id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14688v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14688v3 | Taiyi-Diffusion-XL: Advancing Bilingual Text-to-Image Generation with Large Vision-Language Model Support | 2024-01-26T07:17:50 | 2024-06-18T03:17:18 | Xiaojun Wu, Dixiang Zhang, Ruyi Gan, Junyu Lu, Ziwei Wu, Renliang Sun, Jiaxing Zhang, Pingjian Zhang, Yan Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in text-to-image models have significantly enhanced image
generation capabilities, yet a notable gap of open-source models persists in
bilingual or Chinese language support. To address this need, we present
Taiyi-Diffusion-XL, a new Chinese and English bilingual text-to-image model
which is developed by extending the capabilities of CLIP and
Stable-Diffusion-XL through a process of bilingual continuous pre-training.
This approach includes the efficient expansion of vocabulary by integrating the
most frequently used Chinese characters into CLIP's tokenizer and embedding
layers, coupled with an absolute position encoding expansion. Additionally, we
enrich text prompts by large vision-language model, leading to better images
captions and possess higher visual quality. These enhancements are subsequently
applied to downstream text-to-image models. Our empirical results indicate that
the developed CLIP model excels in bilingual image-text retrieval.Furthermore,
the bilingual image generation capabilities of Taiyi-Diffusion-XL surpass
previous models. This research leads to the development and open-sourcing of
the Taiyi-Diffusion-XL model, representing a notable advancement in the field
of image generation, particularly for Chinese language applications. This
contribution is a step forward in addressing the need for more diverse language
support in multimodal research. The model and demonstration are made publicly
available at
\href{https://huggingface.co/IDEA-CCNL/Taiyi-Stable-Diffusion-XL-3.5B/},
fostering further research and collaboration in this domain. | [
-0.3395186960697174,
-0.7453683018684387,
0.5746551752090454,
0.7070854902267456,
-0.4773978590965271,
-0.1858835220336914,
-0.19451850652694702,
-0.595747172832489,
0.31604334712028503,
0.5412622094154358,
-0.18489602208137512,
-0.32906684279441833,
-0.7866992950439453,
0.183004230260849,
-0.518507719039917,
0.5007361173629761,
-0.287081778049469,
0.37578675150871277,
0.2786882817745209,
-0.19247201085090637,
-0.5252282619476318,
-0.17354457080364227,
-0.9524410367012024,
0.007029152475297451,
0.5071907043457031,
0.1823517233133316,
0.720302402973175,
0.7314854860305786,
0.03381767496466637,
0.24040673673152924,
0.04898711293935776,
0.18105386197566986,
-0.11997464299201965,
-0.15853123366832733,
0.16461949050426483,
-0.36907634139060974,
-0.6797099113464355,
-0.1358526349067688,
1.1111865043640137,
0.4213288426399231,
0.012469781562685966,
-0.3470928370952606,
-0.007776976563036442,
0.4346623122692108,
-0.5922690629959106,
-0.047169432044029236,
-0.44194352626800537,
0.2995178997516632,
-0.26891210675239563,
0.11510834097862244,
-0.5119099617004395,
-0.1720161885023117,
0.05034021660685539,
-0.6265320777893066,
-0.14883531630039215,
-0.10271087288856506,
0.8350235819816589,
-0.37911686301231384,
-0.6213424801826477,
0.007095040753483772,
-0.34522125124931335,
0.8070836067199707,
-0.43999215960502625,
0.5668834447860718,
0.10399680584669113,
0.0627833679318428,
0.42172572016716003,
-0.9547370076179504,
-0.6410464644432068,
-0.23257094621658325,
0.22201460599899292,
0.3947277069091797,
-0.11422854661941528,
-0.29958972334861755,
-0.034396979957818985,
0.09761231392621994,
-0.320957750082016,
0.15281493961811066,
-0.3618322014808655,
-0.08918247371912003,
0.5425925850868225,
0.010875842534005642,
0.745380163192749,
-0.0047644865699112415,
-0.5922715663909912,
0.04342757910490036,
-0.6971656084060669,
-0.13293921947479248,
0.2449381947517395,
-0.0639522597193718,
-0.3130621016025543,
0.316256046295166,
0.2666781544685364,
0.5497925877571106,
0.1133897453546524,
0.1253427416086197,
0.2604391276836395,
-0.5333946943283081,
-0.14234770834445953,
0.04897153750061989,
1.2582460641860962,
0.4984686076641083,
-0.1500617116689682,
0.05704449862241745,
-0.29348695278167725,
-0.5034801959991455,
-0.2339594066143036,
-1.1263376474380493,
-0.039541296660900116,
-0.055920206010341644,
-0.5789844393730164,
-0.25833988189697266,
0.10788179188966751,
-0.744082510471344,
-0.008009154349565506,
0.17571665346622467,
0.47728896141052246,
-0.5174047946929932,
-0.6811348795890808,
0.12471911311149597,
-0.3709748685359955,
0.002972979564219713,
0.4321567714214325,
-0.63737553358078,
0.010312492027878761,
0.3618963658809662,
1.2420552968978882,
-0.5516642928123474,
-0.42618444561958313,
-0.6664621829986572,
0.28483736515045166,
-0.6021109819412231,
0.7003405690193176,
-0.4162655770778656,
-0.462837815284729,
0.10531651973724365,
0.39545738697052,
0.13274408876895905,
-0.4631635546684265,
0.530413031578064,
-0.5347656607627869,
0.2916615903377533,
-0.18219727277755737,
-0.14394427835941315,
-0.20284047722816467,
0.05011396482586861,
-1.0682134628295898,
0.8121048212051392,
0.08329781144857407,
-0.7955641150474548,
0.1880161166191101,
-0.7885820865631104,
-0.36899855732917786,
0.3526135981082916,
0.04056103527545929,
-0.5708234906196594,
-0.22416788339614868,
0.16739094257354736,
0.3426869809627533,
-0.3988467752933502,
0.3414313495159149,
-0.41874000430107117,
-0.1729939877986908,
0.1317891925573349,
-0.45486801862716675,
1.1796170473098755,
0.2499799281358719,
-0.29075995087623596,
-0.02645411342382431,
-0.3611032962799072,
-0.10361579060554504,
0.25481030344963074,
-0.14204618334770203,
-0.5849508047103882,
-0.11886697262525558,
0.5653725266456604,
0.16805681586265564,
0.4069012403488159,
-0.5620647668838501,
-0.14698053896427155,
-0.044568292796611786,
0.49816107749938965,
0.5717977285385132,
-0.14718583226203918,
0.6088006496429443,
-0.028929684311151505,
0.5380919575691223,
0.4721386730670929,
0.3110789954662323,
-0.9267972707748413,
-0.7748281955718994,
-0.5028048157691956,
-0.3158436715602875,
0.36547818779945374,
0.6659712195396423,
-0.9504038691520691,
0.24850159883499146,
-0.08700700104236603,
-0.3278053402900696,
-0.36233070492744446,
0.10809341818094254,
0.19978320598602295,
0.5482087731361389,
0.24925149977207184,
-0.6256380081176758,
-0.35914644598960876,
-0.7546452283859253,
0.3125542402267456,
0.088031105697155,
-0.014319476671516895,
0.26019030809402466,
0.4432899057865143,
-0.43535929918289185,
0.48496246337890625,
-0.3414052128791809,
-0.16095224022865295,
-0.42163315415382385,
0.3086671233177185,
-0.13667969405651093,
0.4713994264602661,
0.9868789911270142,
-1.134413242340088,
-0.9787787199020386,
0.2858220934867859,
-0.5189170837402344,
-0.18046659231185913,
0.014431753195822239,
-0.4710552990436554,
0.3374011814594269,
0.3534452021121979,
-0.35397735238075256,
0.24115897715091705,
0.9011160731315613,
-0.24684903025627136,
0.7716557383537292,
-0.3337230384349823,
0.31030353903770447,
-1.475184440612793,
0.08294811099767685,
0.320300817489624,
-0.5430701375007629,
-0.5941319465637207,
0.30977290868759155,
0.5245602130889893,
-0.1579941362142563,
-0.6593770384788513,
0.49513253569602966,
-0.43374696373939514,
0.36644446849823,
-0.44866761565208435,
0.3075513243675232,
0.1139269471168518,
0.030054409056901932,
0.6635616421699524,
0.7222478985786438,
1.1303634643554688,
-0.6153963804244995,
0.5072359442710876,
0.0981622263789177,
-0.28013643622398376,
0.6246554851531982,
-0.8372739553451538,
-0.22993220388889313,
-0.031456440687179565,
0.26141804456710815,
-0.7297818064689636,
-0.018215572461485863,
0.40060725808143616,
-0.09910763800144196,
0.22493429481983185,
-0.0015751596074551344,
-0.5040913224220276,
-0.14990830421447754,
-0.5420169234275818,
0.7888825535774231,
0.5318856239318848,
-0.6641728281974792,
0.5398973226547241,
0.4292781352996826,
-0.3542771339416504,
-0.5797597765922546,
-0.9349209070205688,
0.3194443881511688,
-0.040779560804367065,
-0.7879329919815063,
0.7400693297386169,
-0.18623581528663635,
0.02937965653836727,
0.13723444938659668,
0.5390474200248718,
-0.5694406032562256,
-0.2621959149837494,
-0.18878008425235748,
0.5422635674476624,
-0.5157766938209534,
-0.022645076736807823,
0.2859974801540375,
0.044684939086437225,
0.011712481267750263,
-0.5713964104652405,
0.39617663621902466,
0.36168500781059265,
0.08962718397378922,
-0.38843774795532227,
0.6650920510292053,
0.34852102398872375,
-0.5132274627685547,
0.7757436633110046,
0.8362096548080444,
-0.18718715012073517,
-0.12839306890964508,
-0.19137485325336456,
0.30260416865348816,
-0.438914954662323,
0.6735122799873352,
0.004055502824485302,
-0.7120330929756165,
0.23820967972278595,
0.005130663514137268,
0.15073592960834503,
0.3011607229709625,
0.5627802610397339,
0.08796532452106476,
1.1840965747833252,
1.0206100940704346,
-0.020900139585137367,
0.8652414083480835,
-0.1738530993461609,
-0.10380060225725174,
-0.7315713167190552,
0.10238353163003922,
-0.06098755821585655,
0.032007843255996704,
-0.38652223348617554,
-0.8197066783905029,
0.4296485483646393,
-0.30573680996894836,
0.09498664736747742,
0.3195693790912628,
-0.19384059309959412,
0.3357459008693695,
0.3567718267440796,
0.32782039046287537,
0.3039405047893524,
0.011742671020328999,
-0.2548023760318756,
-0.031135333701968193,
-0.42299583554267883,
-0.10080777853727341,
0.9308775663375854,
0.19694596529006958,
0.6033087968826294,
0.006361165549606085,
0.4822520911693573,
0.21816009283065796,
0.2764279544353485,
-0.5550007820129395,
0.5735878944396973,
-0.5103390216827393,
-0.33143845200538635,
-0.18774066865444183,
-0.3772238492965698,
-0.8116286396980286,
0.17712394893169403,
-0.2942270338535309,
-0.30544719099998474,
-0.059637147933244705,
0.08133598417043686,
0.011238549835979939,
0.5776615738868713,
-0.6476352214813232,
0.9731450080871582,
-0.4316759705543518,
-0.5808985829353333,
-0.3137589693069458,
-0.30381345748901367,
0.6872718334197998,
-0.5228461623191833,
0.07512249797582626,
0.1902637779712677,
-0.4319435954093933,
0.487488329410553,
-0.34435805678367615,
0.560032308101654,
-0.06217453256249428,
-0.4293450713157654,
0.36091604828834534,
-0.019606860354542732,
0.17492333054542542,
0.031889185309410095,
-0.08296377211809158,
0.3639288544654846,
-0.05212197080254555,
-0.30610203742980957,
-0.33722278475761414,
0.5789881348609924,
-0.5652233958244324,
-0.3408118188381195,
0.06949272751808167,
-0.5288692712783813,
0.41449597477912903,
0.4537942111492157,
0.5103697776794434,
0.33662500977516174,
-0.15429577231407166,
0.11212677508592606,
0.7348498106002808,
-0.5745404362678528,
0.5834845304489136,
0.41616126894950867,
-0.5978915691375732,
-0.6267127990722656,
0.8889317512512207,
0.17287935316562653,
0.3995206952095032,
0.6310814023017883,
0.29427027702331543,
-0.22226247191429138,
-0.2973148822784424,
-0.5257862210273743,
0.42318692803382874,
-0.49765637516975403,
-0.06452351808547974,
-0.6499629020690918,
-0.2840983271598816,
-0.46216216683387756,
-0.1500243991613388,
-0.4066189229488373,
-0.31511959433555603,
-0.31752681732177734,
0.18028999865055084,
0.005589928012341261,
0.3856236934661865,
-0.01926160790026188,
0.20383724570274353,
-0.9300260543823242,
0.5249358415603638,
0.2692781388759613,
0.4129491150379181,
0.0804016962647438,
-0.48984500765800476,
-0.5675391554832458,
0.08840183168649673,
-0.5975120067596436,
-1.2429171800613403,
0.6650380492210388,
0.16205479204654694,
0.34734290838241577,
0.5925941467285156,
-0.10416688024997711,
0.7495478391647339,
-0.6250477433204651,
0.9776993989944458,
0.6143306493759155,
-1.0582114458084106,
0.42830923199653625,
-0.24564717710018158,
0.2924124002456665,
-0.27839505672454834,
0.5162960886955261,
-0.6460036039352417,
-0.5921140909194946,
-0.28369590640068054,
-0.8765537142753601,
0.6989034414291382,
-0.01068249624222517,
0.2857770621776581,
0.08434490114450455,
0.10394740849733353,
0.24536646902561188,
-0.14874082803726196,
-1.2738648653030396,
-0.1590835005044937,
-0.4388680160045624,
-0.10756277292966843,
0.17712169885635376,
-0.2210901528596878,
0.2609608769416809,
-0.22025035321712494,
0.7090955376625061,
-0.11757586896419525,
0.2766205072402954,
0.07663987576961517,
-0.21541328728199005,
-0.1083575114607811,
-0.04073720425367355,
0.3549977242946625,
0.22369997203350067,
0.38897550106048584,
-0.026111368089914322,
0.10260362178087234,
-0.6215502619743347,
-0.0792088434100151,
0.1690651774406433,
-0.6509695053100586,
0.307460218667984,
0.05632194131612778,
0.7738649249076843,
-0.031296826899051666,
-0.7129178047180176,
0.7966427803039551,
-0.03077162243425846,
-0.5028451085090637,
-0.3837071359157562,
-0.17230068147182465,
-0.02001979388296604,
0.17182043194770813,
0.39658766984939575,
-0.11654753237962723,
0.210544154047966,
-0.3993366062641144,
0.12796004116535187,
0.637963593006134,
-0.2702140212059021,
-0.47067415714263916,
1.0501424074172974,
0.36364808678627014,
-0.18185022473335266,
0.44581320881843567,
-0.14576253294944763,
-0.49463748931884766,
0.6201004981994629,
0.8273950815200806,
1.0612592697143555,
-0.32489264011383057,
0.6182841658592224,
0.6827956438064575,
0.18628334999084473,
-0.4405837059020996,
0.08325066417455673,
-0.38883042335510254,
-0.8079779744148254,
-0.27137526869773865,
-0.14631451666355133,
-0.3163558840751648,
-0.017566779628396034,
-0.43073782324790955,
0.6146617531776428,
-0.23386992514133453,
-0.2851826548576355,
-0.25557398796081543,
-0.38100624084472656,
-0.1432022899389267,
-0.04803115874528885,
0.4300973117351532,
1.0088986158370972,
-0.7355412840843201,
1.105616807937622,
0.6422622799873352,
-0.3679508864879608,
-0.629705548286438,
0.13982760906219482,
-0.41958194971084595,
-0.7301212549209595,
0.8229939937591553,
0.3369695842266083,
-0.07831037044525146,
-0.21072694659233093,
-0.7245079874992371,
-0.5393550992012024,
1.2033157348632812,
0.4576350152492523,
-0.3166355490684509,
-0.0688088908791542,
0.18773534893989563,
0.32255643606185913,
-0.4909181296825409,
0.30756497383117676,
0.02802162617444992,
0.565216600894928,
0.07122108340263367,
-0.7942736148834229,
-0.02674787864089012,
-0.30668243765830994,
0.28007617592811584,
0.09050863981246948,
-0.9157572388648987,
0.9303038120269775,
-0.22108718752861023,
-0.3547832667827606,
0.3865330219268799,
0.702302098274231,
0.13825079798698425,
0.3369593024253845,
0.5858046412467957,
0.3112988770008087,
0.24149706959724426,
0.009100468829274178,
0.690695583820343,
-0.43380069732666016,
-0.058886658400297165,
0.5824114680290222,
-0.24767246842384338,
0.976851224899292,
0.3728726804256439,
0.18171927332878113,
0.7137966752052307,
0.3200584650039673,
-0.22405706346035004,
0.4381283223628998,
-0.6583299040794373,
-0.412553995847702,
-0.2573576867580414,
-0.20148861408233643,
-0.1697387397289276,
0.07293695956468582,
0.13656844198703766,
-0.7377641797065735,
-0.11192928999662399,
0.145026296377182,
-0.08431383967399597,
0.023003218695521355,
-0.32900917530059814,
0.21518807113170624,
-0.04105932638049126,
-0.7195685505867004,
0.23215124011039734,
0.3760734498500824,
0.9747272729873657,
-0.8140398859977722,
-0.15096020698547363,
-0.12004190683364868,
-0.12831728160381317,
0.03908361494541168,
-1.1241085529327393,
0.11791091412305832,
0.10900284349918365,
0.04410530999302864,
-0.4745972752571106,
0.5104008316993713,
-0.895598292350769,
-0.6295239925384521,
0.4507085978984833,
0.2457672506570816,
-0.10076308250427246,
0.11495662480592728,
-0.7292941808700562,
0.009180395863950253,
0.0020916617941111326,
0.10877184569835663,
0.2109464854001999,
0.5705656409263611,
-0.13075847923755646,
0.2531655728816986,
0.3204682171344757,
0.31255972385406494,
0.2045753300189972,
0.025245655328035355,
0.44024765491485596,
-0.4185646176338196,
-0.7351549863815308,
-0.8002696633338928,
0.5356611609458923,
-0.11629772931337357,
-0.016500374302268028,
0.6310096979141235,
0.702958345413208,
0.5957915186882019,
-0.1814669668674469,
0.8615594506263733,
-0.08866751194000244,
-0.05347598344087601,
-0.5455082058906555,
0.8491365313529968,
-0.9828052520751953,
-0.13407030701637268,
-0.4174862504005432,
-0.6213419437408447,
-0.3023295998573303,
0.33689647912979126,
0.15569327771663666,
0.010161682032048702,
0.5760733485221863,
0.8073721528053284,
-0.16668619215488434,
-0.18888387084007263,
0.40399640798568726,
0.22143632173538208,
0.3376034200191498,
0.7597072720527649,
0.7505683898925781,
-0.6227150559425354,
0.8129909634590149,
-0.28973957896232605,
-0.34368929266929626,
0.12259993702173233,
-1.0583763122558594,
-0.6835559010505676,
-0.8542163372039795,
-0.3909381330013275,
-0.06374002248048782,
-0.1744716763496399,
0.5257128477096558,
0.8087384104728699,
-0.33487552404403687,
-0.3443897068500519,
-0.07529337704181671,
0.039919544011354446,
-0.2803638279438019,
-0.20521283149719238,
0.1808800846338272,
-0.10839277505874634,
-1.1874161958694458,
-0.11999867111444473,
0.6492495536804199,
0.25217926502227783,
-0.42519912123680115,
-0.2524856925010681,
0.05351899936795235,
0.031228601932525635,
0.7496318221092224,
0.38742852210998535,
-0.4951529800891876,
0.28078493475914,
0.16497620940208435,
-0.07818179577589035,
0.21463091671466827,
0.6566351652145386,
-0.5060575008392334,
0.5643392205238342,
0.43633410334587097,
0.4410165548324585,
0.46911367774009705,
-0.28303104639053345,
0.7973939776420593,
-0.5338917374610901,
0.41546010971069336,
-0.1998613327741623,
0.5836448669433594,
0.323135107755661,
-0.19653065502643585,
0.09088265895843506,
0.3848343789577484,
-0.2935512363910675,
-0.6131072640419006,
0.3327699601650238,
-1.1409251689910889,
-0.27172836661338806,
1.1329784393310547,
-0.22981631755828857,
-0.4492587149143219,
0.2284006029367447,
-0.5475350618362427,
0.1582130640745163,
-0.26146188378334045,
0.6333795189857483,
0.5286647081375122,
0.3098505437374115,
-0.8420560956001282,
-0.24092619121074677,
-0.07390183955430984,
0.1800566166639328,
-0.6656182408332825,
-0.03987238556146622,
0.48608705401420593,
0.30585524439811707,
0.11169516295194626,
0.7327257990837097,
-0.4136112332344055,
0.7761299014091492,
-0.02260708622634411,
-0.020953737199306488,
-0.05290887504816055,
-0.1052987277507782,
-0.12736307084560394,
0.07741173356771469,
-0.034951623529195786,
-0.12229020148515701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14681v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14681v2 | MasonTigers@LT-EDI-2024: An Ensemble Approach Towards Detecting Homophobia and Transphobia in Social Media Comments | 2024-01-26T06:56:17 | 2024-02-15T06:05:13 | Dhiman Goswami, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Md Nishat Raihan, Al Nahian Bin Emran | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we describe our approaches and results for Task 2 of the
LT-EDI 2024 Workshop, aimed at detecting homophobia and/or transphobia across
ten languages. Our methodologies include monolingual transformers and ensemble
methods, capitalizing on the strengths of each to enhance the performance of
the models. The ensemble models worked well, placing our team, MasonTigers, in
the top five for eight of the ten languages, as measured by the macro F1 score.
Our work emphasizes the efficacy of ensemble methods in multilingual scenarios,
addressing the complexities of language-specific tasks. | [
-0.5759400725364685,
-0.715665876865387,
0.4117961823940277,
0.3023725748062134,
-0.20302589237689972,
0.4428458511829376,
-0.30825066566467285,
-0.8043290376663208,
0.3422917127609253,
-0.03488437831401825,
-0.6797208786010742,
-0.4788677394390106,
-0.6647869944572449,
0.5430030822753906,
-0.6870661973953247,
0.8320955634117126,
0.02232479676604271,
0.162074476480484,
-0.10665712505578995,
0.15464380383491516,
-0.18326835334300995,
-0.14975585043430328,
-0.7443485856056213,
0.1594759076833725,
0.5900403261184692,
0.14761294424533844,
0.34028956294059753,
0.1477065086364746,
0.5444830060005188,
0.2653961777687073,
0.19200783967971802,
-0.13244174420833588,
-0.5143632292747498,
0.2493329644203186,
-0.22206713259220123,
-0.2248041331768036,
-0.4021640121936798,
0.0812012106180191,
0.7384664416313171,
0.2927577793598175,
0.08750499039888382,
0.33079713582992554,
0.25631293654441833,
0.05227584019303322,
-0.4764825999736786,
-0.22438079118728638,
-0.5071905851364136,
0.06791263818740845,
-0.13673265278339386,
-0.35298392176628113,
-0.6543237566947937,
-0.16689729690551758,
-0.13760864734649658,
-0.5294142961502075,
0.12821565568447113,
0.10732129216194153,
0.2612464427947998,
0.10544481873512268,
-0.6372869610786438,
-0.19387097656726837,
-0.8598670363426208,
1.1723569631576538,
-0.3607065975666046,
0.5719159841537476,
0.30604714155197144,
0.06834528595209122,
0.1608688086271286,
-0.5526090860366821,
-0.4148886799812317,
0.48116445541381836,
0.0028849076479673386,
0.20741787552833557,
-0.2614947557449341,
-0.1615542620420456,
-0.0736350417137146,
-0.12780903279781342,
-0.8719423413276672,
0.22390708327293396,
-0.5649433135986328,
-0.23467567563056946,
1.0950908660888672,
-0.14970014989376068,
0.14579196274280548,
0.14079076051712036,
-0.3684961497783661,
-0.07864432781934738,
-0.1412382572889328,
-0.25756290555000305,
0.7824190258979797,
0.3244864046573639,
-0.21823455393314362,
0.20025750994682312,
0.3831891417503357,
0.49698227643966675,
0.20989874005317688,
-0.2546316087245941,
0.281615287065506,
-0.270400732755661,
0.059775058180093765,
0.11815065890550613,
0.8617752194404602,
0.5431511402130127,
0.37048274278640747,
-0.2485952228307724,
-0.3440031409263611,
0.165557861328125,
0.35318851470947266,
-0.36318543553352356,
-0.16681250929832458,
0.41044509410858154,
-0.33893975615501404,
-0.6349337697029114,
0.0165844913572073,
-1.4812655448913574,
-0.37940701842308044,
0.1426173597574234,
0.25499698519706726,
-0.3858613073825836,
-0.5797271728515625,
-0.386288046836853,
-0.30764058232307434,
0.042827486991882324,
0.25689294934272766,
-0.9425090551376343,
0.4215570390224457,
0.8205289840698242,
0.6341280341148376,
-0.5351457595825195,
-0.2958969175815582,
-0.2835073173046112,
0.10723239928483963,
-0.26317906379699707,
0.8003337383270264,
-0.9333449006080627,
-0.6954854130744934,
0.29349324107170105,
-0.000986289232969284,
-0.3208223581314087,
-0.19166581332683563,
0.6915323138237,
-0.26238828897476196,
0.5036150217056274,
0.06069068983197212,
-0.46715983748435974,
-0.03497514873743057,
0.45888763666152954,
-0.6297255158424377,
1.2804198265075684,
0.10620810091495514,
-0.9021629691123962,
0.1989254206418991,
-0.563380241394043,
-0.4499970078468323,
0.171489879488945,
-0.2174120396375656,
0.023797117173671722,
-0.121666319668293,
-0.050331369042396545,
0.2553347945213318,
-0.04457230493426323,
0.04356030002236366,
-0.41430044174194336,
-0.24347423017024994,
0.03915461152791977,
-0.24382980167865753,
0.709316074848175,
0.3679223656654358,
-0.47109925746917725,
0.4178329110145569,
-0.5217661261558533,
-0.023640329018235207,
-0.04140431061387062,
-0.19992280006408691,
-0.4630507528781891,
-0.16422602534294128,
0.5770415663719177,
0.11695268005132675,
0.1914997100830078,
-0.6438385844230652,
-0.07773968577384949,
-0.1798800826072693,
0.0934254378080368,
1.0801477432250977,
-0.13055923581123352,
0.6594132781028748,
-0.14034923911094666,
0.7805807590484619,
-0.13935695588588715,
0.36391302943229675,
0.2684084177017212,
-0.7763935923576355,
-0.20163214206695557,
-0.11336245387792587,
0.07242755591869354,
0.580767810344696,
-1.0885193347930908,
0.41587376594543457,
-0.2576826810836792,
-0.629408061504364,
-0.19096876680850983,
-0.04937063902616501,
0.2478613555431366,
0.06557384133338928,
0.0609528049826622,
-0.07441461831331253,
-0.7758999466896057,
-0.7377398014068604,
-0.5516017079353333,
-0.5387371182441711,
0.060656122863292694,
-0.11575035005807877,
0.580903172492981,
-0.3679444491863251,
0.5619446039199829,
0.08739647269248962,
0.2365998774766922,
-0.16797849535942078,
0.304416686296463,
0.049997419118881226,
0.5992605686187744,
0.9022615551948547,
-1.3376625776290894,
-0.6165944933891296,
-0.1929747611284256,
-0.5977509021759033,
0.08955938369035721,
0.1202717199921608,
-0.036241792142391205,
0.5574561357498169,
0.34375205636024475,
-0.2247200459241867,
0.23953989148139954,
0.7911019325256348,
-0.5495848059654236,
0.3174828886985779,
0.3840585947036743,
0.4854780435562134,
-1.3419866561889648,
-0.19284191727638245,
0.397086501121521,
-0.2965444326400757,
-1.022666573524475,
0.22036314010620117,
-0.31781965494155884,
0.14313042163848877,
-0.5039435029029846,
0.508843183517456,
-0.24189503490924835,
0.15305469930171967,
0.0288072656840086,
-0.05004657432436943,
-0.6524528861045837,
0.34050530195236206,
0.07467791438102722,
0.6511542201042175,
0.6989086270332336,
-0.4494114816188812,
0.44688302278518677,
-0.012649241834878922,
-0.13324576616287231,
0.535169780254364,
-0.32334282994270325,
0.4015091061592102,
-0.1385962963104248,
-0.006923333741724491,
-1.4616420269012451,
-0.5060209035873413,
0.4186567962169647,
-0.7207497358322144,
0.4378438889980316,
0.21778210997581482,
-0.4100467264652252,
-0.772651195526123,
-0.7869118452072144,
0.682189404964447,
0.42086049914360046,
-0.2406121790409088,
0.9560926556587219,
0.8014801144599915,
-0.07470474392175674,
-0.5089163184165955,
-0.7782296538352966,
0.08267375826835632,
-0.5780744552612305,
-0.6602331399917603,
0.16126523911952972,
-0.22763176262378693,
-0.5835418105125427,
-0.13612821698188782,
-0.04558805003762245,
-0.2954310476779938,
0.31779053807258606,
0.11357548832893372,
0.1860848367214203,
0.15555812418460846,
0.09317272156476974,
-0.06915473937988281,
0.24682778120040894,
0.19644096493721008,
-0.45226430892944336,
0.7460244297981262,
-0.19894814491271973,
-0.11513664573431015,
-0.1076720654964447,
0.4980699121952057,
0.4368975758552551,
0.04544046148657799,
0.6816666126251221,
1.078037977218628,
-0.5216099619865417,
-0.09312345832586288,
-0.49659109115600586,
-0.29061755537986755,
-0.44364070892333984,
0.2640686333179474,
-0.09166625887155533,
-1.2446883916854858,
0.48805394768714905,
0.08432416617870331,
0.2110137641429901,
0.47119084000587463,
0.6655128002166748,
-0.16879472136497498,
1.0053397417068481,
0.8013939261436462,
-0.1437484472990036,
0.36695075035095215,
-0.05667557567358017,
0.40744128823280334,
-0.2754320502281189,
-0.22562052309513092,
-0.5959030985832214,
-0.4876655042171478,
-1.07411789894104,
-0.4025488495826721,
0.7045186161994934,
-0.39700138568878174,
0.06902226060628891,
0.6757451295852661,
-0.542908787727356,
0.15077905356884003,
0.4761873781681061,
-0.1326126605272293,
-0.08544963598251343,
0.15962228178977966,
0.18412120640277863,
0.15454533696174622,
-0.649290919303894,
-0.6029232740402222,
1.0210319757461548,
0.36447298526763916,
0.6105811595916748,
0.47746485471725464,
0.8670759201049805,
0.45425349473953247,
0.34235045313835144,
-0.6725353002548218,
0.6955422759056091,
0.13883614540100098,
-1.0326659679412842,
-0.6277123689651489,
-0.29047921299934387,
-0.7415787577629089,
-0.05838562548160553,
-0.29905346035957336,
-1.3671213388442993,
0.43109044432640076,
0.04798611253499985,
-0.2295224964618683,
0.4913683533668518,
-0.4321604371070862,
0.8163068890571594,
0.034610819071531296,
-0.6230544447898865,
-0.15756168961524963,
-0.836069643497467,
0.4941842257976532,
-0.43582895398139954,
0.8757190704345703,
0.18149907886981964,
-0.1821519136428833,
1.0102002620697021,
0.3255462646484375,
0.9497668743133545,
-0.0023412553127855062,
-0.46627065539360046,
0.42468687891960144,
0.014349478296935558,
0.3952542841434479,
-0.08612503856420517,
-0.4458901584148407,
0.11699986457824707,
0.21124795079231262,
-0.314998984336853,
-0.22851505875587463,
0.6253262162208557,
-0.5287800431251526,
-0.44194403290748596,
-0.28535711765289307,
-0.5623098611831665,
-0.283936083316803,
-0.0009024047758430243,
0.4861241579055786,
0.351447194814682,
-0.5038121342658997,
-0.06663990020751953,
0.510880708694458,
-0.06082389876246452,
0.8392381072044373,
0.11376287788152695,
-0.35156214237213135,
-0.34385794401168823,
0.6162017583847046,
-0.029477352276444435,
0.08796653151512146,
0.2297765165567398,
-0.004767175298184156,
-0.4406687021255493,
-0.2576320767402649,
-0.2799490988254547,
0.0583040677011013,
-0.6231779456138611,
0.11336518824100494,
-0.793653130531311,
0.269437700510025,
-1.1469008922576904,
-0.004873794503509998,
-0.20772938430309296,
-0.4310876429080963,
-0.03617709502577782,
-0.2616349160671234,
0.1535908728837967,
0.8217259049415588,
-0.2143193632364273,
0.09269220381975174,
-0.8440661430358887,
-0.10620176047086716,
0.17583619058132172,
0.2347998321056366,
-0.33958980441093445,
-0.5461867451667786,
-0.17361560463905334,
-0.034050725400447845,
-0.24372737109661102,
-1.0509974956512451,
0.4013282060623169,
0.11562423408031464,
0.5327659845352173,
0.557285487651825,
0.15655286610126495,
0.29615700244903564,
-0.19165962934494019,
0.9631674289703369,
0.21161918342113495,
-0.8191710710525513,
0.5067014694213867,
-0.6286737322807312,
-0.2921004593372345,
0.4786967933177948,
1.0100016593933105,
-0.42349299788475037,
-0.6453830599784851,
-0.6279581189155579,
-0.6030481457710266,
0.5607072114944458,
0.40568891167640686,
0.31201860308647156,
-0.23919843137264252,
0.12187756597995758,
-0.04072708636522293,
0.32754242420196533,
-0.8471821546554565,
-0.3020413815975189,
0.009576844982802868,
-0.5210251212120056,
-0.18479104340076447,
-0.4905516505241394,
-0.18776501715183258,
-0.44586583971977234,
0.7930403351783752,
-0.11061297357082367,
0.45081862807273865,
0.1390278935432434,
0.1621500551700592,
-0.591464102268219,
0.2852330505847931,
0.7207271456718445,
0.7188210487365723,
-0.17978139221668243,
0.4719406068325043,
0.34461715817451477,
-0.41973555088043213,
0.11484124511480331,
-0.11508446931838989,
0.03353266417980194,
0.15137453377246857,
0.8584327101707458,
0.5662419199943542,
0.1317964792251587,
-0.5497705340385437,
0.42654913663864136,
-0.028149627149105072,
-0.33130592107772827,
-0.5133504271507263,
-0.20597310364246368,
-0.12401474267244339,
0.14830723404884338,
0.4026613235473633,
0.034197233617305756,
0.30760473012924194,
-1.0735962390899658,
0.526344358921051,
0.25293704867362976,
-0.7773888111114502,
-0.7108752727508545,
0.6541794538497925,
0.41184842586517334,
-0.4746880531311035,
0.12683530151844025,
-0.45429250597953796,
-0.7790131568908691,
0.530677855014801,
0.6853308081626892,
0.9272708892822266,
-0.8219316601753235,
0.289089560508728,
0.5327025651931763,
0.6366020441055298,
0.019216716289520264,
0.3205867111682892,
0.12306733429431915,
-0.9490320086479187,
-0.18162983655929565,
-0.4968656897544861,
0.013348153792321682,
-0.3227298855781555,
-0.6712433695793152,
0.400783509016037,
-0.3061773180961609,
-0.21462678909301758,
0.028412185609340668,
-0.4617696702480316,
-0.3088793456554413,
0.05991559848189354,
0.43825018405914307,
0.9430952668190002,
-1.062639594078064,
0.7235509753227234,
1.060330867767334,
0.1126968264579773,
-0.5819287896156311,
0.17807090282440186,
0.5538960099220276,
-0.554490327835083,
0.37225541472435,
0.1255093216896057,
-0.1321212649345398,
0.20189763605594635,
-0.691292405128479,
-0.5540112853050232,
0.7488911747932434,
-0.010986444540321827,
-0.653798520565033,
0.05804328992962837,
0.15398558974266052,
0.7515035271644592,
-0.4646507203578949,
0.28926944732666016,
0.5934519171714783,
0.9179161787033081,
0.03456983342766762,
-1.040226697921753,
-0.13849881291389465,
-0.5651947259902954,
-0.25048503279685974,
0.30523237586021423,
-0.4562775194644928,
0.8029347658157349,
0.25077351927757263,
-0.5265169143676758,
0.048266295343637466,
0.5223743915557861,
-0.1977797895669937,
0.5791037082672119,
0.9898137450218201,
0.3680846691131592,
0.6925461292266846,
-0.037956301122903824,
1.2253741025924683,
-0.5244694352149963,
0.5598116517066956,
0.8004583716392517,
-0.3131716251373291,
0.6240170001983643,
0.666362464427948,
-0.2546740472316742,
0.36323001980781555,
0.7371647357940674,
0.030648883432149887,
0.4377378821372986,
0.007369176484644413,
-0.5797883868217468,
-0.4218842387199402,
-0.4194076955318451,
-0.04588208347558975,
0.46739283204078674,
0.18679583072662354,
-0.12178259342908859,
-0.07545524835586548,
0.3177478611469269,
-0.10695178061723709,
0.33805251121520996,
-0.284042090177536,
0.834241509437561,
-0.015183471143245697,
-0.6498589515686035,
0.30937251448631287,
-0.03087121620774269,
1.008449912071228,
-0.15810251235961914,
0.06017051637172699,
0.19009406864643097,
0.025391144677996635,
-0.22663134336471558,
-0.8827749490737915,
0.6420761346817017,
0.20115293562412262,
0.1487070471048355,
-0.24547874927520752,
0.8819156885147095,
-0.6712899208068848,
-0.9051375389099121,
0.6685546636581421,
0.36797454953193665,
0.30362173914909363,
0.09785932302474976,
-0.5186318159103394,
0.07877332717180252,
0.13189400732517242,
-0.08597667515277863,
0.009810570627450943,
0.2669437527656555,
-0.25067582726478577,
0.465070903301239,
0.23664253950119019,
-0.40895989537239075,
0.15919281542301178,
0.03446482494473457,
0.696793258190155,
-0.2684648931026459,
-0.3929717242717743,
-1.0084669589996338,
0.345084011554718,
-0.1281813383102417,
-0.14513957500457764,
0.9970288872718811,
0.6168725490570068,
1.0798460245132446,
-0.23011210560798645,
0.7159582376480103,
-0.365690678358078,
0.5488513112068176,
-0.07499302178621292,
0.421333909034729,
-0.5395268201828003,
0.04859381169080734,
-0.6334050893783569,
-1.0350744724273682,
-0.2853357493877411,
0.3237786889076233,
-0.193705216050148,
0.03691112622618675,
0.7098451256752014,
0.8526461720466614,
-0.06554143875837326,
0.27239614725112915,
0.43721669912338257,
0.13292551040649414,
0.12207045406103134,
0.4081745445728302,
1.017891764640808,
-0.44611069560050964,
0.48337483406066895,
-0.39574337005615234,
-0.18620029091835022,
0.10955360531806946,
-0.5141128301620483,
-1.016326665878296,
-0.6958049535751343,
-0.32185813784599304,
-0.30393272638320923,
0.05667242035269737,
1.0755901336669922,
0.5224305391311646,
-1.0399956703186035,
-0.35533714294433594,
0.0030765701085329056,
0.20057468116283417,
-0.02317139320075512,
-0.24847538769245148,
-0.13639232516288757,
-0.1011558547616005,
-1.154868721961975,
0.3457925617694855,
0.23832738399505615,
-0.09723807126283646,
-0.14986179769039154,
-0.06525730341672897,
-0.6242621541023254,
0.01354400347918272,
0.5094605684280396,
-0.2433658391237259,
-0.555465579032898,
-0.7501024603843689,
0.01838785596191883,
-0.002634286182001233,
-0.2643758952617645,
0.563467264175415,
-0.259078711271286,
0.20952047407627106,
0.5208452343940735,
0.2781029939651489,
0.2769366502761841,
0.06717169284820557,
0.5243986248970032,
-0.7839850783348083,
0.4610784351825714,
0.23479266464710236,
0.2426491528749466,
0.2326785773038864,
-0.4504036605358124,
1.0288866758346558,
0.5493349432945251,
-0.23982098698616028,
-1.0277477502822876,
0.10449087619781494,
-0.9858013987541199,
-0.33473441004753113,
1.1993966102600098,
0.017835645005106926,
-0.41733258962631226,
-0.25300905108451843,
0.14752301573753357,
0.330940842628479,
-0.30385833978652954,
0.7917528748512268,
0.8105125427246094,
0.29062706232070923,
-0.22940383851528168,
-0.35211601853370667,
0.455405592918396,
0.16751772165298462,
-0.7770825624465942,
-0.44208094477653503,
0.12049403786659241,
0.07417654246091843,
0.6043137311935425,
0.4677257239818573,
-0.009098765440285206,
0.2922556400299072,
-0.1017356887459755,
0.2196967750787735,
0.424660861492157,
-0.4637854993343353,
-0.3953942358493805,
0.09536877274513245,
-0.4393759071826935,
-0.0041974857449531555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14680v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14680v2 | MaLLaM -- Malaysia Large Language Model | 2024-01-26T06:56:05 | 2024-01-29T07:18:59 | Husein Zolkepli, Aisyah Razak, Kamarul Adha, Ariff Nazhan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Addressing the gap in Large Language Model pretrained from scratch with
Malaysian context, We trained models with 1.1 billion, 3 billion, and 5 billion
parameters on a substantial 349GB dataset, equivalent to 90 billion tokens
based on our pretrained Byte Pair Encoding (BPE) tokenizer for a single epoch.
MaLLaM contributes to enhanced natural language understanding and generation
tasks in the Malay language. Although trained on a smaller dataset of 90
billion tokens, our instruction-tuned MaLLaM models perform competitively. When
compared to ChatGPT3.5 and Malaysian Mistral, MaLLaM's instruction-tuned models
demonstrate notable proficiency, underscoring the effectiveness of our approach
in capturing and understanding the nuances of the Malaysian language. MaLLaM
models mark a significant contribution to the field, providing comprehensive
language representations grounded in Malaysian context. This endeavor aims to
pave the way for enhanced natural language understanding and generation tasks
specific to the linguistic nuances present in Malaysia. We discuss the training
methodology, dataset composition, and the potential impact of MaLLaM in
advancing the capabilities of large language models within the context of the
Malay language.
All models released at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mesolitica/mallam-6577b59d1e0b436ae75f930f | [
-0.3195958137512207,
-0.6015449166297913,
0.30584385991096497,
0.3589516282081604,
-0.2860187292098999,
-0.13732168078422546,
-0.49280864000320435,
-0.47124984860420227,
-0.24706970155239105,
0.6058474779129028,
-0.2624507546424866,
-0.4788112938404083,
-0.6868990063667297,
0.09084062278270721,
-0.13563735783100128,
0.6701846718788147,
0.07120678573846817,
0.04347686097025871,
0.04139324277639389,
-0.1978369504213333,
-0.7491724491119385,
-0.8319510221481323,
-0.6950812935829163,
0.026366939768195152,
0.30298593640327454,
0.6098384261131287,
0.551228940486908,
0.7947991490364075,
0.6691421866416931,
0.28712859749794006,
-0.050181180238723755,
-0.13913238048553467,
-0.6172462105751038,
0.05368615686893463,
-0.12374360859394073,
-0.5173184275627136,
-0.4539424777030945,
0.04606560990214348,
0.6982699036598206,
1.074222207069397,
-0.2600231468677521,
0.45422831177711487,
-0.25528576970100403,
0.6556831002235413,
-0.5449455380439758,
0.4437505304813385,
-0.530351459980011,
-0.11518175154924393,
-0.3989446461200714,
0.19041529297828674,
-0.24050283432006836,
-0.3663794696331024,
0.17923225462436676,
-0.28957363963127136,
-0.032250791788101196,
0.10773088783025742,
0.537890613079071,
0.26011571288108826,
-0.6072330474853516,
-0.3255399763584137,
-0.7494350075721741,
0.8453712463378906,
-0.8236240148544312,
0.45795106887817383,
0.5800844430923462,
0.5319974422454834,
-0.04255419969558716,
-0.49778059124946594,
-0.41952747106552124,
-0.3086094260215759,
0.2509889006614685,
-0.026213746517896652,
0.13495029509067535,
0.1503005474805832,
0.22856970131397247,
0.4869856536388397,
-0.6823952198028564,
0.3554524779319763,
-0.5305662155151367,
0.08109144121408463,
0.7014632821083069,
0.17029346525669098,
-0.029740920290350914,
-0.23878347873687744,
-0.04425030201673508,
-0.13867652416229248,
-0.9200382232666016,
-0.13913646340370178,
0.45912879705429077,
0.40285223722457886,
-0.04347231239080429,
0.6813908219337463,
-0.06569517403841019,
0.71318519115448,
-0.11145004630088806,
-0.36907270550727844,
-0.07911719381809235,
-0.18499380350112915,
-0.5221326351165771,
0.26621729135513306,
0.4183824956417084,
0.046434953808784485,
0.15447665750980377,
0.043898455798625946,
-0.3595499098300934,
-0.09398302435874939,
0.01648673042654991,
-1.2359164953231812,
-0.16787002980709076,
0.20443056523799896,
-0.610517144203186,
-0.06083497777581215,
0.43192198872566223,
-0.6018325090408325,
-0.3011712431907654,
-0.469048410654068,
0.28732696175575256,
-0.249541774392128,
-0.6926808953285217,
0.520092785358429,
0.4319460093975067,
0.25144991278648376,
0.042879052460193634,
-1.1499794721603394,
0.2767709195613861,
0.8187544941902161,
0.6088128089904785,
-0.020065071061253548,
-0.13275451958179474,
-0.05026324465870857,
0.254576176404953,
-0.2619417607784271,
0.3039514124393463,
-0.7147300243377686,
-0.4820091426372528,
0.04851921275258064,
-0.17459753155708313,
-0.24653582274913788,
-0.8954127430915833,
0.5357570648193359,
-0.4636976718902588,
0.38286256790161133,
-0.05155948922038078,
-0.5927962064743042,
-0.6028721928596497,
0.07831952720880508,
-0.924985408782959,
1.0242666006088257,
0.2357957661151886,
-0.43057918548583984,
0.39727142453193665,
-0.869949996471405,
-0.40242689847946167,
-0.059808649122714996,
0.10794287919998169,
-0.40960898995399475,
0.33225324749946594,
0.21806205809116364,
0.7756412625312805,
-0.18533408641815186,
0.3428909182548523,
-0.1917111575603485,
-0.403910368680954,
0.2720750570297241,
-0.4575844407081604,
0.6981251835823059,
0.2798011004924774,
-0.26980510354042053,
0.18734332919120789,
-0.9703752994537354,
-0.3217371106147766,
0.37346309423446655,
-0.3828679025173187,
-0.06613573431968689,
-0.4408750832080841,
0.33156681060791016,
0.33656230568885803,
0.42284247279167175,
-0.3160240054130554,
0.26233959197998047,
-0.4479125142097473,
0.3245643973350525,
0.5449184775352478,
-0.0534723661839962,
0.3732966482639313,
-0.20324407517910004,
0.6123389601707458,
0.2608305513858795,
0.03658686950802803,
-0.3844211995601654,
-0.2725716829299927,
-0.6604712009429932,
-0.26127591729164124,
0.4242483079433441,
0.2721332311630249,
0.2901187837123871,
0.3378099501132965,
-0.21824678778648376,
-0.3957087993621826,
-0.5221192240715027,
0.07339154183864594,
0.0873667523264885,
0.10320047289133072,
0.067472442984581,
-0.3887386620044708,
-1.0299975872039795,
-0.5904754400253296,
0.0694122388958931,
-0.1547839492559433,
0.019665012136101723,
0.42420634627342224,
0.38046881556510925,
-0.3696853220462799,
0.7692517042160034,
-0.10908711701631546,
0.0012416925746947527,
-0.5069487690925598,
-0.0008035679929889739,
0.3608610928058624,
0.44204726815223694,
0.3552304804325104,
-0.5748783349990845,
-0.27704960107803345,
-0.048904068768024445,
-0.37841543555259705,
-0.06829681247472763,
-0.006607315968722105,
0.08550837635993958,
0.48303544521331787,
0.7406696677207947,
-0.8981114029884338,
0.12428715080022812,
0.7165912985801697,
-0.0519096665084362,
0.7862827181816101,
-0.09967911243438721,
0.05080438777804375,
-1.2781078815460205,
0.36901456117630005,
-0.3463069498538971,
-0.12755699455738068,
-0.5542529225349426,
0.012233089655637741,
-0.21172717213630676,
-0.32613977789878845,
-0.27577322721481323,
0.5909837484359741,
-0.5766828060150146,
-0.03426229581236839,
-0.3650045394897461,
0.1597089320421219,
-0.31587207317352295,
0.4287623167037964,
0.12482903897762299,
0.7041198015213013,
0.5304412841796875,
-0.610040545463562,
0.1788809597492218,
0.21928630769252777,
-0.5285918712615967,
0.3027406632900238,
-0.5603308081626892,
0.22795911133289337,
-0.040495093911886215,
0.12431030720472336,
-0.9068397283554077,
-0.4918740391731262,
0.17543064057826996,
-0.0559474341571331,
0.5197057127952576,
-0.07798971235752106,
-0.48611998558044434,
-0.46398335695266724,
0.030124003067612648,
0.6632047891616821,
0.38436949253082275,
-0.4743829071521759,
0.22947536408901215,
0.48246631026268005,
-0.27227044105529785,
-0.7305832505226135,
-0.3011157810688019,
0.22537006437778473,
-0.4989166259765625,
-0.4351905882358551,
-0.034240420907735825,
0.2907959222793579,
-0.3112841546535492,
-0.2848317623138428,
-0.20197418332099915,
0.04660292714834213,
0.10058566927909851,
0.6177982687950134,
0.10612387955188751,
-0.6947242021560669,
0.110380619764328,
-0.26713675260543823,
-0.1877099573612213,
0.2978106737136841,
-0.35770294070243835,
0.8304277658462524,
-0.16657452285289764,
-0.5133289694786072,
-0.39831143617630005,
0.1233140081167221,
0.5060513019561768,
-0.2512587904930115,
0.9074732661247253,
0.7042421698570251,
-0.4613993465900421,
0.12492869049310684,
-0.5522306561470032,
-0.21480581164360046,
-0.4516262114048004,
0.755332887172699,
-0.5252986550331116,
-1.162584662437439,
0.34564054012298584,
-0.21843822300434113,
0.12083569169044495,
0.4996689260005951,
0.7254974842071533,
0.26825186610221863,
1.1188031435012817,
0.9912533760070801,
-0.45642417669296265,
0.25672298669815063,
-0.11245597153902054,
0.44883087277412415,
-0.37201735377311707,
-0.19910989701747894,
-0.41109761595726013,
-0.2048201560974121,
-0.5539747476577759,
-0.4331763684749603,
-0.15089119970798492,
0.4498784840106964,
-0.5005472898483276,
0.2742079198360443,
-0.2347193956375122,
0.35641080141067505,
0.5375016331672668,
-0.31683024764060974,
0.3204319477081299,
-0.21100673079490662,
0.04742176830768585,
0.10640371590852737,
-0.8266460299491882,
-0.9415220618247986,
1.2778443098068237,
0.46657314896583557,
0.6040184497833252,
0.2730545997619629,
0.3845445513725281,
-0.21248014271259308,
0.15555304288864136,
-0.6043818593025208,
0.6808696389198303,
0.23313963413238525,
-0.6493006348609924,
-0.0828896090388298,
-0.44471728801727295,
-1.1691341400146484,
-0.036808524280786514,
0.03864150494337082,
-0.5186876058578491,
-0.39238715171813965,
-0.052256159484386444,
-0.2533489167690277,
0.33768230676651,
-0.7412363886833191,
1.080330491065979,
-0.20679140090942383,
0.12092709541320801,
-0.6809825897216797,
-0.7362680435180664,
0.71595299243927,
-0.11541734635829926,
-0.22160591185092926,
-0.32446134090423584,
-0.08950086683034897,
0.9009361267089844,
-0.1957532912492752,
0.7093625068664551,
-0.25127270817756653,
-0.2153325229883194,
0.1524476706981659,
-0.1621355563402176,
0.1419840306043625,
0.06061243638396263,
0.0060152471996843815,
0.18628986179828644,
0.044597797095775604,
-0.5911948084831238,
-0.22135522961616516,
0.27138426899909973,
-0.8772024512290955,
-0.6523105502128601,
-0.31204015016555786,
-0.7377238273620605,
-0.28123167157173157,
0.1009962186217308,
-0.16502715647220612,
0.3698814809322357,
-0.5857024788856506,
0.05691254884004593,
0.5115054249763489,
-0.3859575390815735,
0.5971062183380127,
0.3224972188472748,
-0.6225479245185852,
-0.08615577220916748,
0.7840372920036316,
-0.252130925655365,
0.13387413322925568,
0.4153915047645569,
-0.0882396548986435,
-0.5378464460372925,
-0.7090384364128113,
-0.3336312472820282,
0.4828432500362396,
-0.4474826157093048,
-0.1401481330394745,
-0.6038160920143127,
-0.31781086325645447,
-0.3503413200378418,
0.1278432160615921,
-0.394480437040329,
-0.4942711293697357,
-0.2408381700515747,
-0.07278420031070709,
0.31579911708831787,
1.235628366470337,
-0.13442614674568176,
0.6985087990760803,
-0.7967692017555237,
-0.12448438256978989,
0.273845911026001,
0.3214806318283081,
0.17521049082279205,
-0.7241349816322327,
-0.5652801394462585,
0.05608383193612099,
-0.0634683296084404,
-0.4814486503601074,
0.2722265124320984,
0.18722495436668396,
0.31241995096206665,
0.8911135792732239,
-0.5290721654891968,
0.7479472160339355,
-0.3286883533000946,
0.5640473961830139,
-0.10304641723632812,
-0.7830317616462708,
0.3664321303367615,
-0.33422866463661194,
0.520280659198761,
0.44931265711784363,
0.4297172427177429,
-0.8630416393280029,
-0.22025325894355774,
-0.5988501906394958,
-0.5848888158798218,
0.6547073721885681,
-0.17608733475208282,
0.2893972396850586,
0.16512230038642883,
0.24510246515274048,
0.4295908212661743,
0.34481415152549744,
-0.4605899453163147,
-0.04450871795415878,
-0.0946655198931694,
-0.3211781978607178,
0.043765839189291,
-0.47519367933273315,
0.21110554039478302,
-0.2066275030374527,
0.7222644686698914,
0.1971784234046936,
0.2315903753042221,
-0.5502644777297974,
-0.4548380672931671,
-0.1462903916835785,
0.24125038087368011,
0.7646824717521667,
1.0060399770736694,
-0.45559659600257874,
0.08148910105228424,
0.030863188207149506,
-0.9341155290603638,
0.033090606331825256,
0.3098166882991791,
0.339633047580719,
-0.051764607429504395,
0.05415702238678932,
0.9100426435470581,
0.31387996673583984,
-1.0331746339797974,
0.3612517714500427,
-0.0100983502343297,
0.022317374125123024,
0.0014321351191028953,
0.11817754805088043,
0.27047988772392273,
0.11845782399177551,
0.41295114159584045,
0.045075856149196625,
-0.3357069194316864,
-0.3764106333255768,
0.29847416281700134,
0.3048917353153229,
-0.1292106658220291,
-0.5162534117698669,
0.6833967566490173,
0.06800754368305206,
0.028124500066041946,
0.6528946161270142,
-0.18014125525951385,
-0.5538299083709717,
0.35953986644744873,
0.7908754348754883,
0.4942805767059326,
-0.495819628238678,
0.08119779080152512,
0.6641619205474854,
0.31945380568504333,
-0.18099384009838104,
0.0960356593132019,
0.17268261313438416,
-0.4653231203556061,
-0.6743889451026917,
-0.6998394727706909,
-0.6066393852233887,
0.5361265540122986,
-0.4701904058456421,
0.17922759056091309,
-0.5658265948295593,
0.12353957444429398,
-0.5803059339523315,
0.6197978854179382,
-0.5408995747566223,
0.1448943018913269,
0.3982400894165039,
0.9956645965576172,
-0.7098598480224609,
0.73713219165802,
0.7274563312530518,
-0.2771186828613281,
-0.9332141876220703,
-0.2262951284646988,
-0.2244289070367813,
-0.9191363453865051,
0.42016929388046265,
0.7244737148284912,
0.25295016169548035,
0.16123166680335999,
-0.4003387689590454,
-1.0025073289871216,
0.904934823513031,
0.4126608967781067,
-0.6226538419723511,
0.21227556467056274,
0.6230453252792358,
0.2598073184490204,
-0.3122754991054535,
0.14840620756149292,
0.8675034642219543,
0.4722370207309723,
0.06368027627468109,
-0.8234800696372986,
0.05561565235257149,
-0.2191370129585266,
-0.05622435361146927,
0.24015308916568756,
-0.486100435256958,
0.6341580748558044,
-0.2617594301700592,
-0.337557852268219,
0.32027488946914673,
0.9341368079185486,
0.44512975215911865,
-0.12101702392101288,
0.331899493932724,
0.670034646987915,
1.0182528495788574,
0.024569950997829437,
0.5628990530967712,
-0.34616559743881226,
-0.09362415224313736,
1.0283989906311035,
-0.17310193181037903,
0.9002684950828552,
0.15544931590557098,
-0.24359837174415588,
0.25481536984443665,
0.8834502696990967,
0.016171736642718315,
0.22339998185634613,
0.19370952248573303,
-0.42858967185020447,
0.11274264007806778,
-0.1354246437549591,
-0.5254840850830078,
0.873506486415863,
0.3643724024295807,
-0.09905128926038742,
-0.13224373757839203,
0.002882733242586255,
0.2452307939529419,
-0.24625633656978607,
-0.6017343997955322,
0.4836808443069458,
0.1845223605632782,
-0.5311875939369202,
0.4851430356502533,
0.2176501601934433,
0.5887276530265808,
-0.46240395307540894,
0.2174863964319229,
-0.20860664546489716,
0.2575545907020569,
-0.035669829696416855,
-0.452827513217926,
0.16749079525470734,
-0.11979852616786957,
0.05245421454310417,
-0.11616138368844986,
0.5913684368133545,
-0.6608133316040039,
-0.3944430947303772,
-0.4020463228225708,
0.6143114566802979,
0.37405717372894287,
-0.38188934326171875,
-0.6414963006973267,
0.07877910882234573,
-0.28150078654289246,
-0.17932800948619843,
0.20672695338726044,
0.5969899892807007,
-0.06249254569411278,
0.38830330967903137,
0.501630961894989,
0.061808887869119644,
0.26402154564857483,
0.24287796020507812,
0.38279056549072266,
-0.8089543581008911,
-0.28030744194984436,
-0.7530506253242493,
0.27294686436653137,
-0.02270113117992878,
-0.6151495575904846,
0.8438981771469116,
0.8287461400032043,
0.9075872898101807,
-0.09979581087827682,
0.5830183029174805,
-0.002069150796160102,
0.34831082820892334,
-0.23106367886066437,
0.7043842077255249,
-0.1270178109407425,
-0.008141232654452324,
0.06326524168252945,
-1.291344404220581,
-0.4961528480052948,
0.690823495388031,
-0.3332323431968689,
0.3353218734264374,
0.5098347663879395,
0.9175747036933899,
-0.3307064175605774,
0.24922296404838562,
0.24358701705932617,
0.36374419927597046,
0.051179733127355576,
0.7127349972724915,
0.8891830444335938,
-0.3276008665561676,
0.4642358124256134,
0.043756842613220215,
0.029173633083701134,
-0.47340312600135803,
-0.6807494759559631,
-1.1894043684005737,
-0.564457893371582,
-0.05645173043012619,
-0.022127734497189522,
-0.1891241818666458,
1.0782088041305542,
0.7550597786903381,
-1.0365763902664185,
-0.5404148101806641,
-0.05623652786016464,
-0.11809252202510834,
-0.08295124769210815,
-0.13299673795700073,
0.5441471934318542,
-0.35931092500686646,
-0.7597048878669739,
0.23227474093437195,
0.5090110301971436,
0.22563549876213074,
-0.590110182762146,
-0.06983828544616699,
-0.2138843685388565,
0.10941410809755325,
0.7329331636428833,
0.36058443784713745,
-0.43922165036201477,
-0.021038953214883804,
0.10929000377655029,
-0.38614147901535034,
0.2787044644355774,
0.7919812798500061,
-0.6708842515945435,
0.04380671679973602,
0.08439242839813232,
0.8956376910209656,
0.5724620819091797,
-0.09863556921482086,
0.7183772325515747,
-0.7391376495361328,
0.411958247423172,
0.1436939537525177,
0.21594807505607605,
0.6203522682189941,
0.05450063571333885,
0.5614252090454102,
0.1159888505935669,
-0.6379016041755676,
-0.872938871383667,
0.08880006521940231,
-1.0664321184158325,
-0.11297224462032318,
1.0306355953216553,
0.20258666574954987,
-0.16297854483127594,
-0.21511957049369812,
-0.41040417551994324,
0.4403911530971527,
-0.08587643504142761,
0.9567931294441223,
0.6730507612228394,
0.33344918489456177,
-0.23018257319927216,
-0.6629254221916199,
0.512667715549469,
0.7611162662506104,
-0.8857806324958801,
0.22025801241397858,
0.40736329555511475,
-0.16815057396888733,
-0.31612110137939453,
0.43356430530548096,
0.0658985897898674,
0.27656105160713196,
-0.00612210389226675,
-0.1143583133816719,
0.0642089918255806,
-0.2737984359264374,
-0.3349716365337372,
0.10333102941513062,
0.3425118327140808,
-0.12134756147861481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14664v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14664v1 | UNIT-DSR: Dysarthric Speech Reconstruction System Using Speech Unit Normalization | 2024-01-26T06:08:47 | 2024-01-26T06:08:47 | Yuejiao Wang, Xixin Wu, Disong Wang, Lingwei Meng, Helen Meng | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Dysarthric speech reconstruction (DSR) systems aim to automatically convert
dysarthric speech into normal-sounding speech. The technology eases
communication with speakers affected by the neuromotor disorder and enhances
their social inclusion. NED-based (Neural Encoder-Decoder) systems have
significantly improved the intelligibility of the reconstructed speech as
compared with GAN-based (Generative Adversarial Network) approaches, but the
approach is still limited by training inefficiency caused by the cascaded
pipeline and auxiliary tasks of the content encoder, which may in turn affect
the quality of reconstruction. Inspired by self-supervised speech
representation learning and discrete speech units, we propose a Unit-DSR
system, which harnesses the powerful domain-adaptation capacity of HuBERT for
training efficiency improvement and utilizes speech units to constrain the
dysarthric content restoration in a discrete linguistic space. Compared with
NED approaches, the Unit-DSR system only consists of a speech unit normalizer
and a Unit HiFi-GAN vocoder, which is considerably simpler without cascaded
sub-modules or auxiliary tasks. Results on the UASpeech corpus indicate that
Unit-DSR outperforms competitive baselines in terms of content restoration,
reaching a 28.2% relative average word error rate reduction when compared to
original dysarthric speech, and shows robustness against speed perturbation and
noise. | [
-0.4104788303375244,
-0.6339757442474365,
0.18165932595729828,
-0.32871314883232117,
-0.10710085928440094,
0.4020581841468811,
-0.1469443291425705,
0.024197308346629143,
0.7791751027107239,
0.454898864030838,
-0.2849724292755127,
-0.08760863542556763,
-0.41597867012023926,
0.20569102466106415,
-0.3679756820201874,
0.8309422731399536,
0.31984463334083557,
0.17651472985744476,
0.02566934935748577,
-0.06470829993486404,
-0.3223007619380951,
-0.570277750492096,
-0.7072743773460388,
-0.5393589735031128,
0.3547838628292084,
0.26059117913246155,
0.5831431746482849,
0.6255638599395752,
0.5087502598762512,
0.4069988429546356,
-0.02231799252331257,
-0.23158471286296844,
-0.500099241733551,
0.2406618893146515,
0.14436715841293335,
0.02745259553194046,
-1.0800670385360718,
-0.3391711711883545,
0.7854940891265869,
0.979080319404602,
-0.5322557687759399,
-0.27587077021598816,
0.13598120212554932,
0.8505321741104126,
-0.3201267123222351,
0.00412443233653903,
-0.3391477167606354,
-0.011278648860752583,
-0.056238703429698944,
-0.06679386645555496,
-0.1398800015449524,
-0.1795923262834549,
-0.23135076463222504,
-0.5422585010528564,
0.2913537323474884,
-0.1727953553199768,
0.3827075958251953,
0.4327561557292938,
-0.06289715319871902,
-0.09207339584827423,
-0.949089765548706,
0.47030964493751526,
-0.7539616227149963,
0.5088961720466614,
0.5579892992973328,
0.42984333634376526,
-0.1699625849723816,
-0.830325722694397,
-0.6625458002090454,
-0.027768880128860474,
-0.17133186757564545,
0.15359298884868622,
-0.5071818232536316,
0.42466387152671814,
0.19702869653701782,
0.5811122059822083,
-0.8737172484397888,
0.07499247789382935,
-0.6134682297706604,
-0.1876107156276703,
0.786640465259552,
0.08564456552267075,
0.3936295211315155,
-0.44371968507766724,
-0.07980459928512573,
-0.08941132575273514,
-0.4744094908237457,
-0.1432899683713913,
0.26005038619041443,
0.2752476930618286,
0.06477418541908264,
0.3454018831253052,
-0.4334447681903839,
0.6855101585388184,
0.43130967020988464,
-0.7113125920295715,
0.31886377930641174,
0.2367836982011795,
-0.3395138680934906,
0.6436034440994263,
0.4943866431713104,
0.19072209298610687,
-0.06118316575884819,
-0.6190727949142456,
-0.42268702387809753,
0.23520761728286743,
0.3301137685775757,
-0.600331723690033,
-0.49041175842285156,
-0.019639892503619194,
-0.36275485157966614,
-0.03478790447115898,
-0.03269395977258682,
-0.3458276391029358,
-0.13612233102321625,
-0.8721911907196045,
0.4921804666519165,
-0.5479338765144348,
-0.5827562212944031,
0.16811031103134155,
-0.03427344933152199,
0.06063162162899971,
-0.0021718440111726522,
-1.0606749057769775,
0.6989079117774963,
0.6215492486953735,
0.5582799315452576,
-0.4251801669597626,
-0.2040816992521286,
-0.5778894424438477,
0.16499459743499756,
-0.31878888607025146,
0.5954725742340088,
-0.0037547003012150526,
-0.5301235318183899,
-0.643454909324646,
0.18181554973125458,
-0.1333964318037033,
-0.7253313064575195,
0.43865376710891724,
-0.5033056139945984,
-0.316765159368515,
-0.3330399990081787,
-0.4686950743198395,
-0.17670565843582153,
-0.009529597125947475,
-0.5703397393226624,
0.8574856519699097,
0.2601953148841858,
-0.5722413063049316,
0.24657081067562103,
-0.38860613107681274,
-0.48506489396095276,
0.5150183439254761,
-0.22609487175941467,
-0.1263689398765564,
0.27591943740844727,
0.1670866459608078,
0.3576246500015259,
0.04723682254552841,
0.3679148256778717,
-0.0365588515996933,
-0.29639706015586853,
0.11342046409845352,
-0.5768707394599915,
0.6112449765205383,
0.337103933095932,
-0.21605996787548065,
0.044897813349962234,
-1.1169075965881348,
-0.059380967170000076,
-0.17478078603744507,
-0.23477803170681,
-0.5525672435760498,
-0.13532106578350067,
-0.15744549036026,
-0.04716969281435013,
-0.17633594572544098,
-0.8677647709846497,
0.03264618664979935,
-0.3965928256511688,
0.4635588228702545,
0.490967333316803,
-0.12139611691236496,
0.6439344882965088,
-0.4654809236526489,
0.43695688247680664,
-0.25912022590637207,
-0.22345900535583496,
0.35628193616867065,
-0.17146140336990356,
-0.5280776023864746,
-0.6910964250564575,
0.20937089622020721,
0.20949704945087433,
-0.9015535712242126,
0.6589934229850769,
-0.7077385187149048,
-0.1549680233001709,
-0.667360782623291,
-0.38418048620224,
0.1508229672908783,
0.8500734567642212,
0.34348857402801514,
-0.5111076235771179,
-0.7278534770011902,
-0.5936896800994873,
0.5041608810424805,
-0.21049366891384125,
-0.25875207781791687,
0.07537778466939926,
0.12270000576972961,
-0.09609190374612808,
0.9365270733833313,
-0.2389613538980484,
-0.4626304805278778,
-0.40236416459083557,
-0.0261518731713295,
0.041822727769613266,
0.44800832867622375,
0.2758747637271881,
-0.47028326988220215,
-0.4808077812194824,
0.0029905380215495825,
-0.7999753952026367,
-0.07125281542539597,
0.21443328261375427,
0.4084503650665283,
0.23988991975784302,
0.6402357816696167,
-0.30392107367515564,
0.6220551133155823,
0.7064841985702515,
-0.032113492488861084,
0.3883020579814911,
-0.5734772682189941,
0.30462977290153503,
-0.95081627368927,
0.03444436565041542,
-0.722150444984436,
-0.17939680814743042,
-0.9484426975250244,
-0.3648220896720886,
-0.2055215835571289,
-0.3848421573638916,
0.04681990295648575,
0.1332630217075348,
-0.42812126874923706,
-0.4284035861492157,
-0.4821110963821411,
0.3303014934062958,
0.07899322360754013,
0.1519256979227066,
-0.17330561578273773,
0.8710929751396179,
0.7753116488456726,
-0.633939266204834,
0.6530107259750366,
0.3100273013114929,
-0.01344237755984068,
1.0138696432113647,
-0.7468849420547485,
0.39771631360054016,
-0.4686874747276306,
0.26758629083633423,
-0.8290166258811951,
-0.3205202519893646,
0.034719068557024,
-0.5446109771728516,
0.6908042430877686,
-0.05132688581943512,
0.044373419135808945,
-0.5296364426612854,
-0.05018613860011101,
0.27854135632514954,
0.4566332995891571,
-0.710203230381012,
0.5011142492294312,
0.6357260346412659,
-0.421059787273407,
-0.38380590081214905,
-0.802109956741333,
0.383208304643631,
-0.008081271313130856,
-0.571587324142456,
0.6530355215072632,
-0.041902679949998856,
-0.3073587119579315,
0.22528617084026337,
-0.16819815337657928,
0.00792697910219431,
-0.17344017326831818,
0.13575567305088043,
0.03473503515124321,
-0.36283981800079346,
0.2366236299276352,
0.11941809207201004,
-0.26274704933166504,
-0.23283390700817108,
0.006118793040513992,
0.6407424211502075,
-0.09012101590633392,
-0.5336323976516724,
-0.7248412370681763,
0.3209051787853241,
0.5455173850059509,
0.00017211475642398,
0.0011668020160868764,
0.3673652708530426,
-0.4232000410556793,
0.08821430802345276,
-0.6013583540916443,
-0.43018069863319397,
-0.44064316153526306,
0.42604291439056396,
-0.7149158716201782,
-0.6016063690185547,
0.17149552702903748,
0.22763891518115997,
-0.6878904104232788,
0.3906780183315277,
0.2730001211166382,
-0.0941593274474144,
0.8635989427566528,
0.34241563081741333,
-0.3528589904308319,
0.16784007847309113,
-0.3523714244365692,
0.17170840501785278,
-1.2556486129760742,
-0.17991456389427185,
-0.3657242953777313,
-0.4317915439605713,
-0.40431690216064453,
-0.03879885375499725,
0.14110523462295532,
0.15260863304138184,
-0.18227726221084595,
0.4435303807258606,
-0.8108858466148376,
0.19526131451129913,
0.43109673261642456,
0.1770976483821869,
0.4030115008354187,
0.2210049331188202,
0.2199535220861435,
-0.26852965354919434,
-0.8297298550605774,
-0.39665335416793823,
0.819746732711792,
0.062259022146463394,
0.9995442032814026,
0.0925530344247818,
0.9986624717712402,
0.33120211958885193,
0.1174180656671524,
-1.240261197090149,
0.4426684081554413,
-0.6289584040641785,
-0.26007020473480225,
-0.6662325263023376,
-0.5013580918312073,
-1.087813377380371,
0.11479800939559937,
0.11585898697376251,
-0.6593868136405945,
0.5623328685760498,
-0.31418272852897644,
-0.528331458568573,
0.6080060601234436,
-0.23552541434764862,
0.15301448106765747,
-0.020086321979761124,
0.15749981999397278,
-0.2013959139585495,
-0.5087898969650269,
0.07457298785448074,
0.036914318799972534,
0.10837730020284653,
-0.21862857043743134,
0.4202055037021637,
0.6620121002197266,
-0.4035816192626953,
0.5307690501213074,
-0.3744393587112427,
0.1527833342552185,
0.025106651708483696,
-0.04406550154089928,
0.1826741099357605,
-0.0857664942741394,
-0.23899075388908386,
-0.021117232739925385,
-0.05022640898823738,
-0.03158869966864586,
-0.6144694089889526,
0.7995339035987854,
-0.7522442936897278,
-0.45546481013298035,
-0.46621328592300415,
-0.7136767506599426,
-0.13488632440567017,
0.005886713042855263,
-0.019255200400948524,
0.7920013666152954,
-0.6647634506225586,
0.42565542459487915,
0.7017366886138916,
0.13064318895339966,
0.6808574795722961,
0.41893133521080017,
-0.024302953854203224,
-0.8303423523902893,
0.9767812490463257,
0.2446935623884201,
0.25498414039611816,
0.18410727381706238,
0.08593293279409409,
-0.222793310880661,
-0.5996275544166565,
-0.6005205512046814,
0.17273376882076263,
-0.4507315456867218,
-0.4850319027900696,
-0.6645122170448303,
-0.49531546235084534,
-0.6292173266410828,
-0.03889818117022514,
-0.2955630421638489,
-0.5857161283493042,
-0.39251622557640076,
-0.0668933093547821,
0.3480550944805145,
0.9482630491256714,
-0.6408230066299438,
0.3891299366950989,
-0.4776133894920349,
0.9002841114997864,
0.6646147966384888,
0.24299195408821106,
-0.23023991286754608,
-0.810514509677887,
0.13434970378875732,
0.14018824696540833,
-0.08860880881547928,
-0.46535560488700867,
0.675593376159668,
0.3843928873538971,
0.6261151432991028,
0.16427801549434662,
0.29676827788352966,
0.7183257341384888,
-0.5015601515769958,
0.44403648376464844,
0.39379414916038513,
-0.6736372709274292,
0.33489471673965454,
0.15001744031906128,
0.13021035492420197,
0.528979480266571,
0.08747991919517517,
-0.6739698052406311,
0.01816587708890438,
-0.4969659149646759,
-0.6054937839508057,
0.7922839522361755,
-0.028872523456811905,
-0.04700161889195442,
-0.08908063173294067,
0.5012224912643433,
-0.13247215747833252,
-0.1789085566997528,
-0.028532598167657852,
-0.3357314467430115,
-0.4282407760620117,
-0.1978510320186615,
-0.23455800116062164,
-0.11297624558210373,
-0.31027477979660034,
-0.4548110067844391,
0.7802550792694092,
-0.15911947190761566,
0.21146105229854584,
0.5400623679161072,
-0.3006168305873871,
-0.07148142158985138,
0.3969305157661438,
0.2868770956993103,
0.3874775171279907,
-0.19791613519191742,
0.19254370033740997,
0.24424266815185547,
-0.8838062882423401,
0.5136091113090515,
0.45694589614868164,
-0.3989265263080597,
0.1456604152917862,
-0.11962408572435379,
1.0274745225906372,
-0.022825995460152626,
0.08123723417520523,
0.5621603727340698,
-0.2134161740541458,
-0.29713091254234314,
0.02967163734138012,
-0.2582206130027771,
0.018676938489079475,
0.1812441051006317,
0.5233355164527893,
0.07409331947565079,
0.322709321975708,
-0.3415605127811432,
0.470145046710968,
0.2644302248954773,
-0.608664333820343,
-0.6246594190597534,
0.4886901378631592,
-0.011934870854020119,
-0.5271534323692322,
0.41699519753456116,
-0.3732605576515198,
-0.18583549559116364,
0.38269197940826416,
0.8426031470298767,
0.9857341051101685,
-0.6251564621925354,
0.3724059462547302,
0.3756546378135681,
0.03760203719139099,
-0.16175514459609985,
0.34384942054748535,
0.04367008060216904,
-0.6625721454620361,
-0.40794530510902405,
-0.7330777049064636,
-0.15023191273212433,
0.047172967344522476,
-0.9902110695838928,
0.012156989425420761,
-0.1366203874349594,
-0.15429262816905975,
0.03034050203859806,
-0.15516799688339233,
-0.17697761952877045,
0.40799999237060547,
-0.012265432626008987,
0.3810296952724457,
-0.32421061396598816,
1.3065123558044434,
0.5316296815872192,
-0.38953420519828796,
-0.664613664150238,
0.05404040962457657,
-0.09034311771392822,
-0.5778284668922424,
0.6711924076080322,
-0.34896421432495117,
-0.4862613379955292,
0.39908525347709656,
0.11474310606718063,
-0.934975802898407,
1.3305007219314575,
0.4658263027667999,
-0.6497660279273987,
0.151796355843544,
0.20537017285823822,
0.528237521648407,
-0.2593268156051636,
-0.4466584622859955,
0.7897114157676697,
0.229254350066185,
0.13020947575569153,
-1.0229488611221313,
0.0819934830069542,
0.22335097193717957,
0.25550130009651184,
0.03568415343761444,
-0.10412535816431046,
0.5973148345947266,
-0.08330467343330383,
-0.2675175070762634,
0.20309092104434967,
0.5534458160400391,
0.13567179441452026,
0.1927776038646698,
0.5380541682243347,
0.6861957907676697,
0.9620601534843445,
-0.14105358719825745,
0.6695056557655334,
-0.3508871793746948,
0.14759279787540436,
0.875468373298645,
-0.16816097497940063,
0.6754556894302368,
0.572067379951477,
-0.28086328506469727,
0.3154734969139099,
-0.14234589040279388,
0.4406203627586365,
0.6595011353492737,
0.31464481353759766,
-0.6960744261741638,
0.2909546494483948,
-0.13325302302837372,
-0.5826942324638367,
0.7874788641929626,
0.33811628818511963,
0.09659355878829956,
0.022295787930488586,
0.3158594071865082,
-0.15545324981212616,
0.16820287704467773,
-0.40540236234664917,
1.2720943689346313,
0.01997644640505314,
-0.3103698194026947,
0.8575034141540527,
-0.26125746965408325,
0.7081781029701233,
-0.6234607100486755,
0.29020366072654724,
-0.44043681025505066,
0.3126676678657532,
-0.33859604597091675,
-0.3401701748371124,
0.74654620885849,
-0.38728824257850647,
-0.11920195817947388,
-0.23911379277706146,
0.9294928908348083,
-0.35029226541519165,
-0.32139551639556885,
0.2737337350845337,
0.4325239956378937,
0.25231581926345825,
-0.1540762186050415,
-0.2401866316795349,
0.08903071284294128,
-0.13377788662910461,
-0.025528373196721077,
0.41014939546585083,
0.5066527724266052,
0.289778470993042,
0.1913968026638031,
0.4521302878856659,
0.2835626006126404,
-0.168405219912529,
0.43971189856529236,
0.9934946298599243,
-0.47561389207839966,
-0.06256269663572311,
-0.3289514183998108,
0.23276975750923157,
-0.06036870554089546,
0.032094310969114304,
0.4039776623249054,
0.49244582653045654,
0.7041828036308289,
0.11975284665822983,
0.7650284171104431,
-0.3505801260471344,
0.606877326965332,
-0.19225601851940155,
1.0397223234176636,
-0.3777328133583069,
0.10253657400608063,
-0.20877252519130707,
-0.6274492144584656,
-0.4740501046180725,
0.7571093440055847,
-0.13467572629451752,
-0.10607126355171204,
0.5929654836654663,
1.0253829956054688,
-0.19223660230636597,
-0.10264770686626434,
0.9229087829589844,
0.1102331355214119,
0.01095008198171854,
-0.07621297985315323,
0.4882362484931946,
-0.5750664472579956,
0.543643593788147,
-0.49439510703086853,
-0.647834062576294,
0.037359390407800674,
-0.4137342870235443,
-0.2699457108974457,
-0.599811851978302,
-0.25207656621932983,
-0.3164566159248352,
0.37096652388572693,
0.7382510900497437,
0.784053385257721,
-0.9777319431304932,
-0.4540862441062927,
-0.14002035558223724,
-0.1917303502559662,
-0.3865199387073517,
-0.1888820379972458,
0.5448471307754517,
-0.4257870614528656,
-0.4534275233745575,
1.0158761739730835,
0.505587637424469,
0.11029266566038132,
-0.2973307967185974,
-0.43287038803100586,
0.10847371071577072,
-0.18004333972930908,
0.7442172169685364,
0.3378406763076782,
-0.6454905867576599,
-0.38821178674697876,
0.28363317251205444,
-0.1667267084121704,
0.32552945613861084,
0.7375051975250244,
-0.8589284420013428,
0.6382544636726379,
0.4805142283439636,
0.6117591261863708,
0.7794960141181946,
-0.11091803014278412,
0.3587161600589752,
-0.6567906141281128,
0.13040773570537567,
0.40546634793281555,
0.4767898917198181,
0.691177487373352,
-0.1083991751074791,
0.257632851600647,
0.3419226109981537,
-0.6440876722335815,
-0.6505106687545776,
0.31937384605407715,
-1.014682650566101,
-0.12985798716545105,
1.1053780317306519,
-0.18860118091106415,
0.05104062333703041,
-0.4461638331413269,
-0.5184158682823181,
0.37341704964637756,
-0.26445960998535156,
0.8280702829360962,
0.3182571530342102,
-0.2719756066799164,
0.06592713296413422,
-0.280426561832428,
0.4933907687664032,
-0.086732417345047,
-0.6338883638381958,
0.1359216570854187,
0.5010014772415161,
0.3629598915576935,
0.08623389154672623,
0.9845871329307556,
-0.23266734182834625,
0.05378974229097366,
0.33115822076797485,
0.25707972049713135,
0.029186300933361053,
-0.40256550908088684,
-0.7495132684707642,
0.03994493931531906,
-0.014344392344355583,
-0.27377304434776306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14656v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14656v1 | Scientific Large Language Models: A Survey on Biological & Chemical Domains | 2024-01-26T05:33:34 | 2024-01-26T05:33:34 | Qiang Zhang, Keyang Ding, Tianwen Lyv, Xinda Wang, Qingyu Yin, Yiwen Zhang, Jing Yu, Yuhao Wang, Xiaotong Li, Zhuoyi Xiang, Xiang Zhuang, Zeyuan Wang, Ming Qin, Mengyao Zhang, Jinlu Zhang, Jiyu Cui, Renjun Xu, Hongyang Chen, Xiaohui Fan, Huabin Xing, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as a transformative power in
