857117, 0.04715050756931305, 0.30298128724098206, -0.6864644289016724, -0.8915773034095764, 0.404811829328537, 0.40085694193840027, -0.6358358860015869, -0.09181535243988037, -0.3087192475795746, -0.0992235317826271, -0.46890661120414734, 0.579100489616394, -0.16208380460739136, -1.3517613410949707, -0.26004451513290405, -0.27131322026252747, 0.19801859557628632, -0.06694850325584412, 0.34368568658828735, -0.7025313377380371, 0.1551874876022339, 0.7819870710372925, -0.7428842186927795, -0.31728053092956543, -0.971673309803009, 0.8420478701591492, 0.5572983622550964, 0.012819623574614525, -0.8689298629760742, -0.8773078918457031, 0.022697601467370987, 0.3489396572113037, -0.4670243561267853, 0.3855046033859253, -0.5467489361763, 0.25262048840522766, 0.15246149897575378, -0.2497771680355072, -0.9836283922195435, -0.3394845426082611, 0.22467991709709167, 0.5073076486587524, 0.34291860461235046, 0.9650724530220032, 0.08857807517051697, 0.7869021892547607, 0.6136362552642822, 0.9608510136604309, -0.8541431427001953, 0.3886019289493561, -1.013094425201416, -1.0521128177642822, -0.7006163001060486, 0.2578486502170563, -0.04093695431947708, 0.26774024963378906, -0.25016728043556213, -0.6630039215087891, 0.3448949158191681, 0.6886860132217407, -0.17842859029769897, -0.4716164767742157, 1.0462640523910522, -0.23629719018936157, 0.427730917930603, 1.117194652557373, 0.37733182311058044, -0.18790864944458008, 0.24366238713264465, 0.37647974491119385, -0.537815272808075, 0.6214053630828857, -0.3654472231864929, 0.5688467025756836, -0.12351075559854507, -0.5674117207527161, -0.34237080812454224, -0.5954675078392029, -0.1147255152463913, -0.5801435708999634, -0.2571256458759308, -0.47357824444770813, -0.6018311381340027, -0.7660043835639954, -0.1925213634967804, -1.100140929222107, 0.2871263325214386, 0.40233615040779114, -0.5259642601013184, -0.6160447001457214, -0.08803340047597885, -0.31929007172584534, -0.5263656377792358, -0.1687069684267044, 0.5287726521492004, 0.07922206073999405, 0.09414126724004745, 0.8510122895240784, 0.18676644563674927, -0.231165811419487, 0.46236222982406616, 0.16056309640407562, -0.7268528342247009, -0.08786937594413757, -0.14950524270534515, 0.22182410955429077, -0.48300701379776, -0.16738979518413544, 0.17586441338062286, -0.4311591386795044, 0.3324986696243286, 0.015371863730251789, -0.24288561940193176, 0.8523420691490173, -0.5908465385437012, -0.12211556732654572, 1.5252503156661987, -0.2588483691215515, -1.4255585670471191, -0.2351357489824295, 0.33120208978652954, 0.4017358720302582, -0.01718982309103012, 0.11412850767374039, -0.6033087372779846, -0.44683507084846497, -1.1412209272384644, -0.472087562084198, -0.6447622776031494, 0.38801613450050354, -0.29495111107826233, 0.30965304374694824, 0.1232263371348381, 0.36992937326431274, 0.5291078686714172, 0.11716747283935547, 0.07344309240579605, -0.4295530319213867, 0.994751513004303, -0.057082004845142365, -0.09795067459344864, -0.30825644731521606, -0.4975217580795288, 0.6075676083564758, 1.307783603668213, 0.539132833480835, -0.8375159502029419, 0.666603147983551, -0.21237635612487793, 0.7266013026237488, 0.2946126163005829, -0.42782214283943176, -0.5745388865470886, -0.01826164685189724, 0.5589596629142761, -0.5925728678703308, -0.31485313177108765, -1.2120283842086792, -0.23880605399608612, -0.7526682615280151, 0.05907285958528519, -0.17665600776672363, -0.07433891296386719, 0.3307410478591919, -0.48763275146484375, 0.9226520657539368, -1.2559726238250732, 0.0033876034431159496, -1.066786289215088, 0.05944107100367546, 0.07707729190587997, 0.7198960781097412, -0.9060225486755371, -0.8979538679122925, -0.8236380219459534, -0.6413043737411499, 1.0052489042282104, -0.2782776951789856, -0.004316266160458326, 0.27115222811698914, 0.09320875257253647, 0.0930781289935112, -0.5717542767524719, 0.9797057509422302, 0.7288167476654053, -0.808668851852417, -0.5095707178115845, 0.20634925365447998, 0.21020926535129547, -0.36113929748535156, -0.17563898861408234, -0.014693476259708405, -0.4828146994113922, 0.028798379004001617, 0.0160810723900795, -0.714483380317688, -0.7140393257141113, -0.7026469111442566, 0.5918486714363098, 0.874808669090271, -0.11145751178264618, 0.3878422677516937, -0.17053723335266113, 0.1960005760192871, -0.5487489700317383, 0.9401029348373413, -0.24865984916687012, 0.3939608633518219, 0.8813084959983826, -0.4571877419948578, -0.26135334372520447, 0.3973894417285919, -0.2669629752635956, -0.6836100220680237, -0.34190961718559265, 0.37234485149383545, 0.2676096558570862, -0.705945611000061, 0.21589505672454834, 0.2564653754234314, -0.30124807357788086, -0.7396935820579529, 0.00039979221764951944, 0.049667615443468094, -0.22262108325958252, -0.14559322595596313, 0.32800865173339844, 0.9409155249595642, -0.293341726064682, 0.5941208004951477, 0.2126096934080124, -0.21754860877990723, 0.39075803756713867, -0.06816422194242477, -0.2871205806732178, -0.5728996396064758, 0.21534711122512817, 0.5200739502906799, -0.07455792278051376, 0.5388399362564087, -0.11818122863769531, 0.5939382314682007, 0.18448352813720703, -0.07258400321006775, 0.2631855309009552, -0.5232061147689819, -0.9781277179718018, 0.03280147165060043, 0.3405226469039917, -0.18314960598945618, -0.05138760432600975, -0.5673660635948181, 0.7889435291290283, 0.31901031732559204, 0.060631029307842255, -0.5117499828338623, -0.17913492023944855, 1.1858845949172974, 0.6005023717880249, 0.11767078936100006, -0.13603070378303528, 0.642225980758667, 0.3602134883403778, -0.053507495671510696, -0.4426438808441162, -0.25145402550697327, -0.4785698652267456, -0.4773980379104614, 0.5784435868263245, -1.681039571762085, 0.072991281747818, 0.8333283066749573, -0.4123147130012512, -0.07399925589561462, -0.570557713508606, 1.206584095954895, 0.07857875525951385, 0.17211121320724487, -0.617212176322937, -0.119325652718544, -0.813254177570343, -0.07095504552125931, 0.03271125629544258, -0.7841071486473083, 0.19713449478149414, 0.1947295218706131, -0.5495911836624146, -0.428782194852829, 0.14101152122020721, 0.994481086730957, -0.05940351262688637, 0.3488338887691498, -0.2799924314022064, 0.010315935127437115, 0.010752726346254349, 0.3136155307292938, 0.20022322237491608, -0.11566609144210815, 1.0706534385681152, 0.02167409658432007, 0.8739826679229736, 0.4595794081687927, -0.17240174114704132, -0.7472169995307922, 0.22978857159614563, 0.53169846534729, -0.9866836071014404, -0.9224615693092346, -0.07377301156520844, 0.542584240436554, -0.6384946703910828, -1.0208828449249268, -0.8480208516120911, -0.21910279989242554, -0.7178942561149597, 1.1826300621032715, -1.2251465320587158, 0.8930961489677429, 0.2817746698856354, -0.6827983856201172, 0.3164885640144348, 0.5021622180938721, 0.6589205861091614, 0.021108750253915787, -0.04493899643421173, -0.007151670753955841, 0.5514461994171143, 0.44620251655578613, -0.08146211504936218, 0.5320032835006714, -0.8555073738098145, 0.22069714963436127, 0.10022354125976562, 0.7793376445770264, 0.765133798122406, 0.007514121942222118, 0.04759286716580391, 0.5307206511497498, 0.18610833585262299, -0.36318767070770264, 0.0619870163500309, 0.16793674230575562, -0.5098690390586853, -0.4318777918815613, -0.32144680619239807, -1.1219977140426636, 0.6153359413146973, -0.6770817041397095, 0.35810303688049316, 0.33560675382614136, -0.9044519066810608, 0.536483108997345, 0.6118999123573303, -0.17163242399692535, 0.6042224168777466, 0.30971431732177734, 0.39286836981773376, 0.42357203364372253, 0.3862478733062744, -0.0003715322818607092, 0.9502711892127991, 0.4706595540046692, -0.8641684651374817, -0.3296752870082855, -0.2675608694553375, -0.19385628402233124, 0.004489947576075792, -0.4565511643886566, -0.021083518862724304, 0.36558857560157776, 0.15767456591129303, -0.44388312101364136, -0.5313110947608948, -0.2753289043903351, -0.9682955741882324, 0.4270063042640686, -0.5423187613487244, 0.15503282845020294, -0.10473226010799408, 0.3132118582725525, -0.013197489082813263, -0.4648384749889374, -0.18173743784427643, -0.17631222307682037, 1.1118181943893433, -0.3435896635055542, 0.3459092080593109, 0.07686277478933334, 0.4114561080932617, -0.4550764560699463, 0.21580013632774353, 0.3545725345611572, 0.2819248139858246, 0.6501461267471313, 0.2919313311576843, 0.701407790184021, 0.4704972803592682, 0.9737072587013245, -0.20051272213459015, 0.16380839049816132, 1.1806222200393677, -0.18185067176818848, 0.2935664653778076, 0.04795205220580101, -0.3678663372993469, 0.3250855803489685, 1.2055346965789795, -0.7436621785163879, 0.04213385656476021, 0.20391179621219635, 0.24194194376468658, -0.14143124222755432, -0.17766760289669037, 0.4947059452533722, -1.1437292098999023, -0.07457007467746735, -0.14318524301052094, 0.6606026291847229, 0.5930662155151367, 0.6676810383796692, 0.6022359132766724, -0.9147080779075623, 0.9585878252983093, -0.07447350025177002, 0.1276247501373291, 0.3936452269554138, -0.24760501086711884, -0.36143258213996887, -0.45031529664993286, -0.21899451315402985, -0.11747520416975021, -0.06716377288103104, 0.20059403777122498, -0.37830016016960144, -0.5251442790031433, 0.6040379405021667, -0.2952542006969452, 0.2933056056499481, 0.472244530916214, -0.8758629560470581, -0.8440666198730469, -0.14366741478443146, 0.08274716138839722, -1.1599879264831543, 0.014846429228782654, 0.5146769285202026, -0.6138563752174377, 0.17896097898483276, 0.17796677350997925, -0.22594770789146423, 0.7330880165100098, 0.695654571056366, 0.4865027070045471, -0.13362735509872437, 0.5697396993637085, 0.40910977125167847, 0.06807468086481094, 0.07286364585161209, -0.477896511554718, -0.48498067259788513, 0.17806380987167358, -0.3232932686805725, 0.4318554997444153, 0.025905054062604904, -0.10048313438892365, -0.7043994665145874, 0.24797402322292328, -0.1736801266670227, -0.3194427788257599, -0.8639951944351196, -0.11820726096630096, 0.6704664826393127, -0.6687085628509521, -0.20903944969177246, 0.5331449508666992, -0.8469460606575012, 0.030933469533920288, -0.9060947895050049, -0.20096708834171295, -0.5372441411018372, -0.3693406879901886, -0.9440354704856873, 0.18768350780010223, 0.15003755688667297, -0.06909186393022537, -0.5958746075630188, -0.8343831896781921, -0.35589510202407837, 0.2127734124660492, -0.18678586184978485, -0.6957509517669678, 0.5076931715011597, -0.20511429011821747, -0.004743478260934353, 0.30600661039352417, -0.032320257276296616, -0.026110786944627762, 0.7981148362159729, 0.3143141269683838, -0.5077400803565979, 0.001741733169183135, -0.3324919641017914, 0.37908634543418884, 0.02401883527636528, 0.5706908106803894, 0.007980688475072384, -0.07633303105831146, -0.07333638519048691, -0.614877462387085, 0.539090633392334, -0.7439681887626648, -0.9591856598854065, 0.4913298189640045, 0.28281980752944946, -0.2586459517478943, -1.3254073858261108, -1.0677199363708496, 0.0751224234700203, -0.5775445103645325, 0.8683093786239624, 0.17752884328365326, 0.28900402784347534, 0.5776790380477905, 0.04640168696641922, 0.11643010377883911, -1.0282726287841797, 3.9449942111968994, 1.532561182975769, 0.5938248634338379, -0.43742635846138, -0.0066961138509213924, 0.23105797171592712, 0.5133324861526489, -0.1714899092912674, -0.02275506593286991, 0.2951219975948334, -0.15867772698402405, 0.4585297107696533, 0.001319173607043922, -0.7980639338493347, 0.7108892202377319, 0.0434102863073349, -0.7258847951889038, 0.4228283762931824, -0.014127391390502453, -0.8659361004829407, -0.23533925414085388, 0.7017649412155151, -0.15063664317131042, -0.12500987946987152, 0.42433905601501465, -0.055617958307266235, 0.056920528411865234, 0.0888083204627037, -0.41299429535865784, 0.49823200702667236, 0.0259782113134861, -1.2502901554107666, 0.28741133213043213, 0.0011381928343325853, -0.2168445885181427, 0.6163620352745056, -0.32250890135765076, -0.11537893861532211, -0.3817169964313507, 0.12749044597148895, -0.15590068697929382, -0.5299726128578186, -1.0017859935760498, -0.44419071078300476, -0.31381478905677795, 0.47516557574272156, -0.07303168624639511, 0.6270816326141357, 0.13863225281238556, -0.5619196891784668, 0.9589130282402039, -1.4276351928710938, 0.4604422450065613, -0.3567156493663788, -0.568293571472168, 0.1038486510515213, -0.03448420763015747, -0.6777544021606445, 0.07034153491258621, 0.01052696444094181, 0.6199132800102234, -0.03695734590291977, -0.3982027471065521, 0.18269222974777222, 0.5029536485671997, 0.5464094877243042, 0.7244268655776978, -0.19737868010997772, 0.005828964523971081, -0.049417849630117416, -0.18504737317562103, -0.04551780968904495, -0.7752678394317627, 0.287238210439682, 0.29279839992523193, 0.641434907913208, -0.5605371594429016, 0.5654231905937195, -0.41323384642601013, -0.7208821773529053, 0.2564541697502136, -0.39290672540664673, -0.033915530890226364, -1.11164128780365, 0.31744855642318726, 0.7497644424438477, -0.6752138137817383, 0.04911837726831436, -1.1299045085906982, 0.7960562109947205, -0.45027676224708557, -0.8383249044418335, 0.24187041819095612, -0.08879687637090683, -0.024480529129505157 ]
{"Title": "Exceptionally low likelihood of Alzheimer\u2019s dementia in APOE2 homozygotes", "Authors": "Reiman Eric M., Arboleda-Velasquez Joseph F., Quiroz Yakeel T., Huentelman Matthew J., Beach Thomas G., Caselli Richard J., Chen Yinghua, Su Yi, Myers Amanda J., Hardy John, Vonsattel Jean Paul, Younkin Steven G., Bennett David A., De Jager Philip L., Larson Eric B., Crane Paul K., Keene C. Dirk, Kamboh M. Ilyas, Kofler Julia K., Duque Linda, Gilbert John R., Gwirtsman Harry E., Buxbaum Joseph D., Dickson Dennis W., Frosch Matthew P., Ghetti Bernardino, Lunetta Kathryn L., Wang Li-San, Hyman Bradley T., Kukull Walter A., Foroud Tatiana, Haines Jonathan L., Mayeux Richard P., Pericak-Vance Margaret A., Schneider Julie A., Trojanowski John Q., Farrer Lindsay A., Schellenberg Gerard D., Beecham Gary W., Montine Thomas J., Jun Gyungah R.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Each additional copy of the apolipoprotein E4 (APOE4) allele is associated with a higher risk of Alzheimer\u2019s dementia, such that APOE4 homozygotes have a particularly high risk. While the APOE2 allele is associated with a lower risk of Alzheimer\u2019s dementia, it is not yet known whether APOE2 homozygotes have a particularly low risk. We generated Alzheimer\u2019s dementia odds ratios and other findings in more than 5,000 clinically characterized and neuropathologically characterized Alzheimer\u2019s dementia cases and controls. APOE2/2 was associated with exceptionally low Alzheimer\u2019s dementia odds ratios compared to APOE2/3, 3/3 and 4/4, and the impact of APOE2 and APOE4 gene dose was significantly greater in the neuropathologically confirmed group than in more than 24,000 neuropathologically unconfirmed cases and controls. Finding and targeting the factors by which APOE and its variants influence Alzheimer\u2019s disease could have a major impact on the understanding, treatment and prevention of this terrible disease.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19011015"}
10.1101/19008508
[ -0.32197675108909607, -0.3664093017578125, -0.6728129386901855, 0.8674921989440918, -0.40360116958618164, -0.09741877019405365, 0.5132436156272888, 0.18581122159957886, -0.2705506980419159, 0.7023928761482239, -0.337859570980072, -0.16836677491664886, 0.011076647788286209, 0.5525141358375549, -0.5600612163543701, -0.5727658271789551, -0.4637349545955658, -0.3205251395702362, -0.04642273113131523, 0.4096273183822632, 0.22569401562213898, 0.3750426769256592, -0.9931782484054565, 0.05170927569270134, -0.6331060528755188, 0.925774872303009, -0.19874271750450134, 0.12358523160219193, 1.111595869064331, 1.0695571899414062, 0.20951737463474274, 0.5424296259880066, 0.5253663659095764, -1.1306533813476562, -0.5370643734931946, -0.06702268123626709, 0.021379726007580757, -0.31080934405326843, -0.5133599638938904, -0.2381269782781601, -0.12528228759765625, 0.06635343283414841, 0.012529305182397366, -0.6058011054992676, -0.9866052865982056, 0.45752835273742676, 0.22131416201591492, -0.2963217496871948, 0.014776119962334633, 0.21555981040000916, -0.07862956076860428, -0.41582292318344116, -0.692116916179657, -0.19390666484832764, -0.40866363048553467, -0.7452578544616699, 0.6673942804336548, -0.16078531742095947, -0.653404951095581, 0.20998142659664154, 0.4895930886268616, -0.08342909067869186, 0.6253823637962341, -1.381196141242981, 0.3859553635120392, 0.6057340502738953, -0.575707197189331, -0.0001139006344601512, -0.32761532068252563, -0.5344947576522827, -0.45846226811408997, -0.2668232321739197, -0.2932080030441284, -0.7697460651397705, -0.11067567765712738, -0.26459801197052, 0.23604799807071686, -0.6193442344665527, 0.06423120200634003, -0.6701807379722595, 0.8108395934104919, 0.4657537341117859, 0.3840161859989166, 0.08017586171627045, -0.6586014628410339, 0.2682137191295624, 0.2322567105293274, -0.18087956309318542, 0.5015723705291748, 0.11128982156515121, 0.23703010380268097, 0.4713761806488037, -0.36226382851600647, 0.07175533473491669, 0.7659084796905518, 1.4027578830718994, -0.23261672258377075, 0.19902217388153076, 0.2346772998571396, 0.4044838845729828, 1.4684206247329712, 0.7703567147254944, -0.2897818088531494, 0.5608944892883301, -0.9092254638671875, 0.7286264896392822, 0.2598403990268707, -0.4930272102355957, 0.42575371265411377, -1.1302921772003174, -0.31036561727523804, -0.5931233167648315, -0.5081018805503845, -0.5308545827865601, 0.4093240201473236, 0.3340132236480713, -0.4965108633041382, 0.569409966468811, -0.5200093984603882, 0.7081968784332275, -0.4930609166622162, -0.288176566362381, 0.7177091836929321, -0.5060913562774658, 0.7213149666786194, -0.041803695261478424, 0.46002620458602905, 0.2005045861005783, -0.5461040139198303, -0.5954205393791199, 0.5967700481414795, -0.7732582688331604, 0.23676697909832, -0.07095109671354294, -0.13293568789958954, -0.6176438927650452, 0.21495796740055084, 0.8148297667503357, 0.12716548144817352, 0.2995136082172394, -0.4865034222602844, 0.8632007837295532, -0.2679656147956848, 1.4090535640716553, 0.0734659880399704, 0.6265324950218201, -0.4803418815135956, -0.5918627381324768, -0.8162580728530884, -0.15417201817035675, 0.9956420660018921, 0.1551842987537384, 0.005837128963321447, 0.5866000652313232, 0.05215291306376457, -0.09381972253322601, -0.9072613716125488, 0.28828689455986023, -0.05117666348814964, 0.5126693844795227, -0.8707683086395264, 0.4331226646900177, -0.08872775733470917, 0.3964480757713318, -0.8363361954689026, 0.8699108362197876, -0.04371122270822525, -0.25112634897232056, 0.8968035578727722, -0.3890998661518097, 0.6615443229675293, 0.16400592029094696, -0.5032213926315308, -0.40571531653404236, 0.24620041251182556, 0.8001459836959839, 0.4272856116294861, 0.35759446024894714, -0.12349241226911545, 0.28608161211013794, -0.20051102340221405, 0.5638485550880432, 0.09263278543949127, 0.962954580783844, 0.4181530773639679, -0.16104194521903992, -0.47176897525787354, -0.5863144397735596, 0.1815442591905594, 0.05204368010163307, -0.5904169678688049, 0.46370139718055725, -0.8275266885757446, 0.27659013867378235, 0.7227583527565002, -0.1292227804660797, -0.31743550300598145, -0.3310098350048065, 0.3862038254737854, -0.969498872756958, -0.5878281593322754, 0.13031898438930511, -0.44637832045555115, 1.0909982919692993, -0.4881640672683716, 0.46725866198539734, 0.34860759973526, 0.47969064116477966, 0.03907928243279457, 0.3570895195007324, 0.41403061151504517, -0.023317549377679825, -0.3356761038303375, -0.5501257181167603, 0.7202103137969971, -0.2643246352672577, -0.1008613258600235, -0.05800551176071167, -1.0957763195037842, -0.12227257341146469, -0.5896268486976624, -0.34867098927497864, 0.5452106595039368, -0.18898840248584747, -0.5417149066925049, -0.1801583468914032, 0.5127940773963928, 0.33762577176094055, -0.7985290288925171, -0.20134854316711426, -0.4416246712207794, 0.20927639305591583, 0.10867400467395782, 1.344460368156433, 1.03048574924469, 0.29874810576438904, -0.273459255695343, 0.35590046644210815, 0.97139573097229, -0.049520790576934814, 0.3019893765449524, 0.7705503106117249, 1.0546789169311523, 0.11964059621095657, -1.0253098011016846, 0.6133714318275452, 0.12354616820812225, -0.030276913195848465, 0.03920070827007294, 0.017702054232358932, -0.2101769745349884, 0.051491230726242065, 0.9741576910018921, 1.1838675737380981, -1.0641021728515625, 0.29380398988723755, 0.5086985230445862, 0.44378021359443665, -0.10086642950773239, -0.43723759055137634, -0.25425130128860474, 0.2610221207141876, 0.18370921909809113, 0.2334553748369217, 0.49899566173553467, -0.27144891023635864, -0.3037715256214142, 0.6126887202262878, 0.6548481583595276, -0.08911079913377762, -1.3404451608657837, 0.17030809819698334, -0.7930588126182556, -0.9379166960716248, -0.4198175072669983, 0.571346640586853, 0.19198168814182281, -0.07152094691991806, 0.13149642944335938, 0.06249073147773743, 0.06058599427342415, 0.0340193435549736, 0.7675482630729675, 0.3455146253108978, 0.3663797676563263, 0.2810388207435608, -0.7627869248390198, 0.4550684690475464, -0.2957765758037567, 0.6672943234443665, 0.02590472623705864, -0.45928671956062317, -0.5332121849060059, -0.941057562828064, 0.3566383123397827, -0.14618773758411407, 0.030049121007323265, -0.4838019013404846, -0.4514252245426178, -0.6668932437896729, 0.4439203143119812, -0.4440446197986603, -0.27545928955078125, -0.09355182200670242, -0.5463280081748962, 0.5867663621902466, -0.02734321914613247, 0.18606597185134888, 0.5742031335830688, 0.1687801480293274, -0.488936185836792, 0.2378031462430954, -0.5839502215385437, -0.3017863631248474, -0.9562350511550903, -0.24521180987358093, 0.53956139087677, -0.4089539349079132, 0.0742291808128357, -0.08821210265159607, -0.7558398842811584, -0.11294516175985336, 0.06535714119672775, -0.2297012209892273, -0.5295640230178833, 0.31077632308006287, 0.02124401554465294, -1.8442293405532837, 0.2540227472782135, -0.5013701915740967, -0.83236163854599, 0.2186823934316635, -0.113914854824543, 0.11882041394710541, 0.08692549169063568, -0.703700840473175, -0.6943692564964294, 0.07427824288606644, -0.017310362309217453, -0.1624395251274109, 0.49550947546958923, -0.49591994285583496, -0.011978421360254288, -0.12993784248828888, 0.0775914415717125, 0.5155499577522278, 0.20607802271842957, -0.013990159146487713, -0.415343701839447, -0.13609306514263153, 0.27545449137687683, 0.1849646270275116, 0.4747558534145355, 0.2259804755449295, -0.2654086947441101, 0.646206259727478, -0.6242954730987549, -0.3180474638938904, -0.0167719554156065, 0.39243972301483154, -0.607713520526886, 0.5583453178405762, -0.7019042372703552, -0.4494766891002655, -0.47579288482666016, -0.6036057472229004, 0.24353624880313873, 0.5632397532463074, 0.7767956256866455, -0.04569767788052559, 0.4250684678554535, -0.5683783888816833, -0.42640918493270874, 0.4367763102054596, -0.4065014719963074, -0.756742537021637, 0.8610875606536865, 0.17063766717910767, 0.694659948348999, -1.000765085220337, 0.08568517118692398, -0.0009610814740881324, 1.5475072860717773, 0.18926666676998138, 0.022290579974651337, 0.5510488152503967, -0.9538190960884094, 0.4882672429084778, 0.39145544171333313, -0.7584091424942017, 0.05934501811861992, -0.12445900589227676, 0.4602024555206299, 0.15436726808547974, -0.5910865068435669, -0.22061215341091156, 0.02613583579659462, -0.30339086055755615, 0.14213328063488007, -0.4756920337677002, 0.3192896246910095, 0.5057621002197266, 0.5861965417861938, 0.322463721036911, 0.4969435930252075, 0.5683636665344238, -0.4418635070323944, 0.3052034378051758, -0.342063307762146, -0.5768095254898071, -0.6150742173194885, -0.9311029314994812, -0.4196898639202118, -0.022748515009880066, 0.8085315227508545, 0.039130788296461105, -0.43180662393569946, -0.5873525738716125, 0.31085914373397827, 0.15573148429393768, -0.0026509796734899282, 0.01689193770289421, -0.8668053150177002, 0.6585401892662048, 0.3791378140449524, 0.04000508412718773, -0.5245662331581116, -0.417782723903656, 0.7008110880851746, 0.9464175701141357, -0.5413030385971069, -0.9204218983650208, 0.47944530844688416, 0.40509524941444397, 0.012777638621628284, 0.10649710893630981, 0.16790933907032013, -0.27223843336105347, -0.01089000515639782, -0.4106441140174866, -0.10277990251779556, -0.40218865871429443, -0.02613414265215397, -0.209348663687706, -0.00447147386148572, 0.33419156074523926, 0.9319837093353271, 0.1546415239572525, -0.0010827122023329139, 0.2602458894252777, 0.3734036684036255, -1.092003345489502, 0.07370303571224213, -0.5158823132514954, -0.41667285561561584, -0.2989846467971802, 0.10197822004556656, -0.04684838652610779, -0.41920363903045654, -0.17602288722991943, -0.381274551153183, 0.4523566663265228, 0.05582295358181, -0.2657753825187683, 0.3158351480960846, 0.7222972512245178, 0.2354753166437149, -0.31010720133781433, 1.0325137376785278, -0.3763357698917389, 0.249602273106575, 0.4643053710460663, -0.5874752998352051, -0.9843061566352844, 0.6071547865867615, 0.23658235371112823, -0.10283616930246353, 0.3293369710445404, -0.37544772028923035, -0.014674901962280273, 0.20349416136741638, -0.02727406471967697, 0.1880788952112198, 0.33764374256134033, -0.37047311663627625, -0.35379812121391296, -0.8774690628051758, 0.07231219857931137, -0.907829225063324, 0.17609980702400208, -0.2975982427597046, -0.6113351583480835, 0.20416170358657837, 0.07187743484973907, -0.3415381610393524, -0.7511733174324036, -0.29083383083343506, -0.249312162399292, -0.385235458612442, 0.5633742809295654, 1.2522419691085815, -0.5410230159759521, -0.6288508772850037, -0.16998426616191864, 0.3397350311279297, -0.603974461555481, -0.41590532660484314, -0.08460316807031631, -0.5141638517379761, 0.1211727038025856, -0.39811453223228455, -0.007665737997740507, -0.5479995608329773, 0.030154027044773102, -0.2292371392250061, -0.4012332260608673, 0.7269646525382996, -0.38122862577438354, -0.2548339366912842, 0.40501677989959717, -0.49237385392189026, -0.685723066329956, -0.15642420947551727, 0.04342079907655716, 0.1925351619720459, 0.16445615887641907, -0.06473996490240097, -0.1985807865858078, -0.6379408240318298, -1.294060468673706, -0.11525702476501465, -0.3767028748989105, -0.02554989419877529, 0.3474682867527008, -0.33948883414268494, 0.2519068419933319, 0.39919301867485046, -0.3674784004688263, 0.9467928409576416, -0.17859499156475067, -0.21929802000522614, 0.38776758313179016, 0.2516127824783325, -0.4866749048233032, 0.43814870715141296, -0.5928899645805359, 0.1326625645160675, 0.6816922426223755, 0.8163025379180908, -0.3974192440509796, -0.42321792244911194, -0.023449838161468506, 0.312208354473114, 0.15323500335216522, 0.10321424901485443, 0.131060391664505, -0.400280624628067, 0.1638304442167282, -0.621056079864502, -0.054735347628593445, -1.1138561964035034, 0.7546882033348083, 0.07694297283887863, -0.09123788774013519, -0.15444162487983704, -0.3017385005950928, 0.26769542694091797, 0.02160853147506714, 0.8360796570777893, 0.08869710564613342, 0.2938711941242218, -0.030601274222135544, 0.15521396696567535, 0.7687005996704102, 0.2971523404121399, -0.8902550339698792, -1.1740435361862183, -0.37713468074798584, -0.8819400072097778, 0.2741423547267914, 0.17219099402427673, -0.29485490918159485, 0.4892460107803345, -0.2571633458137512, -0.214374840259552, -0.3158072531223297, 0.3346061408519745, 0.45969927310943604, -0.8076135516166687, -0.3454500734806061, 0.2874320149421692, 0.6810995936393738, 0.24125882983207703, 0.5715339183807373, 0.1477779895067215, -0.4916386306285858, 0.17253679037094116, -0.5234953165054321, 0.07305745035409927, -0.6021676063537598, 0.022296519950032234, -0.16134949028491974, 0.6140044927597046, 0.12711207568645477, -0.1907481998205185, 0.4871880114078522, -1.0285595655441284, -0.49178045988082886, 0.34987446665763855, 0.0028631140012294054, -0.30524352192878723, 1.2142314910888672, -0.3029506206512451, -0.3133090138435364, 0.49643999338150024, -0.20055192708969116, 0.3229224681854248, -0.1724219024181366, 0.27310436964035034, 0.8522785305976868, -1.217636227607727, 0.5849382281303406, 0.46516361832618713, -0.9263855814933777, -0.29690021276474, -0.40784239768981934, -0.45337384939193726, 0.17744991183280945, 0.05772266909480095, -1.0654065608978271, 0.438213050365448, 0.24296116828918457, 0.5838803052902222, -0.011286419816315174, -0.08646968752145767, -0.3944888710975647, -0.08904042094945908, 0.37905219197273254, -0.8726992011070251, 0.12201104313135147, 0.3551676273345947, -0.6073845028877258, -0.09165117144584656, 0.43852996826171875, 0.29158374667167664, 0.30273517966270447, 0.430202454328537, 0.16489428281784058, -1.0743368864059448, -0.6468706130981445, -0.131386861205101, -0.02745979279279709, 0.2898951768875122, -0.03578978031873703, -0.005486391484737396, 0.2449938952922821, 0.008680067956447601, -0.2389654666185379, -0.5497857332229614, 0.6580124497413635, 0.35524219274520874, -0.10201907157897949, -0.16287735104560852, -0.1899345964193344, 0.7079612612724304, 0.17449606955051422, 0.9476161599159241, -0.2318006306886673, -0.8947521448135376, -0.5751011967658997, -0.5046818256378174, -0.6008504629135132, 0.021177735179662704, -0.12795516848564148, 0.28830310702323914, -0.7376216053962708, -0.5049660205841064, -0.18352483212947845, 0.7202275991439819, -0.11935777962207794, -0.06177521124482155, -0.19437310099601746, 1.0517604351043701, -0.7876579165458679, -1.026618242263794, -0.19403652846813202, -0.210407093167305, -0.3075350522994995, 1.290435791015625, -0.8628818988800049, 0.13474424183368683, -0.27133458852767944, 0.15485839545726776, 0.17971216142177582, 0.659546971321106, -0.5569637417793274, -0.7278467416763306, 0.3706181049346924, 0.7271917462348938, 0.4244784116744995, 0.3704497814178467, 1.129490852355957, -0.1298057734966278, 0.4979285001754761, 0.08442490547895432, -0.23813283443450928, -0.25684091448783875, -0.05565731227397919, -0.07820732146501541, -0.9205021262168884, -0.7442439198493958, -0.9615047574043274, 0.5403910279273987, -0.7592411041259766, -0.6281754970550537, -0.5297858119010925, -0.1348126381635666, -0.10027211904525757, 0.22234350442886353, 0.18674050271511078, 0.4669654965400696, 0.03136442229151726, 0.49114587903022766, 0.3291409909725189, 1.1803414821624756, -0.06904898583889008, 0.38543468713760376, 0.051628462970256805, 0.25613340735435486, -0.37221378087997437, -0.8762608766555786, 0.4493587613105774, 1.0765787363052368, -0.19565118849277496, 0.16242824494838715, -1.1157773733139038, -0.07787835597991943, 0.29104548692703247, -0.46821898221969604, 0.5052618384361267, 0.8767138123512268, 0.4308305084705353, 0.2730022370815277, 0.6891353130340576, -0.3254316449165344, 0.02850615419447422, -0.9783312082290649, -1.376929521560669, -0.6499418020248413, 0.8080011010169983, -0.2824329733848572, 0.0020745485089719296, -0.5934723615646362, -0.13626819849014282, 0.2882794141769409, -0.16642233729362488, 0.08504117280244827, 0.22319000959396362, 0.9711507558822632, -0.4745577573776245, 0.6221805810928345, 0.4032632112503052, 0.3863789737224579, -0.41905373334884644, 0.42172908782958984, -0.3921355903148651, -0.6718297600746155, 0.5534336566925049, 0.12872329354286194, 0.5083429217338562, 0.6309381127357483, -0.2043369859457016, -0.0006117670563980937, -0.16207551956176758, -0.07125665247440338, -0.20729580521583557, -0.040942903608083725, -0.5145243406295776, -0.3179177939891815, 0.6360735297203064, 0.9397431015968323, -0.515957772731781, -0.2033519446849823, 0.24586468935012817, -1.4329832792282104, -0.8400359153747559, 0.9333605170249939, 0.9136987924575806, -0.5404171943664551, 0.5294017791748047, 0.06852439790964127, 0.017676187679171562, 0.7296022772789001, -0.39209896326065063, 0.8528506755828857, 0.3235524594783783, -0.12274538725614548, 0.40090569853782654, -0.04466548562049866, -0.07388155907392502, 0.6144780516624451, 0.7949463129043579, 0.15010738372802734, 0.46061182022094727, 0.14660394191741943, -0.046623945236206055, -0.27847373485565186, -0.3467668890953064, 0.06690435111522675, 0.3775562345981598, -0.5305377840995789, 0.38144975900650024, 0.4091945290565491, 0.6351146101951599, 0.09117605537176132, -0.3876825273036957, 0.7654174566268921, -0.9366598725318909, -0.7284614443778992, -0.08977081626653671, 0.36994844675064087, 0.02668651193380356, 0.31928983330726624, 0.3580227196216583, 0.3071642816066742, 1.091041922569275, 0.02066977508366108, -0.8218640089035034, 0.34949755668640137, -0.01432481687515974, -0.6684176325798035, -0.15103758871555328, -0.029458653181791306, 0.1333884298801422, 0.03572552278637886, 0.11092276126146317, 0.022936416789889336, 0.2407761961221695, 0.3538708984851837, -0.5165193676948547, -0.2508589029312134, 0.7940136790275574, -0.283344566822052, -0.09663739800453186, 0.17965629696846008, -0.3324033319950104, -0.08019541949033737, -0.5334614515304565, 0.23627610504627228, 0.11438135802745819, -0.1750042885541916, -0.1737150102853775, 0.9656081199645996, 0.2882872521877289, 0.1701352745294571, 0.13336454331874847, -0.4006679356098175, -0.054979074746370316, 0.7081503868103027, 0.42836061120033264, 0.049454789608716965, -0.2671425938606262, 0.24415132403373718, 0.1449536681175232, 0.13850939273834229, 0.1707760989665985, 0.34042030572891235, 0.27279457449913025, -0.3546828329563141, 0.25382161140441895, 0.012245126999914646, -0.15745867788791656, -1.3712794780731201, -0.014456015080213547, 0.281602680683136, 0.36275559663772583, 0.40566757321357727, -0.32004570960998535, 0.08849339187145233, -0.5640965104103088, 0.182634636759758, -0.28570428490638733, -0.7833015322685242, 0.3334304094314575, -0.651315450668335, 0.5568491220474243, 0.6671836972236633, -0.22933697700500488, -0.8646308779716492, -1.4610556364059448, 0.06293626129627228, -0.23152150213718414, 0.11260611563920975, -1.165663480758667, -0.24572120606899261, 0.2706303894519806, 0.05175124853849411, -0.6496836543083191, -0.7541621327400208, -0.6206606030464172, 0.03519594296813011, 1.1841485500335693, -0.6099832653999329, 1.0597741603851318, 0.414885014295578, -0.129269540309906, 0.21997253596782684, -0.36857178807258606, -0.0025015936698764563, 0.2945931553840637, -0.4506276249885559, -0.17412824928760529, -0.19001473486423492, -0.05400783196091652, -0.9657405018806458, 0.3944711983203888, 0.9397484064102173, 0.010704454965889454, -0.0297415629029274, -0.021944044157862663, -0.28219830989837646, -0.45102041959762573, 1.0608723163604736, -0.4222070872783661, -0.1722564697265625, 0.3201048672199249, 0.41290104389190674, 0.5417062640190125, -1.0225446224212646, 4.109817981719971, 0.9528846144676208, 0.25657716393470764, 0.22248633205890656, 0.9328311085700989, 0.7668205499649048, 0.7841800451278687, 0.19511502981185913, 1.0954867601394653, -0.09971538186073303, 0.07616037130355835, -0.026471862569451332, 0.3496282398700714, 0.2926601469516754, 0.04623332992196083, 0.04587799683213234, -0.8339608907699585, -0.04021849483251572, -0.23693649470806122, -0.8143377304077148, -0.05446111410856247, 0.3191700577735901, -0.22498713433742523, -0.11914131045341492, -0.15729467570781708, 0.0791470929980278, 0.5558013319969177, 0.9043177366256714, -0.15242958068847656, -0.33137741684913635, 0.45913174748420715, -0.31510621309280396, 0.5940853953361511, -0.2979471981525421, -0.7186253666877747, 0.29149705171585083, 0.16212555766105652, -0.779275119304657, 0.2404216080904007, 0.12417475134134293, 0.552195131778717, 0.4140654504299164, 0.2361062467098236, -0.5455957651138306, -0.5030452609062195, 0.4052516222000122, -0.5147483944892883, -0.24754305183887482, 0.17740215361118317, -0.09679563343524933, 1.0023647546768188, -0.7804759740829468, 0.2243739366531372, 0.11993330717086792, -0.5880682468414307, -0.5409024357795715, 0.1274348944425583, -1.0097734928131104, 0.5121220946311951, -0.4684475362300873, 1.0726392269134521, -0.36539143323898315, 0.030833760276436806, -0.365779310464859, 0.36943089962005615, 0.7646245360374451, 0.8721181154251099, -0.28727415204048157, -0.37738901376724243, -0.5123011469841003, 0.003520865924656391, -0.46474936604499817, -0.3624970018863678, -0.03671569749712944, 0.6374009251594543, 0.3381900191307068, -0.09512723982334137, 1.01545250415802, -0.7189176082611084, -0.9067033529281616, 0.0939183160662651, 0.22850623726844788, 0.5679661631584167, 0.3061015009880066, -0.424997478723526, 0.9980019330978394, -0.22929465770721436, -0.2736430764198303, -1.4684772491455078, 0.09081309288740158, 0.8411569595336914, -0.1558101922273636, -0.1373683363199234, -0.06604299694299698, 0.34833887219429016 ]
{"Title": "A conceptual model for pluralistic healthcare behavior: results from a qualitative study in southwestern Uganda", "Authors": "Sundararajan Radhika, Mwanga-Amumpaire Juliet, King Rachel, Ware Norma C.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Introduction Medical pluralism , or concurrent utilization of multiple therapeutic modalities, is common in various international contexts, and has been characterized as a factor contributing to poor health outcomes in low-resource settings. Traditional healers are ubiquitous providers in most regions, including the study site of southwestern Uganda. It is not well understood why patients in pluralistic settings continue to engage with both therapeutic healthcare modalities, rather than simply selecting one or the other. The goal of this study was to identify factors that motivate pluralistic healthcare utilization, and create a general, conceptual framework of pluralistic health behavior. Methods In-depth interviews were conducted between September 2017 and February 2018 with patients seeking care at traditional healers (N=30) and at an outpatient medicine clinic (N=30) in Mbarara, Uganda; the study is nested within a longitudinal project examining HIV testing engagement among traditional healer-utilizing communities. Inclusion criteria included age \u226518 years, and ability to provide informed consent. Participants were recruited from healer practices representing the range of healer specialties. Following an inductive approach, interview transcripts were reviewed and coded to identify conceptual categories explaining healthcare utilization. Results We identified three broad categories relevant to healthcare utilization among study participants: 1) traditional healers treat patients with \u201ccare\u201d; 2) biomedicine uses \u201cmodern\u201d technologies; and 3) peer \u201ctestimony\u201d influences healthcare engagement. These categories describe variables at the healthcare provider , healthcare system , and peer levels that interrelate to motivate individual engagement in pluralistic health resources. Conclusions Patients perceive clear advantages and disadvantages to biomedical and traditional care in medically pluralistic settings. We identified factors at the healthcare provider, healthcare system, and peer levels which influence patients\u2019 therapeutic itineraries. Our findings provide a basis to improve health outcomes in medically pluralistic settings, and underscore the importance of recognizing traditional healers as important stakeholders in community health. STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF THIS STUDY Medical pluralism is common in both high- and low-resource settings, and has been characterized as a factor leading to poor health outcomes for both infectious and non-communicable diseases This study identifies factors that motivate utilization of healthcare in a medically pluralistic community Patients in pluralistic settings perceive clear advantages and disadvantages of both traditional care and biomedicine; characteristics of healthcare providers, the healthcare system, and peer influences motivate patients to engage with particular healthcare modalities Patients often prefer traditional healing instead of biomedicine; this utilization is not simply a function of limited access to biomedical resources Traditional healers should be considered important stakeholders in community health", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008508"}
10.1101/19003236
[ 0.16038134694099426, 0.8755747675895691, -0.2868424355983734, -0.481518030166626, -0.29012030363082886, 0.18097719550132751, -0.2086944878101349, -0.015110409818589687, 0.3947617709636688, 0.5120658874511719, -0.4164049029350281, 0.07214708626270294, 0.4347722828388214, -0.7761008739471436, -0.036623548716306686, 0.1293865591287613, -1.1236279010772705, -0.23942558467388153, -0.7762497067451477, -0.34998592734336853, -0.3184472620487213, -0.20470647513866425, -0.7737657427787781, -0.036060020327568054, -0.5417968034744263, 0.10626976937055588, 0.4998716711997986, -1.1340959072113037, 1.341346025466919, 0.8923971652984619, -0.5107353925704956, -1.124206781387329, 0.3204843997955322, -0.4537854790687561, -0.1804042011499405, 0.4325774610042572, 1.4105201959609985, -0.522262692451477, -0.8990622758865356, -0.5011552572250366, 0.16013489663600922, -0.26993629336357117, 0.25693294405937195, -0.807654082775116, -0.35641080141067505, -0.30153992772102356, -0.023593153804540634, -0.4889208972454071, 0.23976188898086548, -0.7205031514167786, -0.7015639543533325, -0.04785605147480965, -0.17910346388816833, -0.7454750537872314, -0.18672296404838562, 0.1276494860649109, 0.16951052844524384, 0.34693989157676697, 0.5132830142974854, -0.036151859909296036, 0.5704333186149597, -0.1749495565891266, 0.05474132299423218, -1.2569341659545898, -0.24110014736652374, 0.4153355658054352, -0.1645509898662567, -0.10500161349773407, -0.13913151621818542, -0.7091466784477234, -1.107782006263733, 0.2901611626148224, 0.2354791760444641, -0.3690025508403778, -0.5420492887496948, 0.5137714147567749, 0.7893471121788025, 0.5716688632965088, -0.014982422813773155, -0.40660619735717773, -0.43283697962760925, 0.5709612369537354, -0.3548032343387604, 0.00008050593896768987, 0.0633775144815445, -0.531575083732605, 0.8217650055885315, 0.2766273021697998, 0.40111076831817627, -0.5773468017578125, 0.30288732051849365, 0.07562664151191711, 0.4656413793563843, -0.3501237630844116, 0.19266654551029205, 0.7580142021179199, -0.27138349413871765, 0.2704606354236603, -0.015042424201965332, -0.14377854764461517, 0.5910854935646057, 1.6067720651626587, -0.13774026930332184, 0.9621398448944092, -0.7639761567115784, 0.5324420928955078, 0.0028070772532373667, -0.12452898174524307, -0.2819589674472809, -0.4197109341621399, 0.05385200306773186, 0.497371107339859, -0.2387039065361023, 0.583175778388977, 0.2621403932571411, -0.06281173974275589, -0.3705589175224304, 0.35898950695991516, -0.7098249793052673, -0.345640629529953, -0.3679113984107971, 0.2651399075984955, 0.6086604595184326, -0.5076557397842407, 0.30731314420700073, -0.22671055793762207, -0.11850277334451675, 0.5629180669784546, -0.7657720446586609, -0.2573218047618866, 0.06586181372404099, -0.7027008533477783, -0.5406420826911926, 0.8428716063499451, 0.311341792345047, 0.4558488130569458, -0.011987006291747093, -0.07428760081529617, -0.31986671686172485, 0.3775022327899933, -0.6674995422363281, 0.48346105217933655, -0.31864461302757263, 1.4992274045944214, -0.7585585117340088, 0.5223429799079895, 0.34500932693481445, -0.7398909330368042, -0.26550546288490295, -0.10873504728078842, -0.13186882436275482, 0.5592817068099976, -0.4388866722583771, -0.4658428728580475, -0.7556160688400269, 0.27641335129737854, -0.6197497844696045, 0.3121885657310486, -0.4377661347389221, 0.41864001750946045, -0.07924850285053253, -0.3486030101776123, 0.2233363837003708, 0.40401163697242737, -0.7101942896842957, 0.8438093662261963, 0.49580737948417664, -0.36646556854248047, 0.16408179700374603, -0.8673244714736938, 0.18808871507644653, -0.19635145366191864, 0.32036250829696655, -0.46989697217941284, 0.4686606526374817, 0.08367806673049927, 1.1643879413604736, 0.13267599046230316, -0.16302017867565155, 0.38656437397003174, -0.3156367838382721, -0.2416241466999054, 0.4340327978134155, 0.49580681324005127, -0.3982597887516022, 0.36172330379486084, -0.21758782863616943, -0.21992574632167816, 0.1787370890378952, 0.26114317774772644, 0.08676732331514359, 1.3904391527175903, -1.0294159650802612, 0.6362811923027039, -0.5680199861526489, -0.43160146474838257, -0.281471848487854, 0.5909329652786255, 0.3020557165145874, -0.46514976024627686, -0.41880133748054504, 0.732947587966919, -0.7362235188484192, 0.5244991779327393, -1.2630356550216675, 0.5000070929527283, -0.15372124314308167, 0.7933133244514465, -0.44768887758255005, 0.0385298989713192, 0.6127597093582153, -0.04339395463466644, 0.3290708661079407, 0.8114938735961914, 0.4333508610725403, -0.36270079016685486, 0.42018839716911316, 0.13164116442203522, 0.2530917227268219, -0.4203612506389618, 0.3573317527770996, 0.25087815523147583, 0.023540519177913666, -0.1273186355829239, 0.680321991443634, -0.15497563779354095, -0.05599161982536316, 0.40598398447036743, 0.4683948755264282, -0.1323395073413849, 0.3910320997238159, 0.8741602301597595, -0.8918125033378601, 0.7548589706420898, 0.8044307827949524, 0.8336585164070129, 0.1922956109046936, 0.12104097008705139, 0.14346057176589966, -0.18345023691654205, 0.20349150896072388, 0.5108413696289062, 0.5353492498397827, 0.6407291889190674, -0.43802610039711, 0.4697316288948059, 0.17033268511295319, 0.3229583501815796, -0.212690070271492, -0.05722035840153694, -1.053038239479065, 1.0760834217071533, -0.06902225315570831, 0.03549252450466156, -0.22892428934574127, -0.4692557454109192, 0.16794481873512268, 0.20785167813301086, 0.2829306125640869, -1.092994213104248, 0.5293957591056824, -0.18851213157176971, 0.3748408854007721, 0.10480808466672897, 0.2318260669708252, 0.45313674211502075, 0.17849946022033691, -0.15723295509815216, -0.2632482051849365, -0.8107659220695496, -0.858668327331543, -0.5520109534263611, -1.4675662517547607, -0.9498811960220337, -0.180045485496521, -0.6316417455673218, -0.10155869275331497, -0.9026958346366882, 0.5928288102149963, -0.06468908488750458, -0.040831562131643295, -0.0069479504600167274, -0.7205631732940674, 0.6206682324409485, -0.2946752607822418, 0.5911446809768677, -1.3141388893127441, 0.18264876306056976, -0.2590000629425049, 0.7118497490882874, 0.05999106168746948, -0.40216508507728577, -0.989228367805481, -0.5235125422477722, 0.16678310930728912, -0.7011989951133728, -0.10232994705438614, -0.6538522243499756, -0.5087335705757141, -0.8306097388267517, 0.6119195818901062, -0.6269067525863647, 0.007322664372622967, -0.17276190221309662, -0.24508197605609894, 0.27714118361473083, 0.6533538103103638, -0.5377689003944397, 0.4487546682357788, 0.5568574666976929, -0.1161552146077156, 0.8968451023101807, 0.12357679754495621, 0.5325464606285095, -0.40182700753211975, 1.0349267721176147, 0.42251652479171753, -0.45170944929122925, -0.28596657514572144, -0.2519102394580841, -1.188838243484497, 0.045746322721242905, -0.40282243490219116, -0.4435090720653534, 0.08713982254266739, 1.2426776885986328, 0.3673607409000397, -0.8892323970794678, 0.5016942024230957, -0.5183838605880737, -1.0745816230773926, 0.5308281779289246, -0.188350111246109, 0.6755355000495911, 0.6336906552314758, -0.25626078248023987, -0.24321798980236053, -0.18337495625019073, 0.2205020934343338, 0.398391455411911, -0.15332932770252228, -0.13968652486801147, 0.011802703142166138, 0.5176292061805725, 0.11850832402706146, 0.389202743768692, 0.713678240776062, -0.5939226746559143, -0.2460087537765503, -0.03523345664143562, -0.5850704908370972, 0.8655105233192444, 0.128536656498909, -0.22241392731666565, -0.05788806453347206, 0.0756128802895546, -0.4352492392063141, -0.1647956669330597, -0.21545743942260742, 0.5112492442131042, -0.4766160845756531, -0.22637014091014862, -0.32255682349205017, 0.5796148777008057, -0.6432139277458191, -0.37393811345100403, 0.17524351179599762, 0.9121646881103516, 0.6871747970581055, -1.042634129524231, 0.6863137483596802, -0.1395968198776245, -0.3057897090911865, -0.224384605884552, -0.11870065331459045, -0.5443426966667175, 0.8752198219299316, 0.2953298091888428, 1.3340866565704346, -1.2189127206802368, -0.4341680407524109, 0.41683289408683777, 0.6743087768554688, -0.10536771267652512, 1.0483124256134033, 0.3403145968914032, -0.4141547977924347, 0.08590222150087357, 0.48391300439834595, -0.36701393127441406, 0.07352551072835922, -0.03860785812139511, -0.4531833231449127, -0.4405314028263092, -1.0229592323303223, -0.21073725819587708, 0.16675803065299988, 0.2460843324661255, -0.04859607294201851, -0.17163224518299103, 0.624025821685791, -0.4584732949733734, 0.7568275928497314, 0.8478021025657654, -0.12667228281497955, -0.30339717864990234, -0.36402907967567444, -0.3579294681549072, -0.15323813259601593, -1.0304219722747803, -0.3298998177051544, -0.13900086283683777, 0.09323050826787949, -0.31059694290161133, 0.02830677106976509, 0.4618861675262451, -0.7775928974151611, 0.22292567789554596, -0.2587067782878876, 0.485408753156662, -0.1369573175907135, -0.0022657846566289663, -0.8885464072227478, 0.5356159210205078, -0.0685182586312294, -0.2827132046222687, -0.17542096972465515, -0.5425266027450562, 0.12707850337028503, 0.7585915923118591, -0.24756571650505066, -0.25389841198921204, 0.6181001663208008, -0.3244992196559906, -0.4672302007675171, 1.0053385496139526, 0.007554071024060249, 0.03955854848027229, 0.1397963911294937, -0.1928487867116928, -0.31829169392585754, -0.6323705315589905, -0.1136392131447792, -0.28668737411499023, -0.08778315037488937, -0.02297896519303322, 0.43062499165534973, -0.14644761383533478, -0.16732925176620483, -0.17362457513809204, 0.6290159821510315, -0.5072067975997925, 0.752874493598938, -0.31889668107032776, -1.1130861043930054, 0.031985968351364136, -0.3194035291671753, -0.3292190730571747, 0.38005495071411133, 0.15275432169437408, -0.31434446573257446, -0.04881022498011589, 0.24297450482845306, -0.14461009204387665, -1.472817301750183, 0.5904267430305481, -0.22832056879997253, 0.4088229238986969, 1.0293817520141602, -0.38206368684768677, -0.039503831416368484, -0.09157955646514893, 0.10317564010620117, -0.36887127161026, 0.15564826130867004, -0.39055562019348145, -0.2724601924419403, -0.46429094672203064, -0.48528730869293213, 0.2970864772796631, -0.7078518271446228, -0.31184083223342896, 0.14243552088737488, -0.05035213753581047, -0.05439746379852295, -0.15151533484458923, -0.3892625570297241, 0.1928570717573166, -0.47653600573539734, -0.2740260064601898, -0.11066386103630066, -0.10025916993618011, -0.17231611907482147, -0.7027683258056641, -0.7186555862426758, 0.4503096640110016, -0.8714454770088196, -0.00793685857206583, -0.043853048235177994, -0.37249571084976196, 0.9265629649162292, -0.7209527492523193, -0.7204741835594177, 0.5159742832183838, 0.30921071767807007, -0.3549818992614746, -0.16800783574581146, 0.21426403522491455, -0.2362794280052185, -0.1507074385881424, -0.17266470193862915, -0.1749330312013626, -0.4813826382160187, 0.3073517978191376, -0.6242084503173828, 0.8074719309806824, 0.051801204681396484, -0.17930328845977783, -0.6674849987030029, 0.26160287857055664, -0.548154890537262, -1.3803369998931885, -0.17026261985301971, 0.5717693567276001, 0.23401875793933868, -0.02465781383216381, 0.0013072185683995485, -0.7642077803611755, 0.3284573554992676, -0.15543384850025177, 0.5785000324249268, -0.905828595161438, 0.2590632438659668, -0.4023384749889374, -0.632199764251709, -0.23443706333637238, -0.08171204477548599, -0.3299281597137451, -0.1694594770669937, -0.4501901865005493, -0.9028078317642212, 0.2965575158596039, -0.5748211741447449, -0.8315566778182983, 0.1012570858001709, 0.3599712550640106, 0.08864299952983856, 0.7761385440826416, 0.28211820125579834, -0.7314028739929199, 0.2648683488368988, 0.3224417269229889, 0.6173047423362732, 0.7442660331726074, -0.6281993389129639, -0.7259235978126526, -0.25030145049095154, 0.16464662551879883, 0.5370621681213379, -0.24092096090316772, -1.0705534219741821, -0.21767933666706085, -0.502302348613739, -0.267147958278656, -0.5637199282646179, -0.3484218716621399, 0.2660096287727356, -0.7254854440689087, 0.5931244492530823, -0.7832142114639282, -0.18853043019771576, 1.0200660228729248, -0.34989872574806213, 0.3044734299182892, -0.22127577662467957, -0.6337233781814575, -0.8400095701217651, -0.10177529603242874, -0.5562225580215454, 0.5770841240882874, -0.17894458770751953, -0.17971202731132507, 0.05385991930961609, 0.24377186596393585, -0.20441171526908875, -0.33429262042045593, 1.3782684803009033, 0.6327899098396301, 0.10863834619522095, -0.8515318632125854, -0.18950165808200836, -0.3309508264064789, 0.04802577570080757, 0.2669042646884918, -0.1205962747335434, -0.8186890482902527, -0.10696730017662048, -0.025333015248179436, -0.435249924659729, -0.7134910225868225, 0.12999223172664642, -0.07640448212623596, 0.37469789385795593, -0.5024914145469666, 0.7408932447433472, -0.1800260692834854, 0.02231532707810402, -0.46961405873298645, 0.38521480560302734, -0.5770558714866638, -0.08664988726377487, 0.7876294851303101, -0.23749898374080658, 0.17555290460586548, 0.9254431128501892, -0.7373362183570862, -0.30074599385261536, 0.1619292050600052, 0.11604636907577515, -0.028506483882665634, -1.2168930768966675, 0.20977242290973663, -0.4247409999370575, -0.3342369496822357, -0.8287703990936279, 0.12400144338607788, -0.1336924284696579, 0.5409447550773621, -0.22677966952323914, -0.2680160105228424, 0.4677494466304779, -0.4182785749435425, -0.22009675204753876, 0.21180206537246704, -0.06633395701646805, -0.07948284596204758, -0.014452568255364895, 0.1589297205209732, -0.8917559385299683, 0.48613491654396057, 1.041192650794983, -0.2060704231262207, 0.8084403276443481, -0.09205498546361923, -0.39640823006629944, 0.23607228696346283, -0.13899968564510345, 0.1398506909608841, -0.16514350473880768, -0.12204712629318237, 0.13703379034996033, 0.08016175776720047, 0.3024468421936035, -0.029231728985905647, 0.14441029727458954, 0.6111536622047424, 0.27602723240852356, -0.5305782556533813, -0.6555156111717224, 0.4430243968963623, 0.43482503294944763, 0.6191269755363464, -0.35117802023887634, -0.053802669048309326, 0.852742075920105, 0.63291996717453, 0.32611963152885437, -0.2685393989086151, -0.2742224931716919, -0.8677127957344055, -0.6801313161849976, -0.014930609613656998, -0.33674541115760803, -0.7469869256019592, 1.0332424640655518, -0.5760765075683594, -0.48864367604255676, 0.3080143630504608, 0.6041013598442078, -0.24204117059707642, 0.3037661910057068, -0.8039053082466125, -0.2131577730178833, -0.7652145624160767, -0.2918819785118103, -0.2723677158355713, -0.3838748037815094, 0.2084745168685913, 1.105912208557129, -0.12862449884414673, -0.16912266612052917, 1.2569057941436768, 0.23379649221897125, 0.23432649672031403, 0.9742241501808167, 0.04540545493364334, 0.34362712502479553, 0.20105552673339844, 0.5000505447387695, 0.09157532453536987, 0.6851068139076233, 0.5867721438407898, -0.5086460113525391, 0.4309135973453522, 0.7068682909011841, -0.5977345108985901, -0.01541267428547144, 0.05140341445803642, 0.2342771291732788, -0.14151796698570251, 0.19059869647026062, -0.03381863608956337, 0.5110120177268982, -1.1656653881072998, -0.44035136699676514, 0.42715129256248474, -0.21595826745033264, -0.194890558719635, 0.034219153225421906, -0.08499202877283096, 0.6359535455703735, 0.007791752927005291, 0.4178854525089264, -0.7701231241226196, -0.2977202832698822, -0.1017606109380722, 0.09628036618232727, 0.15040501952171326, -0.14927895367145538, 0.13834936916828156, -1.974125862121582, 0.42695289850234985, 0.4953742027282715, -0.43013811111450195, 0.11569442600011826, -0.1777859628200531, -0.13048695027828217, -0.3042443096637726, 0.030152568593621254, 0.49226948618888855, 0.1121048852801323, 0.10286422073841095, -0.09612181037664413, 0.44673413038253784, -0.053770218044519424, -0.7540690302848816, -0.13705116510391235, -0.36412113904953003, -0.5222501754760742, 0.7339144349098206, -0.19248676300048828, 0.38431215286254883, -0.18171752989292145, -0.12186983972787857, 0.47763895988464355, 0.3840879499912262, 0.48917511105537415, 0.31903424859046936, 0.49936097860336304, 0.021023523062467575, -0.03333371877670288, -0.38573023676872253, 0.2873363494873047, 0.5150274634361267, 0.10969506204128265, -0.06976288557052612, -0.2857304811477661, 0.9018881916999817, 0.19555233418941498, 0.5514317154884338, -0.11110325902700424, -0.5796042084693909, 0.14629386365413666, 0.23644210398197174, -0.6102966070175171, -0.31020739674568176, 0.27429115772247314, -0.7265406250953674, 0.48581749200820923, -0.19349552690982819, 0.1294763833284378, 0.027380529791116714, 0.4140796363353729, 0.30382004380226135, -0.4266321063041687, -0.8927942514419556, -0.7593567371368408, 0.28375300765037537, -0.09693638235330582, 0.37604254484176636, 0.16142845153808594, 1.1343134641647339, -0.5998914837837219, -0.6037949323654175, 0.1859937310218811, 0.5492870807647705, 0.6087422370910645, 0.1977778971195221, -0.33391422033309937, 0.9009628891944885, 1.4629284143447876, 0.33453434705734253, 0.9640255570411682, 1.492952585220337, 0.3413373827934265, 0.0993601456284523, 0.43293631076812744, -0.1933319866657257, 0.6848446130752563, -0.32287949323654175, 0.6653762459754944, 0.19980421662330627, 0.33736807107925415, -0.31306490302085876, 0.1643718183040619, -0.20529240369796753, 0.03016422875225544, 0.11281196027994156, -0.8370461463928223, -0.6105119585990906, 0.5088037252426147, 0.5683526992797852, 0.03877785801887512, 0.18838469684123993, 0.5738121867179871, 0.6776452660560608, 0.19936595857143402, 0.15155237913131714, 0.8517894744873047, 0.05308583751320839, -0.22937548160552979, -0.7579588890075684, 1.284799575805664, 0.11726339161396027, 0.2162008136510849, 0.3351716995239258, 0.5248787999153137, -0.31510129570961, 0.7418195605278015, -0.39766430854797363, -0.5205363631248474, 0.21850094199180603, 0.36909574270248413, -0.03046761453151703, -1.215644359588623, 0.42175325751304626, -0.6661586165428162, -0.561881959438324, 0.5087429881095886, -0.7354332208633423, -0.09528060257434845, 0.5310177803039551, 0.3882017731666565, 0.33195844292640686, 1.2429726123809814, 0.5079808235168457, -0.8005270957946777, 1.4345555305480957, 0.3837846517562866, 0.15266454219818115, 0.3540649712085724, 0.2520759403705597, -0.28552794456481934, 0.3751962184906006, -0.6327575445175171, 1.058146357536316, 0.7073591947555542, 0.20935623347759247, -0.3025861084461212, -0.18663112819194794, -0.7999200224876404, 0.3041887879371643, -0.3859439492225647, 0.11800023168325424, 0.22228924930095673, -0.19151630997657776, 0.38134509325027466, 0.5677266716957092, 0.4805391728878021, 0.006009049713611603, 0.1517591029405594, -0.44049176573753357, -0.688771665096283, -0.135171577334404, -0.25118669867515564, 0.15226684510707855, -0.2707619071006775, -0.6827666163444519, 0.08050303161144257, -0.42811471223831177, -0.1760234385728836, 0.2687632143497467, -0.38394078612327576, -0.5680660009384155, 0.879734456539154, 0.3346449136734009, 0.5783836245536804, 0.07119305431842804, -0.0723089650273323, 0.4922803044319153, 0.164311483502388, 0.6767808198928833, 0.12180142849683762, 0.41617029905319214, -0.09903644025325775, 0.23080606758594513, 0.3378148674964905, 0.2698875069618225, -0.43975988030433655, 0.1115691065788269, -0.29035869240760803, -0.3383338153362274, -0.10394091159105301, -0.8239343166351318, -0.7449000477790833, -0.18634341657161713, 0.7173967957496643, 0.13232572376728058, -0.5443655848503113, -0.30256345868110657, 0.056062474846839905, -0.10967330634593964, 1.1212050914764404, -0.03459539636969566, 0.5663245320320129, 0.82765793800354, -0.407697856426239, 0.4127814769744873, -0.513349175453186, 4.150577068328857, 1.1291645765304565, 1.2162601947784424, -0.017896203324198723, 0.8652574419975281, 0.5997068285942078, -0.18747153878211975, -0.5800225138664246, -0.5485934019088745, 0.39240413904190063, 0.2934175431728363, 0.029729358851909637, -0.017577946186065674, -0.35326167941093445, 0.4333042800426483, 0.6203454732894897, 0.19511212408542633, -0.13675008714199066, -0.19717900454998016, -0.8666569590568542, -1.1980862617492676, 0.611118495464325, -0.5201288461685181, -0.038490794599056244, -0.003997229039669037, -0.19152729213237762, -0.06720169633626938, -0.08898987621068954, 0.23581790924072266, -0.6124197244644165, -0.4615834057331085, -0.8283422589302063, -0.03526075929403305, -0.48954683542251587, -0.035157106816768646, 0.5734765529632568, 0.5703510642051697, -0.0516909621655941, -0.35659801959991455, -0.35201185941696167, 0.6105228662490845, 0.03793035075068474, -0.055703334510326385, -0.5941079258918762, -0.7271102070808411, 0.33610764145851135, 0.22205567359924316, 0.004339431878179312, 0.34052443504333496, -0.2863676846027374, 0.9580497145652771, -0.5690907835960388, -0.30457809567451477, 0.3423386216163635, -0.7858980894088745, 0.2038082480430603, -0.38435059785842896, -0.6853227019309998, 0.054225482046604156, 0.04382593184709549, 0.6159164905548096, 0.5788854360580444, -0.3923330307006836, -0.08940300345420837, -0.4940209686756134, 0.2820124626159668, 0.3167915344238281, -0.2496010810136795, 0.1715453416109085, 0.20215897262096405, 0.08282751590013504, 0.0441601388156414, -0.24270662665367126, 0.753130316734314, 0.6212325096130371, 0.8410271406173706, -0.6173880696296692, 0.5771613121032715, -0.17149889469146729, -0.3950551748275757, 0.06949640810489655, 0.17444387078285217, 0.31319472193717957, -0.1917109489440918, 0.44821932911872864, 0.013221143744885921, -0.58354651927948, -0.28519928455352783, -0.9963797330856323, 0.3575386106967926, 0.681837797164917, 0.3169742822647095, 0.18061555922031403, -0.312976598739624, -0.31245553493499756 ]
{"Title": "Toward Automated Classification of Pathological Transcranial Doppler Waveform Morphology via Spectral Clustering", "Authors": "Thorpe Samuel G., Thibeault Corey M., Canac Nicolas, Jalaleddini Kian, Dorn Amber, Wilk Seth J., Devlin Thomas, Scalzo Fabien, Hamilton Robert B.", "Abstract": "Abstract Cerebral Blood Flow Velocity waveforms acquired via Transcranial Doppler (TCD) can provide evidence for cerebrovascular occlusion and stenosis. Thrombolysis in Brain Ischemia (TIBI) flow grades are widely used for this purpose, but require subjective assessment by expert evaluators to be reliable. In this work we seek to determine whether TCD morphology can be objectively assessed using an unsupervised machine learning approach to waveform categorization. TCD beat waveforms were recorded at multiple depths from the Middle Cerebral Arteries of 106 subjects; 33 with CTA-confirmed Large Vessel Occlusion (LVO). From each waveform, three morphological variables were extracted, quantifying absolute peak onset, number/prominence of auxiliary peaks, and systolic canopy length. Spectral clustering identified groups implicit in the resultant three-dimensional feature space, with gap-statistic criteria establishing the optimal cluster number. We found that gap-statistic disparity was maximized at four clusters, referred to as flow types I, II, III, and IV. Types I and II were primarily composed of control subject waveforms, whereas types III and IV derived mainly from LVO patients. Cluster morphologies for types I and IV aligned clearly with Normal and Blunted TIBI flows, respectively. Types II and III represented commonly observed flow-types not delineated by TIBI, which nonetheless deviate quantifiably from normal and blunted flows. We conclude that important morphological variability exists beyond that currently quantified by TIBI in populations experiencing or at-risk for acute ischemic stroke, and posit that the observed flow-types provide the foundation for objective methods of real-time automated flow type classification.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003236"}
10.1101/19002147
[ -0.1902267336845398, 0.05800163373351097, 0.0016178293153643608, 0.5736784934997559, -0.0829935073852539, -0.2758650779724121, -0.08306849747896194, 0.2010912448167801, -0.36654338240623474, 0.4887251853942871, -0.33993422985076904, -0.5273298025131226, -0.019085213541984558, -0.6369696855545044, -0.1298055201768875, 0.418264776468277, -1.081666111946106, 0.19691850244998932, -0.36971592903137207, 0.004668248817324638, 0.4633842408657074, 0.3084091544151306, -0.264211505651474, 0.41999414563179016, -0.2587917149066925, 0.9890168309211731, -0.10757337510585785, 0.4645136594772339, 1.108008861541748, -0.06031975895166397, -0.07662253081798553, -0.9608465433120728, 0.3815416395664215, -0.743018627166748, -0.28184497356414795, 0.4203642010688782, 0.792163074016571, -0.8000659942626953, -0.05217764899134636, -0.49258163571357727, 0.3145362436771393, -0.8253322243690491, 0.4715580642223358, -1.2764708995819092, -0.24522347748279572, -0.1310870349407196, -0.7544721364974976, -0.7576483488082886, -0.21686357259750366, -0.6310549974441528, -0.724760890007019, 0.15479877591133118, -0.05503718554973602, 0.02341524511575699, -0.431124746799469, -0.32817333936691284, -0.01915355585515499, 0.16944706439971924, -0.4092279374599457, -0.10654516518115997, 0.1969016194343567, -0.3562370836734772, 0.38392114639282227, -1.9414231777191162, -0.5354520082473755, 0.983417809009552, -0.2909921109676361, -0.14589078724384308, -0.4068923890590668, -0.35287055373191833, -0.9119396209716797, 0.047141265124082565, -0.4518900513648987, -0.4533520042896271, -0.15325604379177094, 0.19167307019233704, 0.5912600159645081, -0.10349678993225098, 0.3144213557243347, -0.3113657236099243, 0.5474196672439575, -0.46226638555526733, -0.07166825979948044, 0.8826782703399658, -0.12128549814224243, -0.475948303937912, 0.12909112870693207, 0.24763914942741394, 0.4817989468574524, -0.08350814133882523, 0.5687243938446045, 0.19395782053470612, 0.45530691742897034, 0.06959794461727142, 0.0599091500043869, 0.5905827879905701, -0.42410922050476074, 0.23051269352436066, 0.26416799426078796, 0.3968293070793152, 0.13564613461494446, 0.5174868702888489, -0.34814831614494324, 1.2315692901611328, -0.7978433966636658, 0.034974340349435806, 0.7864850163459778, 0.22229407727718353, -0.2047106772661209, -0.9094187021255493, 0.1897108405828476, -0.36709848046302795, -0.27848902344703674, 0.5687353610992432, 0.1673039346933365, 0.4158962666988373, -0.4991721212863922, -0.043224532157182693, -0.6008892059326172, 0.18161067366600037, -0.46952924132347107, -0.6446998715400696, 0.15933984518051147, -0.0015758556546643376, 1.0160398483276367, 0.04784490168094635, -0.4229987561702728, 1.059558629989624, 0.09304006397724152, -0.21784569323062897, -0.0010719387792050838, -0.42581504583358765, -0.5943023562431335, 0.5505154132843018, -0.03855722025036812, -0.1581927239894867, -0.24461974203586578, 0.7607600688934326, -0.4144321084022522, 0.016305454075336456, -0.69300776720047, 0.5503257513046265, 0.10957781225442886, 1.0298374891281128, 0.21815641224384308, 0.8821918368339539, -1.0800483226776123, -0.8305273056030273, 0.22097668051719666, -0.5118526816368103, -0.18521536886692047, 0.3826332986354828, 0.07349236309528351, -0.14901475608348846, -0.8546803593635559, -0.32500213384628296, -0.38356417417526245, 0.8438699245452881, -0.49211716651916504, 0.22976700961589813, -0.20479314029216766, 0.034725625067949295, -0.04994674026966095, 0.8907769322395325, -0.7619940042495728, 0.42730793356895447, -0.046756938099861145, -0.724348783493042, 0.3822687566280365, -0.8337603211402893, 0.06272657215595245, 1.0508363246917725, -0.1497775763273239, -0.980036735534668, -0.16937316954135895, 0.1708499789237976, 0.575666606426239, 0.27058330178260803, 0.2692977786064148, 0.6767995357513428, 0.18174339830875397, -0.4448559582233429, 1.2274760007858276, 0.24087660014629364, 0.3505227863788605, -0.14461830258369446, -0.1429109275341034, -0.5527998805046082, -0.28823626041412354, 0.45153987407684326, -0.036928169429302216, 0.7469224333763123, -0.6701807975769043, 0.6998493075370789, -0.19388844072818756, 0.31238994002342224, -0.4059019982814789, 0.16505688428878784, 0.05772249028086662, -0.05543375760316849, -0.2131105661392212, 0.646916925907135, -0.15508536994457245, -0.17830711603164673, -0.5004871487617493, 0.21337942779064178, 0.002882597269490361, 0.5883224010467529, -0.6055787801742554, -0.1412331759929657, 0.16024522483348846, 0.14188316464424133, 0.5949418544769287, -0.07060446590185165, 1.043776512145996, -0.7338738441467285, 0.33112451434135437, -0.010936015285551548, 0.22738778591156006, -0.3250487148761749, 1.0635250806808472, 0.46430593729019165, 0.3390120565891266, -0.2066420465707779, -0.15481723845005035, 0.0547618642449379, 0.36530646681785583, -0.14720378816127777, 0.15436290204524994, -0.596046507358551, 0.10477803647518158, 0.8820366263389587, 0.5516723990440369, 0.10706949979066849, 0.3774030804634094, 0.17735661566257477, 1.071038842201233, 0.026391956955194473, 1.1440515518188477, -0.0477752685546875, 0.16889025270938873, 0.5946676731109619, 1.0979806184768677, 0.3565770387649536, 0.04482688754796982, 0.44494837522506714, -0.3053074777126312, 0.6214986443519592, -0.7620384693145752, 0.10164431482553482, -1.3561598062515259, 0.6158561110496521, -0.34930384159088135, 0.37013036012649536, -0.09186927229166031, -0.20177243649959564, 0.24799096584320068, 0.28885766863822937, 0.5287219882011414, -1.5775376558303833, -0.061310358345508575, -0.17345377802848816, 0.4314801096916199, -0.2561715543270111, 0.9094223380088806, 0.8017310500144958, 0.2787085473537445, 0.14281748235225677, 0.006551342085003853, -0.4164281487464905, -0.38964489102363586, -0.05758224055171013, -1.2577204704284668, -0.545606791973114, -0.7599167823791504, -0.8675256967544556, -0.1445736587047577, -0.04442388936877251, -0.020774852484464645, 0.5678912997245789, 0.755850076675415, -0.6218859553337097, 0.29051071405410767, 0.21731384098529816, 0.10191524028778076, 0.6329429149627686, -1.0538454055786133, 0.1877683848142624, -0.5013594031333923, 0.19231607019901276, -0.1759137511253357, -0.8714603185653687, -0.9025639295578003, -0.6476477980613708, 0.7499291300773621, -0.23285581171512604, -0.07008392363786697, 0.23836158215999603, -0.2359154373407364, -0.6614404320716858, -0.4804614782333374, 0.09251376986503601, 0.48372507095336914, -0.1528477817773819, -0.8644028902053833, 0.3976634740829468, 0.3264390230178833, 0.5654833316802979, 0.5604978203773499, -0.2583426535129547, -0.08839546144008636, 0.5186320543289185, 0.044036149978637695, 0.37231725454330444, -0.6647014021873474, 0.6555799245834351, 0.6966920495033264, -0.34571537375450134, 0.1300082802772522, -0.48465681076049805, -0.9832348227500916, -0.3812297582626343, 0.20863112807273865, -0.7448347806930542, 0.4876984655857086, 0.06491105258464813, 0.17689630389213562, -1.1313682794570923, -0.03559790179133415, -0.5643354058265686, -0.8281781673431396, 0.2418367564678192, -0.5476818084716797, 0.7067111134529114, 0.1502199023962021, -0.01582595892250538, -0.7931723594665527, 0.28714820742607117, 0.020453624427318573, 0.20094537734985352, 0.48399049043655396, -0.7645765542984009, -0.5384676456451416, 0.5715240836143494, 0.04038740321993828, -0.22963134944438934, 1.0713731050491333, -0.0705043151974678, -0.1915455013513565, 0.25334078073501587, -0.15646061301231384, 0.10690829157829285, 0.34780222177505493, -0.6305427551269531, 0.8062360286712646, 0.07456378638744354, -0.5875214338302612, -0.40809813141822815, 0.06133866310119629, 0.8550018668174744, -0.08693613857030869, 0.5720868110656738, 0.24150988459587097, 0.5868423581123352, -0.7443159222602844, -0.4255479574203491, 0.6682344675064087, -0.26216551661491394, 0.22984014451503754, -1.2640479803085327, 0.30297061800956726, -0.01666855253279209, -0.08270964026451111, 0.1131487637758255, -0.18646402657032013, 0.020294440910220146, 0.7585482597351074, 0.46568962931632996, 1.4701035022735596, -1.0532492399215698, 0.2035776525735855, 0.15372934937477112, 1.0660220384597778, 0.3828675448894501, -0.1729123890399933, 0.2092677503824234, -0.4837837219238281, 0.44043806195259094, 0.27467748522758484, -0.12135583907365799, 0.4331831932067871, 0.3742312788963318, -0.6621087193489075, -0.20740635693073273, -0.6868976354598999, -0.21869942545890808, 0.8931784629821777, 0.4559190571308136, -0.5572344660758972, -0.46238845586776733, 0.3806183934211731, -0.12463203817605972, 0.5061845779418945, 0.49293407797813416, 0.17563633620738983, -0.4274187386035919, -0.1796487420797348, 0.30663493275642395, -0.4465998411178589, -0.31256529688835144, 0.22052927315235138, -0.0026237594429403543, 0.02320072054862976, -0.1324518769979477, 0.08591364324092865, -0.003590851789340377, -0.40274733304977417, -0.1752602756023407, -0.07545819878578186, 0.20611608028411865, -0.3986312747001648, 0.7156698107719421, -0.9346397519111633, -0.002225313801318407, 0.5714831948280334, -0.7684077620506287, 0.4491480588912964, -0.404998242855072, 0.7530128955841064, 0.7460556626319885, 0.11860490590333939, -0.5945234298706055, 0.1499881148338318, 0.10506393015384674, -0.4781017303466797, 0.6863160729408264, 0.03908170014619827, -0.6919542551040649, 0.6054002046585083, 0.5467223525047302, 0.42910996079444885, -0.5808179974555969, -0.3136262595653534, -0.3756784498691559, 0.3260776698589325, 0.295463889837265, 0.09231773763895035, 0.32628291845321655, 0.3886318802833557, -0.1672295778989792, 0.6797477006912231, -0.5985608696937561, 0.5425743460655212, -0.3007064759731293, -0.8774188756942749, -0.14195238053798676, -0.20821724832057953, -0.13865235447883606, 0.12404590100049973, -0.6867860555648804, -0.2969616949558258, -0.45336294174194336, -0.14605802297592163, 0.0951932892203331, -0.5078995227813721, 0.2064816802740097, 0.006147716194391251, 0.786177396774292, 0.6185571551322937, 0.22598229348659515, 0.06748802959918976, 0.02011893503367901, -0.03923241049051285, -0.6569649577140808, -0.3069722354412079, -0.9751904010772705, -0.32915183901786804, -0.2477523535490036, 0.07387357950210571, -0.1343756765127182, -0.09131301939487457, -0.05158671364188194, -0.48688027262687683, 0.15872034430503845, -0.3744499981403351, -0.2599259614944458, -0.6904118657112122, 0.4170117676258087, -0.9800959229469299, 0.39629608392715454, 0.22978445887565613, -0.6073925495147705, -0.23727500438690186, 0.5298705101013184, -0.06760653853416443, -0.36300668120384216, -1.4585120677947998, 0.5116211771965027, 0.18172281980514526, -0.42757686972618103, 1.4028122425079346, -0.0056128366850316525, -0.6429612636566162, 0.5770717859268188, 0.5651986002922058, -0.9313690662384033, -0.750755786895752, -0.2763647437095642, -0.2596127986907959, -0.20999185740947723, -0.11576656252145767, 0.1131812259554863, -0.03720373287796974, 0.08762289583683014, -0.08744703233242035, 0.27822810411453247, 0.6924590468406677, -0.9352059960365295, -0.8646005988121033, 0.9130826592445374, 0.36336591839790344, -0.8468686938285828, -0.24541150033473969, 0.790341854095459, 0.06856229901313782, 0.15192320942878723, -0.5373135209083557, -0.39624541997909546, 0.12422007322311401, -0.4283295273780823, 0.5833680629730225, -1.9241207838058472, 0.2518080174922943, 0.13935524225234985, 0.10867201536893845, 0.2370368093252182, -0.7557597756385803, 0.4942414462566376, -0.14707402884960175, -0.5286037921905518, -0.4967387914657593, 0.12066502869129181, -0.539644718170166, -0.8030371069908142, -0.19702661037445068, 0.27046576142311096, -0.19021640717983246, 0.9011934995651245, 0.7605640292167664, -0.33230289816856384, 1.1101007461547852, -0.029711483046412468, 0.5432530045509338, -0.17517873644828796, -0.4369701147079468, -0.4148353636264801, 0.28200563788414, 0.552278995513916, 0.24897484481334686, -0.43251994252204895, -1.0525107383728027, 0.25713658332824707, -0.3359093964099884, 0.2512792944908142, -0.5301811099052429, 0.25892019271850586, -0.1170898824930191, -0.49069273471832275, 0.5318490266799927, -0.7328492403030396, -0.16737061738967896, 0.4818194508552551, 0.07067312300205231, -0.6701413989067078, -0.021899307146668434, -0.6382193565368652, -0.8343090415000916, -1.0820173025131226, -1.1687188148498535, 0.572929859161377, -0.15316671133041382, 0.7606672644615173, 0.428764283657074, 0.12701745331287384, -0.40837106108665466, -0.24538245797157288, 0.6615341305732727, 0.49136751890182495, 0.028310224413871765, -0.18547196686267853, -0.2839427590370178, 0.35759058594703674, 0.6885549426078796, -0.33358776569366455, -0.5617452263832092, -0.5544857978820801, -0.13989032804965973, -0.257070928812027, -0.8464047312736511, -0.7699325680732727, -0.010717520490288734, 0.3424791395664215, 0.22481782734394073, 0.04070098325610161, 0.6745306253433228, -0.3541378676891327, 0.11770056188106537, -0.6986488699913025, 0.7457994222640991, -0.4573269188404083, -0.16359277069568634, 0.323540061712265, -0.7472352385520935, -0.5632139444351196, 0.291354238986969, -0.14014297723770142, -0.46129006147384644, -0.02471524477005005, 0.06758387386798859, 0.5643526911735535, -1.1294883489608765, 0.1849791556596756, 0.1602630466222763, -0.3746417164802551, -1.0827889442443848, 0.09789425134658813, -0.1847059577703476, -0.05732952803373337, -0.14493092894554138, -0.19434352219104767, 0.5467367172241211, -0.4624193608760834, -0.052274782210588455, 0.9194783568382263, 0.058293458074331284, -0.07372679561376572, 0.09773242473602295, -0.5423402190208435, -0.6224198937416077, 0.3098507821559906, 0.40456289052963257, 0.15110982954502106, 0.5470824837684631, 0.15839003026485443, 0.13719375431537628, 0.5371212959289551, -0.014015505090355873, 0.696201741695404, -0.5282468199729919, -0.17927323281764984, -0.12751053273677826, 0.8003328442573547, -0.3894290030002594, 0.06201457604765892, 0.27112001180648804, 0.725189745426178, 0.03799920156598091, -0.09073887020349503, 0.23577427864074707, 0.48681801557540894, 0.9760496616363525, 1.0261757373809814, -0.853046178817749, -0.10498917102813721, 0.9253720045089722, 1.029781460762024, -0.3393617272377014, -0.04153488948941231, -1.5457401275634766, -1.0721416473388672, 0.1562483161687851, 0.24722576141357422, -1.332108974456787, 0.015784598886966705, 0.7100062370300293, -0.4682762324810028, -0.8582340478897095, -0.146576926112175, 0.9414802193641663, -0.9184830188751221, -0.10394100844860077, -0.5448575615882874, -0.30174171924591064, -1.0414906740188599, 0.3818996548652649, -0.14896529912948608, -1.2574573755264282, -0.380489319562912, 0.47697871923446655, -0.10556193441152573, -0.03416338562965393, 0.12261879444122314, 0.8788328766822815, -0.13093453645706177, 0.8122996687889099, -0.7101370096206665, -0.13371559977531433, -0.30325478315353394, 0.6013962626457214, 0.26088622212409973, -0.03565550222992897, 0.9457237124443054, -0.1965099275112152, 0.6921147704124451, 0.18396249413490295, -0.46942123770713806, -0.3584762215614319, -0.38564854860305786, 0.17687323689460754, -0.8383840322494507, -0.466664582490921, -0.03871907666325569, 0.5533641576766968, -0.7815173864364624, -1.049107313156128, -0.8728812336921692, 0.10739178210496902, -0.13214728236198425, -0.49267444014549255, 0.07895152270793915, 1.1204036474227905, -0.0453328974545002, -0.14570075273513794, -0.2567596137523651, 0.1008872538805008, 0.025193247944116592, 0.695180356502533, 0.3480137884616852, -0.42999789118766785, 0.6254830956459045, -0.8186025619506836, -0.006323020439594984, -0.29022979736328125, -0.47917604446411133, 0.2710447907447815, -0.14136382937431335, 0.4059826135635376, 0.1526801437139511, -0.06887433677911758, -0.08674515783786774, 0.6479998826980591, 0.08354873955249786, 0.20875152945518494, 0.7256895899772644, -0.4115934669971466, -0.46904510259628296, -0.06174996495246887, -0.5452844500541687, -0.6484231948852539, 0.6318531036376953, -0.5454185009002686, 0.00885095540434122, 0.034570932388305664, -0.7796168327331543, 0.6954931616783142, 0.2112061083316803, 0.6343548893928528, 0.34327906370162964, 0.8313851356506348, 0.3813142478466034, 0.23778267204761505, 0.029917359352111816, 0.21728026866912842, 0.2591247856616974, 0.026195034384727478, -0.4211631417274475, -0.7481913566589355, 0.7251347303390503, -0.07958994060754776, -0.11297707259654999, -0.6013022065162659, -0.43371978402137756, 0.0592406764626503, -0.17084906995296478, -0.6395854949951172, -0.42904818058013916, 0.0416693352162838, -0.7561014294624329, 0.21486251056194305, -0.42551177740097046, -0.28503403067588806, -0.7163000106811523, 0.8451406359672546, 0.48741161823272705, -0.28031742572784424, -0.3066175878047943, -0.4733923077583313, 1.0026313066482544, -0.024050893262028694, 0.3040724992752075, -0.4593437612056732, 0.27302733063697815, -0.6249114274978638, -0.015129254199564457, 0.3502573072910309, 0.44443222880363464, 0.5994191765785217, -0.18476814031600952, 0.30776458978652954, 1.2761404514312744, 0.5719358325004578, 0.44941678643226624, 0.6149119138717651, 0.09537581354379654, -0.17998673021793365, 0.47367435693740845, 0.17295204102993011, -0.2447851002216339, 0.8729361295700073, 0.9133579730987549, 0.8595579266548157, 0.31486764550209045, 0.36824849247932434, 0.5299493074417114, -0.4377789795398712, -0.17867274582386017, 0.5315062403678894, -0.5247073173522949, -0.5234102010726929, -0.36332276463508606, 0.9426085352897644, 0.38184040784835815, 0.1010603979229927, 0.8430423736572266, -0.44606834650039673, 0.5166143774986267, 0.5675954818725586, -0.4812595844268799, 0.6681495308876038, 0.21715548634529114, -0.5969299674034119, -0.41710007190704346, 0.7274112701416016, 0.3835090398788452, 0.2380940169095993, 0.852318525314331, -0.351958692073822, -0.25963523983955383, 0.39146676659584045, -0.09408031404018402, -0.5259775519371033, 0.2786064147949219, -0.6952921748161316, -0.7045519351959229, -0.6132667064666748, -0.038317397236824036, -0.4678197205066681, -0.1387988179922104, 0.6468925476074219, -0.7418366074562073, 0.17677855491638184, 0.7512163519859314, -0.3633824288845062, 0.2807771563529968, 0.47091007232666016, 0.3876064717769623, -0.35034480690956116, 1.012084722518921, 0.3458450138568878, -0.05321361869573593, 0.6120350360870361, 0.1441641002893448, -0.15685611963272095, 0.7256978750228882, -0.30679255723953247, 0.3230225443840027, 0.5550568699836731, -0.18108291923999786, 0.016044840216636658, 0.19191494584083557, -0.4664057791233063, 0.49425482749938965, -0.3761719763278961, 0.5145043730735779, 0.19210989773273468, -0.3483239710330963, 0.2136884480714798, 0.2212023138999939, -0.18814770877361298, 0.01180942915380001, 0.21416673064231873, -0.21723759174346924, -0.1959696114063263, 0.32529178261756897, -0.164211243391037, 0.8064345121383667, 0.19604912400245667, -0.7757025957107544, -0.535754382610321, -0.5886434316635132, -0.37930697202682495, 0.08066199719905853, -0.5495077967643738, -0.7023465037345886, 0.12785011529922485, 0.21072106063365936, 0.3316526710987091, 0.5029941201210022, 0.3756457567214966, 0.029399417340755463, 0.08617427945137024, 0.9323984384536743, -0.05382786691188812, -0.07053180038928986, 0.8096259236335754, 0.4220055937767029, 0.3392568826675415, 0.6926629543304443, 0.2755921483039856, 0.030376292765140533, -0.12173238396644592, -0.3197915554046631, -0.24205555021762848, -0.2735874354839325, -0.3300003111362457, 0.1064186617732048, -0.034333981573581696, -0.5895699262619019, -0.1843341886997223, -0.5016013383865356, -0.8197210431098938, 0.055111344903707504, 0.9770598411560059, -0.10473383963108063, 0.42226314544677734, 0.26556700468063354, -1.007856011390686, -0.2048422247171402, -0.8680442571640015, 4.088006019592285, 1.7980057001113892, 0.3551604747772217, -0.10458638519048691, 0.1371845155954361, 0.399313360452652, 0.6084107160568237, -0.7689658403396606, -0.008603405207395554, 0.21205615997314453, -0.48896607756614685, 0.5115537643432617, -0.6024255156517029, -0.735847532749176, 0.6933722496032715, 0.5933035016059875, -0.17335385084152222, -0.39453452825546265, 0.5051082968711853, -0.914836049079895, 0.001669800840318203, 0.407260924577713, -0.1975080966949463, -0.2342248111963272, 0.053284917026758194, -0.42305389046669006, 0.025151515379548073, 0.2835981845855713, -0.6113481521606445, 0.21732458472251892, -0.1952209621667862, -0.9965054392814636, 0.26771411299705505, 0.011637985706329346, 0.16304634511470795, 0.36904820799827576, -0.49632370471954346, -0.04133610054850578, -0.3336019515991211, -0.5118616223335266, -0.008803215809166431, -0.2123415470123291, 0.1651403158903122, -0.6069759726524353, -0.18425463140010834, 0.8157156109809875, 0.14855127036571503, 0.21594062447547913, 0.6157421469688416, -0.6921864151954651, 1.0930551290512085, -0.9282557368278503, -0.301973432302475, 0.31071990728378296, -1.046988606452942, 0.3049464225769043, -0.25472936034202576, -0.5731869339942932, 0.4214639663696289, -0.30775967240333557, 0.6800121068954468, 0.2225375771522522, 0.2568758428096771, -0.7758260369300842, 0.01421321276575327, -0.2525857985019684, 0.6803454160690308, 0.6750100255012512, -0.31226569414138794, 0.3911498785018921, 0.10374685376882553, 0.05435294285416603, -1.4056214094161987, 0.7335894107818604, 0.7007967233657837, 1.046104907989502, -0.35915932059288025, -0.244816392660141, -0.5683424472808838, -0.28855443000793457, 0.3403220772743225, 0.19533376395702362, 0.20516778528690338, 0.2713167071342468, 0.17569811642169952, 0.9781152009963989, 0.0537431575357914, -0.25803348422050476, -0.90204256772995, 0.5514596700668335, 0.5252761244773865, -0.17299841344356537, -0.16805586218833923, -0.856529176235199, -0.1722532957792282 ]
{"Title": "Structural and functional MRI changes associated with cognitive impairment and dementia in Parkinson disease", "Authors": "Owens-Walton Conor, Jakabek David, Power Brian D., Walterfang Mark, Hall Sara, van Westen Danielle, Looi Jeffrey C.L., Shaw Marnie, Hansson Oskar", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective Cognitive impairment in Parkinson disease (PD) places a high burden on patients and the pathophysiological mechanisms that differentiate patients with cognitive impairment from those without it are still incompletely understood. Methods We conducted a resting-state seed region-of-interest approach to investigate functional connectivity (FC) of important subdivisions of the caudate nucleus, putamen and thalamus in controls (n=33), cognitively unimpaired subjects (PD-CU, n=33), PD subjects with mild cognitive impairment (PD-MCI, n=22) and subjects with dementia (PDD, n=17). We then investigated how the morphology of these structures differed between groups. Results PD-CU subjects, compared to controls, displayed increased and decreased FC of caudate, putamen and thalamic subdivisions. PD-MCI subjects demonstrated reduced FC of the mediodorsal thalamus with the paracingulate cortex, compared to PD-CU, and reduced FC of the mediodorsal thalamus with the posterior cingulate cortex compared to PDD. Extensive volumetric and surface-based deflation was found in subjects with dementia. Conclusions Our research suggests that cognitive impairment and dementia in PD may be associated with a breakdown in FC of the mediodorsal thalamus with para- and posterior cingulate regions of the brain, respectively. Significance Cognitive impairment and dementia in PD may relate to pathophysiological changes in FC of the mediodorsal thalamus.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002147"}
10.1101/19012203