enhancing natural language comprehension, representing a significant stride
toward artificial general intelligence. The application of LLMs extends beyond
conventional linguistic boundaries, encompassing specialized linguistic systems
developed within various scientific disciplines. This growing interest has led
to the advent of scientific LLMs, a novel subclass specifically engineered for
facilitating scientific discovery. As a burgeoning area in the community of AI
for Science, scientific LLMs warrant comprehensive exploration. However, a
systematic and up-to-date survey introducing them is currently lacking. In this
paper, we endeavor to methodically delineate the concept of "scientific
language", whilst providing a thorough review of the latest advancements in
scientific LLMs. Given the expansive realm of scientific disciplines, our
analysis adopts a focused lens, concentrating on the biological and chemical
domains. This includes an in-depth examination of LLMs for textual knowledge,
small molecules, macromolecular proteins, genomic sequences, and their
combinations, analyzing them in terms of model architectures, capabilities,
datasets, and evaluation. Finally, we critically examine the prevailing
challenges and point out promising research directions along with the advances
of LLMs. By offering a comprehensive overview of technical developments in this
field, this survey aspires to be an invaluable resource for researchers
navigating the intricate landscape of scientific LLMs. | [
-0.30470794439315796,
-0.8706822395324707,
0.849628746509552,
0.13281822204589844,
0.04257625713944435,
0.5528278350830078,
-0.5289921164512634,
-0.6330775618553162,
0.2642933428287506,
0.5178464651107788,
-0.3886181116104126,
-0.6562137603759766,
-0.8229328989982605,
0.510631799697876,
-0.2880466878414154,
0.7836425304412842,
0.16560594737529755,
0.36947157979011536,
-0.6022697687149048,
-0.03819561377167702,
0.1694970577955246,
-0.4796968102455139,
-0.3932611048221588,
-0.6005567908287048,
0.727389395236969,
-0.02201807126402855,
0.44300577044487,
0.5531637668609619,
0.7789509296417236,
0.4065437912940979,
-0.4995592534542084,
0.2912897765636444,
-0.27036088705062866,
0.2569901943206787,
-0.3779575228691101,
-0.56806880235672,
-0.5804359316825867,
-0.025202354416251183,
0.8170673251152039,
1.2455072402954102,
0.25058338046073914,
0.038740821182727814,
-0.2068725824356079,
0.559087872505188,
-0.2496538609266281,
0.4263763427734375,
-0.5947146415710449,
0.1365172266960144,
-0.33309197425842285,
-0.1843441277742386,
-0.2678244709968567,
-0.06129106506705284,
0.3918607831001282,
-0.4970073699951172,
0.10764103382825851,
0.1678035408258438,
0.25690802931785583,
0.1657683104276657,
-0.6259353756904602,
-0.26173827052116394,
-0.7589943408966064,
0.9143770933151245,
-0.7781941294670105,
0.6063282489776611,
0.09559658169746399,
0.14232976734638214,
-0.5937607288360596,
-0.8836876749992371,
-0.5453657507896423,
-0.7730242609977722,
0.2615577280521393,
-0.03936704993247986,
-0.2291794866323471,
0.24071663618087769,
-0.05181329324841499,
0.31299588084220886,
-0.6913375854492188,
0.3051601052284241,
-0.5159269571304321,
-0.08876798301935196,
0.6568652391433716,
0.24878501892089844,
0.40259993076324463,
0.0451437309384346,
-0.054950591176748276,
0.2585148215293884,
-0.8429631590843201,
-0.41810116171836853,
-0.08945879340171814,
0.29728513956069946,
0.03372664749622345,
0.8745049834251404,
-0.022360138595104218,
0.5344324111938477,
-0.44317513704299927,
-0.1696007251739502,
0.09130974113941193,
-0.582425057888031,
-0.173568993806839,
-0.009632718749344349,
0.9938923716545105,
0.04496414214372635,
0.3049291968345642,
-0.014427708461880684,
0.03608643636107445,
0.0265505313873291,
0.02506645955145359,
-0.7379977107048035,
-0.08519457280635834,
0.29375144839286804,
-0.2926872968673706,
-0.12472138553857803,
-0.3087334930896759,
-0.6971386671066284,
-0.5281797051429749,
-0.37768954038619995,
-0.23840561509132385,
-0.2642982602119446,
-0.07804244011640549,
0.024620698764920235,
0.021231213584542274,
-0.10560515522956848,
0.25223517417907715,
-0.8387355208396912,
0.3729241192340851,
0.8739804029464722,
0.9103227853775024,
-0.34238362312316895,
-0.14543844759464264,
0.09633383899927139,
0.277619332075119,
-0.2973021864891052,
0.8248686790466309,
-0.7497075200080872,
-0.6163206696510315,
-0.021909328177571297,
-0.054721347987651825,
0.109205462038517,
-0.6545909643173218,
0.15595680475234985,
-0.7822815179824829,
-0.07836460322141647,
-0.25440680980682373,
-0.5799908638000488,
-0.14728963375091553,
0.1473490595817566,
-0.480306476354599,
0.6744431257247925,
-0.0839196965098381,
-0.4727802872657776,
0.18221503496170044,
-0.8465356826782227,
-0.2879123389720917,
0.39454951882362366,
-0.33314135670661926,
-0.01730760559439659,
0.11662447452545166,
-0.24163727462291718,
0.42115965485572815,
-0.762127697467804,
0.5386465191841125,
-0.48700541257858276,
0.011285620741546154,
0.53102707862854,
-0.014647115021944046,
0.42544999718666077,
0.32544654607772827,
-0.054077357053756714,
0.37589704990386963,
-0.6787581443786621,
0.002417567651718855,
0.025593550875782967,
-0.17416152358055115,
-0.38531070947647095,
0.17927126586437225,
0.007457772735506296,
-0.028446214273571968,
0.38609302043914795,
-0.6828216314315796,
0.5098272562026978,
-0.4969892203807831,
1.0053151845932007,
0.5310778617858887,
-0.012489890679717064,
0.6346178650856018,
0.010661100968718529,
0.34886792302131653,
-0.21787817776203156,
0.07916194945573807,
-0.033541202545166016,
-0.5457433462142944,
-0.33311551809310913,
-0.4876207113265991,
0.22369027137756348,
0.4127003848552704,
-0.44424712657928467,
0.40148237347602844,
-0.28086426854133606,
-0.6052690744400024,
-0.27688196301460266,
0.2571101188659668,
0.2324732095003128,
0.14358936250209808,
0.3611087203025818,
-0.08120233565568924,
-0.4680117964744568,
-0.9174093008041382,
-0.14753946661949158,
-0.20137947797775269,
-0.16047349572181702,
0.43634727597236633,
0.8262472152709961,
-0.7454544305801392,
0.8445237874984741,
-0.33632078766822815,
-0.06779341399669647,
-0.17424501478672028,
-0.002132103778421879,
0.1700471043586731,
0.08596602827310562,
0.3407750129699707,
-0.6373650431632996,
-0.345596581697464,
0.2077866643667221,
-0.8835688233375549,
-0.18221576511859894,
0.43231943249702454,
0.2146981805562973,
0.11401765793561935,
0.5921663045883179,
-0.8422392010688782,
-0.08731511235237122,
0.4351622462272644,
-0.18176716566085815,
0.5264373421669006,
-0.06580360233783722,
-0.056484390050172806,
-0.694290041923523,
0.17355792224407196,
0.23442426323890686,
0.09095229208469391,
-0.8009138703346252,
0.13373874127864838,
-0.15507608652114868,
0.19574859738349915,
-0.4331887364387512,
0.8317615389823914,
-0.6578742861747742,
-0.07634951174259186,
-0.5255093574523926,
0.1278245896100998,
-0.25229743123054504,
0.03356790915131569,
0.15938404202461243,
0.4687127470970154,
0.5525623559951782,
-0.5724456310272217,
0.5027074813842773,
0.30858537554740906,
-0.28602850437164307,
0.09173136204481125,
-0.8117831945419312,
-0.0634007602930069,
-0.2767702341079712,
0.5140933990478516,
-0.7797215580940247,
-0.40353935956954956,
0.18340656161308289,
-0.3220701813697815,
0.33226534724235535,
0.1104290708899498,
-0.5437337160110474,
-0.4436104893684387,
-0.10606995224952698,
0.554213285446167,
0.3876436948776245,
-0.08069784194231033,
0.3491221070289612,
0.5779091715812683,
-0.6991838812828064,
-0.29084208607673645,
-0.5782833695411682,
0.23994645476341248,
-0.00233832816593349,
-0.6396046280860901,
0.3644484579563141,
-0.14620648324489594,
-0.7203505635261536,
-0.09233406186103821,
-0.19014595448970795,
-0.011290020309388638,
-0.1890919804573059,
-0.018164757639169693,
0.36141517758369446,
-0.3598897159099579,
0.22356709837913513,
-0.06834898144006729,
0.1851121038198471,
0.38458025455474854,
-0.2886824309825897,
0.49012890458106995,
-0.14861184358596802,
-0.12722907960414886,
-0.07572624087333679,
0.3698267936706543,
0.9300282597541809,
-0.18294928967952728,
0.5632115006446838,
0.1249983087182045,
-0.3539668023586273,
-0.2657470703125,
-0.31024062633514404,
-0.28391116857528687,
-0.434095174074173,
0.7486783266067505,
-0.03743153065443039,
-1.0590007305145264,
0.47267451882362366,
-0.383579820394516,
-0.1478976160287857,
0.44515302777290344,
0.6622475981712341,
-0.02680056355893612,
0.847244381904602,
0.767406165599823,
-0.07368729263544083,
0.22515806555747986,
-0.15909811854362488,
0.40340450406074524,
-0.8204495906829834,
-0.7293346524238586,
-0.7019193768501282,
0.04813980683684349,
-0.47268158197402954,
-0.6068731546401978,
0.5729615688323975,
-0.29697468876838684,
-0.4715665578842163,
-0.06732790172100067,
-0.3347572982311249,
0.3150143027305603,
0.15831692516803741,
-0.2609512209892273,
0.2916812598705292,
-0.007397617679089308,
-0.20342977344989777,
0.04310791939496994,
-0.6976355314254761,
-0.8776090741157532,
0.9966334700584412,
0.6465847492218018,
0.8346117734909058,
-0.01328697893768549,
0.32177799940109253,
0.12559035420417786,
0.46209922432899475,
-0.9651756286621094,
0.7376465201377869,
-0.16335256397724152,
-0.6535338163375854,
-0.3573552966117859,
-0.5068402886390686,
-0.9151241779327393,
0.17743214964866638,
-0.09191812574863434,
-0.5944874286651611,
0.0490310862660408,
-0.1670132875442505,
-0.13020339608192444,
0.2873762249946594,
-0.2514480650424957,
0.5165812969207764,
-0.5225576758384705,
-0.3261115252971649,
-0.203311026096344,
-0.8642197847366333,
0.6308383941650391,
-0.44840195775032043,
0.4363177716732025,
-0.298325777053833,
-0.35631999373435974,
0.8086376190185547,
-0.37093308568000793,
0.881765604019165,
0.1809152066707611,
-0.4916042983531952,
0.2141985297203064,
-0.015701018273830414,
0.21678924560546875,
-0.02245868742465973,
0.04385223984718323,
0.4811423718929291,
0.2077225297689438,
-0.30517682433128357,
-0.3782244026660919,
0.8844820857048035,
-0.6032686233520508,
-0.591739296913147,
-0.7843310236930847,
-0.69427889585495,
-0.49049112200737,
0.24989382922649384,
-0.05391557887196541,
-0.036805570125579834,
-0.27341267466545105,
0.1369672566652298,
0.9191388487815857,
-0.5229470729827881,
0.2584376335144043,
0.6403740644454956,
-0.4206319749355316,
-0.32753244042396545,
0.7393966317176819,
-0.10203444212675095,
0.296163946390152,
0.41528600454330444,
0.12955895066261292,
-0.5683550834655762,
-0.9328904747962952,
-0.005681576207280159,
0.607186496257782,
-0.48204055428504944,
-0.13755057752132416,
-0.7807965874671936,
-0.33704644441604614,
-0.5491525530815125,
0.011138999834656715,
-0.26789259910583496,
-0.19538100063800812,
-0.25402209162712097,
0.10619395971298218,
0.5348399877548218,
1.1092345714569092,
0.21981140971183777,
0.07491417229175568,
-0.9701019525527954,
0.3896416127681732,
-0.06578872352838516,
0.2784790098667145,
-0.12726272642612457,
-0.3527430593967438,
-0.07812056690454483,
0.1841295212507248,
-0.08404268324375153,
-0.7327104806900024,
0.6353320479393005,
0.41045674681663513,
0.791158139705658,
0.20829513669013977,
-0.34424594044685364,
0.360063374042511,
-0.7613059282302856,
0.9534016251564026,
0.21486002206802368,
-0.6057226061820984,
0.3468571603298187,
-0.4896794855594635,
0.20471078157424927,
0.214609295129776,
0.8228803277015686,
-0.5855517387390137,
-0.43117034435272217,
-0.23299390077590942,
-1.019031286239624,
0.1398898810148239,
-0.1243412047624588,
0.038434818387031555,
-0.1505800485610962,
0.37060225009918213,
0.04703071713447571,
0.3432069420814514,
-0.4377211630344391,
-0.29643741250038147,
0.18813654780387878,
-0.3197636902332306,
-0.2568585276603699,
-0.07136499881744385,
-0.28760966658592224,
-0.28912079334259033,
0.6484104990959167,
-0.12710800766944885,
0.18497689068317413,
0.15882521867752075,
-0.03868922218680382,
-0.11165674775838852,
0.4775593876838684,
0.7760430574417114,
0.6242573857307434,
-0.06975122541189194,
0.2823569178581238,
-0.07667940109968185,
-0.8271820545196533,
0.14849093556404114,
0.0661233440041542,
0.007047098595649004,
-0.21910527348518372,
0.5985599160194397,
0.36922919750213623,
0.05908582732081413,
-1.0276585817337036,
0.045714106410741806,
0.3246500492095947,
-0.28320321440696716,
-0.11404726654291153,
-0.08192043006420135,
0.19325651228427887,
0.49040699005126953,
0.5468735694885254,
0.018835358321666718,
0.10816819965839386,
-0.9075495600700378,
-0.018023129552602768,
0.7116114497184753,
-0.055514637380838394,
-0.454387903213501,
0.4972841441631317,
0.08930779993534088,
-0.08784177154302597,
0.48007896542549133,
0.10522910952568054,
-0.5690500140190125,
0.6117078065872192,
0.5330367088317871,
0.6679205894470215,
-0.17708176374435425,
0.020144736394286156,
0.03918281942605972,
0.20629163086414337,
0.1080961525440216,
0.21423637866973877,
0.2539936900138855,
-0.5810075402259827,
-0.4690684676170349,
-1.0086950063705444,
-0.3934977054595947,
0.32077866792678833,
0.01302927453070879,
-0.03773320093750954,
-0.5585500001907349,
-0.22913546860218048,
0.5473679304122925,
0.1687280684709549,
-0.19339098036289215,
-0.016842730343341827,
0.2881256639957428,
1.0954822301864624,
-0.6583447456359863,
0.7572727799415588,
0.8701640367507935,
-0.1945054829120636,
-0.17760635912418365,
-0.46734142303466797,
0.22709377110004425,
-0.6093974709510803,
1.1291993856430054,
-0.34330835938453674,
-0.15610431134700775,
-0.15061801671981812,
-0.8438751697540283,
-1.0585871934890747,
0.856206476688385,
0.14048300683498383,
-0.7507084608078003,
0.0356760136783123,
0.3953942060470581,
1.0416927337646484,
-0.42824509739875793,
0.14529351890087128,
0.6568616032600403,
0.7446709871292114,
0.20881380140781403,
-0.9211055636405945,
-0.004956078715622425,
-0.49140578508377075,
-0.05124710127711296,
0.08911734074354172,
-0.6808527708053589,
0.7081900238990784,
-0.1506129950284958,
-0.00029996977536939085,
0.4106467664241791,
0.6777915954589844,
0.5448729395866394,
0.5050023198127747,
-0.1697707325220108,
0.09537918120622635,
0.7192639112472534,
-0.06746553629636765,
0.8653707504272461,
-0.23818044364452362,
0.06559894233942032,
0.6941929459571838,
-0.7036646008491516,
0.7120848298072815,
0.651554524898529,
-0.4857505261898041,
0.28458234667778015,
0.7555315494537354,
-0.20249409973621368,
0.2136523425579071,
0.8270512223243713,
-0.6441860795021057,
-0.12495336681604385,
-0.33488044142723083,
-0.4480808973312378,
0.28333646059036255,
0.8447426557540894,
-0.4822922945022583,
-0.011273873969912529,
0.04854527860879898,
-0.13478000462055206,
0.07198560982942581,
-0.49341925978660583,
0.6184750199317932,
0.46177566051483154,
-0.5099641680717468,
0.40032780170440674,
0.16241905093193054,
0.6384173631668091,
-0.870664656162262,
-0.16486020386219025,
-0.16990168392658234,
-0.07947766035795212,
-0.20452681183815002,
-0.7562742829322815,
0.1349661648273468,
0.053596381098032,
-0.34448397159576416,
-0.060039520263671875,
0.7352273464202881,
-0.5006595849990845,
-0.3697013258934021,
0.19631557166576385,
0.4932461082935333,
0.2879646420478821,
0.2528868317604065,
-0.42778196930885315,
0.3099423050880432,
-0.3210909366607666,
-0.1749400496482849,
0.26770272850990295,
0.26515424251556396,
-0.26269909739494324,
0.9185025691986084,
0.6768695712089539,
0.3121059536933899,
0.15178565680980682,
0.004616776946932077,
0.7924978733062744,
-0.9958146214485168,
0.09258067607879639,
-0.8297187685966492,
0.05665650591254234,
0.1898602992296219,
0.0898553654551506,
0.8134795427322388,
0.5977118611335754,
0.6119394898414612,
-0.3415014147758484,
1.0868607759475708,
0.16354988515377045,
0.32276451587677,
-0.3888820707798004,
0.7990235686302185,
-0.40129607915878296,
0.375923752784729,
-0.25262799859046936,
-0.9512624740600586,
-0.6742011904716492,
0.298117071390152,
-0.3398779034614563,
0.22939705848693848,
0.8092082738876343,
0.6969804167747498,
0.07931048423051834,
0.17508409917354584,
0.1777200698852539,
0.6740033626556396,
0.3375580608844757,
0.3866502642631531,
1.1029369831085205,
0.029042230919003487,
-0.09203246235847473,
0.17568494379520416,
-0.22467993199825287,
-0.195745587348938,
-0.8643996119499207,
-0.8227061033248901,
-0.41203179955482483,
-0.31739404797554016,
0.016372686251997948,
0.07520195841789246,
1.0042438507080078,
0.535521924495697,
-0.7267957925796509,
-0.3784782588481903,
-0.16962914168834686,
-0.12838172912597656,
0.26087069511413574,
-0.149685800075531,
0.24778220057487488,
-0.20848135650157928,
-0.7801541686058044,
0.754776656627655,
0.5644098520278931,
0.21755370497703552,
-0.5840577483177185,
-0.05921486020088196,
-0.31358471512794495,
0.4335508644580841,
1.018402338027954,
0.6559040546417236,
-0.9276397228240967,
0.06964661180973053,
0.3462444841861725,
-0.2786228358745575,
-0.23657459020614624,
0.8563005328178406,
-0.5264961123466492,
0.08018151670694351,
0.5282803177833557,
0.6673946380615234,
0.2539871335029602,
-0.5618245005607605,
0.5815644264221191,
-0.3355458974838257,
-0.2121419906616211,
0.5792304873466492,
0.36797529458999634,
0.2912144064903259,
-0.2275819182395935,
0.44495683908462524,
0.364057332277298,
-0.6220752000808716,
-0.9746869802474976,
0.2497338205575943,
-1.2798281908035278,
-0.5548937916755676,
1.3055768013000488,
0.24699673056602478,
-0.4510095715522766,
-0.13294707238674164,
-0.0864032581448555,
0.09719524532556534,
-0.1228715032339096,
0.683884859085083,
0.6963266730308533,
-0.22304664552211761,
0.03048894554376602,
-0.5995434522628784,
0.4369141757488251,
0.37840941548347473,
-0.884657621383667,
0.08304879069328308,
0.6803409457206726,
0.28587839007377625,
0.2826053500175476,
0.38402441143989563,
-0.3714412450790405,
0.022570621222257614,
-0.3895651698112488,
0.022102728486061096,
0.019204329699277878,
-0.5776664018630981,
-0.38442400097846985,
0.17268718779087067,
0.14716582000255585,
0.5522899627685547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14654v1 | A Korean Legal Judgment Prediction Dataset for Insurance Disputes | 2024-01-26T05:26:27 | 2024-01-26T05:26:27 | Alice Saebom Kwak, Cheonkam Jeong, Ji Weon Lim, Byeongcheol Min | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces a Korean legal judgment prediction (LJP) dataset for
insurance disputes. Successful LJP models on insurance disputes can benefit
insurance companies and their customers. It can save both sides' time and money
by allowing them to predict how the result would come out if they proceed to
the dispute mediation process. As is often the case with low-resource
languages, there is a limitation on the amount of data available for this
specific task. To mitigate this issue, we investigate how one can achieve a
good performance despite the limitation in data. In our experiment, we
demonstrate that Sentence Transformer Fine-tuning (SetFit, Tunstall et al.,
2022) is a good alternative to standard fine-tuning when training data are
limited. The models fine-tuned with the SetFit approach on our data show
similar performance to the Korean LJP benchmark models (Hwang et al., 2022)
despite the much smaller data size. | [
-0.215998113155365,
-0.1480252891778946,
0.32818272709846497,
0.5231816172599792,
-0.11582611501216888,
-0.1976078599691391,
-0.1657547503709793,
-0.769124448299408,
0.0829022154211998,
0.977557361125946,
-0.2746066749095917,
-0.23559381067752838,
-0.4856381118297577,
-0.1557679921388626,
0.1962631344795227,
1.0734937191009521,
0.026218410581350327,
0.21074950695037842,
-0.04454854503273964,
-0.1644311398267746,
-0.8061336874961853,
0.018257606774568558,
-0.702846109867096,
-0.5552610754966736,
0.45031702518463135,
0.6498419642448425,
1.0287972688674927,
0.6910334229469299,
0.645561158657074,
0.2406829297542572,
-0.023413218557834625,
0.009028072468936443,
-0.3941020667552948,
0.17587332427501678,
-0.1752607375383377,
-0.7240455150604248,
-0.05996515974402428,
-0.06005307286977768,
0.4257639944553375,
0.6371938586235046,
-0.19726109504699707,
0.06067580357193947,
-0.18314069509506226,
1.0995748043060303,
-0.6273489594459534,
0.30177760124206543,
-0.5365713238716125,
0.6651188731193542,
0.018988318741321564,
-0.12058987468481064,
-0.5768833160400391,
-0.2366022914648056,
0.26561692357063293,
-0.5091675519943237,
0.2527628540992737,
0.4312853217124939,
1.202271580696106,
0.7400059103965759,
-0.7818113565444946,
0.05352647975087166,
-0.7359704375267029,
0.41751131415367126,
-0.5902666449546814,
0.2403673380613327,
0.48766857385635376,
0.735964298248291,
-0.2700387239456177,
-0.6670073866844177,
-0.3690364956855774,
-0.3873016834259033,
-0.3318903148174286,
0.576698899269104,
-0.2857634127140045,
0.3875933587551117,
0.5381618738174438,
0.2706732749938965,
-0.3904935419559479,
0.32278648018836975,
-0.3898347318172455,
-0.19840669631958008,
0.9435917735099792,
0.24687644839286804,
0.06854528933763504,
-0.6574633121490479,
0.02256806194782257,
-0.03733270987868309,
-0.7834067940711975,
0.31192320585250854,
0.4295256733894348,
0.38436639308929443,
0.05237022042274475,
0.6952657103538513,
-0.5810787677764893,
0.5752701163291931,
0.09397073835134506,
-0.312870055437088,
0.17963019013404846,
0.19361424446105957,
-0.42790573835372925,
0.45093175768852234,
0.723797082901001,
0.7672532796859741,
0.27261555194854736,
-0.1406344771385193,
-0.14449316263198853,
-0.012122608721256256,
0.27701854705810547,
-0.8897931575775146,
-0.17776362597942352,
0.10636718571186066,
-0.7758108377456665,
-0.3290097117424011,
-0.06618816405534744,
-0.7859043478965759,
-0.7524164915084839,
-0.4255034327507019,
0.06989111006259918,
-0.23105961084365845,
-0.04377998039126396,
0.4989204406738281,
-0.011695314198732376,
-0.26526737213134766,
0.09859049320220947,
-0.4437882602214813,
0.19250129163265228,
0.37551575899124146,
0.5057875514030457,
0.09787534922361374,
0.2869025766849518,
-0.5658553242683411,
-0.00597793934866786,
-0.38105344772338867,
0.6361753940582275,
-0.3285834789276123,
-0.06968045234680176,
0.17881260812282562,
0.07883429527282715,
-0.06120598316192627,
-0.7081958055496216,
1.109596848487854,
-0.4979344606399536,
0.05192258581519127,
0.1086912676692009,
-0.6176694631576538,
-0.0663197711110115,
0.12153767049312592,
-1.074706792831421,
0.38069236278533936,
0.22000016272068024,
-0.8126230835914612,
0.934752881526947,
-0.6070993542671204,
-0.5619843006134033,
0.2041056901216507,
-0.23988135159015656,
-0.8634611368179321,
0.2527046203613281,
0.17633786797523499,
0.5263649821281433,
-0.29798099398612976,
0.241176038980484,
-0.389587938785553,
-0.20081204175949097,
-0.0028196298517286777,
-0.427486389875412,
0.6066799759864807,
0.45797163248062134,
0.11809693276882172,
-0.17557568848133087,
-1.0314394235610962,
0.19576537609100342,
0.1765766441822052,
-0.34323564171791077,
-0.5244209170341492,
0.08244853466749191,
-0.14891867339611053,
0.3887166678905487,
-0.026477666571736336,
-0.7578443288803101,
0.3121758699417114,
-0.717955470085144,
0.06137462705373764,
0.4802551567554474,
0.05746318772435188,
0.3223167061805725,
-0.3048694431781769,
0.7039321660995483,
0.22010737657546997,
-0.007086727302521467,
0.16042670607566833,
-0.21910889446735382,
-0.780681848526001,
0.171516552567482,
0.6900733113288879,
0.6660169959068298,
-0.9913830757141113,
0.03221151977777481,
-0.5132734179496765,
-0.5234614014625549,
-0.8867641091346741,
-0.3038681149482727,
0.30749377608299255,
0.5335166454315186,
0.2758355140686035,
0.19632430374622345,
-0.7801133394241333,
-1.2116256952285767,
-0.7221491932868958,
0.03206072375178337,
-0.07941074669361115,
0.5655751824378967,
0.1964053362607956,
0.2438633143901825,
0.9515388011932373,
-0.6681204438209534,
-0.4573068618774414,
-0.37699010968208313,
0.14125314354896545,
0.6449577212333679,
0.2927704155445099,
0.524199366569519,
-0.9851736426353455,
-0.8370418548583984,
0.3687485158443451,
-0.5770148634910583,
-0.17697416245937347,
-0.40935105085372925,
0.2286137491464615,
0.03863225504755974,
0.5083754658699036,
-0.32954058051109314,
0.5559559464454651,
0.4193286597728729,
-0.7194284796714783,
0.4834537208080292,
-0.14323705434799194,
0.14616696536540985,
-1.168439269065857,
-0.38828206062316895,
0.15614788234233856,
-0.6885932683944702,
-0.5213733315467834,
-0.18095055222511292,
0.20997749269008636,
0.0422949343919754,
-0.4210638105869293,
0.27095550298690796,
-0.15697768330574036,
0.09281402081251144,
-0.37432146072387695,
-0.29342058300971985,
-0.26201173663139343,
0.2690024673938751,
-0.07253009080886841,
0.8167154788970947,
0.1530664563179016,
-0.609235405921936,
0.3524872064590454,
0.4353690445423126,
-0.661370575428009,
0.4944935142993927,
-0.6617093682289124,
-0.3699020445346832,
-0.2814291715621948,
0.11015326529741287,
-0.44002875685691833,
-0.42597270011901855,
0.09531833976507187,
0.005746739450842142,
0.2873695492744446,
-0.5361078977584839,
-0.3090015649795532,
-0.6171510815620422,
0.026766153052449226,
0.12604530155658722,
0.3366582989692688,
-0.5763505697250366,
0.6474679112434387,
0.3375038504600525,
-0.09642265737056732,
-0.9445057511329651,
-0.6959222555160522,
0.1384040266275406,
-0.5053538084030151,
-0.658488392829895,
0.5785499215126038,
0.4976421594619751,
-0.10056661814451218,
0.1789969801902771,
0.07014613598585129,
0.18741773068904877,
-0.19175651669502258,
0.5820773243904114,
0.09477873891592026,
-0.3408145606517792,
0.41197094321250916,
0.17663617432117462,
-0.35652557015419006,
0.07130670547485352,
0.020852990448474884,
0.4899377226829529,
-0.19063609838485718,
-0.1848091185092926,
-0.3147338032722473,
0.05085895583033562,
0.06026838347315788,
0.20040000975131989,
0.6130713820457458,
-0.013865931890904903,
-0.3220055401325226,
-0.08226286619901657,
-0.5197378396987915,
0.44715452194213867,
-0.48036664724349976,
0.46424123644828796,
-0.67473965883255,
-0.9151963591575623,
0.5473436117172241,
-0.43393245339393616,
-0.0705064907670021,
0.7341229915618896,
0.43075981736183167,
0.01557844690978527,
1.001803994178772,
0.7949612140655518,
-0.3679030239582062,
0.4542059302330017,
0.13759776949882507,
0.3382372260093689,
-0.40894171595573425,
0.05103066936135292,
-0.5832712650299072,
-0.3489740192890167,
-1.0010552406311035,
0.12274095416069031,
0.4985732436180115,
0.0949355885386467,
-0.2459525465965271,
0.5731953978538513,
-0.2506883144378662,
0.9883773326873779,
0.3968983292579651,
0.26734599471092224,
0.4857547879219055,
-0.01573248580098152,
-0.06250868737697601,
-0.30251067876815796,
-0.7741193771362305,
-0.3283969461917877,
0.9335215091705322,
0.488214373588562,
0.6668797731399536,
-0.03520046919584274,
0.5791481733322144,
0.2302550971508026,
0.17739766836166382,
-0.6328944563865662,
0.3754937946796417,
-0.425097793340683,
-0.3930085301399231,
-0.25568437576293945,
-0.7266297340393066,
-1.200090765953064,
0.16087600588798523,
-0.3351799249649048,
-0.5702149271965027,
0.2988318204879761,
0.10379371792078018,
-0.6463251709938049,
0.04888511821627617,
-0.44309473037719727,
0.6582012176513672,
0.13800112903118134,
-0.20366521179676056,
-0.2895406484603882,
-0.6965044736862183,
0.4401794672012329,
0.04106129705905914,
-0.2730919122695923,
-0.33539703488349915,
0.339826375246048,
0.6621018052101135,
-0.5363720059394836,
0.5094555616378784,
-0.3066900968551636,
0.05727981775999069,
0.29423558712005615,
0.013057815842330456,
0.6660640835762024,
0.30171504616737366,
-0.13845635950565338,
-0.29798927903175354,
0.16516654193401337,
-0.11439324170351028,
-0.6121705770492554,
0.39865314960479736,
-0.5365214943885803,
-0.2073134034872055,
-0.31833580136299133,
-0.7334002256393433,
-0.5647497177124023,
0.266952246427536,
0.33446305990219116,
-0.24390371143817902,
-0.07152131199836731,
0.23598188161849976,
0.4039291739463806,
-0.4004168212413788,
0.4014708697795868,
0.7139387130737305,
-0.3174741566181183,
-0.34164494276046753,
0.9482452869415283,
0.23998962342739105,
0.05326882004737854,
0.06975683569908142,
0.2887915074825287,
-0.15598025918006897,
-0.30843105912208557,
-0.38771170377731323,
0.01419337559491396,
-0.7467504739761353,
-0.8420235514640808,
-0.4786980450153351,
-0.42694586515426636,
-0.10337969660758972,
0.23892880976200104,
-0.5962281823158264,
-0.7225141525268555,
0.24011266231536865,
-0.1450444757938385,
0.31403568387031555,
0.4859805405139923,
0.09604357182979584,
0.48819929361343384,
-0.6725732684135437,
0.35536065697669983,
-0.1560651659965515,
0.6919416189193726,
-0.5071227550506592,
-0.4739685654640198,
-0.39962995052337646,
-0.13227656483650208,
-0.3055533766746521,
-0.3270460367202759,
0.4414728581905365,
0.04072296991944313,
0.031254786998033524,
0.4328800141811371,
0.3782273530960083,
0.9136010408401489,
-0.8110911250114441,
0.47077277302742004,
0.2792232930660248,
-0.4587344229221344,
0.5474962592124939,
-0.16887599229812622,
0.02301524393260479,
0.8382978439331055,
0.2956567108631134,
-0.78945392370224,
-0.3111937344074249,
-0.6950523853302002,
-0.675656259059906,
0.6261066794395447,
-0.06350584328174591,
0.11957165598869324,
0.2410392016172409,
0.45578017830848694,
-0.019435426220297813,
0.16753710806369781,
-0.7289133071899414,
0.07585612684488297,
0.1135357990860939,
-0.2921837866306305,
0.25597989559173584,
-0.22621427476406097,
-0.09108708053827286,
-0.22787219285964966,
0.7027348279953003,
-0.14838358759880066,
0.1915680468082428,
-0.024444174021482468,
0.1736932098865509,
-0.4812081456184387,
0.25493499636650085,
0.38382747769355774,
0.31699657440185547,
-0.04460643231868744,
-0.16955550014972687,
0.16926558315753937,
-0.41546303033828735,
0.1705629825592041,
0.309493750333786,
-0.32184550166130066,
0.16199322044849396,
0.3148547112941742,
1.1181846857070923,
-0.22945158183574677,
-0.7224797010421753,
0.5972005128860474,
-0.16707603633403778,
-0.3030126392841339,
-0.4431823790073395,
0.12001483887434006,
-0.15995804965496063,
0.6114059686660767,
-0.05528012663125992,
0.2459295690059662,
0.3636089265346527,
0.009922608733177185,
0.18970714509487152,
0.1583654135465622,
-0.4305156171321869,
0.37967005372047424,
0.6366886496543884,
-0.14546886086463928,
0.06353825330734253,
0.5129103064537048,
-0.20787835121154785,
-0.3180773854255676,
0.6801662445068359,
0.5666957497596741,
0.5251132249832153,
-0.08758611977100372,
0.17154119908809662,
0.2331976443529129,
0.1187274381518364,
-0.461016982793808,
0.2512785494327545,
0.6218622326850891,
-0.9236807227134705,
-0.7130329012870789,
-0.5041690468788147,
-0.20193661749362946,
0.412511944770813,
-0.6655167937278748,
0.3548831045627594,
-0.44157740473747253,
-0.19041217863559723,
-0.03780249506235123,
0.14011980593204498,
-0.7458511590957642,
0.4073190689086914,
-0.17298489809036255,
0.9543883800506592,
-0.6175562739372253,
0.5001828074455261,
0.12354741990566254,
-0.5113776922225952,
-0.9934194087982178,
-0.027594465762376785,
-0.41752004623413086,
-0.6637685894966125,
0.6722750663757324,
0.2822067439556122,
0.19719190895557404,
-0.5033939480781555,
-0.4081338047981262,
-0.6542450785636902,
0.8194538950920105,
0.5982482433319092,
-1.0330429077148438,
0.009990745224058628,
0.5740334987640381,
0.6843613982200623,
-0.20974789559841156,
-0.3401256799697876,
0.7579291462898254,
0.33826613426208496,
-0.14238451421260834,
-0.9971038103103638,
0.022826099768280983,
-0.11395326256752014,
0.035109005868434906,
0.3304450213909149,
-0.7064308524131775,
0.5335636138916016,
0.016081372275948524,
-0.09813506156206131,
-0.10363955795764923,
1.0751820802688599,
-0.20716071128845215,
0.5354095697402954,
0.7118423581123352,
0.7402893900871277,
0.8018965125083923,
-0.24710234999656677,
1.3434747457504272,
-0.240609273314476,
0.40923553705215454,
1.4209481477737427,
-0.2493678480386734,
0.5661581754684448,
0.2779442071914673,
-0.35016849637031555,
0.09819172322750092,
0.5270626544952393,
-0.31620967388153076,
0.6023367643356323,
0.40031012892723083,
-0.09704555571079254,
-0.32135888934135437,
-0.39408835768699646,
-0.19777649641036987,
0.5178061723709106,
-0.11108717322349548,
-0.5240333676338196,
0.0768618956208229,
0.24333316087722778,
0.07626122981309891,
0.09795694053173065,
-0.46822914481163025,
0.7152584791183472,
0.11354400962591171,
-0.7102823853492737,
0.056857939809560776,
0.20638029277324677,
0.34119582176208496,
-0.22954726219177246,
0.023462750017642975,
-0.05842761695384979,
0.39013466238975525,
-0.35940584540367126,
-0.7924989461898804,
0.3934783935546875,
-0.3468151390552521,
-0.31758642196655273,
-0.12641827762126923,
1.1105244159698486,
-0.4080323576927185,
-0.6234572529792786,
0.13181506097316742,
0.23103538155555725,
-0.032701268792152405,
-0.05279211699962616,
-0.5628407001495361,
-0.548372745513916,
-0.01421801932156086,
-0.49631303548812866,
0.3584705889225006,
0.6001202464103699,
-0.19994381070137024,
0.7637763619422913,
0.19764897227287292,
0.4346165657043457,
-0.16061274707317352,
0.32011884450912476,
0.7747151851654053,
-0.5755656957626343,
-0.535068929195404,
-0.5889865756034851,
0.3939753472805023,
-0.47876277565956116,
-0.4199390113353729,
0.3052804172039032,
0.5018510222434998,
0.7745494842529297,
-0.23249471187591553,
0.85018390417099,
-0.08241664618253708,
0.904601514339447,
-0.8539454340934753,
0.7107157111167908,
-0.4764540493488312,
0.10102899372577667,
-0.17713101208209991,
-0.5470452308654785,
-0.4821877181529999,
0.6924872398376465,
-0.4707809090614319,
-0.0751378983259201,
0.3782028555870056,
0.49114978313446045,
-0.1856369972229004,
0.31871336698532104,
0.4443160593509674,
0.17798203229904175,
0.3566685616970062,
0.5234133005142212,
0.6388946771621704,
-0.584194004535675,
0.5064360499382019,
-0.44439858198165894,
0.17188268899917603,
-0.28179675340652466,
-0.9201614856719971,
-0.7760040163993835,
-0.054729163646698,
-0.10811717063188553,
-0.6474712491035461,
-0.1735130250453949,
1.011136531829834,
0.3566678762435913,
-0.7671574354171753,
0.05159343034029007,
-0.1605619639158249,
-0.16225634515285492,
-0.18402215838432312,
-0.21917824447155,
0.3629293143749237,
-0.49657362699508667,
-0.4036344289779663,
0.4247657060623169,
0.026776893064379692,
0.0025837160646915436,
0.2254214733839035,
-0.1931762546300888,
0.3313814401626587,
-0.09068736433982849,
0.39673760533332825,
0.211478129029274,
-0.3001944124698639,
-0.4684298634529114,
-0.5230425000190735,
-0.054711803793907166,
0.13383345305919647,
1.0593044757843018,
-0.5870110392570496,
0.2824471890926361,
0.22081831097602844,
0.9523327946662903,
0.5075548887252808,
-0.050640642642974854,
0.745089590549469,
-0.8776919841766357,
0.40976569056510925,
0.44813939929008484,
0.6144355535507202,
-0.09214672446250916,
-0.647596538066864,
1.0369008779525757,
-0.17680616676807404,
-0.6222406029701233,
-0.7030994296073914,
0.34821799397468567,
-0.7201960682868958,
-0.1941789835691452,
0.7872805595397949,
-0.16709715127944946,
0.06209724023938179,
-0.08233103156089783,
-0.32339927554130554,
0.27452951669692993,
-0.2852397859096527,
0.9305419921875,
0.9052819609642029,
-0.23129242658615112,
-0.22767838835716248,
-1.0551016330718994,
0.8905971050262451,
0.6338922381401062,
-0.7394567131996155,
0.20095621049404144,
0.443306565284729,
0.07307029515504837,
0.2807547450065613,
0.28991615772247314,
0.1914147138595581,
0.33915388584136963,
0.025834640488028526,
-0.25625884532928467,
-0.13792870938777924,
-0.4619500935077667,
-0.2737278342247009,
0.2749194800853729,
-0.1993706226348877,
0.013602254912257195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14640v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14640v1 | Benchmarking Large Language Models in Complex Question Answering Attribution using Knowledge Graphs | 2024-01-26T04:11:07 | 2024-01-26T04:11:07 | Nan Hu, Jiaoyan Chen, Yike Wu, Guilin Qi, Sheng Bi, Tongtong Wu, Jeff Z. Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL | The attribution of question answering is to provide citations for supporting
generated statements, and has attracted wide research attention. The current
methods for automatically evaluating the attribution, which are often based on
Large Language Models (LLMs), are still inadequate, particularly in recognizing
subtle differences between attributions, and complex relationships between
citations and statements. To compare these attribution evaluation methods and
develop new ones, we introduce a set of fine-grained categories (i.e.,
supportive, insufficient, contradictory and irrelevant) for measuring the
attribution, and develop a Complex Attributed Question Answering (CAQA)
benchmark by leveraging knowledge graphs (KGs) for automatically generating
attributions of different categories to question-answer pairs. Our analysis
reveals that existing evaluators perform poorly under fine-grained attribution
settings and exhibit weaknesses in complex citation-statement reasoning. Our
CAQA benchmark, validated with human annotations, emerges as a promising tool
for selecting and developing LLM attribution evaluators. | [
-0.3650006651878357,
-0.8053416609764099,
0.7627435326576233,
0.1808352917432785,
0.017400041222572327,
0.22463098168373108,
-0.048387520015239716,
-0.5195081233978271,
-0.19574899971485138,
0.19852742552757263,
-0.43339836597442627,
-0.16073501110076904,
-0.39314329624176025,
0.22432106733322144,
-0.24765878915786743,
0.6504461765289307,
-0.21190427243709564,
0.18643444776535034,
-0.8208452463150024,
-0.16016942262649536,
-0.31411126255989075,
-0.3736838102340698,
-0.8102815747261047,
-0.6583597660064697,
0.8798654675483704,
0.33424660563468933,
0.5654868483543396,
0.3428623080253601,
0.5552535057067871,
0.2084195911884308,
0.04965827241539955,
0.29884737730026245,
-0.2970941364765167,
0.10137581080198288,
-0.3237136900424957,
-0.49882030487060547,
-0.32745447754859924,
-0.04713614657521248,
0.6490834951400757,
0.8713146448135376,
0.13321834802627563,
0.5771149396896362,
-0.028545523062348366,
0.4439428150653839,
-1.0476535558700562,
0.3135925829410553,
-0.7009046673774719,
-0.1891765147447586,
-0.11461581289768219,
-0.23217704892158508,
-0.34219008684158325,
-1.0224392414093018,
0.03924404829740524,
-0.3938913643360138,
-0.09042172878980637,
0.23172681033611298,
0.6938327550888062,
0.2303118109703064,
-0.6206822395324707,
-0.4813791811466217,
-0.5711419582366943,
0.7975206971168518,
-0.7000051736831665,
0.1519167721271515,
0.3613288700580597,
0.6183561086654663,
-0.0942680612206459,
-0.7299994826316833,
-0.5651304125785828,
-0.3143826723098755,
-0.03894969820976257,
-0.036955539137125015,
-0.4307861924171448,
-0.22153340280056,
0.017864780500531197,
0.18531110882759094,
-0.5658684968948364,
0.14236441254615784,
-0.1876966506242752,
-0.30768877267837524,
0.5666540265083313,
0.18368779122829437,
0.09940801560878754,
-0.239658921957016,
-0.42669352889060974,
-0.2149856835603714,
-0.7876489162445068,
0.15780070424079895,
0.35599368810653687,
0.24831417202949524,
0.31643402576446533,
0.7293044924736023,
-0.3665768802165985,
0.6147874593734741,
-0.2928871810436249,
0.09367470443248749,
0.2008812129497528,
-0.06665564328432083,
-0.10112465918064117,
0.1922617256641388,
0.8458311557769775,
0.45031777024269104,
0.7197555899620056,
-0.41141417622566223,
-0.0790286511182785,
0.044388435781002045,
0.11350840330123901,
-0.800475001335144,
-0.22477123141288757,
0.026961715891957283,
-0.2784004211425781,
-0.3159013092517853,
-0.09073410928249359,
-0.4730796813964844,
-0.5600676536560059,
-0.09988021850585938,
0.4545567035675049,
-0.06062714383006096,
-0.0816609114408493,
-0.07496490329504013,
-0.14235328137874603,
0.3740869164466858,
0.320639044046402,
-0.27073007822036743,
0.4840266704559326,
0.4886130690574646,
0.5848381519317627,
-0.256572961807251,
-0.25877946615219116,
-0.8043009638786316,
0.2133655995130539,
-0.2458769679069519,
1.1425199508666992,
-0.5444856882095337,
0.0563119612634182,
0.07129765301942825,
-0.12348135560750961,
-0.08912529051303864,
-0.8947560787200928,
0.7869206070899963,
-0.6327149868011475,
-0.12514619529247284,
-0.5408695936203003,
-0.7241025567054749,
-0.17706811428070068,
0.6016124486923218,
-0.5970382690429688,
1.0824235677719116,
0.2284749150276184,
-0.578236997127533,
0.11768840998411179,
-0.5199713110923767,
-0.29781973361968994,
0.06786544620990753,
-0.22213570773601532,
-0.2920858860015869,
-0.1104496419429779,
0.09621712565422058,
0.49852946400642395,
-0.927480161190033,
0.5394730567932129,
-0.6276084780693054,
-0.15172861516475677,
0.6061006784439087,
-0.5269170999526978,
0.8093760013580322,
0.3183039426803589,
-0.1923830658197403,
0.07928887754678726,
-0.8624401688575745,
0.3368142247200012,
0.21201543509960175,
-0.4149249196052551,
-0.5004538893699646,
0.18061809241771698,
0.04702504724264145,
0.12403792887926102,
0.18982456624507904,
-0.6111962795257568,
0.11908846348524094,
-0.1252177655696869,
0.3560640215873718,
0.5458779335021973,
0.025949863716959953,
0.05753818154335022,
-0.13422474265098572,
0.6021428108215332,
-0.12956558167934418,
-0.21272395551204681,
0.2845517098903656,
-0.181966170668602,
-0.45722219347953796,
0.0077723050490021706,
0.27045565843582153,
0.5821736454963684,
-0.5966587066650391,
0.2156313955783844,
-0.35738277435302734,
-0.8109089136123657,
-0.3887145519256592,
0.10082918405532837,
0.6828407049179077,
0.6574803590774536,
0.3966442942619324,
-0.18274615705013275,
-0.3280496299266815,
-1.1636133193969727,
-0.7649245262145996,
-0.4526423513889313,
-0.1951293796300888,
0.4487015902996063,
0.5487802624702454,
0.11067202687263489,
1.0723185539245605,
-0.8077563047409058,
0.040368013083934784,
-0.12341489642858505,
0.3745307922363281,
-0.34955424070358276,
0.3912270665168762,
0.59166419506073,
-0.5743600130081177,
-0.3756956458091736,
-0.23769821226596832,
-0.689089298248291,
-0.37179967761039734,
0.17656151950359344,
-0.10197509080171585,
-0.26822754740715027,
0.6211615800857544,
-0.5890502333641052,
0.022280622273683548,
0.43885770440101624,
-0.5392096042633057,
0.787690281867981,
0.28537052869796753,
0.28608596324920654,
-0.8591414093971252,
0.36212629079818726,
0.07588150352239609,
-0.3997645676136017,
-0.412438303232193,
0.08151539415121078,
0.23877239227294922,
0.08252814412117004,
-0.4558785855770111,
0.7712609767913818,
-0.3313039243221283,
-0.19778509438037872,
0.10241293162107468,
0.3437516391277313,
0.24287059903144836,
0.44704627990722656,
-0.2814403474330902,
0.5719634294509888,
0.20084503293037415,
-0.4114486873149872,
0.6536459922790527,
0.1270674467086792,
-0.6539548635482788,
0.49645450711250305,
-0.8453277945518494,
0.0011878273217007518,
0.013674868270754814,
0.4328601360321045,
-1.2676825523376465,
-0.23071222007274628,
0.09209848940372467,
-0.29211434721946716,
0.07415460795164108,
-0.12782520055770874,
-0.7376421689987183,
-0.4186738431453705,
-0.3807322382926941,
0.802476704120636,
0.052214208990335464,
-0.19641205668449402,
0.5846680402755737,
0.1535460501909256,
-0.2733572721481323,
-0.3981625735759735,
-0.6920444965362549,
-0.03382109850645065,
-0.3172455430030823,
-0.5641207695007324,
0.07030283659696579,
-0.038741834461688995,
-0.49684861302375793,
0.04941409453749657,
-0.22258169949054718,
-0.29821521043777466,
0.3440949618816376,
-0.07963428646326065,
0.12672916054725647,
-0.41229742765426636,
0.19133366644382477,
0.011703135445713997,
0.07998693734407425,
0.4457972049713135,
0.10872484743595123,
0.7073334455490112,
-0.26297515630722046,
-0.530627965927124,
-0.13900615274906158,
0.1886204034090042,
0.514760434627533,
-0.38350147008895874,
0.6286170482635498,
0.5735518336296082,
-0.3311164677143097,
0.1677730679512024,
-0.7607162594795227,
-0.04694647714495659,
-0.411509245634079,
0.45199018716812134,
-0.30894196033477783,
-0.8166225552558899,
0.7642548680305481,
-0.1765078902244568,
-0.10469409823417664,
0.6365684270858765,
0.5579967498779297,
0.10595744103193283,
0.910648763179779,
0.012125601060688496,
-0.05276937782764435,
0.15116353332996368,
0.1134268119931221,
0.04880371317267418,
-0.8223961591720581,
-0.2068689614534378,
-0.8927435278892517,
-0.15080514550209045,
-0.308846116065979,
-0.22055774927139282,
0.24318435788154602,
0.3540804982185364,
-0.5471659302711487,
0.02617448754608631,
-0.1870926469564438,
0.47712644934654236,
0.436007559299469,
-0.13109718263149261,
0.3412795662879944,
-0.20941971242427826,
0.17269249260425568,
0.25966817140579224,
-0.5156846046447754,
-0.6807019710540771,
0.9906882643699646,
0.3449929654598236,
0.8012604117393494,
0.3510870039463043,
0.29374825954437256,
0.3146715760231018,
0.4757407307624817,
-0.8291682004928589,
0.49117112159729004,
0.08517208695411682,
-0.6059831976890564,
-0.2907373607158661,
-0.6272743940353394,
-0.8107674717903137,
0.09440543502569199,
-0.17927798628807068,
-0.8857124447822571,
0.07404187321662903,
0.16089104115962982,
-0.5049770474433899,
0.10772513598203659,
-0.8812464475631714,
1.1742498874664307,
0.058956123888492584,
-0.19391174614429474,
0.20197443664073944,
-0.5211955308914185,
0.3501527011394501,
-0.05412013456225395,
0.10777497291564941,
-0.23097002506256104,
0.21831835806369781,
0.9764780402183533,
-0.2534945011138916,
0.7121492624282837,
-0.34033098816871643,
-0.22621729969978333,
0.5965926647186279,
0.18977195024490356,
0.6237220168113708,
-0.0502614825963974,
-0.23972326517105103,
-0.25220224261283875,
0.18787972629070282,
-0.38016650080680847,
-0.5984109044075012,
0.6480844616889954,
-0.7563458681106567,
-0.3609822690486908,
-0.15341722965240479,
-0.7137084007263184,
-0.6653792262077332,
0.22881144285202026,
0.008431199006736279,
0.5646219849586487,
-0.15842211246490479,
0.4224523603916168,
0.5515839457511902,
-0.22033853828907013,
0.16729138791561127,
0.36216726899147034,
-0.12758488953113556,
-0.18266300857067108,
0.8124215602874756,
0.0358860157430172,
0.598962664604187,
0.2836202383041382,
0.42543286085128784,
-0.306189626455307,
-0.4065001904964447,
-0.4609387218952179,
0.02507716976106167,
-0.8937839269638062,
-0.5336617827415466,
-0.6220918297767639,
-0.06437963992357254,
-0.4580449163913727,
0.003495265729725361,
-0.3339942395687103,
-0.4583835303783417,
0.1226220354437828,
0.08569055795669556,
0.2206452637910843,
0.46372804045677185,
0.6571336388587952,
0.1398407220840454,
-0.6582412719726562,
0.18474547564983368,
0.6180423498153687,
0.2196989506483078,
0.3619349002838135,
-0.30192527174949646,
-0.18579386174678802,
0.027544373646378517,
-0.37421080470085144,
-0.6943827271461487,
-0.1686571091413498,
0.2620723843574524,
0.4995192587375641,
0.09272313117980957,
0.3344903588294983,
0.8989383578300476,
-0.3963879942893982,
0.7469432353973389,
0.08190823346376419,
-0.8418509364128113,
0.3498300313949585,
-0.3345755934715271,
0.4739364981651306,
0.7322264313697815,
0.3233042359352112,
-0.3637045621871948,
-0.6376886963844299,
-0.36513012647628784,
-0.8783157467842102,
0.605413019657135,
0.2298697829246521,
-0.12163971364498138,
-0.03902537003159523,
0.36619576811790466,
-0.08854412287473679,
0.2881360948085785,
-0.8589037656784058,
-0.39515358209609985,
0.12153636664152145,
-0.393080472946167,
-0.12804751098155975,
-0.1879773586988449,
-0.2670157551765442,
-0.16338114440441132,
0.4751456081867218,
-0.31249111890792847,
0.0791381374001503,
0.19442589581012726,
-0.21138718724250793,
-0.3733815848827362,
0.48164182901382446,
0.3487773835659027,
0.7875128388404846,
-0.14552034437656403,
0.412960946559906,
0.20897464454174042,
-0.19353732466697693,
-0.027548041194677353,
0.33672207593917847,
-0.1154152899980545,
-0.24508844316005707,
0.5780619382858276,
0.5452380180358887,
0.1510074883699417,
-0.9792454838752747,
0.6481308937072754,
0.021876558661460876,
-0.06479495018720627,
-0.27213239669799805,
0.12468687444925308,
0.49731895327568054,
0.4187757670879364,
0.5381990671157837,
-0.02112000621855259,
0.24686525762081146,
-0.8171356320381165,
-0.06114926189184189,
0.5647954344749451,
-0.40681225061416626,
-0.06347927451133728,
0.5580945014953613,
-0.04915689304471016,
-0.08806286752223969,
0.2883831858634949,
-0.1568569839000702,
-0.5352122783660889,
0.6840476393699646,
0.5151572227478027,
0.7837949395179749,
-0.08655723929405212,
0.08205939829349518,
0.3684970736503601,
0.013045277446508408,
-0.017423082143068314,
0.1145840436220169,
0.007011559326201677,
-0.7052031755447388,
-0.37272217869758606,
-0.7092108130455017,
-0.30008402466773987,
-0.02643468789756298,
-0.8707112669944763,
-0.05152770131826401,
-0.0987773984670639,
0.0653066337108612,
0.35418012738227844,
0.13515783846378326,
-0.6934273838996887,
0.280788779258728,
0.1631835401058197,
0.9458369016647339,
-1.0174542665481567,
0.6861021518707275,
0.8905854821205139,
-0.42037415504455566,
-0.9915923476219177,
0.06342825293540955,
-0.0605047270655632,
-0.7629601955413818,
0.7376753687858582,
0.0447678416967392,
-0.3609797954559326,
0.1100902408361435,
-0.7208970189094543,
-0.7328351140022278,
1.245639681816101,
0.4548329710960388,
-0.27026087045669556,
0.06488394737243652,
0.26130157709121704,
0.4479078948497772,
-0.44922521710395813,
0.2914891541004181,
0.6167035698890686,
0.49473389983177185,
0.15869872272014618,
-0.9031333923339844,
0.2879828214645386,
-0.0906304270029068,
-0.2214035540819168,
0.14257971942424774,
-0.48267871141433716,
0.8257219791412354,
0.2261035293340683,
-0.05002422258257866,
0.025107240304350853,
0.49587470293045044,
0.3842758536338806,
0.4596281051635742,
0.6974648237228394,
0.18969710171222687,
0.7210428714752197,
-0.10475484281778336,
0.9510142207145691,
0.08305088430643082,
0.45041176676750183,
1.2837116718292236,
-0.25971242785453796,
0.9697457551956177,
0.5677812695503235,
-0.37451666593551636,
0.609396755695343,
0.5953800678253174,
-0.05851376801729202,
0.36936062574386597,
0.48995301127433777,
-0.17993243038654327,
-0.5051748156547546,
-0.3756762146949768,
-0.08455239236354828,
0.3390096426010132,
0.1045503169298172,
-0.27523544430732727,
-0.5035391449928284,
-0.18009737133979797,
0.16186679899692535,
0.10821469128131866,
-0.4437328577041626,
0.7498602271080017,
0.11713376641273499,
-0.8783982992172241,
0.7425370216369629,
-0.08266830444335938,
0.218890979886055,
-0.6597468256950378,
0.1744040548801422,
0.006838837638497353,
0.16710056364536285,
-0.3426951467990875,
-1.0271965265274048,
0.17033912241458893,
0.30660775303840637,
-0.13609088957309723,
0.15639744699001312,
0.7323106527328491,
-0.44808682799339294,
-0.4133973717689514,
0.19714659452438354,
0.5502693057060242,
0.15176036953926086,
-0.29271039366722107,
-0.6033257246017456,
-0.12664565443992615,
-0.14619536697864532,
-0.5895534753799438,
0.215061217546463,
0.527619481086731,
-0.33629554510116577,
0.8719577789306641,
0.4169307053089142,
-0.06603220105171204,
0.027296768501400948,
0.34366562962532043,
0.9804314970970154,
-0.5275423526763916,
-0.04795118048787117,
-0.9015074372291565,
0.38625791668891907,
-0.09871885925531387,
-0.3547183871269226,
0.843427836894989,
0.7784897089004517,
0.6747328042984009,
0.11351328343153,
0.7363763451576233,
-0.24473600089550018,
0.48581913113594055,
-0.4029798209667206,
0.46306169033050537,
-0.7830134630203247,
0.20206016302108765,
-0.5886303186416626,
-1.140808343887329,
-0.4284508228302002,
0.26794713735580444,
-0.44440165162086487,
-0.1084834411740303,
0.5419694781303406,
0.6320079565048218,
-0.15463688969612122,
-0.2385787069797516,
0.023260412737727165,
0.1942594349384308,
0.5042622089385986,
0.47389456629753113,
0.8615915179252625,
-0.45094820857048035,
0.8393524289131165,
0.13842032849788666,
-0.125392884016037,
-0.3033999800682068,
-0.9316297173500061,
-0.7774340510368347,
-0.3748820126056671,
-0.3622031509876251,
-0.3403626084327698,
-0.19828297197818756,
1.0293965339660645,
0.157411128282547,
-0.7753480672836304,
-0.18606379628181458,
-0.005958883091807365,
0.03321666643023491,
-0.20068559050559998,
-0.2645493447780609,
0.6262345910072327,
-0.30121496319770813,
-0.4855981171131134,
-0.01366550661623478,
0.006278176326304674,
-0.2909802198410034,
-0.4461527466773987,
-0.08463182300329208,
-0.361285537481308,
0.0813513845205307,
0.7579413652420044,
0.30456191301345825,
-0.7363975644111633,
-0.6454422473907471,
-0.09151977300643921,
-0.2826497256755829,
-0.049066297709941864,
0.7769878506660461,
-0.5728195905685425,
0.29794663190841675,
0.500873327255249,
0.7298324704170227,
0.22471295297145844,
0.21075354516506195,
0.5219674706459045,
-0.648124635219574,
-0.3494466245174408,
0.34401968121528625,
0.19174985587596893,
0.3212016820907593,
0.058091066777706146,
0.4427001476287842,
-0.03180072084069252,
-0.7033745050430298,
-0.9929762482643127,
0.2544328570365906,
-1.0993032455444336,
-0.28984928131103516,
1.249599814414978,
-0.43010061979293823,
-0.17751657962799072,
-0.2316984236240387,
-0.12766709923744202,
0.32258927822113037,
-0.19585253298282623,
0.7220503091812134,
0.8439086675643921,
-0.11158299446105957,
0.23223955929279327,
-0.47727838158607483,
0.4448813498020172,
0.3975585103034973,
-0.9691280126571655,
0.5425170660018921,
0.5464345812797546,
0.3097587525844574,
0.263113796710968,
0.48062846064567566,
0.01999986730515957,
0.16690459847450256,
-0.1082925871014595,
0.005243215244263411,
0.03542052209377289,
-0.012152082286775112,
0.050124868750572205,
0.27776217460632324,
0.4508974552154541,
0.12135563790798187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14637v1 | T-Rex: Text-assisted Retrosynthesis Prediction | 2024-01-26T04:08:50 | 2024-01-26T04:08:50 | Yifeng Liu, Hanwen Xu, Tangqi Fang, Haocheng Xi, Zixuan Liu, Sheng Zhang, Hoifung Poon, Sheng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | As a fundamental task in computational chemistry, retrosynthesis prediction
aims to identify a set of reactants to synthesize a target molecule. Existing
template-free approaches only consider the graph structures of the target
molecule, which often cannot generalize well to rare reaction types and large
molecules. Here, we propose T-Rex, a text-assisted retrosynthesis prediction
approach that exploits pre-trained text language models, such as ChatGPT, to
assist the generation of reactants. T-Rex first exploits ChatGPT to generate a
description for the target molecule and rank candidate reaction centers based
both the description and the molecular graph. It then re-ranks these candidates
by querying the descriptions for each reactants and examines which group of
reactants can best synthesize the target molecule. We observed that T-Rex
substantially outperformed graph-based state-of-the-art approaches on two
datasets, indicating the effectiveness of considering text information. We
further found that T-Rex outperformed the variant that only use ChatGPT-based
description without the re-ranking step, demonstrate how our framework
outperformed a straightforward integration of ChatGPT and graph information.
Collectively, we show that text generated by pre-trained language models can
substantially improve retrosynthesis prediction, opening up new avenues for
exploiting ChatGPT to advance computational chemistry. And the codes can be
found at https://github.com/lauyikfung/T-Rex. | [
-0.15072010457515717,
-0.5841432213783264,
0.7739766240119934,
-0.13763651251792908,
-0.28973278403282166,
0.652519702911377,
-0.14601150155067444,
-0.3529696762561798,
0.43646207451820374,
0.2240726500749588,
-0.7511382699012756,
-0.48089200258255005,
-0.36131584644317627,
0.24093183875083923,
0.006225481163710356,
0.8677873015403748,
0.0809137374162674,
0.29523223638534546,
-0.0717533528804779,
0.3465684652328491,
-0.31780436635017395,
-0.17182551324367523,
-0.5973315834999084,
-0.4733225405216217,
0.5299057364463806,
0.3360396921634674,
0.37508493661880493,
0.5769539475440979,
0.1495751291513443,
0.23135291039943695,
-0.00575145473703742,
-0.09585104137659073,
-0.44877249002456665,
0.4419964849948883,
-0.13211368024349213,
-0.07445231080055237,
-0.5457369089126587,
0.013759220950305462,
0.5142170786857605,
0.5821812748908997,
0.20730462670326233,
0.034260813146829605,
-0.192586287856102,
0.5792273283004761,
-0.46315231919288635,
0.3842618465423584,
-0.662161648273468,
0.29277971386909485,
-0.19459396600723267,
-0.3194237947463989,
-0.6040600538253784,
-0.6355406641960144,
0.3080952763557434,
-0.5972416400909424,
0.16645635664463043,
-0.0012602285714820027,
0.524754524230957,
0.1245187446475029,
-0.26157134771347046,
0.0701625645160675,
-0.6510344743728638,
0.7508025765419006,
-0.4285147190093994,
0.7035053968429565,
-0.08327485620975494,
0.526748776435852,
-0.6095367074012756,
-1.080067753791809,
-0.4883560240268707,
-0.44319063425064087,
0.19059030711650848,
0.25800493359565735,
-0.03675038367509842,
0.17515085637569427,
-0.10596621781587601,
0.16570813953876495,
-0.6883203387260437,
-0.20026493072509766,
-0.053604856133461,
-0.2472625970840454,
0.14196819067001343,
-0.008701303973793983,
0.45047786831855774,
-0.4718380868434906,
-0.5305843353271484,
-0.18682460486888885,
-0.6884822845458984,
-0.5809725522994995,
-0.1451103687286377,
0.6068775653839111,
0.2477005273103714,
1.036466360092163,
0.22734932601451874,
0.5352903604507446,
-0.024695539847016335,
0.166581928730011,
-0.027593528851866722,
-0.3107893764972687,
-0.15439896285533905,
0.3695625066757202,
0.944164514541626,
0.2746870219707489,
0.5126511454582214,
-0.36955273151397705,
-0.0768565684556961,
-0.04833241179585457,
0.09757322818040848,
-1.2173434495925903,
-0.21905185282230377,
0.2863641679286957,
-0.2965615689754486,
-0.5690442323684692,
-0.383931428194046,
-1.3825278282165527,
-0.2624923884868622,
-0.013844922184944153,
0.7416735291481018,
-0.6983034014701843,
-0.23007769882678986,
-0.34624287486076355,
-0.6055154204368591,
-0.2710225284099579,
0.2629154920578003,
-0.6633040904998779,
0.0996210128068924,
0.6509371995925903,
0.6911951303482056,
0.16149717569351196,
-0.2079242765903473,
-0.5168446898460388,
0.21868740022182465,
-0.3391149342060089,
1.036970615386963,
-0.9434493184089661,
-0.6372447609901428,
-0.16201820969581604,
-0.21839748322963715,
-0.14307574927806854,
-0.2024565190076828,
0.22610224783420563,
-0.3287017345428467,
0.4179547131061554,
0.013295283541083336,
-0.8623805642127991,
0.10474786907434464,
0.04976716265082359,
-0.6333292722702026,
0.8186677098274231,
0.1539592444896698,
-0.715074360370636,
0.38316065073013306,
-0.44911307096481323,
-0.6219040155410767,
-0.05189061909914017,
-0.2184467315673828,
-0.6213438510894775,
0.0318816713988781,
0.13224509358406067,
0.33380383253097534,
-0.2596021592617035,
-0.06124556064605713,
-0.6620532274246216,
-0.2049708217382431,
0.4612257182598114,
0.09920574724674225,
0.6105861663818359,
0.19684921205043793,
-0.3962308466434479,
0.10263782739639282,
-0.680351972579956,
0.37381038069725037,
-0.02925838902592659,
-0.2068004012107849,
0.07860595732927322,
-0.004179058130830526,
0.22294169664382935,
-0.009325583465397358,
0.017851674929261208,
-0.6906028389930725,
0.4268844425678253,
-0.5189383625984192,
0.6203874945640564,
0.7182360291481018,
0.26462286710739136,
0.3812093734741211,
0.04832569137215614,
0.626011073589325,
-0.6398981809616089,
-0.3672087788581848,
-0.20952920615673065,
-0.6715408563613892,
-0.1831395924091339,
0.11451049894094467,
0.3036470413208008,
0.6215769052505493,
-0.8334077000617981,
0.059274472296237946,
-0.36622634530067444,
-0.7121332883834839,
0.22804735600948334,
-0.37785640358924866,
0.6480979919433594,
0.6338602900505066,
0.3733437657356262,
0.1504150629043579,
-1.1566095352172852,
-0.508250892162323,
-0.6510341167449951,
-0.7294138669967651,
0.08653375506401062,
0.382144570350647,
0.29006487131118774,
-0.1168602779507637,
0.9716525673866272,
-0.6210035681724548,
-0.2277315855026245,
-0.3434674143791199,
0.24143797159194946,
-0.15083204209804535,
0.37804898619651794,
0.38775336742401123,
-0.5386784076690674,
-0.3996543884277344,
0.3570757806301117,
-0.5062942504882812,
-0.09201081842184067,
0.3821711540222168,
-0.04537852853536606,
0.4439716339111328,
0.7194600105285645,
-0.7100618481636047,
0.24167212843894958,
0.3440839946269989,
-0.10660146921873093,
0.4536339044570923,
0.06499824672937393,
0.11461509764194489,
-1.7979899644851685,
0.32228150963783264,
-0.21738265454769135,
-0.17184951901435852,
-0.5126309990882874,
-0.2936595678329468,
-0.01650492660701275,
-0.8802611827850342,
-0.4050242006778717,
0.7594932913780212,
-0.21596674621105194,
-0.261008083820343,
0.027516985312104225,
-0.003917346242815256,
-0.21342365443706512,
0.25490620732307434,
0.21111436188220978,
0.8833584785461426,
0.02400991879403591,
-0.2881031036376953,
-0.0765557661652565,
0.25334036350250244,
0.19465090334415436,
0.031252775341272354,
-0.5686269402503967,
0.2345476895570755,
0.1841878443956375,
0.644913911819458,
-1.525970458984375,
-0.3990063965320587,
0.2724352180957794,
-0.9437592625617981,
0.7816721200942993,
-0.48095566034317017,
-0.1609879583120346,
-0.22818675637245178,
-0.15935656428337097,
0.4468689560890198,
0.4180745780467987,
-0.4171384572982788,
1.2094165086746216,
0.32233718037605286,
-0.013556152582168579,
-0.7967942953109741,
-0.6439557075500488,
0.22972267866134644,
-0.28492507338523865,
-0.6580290198326111,
0.5642901062965393,
-0.04317188635468483,
0.03863804042339325,
-0.016649439930915833,
-0.11642801016569138,
-0.20922935009002686,
-0.16290588676929474,
0.2332351952791214,
0.2760268747806549,
-0.22423097491264343,
0.4191588759422302,
-0.16873349249362946,
-0.39224499464035034,
-0.184598907828331,
-0.7228969931602478,
0.7064299583435059,
0.02681797556579113,
0.42598649859428406,
-0.3751693665981293,
0.1752123087644577,
0.674435555934906,
-0.13509872555732727,
0.3842313885688782,
0.5431455969810486,
-0.36783120036125183,
-0.1334976702928543,
-0.3828606605529785,
-0.22329160571098328,
-0.4198189675807953,
0.4248889088630676,
-0.225254088640213,
-0.5755570530891418,
0.3602871000766754,
-0.2542727291584015,
-0.24103745818138123,
0.37476882338523865,
0.29175451397895813,
-0.008555480279028416,
0.9841173887252808,
0.4874191880226135,
0.207686185836792,
0.7735083103179932,
0.050010163336992264,
0.19219915568828583,
-0.44476640224456787,
-0.1715235412120819,
-0.6722955703735352,
0.18014417588710785,
-0.9072201251983643,
-0.27770018577575684,
0.45602530241012573,
-0.2866957485675812,
-0.4184378385543823,
0.6104902029037476,
-0.5320295691490173,
0.3021295964717865,
-0.02978888526558876,
0.18335072696208954,
-0.020277947187423706,
0.2781895101070404,
-0.2959919273853302,
-0.1142822727560997,
-0.4054878354072571,
-0.3092230558395386,
1.3439874649047852,
0.12142711132764816,
0.754039466381073,
0.0614502876996994,
1.0454765558242798,
-0.017458997666835785,
0.17601552605628967,
-0.8900377750396729,
0.8292309641838074,
-0.3708646893501282,
-0.5370848178863525,
-0.06376484781503677,
-0.5490105152130127,
-0.914740800857544,
-0.23392441868782043,
-0.45284730195999146,
-0.7381806373596191,
-0.1148943305015564,
0.17019681632518768,
-0.10678501427173615,
0.18001800775527954,
-1.1533193588256836,
1.073288917541504,
0.07097182422876358,
-0.4202722907066345,
-0.10014453530311584,
-0.47028109431266785,
0.002599254483357072,
-0.06445693224668503,
-0.11615075916051865,
0.1597147434949875,
-0.1629668027162552,
0.5413333177566528,
-0.46971312165260315,
0.700422465801239,
-0.07824312150478363,
0.26007190346717834,
0.3085237443447113,
0.3961784839630127,
0.4728090167045593,
0.030641404911875725,
-0.051095135509967804,
-0.2892182171344757,
-0.13758189976215363,
-0.1866684854030609,
-0.4220012426376343,
0.6502995491027832,
-0.46591395139694214,
-0.5988354086875916,
-0.2169296145439148,
-0.08050672709941864,
-0.3217376172542572,
0.6269990801811218,
0.588569164276123,
0.5247608423233032,
-0.722946286201477,
-0.22555530071258545,
0.4568566083908081,
-0.3106552064418793,
0.7774458527565002,
0.1634877473115921,
-0.5677762031555176,
-0.8668137788772583,
0.9739442467689514,
0.050782211124897,
0.29389482736587524,
0.8302968740463257,
0.31701526045799255,
-0.4560281038284302,
-0.32427456974983215,
-0.5274863839149475,
0.05303581804037094,
-0.7122635841369629,
-0.3283960819244385,
-0.6724511981010437,
0.03623137250542641,
-0.5582624673843384,
0.016119521111249924,
-0.6397083401679993,
-1.1204954385757446,
-0.15709412097930908,
-0.15271033346652985,
0.42323872447013855,
0.8041466474533081,
0.11201445013284683,
-0.07673691213130951,
-0.6924260854721069,
0.16211886703968048,
0.4461410939693451,
0.47092539072036743,
-0.132511168718338,
0.09997991472482681,
0.17622767388820648,
-0.2553994059562683,
-0.17768029868602753,
-1.1654632091522217,
0.3893113434314728,
0.37715932726860046,
0.3047308921813965,
-0.28667521476745605,
-0.15579251945018768,
0.5702286958694458,
-0.8644853830337524,
0.7375026345252991,
0.00042526150355115533,
-0.8968243598937988,
0.8153110146522522,
-0.6416563987731934,
0.04794681444764137,
0.1257214993238449,
0.059880539774894714,
-0.3190440833568573,
-0.3902653455734253,
-0.5469166040420532,
-0.9188169836997986,
0.46933192014694214,
0.3290790915489197,
-0.11034155637025833,
-0.22990843653678894,
0.30748480558395386,
0.13678288459777832,
-0.10386094450950623,
-0.658085823059082,
-0.01937856897711754,
-0.5816541314125061,
-0.252248615026474,
0.020253844559192657,
-0.015379289165139198,
0.30675363540649414,
0.19055315852165222,
0.759412944316864,
-0.04029948636889458,
0.567518949508667,
0.23591628670692444,
0.01022987999022007,
-0.4127257168292999,
0.3809272050857544,
0.587133526802063,
0.6409603357315063,
-0.7976609468460083,
-0.024371251463890076,
-0.07290733605623245,
-0.7011059522628784,
0.03981638699769974,
0.5068724751472473,
0.19053415954113007,
0.2130478173494339,
0.22708797454833984,
0.34910446405410767,
0.18030375242233276,
-0.5619746446609497,
0.16968075931072235,
-0.3290601968765259,
0.227830708026886,
-0.4865642786026001,
-0.17309008538722992,
0.2177008092403412,
0.2182503044605255,
0.6117292642593384,
0.24267306923866272,
0.052767716348171234,
-0.4950043261051178,
0.4664444625377655,
0.36349186301231384,
-0.6053435206413269,
-0.39754560589790344,
0.8016122579574585,
0.10498447716236115,
-0.3190881013870239,
0.24508100748062134,
0.15019455552101135,
-0.6313495635986328,
0.6522860527038574,
0.595231294631958,
1.3411623239517212,
-0.7486890554428101,
0.1776023954153061,
0.6138684153556824,
-0.24061723053455353,
0.19765256345272064,
0.24951547384262085,
0.16359131038188934,
-0.45705553889274597,
-0.1993059366941452,
-0.3649156391620636,
-0.3453350365161896,
-0.2276459038257599,
-0.055298782885074615,
0.4408799409866333,
-0.8078765273094177,
-0.32654696702957153,
0.5807732939720154,
-0.022855443879961967,
-0.28668397665023804,
0.31073954701423645,
-0.023109911009669304,
0.6621731519699097,
-0.5569185018539429,
0.7779662013053894,
0.8369919061660767,
-0.5516141057014465,
-0.7444713711738586,
0.37619447708129883,
0.11148156970739365,
-0.6302620768547058,
0.8916114568710327,
0.30347201228141785,
-0.16321906447410583,
0.08517982810735703,
-0.2996963560581207,
-0.8699748516082764,
1.0327081680297852,
0.5504344701766968,
-0.15210792422294617,
0.04249114915728569,
0.07562365382909775,
0.6382232904434204,
-0.5072232484817505,
0.4309271275997162,
0.21001391112804413,
0.3658876419067383,
0.39405757188796997,
-0.8402370810508728,
0.3095572888851166,
-0.2463143914937973,
-0.012307381257414818,
0.3765659034252167,
-0.34315934777259827,
0.9396440982818604,
-0.3609149158000946,
-0.4858083426952362,
0.3634450137615204,
0.4747195541858673,
0.41726356744766235,
0.43368202447891235,
0.1690947562456131,
0.46248239278793335,
0.4349547326564789,
-0.1651555597782135,
1.1312239170074463,
-0.22056587040424347,
0.4636268615722656,
0.8376399278640747,
-0.01993941143155098,
1.0136839151382446,
0.48488661646842957,
-0.2587243914604187,
0.47172266244888306,
0.7597967386245728,
0.19217658042907715,
0.5953124165534973,
-0.02752712368965149,
-0.25808602571487427,
-0.2128855139017105,
-0.1080523133277893,
-0.49942007660865784,
0.3068908154964447,
0.4235176742076874,
-0.5685597658157349,
-0.3465389907360077,
-0.15429489314556122,
0.23650462925434113,
-0.14861848950386047,
-0.2752227187156677,
0.6131909489631653,
0.002235014457255602,
-0.8992062211036682,
0.7509157657623291,
-0.44518572092056274,
0.05126262828707695,
-0.23676630854606628,
-0.4239416718482971,
-0.1927727609872818,
0.5067463517189026,
-0.07564109563827515,
-1.0289325714111328,
0.10564975440502167,
-0.31966227293014526,
-0.043635472655296326,
-0.12176245450973511,
0.9625043272972107,
-0.40662825107574463,
-0.41569024324417114,
0.27969682216644287,
0.30423450469970703,
-0.11790101230144501,
0.06329809874296188,
-0.42234858870506287,
-0.2205873727798462,
0.25657254457473755,
-0.20882822573184967,
0.1457870453596115,
0.4501505196094513,
-0.059342771768569946,
0.6233837008476257,
0.3432038724422455,
-0.36216023564338684,
-0.21343939006328583,
-0.2736597955226898,
1.1126419305801392,
-0.8366206884384155,
-0.3816351294517517,
-0.8058153986930847,
0.29809457063674927,
0.16234473884105682,
-0.23265954852104187,
0.42076751589775085,
0.6562670469284058,
0.4879095256328583,
-0.3532150983810425,
0.8624609112739563,
-0.0124785415828228,
0.7212510108947754,
-0.6258038878440857,
0.7061740756034851,
-0.6643781065940857,
0.26735731959342957,
-0.7295148968696594,
-1.1626156568527222,
-0.33306971192359924,
0.2098637819290161,
-0.17494668066501617,
0.33647507429122925,
0.8443276286125183,
0.646236002445221,
0.03285149484872818,
0.30626848340034485,
-0.17998109757900238,
0.35152965784072876,
0.6030401587486267,
0.620060920715332,
0.7069321870803833,
-0.48806723952293396,
0.9588661789894104,
-0.07584881782531738,
0.1589481681585312,
-0.17151351273059845,
-1.176845669746399,
-1.1431686878204346,
-0.555957019329071,
0.026718348264694214,
-0.7872410416603088,
0.3005811870098114,
1.0185750722885132,
0.5129713416099548,
-0.5951558351516724,
-0.16295211017131805,
-0.428507536649704,
-0.03761909902095795,
0.20471295714378357,
-0.2022443562746048,
0.5869098901748657,
-0.33196061849594116,
-0.7020434141159058,
0.5589393973350525,
0.23995135724544525,
0.41370636224746704,
0.18410234153270721,
0.1392088085412979,
-0.03667478635907173,
-0.17283235490322113,
0.36956876516342163,
0.6016992926597595,
-0.5776103138923645,
-0.41143664717674255,
0.13243862986564636,
0.032451871782541275,
0.17750181257724762,
0.7962565422058105,
-0.9250644445419312,
0.7368149757385254,
0.7665303349494934,
0.5853363275527954,
0.9579389691352844,
-0.17559285461902618,
1.1947065591812134,
-0.8481606245040894,
0.053757134824991226,
0.3335760831832886,
0.2573813199996948,
0.46186333894729614,
-0.35160279273986816,
0.5736329555511475,
0.3524446189403534,
-0.4685513377189636,
-0.7167227268218994,
0.22512498497962952,
-1.151954174041748,
-0.6100634336471558,
1.0419886112213135,
0.022062798961997032,
-0.6251397728919983,
0.12401137501001358,
-0.20580564439296722,
0.6708784699440002,
-0.7420859336853027,
0.6963507533073425,
0.44162556529045105,
-0.2479621022939682,
-0.2526433765888214,
-0.345487117767334,
0.8023474216461182,
0.5769913792610168,
-0.6225903630256653,
0.3261454999446869,
0.45744627714157104,
0.433709979057312,
0.4312646687030792,
0.3534514904022217,
-0.16251234710216522,
0.4164503216743469,
-0.06653916835784912,
-0.054925162345170975,
-0.12371310591697693,
0.0013587569119408727,
0.14247438311576843,
0.08909443765878677,
-0.1705499142408371,
-0.10291623324155807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14630v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14630v1 | An Empirical Investigation of Domain Adaptation Ability for Chinese Spelling Check Models | 2024-01-26T03:49:55 | 2024-01-26T03:49:55 | Xi Wang, Ruoqing Zhao, Hongliang Dai, Piji Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chinese Spelling Check (CSC) is a meaningful task in the area of Natural
Language Processing (NLP) which aims at detecting spelling errors in Chinese
texts and then correcting these errors. However, CSC models are based on
pretrained language models, which are trained on a general corpus.
Consequently, their performance may drop when confronted with downstream tasks
involving domain-specific terms. In this paper, we conduct a thorough
evaluation about the domain adaption ability of various typical CSC models by
building three new datasets encompassing rich domain-specific terms from the
financial, medical, and legal domains. Then we conduct empirical investigations
in the corresponding domain-specific test datasets to ascertain the
cross-domain adaptation ability of several typical CSC models. We also test the
performance of the popular large language model ChatGPT. As shown in our
experiments, the performances of the CSC models drop significantly in the new
domains. | [
0.09627814590930939,
-0.6030436158180237,
0.24469949305057526,
0.07424192130565643,
0.008184504695236683,
0.06180816516280174,
-0.3940277397632599,
-0.5574926137924194,
-0.3003719747066498,
0.5047153830528259,
-0.5049840211868286,
-0.5495098233222961,
-0.540183961391449,
0.13734212517738342,
-0.3948219418525696,
1.059329628944397,
-0.2300935983657837,
0.12097044289112091,
-0.061091531068086624,
0.02699814923107624,
-0.6348640322685242,
-0.8014782071113586,
-0.9190426468849182,
0.030636057257652283,
0.23957113921642303,
-0.006194580812007189,
0.6723500490188599,
0.2206299901008606,
0.5475054383277893,
0.18560756742954254,
-0.09500070661306381,
0.3759031593799591,
-0.6947106719017029,
-0.5290826559066772,
-0.41071072220802307,
-0.5531232953071594,
-0.5142425894737244,
0.052240245044231415,
0.6020181775093079,
0.8008460402488708,
-0.14523538947105408,
0.011510450392961502,
0.45409712195396423,
0.5593632459640503,
-0.8047488927841187,
-0.00829402543604374,
-0.9115427136421204,
0.0022226970177143812,
-0.1935398429632187,
-0.2712947428226471,
-0.6651784777641296,
-0.3570283353328705,
0.5850710868835449,
-1.0008376836776733,
0.7067188620567322,
0.2299562692642212,
1.0594112873077393,
-0.10141925513744354,
-0.3194139301776886,
-0.42852580547332764,
-0.6233295202255249,
0.5978147983551025,
-0.9661301970481873,
0.4436529874801636,
0.6119786500930786,
0.2338467836380005,
-0.25886398553848267,
-0.821184515953064,
-0.48875969648361206,
-0.3330039083957672,
0.09574724733829498,
0.29839053750038147,
-0.08603715151548386,
0.1844298243522644,
0.18284949660301208,
0.3869132399559021,
-0.7314322590827942,
0.04657144472002983,
-0.3271816372871399,
-0.3661307692527771,
0.441618412733078,
0.11167266219854355,
0.6777935028076172,
0.11780516803264618,
-0.037550199776887894,
-0.017861362546682358,
-0.7101278901100159,
0.29505491256713867,
0.14950785040855408,
0.5417787432670593,
-0.16092371940612793,
0.15004318952560425,
-0.10794752091169357,
0.6814765930175781,
0.21815919876098633,
0.07007580995559692,
-0.12586061656475067,
-0.3876616358757019,
-0.4816499650478363,
-0.05081779137253761,
0.0938698872923851,
0.10403118282556534,
0.47995349764823914,
-0.1631578952074051,
-0.12823431193828583,
-0.20708057284355164,
0.4176660478115082,
-0.4835779070854187,
-0.6390464901924133,
0.07038386911153793,
-0.6459868550300598,
0.03596341609954834,
0.0030119928997009993,
-0.04993297904729843,
-0.5255007743835449,
-0.3588201105594635,
0.5977990031242371,
-0.6778087615966797,
-0.11833702027797699,
0.3097009062767029,
0.007737727370113134,
0.3962244391441345,
0.2942104935646057,
-0.8708447217941284,
0.510172426700592,
0.7598621249198914,
0.7846674919128418,
-0.4689364731311798,
-0.5961353778839111,
-0.36548280715942383,
-0.28915688395500183,
-0.37856823205947876,
1.009608507156372,
-0.36950838565826416,
-0.20816642045974731,
0.3823273479938507,
0.5254060626029968,
-0.8685593008995056,
-0.7453713417053223,
0.6860483288764954,
-0.7217370271682739,
-0.023396877571940422,
-0.3964732587337494,
-0.635586142539978,
-0.4106045365333557,
0.09738846868276596,
-0.5657671689987183,
0.6685029864311218,
0.1806221902370453,
-0.6753312945365906,
0.6188276410102844,
-0.5950812101364136,
-0.6736430525779724,
0.2135971188545227,
0.6072066426277161,
-0.3458560109138489,
0.08954612910747528,
0.11030035465955734,
0.5143834352493286,
-0.2263144552707672,
-0.09296401590108871,
-0.5400479435920715,
-0.3906828463077545,
0.4292285740375519,
-0.16427597403526306,
0.9958125352859497,
0.002162985038012266,
-0.15202604234218597,
-0.1803564578294754,
-0.8644320368766785,
0.12025465816259384,
-0.010487428866326809,
-0.1616063266992569,
-0.7056702971458435,
0.2920784652233124,
0.06905157119035721,
0.26346978545188904,
-0.07073996961116791,
-0.12705112993717194,
0.06201942265033722,
-0.4416671097278595,
0.25486263632774353,
0.6738486289978027,
-0.1278134435415268,
0.3095545172691345,
-0.29391035437583923,
0.4794183373451233,
0.025359736755490303,
0.1591808944940567,
0.18015936017036438,
-0.26222699880599976,
-0.9503763914108276,
-0.09478428959846497,
0.8132193684577942,
0.6508917808532715,
-0.854080855846405,
0.3139927089214325,
-0.246841162443161,
-0.3793104290962219,
-0.3814641535282135,
-0.13504847884178162,
0.27328765392303467,
0.2008357048034668,
0.12309320271015167,
-0.5757424235343933,
-0.30387988686561584,
-0.6146619319915771,
-0.6302022337913513,
-0.024745922535657883,
-0.08224423229694366,
0.2560529112815857,
0.5681639909744263,
0.0262265894562006,
0.5817919373512268,
-0.5262280702590942,
-0.25586727261543274,
-0.10944794863462448,
-0.04545268043875694,
0.04478143900632858,
0.10520502179861069,
0.6525335311889648,
-0.5024920701980591,
-0.5912732481956482,
0.3273220956325531,
-0.38014131784439087,
-0.09225635975599289,
-0.3492412865161896,
-0.2772122919559479,
0.2930334210395813,
-0.06992551684379578,
-0.0006260296213440597,
0.8187499642372131,
0.6920022964477539,
-0.5224247574806213,
0.9162299036979675,
-0.39176690578460693,
0.365518718957901,
-0.7604368329048157,
0.14895297586917877,
0.07907617837190628,
-0.08556366711854935,
-1.0478084087371826,
0.038096681237220764,
0.37266573309898376,
0.10298531502485275,
-0.42788028717041016,
0.3291394114494324,
-0.6117511987686157,
-0.14806143939495087,
-0.4557619094848633,
0.10511039197444916,
-0.07776681333780289,
0.5715599060058594,
0.2525726556777954,
0.7067486047744751,
0.5711445808410645,
-1.138671636581421,
0.013382768258452415,
0.1769040822982788,
-0.41816455125808716,
0.6486844420433044,
-0.4283348023891449,
-0.020644433796405792,
0.4348018765449524,
0.14346377551555634,
-0.856671929359436,
-0.07305169105529785,
-0.026291241869330406,
-0.29784712195396423,
0.029522595927119255,
0.016107715666294098,
-0.3937210440635681,
-0.41866278648376465,
0.034628093242645264,
0.21280653774738312,
0.2468910962343216,
-0.8702611923217773,
0.5224806070327759,
0.12645886838436127,
0.012701291590929031,
-0.25587645173072815,
-0.6334697604179382,
0.017245151102542877,
0.19653740525245667,
-0.8413382172584534,
0.4194169044494629,
-0.1812608242034912,
0.13461309671401978,
-0.033033303916454315,
0.08542705327272415,
-0.610507071018219,
0.3142508268356323,
0.2011554092168808,
0.5177522897720337,
-0.4894992709159851,
-0.1855268031358719,
-0.083136647939682,
0.429485946893692,
0.0051841288805007935,
-0.24881696701049805,
0.20993547141551971,
0.2225448340177536,
-0.36764171719551086,
-0.3160901367664337,
-0.16816438734531403,
0.21201972663402557,
-0.2417813241481781,
0.865892231464386,
0.10460536926984787,
-0.6236249208450317,
-0.6981441974639893,
-0.37218987941741943,
0.04526759311556816,
-0.42640000581741333,
0.4956151247024536,
-0.3633165657520294,
-0.6722128987312317,
0.7999255657196045,
-0.01640700176358223,
0.13186286389827728,
0.6615266799926758,
0.6273259520530701,
0.5189422965049744,
0.7083300352096558,
0.7908545136451721,
0.11249471455812454,
0.1867608278989792,
0.009350205771625042,
0.7104751467704773,
-0.6397745013237,
0.18177300691604614,
-0.3787904977798462,
0.12481009215116501,
-0.5388727188110352,
-0.3537456691265106,
-0.052809663116931915,
-0.17783911526203156,
0.07127311080694199,
0.6822728514671326,
-0.43592211604118347,
0.24767090380191803,
0.3155553340911865,
0.1300293207168579,
0.31179723143577576,
-0.014772999100387096,
-0.18133971095085144,
-0.05435032770037651,
-0.5574844479560852,
-0.15982204675674438,
0.9847940802574158,
0.09851479530334473,
0.3143067955970764,
-0.13165269792079926,
-0.13414812088012695,
0.4517797529697418,
0.36383721232414246,
-0.5313996076583862,
0.18355309963226318,
-0.8099735975265503,
-0.602741539478302,
-0.011945247650146484,
-0.1781497597694397,
-0.7418043613433838,
0.1279207170009613,
-0.39456474781036377,
-0.3441114127635956,
0.38054358959198,
0.08570203930139542,
-0.6965587735176086,
0.4695909321308136,
-0.59620600938797,
0.7698683738708496,
-0.2781253159046173,
-0.07750096172094345,
-0.16588224470615387,
-0.14309772849082947,
0.6277818083763123,
-0.6485183238983154,
0.17660409212112427,
-0.058227796107530594,
0.4497532844543457,
0.6551002264022827,
-0.4441247880458832,
0.6638439893722534,
0.004471569787710905,
-0.265590101480484,
0.3750218451023102,
0.08177812397480011,
0.35419660806655884,
-0.41792282462120056,
-0.26750707626342773,
0.5672996640205383,
0.3591911792755127,
-0.3214222490787506,
-0.4913547933101654,
0.5455004572868347,
-0.8221838474273682,
-0.12189546227455139,
-0.40423309803009033,
-0.271657258272171,
-0.2971051335334778,
0.09798183292150497,
0.19333070516586304,
0.17677150666713715,
-0.5995330810546875,
-0.2521471679210663,
0.20199328660964966,
-0.5776318907737732,
0.06794542074203491,
0.8303667902946472,
0.09673700481653214,
-0.15103206038475037,
0.8459486961364746,
0.4174833297729492,
0.43192487955093384,
0.11295243352651596,
0.014623965136706829,
0.003724324982613325,
-0.8144415616989136,
-0.24262286722660065,
0.17585888504981995,
-0.6474308967590332,
0.12202677130699158,
-0.3131987750530243,
-0.6169903874397278,
-0.8241799473762512,
-0.19148588180541992,
-0.12780186533927917,
-0.2060103714466095,
-0.2758999466896057,
0.19051431119441986,
0.2159096896648407,
0.6754065155982971,
0.12741528451442719,
0.42776772379875183,
-0.6402273774147034,
0.35690009593963623,
0.25103622674942017,
0.5156557559967041,
0.09421931207180023,
-1.1573461294174194,
-0.6073253750801086,
0.1748361885547638,
-0.26663774251937866,
-0.4509516656398773,
0.5533777475357056,
0.36418581008911133,
0.44592729210853577,
0.3812198340892792,
0.020819678902626038,
0.9988921880722046,
-0.6101407408714294,
1.0169861316680908,
-0.13062436878681183,
-1.1380491256713867,
0.15795309841632843,
-0.17120105028152466,
-0.03371946141123772,
0.3245333731174469,
0.24400964379310608,
-1.0161839723587036,
-0.0510280504822731,
-0.38117796182632446,
-0.580884575843811,
0.8430907130241394,
0.17770667374134064,
-0.21211938560009003,
0.30399689078330994,
0.7821917533874512,
0.19285821914672852,
-0.2713456451892853,
-0.46354901790618896,
-0.19305802881717682,
-0.07072504609823227,
0.08414046466350555,
0.16054122149944305,
-0.1622038036584854,
0.49787747859954834,
-0.10799964517354965,
1.0968761444091797,
-0.14731185138225555,
-0.011595222167670727,
0.17484931647777557,
-0.31220898032188416,
0.13586048781871796,
-0.045926306396722794,
0.6349671483039856,
0.5889288187026978,
0.17733877897262573,
-0.23353470861911774,
0.570083498954773,
-0.7847467660903931,
-0.24019883573055267,
0.008031049743294716,
0.0050802454352378845,
-0.046395279467105865,
0.501984715461731,
0.7339234948158264,
0.1744394600391388,
-0.5382398366928101,
0.5309751629829407,
-0.21628889441490173,
-0.5623058080673218,
-0.34879791736602783,
0.02112746611237526,
-0.11977193504571915,
-0.21562319993972778,
0.22160759568214417,
0.11335013806819916,
0.3611554801464081,
-0.32393044233322144,
0.10272850841283798,
0.2207527756690979,
-0.323347270488739,
-0.5824379324913025,
0.585284411907196,
0.0621822252869606,
-0.11040960252285004,
0.601840078830719,
-0.1114121526479721,
-0.7529121041297913,
0.7234009504318237,
0.5064306259155273,
1.0946727991104126,
-0.4079635739326477,
0.09417718648910522,
0.389919638633728,
0.28406038880348206,
-0.4262419044971466,
-0.21775272488594055,
0.27753153443336487,
-0.8016725182533264,
-0.5858898758888245,
-0.24805030226707458,
-0.4845309555530548,
0.06989461183547974,
-0.6069958806037903,
0.435276061296463,
-0.5422340631484985,
-0.10534023493528366,
0.05426792427897453,
0.1349281221628189,
-0.9057972431182861,
0.48038801550865173,
0.33930230140686035,
0.652364194393158,
-0.8184155225753784,
0.8303916454315186,
0.4228672981262207,
0.011818029917776585,
-0.9764517545700073,
0.11551381647586823,
0.02646895870566368,
-1.0228303670883179,
0.74776291847229,
-0.05478132516145706,
-0.13348388671875,
-0.3319801390171051,
-0.5595881938934326,
-0.858833372592926,
0.7938064336776733,
0.09362512826919556,
-0.5537556409835815,
0.0327187106013298,
0.4397068917751312,
0.7255496382713318,
-0.3244318962097168,
0.1477748304605484,
0.845665693283081,
0.35466352105140686,
-0.1717478334903717,
-1.3190830945968628,
0.02370770275592804,
-0.30647894740104675,
0.08350851386785507,
-0.2645370662212372,
-0.47332608699798584,
0.9355400204658508,
-0.012089463882148266,
-0.5628649592399597,
0.22962865233421326,
0.5742425322532654,
0.047139864414930344,
0.4262673556804657,
0.6867874264717102,
0.17374205589294434,
0.8575981259346008,
0.0041078305803239346,
0.9605833292007446,
-0.5651224255561829,
0.3616044819355011,
0.8916776180267334,
-0.7318664193153381,
0.9053581357002258,
-0.23870962858200073,
-0.29145392775535583,
0.6030248403549194,
0.889323353767395,
-0.20577368140220642,
0.307842493057251,
0.5108164548873901,
-0.07691244781017303,
-0.3971783518791199,
-0.04733029380440712,
-0.12779682874679565,
0.4065958857536316,
0.2964596450328827,
-0.30766674876213074,
0.25471070408821106,
-0.07945558428764343,
-0.08408273756504059,
0.14443783462047577,
-0.4264976978302002,
0.5141540765762329,
0.029545562341809273,
-0.6982730031013489,
0.7257506251335144,
0.22191888093948364,
0.7873636484146118,
-0.5894458889961243,
0.033174868673086166,
-0.00986397359520197,
0.5171401500701904,
-0.3110973536968231,
-0.24094447493553162,
0.05402982234954834,
-0.050543319433927536,
-0.15761971473693848,
0.2791701555252075,
0.9016498923301697,
-0.24370165169239044,
-0.49478989839553833,
0.4137737452983856,
0.26237520575523376,
0.3089730739593506,
-0.2783646583557129,
-0.7913466691970825,
-0.2675856351852417,
0.027362842112779617,
-0.03065858595073223,
0.35204750299453735,
0.43327102065086365,
-0.22626274824142456,
0.44503653049468994,
0.9632620811462402,
0.37948599457740784,
0.21915093064308167,
0.14156897366046906,
0.5051058530807495,
-0.7005181312561035,
-0.52787184715271,
-0.5662114024162292,
0.002150110434740782,
0.011506880633533001,
-0.44899967312812805,
0.9285433888435364,
0.35446178913116455,
0.8774175047874451,
-0.2398620992898941,
1.0332050323486328,
0.25919458270072937,
0.6523154377937317,
-0.4733830988407135,
0.9358841180801392,
-0.4665655195713043,
0.0876249223947525,
-0.2663080096244812,
-0.6238681674003601,
-0.5157902836799622,
0.46673327684402466,
-0.5181304216384888,
0.0527430884540081,
1.0322192907333374,
0.7529984712600708,
0.07065203785896301,
0.25164303183555603,
0.6257559657096863,
0.12518510222434998,
0.1600673496723175,
0.7435466647148132,
0.5144718885421753,
-0.6625752449035645,
0.33882570266723633,
-0.3146294951438904,
-0.0804387629032135,
-0.18459023535251617,
-0.7421181201934814,
-1.0907514095306396,
-0.5694264769554138,
-0.4307486116886139,
-0.5387768149375916,
0.4105406403541565,
0.6383515000343323,
0.6396104693412781,
-1.1178009510040283,
-0.03350304439663887,
0.36115655303001404,
-0.1897662729024887,
-0.6800705194473267,
-0.19482019543647766,
0.9565313458442688,
-0.23512716591358185,
-0.5608224868774414,
0.024818815290927887,
0.1626727432012558,
-0.17829960584640503,
0.13624757528305054,
0.08714842051267624,
-0.030871273949742317,
0.3915044069290161,
0.6681448817253113,
0.28434717655181885,
-0.5964710116386414,
-0.48429223895072937,
0.30689847469329834,
-0.1516278088092804,
-0.11313817650079727,
1.082726001739502,
-0.32672879099845886,
0.3243216276168823,
0.3997439444065094,
0.7526687383651733,
-0.15806175768375397,
-0.12041394412517548,
0.5540943145751953,
-0.21284811198711395,
-0.3322713077068329,
-0.24731047451496124,
0.3981224298477173,
0.21607282757759094,
-0.47047165036201477,
0.4116154611110687,
0.3756004571914673,
-0.7681778073310852,
-0.4093739092350006,
-0.34331032633781433,
-0.870551347732544,
-0.40986648201942444,
1.240902304649353,
-0.4579170048236847,
-0.5584781169891357,
-0.4408612549304962,
-0.28820914030075073,
0.26337406039237976,
0.05526377260684967,
0.8559550642967224,
0.9028121829032898,
0.1664476841688156,
0.3468155264854431,
-0.6295446157455444,
0.6753093600273132,
0.5716503262519836,
-0.7252199053764343,
0.6140468716621399,
0.28134894371032715,
0.563398540019989,
-0.07773804664611816,
0.5479623675346375,
0.04761163517832756,
0.6305965781211853,
-0.0995248332619667,
0.4707644581794739,
0.3270852863788605,
0.15439411997795105,
-0.43065446615219116,
-0.034511663019657135,
0.10145163536071777,
-0.029085036367177963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14625v1 | Toward Practical Automatic Speech Recognition and Post-Processing: a Call for Explainable Error Benchmark Guideline | 2024-01-26T03:42:45 | 2024-01-26T03:42:45 | Seonmin Koo, Chanjun Park, Jinsung Kim, Jaehyung Seo, Sugyeong Eo, Hyeonseok Moon, Heuiseok Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) outcomes serve as input for downstream
tasks, substantially impacting the satisfaction level of end-users. Hence, the
diagnosis and enhancement of the vulnerabilities present in the ASR model bear
significant importance. However, traditional evaluation methodologies of ASR
systems generate a singular, composite quantitative metric, which fails to
provide comprehensive insight into specific vulnerabilities. This lack of
detail extends to the post-processing stage, resulting in further obfuscation
of potential weaknesses. Despite an ASR model's ability to recognize utterances
accurately, subpar readability can negatively affect user satisfaction, giving
rise to a trade-off between recognition accuracy and user-friendliness. To
effectively address this, it is imperative to consider both the speech-level,
crucial for recognition accuracy, and the text-level, critical for
user-friendliness. Consequently, we propose the development of an Error
Explainable Benchmark (EEB) dataset. This dataset, while considering both
speech- and text-level, enables a granular understanding of the model's
shortcomings. Our proposition provides a structured pathway for a more
`real-world-centric' evaluation, a marked shift away from abstracted,
traditional methods, allowing for the detection and rectification of nuanced
system weaknesses, ultimately aiming for an improved user experience. | [
-0.5311825275421143,
-0.5921311378479004,
0.4962180554866791,
-0.0782189816236496,
-0.14594170451164246,
-0.00013116370246279985,
-0.1211761012673378,
-0.6874333024024963,
-0.32457053661346436,
0.19043730199337006,
-0.37731143832206726,
-0.28868159651756287,
-0.5805741548538208,
0.09444917738437653,
-0.7746270895004272,
0.7597547769546509,
-0.08749716728925705,
-0.06560441106557846,
-0.37388482689857483,
-0.36622223258018494,
-0.5621399879455566,
-0.6757853031158447,
-0.7681247591972351,
-0.2983899712562561,
0.26778313517570496,
0.41136595606803894,
0.6353607773780823,
0.718469500541687,
0.5292280912399292,
0.2956344485282898,
0.02868920937180519,
-0.14577269554138184,
0.05523185804486275,
0.02354307658970356,
-0.12508876621723175,
-0.3360443413257599,
-0.6492605805397034,
-0.17869971692562103,
0.4805062711238861,
0.8698341846466064,
-0.30500316619873047,
0.1498895138502121,
0.30662789940834045,
0.5206490755081177,
-0.482426255941391,
0.09902159869670868,
-0.373151570558548,
0.011961260810494423,
-0.32536545395851135,
-0.07426454871892929,
-0.15599246323108673,
-0.3303409814834595,
0.1375153660774231,
-0.5864341855049133,
0.2550860345363617,
-0.17541863024234772,
0.7536152601242065,
0.541741132736206,
-0.1397401988506317,
-0.3518953025341034,
-0.8837699890136719,
0.5300137400627136,
-0.6958977580070496,
0.6487694382667542,
0.3540930151939392,
0.7591717839241028,
0.09346888959407806,
-0.5299004316329956,
-0.7081817388534546,
-0.02523069828748703,
0.09465812891721725,
-0.07225844264030457,
-0.5956947803497314,
-0.14612235128879547,
0.3417057991027832,
0.3009559214115143,
-0.6444574594497681,
0.14281851053237915,
-0.13899235427379608,
-0.2775939702987671,
0.4723847508430481,
0.05494632571935654,
0.18161848187446594,
0.21634730696678162,
-0.026717502623796463,
-0.18683351576328278,
-0.4615471363067627,
0.5191754102706909,
0.290107399225235,
0.34846746921539307,
0.03317536786198616,
0.20421497523784637,
-0.24203899502754211,
0.5686076879501343,
-0.04178750142455101,
0.12939532101154327,
0.5505971908569336,
-0.1389937549829483,
-0.02623918652534485,
0.09315972030162811,
0.5033366680145264,
0.3444955050945282,
0.22117532789707184,
-0.11211381107568741,
-0.48571527004241943,
0.31471630930900574,
0.41788631677627563,
-0.5734965801239014,
-0.2531678080558777,
0.3267390727996826,
-0.5303640961647034,
-0.12866823375225067,
0.06473889201879501,
-0.5279014706611633,
-0.4301079213619232,
-0.2844833731651306,
0.6461343765258789,
-0.4479807913303375,
-0.2421274334192276,
-0.006728381849825382,
-0.05929167941212654,
0.18312811851501465,
0.4302891194820404,
-0.4329095482826233,
0.5908131003379822,
0.6279211640357971,
0.6899115443229675,
0.19910301268100739,
-0.10207079350948334,
-0.6016809940338135,
-0.010257864370942116,
-0.09462577849626541,
1.0528713464736938,
-0.4981328248977661,
-0.5398341417312622,
-0.24847301840782166,
-0.19067737460136414,
0.05749145522713661,
-0.81100994348526,
0.7933915853500366,
-0.13317331671714783,
-0.17746032774448395,
-0.2601642608642578,
-0.3510870337486267,
-0.23371465504169464,
0.029659083113074303,
-0.3532845377922058,
0.6618261933326721,
-0.20866627991199493,
-0.4841699004173279,
0.38765332102775574,
-0.69040846824646,
-0.42054712772369385,
-0.08127112686634064,
-0.23439714312553406,
-0.45271503925323486,
0.2468259632587433,
0.2920684814453125,
0.18894366919994354,
-0.42407917976379395,
0.15377506613731384,
-0.2672731280326843,
-0.5601668953895569,
0.29282015562057495,
-0.6607437133789062,
0.5263514518737793,
0.3592051863670349,
-0.43907278776168823,
0.08025955408811569,
-1.2235099077224731,
0.14765596389770508,
-0.1162417083978653,
-0.20404379069805145,
-0.32196497917175293,
0.25349563360214233,
-0.00016726837202440947,
0.09310624748468399,
0.04614218696951866,
-0.5646100044250488,
-0.5193617939949036,
-0.4024927616119385,
0.39592933654785156,
0.5813213586807251,
-0.41347625851631165,
0.26083001494407654,
-0.26976579427719116,
0.4040656089782715,
0.011281515471637249,
0.266372948884964,
-0.4180641770362854,
-0.21036186814308167,
-0.6747463941574097,
-0.1255376636981964,
0.3105212450027466,
0.6814974546432495,
-0.4876011908054352,
0.5088725090026855,
-0.2732425630092621,
-0.6165384650230408,
-0.6443569660186768,
-0.13145560026168823,
0.8282184600830078,
0.9604910612106323,
0.2946372628211975,
-0.47812125086784363,
-0.6192030906677246,
-0.7959153056144714,
-0.6046981811523438,
-0.4112785756587982,
-0.44479626417160034,
0.4790950119495392,
-0.0521051287651062,
-0.40426433086395264,
0.8605155944824219,
-0.15427477657794952,
-0.20385976135730743,
-0.03265707567334175,
0.17129163444042206,
0.13772667944431305,
0.5041537284851074,
-0.023519843816757202,
-0.7538461089134216,
-0.14471325278282166,
0.049580395221710205,
-0.7169482111930847,
-0.4909476637840271,
0.25215160846710205,
0.587287187576294,
0.09407927840948105,
0.5836470723152161,
-0.12339793145656586,
0.6912989616394043,
0.2811201810836792,
-0.2626389265060425,
0.6119573712348938,
-0.3708001673221588,
0.23705385625362396,
-0.43961095809936523,
0.1395353376865387,
-0.048944372683763504,
-0.23310866951942444,
-0.6287332773208618,
-0.08365462720394135,
-0.044777847826480865,
-0.38508710265159607,
-0.12820231914520264,
0.32822462916374207,
-0.2274070680141449,
-0.48549091815948486,
-0.21698223054409027,
0.0535777285695076,
0.1788746565580368,
0.03731086477637291,
-0.1255834698677063,
0.7031641602516174,
0.5494340062141418,
-0.6031450629234314,
0.22652076184749603,
0.2589983344078064,
-0.12941418588161469,
0.9143548011779785,
-1.1136711835861206,
0.14818373322486877,
-0.17760467529296875,
0.17169517278671265,
-0.9661184549331665,
-0.12197499722242355,
0.09497622400522232,
-0.7825374603271484,
0.23310767114162445,
0.22445867955684662,
-0.3145608901977539,
-0.3374190926551819,
-0.019822459667921066,
0.45434844493865967,
0.5790579319000244,
-0.5510593056678772,
0.5915926694869995,
0.5566871762275696,
-0.23574461042881012,
-0.3357214331626892,
-0.6294388771057129,
0.017982134595513344,
-0.22480952739715576,
-0.7396110892295837,
0.2719752788543701,
0.024816300719976425,
-0.33660823106765747,
-0.16867530345916748,
-0.42962202429771423,
-0.155562624335289,
0.21337835490703583,
0.48052898049354553,
-0.04160766303539276,
-0.22329451143741608,
0.004296833649277687,
-0.35190054774284363,
-0.5603470802307129,
0.131714329123497,
-0.001962789334356785,
0.22232162952423096,
-0.5197324156761169,
-0.4687713384628296,
-0.7767297625541687,
0.3012619912624359,
0.2358938604593277,
-0.20098887383937836,
0.24788504838943481,
0.5085622072219849,
-0.569628894329071,
-0.0622633621096611,
-0.48668625950813293,
-0.16222117841243744,
-0.46890124678611755,
0.2598923444747925,
-0.5857124924659729,
-0.5427950620651245,
0.7622515559196472,
0.06770086288452148,
-0.07140415906906128,
0.2581031918525696,
0.02997869811952114,
-0.44893091917037964,
0.9850098490715027,
0.49757304787635803,
0.35259106755256653,
0.406477689743042,
0.16082820296287537,
0.3727341592311859,
-0.6319402456283569,
-0.2586328387260437,
-0.7956575751304626,
-0.10119835287332535,
-0.38098227977752686,
-0.17121659219264984,
0.48186832666397095,
0.02580699510872364,
-0.1719329059123993,
0.37315699458122253,
-0.45925575494766235,
0.23032070696353912,
0.4603009819984436,
0.15777026116847992,
0.16181126236915588,
-0.11288630962371826,
0.009992505423724651,
-0.09880216419696808,
-0.48270899057388306,
-0.7034482359886169,
0.8383917808532715,
0.5319293141365051,
0.6450282335281372,
-0.031157977879047394,
0.6447173357009888,
0.4282032251358032,
-0.06778685003519058,
-0.6043182611465454,
0.3753756880760193,
-0.32479092478752136,
-0.33046767115592957,
-0.4772910475730896,
-0.4928950071334839,
-0.7237110733985901,
0.06131110340356827,
0.13355572521686554,
-0.7077060341835022,
0.423187255859375,
0.7593222856521606,
-0.6270020008087158,
-0.04347505792975426,
-0.9355037212371826,
1.1109482049942017,
-0.015758220106363297,
-0.050605904310941696,
-0.060300394892692566,
-0.8427858948707581,
0.009991084225475788,
-0.08569467067718506,
0.6813287138938904,
0.009557953104376793,
0.056614916771650314,
0.702458918094635,
-0.6690858602523804,
0.49189844727516174,
-0.5156092047691345,
0.08869599550962448,
0.06372668594121933,
-0.09786097705364227,
0.4222717881202698,
-0.3516148030757904,
-0.30137836933135986,
0.228777214884758,
0.10327369719743729,
-0.2179543524980545,
-0.6524692177772522,
0.34401735663414,
-0.6284642815589905,
-0.47765254974365234,
-0.36722543835639954,
-0.24373221397399902,
-0.5889209508895874,
0.000027951189622399397,
0.21278217434883118,
0.9363895058631897,
-0.1297878473997116,
0.14507561922073364,
0.7011138796806335,
-0.4490734040737152,
0.3068980872631073,
0.6505441665649414,
0.09595678001642227,
-0.17172499001026154,
1.07530677318573,
0.3148917257785797,
0.003927398473024368,
0.13925282657146454,
0.15962974727153778,
-0.3468097448348999,
-0.7911084890365601,
-0.30679014325141907,
-0.3004014790058136,
-0.55963534116745,
-0.09436104446649551,
-0.6528223752975464,
-0.2267778366804123,
-0.34799858927726746,
-0.20287983119487762,
-0.4622771143913269,
-0.3694315254688263,
-0.32716891169548035,
0.007821636274456978,
0.21035143733024597,
0.4763367176055908,
-0.3446439802646637,
0.5854562520980835,
-0.7890013456344604,
0.47482165694236755,
0.14303815364837646,
0.5093483924865723,
-0.03760184720158577,
-0.8643096685409546,
-0.1331082284450531,
0.036950331181287766,
-0.12479428946971893,
-0.5821776986122131,
0.22014746069908142,
0.42599162459373474,
0.7114419341087341,
0.3405678868293762,
0.15017922222614288,
0.84688401222229,
-0.7224324345588684,
0.38548821210861206,
0.1456650197505951,
-1.202659010887146,
0.7241588234901428,
-0.14255350828170776,
0.18512557446956635,
0.8131771087646484,
0.047576338052749634,
-0.5088778138160706,
-0.2734159827232361,
-0.5904316902160645,
-1.1955132484436035,
0.772786021232605,
0.09190070629119873,
-0.17983612418174744,
0.24188117682933807,
0.249317467212677,
0.24979640543460846,
0.23343490064144135,
-0.5745675563812256,
-0.2756024897098541,
-0.48600003123283386,
-0.15401925146579742,
-0.2876345217227936,
-0.17647209763526917,
0.052520882338285446,
-0.05091347545385361,
0.6351520419120789,
0.11905799061059952,
0.26186197996139526,
0.21654270589351654,
-0.26988455653190613,
-0.020893987268209457,
0.43311578035354614,
0.24944595992565155,
0.8541640639305115,
-0.35536718368530273,
0.32670679688453674,
0.010442144237458706,
-0.38993048667907715,
0.17867188155651093,
0.6105791926383972,
-0.04488656669855118,
-0.020601976662874222,
0.24842716753482819,
0.7080823183059692,
0.18538951873779297,
-0.9309132099151611,
0.6829971671104431,
-0.14659084379673004,
0.2961265444755554,
-0.4924086332321167,
0.12105384469032288,
-0.2553449273109436,
0.26554250717163086,
0.5115490555763245,
0.31736141443252563,
0.63455730676651,
-0.604797899723053,
0.4845924973487854,
0.3112656772136688,
-0.7211496829986572,
-0.3470221161842346,
0.6840457916259766,
0.33850955963134766,
-0.6406316757202148,
0.1950441151857376,
-0.16804365813732147,
-0.389348566532135,
0.629570484161377,
0.312073677778244,
0.7877565622329712,
-0.5320315957069397,
0.09565744549036026,
0.20609354972839355,
0.3011118769645691,
0.11581338942050934,
0.2947157025337219,
-0.15566276013851166,
-0.6042152047157288,
0.08173315227031708,
-0.5896391272544861,
-0.5629976987838745,
-0.04093346372246742,
-1.0573567152023315,
0.24415692687034607,
-0.5071581602096558,
-0.08024439960718155,
0.40749189257621765,
-0.41292834281921387,
-0.632192850112915,
0.6112244725227356,
0.10258976370096207,
0.7446407675743103,
-0.707251787185669,
0.5135915279388428,
0.5202376246452332,
-0.24617601931095123,
-0.6676307320594788,
0.0998615175485611,
0.25630104541778564,
-0.8248660564422607,
0.2657703459262848,
0.365913450717926,
-0.09031414985656738,
-0.13728438317775726,
0.06114297732710838,
-0.4624329209327698,
0.8974335789680481,
0.41597968339920044,
-0.8453723192214966,
-0.022400429472327232,
0.07202591001987457,
0.6619687080383301,
-0.1746051162481308,
0.28566786646842957,
0.7329796552658081,
0.2984515130519867,
-0.07078301906585693,
-1.173040747642517,
0.12986402213573456,
-0.32581445574760437,
0.027772970497608185,
0.02979796566069126,
-0.2820051312446594,
0.5100906491279602,
-0.16828005015850067,
-0.2549149692058563,
-0.22641786932945251,
0.37206190824508667,
0.25533029437065125,
0.8237242102622986,
0.8248189687728882,
0.5768092274665833,
0.6741886138916016,
-0.1468142569065094,
1.0664101839065552,
0.12229795753955841,
-0.21595172584056854,
1.1973903179168701,
-0.31027087569236755,
1.1323940753936768,
0.4690421223640442,
-0.42880234122276306,
0.35036158561706543,
0.4608463644981384,
0.27528300881385803,
0.5300232768058777,
0.31394127011299133,
-0.333915650844574,
-0.026841498911380768,
-0.0638945996761322,
-0.44648146629333496,
0.5417559146881104,
0.4070427119731903,
-0.3035503923892975,
-0.245452418923378,
0.2025093287229538,
-0.1649629771709442,
0.24670815467834473,
-0.42076244950294495,
0.9713956117630005,
0.1492975354194641,
-0.26456406712532043,
0.5137243866920471,
-0.1942276954650879,
0.5143203139305115,
-0.4285275340080261,
0.07816790044307709,
0.12489224225282669,
0.4158356189727783,
-0.3630218803882599,
-0.692008376121521,
0.7549005746841431,
0.40099143981933594,
-0.4389495253562927,
-0.2502110004425049,
0.720713198184967,
0.018242914229631424,
-0.40050625801086426,
0.21636763215065002,
0.38038426637649536,
0.4495404064655304,
-0.2657391130924225,
-0.5308260321617126,
0.448512464761734,
-0.06925154477357864,
-0.006158594507724047,
0.12017398327589035,
0.4312343895435333,
0.1348467916250229,
0.5987433791160583,
0.5031424164772034,
-0.0010051376884803176,
-0.14210762083530426,
0.23125424981117249,
0.7300823330879211,
-0.47571179270744324,
-0.6043126583099365,
-0.6109011173248291,
0.6835516691207886,
-0.014151027426123619,
-0.08435353636741638,
0.5971553325653076,
0.3971604108810425,
0.6518425941467285,
0.3907821774482727,
0.986699640750885,
-0.1048220843076706,
1.005792260169983,
-0.09980934858322144,
0.6900736689567566,
-0.5427823066711426,
0.7078282833099365,
-0.4915688931941986,
-0.6574544906616211,
-0.28625404834747314,
0.7807388305664062,
-0.3763484060764313,
0.045006297528743744,
0.36780300736427307,
0.693701982498169,
-0.042671363800764084,
0.14740526676177979,
0.44799160957336426,
0.2795353829860687,
0.23424766957759857,
0.34441787004470825,
0.7876411080360413,
-0.5893241167068481,
1.0525922775268555,
-0.10620205849409103,
-0.607680082321167,
-0.18535885214805603,
-0.8455533981323242,
-0.3359420895576477,
-0.5029957294464111,
-0.46285831928253174,
-0.4338967800140381,
0.4609886407852173,
0.6048264503479004,
0.5434983968734741,
-0.9738579392433167,
-0.06412319839000702,
-0.33890360593795776,
-0.15999436378479004,
-0.20924349129199982,
-0.20013606548309326,
0.04270494356751442,
-0.10867881029844284,
-0.37673017382621765,
0.297414630651474,
0.248585045337677,
0.02239244617521763,
0.16438695788383484,
-0.11330589652061462,
0.5158082246780396,
0.021717913448810577,
0.2977119982242584,
0.6685682535171509,
-0.677176296710968,
-0.4166705906391144,
-0.229664146900177,
0.2293926477432251,
-0.019862191751599312,
0.5514774322509766,
-0.8214128613471985,
0.6971437335014343,
0.15810561180114746,
0.8056946992874146,
0.15706861019134521,
-0.0411723256111145,
0.8276113271713257,
-0.5448812246322632,
-0.07587258517742157,
0.25913184881210327,
0.3424662947654724,
0.5569266080856323,
-0.2582419514656067,
0.3763324022293091,
0.13398970663547516,
-0.5931798219680786,
-1.2359833717346191,
0.18262040615081787,
-0.8918971419334412,
0.027778446674346924,
0.763963520526886,
-0.5930867195129395,
0.0673920288681984,
-0.43706050515174866,
-0.15389040112495422,
0.3587817847728729,
-0.3920779824256897,
0.7687309980392456,
0.4973771274089813,
-0.4075052738189697,
-0.24177393317222595,
-0.37785401940345764,
0.5709844827651978,
0.284812867641449,
-0.8925023674964905,
0.27101510763168335,
0.5950246453285217,
0.258884459733963,
0.10118899494409561,
0.5956302881240845,
-0.25345900654792786,
0.60942542552948,
0.26980024576187134,
0.03315659612417221,
-0.18179951608181,
-0.2719353139400482,
-0.7176831364631653,
0.12482189387083054,
0.24532583355903625,
-0.29828259348869324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14624v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14624v3 | Query of CC: Unearthing Large Scale Domain-Specific Knowledge from Public Corpora | 2024-01-26T03:38:23 | 2024-03-05T02:45:41 | Zhaoye Fei, Yunfan Shao, Linyang Li, Zhiyuan Zeng, Conghui He, Hang Yan, Dahua Lin, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have demonstrated remarkable potential in various
tasks, however, there remains a significant scarcity of open-source models and
data for specific domains. Previous works have primarily focused on manually
specifying resources and collecting high-quality data on specific domains,
which significantly consume time and effort. To address this limitation, we
propose an efficient data collection method $\textit{Query of CC}$ based on
large language models. This method bootstraps seed information through a large
language model and retrieves related data from public corpora. It not only
collects knowledge-related data for specific domains but unearths the data with
potential reasoning procedures. Through the application of this method, we have
curated a high-quality dataset called KNOWLEDGE PILE, encompassing four major
domains, including stem and humanities sciences, among others. Experimental
results demonstrate that KNOWLEDGE PILE significantly improves the performance
of large language models in mathematical and knowledge-related reasoning
ability tests. To facilitate academic sharing, we open-source our dataset and
code, providing valuable support to the academic community. | [
-0.49825456738471985,
-0.744458794593811,
0.782956063747406,
-0.0009628834668546915,
-0.01800820231437683,
0.23784945905208588,
-0.441307932138443,
-0.1494252234697342,
0.12255056947469711,
0.8440755009651184,
-0.4603826701641083,
-0.9169385433197021,
-0.5508140325546265,
-0.22079132497310638,
-0.5558228492736816,
0.7514508366584778,
0.22271758317947388,
-0.019442465156316757,
-0.5605778098106384,
-0.046811483800411224,
-0.20936498045921326,
-0.618462085723877,
-0.23077629506587982,
0.31835463643074036,
0.5453360676765442,
0.5798887014389038,
0.4989926517009735,
0.46970847249031067,
0.5630764365196228,
0.20649610459804535,
-0.13292011618614197,
0.5091297030448914,
-0.7713775038719177,
0.06271650642156601,
-0.5710848569869995,
-0.3297126889228821,
-0.21251285076141357,
-0.06585224717855453,
0.8004735708236694,
1.0191059112548828,
-0.03709946945309639,
0.23402468860149384,
-0.203006312251091,
0.6125693321228027,
-0.9365500211715698,
0.2504429817199707,
-0.9393550157546997,
-0.25459107756614685,
-0.555343747138977,
-0.26503458619117737,
-0.6393706798553467,
-0.3701920211315155,
0.022742634639143944,
-0.9203675389289856,
0.37743788957595825,
0.4334411025047302,
0.6543338298797607,
0.05461020767688751,
-0.18070098757743835,
-0.31502413749694824,
-0.4863017499446869,
1.0167796611785889,
-0.2992306649684906,
0.3180706202983856,
0.8360308408737183,
0.49932950735092163,
-0.014469698071479797,
-0.7698753476142883,
-0.6462855339050293,
-0.07797260582447052,
-0.15655766427516937,
-0.11617615073919296,
-0.2415274977684021,
-0.2461530715227127,
0.21600134670734406,
0.5135110020637512,
-0.6081767082214355,
-0.09294766187667847,
-0.6102533340454102,
-0.2683090567588806,
0.550984263420105,
0.09394469112157822,
0.43488776683807373,
-0.12273460626602173,
-0.1382574588060379,
-0.08586909621953964,
-1.0309569835662842,
-0.21478986740112305,
0.3607032001018524,
0.46115756034851074,
0.20052564144134521,
0.841803789138794,
-0.3284468352794647,
0.9569466710090637,
-0.2337729036808014,
0.13254816830158234,
-0.08874216675758362,
-0.42648643255233765,
-0.04026881232857704,
-0.2676738202571869,
0.57900071144104,
-0.15276995301246643,
0.1123516783118248,
-0.22429795563220978,
0.1281312108039856,
-0.06917405873537064,
0.010650532320141792,
-0.6704561114311218,
-0.38929975032806396,
0.2785693407058716,
-0.1230052039027214,
-0.04321245849132538,
0.17635752260684967,
-0.8573958277702332,
-0.4244092106819153,
-0.46454769372940063,
-0.2520034909248352,
-0.3827168345451355,
-0.4135810136795044,
0.17951492965221405,
-0.08628911525011063,
-0.029840582981705666,
0.3643395006656647,
-0.69377601146698,
0.3028573989868164,
0.9484245777130127,
0.7094847559928894,
-0.47602108120918274,
-0.0010708612389862537,
-0.7625711560249329,
0.08696264028549194,
-0.3374035358428955,
0.6373718976974487,
-0.8312382102012634,
-0.2266065627336502,
0.22831657528877258,
0.2490188628435135,
0.01368861086666584,
-0.6860149502754211,
0.493267685174942,
-0.9063360691070557,
0.0653453841805458,
-0.5206547379493713,
-0.5506730675697327,
0.059046342968940735,
0.15811088681221008,
-0.8129669427871704,
0.7753152847290039,
0.2887205481529236,
-0.9853243231773376,
0.20116327702999115,
-0.5695849061012268,
-0.2273111790418625,
0.3983635902404785,
-0.3544921278953552,
0.1145671084523201,
-0.11396703869104385,
0.3345952332019806,
0.5724235773086548,
-0.7464160323143005,
0.4691909849643707,
-0.41318339109420776,
-0.09220253676176071,
0.009785545989871025,
-0.03696487098932266,
1.2145313024520874,
0.39530810713768005,
-0.009208694100379944,
-0.19013334810733795,
-0.8175582885742188,
0.042701464146375656,
0.1671251356601715,
-0.15060007572174072,
-0.7750307321548462,
0.10653894394636154,
-0.1570281982421875,
0.1352752447128296,
0.21986141800880432,
-0.5708768963813782,
0.5162909030914307,
-0.0027085398323833942,
0.36845120787620544,
0.45955559611320496,
0.041295506060123444,
0.3378395736217499,
-0.0312652587890625,
0.3809551000595093,
0.013061391189694405,
-0.16018295288085938,
0.10497834533452988,
-0.398758202791214,
-0.4934537708759308,
-0.5381031632423401,
0.3629532754421234,
0.14861969649791718,
-0.851906955242157,
0.3984944820404053,
-0.3013603091239929,
-0.5369354486465454,
-0.5990156531333923,
-0.005017872899770737,
0.3096034526824951,
0.30582985281944275,
0.4656938910484314,
-0.06835872679948807,
-0.16398702561855316,
-0.6790592074394226,
0.057879962027072906,
-0.10728265345096588,
-0.2089703530073166,
0.5825985074043274,
0.5697119235992432,
0.10834773629903793,
1.0390669107437134,
-1.2448781728744507,
-0.007338331080973148,
-0.13352686166763306,
0.26387956738471985,
-0.08585472404956818,
0.3577686846256256,
0.3383557200431824,
-0.9634749889373779,
-0.12839272618293762,
0.1356285661458969,
-0.6118911504745483,
-0.12110654264688492,
0.34458285570144653,
-0.7443409562110901,
-0.028534790500998497,
0.35600516200065613,
-0.6129093170166016,
0.2501000761985779,
0.6625569462776184,
-0.46948787569999695,
0.8289118409156799,
0.09478703141212463,
0.3413887321949005,
-0.8016104698181152,
0.4416968524456024,
-0.2328885942697525,
-0.04458435997366905,
-0.24786610901355743,
0.337779700756073,
0.15640902519226074,
-0.23037351667881012,
-0.43930235505104065,
0.5236846208572388,
-0.542716920375824,
-0.214972585439682,
-0.1539422869682312,
0.5897639989852905,
0.06329227983951569,
0.4249597191810608,
0.4085276424884796,
0.749500036239624,
0.7622854113578796,
-0.8438380360603333,
0.3326754570007324,
0.32696130871772766,
-0.6787514090538025,
0.42214399576187134,
-0.425094872713089,
0.19740743935108185,
-0.06872521340847015,
0.073002889752388,
-0.6641095876693726,
-0.4352143704891205,
-0.17045047879219055,
-0.42855051159858704,
0.006186990067362785,
-0.18109142780303955,
-0.5662708878517151,
-0.3403112590312958,
0.19801729917526245,
0.4626244604587555,
0.20407439768314362,
-0.7540407180786133,
0.12513309717178345,
0.8047481179237366,
-0.36791113018989563,
-0.6623964309692383,
-0.3774682879447937,
-0.23530592024326324,
0.09286116063594818,
-0.7798622846603394,
0.19341127574443817,
-0.2645826041698456,
-0.5953842401504517,
0.03398081660270691,
0.03264394775032997,
-0.49823707342147827,
-0.18359948694705963,
-0.12241128087043762,
0.25067415833473206,
-0.14420351386070251,
0.18807454407215118,
0.029979582875967026,
0.2714424431324005,
0.12598702311515808,
-0.5585298538208008,
0.6487343311309814,
0.19264714419841766,
-0.5972901582717896,
0.15555864572525024,
0.4502527415752411,
0.7560995817184448,
-0.6206806302070618,
0.812467634677887,
0.15831787884235382,
-0.5574479699134827,
-0.623989462852478,
-0.502787172794342,
-0.08861212432384491,
-0.3989661633968353,
0.30318066477775574,
-0.12603409588336945,
-1.0465747117996216,
0.1452767252922058,
-0.07746700942516327,
0.09349939227104187,
0.4441840648651123,
0.5934591293334961,
0.369770348072052,
0.8606254458427429,
0.6646496057510376,
-0.2807471752166748,
-0.008766498416662216,
-0.4251461923122406,
0.16868600249290466,
-0.5808717012405396,
-0.2530117332935333,
-0.9672120213508606,
0.3932441771030426,
-0.19269870221614838,
-0.9436683058738708,
0.10077708959579468,
-0.020831085741519928,
-0.2589060068130493,
0.5287594199180603,
-0.5824832320213318,
0.38567495346069336,
0.5168736577033997,
-0.052140265703201294,
0.7694475054740906,
0.060368288308382034,
-0.21215762197971344,
0.05106928572058678,
-0.5461266040802002,
-0.4169616997241974,
0.8908728957176208,
-0.016701601445674896,
0.4309045672416687,
0.09177295118570328,
0.11936090141534805,
0.20622974634170532,
0.10969945043325424,
-0.5581592917442322,
0.5314132571220398,
-0.146340474486351,
-0.95020592212677,
-0.3786317706108093,
-0.7881476879119873,
-0.9091584086418152,
0.10859084874391556,
-0.152938112616539,
-0.5478932857513428,
0.2207976132631302,
-0.07849469035863876,
-0.13894236087799072,
0.49718964099884033,
-0.3913375437259674,
0.706670343875885,
-0.06545113772153854,
-0.4355960786342621,
-0.4642676115036011,
-0.5419117212295532,
0.7311295866966248,
-0.4336199164390564,
0.3933882415294647,
-0.08339369297027588,
0.2584538459777832,
0.5694968104362488,
-0.5349988341331482,
0.4534599781036377,
-0.13982108235359192,
-0.09771749377250671,
0.7083460092544556,
0.18539942800998688,
0.4233057200908661,
0.07838141918182373,
-0.17637966573238373,
0.06590882688760757,
-0.08424742519855499,
-0.5596371293067932,
-0.62067049741745,
0.9378427267074585,
-0.7769618630409241,
-0.4453268349170685,
-0.21488821506500244,
-0.6292275190353394,
-0.3510242998600006,
0.20157091319561005,
0.08010338246822357,
0.4893447160720825,
-0.21146051585674286,
0.44457709789276123,
0.8180325627326965,
-0.5180632472038269,
0.042844370007514954,
0.712386429309845,
-0.125515878200531,
-0.12461447715759277,
0.9486619830131531,
0.10578084737062454,
0.5046417117118835,
0.6739971041679382,
0.05270231515169144,
-0.2370513379573822,
-0.5131516456604004,
-0.22831858694553375,
0.2959800362586975,
-0.46531933546066284,
-0.35482633113861084,
-0.8344509601593018,
-0.09347671270370483,
-0.5651121735572815,
-0.09097963571548462,
-0.24433238804340363,
-0.6143487095832825,
0.015325301326811314,
-0.1584843248128891,
0.4697098731994629,
0.6328061819076538,
0.30646243691444397,
0.010968317277729511,
-0.6590160727500916,
0.324534147977829,
0.17280854284763336,
0.3358035683631897,
0.0029920462984591722,
-0.14995232224464417,
-0.22178861498832703,
-0.02455471269786358,
-0.24710404872894287,
-0.5812161564826965,
0.5731504559516907,
-0.26039332151412964,
0.4510249197483063,
0.42158427834510803,
0.4449075162410736,
0.5855239629745483,
-0.2776019871234894,
0.9120489358901978,
0.1275537610054016,
-0.7513999342918396,
0.5212447643280029,
-0.5895931124687195,
0.24169188737869263,
0.5860892534255981,
0.899949312210083,
-0.28515100479125977,
-0.44922909140586853,
-0.7143191695213318,
-0.908191978931427,
0.774185061454773,
0.2768830955028534,
-0.33899959921836853,
-0.15457314252853394,
0.05577690154314041,
0.11439547687768936,
0.26855799555778503,
-0.14714039862155914,
-0.1817680150270462,
0.1027602106332779,
0.01061260886490345,
0.09630297869443893,
0.07167545706033707,
-0.26053887605667114,
-0.2810194492340088,
0.7421841621398926,
-0.1127547174692154,
0.08610913902521133,
0.07041952759027481,
-0.1743369698524475,
-0.12966378033161163,
0.18185389041900635,
0.10558761656284332,
0.970939576625824,
0.01554659754037857,
0.14798429608345032,
-0.039343588054180145,
-0.662750780582428,
-0.3434007465839386,
0.07810840010643005,
0.013263782486319542,
-0.13319572806358337,
0.033860716968774796,
0.20771940052509308,
-0.07532832771539688,
-1.1334412097930908,
0.6979244947433472,
0.14860765635967255,
-0.23837631940841675,
-0.38451266288757324,
-0.164168581366539,
0.2702665627002716,
-0.11072026193141937,
0.36153772473335266,
-0.20330947637557983,
0.07918432354927063,
-0.5653575658798218,
0.4030718207359314,
0.2700071632862091,
-0.15338344871997833,
-0.15110497176647186,
0.5486093759536743,
-0.0057054245844483376,
0.11513090878725052,
1.0725200176239014,
-0.06644771993160248,
-0.186859592795372,
0.5936703681945801,
0.4855825901031494,
0.25221580266952515,
0.18452312052249908,
0.2582215964794159,
0.6513427495956421,
-0.14616842567920685,
-0.123698890209198,
0.042287785559892654,
-0.06440051645040512,
-0.6402814388275146,
-0.8514167666435242,
-0.7007194757461548,
-0.5806416869163513,
0.3110237419605255,
-0.554453432559967,
0.4508410394191742,
-0.41246989369392395,
0.18256859481334686,
-0.0060040815733373165,
0.24750283360481262,
-0.6780462265014648,
0.2511017918586731,
-0.06338286399841309,
1.2425549030303955,
-0.5855621099472046,
0.797224760055542,
0.46005386114120483,
-0.5735315680503845,
-0.929660975933075,
-0.18314415216445923,
-0.018737904727458954,
-0.9006159901618958,
0.8144800662994385,
-0.27541083097457886,
-0.1507825255393982,
-0.03376677632331848,
-1.0817972421646118,
-0.9953647255897522,
0.9737852811813354,
0.2679141163825989,
-0.7415162920951843,
-0.06221183389425278,
0.025721414014697075,
0.3690674901008606,
-0.4121483862400055,
0.18966716527938843,
0.5958014726638794,
0.6139097809791565,
0.3513834774494171,
-0.5319016575813293,
0.15940231084823608,
-0.2877906560897827,
-0.5891756415367126,
0.27804628014564514,
-0.6212615370750427,
0.7135288119316101,
-0.04934104532003403,
-0.23867225646972656,
0.0827208012342453,
0.8558040857315063,
0.6849431395530701,
0.27922898530960083,
0.4219912886619568,
0.453706294298172,
1.2318941354751587,
-0.1321488469839096,
1.008241891860962,
-0.49529945850372314,
0.25716474652290344,
0.700385332107544,
-0.2542235255241394,
0.8231332302093506,
0.1156744733452797,
-0.15120697021484375,
0.471586674451828,
0.29651057720184326,
0.04020284488797188,
0.30713871121406555,
0.6924786567687988,
-0.4128795564174652,
-0.388614296913147,
-0.24774131178855896,
-0.21630586683750153,
0.3995552659034729,
0.523053765296936,
-0.22467264533042908,
-0.0368342250585556,
-0.27108362317085266,
0.17478765547275543,
0.31530705094337463,
-0.42970892786979675,
0.41194620728492737,
-0.037643201649188995,
-1.1336438655853271,
0.4635103940963745,
-0.2275639772415161,
0.37707653641700745,
-0.5479967594146729,
-0.20049919188022614,
-0.040353767573833466,
0.06881670653820038,
-0.22605615854263306,
-0.6481063961982727,
0.3693903088569641,
0.2873019278049469,
-0.20958060026168823,
-0.037110671401023865,
0.6804689764976501,
-0.5319104790687561,
-0.44569164514541626,
0.2388206124305725,
0.7716264724731445,
0.5847126841545105,
-0.32796159386634827,
-0.21513913571834564,
-0.054189227521419525,
-0.19523856043815613,
-0.03771543130278587,
0.41176727414131165,
0.7728460431098938,
-0.2635045349597931,
0.5509201288223267,
0.8316376805305481,
0.3660706579685211,
-0.1358509510755539,
0.14974361658096313,
1.172127366065979,
-0.635459840297699,
-0.14375463128089905,
-0.24601542949676514,
0.46934568881988525,
-0.3505105674266815,
-0.25972071290016174,
0.6024572253227234,
0.7694513201713562,
1.006270170211792,
-0.03970129042863846,
1.1103849411010742,
-0.4204113185405731,
0.8622106313705444,
-0.3984518051147461,
0.7990280985832214,
-0.41264471411705017,
0.18218860030174255,
-0.2893112897872925,
-0.746570348739624,
-0.41338399052619934,
0.36690911650657654,
-0.4902344346046448,
-0.25185370445251465,
0.9004422426223755,
0.8797034025192261,
-0.15178543329238892,
0.2551930248737335,
0.3906630575656891,
0.2364395409822464,
0.14320577681064606,
0.3468070328235626,
0.8061307668685913,
0.21495041251182556,
0.6364959478378296,
-0.14701437950134277,
-0.44260120391845703,
0.04722142592072487,
-0.8237581849098206,
-0.768075704574585,
-0.7502906322479248,
-0.176875039935112,
-0.3356521725654602,
0.14040379226207733,
0.8796607851982117,
0.8710761666297913,
-0.9511568546295166,
-0.10332128405570984,
-0.15322640538215637,
0.2101660668849945,
-0.18151982128620148,
-0.2629319429397583,
0.7092292308807373,
-0.36875250935554504,
-0.8337856531143188,
0.48851433396339417,
-0.2561955451965332,
-0.638457715511322,
-0.40821486711502075,
0.07638534903526306,
-0.17333418130874634,
-0.04233800247311592,
0.6842154264450073,
0.3117571175098419,
-0.30370673537254333,
-0.04203452542424202,
0.4287380576133728,
-0.07090522348880768,
-0.2625370919704437,
1.2829563617706299,
-0.5803517699241638,
0.25744175910949707,
0.7170158624649048,
0.7571365237236023,
0.5333397388458252,
0.19800961017608643,
0.5951585173606873,
-0.6255279779434204,
-0.17416298389434814,
0.34671512246131897,
0.5371542572975159,
0.3296543061733246,
-0.5523580312728882,
0.48996493220329285,
0.3087502717971802,
-0.7235100865364075,
-0.5491998195648193,
0.197622612118721,
-1.1973942518234253,
-0.6503164172172546,
1.3887051343917847,
-0.3091002106666565,
-0.15896107256412506,
-0.3739550709724426,
-0.21221424639225006,
0.14172415435314178,
-0.42048054933547974,
0.6649028062820435,
0.7804757356643677,
0.14849136769771576,
0.1294134110212326,
-0.7454428672790527,
0.4191229045391083,
0.07746212929487228,
-0.860672116279602,
0.5745136141777039,
0.7574030160903931,
0.2043929398059845,
0.35343238711357117,
0.6486429572105408,
-0.5888630747795105,
-0.06473948806524277,
-0.05714347958564758,
0.1078459620475769,
-0.06341259181499481,
-0.6852723956108093,
0.2534075975418091,
0.7579470872879028,
0.006193489767611027,
0.22057253122329712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14616v1 | Alternative Speech: Complementary Method to Counter-Narrative for Better Discourse | 2024-01-26T03:16:54 | 2024-01-26T03:16:54 | Seungyoon Lee, Dahyun Jung, Chanjun Park, Seolhwa Lee, Heuiseok Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce the concept of "Alternative Speech" as a new way to directly
combat hate speech and complement the limitations of counter-narrative. An
alternative speech provides practical alternatives to hate speech in real-world
scenarios by offering speech-level corrections to speakers while considering
the surrounding context and promoting speakers to reform. Further, an
alternative speech can combat hate speech alongside counter-narratives,
offering a useful tool to address social issues such as racial discrimination
and gender inequality. We propose the new concept and provide detailed
guidelines for constructing the necessary dataset. Through discussion, we
demonstrate that combining alternative speech and counter-narrative can be a
more effective strategy for combating hate speech by complementing specificity
and guiding capacity of counter-narrative. This paper presents another
perspective for dealing with hate speech, offering viable remedies to
complement the constraints of current approaches to mitigating harmful bias. | [
-0.3977222144603729,
-0.9276890754699707,
0.12500253319740295,
-0.5599247813224792,
-0.17937934398651123,
0.31174400448799133,
-0.2599300146102905,
-0.55511873960495,
0.7140806317329407,
0.661632776260376,
-0.7315294742584229,
-0.14449970424175262,
-0.3771738111972809,
-0.32341498136520386,
-0.4239281117916107,
1.0853158235549927,
0.285344660282135,
0.4320454001426697,
-0.16767114400863647,
-0.6300927996635437,
-0.8138436079025269,
-0.6226240396499634,
-0.6880806684494019,
-0.29649361968040466,
0.9440500140190125,
0.5299654006958008,
0.8169517517089844,
0.33491551876068115,
0.2276950627565384,
0.18934759497642517,
0.11187335103750229,
-0.09364085644483566,
-0.5805492401123047,
0.6018949747085571,
-0.5991435050964355,
-0.3541455864906311,
-0.2933582365512848,
0.27077969908714294,
0.5347639322280884,
0.48273247480392456,
-0.0371774397790432,
0.3353579640388489,
-0.08628979325294495,
0.44464775919914246,
-0.604361891746521,
-0.7421572804450989,
-0.5355724692344666,
0.1117074266076088,
-0.4607934355735779,
0.06297498196363449,
-0.23087339103221893,
-0.247029647231102,
-0.03438441455364227,
-0.46398231387138367,
0.3265308737754822,
0.0331353135406971,
0.31983816623687744,
0.18591147661209106,
-0.2837994694709778,
-0.171007439494133,
-0.9649597406387329,
0.5740683078765869,
-0.7162808179855347,
0.27052444219589233,
0.3164765238761902,
0.44182538986206055,
0.375751793384552,
-0.4718787372112274,
-0.7379335165023804,
-0.4454529881477356,
0.04598679021000862,
0.22195710241794586,
-0.42493730783462524,
-0.029423363506793976,
0.36633169651031494,
0.21213413774967194,
-0.4865312874317169,
0.3160821497440338,
-0.3655094504356384,
-0.2692352533340454,
0.6998836398124695,
0.330059289932251,
0.4364446997642517,
0.023474019020795822,
-0.11354856193065643,
0.19433391094207764,
-0.7379316091537476,
0.040591735392808914,
0.9435544013977051,
0.5035887956619263,
0.15260568261146545,
0.5041817426681519,
-0.2192726582288742,
0.5424070358276367,
0.04410318657755852,
-0.29801008105278015,
0.13419125974178314,
-0.14260801672935486,
0.061823274940252304,
0.5575565695762634,
0.12956057488918304,
0.5454047322273254,
-0.017848588526248932,
-0.1734520047903061,
0.3038502633571625,
0.40184804797172546,
0.5344097018241882,
-0.4873090386390686,
-0.06144605204463005,
-0.02578163333237171,
-0.5357140898704529,
-0.059858616441488266,
-0.41517505049705505,
-0.9691675305366516,
-0.683229386806488,
-0.2831197679042816,
0.11247192323207855,
-0.18507154285907745,
-0.20528070628643036,
-0.4342910349369049,
-0.6886406540870667,
0.3533512353897095,
0.16889430582523346,
-0.7005518078804016,
0.5441386699676514,
0.5961777567863464,
0.8201513886451721,
-0.29419785737991333,
0.21069598197937012,
-0.6231968402862549,
0.5415224432945251,
-0.3158293068408966,
0.6768696308135986,
-0.9727421998977661,
-0.35307422280311584,
-0.1260399967432022,
-0.1764936000108719,
0.4693475663661957,
-0.37632036209106445,
1.1829907894134521,
-0.27532216906547546,
0.27659228444099426,
-0.48162081837654114,
-0.41758066415786743,
-0.3282511234283447,
0.20531131327152252,
-0.3573077321052551,
0.7468822002410889,
-0.03655005991458893,
-0.8286262154579163,
0.2400682121515274,
-0.5114395618438721,
-0.5901996493339539,
0.20434686541557312,
-0.12990309298038483,
-0.35281169414520264,
0.20001696050167084,
-0.0650959312915802,
-0.5064170360565186,
-0.2775343954563141,
0.13701622188091278,
-0.5313303470611572,
-0.19828492403030396,
-0.02886434830725193,
-0.5683618783950806,
0.720419704914093,
0.27538976073265076,
-0.5360893607139587,
0.3985644280910492,
-0.5362446308135986,
-0.3420201539993286,
0.17657504975795746,
0.373116672039032,
-0.7598598599433899,
-0.0002337706828257069,
-0.10471106320619583,
0.029863722622394562,
0.08947841823101044,
-0.9194896817207336,
-0.12480151653289795,
-0.5187857747077942,
-0.07407309859991074,
0.8602328300476074,
-0.34424179792404175,
0.3716392517089844,
-0.7921615839004517,
0.8432105779647827,
-0.38362881541252136,
0.06960757076740265,
0.09346289187669754,
-0.6125659942626953,
-0.6955810785293579,
-0.010415609925985336,
-0.16170574724674225,
0.8050537109375,
-0.7836467623710632,
-0.11845188587903976,
0.22154434025287628,
-0.5250585675239563,
-0.5856789350509644,
-0.38425180315971375,
0.5187652111053467,
1.1187819242477417,
0.7283462882041931,
-0.2633213400840759,
-1.5573256015777588,
-1.0421741008758545,
-0.7333077192306519,
-0.2462083399295807,
0.35966214537620544,
0.06681720912456512,
0.24045482277870178,
0.26135775446891785,
1.0256990194320679,
-0.31211167573928833,
-0.10768484324216843,
-0.24060076475143433,
0.2216304987668991,
-0.0924411192536354,
0.42158418893814087,
0.4061225354671478,
-0.8646805286407471,
-0.46896493434906006,
-0.5916668772697449,
-0.1982976496219635,
-0.20734743773937225,
0.021075058728456497,
0.08101028203964233,
0.003797173500061035,
0.2388496845960617,
0.14880675077438354,
0.37928009033203125,
0.31361669301986694,
-0.23198413848876953,
0.6290764212608337,
0.35714656114578247,
0.48879754543304443,
-0.7539036273956299,
-0.42016032338142395,
-0.19239704310894012,
-0.191909521818161,
-1.0240494012832642,
0.1707228124141693,
-0.7541257739067078,
-0.06283088773488998,
-0.6739287972450256,
0.3742195963859558,
-0.019733255729079247,
0.17814002931118011,
-0.655866801738739,
0.1872510462999344,
-0.39142948389053345,
-0.023379134014248848,
0.3360615074634552,
0.482190877199173,
0.22790256142616272,
-0.3595070540904999,
0.7950382828712463,
0.32473012804985046,
-0.06799546629190445,
1.2153353691101074,
-0.3855639100074768,
0.24938011169433594,
-0.36568138003349304,
0.7095736265182495,
-0.8644881844520569,
0.09536484628915787,
0.6934981942176819,
-0.46268966794013977,
-0.161469966173172,
-0.075436532497406,
-0.045516785234212875,
-0.6968661546707153,
-0.5320780277252197,
0.4435741603374481,
0.3547680675983429,
-0.38646212220191956,
0.25473350286483765,
0.7091739177703857,
-0.36569344997406006,
-0.7397274971008301,
-0.8501541614532471,
0.4990890920162201,
-0.6505765914916992,
-0.37196284532546997,
0.8026723861694336,
-0.15525180101394653,
-0.5212412476539612,
-0.07485886663198471,
0.09599155932664871,
-0.004845392424613237,
-0.3203289806842804,
0.13489282131195068,
0.07373399287462234,
-0.12927581369876862,
0.16040250658988953,
0.08561942726373672,
-0.145002543926239,
-0.061503201723098755,
-0.045487429946660995,
0.4632246494293213,
0.27391520142555237,
-0.22968097031116486,
-0.018959544599056244,
0.8871680498123169,
-0.282221257686615,
0.2956649363040924,
0.615228533744812,
0.7779176831245422,
-0.4059292674064636,
0.16738298535346985,
-0.6458755135536194,
-0.1875656545162201,
-0.3549577295780182,
0.02658424898982048,
-0.18003179132938385,
-0.9284322261810303,
0.19951628148555756,
0.19379648566246033,
0.1572006493806839,
0.30356696248054504,
0.5043217539787292,
-0.11081156879663467,
0.7672787308692932,
0.3664759695529938,
0.0741017758846283,
0.5042473077774048,
0.3815038502216339,
0.49271246790885925,
-0.6612553596496582,
-0.1256837695837021,
-0.6231163740158081,
-0.43232566118240356,
-0.21426956355571747,
-0.3976016342639923,
0.16588535904884338,
-0.2871924936771393,
-0.21673966944217682,
0.422278493642807,
-0.5850871205329895,
0.26542216539382935,
0.5746727585792542,
0.08022937178611755,
0.4350111186504364,
-0.23676738142967224,
-0.075470931828022,
-0.4918442666530609,
-0.49868032336235046,
-0.49083080887794495,
0.5772414207458496,
0.21950878202915192,
0.309763103723526,
0.3571895956993103,
0.4338698387145996,
0.39583948254585266,
0.4903751611709595,
-0.46273499727249146,
0.4770323634147644,
-0.10206010192632675,
-0.9325249791145325,
-0.365642786026001,
-0.30423498153686523,
-0.48557576537132263,
0.41326990723609924,
-0.1396237313747406,
-0.848207414150238,
0.10276617854833603,
0.3569527864456177,
-0.548185408115387,
0.6830549836158752,
-0.5380198955535889,
0.6728816032409668,
-0.05963902175426483,
-0.5574668049812317,
-0.4644935429096222,
-0.6314696669578552,
0.4351077377796173,
0.3359329104423523,
0.6615402698516846,
-0.08942752331495285,
-0.25145038962364197,
0.865939199924469,
-0.39999526739120483,
1.1010639667510986,
-0.17691880464553833,
-0.239260733127594,
0.43671977519989014,
-0.2525101900100708,
0.3005002439022064,
-0.13144640624523163,
-0.040368370711803436,
-0.020822681486606598,
-0.2753491997718811,
-0.14054955542087555,
-0.3629266321659088,
0.5424348711967468,
-0.2880149781703949,
-0.9291177988052368,
-0.32342302799224854,
-0.5562286972999573,
-0.3828474283218384,
-0.0513804629445076,
0.32016465067863464,
0.3509294092655182,
-0.7055067420005798,
-0.014084618538618088,
0.5029409527778625,
-0.43559524416923523,
0.5670346021652222,
0.7005096077919006,
-0.004451892338693142,
-0.6334247589111328,
0.9426612257957458,
0.3834483325481415,
0.12911128997802734,
0.40161287784576416,
0.4000298082828522,
-0.7188178300857544,
-0.44594550132751465,
-0.15786883234977722,
-0.2147546261548996,
-0.5143969655036926,
-0.20483559370040894,
-0.8358644247055054,
0.09404883533716202,
-0.9711052775382996,
-0.4023462235927582,
-0.04065195098519325,
-0.7549907565116882,
0.17499038577079773,
-0.2738986015319824,
0.4398266673088074,
0.43273690342903137,
-0.814300537109375,
0.4304654002189636,
-0.298612117767334,
0.8500056266784668,
0.5852872729301453,
-0.04782057926058769,
-0.10434399545192719,
-1.000474214553833,
0.06583834439516068,
0.2924107015132904,
-0.488492488861084,
-1.290528655052185,
0.22744274139404297,
-0.16744627058506012,
0.6277366876602173,
-0.1631888896226883,
0.5562598705291748,
0.8583080172538757,
-0.7532020807266235,
0.8939074873924255,
0.5422345995903015,
-0.9022369384765625,
0.8602571487426758,
-0.3217308223247528,
0.09555292874574661,
0.4096902012825012,
0.5271733403205872,
-0.9847445487976074,
-0.6287289261817932,
-0.9319018125534058,
-0.8692342042922974,
0.41204527020454407,
0.05733799561858177,
0.25348061323165894,
0.02425856702029705,
-0.3002646863460541,
0.16737058758735657,
0.2828613221645355,
-0.9568252563476562,
-0.5884005427360535,
-0.39744165539741516,
0.1001906767487526,
-0.08867684751749039,
-0.34719040989875793,
-0.6347938179969788,
-0.4948592483997345,
0.8209490776062012,
0.2441612035036087,
-0.1625806987285614,
0.06484940648078918,
-0.030983224511146545,
-0.03664539381861687,
0.5742985606193542,
0.5400809645652771,
0.3713165521621704,
0.025985190644860268,
0.39087235927581787,
0.4816756546497345,
-0.25994861125946045,
0.32854005694389343,
-0.1177113801240921,
-0.3216044008731842,
0.17370814085006714,
0.22732093930244446,
0.683921754360199,
0.03953886404633522,
-0.5172044038772583,
0.38814017176628113,
0.1275288164615631,
-0.09473685175180435,
-0.38022512197494507,
0.016290253028273582,
0.09804239869117737,
0.18948760628700256,
0.16932682693004608,
0.04892011731863022,
0.4204305410385132,
-0.8034335970878601,
0.5002469420433044,
0.48271414637565613,
-0.6414161324501038,
0.25441774725914,
0.660355269908905,
0.39573055505752563,
-0.5595823526382446,
-0.12424833327531815,
-0.12393111735582352,
-0.3274293839931488,
0.34730252623558044,
0.9104762077331543,
0.6688611507415771,
-0.5248925089836121,
0.6551055908203125,
0.3367028832435608,
0.2761078178882599,
0.4172230064868927,
-0.11220907419919968,
0.13501401245594025,
-0.7936379313468933,
-0.42925119400024414,
-0.26159703731536865,
-0.6720799207687378,
-0.0032725422643125057,
-0.5857844352722168,
0.11532646417617798,
-0.4500986933708191,
0.05371296778321266,
-0.10396993160247803,
-0.1208595484495163,
0.16930226981639862,
0.03937255218625069,
0.5244381427764893,
0.7271165251731873,
-0.7614712119102478,
0.5142815113067627,
0.44743776321411133,
-0.471856027841568,
-0.14261406660079956,
0.014717571437358856,
0.5629054307937622,
-0.4998229146003723,
0.18630918860435486,
0.133680522441864,
-0.6437989473342896,
-0.3827769458293915,
-0.41706418991088867,
-0.4955534040927887,
0.49338242411613464,
0.48449811339378357,
-0.7440757751464844,
0.143123060464859,
0.153245210647583,
0.6284348368644714,
-0.48564833402633667,
0.17629209160804749,
0.6226783394813538,
0.5346450805664062,
0.4733924865722656,
-0.5587419271469116,
0.277072936296463,
0.16107867658138275,
-0.053274404257535934,
-0.03293202817440033,
-0.6947874426841736,
0.44323641061782837,
-0.027310477569699287,
-0.21206127107143402,
0.07649538666009903,
0.7479209303855896,
-0.029362741857767105,
0.3763037621974945,
0.6454018354415894,
0.6391862630844116,
0.7412241697311401,
0.13706912100315094,
0.7644208669662476,
0.31812962889671326,
-0.22722534835338593,
1.6633129119873047,
-0.3102978765964508,
0.4877811074256897,
0.15409964323043823,
-0.15518416464328766,
0.5183632373809814,
0.2039743959903717,
0.3338615894317627,
0.35197412967681885,
0.5357611775398254,
-0.6521307229995728,
-0.2650456130504608,
-0.7262561917304993,
-0.696921706199646,
0.6105766296386719,
0.29440838098526,
0.1394985318183899,
-0.3242519199848175,
0.23066432774066925,
0.05980859324336052,
0.8510953187942505,
-0.4458874762058258,
0.6598871350288391,
-0.0898728147149086,
-0.5107544660568237,
0.16836193203926086,
0.07031528651714325,
0.8573325276374817,
-0.24658669531345367,
-0.168334499001503,
0.15860670804977417,
-0.13014118373394012,
-0.2092454433441162,
-0.40240827202796936,
1.0346388816833496,
0.07110755890607834,
-0.23960231244564056,
-0.44394782185554504,
0.8707399368286133,
-0.4310298562049866,
-0.19113293290138245,
0.17516528069972992,
0.0895087793469429,
-0.18441560864448547,
0.07838492095470428,
-0.9302924275398254,
-0.05592679977416992,
0.0020014834590256214,
0.519960343837738,
0.12156352400779724,
-0.14453043043613434,
0.20163290202617645,
0.37713298201560974,
0.5682855248451233,
0.2120038866996765,
-0.08977823704481125,
0.2195121943950653,
0.6679350733757019,
-0.6370208263397217,
-0.7118087410926819,
-0.8193106055259705,
0.3902379274368286,
-0.5372678637504578,
-0.37088605761528015,
0.8592514395713806,
0.5988407135009766,
0.91485196352005,
0.42561665177345276,
0.7758851647377014,
-0.24225600063800812,
1.3383815288543701,
-0.2911922335624695,
-0.01005003321915865,
-0.184968501329422,
0.015255996957421303,
-0.6862817406654358,
-0.6828495860099792,
-0.25425830483436584,
0.5919618606567383,
-0.652938187122345,
-0.12727054953575134,
0.6850976943969727,
0.8550792336463928,
0.20911502838134766,
0.5833908915519714,
0.4632905125617981,
0.19198063015937805,
0.23812760412693024,
0.12827911972999573,
1.2615270614624023,
-0.18479345738887787,
0.7123015522956848,
0.05812009423971176,
-0.3438848853111267,
0.1880875825881958,
-0.5887129902839661,
-0.421175479888916,
-0.4133770167827606,
-0.3352964222431183,
-0.38731151819229126,
0.45310109853744507,
0.5954603552818298,
0.4792852997779846,
-0.6746717691421509,
-0.13234567642211914,
0.16395694017410278,
0.48919641971588135,
-0.3865521550178528,
-0.23517963290214539,
-0.4224342703819275,
-0.09214846789836884,
-0.7613885998725891,
0.5328289866447449,
0.2942616939544678,
-0.2227582335472107,
-0.02864892967045307,
-0.06348448246717453,
-0.4483506679534912,
0.27531564235687256,
0.6421892642974854,
0.5204821228981018,
-0.7290990352630615,
-0.5043491721153259,
-0.6135293245315552,
0.3298124670982361,
0.04435034841299057,
1.4427964687347412,
-0.7922792434692383,
0.16884678602218628,
0.21235954761505127,
0.6195994019508362,
0.27213430404663086,
-0.06695890426635742,
0.7059146761894226,
-0.7973385453224182,
0.4721978008747101,
0.5792338848114014,
0.27460774779319763,
0.3192961812019348,
-0.2872459590435028,
0.35566580295562744,
0.40210476517677307,
-0.05782262235879898,
-0.721030592918396,
1.0095404386520386,
-0.5013512969017029,
-0.6157248020172119,
1.0540213584899902,
0.17551788687705994,
0.278771311044693,
-0.6977000832557678,
-0.5340169668197632,
0.38764190673828125,
-0.5681451559066772,
0.42471370100975037,
0.6403493881225586,
-0.3405078649520874,
-0.3210594654083252,
-0.07462484389543533,
0.5127896666526794,
0.5765668749809265,
-0.7361469864845276,
0.1233188584446907,
0.786411702632904,
-0.24297334253787994,
0.1915895789861679,
0.9779674410820007,
-0.1025267243385315,
0.040584322065114975,
0.20923450589179993,
-0.3336266577243805,
0.26431411504745483,
-0.3931117355823517,
-0.26348480582237244,
0.24094189703464508,
-0.46430498361587524,
-0.09807848185300827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14589v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14589v2 | Enhancing Diagnostic Accuracy through Multi-Agent Conversations: Using Large Language Models to Mitigate Cognitive Bias | 2024-01-26T01:35:50 | 2024-05-12T05:28:23 | Yu He Ke, Rui Yang, Sui An Lie, Taylor Xin Yi Lim, Hairil Rizal Abdullah, Daniel Shu Wei Ting, Nan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Background: Cognitive biases in clinical decision-making significantly
contribute to errors in diagnosis and suboptimal patient outcomes. Addressing
these biases presents a formidable challenge in the medical field.