[ -0.1619998812675476, 0.0852162316441536, -0.09473041445016861, 0.9151906967163086, 0.11060051620006561, -0.18537023663520813, -0.5050675868988037, 0.19285424053668976, 0.07474146038293839, 0.3926291763782501, -0.045552607625722885, -0.2543497681617737, 0.1272563636302948, -0.5617742538452148, 0.03704448789358139, 0.2354365587234497, -1.01822829246521, 0.08733415603637695, -0.23275485634803772, -0.23093540966510773, 0.4070589542388916, 0.3572011888027191, -0.28130966424942017, 0.42964106798171997, -0.3058231770992279, 0.6979799866676331, -0.2349124699831009, 0.4552352726459503, 1.4353203773498535, 0.3536456525325775, 0.44094693660736084, -0.9658339619636536, -0.06309428066015244, -0.8732858896255493, -0.16710111498832703, -0.01962204836308956, 0.43394196033477783, -0.8235849738121033, -0.6495844721794128, -0.6908681392669678, 0.402998685836792, -0.18618173897266388, 0.6429792046546936, -0.799347460269928, -0.3487948179244995, -0.2796381413936615, -0.27295833826065063, -0.19565048813819885, -0.37648236751556396, -0.13545061647891998, -0.5073688626289368, 0.0011618280550464988, -0.23812703788280487, -0.5154125690460205, -0.00645791320130229, -0.20666469633579254, 0.09413537383079529, 0.3756624162197113, -0.56354159116745, 0.3869587182998657, 1.147368311882019, -0.2934667468070984, 0.24920901656150818, -1.5361623764038086, -0.04084699600934982, 0.7101973295211792, -0.4867764413356781, 0.2960660457611084, -0.6341984868049622, 0.3931887745857239, -0.9436683058738708, 0.09565278887748718, -0.672974169254303, -0.19544877111911774, 0.08077602833509445, -0.06378546357154846, 0.4944798946380615, -0.005277177318930626, 0.2935081720352173, -0.5291172862052917, 1.24648916721344, -0.2433219999074936, -0.4574621319770813, 0.15416789054870605, -0.12668149173259735, -0.32479116320610046, 0.16497012972831726, 0.7502636313438416, 0.07485982030630112, -0.2765824794769287, 0.1640239804983139, 0.06024802103638649, 0.4884185492992401, 0.08408836275339127, -0.5281659960746765, 0.8120432496070862, -0.3879799544811249, 0.12987947463989258, -0.1812521368265152, -0.22517704963684082, 0.6090415716171265, 0.5148023962974548, -0.22455407679080963, 1.2069164514541626, -1.1184968948364258, 0.5358075499534607, 0.6984733939170837, -0.1919080913066864, -0.49447694420814514, -1.3312244415283203, -0.20571036636829376, 0.3648005425930023, -0.200344517827034, 0.660241425037384, 0.1965213268995285, 0.4367467164993286, -0.5734097361564636, -0.010171567089855671, -0.5816488862037659, 0.6965432167053223, -0.3849855661392212, -0.4824935495853424, 0.21506215631961823, -0.22297997772693634, 0.32141274213790894, 0.03883307799696922, -0.24308907985687256, 0.6931345462799072, 0.13152988255023956, -0.2507288157939911, 0.35162562131881714, -0.5133549571037292, 0.16865137219429016, 0.8915219306945801, -0.43340879678726196, 0.2537985146045685, -0.005165755283087492, 0.5003875494003296, -0.5150548219680786, -0.2368890643119812, -0.0002322488435311243, 0.0074668265879154205, 0.012150135822594166, 0.85324627161026, 0.22801052033901215, 0.6800433397293091, -0.5965304970741272, -1.532824993133545, 0.011123498901724815, -0.16041965782642365, -0.09337498992681503, 0.8698787093162537, -0.05033520981669426, -0.2585115134716034, -0.5492270588874817, -0.19441479444503784, -0.6176699995994568, 0.5811388492584229, -0.17736701667308807, 0.030077584087848663, -0.26700836420059204, 0.19668470323085785, -0.04132799431681633, 0.899906575679779, -0.8337739706039429, 0.015444914810359478, 0.015031224116683006, -0.5462123155593872, 0.7807883024215698, -0.24308814108371735, 0.14977377653121948, 0.789509654045105, 0.07706721127033234, -0.43973860144615173, 0.19773733615875244, 0.6775563955307007, 1.006467580795288, -0.05201928690075874, 0.019009990617632866, 0.16947880387306213, 0.4428427219390869, -0.2755041718482971, 0.6552030444145203, 0.29105088114738464, -0.04302743449807167, -0.39416393637657166, -0.6604641675949097, -0.5251200199127197, -0.1265326738357544, -0.3332087993621826, -0.48915934562683105, 0.7211337685585022, -0.8925885558128357, 0.6913519501686096, -0.7601804733276367, 0.03185947239398956, -0.3577456772327423, 0.3202093243598938, 0.2437286525964737, -0.22324666380882263, -0.4014371633529663, 0.6199219226837158, -0.648664116859436, 0.07915793359279633, -0.7350822687149048, 0.4936821162700653, 0.23881538212299347, 0.3850589990615845, -0.7332648634910583, 0.05563884228467941, -0.011692014522850513, -0.29119929671287537, 0.19392889738082886, -0.3937107026576996, 0.9157629013061523, -0.6781678199768066, 0.5481926202774048, -0.2038154900074005, -0.08951327949762344, -0.5762250423431396, 0.7179030776023865, 0.12323704361915588, 0.8665055632591248, -0.038249146193265915, 0.29693686962127686, 0.05835845693945885, 0.699119508266449, -0.31004688143730164, -0.33389702439308167, -0.23679183423519135, 0.161900594830513, 0.7120507955551147, 0.2419736236333847, 0.5100805163383484, 0.5539080500602722, 0.1806088536977768, 0.30035388469696045, 0.13167014718055725, 0.7701871991157532, 0.104200080037117, 0.6480846405029297, 0.00896168127655983, 1.1759281158447266, 0.5949007868766785, -0.10289523750543594, 0.11890222877264023, -0.23960451781749725, 0.3704672157764435, -0.9842897057533264, 0.7781667709350586, -1.2636423110961914, 0.9323064684867859, 0.007017163094133139, 0.18187221884727478, -0.2171972095966339, -0.12521342933177948, 0.01469551119953394, 0.5166986584663391, 0.1455337256193161, -0.7690413594245911, -0.26289331912994385, -0.8025234937667847, 0.44560861587524414, -0.1817363053560257, 1.0765613317489624, 0.7434441447257996, 0.11039614677429199, 0.6550836563110352, 0.10561826080083847, -0.7052521705627441, 0.15258383750915527, -0.5637125372886658, -1.2966681718826294, -0.7441954612731934, -0.9638411998748779, -0.5310963988304138, 0.8107410073280334, -0.11991165578365326, 0.29723620414733887, 0.9727747440338135, 0.5819169878959656, -0.3117443919181824, 0.5946801900863647, 0.9342402815818787, 0.8954562544822693, 0.019060054793953896, -0.6949854493141174, 0.280965656042099, -0.5748997926712036, 0.39208874106407166, 0.07916834950447083, -1.0178278684616089, -0.4842509329319, -0.951721727848053, 0.5353103280067444, -0.28304630517959595, 0.06275257468223572, 0.16377979516983032, -0.2080860584974289, -0.29501351714134216, -0.22699177265167236, 0.08150239288806915, 0.04678410291671753, -0.08835610002279282, -0.6689791083335876, 0.5376158952713013, 0.04056272655725479, -0.12059430778026581, 0.5784623622894287, 0.4317002594470978, -0.026306822896003723, 1.1702369451522827, 0.04767211526632309, 0.1762702763080597, -0.8171684145927429, 1.0982736349105835, 0.6394544839859009, -0.34052208065986633, 0.05991814285516739, -0.6980099678039551, -1.1952424049377441, -0.5357776284217834, 0.1895599216222763, -0.4818321466445923, 0.20180873572826385, 0.18621422350406647, -0.18885363638401031, -0.7859819531440735, 0.030232984572649002, -0.40595272183418274, -0.9326643943786621, 0.26177188754081726, -0.5603622794151306, 0.45966044068336487, -0.04449460655450821, -0.24232417345046997, -0.6900345087051392, -0.17726446688175201, 0.25714486837387085, 0.314179003238678, 0.41807693243026733, -0.3324696123600006, -0.45789554715156555, 0.45101287961006165, 0.6587101221084595, 0.45281729102134705, 0.9622097015380859, -0.7881847620010376, 0.08123922348022461, -0.32009389996528625, -0.3623068630695343, 0.5970404148101807, 0.6501246690750122, -0.2997642755508423, 0.21648433804512024, -0.47104403376579285, -0.2143041342496872, -0.16918906569480896, -0.25787514448165894, 0.3292582333087921, -0.6132597923278809, 0.19358089566230774, 0.3897269666194916, 1.1679946184158325, -1.1146692037582397, -0.4064505100250244, 0.37130388617515564, -0.20862433314323425, 0.486563503742218, -1.2292672395706177, 0.4430255591869354, 0.10465805232524872, 0.33518660068511963, 0.25412169098854065, -0.2644847333431244, -0.2822701930999756, 0.6416531801223755, 0.19064177572727203, 1.0152348279953003, -1.0709630250930786, -0.3900746703147888, 0.6464415788650513, 0.9709923267364502, 0.7634270191192627, 0.3581831753253937, -0.017853301018476486, -0.7284544110298157, 0.31133630871772766, 0.08909178525209427, 0.5297333002090454, 0.5430296659469604, 0.2200891524553299, -0.5387417674064636, 0.07022780179977417, -0.599970817565918, -0.20871242880821228, 0.32027778029441833, 0.9409579634666443, -0.9464739561080933, -0.8407619595527649, 0.7829211354255676, -0.39143887162208557, 0.15258662402629852, 0.6488457322120667, 0.8024677634239197, -0.011649305932223797, -0.36590829491615295, 0.039119452238082886, -0.15186260640621185, -0.030772842466831207, 0.2845431864261627, -0.3757646381855011, -0.06798143684864044, -0.37061846256256104, 0.5303133130073547, -0.7084568738937378, -0.14945624768733978, -0.4582347273826599, 0.524125874042511, -0.3024697005748749, -0.1677379459142685, 0.8679295182228088, -0.7433235049247742, 0.4062274098396301, 0.4573633074760437, -0.9326496124267578, -0.019547484815120697, -0.3832077085971832, 0.777125895023346, 1.0185542106628418, 0.9309880137443542, -0.7910228371620178, 0.09909730404615402, 0.27971628308296204, -0.16585282981395721, 0.5576393604278564, -0.007588998414576054, -0.30834290385246277, 0.21296440064907074, 0.17794686555862427, -0.20398099720478058, -0.05523057281970978, 0.03800777718424797, -0.220185786485672, -0.1577122062444687, 0.2712152600288391, 0.305713951587677, 0.32463207840919495, 0.7559372782707214, -0.4343222379684448, 0.5474503636360168, -0.5351120829582214, 0.31333157420158386, -0.6232348084449768, -0.8617072701454163, -0.7279045581817627, 0.2674154043197632, -0.09960659593343735, -0.1068185493350029, -0.6072543263435364, -0.2852431833744049, -0.6287775635719299, 0.5228412747383118, 0.0966264083981514, -0.6206322908401489, 0.941094160079956, -0.00637851282954216, 0.3829730749130249, 0.6552039384841919, 0.5123850107192993, -0.5758628845214844, 0.036453086882829666, 0.40363335609436035, -1.1537175178527832, 0.09507519006729126, -0.19727255403995514, -0.2301226705312729, -0.47021591663360596, 0.04649171233177185, -0.03365132212638855, -0.26524296402931213, 0.2209354192018509, -0.35115522146224976, -0.023987896740436554, -0.28333497047424316, -0.07836423069238663, -0.4630891978740692, -0.5058093667030334, -0.7579413652420044, 0.07298675924539566, 0.21754439175128937, -0.7102470397949219, -0.2572871148586273, 0.632550060749054, -1.009487509727478, -0.39671629667282104, -1.1191956996917725, 0.5712590217590332, 0.17739242315292358, 0.2147737443447113, 1.4169758558273315, 0.11282198876142502, -0.17895185947418213, 0.7117593884468079, 0.10528920590877533, -0.7220908999443054, -0.11322052776813507, -0.4398806691169739, 0.05593603849411011, -0.4050627648830414, 0.40650707483291626, -0.5981196761131287, 0.036524612456560135, 0.3693804144859314, -0.11306477338075638, -0.4571090638637543, 0.6882283091545105, -0.47081267833709717, -0.6122180819511414, 0.7642024755477905, -0.2620299756526947, -0.7179178595542908, -0.43708276748657227, 0.465146005153656, -0.013340787030756474, 0.09465810656547546, -0.21981003880500793, -0.40480348467826843, -0.5440276861190796, -1.0855000019073486, 0.12068385630846024, -1.2898097038269043, 0.5310139656066895, -0.38587069511413574, 0.7266321778297424, 0.22332283854484558, -0.19656315445899963, 0.8637598156929016, -0.5658564567565918, 0.004370936658233404, -0.6609638929367065, 0.32844579219818115, -0.5121400356292725, -0.814509928226471, -0.02845805697143078, -0.4094267189502716, 0.426877498626709, 1.488233208656311, 0.3841305375099182, -0.8347362875938416, 0.4031379818916321, 0.15028509497642517, 0.694003701210022, 0.45424407720565796, -0.24771252274513245, -0.3798430263996124, 0.4792806804180145, 0.9224398136138916, 0.24226298928260803, -0.1758098602294922, -0.7132962942123413, -0.351549357175827, -0.2971324324607849, 0.009595352225005627, -0.46333491802215576, -0.20686039328575134, -0.2827353775501251, -0.3890320956707001, 0.8190586566925049, -0.7889876961708069, 0.38647961616516113, -0.6020559072494507, 0.02813073992729187, 0.32163599133491516, 0.03435356542468071, -0.7277482151985168, -0.430984228849411, -0.7306113839149475, -0.8246615529060364, 0.34348124265670776, -0.28326380252838135, 0.4742617607116699, 0.7050092220306396, 0.5950632691383362, -0.051557570695877075, -0.23785613477230072, 0.7930538058280945, 0.30543720722198486, -0.45863068103790283, -0.7000206708908081, 0.08122461289167404, 0.6087812781333923, 0.23536165058612823, -0.04112030938267708, -0.5693843364715576, -0.3891267776489258, -0.020376620814204216, -0.2344723641872406, -0.8997620940208435, -0.8277498483657837, 0.18427325785160065, 0.2513035535812378, 0.6054590940475464, 0.354300856590271, 0.5261998176574707, -0.16293811798095703, -0.011600983329117298, -0.5200878381729126, 0.5310837626457214, -0.24687997996807098, -0.32360056042671204, 0.2608046233654022, -0.31384143233299255, -0.5079182982444763, 0.2171895056962967, 0.0015577934682369232, -0.7150601744651794, -0.20697149634361267, 0.41405367851257324, 0.245732381939888, -0.8579915165901184, 0.1632930487394333, 0.4441221356391907, -0.30169442296028137, -1.3110026121139526, -0.45902955532073975, 0.14647126197814941, 0.04365347698330879, -0.960340678691864, -0.046091075986623764, 0.2178562879562378, -0.22318914532661438, 0.0781351700425148, 0.7726866602897644, 0.29683011770248413, -0.1794995814561844, 0.5162416100502014, -0.16388721764087677, -0.8808073401451111, 0.3318551480770111, 0.521365225315094, 0.061153594404459, 0.930397629737854, 0.5339013934135437, 0.5216711163520813, 0.025907788425683975, 0.0702587142586708, 0.3400760293006897, -0.6328907608985901, -0.2176295518875122, -0.327363520860672, 0.6803610920906067, -0.7051120400428772, 0.15263836085796356, 0.14516893029212952, 0.9819965362548828, -0.36794862151145935, -0.3954498767852783, -0.42540085315704346, 0.4709785282611847, 1.4186608791351318, 1.1144002676010132, -0.2708771824836731, 0.03769068419933319, 1.039762020111084, 0.7324421405792236, -0.006547159049659967, -0.9920796155929565, -1.3086477518081665, -0.7623319029808044, 0.06692346930503845, 0.30204007029533386, -1.1751295328140259, 0.17588144540786743, 0.471073716878891, -0.4119041860103607, -0.6296869516372681, -0.7526919841766357, 0.9773833155632019, -0.2430858314037323, 0.0077497283928096294, -0.5586848258972168, 0.21707560122013092, -0.4829348623752594, 0.11687874048948288, -0.12908972799777985, -1.2392584085464478, -0.12815509736537933, 0.6104469299316406, -0.5460425615310669, -0.31070181727409363, 0.05757942795753479, -0.27207523584365845, 0.14895397424697876, 0.04359975457191467, -0.82138991355896, -0.6316832900047302, -0.7120497226715088, 0.7753788232803345, 0.16136585175991058, 0.3414820432662964, 0.9149173498153687, -0.22098569571971893, 0.24576781690120697, 0.0032844864763319492, -0.2335921972990036, -0.4790678918361664, -0.2071084976196289, 0.09258293360471725, -0.5200797319412231, -0.6942245364189148, -0.20480680465698242, 0.5500181317329407, -1.041853666305542, -0.9434177279472351, -0.7971614599227905, 0.21057364344596863, -0.6134909391403198, 0.11927887797355652, -0.27269262075424194, 0.8275535702705383, -0.04090540111064911, -0.0831739753484726, -0.0392872579395771, 0.12275750935077667, 0.27295824885368347, 0.4853484034538269, -0.17768822610378265, -0.3911769390106201, 0.5135512351989746, -0.6037598252296448, 0.4601500332355499, -0.07222885638475418, -0.7655134797096252, 0.6824167966842651, -0.5688273906707764, 0.47247135639190674, 0.33206281065940857, -0.04991064593195915, -0.037109486758708954, 0.19663821160793304, -0.024841975420713425, -0.002670868067070842, 0.542953372001648, -0.2380194365978241, -0.6229718923568726, -0.6865174174308777, -0.8710299730300903, -0.2813206911087036, 0.0837354063987732, -0.6813844442367554, 0.36154940724372864, 0.18392133712768555, -0.7186610698699951, 0.6098326444625854, 0.11945074051618576, 0.05021864175796509, 0.30936166644096375, 0.523266077041626, 0.2218308448791504, 0.4317196309566498, -0.23731952905654907, 0.4433195888996124, 0.46712544560432434, -0.05625077709555626, -0.7881796956062317, -0.9417375922203064, 0.5661942362785339, 0.03555383160710335, -0.6588535308837891, -0.09952541440725327, -0.12001176178455353, -0.021697767078876495, 0.12165647745132446, -0.2746425271034241, -0.26910853385925293, 0.6223799586296082, -0.19628624618053436, 0.20523056387901306, -0.5699522495269775, 0.14482511579990387, -0.5740567445755005, 0.7000371813774109, 0.5935125350952148, -0.19592951238155365, -0.4875777065753937, 0.42864730954170227, 0.891135036945343, -0.07104944437742233, 0.3718447983264923, -0.36936354637145996, 0.614335298538208, -0.43752169609069824, 0.1852734535932541, 0.135771244764328, 0.4373664855957031, 0.08196117728948593, 0.2951934039592743, 0.5477955341339111, 1.4281288385391235, 0.5954227447509766, 0.29166939854621887, 0.490168958902359, 0.9165048599243164, -0.42337965965270996, 0.1298830211162567, -0.04276953637599945, -0.04858678579330444, 0.5565474629402161, 0.7909151911735535, 0.37917524576187134, 0.24905873835086823, -0.7872840166091919, 0.3814302980899811, -0.45934078097343445, -0.38503479957580566, 0.3332568109035492, -0.07172189652919769, -0.427555114030838, 0.09196217358112335, 0.6561633944511414, 0.6645855903625488, 0.24837824702262878, 0.5833682417869568, -0.24111802875995636, 0.404519647359848, 0.833490252494812, -0.2108224332332611, 0.9721425771713257, -0.4216999411582947, -0.4917795658111572, -0.3601364493370056, 0.33294677734375, 0.37907058000564575, -0.3427625596523285, 0.6145859956741333, -0.32332953810691833, -0.4995887279510498, 0.2736259400844574, -0.14909330010414124, -0.17800846695899963, 0.5187647342681885, -0.18829496204853058, -0.7489075064659119, -0.5932474732398987, -0.14356310665607452, -0.743722140789032, 0.0544249527156353, 0.54953932762146, -0.534652590751648, -0.11853751540184021, 0.4201182723045349, 0.05628952011466026, 0.5122168660163879, 0.10479983687400818, 0.24726314842700958, -0.43479064106941223, 1.3388885259628296, 0.19766895473003387, 0.5639583468437195, 0.14395290613174438, -0.4715028405189514, -0.43964511156082153, 0.28106725215911865, -0.10988149791955948, 0.31601619720458984, 0.5334171652793884, -0.5423970222473145, -0.3134927451610565, 0.1725601851940155, -0.0722692534327507, -0.14384053647518158, -0.6965745091438293, 0.03920234739780426, 0.7325882911682129, -0.08455808460712433, -0.38546791672706604, 0.9745284914970398, -0.17737776041030884, 0.15813298523426056, -0.4456363618373871, -0.052930817008018494, -0.545791506767273, 0.42102742195129395, -0.12507908046245575, 0.8199883699417114, 0.47096091508865356, -0.38520434498786926, -0.6210600733757019, -0.8369097113609314, -0.45128118991851807, -0.7542315125465393, -0.7432264089584351, -1.1519147157669067, 0.45049116015434265, -0.1981813609600067, 0.02965060994029045, 0.31226223707199097, -0.06423410028219223, 0.16278471052646637, 0.21271273493766785, 1.3105041980743408, -0.3994999825954437, 0.2529732584953308, 0.17978569865226746, 0.19574347138404846, 0.3163430094718933, 0.49005186557769775, 0.42465707659721375, -0.07116907835006714, 0.011445165611803532, 0.016214236617088318, -0.2079417109489441, -0.20842328667640686, -0.3566877245903015, 0.16175919771194458, -0.4140838086605072, -0.40117987990379333, -0.4391152858734131, -0.6986461877822876, -0.6674628853797913, -0.44877442717552185, 0.8325327634811401, -0.4224475920200348, 0.36667266488075256, 0.20911355316638947, -0.4543302357196808, 0.2469554841518402, -0.17821523547172546, 4.082874298095703, 1.6917989253997803, 0.17682211101055145, -0.5795217752456665, -0.041047267615795135, 0.17581479251384735, 0.2544943690299988, -0.3582741916179657, 0.26078906655311584, 0.3978614807128906, -0.5076055526733398, 0.893060028553009, -0.03700736165046692, -0.7160621881484985, 1.052212119102478, 0.491228848695755, -0.29112035036087036, 0.0927770733833313, -0.003039724426344037, -0.2382228970527649, -0.2061716914176941, 0.8429694175720215, -0.010972334071993828, -0.4293340742588043, 0.39248862862586975, 0.2272692173719406, -0.039079826325178146, 0.19034184515476227, -1.0475366115570068, 0.41633129119873047, 0.3584221303462982, -1.0542280673980713, 0.5902847647666931, -0.17353734374046326, 0.0784144252538681, 0.7617696523666382, -0.4816907048225403, -0.2583882212638855, -0.2777271270751953, 0.07461321353912354, 0.16512392461299896, -0.2276431769132614, -0.5544780492782593, -0.40224167704582214, -0.5984646081924438, 0.14497385919094086, -0.3441343903541565, 0.43140366673469543, 0.5210254788398743, -0.4358033835887909, 0.9796265363693237, -0.8557385802268982, 0.018887288868427277, 0.2893882393836975, -0.8695033192634583, -0.19020019471645355, -0.508513867855072, -1.1670023202896118, 0.00992633868008852, -0.06286503374576569, 0.5361303687095642, 0.01865909807384014, -0.06909198313951492, -0.18016476929187775, 0.41768452525138855, 0.8590953350067139, 0.5780904293060303, 0.7011400461196899, -0.3019822835922241, -0.3001132905483246, -0.1878611147403717, 0.04282069578766823, -1.149910807609558, 0.5733401775360107, 0.22641408443450928, 0.6069817543029785, -0.4690000116825104, 0.28786295652389526, 0.08384567499160767, -0.4915444850921631, -0.10445655137300491, -0.5782427191734314, 0.023516640067100525, -0.2176036387681961, 0.40421172976493835, 0.8232253789901733, -0.39609673619270325, -0.22438892722129822, -1.2806910276412964, 0.9257718324661255, 0.8185809254646301, 0.30751124024391174, -0.11251609027385712, 0.23769360780715942, -0.4869156777858734 ]
{"Title": "Brain functional network integrity sustains cognitive function despite atrophy in presymptomatic genetic frontotemporal dementia", "Authors": "Tsvetanov Kamen A., Gazzina Stefano, Jones P. Simon, Swieten John van, Borroni Barbara, Sanchez-Valle Raquel, Moreno Fermin, Laforce Robert Jr, Graff Caroline, Synofzik Matthis, Galimberti Daniela, Masellis Mario, Tartaglia Maria Carmela, Finger Elizabeth, Vandenberghe Rik, de Mendon\u00e7a Alexandre, Tagliavini Fabrizio, Santana Isabel, Ducharme Simon, Butler Chris, Gerhard Alexander, Danek Adrian, Levin Johannes, Otto Markus, Frisoni Giovanni, Ghidoni Roberta, Sorbi Sandro, Rohrer Jonathan D., Rowe James B.", "Abstract": "Abstract INTRODUCTION The presymptomatic phase of neurodegenerative disease can last many years, with sustained cognitive function despite progressive atrophy. We investigate this phenomenon in familial Frontotemporal dementia (FTD). METHODS We studied 121 presymptomatic FTD mutation carriers and 134 family members without mutations, using multivariate data-driven approach to link cognitive performance with both structural and functional magnetic resonance imaging. Atrophy and brain network connectivity were compared between groups, in relation to the time from expected symptom onset. RESULTS There were group differences in brain structure and function, in the absence of differences in cognitive performance. Specifically, we identified behaviourally-relevant structural and functional network differences. Structure-function relationships were similar in both groups, but coupling between functional connectivity and cognition was stronger for carriers than for non-carriers, and increased with proximity to the expected onset of disease. DISCUSSION Our findings suggest that maintenance of functional network connectivity enables carriers to maintain cognitive performance.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012203"}
10.1101/19011023
[ -0.29938042163848877, 0.08310725539922714, -1.2280923128128052, 1.1175730228424072, -0.8185168504714966, -0.7799099683761597, 0.22152990102767944, 0.13646605610847473, 0.16968752443790436, 0.06362670660018921, -0.24651014804840088, -0.03772406280040741, 0.8644224405288696, 0.06617032736539841, -0.0651414766907692, -0.49186182022094727, -0.525745689868927, -0.21899005770683289, -1.1478639841079712, 0.27690717577934265, 0.4093075394630432, 0.7454549074172974, -0.2538481652736664, 0.18119341135025024, -0.5460283160209656, 0.3083066940307617, 0.007487830705940723, -0.1158466711640358, 1.3840545415878296, 1.0254939794540405, 0.3324831426143646, 0.261528879404068, 0.1345197856426239, -0.31437551975250244, -0.6263079047203064, -1.0076370239257812, -0.1990867257118225, -0.7054653167724609, -0.2762382924556732, -0.23832091689109802, -0.050966255366802216, -0.21467739343643188, -0.08415300399065018, -1.1634492874145508, -1.4999313354492188, -0.5193886756896973, -0.0105091892182827, -0.7219287157058716, -0.30160871148109436, -0.5132497549057007, -0.2113812416791916, 0.3475625514984131, 0.01776728592813015, -0.12254250794649124, 0.12479153275489807, 0.15219703316688538, 0.10804270207881927, 0.03738576918840408, -0.5048456192016602, 0.893138587474823, 0.2745298147201538, -0.060456156730651855, 0.1550149917602539, -0.5439756512641907, 0.3390236496925354, 0.5937110781669617, 0.10012461245059967, -0.206803560256958, -0.37377113103866577, -0.6231371164321899, -1.3308714628219604, -0.22721810638904572, 0.056876812130212784, -0.19639676809310913, -0.23450754582881927, 0.23286962509155273, 0.1671304851770401, -0.3063391149044037, -0.13752403855323792, -0.5126531720161438, 0.3099863827228546, 0.24380674958229065, 0.00860926229506731, 0.9595563411712646, -0.12561164796352386, 0.24128411710262299, 0.25631359219551086, -0.4339282810688019, 0.7115252614021301, 0.05821334198117256, 0.11857105046510696, 0.00253180880099535, -0.11140251904726028, 0.5071837902069092, 0.1705903261899948, 0.3285910189151764, -0.9132857918739319, 0.08084650337696075, 0.6513907313346863, -0.20858164131641388, 0.6180415153503418, 0.8186339139938354, -0.3454829752445221, 0.38252681493759155, -0.9539834260940552, 0.5641722083091736, 0.8369461894035339, -0.3450812101364136, -0.17271162569522858, -0.7327167391777039, -0.4274789094924927, 0.42506644129753113, 0.4025965929031372, 0.060519181191921234, -0.16943255066871643, 0.07881969213485718, 0.6249451637268066, 0.5159204602241516, -0.6316846609115601, 0.8032082915306091, 0.18683752417564392, -0.2574121654033661, 0.10224418342113495, -1.1495656967163086, 0.7083497643470764, -0.1796768605709076, 0.5853394865989685, 0.37270432710647583, -0.3453325927257538, -0.17236553132534027, -0.17944470047950745, 0.031072435900568962, 0.16254866123199463, 0.6596155762672424, -1.021894931793213, 0.24540165066719055, -0.1587700992822647, 0.7398932576179504, 0.07698644697666168, -0.031190363690257072, -0.23210881650447845, 1.1174893379211426, -0.12141597270965576, 1.01621413230896, 0.11178258806467056, 1.1076442003250122, -0.7202579975128174, -1.160948634147644, -0.6213932037353516, -0.10440623760223389, 0.2721068859100342, 0.6917941570281982, 0.0036746340338140726, 0.37084800004959106, 0.17801719903945923, 0.08754514157772064, -0.17771458625793457, 0.462741881608963, -0.4672030210494995, 0.6835566759109497, 0.2729904055595398, 0.6027753949165344, -1.0851563215255737, 1.115430235862732, -0.5729459524154663, 0.5091985464096069, -0.1408284306526184, -0.09153088182210922, 0.9885647296905518, -0.815687358379364, 0.6372242569923401, 0.1318293958902359, -0.3316723704338074, -0.5295780897140503, 0.09075725078582764, 0.5496458411216736, 1.0430511236190796, 0.7559599876403809, -0.22701577842235565, 0.601670503616333, -0.024471957236528397, -0.09703472256660461, 0.7897474765777588, 1.1832952499389648, -0.33231186866760254, -0.23521263897418976, -0.6816500425338745, -0.8369613289833069, -0.30672773718833923, -0.06456933170557022, 0.1004219651222229, 0.8255229592323303, -1.0041438341140747, 1.1429587602615356, 0.5115289688110352, -0.37569302320480347, -0.1943884938955307, 0.5763819217681885, 0.4826454222202301, -0.3920252323150635, -0.9611907601356506, 0.3124847412109375, 0.039284657686948776, 0.6646867990493774, -0.2317899763584137, 0.18988431990146637, 0.1494646817445755, 0.38184037804603577, 0.006094709504395723, 0.0896870419383049, 0.186863511800766, 0.15348197519779205, -0.1324809342622757, 0.2561797499656677, 0.813724935054779, -0.3244279623031616, 0.5830153226852417, 0.02392682433128357, -0.18997706472873688, -0.062031421810388565, -0.4670637845993042, 0.4646618366241455, 0.3807115852832794, -0.5466257333755493, 0.040057405829429626, -0.02109549194574356, 0.6937776803970337, 0.23539718985557556, -0.572712242603302, -0.29920098185539246, -0.11534015834331512, 1.0492501258850098, 0.22639326751232147, 0.8275160789489746, 0.3141559362411499, 1.2938328981399536, 0.14267173409461975, 0.7913649678230286, 1.492836594581604, -0.102923184633255, 0.29437515139579773, 0.011724847368896008, 1.200923204421997, 0.18386997282505035, -0.4618401825428009, 0.2529692053794861, -0.4726918041706085, -0.2670998275279999, -0.28885307908058167, -0.3143162727355957, -0.05908091366291046, 0.6949147582054138, 0.49477872252464294, 0.05773279815912247, -1.243881344795227, 0.5080881118774414, 0.9620747566223145, 0.5909579992294312, -0.17069192230701447, -0.4795721173286438, -0.029848869889974594, 0.31044718623161316, 0.5519790649414062, 0.45183512568473816, 1.0525550842285156, -0.652485728263855, -0.06796377897262573, 0.4429565668106079, 0.29794061183929443, 0.39366811513900757, -0.9597291350364685, -0.655443012714386, -1.3373245000839233, -0.7322918176651001, -0.5088770985603333, -0.26131805777549744, -0.1660226434469223, -0.3771153390407562, -0.146988645195961, -0.2883204221725464, -0.07064059376716614, -0.6552981734275818, 0.41424494981765747, 0.28185221552848816, 0.4738864004611969, 0.1598728597164154, -0.8721341490745544, 0.16153274476528168, -0.6549520492553711, -0.13433755934238434, -0.26772063970565796, -0.6501398682594299, -0.6348277926445007, -0.5865981578826904, 0.4495260715484619, -0.21894021332263947, -0.2828923463821411, 0.006567882373929024, -0.9850518107414246, -0.3928958773612976, 0.19067135453224182, -0.4399126470088959, 0.49108460545539856, 0.126882404088974, -0.771750807762146, 0.5236042141914368, -0.35469067096710205, -0.10357599705457687, 0.7384985089302063, 0.8455234169960022, -0.44198518991470337, 1.3117897510528564, 0.3503448963165283, 0.11502993851900101, -0.6022849082946777, 0.18018579483032227, 0.6084231734275818, -0.34814152121543884, -0.3607323169708252, -0.40613019466400146, -0.6370016932487488, 0.24985985457897186, 0.29495829343795776, -0.4908609986305237, 0.2585764229297638, -0.31179460883140564, -0.4455619156360626, -1.3410685062408447, 0.19177792966365814, -0.9284378886222839, -1.3315404653549194, -0.24316594004631042, -0.21969187259674072, -0.054152194410562515, 0.38755565881729126, 0.1744924634695053, 0.6555083990097046, -0.42716485261917114, -0.023502109572291374, -0.3494383990764618, 0.07924927771091461, -0.1461450159549713, -0.22739382088184357, 0.7072688937187195, -0.6218628287315369, 0.5868611931800842, -0.1727893203496933, -0.19255387783050537, -0.3561069071292877, -0.37565547227859497, -0.2139785885810852, 0.043979525566101074, 0.5069766640663147, -0.7003521919250488, 0.2366281896829605, 0.5472317934036255, -0.2589365839958191, 0.4336858093738556, 0.09630180150270462, 0.8629136681556702, -0.5997411608695984, 0.5279255509376526, 0.34181979298591614, 0.09379775077104568, -0.6802595257759094, -0.3260491192340851, 0.8037247061729431, 0.4598580300807953, 0.503104567527771, -0.33925095200538635, 0.9883060455322266, -0.19122867286205292, -0.059351470321416855, -0.11178959906101227, -0.38888826966285706, -0.6776552200317383, 1.2273359298706055, -0.01598566770553589, 0.46135884523391724, -1.4159337282180786, 0.0784386545419693, 0.11452139168977737, 1.5758880376815796, -0.0655083954334259, 0.20768041908740997, -0.10468126088380814, 0.10015557706356049, -0.19232872128486633, 0.6367089152336121, 0.12360748648643494, -0.29896026849746704, -0.4972538352012634, 0.2709353566169739, -0.021595267578959465, -0.4171961843967438, -0.22460754215717316, 0.6776955723762512, 0.10134150087833405, 0.5376921892166138, -0.66282057762146, 0.14735986292362213, 0.4355449080467224, 0.8122239112854004, 0.3396415114402771, 0.42712193727493286, 0.07913372665643692, -0.8233934640884399, -0.007344044279307127, -0.01698974519968033, 0.16987344622612, -0.5968061089515686, 0.19704753160476685, -0.20456662774085999, 0.43604326248168945, 0.09084351360797882, 0.49427714943885803, 0.053075436502695084, -0.3196749985218048, -0.5190179944038391, 0.044359445571899414, 0.2974662184715271, -0.5073413252830505, -0.8614438772201538, 0.28440821170806885, 0.39602816104888916, 0.4681526720523834, -0.36253809928894043, -0.4855186343193054, 0.06391976028680801, 0.6409581899642944, -0.7864840626716614, -0.3979039788246155, 0.006748697720468044, 0.31759023666381836, -0.3591679632663727, 0.046649277210235596, 0.03136548772454262, -0.8323583602905273, 0.08526651561260223, -0.7321348190307617, -0.12330776453018188, -0.4184143543243408, -0.2345777004957199, -0.12098176777362823, -0.25056660175323486, 0.053908832371234894, 0.6216857433319092, 0.1060790941119194, 0.2072007656097412, 0.23222801089286804, 0.5684850811958313, -0.5478264093399048, 0.04734158515930176, 0.2729426324367523, -0.14534848928451538, -0.09275344014167786, -0.129429891705513, 0.22203388810157776, 0.17891231179237366, 0.2899214029312134, -0.6284360289573669, -0.09497329592704773, 0.2191990166902542, 0.4255210757255554, 0.5175437927246094, 0.5006589293479919, -0.5963094830513, -0.2945083975791931, 0.8360348343849182, -0.32927829027175903, -0.30193543434143066, 0.16624893248081207, 0.14043883979320526, -0.8925727009773254, 0.5730262398719788, -0.6220266819000244, -0.09548000246286392, 0.24251532554626465, -0.5143102407455444, 0.4224807620048523, -0.4139433205127716, 0.15060152113437653, -0.25402164459228516, -0.29668116569519043, -0.443387895822525, -0.37241894006729126, -0.21147994697093964, -0.02670048363506794, -0.6532142758369446, -0.01684291660785675, -0.16599231958389282, -1.0308842658996582, -0.15217921137809753, -0.3756340742111206, -0.3698602318763733, -0.05890277400612831, -0.603409469127655, 1.0112254619598389, -0.31728896498680115, -0.07768083363771439, 0.7014214992523193, -1.0159189701080322, -0.6722283959388733, 0.4829847812652588, 0.06051360443234444, -0.6149963736534119, 0.1818753182888031, -0.11011900007724762, 0.06119856610894203, 0.31085631251335144, -0.2605666518211365, 0.4869581162929535, -0.5517833232879639, 1.0936726331710815, 0.5495927929878235, 0.09622464329004288, -0.060183774679899216, -0.5568822026252747, -0.07006556540727615, 0.7199521064758301, -0.5526549220085144, -0.7138122320175171, -0.5149471759796143, 0.007402386050671339, -0.20547707378864288, 0.49312397837638855, -0.7239919900894165, -0.08045882731676102, -0.38103368878364563, -1.290666103363037, -0.22557905316352844, -0.3990660011768341, -0.5635334849357605, -0.4861510396003723, -0.7212216854095459, -0.23063217103481293, 0.25257939100265503, 0.10800612717866898, -0.06881602853536606, 0.015542786568403244, -0.4507867395877838, 0.11072009801864624, -0.6395033001899719, -0.1646822839975357, 0.8012471199035645, -0.2441793829202652, 0.576317310333252, 1.3284966945648193, 1.315962791442871, 0.03451307490468025, 0.06663619726896286, 0.1908758133649826, 1.0776128768920898, 0.2664777636528015, -0.34870630502700806, -0.35893484950065613, 0.11589903384447098, -0.17034663259983063, 0.22712871432304382, 0.37807318568229675, -0.5339439511299133, 0.3052058219909668, -0.5597599744796753, 0.2632977068424225, -0.8963814377784729, -0.2745317220687866, 0.14936143159866333, -0.1269671469926834, 0.9782708287239075, -0.4609336256980896, -0.10610783845186234, 0.13918238878250122, 0.000351076916558668, 0.4908556342124939, -0.3429661691188812, -0.46364685893058777, -0.7966535687446594, -0.9220353960990906, -0.715496838092804, -0.4684019982814789, 0.3447396755218506, -0.13853280246257782, -0.08580513298511505, -0.535760760307312, 0.20154200494289398, -0.5602996945381165, 0.9099292159080505, 1.0120946168899536, -0.7822454571723938, -0.4261837303638458, -0.3175713121891022, 0.14775842428207397, 0.9938940405845642, 0.3853888213634491, 0.07389936596155167, -0.4509408473968506, -0.36637264490127563, -0.274994820356369, -0.483611136674881, -0.8212000727653503, 0.1297857165336609, 0.39363425970077515, 0.5888499021530151, -0.712517499923706, 0.269951194524765, -0.3484647572040558, 0.2438676357269287, -0.9613159894943237, 0.8896567225456238, -0.184587761759758, -0.20101310312747955, 0.545717716217041, -1.029815435409546, -0.7407307028770447, -0.12597313523292542, -0.04506510868668556, 0.1659644991159439, 0.3188687860965729, 0.5282395482063293, 0.917720377445221, -0.650374174118042, 0.3722996711730957, 0.7325360178947449, -0.22529472410678864, -0.5859376788139343, 0.15748576819896698, 0.1886090636253357, 0.04722242057323456, -0.30457237362861633, -0.35842886567115784, 1.426337718963623, 0.3855338394641876, 0.946969747543335, 0.05033877119421959, -0.5940895676612854, -0.40188759565353394, -0.4744255542755127, 0.18591555953025818, -0.7840014696121216, 0.19207686185836792, 0.4293796718120575, 0.32088378071784973, 0.18678508698940277, 0.049582235515117645, 0.27119681239128113, 0.26819908618927, -0.12847550213336945, 0.45643600821495056, -0.7188730239868164, -0.49404728412628174, -0.42722469568252563, 0.4195486605167389, 0.028262978419661522, -0.34437140822410583, 0.20266707241535187, 0.5972282886505127, 0.08103257417678833, -0.004727210383862257, -0.6560758352279663, 0.33183109760284424, -0.8628994822502136, 0.6858364343643188, -0.6894562244415283, -0.16117262840270996, 0.9024475812911987, 0.8154364228248596, 0.5865113735198975, -0.3809131979942322, -1.1136363744735718, -0.17443250119686127, -0.5462309718132019, 0.2622709572315216, -0.31960219144821167, 0.0034283804707229137, 0.3607822060585022, -0.2837466299533844, -0.24616988003253937, -0.4964527189731598, 1.4643794298171997, -1.0022509098052979, 0.09550543129444122, -1.1123219728469849, 0.8476133346557617, -0.9851906895637512, -0.7174788117408752, -0.8355724811553955, -0.3169490694999695, -0.25624358654022217, 0.6169214844703674, -0.14438357949256897, -0.24297046661376953, 0.1460554301738739, 0.289793461561203, 0.15223342180252075, 0.4429229199886322, -0.6428800821304321, -0.09858065843582153, 0.5681623816490173, 1.0339325666427612, 0.12760327756404877, 0.8573022484779358, 0.49824613332748413, -0.552518904209137, 0.0436011366546154, -0.08268322050571442, -0.5024675726890564, -0.7459767460823059, -0.0376504585146904, 0.2442217618227005, -0.32852721214294434, -0.2890695333480835, -0.31108972430229187, 0.09945951402187347, -0.47863146662712097, 0.16458465158939362, 0.8140745759010315, -0.013114280998706818, -0.2838289141654968, -0.0758076012134552, -0.1132044792175293, 0.15465466678142548, -0.18241459131240845, 0.15771447122097015, 0.4334650933742523, 0.8478713631629944, 0.05236306041479111, 0.21924108266830444, -0.02752191759645939, 0.4324553906917572, 0.0950503721833229, -1.1179507970809937, 0.8806344866752625, 0.032536476850509644, -0.48647722601890564, 0.06253702938556671, -0.8578841090202332, 0.29945555329322815, -0.21952590346336365, -0.1836586892604828, 0.4938315153121948, 1.322450041770935, 0.17219312489032745, -0.547747790813446, -0.06075755134224892, -0.16008667647838593, -0.3224802613258362, -0.3619856536388397, -1.0697448253631592, -0.5421946048736572, 0.397958368062973, -0.4030398726463318, -0.599898636341095, -0.3408311605453491, -0.2743113934993744, 0.11725807934999466, 0.10496893525123596, 0.20313966274261475, -0.8636463284492493, 0.27457907795906067, 0.4606727063655853, 0.3806171715259552, -0.20395934581756592, -0.18620911240577698, 0.32147663831710815, 0.057442355901002884, -0.6229372024536133, -0.1988794058561325, 0.8056350946426392, -0.013021262362599373, 0.5677345991134644, -0.5375846028327942, 0.3936425447463989, 0.6846767663955688, 0.08434785157442093, 0.36430609226226807, -0.4852675199508667, 0.6733596920967102, 0.2597745656967163, -0.654700517654419, 0.1543775200843811, 0.5059191584587097, 0.006786189042031765, 0.4413071274757385, 0.5745989680290222, -0.9355966448783875, -0.7342405319213867, 0.08307835459709167, 0.43725547194480896, -0.23610037565231323, 0.8460410237312317, -0.8495379686355591, 0.6045756936073303, -0.1152697205543518, 0.4698898494243622, 0.8698061108589172, 0.4226507842540741, 0.9336499571800232, 0.5046703815460205, -0.2553519904613495, 0.1850607842206955, 0.30343547463417053, 0.14158178865909576, 0.29302504658699036, 0.5769400596618652, -0.04612116515636444, -0.28241682052612305, 0.5881482362747192, -0.3029629588127136, 0.555108904838562, 0.06252654641866684, -0.10918751358985901, 0.19851142168045044, -0.1240946352481842, 0.9615098834037781, 0.1318850815296173, -0.7872596979141235, 0.37877926230430603, -0.5341785550117493, -0.7881893515586853, -0.11592237651348114, -0.5716933608055115, 0.381326287984848, -0.15619230270385742, 0.3094768822193146, 0.21500879526138306, 0.12826640903949738, 0.4470102787017822, 0.04239422455430031, 0.5119224786758423, -0.056154750287532806, -0.7163498401641846, -0.2642194330692291, 0.41202306747436523, -0.14126567542552948, 0.16830086708068848, -0.1393224447965622, 0.10612753033638, 0.6148987412452698, 0.3647133409976959, 0.03568096086382866, -0.5848362445831299, 0.8913567066192627, -0.3771545886993408, -0.06961444765329361, -0.30764684081077576, -0.598916232585907, -0.2103842943906784, -0.4465177655220032, 0.521020233631134, -0.5732907056808472, 0.026970429345965385, 0.3631252646446228, 0.060810767114162445, 0.5951015949249268, 0.14131508767604828, 0.874092698097229, -0.7451609373092651, 0.6055681705474854, 0.8011467456817627, -0.41332876682281494, 0.17625084519386292, 0.1449076384305954, -0.28003227710723877, 0.14350078999996185, 0.12013787031173706, 0.3854028880596161, -0.590948224067688, 0.10391707718372345, 0.022710619494318962, 0.1031956672668457, 0.0010457361349835992, -0.18549786508083344, -0.9954166412353516, 0.015188613906502724, -0.07120666652917862, 0.5759266018867493, -0.15709030628204346, 0.44225624203681946, -0.2728337049484253, -0.23683249950408936, -0.46500009298324585, -0.14646488428115845, -0.5486236810684204, 0.49225926399230957, -0.4691022038459778, 0.49888473749160767, 0.27019843459129333, -0.7011231184005737, -0.3239942491054535, -1.0566620826721191, 0.17375431954860687, 0.8634644746780396, -0.14783434569835663, -1.0617095232009888, -0.2440675050020218, -0.35765570402145386, 0.33382484316825867, 0.2041543871164322, 0.07798104733228683, -0.32846128940582275, 0.7671223282814026, 0.33213481307029724, -0.12739837169647217, 0.2674524784088135, 0.3168140649795532, 0.06426814943552017, 0.38657188415527344, 0.22297315299510956, 0.04027433320879936, -0.19396314024925232, -0.49800488352775574, -0.1806211769580841, 0.6663733124732971, -0.2474394291639328, -0.8615310192108154, 0.10424836724996567, 0.37978747487068176, -0.3627859055995941, 0.22406978905200958, -0.9571810364723206, -0.6651738286018372, -0.2571011185646057, 0.7229521870613098, -0.5504927039146423, 0.20490726828575134, -0.05394276604056358, -0.023932049050927162, 0.3602359890937805, -0.6487293839454651, 4.148585319519043, 0.7532575726509094, -0.1681760549545288, 0.05452582612633705, 0.9607881903648376, 0.4361551105976105, 1.415885090827942, -0.037283871322870255, -0.07109081000089645, -0.23901687562465668, -0.07999789714813232, 0.16729578375816345, -0.3027247488498688, -0.048514582216739655, 0.16933396458625793, 0.19092129170894623, -0.7418124675750732, -0.39460232853889465, -0.7943297624588013, -0.9167942404747009, -0.21674534678459167, 0.5822479724884033, -0.24502520263195038, 0.16419410705566406, -0.35719382762908936, 0.12631386518478394, -0.04871416091918945, 0.4443708062171936, 0.07450923323631287, 0.17331965267658234, 0.05072125419974327, -0.9313093423843384, 0.1706131100654602, -1.3942761421203613, -0.04366842657327652, 0.45137348771095276, 0.27608540654182434, -0.2490207403898239, -0.27044621109962463, -0.026033828034996986, 0.8318242430686951, -0.012996677309274673, -0.3971711993217468, -0.19355463981628418, -0.9624716639518738, -0.17512521147727966, 0.008806147612631321, 0.08313401788473129, -0.20894522964954376, -0.6960510611534119, 0.9498823285102844, -0.7470260858535767, 0.19120736420154572, 0.43730250000953674, -0.41315534710884094, -0.3676179051399231, 0.48271429538726807, -0.5989823937416077, -0.13908609747886658, 0.0286164078861475, 0.694714367389679, -0.05799289047718048, -0.06598690152168274, 0.0427560955286026, -0.0855824202299118, 0.43201175332069397, 0.028351236134767532, 0.1273975372314453, -0.34665802121162415, -0.23654142022132874, -0.028447676450014114, -0.7147171497344971, -0.3394854962825775, 0.04543709754943848, 1.237184762954712, 0.4985237717628479, 0.2989666759967804, 0.5194397568702698, 0.0026480641681700945, -0.7791131138801575, 0.048857323825359344, 0.4357296824455261, 0.14666150510311127, 0.2672843635082245, -0.37597933411598206, 0.4878973662853241, -1.130990743637085, -0.18040190637111664, -0.844539225101471, 0.5047781467437744, 0.2877490818500519, -0.2980892062187195, -0.13455529510974884, -0.4770699143409729, -0.07659977674484253 ]
{"Title": "Motivational Strategies for Stroke Rehabilitation: A Descriptive Cross-sectional Study", "Authors": "Oyake Kazuaki, Suzuki Makoto, Otaka Yokei, Tanaka Satoshi", "Abstract": "Abstract Background and Purpose The addition of motivational strategies to a rehabilitation program is thought to enhance patient adherence and improve outcomes. However, little is known about how rehabilitation professionals motivate stroke patients during rehabilitation. The primary objective of this study was to provide a comprehensive and quantitative list of motivational strategies for stroke rehabilitation. In addition, we aimed to examine (1) whether professionals with more clinical experience used a higher number of motivational strategies, (2) the purpose for using each strategy, and (3) the information considered when choosing strategies. Methods This descriptive, cross-sectional study was conducted using a web survey with a random sample of 407 rehabilitation professionals including physicians, nurses, physical therapists, occupational therapists, and speech-language-hearing therapists. Results We received data for 362 participants. Fifteen strategies were found to be used by more than 75% of the respondents reported using to motivate their patients. Almost all of the respondents reported that they actively listen to and praise their patients to increase patient adherence to rehabilitation programs. Respondents with more clinical experience tended to use a higher number of motivational strategies (rho = 0.208, p < 0.001). For 11 of the 15 strategies selected by more than 75% of respondents, the highest percentage of respondents reported that they used the strategies to make rehabilitation worthwhile for their patients. The majority of respondents reported that they decide which motivational strategy to use by considering comprehensive information regarding the patient health condition, environmental factors, and personal factors. Conclusions The comprehensive list of motivational strategies obtained may be useful for increasing patient adherence to rehabilitation, especially for professionals with less clinical experience. Furthermore, our findings regarding the purpose for using each strategy and the information used to choose strategies might help rehabilitation professionals to utilize the motivational strategy list.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19011023"}
10.1101/19000919
[ 0.10314522683620453, -0.7229461669921875, -0.009249483235180378, 0.39557868242263794, -0.7565603256225586, -0.6693777441978455, -0.049718376249074936, 0.007058558985590935, 0.31167879700660706, 0.6159815192222595, -0.032474420964717865, -0.32985591888427734, 0.6558447480201721, 0.27877381443977356, -0.8401979207992554, 0.8298539519309998, -0.36564186215400696, -0.16758187115192413, 0.4501887559890747, 0.5107342004776001, -0.2404300421476364, 0.4317382872104645, -0.6485782265663147, -0.5551739931106567, 0.22017382085323334, 0.01227713841944933, -0.7402704954147339, -0.2557222843170166, 1.274644136428833, 0.7780113220214844, -0.04812101274728775, 0.348521888256073, 0.8476929068565369, -0.29087501764297485, -0.013021593913435936, -0.2525276243686676, 0.6977943181991577, -0.3859099745750427, 0.43281641602516174, -0.2306670844554901, 0.26060399413108826, 0.07470684498548508, 0.7792531251907349, -0.16506275534629822, -0.051133014261722565, -0.6403979659080505, -0.3805193305015564, 0.2553822696208954, 0.3863377571105957, -0.017447607591748238, 0.1637367159128189, 0.6110223531723022, 0.2073148787021637, -0.23328721523284912, -0.050704967230558395, -0.18895716965198517, 0.21586844325065613, -0.2530231475830078, -0.9838859438896179, -0.580966055393219, -0.25048765540122986, -0.4142588973045349, 0.3915593922138214, -1.0224062204360962, 0.7632367014884949, 0.8933863043785095, 0.44840526580810547, -0.8407577276229858, -0.2539371848106384, -0.4949811100959778, -0.026432987302541733, 0.5882244110107422, -0.38226792216300964, -0.34774449467658997, -0.5027246475219727, -0.4500388205051422, 0.2311452329158783, -0.2223932147026062, -0.27192166447639465, 0.05908382311463356, -0.02586277201771736, 0.19723868370056152, 0.35444411635398865, -0.41120627522468567, -0.43720948696136475, 0.564210057258606, 0.43709471821784973, 0.5065230131149292, 0.25883960723876953, 0.5849865674972534, 0.8588162064552307, 0.3863857388496399, -0.1514054387807846, -0.27188464999198914, 0.2925455570220947, 1.1866555213928223, -0.899621844291687, 0.14495375752449036, 0.6880066394805908, 0.49082323908805847, 1.1017239093780518, 0.8326395153999329, 0.3296879231929779, 1.357380986213684, -0.5641664862632751, 0.23193447291851044, 0.6791660785675049, -0.7218149304389954, -0.5966576337814331, -0.5124927759170532, 0.16114942729473114, 0.47348397970199585, -0.26699525117874146, -0.8299019932746887, 1.0446982383728027, 0.6215795874595642, 0.14305250346660614, 0.7440367341041565, -0.2604621946811676, 1.1878076791763306, 0.2972334623336792, -0.5651826858520508, 0.5273114442825317, -0.8232656121253967, -0.03504318371415138, 0.23583711683750153, 0.6793654561042786, 0.6651940941810608, -0.554396390914917, -0.641158938407898, 0.371509850025177, -0.4302509129047394, -0.45756471157073975, 0.7515742778778076, 0.08504044264554977, -0.5655711889266968, 0.19950295984745026, 0.5219178795814514, 0.6486045122146606, -0.22416651248931885, -0.5127765536308289, 0.22064033150672913, -0.6064077019691467, 1.0105786323547363, -0.47025078535079956, 0.3146928548812866, -0.11374026536941528, -0.6713085770606995, -1.2831628322601318, 0.05581885203719139, -0.42114517092704773, 0.2272682785987854, 0.03393559530377388, 0.4916473925113678, -0.19442011415958405, -0.2790856957435608, -0.482695609331131, -0.001633049687370658, -0.4289431869983673, 0.7506271004676819, -0.5205397605895996, 0.8699844479560852, 0.22173067927360535, 0.3428908884525299, -1.2232937812805176, 0.29637089371681213, -0.7178322076797485, -0.14197170734405518, 0.2875945568084717, -1.018864393234253, 0.7299425601959229, 0.08847994357347488, -0.45074114203453064, 0.49745020270347595, 0.4037720263004303, 0.8705748915672302, 0.7661441564559937, -0.2593466639518738, 0.14227086305618286, 0.6435871720314026, -0.01215518731623888, -0.38356858491897583, 0.2892264723777771, 0.31661608815193176, -0.43036195635795593, -0.4599430561065674, -0.45186731219291687, -1.389377236366272, -0.07519571483135223, -0.4368574321269989, 0.1591702103614807, -0.0692112147808075, -0.9330346584320068, 0.49058428406715393, 0.035597678273916245, -1.0364325046539307, -0.9927386045455933, 0.861059844493866, 0.4175911843776703, -0.8759633302688599, -0.46502089500427246, 0.8353156447410583, -0.3363819420337677, -0.21488815546035767, -0.009974364191293716, 0.6394737362861633, 0.39947354793548584, 0.2826730012893677, 0.5533132553100586, 0.17088432610034943, 0.8078938722610474, -0.6748877167701721, -0.26300203800201416, -0.2665731608867645, 0.7410776019096375, -0.1769336313009262, -0.37598374485969543, 0.6905817985534668, -0.8366338014602661, 0.459008127450943, -0.7290331721305847, -0.44231411814689636, 0.7688314914703369, 0.5713955163955688, -0.5910623669624329, -0.24947614967823029, 0.9141175746917725, -0.1572495698928833, -0.38806456327438354, 0.22363048791885376, -0.10145253688097, 0.8617566227912903, -0.3340875804424286, 0.5698854923248291, 0.9221110939979553, 0.2864588797092438, -0.0016362662427127361, 0.5449277758598328, 0.2947409451007843, 0.122688889503479, -0.3098384439945221, 0.34397560358047485, -0.38880446553230286, -0.0871940404176712, 0.12892328202724457, 1.0421448945999146, 0.11792831867933273, 0.013360884971916676, -0.8586229085922241, -0.3216838538646698, -0.17337556183338165, 0.8569300174713135, 0.44613614678382874, -0.05048508942127228, -1.158848762512207, -0.3373313546180725, 0.6731856465339661, 0.4642181694507599, -0.8323334455490112, -0.7883457541465759, 0.40090128779411316, 0.6948733329772949, -0.47021594643592834, -0.06903211027383804, 1.054495096206665, 0.7636430263519287, -0.1520819216966629, 1.1030362844467163, 0.4802185297012329, 0.08680693060159683, -1.4369739294052124, -0.7647198438644409, -0.8726212382316589, -0.8012822866439819, -1.1921310424804688, 0.15545837581157684, 0.15693266689777374, -0.06881150603294373, 0.9100365042686462, 0.042656850069761276, 0.8471261858940125, 0.048877932131290436, -0.2761286795139313, -0.27039361000061035, 0.3923798203468323, 0.5340552926063538, -0.8462122082710266, 0.5597251057624817, -0.33348214626312256, -0.3318716883659363, -0.6557607650756836, 0.014625932089984417, -0.4750342071056366, 0.08119432628154755, 0.3847544491291046, -0.2637926936149597, 0.1603415459394455, 0.03910987824201584, -0.7428576946258545, -0.05646291375160217, 0.2802998423576355, -0.1401151716709137, 0.45635783672332764, 0.1574973165988922, -0.466879665851593, 0.48825308680534363, 0.07841909676790237, -0.10763801634311676, 0.7389130592346191, -0.4452636241912842, -0.14216038584709167, 0.350811243057251, 0.5255052447319031, -0.013733086176216602, -1.2289022207260132, -0.045284122228622437, 0.1899520307779312, -0.5867584943771362, 0.2014540731906891, -0.6229954361915588, -0.7894490361213684, 0.4294573664665222, -0.5346399545669556, -0.02452031895518303, -0.5059860348701477, 0.4765673875808716, 0.054140351712703705, -1.2901862859725952, 0.8714371919631958, -0.2547970712184906, -1.1864351034164429, -0.18724828958511353, 0.36844950914382935, -0.28609034419059753, 0.03812484070658684, 0.116459921002388, 0.10179848968982697, -0.1823706030845642, 0.10445636510848999, -0.5983083248138428, -0.1846648007631302, -0.23184219002723694, 0.06144479662179947, -0.9483066201210022, -0.2396376132965088, 0.5211354494094849, -0.29671990871429443, -0.3059098720550537, -0.7667474150657654, -0.68683922290802, -0.24898335337638855, 1.0183285474777222, 0.7584186792373657, 0.6741921305656433, -0.5664984583854675, 0.28259536623954773, 0.48391059041023254, 0.10102321952581406, 0.35138630867004395, 0.01815982721745968, 0.10379937291145325, 0.23988477885723114, -0.43296051025390625, 0.2329878807067871, -0.250527024269104, -0.5289093255996704, 0.2966478765010834, -0.20956669747829437, 0.4769286811351776, -0.07700426876544952, 0.9002904891967773, -0.04536234587430954, 0.12212005257606506, 0.18675951659679413, 0.11000052094459534, -0.47147589921951294, 0.9259524345397949, -0.36578959226608276, 0.9727545976638794, -0.3472825884819031, -0.2498321235179901, 0.4575643837451935, 0.4316452145576477, 0.5898920297622681, -0.23703262209892273, 0.5241515040397644, -0.8708485960960388, 0.21359282732009888, 0.36356550455093384, -0.08241316676139832, -0.30515581369400024, 0.15087561309337616, 0.46995702385902405, 0.06505440175533295, -1.0641703605651855, -0.0335681326687336, -0.08305391669273376, 0.7761033177375793, 0.42125922441482544, 0.1534535437822342, 1.6063103675842285, 0.27290838956832886, 0.12199370563030243, -0.15168464183807373, 0.48575082421302795, 0.2720620334148407, -1.1183263063430786, 0.7087527513504028, -0.18874122202396393, -0.3178712725639343, -0.7331142425537109, -0.06059606745839119, 0.2898055911064148, -0.41866353154182434, 0.22166089713573456, -0.38396626710891724, -0.1810658723115921, -0.8066114187240601, -0.13867789506912231, 0.34387922286987305, 0.17700879275798798, 0.12886004149913788, 0.10210046172142029, -0.11787225306034088, -0.5698524713516235, -0.5984172224998474, -0.4449453055858612, -0.1152387410402298, 0.20368459820747375, 0.45286279916763306, -0.25596216320991516, -0.8137694001197815, -0.28456729650497437, -0.4098713994026184, -1.0680997371673584, 0.0972275510430336, 0.26276347041130066, 0.7044709324836731, 0.4549752473831177, -0.9029940366744995, -0.2316480576992035, -0.09291895478963852, -0.32023999094963074, -0.41689035296440125, 0.1814512461423874, 0.46779975295066833, 0.8776711225509644, 0.5997718572616577, 1.009325385093689, 0.541875958442688, 0.14806170761585236, -0.9924960732460022, 0.5620319247245789, -0.6453161835670471, -0.9146581888198853, -0.24452078342437744, 0.6481005549430847, 0.48145249485969543, 0.4066271185874939, 0.19125191867351532, -0.09035317599773407, -0.5422387719154358, -0.011983869597315788, -0.6131688952445984, -0.06042108312249184, 1.2269428968429565, -0.5065578818321228, -0.4673127830028534, 1.604885220527649, -0.7066959738731384, 0.1332242339849472, 0.5479166507720947, -0.15788735449314117, -0.3786625266075134, 0.38022708892822266, 0.8210445642471313, 0.566540539264679, 0.7009862065315247, -0.5454678535461426, -0.26880913972854614, -0.41435185074806213, 0.7371904253959656, -0.2922249436378479, 0.24928279221057892, -0.453227698802948, -0.4185713827610016, -0.5794277787208557, -0.3633178174495697, -0.4161791205406189, 1.056896686553955, -0.7511232495307922, -0.41569483280181885, -0.8331099152565002, 0.3896830379962921, -1.0721955299377441, 0.10424677282571793, 0.1805923730134964, -0.3998129367828369, -0.4633852243423462, 0.6860214471817017, 0.19080649316310883, -0.034000106155872345, -1.0008915662765503, 0.2567306160926819, 0.21938888728618622, -0.4334235191345215, -0.18521271646022797, -0.017578864470124245, 0.5685303211212158, 0.1381373256444931, -0.7230204939842224, 0.5010038614273071, -0.046088043600320816, -0.16503804922103882, -0.4221149981021881, -0.7165789008140564, 0.8518562316894531, 0.8237331509590149, -0.4543594419956207, 0.7402292490005493, 0.45552441477775574, -1.0832523107528687, -0.22690553963184357, 0.4287889301776886, -0.37482842803001404, 0.3225434422492981, 0.04511713981628418, -0.10891421139240265, -0.5098267793655396, -1.3628023862838745, -0.2532738149166107, -0.39592525362968445, -0.31262773275375366, -0.02870333194732666, -0.31266456842422485, 0.10204897075891495, 0.3631899654865265, 0.41985148191452026, 0.4212755262851715, -0.307451069355011, -0.33033472299575806, -0.01969756931066513, 0.08117929846048355, 0.150634303689003, 0.0820855125784874, -1.5944240093231201, -0.16253748536109924, 0.7272508144378662, 0.07726484537124634, -0.48432657122612, -0.12755268812179565, 0.47173410654067993, 0.26139163970947266, 0.009692720137536526, -0.3365720808506012, -1.0696802139282227, 0.2852744460105896, 1.000691533088684, -0.5445806384086609, 0.2750624716281891, -0.23821784555912018, -0.0188614334911108, -0.4299793541431427, 0.6622916460037231, 0.05261234566569328, 0.005259498488157988, -0.19861546158790588, -0.5543767213821411, 1.0879758596420288, -0.6911125183105469, 0.9122803807258606, 0.8381797671318054, -0.5986449122428894, 0.2944697141647339, 0.1333814114332199, 0.4195891320705414, -0.1147608682513237, -0.3969185948371887, -1.2214431762695312, 0.04321786388754845, 0.2900858521461487, -0.5561420321464539, 0.11878199130296707, -0.17103004455566406, 0.6388028264045715, -0.439716100692749, 0.3742188513278961, 0.8859377503395081, -0.6498115062713623, -1.0272753238677979, 0.38955503702163696, 1.027209997177124, 0.09893577545881271, -0.22831234335899353, 0.2847781479358673, -0.7956924438476562, 0.9745886325836182, -0.15468184649944305, 0.12337436527013779, -0.3889996409416199, -0.6166614890098572, 0.27180859446525574, 0.8986970782279968, -0.06610681116580963, 0.19903570413589478, -0.19233162701129913, -0.3378107249736786, -1.0701223611831665, 0.07420191913843155, -0.4812876880168915, 0.5684995651245117, 0.25412264466285706, -0.47966212034225464, -0.2957248389720917, 0.07717780768871307, 0.14199534058570862, 0.060786519199609756, -0.4068111777305603, 0.8801987171173096, -0.108775794506073, -1.3349850177764893, 0.6248291730880737, 0.22009360790252686, -0.12444660812616348, 0.03183184564113617, 0.41661956906318665, 0.3731943666934967, 0.5838685631752014, -0.2011389583349228, -0.6137513518333435, 0.20953671634197235, 0.29044413566589355, 0.6960272192955017, -0.15000173449516296, -0.22822460532188416, 0.30274975299835205, -0.8708939552307129, 0.610856294631958, 0.11995495855808258, -0.554734468460083, 0.23995649814605713, -0.17143301665782928, 0.009361726231873035, 0.3692406713962555, 0.16988849639892578, 0.3092648983001709, -0.04562758654356003, 0.5872611403465271, -0.48387065529823303, 1.2634479999542236, -0.15514542162418365, 0.5353458523750305, 0.4334274232387543, -0.4063100218772888, -0.02717924304306507, 0.086037777364254, 0.41481614112854004, -0.49745190143585205, -0.7211208939552307, 0.08300241827964783, -0.05246815085411072, 0.49460139870643616, -0.2390860915184021, -0.5399609804153442, 0.39451128244400024, 0.6632137894630432, 0.3711164891719818, -0.7704833745956421, -0.35797253251075745, -0.6616053581237793, 0.09513507783412933, 0.06979398429393768, -0.7399095892906189, -0.42803576588630676, -0.12493813782930374, -1.1892305612564087, -0.38395068049430847, -0.04951286315917969, 0.30588388442993164, -0.587795078754425, 0.0062701464630663395, -0.6952748894691467, -0.1337834745645523, 0.12583699822425842, -1.0481414794921875, -0.16106098890304565, -0.44476020336151123, -0.35400593280792236, 0.6927765011787415, -1.1219857931137085, -0.1988982856273651, 0.12008865922689438, 0.20663505792617798, -0.6583880186080933, 0.007603887934237719, -0.6159802079200745, -0.3520831763744354, -0.05227995291352272, 0.4995148181915283, 0.01090164203196764, 0.06843214482069016, 0.7968356609344482, -0.3065331280231476, 0.7176223397254944, -0.10854844748973846, 0.06628578901290894, 0.30477601289749146, 0.4807334244251251, 0.3949088752269745, -0.5384170413017273, -1.2587532997131348, -0.5455412268638611, 0.21811498701572418, -1.2670214176177979, 0.47139862179756165, -1.055468201637268, 0.16504912078380585, 0.17603611946105957, 0.19808565080165863, -0.10890127718448639, 0.27668464183807373, 0.02853139117360115, 0.5711475014686584, 0.43946483731269836, 0.9399322867393494, 0.31914547085762024, 0.36225324869155884, 0.4881117045879364, 0.16434845328330994, -0.4608914852142334, -0.01617330312728882, -0.22354979813098907, 0.11402251571416855, 0.09041417390108109, 0.555884838104248, -0.5714592337608337, 0.6852330565452576, 0.574677050113678, -0.5916295051574707, -0.5954394340515137, 1.1275444030761719, 0.42045989632606506, 0.7481328248977661, -0.5319892168045044, -0.45828819274902344, -0.531378984451294, -0.5688470005989075, -1.1595743894577026, 0.2128937542438507, 0.2449958771467209, -0.3092118799686432, -0.38970133662223816, -0.6764043569564819, -1.2763848304748535, 0.7883514761924744, -0.041716318577528, 0.09402507543563843, -0.011161170899868011, 0.8312212824821472, 0.335779070854187, 0.6414339542388916, 0.16155873239040375, 0.6599169969558716, -0.0630403608083725, -0.13437360525131226, -0.7782878279685974, 0.054740481078624725, -0.37647897005081177, 0.46556732058525085, 1.180978536605835, 0.19451230764389038, -0.3328467011451721, 0.02735220082104206, 0.03170794993638992, -0.6888222694396973, -0.316059947013855, 0.07933512330055237, -1.3113173246383667, -0.05582921952009201, -0.058543860912323, -0.11622168868780136, -0.6687018275260925, 0.7497174739837646, -0.23806603252887726, -0.8258128762245178, -0.7091284990310669, 0.28033289313316345, 0.5701654553413391, 0.29094189405441284, 0.5013559460639954, 0.20709219574928284, 0.7004426717758179, -0.3272678256034851, -0.39964598417282104, 0.8470640778541565, 0.7378940582275391, 0.469009131193161, 0.22748596966266632, -0.5196671485900879, 0.5256475806236267, 1.2886290550231934, 0.0017376506002619863, 0.1467890590429306, 0.14638520777225494, 0.24501222372055054, -0.17066413164138794, -0.20916496217250824, -0.6160728335380554, 0.7511242032051086, -0.33441901206970215, -0.318274587392807, 0.6659409999847412, 0.2379736453294754, 0.505857527256012, 0.5388355851173401, -0.5917148590087891, 0.16529802978038788, -1.1784435510635376, -0.8386861681938171, 0.5272534489631653, -0.2866363525390625, 0.8842014670372009, 0.9651687741279602, 0.2673673927783966, -0.21131156384944916, 0.26793405413627625, -0.20414237678050995, 0.3317372798919678, 0.5666539669036865, -0.49996301531791687, -0.23722857236862183, -0.29921016097068787, 0.48780661821365356, -0.4414580464363098, 0.47293129563331604, 0.7792226076126099, 0.10408280044794083, -0.048134975135326385, 0.3663323223590851, -0.8834056854248047, 0.29504674673080444, 0.5160556435585022, -0.2714097797870636, 0.08947974443435669, -0.028545252978801727, 0.08599958568811417, -0.5391321182250977, -0.44364839792251587, 0.029330771416425705, 0.1652553826570511, -0.20204317569732666, -0.2360956072807312, 0.6203265190124512, 0.39535999298095703, 0.22210130095481873, 0.3438192307949066, -0.0008519648108631372, -0.24119536578655243, 0.4190181791782379, 0.018110599368810654, -0.28643178939819336, -0.0985569953918457, -0.2718064486980438, -0.48319053649902344, -0.12103167921304703, 0.4363822042942047, -0.4906126856803894, 0.17739152908325195, -0.4401409924030304, -0.33102646470069885, -0.2065865695476532, -0.05468675121665001, -0.6639935374259949, 0.28090813755989075, -0.15750597417354584, 0.19408006966114044, -1.0615012645721436, 0.10039647668600082, 0.8184616565704346, 0.1383073776960373, 0.011277792043983936, -1.000373363494873, -0.6699482202529907, 0.3857114613056183, -0.7870102524757385, -0.32929515838623047, -0.2701508104801178, 0.021059662103652954, -0.2908574342727661, -0.6035091280937195, -0.0729336366057396, -0.41455933451652527, -0.19146175682544708, -0.5216931700706482, -0.3180638551712036, 0.2548348605632782, 0.5582375526428223, 0.6140427589416504, -0.2492758333683014, 0.02874460630118847, 0.4986826479434967, 0.6710987687110901, -0.2189038246870041, 0.23647096753120422, 0.20586517453193665, 0.3169316053390503, 0.20382650196552277, -0.5189638733863831, -0.10545249283313751, -0.5514690279960632, -0.8209965825080872, -0.5708795189857483, 0.1796877533197403, -0.3832609951496124, -0.936954915523529, 0.6607763171195984, 0.5954669713973999, -0.024390021339058876, -0.1592835634946823, -0.6327343583106995, 0.026183070614933968, -0.7650613784790039, 1.2182087898254395, -0.8798229098320007, -0.471615195274353, -0.05636787787079811, -0.14281749725341797, 1.317457914352417, -1.012984275817871, 3.8518617153167725, 1.3547847270965576, 0.14414101839065552, 0.5168882608413696, 0.5751019716262817, 0.5872276425361633, 0.658049464225769, -0.36062243580818176, -0.34645339846611023, -0.8582524657249451, -0.6227173805236816, -0.21460147202014923, 0.33867543935775757, 0.5647908449172974, -0.32944557070732117, 1.1429959535598755, -1.1212642192840576, 0.28778839111328125, -0.20858024060726166, -1.370426058769226, -0.47031888365745544, 0.22351038455963135, -0.39335721731185913, 0.8289100527763367, 0.07602237910032272, -0.37575823068618774, 0.964766800403595, 0.22016698122024536, 0.6077471971511841, -0.16218602657318115, 0.05183590576052666, -0.6371164917945862, 0.46238958835601807, -0.5160752534866333, -0.505248486995697, 0.23945669829845428, -0.3094709515571594, -0.8975762724876404, 0.08809935301542282, 0.3105963468551636, -0.05295303463935852, 0.5778000950813293, -0.5631633400917053, -0.30197614431381226, 0.30211690068244934, 0.33668383955955505, -0.9746140837669373, -0.0630149096250534, -0.007800005376338959, -0.4039340913295746, 1.3694440126419067, -1.269018292427063, 0.19005616009235382, -0.07760801911354065, -0.6556850075721741, -0.4844469130039215, -0.31878504157066345, -0.6819416284561157, 0.3662504255771637, -0.007199061568826437, 0.4833073616027832, -0.2744816243648529, -0.5707331299781799, -0.6364913582801819, 0.6800613403320312, 0.23536084592342377, 0.6584706902503967, -0.5933305025100708, 0.22331930696964264, -0.05798229202628136, -0.11204899847507477, 0.20121784508228302, -0.6380000114440918, 0.13068383932113647, 0.06692883372306824, 0.7222756743431091, -0.2687626779079437, 0.8665066361427307, 0.9173658490180969, -0.02083783596754074, 0.5161341428756714, 0.25266164541244507, 0.027903761714696884, 0.17279337346553802, 0.6109257340431213, 0.6514602899551392, -0.7030901908874512, -0.675561785697937, -0.8050984144210815, 0.30196523666381836, 0.3615140914916992, -0.809009313583374, 0.1941870152950287, 0.30446717143058777, -0.21289071440696716 ]
{"Title": "Trends and variation in unsafe prescribing of methotrexate: a cohort study in English NHS primary care", "Authors": "MacKenna Brian, Curtis Helen J, Walker Alex J, Croker Richard, Bacon Seb, Goldacre Ben", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective To describe trends and geographical variation in methotrexate prescribing that breaches national safety recommendations; deaths from methotrexate poisoning; and associated litigation. Methods A retrospective cohort study of English NHS primary care prescribing data, complemented by information obtained through Freedom of Information (FOI) requests. The main outcome measures were: (1) variation in ratio of breaching / adherent prescribing, geographically and over time, between General Practices and Clinical Commissioning Groups; (2) description of responses to FOI requests. Results Out of 7349 NHS General Practices in England, 1689 practices prescribed both 2.5mg and 10mg tablets to individual patients in 2017, breaching national guidance. In April 2018, 697 practices (at the 90th centile and above) prescribed at least 14.3% of all methotrexate as 10mg tablets, breaching national guidance. The 66 practices at the 99th percentile and above gave at least 52.4% of all prescribed methotrexate in the form of 10 mg tablets. The prescribing of 10mg tablets has fallen over 7 years, with 10mg tablets as a proportion of all methotrexate tablets falling from 9.1% to 3.4%. 21 deaths caused by methotrexate poisoning have been reported from 1993-2017. Conclusions The prevalence of unsafe methotrexate prescribing has reduced but it remains common, with substantial variation between organisations. We recommend the NHS invests in better strategies around implementation of safety recommendations. 21 deaths have been attributed to methotrexate poisoning but with no further details easily available: the full coroners reports for these deaths should be reviewed to identify recurring themes.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000919"}
10.1101/19008516
[ 0.23486673831939697, 0.2881084084510803, -0.0048108394257724285, 0.6593285799026489, -0.0636056512594223, 0.551647961139679, -0.04302016273140907, 0.16742056608200073, 0.07759051769971848, 1.1043009757995605, -0.4322078824043274, -0.12234464287757874, 0.7490488290786743, -0.7169705629348755, 0.24266944825649261, -0.38187238574028015, -0.17714548110961914, 0.44921496510505676, -0.215192973613739, -0.2413637787103653, -0.4780428409576416, 0.47556182742118835, -0.4880686402320862, 0.2561676800251007, -0.22487223148345947, 0.39291509985923767, 0.3937819004058838, 0.3183290362358093, 0.6763401031494141, 0.6664087772369385, 0.23372286558151245, -0.48707619309425354, -0.023958677425980568, -0.3475542664527893, 0.0698772668838501, -0.27776622772216797, 0.9593867063522339, -0.835246205329895, 0.15415021777153015, 0.5171941518783569, 0.35423123836517334, 0.053941741585731506, 0.14054639637470245, -0.8316493630409241, -0.5395084023475647, -0.31506234407424927, -0.4724791944026947, -0.22782787680625916, -0.3088977336883545, -0.41688528656959534, -0.8012134432792664, -0.22602659463882446, 0.17529913783073425, -0.36522236466407776, 0.3007296919822693, -0.020112859085202217, 0.35569095611572266, -0.9632388353347778, -0.6278010606765747, -0.15289561450481415, -0.14593538641929626, -0.1370563954114914, 0.4108220636844635, -0.5320086479187012, -0.11985049396753311, 0.4035184979438782, -0.6511750221252441, 0.004787708166986704, -0.6564404964447021, -0.09339172393083572, -0.7443686723709106, -0.0816650539636612, -0.31107470393180847, -0.014663243666291237, -0.24746888875961304, -0.24408362805843353, 0.13477343320846558, -0.12428551912307739, 0.4226904511451721, 0.13061779737472534, 0.4596328139305115, 0.7815640568733215, 0.7386670708656311, 0.08973018825054169, -0.5908997654914856, 0.3319008946418762, -0.18430618941783905, 0.1649451106786728, 0.5390031933784485, 0.1152467355132103, -0.6033231616020203, 0.533778965473175, -0.3225289285182953, 0.6550831198692322, -0.24286192655563354, 0.3227059245109558, 0.41382288932800293, -0.21217966079711914, 0.49850478768348694, -0.25140348076820374, 0.7133393287658691, 0.5800449848175049, 0.3115249276161194, 1.1810065507888794, -0.8975297808647156, 0.9038374423980713, 0.14976732432842255, -0.22547590732574463, -0.05196274444460869, -0.7987733483314514, -0.3861171305179596, 0.3658958673477173, 0.20121446251869202, -0.7231025099754333, -0.44613829255104065, 0.06331642717123032, -0.35963866114616394, 0.5573827624320984, -0.13634200394153595, 1.2502797842025757, -0.3010466694831848, 0.19343970715999603, 0.48109447956085205, -1.0645030736923218, 0.5368022918701172, -0.36108148097991943, 0.1285003274679184, 1.1741517782211304, -0.7234570980072021, 0.2788355350494385, 0.27729663252830505, -0.647564709186554, -0.17834517359733582, 0.626353919506073, -0.31105148792266846, 0.27419909834861755, 0.542859673500061, 1.0484954118728638, 0.2961016893386841, 0.05483737587928772, 0.040079351514577866, 0.4712070822715759, -0.6386389136314392, 0.8279170393943787, -0.2962861657142639, 0.054986804723739624, -0.24749255180358887, -1.174925446510315, -0.4212309420108795, 0.06159667670726776, -0.10092530399560928, 0.8717363476753235, 0.1096232458949089, 0.135158509016037, -0.12398339062929153, 0.010225159116089344, 0.626132071018219, 0.04051901027560234, -0.46929606795310974, 0.041429925709962845, -0.7059459090232849, -0.6188418865203857, -0.19027480483055115, 0.5203312039375305, -0.4158381521701813, 0.7305867075920105, 0.01963372342288494, 0.1982279121875763, -0.31257081031799316, -0.6815623044967651, 0.7133632898330688, 0.5750300288200378, -0.17136745154857635, -0.08967175334692001, 0.14903731644153595, 0.41667667031288147, 0.7631009817123413, 0.32721737027168274, -0.09317025542259216, 0.08613529056310654, -0.45796576142311096, -0.6210232973098755, 0.0840960219502449, 0.3707575798034668, -0.07484207302331924, 0.5779216289520264, -0.4050067961215973, -0.8170093894004822, -0.19324961304664612, -0.32605746388435364, 0.006886765360832214, 0.47606757283210754, -0.4161194860935211, 0.7687732577323914, 0.13697393238544464, -0.3785367012023926, -0.03062172792851925, -0.19720283150672913, -0.22424937784671783, -0.14414489269256592, -0.3268323242664337, 0.393331915140152, 0.3151528239250183, 0.08537585288286209, -0.3939836621284485, 0.6615874171257019, 0.2493014633655548, 0.3948703408241272, -1.1828924417495728, -0.34907153248786926, 1.0493547916412354, -0.057976409792900085, -0.289724737405777, 0.21878354251384735, 0.30969762802124023, 0.03456912189722061, -0.03252297639846802, 0.5905007719993591, 0.2370465248823166, -0.18815268576145172, -0.6894708871841431, -0.000035745935747399926, 0.011533066630363464, 0.03213273361325264, 0.6369394659996033, -0.047715261578559875, -0.05321509763598442, 0.6814296841621399, -0.5717567205429077, -0.16067634522914886, 0.8153622150421143, 0.8611367344856262, -0.3794983923435211, 0.3713732659816742, 0.521315336227417, 0.20232129096984863, 0.09799446910619736, 0.6730371117591858, 0.7038745284080505, 0.0396425686776638, 0.37627431750297546, 0.27237650752067566, 0.500141978263855, 0.05083601176738739, -0.08372770249843597, 0.7488975524902344, -0.4712722599506378, -0.720313549041748, 0.1754903495311737, 0.1896728128194809, -0.8604369759559631, 0.6018407940864563, 0.5582784414291382, 0.5857492089271545, -0.9375573992729187, 0.49973613023757935, 0.17432023584842682, 0.5646189451217651, -0.7744821310043335, -0.19889047741889954, 0.12520407140254974, 0.25405368208885193, 0.32728949189186096, 0.02571350894868374, 0.5350015759468079, 0.33948031067848206, 0.04445633664727211, 0.15480104088783264, 0.4448111653327942, -0.2894401550292969, -0.4253397583961487, -1.0521563291549683, -0.7076787948608398, -0.4791790843009949, 0.12113241106271744, 0.45221608877182007, -0.14272502064704895, -0.9660403728485107, 0.08343809843063354, -0.19072234630584717, 0.03166072070598602, -0.19723933935165405, -0.30226215720176697, 0.695824384689331, 0.37785929441452026, 0.1820865124464035, -0.880561351776123, 0.36048272252082825, 0.3815250098705292, 0.14044786989688873, -0.11804024875164032, -0.6242228150367737, -0.7443168759346008, -0.7582311630249023, 0.07929528504610062, -1.8078944683074951, 0.36181870102882385, 0.13972972333431244, -0.48599791526794434, -0.6601354479789734, 0.6239418387413025, -0.6971104145050049, -0.3487282395362854, -0.18367236852645874, -0.6007518768310547, 0.49455854296684265, 0.6037978529930115, -0.43829774856567383, 0.11634858697652817, -0.10978032648563385, -0.43598243594169617, 0.8281043171882629, -0.08463980257511139, 0.526380181312561, -0.6454432606697083, 0.34221166372299194, 0.15097962319850922, -1.0879184007644653, -0.42280203104019165, -0.3897731304168701, -0.3645837903022766, -0.6819196343421936, -0.09928073734045029, -0.08831554651260376, 0.41969066858291626, -0.011544444598257542, 0.47220349311828613, -0.9113064408302307, 0.5644631385803223, -0.8378753066062927, -0.13413439691066742, -0.7055330872535706, -0.434306800365448, 0.0038260463625192642, 0.4268655478954315, 0.2833426594734192, -0.6764587759971619, 0.4160144627094269, 0.5611590147018433, 0.0005827452405355871, 0.5085209012031555, -0.5086230635643005, -0.358317494392395, 0.8842425346374512, -0.05995944142341614, 0.6430588364601135, -0.2800091803073883, 0.23245635628700256, -0.6126523017883301, -0.06989412009716034, 0.29554304480552673, 0.16365404427051544, 0.9730016589164734, -0.18224573135375977, -0.11587966978549957, 0.6594139933586121, 0.2640612721443176, 0.3287564814090729, -0.14584258198738098, 0.23056456446647644, -0.9809755086898804, -0.0952557623386383, -1.0805786848068237, 0.43304887413978577, -1.0421150922775269, -0.29720157384872437, 0.5970585346221924, 0.3013971149921417, 0.5315295457839966, -0.9910634160041809, 1.0195024013519287, -0.41718921065330505, 0.20941641926765442, 0.5121755003929138, -0.28909122943878174, -0.5339215397834778, 0.6483921408653259, 0.1370197832584381, 0.5031927824020386, -0.9660020470619202, -0.16881880164146423, 0.01085820235311985, 0.6985421180725098, 0.4715346395969391, 0.191017746925354, 0.32075491547584534, 0.024384984746575356, 0.5336863398551941, -0.2736472189426422, -0.4949071407318115, 0.6770429015159607, 0.12542100250720978, 0.12824103236198425, -0.808838427066803, -0.2549572288990021, -0.4125089943408966, 0.5597780346870422, 0.44707223773002625, 0.17091858386993408, -0.10073696076869965, 0.8516832590103149, -0.6977779269218445, 0.5703252553939819, 0.38093799352645874, 0.08375945687294006, -0.008875273168087006, -1.1873908042907715, -0.15940770506858826, -0.21162725985050201, -0.5470385551452637, -0.41408416628837585, -0.23018531501293182, 0.1368383765220642, 0.08220596611499786, 0.29360392689704895, 0.1348203718662262, -0.31930312514305115, -0.03100522980093956, -0.4892238974571228, 0.6677272319793701, 0.23465950787067413, -0.8789351582527161, -0.5734756588935852, 0.11617512255907059, -0.05805516242980957, -0.9031926989555359, -0.38925066590309143, -0.2602757215499878, 0.07518144696950912, 1.0185602903366089, -0.5678470730781555, -1.1694552898406982, -0.011700397357344627, -0.34634697437286377, -0.06253425776958466, -0.32658445835113525, 0.342334121465683, -0.787503719329834, -0.33687105774879456, -0.7703415155410767, -0.3899657428264618, 0.5332900881767273, 0.2746240794658661, -0.5173598527908325, 0.10985278338193893, -0.23308928310871124, 0.7891964316368103, 0.38291135430336, 0.017109738662838936, 0.012171697802841663, -0.001379215158522129, -0.7871597409248352, 0.1067957878112793, 0.6473879814147949, -0.3858482837677002, -0.02223077602684498, 0.270853728055954, -0.3376987874507904, -0.3240082263946533, -0.7248921990394592, -0.3040739893913269, 0.9095936417579651, 0.22242967784404755, -0.02155502513051033, -0.5336207747459412, 0.6111453771591187, -0.46109041571617126, 0.21871910989284515, 0.767025887966156, -0.2317073941230774, -1.1017531156539917, 0.10902818292379379, -0.6976618766784668, -0.4924388825893402, 1.1281359195709229, 0.2682771384716034, 0.21519213914871216, -0.3323386311531067, -0.27114012837409973, 0.6990804076194763, 0.21319326758384705, 0.6616975665092468, -0.644675076007843, -1.2184977531433105, -0.4310786724090576, -0.6907371878623962, 0.06689511239528656, -0.05083809047937393, -0.7238750457763672, -0.09456661343574524, 0.13176371157169342, -0.21541449427604675, -0.5530843138694763, -0.2080850452184677, 0.5294734835624695, 0.21906137466430664, 0.36430758237838745, 0.37776637077331543, -0.10830067098140717, 0.30742785334587097, -0.06558016687631607, -0.05063771456480026, -0.4325633943080902, -0.7192493677139282, 0.07004763185977936, -0.7993670701980591, -0.3673071563243866, -0.4176785945892334, -0.48121097683906555, -0.8972713351249695, 0.15399789810180664, 0.6768171787261963, -0.3977692425251007, 0.8124765157699585, -0.05549497529864311, 0.281986802816391, -0.007246425375342369, 0.2657434046268463, 0.025115787982940674, 0.44650140404701233, -0.260551393032074, -0.0937400758266449, -0.9172871112823486, 0.2743104100227356, 0.2165413498878479, 0.23680894076824188, -1.217868685722351, -0.19598186016082764, -0.34708353877067566, -1.222907304763794, -0.019362613558769226, -0.3042067587375641, 0.6619935035705566, -0.3530671000480652, -0.31031709909439087, 0.48983243107795715, 0.07075740396976471, 0.750382661819458, 0.16665077209472656, -0.011706684716045856, -0.6036645174026489, 0.06577538698911667, 0.13109847903251648, -0.6546554565429688, 0.3577936887741089, -0.4430493116378784, 0.09780842810869217, 1.1025029420852661, 0.34712982177734375, 0.5036574602127075, 0.5053299069404602, 0.019385116174817085, 0.23312003910541534, 0.256134957075119, -0.4914967119693756, -0.07912172377109528, -0.3605691194534302, 0.20057840645313263, 0.03454214334487915, -0.4944697618484497, -0.043341442942619324, 0.6558929681777954, -0.6491462588310242, 0.26497840881347656, 0.012297781184315681, -0.2666042745113373, 0.3982159495353699, -0.3461933434009552, 0.7243696451187134, -0.022912349551916122, -0.21598264575004578, 0.1566162258386612, 0.19602906703948975, 0.10450209677219391, 0.05708879604935646, -0.9349615573883057, -0.7482165694236755, -0.46579211950302124, -0.5939825177192688, 0.37748703360557556, 0.4483943283557892, 0.25601300597190857, -0.19790299236774445, -0.20348700881004333, -0.15875248610973358, -0.7740232944488525, 1.4344704151153564, 0.69564288854599, -0.29929861426353455, -0.33459582924842834, 0.3615236282348633, 0.3133733570575714, 0.31740644574165344, 0.43751707673072815, 0.47926023602485657, -0.6249204874038696, -0.1724632978439331, -0.17578396201133728, -0.4217326045036316, -0.242177814245224, -0.5865838527679443, 0.27322494983673096, 0.6511375904083252, 0.3883902430534363, 0.8944892287254333, 0.2622307538986206, 0.14787662029266357, -0.35106322169303894, 0.6331943869590759, -0.5073450803756714, 0.7014390230178833, 0.8033527135848999, 0.06826594471931458, -1.166761040687561, 0.2656078040599823, -0.665408730506897, 0.10559220612049103, -0.1698848009109497, 0.23480625450611115, -0.06020204722881317, -1.141843557357788, 0.5907255411148071, 0.7285972237586975, -0.7121818661689758, -0.01844709739089012, -0.44630923867225647, -0.24761193990707397, 0.6839664578437805, -0.5775558948516846, -0.6008020043373108, 1.3810763359069824, -0.05861971527338028, 0.10012829303741455, -0.623748242855072, -0.5994782447814941, -0.268722802400589, -0.3864263594150543, 0.48458197712898254, -0.7817334532737732, 0.6618567109107971, 0.7522457242012024, -0.6379373669624329, 0.5090219378471375, -0.09774176776409149, -0.4468560218811035, -0.24514906108379364, -0.31572216749191284, 0.7376925945281982, -1.0679829120635986, -1.162149429321289, -0.8158981800079346, -0.36377376317977905, -0.020136794075369835, -0.4431779682636261, -0.05506524071097374, 0.6550768613815308, -0.7961597442626953, -0.9845012426376343, -0.3094339668750763, -0.32969382405281067, 0.27842143177986145, 0.5835093855857849, -0.8691049218177795, 0.8878602385520935, 0.5959946513175964, 0.08144029229879379, 0.422500342130661, -0.8413110375404358, -0.255852609872818, -0.2143411487340927, -0.5543738007545471, -0.917756974697113, -0.8929157853126526, -0.42331358790397644, 0.4071805775165558, 0.31140708923339844, -0.23177964985370636, 0.14960068464279175, 1.0133781433105469, -0.47514501214027405, 0.15030162036418915, -0.4081169664859772, 0.24267396330833435, 0.15454773604869843, -0.14759841561317444, -0.09495025128126144, -0.35254737734794617, 0.47614604234695435, 0.7535042762756348, -0.6663517355918884, 0.18948572874069214, 0.4765496253967285, -0.30447810888290405, 0.8933876156806946, 0.5368559956550598, -0.5665372610092163, -0.2956235408782959, 0.6568213105201721, -0.11535513401031494, -0.48061543703079224, 0.021761110052466393, 0.43759870529174805, -0.7907503247261047, 0.3119278848171234, 0.0716501921415329, 0.031130334362387657, 0.23471294343471527, 0.39041540026664734, 0.3994145095348358, -0.2616545557975769, -0.8098036050796509, -0.11723152548074722, 0.625389814376831, 0.17614173889160156, -0.12082452327013016, -0.5449405908584595, -0.17236323654651642, 0.3643597960472107, -0.557644248008728, 0.025394853204488754, 0.29532867670059204, -0.17221634089946747, -0.04078236222267151, 0.4363977015018463, 0.6467466950416565, 0.3948371112346649, 0.5162398815155029, -0.2755569517612457, -0.05095160752534866, -0.14757263660430908, -1.2365086078643799, 0.5814819931983948, 0.2294258028268814, -0.33636975288391113, 1.0630556344985962, 0.0072404383681714535, -0.15982863306999207, 0.08974389731884003, -0.506736695766449, -0.10133939981460571, 0.9418658018112183, 0.10041295737028122, 0.22121532261371613, 0.004958867561072111, -0.23985697329044342, -0.37708166241645813, 0.31586945056915283, -0.8725086450576782, -0.883497416973114, 0.41987141966819763, -0.2078576534986496, -0.7507171630859375, -0.6345468163490295, -0.5171449184417725, 0.10574547946453094, -0.1642318218946457, 0.20053711533546448, 0.3291274607181549, 0.5333802103996277, 0.46744486689567566, 0.2120138257741928, 0.609489917755127, 0.035739727318286896, -0.009373188018798828, 0.5037197470664978, -0.5926285982131958, -0.3333793878555298, -0.11057955771684647, 0.8465471267700195, 0.37571945786476135, 0.47588402032852173, 0.21417035162448883, -0.6275995373725891, 0.11679261177778244, 0.5964453816413879, 0.3118698298931122, 0.33333927392959595, -1.040444254875183, -0.6194396615028381, -0.28171488642692566, 0.6341073513031006, -0.656877875328064, 0.33445096015930176, -0.23643766343593597, -0.6969137787818909, -0.6851440668106079, -0.2856491804122925, 0.891232967376709, 0.2995830476284027, -0.11522114276885986, -0.11486908793449402, 0.531300961971283, -0.11818309873342514, -0.3873237669467926, 0.2614825665950775, 1.3333097696304321, 0.788957953453064, 0.5185877680778503, 0.036560915410518646, -0.07047071307897568, 1.0160887241363525, 0.08714704215526581, 0.14076843857765198, 0.8504889011383057, 0.8333745002746582, 0.4530015289783478, 0.19031496345996857, -0.1621159464120865, 0.38551539182662964, 0.03682846948504448, -0.44168731570243835, -0.18061956763267517, -0.6004363298416138, 0.2328851819038391, -0.06778672337532043, -0.4795383810997009, 0.8776294589042664, -0.308740496635437, -0.6314547061920166, 0.0903451070189476, 0.2672230899333954, 0.3776725232601166, 0.5732057094573975, 0.11150965094566345, 0.15061567723751068, 0.9919864535331726, -0.007553305011242628, 0.41454651951789856, 0.6604456901550293, -0.2009347677230835, -0.28831735253334045, -0.3312172293663025, 0.3120604455471039, -0.5834906697273254, 0.39335307478904724, -0.5086833238601685, -0.2711622416973114, 0.028646403923630714, 0.6502593755722046, 0.3085481822490692, -0.06976671516895294, 0.7873746752738953, -0.3871583342552185, -0.8765382170677185, -0.03576468303799629, -0.16354867815971375, -0.7394666075706482, -0.06204989552497864, 0.7395827174186707, -0.8029747605323792, -0.26490646600723267, 0.4251185357570648, 0.94145667552948, 0.1511046439409256, 0.636631965637207, 0.24423500895500183, -0.13036879897117615, 1.1592413187026978, -0.1546730399131775, -0.32180556654930115, 0.42120829224586487, -0.42200738191604614, -0.5843727588653564, 0.402642160654068, -0.6509607434272766, 0.2792273461818695, 0.1318063586950302, -0.5043591856956482, -0.4383752644062042, 0.523108959197998, 0.16596373915672302, -0.09187101572751999, -0.3541816174983978, 0.026770595461130142, -0.32559734582901, -0.09203477203845978, 0.31445780396461487, 0.2178805023431778, 0.635461151599884, -0.21014468371868134, -0.12372127920389175, -0.695850670337677, -0.1305011808872223, 0.14732839167118073, 0.07928300648927689, 0.7402845621109009, -0.4206601083278656, -1.1887257099151611, 0.022206474095582962, -0.7156877517700195, -0.2306128442287445, 0.8717900514602661, -0.3931949734687805, -0.7866048812866211, 0.05939871817827225, -0.1108640655875206, 0.06993100792169571, -0.5538057684898376, -0.12805341184139252, -0.42883366346359253, 0.4013179540634155, 0.8407101631164551, -0.7884714603424072, 0.4680974781513214, -0.3460324704647064, -0.541584849357605, 0.32577744126319885, -0.7044364809989929, -0.20552340149879456, 0.09033546596765518, -0.5134350061416626, -0.10223687440156937, 0.18808706104755402, -0.3758423626422882, -0.649185836315155, 0.10966621339321136, 0.09848722070455551, -0.6686670184135437, 0.3912409245967865, -0.7967488765716553, -0.7012717127799988, -0.41989463567733765, 0.9507576823234558, -0.43426457047462463, 0.7087820172309875, 0.23355938494205475, 0.40969887375831604, 0.11869168281555176, -0.8554732799530029, 4.175656795501709, 0.4082575738430023, 0.2925785779953003, -0.3760851323604584, 0.816171407699585, 0.5385981202125549, 1.1211519241333008, 0.3478655219078064, 0.513775110244751, 0.016550984233617783, 0.06433570384979248, 0.3626406490802765, 0.1528109312057495, 0.07250547409057617, 0.364994615316391, 0.3263472318649292, -0.774842381477356, 0.053814440965652466, 0.7697908282279968, -1.0809534788131714, -0.518349289894104, -0.1448434591293335, -0.056661903858184814, 0.263509064912796, 0.3020269274711609, 0.1435588151216507, 0.4559476673603058, -0.6142793893814087, 0.5955976247787476, 0.12570127844810486, 0.3068954050540924, -0.8892976641654968, 0.16751191020011902, -0.7993285059928894, 0.061821263283491135, 0.09663873165845871, 0.2668527662754059, -0.5803318619728088, -0.8288313746452332, -0.11393880099058151, -0.047109879553318024, 0.19227838516235352, 0.6879505515098572, -0.5093167424201965, -0.681469202041626, 0.48850181698799133, -0.5727738738059998, 0.08897053450345993, 0.4013587534427643, -0.42969632148742676, 1.0820468664169312, -1.3919711112976074, 0.11122344434261322, 0.6168432235717773, -0.4892694354057312, 0.08132090419530869, -0.5372235178947449, -0.5684376358985901, -0.10615632683038712, 0.2221587896347046, 0.9878960847854614, -0.24148012697696686, -0.3849622309207916, 0.23077479004859924, 0.5472738146781921, 0.2403431087732315, 0.8386423587799072, -0.2708914279937744, 0.31146055459976196, 0.12020401656627655, 0.2148069590330124, 0.019318383187055588, -0.6625733375549316, -0.4037702679634094, 1.2692782878875732, 0.5541537404060364, -0.15728043019771576, 1.318371295928955, -0.8933723568916321, -0.9629426598548889, 0.41907966136932373, 0.0780094787478447, -0.4130271077156067, -0.43343254923820496, -0.30988287925720215, 1.4031702280044556, -0.9847232699394226, -1.1482573747634888, -0.8576778769493103, 0.5646103024482727, 0.6199124455451965, 0.4608743190765381, -0.09428683668375015, 0.016653750091791153, 0.028541240841150284 ]