Objective: This study explores the role of large language models (LLMs) in
mitigating these biases through the utilization of a multi-agent framework. We
simulate the clinical decision-making processes through multi-agent
conversation and evaluate its efficacy in improving diagnostic accuracy.
Methods: A total of 16 published and unpublished case reports where cognitive
biases have resulted in misdiagnoses were identified from the literature. In
the multi-agent framework, we leveraged GPT-4 to facilitate interactions among
four simulated agents to replicate clinical team dynamics. Each agent has a
distinct role: 1) To make the final diagnosis after considering the
discussions, 2) The devil's advocate and correct confirmation and anchoring
bias, 3) The tutor and facilitator of the discussion to reduce premature
closure bias, and 4) To record and summarize the findings. A total of 80
simulations were evaluated for the accuracy of initial diagnosis, top
differential diagnosis and final two differential diagnoses.
Results: In a total of 80 responses evaluating both initial and final
diagnoses, the initial diagnosis had an accuracy of 0% (0/80), but following
multi-agent discussions, the accuracy for the top differential diagnosis
increased to 71.3% (57/80), and for the final two differential diagnoses, to
80.0% (64/80).
Conclusions: The framework demonstrated an ability to re-evaluate and correct
misconceptions, even in scenarios with misleading initial investigations. The
LLM-driven multi-agent conversation framework shows promise in enhancing
diagnostic accuracy in diagnostically challenging medical scenarios. | [
-0.4765462875366211,
-0.8275511264801025,
1.1735466718673706,
0.12065255641937256,
-0.17515456676483154,
0.09924786537885666,
-0.4315602779388428,
-0.5841347575187683,
0.08554396778345108,
0.503847599029541,
-0.4162679612636566,
-0.5651295781135559,
-0.6619481444358826,
0.051213521510362625,
0.07080616801977158,
0.9971819519996643,
0.07079868018627167,
0.6999409794807434,
-0.06964784860610962,
-0.019027069211006165,
-0.7224202752113342,
-0.47338882088661194,
-1.1125707626342773,
-0.6503512859344482,
0.2476624995470047,
0.17171919345855713,
1.0748353004455566,
0.518708348274231,
0.4334789216518402,
0.2907998859882355,
0.06640038639307022,
0.4448843002319336,
-0.18041187524795532,
0.40265020728111267,
-0.1299007683992386,
-0.35947370529174805,
-0.7444884181022644,
-0.15704859793186188,
0.4050414562225342,
0.6667439341545105,
-0.36618152260780334,
-0.2906983494758606,
-0.023910537362098694,
0.286853551864624,
-0.3547247350215912,
0.34581995010375977,
-0.2152547389268875,
0.05971445515751839,
0.03139917179942131,
-0.1515999436378479,
-0.503709077835083,
-0.07367876917123795,
0.31371501088142395,
-0.7577446103096008,
0.3772875964641571,
-0.2908723056316376,
0.5270888209342957,
0.41166308522224426,
-0.5191105008125305,
-0.4175255596637726,
-0.8937058448791504,
0.5931527018547058,
-0.7124979496002197,
0.13452155888080597,
0.3698028028011322,
0.4852416515350342,
-0.20565767586231232,
-0.3818405568599701,
-0.47998809814453125,
-0.18424588441848755,
0.06928171962499619,
0.3202645182609558,
-0.13544480502605438,
0.33857789635658264,
0.34428492188453674,
-0.22473132610321045,
-0.3412090241909027,
0.2874988615512848,
-0.05036101117730141,
-0.471553236246109,
0.6026967167854309,
0.5174368023872375,
0.23987609148025513,
0.3270837366580963,
-0.11554756760597229,
-0.09819052368402481,
-0.35289493203163147,
-0.4161494970321655,
-0.16848880052566528,
0.2643308937549591,
0.0026116352528333664,
0.29869163036346436,
-0.01864459179341793,
0.41028204560279846,
0.29731905460357666,
-0.5313422083854675,
0.40907469391822815,
-0.40249595046043396,
-0.16192537546157837,
0.2820737659931183,
0.6558408737182617,
0.7010623812675476,
0.46485471725463867,
0.06368953734636307,
0.05194868519902229,
0.4638078212738037,
0.43613961338996887,
-0.575090229511261,
0.022730881348252296,
0.402821809053421,
-0.5091822743415833,
-0.23129074275493622,
-0.43296292424201965,
-0.7913464903831482,
-0.7482738494873047,
-0.2991850674152374,
0.14233694970607758,
-0.4817008972167969,
-0.34542545676231384,
0.2563696801662445,
-0.026836076751351357,
0.004201630596071482,
0.774573802947998,
-0.3907303810119629,
0.49313488602638245,
0.2832988500595093,
0.46307143568992615,
0.22759203612804413,
-0.2693180739879608,
-0.5331562161445618,
0.3835618495941162,
-0.6090540289878845,
0.9025471806526184,
-0.48953142762184143,
-0.5031254291534424,
-0.10514020174741745,
-0.23300527036190033,
-0.17592407763004303,
-0.5813384652137756,
0.46455660462379456,
-0.03580310940742493,
0.04523831605911255,
-0.2759392559528351,
-0.346240758895874,
-0.03517760708928108,
0.4667944610118866,
-0.5680161118507385,
0.6747438311576843,
0.05926625058054924,
-0.33594226837158203,
0.5118362307548523,
-0.5815214514732361,
-0.3166811764240265,
-0.07530703395605087,
-0.4964964687824249,
-0.360363632440567,
-0.18570689857006073,
0.5681381225585938,
0.4213739335536957,
-0.8064632415771484,
0.4494990408420563,
-0.10693167895078659,
-0.23100697994232178,
0.06130867823958397,
-0.5291754603385925,
0.44224679470062256,
0.03980592265725136,
-0.43214166164398193,
-0.0636066421866417,
-0.23909783363342285,
0.028618568554520607,
0.18086087703704834,
0.04698210954666138,
-0.24841392040252686,
-0.14907562732696533,
-0.44549044966697693,
0.36455070972442627,
-0.13003236055374146,
-0.3030196726322174,
0.2966088354587555,
-0.4290730059146881,
-0.12580639123916626,
0.6015785336494446,
0.14984486997127533,
0.20700059831142426,
-0.9116808772087097,
0.8277128338813782,
0.5446771383285522,
0.48056769371032715,
-0.18950319290161133,
-0.8794684410095215,
-0.43286076188087463,
-0.34175801277160645,
-0.01979859173297882,
0.5145142078399658,
-0.9369298815727234,
0.018692201003432274,
-0.3372524678707123,
-0.37598851323127747,
-0.7067535519599915,
-0.21749138832092285,
0.6191775798797607,
0.7281778454780579,
0.3952667713165283,
-0.20124046504497528,
-0.16862992942333221,
-0.9210438132286072,
0.022092079743742943,
-0.17551808059215546,
0.163338765501976,
0.4558558464050293,
0.35800114274024963,
-0.4555434286594391,
0.6410391330718994,
-0.49763742089271545,
-0.6330889463424683,
-0.19779257476329803,
-0.04057631269097328,
0.04582124575972557,
0.34301701188087463,
0.6172142028808594,
-0.34011682868003845,
-0.4058900773525238,
0.14544382691383362,
-0.7308364510536194,
-0.07184255868196487,
-0.133220374584198,
-0.01962866447865963,
0.46966052055358887,
0.1767568588256836,
-0.9072741866111755,
0.673915684223175,
0.418680340051651,
-0.39010629057884216,
0.63458651304245,
-0.60774827003479,
0.3937518894672394,
-1.0288660526275635,
-0.3504314422607422,
0.04106811806559563,
-0.22400645911693573,
-0.5826412439346313,
-0.2739907503128052,
-0.15202045440673828,
0.34772276878356934,
-0.26066499948501587,
0.4024275839328766,
-0.5127946138381958,
0.07327928394079208,
-0.1961836814880371,
0.22101545333862305,
0.09806153923273087,
0.05213327333331108,
0.013761539943516254,
0.6808552145957947,
0.7049550414085388,
-0.7158207893371582,
0.14595550298690796,
0.2664521634578705,
0.056532129645347595,
0.8218495845794678,
-0.4314814507961273,
0.09654305130243301,
-0.2909233868122101,
0.5639147758483887,
-0.6867727637290955,
0.10673806071281433,
0.17079484462738037,
-0.40416082739830017,
0.23296701908111572,
-0.0809977799654007,
-0.5600759387016296,
-0.32634666562080383,
-0.18707729876041412,
0.5498956441879272,
0.34401002526283264,
-0.16434860229492188,
0.7805340886116028,
0.24522267282009125,
-0.25903379917144775,
-0.6519177556037903,
-0.793231725692749,
0.021429499611258507,
0.04250797629356384,
-0.7195914387702942,
0.3133590519428253,
-0.3005655109882355,
-0.3844973146915436,
-0.26437556743621826,
0.18819518387317657,
-0.11155840009450912,
-0.12322031706571579,
-0.0060879685916006565,
0.32900866866111755,
-0.32832592725753784,
0.5622829794883728,
0.18660801649093628,
-0.14108063280582428,
0.04140574857592583,
0.008735015988349915,
0.8150913715362549,
-0.13519595563411713,
-0.7219142913818359,
-0.39623937010765076,
0.30663001537323,
0.8345069885253906,
-0.021835019811987877,
0.7303504943847656,
0.3988130986690521,
-0.5560352206230164,
-0.24570588767528534,
-0.8030352592468262,
-0.4775344431400299,
-0.33317244052886963,
0.26154962182044983,
-0.3256438672542572,
-0.555614709854126,
0.7609909176826477,
-0.1348443329334259,
-0.1756533831357956,
0.3924175202846527,
0.9701103568077087,
0.014758641831576824,
1.3765307664871216,
0.1523253172636032,
0.12115615606307983,
0.0009177972679026425,
-0.03567026928067207,
0.26018086075782776,
-0.9235487580299377,
-0.08673825114965439,
-0.4355199337005615,
0.1554819792509079,
-0.46203532814979553,
-0.8339870572090149,
0.7834804654121399,
-0.3861275613307953,
-0.22424785792827606,
-0.5220152735710144,
-0.6062580943107605,
0.3431990146636963,
0.1772369146347046,
0.43530645966529846,
0.388806015253067,
-0.14493049681186676,
-0.43311378359794617,
-0.141066312789917,
-0.8069574236869812,
-0.5915124416351318,
1.4455856084823608,
0.26832446455955505,
0.43799853324890137,
0.17142169177532196,
0.4290197789669037,
0.36534491181373596,
0.4181942939758301,
-0.7466276288032532,
0.2903825342655182,
0.13956989347934723,
-0.6583177447319031,
-0.3155822455883026,
-0.3219924867153168,
-1.0886632204055786,
0.6039339900016785,
-0.14524351060390472,
-0.4793475568294525,
0.113381527364254,
0.03909637778997421,
-0.5871462225914001,
0.06456643342971802,
-0.6789803504943848,
0.7657187581062317,
-0.30156949162483215,
-0.19410006701946259,
-0.3676128685474396,
-0.6616362929344177,
0.3191269338130951,
-0.26328107714653015,
0.527884840965271,
-0.016302896663546562,
-0.0845903754234314,
0.384539932012558,
-0.36836469173431396,
0.8914877772331238,
-0.15275177359580994,
-0.20217978954315186,
0.050239164382219315,
0.03405298665165901,
0.46604371070861816,
0.26321759819984436,
-0.1894928365945816,
0.1449042111635208,
0.07218865305185318,
-0.3231717050075531,
-0.6122937798500061,
0.3763915002346039,
-0.8598273396492004,
-0.5550768375396729,
-0.6381952166557312,
-0.53230220079422,
-0.5459277629852295,
0.1703493595123291,
-0.07972163707017899,
0.6296388506889343,
-0.3909018039703369,
-0.4266791343688965,
0.727857768535614,
-0.33717361092567444,
0.14944826066493988,
0.9197202324867249,
-0.04451737925410271,
-0.22327136993408203,
0.3468167781829834,
0.013584288768470287,
0.4168257415294647,
-0.13867828249931335,
0.36153268814086914,
-0.15496236085891724,
-0.6418454647064209,
-0.42304301261901855,
0.5327518582344055,
-0.8426353931427002,
-0.286400705575943,
-0.7519474625587463,
-0.15398745238780975,
-0.5825428366661072,
-0.05767537280917168,
-0.5561087727546692,
0.041721221059560776,
-0.03309481963515282,
-0.05991232022643089,
0.22484926879405975,
0.744212806224823,
-0.013860377483069897,
0.2927926182746887,
-0.5378156304359436,
0.17471937835216522,
-0.17387712001800537,
0.08728679269552231,
0.1692923754453659,
-0.3122742474079132,
-0.255708783864975,
0.40878602862358093,
-0.23238863050937653,
-0.9131494164466858,
0.5103616118431091,
-0.08476569503545761,
0.7363405227661133,
0.3485215902328491,
0.15767964720726013,
0.8571097254753113,
-0.2977111041545868,
0.6487496495246887,
0.2880841791629791,
-0.8734409213066101,
0.540982723236084,
-0.4370940923690796,
0.3747110366821289,
0.3645467758178711,
0.07880832999944687,
-0.4028685390949249,
-0.6900002360343933,
-0.6445695161819458,
-0.4381500780582428,
0.7802138924598694,
0.07409874349832535,
-0.4160948693752289,
-0.24625611305236816,
0.3987697660923004,
-0.06595993787050247,
0.10163906961679459,
-0.1708672046661377,
-0.4300827085971832,
0.22213105857372284,
-0.3345507085323334,
-0.4403424561023712,
-0.10046926885843277,
-0.565624475479126,
-0.3894987404346466,
0.5677793025970459,
-0.46254411339759827,
0.5283359885215759,
0.6158490777015686,
0.0019366610795259476,
-0.1663360744714737,
0.24546082317829132,
0.8456574082374573,
0.839627742767334,
0.2792378067970276,
-0.06532084196805954,
0.34163936972618103,
-0.7907970547676086,
0.11877545714378357,
0.2754485607147217,
0.155875101685524,
0.03141279146075249,
0.3708178699016571,
0.5514281392097473,
-0.07384377717971802,
-0.7273097038269043,
0.6858248710632324,
-0.3011796176433563,
-0.17938029766082764,
-0.29052504897117615,
-0.27742427587509155,
0.10262399911880493,
0.5546045899391174,
0.16246561706066132,
0.32190653681755066,
0.06167437136173248,
-0.481818288564682,
0.09875155240297318,
0.5352359414100647,
-0.1939517855644226,
0.007591737899929285,
0.3918839991092682,
0.03994760289788246,
-0.08159195631742477,
0.7912340760231018,
-0.12725190818309784,
-0.4929408133029938,
1.0300307273864746,
0.5878075957298279,
0.4946683347225189,
-0.3692202866077423,
0.5000513792037964,
-0.06717728823423386,
0.5787093043327332,
-0.36078059673309326,
0.22072672843933105,
0.3680133819580078,
-1.213849425315857,
-0.5105438828468323,
-0.007162101566791534,
-0.5540857315063477,
0.12671056389808655,
-0.5525299906730652,
0.2743591368198395,
-0.4160943925380707,
-0.6968544125556946,
-0.05564276874065399,
0.04281460866332054,
-0.7168199419975281,
0.364223837852478,
0.044559214264154434,
0.4946431815624237,
-0.5045584440231323,
0.8388795852661133,
0.7808722853660583,
-0.4391454756259918,
-0.9393710494041443,
0.005139743443578482,
0.12675204873085022,
-0.9154305458068848,
0.22104352712631226,
-0.01031600683927536,
-0.14905381202697754,
-0.25051426887512207,
-0.2553580701351166,
-0.7959164977073669,
1.1730760335922241,
0.651969850063324,
-0.3606492578983307,
0.12496908754110336,
0.10353776067495346,
0.9579041004180908,
-0.683266818523407,
0.825098991394043,
0.5839690566062927,
0.6370217204093933,
0.10313687473535538,
-1.6159553527832031,
0.25533732771873474,
0.004984622355550528,
-0.25780412554740906,
0.14299114048480988,
-0.5978022217750549,
0.9355290532112122,
-0.4449497163295746,
0.12742944061756134,
-0.18380755186080933,
-0.1580689549446106,
0.40976786613464355,
0.5745724439620972,
0.37389180064201355,
0.4296407699584961,
1.1185778379440308,
-0.02031286619603634,
1.2859145402908325,
-0.4950525760650635,
0.07894247025251389,
0.8259990215301514,
-0.7738820910453796,
0.2174030989408493,
0.27453723549842834,
0.1294017881155014,
0.23881585896015167,
0.2551988959312439,
0.27059072256088257,
0.07598388940095901,
-0.034417908638715744,
-0.3640775680541992,
-0.44472527503967285,
-0.3149058520793915,
-0.6171624660491943,
0.3549962341785431,
0.6817097067832947,
-0.47882595658302307,
-0.13587002456188202,
0.05591319501399994,
0.25160911679267883,
0.030369454994797707,
-0.16886712610721588,
0.7974893450737,
-0.10263644903898239,
-0.7686986923217773,
0.5685667395591736,
-0.059393808245658875,
0.3609839379787445,
-0.4674121141433716,
-0.15868665277957916,
-0.08568917959928513,
0.4291299879550934,
-0.03738264739513397,
-0.5739519000053406,
0.13276377320289612,
-0.3495164215564728,
-0.4101477563381195,
-0.34163686633110046,
0.54684978723526,
-0.3080756366252899,
-0.4204138517379761,
0.4268774092197418,
0.9374418258666992,
0.15445087850093842,
-0.2588178217411041,
-0.8359990119934082,
0.24272622168064117,
-0.124003566801548,
0.02252054028213024,
0.3004970848560333,
0.4520374834537506,
-0.31778424978256226,
0.8869054913520813,
0.3789067566394806,
0.31520456075668335,
-0.1340486854314804,
0.47097048163414,
0.8859253525733948,
-0.45906195044517517,
-0.36247527599334717,
-0.7392673492431641,
0.14761263132095337,
-0.0563630610704422,
-0.15901732444763184,
0.27952706813812256,
0.25876498222351074,
0.4670543968677521,
-0.021059831604361534,
0.9212932586669922,
0.5195779800415039,
0.49894407391548157,
-0.3274715840816498,
0.7202033400535583,
-0.33500590920448303,
0.34005871415138245,
-0.38582977652549744,
-0.5424101948738098,
-0.2989102005958557,
0.5849838852882385,
-0.3060517907142639,
0.4752735197544098,
1.0316063165664673,
0.748709499835968,
0.3936411440372467,
0.07182011008262634,
0.42280206084251404,
0.5550183653831482,
0.5498736500740051,
0.8048389554023743,
0.7400071024894714,
-0.2570793926715851,
0.26530295610427856,
-0.06785398721694946,
-0.43828800320625305,
-0.07490935176610947,
-0.5815719962120056,
-0.9463573098182678,
-0.1011013314127922,
-0.3724237382411957,
-0.39395079016685486,
0.5029196739196777,
0.9532102942466736,
0.7467548251152039,
-0.4138622283935547,
-0.08061645925045013,
0.17089594900608063,
0.21740472316741943,
-0.44137445092201233,
-0.20350205898284912,
0.22554345428943634,
-0.12993820011615753,
-0.6123211979866028,
0.4118328392505646,
0.2339017242193222,
0.10530068725347519,
-0.23841863870620728,
-0.167982816696167,
-0.06864014267921448,
-0.014408390037715435,
0.6081788539886475,
-0.2814796268939972,
-0.7002066969871521,
-0.11652541160583496,
-0.25841668248176575,
-0.3437676429748535,
0.26638856530189514,
0.6494739651679993,
-1.0314818620681763,
0.5641806125640869,
-0.17897315323352814,
0.5771844983100891,
0.44302210211753845,
-0.03973691537976265,
0.9025132060050964,
-0.09975621104240417,
0.017589503899216652,
0.5730721950531006,
0.11925207823514938,
0.128301739692688,
-0.6614445447921753,
0.3168236017227173,
0.2793214023113251,
-0.5776943564414978,
-0.5792978405952454,
0.1089523434638977,
-0.8535532355308533,
-0.3190305233001709,
1.120963215827942,
0.1432756632566452,
0.030276259407401085,
-0.6105847954750061,
-0.4576146900653839,
0.2511630356311798,
-0.6831953525543213,
0.7049704194068909,
0.6787040829658508,
-0.43593594431877136,
-0.08373252302408218,
-0.7336444854736328,
0.48207274079322815,
0.5144460797309875,
-0.6625775694847107,
-0.3587978184223175,
0.6861892342567444,
0.33713969588279724,
0.05039868876338005,
1.099268913269043,
-0.04605964943766594,
0.5623320937156677,
-0.06905438750982285,
0.09746547788381577,
-0.012713298201560974,
-0.16963835060596466,
-0.2298680543899536,
-0.07697101682424545,
-0.0183281060308218,
0.020933350548148155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14569v1 | Detecting Structured Language Alternations in Historical Documents by Combining Language Identification with Fourier Analysis | 2024-01-25T23:54:34 | 2024-01-25T23:54:34 | Hale Sirin, Sabrina Li, Tom Lippincott | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we present a generalizable workflow to identify documents in a
historic language with a nonstandard language and script combination,
Armeno-Turkish. We introduce the task of detecting distinct patterns of
multilinguality based on the frequency of structured language alternations
within a document. | [
-0.21794787049293518,
-1.1877690553665161,
0.395746111869812,
0.09553321450948715,
-0.28024643659591675,
0.06539670377969742,
-0.14361055195331573,
-0.6305850148200989,
0.46859368681907654,
0.8524042367935181,
-0.36784452199935913,
-0.508765697479248,
-0.5007914304733276,
0.3385260999202728,
-0.4854685366153717,
0.8193753957748413,
-0.5399543642997742,
0.06596322357654572,
0.634689211845398,
-0.45414867997169495,
-0.2933717966079712,
-0.4378020763397217,
-0.590556800365448,
-0.479558527469635,
0.30009686946868896,
0.31791383028030396,
0.6743249893188477,
0.7321168184280396,
0.5013195276260376,
0.4793095588684082,
0.019850196316838264,
0.014446434564888477,
0.20515099167823792,
0.449989378452301,
-0.002767527010291815,
-0.3018217086791992,
-0.3902871906757355,
-0.1276462972164154,
0.9206250905990601,
0.6092912554740906,
-0.31420040130615234,
0.23157024383544922,
-0.2705344557762146,
0.6281440258026123,
-0.398868590593338,
0.3234271705150604,
-0.3371620178222656,
0.03301461786031723,
-0.9289379119873047,
-0.4168906807899475,
-0.3402939438819885,
-0.053044386208057404,
-0.5172137022018433,
-0.37797263264656067,
0.5547563433647156,
0.03326001763343811,
0.6418614387512207,
-0.06949052959680557,
-0.3037918210029602,
-0.35152530670166016,
-0.8492134809494019,
0.7333444356918335,
-0.6005958318710327,
0.8012068867683411,
0.461177259683609,
0.32144495844841003,
-0.4788699746131897,
-0.46277961134910583,
-0.7422316670417786,
0.024938778951764107,
-0.2719841003417969,
-0.1796925961971283,
-0.04862825199961662,
-0.022956619039177895,
0.2212860882282257,
0.5878154039382935,
-0.9241155385971069,
-0.03857027739286423,
-0.5530122518539429,
-0.4524267613887787,
0.5591899156570435,
-0.025321107357740402,
0.5874029994010925,
-0.23482365906238556,
0.19091828167438507,
-0.18874797224998474,
-0.32373046875,
0.23731093108654022,
0.950170636177063,
0.4913042485713959,
0.05617807060480118,
0.8432365655899048,
-0.30194365978240967,
0.7951202392578125,
0.1648676097393036,
-0.43098583817481995,
0.21051308512687683,
-0.1467205286026001,
-0.4951780438423157,
0.26876920461654663,
0.6398917436599731,
-0.22240793704986572,
0.22722630202770233,
-0.1440119445323944,
-0.41485777497291565,
-0.2571524381637573,
0.17998500168323517,
-0.26607879996299744,
0.04305523633956909,
0.2704060971736908,
-0.5701991319656372,
-0.15833525359630585,
0.20273804664611816,
-0.7373911738395691,
-0.19640657305717468,
-0.19467642903327942,
0.0677187368273735,
-0.7575227618217468,
-0.4022252559661865,
-0.19937841594219208,
-0.35880646109580994,
0.4121610224246979,
0.32226407527923584,
-1.1748995780944824,
0.20542044937610626,
0.8298801183700562,
0.8068675994873047,
0.03675217181444168,
-0.5732313394546509,
-0.4659348428249359,
0.3141763210296631,
-0.5732514262199402,
1.0553442239761353,
-0.9863807559013367,
-0.4164465367794037,
0.09144692122936249,
0.3432735502719879,
0.055430300533771515,
-0.4451155662536621,
0.6464186906814575,
-0.5345574021339417,
0.4186343252658844,
0.23618653416633606,
-0.2736056447029114,
-0.35983943939208984,
0.08333562314510345,
-1.0372827053070068,
1.3763043880462646,
0.5375106930732727,
-0.755001425743103,
0.5066366195678711,
-0.24230508506298065,
-0.5271012187004089,
0.386819988489151,
-0.2825554609298706,
-0.6694329977035522,
0.13690444827079773,
0.0033872737549245358,
0.1564612239599228,
0.08135772496461868,
0.45249876379966736,
0.09396973997354507,
-0.4653664529323578,
-0.10347133874893188,
-0.29313725233078003,
0.7523161172866821,
0.10499776899814606,
-0.24351122975349426,
0.20414359867572784,
-1.034355640411377,
-0.1753157377243042,
-0.048581235110759735,
-0.6924464106559753,
-0.5850727558135986,
0.05160902813076973,
0.47966593503952026,
0.09430279582738876,
0.16823089122772217,
-0.45104923844337463,
0.3697071969509125,
-0.5773221254348755,
-0.12237538397312164,
0.4321867823600769,
0.20050153136253357,
0.24405241012573242,
-0.6474123001098633,
0.6292508244514465,
-0.06070037558674812,
-0.07823953777551651,
-0.19827820360660553,
-0.4959803521633148,
-0.6627326011657715,
-0.4283560812473297,
-0.255427747964859,
0.6177201271057129,
-0.6270784139633179,
0.10816293954849243,
0.0033015236258506775,
-0.46039706468582153,
-0.3639020621776581,
0.4220157563686371,
0.47549885511398315,
0.36112067103385925,
0.22830326855182648,
-0.21379773318767548,
-0.8531611561775208,
-1.0455260276794434,
-0.44056788086891174,
-0.5225638151168823,
-0.04301118850708008,
-0.06198568269610405,
0.4218374788761139,
-0.08239950239658356,
0.5157137513160706,
0.049640342593193054,
-0.20697760581970215,
-0.11728520691394806,
0.7550816535949707,
0.65388023853302,
0.3959085941314697,
0.6405938863754272,
-0.7554881572723389,
-0.5694183111190796,
0.3763618767261505,
-0.1749270260334015,
-0.3383691906929016,
-0.0767085924744606,
0.1939411461353302,
0.6334940195083618,
0.8299970626831055,
-0.09154766798019409,
0.19838285446166992,
0.4316304326057434,
-0.33737000823020935,
0.5405958890914917,
-0.27789896726608276,
0.6253127455711365,
-1.079498529434204,
0.24359221756458282,
-0.09411492943763733,
-0.03708886355161667,
-1.0304518938064575,
-0.18570563197135925,
0.24880941212177277,
0.017419975250959396,
-0.3852248191833496,
0.5572025775909424,
-0.5016318559646606,
0.1423630714416504,
0.000278538471320644,
-0.29494625329971313,
-0.2866825759410858,
0.6976224184036255,
0.48011165857315063,
0.5646962523460388,
0.20588567852973938,
-0.10327503830194473,
0.2839391529560089,
0.22271239757537842,
-0.44159555435180664,
0.8412488102912903,
-0.28484290838241577,
0.044023919850587845,
-0.52671879529953,
-0.17341189086437225,
-1.0901267528533936,
-0.4008835256099701,
0.2688208520412445,
-0.37423941493034363,
0.59134840965271,
-0.49209490418434143,
-0.34776753187179565,
0.08138547837734222,
-0.4781845211982727,
0.24796083569526672,
-0.09231307357549667,
-0.11656992137432098,
0.6318560838699341,
0.14665037393569946,
-0.556248664855957,
-0.9225951433181763,
-0.39961880445480347,
0.06111318618059158,
-0.23263390362262726,
-0.6194639801979065,
0.3966633975505829,
0.08945012092590332,
-0.6337099075317383,
-0.34966403245925903,
-0.09765118360519409,
-0.6925825476646423,
0.10611873865127563,
0.21552018821239471,
0.45203980803489685,
-0.48776501417160034,
-0.07732394337654114,
0.34305381774902344,
0.08285199105739594,
-0.37201565504074097,
-0.0600363127887249,
0.7674654722213745,
-0.12887145578861237,
-0.43550652265548706,
-0.3578992187976837,
0.8620979189872742,
0.8719140887260437,
-0.20359675586223602,
0.6170468330383301,
0.7596744298934937,
-0.4340025782585144,
0.1703590750694275,
-0.8333250880241394,
0.2720082104206085,
-0.45459479093551636,
0.18750950694084167,
-0.4140128195285797,
-0.8244644403457642,
0.734875500202179,
0.247909814119339,
-0.026320943608880043,
0.6693404316902161,
0.8581962585449219,
-0.09828947484493256,
0.5861061215400696,
0.556611180305481,
-0.17091120779514313,
0.8244560360908508,
0.31776294112205505,
0.18206869065761566,
-0.5577771067619324,
-0.25573691725730896,
-0.7913762331008911,
-0.03742571920156479,
-0.661125123500824,
-0.22912652790546417,
0.23931512236595154,
0.23089006543159485,
0.026034602895379066,
0.4321889877319336,
-0.11758579313755035,
0.5621026754379272,
0.3358793258666992,
-0.35712718963623047,
0.46933141350746155,
-0.30027735233306885,
-0.08582031726837158,
0.16328728199005127,
0.04735582321882248,
-0.8156309127807617,
0.9168522953987122,
0.04283951222896576,
0.4484884738922119,
0.5317597389221191,
0.8771817088127136,
0.5554494261741638,
0.25716060400009155,
-0.7838237285614014,
0.09077457338571548,
0.044615257531404495,
-0.6954256296157837,
-0.4695289134979248,
-0.1004181057214737,
-1.0258594751358032,
0.2363908290863037,
-0.1902415007352829,
-0.945207953453064,
0.49434369802474976,
-0.0685240626335144,
0.036759037524461746,
0.0826849639415741,
-0.5088046193122864,
0.7432726621627808,
-0.0994088351726532,
0.06569959223270416,
0.12883660197257996,
-0.31193941831588745,
0.2611794173717499,
-0.43951016664505005,
0.5557245016098022,
-0.07123301178216934,
0.18949252367019653,
0.726324200630188,
-0.3050212860107422,
0.674759566783905,
0.13464272022247314,
-0.22095556557178497,
0.05487882345914841,
0.486398309469223,
0.6077181696891785,
0.055359918624162674,
-0.34912365674972534,
0.30646002292633057,
0.44243741035461426,
-0.3235856592655182,
-0.3620714247226715,
0.31744086742401123,
-0.45032042264938354,
-0.564719557762146,
-0.4897190034389496,
-0.6166732907295227,
-0.05115790292620659,
0.6157432794570923,
0.09762917459011078,
0.3907521367073059,
-0.6645468473434448,
-0.0769924521446228,
0.18611392378807068,
0.12558920681476593,
0.9167202115058899,
1.027377724647522,
0.026247376576066017,
-0.3823931813240051,
0.5056073069572449,
0.06698416918516159,
-0.1527436226606369,
0.5813438296318054,
0.16875533759593964,
-0.025363773107528687,
-0.8802782297134399,
-0.6010780334472656,
0.23952670395374298,
-0.5002908110618591,
0.06843079626560211,
-0.37473464012145996,
0.11432385444641113,
-0.7183753252029419,
-0.36992567777633667,
-0.19473417103290558,
-0.4796019196510315,
-0.08004316687583923,
0.1902361810207367,
-0.019221168011426926,
0.7887791991233826,
-0.053010594099760056,
0.31312865018844604,
-1.0004853010177612,
0.2980968654155731,
0.2660570740699768,
0.29041236639022827,
-0.3993578553199768,
-0.3592596650123596,
-0.07524852454662323,
-0.3039775490760803,
0.011515508405864239,
-1.3222832679748535,
0.5877274870872498,
0.37695419788360596,
0.961478054523468,
0.7267132997512817,
-0.3386428952217102,
0.3988789916038513,
-0.5644403100013733,
0.5021522045135498,
-0.15401765704154968,
-1.0974489450454712,
0.6364253163337708,
-0.7264717817306519,
0.037296511232852936,
0.5247031450271606,
0.3606252074241638,
-1.1781394481658936,
-0.743002712726593,
-0.4225650727748871,
-0.68580561876297,
1.0370665788650513,
0.12100030481815338,
-0.26191678643226624,
-0.058206938207149506,
0.3122483193874359,
0.222055584192276,
0.2201346457004547,
-0.6525382399559021,
-0.026666607707738876,
-0.23587830364704132,
-0.2769908905029297,
0.09400124847888947,
-0.2713327407836914,
-0.3386230170726776,
-0.02935069426894188,
0.6114292740821838,
-0.1405118703842163,
-0.007989844307303429,
0.08963848650455475,
-0.4436876177787781,
-0.3767336308956146,
0.6996757388114929,
0.7491127848625183,
0.7375739216804504,
-0.37185046076774597,
0.35501208901405334,
-0.11269450187683105,
-0.5910431742668152,
0.06406018882989883,
0.17986896634101868,
0.09506913274526596,
0.23738674819469452,
1.0523178577423096,
0.6199945211410522,
0.09479638934135437,
-0.6072462201118469,
0.2784985899925232,
0.1587279736995697,
-0.08194050192832947,
-0.48196443915367126,
-0.014614894986152649,
-0.34170880913734436,
0.5965560078620911,
0.42890581488609314,
-0.3207327127456665,
0.2000744342803955,
-0.7099578976631165,
0.23569650948047638,
0.42973941564559937,
-0.23520860075950623,
-0.37282469868659973,
0.24180075526237488,
-0.16448518633842468,
-0.7836225032806396,
0.4949262738227844,
0.0032925144769251347,
-0.5298165082931519,
0.6267802119255066,
0.5822616815567017,
0.9070717692375183,
-1.0077656507492065,
0.45349937677383423,
0.20935194194316864,
0.5800114870071411,
-0.14250680804252625,
0.6038873195648193,
-0.3985651433467865,
-0.9128221273422241,
-0.23234443366527557,
-0.9836578369140625,
-0.42248106002807617,
0.09148887544870377,
-0.7899617552757263,
0.4966832995414734,
-0.16675928235054016,
0.23775020241737366,
0.5771357417106628,
-0.24650254845619202,
-0.283710777759552,
-0.220667764544487,
0.11116496473550797,
0.46454206109046936,
-1.4096766710281372,
1.3199048042297363,
0.7043687105178833,
-0.43617263436317444,
-0.4226571023464203,
-0.17883527278900146,
0.3310319781303406,
-0.8439267873764038,
0.8578144311904907,
-0.18432539701461792,
-0.19011428952217102,
-0.3604927659034729,
0.026002276688814163,
-0.8566349148750305,
0.8226858973503113,
0.12326955795288086,
-0.33693253993988037,
0.27901491522789,
0.23720088601112366,
0.7850163578987122,
0.017635615542531013,
0.20820872485637665,
0.8856662511825562,
0.8304823637008667,
0.15524597465991974,
-1.0934120416641235,
-0.06821548193693161,
-0.5810197591781616,
-0.15950532257556915,
0.9554866552352905,
-0.19131100177764893,
1.0626261234283447,
0.4663618206977844,
-0.5288736820220947,
-0.18753977119922638,
0.2810409367084503,
-0.2913751006126404,
0.3494422137737274,
0.36874255537986755,
0.42658835649490356,
0.9094686508178711,
-0.04110877960920334,
0.6852800250053406,
-0.33079981803894043,
0.25065839290618896,
0.7450650334358215,
-0.06461551040410995,
0.793695330619812,
0.6706330180168152,
-0.30349811911582947,
0.5121582746505737,
0.5923521518707275,
-0.005690873600542545,
0.18228965997695923,
-0.29985544085502625,
-0.40231388807296753,
0.03732289746403694,
0.13880804181098938,
-0.20281629264354706,
0.8709416389465332,
0.46228089928627014,
-0.3598051965236664,
-0.4068358838558197,
-0.1698702871799469,
0.5585177540779114,
-0.11816885322332382,
-0.07300905138254166,
0.8111492991447449,
-0.517517626285553,
-0.7974976897239685,
0.5607169270515442,
0.3479215204715729,
0.3767055869102478,
-0.7819832563400269,
-0.22440333664417267,
-0.3281079828739166,
-0.13429442048072815,
-0.3330191969871521,
-0.6039842367172241,
0.9504391551017761,
-0.17189142107963562,
-0.4141403138637543,
-0.40695276856422424,
0.39226943254470825,
-0.7957628965377808,
-0.7273858785629272,
0.09452719986438751,
0.5404145121574402,
-0.08432569354772568,
0.07559897005558014,
-0.30672264099121094,
-0.14551827311515808,
-0.22322805225849152,
-0.30515941977500916,
0.07795406877994537,
0.2878102660179138,
-0.5288817882537842,
-0.051766909658908844,
0.7283927202224731,
0.08765935152769089,
-0.11599288135766983,
0.12602469325065613,
0.49376168847084045,
-0.6860365867614746,
-0.31644266843795776,
-0.8636640310287476,
0.061685286462306976,
0.04544275999069214,
-0.3052571415901184,
0.6371892094612122,
0.6245384812355042,
0.7468775510787964,
0.002559871878474951,
0.5174161791801453,
-0.040931157767772675,
0.3051219582557678,
-0.5871744155883789,
0.6510816812515259,
-0.42252522706985474,
0.09141336381435394,
-0.6932158470153809,
-0.881759524345398,
-0.5030864477157593,
0.44298315048217773,
-0.04063569754362106,
-0.33924001455307007,
0.9401909708976746,
0.8713382482528687,
0.000689068459905684,
0.055009711533784866,
0.2748264670372009,
0.10628587007522583,
0.30210432410240173,
0.0772436186671257,
0.6455914974212646,
-0.015255029313266277,
0.4101368486881256,
-0.3243446946144104,
-0.36433541774749756,
-0.2161971777677536,
-0.8551800847053528,
-0.7763674855232239,
-1.1412967443466187,
-0.11715991795063019,
-0.30693739652633667,
-0.027634095400571823,
0.6565088629722595,
0.14009574055671692,
-1.2737582921981812,
-0.4918394088745117,
0.1455124169588089,
0.4512771666049957,
-0.5672293305397034,
-0.22609715163707733,
0.6363323926925659,
-0.18935219943523407,
-1.0426990985870361,
0.764178454875946,
0.7542458176612854,
0.14674003422260284,
-0.12466101348400116,
0.23611930012702942,
-0.3688790798187256,
0.30255165696144104,
0.2977266013622284,
0.6619181632995605,
-0.5929967761039734,
-0.4201144278049469,
-0.20149469375610352,
0.07089394330978394,
0.25528979301452637,
1.4592698812484741,
-0.08544640243053436,
0.7923740148544312,
0.9611202478408813,
0.13693347573280334,
0.48028096556663513,
-0.12533701956272125,
0.426993191242218,
-1.040060043334961,
0.5463921427726746,
0.09828458726406097,
0.6548627614974976,
0.1790805160999298,
-0.5453425645828247,
0.3371140956878662,
0.3558986783027649,
-0.2626661956310272,
-0.5358047485351562,
0.17630037665367126,
-1.0553069114685059,
-0.3383656144142151,
0.8443968892097473,
0.04308586195111275,
-0.27307677268981934,
-0.8842262029647827,
-0.27272146940231323,
0.32635340094566345,
-0.24318894743919373,
0.9797046780586243,
1.1441150903701782,
-0.4195098280906677,
-0.2189483642578125,
-0.29266756772994995,
0.5238106846809387,
-0.11468662321567535,
-0.6266501545906067,
-0.23566122353076935,
0.711716890335083,
0.11525951325893402,
0.29662442207336426,
0.7661798596382141,
-0.28444862365722656,
0.1376381814479828,
-0.06249363347887993,
0.134439617395401,
-0.24413585662841797,
-0.1573614478111267,
-0.29599183797836304,
0.21305055916309357,
-0.032378941774368286,
-0.016145437955856323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01715v1 | ChatGPT vs Gemini vs LLaMA on Multilingual Sentiment Analysis | 2024-01-25T23:15:45 | 2024-01-25T23:15:45 | Alessio Buscemi, Daniele Proverbio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automated sentiment analysis using Large Language Model (LLM)-based models
like ChatGPT, Gemini or LLaMA2 is becoming widespread, both in academic
research and in industrial applications. However, assessment and validation of
their performance in case of ambiguous or ironic text is still poor. In this
study, we constructed nuanced and ambiguous scenarios, we translated them in 10
languages, and we predicted their associated sentiment using popular LLMs. The
results are validated against post-hoc human responses. Ambiguous scenarios are
often well-coped by ChatGPT and Gemini, but we recognise significant biases and
inconsistent performance across models and evaluated human languages. This work
provides a standardised methodology for automated sentiment analysis evaluation
and makes a call for action to further improve the algorithms and their
underlying data, to improve their performance, interpretability and
applicability. | [
-0.3482961356639862,
-0.688152551651001,
0.5146229267120361,
0.7333694696426392,
-0.4763904809951782,
0.34422656893730164,
-0.2901151180267334,
-0.795480489730835,
0.13883091509342194,
0.21327683329582214,
-0.5249552130699158,
-0.5498625636100769,
-0.9091811776161194,
0.42301827669143677,
-0.2870931029319763,
1.0794222354888916,
-0.23172609508037567,
0.2886979281902313,
-0.258034884929657,
-0.3469454050064087,
-0.3724473714828491,
-0.7288273572921753,
-0.6052343845367432,
-0.1536531150341034,
0.43484747409820557,
0.2626325786113739,
0.8181269764900208,
-0.07737122476100922,
0.8106386661529541,
0.33269187808036804,
-0.19108417630195618,
0.1489766538143158,
-0.2392711192369461,
0.18986819684505463,
0.046841688454151154,
-0.296164333820343,
-0.5121937990188599,
0.015450947917997837,
0.4340512752532959,
0.6405025124549866,
-0.24876342713832855,
0.2559352517127991,
0.00038572843186557293,
0.483687162399292,
-0.4321776330471039,
0.32076823711395264,
-0.552623987197876,
0.12613441050052643,
-0.09952337294816971,
0.13274025917053223,
-0.2220023274421692,
-0.4022888243198395,
0.12542933225631714,
-0.2747339904308319,
-0.211761936545372,
0.01628713868558407,
0.5900817513465881,
0.5682465434074402,
-0.42705756425857544,
-0.4360668957233429,
-0.6072120070457458,
0.8851417303085327,
-0.8572892546653748,
0.16945290565490723,
-0.2417648285627365,
0.21928741037845612,
-0.06679680943489075,
-0.7203506231307983,
-0.6180940270423889,
-0.23287826776504517,
0.08718808740377426,
0.4745091199874878,
-0.31924158334732056,
0.05313490331172943,
0.11747080832719803,
0.32605448365211487,
-0.5837032198905945,
0.3282441794872284,
-0.15977799892425537,
-0.07454311847686768,
0.7246289849281311,
0.23567022383213043,
0.16939887404441833,
-0.5111719369888306,
-0.5378220677375793,
0.11526850610971451,
-0.5381577610969543,
-0.03287498280405998,
0.5837399363517761,
0.18806666135787964,
-0.24700763821601868,
0.6580162048339844,
-0.16124898195266724,
0.5063449144363403,
-0.21842867136001587,
0.025293957442045212,
0.4727831780910492,
0.1297675222158432,
-0.1357199251651764,
-0.07270484417676926,
1.2176845073699951,
0.6028780937194824,
0.38051196932792664,
-0.10181406885385513,
-0.26574358344078064,
0.45877474546432495,
-0.001597040449269116,
-0.4642200171947479,
0.1539973020553589,
0.5013983249664307,
-0.4423195421695709,
-0.25079938769340515,
-0.03275139257311821,
-0.9098913669586182,
-0.6205286383628845,
-0.077045738697052,
0.21565622091293335,
-0.04969162866473198,
-0.33973658084869385,
0.21975259482860565,
-0.1314069926738739,
0.40122267603874207,
0.40734052658081055,
-0.48091620206832886,
0.12315589934587479,
0.7743778228759766,
0.7865750789642334,
-0.42431843280792236,
-0.29303523898124695,
-0.13960561156272888,
-0.2613379955291748,
-0.2499244213104248,
0.9136451482772827,
-0.6547266840934753,
-0.5512176752090454,
-0.021173754706978798,
-0.3832896053791046,
-0.15418700873851776,
-0.5469040870666504,
0.8973233699798584,
-0.5046037435531616,
0.47669363021850586,
-0.1825868934392929,
-0.3686320185661316,
-0.2947927713394165,
0.5321416854858398,
-0.6817739009857178,
1.274702548980713,
0.009437470696866512,
-0.9455623626708984,
0.12046651542186737,
-0.9512341618537903,
-0.3861164450645447,
-0.11258050054311752,
-0.17740431427955627,
-0.36885520815849304,
-0.023167410865426064,
0.3062504827976227,
0.6602625846862793,
-0.5129356980323792,
0.4969685673713684,
-0.45424965023994446,
-0.32758381962776184,
0.6283779740333557,
-0.6694241762161255,
0.5175763964653015,
0.3032521903514862,
-0.4590684175491333,
0.04857206717133522,
-0.6078809499740601,
-0.11786435544490814,
-0.0280343946069479,
-0.3989497721195221,
0.08129489421844482,
0.12429744005203247,
0.40565401315689087,
0.5508406758308411,
0.3556116819381714,
-0.5724457502365112,
0.16198813915252686,
-0.5322145223617554,
0.5735540986061096,
0.6614607572555542,
-0.06123648211359978,
0.08856317400932312,
-0.030734723433852196,
0.7925909757614136,
0.16615383327007294,
0.2956733703613281,
0.1501268744468689,
-0.7874786853790283,
-0.7783529758453369,
-0.0010012069251388311,
0.18505463004112244,
0.8979943990707397,
-0.6837562918663025,
0.1004057377576828,
-0.36244481801986694,
-0.36466991901397705,
-0.7131243348121643,
0.023781051859259605,
0.16175976395606995,
0.2715253531932831,
0.23764640092849731,
-0.3551792502403259,
-0.6032361388206482,
-0.8694139122962952,
-0.564308226108551,
-0.3768669664859772,
0.163892462849617,
0.1920117735862732,
0.3696819543838501,
-0.6241299510002136,
0.830985426902771,
-0.17429274320602417,
0.058273036032915115,
-0.4071608781814575,
0.24387380480766296,
0.4282718300819397,
0.038465362042188644,
0.4643002152442932,
-0.8409395217895508,
-0.6450210809707642,
0.15245649218559265,
-0.7319455742835999,
-0.1261247843503952,
-0.04061279073357582,
0.2149447649717331,
0.5493611097335815,
0.27141326665878296,
-0.7015199065208435,
0.2894819676876068,
0.9369057416915894,
-0.03201517090201378,
0.6213073134422302,
0.2078867405653,
0.2906873822212219,
-1.0882538557052612,
0.17184807360172272,
-0.0648326501250267,
-0.2445772886276245,
-0.518667459487915,
-0.06138702481985092,
-0.013209627009928226,
-0.08829497545957565,
-0.592423141002655,
0.6988798975944519,
-0.2077440470457077,
-0.23325996100902557,
-0.2220108062028885,
0.30268847942352295,
-0.1615387201309204,
0.3424460291862488,
0.027246836572885513,
0.7690595388412476,
0.4046339988708496,
-0.06796350330114365,
0.5235093832015991,
0.017159976065158844,
-0.3361922800540924,
0.41473644971847534,
-0.6549891829490662,
0.13455434143543243,
-0.07199916988611221,
0.30062979459762573,
-1.4012835025787354,
-0.2252032607793808,
0.6600359082221985,
-0.5503666400909424,
0.07326137274503708,
0.05544209107756615,
-0.6403403878211975,
-0.3563745617866516,
-0.3028861880302429,
0.26092836260795593,
0.3892193138599396,
-0.3289237320423126,
0.797278881072998,
0.240266814827919,
-0.3731524646282196,
-1.0307525396347046,
-0.547535240650177,
0.3968890905380249,
-0.5239673256874084,
-0.6800490617752075,
0.0031004755292087793,
-0.06350135803222656,
-0.6519619226455688,
-0.17552898824214935,
-0.02133924514055252,
-0.0781872570514679,
0.10911213606595993,
0.434978723526001,
0.4124012589454651,
-0.07743591070175171,
0.018375609070062637,
-0.07891373336315155,
-0.26090824604034424,
0.1231667622923851,
-0.015600734390318394,
0.6261475682258606,
-0.46882107853889465,
-0.4469779431819916,
-0.3600444197654724,
0.33872994780540466,
0.7965218424797058,
-0.15382595360279083,
0.6604276299476624,
0.7963842749595642,
-0.10346592962741852,
0.18735764920711517,
-0.7261547446250916,
0.3019806742668152,
-0.45467597246170044,
0.28838855028152466,
-0.14769381284713745,
-0.8641072511672974,
0.7521002292633057,
-0.13381655514240265,
0.042444612830877304,
0.7677532434463501,
0.7046422958374023,
-0.1781919151544571,
1.0940653085708618,
0.4751070737838745,
-0.4790497124195099,
0.23547236621379852,
0.028752507641911507,
0.28068482875823975,
-0.5668929815292358,
-0.0635392889380455,
-0.42095690965652466,
-0.29380592703819275,
-0.8664154410362244,
-0.2567667067050934,
0.4926867187023163,
-0.23919352889060974,
0.01340699102729559,
-0.1747642606496811,
-0.21384188532829285,
0.32266873121261597,
0.24798458814620972,
-0.1870848685503006,
0.3048434853553772,
-0.008375563658773899,
-0.15598133206367493,
-0.07247133553028107,
-0.6030471324920654,
-0.8316377997398376,
1.0414851903915405,
0.3611387312412262,
0.5361989736557007,
0.10016999393701553,
0.5215722322463989,
0.2699889838695526,
0.6210682392120361,
-1.0971136093139648,
0.4859691858291626,
-0.27346739172935486,
-0.5989478826522827,
-0.03888934105634689,
-0.3792259097099304,
-0.8988340497016907,
0.44926729798316956,
-0.2045595347881317,
-0.6206163763999939,
-0.16728150844573975,
-0.19839909672737122,
-0.15043480694293976,
0.1271536648273468,
-0.7217108607292175,
0.7904996275901794,
-0.26391837000846863,
-0.10999415069818497,
-0.16007612645626068,
-0.7899019718170166,
0.37116044759750366,
-0.15307702124118805,
0.5482172966003418,
-0.1458362191915512,
-0.2237171083688736,
0.5625358819961548,
-0.0450495108962059,
1.0892291069030762,
0.005227795336395502,
-0.28560006618499756,
0.3321601450443268,
-0.1514647752046585,
0.45342230796813965,
0.1289820671081543,
-0.5311098098754883,
0.5065243244171143,
-0.01296157669275999,
-0.2505224347114563,
-0.390307754278183,
0.5617315769195557,
-1.0686219930648804,
-0.5452008843421936,
-0.5500625967979431,
-0.4514578878879547,
-0.3809122145175934,
-0.09524357318878174,
0.3194071650505066,
0.09754825383424759,
-0.27114972472190857,
-0.1544116586446762,
0.19896742701530457,
-0.4106563329696655,
0.5055637359619141,
0.38562628626823425,
-0.14756333827972412,
-0.41975638270378113,
0.6029694676399231,
-0.03321840614080429,
0.1205175444483757,
0.325281023979187,
0.0958842933177948,
-0.4273674190044403,
-0.4321364164352417,
-0.6090195775032043,
0.2325364649295807,
-1.0037572383880615,
-0.025448765605688095,
-0.5937906503677368,
-0.056606221944093704,
-0.3405645787715912,
-0.06866785883903503,
-0.4638840854167938,
-0.5681809782981873,
-0.1384042501449585,
0.034788087010383606,
0.3255552351474762,
0.7400029897689819,
0.07380462437868118,
0.46786653995513916,
-0.9206172227859497,
0.08327116072177887,
-0.051366787403821945,
0.2268449068069458,
-0.3287632465362549,
-0.33218395709991455,
0.02137700468301773,
-0.06619787961244583,
-0.35687917470932007,
-1.0385351181030273,
0.5320938229560852,
0.03998066857457161,
0.5643308758735657,
0.46566784381866455,
-0.08897688239812851,
0.6030587553977966,
-0.2660205364227295,
0.8594833016395569,
0.23107679188251495,
-0.8863708972930908,
0.29608994722366333,
-0.37537938356399536,
0.07319331914186478,
0.3213322162628174,
0.4031294584274292,
-1.0302340984344482,
-0.4590755105018616,
-0.6547454595565796,
-1.0336029529571533,
0.48238298296928406,
0.10555849969387054,
0.1625656634569168,
0.012153564020991325,
0.45215341448783875,
0.2754342555999756,
0.3391386568546295,
-1.031744360923767,
-0.34660303592681885,
-0.038563452661037445,
-0.4297794699668884,
-0.33286377787590027,
-0.21725285053253174,
-0.0057774493470788,
0.1335570365190506,
0.43661752343177795,
-0.0527830645442009,
0.3161996603012085,
-0.08190084248781204,
-0.13450293242931366,
0.0181694645434618,
0.40685051679611206,
0.3074856102466583,
0.49142566323280334,
-0.10470638424158096,
-0.09115082770586014,
0.4951220154762268,
-0.4479231536388397,
0.02477938123047352,
0.20232214033603668,
0.08133087307214737,
0.003217254765331745,
0.46559616923332214,
0.6431922912597656,
0.24399875104427338,
-0.9069982767105103,
0.5363821983337402,
-0.2447611540555954,
0.027537435293197632,
-0.48187926411628723,
-0.004774921108037233,
0.16054506599903107,
0.3883790671825409,
0.1391717940568924,
0.2588393986225128,
0.2997378706932068,
-0.4015228748321533,
-0.25897103548049927,
0.44143006205558777,
-0.3678736090660095,
-0.20202916860580444,
0.40282395482063293,
0.16123510897159576,
-0.0031072963029146194,
0.5756140351295471,
-0.12535648047924042,
-0.7693636417388916,
0.6176577210426331,
0.1762402206659317,
0.9809045791625977,
-0.19403541088104248,
0.17829495668411255,
0.10680451989173889,
0.35013237595558167,
-0.11056021600961685,
0.464392751455307,
0.24290543794631958,
-0.7721471786499023,
-0.663232147693634,
-0.6651217341423035,
-0.7168899178504944,
-0.20496739447116852,
-0.5486950278282166,
0.25078698992729187,
-0.2250559777021408,
-0.2088911086320877,
-0.22828233242034912,
0.1410931497812271,
-0.6025788187980652,
0.26940804719924927,
0.20598720014095306,
0.6903129816055298,
-0.941287100315094,
0.712009847164154,
1.052565574645996,
-0.08204437792301178,
-0.6374711990356445,
0.03858989477157593,
0.09350842237472534,
-0.8025484085083008,
0.5141575336456299,
0.32621127367019653,
-0.23292382061481476,
-0.17172789573669434,
-0.3700460195541382,
-0.8573899865150452,
0.8680291175842285,
0.22146497666835785,
-0.5197293162345886,
0.3981351852416992,
0.5068124532699585,
0.7753698229789734,
-0.25112730264663696,
0.5315170288085938,
0.5458657145500183,
0.6157141923904419,
0.2405717968940735,
-1.0714151859283447,
-0.3627702295780182,
-0.3725760281085968,
-0.22422757744789124,
0.16270144283771515,
-0.7339178323745728,
0.7912392020225525,
-0.09909699857234955,
-0.27193599939346313,
0.060059282928705215,
0.5060181617736816,
0.17694473266601562,
0.41767266392707825,
0.4168841540813446,
0.4453465938568115,
0.793328046798706,
-0.1365916132926941,
1.181931495666504,
-0.26422303915023804,
0.36781707406044006,
0.8309810161590576,
-0.4930555522441864,
1.2610116004943848,
0.5411686301231384,
-0.41208869218826294,
0.49105677008628845,
0.956988513469696,
0.08300307393074036,
0.10598810762166977,
0.019460486248135567,
-0.34670621156692505,
-0.2139841765165329,
0.1569976657629013,
-0.3681480288505554,
0.6993216276168823,
0.5588732957839966,
-0.13013939559459686,
-0.10125690698623657,
-0.11873981356620789,
0.2258865088224411,
-0.17769676446914673,
-0.258246511220932,
0.5771571397781372,
0.17541514337062836,
-0.6122137904167175,
0.28863516449928284,
0.4083690941333771,
0.9574192762374878,
-0.3918803036212921,
0.3787693977355957,
-0.29405778646469116,
0.1477654129266739,
-0.26347070932388306,
-0.8760190606117249,
0.39327895641326904,
0.27489277720451355,
0.16556300222873688,
0.03286704048514366,
0.723314106464386,
-0.05028315261006355,
-0.647167444229126,
0.38587453961372375,
0.7373748421669006,
0.3615250885486603,
-0.24368824064731598,
-1.0462862253189087,
0.14080892503261566,
-0.0270779300481081,
-0.5599445104598999,
0.15034441649913788,
0.4139974117279053,
-0.15290863811969757,
0.863726019859314,
0.5726339817047119,
-0.0697680190205574,
0.02333368919789791,
0.128367081284523,
0.8556079268455505,
-0.6846804618835449,
-0.3608761429786682,
-1.0883489847183228,
0.49536067247390747,
0.08634881675243378,
-0.4413386583328247,
0.8949499130249023,
0.4213094413280487,
0.5887560248374939,
-0.010456692427396774,
0.9226278066635132,
0.01623818464577198,
0.4498066306114197,
-0.3981131911277771,
0.42483365535736084,
-0.47278937697410583,
0.5032694339752197,
-0.4937475323677063,
-1.0309094190597534,
-0.650436520576477,
0.5447759032249451,
-0.6441280841827393,
0.16111886501312256,
0.575260579586029,
0.6190534234046936,
0.10589779168367386,
0.13687466084957123,
0.08715104311704636,
0.295156329870224,
0.17219549417495728,
0.4554385840892792,
1.5225564241409302,
-0.386086642742157,
0.5778417587280273,
-0.05037835240364075,
-0.10573605448007584,
-0.2727518379688263,
-1.1270151138305664,
-0.7361919283866882,
-0.16168805956840515,
-0.26227039098739624,
-0.055153511464595795,
-0.11891450732946396,
0.9892116189002991,
0.25155019760131836,
-0.6500217914581299,
-0.3782908022403717,
0.24427397549152374,
0.1483708620071411,
-0.10612405836582184,
-0.22871968150138855,
0.33565661311149597,
-0.3187096416950226,
-0.806037187576294,
0.067551389336586,
0.4418428838253021,
-0.14472846686840057,
-0.16189435124397278,
-0.21628211438655853,
0.2314186841249466,
0.04512639343738556,
0.8696234226226807,
-0.04745015874505043,
-0.9156538248062134,
-0.1705217957496643,
0.053809549659490585,
-0.12752707302570343,
0.21403394639492035,
0.4794715940952301,
-0.6119988560676575,
0.23804429173469543,
0.3355761766433716,
0.4423394799232483,
0.21812981367111206,
0.08732636272907257,
0.4030202329158783,
-0.5768874883651733,
0.23620069026947021,
0.26719528436660767,
0.41689807176589966,
0.499807745218277,
-0.25916752219200134,
0.426824152469635,
0.14233484864234924,
-0.5663325190544128,
-0.6354981064796448,
0.08252589404582977,
-1.1224024295806885,
-0.3626120388507843,
1.3107194900512695,
-0.2045237272977829,
0.023562217131257057,
-0.061288610100746155,
-0.42734745144844055,
0.18261843919754028,
-0.2954859435558319,
1.0157694816589355,
0.8427351117134094,
-0.1724819839000702,
-0.01868637092411518,
-0.7197496294975281,
0.13609901070594788,
0.42540067434310913,
-0.8973127007484436,
-0.11009481549263,
0.4737749695777893,
0.17657917737960815,
-0.027487078681588173,
0.5197620987892151,
-0.17325402796268463,
0.1977507472038269,
-0.1984594613313675,
0.20458996295928955,
0.42760080099105835,
-0.08376259356737137,
-0.5252267122268677,
0.2092829793691635,
0.28144845366477966,
0.06910081952810287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14559v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14559v1 | Language Modelling Approaches to Adaptive Machine Translation | 2024-01-25T23:02:54 | 2024-01-25T23:02:54 | Yasmin Moslem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR | Consistency is a key requirement of high-quality translation. It is
especially important to adhere to pre-approved terminology and adapt to
corrected translations in domain-specific projects. Machine translation (MT)
has achieved significant progress in the area of domain adaptation. However,
in-domain data scarcity is common in translation settings, due to the lack of
specialised datasets and terminology, or inconsistency and inaccuracy of
available in-domain translations. In such scenarios where there is insufficient
in-domain data to fine-tune MT models, producing translations that are
consistent with the relevant context is challenging. While real-time adaptation
can make use of smaller amounts of in-domain data to improve the translation on
the fly, it remains challenging due to supported context limitations and
efficiency constraints. Large language models (LLMs) have recently shown
interesting capabilities of in-context learning, where they learn to replicate
certain input-output text generation patterns, without further fine-tuning.
Such capabilities have opened new horizons for domain-specific data
augmentation and real-time adaptive MT. This work attempts to address two main
relevant questions: 1) in scenarios involving human interaction and continuous
feedback, can we employ language models to improve the quality of adaptive MT
at inference time? and 2) in the absence of sufficient in-domain data, can we
use pre-trained large-scale language models to improve the process of MT domain
adaptation? | [
-0.21916621923446655,
-0.9544601440429688,
0.4019695520401001,
0.26918014883995056,
-0.02768014185130596,
0.18073247373104095,
-0.4804539978504181,
-0.5156645774841309,
-0.13721700012683868,
0.6946146488189697,
-0.510638415813446,
-0.23200765252113342,
-0.5572643280029297,
0.2294919788837433,
-0.39764687418937683,
0.6619253158569336,
-0.614488959312439,
0.14310811460018158,
-0.18850716948509216,
-0.3004246652126312,
-0.7553505301475525,
-0.9182760715484619,
-0.48359885811805725,
-0.39787694811820984,
0.1664404273033142,
0.39654695987701416,
0.7904665470123291,
0.6168141961097717,
0.3411807417869568,
0.21753865480422974,
0.027658268809318542,
0.48078495264053345,
-0.42281854152679443,
0.23937013745307922,
-0.3276688754558563,
-0.22017930448055267,
-0.6302152872085571,
0.018290435895323753,
0.8819621205329895,
1.001590371131897,
-0.17547793686389923,
-0.0381472222507,
0.4238612651824951,
0.40727630257606506,
-0.3876897394657135,
0.17817027866840363,
-0.705280065536499,
-0.12490790337324142,
0.1824379414319992,
-0.15310117602348328,
-0.5112426280975342,
-0.1264483779668808,
0.2150941789150238,
-0.7478755116462708,
-0.019919542595744133,
0.17386490106582642,
0.8961818814277649,
0.2517458200454712,
-0.32103532552719116,
-0.4628756642341614,
-1.071102261543274,
0.8625859618186951,
-1.0718642473220825,
0.43776044249534607,
0.594269871711731,
0.17082028090953827,
-0.5355408787727356,
-0.5842903852462769,
-0.6071566939353943,
-0.21158069372177124,
-0.08111031353473663,
0.06457605957984924,
0.06413392722606659,
-0.07988190650939941,
0.11700789630413055,
0.1133042648434639,
-0.45612454414367676,
0.38159313797950745,
0.1710132509469986,
0.04066217318177223,
0.5492076277732849,
0.27781742811203003,
0.16022565960884094,
0.11069539934396744,
-0.2808172404766083,
0.06864645332098007,
-0.7336979508399963,
-0.27014628052711487,
0.04493186995387077,
0.47964632511138916,
-0.21886134147644043,
0.32407239079475403,
-0.1537408083677292,
0.8838073015213013,
0.042361460626125336,
-0.05648375302553177,
0.04528753086924553,
-0.43589887022972107,
-0.3127802610397339,
-0.3270598351955414,
0.6379685997962952,
0.05920412763953209,
0.2938428223133087,
-0.1915358155965805,
-0.3746401071548462,
-0.14682108163833618,
0.24008575081825256,
-0.5433407425880432,
-0.0205470509827137,
0.29687750339508057,
-0.2406255155801773,
-0.09534136205911636,
-0.3054751455783844,
-0.4855014681816101,
-0.14275328814983368,
-0.66279536485672,
0.7044972777366638,
-0.4467858374118805,
-0.2870486080646515,
0.2478571981191635,
0.5633741617202759,
0.10334084182977676,
0.5538166761398315,
-0.7297970056533813,
0.261160671710968,
0.50385582447052,
0.7832065224647522,
-0.3302742540836334,
-0.46922484040260315,
-0.5536984205245972,
0.3082360029220581,
-0.5616492033004761,
0.5064563751220703,
-0.49945902824401855,
-0.18356837332248688,
0.16765916347503662,
0.26534029841423035,
-0.3527793884277344,
-0.6964812278747559,
0.4640609622001648,
-0.6267544031143188,
0.4074452817440033,
-0.0447482131421566,
-0.7221285700798035,
-0.24447384476661682,
0.2512972950935364,
-0.40418386459350586,
0.9661095142364502,
0.42703551054000854,
-0.4647930860519409,
0.27110084891319275,
-0.8163046836853027,
-0.5052802562713623,
0.006102465093135834,
0.3923704922199249,
-0.546440839767456,
0.14294232428073883,
0.13114258646965027,
0.568023681640625,
-0.2617858052253723,
0.5333357453346252,
-0.327795147895813,
-0.18775318562984467,
0.5436385869979858,
-0.46580830216407776,
0.4672819972038269,
0.3449486792087555,
-0.10068996995687485,
0.12132300436496735,
-0.6532276272773743,
-0.10086777806282043,
-0.018784601241350174,
-0.37652072310447693,
-0.295297235250473,
0.2925148010253906,
0.18289406597614288,
0.46745625138282776,
-0.006744070444256067,
-0.24958571791648865,
0.3586339056491852,
-0.29754677414894104,
0.5754596590995789,
0.6660537719726562,
0.07319168001413345,
0.4931492805480957,
-0.35751351714134216,
0.4608915150165558,
0.2586944103240967,
0.05527987331151962,
-0.25059452652931213,
-0.1421022117137909,
-0.6978380084037781,
-0.2818159759044647,
0.7262589931488037,
0.6795106530189514,
-1.034754991531372,
0.24147771298885345,
-0.5367743372917175,
-0.08302851021289825,
-0.6595821976661682,
0.1848226636648178,
0.28910231590270996,
0.5503490567207336,
0.37379682064056396,
-0.6211329102516174,
-0.5819743275642395,
-0.44701045751571655,
-0.1458349972963333,
0.019924458116292953,
-0.06381724029779434,
0.22618775069713593,
0.32686901092529297,
-0.4396127164363861,
0.9232526421546936,
-0.09220180660486221,
-0.1290634274482727,
-0.20093095302581787,
0.023268157616257668,
0.16870670020580292,
0.6566405296325684,
0.4279835820198059,
-0.8289041519165039,
-0.5767439007759094,
0.1377599686384201,
-0.9015815258026123,
-0.17157454788684845,
-0.2803349494934082,
-0.007808212656527758,
0.35173851251602173,
0.29794567823410034,
-0.47215187549591064,
0.2792908847332001,
0.8899796009063721,
-0.11626384407281876,
0.4754032492637634,
-0.47807878255844116,
0.28689277172088623,
-1.3894356489181519,
-0.0316610112786293,
-0.04555436223745346,
-0.5899063348770142,
-1.1616886854171753,
0.2190014123916626,
0.10762666165828705,
-0.01965051330626011,
-0.528449296951294,
0.7980181574821472,
-0.4975534975528717,
-0.11399145424365997,
-0.5256693959236145,
0.26849430799484253,
-0.05374245345592499,
0.46538403630256653,
0.18090415000915527,
0.7972405552864075,
0.5298301577568054,
-0.9301822781562805,
0.01405860111117363,
0.14905233681201935,
-0.3055165708065033,
0.4804985523223877,
-0.380019873380661,
0.0006763816345483065,
0.007586878724396229,
0.26234105229377747,
-0.7950744032859802,
-0.4662221074104309,
0.48391929268836975,
-0.48956575989723206,
0.48406121134757996,
-0.2453991174697876,
-0.7496095895767212,
-0.08135005086660385,
0.3150125741958618,
0.36870208382606506,
0.5265771150588989,
-0.5943637490272522,
0.5506098866462708,
0.37058454751968384,
-0.2613013982772827,
-0.30190378427505493,
-0.6028426885604858,
0.20546916127204895,
-0.10998623073101044,
-0.4514983892440796,
0.3375627100467682,
-0.16585344076156616,
-0.20751331746578217,
-0.034913383424282074,
0.14816021919250488,
-0.21277417242527008,
0.3723616898059845,
0.20762047171592712,
0.23794187605381012,
-0.10675285011529922,
0.0005556586547754705,
-0.029425304383039474,
-0.07039505243301392,
-0.27408114075660706,
-0.6314930319786072,
0.43370530009269714,
0.20379319787025452,
-0.3513260781764984,
-0.6651056408882141,
0.36488065123558044,
0.6498978734016418,
-0.051611315459012985,
0.9521741271018982,
0.44421401619911194,
-0.6047677993774414,
-0.22704367339611053,
-0.3661438822746277,
-0.0949331745505333,
-0.39445868134498596,
0.3248315155506134,
-0.6202868819236755,
-1.0109989643096924,
0.5241182446479797,
-0.2611440122127533,
0.20497526228427887,
0.30183038115501404,
0.8309844732284546,
-0.2543068528175354,
1.086363673210144,
0.8012600541114807,
-0.09871806204319,
0.4547808766365051,
0.004053032025694847,
0.14417357742786407,
-0.9399951100349426,
0.27022579312324524,
-0.4112456440925598,
-0.05997724086046219,
-0.4662284851074219,
-0.46887412667274475,
0.005862902849912643,
0.3842242658138275,
-0.07162854820489883,
0.5908446311950684,
-0.1247720941901207,
0.025274934247136116,
0.23436112701892853,
0.01853756047785282,
0.278836727142334,
0.18399444222450256,
-0.12141673266887665,
-0.04801228269934654,
-1.0034347772598267,
-0.7253689169883728,
0.8802936673164368,
0.3990965783596039,
0.5345752239227295,
-0.006893008016049862,
0.08216951042413712,
0.38814666867256165,
0.7086219787597656,
-0.5530058145523071,
0.22763259708881378,
-0.10743044316768646,
-0.44127416610717773,
-0.2995847165584564,
-0.5043535232543945,
-0.8975933194160461,
0.28761765360832214,
-0.2887955904006958,
-0.4182068705558777,
0.0560370571911335,
0.4060642719268799,
-0.08560018986463547,
0.32238587737083435,
-0.6185382604598999,
0.7638502717018127,
-0.1380094289779663,
-0.5023068189620972,
-0.16910907626152039,
-0.5953390598297119,
0.09739898890256882,
-0.5866460800170898,
0.6287189722061157,
0.015089081600308418,
0.08609944581985474,
0.3650374710559845,
-0.2728003263473511,
0.9995740056037903,
-0.19721974432468414,
-0.3165834844112396,
0.2783081531524658,
0.29424887895584106,
0.7503567337989807,
-0.2157849371433258,
-0.34128302335739136,
0.1648988425731659,
-0.03812360763549805,
-0.7409460544586182,
-0.6088000535964966,
0.5182064175605774,
-0.7717945575714111,
-0.48030853271484375,
-0.17061051726341248,
-0.8392912149429321,
-0.42756471037864685,
0.012528891675174236,
0.021591823548078537,
0.34360480308532715,
-0.05022336170077324,
-0.06686335057020187,
0.5740127563476562,
-0.27865126729011536,
0.4156041145324707,
0.7500476241111755,
-0.3335999548435211,
-0.3485778272151947,
0.8960661888122559,
0.12139546126127243,
0.681551456451416,
0.4802664816379547,
-0.08699548244476318,
-0.03887418657541275,
-0.7930465936660767,
-0.6992114186286926,
0.20047929883003235,
-0.5067857503890991,
-0.03280172869563103,
-0.6240911483764648,
-0.15302816033363342,
-0.30159932374954224,
-0.1630084216594696,
-0.24434329569339752,
-0.4636189341545105,
-0.36704307794570923,
0.19508682191371918,
0.33204028010368347,
0.6657770276069641,
0.04051046818494797,
0.5570380687713623,
-0.9549840092658997,
0.1449182778596878,
-0.08164365589618683,
0.33627229928970337,
-0.047208789736032486,
-1.0232902765274048,
-0.6124857664108276,
0.39017289876937866,
-0.11469429731369019,
-0.6279697418212891,
0.6621596217155457,
0.17174480855464935,
0.5511743426322937,
-0.14366336166858673,
-0.12908178567886353,
0.7408995628356934,
-0.5899911522865295,
0.8723173141479492,
-0.1822354942560196,
-0.979705810546875,
0.2243240922689438,
-0.3528900444507599,
0.21750779449939728,
0.2220214307308197,
0.5000801086425781,
-0.6575534343719482,
-0.34442970156669617,
-0.4297603368759155,
-0.6590772271156311,
0.5313751697540283,
0.13764695823192596,
0.1272049993276596,
0.2769242823123932,
0.6668283939361572,
0.37649935483932495,
0.12362444400787354,
-0.5756255388259888,
0.18495000898838043,
-0.12864233553409576,
-0.364423006772995,
-0.22396567463874817,
-0.12096983939409256,
0.12650874257087708,
0.05291324481368065,
0.8014879822731018,
-0.2746376693248749,
0.10390724241733551,
-0.048738230019807816,
-0.5941338539123535,
-0.25089749693870544,
0.33162251114845276,
0.8562368154525757,
0.9808904528617859,
-0.07729708403348923,
-0.04421059042215347,
0.4599991738796234,
-0.25693339109420776,
0.35669898986816406,
-0.15330100059509277,
-0.30648073554039,
0.08635462075471878,
0.3497872054576874,
0.9536559581756592,
0.22131912410259247,
-0.5640867948532104,
0.2454499453306198,
0.11728085577487946,
-0.25159838795661926,
-0.15902622044086456,
-0.17643919587135315,
0.014285370707511902,
-0.014852980151772499,
0.2504359185695648,
0.22016574442386627,
-0.4501066505908966,
-0.5641425848007202,
0.33286771178245544,
0.22240380942821503,
-0.5867817997932434,
-0.5483185648918152,
0.686603844165802,
0.004637229256331921,
-0.42816001176834106,
0.5197474956512451,
-0.04867258295416832,
-0.38745078444480896,
0.21384137868881226,
0.6610543727874756,
0.8159257769584656,
-0.4421740472316742,
-0.13877418637275696,
0.2143292874097824,
0.1266678273677826,
-0.3735799193382263,
0.06308082491159439,
0.15615813434123993,
-0.7731896042823792,
-0.8269159197807312,
-0.6598554849624634,
-0.6615443229675293,
0.08689196407794952,
-0.4711129069328308,
0.19778308272361755,
-0.2273920476436615,
-0.07032310962677002,
-0.2947511672973633,
-0.1891455203294754,
-0.49351605772972107,
0.34470027685165405,
-0.2415316104888916,
0.9506574273109436,
-0.8008881211280823,
1.3156261444091797,
0.5800787210464478,
-0.2951987385749817,
-0.6110056638717651,
0.13312727212905884,
-0.25065770745277405,
-0.5375041365623474,
0.4004284143447876,
-0.30694758892059326,
-0.023839175701141357,
0.11246640235185623,
-0.48223876953125,
-0.8808727860450745,
0.872628390789032,
0.3412882089614868,
-0.46784868836402893,
0.07984788715839386,
0.18473775684833527,
0.6859022974967957,
-0.6623389720916748,
-0.2308996021747589,
0.3874751031398773,
0.43870899081230164,
-0.10037245601415634,
-1.021071195602417,
-0.07573916763067245,
-0.01646907813847065,
0.276992529630661,
0.12377212941646576,
-0.31802523136138916,
0.5841863751411438,
0.11552143096923828,
-0.20551303029060364,
0.29792290925979614,
0.7693555951118469,
0.16218781471252441,
0.025618504732847214,
0.32193079590797424,
0.3340558707714081,
0.49396127462387085,
-0.11403004825115204,
1.136898398399353,
-0.5156685709953308,
0.3526894450187683,
1.1908595561981201,
-0.6274822354316711,
1.0038594007492065,
0.4240815341472626,
-0.1426410675048828,
0.24421362578868866,
0.775274395942688,
0.3313707709312439,
0.31362608075141907,
0.10249362885951996,
-0.19396212697029114,
-0.19471043348312378,
-0.09301566332578659,
-0.1455560177564621,
0.17172208428382874,
0.5739169716835022,
-0.2220630943775177,
0.170189768075943,
0.2752131223678589,
-0.03973871096968651,
0.3022702932357788,
-0.18358930945396423,
0.888152539730072,
0.033775486052036285,
-0.8413339853286743,
0.9339962601661682,
0.32521897554397583,
0.5208916664123535,
-0.40221652388572693,
0.04560571908950806,
-0.24016451835632324,
0.2934683561325073,
-0.022167334333062172,
-0.5547484755516052,
0.3753744959831238,
0.02326222136616707,
-0.36419686675071716,
-0.4714217782020569,
0.6670098900794983,
-0.6202238202095032,
-0.426052063703537,
0.24093568325042725,
0.6297498941421509,
0.08995454013347626,
0.20938825607299805,
-0.6475293040275574,
0.10320589691400528,
-0.13504017889499664,
-0.24540896713733673,
0.5938021540641785,
0.3933753967285156,
-0.2707414925098419,
0.919343888759613,
0.6797199249267578,
0.23893240094184875,
0.11999630182981491,
0.050610218197107315,
0.6141214370727539,
-0.49160322546958923,
-0.2506497800350189,
-0.6584601402282715,
0.4310398995876312,
0.25569477677345276,
0.03793159872293472,
0.7330549955368042,
0.323201060295105,
1.0038799047470093,
-0.1943408101797104,
0.8909523487091064,
0.21379074454307556,
0.7455098628997803,
-0.6037999987602234,
0.514642059803009,
-0.5314268469810486,
0.2716488838195801,
-0.32039332389831543,
-0.9356611967086792,
-0.5677475929260254,
0.4620323181152344,
-0.2281724512577057,
0.009355970658361912,
0.4727536737918854,
0.8690572381019592,
-0.29594340920448303,
-0.21825169026851654,
0.402068555355072,
0.35385388135910034,
0.3096576929092407,
0.37553852796554565,
0.8770677447319031,
-0.5518419146537781,
0.30898791551589966,
0.20292812585830688,
-0.22800669074058533,
-0.28879567980766296,
-0.9927375316619873,
-0.530116856098175,
-0.7694371342658997,
-0.3909986913204193,
-0.4690513610839844,
0.19776618480682373,
1.2279224395751953,
0.885951817035675,
-1.033329963684082,
-0.5793673992156982,
0.004698161501437426,
0.0513017363846302,
-0.5119828581809998,
-0.19454947113990784,
0.1837259829044342,
-0.4230252504348755,
-0.7759592533111572,
0.49288931488990784,
0.4641079306602478,
0.30012017488479614,
-0.14030009508132935,
-0.4032742381095886,
-0.3547700047492981,
0.2653059959411621,
0.8004699945449829,
0.4069432318210602,
-0.7138722538948059,
-0.45873919129371643,
-0.07261805236339569,
-0.2215069681406021,
0.1727859079837799,
0.6876052618026733,
-0.714839518070221,
0.3673297166824341,
0.32367485761642456,
0.895815372467041,
0.4248163104057312,
0.11517179012298584,
0.8429068326950073,
-0.6768177151679993,
0.06640831381082535,
0.008229798637330532,
0.26084104180336,
0.5689538717269897,
-0.06840620189905167,
0.5093046426773071,
0.31463897228240967,
-0.6302661299705505,
-0.9481220841407776,
0.42206019163131714,
-0.6275197267532349,
-0.35071393847465515,
1.037442684173584,
-0.4012193977832794,
-0.1730351597070694,
-0.29192084074020386,
-0.10691522806882858,
0.3472385108470917,
0.07428684830665588,
0.7132040858268738,
0.7556180953979492,
0.02161642722785473,
-0.15283115208148956,
-0.7896382212638855,
0.3671952784061432,
0.32619374990463257,
-0.8250492811203003,
0.46208563446998596,
0.2692474126815796,
0.3835285007953644,
-0.1321372538805008,
0.4451817572116852,
-0.056298546493053436,
0.00420377217233181,
-0.4223523437976837,
-0.04875315725803375,
0.1377660483121872,
-0.24307456612586975,
-0.4590514302253723,
0.06613481044769287,
0.23512904345989227,
0.05943287909030914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14556v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14556v3 | Looking Right is Sometimes Right: Investigating the Capabilities of Decoder-only LLMs for Sequence Labeling | 2024-01-25T22:50:48 | 2024-06-06T12:33:19 | David Dukić, Jan Šnajder | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models based on masked language modeling (MLM) excel in
natural language understanding (NLU) tasks. While fine-tuned MLM-based encoders
consistently outperform causal language modeling decoders of comparable size,
recent decoder-only large language models (LLMs) perform on par with smaller
MLM-based encoders. Although their performance improves with scale, LLMs fall
short of achieving state-of-the-art results in information extraction (IE)
tasks, many of which are formulated as sequence labeling (SL). We hypothesize
that LLMs' poor SL performance stems from causal masking, which prevents the
model from attending to tokens on the right of the current token. Yet, how
exactly and to what extent LLMs' performance on SL can be improved remains
unclear. We explore techniques for improving the SL performance of open LLMs on
IE tasks by applying layer-wise removal of the causal mask (CM) during LLM
fine-tuning. This approach yields performance gains competitive with
state-of-the-art SL models, matching or outperforming the results of CM removal
from all blocks. Our findings hold for diverse SL tasks, demonstrating that
open LLMs with layer-dependent CM removal outperform strong MLM-based encoders
and even instruction-tuned LLMs. | [
-0.1681525558233261,
-0.7532759308815002,
0.4883933365345001,
0.09885844588279724,
-0.5053880214691162,
0.21606241166591644,
-0.20013265311717987,
-0.7161028981208801,
0.03118857368826866,
0.8980667591094971,
-0.48627880215644836,
-0.590690016746521,
-0.8550865650177002,
0.29391294717788696,
-0.323297381401062,
0.898807168006897,
0.2272460013628006,
0.11596706509590149,
-0.23577880859375,
-0.018192898482084274,
-0.45029640197753906,
-0.5267113447189331,
-0.791968047618866,
-0.36526763439178467,
0.6847895383834839,
0.3033551275730133,
0.70485919713974,
1.2820578813552856,
0.4590776264667511,
0.21745707094669342,
-0.37671348452568054,
0.3347720205783844,
-0.6372974514961243,
-0.010961301624774933,
-0.09414609521627426,
-0.5994482040405273,
-0.4117625653743744,
0.0491236113011837,
0.7414143085479736,
0.6705113053321838,
0.15804633498191833,
0.2446325421333313,
0.11648208647966385,
0.6951553821563721,
-0.8169494271278381,
0.056968510150909424,
-0.6770058274269104,
0.20717202126979828,
-0.34549176692962646,
-0.3744005262851715,
-0.8254371285438538,
-0.13610762357711792,
0.1461779773235321,
-0.5687974691390991,
0.22689908742904663,
0.44053569436073303,
0.9396184086799622,
0.4197274148464203,
-0.22530144453048706,
-0.14358510076999664,
-0.7526540160179138,
0.6512789726257324,
-0.8627703189849854,
0.41897639632225037,
0.4788486659526825,
0.1404792070388794,
-0.14758005738258362,
-0.5855219960212708,
-0.1950259804725647,
0.1826784461736679,
-0.23304064571857452,
-0.11836053431034088,
-0.29023030400276184,
0.21691171824932098,
0.5405794978141785,
0.25198453664779663,
-0.5136348009109497,
0.47560468316078186,
-0.37946704030036926,
-0.36078184843063354,
0.4412386119365692,
0.005943204276263714,
0.3023059070110321,
-0.0915934219956398,
-0.39944520592689514,
0.27738380432128906,
-1.0782939195632935,
0.14818307757377625,
0.09770539402961731,
0.3639354109764099,
0.3807907998561859,
0.7021229267120361,
0.1506035476922989,
1.0444344282150269,
-0.009739733301103115,
-0.1440550833940506,
-0.02629232034087181,
-0.15759308636188507,
-0.6826288104057312,
0.2766285538673401,
0.3973827362060547,
-0.03428826853632927,
0.26746729016304016,
-0.43545594811439514,
-0.42526572942733765,
-0.29639899730682373,
0.2959921658039093,
-0.5735362768173218,
0.005700210575014353,
0.02130897156894207,
-0.4766775965690613,
-0.17118561267852783,
-0.005847015883773565,
-0.44147634506225586,
-0.45687252283096313,
-0.5216739773750305,
0.6498240232467651,
-0.02273893915116787,
-0.07092466205358505,
0.36262020468711853,
-0.024619247764348984,
0.381058007478714,
0.15910851955413818,
-0.5553271174430847,
0.2242891937494278,
0.9370937347412109,
0.7855143547058105,
-0.24928244948387146,
0.08657383918762207,
-0.9793999195098877,
0.11026232689619064,
-0.3839697241783142,
0.46640485525131226,
-0.5498321056365967,
-0.07818886637687683,
0.0630124881863594,
0.1340479552745819,
-0.3841477036476135,
-0.941289484500885,
0.4303337335586548,
-0.9701483845710754,
-0.011276821605861187,
-0.31474435329437256,
-0.6174098253250122,
-0.0204637311398983,
0.09036988019943237,
-0.8256321549415588,
0.7463079690933228,
-0.3863143026828766,
-0.6883789300918579,
0.21534933149814606,
-0.42350825667381287,
-0.5665663480758667,
-0.01700701378285885,
0.06875254213809967,
-0.5197616219520569,
0.17774483561515808,
0.24783489108085632,
0.534294068813324,
-0.22514846920967102,
0.39027905464172363,
-0.08905612677335739,
-0.6516327261924744,
0.18086813390254974,
-0.24421297013759613,
0.7704649567604065,
0.2896193563938141,
-0.5916539430618286,
0.27990326285362244,
-1.0778250694274902,
-0.1708669662475586,
0.006217700429260731,
-0.2875388264656067,
-0.36231470108032227,
0.11292745918035507,
-0.41130128502845764,
0.30068719387054443,
-0.04139968752861023,
-0.3602010905742645,
-0.16201454401016235,
-0.49708762764930725,
0.45774999260902405,
0.9258962273597717,
-0.2764144837856293,
0.6225336194038391,
-0.1105119064450264,
0.5236707329750061,
0.07533316314220428,
-0.0652686282992363,
-0.08322107791900635,
-0.5156009793281555,
-1.1693264245986938,
-0.5806916356086731,
0.24432790279388428,
0.6611707210540771,
-0.68672776222229,
0.4173997938632965,
-0.22647786140441895,
-0.043151333928108215,
-0.7948152422904968,
0.16447649896144867,
0.6515083312988281,
0.7252333164215088,
0.4360427260398865,
-0.4451042413711548,
-0.7514371275901794,
-1.0192910432815552,
-0.7025657296180725,
0.05777492746710777,
0.047086600214242935,
0.035309553146362305,
0.1665026843547821,
-0.06921534240245819,
1.03730309009552,
-0.3102223873138428,
-0.11578716337680817,
-0.2570916712284088,
0.1677720546722412,
0.33449071645736694,
0.28102049231529236,
-0.26303499937057495,
-0.7606536149978638,
-0.1782764047384262,
-0.22944246232509613,
-0.7166910767555237,
-0.22577664256095886,
-0.12598437070846558,
-0.1953684389591217,
0.3303495943546295,
0.7474667429924011,
-0.5434913635253906,
0.711842954158783,
0.16039888560771942,
-0.13554790616035461,
0.493574321269989,
-0.16022010147571564,
-0.26518189907073975,
-0.5242798328399658,
0.18492701649665833,
0.13778245449066162,
-0.5003634691238403,
-0.969732940196991,
0.07065315544605255,
0.2964162826538086,
-0.01912667229771614,
-0.6360384821891785,
0.3966831862926483,
-0.7297019958496094,
-0.2992878556251526,
-0.23453180491924286,
0.09611514210700989,
0.20586612820625305,
0.48613667488098145,
0.08927983790636063,
0.7040507197380066,
0.39356476068496704,
-0.6807351112365723,
-0.1547354757785797,
-0.10940788686275482,
-0.5627905130386353,
0.009596199728548527,
-0.5097182989120483,
0.24437181651592255,
-0.49347731471061707,
0.10770727694034576,
-0.8219788074493408,
-0.0373140312731266,
0.4313053786754608,
0.08904149383306503,
0.7085519433021545,
-0.1299956738948822,
-0.44159233570098877,
-0.35213297605514526,
-0.1251460760831833,
0.5156733393669128,
0.5018059015274048,
-0.7335061430931091,
0.5417462587356567,
0.23815864324569702,
0.06469158828258514,
-0.7874470949172974,
-0.8225807547569275,
0.25712257623672485,
-0.3397950828075409,
-0.605990469455719,
0.26187098026275635,
0.062095653265714645,
-0.18218569457530975,
-0.16739068925380707,
-0.39500513672828674,
-0.1101289913058281,
0.20059232413768768,
0.04737997055053711,
0.28254076838493347,
-0.3663722574710846,
0.16076113283634186,
-0.21378208696842194,
-0.1988793909549713,
0.1651046872138977,
-0.4554175138473511,
0.3136768341064453,
0.011363725177943707,
-0.2888511121273041,
-0.3166697323322296,
0.19043533504009247,
0.3401566445827484,
-0.412352591753006,
0.9380494952201843,
0.6119329929351807,
-0.3955160677433014,
-0.13720716536045074,
-0.720288097858429,
-0.0731668695807457,
-0.4649757146835327,
0.326850950717926,
-0.5043736696243286,
-1.1694213151931763,
0.5055203437805176,
0.045319851487874985,
-0.021709538996219635,
0.24746325612068176,
0.19923298060894012,
-0.050879791378974915,
0.9963265061378479,
0.6104344725608826,
-0.08449985831975937,
0.34959763288497925,
-0.0379905067384243,
0.7318035364151001,
-0.7816748023033142,
-0.36932364106178284,
-0.4467942416667938,
-0.15446864068508148,
-0.3632982075214386,
-0.41513803601264954,
0.16122214496135712,
0.5336039662361145,
-0.08977001905441284,
0.28342103958129883,
-0.436962753534317,
0.7906254529953003,
0.5020990967750549,
0.3698331415653229,
0.45289525389671326,
-0.09458988904953003,
0.1779506802558899,
0.012176386080682278,
-0.8575971126556396,
-0.6538934111595154,
0.8116238117218018,
0.42086488008499146,
0.6458553075790405,
-0.056702811270952225,
0.7479639053344727,
0.1886470764875412,
0.1844555288553238,
-0.5375118255615234,
0.6479309797286987,
-0.14833812415599823,
-0.4373536705970764,
-0.18830575048923492,
-0.36438634991645813,
-0.9215700030326843,
0.3563517928123474,
-0.00782209262251854,
-0.6579582691192627,
0.18311211466789246,
0.1813228279352188,
-0.29750192165374756,
0.5042812824249268,
-0.5231568217277527,
0.7763001322746277,
0.09572340548038483,
-0.41113072633743286,
0.07313442975282669,
-1.0117501020431519,
0.39754757285118103,
-0.1841643750667572,
0.45767825841903687,
-0.04490797221660614,
0.031203020364046097,
0.7674816250801086,
-0.27602264285087585,
0.9342655539512634,
0.06004972383379936,
-0.28602591156959534,
0.2310987114906311,
0.01972617395222187,
0.7545140385627747,
-0.2678668200969696,
-0.042890843003988266,
0.18154679238796234,
-0.4245937764644623,
-0.45964542031288147,
-0.5633715987205505,
0.508659839630127,
-0.5116483569145203,
-1.0219615697860718,
-0.1819761097431183,
-0.3667105734348297,
0.07339941710233688,
0.29766708612442017,
0.3516871929168701,
0.5505051612854004,
0.12044872343540192,
-0.14569513499736786,
1.1219267845153809,
-0.29340726137161255,
0.5311510562896729,
0.30839309096336365,
-0.08959738910198212,
-0.042899735271930695,
1.024085521697998,
0.052410680800676346,
0.5035227537155151,
0.6381528377532959,
0.08150561153888702,
-0.2044486552476883,
-0.6405059099197388,
-0.2903265655040741,
0.20769739151000977,
-0.9598636627197266,
-0.1568838357925415,
-0.7914528846740723,
-0.4514048993587494,
-0.48362603783607483,
0.02433515526354313,
-0.1831299215555191,
-0.45416179299354553,
-0.6387732028961182,
-0.18642862141132355,
-0.15443803369998932,
0.7116000056266785,
-0.1497630625963211,
0.08406267315149307,
-0.8022620677947998,
0.246523916721344,
0.31343919038772583,
0.23652538657188416,
0.050094135105609894,
-0.5306703448295593,
-0.41688618063926697,
-0.09998234361410141,
-0.04928293079137802,
-0.7346571683883667,
0.4434122145175934,
0.18328090012073517,
0.43487250804901123,
0.3140747547149658,
-0.09638964384794235,
0.8272428512573242,
-0.5642307996749878,
0.615383505821228,
-0.11800690740346909,
-0.9929366111755371,
0.436742901802063,
-0.10830390453338623,
0.36715996265411377,
0.17595362663269043,
0.34385693073272705,
-0.2986257076263428,
-0.5949814319610596,
-0.251006543636322,
-0.914714515209198,
0.8939432501792908,
0.2074679434299469,
-0.3018970489501953,
-0.09114937484264374,
0.4005070924758911,
0.12985818088054657,
0.170137420296669,
-0.8449496030807495,
-0.38291582465171814,
-0.03540470823645592,
-0.0849679484963417,
-0.3440132439136505,
-0.4386504590511322,
-0.00846005231142044,
-0.09359459578990936,
0.7145366072654724,
0.16239073872566223,
0.3135920763015747,
0.33272409439086914,
-0.5863417387008667,
-0.20834650099277496,
0.45584341883659363,
0.8428556323051453,
0.797269880771637,
-0.34156525135040283,
0.45312386751174927,
-0.10825540870428085,
-0.16911154985427856,
-0.10442084074020386,
-0.10711817443370819,
-0.18411315977573395,
-0.01436467096209526,
0.43889209628105164,
0.975660502910614,
0.3237304091453552,
-0.6802526116371155,
0.40099036693573,
0.06680338084697723,
0.21017643809318542,
0.27061980962753296,
0.07452581077814102,
0.04038294032216072,
0.16722522675991058,
0.45558878779411316,
0.205844447016716,
0.17572052776813507,
-0.417079895734787,
0.23089100420475006,
0.2749064266681671,
-0.36481615900993347,
-0.1537451446056366,
0.5288407206535339,
-0.08782556653022766,
-0.6305845379829407,
0.5104030966758728,
-0.002836157102137804,
-0.5969505906105042,
0.8143091201782227,
0.7996189594268799,
0.8864516615867615,
0.11258520931005478,
0.03906700387597084,
0.3533836901187897,
0.4109422564506531,
-0.23753471672534943,
-0.1407759040594101,
-0.06730828434228897,
-0.6189129948616028,
-0.702602207660675,
-0.5078149437904358,
-0.12405438721179962,
0.12145309895277023,
-0.9459289908409119,
0.10226920247077942,
-0.40473097562789917,
-0.030186185613274574,
-0.05965811386704445,
-0.34219345450401306,
-0.864280641078949,
0.26665616035461426,
0.21017062664031982,
0.89939284324646,
-0.5590989589691162,
0.908969521522522,
0.3262680470943451,
0.006857102271169424,
-0.7548776865005493,
-0.2305641621351242,
0.08760867267847061,
-0.9308828115463257,
0.817718505859375,
0.5582059621810913,
-0.22757065296173096,
0.13386300206184387,
-0.57989901304245,
-0.8081861138343811,
0.8897910118103027,
0.32946065068244934,
-0.8566264510154724,
-0.22639045119285583,
0.39700502157211304,
0.31101927161216736,
-0.38211995363235474,
0.106582872569561,
0.7303894758224487,
0.3285525143146515,
0.011732812039554119,
-0.8010696768760681,
0.12288355827331543,
-0.06941919773817062,
0.014741848222911358,
0.3073176443576813,
-0.27078744769096375,
0.5748915672302246,
-0.2942006289958954,
-0.5184246301651001,
0.07223008573055267,
0.556504487991333,
0.23592087626457214,
0.5044214725494385,
0.41611745953559875,
0.5911398530006409,
0.7766137719154358,
-0.04041849821805954,
0.8995236158370972,
0.017701558768749237,
0.14606577157974243,
1.1979312896728516,
-0.0634334459900856,
0.6699380278587341,
0.5485379099845886,
0.22214654088020325,
0.2801368534564972,
0.7775896191596985,
0.28070175647735596,
0.7160210609436035,
0.47651395201683044,
-0.19497203826904297,
-0.45773765444755554,
-0.011143481358885765,
-0.15797384083271027,
0.14730891585350037,
0.14927487075328827,
-0.5161108374595642,
-0.0710766538977623,
0.13147935271263123,
-0.0049997479654848576,
-0.03190307319164276,
-0.5478804707527161,
0.7828269600868225,
0.21286746859550476,
-0.6449522376060486,
0.6418622136116028,
0.004681343212723732,
0.7042997479438782,
-0.41184642910957336,
0.117660291492939,
-0.14965194463729858,
-0.13406886160373688,
-0.24172423779964447,
-0.3741813898086548,
0.29649579524993896,
-0.053355179727077484,
-0.3002641499042511,
-0.36629438400268555,
0.9916546940803528,
-0.5722116827964783,
-0.27445194125175476,
0.3504500389099121,
0.4105648994445801,
0.19915398955345154,
0.07940750569105148,
-0.3679937720298767,
0.28708523511886597,
0.046169769018888474,
-0.22449514269828796,
0.3895045518875122,
0.2532101273536682,
0.006649399176239967,
0.7806430459022522,
0.5998876094818115,
0.09643307328224182,
0.5293784141540527,
0.07423541694879532,
0.6462105512619019,
-0.8484461307525635,
-0.22798267006874084,
-1.1374841928482056,
0.46881112456321716,
-0.042794059962034225,
0.054102104157209396,
0.5957194566726685,
0.5668622255325317,
0.9539227485656738,
-0.08682668209075928,
0.2980911433696747,
0.45640021562576294,
0.1692681610584259,
-0.7902292609214783,
0.5126935839653015,
-0.5843570828437805,
0.562179446220398,
-0.14819474518299103,
-0.9767483472824097,
-0.6741265654563904,
0.39244726300239563,
-0.18781501054763794,
-0.3299413025379181,
0.5427642464637756,
1.0191248655319214,
0.1287267953157425,
0.32136183977127075,
0.5099689960479736,
0.3612420856952667,
0.43735745549201965,
0.47505950927734375,
0.8670252561569214,
-0.3706899881362915,
0.29660505056381226,
-0.09415698796510696,
-0.1653570532798767,
-0.004713968839496374,
-1.1280146837234497,
-0.8902072906494141,
-0.2793523967266083,
-0.42600810527801514,
-0.29249560832977295,
0.40823206305503845,
0.8139883875846863,
0.6266752481460571,
-0.6439999938011169,
-0.06313426047563553,
-0.10253408551216125,
0.44723623991012573,
-0.07148627936840057,
-0.2346675544977188,
0.35654687881469727,
-0.47647786140441895,
-0.4822208881378174,
0.5895245671272278,
0.5803868770599365,
-0.1410350650548935,
0.056844908744096756,
-0.07492608577013016,
-0.18495897948741913,
0.1341688483953476,
0.6800786256790161,
0.363762766122818,
-0.9888572096824646,
-0.29513248801231384,
-0.07008806616067886,
-0.3743666708469391,
0.2794809937477112,
0.9439051151275635,
-0.7103701829910278,
0.5412550568580627,
0.3373611569404602,
0.9591308236122131,
0.48585808277130127,
-0.1745648980140686,
0.5829567909240723,
-0.7093113660812378,
-0.1398642361164093,
0.17203879356384277,
0.25222480297088623,
0.23093043267726898,
-0.536197304725647,
0.39749395847320557,
0.012603052891790867,
-0.533417820930481,
-0.9450518488883972,
0.12931227684020996,
-0.785894513130188,
-0.22111688554286957,
1.106023907661438,
-0.25444528460502625,
-0.38192301988601685,
-0.2684686481952667,
0.05337272956967354,
0.4132564961910248,
-0.044743746519088745,
0.5346779823303223,
0.6249691247940063,
-0.08039438724517822,
-0.17106400430202484,
-0.3619379699230194,
0.41450580954551697,
0.699710488319397,
-0.4681009352207184,
-0.009925582446157932,
0.2810257077217102,
0.23548607528209686,
-0.05016029253602028,
0.6681318283081055,
-0.10462500154972076,
0.09709805250167847,
-0.6594457626342773,
-0.20766910910606384,
-0.24788588285446167,
-0.548582136631012,
-0.6192765235900879,
0.06499722599983215,
0.07648971676826477,
-0.20746706426143646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14530v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14530v1 | Relative Value Biases in Large Language Models | 2024-01-25T21:49:32 | 2024-01-25T21:49:32 | William M. Hayes, Nicolas Yax, Stefano Palminteri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Studies of reinforcement learning in humans and animals have demonstrated a
preference for options that yielded relatively better outcomes in the past,
even when those options are associated with lower absolute reward. The present
study tested whether large language models would exhibit a similar bias. We had
gpt-4-1106-preview (GPT-4 Turbo) and Llama-2-70B make repeated choices between
pairs of options with the goal of maximizing payoffs. A complete record of
previous outcomes was included in each prompt. Both models exhibited relative
value decision biases similar to those observed in humans and animals. Making
relative comparisons among outcomes more explicit magnified the bias, whereas
prompting the models to estimate expected outcomes caused the bias to
disappear. These results have implications for the potential mechanisms that
contribute to context-dependent choice in human agents. | [
-0.2395554482936859,
-0.4070952832698822,
0.7730143666267395,
0.004711036570370197,
0.0839574784040451,
0.009718886576592922,
-0.3611639738082886,
-0.5876301527023315,
0.17550772428512573,
0.24707020819187164,
-0.41869157552719116,
0.08517148345708847,
-0.49578648805618286,
0.14479728043079376,
0.059468138962984085,
1.246827483177185,
-0.031428005546331406,
0.20446154475212097,
-0.03167424350976944,
-0.20203129947185516,
-0.6038703918457031,
-1.0001834630966187,
-0.7913415431976318,
-0.8360801339149475,
0.8214863538742065,
0.11501749604940414,
0.9497079849243164,
0.3830355405807495,
0.16648568212985992,
0.2685135006904602,
-0.19811400771141052,
-0.34640559554100037,
-0.5163078308105469,
0.10537347197532654,
-0.39699241518974304,
-0.6115578413009644,
-0.3519318401813507,
0.5160333514213562,
0.6510493159294128,
0.49119773507118225,
-0.14415113627910614,
-0.16510175168514252,
-0.22969850897789001,
0.7085455060005188,
-0.5505316853523254,
0.18907038867473602,
-0.6269194483757019,
0.01618005521595478,
-0.11126375198364258,
-0.2965192198753357,
-0.3430284559726715,
-0.4470842778682709,
0.4092196524143219,
-0.5719599723815918,
-0.07035726308822632,
-0.04799375683069229,
0.9260310530662537,
0.19393247365951538,
-0.4728938043117523,
-0.36178112030029297,
-0.44676047563552856,
0.9762328863143921,
-0.5166736245155334,
0.24441395699977875,
0.6664926409721375,
0.0989491418004036,
-0.21994753181934357,
-0.49932393431663513,
-0.5304621458053589,
-0.8265390396118164,
-0.07152734696865082,
-0.10020291060209274,
-0.017077814787626266,
-0.02207331545650959,
0.5676248669624329,
0.2074466347694397,
-0.2814795672893524,
0.28471866250038147,
-0.2529943287372589,
-0.28797227144241333,
0.24831277132034302,
0.14056377112865448,
0.059183329343795776,
-0.011985225602984428,
-0.21435119211673737,
-0.517267644405365,
-1.0809229612350464,
0.4912501871585846,
0.6154158115386963,
0.12692725658416748,
0.035455700010061264,
0.5423640608787537,
-0.2700239419937134,
0.5611417889595032,
0.11392868310213089,
-0.26199766993522644,
0.34396567940711975,
-0.16894759237766266,
-0.13042189180850983,
0.12906260788440704,
0.41962066292762756,
0.44679054617881775,
0.5366004109382629,
0.012502930127084255,
-0.4490154981613159,
0.27985167503356934,
0.1420116126537323,
-0.5563529133796692,
0.07725393772125244,
-0.1481388807296753,
-0.5361158847808838,
-0.5569278001785278,
-0.14492195844650269,
-0.35295507311820984,
-0.2858209013938904,
-0.2965232729911804,
0.3607601523399353,
-0.12345267087221146,
-0.25046056509017944,
0.20597918331623077,
-0.4776970148086548,
0.4695534110069275,
0.12173928320407867,
-0.9466919898986816,
0.21859005093574524,
0.38753610849380493,
0.6298856735229492,
-0.33062943816185,
-0.48881277441978455,
-0.5993326902389526,
-0.02640349231660366,
-0.35791078209877014,
1.0002018213272095,
-0.7856722474098206,
-0.5490531921386719,
-0.12331868708133698,
-0.1276623159646988,
0.2809222340583801,
-0.7495673298835754,
0.6008431315422058,
-0.659049391746521,
0.3252681493759155,
-0.8328093886375427,
-0.2821206748485565,
-0.19913101196289062,
0.2561810314655304,
-0.6449673175811768,
0.7427850365638733,
0.18941465020179749,
-0.9335469007492065,
0.8287291526794434,
-0.5755422711372375,
-0.38855546712875366,
-0.21329979598522186,
-0.42121782898902893,
-0.342521071434021,
-0.07828278839588165,
-0.079995296895504,
0.1468326449394226,
-0.323498010635376,
0.21884240210056305,
-0.4183938503265381,
-0.5610706210136414,
0.5354459285736084,
-0.7164681553840637,
0.4984671473503113,
-0.09004092961549759,
-0.6643797755241394,
0.1911390721797943,
-0.3300684690475464,
-0.12384666502475739,
0.5782931447029114,
-0.4976968765258789,
-0.7047375440597534,
0.12597061693668365,
-0.4004364311695099,
0.4040905833244324,
0.16482387483119965,
-0.22985750436782837,
0.42266353964805603,
-0.11866126209497452,
0.4243440330028534,
1.1870644092559814,
-0.1244422122836113,
0.4140300750732422,
-0.6689898371696472,
0.5421221256256104,
-0.005674115382134914,
-0.03269870579242706,
0.200011745095253,
-0.46359264850616455,
-0.6162991523742676,
-0.08154267817735672,
0.19048629701137543,
0.23445191979408264,
-0.6012995839118958,
-0.10634949803352356,
-0.2637547552585602,
0.25748229026794434,
-0.21995869278907776,
-0.2929233908653259,
0.47474151849746704,
0.3624342978000641,
0.1953248232603073,
-0.2897113263607025,
-0.22153843939304352,
-1.3778754472732544,
-0.10570377111434937,
-0.39590218663215637,
-0.25724565982818604,
0.4867359399795532,
0.39524585008621216,
-0.1918715089559555,
0.9012531638145447,
-0.5335901975631714,
-0.0007105228141881526,
-0.21975241601467133,
0.06331145018339157,
0.08975772559642792,
0.1420724093914032,
0.7408665418624878,
-0.787064790725708,
-0.16975563764572144,
-0.0844891220331192,
-0.2873493432998657,
-0.023848552256822586,
-0.14364111423492432,
-0.2719379961490631,
0.23169110715389252,
0.020396525040268898,
-0.46903321146965027,
0.34661877155303955,
0.34884122014045715,
-0.29418039321899414,
0.8236966133117676,
-0.10039296746253967,
0.21537555754184723,
-0.45402762293815613,
0.03907359391450882,
0.0390908308327198,
-0.26287394762039185,
-0.34955984354019165,
-0.44228336215019226,
0.027945484966039658,
0.7351788282394409,
-0.3701912462711334,
0.6342920660972595,
-0.19584505259990692,
-0.5041579008102417,
-0.3906654119491577,
0.05137348547577858,
-0.07966535538434982,
0.5110160708427429,
0.6854326725006104,
1.2247462272644043,
0.07112152129411697,
-0.6192191243171692,
0.0604453980922699,
0.08380906283855438,
-0.18877236545085907,
0.3120693564414978,
-0.6710447669029236,
0.22723841667175293,
-0.003065970027819276,
0.621860146522522,
-0.5819462537765503,
-0.14826977252960205,
0.24410884082317352,
-0.3218725621700287,
0.15672653913497925,
0.1473817378282547,
-0.2967837452888489,
-0.37812134623527527,
-0.6956717371940613,
0.4690718352794647,
0.5186746120452881,
-0.5924921631813049,
-0.09362373501062393,
0.3506162464618683,
-0.22960619628429413,
-0.8187031745910645,
-0.5592005848884583,
-0.17907123267650604,
-0.4051109552383423,
-0.22903424501419067,
0.2714509069919586,
-0.16854539513587952,
-0.5657094717025757,
-0.1374390572309494,
-0.10191888362169266,
0.17769189178943634,
-0.19857802987098694,
0.13284367322921753,
0.49099409580230713,
-0.06426194310188293,
0.15658113360404968,
0.05418119579553604,
-0.09111283719539642,
0.11248788237571716,
-0.24195800721645355,
0.578202486038208,
-0.20025795698165894,
-0.1783841997385025,
0.09515456110239029,
0.025048060342669487,
0.48781028389930725,
-0.09382800757884979,
0.7011705040931702,
0.07647290080785751,
-0.16109095513820648,
0.05933711305260658,
-0.6945162415504456,
-0.4015216529369354,
-0.4527894854545593,
0.29657384753227234,
-0.5312939286231995,
-0.9583152532577515,
0.442148357629776,
0.13946303725242615,
-0.08399410545825958,
0.35868287086486816,
0.8118835687637329,
0.10913099348545074,
1.0552855730056763,
0.3715912699699402,
-0.4502485990524292,
0.7819888591766357,
-0.21954910457134247,
-0.20102381706237793,
-0.9769511222839355,
-0.01710740476846695,
-0.47674882411956787,
-0.15768779814243317,
-0.5100337862968445,
-0.15543009340763092,
0.37559840083122253,
-0.27695363759994507,
-0.4295656979084015,
-0.11893852055072784,
-0.3974946439266205,
0.7145014405250549,
0.6181886792182922,
0.19194728136062622,
0.18733911216259003,
-0.023495610803365707,
-0.38970524072647095,
0.023364519700407982,
-0.5526533722877502,
-0.5602553486824036,
1.1495767831802368,
0.32599538564682007,
0.4897104799747467,
0.0825747698545456,
0.12160591036081314,
0.3251647353172302,
0.5599665641784668,
-0.7037933468818665,
0.2234577238559723,
0.33225584030151367,
-0.7376708388328552,
-0.4536436200141907,
-0.3650262653827667,
-1.0726518630981445,
0.5551148653030396,
0.043458856642246246,
-0.7721337676048279,
0.114609494805336,
0.0738823339343071,
-0.36985036730766296,
0.20404218137264252,
-0.5737263560295105,
0.6108281016349792,
-0.3399665951728821,
-0.5947924852371216,
-0.29059898853302,
-0.7309970855712891,
0.5108051896095276,
-0.13055656850337982,
0.09406476467847824,
0.010825826786458492,
-0.0014006341807544231,
0.747749924659729,
-0.20451734960079193,
0.6011876463890076,
0.006062976084649563,
-0.13389459252357483,
0.11566545814275742,
0.047740332782268524,
0.7624191641807556,
0.11328239738941193,
-0.3022371530532837,
0.05791991204023361,
-0.29159924387931824,
-0.47220584750175476,
-0.3179636597633362,
0.8207838535308838,
-0.9306299090385437,
-0.6780677437782288,
-0.6995024085044861,
-0.36702972650527954,
-0.23184151947498322,
-0.021172422915697098,
0.23126555979251862,
0.424372136592865,
0.013364354148507118,
-0.06673603504896164,
0.5479562282562256,
-0.5913779735565186,
0.39615049958229065,
0.6567918062210083,
-0.1487141251564026,
-0.17560015618801117,
0.3339128792285919,
-0.09278758615255356,
0.6155555248260498,
0.20138153433799744,
0.3811510503292084,
-0.48784780502319336,
-0.25725775957107544,
-0.272942453622818,
0.4923056364059448,
-0.6379493474960327,
-0.03886885195970535,
-0.2754131555557251,
0.040819864720106125,
-0.01736420951783657,
-0.4919622838497162,
-0.26660311222076416,
-0.17411339282989502,
0.024073658511042595,
-0.49301964044570923,
0.19744212925434113,
1.0074727535247803,
-0.052012670785188675,
0.08474370092153549,
-0.3645390570163727,
0.11402886360883713,
0.5652937293052673,
0.3509840667247772,
0.17261293530464172,
-0.5590389370918274,
-0.07041720300912857,
0.2550782561302185,
-0.3229060173034668,
-0.8047751188278198,
0.20258095860481262,
-0.3651221692562103,
0.7170683741569519,
0.25009843707084656,
-0.1228317990899086,
0.39554286003112793,
-0.5088149309158325,
0.9064251780509949,
0.12311165779829025,
-0.7229191660881042,
0.23693183064460754,
-0.5811429023742676,
0.4683908522129059,
0.40231823921203613,
0.41488149762153625,
-0.6765217185020447,
-0.13711139559745789,
-0.5782528519630432,
-0.6474937796592712,
0.9315746426582336,
0.15097644925117493,
-0.013441693037748337,
-0.27090829610824585,
0.3493371903896332,
0.4482532739639282,
0.2598324120044708,
-1.0669519901275635,
-0.2389283925294876,
-0.1830962747335434,
0.5209038257598877,
-0.21823453903198242,
-0.3755764663219452,
0.05251278355717659,
-0.21320310235023499,
0.5665581226348877,
-0.024823065847158432,
0.3006334602832794,
0.13186725974082947,
-0.10372854769229889,
-0.24685753881931305,
0.45929011702537537,
0.9885124564170837,
0.7590737342834473,
-0.4275893270969391,
0.042442724108695984,
0.41781163215637207,
-0.3836210370063782,
0.38472071290016174,
-0.39215877652168274,
-0.07610893994569778,
-0.28087085485458374,
0.3276796042919159,
0.9671809673309326,
0.24440808594226837,
-0.746630847454071,
0.6249934434890747,
-0.13896115124225616,
-0.1198214516043663,
-0.4590253531932831,
-0.16971230506896973,
0.032542578876018524,
0.1529591977596283,
0.2990209758281708,
-0.02062169462442398,
0.26883673667907715,
-0.7245711088180542,
0.05243078991770744,
0.4457389712333679,
-0.23538736999034882,
-0.37596791982650757,
0.5842818021774292,
0.007708858698606491,
-0.08399300277233124,
0.6672914624214172,
-0.30586570501327515,
-0.9471339583396912,
0.6802453994750977,
0.45646706223487854,
0.7055160999298096,
-0.013036459684371948,
0.21749788522720337,
0.121660016477108,
0.05884712189435959,
-0.30351918935775757,
0.022641083225607872,
0.0175616517663002,
-0.8827793598175049,
-0.5224493145942688,
-0.4277642071247101,
-0.3570729196071625,
0.42431923747062683,
-0.586329460144043,
0.17311570048332214,
-0.03550664708018303,
-0.39490556716918945,
0.08123975247144699,
-0.11719915270805359,
-0.6114171743392944,
0.11537716537714005,
0.19065144658088684,
0.48779407143592834,
-0.7587246894836426,
1.1651614904403687,
0.8257858753204346,
-0.7219857573509216,
-0.9384584426879883,
0.264400452375412,
0.029731903225183487,
-0.6273846626281738,
1.1192750930786133,
0.1592307984828949,
-0.39672350883483887,
-0.35670340061187744,
-0.41350093483924866,
-0.9330316185951233,
0.9664312601089478,
0.2182825207710266,
-0.2455502152442932,
-0.16712932288646698,
0.0318353995680809,
0.545823872089386,
-0.22118785977363586,
0.723921000957489,
0.7895221710205078,
0.4952957034111023,
0.023704009130597115,
-1.2700680494308472,
0.01960999146103859,
0.09836406260728836,
0.0641997903585434,
0.30971530079841614,
-0.8484762907028198,
1.029874324798584,
-0.18406228721141815,
0.08981683105230331,
-0.2447691559791565,
0.24714091420173645,
0.5063740611076355,
0.021265603601932526,
0.6376826763153076,
0.18360236287117004,
0.5344602465629578,
0.16448833048343658,
1.3337212800979614,
0.05799391493201256,
0.3535182774066925,
0.8847295045852661,
-0.47718870639801025,
0.8275796175003052,
0.43428173661231995,
-0.5593772530555725,
0.5679160952568054,
0.8593488335609436,
0.6400442719459534,
0.8128451108932495,
0.4736412763595581,
-0.10143867135047913,
-0.22113466262817383,
-0.09453226625919342,
-0.5480805039405823,
0.2004333883523941,
0.279181569814682,
-0.19728267192840576,
0.08872102200984955,
-0.1388988047838211,
0.2882641851902008,
-0.17132437229156494,
-0.2467832714319229,
0.6493536233901978,
0.06783558428287506,
-0.8278958797454834,
0.607664942741394,
-0.10334429144859314,
0.9791003465652466,
-0.7105319499969482,
0.003168887458741665,
-0.35529887676239014,
0.0977097749710083,
0.04702708497643471,
-0.735400915145874,
-0.028140563517808914,
-0.12025022506713867,
-0.39050912857055664,
-0.14523452520370483,
0.5045351982116699,
-0.17094674706459045,
0.06886162608861923,
0.47878870368003845,
0.10648825764656067,
0.007887080311775208,
-0.18184791505336761,
-0.6244639754295349,
0.09419189393520355,
0.1902085244655609,
-0.6970528960227966,
0.69893878698349,
0.04625678434967995,
-0.5170373320579529,
0.9035866260528564,
0.6323127150535583,
0.23840026557445526,
0.0066477092914283276,
-0.07527269423007965,
0.8422701358795166,
-0.6293973922729492,
-0.5947118997573853,
-0.928734540939331,
0.17013610899448395,
-0.15433356165885925,
-0.14213436841964722,
0.39073672890663147,
0.511784017086029,
1.0079435110092163,
-0.08784085512161255,
0.947077751159668,
0.23990243673324585,
0.5184997916221619,
-0.6217173337936401,
0.351961225271225,
-0.49301043152809143,
0.36010339856147766,
-0.26934531331062317,
-1.007315993309021,
0.13334636390209198,
0.7962709069252014,
-0.7687042355537415,
0.3426457941532135,
1.073900818824768,
0.5339610576629639,
0.12179044634103775,
-0.07399528473615646,
0.32651785016059875,
-0.03527376055717468,
0.30160999298095703,
0.7348424196243286,
1.0426374673843384,
0.16974954307079315,
0.2687455117702484,
-0.08662614226341248,
-0.3419772684574127,
-0.2077229917049408,
-0.8096252679824829,
-0.7841265201568604,
-0.5202303528785706,
0.04768223315477371,
-0.2104170173406601,
0.2610051929950714,
1.3311868906021118,
0.571189820766449,
-0.6838394403457642,
-0.2657335698604584,
0.3271326422691345,
0.14443448185920715,
-0.042396076023578644,
-0.15318869054317474,
0.30239352583885193,
-0.07007313519716263,
-0.5532608032226562,
0.26378437876701355,
0.13288207352161407,
0.11147675663232803,
-0.1137043908238411,
-0.3546696901321411,
-0.039416853338479996,
0.23579899966716766,
0.5334588885307312,
0.37025976181030273,
-0.9269307851791382,
-0.5790906548500061,
-0.24795211851596832,
-0.3452003300189972,
0.22438770532608032,
0.9594447612762451,
-0.95843505859375,
0.04127483442425728,
0.3261220157146454,
0.40282177925109863,
0.4653241038322449,
0.06797720491886139,
0.8453060388565063,
-0.3795575499534607,
0.5252133011817932,
-0.019360724836587906,
0.3991658687591553,
0.15775658190250397,
-0.38759902119636536,
0.5310545563697815,
0.2262556254863739,
-0.782172679901123,
-0.5924496054649353,
0.2753486931324005,
-0.6865295171737671,
-0.44231846928596497,
1.4811631441116333,
0.02590918354690075,
0.09937427192926407,
0.19553454220294952,
-0.47971469163894653,
0.01855303719639778,
-0.7199648022651672,
0.7236833572387695,
1.0600545406341553,
-0.16850566864013672,
0.2488340586423874,
-0.8788346648216248,
0.659315824508667,
0.6064854860305786,
-0.6263923645019531,
-0.17525358498096466,
0.8337818384170532,
0.3226642608642578,
-0.2450433373451233,
0.7732653021812439,
0.05740227922797203,
0.28842222690582275,
-0.05942104384303093,
0.12429782003164291,
0.2527241110801697,
-0.13824275135993958,
-0.4859621226787567,
-0.11852274090051651,
0.5718916058540344,
-0.004820972215384245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14526v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14526v1 | MEDs for PETs: Multilingual Euphemism Disambiguation for Potentially Euphemistic Terms | 2024-01-25T21:38:30 | 2024-01-25T21:38:30 | Patrick Lee, Alain Chirino Trujillo, Diana Cuevas Plancarte, Olumide Ebenezer Ojo, Xinyi Liu, Iyanuoluwa Shode, Yuan Zhao, Jing Peng, Anna Feldman | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study investigates the computational processing of euphemisms, a
universal linguistic phenomenon, across multiple languages. We train a
multilingual transformer model (XLM-RoBERTa) to disambiguate potentially
euphemistic terms (PETs) in multilingual and cross-lingual settings. In line
with current trends, we demonstrate that zero-shot learning across languages
takes place. We also show cases where multilingual models perform better on the
task compared to monolingual models by a statistically significant margin,
indicating that multilingual data presents additional opportunities for models
to learn about cross-lingual, computational properties of euphemisms. In a
follow-up analysis, we focus on universal euphemistic "categories" such as
death and bodily functions among others. We test to see whether cross-lingual
data of the same domain is more important than within-language data of other
domains to further understand the nature of the cross-lingual transfer. | [
-0.24597424268722534,
-0.6662704348564148,
0.5578998327255249,
0.27488991618156433,
-0.2409137785434723,
0.1820635050535202,
-0.4262605309486389,
-0.5676344037055969,
0.1301817148923874,
0.28884461522102356,
-0.335411936044693,
-0.30267611145973206,
-0.5370110273361206,
0.7662210464477539,
-0.02443799562752247,
1.1173818111419678,
0.1391303539276123,
0.5640937089920044,
0.061386775225400925,
-0.4600348472595215,
0.020777756348252296,
-0.8140988349914551,
-0.6253760457038879,
-0.5069583058357239,
0.7937721610069275,
0.20510868728160858,
0.9405050277709961,
0.4898890256881714,
0.7145272493362427,
0.3037062883377075,
-0.04289699345827103,
-0.1841273307800293,
-0.18963779509067535,
0.2573032081127167,
-0.3798444867134094,
-0.44768235087394714,
-0.3796394169330597,
-0.2510423958301544,
0.39416712522506714,
1.0206705331802368,
-0.3301568031311035,
-0.1687273532152176,
-0.3493850529193878,
0.5751850605010986,
-0.49419519305229187,
-0.05554575100541115,
-0.6023665070533752,
0.524832010269165,
-0.046184372156858444,
-0.3160645365715027,
-0.5166964530944824,
0.2091255486011505,
0.04973277077078819,
-0.7610706090927124,
0.011072876863181591,
-0.13621684908866882,
0.7871918678283691,
-0.1141464114189148,
-0.4161031246185303,
-0.42122119665145874,
-0.6254255771636963,
0.9249117970466614,
-0.3494380712509155,
0.4688711166381836,
0.188939169049263,
0.09512462466955185,
-0.03073807805776596,
-0.6289620399475098,
-0.4198756814002991,
-0.3316424787044525,
-0.25905290246009827,
-0.05449119210243225,
-0.36092445254325867,
0.2457151710987091,
0.2692895531654358,
0.43003469705581665,
-0.8395158052444458,
0.14129331707954407,
-0.548958957195282,
-0.250430703163147,
0.4063290059566498,
0.23935353755950928,
0.6663014888763428,
-0.3037208914756775,
-0.458575040102005,
0.14428552985191345,
-0.6551675796508789,
-0.04396495595574379,
0.0006584451184608042,
0.5379534363746643,
-0.1252441257238388,
0.37528151273727417,
0.07976049929857254,
0.5770242810249329,
-0.08984250575304031,
-0.32554808259010315,
0.5586737394332886,
-0.395900696516037,
-0.20013120770454407,
0.02137867547571659,
0.7196961641311646,
0.4101801812648773,
0.30614957213401794,
-0.45533591508865356,
0.2268524318933487,
0.08878956735134125,
0.08982247859239578,
-0.848976731300354,
-0.10662476718425751,
0.34770992398262024,
-0.28416386246681213,
-0.1888827383518219,
-0.6143909692764282,
-0.5666911005973816,
-0.35028281807899475,
-0.10343252122402191,
0.3725895285606384,
-0.43599191308021545,
-0.32905688881874084,
0.572763979434967,
-0.4474238455295563,
0.13782037794589996,
-0.1813926249742508,
-1.1211602687835693,
0.14096905291080475,
0.2885712683200836,
0.6636902689933777,
-0.14345042407512665,
-0.6980786323547363,
-0.2765459418296814,
0.2287631779909134,
-0.4651643633842468,
0.8655643463134766,
-0.7643347382545471,
-0.6135743856430054,
-0.1460791826248169,
0.6277165412902832,
-0.13347674906253815,
-0.3921610116958618,
0.37649738788604736,
-0.024399803951382637,
0.25449657440185547,
-0.08002898842096329,
-0.2874372899532318,
-0.3042331039905548,
0.24458545446395874,
-0.49722713232040405,
0.7574950456619263,
-0.10576179623603821,
-0.5866499543190002,
0.3876432776451111,
-0.859591007232666,
-0.5340408086776733,
0.01086877379566431,
-0.18672500550746918,
-0.3649381399154663,
0.16630004346370697,
-0.07434521615505219,
0.6461758613586426,
-0.15495732426643372,
0.2582569718360901,
-0.27420124411582947,
-0.02030101791024208,
0.31401321291923523,
-0.298759400844574,
0.8018142580986023,
0.09333408623933792,
-0.0698571726679802,
-0.3281167149543762,
-0.7958325147628784,
-0.011521389707922935,
0.1846511960029602,
-0.13882339000701904,
-0.8303220868110657,
-0.025238994508981705,
0.25010862946510315,
0.4030347168445587,
-0.005736209452152252,
-0.7332184910774231,
0.1800520122051239,
-0.28261134028434753,
0.40461212396621704,
-0.046349719166755676,
-0.038813188672065735,
0.4268591105937958,
-0.32759764790534973,
0.5558165311813354,
-0.0012406730093061924,
0.33352336287498474,
-0.36803215742111206,
-0.46322548389434814,
-0.2611599266529083,
-0.2624100148677826,
0.32661697268486023,
0.6201364994049072,
-0.48322737216949463,
-0.18748413026332855,
0.11647237092256546,
-0.39219969511032104,
-0.270046591758728,
-0.22131182253360748,
0.5762722492218018,
0.3244555592536926,
0.3413996994495392,
-0.12823089957237244,
-0.4880886673927307,
-0.9446917772293091,
-0.254998117685318,
0.07286862283945084,
-0.13088595867156982,
0.07250851392745972,
0.543095052242279,
-0.19787263870239258,
0.1725246161222458,
-0.16624349355697632,
-0.23407812416553497,
-0.2120797038078308,
0.37079790234565735,
-0.07341131567955017,
0.2444794476032257,
0.9629592299461365,
-1.0241820812225342,
-0.6210353970527649,
0.40431541204452515,
-0.6583289504051208,
0.12167461961507797,
-0.4091731607913971,
0.10109734535217285,
0.09635531902313232,
0.538820207118988,
-0.6077062487602234,
0.3102659285068512,
0.4899735450744629,
-0.1916271299123764,
0.3049152195453644,
-0.4816337823867798,
0.31510278582572937,
-1.404274821281433,
0.09237643331289291,
-0.17763759195804596,
-0.22349277138710022,
-0.9297833442687988,
0.15649498999118805,
0.08963940292596817,
-0.03981829062104225,
-0.8984999060630798,
0.637082040309906,
-0.6365117430686951,
-0.05376187711954117,
0.05281385779380798,
0.31813666224479675,
0.15713126957416534,
0.3054066300392151,
0.4370645582675934,
0.5326054096221924,
1.084451675415039,
-0.6073159575462341,
0.4038836359977722,
0.3079644739627838,
0.4783037006855011,
0.7743503451347351,
-0.2731325030326843,
-0.3123444616794586,
-0.004045728128403425,
-0.013284267857670784,
-0.6812784671783447,
-0.2281317561864853,
0.13804355263710022,
-0.6327998638153076,
0.30798181891441345,
0.0351422093808651,
-0.4034658670425415,
-0.2575232982635498,
-0.2933361232280731,
0.35918349027633667,
0.18630185723304749,
-0.2933509349822998,
0.384214848279953,
0.756578266620636,
-0.2023468166589737,
-0.5884941816329956,
-0.8394242525100708,
0.19711202383041382,
-0.4894298017024994,
-0.05987730622291565,
0.5224272012710571,
-0.13019536435604095,
-0.20487883687019348,
-0.06622578203678131,
0.2580433487892151,
-0.34751155972480774,
-0.033962953835725784,
-0.03416367247700691,
0.1620866060256958,
-0.09238976240158081,
0.5829830169677734,
-0.055569205433130264,
-0.09723923355340958,
-0.029555611312389374,
0.176261305809021,
0.3358508348464966,
-0.018999041989445686,
-0.3028923273086548,
-0.03013044036924839,
0.7431476712226868,
0.9278846383094788,
-0.05308186635375023,
0.5093294978141785,
0.6466560959815979,
-0.4363403618335724,
-0.1587262600660324,
0.030025886371731758,
0.029538622125983238,
-0.3990755081176758,
0.5576565265655518,
-0.5019353032112122,
-0.5438482165336609,
0.9080172777175903,
-0.09655486047267914,
0.13399717211723328,
0.39447420835494995,
0.7794383764266968,
0.05257735028862953,
1.5217097997665405,
1.021156668663025,
0.03324953094124794,
0.300292044878006,
0.006031667347997427,
0.14492882788181305,
-0.6210053563117981,
-0.2500501573085785,
-0.5972956418991089,
0.015919562429189682,
-0.9463924169540405,
-0.5187098383903503,
0.45597052574157715,
-0.11125127971172333,
-0.17727941274642944,
0.10309651494026184,
-0.5211859941482544,
0.7847088575363159,
-0.19688822329044342,
-0.26827117800712585,
0.35403573513031006,
0.4180959463119507,
-0.4395145773887634,
-0.130811408162117,
-0.683093249797821,
-0.2172057330608368,
1.162103295326233,
0.15038135647773743,
0.7917590141296387,
0.0016221675323322415,
0.3161488473415375,
0.2232573926448822,
0.3163396120071411,
-0.9717598557472229,
0.17809277772903442,
-0.6392782926559448,
-0.7570803761482239,
-0.34351637959480286,
-0.17690660059452057,
-1.3622857332229614,
0.5840266942977905,
0.20568469166755676,
-0.8843443393707275,
-0.15729349851608276,
-0.31947168707847595,
-0.5373092889785767,
0.4671943187713623,
-0.18080829083919525,
0.8729293346405029,
-0.5480207204818726,
-0.05169321224093437,
-0.35975995659828186,
-0.7314005494117737,
0.09151171892881393,
-0.31232863664627075,
0.40732523798942566,
-0.2468220591545105,
-0.22961488366127014,
0.38511577248573303,
-0.4284563958644867,
0.6511937379837036,
0.2204340398311615,
-0.17429299652576447,
-0.12920154631137848,
-0.0657077431678772,
-0.212903693318367,
0.0146230049431324,
-0.14457181096076965,
0.562034010887146,
0.46542108058929443,
-0.48381125926971436,
-0.45455533266067505,
0.3924899697303772,
-0.48880085349082947,
-0.11072686314582825,
-0.7058352828025818,
-0.5329408645629883,
-0.46505528688430786,
0.21007947623729706,
0.36373382806777954,
0.4070866107940674,
-0.2024926394224167,
0.082084521651268,
0.5109679102897644,
-0.48385089635849,
0.3654177486896515,
1.4232856035232544,
-0.5706461668014526,
-0.3817150890827179,
0.7680078744888306,
-0.0008258706075139344,
0.4638122320175171,
0.43005016446113586,
0.18605470657348633,
-0.4056504964828491,
-0.1214502602815628,
-0.9746546149253845,
0.4370554983615875,
-0.5727552771568298,
-0.14361874759197235,
-0.4288824200630188,
-0.22921298444271088,
-0.0006398279219865799,
-0.30450865626335144,
-0.34948644042015076,
-0.3719383478164673,
-0.0906887948513031,
-0.00913020595908165,
0.6455607414245605,
0.7932736277580261,
-0.5695613026618958,
0.01663341000676155,
-1.0512624979019165,
0.4897519648075104,
-0.12780459225177765,
0.4031614363193512,
-0.5088376998901367,
-0.503350019454956,
-0.26218879222869873,
0.2710351347923279,
-0.2716299295425415,
-1.1547213792800903,
0.43531346321105957,
0.689272940158844,
0.6608651280403137,
0.30258792638778687,
-0.1765861064195633,
0.8874093294143677,
-0.6964089870452881,
0.8016735315322876,
0.5335530042648315,
-0.6497254371643066,
0.4460848271846771,
-0.5265577435493469,
0.24600805342197418,
0.37540531158447266,
0.9699866771697998,
-1.3184266090393066,
-0.5546027421951294,
-0.5265871286392212,
-0.8754971027374268,
0.6327653527259827,
-0.08110892027616501,
0.49859461188316345,
-0.20350505411624908,
0.2904246747493744,
0.340284138917923,
0.1881430745124817,
-0.8622748851776123,
-0.5458688139915466,
0.4453355669975281,
0.17209266126155853,
-0.08060318231582642,
0.224351167678833,
-0.03423159196972847,
-0.5452176928520203,
0.5176311135292053,
-0.22180584073066711,
0.09340571612119675,
0.145802304148674,
-0.1274777352809906,
-0.42248284816741943,
0.356509804725647,
0.6040506958961487,
0.49109670519828796,
0.009543420746922493,
-0.09837841987609863,
0.2576087713241577,
-0.5860025882720947,
0.2990345358848572,
0.1396360844373703,
-0.08563496917486191,
0.5495299100875854,
0.024729866534471512,
0.6028931140899658,
0.5716365575790405,
-0.9520811438560486,
0.43029651045799255,
-0.3405735492706299,
-0.1256827563047409,
-0.2009366750717163,
-0.3994196653366089,
-0.05163959786295891,
0.01065142173320055,
0.11403948813676834,
0.0040744515135884285,
0.2632860839366913,
-0.8412545919418335,
0.36940714716911316,
0.47609275579452515,
-0.10652501881122589,
-0.6047897934913635,
0.44710174202919006,
-0.057892780750989914,
-0.20340852439403534,
0.26254698634147644,
-0.29943034052848816,
-0.6156421303749084,
0.6838077306747437,
0.6371093988418579,
0.6541205048561096,
-0.6338133215904236,
0.6288244724273682,
0.2899961471557617,
0.03499148041009903,
0.014809411950409412,
0.681100070476532,
-0.0901113972067833,
-0.6538448929786682,
-0.19450542330741882,
-0.8883926868438721,
-0.6560824513435364,
0.4299638867378235,
-0.8075793385505676,
0.2737847864627838,
0.11097260564565659,
-0.2699977159500122,
0.6110132336616516,
-0.3595370054244995,
-0.34199750423431396,
0.1759006381034851,
0.5564038753509521,
0.5189178586006165,
-0.8762929439544678,
0.6314387321472168,
1.1884254217147827,
-0.6820749044418335,
-0.9500982761383057,
-0.21487505733966827,
-0.24218939244747162,
-0.6930346488952637,
0.5995773673057556,
-0.03670631721615791,
-0.04794473573565483,
-0.18125019967556,
-0.12311026453971863,
-0.9065258502960205,
0.5115313529968262,
0.3255005180835724,
-0.436625599861145,
-0.15198518335819244,
0.8292790651321411,
1.0133321285247803,
-0.26799821853637695,
0.33104944229125977,
0.4522988796234131,
0.33032548427581787,
-0.1775764375925064,
-1.4144904613494873,
-0.35754454135894775,
-0.34958094358444214,
-0.32990893721580505,
0.14844587445259094,
-0.5964075922966003,
1.063686490058899,
-0.3954025208950043,
-0.13353699445724487,
0.08645768463611603,
-0.25267574191093445,
-0.017212005332112312,
0.22983387112617493,
0.14773501455783844,
0.42453819513320923,
0.6379092335700989,
0.10656312108039856,
0.9125959277153015,
-0.7584280967712402,
0.7227575182914734,
0.6755443215370178,
-0.3037188947200775,
1.0379716157913208,
0.5904216170310974,
-0.42573755979537964,
0.5077493786811829,
0.8336678147315979,
0.06973195821046829,
0.4188954532146454,
0.18144996464252472,
-0.2275063693523407,
-0.35530680418014526,
-0.1855621486902237,
-0.5456604957580566,
0.6481160521507263,
0.7843502163887024,
-0.53348308801651,
-0.6578737497329712,
0.5953331589698792,
0.07785432785749435,
-0.25769534707069397,
-0.3202534019947052,
0.8370751738548279,
0.15949973464012146,
-0.5719499588012695,
1.1110106706619263,
0.00292401690967381,
0.4692120850086212,
-0.7083942890167236,
-0.08152282238006592,
-0.2532317340373993,
0.2637585997581482,
-0.12017907202243805,
-0.6969376802444458,
0.554435133934021,
0.14065095782279968,
-0.1939930021762848,
-0.2522546947002411,
0.4379984140396118,
-0.6846230030059814,
-0.7283389568328857,
0.6761087775230408,
0.7382476329803467,
0.7338292598724365,
0.0665053054690361,
-1.0925788879394531,
-0.18437586724758148,
-0.09087810665369034,
-0.09810943901538849,
0.5208614468574524,
0.6441962718963623,
-0.19477184116840363,
0.6646665334701538,
0.4381970167160034,
0.5726070404052734,
0.1778242588043213,
0.24093188345432281,
0.5608026385307312,
-0.4654965400695801,
-0.5509338974952698,
-0.8969175815582275,
0.43855687975883484,
0.10702046751976013,
-0.3245221972465515,
0.7758355140686035,
0.5331921577453613,
1.0982948541641235,
-0.28253695368766785,
0.8059560060501099,
-0.09941799938678741,
0.5228455066680908,
-0.1588689684867859,
0.9515028595924377,
-1.127294659614563,
-0.0792347639799118,
-0.004232596140354872,
-0.2998685836791992,
-0.5936765670776367,
0.6042076945304871,
-0.22345547378063202,
-0.24295268952846527,
0.7811169028282166,
0.9191252589225769,
-0.13189029693603516,
-0.023370899260044098,
0.9082375764846802,
-0.005999610293656588,
-0.2917189598083496,
0.5176117420196533,
0.8688045144081116,
-0.4748309254646301,
0.47415032982826233,
-0.5333933234214783,
0.16464969515800476,
-0.01627543941140175,
-0.6181502938270569,
-0.7859135270118713,
-0.7305272221565247,
-0.28345492482185364,
-0.010105211287736893,
0.2287743091583252,
0.7716801762580872,
0.7893126010894775,
-0.9410943984985352,
-0.25346991419792175,
0.051172662526369095,
0.1007893830537796,
-0.1496855765581131,
-0.1836596578359604,
0.20090137422084808,
-0.570591926574707,
-0.7415518760681152,
0.16929025948047638,
0.6768926978111267,
-0.07720115035772324,
-0.451778769493103,
-0.02702147141098976,
-0.024757692590355873,
0.3085518479347229,
0.6528681516647339,
0.5289058089256287,
-0.9716461896896362,
0.00859018974006176,
0.10439959168434143,
-0.37210384011268616,
0.40928852558135986,
0.7882223129272461,
-0.5012850761413574,
0.6079238653182983,
0.15817464888095856,
0.2703514099121094,
-0.0468936562538147,
-0.22725528478622437,
0.45220381021499634,
-0.6993559002876282,
0.2622361183166504,
0.15055464208126068,
0.5100902318954468,
0.4453479051589966,
-0.47412240505218506,
0.2883395552635193,
0.28615015745162964,
-0.40599939227104187,
-1.0943530797958374,
0.20493865013122559,
-0.5710101127624512,
-0.4665859639644623,
1.108433485031128,
-0.3044302463531494,
-0.3381144404411316,
-0.25610679388046265,
-0.22380010783672333,
0.23409563302993774,
-0.03948859125375748,
0.7796114087104797,
0.5823955535888672,
-0.48038437962532043,
-0.002657360164448619,
-0.8381276726722717,
0.8111875653266907,
0.4196225106716156,
-0.9187149405479431,
0.07364451140165329,
0.4119621217250824,
0.5937029123306274,
0.3967292010784149,
0.5747206807136536,
-0.2879132926464081,
0.6072729825973511,
0.18019190430641174,
0.4460047483444214,
0.4583323001861572,
-0.24796448647975922,
-0.6350382566452026,
0.10287151485681534,
-0.17909647524356842,
-0.21805202960968018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14524v1 | Evaluating GPT-3.5's Awareness and Summarization Abilities for European Constitutional Texts with Shared Topics | 2024-01-25T21:34:53 | 2024-01-25T21:34:53 | Candida M. Greco, A. Tagarelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.DL, physics.soc-ph | Constitutions are foundational legal documents that underpin the governmental
and societal structures. As such, they are a reflection of a nation's cultural
and social uniqueness, but also contribute to establish topics of universal
importance, like citizens' rights and duties (RD). In this work, using the
renowned GPT-3.5, we leverage generative large language models to understand
constitutional passages that transcend national boundaries. A key contribution
of our study is the introduction of a novel application of abstractive
summarization on a multi-source collection of constitutional texts, with a
focus on European countries' constitution passages related to RD topics. Our
results show the meaningfulness of GPT-3.5 to produce informative, coherent and
faithful summaries capturing RD topics across European countries. | [
-0.6672715544700623,
-0.40742918848991394,
0.6103461384773254,
0.3046686053276062,
-0.6386842131614685,
-0.2189037948846817,
-0.2496277093887329,
-0.5668004751205444,
0.21231043338775635,
0.5724321007728577,
-0.0775289535522461,
-0.3809686601161957,
-0.6348430514335632,
0.4099887013435364,
-0.48979315161705017,
1.0663609504699707,
-0.09228573739528656,
-0.016432369127869606,
0.02192196622490883,
0.09603282809257507,
0.050987690687179565,
-0.6602321863174438,
0.003999609965831041,
0.09523012489080429,
0.2424195110797882,
0.23317675292491913,
0.3621313273906708,
0.356355756521225,
0.6349176168441772,
0.22286079823970795,
-0.4436960518360138,
-0.15354600548744202,
-0.4481596350669861,
-0.1330549418926239,
-0.34164178371429443,
-0.250657320022583,
-0.381125271320343,
0.029833905398845673,
0.6986741423606873,
0.4181177616119385,
-0.008577066473662853,
0.0125266183167696,
0.41595128178596497,
0.8493402600288391,
-0.3934440314769745,
0.6368724703788757,
-0.4769231975078583,
0.08226834982633591,
-0.19849194586277008,
0.011007699184119701,
0.07836609333753586,
-0.5270530581474304,
0.5868253707885742,
-0.7776360511779785,
0.49724453687667847,
-0.6912040114402771,
0.7023693323135376,
-0.0755547508597374,
-0.6620361804962158,
-0.29705676436424255,
-0.487841933965683,
0.5511541962623596,
-0.38436612486839294,
0.2866726815700531,
0.26392868161201477,
0.07015164941549301,
0.004297483246773481,
-0.9126136898994446,
-0.6138275265693665,
-0.021583903580904007,
-0.2311180979013443,
0.4638497233390808,
-0.08934088051319122,
0.11049827188253403,
0.19769133627414703,
0.7091384530067444,
-0.4394714832305908,
-0.30857694149017334,
-0.8842491507530212,
-0.1929231584072113,
0.5754327178001404,
-0.0037684065755456686,
0.27227023243904114,
-0.40185093879699707,
-0.06856916844844818,
0.2536309063434601,
-0.5513494610786438,
0.08656586706638336,
0.6065719723701477,
0.2808820903301239,
-0.42323049902915955,
0.7225911617279053,
-0.2601853311061859,
0.6304215788841248,
0.06865102797746658,
0.39680346846580505,
-0.04120566323399544,
-0.5824121236801147,
0.2283681184053421,
-0.30959412455558777,
0.534463107585907,
0.5332428216934204,
0.447796493768692,
-0.036539893597364426,
0.12085223942995071,
-0.322279155254364,
0.16710129380226135,
-0.8547098636627197,
-0.05614475533366203,
0.357281893491745,
-0.5237358212471008,
-0.06923504173755646,
0.42713919281959534,
-0.4040187895298004,
-0.3481108546257019,
-0.8187357187271118,
-0.05898618325591087,
-0.314119815826416,
-0.1809653788805008,
0.39380016922950745,
-0.3556312024593353,
0.49021264910697937,
0.4797946810722351,
-1.2958508729934692,
0.0815339982509613,
0.9860142469406128,
0.7835782766342163,
-0.1771857887506485,
0.008161921985447407,
0.24049970507621765,
0.35099291801452637,
-0.11158456653356552,
0.8605808019638062,
-0.3521743714809418,
-0.6928721070289612,
0.019274011254310608,
0.21828290820121765,
-0.0515572652220726,
-0.17631466686725616,
0.6848006248474121,
-0.2745973467826843,
0.19608382880687714,
-0.5605593323707581,
-0.6639509797096252,
-0.22344522178173065,
0.277991384267807,
-0.9544636011123657,
0.5476400256156921,
-0.20563723146915436,
-0.7677097320556641,
0.6160769462585449,
-0.931806743144989,
-0.43717414140701294,
0.18447370827198029,
-0.41558530926704407,
-0.19813363254070282,
0.3410736918449402,
0.3012416958808899,
0.6655457615852356,
0.20778492093086243,
-0.020268015563488007,
-0.11669463664293289,
-0.23815827071666718,
-0.15164688229560852,
-0.02922995015978813,
0.9015833735466003,
0.06800799071788788,
-0.21153603494167328,
-0.13913126289844513,
-0.3059918284416199,
-0.27702540159225464,
-0.3060140311717987,
-0.4410499930381775,
-0.36932173371315,
0.09619701653718948,
0.09760147333145142,
0.2177303284406662,
0.5215062499046326,
-0.26701706647872925,
0.2571224868297577,
-0.3485194444656372,
0.5111156702041626,
0.47721293568611145,
0.45112189650535583,
0.3676948845386505,
-0.3273363411426544,
0.5438432097434998,
-0.1432139277458191,
0.12300585955381393,
0.01805548556149006,
-0.7093217968940735,
-0.30821630358695984,
-0.3362298011779785,
0.2350793033838272,
0.7037205100059509,
-0.16627861559391022,
0.7440751791000366,
-0.3835446238517761,
-0.4231436848640442,
-0.03500596433877945,
-0.17375242710113525,
-0.06083657592535019,
-0.00512304063886404,
0.21990172564983368,
-0.18370023369789124,
-0.4951997697353363,
-0.9710178375244141,
-0.33495137095451355,
-0.3236791789531708,
-0.08053076267242432,
0.11602111160755157,
1.0145877599716187,
0.30491766333580017,
0.8400095105171204,
-0.23635950684547424,
-0.42395591735839844,
-0.5427148342132568,
0.05039428174495697,
0.09371527284383774,
0.34918585419654846,
0.4700440466403961,
-0.766549825668335,
-0.49898824095726013,
0.3268028497695923,
-0.5638882517814636,
0.04057316854596138,
-0.07437887787818909,
-0.1616576462984085,
-0.01956234499812126,
0.3283909261226654,
-0.3877595067024231,
0.45034196972846985,
0.23168045282363892,
-0.5954891443252563,
0.3499802350997925,
-0.3357737958431244,
0.4750852882862091,
-1.4395965337753296,
0.1410033106803894,
-0.2138289511203766,
-0.1635671705007553,
-0.4900380074977875,
0.06671229004859924,
0.26749387383461,
-0.06286288052797318,
-0.4909246563911438,
0.3063133955001831,
-0.3942602872848511,
-0.030902966856956482,
-0.023988425731658936,
0.1392834335565567,
0.08889637887477875,
0.017429182305932045,
0.23111246526241302,
0.8381436467170715,
0.2822454869747162,
-0.5883877873420715,
0.13237883150577545,
0.6440168619155884,
-0.3751419186592102,
0.8774259686470032,
-0.542681097984314,
-0.11682478338479996,
-0.27506008744239807,
0.38484635949134827,
-0.4891183376312256,
-0.3374585807323456,
-0.02176099456846714,
-0.2921642065048218,
-0.060126107186079025,
-0.3491155505180359,
-0.3217647969722748,
-0.050709933042526245,
-0.3505096733570099,
0.07680452615022659,
0.24605295062065125,
0.09341266751289368,
0.5793974995613098,
0.7288143038749695,
-0.3816888928413391,
-0.6581846475601196,
-0.6069802045822144,
0.14356733858585358,
-0.2747800946235657,
-0.5582643747329712,
0.201602503657341,
0.28493791818618774,
-0.3204953670501709,
-0.06317155063152313,
-0.08222106844186783,
-0.08220897614955902,
0.006283536087721586,
0.0993623286485672,
-0.0943426862359047,
0.1435472071170807,
-0.07080276310443878,
0.10385489463806152,
0.10398154705762863,
-0.022962048649787903,
-0.43622949719429016,
0.11312248557806015,
-0.22748659551143646,
-0.21856507658958435,
-0.6804761290550232,
0.72126704454422,
0.7089502811431885,
-0.42557528614997864,
0.4199788570404053,
0.21602562069892883,
-0.24870507419109344,
0.1784813106060028,
-0.4211871027946472,
0.0006507615908049047,
-0.3288983702659607,
0.24685826897621155,
-0.4096609950065613,
-0.9401105642318726,
0.9407855868339539,
0.3983510136604309,
0.3990294933319092,
0.727835476398468,
0.47664856910705566,
-0.010069765150547028,
0.3543459475040436,
0.6435487270355225,
-0.10483545809984207,
0.5151572227478027,
-0.39675429463386536,
-0.03715517371892929,
-0.7065387964248657,
-0.30021655559539795,
-0.9312236905097961,
-0.018337618559598923,
-0.7608237266540527,
-0.3371817469596863,
0.4701120853424072,
0.09466652572154999,
0.11567912250757217,
0.46425533294677734,
-0.2863054871559143,
0.7903380393981934,
0.23814328014850616,
0.000020434026737348177,
0.5416567325592041,
0.08583803474903107,
-0.011881375685334206,
-0.01609751395881176,
0.06438340991735458,
-0.9702293276786804,
1.2453513145446777,
0.04704413190484047,
0.5421077609062195,
0.4345772862434387,
0.8483070135116577,
0.47676417231559753,
0.11720917373895645,
-0.5745503902435303,
0.4612003266811371,
-0.42659470438957214,
-0.8435434103012085,
-0.44682395458221436,
-0.16014795005321503,
-0.7494949102401733,
0.5838047862052917,
0.008696029894053936,
-0.696757435798645,
0.42779508233070374,
0.08058688789606094,
-0.6323822736740112,
0.3675559461116791,
-0.5561461448669434,
0.8455073237419128,
0.3174252212047577,
-0.12406569719314575,
-0.490831583738327,
-0.5653849840164185,
0.40356284379959106,
-0.020186830312013626,
-0.15971462428569794,
-0.27184271812438965,
-0.2537710964679718,
0.6961042881011963,
-0.07489129155874252,
0.5463616251945496,
-0.06203019618988037,
-0.3913191556930542,
0.2521708309650421,
-0.40647754073143005,
0.29351457953453064,
0.4061686098575592,
-0.017319651320576668,
0.03234967589378357,
0.2256806641817093,
-0.3030453622341156,
-0.2569577991962433,
0.4793268144130707,
-0.651187539100647,
-0.5599559545516968,
-0.423846036195755,
-0.3474319577217102,
0.013331983238458633,
0.19442839920520782,
0.22073335945606232,
0.3383655548095703,
-0.623883843421936,
0.363985151052475,
0.7798479199409485,
0.10797516256570816,
0.32342228293418884,
0.5845814347267151,
0.03480295091867447,
-0.33823636174201965,
0.43790072202682495,
0.3372217118740082,
0.14530575275421143,
0.4416653513908386,
-0.1384134143590927,
-0.6314500570297241,
-0.4541979134082794,
-0.3816693425178528,
0.09389960020780563,
-0.6743882894515991,
0.2269403636455536,
-0.9099428653717041,
0.05781693011522293,