{"Title": "Local socioeconomic status and paramedic students\u2019 academic performance", "Authors": "Hamel Lydia, Procum Ashley, Hunter Justin, Gridley Donna, O\u2019Connor Kathleen, Fentress Thomas, Goenner Christopher, Khalsa Sahaj, Batt Alan M.", "Abstract": "Abstract Research indicates students of lower socioeconomic status (SES) are educationally disadvantaged. We sought to examine differences in paramedic student academic performance from counties with varying SES in the United States. Student performance data and SES data were combined for counties within the states of California, Mississippi, Louisiana, Texas and Virginia. Linear multiple regression modelling was performed to determine the relationship between income, high school graduation rate, poverty and food insecurity with first-attempt scores on the Fisdap Paramedic Readiness Exam (PRE) versions 3 and 4. Linear regression models indicated that there was a significant relationship between county-level income, poverty, graduation rate, food insecurity, and paramedic student academic performance. It remains unclear what type of relationship exists between individual SES and individual academic performance of paramedic students. These findings support the future collection of individual student level SES data in order to identify issues and mitigate impact on academic performance.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008516"}
10.1101/2019.12.12.19014621
[ 0.00860560592263937, -0.3084714412689209, 0.22694586217403412, 0.3843710720539093, -0.5520005226135254, -0.03898605331778526, -0.29739126563072205, -0.1415983885526657, -0.568213164806366, 0.651296079158783, 0.04462790489196777, -0.45555853843688965, -0.21533402800559998, 0.3907022774219513, -0.7659057378768921, -0.2790336012840271, -0.22946739196777344, -0.29450419545173645, -0.13310833275318146, -0.07625900954008102, 0.41367098689079285, 0.5880164504051208, -1.0057017803192139, 0.23710499703884125, -0.9817126989364624, 0.5216537117958069, -0.05530314892530441, -0.18443994224071503, 0.8326117992401123, 0.33117449283599854, -0.12166325747966766, -0.6422258019447327, 0.2639153003692627, -0.8972024917602539, 0.33752521872520447, -0.3515319228172302, 0.2426883578300476, -0.2596529722213745, -0.4226575493812561, -0.14555782079696655, 0.05661490187048912, 0.1214311271905899, 0.001607180805876851, -0.4401334524154663, -1.4424744844436646, 0.03169284388422966, -0.44018885493278503, -0.1616227775812149, -0.8389067649841309, 0.5371764302253723, -0.39846181869506836, 0.024321869015693665, 0.17179277539253235, -0.6517578959465027, 0.09481076151132584, -0.02121848240494728, 0.06527183949947357, -0.2051185816526413, -0.5945402383804321, 0.6920947432518005, 0.7713922262191772, -0.50128573179245, 0.5707468390464783, -0.6910971403121948, 0.34128063917160034, 0.5206828713417053, -0.17618303000926971, -0.09048604220151901, 0.4855303168296814, -0.8313092589378357, -0.6842538118362427, -0.11320115625858307, -0.3091731667518616, -0.7970069646835327, -0.23832711577415466, -0.33096662163734436, 0.3069725036621094, -0.5982999205589294, -0.29917222261428833, 0.27082180976867676, -0.6484807729721069, 0.2064708173274994, 0.5588391423225403, -0.13428862392902374, -0.4907766580581665, 0.5261960029602051, -0.013752570375800133, 0.15867872536182404, 0.030595390126109123, 0.47709158062934875, -0.2696998715400696, 0.5183230042457581, 0.03271246328949928, 0.0005555741372518241, -0.15573550760746002, 0.8246815800666809, -0.07222143560647964, 0.26698315143585205, 0.26783403754234314, 0.2755243182182312, 0.8396096229553223, 0.1562974452972412, -0.434175580739975, 1.3049613237380981, -0.26296085119247437, 0.9977023601531982, 0.34044092893600464, -0.7073220610618591, -1.1500937938690186, -0.6464568376541138, -0.48381441831588745, -0.5235373377799988, 0.07994263619184494, 0.07252659648656845, 0.38599395751953125, -0.029683414846658707, 0.5128673911094666, 0.36127838492393494, -0.2284460812807083, 0.8651831150054932, 0.5074290037155151, -0.13802753388881683, 1.0897154808044434, -0.5640825033187866, 0.03119986690580845, 0.1894303560256958, 0.7635730504989624, 0.15176250040531158, -0.9277685880661011, -0.6621250510215759, 0.6009915471076965, -0.7070382833480835, -0.6437129378318787, 0.4850349426269531, 0.269121378660202, -0.3339812159538269, 0.6600996851921082, 0.5005221366882324, 0.5111634135246277, 0.3623213469982147, -0.31677499413490295, 0.8536956906318665, -1.1826478242874146, 1.2230733633041382, 0.41808706521987915, 0.44241586327552795, 0.10726018995046616, -1.1096152067184448, -0.570125937461853, -0.06773149967193604, -0.41074302792549133, 0.2844637930393219, -0.5716541409492493, 0.015043591149151325, -0.537855327129364, 0.3449253737926483, -0.013787124305963516, 0.24025513231754303, -1.0402202606201172, 0.18652085959911346, -0.008138306438922882, -0.17903293669223785, -0.11523474007844925, 0.3767416179180145, -0.5314180254936218, 0.7293164730072021, -0.13264471292495728, 0.5554056167602539, 0.21016912162303925, -0.8150296211242676, 1.382039189338684, -0.4517941474914551, -0.7344073057174683, 0.46706563234329224, 0.7054386138916016, 1.0117285251617432, 1.2594753503799438, -0.09076204150915146, 0.012582661584019661, 0.7080419659614563, -0.24760903418064117, 0.36625936627388, -0.12054583430290222, 0.7182946801185608, 0.7309019565582275, 0.544044554233551, 0.18426214158535004, -0.19017456471920013, 0.36456090211868286, -0.3128810524940491, -0.16110774874687195, 0.4399295449256897, -1.103087306022644, 0.2928488552570343, -0.6440671682357788, -0.23091477155685425, -0.17091110348701477, 0.2201259285211563, -0.3284095227718353, -0.29737842082977295, -0.43347451090812683, 0.10897015780210495, -0.38174334168434143, 0.033459845930337906, -0.05932880565524101, 0.7111881375312805, 0.0593874529004097, 0.01978164352476597, -0.7979589104652405, 0.304690957069397, 1.0071829557418823, -0.23550042510032654, -0.7105097770690918, 0.16110122203826904, 0.44940871000289917, 0.05831335484981537, -0.30988064408302307, -0.10858023911714554, -0.4476802349090576, -0.28587672114372253, -0.15264630317687988, -0.5310458540916443, 0.30313897132873535, -0.11940125375986099, 0.43539974093437195, 0.34829238057136536, 0.555285632610321, 0.6849972605705261, 0.2350398153066635, -0.19832773506641388, -0.26050639152526855, 0.7920281887054443, -0.562207818031311, 1.0837671756744385, 0.46041131019592285, -0.16466321051120758, 0.10697734355926514, 0.1628069132566452, 0.48274296522140503, 0.42603033781051636, 0.3921523690223694, 0.10495562851428986, 0.7113720178604126, -0.262942910194397, -0.9214991927146912, 0.8402640223503113, -0.166986346244812, -0.07616627961397171, -0.3278873562812805, 0.366103857755661, -0.2280764877796173, 0.560665488243103, 0.05863220617175102, 0.4611022472381592, -0.2582728862762451, -0.017967594787478447, 0.7877769470214844, 0.15340784192085266, -0.7750700116157532, -0.21638458967208862, -0.15719963610172272, -0.3377063572406769, -0.3052474856376648, 0.18458031117916107, 0.5134069919586182, 0.7569219470024109, -0.24657830595970154, 0.19501206278800964, 0.3540405333042145, 0.3284621238708496, -0.8397848010063171, -0.32300233840942383, -0.3763001263141632, -0.42949849367141724, -0.40897494554519653, -0.026980768889188766, 0.14961864054203033, 0.09143892675638199, 0.0006220909999683499, -0.2263302356004715, -0.6714415550231934, -0.2103184163570404, 0.2674560546875, 0.40235602855682373, 0.0019881397020071745, 0.22661477327346802, -0.8015670776367188, 0.33750709891319275, 0.7063438296318054, 0.31980741024017334, 0.10489830374717712, -0.13349758088588715, -0.8191409111022949, -0.9780194759368896, 0.11501842737197876, -0.9813083410263062, 0.26155948638916016, 0.18685032427310944, -0.5209769010543823, -0.15748845040798187, 0.09081767499446869, 0.4937633275985718, 0.688532292842865, -0.14012035727500916, -0.7692042589187622, 0.17003430426120758, -0.22577135264873505, 0.43328407406806946, 0.1822660118341446, 0.23419907689094543, -0.38407647609710693, 0.5819399952888489, -0.6840969324111938, 0.5125705599784851, -0.4701579809188843, -0.09965343773365021, -0.41061267256736755, -0.3466910421848297, -0.024543236941099167, -0.5592687129974365, -0.28110986948013306, 0.22466793656349182, -0.04519212618470192, 0.23515522480010986, 0.34193044900894165, 0.40018677711486816, 0.2952672839164734, -2.1015145778656006, -0.23701563477516174, -1.2491345405578613, -1.0667755603790283, -0.2628929018974304, 0.21610651910305023, -0.01793839782476425, -0.26829248666763306, -0.4451064169406891, -1.1088958978652954, 0.16938072443008423, 0.35821837186813354, 0.4767947196960449, 0.22924743592739105, -0.6743805408477783, 0.1259235441684723, 0.3001531958580017, -0.17484161257743835, 0.22237026691436768, -0.11055073142051697, -0.6183127164840698, -0.395040363073349, 0.1391279250383377, -0.085757315158844, -0.19032560288906097, 0.29795005917549133, 0.01558096893131733, -0.3305785655975342, 0.4899129867553711, -0.24062348902225494, 0.4821862578392029, -0.26228809356689453, 0.30448538064956665, -0.2413228452205658, 0.46446898579597473, -0.009719443507492542, 0.41167891025543213, -0.4776368737220764, -1.281806230545044, 0.5556294918060303, 0.6438961625099182, 0.6609651446342468, 0.009293479844927788, 0.5351213812828064, -0.17157696187496185, -0.8373265266418457, 0.09514259546995163, -0.38741645216941833, -0.26392728090286255, 0.8255565762519836, 0.9666814208030701, 0.8601295351982117, -0.4891546964645386, 0.2474847137928009, -0.04425431042909622, 0.8754040002822876, -0.009688430465757847, 0.12967024743556976, -0.06870503723621368, -0.2543894350528717, 0.06521438807249069, -0.4605174958705902, -0.19725236296653748, 0.06690420210361481, -0.018969593569636345, 0.5762423872947693, 0.5669400095939636, -0.21538282930850983, -0.6876288056373596, 0.22893963754177094, 0.5259962677955627, 0.26044532656669617, -0.06605205684900284, 0.7268567681312561, -0.8383506536483765, 0.7106599807739258, 0.4847715497016907, 0.5307357907295227, 0.47848957777023315, -0.11695372313261032, 0.3329343795776367, -0.8091344237327576, -0.27443718910217285, -0.41550421714782715, -0.03891224041581154, -0.4293327033519745, 0.56964510679245, -0.4574381709098816, 0.10056592524051666, -0.20369546115398407, 0.40091055631637573, -0.43187496066093445, -0.8382170796394348, -0.08404654264450073, -0.43637529015541077, -0.3876258134841919, -0.19026532769203186, 1.0495675802230835, -1.1575918197631836, -0.1326524317264557, -0.2075144499540329, 0.779840886592865, 0.5716944932937622, -0.5490620136260986, -0.368554025888443, -0.20051755011081696, -0.35631585121154785, -0.2769870162010193, 0.20265787839889526, 0.3756004869937897, -0.3811895251274109, -0.22417648136615753, -0.5875359773635864, -0.33052197098731995, -0.24910666048526764, 0.45484089851379395, -0.6472294330596924, 0.018237899988889694, -0.1017896756529808, 1.0507376194000244, 0.4262666404247284, -0.1872539222240448, -0.40151238441467285, -0.5057154893875122, -1.0519826412200928, 0.33943724632263184, -0.7827172875404358, 0.014489690773189068, -0.32159489393234253, 0.31816205382347107, -0.401150643825531, -0.10517911612987518, -0.08634117245674133, -0.2909896671772003, -0.08608824014663696, 0.6574566960334778, -0.34598734974861145, -0.13860641419887543, 0.7644520998001099, -0.17568446695804596, 0.6166776418685913, 1.219886064529419, -0.29836830496788025, -0.1350945234298706, 0.6173850297927856, 0.16307471692562103, -0.8793310523033142, 0.07099198549985886, -0.5857738852500916, 0.07683997601270676, 0.5843552947044373, -0.5095990896224976, 0.03163957968354225, -0.2194252908229828, 0.40741249918937683, 0.1622346192598343, 0.15623851120471954, -0.9437150359153748, -0.1502550095319748, 0.057449180632829666, -0.11124273389577866, -0.5227111577987671, 0.49924248456954956, -0.1842118799686432, -0.1682707816362381, -0.38014042377471924, 0.2734157145023346, -0.8519500494003296, -0.13842180371284485, -0.5430296063423157, -0.16778486967086792, -0.3477272391319275, 0.5213167071342468, 0.4219605028629303, -0.6985658407211304, -0.6529456973075867, -0.28353723883628845, -0.021392369642853737, -1.0959815979003906, -0.06808698922395706, 0.028484642505645752, -0.007789072580635548, -0.3940236568450928, -0.4947202205657959, 0.3963627219200134, -0.2391684502363205, -0.4252115488052368, -0.3649757206439972, -0.267685204744339, -0.07054014503955841, 0.08084049075841904, -0.25120750069618225, 0.3756084442138672, 0.2631661891937256, -0.48747679591178894, -0.6117972135543823, 0.1187218651175499, 0.41000255942344666, 0.5475132465362549, 0.03183489292860031, -0.8118752837181091, 0.10123272985219955, -0.5298481583595276, 0.157868430018425, 0.09581991285085678, 0.26222431659698486, -0.4042011499404907, -1.1629689931869507, -0.3056422770023346, 0.168660506606102, 0.517558217048645, 0.7590888738632202, -0.13351739943027496, -1.026120901107788, 0.20581191778182983, 0.057769179344177246, 0.27043280005455017, -0.044574156403541565, -1.0437865257263184, -0.017556369304656982, 0.3030458390712738, 0.11809846013784409, -0.2918766140937805, -0.6230719685554504, 0.4213869869709015, 0.587275505065918, 0.3077014982700348, -0.4748433530330658, -0.8719611167907715, 0.10677129775285721, 0.8172695636749268, -0.4138323664665222, -0.9214285612106323, -0.8151633143424988, 0.4791557192802429, -0.2087252289056778, 0.5742502808570862, 0.6479367017745972, -0.8598541021347046, 0.31075674295425415, 0.00032459874637424946, 1.5911810398101807, -0.19562001526355743, 0.5039275884628296, 0.004862950183451176, 0.6545820832252502, 0.44385382533073425, 0.10732334107160568, -1.1718406677246094, -0.9499998092651367, -0.22729484736919403, -0.15894754230976105, 0.6091922521591187, 0.12256883084774017, 0.030001625418663025, 0.2932240068912506, -0.15920411050319672, -0.7211988568305969, -0.21334992349147797, 1.0499752759933472, 1.1543023586273193, -0.4567672908306122, -0.5470699071884155, -0.5048549771308899, 0.609589695930481, 0.27054446935653687, 0.4748073220252991, 0.3110453486442566, -0.30026063323020935, 0.08814121037721634, -0.023734066635370255, -0.12481756508350372, -0.8907110095024109, -0.5605023503303528, -0.1493780016899109, 0.6134691834449768, 0.06231141835451126, 0.23466385900974274, -0.0321902260184288, -0.06952036172151566, -0.24283011257648468, 0.5183800458908081, 0.21114757657051086, 0.3217410743236542, 0.8651033639907837, 0.291838139295578, -0.7440356016159058, 0.35757067799568176, -0.8765398263931274, -0.04722603037953377, -0.4309857189655304, 0.8294352889060974, 0.3065984845161438, -0.6683689951896667, 0.8059927225112915, 0.48719581961631775, -0.1358853429555893, -0.8722628355026245, 0.07177890837192535, 0.08078766614198685, 0.1712750494480133, -0.023734252899885178, -0.5773438811302185, 0.6113303303718567, -0.34909090399742126, 0.4956376552581787, -0.24581654369831085, -0.45210421085357666, 0.327749103307724, -0.21704672276973724, 0.8311859965324402, -0.8458696603775024, -0.483212411403656, 0.25845927000045776, 0.0600908026099205, 0.15347225964069366, 0.14707428216934204, -0.37393349409103394, 0.29905661940574646, 0.29897013306617737, 0.29605504870414734, -0.19130432605743408, -0.3087731897830963, -0.3723648190498352, 0.3596835732460022, 0.758934736251831, 0.5098448991775513, -0.938079297542572, 0.7474970817565918, 0.1189507320523262, -0.7062138915061951, 0.16858960688114166, -0.3318561911582947, 0.6557023525238037, 0.08504382520914078, 0.29104265570640564, 0.17902834713459015, -0.17739298939704895, 0.3565613925457001, 0.6753848195075989, -0.49076732993125916, -0.18542571365833282, -0.8003974556922913, -0.5100372433662415, -0.3971467912197113, -0.6730378270149231, -0.08665528148412704, -0.35609516501426697, -0.3876389265060425, -0.4099089801311493, -0.38963162899017334, 0.4760103225708008, -0.09935042262077332, -0.20878995954990387, -0.543716549873352, 0.022789988666772842, -0.3335973620414734, -1.4339739084243774, -0.5702812671661377, -0.8013209700584412, -0.1795521080493927, 0.9457530379295349, -0.8639803528785706, -0.32537105679512024, 0.33395496010780334, -0.09520912170410156, -0.3688327670097351, -0.01811250112950802, -0.2602781355381012, -0.7510606050491333, 0.1917547583580017, 0.7394407987594604, 0.8443533778190613, 0.18131715059280396, 1.059654712677002, -0.6248996257781982, 0.6747690439224243, 0.37740558385849, 0.2686132788658142, -0.6735216975212097, -0.19316056370735168, 0.21341514587402344, -0.5344563722610474, 0.46137309074401855, -0.40142473578453064, 0.03017878718674183, -1.129645824432373, -0.3121243715286255, -0.08576855808496475, -0.15770038962364197, 0.6525006890296936, -0.37467116117477417, 0.17391690611839294, 0.565504789352417, -0.3035823404788971, 0.1861172765493393, 0.6177893877029419, 0.5925117135047913, 0.11644334346055984, -0.03998223692178726, 0.39974910020828247, 0.19572223722934723, -0.2920408546924591, -0.549211859703064, 0.04458947107195854, 0.17417897284030914, 0.018356336280703545, 0.017509419471025467, -0.575805127620697, 0.5831601619720459, -0.39664265513420105, -0.4358782172203064, 0.9147324562072754, 0.2286447137594223, 0.6285585165023804, 0.6714632511138916, 0.17131465673446655, 0.4907817840576172, -0.25329387187957764, -0.8766214847564697, -0.7216761708259583, -1.0676461458206177, 0.10594925284385681, -0.462639182806015, -0.09970476478338242, -0.6938681602478027, -0.7552734017372131, -0.30228185653686523, 0.356143057346344, 0.41608670353889465, -0.7128506898880005, 1.183293104171753, 0.2254171222448349, 0.9857974052429199, -0.03505852073431015, 0.2959480583667755, 0.4389359652996063, 0.1625901758670807, -0.10393968224525452, -0.6983600854873657, 0.6926162838935852, 0.2952646017074585, 0.04017346724867821, -0.6717670559883118, -0.17271718382835388, 0.7367626428604126, -0.0658043920993805, 0.03107646480202675, -0.262465238571167, 0.8289669752120972, -0.5560527443885803, 0.5272731184959412, -0.19877459108829498, 0.08887200802564621, 0.0790686160326004, 0.5043355822563171, 0.16129891574382782, -0.976448655128479, -0.9933101534843445, -0.5034317970275879, 0.3576207756996155, -0.7515502572059631, 0.49373650550842285, -0.21964651346206665, 0.6043806672096252, 0.869732677936554, -0.07149937003850937, 0.24240070581436157, 0.5443490147590637, -0.21821221709251404, -0.011822812259197235, -0.014731191098690033, 0.29779040813446045, 0.5978296995162964, -0.041884131729602814, -0.49138960242271423, 0.3658069372177124, -0.08316521346569061, 0.057330045849084854, -0.16868983209133148, -0.30539146065711975, 0.664547860622406, -0.5465235710144043, -0.35070210695266724, -0.05852590128779411, -0.1366114318370819, 0.6901796460151672, -0.03217308223247528, -0.3465576171875, 0.4982224702835083, -0.43254488706588745, -0.6490033864974976, 0.8375164866447449, -0.23666448891162872, 0.57166588306427, 0.13215526938438416, -0.15662100911140442, -0.29933562874794006, 0.789751410484314, -0.0063157714903354645, -0.007603911682963371, 0.6878001689910889, -0.399586945772171, -0.4190111458301544, -0.9103901982307434, 0.3328242599964142, -0.3782341480255127, 0.4263707995414734, 0.5326585173606873, 0.2700849175453186, -0.390985906124115, 0.04115470498800278, -0.40150153636932373, 0.26313355565071106, 0.8247556686401367, 0.13567087054252625, 0.4535764753818512, -0.0007174467318691313, 0.3715589940547943, -0.2632569372653961, 0.314939022064209, 0.5746746063232422, -0.5013440847396851, -0.4424230754375458, -0.0026361756026744843, 1.0673614740371704, 0.43834975361824036, 0.5126178860664368, 0.34949618577957153, 0.05357176810503006, 0.12008475512266159, 0.6545711159706116, -0.425504595041275, 0.3102537989616394, -0.25748154520988464, 0.14708246290683746, -0.3336813151836395, -0.14183595776557922, 0.16443094611167908, -0.1933508664369583, -0.3332582712173462, -0.42933520674705505, 0.4404393434524536, 0.36603909730911255, -0.3895156681537628, -0.8474624156951904, -0.13104033470153809, -0.3828776776790619, 0.1907886415719986, 0.0553339421749115, 1.0504794120788574, 0.9383363127708435, -0.15233266353607178, -0.010284069925546646, -0.4156360924243927, -0.4847744405269623, -0.16709132492542267, 0.11084956675767899, -0.006658026948571205, -0.13062435388565063, 0.15798477828502655, -0.0982128232717514, -0.9704042673110962, 0.3059979975223541, 0.1243707686662674, -0.08833274990320206, -0.5975643396377563, 0.045423682779073715, 0.4740683138370514, 0.633791446685791, 0.5133488178253174, 0.6091940402984619, 0.05822776257991791, 0.1685199737548828, -0.00540508609265089, -0.024780822917819023, 0.4764668941497803, 0.3665263056755066, -0.04490058124065399, -0.2986188232898712, -0.3998399078845978, -0.13432592153549194, 0.4820813834667206, -0.5383110642433167, 0.027029603719711304, 0.23248909413814545, -0.21751977503299713, -0.455466628074646, 0.22684608399868011, 0.9556349515914917, -0.11500375717878342, -0.20162062346935272, -0.6570751667022705, -0.1400788426399231, -0.3104810118675232, 0.362434446811676, -0.31557196378707886, -0.07574423402547836, -0.4589295983314514, 0.03213353455066681, 0.7471503019332886, -1.1572797298431396, 4.294079303741455, 0.9588486552238464, 0.9688122868537903, -0.360368013381958, 0.8579393625259399, -0.04816162586212158, 0.09704723954200745, -0.5063174366950989, 0.15290899574756622, 0.13531844317913055, -0.016405990347266197, -0.5757096409797668, -0.026779644191265106, -0.33623719215393066, 0.6792858242988586, 0.2707551121711731, -0.23765581846237183, -0.057639721781015396, -0.24441412091255188, -0.552808403968811, -0.5375201106071472, 0.32037273049354553, -0.3612608015537262, 0.24154981970787048, 0.4879286587238312, -0.0007453602738678455, 0.21782872080802917, 0.3213505744934082, -0.25511807203292847, -0.16890738904476166, 0.8787551522254944, -0.3757219612598419, 0.5539231896400452, -0.5978627800941467, -0.7163795232772827, 0.16315767168998718, 0.4063708484172821, -0.21248067915439606, 0.3342759907245636, 0.44577208161354065, 0.5676259398460388, -0.04893928021192551, -0.003119234461337328, -0.04131279140710831, -0.4236062169075012, 0.3490016460418701, -1.119758129119873, 0.5393651127815247, 0.8741424679756165, -0.32334163784980774, 0.7762443423271179, -0.3128689229488373, 0.16771741211414337, 0.2890653610229492, -0.9574181437492371, -0.6487777233123779, -0.23841768503189087, -0.8469315767288208, 0.1150921881198883, 0.9032161831855774, 1.5259959697723389, 0.19048722088336945, 0.014981360174715519, -0.3237892985343933, 0.25622016191482544, 0.3752935528755188, 0.07325659692287445, 0.4688590466976166, -0.209344744682312, -0.23466072976589203, -0.42277950048446655, -0.23483768105506897, 0.15604043006896973, -0.003369452664628625, 0.6101136207580566, 0.32463932037353516, -0.6160885691642761, 0.5001852512359619, -0.30969828367233276, -0.4630470275878906, 0.41802501678466797, 0.17180590331554413, 0.3025382459163666, 0.06992942094802856, -0.3188619613647461, 0.8138106465339661, -0.4216998815536499, 0.024258486926555634, -0.7819831967353821, 0.502927303314209, 0.595356822013855, 0.2324085235595703, -0.14273598790168762, 0.5895305275917053, -0.6370705962181091 ]
{"Title": "Hepatitis C Core Antigen test as an alternative for diagnosing HCV infection: mathematical model and cost-effectiveness analysis", "Authors": "Sadeghimehr Maryam, Keiser Olivia, Negro Francesco, Butsashvili Maia, Shilton Sonjelle, Tskhomelidze Irina, Tsereteli Maia, Bertisch Barbara, Estill Janne", "Abstract": "Abstract Background The cost and complexity of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing is a significant barrier for the diagnosis and treatment of patients infected with hepatitis C virus (HCV). We investigated the cost-effectiveness of various testing strategies using antigen as an alternative to PCR. Methods We developed a mathematical model for HCV to estimate the number of newly diagnosed individuals and cases of different stages of liver disease. We compared the following testing strategies: antibody test followed by PCR in case of positive antibody (baseline strategy); antibody test followed by HCV-antigen test (antibody-antigen); antigen test alone; and PCR test alone. We conducted cost-effectiveness analyses considering the costs of HCV testing (of both infected and uninfected individuals) (A1), liver-related complications (A2) and all costs including HCV treatment (A3). The model was parameterized for the country of Georgia, and several sensitivity analyses were conducted to generalize the findings for different settings. Results Using the current standard of testing, 89% of infected individuals were detected. Comparatively, antibody-antigen and antigen testing alone detected 86% and 88% of infected individuals, respectively. PCR testing alone detected 91% of the infected individuals with the remaining 9% dying or spontaneously recovering before testing. In analysis A1, antibody-antigen testing was not found to be essentially cheaper compared to the baseline strategy. In analysis A2, strategies using PCR were cheaper than antigen-based strategies. In analysis A3, antibody-antigen testing was the cheapest strategy, followed by the baseline strategy, and PCR testing alone. Conclusion Antigen testing, either following a positive antibody test or alone, performed almost as well as the current practice of HCV testing. The cost-effectiveness of these strategies strongly depends on the inclusion of treatment costs. Lay summary Core antigen testing is a reliable alternative test for diagnose HCV infection. Antigen-based strategies may be cost-effective, in particular if treatment costs are considered. Highlights Strategies using an antigen test to diagnose HCV infection performed reasonably well compared with the traditional antibody- and PCR based approach. According to our study, antigen test alone missed about 3%, and antibody followed by PCR test 2% of HCV infected individuals. The maximum difference in quality-adjusted life expectancy across the different strategies of diagnosing HCV was only one month.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.12.19014621"}
10.1101/19011031
[ -0.4799897074699402, 0.9386441111564636, -0.5649427771568298, 0.6186381578445435, -0.26295387744903564, -0.3528355062007904, 0.09897688031196594, -0.0036505539901554585, 0.033523473888635635, 0.6456673741340637, -0.27598869800567627, -0.35732927918434143, -0.30178964138031006, -0.8610522747039795, 0.15942177176475525, 0.16938593983650208, -1.2723661661148071, 0.2689550518989563, -0.5672566890716553, -0.12714429199695587, 0.5305672287940979, -0.05404004454612732, -0.5275170207023621, 0.0944816842675209, -0.42339658737182617, 0.6405805349349976, -0.058634333312511444, -0.33455464243888855, 1.0968446731567383, 0.5528515577316284, 0.1387859731912613, -0.8811179399490356, 0.2965000867843628, -0.5949398279190063, -0.09431258589029312, 0.13962703943252563, 0.5212182402610779, -0.5043129324913025, -0.3943687379360199, -0.2693311274051666, 0.004769011866301298, -0.4225837290287018, 0.7727941274642944, -0.9316595792770386, -0.5040302276611328, 0.13685718178749084, 0.20510020852088928, -0.7347257137298584, -0.2691170573234558, -0.962787926197052, -0.5594134330749512, -0.05152494087815285, -0.13957543671131134, -0.2912248373031616, -0.19199317693710327, -0.24121534824371338, 0.2747548222541809, 0.26416751742362976, -0.29020488262176514, 0.18581953644752502, 0.7125869393348694, -0.45619305968284607, 0.3775411546230316, -1.7718216180801392, -0.06454896181821823, 0.8560778498649597, 0.16823159158229828, 0.2700357139110565, -0.2196769267320633, -0.6210580468177795, -1.492003083229065, -0.17400236427783966, -0.5937862992286682, -0.5215566158294678, 0.04475589469075203, 0.5324001908302307, 0.15426918864250183, 0.24706892669200897, 0.49432361125946045, -0.7437818050384521, 0.3304305374622345, -0.03485295921564102, -0.5796384811401367, 0.04089540243148804, 0.0861087292432785, -0.0347166582942009, -0.18857352435588837, 0.13473229110240936, 0.34659236669540405, -0.2838049530982971, 0.6222901344299316, -0.11750955879688263, 0.17889787256717682, 0.16990768909454346, 0.2074238359928131, 0.6698628664016724, -1.0703001022338867, -0.3193034827709198, 0.3417755961418152, -0.44885191321372986, 0.47775906324386597, 1.1200127601623535, -0.292633593082428, 1.043150782585144, -1.3041406869888306, -0.38569411635398865, 0.32437220215797424, 0.008811983279883862, -0.30432629585266113, -0.7665490508079529, -0.36360013484954834, 0.8168681859970093, -0.423944354057312, 0.998586118221283, 0.19407498836517334, 0.34093019366264343, -0.17412319779396057, -0.0800580158829689, -0.4425123333930969, 0.6332882046699524, -0.3065851330757141, -0.2533265948295593, 0.23422764241695404, -0.8072831034660339, 0.5091305375099182, 0.09218066930770874, -0.241399884223938, 0.527582585811615, 0.12103638797998428, 0.18735593557357788, 0.5033944249153137, -0.01472291350364685, -0.30684617161750793, 0.945837676525116, -0.6793322563171387, -0.00699307955801487, -0.6916618943214417, 1.2295249700546265, -0.17751389741897583, -0.44198986887931824, -0.8645436763763428, 0.4622141420841217, -0.2247266322374344, 0.9384428858757019, -0.3615170121192932, 0.6174829602241516, 0.05991031974554062, -1.2634581327438354, 0.2585182785987854, -0.003669159021228552, 0.391793817281723, 0.4494152069091797, -0.4261626899242401, -0.07527970522642136, -1.0510962009429932, -0.4243054986000061, -0.4064643681049347, 1.0357810258865356, -0.7244234681129456, 0.4667261242866516, 0.25870779156684875, 0.52901691198349, -0.023920226842164993, 0.9660334587097168, -0.6436983942985535, 0.6757605075836182, -0.12373118847608566, -0.7233999967575073, 0.2284572422504425, -0.507963240146637, 0.24119694530963898, 0.41927096247673035, 0.09986384958028793, -0.5446746349334717, -0.20270976424217224, 0.28367745876312256, 0.8009262084960938, 0.5394080877304077, -0.261944055557251, 0.34872832894325256, -0.1836482286453247, -0.6536827683448792, 1.2265805006027222, 0.29324227571487427, 0.1537933647632599, -0.20975281298160553, -0.5140080451965332, -0.9834420084953308, -0.3812704384326935, 0.4558679163455963, 0.14489687979221344, 1.4869884252548218, -1.1599795818328857, 0.36266443133354187, -1.0196373462677002, 0.29416272044181824, -0.3203829228878021, 0.5666723251342773, 0.7212254405021667, -0.25355565547943115, -0.41053926944732666, 0.5320376753807068, -0.685620903968811, 0.3071892559528351, -0.9557655453681946, 0.32907000184059143, 0.23201054334640503, 0.3622625172138214, -0.38732531666755676, -0.09641589224338531, 0.4279727041721344, -0.7300703525543213, -0.05805434286594391, 0.4075177311897278, 0.16865037381649017, -0.7494717836380005, 0.5429191589355469, 0.6685968637466431, 0.3837011158466339, -0.2324635535478592, 0.7697672843933105, 0.42928585410118103, 0.5655312538146973, -0.102969229221344, 0.2948538064956665, 0.09686364978551865, 1.062563180923462, -0.13769370317459106, 0.4888889193534851, 0.04512246698141098, 0.3418431580066681, 0.9565714001655579, -0.3635760247707367, 0.5173165798187256, 0.7941503524780273, 0.5258991122245789, 0.2053331881761551, 0.7499891519546509, 0.8130470514297485, -0.5045533776283264, 0.5210102200508118, 0.2322082668542862, 1.0786678791046143, 0.07252790778875351, -0.3256038427352905, -0.07403886318206787, -0.1169138103723526, 0.2736828327178955, -0.6979178190231323, -0.49433982372283936, -0.9285590052604675, 0.898091733455658, 0.1379893720149994, 0.0710890144109726, -0.16628777980804443, 0.45012351870536804, 0.2399260401725769, 0.5296334624290466, -0.2919366955757141, -1.08747398853302, -0.29126662015914917, -0.33048215508461, 0.5157122015953064, -0.25180888175964355, 0.8670586347579956, 0.745766818523407, 0.1729808747768402, 0.32266765832901, 0.007294191047549248, -0.12328080832958221, -1.0371804237365723, -0.7366652488708496, -1.1377341747283936, -0.577078640460968, -0.5316640138626099, -0.8074711561203003, 0.43783578276634216, -0.08307826519012451, 0.6661499738693237, 0.5310198068618774, 0.5378711223602295, -0.8202002644538879, -0.024508245289325714, 0.5847541689872742, 0.21301327645778656, 0.11063302308320999, -0.9825804233551025, 0.328151673078537, -0.11450018733739853, 0.7825071811676025, -0.3397023379802704, -0.7469546794891357, -0.6714937686920166, -0.2227926254272461, -0.05547705292701721, -0.43205124139785767, 0.0056220656260848045, 0.008504630997776985, -0.575732409954071, -0.26305511593818665, 0.5334422588348389, 0.08610498905181885, 0.22584667801856995, -0.020748749375343323, -0.8995811343193054, 1.1682801246643066, 0.22192007303237915, -0.40316084027290344, 0.7734418511390686, 0.22486861050128937, -0.03771722689270973, 1.3469159603118896, -0.3116040527820587, -0.028147920966148376, -0.3058847486972809, 1.4579784870147705, 0.6300045251846313, 0.20035941898822784, -0.029133446514606476, -0.41824692487716675, -1.1968886852264404, -0.3611195385456085, 0.39511069655418396, -0.7454021573066711, 0.4077264666557312, 0.7218778133392334, 0.3164837658405304, -0.9514490365982056, 0.12324514240026474, -0.719035804271698, -0.9554867148399353, 0.04178328067064285, -0.4750697910785675, 0.354473352432251, -0.007358219940215349, -0.27180108428001404, -0.49115151166915894, -0.13533392548561096, 0.38199126720428467, 0.19852754473686218, 0.6538141965866089, -0.8475230932235718, -0.3938859701156616, 0.3677658140659332, -0.05261531099677086, 0.2638316750526428, 0.9081788063049316, -0.44627606868743896, -0.1380612850189209, -0.005111736245453358, -0.42543286085128784, 0.27027881145477295, -0.13166543841362, -0.4740637242794037, 0.19518086314201355, -0.37136775255203247, -0.13674044609069824, 0.27745485305786133, -0.42256292700767517, 0.42326751351356506, -0.2680748403072357, -0.03986094892024994, -0.2737933099269867, 0.72728031873703, -0.7588405609130859, -0.22084957361221313, 0.4954467713832855, 0.26848408579826355, 0.2596200108528137, -0.62787926197052, 0.8882611393928528, 0.20010501146316528, 0.7060927748680115, -0.5128306150436401, -0.35871392488479614, -0.5206440687179565, 0.3675902187824249, 0.33667901158332825, 0.9238529205322266, -1.6788016557693481, -0.2006821632385254, 0.7012129426002502, 1.3529832363128662, 0.36451295018196106, 0.4963914453983307, 0.21664807200431824, -0.40333208441734314, 0.018903659656643867, 0.1362455040216446, -0.09269800782203674, 0.48305997252464294, -0.10651632398366928, -0.5812920331954956, -0.34084710478782654, -0.6904107332229614, 0.0842200368642807, 0.6135129928588867, 0.32375478744506836, -0.5866382122039795, -0.9817531108856201, 0.823861837387085, 0.16423596441745758, 0.8660223484039307, 1.1360493898391724, 0.008482414297759533, -0.3818480372428894, -0.6952013373374939, 0.27741649746894836, 0.10317286103963852, -0.12759199738502502, -0.23056074976921082, -0.2807428240776062, 0.1615130454301834, -0.07358689606189728, 0.2464522272348404, 0.1922614723443985, -0.5032922625541687, -0.18694259226322174, -0.025680560618638992, -0.1211688369512558, 0.11074236780405045, 0.44940441846847534, -0.9873043894767761, 0.464030385017395, 0.18810608983039856, -0.7672773003578186, -0.1115901842713356, -0.46125978231430054, 0.2354934960603714, 1.0604652166366577, 0.07701689004898071, -0.635993242263794, 0.553114116191864, 0.35767611861228943, -0.5281094908714294, 0.8615472316741943, -0.5187680721282959, -1.0417388677597046, -0.2714316248893738, 0.21454212069511414, -0.436206191778183, -0.80311119556427, 0.041098665446043015, -0.2273961752653122, -0.23211124539375305, 0.07817232608795166, 0.1647089123725891, 0.2856903076171875, 0.17643451690673828, 0.21578572690486908, 0.7861599922180176, -0.4354139268398285, 0.4617635905742645, 0.1335594207048416, -1.0223828554153442, -0.46597129106521606, 0.35508763790130615, -0.28491589426994324, 0.7150546908378601, -0.6455531716346741, -0.44177788496017456, -0.23077207803726196, 0.41789209842681885, 0.021761737763881683, -0.30679836869239807, 0.640718936920166, -0.6997440457344055, 0.4723310172557831, 0.5877909660339355, -0.10680295526981354, -0.5504669547080994, 0.08908157795667648, -0.2829184830188751, -0.906794011592865, -0.03377143666148186, -0.4861631989479065, 0.0949440598487854, -0.13081662356853485, 0.4813276529312134, 0.2622610628604889, -0.46687689423561096, 0.21441994607448578, -0.1448579579591751, 0.6352590918540955, -0.19444800913333893, 0.4516291916370392, -0.21213294565677643, -0.11612914502620697, -0.4118373394012451, -0.40727779269218445, 0.3068075180053711, -0.3626616895198822, 0.11170759052038193, 0.3307904303073883, -0.45779991149902344, 0.11425178498029709, -1.0965877771377563, 0.7281560897827148, -0.07878376543521881, -0.7730317711830139, 1.2560582160949707, -0.46546632051467896, -0.5225632786750793, 0.28870490193367004, 0.10050154477357864, -0.052886057645082474, -0.740100085735321, -0.1625998616218567, -0.18397146463394165, 0.14163362979888916, -0.2768878936767578, -0.551624059677124, -0.024175535887479782, 0.6785318851470947, -0.04766272008419037, 0.018700076267123222, -0.14194883406162262, -0.39064767956733704, -0.5633065104484558, 0.09762818366289139, -0.40698903799057007, -0.5005248785018921, -0.3530040979385376, 0.389045774936676, -0.3671318292617798, -0.30449822545051575, -0.5414020419120789, -0.7972073554992676, -0.01802673377096653, -0.92291659116745, 0.8279849290847778, -1.5219628810882568, 0.3475983738899231, -0.5007547736167908, -0.3859340250492096, -0.27957066893577576, -0.5050787329673767, 0.19544415175914764, -0.04731568321585655, -0.150027334690094, -0.6762247681617737, 0.20026037096977234, -0.4924166202545166, -0.3499583303928375, -0.21317686140537262, -0.17696525156497955, -0.1437913030385971, 1.0936565399169922, 0.7420448064804077, -0.17188869416713715, 0.2740645706653595, -0.2558225095272064, 0.585261881351471, 0.07083925604820251, -0.08157441020011902, -0.15994255244731903, 0.4609254002571106, 0.19538234174251556, 0.7516059875488281, 0.046663783490657806, -0.47183337807655334, -0.45542699098587036, -0.2656366527080536, 0.4981811046600342, -0.5052677392959595, 0.29508814215660095, -0.38368064165115356, -0.5050446391105652, 0.7835239171981812, -0.7561923265457153, 0.46720755100250244, 0.5428589582443237, 0.23324047029018402, -0.15266820788383484, -0.22274567186832428, -1.0931726694107056, -0.7562596797943115, -1.171776533126831, -1.057651400566101, 0.45177751779556274, -0.14383001625537872, 0.2820981740951538, -0.17387479543685913, 0.01996343582868576, -0.268729567527771, -0.37894269824028015, 1.199007272720337, 0.5753515362739563, 0.11998928338289261, -0.4434663653373718, -0.16268609464168549, 0.34505078196525574, 0.15944096446037292, 0.0006673074094578624, -0.007846737280488014, -0.31821390986442566, -0.2678709924221039, -0.7272458076477051, -0.6120714545249939, -1.0856760740280151, 0.46940910816192627, 0.1784512996673584, 0.570488691329956, 0.17824752628803253, 1.1731293201446533, 0.25893738865852356, 0.13784581422805786, -0.6191738843917847, 0.702415943145752, -0.7828523516654968, -0.24907317757606506, 0.3588424026966095, -0.5466522574424744, -0.12328421324491501, 0.08984430879354477, -0.073700912296772, -0.21325178444385529, 0.7975355982780457, -0.021121690049767494, 0.5931836366653442, -0.4790153503417969, 0.011886924505233765, 0.06038079783320427, -0.06623192131519318, -1.3292853832244873, -0.5824870467185974, -0.03304950147867203, 0.3176743984222412, -0.39622384309768677, -0.5115460753440857, 0.2165699005126953, -0.26371580362319946, -0.14708665013313293, 0.5677207112312317, 0.15633825957775116, -0.42948117852211, 0.16468285024166107, -0.5993981957435608, -0.4412630498409271, 0.6311718225479126, 0.9186893701553345, 0.15237200260162354, 0.21175161004066467, -0.05651160702109337, 0.12098143249750137, 0.2937163710594177, -0.10873159766197205, 0.4394069015979767, -0.8094616532325745, 0.28175753355026245, -0.38935577869415283, 0.6981465816497803, -0.8736349940299988, -0.14660567045211792, 0.42379212379455566, 0.6152597069740295, 0.09066832065582275, -0.23885060846805573, -0.5824075937271118, 0.7058395147323608, 0.4017464220523834, 0.8549694418907166, -0.5971670150756836, -0.1267336755990982, 1.0462067127227783, 0.7731856107711792, -0.29660090804100037, -0.7858940958976746, -1.475395917892456, -1.119488000869751, -0.14233212172985077, 0.5417018532752991, -0.5390028357505798, -0.5595095157623291, 0.6607068777084351, -0.5810007452964783, -1.0128810405731201, -0.41351741552352905, 1.159736156463623, -0.8778526782989502, 0.5218299627304077, -0.6387007236480713, -0.24483740329742432, -1.2164504528045654, 0.4484347999095917, -0.03416653349995613, -0.9114457964897156, -0.9758906364440918, 0.7637867331504822, 0.26295480132102966, 0.1554630547761917, 0.5267115831375122, 0.2414749711751938, 0.30033814907073975, 0.5556525588035583, -0.6497072577476501, -0.07072895765304565, -0.32244938611984253, 0.25882476568222046, 0.5436288714408875, 0.4176322817802429, 0.598869264125824, -0.25998300313949585, 0.7670398950576782, 0.22961801290512085, -0.5264963507652283, -0.9727011919021606, -0.24238461256027222, 0.14598257839679718, 0.07773394882678986, -0.22736243903636932, -0.012600503861904144, 0.3457983136177063, -0.7531354427337646, -0.3460420072078705, -0.2448752224445343, 0.3467315435409546, -0.06336857378482819, -0.4507262110710144, 0.08474871516227722, 0.6592910289764404, -0.31523141264915466, 0.18691009283065796, -0.7787518501281738, 0.024423066526651382, -0.08633765578269958, -0.2110229730606079, -0.15325865149497986, 0.49173417687416077, 0.3339223265647888, -1.3802798986434937, 0.49030786752700806, 0.10229624807834625, -0.9020214080810547, 0.2437167912721634, -0.6452730298042297, 0.3816387355327606, 0.17065198719501495, 0.051326725631952286, 0.534317672252655, 0.7863550782203674, 0.0011766881216317415, -0.09569580852985382, 0.051640164107084274, -0.3892047107219696, -0.8614906072616577, -0.460239440202713, -0.959810733795166, -0.04729039967060089, 0.006759416311979294, -0.2799185812473297, -0.3512393832206726, -0.26253533363342285, -0.11390850692987442, 0.1618824303150177, 0.2527830898761749, 0.1938905268907547, -0.3146430253982544, -0.013396717607975006, 0.555854082107544, 0.3002994656562805, 0.02860850840806961, -0.16462576389312744, 0.42860573530197144, -0.01784268207848072, -0.5452730655670166, -0.48957908153533936, 0.5959248542785645, 0.23813404142856598, -0.07919053733348846, -0.12017855793237686, -0.2135191559791565, -0.0135195292532444, -0.05251704156398773, -0.40336284041404724, -0.4834595322608948, 0.24126693606376648, -0.3219514787197113, -0.08871811628341675, -0.2715838551521301, 0.025081662461161613, -0.660564124584198, 0.5798999071121216, 0.3689594864845276, -0.5419003963470459, -0.46007540822029114, -0.2810667157173157, -0.07980923354625702, -0.25845271348953247, 0.0613061860203743, -0.46764346957206726, 0.37062889337539673, -0.4873361587524414, 0.16298174858093262, 0.2706475257873535, 0.3864973485469818, 0.9972867369651794, -0.20579677820205688, 0.07748638838529587, 1.368465542793274, 0.5132379531860352, 0.07315840572118759, 0.2024035006761551, 0.8137009739875793, 0.16060596704483032, -0.5179351568222046, 0.2310200184583664, 0.2653367221355438, 0.8128195405006409, 0.18200574815273285, 0.3199782371520996, 0.2803054749965668, 0.5166276097297668, -0.15012750029563904, -0.035655103623867035, -0.631331205368042, 0.43858224153518677, 0.04026484861969948, -0.8493086099624634, -0.17107699811458588, 0.42576032876968384, 0.23626774549484253, -0.17306332290172577, 0.7403134703636169, 0.3262201249599457, 0.8799992799758911, 0.4083003103733063, -0.015150247141718864, 0.5989183783531189, 0.12662605941295624, -0.9065216183662415, -0.13797077536582947, 0.5321078300476074, 0.16190433502197266, 0.7584785223007202, 0.7761203646659851, -0.10560430586338043, -0.07286185026168823, 0.47181621193885803, -0.3839505612850189, -0.5919248461723328, 0.6640020608901978, -0.052436698228120804, -0.8431373238563538, -1.0444144010543823, 0.27020472288131714, -0.5159851908683777, -0.1653108298778534, 0.8831278681755066, -0.5551816821098328, 0.700499951839447, 0.7955403923988342, 0.11926351487636566, 0.5706424713134766, 0.5340925455093384, 0.37838083505630493, -0.7138075232505798, 1.6952860355377197, 0.4561859965324402, -0.057737212628126144, 0.5384089946746826, -0.07463628798723221, -0.2347516268491745, -0.011583900079131126, -0.46798184514045715, 0.8933594226837158, 0.620956540107727, -0.6654229760169983, -0.4103146195411682, 0.37201443314552307, -0.32939964532852173, -0.06377792358398438, -0.5328765511512756, -0.017620179802179337, 0.21856018900871277, -0.13405470550060272, -0.189296156167984, 1.1605944633483887, -0.004742167424410582, -0.2103874832391739, 0.03863442689180374, -0.03871835023164749, -0.23690348863601685, 0.08900341391563416, -0.44197067618370056, 0.6354236602783203, 0.4705425500869751, 0.16953617334365845, -0.18491065502166748, -1.0295320749282837, -0.29890117049217224, 0.10148324817419052, -0.7753721475601196, -0.9873532056808472, 0.7743693590164185, 0.22143730521202087, 0.4087426960468292, 0.6484440565109253, -0.22625741362571716, 0.3149455189704895, 0.25141406059265137, 0.7938855886459351, 0.4144892692565918, 0.06477688252925873, 0.4641790986061096, 0.3782712519168854, 0.2190691977739334, 0.4289862811565399, 0.34539467096328735, 0.27436476945877075, -0.12425565719604492, -0.008883300237357616, 0.05130261182785034, -0.1612568348646164, -0.4571462571620941, 0.2577837407588959, -0.5812813639640808, -0.6101292371749878, -0.19211916625499725, -0.32636135816574097, -0.5474359393119812, -0.3361482620239258, 1.1089915037155151, -0.31819263100624084, 0.618767499923706, 0.5257440805435181, -0.3304198086261749, 0.6928836107254028, 0.0337132066488266, 4.0533671379089355, 1.2410145998001099, 0.3279914855957031, -0.511962890625, 0.3425915241241455, 0.6425151228904724, 0.7919304370880127, 0.35374459624290466, -0.19350653886795044, 0.08946166187524796, -0.5036544799804688, 1.2883024215698242, -0.2048119753599167, 0.10827911645174026, 0.5053576231002808, 0.8726468682289124, -0.21626542508602142, -0.03503718227148056, -0.31389471888542175, -1.2575165033340454, 0.17671144008636475, 0.08701728284358978, -0.1320822685956955, 0.03688913583755493, 0.3655482232570648, 0.047311004251241684, -0.578133761882782, 0.14202925562858582, -0.22957275807857513, 0.15993276238441467, -0.3587424159049988, -0.9109128713607788, -0.051381565630435944, -0.6962429881095886, 0.2468993067741394, 0.225675567984581, -0.1361791342496872, -0.012992564588785172, -0.6133076548576355, -0.4399813413619995, 0.40719085931777954, 0.08738704025745392, -0.06290805339813232, -0.18495573103427887, -0.31854158639907837, 0.10258808732032776, 0.4417160749435425, 0.18160676956176758, 0.4687515199184418, -0.7886974215507507, 0.9588485360145569, -0.3445097506046295, -0.3486683964729309, 0.45802417397499084, -0.767930269241333, 0.42706194519996643, -0.018645234405994415, -0.4730548560619354, 0.24970224499702454, -0.35392823815345764, 0.7159720063209534, 0.3991728127002716, 0.3457087576389313, 0.06104585900902748, 0.2732674777507782, -0.03656301647424698, 0.6367743015289307, 0.6368224620819092, -0.4981265068054199, -0.4298306703567505, -0.12771719694137573, 0.051085542887449265, -0.987464964389801, 0.17171481251716614, 0.6005524396896362, 0.3369693160057068, -0.6987003684043884, 0.33275502920150757, 0.06238355115056038, -0.3827841281890869, -0.04887446016073227, -0.0064142849296331406, 0.7182117700576782, 0.39432308077812195, 0.3922143578529358, 0.4616575241088867, 0.32257962226867676, -0.7555819749832153, -0.8684247732162476, 0.46568167209625244, 0.259954035282135, -0.08719471096992493, -0.2554658055305481, -0.2522653341293335, 0.003977698273956776 ]
{"Title": "Acute ischemic stroke alters the brain\u2019s preference for distinct dynamic connectivity states", "Authors": "Bonkhoff Anna K., Espinoza Flor A., Gazula Harshvardhan, Vergara Victor M., Hensel Lukas, Michely Jochen, Paul Theresa, Rehme Anne, Volz Lukas J., Fink Gereon R., Calhoun Vince D., Grefkes Christian", "Abstract": "Abstract Acute ischemic stroke disturbs healthy brain organization, prompting subsequent plasticity and reorganization to compensate for loss of specialized neural tissue and function. Static resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies have already furthered our understanding of cerebral reorganization by estimating stroke-induced changes in network connectivity aggregated over the duration of several minutes. In this study, we utilized dynamic resting-state fMRI analyses to increase temporal resolution to seconds and explore transient configurations of motor network connectivity in acute stroke. To this end, we collected resting-state fMRI data of 31 acute ischemic stroke patients and 17 age-matched healthy controls. Stroke patients presented with moderate to severe hand motor deficits. By estimating dynamic connectivity within a sliding window framework, we identified three distinct connectivity configurations of motor-related networks. Motor networks were organized into three regional domains, i.e. a cortical, subcortical and cerebellar domain. Temporal connectivity patterns of stroke patients markedly diverged from those of healthy controls depending on the severity of the initial motor impairment. Moderately affected patients (n=18) spent significantly more time in a weakly connected configuration that was characterized by low levels of connectivity, both locally as well as between distant regions. In contrast, severely affected patients (n=13) showed a significant preference for transitions into a spatially segregated connectivity configuration. This configuration featured particularly high levels of local connectivity within the three regional domains as well as anti-correlated connectivity between distant networks across domains. A third connectivity configuration represented an intermediate connectivity pattern compared to the preceding two, and predominantly encompassed decreased inter-hemispheric connectivity between cortical motor networks independent of individual deficit severity. Alterations within this third configuration thus closely resembled previously reported ones originating from static resting-state fMRI studies post-stroke. In summary, acute ischemic stroke not only prompted changes in connectivity between distinct functional networks, yet also caused severe aberrations in temporal properties of large-scale network interactions depending on the individual deficit severity. These findings offer new vistas on the dynamic neural mechanisms underlying acute neurological symptoms, cortical reorganization and treatment effects in stroke patients.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19011031"}
10.1101/19000950
[ 0.10850014537572861, 0.21230918169021606, -0.08128800243139267, 0.565565288066864, -0.09761474281549454, -0.5519634485244751, 0.47007444500923157, -0.19296914339065552, 0.7016086578369141, 0.9172160625457764, 0.3171289563179016, -0.5974746942520142, 1.0326118469238281, -0.37090596556663513, 0.2260386049747467, -0.6673452854156494, -0.26866260170936584, -0.12455736100673676, 0.07814259827136993, -0.28103896975517273, -0.4375979006290436, 0.3193356394767761, -1.0641053915023804, -0.196059912443161, -1.3614412546157837, 0.6857305765151978, 0.37128084897994995, -0.5237346291542053, 1.2494511604309082, 0.7550207376480103, -0.9170005321502686, -0.6213958859443665, 1.3425334692001343, -0.6529118418693542, -0.1125313937664032, -0.25694000720977783, 0.9751479029655457, -0.938005268573761, -0.44229382276535034, -0.7512662410736084, 0.32715803384780884, 0.28645068407058716, 0.2269601821899414, -0.3988283574581146, 0.012695763260126114, -0.2327275276184082, -0.3758888840675354, -0.45125409960746765, -0.6179763078689575, -0.07732021808624268, -0.015990417450666428, 0.1883702427148819, -0.26779013872146606, 0.05815236270427704, 0.2087620347738266, 0.43063437938690186, 0.04236158728599548, -0.6534643173217773, -0.6289921998977661, 0.1915908008813858, 0.2998741567134857, -0.14149333536624908, -0.19438116252422333, -0.651509702205658, 1.1511136293411255, 0.908248245716095, -0.23105044662952423, -0.054241083562374115, -0.14054298400878906, -0.5728108286857605, -0.04774954542517662, 0.1027650535106659, -0.6441539525985718, -0.756765604019165, -0.9487655758857727, -0.4218403995037079, 0.5924087166786194, -0.005069385282695293, -0.22127260267734528, 0.04931483790278435, -0.2111305594444275, -0.10172228515148163, 0.44527021050453186, -0.05650549754500389, -0.623458743095398, 0.749188244342804, 0.2731841802597046, 0.7727092504501343, -0.5273962616920471, 0.11709433048963547, -0.21937744319438934, 0.22610484063625336, 0.0385180227458477, -0.41252899169921875, -0.6683450937271118, 0.9830875396728516, -0.9536617994308472, 0.3988252580165863, -0.3371939957141876, -0.543543815612793, 0.05897381901741028, 0.4059770107269287, -0.5481756925582886, 0.16865651309490204, 0.0035316646099090576, 0.909196138381958, 0.688256025314331, -0.26655980944633484, -0.18700265884399414, -0.5373307466506958, 0.3541232943534851, -0.11889654397964478, -0.29477277398109436, 0.3511665165424347, 0.7542374134063721, 0.7402065396308899, -0.7328327298164368, 0.8198962211608887, -0.19640587270259857, -0.5429995059967041, -0.3766119182109833, -0.4995482861995697, 1.5279195308685303, -0.17643630504608154, 0.3484286963939667, 0.3635266423225403, 0.17506729066371918, 1.0621106624603271, -0.014141860418021679, -0.4445037841796875, 0.2597074508666992, -0.3289475440979004, -0.13415007293224335, 0.7814369797706604, 0.7082968354225159, -0.3453979790210724, -0.006382531952112913, 0.12240982800722122, 0.5252639651298523, -0.5024811029434204, -0.04121926426887512, 0.9158641695976257, -0.3984687626361847, 1.037099838256836, -0.2889338731765747, 0.459660142660141, -0.6334566473960876, -1.2968124151229858, -0.19208860397338867, 0.04643996059894562, 0.003699982538819313, 0.3873046040534973, -0.15744809806346893, -0.32180097699165344, -0.29755765199661255, 1.2319068908691406, 0.44633373618125916, 0.19818080961704254, -0.34675124287605286, 0.21856357157230377, -0.11846138536930084, -0.24408401548862457, -0.15674002468585968, 0.4350440502166748, -0.2236364334821701, 1.1685994863510132, -0.3842114806175232, 0.09509893506765366, -0.1916409283876419, -0.4652729332447052, 0.8308917284011841, -0.43324047327041626, -1.0832444429397583, -0.2085297405719757, -0.20806382596492767, 0.5130528807640076, 0.7861531376838684, 0.16540534794330597, 0.20214618742465973, 0.9062180519104004, -0.06891803443431854, 0.06998392194509506, 0.41292884945869446, 0.9316530823707581, -0.11153769493103027, 0.1290181279182434, -0.45401254296302795, -0.4063051640987396, 0.6661577820777893, -0.6120983958244324, -0.07215993106365204, 0.2049737125635147, 0.06065182760357857, 0.23533515632152557, -0.3358558416366577, -0.03820775821805, -0.5756279230117798, 0.037317290902137756, -0.18986760079860687, -0.08819106966257095, -0.6804395914077759, -0.08275861293077469, -0.11249499768018723, 0.9907576441764832, -0.41607820987701416, 0.5383867621421814, 0.5772900581359863, 0.4505651891231537, -1.1741324663162231, 0.2893659174442291, 0.7498651146888733, 0.21379528939723969, -0.6035752296447754, -0.6179091334342957, 0.48018983006477356, -1.0118900537490845, 0.09862972050905228, 0.5208432674407959, 0.19802238047122955, 0.23666110634803772, -0.11171092092990875, 0.34067896008491516, 0.7568153142929077, 0.9339497685432434, 0.3414952754974365, 1.3385846614837646, 0.13034114241600037, 0.8887494206428528, 0.14776553213596344, -0.3180532157421112, 0.708892285823822, 1.2630374431610107, 0.10188619792461395, 0.7482107281684875, 0.0914093405008316, 0.43673110008239746, 0.47707268595695496, -0.1746807098388672, 0.7291154861450195, 0.29426559805870056, 0.19060812890529633, 0.06332019716501236, 1.028111457824707, -0.14337408542633057, -0.24891355633735657, 0.3514394760131836, -0.37810176610946655, 0.18279753625392914, -0.16413366794586182, 0.7364544868469238, -0.003518834477290511, 0.6392269134521484, 0.8337306380271912, 0.9212181568145752, -0.8815010786056519, -0.3209173083305359, 0.5357654690742493, 0.08433614671230316, -0.06839723885059357, -0.15850456058979034, 0.6735385656356812, 0.7783318161964417, 0.08375436812639236, 0.1312730461359024, 0.6219119429588318, 0.17376744747161865, 0.18601366877555847, 0.6082409024238586, -0.3091644048690796, -0.9318428635597229, -1.2455921173095703, -0.3751067817211151, -1.067176342010498, -0.7002977728843689, -0.17755362391471863, 0.11522819846868515, 0.8032636642456055, -0.45575207471847534, 0.004232669249176979, 0.8175049424171448, 0.06549753993749619, -0.31115105748176575, -0.658987283706665, 0.7794102430343628, -0.09156409651041031, -0.0045867785811424255, -0.38343751430511475, -0.21033351123332977, -0.4065408408641815, 0.43177899718284607, -0.7350172400474548, -0.09807399660348892, -0.5928564071655273, -0.7531218528747559, -0.17183129489421844, -0.09635768085718155, -0.1605447381734848, -0.23979021608829498, 0.6993001103401184, 0.05072891712188721, 0.04934233799576759, -0.1440553069114685, 0.4028241038322449, -0.25482186675071716, -0.5414658784866333, 0.34983590245246887, -0.708458662033081, 0.5324386358261108, 0.20583218336105347, 0.8390529751777649, -0.3141080439090729, 0.14054110646247864, -0.17491115629673004, 0.13888810575008392, -0.46776992082595825, 0.5049232244491577, -0.05346912518143654, 0.8408045768737793, 0.14423921704292297, -1.3640484809875488, -0.5887667536735535, 0.34123149514198303, -0.6079578399658203, -0.48421964049339294, 0.26456865668296814, 0.7300068736076355, 0.07879520952701569, -1.51455557346344, 0.10919508337974548, -0.5566340684890747, -1.6994731426239014, -0.14741000533103943, -0.4431629180908203, 0.29262182116508484, 0.056540824472904205, 0.15010757744312286, -0.4009162485599518, 0.46077385544776917, -0.1278180629014969, 0.2101479321718216, 0.5777837634086609, -0.9505457282066345, 0.34167566895484924, 0.3812686800956726, -0.02209942229092121, 0.5445023775100708, 0.47228798270225525, -0.3335363566875458, 0.11162195354700089, -0.057367920875549316, -0.39437758922576904, -0.060922153294086456, 0.47833627462387085, 0.07091385871171951, -0.09697263687849045, 0.4196764826774597, -0.4442346394062042, 0.05187734216451645, 0.22968433797359467, 0.3170660734176636, 0.24975617229938507, 0.4428417384624481, -0.17047898471355438, -0.26952895522117615, -0.5459469556808472, -0.21505515277385712, -0.3287859857082367, 0.23118376731872559, 0.06916205585002899, -0.5943747758865356, 0.44248300790786743, 0.20889288187026978, -0.3877524137496948, 0.1038227379322052, -0.6973826885223389, -0.24729260802268982, 0.6158447265625, -0.5490611791610718, 1.051517367362976, -1.3230741024017334, 0.9286536574363708, -0.13708123564720154, 1.4157626628875732, 0.2235088348388672, -0.1623048037290573, 0.6698052883148193, -0.16428843140602112, 0.5558908581733704, 0.05401872470974922, -0.9234604835510254, 0.17067205905914307, -0.5868939757347107, 0.46497803926467896, 0.42744889855384827, -0.7147817015647888, 0.3812691271305084, 0.2848244309425354, 0.342820405960083, -0.006333057768642902, 0.0722590908408165, 0.46440833806991577, 0.11359850317239761, 0.5973569750785828, -0.3768501877784729, -0.017206916585564613, -0.0510074682533741, -0.18347539007663727, 0.40072518587112427, -0.45624351501464844, -0.17488311231136322, -0.6356839537620544, 0.49280452728271484, -0.05962463840842247, -0.3320547640323639, 0.5763009190559387, -0.662301242351532, -0.36458316445350647, -0.1005760133266449, -0.6912950277328491, -0.2165091186761856, 0.49457958340644836, -0.16376566886901855, -0.5204148888587952, 0.3219112753868103, 0.6914870738983154, -0.5811590552330017, 0.4517560601234436, -0.09794893115758896, 0.21409858763217926, 0.8301413059234619, -0.28044867515563965, -0.226573646068573, -0.29066768288612366, 0.08687690645456314, -0.30040276050567627, 0.2823134660720825, 0.018724098801612854, 0.09067806601524353, 0.52911376953125, -0.5869048833847046, -0.06144365295767784, -1.0369219779968262, -0.17114345729351044, -0.43500933051109314, 0.17294150590896606, 0.1245168074965477, 1.1734007596969604, 0.2051972895860672, -0.12248285859823227, 0.016944685950875282, 0.5788952112197876, -0.9109477996826172, 0.3969770669937134, 0.01223116833716631, -0.2678501009941101, 0.4484180212020874, -0.24885523319244385, -0.024945301935076714, 0.7653337121009827, 0.2238011658191681, -0.3780759572982788, -0.33516204357147217, 0.01967521943151951, -0.8688757419586182, -0.929295003414154, 0.31557559967041016, -0.18497173488140106, 0.20596878230571747, 1.0721831321716309, -0.1102987676858902, 0.07433944940567017, 0.21142499148845673, 1.1774098873138428, 0.006286922842264175, -0.47879666090011597, -0.040860529989004135, 0.2039308398962021, 0.4900835156440735, -0.6946485638618469, 0.38925981521606445, -0.41177302598953247, 0.488829642534256, -0.13229495286941528, -0.33278295397758484, -0.1823255866765976, -0.2091892659664154, -0.4061853587627411, 0.33851107954978943, -0.5700344443321228, 0.5419395565986633, -0.22813723981380463, -0.039704907685518265, 0.8255005478858948, 0.5525328516960144, -0.30850937962532043, -0.510857343673706, -1.0745683908462524, -0.7643705606460571, -0.0961696058511734, 0.1291971653699875, 0.7830642461776733, -0.7432581782341003, -0.7233962416648865, 0.3181212544441223, -0.13578590750694275, -0.2028566151857376, -0.373957097530365, 0.573066771030426, 0.016132166609168053, -0.7190452218055725, -0.8986793756484985, 0.12536238133907318, -0.6049375534057617, -0.7905172109603882, -0.41554030776023865, -0.38931816816329956, 0.2593601942062378, 0.43165910243988037, -0.20445199310779572, 0.5496652722358704, 0.8060050010681152, -0.5430262088775635, -0.5433030724525452, 0.9169985055923462, -0.13344399631023407, 0.3256434500217438, -0.11046727746725082, -0.07447554171085358, 0.38782939314842224, -0.42636436223983765, 0.19404089450836182, -0.7688236236572266, 0.3649197816848755, -0.7571578621864319, 0.0768156424164772, 0.4183296263217926, 0.5671426057815552, 0.10717983543872833, 0.11766359210014343, -0.10883383452892303, -1.1823354959487915, -0.13078628480434418, -0.2055317461490631, -0.4757152795791626, -0.017538366839289665, -0.7453867197036743, -0.4753246605396271, 0.12218346446752548, 0.6828631162643433, 0.11888954788446426, -0.6716744303703308, 0.3313884139060974, 0.5841509103775024, 0.2701590955257416, -0.7107358574867249, -0.5475861430168152, 0.03291971981525421, 0.4622541666030884, -0.2764380872249603, -0.6504092812538147, -1.5331655740737915, 0.904823899269104, -0.5075071454048157, 0.03818357735872269, -0.13379693031311035, -1.1389005184173584, -0.29428744316101074, -0.4991086721420288, 0.8965703248977661, -0.2257501780986786, -0.062429964542388916, 0.16354507207870483, 0.0655597671866417, -0.4049721360206604, 0.13736283779144287, -0.26136302947998047, -0.4735908806324005, -0.7707709670066833, -0.6573142409324646, 0.16964417695999146, -0.09177011251449585, 0.030238963663578033, -0.01009283121675253, -0.20342139899730682, 0.13839909434318542, -0.7276092767715454, 0.7436528205871582, 0.36597251892089844, -0.5650666952133179, -0.053995247930288315, -0.7427260279655457, 0.9519262313842773, 0.1887822151184082, 0.12663394212722778, -0.20319721102714539, 0.8824179172515869, -0.3485186696052551, -0.7235870361328125, 0.09385744482278824, -1.465214490890503, -0.3293057084083557, 0.05012530833482742, -0.12855906784534454, 0.4253603518009186, 0.43851664662361145, -0.36635446548461914, -0.5974031090736389, 0.09547977894544601, 0.691724419593811, 0.2531125843524933, 0.8008276224136353, 0.6888096332550049, 0.07660499960184097, -0.05866001546382904, 0.7197169065475464, -0.24510541558265686, 0.495954304933548, 0.10842689126729965, 0.4191116392612457, 0.551429808139801, -0.8641090989112854, 0.8869354128837585, 1.0692358016967773, -0.08840394765138626, -0.3359430134296417, 0.13859331607818604, -0.6426204442977905, -0.33576062321662903, -0.05734151601791382, -0.641950786113739, 0.43265846371650696, -0.6316028237342834, 0.09651794284582138, -0.13047781586647034, 0.23199734091758728, -0.13275033235549927, -0.602043628692627, 0.02217327617108822, -0.06788641959428787, -0.33982419967651367, 1.1293885707855225, -0.24614962935447693, 0.38056644797325134, 0.24184443056583405, 0.7112440466880798, 0.04707277938723564, -0.2340494990348816, -0.014675434678792953, -0.6285688877105713, 0.42073580622673035, 0.2164742648601532, -0.03340927138924599, -0.0997014045715332, 0.2416003942489624, -0.5103053450584412, 0.9318423867225647, 0.7444222569465637, -0.37077680230140686, 0.09902848303318024, 0.06632686406373978, 0.726658821105957, 0.08254172652959824, 1.0531885623931885, -0.7428566813468933, -0.34668296575546265, -0.05222255736589432, -0.20577256381511688, -0.08309319615364075, -0.2424531877040863, -0.5089072585105896, 0.18064486980438232, -0.24638615548610687, -0.04850129410624504, 0.04073154926300049, 0.7213070392608643, -0.7228201627731323, -0.7441406846046448, -0.6182874441146851, 0.9760688543319702, 0.017542803660035133, 0.21967937052249908, -0.05035160109400749, 0.8448510766029358, -0.9010322093963623, -1.4284179210662842, -0.34960776567459106, -0.2721072733402252, 0.12566033005714417, 1.2224878072738647, -0.7815417051315308, -0.4302348494529724, 0.5778540968894958, -0.4838976263999939, -0.4964856505393982, 0.19771192967891693, -0.6317375898361206, -0.39087235927581787, -0.9852432608604431, 0.9594665169715881, -0.24422404170036316, -0.222789466381073, 0.6496954560279846, -0.28622370958328247, 0.3774668276309967, 0.509529173374176, -0.32276451587677, -0.628770649433136, 0.04838985204696655, 1.075266718864441, -0.7016011476516724, -0.4861624240875244, -0.3090173900127411, -0.02794942818582058, -1.2340275049209595, -0.5301924347877502, -0.6405205130577087, -0.09990284591913223, 0.8356525897979736, -0.04620860144495964, 0.5728015303611755, 0.45048999786376953, -0.13616298139095306, -0.13865377008914948, 0.3350270092487335, 1.2293490171432495, -0.009319854900240898, -0.7146735191345215, 0.754993200302124, 0.20271410048007965, 0.49206826090812683, -0.0912705585360527, 0.35261619091033936, 0.7763686180114746, -0.4857276976108551, 0.35816019773483276, -0.37545979022979736, 0.6658522486686707, -0.3148967921733856, -0.555803120136261, -0.27824556827545166, 0.42040231823921204, 0.8912932276725769, 0.2555678188800812, -0.06047719717025757, -0.6002441048622131, -0.7677918076515198, -0.3527742326259613, -0.6452659368515015, -1.036696434020996, 0.5236278176307678, -0.3206923007965088, 0.28524574637413025, -1.2422595024108887, -0.6365598440170288, 0.4063737690448761, 0.7867448925971985, 0.3733414113521576, -0.4024527072906494, -0.06682681292295456, 0.23876158893108368, 0.6392102837562561, -0.4270270764827728, -0.12118908017873764, -0.43711334466934204, 0.0475543811917305, -0.6057136654853821, -0.40115949511528015, 0.19269421696662903, -0.1810886263847351, 0.4978351294994354, -0.8443824052810669, -0.5849601030349731, 0.6532385945320129, 0.2641454339027405, -0.0982629656791687, -0.5049869418144226, -0.17470543086528778, -0.7750915884971619, -0.11634697765111923, -0.32218295335769653, 0.17577707767486572, -0.636745035648346, 0.6104258894920349, -0.06548776477575302, -0.6820492744445801, -0.6059389114379883, -0.6683695316314697, 1.16698157787323, -1.2908834218978882, 0.7484080195426941, -0.26991039514541626, 0.004263498820364475, -0.3044517934322357, -0.315530925989151, 0.7383586168289185, -0.037985701113939285, -0.04583887383341789, 0.193425253033638, 0.06693178415298462, 0.003870240179821849, 0.7453082799911499, 0.29034459590911865, -0.04281847923994064, 0.02872098796069622, 0.3192949593067169, -0.17048734426498413, 0.4214318096637726, -0.09785235673189163, 0.3099367022514343, 0.5184434056282043, -0.3139563798904419, 0.09845241904258728, 0.4174249470233917, 0.2741742432117462, 0.31619763374328613, -0.0883912742137909, 0.00745626725256443, -0.7075784802436829, -0.47158411145210266, 0.021055148914456367, -0.22963951528072357, 0.0572439543902874, 0.42983943223953247, 0.3643445372581482, 0.5031956434249878, 0.862788200378418, -0.21036241948604584, 0.24713252484798431, 0.8042027354240417, -0.4362909495830536, -0.7359870076179504, -0.3047947883605957, 0.36706554889678955, 0.13966652750968933, 0.1340123414993286, -0.08957098424434662, -0.6347261667251587, -0.5917827486991882, 0.7987931966781616, -0.41452550888061523, 0.31529179215431213, 1.1186647415161133, -0.09748909622430801, 0.11151464283466339, -0.8975392580032349, -0.09337788820266724, -0.4635260999202728, -0.13468582928180695, 0.5504190921783447, -0.6403026580810547, 0.60417240858078, 0.5840392708778381, 0.641740083694458, 0.6938614249229431, -0.01057225838303566, 0.70518559217453, -0.29484790563583374, -0.16697563230991364, 0.4569454789161682, 0.45875778794288635, -0.34952619671821594, 0.176723450422287, -0.6040281653404236, -0.06560411304235458, -0.2697199285030365, 0.4101990759372711, -0.05539374426007271, -0.7223061323165894, 0.2036970555782318, -0.24841265380382538, 0.19722199440002441, -0.2707303762435913, -1.223923921585083, -0.02025756426155567, -0.06931152194738388, -0.526708722114563, 0.049768660217523575, 0.049813348799943924, 0.4983193278312683, 0.20758402347564697, 0.49519816040992737, -0.06381256878376007, -0.24708305299282074, -0.4963519275188446, -0.6783645749092102, 0.3480207324028015, 0.023405052721500397, 0.19798614084720612, -0.07548252493143082, -1.250765085220337, 0.09228373318910599, 0.27145448327064514, 0.017393089830875397, -1.366100788116455, 0.09462026506662369, 0.41503670811653137, 1.1179118156433105, -0.10380689799785614, -0.6240215301513672, 0.32633158564567566, -0.40240952372550964, 0.3250385522842407, 0.08721450716257095, -0.1329994946718216, -0.09858672320842743, -0.13220812380313873, -0.1420159488916397, 0.12036021798849106, 0.9849967360496521, 0.19111515581607819, 0.05348211154341698, -0.36733341217041016, 0.16427575051784515, -0.4100125730037689, -0.8019955158233643, 0.8713025450706482, 1.4836291074752808, -0.46886372566223145, 0.1144445464015007, -0.4647217094898224, 0.09230896085500717, -0.27892059087753296, 0.18788757920265198, -0.324541300535202, -0.1983719766139984, -0.2081121802330017, -0.014600824564695358, 0.5640271306037903, -1.258185863494873, 3.985663414001465, 0.6878665089607239, 0.6229940056800842, 0.13657361268997192, 0.7255899906158447, 0.1490715742111206, 0.5000818371772766, -0.5799539089202881, 0.24214860796928406, -0.0838075801730156, 0.015723444521427155, -0.3394848108291626, -0.24907290935516357, -0.34669947624206543, 0.28055310249328613, 0.7739591002464294, -1.156453251838684, -0.04177454486489296, 0.11384111642837524, -0.9811417460441589, -0.3279363512992859, -0.2274838387966156, 0.25332048535346985, -0.7243720889091492, 0.33957335352897644, 0.15318258106708527, -0.6220588684082031, 0.714175820350647, -0.5098305344581604, -0.7031903266906738, -0.7814755439758301, -0.573543131351471, 0.5154171586036682, -0.7670810222625732, -0.4453487694263458, 0.5361717343330383, 0.4304632246494293, -0.5720834136009216, 0.08569129556417465, 0.7497312426567078, 0.6446818113327026, -0.28741350769996643, 0.4535282254219055, -0.14133097231388092, 0.10174635052680969, -0.6006143689155579, -0.9579784274101257, 0.7502046227455139, 0.09743412584066391, -0.6789261698722839, 0.5274547934532166, -0.7838884592056274, 0.6416007876396179, 0.26647159457206726, -0.36334460973739624, -0.4569104015827179, 0.305643230676651, -0.6848745942115784, -0.5404899716377258, 0.35994598269462585, 1.0092215538024902, 0.27486610412597656, 0.012578274123370647, -0.06847671419382095, -0.08747309446334839, 0.9420598149299622, -0.1631789207458496, 1.0379289388656616, -0.07105554640293121, -1.1793949604034424, 0.06306564062833786, -0.8301787972450256, -0.26284605264663696, 0.24449752271175385, 1.1874929666519165, 0.42069122195243835, -0.5705693364143372, 0.5183810591697693, -0.4160352945327759, -0.5688568949699402, 0.8872638940811157, 0.7778312563896179, -0.03807013854384422, -0.4201412796974182, 0.06708844751119614, 0.09892487525939941, -0.2803053557872772, -0.38503071665763855, -1.0383168458938599, 0.7066081166267395, 0.5607933402061462, -0.11230223625898361, 0.07968895882368088, -0.6544159054756165, 0.11317261308431625 ]
{"Title": "Oncofetal Protein CR-1 in a new clinical role: a potential tumor marker for Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma", "Authors": "Anu Jain, Kumar Mallupattu Sumanth, Reetu Thakur, Satyawati Mohindra, Amanjit Bal, Ashim Das, Sushmita Ghoshal, Arnab Pal", "Abstract": "Abstract PURPOSE CR-1 (CR-1) is an oncofetal protein with its role as a key factor in early process of carcinoma has been evaluated in cases of various cancers. However, very few studies have reported its role in oral cancers, which is the sixth most common cancer around the world, particularly with high prevalence in developing countries. Oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) is the most predominant (90%) of all the histological types of oral cancer. Late detection, associated with increased morbidity and mortality, is mainly attributed to non-availability of a suitable biomarker for the disease. In the present pilot study we have evaluated the role of soluble CR-1, in serum as a potential tumor marker for OSCC. METHODS CR-1 was estimated using sandwich ELISA in serum samples of 50 biopsy proven OSCC patients (pre and post treatment) along with age and gender matched healthy controls. Immunohistochemistry was also done in corresponding tumor tissue sections to check the expression of CR-1. RESULTS Pre-treatment CR-1 was found to be 2.25 fold higher in serum of OSCC patients as compared to control (p<0.0001***), which was reduced to 1.6 folds post treatment (p=0.0006***). CR-1 levels were comparatively higher in early stage of disease. Upon IHC 80% of the cases were found to be positive for CR-1. CONCLUSION This study provides evidence that serum levels of CR-1 are elevated in patients of Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma, which decrease post treatment. Also, the association of expression of protein with tumor progression predicts CR-1 as a molecule that can be further evaluated as a potential tumor maker in OSCC.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000950"}
10.1101/19003251
[ 0.16850006580352783, 0.8647178411483765, -0.8394802212715149, 0.5819621682167053, -0.9489525556564331, 0.1268819123506546, -0.11004577577114105, 0.35174545645713806, 0.18833458423614502, 1.1543258428573608, -0.6226375699043274, -0.014374686405062675, -0.006181696895509958, -0.8394593596458435, -0.2512485980987549, 0.5274076461791992, -0.7357556223869324, -0.6270821690559387, -0.7257245182991028, 0.25770944356918335, 0.17038945853710175, 0.3067178428173065, -0.8817892074584961, -0.48473483324050903, -0.5351945161819458, 0.9505186676979065, -0.4614514112472534, -0.4015176296234131, 0.9630136489868164, 0.519131600856781, 1.1418390274047852, -0.638582170009613, 0.7573075890541077, -0.8892098069190979, -0.3299484848976135, -0.3522712290287018, 0.8626442551612854, -0.8279935121536255, 0.1406366229057312, -0.21194027364253998, 0.38576364517211914, -0.48245397210121155, 0.08753331005573273, -0.754266619682312, -0.6097055673599243, -0.6832572817802429, -0.5274112820625305, -0.49560046195983887, -0.18205003440380096, -0.4307795763015747, -0.23195773363113403, 0.17763517796993256, 0.014701948501169682, 0.6360106468200684, -0.2770441174507141, 0.4567313492298126, -0.23092155158519745, -0.10584350675344467, -0.49329331517219543, 0.1686141937971115, 0.2656230032444, 0.0611715205013752, 0.5321955680847168, -1.9277470111846924, 0.39027276635169983, 0.9497828483581543, 0.17780138552188873, -0.5035709142684937, -0.9138208627700806, -0.7215752005577087, -0.6303432583808899, 0.2573249638080597, 0.4095154106616974, -0.5119714140892029, 0.02591986581683159, 0.9658856987953186, -0.08424031734466553, -0.0579669214785099, -0.21556755900382996, -0.20075160264968872, 0.26101264357566833, 0.30925995111465454, -0.21369975805282593, 0.297505646944046, -0.6085300445556641, 0.11217222362756729, -0.3390640318393707, -0.7207333445549011, 0.6182158589363098, -0.29131725430488586, 0.8221147060394287, 1.0143190622329712, 0.5960617661476135, -0.0036601887550204992, -0.059563737362623215, 0.5372662544250488, -0.3430898189544678, 0.2879410684108734, 0.8501865863800049, 0.0065568373538553715, -0.277220219373703, 0.7667198777198792, -0.39810454845428467, 0.8754182457923889, -0.12431258708238602, 0.14410987496376038, 0.5427583456039429, -0.13835015892982483, -0.5885100960731506, -1.1402091979980469, 0.1288088858127594, 0.33745577931404114, -0.16041956841945648, 0.5185362696647644, -0.16563855111598969, 0.31349918246269226, 0.2890256941318512, 0.5394566059112549, -0.07498379051685333, 0.9692268371582031, 0.1529577672481537, -0.45564937591552734, 0.47170335054397583, -0.4937642216682434, 0.6455481648445129, -0.6842384338378906, -0.028155282139778137, 0.3991937041282654, -0.21355967223644257, 0.01536578219383955, -0.05977845937013626, 0.25210875272750854, 0.20363856852054596, 0.5131635665893555, 0.014143640175461769, 0.2840886414051056, -0.23713023960590363, 0.3405332565307617, -0.15866400301456451, -0.29840025305747986, -0.4748356342315674, 0.5561541318893433, -0.3838939070701599, 1.1144002676010132, -0.07262192666530609, 0.5828067064285278, -0.5944883227348328, -0.3961291015148163, -0.19757486879825592, -0.37499555945396423, -0.6376821994781494, 0.7480971217155457, -0.40465113520622253, -0.21554531157016754, 0.36662566661834717, -0.4504663646221161, -0.3774454593658447, 0.8982972502708435, -0.040251024067401886, 0.41543856263160706, 0.26660987734794617, 0.26312482357025146, -0.734661340713501, -0.1370292603969574, -0.8253090381622314, 0.5290830731391907, -0.4280211627483368, 0.03896888718008995, 0.6825978755950928, -0.7302934527397156, 0.2569558322429657, 1.0926945209503174, 0.09992107003927231, -0.9801722168922424, -0.03658250346779823, 0.7661242485046387, 1.1093735694885254, 0.6374465227127075, 0.09106621891260147, 0.0999300628900528, -0.276808500289917, -0.26282522082328796, 0.3688475489616394, 0.38074448704719543, 0.1811598539352417, -0.4949432909488678, -1.07046639919281, -0.5125917792320251, -0.6667211651802063, 0.8260045051574707, -0.24128659069538116, 0.9660934209823608, -0.6657613515853882, 0.19482453167438507, 0.06162354350090027, -0.2220793217420578, 0.5373405814170837, 0.24520368874073029, -0.31564292311668396, -0.8613628149032593, -0.6530794501304626, 0.6317693591117859, -0.2961117923259735, 0.48430436849594116, -0.7013280987739563, 0.9392753839492798, 0.3695746660232544, 0.5369133949279785, -0.03720570355653763, 0.7053381204605103, 0.5809600353240967, -0.049230657517910004, -0.042813725769519806, 0.11801120638847351, 0.6791976690292358, -0.4061519205570221, -0.032524652779102325, -0.32513493299484253, -0.2876189947128296, 0.350942462682724, 0.2565065622329712, -0.3188270330429077, 0.508025586605072, -0.2826184928417206, 0.44389885663986206, -0.08350291103124619, 0.6999374032020569, 0.19717448949813843, 0.03093213587999344, 0.280099093914032, -0.19982053339481354, 0.5069156289100647, 0.2065197080373764, 0.38269662857055664, 0.5804362893104553, 0.5795385837554932, 0.47182783484458923, 0.5490494966506958, 0.9220340847969055, -0.21633082628250122, 0.3889950215816498, 0.5106478333473206, 1.1674437522888184, 0.28320008516311646, -0.3064255118370056, 0.6011918783187866, 0.23804977536201477, 0.32629117369651794, -0.024034885689616203, -0.5634642839431763, -1.2097669839859009, 0.5745465755462646, -0.15565887093544006, -0.05888718366622925, -0.4958874583244324, 0.2924945056438446, 1.078908920288086, 0.34183353185653687, 0.23951402306556702, -1.334718942642212, 0.709486186504364, 0.5993406772613525, 0.27736639976501465, 0.19855459034442902, 0.18925181031227112, 0.8059084415435791, 0.40691763162612915, 0.755134105682373, 0.4664590358734131, -0.04154583439230919, -0.4016105830669403, -0.8441036343574524, -0.7551407814025879, -0.5946686863899231, -0.7279474139213562, -0.7585288286209106, -0.3419297933578491, -0.7853741645812988, 0.7809789776802063, 0.5194825530052185, 0.09729816764593124, -1.0725048780441284, 0.6008461713790894, 0.6551473736763, 0.4326189458370209, 0.28143438696861267, -0.9407564401626587, 0.38689619302749634, -0.6907265186309814, 0.16045404970645905, 0.3412618339061737, -0.6044889688491821, -0.7632449865341187, -0.11695212870836258, 0.30992940068244934, -0.3661012351512909, -0.22440634667873383, 0.7178062796592712, -0.48745542764663696, 0.22040371596813202, 0.04468143731355667, 0.661745548248291, -0.17415590584278107, 0.10989287495613098, -1.1104925870895386, 0.6626988649368286, 0.0704285204410553, -0.1804409772157669, 0.5475825071334839, 0.4571806788444519, -0.08614493161439896, 0.653427243232727, 0.34373754262924194, -0.017672518268227577, -0.8096870183944702, 0.3045022785663605, 1.4963271617889404, -0.7415704727172852, 0.36760789155960083, -0.2559872269630432, -0.7590152025222778, -0.5987104177474976, -0.007727892138063908, -0.4282969832420349, -0.6080901026725769, 0.05903050675988197, -0.17548269033432007, -1.1382157802581787, 0.26122623682022095, -0.8696427941322327, -0.8353317379951477, 0.37478798627853394, -0.3247394263744354, 0.7133081555366516, 0.7193425893783569, -0.01615361124277115, -0.08194174617528915, -0.20838189125061035, 0.05117649585008621, 0.08375945687294006, -0.23938621580600739, 0.1984759122133255, -0.2808554172515869, 0.5503224730491638, -0.2916404604911804, 0.7317352890968323, 0.13771049678325653, -0.22281020879745483, -0.32056984305381775, -0.0949309840798378, -0.6333807110786438, -0.1779952198266983, 0.3920901417732239, -0.8621072173118591, 0.5330767035484314, 0.26725903153419495, -0.5879249572753906, -0.049458496272563934, 0.2009539157152176, 0.6306955218315125, 0.1802060306072235, 0.0587552972137928, 0.3091646432876587, -0.22305545210838318, -0.594021201133728, -0.07557595521211624, 0.2786349952220917, 0.3881813883781433, 0.5548924207687378, -0.5490385890007019, 0.4868791997432709, -0.012785390950739384, -0.3937566876411438, 0.25747552514076233, -0.5454676747322083, 0.23092159628868103, 1.231340765953064, 0.3736315369606018, 1.0349324941635132, -1.2832814455032349, 0.43297556042671204, -0.01822945661842823, 0.5243151187896729, 0.40731513500213623, 0.07313424348831177, 0.10052967071533203, -0.9027318954467773, -0.441177099943161, 0.653701663017273, -0.15535421669483185, -0.2881360948085785, 0.4460812509059906, 0.1064290925860405, -0.2515738308429718, -0.35857561230659485, 0.2329324632883072, 0.7124457359313965, 0.9036245346069336, 0.018998462706804276, 0.23775988817214966, 0.693168044090271, 0.10881588608026505, 0.5339383482933044, 0.12744562327861786, 0.3680877685546875, -0.06981034576892853, -0.29012253880500793, -0.33191052079200745, 0.0414283387362957, 0.5231499075889587, -0.6252443194389343, -0.7316765785217285, -0.7495701313018799, 0.13965095579624176, 0.4926183223724365, 0.5662581324577332, -0.2552748918533325, -0.06173841282725334, -0.4449304938316345, -0.2786809802055359, 0.21844588220119476, 0.5239012837409973, -0.862373411655426, 0.14610224962234497, 0.5934287309646606, 0.22155985236167908, -0.33908501267433167, -0.8479690551757812, 0.5883285999298096, 0.7413361668586731, -0.3222247064113617, -0.6614710688591003, -0.1240859180688858, 0.46878018975257874, -0.7768248319625854, 0.6035693883895874, 0.5166526436805725, -0.5708481073379517, 0.0888180062174797, -0.03226286172866821, -0.1742093414068222, -0.164981871843338, -0.4697008430957794, -0.1351599395275116, 0.44221076369285583, -0.011218228377401829, 0.07455205917358398, 0.2397555112838745, 0.6290133595466614, -0.06248822808265686, 1.040985107421875, -0.990326464176178, 0.5869757533073425, -0.3327955901622772, -0.3206861913204193, -0.6670819520950317, -0.2504037022590637, -0.19682812690734863, -0.1771923452615738, -0.39380547404289246, -0.1933377981185913, -0.5375394225120544, -0.23490233719348907, 0.20036545395851135, -0.08597801625728607, 0.4118994474411011, -0.8547101616859436, -0.015593918040394783, 0.8518974184989929, 0.219146728515625, 0.26765573024749756, -0.5159324407577515, -0.07385189831256866, -0.4336163103580475, -0.06591327488422394, -0.19128450751304626, -0.2653961181640625, -0.6718541979789734, -0.5313867330551147, 0.07024230808019638, -0.6956965923309326, -0.05060741305351257, -0.10898055136203766, 0.5064533948898315, -0.3958936333656311, -0.8325121998786926, -0.5960714817047119, -0.5221049189567566, -0.5046707391738892, 0.5793861150741577, 0.01988297514617443, -0.1323891431093216, 0.3737553358078003, -0.5723544955253601, -0.08609655499458313, -0.538537323474884, -0.7539823055267334, 0.6537733674049377, 0.24909920990467072, 0.1971115618944168, 0.7743352055549622, -1.2012566328048706, -0.5243043303489685, 0.715952455997467, 0.8692091703414917, -1.0631011724472046, -0.12685686349868774, -0.12267736345529556, -0.12186874449253082, -0.7886191606521606, -0.34243860840797424, 0.041125472635030746, -0.39196690917015076, 0.6567627787590027, 0.6501685976982117, -0.2001626044511795, 0.22769887745380402, -0.20554815232753754, -0.8050583004951477, 0.42691415548324585, 0.061571154743433, -0.660386860370636, -0.6032982468605042, 0.396666944026947, 0.2793067991733551, 0.24153175950050354, -0.12563960254192352, 0.09094233065843582, -0.454743355512619, -0.6036370992660522, 0.8014283180236816, -0.7638769745826721, 0.1565851867198944, -0.5893020629882812, -0.4938987195491791, -0.12320588529109955, 0.03760712593793869, 0.23492516577243805, -0.815978467464447, -0.40869274735450745, -0.23562005162239075, 0.5231229662895203, -1.2053292989730835, -0.19949971139431, 0.037230394780635834, 0.1993921995162964, 0.46817660331726074, 0.48302343487739563, -0.1109652891755104, -0.46401238441467285, 0.8391216993331909, -0.022212432697415352, 0.636418342590332, 0.08795784413814545, -0.5023030638694763, -0.9450342059135437, 0.3226827383041382, 0.43445178866386414, -0.001187002519145608, -0.08146737515926361, 0.38582631945610046, 0.7109190225601196, -0.5137143135070801, 0.4774933159351349, -0.47862735390663147, 0.03824484348297119, 0.3895130455493927, -0.49292653799057007, 0.8502171635627747, -0.8494719862937927, -0.5283299088478088, 0.19144916534423828, 0.3577668368816376, -0.4310682415962219, -0.02337297424674034, -0.6934723854064941, -0.544034481048584, -0.7042186260223389, -1.0148870944976807, -0.1557663083076477, 0.1671411097049713, -0.21733379364013672, 0.07630621641874313, -0.08935483545064926, 0.06562353670597076, -0.22304517030715942, 0.322236031293869, 0.8934151530265808, -0.3408045768737793, -0.049783043563365936, -0.6367589831352234, 0.03385912999510765, 0.7374712228775024, 0.17565640807151794, -0.1277957260608673, -0.2711898684501648, 0.12356483191251755, -0.08141785115003586, -0.4439549744129181, -1.0264580249786377, -0.22628672420978546, 0.345401406288147, 0.6748960614204407, 0.00003374821972101927, 0.197860985994339, -0.09524232894182205, -0.28058114647865295, -0.7424119114875793, 0.8596110343933105, -0.5095921754837036, -0.015464674681425095, 0.5494927763938904, -0.41420236229896545, -0.1981072574853897, -0.271394819021225, -0.018931260332465172, -0.4481395483016968, 0.3500685691833496, 0.14609067142009735, 0.46968913078308105, -1.3236163854599, 0.09568198025226593, 0.42643964290618896, -0.4014194905757904, -0.7597880959510803, 0.1159839779138565, -0.5031015872955322, 0.6297509074211121, -0.5548578500747681, 0.05672087147831917, 1.0160508155822754, 0.47219204902648926, 0.18437887728214264, -0.1314539611339569, -0.3033352196216583, 0.27778810262680054, -0.38507670164108276, -0.20939281582832336, -0.9386348128318787, -0.0671292096376419, 0.41701939702033997, 0.03463324159383774, 0.19261042773723602, -0.2733341455459595, -0.13337896764278412, -0.003223684150725603, -0.26237747073173523, 0.3012700378894806, -0.7863708734512329, 0.2407217025756836, 0.45032796263694763, 0.6780967116355896, -0.5165945887565613, 0.15404891967773438, 0.5238010287284851, 1.0155664682388306, -0.014829551801085472, -0.5282043814659119, -0.5938814282417297, 0.511850893497467, 0.018837718293070793, 0.6492136120796204, -0.6711172461509705, -0.16765788197517395, 0.7422810792922974, 0.6470491886138916, -0.188501238822937, -0.4511115550994873, -0.5316039323806763, -0.5905756950378418, -0.5896827578544617, 0.9556373357772827, -0.8151476979255676, 0.5661977529525757, 0.9946998357772827, -0.5361717939376831, -0.758097767829895, -0.2852201461791992, -0.15636907517910004, -0.21332262456417084, -0.6695511937141418, -0.7299721240997314, 0.261898010969162, -0.9809967279434204, -0.4677920341491699, -0.49681299924850464, -0.7086544036865234, 0.30057039856910706, 0.18228714168071747, -0.39234334230422974, -0.5438193082809448, -0.3966854214668274, 0.6684069037437439, -0.09798663854598999, 0.7000657320022583, -0.014206434600055218, 0.6725530624389648, -0.19596318900585175, 0.8992563486099243, 0.30919432640075684, 0.3842312693595886, 1.2525591850280762, 0.008446605876088142, 0.30884096026420593, 0.4814327657222748, -0.3003131151199341, -0.6458115577697754, 0.21778658032417297, 0.3482253849506378, -1.0044987201690674, -0.6973632574081421, 0.07432103902101517, 0.7795140147209167, -0.6148590445518494, -0.0005672788247466087, 0.0849626362323761, 0.1201276183128357, -0.0665203407406807, 0.035004157572984695, -0.14527085423469543, 0.830284059047699, 0.5830835700035095, 0.3516184687614441, -0.11874949187040329, 0.6480490565299988, -0.3487791121006012, 0.49020540714263916, 0.16442234814167023, 0.6941372752189636, -0.046054255217313766, -2.0698723793029785, 0.44083595275878906, 0.390645295381546, -0.8192957043647766, -0.23493275046348572, -0.4904455840587616, -0.06458279490470886, 0.042064715176820755, -0.33913663029670715, -0.19991159439086914, 0.1900162249803543, 0.23503945767879486, 0.10511309653520584, 0.5594735145568848, -0.22459690272808075, -0.4019996225833893, -0.5590212941169739, -1.4037965536117554, -0.6208308935165405, 0.8656074404716492, -0.27797406911849976, -0.09588237851858139, 0.010254837572574615, -0.08689433336257935, 0.755954921245575, -0.21136276423931122, 0.45708099007606506, -0.46162790060043335, 0.719985842704773, 0.038721874356269836, 0.8504220843315125, -0.4707375764846802, -0.49971985816955566, -0.07193432748317719, 0.7417885065078735, -0.6726688742637634, -0.5704566836357117, 0.27634888887405396, 0.20793020725250244, 0.7744731307029724, -0.44403132796287537, 0.001970241777598858, -0.15244796872138977, -0.09909339994192123, -0.725702702999115, -0.4270721971988678, 0.30847465991973877, -0.20056213438510895, -0.02312789298593998, -0.06934674084186554, -0.2131272852420807, 0.10150443017482758, 0.7787301540374756, 0.1995667815208435, -0.6699327826499939, 0.1410159319639206, 0.12620867788791656, 0.5719748139381409, -0.6198589205741882, 0.4323473274707794, -0.45730486512184143, 0.6856058835983276, -0.30536550283432007, -0.10128207504749298, 0.604356586933136, 0.40700581669807434, 0.44749915599823, 0.43115273118019104, -0.19187627732753754, 0.3996826708316803, 0.45429831743240356, 0.06535341590642929, 0.7534245252609253, 0.4238215386867523, 0.3677941560745239, -0.2315240204334259, 0.08338997513055801, -0.552761971950531, 0.59014493227005, 0.2175283282995224, 0.03145230561494827, 0.11811912059783936, 1.0130690336227417, 0.4259902238845825, -0.021491367369890213, -0.6403813362121582, 0.32820186018943787, 0.41864049434661865, -1.2880663871765137, -0.32344380021095276, 0.8065798878669739, 0.1724860966205597, 0.09214127063751221, 0.19899483025074005, -0.4792420268058777, 0.22448237240314484, 0.717770516872406, -0.049984872341156006, 0.41225525736808777, 0.0544615238904953, -0.0737517699599266, -0.3022053837776184, 0.9239863157272339, 0.37562769651412964, -0.05555100739002228, 0.019581109285354614, 0.06936872750520706, 0.20179395377635956, 0.31598836183547974, -0.5989657044410706, -0.5216639041900635, -0.002455890877172351, -0.25354263186454773, 0.2612321376800537, 0.26006633043289185, 0.022160755470395088, -0.46066194772720337, -0.552334725856781, 0.18530884385108948, -0.4586552083492279, -0.4463871419429779, 0.9274227619171143, -0.2036907970905304, 0.06783758103847504, 0.5158940553665161, 0.9225313663482666, -0.9157077074050903, 0.8069913387298584, 0.5006709694862366, -0.2716538906097412, 0.30267471075057983, 0.5458053350448608, -0.2249799519777298, -0.03414098173379898, 0.018588745966553688, -0.0786222442984581, -0.7987265586853027, -0.5021848678588867, -0.02005746215581894, 0.27550774812698364, -0.7245038747787476, 0.13761383295059204, -0.4002208113670349, 0.25513172149658203, 0.23615610599517822, -0.20654898881912231, -0.06750737875699997, 0.1584656685590744, 0.0037418717984110117, -0.2743013799190521, -0.5217259526252747, -0.4273949861526489, -0.14926835894584656, 0.27986398339271545, -0.7013152241706848, 0.4890127182006836, -0.36351004242897034, -0.5029999017715454, -0.4117879867553711, -0.8073081374168396, -0.21010784804821014, 0.26757797598838806, -0.6187438368797302, -0.698042094707489, -0.06232490763068199, 0.41833481192588806, 0.56160968542099, 0.5093767642974854, 0.49363619089126587, 0.14527404308319092, 0.40003883838653564, 0.926893949508667, -0.14422129094600677, 0.17039920389652252, 0.06453761458396912, -0.2977457642555237, -0.37139955163002014, 0.0369117371737957, -0.0386430025100708, -0.6572007536888123, -0.14240510761737823, -0.014473510906100273, 0.2623993754386902, -0.29882869124412537, -0.8339473605155945, 0.23141588270664215, -0.1699010729789734, -0.10050587356090546, -0.04499078169465065, -1.1588958501815796, -0.7565227150917053, -0.4691290557384491, 0.7771790027618408, -0.06796103715896606, -0.3233390748500824, 0.10548170655965805, -0.5368658304214478, -0.1248747929930687, -0.38900303840637207, 4.126999855041504, 1.3878344297409058, 0.0569608137011528, 0.16432705521583557, 0.434585839509964, 0.7071731090545654, 0.9647234678268433, -0.4526090621948242, -0.03436892479658127, 0.08722225576639175, -0.3007219433784485, -0.0761910155415535, -0.36655017733573914, -0.4100101590156555, 0.6065404415130615, 0.5329920053482056, -0.26570776104927063, -0.2372472882270813, 0.6089508533477783, -1.0844075679779053, -0.44155535101890564, 0.325421541929245, 0.3292827606201172, 0.19032146036624908, -0.31264570355415344, 0.22540244460105896, 0.10539939254522324, 0.1528077870607376, -0.5542348027229309, -0.061398882418870926, -0.15309783816337585, -0.642172634601593, -0.22760345041751862, -0.3246258795261383, -0.15593785047531128, 0.5909878015518188, -0.21071556210517883, 0.22823520004749298, -0.69124835729599, -0.4973704516887665, 0.33124005794525146, 0.18722178041934967, -0.6205775737762451, -0.20220433175563812, -0.40915676951408386, 0.6069536805152893, 0.435969740152359, -0.21639057993888855, 0.39591509103775024, -1.0034862756729126, 1.4696167707443237, -0.17472660541534424, 0.9715690016746521, 0.09300916641950607, -1.1434249877929688, 0.08159799128770828, 0.14333727955818176, -0.937298059463501, -0.14333699643611908, 0.357430636882782, 0.650907576084137, -0.03420695289969444, -0.1631416231393814, -0.22666053473949432, -0.1554628163576126, 0.3657742142677307, 0.13729225099086761, 0.13651271164417267, -0.16265533864498138, 0.45849108695983887, -0.23572076857089996, -0.7527247667312622, -0.49558693170547485, -0.12336592376232147, 1.0655452013015747, 1.13349187374115, -0.09929156303405762, 0.470603346824646, -0.20248106122016907, -0.5212502479553223, 0.20666669309139252, -0.2722979187965393, 0.8284843564033508, 0.09675674885511398, 0.3251124322414398, 0.45804497599601746, -0.77651447057724, -0.11503520607948303, -1.0248733758926392, 0.377370685338974, 0.30792343616485596, -0.014876746572554111, -0.023006433621048927, -1.2504860162734985, -0.48888158798217773 ]
{"Title": "The Effects of Metronome Frequency Differentially Affects Gait on a Treadmill and Overground in People with Parkinson\u2019s Disease", "Authors": "Wygand Madelon, Chawla Guneet, Browner Nina, Lewek Michael D", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective To determine the effect of different metronome cue frequencies on spatiotemporal gait parameters when walking overground compared to walking on a treadmill in people with Parkinson\u2019s disease Design Repeated-measures, within-subject design Setting Research laboratory Participants Twenty-one people with Parkinson\u2019s disease (Hoehn & Yahr stage 1-3) Interventions Participants walked overground and on a treadmill with and without metronome cues of 85%, 100%, and 115% of their baseline cadence for one minute each. Main Outcome Measures Gait speed, step length, and cadence Results An interaction effect between cue frequency and walking environment revealed that participants took longer steps during the 85% condition on the treadmill only. When walking overground, metronome cues of 85% and 115% of baseline cadence yielded decreases and increases, respectively, in both cadence and gait speed with no concomitant change in step length. Conclusions These data suggest that people with PD are able to alter spatiotemporal gait parameters immediately when provided the appropriate metronome cue and walking environment. We propose to target shortened step lengths by stepping to the beat of slow frequency auditory cues while walking on a treadmill, whereas the use of fast frequency cues during overground walking can facilitate faster walking speeds.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003251"}
10.1101/19008524
[ -0.10275714844465256, 0.08247870951890945, 0.8733032941818237, 0.7100495100021362, -0.20680397748947144, -0.24336324632167816, 0.09261024743318558, -0.05847552418708801, 0.09026060253381729, 0.06471233069896698, -0.16909487545490265, -0.43880388140678406, 0.19958728551864624, -0.6783710718154907, -0.29457026720046997, -0.8504690527915955, -0.1527664065361023, -0.1686190664768219, -0.6587986350059509, -0.06415486335754395, 0.3079526722431183, 0.4164814054965973, -0.29881516098976135, 0.7214334011077881, -0.01756102964282036, 0.7452607154846191, 0.15876099467277527, 0.12166029959917068, 1.172161340713501, 0.23440702259540558, -0.6626879572868347, -0.42837849259376526, 0.33118951320648193, -0.6655459403991699, -0.635373592376709, 0.006281381007283926, 1.0888597965240479, 0.21400141716003418, 0.23321209847927094, -0.16711415350437164, -0.1940094530582428, 0.7575212121009827, 0.23737438023090363, -0.5615876913070679, -0.2792654037475586, -0.3243514597415924, -0.6903200745582581, 0.1522938311100006, 0.2777799367904663, -0.26987868547439575, -0.7400408387184143, -0.0977371335029602, 0.2846332788467407, -0.048294853419065475, 0.5276170372962952, -0.09497940540313721, 0.7310873866081238, -0.047795794904232025, -0.9673092365264893, 0.16623461246490479, -0.23144038021564484, 0.19730103015899658, 0.5941552519798279, -1.311449646949768, 0.9801760315895081, 0.5200312733650208, -0.08982469886541367, -0.7227028012275696, 0.16330888867378235, -0.038916751742362976, -0.0014110322808846831, -0.13248778879642487, -0.11090274900197983, -0.31884974241256714, -0.11485737562179565, -0.34339645504951477, 0.29611682891845703, -0.30658072233200073, 0.036942917853593826, -0.1656106859445572, -0.33231106400489807, 0.5605876445770264, -0.04228364676237106, 0.33080676198005676, -0.2776084542274475, -0.18755467236042023, 0.7052633762359619, 0.5007950663566589, 0.5856592655181885, 0.5846787691116333, 0.023458335548639297, 0.6691188812255859, 0.13176241517066956, 0.40436604619026184, -0.23590868711471558, 0.9103246331214905, -0.5921589136123657, -0.35455238819122314, -0.0055124107748270035, -0.800636887550354, 0.18903471529483795, -0.034283462911844254, -0.704451322555542, 1.2288060188293457, -0.3825700581073761, 0.251956582069397, 0.7619025707244873, -0.2986219823360443, -0.5303044319152832, 0.1366175413131714, 0.3522762358188629, -0.03682319074869156, -0.7282646298408508, 0.2746986448764801, 0.38055700063705444, 0.2730151414871216, -0.17513874173164368, 0.6693999767303467, -0.6216366291046143, -0.09152621030807495, 0.15135224163532257, -0.4140514135360718, 0.7280736565589905, -0.1647644340991974, -0.17815861105918884, 0.2268078327178955, -0.1797506958246231, 0.1267842948436737, -0.9602979421615601, -0.00692641269415617, -0.5133242011070251, -0.5864717960357666, -0.05999622121453285, 0.6333761811256409, -0.1884896606206894, -0.09148593991994858, 0.3530123233795166, 0.5072384476661682, 0.11007525771856308, -0.8904582262039185, -0.585930585861206, -0.13483281433582306, -0.8838434219360352, 1.2221834659576416, 0.46593812108039856, 1.024130940437317, -0.5700296759605408, -1.385677456855774, -0.9577124714851379, -0.31371045112609863, -0.05563722550868988, 0.24169670045375824, 0.3289247155189514, -0.27968233823776245, 0.18745677173137665, 0.6355190873146057, -0.2028740644454956, 0.6754552721977234, -0.7299246191978455, 0.27813971042633057, -0.04057285934686661, 0.0011916179209947586, 0.2795839309692383, 0.5231322646141052, -0.669741153717041, 0.8943606019020081, 0.294384628534317, 0.35833704471588135, -0.2666747570037842, -0.3570168614387512, 0.7707172632217407, -0.006311291363090277, -0.3674415647983551, 0.08649932593107224, -0.6883316040039062, 0.9315151572227478, 0.9795842170715332, 0.49516230821609497, 0.35475099086761475, 0.04630892351269722, -0.2984195053577423, -0.2363130748271942, 0.4047977924346924, 0.6080819964408875, -0.13717088103294373, 0.46673622727394104, -0.2875007688999176, -0.44909948110580444, -0.5044727921485901, -0.5052908658981323, -0.5094351172447205, 0.4236469268798828, -0.8832783102989197, 0.7719404101371765, -0.23219458758831024, 0.2724962830543518, -0.8190723061561584, -0.09847065806388855, 0.04849503934383392, -0.18255603313446045, -0.31605225801467896, 1.3595975637435913, -0.31107813119888306, -0.26039692759513855, -0.2408810257911682, 0.7997251749038696, -0.2934592068195343, 0.3398178815841675, -0.5425814390182495, -0.22036468982696533, 0.5569419264793396, 0.015298241749405861, -0.1483696550130844, 0.8083193302154541, 0.5951219201087952, 0.2834516167640686, -0.008898812346160412, 0.27983760833740234, -0.5231887698173523, 0.3555871546268463, -0.06542375683784485, -0.5952485203742981, 0.6848702430725098, 0.411545991897583, -0.07074917107820511, 0.8114346861839294, 0.5679883360862732, 0.6506625413894653, 0.1487768441438675, -0.4103991389274597, 0.38645389676094055, 0.7998058795928955, -0.31705397367477417, 0.7227885127067566, 0.2150396853685379, 0.49823635816574097, 0.23598475754261017, 0.17358186841011047, -0.08688036352396011, 0.37086471915245056, 0.28711196780204773, 0.3205283582210541, 0.6483248472213745, 0.5064904689788818, -0.09832990169525146, 0.4775363504886627, -0.7207222580909729, 0.14890015125274658, -0.09675154089927673, 0.5211847424507141, -0.6213659048080444, 0.43859943747520447, 0.6423949599266052, 0.17009127140045166, -1.1746160984039307, -0.5473626255989075, 0.7440822124481201, 0.09915148466825485, -0.17113876342773438, -0.76483154296875, 0.24337254464626312, 0.1196223795413971, -0.04777081683278084, -0.2158663272857666, 0.8656319379806519, 1.0335652828216553, 0.634697437286377, 0.7213729619979858, 0.1284518539905548, 0.0723787248134613, -0.8577447533607483, -1.3743962049484253, -1.2319203615188599, -0.7522467374801636, -0.7436631917953491, -0.2376382201910019, 0.3015734851360321, -0.4315633773803711, 0.30467405915260315, -0.12280380725860596, 0.13450874388217926, 0.00636466545984149, 0.02625112049281597, 0.6655524969100952, 0.934390127658844, 0.6870748996734619, -0.7418618202209473, 0.02373613230884075, 0.08499796688556671, 0.3000964820384979, -0.27989816665649414, 0.11203323304653168, -0.17658871412277222, -1.1760674715042114, 0.5756939649581909, -1.4178460836410522, 0.16249603033065796, -0.7781518697738647, 0.11061519384384155, -0.1885627657175064, 0.16114650666713715, 0.3178839385509491, 0.0864722952246666, -0.042981941252946854, -0.7045978307723999, 0.5719642043113708, 0.5182375907897949, -0.02226383052766323, 0.2985730469226837, 0.6038984656333923, -0.01545772422105074, 0.640575647354126, -0.011202668771147728, 0.2737448811531067, -0.9043684601783752, 0.0042776367627084255, 0.4611077904701233, -0.033262189477682114, 0.42616161704063416, -1.1953083276748657, -0.7791935801506042, 0.0526876226067543, -0.003613125067204237, -0.04476244002580643, -0.04490111023187637, -0.03645238280296326, -0.004663127474486828, -1.3003883361816406, -0.1659216731786728, -0.48055794835090637, -0.9110530614852905, 0.7668894529342651, -0.23875927925109863, 0.2653447985649109, 0.19791531562805176, 0.7268255949020386, -0.6146236062049866, 0.3408419191837311, 0.3468751013278961, 0.8880292773246765, -0.1598212718963623, 0.30822044610977173, -0.2880387306213379, 0.1812020093202591, 0.03631340339779854, 0.17361612617969513, 0.33876925706863403, -0.1583639681339264, -0.3055359423160553, -0.4349827766418457, -0.15915556252002716, 0.1875154823064804, 0.8301777839660645, -0.1584545075893402, 0.07966103404760361, 0.33575326204299927, 0.27843788266181946, -0.5519039034843445, 0.43333280086517334, -0.23822914063930511, -0.47139936685562134, -0.04780207946896553, 0.08402616530656815, 0.032429326325654984, -0.6022957563400269, -0.5785359740257263, 0.3414836525917053, 0.16269636154174805, 0.5227513909339905, -0.42814910411834717, 0.45112186670303345, 0.4798870086669922, -0.525191068649292, 0.3064635694026947, -0.5432884693145752, 0.2769719362258911, 0.7893584370613098, 0.05074688419699669, 1.4549355506896973, -0.6841447353363037, 0.7069557309150696, 0.34512925148010254, 0.7244518995285034, -0.03135450929403305, 0.5400139093399048, -0.03776806592941284, -0.891907274723053, 0.48241445422172546, 0.14611251652240753, 0.40664151310920715, 0.4513227939605713, 0.2502535283565521, -0.08887839317321777, 0.569307804107666, -0.8883088231086731, -0.70546954870224, 0.561398446559906, 0.613932192325592, 0.15776567161083221, 0.15672530233860016, 1.0514352321624756, -0.5488438010215759, -0.11134462803602219, 0.02222948893904686, 0.8022995591163635, -0.06361188739538193, -0.7431996464729309, 0.23574583232402802, 0.13335366547107697, -0.4062139391899109, 0.10673081129789352, -0.17375613749027252, -0.06669626384973526, 0.1077856793999672, 0.5799375176429749, 0.10765279084444046, -0.767990231513977, -0.2544982135295868, -0.5892912149429321, 0.4755741357803345, -0.0995975211262703, 0.9579014182090759, -0.6979184150695801, 0.13052360713481903, -0.003623562166467309, -0.6696118116378784, 0.16859927773475647, -0.40886324644088745, -0.15133345127105713, 0.649078905582428, -0.44632428884506226, -1.2664456367492676, -0.8217542171478271, 0.002898761536926031, -0.515180766582489, -0.4829585552215576, 0.5817499160766602, -0.2043015956878662, 0.4440445303916931, 0.024265343323349953, -0.3478143811225891, -0.21314841508865356, -0.2156151533126831, 0.158873051404953, 0.2938907742500305, -0.044815223664045334, 1.2944103479385376, 0.41725122928619385, 1.0329256057739258, -0.3586042821407318, 0.646098792552948, -0.9580947160720825, 0.4702272117137909, -0.44532132148742676, -0.4063110649585724, -0.24440263211727142, -0.9697121381759644, 0.09666354954242706, -0.19329866766929626, -0.3093419075012207, -0.30663594603538513, -0.13269928097724915, 0.3590240776538849, -0.16085335612297058, -0.26269102096557617, 0.750808596611023, -0.8549989461898804, 0.2055584043264389, 0.7191096544265747, -0.232220858335495, 0.17775455117225647, -0.13744552433490753, -0.14050865173339844, -0.6754828691482544, 0.7279526591300964, 0.7017887830734253, 0.8969380259513855, -0.25620678067207336, -0.7192785739898682, -0.4021170735359192, -0.26110026240348816, 0.547748327255249, -0.7932142615318298, -0.6713001728057861, -0.4284002482891083, -0.30661505460739136, -0.7051622867584229, -0.26385924220085144, -0.9942392110824585, 0.5405896902084351, 0.1177862137556076, -0.8249870538711548, -0.23803435266017914, -0.18302664160728455, -0.27962854504585266, -0.6231859922409058, -0.7409394979476929, 0.20309583842754364, 0.044069282710552216, -0.26074427366256714, 0.8209092617034912, -0.7656081914901733, -0.7925254702568054, 0.058892134577035904, 0.314083069562912, -0.8707859516143799, -0.7942078709602356, -0.003335618879646063, -0.30202504992485046, -0.2618088722229004, -0.4972447454929352, -0.29879114031791687, -0.5157981514930725, -0.7211990356445312, -0.017749251797795296, -0.1729137897491455, 0.33574873208999634, 0.4195886552333832, -0.2067880630493164, 0.8939214944839478, 0.5743541717529297, -0.545351505279541, 0.02403334528207779, 0.34761083126068115, 0.17303360998630524, 0.13434894382953644, -0.4940387010574341, -0.9727559089660645, 0.07012040168046951, -0.7367003560066223, 0.060251783579587936, -0.8381891846656799, 0.09894818812608719, -0.4355684518814087, -0.016640575602650642, -0.219960555434227, 0.30903056263923645, 0.06059540808200836, 0.062183015048503876, -0.3365400731563568, -0.6110565662384033, 0.04569121077656746, -0.6079791784286499, -0.3333226442337036, -0.5822927951812744, -0.11784257739782333, 0.21369479596614838, 0.3372734487056732, -0.07401280105113983, -0.2863105237483978, 0.3003735840320587, -0.03491584584116936, 0.4259313642978668, 0.71816086769104, -0.5691813826560974, -0.13781005144119263, 0.058732517063617706, 0.46908509731292725, -0.1709657609462738, -0.2027701884508133, -0.7378669381141663, 0.7431169748306274, -0.39573338627815247, 0.06181648373603821, 0.0047011906281113625, -0.27814075350761414, 0.035018157213926315, 0.2150958925485611, 1.1803534030914307, -0.5926822423934937, 0.6530712246894836, -0.0606594979763031, -0.3958926796913147, -0.10199480503797531, 0.9329169392585754, -0.7810166478157043, -0.3875827491283417, -0.8474482297897339, -0.8074252605438232, 0.47121530771255493, -0.5098000764846802, -0.03412450850009918, 0.9275100231170654, 0.5110954642295837, -0.3071509301662445, -0.4606000781059265, 0.639336347579956, 0.8887647986412048, -0.6497594714164734, -0.5257066488265991, -0.14620310068130493, -0.20748141407966614, 0.21818825602531433, -0.8675366640090942, 0.20615097880363464, -0.010586039163172245, -0.2754161059856415, -0.25593990087509155, -0.5293031930923462, -0.5274807810783386, -0.020190518349409103, 0.15809522569179535, 0.967587947845459, 0.31082963943481445, -0.07457694411277771, -0.22625723481178284, -0.08431825786828995, -0.06950421631336212, 0.5145800709724426, -0.4791010022163391, 0.4759463965892792, 0.6498414874076843, -0.4706294536590576, -0.30971288681030273, 0.7585663199424744, -0.4353284537792206, -0.1856221854686737, -0.16292908787727356, -0.05979197099804878, 0.5606741309165955, -0.8345765471458435, 0.8179112076759338, 0.26964864134788513, -0.3267464339733124, -0.22360481321811676, 0.6565079689025879, -0.1623825877904892, -0.542945384979248, -0.1588604599237442, -0.5308148264884949, 0.3875998556613922, -0.13684335350990295, -0.07356932014226913, -0.12540173530578613, 0.6849706768989563, -0.16162653267383575, -0.6472402811050415, -0.45675504207611084, -0.5139958262443542, 0.07602423429489136, 1.1078367233276367, -0.37627112865448, 0.0632534772157669, -0.5615220665931702, 1.0243569612503052, -0.3343871533870697, 0.13069933652877808, -0.08402451872825623, -0.2910090982913971, -0.5208519697189331, -0.2913258969783783, -0.1820719987154007, 0.30017414689064026, 0.12301908433437347, -0.39084088802337646, 0.9871501922607422, 0.3183063566684723, -0.8224508166313171, -0.487751305103302, -0.009575511328876019, 0.48582977056503296, 0.48823150992393494, 0.10783492028713226, 0.22365514934062958, 0.9198678135871887, -0.5570766925811768, -0.035785675048828125, 0.1346699595451355, -0.3341691493988037, -0.6504749655723572, -0.8896760940551758, 0.017571186646819115, -0.9761435985565186, 0.13037995994091034, 1.1546064615249634, -0.35939741134643555, -0.3790004849433899, -0.41109129786491394, 1.0537116527557373, -0.16608649492263794, -0.19260181486606598, -0.22588284313678741, -0.042499952018260956, -0.8258865475654602, -0.6690428256988525, -0.10511261224746704, -1.208712100982666, 0.3371935784816742, 0.889625608921051, 0.13020169734954834, -0.6006671190261841, -0.15540988743305206, 0.5585062503814697, -0.36037707328796387, 0.3533110022544861, -0.7117379903793335, -0.43269434571266174, 0.1412266194820404, 0.5063321590423584, 0.4012013375759125, -0.563723623752594, 1.1529860496520996, -0.18358922004699707, 0.5733274817466736, 0.5443651676177979, 0.41979146003723145, -0.1970902532339096, -0.0006177639006637037, 0.22456035017967224, -1.030672550201416, -0.06930802017450333, -0.32749149203300476, 0.5665299296379089, -1.0449497699737549, -0.8167997598648071, -0.572695255279541, 0.07542651891708374, 0.37436285614967346, 0.32990753650665283, 0.08406643569469452, 0.8155128955841064, 0.3893442749977112, 0.14407777786254883, -0.09517146646976471, 0.771308958530426, 0.6722525954246521, -0.09032408893108368, 0.30904343724250793, -0.3165932893753052, 0.27160927653312683, -0.9184449315071106, -0.10517609119415283, 0.2584020793437958, -0.08197016268968582, 0.6233827471733093, -0.06243611499667168, 0.21906621754169464, -0.18168124556541443, 0.3753511607646942, -0.20016509294509888, 0.17350761592388153, 0.5573633313179016, 0.47370874881744385, -0.4775083661079407, -0.10937138646841049, -0.8200231194496155, -0.11631233990192413, -0.6082540154457092, -0.7578908205032349, 0.7295792698860168, -0.5191957950592041, -0.28472527861595154, -0.7926937341690063, -0.6631209254264832, 0.744599461555481, -0.25754284858703613, 0.8855496644973755, -0.5384275913238525, 0.6596513986587524, 0.46354424953460693, -0.12586280703544617, -0.08669887483119965, -0.07092531770467758, 0.1229717954993248, -0.09890777617692947, -0.44770628213882446, -0.4008164703845978, 0.8287582397460938, 0.4849547743797302, 0.47556278109550476, -0.33501094579696655, -0.35399648547172546, 0.03865397348999977, 0.27593982219696045, -0.5979899168014526, -0.4394150972366333, -0.1078946590423584, -0.8763104677200317, -0.12825600802898407, -0.984682023525238, -0.36343035101890564, -0.09041240811347961, 0.08796625584363937, 0.24037261307239532, -0.716262698173523, 0.20389865338802338, -0.2460441291332245, 1.005393624305725, -0.5826771259307861, 0.4584399163722992, -0.03498110920190811, -0.07151759415864944, -0.47848087549209595, -0.2874193787574768, 0.39119112491607666, 0.3406737744808197, 0.5387514233589172, -0.12837228178977966, -0.39173534512519836, -0.004991780500859022, 1.0860350131988525, 0.6003828048706055, 0.06386242806911469, 0.6931130886077881, 0.3252086639404297, 0.19600172340869904, 0.12419743090867996, -0.7420376539230347, 0.38572362065315247, 0.22626350820064545, -0.42003872990608215, 0.07666042447090149, 0.319595605134964, 0.3866903483867645, 0.1313513219356537, -0.35215020179748535, 0.12813009321689606, -0.43103769421577454, -0.11436333507299423, 0.5182762742042542, 0.09690810739994049, 1.0250388383865356, 0.2670919597148895, -0.06531495600938797, 0.2775901257991791, 0.6656642556190491, 0.03602733090519905, 0.937471330165863, 0.906844973564148, -0.9805980920791626, -0.3368026316165924, -0.3754894733428955, 0.32003679871559143, 0.6235563158988953, -0.0944865420460701, 0.18532663583755493, -0.5043267011642456, -0.30971425771713257, 0.8520492911338806, -0.2539460062980652, -0.6849332451820374, 0.24897243082523346, 0.17308823764324188, -0.13075728714466095, 0.062068041414022446, -0.17738103866577148, -0.21297071874141693, 0.3460858464241028, 0.9662426710128784, -0.8076509833335876, 0.6831142902374268, -0.0428735576570034, 0.09941329061985016, 0.7420194149017334, 0.2591628432273865, -0.10685423016548157, -0.42723408341407776, 0.21375444531440735, 0.4475298821926117, 0.07842352241277695, 0.46728765964508057, -0.1972595900297165, -0.4813750088214874, -0.09669534116983414, -0.04894886538386345, 0.2255609780550003, 0.09896241873502731, -0.15559357404708862, -0.045761432498693466, 0.48919686675071716, -0.30900415778160095, -0.41130223870277405, -1.049018383026123, -0.4200693666934967, -0.19056349992752075, 0.08792034536600113, -0.04823893681168556, 0.2278270125389099, 0.49644050002098083, -0.25981447100639343, 0.08950988203287125, -0.7016310095787048, -0.6774578094482422, -0.2022077888250351, -0.23827679455280304, 0.5392578840255737, 0.15133678913116455, -0.34512093663215637, -0.592472493648529, -1.3647162914276123, -0.39797860383987427, -0.6073626279830933, -0.22684861719608307, -0.5803573131561279, -0.39072829484939575, 0.25565606355667114, 0.6866045594215393, 0.5483498573303223, 0.18327023088932037, -0.2448766827583313, -0.13162674009799957, 0.7792969942092896, -0.1630062758922577, -0.19913092255592346, 0.2828141450881958, 0.26795822381973267, 0.006033172365278006, 0.18474268913269043, -0.007148501463234425, -0.14499936997890472, 0.11404868215322495, -0.8210540413856506, -0.012156586162745953, 0.015021637082099915, -0.6782853007316589, 0.7747755646705627, 0.7727084755897522, -0.34257227182388306, 0.19175326824188232, -0.9328064918518066, -0.12605760991573334, -0.22767551243305206, 0.5803996324539185, -0.20823702216148376, 0.04013172909617424, 0.6559794545173645, -0.056174617260694504, 0.6822336316108704, -0.7162793278694153, 4.1392669677734375, 1.2857108116149902, 0.9258084297180176, -0.5422804355621338, 0.8108532428741455, 0.7697308659553528, 1.1988911628723145, 0.05349944531917572, -0.08046707510948181, -0.7074862718582153, 0.12354599684476852, -0.006974648684263229, 0.11258639395236969, -0.40464040637016296, 0.5070856213569641, 0.5452525019645691, -1.2576707601547241, 0.15239498019218445, -0.5422682762145996, -0.6034432053565979, -0.5801916122436523, -0.011708078905940056, 0.23779472708702087, -0.2484685480594635, 0.3284980356693268, -0.3776973783969879, 0.13333158195018768, -0.15000683069229126, -0.496715247631073, -0.7864991426467896, 0.018505169078707695, -0.7754868268966675, 0.002015609061345458, -1.0445683002471924, -0.312968373298645, 0.2803376615047455, -0.4583131670951843, -0.36452558636665344, 0.04209315776824951, 0.24620403349399567, -0.29067784547805786, -0.47647160291671753, 0.00815839134156704, -0.5110292434692383, -0.08065496385097504, 0.5144561529159546, -0.6056537628173828, 0.6256087422370911, 0.9425864219665527, -0.023553937673568726, 0.974060595035553, -1.4421218633651733, 0.710440993309021, -0.19956646859645844, -0.6251593232154846, -0.5156554579734802, -0.6053119897842407, -1.2704910039901733, 0.613444983959198, 1.0261297225952148, 0.291929692029953, 0.32906463742256165, -0.7289761304855347, 0.1987500935792923, 0.4281316101551056, 0.9362528920173645, 0.3599543571472168, 0.8417990803718567, -0.03044191747903824, -0.5579423904418945, 0.28171631693840027, -0.6003361940383911, -0.11845629662275314, 0.08523663133382797, 1.0240219831466675, 0.3665800392627716, -0.01225971058011055, 0.904091477394104, -0.4760456383228302, -0.5926039218902588, 0.45988228917121887, 0.2836637794971466, 0.04681238532066345, -1.003081202507019, -0.02509162761271, 0.7933972477912903, -0.6397779583930969, -0.06773948669433594, -0.7112516164779663, 0.8641969561576843, 0.2892971336841583, 0.446792870759964, 0.1968122124671936, 0.06934861838817596, -0.6577494740486145 ]
{"Title": "Genome-wide investigation of DNA methylation in congenital adrenal hyperplasia", "Authors": "Karlsson Leif, Barbaro Michela, Ewing Ewoud, Gomez-Cabrero David, Lajic Svetlana", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Patients with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) are at risk of long-term cognitive and metabolic sequelae with some of the effects being attributed to the chronic glucocorticoid treatment that they receive. This study investigates genome-wide DNA methylation in patients with CAH to determine whether there is evidence for epigenomic reprogramming as well as any relationship to patient outcome. Methods We analysed CD4+ T cell DNA from 28 patients with CAH (mean age=18.5 \u00b16.5 years [y]) and 37 population controls (mean age=17.0 \u00b16.1 y) with the Infinium-HumanMethylation450 BeadChip array to measure genome-wide locus-specific DNA methylation levels. Effects of CAH, phenotype and CYP21A2 genotype on methylation were investigated as well as the association between differentially methylated CpGs, glucose homeostasis, blood lipid profile and cognitive functions. In addition, we report data on a small cohort of 11 patients (mean age=19.1, \u00b16.0 y) with CAH who were treated prenatally with dexamethasone (DEX) in addition to postnatal glucocorticoid treatment. Results We identified two CpGs to be associated with patient phenotype: cg18486102 (located in the FAIM2 gene; rho=0.58, adjusted p=0.027) and cg02404636 (located in the SFI1 gene; rho=0.58, adjusted p=0.038). cg02404636 was also associated with genotype (rho=0.59, adjusted p=0.024). Higher levels of serum C-peptide was also observed in patients with CAH (p=0.044). Additionally, levels of C-peptide and HbA1c were positively correlated with patient phenotype (p=0.044 and p=0.034) and genotype (p=0.044 and p=0.033), respectively. No significant association was found between FAIM2 methylation and cognitive or metabolic outcome. However, SFI1 TSS methylation was associated with fasting plasma HDL cholesterol levels (p=0.035). Conclusion In conclusion, higher methylation levels in CpG sites covering FAIM2 and SFI1 were associated with disease severity. Hypermethylation in these genes may have implications for long-term cognitive and metabolic outcome in patients with CAH.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008524"}
10.1101/2019.12.12.19014647
[ 0.60836261510849, 0.3828508257865906, 0.3994878828525543, -0.08112286776304245, 0.11043600738048553, -0.46729061007499695, 0.14221245050430298, -0.5736905932426453, 0.19726385176181793, 0.9627219438552856, 0.7206127047538757, -0.6090706586837769, 0.8005902171134949, -0.6173245906829834, 0.10626707226037979, -0.525722861289978, -0.31621500849723816, 0.14839784801006317, -0.08887913078069687, -0.7459850311279297, 0.22857129573822021, 0.699150025844574, -1.2416220903396606, -0.5487890839576721, -0.8088453412055969, 0.2365245670080185, 0.35398411750793457, 0.20564210414886475, 0.8583333492279053, 0.4590572118759155, -0.43276169896125793, -0.43730655312538147, 0.9673334360122681, -0.20422236621379852, -0.12960806488990784, 0.010185792110860348, 0.8176957368850708, -0.6932125091552734, -0.5782601833343506, -0.35342979431152344, 0.6120140552520752, 0.29372304677963257, 0.5359547734260559, -1.3816096782684326, -0.08817486464977264, -0.2730330526828766, 0.025036146864295006, 0.3472888171672821, -0.16486264765262604, -0.409305214881897, -0.175214022397995, 0.8117088675498962, -0.19854995608329773, -0.5816519260406494, -0.43015754222869873, 0.21679916977882385, 0.08794141560792923, -0.2309270203113556, -0.7439290881156921, -0.557258665561676, 0.252479612827301, -0.03531898185610771, 0.46981045603752136, -0.7908247709274292, 0.7063627243041992, 0.6200385689735413, -0.41169267892837524, 0.38408902287483215, 0.283576637506485, -0.2624072730541229, -0.4975517690181732, 0.1043088510632515, -0.13008634746074677, -0.8349680304527283, -0.2526256740093231, -0.46846306324005127, 0.15170599520206451, -0.3361007273197174, -0.19776751101016998, 0.21913273632526398, -0.07244817167520523, 0.02260853536427021, -0.16392526030540466, 0.4560357928276062, 0.0752958431839943, 0.05426167696714401, 1.1687498092651367, 0.45214423537254333, -0.3046483099460602, -0.2660719156265259, 0.15650208294391632, 0.38381797075271606, -0.07917346060276031, 0.14247345924377441, 0.3356635570526123, 0.49904927611351013, -0.3441369831562042, 0.607134222984314, 0.2987419664859772, -0.007714667357504368, 0.2645556926727295, 1.158042550086975, -0.6709591150283813, 0.9953716993331909, -0.7277753353118896, 0.539982795715332, 0.34140926599502563, -0.6941938996315002, 0.022987516596913338, -0.93767911195755, 0.39042288064956665, 0.10401362925767899, -0.7408320903778076, 0.08277559280395508, 0.034260109066963196, 0.3802814781665802, 0.48123252391815186, 0.6454916000366211, 0.24784912168979645, -0.21863698959350586, -0.28475815057754517, -0.18683303892612457, 0.48811274766921997, -0.39374130964279175, 0.047669727355241776, -0.04498109593987465, 0.3845627009868622, 0.7350484728813171, -0.5398980379104614, -0.7464455962181091, 0.14868968725204468, -0.11456470936536789, -0.3798847794532776, 0.5232711434364319, -0.1920626163482666, -0.16008947789669037, -0.15867123007774353, -0.03823813423514366, 0.37170469760894775, -0.06124760955572128, 0.16042010486125946, 0.13948802649974823, -0.40335625410079956, 1.3238576650619507, -0.31075406074523926, -0.0785655826330185, 0.15379191935062408, -0.9490000009536743, -0.3959641754627228, -0.423759400844574, -0.07881978899240494, 0.48314201831817627, -0.2346174716949463, 0.029271457344293594, -0.43258509039878845, 0.8837875723838806, -0.21979108452796936, 0.0322997160255909, -0.5392071008682251, -0.19456970691680908, 0.27204254269599915, 0.40745505690574646, -0.1160779669880867, 0.581427812576294, 0.23247705399990082, 0.5752531290054321, -0.03822153061628342, 0.04664799943566322, -0.010913453996181488, -0.6885829567909241, 0.5529282689094543, -0.4614291489124298, -0.22406987845897675, -0.2637777030467987, 0.2840735912322998, 0.9071706533432007, 1.1010990142822266, 0.038416482508182526, 0.06301946938037872, 0.13646680116653442, -0.3677438497543335, -0.8121508955955505, 0.26551011204719543, 0.6222443580627441, 0.10654179751873016, 0.5625579357147217, -0.12807290256023407, -0.6490746736526489, 0.17545586824417114, -0.41558995842933655, 0.2120203673839569, 0.29096516966819763, -0.4195656180381775, 0.31567296385765076, -0.4328944683074951, -0.36755678057670593, -0.04494227468967438, 0.03276495262980461, 0.46939215064048767, -0.9521996378898621, -0.2692519426345825, 0.2808273434638977, -0.3836449384689331, -0.011837318539619446, -0.41854679584503174, 0.4530144929885864, 0.1451341062784195, 0.3131265342235565, -1.1484748125076294, 0.5003451108932495, -0.10292447358369827, 0.045266032218933105, 0.37795373797416687, -0.630731463432312, 0.7641143202781677, -0.5071761012077332, 0.10392951220273972, -0.17101964354515076, 0.007134428713470697, -0.1397896260023117, -0.1810368299484253, 0.22446244955062866, 0.3107736110687256, 0.295818954706192, 0.2476915717124939, -0.1824694275856018, 0.02146269381046295, 0.1307545006275177, -0.07824866473674774, 0.0700712725520134, -0.09404204040765762, 0.8165672421455383, -0.010921704582870007, 0.27165862917900085, 0.9195993542671204, 0.44654861092567444, 0.39367687702178955, 0.1242385134100914, 0.38153010606765747, 0.1116599440574646, -0.08987590670585632, 0.3567894399166107, 0.724786102771759, 0.4910770058631897, 0.3339000940322876, 0.8211225271224976, -0.2645256221294403, -0.019151195883750916, -0.05452693998813629, 0.06724335253238678, -0.3898005187511444, 1.2908724546432495, 0.9470811486244202, 0.5405197143554688, -1.020174264907837, -0.013494995422661304, 0.6565999388694763, 0.492939293384552, -0.32718175649642944, -0.08584821969270706, -0.3165121078491211, 0.02289898507297039, -0.21461476385593414, 0.2052830308675766, 0.6132495403289795, 0.6079478859901428, 0.27177920937538147, -0.13370570540428162, -0.05071008950471878, -0.4499906897544861, -1.4101215600967407, -0.3399783670902252, -1.7438514232635498, -0.5255380272865295, -0.6345165967941284, -0.5300297141075134, 0.05709032714366913, -0.3525615930557251, 0.3918763995170593, -0.4290138781070709, -0.40722763538360596, -0.7188397645950317, -0.21651476621627808, 0.0806770846247673, 0.22147896885871887, 0.3095349669456482, -0.9743545055389404, -0.13967059552669525, -0.021079279482364655, 0.36380860209465027, -0.5887419581413269, -0.38627123832702637, -0.35154202580451965, 0.1387552171945572, 0.18979698419570923, -0.6763274073600769, 0.44902896881103516, 0.2228710949420929, -0.4812217056751251, 0.1601637452840805, 0.4809717833995819, -0.14204861223697662, 0.11102968454360962, 0.1387648731470108, -0.05200755596160889, 0.4615223705768585, -0.03042476624250412, -0.05574866756796837, 1.1540507078170776, 0.5242718458175659, -0.5031704306602478, 0.6129554510116577, -0.2016206532716751, 0.013378851115703583, -0.25911033153533936, 0.5518008470535278, 0.5536124110221863, -0.06070123240351677, 0.11787938326597214, -0.7299416065216064, -0.39113330841064453, 0.14814600348472595, -0.31835129857063293, -0.9056276082992554, 0.14161138236522675, 0.25155606865882874, 0.11130433529615402, -1.1415618658065796, -0.18607699871063232, -0.9380950331687927, -1.4981868267059326, -0.5959938764572144, -0.002005717484280467, 0.7809618711471558, 0.1597825288772583, 0.14049173891544342, -0.3814815878868103, 0.505961537361145, 0.06536848098039627, 0.26056918501853943, 0.21665199100971222, -1.0451236963272095, -0.5204299688339233, 0.6021260619163513, 0.7492163777351379, 0.2584438920021057, -0.1638825535774231, -0.04758942127227783, 0.28889578580856323, -0.15478850901126862, -0.2314153015613556, -0.24162903428077698, 0.6553512215614319, 0.07497846335172653, -0.3409440815448761, 0.10950799286365509, -0.3855067491531372, -0.047745827585458755, 0.42221134901046753, 0.15955892205238342, 0.802985429763794, 0.7151793241500854, -0.20688264071941376, 0.08107208460569382, -0.44191035628318787, -0.22383926808834076, -0.4012022316455841, 0.2943761348724365, 0.4206124544143677, -0.28737038373947144, -0.01377864833921194, -0.4855519235134125, -0.1268669217824936, 0.2045944482088089, 0.11205422878265381, -0.3548605144023895, 0.6101096868515015, 0.0874110758304596, 1.3661367893218994, -0.897982656955719, -0.16479012370109558, 0.08887645602226257, 0.19653445482254028, 0.5487434267997742, -0.13903482258319855, 0.37213924527168274, -0.02677207998931408, -0.7531238794326782, -0.13830655813217163, -0.33590856194496155, -0.04817263409495354, 0.27473315596580505, -0.5078555345535278, 0.8794564604759216, -0.40127992630004883, -0.20499444007873535, -0.5818154215812683, -0.05811966210603714, 0.20481307804584503, -0.0689670667052269, 0.5228997468948364, -0.2240883708000183, 0.3736151158809662, 0.5428494811058044, 0.25197261571884155, -0.2222556322813034, -0.446938157081604, 0.15460115671157837, -0.4819730520248413, -0.5965449213981628, -0.33484798669815063, -0.007250583730638027, 0.49616125226020813, -0.27818164229393005, 0.022061586380004883, 0.3119628131389618, -0.08833818137645721, -0.35472384095191956, -0.37318217754364014, 0.3241807818412781, 0.4822802245616913, -0.3728201687335968, -1.3013105392456055, 0.4614948034286499, 0.31809115409851074, -0.8176090121269226, -0.13373534381389618, -0.5208728909492493, 0.09834320843219757, 0.514846682548523, -0.4885590970516205, -0.5458652973175049, 0.19346314668655396, -0.4851473569869995, 0.17985498905181885, 0.2915042042732239, 0.6440569758415222, -0.3879365921020508, 0.4364103376865387, -0.34755179286003113, -0.5146629810333252, 0.2778174877166748, -0.765643298625946, -0.14642725884914398, 0.23965439200401306, 0.0376974456012249, 1.550323724746704, 0.4965835213661194, -0.1625015288591385, -0.10868771374225616, 0.30577391386032104, -0.7298892736434937, 0.7073566913604736, -0.5501559972763062, -0.21212515234947205, 0.13672274351119995, 0.10517437011003494, -0.2883700132369995, 0.5663455128669739, 0.027820764109492302, 0.08149734139442444, -0.08733811974525452, 0.6384352445602417, -0.679238498210907, -0.8307695388793945, 0.5645169019699097, 0.22839489579200745, 0.6224767565727234, 0.6977517008781433, -0.8635680675506592, -0.3186003267765045, 0.0625510886311531, 0.36394789814949036, -0.6995146870613098, 0.47259560227394104, 0.13850842416286469, 0.07241669297218323, 0.25485605001449585, -0.5896503329277039, -0.29860371351242065, -0.5045385360717773, 0.3465401530265808, -0.5066997408866882, -0.6525180339813232, 0.20461755990982056, -0.1271388679742813, -0.396383672952652, 0.3340131938457489, -0.7918170094490051, 0.576273500919342, -0.004019932821393013, -0.7968003749847412, 0.06300626695156097, 0.024905594065785408, -0.31906142830848694, 0.07318609952926636, -0.7569994330406189, -0.151986226439476, 0.2845328748226166, -0.23059257864952087, 0.19771692156791687, -0.7457942366600037, -0.44107601046562195, 0.3448106348514557, -0.022274356335401535, -0.2991865873336792, -0.2571985125541687, 0.38189128041267395, -0.010655506514012814, -0.30048370361328125, -1.0032421350479126, -0.10714001208543777, -0.2174183428287506, -0.46144822239875793, 0.09800580143928528, -0.3989768624305725, 0.10600490868091583, 0.3587662875652313, -0.9327810406684875, 0.9584749937057495, -0.06753406673669815, -1.1726880073547363, -0.7410134077072144, 0.51734858751297, 0.6085765361785889, -0.09803210198879242, 0.11126541346311569, -0.43099552392959595, -0.08890724927186966, -0.7582380771636963, 0.5442224740982056, -0.6178616881370544, -0.33360201120376587, -0.4894251227378845, -0.14856907725334167, 0.0684804618358612, 0.6702865958213806, 0.15241536498069763, -0.002320571569725871, -0.27884218096733093, -0.6290095448493958, -0.09714841842651367, -0.45194941759109497, -0.3008066713809967, -0.38255390524864197, -0.479889839887619, -0.3020760715007782, 0.3310949504375458, 0.5918673276901245, -0.7415677309036255, 0.09313849359750748, 0.34464502334594727, 0.087432861328125, 0.7121235728263855, -0.4375079274177551, -0.7850812077522278, 0.4136429727077484, -0.37447983026504517, 0.11090607941150665, 0.34725886583328247, -0.7287015914916992, 0.7781134247779846, -0.3729698657989502, 0.08868932723999023, 0.0564773827791214, -0.3450620770454407, 0.3797505497932434, -0.7645390629768372, 0.8398889303207397, -0.3570411503314972, 0.5936282873153687, -0.07477379590272903, -0.018032563850283623, -0.04915960878133774, 0.29814445972442627, -0.7247292399406433, -0.7726647853851318, -0.3576343059539795, -1.0353076457977295, 0.2016722857952118, -0.4336201846599579, -0.08861327171325684, -0.2040196806192398, -0.387192040681839, -0.16111202538013458, -0.3182409703731537, 0.3850938677787781, 0.6139505505561829, 0.26646876335144043, -0.12470664829015732, -0.014297823421657085, 0.00419151084497571, 0.10403319448232651, 0.05567514896392822, -0.21035470068454742, -0.2942776083946228, -0.14898017048835754, -0.5336658954620361, -0.047063346952199936, -0.8564724922180176, -0.4208802580833435, 0.21117980778217316, 0.14816313982009888, -0.3833717405796051, 0.42723456025123596, -0.11856977641582489, -0.3912370502948761, -0.5281612873077393, 0.6347761750221252, -0.29298272728919983, 0.030487826094031334, 0.8123089671134949, 0.23843897879123688, -0.07976699620485306, 0.387800395488739, -0.08267930895090103, -0.2876396179199219, -0.23310266435146332, 0.4613078534603119, 0.4793764054775238, -0.9426345825195312, -0.05234013870358467, 0.6702437400817871, -0.530251681804657, -0.1311003565788269, 0.5227025151252747, -0.283895343542099, -0.021645644679665565, -0.3806980550289154, -0.35396161675453186, 0.02143545262515545, -0.4601375460624695, 0.2748875319957733, -0.12897680699825287, 0.16717301309108734, -0.42108815908432007, -0.24324531853199005, 0.7578715682029724, -0.7438298463821411, 0.0727389007806778, 0.9321012496948242, -0.3646899461746216, 0.07431382685899734, -0.4832444190979004, -0.6829940676689148, 0.256710022687912, 0.08230504393577576, 0.6038334369659424, 0.3628867268562317, 0.08343980461359024, 0.8621422648429871, 0.28986886143684387, 0.3643140494823456, -0.358853280544281, -0.1903712898492813, 0.5958046317100525, 0.5191214084625244, -0.7138634324073792, -0.8301207423210144, 0.8761735558509827, 0.35113587975502014, 0.3664122521877289, 0.10336121916770935, 0.11712903529405594, 0.4329947531223297, 0.7234640717506409, 0.4316197335720062, -0.37233486771583557, -0.39526569843292236, -0.9185989499092102, -0.2806980311870575, 0.10258974134922028, -0.33442556858062744, -0.8037524223327637, 0.09674013406038284, 0.11152815818786621, -0.5359575152397156, 0.07936418801546097, 1.2204371690750122, -0.3022644817829132, -0.12584884464740753, -0.5960038900375366, 0.5265169739723206, -0.7080102562904358, -0.8629289269447327, -0.05818209424614906, 0.005766981281340122, 0.6250359416007996, 1.3079733848571777, -0.7377482652664185, -0.6845592856407166, 0.3619053363800049, -0.17443343997001648, -0.5744155645370483, 0.4915759861469269, -0.5381640791893005, -0.1135571226477623, -0.4844677150249481, 0.2715565860271454, 0.023656107485294342, -0.31530362367630005, 0.810211718082428, -0.8074845671653748, 0.2701624631881714, 0.928887665271759, 0.2575119733810425, -0.5060070753097534, 0.27984628081321716, 0.3712003529071808, -0.5982805490493774, 0.30930495262145996, 0.2192133218050003, 0.111365407705307, -1.0642931461334229, 0.14039206504821777, 0.013217782601714134, -0.3494543731212616, 0.6304827332496643, -0.09671014547348022, 0.419251024723053, 0.5806456804275513, 0.05463092401623726, 0.10073473304510117, 0.09233763068914413, 0.810191810131073, 0.09500279277563095, -0.4294236898422241, 0.8434197306632996, 0.35953301191329956, 0.3277300000190735, -0.908565878868103, 0.8026168346405029, 1.0672138929367065, -0.24268464744091034, -0.041858457028865814, 0.22373534739017487, 0.11848089098930359, 0.39397841691970825, -0.43846574425697327, 0.19687215983867645, 0.5196412205696106, 0.3732244074344635, 0.7246440052986145, 0.3907132148742676, -0.47994378209114075, -0.8299996256828308, 0.14982229471206665, -1.012389898300171, -1.013126254081726, 0.6453405618667603, -0.5290568470954895, 0.07214735448360443, -0.8616078495979309, -0.6741929650306702, 0.8328020572662354, 0.5531978011131287, 0.34848836064338684, -0.11933737993240356, 0.501920759677887, 0.15372365713119507, 0.7678065299987793, -0.3454683721065521, -0.041267286986112595, 0.057149432599544525, -0.023302944377064705, -0.18662895262241364, -0.8740800619125366, 0.4913499355316162, -0.2943132817745209, 0.33723360300064087, -0.1664251685142517, -0.44391578435897827, 1.02168607711792, 0.6422586441040039, -0.4554201066493988, -0.3820941746234894, 0.4040633738040924, -1.6158993244171143, 0.6080026030540466, -0.15899339318275452, 0.6182653307914734, -0.013958403840661049, 0.663203775882721, 0.46573370695114136, -0.4158378541469574, -0.8518567681312561, -0.548023521900177, 0.6997044682502747, -1.1629769802093506, 0.5633141398429871, 0.14036497473716736, 0.7007982730865479, -0.09741634875535965, -0.3834865093231201, 0.7620560526847839, -0.02881520241498947, -0.02144700475037098, -0.10436756163835526, -0.21983787417411804, 0.15231356024742126, 0.9779070019721985, 0.23554900288581848, 0.1794227808713913, 0.6497505307197571, -0.32674703001976013, 0.532268226146698, 0.13354654610157013, -0.43638309836387634, 0.6228128671646118, 0.04917959123849869, 0.1871696561574936, 0.05605734884738922, 0.28783994913101196, 0.04383815824985504, 0.6042267084121704, -0.6453557014465332, 0.223802387714386, -0.5206860303878784, -0.8489550352096558, -0.44042354822158813, 0.23298294842243195, 0.39838799834251404, 0.10980334132909775, 0.5462408065795898, 0.07969749718904495, 0.2758413553237915, 0.6206072568893433, -0.3223266899585724, 0.6959989070892334, -0.2700329124927521, -0.3890950381755829, -0.20910224318504333, 0.36965009570121765, -0.3412444591522217, -0.24643796682357788, 0.8192129731178284, -0.5382257699966431, -0.04081936180591583, 0.45831823348999023, 0.18730244040489197, -0.46015921235084534, 0.8365145325660706, -0.04846500605344772, 0.05663110688328743, -0.38352665305137634, 0.1941559612751007, -0.7400621175765991, -0.0700887143611908, 0.6200808882713318, -1.0515629053115845, -0.05307045951485634, 0.43122154474258423, -0.31895017623901367, 0.3603839874267578, 0.8905389308929443, 0.30827632546424866, 0.36792659759521484, 1.0600224733352661, 0.792758584022522, -0.09419069439172745, 0.24056994915008545, 0.030848534777760506, -0.7704269886016846, 0.542776346206665, -0.3818875551223755, 0.3634994626045227, 1.065191626548767, -0.7260718941688538, -0.008500018157064915, -0.0377870574593544, -0.36480778455734253, -0.6845762729644775, -0.4859846234321594, -0.2822132110595703, 0.2861715853214264, -0.23080532252788544, -0.32552698254585266, 0.1289970725774765, 0.3096640706062317, 0.10910002887248993, -0.0036711059510707855, -0.3259734809398651, -0.4413903057575226, -0.05515143647789955, -0.5497638583183289, 0.6410504579544067, -0.36653926968574524, -0.13929179310798645, -0.3752191662788391, -1.1249594688415527, 0.06618762016296387, 0.40513065457344055, -0.025902485474944115, -0.18088717758655548, 0.37752556800842285, 0.9013402462005615, 0.08870822191238403, 0.2972054183483124, -0.1561882048845291, 0.11125804483890533, 0.03220817819237709, 0.7196313142776489, 0.2842545211315155, 0.9290642142295837, 0.7855913043022156, 0.11330144107341766, 0.22720083594322205, 0.35623911023139954, -0.24147753417491913, -0.06235070526599884, -0.23093366622924805, 0.025746077299118042, 0.21268655359745026, -0.7120557427406311, -0.2765817642211914, 0.5089127421379089, 0.964181125164032, -0.023852594196796417, -0.4326956272125244, -0.6487037539482117, 0.05975278466939926, -0.5299021005630493, 1.0204330682754517, -0.2273338884115219, 0.48091262578964233, -0.20092791318893433, -0.46476951241493225, -0.434969425201416, -0.5390923023223877, 4.3460211753845215, 0.9171854257583618, 0.45232734084129333, 0.7219148874282837, 0.637371838092804, -0.17164790630340576, 0.64815354347229, -0.33848631381988525, 0.13904264569282532, 0.2473156750202179, 0.0702764168381691, -0.5060021877288818, 0.11132663488388062, 0.08678890764713287, 0.3329930007457733, -0.14485067129135132, -1.1486504077911377, -0.3565969169139862, 0.5659717917442322, -0.7712754607200623, -0.648042619228363, 0.6677817106246948, -0.19641970098018646, -0.2865947484970093, 0.13164286315441132, -0.21570752561092377, -0.5952373147010803, 0.26759830117225647, -0.4485042989253998, -0.35428547859191895, -0.026110254228115082, -0.2439395785331726, -0.09411200881004333, -0.4129583537578583, 0.23385043442249298, 0.07749366015195847, 0.46388527750968933, -0.01921992003917694, -0.3510906398296356, 0.11603546142578125, 0.13168679177761078, -0.26828742027282715, 0.2033587098121643, -0.021008796989917755, -0.5365584492683411, 0.017013859003782272, -0.423831045627594, -0.7142513990402222, 0.611215353012085, -0.5308259129524231, 0.9296022653579712, -1.212285041809082, -0.027712460607290268, 0.026276711374521255, -0.6969872713088989, -0.4916374981403351, -1.12396240234375, -0.8950532078742981, 0.48577195405960083, 0.5914685726165771, 0.2943836450576782, 0.08346053957939148, -0.2159704715013504, -0.14564011991024017, -0.7850710153579712, 0.06669781357049942, -0.09953738749027252, -0.31009721755981445, 0.17493076622486115, -0.18346136808395386, 0.3466898202896118, 0.2044905126094818, 0.19614018499851227, 0.4810086190700531, 0.25793251395225525, 0.21787258982658386, -0.6749845147132874, 1.1560685634613037, -0.6601534485816956, -0.6249231696128845, 0.3830474019050598, 0.19654345512390137, 0.3163493573665619, -0.25059252977371216, 0.5288805365562439, 0.0386776477098465, -1.0713777542114258, 0.281447172164917, -0.7846047878265381, 0.6921111345291138, 0.08803940564393997, -0.14861485362052917, 0.1134457215666771, -0.14049866795539856, 0.044247642159461975 ]
{"Title": "Retrospective Assessment of Deep Neural Networks for Skin Tumor Diagnosis", "Authors": "Han Seung Seog, Moon Ik Jun, Na Jung-Im, Kim Myoung Shin, Park Gyeong Hun, Kim Seong Hwan, Kim Kiwon, Lee Ju Hee, Chang Sung Eun", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT BACKGROUND The aim of this study was to validate the performance of algorithm ( http://rcnn.modelderm.com ) for the diagnosis of benign and malignant skin tumors. METHODS With external validation dataset (43 disorders; 40,331 clinical images from 10,426 patients; January 1, 2008 \u2013 March 31, 2019), we compared the prediction of algorithm with the clinical diagnosis of 65 attending physicians at the time of biopsy request. RESULTS For binary-task classification of determining malignancy, the AUC of the algorithm was 0.863(95% CI 0.852-0.875) with unprocessed clinical photographs. The sensitivity/specificity of the algorithm at the predefined high-sensitivity and high-specificity threshold were 79.1%(76.9-81.4)/76.9%(76.1-77.8) and 62.7%(59.9- 65.5)/90.0%(89.4-90.6), respectively. The sensitivity/specificity calculated by the clinical diagnosis of attending physicians were 88.1%/83.8%(Top-3) and 70.2%/95.6%(Top-1), which were superior to those of algorithm. For multi-task classification, the mean Top-1,2,3 accuracies of the algorithm were 42.6\u00b120.7%, 56.1\u00b122.8%, 61.9\u00b122.9%, and those of clinical diagnosis were 65.4\u00b117.7%, 73.9\u00b116.6%, 74.7\u00b116.6%, respectively. In the reader test with images from 30-patients batches, the sensitivity / specificity of the algorithm at the predefined threshold were 66.9%\u00b130.2% / 87.4%\u00b116.5%. The sensitivity / specificity derived from the first diagnosis of 44 the participants were 65.8%\u00b133.3% / 85.7%\u00b111.0%, which were comparable with those of the algorithm (Wilcoxon signed-rank test; P=0.61 / 0.097). CONCLUSIONS Our algorithm could diagnose skin tumors at dermatologist-level when diagnosis was made solely with photographs, demonstrating its potential as a mass screening tool in telemedicine setting. However, due to limited data relevancy, the performance was inferior to that of actual medical examination. Clinical information should be integrated with imaging information to achieve more accurate predictions.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.12.19014647"}
10.1101/19003269
[ -0.08239617198705673, 0.8333289623260498, -0.5291658639907837, 0.7160918712615967, -0.7488323450088501, 0.07627137005329132, -0.20661115646362305, 0.1604139655828476, 0.09872838109731674, 1.2099517583847046, -0.36382362246513367, -0.1516931653022766, -0.16387709975242615, -0.7532655000686646, -0.13690227270126343, 0.3950692415237427, -0.7624320983886719, -0.4129050076007843, -0.7243593335151672, 0.25205644965171814, 0.3413858413696289, 0.2657957375049591, -0.8444312810897827, -0.34283527731895447, -0.605551540851593, 0.7860804796218872, -0.3959827125072479, -0.3964698612689972, 0.7890934348106384, 0.5688337683677673, 0.9990820288658142, -0.6819224953651428, 0.7744829654693604, -0.7671602964401245, -0.30420365929603577, -0.4812880754470825, 0.7822632789611816, -0.7969953417778015, 0.1442946493625641, -0.3983113467693329, 0.3417568504810333, -0.3630201518535614, 0.02086642012000084, -0.7069668173789978, -0.6113970279693604, -0.6307359337806702, -0.5753540396690369, -0.4863094985485077, -0.1552067995071411, -0.431214839220047, -0.10694058239459991, 0.15874743461608887, 0.11186467856168747, 0.5826547145843506, -0.445497065782547, 0.5555384755134583, -0.2370719015598297, -0.4518945515155792, -0.47615572810173035, 0.013849458657205105, 0.15186530351638794, 0.013978742063045502, 0.45791351795196533, -1.7733821868896484, 0.3265748620033264, 0.8513506650924683, 0.07184242457151413, -0.5382484793663025, -1.056821346282959, -0.8897694945335388, -0.8615821003913879, 0.23179277777671814, 0.3706911504268646, -0.5397645831108093, -0.06792592257261276, 0.8796725869178772, -0.3041464388370514, -0.11116085201501846, -0.07711485773324966, 0.1486951857805252, 0.05731600522994995, 0.2960928976535797, -0.25664016604423523, 0.4943532943725586, -0.5416852831840515, 0.17452214658260345, -0.27024731040000916, -0.5126357078552246, 0.2359440177679062, -0.42134833335876465, 0.7273265719413757, 0.9088541269302368, 0.310269296169281, -0.13032646477222443, 0.24620312452316284, 0.5444920659065247, -0.45924484729766846, 0.48234227299690247, 0.7925912141799927, -0.22645311057567596, -0.013879155740141869, 0.7857998013496399, -0.25361332297325134, 0.9925895929336548, -0.15584221482276917, 0.10068713128566742, 0.660936713218689, -0.10320545732975006, -0.7873127460479736, -1.2268890142440796, 0.12746869027614594, 0.12393385171890259, -0.07286164909601212, 0.4181188941001892, -0.1576860398054123, 0.4794827401638031, 0.21964377164840698, 0.5978400111198425, 0.04698958247900009, 0.8963086009025574, 0.2951384484767914, -0.4398765563964844, 0.33411291241645813, -0.6008005738258362, 0.5518895983695984, -0.5303462743759155, -0.16234390437602997, 0.4993995428085327, -0.2753346860408783, 0.12283898890018463, -0.17693594098091125, 0.2453809380531311, 0.36818352341651917, 0.7185726165771484, -0.1291579306125641, 0.2319781333208084, -0.26238295435905457, 0.5390467047691345, -0.1368006467819214, -0.34901928901672363, -0.3400774598121643, 0.4744354784488678, -0.4597291648387909, 1.145789384841919, 0.10672534257173538, 0.6460141539573669, -0.6647465825080872, -0.4065236449241638, 0.13497519493103027, -0.5591750741004944, -0.5272580981254578, 0.7076489329338074, -0.2450350522994995, -0.047479309141635895, 0.2624787390232086, -0.33410516381263733, -0.3782467544078827, 0.909920871257782, 0.0840630754828453, 0.4089715778827667, 0.211024209856987, 0.4119417667388916, -0.8471789956092834, -0.01714513823390007, -0.8381345272064209, 0.4585834741592407, -0.4899602234363556, -0.06436224281787872, 0.7336907386779785, -0.7550197243690491, 0.06339876353740692, 0.885129451751709, 0.002834907965734601, -0.7923892736434937, -0.15637542307376862, 0.6485040783882141, 1.047964096069336, 0.556524932384491, 0.22454281151294708, -0.012097811326384544, -0.29981857538223267, -0.27092665433883667, 0.45918965339660645, 0.30999159812927246, -0.03887264430522919, -0.40450820326805115, -0.9986847639083862, -0.27748340368270874, -0.5310167074203491, 0.7704117298126221, -0.1187022477388382, 1.0364327430725098, -0.7121478915214539, 0.22458992898464203, 0.11359967291355133, -0.2293776124715805, 0.4527551829814911, 0.35766685009002686, -0.26899561285972595, -0.7562932968139648, -0.7047813534736633, 0.6861867904663086, -0.37222176790237427, 0.4623048007488251, -0.6335873007774353, 0.9105995297431946, 0.4265678822994232, 0.4285942614078522, -0.23204471170902252, 0.9231871962547302, 0.5169636011123657, 0.017061734572052956, -0.09132911264896393, 0.15495367348194122, 0.608839750289917, -0.463137149810791, -0.06941082328557968, -0.3866787850856781, -0.22283753752708435, 0.22949504852294922, 0.405708909034729, -0.30323633551597595, 0.6015145778656006, -0.1718066930770874, 0.4883881211280823, -0.11883954703807831, 0.8422536849975586, 0.32795146107673645, 0.03172822296619415, 0.30320483446121216, -0.07583555579185486, 0.6015687584877014, 0.1787748783826828, 0.38824430108070374, 0.698375940322876, 0.701617956161499, 0.43747612833976746, 0.44598716497421265, 0.9974389672279358, -0.4092605412006378, 0.38652491569519043, 0.44260162115097046, 1.0260425806045532, 0.5357338190078735, -0.4225037395954132, 0.7461109161376953, 0.3834502398967743, 0.2703445255756378, 0.1276324987411499, -0.7442685961723328, -1.3123911619186401, 0.7524623274803162, -0.159959077835083, -0.027896316722035408, -0.3556094169616699, 0.4671504497528076, 1.3042820692062378, 0.3230642080307007, 0.32677921652793884, -1.2055158615112305, 0.6695988178253174, 0.38279977440834045, 0.1244533509016037, 0.39983534812927246, 0.3011484444141388, 0.8210230469703674, 0.3336679935455322, 0.7580991983413696, 0.2962580919265747, -0.09251103550195694, -0.5918827652931213, -1.0306288003921509, -0.9105712175369263, -0.5798108577728271, -0.5979348421096802, -0.8102589845657349, -0.18827584385871887, -0.8900613784790039, 0.7640967965126038, 0.4724830389022827, 0.15118999779224396, -1.054424524307251, 0.5780763626098633, 0.6517224907875061, 0.3597636818885803, 0.25271132588386536, -1.0067425966262817, 0.37635213136672974, -0.6378933787345886, 0.2736954689025879, 0.31872081756591797, -0.6949381232261658, -0.6910760402679443, -0.2944108545780182, 0.35086601972579956, -0.27440759539604187, -0.045443493872880936, 0.490999698638916, -0.4901568591594696, 0.10510033369064331, 0.07022380828857422, 0.6783463954925537, -0.07688045501708984, 0.34776026010513306, -1.098908543586731, 0.5657529234886169, -0.03890669718384743, -0.13792167603969574, 0.6465293169021606, 0.4094504415988922, -0.26241979002952576, 0.6205071806907654, 0.2923511862754822, 0.03358922526240349, -0.828908383846283, 0.14645707607269287, 1.2535487413406372, -0.631603479385376, 0.10540186613798141, -0.36325475573539734, -0.6711066961288452, -0.4654582440853119, -0.11211468279361725, -0.24381989240646362, -0.7889072299003601, -0.05954625457525253, -0.16360890865325928, -1.0765358209609985, 0.18759597837924957, -0.8118757605552673, -0.8534353971481323, 0.3449077010154724, -0.17084909975528717, 0.6998960375785828, 0.8221583366394043, -0.14224125444889069, -0.04513464495539665, 0.04564271494746208, -0.039148200303316116, 0.2339090257883072, -0.08758481591939926, 0.15448148548603058, -0.28236714005470276, 0.539437472820282, -0.4529821276664734, 0.4683384597301483, 0.13229171931743622, -0.3213922083377838, -0.29541274905204773, -0.13555477559566498, -0.7089710235595703, -0.02139718271791935, 0.34808918833732605, -0.7451653480529785, 0.618428111076355, 0.21711085736751556, -0.4933595657348633, -0.4667719602584839, 0.04335872828960419, 0.7538762092590332, 0.008390110917389393, 0.11277318000793457, 0.37789326906204224, 0.0012377930106595159, -0.461325079202652, -0.13989920914173126, 0.37865883111953735, 0.228593111038208, 0.5453711152076721, -0.5978237986564636, 0.41277241706848145, 0.12562590837478638, -0.43730905652046204, 0.38412725925445557, -0.5391976237297058, 0.22401244938373566, 1.4354077577590942, 0.24933257699012756, 1.1099528074264526, -1.3114392757415771, 0.3083992302417755, 0.21061499416828156, 0.6086573004722595, 0.13800853490829468, -0.0021586555521935225, -0.20301415026187897, -1.0320910215377808, -0.23578967154026031, 0.49688994884490967, -0.09065482020378113, -0.287958025932312, 0.5727180242538452, -0.03361549228429794, -0.34145939350128174, -0.475631982088089, 0.09895693510770798, 0.6132791638374329, 0.8798860907554626, -0.006749134045094252, 0.11396019905805588, 0.8061434626579285, 0.13074015080928802, 0.5547518134117126, -0.04383024200797081, 0.47927525639533997, -0.024962270632386208, -0.30895745754241943, -0.3729974031448364, 0.0592883825302124, 0.48850712180137634, -0.6249015927314758, -0.5096603035926819, -0.7202353477478027, -0.028500227257609367, 0.4665130376815796, 0.7615610957145691, -0.33870863914489746, -0.11511358618736267, -0.5507365465164185, -0.5575875043869019, -0.08882156014442444, 0.6226499080657959, -1.026566982269287, 0.20920053124427795, 0.6554008722305298, 0.1264653503894806, -0.07891664654016495, -0.8284880518913269, 0.4355699419975281, 0.8709743618965149, -0.4602278470993042, -0.623653769493103, -0.09158391505479813, 0.5037931799888611, -0.7794515490531921, 0.33793482184410095, 0.4919935464859009, -0.684837818145752, 0.21237722039222717, -0.05314541980624199, -0.06853321939706802, -0.06680922955274582, -0.4372105002403259, -0.05716102197766304, 0.4660724699497223, 0.007336406037211418, 0.09218208491802216, 0.2199246734380722, 0.7483565211296082, -0.05399973690509796, 1.0092978477478027, -1.103583812713623, 0.22800371050834656, -0.428522527217865, -0.08312638849020004, -0.34814453125, -0.1288163661956787, -0.41105392575263977, -0.36554354429244995, -0.27170345187187195, -0.3032432198524475, -0.6221039295196533, -0.12881432473659515, 0.2708277404308319, -0.10217959433794022, 0.4045414328575134, -0.5831024646759033, 0.09574954956769943, 1.042697787284851, 0.274170458316803, 0.2166764736175537, -0.5836582779884338, -0.14829732477664948, -0.49963900446891785, -0.04908662289381027, -0.0309559665620327, -0.40039536356925964, -0.6198486685752869, -0.3771473467350006, 0.1539258509874344, -0.613265335559845, 0.026011977344751358, -0.1604277491569519, 0.5514391660690308, -0.4715135395526886, -0.5807809233665466, -0.44287553429603577, -0.4185091257095337, -0.5390530824661255, 0.5398954749107361, 0.19479282200336456, -0.3734184503555298, 0.31746530532836914, -0.40977051854133606, -0.2632269263267517, -0.5484756827354431, -0.8377975821495056, 0.9128995537757874, 0.08341804891824722, 0.18465299904346466, 0.958127498626709, -1.3419735431671143, -0.5924303531646729, 0.7642867565155029, 0.9191897511482239, -0.7834001183509827, -0.06653197109699249, -0.47395169734954834, -0.456556499004364, -0.7271406650543213, -0.23698963224887848, 0.1779310703277588, -0.15232908725738525, 0.608004629611969, 0.8096100091934204, -0.09608647972345352, 0.270072877407074, -0.35881519317626953, -0.8682498335838318, 0.5493905544281006, 0.10728514939546585, -0.6847885251045227, -0.489582896232605, 0.5385410785675049, -0.10695633292198181, 0.20472727715969086, -0.2023485004901886, -0.014524216763675213, -0.4965779185295105, -0.5597116947174072, 0.9298279285430908, -0.6999446749687195, 0.16328170895576477, -0.6853493452072144, -0.3159743845462799, -0.12727537751197815, 0.19033287465572357, 0.1306307017803192, -0.6194472908973694, -0.38672158122062683, -0.22273889183998108, 0.30065450072288513, -1.2949442863464355, -0.23646512627601624, 0.04399842396378517, 0.06502856314182281, 0.5166693329811096, 0.48199763894081116, 0.11966833472251892, -0.4810835123062134, 0.5340606570243835, -0.11345832049846649, 0.658467710018158, -0.11959991604089737, -0.4614182710647583, -0.779184103012085, 0.4894212484359741, 0.4731743037700653, -0.05343185365200043, -0.09587160497903824, 0.4731874167919159, 0.58066725730896, -0.6010099649429321, 0.5027877688407898, -0.26674264669418335, 0.13565316796302795, 0.23294776678085327, -0.3530004024505615, 0.9726906418800354, -0.7839785814285278, -0.3301352858543396, 0.01581895537674427, 0.4523468315601349, -0.3207385540008545, -0.07973401248455048, -0.7240509390830994, -0.4907243847846985, -0.9656028151512146, -1.1231701374053955, -0.2565482258796692, 0.2914813756942749, -0.09087967127561569, 0.43813830614089966, -0.008120126090943813, 0.2893843352794647, -0.5875300168991089, 0.4560633897781372, 0.9061493873596191, -0.39578935503959656, -0.2580377757549286, -0.41950127482414246, 0.20304712653160095, 0.8252899050712585, 0.072573721408844, -0.36572206020355225, -0.21129487454891205, -0.017595695331692696, -0.24025177955627441, -0.5293676853179932, -1.033656120300293, -0.1681821346282959, 0.3332439363002777, 0.8608618974685669, -0.06701440364122391, 0.18318648636341095, -0.1312609761953354, -0.16781729459762573, -0.7631649374961853, 0.9481064081192017, -0.5373167991638184, -0.04778575524687767, 0.6385216116905212, -0.4039979577064514, -0.3152689039707184, -0.3146803081035614, 0.02349783666431904, -0.6366854310035706, 0.3451980650424957, 0.21089564263820648, 0.45730164647102356, -1.1851083040237427, -0.02410000190138817, 0.5784813761711121, -0.25835272669792175, -0.36345112323760986, 0.17080824077129364, -0.5251597762107849, 0.46898123621940613, -0.42666423320770264, 0.03844570741057396, 0.9436003565788269, 0.4600580632686615, 0.2797658145427704, -0.04103410989046097, -0.5525503158569336, 0.4892967641353607, -0.5291746854782104, -0.11898614466190338, -0.8516156673431396, 0.04172532632946968, 0.5164336562156677, -0.11521125584840775, 0.1978106051683426, -0.43031957745552063, -0.018949024379253387, -0.06349074095487595, -0.2703097462654114, 0.4628260135650635, -0.7588093280792236, 0.24768485128879547, 0.45315390825271606, 0.8072840571403503, -0.7098946571350098, 0.021020149812102318, 0.5155059099197388, 1.0445979833602905, -0.04062444344162941, -0.6993389129638672, -0.5464873909950256, 0.5404745936393738, -0.14263932406902313, 0.7666598558425903, -0.7484883069992065, -0.23328956961631775, 0.5594644546508789, 0.8459069728851318, 0.021051792427897453, -0.4555904269218445, -0.8010433912277222, -0.589998185634613, -0.5244733095169067, 1.0213892459869385, -0.6922624707221985, 0.5240994095802307, 0.9236559271812439, -0.5637218356132507, -0.8007889986038208, -0.510252058506012, -0.008638972416520119, -0.5255042314529419, -0.8236322999000549, -0.8316304683685303, 0.3011809289455414, -0.9403122663497925, -0.41738414764404297, -0.45846429467201233, -0.6215000748634338, 0.06358800083398819, 0.276842325925827, -0.2696602940559387, -0.4124322533607483, -0.22947144508361816, 0.7667765617370605, -0.35162103176116943, 0.5724945664405823, 0.10607688128948212, 0.7557719945907593, 0.015528359450399876, 0.8360872268676758, 0.17792682349681854, 0.6337829828262329, 1.3182892799377441, -0.12273403257131577, 0.5092980265617371, 0.35187864303588867, -0.2079453319311142, -0.7784104943275452, 0.2035093754529953, 0.1316768079996109, -1.0195690393447876, -0.6312441825866699, -0.17349106073379517, 0.6998800039291382, -0.7623801231384277, -0.0629071593284607, -0.16464270651340485, 0.37478864192962646, -0.1549965739250183, -0.11690089851617813, -0.25244370102882385, 0.6138299703598022, 0.41790860891342163, 0.42856070399284363, -0.11393740028142929, 0.6459366083145142, -0.29769349098205566, 0.4550733268260956, 0.3078252077102661, 0.5845760107040405, -0.07910178601741791, -1.9193321466445923, 0.25632548332214355, 0.46454867720603943, -0.751775860786438, -0.2035408914089203, -0.7967847585678101, 0.007515284698456526, 0.18888449668884277, -0.2836805284023285, -0.2436615228652954, 0.3326258957386017, 0.14474135637283325, 0.07761327177286148, 0.6123088002204895, -0.3168800473213196, -0.47155722975730896, -0.5871561765670776, -1.3924195766448975, -0.662106454372406, 0.8489664793014526, -0.0266537144780159, -0.30877387523651123, -0.025352399796247482, -0.12771053612232208, 0.4051280915737152, 0.023587919771671295, 0.4515986442565918, -0.38838011026382446, 1.0071148872375488, 0.021452907472848892, 0.9433634877204895, -0.253723680973053, -0.49949610233306885, -0.12608277797698975, 0.6214548945426941, -0.6451206803321838, -0.7888246178627014, 0.5158554315567017, 0.16247546672821045, 0.7179827690124512, -0.4388880729675293, 0.043068885803222656, -0.20725791156291962, -0.11046760529279709, -0.5007960200309753, -0.4995090365409851, 0.3255913555622101, -0.13014663755893707, -0.18112465739250183, 0.05491063743829727, 0.16503149271011353, 0.10617776215076447, 0.8657802939414978, 0.12598614394664764, -0.7454345226287842, 0.22151438891887665, 0.2532006800174713, 0.4971811771392822, -0.737237274646759, 0.19272641837596893, -0.5657112002372742, 0.7941761612892151, -0.18609271943569183, -0.034462183713912964, 0.6277196407318115, 0.6678539514541626, 0.4019715189933777, 0.44874894618988037, -0.29038071632385254, 0.4462120831012726, 0.5893597602844238, 0.17232021689414978, 0.8312199711799622, 0.47464922070503235, 0.16258332133293152, -0.06944326311349869, 0.17813971638679504, -0.6443907618522644, 0.5184626579284668, 0.27208229899406433, -0.12160631269216537, 0.3630983233451843, 1.0533281564712524, 0.3385356366634369, -0.2798905074596405, -0.7215438485145569, 0.41296783089637756, 0.2879544496536255, -1.0072460174560547, -0.1170816421508789, 0.9165810346603394, 0.30282706022262573, -0.1882527768611908, 0.2365780770778656, -0.6065212488174438, 0.23072248697280884, 0.7320408821105957, -0.08526252955198288, 0.24805837869644165, 0.08932630717754364, -0.31443601846694946, -0.27543097734451294, 0.6894010305404663, 0.4660367965698242, 0.16036780178546906, 0.04782518371939659, 0.05390625447034836, 0.03502105548977852, 0.31514593958854675, -0.549767255783081, -0.569244384765625, 0.21273015439510345, 0.09951821714639664, 0.3346179723739624, 0.25870078802108765, -0.19495661556720734, -0.4670368432998657, -0.4000667929649353, 0.06613416224718094, -0.4230445325374603, -0.3677928149700165, 0.8156019449234009, -0.15910406410694122, 0.22647257149219513, 0.4331604242324829, 0.931786835193634, -0.8835305571556091, 0.697451651096344, 0.5689473748207092, -0.3298059403896332, 0.17541788518428802, 0.6640029549598694, -0.13382375240325928, -0.40733644366264343, 0.05541517958045006, 0.07920725643634796, -0.8348062038421631, -0.6206831932067871, 0.017708059400320053, 0.30483514070510864, -0.9975743293762207, -0.15052515268325806, -0.2808724641799927, 0.12373444437980652, 0.16049230098724365, -0.16630740463733673, -0.1271011084318161, 0.08526032418012619, -0.12051591277122498, -0.45701882243156433, -0.417080283164978, -0.3501264154911041, -0.11696343123912811, 0.3675875663757324, -0.7052472233772278, 0.5973132848739624, -0.4550151824951172, -0.49034684896469116, -0.33980250358581543, -0.7310529351234436, -0.28526464104652405, 0.06821651756763458, -0.4292246699333191, -0.7291435599327087, 0.15934120118618011, 0.4916917383670807, 0.4608810842037201, 0.45098400115966797, 0.4017775058746338, 0.3623508810997009, 0.3983941078186035, 0.9646774530410767, -0.25896090269088745, 0.2601824402809143, 0.07789970934391022, -0.25356191396713257, -0.2250182032585144, 0.07065790891647339, -0.03694063052535057, -0.6795225143432617, -0.1210816353559494, -0.022025374695658684, 0.2791227102279663, -0.39138075709342957, -0.6547961831092834, 0.2114112675189972, 0.018628530204296112, -0.004689295310527086, -0.09362730383872986, -1.428204894065857, -0.48239007592201233, -0.5567952990531921, 0.5942679643630981, -0.11052975058555603, -0.3515099585056305, 0.15120424330234528, -0.5522918105125427, -0.018058672547340393, -0.46263086795806885, 4.114026069641113, 1.4058343172073364, 0.061509937047958374, 0.21956340968608856, 0.39854228496551514, 0.6475829482078552, 1.028182864189148, -0.5420869588851929, -0.09467426687479019, 0.266457200050354, -0.2650422155857086, -0.10525088012218475, -0.08733952045440674, -0.43777817487716675, 0.7702012658119202, 0.5565913319587708, -0.253819078207016, -0.28072765469551086, 0.5539510846138, -1.2420709133148193, -0.532910168170929, 0.30647191405296326, 0.12150891870260239, 0.19141912460327148, -0.40191859006881714, 0.17565900087356567, 0.1574338674545288, 0.19192317128181458, -0.3868562877178192, 0.03196815401315689, -0.06285741925239563, -0.441055029630661, -0.0611722394824028, -0.3154679834842682, 0.034878939390182495, 0.4765704274177551, -0.23585177958011627, 0.42728644609451294, -0.6003416180610657, -0.39216551184654236, 0.2919973134994507, 0.24095332622528076, -0.7242617607116699, -0.11844529956579208, -0.5312415361404419, 0.5606315732002258, 0.3330319821834564, -0.14385861158370972, 0.31846845149993896, -0.7119612693786621, 1.3187627792358398, -0.29880139231681824, 0.7860510349273682, 0.27620553970336914, -0.9603636264801025, -0.014362935908138752, 0.09019987285137177, -0.9951504468917847, -0.21005626022815704, 0.415892630815506, 0.4561532139778137, -0.004733751993626356, -0.13712434470653534, -0.06246565654873848, -0.1643347442150116, 0.28151169419288635, 0.10642281174659729, -0.00852751825004816, -0.0855429396033287, 0.4040820598602295, -0.3392045199871063, -0.9070240259170532, -0.7154602408409119, -0.21618437767028809, 0.959237277507782, 1.2136828899383545, -0.10108542442321777, 0.6355130076408386, -0.42897775769233704, -0.6613553762435913, 0.4665636420249939, -0.25177913904190063, 0.8558061122894287, -0.03956642746925354, 0.3793196976184845, 0.4252146780490875, -0.741253674030304, 0.12182088196277618, -0.7370137572288513, 0.47621989250183105, 0.3376867175102234, -0.19798968732357025, 0.2155790776014328, -1.177152395248413, -0.5484908819198608 ]
{"Title": "Individuals with Parkinson\u2019s Disease Retain Spatiotemporal Gait Control With Music and Metronome Cues", "Authors": "Chawla Guneet, Wygand Madelon, Browner Nina, Lewek Michael D", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Parkinson\u2019s disease (PD) is marked by a loss of motor automaticity, resulting in decreased control of step length during gait. Rhythmic auditory cues (metronomes or music) may enhance automaticity by adjusting cadence. Both metronomes and music may offer distinct advantages, but prior attempts at quantifying their influence on spatiotemporal aspects of gait have been confounded by altered gait speeds from overground walking. We hypothesized that when gait speed is fixed, individuals with PD would experience difficulty in modifying cadence due to the concomitant requirement to alter step length, with greater changes noted with metronomes compared to music cues. Research Question Can a metronome or music promote spatiotemporal adjustments when decoupled from changes in gait speed in individuals with PD? Methods 21 participants with PD were instructed to time their steps to a metronome and music cues (at 85%, 100%, and 115% of overground cadence) during treadmill walking. We calculated cadence, cadence accuracy, and step length during each cue condition and an uncued control condition. We compared the various cue frequencies and auditory modalities. Results At fixed gait speeds, participants were able to increase and decrease cadence in response to auditory cues. Music and metronome cues produced comparable results in cadence manipulation with greater cadence errors noted at slower intended frequencies. Nevertheless, the induced cadence changes created a concomitant alteration in step length, with music and metronomes producing comparable changes. Notably, longer step lengths were induced with both music and metronome during slow frequency cueing. Significance This important change conflicts with conventional prescriptive approaches, which advocate for faster cue frequencies, if applied on a treadmill. The music and metronome cues produced comparable changes to gait, suggesting that either cue may be effective at overcoming the shortened step lengths during treadmill walking if slower frequencies are used.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003269"}
10.1101/19011049