-0.5496107339859009,
-0.25332343578338623,
0.11235059797763824,
-0.9531306624412537,
-0.34103846549987793,
-0.26442769169807434,
0.18728096783161163,
0.7973730564117432,
-0.31238308548927307,
0.10099256783723831,
-0.6421982049942017,
0.6906986832618713,
0.47862401604652405,
0.20109763741493225,
-0.6345317363739014,
-0.3230298161506653,
0.0730786845088005,
-0.3765646815299988,
-0.4923933148384094,
-0.9621410369873047,
-0.17347177863121033,
0.14527557790279388,
0.5301065444946289,
0.31135380268096924,
0.1183273196220398,
0.5163923501968384,
-0.41222167015075684,
0.9921901822090149,
-0.24554261565208435,
-1.1224442720413208,
0.4921185076236725,
-0.6485486030578613,
0.13622060418128967,
0.6719940304756165,
0.24287453293800354,
-0.5638889074325562,
-0.96440589427948,
-0.5998528003692627,
-0.888232409954071,
0.5000938177108765,
0.4940219223499298,
0.5339539647102356,
0.052186090499162674,
0.2926957905292511,
0.061784807592630386,
-0.03722532466053963,
-0.6789526343345642,
0.232583686709404,
-0.285144567489624,
0.007904398255050182,
0.1812877207994461,
-0.08460154384374619,
-0.2609391510486603,
-0.3001497983932495,
0.6402494311332703,
0.004321038722991943,
0.3261686861515045,
0.6442870497703552,
-0.14673081040382385,
0.33393073081970215,
0.7879617810249329,
0.9918140172958374,
1.1458457708358765,
-0.09003087878227234,
-0.08606221526861191,
0.14899981021881104,
-0.9747975468635559,
0.050672996789216995,
0.5514622926712036,
-0.2519701421260834,
0.00985277071595192,
0.21773375570774078,
0.31272557377815247,
-0.27872106432914734,
-0.007929427549242973,
0.5781363844871521,
-0.30429065227508545,
-0.5682942867279053,
-0.5914633274078369,
-0.2810923457145691,
0.1388389617204666,
0.11561963707208633,
0.356756329536438,
-0.14406099915504456,
0.3390862047672272,
-0.3829900920391083,
0.37723904848098755,
0.3731779158115387,
-0.23358461260795593,
-0.31465229392051697,
0.6241576671600342,
0.47744160890579224,
0.587776780128479,
0.021662050858139992,
0.054197605699300766,
-0.5252217650413513,
0.6148204207420349,
0.01978898234665394,
0.8935352563858032,
-0.073104627430439,
0.17767556011676788,
0.5046667456626892,
0.4800466001033783,
-0.08575956523418427,
0.5888582468032837,
-0.2709674835205078,
-0.34363627433776855,
-0.551035463809967,
-0.3982851505279541,
-0.3984847962856293,
0.0553896464407444,
-0.6618222594261169,
0.18840700387954712,
-0.27535194158554077,
-0.18690067529678345,
0.02222234196960926,
0.29372695088386536,
-0.4196387529373169,
-0.1527949869632721,
-0.11624821275472641,
0.7379313707351685,
-0.9484962224960327,
0.3965119421482086,
0.3070380985736847,
-0.36458277702331543,
-0.4782044291496277,
0.2573685050010681,
0.0007931424770504236,
-0.3347196578979492,
0.22901158034801483,
0.07209918648004532,
-0.02124270424246788,
-0.012040658853948116,
-0.18222278356552124,
-0.22944138944149017,
0.960780918598175,
0.3029353618621826,
-0.28239813446998596,
-0.0999240130186081,
0.37773969769477844,
0.3206067979335785,
-0.05079016461968422,
-0.11813600361347198,
0.6232938170433044,
0.6324095726013184,
-0.17929479479789734,
-1.0159413814544678,
-0.17505773901939392,
-0.05345643684267998,
-0.07951904088258743,
0.21370325982570648,
-0.33362454175949097,
0.618162214756012,
-0.1014968752861023,
-0.28485819697380066,
-0.0009984737262129784,
0.617835521697998,
-0.07778725028038025,
-0.23499472439289093,
0.21478171646595,
0.47938036918640137,
0.605451762676239,
-0.3588983416557312,
0.9981980323791504,
-0.48902472853660583,
0.30502161383628845,
0.7730717062950134,
-0.2854536175727844,
0.4994919002056122,
0.4622928500175476,
-0.13696415722370148,
0.16227662563323975,
0.3493182957172394,
0.08721518516540527,
0.4113897383213043,
0.32526248693466187,
-0.737826406955719,
-0.014391851611435413,
0.04605459049344063,
-0.7031953930854797,
0.38114112615585327,
0.41796016693115234,
-0.3611147105693817,
-0.43626096844673157,
-0.23686924576759338,
-0.0737169161438942,
0.11827050149440765,
-0.4051215648651123,
1.1514712572097778,
0.007947461679577827,
-0.5239136219024658,
-0.011037416756153107,
-0.14492133259773254,
0.1391187608242035,
-0.46566706895828247,
-0.16145257651805878,
-0.42710742354393005,
-0.029735460877418518,
-0.22269609570503235,
-0.9557128548622131,
0.5314710736274719,
0.46110546588897705,
-0.24888241291046143,
-0.33137398958206177,
0.12869243323802948,
-0.24197524785995483,
-0.4560011625289917,
-0.3054089844226837,
0.38817206025123596,
0.2468438595533371,
-0.08236920833587646,
-0.4152664840221405,
-0.2529183626174927,
-0.0425323024392128,
-0.28919726610183716,
-0.18603526055812836,
0.7476286888122559,
-0.36555057764053345,
0.18222953379154205,
0.4263531267642975,
0.3521711528301239,
-0.0062734223902225494,
0.09507229924201965,
0.6252903938293457,
-0.48570483922958374,
-0.8617132306098938,
-0.8334594964981079,
0.7766661643981934,
-0.38135284185409546,
-0.3214558959007263,
0.5910428166389465,
1.0361907482147217,
0.874204158782959,
-0.23351463675498962,
1.1899574995040894,
-0.4555332064628601,
0.48237428069114685,
-0.5409240126609802,
0.9799522757530212,
-0.09108908474445343,
0.038032978773117065,
-0.2081000953912735,
-0.8733360171318054,
-0.6605378985404968,
0.6536599397659302,
-0.5255473256111145,
-0.14326268434524536,
0.4778811037540436,
0.583056628704071,
-0.22750382125377655,
0.13345730304718018,
0.21556727588176727,
-0.31064826250076294,
0.28808683156967163,
0.2781907916069031,
0.9250792860984802,
-0.023752616718411446,
0.6195348501205444,
-0.0392848402261734,
0.12227733433246613,
0.19178971648216248,
-0.8062097430229187,
-0.79213947057724,
-0.8862817883491516,
0.039010826498270035,
-0.22860628366470337,
-0.06385169923305511,
0.957825779914856,
0.5836038589477539,
-0.9329732060432434,
-0.27589303255081177,
-0.2060140073299408,
-0.11477173864841461,
0.03267058730125427,
-0.16474804282188416,
0.5859730839729309,
-0.20080651342868805,
-0.866980254650116,
-0.16920408606529236,
0.08355949074029922,
0.3964291512966156,
-0.14909587800502777,
0.16241192817687988,
0.16202978789806366,
0.05517154186964035,
0.49298447370529175,
0.3861769437789917,
-0.8861400485038757,
-0.3801705241203308,
-0.46999335289001465,
-0.22546739876270294,
-0.14086240530014038,
1.2662285566329956,
-0.11018912494182587,
0.32865744829177856,
0.6833915114402771,
0.30778881907463074,
0.4122427701950073,
0.2910725474357605,
0.8257141709327698,
-0.503357470035553,
0.17471155524253845,
0.2350182980298996,
0.5388672351837158,
0.24905182421207428,
-0.32161301374435425,
0.46284186840057373,
0.014632688835263252,
-0.4805062413215637,
-0.15441903471946716,
0.3356327712535858,
-1.0731879472732544,
0.09924770146608353,
0.8099725842475891,
-0.38462451100349426,
0.23615679144859314,
-0.6215649247169495,
-0.4262852370738983,
0.21454571187496185,
-0.39277055859565735,
0.928205668926239,
0.8698676824569702,
-0.06842159479856491,
-0.007698269095271826,
-0.9429441690444946,
0.8708381056785583,
-0.11782894283533096,
-1.092769980430603,
0.43973782658576965,
0.803166925907135,
0.23233726620674133,
-0.08427464216947556,
0.731907069683075,
-0.7577815651893616,
0.3315800726413727,
-0.6005694270133972,
0.098515585064888,
0.125061497092247,
-0.0367317758500576,
-0.5104618668556213,
0.35116472840309143,
-0.23095320165157318,
0.04266316816210747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14523v1 | Empathy and the Right to Be an Exception: What LLMs Can and Cannot Do | 2024-01-25T21:30:06 | 2024-01-25T21:30:06 | William Kidder, Jason D'Cruz, Kush R. Varshney | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Advances in the performance of large language models (LLMs) have led some
researchers to propose the emergence of theory of mind (ToM) in artificial
intelligence (AI). LLMs can attribute beliefs, desires, intentions, and
emotions, and they will improve in their accuracy. Rather than employing the
characteristically human method of empathy, they learn to attribute mental
states by recognizing linguistic patterns in a dataset that typically do not
include that individual. We ask whether LLMs' inability to empathize precludes
them from honoring an individual's right to be an exception, that is, from
making assessments of character and predictions of behavior that reflect
appropriate sensitivity to a person's individuality. Can LLMs seriously
consider an individual's claim that their case is different based on internal
mental states like beliefs, desires, and intentions, or are they limited to
judging that case based on its similarities to others? We propose that the
method of empathy has special significance for honoring the right to be an
exception that is distinct from the value of predictive accuracy, at which LLMs
excel. We conclude by considering whether using empathy to consider exceptional
cases has intrinsic or merely practical value and we introduce conceptual and
empirical avenues for advancing this investigation. | [
-0.5267263650894165,
-0.653076708316803,
1.015275478363037,
0.05504779890179634,
-0.10471625626087189,
-0.16308121383190155,
-0.18401335179805756,
-0.435356467962265,
0.10057377815246582,
0.36139848828315735,
-0.3771660029888153,
-0.13096395134925842,
-0.9477629661560059,
0.2858661115169525,
-0.2945854365825653,
0.7923750877380371,
0.0049938964657485485,
-0.014431491494178772,
-0.33773401379585266,
-0.43650588393211365,
-0.2801106572151184,
-0.6866306662559509,
-0.5961578488349915,
-0.21292442083358765,
0.47763189673423767,
0.36480554938316345,
0.555802047252655,
0.7006962895393372,
0.598442554473877,
0.3107447028160095,
0.013889811933040619,
0.24079707264900208,
-0.27765581011772156,
-0.3883896768093109,
-0.44652795791625977,
-0.7163543701171875,
-0.7135893702507019,
0.313730925321579,
0.38668474555015564,
0.4451025128364563,
-0.09094061702489853,
-0.18133129179477692,
0.10026349127292633,
0.5796405076980591,
-0.42896002531051636,
-0.33909890055656433,
-0.7154613733291626,
0.24052976071834564,
-0.002091487869620323,
-0.2296624630689621,
-0.3986941874027252,
-0.3204014003276825,
0.02643127366900444,
-0.4972187578678131,
0.09148318320512772,
0.2666703760623932,
0.8458861112594604,
0.5134208798408508,
-0.47413474321365356,
-0.31017938256263733,
-0.42434102296829224,
1.0750423669815063,
-0.8340095281600952,
-0.031104926019906998,
0.5644324421882629,
0.052235450595617294,
-0.25800958275794983,
-0.338629812002182,
-0.921894371509552,
-0.11276096850633621,
0.13205169141292572,
0.2357938438653946,
-0.399282306432724,
0.2620013952255249,
0.45702552795410156,
0.31451520323753357,
-0.18960484862327576,
0.03132682666182518,
0.027262018993496895,
0.2950506806373596,
0.835352897644043,
0.36572369933128357,
0.4336662292480469,
-0.10479269921779633,
-0.24880892038345337,
0.08121740818023682,
-0.45693689584732056,
0.04440278187394142,
0.36762315034866333,
0.3448846936225891,
-0.18978147208690643,
0.5145255923271179,
0.3632435202598572,
0.10533543676137924,
0.0601373165845871,
0.19686532020568848,
-0.08146777004003525,
0.44982731342315674,
-0.3845989406108856,
0.12604770064353943,
0.5860222578048706,
0.7629303932189941,
0.927453339099884,
-0.007059034425765276,
-0.071798175573349,
0.2512093484401703,
0.6447141766548157,
-0.06578399240970612,
0.12928956747055054,
0.3360788822174072,
-0.7047236561775208,
-0.0011722411727532744,
0.14129741489887238,
-0.47867870330810547,
-0.598175585269928,
-0.3565065860748291,
0.23303531110286713,
-0.30894413590431213,
-0.4193255305290222,
0.10085921734571457,
-0.20286871492862701,
0.43087565898895264,
0.32451215386390686,
-0.7356244325637817,
0.5391071438789368,
0.8358217477798462,
0.7233173251152039,
-0.1969219148159027,
-0.6835134029388428,
-0.28688105940818787,
0.16061963140964508,
-0.6866099834442139,
0.6976087093353271,
-0.7355021238327026,
-0.7397605180740356,
-0.3077760636806488,
-0.00206631887704134,
-0.14929525554180145,
-0.5275089740753174,
0.5521764159202576,
-0.0751430094242096,
-0.3350191116333008,
-0.5509850978851318,
-0.8138622641563416,
-0.2933036684989929,
0.04641648381948471,
-0.010417715646326542,
0.3308417499065399,
0.29616475105285645,
-0.5176143646240234,
0.29733017086982727,
-0.7152837514877319,
-0.3969489336013794,
0.04462825134396553,
-0.3752330541610718,
-0.011104854755103588,
0.7630502581596375,
-0.3289511203765869,
0.5412760972976685,
-0.47752368450164795,
0.22502654790878296,
-0.7255375981330872,
-0.3158821761608124,
0.5982831120491028,
-0.5809826254844666,
0.7541968822479248,
0.26220396161079407,
-0.33099061250686646,
-0.14070425927639008,
-0.4102513790130615,
0.05213687941431999,
0.1843547224998474,
-0.16964595019817352,
-0.5876613855361938,
0.24351541697978973,
0.025377541780471802,
0.0622875802218914,
-0.04972140118479729,
-0.4785903990268707,
0.16169589757919312,
-0.2849964201450348,
0.32583847641944885,
1.4406416416168213,
-0.3060009479522705,
0.593242347240448,
-0.6252155303955078,
0.49980831146240234,
0.10250534862279892,
0.2528739273548126,
0.29050570726394653,
-0.40276679396629333,
-0.8666935563087463,
-0.3621438145637512,
-0.033956315368413925,
0.6211056113243103,
-0.005719483830034733,
0.5944532155990601,
-0.050652358680963516,
-0.14367984235286713,
-0.7694128751754761,
0.18924719095230103,
0.5367931723594666,
0.34351763129234314,
0.18740370869636536,
-0.5297946333885193,
-0.5953043103218079,
-1.015114426612854,
-0.8138301968574524,
-0.2557368576526642,
0.07737847417593002,
0.6762213706970215,
0.3470596969127655,
-0.01514496374875307,
1.0297331809997559,
-0.15424685180187225,
-0.12177889794111252,
-0.14015056192874908,
-0.10326799005270004,
0.22497951984405518,
0.6049648523330688,
0.5108696818351746,
-0.7491228580474854,
-0.3389420807361603,
0.03486885875463486,
-1.1537443399429321,
0.07135344296693802,
-0.03218407556414604,
-0.1173999160528183,
0.26063334941864014,
0.26870664954185486,
-0.7073375582695007,
0.7556511759757996,
0.2930581569671631,
-0.7328320145606995,
-0.06594757735729218,
-0.29142406582832336,
0.3228101432323456,
-1.1550178527832031,
-0.26961660385131836,
0.18726879358291626,
0.18507438898086548,
-0.742310106754303,
-0.13925357162952423,
-0.03584005683660507,
0.7157044410705566,
-0.46522247791290283,
0.8010686039924622,
0.0354127362370491,
-0.024256255477666855,
-0.4910103380680084,
-0.15700601041316986,
-0.2595991790294647,
0.13483396172523499,
-0.027605600655078888,
0.42853519320487976,
0.46242332458496094,
-0.8800289630889893,
0.21749241650104523,
0.21424853801727295,
-0.18561667203903198,
1.1358212232589722,
-0.3828345239162445,
0.40286311507225037,
-0.25847458839416504,
-0.12673208117485046,
-0.5724215507507324,
-0.3463647961616516,
0.5576958060264587,
-0.47260725498199463,
-0.0780344009399414,
0.13968217372894287,
-0.13027700781822205,
-0.23472139239311218,
-0.18546806275844574,
0.2778283357620239,
0.7898901700973511,
-0.4192787706851959,
1.0209505558013916,
0.473170667886734,
-0.1487916260957718,
-0.3615722060203552,
-0.839524507522583,
0.2632658779621124,
-0.7065665125846863,
-0.2002679854631424,
0.059737417846918106,
-0.40343618392944336,
-0.9346522688865662,
-0.036274611949920654,
0.22536823153495789,
-0.19568106532096863,
0.17242495715618134,
0.4478926658630371,
-0.05166409909725189,
0.04360760748386383,
0.10591485351324081,
0.17186371982097626,
-0.17819121479988098,
0.12640869617462158,
0.17980733513832092,
0.11215049028396606,
-0.2485533505678177,
-0.6776766180992126,
-0.4977540075778961,
0.5522675514221191,
0.6606481671333313,
0.1631937175989151,
0.32740864157676697,
-0.012414984405040741,
-0.6201298236846924,
-0.1279059499502182,
-0.5681478381156921,
-0.2355560064315796,
-0.437923401594162,
0.09962798655033112,
-0.41737502813339233,
-0.6526128053665161,
0.3757249116897583,
0.2766391336917877,
0.03129306063055992,
0.2208973616361618,
0.44806089997291565,
-0.3880842328071594,
1.2289085388183594,
0.8595032691955566,
-0.3547249138355255,
0.23027673363685608,
0.13794288039207458,
0.5258288979530334,
-1.0525295734405518,
0.06865837424993515,
-0.4193994402885437,
-0.4519917666912079,
-0.7243798971176147,
-0.03443710878491402,
0.056585248559713364,
-0.13318920135498047,
-0.24496304988861084,
-0.16946789622306824,
-0.4812973141670227,
0.377689391374588,
0.6752058267593384,
0.2530299127101898,
0.18852584064006805,
-0.28528890013694763,
0.4044031798839569,
-0.10263018310070038,
-0.6897556781768799,
-0.9111234545707703,
1.0823311805725098,
0.43924614787101746,
0.6931911110877991,
0.09843506664037704,
0.55711430311203,
0.6433640718460083,
0.523822546005249,
-0.8876529335975647,
0.7631717324256897,
0.0023873220197856426,
-0.6135558485984802,
-0.2003108561038971,
-0.10488012433052063,
-0.8425989151000977,
-0.0528603158891201,
0.1169450581073761,
-0.970634400844574,
0.5817691683769226,
0.37616869807243347,
-0.2829236388206482,
0.4397217929363251,
-0.9130977988243103,
0.5449432730674744,
-0.21684512495994568,
-0.1718354970216751,
-0.3322027325630188,
-0.6705037355422974,
0.14264914393424988,
-0.14880135655403137,
0.37051233649253845,
-0.5188091993331909,
-0.16218183934688568,
0.6205695271492004,
-0.23513245582580566,
0.9360072612762451,
-0.16863912343978882,
-0.14118199050426483,
0.3919183909893036,
0.16588619351387024,
0.284131795167923,
-0.1737138330936432,
-0.0878247395157814,
0.29895925521850586,
-0.10025647282600403,
-0.5721502900123596,
-0.6973105669021606,
0.45581066608428955,
-0.787106990814209,
-0.9694239497184753,
-0.5260187387466431,
-0.7557146549224854,
-0.14541968703269958,
-0.02431059256196022,
0.1874246597290039,
-0.22771389782428741,
-0.033959850668907166,
-0.1439828872680664,
0.5800800919532776,
-0.16056504845619202,
0.505654513835907,
0.4349250793457031,
0.2188597023487091,
-0.1554797738790512,
1.0987900495529175,
0.12495081126689911,
0.006140128709375858,
-0.03311527520418167,
0.4225119352340698,
-0.09649160504341125,
-0.5268996357917786,
0.038933880627155304,
0.15203073620796204,
-0.7272725701332092,
0.06832638382911682,
-0.6083288192749023,
0.07551425695419312,
-0.29637637734413147,
-0.6277702450752258,
-0.20729678869247437,
0.0760197564959526,
-0.3611515760421753,
-0.12359730154275894,
0.5998047590255737,
0.8639883995056152,
-0.2117907851934433,
0.06073003262281418,
-0.7897738814353943,
0.21270956099033356,
0.17710073292255402,
0.36323410272598267,
-0.02242616005241871,
-0.7958765029907227,
0.12292563915252686,
-0.04837104678153992,
-0.21052762866020203,
-0.4586191773414612,
0.30761489272117615,
-0.11005963385105133,
0.580155611038208,
0.7528008818626404,
0.21955853700637817,
0.756287693977356,
-0.5013961791992188,
0.499755859375,
-0.015117519535124302,
-1.160226821899414,
0.5284658074378967,
-0.30381080508232117,
-0.09055645763874054,
0.11436210572719574,
0.245908722281456,
-0.47633248567581177,
-0.6898216605186462,
-0.9348705410957336,
-0.54422527551651,
0.7214409112930298,
-0.18618445098400116,
0.5555980801582336,
-0.3050895035266876,
0.6603339910507202,
0.17289063334465027,
0.10597924143075943,
-0.6236129999160767,
0.04105917364358902,
-0.06439425051212311,
-0.6661072969436646,
-0.343018114566803,
-0.24971063435077667,
-0.4304393231868744,
-0.20898355543613434,
0.17631037533283234,
-0.22687208652496338,
0.37794408202171326,
0.3927302360534668,
0.17967507243156433,
-0.1817672848701477,
0.18825171887874603,
0.44187498092651367,
0.5797320008277893,
0.16283734142780304,
0.1204325407743454,
0.5689259767532349,
-0.13771046698093414,
0.2450609654188156,
-0.3295443654060364,
0.2627904415130615,
-0.492055743932724,
0.4986984431743622,
0.3045330345630646,
-0.17776203155517578,
-1.0179914236068726,
0.4688003659248352,
-0.05785670131444931,
-0.2473447620868683,
-0.32289305329322815,
0.3197762072086334,
-0.2182033210992813,
0.7226749062538147,
0.22200168669223785,
-0.035326991230249405,
0.13893164694309235,
-0.7784435749053955,
0.12954050302505493,
0.5908759832382202,
-0.37480857968330383,
-0.25234463810920715,
0.3298860788345337,
-0.14346083998680115,
-0.8815526366233826,
0.6472786664962769,
0.2735791504383087,
-0.24319976568222046,
0.936050534248352,
0.4540179371833801,
1.031590223312378,
-0.3895370662212372,
-0.26918840408325195,
-0.3411191701889038,
0.31158676743507385,
-0.10382930934429169,
0.4478199779987335,
0.08315669000148773,
-1.2830063104629517,
0.04207020252943039,
-0.2167261391878128,
-0.6045423150062561,
-0.30922767519950867,
-0.9553831815719604,
-0.1410120129585266,
-0.7074571251869202,
-0.282693088054657,
-0.43707334995269775,
-0.28181883692741394,
-0.47479698061943054,
0.3883347809314728,
-0.004052858799695969,
0.9422749876976013,
-0.6956660151481628,
0.6110132336616516,
0.8517851829528809,
0.07346782833337784,
-0.5649476647377014,
0.20830556750297546,
0.053200919181108475,
-0.9943824410438538,
0.256589412689209,
-0.02350618503987789,
-0.1572999805212021,
0.11224359273910522,
-0.5802311897277832,
-0.36204883456230164,
0.7751070857048035,
0.5574110746383667,
-0.3434605598449707,
-0.045001305639743805,
-0.1668611764907837,
0.4633099436759949,
-0.6703221797943115,
0.18776610493659973,
0.7577922344207764,
0.5452863574028015,
-0.3208368718624115,
-0.5897207856178284,
-0.01500646211206913,
-0.2334091067314148,
0.10108013451099396,
-0.09190535545349121,
-0.9793304800987244,
0.7217299938201904,
-0.5525951385498047,
0.002358760219067335,
0.048129379749298096,
0.3875540494918823,
0.2054343968629837,
0.7427130341529846,
0.3224455714225769,
0.5201490521430969,
0.782017171382904,
-0.06442250311374664,
1.3908419609069824,
-0.18508663773536682,
0.04810306057333946,
0.7142145037651062,
-0.5517110228538513,
0.569381594657898,
0.7264358401298523,
-0.23982709646224976,
0.0037093583960086107,
0.8211247324943542,
0.1965690404176712,
0.49917182326316833,
-0.09986856579780579,
-0.334541916847229,
-0.36333465576171875,
-0.3531583249568939,
-0.019588617607951164,
0.554683268070221,
0.39811447262763977,
-0.40648242831230164,
0.3101204037666321,
-0.053285304456949234,
-0.060332510620355606,
0.4319218695163727,
-0.474565714597702,
0.7267313599586487,
0.5608155727386475,
-0.4762415587902069,
0.20245784521102905,
-0.10720832645893097,
0.48788100481033325,
-0.2661217451095581,
-0.04325108230113983,
-0.29664289951324463,
0.25011539459228516,
-0.2378368079662323,
-0.8067979216575623,
0.14389251172542572,
0.07412359118461609,
-0.23509308695793152,
-0.09200477600097656,
0.31373491883277893,
0.41210129857063293,
-0.3471337854862213,
0.3802405297756195,
0.5925419926643372,
0.3712219297885895,
0.33310529589653015,
-0.6642362475395203,
0.21227005124092102,
-0.0814284235239029,
-0.45300641655921936,
0.3383405804634094,
0.5153440237045288,
0.08858413994312286,
0.9983222484588623,
0.32941991090774536,
0.257969468832016,
-0.07592624425888062,
-0.05115533247590065,
0.5732826590538025,
-1.0322058200836182,
-0.0056357248686254025,
-1.3274238109588623,
0.5234339237213135,
0.05486942455172539,
-0.5977457761764526,
0.6057711839675903,
0.13096505403518677,
0.8171760439872742,
0.14009633660316467,
1.1657966375350952,
0.005284776445478201,
0.5326544046401978,
-0.6987621784210205,
0.3848808705806732,
-0.8252344131469727,
0.1585984081029892,
-0.5026328563690186,
-0.7137378454208374,
-0.30272334814071655,
1.0287363529205322,
-0.4254909157752991,
0.40790092945098877,
0.6416229009628296,
0.6737589240074158,
0.21322056651115417,
0.19622069597244263,
0.7800573110580444,
0.2657987177371979,
0.2376536875963211,
0.7452169060707092,
1.043036699295044,
0.10800737142562866,
-0.04114154726266861,
0.23704931139945984,
-0.41926124691963196,
-0.2076425701379776,
-0.8743751645088196,
-0.758205771446228,
-0.3073529601097107,
0.05188395082950592,
-0.2970471978187561,
0.28218692541122437,
1.3986705541610718,
0.39094313979148865,
-0.6019027829170227,
-0.4059447646141052,
-0.35014665126800537,
0.4453989267349243,
-0.29878416657447815,
-0.21356652677059174,
0.1501976102590561,
-0.1933383047580719,
-1.2056608200073242,
0.16884532570838928,
0.6246736645698547,
0.31156444549560547,
0.13836361467838287,
-0.40110790729522705,
0.2301306128501892,
0.5762660503387451,
0.4886464774608612,
0.38168707489967346,
-1.003708839416504,
-0.7961631417274475,
-0.2915847599506378,
-0.09278423339128494,
0.34529685974121094,
0.804335355758667,
-0.24914228916168213,
0.28772100806236267,
-0.1872580200433731,
0.7517442107200623,
-0.5114027261734009,
0.02389080636203289,
0.5983943343162537,
0.12014329433441162,
-0.0681355893611908,
0.583521842956543,
0.5053463578224182,
-0.07012991607189178,
-0.5432289838790894,
0.31098178029060364,
0.2868729531764984,
-0.5948644280433655,
-1.0268532037734985,
0.6042876839637756,
-0.8130671977996826,
-0.13137923181056976,
0.9556809663772583,
-0.26603996753692627,
-0.14777053892612457,
-0.19513900578022003,
-0.21519336104393005,
0.13284708559513092,
-0.3994646966457367,
1.2508385181427002,
0.8524539470672607,
-0.5945117473602295,
-0.3702683448791504,
-0.5007336735725403,
0.2859541177749634,
0.6463539600372314,
-0.6837537288665771,
0.18425288796424866,
0.21886759996414185,
0.01183349546045065,
-0.1799566149711609,
0.7137274146080017,
0.0635073110461235,
0.25451019406318665,
0.003941745962947607,
0.13541138172149658,
0.34435367584228516,
-0.32484573125839233,
-0.4821106195449829,
-0.06280483305454254,
0.5680752396583557,
0.024199282750487328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01714v1 | TrICy: Trigger-guided Data-to-text Generation with Intent aware Attention-Copy | 2024-01-25T20:17:06 | 2024-01-25T20:17:06 | Vibhav Agarwal, Sourav Ghosh, Harichandana BSS, Himanshu Arora, Barath Raj Kandur Raja | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Data-to-text (D2T) generation is a crucial task in many natural language
understanding (NLU) applications and forms the foundation of task-oriented
dialog systems. In the context of conversational AI solutions that can work
directly with local data on the user's device, architectures utilizing large
pre-trained language models (PLMs) are impractical for on-device deployment due
to a high memory footprint. To this end, we propose TrICy, a novel lightweight
framework for an enhanced D2T task that generates text sequences based on the
intent in context and may further be guided by user-provided triggers. We
leverage an attention-copy mechanism to predict out-of-vocabulary (OOV) words
accurately. Performance analyses on E2E NLG dataset (BLEU: 66.43%, ROUGE-L:
70.14%), WebNLG dataset (BLEU: Seen 64.08%, Unseen 52.35%), and our Custom
dataset related to text messaging applications, showcase our architecture's
effectiveness. Moreover, we show that by leveraging an optional trigger input,
data-to-text generation quality increases significantly and achieves the new
SOTA score of 69.29% BLEU for E2E NLG. Furthermore, our analyses show that
TrICy achieves at least 24% and 3% improvement in BLEU and METEOR respectively
over LLMs like GPT-3, ChatGPT, and Llama 2. We also demonstrate that in some
scenarios, performance improvement due to triggers is observed even when they
are absent in training. | [
-0.004427604377269745,
-0.7771528363227844,
0.5413767099380493,
0.183019757270813,
-0.4129263758659363,
-0.15605434775352478,
-0.38524293899536133,
-0.25982749462127686,
-0.09503677487373352,
0.7092339396476746,
-0.5032989382743835,
-0.6620156764984131,
-0.3135913610458374,
0.06374989449977875,
-0.6336603164672852,
1.1133315563201904,
0.09247376024723053,
-0.5546656847000122,
-0.03978850692510605,
0.1654806137084961,
-0.700588583946228,
-0.23015250265598297,
-0.6605345010757446,
-0.11027289927005768,
0.3086346983909607,
0.9154542088508606,
0.4450320601463318,
0.5348851084709167,
0.3671456575393677,
0.09821976721286774,
0.16371260583400726,
0.45191526412963867,
-0.7683732509613037,
0.27893832325935364,
0.0047237081453204155,
-0.4694780111312866,
-0.4135259687900543,
-0.2096325010061264,
0.3527078926563263,
0.27561286091804504,
-0.06106032431125641,
0.16939860582351685,
0.23223042488098145,
0.7830259203910828,
-0.6518731713294983,
0.03974539786577225,
-0.9112719297409058,
-0.17571556568145752,
-0.4009378254413605,
-0.2781256437301636,
-0.5644009113311768,
-0.16425848007202148,
0.2643725275993347,
-0.7494867444038391,
0.13097207248210907,
0.2500912845134735,
0.31626254320144653,
0.6860163807868958,
-0.3027832508087158,
-0.6912350058555603,
-0.706015944480896,
0.5420705080032349,
-0.4700855016708374,
0.19207210838794708,
0.13486537337303162,
-0.06911741197109222,
-0.18769988417625427,
-0.8422490954399109,
-0.9105958342552185,
-0.1567390412092209,
0.15849170088768005,
0.33278152346611023,
0.04092735797166824,
-0.046058617532253265,
0.1419581174850464,
0.3184845745563507,
-0.6215182542800903,
-0.1972619742155075,
-0.04901352524757385,
0.13951663672924042,
0.6520504355430603,
0.15097570419311523,
0.21651655435562134,
-0.2919960916042328,
-0.5003626346588135,
0.1846657544374466,
-0.6897433400154114,
-0.20369568467140198,
0.22672434151172638,
0.43957263231277466,
-0.2853710353374481,
0.7552822232246399,
-0.013926197774708271,
0.8224123120307922,
0.430530309677124,
0.2630602717399597,
0.07131574302911758,
-0.7437793612480164,
-0.06897642463445663,
0.43886616826057434,
1.0203639268875122,
0.5667605400085449,
0.3161217272281647,
-0.19423815608024597,
0.18029798567295074,
-0.12268179655075073,
0.3008593022823334,
-0.669601321220398,
-0.039994508028030396,
0.35212498903274536,
-0.06271662563085556,
-0.4907430112361908,
-0.14235614240169525,
-0.8965796232223511,
-0.24294252693653107,
-0.00039477928658016026,
0.21884596347808838,
-0.4650290906429291,
0.001703672925941646,
0.4201677441596985,
0.3028865158557892,
-0.21860864758491516,
-0.0057929097674787045,
-0.9580327868461609,
0.12339864671230316,
0.49239662289619446,
1.0162876844406128,
-0.5042942762374878,
-0.17730246484279633,
-0.5413993000984192,
0.5090909600257874,
-0.14688263833522797,
0.6455971002578735,
-0.20887959003448486,
-0.3730533719062805,
0.049226559698581696,
-0.5489218235015869,
-0.08185501396656036,
-0.24098089337348938,
0.6548709273338318,
-0.42943912744522095,
0.5038317441940308,
-0.14469099044799805,
-0.5986157655715942,
-0.06037023663520813,
-0.01337910071015358,
-0.6422283053398132,
1.3761491775512695,
-0.01745825633406639,
-1.0172770023345947,
0.6224004030227661,
-0.8802858591079712,
-0.672199547290802,
0.2540152966976166,
0.06448182463645935,
-0.5302951335906982,
0.06909618526697159,
0.1922193169593811,
0.49279218912124634,
-0.3875131607055664,
0.283801794052124,
-0.2956175208091736,
-0.4018338620662689,
-0.039565663784742355,
-0.31043675541877747,
0.48649030923843384,
-0.007354763336479664,
-0.7394425868988037,
-0.11108201742172241,
-0.8486607074737549,
0.0833565890789032,
0.06661591678857803,
-0.25958600640296936,
-0.20452764630317688,
-0.0162567887455225,
0.08109746128320694,
0.23863773047924042,
0.24477092921733856,
-0.6764715909957886,
0.1966400295495987,
-0.6594759821891785,
0.32218867540359497,
0.273806095123291,
0.315047949552536,
0.45342817902565,
-0.15006636083126068,
0.03749106824398041,
-0.07565449178218842,
-0.055053479969501495,
0.028052078559994698,
-0.6290683746337891,
-0.7451413869857788,
-0.00980419758707285,
0.0047198389656841755,
0.7302591800689697,
-1.038839340209961,
0.44186556339263916,
-0.5191012620925903,
-0.2880631387233734,
-0.3894261121749878,
0.3942202031612396,
0.2725314199924469,
0.6825236678123474,
0.3104672431945801,
0.1291642040014267,
-0.36559316515922546,
-0.46545207500457764,
-0.4289112985134125,
-0.28993096947669983,
0.1588517278432846,
0.5784040093421936,
0.23010897636413574,
-0.06326932460069656,
1.2842588424682617,
-0.3910481929779053,
-0.4304845333099365,
-0.7050186395645142,
0.355387419462204,
0.0834849551320076,
0.04648207500576973,
0.43713146448135376,
-0.7373591661453247,
-0.7213495373725891,
-0.060661446303129196,
-0.5789763927459717,
-0.40819621086120605,
-0.17515689134597778,
-0.19277732074260712,
0.43228772282600403,
0.284930944442749,
-0.7367693781852722,
0.48262783885002136,
0.5260540843009949,
-0.19366446137428284,
0.10386921465396881,
-0.1899271458387375,
0.05822718143463135,
-1.6142984628677368,
0.20565959811210632,
-0.19841623306274414,
-0.132819265127182,
-0.9347758889198303,
-0.9229799509048462,
-0.06101923808455467,
-0.10193425416946411,
-0.6165623068809509,
0.737694263458252,
-0.13252197206020355,
-0.228399395942688,
-0.31115615367889404,
0.36259692907333374,
-0.09260040521621704,
0.394417405128479,
0.11618217825889587,
0.9718731641769409,
0.24891164898872375,
-0.8493981957435608,
0.366047203540802,
0.5059555172920227,
-0.24081391096115112,
0.5514820218086243,
-0.5622073411941528,
0.3907274603843689,
0.17853331565856934,
0.045864738523960114,
-0.8654683232307434,
-0.42157232761383057,
0.3620411455631256,
-0.4942936599254608,
0.249642476439476,
0.10154011845588684,
-0.6785048246383667,
-0.31257832050323486,
-0.12403170764446259,
0.47697851061820984,
0.3110968768596649,
-0.6762776374816895,
0.28507688641548157,
0.18896172940731049,
-0.13792003691196442,
-0.4780152440071106,
-0.637121856212616,
0.25639158487319946,
-0.20502471923828125,
-0.5877524018287659,
0.4054713249206543,
0.05054282769560814,
0.04661482200026512,
-0.05531555414199829,
0.2619556784629822,
0.11103255301713943,
-0.1262657195329666,
0.2515701949596405,
0.2543618977069855,
0.3185136616230011,
0.5986342430114746,
0.004702216945588589,
-0.20640145242214203,
-0.14960941672325134,
-0.6731733679771423,
0.5948374271392822,
0.2305675446987152,
-0.2385711669921875,
-0.571856677532196,
0.306588739156723,
0.42093804478645325,
-0.19903656840324402,
0.36170250177383423,
0.7318598628044128,
-0.0950518250465393,
-0.3906892240047455,
-0.2778019905090332,
-0.19224154949188232,
-0.4513002634048462,
0.34168165922164917,
-0.09849944710731506,
-0.8856968879699707,
-0.014545397832989693,
-0.013531433418393135,
0.18291598558425903,
0.2558451294898987,
0.9650163650512695,
-0.12452280521392822,
0.7860217094421387,
0.35816454887390137,
-0.014587833546102047,
0.7153670787811279,
-0.15949022769927979,
0.4999231994152069,
-0.6917186379432678,
-0.025681518018245697,
-0.04065190628170967,
-0.2493039071559906,
-0.5940384268760681,
-0.5124441385269165,
0.4494428336620331,
-0.1519174426794052,
0.015190410427749157,
0.3183571696281433,
-0.5765493512153625,
0.18717418611049652,
0.5087631344795227,
0.04327268898487091,
0.34948280453681946,
0.1102416142821312,
0.31173571944236755,
0.14469411969184875,
-0.9695801138877869,
-0.5047556161880493,
1.5743520259857178,
-0.14191360771656036,
0.6901684403419495,
-0.27835017442703247,
0.962306797504425,
0.2896974980831146,
0.1818087100982666,
-0.5939475893974304,
0.5646114349365234,
-0.2040794938802719,
-0.6663960814476013,
-0.1999528855085373,
-0.5237612724304199,
-0.7165586352348328,
-0.5881251692771912,
-0.13521485030651093,
-0.8180384635925293,
-0.032384227961301804,
0.2792510688304901,
-0.6090699434280396,
0.23124048113822937,
-0.7048711776733398,
0.6747737526893616,
-0.47707295417785645,
-0.8612614870071411,
-0.10295707732439041,
-0.5264790058135986,
0.34039807319641113,
-0.04957249388098717,
-0.06977619230747223,
-0.2055635154247284,
-0.186761736869812,
0.6345826983451843,
-0.08498284220695496,
0.8188101649284363,
-0.1130506694316864,
-0.012906474061310291,
0.757278323173523,
-0.04623324051499367,
0.5352730751037598,
0.3156305253505707,
-0.040114231407642365,
0.05328753963112831,
-0.5516825318336487,
0.05249549821019173,
-0.4321412742137909,
0.786939263343811,
-0.4384036958217621,
-0.07765667885541916,
-0.07584825158119202,
-0.9614916443824768,
-0.16427132487297058,
0.321880578994751,
0.8045466542243958,
0.43515247106552124,
-0.12426681816577911,
0.15937916934490204,
0.7717809081077576,
-0.22743888199329376,
0.5966328382492065,
0.24966512620449066,
0.05987344682216644,
-0.432197630405426,
0.9193773865699768,
-0.05220568925142288,
0.3656190037727356,
0.4879254996776581,
-0.06953728944063187,
-0.4644327163696289,
-0.49012142419815063,
-0.630897045135498,
-0.07256713509559631,
-0.18747681379318237,
-0.21899591386318207,
-0.9270347952842712,
0.1841869354248047,
-0.32380014657974243,
-0.18898476660251617,
-0.6873103380203247,
-0.41174814105033875,
-0.5557699799537659,
0.09026654809713364,
0.7093116044998169,
0.8335145711898804,
0.10195640474557877,
0.5262967348098755,
-0.608906626701355,
0.5285265445709229,
0.3374284505844116,
0.43859419226646423,
-0.5347267985343933,
-0.32464271783828735,
-0.25565391778945923,
0.14981597661972046,
-0.2289535105228424,
-0.8638990521430969,
0.28482168912887573,
0.41247960925102234,
0.13781389594078064,
-0.0033430601470172405,
0.26409390568733215,
0.32734841108322144,
-0.17087361216545105,
0.8011122941970825,
0.11661326140165329,
-0.9574821591377258,
0.8296992182731628,
-0.42466428875923157,
0.26312255859375,
0.7335017323493958,
0.06667031347751617,
-0.4097948372364044,
-0.36958837509155273,
-0.5884458422660828,
-0.8095602989196777,
0.947975754737854,
0.5946590304374695,
-0.062112629413604736,
-0.16415736079216003,
0.65534907579422,
0.07632581144571304,
0.34565991163253784,
-0.5095884203910828,
-0.11606437712907791,
-0.14048166573047638,
-0.8162704110145569,
-0.17265823483467102,
-0.3013516962528229,
0.25747472047805786,
0.40120992064476013,
0.4570873975753784,
-0.23255281150341034,
0.26445072889328003,
0.37050363421440125,
-0.24506312608718872,
0.025011051446199417,
0.21609516441822052,
0.5382087230682373,
0.032824765890836716,
-0.2097535878419876,
-0.15672194957733154,
0.26270100474357605,
-0.7498149871826172,
0.08006497472524643,
0.07494839280843735,
-0.38570457696914673,
-0.01940186694264412,
0.31119799613952637,
0.8672681450843811,
0.3896995782852173,
-0.4365094006061554,
0.5248743295669556,
-0.13482636213302612,
-0.0691760778427124,
0.10803378373384476,
0.11772095412015915,
-0.10290970653295517,
-0.031886518001556396,
0.02940654195845127,
-0.20148085057735443,
0.31292054057121277,
-0.2829027771949768,
0.3570573627948761,
0.06537499278783798,
-0.5207318067550659,
-0.29212769865989685,
0.6166548728942871,
0.45896556973457336,
-0.1799013912677765,
0.5218464136123657,
-0.32940948009490967,
-0.49179401993751526,
0.2592603266239166,
0.4675464928150177,
1.1408687829971313,
-0.08444502204656601,
0.03272005170583725,
0.444935142993927,
0.16992314159870148,
-0.02803707867860794,
0.5600234270095825,
-0.2222239226102829,
-0.7042783498764038,
-0.14168424904346466,
-0.3071851134300232,
-0.3107253611087799,
-0.06742388010025024,
-0.32284829020500183,
0.6224471926689148,
-0.27069607377052307,
-0.30086663365364075,
-0.36260786652565,
0.19865509867668152,
-0.6189661026000977,
0.07947112619876862,
0.2520109713077545,
0.672691285610199,
-0.6052449941635132,
0.7661270499229431,
0.5498201251029968,
-0.10721790045499802,
-0.6404387950897217,
0.18760782480239868,
-0.0024786642752587795,
-0.7104082703590393,
0.5020191073417664,
0.24195191264152527,
-0.1659024953842163,
0.40173232555389404,
-0.18795624375343323,
-0.7380651831626892,
1.210741639137268,
0.2682076394557953,
-0.6190187931060791,
-0.06819454580545425,
0.5580363273620605,
0.4224306643009186,
-0.7005262970924377,
0.19309119880199432,
0.7075811624526978,
0.34901657700538635,
0.329158753156662,
-0.7893335223197937,
-0.17086383700370789,
0.027179207652807236,
-0.09171726554632187,
0.11124266684055328,
-0.5942812561988831,
0.5266532301902771,
-0.5254946351051331,
-0.43754029273986816,
-0.1516188532114029,
0.34261682629585266,
0.2856471538543701,
0.458446204662323,
0.4061679542064667,
0.6918330192565918,
0.42363011837005615,
-0.1234041377902031,
1.0396556854248047,
-0.7650030851364136,
0.2706131935119629,
1.346070408821106,
-0.5753363966941833,
0.728417158126831,
0.4555738866329193,
0.42386433482170105,
0.1971016228199005,
0.39628100395202637,
0.3694024980068207,
0.6432735323905945,
-0.24569149315357208,
-0.2694242000579834,
-0.19097740948200226,
-0.37483763694763184,
-0.12485432624816895,
0.6777793169021606,
0.3063650131225586,
-0.2706437110900879,
-0.13242661952972412,
0.035953834652900696,
-0.11562558263540268,
-0.10672597587108612,
-0.1419897824525833,
1.113073706626892,
-0.037818584591150284,
-0.685798704624176,
0.2880016267299652,
-0.5776118040084839,
0.42761731147766113,
-0.27842527627944946,
0.014896905981004238,
-0.10428176075220108,
0.43296775221824646,
-0.25838664174079895,
-1.0518828630447388,
0.285347580909729,
0.3028284013271332,
-0.09189335256814957,
-0.36024031043052673,
0.9010589718818665,
-0.734401524066925,
-0.36814460158348083,
0.25931236147880554,
0.27037614583969116,
-0.17999045550823212,
-0.13952851295471191,
-0.5200387835502625,
0.1490212082862854,
0.0412849485874176,
-0.40417808294296265,
-0.28526192903518677,
0.6707723736763,
0.11614405363798141,
0.5965322256088257,
0.6244383454322815,
0.09920153766870499,
0.0814681425690651,
-0.01641506887972355,
0.72475266456604,
-0.4357697069644928,
-0.4976823627948761,
-0.7194932103157043,
0.48356685042381287,
-0.23827816545963287,
-0.4697856903076172,
0.6112613677978516,
0.658863365650177,
0.5598806142807007,
0.23763640224933624,
0.8979108929634094,
-0.28866124153137207,
0.7075506448745728,
-0.45148882269859314,
0.5927779078483582,
-0.46765413880348206,
0.2369253784418106,
-0.0731467679142952,
-0.957098662853241,
-0.062402643263339996,
0.04089317098259926,
-0.5241454839706421,
0.0002423832193017006,
0.5555189251899719,
0.6697322130203247,
0.1292138397693634,
0.1672201156616211,
0.16852796077728271,
0.07706251740455627,
0.32789599895477295,
0.9747151732444763,
0.6579609513282776,
-0.5637772679328918,
0.7495756149291992,
-0.1823357492685318,
-0.26445043087005615,
-0.4835185110569,
-0.8249306082725525,
-1.1090565919876099,
-0.6071153879165649,
-0.10407257825136185,
-0.0012375923106446862,
0.20922665297985077,
0.8080489039421082,
0.6640152931213379,
-0.5177262425422668,
0.012172413989901543,
-0.6371688842773438,
0.03429647162556648,
0.16613219678401947,
-0.1343105435371399,
0.256279319524765,
-0.5716768503189087,
-0.6223069429397583,
0.21123692393302917,
0.6439751982688904,
0.10289555042982101,
0.18852703273296356,
-0.04403797909617424,
-0.11900485306978226,
-0.03931264206767082,
0.441384881734848,
-0.016133448109030724,
-0.4087572693824768,
-0.3037623167037964,
0.08142662048339844,
-0.2817920446395874,
-0.08705559372901917,
0.8480890989303589,
-0.6432334184646606,
0.6198664307594299,
0.5112375617027283,
0.48134762048721313,
0.5319381356239319,
-0.013034946285188198,
0.7970020771026611,
-0.819348156452179,
0.11622727662324905,
0.4267197251319885,
-0.1437104344367981,
0.42374393343925476,
-0.6240519881248474,
0.31001994013786316,
0.18777798116207123,
-0.45613011717796326,
-0.5493966937065125,
0.14220064878463745,
-1.0640599727630615,
0.3156529366970062,
1.3220924139022827,
0.1286981701850891,
-0.31584054231643677,
-0.14315930008888245,
-0.3967466354370117,
0.6210241913795471,
-0.475204199552536,
0.8802433013916016,
0.32852837443351746,
-0.07009910047054291,
-0.13208669424057007,
-0.6817299127578735,
0.9498557448387146,
0.39861467480659485,
-1.0377123355865479,
0.6207605600357056,
0.16447773575782776,
-0.0030496586114168167,
-0.032533179968595505,
0.5903576016426086,
0.030933357775211334,
0.37977635860443115,
-0.12500892579555511,
0.21378615498542786,
-0.1616050899028778,
-0.40451982617378235,
-0.005643798038363457,
-0.06855980306863785,
-0.381548136472702,
-0.23556776344776154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01713v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01713v2 | Prompting Large Language Models for Zero-Shot Clinical Prediction with Structured Longitudinal Electronic Health Record Data | 2024-01-25T20:14:50 | 2024-02-10T16:31:40 | Yinghao Zhu, Zixiang Wang, Junyi Gao, Yuning Tong, Jingkun An, Weibin Liao, Ewen M. Harrison, Liantao Ma, Chengwei Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The inherent complexity of structured longitudinal Electronic Health Records
(EHR) data poses a significant challenge when integrated with Large Language
Models (LLMs), which are traditionally tailored for natural language
processing. Motivated by the urgent need for swift decision-making during new
disease outbreaks, where traditional predictive models often fail due to a lack
of historical data, this research investigates the adaptability of LLMs, like
GPT-4, to EHR data. We particularly focus on their zero-shot capabilities,
which enable them to make predictions in scenarios in which they haven't been
explicitly trained. In response to the longitudinal, sparse, and
knowledge-infused nature of EHR data, our prompting approach involves taking
into account specific EHR characteristics such as units and reference ranges,
and employing an in-context learning strategy that aligns with clinical
contexts. Our comprehensive experiments on the MIMIC-IV and TJH datasets
demonstrate that with our elaborately designed prompting framework, LLMs can
improve prediction performance in key tasks such as mortality, length-of-stay,
and 30-day readmission by about 35\%, surpassing ML models in few-shot
settings. Our research underscores the potential of LLMs in enhancing clinical
decision-making, especially in urgent healthcare situations like the outbreak
of emerging diseases with no labeled data. The code is publicly available at
https://github.com/yhzhu99/llm4healthcare for reproducibility. | [
0.06257002800703049,
-0.9358008503913879,
1.2246263027191162,
-0.1167871356010437,
-0.15350668132305145,
-0.23538216948509216,
-0.12932023406028748,
-0.4570446014404297,
0.07320550084114075,
0.3665751516819,
-0.6140716075897217,
-0.8239150047302246,
-0.35822591185569763,
0.24829724431037903,
-0.11154977977275848,
1.2205270528793335,
-0.08278664201498032,
0.04446786269545555,
-0.010027631185948849,
0.024264661595225334,
-0.802873969078064,
-0.4620814919471741,
-0.5117674469947815,
-0.6032630205154419,
0.8209213614463806,
0.5044509172439575,
0.35295403003692627,
0.7817283272743225,
0.17637032270431519,
0.0814250260591507,
0.1702098399400711,
-0.30913782119750977,
-0.5517823100090027,
0.5001825094223022,
0.2246054857969284,
-0.40551483631134033,
-0.795100212097168,
-0.5932219624519348,
0.46189311146736145,
0.5930280089378357,
-0.35207661986351013,
0.16192269325256348,
-0.017197659239172935,
0.4933845102787018,
-0.3418043553829193,
0.24097603559494019,
-0.7259331345558167,
0.17158342897891998,
-0.22277353703975677,
-0.5637012720108032,
-0.4358554184436798,
-0.05820769444108009,
0.39234301447868347,
-0.6090766191482544,
0.24071843922138214,
0.06915807723999023,
0.5319475531578064,
0.03566150367259979,
-0.3680669665336609,
-0.06388717889785767,
-0.82601398229599,
0.5595204830169678,
-0.7061553001403809,
0.4517255425453186,
0.3626357316970825,
0.3245585262775421,
-0.20614898204803467,
-0.7237079739570618,
-0.3457830250263214,
-0.29032665491104126,
0.23731517791748047,
0.2830798327922821,
-0.3854517936706543,
0.2136695832014084,
0.4062824249267578,
0.02608681097626686,
-0.8797399997711182,
0.30716538429260254,
-0.3714805841445923,
0.04880190268158913,
0.2475619614124298,
0.540928065776825,
0.26000627875328064,
-0.09528765827417374,
-0.0944916158914566,
0.3485029637813568,
-0.9546133279800415,
-0.15564419329166412,
-0.2395206242799759,
0.4515002369880676,
-0.34726396203041077,
0.45985153317451477,
-0.23409709334373474,
0.5445523858070374,
0.3965838551521301,
-0.03903713449835777,
0.40243491530418396,
-0.028871040791273117,
-0.405666321516037,
0.3721555173397064,
0.6205620765686035,
0.32100024819374084,
0.0705002099275589,
-0.005087978206574917,
-0.0906648263335228,
0.012236944399774075,
0.3453981280326843,
-0.8667178153991699,
-0.3309304714202881,
0.5494718551635742,
-0.33962467312812805,
-0.13007935881614685,
-0.34816354513168335,
-0.9629882574081421,
-0.2648405134677887,
-0.250167578458786,
0.5706836581230164,
-0.4580252170562744,
0.05594239756464958,
0.34009861946105957,
0.23837339878082275,
0.2738216817378998,
0.44988301396369934,
-0.9097867012023926,
0.2143157571554184,
0.5836036801338196,
0.8799232840538025,
0.046963222324848175,
-0.19788631796836853,
-0.7321551442146301,
0.32477831840515137,
-0.32324114441871643,
0.7508893013000488,
-0.35109299421310425,
-0.5797756910324097,
0.21282464265823364,
-0.016954153776168823,
-0.17193633317947388,
-0.288790762424469,
0.5977955460548401,
-0.31445205211639404,
0.2490038424730301,
-0.053723353892564774,
-0.7225081324577332,
0.10538072884082794,
0.4725947082042694,
-0.5184721946716309,
0.5571093559265137,
0.11794301122426987,
-0.6581787467002869,
0.48946258425712585,
-0.5544075965881348,
-0.4337022304534912,
0.4313165843486786,
-0.3829266428947449,
-0.8164856433868408,
0.04674047976732254,
0.42783108353614807,
0.6731992959976196,
-0.1758805215358734,
0.4654254913330078,
-0.5710324645042419,
-0.14267799258232117,
-0.004103085491806269,
-0.2594379186630249,
0.2467433214187622,
0.0034719647374004126,
-0.24296115338802338,
0.3093981444835663,
-0.513603925704956,
0.031552884727716446,
0.32397428154945374,
-0.06346854567527771,
-0.17049789428710938,
-0.08748134225606918,
-0.20000402629375458,
0.07504895329475403,
-0.005282271653413773,
-0.3599260151386261,
0.24954122304916382,
-0.41213372349739075,
0.23600326478481293,
0.5447345972061157,
0.3628009557723999,
0.19317582249641418,
-0.6981761455535889,
0.7339953184127808,
-0.0674804225564003,
0.3573381006717682,
-0.7311638593673706,
-0.6841742992401123,
-0.2811834216117859,
-0.1363593190908432,
-0.020574675872921944,
0.5943722724914551,
-0.6184476017951965,
0.13610437512397766,
-0.5004803538322449,
-0.2557114064693451,
-0.33753228187561035,
-0.1594126671552658,
0.28782564401626587,
0.9815686941146851,
0.5939619541168213,
-0.028141237795352936,
-0.6180824637413025,
-0.520379364490509,
0.008605176582932472,
-0.33616867661476135,
-0.36724597215652466,
0.3709190785884857,
0.38449105620384216,
-0.3544003963470459,
0.58797287940979,
-0.4815351665019989,
-0.28472083806991577,
-0.5117024183273315,
0.08541368693113327,
0.50228351354599,
0.0995776355266571,
0.21477873623371124,
-0.34011396765708923,
-0.5238586068153381,
0.17004798352718353,
-0.9476689100265503,
-0.09789709746837616,
-0.13990028202533722,
0.20109914243221283,
-0.12948335707187653,
0.3868425488471985,
-0.36729007959365845,
0.38398104906082153,
0.5548591613769531,
-0.17954713106155396,
0.5408156514167786,
-0.485251247882843,
0.04046280309557915,
-0.8960980772972107,
0.06369652599096298,
0.07556457072496414,
-0.09946268796920776,
-1.120141863822937,
-0.38139036297798157,
0.13645301759243011,
-0.026854248717427254,
-0.37366414070129395,
0.6944426894187927,
-0.47142332792282104,
0.3227808177471161,
-0.03165588155388832,
-0.29666802287101746,
-0.03336606174707413,
0.1562352329492569,
0.1380896270275116,
0.387977659702301,
0.71087247133255,
-0.5242264270782471,
-0.1350822150707245,
0.48286983370780945,
-0.17564333975315094,
0.5250853300094604,
-0.8743816614151001,
0.11336743831634521,
-0.3157876431941986,
0.4076063632965088,
-0.4168688952922821,
-0.615024745464325,
0.17465855181217194,
-0.36798083782196045,
0.4762198328971863,
-0.2558059096336365,
-0.16946251690387726,
-0.4291042983531952,
-0.33517423272132874,
0.40413177013397217,
0.655565083026886,
-0.19128380715847015,
0.4871262311935425,
0.12671132385730743,
-0.42527949810028076,
-0.2920614182949066,
-0.629869818687439,
0.15109845995903015,
-0.32413098216056824,
-0.23288896679878235,
0.4987630844116211,
-0.22980329394340515,
0.017165735363960266,
0.0003218472993467003,
0.1473163217306137,
-0.0010369149968028069,
-0.2268241047859192,
0.47827935218811035,
0.7499395608901978,
-0.3782675266265869,
0.17659814655780792,
-0.007108417339622974,
-0.043957650661468506,
0.047240883111953735,
-0.4105144143104553,
0.28289440274238586,
0.030784329399466515,
-0.5435084700584412,
-0.5058118104934692,
0.14820347726345062,
0.5737529397010803,
0.178037628531456,
0.6092134118080139,
0.16821010410785675,
-0.5292909145355225,
-0.11978363990783691,
-0.5022867321968079,
-0.3070223927497864,
-0.35522934794425964,
0.24112999439239502,
-0.1421242505311966,
-0.9905946850776672,
0.35612228512763977,
0.17826545238494873,
0.022710241377353668,
0.13131369650363922,
0.9309684038162231,
0.02743496559560299,
0.9113976955413818,
0.41465726494789124,
-0.15667010843753815,
0.2976737916469574,
0.13804937899112701,
0.13826879858970642,
-0.7680983543395996,
-0.2870399057865143,
-0.22284960746765137,
0.10365372151136398,
-0.6171694993972778,
-0.29249146580696106,
0.940449595451355,
-0.2951172888278961,
-0.424793541431427,
-0.202923983335495,
-0.26132071018218994,
0.21926449239253998,
0.02395789884030819,
0.40327829122543335,
0.3468998670578003,
-0.16526734828948975,
-0.01623496599495411,
-0.04298599436879158,
-0.7655037641525269,
-0.23242199420928955,
1.4359432458877563,
0.44184207916259766,
0.626867949962616,
-0.11971624195575714,
0.6632386445999146,
0.13423191010951996,
0.40514037013053894,
-0.8983871936798096,
0.021499281749129295,
0.09624022990465164,
-0.4062693417072296,
-0.30545079708099365,
-0.27838143706321716,
-1.4113385677337646,
-0.16232465207576752,
-0.30191752314567566,
-0.7018563151359558,
0.04133166745305061,
0.36438295245170593,
-0.8493871092796326,
0.09853155165910721,
-0.33894339203834534,
0.7679906487464905,
-0.28933143615722656,
-0.26218023896217346,
0.2600122392177582,
-0.695807933807373,
0.2852481007575989,
-0.3619425594806671,
0.37438341975212097,
-0.1557828038930893,
-0.05500369518995285,
0.31819605827331543,
-0.2611970007419586,
0.8172666430473328,
0.0447038933634758,
0.12570849061012268,
0.11991647630929947,
0.13677868247032166,
0.5278211236000061,
0.05687050148844719,
-0.22469069063663483,
0.2185780256986618,
-0.04577470198273659,
-0.2395423799753189,
-0.41055673360824585,
0.6019465327262878,
-0.5381265878677368,
-0.4318716824054718,
-0.3283701241016388,
-0.325216144323349,
-0.47009140253067017,
0.298726886510849,
0.39280369877815247,
0.5521525144577026,
-0.3723066449165344,
0.13515573740005493,
0.6650190353393555,
-0.27953290939331055,
0.20689035952091217,
0.6198931336402893,
-0.2550741136074066,
-0.2435738742351532,
0.5033701658248901,
0.07336649298667908,
0.16568215191364288,
0.45802441239356995,
0.46431517601013184,
-0.3803517818450928,
-0.7724488973617554,
-0.5535487532615662,
0.27605196833610535,
-0.34851929545402527,
-0.3303092122077942,
-0.7058440446853638,
-0.1902143955230713,
-0.28913843631744385,
-0.3160054087638855,
0.0869516134262085,
0.18679170310497284,
-0.4583286643028259,
-0.32144486904144287,
0.5637825131416321,
0.8947287797927856,
0.24805571138858795,
0.07383449375629425,
-1.0923486948013306,
0.14731277525424957,
0.11466323584318161,
0.36340656876564026,
0.07084284722805023,
-0.7298613786697388,
-0.186282679438591,
-0.3183057904243469,
-0.20775291323661804,
-1.084574818611145,
0.6222448348999023,
0.2647366523742676,
0.3764841854572296,
0.39648929238319397,
0.020548732951283455,
0.6978250741958618,
-1.0974798202514648,
0.6962175369262695,
0.3076443076133728,
-0.6555346846580505,
0.6840465068817139,
-0.9415597915649414,
0.4413645565509796,
0.48280438780784607,
0.5288766622543335,
-0.5314385294914246,
-0.14786776900291443,
-0.64055997133255,
-0.8023724555969238,
0.3734806478023529,
-0.07670655846595764,
0.002825565170496702,
-0.0921744704246521,
0.47922417521476746,
0.16946785151958466,
0.09359671920537949,
-0.4625498056411743,
-0.16505740582942963,
-0.036031465977430344,
-0.3304358124732971,
-0.0678543671965599,
-0.272241473197937,
0.009568830020725727,
-0.0550563707947731,
0.34946227073669434,
-0.29393792152404785,
0.2394849956035614,
0.33799126744270325,
0.22393839061260223,
-0.5023532509803772,
0.5752655863761902,
0.339591920375824,
0.638377845287323,
-0.3079940378665924,
-0.1166544109582901,
0.3630289137363434,
-0.3610405921936035,
0.11049079895019531,
0.05784321576356888,
-0.25259992480278015,
0.019378114491701126,
0.4290216565132141,
0.9572241902351379,
0.5166074633598328,
-0.6255312561988831,
0.5882606506347656,
0.0840105339884758,
-0.30105528235435486,
-0.37030521035194397,
-0.20746298134326935,
-0.11066330969333649,
0.0583353228867054,
0.24359512329101562,
-0.5196262001991272,
0.16551260650157928,
-0.474377304315567,
0.4568074345588684,
0.1731300950050354,
-0.41320815682411194,
-0.6776716113090515,
0.8595242500305176,
-0.08784408122301102,
-0.02961909770965576,
0.5409112572669983,
0.06784669309854507,
-0.15309330821037292,
0.36112046241760254,
0.8003721237182617,
0.6917809844017029,
-0.497996062040329,
0.20261438190937042,
0.5317844152450562,
-0.10554806143045425,
-0.2856752574443817,
0.22130781412124634,
0.42640164494514465,
-0.6603307723999023,
-0.5935841202735901,
-0.4166736602783203,
-0.5839794874191284,
0.5044713020324707,
-0.8722909688949585,
0.5089375972747803,
-0.5795918107032776,
-0.20237137377262115,
0.01753804087638855,
-0.32297468185424805,
-0.8476877808570862,
0.1337757110595703,
0.46179014444351196,
0.6727182865142822,
-0.8394080400466919,
0.8657256960868835,
0.40442606806755066,
-0.20351852476596832,
-0.987874448299408,
0.21410787105560303,
0.5334476232528687,
-0.8886737823486328,
0.313836932182312,
0.17744795978069305,
0.26224285364151,
0.042222075164318085,
-0.24086441099643707,
-0.6341840624809265,
1.1860228776931763,
0.26295939087867737,
-0.856788694858551,
-0.21785759925842285,
-0.09612561017274857,
0.6888548135757446,
-0.33041733503341675,
0.25455978512763977,
0.48747968673706055,
0.43448781967163086,
0.24134698510169983,
-1.051522970199585,
0.1274249404668808,
0.019562410190701485,
-0.20992331206798553,
0.29692190885543823,
-0.1659441888332367,
0.7470002174377441,
-0.52344810962677,
-0.08974974602460861,
0.06893178820610046,
0.37561213970184326,
0.5178598165512085,
0.7722564935684204,
0.13652947545051575,
0.4581727087497711,
0.7856304049491882,
0.1716753989458084,
1.258683443069458,
-0.2339005023241043,
0.22924138605594635,
1.1102160215377808,
-0.7877426743507385,
1.0289011001586914,
0.19360484182834625,
-0.13207802176475525,
0.7530214786529541,
0.46706998348236084,
-0.015893714502453804,
0.2502877712249756,
-0.19579657912254333,
-0.5154728889465332,
0.014714215882122517,
-0.2162947803735733,
-0.3690696358680725,
0.1533091813325882,
0.6186495423316956,
-0.22759202122688293,
-0.235286682844162,
-0.015704894438385963,
0.158936008810997,
-0.20311185717582703,
-0.43899044394493103,
0.9046921133995056,
0.18199117481708527,
-0.5392501354217529,
0.4567732810974121,
-0.39556923508644104,
0.3506186902523041,
-0.7101660966873169,
-0.17596665024757385,
0.05459610000252724,
-0.037481486797332764,
-0.2499118596315384,
-0.7625463008880615,
0.10585562139749527,
0.04634232819080353,
-0.24784564971923828,
-0.23037466406822205,
0.6747177839279175,
-0.39537179470062256,
-0.4187915325164795,
0.36956480145454407,
0.9005739092826843,
-0.01552667561918497,
-0.0001822554477257654,
-0.6814255714416504,
0.06497043371200562,
-0.10405449569225311,
-0.22978022694587708,
0.570917010307312,
0.6130820512771606,
-0.13503706455230713,
0.5106260180473328,
0.779288649559021,
0.5548728108406067,
-0.25681161880493164,
0.15785294771194458,
0.6954989433288574,
-0.7894721627235413,
-0.4381366968154907,
-1.004710078239441,
0.3846616744995117,
0.36985406279563904,
-0.06657815724611282,
0.5813747644424438,
0.25016695261001587,
0.4715842008590698,
-0.03425922617316246,
0.9112039804458618,
0.3156217932701111,
0.7146591544151306,
-0.5307400822639465,
0.4975082576274872,
-0.3609023988246918,
0.17285355925559998,
-0.0038245776668190956,
-0.29420486092567444,
-0.675341784954071,
0.05652609467506409,
-0.5901305675506592,
0.09728007018566132,
0.6492620706558228,
0.5746736526489258,
0.23734214901924133,
-0.12781070172786713,
0.6763491630554199,
0.5247951745986938,
0.35761356353759766,
0.7067275643348694,
0.5051130652427673,
-0.016396161168813705,
0.26384595036506653,
0.08490502089262009,
-0.26940348744392395,
-0.4504663646221161,
-1.1113030910491943,
-0.6669047474861145,
-0.207624614238739,
-0.12725384533405304,
-0.26684391498565674,
0.2801608741283417,
1.0464199781417847,
0.5024248361587524,
-0.8393791913986206,
0.11228400468826294,
-0.06925609707832336,
-0.2541152238845825,
0.10335943847894669,
-0.1138727143406868,
0.3896753191947937,
-0.13896198570728302,
-0.30009764432907104,
0.5470513701438904,
0.635090172290802,
0.22941291332244873,
0.10050100833177567,
-0.11421820521354675,
0.29030197858810425,
-0.19152145087718964,
0.5536981225013733,
0.6494248509407043,
-0.7452765703201294,
-0.07850881665945053,
0.17030103504657745,
0.05592226982116699,
0.2365243285894394,
0.9081094861030579,
-0.9295399188995361,
0.611407458782196,
0.16135375201702118,
0.659353494644165,
0.3904838562011719,
0.016833772882819176,
0.5460467338562012,
-0.42273759841918945,
-0.22084450721740723,
0.5356536507606506,
0.3962307572364807,
0.3562626242637634,
-0.6252833008766174,
0.10077835619449615,
-0.015122493728995323,
-0.8480926752090454,
-0.5966542959213257,
0.0937705785036087,
-0.7994956970214844,
-0.043277449905872345,
1.0486199855804443,
-0.05760813504457474,
-0.23365558683872223,
-0.48683905601501465,
0.06580611318349838,
-0.045798324048519135,
-0.5999051332473755,
0.7015034556388855,
0.2147950828075409,
-0.5691238045692444,
-0.2296539694070816,
-1.0878474712371826,
0.4494982063770294,
0.3093753755092621,
-0.9025720357894897,
-0.009146398864686489,
0.6874455809593201,
0.4297119379043579,
-0.41462716460227966,
0.9612560272216797,
-0.16893205046653748,
0.41002824902534485,
-0.3201673924922943,
-0.16869571805000305,
-0.0007177050574682653,
-0.35936662554740906,
-0.8367365598678589,
0.04095150902867317,
0.18876846134662628,
0.1234818696975708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14493v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14493v1 | K-QA: A Real-World Medical Q&A Benchmark | 2024-01-25T20:11:04 | 2024-01-25T20:11:04 | Itay Manes, Naama Ronn, David Cohen, Ran Ilan Ber, Zehavi Horowitz-Kugler, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Ensuring the accuracy of responses provided by large language models (LLMs)
is crucial, particularly in clinical settings where incorrect information may
directly impact patient health. To address this challenge, we construct K-QA, a
dataset containing 1,212 patient questions originating from real-world
conversations held on K Health (an AI-driven clinical platform). We employ a
panel of in-house physicians to answer and manually decompose a subset of K-QA
into self-contained statements. Additionally, we formulate two NLI-based
evaluation metrics approximating recall and precision: (1) comprehensiveness,
measuring the percentage of essential clinical information in the generated
answer and (2) hallucination rate, measuring the number of statements from the
physician-curated response contradicted by the LLM answer. Finally, we use K-QA
along with these metrics to evaluate several state-of-the-art models, as well
as the effect of in-context learning and medically-oriented augmented retrieval
schemes developed by the authors. Our findings indicate that in-context
learning improves the comprehensiveness of the models, and augmented retrieval
is effective in reducing hallucinations. We make K-QA available to to the
community to spur research into medically accurate NLP applications. | [
-0.2138376384973526,
-0.8127204775810242,
0.9983767867088318,
0.08130964636802673,
-0.06613330543041229,
0.1043086051940918,
0.02128598652780056,
-0.6686464548110962,
0.4360731244087219,
0.4664763808250427,
-0.36012354493141174,
-0.45962321758270264,
-0.4555964469909668,
0.16676931083202362,
-0.24678494036197662,
0.6221185326576233,
0.15043547749519348,
0.4801543951034546,
-0.3900599479675293,
-0.3575146794319153,
-0.6041135191917419,
-0.7788339257240295,
-0.45291244983673096,
-0.22311235964298248,
0.6082589626312256,
0.19108496606349945,
0.805719792842865,
0.474355012178421,
0.6921367645263672,
0.11545420438051224,
-0.09164026379585266,
0.05793323367834091,
-0.3739834725856781,
0.24854622781276703,
0.03389265015721321,
-0.5947011709213257,
-0.5086838006973267,
-0.07812441140413284,
0.3990483582019806,
0.9860511422157288,
-0.3301869034767151,
0.28542616963386536,
-0.3253198564052582,
0.6838399767875671,
-0.7697283625602722,
-0.12955567240715027,
-0.3671867847442627,
0.21642948687076569,
0.5034154057502747,
-0.18628360331058502,
-0.3231705129146576,
-0.7949425578117371,
0.3914784789085388,
-0.6335579752922058,
-0.08712513744831085,
-0.15235114097595215,
0.8932747840881348,
0.4724506735801697,
-0.47710421681404114,
-0.5625619888305664,
-0.6448351740837097,
0.439292311668396,
-0.7461551427841187,
0.7696046829223633,
0.6245231628417969,
0.5121318697929382,
-0.0943838432431221,
-0.6771223545074463,
-0.6019676923751831,
-0.3870883584022522,
-0.1763233244419098,
0.19681966304779053,
0.02900933101773262,
-0.04545405134558678,
0.3170074224472046,
0.2754291296005249,
-0.5691910982131958,
-0.05779639631509781,
-0.2851961553096771,
-0.2569252550601959,
0.5259170532226562,
0.372344970703125,
0.355778306722641,
-0.13256718218326569,
0.021975597366690636,
-0.2460675835609436,
-0.6999989748001099,
-0.1190207302570343,
-0.21453264355659485,
-0.17662575840950012,
0.1688346564769745,
0.5443926453590393,
-0.29656198620796204,
0.2831037938594818,
0.08064933121204376,
-0.38008764386177063,
0.3580109477043152,
-0.3540138006210327,
-0.009382753632962704,
0.0370100773870945,
0.7028772234916687,
0.7570763230323792,
0.1119656041264534,
-0.5956624746322632,
0.06482238322496414,
0.13535360991954803,
0.7612427473068237,
-0.7342545390129089,
-0.4150531589984894,
0.644085705280304,
-0.6484378576278687,
-0.1159151941537857,
-0.2393070012331009,
-0.8667590022087097,
-0.5504686832427979,
-0.3565840423107147,
0.548122227191925,
-0.3822172284126282,
-0.13872526586055756,
0.08310987800359726,
0.050936222076416016,
0.29556235671043396,
0.10885033756494522,
-0.3528427183628082,
0.3867107629776001,
0.5237859487533569,
0.42439356446266174,
-0.09252697974443436,
-0.03000595048069954,
-0.5696938633918762,
-0.2541227340698242,
-0.6169491410255432,
0.7424142956733704,
-0.4339812397956848,
-0.5320039987564087,
0.1748328059911728,
0.08157656341791153,
0.04559320583939552,
-1.0523436069488525,
0.43153542280197144,
-0.4439280927181244,
0.2291502207517624,
-0.6623971462249756,
-0.824650764465332,
-0.06184355169534683,
0.5324180722236633,
-0.38608866930007935,
0.8100714087486267,
0.2246486246585846,
-0.3295571208000183,
0.5650999546051025,
-0.2046934962272644,
-0.06998281180858612,
0.2593716084957123,
-0.32907748222351074,
-0.44294971227645874,
0.23936115205287933,
0.32578617334365845,
0.313713937997818,
-0.16939371824264526,
0.457811564207077,
-0.25535067915916443,
-0.3387371301651001,
0.39480626583099365,
-0.15094031393527985,
0.39690011739730835,
0.12638506293296814,
0.007638528011739254,
-0.11692993342876434,
-1.024139165878296,
0.30270490050315857,
-0.06141756847500801,
-0.3029033839702606,
-0.2516145706176758,
-0.1827174425125122,
-0.10893213748931885,
0.38513490557670593,
0.12155821174383163,
-0.6077247262001038,
-0.030490800738334656,
-0.46438074111938477,
0.14003494381904602,
0.2722439765930176,
0.4574529230594635,
0.0921279713511467,
-0.5458577871322632,
0.6056972742080688,
-0.1223103404045105,
0.39977771043777466,
-0.10769538581371307,
-0.4620983600616455,
-0.47255030274391174,
-0.1485118269920349,
0.2696666419506073,
0.6465258598327637,
-0.576325535774231,
0.47884973883628845,
-0.30588603019714355,
-0.7611876726150513,
-0.9260873198509216,
-0.2451438158750534,
0.5930801033973694,
0.934489905834198,
0.5060329437255859,
-0.25634899735450745,
-0.3842068612575531,
-0.8564483523368835,
-0.32185107469558716,
-0.3243538439273834,
-0.22274743020534515,
0.6362738013267517,
0.40069809556007385,
-0.332580029964447,
0.670644998550415,
-0.5096573829650879,
-0.2230522334575653,
0.0848916620016098,
-0.16341660916805267,
0.02900717407464981,
0.22880330681800842,
0.27189674973487854,
-0.5775979161262512,
-0.4526674449443817,
-0.1937708556652069,
-1.0460186004638672,
-0.21227219700813293,
-0.016617046669125557,
-0.017119165509939194,
-0.1798402965068817,
0.39107269048690796,
-0.5562134385108948,
0.3360777497291565,
0.27110859751701355,
-0.34210750460624695,
0.6829243302345276,
-0.3902454376220703,
0.5042469501495361,
-1.1395080089569092,
0.36331966519355774,
-0.21757730841636658,
-0.05584464967250824,
-0.7117724418640137,
0.26712608337402344,
0.22116094827651978,
-0.10814007371664047,
-0.2946301996707916,
0.6522136926651001,
0.03014504723250866,
0.05570637807250023,
-0.14597465097904205,
0.20122963190078735,
0.06208645924925804,
0.32214125990867615,
-0.21514983475208282,
0.7108726501464844,
0.2860146760940552,
-0.6235316395759583,
0.24416449666023254,
0.42989620566368103,
-0.4252804219722748,
0.9432176351547241,
-0.7878503203392029,
0.2761937379837036,
-0.12842372059822083,
0.21921606361865997,
-0.6860613226890564,
-0.32156842947006226,
0.10171682387590408,
-0.5447384119033813,
-0.16563725471496582,
0.2235090285539627,
-0.5482879877090454,
-0.1744071990251541,
-0.016331233084201813,
0.6299623250961304,
0.628612756729126,
-0.5198555588722229,
0.4817129075527191,
0.5600102543830872,
-0.04247109591960907,
-0.43903666734695435,
-0.2846926748752594,
0.15958131849765778,
0.0038425519596785307,
-0.17551082372665405,
0.24031315743923187,
-0.26466912031173706,
-0.27569711208343506,
0.007033525966107845,
-0.12688885629177094,
-0.24974937736988068,
0.08529435098171234,
0.23940211534500122,
0.12220444530248642,
-0.18193581700325012,
0.4036337733268738,
-0.0666276216506958,
0.0023106972221285105,
0.4257623851299286,
0.16297194361686707,
0.5898059010505676,
0.024674924090504646,
-0.39844298362731934,
-0.8736570477485657,
0.35201528668403625,
0.6766453385353088,
0.07987822592258453,
0.48222121596336365,
0.10453949868679047,
-0.7487370371818542,
0.2576903700828552,
-0.7955276966094971,
-0.3998137414455414,
-0.3332846760749817,
0.44663354754447937,
-0.3281881511211395,
-0.8482567071914673,
0.7886778116226196,
-0.051102958619594574,
-0.15891478955745697,
0.38152652978897095,
0.5715178847312927,
-0.20434464514255524,
1.3334065675735474,
0.27200713753700256,
0.0018323950935155153,
-0.17992226779460907,
-0.042638298124074936,
0.45718544721603394,
-0.6692202687263489,
-0.5598462820053101,
-0.5517203211784363,
-0.14072845876216888,
-0.47363030910491943,
-0.23921789228916168,
0.8950585722923279,
0.09338743984699249,
0.0006192252039909363,
0.0478983111679554,
-0.5590149760246277,
0.40018707513809204,
0.30845099687576294,
0.37867191433906555,
0.24718330800533295,
-0.34686386585235596,
-0.07207371294498444,
-0.052204739302396774,
-0.6102320551872253,
-0.4775874614715576,
1.2737812995910645,
0.47762903571128845,
0.43611422181129456,
-0.07959657162427902,
0.5411671996116638,
0.24762889742851257,
0.2409524917602539,
-0.8701162934303284,
0.4367137551307678,
0.08810903877019882,
-0.49640658497810364,
-0.12124458700418472,
-0.47419410943984985,
-0.7814769744873047,
0.21623550355434418,
-0.3790109157562256,
-0.5403094291687012,
0.24201513826847076,
0.09464684873819351,
-0.8050622344017029,
0.02002527378499508,
-0.581095814704895,
0.7984946966171265,
-0.01266962755471468,
0.17133347690105438,
-0.20761649310588837,
-0.7225877642631531,
0.1480434238910675,
-0.12841446697711945,
0.038184504956007004,
-0.1791532188653946,
-0.12328416854143143,
0.4796845316886902,
-0.327810138463974,
0.5681139826774597,
-0.17818373441696167,
-0.11779831349849701,
0.01671752706170082,
0.11120951920747757,
0.2836707830429077,
0.34074506163597107,
0.10260190814733505,
0.048301469534635544,
0.663798987865448,
-0.5330083966255188,
-0.9146237373352051,
0.5318700671195984,
-0.7525277733802795,
-0.28878867626190186,
-0.3042655289173126,
-0.5487553477287292,
-0.5695006847381592,
-0.03430122882127762,
0.11348608881235123,
0.5654857158660889,
-0.3942454755306244,
0.1513337641954422,
0.7618008852005005,
-0.4653988182544708,
-0.19774284958839417,
0.5625331997871399,
-0.20284844934940338,
-0.5645984411239624,
0.7999144792556763,
0.17839987576007843,
0.21906781196594238,
0.3397662043571472,
0.15866121649742126,
-0.4021124839782715,
-0.48129820823669434,
-0.4236804246902466,
0.399326890707016,
-0.9803369641304016,
-0.06840451806783676,
-1.0065927505493164,
-0.3436968922615051,
-0.42394861578941345,
-0.06887029856443405,
-0.23315413296222687,
-0.1984819918870926,
-0.05674545466899872,
0.05028785392642021,
0.025867225602269173,
0.5957803130149841,
0.3493809700012207,
0.0727069154381752,
-0.9583629965782166,
0.5606393218040466,
0.42026159167289734,
0.491576611995697,
-0.05364822596311569,
-0.3751630187034607,
-0.09606485813856125,
0.01435726135969162,
-0.12026091665029526,
-0.8573813438415527,
0.4309201240539551,
0.2083011418581009,
0.5939053297042847,
0.1788317710161209,
0.09134213626384735,
0.6267988681793213,
-0.39640504121780396,
0.8923377394676208,
0.01400774996727705,
-0.4943390488624573,
0.47006624937057495,
0.10053276270627975,
0.5884771347045898,
0.8810887336730957,
0.5008203387260437,
-0.8754824995994568,
-0.5099794268608093,
-0.5782108902931213,
-0.6687479019165039,
0.10510970652103424,
-0.08237475901842117,
0.035046499222517014,
-0.42626243829727173,
0.8303862810134888,
0.17540127038955688,
0.026092229411005974,
-0.38369303941726685,
-0.13895149528980255,
0.06956797093153,
-0.3501029908657074,
0.026212548837065697,
-0.41053256392478943,
-0.25489914417266846,
-0.06754907965660095,
0.6243081092834473,
-0.25677892565727234,
0.1830054074525833,
0.6353021860122681,
-0.1881885677576065,
-0.041959669440984726,
0.24960792064666748,
0.4789738953113556,
1.1098159551620483,
-0.4094732403755188,
0.16414448618888855,
0.34146007895469666,
-0.7091943621635437,
0.16614311933517456,
-0.19431081414222717,
-0.1972087174654007,
0.028188075870275497,
0.25714540481567383,
0.3172264099121094,
-0.06773307919502258,
-1.3012456893920898,
0.49101918935775757,
-0.27752187848091125,
-0.18585947155952454,
-0.2865225374698639,
-0.18363025784492493,
-0.16760464012622833,
0.11466436088085175,
0.28861358761787415,
-0.18789809942245483,
0.29311397671699524,
-0.492035835981369,
0.44188404083251953,
0.24780593812465668,
-0.7375614643096924,
-0.2794032394886017,
0.6107190251350403,
-0.07493694126605988,
-0.48558300733566284,
0.7142431139945984,
0.0026335997972637415,
-0.33348923921585083,
0.6380437612533569,
0.32009074091911316,
0.7555540204048157,
-0.07808602601289749,
0.18126504123210907,
0.6200154423713684,
0.14159609377384186,
-0.08573147654533386,
0.5426138639450073,
0.2602500319480896,
-0.5574301481246948,
-0.4012925922870636,
-0.4000536799430847,
-0.6584866046905518,
0.3151102662086487,
-0.9214110970497131,
-0.09692942351102829,
-0.589880108833313,
-0.2859727740287781,
0.062452252954244614,
-0.05807337909936905,
-0.5294403433799744,
0.5237649083137512,
-0.13414907455444336,
0.8327174782752991,
-0.5924675464630127,
0.6435315012931824,
0.5664666295051575,
-0.3707210421562195,
-0.5728214383125305,
0.11532893776893616,
-0.3128907382488251,
-0.7859874963760376,
0.21490928530693054,
0.047834936529397964,
0.19716545939445496,
-0.32348883152008057,
-0.47376129031181335,
-0.7409519553184509,
0.9495177865028381,
0.2131636142730713,
-0.48322129249572754,
0.042786069214344025,
0.272120863199234,
1.022032618522644,
-0.37940773367881775,
0.12409508228302002,
0.6892967224121094,
-0.003935521934181452,
-0.20563620328903198,
-1.093670129776001,
0.15802401304244995,
-0.33423277735710144,
-0.14854013919830322,
0.18673577904701233,
-0.36113929748535156,
0.2114616185426712,
-0.20740841329097748,
-0.03877292573451996,
0.2068347930908203,
0.286681205034256,
0.5222098231315613,
0.5988709926605225,
0.42866092920303345,
0.8025774359703064,
0.9064209461212158,
0.002678404562175274,
1.111232876777649,
-0.6042463183403015,
0.07594554126262665,
1.019435167312622,
-0.23971951007843018,
0.9410901069641113,
0.5879631042480469,
-0.16630819439888,
0.1731191724538803,
0.4219481348991394,
0.09851471334695816,
0.5190472602844238,
0.22755365073680878,
-0.2208099514245987,
-0.2647070288658142,
-0.4601571261882782,
-0.5502118468284607,
0.16875436902046204,
0.29739221930503845,
-0.33027034997940063,
0.0795036256313324,
0.11896070837974548,
-0.006132751703262329,
0.2846316397190094,
-0.022630836814641953,
1.034862756729126,
0.1737130731344223,
-0.834173858165741,
0.7708910703659058,
-0.35223388671875,
0.23569439351558685,
-0.34631872177124023,
-0.1614741086959839,
-0.39469122886657715,
0.06722138822078705,
0.005526193883270025,
-0.46456339955329895,
0.3509026765823364,
-0.15099957585334778,
-0.2990565598011017,
0.17413179576396942,
0.3486438989639282,
-0.43086525797843933,
-0.473190039396286,
0.17947785556316376,
0.6585177779197693,
0.43971121311187744,
-0.12078380584716797,
-0.6610238552093506,
-0.1799253523349762,
-0.37616509199142456,
0.09528054296970367,
0.48967111110687256,
0.24877938628196716,
0.05114120990037918,
0.9427889585494995,
0.4462478756904602,
0.1965947449207306,
-0.008620432578027248,
0.2714947462081909,
0.7325558662414551,
-0.6645748019218445,
-0.2479623556137085,
-0.37260347604751587,
0.11712143570184708,
-0.13494762778282166,
-0.5721833109855652,
0.42169317603111267,
0.5664482116699219,
0.7455798983573914,
0.05221566557884216,
0.5148108601570129,
0.20852519571781158,
0.8656048774719238,
-0.3285938799381256,
0.9205161333084106,
-0.6510561108589172,
0.16955435276031494,
0.020020652562379837,
-0.671829104423523,
-0.42896562814712524,
0.40507566928863525,
-0.07295389473438263,
-0.11473152041435242,
0.7199847102165222,
0.8147636651992798,
0.3490922749042511,
-0.029045002534985542,
0.5613800287246704,
0.29668480157852173,
0.40759310126304626,
0.5768613815307617,
0.7153151631355286,
-0.8009940981864929,
0.3154473602771759,
-0.5360910296440125,
0.01251419447362423,
-0.11152023077011108,
-0.5637012124061584,
-0.6272268891334534,
-0.4159577190876007,
-0.5004498362541199,
-0.5719544291496277,
0.2633891999721527,
1.1200838088989258,
0.6266247630119324,
-0.9771867394447327,
-0.08055378496646881,
0.21617360413074493,
-0.1319030225276947,
-0.46964457631111145,
-0.16775210201740265,
0.6505354642868042,
-0.40276825428009033,
-0.31121546030044556,
0.47531506419181824,
0.3774974048137665,
-0.13660220801830292,
-0.24930167198181152,
-0.1024741679430008,
0.009687935002148151,
0.06137998402118683,
0.5120699405670166,
0.15116934478282928,
-0.8248535990715027,
-0.29454267024993896,
0.43738749623298645,
-0.3825981914997101,
0.17914257943630219,
0.535389244556427,
-0.9176679253578186,
0.7362292408943176,
0.36989685893058777,
0.9617107510566711,
-0.02327197603881359,
0.014991275034844875,
0.5549508333206177,
-0.33913397789001465,
-0.45629921555519104,
0.6372577548027039,
0.047064777463674545,
0.1427416205406189,
-0.458580881357193,
0.4375360310077667,
0.2159973531961441,
-0.7051712274551392,
-1.096175193786621,
-0.11133387684822083,
-0.8004938960075378,
-0.2168569564819336,
0.8462069034576416,
-0.13037699460983276,
-0.06489237397909164,
-0.4305194914340973,
-0.23916998505592346,
-0.03131468966603279,
-0.03983888775110245,
1.410927653312683,
0.6120938062667847,
-0.11973678320646286,
-0.11318965256214142,
-0.7630371451377869,
0.7220172882080078,
0.6885926127433777,
-0.9701939225196838,
-0.15845243632793427,
0.4374438226222992,
0.22820882499217987,
0.14088672399520874,
0.7888256907463074,
-0.2929721772670746,
0.673749566078186,
-0.11182360351085663,
0.10014966875314713,
0.4135686457157135,
-0.26047390699386597,
-0.36798444390296936,
0.4688151776790619,
-0.057064708322286606,
-0.0012659667991101742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14490v1 | LongHealth: A Question Answering Benchmark with Long Clinical Documents | 2024-01-25T19:57:00 | 2024-01-25T19:57:00 | Lisa Adams, Felix Busch, Tianyu Han, Jean-Baptiste Excoffier, Matthieu Ortala, Alexander Löser, Hugo JWL. Aerts, Jakob Nikolas Kather, Daniel Truhn, Keno Bressem | cs.CL | cs.CL | Background: Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) offer
potential benefits in healthcare, particularly in processing extensive patient
records. However, existing benchmarks do not fully assess LLMs' capability in
handling real-world, lengthy clinical data.
Methods: We present the LongHealth benchmark, comprising 20 detailed
fictional patient cases across various diseases, with each case containing
5,090 to 6,754 words. The benchmark challenges LLMs with 400 multiple-choice
questions in three categories: information extraction, negation, and sorting,
challenging LLMs to extract and interpret information from large clinical
documents.
Results: We evaluated nine open-source LLMs with a minimum of 16,000 tokens
and also included OpenAI's proprietary and cost-efficient GPT-3.5 Turbo for
comparison. The highest accuracy was observed for Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1,
particularly in tasks focused on information retrieval from single and multiple
patient documents. However, all models struggled significantly in tasks
requiring the identification of missing information, highlighting a critical
area for improvement in clinical data interpretation.
Conclusion: While LLMs show considerable potential for processing long
clinical documents, their current accuracy levels are insufficient for reliable
clinical use, especially in scenarios requiring the identification of missing
information. The LongHealth benchmark provides a more realistic assessment of
LLMs in a healthcare setting and highlights the need for further model
refinement for safe and effective clinical application.
We make the benchmark and evaluation code publicly available. | [
-0.052093856036663055,
-0.7739924192428589,
0.9952641725540161,
0.1547800600528717,
-0.32164543867111206,
-0.11324013024568558,
-0.2928740680217743,
-0.9572051763534546,
-0.00316562014631927,
0.7437859177589417,
-0.44967779517173767,
-0.6668320298194885,
-0.5248689651489258,
0.2363366037607193,
-0.16989457607269287,
0.9301281571388245,
-0.23098400235176086,
0.06354532390832901,
-0.4683941900730133,
-0.32263949513435364,
-0.15080229938030243,
-0.4786616563796997,
-0.44399216771125793,
-0.2648546099662781,
0.772659420967102,
0.2415006160736084,
0.6957329511642456,
0.5986533164978027,
0.8582083582878113,
0.12987138330936432,
-0.14826011657714844,
0.06599714607000351,
-0.6112383008003235,
0.40484917163848877,
0.06456834077835083,
-0.1736517697572708,
-0.6318310499191284,
-0.1914023458957672,
0.4667344093322754,
0.6683176755905151,
-0.23929940164089203,
0.36601126194000244,
-0.1923445463180542,
0.7621062397956848,
-0.5553033947944641,
-0.021986879408359528,
-0.1330597996711731,
-0.05138111859560013,
-0.5106525421142578,
-0.08836255967617035,
-0.2868519127368927,
-0.6242040991783142,
0.3122641444206238,
-0.5798938870429993,
-0.0824582576751709,
0.08196388185024261,
0.6591163277626038,
0.27708765864372253,
-0.5384006500244141,
-0.47651347517967224,
-0.3956453204154968,
0.5094952583312988,
-0.9146710634231567,
0.5706380605697632,
0.5550015568733215,
0.5481144785881042,
-0.1385054886341095,
-1.0043861865997314,
-0.4314095675945282,
-0.24889639019966125,
-0.006071527488529682,
0.31417086720466614,
-0.3400362730026245,
0.2828754782676697,
0.5654993653297424,
0.2714971899986267,
-0.9278604984283447,
0.3833352327346802,
-0.5787663459777832,
-0.140716552734375,
0.564712405204773,
0.44871118664741516,
0.0625932514667511,
-0.4268035888671875,
-0.519069492816925,
0.14850357174873352,
-0.7160724997520447,
-0.048891715705394745,
-0.07653691619634628,
0.012871219776570797,
-0.24871386587619781,
0.5558111667633057,
-0.3464182913303375,
0.43265587091445923,
-0.510103702545166,
-0.40203601121902466,
0.5833606123924255,
-0.1521078497171402,
-0.35998809337615967,
0.06647666543722153,
0.7947583198547363,
0.5684654712677002,
0.011647218838334084,
-0.36448174715042114,
0.03344511613249779,
-0.38897377252578735,
0.18101458251476288,
-1.0269265174865723,
0.21078738570213318,
0.7154073119163513,
-0.6993390917778015,
0.11382931470870972,
-0.30429893732070923,
-1.0437127351760864,
-0.6611685156822205,
-0.13623157143592834,
0.12299847602844238,
-0.4038335382938385,
-0.06067865341901779,
0.43335410952568054,
-0.016679739579558372,
0.3176821172237396,
0.3334266245365143,
-0.3088288903236389,
0.49016624689102173,
0.742695689201355,
0.7409023642539978,
-0.5105942487716675,
-0.17714323103427887,
-0.6860929131507874,
0.24556772410869598,
-0.244985431432724,
0.6092631816864014,
-0.3043500483036041,
-0.502322256565094,
0.14368867874145508,
0.1770794689655304,
-0.044526293873786926,
-0.7062729597091675,
0.7644243836402893,
-0.3045880198478699,
0.21878977119922638,
-0.3430262804031372,
-0.7791864275932312,
0.15612547099590302,
0.26762282848358154,
-0.7813412547111511,
0.8925192356109619,
0.2889322340488434,
-0.6223964095115662,
0.13938331604003906,
-0.5135454535484314,
-0.38926994800567627,
0.46643421053886414,
-0.24301473796367645,
-0.5120224356651306,
0.05102628841996193,
0.1398988664150238,
0.48910120129585266,
-0.8564613461494446,
0.3478701710700989,
-0.47939637303352356,
-0.3945491909980774,
0.12905210256576538,
-0.3282685875892639,
0.49444258213043213,
0.22606462240219116,
-0.16423489153385162,
0.06809120625257492,
-0.872786283493042,
0.0998663529753685,
0.21767441928386688,
-0.25647711753845215,
-0.21663708984851837,
-0.180097296833992,
0.10497453808784485,
0.3255445957183838,
0.23375387489795685,
-0.7905734777450562,
0.15665693581104279,
-0.11844804883003235,
0.29745808243751526,
0.49568045139312744,
-0.0013865007786080241,
-0.3271561563014984,
-0.4946437478065491,
0.7603422403335571,
-0.11770255863666534,
0.29606500267982483,
-0.0048223878256976604,
-0.45354223251342773,
-0.282710462808609,
-0.44370758533477783,
0.07996693253517151,
0.42875269055366516,
-0.47776755690574646,
0.1497991979122162,
-0.6803901791572571,
-0.3832147717475891,
-0.7325765490531921,
-0.009333711117506027,
0.41934099793434143,
0.8964328169822693,
0.6962971091270447,
0.06579318642616272,
-0.21856628358364105,
-1.0407676696777344,
-0.16328305006027222,
-0.0035325249191373587,
-0.19053390622138977,
0.6284265518188477,
0.5683326125144958,
-0.38563793897628784,
0.5865260362625122,
-0.6295212507247925,
-0.15156665444374084,
-0.1561119109392166,
0.0489521324634552,
0.2838492691516876,
-0.008783676661550999,
0.23770500719547272,
-0.5580748319625854,
-0.2768135666847229,
-0.20802651345729828,
-0.8114315271377563,
-0.046335212886333466,
0.21347880363464355,
0.0808229148387909,
0.052315715700387955,
0.54253089427948,
-0.7098168134689331,
0.49646568298339844,
0.5879899263381958,
-0.04894939810037613,
0.5519117116928101,
-0.4385366439819336,
0.04977871850132942,
-1.0467472076416016,
0.5146339535713196,
-0.04777706786990166,
-0.33872276544570923,
-0.5237820148468018,
0.20387938618659973,
0.3931514024734497,
-0.3390958607196808,
-0.5839852094650269,
0.7503251433372498,
-0.3637024462223053,
0.16897352039813995,
-0.11574534326791763,
-0.01732601411640644,
-0.0022531396243721247,
0.2178303450345993,
-0.01734183356165886,
0.8193848729133606,
0.24786190688610077,
-0.1837913542985916,
0.3793535828590393,
0.13885511457920074,
-0.6253089308738708,
0.47698312997817993,
-1.0484790802001953,
0.29815104603767395,
-0.27137428522109985,
0.4830244779586792,
-0.7943774461746216,
-0.35609424114227295,
-0.16470493376255035,
-0.01968003623187542,
0.05443493276834488,
-0.11413928866386414,
-0.7013154029846191,
-0.74196457862854,
-0.22778716683387756,
0.4998578131198883,
0.6109650135040283,
-0.17982257902622223,
0.29138287901878357,
0.23941561579704285,
-0.4007086455821991,
-0.3456881642341614,
-0.58707594871521,
0.0497773103415966,
-0.22055171430110931,
-0.46507659554481506,
0.3010697364807129,
-0.20660237967967987,
-0.17006807029247284,
-0.2144804447889328,
-0.019208278506994247,
-0.12569649517536163,
-0.12246585637331009,
0.4366639256477356,
0.18143512308597565,
-0.24074995517730713,
0.4980925917625427,
-0.10785192996263504,
-0.010035975836217403,
0.20282785594463348,
0.17594210803508759,
0.4689579904079437,
-0.08065292239189148,
-0.5842794179916382,
-0.2858380675315857,
0.6690793037414551,
0.9166244864463806,
-0.3166443109512329,
0.5725821852684021,
0.2830682396888733,
-0.6573746800422668,
0.14464826881885529,
-0.7983831167221069,
0.26065492630004883,
-0.383854478597641,
0.5568850040435791,
-0.2164725661277771,
-0.8530174493789673,
0.5041699409484863,
-0.022920766845345497,
0.051378753036260605,
0.5158891677856445,
0.5113576054573059,
-0.05126043036580086,
0.7019041180610657,
0.2229187935590744,
-0.2527424991130829,
-0.27673739194869995,
0.19554945826530457,
-0.01655811443924904,
-0.7243459820747375,
-0.31721973419189453,
-0.5172402858734131,
-0.06041210889816284,
-0.7338677048683167,
-0.5945830941200256,
0.6987663507461548,
-0.1787530481815338,
-0.22655180096626282,
-0.011702262796461582,
-0.27089735865592957,
0.17406947910785675,
0.26215660572052,
0.6494390964508057,
0.34261468052864075,
-0.3731071650981903,
0.07082512229681015,
-0.014643444679677486,
-0.2747475504875183,
-0.2676336467266083,
1.290209174156189,
0.6858428120613098,
0.7201309204101562,
0.20567983388900757,
0.7769721150398254,
0.12415765225887299,
0.3017171323299408,
-0.6826337575912476,
0.38154512643814087,
-0.2441248893737793,
-0.6631505489349365,
-0.37991055846214294,
-0.3938816487789154,
-1.1244304180145264,
-0.12175948172807693,
-0.05305889621376991,
-0.6429812908172607,
-0.025553038343787193,
-0.2195475846529007,
-0.5288605690002441,
0.1493932008743286,
-0.32762467861175537,
0.8000559210777283,
-0.483037531375885,
-0.4819300174713135,
-0.15197297930717468,
-0.7947830557823181,
0.14880242943763733,
-0.25329533219337463,
0.1659649908542633,
-0.287044882774353,
-0.2346455454826355,
0.8219297528266907,
-0.3938461244106293,
0.4570017158985138,
0.00754215382039547,
-0.11951392143964767,
-0.10518817603588104,
-0.31743323802948,
0.4538809359073639,
0.10260708630084991,
-0.4902249872684479,
0.24542438983917236,
0.3170151710510254,
-0.5626590251922607,
-0.4281518757343292,
0.6583494544029236,
-0.6264861226081848,
-0.5109395980834961,
-0.594609260559082,
-0.45059213042259216,
-0.5801677703857422,
0.48842382431030273,
0.10246222466230392,
0.7211411595344543,
-0.23145315051078796,
0.41300874948501587,
0.6584237217903137,
-0.48621445894241333,
0.05908218398690224,
0.6448764204978943,
-0.05430116504430771,
-0.37863466143608093,
0.5186432003974915,
-0.13987571001052856,
0.27430662512779236,
0.3707685172557831,
0.40544986724853516,
-0.32588380575180054,
-0.83617103099823,
-0.4060424268245697,
0.4907801151275635,
-0.6388141512870789,
-0.13833940029144287,
-0.7440944910049438,
-0.3197602927684784,
-0.39744001626968384,
0.20509834587574005,
-0.22544364631175995,
0.1109711229801178,
-0.15908494591712952,
0.05239466577768326,
0.33985844254493713,
0.7464966177940369,
0.5479665994644165,
-0.11662834882736206,
-0.8938724994659424,
0.6289404034614563,
0.22958149015903473,
0.7509100437164307,
-0.19996097683906555,
-0.3077544569969177,
-0.16248778998851776,
-0.02448715828359127,
0.02207728661596775,
-0.8468371629714966,
0.2119658887386322,
-0.01557537168264389,
0.6104807257652283,
0.22764913737773895,
0.16332601010799408,
0.9299807548522949,
-0.598280668258667,
0.7293203473091125,
0.3045748174190521,
-0.48994210362434387,
0.2606176733970642,
-0.4446476399898529,
0.7094314098358154,
1.032188892364502,
0.7480363249778748,
-0.6462879180908203,
0.012785755097866058,
-0.36930790543556213,
-0.8075355291366577,
0.29980769753456116,
-0.07338230311870575,
-0.27635657787323,
-0.22467857599258423,
0.43125295639038086,
0.2469559907913208,
0.15323272347450256,
-0.36372479796409607,
-0.17756903171539307,
0.2061956375837326,
-0.3240666389465332,
-0.2668972313404083,
-0.45654046535491943,
-0.19661018252372742,
-0.1190812885761261,
0.300769567489624,
-0.19537442922592163,
0.29110535979270935,
0.43712902069091797,
-0.09995610266923904,
-0.0850043073296547,
0.5688900947570801,
0.6166884303092957,
0.8681083917617798,
-0.47587835788726807,
-0.16195596754550934,
0.1431298851966858,
-0.6447722911834717,
-0.29036036133766174,
0.5954747796058655,
0.20222808420658112,
0.025385035201907158,
0.45492351055145264,
0.6390119194984436,
0.26346495747566223,
-1.0888047218322754,
0.6682629585266113,
-0.15671393275260925,
-0.36127761006355286,
-0.3020189702510834,
-0.2640477418899536,
0.35235413908958435,
0.04590205103158951,
0.21133208274841309,
-0.5319753289222717,
0.2033529430627823,
-0.4162779450416565,
0.10510272532701492,
0.2566699981689453,
-0.6370574831962585,
0.03701123967766762,
0.5033290982246399,
0.025841813534498215,
0.006955146789550781,
0.9600332379341125,
0.31487801671028137,
-0.01094028353691101,
0.44180670380592346,
0.44521963596343994,
0.5523532032966614,
0.18286743760108948,
-0.10768430680036545,
0.19774320721626282,
-0.0565723218023777,
-0.1014682799577713,
0.4116867482662201,
0.25090575218200684,
-0.14664681255817413,
-0.39245593547821045,
-0.5494536757469177,
-0.6761674880981445,
0.6103742718696594,
-0.9157782793045044,
0.17283779382705688,
-0.24987857043743134,
-0.1636011004447937,
0.1696500927209854,
0.11432478576898575,
-0.8538209795951843,
0.3099115192890167,
0.34344610571861267,
1.1130610704421997,
-0.2990971505641937,
0.8342511057853699,
0.44172853231430054,
-0.24782538414001465,
-0.6792452931404114,
0.01339507196098566,
-0.11331146210432053,
-0.8713086843490601,
0.27675122022628784,
0.3246285319328308,
0.22348429262638092,
-0.32424595952033997,
-0.4043184220790863,
-0.7065922617912292,
1.1430836915969849,
0.3545447289943695,
-0.7111389636993408,
-0.4630430340766907,
0.48819592595100403,
0.8274101614952087,
0.0358237586915493,
0.3708091378211975,
0.4202280044555664,
0.3925548493862152,
-0.046923767775297165,
-1.3463753461837769,
0.2111896276473999,
-0.37717005610466003,
-0.5211383104324341,
0.3558596074581146,
-0.6866835951805115,
0.6875883936882019,
-0.11161364614963531,
-0.02570948377251625,
0.3442116975784302,
0.23649658262729645,
0.33036401867866516,
0.68876713514328,
0.2514492869377136,
0.5859904885292053,
0.9319645762443542,
0.08950317651033401,
1.264574408531189,
-0.3459058403968811,
0.16331428289413452,
1.120919108390808,
-0.7538592219352722,
0.8574047088623047,
0.3673118054866791,
-0.22929982841014862,
0.35040509700775146,
0.3619384765625,
0.2681407034397125,
0.20778873562812805,
0.38439249992370605,
-0.28037410974502563,
-0.24446062743663788,
-0.08788523077964783,
-0.7070054411888123,
0.34185442328453064,
0.2692544162273407,
-0.5573741793632507,
-0.19254493713378906,
0.03843001276254654,
0.14155295491218567,
-0.2449440062046051,
-0.06453486531972885,
0.7586188316345215,
0.1592177003622055,
-0.7545771598815918,
0.7349638342857361,
-0.23162901401519775,
0.35355451703071594,
-0.9867745637893677,
-0.032220352441072464,
-0.20428955554962158,
0.12118600308895111,
-0.19584745168685913,
-0.8186728358268738,
-0.09288007020950317,
0.09572860598564148,
-0.044031038880348206,
-0.17693816125392914,
0.5754313468933105,
-0.18893122673034668,
-0.43573006987571716,
0.31807950139045715,
0.5552170872688293,
0.3839130997657776,
-0.033629681915044785,
-0.6587542295455933,
-0.022614682093262672,
-0.2607557475566864,
-0.29512256383895874,
0.4366151690483093,
0.16783808171749115,
-0.2256297767162323,
0.7264168858528137,
0.637101411819458,
0.45299050211906433,
-0.3309357762336731,
0.22063958644866943,
0.8595432639122009,
-0.8777070641517639,
-0.36633455753326416,
-0.5895646214485168,
0.015787292271852493,
-0.2451123148202896,
-0.7458818554878235,
0.593562662601471,
0.8028428554534912,
0.4284689724445343,
0.2630319595336914,
0.652083694934845,
0.36659687757492065,
0.981217622756958,
-0.44404858350753784,
0.7401462197303772,
-0.7400696277618408,
-0.07535934448242188,
-0.2361600399017334,
-0.37805038690567017,
-0.222525954246521,
-0.13359345495700836,
-0.4749545156955719,
-0.18116331100463867,
0.8188737034797668,
0.44681835174560547,
0.013261186890304089,
0.23515141010284424,
0.3499450087547302,
0.14340776205062866,
0.45716536045074463,
0.7642620801925659,
0.43871158361434937,
-0.3312007188796997,
0.30052822828292847,
-0.29431700706481934,
-0.05895506590604782,
-0.16001294553279877,
-0.8489909172058105,
-0.6647883653640747,
-0.1267690807580948,
-0.06962480396032333,
-0.4477714002132416,
0.48606786131858826,
1.1065940856933594,
0.6568501591682434,
-0.6449547410011292,
-0.04272434487938881,
0.3942478597164154,
-0.3316645324230194,
-0.1343335658311844,
-0.0706590786576271,
0.697086751461029,
0.2334592640399933,
-0.30034664273262024,
0.5040097832679749,
0.3695274293422699,
-0.056098949164152145,
-0.08447036892175674,
-0.11280625313520432,
-0.004719064105302095,
-0.1461353302001953,
0.5382347702980042,
0.4396965205669403,
-0.5655326843261719,
0.013459347188472748,
0.30978742241859436,
-0.5044981241226196,
0.2481164187192917,
0.7405915856361389,
-0.5979889035224915,
0.6468099355697632,
0.3559468984603882,
0.8053293824195862,
0.6968281865119934,
0.08864150941371918,
0.19512702524662018,
-0.02348955348134041,
-0.09573350846767426,
0.5952591896057129,
0.38457825779914856,
0.16784492135047913,
-0.3676886260509491,
0.31054553389549255,
0.030101921409368515,
-0.6609793305397034,
-0.8189301490783691,
-0.12471446394920349,
-1.163849115371704,
-0.2660214304924011,
1.3849997520446777,
-0.2334461808204651,
-0.3157917559146881,
-0.3065604567527771,
0.05079251527786255,
0.04473945498466492,
-0.27953943610191345,
0.48578107357025146,
0.4334529638290405,
-0.234232097864151,
0.05314473435282707,
-0.9347166419029236,
0.34712734818458557,
0.38633400201797485,
-1.2211543321609497,
0.21181786060333252,
0.5632705092430115,
0.37010520696640015,
-0.24152696132659912,
0.9209308624267578,
-0.40048643946647644,
0.6406280994415283,
-0.4577655494213104,
-0.11913057416677475,
-0.12018925696611404,
0.017254244536161423,
-0.21933762729167938,
0.2671794593334198,
-0.10812965780496597,
0.2036459892988205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14400v1 | Modular Adaptation of Multilingual Encoders to Written Swiss German Dialect | 2024-01-25T18:59:32 | 2024-01-25T18:59:32 | Jannis Vamvas, Noëmi Aepli, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating neural text encoders for written Swiss German is challenging due to
a dearth of training data combined with dialectal variation. In this paper, we
build on several existing multilingual encoders and adapt them to Swiss German
using continued pre-training. Evaluation on three diverse downstream tasks
shows that simply adding a Swiss German adapter to a modular encoder achieves
97.5% of fully monolithic adaptation performance. We further find that for the
task of retrieving Swiss German sentences given Standard German queries,
adapting a character-level model is more effective than the other adaptation
strategies. We release our code and the models trained for our experiments at
https://github.com/ZurichNLP/swiss-german-text-encoders | [
-0.34591761231422424,
-0.6307546496391296,
0.45267319679260254,
0.2988935112953186,
-0.29376959800720215,
-0.19156205654144287,
-0.44212591648101807,
-0.3431454598903656,
0.2256244421005249,
0.5488753318786621,
-0.8721883296966553,
-0.43560048937797546,
-0.4456638991832733,
0.35640978813171387,
0.05052375793457031,
0.9850035309791565,
0.09161276370286942,
0.3086974322795868,
-0.04874907433986664,
-0.37355002760887146,
-0.33861178159713745,
-1.034469723701477,
-0.5459213852882385,
-0.3978900611400604,
0.4919305443763733,
0.39031580090522766,
0.32426708936691284,
0.002402331680059433,
0.2074422985315323,
0.36024653911590576,
0.04560432210564613,
-0.05740831047296524,
-0.4360496401786804,
0.042278192937374115,
-0.1878545880317688,
-0.39403578639030457,
-0.5135512351989746,
-0.7663596272468567,
0.7283453941345215,
0.6961997151374817,
-0.310369610786438,
-0.09440658986568451,
-0.09063533693552017,
0.9592549800872803,
-0.38640475273132324,
0.22587616741657257,
-0.548891007900238,
0.2692393362522125,
-0.2044796496629715,
0.2154499590396881,
-0.6663105487823486,
-0.24983321130275726,
0.1503850817680359,
-0.49866849184036255,
0.2127579003572464,
-0.23759649693965912,
0.4090645909309387,
-0.17201216518878937,
-0.4717259407043457,
-0.23179520666599274,
-0.6603776216506958,
0.38253986835479736,
-0.9658638834953308,
0.4184488356113434,
0.059742774814367294,
0.15518571436405182,
0.03455294296145439,
-0.6396365165710449,
-0.5153803825378418,
-0.052860457450151443,
-0.045884426683187485,
0.3456869125366211,
-0.3058687150478363,
-0.0178398285061121,
0.14050717651844025,
0.33339405059814453,
-0.4880233108997345,
0.1371455192565918,
-0.3602049648761749,
-0.12915277481079102,
0.44318249821662903,
-0.0477723628282547,
0.23054420948028564,
-0.17090551555156708,
-0.033908020704984665,
-0.07366403937339783,
-0.34469249844551086,
0.0917702242732048,
0.6713914275169373,
0.35812559723854065,
-0.04894013702869415,
0.3203788697719574,
-0.24534133076667786,
0.8891724348068237,
0.47386524081230164,
0.0109607158228755,
0.5928032398223877,
-0.5311457514762878,
0.12795047461986542,
0.22560304403305054,
0.4818374812602997,
-0.06071363762021065,
0.5150811076164246,
-0.25049328804016113,
-0.48466232419013977,
-0.5372312664985657,
0.5605562925338745,
-0.983122706413269,
-0.24613705277442932,
-0.11652681231498718,
-0.44247639179229736,
0.2625509202480316,
0.2941722273826599,
-0.5843756198883057,
0.009996086359024048,
-0.11720573157072067,
0.48126548528671265,
-0.5796486139297485,
-0.3218511939048767,
0.7760952711105347,
-0.22716842591762543,
0.29818832874298096,
0.22281795740127563,
-1.2068227529525757,
0.4524330496788025,
0.3406572937965393,
0.7766280174255371,
0.031046533957123756,
-0.5352935194969177,
-0.2752552926540375,
0.12382785975933075,
-0.20720523595809937,
0.8268776535987854,
-0.20041020214557648,
-0.3977913558483124,
0.29329216480255127,
0.41053706407546997,
-0.461422324180603,
-0.6007336974143982,
0.5673470497131348,
-0.6014765501022339,
0.24932633340358734,
-0.016801640391349792,
-0.338506281375885,
-0.36638349294662476,
0.06931254267692566,
-0.9408630728721619,
0.7626212239265442,
0.3614708483219147,
-0.6815266609191895,
0.021782102063298225,
-0.6996447443962097,
-1.1405632495880127,
-0.055374979972839355,
0.41195616126060486,
-0.1870225965976715,
0.6216278672218323,
0.3801455795764923,
0.33276572823524475,
0.07068856805562973,
0.06560450792312622,
-0.2945411801338196,
-0.13509047031402588,
0.35239943861961365,
-0.1478077620267868,
0.7548722624778748,
-0.16426080465316772,
-0.02878602407872677,
0.11730856448411942,
-0.7726516723632812,
0.09597378969192505,
-0.2078126221895218,
-0.5932422280311584,
-0.18623612821102142,
0.23731544613838196,
0.25970274209976196,
0.16101761162281036,
0.08465917408466339,
-0.506186306476593,
-0.053588926792144775,
-0.24298876523971558,
0.47908273339271545,
0.7774976491928101,
-0.2590969502925873,
0.5875346064567566,
-0.25199446082115173,
0.4939683973789215,
0.15200215578079224,
-0.03138105198740959,
-0.39185675978660583,
-0.04501697048544884,
-1.0657882690429688,
-0.21347087621688843,
0.5545855164527893,
0.8377059698104858,
-0.9445571303367615,
0.8778780102729797,
-0.5905781984329224,
-0.3642248213291168,
-0.49568262696266174,
0.11317069828510284,
0.23922426998615265,
0.4161771237850189,
0.1993705928325653,
-0.6425902247428894,
-0.309320330619812,
-1.0047019720077515,
-0.04483392462134361,
-0.2394900768995285,
-0.08234863728284836,
0.07705287635326385,
0.6572635769844055,
-0.17932993173599243,
0.5740529894828796,
-0.5435838103294373,
-0.04655148461461067,
-0.4015054404735565,
0.14621134102344513,
0.35567593574523926,
0.6328572034835815,
0.7648681402206421,
-0.5711974501609802,
-0.42688238620758057,
0.3315683901309967,
-0.7503047585487366,
0.11960532516241074,
-0.07605133205652237,
-0.11581827700138092,
0.2786397337913513,
0.43660855293273926,
-0.3210717439651489,
-0.26290619373321533,
0.6657875180244446,
-0.16018085181713104,
0.6509864926338196,
-0.5067260265350342,
0.12534035742282867,
-1.3569610118865967,
-0.0867704227566719,
-0.04188019409775734,
-0.466379851102829,
-1.0298480987548828,
0.18249614536762238,
0.18898503482341766,
-0.17166931927204132,
-0.3864721953868866,
0.2496730089187622,
-0.5440341830253601,
0.1599217653274536,
0.009440300986170769,
-0.20327860116958618,
-0.12197424471378326,
0.5477116107940674,
0.28352153301239014,
0.6587882041931152,
0.6077251434326172,
-0.4253387451171875,
0.251471608877182,
0.22207660973072052,
-0.6294394731521606,
0.6772353649139404,
-0.6240289211273193,
0.40995556116104126,
-0.2350151240825653,
0.2283814251422882,
-0.6155369281768799,
-0.3640443682670593,
0.05165357142686844,
-0.1155562549829483,
0.35901468992233276,
-0.2789596617221832,
-0.6448390483856201,
-0.29326993227005005,
-0.03967045247554779,
0.3512842357158661,
0.5462016463279724,
-0.5392741560935974,
0.9282203912734985,
0.19344376027584076,
-0.6937238574028015,
-0.07392110675573349,
-1.0529255867004395,
0.0781598687171936,
0.00680963322520256,
-0.9380937814712524,
0.23323436081409454,
-0.24720127880573273,
0.21047130227088928,
-0.0500757209956646,
-0.16439761221408844,
-0.4981082081794739,
-0.06332974880933762,
-0.21154385805130005,
-0.07189567387104034,
-0.7628859877586365,
0.11070942133665085,
0.23844534158706665,
-0.0862518846988678,
-0.10153081268072128,
-0.5840320587158203,
0.37985366582870483,
-0.28107166290283203,
-0.4120945632457733,
-0.2476811408996582,
0.7294921278953552,
0.4311203360557556,
-0.12047959119081497,
0.5242748260498047,
0.535788893699646,
-0.30787092447280884,
-0.3077484667301178,
-0.4565626084804535,
-0.20650383830070496,
-0.47300049662590027,
0.8283949494361877,
-0.7098064422607422,
-1.186719298362732,
0.6630442142486572,
-0.07639281451702118,
-0.4551931321620941,
0.2967129647731781,
0.363761842250824,
0.12036120891571045,
0.6989073753356934,
0.9715081453323364,
-0.05646110326051712,
0.5850048065185547,
0.34373676776885986,
0.2794405519962311,
-0.45953360199928284,
-0.04536878690123558,
-0.5085705518722534,
-0.10034862905740738,
-0.49805375933647156,
-0.32815322279930115,
0.20714443922042847,
0.2540391981601715,
0.13353215157985687,
0.39684921503067017,
-0.03740721568465233,
0.3445330262184143,
0.39318007230758667,
0.4335171580314636,
0.1625962257385254,
0.19450001418590546,
0.1839796006679535,
-0.22821399569511414,
-0.9884299635887146,
-0.17214873433113098,
0.6639257669448853,
-0.04313192889094353,
0.6348608732223511,
0.34705308079719543,
0.5688962936401367,
0.09722646325826645,
-0.06106160581111908,
-0.7415302991867065,
0.348245233297348,
-0.6177096962928772,
-0.5844168066978455,
-0.04327244684100151,
-0.26255810260772705,
-0.3474826216697693,
0.3132329285144806,
-0.1087263897061348,
-0.3843531012535095,
0.42208045721054077,
0.012143442407250404,
-0.2663070261478424,
0.12146735191345215,
-0.8808913230895996,
1.1551923751831055,
-0.3374057710170746,
0.12022895365953445,
-0.23460745811462402,
-0.5030624270439148,
0.0735224261879921,
-0.8895513415336609,
0.24915668368339539,
0.1608908623456955,
0.1155058965086937,
0.5163478851318359,
-0.20536431670188904,
0.9012935161590576,
-0.0770050585269928,
0.07442301511764526,
0.11134933680295944,
-0.1856134831905365,
0.22696611285209656,
0.04921068996191025,
-0.576938271522522,
0.34805816411972046,
-0.038103584200143814,
-0.6735185980796814,
-0.574383556842804,
0.3789503574371338,
-0.6166521310806274,
-0.6851183772087097,
-0.36355283856391907,
-0.6166347861289978,
-0.11994878202676773,
0.4723069965839386,
0.0489727221429348,
0.5582229495048523,
-0.6914828419685364,
0.2246735841035843,
0.7792107462882996,
-0.16487149894237518,
0.6856867671012878,
0.5851304531097412,
-0.04961052164435387,
-0.5738568902015686,
0.8015759587287903,
-0.0027631123084574938,
0.405313104391098,
0.37158846855163574,
-0.038347382098436356,
0.06889709085226059,
-0.832817018032074,
-0.8715724945068359,
0.05818699300289154,
-0.7965705990791321,
0.05421983823180199,
-0.5642601251602173,
-0.26938900351524353,
-0.3310243785381317,
-0.330893337726593,
-0.20429760217666626,
-0.6044977307319641,
-0.3739164173603058,
-0.2162068635225296,
0.1368056833744049,
0.7337127327919006,
-0.11850490421056747,
0.584711492061615,
-0.990536630153656,
-0.018755868077278137,
0.3396151661872864,
0.14773795008659363,
-0.2625499963760376,
-0.642429769039154,
-0.5536430478096008,
-0.06151813641190529,
0.15961669385433197,
-0.7200800776481628,
0.19317404925823212,
0.539361298084259,
0.5956946015357971,
0.27927568554878235,
-0.052197281271219254,
0.6553167700767517,
-0.9135332703590393,
0.7096456289291382,
0.4160904288291931,
-1.1225849390029907,
0.25324898958206177,
-0.2578720152378082,
0.8211934566497803,
0.8407034873962402,
0.26740989089012146,
-0.5257998704910278,
0.07590032368898392,
-0.0757208839058876,
-0.7410768270492554,
0.9812854528427124,
-0.1291360706090927,
0.8031510710716248,
0.15531960129737854,
0.5572518706321716,
0.4448515772819519,
0.07570945471525192,
-0.8845401406288147,
0.03265197202563286,
-0.46243149042129517,
-0.19403168559074402,
-0.37465032935142517,
-0.3998251259326935,
-0.08808010816574097,
-0.4503169357776642,
0.5121440887451172,
-0.4462231695652008,
0.2798517048358917,
0.10883036255836487,
-0.5546889901161194,
0.320354163646698,
0.4899197220802307,
0.5917648077011108,
0.6978808641433716,
0.02248511090874672,
-0.001527398475445807,
0.4113026261329651,
-0.3717791736125946,
0.13023033738136292,
0.42623186111450195,
-0.222244992852211,
0.307306706905365,
0.579163670539856,
1.1282148361206055,
0.48400914669036865,
-0.43426841497421265,
0.3723917007446289,
-0.05100199207663536,
-0.5136487483978271,
-0.299652636051178,
-0.023060990497469902,
0.423583060503006,
0.24929989874362946,
0.3229941129684448,
0.2768239974975586,
-0.02762247808277607,
-0.571932852268219,
0.20548972487449646,
0.0830659419298172,
-0.5974014401435852,
-0.787609338760376,
0.1387452483177185,
0.2364744395017624,
-0.3401276767253876,
0.6081430912017822,
-0.023651158437132835,
-0.7502975463867188,
0.2878669798374176,
0.9905334115028381,
1.0075161457061768,
-0.43118754029273987,
0.3429151773452759,
0.38157960772514343,
0.41079914569854736,
-0.3494535982608795,
0.33311134576797485,
0.01128254272043705,
-0.8167777061462402,
-0.38314494490623474,
-0.551413357257843,
-0.09315420687198639,
-0.587679922580719,
-0.8957306146621704,
0.008324476890265942,
-0.20533709228038788,
-0.1385524719953537,
-0.039188675582408905,
-0.5444213151931763,
-0.36835798621177673,
-0.07576356828212738,
-0.06856156140565872,
1.061692476272583,
-0.7717897891998291,
1.048788070678711,
0.8574298620223999,
-0.21868444979190826,
-0.13178373873233795,
0.07579412311315536,
-0.37547776103019714,
-0.6504220366477966,
0.31538593769073486,
0.05825822055339813,
-0.1914387345314026,
0.2000477910041809,
-0.1248285323381424,
-0.5889586210250854,
0.7245585918426514,
0.6778930425643921,
-0.5239762663841248,
0.01822148635983467,
0.0030940757133066654,
0.603220522403717,
-0.5713743567466736,
-0.1536179780960083,
0.381854385137558,
0.6481575965881348,
-0.17203232645988464,
-0.7097475528717041,
-0.12278075516223907,
-0.4014987647533417,
0.052471477538347244,
0.18808382749557495,
-0.38921067118644714,
0.8329834342002869,
-0.009719389490783215,
-0.06228767707943916,
0.17161494493484497,
0.6674578785896301,
-0.25602495670318604,
-0.14957468211650848,
0.4621902108192444,
0.5448847413063049,
0.7251434922218323,
-0.1875753551721573,
1.1406729221343994,
-0.2630760371685028,
0.011578025296330452,
1.1196539402008057,
-0.3847488462924957,
0.9862045049667358,
0.41672736406326294,
0.0615742951631546,
0.8442530035972595,
0.5939779877662659,
-0.026903420686721802,
0.7736374139785767,
0.010053042322397232,
-0.6455241441726685,
-0.4338859021663666,
0.2938922047615051,
-0.44407856464385986,
0.2734629213809967,
0.05100034177303314,
-0.09416400641202927,
-0.08104949444532394,
0.2499854415655136,
0.14578410983085632,
-0.02189468778669834,
-0.1871073693037033,
1.0351448059082031,
0.012010741047561169,
-0.7054224610328674,
0.31246963143348694,
0.18837594985961914,
0.6618669629096985,
-0.9545328617095947,
0.42895564436912537,
-0.22263242304325104,
0.6069254875183105,
-0.12907327711582184,
-0.4467085003852844,
0.30439111590385437,
-0.17466412484645844,
-0.7040321826934814,
-0.3043087422847748,
0.7177768349647522,
-0.45869946479797363,
-0.9026152491569519,
0.445725679397583,
0.8006982207298279,
-0.1141125038266182,
-0.11029911786317825,
-0.5752198100090027,
-0.21916119754314423,
0.12665848433971405,
-0.15133006870746613,
0.5516228675842285,
0.7122259140014648,
0.22537362575531006,
0.03938507288694382,
0.6866116523742676,
-0.10886219888925552,
0.35612544417381287,
0.2640685439109802,
0.9237240552902222,
-0.7969669699668884,
-0.46330496668815613,
-0.8068395256996155,
0.6579912304878235,
-0.024951742962002754,
-0.40368205308914185,
0.7185486555099487,
0.6111688017845154,
1.143755555152893,
-0.5398805737495422,
0.9655592441558838,
-0.058817293494939804,
-0.1432415246963501,
-0.7757906913757324,
0.7192519903182983,
-0.5393618941307068,
-0.3040638864040375,
-0.00967954471707344,
-0.8452739715576172,
-0.3286880850791931,
0.6016259789466858,
0.043433818966150284,
0.10708729177713394,
1.0325013399124146,
0.7383335828781128,
-0.41379332542419434,
0.2512887418270111,
0.24672020971775055,
0.1142389178276062,
-0.10546586662530899,
0.48827269673347473,
0.5377023816108704,
-0.3033744692802429,
0.3397162854671478,
-0.262908399105072,
-0.18046706914901733,
0.058686260133981705,
-1.0745855569839478,
-0.900286078453064,
-0.416185587644577,
-0.25473880767822266,
-0.19124692678451538,
0.37072959542274475,
0.36896830797195435,
0.8739565014839172,
-1.107511281967163,
-0.7213252186775208,
0.16610272228717804,
-0.00960996001958847,
-0.36190614104270935,
-0.09544158726930618,
0.0726996511220932,
-0.6019808650016785,
-0.713623046875,
0.5203732848167419,
0.2872159779071808,
-0.042537447065114975,
0.07360619306564331,
-0.2501542270183563,
-0.269378125667572,
0.05379157140851021,
0.8861234784126282,
0.16914011538028717,
-0.39197251200675964,
-0.38370105624198914,
0.16546346247196198,
0.006610272917896509,
0.33700525760650635,
1.1971029043197632,
-0.2784878611564636,
0.7040054202079773,
0.5173625946044922,
0.8653588891029358,
0.8986319899559021,
-0.15794552862644196,
0.9021168947219849,
-0.6390755772590637,
0.3240284323692322,
0.009737386368215084,
0.43339967727661133,
0.5239696502685547,
-0.00870673917233944,
0.2556380033493042,
0.23972781002521515,
-0.33513379096984863,
-0.49226316809654236,
0.21035748720169067,
-0.9692360758781433,
-0.4644502103328705,
0.9207386374473572,
-0.37437742948532104,
-0.29850125312805176,
-0.11389173567295074,
-0.1617591232061386,
-0.06959376484155655,
-0.18392157554626465,
0.3739614486694336,
1.138114094734192,
-0.005220348015427589,
-0.06134392321109772,
-0.5553014874458313,
0.041088562458753586,
0.40754809975624084,
-0.8432009220123291,
-0.08829202502965927,
0.7125949859619141,
0.33855608105659485,
-0.004768752492964268,
0.8039141297340393,
0.010833067819476128,
0.24841243028640747,
0.13229049742221832,
0.29979461431503296,
-0.021876322105526924,
-0.19296525418758392,
-1.036047101020813,
0.22100132703781128,
0.028500616550445557,
0.1514284908771515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14447v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14447v1 | Wordflow: Social Prompt Engineering for Large Language Models | 2024-01-25T18:58:11 | 2024-01-25T18:58:11 | Zijie J. Wang, Aishwarya Chakravarthy, David Munechika, Duen Horng Chau | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) require well-crafted prompts for effective use.
Prompt engineering, the process of designing prompts, is challenging,
particularly for non-experts who are less familiar with AI technologies. While
researchers have proposed techniques and tools to assist LLM users in prompt
design, these works primarily target AI application developers rather than
non-experts. To address this research gap, we propose social prompt
engineering, a novel paradigm that leverages social computing techniques to
facilitate collaborative prompt design. To investigate social prompt
engineering, we introduce Wordflow, an open-source and social text editor that
enables everyday users to easily create, run, share, and discover LLM prompts.
Additionally, by leveraging modern web technologies, Wordflow allows users to
run LLMs locally and privately in their browsers. Two usage scenarios highlight
how social prompt engineering and our tool can enhance laypeople's interaction
with LLMs. Wordflow is publicly accessible at
https://poloclub.github.io/wordflow. | [
-0.18685553967952728,
-0.9283249974250793,
0.9844415783882141,
0.6704490780830383,
-0.12802991271018982,
0.39932382106781006,
-0.23302635550498962,
-0.3022861182689667,
0.45751750469207764,
0.2386639416217804,
-0.7849286198616028,
-0.5724849104881287,
-0.43984243273735046,
0.150291308760643,
-0.28680169582366943,
0.7401349544525146,
-0.17238816618919373,
0.1173510029911995,
-0.3413195013999939,
0.05270957201719284,
-0.4835749864578247,
-0.24714182317256927,
-0.8437970876693726,
-0.19360844790935516,
1.0379115343093872,
0.4701572358608246,
0.7962056994438171,
0.21889738738536835,
0.24074465036392212,
0.40706393122673035,
-0.22716259956359863,
0.17856281995773315,
-0.4905700087547302,
0.33596059679985046,
-0.17328396439552307,
-0.13997529447078705,
-0.29040366411209106,
-0.01702352613210678,
0.26877090334892273,
0.7402976751327515,
0.07478076219558716,
0.36157795786857605,
0.2595565617084503,
0.6158686876296997,
-0.32880306243896484,
0.11256947368383408,
-0.5103089809417725,
-0.18626032769680023,
-0.2589746415615082,
-0.11928034573793411,
-0.2886739671230316,
-0.9808999300003052,
-0.16958890855312347,
-0.6246830224990845,
0.027635224163532257,
0.27587080001831055,
0.2617940306663513,
0.084398552775383,
0.05232665687799454,
-0.18339505791664124,
-0.5566224455833435,
0.3523244857788086,
-0.5758135914802551,
0.1727641373872757,
0.2442156821489334,
0.494659423828125,
-0.5335642099380493,
-0.48338526487350464,
-0.6297033429145813,
-0.29764777421951294,
0.19906361401081085,
-0.15998288989067078,
0.07229646295309067,
0.19207711517810822,
0.17543846368789673,
0.08222730457782745,
-0.7608042359352112,
0.341492623090744,
-0.36762067675590515,
-0.11897595971822739,
0.7203865647315979,
0.20599952340126038,
0.7333831191062927,
0.0973595529794693,
-0.06053337827324867,
0.36299413442611694,
-0.6509691476821899,
0.04658303037285805,
0.3865619897842407,
0.5216467976570129,
-0.3845280706882477,
0.7544723153114319,
-0.3487122058868408,
0.5652639865875244,
-0.23227953910827637,
0.14515291154384613,
-0.003669510129839182,
0.052613746374845505,
0.021918021142482758,
0.1673261523246765,
1.0171699523925781,
0.3961341679096222,
0.4415125548839569,
-0.23267695307731628,
-0.2098618894815445,
0.17002621293067932,
-0.11760440468788147,
-0.604824423789978,
0.024354107677936554,
0.4146117568016052,
-0.3693416118621826,
-0.596254289150238,
-0.1512785404920578,
-0.5528247356414795,
-1.1197407245635986,
-0.4367724359035492,
0.22603502869606018,
-0.08503957092761993,
-0.07390382140874863,
-0.018713369965553284,
-0.5316998362541199,
0.1346583068370819,
0.4456828236579895,
-0.6762336492538452,
0.062350932508707047,
1.1215816736221313,
1.33970308303833,
-0.07452309131622314,
-0.4837137758731842,
-0.8157539367675781,
-0.01646967977285385,
-0.21428023278713226,
0.7746114134788513,
-0.7451390624046326,
-0.8173719644546509,
0.1903434693813324,
-0.08558369427919388,
0.3833368420600891,
-0.09284833073616028,
0.11791328340768814,
-0.598800778388977,
0.12279362231492996,
-0.3375972807407379,
-0.5956898927688599,
0.24481360614299774,
-0.04585539549589157,
-0.5360254645347595,
0.640285849571228,
-0.11982979625463486,
-0.6945693492889404,
-0.07692273706197739,
-0.8037662506103516,
-0.4129115343093872,
0.7670316100120544,
-0.26714026927948,
0.17843158543109894,
0.40487566590309143,
-0.04376298561692238,
0.5392464399337769,
-0.2886732220649719,
0.3892379105091095,
-0.858432948589325,
-0.4992266297340393,
0.10312964767217636,
-0.1376350224018097,
0.9641709923744202,
0.2283148169517517,
0.014152486808598042,
0.48577335476875305,
-0.5446215271949768,
-0.2508227229118347,
0.2592368721961975,
-0.13276362419128418,
-0.2415044903755188,
-0.1067013293504715,
0.0777718648314476,
-0.008582917973399162,
0.47046369314193726,
-0.6401736736297607,
0.38281166553497314,
-0.21413320302963257,
0.56779944896698,
1.066550374031067,
0.01899329200387001,
0.4931781589984894,
-0.5330966711044312,
0.7212610244750977,
-0.6591014862060547,
0.19950886070728302,
-0.03012693114578724,
-0.7621262669563293,
-0.1890520304441452,
-0.1768527776002884,
0.048726070672273636,
0.6904104351997375,
-0.9417012333869934,
0.25293371081352234,
-0.1270758956670761,
-0.7849647998809814,
-0.545865535736084,
0.4395333528518677,
-0.1904064565896988,
0.19166342914104462,
-0.01760195568203926,
0.19550064206123352,
-0.2845900356769562,
-0.6010457873344421,
-0.2799697518348694,
-0.2658138871192932,
-0.33634135127067566,
0.22163249552249908,
0.0930914580821991,
-0.39381125569343567,
1.0686768293380737,
-0.6249533891677856,
-0.12402238696813583,
-0.548888623714447,
0.25318726897239685,
0.18929709494113922,
0.1394573599100113,
0.3526083528995514,
-0.45977842807769775,
-0.5529532432556152,
-0.06036601960659027,
-0.7444741725921631,
-0.5738865733146667,
0.033715441823005676,
-0.2552435100078583,
0.021312767639756203,
0.6836229562759399,
-0.7578168511390686,
0.11841464042663574,
0.8139133453369141,
-0.42021453380584717,
0.4656605124473572,
-0.18804560601711273,
-0.0064406623132526875,
-1.3636329174041748,
-0.08792533725500107,
0.25794902443885803,
-0.16111505031585693,
-0.3974831998348236,
0.09280150383710861,
-0.02743946947157383,
-0.7084711194038391,
-0.657958984375,
0.928434431552887,
-0.5119082927703857,
0.040657177567481995,
-0.38370320200920105,
0.38041189312934875,
-0.07086357474327087,
0.1594313532114029,
-0.16717226803302765,
0.904860258102417,
0.57033371925354,
-0.3001857399940491,
0.6066341400146484,
0.10647045075893402,
-0.2323376089334488,
0.5131044387817383,
-1.090474247932434,
0.4030829668045044,
-0.21356797218322754,
0.2086346298456192,
-1.0851389169692993,
-0.40576794743537903,
0.12803956866264343,
-0.4980587959289551,
-0.06842676550149918,
0.08116714656352997,
-0.6893941760063171,
-0.3924049735069275,
-0.6975830793380737,
0.08046495169401169,
0.4858645498752594,
-0.5815250873565674,
0.5295882821083069,
0.4923401474952698,
-0.6096796989440918,
0.10668819397687912,
-0.3393001854419708,
0.28698474168777466,
-0.07840811461210251,
-0.9522355198860168,
0.2063758820295334,
-0.43815281987190247,
-0.5237606763839722,
-0.08420029282569885,
0.36686307191848755,
-0.007910850457847118,
0.36906397342681885,
0.3631238639354706,
0.4645395874977112,
0.010959210805594921,
0.16916969418525696,
0.11569931358098984,
0.08995602279901505,
0.21799959242343903,
0.05067785456776619,
0.6353176832199097,
0.10515639930963516,
-0.1525825560092926,
-0.6734285950660706,
0.6039283871650696,
0.6595473885536194,
-0.31585177779197693,
0.7553602457046509,
0.41756927967071533,
-0.5404820442199707,
-0.28073638677597046,
-0.5364816784858704,
-0.08390221744775772,
-0.6524196267127991,
-0.09603728353977203,
0.01599118486046791,
-1.2666879892349243,
0.4623333811759949,
-0.3279182016849518,
0.338467538356781,
-0.08650947362184525,
0.4080924391746521,
-0.1597573459148407,
0.9020345211029053,
0.8010916709899902,
-0.3977183401584625,
0.7283372282981873,
0.2924433648586273,
0.04259580001235008,
-0.5550609827041626,
0.05789905786514282,
-0.640773594379425,
-0.38258010149002075,
-0.3077739179134369,
-0.355972021818161,
0.2822872996330261,
-0.16305312514305115,
-0.05659111961722374,
-0.034674663096666336,
-0.4773830771446228,
0.7012001872062683,
0.499022513628006,
0.0869935005903244,
0.06684545427560806,
-0.1732003390789032,
-0.11874498426914215,
0.2746058404445648,
-0.38618600368499756,
-0.6950185894966125,
0.45154184103012085,
0.2904854416847229,
0.9549671411514282,
-0.015335286036133766,
1.0474556684494019,
0.5154456496238708,
0.34245118498802185,
-0.7975037097930908,
0.8757821917533875,
0.10318921506404877,
-0.27986738085746765,
-0.5306949019432068,
-0.3316931128501892,
-0.854084849357605,
-0.19496887922286987,
-0.37447330355644226,
-0.7177628874778748,
-0.2261471003293991,
0.14378750324249268,
-0.5616985559463501,
0.12047603726387024,
-0.8764947652816772,
0.8096250891685486,
-0.23116646707057953,
-0.3618184030056,
-0.04934556782245636,
-0.4687458574771881,
0.04207148775458336,
-0.120336152613163,
0.5318505764007568,
-0.16392777860164642,
0.04282303526997566,
0.47462400794029236,
-0.7343356013298035,
1.144663691520691,
-0.36014801263809204,
-0.15606030821800232,
0.2830711901187897,
0.2855497896671295,
0.8836554884910583,
0.07932566106319427,
-0.09222613275051117,
0.12010403722524643,
-0.3421986699104309,
-0.20783455669879913,
-0.6284124851226807,
1.0558733940124512,
-0.6410133242607117,
-0.7180368900299072,
-0.14098477363586426,
-0.2954977750778198,
-0.26764076948165894,
0.1717640459537506,
-0.0927787646651268,
0.3847583830356598,
-0.2833386957645416,
0.12002044916152954,
0.4154137074947357,
-0.5836418271064758,
0.6016894578933716,
0.358389675617218,
-0.3862445056438446,
-0.3119756877422333,
0.8697957396507263,
0.043930619955062866,
0.06210123002529144,
0.23143485188484192,
0.5375092029571533,
-0.2613711357116699,
-0.4845587909221649,
-0.521065354347229,
0.44500693678855896,
-0.5870346426963806,
0.013147595338523388,
-0.6062769889831543,
-0.13999852538108826,
-0.6561519503593445,
-0.7356081604957581,
-0.03354562073945999,
-0.22586165368556976,
-0.4482913911342621,
-0.19220587611198425,
0.7037559747695923,
0.8896498084068298,
0.16445386409759521,
0.37556588649749756,
-1.0097410678863525,
0.2273971289396286,
0.5059815049171448,
0.31561902165412903,
-0.08749253302812576,
-0.05864901840686798,
0.0700141191482544,
-0.12394645065069199,
-0.0864601731300354,
-0.9643141627311707,
0.1191948875784874,
-0.029506681486964226,
0.415711373090744,
0.0831649899482727,
0.1915966421365738,
0.3570990562438965,
-0.8772104978561401,
1.0200769901275635,
0.17662273347377777,
-0.974959135055542,
0.6857948899269104,
-0.49980825185775757,
0.42674019932746887,
0.5697383880615234,
0.5457351207733154,
-1.0992339849472046,
-0.5968707203865051,
-0.22026869654655457,
-0.8100823163986206,
0.3124609589576721,
-0.07998434454202652,
0.32239437103271484,
-0.20550347864627838,
0.39170557260513306,
0.08894246816635132,
0.06070501729846001,
-0.30144765973091125,
-0.16883805394172668,
0.07506786286830902,
-0.5766820311546326,
-0.17276877164840698,
-0.2452879697084427,
0.1580168455839157,
0.05083141475915909,
0.4697973430156708,
-0.14907988905906677,
-0.04441800341010094,
-0.055020686239004135,
0.04918593913316727,
-0.1062571182847023,
0.17032767832279205,
0.5377825498580933,
0.6832741498947144,
0.09647337347269058,
-0.03057987056672573,
0.1764754354953766,
-0.23167374730110168,
0.026204749941825867,
0.2622072994709015,
-0.2640872001647949,
0.007618328556418419,
0.1937127560377121,
0.5859396457672119,
0.07809732854366302,
-0.4431149363517761,
0.5372738838195801,
-0.49517568945884705,
-0.142323300242424,
-0.2954716682434082,
0.21394406259059906,
0.6652815341949463,
0.4880121350288391,
0.15881475806236267,
-0.29156258702278137,
0.18487383425235748,
-0.3735920786857605,
-0.2616320252418518,
0.5511652827262878,
-0.35548844933509827,
-0.34740060567855835,
0.9450094699859619,
0.6640953421592712,
-1.109236478805542,
0.34307312965393066,
-0.19783009588718414,
-0.17659957706928253,
0.3698769211769104,
0.2829286456108093,
1.1919209957122803,
-0.05152900889515877,
0.51959627866745,
-0.09617114812135696,
0.06718555092811584,
-0.03867083415389061,
0.39804205298423767,
-0.046152789145708084,
-0.40033191442489624,
-0.5174040198326111,
-0.5914321541786194,
-0.7540305852890015,
-0.06699201464653015,
-0.057524021714925766,
0.5664974451065063,
-0.6531697511672974,
-0.055771633982658386,
0.1591610312461853,
-0.26107603311538696,
-0.5036329627037048,
-0.26959651708602905,
0.3701847195625305,
1.0079697370529175,
-0.7065557241439819,
0.5498026013374329,
0.9704927206039429,
-0.042120929807424545,
-0.7990835309028625,
-0.2197631597518921,
0.36777108907699585,
-0.7032630443572998,
0.31055930256843567,
0.4180171489715576,
-0.22691287100315094,
0.03843694552779198,
-0.8153419494628906,
-0.4451766312122345,
1.0368753671646118,
0.3770942986011505,
-0.6438295245170593,
-0.14234891533851624,
0.16825678944587708,
0.5011220574378967,
-0.1462773233652115,
0.0779489055275917,
-0.17471745610237122,
0.25526130199432373,
0.13601788878440857,
-0.7160084843635559,
0.26273462176322937,
-0.2557884752750397,
0.24866871535778046,
0.05943654850125313,
-0.7760990858078003,
0.34280455112457275,
-0.10465879738330841,
-0.25392091274261475,
-0.001346773118712008,
0.6616185903549194,
0.6175958514213562,
0.46825459599494934,
0.5150740146636963,
-0.003447642782703042,
0.9615976810455322,
0.2735308110713959,
0.945215106010437,
-0.5378868579864502,
0.00009783144923858345,
1.0570943355560303,
-0.6466666460037231,
0.7038917541503906,
0.45481374859809875,
0.039113134145736694,
0.22464784979820251,
0.5713013410568237,
0.3598943054676056,
0.16957083344459534,
0.3478375971317291,
-0.5901907682418823,
-0.19899123907089233,
-0.42977339029312134,
-0.23467913269996643,
-0.05531536415219307,
0.1261475533246994,
-0.17339563369750977,
0.02029898762702942,
-0.025355596095323563,
0.07631514966487885,
0.06464052945375443,
-0.39656344056129456,
0.7030510306358337,
0.407174676656723,
-0.3783492147922516,
-0.03738149628043175,
-0.05443708226084709,
0.8328775763511658,
-0.5888732671737671,
-0.06172545999288559,
-0.376649409532547,
-0.2599218487739563,
-0.02310018427670002,
-0.760956346988678,
0.19955816864967346,
0.20799270272254944,
0.07222812622785568,
-0.4959966838359833,
0.8579440712928772,
-0.1645050346851349,
-0.48915261030197144,
0.29797467589378357,
0.4921802580356598,
0.1042386069893837,
-0.2945448160171509,
-0.6452968120574951,
0.25487658381462097,
-0.3020216226577759,
-0.26980060338974,
0.1403845101594925,
0.8228774666786194,
-0.037531234323978424,
0.7506160140037537,
0.8421932458877563,
0.3701755404472351,
-0.08206531405448914,
0.3974197804927826,
0.9505346417427063,
-0.6934012770652771,
-0.5555262565612793,
-1.2849786281585693,
0.3542931377887726,
-0.2267400175333023,
-0.19510091841220856,
0.6493965983390808,
0.35808348655700684,
0.49219125509262085,
-0.00791587121784687,
0.9030411839485168,
0.037196241319179535,
0.5048471689224243,
-0.2066638320684433,
0.9699549078941345,
-0.48347413539886475,
0.11562361568212509,
-0.45614588260650635,
-0.8546066880226135,
-0.355646550655365,
0.2856435179710388,
-0.1670677363872528,
-0.20711496472358704,
0.2740563154220581,
0.8899673819541931,
0.3109831213951111,
0.28016144037246704,
0.21726742386817932,
-0.1412409543991089,
0.6192477941513062,
0.23252199590206146,
1.0296987295150757,
0.3130134344100952,
0.24739691615104675,
-0.10155769437551498,
-0.5565381050109863,
-0.14644567668437958,
-0.9488039612770081,
-1.2220712900161743,
-0.31624022126197815,
-0.22881591320037842,
-0.17890001833438873,
0.07882034778594971,
1.593213677406311,
0.3856979310512543,
-0.3750387728214264,
-0.2221699357032776,
-0.06161677837371826,
0.3307429552078247,
0.23972944915294647,
-0.22871536016464233,
-0.06004966050386429,
-0.3379496932029724,
-0.5541186332702637,
0.5389657616615295,
0.3629980683326721,
0.17436324059963226,
-0.4900936484336853,
-0.03390001878142357,
0.10868663340806961,
0.18245553970336914,
0.6246588230133057,
0.1374816745519638,
-0.3069061040878296,
-0.2791658043861389,
0.10856111347675323,
-0.13961641490459442,
-0.34812965989112854,
0.7871115207672119,
-0.3056715428829193,
0.2116921842098236,
0.7999868392944336,
0.9751203656196594,
-0.1252090483903885,
0.04222783446311951,
0.6994654536247253,
-0.5817124843597412,
-0.006998191121965647,
-0.006006909534335136,
0.4727778732776642,
0.4670875370502472,
-0.6842051148414612,
0.41458797454833984,
0.29927685856819153,
-0.7746145725250244,
-0.6867862343788147,
0.1076943650841713,
-0.8760431408882141,
-0.3480185270309448,
1.5011074542999268,
0.09986913949251175,
-0.5550143122673035,
0.0017961333505809307,
-0.6002274751663208,
0.18524739146232605,
-0.7440958023071289,
0.816300630569458,
0.9258642196655273,
0.21401409804821014,
-0.136140376329422,
-0.48660916090011597,
0.2985680401325226,
-0.11368908733129501,
-0.83214271068573,
0.1174514964222908,
0.6510693430900574,
0.25780367851257324,
-0.012251090258359909,
0.8641197085380554,
0.3363960087299347,
0.08217324316501617,
-0.35423991084098816,
0.12058164924383163,
-0.3021332323551178,
-0.16078956425189972,
-0.3765254318714142,
0.14143002033233643,
0.3165699541568756,
-0.053583208471536636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01712v1 | Socially Aware Synthetic Data Generation for Suicidal Ideation Detection Using Large Language Models | 2024-01-25T18:25:05 | 2024-01-25T18:25:05 | Hamideh Ghanadian, Isar Nejadgholi, Hussein Al Osman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Suicidal ideation detection is a vital research area that holds great
potential for improving mental health support systems. However, the sensitivity
surrounding suicide-related data poses challenges in accessing large-scale,
annotated datasets necessary for training effective machine learning models. To
address this limitation, we introduce an innovative strategy that leverages the
capabilities of generative AI models, such as ChatGPT, Flan-T5, and Llama, to
create synthetic data for suicidal ideation detection. Our data generation
approach is grounded in social factors extracted from psychology literature and
aims to ensure coverage of essential information related to suicidal ideation.