[ -0.06535623967647552, 0.044261008501052856, 0.08097835630178452, 0.639618456363678, -1.1602511405944824, -0.511566698551178, -0.1450301855802536, -0.008493530564010143, 0.16527330875396729, 1.202692985534668, -0.6901904344558716, 0.04973294958472252, -0.11406422406435013, -0.3357016444206238, -1.0455958843231201, -0.4835633337497711, 0.09801924973726273, 0.397431343793869, -0.6134446859359741, -0.14784638583660126, 0.44157764315605164, 0.28401240706443787, -1.0658174753189087, 0.4179060161113739, -0.3617997467517853, 0.7049493193626404, -0.011176127940416336, 0.02210807055234909, 1.1246308088302612, 0.3359960615634918, -0.3158886432647705, -0.5413325428962708, 0.546125054359436, -0.9178927540779114, -0.14183981716632843, -0.8281190991401672, 1.1240806579589844, -0.08936460316181183, -0.6975419521331787, -0.9330509901046753, 0.2977471947669983, -0.16116563975811005, -0.36287081241607666, -0.264047235250473, -1.2219674587249756, -1.0023045539855957, -0.47799959778785706, 0.5824239253997803, -0.07473703473806381, 0.16198933124542236, 0.18674851953983307, 0.44693705439567566, 0.023057380691170692, -0.7090705633163452, -1.0638169050216675, -0.0636899396777153, -0.26935601234436035, -0.5270496606826782, -0.8842165470123291, 0.7443474531173706, 1.1777607202529907, -0.15480327606201172, 0.32107412815093994, -1.0902432203292847, 0.9773686528205872, 0.7082362771034241, 0.06039620563387871, -0.23762425780296326, 0.04940574988722801, -0.9772660136222839, -0.13954301178455353, 0.31245771050453186, -0.49749353528022766, -0.9785547256469727, -0.6176875829696655, -0.3465591073036194, 0.11530705541372299, -0.006867522373795509, -0.2868803143501282, -0.37503620982170105, 0.49315181374549866, 0.012044001370668411, 0.30393654108047485, -0.15187618136405945, -0.6660680770874023, 0.47190457582473755, -0.5302987098693848, 0.4719051122665405, 0.35076507925987244, 0.07968800514936447, 0.10402754694223404, 0.966223418712616, -0.07552627474069595, 0.0006701955571770668, 0.22778435051441193, 0.48440518975257874, -0.11991234868764877, 0.12835094332695007, 0.9032660722732544, -0.9591158032417297, 0.14287474751472473, 0.26768577098846436, -0.4740872383117676, 1.1873582601547241, -0.06975652277469635, 0.37028321623802185, 0.1549958437681198, 0.038808077573776245, -0.0009131289552897215, -0.4260639250278473, 0.005865258164703846, -0.6624879837036133, -0.6747761964797974, 0.11613500863313675, 0.30466166138648987, 0.30804258584976196, -0.09872604161500931, 0.855607807636261, -0.013844565488398075, -0.1370377093553543, 0.3623199760913849, -0.22068168222904205, 0.5499211549758911, -0.5626491904258728, 0.2868257761001587, -0.07915854454040527, 0.6706576943397522, 0.3420323133468628, -0.5722501873970032, -0.15286695957183838, 0.38407114148139954, -0.6977481245994568, -0.02913293056190014, -0.022189263254404068, -0.3266691565513611, -0.6348492503166199, 0.49736398458480835, 0.5927209854125977, 0.36081352829933167, -0.3140365779399872, -0.1520570069551468, 0.017507649958133698, -0.3926428258419037, 0.5445361137390137, -0.6430326104164124, 0.7137083411216736, 0.12566503882408142, -1.3616052865982056, -0.17311564087867737, -0.15751883387565613, -0.435107946395874, -0.05919342488050461, 0.12903186678886414, 0.18208366632461548, 0.27755627036094666, 0.35952141880989075, -0.12930823862552643, 0.42982909083366394, -0.5585977435112, -0.2947775721549988, -0.024443022906780243, 0.8898659348487854, 0.04932798817753792, 0.45754730701446533, -0.5133628845214844, 0.7296608090400696, 0.21014384925365448, -0.36019954085350037, 0.6295994520187378, -0.750116229057312, 0.291897177696228, -0.4421490728855133, -0.014259115792810917, 0.7012190818786621, 0.3201635777950287, 0.588209867477417, 1.219101905822754, 0.38099202513694763, 0.4271259307861328, 0.6555461287498474, -0.38242077827453613, -0.13590362668037415, 0.13086190819740295, 0.7643865942955017, 0.3880465030670166, 0.5960136651992798, -0.2320018708705902, -0.9355627298355103, 0.579585075378418, -0.13933666050434113, -0.07114268839359283, 0.2955487370491028, -0.9537171125411987, 0.5055332779884338, -0.1337617039680481, 0.6494708061218262, -0.3670707941055298, 0.38002002239227295, 0.2656703591346741, -0.8947353363037109, 0.24716976284980774, -0.12083496153354645, 0.32219043374061584, 0.3177753686904907, -0.6347407698631287, 0.26149195432662964, 0.9391539692878723, -0.21769264340400696, -0.7696314454078674, -0.10511763393878937, 0.7867677211761475, -0.529233455657959, 0.13448484241962433, 0.0027873837389051914, 1.0467528104782104, -0.7909306883811951, -0.58104407787323, 0.11673448979854584, -1.0106642246246338, 0.639941930770874, 0.2307826727628708, -0.18382513523101807, 0.7099021077156067, 0.5310003757476807, 0.4442349374294281, 0.414970725774765, -0.1274416148662567, 0.4333847463130951, -0.4803096055984497, -1.181190013885498, 0.18000318109989166, 0.5694366693496704, -0.3182316720485687, 0.9470608830451965, 0.8940589427947998, 0.007951871491968632, 0.5361695289611816, 0.3606111705303192, 0.47894614934921265, 0.20486783981323242, -0.28906187415122986, 0.7713339924812317, 0.5565165281295776, 0.348966509103775, -0.683844804763794, 0.9891741275787354, -0.5712020993232727, -0.07487582415342331, -0.1555040329694748, 0.6108159422874451, -0.06065068393945694, 0.5137824416160583, 0.35379886627197266, 0.4122609794139862, -0.3689980208873749, -0.8586078882217407, 0.6301186680793762, 0.5049527287483215, -0.6557891964912415, -0.09821686893701553, -0.10052125155925751, 0.2838708758354187, -0.12061932682991028, 0.17649802565574646, 0.922944188117981, 1.0562118291854858, -0.0835593119263649, -0.4660821259021759, 0.486268550157547, -0.5378940105438232, -0.6486190557479858, -0.3287503719329834, -0.9666683673858643, -0.22375941276550293, -0.7509241700172424, -0.1929859220981598, 0.8652031421661377, -0.2512311637401581, 0.7582334280014038, -0.06570892781019211, -0.2661629915237427, -0.24394015967845917, -0.2190869301557541, 0.41220250725746155, 0.5165475010871887, 0.1681227684020996, -0.5330949425697327, 0.14748309552669525, -0.1714189052581787, 0.24136103689670563, -0.23817890882492065, -0.23284734785556793, -0.7183773517608643, 0.28971704840660095, 0.6279097199440002, -0.22371770441532135, -0.11879827827215195, 0.11568181961774826, -0.33240583539009094, 0.13831670582294464, 0.29751577973365784, 1.0061873197555542, 0.8617902994155884, -0.20328296720981598, -0.9711248278617859, 0.7947478890419006, -0.2261553853750229, 0.22819937765598297, 0.08474630117416382, 0.24245049059391022, -0.5046515464782715, 0.2806985378265381, 0.10829905420541763, -0.004851080477237701, -0.6823529601097107, 0.4148976504802704, 0.7091610431671143, -0.15482431650161743, 0.5364797115325928, -0.4156937599182129, -0.959277868270874, 0.4770106077194214, 0.5786569118499756, -0.3935368061065674, 0.25837966799736023, 0.506558358669281, -0.1829001009464264, -1.4618077278137207, 0.2010730504989624, -1.0398300886154175, -1.2083629369735718, 0.3400948941707611, 0.02004103548824787, 0.34866493940353394, 0.3318914771080017, 0.25350767374038696, -0.3663981854915619, 0.2726641893386841, 0.38635900616645813, -0.18830104172229767, 0.4477829337120056, -0.11425944417715073, 0.2703167200088501, 0.12199656665325165, -0.27502769231796265, 0.37424802780151367, 0.3293308615684509, -0.5921894907951355, -0.5234547853469849, 0.2122776210308075, -0.32657602429389954, -0.20358097553253174, 0.13932566344738007, -0.19709888100624084, 0.11248105764389038, 0.20155459642410278, 0.5516934990882874, 0.0010540017392486334, -0.13698482513427734, 0.4420106112957001, -0.23739394545555115, 0.16483108699321747, 0.12002474069595337, 1.3982326984405518, -0.80460125207901, -1.162896990776062, -0.025125684216618538, 0.9356124401092529, 0.3727555572986603, -0.6429516077041626, 0.636317789554596, -0.18146057426929474, -0.21419823169708252, 0.01436225138604641, -0.08401037752628326, 0.2113640308380127, 0.4695495367050171, -0.171560138463974, 2.2322769165039062, -1.180647611618042, -0.1350192129611969, 0.8418498039245605, 0.3935377895832062, -0.28435567021369934, 0.9017292857170105, -0.24227340519428253, -0.7175576686859131, 0.35237669944763184, 0.2303420752286911, -0.10978055745363235, -0.48690393567085266, -0.2748979926109314, -0.5815075635910034, 0.37999460101127625, -0.4178895950317383, -0.44503405690193176, -0.2127736657857895, 0.3580537736415863, 0.26847344636917114, -0.0632130578160286, 0.347371369600296, 0.10607829689979553, 0.44900617003440857, 0.5774350166320801, 0.7732513546943665, 0.1893567144870758, -0.26978978514671326, 0.20828281342983246, -0.16281460225582123, -0.5888150334358215, -0.26731204986572266, 0.08074634522199631, -0.8825324773788452, -0.011521254666149616, -0.2135196030139923, -0.49482011795043945, -0.7693196535110474, 0.5519104599952698, -0.1135638877749443, -0.0008840205846354365, -0.11517656594514847, 0.3060580790042877, -0.3350628614425659, -0.6463671326637268, 0.16596153378486633, -0.9286361932754517, 0.1542321741580963, -0.5486226081848145, 0.23307248950004578, 0.9673645496368408, 0.11087831854820251, -0.19187183678150177, -1.0112388134002686, -0.1058138757944107, 0.46916142106056213, -0.6257097125053406, 0.04563627764582634, 0.43803054094314575, 0.7509826421737671, 0.15511038899421692, -0.0038569513708353043, -1.164392113685608, -0.32289353013038635, -0.47929275035858154, -0.42742860317230225, 0.05948898196220398, 1.026775598526001, 0.3159969449043274, 0.9209256768226624, 0.285478800535202, 0.8841144442558289, -0.9921944737434387, -0.0553213395178318, -0.9303640723228455, -0.46318721771240234, 0.25837790966033936, -0.34182921051979065, 0.6377829313278198, 0.752250075340271, -0.31613224744796753, -0.4478757381439209, -0.12766963243484497, 0.0945877954363823, -0.470162570476532, -0.2770482897758484, 0.961056649684906, -0.16420409083366394, 0.8086452484130859, 0.6903331279754639, -0.5379815697669983, -0.0880218967795372, 0.7103769183158875, -0.092508465051651, -0.5073718428611755, 0.46498575806617737, -0.38330361247062683, 0.3800073266029358, 0.2717339098453522, -0.912333607673645, -0.16871733963489532, 0.25308969616889954, 0.03883225470781326, -0.020642759278416634, -0.02146477997303009, -0.7434582114219666, -0.4381117820739746, -0.08924585580825806, -0.34088408946990967, -0.2135162353515625, 0.6593157052993774, 0.020889047533273697, -0.01840716414153576, -0.3112080693244934, 0.7174645662307739, -1.0148022174835205, -0.5227881669998169, -0.20302462577819824, -0.024888845160603523, -0.1600770652294159, -0.1110808476805687, 0.572903573513031, -0.528152346611023, -1.5570367574691772, 0.5323439836502075, 0.15294405817985535, -0.33924031257629395, -0.4327511191368103, -0.283657431602478, -0.32043907046318054, 0.09180522710084915, -0.45959725975990295, 0.7999010682106018, -1.2784579992294312, -0.2407257854938507, 0.4869324564933777, -0.599662721157074, 0.5406006574630737, 0.10200896859169006, -0.3879646062850952, 0.4901047945022583, -0.20897121727466583, -0.5932760834693909, -1.0967272520065308, -0.02086476981639862, 0.693686306476593, 0.29728156328201294, -0.4738660454750061, -0.7227556109428406, -0.6631109118461609, -0.52579665184021, -0.17782002687454224, -0.36234307289123535, 0.2631772458553314, 0.07404422760009766, 0.3626386821269989, 0.018043575808405876, 0.5028290152549744, 0.6173651814460754, 0.3022814989089966, -0.3660479784011841, -0.8361426591873169, 0.5061598420143127, 0.4364875853061676, -0.24493451416492462, -0.22529776394367218, -1.184557557106018, -0.40140751004219055, 0.07095270603895187, -0.032982487231492996, 0.18749092519283295, 0.03434747830033302, 0.7021729946136475, -0.27606165409088135, 0.38522496819496155, -0.2885858714580536, -1.1295254230499268, 0.20798726379871368, 0.8986114859580994, -0.6734392642974854, -1.2952611446380615, -1.561461329460144, 0.912527859210968, -0.592050313949585, 0.6743550300598145, -0.5530064702033997, 0.09665048122406006, -0.29258832335472107, -1.021458625793457, 0.8748089075088501, -0.498311311006546, -0.10875746607780457, 0.355001300573349, 0.4381309449672699, -0.10392465442419052, 0.3793319761753082, -0.8660176992416382, -0.6961149573326111, -0.18266110122203827, -0.9505704641342163, 0.2787487208843231, -0.35086289048194885, 0.21041011810302734, -0.13095156848430634, 0.19173721969127655, -0.13051030039787292, -0.3784870207309723, 1.208398699760437, 0.2705211639404297, -1.2836277484893799, -0.5687053799629211, -0.22584199905395508, -0.020827017724514008, 0.20885443687438965, 0.3693167269229889, 0.17938914895057678, 0.00818387046456337, -0.00788052286952734, 0.5626406669616699, 0.5689325928688049, -0.6336517333984375, -0.8053904175758362, 0.11314156651496887, 0.5502234697341919, -0.05245562270283699, -0.40746521949768066, -0.5853367447853088, -0.30818143486976624, -0.41284728050231934, 0.4003485143184662, -0.6522099375724792, 0.05385488644242287, 0.5561755895614624, 0.19425350427627563, -1.0716286897659302, 0.0005126691539771855, -0.4692603647708893, -0.02402336150407791, -0.08337811380624771, 0.5628788471221924, 0.32186999917030334, -1.1306513547897339, 0.5486252307891846, 0.9863696694374084, 0.14210189878940582, -0.4653896987438202, 0.2935797870159149, 0.3130399286746979, -0.23411600291728973, 0.3781834840774536, -0.04044465348124504, 0.10006668418645859, -0.544992983341217, 0.28763607144355774, -0.1625846028327942, 0.2884708642959595, 0.20539887249469757, -0.7299407124519348, 0.11991019546985626, -0.6074610352516174, -0.24934491515159607, 0.514208972454071, 0.1976105272769928, 0.2684074342250824, -0.1987072080373764, 0.43747445940971375, 0.4929583668708801, -0.07899312674999237, 0.22082066535949707, -0.2104605734348297, -0.4298500716686249, 0.29327356815338135, 0.9074956178665161, 0.7870823740959167, 0.09004861861467361, -0.8990160822868347, 1.228111982345581, 0.2976323068141937, -0.902838945388794, -0.2819027900695801, 0.38842350244522095, 0.9997961521148682, 0.1590745896100998, -0.35342592000961304, 0.0049787540920078754, 0.49590545892715454, 0.3423493206501007, 1.3599095344543457, 0.030218547210097313, -0.8333098292350769, -0.6394325494766235, 0.13443680107593536, 0.021188480779528618, -0.2586725354194641, -0.29975900053977966, 0.7118947505950928, -0.5336112380027771, -0.3433230519294739, -0.08973294496536255, 0.5543367862701416, 0.041494470089673996, -0.8763489127159119, -0.5585334897041321, -0.27354010939598083, -0.7860139012336731, -0.4471520781517029, 0.10316703468561172, -0.4627677798271179, 0.07354291528463364, 0.288678914308548, -0.6429211497306824, -0.5491613745689392, 0.5943870544433594, 0.0616324283182621, -0.18771860003471375, 0.4071882665157318, -0.5541778802871704, -1.0409640073776245, -0.3202211558818817, -0.015024084597826004, -0.14996576309204102, 0.2812230885028839, 0.8572556972503662, -0.6256940364837646, 0.5419638156890869, 0.011317595839500427, 0.10520032048225403, -0.34549498558044434, -0.47365447878837585, 0.710419237613678, -0.21900209784507751, -0.47331035137176514, -0.5297825932502747, 0.23146609961986542, -0.7615635991096497, -0.07106056064367294, -0.5863811373710632, 0.1263343244791031, 0.37922871112823486, -0.5917543172836304, -0.07835830003023148, -0.004446452017873526, -0.05015723407268524, -0.08296158164739609, 0.1713591367006302, 1.1263298988342285, -0.09569787979125977, 0.3026180863380432, 1.1354018449783325, 0.4863129258155823, 0.20854400098323822, -0.43952426314353943, 0.7334715723991394, 0.48072168231010437, -0.12839309871196747, 0.41281116008758545, -0.6593190431594849, 0.26998138427734375, 0.10107199102640152, -0.38728201389312744, 0.8129615783691406, 0.5618539452552795, 0.7620431184768677, 0.7339937090873718, -0.43617919087409973, 0.1841723769903183, -0.6029384136199951, -0.8458142876625061, -1.1588032245635986, -0.8504648208618164, 0.14748284220695496, -0.6088818907737732, -0.04256942495703697, -0.304324209690094, -0.6612315773963928, 0.26039329171180725, -0.20302192866802216, 0.1511201709508896, -0.4707132875919342, 0.7647216320037842, 0.5310775637626648, 1.1935381889343262, -0.32388806343078613, 0.49055215716362, 0.5295535922050476, 0.25486716628074646, -0.5411813259124756, -0.7178707122802734, 0.028853312134742737, 0.3906121253967285, 0.442045122385025, -0.3690389096736908, -0.35168203711509705, 0.5057377219200134, -0.20914621651172638, -0.7959454655647278, -0.2624273896217346, 0.26675689220428467, -1.2273997068405151, 0.05029672011733055, -0.20836490392684937, -0.25245678424835205, 0.11892350763082504, 0.21013343334197998, 0.035411760210990906, -0.38891157507896423, -0.9136775135993958, -0.4847780466079712, 0.9192080497741699, -0.8169848918914795, 0.5816847681999207, -0.10030508041381836, -0.07973549515008926, -0.19904904067516327, 0.16863518953323364, 0.9902310967445374, 0.7546542286872864, 0.45129260420799255, 0.19415345788002014, -0.3496818244457245, 0.43731042742729187, 0.7268857955932617, 0.1643597036600113, 0.20811311900615692, 0.5978389382362366, -0.3130621910095215, -0.646831214427948, -0.11916913092136383, -0.3328731954097748, 0.4437653124332428, 0.7730545401573181, 0.14684787392616272, 0.10861921310424805, 0.5446170568466187, 0.11982633918523788, 0.34102293848991394, -0.364181250333786, 0.41361093521118164, -1.0803149938583374, -0.04056376591324806, -0.19783733785152435, -0.4061799645423889, 0.9681146740913391, 0.26347073912620544, -0.19864915311336517, -0.20336247980594635, 1.167867660522461, -0.20414675772190094, -0.1951611489057541, 0.46337103843688965, -0.3725196123123169, -0.31364163756370544, -0.5667737126350403, 0.08079500496387482, -0.13308478891849518, 0.33304563164711, 0.224730983376503, 0.24829447269439697, 0.4855057895183563, 0.6346888542175293, -0.18956232070922852, -0.4997229278087616, 0.3563281297683716, -0.05173500254750252, 0.20207741856575012, -0.40068379044532776, 0.6838554739952087, -1.0191946029663086, -0.35957515239715576, 0.2888929843902588, -0.9263639450073242, 0.3479737341403961, -0.14242054522037506, 0.3371700644493103, 0.7783226370811462, 1.0427747964859009, 0.23750083148479462, -0.6622485518455505, 0.19296228885650635, 0.3975488841533661, 0.41918161511421204, 0.4374709725379944, 0.3142637014389038, -0.6912572979927063, -0.3557581603527069, -0.09390950947999954, -0.041087377816438675, 0.0488235205411911, -0.5645323395729065, -0.37372034788131714, 0.3911325931549072, -0.032717786729335785, -0.41482022404670715, -1.5956193208694458, 0.27546656131744385, 0.7517467737197876, -0.3280596137046814, 0.2934236526489258, 1.0440113544464111, 0.5356820225715637, 0.3886866271495819, -0.06977950036525726, -0.9289920330047607, -0.3455517292022705, -0.47115558385849, -0.5250217914581299, 0.9480782747268677, 0.04131091386079788, -0.2122730016708374, -0.18313555419445038, -1.1347874402999878, -0.390176385641098, -0.49325767159461975, -0.5291873812675476, -1.2128900289535522, -0.3449042737483978, 0.7695783376693726, 0.7243918776512146, 0.12263315171003342, 0.032784946262836456, -0.060461774468421936, 0.0064785960130393505, 0.09839796274900436, -0.3147956132888794, 0.7190628051757812, 0.0665927603840828, -0.08784802258014679, 0.28472548723220825, 0.21950213611125946, 0.3092814087867737, -0.18897780776023865, -0.4693951904773712, -0.974065363407135, 0.20828531682491302, 0.0167893897742033, -0.3677561283111572, 0.3013865053653717, 1.2369862794876099, -0.7401533722877502, -0.6105647087097168, -0.5781334042549133, -0.5998479723930359, -0.5144057273864746, 0.39379024505615234, -0.1481899470090866, 0.04638579487800598, 0.38309377431869507, -0.42186567187309265, 1.24952232837677, -0.6679781079292297, 3.950486898422241, 0.9458195567131042, 0.9080522060394287, -0.10412091016769409, 0.2439948171377182, 0.1668461561203003, 0.5226360559463501, -0.9571447968482971, 0.04487136751413345, 0.01782582886517048, 0.1278381198644638, 0.28872936964035034, 0.12392589449882507, -0.4084438383579254, 0.6108340620994568, 0.41784271597862244, -0.02811628021299839, -0.27161622047424316, 0.3796786665916443, -1.394246220588684, -0.6263879537582397, 0.6946076154708862, -0.6834642887115479, -0.0003592250286601484, 1.1777467727661133, -0.6933388113975525, 0.22901956737041473, -0.1302025020122528, -0.13860487937927246, -0.15851597487926483, 0.37290534377098083, 0.23560670018196106, 0.6413029432296753, -0.6963567733764648, -0.2505126893520355, 0.36540383100509644, 0.14914411306381226, -0.892320454120636, 0.289326548576355, 0.052363067865371704, 0.35326534509658813, -0.11941974610090256, 0.2312525063753128, -0.06765222549438477, -0.07907707989215851, 0.496407151222229, -0.3292091488838196, 0.03773330897092819, 0.4587503969669342, -0.22125126421451569, 0.9756858348846436, 0.030372153967618942, 0.3961322009563446, -0.20493608713150024, -1.028828740119934, -0.2583480477333069, -0.025431256741285324, -0.8060624003410339, 0.43072617053985596, 0.38908472657203674, 0.2856734097003937, 0.64191073179245, -0.4762406051158905, -0.3623853027820587, -0.48212528228759766, 0.018393417820334435, 0.6045039296150208, 0.5480983257293701, -0.4931870698928833, -0.6987534165382385, -0.31448355317115784, -0.06764073669910431, -0.08273515850305557, -0.26263120770454407, 0.17070725560188293, 1.199880599975586, -0.24583102762699127, 0.3956894278526306, -0.6229075193405151, -0.38447293639183044, 0.2831342816352844, 0.2565688192844391, -0.015269754454493523, -0.2787139415740967, 0.13634076714515686, 0.9310710430145264, -0.057478681206703186, 0.528363823890686, -1.0050328969955444, 0.8224603533744812, 0.9016061425209045, -0.37792453169822693, -0.787115752696991, -0.12900365889072418, 0.3185199499130249 ]
{"Title": "An international multicenter examination of MOG antibody assays", "Authors": "Reindl Markus, Schanda Kathrin, Woodhall Mark, Tea Fiona, Ramanathan Sudarshini, Sagen Jessica, Fryer Jim, Mills John, Teegen Bianca, Mindorf Swantje, Ritter Nora, Krummrei Ulrike, St\u00f6cker Winfried, Eggert Juliane, Flanagan Eoin P., Ramberger Melanie, Hegen Harald, Rostasy Kevin, Berger Thomas, Leite Maria Isabel, Palace Jacqueline, Irani Sarosh R., Dale Russell C., Probst Christian, Probst Monika, Brilot Fabienne, Pittock Sean, Waters Patrick", "Abstract": "Abstract Objectives To compare the reproducibility of 11 antibody assays for IgG and IgM myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein antibodies (MOG-IgG, MOG-IgM) from five international centers. Methods The following samples were analyzed: MOG-IgG clearly positive sera (n=39), MOG-IgG low positive sera (n=39), borderline negative sera (n=13), clearly negative sera (n=40), and healthy blood donors (n=30). As technical controls, 18 replicates (9 MOG-IgG positive and 9 negative) were included. All samples and controls were re-coded, aliquoted, and distributed to the five testing centers which performed the following antibody assays: five live and one fixed immunofluorescence cell-based assays (CBA-IF, five MOG-IgG, one MOG-IgM), three live flow cytometry cell-based assays (FACS-CBA, all MOG-IgG), and two enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA, both MOG-IgG). Results We found excellent agreement (96%) between the live CBAs for MOG-IgG for samples previously identified as clearly positive or negative from four different national testing centers. The agreement was lower with fixed CBA-IF (90%) and the ELISA showed no concordance with CBAs for detection of human MOG-IgG. All CBAs showed excellent inter-assay reproducibility. The agreement of MOG-IgG CBAs for borderline negative (77%) and particularly low positive (33%) samples was less good. Finally, most samples from healthy blood donors (97%) were negative for MOG-IgG in all CBAs. Conclusion Live MOG-IgG CBAs showed excellent agreement for high positive and very good agreement for negative samples at four international testing centers. Low positive samples were more frequently discordant than in similar assays for other autoantigens. Further research is needed to improve international standardization for clinical care.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19011049"}
10.1101/19000968
[ -0.3859212398529053, -0.2868022620677948, 0.13790695369243622, 0.46471357345581055, -0.554168701171875, 0.1786610335111618, -0.21573945879936218, 0.4873069226741791, -0.38501226902008057, 0.926505446434021, -0.6792394518852234, -0.9147139191627502, 0.33328044414520264, 0.07744746655225754, -0.07528647035360336, -0.08089063316583633, -0.5641378164291382, -0.2444418966770172, 0.09885399788618088, 0.013356964103877544, 0.5603713989257812, -0.06478935480117798, -0.48898550868034363, 0.3662097454071045, -0.32226526737213135, 0.695351243019104, -0.6711651086807251, 0.044903602451086044, 1.45222008228302, 0.8914631009101868, -0.16136279702186584, -0.006661752704530954, 0.1686575561761856, -0.8043545484542847, -0.18421664834022522, -0.07189517468214035, 0.3811531662940979, -0.18984417617321014, -0.9086582064628601, -0.2542881369590759, 0.29884472489356995, -0.17164123058319092, 0.4372407793998718, 0.2704714238643646, -0.35117802023887634, 0.323133260011673, -0.007957306690514088, -0.38465094566345215, -0.20570401847362518, 0.750776469707489, -0.3015136122703552, -0.26653578877449036, -0.24457907676696777, -0.7380332946777344, -0.165403351187706, -0.18693068623542786, -0.2753274738788605, -0.45551323890686035, -0.45092132687568665, 0.7422629594802856, 0.6807076930999756, 0.060613591223955154, 0.07720709592103958, -0.9027062654495239, 0.3381512463092804, 0.35527458786964417, -0.19164492189884186, -0.144341841340065, 0.07784179598093033, -0.7594590783119202, -0.39923566579818726, 0.3266719579696655, -0.9142329692840576, -0.4412325322628021, -0.1612977683544159, -0.19093064963817596, -0.12596674263477325, -0.3458706736564636, 0.0920843705534935, 0.3664209544658661, 0.13083170354366302, 0.6641882061958313, 0.905267059803009, 0.18248200416564941, -0.5616128444671631, 0.31443527340888977, -0.11717164516448975, 0.4255416691303253, 0.5689290761947632, 0.34172528982162476, 0.1031973585486412, 0.1987800896167755, -0.20037317276000977, -0.6517328023910522, -0.27898797392845154, 1.4201034307479858, -0.33551517128944397, 0.01664968766272068, -0.017176175490021706, 0.003654379164800048, 1.1118475198745728, 0.5610764026641846, -0.4700416624546051, 1.1820237636566162, -0.25925570726394653, 0.9599081873893738, 0.4495108127593994, -0.21239537000656128, -0.20393006503582, -1.1293814182281494, 0.040003884583711624, -0.5935416221618652, -0.42127615213394165, -0.3143797814846039, 0.34436777234077454, 0.08636533468961716, 0.0695418044924736, 0.4717543125152588, 0.2629835605621338, 0.7975913286209106, 0.1022731363773346, 0.28721052408218384, 1.5620886087417603, -0.06643202900886536, 0.18702077865600586, -0.06713537126779556, 0.611895740032196, 0.1977795511484146, -0.5691706538200378, -0.6033816933631897, 0.8161869049072266, -1.153938889503479, -0.44761309027671814, 0.361958384513855, -0.25328361988067627, -0.2993271052837372, -0.2918154001235962, 0.9728200435638428, 0.08771764487028122, 0.26266399025917053, 0.10430759191513062, 0.5044105052947998, -0.669169545173645, 1.2338690757751465, -0.09614551067352295, 0.462413489818573, 0.04820529371500015, -0.9155179858207703, -0.5623392462730408, -0.04894581064581871, 0.20459336042404175, -0.024822767823934555, -0.5647711753845215, 0.3826198875904083, 0.21472866833209991, 0.5896961688995361, -0.07282596826553345, -0.2924085259437561, -0.23759667575359344, -0.09661530703306198, -0.9412062168121338, -0.39108672738075256, -0.23788106441497803, -0.18236878514289856, -0.8992089033126831, 0.5685397982597351, -0.190287247300148, 0.36579829454421997, 0.7362709641456604, -0.6088978052139282, 0.9065635800361633, -0.4962925314903259, -0.3683124780654907, 0.40239179134368896, 0.5640836954116821, 0.8140954375267029, 0.672442615032196, -0.14432552456855774, -0.10383154451847076, 1.0128741264343262, 0.15511803328990936, 0.667877733707428, -0.2694438397884369, 0.7579655647277832, 0.2896265387535095, 0.5147414803504944, -0.47742101550102234, -0.444068968296051, 0.518796443939209, -0.19421614706516266, -0.5622644424438477, 0.5964401364326477, -0.483697772026062, 0.32431358098983765, -0.19917750358581543, -0.09410879015922546, -0.5870341658592224, 0.41021743416786194, -0.046242307871580124, -1.1493808031082153, -0.7597764730453491, 0.03782450035214424, 0.08913926035165787, 0.6256264448165894, 0.10429514199495316, 0.9182300567626953, 0.31902676820755005, 0.5600314140319824, -0.45086610317230225, 0.6368052959442139, 0.9376492500305176, 0.10724786669015884, -0.24173058569431305, 0.2384147346019745, 0.4480744004249573, -0.23376153409481049, -0.5386586785316467, 0.043089624494314194, -0.9506078958511353, 0.23090419173240662, -0.7550930380821228, -0.6521065831184387, 0.914816677570343, -0.12178065627813339, -0.011430012062191963, 0.18880601227283478, 0.11311621218919754, 0.41836968064308167, -0.22851087152957916, -0.18128153681755066, -0.591643214225769, 0.3593544065952301, 0.03337540104985237, 1.0875290632247925, 0.7399876117706299, -0.14553140103816986, 0.15333177149295807, 0.4113825857639313, 0.6108216643333435, 0.27330341935157776, 0.32921478152275085, 0.4904189705848694, -0.06837035715579987, 0.5358613729476929, -0.8167737722396851, 0.7218274474143982, -0.41265350580215454, 0.10825920104980469, -0.10424712300300598, 0.1582702100276947, -0.12662319839000702, 0.33889710903167725, 0.6634339094161987, 0.2480889856815338, -1.1593507528305054, -0.5386645197868347, 0.35002395510673523, 0.29822641611099243, -0.328668475151062, -0.4209515452384949, -0.38205763697624207, 0.0015599267790094018, 0.08881306648254395, 0.3282512426376343, 0.8286857008934021, 0.5715779662132263, -0.36215999722480774, 0.6154008507728577, 0.5911132097244263, -0.22846902906894684, -0.9160945415496826, -0.3784785270690918, -0.8873353600502014, -0.691559910774231, -0.5206943154335022, 0.6386224627494812, 0.14548459649085999, 0.34377428889274597, -0.1003718301653862, 0.5997757315635681, -0.38982152938842773, -0.17996838688850403, 0.775516152381897, 0.6258400082588196, 0.2447701245546341, -0.031267810612916946, -0.45099639892578125, 0.4124516248703003, 0.5621402859687805, 0.2325291931629181, 0.004631364718079567, -0.7472617626190186, -0.9205751419067383, -1.185343861579895, 0.32328030467033386, -0.19235634803771973, -0.6239587664604187, 0.682809591293335, 0.30381935834884644, -0.3481901288032532, 0.26137107610702515, -0.11047426611185074, -0.560889482498169, -0.22476230561733246, -1.0169777870178223, 0.3148636519908905, 0.0941644236445427, 0.26582783460617065, 0.2951713502407074, -0.2636277973651886, -0.0016393396072089672, 0.20586994290351868, -0.3367901146411896, 0.14523403346538544, -0.49605676531791687, -0.05376547574996948, 0.9031956791877747, -0.48908525705337524, 0.036173317581415176, -1.0662071704864502, -0.9210399389266968, -0.4355860650539398, 0.4107368290424347, -0.23118676245212555, 0.04063735902309418, 0.030528156086802483, 0.08370951563119888, -1.2589980363845825, -0.0313735269010067, -0.2771313190460205, -1.0743824243545532, 0.4620397686958313, 0.174890398979187, -0.05886785686016083, 0.018287671729922295, -0.7068127989768982, -0.5543218851089478, 0.13988295197486877, -0.1627814918756485, 0.06682295352220535, 0.30440405011177063, -0.6003658771514893, 0.34428831934928894, 0.6601007580757141, 0.09942205995321274, 0.330730676651001, 0.1623293161392212, -0.4229081869125366, -0.18500910699367523, -0.05955857038497925, 0.21063783764839172, 0.14706291258335114, 0.9281588792800903, 0.733031690120697, -0.8563795685768127, 1.0111358165740967, -0.010510185733437538, -0.17387503385543823, 0.719429612159729, 0.7543898224830627, -0.8102207779884338, 0.18870830535888672, 0.09890538454055786, 0.5604708194732666, -0.6470761895179749, -1.2344622611999512, 0.04542924091219902, 0.4381716847419739, 0.5425543785095215, -0.5633189678192139, 0.37411701679229736, -0.3183959424495697, 0.1369089037179947, 0.020980238914489746, -0.04258163645863533, 0.05072636157274246, 0.6399893164634705, 0.5707148313522339, 1.5710012912750244, -1.3615193367004395, 0.5160874724388123, 0.5251699090003967, 1.1118009090423584, 0.658643364906311, -0.43608012795448303, 0.501861572265625, -0.9527945518493652, -0.025155115872621536, 0.11361364275217056, -0.3317349851131439, -0.1035335510969162, 0.4121856689453125, 0.6553013920783997, 0.0887206494808197, -0.7414815425872803, -0.5585833787918091, -0.06270493566989899, 0.7678883671760559, 0.9907132983207703, 0.1466744989156723, 0.27578145265579224, -0.44092869758605957, 0.9099164605140686, 0.008024260401725769, 0.08073025196790695, -0.004121697507798672, -0.4809499979019165, -0.3636787235736847, -0.4826822876930237, -0.69328373670578, 0.02914813719689846, -0.6578618884086609, -0.0077485269866883755, 0.01787574589252472, 0.3137441873550415, 0.040469031780958176, -0.37009891867637634, -0.3814201056957245, -0.11298021674156189, -0.05705136060714722, 0.5338799357414246, -0.2002561390399933, -0.37185969948768616, -0.21592171490192413, 0.3900400996208191, -0.6767853498458862, -0.04355110228061676, -0.23915740847587585, 0.8847138285636902, 0.8499319553375244, -1.0073573589324951, -0.5613595843315125, -0.4694964587688446, 0.5364313721656799, -0.4378994107246399, 0.053452253341674805, 0.08151406049728394, 0.3132130205631256, 0.5039606690406799, -0.8220059275627136, -0.44708052277565, -0.8155871629714966, 0.010226540267467499, -0.32966119050979614, 0.092954121530056, 0.05799272283911705, 1.1067383289337158, 0.40528565645217896, -0.047269418835639954, -0.07551483809947968, 0.6405860185623169, -1.353294014930725, 0.30561622977256775, -0.28183114528656006, -0.3502976894378662, -0.343195378780365, -0.1610444337129593, 0.40956777334213257, -0.33391842246055603, -0.5619810819625854, -0.9194514155387878, 0.2977890372276306, 0.2248786836862564, -0.16216811537742615, -0.00935573223978281, 0.784076988697052, -0.12094665318727493, -0.0814509317278862, 1.178517460823059, -0.5184516310691833, -0.5115892887115479, 0.27810385823249817, 0.12118943780660629, -1.3637398481369019, 0.07710105925798416, 0.014405508525669575, 0.07350342720746994, 0.19402216374874115, -0.029741844162344933, -0.49065113067626953, 0.2221037745475769, 0.5854324102401733, 0.4398474395275116, 0.2111576497554779, -0.279847115278244, -0.36210206151008606, -0.31539466977119446, -0.017970839515328407, -1.1004356145858765, 0.5898196697235107, -0.3826760947704315, -0.7467995285987854, -0.6302143335342407, 0.4738554060459137, -0.9001404643058777, -0.45908936858177185, -0.9510868191719055, -0.006047737319022417, -0.7426696419715881, 0.2573315501213074, 0.7035975456237793, -0.571209192276001, -0.7041313648223877, -0.19305622577667236, 0.48368051648139954, -1.0106505155563354, -0.37424516677856445, 0.7332545518875122, -0.3649823069572449, 0.1480502337217331, -0.4085943102836609, -0.14752602577209473, -0.20204579830169678, -0.41407570242881775, -0.5340954065322876, 0.1270633190870285, 0.7321541905403137, -0.11484511941671371, 0.10849914699792862, -0.027089165523648262, -0.17755576968193054, -0.5516185164451599, -0.42775458097457886, 0.1089167669415474, 0.02453373558819294, 0.07212580740451813, -0.5539411902427673, -0.3794563114643097, -0.06484898179769516, -1.2485227584838867, -0.20585541427135468, -0.4765995144844055, 0.514003574848175, 0.2977988123893738, -0.40605437755584717, -0.10347256809473038, 0.46755924820899963, 0.4697224199771881, 0.3928086459636688, -0.10232874751091003, -0.6743253469467163, 0.5874513983726501, 0.03400595486164093, -0.6689769625663757, -0.3578534424304962, -0.8327768445014954, -0.10956791043281555, 0.859218955039978, -0.15912297368049622, 0.010073989629745483, -0.24650178849697113, -0.06324378401041031, 0.6083060503005981, -0.23419377207756042, -0.48822924494743347, -0.5678495168685913, -0.1630222499370575, 0.880046010017395, -0.3015822768211365, -1.1735597848892212, -1.10683274269104, 1.0035759210586548, -0.7955604791641235, 0.11095152795314789, 0.0022427323274314404, -0.7662230134010315, 0.10672146081924438, -0.42443710565567017, 1.3645514249801636, -0.4043397307395935, 0.4302801489830017, 0.060739170759916306, 0.3787258267402649, 0.3539256453514099, -0.39669251441955566, -0.5763497352600098, -0.9813364148139954, -0.829541027545929, -0.9860232472419739, 0.44623324275016785, -0.29024773836135864, -0.0954815223813057, 0.5811394453048706, 0.28166061639785767, -0.3939880430698395, -0.17523549497127533, 1.217161774635315, 0.6918573379516602, -0.49189746379852295, -0.4914366900920868, 0.4731331169605255, 0.8546155691146851, 0.5009251236915588, 0.686953604221344, 0.568805456161499, -0.6695369482040405, 0.598840057849884, 0.10795295983552933, -0.16807134449481964, -0.430637925863266, -0.12617622315883636, 0.043451935052871704, 0.9817203283309937, 0.29400044679641724, 0.08864372223615646, 0.44210848212242126, -0.280217707157135, -0.3646926283836365, -0.018156154081225395, 0.15121355652809143, 0.4954267144203186, 0.6240461468696594, -0.13901609182357788, -0.1558622121810913, 0.6613694429397583, -0.30440500378608704, 0.14691691100597382, -0.11179910600185394, 0.5066760182380676, 0.7906869053840637, -1.2218432426452637, 1.0560299158096313, 0.3082428276538849, -0.6110188364982605, -0.6190325617790222, 0.09969215095043182, -0.0980125144124031, 0.179413303732872, 0.12231527268886566, -0.5833793878555298, -0.06375293433666229, -0.2930111885070801, 0.3209303915500641, -0.21151244640350342, 0.16244035959243774, 0.36021122336387634, -0.6723171472549438, 0.7891567349433899, -1.0416406393051147, 0.0898083746433258, 0.9111558198928833, -0.8734679222106934, 0.21098639070987701, 0.9942636489868164, 0.42063412070274353, 0.6486527323722839, 0.2927963435649872, 0.5878092646598816, -0.6269162893295288, -0.3866725564002991, -0.26241397857666016, -0.05041772499680519, -0.06904055923223495, 0.3238498568534851, -0.6913344860076904, 0.5589048266410828, 0.3038318157196045, -0.657322108745575, -0.29414018988609314, 0.9172161817550659, 0.6510659456253052, 0.3821300268173218, -0.32708969712257385, 0.06294803321361542, 0.37007319927215576, 0.1086190789937973, 0.6134441494941711, -0.5400828719139099, -0.5338791608810425, -0.4446103572845459, 0.09142123907804489, -0.7128859162330627, -1.0064587593078613, 0.2552216053009033, 0.5478749871253967, -0.3605062961578369, -0.9942179918289185, -0.37718501687049866, 0.534416913986206, -0.012227719649672508, -0.5158030986785889, -0.39639803767204285, 0.7527065277099609, -0.2279100865125656, -0.9563944339752197, -0.013969664461910725, 0.03329779952764511, -0.7125086784362793, 1.239402174949646, -0.9655645489692688, -0.019991833716630936, 0.876862108707428, 0.11054448783397675, 0.4650917947292328, 0.29750776290893555, -0.21891194581985474, -0.3882429599761963, -0.448143869638443, 0.5560824871063232, 0.21246494352817535, 0.03260821849107742, 0.9693319797515869, -0.18137522041797638, 0.5307575464248657, 0.2924082279205322, 0.07824327051639557, -0.15805406868457794, -0.31591716408729553, -0.2985825836658478, -0.4556509256362915, -0.5566242933273315, -0.3585902750492096, 0.487875372171402, -1.1347649097442627, -0.5235040187835693, -1.1554548740386963, -0.1612139344215393, 0.005135803483426571, 0.09847407788038254, 0.20314808189868927, 0.46419182419776917, -0.24081529676914215, -0.029950739815831184, -0.08960866183042526, 0.40119263529777527, 0.30716460943222046, -0.19901776313781738, 0.5154281854629517, 0.3288998305797577, -0.001919067115522921, -1.0520180463790894, 0.1872798204421997, 1.0945380926132202, -0.7587392330169678, 0.8390370607376099, -0.9234592914581299, 0.3091849386692047, 0.21090729534626007, -0.3525535464286804, 0.8684176802635193, 0.5178931951522827, -0.16783231496810913, 0.6530162692070007, -0.19681335985660553, -0.053245991468429565, -0.5997220873832703, -0.654715359210968, -0.8590896129608154, -0.4365052580833435, 0.32522180676460266, -0.6646320819854736, -0.03597237914800644, -0.25035443902015686, -1.309606909751892, 0.6528891921043396, -0.13185669481754303, 0.12257052212953568, -0.193611279129982, 0.5589812397956848, -0.30682551860809326, 0.5008165240287781, 0.30017518997192383, -0.423448771238327, 0.2385825216770172, 0.3550872504711151, -0.6702545285224915, -0.7776580452919006, 1.0897284746170044, 0.35096675157546997, 0.44487515091896057, 0.17636877298355103, -0.26613080501556396, -0.03258253633975983, -0.3558308780193329, -0.6463209986686707, 0.42331841588020325, -0.42751815915107727, -0.7635470628738403, 0.3540816605091095, -0.41141900420188904, 0.36713770031929016, -0.7578209638595581, 0.2708958387374878, -0.45856282114982605, -0.611114501953125, -0.6323449611663818, -0.31390324234962463, 0.7334116697311401, -0.31122857332229614, 0.24751563370227814, -0.48380666971206665, 0.09899141639471054, 0.1557161659002304, -0.1815999299287796, 0.33292707800865173, 0.43784356117248535, -0.3895847499370575, 0.4161803722381592, -0.06451847404241562, 0.2716332972049713, 0.8230555057525635, 0.3770105242729187, 0.02321535162627697, 0.55264812707901, 0.3303658962249756, 0.4725019335746765, -0.01680382713675499, -0.9440648555755615, -0.17695876955986023, 0.42834237217903137, -0.6411840915679932, 0.44417691230773926, 0.38152018189430237, 1.0191611051559448, -0.25950491428375244, 0.1776977777481079, 0.6287927031517029, -0.7088701128959656, -0.47554072737693787, 0.091972216963768, 0.2602771818637848, 0.6368357539176941, 0.12955941259860992, 0.6064143180847168, -0.04434938728809357, 0.9121896624565125, -0.03750148043036461, -0.5999489426612854, 0.3764677047729492, -0.47849294543266296, -0.33336877822875977, -0.5542334914207458, 0.5932332277297974, -0.34970739483833313, 0.3492487967014313, 0.12871995568275452, -0.10858048498630524, -0.25549569725990295, -0.2439085990190506, -0.30497467517852783, 0.38273727893829346, 1.5146138668060303, -0.03391360864043236, -0.10005570203065872, -0.12593278288841248, -0.23394034802913666, -0.5365116596221924, 0.3193489909172058, 0.22213484346866608, -0.13620339334011078, -0.17052336037158966, 0.13179707527160645, 0.953719437122345, 0.23343241214752197, 0.19193819165229797, 0.537450909614563, 0.17788158357143402, -0.07753953337669373, -0.04571028798818588, 0.2371806502342224, -0.042183857411146164, -0.3113231360912323, 0.16097226738929749, -0.11917971074581146, -0.734000027179718, 0.31301236152648926, -0.22054585814476013, -0.338418573141098, -0.8826936483383179, 0.7492709755897522, 0.20530125498771667, 0.13080145418643951, -0.762173056602478, -0.004351003095507622, -0.2816101610660553, -0.17292526364326477, -0.2919427752494812, -0.010159355588257313, 0.39672666788101196, -0.27224835753440857, 0.0912538394331932, -0.9706591963768005, -0.29806533455848694, -0.6052961349487305, -0.12348846346139908, 0.2326323688030243, 0.3923881947994232, 0.36155611276626587, -0.3221921920776367, -1.135242223739624, -0.18295976519584656, -0.07359401136636734, 0.02239345572888851, -0.4262714087963104, 0.1651879996061325, 0.3301287293434143, 0.2810291647911072, -0.3840850293636322, 0.10602222383022308, -0.05393652617931366, 0.48963087797164917, 0.9603900909423828, -1.0088452100753784, 1.0239853858947754, -0.05724550411105156, -0.8787485361099243, 0.6641015410423279, -0.201348677277565, -0.7187009453773499, -0.07814756035804749, -0.5346522331237793, -0.3281799852848053, 0.00003489956725388765, 0.10552313923835754, -0.6875607371330261, 0.2976139485836029, 0.6467726230621338, -0.7182969450950623, 0.38223975896835327, -0.28231680393218994, 0.24640905857086182, -0.7643724679946899, 0.6275038719177246, -0.2711058557033539, 0.294404000043869, -0.17893880605697632, 0.6242465972900391, 0.6054220795631409, -0.8779956698417664, 4.051975727081299, 0.9520568251609802, 0.8782911896705627, 0.05312874913215637, 0.4492562413215637, -0.348154753446579, 0.7610771059989929, -0.29427674412727356, 0.24198287725448608, -0.024422138929367065, -0.10165339708328247, 0.2889004945755005, 0.6589678525924683, -0.30680203437805176, 0.3402385413646698, 0.5344266891479492, -0.3975832760334015, 0.03824609890580177, 0.03380398452281952, -1.294370174407959, -0.593625009059906, -0.08199720084667206, -0.5010640621185303, 0.34145158529281616, 0.7536850571632385, -0.0010026412783190608, 0.6952597498893738, 0.1835843026638031, 0.19975683093070984, -0.16590870916843414, 0.8889789581298828, -0.45212987065315247, 0.5727934241294861, -0.928070068359375, -0.32376548647880554, 0.06317534297704697, 0.29961317777633667, -0.8739664554595947, 0.07038167119026184, 0.03822910040616989, 0.4034781754016876, -0.303355872631073, 0.09291325509548187, -0.1518116593360901, -0.3590068221092224, 0.6123291850090027, -0.5650550127029419, 0.1648889034986496, 0.6359622478485107, -0.04941267892718315, 0.4376738667488098, -0.8078237771987915, 0.2779201567173004, 0.29176566004753113, -1.3032647371292114, -0.04596073925495148, -0.6396690607070923, -1.0827105045318604, 0.023829899728298187, 0.4292103350162506, 1.1663599014282227, 0.06354626268148422, -0.40689000487327576, -0.07553233206272125, 0.8080635666847229, 0.4537911117076874, 0.9249408841133118, -0.17335574328899384, 0.06378641724586487, -0.4380028247833252, -0.09740760177373886, -0.07679575681686401, -0.5742281079292297, -0.22530058026313782, 0.28465965390205383, 0.3496846854686737, -0.37171390652656555, 0.6240230202674866, -0.4794486463069916, -1.0233629941940308, -0.03879248723387718, 0.02416953258216381, 0.10737913846969604, -0.39845797419548035, 0.3221374452114105, 0.5847523808479309, -0.4348450005054474, -0.2302197813987732, -0.961647629737854, 0.5805763602256775, 1.1219538450241089, 0.3377576768398285, -0.04401800036430359, 0.14894165098667145, -0.13460242748260498 ]
{"Title": "Liver function tests and fibrosis scores in a rural population in Africa: estimation of the burden of disease and associated risk factors", "Authors": "O\u2019Hara Geraldine A, Mokaya Jolynne, Hau Jeffrey P, Downs Louise O, McNaughton Anna L, Karabarinde Alex, Asiki Gershim, Seeley Janet, Matthews Philippa C, Newton Robert", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Introduction Liver disease is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in sub-Saharan Africa. However, its prevalence, distribution and aetiology have not been well characterised. We examined liver function tests (LFTs) and calculated liver fibrosis scores in a rural population in Uganda. Methodology A cross-sectional survey of LFTs was undertaken in 2011 in a rural population cohort in South-Western Uganda. We classified abnormal LFTs based on reference ranges set in America and in Africa. We derived fibrosis scores (AST to Platelet Ratio Index, fibrosis-4, GGT to platelet ratio, red cell distribution width to platelet ratio, and S-index) to evaluate the potential prevalence of liver disease. We collected information about alcohol intake, and infection with HIV, HBV and HCV, to determine the contribution made by these factors to liver inflammation or fibrosis. Results Data were available for 8,099 participants (median age 30 years; 56% female). The prevalence of HBV, HCV and HIV infection were 3%, 0.2% and 8%, respectively. The prevalence of abnormal LFTs was higher based on the American reference range compared to the African reference range (e.g. for AST 13% vs 3%, respectively). The prevalence of AST/ALT ratio >2 was 11%, suggestive of alcoholic hepatitis. The highest prevalence of fibrosis was suggested by the GPR score, with 24% of the population falling above the threshold for fibrosis. By multivariate analysis, elevated LFTs and fibrosis scores were most consistently associated with older age, male sex, being under-weight, infection with HIV or HBV, and alcohol consumption. Based on population attributable risk, the highest proportion of elevated fibrosis scores was associated with alcohol use (e.g. 64% of elevated S-index scores). Conclusion Further work is required to determine normal reference ranges for LFTs in this setting, to evaluate the specificity and sensitivity of fibrosis scores, and to determine aetiology of liver disease. KEY FINDINGS What is already known? Liver disease is not well characterised in many parts of sSA despite the high prevalence of chronic viral infections (HIV, HBV and HCV), and potential exposure to hepatotoxins including alcohol, aflatoxins and traditional herbal medicine. Non-invasive blood tests for markers of fibrosis are relatively simple and offer a safe route to assess for liver fibrosis, however, their diagnostic accuracy is not well established in sSA. Appropriate reference ranges for LFTs are crucial for optimising the sensitivity and specificity of the detection of underlying liver disease. What are the new findings? There is a disparity in the prevalence of abnormal LFTs in our study cohort when comparing two references ranges (American vs. local reference ranges). Based on GPR score, there is a high prevalence of liver fibrosis (almost 1 in 4 of this population) and elevated GPR score is associated with older age, male sex, being under-weight, infection with HIV or HBV, and alcohol consumption. Alcohol consumption accounted for 64% of abnormal S-index scores, 32% of elevated FIB-4 scores, and 19% of GPR abnormalities. What do the new findings imply? Appropriate reference ranges for LFTs are necessary to contribute to an understanding of the burden and aetiology of liver disease. Alcohol, HIV and HBV are risk factors for deranged LFTs and liver fibrosis, with alcohol making the most significant and striking contribution. Further investigation is needed to determine other factors that contribute to liver disease in this setting.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000968"}
10.1101/19008581
[ 0.6187496185302734, 0.07544087618589401, -0.6532542705535889, 0.9391708970069885, -0.6572068929672241, -1.1716440916061401, 0.29347169399261475, -0.13075847923755646, 0.3934711515903473, 1.172452688217163, 0.42648613452911377, -0.2484012097120285, 0.2553882300853729, -0.9660530090332031, -0.15972210466861725, 0.07601723819971085, -0.9417988061904907, -0.18436506390571594, -0.12442497164011002, -0.31933391094207764, 0.6895645260810852, 0.3374016284942627, -0.45534229278564453, 0.48464861512184143, -0.9570770263671875, 0.4108889102935791, -0.1458756923675537, 0.7448338866233826, 0.8989266753196716, 0.6730570793151855, -0.13020890951156616, -0.6074396967887878, 0.18140587210655212, -0.9095322489738464, -0.1430332213640213, 0.18588629364967346, 1.1686999797821045, -0.959533154964447, -0.3083252012729645, -0.4179565906524658, 0.046513307839632034, 0.11527187377214432, 0.4312213957309723, -1.176639199256897, -0.5265291929244995, -0.3663863241672516, -0.21929432451725006, -0.5045540928840637, -0.05787965655326843, -0.9874339699745178, -0.2230692058801651, -0.25734835863113403, -0.09015623480081558, -0.4727555215358734, -0.1390295922756195, -0.25592055916786194, 0.26987898349761963, 0.37333405017852783, -0.48667046427726746, 0.20273816585540771, 0.493985652923584, 0.030429912731051445, 0.36765527725219727, -1.696987509727478, 0.5780905485153198, 0.7335682511329651, -0.149608314037323, -0.02208232693374157, -0.7926359176635742, 0.09915676712989807, -0.7458359003067017, -0.12768664956092834, -0.622974157333374, -0.8359502553939819, 0.5741996765136719, 0.20439758896827698, 0.05088203027844429, 0.14144687354564667, -0.04933984577655792, -0.5951985716819763, 0.640381932258606, 0.19752858579158783, -0.09170877933502197, 0.8560232520103455, -0.12347640842199326, -0.2382849007844925, 0.43869125843048096, 0.7047985196113586, 0.47557708621025085, -0.2457670420408249, 0.31155386567115784, -0.14132481813430786, 0.29361018538475037, -0.07645498961210251, -0.3306175172328949, 0.74045729637146, -0.6479985117912292, 0.1455952376127243, 0.6676487922668457, -0.18052998185157776, 0.6039738655090332, 0.6812848448753357, -0.7256890535354614, 0.8314179182052612, -0.5495477914810181, 0.00936727412045002, 0.7432464361190796, -0.20686981081962585, 0.21320924162864685, -1.0218420028686523, 0.21275684237480164, 0.4583187401294708, -0.055716875940561295, 0.7250270247459412, 0.17286492884159088, 0.4939594566822052, -0.38851988315582275, 0.01632293500006199, -0.1089254841208458, 0.6941013336181641, 0.2374141365289688, -0.32694724202156067, 0.35995709896087646, -0.4158417582511902, 0.5043368339538574, 0.06736481189727783, 0.5002671480178833, 0.2503902018070221, -0.0743144303560257, -0.40486234426498413, -0.17038387060165405, -0.6057114005088806, -0.20844697952270508, 0.3641669750213623, -0.08618195354938507, -0.10354450345039368, -0.6703194379806519, 0.39214667677879333, 0.1793772578239441, -0.3802410364151001, -0.015620102174580097, -0.3199675977230072, 0.13294032216072083, 1.2279584407806396, 0.009334261529147625, 0.8066578507423401, -0.4992969334125519, -1.2364184856414795, 0.029786409810185432, -0.31195709109306335, 0.05792701989412308, 0.015303606167435646, -0.1782902181148529, 0.4760410785675049, -0.474016010761261, 0.10178646445274353, -0.8734695315361023, 0.8766359686851501, -0.738794207572937, -0.2152450978755951, -0.38491716980934143, 0.4665274918079376, 0.10719799995422363, 1.561627984046936, -0.2819759249687195, 0.9145467281341553, -0.23491626977920532, -0.4951004683971405, 0.0952761098742485, -0.5381767153739929, 0.05199799686670303, 0.1480714976787567, -0.259387344121933, -0.26427024602890015, -0.010741143487393856, 0.8612030744552612, 0.8139598965644836, 0.3455972671508789, 0.004540346562862396, -0.06093401461839676, -0.2446131855249405, -0.937558650970459, 0.26739227771759033, 0.5360204577445984, -0.03075968287885189, -0.25612834095954895, -0.39703091979026794, -0.5598914623260498, -0.22266128659248352, -0.1190141960978508, 0.09175493568181992, 0.39959517121315, -0.7786863446235657, 0.1503644585609436, -0.15548326075077057, 0.3562922477722168, 0.33578792214393616, 0.4110200107097626, 0.0652947872877121, -0.13945980370044708, -0.3136816620826721, 0.291716992855072, -0.18017373979091644, 0.9694414138793945, -0.34365805983543396, 0.7698965668678284, 0.6327765583992004, 0.5595919489860535, -0.15387189388275146, 0.0654647946357727, 0.16683144867420197, -0.3034180998802185, 0.2337953746318817, 0.1431635618209839, 1.0898938179016113, -0.4505094587802887, 0.44205939769744873, 0.10092595219612122, 0.4425120949745178, -0.011853138916194439, 0.7666419148445129, -0.5925251245498657, 0.8064645528793335, -0.08677259087562561, -0.12501820921897888, 0.5045603513717651, 0.06938371062278748, -0.09052299708127975, 0.7284876704216003, -0.196321502327919, -0.4134696125984192, 0.9173845052719116, -0.39611122012138367, 0.45363521575927734, 0.9306644797325134, 0.3702299892902374, 0.36285844445228577, 0.10873837023973465, 0.894364595413208, -0.1330881416797638, 0.32226601243019104, 0.5764461755752563, 0.7451348304748535, 0.638741672039032, 0.1463695615530014, 0.14968571066856384, -0.6180415153503418, 0.4081351161003113, -1.0025845766067505, 0.21583770215511322, -0.606304943561554, 0.7373734712600708, 0.20385673642158508, 0.5390377640724182, -0.7755494713783264, -0.39500704407691956, 0.31886255741119385, 0.8739684224128723, -0.41266778111457825, -0.7891878485679626, -0.18213582038879395, 0.3187413513660431, 0.6080530285835266, 0.4528542459011078, 1.1832901239395142, 0.7618064880371094, 0.3638741374015808, -0.06844907253980637, 0.11802860349416733, -0.5801702737808228, -0.7110586166381836, -0.40149515867233276, -1.0924783945083618, -0.6777405738830566, -0.5724959373474121, -0.8256875276565552, 0.5665693879127502, -0.3137829899787903, 0.10650564730167389, 0.08524857461452484, 0.014677994884550571, -1.3501806259155273, 0.3375205099582672, 1.1687493324279785, 0.237623393535614, -0.04940551146864891, -1.1583222150802612, 0.27776145935058594, -0.18913409113883972, -0.02514573745429516, -0.3218211829662323, -0.47825002670288086, -0.7051042914390564, -0.8142587542533875, 0.5596063137054443, -0.3829321563243866, 0.04839320853352547, 0.13652440905570984, -0.731846809387207, -0.12567810714244843, -0.018916504457592964, 0.012072158977389336, -0.10465835779905319, 0.1314711719751358, -0.25971361994743347, 0.5074613094329834, 0.1195584163069725, 0.18861998617649078, 1.5828070640563965, 0.09794926643371582, -0.5832196474075317, 0.6569923162460327, 0.03423130139708519, -0.042086608707904816, -0.4655936658382416, 0.705998957157135, 0.6424594521522522, 0.16213661432266235, 0.022033115848898888, -0.49040400981903076, -0.9358079433441162, 0.013523997738957405, 0.002210755832493305, -0.7000953555107117, 0.2461063712835312, 0.4103972911834717, 0.33097246289253235, -1.2130701541900635, -0.01914406195282936, -0.18759113550186157, -0.9947776794433594, -0.1062982901930809, -1.0544543266296387, 0.34827080368995667, -0.18826398253440857, 0.003402048721909523, -0.8151626586914062, -0.11267063021659851, -0.03602372854948044, 0.2978806793689728, 0.2536257803440094, -0.7401218414306641, -0.02097323350608349, 0.08486846834421158, 0.3331955373287201, -0.27686041593551636, 0.7183724641799927, -0.5821554064750671, 0.011833470314741135, -0.2505199909210205, -0.10181520134210587, 0.16877464950084686, 0.6112347841262817, -0.5876650214195251, 0.5718889832496643, -0.20075903832912445, -0.2708764374256134, 0.23962943255901337, 0.09125395864248276, 0.39081886410713196, 0.483001172542572, 0.690798282623291, 0.18881717324256897, 0.48865097761154175, -0.6846539378166199, -0.049986016005277634, 0.5004588961601257, 0.2242550551891327, 0.5325753092765808, -1.0156573057174683, 0.4779043197631836, 0.31632810831069946, 0.23728521168231964, 0.010136845521628857, -0.4097755253314972, -0.12791110575199127, 0.7492291331291199, -0.5288445353507996, 1.1701102256774902, -1.2779184579849243, 0.2610536813735962, 0.5787909030914307, 0.7057546973228455, 0.19621795415878296, 0.0986173003911972, 0.1445053666830063, -0.51558518409729, 0.5015373826026917, 0.22264738380908966, 0.1075611338019371, 0.03664802014827728, -0.6884771585464478, -0.7018023729324341, -0.34045007824897766, -0.582741916179657, 0.2304188311100006, 0.5696086287498474, 0.3202882409095764, -0.30614355206489563, -0.9016984105110168, 0.4777105748653412, 0.30171170830726624, -0.07162238657474518, 1.1206918954849243, 0.0369783416390419, -0.5040788650512695, -0.5737690925598145, 0.2710721790790558, -0.19015517830848694, -0.4072362780570984, -0.5112935900688171, 0.4802144467830658, -0.5733739137649536, 0.575199544429779, 0.44084632396698, 0.061416108161211014, -0.30357247591018677, -0.2254355102777481, 0.01253978069871664, -0.40745508670806885, 0.48667341470718384, 0.548478901386261, -0.9175617098808289, -0.032335590571165085, 0.2898288369178772, -0.568630039691925, 0.17528988420963287, -0.34932461380958557, 0.32060447335243225, 0.6754210591316223, -0.7420969009399414, -0.6269937753677368, -0.1950148195028305, -0.24447529017925262, -0.1016496866941452, 0.22818200290203094, -0.30934250354766846, -0.5910019874572754, 0.157772958278656, 0.26326674222946167, -0.23354800045490265, -0.8334150314331055, -0.31652572751045227, 0.06759607046842575, -0.16888375580310822, 0.6626198887825012, 0.9693135023117065, 0.560778796672821, 0.07466649264097214, 0.7566041350364685, 1.15738046169281, -0.36265215277671814, 0.40261632204055786, -0.43542417883872986, -0.7934885621070862, 0.10184243321418762, -0.5044364333152771, -0.5131138563156128, 0.31698930263519287, -0.26374733448028564, -0.5439814925193787, -0.48746639490127563, 0.11870600283145905, -0.6019829511642456, -0.16053488850593567, 0.9526756405830383, -0.37800177931785583, 0.35376453399658203, 1.011216163635254, -0.22974437475204468, -0.02352719008922577, 0.1311018168926239, 0.7086049914360046, -0.9527414441108704, 0.3239790201187134, -0.06354518234729767, -0.05929313600063324, -0.5924490094184875, -0.08028268069028854, -0.43602684140205383, 0.11080530285835266, 0.22270694375038147, -0.40748095512390137, 0.43298497796058655, -0.5290568470954895, -0.1888687163591385, -0.9137413501739502, 0.30308324098587036, -0.83990877866745, 0.06996362656354904, -0.022285209968686104, -0.45552998781204224, 0.22290438413619995, -0.05445576831698418, -0.3370217978954315, 0.5039964318275452, -1.0108511447906494, 0.32334622740745544, 0.2918072044849396, -0.18664325773715973, -0.053407855331897736, -0.24315345287322998, -1.2306898832321167, 0.5362437963485718, -0.18166010081768036, -0.13963785767555237, -0.28668150305747986, -0.4838238060474396, -0.3996203541755676, -0.5599274039268494, -0.1786288321018219, -0.3760641813278198, -0.14790047705173492, -0.31754517555236816, 0.08157891035079956, -0.5270147323608398, 0.1667696088552475, -0.5005622506141663, -0.9509996771812439, 1.1851274967193604, -0.2532414495944977, -0.5015517473220825, 0.04519281163811684, 0.5695038437843323, -0.0738537460565567, 0.3155497908592224, -0.5397440791130066, -0.7373130917549133, -0.12005343288183212, -0.9714006781578064, 0.2396068572998047, -1.0438716411590576, 0.12151183187961578, -0.4728737473487854, 0.19276855885982513, -0.025015588849782944, -0.05002862587571144, 0.5090132355690002, -0.3346725106239319, 0.3753078877925873, -0.7470628023147583, 0.10933324694633484, -0.13255490362644196, -0.5890563130378723, -0.17559559643268585, -0.47113391757011414, 0.11476019769906998, 1.3211085796356201, 0.5332674384117126, -0.5341215133666992, 0.5847455263137817, 0.3902190923690796, 0.07122205197811127, -0.04494493454694748, -0.2913239598274231, -0.29803481698036194, -0.020310131832957268, 0.24300651252269745, 0.5836590528488159, -0.4891795516014099, -1.0886731147766113, 0.06722797453403473, -0.08703120797872543, 0.38388746976852417, -0.6294175386428833, 0.34328681230545044, -0.17907389998435974, -1.1905056238174438, 0.7549887299537659, -0.3499923050403595, 0.2272404134273529, 0.1576533019542694, 0.18538494408130646, -0.002687998116016388, 0.3945891857147217, -0.627375602722168, -1.0584100484848022, -0.6495476365089417, -1.2181951999664307, 0.35643962025642395, -0.282948762178421, 0.37796276807785034, 0.04058530926704407, 0.4999149739742279, -0.07243557274341583, -1.1659374237060547, 0.7691637277603149, 0.390009343624115, -0.0066808974370360374, -0.39711153507232666, -0.5138054490089417, 0.11581006646156311, 0.5000901818275452, -0.3187844455242157, -0.13179099559783936, -0.4791974425315857, -0.7354167103767395, -0.9530776143074036, -1.0020034313201904, -1.2383475303649902, -0.36498555541038513, 0.009747376665472984, 0.3224077522754669, 0.06081626936793327, 0.5556035041809082, 0.27605241537094116, 0.24869829416275024, -0.5129008889198303, 0.8911627531051636, -0.4086272120475769, 0.3271764814853668, 0.3382798433303833, -0.5345376133918762, 0.043482713401317596, -0.18916384875774384, 0.03435856103897095, -0.6817905306816101, 0.024163244292140007, 0.26292145252227783, 0.7289199829101562, -0.7860834002494812, -0.06693688035011292, -0.23728592693805695, -0.41417214274406433, -0.678443193435669, 0.13092274963855743, -0.2639489471912384, -0.1687641739845276, -0.6007749438285828, 0.3859970271587372, 0.2665908932685852, -0.302397757768631, 0.4882485270500183, 0.6673244833946228, 0.3526592254638672, -0.07488638907670975, 0.09766798466444016, -0.032106466591358185, -0.5095797777175903, 0.1499062478542328, 0.7246166467666626, 0.14027822017669678, 0.41013145446777344, -0.20720671117305756, -0.29674261808395386, 0.48276060819625854, 0.06569751352071762, 0.2323368340730667, -0.5963138341903687, 0.2187032550573349, -0.8489449620246887, 0.4617670178413391, -0.2920446991920471, 0.3589877784252167, -0.09617076069116592, 0.8710299730300903, -0.20616808533668518, -0.39841169118881226, 0.15447157621383667, 0.5468125939369202, 0.8502575159072876, 0.902122437953949, -0.025984780862927437, -0.35362911224365234, 0.3170691728591919, 0.5384050607681274, -0.08130098879337311, -0.8622218370437622, -1.1250412464141846, -0.9385647177696228, -0.5640706419944763, -0.051120106130838394, -0.7069922685623169, -0.4775027632713318, 0.9202858209609985, -0.8282830715179443, -0.6155155301094055, -0.5884993076324463, 1.321284532546997, -0.6626770496368408, -0.25247815251350403, -0.4042912423610687, 0.10096375644207001, -1.073319911956787, 0.2253504991531372, -0.015296004712581635, -1.2449806928634644, -0.44115281105041504, 1.0670422315597534, 0.037357769906520844, -0.30067506432533264, -0.1766287237405777, 0.03239602968096733, -0.15702809393405914, 0.5800537467002869, -0.7733727097511292, -0.10026627779006958, -0.3001134395599365, 0.3615509867668152, 0.24888315796852112, -0.1658918708562851, 1.050229787826538, -0.399027943611145, 0.39004260301589966, 0.2452823370695114, 0.0840640738606453, -0.29497674107551575, 0.007243467029184103, 0.426283061504364, -0.7271663546562195, -0.40347185730934143, -0.13580752909183502, -0.02114998549222946, -0.9492212533950806, -0.14900144934654236, -0.45344606041908264, 0.4413784444332123, 0.4946773648262024, -0.5019932389259338, 0.1701851189136505, 1.0990439653396606, -0.3748084604740143, -0.34762057662010193, 0.2214931845664978, 0.6058070659637451, 0.2599572241306305, 0.094027079641819, 0.3418862819671631, 0.1571723073720932, 0.29157501459121704, -0.2710919678211212, 0.029987651854753494, 0.4099200963973999, -0.6479210257530212, 0.49696630239486694, -0.3412437438964844, 0.7641757726669312, 0.7992016673088074, -0.11334558576345444, 0.04137459769845009, 0.9366720914840698, 0.14595717191696167, 0.14878122508525848, 0.5311846137046814, -0.3317108452320099, -0.7408244609832764, -0.2397889643907547, -0.9708217978477478, -0.4598046839237213, 0.5186365246772766, -0.7809106111526489, -0.4430648386478424, -0.9116145372390747, -0.3363780975341797, 0.26166775822639465, 0.3431251049041748, 0.21080437302589417, -0.41832005977630615, 0.13032680749893188, 0.2843564748764038, 0.3137858211994171, -0.5892550945281982, 0.08060349524021149, -0.21938525140285492, -0.017730509862303734, -0.8936249613761902, -0.5564413666725159, 0.16868184506893158, -0.07144619524478912, 0.1283748596906662, -0.331231027841568, -0.4278276860713959, 0.2735656201839447, 0.5323972105979919, -0.2991204559803009, -0.6426675319671631, 0.1340392827987671, -0.3497234582901001, 0.08388073742389679, 0.022183716297149658, -0.13039712607860565, 0.08407554775476456, 0.25338876247406006, 0.6371070146560669, -0.25443097949028015, -0.5115323662757874, -0.2673397660255432, 0.5619550347328186, -0.5290006399154663, 0.6003791093826294, -0.12589822709560394, 0.4335230886936188, -0.4828900992870331, -0.01139155961573124, 1.133280873298645, 0.2652881443500519, 0.24822565913200378, -0.09948166459798813, 0.01778130605816841, 0.8201215267181396, 0.4704396426677704, 0.4290289580821991, 0.7649720311164856, 0.42004361748695374, 0.5072001218795776, -0.6007369756698608, 0.13499440252780914, 0.03672817349433899, 0.5417305827140808, 0.752934455871582, 0.1992846429347992, 0.7506529092788696, 0.016483228653669357, 0.20776256918907166, -0.3716326951980591, -0.3292531669139862, -0.08522273600101471, -0.41897839307785034, -0.620276927947998, 0.05566801130771637, 0.5926565527915955, 0.5581052899360657, -0.16121681034564972, 0.6856039762496948, -0.1556311547756195, 0.6855171322822571, -0.23963278532028198, -0.389811247587204, 0.6962108612060547, -0.3387397527694702, -0.5161473751068115, -0.11419286578893661, 0.504543662071228, 0.17589020729064941, -0.027505813166499138, 0.9587621092796326, -0.3777652382850647, 0.13141722977161407, 0.5442188382148743, -0.08633644878864288, -0.4624985158443451, 0.6890652775764465, -0.4904406666755676, -0.6959858536720276, -0.7072860598564148, -0.81788170337677, -0.7887488603591919, -0.016079949215054512, 0.07496944069862366, -0.42339026927948, 0.37120237946510315, 0.13198819756507874, 0.3173998296260834, 0.6645383238792419, 0.6140236258506775, 0.2898898422718048, -0.14453455805778503, 0.5685513019561768, 0.6216018795967102, -0.27783751487731934, -0.09457116574048996, -0.6533693075180054, -0.48971492052078247, 0.34696489572525024, -0.14246945083141327, 0.37954282760620117, 1.1413227319717407, -0.15482041239738464, 0.34882569313049316, 0.4790177643299103, -0.14311420917510986, 0.07723848521709442, -0.9191288352012634, 0.3513627052307129, 0.14512859284877777, 0.14007455110549927, -0.36090731620788574, 0.7461258172988892, -0.04874509945511818, 0.1079413890838623, 0.2096732258796692, 0.0069559053517878056, -0.1531924158334732, 0.36960992217063904, -0.22313807904720306, 0.37462928891181946, 0.04903624206781387, 0.1083274632692337, 0.038429901003837585, -1.3929798603057861, 0.5463396906852722, 0.28010112047195435, -0.937408983707428, -0.8406611680984497, 0.9485595226287842, 1.045944094657898, 0.4590945541858673, 0.07115960121154785, -1.108343482017517, 0.068780817091465, 0.6844019293785095, 0.4833713173866272, -0.27689188718795776, 0.8661798238754272, 0.022656787186861038, 0.03665495291352272, 0.013497433625161648, 0.5965715646743774, 0.7927454113960266, -0.15563061833381653, -0.629513144493103, 0.13721656799316406, -0.06511443853378296, -0.681006669998169, -0.570979118347168, 1.0690771341323853, 0.02024117298424244, -0.14633245766162872, -0.2935514450073242, -0.833070695400238, -0.3185471296310425, -0.3267214000225067, 0.947759211063385, -0.542944073677063, 0.30592039227485657, 0.4100499749183655, -0.5756850838661194, -0.12164174765348434, -0.5874519348144531, 4.0790114402771, 1.679835557937622, 0.4269721806049347, -0.6541047692298889, 0.12808549404144287, -0.0714275985956192, 1.0769373178482056, 0.1832333356142044, 0.41232946515083313, 0.14961305260658264, 0.20534956455230713, 0.7306774854660034, 0.06493017077445984, -0.7589397430419922, 0.9072780609130859, 0.6242417097091675, -0.5628660917282104, 0.20431187748908997, -0.19519443809986115, -0.35402122139930725, 0.011170596815645695, 0.7734251022338867, -0.030276333913207054, -0.7032397985458374, 0.7001861333847046, -0.04119187220931053, -0.738601803779602, -0.41413548588752747, -0.2994902729988098, 0.21966351568698883, -0.6008076071739197, -0.7729073762893677, 0.373884379863739, -0.7232444286346436, -0.0022008568048477173, 0.3489256203174591, -0.31344398856163025, -0.9244719743728638, 0.4890033006668091, -0.024119654670357704, -0.6004277467727661, -0.26140254735946655, -0.0947832316160202, 0.17427697777748108, -0.026080602779984474, 0.17215004563331604, -0.3695332407951355, 0.8618621230125427, 0.5600033402442932, -0.377963125705719, 1.6733869314193726, -0.5773373246192932, -0.3897031843662262, -0.2976517379283905, -0.7170436978340149, 0.018110862001776695, -0.20461416244506836, -0.43405553698539734, 0.30361294746398926, -0.26029321551322937, 0.6341997981071472, 0.4684373140335083, -0.169747456908226, -0.13544124364852905, 0.7489525079727173, 0.5869821906089783, -0.027065981179475784, -0.2836989462375641, -0.10287049412727356, -0.21535512804985046, 0.4667094647884369, 0.08268652856349945, -0.9892688393592834, 0.31407374143600464, 0.8622398376464844, 0.3485882580280304, -0.44405990839004517, 0.5911820530891418, -0.16952292621135712, -0.2835898995399475, 0.03157183900475502, 0.569664478302002, 0.3477001488208771, 0.11591112613677979, 0.03563236445188522, 1.1300660371780396, -0.5885457992553711, -0.3907906711101532, -1.152066707611084, 1.0055298805236816, 0.4893174171447754, -0.2684660255908966, -0.855486273765564, 0.007134375628083944, 0.2837841212749481 ]
{"Title": "Memory recovery is related to default mode network impairment and neurite density during brain tumours treatment", "Authors": "Romero-Garcia R, Suckling J, Owen M, Assem M, Sinha R, Coelho P, Woodberry E, Price SJ, Burke GAA, Santarius T, Erez Y, Hart MG", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Surgical resection is an effective treatment to delay brain tumour progression and improve survival. Nevertheless, a large proportion of patients have treatment-induced memory deficits that dramatically reduce their life quality. Our aim is to test brain tumour interactions with brain networks thereby identifying protective features and risk factors for memory recovery. Seventeen patients with diffuse glioma (aged 22-56 years) were MRI-scanned and cognitively assessed before and after surgery, and during a 12-months recovery period (47 MRI in total after exclusion). Using structural MRI and Neurite Orientation Dispersion and Density Imaging (NODDI) derived from diffusion-weighted images, we respectively estimated lesion overlap and Neurite Density with brain networks derived from normative data in healthy participants. Non-local effects of tumours were evident on neurite density, which was reduced not only within the tumour, but also beyond the tumour boundary. In contrast, high preoperative neurite density outside the tumour, but within the DMN, was associated with better memory recovery. Furthermore, follow-up neurite density within the DMN and Frontoparietal network were also associated with memory recovery. Preoperative tumour, and post-operative lesion, overlap with the DMN showed a significant negative association with memory recovery. Our findings suggest that brain tumours and their corresponding treatment affecting brain networks that are fundamental for memory functioning such as the DMN can have a major impact on patient\u2019s memory recovery.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008581"}
10.1101/19002246
[ -0.17928308248519897, 0.7652008533477783, 0.32980456948280334, 0.09286565333604813, -0.4979628622531891, -0.5310102701187134, -0.5909073948860168, 0.12034671753644943, 0.27167782187461853, 1.0405175685882568, -0.5654710531234741, -0.5720356702804565, 0.028531821444630623, 0.8712741136550903, -0.23578351736068726, -0.4741823673248291, -0.7031094431877136, -0.17411112785339355, 0.4439280033111572, 0.48201632499694824, 0.024701468646526337, 0.7819388508796692, -1.2490125894546509, -0.7891219258308411, -0.9982678294181824, 0.8286949396133423, 0.44583699107170105, -0.599520206451416, 1.571860671043396, 1.4892706871032715, 0.2229042500257492, -0.7794893980026245, 0.40332886576652527, -0.8616275191307068, 0.11984212696552277, 0.26186513900756836, 0.7123937606811523, -0.6304364800453186, -0.419588178396225, -0.8423609733581543, 0.6111814379692078, -0.6811267137527466, 0.08936689794063568, -0.8511529564857483, -0.4910051226615906, 0.008922470733523369, 0.17270278930664062, 1.3153051137924194, 0.1635236144065857, -0.21844089031219482, 0.28605830669403076, 0.718727171421051, -0.4878244698047638, -0.910767674446106, -0.8693302273750305, -0.2747340202331543, -0.35694727301597595, -0.5996844172477722, -0.08704502135515213, 0.32783910632133484, 0.08448281139135361, -0.038528669625520706, 0.4840564429759979, -0.9275587797164917, 0.1705903708934784, 0.8811538219451904, -0.41253817081451416, -0.08582475781440735, 0.4454371929168701, -0.35011205077171326, -0.029777977615594864, -0.4558970034122467, -0.2928164601325989, -0.21724919974803925, -0.7732502818107605, -0.34628915786743164, 0.09853943437337875, -0.28195416927337646, -0.32017210125923157, 0.09793220460414886, 0.24554497003555298, 0.5053143501281738, 0.22352397441864014, 0.17824019491672516, -0.5534334182739258, 0.26038581132888794, 0.059435874223709106, -0.24572782218456268, 0.10281892865896225, 0.7980444431304932, -0.6280600428581238, 0.21672958135604858, 0.07058938592672348, 0.2768925428390503, 0.6972566843032837, 0.452486127614975, -0.016872679814696312, -0.11258012056350708, -0.07747995853424072, 0.2531996965408325, 0.8322449922561646, 0.9965441226959229, -0.026036426424980164, 1.3865286111831665, -0.0958983451128006, 1.084429144859314, 0.626925528049469, -0.27349916100502014, -0.4398384094238281, -1.0178658962249756, 0.37824246287345886, 0.5322930812835693, -0.43955230712890625, -0.21834786236286163, 0.7983918190002441, 0.5059831738471985, 0.5412682890892029, 0.613750159740448, -0.4008619487285614, 0.41343727707862854, -0.9016216993331909, 0.9045230150222778, 0.8313746452331543, 0.21122325956821442, 0.3888739347457886, -0.3324374556541443, 0.3265804350376129, 0.49862539768218994, -0.2983975112438202, 0.3747362196445465, -0.1688171923160553, -1.1393005847930908, -0.7148059010505676, 0.6101385354995728, 0.13325540721416473, 0.1565941721200943, 0.42692679166793823, 0.8913980722427368, 0.21534191071987152, 0.3164171874523163, 0.08864346146583557, 0.45282846689224243, -0.7434698343276978, 1.55224609375, 0.2590792179107666, 1.1271114349365234, 0.20915865898132324, -0.552769124507904, -0.15720342099666595, 0.13975557684898376, 0.07784555852413177, 0.24556612968444824, -0.5308222770690918, 0.026097871363162994, 0.15113215148448944, 0.0771394893527031, -0.2615700364112854, -0.2158302515745163, -0.5353634357452393, -0.010886764153838158, -0.19872775673866272, -0.3629642128944397, -0.3334060311317444, -0.3104552626609802, -1.1442487239837646, 1.1435092687606812, -0.013866384513676167, 0.5966801643371582, 0.25085023045539856, -0.7385016083717346, 1.1020240783691406, 0.30533552169799805, 0.024362431839108467, 0.07500823587179184, 0.44813376665115356, 0.3597232699394226, -0.19855378568172455, -0.8118323683738708, 0.9682660698890686, 0.49547380208969116, 0.21039338409900665, 0.31049105525016785, 0.4429911971092224, 0.30842241644859314, 0.7378141283988953, -0.013249890878796577, 0.11974986642599106, -0.5919217467308044, 0.18281394243240356, 0.0694824680685997, -0.013080224394798279, -0.05331036075949669, -0.45682281255722046, 0.8131991028785706, -0.06403282284736633, -0.6235815286636353, -0.31033432483673096, -0.21261441707611084, 0.7934290170669556, 0.05495082214474678, -0.3221268951892853, -0.05969773977994919, -0.49401065707206726, 0.20083007216453552, -0.9608508944511414, 0.7005338668823242, 0.469112366437912, 0.1121632382273674, -0.7269323468208313, 1.0045217275619507, 0.7249540686607361, -0.288344144821167, 0.03379761800169945, -0.8510032296180725, 0.3918835520744324, 0.021123763173818588, -0.11380967497825623, 0.12232708185911179, -0.6247645616531372, -0.40930357575416565, -0.18243879079818726, -0.12211605906486511, 0.791049063205719, 0.21128684282302856, 0.7786608934402466, 0.987327516078949, 0.48374155163764954, 0.655450701713562, 0.3784797489643097, 0.6767730116844177, 0.7136134505271912, -0.04137953370809555, 0.4653680622577667, 0.9344909191131592, 0.7561760544776917, -0.24750128388404846, 0.13895399868488312, 0.013573496602475643, 0.368535578250885, 0.4984271228313446, 0.5798799991607666, 0.265618234872818, 0.9145064353942871, 0.13090087473392487, -0.35512518882751465, 0.8985645771026611, -0.1225053071975708, -0.3921125829219818, -0.6270459294319153, 0.05579018220305443, -0.4327908754348755, 0.6579944491386414, 0.0012281896779313684, 0.2987487018108368, -0.3788948655128479, -0.6229681372642517, 0.6940794587135315, -0.03181080147624016, -0.25130414962768555, -0.36264246702194214, -0.8587020635604858, 0.14603284001350403, -0.23936204612255096, -0.5504888892173767, 0.671167254447937, 1.3550920486450195, 0.11605599522590637, -0.19769027829170227, -0.36826056241989136, -0.8638539910316467, -1.2088744640350342, -0.3179158568382263, -1.0454298257827759, -0.7082032561302185, -0.9901373386383057, 0.04535563662648201, 0.2996249198913574, -0.4105226695537567, 0.4507727324962616, 0.09899449348449707, -0.7769588828086853, -0.03973853588104248, -0.13085773587226868, 0.31743696331977844, 0.7997310161590576, -0.381001353263855, -1.130881428718567, 0.4714614748954773, 0.33937108516693115, 0.4120272696018219, 0.22573959827423096, -0.22763440012931824, -0.7997283935546875, -0.6391491889953613, 0.4604335427284241, -0.07408596575260162, 0.0001558665680931881, 0.49348998069763184, -0.6493523120880127, -0.15828746557235718, -0.7037829160690308, 0.9389709234237671, -0.1793297976255417, -0.6962155699729919, -0.8031877279281616, 0.3344365656375885, -0.8103293180465698, 0.22066530585289001, -0.009732617996633053, 0.029429152607917786, -0.7308289408683777, 0.4018653631210327, -0.17821922898292542, -0.22098487615585327, -0.9566472172737122, -0.26221057772636414, 1.0693403482437134, -0.30606821179389954, 0.08403974771499634, 0.030159318819642067, -1.455331802368164, 0.4349786341190338, -0.24242329597473145, 0.07594513893127441, -0.13085132837295532, 0.6027531623840332, 0.08413510024547577, -1.2983696460723877, 0.8137578964233398, -0.7437903881072998, -0.8624321222305298, 0.36918944120407104, -0.04680468142032623, -0.047759197652339935, 0.8733037114143372, -0.15242049098014832, -0.9722367525100708, 0.1586475670337677, 0.27567237615585327, 0.04475410655140877, 0.3352585732936859, -0.44376957416534424, 0.196577250957489, 0.4127987027168274, -0.07612034678459167, 0.49345457553863525, 0.819758415222168, -0.46463483572006226, -0.3084953725337982, 1.0631887912750244, -0.38841286301612854, -0.3119933009147644, 0.45879319310188293, 0.0778745487332344, 0.13644073903560638, 0.7121233940124512, -0.5366030931472778, 0.5593361854553223, 0.23101894557476044, 0.26505327224731445, 0.17502860724925995, 0.40549135208129883, -0.6618027687072754, 0.18879282474517822, -0.6311647295951843, -0.6762392520904541, 0.2593768537044525, 0.5641255974769592, 0.21669629216194153, 0.05624248832464218, 0.1812296211719513, -0.35076844692230225, -0.6221585869789124, 0.34818002581596375, -0.09258124232292175, -0.22889062762260437, 0.6867238283157349, 0.4048011898994446, 1.412806749343872, -1.6845849752426147, 0.20190784335136414, 0.26421919465065, 1.069951057434082, 0.7983099222183228, 0.27444881200790405, 0.5771889090538025, -0.5637374520301819, 0.13153120875358582, 0.037851881235837936, -0.47786200046539307, 0.21667352318763733, -0.8013576865196228, -0.4243451654911041, -0.2901502549648285, -0.9024880528450012, -0.8054727911949158, 0.03173232823610306, 0.3141946792602539, 0.2934369444847107, -0.21577899158000946, 0.8697310090065002, -0.31216588616371155, 0.14331892132759094, 0.843030571937561, 0.9909973740577698, 0.43387484550476074, -0.35994768142700195, 0.4207119047641754, -0.4795304834842682, -0.9925719499588013, 0.3046031594276428, -1.0582268238067627, -0.4084087908267975, -0.08529508858919144, 0.6127516627311707, -0.09584922343492508, -1.1104693412780762, 0.18319353461265564, -0.7380873560905457, -0.5920184850692749, 0.7534531950950623, 0.521181046962738, -0.5514321327209473, -0.07625098526477814, 0.514704167842865, -0.6773891448974609, 0.2525445818901062, -1.0138520002365112, 0.952081024646759, 1.1105598211288452, 0.34638190269470215, -0.12074185162782669, -0.17981913685798645, 0.5096355080604553, -0.12534171342849731, 0.5514144897460938, 0.5140093564987183, -0.2724507451057434, 0.4912589192390442, -1.1829568147659302, -0.24171330034732819, -0.1907598227262497, -0.23859816789627075, -0.6641172766685486, -0.043312955647706985, 0.23295153677463531, 1.0947602987289429, 0.6559625267982483, -0.023853449150919914, -0.18007148802280426, 0.35072803497314453, -0.9687978625297546, 0.38164380192756653, -1.0073004961013794, -0.2520267963409424, -0.5364525318145752, -0.06308703869581223, -0.09138894826173782, 0.4735337793827057, -0.1292707771062851, -0.6236571073532104, -0.40171703696250916, 0.007132217288017273, -0.4384899437427521, -0.6924937963485718, 1.1425424814224243, 0.6541039943695068, 0.2626442611217499, 0.8842257857322693, -0.15467213094234467, -0.23309555649757385, -0.018012626096606255, -0.2895811200141907, -1.1663002967834473, -0.2516675293445587, -0.04203147813677788, -0.23831607401371002, 0.7376089096069336, -0.24832534790039062, 0.5242794156074524, -0.4733605980873108, 0.07187146693468094, 0.05928685516119003, -0.3203827440738678, -1.1774601936340332, -0.4024762511253357, -0.44325944781303406, -0.050090182572603226, -0.8447006940841675, 0.7976312041282654, 0.0007519369246438146, -0.19920159876346588, -0.8453028798103333, 0.7717158794403076, -0.7537426352500916, 0.2650184631347656, -0.3065159320831299, 0.045470818877220154, -0.4418694078922272, -0.014615437015891075, 1.1049412488937378, -0.481842964887619, -0.7016026377677917, 0.08795331418514252, 0.5475280284881592, -0.5449596047401428, -0.89061439037323, -0.052223365753889084, -0.3822766840457916, -0.3265540301799774, -0.674344539642334, -0.19458727538585663, -0.84017014503479, -0.32016873359680176, -0.25933435559272766, 0.22600364685058594, 0.34995320439338684, -0.09331533312797546, 0.10455159842967987, 0.38213106989860535, 0.27437347173690796, -0.26286330819129944, -0.4053754210472107, 0.7361665368080139, -0.1760619431734085, 0.5483055114746094, 0.08072308450937271, -0.8110053539276123, -0.010021012276411057, -0.7497289180755615, -0.48113858699798584, -1.1514636278152466, 0.5242275595664978, -0.2981910705566406, 0.3597954511642456, -0.30977314710617065, -0.2330412119626999, 1.042372226715088, 0.4162144660949707, -0.2301967442035675, -0.7521079182624817, 0.9850515723228455, -0.34808626770973206, -0.36568886041641235, 0.13236534595489502, -0.4219398498535156, 0.3310333490371704, 0.9152535796165466, -0.08836353570222855, -1.1768152713775635, -0.17507655918598175, 0.6592772006988525, 0.8773959875106812, -0.09133997559547424, -0.5302234888076782, -0.2970879375934601, 0.3883538842201233, 1.1411999464035034, -0.429290235042572, -0.8925576210021973, -0.6782065629959106, 0.8904880285263062, -0.7069202065467834, -0.01218902412801981, 0.19691188633441925, -0.5697618126869202, 0.19710898399353027, 0.21867290139198303, 1.1450679302215576, -0.45005500316619873, 0.4751831293106079, -0.19774338603019714, 0.20520493388175964, 0.5274242758750916, 0.20890983939170837, -0.6424369215965271, -0.7101811766624451, -0.42169472575187683, -0.6523317098617554, 0.22183066606521606, -0.48007577657699585, 0.11629167944192886, 0.07704835385084152, -0.40285226702690125, 0.23080430924892426, 0.23798681795597076, 1.3307825326919556, 0.8316061496734619, -0.11501938104629517, 0.33094316720962524, 0.4816815257072449, -0.058430857956409454, -0.1383473128080368, 0.4243159890174866, 0.2187454104423523, 0.3320002555847168, 0.4129253625869751, -0.02675081416964531, 0.1574307382106781, -1.444339394569397, -0.3363724946975708, 0.24018217623233795, 0.744138777256012, -0.19057148694992065, 0.9148659110069275, 0.31156492233276367, -0.8127173185348511, -0.16191419959068298, 0.5447781682014465, 0.24395382404327393, -0.20364543795585632, 1.3439795970916748, -0.057877201586961746, -0.36256393790245056, 0.9332116842269897, -0.2058778703212738, 0.12957462668418884, -0.05913623049855232, 0.6685621738433838, 0.13648222386837006, -0.9016950130462646, 0.2527235746383667, 0.23529277741909027, 0.12242631614208221, -0.6153711080551147, -0.7867613434791565, -0.3252260088920593, 0.3358413875102997, 0.27595600485801697, 0.06401340663433075, 0.17197951674461365, -1.1702780723571777, 0.40768760442733765, -0.1427459567785263, -0.32206031680107117, -0.24735572934150696, 0.5956590175628662, 0.20709173381328583, -1.7414473295211792, 0.21148493885993958, 0.4567957818508148, -0.4893001914024353, 0.20455221831798553, 0.2895394265651703, -0.48551470041275024, 0.4778793752193451, -0.44855618476867676, 0.6389778256416321, -0.7580093741416931, 0.34237203001976013, 0.5026487708091736, 0.11354685574769974, 0.4168223440647125, 0.2592988908290863, -0.3731454312801361, 1.1369479894638062, 0.2795475423336029, -0.991188645362854, -0.6683236360549927, 0.2424577921628952, 0.06471824645996094, 0.3701077699661255, -0.17697764933109283, 0.1291673481464386, 0.35861673951148987, 0.1793110966682434, 0.004604525864124298, -0.5368351340293884, -0.37186262011528015, -0.7424077987670898, -0.15930910408496857, -0.10147915780544281, -0.1383744478225708, -0.062301408499479294, 0.23696395754814148, -0.5353967547416687, -1.4343193769454956, 0.013702942989766598, 0.9846997261047363, -0.10446557402610779, 0.7594391107559204, -0.34514325857162476, -0.628818929195404, -0.6762004494667053, -0.7023849487304688, -0.4389113485813141, -0.35503482818603516, 0.4251881539821625, 0.9313343167304993, -0.8888821601867676, -0.32568031549453735, -0.8601984977722168, 0.10193049907684326, 1.0062732696533203, 0.3595290780067444, -0.4770364463329315, -0.7306363582611084, -0.8677743673324585, 0.710304319858551, -0.07014265656471252, 0.19064101576805115, 0.5195867419242859, -0.22895534336566925, 0.0184984989464283, -0.0062782675959169865, 0.15759466588497162, 0.04700792208313942, -0.07437171787023544, 0.2790263295173645, -0.629663348197937, -0.322522908449173, -0.7685192227363586, 0.3490484654903412, -1.156315803527832, -0.8341193199157715, -0.6139448881149292, 0.22317206859588623, -0.6897860169410706, -0.5354312062263489, -0.1588207334280014, 0.33213940262794495, 0.1732063889503479, 0.7326213121414185, -0.8024328947067261, 0.3682418167591095, -0.022285878658294678, -0.25250568985939026, -0.002552703022956848, 0.12474403530359268, 0.7431159615516663, -1.3004441261291504, 0.9178844690322876, 0.5720298886299133, -0.5789243578910828, 0.24481752514839172, -0.6184777617454529, -0.2969225347042084, -0.0684029683470726, -0.7268604040145874, 0.6554873585700989, 0.9221007823944092, 0.5304024815559387, 1.0645751953125, -0.6577563881874084, -0.7695997357368469, -0.1909330040216446, -0.37893763184547424, -1.11282217502594, -0.03204840049147606, 0.362848162651062, -0.15672823786735535, -0.34728455543518066, -0.8743604421615601, -0.5018419623374939, 0.40333911776542664, 0.13550837337970734, -0.5253062844276428, 0.4098478853702545, 0.6699674129486084, -0.3089171350002289, 0.6451824903488159, -0.13488127291202545, 0.16762402653694153, -0.012714611366391182, 0.1020558774471283, -0.8788822293281555, -0.6377267837524414, -0.3326662480831146, 0.6278753876686096, 0.3689449429512024, -0.6799677014350891, -0.5657047033309937, 0.5308115482330322, -0.738468587398529, -0.33864909410476685, -0.07376990467309952, 0.5331928730010986, -0.8444463014602661, -0.400439590215683, 0.2151586264371872, -0.07660696655511856, -0.329578161239624, 0.4376554489135742, -0.20285683870315552, -0.30871373414993286, -0.8825690746307373, 0.03360048308968544, 0.8777827024459839, 0.06198599562048912, 0.3116515874862671, -0.07661944627761841, 0.28271710872650146, 0.07956264168024063, -0.5625579953193665, 0.3315795063972473, 0.7997792363166809, -0.16408610343933105, -0.14289698004722595, -0.17799365520477295, 0.13397227227687836, 0.756907045841217, 0.015056977979838848, -0.5917901396751404, 0.568769633769989, -0.1239393800497055, 0.7886961102485657, 0.3311725854873657, -0.5168037414550781, 0.41572120785713196, 0.09192363172769547, -0.43715599179267883, 0.1139661967754364, 0.2521962821483612, 0.5953536629676819, 0.598560094833374, -0.3505484461784363, 1.222705602645874, -0.5390104651451111, -0.573852002620697, -0.5151715278625488, 0.05074954032897949, 0.9449275732040405, -0.21238432824611664, 0.22244587540626526, 0.3586465120315552, 1.0403192043304443, 0.5626450777053833, -0.3344179391860962, -0.19564804434776306, 0.26102572679519653, 0.37296611070632935, -0.7910407185554504, -0.013702582567930222, -0.3144168555736542, -0.13806875050067902, 0.21708115935325623, -0.05126319080591202, 0.09786314517259598, -0.2689739763736725, 0.09629806876182556, 0.3574458658695221, 0.6914307475090027, 0.2880436182022095, -0.18836474418640137, -0.4352853298187256, 0.47649091482162476, -0.4016757309436798, -0.032446667551994324, 0.05734584480524063, -0.09480347484350204, 0.01726144552230835, -0.12703761458396912, 0.7225192785263062, 0.05848158523440361, 0.22355619072914124, 0.38045230507850647, -0.4290323853492737, 0.26530635356903076, 0.49298515915870667, -0.309416264295578, -0.07989990711212158, -0.4542366862297058, 0.09522568434476852, -0.571938693523407, -0.6913172602653503, -0.003592468099668622, 0.5642762780189514, -0.4326324164867401, -0.11701768636703491, -0.02626616694033146, 0.14631015062332153, 0.12345024198293686, -1.123663306236267, 0.2841954231262207, -0.324387788772583, -0.03167529031634331, -0.4336485266685486, 0.46792811155319214, -0.02068408951163292, -0.0007101118681021035, 0.07949946075677872, 0.10728137195110321, -0.8201326727867126, 0.612917423248291, -0.972005307674408, 0.9100766777992249, 0.31574657559394836, -0.3470766842365265, -1.0907244682312012, -0.6920797824859619, -0.08219577372074127, -0.03810156509280205, 0.18911343812942505, -0.9546254873275757, 0.42164158821105957, 0.7097362875938416, 0.5620803833007812, 0.17460642755031586, 0.3486796021461487, 0.12598146498203278, 0.27926263213157654, 0.9247607588768005, -0.48917219042778015, -0.004603145644068718, -0.7744206190109253, -0.17320366203784943, -0.02961062267422676, -0.17328010499477386, -0.2093193084001541, 0.8452463746070862, -0.8133485317230225, -0.28807902336120605, -0.04948222637176514, -0.3067609965801239, -1.0937435626983643, -0.10395131260156631, 0.6805711388587952, -0.43733447790145874, -0.4737693667411804, -0.029584679752588272, 0.16919994354248047, -0.20800940692424774, 1.0063018798828125, -0.1580507457256317, 0.2172442376613617, 0.05604087561368942, 0.026989402249455452, 0.6902335286140442, -0.7908219695091248, 3.820556879043579, 0.626558244228363, 0.22269736230373383, -0.7830438017845154, 0.9064079523086548, 0.47196298837661743, 0.2087860256433487, -0.28002995252609253, 0.015802720561623573, 0.3024832308292389, -0.7083902955055237, 0.4198504686355591, -0.5046741962432861, -0.08885300904512405, 0.44760650396347046, 0.10301721841096878, -0.7197262048721313, 0.720495879650116, -0.1948416531085968, -1.0169472694396973, -0.8103789687156677, 1.1818634271621704, -0.2985113561153412, 0.4563344717025757, 0.03910139203071594, 0.4780300259590149, -0.1762028932571411, 0.42046546936035156, -0.06161468103528023, 0.3718065023422241, 0.46937912702560425, -0.5952183604240417, 0.02393530309200287, -0.43179646134376526, -0.39731621742248535, 0.07665031403303146, 0.296673983335495, -0.395147442817688, 0.0210004523396492, -0.41465941071510315, 0.2892672121524811, 0.15802475810050964, -0.14188437163829803, -0.4550723731517792, -0.41312164068222046, 0.4589773118495941, -0.25765460729599, -0.6372494101524353, 0.36192697286605835, -0.34476885199546814, 0.9248722791671753, -0.39680832624435425, 0.2995343804359436, -0.37148162722587585, -0.8698353171348572, 0.41496777534484863, -0.0030545087065547705, -1.4936188459396362, 0.4408532679080963, 0.33054232597351074, 0.6581268310546875, -0.2118011862039566, 0.35812994837760925, 0.323133647441864, -0.1973525881767273, -0.32855042815208435, -0.0475076362490654, -0.5745065212249756, -0.20996050536632538, -0.2788676619529724, -0.14961619675159454, -0.04719708859920502, -0.30594444274902344, -0.2538492977619171, 0.2135365605354309, 0.5084319710731506, -0.8264082670211792, 0.4609438478946686, -0.5038689970970154, -0.626636803150177, 0.36216625571250916, -0.07286172360181808, 0.5741718411445618, -0.5376949310302734, 0.40696296095848083, 0.7978760600090027, 0.15437257289886475, -0.08746913820505142, -0.3043490946292877, 0.2989951968193054, 0.8766639828681946, -0.4041789174079895, 0.638841450214386, 0.4159609377384186, -0.06410258263349533 ]
{"Title": "Interdependence between confirmed and discarded cases of dengue, chikungunya and Zika viruses in Brazil: A multivariate time-series analysis", "Authors": "Oliveira Juliane F, Rodrigues Moreno S., Skalinski Lacita M., Santos Aline ES, Costa Larissa C., Cardim Luciana L., Paix\u00e3o Enny S., da Concei\u00e7\u00e3o N. Costa Maria, Oliveira Wanderson K., Barreto Maur\u00edcio L., Gl\u00f3ria Teixeira Maria, Andrade Roberto F. S.", "Abstract": "Abstract The co-circulation of different arboviruses in the same time and space poses a significant threat to public health given their rapid geographic dispersion and serious health, social, and economic impact. Therefore, it is crucial to have high quality of case registration to estimate the real impact of each arboviruses in the population. In this work, a Vector Autoregressive (VAR) model was developed to investigate the interrelationships between discarded and confirmed cases of dengue, chikungunya, and Zika in Brazil. We used data from the Brazilian National Notifiable Diseases Information System (SINAN) from 2010 to 2017. There were two waves in the series of dengue notification in this period, one occurring in 2013 and the second in 2015. The series of reported cases of both Zika and chikungunya reached their peak in late 2015 and early 2016. The VAR model shows that the Zika series have a significant impact on the dengue series and vice versa, suggesting that several discarded and confirmed cases of dengue could actually have been cases of Zika. The model also suggests that the series of confirmed chikungunya cases is almost independent of the cases of dengue and Zika. In conclusion, co-circulation of arboviruses with similar symptoms could lead to misdiagnosed diseases in the surveillance system. We argue that the use of mathematical and statistical models routinely in association with traditional symptom-surveillance could help to decrease such errors and to provide early indication of possible future outbreaks. These findings address the challenges regarding notification biases and shed new light on how to handle reported cases based only in clinical-epidemiological criteria when multiples arboviruses co-circulate in the same population. Author summary Arthropod-borne viruses (arboviruses) transmission is a growing health problem worldwide. The real epidemiological impact of the co-circulation of different arboviruses in the same urban spaces is a recent phenomenon and there are many issues to explore. One of this issue is the misclassification due to the scarce availability of confirmatory laboratory tests. This establishes a challenge to identify, distinguish and estimate the number of infections when different arboviruses co-circulate. We propose the use of multivariate time series analysis to understand how the weekly notification of suspected cases of dengue, chikungunya and Zika, in Brazil, affected each other. Our results suggest that the series of Zika significantly impact on the series of dengue and vice versa, indicating that several discarded and confirmed cases of dengue might actually have been Zika cases. The results also suggest that the series of confirmed cases of chikungunya are almost independent of those of dengue and Zika. Our findings shed light on yet hidden aspects on the co-circulation of these three viruses based on reported cases. We believe the present work provides a new perspective on the longitudinal analysis of arboviruses transmission and call attention to the challenge in dealing with biases in the notification of multiple arboviruses that circulate in the same urban environment.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002246"}
10.1101/19012211
[ 0.6533582806587219, -0.8318283557891846, -0.34230560064315796, 0.5500970482826233, -0.16156814992427826, -0.578210711479187, -0.061888910830020905, -0.07331941276788712, 0.8547659516334534, 0.28147006034851074, 0.27567437291145325, 0.10329534858465195, 0.34300029277801514, -0.47333911061286926, 0.158305361866951, -0.4485695958137512, -0.005281886551529169, -0.40185031294822693, -0.3771526515483856, -0.4179050028324127, 0.1884564757347107, 0.2757744789123535, -0.8194062113761902, 0.061057597398757935, -0.44713258743286133, 0.5553592443466187, 0.291065514087677, -0.05463084205985069, 1.036458969116211, 0.4891606271266937, -0.5676475763320923, -0.5346239805221558, 0.8264132738113403, -1.1423263549804688, -0.23879945278167725, -0.47620123624801636, 0.8844638466835022, -0.2077813595533371, -0.3386381268501282, -0.7588474750518799, 0.3436833322048187, -0.4392853379249573, 0.0820232555270195, 0.18771584331989288, -0.8491900563240051, -0.42441561818122864, -0.9254297018051147, -0.20841355621814728, 0.4597559869289398, -0.329796701669693, -0.45470479130744934, 0.19249795377254486, -0.14504700899124146, -0.6104214787483215, -0.19444875419139862, 0.11104104667901993, -0.3416067659854889, 0.30671268701553345, -0.26254215836524963, 0.45828765630722046, -0.08333621919155121, -0.2349773645401001, 0.38466882705688477, -0.8710445761680603, 0.5592724680900574, 0.5235755443572998, 0.37276962399482727, -0.3793758749961853, 0.4657285511493683, -0.8828904032707214, -0.40466076135635376, 0.4670771062374115, 0.23840224742889404, -0.5750421285629272, -0.36470749974250793, -0.32086196541786194, 0.19774171710014343, -0.30900129675865173, -0.13943514227867126, -0.6263471245765686, 0.107386015355587, 0.400086373090744, 0.4659813344478607, -0.15800170600414276, 0.051924336701631546, -0.06450846791267395, 0.24319323897361755, -0.044198911637067795, 0.6985202431678772, 0.10701719671487808, 0.47721484303474426, 0.6340339183807373, 0.6919686794281006, -0.058729324489831924, -0.41406598687171936, 1.0446224212646484, -0.7160990834236145, 0.13864731788635254, 0.5603787899017334, 0.44928961992263794, 0.22705470025539398, 0.9697840213775635, -0.9104744791984558, 0.9327377080917358, -0.8860095739364624, 0.3864884376525879, 0.5960505604743958, -0.7398787140846252, -0.43602612614631653, -0.4784470796585083, 0.13697420060634613, 0.15157990157604218, -0.38274717330932617, -0.020220892503857613, 0.4681148827075958, 0.5239511728286743, -0.47880586981773376, 0.2429349720478058, -0.23774950206279755, 0.006240352056920528, 0.2977888882160187, -0.5756946802139282, 0.8801631331443787, -1.1205928325653076, 0.8376508355140686, 0.10175866633653641, 0.13477449119091034, 0.882443904876709, -0.3869225084781647, -0.35893937945365906, -0.15468566119670868, -0.7348603010177612, 0.0395389199256897, 0.3547299802303314, -0.29767826199531555, -0.23816640675067902, 0.3459632992744446, 0.47202640771865845, 0.47733375430107117, -0.5816872119903564, 0.01915646530687809, 0.3766839802265167, -1.1756731271743774, 0.797124445438385, 0.11978471279144287, 0.6133390665054321, -0.865127444267273, -1.0716907978057861, -0.8602281808853149, 0.2414960116147995, -0.23734761774539948, 0.1473083645105362, 0.05007138103246689, 0.3325323164463043, -0.03364510089159012, 0.8675721883773804, 0.09842183440923691, 0.3795838952064514, -0.3165571093559265, 0.14513927698135376, -0.5818662643432617, 0.21646562218666077, -0.05356977880001068, 0.3445611298084259, -0.5463017225265503, 0.7365405559539795, 0.1957099288702011, -0.27016139030456543, -0.36047127842903137, -0.7605050802230835, 0.5116331577301025, -0.5863493084907532, -0.35098469257354736, 0.12770938873291016, 0.11257127672433853, 0.9964373111724854, 0.7463601231575012, 0.7308765649795532, -0.3013627231121063, 0.3609054684638977, 0.04525287449359894, -0.29174503684043884, -0.14363637566566467, 0.8074058294296265, -0.3061143755912781, 0.32983118295669556, -0.07247540354728699, -0.7527716755867004, -0.12819546461105347, -0.203168123960495, -0.5284130573272705, 0.7858280539512634, 0.24107779562473297, 0.19868585467338562, -0.4806922674179077, 0.2617816925048828, 0.1545274555683136, 0.18163281679153442, 0.46610257029533386, 0.22848904132843018, -0.6836591958999634, 0.480933278799057, -0.9798156023025513, 0.5502902269363403, -0.5720598697662354, 0.6657560467720032, 0.4004612863063812, 0.3799254894256592, 0.13699784874916077, -0.24017861485481262, 0.4282805919647217, -0.3606110215187073, -0.23954631388187408, 0.1991228610277176, 0.5805267691612244, -0.9348847270011902, -0.12764282524585724, 0.593471348285675, 0.1983645260334015, 0.6006733775138855, -0.6176270246505737, -0.4200904369354248, 0.7829384207725525, 0.6431093811988831, 0.16598859429359436, 0.47126996517181396, 0.10426685214042664, 0.12048721313476562, -0.3021395206451416, -0.7400011420249939, 0.09195587038993835, 0.9988080263137817, -0.785231351852417, 0.7455432415008545, 0.4505508542060852, 0.7439212203025818, 0.16026049852371216, 0.5998398065567017, 0.19943243265151978, -0.12221456319093704, 0.24984371662139893, -0.01878361590206623, 0.7312642931938171, 0.4428679049015045, -0.5370691418647766, 0.5770127177238464, -0.6532664895057678, 0.16425548493862152, -0.18313895165920258, 0.861452043056488, -0.10679541528224945, 0.45590972900390625, 0.6019015908241272, 0.4070848524570465, -1.3664954900741577, -0.49881213903427124, -0.19967114925384521, 0.6822461485862732, -0.27042946219444275, -0.6278612613677979, 0.4403481185436249, 0.06550182402133942, -0.5580576062202454, 0.14898677170276642, 1.0000195503234863, 1.2622302770614624, 0.17490506172180176, -0.2094350904226303, -0.03088330291211605, -0.34760621190071106, -0.5926336646080017, -0.5550783276557922, -1.4622023105621338, -0.28524497151374817, -0.8369188904762268, -0.12478427588939667, 0.26129502058029175, -0.6326581835746765, 0.47115233540534973, 0.05694286525249481, -0.13592888414859772, -0.13868147134780884, -0.5918322205543518, -0.19332122802734375, 0.4057219326496124, 0.27765166759490967, -1.400375485420227, 0.30492275953292847, 0.12045178562402725, 0.11896387487649918, -0.34924113750457764, -0.29895615577697754, -0.7888469099998474, -0.11246787756681442, -0.0864672064781189, -0.6486518383026123, 0.03109883889555931, -0.4057405889034271, -0.8262342810630798, -0.2369898557662964, 0.5624239444732666, 0.6613008379936218, 0.6502127647399902, 0.230980783700943, -0.2893080711364746, 1.102104902267456, -0.31207969784736633, 0.15088948607444763, 1.2839205265045166, 0.7301634550094604, -0.6512206196784973, 0.7745786905288696, -0.18178831040859222, -0.19199930131435394, -0.3380749225616455, 0.17580793797969818, 0.6695280075073242, -0.34944283962249756, 0.37331506609916687, -0.7662214040756226, -0.7365939021110535, -0.031000835821032524, -0.031221816316246986, -0.08307316899299622, 0.3399818241596222, 0.38921526074409485, 0.5139286518096924, -1.1760669946670532, -0.4580344557762146, -0.11918260157108307, -0.5836765766143799, -0.35088831186294556, 0.099667988717556, -0.31757619976997375, 0.3205747604370117, -0.010495060123503208, -0.4886385202407837, 0.44256791472435, 0.49911555647850037, 0.2758788466453552, -0.027615422382950783, -0.780773401260376, 0.2036147266626358, 0.25299888849258423, 0.13855613768100739, 0.2796534597873688, 0.06389135122299194, 0.07302981615066528, -0.7061202526092529, -0.26653850078582764, -0.9806828498840332, 0.12086673080921173, 0.0512026883661747, -0.18819183111190796, -0.24104902148246765, 0.2078918069601059, 0.30249303579330444, -0.13674533367156982, 0.4339236319065094, 0.07413584738969803, 0.2560547888278961, 0.1608913242816925, -0.33806222677230835, 0.09196151793003082, -0.5319026112556458, -0.9469705820083618, 0.3788885474205017, 0.18869411945343018, 0.5927301049232483, -0.4807801842689514, 0.9663554430007935, 0.1343848705291748, -0.17992235720157623, -0.08707228302955627, -0.3538719713687897, 0.042258866131305695, 0.0508001409471035, -0.4581754207611084, 1.038285255432129, -0.7541332244873047, 0.20854906737804413, 0.9792916178703308, 1.162365198135376, -0.16512905061244965, 0.5377412438392639, 0.2521020174026489, -0.10820062458515167, 0.706312894821167, 0.5553227066993713, -0.5822100639343262, 0.12378747761249542, -0.10420581698417664, 0.11810009926557541, -0.2953977882862091, -0.5931879878044128, 0.1814415156841278, 0.26226308941841125, 0.5151658058166504, 0.23783224821090698, 0.34717366099357605, 1.142203688621521, 0.47464245557785034, 0.190740168094635, 0.20072954893112183, 0.36699172854423523, -0.5505281090736389, -0.7056077718734741, -0.2125348150730133, -0.5117443203926086, 0.06327223777770996, -1.0046260356903076, 0.4332942068576813, -0.22396500408649445, 0.4689447283744812, -0.4567204415798187, -0.15667767822742462, -0.3212399482727051, 0.25290876626968384, -0.29984819889068604, 0.34712186455726624, 0.0925520658493042, -0.25622084736824036, -0.18863381445407867, -0.006346442736685276, -0.2933439612388611, -0.5653133988380432, -0.35651513934135437, 0.08933073282241821, 0.1873142421245575, 0.32661962509155273, -0.8315188884735107, -0.2617592513561249, -0.7268689870834351, -0.19121810793876648, -0.8155175447463989, 0.3926451504230499, 0.03446643799543381, -0.24850735068321228, -0.09843756258487701, -0.28740376234054565, -0.0565960668027401, -0.7007900476455688, -0.37149450182914734, -0.777490496635437, 0.0721537321805954, -0.03150036558508873, 1.5857950448989868, -0.17765241861343384, -0.37800145149230957, 0.035490814596414566, 0.9314202666282654, -0.25731590390205383, 0.5243356823921204, -0.43518370389938354, -0.6216789484024048, 0.22078676521778107, -0.5420545935630798, -0.17793145775794983, 0.5624104738235474, 0.287174791097641, -0.8113436698913574, -0.4337412416934967, 0.22815269231796265, -0.04226486757397652, 0.009296699427068233, 0.5379099249839783, -0.17800810933113098, 1.3173078298568726, 0.9093987941741943, -0.35700544714927673, 0.28273507952690125, -0.1231267973780632, 0.24002136290073395, -0.47312596440315247, 0.38661128282546997, 0.10545143485069275, -0.37868690490722656, 0.9163976907730103, -0.35708799958229065, 0.07973805069923401, 0.14187146723270416, 0.6562513709068298, -0.2668580710887909, 0.06900198757648468, -0.44558781385421753, 0.07627344131469727, -0.42219722270965576, -0.16739241778850555, -0.3597412109375, -0.08636458218097687, 0.2583352327346802, -0.4461807608604431, 0.5434892177581787, 0.787351131439209, -0.5800581574440002, -0.7831464409828186, -0.7321422696113586, -0.07089142501354218, -0.21204759180545807, 0.0356617271900177, 0.1706276834011078, -1.1126132011413574, -0.6152607202529907, -0.04592866450548172, -0.5952337384223938, -0.34147319197654724, -0.44740527868270874, -0.5477099418640137, 0.28768864274024963, -0.6707338094711304, -0.3130680024623871, -0.16186204552650452, -0.4617180824279785, -1.1464908123016357, -0.19763991236686707, -0.21631336212158203, 0.2639884352684021, 0.5110067129135132, -0.22425778210163116, 0.9541950225830078, 0.06058777496218681, -0.5839819312095642, -0.6286864876747131, 0.29370999336242676, -0.06812521070241928, 0.2410925328731537, 0.2650519907474518, -0.5373082756996155, -0.30881208181381226, -0.4077063500881195, 0.10889925062656403, -0.34741634130477905, -0.09649696201086044, 0.24217209219932556, -0.11295687407255173, -0.21832655370235443, -0.10519802570343018, 0.11153776943683624, 0.11880951374769211, -0.4121588170528412, -0.2530018389225006, 0.2849186658859253, -0.17641352117061615, 0.0036287428811192513, -0.532665491104126, -0.42894241213798523, -0.6917881369590759, 0.2648870646953583, 0.2140352427959442, -0.07551458477973938, -0.25490912795066833, 0.4285799264907837, 0.20427952706813812, -0.06956425309181213, 0.26735231280326843, -1.2227712869644165, -0.2616499364376068, 0.16841550171375275, 0.27362188696861267, 0.5982261896133423, -0.9557576775550842, 0.3750694990158081, -0.5613341331481934, -0.021314458921551704, -0.11381985992193222, -0.6670663952827454, -0.6218661069869995, -0.801207959651947, 0.5851226449012756, -0.46152010560035706, 0.7874516248703003, 0.4705936014652252, 0.17571653425693512, -0.3144998550415039, 0.23252032697200775, -0.7796129584312439, -0.32177111506462097, -0.6968493461608887, -1.0324335098266602, 0.5225071907043457, -0.08707872033119202, -0.013770253397524357, 0.18096837401390076, -0.42850226163864136, 0.4149200916290283, -0.6154435873031616, 0.8556935787200928, 0.7089920043945312, -0.6672873497009277, -0.7357183694839478, -0.3462177813053131, 0.07274629175662994, -0.04856447875499725, -0.09878139942884445, -0.39603957533836365, -0.38469672203063965, 0.45191243290901184, -0.6483646035194397, 0.03350164741277695, -1.4240597486495972, -0.1443658024072647, 0.18826784193515778, 0.41513699293136597, -0.2613919973373413, 0.27525794506073, -0.44631531834602356, -0.07425832003355026, -0.5000214576721191, 0.29057514667510986, -0.20411624014377594, 0.5728707909584045, 0.6468326449394226, -0.12210448831319809, 0.24718713760375977, 0.17021164298057556, -0.18304003775119781, -0.3545617461204529, -0.3979828953742981, 0.3204747140407562, 0.2479415088891983, -1.0043092966079712, 0.7809445858001709, -0.011951548047363758, -0.3330041170120239, -0.378642201423645, 0.5557698011398315, -0.2803965210914612, -0.6930810809135437, 0.48892858624458313, -0.3379993736743927, 0.54731684923172, -0.8847987055778503, 0.7755917906761169, -0.2850703001022339, 0.10263030230998993, -0.6206232309341431, -0.6179004907608032, -0.017520105466246605, -0.6215092539787292, -0.20606766641139984, 0.7239471077919006, 0.018529219552874565, 0.16972662508487701, -0.36834707856178284, 0.33095285296440125, 0.19941796362400055, -0.08811100572347641, 0.26692822575569153, 0.11563016474246979, 0.41498953104019165, -0.16216497123241425, 0.28570055961608887, 0.3130824565887451, 0.3304595947265625, -0.6383054852485657, 0.8086458444595337, 0.5400094985961914, -0.6060969829559326, 0.16956326365470886, 0.16205134987831116, 1.3301118612289429, 0.34768402576446533, 0.04127613455057144, 0.04430701583623886, 1.0244488716125488, -0.298492968082428, 0.14842690527439117, -0.4810006320476532, -0.2973681688308716, -0.7266263365745544, -0.5210639834403992, -0.4025889039039612, -0.10793185234069824, -0.5783613920211792, 0.6536980271339417, -0.2782130539417267, -0.40817421674728394, -0.25427383184432983, 0.9974415302276611, 0.8733786344528198, -0.05344218388199806, -0.0678739920258522, -0.026609176769852638, -1.2533823251724243, -1.5020657777786255, -0.02489534765481949, -0.5517812967300415, 0.9619429111480713, 0.5843190550804138, -1.2904399633407593, -0.604815661907196, 0.6841802597045898, -0.1807146966457367, -0.12455745786428452, 0.4460548460483551, -0.5729413628578186, 0.17330330610275269, 0.2304612398147583, 0.02871859446167946, -0.04856569319963455, -0.5458948612213135, 1.033761739730835, -0.4362577497959137, 0.5293380618095398, 0.6944576501846313, -0.3521978259086609, -0.15481120347976685, 0.21635515987873077, 0.5201836824417114, -0.9722146391868591, -0.3491891622543335, -0.05281759053468704, 0.6221902370452881, -0.9383288621902466, -0.3650526702404022, -0.4348262548446655, -0.6943160891532898, 0.879191517829895, 0.4063813388347626, 0.5520557165145874, 1.0870823860168457, 0.37147796154022217, 0.11206890642642975, -0.47515755891799927, 1.3491324186325073, 0.8218787312507629, 0.05952007323503494, 0.3865516185760498, -0.07405366003513336, 0.07246893644332886, -0.6168903112411499, -0.03843952342867851, 0.6141141653060913, -0.564784049987793, 0.25077366828918457, -0.07487663626670837, 0.645002007484436, -0.2964864671230316, -0.7921927571296692, 0.21728846430778503, 0.7590500712394714, 0.9299175143241882, 1.1815345287322998, 0.44360673427581787, -0.3863147795200348, -0.41886454820632935, -0.6252784729003906, -0.8423187136650085, -0.9458217024803162, 0.7097017168998718, -0.01868385262787342, -0.07667393237352371, -0.15884681046009064, -0.417140394449234, 0.5341362357139587, 0.6160285472869873, 0.3689268231391907, -0.39609774947166443, -0.07823418825864792, 0.43731674551963806, -0.3013332188129425, -0.20613504946231842, 0.23453889787197113, 0.29767081141471863, 0.5106272101402283, -0.010366448201239109, 0.14481575787067413, 0.20060640573501587, 0.18647564947605133, 0.32279205322265625, -0.35400497913360596, -0.5628394484519958, 0.7084528207778931, 0.4701180160045624, -0.22356589138507843, -0.6731613874435425, 0.001463195076212287, -0.9467176795005798, 0.30331286787986755, 0.2698841094970703, -0.1481534242630005, 0.0756034106016159, -0.2305956333875656, -0.2710321545600891, 0.02102263830602169, -0.14412984251976013, -0.6677887439727783, 0.9117483496665955, -0.9369141459465027, 0.6504471302032471, -0.05497084558010101, 0.3204823136329651, -0.27184244990348816, -0.3045748174190521, 1.0539551973342896, 0.42776623368263245, 0.5191164612770081, 0.4512878954410553, 0.10735519230365753, -0.06254461407661438, 1.096731185913086, 0.39378198981285095, 0.14705002307891846, 0.242055743932724, -0.045355286449193954, -0.056433260440826416, -0.550006628036499, 0.2001151442527771, 0.707981526851654, 0.1564132422208786, -0.11262724548578262, 0.05294039845466614, 0.15843288600444794, -0.09274806827306747, 0.3166060149669647, -0.07172022759914398, -0.1782694011926651, -1.6584618091583252, -0.85495525598526, -0.638446033000946, -0.2151770144701004, 0.3319694995880127, -0.3675207197666168, 0.0650789886713028, -0.554110050201416, 0.3910122513771057, -0.38507533073425293, -0.040941569954156876, 0.46792468428611755, -0.45240721106529236, -0.4400951564311981, -0.38304322957992554, 0.4740072786808014, 0.08958277851343155, 0.11011964082717896, 0.7419928312301636, -0.4958011209964752, 0.40874722599983215, 0.9307747483253479, -0.564393162727356, -0.29013288021087646, 0.3065398633480072, -0.12582992017269135, 0.05077337846159935, -1.0858163833618164, 0.003283408936113119, -0.9673620462417603, -0.27380186319351196, 0.42118844389915466, -0.440748393535614, 0.6774196624755859, 0.7131513953208923, 0.7530277967453003, 1.277819275856018, 0.28236278891563416, 0.3022829592227936, -0.4262414276599884, -0.15167605876922607, 0.3050992786884308, -0.16775698959827423, -0.2144732028245926, 0.2545185983181, -0.24235820770263672, -0.5176560878753662, -0.03265339881181717, 0.6714563965797424, 0.4365125298500061, -0.029046377167105675, 0.20476682484149933, 0.4311326742172241, -0.2375461906194687, 0.07172784209251404, -0.9839428067207336, -0.20371781289577484, 0.03391140699386597, 0.22520829737186432, -0.0026002610102295876, 0.17116306722164154, 0.1766134351491928, 0.1684449017047882, -0.5350155830383301, -0.017952732741832733, -0.011193467304110527, -0.2787012755870819, -0.5262563228607178, 0.07805387675762177, -0.5261616110801697, -0.23570913076400757, -0.1080281063914299, -0.7234350442886353, 0.6080507040023804, 0.21026694774627686, 0.002228216966614127, -0.5017903447151184, 0.8397719264030457, 0.738120436668396, 0.8659451603889465, 0.13136090338230133, -0.365355908870697, -0.3392224609851837, 0.30099204182624817, 0.5493612289428711, 0.24413155019283295, 0.5539352893829346, 0.6147651076316833, 0.0677320808172226, 0.3602704405784607, 0.06127325817942619, 0.3027482330799103, 0.1669609546661377, 0.22804051637649536, -0.27168524265289307, 0.29833269119262695, 0.1460781693458557, -0.48074832558631897, 0.9302247166633606, 0.9536281228065491, 0.6045209169387817, -0.5150623321533203, -1.1911351680755615, -0.1601511687040329, -0.28035709261894226, 0.400155246257782, 0.5286314487457275, 0.6141828894615173, 0.15000833570957184, -0.24955539405345917, 0.5590324997901917, -0.5474461317062378, 4.145096778869629, 1.3171780109405518, 0.4615978002548218, -0.15109360218048096, 0.7171330451965332, 0.04996266961097717, 0.9245806336402893, -0.7530636191368103, 0.3200051784515381, 0.1976189911365509, 0.11549047380685806, -0.5538780689239502, 0.1643553376197815, -0.30488184094429016, 0.2639005184173584, 0.4305117130279541, -0.44538331031799316, 0.04958159103989601, 0.1475219875574112, -1.464248538017273, -1.167301893234253, 0.46451815962791443, -0.3685562312602997, 0.5006745457649231, 0.6354708671569824, -0.10075537860393524, -0.18789991736412048, -0.25371161103248596, -0.21908652782440186, -0.3742215633392334, -0.5289046764373779, -0.6140576004981995, 0.10734125226736069, 0.16204801201820374, -0.41755881905555725, 0.9565279483795166, -0.23130358755588531, -1.137972116470337, 0.22216834127902985, 0.31097787618637085, -0.27585774660110474, -0.3157300651073456, 0.16461755335330963, -0.05199657753109932, -0.4287353456020355, -0.0055860476568341255, -0.8605043292045593, 0.606052041053772, 0.31260305643081665, -0.8112165331840515, 0.8166729211807251, -0.4927634298801422, 0.4338107109069824, 0.030629487708210945, -0.3746759295463562, -0.9815233945846558, -0.4399179518222809, -0.8814128041267395, 0.19224616885185242, 0.7688427567481995, 1.4718271493911743, 0.5818179845809937, 0.05439450964331627, 0.01765326038002968, -0.30116698145866394, 1.0837116241455078, 0.18428640067577362, 0.6584197878837585, 0.050255246460437775, -0.7707926034927368, 0.276678204536438, -0.019920960068702698, -0.5370030999183655, -0.034435171633958817, 0.21018941700458527, 0.22378714382648468, -0.3143155872821808, 0.7633602023124695, -0.3202071189880371, -0.8312536478042603, 0.1477528214454651, 0.7465735673904419, 0.07059173285961151, -0.3324660360813141, 0.279791921377182, 0.1870676577091217, -0.3042078912258148, -0.6390700340270996, -1.3662443161010742, 0.2978180944919586, 0.27492788434028625, 0.3155517578125, -0.4801708459854126, -0.18851934373378754, -0.24353207647800446 ]
{"Title": "Dysmetabolic circulating tumor cells are prognostic in metastatic breast cancer", "Authors": "Brisotto Giulia, Biscontin Eva, Rossi Elisabetta, Bulfoni Michela, Piruska Aigars, Spazzapan Simon, Poggiana Cristina, Vidotto Riccardo, Steffan Agostino, Colombatti Alfonso, Huck Wilhelm T. S., Cesselli Daniela, Zamarchi Rita, Turetta Matteo, Ben Fabio Del", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT The prognostic value of the circulating tumor cells (CTCs), defined as EpCAM+, Cytokeratin (8, 18, 19)+ and CD45-nucleated cells, has been provided in metastatic breast cancer (mBC), with Level I of evidence. However, CTCs belong to a heterogeneous pool of rare cells, and there isn\u2019t consensus on an univocal definition of CTCs. Here, we present a definition of metabolically altered CTCs (MBA-CTC) as CD45-negative cells with an increased extracellular acidification rate (iECAR), supported by the presence of iECAR among the hallmarks of cancer. We tested the prognostic value of MBA-CTC present in mBC patients before starting a new systemic therapy (T0) and 3-4 weeks after (T1). Samples were analyzed in parallel with CellSearch platform (CS). Standard RECIST criteria were used to determine patients\u2019 responses to treatment. In our cohort of n=31 mBC patients, a level of MBA-CTCs above the cut-off was associated with: i) a shorter median PFS both pre-therapy (123 days vs 306; p<0.0001) and during therapy (139 vs 266 days; p= 0.0009); ii) a worse OS both pre-therapy (p=0.0003, 82% survival vs 20%) and during therapy (p=0.0301, 67% survival vs 38%); iii) good agreement with therapy response (kappa=0.685). Both the trend of MBA-CTCs over time and the combined results of the two assays (MBA and CS) enabled more accurate stratification. MBA and CS results showed fair (K=0.33) and poor (K=0.077) agreement at T0 and T1, respectively. This fact and the increased accuracy in combining results suggest that the assays detect different CTC subsets. In conclusion, MBA-CTCs does provide prognostic information at least equivalent to CS, and are even more informative when analyzed over time or combined with CS-CTCs.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19012211"}
10.1101/19003301
[ 0.14117711782455444, 0.9995696544647217, -0.34437838196754456, 0.29966992139816284, -0.4677295982837677, -0.17513854801654816, -0.46506863832473755, -0.6796568632125854, 0.1828566938638687, 0.7779759168624878, -0.25623807311058044, -0.7705627083778381, -0.03584539145231247, -1.2744802236557007, -0.04075001925230026, -0.03666626289486885, -0.8695087432861328, -0.7024356722831726, -0.2904016673564911, -0.6825315356254578, -0.011882309801876545, -0.09255459904670715, -0.7510141730308533, 0.4770938754081726, -0.9643926620483398, -0.04510096088051796, 0.699994683265686, -0.6503146886825562, 1.3298287391662598, 0.6419380903244019, 0.42457035183906555, -0.7177870869636536, 0.39496591687202454, -0.9260402917861938, 0.7122829556465149, -1.045338749885559, 1.1332292556762695, -0.41675639152526855, -0.0999583825469017, -0.49574026465415955, 0.17122329771518707, 0.6699554920196533, -0.6343598961830139, -0.8111616373062134, -0.1772959977388382, -1.1897282600402832, -0.3429861068725586, -0.06908535957336426, -0.10975698381662369, -0.27150294184684753, -0.3803170919418335, -0.20787784457206726, 0.008643366396427155, -0.3329901397228241, 0.31316089630126953, -0.059763867408037186, -0.12413816899061203, -0.5320277214050293, -0.36104562878608704, 0.18233874440193176, 0.9156514406204224, 0.32073500752449036, 0.6743027567863464, -0.7020034790039062, 0.9339171648025513, 0.4643741250038147, -0.2488405555486679, -0.48824337124824524, -0.5310392379760742, -0.5029525756835938, -0.6177920699119568, 0.6985903978347778, -0.4665878117084503, -0.986417293548584, -0.6209657788276672, -0.1282476931810379, 0.456994891166687, -0.030784957110881805, 0.03139735385775566, -0.24974627792835236, -0.24311022460460663, 0.0037423267494887114, -0.2411867082118988, 0.05672077089548111, -0.173355370759964, -0.1292005479335785, 0.5996338129043579, -0.10999473184347153, 0.11696259677410126, 0.16472089290618896, 0.6869986057281494, 0.545444667339325, 0.39091089367866516, 0.4333692193031311, -0.14478284120559692, 0.3890151381492615, -0.04232202470302582, 0.4335380792617798, 0.7176228761672974, 0.21723689138889313, -0.12797729671001434, 0.8734083771705627, -0.13734710216522217, 1.0812498331069946, -0.07886700332164764, 0.060651104897260666, -0.2670091390609741, 0.07508481293916702, -0.1589522361755371, -0.5215973854064941, 0.022731222212314606, 0.13585205376148224, -0.3387743830680847, 0.16962897777557373, -0.5437072515487671, 0.6048256754875183, 0.32552576065063477, 0.7235887050628662, -0.3396907150745392, 0.43873411417007446, 0.09990283846855164, 0.12907665967941284, 0.619192361831665, -0.17197386920452118, 0.15872201323509216, -0.3216094970703125, 0.06923464685678482, 0.15001538395881653, -0.28554290533065796, -0.3735005557537079, -0.3013628125190735, -0.046825580298900604, -0.4576168656349182, 0.6242990493774414, 0.291011780500412, -0.21837252378463745, 0.27057960629463196, 0.0047832028940320015, -0.08849545568227768, -0.16955706477165222, -0.26654908061027527, 0.43551138043403625, -0.21428154408931732, 1.3616260290145874, -0.22267016768455505, 0.3462439179420471, -0.34038546681404114, 0.12951615452766418, 0.3119136095046997, -0.07615088671445847, -0.505405068397522, 0.5887457728385925, 0.15607547760009766, -0.2753252685070038, 0.057058222591876984, -0.19706925749778748, -0.19514146447181702, 0.34335920214653015, -0.7852973341941833, 0.02489239163696766, 0.1970619261264801, 0.6079777479171753, -1.4268959760665894, -0.07000336796045303, -0.6955769658088684, 0.48875463008880615, 0.16537980735301971, -0.20048758387565613, 0.2975558936595917, -1.1242064237594604, 0.12149369716644287, 0.35720181465148926, 0.9493122696876526, 0.11687840521335602, 0.19958007335662842, -0.3359717130661011, 1.2111982107162476, 0.6299952268600464, 0.38036495447158813, 0.2571827471256256, -0.2975444495677948, -0.6270508766174316, 0.265414297580719, 0.6161182522773743, 0.11201385408639908, 0.13006363809108734, -0.3158859312534332, -0.29192379117012024, -0.1413871943950653, -0.09858394414186478, 0.3221992254257202, 0.6921969056129456, -0.17717953026294708, -0.2057936191558838, -1.1090596914291382, 0.3598233461380005, 0.05544812232255936, 0.13802067935466766, 0.18953362107276917, -0.47735100984573364, -0.00903148390352726, 0.38372889161109924, -0.11209537833929062, 0.9503923654556274, -0.724262535572052, 1.0441690683364868, 0.9358741641044617, 0.8073387742042542, -0.47632449865341187, 0.2435580939054489, 0.20376628637313843, -0.04957525432109833, -0.38212642073631287, 1.020738959312439, 0.36547091603279114, -0.8327534794807434, -0.20921924710273743, 0.19508245587348938, 0.6137211918830872, 0.7865615487098694, -0.3840537667274475, -0.7679418921470642, 0.5084812641143799, 0.3027348220348358, 0.1587752103805542, -0.1608743667602539, -0.09950459003448486, 0.15261508524417877, 0.4026530981063843, 0.14237995445728302, -0.35356247425079346, 0.3767075538635254, 0.06351933628320694, 0.45459771156311035, 0.6697962284088135, -0.040078774094581604, 0.6530992984771729, 0.0310676172375679, 1.1246479749679565, 0.018844377249479294, -0.292968213558197, 0.11980906128883362, 0.8572855591773987, 0.6822291612625122, -0.2322390079498291, 0.12996195256710052, 0.21475888788700104, -0.6238431930541992, 0.0812293216586113, -0.7962784171104431, -0.30271920561790466, 1.8746415376663208, -0.0030033160001039505, 0.5512731075286865, -0.8509173393249512, -0.5013293623924255, 0.4324192404747009, 0.7955406904220581, -0.20877130329608917, -0.854072630405426, 0.036425817757844925, 0.14240962266921997, 0.23180197179317474, 0.39497748017311096, 0.19161513447761536, 0.4102238714694977, -0.23366641998291016, 0.4912518858909607, -0.030114034190773964, -0.4123477041721344, -0.3083387613296509, -0.6106339693069458, -0.8682774901390076, -0.11221625655889511, -0.39845728874206543, -0.9050248861312866, -0.5069812536239624, -0.44661059975624084, 0.5963379740715027, -0.3479083478450775, 0.14772044122219086, -0.6249583959579468, 0.08032611757516861, 0.41592979431152344, -0.17325827479362488, -0.6645781993865967, -0.8699774742126465, 0.16325370967388153, -0.05797563120722771, 0.8129703402519226, 0.0288836769759655, -0.6456642150878906, -0.9899466633796692, -0.5405193567276001, 0.029138687998056412, -0.40870195627212524, -0.35932493209838867, 0.5071826577186584, 0.24136000871658325, -0.015218636021018028, 0.2601735591888428, 0.2837199866771698, -0.1644488275051117, -0.29701441526412964, -0.6104376316070557, 0.2523679733276367, -0.04702359810471535, 0.025308765470981598, 0.4165806174278259, 0.7006314396858215, -0.9259526133537292, 0.21292485296726227, 0.4896654784679413, 0.14402878284454346, -0.33806872367858887, -0.1959460973739624, 0.6702792048454285, -0.7732687592506409, -0.06325330585241318, -0.6335912346839905, -1.1693307161331177, -0.5936972498893738, -0.09412617981433868, -0.5016127824783325, 0.017932219430804253, 0.9544909596443176, 0.33151522278785706, -0.7573569416999817, 0.15600591897964478, -1.2292197942733765, -1.4173284769058228, 0.4553164541721344, 0.15568064153194427, 0.7722761034965515, 0.6383183598518372, 0.0846843421459198, -0.09626160562038422, 0.5972272157669067, 0.38975489139556885, 0.564746618270874, 0.9821507334709167, -0.7163457274436951, -0.3445848226547241, 0.2769310176372528, -0.037605177611112595, 0.37697604298591614, -0.12423448264598846, -0.39673349261283875, -0.11432314664125443, 0.24226689338684082, -0.9936875700950623, -0.14808444678783417, -0.05238886550068855, -0.10854707658290863, 0.7489064931869507, 0.2056286782026291, -0.15893034636974335, -0.261039137840271, 0.43893489241600037, 0.9372135996818542, -0.24743512272834778, -0.21224436163902283, -0.32244449853897095, 1.5291794538497925, -0.41305381059646606, -0.5308855772018433, 0.23259170353412628, -0.4810402989387512, 0.26367810368537903, -0.9583949446678162, 0.742807149887085, 0.7102044820785522, -0.3121163249015808, 0.25110483169555664, 0.19077490270137787, 0.7737025022506714, 0.8528919816017151, -0.5630621314048767, 1.7431501150131226, -1.1053835153579712, 0.5752497911453247, 0.9243457913398743, -0.060895029455423355, 0.4334961771965027, -0.2452775239944458, 0.010418947786092758, -0.05544174462556839, -0.026349972933530807, -0.015717534348368645, 0.2718433737754822, -0.3116433322429657, -0.3928757607936859, -0.36214399337768555, -0.12207034230232239, -0.5189633965492249, -0.028469929471611977, 0.8391902446746826, 0.20113664865493774, 0.09050603955984116, -0.12136130779981613, 0.2663682997226715, -1.2795028686523438, 0.6643695831298828, 0.6208440661430359, 0.46267402172088623, 0.2713250517845154, -0.24300585687160492, 0.4062972366809845, -0.6358256340026855, -0.10453363507986069, -0.21811319887638092, 0.5597981810569763, -0.6230846643447876, 0.33047348260879517, 0.2572236657142639, 0.8282946348190308, -0.021391961723566055, -0.312842458486557, -0.3464093804359436, -0.22708269953727722, -0.07215108722448349, 0.11887737363576889, -0.49087610840797424, 0.2926585376262665, 0.08368691056966782, -0.8644598722457886, 0.717318594455719, -1.3122081756591797, 0.5142092704772949, 0.7377590537071228, -0.6637004613876343, -0.3027839958667755, -0.19115637242794037, -0.6307246088981628, -0.694253146648407, -0.23680438101291656, 0.6816223859786987, 0.2821367681026459, -0.01642487570643425, 0.0566454753279686, -0.7205700278282166, -0.5168483257293701, -0.6957689523696899, -0.6802167296409607, 0.15195466578006744, 0.5655835866928101, -0.2416258007287979, 0.33430737257003784, 0.4196404814720154, -0.016209878027439117, 0.7299829125404358, -1.3478922843933105, 0.5960039496421814, -0.49913710355758667, -0.3257203996181488, 0.27053412795066833, 0.17292295396327972, -0.3434808850288391, -0.3552219867706299, -0.5376151204109192, -0.5568292737007141, 0.005481087137013674, 0.3668830692768097, -0.05406596139073372, -1.177400827407837, 0.13065476715564728, 0.2656119465827942, 0.2890848219394684, 0.46177855134010315, -0.7561203837394714, 0.2537156939506531, -0.7682819962501526, -0.31006330251693726, -0.33467501401901245, 0.40476447343826294, -0.38119062781333923, 0.5127013325691223, 0.10802658647298813, -0.9062971472740173, 0.6387065052986145, -0.31118351221084595, 0.417099267244339, -0.3025672435760498, -0.281764417886734, -0.6324188709259033, -0.5511135458946228, -0.7400498986244202, -0.1704724282026291, -0.5013620853424072, 0.6692517995834351, 0.11324325203895569, -0.09296761453151703, -0.25745144486427307, -0.17273862659931183, -0.4491778016090393, -0.15054190158843994, -0.7693474292755127, -0.32960212230682373, 0.1096617802977562, 0.3191239535808563, 1.1856069564819336, -0.9568741917610168, 0.20888012647628784, 0.1870368868112564, 0.42805397510528564, -0.5596356987953186, -1.0130858421325684, -0.19533897936344147, -0.343696653842926, -0.5892437696456909, -0.3665846288204193, 0.36033108830451965, -0.549506664276123, 0.26773738861083984, -0.6459163427352905, -0.05132634565234184, 0.12112884968519211, -0.18884490430355072, -0.7946912050247192, 0.50860196352005, -0.005569992586970329, -0.9308596849441528, -0.691836416721344, 0.059136997908353806, -0.053445082157850266, 0.19865059852600098, -0.15093855559825897, -0.47274187207221985, 0.11734090000391006, 0.6155074238777161, 0.3319341242313385, 0.08840769529342651, 0.21735893189907074, -0.768248438835144, -0.3818293511867523, -1.0447843074798584, 0.39141345024108887, 0.5447143316268921, 0.07117896527051926, 0.297276109457016, -0.3532067537307739, -0.12406391650438309, -0.3110593855381012, -0.31864073872566223, -0.22079826891422272, -0.18824420869350433, 0.16037319600582123, 1.0021003484725952, 0.3575388789176941, -1.154991865158081, 0.9946279525756836, -0.5269533395767212, 0.6450051069259644, 0.26453468203544617, -0.46062374114990234, -0.7344930171966553, -0.3888622522354126, 0.8460362553596497, -0.23127241432666779, 0.16402852535247803, -0.46210208535194397, 0.6049073338508606, -0.42588651180267334, 0.8974074125289917, -0.9569658041000366, 0.2478056252002716, -0.1378154307603836, -1.09452486038208, 0.4885087013244629, 0.19850602746009827, -0.4850216805934906, 0.5527116656303406, 0.13988348841667175, 0.5361963510513306, -0.3021634817123413, -0.7719733119010925, -0.8847978115081787, -1.0149564743041992, -1.0006498098373413, 0.030819140374660492, -0.038916002959012985, -0.2392885386943817, 0.2925569415092468, 0.5581942200660706, 0.2583930492401123, -1.0035245418548584, 0.9677107334136963, 0.21008478105068207, -0.05892767757177353, -0.34209513664245605, -0.09811296314001083, -0.0545450858771801, 0.2996121942996979, 0.08098604530096054, 0.2002415955066681, -0.7621656060218811, 0.5467138886451721, -0.21574319899082184, -0.7587040066719055, -0.7727506756782532, -0.40487879514694214, 0.3046181797981262, 0.24302786588668823, -0.5580724477767944, -0.04851587489247322, -0.1580609381198883, -0.7248260974884033, -0.11701188236474991, 0.4437590539455414, -0.1139015257358551, 0.23535855114459991, 1.113346815109253, -0.2415182888507843, -0.1437014788389206, 0.26427122950553894, -0.6088700890541077, -0.1955554038286209, -0.2957598567008972, 0.27319762110710144, 0.656915009021759, -0.7855044603347778, 0.5816721320152283, -0.15967383980751038, -0.9588332772254944, -0.3684317171573639, 0.23040564358234406, -0.3653930425643921, -0.06221598759293556, -0.7466108202934265, -0.19795344769954681, -0.19551539421081543, 0.05837944149971008, -0.8175342082977295, 0.09314262866973877, -0.8338184952735901, 0.6096456050872803, -0.2625347375869751, -0.3557179272174835, -0.535075843334198, 0.4715420603752136, 0.49028608202934265, 0.33917132019996643, 1.113745093345642, -0.24436847865581512, 0.463739812374115, -0.24727299809455872, -0.18445512652397156, 0.1357070356607437, -0.09377691149711609, 0.3768485188484192, 0.19552016258239746, 1.1359150409698486, 0.03396345302462578, 0.7485645413398743, -0.45487698912620544, 0.3418283462524414, 0.5548694133758545, -1.291124939918518, -0.25238269567489624, 0.09450230747461319, 0.7251980900764465, 0.6587890982627869, -0.673201858997345, -0.38531824946403503, 1.0214914083480835, 0.9817166328430176, 0.7018222808837891, -0.3090988099575043, -0.5883674621582031, -0.760178804397583, -0.08483316004276276, -0.2790214717388153, -0.8223022222518921, -0.0864858627319336, 1.271951675415039, -0.6607941389083862, -0.36572375893592834, -0.0029215894173830748, -0.5220951437950134, -0.7363929748535156, -0.6493890285491943, -1.0429083108901978, -0.4148925244808197, 0.14380541443824768, -0.45547860860824585, -0.041099704802036285, -0.2643960118293762, -0.2913758456707001, 0.49588242173194885, -0.15425895154476166, -0.023546859622001648, 0.5116089582443237, 0.3513249456882477, -0.6909993290901184, 0.8470001220703125, 0.08010125905275345, 0.303747296333313, 0.44710618257522583, 0.02510007657110691, -0.02042633853852749, 0.7661945223808289, -0.3311674892902374, -0.4328756332397461, 0.4949658513069153, 0.20055565237998962, 0.3882006108760834, -0.06710343807935715, 0.24600742757320404, 0.361431747674942, -0.5633698105812073, -0.29339924454689026, 0.07003030925989151, 0.25178974866867065, -0.22648507356643677, -0.008257986046373844, -0.21518409252166748, 0.5303032398223877, -0.378670871257782, 0.043010495603084564, 0.0981765165925026, 1.1481634378433228, 0.4070836007595062, 0.09625567495822906, -0.030931487679481506, 0.2914424538612366, -0.06266552209854126, 0.6128045916557312, 0.2693924009799957, 0.45519140362739563, 0.061937447637319565, -1.4289964437484741, 0.10638149082660675, 0.4106694161891937, -0.5051792860031128, -0.08789049088954926, -0.4458787143230438, 0.06319320946931839, 0.14262539148330688, -0.2577553987503052, 0.49614399671554565, 0.6831270456314087, 0.018522877246141434, -0.2298489809036255, -0.0691194012761116, 0.2873276174068451, -0.7134291529655457, 0.07849467545747757, -0.6764674186706543, -0.6416769027709961, 0.08564462512731552, -0.3311675786972046, 0.2033754140138626, -0.3799215853214264, -1.186779499053955, 0.2550366520881653, 1.0572210550308228, -0.012580177746713161, -0.1435108333826065, 1.3651031255722046, 0.5229694843292236, 0.7640557289123535, 0.2734052240848541, -0.5191786289215088, 0.2166130542755127, 0.29124078154563904, -0.3067892789840698, -0.5462907552719116, 0.2640787959098816, 0.3100282549858093, 0.6362284421920776, -0.8836816549301147, -0.3758912980556488, 0.0756232962012291, -0.13564752042293549, 0.15342701971530914, -0.5032954216003418, -0.11397766321897507, -0.7122125029563904, 0.10380987077951431, -0.7100753784179688, 0.044943153858184814, 0.05989537760615349, 0.17708702385425568, 0.05009620636701584, 0.011984504759311676, -0.4709976017475128, -0.20266538858413696, 0.306959331035614, -0.8561164736747742, -0.07765994966030121, -0.13173244893550873, 0.6923851370811462, 0.015578851103782654, 0.142185777425766, 0.13551831245422363, 0.41003477573394775, 0.3543998599052429, -0.01864745281636715, -0.6573219299316406, 0.8633251190185547, 1.036663293838501, 0.10740998387336731, -0.10662932693958282, 0.7206339240074158, 0.05870306119322777, -0.5828470587730408, 0.23565377295017242, -0.6666549444198608, 0.778271496295929, 0.00976240262389183, -0.0318959578871727, -0.4502386748790741, 0.2994980216026306, -0.2580585777759552, -0.11457027494907379, -0.5070604681968689, 0.8701496124267578, 0.26523610949516296, -0.4135426878929138, -0.07308157533407211, 0.4261821508407593, 1.5233190059661865, 0.01955655962228775, -0.15505880117416382, -0.7576639652252197, 0.3493955135345459, 0.7260048985481262, 0.0627267062664032, 0.7545516490936279, 0.0974062904715538, -0.2911263108253479, -0.25469714403152466, 0.5002168416976929, 0.08997675031423569, -0.12277068942785263, -0.2343805879354477, -0.04038612172007561, -0.8739621639251709, 0.09944767504930496, 0.32493001222610474, -0.6895173788070679, 0.4377773702144623, -0.09334024786949158, 0.0007119557121768594, -0.6858030557632446, 0.3102182447910309, -1.1797510385513306, -0.01682731881737709, 0.05064259469509125, -0.43798500299453735, -0.3060898184776306, 0.8139612078666687, 0.01592865213751793, 0.5917117595672607, 0.7186567783355713, 0.6790104508399963, -0.30706509947776794, 0.9468772411346436, 0.058731675148010254, 0.43843090534210205, -0.305187463760376, 0.5013094544410706, -0.6752768754959106, -0.14597178995609283, -0.5069038271903992, 0.18103155493736267, 0.2957833409309387, 0.11523875594139099, -0.4166114032268524, 0.29889917373657227, -0.03428039327263832, -0.3573676347732544, -0.1489100456237793, -0.3472440838813782, -0.5695400834083557, -0.29467713832855225, -0.00834175106137991, 0.969314694404602, 0.24178718030452728, 0.5057177543640137, -0.3978499472141266, -0.923467755317688, -0.22173058986663818, 0.3176991641521454, 0.4205438494682312, 0.48834800720214844, -0.35947030782699585, -0.6213441491127014, -0.050442177802324295, -0.5580378770828247, -0.7643839716911316, 0.6281462907791138, -0.40081554651260376, 0.0582519993185997, 0.2781527042388916, 0.38220956921577454, 0.5310024619102478, 0.7497515082359314, 0.10956279188394547, 0.6510698795318604, 0.47192198038101196, 0.8006532192230225, 0.28957682847976685, 1.0681853294372559, 0.24857133626937866, 0.5070467591285706, -0.5478878021240234, 0.13370323181152344, -0.032312456518411636, 0.08108051866292953, 0.1541595757007599, -0.5866486430168152, -0.43049588799476624, -0.504956841468811, -0.374454528093338, 0.19320301711559296, 0.11637173593044281, -0.6510707139968872, 0.07305924594402313, -1.1163525581359863, -0.12558752298355103, -1.0640519857406616, 0.2705230116844177, -0.24763666093349457, 0.9201977252960205, 0.2738795578479767, -0.3850681483745575, -0.2960115373134613, -0.5260561108589172, 4.053745269775391, 1.1487922668457031, 0.4627666473388672, 0.13298366963863373, 0.5354139804840088, 0.452462375164032, 0.6672884821891785, -1.0078907012939453, -0.044424597173929214, 0.6289041638374329, 0.2474203258752823, -0.18052922189235687, -0.08496475219726562, 0.12889395654201508, 0.29716601967811584, 0.7009063363075256, -0.07296618074178696, -0.3000416159629822, 0.29825642704963684, -1.5640246868133545, -0.550445556640625, 0.5433610677719116, -0.49215251207351685, -0.07135441899299622, -0.09203065186738968, -0.01760919764637947, 0.17342980206012726, 0.07222543656826019, 0.2784620523452759, -0.4898611903190613, 0.4141833186149597, -0.11831358820199966, 0.3518885672092438, -0.3867833614349365, -0.21481122076511383, 0.6213215589523315, 0.791530966758728, 0.2833229601383209, -0.501471996307373, 0.24488285183906555, 1.0242501497268677, -0.003235604614019394, -0.3885607421398163, -0.27412888407707214, -0.9036787748336792, 0.8718246221542358, -0.05916019156575203, 0.26373958587646484, 0.670315146446228, -0.7978722453117371, 0.9089358448982239, -0.48449093103408813, 0.4219667613506317, 0.5945019125938416, -0.9868950247764587, 0.47725215554237366, -0.6161790490150452, -0.17552369832992554, -0.5494192838668823, 0.6058903336524963, 1.0964527130126953, 0.9246678352355957, 0.42844831943511963, -0.31646788120269775, -0.3972223401069641, 0.27870604395866394, -0.11018022894859314, 0.5969902873039246, -0.1724882274866104, 0.4045581519603729, -0.005907564889639616, -0.12132277339696884, -0.5998216867446899, -0.2056695818901062, 0.5760276317596436, 0.8668500185012817, -0.25248488783836365, 0.4214252233505249, -0.2140538990497589, -0.4053320288658142, 0.07195187360048294, 0.4178243577480316, 0.7690173387527466, -0.45103490352630615, 0.8489629030227661, 0.612236499786377, -0.4774130880832672, 0.03237741068005562, -1.009048342704773, 0.39437195658683777, 0.43875381350517273, -0.05042598396539688, 0.13635431230068207, -0.5773742198944092, -0.18433181941509247 ]
{"Title": "Real-time Hearing Threshold Determination of Auditory Brainstem Responses by Cross-correlation Analysis", "Authors": "Wang Haoyu, Li Bei, Lu Yan, Han Kun, Sheng Haibin, Zhou Jialei, Qi Yumeng, Wang Xueling, Huang Zhiwu, Song Lei, Hua Yunfeng", "Abstract": "Summary Auditory brainstem response (ABR) serves as an objective indication of auditory perception at given sound level and is nowadays widely used in hearing function assessment. Despite efforts for automation over decades, hearing threshold determination by machine algorithm remains unreliable and thereby still rely on visual identification by trained personnel. Here, we described a procedure for automatic threshold determination that can be used in both animal and human ABR tests. The method terminates level averaging of ABR recordings upon detection of time-locked waveform through cross-correlation analysis. The threshold level was then indicated by a dramatic increase in the sweep numbers required to produce \u201cqualified\u201d level averaging. A good match was obtained between the algorithm outcome and the human readouts. Moreover, the method varies the level averaging based on the cross-correlation, thereby adapting to the signal-to-noise ratio of single sweep recordings. These features empower a robust and fully automated ABR test.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003301"}
10.1101/2019.12.14.19014654
[ 0.4864990711212158, -0.10470478236675262, -0.601899266242981, 0.25617995858192444, 0.00033757463097572327, -0.4960639774799347, 0.3791740834712982, 0.021777678281068802, 1.1198033094406128, 0.3992886245250702, -0.30875611305236816, -0.19757020473480225, 0.4142622649669647, -0.02621111087501049, -0.40133848786354065, -0.4211868643760681, -0.4953834116458893, -0.2192038744688034, -0.5428698658943176, 0.29784828424453735, 0.31700628995895386, 1.055906891822815, -0.86442631483078, -0.15875199437141418, -0.35393306612968445, 0.4269134998321533, -0.00603205431252718, 0.24883300065994263, 1.37623131275177, 0.4389552175998688, -0.1328284591436386, 0.23268702626228333, 0.16093622148036957, -0.4943774342536926, -0.4412728548049927, 0.4361189901828766, 0.4272560179233551, 0.47169357538223267, -0.23344686627388, -0.32693228125572205, 0.224050372838974, 0.28312167525291443, -0.14356186985969543, -0.34314441680908203, -1.0286718606948853, 0.0023931388277560472, 0.036618318408727646, -0.6121756434440613, -0.0642552450299263, -0.3417213261127472, -0.4306977391242981, -0.2917211651802063, 0.26352933049201965, -0.46720725297927856, -0.4581410586833954, 0.12040511518716812, 0.2875448763370514, 0.31610411405563354, -0.8352482914924622, 1.122288703918457, 0.5024610161781311, -0.6517546772956848, 0.796155571937561, -0.5455272197723389, 1.2109248638153076, 0.7184783220291138, -0.06342675536870956, -0.3714425265789032, -0.1744292974472046, -0.2602382302284241, -1.0873219966888428, 0.349052369594574, -0.5985873341560364, -1.0359947681427002, 0.206948921084404, -0.06212664395570755, 0.14586348831653595, 0.1069369837641716, 0.02972174435853958, -0.49337664246559143, 0.5936511754989624, 0.3958699405193329, 0.3169229030609131, 0.19387099146842957, -0.31408214569091797, 0.07467509061098099, 1.2340127229690552, -0.19848522543907166, -0.08691219985485077, 0.34309807419776917, -0.11675136536359787, 0.32936131954193115, 1.1205065250396729, -0.3235323429107666, -0.09512913972139359, 1.7017642259597778, -0.024164965376257896, 0.27831053733825684, 0.1014748364686966, -0.016039786860346794, 0.542715311050415, 1.1329115629196167, -0.6414029002189636, 1.3639782667160034, -0.5456427931785583, 0.7057679295539856, 1.0790818929672241, -0.5064871907234192, -0.6044593453407288, -1.3473623991012573, 0.15293675661087036, 0.07585767656564713, -0.4691373407840729, 0.30134665966033936, 0.5474094152450562, 1.1049505472183228, -0.5373043417930603, 0.2867526710033417, 0.021217625588178635, 0.3628273010253906, 0.0816490426659584, 0.4203137755393982, 0.5515077114105225, -0.8387532830238342, 0.7497888803482056, 0.1307901293039322, -0.009543231688439846, 0.7317997217178345, -0.16660374402999878, -1.0706490278244019, 0.6291003227233887, -0.5478489398956299, -0.13394470512866974, 1.0604215860366821, -0.8071504235267639, -0.020749136805534363, 0.8178276419639587, 0.05215373635292053, 0.7352357506752014, -0.4635729491710663, -0.17056025564670563, 0.024062704294919968, -0.549643337726593, 1.1967623233795166, -0.16703742742538452, 0.37928852438926697, -0.7150201201438904, -1.6498318910598755, -0.5946506857872009, -0.07604416459798813, -0.44605085253715515, -0.05939016863703728, -0.18304504454135895, 0.35542240738868713, 0.5485681295394897, 0.43946900963783264, -0.06816982477903366, 0.042954981327056885, -0.8321169018745422, 0.02417025715112686, -0.11780337244272232, 0.3551749289035797, -0.37073037028312683, 0.33650466799736023, 0.08593883365392685, 0.8724548816680908, -0.053845178335905075, 0.25383761525154114, -0.15038497745990753, -0.25932469964027405, 0.3684273660182953, -0.22147886455059052, -0.47767868638038635, 0.17004556953907013, 0.661465048789978, 0.7422377467155457, 0.8588436841964722, 0.3204505443572998, -0.43461042642593384, 0.22624053061008453, -0.2959158420562744, 0.41172587871551514, 0.5202494263648987, 0.7067165374755859, -0.8496007323265076, 0.48602795600891113, -0.08631917834281921, -0.4625962972640991, -0.330109566450119, -0.4862435758113861, -0.2056851089000702, 0.5311063528060913, -0.06601828336715698, 0.5589093565940857, -0.4931883215904236, 0.19726328551769257, -0.3156457841396332, 0.13162890076637268, -0.048533882945775986, -0.33036091923713684, -0.7830593585968018, 0.3847665786743164, 0.13846427202224731, 0.531849205493927, -0.4023638367652893, 1.041745662689209, 0.018358847126364708, -0.45178285241127014, -0.6355005502700806, 0.28632238507270813, 0.17023755609989166, 0.04976999759674072, -0.8311895132064819, 0.1770612597465515, 1.1038357019424438, -0.742918848991394, -0.52125483751297, 0.31206920742988586, -0.1009187325835228, 0.05849335715174675, -0.15877781808376312, -0.22648414969444275, 0.6981921195983887, 0.17487847805023193, 0.5098066329956055, 0.6943836808204651, 0.48412221670150757, 0.3525901734828949, -0.2462749034166336, -0.9419357180595398, 0.5284618735313416, 0.8546142578125, -0.9775426387786865, 1.34429132938385, 0.44413289427757263, 0.22408054769039154, -0.21499784290790558, 0.06288251280784607, -0.11434603482484818, -0.2331518530845642, 0.9282042384147644, -0.17341424524784088, 0.694438636302948, 0.6552716493606567, -1.094757080078125, 0.2170364111661911, -0.41195064783096313, 0.054735541343688965, -0.07641389966011047, 0.04237956181168556, -0.5479311347007751, 0.7782101035118103, 0.5451214909553528, 0.3818003833293915, -1.6297378540039062, -0.4041329324245453, 0.08850055932998657, -0.14437879621982574, -0.37325969338417053, 0.06664355844259262, -0.3801390528678894, 0.16682001948356628, -0.48913249373435974, -0.3941594064235687, 0.25247636437416077, 0.6114808320999146, -0.12765705585479736, -0.09513402730226517, -0.06077682599425316, -0.9203183054924011, -1.3472055196762085, -1.0078068971633911, -0.9880509376525879, -0.8160653114318848, -0.5141485929489136, -0.18984360992908478, 0.11618093401193619, -0.15824317932128906, 0.430450439453125, -0.2531442642211914, 0.3186167776584625, 0.03357705846428871, 0.5640807151794434, 0.2674107551574707, 0.482688844203949, 0.42204004526138306, -0.577210009098053, 0.593916654586792, -0.5193595290184021, 0.38943302631378174, 0.0016335737891495228, -0.1812109649181366, 0.1454572230577469, -0.6226123571395874, 0.3499266505241394, -1.1430193185806274, 0.05826139450073242, -0.03720752149820328, -0.7917931079864502, -0.2940964996814728, 0.6394721269607544, 0.3055959939956665, 0.42705991864204407, 0.2556639015674591, -0.860659658908844, 0.7214716672897339, 0.7961133718490601, -0.5525848269462585, 0.9036644101142883, 0.3762189745903015, 0.02149111032485962, 0.2492462545633316, -0.4408734142780304, -0.8996068239212036, -0.9255850911140442, -0.23365536332130432, -0.03800000622868538, -0.6236447095870972, -0.07265651226043701, -0.6593076586723328, -0.4914454221725464, 0.05119810253381729, -0.28346195816993713, -0.3218969702720642, 0.7992385625839233, 0.4842011332511902, 0.14469420909881592, -1.1258447170257568, -0.1550123691558838, -0.32933309674263, -0.6590203046798706, -0.1498115211725235, -0.11540310084819794, 0.6998967528343201, 0.464297354221344, -0.059840548783540726, -0.9185262322425842, 0.04609713330864906, 0.4145307242870331, -0.0019877778831869364, 0.004915466997772455, -0.37528330087661743, -0.25598466396331787, 0.28043851256370544, 0.852273166179657, 0.12089379131793976, 0.4268575608730316, -0.35245925188064575, -0.49494510889053345, 0.03223585709929466, -0.5537828207015991, -0.40859255194664, -0.03831353038549423, -0.8614071011543274, -0.27323782444000244, 0.41478148102760315, -0.11404751986265182, -0.7055530548095703, 0.5038570761680603, 0.32056230306625366, 0.04581211879849434, 0.42166560888290405, -0.014537355862557888, 0.17447789013385773, -0.2836693227291107, -1.0630390644073486, 0.15929052233695984, 0.481737345457077, 0.28486767411231995, -0.9047167301177979, 0.9786515831947327, -0.15509478747844696, -0.733167290687561, 0.5156453251838684, 0.20310746133327484, -0.4429467022418976, 0.106382817029953, -0.2166510671377182, 1.0651073455810547, -0.3741607367992401, -0.21517793834209442, 1.3788834810256958, 1.2755128145217896, 0.35011863708496094, 0.9062116742134094, 0.2767871618270874, -0.28708502650260925, -0.09972550719976425, 0.15886721014976501, -0.3513698875904083, -0.03521604835987091, -0.08082656562328339, -0.0027018869295716286, 0.25542861223220825, -0.6443709135055542, -0.12772700190544128, 0.19204871356487274, 0.3352470099925995, 0.09975311905145645, -1.0495573282241821, 1.4050909280776978, 0.12630639970302582, -0.28133559226989746, -0.10327433049678802, 0.5525787472724915, 0.23266537487506866, -0.719308078289032, -0.10281706601381302, -0.18679821491241455, -0.39925968647003174, -1.2449843883514404, -0.4625754654407501, 0.06736689060926437, -0.1250767856836319, 0.24227534234523773, 0.030358970165252686, -0.39897608757019043, -0.4286767542362213, -0.588563859462738, 0.6722231507301331, 0.9344008564949036, 0.01984725520014763, -0.41465044021606445, -0.18032321333885193, -0.154021754860878, -0.27688777446746826, -0.40100228786468506, -0.4413510859012604, -0.05688050761818886, 1.1194576025009155, -0.5789310932159424, -0.8163332343101501, -0.29880577325820923, -0.23246318101882935, -0.5030972957611084, 0.6368882656097412, 0.5147914290428162, -0.23553647100925446, 0.3820488750934601, -0.47131702303886414, -0.11631228774785995, -0.034209221601486206, -0.6331258416175842, -0.8428093194961548, 0.21182776987552643, -0.07655515521764755, 0.8149298429489136, 0.34387871623039246, 0.2644372880458832, 0.3742257356643677, 0.9968231916427612, -0.8230193853378296, 0.5190887451171875, -0.4349370002746582, -0.2341526299715042, 0.18052634596824646, -0.3965202271938324, -0.19486984610557556, 0.460128515958786, 0.038711871951818466, -0.3487662971019745, -0.056208014488220215, 0.08760298788547516, 0.4597398340702057, -0.058476950973272324, 0.9686855673789978, 0.16272124648094177, 0.6575347781181335, 1.1794419288635254, -1.1003135442733765, -0.6910811066627502, 0.0442240908741951, 0.12541018426418304, -0.46872735023498535, 0.7925978899002075, 0.19029493629932404, 0.4242408871650696, -0.6281210780143738, -0.7593159079551697, 0.4592015743255615, -0.6372403502464294, -0.2919749617576599, -0.7084641456604004, 0.09630803763866425, -0.08859213441610336, -0.5001075267791748, -0.6983582973480225, -0.3119916319847107, -0.9782028794288635, 0.42133018374443054, -0.5918413996696472, -0.6381517648696899, 0.634829044342041, -0.0806904286146164, -0.7802618741989136, -0.443509578704834, 0.05175482854247093, 0.23480212688446045, -0.34957197308540344, -0.3464212417602539, -0.08273526281118393, -0.8266683220863342, -1.1767966747283936, 0.25515520572662354, 0.3595190644264221, -0.9190220236778259, -0.07653284817934036, -0.9547135233879089, -0.009964228607714176, -0.27871134877204895, -0.11177430301904678, -0.11741174757480621, -0.3990854024887085, -0.3656400144100189, -0.5576602816581726, 0.3310406804084778, -0.13091136515140533, 0.0443345382809639, 0.0035418071784079075, 0.8877527117729187, -0.07608404755592346, -0.7078508138656616, -0.32389557361602783, -0.2039845734834671, 0.7638471126556396, 0.44801798462867737, 0.06666316837072372, -0.6127063632011414, -0.2189648300409317, -0.2901109755039215, 0.4669320583343506, -0.7466097474098206, -0.3607780635356903, -0.25586050748825073, -0.13953809440135956, -0.7189242839813232, -0.461744099855423, 0.21493855118751526, 0.043445389717817307, -0.6156781315803528, -0.22284278273582458, 0.09477496892213821, 0.25489169359207153, 0.2804834246635437, -0.4643910229206085, -0.14290200173854828, 0.6227689981460571, 0.8663367033004761, -0.2239789515733719, -0.007670854218304157, -0.46699270606040955, -0.26795369386672974, 0.3607161343097687, 0.9968493580818176, -0.2217257022857666, -0.7370892763137817, 0.09344851225614548, 0.002856869949027896, 0.6962036490440369, -0.1895526945590973, -0.16669757664203644, -0.02731667272746563, -0.8989296555519104, -0.2386537790298462, -0.4564594626426697, -0.13842247426509857, -0.1182054877281189, -0.12496805191040039, 0.632514238357544, -0.22218969464302063, 1.318943738937378, -0.12859533727169037, -0.6040751934051514, -0.11904884874820709, 0.47310149669647217, -0.5502804517745972, -0.03326326981186867, -0.6378186345100403, -0.8759710788726807, 0.630523681640625, -0.4414011836051941, -0.0709013044834137, -0.171188622713089, -0.6170739531517029, 0.31180933117866516, -0.2884819507598877, 1.4153110980987549, 0.9988194704055786, 0.10853778570890427, 0.0678495317697525, 0.4652462303638458, -0.03809418901801109, 0.2614523470401764, 0.34719452261924744, -0.09799724817276001, -0.16780787706375122, 0.1325143575668335, -0.3610272705554962, -0.3983481228351593, -0.500653088092804, -0.6729169487953186, 0.6403325200080872, 0.3755406141281128, 0.0478256419301033, 0.44900965690612793, -0.2837202548980713, -0.4655573070049286, -0.555618166923523, 0.2297135293483734, 0.15606829524040222, 0.17653514444828033, 0.2711198925971985, 0.1575903445482254, 0.21123246848583221, 0.24195405840873718, -0.38996773958206177, 0.6293895244598389, -0.17595142126083374, -0.055683668702840805, 0.14454491436481476, -0.8665655851364136, 0.8595241904258728, 0.22008277475833893, -0.28505298495292664, -0.8373282551765442, 0.15947292745113373, -0.23444212973117828, 0.15683399140834808, -0.5083308219909668, -0.16260699927806854, 0.46347516775131226, -0.25936412811279297, 0.34462863206863403, -0.07800502330064774, 0.019156480208039284, -0.27600565552711487, -0.2244575023651123, -0.07577826827764511, -0.5680924654006958, -0.04809911176562309, 0.668793797492981, -0.2964786887168884, 0.4392705261707306, -0.2957548499107361, 0.45290789008140564, 0.30751702189445496, 0.543195903301239, -0.22420912981033325, 0.05209644138813019, -0.41601938009262085, -0.15858076512813568, 0.3952282667160034, 0.25447818636894226, 0.3842923045158386, 0.16948507726192474, 0.3813837766647339, 0.4496610462665558, -1.2609397172927856, -0.11768200248479843, 0.7325644493103027, 0.5622363090515137, 0.409916490316391, 0.19832022488117218, 0.4774160087108612, 0.6906307339668274, 0.25743672251701355, 0.41480666399002075, -1.0451024770736694, -0.4268401861190796, -0.5114602446556091, -0.41623109579086304, 0.27825814485549927, 0.1356826275587082, -0.1767100989818573, 0.8216891288757324, -0.2260405570268631, -0.6570650935173035, 0.1995876133441925, 1.8068103790283203, 0.26428452134132385, -0.4495770335197449, -0.9226974248886108, 0.20579613745212555, -0.8400311470031738, -0.6625990867614746, -0.3036239445209503, -0.5951328873634338, 0.6251147389411926, 1.5528227090835571, -0.1403162181377411, -0.2935880422592163, 0.47440335154533386, -0.2536969482898712, -0.3643038868904114, 0.49467143416404724, -0.8744668960571289, -0.3764741122722626, -0.14679649472236633, 0.43648195266723633, 0.7572579383850098, -0.5491228103637695, 1.3770231008529663, -0.7874937057495117, 0.09585867822170258, 0.4028782844543457, 0.5001994371414185, -0.43725457787513733, 0.24337565898895264, 0.24717918038368225, -0.8916811943054199, -0.2987234592437744, -0.1153571680188179, 0.566836416721344, -1.0955761671066284, -0.4217744469642639, 0.5619859099388123, -0.4328548312187195, 0.06982837617397308, 1.136019229888916, 0.053407251834869385, 0.14166174829006195, 0.5003395676612854, 0.22781288623809814, -0.28513261675834656, 1.4052295684814453, 0.5004810690879822, -0.014027879573404789, 0.30292096734046936, 0.5585113763809204, -0.10399344563484192, -1.1949453353881836, 0.9503995180130005, 0.4058128893375397, 0.41923731565475464, 0.12749458849430084, -0.3025614619255066, 0.30837440490722656, 0.049444157630205154, -0.12629173696041107, -0.08242259919643402, 0.9504633545875549, 0.6962069272994995, 0.7652375102043152, 0.20502036809921265, -0.4992489814758301, -0.7932424545288086, -0.5219148397445679, -1.172305941581726, -1.4164403676986694, 0.3912156820297241, -0.10748877376317978, 0.051894329488277435, -0.6145241260528564, -0.017541637644171715, 0.08852526545524597, 0.2994689345359802, 0.12751057744026184, -0.49104559421539307, -0.028512978926301003, 0.16469509899616241, 0.010165102779865265, 0.2524314224720001, -0.20967964828014374, 0.1345714032649994, 0.9852659702301025, 0.17487511038780212, -0.17322112619876862, 0.19370178878307343, 0.4757480025291443, 0.4003845751285553, -0.6868017911911011, -0.7054758071899414, -0.34567826986312866, 0.8883894085884094, -0.4333873689174652, -0.8841366171836853, -0.15528970956802368, -0.21299320459365845, 0.03929723799228668, -0.15839128196239471, 0.12570533156394958, -0.19241026043891907, 0.30552399158477783, -0.15709467232227325, -0.7675623893737793, -0.306042343378067, -0.09634116291999817, 0.7709764838218689, -0.29006198048591614, 0.47924742102622986, -0.3963782787322998, 0.36835452914237976, -0.46924445033073425, -0.5408823490142822, 0.8103109002113342, 0.7276880741119385, 0.253618985414505, 0.14628195762634277, -0.08131244778633118, 0.3663090169429779, 1.0567392110824585, 0.676781177520752, 0.13420192897319794, 1.0308620929718018, -0.09655667841434479, 0.1944868117570877, 0.45379576086997986, -0.67425936460495, 0.31071949005126953, 0.09214258939027786, 0.13516509532928467, 0.34676557779312134, 0.4326583445072174, -0.019231479614973068, 0.15886493027210236, -0.19411294162273407, -0.023796608671545982, -0.937168538570404, -0.8204516172409058, 0.41091296076774597, -0.25611740350723267, 0.7019782066345215, -0.4138866066932678, 0.21792471408843994, 0.03735232725739479, -0.09582241624593735, 0.07848171144723892, 0.3175109326839447, 0.7287001013755798, -0.09230578690767288, -0.49626362323760986, -0.9491428136825562, 0.4746858775615692, -0.47990524768829346, 0.20826570689678192, -0.30603671073913574, -0.22784225642681122, 0.2261621356010437, 0.5974521636962891, 0.2733892798423767, -0.4026280641555786, 0.41815128922462463, -0.15205132961273193, 0.030026473104953766, -0.34300774335861206, -0.2652217149734497, 0.08385580033063889, -0.6467205286026001, 0.5760054588317871, -0.2631492018699646, -0.2900393307209015, -0.2220568060874939, 0.1994311809539795, 0.9111924171447754, 0.27748793363571167, 0.43929481506347656, -0.08481308817863464, 0.4297443926334381, 0.6771746277809143, -0.20972417294979095, -0.41332772374153137, -0.2906768023967743, -0.20727302134037018, -0.11355932056903839, -0.06374868005514145, 0.317966103553772, 0.2340654879808426, -0.3246597349643707, -0.5429532527923584, 0.01958332024514675, -0.425539493560791, 0.10094136744737625, -1.025439739227295, -0.35119205713272095, -1.037367343902588, 0.12598444521427155, -0.10059195756912231, 0.17304950952529907, -0.006073146127164364, -0.15320248901844025, 0.03082018345594406, 0.2605036795139313, -0.400331974029541, 0.6770305633544922, -0.7453635334968567, -0.22042804956436157, -0.11392132192850113, -0.19943459331989288, -0.5544578433036804, -0.6716012954711914, -0.30055302381515503, -0.09305792301893234, 0.3386450409889221, -0.13161975145339966, 0.16764256358146667, 0.2164309024810791, 0.9223345518112183, 0.3593142330646515, -0.4106424152851105, -0.1599448323249817, 0.4548585116863251, 0.2892596423625946, -0.10445644706487656, 0.7059712409973145, 0.2742209732532501, -0.25667715072631836, -0.06991040706634521, -0.07548324763774872, -0.05615584924817085, -0.3215000629425049, -0.4204317033290863, -0.3448677957057953, 0.06994665414094925, -0.19060270488262177, -0.872286319732666, 0.33388257026672363, 1.0626376867294312, -0.1083524227142334, -0.3588418960571289, -0.6456373333930969, -0.038985028862953186, -0.5372023582458496, 0.7777233719825745, -0.5040259957313538, 0.5773358345031738, 0.12418234348297119, 0.3303290903568268, -0.17433466017246246, -1.0801218748092651, 3.9504404067993164, 1.301543116569519, 1.0295811891555786, 0.25251755118370056, 0.45073962211608887, 0.27389928698539734, 0.9228047728538513, 0.0643332228064537, -0.508834958076477, -0.2292540818452835, 0.09207244217395782, 0.23046554625034332, -0.33029547333717346, 0.43871942162513733, -0.3087696433067322, 0.059035420417785645, -1.5112626552581787, 0.36287397146224976, -0.3839919865131378, -1.8547345399856567, -0.6394013166427612, 0.4676089286804199, 0.4838716983795166, 0.5848106741905212, 0.6263474225997925, 0.04755792394280434, 0.02290330082178116, -0.35121950507164, 0.0900951400399208, -0.20093518495559692, -0.7919965982437134, -0.6151627898216248, 0.34961357712745667, -0.33114415407180786, 0.06909740716218948, 0.6540030837059021, 0.23418772220611572, -0.5322273969650269, -0.31715166568756104, 0.49442392587661743, 0.276376873254776, -0.22195236384868622, -0.059308379888534546, -0.34765881299972534, -0.6961947679519653, 0.02025611139833927, -0.9140264987945557, 0.3884021043777466, 0.3034358322620392, -1.3022652864456177, 0.7294542193412781, -1.4376466274261475, 0.48636162281036377, -0.7239770293235779, -0.8697935342788696, -0.8437371850013733, -0.8210999965667725, -0.9216854572296143, -0.02561209164559841, 0.41691717505455017, 0.72356778383255, 0.4073405861854553, -0.5322250723838806, 0.12776023149490356, -0.007088042795658112, 1.4145734310150146, 0.507856547832489, 0.4942817986011505, 0.0449577197432518, -0.08590517193078995, -0.19808520376682281, -0.2512526512145996, -0.6869949698448181, 0.35777539014816284, 0.6403566002845764, 0.28566357493400574, -0.018378380686044693, 0.6600136160850525, 0.32265251874923706, -0.6509997844696045, 0.5871251225471497, 0.9590321779251099, 0.16078752279281616, -0.5410280823707581, 0.2586551904678345, 0.42865023016929626, -0.5824874043464661, -0.34124118089675903, -0.3869783282279968, 0.5405958294868469, 1.035476803779602, 0.011529817245900631, -0.456611305475235, 0.8220754265785217, -0.4700455367565155 ]
{"Title": "Interactive web application for plotting personalized prognosis prediction curves in allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation using machine learning", "Authors": "Okamura Hiroshi, Nakamae Mika, Koh Shiro, Nanno Satoru, Nakashima Yasuhiro, Koh Hideo, Nakane Takahiko, Hirose Asao, Hino Masayuki, Nakamae Hirohisa", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (allo-HCT) is a curative treatment option for malignant hematological disorders. Transplant clinicians estimate patient-specific prognosis empirically in clinical practice based on previous studies on similar patients. However, this approach does not provide objective data. The present study primarily aimed to develop a tool capable of providing accurate personalized prognosis prediction after allo-HCT in an objective manner. Methods We developed an interactive web application tool with a graphical user interface capable of plotting the personalized survival and cumulative incidence prediction curves after allo-HCT adjusted by eight patient-specific factors, which are known as prognostic predictors, and assessed their predictive performances. A random survival forest model using the data of patients who underwent allo-HCT at our institution was applied to develop this application. Results We succeeded in showing the personalized prognosis prediction curves of 1-year overall survival (OS), progression-free survival (PFS), relapse/progression, and non-relapse mortality (NRM) interactively using our web application ( https://predicted-os-after-transplantation.shinyapps.io/RSF_model/ ). To assess its predictive performance, the entire cohort (363 cases) was split into a training cohort (70%) to develop the predictive model and test cohort (30%) to confirm its performance time-sequentially. The areas under the receiver-operating characteristic curves for 1-year OS, PFS, relapse/progression, and NRM in test cohort were 0.70, 0.72, 0.73, and 0.77, respectively. Conclusions The new web application could allow transplant clinicians to inform a new allo-HCT candidate of the objective personalized prognosis prediction and facilitate decision-making.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.14.19014654"}
10.1101/19011064
[ -0.5341874361038208, 0.5543159246444702, 0.001147543080151081, 0.033803001046180725, -0.11584106087684631, -0.41603803634643555, -0.18957212567329407, -0.22302454710006714, -0.7757362723350525, 0.3555711805820465, -0.13039502501487732, -0.5831778645515442, 0.12341354787349701, -0.2162582129240036, 0.1559273600578308, -0.4062834084033966, -0.6322344541549683, -0.024354081600904465, -0.23081862926483154, -0.026139933615922928, 0.08999621123075485, 0.3957218527793884, -0.7101244330406189, -0.10011019557714462, -0.09227576106786728, 0.9368245005607605, -0.13611017167568207, -0.25829416513442993, 1.193853497505188, 0.7522300481796265, -0.5474591255187988, -0.9897719621658325, 0.4105364680290222, -0.14612765610218048, -0.34418782591819763, -0.05953717976808548, 0.6787614822387695, -0.9804344177246094, 0.2552168667316437, 0.007374254055321217, 0.12144894897937775, -0.26810505986213684, 0.5679175853729248, -0.6245254874229431, -0.6962920427322388, -0.09820491075515747, 0.5826308131217957, -0.46488019824028015, 0.19287356734275818, 0.591582179069519, -0.07070811837911606, 0.00561953242868185, 0.5933449268341064, 0.04439956694841385, -0.10308544337749481, -0.3924688994884491, 0.8757411241531372, -0.06738181412220001, -0.7580812573432922, -0.05063796043395996, 0.139173224568367, 0.11047065258026123, 0.5228825807571411, -0.8484494686126709, -0.0034114927984774113, 0.6361823678016663, -0.6170520782470703, -0.252514511346817, -0.6618923544883728, 0.4350266456604004, -0.3131057918071747, 0.049983713775873184, -0.20023368299007416, -0.41628462076187134, 0.19527152180671692, -0.8711735606193542, 0.40316376090049744, -0.6932173371315002, 0.41094323992729187, 0.03144775703549385, 0.21452383697032928, 0.19756685197353363, 0.5159695148468018, 0.5294482707977295, -0.5966698527336121, -0.07438147813081741, -0.08732149004936218, 0.5004767775535583, 0.2857108414173126, 0.7338499426841736, 0.006759087089449167, 0.36440691351890564, -0.3447345197200775, 0.514545202255249, 0.23431475460529327, 0.9977256059646606, -0.21392767131328583, 0.11295923590660095, -0.18670158088207245, -0.3328702449798584, 0.545963704586029, 0.7233664393424988, -0.12497090548276901, 0.7283335328102112, -0.8574323654174805, 0.31293419003486633, 0.4785645604133606, 0.3008624017238617, -0.1798228770494461, -0.29078003764152527, 0.2667638957500458, -0.0459170900285244, -0.01279087457805872, -0.5426326990127563, 0.10224965959787369, 0.848414421081543, -0.21601097285747528, 0.595430850982666, -1.1110882759094238, 0.4996786117553711, -0.36064156889915466, 0.2994441092014313, 0.6731277108192444, -0.2047140747308731, 0.43508538603782654, 0.020291768014431, -0.30805885791778564, 0.052339714020490646, 0.07019512355327606, 0.33959218859672546, -0.07927235960960388, -0.6847434043884277, -0.26929202675819397, 0.768046498298645, 0.06025347486138344, -0.13446031510829926, -0.2984755039215088, 0.8616808652877808, 0.2048424631357193, -0.44685569405555725, -0.33643150329589844, -0.03190963342785835, -0.07441415637731552, 0.9735211133956909, -0.22003893554210663, 0.5406691431999207, -0.7406771779060364, -0.5322867631912231, -0.0162553358823061, -0.2122122347354889, -0.20709386467933655, -0.08554019033908844, 0.03853945806622505, 0.6180022358894348, 0.3633911907672882, -0.039994899183511734, -0.5010555386543274, 0.18438033759593964, 0.016020536422729492, -0.09589461982250214, -0.437499463558197, -0.10755321383476257, -0.29892027378082275, 0.4033527076244354, -1.065720558166504, 0.2001011073589325, 0.0682012066245079, -0.1700664907693863, 0.45334380865097046, -0.5099342465400696, 0.5875306129455566, 0.42078152298927307, -0.5373160243034363, -0.26190686225891113, -0.18504907190799713, 0.5406823754310608, 0.6627354025840759, -0.08653541654348373, 0.339525043964386, 0.6627985239028931, -0.2313205748796463, -0.43531277775764465, 0.6408851742744446, 0.8849436640739441, -0.0007151767495088279, 0.27153724431991577, -0.6570442914962769, -0.09749925136566162, -0.32409730553627014, -0.19938017427921295, -0.16363419592380524, 0.9130477905273438, -0.7039321064949036, 0.6217684745788574, 0.1692848801612854, 0.3600349724292755, -0.6116781830787659, 0.2116008996963501, 0.008701365441083908, -0.9467892050743103, -0.5547585487365723, 0.2231978327035904, 0.4236239790916443, 0.8825876116752625, -0.018092263489961624, 0.4640696346759796, -0.04338297247886658, 0.5644538402557373, -0.48271799087524414, -0.35988229513168335, 0.5433879494667053, -0.0972912609577179, 0.21644356846809387, 0.3586079180240631, 0.509575366973877, -0.8745918273925781, -0.5815561413764954, 0.44334855675697327, 0.162104070186615, 0.421434611082077, 0.12921284139156342, -0.6280472278594971, 0.19762414693832397, 0.2226964831352234, -0.17162694036960602, 0.27791541814804077, 0.2551215589046478, 0.649645209312439, 0.17915990948677063, -0.11599602550268173, 0.3873332142829895, 0.5706911683082581, 0.10711255669593811, 0.202758327126503, 0.9946040511131287, 0.41183069348335266, -0.011965148150920868, 0.889975368976593, -0.26923835277557373, -0.10039600729942322, 0.4875108599662781, 0.43665602803230286, 0.8508307337760925, 0.2896026372909546, -0.4685095250606537, 0.5917644500732422, -0.5945019721984863, 0.3332318961620331, -0.04661649093031883, 0.7572746276855469, -1.2214542627334595, 1.2202154397964478, 0.34700560569763184, 0.39654308557510376, -0.6229593753814697, 0.09935347735881805, -0.52040034532547, 0.22346524894237518, -0.1943145990371704, -1.50713312625885, -0.12331326305866241, 0.992804229259491, 0.3666658401489258, -0.3886237144470215, 1.1703375577926636, 0.8942980766296387, -0.5253090858459473, 0.9526501297950745, -0.4719161093235016, -1.145207166671753, -0.03969081863760948, -0.0631246268749237, -0.8513478636741638, -0.05549627169966698, -1.1998682022094727, 0.24721425771713257, 0.472470223903656, -0.6381581425666809, 0.39274415373802185, -0.05122028663754463, -0.207971453666687, -0.03210953623056412, 0.3439739942550659, 0.6016600728034973, 0.6945459842681885, -0.14923352003097534, -0.9228495359420776, 0.31509608030319214, 0.11181851476430893, -0.20399734377861023, 0.07030730694532394, -0.3319055736064911, -0.763978123664856, -1.7314287424087524, 1.2053018808364868, -0.2155492603778839, 0.027115724980831146, 0.4780527949333191, -0.06120544299483299, -0.17556896805763245, -0.3845871686935425, -0.401250422000885, -0.888806939125061, -0.015941841527819633, -1.0131608247756958, 0.8565965294837952, 0.16306842863559723, 0.5862551927566528, 0.6465142965316772, -0.25132277607917786, 0.07872002571821213, 0.6660814881324768, -0.004364527761936188, 0.3182511329650879, -0.5424346327781677, 0.049744825810194016, 0.2681700885295868, -0.19040915369987488, 0.2780112624168396, -0.21868771314620972, -0.6049798130989075, -0.5937000513076782, 0.348141610622406, -0.09052130579948425, 0.08621928840875626, 0.13341155648231506, 0.43033885955810547, -1.0862094163894653, -0.5186888575553894, -0.2501286268234253, -0.942105770111084, 0.34249594807624817, -0.006765594705939293, -0.10114627331495285, 0.16266687214374542, -0.16083106398582458, -0.3823363184928894, -0.3119225800037384, 0.21656562387943268, 0.21556273102760315, 0.6232702732086182, -0.10407888144254684, 0.3718017339706421, 0.060799602419137955, 0.04805208742618561, 0.03649537265300751, 0.8432420492172241, 0.054057858884334564, 0.005682570394128561, 0.5256081223487854, 0.5235127210617065, 0.31328079104423523, 0.7450464367866516, -0.4463551640510559, 0.1702539324760437, 0.12955403327941895, -0.3256915509700775, -0.2909461259841919, -0.09670824557542801, 0.3543373644351959, -0.5859193205833435, -0.23382525146007538, -0.32406672835350037, 0.12225443869829178, -0.8153178095817566, -0.22855155169963837, 0.6323656439781189, -0.35006868839263916, 0.3701769709587097, -0.7077385783195496, 0.6277831792831421, -0.25918254256248474, -0.09544514119625092, 0.6166258454322815, -0.03239815682172775, -0.3678610026836395, 1.3116726875305176, 0.1833466738462448, 1.3686782121658325, -0.8203057050704956, 0.4182996153831482, 0.27979183197021484, 1.4944947957992554, 0.2769846022129059, -0.27622297406196594, 0.2924938499927521, 0.03761517256498337, 0.7765101194381714, 0.6743864417076111, -0.6275230646133423, 0.17215149104595184, -0.7166368365287781, 0.30824553966522217, -0.6429967284202576, -0.45473650097846985, -0.6668867468833923, 0.4612831473350525, 0.31633317470550537, 0.4551837742328644, -0.3189947009086609, -0.2917698621749878, -0.5844959020614624, -0.030874522402882576, 0.23813779652118683, 0.5106377601623535, 0.046839550137519836, -0.8081010580062866, 0.37517744302749634, -0.22701174020767212, -0.968218207359314, -0.06174452602863312, -0.09457554668188095, -0.39791950583457947, -0.21676062047481537, 0.17012597620487213, -0.4069123864173889, -0.7535943984985352, -0.7150569558143616, 0.07459621131420135, 0.05942007899284363, -0.002157233189791441, 0.6984201073646545, -0.20308810472488403, 0.41440826654434204, 0.24290530383586884, -1.0113271474838257, 0.2770256996154785, -1.0324112176895142, 0.7245573401451111, 0.6065794825553894, -0.5683271884918213, -0.29136696457862854, -0.5000405311584473, -0.3040822744369507, 0.016341401264071465, -0.4764416515827179, 0.6163190603256226, -0.7658462524414062, 0.3714657425880432, -0.3831215798854828, 0.20410741865634918, -0.17441968619823456, -0.045450810343027115, -0.3284423053264618, 0.18876345455646515, 0.32326629757881165, 0.506966769695282, 0.02638689987361431, -0.041807904839515686, -0.132656067609787, 0.6684491634368896, -1.0486502647399902, -0.012208986096084118, -0.14150236546993256, 0.17521217465400696, -0.5349575281143188, -0.07044210284948349, 0.03417181223630905, -0.0713421106338501, -0.8703211545944214, -0.44188573956489563, 0.3653956651687622, 0.3006867468357086, 0.1787453442811966, -0.28823158144950867, 0.4515814781188965, -0.8940847516059875, 0.18611563742160797, 0.3868936598300934, 0.2299472987651825, -0.46302086114883423, 0.29344600439071655, -0.47263965010643005, -0.6784185171127319, 0.34060677886009216, 0.05906622111797333, -0.05601286143064499, -0.03670436888933182, 0.06030740216374397, 0.004426245577633381, 0.40388837456703186, 0.24225345253944397, -0.6619105339050293, -0.3757322132587433, -0.6229175329208374, -0.4119194746017456, -0.5449384450912476, -0.19824449717998505, -1.0938856601715088, 0.0843079537153244, 0.4485267102718353, -0.44285690784454346, -0.12816549837589264, 0.7108621001243591, 0.13923609256744385, -0.8183298707008362, -0.44544872641563416, -0.1365613341331482, 0.14031758904457092, -0.08827509731054306, 0.8823906183242798, 0.07619870454072952, 0.12845352292060852, -0.4360886216163635, 0.2629069685935974, -0.38511812686920166, -0.1586577147245407, 0.08269879966974258, -0.6624823808670044, -0.51568603515625, 0.4183504581451416, 0.04388311877846718, -0.9936685562133789, -0.32229912281036377, 0.12257330864667892, -0.29963433742523193, 0.4717329740524292, -0.21936391294002533, -0.1631973832845688, 0.7359895706176758, -0.0710681825876236, -0.029587874189019203, -0.2804797291755676, 0.5704811811447144, -0.9205062985420227, 0.2635490298271179, -0.7644925117492676, -0.9818564057350159, -0.7369273900985718, -1.1215254068374634, 0.3531742990016937, -1.3693822622299194, 0.21952515840530396, -0.15353646874427795, 0.0854276493191719, 0.49417877197265625, -0.12453915923833847, 1.1111186742782593, -0.2613913118839264, 0.22324971854686737, -0.5208780765533447, 0.25402817130088806, -0.12982605397701263, -0.46446096897125244, 0.3336482048034668, -1.0544264316558838, 0.6633416414260864, 0.9895063638687134, 0.48162841796875, 0.003675836604088545, 0.9305081963539124, 0.3116469085216522, 0.22810785472393036, 0.4016738533973694, -0.6763679385185242, 0.07690760493278503, -0.27496764063835144, 1.3818565607070923, 0.22296380996704102, -0.6201707720756531, -0.5636460781097412, 0.8870130777359009, -0.08696841448545456, 0.17400333285331726, 0.11833875626325607, -0.3266271948814392, 0.22012388706207275, -0.7282310128211975, 1.0362370014190674, 0.5758053660392761, 0.019049622118473053, -0.502943754196167, -0.016451124101877213, 0.28410884737968445, -0.13778574764728546, -0.6334950923919678, -0.6941074132919312, -0.6642219424247742, -0.6760223507881165, -0.057551514357328415, 0.5389851927757263, -0.33088135719299316, 0.22903664410114288, -0.05651053786277771, -0.1848372370004654, -0.2693134844303131, 1.024099349975586, 0.6040422320365906, -0.5130836963653564, -0.2730533480644226, 0.13753844797611237, 0.038496408611536026, -0.14558753371238708, -0.0016898621106520295, -0.24475152790546417, -0.28185051679611206, -0.27235063910484314, -0.3084900975227356, -0.5324442982673645, -0.4747840166091919, -0.5014067888259888, 0.39943358302116394, 0.9555613398551941, -0.5169856548309326, 0.2325964719057083, 0.4401920735836029, 0.010300206020474434, -0.5618932843208313, 0.8702805042266846, -0.3567720949649811, 0.1543036699295044, 0.46546533703804016, -0.28650692105293274, -0.9743841290473938, 0.33215904235839844, -0.22268863022327423, -0.09513942897319794, 0.4877905249595642, 0.8321110606193542, 0.5844928026199341, -1.0769867897033691, -0.06804356724023819, 0.27604836225509644, -0.48007261753082275, -0.8195703029632568, -0.1574712097644806, -0.27497926354408264, -0.2565101385116577, -0.5077422857284546, -0.10997522622346878, 0.35802626609802246, 0.05897882580757141, 0.33473363518714905, 0.6853802800178528, -0.08550702780485153, 0.3415336608886719, 0.6788960099220276, -0.021462855860590935, -0.498024582862854, -0.13303905725479126, 0.9070615172386169, -0.3361084461212158, 0.12324176728725433, 0.43218034505844116, -0.07945528626441956, -0.027386115863919258, -0.48838502168655396, 0.5688502788543701, -0.4453936517238617, -0.37049052119255066, -0.6678468585014343, -0.27855610847473145, -0.2608754634857178, -0.3978794515132904, -0.52920001745224, 0.9533883929252625, -0.310746431350708, -0.41960373520851135, -0.24491727352142334, 0.42023661732673645, 0.8140743374824524, 0.34408971667289734, -0.5249369144439697, -0.5412130355834961, -0.02684319205582142, -0.14775162935256958, 0.1473708301782608, -0.08118002861738205, -0.7346871495246887, -0.7530831098556519, -0.8185014724731445, -0.0653662160038948, -1.1747496128082275, 0.3168400228023529, -0.10631626099348068, -0.1497577577829361, -0.6462160348892212, -0.08740980923175812, 1.151339054107666, -0.6153040528297424, -0.5152637362480164, -0.26447078585624695, 0.046714961528778076, -0.7225217819213867, -0.3202866315841675, 0.08405645936727524, -0.37199437618255615, -0.8939279913902283, 0.7858721613883972, -0.4131343960762024, 0.28686439990997314, -0.5468733310699463, 0.5796477794647217, -0.11129980534315109, 0.43799272179603577, -0.6842268109321594, 0.002978913951665163, 0.44073185324668884, 0.30667543411254883, 0.11554525792598724, -0.4082685708999634, 0.38115227222442627, -0.39425817131996155, 0.5314393043518066, 0.41524434089660645, 0.21551038324832916, -0.40758657455444336, 0.6926718354225159, 0.5819762349128723, -0.8777320981025696, -0.9065799713134766, 0.5189485549926758, 1.0207107067108154, -1.0445529222488403, -0.9550153017044067, -0.9279604554176331, 0.5054752230644226, -0.1756061613559723, -0.5163794159889221, 0.7705148458480835, 0.5766386985778809, -0.2984277606010437, 0.26196718215942383, -0.07556919753551483, 0.5427576899528503, 0.5297568440437317, 0.5121942758560181, 0.21803049743175507, 0.16140641272068024, 0.38337045907974243, -0.7265183925628662, 0.07084377855062485, 0.04012737795710564, 0.01854763552546501, 0.6738914251327515, 0.08093579858541489, 0.6046611070632935, 0.3429870009422302, 0.4139648973941803, -0.2273709625005722, 1.1603015661239624, -0.06359957158565521, -0.2690528333187103, -0.4250963032245636, -0.35529470443725586, 0.1253167986869812, -0.2550836205482483, -0.35440367460250854, -0.8499684929847717, 0.23705971240997314, -0.4240421950817108, -0.4900933504104614, -0.23816272616386414, -1.0060410499572754, 0.21228185296058655, -0.40867236256599426, 0.1115824431180954, 0.7361241579055786, 0.484331876039505, 0.09373725205659866, 0.40078186988830566, 0.18678146600723267, 0.42998015880584717, 0.4148387014865875, -0.4478474259376526, -0.4162931442260742, -0.7254305481910706, 0.20592841506004333, 0.8846002817153931, -0.0739355981349945, -0.5833141803741455, -0.41715437173843384, -0.6656479835510254, 0.04155571013689041, 0.3418539762496948, 0.13728328049182892, -0.07438675314188004, -0.5407022833824158, -0.17160792648792267, -0.3284170925617218, 0.5282303094863892, -0.23823626339435577, 0.3721204400062561, 0.5505102872848511, -0.40093910694122314, -0.6186981797218323, 0.24856846034526825, 0.9424659609794617, 0.5094764232635498, 0.2571263015270233, -0.3243645131587982, 0.4931626319885254, -0.858906090259552, 0.6182907223701477, 0.8952540159225464, 0.7260610461235046, 0.49948787689208984, -0.12663136422634125, 0.48034653067588806, 0.4750116169452667, 0.8161728978157043, -0.32105639576911926, -0.1769189089536667, -0.1274353563785553, 0.43561238050460815, 0.043129365891218185, -0.27645522356033325, -0.5797512531280518, 0.0742793008685112, 0.5691906809806824, -0.9546718001365662, 0.43421006202697754, -0.3100227117538452, 0.9100923538208008, -0.45297908782958984, -0.016466554254293442, 0.7212840914726257, -0.06782931089401245, 0.03166594356298447, 0.04881343990564346, 0.08403836935758591, 0.869297206401825, 0.23252421617507935, 0.3329910337924957, 0.6462008357048035, 0.9471466541290283, 0.34906962513923645, -0.28887754678726196, 0.5007895827293396, -0.5951365828514099, -0.3249560296535492, -0.2989206314086914, 0.3131150007247925, 0.8607155680656433, -0.0012909873621538281, -0.007928388193249702, -0.5050064921379089, -0.5027717351913452, 1.039903163909912, 0.28055477142333984, -0.07073841243982315, 0.9546869397163391, -0.49377167224884033, -1.1321386098861694, 0.10648451000452042, 0.03261033445596695, -0.8431715369224548, 0.20721612870693207, 0.48989221453666687, -0.028822705149650574, -0.04865996539592743, -0.5204148292541504, 0.19584819674491882, -0.07139953225851059, 0.41419747471809387, 0.7367041707038879, -0.5727357864379883, 0.3370411992073059, 0.6075119376182556, 0.266049861907959, 0.2850171625614166, -0.3552386462688446, -0.6055601239204407, 0.283221960067749, 0.07902810722589493, 0.19892361760139465, -0.1826508492231369, -0.9669251441955566, -0.1665298342704773, -0.2570312023162842, 0.5278664827346802, -0.16844110190868378, -0.30747199058532715, -0.058759670704603195, 0.06542845815420151, -0.39203202724456787, 0.3899794816970825, 0.14256392419338226, -0.11058228462934494, 0.103765569627285, 0.40208303928375244, -0.36932626366615295, -0.004736970644444227, 0.7731178402900696, -0.19853436946868896, 0.6446359157562256, -0.03671415150165558, -0.8176474571228027, 0.050184860825538635, -1.0959745645523071, -0.4822668731212616, 0.11600179225206375, -0.26811692118644714, -1.0258985757827759, -0.0501706600189209, 0.3933037519454956, 0.3091999590396881, -0.5362092852592468, -0.6014960408210754, -0.6216492652893066, 0.6570640206336975, 1.0995005369186401, -0.4365498423576355, 0.2280920147895813, -0.49747246503829956, -0.5808201432228088, 0.17471656203269958, 0.2756669223308563, 0.2655085623264313, 0.1348876953125, -0.3503189980983734, -0.270918071269989, -0.294705331325531, 0.13145068287849426, -0.42169827222824097, 0.24891720712184906, 0.220201775431633, -0.8016465306282043, 0.19343751668930054, -0.8970314264297485, -0.13093852996826172, -1.02759850025177, 0.8605623841285706, -0.14545871317386627, 0.3122905194759369, -0.6188482642173767, -0.6543393731117249, 0.26821452379226685, -1.2206202745437622, 4.246516704559326, 1.1895090341567993, 0.4417712688446045, -0.6349822878837585, 0.5201069712638855, 0.5359954833984375, 0.7077920436859131, -0.10336481034755707, 0.3226340115070343, 0.05935335159301758, -0.525577187538147, 0.8915247321128845, -0.19293874502182007, -0.7777596116065979, 0.4312901794910431, 0.4960099458694458, -0.5260400772094727, -0.21121135354042053, -0.2235630750656128, -0.4803796410560608, -0.14416521787643433, 0.5920404195785522, -0.17505930364131927, -0.23196417093276978, 0.09849902242422104, 0.11352337151765823, 0.16056393086910248, -0.49559295177459717, -0.2766565978527069, -0.021940121427178383, -0.2766602635383606, -0.47833332419395447, 0.6941171288490295, -0.5192186832427979, -0.3392547070980072, 0.7093146443367004, -0.30996647477149963, -0.37463557720184326, 0.079081691801548, 0.24353331327438354, -0.1278531551361084, 0.058572303503751755, 0.01718534529209137, -1.1105329990386963, 0.28611451387405396, 0.37724483013153076, -0.3350284993648529, 0.16881290078163147, 0.46002820134162903, -0.2546841502189636, 0.5278517007827759, -0.6709206104278564, -0.04253208637237549, -0.014109260402619839, -1.1305407285690308, 0.17581212520599365, -0.08636737614870071, -0.6026629209518433, -0.26242896914482117, 0.3293520212173462, 0.1642126590013504, -0.2545326352119446, 0.2396785169839859, 0.5157043933868408, 0.40903961658477783, 0.18250103294849396, 0.7534343600273132, 0.5133870840072632, -0.0378417931497097, 0.2195505052804947, 0.5482453107833862, -0.5464543700218201, -0.5616363286972046, -0.5463170409202576, 0.41025686264038086, 0.20323260128498077, 0.07389742136001587, 0.377556174993515, -0.32808759808540344, -1.1266568899154663, -0.12952569127082825, 0.1265878677368164, 0.058360930532217026, -0.29494455456733704, 0.43178805708885193, 0.9925978779792786, -0.0810106098651886, -0.30616387724876404, -0.9149948954582214, 0.5315897464752197, 0.5016244053840637, 0.16057424247264862, -0.017265066504478455, 0.1562071144580841, 0.4572679400444031 ]
{"Title": "Factors associated with risk of developmental delay in preschool children in a setting with high rates of malnutrition: a cross-sectional analysis of data from the IHOPE study, Madagascar", "Authors": "Miller Ann C., Garchitorena Andres, Rabemananjara Faramalala, Cordier Laura, Randriamanambintsoa Marius, Rabeza Victor, Razanadrakoto Hery-Tiana Rahaniraka, Ramakasoa Ranaivozafindary Rakoto, RamahefarisonTiana Olivier, Ratsimbazafy Baolova Nathaline, Ouenzar Mohammed Ali, Bonds Matthew H., Ratsifandrihamanana Lisy", "Abstract": "Background Nearly two hundred eighty million children in low and middle income countries are at risk for not achieving their full developmental potential( 1 ). Poor development can lead to reduced scholastic ability( 2 ) or opportunity (promoting and entrenching inequity), and has been associated with lower adult earning potential( 3 ), and poorer health( 4 ), thus potentially contributing to intergenerational poverty traps. While the entire period of childhood is important for development, the first 1000 days (conception to age 2) are critically important for brain development; with the most rapid and prolific development of neural pathways, first in sensory development, then language skills and then higher cognitive functioning( 5 ). Experiences during this period \u2013 positive or negative \u2013 can substantially impact the architecture of the developing brain. Adverse events such as exposure to familial or societal violence, toxins such as lead or arsenic, illness (anemia, diarrhea, HIV, chronic malnutrition, maternal depression), or lack of a developmentally stimulating and nurturing environment can all act as toxic stressors on young children that negatively impact cognitive development throughout the life-course( 6 ). Infants and young children in settings of poverty are often faced with many of these stressors( 7 ).", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19011064"}
10.1101/19002345
[ 0.1658717691898346, 0.39076584577560425, -0.08257687836885452, 0.2677200436592102, -0.4737025797367096, 0.08047236502170563, -0.5259183049201965, -0.020845413208007812, 0.017364010214805603, 0.5606902241706848, -0.24350933730602264, -0.3359397053718567, 0.2550417184829712, 0.7870780229568481, -0.2245742380619049, -0.22784548997879028, -0.47485077381134033, -0.29789015650749207, -0.09707286208868027, 0.22912874817848206, -0.14190243184566498, 1.2689387798309326, -0.7165088057518005, -0.10608179867267609, -0.5677269697189331, 0.7181065678596497, 0.3074946999549866, -0.11459160596132278, 1.4021316766738892, 0.8601917624473572, 0.3003324866294861, -0.4125562608242035, 0.4505975842475891, -0.7601879835128784, -0.1693563610315323, -0.37158527970314026, 0.3340405523777008, 0.08610638976097107, -0.8565109968185425, -0.47065970301628113, 0.5060994029045105, 0.08026104420423508, 0.4028111398220062, -0.48734909296035767, -0.5401450991630554, -0.061003994196653366, -0.2715335190296173, 0.09675656259059906, -0.121706523001194, 0.07403324544429779, 0.3258172869682312, -0.06350496411323547, -0.5098204016685486, -0.633368194103241, -0.07292816787958145, -0.1823524385690689, -0.06857368350028992, -0.27511510252952576, -0.6528787612915039, 0.372136652469635, -0.2141236662864685, 0.28798308968544006, 0.112641341984272, -0.8907938599586487, 0.6061937212944031, 0.8976284265518188, 0.0204496867954731, -0.09263850748538971, 0.11711930483579636, -0.6806150078773499, -0.36020225286483765, -0.5613223314285278, -0.6053484082221985, -0.5806490182876587, -0.2409745454788208, -0.777671754360199, 0.6766485571861267, 0.04536019265651703, -0.5807446837425232, -0.3377387821674347, 0.2719191014766693, 0.1901284158229828, 0.16980111598968506, 0.10386717319488525, -1.1930264234542847, 0.6488099098205566, 0.565041184425354, 0.2875736653804779, 0.5357905030250549, 0.4909382164478302, 0.18057656288146973, 0.05603427439928055, 0.7600462436676025, -0.0964728370308876, -0.11927255988121033, 1.078654408454895, -0.3848850727081299, -0.42592018842697144, 0.5001022815704346, -0.21265679597854614, 0.7336860299110413, 0.6945281624794006, -0.6380409598350525, 0.5690011382102966, -0.24863234162330627, 1.0398356914520264, 0.8612964749336243, -0.7627401351928711, 0.07117769122123718, -0.7666341066360474, 0.5200405120849609, -0.14730164408683777, -0.6024956703186035, 0.159770667552948, 0.5643137693405151, 0.13296714425086975, -0.11377573013305664, 0.9915391802787781, 0.13996247947216034, 0.21459200978279114, 0.28262484073638916, 0.3789083957672119, 0.8782308101654053, -0.2321118414402008, 0.3826881945133209, 0.13691578805446625, 0.4016488790512085, 0.3195452094078064, -0.7697531580924988, -0.22246943414211273, -0.2016116976737976, -0.43082088232040405, -0.07350870221853256, 0.5195282101631165, 0.0618719719350338, -0.5389227867126465, 0.20379774272441864, 0.400046169757843, 0.4537166357040405, -0.14251476526260376, -0.46611616015434265, 0.3682708144187927, -0.34322676062583923, 1.3534440994262695, -0.28467825055122375, 0.6051896810531616, -0.08069498836994171, -1.2176165580749512, -0.44653427600860596, 0.2821660041809082, 0.060059789568185806, 0.34109777212142944, -0.37029069662094116, -0.15475572645664215, 0.32310858368873596, -0.26213112473487854, -0.14821738004684448, -0.48194026947021484, -0.2281200885772705, 0.11091222614049911, -1.1148730516433716, -0.25961896777153015, -0.3618941307067871, 0.5529124736785889, -0.34442806243896484, 1.0279220342636108, -0.039699021726846695, 0.8861876726150513, 0.004110760986804962, -0.7453073859214783, 1.0917099714279175, 0.06873401999473572, -0.06185193359851837, 0.24785634875297546, 0.2930145859718323, 0.9915128946304321, 0.40743717551231384, -0.44041597843170166, 0.4574005901813507, 1.090904712677002, -0.4245557487010956, -0.05180634930729866, 0.11675690859556198, 0.9227268099784851, 0.28121843934059143, 0.23323863744735718, -0.09545406699180603, -0.29040202498435974, -0.0694919303059578, -0.8039197325706482, 0.4030894339084625, 0.04620381444692612, -0.4296702742576599, 0.5534927845001221, 0.054618846625089645, -0.17528416216373444, -0.08746249973773956, 0.4793277978897095, -0.6016222238540649, -0.7399603724479675, -0.336505264043808, -0.3284662365913391, 0.07876170426607132, 1.0572208166122437, -0.6612349152565002, 0.7771226167678833, 0.058821018785238266, 0.02161591872572899, -0.8317176103591919, 1.0606553554534912, 1.2259293794631958, -0.0506897009909153, -0.5171529054641724, -0.43285298347473145, 0.2931962013244629, -0.22520703077316284, -0.23738503456115723, 0.4367033839225769, -1.0992497205734253, 0.27281978726387024, 0.004836816340684891, -0.28254732489585876, 0.22372202575206757, -0.3080122768878937, 0.5994682312011719, 0.0038490723818540573, -0.09957392513751984, 0.6952434182167053, 0.015570071525871754, 0.25869840383529663, -0.155876025557518, 0.6559341549873352, 0.06056574732065201, 0.8465447425842285, -0.07418375462293625, 0.03489578515291214, 0.11892834305763245, 0.5031739473342896, 0.40322190523147583, 0.806404173374176, 0.7238062024116516, 0.9279582500457764, 0.1682749092578888, -0.10386881977319717, -0.6542596220970154, 0.7984368801116943, 0.0032819348853081465, -0.19044026732444763, -0.016366126015782356, 0.17498362064361572, -0.5878773331642151, 0.7587310671806335, 0.09844259172677994, 0.5066808462142944, -0.901343584060669, -0.7987809181213379, 0.76374351978302, -0.08284132182598114, -1.0682299137115479, -0.3750952184200287, -0.5910241007804871, 0.7974810004234314, -0.3191037178039551, -0.17351873219013214, 1.2042757272720337, 0.6644014716148376, 0.3250684440135956, 0.8192701935768127, 0.10724997520446777, -0.36872538924217224, -0.6703654527664185, -0.250777930021286, -1.1413630247116089, -1.2197338342666626, -0.6929423213005066, 0.24998854100704193, 0.09295881539583206, -0.14682449400424957, -0.6530836820602417, -0.250353068113327, -0.7134612202644348, -0.09879186004400253, 0.03424686938524246, 0.4636348783969879, -0.04018278792500496, -0.004762587137520313, -0.41212770342826843, 0.12664547562599182, 0.16511750221252441, 0.3066198527812958, 0.1030658483505249, -0.7504167556762695, -0.5087358355522156, -0.4108048677444458, 0.15376923978328705, -0.15624985098838806, 0.029922209680080414, 0.3301629424095154, 0.26160791516304016, -0.7321853041648865, 0.39176514744758606, -0.3366398215293884, -0.27320706844329834, -0.03708326444029808, -0.8062372207641602, 0.17080745100975037, -0.6839073300361633, 0.47442346811294556, 0.3943638205528259, 0.5200549960136414, -0.3905988335609436, -0.08870934695005417, 0.37601083517074585, 0.6397089958190918, -0.5537232756614685, -0.10639715939760208, 0.4394124448299408, -0.296517938375473, 0.06195531040430069, -0.07425449788570404, -0.8361082673072815, 0.2569738030433655, -0.07359945774078369, -0.2692151367664337, -0.2207021862268448, 0.3056487441062927, 0.5505502223968506, -1.2240772247314453, 0.17927062511444092, -0.6094833016395569, -1.2993934154510498, 0.10699160397052765, -0.06012367084622383, 0.8673720955848694, 0.695047914981842, -0.35919469594955444, -0.5788334608078003, -0.3776303231716156, -0.3508231043815613, 0.049841929227113724, 0.07794248312711716, -0.5215585231781006, 0.2973180413246155, 0.18457461893558502, -0.23288165032863617, 0.38916242122650146, 0.5879661440849304, -0.4759996831417084, 0.14179714024066925, 0.3856387436389923, -0.26738741993904114, 0.10162511467933655, 0.5708541870117188, -0.05441022664308548, -0.6408220529556274, 0.782159686088562, 0.11279620975255966, 0.37974634766578674, 0.20886150002479553, 0.5563384890556335, 0.5395016670227051, 0.6996968984603882, -0.4217959940433502, 0.6413065791130066, -1.0048729181289673, -0.31807032227516174, 0.07774438709020615, -0.18135002255439758, 1.2464570999145508, -0.30026742815971375, 0.4616340696811676, -0.8599904179573059, -0.11855753511190414, 0.0867108628153801, 0.05263083428144455, -0.24308660626411438, 1.15218985080719, 0.48531457781791687, 1.2688281536102295, -0.535042941570282, -0.05164698138833046, 0.6481198072433472, 0.3687775135040283, 0.6951577663421631, -0.32506418228149414, 0.5873522162437439, -0.2214687168598175, -0.07988689094781876, -0.06871487200260162, -0.16109557449817657, -0.1533091515302658, -0.41006723046302795, 0.5563393235206604, 0.4980390965938568, -0.5838803648948669, -0.3015930950641632, 0.38371092081069946, 0.5099818110466003, 0.020932957530021667, 0.08325432986021042, 0.7580563426017761, -0.5990697741508484, 0.42424172163009644, 0.6356764435768127, 0.481126993894577, 0.6475051641464233, -0.5411878824234009, 0.3387833833694458, -0.0885382816195488, -1.0269781351089478, -0.28757694363594055, -0.9586931467056274, -0.4786871671676636, -0.3229254484176636, 0.39101728796958923, 0.14672434329986572, -0.2574978172779083, -0.6268331408500671, -0.7372967600822449, -0.6430486440658569, 0.7282298803329468, -0.17043496668338776, -0.6595500111579895, 0.3536422550678253, 0.4006538391113281, -0.24017632007598877, -0.007013313472270966, -1.273798942565918, 0.6088823080062866, 1.1901363134384155, -0.23153473436832428, -1.104064702987671, -0.24776440858840942, -0.5645381212234497, -0.7311148047447205, 0.04191990941762924, 0.20485976338386536, 0.190286323428154, -0.5602847337722778, -0.7056484818458557, -0.03885061666369438, -0.3682842552661896, -0.46618232131004333, -0.23206683993339539, -0.09284111112356186, 0.17122569680213928, 0.6887961030006409, 0.479844331741333, 0.16432392597198486, 0.19716420769691467, 0.1998024433851242, -0.9125990271568298, 0.7672441601753235, -0.46592673659324646, -0.30815839767456055, -0.1345306634902954, 0.2381991297006607, -0.10760864615440369, -0.2389332354068756, -0.34127745032310486, -0.3852739632129669, -0.31335294246673584, 0.3058536946773529, -0.3700048625469208, -0.20607727766036987, 0.8557763695716858, -0.03312288969755173, -0.16129279136657715, 0.9010491371154785, -0.7386694550514221, -0.07589913159608841, 0.22530539333820343, 0.21095938980579376, -0.0127639165148139, 0.18388953804969788, 0.43115389347076416, 0.2580038905143738, -0.02879181131720543, -0.4461786448955536, 0.028819037601351738, -0.4219614565372467, 0.3902245759963989, -0.1444091647863388, -0.16717149317264557, -0.2970333695411682, -0.3612394332885742, -0.5593847632408142, -0.26485392451286316, -1.0152513980865479, 1.162726879119873, -0.5258979797363281, -0.30761459469795227, -0.45958641171455383, -0.03970583900809288, -0.6516435146331787, 0.06429450958967209, -0.4543905556201935, 0.5179235935211182, 0.08263082057237625, 0.4770757257938385, 0.40425366163253784, -0.5195757746696472, -0.5314227342605591, 0.057089269161224365, 0.6243113279342651, -0.7499967813491821, -0.23499882221221924, 0.253845751285553, -0.3629958927631378, -0.5359171032905579, -0.37739723920822144, 0.6626041531562805, -0.2850970923900604, -0.07467592507600784, -0.23420238494873047, 0.23371633887290955, 0.7320865988731384, -0.24077211320400238, 0.02534671686589718, 0.023556679487228394, -0.5475795865058899, -0.5984203815460205, 0.1654457002878189, 0.15124468505382538, 0.19333380460739136, 0.743245542049408, -0.1663990169763565, -0.8440807461738586, -0.4393380284309387, -0.9058408141136169, 0.5946735143661499, -0.19918885827064514, 0.15124788880348206, -0.6703681945800781, -0.6921324729919434, -0.11758154630661011, 0.5663720965385437, 0.09158366173505783, 0.5156266093254089, 0.10558486729860306, -0.3094761371612549, 0.9057596325874329, -0.30040690302848816, 0.27080801129341125, -0.09671860188245773, -0.8221418857574463, 0.7690737247467041, 0.7725433111190796, -0.28642740845680237, -0.3894055187702179, -0.0600084625184536, -0.12446700036525726, 0.9471040964126587, 0.09398241341114044, -0.06934484094381332, -0.4259963631629944, 0.29238003492355347, 0.7206966876983643, -0.3723498284816742, -0.44866135716438293, -1.1105352640151978, 0.8393140435218811, 0.05012282356619835, 0.7325007319450378, -0.10198432952165604, -0.6944218277931213, 0.19042612612247467, -0.670220673084259, 1.012764573097229, -0.16969648003578186, 0.3647083640098572, 0.09058019518852234, -0.15404276549816132, -0.19487552344799042, 0.5468066930770874, -0.6346198320388794, -0.8098308444023132, -0.11033337563276291, -0.4398804008960724, 0.36034029722213745, -0.08849254250526428, 0.4689452350139618, -0.35181736946105957, -0.5200178027153015, -0.013104905374348164, -0.40479061007499695, 0.6588316559791565, 0.8647446036338806, -0.4998887777328491, 0.24800243973731995, 0.24923773109912872, 0.7511685490608215, -0.1946069300174713, 0.4725777804851532, 0.2106190323829651, -0.11018700897693634, -0.7472079992294312, 0.11025115847587585, -0.6035469770431519, -1.169041633605957, 0.020007701590657234, 0.08222097158432007, 0.5337158441543579, 0.108491912484169, 0.3976299464702606, 0.440292626619339, -0.5978613495826721, -0.025448614731431007, 0.40993934869766235, 0.4838399291038513, 0.3268946409225464, 0.9242722392082214, 0.11603938043117523, -1.0021852254867554, 0.5504547357559204, -0.08920437842607498, 0.2963126003742218, 0.2117430865764618, 0.9823879599571228, 0.36744338274002075, -1.3049920797348022, 1.1917306184768677, 0.15677715837955475, -0.6497090458869934, 0.04593409225344658, 0.02613169699907303, -0.388637900352478, 0.0740935280919075, 0.28549838066101074, -0.17653460800647736, 0.5572662353515625, -0.5171674489974976, 0.9594658613204956, -0.08112594485282898, 0.28022342920303345, 0.047202400863170624, -0.11924701929092407, 0.12446564435958862, -0.6468529105186462, -0.09563667327165604, 0.27089762687683105, -0.6261223554611206, 0.6965944170951843, 0.25366461277008057, 0.13494302332401276, 0.3094666600227356, 0.08442279696464539, 0.1944161057472229, -0.7475830912590027, -0.7557123899459839, 0.3642195463180542, -0.01359217707067728, 0.757072389125824, 0.3500475287437439, -0.28606897592544556, 0.9967552423477173, 0.31174999475479126, -1.0706377029418945, -0.41982302069664, 0.5274099707603455, -0.1722332090139389, 0.3615032434463501, 0.007855229079723358, 0.2953559160232544, 0.36091503500938416, 0.2734183967113495, 0.34816038608551025, -0.5064213871955872, -0.19299761950969696, -0.5485001802444458, -0.8207287788391113, -0.32389727234840393, -0.3870972692966461, 0.5281339287757874, 1.2319635152816772, -0.7878914475440979, -0.9676222205162048, -0.429375022649765, 1.1687289476394653, 0.3564246892929077, -0.29971468448638916, -0.5961773991584778, 0.006638599559664726, -0.4276603162288666, -0.5630964040756226, -0.36983978748321533, -0.3266426920890808, 0.20077654719352722, 1.3330144882202148, -0.4826200604438782, -0.45242592692375183, -0.03268003836274147, -0.326418936252594, 0.3103777766227722, 0.9451357126235962, -0.11157332360744476, -0.5068066716194153, -0.15330339968204498, 0.4195861220359802, 0.05960090085864067, -0.3519939184188843, 0.9830409288406372, -0.4132912755012512, 0.25523117184638977, 0.3504481613636017, -0.1334446221590042, 0.022002872079610825, -0.4014316201210022, 0.36377719044685364, -0.06895478814840317, -0.09781088680028915, -0.3295680284500122, 0.5195698738098145, -1.3797811269760132, -0.49112287163734436, -0.4262774884700775, -1.1020294427871704, 0.020343227311968803, -0.03888681158423424, -0.6936759948730469, 0.22874785959720612, -0.043774910271167755, 0.23074133694171906, 0.053954362869262695, 0.5759261250495911, 0.7233079075813293, -0.05317925289273262, 1.0442016124725342, 0.5085927844047546, 0.09992704540491104, -0.7692024111747742, 0.8338577151298523, -0.037378374487161636, -0.30129915475845337, 0.20196370780467987, -0.19951988756656647, 0.32618510723114014, 0.32802146673202515, -0.1861458569765091, -0.2581906318664551, 0.9172579050064087, 0.021188270300626755, 0.9456557631492615, -0.44597241282463074, -0.4989117383956909, -0.487966924905777, -0.3660176992416382, -1.6653183698654175, -1.0550329685211182, 0.44806212186813354, -1.006909966468811, -0.1152571514248848, -0.17052564024925232, -1.0021528005599976, 0.39753028750419617, 0.20735476911067963, -0.4190753102302551, -0.5526809692382812, 0.4310356378555298, -0.3228776454925537, 1.0241414308547974, 0.4815809428691864, -0.07563429325819016, 0.0496862456202507, 0.3395083248615265, -0.8376659750938416, -0.7705820798873901, -0.4684000611305237, 0.6621097922325134, 0.20574851334095, -0.43578341603279114, -0.4173646867275238, 0.33661118149757385, -0.2468988001346588, -0.7942923307418823, 0.04364817216992378, 0.01707146316766739, -0.3439250886440277, -0.2872868478298187, -0.5686056017875671, 0.19473585486412048, 0.20549048483371735, 0.4983772337436676, 0.19554324448108673, -1.0652350187301636, -0.3826081156730652, 0.28079289197921753, 0.2616512179374695, 0.03243079036474228, 0.2368762493133545, 0.09535085409879684, 0.49229827523231506, -0.12023066729307175, -0.8053811192512512, 0.6337975859642029, 0.7501301169395447, -0.13537421822547913, 0.12085673213005066, 0.4717273414134979, -0.04035467654466629, 0.7307723760604858, 0.39895445108413696, -0.5956200957298279, 0.23059934377670288, 0.05013886094093323, 0.011711344122886658, 0.168439120054245, -0.5600937008857727, 0.5602658987045288, -0.03566371649503708, -0.237283855676651, -0.01680874451994896, 0.19693922996520996, 1.00653874874115, 0.21024014055728912, -0.423522025346756, 0.3874921500682831, -0.6285872459411621, 0.17432942986488342, -0.0888901948928833, 0.15785543620586395, 0.7615072727203369, -0.30153512954711914, 0.007639382500201464, -0.026433652266860008, 0.9657774567604065, 0.7827954888343811, -0.08645804226398468, 0.6427158117294312, -0.28934162855148315, 0.3288942575454712, -0.6992246508598328, 0.5731481313705444, -0.3411595821380615, 0.12768268585205078, -0.10215257108211517, -0.6306409239768982, -0.118252694606781, 0.07160872220993042, 0.02720903418958187, 0.4582754969596863, 1.019608974456787, -0.44811558723449707, 0.006905125454068184, 0.1473475843667984, 0.26766642928123474, -0.8136146068572998, -0.5047671794891357, 1.1526768207550049, 0.2354460209608078, -0.2072521150112152, 0.131526380777359, 0.7750095129013062, 0.6162375211715698, 0.6921219229698181, 0.8585488796234131, -0.3179951012134552, 0.10041025280952454, 0.5633707642555237, -0.4814096689224243, -0.366951584815979, -0.3121650815010071, -0.2757451832294464, -0.15861503779888153, -0.01845400035381317, 0.405781090259552, 0.2792746126651764, -0.45945337414741516, 0.2373722940683365, 0.24226486682891846, -0.18344300985336304, 0.12951913475990295, -1.2518121004104614, -0.5543195009231567, -0.787905216217041, -0.523271918296814, -0.2548932433128357, 0.4419436454772949, 0.39155203104019165, -0.17402499914169312, -0.7613700032234192, -0.9037031531333923, -0.5740437507629395, 0.078988216817379, -0.7655466198921204, 0.40774157643318176, 0.06389892101287842, -0.12820211052894592, -0.8691053986549377, -1.2505714893341064, -0.15727052092552185, -0.05886613577604294, 0.1683865189552307, -0.6639402508735657, -0.07325313985347748, 0.1292920708656311, 0.7401578426361084, 0.47602418065071106, -0.3132912218570709, -0.38041484355926514, 0.025899508967995644, 0.773067057132721, -0.32244670391082764, 0.7413965463638306, -0.09026634693145752, 0.4085521399974823, -0.5972471237182617, -0.6064645051956177, -0.39880427718162537, 0.21849609911441803, -0.7428879737854004, -0.38868722319602966, 0.09747738391160965, -0.20737655460834503, -0.625689685344696, -0.06422390043735504, 0.07089030742645264, -0.8357993960380554, -0.3554965853691101, -0.0044438946060836315, -0.5360599756240845, -0.5904173254966736, 0.867653489112854, -0.47431790828704834, -0.12768225371837616, 0.06776077300310135, -0.29756665229797363, 0.47736963629722595, -0.8782698512077332, 4.104902744293213, 0.6619365811347961, 0.6368652582168579, -0.4388446807861328, 1.1937986612319946, 0.7654568552970886, 0.20141303539276123, 0.08786683529615402, 0.4372837245464325, -0.13110464811325073, 0.03143838047981262, 0.17111089825630188, -0.6612090468406677, 0.09758225828409195, 0.8057248592376709, 0.00914346519857645, -0.7913828492164612, -0.2536497414112091, 0.3296456038951874, -1.0215626955032349, -0.1417766660451889, 0.24242067337036133, 0.07571954280138016, 0.7474448680877686, 0.4931736886501312, 0.22402477264404297, 0.335332453250885, -0.14208900928497314, 0.030965043231844902, -0.46591857075691223, 0.279954195022583, -0.39220690727233887, 0.37148863077163696, -1.0328967571258545, -0.5159142017364502, -0.09958580881357193, -0.22206774353981018, -0.6343315839767456, 0.25757646560668945, -0.7879435420036316, 0.19088876247406006, 0.27403029799461365, -0.23117735981941223, -0.4157969057559967, -0.32589268684387207, 0.46283984184265137, -0.6076552271842957, 0.2965514659881592, 0.6850103139877319, -0.5549377799034119, 0.42500635981559753, -0.9009356498718262, 0.2972719669342041, -0.041327930986881256, -1.091442346572876, 0.30657753348350525, 0.052300918847322464, -1.1592793464660645, 0.5042257308959961, 0.6949223279953003, 0.40721213817596436, 0.00969951506704092, -0.5475937724113464, 0.6088463068008423, 0.377549946308136, -0.11682934314012527, -0.22639699280261993, -0.7150732278823853, -0.24184280633926392, -0.029244985431432724, 0.027451740577816963, -0.512641966342926, 0.3042135238647461, -0.9985485076904297, 0.4409123957157135, 0.2615504562854767, -0.4940679669380188, 0.6575136184692383, -0.3484703302383423, -0.8096529245376587, 0.06223886087536812, 0.10250365734100342, 1.0057581663131714, -0.5211861729621887, 0.47396621108055115, 1.1230493783950806, -0.8023654222488403, -0.5435284972190857, -0.5337034463882446, 0.6041716933250427, 0.15265914797782898, -0.42144811153411865, 0.35779762268066406, 0.3426344394683838, -0.48964399099349976 ]
{"Title": "Periodic Testing and Estimation of STD-HIV Association", "Authors": "M\u00e2sse B.R., Guibord P., Boily M.-C., Alary M.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background The validity of measures used in follow-up studies to estimate the magnitude of the HIV-STD association will be the focus of this paper. A recent simulation study by Boily et al [1] based on a model of HIV and STD transmission showed that the relative risk ( RR ), estimated by the hazard rate ratio ( HRR ) obtained by the Cox model had poor validity, either in absence or in presence of a real association between HIV and STD. The HRR tends to underestimate the true magnitude of a non-null association. These results were obtained from simulated follow-up studies where HIV was periodicaly tested every three months and every month for the STD. Aims and Methods This paper extends the above results by investigating the impact of using different periodic testing intervals on the validity of HRR estimates. Issues regarding the definition of exposure to STDs in this context are explored. A stochastic model for the transmission of HIV and other STDs is used to simulate follow-up studies with different periodic testing intervals. HRR estimates obtained with the Cox model with a time-dependent STD exposure covariate are compared to the true magnitude of the HIV-STD association. In addition, real data are reanalysed using the STD exposure definition described in this paper. The data from Laga et al [2] are used for this purpose. Results (1) Simulated data: independently of the magnitude of the true association, we observed a greater reduction of the bias when increasing the frequency of HIV testing than that of the STD testing. (2) Real data: The STD exposure definition can create substantial differences in the estimation of the HIV-STD association. Laga et al [2] have found a HRR of 2.5 (1.1 - 6.4) for the association between HIV and genital ulcer disease compared to an estimate of 3.5 (1.5 - 8.3) with our improved definition of exposure. Conclusions Results on the simulated data have an important impact on the design of field studies. For instance when choosing between two designs; one where both HIV and STD are screened every 3 months versus one where HIV and STD are screened every 3 months and monthly, respectively. The latter design is more expensive and involves more complicated logistics. Furthermore, this increment in cost may not be justified considering the relatively small gain in terms of validity and variability.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002345"}
10.1101/19001149
[ -0.043571941554546356, 0.1357167661190033, 0.6382453441619873, 0.4603707790374756, -0.6690539121627808, 0.6901209950447083, 0.8724846839904785, -0.09384879469871521, 0.3067641258239746, 0.36912816762924194, 0.14644461870193481, -0.36589330434799194, 0.4449654221534729, -1.0622327327728271, 0.45706984400749207, -0.5989778637886047, -0.3183879256248474, -0.5557476878166199, -0.3491496443748474, 0.3040563762187958, 0.025135725736618042, 0.37525030970573425, -0.48823341727256775, -0.20718133449554443, -1.001719355583191, -0.290930837392807, 0.19922350347042084, -0.5668203830718994, 1.1469124555587769, 0.4018460214138031, -0.1852140724658966, -0.6709178686141968, 0.33058658242225647, -0.5260815024375916, 0.009097350761294365, 0.005384625401347876, 0.6305332183837891, -0.39771339297294617, -0.7174541354179382, -0.32531818747520447, 0.1294097602367401, -0.18536993861198425, -0.026078414171934128, -0.28924816846847534, -0.4161067306995392, -0.20938439667224884, -0.05773482471704483, -0.5365025401115417, -0.2937818169593811, -0.5108188390731812, 0.06051599979400635, 0.041658058762550354, 0.1899677813053131, -0.6064310669898987, -0.10375920683145523, 0.1277688890695572, -0.05762162804603577, -0.03127248212695122, -0.3909319043159485, 0.5561189651489258, 0.23505738377571106, -0.2430686354637146, -0.012532890774309635, -0.8479149341583252, 1.0500768423080444, 0.468919575214386, 0.14269661903381348, -0.13471440970897675, 0.23521819710731506, -0.5224917531013489, -0.3533598780632019, -0.05066806077957153, -0.6904323697090149, 0.018606778234243393, -0.6700503826141357, 0.33069556951522827, 0.2545386254787445, 0.47013816237449646, -0.2400868684053421, -0.4965142011642456, 0.012619334273040295, 0.8993332386016846, 0.21468430757522583, -0.1109766960144043, -0.5875265598297119, 0.06092043220996857, -0.17640841007232666, -0.23632358014583588, 0.28522515296936035, -1.0271087884902954, -0.03424246981739998, 0.6553553938865662, 0.014170908369123936, -0.21897979080677032, -0.10547544062137604, 0.2908138930797577, -0.7098958492279053, -0.33076751232147217, -0.8149393796920776, -0.5651040077209473, 0.7175682187080383, 0.42834949493408203, 0.009431586600840092, 0.5629363059997559, -1.45138418674469, 1.2098969221115112, 0.21373893320560455, -0.51319819688797, -0.1787220984697342, -0.3617238998413086, 0.6416029930114746, 0.14559084177017212, -0.25336629152297974, 0.06186322495341301, 0.6449084281921387, -0.13865680992603302, 0.15401691198349, 0.3351272642612457, 0.4026578366756439, 0.2967627942562103, -0.021979598328471184, -0.0014379166532307863, -0.026677554473280907, -0.33420953154563904, 0.2690602242946625, -0.01142599992454052, 0.6237899661064148, 0.27010205388069153, -0.5706363916397095, -0.14148597419261932, 0.03371979668736458, -0.37230709195137024, -0.07898907363414764, -0.0170363150537014, -0.4369530975818634, -0.10362319648265839, 0.1724468469619751, 1.6287180185317993, -0.012003171257674694, -0.8462617993354797, 0.1032390296459198, 0.8946466445922852, 0.09080059081315994, 0.9389172792434692, -0.43961864709854126, 0.650116503238678, -0.12245872616767883, -0.6601457595825195, -0.3686861991882324, 0.04441846162080765, -0.406175822019577, 0.46299120783805847, 0.08716020733118057, -0.3847580850124359, -0.011975865811109543, 0.16671042144298553, -0.2827237546443939, 0.27184268832206726, -0.1606115698814392, 0.4516964554786682, -0.411742627620697, -0.2863796055316925, -0.5110838413238525, 0.5831484794616699, -0.7862608432769775, 0.8519803285598755, -0.06462866067886353, -0.46404820680618286, 0.3516313433647156, -0.3151857852935791, 0.46812760829925537, -0.20261861383914948, 0.0029424030799418688, -0.1566726416349411, 0.12752148509025574, 0.6965207457542419, 0.9238393902778625, 0.10014044493436813, 0.36912786960601807, 0.7050896286964417, -0.1639861762523651, 0.024643337354063988, 0.8785802721977234, 0.9549818634986877, -0.27157488465309143, 0.5729681849479675, -0.48879924416542053, -0.8973989486694336, 0.03280068188905716, -0.13587722182273865, 0.19909170269966125, 0.04666101932525635, -0.8304852247238159, 0.1332213431596756, -0.22432941198349, -0.8533429503440857, -0.35571515560150146, 0.5814544558525085, -0.11072347313165665, -0.5645859837532043, -0.43961775302886963, 0.342212975025177, -0.649927020072937, 0.3948622941970825, -0.9767628312110901, 0.8207708597183228, 0.41572335362434387, 1.0475940704345703, -0.2839072346687317, 0.6937272548675537, 1.320270299911499, -0.18603408336639404, 0.15076561272144318, -0.3333757817745209, 0.28624939918518066, 0.42711466550827026, -0.11613818258047104, 0.2099238783121109, -0.8088638782501221, 0.07810131460428238, -1.0064595937728882, -0.5214447975158691, 0.7562776207923889, -0.10300549119710922, 0.5278252363204956, 0.031876496970653534, -0.22036340832710266, 0.8140376210212708, -0.010972665622830391, 0.013325934298336506, 0.2990644574165344, 0.6412158012390137, 0.014641598798334599, 0.6327452659606934, 0.40794992446899414, -0.12878717482089996, 0.5863580703735352, 0.39760318398475647, 0.7335725426673889, 0.2331877499818802, 0.4390483796596527, 0.5861331820487976, 0.8393076658248901, 0.22448216378688812, 0.0739835798740387, 0.0564897358417511, -0.9254603981971741, -0.4997425377368927, 0.27385053038597107, 0.6185837388038635, 0.13223285973072052, -0.14808787405490875, 0.9871276021003723, 0.011550438590347767, -1.326004147529602, 0.35425305366516113, 0.28351354598999023, -0.3098796308040619, -0.36708512902259827, -0.3045157194137573, 0.12559299170970917, -0.19788038730621338, 0.49678295850753784, -0.057832229882478714, 0.6331303715705872, 0.8816791772842407, 0.4158322513103485, 0.32944971323013306, 0.27169299125671387, 0.1403738260269165, -0.4040446877479553, -0.8488216996192932, -1.7103999853134155, -1.0510804653167725, -0.5408610701560974, 0.28718051314353943, 0.2837132513523102, -0.5582876205444336, 0.4398818016052246, 0.18037429451942444, -0.05760972574353218, -0.29094183444976807, -0.03152754157781601, 0.5542186498641968, -0.050396110862493515, 0.4243917763233185, -0.7053399085998535, 0.02293788082897663, -0.6880269646644592, -0.13709327578544617, -0.317361980676651, -0.2938726246356964, -0.025929348543286324, -0.582911491394043, 0.4964330792427063, -0.8784006237983704, 0.26210546493530273, -0.5817165374755859, -0.13797619938850403, -0.20370632410049438, 0.940948486328125, -0.20522041618824005, 0.2887306809425354, 0.026291489601135254, -0.360733300447464, 0.23064248263835907, -0.41736823320388794, 0.3951804041862488, 0.34077924489974976, 0.34015557169914246, -0.16398736834526062, 1.0740551948547363, -0.01154070533812046, 0.16224978864192963, -0.3624805510044098, 0.38997942209243774, 1.1015069484710693, -0.76713627576828, 0.015503362752497196, -0.5741588473320007, -0.40210914611816406, -0.3151562511920929, -0.5175351500511169, -0.44013097882270813, -0.6166112422943115, 0.24216687679290771, -0.5450119972229004, -1.2220027446746826, -0.16765207052230835, -0.6445645093917847, -0.6890976428985596, 0.4622276723384857, -0.2814565896987915, -0.27337074279785156, -0.2496218979358673, -0.3899229168891907, -0.10770190507173538, 0.020625725388526917, -0.05721357837319374, 0.3885604739189148, -0.1850084811449051, -0.01438964530825615, 0.372781366109848, 0.5343306064605713, -0.3144630491733551, 0.3338969349861145, -0.26426413655281067, 0.32313963770866394, -0.7885174751281738, -0.1330622285604477, -0.9583828449249268, 0.6515260338783264, 0.2600691020488739, -0.16372007131576538, -0.4844701588153839, 0.8311372995376587, 0.13997788727283478, 0.2963588237762451, 0.7085829377174377, 0.47832509875297546, 0.06976009905338287, 0.11831217259168625, 0.21878834068775177, 0.16546548902988434, -0.6462838053703308, -0.4634086787700653, 0.2268415242433548, 0.4549098312854767, 0.43025219440460205, -0.24914662539958954, 0.8383030891418457, 0.114791639149189, 0.019897211343050003, 0.13346275687217712, 0.5261058211326599, -0.054219819605350494, 1.2906943559646606, 1.0389000177383423, 1.3025176525115967, -0.930564284324646, 0.5339067578315735, 0.7520788311958313, 1.1026527881622314, 0.07757246494293213, 0.2598569691181183, 0.5568038821220398, -0.7604354619979858, -0.2576392889022827, 0.1046588122844696, -0.5810180902481079, -0.5024160742759705, 0.672140896320343, -0.021284785121679306, 0.2185259312391281, -0.9359686970710754, -0.4465778172016144, 0.3360179364681244, 0.4284015893936157, 0.17978130280971527, -0.22024229168891907, 0.3845066428184509, -0.17478011548519135, 0.06379225105047226, 0.04957517981529236, 0.1952640265226364, -0.06059551239013672, -0.09836839884519577, -0.3445320725440979, 0.26721054315567017, -0.41001805663108826, -0.2392272800207138, -0.1064814105629921, -0.18487097322940826, -0.5929369330406189, 0.7629550099372864, -0.47127991914749146, -0.8236798644065857, 0.020122729241847992, -1.2150895595550537, 0.2701320946216583, 0.6428290009498596, -0.7165899872779846, -0.3114115297794342, -0.0743960291147232, 0.16868971288204193, -0.3035273849964142, -0.14896787703037262, -0.5086200833320618, 0.47481414675712585, 0.9791560173034668, -0.5094684958457947, -0.5725542306900024, -0.673380434513092, -0.39379850029945374, -0.696456789970398, -0.29625970125198364, 0.2292889505624771, -0.32062047719955444, 0.07777723670005798, -0.466613233089447, -0.6934661269187927, -0.8179118633270264, -0.14254869520664215, -0.7376647591590881, -0.2424066960811615, 0.034496650099754333, 0.625409722328186, 0.5838470458984375, 0.20020750164985657, 0.08891116082668304, 0.3757288157939911, -1.26978600025177, 0.7595097422599792, -0.7034170627593994, -0.5317877531051636, -0.039142027497291565, -0.34327155351638794, 0.2012048065662384, -0.31283751130104065, 0.40249213576316833, -0.8676131367683411, -0.1435171514749527, 0.5393521189689636, -0.1317121684551239, 0.08004935830831528, 1.0580281019210815, -0.8888356685638428, 0.0351078137755394, 1.8476561307907104, -0.42089352011680603, 0.07185748964548111, -0.26879242062568665, 0.06339132785797119, -0.40425553917884827, 0.38034701347351074, -0.3689991533756256, -0.19473126530647278, -0.434688001871109, 0.22956369817256927, 0.018154926598072052, -0.4177398085594177, 0.25348272919654846, -0.4271135628223419, 0.21209245920181274, -0.4565223455429077, -0.353137731552124, -0.1534121185541153, -0.3445514440536499, 0.0033381618559360504, 0.8853438496589661, 0.3231954574584961, -0.11391320824623108, -0.04280415549874306, 0.30182188749313354, -0.3785358667373657, 0.2564023435115814, -1.1112359762191772, 0.13227976858615875, -0.22946485877037048, -0.12554334104061127, -0.16181409358978271, -1.1315102577209473, -0.31113171577453613, 0.21939243376255035, 0.6329753398895264, -0.6422961950302124, -0.007269282825291157, -0.5437121987342834, 0.05011972784996033, -0.5301925539970398, -0.529717743396759, 1.041013479232788, -0.6407941579818726, 0.4290357828140259, 0.09157391637563705, -0.22514969110488892, 0.48273175954818726, 0.18367895483970642, -0.7287257313728333, 0.3553977608680725, -0.40647396445274353, -0.1672419160604477, -0.3575857877731323, 0.8214864134788513, 0.9494458436965942, -0.1665424406528473, -0.028879988938570023, -0.9445107579231262, -0.1411253809928894, -0.9503016471862793, 0.16545793414115906, -0.39898818731307983, -0.17070429027080536, -0.6808315515518188, -0.43843477964401245, -0.20342178642749786, 0.5359094738960266, -0.029430299997329712, -0.13432320952415466, 0.36328527331352234, -0.2972642779350281, 1.0321416854858398, -0.2337203174829483, 0.007728938944637775, -0.5353737473487854, -0.23541277647018433, 0.636772632598877, 0.7164236307144165, 0.2920922636985779, 0.34680965542793274, 0.2467132806777954, 0.060322731733322144, 0.34422627091407776, 0.8557553887367249, -0.6753337383270264, -0.379811555147171, 0.3792639374732971, 0.49771741032600403, -0.3633454144001007, -0.4159126877784729, -0.13798493146896362, 0.42013171315193176, -0.4518674314022064, 0.11695370078086853, 0.4280839264392853, -0.0811043232679367, 0.623347818851471, -0.4048968255519867, 1.0368494987487793, -0.49063965678215027, 0.18803133070468903, 0.309871643781662, -0.23498493432998657, -0.5054993629455566, 0.40898561477661133, -1.1236391067504883, 0.21949023008346558, -0.2198607176542282, -0.8328627943992615, 0.31354278326034546, 0.2037290632724762, -0.5380033850669861, 0.2790251076221466, 0.2910199463367462, 0.23812615871429443, -0.7504914999008179, 0.8230301141738892, 1.0060842037200928, -0.20508046448230743, -0.5501629710197449, 0.0663968101143837, 0.4008099436759949, -0.09079481661319733, 0.8742976784706116, -0.29500558972358704, -0.19166770577430725, 0.07034728676080704, -0.4066290557384491, 0.08708348870277405, -1.3499813079833984, -0.504815399646759, 0.5615419149398804, 0.24673742055892944, 0.4475369155406952, 1.0054826736450195, 0.16283701360225677, -0.2813466787338257, -0.2582239806652069, 0.5699635744094849, 0.09987770766019821, 0.2522708773612976, 0.671356737613678, -0.2441912144422531, -0.26331520080566406, -0.5360594391822815, -0.16746526956558228, -0.0337085947394371, 0.12047535181045532, 0.28157833218574524, 0.6247729063034058, -0.8113395571708679, 1.0540374517440796, 0.447130411863327, -0.2537432909011841, -0.4518047273159027, 0.07654280215501785, -0.41531050205230713, 0.18058809638023376, 0.11482053250074387, -0.11608124524354935, 0.2654868960380554, -0.6235723495483398, -0.5601118206977844, -0.4020453989505768, -0.19305011630058289, -0.051851920783519745, -0.7554909586906433, 0.2338675558567047, -0.8513478636741638, 0.21408136188983917, -0.08253660798072815, -0.37659892439842224, 0.1335170865058899, -0.2695918083190918, 1.2928869724273682, -0.3922017216682434, 0.006465135607868433, 0.603050947189331, -0.6096777319908142, -0.5063436627388, 0.028768368065357208, 0.23493526875972748, -0.07768390327692032, -0.5740429162979126, 0.49707674980163574, 0.5851122140884399, 0.2880108058452606, -0.11192308366298676, -0.8069897294044495, 0.15523645281791687, 0.2085370272397995, 0.602382242679596, 0.17997309565544128, 0.10804833471775055, 0.6188668012619019, 0.07918243110179901, 0.1885434091091156, -0.06747791171073914, -0.0398380346596241, -0.9160104393959045, 0.1680874228477478, 0.15046250820159912, 0.22271192073822021, -0.3024233877658844, 1.1946479082107544, -0.4812528192996979, -0.49584731459617615, -0.554111659526825, 0.4094642400741577, 0.5438376069068909, 0.4178510308265686, -0.2730671465396881, 1.1941734552383423, -0.3943248987197876, -0.5692185759544373, -0.03548979014158249, -0.5975580811500549, -0.12406045198440552, 0.7338645458221436, -0.47608286142349243, -0.48766273260116577, 0.8626861572265625, -0.7302442789077759, 0.49377676844596863, 0.5570480227470398, -0.7011160254478455, -0.09537804126739502, 0.17427362501621246, 0.4509202241897583, 0.1364121437072754, 0.09663376212120056, 0.9394515156745911, -0.15460620820522308, 0.27554458379745483, 0.4114032983779907, 0.23347964882850647, -0.7233179807662964, 0.10889498144388199, 0.7497907280921936, -0.17915520071983337, -0.34292271733283997, -0.02015131525695324, -0.07776297628879547, -0.8228479027748108, -0.14001530408859253, -0.43718722462654114, -0.6218433380126953, 0.5273452401161194, 0.2755267024040222, 0.1565832644701004, 0.7739371657371521, -0.04843546822667122, -0.33562618494033813, -0.7050884962081909, 0.3587489128112793, 0.561766505241394, 0.021478191018104553, 1.1582729816436768, 0.8781620264053345, -0.16518531739711761, -1.1928213834762573, 0.2836664319038391, -0.003832939313724637, -1.1943353414535522, 0.39775988459587097, -0.007989032194018364, 0.016869978979229927, 0.14501778781414032, -0.2803722620010376, 0.8405415415763855, 0.0151036586612463, 0.17640359699726105, 1.4042637348175049, -0.3429514765739441, -0.02946549281477928, -0.964698851108551, -0.12925226986408234, -1.565977692604065, -0.35155054926872253, 0.5137297511100769, -0.2226545661687851, 0.002389596775174141, -0.6407855749130249, -0.8647904992103577, 0.5248898863792419, -0.4127587378025055, -0.5140872597694397, -0.11054658144712448, 0.03547585383057594, 0.4757311940193176, 0.1851785033941269, -0.11173461377620697, -0.2390969693660736, 0.056690018624067307, -0.5987193584442139, -1.395614743232727, -0.3030376732349396, 0.7854462265968323, 1.1096299886703491, 0.025433309376239777, 0.180018350481987, -0.0814778283238411, 0.1321762502193451, 0.18516692519187927, -0.03580094873905182, -0.4071445167064667, -0.19556652009487152, -0.5133369565010071, -0.2707180678844452, 0.315125048160553, 0.21717269718647003, -0.6813390851020813, 0.27813905477523804, 0.09491133689880371, -1.202176570892334, -0.3076844811439514, -0.16097503900527954, 0.7928060293197632, -0.955862283706665, 0.3730539381504059, -0.46753624081611633, 0.379098504781723, -0.11441435664892197, -0.25587087869644165, 0.5824335217475891, 0.6975141763687134, 0.2585880756378174, 0.3145497143268585, -0.1814774125814438, 0.5307795405387878, 0.5598519444465637, 0.09464322030544281, -0.11887422204017639, 0.5195972323417664, -0.01851840503513813, 0.23964866995811462, 0.04778392240405083, -0.2143959403038025, 0.34403860569000244, 0.333274781703949, -0.8158431053161621, 0.03574497997760773, 0.3399135172367096, 0.26356956362724304, 0.3269648849964142, -0.11162057518959045, 0.5477839708328247, -0.19718007743358612, -0.08765723556280136, 0.5799477696418762, -0.045810095965862274, 0.8433820605278015, 0.5770732164382935, 0.23077942430973053, -0.07679539173841476, 1.2436435222625732, 0.11842970550060272, 0.5420292019844055, 1.0534415245056152, -0.7495182156562805, -0.2859056293964386, -0.7026399970054626, 0.8355847597122192, -0.19587679207324982, 0.317968487739563, -0.16694465279579163, 0.08658698201179504, 0.13619858026504517, 0.6352218985557556, -0.07281846553087234, 0.3791854679584503, 0.9069507122039795, 0.10732769221067429, 0.24552397429943085, -0.38895314931869507, -0.4984930157661438, -0.7093929648399353, -0.5771164298057556, 0.8062417507171631, -0.2763049602508545, 0.4467305839061737, 0.6565465331077576, 0.3261531591415405, 0.06662239879369736, -0.43562403321266174, 0.47518759965896606, -0.07893917709589005, -0.12595833837985992, 0.9734106659889221, 0.10753034800291061, 0.09933881461620331, -0.19856052100658417, -0.4978284239768982, -0.09547910839319229, -0.7245858907699585, 0.18688304722309113, -0.02334744669497013, 0.4400707483291626, -0.5593745112419128, 0.4366503655910492, 0.21054109930992126, 0.31480100750923157, -1.5772202014923096, 0.1284913867712021, -0.06722874194383621, 0.0033704014495015144, -1.001080870628357, -0.14542604982852936, 0.016167473047971725, 0.14426423609256744, -0.821334719657898, -0.5532465577125549, -0.25607040524482727, -0.27725186944007874, -0.9052951335906982, 0.5464538931846619, -0.08450072258710861, 0.09053412079811096, 0.28370413184165955, -1.5019571781158447, -0.3607601523399353, 0.5096272826194763, 0.19849355518817902, -0.8924943804740906, 0.10607126355171204, 0.290377676486969, 0.39791494607925415, 0.10780790448188782, -0.26111310720443726, -0.1276381015777588, 0.31015539169311523, 1.1239830255508423, -0.4142025113105774, 0.17521795630455017, 0.2872181534767151, 0.017290310934185982, 0.10197168588638306, -1.06974458694458, -0.30757927894592285, 0.17963907122612, 0.17156124114990234, -0.5061922669410706, -0.10650767385959625, -0.36128491163253784, -0.529934287071228, 0.5763276815414429, 0.4124750792980194, -0.347779780626297, 0.33673611283302307, -0.3094184994697571, -0.23917724192142487, -0.6265503764152527, 0.9860719442367554, -0.19222299754619598, -0.202415332198143, 0.5771841406822205, -0.0905556008219719, 0.10385171324014664, -1.2572115659713745, 4.146414279937744, 0.2702083885669708, 0.5520403385162354, -0.26525938510894775, 0.7062171101570129, 1.1198437213897705, 0.22244058549404144, -0.5814341306686401, -0.5002102255821228, 0.6149730682373047, -0.0007160804816521704, -0.1059003472328186, 0.19502131640911102, -0.3190546929836273, 0.8478838801383972, 0.6808058619499207, -0.8041783571243286, -0.18864324688911438, 0.1777687668800354, -0.9441356062889099, -0.1326410174369812, 0.28508129715919495, -0.054016027599573135, 0.7003542184829712, 0.8916612863540649, 0.44954875111579895, 0.15448427200317383, -0.06334980577230453, 0.2883971929550171, -0.6320364475250244, 0.08196110278367996, 0.08332814276218414, -0.11997256428003311, -0.3965429663658142, 0.17904770374298096, 0.38325294852256775, 0.13793668150901794, -1.1331748962402344, -0.628576397895813, -0.28440988063812256, -0.15432490408420563, -0.32825732231140137, 0.1084054708480835, -1.0064847469329834, -0.494864821434021, 0.2822601795196533, -0.005083511117845774, 0.3680742084980011, 0.1608227789402008, -0.6522563099861145, 0.8800222277641296, -0.44858404994010925, -0.2559781074523926, -0.12901732325553894, -1.0621147155761719, -0.17644253373146057, -0.7229161858558655, -0.4130672216415405, -0.036180444061756134, 0.3018743693828583, 0.6899939179420471, -0.291065514087677, -0.1361333131790161, 0.6398072838783264, -0.1819501370191574, 0.7741666436195374, -0.7165860533714294, 0.015593314543366432, -0.09880975633859634, -0.7460432052612305, 0.01422907691448927, -0.5948740243911743, -0.3567565381526947, -0.3614935278892517, 0.8049299120903015, 0.3789505362510681, -0.20980462431907654, 0.535807192325592, -0.13265010714530945, -0.38200944662094116, 0.35770463943481445, -0.043159402906894684, 0.8351574540138245, -0.6702685952186584, 0.22757360339164734, 0.8967008590698242, 0.605419397354126, -0.3359423577785492, -1.4241763353347778, 0.11192138493061066, -0.01342853158712387, 0.20160791277885437, 0.01711072027683258, 0.3526763319969177, -0.29339364171028137 ]
{"Title": "Aerobic capacity predicts skeletal but not cardiac muscle damage after a full distance Ironman triathlon - the Iron(wo)man-study", "Authors": "Danielsson Tom, Carlsson J\u00f6rg, Siethoff Lasse Ten, Ahnesj\u00f6 Jonas, Bergman Patrick", "Abstract": "Abstract Purpose This study examines the association between aerobic capacity and biomarkers of skeletal- and cardiac muscle damage among amateur triathletes after a full distance Ironman. Methods Men and women (N=55) were recruited from local sport clubs. One month before an Iron-man triathlon, they conducted a 20m shuttle run test to determine aerobic capacity. Blood samples were taken immediately after finishing the triathlon, and analyzed for biomarkers of cardiac- and skeletal muscle damage. Regression models examining the association between aerobic capacity expressed in both relative terms (mLO2*kg-1*min-1) and absolute terms (LO2*min-1) controlled for weight and were fitted. Result A total of 39 subjects (26% females) had complete data and were included in the analysis. No association between aerobic capacity and cardiac muscle damage but a significant negative association between aerobic capacity and skeletal muscle damage was observed. This association was independent of how aerobic capacity was expressed, although the model with aerobic capacity expressed in absolute terms and controlled for weight resulted in slightly higher r 2 values, than when aerobic capacity was expressed in relative terms. Conclusion A negative association between aerobic capacity and skeletal muscle damage was seen but despite the well-known cardio-protective health effect of high aerobic fitness no such association could be observed in this study.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19001149"}
10.1101/19003319
[ -0.1845434606075287, -0.20444077253341675, -0.38426682353019714, 0.8396449685096741, -1.133105993270874, -0.15365982055664062, -0.27941155433654785, -0.2920345366001129, -0.13344991207122803, 0.5309736728668213, -0.15788790583610535, 0.23967090249061584, -0.006357860751450062, -0.6730496287345886, 0.16270685195922852, 0.06750542670488358, -0.03352377936244011, -0.18362827599048615, -0.781816840171814, 0.09477928280830383, -0.7611215114593506, 0.5336529612541199, -0.32098308205604553, -0.35016828775405884, -0.28706833720207214, 0.43549203872680664, -0.44405597448349, -0.39600715041160583, 1.0281506776809692, 0.5552124977111816, 0.051944587379693985, 0.4168594479560852, -0.06922110170125961, 0.2287009358406067, -0.27637678384780884, 0.15274503827095032, 0.3697475492954254, 0.20662884414196014, -0.08550982922315598, -0.4791273772716522, 0.38711586594581604, -0.1325165331363678, 0.2249220758676529, -0.35160568356513977, -0.48359575867652893, -0.4588139057159424, -0.46614396572113037, -0.2368311733007431, 0.09912731498479843, 0.02821173705160618, 0.12870599329471588, -0.48554491996765137, -0.025034936144948006, -0.5652328133583069, 0.14398294687271118, 0.3329905867576599, -0.10792895406484604, -0.17902958393096924, 0.1445246934890747, 0.14165808260440826, 0.6989150643348694, 0.14141236245632172, 0.8753572106361389, -0.5267929434776306, 0.8758562207221985, 0.687978208065033, -0.25020962953567505, -0.17237234115600586, 0.07255566865205765, -0.21402867138385773, 0.18692001700401306, -0.4606174826622009, 0.18499019742012024, -0.40161821246147156, -0.34148889780044556, -0.44303539395332336, -0.09388399124145508, -0.058648984879255295, 0.07813340425491333, 0.3486262857913971, -0.7558041214942932, -0.986233115196228, 0.40366384387016296, -0.09966351091861725, -0.3636925220489502, 0.46379804611206055, -0.037579815834760666, -0.015973107889294624, 0.4607308506965637, -0.11140146851539612, 0.5895193815231323, 0.15241457521915436, -0.3443741500377655, 0.2674638330936432, -0.05150129646062851, 0.954666793346405, 0.202535480260849, 0.5281034111976624, 0.3627992868423462, 1.008279800415039, -0.32438185811042786, 0.28451958298683167, -0.19255590438842773, 1.0165632963180542, -0.15327978134155273, 0.258229523897171, -0.38073647022247314, 0.3523400127887726, 0.15765812993049622, -0.48914921283721924, 0.025662561878561974, -0.09608069807291031, 0.13511012494564056, 0.10330300033092499, 0.7379229664802551, 0.3411671817302704, -0.3301829993724823, 0.24511417746543884, 0.2508578300476074, 0.5902858376502991, 0.3432556092739105, 0.24782472848892212, -0.033138208091259, -0.4646318554878235, 0.47540149092674255, -0.03813938423991203, -0.5065258145332336, -0.15973974764347076, -0.39557012915611267, -0.7497460842132568, 0.14067338407039642, -0.014133838005363941, 0.1423899531364441, 0.4438621997833252, -0.41848024725914, -0.25723621249198914, -0.09476207196712494, 0.5919382572174072, 0.24302485585212708, 0.11057940870523453, 0.0005649696104228497, 0.15500304102897644, -0.28028979897499084, 1.0154227018356323, -0.3291696310043335, 0.6781138777732849, -0.37486618757247925, -0.7429017424583435, -0.271716445684433, 0.2033727914094925, -0.06615784019231796, 0.15900838375091553, -0.0906609371304512, 0.02413383685052395, 0.6610826253890991, 0.17089083790779114, -0.8211538195610046, 0.8144077062606812, -0.5461088418960571, 0.0007230889750644565, 0.4682203531265259, 1.2212625741958618, -0.4921779930591583, 0.23789551854133606, -0.07751395553350449, 0.49557048082351685, -0.3688875436782837, -0.18098393082618713, -0.2882888913154602, -0.13577628135681152, 0.8482843041419983, -0.6440884470939636, 0.03068597801029682, -0.5876151919364929, 0.3596993386745453, 0.4562879502773285, 0.6010444164276123, -0.3568020462989807, -0.26154300570487976, 0.09532852470874786, -0.01102239266037941, 0.20880047976970673, 0.39198213815689087, 0.5785263776779175, 0.5935529470443726, 0.04874398186802864, -0.5382966995239258, -0.30411800742149353, 0.11122391372919083, -0.3449991047382355, 0.12270396202802658, 0.1588074117898941, -0.05758501961827278, 0.3137160539627075, -1.396079421043396, 0.3506479561328888, 0.2115844190120697, 0.1264781951904297, 0.15060986578464508, -0.6358274221420288, 0.49801114201545715, 0.4361928701400757, 0.11828546971082687, 0.5444754958152771, 0.05905761942267418, -0.2244507521390915, 0.15160709619522095, 0.08707572519779205, 0.315400630235672, 1.345144510269165, 0.33854684233665466, -0.2779879868030548, 0.056043047457933426, 0.09322705119848251, 0.9632876515388489, -0.2933841049671173, -0.6710448861122131, -0.1841966062784195, -0.46044352650642395, 0.30769991874694824, 0.003056031884625554, -0.009013204835355282, 0.36216065287590027, 0.38023436069488525, -0.6056712865829468, -0.04447924345731735, -0.1179296150803566, 0.7094101905822754, -0.36080336570739746, -0.7541396617889404, -0.454168438911438, 0.5975632071495056, -0.18802420794963837, 0.38658425211906433, 0.7412495017051697, -0.21775250136852264, -0.14678829908370972, -0.49420076608657837, -0.28603437542915344, 0.1487269401550293, -0.0035481334198266268, 0.8056033253669739, 0.8070663809776306, 0.9354091882705688, -0.3649148941040039, 1.018484354019165, -0.19047698378562927, 0.14835374057292938, 0.24693921208381653, 0.7617405652999878, -0.20694223046302795, 0.9535837769508362, -0.818880558013916, 0.4923422038555145, -0.015974359586834908, 0.027914829552173615, 0.2431906908750534, -0.5469722747802734, 0.019082387909293175, -0.7777398824691772, -0.5810491442680359, 0.04149153456091881, -0.38231977820396423, -0.1386498510837555, 0.5380151867866516, 0.009004629217088223, 0.19178225100040436, -0.14471657574176788, 0.4530746340751648, 0.27119898796081543, -0.48558488488197327, -0.029110416769981384, -0.7956878542900085, -0.30855318903923035, -0.5135239362716675, -0.668053150177002, 0.28450828790664673, -0.6281301975250244, 0.716200590133667, -0.12375125288963318, 0.5640155673027039, -0.2601587474346161, -0.614772617816925, 0.17735303938388824, -0.5912814736366272, 0.426939457654953, -0.7674432992935181, 0.18814025819301605, -0.18660201132297516, -0.4583309292793274, -0.06795905530452728, -0.42812636494636536, -0.6611929535865784, -0.2621075212955475, 0.3583628237247467, -0.656640887260437, 0.07577678561210632, -0.24358531832695007, -0.39094218611717224, -0.50601726770401, 0.4913790225982666, 0.0010403982596471906, 0.12701305747032166, -0.38341477513313293, -0.03619479760527611, 0.20712420344352722, -0.3272041082382202, 0.501769483089447, 0.14104142785072327, -0.1165633574128151, -1.0628360509872437, 0.2990226745605469, 0.35386931896209717, 0.08820603787899017, -0.6161214113235474, -0.16999393701553345, 0.4405210614204407, -0.25718173384666443, -0.07976000756025314, 0.03923863172531128, -0.8237932324409485, 0.5016921162605286, 0.039243508130311966, -0.7249295711517334, 0.45970794558525085, -0.06005241721868515, 0.36832883954048157, -0.8825260400772095, -0.0751904845237732, -0.36387524008750916, -0.9160650968551636, -0.411146342754364, -0.37011125683784485, 0.8420141339302063, -0.34044304490089417, 0.13343480229377747, -0.10199156403541565, 0.09511120617389679, 0.5473834872245789, 0.10247926414012909, 0.751011073589325, -0.4672904312610626, 0.003685439471155405, 0.20296244323253632, -0.20168137550354004, -0.04611700400710106, -0.18637065589427948, -0.42743298411369324, 0.058851808309555054, -0.5529723167419434, -0.3860182464122772, 0.5725587606430054, 0.03719848021864891, 0.32232680916786194, -0.12710335850715637, 0.2534966468811035, -0.30370745062828064, 0.30528658628463745, -0.04418839141726494, -0.558117151260376, 0.3451176881790161, 0.288816899061203, 0.36447617411613464, -0.02820850908756256, -0.06491365283727646, -0.6210175156593323, 0.5072603821754456, 1.1290428638458252, -0.044190872460603714, 0.02410045638680458, 0.18081752955913544, -0.1654157042503357, 0.12633520364761353, 0.1337376981973648, 0.8394412398338318, 0.681280791759491, 0.18128162622451782, 0.5241028070449829, 1.0676243305206299, -0.35616251826286316, 0.13154880702495575, 0.2608954608440399, 0.33418962359428406, -0.6568917632102966, -0.4899478256702423, -0.40146058797836304, -0.5134721994400024, 0.40596723556518555, 0.05192866176366806, -0.9374302625656128, -0.30681362748146057, 0.16980195045471191, -0.7227969169616699, 0.2177949994802475, -0.9144299030303955, -0.49660754203796387, 0.047789040952920914, -0.26018649339675903, 0.20746199786663055, -0.18839295208454132, 0.22507064044475555, -0.07944885641336441, 0.8064149022102356, 0.7156144380569458, -0.400165855884552, 0.1947946846485138, 0.013025046326220036, 0.5332556962966919, -0.7506360411643982, -0.07224776595830917, -0.38482558727264404, 0.11351514607667923, -0.350075900554657, 0.14611782133579254, -0.5342508554458618, 0.7149527072906494, -0.35230162739753723, 0.4129761755466461, -0.06862659752368927, 1.0134284496307373, -0.08627934008836746, 0.3128640651702881, -0.34806981682777405, 0.04374537616968155, -0.40787971019744873, -0.43058961629867554, -0.500525176525116, 0.3273094594478607, 0.6063728928565979, 0.024757826700806618, -0.5485106706619263, 0.0999792069196701, -0.24219509959220886, 0.09244772791862488, -0.05712928622961044, -0.013237814418971539, 0.44543978571891785, 0.1091265007853508, 0.6140052080154419, -0.08198446035385132, -0.0326090082526207, -0.5335072875022888, -1.0266234874725342, 0.12330310791730881, -0.451666921377182, 0.7028915882110596, 1.4182449579238892, 0.6399621367454529, 0.32963278889656067, -0.4214931130409241, 0.6345102190971375, -0.6350008249282837, 1.5784019231796265, -0.05757974088191986, -0.030123678967356682, -0.16087079048156738, 0.4650864899158478, 0.04966384917497635, -0.49514204263687134, 0.23803557455539703, -0.515302300453186, -0.6584796905517578, -0.8696778416633606, -0.006033068057149649, -0.3054693341255188, -0.36418625712394714, -0.6437932252883911, 0.33600375056266785, 0.43278568983078003, -0.7720966935157776, -0.023101257160305977, -0.3364817798137665, -0.17204108834266663, -0.9366234540939331, 0.2448580116033554, -0.6593301892280579, 0.2652236819267273, 0.6167346239089966, -0.36830973625183105, 0.2001693695783615, 0.2467895895242691, 0.15001261234283447, -0.33630675077438354, -0.07441932708024979, -0.31797555088996887, 0.09437937289476395, 0.5097892880439758, 0.1487610787153244, -0.8781431317329407, 0.9849144220352173, 0.03517170995473862, -0.7583123445510864, 0.1764981597661972, -0.7010986804962158, -0.22235801815986633, -0.2587626874446869, -0.4938848316669464, -0.1277952790260315, -0.3675159215927124, -0.4975042939186096, 0.11936087906360626, -0.3833846151828766, -0.8143851161003113, 0.49486038088798523, 0.17846336960792542, -0.33094415068626404, -0.41824907064437866, -0.5301520228385925, 0.01891881227493286, -0.3156707286834717, -0.8265862464904785, -0.3246181905269623, -0.5701925754547119, -0.016218028962612152, -0.1601964384317398, -0.19839009642601013, 0.21954508125782013, 0.13873954117298126, -0.4263799488544464, 0.5316080451011658, 0.608647346496582, -0.8234999179840088, -0.5748669505119324, 0.7711199522018433, 0.4798155426979065, 0.9487671852111816, 0.07151995599269867, -0.2172960638999939, 0.16683445870876312, -0.09382007271051407, 0.3962981402873993, -0.5745699405670166, -0.6335889101028442, 0.09445304423570633, -1.0071649551391602, -0.17955149710178375, 0.37064671516418457, 0.028413645923137665, -0.3957153558731079, 0.4438839852809906, -0.6273701786994934, -0.16349036991596222, -0.5988045930862427, -0.059688981622457504, -0.06891268491744995, -0.9041597247123718, -0.42180225253105164, 0.8436145186424255, 0.19443000853061676, 0.4779244065284729, 0.2799834609031677, -0.5077127814292908, -0.18016530573368073, 0.1072007268667221, 0.34654632210731506, -0.9165437817573547, -0.12273592501878738, 0.6267725825309753, -0.5884588956832886, -0.7297501564025879, -1.0905574560165405, 0.9277826547622681, -0.512883186340332, 0.6940243244171143, -0.4221479594707489, 0.05725385621190071, -0.09694761037826538, -0.41647279262542725, 0.024806847795844078, -0.5379623770713806, 0.39999812841415405, 0.006134850438684225, -0.0040279277600348, 0.10928120464086533, 0.3154236972332001, -0.6777409911155701, -0.6766787171363831, -0.29743748903274536, -1.295173168182373, 0.6450269222259521, -0.45882079005241394, 0.043991055339574814, 0.12470750510692596, 0.15230292081832886, -0.45455214381217957, 0.037470340728759766, 0.7672662138938904, 0.8439193964004517, -0.5043155550956726, 0.5022722482681274, -0.22311250865459442, 0.5616104602813721, 1.1595547199249268, 0.664480984210968, 0.10259696841239929, -0.19643430411815643, 0.08844110369682312, 0.01996132917702198, 0.022800004109740257, -0.4553585648536682, -0.44890695810317993, 0.6681894063949585, 0.5069088935852051, -0.9465823173522949, -0.20215921103954315, 0.3612861633300781, 0.032264452427625656, 0.3123435974121094, 0.9337579011917114, 0.29849666357040405, -0.6954152584075928, 0.4691402316093445, -0.052791520953178406, -0.8201830983161926, 0.5316181778907776, -0.40816834568977356, 0.13654518127441406, 0.1251756250858307, -0.21237227320671082, -0.21665987372398376, -1.007407546043396, 0.775429368019104, -0.14948709309101105, -0.4146280288696289, -0.3280525803565979, 0.18971966207027435, -0.5688652992248535, -0.4376274645328522, 0.03460022807121277, -0.4677409529685974, -0.11473559588193893, 0.045308444648981094, -0.49432072043418884, -0.17623406648635864, 0.8571673035621643, 0.564719557762146, -1.1113495826721191, 0.5331771373748779, -0.1741826981306076, 0.320733904838562, 0.4987850487232208, -0.03536371514201164, 0.11232546716928482, -0.36667919158935547, 0.22667814791202545, -0.11863967031240463, 0.4852682054042816, 0.7992236614227295, -0.0752459317445755, 0.518537700176239, -0.019125180318951607, 0.17466047406196594, 0.40722939372062683, -0.253196120262146, -0.3859356641769409, 0.7256796956062317, -0.3302193880081177, -0.826043963432312, -0.5766112208366394, 0.31574389338493347, 0.5830363035202026, 0.2614612579345703, -0.30005940794944763, -0.7981305718421936, 0.7437026500701904, -0.15652228891849518, -0.02895486168563366, -0.07076995819807053, -0.4310900866985321, -0.2428092360496521, 0.01681140623986721, -0.05120304226875305, 0.2810492217540741, -0.7238278985023499, 0.2707988917827606, -0.20472285151481628, -0.3740939497947693, 0.6461363434791565, 0.2590874433517456, -0.05001695454120636, 0.028338953852653503, 0.37473249435424805, 0.13948951661586761, -0.24798648059368134, -1.042866826057434, -0.2743188738822937, -1.1371761560440063, 0.5725601315498352, 0.21516041457653046, -0.23993194103240967, -0.4012700915336609, 0.9790569543838501, -0.08339107781648636, 0.16619277000427246, -0.2604895234107971, -0.27098292112350464, -0.39470958709716797, -0.07817193865776062, 0.05226707085967064, 0.3811894953250885, -0.19904188811779022, 0.6201338768005371, -0.48973801732063293, 0.2674056887626648, 0.7788918614387512, -0.29447105526924133, 0.6078112721443176, 0.10489413887262344, 0.40626516938209534, -0.4697182774543762, -0.42233923077583313, 0.3663040101528168, 0.010869286954402924, -0.5394890308380127, -0.02782539092004299, -0.24051743745803833, -0.030764002352952957, 0.11280716955661774, 0.020631281659007072, -0.25055772066116333, 0.4028526842594147, 0.24940159916877747, 0.33026745915412903, 0.14156654477119446, 0.3481738269329071, 0.46564772725105286, -0.2763202488422394, 0.23457494378089905, 0.6376420855522156, 0.1445222795009613, -1.0729478597640991, 0.23111499845981598, 0.30037885904312134, -0.04160935431718826, -0.290816992521286, 0.05586571246385574, -0.09297878295183182, -0.823642373085022, -0.012271632440388203, -0.2069408893585205, 0.3066415786743164, -0.1776065081357956, 0.01703142374753952, 0.20235928893089294, 0.4270373582839966, -0.5616472959518433, 0.12381517887115479, -0.6568581461906433, -0.6667534112930298, 0.22698383033275604, -1.3425911664962769, 0.007886598818004131, -0.7818419337272644, -1.416612982749939, 0.048955053091049194, 0.18744732439517975, 0.41531211137771606, -0.03965018689632416, 0.5362256169319153, 0.7247616052627563, 0.4180387556552887, 0.5664973258972168, -0.02809378318488598, 0.274974524974823, 0.2734895646572113, -0.6613501310348511, -0.10180310159921646, -0.20352135598659515, -0.36160144209861755, -0.2375468909740448, -0.20516379177570343, 0.0258517824113369, -0.15604548156261444, 0.7112297415733337, -0.05277562886476517, -0.4767340421676636, 0.11964187771081924, -1.3212007284164429, 0.01988890953361988, -0.4020114243030548, -0.7771455645561218, 0.1264776885509491, 0.1649148166179657, -0.6122168898582458, -0.5309333801269531, -0.9410291910171509, 0.1772518903017044, 0.33412325382232666, -0.6457305550575256, 0.4958440065383911, 0.5772214531898499, 0.4488847255706787, 0.22702471911907196, -0.30486035346984863, 0.5238751769065857, -0.08997663855552673, 0.598426878452301, 0.34061917662620544, -0.3559992015361786, 0.11326409876346588, 0.9971265196800232, 0.86249178647995, 0.20671199262142181, 0.2886323630809784, -0.015320304781198502, 0.13554610311985016, 0.44039037823677063, -1.0279892683029175, 0.18429699540138245, 0.18894897401332855, 0.2948939800262451, 0.11427775025367737, 0.9193733334541321, 0.11400020122528076, 0.3971085250377655, -1.711881399154663, -0.2928808629512787, -1.2128911018371582, -0.35897696018218994, -0.7215512990951538, -0.029446152970194817, 0.8196355104446411, -0.1309242844581604, 0.8814451694488525, 0.4317396581172943, 0.30191701650619507, -0.2597430348396301, -0.6543874740600586, 0.5386737585067749, -0.39613303542137146, -0.6285926103591919, 0.025779427960515022, 0.0812438353896141, -0.0030792774632573128, 0.45337623357772827, 0.21539928019046783, 0.047635167837142944, 0.6756806969642639, 0.6337236762046814, -0.20820963382720947, 0.046532269567251205, 0.2283465415239334, -0.05640609562397003, 0.2432587742805481, -0.004817723762243986, 0.3890271484851837, -0.4876692593097687, -0.6029026508331299, 0.3147508502006531, -0.5867499113082886, -0.31563758850097656, 0.42514097690582275, 0.41885098814964294, -0.0706712007522583, 0.656951367855072, 1.1102782487869263, -0.14784252643585205, 0.5967937111854553, -0.1395420879125595, -0.04485512152314186, -0.1576349139213562, -0.38075926899909973, -0.2679820954799652, 0.0036952209193259478, -0.26622405648231506, -0.18895088136196136, 0.6692582368850708, 0.4097793996334076, -0.3970796465873718, 0.0700373500585556, 0.0952741801738739, -0.3440871834754944, -0.9284927248954773, -0.48961448669433594, -0.3875749707221985, 0.1874050498008728, -0.34118473529815674, -0.24621082842350006, 0.18044152855873108, 0.46892017126083374, -0.49025338888168335, -0.05245445668697357, -0.7848970890045166, -0.5111059546470642, 0.0865960493683815, 0.45647040009498596, -0.11561408638954163, -0.5929594039916992, -1.305713176727295, -0.9356293678283691, 0.34212180972099304, 0.44455963373184204, 0.17243792116641998, -1.0239108800888062, -0.0839608758687973, 0.9169795513153076, 0.4393882751464844, 0.3051236867904663, 0.09958574175834656, 0.3221859633922577, -0.5035893321037292, 1.3296124935150146, 0.6212857961654663, 0.759840190410614, 1.2862813472747803, 0.08368988335132599, 0.4309998154640198, 0.0573103204369545, 0.29544463753700256, -0.033392805606126785, 0.09185741096735, -0.2567879259586334, 0.6077719926834106, -0.049282241612672806, -0.045032281428575516, -0.08494855463504791, 1.1519173383712769, -0.8843809962272644, -0.1773087978363037, -0.6088531017303467, 0.029941953718662262, -0.930920422077179, 0.687104344367981, 0.10922089964151382, 0.05605153366923332, 0.2691866457462311, 0.24237944185733795, 0.12175914645195007, -0.6667743921279907, 4.360022068023682, 0.9548624157905579, 1.2438079118728638, -0.192966029047966, 0.6838009357452393, 0.18916678428649902, 0.9033049941062927, -0.17949245870113373, -0.3770137429237366, -0.5240337252616882, 0.27097395062446594, -0.006005243398249149, 0.397752046585083, -0.05650382488965988, 0.03664911538362503, -0.002629147144034505, -0.23025667667388916, -0.05828772857785225, -0.010397742502391338, -0.872658371925354, -0.8854540586471558, 0.42003369331359863, -0.4961667060852051, -0.12157948315143585, -0.13846589624881744, -0.6068835854530334, -0.0950530618429184, -0.08225371688604355, -0.11708942800760269, -1.2096071243286133, -0.5443496108055115, -0.035437390208244324, 0.9100361466407776, -1.1490906476974487, -0.15625181794166565, 0.7734951972961426, 0.7651335000991821, 0.08548419922590256, -0.18622605502605438, -0.6901035308837891, 0.7069339752197266, -0.13860772550106049, -0.02886001206934452, -0.257652223110199, 0.677056074142456, -0.2437097728252411, -0.3978748917579651, -0.8682724833488464, 0.48830124735832214, -0.46375519037246704, 0.9754191040992737, -0.4818151593208313, -0.13066412508487701, 0.520736038684845, -1.3775172233581543, -0.05406149476766586, -0.7766752243041992, -0.2606666684150696, 0.4638366103172302, 0.5886059999465942, 0.7452307343482971, -0.02822508104145527, -0.12967313826084137, -0.7820644974708557, 0.1636802852153778, 0.21786564588546753, -0.5306913256645203, 1.3435813188552856, 0.06391321122646332, 0.028550315648317337, 0.31691399216651917, -0.8503596782684326, 0.10589856654405594, 0.7716784477233887, 0.7795866131782532, 0.8728699088096619, 0.0010836657602339983, 0.3397882878780365, 0.22741499543190002, -0.20184488594532013, 0.5727453827857971, 0.41668903827667236, -0.14612801373004913, 0.14897370338439941, -0.3966383934020996, 0.6129602193832397, -0.05892587825655937, -0.44673243165016174, -0.8863019347190857, 0.5421971678733826, 0.3427518308162689, 0.655864417552948, 0.11580315977334976, -0.2028752714395523, -0.6872087717056274 ]
{"Title": "Toric Intraocular Lens Implantation in Cataract Patients with Corneal Opacity", "Authors": "Ra Ho, Kim Hyun Seung, Kim Man Soo, Kim Eun Chul", "Abstract": "Abstract Aims To evaluate the effect of toric intraocular lens implantation in cataract patient with corneal opacity and high astigmatism. Methods 31 eyes of 31 patients who underwent cataract surgery with toric intraocular lens implantation were included. All patients had corneal opacity with regular astigmatism. Preoperative total corneal astigmatism was determined considering posterior astigmatism using a rotating Scheimpflug camera (Pentacam\u00ae: Oculus, Wetzlar, Germany). At 2 months after toric intraocular lens implantation, we evaluated residual astigmatism, uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) and best corrected visual acuity (BCVA). Results Postoperative UCVA and BCVA (0.30 \u00b1 0.17, 0.22 \u00b1 0.16LogMAR) statistically improved compared to preoperative UCVA and BCVA (1.2 \u00b1 0.34, 1.1 \u00b1 0.30LogMAR, respectively) (P<0.01). Postoperative residual refractive astigmatism (1.2 \u00b1 0.35D) was statistically reduced compared to preoperative refractive astigmatism (2.4 \u00b1 0.65D) (P<0.05). Preoperative and postoperative total corneal astigmatism values were not statistically different. All cases achieved visual acuity were as good as or better than that preoperatively. The percentage of corneal opacity covering pupillary area had significant negative correlation with postoperative UCVA and BCVA (logMAR) (R=-0.88 P<0.00001 and R=-0.87 P<0.00001, respectively) Conclusion Toric intraocular lens implantation can improve UCVA, BCVA, and refractive astigmatism in cataract patient with corneal opacity. The percentage of central corneal opacity covering pupillary area is the major prognostic factor for postoperative visual improvement. Therefore, toric intraocular lens implantation should be considered for cataract patients who have corneal opacity with high astigmatism.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19003319"}
10.1101/2019.12.12.19014662
[ 0.1948387324810028, 0.08381234109401703, 0.25342151522636414, -0.11129938066005707, -0.6829777956008911, 0.6595388054847717, 0.5666236877441406, 0.7378007769584656, 0.3727263808250427, 0.4287509620189667, -0.38390377163887024, -0.731755793094635, 0.867495059967041, -0.5444208979606628, -0.384347140789032, -0.5375580787658691, -0.053908251225948334, -0.46200600266456604, -0.02892964519560337, 0.29495903849601746, 0.4473956823348999, 0.8327881097793579, -0.3559626042842865, 0.19258444011211395, -0.6572554707527161, 0.19209720194339752, -0.20678795874118805, -0.22649286687374115, 1.1987581253051758, 0.3543151319026947, -0.42675405740737915, -0.15168362855911255, 0.5884059071540833, -0.4384077489376068, -0.06358187645673752, -0.24883170425891876, 0.711182713508606, -0.43151742219924927, -0.050853535532951355, -0.9065791964530945, 0.16357824206352234, -0.058541979640722275, -0.13347847759723663, 0.16270790994167328, -0.23493655025959015, 0.19964517652988434, -0.42162948846817017, -0.24329322576522827, -0.43804576992988586, 0.18233944475650787, -0.03952791914343834, 0.4468724727630615, 0.2120610475540161, -0.0226410124450922, -0.12270399928092957, 0.03676412254571915, -0.09173102676868439, -0.5931199789047241, -0.7657456994056702, -0.09715291857719421, 0.41135793924331665, -0.07669103890657425, -0.04722682014107704, -0.32275912165641785, 1.1633821725845337, 1.159500002861023, -0.7507543563842773, -0.06119804084300995, 0.27448177337646484, -0.07136436551809311, 0.016542039811611176, -0.1237504631280899, 0.7175344824790955, -1.042079210281372, -0.7008559107780457, 0.14656558632850647, -0.10366057604551315, -0.0011793442536145449, -0.10624153912067413, 0.20103397965431213, -0.38263294100761414, 0.5861096382141113, 0.4599137306213379, -0.3324015438556671, -0.7010572552680969, 0.49912503361701965, -0.36782994866371155, 0.5669531226158142, 0.5270918011665344, -0.3481238782405853, -0.035089220851659775, 0.37663984298706055, -0.4671894311904907, -0.6154484748840332, -0.2183801680803299, 0.4775964319705963, -1.2171149253845215, 0.610140323638916, 0.29393377900123596, -0.5355563163757324, -0.5044375061988831, 0.6433325409889221, -0.3623444736003876, 0.3659423291683197, 0.07502031326293945, 0.7188747525215149, 0.08414852619171143, 0.12342590093612671, -0.18209116160869598, -0.21742218732833862, 0.6876438856124878, -0.40250998735427856, -0.12291119992733002, -0.3763834834098816, 0.5730164051055908, 0.3828496038913727, -0.6007611751556396, 0.4096384644508362, -0.9965922236442566, -0.20380574464797974, 0.19444769620895386, -0.8894029855728149, -0.07143128663301468, -0.7027827501296997, -0.022600257769227028, 0.16481371223926544, 0.07162357121706009, -0.05466286092996597, -0.687623918056488, -0.1599547564983368, -0.04079880192875862, -0.5972021222114563, -0.07274766266345978, 0.8916407823562622, -0.007478457875549793, 0.20388439297676086, -0.6385855078697205, 0.8455381393432617, 0.5346667766571045, -0.31960320472717285, 0.5052027702331543, 0.49533942341804504, -0.6343765258789062, 0.8020817637443542, 0.33820298314094543, 1.015249252319336, -0.46205008029937744, -1.225765347480774, -0.1361120194196701, 0.3356100022792816, -0.4123964011669159, -0.11408660560846329, -0.5369781255722046, -0.15006273984909058, -0.1245957687497139, 0.8364880681037903, -0.10151080787181854, 0.46846503019332886, -0.20598749816417694, 0.6600141525268555, -0.2147705852985382, 0.3493410348892212, -0.08069788664579391, 0.4529617428779602, -0.7425252199172974, 0.8402790427207947, -0.5959823131561279, -0.5790072083473206, 0.15467983484268188, -0.6059612035751343, 0.7073941826820374, -0.2503999173641205, -0.5133062601089478, 0.08970349282026291, -0.1691378504037857, 0.4194461703300476, 0.841135561466217, -0.0734979659318924, -0.21277423202991486, 0.023272033780813217, -0.09724113345146179, -0.7810918688774109, 0.19711777567863464, 0.752690315246582, -0.7019513845443726, 0.0013640495017170906, -0.2571166753768921, -0.8947699666023254, -0.3401927351951599, 0.13467109203338623, 0.11483259499073029, 0.043940529227256775, 0.029408806934952736, 0.278089314699173, -0.6926316618919373, 0.035933561623096466, -0.3551362454891205, 0.6801596283912659, -0.2114805281162262, -0.4000616669654846, -0.4602270722389221, 0.710331916809082, -0.18100011348724365, -0.05245893821120262, 0.024353977292776108, -0.007059494033455849, 0.35319504141807556, -0.08480577170848846, -0.5602041482925415, 0.5881242752075195, 0.7831546664237976, -0.14992953836917877, -0.2565898597240448, -0.18042390048503876, 0.33407649397850037, -0.7779935598373413, -0.0026477021165192127, 0.38466304540634155, -0.4558809697628021, 0.19603954255580902, -0.43300744891166687, -0.9122658371925354, 0.36750328540802, 0.3270927965641022, -0.24848803877830505, 0.697736382484436, 0.07289764285087585, 0.3605130612850189, -0.3324623703956604, -0.41386890411376953, -0.04337439686059952, 0.6597986221313477, -0.18915322422981262, 1.0731010437011719, 0.7982101440429688, 0.9443609118461609, 0.5155029892921448, 0.315311998128891, 0.20320136845111847, 0.16174450516700745, 0.021787570789456367, 0.17792439460754395, 0.4638832211494446, 0.12749376893043518, -0.10576406866312027, 0.3530016541481018, -0.9808481931686401, -0.06284795701503754, -0.31657832860946655, 0.34451162815093994, -1.1261487007141113, 0.6835212111473083, 0.5707052946090698, 0.18531189858913422, -0.413582444190979, 0.5344528555870056, 0.3740750253200531, 0.19152867794036865, -0.786948025226593, -0.6254837512969971, 0.45537641644477844, 0.583541214466095, -0.2410658448934555, -0.09771759808063507, 0.48081523180007935, 0.4469635486602783, -0.2774169445037842, 0.5023463368415833, 0.17460530996322632, -0.21937966346740723, -0.7470861673355103, -0.27668046951293945, -1.2323182821273804, -0.31096190214157104, -0.5883277058601379, -0.1800631433725357, 0.47852933406829834, 0.32727324962615967, 0.013232316821813583, 0.1948983520269394, 0.341377317905426, -0.7520505785942078, -0.8238423466682434, 0.3456161320209503, 0.5430256128311157, 0.3086569309234619, -0.18829445540905, -0.38019075989723206, -0.3499271273612976, 0.4001901149749756, -1.058235764503479, 0.06402202695608139, -0.612098217010498, -0.6887698769569397, 0.149474635720253, -0.41928842663764954, 0.2425374537706375, -0.07630941271781921, -0.14340434968471527, 0.583324134349823, 0.46697723865509033, 0.4514150023460388, 0.5138548612594604, 0.5840415358543396, -0.3505972623825073, 0.864116370677948, -0.039484038949012756, 0.7508623600006104, 0.7872939109802246, -0.33576521277427673, 0.46257659792900085, 0.4779631495475769, 0.21551775932312012, 0.5300390124320984, -0.8812734484672546, 0.7363573312759399, 0.9820271134376526, 0.7315472960472107, -0.08522385358810425, -0.7895651459693909, -0.8156375288963318, 0.4381455183029175, 0.6269689202308655, 0.0488789938390255, -0.24104507267475128, 0.12468398362398148, 0.1608646959066391, -1.3792617321014404, 0.7417151927947998, -0.7333562970161438, -0.8450033068656921, 0.08241117000579834, -0.15892291069030762, 0.19572684168815613, -0.03924333304166794, -0.01544517558068037, -0.4754401445388794, -0.026927364990115166, -0.4183410406112671, -0.0499889962375164, 0.2587945759296417, -0.11122438311576843, 0.1329198181629181, 0.15604494512081146, -0.5052756667137146, 0.5602930784225464, -0.40004193782806396, -0.2644176483154297, 0.07547315955162048, -0.16905994713306427, -0.03064299374818802, 0.8273293375968933, 0.5709006786346436, 0.1744915246963501, 0.5756660103797913, 0.3871712386608124, -0.21649211645126343, 0.2834269106388092, 0.4829196035861969, 0.1666569709777832, 0.45384904742240906, 0.3543682098388672, 0.4020012319087982, 0.19434617459774017, -1.2607029676437378, -0.5754224061965942, 0.3231346607208252, 0.10101582854986191, 0.5042787194252014, -0.25174108147621155, 0.03634032607078552, 0.5653601884841919, -0.14160630106925964, 0.4919449985027313, -0.34199851751327515, 0.10544698685407639, 0.8626008629798889, 0.2738388776779175, 1.310155987739563, -0.3767327666282654, 0.6114355325698853, 0.5288589000701904, 0.8458362221717834, -0.05194513127207756, -0.20681677758693695, 0.3477150499820709, -0.9668495059013367, 0.02087470330297947, -0.22927244007587433, -0.8193038105964661, -0.06409843266010284, -0.5930077433586121, 0.1601082980632782, 0.06390460580587387, -0.9120290875434875, -0.11482525616884232, -0.14577427506446838, 0.38137590885162354, 0.5029534697532654, 0.6375269293785095, 0.7880272269248962, -0.19481872022151947, 0.36536821722984314, 0.0796465203166008, 0.9832547307014465, -0.08671803027391434, -0.4161309003829956, 0.1999189257621765, 0.06113652139902115, -0.6263086199760437, -0.13883164525032043, 0.057846006006002426, -0.13264332711696625, -0.19613786041736603, -0.3817078173160553, -0.36247774958610535, -0.016884060576558113, 0.5954486131668091, -0.036366213113069534, 0.7481651902198792, -0.29663532972335815, -0.5022383332252502, -0.11857463419437408, 0.08677027374505997, 0.12448105961084366, -0.8649235367774963, 0.0002594728721305728, -0.8528070449829102, 0.5832030773162842, 0.9193623065948486, -0.5556545257568359, -0.4456694722175598, -0.6447108387947083, -0.6461385488510132, -0.6485499739646912, 0.2750379145145416, 0.25698354840278625, -0.6413852572441101, 0.14528487622737885, 0.20348767936229706, 0.03771768882870674, 0.26340407133102417, -0.3604047894477844, -0.10556560754776001, -0.36220481991767883, 0.35250452160835266, 1.009566307067871, 0.5965391397476196, 0.38417500257492065, -0.09568951278924942, 0.27486345171928406, -0.6437605619430542, 0.2589290142059326, -0.35796472430229187, -0.4901667535305023, 0.1467263251543045, -0.07700597494840622, -0.11566923558712006, 0.6865199208259583, 0.18736803531646729, -0.45874297618865967, 0.08914794027805328, 0.406408429145813, -0.41850775480270386, -0.28120580315589905, 0.365401953458786, -1.1065093278884888, 0.052578315138816833, 1.088596224784851, 0.11286094039678574, 0.007576804142445326, 0.25967252254486084, 0.7261289954185486, -0.6941467523574829, 0.05721891298890114, 0.11574316024780273, 0.057435594499111176, 0.8327709436416626, -0.37023505568504333, 0.3246288299560547, 0.4046511650085449, 0.3482636511325836, -0.5440422296524048, 0.555759847164154, 0.02148321457207203, 0.11739008873701096, 0.04722137376666069, 0.23905642330646515, -0.49300435185432434, 0.3625055253505707, -0.15982943773269653, -0.9063199758529663, 0.26289278268814087, 0.31069377064704895, 0.04340372607111931, -0.6802136301994324, -0.32194453477859497, -0.3937363028526306, 0.4943367838859558, 0.12218320369720459, 0.5882502794265747, -0.4691653847694397, -0.9894370436668396, 0.07281646877527237, 0.16166110336780548, -0.15598486363887787, -0.5070624351501465, 0.2795937955379486, 0.18278862535953522, -0.4326394200325012, -0.31588253378868103, -0.0461084358394146, -0.20144394040107727, -0.16540312767028809, 0.3023890554904938, -0.32468268275260925, 0.6977210640907288, 0.21940995752811432, -0.36638447642326355, 0.837275505065918, 0.3977203369140625, -0.46206972002983093, -0.9507043361663818, 0.785205602645874, 0.06112225726246834, 0.6218932867050171, -0.36034491658210754, -0.5692591071128845, -0.11043132096529007, -0.4509473145008087, 0.9530713558197021, -1.18538236618042, -0.7173826694488525, -0.6636289358139038, -0.16875094175338745, -0.4980892241001129, 1.2373616695404053, 0.19550585746765137, -0.43650513887405396, 0.0954551100730896, -0.6978679895401001, -0.07799191027879715, -0.11427392065525055, -0.23455213010311127, -0.9402422904968262, -0.7108065485954285, -0.5041636228561401, 0.15161658823490143, -0.025679245591163635, -0.48779428005218506, -0.18630173802375793, 0.3238132894039154, 0.15955466032028198, 0.20687757432460785, -0.3585287630558014, -0.3111385107040405, -0.4043636620044708, 0.1602630466222763, -0.191285640001297, -0.054979775100946426, 0.06958340853452682, 0.46871277689933777, -0.8859531879425049, 0.3682704269886017, -0.5127360820770264, 0.4430440664291382, 0.5699425339698792, -0.5945945978164673, 0.8725688457489014, -0.30081743001937866, 0.2643085718154907, 0.2973412275314331, 0.1996537446975708, -0.6107990145683289, 0.4634937047958374, -0.9844381213188171, -0.3695383667945862, -1.0074167251586914, -0.3295074701309204, 0.552818238735199, -0.5822737812995911, -0.42742353677749634, -0.22360213100910187, -0.5045447945594788, -0.20892450213432312, -0.45185479521751404, 1.2857390642166138, 0.8331030011177063, -0.5869436860084534, -0.5521395802497864, -0.464255690574646, 0.3557492196559906, 0.1385243982076645, 0.025523759424686432, 0.11102394759654999, -0.3425295352935791, -0.5104025602340698, -0.47297731041908264, -0.16006092727184296, -0.7332316040992737, -0.26124900579452515, 0.03578254580497742, 0.16473637521266937, 0.2182847410440445, 0.12329455465078354, 0.4816468060016632, 0.13291500508785248, -0.21596543490886688, 0.8805956840515137, 0.138963520526886, 0.6197770237922668, 0.15962785482406616, -0.8229668736457825, -0.8947353363037109, 0.5267651677131653, 0.31783175468444824, -0.518902599811554, 0.39928126335144043, 0.33709782361984253, 0.49603161215782166, -0.5113435983657837, 0.2639617323875427, 0.26824960112571716, -0.49171245098114014, -0.328468382358551, 0.5509506464004517, 0.20797152817249298, -0.028216825798153877, -0.24495556950569153, -0.35918205976486206, 1.0267603397369385, -0.6991503238677979, 0.30433645844459534, 0.09798220545053482, -0.069246307015419, 0.5250322818756104, -1.13051176071167, -0.5496839880943298, -0.17720180749893188, -0.5462870597839355, 0.650630533695221, 0.23329000174999237, -0.8222898840904236, 0.21202117204666138, 0.02717517875134945, -0.4565163552761078, 0.5495119690895081, -0.23197704553604126, -0.5747875571250916, -0.043160803616046906, 0.47481924295425415, 0.4627838432788849, 0.1747400164604187, 0.12239079177379608, -0.33797067403793335, 0.4969918131828308, 0.32678526639938354, -0.6195715665817261, -0.03789227083325386, 0.08352740108966827, 0.6462035179138184, 0.04979895055294037, 0.5074425935745239, 0.4645712375640869, 0.35069963335990906, 0.22886700928211212, 0.01366380788385868, -0.2132120579481125, -0.5352469682693481, -0.7088476419448853, -0.07298530638217926, -0.5935466289520264, -0.2450488954782486, 0.3980576694011688, 0.6870493292808533, -0.06184377148747444, -0.6806446313858032, -0.5218270421028137, 0.710903525352478, 0.2510480284690857, 0.35616064071655273, -0.237283855676651, 0.7505545020103455, -0.9029855132102966, -1.5899485349655151, -0.1730298101902008, -0.4948904812335968, 0.008650009520351887, 0.4780988395214081, -0.7135297656059265, -0.22985407710075378, -0.06571425497531891, 0.33522680401802063, -0.46216273307800293, 0.4169467091560364, -0.0457511730492115, -0.21016083657741547, 0.2049887478351593, 0.5805531144142151, 0.3123427629470825, -0.6257925629615784, 0.6860349178314209, -0.5436912178993225, 0.1811378300189972, 0.3006001114845276, 0.11577656865119934, -0.4197371006011963, -0.17553819715976715, 0.5358887314796448, -0.676363468170166, -0.21004889905452728, -0.12318401783704758, 0.8414788246154785, -0.5897499322891235, 0.4295554459095001, -1.3348801136016846, -0.2018391191959381, 0.7285435199737549, 0.4690549075603485, 0.15679901838302612, 1.2930359840393066, 0.1213705912232399, -0.2719232439994812, 0.18406523764133453, 0.7332722544670105, 0.3879411518573761, -0.11381632834672928, 0.4048267900943756, 0.33130690455436707, 0.302560955286026, -0.6308440566062927, -0.10184469074010849, 0.9652318954467773, -0.3751778304576874, 0.5189802050590515, 0.2032470852136612, 0.32602688670158386, -0.0958157554268837, -0.6940218806266785, -0.28906524181365967, 0.7095509767532349, 0.27315518260002136, 0.008253036066889763, 0.0029232031665742397, -0.18714545667171478, -0.14793901145458221, -0.21491393446922302, -0.34737277030944824, -0.3269687592983246, 0.612375795841217, -0.8730749487876892, -0.7189291715621948, -0.7909271717071533, -0.7877345681190491, 0.7053448557853699, 0.300986111164093, 0.21341027319431305, -0.4205639362335205, -0.1616540402173996, 0.4642990529537201, 0.49077117443084717, -0.20112912356853485, -0.03455198183655739, -0.042381711304187775, -0.3484865128993988, -0.9937057495117188, -0.12686295807361603, 0.5640154480934143, 0.018089378252625465, 0.35488954186439514, -0.8274202942848206, -0.6171478629112244, -0.015753990039229393, 0.5014556646347046, 0.2247556895017624, -0.37209242582321167, -0.42082250118255615, -1.093958854675293, 0.07150688022375107, -0.46222084760665894, -0.4507264494895935, -0.1400442272424698, -0.0418376699090004, -0.5564412474632263, -0.7376553416252136, -0.5398038625717163, 0.46695220470428467, 0.7055599689483643, -0.1151808500289917, 0.3129255771636963, -0.2343067228794098, 0.7522990107536316, -0.6476096510887146, -0.1337250918149948, 0.6828724145889282, 0.23624691367149353, 0.4559478461742401, -0.11040560156106949, -0.3694551885128021, 0.31879904866218567, 0.7043861150741577, -0.4019303321838379, 0.360758513212204, 0.5692988038063049, -0.11833260953426361, -0.04189307242631912, 0.17375628650188446, -0.7032209038734436, 0.15837275981903076, 0.827255129814148, -0.8342833518981934, -0.27338892221450806, 0.5115538835525513, 0.1334797888994217, 0.3297156095504761, -0.425173282623291, -0.48406291007995605, -0.6966087818145752, -0.06341192871332169, 0.18169032037258148, -0.6199420094490051, 0.5985164046287537, 0.3307560682296753, 0.29086536169052124, -0.3392769396305084, 1.3155760765075684, 0.21639764308929443, 0.09087130427360535, 0.5509806871414185, -1.1620240211486816, -0.865885317325592, -0.6070851683616638, 0.3827422559261322, 0.3339275121688843, 0.3827980160713196, 0.6548428535461426, -0.7970312833786011, 0.03726805001497269, 0.5290166139602661, -0.2490900456905365, -0.21763098239898682, 0.7399094700813293, 0.2736734449863434, -0.8752716779708862, 0.23466283082962036, 0.3696138262748718, -0.6657848954200745, -0.09184493869543076, -0.1822955459356308, -0.303715318441391, 0.3852180540561676, -0.4439062476158142, 0.3715098202228546, 0.5209273099899292, 0.6392138600349426, 0.3218924403190613, 0.28150418400764465, -0.021111730486154556, 0.5880266427993774, -0.5683727264404297, 0.5879559516906738, 0.4977566599845886, -0.5617901682853699, 0.08964700996875763, -0.8044449687004089, 0.5005824565887451, -0.19949515163898468, -0.28086647391319275, -0.5368514060974121, 0.36587828397750854, 0.3208404779434204, -0.32637661695480347, -0.15341056883335114, 0.1731499880552292, 0.3775726854801178, 0.1165851280093193, -0.07713454216718674, 0.21382059156894684, 0.6841964721679688, 0.06346653401851654, -0.1166648343205452, -0.3506492078304291, -0.037486884742975235, -0.018825748935341835, -0.3636462688446045, 0.44464415311813354, -0.62298583984375, 0.2781091034412384, -0.2168586552143097, -0.5560502409934998, -0.495079904794693, 0.07040325552225113, -0.1077156811952591, -0.5838322043418884, 0.28125956654548645, 0.07305305451154709, 0.6846315264701843, -0.235040545463562, -0.12821289896965027, -0.09166141599416733, -0.029845532029867172, 0.887850284576416, 0.34933918714523315, 0.769292950630188, 0.16093489527702332, -0.5721978545188904, 0.15829315781593323, 0.27298280596733093, 0.7998228669166565, -0.5711738467216492, -0.309765487909317, -0.17114998400211334, -0.0871821790933609, -0.5934197902679443, -0.7828181385993958, 0.2813918888568878, 0.31267276406288147, -0.2227616161108017, -0.0967390388250351, -0.7929137945175171, -0.3897492587566376, -0.2863837778568268, 0.35631707310676575, -0.2733745276927948, -0.49208900332450867, 0.4786740839481354, -0.7329559326171875, 0.4901105761528015, -1.2493642568588257, 4.3466715812683105, 0.9045915007591248, 0.49070003628730774, -0.6456679701805115, 0.5447722673416138, 0.44245851039886475, 0.6423395276069641, 0.24778786301612854, -0.21704363822937012, 0.3475766181945801, 0.538516640663147, -0.012613046914339066, 0.05297224223613739, 0.2250249981880188, 0.21458865702152252, 0.4317117929458618, -0.8893588185310364, 0.005594563204795122, 0.013564779423177242, -0.29468873143196106, -0.4189991056919098, -0.5219300985336304, -0.2983308732509613, -0.28662264347076416, 0.2521726191043854, 0.10094035416841507, 0.17107979953289032, 0.5948498249053955, 0.0560116171836853, -0.12920884788036346, -0.14078721404075623, -0.11742734909057617, 0.5294389128684998, -1.1355422735214233, -0.41837313771247864, 0.025045717135071754, 0.02366742305457592, -0.2595958709716797, -0.31364595890045166, -0.3639006018638611, 0.01589997485280037, 0.02880781516432762, 0.007399217691272497, -0.6945794820785522, -0.18971706926822662, 0.7171664834022522, -0.7136354446411133, 0.2868100702762604, 0.5429204702377319, -0.4135088622570038, 0.7627055644989014, -0.6258783340454102, 0.37634560465812683, -0.6590047478675842, -0.6506709456443787, -0.21091386675834656, -0.4093535840511322, -0.7864123582839966, 0.43854406476020813, 0.5350102782249451, 0.5179481506347656, 0.2642446458339691, 0.07640699297189713, 0.18203726410865784, 0.8233328461647034, 0.7365619540214539, -0.024365205317735672, 0.9227365255355835, 0.10884831845760345, -0.923556387424469, 0.009950784035027027, -1.0173299312591553, -0.0276250671595335, 0.1293964982032776, 1.164698839187622, 0.3713499903678894, -0.512493371963501, 0.06038469076156616, -0.28114911913871765, -0.3207967281341553, 0.24364201724529266, -0.18282067775726318, 0.22443987429141998, -0.40462401509284973, 0.1422359049320221, 0.08675826340913773, 0.07259369641542435, -0.7049162983894348, -0.8711462020874023, 0.4443393349647522, 0.32446157932281494, 0.11927293986082077, -0.1134319081902504, -0.40125080943107605, -0.06490468233823776 ]
{"Title": "ULCERATIVE COLITIS-DERIVED COLONOID CULTURE: A Multi-Mineral-Approach to Improve Barrier Protein Expression", "Authors": "Aslam Muhammad N, McClintock Shannon D, Attili Durga, Pandya Shailja, Rehman Humza, Nadeem Daniyal M, Jawad-Makki Mohamed Ali H, Rizvi Areeba H, Berner Maliha M, Dame Michael K, Turgeon Danielle Kim, Varani James", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Recent studies demonstrated that Aquamin \u00ae , a calcium-, magnesium-, and multiple trace element-rich natural product, improves barrier structure and function in colonoids obtained from tissue of healthy subjects. The goal of the present study was to determine if the colonic barrier could be improved in tissue from subjects with ulcerative colitis (UC). Methods Colonoid cultures were established with tissue from 9 individuals with UC. The colonoids were then incubated for a 2-week period under control conditions (i.e., in culture medium with a final calcium concentration of 0.25 mM) or in the same medium supplemented with Aquamin \u00ae to provide 1.5 \u2013 4.5 mM calcium. Effects on differentiation and barrier protein expression were determined using several approaches: phase-contrast & scanning electron microscopy, quantitative histology & immunohistology, mass spectrometry-based proteome assessment and transmission electron microscopy. Results Aquamin \u00ae -treated colonoids demonstrated a modest up-regulation of tight junctional proteins but stronger induction of adherens junction proteins and desmosomal proteins. Increased desmosomes were seen at the ultrastructural level. Proteomic analysis also demonstrated increased expression of basement membrane proteins and hemidesmosomal components. Proteins expressed at the apical surface (mucins and trefoils) were also increased as were several additional proteins with anti-microbial activity or that modulate inflammation. Conclusion A majority of individuals including patients with UC do not reach the recommended daily intake for calcium and other minerals. The findings presented here suggest that adequate mineral intake might improve the colonic barrier.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.12.19014662"}
10.1101/19011072
[ -0.19691403210163116, 0.8516722321510315, -0.21643558144569397, 0.5069167017936707, -0.5174187421798706, -0.12475686520338058, -0.970241129398346, 0.395283579826355, 0.2791058421134949, 0.654326856136322, -0.05104758217930794, -0.1356455385684967, -0.6461939811706543, 0.3617651164531708, -0.951445460319519, -0.6836968660354614, -0.46258220076560974, -0.06973195821046829, -0.06046675890684128, 0.23982924222946167, 0.12789812684059143, 0.9614851474761963, -1.2579779624938965, -1.0089912414550781, -0.9775578379631042, 0.8146013021469116, -0.06291228532791138, -0.6865667104721069, 1.321344017982483, 0.8634820580482483, 0.3353259563446045, -0.3741729259490967, 0.5612964034080505, -0.8314220905303955, 0.03125898167490959, -0.12396232038736343, 0.4979860484600067, -0.5033472180366516, 0.003191703464835882, -0.6378936767578125, 0.20968912541866302, -0.5612074732780457, 0.004116975702345371, 0.20382767915725708, -0.5328075885772705, 0.018762443214654922, -0.1365504264831543, 0.6354238390922546, -0.32988202571868896, 0.6687445044517517, -0.035708047449588776, 0.6436017155647278, -0.11145603656768799, -0.6404520869255066, -1.2660002708435059, -0.39834854006767273, -0.034127913415431976, -0.46235495805740356, -0.2587846517562866, -0.07698114961385727, 0.014462378807365894, 0.12179253250360489, 0.1842736452817917, -0.8704102635383606, -0.392774760723114, 0.9762402772903442, -0.8028671741485596, 0.2475605010986328, 0.07271504402160645, -0.12985864281654358, -0.2606920897960663, -0.6640545725822449, -0.45857807993888855, -0.9361861348152161, -0.0805060938000679, -0.3722936511039734, -0.007166076451539993, -1.3542802333831787, -0.29962247610092163, -0.20945395529270172, -0.5791701078414917, 0.635335385799408, 0.3631901741027832, -0.9717621207237244, -1.1705880165100098, 0.5667291283607483, 0.416950523853302, -0.16462789475917816, 0.774737536907196, 0.8502930998802185, -0.4324550926685333, 0.19310548901557922, -0.22665327787399292, 0.005021022167056799, 0.08119158446788788, 0.44640228152275085, -0.3316127061843872, 0.12071630358695984, 0.16929110884666443, -0.21464382112026215, 0.6899705529212952, 0.8332449793815613, -0.4723130166530609, 1.2464298009872437, -0.14394037425518036, 0.5088623762130737, 0.1680406630039215, -0.39088764786720276, -0.2127067595720291, -0.8066064715385437, 0.35694849491119385, 0.2939011752605438, -0.4651394784450531, -0.6903045177459717, 0.8821056485176086, 0.5306860208511353, 0.1986381858587265, 0.6342183351516724, -0.3607650399208069, 0.8475926518440247, -0.6990302205085754, -0.18101732432842255, 0.7530297636985779, -0.1382913589477539, 0.20391187071800232, -0.42660102248191833, 0.3916076719760895, 0.4293572008609772, -0.6514997482299805, -0.1732158362865448, -0.031105907633900642, -0.8554844260215759, -0.32494011521339417, 1.0507947206497192, -0.14681017398834229, -0.21898044645786285, 0.5035132765769958, 0.7811543941497803, 1.0337730646133423, -0.05026399716734886, -0.5009204745292664, 0.38931435346603394, -0.43425872921943665, 1.3615280389785767, -0.46148011088371277, 1.4984954595565796, -0.592683732509613, -0.2232760488986969, -0.46225661039352417, 0.28173500299453735, -0.10614202171564102, 0.08635573089122772, -0.6906312704086304, -0.12154236435890198, 0.23648199439048767, 0.9440022110939026, 0.09062977880239487, -0.2030053436756134, -0.3366774916648865, 0.2571229338645935, -0.7555075883865356, -0.38387975096702576, -0.10182159394025803, -0.1588616669178009, -1.1944186687469482, 0.6953125, -0.03617025539278984, 0.03691690042614937, -0.6002208590507507, -0.5623874664306641, 1.2392561435699463, -0.3464304804801941, 0.07075571268796921, 0.20650233328342438, 0.4900396168231964, 1.0745859146118164, 0.5175532698631287, -0.040848273783922195, 0.8342734575271606, 0.556853175163269, 0.5134516358375549, 0.19722777605056763, 0.16497354209423065, 0.6300866603851318, 0.1822020560503006, -0.3068336248397827, -0.1999961882829666, -0.5160494446754456, -0.3089543581008911, -0.2153301239013672, -0.21555112302303314, 0.5667717456817627, -0.5835516452789307, -0.28712689876556396, 0.21305839717388153, 0.021356452256441116, -0.07366302609443665, -0.1737009882926941, 0.6555456519126892, -0.14922115206718445, -0.4324274957180023, 0.2798546254634857, -0.44669845700263977, 0.08023010939359665, -0.9512580037117004, 0.8756260275840759, 0.4263453483581543, 0.19974708557128906, -0.8418921232223511, 0.34828054904937744, 0.675595760345459, -0.12975123524665833, -0.15326045453548431, -0.242275670170784, 0.46953898668289185, 0.008166489191353321, -0.39997005462646484, 0.07615333795547485, -0.4023945927619934, -0.1812697798013687, -0.24026043713092804, -0.27997180819511414, 0.44952094554901123, 0.3864399492740631, 0.550625205039978, 0.3386041224002838, 0.4296640157699585, 0.6879345774650574, -0.7434940338134766, 0.6432637572288513, 0.36999496817588806, -0.3293337821960449, -0.5171400904655457, 1.0572632551193237, 0.6779568791389465, 0.1771000474691391, 0.21100082993507385, 0.17113268375396729, 0.037124115973711014, 0.13166727125644684, 0.4749618172645569, 1.1574443578720093, 0.8179314136505127, -0.21957622468471527, -0.23366345465183258, 0.8120376467704773, -0.39408254623413086, -0.25306811928749084, -0.39885902404785156, 1.0046674013137817, -0.19068549573421478, 0.19558124244213104, 0.5913935899734497, 0.593554675579071, -0.5085027813911438, 0.44335171580314636, 0.09182751923799515, -0.44387754797935486, -0.4110061824321747, -0.5924821496009827, 0.04992038384079933, 0.33687838912010193, -0.5497693419456482, -0.8508899211883545, 0.4876813590526581, 1.2603590488433838, -0.251027375459671, 0.19057637453079224, 0.49106791615486145, -0.5364826321601868, -1.0130605697631836, -0.12638245522975922, -1.2247018814086914, -0.5315455794334412, -0.851091206073761, -0.1864788979291916, 0.02773236855864525, -0.15373852849006653, 0.04249884560704231, -0.43447715044021606, -0.6092429161071777, 0.33895763754844666, -0.3610503673553467, 0.5367092490196228, 0.48775938153266907, -0.6482381224632263, -0.7533239126205444, -0.15016570687294006, 0.358224093914032, 0.2640432119369507, 0.2206713855266571, -0.04006446152925491, -0.4359353184700012, -0.6063242554664612, 0.38925185799598694, -0.06650516390800476, 0.39743155241012573, 1.0068016052246094, -0.002533254912123084, 0.17041300237178802, 0.4272954761981964, 0.3998821973800659, 0.3709849715232849, -0.04198170080780983, -0.5869817137718201, 0.8669909238815308, -0.3261062800884247, 0.1717354953289032, 0.7266905307769775, 0.0047353762201964855, -0.2762397527694702, 0.8792099952697754, -0.5951523184776306, 0.4814169108867645, -1.0082998275756836, 0.4884130358695984, 1.0412516593933105, 0.1475997120141983, -0.4379480481147766, 0.07074613869190216, -0.7938418984413147, 0.40276023745536804, -0.19864383339881897, -0.44128942489624023, -0.7685995101928711, 0.2404567301273346, -0.1642812043428421, -1.5368083715438843, -0.19925490021705627, -0.3718411326408386, -0.5842904448509216, 0.6084756851196289, -0.26750966906547546, 0.08707170933485031, 0.38504496216773987, 0.06497261673212051, -1.227128028869629, 0.19320695102214813, 0.07479243725538254, 0.24421600997447968, 0.18835963308811188, -0.43136927485466003, -0.05111605301499367, 0.42998048663139343, -0.7338384985923767, 0.5149565935134888, 0.25901755690574646, 0.4080233573913574, -0.06611853092908859, 0.3495487570762634, -0.36981701850891113, 0.4707525074481964, 0.8698440790176392, -0.35830703377723694, 0.25359076261520386, 0.5993039608001709, -0.536613941192627, 0.5934496521949768, 0.08536189049482346, 0.2537776529788971, 0.35236218571662903, 0.2259843498468399, -0.19925127923488617, 0.05123305693268776, -0.8519971370697021, -0.5408962368965149, 0.6031275987625122, 1.1052272319793701, 0.4307674467563629, -0.15147796273231506, 0.7441666126251221, -0.19293458759784698, -0.6462626457214355, 0.031334105879068375, -0.43620240688323975, -0.20182587206363678, 0.5548871159553528, 1.0511540174484253, 1.0794453620910645, -0.8822233080863953, 0.5517058372497559, 0.10707511752843857, 1.1403578519821167, 0.07048480212688446, -0.26962515711784363, 0.5713211297988892, -0.3033389449119568, 0.03849808871746063, -0.0737728625535965, -0.5320446491241455, 0.4031459093093872, -0.8431428074836731, -0.36001619696617126, -0.0798521488904953, -0.05412443354725838, -0.6229299306869507, -0.012748942710459232, 0.6053538918495178, 1.2416300773620605, -0.0524909533560276, 1.1194002628326416, 0.06148360297083855, 0.7521043419837952, 0.35521450638771057, 0.41113266348838806, 0.6570817232131958, -0.9898389577865601, 0.2260766178369522, -0.09968216717243195, -0.5523349642753601, 0.0038957654032856226, -0.5361881852149963, 0.5281453728675842, -0.2511673867702484, 0.014737962745130062, -0.26766249537467957, -0.45738235116004944, 0.13549277186393738, 0.007683414034545422, -0.2802278995513916, -0.14573341608047485, -0.019831746816635132, -0.26165542006492615, 0.4151563346385956, -0.03178449347615242, -0.9459629058837891, 0.3657834827899933, -0.9141972064971924, 0.6164917945861816, 0.42361563444137573, -0.3276353180408478, -0.532281219959259, -0.40102913975715637, 0.02567145973443985, -0.7893696427345276, 0.4443739652633667, 0.2467678040266037, -1.0335540771484375, 0.4757313132286072, -0.8721039891242981, -0.16863541305065155, 0.17935387790203094, -0.37888625264167786, -0.8978228569030762, -0.06911331415176392, -0.07734803110361099, 1.415463924407959, 0.8319562077522278, -0.06290386617183685, 0.015495290979743004, 0.22397421300411224, -0.3393939137458801, 0.02693084627389908, -0.4123551845550537, -0.0005591921508312225, -0.33602485060691833, -0.38928499817848206, -0.19114123284816742, 0.36101365089416504, -0.28455641865730286, -0.6137449741363525, -0.008268696255981922, -0.09295503795146942, -0.8644254803657532, -0.7256351709365845, 1.1998233795166016, -0.2806326746940613, 0.4371280074119568, 1.096840262413025, -1.078262209892273, -0.5488287210464478, 0.1549830138683319, 0.3414286971092224, -0.768536388874054, -0.14866133034229279, 0.1043771430850029, 0.3480682671070099, 1.0514253377914429, -0.7497875690460205, 0.9162536859512329, 0.07234526425600052, 0.3799227476119995, -0.554614245891571, -0.16184671223163605, -0.41603150963783264, -0.45542842149734497, 0.4120204448699951, 0.7586706280708313, -0.7522917985916138, 0.5074968934059143, 0.8234217762947083, -0.7814383506774902, -0.16957108676433563, 0.41352882981300354, -0.5398948192596436, -0.5586029887199402, 0.2327597737312317, 0.4249064028263092, 0.26715517044067383, -0.31923261284828186, 0.8467437028884888, -0.23048076033592224, -0.7966828942298889, 0.3093410134315491, -0.006702225189656019, -0.7720893621444702, -0.5688798427581787, 0.32500627636909485, -0.6870259642601013, -0.22913116216659546, -0.348151832818985, -0.47027453780174255, -0.6361720561981201, -0.5151312947273254, -0.06619179248809814, -0.8735278248786926, 0.19326581060886383, -0.296759694814682, 0.3871096074581146, 0.39827993512153625, -0.554642379283905, -0.2143152356147766, -0.5873646140098572, 0.38414114713668823, -0.0767505094408989, 0.3568899631500244, 0.2159596085548401, -0.6475213170051575, -0.28853604197502136, -0.6234410405158997, 0.6700072884559631, -1.1542490720748901, -0.016517039388418198, -0.12460196018218994, -0.733611524105072, 0.5627933144569397, 0.15135732293128967, 0.06217686086893082, 0.3763639032840729, -0.24397091567516327, -0.6151986122131348, -0.24468994140625, -0.1666201949119568, -0.4044741094112396, -0.24936111271381378, -0.7267917394638062, -0.5202142000198364, 0.900753378868103, -0.1832805573940277, -0.7766355276107788, -0.47072529792785645, 0.6966169476509094, 0.07035649567842484, 0.48340821266174316, -0.1409652829170227, -0.4938242435455322, -0.2583698034286499, 0.07537800818681717, -0.41266581416130066, -0.1329624056816101, -0.7906072735786438, 0.9431673884391785, -0.4293890595436096, 0.1813221126794815, -0.4754509925842285, -0.21033653616905212, 0.664815366268158, -0.5774957537651062, 0.7612244486808777, 0.029957596212625504, 0.18054181337356567, -0.027406493201851845, 0.172170951962471, 0.13778558373451233, -0.11712762713432312, -0.677434504032135, -0.6553668975830078, -0.9381950497627258, -0.39188849925994873, 0.5373174548149109, -0.03556956350803375, -0.7286940217018127, 0.036985114216804504, -0.6471680998802185, 0.04468546062707901, -0.0498737208545208, 0.6979920268058777, 0.8319039344787598, -0.7391104102134705, 0.30094578862190247, 0.2928922176361084, 0.30193132162094116, 0.043210241943597794, 0.49593642354011536, 0.06083390489220619, 0.2886611223220825, 0.31112736463546753, 0.31175461411476135, -0.5356797575950623, -0.7865375876426697, -0.39603832364082336, 0.6827482581138611, 0.655143678188324, -0.04723212495446205, 0.5089135766029358, -0.07476485520601273, -0.4390767514705658, -0.7102637887001038, 0.9782336354255676, 0.6322930455207825, 0.4332517683506012, 1.2156416177749634, -0.02779468148946762, -0.5507915616035461, 0.020030086860060692, 0.4584859609603882, 0.4757838845252991, 0.04125533625483513, 1.0142524242401123, 0.00436455337330699, -1.3727425336837769, 0.5250206589698792, 0.9093868732452393, -0.14431844651699066, -0.27116408944129944, -0.14750899374485016, -0.05093805491924286, 0.20553891360759735, 0.09306260198354721, -0.5595048666000366, 0.7557801604270935, -0.4975188970565796, 0.8921353816986084, -0.4303534924983978, -0.677051842212677, 0.11871130019426346, -0.24109362065792084, 0.8938008546829224, -0.27876055240631104, -0.26433834433555603, 0.5663798451423645, -0.579888641834259, 0.0165410153567791, 0.11224187165498734, -0.7876941561698914, 0.3719598054885864, 0.4186755120754242, -0.3728371858596802, -0.285060852766037, -0.0840492844581604, 0.3939955234527588, -0.18817614018917084, 0.8701803088188171, -0.021837133914232254, -0.14302058517932892, 0.7674849629402161, -0.203105628490448, -0.8779452443122864, -0.5049184560775757, 0.42287370562553406, -0.4146582782268524, 0.03598210960626602, -0.2388354390859604, -0.4507876932621002, -0.0021548080258071423, -0.025369027629494667, 0.7033757567405701, -0.10596107691526413, -1.0555390119552612, -0.4453093707561493, -0.266590416431427, -0.4457022547721863, -0.515574038028717, 0.4502323865890503, 0.0932401567697525, -0.13957297801971436, -0.38568824529647827, 0.2862076759338379, 0.1625606119632721, 0.05155979096889496, -0.02385322004556656, 0.2915378510951996, -0.09901435673236847, -0.9203382730484009, -0.6399295926094055, 0.08802751451730728, -0.07125434279441833, 0.11761783808469772, 0.7751344442367554, -0.58347088098526, 0.13008801639080048, -0.05288807302713394, 0.38171398639678955, 0.44819778203964233, 0.7284160852432251, -0.4262901842594147, -0.4202232360839844, -0.2834297716617584, 0.7704538106918335, -0.22800111770629883, 0.07206758856773376, 0.8039817810058594, -0.45147505402565, 0.30936765670776367, -0.0035108739975839853, 0.06325238943099976, -0.4516693651676178, -0.18835200369358063, 0.18885529041290283, -0.2671642601490021, -0.5641179084777832, 0.20581623911857605, 0.6496051549911499, -0.9753413796424866, -0.5546032786369324, -0.3918302357196808, -0.10423953086137772, -0.12566684186458588, 0.06078025698661804, 0.25939440727233887, 0.5071261525154114, -0.14513415098190308, 0.6827614307403564, -0.02172822691500187, 0.4786776900291443, 0.483806848526001, -0.03598568215966225, 0.549308180809021, -0.10218308120965958, 0.3746471405029297, -1.143864393234253, 0.2865099012851715, 0.8496227264404297, 0.2634841501712799, 0.4946032464504242, 0.2868410348892212, -0.09958311915397644, -0.3609153628349304, -0.7807750105857849, -0.309501051902771, 0.17508873343467712, 0.11723610758781433, 0.8467378616333008, -0.07400261610746384, 0.27974188327789307, -0.0696987584233284, -0.5326479077339172, -0.9839420318603516, 0.0806315615773201, 0.6326218247413635, -0.9651316404342651, -0.6782156229019165, -0.21568551659584045, -0.45876312255859375, -0.02509637363255024, -0.04935772344470024, -0.08690395951271057, 0.37274879217147827, 0.2181517779827118, -0.4910421669483185, 1.2115178108215332, -0.2721857726573944, 0.3197198510169983, 0.10196376591920853, 0.09618763625621796, -0.6518593430519104, -0.416960209608078, 0.01413645502179861, 0.6731540560722351, 0.44972315430641174, -0.49767446517944336, -0.5061065554618835, 0.09288771450519562, -0.1748487800359726, 0.08303476125001907, -0.6081034541130066, 0.41206955909729004, -0.6623745560646057, -0.1540134847164154, 0.26159903407096863, 0.17250317335128784, 0.2776951491832733, 0.04666176438331604, -0.666689932346344, -0.40365272760391235, -0.6528194546699524, 0.34229621291160583, 0.5295553803443909, -0.63951176404953, 0.14352858066558838, -0.6556715369224548, 0.8046731948852539, -0.048420727252960205, 0.030707569792866707, -0.06569469720125198, 0.5413656830787659, -0.13365495204925537, 0.5595362186431885, 0.5026010274887085, 0.15864840149879456, 0.4391457140445709, -0.4423026144504547, -0.7056460380554199, 0.47255173325538635, 0.1730164885520935, -0.02850896678864956, -0.6211206316947937, -0.7431709170341492, -0.07320690155029297, -0.20380571484565735, -0.25936856865882874, -0.056498147547245026, 0.6779187917709351, 0.6507773995399475, 0.4833938777446747, -0.5871333479881287, -0.10186847299337387, -1.2488447427749634, -0.7109476327896118, -0.17981061339378357, -0.21043573319911957, 0.7572900056838989, 0.13785144686698914, 0.20119890570640564, 0.664192259311676, 1.3011260032653809, 0.44019609689712524, -0.1701357513666153, 0.33283326029777527, -0.42827925086021423, -0.1872478872537613, -0.5268295407295227, 0.5907858610153198, -0.08539514243602753, 0.03735486418008804, 0.3281056880950928, -0.7566211819648743, 0.26067155599594116, 0.3879278302192688, -0.560614287853241, -0.32485589385032654, 0.8899142742156982, 0.5063605904579163, -0.859088122844696, -0.4120620787143707, 0.6249450445175171, -0.6538955569267273, -0.24507157504558563, 0.24397361278533936, 0.04716500639915466, -0.12968949973583221, -0.13770541548728943, 0.47245460748672485, 0.017169926315546036, 0.6060588955879211, 0.8614268898963928, -0.18940916657447815, 0.2580309212207794, 0.770443320274353, -0.23210258781909943, 0.1634199023246765, 0.3215450048446655, -0.37843844294548035, -0.08833762258291245, 0.027905307710170746, -0.4440171718597412, 0.535194993019104, -0.637615978717804, -0.631878137588501, 0.04454999044537544, 0.2377658635377884, -0.5405935645103455, -0.34140393137931824, -0.42686888575553894, -0.20889084041118622, 0.7645832300186157, -0.7473602294921875, 0.497320294380188, 0.09405926614999771, -0.15457472205162048, -0.12927977740764618, -0.36277827620506287, -0.009021895937621593, 0.8064122796058655, -0.9784130454063416, 0.2856830060482025, -0.23565302789211273, 0.13795776665210724, -0.4807552397251129, -1.2024240493774414, 0.10106650739908218, -0.15501360595226288, 0.33926841616630554, -0.6155500411987305, -0.15054243803024292, 1.0835927724838257, 0.7737844586372375, 0.413077175617218, 0.6808725595474243, -0.15882669389247894, 0.25411325693130493, 0.8835331797599792, 0.4685048460960388, 0.04392009600996971, -0.3082621097564697, 0.25198373198509216, 0.14478307962417603, -0.019652148708701134, 0.48625725507736206, -0.27730023860931396, -0.3440816104412079, -0.2526915669441223, 0.5829219222068787, -0.20729266107082367, -0.4971396028995514, 0.22079746425151825, 0.5134446620941162, -0.12229502201080322, -0.1754816472530365, -0.3626226484775543, -0.4931733310222626, -0.45467785000801086, 0.8632009029388428, -0.31016626954078674, -0.6458443403244019, 0.47576454281806946, -0.1440153568983078, 0.3728961646556854, -0.5277664065361023, 4.063698768615723, 0.8891834020614624, 0.0994693860411644, 0.01629479229450226, 0.9850376844406128, 0.1441541314125061, 0.5648460984230042, 0.23283414542675018, 0.49536916613578796, -0.08273306488990784, 0.16491951048374176, -0.0614926740527153, -0.43998557329177856, -0.24912303686141968, -0.0029750708490610123, -0.16545610129833221, -0.2490953803062439, 0.38325777649879456, -0.08681168407201767, -0.8540790677070618, -0.3963932991027832, 0.23903729021549225, -0.9203292727470398, 0.38337647914886475, 0.39294037222862244, -0.05394715443253517, -0.10509956628084183, 0.18538133800029755, 0.44221219420433044, -0.19432851672172546, 0.19530794024467468, -0.8968210816383362, 0.018343845382332802, -1.4603790044784546, -0.8856899738311768, 0.17054831981658936, 0.604024350643158, -0.52839595079422, -0.23999853432178497, -0.35338976979255676, 0.26369619369506836, 0.7715516090393066, 0.09234953671693802, -0.4069719910621643, -0.12086519598960876, 0.35633981227874756, -0.5897930264472961, -0.12232161313295364, 0.5858511328697205, -0.3718952238559723, 0.2255149483680725, -1.0484415292739868, 1.088902235031128, 0.23577174544334412, -0.6946430802345276, -0.05830724164843559, 0.16649729013442993, -1.2220591306686401, 0.6294866800308228, 0.9783943891525269, 0.2925463914871216, -0.5158478617668152, 0.78260737657547, 0.4496647119522095, -0.1970231682062149, 0.3155462443828583, 0.11937502771615982, -0.4555220603942871, 0.18300822377204895, -0.7218075394630432, 0.13185426592826843, -0.7294302582740784, -0.34022611379623413, -0.2948112189769745, 0.6882265210151672, 0.3781851828098297, 0.2974359691143036, 0.8350784182548523, -0.41896191239356995, -0.6898877620697021, -0.050572749227285385, -0.2926945388317108, -0.30523180961608887, -0.2615754306316376, -0.07620876282453537, 0.8132660984992981, -0.13103875517845154, 0.21601280570030212, -0.02497193031013012, 0.18282203376293182, 0.5299359560012817, 0.5056191682815552, 0.10721622407436371, 0.3474934697151184, 0.2926785349845886 ]
{"Title": "Achieving coordinated national immunity and cholera elimination in Haiti through vaccination", "Authors": "Lee Elizabeth C., Chao Dennis L., Lemaitre Joseph, Matrajt Laura, Pasetto Damiano, Perez-Saez Javier, Finger Flavio, Rinaldo Andrea, Sugimoto Jonathan D., Halloran M. Elizabeth, Longini Ira M. Jr., Ternier Ralph, Vissieres Kenia, Azman Andrew S., Lessler Justin, Ivers Louise C.", "Abstract": "Summary Background Cholera was introduced into Haiti in 2010. Since, there have been over 820,000 reported cases and nearly 10,000 deaths. The year 2019 has seen the lowest reported number of cases since the epidemic began. Oral cholera vaccine (OCV) is safe and effective, but has generally not been seen as a primary tool for cholera elimination due to a limited period of protection and constrained supplies. Regionally, epidemic cholera is contained to the island of Hispaniola. Hence, Haiti may represent a unique opportunity to eliminate cholera by use of OCV. Methods We assess the probability of elimination and the potential health impact of OCV use in Haiti by leveraging simulations from four independent modeling teams. For a 10-year projection period, we compared the impact of five vaccination campaign scenarios, differing in geographic scope, vaccination coverage, and rollout duration to a status quo scenario without vaccination. Teams used common calibration data and assumptions for vaccine efficacy and vaccination scenarios, but all other model features and assumptions were determined independently. Findings A two-department OCV campaign proposed in Haiti\u2019s national plan for elimination had less than 50% probability of elimination across models, and only ambitious, nationwide campaigns had a high probability of reaching this goal. Despite their low probability of elimination, two-department campaigns averted a median of 13-58% of infections across models over the five years after the start of vaccination campaigns; a nationwide campaign implemented at the same coverage and rollout duration averted a median of 58-95% of infections across models. Interpretation Despite recent declines in cholera cases in Haiti, bold action is needed to promote elimination of cholera from the region. Large-scale cholera vaccination campaigns in Haiti offer the opportunity to synchronize nationwide immunity, providing near-term protection to the population while improvements to water and sanitation infrastructure create an environment favorable to long-term cholera elimination. Research in Context Evidence before this study We searched PubMed without language or date restrictions on October 4, 2019 for all records matching (\u201ccholera*\u201d AND \u201cHaiti\u201d AND (\u201cvaccin*\u201d OR \u201celim*\u201d)) in any field and added one known article on the probability of elimination of cholera that was not indexed by PubMed to our review. Of 94 results, four articles were not about the cholera outbreak in Haiti or the use of cholera vaccination, and 34 were not original research articles. Fourteen articles presented research on cholera biology or cholera vaccine biology, either through discussion of Vibrio cholerae genetics, immunogenicity of oral cholera vaccine (OCV), or prospective vaccine candidate antigens. Twenty articles assessed OCV vaccine effectiveness, evaluated OCV campaign implementation or attitudes and knowledge about cholera control, or presented lessons learned on outbreak response and policy as a result of the Haiti cholera outbreak. Seven articles were about general cholera outbreak epidemiology in Haiti, and six articles were related to cholera transmission models outside our research scope. Of the nine remaining articles, five examined the impact of potential OCV campaigns at an early time point when Haiti\u2019s cholera outbreak still exhibited epidemic dynamics, and one other projected the impact of the OCV campaigns planned after Hurricane Matthew in 2016. Two of the articles considered prospects for cholera elimination in Haiti in 2013 and 2014 and found that further targeted interventions were needed. One final study from 2017 modeled the possibility for OCV campaigns to eliminate cholera transmission in the Ouest department within a few years. Added value of this study Previous assessments of the impact of OCV use in Haiti occurred during early points of the outbreak when OCV campaigns were unlikely to lead to cholera elimination. Our study projects cholera transmission in Haiti with multiple years of more recent data, and directly examines prospect of cholera elimination in the status quo and under various mass OCV campaign scenarios. In bringing together results from multiple modeling teams, our study provides robust evidence about the current state of cholera transmission across Haiti and the potential impact of multiple mass OCV campaign scenarios. Implications of all of the available evidence While 2019 has seen the lowest number of cholera cases in Haiti since the outbreak began, model simulations suggest that it may be possible for cholera transmission to persist without additional cholera control interventions.While a single two-department vaccination campaign may avert roughly 13-58% of infections with V. cholerae over a five year period, only a nationwide campaign led to a high probability of cholera elimination. Ambitious nationwide vaccination campaigns may break the cycle of endemic cholera transmission in Haiti as long-term improvements to water and sanitation infrastructure, which will limit the effects of potential re-introductions of Vibrio cholerae , are being made.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19011072"}
10.1101/19001214
[ 0.10083935409784317, -0.5318938493728638, 0.047032665461301804, 0.5825725793838501, -0.4860118329524994, -0.8941283226013184, 0.06357380747795105, 0.4560641348361969, 0.237323597073555, 0.3805385231971741, -0.6076831817626953, -1.1693551540374756, 0.5319532155990601, 0.12361516058444977, -0.35609009861946106, -0.046576518565416336, -0.8683022260665894, 0.33889371156692505, 0.15062397718429565, 0.16401773691177368, 1.0502620935440063, 0.3160613775253296, -0.6580771803855896, -0.06709460914134979, -0.2416728436946869, 0.6599591970443726, -0.15819117426872253, 0.32131776213645935, 1.1910793781280518, 0.4516703486442566, 0.15717460215091705, -0.3742561638355255, 0.20164158940315247, -0.9433225989341736, -0.03293627128005028, 0.03849659487605095, 0.7139854431152344, -0.5780757069587708, 0.04186857119202614, 0.19552473723888397, 0.15269872546195984, -0.15637031197547913, 0.49347296357154846, -0.27670353651046753, 0.039864782243967056, -0.23915374279022217, -0.75534987449646, -0.0787053108215332, -0.6265906691551208, -0.28839927911758423, -0.19908440113067627, -0.1401446908712387, 0.09338604658842087, -0.6429129242897034, 0.3202226459980011, -0.2649242877960205, -0.03207485005259514, 0.1152101531624794, -0.8504645228385925, -0.494238942861557, -0.03598108887672424, 0.3467651903629303, 0.5675013065338135, -1.240255355834961, 0.6909167766571045, 0.48213693499565125, -0.10435479134321213, -0.6796146631240845, -0.571870744228363, -0.2656323313713074, -0.5746033191680908, -0.2037193328142166, -0.5674051642417908, -0.6163268685340881, -0.2992589771747589, 0.03237546980381012, 0.20968861877918243, -0.20101647078990936, 0.46342337131500244, -0.041867945343256, 0.327305406332016, 0.45442891120910645, -0.02434917911887169, 0.3775847852230072, -0.5759449601173401, 0.12232644110918045, 0.9131717681884766, 0.6727853417396545, 0.6449631452560425, -0.30662626028060913, 0.5000470280647278, 0.11831201612949371, -0.30941492319107056, 0.4071866571903229, 0.11657023429870605, 0.9893550872802734, -0.30852529406547546, -0.11446528136730194, 0.07257582992315292, 0.1742703765630722, 0.7633594274520874, 0.3690238893032074, -0.09037599712610245, 1.3045017719268799, -0.3489305377006531, 0.7428203821182251, 0.6475753784179688, -0.32167065143585205, -0.20630155503749847, -1.0170682668685913, 0.12104440480470657, 0.18238598108291626, -0.3734514117240906, 0.012817665003240108, 0.17598959803581238, 0.7187798023223877, 0.0660795271396637, 1.0013413429260254, -0.7752229571342468, 0.4265938997268677, -0.39825350046157837, 0.35714036226272583, 0.5703784227371216, -0.5575779676437378, 0.2997501790523529, -0.8218889236450195, 0.645282506942749, 0.9211208820343018, -0.4378878176212311, -0.26064667105674744, 0.15499429404735565, -1.1625772714614868, -0.16200868785381317, 0.25476890802383423, -0.16574382781982422, -0.49461039900779724, 0.20997458696365356, 1.5772608518600464, 0.05809743329882622, -0.25709792971611023, -0.38562723994255066, 0.2694114148616791, -0.4342086911201477, 0.9814159870147705, -0.3636775314807892, 0.7337422966957092, -0.026049451902508736, -1.4184658527374268, -0.3841593265533447, 0.3592434823513031, 0.3262384235858917, 0.32266831398010254, 0.32893675565719604, -0.24065768718719482, 0.17797346413135529, 0.17292198538780212, -0.6442779898643494, 0.38225021958351135, 0.25400397181510925, -0.2405751496553421, -0.857714831829071, 0.7686339020729065, -0.23930150270462036, 0.6512253284454346, -0.09536942839622498, 0.40161797404289246, 0.15760111808776855, 0.3951306641101837, 0.420234352350235, -0.5593477487564087, 0.47946488857269287, 0.39183881878852844, -0.5244404673576355, 0.6497161388397217, 0.6866539716720581, 0.8306244015693665, 0.9218887686729431, -0.2998366355895996, 1.1456999778747559, 0.15005835890769958, 0.16037540137767792, 0.044028740376234055, 0.5607630610466003, 1.2043739557266235, -0.873615026473999, -0.014332613907754421, -0.62701815366745, -0.8243303298950195, 0.22769902646541595, -0.11644833534955978, 0.01697641611099243, 0.1890699416399002, -0.9178879261016846, 0.8607964515686035, 0.3536856770515442, 0.04363127797842026, -0.09565167874097824, 0.7706384062767029, 0.6818668246269226, -0.7496413588523865, -0.22154201567173004, 0.7778761982917786, -0.2062479853630066, 0.4039786756038666, 0.2176966816186905, 0.7836002111434937, 0.15530966222286224, -0.14848704636096954, 0.10796228796243668, 0.01824241504073143, 1.1060030460357666, 0.08996773511171341, 0.07317051291465759, -0.07665133476257324, 0.6322945952415466, -0.9589704871177673, -0.4134284257888794, 0.005897211376577616, -0.7289841175079346, -0.4325063228607178, -0.7526428699493408, -0.12163575738668442, 0.638083815574646, 0.09430917352437973, -0.3060210645198822, 0.1585753709077835, 0.452176570892334, 0.2591441571712494, -0.2230493724346161, -0.3450411558151245, 0.24477618932724, 0.9478577375411987, 0.28932470083236694, 0.5385628938674927, 0.7243136167526245, -0.027180757373571396, 0.41210898756980896, 0.3744320869445801, 0.07616158574819565, 0.11437676101922989, 0.05867121368646622, 0.812156617641449, 0.5278562903404236, 0.14678552746772766, 0.0658034011721611, -0.17395859956741333, -0.46175307035446167, -0.2302917242050171, 0.07747212052345276, 0.41825154423713684, -0.4118764102458954, 0.1831567883491516, 0.008643882349133492, 0.34130415320396423, -0.9775346517562866, -0.9890618324279785, 0.7789323329925537, -0.06978513300418854, -0.2386811226606369, -0.8714172840118408, -0.31753993034362793, 0.7612921595573425, 0.5152345299720764, 0.19829490780830383, 1.0840858221054077, 0.48811349272727966, -0.16098760068416595, 0.9170530438423157, 0.40318867564201355, -0.01482933759689331, -0.6437593102455139, -0.7153689861297607, -1.7017041444778442, -0.5765373110771179, -1.037920355796814, 0.15140216052532196, -0.0666361078619957, -0.5761937499046326, 0.27654772996902466, 0.1689634621143341, 0.5886754393577576, -0.25950148701667786, 0.6869745254516602, 0.221554696559906, 0.06457708775997162, -0.2949892282485962, -0.9662222266197205, -0.09925246238708496, -0.0957617312669754, 0.854256272315979, 0.05351516231894493, -0.3194100260734558, -0.5142161846160889, -0.8664295077323914, 0.023604419082403183, -0.507993221282959, -0.34742292761802673, 0.5216812491416931, -0.6957712173461914, 0.08237605541944504, 0.3905144929885864, -0.04951304569840431, -0.1549753099679947, -0.5557454228401184, -0.8144146800041199, 0.5070412755012512, 0.556504487991333, 0.5956170558929443, 0.3346434533596039, 0.30425405502319336, -0.3271441161632538, 0.5086917877197266, -0.01867707073688507, 0.008032893761992455, -0.8401325345039368, -0.15309777855873108, 0.8858168125152588, -0.569419801235199, 0.4316549599170685, -0.4326813817024231, -1.2389662265777588, -0.8037742376327515, -0.18992304801940918, -0.24941706657409668, -0.2406310737133026, -0.029345469549298286, 0.36812645196914673, -1.097881555557251, -0.23539108037948608, -0.7536531686782837, -1.0573844909667969, 0.5555464625358582, -0.5917864441871643, 0.42669713497161865, -0.2832173705101013, 0.5580642223358154, 0.023983947932720184, -0.37151432037353516, 0.35069888830184937, 0.5503652095794678, 0.42399540543556213, -0.6319678425788879, -0.7065067291259766, 0.30993714928627014, -0.49588742852211, 0.6758958697319031, -0.0722116231918335, -0.7746719121932983, -0.20279933512210846, -0.4055750370025635, -0.4930354952812195, 0.5329088568687439, 0.8765427470207214, 0.13033492863178253, 0.09263240545988083, 0.5841792821884155, -0.2953232228755951, 0.23583374917507172, 0.526687502861023, -0.12977351248264313, -0.1648079752922058, 0.5627241134643555, -0.12897302210330963, 0.9303655624389648, -0.39281710982322693, -1.1571847200393677, 0.4765040874481201, -0.5037788152694702, 0.9740592241287231, -0.3839010000228882, 0.9328951239585876, -0.3495599031448364, 0.3230239748954773, -0.07774270325899124, 0.2215905636548996, -0.28438740968704224, 1.4383045434951782, 0.1637255847454071, 1.379742980003357, -1.5050643682479858, 0.4489828646183014, 0.8605859875679016, 1.2655525207519531, -0.01699259504675865, -0.14776115119457245, 0.6380141973495483, -1.202438473701477, -0.26478368043899536, -0.11848220229148865, 0.2051566243171692, 0.38237568736076355, 0.6885820031166077, -0.15823954343795776, 0.04081745445728302, -0.7602750062942505, -0.5036459565162659, -0.2503436207771301, 0.09266947209835052, 0.8672698140144348, -0.5218632817268372, 1.3294786214828491, -0.37201225757598877, 0.03517354652285576, 0.5998056530952454, 0.6220269799232483, -0.4863937497138977, -0.41115495562553406, 0.5873346924781799, -0.12710702419281006, -0.7633438110351562, 0.023788826540112495, 0.5064462423324585, -0.47376781702041626, 0.14539702236652374, 0.469779908657074, -0.04219403117895126, -0.5686483979225159, -1.0627243518829346, -0.06147538870573044, 0.45776626467704773, 0.2335805594921112, -0.004908327478915453, -0.40138253569602966, 0.5946807265281677, -0.4266650378704071, -0.3447973430156708, 0.27117857336997986, -0.17039795219898224, 0.15648317337036133, 0.5441516041755676, -0.3100169897079468, -1.4040429592132568, -0.294467031955719, -0.07863537967205048, -0.5126897692680359, -0.16768334805965424, -0.1487615555524826, -0.1725606471300125, 0.465665340423584, -0.0942920595407486, 0.035388197749853134, -0.7715805172920227, -0.3421059846878052, -0.1124957948923111, -0.27612876892089844, 0.550851583480835, 0.7626358866691589, 0.5011321902275085, 1.0715092420578003, -0.12769372761249542, 0.03869546949863434, -0.6622859239578247, 0.08712439239025116, -0.4922146499156952, -0.7190949320793152, -0.002182123949751258, 0.15627504885196686, 0.15325678884983063, -0.11221756041049957, -0.38925740122795105, -0.525744616985321, -0.15792760252952576, 0.5860903859138489, 0.029703648760914803, -0.73354572057724, 1.1926308870315552, -0.7068206071853638, -0.016835421323776245, 1.1110427379608154, -0.2860492467880249, -0.2382550835609436, -0.05916885286569595, 0.3250662684440613, -0.9322547316551208, 0.2739298641681671, 0.4762052893638611, 0.5552130341529846, -0.5925044417381287, -0.4670829176902771, -0.009704709984362125, 0.6698550581932068, 0.47975265979766846, -0.8947448134422302, -0.10751182585954666, -0.9513962268829346, -0.631930410861969, -0.1938610076904297, -0.4850907325744629, -0.49429821968078613, 0.49108392000198364, 0.15644319355487823, -0.8765735030174255, -0.493040531873703, 0.11716322600841522, -0.5770758390426636, -0.11646252125501633, -0.6358070373535156, -0.005966376978904009, -0.8078240752220154, -0.10783658176660538, 0.8353379368782043, -0.1394256055355072, -0.7983106970787048, 0.3293367922306061, 0.9634391665458679, -0.7429237961769104, -0.790610134601593, 0.2836194634437561, 0.6363891959190369, -0.170109361410141, -0.3101288974285126, 0.3302847445011139, -0.882548987865448, -0.03571797534823418, -0.31441566348075867, -0.30386102199554443, 0.3451228439807892, -0.05981239303946495, -0.18518008291721344, 0.2870514988899231, -0.17129307985305786, -0.55052649974823, -0.43401065468788147, 0.08804856985807419, 0.23457419872283936, -0.4695885181427002, 0.05663307383656502, -1.2913274765014648, -0.5106386542320251, -1.5369008779525757, -0.10957950353622437, -1.2242767810821533, 0.22903993725776672, -0.7081153988838196, -0.34072884917259216, 0.14925232529640198, 0.356123149394989, 0.7462009787559509, 0.37677446007728577, -0.2972622513771057, -0.0847584679722786, 0.6291370987892151, 0.07636041939258575, -0.18854151666164398, -0.37394487857818604, -0.23856592178344727, -0.05150157958269119, 0.7321038842201233, 0.06257917732000351, 0.0598306804895401, -0.235151469707489, -0.19471463561058044, 0.22271031141281128, 0.7369803190231323, -0.47454899549484253, -0.16143172979354858, 0.18179821968078613, 0.3010079860687256, -0.0162188820540905, 0.1776539534330368, -1.7767913341522217, 0.30840644240379333, -0.5815815925598145, 0.13683170080184937, -0.4235208034515381, -0.6378739476203918, -0.06096270680427551, -0.3166399598121643, 1.309936761856079, -0.6865456104278564, 0.8738679885864258, 0.7461351752281189, 0.022522052749991417, -0.3523704707622528, 0.26435452699661255, -0.3259974718093872, -0.0033587815705686808, -0.9401800632476807, -0.5659838318824768, -0.08974636346101761, 0.15536187589168549, -0.28972744941711426, 0.7747188210487366, 0.29507604241371155, 0.07127101719379425, -0.7418613433837891, 0.8508551716804504, 0.21145428717136383, -0.6088535189628601, -0.6223374605178833, 0.09132827073335648, 0.05706562474370003, 0.19565698504447937, 0.40843454003334045, 0.5440402030944824, -0.886557936668396, 0.18020930886268616, -0.039109405130147934, -0.7408724427223206, -0.6340844035148621, -0.3431099057197571, 0.14973504841327667, 0.9611223340034485, -0.1535474807024002, -0.19415712356567383, 0.5174556970596313, 0.4139057695865631, -0.8643455505371094, 0.3539964556694031, -0.3649247884750366, 0.2429826855659485, 0.923862874507904, -0.026437539607286453, -0.5848818421363831, -0.08340859413146973, 0.12557990849018097, 0.46308138966560364, -0.7677204608917236, 0.2918582856655121, 0.4695524275302887, -1.241224765777588, 0.5683821439743042, 0.37117382884025574, -0.6698254942893982, -0.9177137613296509, -0.05911792814731598, -0.48776963353157043, 0.8701919317245483, -0.5078381299972534, -0.4783468246459961, -0.23926721513271332, -0.39148974418640137, 0.9535946249961853, -0.24436166882514954, -0.17409078776836395, 0.10335042327642441, -0.7610888481140137, 0.20574715733528137, -0.7589227557182312, 0.05113757774233818, 1.0032424926757812, -0.689924955368042, -0.05223345756530762, 0.33693212270736694, 0.5730580687522888, 0.5542790293693542, 0.5528992414474487, 0.642367959022522, -0.3125520944595337, 0.10377083718776703, -0.046907275915145874, 0.04454638063907623, 0.2612285614013672, 0.0873723104596138, -0.5575588345527649, 0.5948076248168945, -0.0644834116101265, -0.9562196731567383, -0.1825500875711441, 0.26794546842575073, 0.41667065024375916, 0.6943367123603821, -0.33206847310066223, 0.4873219430446625, 0.9310696125030518, 1.244612455368042, 0.06205727159976959, -0.44719552993774414, -0.8169621229171753, -0.2581760287284851, 0.021877404302358627, 0.31192299723625183, -0.8128839135169983, -0.712557315826416, 0.48932430148124695, -0.5866889953613281, -0.9195061922073364, -0.46464452147483826, 0.6122704744338989, -0.4968234598636627, -0.8329069018363953, -0.753400981426239, 0.5691347718238831, -0.2559557557106018, -0.01691472716629505, 0.27590498328208923, -0.8061909079551697, -0.1969282180070877, 0.9042564630508423, -0.9255064129829407, -0.5172470211982727, -0.06879565119743347, 0.6194831728935242, -0.0012279574293643236, 0.18900693953037262, -0.7491090297698975, -0.7955325841903687, -0.3895372450351715, 0.37399744987487793, 0.19875286519527435, -0.22955261170864105, 1.321334719657898, 0.006931130308657885, 0.668470561504364, 0.7639685273170471, 0.314515084028244, -0.5359424948692322, 0.14456455409526825, -0.18298344314098358, -0.038037002086639404, -0.41918933391571045, 0.2729966342449188, 0.96458500623703, -0.8739659190177917, -0.37092918157577515, -0.904424786567688, -0.6210088133811951, -0.14257724583148956, -0.2149076908826828, 0.0866847038269043, 0.46162891387939453, 0.11865442246198654, 0.5696009993553162, 0.5749108195304871, 0.4560388922691345, 0.15381552278995514, -0.4450535476207733, 0.2529326379299164, -0.4204453229904175, -0.4849992096424103, -0.6976587772369385, -0.27561527490615845, 0.2593514025211334, -0.8327403664588928, 0.24787361919879913, -0.5127713680267334, -0.0033141006715595722, 0.34630993008613586, -0.15590022504329681, 0.6535975933074951, 0.7623400688171387, 0.36560341715812683, 0.9686107635498047, -0.2204139083623886, -0.42694079875946045, -1.0135397911071777, -0.5582974553108215, -1.1622310876846313, -0.9010908007621765, 0.7099012136459351, -0.29812392592430115, -0.3536924421787262, -0.744754433631897, -0.5829574465751648, 1.0874639749526978, 0.15113700926303864, -0.0455545075237751, -0.06818956881761551, 0.5387506484985352, -0.23625962436199188, -0.08800071477890015, 0.3711187243461609, -0.03288321942090988, 0.18422892689704895, -0.12203273177146912, -0.12365596741437912, -0.5897194147109985, 0.1689315289258957, 0.6511465907096863, 0.4000515639781952, 0.3241266906261444, -0.5254937410354614, -0.036815859377384186, -0.3299417495727539, -0.9569758176803589, 0.8206655979156494, 0.4676111936569214, -0.41626423597335815, 0.4958113431930542, -0.37878647446632385, 0.3510746359825134, -0.6151790618896484, 0.5904754996299744, -0.13314120471477509, -0.8480389714241028, -0.9105159640312195, 0.014370109885931015, 0.46410712599754333, -0.3458589017391205, 0.33624255657196045, -0.6463430523872375, 0.551612138748169, -0.17772364616394043, 0.23941609263420105, 0.25280916690826416, 1.2205572128295898, 0.26118800044059753, -0.25567466020584106, -0.34634342789649963, 0.5732215642929077, 0.4010961055755615, 0.6708498001098633, -0.01598478853702545, 0.36431944370269775, 0.4072379767894745, 0.3728702962398529, -0.05896264687180519, -1.0233535766601562, 0.6555250883102417, 0.16425921022891998, -0.17476654052734375, 0.19819574058055878, 0.10196933895349503, 0.7500826120376587, -0.24831028282642365, -1.019991159439087, 0.6729152202606201, -0.1610976904630661, -0.6497964859008789, -0.46884557604789734, 0.812150776386261, 1.0313713550567627, 0.13798686861991882, 0.7319825291633606, 0.6500917673110962, 0.07417567819356918, -0.1581043154001236, 0.4924198091030121, 1.2663042545318604, -0.13833528757095337, -1.0195387601852417, -0.14306499063968658, 1.170745611190796, -0.08625231683254242, 0.2505425810813904, 0.40177038311958313, -0.19921022653579712, -0.35215821862220764, 0.46222299337387085, -0.36765986680984497, -0.1826469898223877, 0.2814013361930847, -0.19087421894073486, -0.19887883961200714, -0.14033524692058563, -0.10977508872747421, -0.9111710786819458, -0.6441019177436829, 0.610227108001709, -0.19184117019176483, 0.2327839583158493, -0.18844501674175262, 0.02641421929001808, 0.7857124209403992, -0.3596143126487732, 0.6776623725891113, -0.5417935252189636, 0.1048848032951355, 0.4890761077404022, 0.00976897869259119, 0.15900862216949463, 0.195498526096344, -0.004315327852964401, 0.2151818871498108, -0.011159947142004967, 0.44543394446372986, 0.24853385984897614, -0.31005269289016724, -0.3798082768917084, 0.352699875831604, -0.49466079473495483, -0.1423339694738388, -0.6151795983314514, 0.6428215503692627, -0.11688432842493057, 0.25925764441490173, -0.2505832314491272, -0.3110995888710022, -0.051434263586997986, 0.4768671989440918, -0.041964657604694366, -0.2931709289550781, -0.13821275532245636, -0.18991900980472565, -0.5321691036224365, 0.29860010743141174, 0.3996354639530182, -0.7204371690750122, -0.2665923833847046, -1.307891607284546, -0.6802245378494263, 0.2876991033554077, 0.10575848817825317, -0.29888853430747986, 0.00008954788791015744, 0.08360834419727325, 0.7085328698158264, 0.49927201867103577, -0.2785841226577759, 0.02805696614086628, 0.6693968176841736, 0.6220359206199646, -0.4092603027820587, 0.9152718782424927, -0.41433006525039673, 0.2075589895248413, 0.4429711103439331, -0.06313943862915039, 0.14570173621177673, 0.08946549147367477, -1.0469192266464233, -0.6386705040931702, -0.19061322510242462, -0.4129636287689209, -0.3976301848888397, 0.5022933483123779, 0.8462958335876465, 0.0887310579419136, -0.2826099693775177, -0.7820918560028076, -0.2887652814388275, -0.7535712122917175, 1.4202746152877808, -0.12346840649843216, 0.14727579057216644, 0.3514711260795593, 0.18174853920936584, 0.644138753414154, -1.2755284309387207, 3.899883270263672, 0.832094669342041, 0.5105353593826294, 0.07809822261333466, -0.15828514099121094, 0.06426004320383072, 1.0509233474731445, -0.07824860513210297, 0.28352177143096924, 0.20282022655010223, -1.0145726203918457, 0.7121319770812988, 0.06512496620416641, -0.4075678288936615, 0.4363155961036682, 0.834038496017456, -0.972431480884552, 0.0041617220267653465, 0.18987342715263367, -0.8081797361373901, -0.41998976469039917, 0.08245965838432312, -0.05547012388706207, 0.7444497346878052, 0.04652433842420578, -0.20133326947689056, 0.19944807887077332, -0.109583780169487, -0.32318881154060364, -0.5313528180122375, 0.2780072093009949, -0.5621455907821655, 0.3590805232524872, -0.8076541423797607, -0.37979671359062195, 0.32168328762054443, -0.09438955038785934, -0.4978336989879608, 0.09953783452510834, -0.14989326894283295, 0.32014399766921997, 0.17977476119995117, -0.48787787556648254, -0.16640713810920715, -0.1944611519575119, 0.11194601655006409, -0.5882970690727234, 0.12994766235351562, 0.2383996844291687, -0.29780858755111694, 0.764910101890564, -1.0434730052947998, 0.5475083589553833, -0.04743986576795578, -1.210637092590332, -0.7902582287788391, -0.355629026889801, -0.8071664571762085, 0.20658081769943237, 0.45656219124794006, 0.8210476040840149, 0.0020284170750528574, -0.01953059993684292, 0.12566332519054413, 0.3857734203338623, 0.48112723231315613, 0.32389745116233826, 0.07251205295324326, 0.5662674307823181, -0.4013490676879883, -0.4858531355857849, 0.7914212346076965, -0.27165454626083374, -0.6331726908683777, 0.2930668294429779, 0.5227940082550049, -0.6985399723052979, 0.3985099792480469, 0.1132761687040329, -0.3772262632846832, -0.46908050775527954, 0.24918226897716522, -0.025362370535731316, -0.27045372128486633, 0.5512173771858215, 0.8853302001953125, -0.396776020526886, -0.11348975449800491, -0.9332687258720398, 0.4117027521133423, 0.8663713932037354, -0.0992991179227829, 0.5323516130447388, 0.15656942129135132, 0.21609391272068024 ]
{"Title": "Mental Health in UK Biobank Revised \u2013 development, implementation and results from an online questionnaire completed by 157,366 participants", "Authors": "Davis Katrina A. S., Coleman Jonathan R. I., Adams Mark, Allen Naomi, Breen Gerome, Cullen Breda, Dickens Chris, Fox Elaine, Graham Nick, Holliday Jo, Howard Louise M, John Ann, Lee William, McCabe Rose, McIntosh Andrew, Pearsall Robert, Smith Daniel J., Sudlow Cathie, Ward Joey, Zammit Stan, Hotopf Matthew", "Abstract": "Abstract This paper corrects and updates a paper published in BJPsych Open 2018 \u201cMental Health in UK Biobank\u201d ( https://doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2018.12 ) that was voluntarily retracted following the finding of errors in the coding of the variable for alcohol use disorder. Notably, the percentage of participants reaching threshold for alcohol use disorder on the Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Tool increased from 7% to 21%. Background UK Biobank is a well-characterised cohort of over 500,000 participants that offers unique opportunities to investigate multiple diseases and risk factors. An online mental health questionnaire completed by UK Biobank participants expands the potential for research into mental disorders. Methods An expert working group designed the questionnaire, using established measures where possible, and consulting with a service user group regarding acceptability. Operational criteria were agreed for defining likely disorder and risk states, including lifetime depression, mania/hypomania, generalised anxiety disorder, unusual experiences and self-harm, and current post-traumatic stress and alcohol use disorders. Results 157,366 completed online questionnaires were available by August 2017. Comparison of self-reported diagnosed mental disorder with a contemporary study shows a similar prevalence, despite respondents being of higher average socioeconomic status. Lifetime depression was the most common finding in 24% of participants (37,434), with current alcohol use disorder criteria met by 21% (32,602), while other criteria were met by less than 8% of the participants. There was extensive comorbidity among the syndromes. Mental disorders were associated with a high neuroticism score, adverse life events and long-term illness; addiction and bipolar affective disorder in particular were associated with measures of deprivation. Conclusions The questionnaire represents a very large mental health survey in itself, and the results presented here show high face validity, although caution is needed due to selection bias. Built into UK Biobank, these data intersect with other health data to offer unparalleled potential for crosscutting biomedical research involving mental health.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19001214"}
10.1101/19008615
[ -0.17105501890182495, 0.22184859216213226, -0.06571061164140701, 0.4688038229942322, -0.7541570067405701, -0.0743989646434784, -0.2565089166164398, -0.05663856863975525, 0.4476035237312317, 0.576854944229126, -0.39530831575393677, -0.6438122391700745, 0.060057852417230606, -0.4390491843223572, 0.08282124251127243, 0.5769510269165039, -0.7793396711349487, 0.4459226727485657, 0.44179660081863403, -0.5088369846343994, 0.9424412846565247, 0.15588048100471497, -0.9443636536598206, 0.5085289478302002, -0.857428252696991, 0.5522037744522095, 0.29769134521484375, 0.14593565464019775, 1.268410325050354, 0.06101255118846893, -0.027672581374645233, -0.4368157386779785, 0.2728802561759949, -1.1796973943710327, -0.2718518078327179, -0.3499411344528198, 0.8303495049476624, 0.12577569484710693, -0.36931851506233215, -0.13639502227306366, 0.10282900184392929, 0.1919451206922531, 0.6830554008483887, -0.10876955091953278, -0.8867032527923584, -0.22292524576187134, -0.7321025729179382, 0.0018996989820152521, 0.3298948109149933, -0.15929332375526428, -0.42477431893348694, -0.21140821278095245, 0.2801186442375183, -0.08069349080324173, 0.09930408746004105, 0.11880919337272644, -0.049495577812194824, 0.4129858613014221, 0.00590436439961195, 0.036677584052085876, -0.02181852050125599, -0.44075807929039, 0.4292939305305481, -1.448091745376587, 0.7190235257148743, 1.00469172000885, -0.09411643445491791, -0.5478629469871521, -0.7017289996147156, -0.26725101470947266, -1.1213157176971436, -0.17136164009571075, -0.09376919269561768, -0.5438119769096375, -0.207215815782547, -0.08789664506912231, 0.5431017279624939, -0.3454246520996094, 0.2279568761587143, -0.7928779721260071, 0.11755108833312988, -0.020673347637057304, -0.18662811815738678, 0.7742985486984253, -0.3728691339492798, -0.5446196794509888, -0.24368412792682648, 0.14009647071361542, 0.45899245142936707, 0.024495495483279228, 0.22200749814510345, 0.4404163360595703, 0.11553556472063065, 0.008562665432691574, -0.30742397904396057, 0.5579794049263, -0.7986181974411011, 0.2927040457725525, -0.0892707034945488, -0.11370673030614853, 0.5268866419792175, 0.7524921298027039, 0.14213553071022034, 1.2231334447860718, -1.0341262817382812, 0.23897726833820343, 0.6505741477012634, 0.050328634679317474, -0.6402729749679565, -0.6156001091003418, 0.09624838083982468, -0.07742485404014587, -0.4264898896217346, 0.5523303151130676, 0.40424519777297974, 0.4831216633319855, -0.7172802686691284, 0.6869577169418335, -0.031830620020627975, -0.40252023935317993, -0.16625018417835236, -0.5926451086997986, 0.9155147671699524, -0.8449475765228271, 0.013277704827487469, -0.35327255725860596, -0.35494014620780945, 0.8114461302757263, -0.6737797260284424, -0.2503742575645447, 0.08468064665794373, -0.7496258616447449, 0.01124652847647667, 0.5395866632461548, -0.16054299473762512, -0.26930156350135803, 0.14463388919830322, 0.9137212038040161, -0.4530119001865387, -0.1517793834209442, -0.3218032419681549, -0.18012434244155884, -0.6569446921348572, 1.0640627145767212, 0.1062823012471199, 1.5832821130752563, -0.7005924582481384, -1.3447318077087402, -0.12921923398971558, 0.40597397089004517, -0.2708335518836975, 0.21986687183380127, 0.043027959764003754, 0.006390751805156469, -0.16011232137680054, 0.15183614194393158, -0.37481024861335754, 0.4990319609642029, -0.30199694633483887, -0.09169591218233109, -0.48378440737724304, 0.08029432594776154, -0.12794069945812225, 0.4162939190864563, -0.7376715540885925, 0.8511700630187988, -0.21422730386257172, 0.10583235323429108, 0.03136524558067322, -0.5433995723724365, 0.22614607214927673, 0.5753012895584106, -0.7929646372795105, -0.25085943937301636, -0.3431906998157501, 0.595745861530304, 1.3896204233169556, 0.20026268064975739, 0.39433878660202026, 0.24883005023002625, -0.16480326652526855, -0.9989960193634033, 0.1457013338804245, 0.6804073452949524, -0.3265092074871063, 0.3532133400440216, -0.39703884720802307, -0.32556864619255066, -0.3703456223011017, 0.09347669780254364, -0.42840078473091125, 0.7302587628364563, -0.9361180663108826, 0.567156970500946, -1.01502525806427, 0.5214521884918213, -0.6594286561012268, 0.12420064955949783, 0.3970101475715637, -0.03285151347517967, -0.3050587475299835, 0.2880135178565979, -0.8947776556015015, -0.17170186340808868, 0.26944825053215027, 0.6618782877922058, -0.22294750809669495, 0.20203310251235962, -0.9197666645050049, -0.06799155473709106, 0.22456124424934387, -0.011078338138759136, -0.09219105541706085, 0.6422803997993469, 0.5374624729156494, -0.9046736359596252, -0.08753807842731476, -0.06794508546590805, -0.508764386177063, 0.1019885241985321, 0.253043532371521, -0.8073254823684692, 0.8868343830108643, -0.21358764171600342, 0.30348968505859375, 0.2178802788257599, 0.4892357587814331, -0.4883187711238861, 0.026254866272211075, -0.8500638008117676, 0.026084616780281067, 1.1635408401489258, -0.22941432893276215, 1.0148320198059082, 0.6478706002235413, 0.0833585113286972, 0.6756640076637268, -0.1411561220884323, 0.5247016549110413, 0.3385867476463318, 0.6602696180343628, 0.3979387581348419, 0.649429976940155, 0.5202159285545349, -0.5118226408958435, -0.12477049231529236, 0.08926603198051453, -0.22960937023162842, -0.5605866312980652, 0.6446511745452881, -1.0100610256195068, 0.6463944315910339, 0.1464139223098755, 0.3205529451370239, -0.4327548146247864, -0.7585580348968506, -0.15043386816978455, -0.07217439264059067, 0.272193968296051, -0.6212042570114136, 0.18437333405017853, 0.1007995679974556, -0.40940630435943604, 0.1476561576128006, 0.9817324280738831, 1.5580147504806519, 0.3364385664463043, 0.1784186065196991, 0.24613913893699646, -0.12823769450187683, -0.9545084238052368, -0.9137847423553467, -1.3670783042907715, -0.6599050760269165, -0.8109992146492004, -0.20684729516506195, 0.3489009141921997, -0.2992304265499115, 0.22571656107902527, 0.4671359062194824, 0.5050622224807739, -0.37489214539527893, 0.27957993745803833, 0.4392937421798706, 0.9346567392349243, 0.13264496624469757, -0.8619877099990845, 0.7142629027366638, -0.4686964452266693, 0.3562833368778229, -0.06278039515018463, -0.45897799730300903, -0.7983894348144531, -1.018502116203308, 0.19868744909763336, -0.4097926914691925, 0.18314535915851593, 0.26319319009780884, -0.3860901892185211, -0.22215139865875244, -0.12033013254404068, 0.18890541791915894, 0.36062073707580566, -0.5284877419471741, -0.503324568271637, 0.5947183966636658, 0.6802064776420593, -0.10340481251478195, 0.8034303784370422, 0.2533666491508484, -0.6482292413711548, 0.874875545501709, 0.08249696344137192, -0.01631173864006996, -0.7514297366142273, 0.8100380301475525, 0.149449422955513, -0.42255890369415283, -0.2256159782409668, -1.0384373664855957, -1.4432603120803833, -0.4573829174041748, -0.6070244908332825, -0.5454988479614258, 0.027237821370363235, 0.12756706774234772, 0.021665986627340317, -1.3397563695907593, 0.4614053964614868, 0.19258178770542145, -0.49957218766212463, -0.03519571200013161, 0.45152533054351807, 0.44869452714920044, -0.14596284925937653, -0.15512821078300476, -0.5492428541183472, 0.28873002529144287, 0.35234948992729187, 0.6738770604133606, 0.33783766627311707, -0.2453026920557022, -0.6519836783409119, 0.010366969741880894, 0.5707495212554932, 0.3522452712059021, 0.7381998896598816, -0.3580717146396637, -0.14316771924495697, -0.43916603922843933, 0.25279295444488525, 0.47217705845832825, 0.015275423415005207, 0.22648654878139496, 0.8024880290031433, -0.004497972782701254, -0.026284486055374146, -0.5952804684638977, 0.21563054621219635, -0.4951067268848419, -0.42345237731933594, 0.25905483961105347, -0.008857622742652893, 0.3327435553073883, -0.12697763741016388, -0.5443159937858582, 0.5517634749412537, -0.473296582698822, 0.5293303728103638, -1.196713924407959, 0.8391067385673523, 0.4590480327606201, -0.4899027943611145, 0.24458397924900055, -0.07283563166856766, -0.7407564520835876, 0.5671144127845764, 0.2444673627614975, 1.3333898782730103, -1.2762906551361084, 0.02067130245268345, 0.7545321583747864, 1.502819299697876, 0.49821609258651733, 0.4079192280769348, 0.4677143394947052, -0.41327303647994995, 0.6711522936820984, 0.14446166157722473, 0.25038906931877136, 0.46763134002685547, 0.3261241614818573, -0.833721399307251, 0.2560851573944092, -1.2942017316818237, -0.09922321885824203, 0.4158448278903961, 0.44385313987731934, -0.2468041628599167, -0.533358633518219, 0.993259072303772, -0.24488939344882965, 0.5393248796463013, 0.09091103821992874, 0.5169932842254639, -0.18900246918201447, -0.6272769570350647, 0.17130738496780396, -0.20792561769485474, -0.5659669637680054, -0.31858453154563904, -0.2305697798728943, -0.4531554579734802, -0.07697702944278717, 0.39800724387168884, 0.0856151133775711, -0.6737843155860901, 0.0027833878993988037, -0.5348312258720398, 0.044406916946172714, 0.05133168399333954, 1.0412158966064453, -0.4341897964477539, -0.09691879153251648, 0.30382147431373596, -0.8740507960319519, 0.10743813961744308, -0.7651078104972839, 0.9777728915214539, 0.7314938306808472, -0.5280508399009705, -0.8675565719604492, -0.0992719903588295, 0.4083927571773529, -0.5022986531257629, 0.2873431444168091, -0.04506627470254898, -0.41732221841812134, 0.7191819548606873, -0.1517164558172226, -0.17773742973804474, -0.376492440700531, 0.0973237156867981, -0.19177637994289398, 0.2086590975522995, 0.21481047570705414, 0.9514759182929993, 0.09807544201612473, 0.7570214867591858, 0.30146968364715576, 0.26541754603385925, -0.6620979905128479, 0.552199125289917, -0.7390758395195007, -0.5079635977745056, 0.07194414734840393, -0.07162684947252274, -0.13260190188884735, 0.702677845954895, 0.24192965030670166, -0.37480586767196655, -0.2620221674442291, 0.40743985772132874, -0.37217092514038086, -0.4780219495296478, 1.3855069875717163, -0.27425962686538696, 0.7056671977043152, 0.9529973864555359, 0.15307193994522095, -0.3245059549808502, -0.147627592086792, 0.06633751839399338, -0.5293442606925964, 0.39225825667381287, 0.11093563586473465, 0.16187751293182373, 0.007791469804942608, -0.011520029045641422, -0.30008864402770996, 0.015387744642794132, -0.0852869302034378, -0.1068139523267746, 0.2626301348209381, -0.3613682687282562, -0.5050582885742188, -0.6929293870925903, -0.31718364357948303, -0.7215700149536133, -0.4556652903556824, 0.15158019959926605, -0.7504898309707642, -0.26083606481552124, 0.10575170814990997, -0.3854943811893463, -0.7811534404754639, -0.522433340549469, 0.3953019678592682, -0.44633936882019043, 0.3445296585559845, 0.8619616031646729, -0.11816153675317764, -0.8104208111763, 0.3742211163043976, -0.03121773712337017, -0.2971195876598358, -0.5341957807540894, -0.6811941266059875, -0.12555110454559326, -0.505664587020874, 0.23452067375183105, -0.33833566308021545, -0.20798450708389282, -0.056545715779066086, -0.2023402601480484, -0.394758015871048, 0.44437161087989807, -0.051361292600631714, -0.42169374227523804, 0.994414210319519, 0.1471734195947647, -1.1059588193893433, -0.560872495174408, 0.00709082605317235, -0.06495478004217148, -0.4458080232143402, -0.01878216490149498, -1.185362696647644, 0.07157738506793976, -0.6419171094894409, 0.6617940664291382, -0.7968436479568481, 0.2427695244550705, -0.6456271409988403, -0.28101763129234314, 0.25236600637435913, 0.5232288241386414, 0.5994367599487305, 0.1531856656074524, -0.18480874598026276, -0.4190101623535156, -0.12497993558645248, -0.1077738106250763, -0.6220054030418396, -0.23509807884693146, 0.03165416792035103, 0.8261772990226746, 0.8987621068954468, -0.2549714744091034, -0.8274427056312561, 0.2694060206413269, 0.36332300305366516, 0.649488091468811, 0.6378579139709473, 0.015522944740951061, -0.5024120807647705, -0.11386348307132721, 0.2653219401836395, 0.16694962978363037, 0.34113743901252747, -0.6682910919189453, -0.7496174573898315, -1.0092179775238037, 0.04137520492076874, -0.29288822412490845, -0.1241876557469368, -0.10820014029741287, -0.39546528458595276, 0.8014786839485168, -0.4947180151939392, 0.12166740745306015, -0.04149065539240837, -0.007629359140992165, -0.08499061316251755, 0.5958357453346252, -0.8653055429458618, -0.6201701760292053, -1.113891839981079, -0.9569288492202759, 1.0935397148132324, -0.48404839634895325, -0.1942700445652008, 0.5405614376068115, 0.3316502869129181, -0.18617293238639832, -0.684243381023407, 0.6500992178916931, 0.21063391864299774, -0.22598250210285187, -0.8534755110740662, 0.1845056712627411, -0.08279653638601303, -0.2376732975244522, -0.3968505263328552, -0.03906869888305664, -0.6882199048995972, 0.0692886933684349, -0.35416731238365173, -0.3611076772212982, -1.162627100944519, -0.5527836084365845, 0.21540118753910065, 0.6565700769424438, 0.09252525866031647, 0.04041018709540367, -0.02404753677546978, -0.2944910526275635, -0.3910585641860962, 0.429042249917984, -0.587675154209137, 0.13222530484199524, 1.0901485681533813, -0.7779290080070496, 0.22743716835975647, 0.3154849112033844, -0.4164918065071106, -0.6062901020050049, -0.19068925082683563, 0.44488298892974854, 0.2737766206264496, -0.6872612237930298, 0.6373546719551086, 0.19673310220241547, -0.3706735670566559, -0.486278772354126, 0.8562564849853516, -0.017867062240839005, -0.3456012010574341, -0.42612025141716003, -0.4708711802959442, 0.2031848430633545, -0.6684437394142151, -0.05170595273375511, 0.3991987109184265, 0.16588780283927917, -0.16157718002796173, -0.3423090875148773, 0.11525589972734451, -0.5735918283462524, 0.6417211890220642, 0.7397037148475647, -0.3729410469532013, 0.7706003189086914, 0.20998643338680267, 0.6904143691062927, 0.15322738885879517, -0.1504456251859665, -0.06467264890670776, -0.4572853147983551, -0.5041561126708984, 0.4057545065879822, 0.831251859664917, -0.3228050172328949, 0.06879252195358276, -0.016491781920194626, -0.006926912814378738, 0.5679841041564941, -0.3949601650238037, -0.2522442638874054, 0.16779561340808868, 1.7178071737289429, 0.36778154969215393, 0.005280282348394394, 0.40553122758865356, 1.4167261123657227, 0.47400540113449097, 0.00564222875982523, -0.4152963161468506, -1.24337637424469, -1.2423676252365112, -0.041752155870199203, 0.41528311371803284, -1.347313404083252, -0.019966263324022293, 0.4897182583808899, -0.11475948989391327, -0.6464008092880249, -0.8071504235267639, 0.5802755355834961, -0.1529427319765091, -0.18979491293430328, -0.4603872299194336, 0.03757115826010704, -0.7780904769897461, -0.2845841646194458, 0.022746389731764793, -0.6572105288505554, 0.320489764213562, 1.1165050268173218, -0.5786709785461426, 0.0819317176938057, 0.09956247359514236, 0.5581005215644836, -0.28884074091911316, 0.7554470300674438, -1.3815876245498657, -0.3984740376472473, -0.0701495110988617, 0.7102795243263245, -0.28301581740379333, 0.21412312984466553, 1.006813406944275, -0.23671171069145203, 0.8882973790168762, 0.5674368739128113, -0.11088862270116806, -1.325164794921875, 0.2310185730457306, 0.07831652462482452, -0.7856477499008179, -0.4726257920265198, -0.504248857498169, 0.8698868751525879, -0.675274133682251, -1.1780056953430176, -0.8166831731796265, 0.0932488664984703, -0.043675266206264496, 0.7557530999183655, -0.9007595777511597, 1.2374017238616943, 0.2725889980792999, 0.30008259415626526, -0.07258355617523193, 0.5946199297904968, 0.269716739654541, 0.20886383950710297, 0.589413046836853, -0.4745372533798218, 0.05552876740694046, -0.6076785922050476, 0.5268733501434326, 0.4571658670902252, -0.7883588671684265, 0.12874574959278107, -0.6705151200294495, 0.3126823604106903, 0.0028006418142467737, 0.12780603766441345, 0.5339670181274414, 0.4740833640098572, 0.3402358293533325, -0.5376781225204468, -0.1420465111732483, -0.26427987217903137, -0.5900696516036987, -1.2625280618667603, -1.0123592615127563, -0.9859740138053894, 0.854285478591919, -0.26514264941215515, 0.47663968801498413, 0.30550524592399597, -0.7805278897285461, 0.2691243588924408, 0.42163965106010437, 0.8862418532371521, 0.27845296263694763, 0.29987001419067383, 0.049783725291490555, -0.1815057098865509, 0.05138080194592476, 0.6669973134994507, 0.38177573680877686, -0.2813863754272461, -0.5585311055183411, -0.27521950006484985, 0.5373682975769043, 0.30215927958488464, 0.23111693561077118, -0.13009019196033478, -0.38541269302368164, 0.5467932820320129, 0.18743038177490234, -0.34512859582901, -0.2747005224227905, 0.13746140897274017, -0.6536995768547058, 0.33788859844207764, -0.06609804928302765, -0.38644862174987793, -0.6765625476837158, 0.0952116921544075, 0.3492642045021057, -0.24219699203968048, -0.11224426329135895, -0.28883102536201477, 0.9436156153678894, -0.0889093279838562, 0.4722619950771332, 0.1815861463546753, 0.37760886549949646, -0.7094928622245789, 0.019681842997670174, 0.5355992913246155, 0.21033766865730286, 0.8633074164390564, 0.015032543800771236, -0.3935360312461853, 1.0508363246917725, 1.147436261177063, 0.6426828503608704, 0.5937530398368835, 0.5000696182250977, -0.2011723518371582, -0.2591918408870697, 0.008097713813185692, -0.20788750052452087, 0.5213563442230225, 0.621186375617981, 0.1428859382867813, 0.205506831407547, 0.6894240379333496, -0.3614498972892761, -0.33288103342056274, 0.09372057765722275, -0.30124515295028687, -0.48872140049934387, -1.0210638046264648, 0.30324605107307434, 0.9105727672576904, 0.6447657942771912, 0.4440273642539978, 0.4814510643482208, 0.13634838163852692, 0.7878915667533875, 0.11587397754192352, 0.44113588333129883, 0.7580588459968567, -0.5982421636581421, -0.42916324734687805, -0.13423487544059753, -0.20922163128852844, 0.16118097305297852, 0.4841667413711548, 0.5771894454956055, -0.24444924294948578, -0.23236173391342163, 1.2017080783843994, -0.2502587139606476, -0.5599622130393982, 0.19841130077838898, -0.27716970443725586, 0.10734108090400696, -0.36794236302375793, 0.43350932002067566, -1.2542493343353271, 0.010367080569267273, 0.4850391447544098, -0.6738224029541016, 0.8164628744125366, 0.16473032534122467, -0.23268888890743256, 0.7321990132331848, 0.6556838750839233, 0.18098142743110657, -0.5160433053970337, 0.7213575839996338, 1.1078360080718994, 0.7807783484458923, -0.04375956580042839, -0.14023883640766144, -0.29155972599983215, -0.2530704140663147, -0.37491998076438904, 1.1868934631347656, 0.6363669633865356, -0.3467057943344116, -0.2656295895576477, 0.14135108888149261, -0.47436705231666565, -0.2202182561159134, -0.17237430810928345, 0.04767131432890892, 0.7871825695037842, 0.09112469106912613, 0.22481942176818848, 1.0736550092697144, 0.1392604410648346, 0.22272655367851257, -0.07161833345890045, -0.35192230343818665, -0.5034811496734619, 0.4287296533584595, -0.5175232887268066, 0.5414523482322693, 0.06399544328451157, -0.2536659836769104, 0.128145232796669, -0.9998081922531128, -0.2767675817012787, -0.6081383228302002, -0.38304686546325684, -0.6516169309616089, 0.16370239853858948, 0.504449725151062, 0.2850746810436249, 0.07958163321018219, -0.09494490176439285, 0.4850228428840637, 0.2794838845729828, 0.5507214665412903, -0.03429911658167839, 0.7862163186073303, 0.22339104115962982, 0.6252272725105286, 0.31609469652175903, 0.7853878140449524, 0.06758254021406174, -0.3791505992412567, -0.48415738344192505, -0.5990810990333557, -0.16035647690296173, 0.17902188003063202, -0.9726558923721313, 0.7108339667320251, 0.30440568923950195, 0.11853794008493423, -0.4068637490272522, -0.48693203926086426, -0.010543635115027428, -0.45411035418510437, 1.0881681442260742, 0.3145427703857422, 0.4946911036968231, 0.2822377681732178, -0.11223743110895157, 0.3394373059272766, -0.7401061058044434, 3.947965145111084, 2.0205938816070557, 0.30499380826950073, -0.20990553498268127, 0.3859224021434784, 0.4216260313987732, 0.6727389693260193, -0.49499034881591797, -0.16141335666179657, 0.48781198263168335, -0.256992906332016, 0.320341020822525, 0.0712040513753891, -0.27746447920799255, 0.46018490195274353, 0.7465041279792786, -0.7630665898323059, 0.3657793700695038, -0.24581632018089294, -0.9880953431129456, -0.2568841278553009, 0.6302527785301208, -0.17718635499477386, -0.6182443499565125, 0.4333421289920807, -0.26324883103370667, 0.06952247768640518, 0.505298376083374, 0.07306298613548279, 0.26257050037384033, -0.3703015446662903, -0.20471058785915375, 0.19145996868610382, 0.032153692096471786, -0.24564477801322937, 0.7277406454086304, -0.16815395653247833, -0.4535365402698517, -0.15129654109477997, 0.18207508325576782, -0.2661471962928772, -0.43940040469169617, -0.4821151793003082, 0.09330432116985321, -0.6098620295524597, -0.1964930295944214, -0.1681324541568756, 0.09731846302747726, 0.6093968749046326, -0.8384044766426086, 0.8695683479309082, -1.2974003553390503, 0.1848684847354889, -0.17268580198287964, -0.34296444058418274, -0.9217762351036072, -0.4905538558959961, -0.7572838664054871, 0.5789204835891724, 0.10908551514148712, 1.2394965887069702, 0.5722047686576843, -0.2729160487651825, -0.5576182007789612, 0.5351209044456482, 0.43086278438568115, 1.104144811630249, 0.05937489494681358, -0.04161101207137108, -0.5651402473449707, -0.23144322633743286, 0.13841815292835236, -0.6646756529808044, -0.16605406999588013, 0.20968180894851685, 0.645920991897583, -0.6399838328361511, 0.25982117652893066, -0.7631633281707764, -0.8223421573638916, -0.22505326569080353, 0.004642845597118139, -0.0219265129417181, -0.23294557631015778, 0.31634750962257385, 0.6905298829078674, -0.15955036878585815, 0.5002153515815735, -1.310806155204773, 0.424641489982605, 0.11954197287559509, -0.38587063550949097, -0.25082311034202576, -0.2471628338098526, -0.07603800296783447 ]
{"Title": "A Multiomics Approach to Heterogeneity in Alzheimer\u2019s Disease: Focused Review and Roadmap", "Authors": "Badhwar AmanPreet, McFall G. Peggy, Sapkota Shraddha, Black Sandra E., Chertkow Howard, Duchesne Simon, Masellis Mario, Li Liang, Dixon Roger A., Bellec Pierre", "Abstract": "Abstract Etiological and clinical heterogeneity is increasingly recognized as a common characteristic of Alzheimer\u2019s disease and related dementias. This heterogeneity complicates diagnosis, treatment, and the design and testing of new drugs. An important line of research is discovery of multimodal biomarkers that will facilitate the targeting of subpopulations with homogeneous pathophysiological signatures. High-throughput \u2018omics\u2019 are unbiased data driven techniques that probe the complex etiology of Alzheimer\u2019s disease from multiple levels (e.g. network, cellular, and molecular) and thereby account for pathophysiological heterogeneity in clinical populations. This review focuses on data reduction analyses that identify complementary disease-relevant perturbations for three omics techniques: neuroimaging-based subtypes, metabolomics-derived metabolite panels, and genomics-related polygenic risk scores. Neuroimaging can track accrued neurodegeneration and other sources of network impairments, metabolomics provides a global small-molecule snapshot that is sensitive to ongoing pathological processes, and genomics characterizes relatively invariant genetic risk factors representing key pathways associated with Alzheimer\u2019s disease. Following this focused review, we present a roadmap for assembling these multiomics measurements into a diagnostic tool highly predictive of individual clinical trajectories, to further the goal of personalized medicine in Alzheimer\u2019s disease.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008615"}