In our study, we benchmarked against state-of-the-art NLP classification
models, specifically, those centered around the BERT family structures. When
trained on the real-world dataset, UMD, these conventional models tend to yield
F1-scores ranging from 0.75 to 0.87. Our synthetic data-driven method, informed
by social factors, offers consistent F1-scores of 0.82 for both models,
suggesting that the richness of topics in synthetic data can bridge the
performance gap across different model complexities. Most impressively, when we
combined a mere 30% of the UMD dataset with our synthetic data, we witnessed a
substantial increase in performance, achieving an F1-score of 0.88 on the UMD
test set. Such results underscore the cost-effectiveness and potential of our
approach in confronting major challenges in the field, such as data scarcity
and the quest for diversity in data representation. | [
-0.4256226718425751,
-1.1184604167938232,
0.857982873916626,
0.446990430355072,
-0.08952397853136063,
0.15572905540466309,
-0.27374300360679626,
-0.39515143632888794,
0.2431582659482956,
0.04589483514428139,
-0.7139694690704346,
-0.745223343372345,
-0.35027819871902466,
0.10338877886533737,
-0.27400240302085876,
1.0308631658554077,
0.060654036700725555,
-0.09536772221326828,
0.035722456872463226,
0.031567007303237915,
-0.16134759783744812,
-0.59962397813797,
-1.1076642274856567,
-0.04533858969807625,
0.8062109351158142,
0.3195800185203552,
0.6061527132987976,
0.18810151517391205,
0.31572553515434265,
0.17351222038269043,
-0.15382491052150726,
0.25071296095848083,
-0.45016470551490784,
0.1720287799835205,
0.21147313714027405,
-0.32489556074142456,
-0.5036696195602417,
-0.050571974366903305,
0.3319530785083771,
0.5221413969993591,
-0.07354283332824707,
0.29239144921302795,
0.09706610441207886,
0.8258123397827148,
-0.4714561402797699,
0.19750754535198212,
-0.6617019176483154,
0.5000075101852417,
-0.24847634136676788,
0.06265823543071747,
-0.44287776947021484,
-0.6706889867782593,
0.05087050795555115,
-0.5180808305740356,
0.5718435049057007,
-0.3329731523990631,
0.342764675617218,
0.2594488859176636,
-0.20635353028774261,
-0.10987859964370728,
-0.899403989315033,
0.403593510389328,
-0.7010172605514526,
0.1084984615445137,
0.289652943611145,
0.3170095980167389,
-0.4082165062427521,
-0.284206360578537,
-0.7261590957641602,
-0.12161566317081451,
0.21027083694934845,
0.15726959705352783,
-0.16217181086540222,
0.19838950037956238,
0.5259073972702026,
0.17408262193202972,
-0.773494303226471,
-0.02885514125227928,
-0.1942504644393921,
-0.09655259549617767,
1.1857116222381592,
0.12165189534425735,
0.15231050550937653,
-0.40544676780700684,
-0.05881480127573013,
-0.1090291291475296,
-0.5082558393478394,
-0.15728634595870972,
0.45521920919418335,
0.26043900847435,
-0.009734439663589,
0.7432910799980164,
-0.3744361698627472,
0.29491138458251953,
-0.05477272719144821,
0.14076077938079834,
0.33155113458633423,
-0.05024334788322449,
-0.003928588703274727,
0.2842966914176941,
0.9752978682518005,
0.4750197231769562,
0.4459037482738495,
0.06523451209068298,
-0.14877474308013916,
0.32486701011657715,
0.19278816878795624,
-0.6313561201095581,
-0.38384169340133667,
0.42489394545555115,
-0.5247003436088562,
-0.5392737984657288,
-0.3543780744075775,
-0.7279984951019287,
-0.550717294216156,
-0.3683450520038605,
0.4422231912612915,
-0.7062650322914124,
-0.4062082767486572,
0.017594706267118454,
-0.2685244381427765,
-0.002473825355991721,
0.20171043276786804,
-0.6002925634384155,
-0.12703262269496918,
0.5973441004753113,
1.187190055847168,
-0.11296650022268295,
0.09155130386352539,
-0.08292361348867416,
0.13050946593284607,
-0.2693432569503784,
0.8277302980422974,
-0.25413230061531067,
-0.35162225365638733,
0.07415144890546799,
-0.19175004959106445,
0.05123050883412361,
-0.4380839467048645,
0.7489938139915466,
-0.11358514428138733,
0.040496889501810074,
-0.26738864183425903,
-0.5792533159255981,
-0.06876174360513687,
0.19767658412456512,
-0.6306034922599792,
1.154418706893921,
-0.013685791753232479,
-0.8573611974716187,
0.44894811511039734,
-0.8994157314300537,
-0.5052352547645569,
0.21606360375881195,
-0.17715595662593842,
-0.6940178871154785,
0.13384009897708893,
0.21661941707134247,
0.8358780145645142,
-0.12484419345855713,
0.550916850566864,
-0.8424472212791443,
-0.18490038812160492,
0.43683725595474243,
-0.5792911648750305,
0.7362217903137207,
0.23739708960056305,
-0.21478207409381866,
0.06378434598445892,
-0.8391319513320923,
0.05206197872757912,
0.35744616389274597,
-0.14871574938297272,
-0.4477851092815399,
0.08869771659374237,
0.4072498083114624,
0.21624068915843964,
0.01690750941634178,
-0.8875218033790588,
-0.009099943563342094,
-0.18359458446502686,
0.31196680665016174,
0.8912243247032166,
0.2942558228969574,
-0.11127056181430817,
-0.5948209762573242,
0.596595048904419,
-0.3092196583747864,
0.3704451024532318,
0.3904094099998474,
-0.7779577374458313,
-0.3667408525943756,
-0.4361809492111206,
-0.021722787991166115,
0.542478084564209,
-0.558442234992981,
0.8193579316139221,
0.025775710120797157,
-0.7946866154670715,
-0.5640966296195984,
-0.20677876472473145,
0.10969793796539307,
0.5094366073608398,
0.43489348888397217,
0.1603950709104538,
-0.6577697992324829,
-0.9955079555511475,
-0.203765407204628,
-0.24682776629924774,
-0.24340786039829254,
0.12113717198371887,
0.3081381916999817,
-0.24716144800186157,
1.0171886682510376,
-0.9088028073310852,
-0.46010273694992065,
-0.47782495617866516,
0.36086177825927734,
0.2064586728811264,
0.38168424367904663,
0.40354543924331665,
-0.905977189540863,
-0.5502398610115051,
-0.015065955929458141,
-0.9243441820144653,
-0.28896522521972656,
-0.3155227303504944,
-0.24216940999031067,
-0.009802740067243576,
0.242210254073143,
-0.6305175423622131,
0.534156084060669,
0.14776751399040222,
-0.10003743320703506,
0.6227610111236572,
0.028291204944252968,
-0.12466619908809662,
-1.3686492443084717,
0.06077372282743454,
0.13355496525764465,
-0.01089092344045639,
-0.7058651447296143,
-0.37266528606414795,
-0.1850435435771942,
-0.2577534019947052,
-0.255022257566452,
0.27847054600715637,
0.08069417625665665,
0.21530969440937042,
-0.05098770558834076,
-0.16476282477378845,
-0.4063343405723572,
0.48530715703964233,
0.12441331148147583,
0.45123422145843506,
0.26633912324905396,
-0.23867656290531158,
0.22980421781539917,
0.3833818733692169,
-0.16189579665660858,
0.4636700451374054,
-0.6932330131530762,
0.09586755931377411,
-0.3820968270301819,
0.5210932493209839,
-0.9634913206100464,
-0.5540418028831482,
0.08729779720306396,
-0.4011593163013458,
-0.20905861258506775,
-0.041555654257535934,
-0.5594485998153687,
-0.232425257563591,
-0.45383116602897644,
0.38002607226371765,
0.5944064259529114,
-0.28684327006340027,
0.516086995601654,
0.5751543045043945,
-0.5474649667739868,
-0.144712895154953,
-0.42461299896240234,
0.012918321415781975,
-0.5592556595802307,
-0.7205834984779358,
0.481489360332489,
-0.03039483353495598,
-0.003575059352442622,
-0.18860216438770294,
0.21852082014083862,
0.11989820748567581,
0.008489030413329601,
0.41966596245765686,
0.3401937782764435,
-0.0454268753528595,
0.4545973241329193,
0.37279731035232544,
-0.06999804824590683,
0.39595744013786316,
0.10612227022647858,
0.6262872219085693,
0.08024965971708298,
-0.18994922935962677,
-0.406579852104187,
0.6096844673156738,
0.5367164015769958,
0.004473912995308638,
0.8658815622329712,
0.6185887455940247,
-0.7271596789360046,
-0.4640955328941345,
-0.45779410004615784,
0.010605886578559875,
-0.4515632092952728,
0.2706640660762787,
-0.09410049766302109,
-0.669154167175293,
0.5724766254425049,
-0.2209727168083191,
0.13969236612319946,
0.23272019624710083,
0.5336560010910034,
-0.33432942628860474,
1.4200704097747803,
0.4728034436702728,
0.07680774480104446,
0.6075283885002136,
-0.33987265825271606,
0.4556848108768463,
-0.7756632566452026,
-0.09156559407711029,
-0.0692182257771492,
-0.44439977407455444,
-0.6200320720672607,
-0.30040961503982544,
0.9592043161392212,
-0.0549253486096859,
-0.3045462965965271,
0.09352214634418488,
-0.633262038230896,
0.33893802762031555,
0.19022053480148315,
0.49842703342437744,
0.2640410363674164,
-0.011012506671249866,
0.06189487501978874,
-0.14340642094612122,
-0.5703438520431519,
-0.49210554361343384,
1.4008326530456543,
0.2623046934604645,
0.4876994490623474,
0.09487126767635345,
0.9265801906585693,
0.6350440979003906,
0.6383090615272522,
-0.6761860251426697,
0.6419921517372131,
-0.14296770095825195,
-0.48511025309562683,
-0.28816506266593933,
-0.4956190884113312,
-0.6429668068885803,
-0.061306312680244446,
-0.36103934049606323,
-0.6846126317977905,
0.10778733342885971,
0.16167721152305603,
-0.5145546793937683,
-0.003465602407231927,
-0.8088972568511963,
0.7862711548805237,
-0.278838187456131,
-0.08388520777225494,
-0.2821783125400543,
-0.38983848690986633,
0.48143699765205383,
-0.6460567712783813,
0.1253044605255127,
-0.4686770737171173,
0.3854233920574188,
0.8826570510864258,
-0.3750835955142975,
0.8537042140960693,
-0.30729877948760986,
-0.05621690675616264,
0.16261190176010132,
-0.04862004518508911,
0.4772668182849884,
0.24248149991035461,
-0.29772141575813293,
0.016462435945868492,
-0.1668872982263565,
-0.2388855218887329,
-0.6005728840827942,
0.4529334008693695,
-0.6136686205863953,
-0.386709988117218,
-0.230336531996727,
-0.6957058310508728,
-0.34521159529685974,
0.044174373149871826,
0.4217256009578705,
0.13211116194725037,
-0.46468377113342285,
-0.0023125146981328726,
0.5762035846710205,
-0.2889402210712433,
0.2447449415922165,
0.25290295481681824,
-0.18417024612426758,
-0.34760841727256775,
0.8487005233764648,
0.2507925033569336,
0.3131142258644104,
0.017121022567152977,
0.215336874127388,
-0.363150030374527,
-0.3493656814098358,
-0.2460751086473465,
0.29291588068008423,
-0.48542118072509766,
-0.2708424925804138,
-0.8422704339027405,
-0.513396143913269,
-0.3541894555091858,
-0.35098907351493835,
-0.34884223341941833,
-0.4765448272228241,
-0.04078733175992966,
-0.426785945892334,
0.7458204030990601,
0.6123576760292053,
-0.2910732924938202,
0.05873249098658562,
-0.680828869342804,
0.4751121401786804,
0.02223118767142296,
0.07805731147527695,
0.15315163135528564,
-0.09054386615753174,
0.034032683819532394,
0.22378967702388763,
-0.38632211089134216,
-1.038902997970581,
0.4896738529205322,
0.2608235478401184,
0.17466166615486145,
0.5449491739273071,
0.5414265990257263,
0.6407536268234253,
-0.4507864713668823,
0.467715322971344,
0.05428348481655121,
-0.739021897315979,
0.8869636058807373,
-0.5472069978713989,
-0.016760047525167465,
0.5274203419685364,
0.7757485508918762,
-0.8195788264274597,
-0.5200651288032532,
-0.6756153106689453,
-0.8140471577644348,
0.409584641456604,
0.400779664516449,
0.025502661243081093,
-0.13378839194774628,
0.3266618251800537,
0.14209547638893127,
-0.04277579486370087,
-0.736285924911499,
-0.014265688136219978,
0.08989810943603516,
-0.7227351665496826,
0.1883644014596939,
0.09858279675245285,
-0.062291909009218216,
-0.383704274892807,
0.6943702697753906,
-0.2839089632034302,
0.44673335552215576,
0.356962114572525,
0.32642751932144165,
-0.059674497693777084,
0.012218180112540722,
0.0526113286614418,
0.11668681353330612,
-0.3476119935512543,
-0.0905144140124321,
0.18829795718193054,
-0.4097403287887573,
0.3491954803466797,
0.38058120012283325,
-0.4343152940273285,
-0.030975935980677605,
0.31525301933288574,
0.4543621838092804,
-0.256241112947464,
-0.8567818999290466,
0.3279416561126709,
-0.17154668271541595,
-0.1432776153087616,
-0.8961485624313354,
0.3051638901233673,
0.10550575703382492,
0.28839242458343506,
0.2492171823978424,
0.05733872205018997,
0.2173231840133667,
-0.41658806800842285,
0.22850601375102997,
0.5360325574874878,
-0.11654645949602127,
-0.44884416460990906,
0.5588110685348511,
-0.019625945016741753,
-0.4352763295173645,
0.5155008435249329,
-0.3042357861995697,
-0.6441249847412109,
0.5657716393470764,
0.49965280294418335,
1.0904426574707031,
-0.1827218383550644,
0.7618915438652039,
0.38296449184417725,
-0.05312570556998253,
0.05457804352045059,
0.617843747138977,
-0.12224794924259186,
-0.8816710114479065,
-0.19016145169734955,
-0.7660608887672424,
-0.17758062481880188,
0.4387463927268982,
-0.6628829836845398,
0.2498217672109604,
-0.563139796257019,
-0.3217470943927765,
0.251925528049469,
-0.2639400362968445,
-0.4863452613353729,
0.06270480155944824,
0.3969728946685791,
0.672045111656189,
-1.165537714958191,
0.5839352607727051,
0.5267665386199951,
-0.31759923696517944,
-0.5630744695663452,
0.32780569791793823,
0.13666881620883942,
-0.3576093316078186,
0.4179799556732178,
0.506388247013092,
0.04758192226290703,
0.026045596227049828,
-0.4755313992500305,
-0.7738093733787537,
0.8754289746284485,
0.19541165232658386,
-0.4456653594970703,
-0.15575554966926575,
0.43149542808532715,
0.8411234021186829,
-0.40049806237220764,
-0.03076517954468727,
0.593504786491394,
0.3540116548538208,
-0.035506539046764374,
-0.48446124792099,
0.20306572318077087,
-0.3117491900920868,
0.005899781361222267,
0.2756428122520447,
-0.5147449970245361,
0.4851614236831665,
-0.2462940514087677,
-0.36438989639282227,
-0.12485317885875702,
0.39587777853012085,
0.5328245162963867,
0.477874755859375,
0.5483725666999817,
0.669178307056427,
0.8232994079589844,
0.14547160267829895,
0.7976983189582825,
0.12831518054008484,
0.2063875049352646,
0.6942022442817688,
-0.47018569707870483,
0.969907820224762,
0.12185360491275787,
-0.22438035905361176,
0.2527634799480438,
0.7276827096939087,
0.059747472405433655,
0.4152810573577881,
0.2316722273826599,
-0.7307223081588745,
-0.32641035318374634,
-0.3941735029220581,
-0.09677563607692719,
0.35300204157829285,
0.6647751331329346,
-0.47791728377342224,
-0.08958320319652557,
0.22281120717525482,
-0.011026968248188496,
-0.014916117303073406,
0.03638112172484398,
0.8633025288581848,
0.04542046785354614,
-0.3827435374259949,
0.4964613914489746,
-0.15656448900699615,
0.52903813123703,
-0.389199823141098,
-0.2045895755290985,
-0.17236945033073425,
0.27237486839294434,
-0.14730381965637207,
-0.7893892526626587,
0.49352899193763733,
0.38109907507896423,
-0.25167760252952576,
-0.2267163246870041,
0.7046111226081848,
-0.48246750235557556,
-0.917780339717865,
0.2744961678981781,
0.3706310987472534,
0.05771869421005249,
-0.3066951632499695,
-0.7431936264038086,
-0.1139521598815918,
0.1923590749502182,
-0.04268035665154457,
0.20785285532474518,
0.4583025574684143,
-0.28966498374938965,
0.6257778406143188,
1.030807614326477,
0.38516220450401306,
-0.19652870297431946,
-0.003981784451752901,
0.8520898818969727,
-0.621728241443634,
-0.5246171355247498,
-0.7790892124176025,
0.30738571286201477,
-0.3668802082538605,
-0.44093871116638184,
0.4031655788421631,
0.5154820680618286,
0.8279624581336975,
-0.013021091930568218,
1.02059006690979,
-0.17721261084079742,
0.719253420829773,
-0.3548848032951355,
1.046417474746704,
-0.2534986138343811,
0.07808157801628113,
-0.40584951639175415,
-1.0693330764770508,
-0.2855569124221802,
0.6657905578613281,
-0.47471103072166443,
-0.19270499050617218,
0.30210644006729126,
0.863120436668396,
0.08207384496927261,
0.3288035988807678,
0.005938521586358547,
0.2507050335407257,
0.7010467648506165,
0.6155122518539429,
0.9273760318756104,
-0.23253031075000763,
0.1881682574748993,
-0.39187946915626526,
-0.4447704553604126,
-0.016855888068675995,
-0.6322729587554932,
-0.9032069444656372,
-0.7581585645675659,
-0.31470581889152527,
0.034072160720825195,
-0.050076305866241455,
1.123339295387268,
0.45396602153778076,
-0.6204692125320435,
0.12835471332073212,
-0.2892817556858063,
-0.1664142608642578,
-0.08935724198818207,
-0.33372145891189575,
0.5129265785217285,
-0.13062821328639984,
-0.33610913157463074,
0.2578710913658142,
0.06809590756893158,
0.11937800794839859,
-0.2535741627216339,
0.17673394083976746,
-0.21974006295204163,
0.12474855035543442,
0.7146798372268677,
0.013633963651955128,
-0.5646488666534424,
-0.3350987136363983,
-0.2215389758348465,
0.1558842658996582,
-0.3400728702545166,
0.6129881739616394,
-0.893138587474823,
0.17684324085712433,
0.34253188967704773,
0.7217914462089539,
0.20928283035755157,
0.17686371505260468,
0.7649193406105042,
-0.8166822791099548,
-0.022690268233418465,
0.41020166873931885,
0.13505138456821442,
0.4327581226825714,
-0.8027777671813965,
0.5729506611824036,
0.1320863515138626,
-0.487497478723526,
-0.8548974990844727,
0.22733654081821442,
-0.6619188189506531,
-0.12916751205921173,
0.9081588983535767,
-0.016070639714598656,
-0.09637220203876495,
-0.2436952441930771,
-0.46896421909332275,
0.37271320819854736,
-0.597959578037262,
1.320960283279419,
0.5313897728919983,
-0.5142048597335815,
0.23848891258239746,
-0.5203545689582825,
0.803209125995636,
0.4868987202644348,
-0.9407840371131897,
0.4419572055339813,
0.5449914336204529,
-0.09000033885240555,
0.16504165530204773,
0.5072524547576904,
0.1654587686061859,
0.23308725655078888,
-0.32585644721984863,
0.06067023426294327,
0.1866341531276703,
-0.22907127439975739,
-0.03247202932834625,
0.0843919888138771,
-0.40708839893341064,
-0.005409537814557552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14373v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14373v1 | TURNA: A Turkish Encoder-Decoder Language Model for Enhanced Understanding and Generation | 2024-01-25T18:24:13 | 2024-01-25T18:24:13 | Gökçe Uludoğan, Zeynep Yirmibeşoğlu Balal, Furkan Akkurt, Melikşah Türker, Onur Güngör, Susan Üsküdarlı | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The recent advances in natural language processing have predominantly favored
well-resourced English-centric models, resulting in a significant gap with
low-resource languages. In this work, we introduce the language model TURNA,
which is developed for the low-resource language Turkish and is capable of both
natural language understanding and generation tasks. TURNA is pretrained with
an encoder-decoder architecture based on the unified framework UL2 with a
diverse corpus that we specifically curated for this purpose. We evaluated
TURNA with three generation tasks and five understanding tasks for Turkish. The
results show that TURNA outperforms several multilingual models in both
understanding and generation tasks, and competes with monolingual Turkish
models in understanding tasks. TURNA is made available at
https://huggingface.co/boun-tabi-LMG/TURNA . | [
-0.41873496770858765,
-0.6937754154205322,
0.36081522703170776,
0.3531683385372162,
-0.46181774139404297,
0.01505997497588396,
-0.2072707861661911,
-0.4855559766292572,
0.06318420171737671,
0.688442051410675,
-0.6155751943588257,
-0.12019344419240952,
-0.6185072660446167,
0.33091220259666443,
-0.24549944698810577,
0.8971497416496277,
0.041754234582185745,
0.23303160071372986,
-0.10752296447753906,
-0.18281885981559753,
-0.4609352648258209,
-0.32800936698913574,
-0.8410614132881165,
-0.73727947473526,
0.3399255573749542,
0.4315197765827179,
0.599307119846344,
0.3474290072917938,
0.3033176362514496,
0.21702204644680023,
-0.17688855528831482,
0.09808734804391861,
-0.3271235227584839,
-0.057983726263046265,
-0.22287945449352264,
-0.3598971962928772,
-0.3570515811443329,
-0.18770860135555267,
0.5711113810539246,
0.7327752709388733,
-0.18091963231563568,
0.5645151138305664,
0.09414035826921463,
0.854977548122406,
-0.7741612195968628,
0.1636679321527481,
-0.5371541380882263,
-0.09665445983409882,
-0.20617032051086426,
0.057750970125198364,
-0.56180340051651,
-0.037684522569179535,
-0.0026032766327261925,
-0.5903565287590027,
0.38659289479255676,
-0.18398676812648773,
0.5975819230079651,
0.2250940054655075,
-0.5337103605270386,
-0.39563360810279846,
-0.9481519460678101,
0.7218462228775024,
-0.7702774405479431,
0.757361650466919,
0.22288326919078827,
0.3475078046321869,
-0.23603329062461853,
-0.843744695186615,
-0.9424417614936829,
0.052556321024894714,
-0.06297989189624786,
0.16464222967624664,
-0.14828144013881683,
-0.04852249473333359,
-0.11928193271160126,
0.5811448097229004,
-0.49224939942359924,
-0.016697218641638756,
-0.3698608875274658,
0.18524718284606934,
0.46723708510398865,
0.0631563737988472,
0.42588314414024353,
-0.2684890031814575,
-0.007939948700368404,
-0.054585158824920654,
-0.7498354911804199,
0.21212950348854065,
0.4029493033885956,
0.552429735660553,
-0.0871349349617958,
0.7355890274047852,
-0.339345246553421,
0.8725957870483398,
0.25381410121917725,
-0.04561452940106392,
0.07219059765338898,
-0.3035869300365448,
-0.49447309970855713,
0.015470882877707481,
0.5233291387557983,
-0.24249471724033356,
0.024289840832352638,
-0.25920069217681885,
-0.09770234674215317,
0.2867683172225952,
0.5246252417564392,
-0.8207706809043884,
-0.015743011608719826,
0.21238526701927185,
-0.6515491604804993,
-0.13282792270183563,
-0.020688019692897797,
-0.7562375068664551,
-0.38161391019821167,
-0.30021926760673523,
0.36075639724731445,
-0.5184195637702942,
-0.5983274579048157,
0.5160079002380371,
0.3101640045642853,
0.7080435752868652,
0.16091562807559967,
-0.9854853749275208,
0.25165051221847534,
0.7486912608146667,
0.6389806866645813,
-0.05669032409787178,
-0.25017499923706055,
-0.5136430263519287,
-0.0687888041138649,
-0.23423127830028534,
0.746541440486908,
-0.7145551443099976,
-0.14917172491550446,
0.3529859185218811,
0.09806954115629196,
-0.15508867800235748,
-0.4823264181613922,
0.6576140522956848,
-0.7250539064407349,
0.4998406767845154,
-0.13700930774211884,
-0.23998016119003296,
-0.6527730822563171,
0.1192832812666893,
-0.8956431746482849,
0.9430410265922546,
0.06124718114733696,
-0.918339192867279,
0.5737072229385376,
-0.8808050751686096,
-0.5912721753120422,
0.23711931705474854,
0.05593713000416756,
-0.3385736048221588,
0.3612386882305145,
0.36640894412994385,
0.3348011374473572,
-0.20898394286632538,
0.14388133585453033,
0.14243078231811523,
-0.09845634549856186,
0.07440578937530518,
-0.23704734444618225,
0.7337441444396973,
0.5072197914123535,
-0.278788298368454,
0.21018949151039124,
-0.8065890073776245,
-0.32780423760414124,
0.36606088280677795,
-0.7515436410903931,
-0.16115087270736694,
-0.00822933204472065,
0.32847678661346436,
0.3562993109226227,
0.41384387016296387,
-0.6396517157554626,
0.09907897561788559,
-0.3782784044742584,
0.15016873180866241,
0.15273474156856537,
-0.14894120395183563,
0.5737969279289246,
0.017554696649312973,
0.6488576531410217,
0.20963656902313232,
0.04061300680041313,
-0.11544259637594223,
-0.46737030148506165,
-1.3565940856933594,
-0.05426667630672455,
0.0861627459526062,
0.47052454948425293,
-0.9192862510681152,
0.17554053664207458,
-0.07730571180582047,
-0.1831681877374649,
-1.1743249893188477,
0.26166048645973206,
0.3313485085964203,
0.15147867798805237,
0.408671110868454,
-0.21384930610656738,
-0.6932938694953918,
-0.8488717079162598,
-0.38539937138557434,
0.002158736577257514,
-0.10683655738830566,
0.050291918218135834,
0.30570361018180847,
-0.5406083464622498,
0.703960657119751,
0.1010536476969719,
-0.17817136645317078,
-1.1152381896972656,
0.23289528489112854,
0.378685861825943,
0.43050023913383484,
0.16714704036712646,
-0.5583397746086121,
-0.2865853011608124,
0.1286468654870987,
-0.6823313236236572,
0.17915129661560059,
-0.14333871006965637,
-0.25548094511032104,
0.34522268176078796,
0.2999604344367981,
-0.7564501762390137,
0.32535800337791443,
0.568261981010437,
-0.8503307104110718,
0.22687862813472748,
-0.2569960653781891,
0.03735470771789551,
-1.4465676546096802,
0.09449788928031921,
-0.11661842465400696,
-0.24529516696929932,
-1.0220515727996826,
0.2981165945529938,
-0.1364521086215973,
-0.18986934423446655,
-0.528379499912262,
0.4381570816040039,
-0.640630841255188,
-0.23347574472427368,
-0.41996243596076965,
-0.09336496144533157,
0.08903778344392776,
0.3452776372432709,
0.47827082872390747,
0.7084790468215942,
0.2366117388010025,
-0.6469538807868958,
0.14213639497756958,
0.38133928179740906,
-0.545494019985199,
0.24517479538917542,
-0.3889347314834595,
0.4791971743106842,
-0.27652227878570557,
-0.12102577090263367,
-0.37965232133865356,
-0.11906599253416061,
0.06423414498567581,
-0.296988308429718,
0.48644572496414185,
-0.16528664529323578,
-0.278387188911438,
-0.27632683515548706,
0.07949373126029968,
0.686215341091156,
0.5026634931564331,
-0.8850235342979431,
0.9739737510681152,
0.3501652181148529,
-0.15273645520210266,
-0.4481658935546875,
-0.4218439757823944,
0.06734447181224823,
-0.2158265858888626,
-0.6981947422027588,
0.14702008664608002,
0.2819350063800812,
-0.40656158328056335,
-0.1911468356847763,
0.3244703412055969,
-0.030709149315953255,
-0.1119278073310852,
0.038668692111968994,
-0.011955219320952892,
-0.41199228167533875,
-0.011667490936815739,
0.07196247577667236,
-0.11832915991544724,
-0.0051103634759783745,
-0.3885989189147949,
0.7758930921554565,
-0.3328290581703186,
-0.20143352448940277,
-0.3966418504714966,
0.5360341668128967,
0.5460869073867798,
-0.6595460772514343,
1.1145236492156982,
0.7777511477470398,
-0.49307775497436523,
-0.0806334838271141,
-0.5838639140129089,
-0.1551038920879364,
-0.4607137441635132,
0.43721532821655273,
-0.5954975485801697,
-0.6261041760444641,
0.4689377546310425,
-0.015266286209225655,
0.3202468156814575,
0.5685938596725464,
0.7329443693161011,
-0.04760713875293732,
1.019482135772705,
1.1158154010772705,
0.013658254407346249,
0.38723307847976685,
-0.25462669134140015,
0.34458959102630615,
-0.8544658422470093,
-0.5110076665878296,
-0.575398862361908,
0.09245695173740387,
-0.5625889897346497,
-0.408745139837265,
0.006003010552376509,
0.25838491320610046,
-0.24928246438503265,
0.21615459024906158,
-0.36652496457099915,
0.2916160225868225,
0.6106613874435425,
-0.09879874438047409,
0.4466732442378998,
0.052504848688840866,
0.3057713508605957,
0.18444031476974487,
-0.971244752407074,
-0.9950858354568481,
1.0274624824523926,
0.5107184648513794,
0.6266447305679321,
0.20513172447681427,
0.7455412149429321,
0.11865979433059692,
0.19951306283473969,
-0.6985516548156738,
0.2421145737171173,
-0.21341869235038757,
-0.5000508427619934,
-0.29549822211265564,
-0.09324227273464203,
-1.077059030532837,
0.34499943256378174,
-0.36507099866867065,
-0.4688037633895874,
0.19601765275001526,
0.09858887642621994,
-0.17683696746826172,
0.3198232650756836,
-0.5220286250114441,
1.1169824600219727,
-0.049208562821149826,
-0.12064289301633835,
-0.5474316477775574,
-0.004562508314847946,
0.36417049169540405,
0.24233750998973846,
0.37183627486228943,
0.1347157061100006,
0.366638720035553,
0.9635990262031555,
-0.24386252462863922,
0.46948495507240295,
-0.2593913674354553,
-0.14499253034591675,
0.5134914517402649,
0.2934413552284241,
0.499677836894989,
0.14944544434547424,
-0.06907065212726593,
-0.04794526845216751,
0.09503541886806488,
-0.6201794147491455,
-0.3691920340061188,
0.3351238965988159,
-0.8009095788002014,
-0.38892167806625366,
-0.4136255979537964,
-0.3256876766681671,
-0.07806087285280228,
0.11426457017660141,
0.4611574709415436,
0.34015119075775146,
-0.492183655500412,
-0.06348636746406555,
0.590552568435669,
-0.32087668776512146,
0.49205130338668823,
0.6834646463394165,
-0.22734445333480835,
-0.0016955938190221786,
0.8299490213394165,
-0.38747939467430115,
-0.039765652269124985,
0.19618695974349976,
-0.1328805834054947,
-0.35577279329299927,
-0.6269745826721191,
-0.7590652704238892,
0.34796783328056335,
-0.5556625723838806,
-0.043394725769758224,
-0.6385175585746765,
-0.08840357512235641,
-0.45831161737442017,
-0.04565294831991196,
-0.6378691792488098,
-0.16854365170001984,
-0.3841775357723236,
-0.2949444353580475,
0.1936628669500351,
1.2871067523956299,
-0.04638222977519035,
0.28561532497406006,
-0.5608205199241638,
0.5170210003852844,
0.5218353867530823,
0.26905032992362976,
-0.025018004700541496,
-0.7948627471923828,
-0.5148921012878418,
-0.07448307424783707,
-0.07817289233207703,
-0.9569819569587708,
0.5563509464263916,
0.23316951096057892,
0.3943178653717041,
0.543354868888855,
-0.11858118325471878,
0.07733648270368576,
-0.48993128538131714,
0.5976969599723816,
0.10644259303808212,
-0.9196532368659973,
0.49709534645080566,
-0.0878647044301033,
0.7415531277656555,
0.5836054086685181,
0.03470609709620476,
-0.7026752829551697,
-0.2951454222202301,
-0.33076590299606323,
-0.7181383371353149,
0.8574082851409912,
0.2614123225212097,
0.2541046738624573,
0.11685747653245926,
0.30253010988235474,
0.534406840801239,
-0.07918395102024078,
-0.9625762104988098,
-0.029836516827344894,
-0.6436310410499573,
-0.44839879870414734,
-0.054873932152986526,
-0.7333377003669739,
0.09529897570610046,
-0.1227872222661972,
0.9728593826293945,
-0.15332600474357605,
0.38209041953086853,
-0.0917426198720932,
-0.496924489736557,
-0.16821281611919403,
0.6360871195793152,
0.30592888593673706,
0.6627918481826782,
-0.1289222538471222,
0.2092401683330536,
0.3551618158817291,
-0.8053088784217834,
0.0805678516626358,
0.1976945400238037,
-0.2281097024679184,
-0.09563244879245758,
0.6629969477653503,
1.0766857862472534,
-0.16632717847824097,
-0.4222119450569153,
0.16011224687099457,
-0.34172719717025757,
0.20131458342075348,
-0.32654836773872375,
-0.20572085678577423,
0.21307705342769623,
0.2584969997406006,
0.4451686441898346,
-0.4864499568939209,
0.14440995454788208,
-0.5220947861671448,
-0.022812137380242348,
0.3532271683216095,
-0.25813958048820496,
-0.5653747320175171,
0.3537796437740326,
0.4674568772315979,
-0.36599501967430115,
0.6842561364173889,
-0.40534108877182007,
-0.44034814834594727,
0.307015061378479,
0.7755270004272461,
1.1874743700027466,
-0.30056145787239075,
0.4824816882610321,
0.3658803701400757,
0.4796381890773773,
0.2788982689380646,
0.7334835529327393,
-0.048941515386104584,
-0.9845203757286072,
-0.5810534954071045,
-1.1627726554870605,
-0.2365800142288208,
0.6139107942581177,
-0.9030747413635254,
-0.02614639885723591,
-0.22598187625408173,
-0.00024954555556178093,
-0.20477353036403656,
0.1315551996231079,
-1.0206356048583984,
0.23590107262134552,
0.3452894687652588,
0.9249849915504456,
-0.8280597925186157,
0.8522414565086365,
1.0417863130569458,
-0.3819621801376343,
-0.5066336393356323,
-0.15481896698474884,
-0.5651313066482544,
-0.40084704756736755,
0.5450007915496826,
0.3631187379360199,
-0.3269142806529999,
-0.06082916259765625,
-0.23266378045082092,
-0.7252874970436096,
0.7851186990737915,
0.415738046169281,
-0.36682891845703125,
0.12711270153522491,
0.483211874961853,
0.5083544850349426,
-0.6755338311195374,
0.15779727697372437,
0.9977298974990845,
0.39626264572143555,
-0.2137969583272934,
-0.7310650944709778,
0.01833830215036869,
-0.25992366671562195,
-0.08377189934253693,
-0.04840327054262161,
-0.48522046208381653,
0.7112736105918884,
-0.3436349630355835,
-0.5085402131080627,
-0.1684623509645462,
1.141810655593872,
0.10555907338857651,
0.27076005935668945,
0.39798808097839355,
0.6492063999176025,
0.3612777292728424,
0.034342311322689056,
0.894778847694397,
-0.3021447956562042,
-0.012442304752767086,
0.9615800976753235,
0.0673973336815834,
0.8334515690803528,
0.4732942581176758,
-0.24180780351161957,
0.6841021180152893,
0.7378420829772949,
0.725098729133606,
0.6000673770904541,
-0.26867952942848206,
-0.5644485354423523,
-0.6866002678871155,
-0.12152956426143646,
-0.3264874219894409,
0.8153414130210876,
0.3171623647212982,
-0.16159386932849884,
-0.08738388866186142,
0.1458279937505722,
-0.040993716567754745,
0.09379827231168747,
-0.4440387785434723,
1.04853355884552,
0.09339682012796402,
-0.5360648036003113,
0.5050344467163086,
0.3264620006084442,
0.5954625606536865,
-0.31030017137527466,
-0.012124812230467796,
-0.519725501537323,
0.26609066128730774,
-0.11284732073545456,
-0.43245986104011536,
0.3599684536457062,
0.2178775519132614,
-0.24947921931743622,
0.021885301917791367,
0.7660934925079346,
-0.6211913228034973,
-0.9089152216911316,
0.43013903498649597,
0.6481385827064514,
-0.045684561133384705,
-0.13072094321250916,
-0.4873913824558258,
0.030914125964045525,
-0.020798129960894585,
-0.42655691504478455,
0.19667573273181915,
0.2893994450569153,
0.13281852006912231,
0.5686208009719849,
0.5111191868782043,
-0.14648592472076416,
0.2288069874048233,
0.19112616777420044,
0.6698589324951172,
-0.642690896987915,
-0.5480263233184814,
-0.525892436504364,
0.35587239265441895,
0.21849693357944489,
-0.23267631232738495,
0.37231844663619995,
0.38913553953170776,
0.7800472974777222,
-0.26966190338134766,
0.8271051645278931,
0.085353322327137,
0.3979083299636841,
-0.7333080768585205,
0.8742699027061462,
-0.4189157783985138,
-0.1755082905292511,
0.1320652961730957,
-1.1696275472640991,
0.18677197396755219,
0.6635718941688538,
-0.1089954599738121,
-0.15518517792224884,
0.27206680178642273,
0.39454296231269836,
-0.1950707584619522,
-0.008306152187287807,
0.1540861576795578,
0.10473190993070602,
0.3479025363922119,
0.6310332417488098,
0.7393265962600708,
-0.2758781611919403,
0.3141680359840393,
-0.21943046152591705,
-0.33495959639549255,
-0.13601389527320862,
-0.6616390347480774,
-1.226543664932251,
-0.7316941618919373,
0.025711841881275177,
-0.20316806435585022,
-0.018794983625411987,
0.9298745393753052,
0.6712361574172974,
-1.2378755807876587,
-0.3602677285671234,
-0.28587037324905396,
0.05470274016261101,
-0.21153564751148224,
-0.19764013588428497,
0.2829609513282776,
-0.5378240942955017,
-0.842149555683136,
0.7829859852790833,
0.1834516078233719,
0.04549381509423256,
-0.590580403804779,
-0.37260448932647705,
-0.3253697454929352,
0.45012059807777405,
0.7210460305213928,
0.5549209713935852,
-0.6849777102470398,
-0.0606757253408432,
-0.17196035385131836,
0.1282276213169098,
-0.1529146432876587,
0.9826159477233887,
-1.0707828998565674,
0.6711586713790894,
0.5023159980773926,
0.7091547250747681,
0.8411514759063721,
-0.1325928121805191,
0.9539335370063782,
-0.3495780825614929,
0.4800063371658325,
0.013839530758559704,
0.49845120310783386,
0.7826893925666809,
-0.4395122826099396,
0.31391623616218567,
-0.17049357295036316,
-0.16211847960948944,
-0.6371446847915649,
0.4041137397289276,
-0.5405341386795044,
-0.1485612392425537,
1.1203302145004272,
-0.05122975632548332,
-0.1682002693414688,
-0.24273861944675446,
-0.11384028196334839,
0.7440263032913208,
-0.2893790900707245,
0.9045937061309814,
0.4106958508491516,
-0.1533733308315277,
-0.3675016760826111,
-0.42948585748672485,
0.8145537376403809,
0.5791655778884888,
-0.9402428269386292,
0.09365492314100266,
0.3189786672592163,
-0.022869370877742767,
0.13060498237609863,
0.5287625789642334,
0.0626099556684494,
0.22189053893089294,
-0.13041095435619354,
0.3162907660007477,
-0.23341624438762665,
-0.5722680687904358,
-0.5378361344337463,
0.008791257627308369,
0.4062579572200775,
-0.32350367307662964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14367v1 | Genie: Achieving Human Parity in Content-Grounded Datasets Generation | 2024-01-25T18:14:57 | 2024-01-25T18:14:57 | Asaf Yehudai, Boaz Carmeli, Yosi Mass, Ofir Arviv, Nathaniel Mills, Assaf Toledo, Eyal Shnarch, Leshem Choshen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The lack of high-quality data for content-grounded generation tasks has been
identified as a major obstacle to advancing these tasks. To address this gap,
we propose Genie, a novel method for automatically generating high-quality
content-grounded data. It consists of three stages: (a) Content Preparation,
(b) Generation: creating task-specific examples from the content (e.g.,
question-answer pairs or summaries). (c) Filtering mechanism aiming to ensure
the quality and faithfulness of the generated data. We showcase this
methodology by generating three large-scale synthetic data, making wishes, for
Long-Form Question-Answering (LFQA), summarization, and information extraction.
In a human evaluation, our generated data was found to be natural and of high
quality. Furthermore, we compare models trained on our data with models trained
on human-written data -- ELI5 and ASQA for LFQA and CNN-DailyMail for
Summarization. We show that our models are on par with or outperforming models
trained on human-generated data and consistently outperforming them in
faithfulness. Finally, we applied our method to create LFQA data within the
medical domain and compared a model trained on it with models trained on other
domains. | [
-0.5117291808128357,
-0.7241257429122925,
0.3082122206687927,
0.1578591763973236,
-0.3507527709007263,
0.02065300941467285,
0.0967273935675621,
-0.14872612059116364,
0.2730012834072113,
0.9866288304328918,
-0.7325903177261353,
-0.5568888783454895,
-0.3355795443058014,
0.33429011702537537,
-0.5990005731582642,
1.20371675491333,
0.2623633146286011,
0.08635620772838593,
-0.5836740732192993,
0.10168927907943726,
-0.672674834728241,
-0.361526221036911,
-0.2679286599159241,
-0.24227316677570343,
0.1754215955734253,
0.6455917358398438,
0.9392258524894714,
0.5556932091712952,
0.30045121908187866,
0.12201309204101562,
0.2735748887062073,
0.5881696343421936,
-0.7205547094345093,
0.2582002580165863,
-0.5032035112380981,
-0.11591283231973648,
-0.5298519730567932,
0.12632375955581665,
0.4077071249485016,
1.052639126777649,
-0.07234296947717667,
0.33924251794815063,
0.18743930757045746,
1.042266845703125,
-0.3802960216999054,
-0.032565630972385406,
-0.5741012692451477,
0.18350499868392944,
0.07027269899845123,
-0.1256372332572937,
-0.2531764805316925,
-0.5658356547355652,
-0.12991434335708618,
-0.7628379464149475,
0.7603774666786194,
0.1143777072429657,
1.0285917520523071,
0.2156100571155548,
-0.5118219256401062,
-0.24935024976730347,
-0.5236856937408447,
0.760818600654602,
-0.4449459910392761,
0.25628867745399475,
0.49752697348594666,
0.3760606348514557,
-0.40699025988578796,
-0.6744315028190613,
-0.8832308650016785,
0.13102219998836517,
0.2592407166957855,
0.2841808497905731,
0.45509275794029236,
-0.06266451627016068,
0.32783129811286926,
0.38878005743026733,
-0.555431067943573,
-0.6582311987876892,
-0.3622743487358093,
-0.03679214045405388,
0.8457106351852417,
0.2727676033973694,
0.3277638256549835,
-0.6604687571525574,
-0.12629586458206177,
-0.08634714037179947,
-0.9958852529525757,
0.0379459448158741,
0.27450618147850037,
0.14241112768650055,
0.3081659972667694,
1.0692663192749023,
-0.7331841588020325,
0.8117727637290955,
0.14040601253509521,
-0.26471465826034546,
0.06094164028763771,
-0.61905437707901,
-0.032714083790779114,
0.010805508121848106,
0.5085052251815796,
0.5703344345092773,
0.27018818259239197,
0.020536959171295166,
-0.3921559751033783,
0.011720412410795689,
0.5905313491821289,
-0.7378183603286743,
-0.3179393708705902,
0.2798839211463928,
-0.6748186349868774,
-0.46878767013549805,
0.21017420291900635,
-0.5896878242492676,
-0.5557857751846313,
-0.7344714999198914,
0.3958940804004669,
-0.3614775538444519,
-0.17415307462215424,
0.2858518362045288,
-0.06903813034296036,
0.07461129128932953,
0.3582688570022583,
-0.5944221615791321,
0.4730340540409088,
0.7877033948898315,
0.479467511177063,
-0.2742592692375183,
-0.019557874649763107,
-0.7034797668457031,
0.17441079020500183,
-0.5359583497047424,
0.6160320043563843,
-0.04991213604807854,
-0.20222218334674835,
-0.004959568381309509,
-0.048689793795347214,
0.38709190487861633,
-0.7105202078819275,
0.7956411242485046,
-0.43900784850120544,
0.32774418592453003,
-0.4744222164154053,
-0.6280192136764526,
-0.012627297081053257,
0.24774746596813202,
-0.653007447719574,
0.8893547654151917,
0.40282031893730164,
-0.7392200231552124,
0.6575760245323181,
-0.3643171191215515,
-0.5261223912239075,
-0.09441453218460083,
-0.20786409080028534,
-0.5338489413261414,
0.17322339117527008,
0.5662162899971008,
0.6717615723609924,
-0.7409446239471436,
0.9658999443054199,
0.15677474439144135,
-0.24555671215057373,
0.2511683702468872,
-0.3523487150669098,
0.7211620807647705,
0.23581354320049286,
-0.14725734293460846,
-0.21100972592830658,
-0.9431284666061401,
0.07704465091228485,
0.23213261365890503,
-0.21581454575061798,
-0.06402742117643356,
0.3802364766597748,
-0.11480532586574554,
0.5943868160247803,
-0.04275904595851898,
-0.7084053158760071,
0.15329566597938538,
-0.514729380607605,
0.11003656685352325,
0.36922749876976013,
0.3228697180747986,
0.06591060757637024,
-0.7914762496948242,
0.35181576013565063,
0.2065560519695282,
0.20768141746520996,
-0.19107413291931152,
-0.6745006442070007,
-0.7428187727928162,
-0.040002595633268356,
0.3016819655895233,
0.30170637369155884,
-1.0427135229110718,
0.7383290529251099,
-0.6570937037467957,
-0.2583247125148773,
-0.663024365901947,
0.24564796686172485,
0.44378364086151123,
0.9236480593681335,
0.5108436942100525,
-0.5365022420883179,
-0.46711215376853943,
-0.8490723967552185,
-0.13939806818962097,
0.14575690031051636,
-0.3757614493370056,
0.4040217101573944,
0.42867401242256165,
-0.02920108288526535,
1.4008527994155884,
-0.6459758877754211,
-0.28046953678131104,
-0.36307913064956665,
0.289875864982605,
0.5297638773918152,
0.7012848258018494,
0.24030378460884094,
-1.049123764038086,
-0.3544142246246338,
-0.42642030119895935,
-0.920958936214447,
-0.09266963601112366,
-0.31629979610443115,
-0.4118667542934418,
-0.14513257145881653,
-0.059356141835451126,
-0.5709270238876343,
0.37188148498535156,
0.22215867042541504,
-0.37453800439834595,
0.47259148955345154,
-0.030047016218304634,
0.31856048107147217,
-1.3538576364517212,
0.08585012704133987,
-0.31400030851364136,
-0.47968408465385437,
-0.6345511674880981,
-0.18674951791763306,
0.04325329139828682,
-0.6018121242523193,
-0.46103551983833313,
0.495670884847641,
-0.29601988196372986,
-0.2444075644016266,
-0.1609082818031311,
-0.12997426092624664,
0.5777259469032288,
0.24577851593494415,
0.11206620186567307,
0.8231674432754517,
0.3666042983531952,
-0.5322235226631165,
0.4096270501613617,
0.7073163390159607,
-0.2779528796672821,
0.6256022453308105,
-0.9385352730751038,
0.06475600600242615,
-0.3287477493286133,
0.21818935871124268,
-0.7576817274093628,
-0.8044790625572205,
0.09452934563159943,
-0.6101099848747253,
-0.004923367407172918,
-0.08661208301782608,
-0.5464160442352295,
-0.34593069553375244,
-0.30358004570007324,
0.44352081418037415,
0.9267866611480713,
-0.5736802220344543,
0.3638143837451935,
0.4326859712600708,
-0.29798948764801025,
-0.4021435081958771,
-0.280971884727478,
0.34119364619255066,
0.15765179693698883,
-1.0172988176345825,
0.4362424910068512,
0.12989644706249237,
0.008726907894015312,
-0.07497633993625641,
0.04105379804968834,
-0.20730504393577576,
-0.022579466924071312,
0.2626453936100006,
0.16268391907215118,
-0.002150869695469737,
0.00816092174500227,
0.37373876571655273,
0.07217025011777878,
0.3046126663684845,
-0.38662341237068176,
0.4272339940071106,
0.4176073372364044,
-0.40751007199287415,
-0.42744094133377075,
0.7320655584335327,
0.3280569314956665,
-0.2466743439435959,
0.6664829254150391,
0.28597068786621094,
-0.5369539856910706,
-0.3331419825553894,
-0.46201446652412415,
-0.18374912440776825,
-0.42536619305610657,
-0.09007927775382996,
-0.25540095567703247,
-0.18299275636672974,
0.28683051466941833,
0.08702585846185684,
0.10390866547822952,
0.40761637687683105,
0.3320009112358093,
-0.07805077731609344,
1.4315211772918701,
0.05576302111148834,
0.33743610978126526,
-0.0413595549762249,
-0.2848610579967499,
0.02310146950185299,
-0.6842498183250427,
-0.13231180608272552,
-0.33897921442985535,
0.08205482363700867,
-0.1892346739768982,
-0.579598605632782,
0.5850961804389954,
0.14976254105567932,
-0.30024200677871704,
0.00212146551348269,
-0.6985714435577393,
0.3747285306453705,
0.7480206489562988,
0.4097304344177246,
0.28440678119659424,
0.021076476201415062,
0.09879133850336075,
-0.09889987856149673,
-0.5846189856529236,
-0.6479521989822388,
1.395519495010376,
0.06519512087106705,
0.8118990659713745,
-0.11147798597812653,
0.8819727897644043,
0.6550313830375671,
0.106594018638134,
-0.43126562237739563,
0.46528154611587524,
-0.1388368159532547,
-0.5776636600494385,
-0.2365281879901886,
-0.3887065649032593,
-0.80176842212677,
-0.07628913223743439,
-0.49654504656791687,
0.09126270562410355,
0.12009193748235703,
0.18916656076908112,
-0.2172054946422577,
-0.16331490874290466,
-0.4062376916408539,
0.5612054467201233,
-0.010335101746022701,
-0.6823156476020813,
0.06248856335878372,
-0.8602610230445862,
0.6290152668952942,
-0.21294726431369781,
0.033459559082984924,
-0.15882864594459534,
0.32961106300354004,
0.628511905670166,
-0.5319346189498901,
0.6706489324569702,
-0.39464062452316284,
-0.040899746119976044,
0.5165830254554749,
0.2233334332704544,
0.48932087421417236,
0.5584841966629028,
-0.16713011264801025,
-0.028979452326893806,
-0.2448023557662964,
-0.6909686326980591,
-0.6428914070129395,
0.4374605119228363,
-0.7462033629417419,
-0.6631738543510437,
-0.4054223895072937,
-0.44639238715171814,
-0.3466487228870392,
0.32482385635375977,
0.16035841405391693,
0.519298255443573,
-0.19125758111476898,
0.22722361981868744,
0.7831039428710938,
-0.5491752624511719,
-0.21646049618721008,
0.21515564620494843,
0.021914852783083916,
-0.6351920962333679,
1.1707051992416382,
-0.06651990115642548,
0.32168594002723694,
0.10745177417993546,
0.12241610884666443,
-0.24424122273921967,
-0.448285847902298,
-0.610430896282196,
0.1322735995054245,
-0.6225762963294983,
-0.4231078624725342,
-0.7124266624450684,
-0.503900408744812,
-0.5982809662818909,
-0.2374744415283203,
-0.349826455116272,
-0.564627468585968,
-0.4248949885368347,
0.1922217309474945,
-0.06550262123346329,
0.7489956617355347,
0.1778344064950943,
-0.14357347786426544,
-1.0307817459106445,
1.1134854555130005,
0.4350564479827881,
0.014692525379359722,
-0.3597920536994934,
-0.2151239812374115,
-0.07775455713272095,
0.5701031684875488,
-0.46537983417510986,
-0.7375497817993164,
0.7112601399421692,
0.5326988101005554,
0.250905305147171,
0.30844831466674805,
0.48977941274642944,
0.4753977954387665,
-0.5549412965774536,
1.1259111166000366,
0.1634480357170105,
-1.0664209127426147,
0.9252840876579285,
-0.4990829825401306,
-0.03909160569310188,
0.6634798645973206,
0.25247806310653687,
-0.41414353251457214,
-0.35219287872314453,
-0.5537005662918091,
-0.8072642087936401,
0.5915189981460571,
0.5176327228546143,
0.16612380743026733,
-0.3553580045700073,
0.583695650100708,
0.5313349962234497,
0.512578010559082,
-0.42141613364219666,
0.2232111245393753,
-0.7570742964744568,
-0.43026596307754517,
0.1121712252497673,
-0.22789543867111206,
-0.28939297795295715,
-0.2754354178905487,
0.5114937424659729,
-0.4399511218070984,
0.34082648158073425,
0.4925592243671417,
-0.18854208290576935,
-0.033189188688993454,
-0.0215779859572649,
0.3627411425113678,
0.7561187744140625,
-0.10201991349458694,
0.03663131222128868,
-0.1708873212337494,
-0.42840835452079773,
0.3223082423210144,
-0.23347604274749756,
-0.39523592591285706,
0.028036542236804962,
0.29133227467536926,
0.41309797763824463,
-0.20909984409809113,
-0.9032627940177917,
0.8549038171768188,
-0.14093820750713348,
-0.2267482727766037,
-0.4190295934677124,
0.4087834656238556,
-0.13841824233531952,
-0.2385321408510208,
0.32000139355659485,
-0.09793493151664734,
0.27355825901031494,
-0.3329117000102997,
0.38858675956726074,
0.17113815248012543,
-0.008579661138355732,
-0.23266254365444183,
0.8572517037391663,
0.3896510601043701,
-0.03851434588432312,
1.0037106275558472,
-0.2055322527885437,
-0.22400091588497162,
0.7072356343269348,
0.61542809009552,
0.5958295464515686,
0.09303183108568192,
0.5461784601211548,
0.48580315709114075,
-0.24781782925128937,
-0.3131047785282135,
0.7610208988189697,
-0.2137322574853897,
-0.7370941638946533,
-0.4272288680076599,
-0.7106784582138062,
-0.4370758831501007,
-0.3213856816291809,
-0.9499756693840027,
0.2654602825641632,
-0.15465258061885834,
0.029686985537409782,
-0.08803898841142654,
-0.02624797448515892,
-0.7662307620048523,
0.659891664981842,
-0.20642152428627014,
0.7781444787979126,
-0.9059358835220337,
0.6860195398330688,
0.383311927318573,
-0.5642004013061523,
-0.6523480415344238,
0.08976096659898758,
-0.3421509265899658,
-0.6630533933639526,
0.8022320866584778,
0.14273907244205475,
0.28571608662605286,
0.08996763825416565,
-0.5105711221694946,
-0.801493227481842,
1.0655032396316528,
0.25535139441490173,
-0.28995075821876526,
-0.17647865414619446,
0.586702823638916,
0.4637143909931183,
-0.39212164282798767,
-0.15711680054664612,
0.418590247631073,
0.25070080161094666,
0.011651789769530296,
-0.46388474106788635,
0.1513834297657013,
-0.3563069999217987,
0.0008774931775406003,
0.04978853091597557,
-0.25735291838645935,
0.9447596669197083,
-0.11941905319690704,
-0.1344854235649109,
0.03651811182498932,
0.6300356388092041,
0.3310391306877136,
0.22818762063980103,
0.4627150595188141,
0.32606637477874756,
0.7079457640647888,
-0.1674969494342804,
1.114243745803833,
-0.46503105759620667,
0.22117368876934052,
0.881430983543396,
-0.6413497924804688,
0.3405807316303253,
0.3055260479450226,
0.032476600259542465,
0.08561810851097107,
0.4746165871620178,
0.005492535885423422,
0.45847025513648987,
0.33117517828941345,
-0.33954933285713196,
-0.44836193323135376,
-0.4658030867576599,
-0.28489676117897034,
0.3299112319946289,
0.3254898488521576,
-0.41868484020233154,
-0.028819095343351364,
0.247771754860878,
-0.2151130586862564,
0.21484658122062683,
-0.12133335322141647,
0.9702252149581909,
-0.2053334265947342,
-1.1709223985671997,
0.8734610676765442,
-0.01911954954266548,
0.09094773232936859,
-0.1934172362089157,
-0.45355337858200073,
-0.3642297685146332,
-0.19609738886356354,
-0.21182532608509064,
-1.0286396741867065,
0.36409616470336914,
0.08963658660650253,
-0.29900580644607544,
-0.34746527671813965,
0.8534586429595947,
-0.32854947447776794,
-0.5858626961708069,
-0.3017446994781494,
0.7028236389160156,
0.04113694280385971,
-0.13192349672317505,
-0.43374770879745483,
-0.3728940188884735,
-0.11286034435033798,
-0.2830469012260437,
0.17689214646816254,
0.5117256045341492,
-0.19780656695365906,
0.6104857921600342,
0.9173288941383362,
0.29016488790512085,
-0.0739336609840393,
0.09049996733665466,
1.103461742401123,
-0.7943829894065857,
-0.509239912033081,
-0.219573512673378,
0.5227974057197571,
-0.4748539626598358,
-0.30064645409584045,
0.40851980447769165,
0.6552545428276062,
0.5704939961433411,
-0.21639074385166168,
0.8641893863677979,
-0.21762369573116302,
0.8572100400924683,
-0.6342610120773315,
0.7221652865409851,
-0.514594554901123,
0.09342152625322342,
-0.2509036362171173,
-0.9468426704406738,
-0.28935736417770386,
0.3713243901729584,
0.2309975028038025,
-0.22008921205997467,
0.4142301380634308,
0.784339189529419,
-0.20845440030097961,
-0.0835590735077858,
0.34327906370162964,
-0.1615358144044876,
0.6888921856880188,
0.47197261452674866,
0.8443544507026672,
-0.4287465512752533,
0.09633703529834747,
-0.4085804522037506,
-0.1118699237704277,
-0.06404837220907211,
-0.7951536774635315,
-1.0078039169311523,
-0.5737035870552063,
-0.042581815272569656,
-0.6223260760307312,
0.31649675965309143,
1.2298628091812134,
0.846443772315979,
-0.7986697554588318,
0.16181468963623047,
-0.5123836994171143,
0.1007586196064949,
-0.2121746838092804,
-0.2528277039527893,
0.4265310764312744,
-0.3185516595840454,
-0.6300001740455627,
0.2967793941497803,
-0.06705839931964874,
-0.05267444625496864,
-0.3044205605983734,
-0.05909841135144234,
0.1079978495836258,
0.21646790206432343,
0.5403128266334534,
0.05499802902340889,
-0.45300155878067017,
-0.40293440222740173,
0.06800193339586258,
-0.184806227684021,
0.176002636551857,
0.8399473428726196,
-1.0164884328842163,
0.5290412902832031,
0.5970341563224792,
0.7625361680984497,
0.17242085933685303,
0.6501414775848389,
0.8213736414909363,
-1.0230296850204468,
-0.13108773529529572,
0.6246377229690552,
0.16347771883010864,
0.4105893671512604,
-0.5934739708900452,
0.5111358761787415,
0.08921981602907181,
-0.6616418361663818,
-0.7699820399284363,
0.22643452882766724,
-0.8375852704048157,
-0.09647615253925323,
1.098245620727539,
-0.12433835864067078,
-0.13408732414245605,
-0.4698917865753174,
-0.5159289836883545,
0.31347474455833435,
-0.23843583464622498,
1.1417163610458374,
0.38860470056533813,
-0.1592624932527542,
0.31650158762931824,
-0.5133500695228577,
0.6936337947845459,
0.3739447295665741,
-1.022010326385498,
0.11165603250265121,
0.6861093044281006,
0.2487894743680954,
-0.10534690320491791,
0.4771127998828888,
-0.1103905513882637,
0.5573723912239075,
-0.040042027831077576,
0.23199039697647095,
-0.2477511316537857,
-0.5245639085769653,
0.10442959517240524,
0.3709690272808075,
-0.08298281580209732,
0.06805050373077393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14360v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14360v2 | A Comparative Analysis of Noise Reduction Methods in Sentiment Analysis on Noisy Bangla Texts | 2024-01-25T18:06:19 | 2024-01-29T19:22:20 | Kazi Toufique Elahi, Tasnuva Binte Rahman, Shakil Shahriar, Samir Sarker, Md. Tanvir Rouf Shawon, G. M. Shahariar | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 (Primary), I.2.7 | While Bangla is considered a language with limited resources, sentiment
analysis has been a subject of extensive research in the literature.
Nevertheless, there is a scarcity of exploration into sentiment analysis
specifically in the realm of noisy Bangla texts. In this paper, we introduce a
dataset (NC-SentNoB) that we annotated manually to identify ten different types
of noise found in a pre-existing sentiment analysis dataset comprising of
around 15K noisy Bangla texts. At first, given an input noisy text, we identify
the noise type, addressing this as a multi-label classification task. Then, we
introduce baseline noise reduction methods to alleviate noise prior to
conducting sentiment analysis. Finally, we assess the performance of fine-tuned
sentiment analysis models with both noisy and noise-reduced texts to make
comparisons. The experimental findings indicate that the noise reduction
methods utilized are not satisfactory, highlighting the need for more suitable
noise reduction methods in future research endeavors. We have made the
implementation and dataset presented in this paper publicly available at
https://github.com/ktoufiquee/A-Comparative-Analysis-of-Noise-Reduction-Methods-in-Sentiment-Analysis-on-Noisy-Bangla-Texts | [
-0.5160744786262512,
-0.5033999681472778,
-0.10564722120761871,
0.6556427478790283,
-0.4050177037715912,
0.06413081288337708,
-0.39942076802253723,
-0.5752511620521545,
0.0797167420387268,
0.2717124819755554,
-0.5101203918457031,
-0.5835700631141663,
-0.34990179538726807,
0.48105430603027344,
-0.250164270401001,
1.1303261518478394,
0.3077704906463623,
0.24014058709144592,
-0.07741187512874603,
0.10661127418279648,
-0.32739925384521484,
-0.14689666032791138,
-0.36510220170021057,
-0.1933116912841797,
0.5617040991783142,
-0.09024234861135483,
0.3232324421405792,
-0.29995205998420715,
0.7844110131263733,
0.2030356079339981,
-0.8232437968254089,
0.40805184841156006,
-0.6183552742004395,
0.3240598738193512,
0.033593371510505676,
-0.1283261775970459,
-0.1747817099094391,
-0.14358410239219666,
0.7100319862365723,
0.6393207907676697,
0.4123072326183319,
0.4030245542526245,
0.20521284639835358,
0.7623282074928284,
-0.9230750799179077,
0.4677514433860779,
-0.2977807819843292,
0.16279827058315277,
-0.4893375039100647,
0.03659607470035553,
-0.5762774348258972,
-0.7711055874824524,
-0.19381894171237946,
-0.22820110619068146,
-0.221346914768219,
-0.14323583245277405,
0.9342822432518005,
0.4891476035118103,
-0.1402597576379776,
-0.32876700162887573,
-0.6860377192497253,
0.9897333383560181,
-0.8907763361930847,
0.3240775465965271,
0.33490610122680664,
-0.16769887506961823,
0.11730232834815979,
0.014741575345396996,
-0.28211796283721924,
0.1384095847606659,
-0.18685609102249146,
0.415317177772522,
-0.15332375466823578,
-0.04616636410355568,
0.1485118865966797,
0.6936147809028625,
-0.4116055965423584,
-0.03070840612053871,
-0.5903275609016418,
-0.3270008862018585,
0.4217403531074524,
-0.03990818187594414,
-0.19606450200080872,
-0.43329769372940063,
0.12573717534542084,
0.08830281347036362,
-0.33448904752731323,
0.19350482523441315,
0.6178733706474304,
0.5409208536148071,
-0.14834068715572357,
0.2951805889606476,
-0.3458637297153473,
0.9626625180244446,
0.013423232361674309,
-0.6086934208869934,
0.4744417667388916,
-0.48383423686027527,
-0.18832314014434814,
-0.02355264499783516,
0.696706235408783,
0.5698270797729492,
0.34346118569374084,
0.02427724190056324,
-0.10765878111124039,
0.23620487749576569,
0.2888614237308502,
-1.0708932876586914,
-0.3558915853500366,
0.013105074875056744,
-1.1185468435287476,
-0.7683677077293396,
-0.3147623836994171,
-1.054954171180725,
-0.8007575869560242,
-0.10517454147338867,
0.10716450959444046,
-0.11998091638088226,
-0.43741661310195923,
-0.049632783979177475,
-0.029028043150901794,
0.3635467290878296,
0.34601086378097534,
-0.304572194814682,
0.10623186826705933,
0.3607722818851471,
1.0085201263427734,
0.0821509137749672,
0.25622662901878357,
0.06441645324230194,
-0.43794310092926025,
-0.5709767937660217,
1.1309047937393188,
-0.675707221031189,
-0.5916197299957275,
-0.08739365637302399,
-0.5468783378601074,
-0.0924929603934288,
-0.7568670511245728,
0.9331190586090088,
-0.37690192461013794,
0.08561743050813675,
-0.38584455847740173,
-0.4004461169242859,
-0.6930869817733765,
0.1560239940881729,
-0.6033200025558472,
1.027518391609192,
0.27399739623069763,
-1.1816226243972778,
0.4201497435569763,
-0.4946615993976593,
-0.557008683681488,
-0.29173973202705383,
0.3635931611061096,
-0.7838416695594788,
0.18484430015087128,
0.2629459500312805,
0.4865085780620575,
-0.2364455908536911,
-0.11073055118322372,
-0.3120487630367279,
-0.6498868465423584,
0.582815945148468,
-0.25413092970848083,
0.8605202436447144,
0.6446614265441895,
-0.12601028382778168,
0.00011559436097741127,
-0.9523036479949951,
0.02789972350001335,
-0.2568959593772888,
-0.294573038816452,
-0.4135781228542328,
-0.16713108122348785,
0.34427186846733093,
0.1435023993253708,
0.24920815229415894,
-0.6585950255393982,
0.1471228450536728,
-0.6454771161079407,
0.024431852623820305,
0.49214017391204834,
0.13476932048797607,
0.10400547087192535,
-0.3898029625415802,
0.40916380286216736,
0.13659696280956268,
0.21652080118656158,
0.11847887933254242,
-0.39343616366386414,
-0.7340068817138672,
-0.5794429779052734,
0.4149540066719055,
0.36839213967323303,
-0.1848757266998291,
0.06827978044748306,
-0.0862676128745079,
-0.5080326795578003,
-0.9993959665298462,
0.17125999927520752,
0.3841366469860077,
0.3305545151233673,
0.36370086669921875,
-0.23369775712490082,
-0.9100708365440369,
-0.7451636791229248,
-0.2293226420879364,
-0.3325546383857727,
0.5205854177474976,
-0.02858821302652359,
0.06045883521437645,
-0.27045583724975586,
0.8679065108299255,
-0.2628178000450134,
-0.1728011965751648,
-0.14146170020103455,
0.23712261021137238,
0.16401633620262146,
0.10232511907815933,
0.6238009929656982,
-0.6995400786399841,
-0.5842843651771545,
-0.036022599786520004,
-0.6183452606201172,
-0.6095834970474243,
-0.025439472869038582,
0.2131650745868683,
0.3099464774131775,
0.4550890326499939,
-0.21033143997192383,
0.7913619875907898,
0.5600894689559937,
-0.047663357108831406,
0.8124890923500061,
0.4867153763771057,
0.2866920232772827,
-0.9095621705055237,
0.02588769420981407,
-0.17011089622974396,
-0.08717826753854752,
-0.638780415058136,
-0.26236486434936523,
-0.31755372881889343,
0.07252411544322968,
0.020698517560958862,
0.23668213188648224,
-0.2900319993495941,
0.01795010454952717,
-0.6928198933601379,
-0.28259432315826416,
-0.042082883417606354,
0.22877123951911926,
0.049477290362119675,
0.7861427068710327,
0.5462260246276855,
-0.48753097653388977,
-0.11595961451530457,
0.3856760263442993,
-0.36515119671821594,
0.548577070236206,
-0.3694419264793396,
-0.14917628467082977,
-0.16941779851913452,
0.029698658734560013,
-1.1512160301208496,
0.013384879566729069,
0.6201838254928589,
-0.33727705478668213,
0.04722579941153526,
0.0012253843015059829,
-0.41365545988082886,
-0.35893669724464417,
-0.48768970370292664,
0.20983366668224335,
0.41634830832481384,
-0.28662872314453125,
-0.045456413179636,
0.3033883571624756,
-0.4676000475883484,
-0.5490087270736694,
-0.7601938247680664,
0.02315574325621128,
-0.3970368504524231,
-0.13723471760749817,
-0.07297161966562271,
-0.2793264091014862,
-0.5651779770851135,
-0.16380426287651062,
-0.06238340958952904,
-0.4345323443412781,
-0.05740415304899216,
0.6153537631034851,
0.017303893342614174,
-0.055489879101514816,
0.25762802362442017,
0.2397690862417221,
0.01626129075884819,
0.16072919964790344,
0.23273538053035736,
0.36673808097839355,
-0.40746575593948364,
0.28378826379776,
-0.5603147149085999,
0.19611206650733948,
0.38041961193084717,
0.14534923434257507,
0.7607030272483826,
1.015446424484253,
-0.1404769867658615,
0.11045607924461365,
-0.5205380916595459,
0.15482859313488007,
-0.3704625964164734,
0.1784229576587677,
-0.22681015729904175,
-0.5986887812614441,
0.37581801414489746,
-0.37163105607032776,
-0.07786303013563156,
0.24422354996204376,
0.815246045589447,
-0.1140362098813057,
0.37332966923713684,
0.350823312997818,
-0.27204209566116333,
0.4284474849700928,
0.0279691219329834,
0.6814097762107849,
-0.6053708791732788,
-0.10203028470277786,
-0.8018897771835327,
-0.03617079183459282,
-0.7076622247695923,
-0.19348888099193573,
-0.043665699660778046,
-0.05302950739860535,
-0.08227809518575668,
0.0521249882876873,
-0.7167495489120483,
0.36145105957984924,
0.27432942390441895,
0.05199280008673668,
0.4626617431640625,
0.03637615218758583,
0.2394222468137741,
-0.24848100543022156,
-0.6680428385734558,
-0.4856744110584259,
0.8585677146911621,
0.04898428916931152,
0.5043058395385742,
-0.039893265813589096,
0.7362634539604187,
0.43976232409477234,
0.3315838575363159,
-0.8663758039474487,
0.5310577154159546,
-0.17305491864681244,
-0.47271502017974854,
-0.00760459341108799,
-0.685145378112793,
-0.9378596544265747,
0.26632797718048096,
-0.4516855478286743,
-0.44174376130104065,
0.34613484144210815,
-0.19788025319576263,
-0.3618817925453186,
0.2987426221370697,
-0.5941992402076721,
0.31269848346710205,
0.5400277972221375,
-0.216960608959198,
-0.21520479023456573,
-0.5509428977966309,
0.5049858093261719,
-0.3016436696052551,
0.634779155254364,
-0.11401733011007309,
0.41964057087898254,
0.9200535416603088,
-0.19875302910804749,
0.9530074000358582,
-0.1501878798007965,
-0.3459201455116272,
0.5325728058815002,
-0.15442952513694763,
0.12825468182563782,
-0.30440738797187805,
-0.2965552806854248,
0.28051474690437317,
-0.08948776125907898,
-0.26388710737228394,
-0.24350950121879578,
0.569610595703125,
-0.6399272084236145,
0.34156304597854614,
-0.23122139275074005,
-0.7805818319320679,
-0.040014106780290604,
0.21171626448631287,
0.41496697068214417,
0.43602943420410156,
-0.0002476608788128942,
0.321647584438324,
0.43060940504074097,
-0.19392290711402893,
0.6275330781936646,
0.02856045961380005,
-0.37646380066871643,
-0.35586488246917725,
0.9368677139282227,
0.47826430201530457,
-0.322675883769989,
0.12740667164325714,
0.4207249581813812,
-0.40998777747154236,
-0.7281463742256165,
0.137316033244133,
0.014214524999260902,
-0.68411785364151,
-0.41699713468551636,
-0.5577685236930847,
-0.09891719371080399,
-0.5102530717849731,
-0.24351590871810913,
-0.5174281597137451,
-0.4618925154209137,
-0.12420356273651123,
0.12518514692783356,
0.6465015411376953,
0.7831587195396423,
-0.2726703882217407,
0.5470312833786011,
-0.6447345018386841,
0.34238114953041077,
0.06403514742851257,
0.42313313484191895,
0.037114281207323074,
-0.5575439929962158,
-0.42984604835510254,
-0.2044932246208191,
-0.10159128904342651,
-0.917457103729248,
0.6518967747688293,
0.23884055018424988,
-0.04406397417187691,
0.3965422213077545,
0.375611811876297,
0.8856480717658997,
0.25215715169906616,
0.6140851378440857,
0.07037480175495148,
-0.964412271976471,
0.5508049130439758,
-0.4378783702850342,
0.20396582782268524,
0.7615648508071899,
0.1929015815258026,
-0.0654246136546135,
-0.6003921031951904,
-0.5199722647666931,
-0.7797456383705139,
0.24653390049934387,
0.4870346188545227,
-0.3502763509750366,
0.1787046641111374,
0.27333563566207886,
0.49317875504493713,
0.4614045023918152,
-1.0706907510757446,
-0.3282002806663513,
-0.1866064816713333,
-0.15703630447387695,
0.15715938806533813,
-0.3475750982761383,
0.28694307804107666,
-0.33218345046043396,
0.6655437350273132,
0.37249916791915894,
0.19182099401950836,
0.11901579797267914,
-0.2175760269165039,
0.0680173709988594,
0.5644676685333252,
0.37763291597366333,
0.23069146275520325,
-0.4861788749694824,
-0.12474018335342407,
0.025977319106459618,
-0.7832328677177429,
0.0069523826241493225,
-0.11983480304479599,
-0.7715871930122375,
0.38775143027305603,
0.16105762124061584,
0.6322008967399597,
0.1521875113248825,
-0.40859678387641907,
0.1539873480796814,
0.014338117092847824,
-0.06366612017154694,
-0.04989774525165558,
-0.28159457445144653,
-0.0994175523519516,
0.0528770349919796,
-0.07837827503681183,
0.5038608908653259,
0.6986646056175232,
-0.20848329365253448,
-0.12127437442541122,
0.04263158142566681,
-0.5243856906890869,
-0.15851174294948578,
-0.026242952793836594,
0.2817595303058624,
-0.07552214711904526,
0.35028573870658875,
-0.6774583458900452,
-0.2579197585582733,
0.058917734771966934,
0.36346131563186646,
0.7727140188217163,
-0.10665607452392578,
0.49451687932014465,
0.5723060965538025,
0.3716035485267639,
-0.053988635540008545,
0.29570409655570984,
-0.04089827835559845,
-0.5912377238273621,
-0.7724208235740662,
-0.8182284832000732,
-0.6008886098861694,
0.17958202958106995,
-1.0013689994812012,
-0.03267764672636986,
-0.24812816083431244,
-0.3741630017757416,
-0.171085923910141,
0.33770260214805603,
-0.15529821813106537,
0.17146986722946167,
-0.06542802602052689,
0.0926751047372818,
-0.8204265236854553,
0.3057815432548523,
0.7154892683029175,
-0.1535947620868683,
-0.41619545221328735,
0.26452258229255676,
0.08573218435049057,
-0.08186689019203186,
0.3651357889175415,
0.3392246663570404,
-0.539740800857544,
-0.21627652645111084,
-0.4571390450000763,
-0.3903491199016571,
0.2190321981906891,
0.005067594815045595,
-0.4022239148616791,
0.8322209119796753,
-0.07039222866296768,
0.6945441365242004,
0.07248535007238388,
0.2298414409160614,
0.5995702147483826,
0.8804243803024292,
-0.16736812889575958,
-0.8684074878692627,
-0.15656045079231262,
-0.56393963098526,
-0.32611334323883057,
0.2067328244447708,
-0.982776403427124,
0.7840477824211121,
0.07266172021627426,
0.013552537187933922,
0.0704590454697609,
0.5594709515571594,
0.029399044811725616,
0.6482619643211365,
0.41973385214805603,
0.29618528485298157,
0.9935751557350159,
-0.028360577300190926,
0.5264191627502441,
0.016082776710391045,
0.4392101764678955,
0.9532086849212646,
-0.31668201088905334,
0.6617573499679565,
0.3645505905151367,
-0.4186522662639618,
0.5793035626411438,
0.6835689544677734,
0.06320810317993164,
0.500010073184967,
0.38315463066101074,
-0.33646151423454285,
-0.1930382400751114,
-0.4831748306751251,
-0.44574305415153503,
0.6822128295898438,
0.28598812222480774,
0.0835312008857727,
-0.2721708416938782,
0.14359526336193085,
0.0405130535364151,
0.17869220674037933,
-0.6833563446998596,
0.9321125745773315,
0.01086941547691822,
-0.07989955693483353,
0.5918394327163696,
-0.32482004165649414,
0.9330578446388245,
-0.25291961431503296,
0.25018858909606934,
-0.16624334454536438,
0.14616550505161285,
-0.34935110807418823,
-0.5083873271942139,
0.8924973011016846,
0.23611941933631897,
-0.4352383315563202,
-0.055025845766067505,
1.0817903280258179,
-0.13235685229301453,
-0.5560766458511353,
0.25545138120651245,
0.4116319715976715,
0.46764805912971497,
-0.18402454257011414,
-0.5303605198860168,
0.347462922334671,
0.16806697845458984,
-0.1535950005054474,
0.29666152596473694,
0.36652830243110657,
0.22602714598178864,
0.6069253087043762,
0.43205541372299194,
0.4878838360309601,
0.03527854382991791,
0.254974901676178,
0.8355143666267395,
-0.6673555374145508,
-0.5830550789833069,
-0.4871279001235962,
0.0839451476931572,
-0.2161632478237152,
-0.4225444793701172,
1.033325433731079,
0.45065203309059143,
0.4966411292552948,
-0.37393438816070557,
0.8515470623970032,
0.08979404717683792,
0.9579861164093018,
-0.5067905187606812,
0.7183799743652344,
-0.1853598654270172,
0.1667669713497162,
-0.8220349550247192,
-0.869672417640686,
-0.6262596845626831,
1.248915433883667,
-0.35547950863838196,
0.0476420558989048,
0.5783199667930603,
0.9730004072189331,
0.38665544986724854,
0.22326108813285828,
0.15282456576824188,
0.466722697019577,
-0.23701027035713196,
-0.05521715432405472,
1.080690622329712,
-0.5484853982925415,
0.7552224397659302,
-0.5481859445571899,
0.02067924290895462,
-0.4257940351963043,
-0.7527074813842773,
-0.9791598320007324,
-0.29773592948913574,
-0.6222617030143738,
-0.30818143486976624,
0.27995413541793823,
0.6762781143188477,
0.5157843232154846,
-0.9082732200622559,
-0.23494544625282288,
0.1959986388683319,
0.3012770116329193,
-0.3791118562221527,
-0.3220440745353699,
0.35116156935691833,
-0.47731339931488037,
-0.6056661605834961,
0.3706859052181244,
0.2238846868276596,
-0.1937207579612732,
0.11343327909708023,
0.25954580307006836,
0.010185605846345425,
0.24636252224445343,
0.6983948349952698,
0.07079992443323135,
-0.22489887475967407,
-0.0451052263379097,
-0.2637673318386078,
0.161275714635849,
0.2594788670539856,
0.7416494488716125,
-0.5655307769775391,
0.4916175305843353,
0.6966827511787415,
0.15418373048305511,
0.24773363769054413,
0.12527064979076385,
-0.2754379212856293,
-0.81351238489151,
0.46737122535705566,
0.25925037264823914,
0.06500041484832764,
0.36298003792762756,
-0.2660433053970337,
0.4443732798099518,
0.10451160371303558,
-0.6477538347244263,
-0.9087451100349426,
-0.011784039437770844,
-1.3616076707839966,
-0.3825124204158783,
1.281831979751587,
0.006506731733679771,
-0.076896533370018,
-0.6973050236701965,
-0.5536283254623413,
0.1578797549009323,
-0.6899592876434326,
1.0961039066314697,
0.8519877791404724,
-0.08156262338161469,
-0.0751514583826065,
-0.1465579867362976,
0.5004600286483765,
0.3960181176662445,
-0.6292222142219543,
0.21861422061920166,
0.5059091448783875,
-0.29256361722946167,
0.3306235671043396,
0.5172639489173889,
-0.2284776270389557,
0.10050853341817856,
0.23899804055690765,
0.12435061484575272,
0.13491316139698029,
-0.28513774275779724,
-0.3993726372718811,
0.46726101636886597,
0.10171587765216827,
-0.034137096256017685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14295v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14295v3 | Demystifying Chains, Trees, and Graphs of Thoughts | 2024-01-25T16:34:00 | 2024-04-05T11:40:50 | Maciej Besta, Florim Memedi, Zhenyu Zhang, Robert Gerstenberger, Guangyuan Piao, Nils Blach, Piotr Nyczyk, Marcin Copik, Grzegorz Kwaśniewski, Jürgen Müller, Lukas Gianinazzi, Ales Kubicek, Hubert Niewiadomski, Aidan O'Mahony, Onur Mutlu, Torsten Hoefler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The field of natural language processing (NLP) has witnessed significant
progress in recent years, with a notable focus on improving large language
models' (LLM) performance through innovative prompting techniques. Among these,
prompt engineering coupled with structures has emerged as a promising paradigm,
with designs such as Chain-of-Thought, Tree of Thoughts, or Graph of Thoughts,
in which the overall LLM reasoning is guided by a structure such as a graph. As
illustrated with numerous examples, this paradigm significantly enhances the
LLM's capability to solve numerous tasks, ranging from logical or mathematical
reasoning to planning or creative writing. To facilitate the understanding of
this growing field and pave the way for future developments, we devise a
general blueprint for effective and efficient LLM reasoning schemes. For this,
we conduct an in-depth analysis of the prompt execution pipeline, clarifying
and clearly defining different concepts. We then build the first taxonomy of
structure-enhanced LLM reasoning schemes. We focus on identifying fundamental
classes of harnessed structures, and we analyze the representations of these
structures, algorithms executed with these structures, and many others. We
refer to these structures as reasoning topologies, because their representation
becomes to a degree spatial, as they are contained within the LLM context. Our
study compares existing prompting schemes using the proposed taxonomy,
discussing how certain design choices lead to different patterns in performance
and cost. We also outline theoretical underpinnings, relationships between
prompting and other parts of the LLM ecosystem such as knowledge bases, and the
associated research challenges. Our work will help to advance future prompt
engineering techniques. | [
-0.5046947002410889,
-1.066651701927185,
0.688569188117981,
0.2631109654903412,
-0.06692413985729218,
0.3711213767528534,
-0.04998758062720299,
-0.4176677167415619,
0.19695653021335602,
0.344536691904068,
-0.8162887096405029,
-0.5923040509223938,
-0.24025601148605347,
0.30688247084617615,
-0.3340263366699219,
0.7187529802322388,
-0.09617295861244202,
-0.416169673204422,
-0.1051589846611023,
0.04093272238969803,
-0.6404290795326233,
-0.4820055663585663,
-0.6747589707374573,
-0.2907376289367676,
0.8963792324066162,
-0.04863626882433891,
0.6636343002319336,
0.723986029624939,
0.20105591416358948,
0.3397698700428009,
-0.5719972848892212,
0.32604169845581055,
-0.2877109944820404,
0.39548951387405396,
-0.3050804138183594,
-0.27517935633659363,
-0.2965920865535736,
-0.09541510045528412,
0.5800577402114868,
1.0193558931350708,
0.023798327893018723,
0.040745582431554794,
0.2936055660247803,
0.9225536584854126,
-0.4637172520160675,
0.3481338620185852,
-0.6020110845565796,
0.09907051175832748,
-0.07693029195070267,
-0.6607564091682434,
-0.5616065859794617,
-0.4228772521018982,
-0.0035911560989916325,
-0.5982769131660461,
-0.22675548493862152,
0.5245167016983032,
0.6831793189048767,
0.29721567034721375,
-0.26813629269599915,
-0.5952631235122681,
-0.4647858142852783,
0.5246967077255249,
-0.30994051694869995,
0.29604509472846985,
0.13105592131614685,
0.30397072434425354,
-0.423967182636261,
-0.7073355317115784,
-0.22619681060314178,
-0.08531524986028671,
-0.16723477840423584,
-0.06808571517467499,
-0.4475101828575134,
0.5900266766548157,
0.6284581422805786,
0.37238866090774536,
-0.7543236613273621,
0.1495417058467865,
-0.2819086015224457,
-0.1799044907093048,
0.3200214207172394,
0.2028142511844635,
0.5864879488945007,
-0.2766287326812744,
-0.3863860070705414,
0.13859985768795013,
-0.8117111921310425,
0.11558810621500015,
0.36362460255622864,
0.49683627486228943,
-0.038316261023283005,
0.5540685057640076,
-0.5259993076324463,
0.9815738797187805,
-0.09469562023878098,
0.1609330177307129,
-0.016088977456092834,
-0.4632260501384735,
-0.35223084688186646,
0.05784672498703003,
0.6788016557693481,
0.27165108919143677,
0.4607957601547241,
-0.24470333755016327,
-0.19375213980674744,
0.18338488042354584,
0.32640379667282104,
-0.5809852480888367,
-0.28823432326316833,
0.38286492228507996,
-0.38708195090293884,
-0.27168455719947815,
-0.5568047761917114,
-0.38309207558631897,
-0.3582723140716553,
-0.595070481300354,
0.05052217096090317,
-0.47246238589286804,
-0.12264387309551239,
0.1562468409538269,
-0.27363285422325134,
0.15848657488822937,
0.23448003828525543,
-0.919082522392273,
0.21553754806518555,
0.913442850112915,
1.0648800134658813,
0.09218163788318634,
-0.19022317230701447,
-0.2267504632472992,
0.05261525511741638,
-0.39809852838516235,
1.0313975811004639,
-0.5315415263175964,
-0.3220284581184387,
0.04089004173874855,
-0.2806423306465149,
-0.07781266421079636,
-0.2957935333251953,
0.5033881068229675,
-0.5964816212654114,
0.16687598824501038,
-0.6436931490898132,
-0.5371150374412537,
-0.30439576506614685,
0.5494247674942017,
-0.7980415225028992,
0.9653153419494629,
0.027176329866051674,
-1.0941674709320068,
0.13746868073940277,
-0.8933591246604919,
-0.3231535851955414,
0.2840983271598816,
-0.32795384526252747,
0.2615167498588562,
-0.09269779175519943,
0.3217054307460785,
0.18227511644363403,
-0.277466744184494,
0.4396136701107025,
-0.20487739145755768,
-0.24130547046661377,
-0.09813742339611053,
-0.11387640237808228,
1.23354971408844,
0.3033766448497772,
-0.06348393857479095,
0.43617239594459534,
-0.591537594795227,
0.1324024647474289,
-0.13583523035049438,
-0.2231544405221939,
-0.3188876509666443,
0.08114264160394669,
-0.529668390750885,
0.15244582295417786,
0.05762246996164322,
-0.2103237807750702,
0.4985135793685913,
-0.7151472568511963,
0.6808860301971436,
0.8364666700363159,
0.21320270001888275,
0.5864169597625732,
-0.2815396785736084,
0.632975697517395,
-0.19734542071819305,
0.13455930352210999,
-0.5024594664573669,
-0.674258291721344,
-0.5428645610809326,
-0.008182092569768429,
-0.1182483360171318,
0.5183047652244568,
-0.7951725721359253,
0.2582208514213562,
0.13519695401191711,
-0.358443945646286,
-0.2524101138114929,
-0.13598383963108063,
0.31583088636398315,
0.7808668613433838,
0.3516543507575989,
-0.022803256288170815,
-0.8134729266166687,
-0.8021442294120789,
-0.35281503200531006,
-0.47935909032821655,
0.0960550308227539,
0.11005245894193649,
0.38646411895751953,
0.07133052498102188,
1.1401094198226929,
-0.5447105765342712,
0.3301626741886139,
-0.39793500304222107,
0.028443127870559692,
0.667974054813385,
0.22029243409633636,
0.5088260769844055,
-0.42774754762649536,
-0.10324092954397202,
-0.14058606326580048,
-0.8356416821479797,
-0.21897996962070465,
-0.2544870674610138,
-0.5357416272163391,
-0.08957923948764801,
0.43798741698265076,
-0.8569784164428711,
0.1252581626176834,
0.16440649330615997,
-0.4341721832752228,
0.8783975839614868,
0.11500050872564316,
-0.07382193207740784,
-0.8944011926651001,
0.07977437227964401,
-0.17259883880615234,
0.22639133036136627,
-0.6485552787780762,
0.3326011598110199,
-0.2591278553009033,
-0.2169821709394455,
-0.22268621623516083,
0.5543146133422852,
-0.6017972826957703,
-0.15823739767074585,
-0.1540418416261673,
0.1922922134399414,
0.09235265105962753,
0.7215742468833923,
-0.18879173696041107,
0.7754561901092529,
0.8066840767860413,
-0.7560929656028748,
0.39212560653686523,
0.31276869773864746,
-0.3912274241447449,
0.5175421833992004,
-0.7819943428039551,
0.25878435373306274,
-0.3186253309249878,
0.23367847502231598,
-0.9389791488647461,
-0.012715703807771206,
0.3679491877555847,
-0.23720692098140717,
0.06247042864561081,
-0.23269261419773102,
-0.5657815337181091,
-0.6396783590316772,
-0.38298121094703674,
0.09284231066703796,
0.3106829822063446,
-0.5719713568687439,
0.39856448769569397,
0.24961784482002258,
-0.2457568198442459,
-0.5707682371139526,
-0.3758348524570465,
0.248696967959404,
-0.2837826907634735,
-0.7916965484619141,
0.29919305443763733,
-0.13801775872707367,
-0.43751266598701477,
-0.07906042039394379,
-0.027510594576597214,
0.023041335865855217,
0.3907897472381592,
0.2374390959739685,
0.247528076171875,
-0.19366015493869781,
0.31249481439590454,
0.10577282309532166,
-0.17254234850406647,
0.5137268900871277,
-0.7079136967658997,
0.5311894416809082,
-0.2239566594362259,
-0.23990151286125183,
-0.34201955795288086,
0.37543052434921265,
0.26481717824935913,
-0.14773467183113098,
0.4791411757469177,
0.049894507974386215,
-0.4344061613082886,
-0.46103325486183167,
-0.15035299956798553,
-0.18372908234596252,
-0.5405051112174988,
0.04864940792322159,
-0.6178908348083496,
-0.992792546749115,
0.5513362884521484,
-0.3423575758934021,
0.3914559781551361,
0.21696513891220093,
0.4982685148715973,
-0.3156644105911255,
0.8589165210723877,
0.5746504664421082,
-0.039000459015369415,
0.44370245933532715,
-0.3259612023830414,
0.5118078589439392,
-0.7818093299865723,
-0.2914462983608246,
-0.6166276335716248,
-0.4095420837402344,
-0.4457795023918152,
-0.32693344354629517,
0.1985718011856079,
0.4294556975364685,
-0.3533388376235962,
0.38759645819664,
-0.7695174217224121,
0.5966916680335999,
0.4323568344116211,
-0.2743476927280426,
0.32482272386550903,
0.18795223534107208,
-0.6551596522331238,
0.32600611448287964,
-0.8927729725837708,
-0.8364260792732239,
0.5780069231987,
0.2924865186214447,
0.5116457939147949,
-0.21926070749759674,
0.5096268653869629,
0.2053566724061966,
0.044346753507852554,
-0.9701452255249023,
0.8228580355644226,
0.3945188522338867,
-0.47856631875038147,
-0.2736540138721466,
-0.26484251022338867,
-1.1208455562591553,
0.22922353446483612,
0.1281021535396576,
-0.8790549039840698,
0.07179827243089676,
0.25509706139564514,
-0.454176127910614,
0.4898659288883209,
-0.5824328660964966,
0.7450927495956421,
-0.051912494003772736,
-0.0514712817966938,
-0.15178294479846954,
-0.5290498733520508,
0.434220552444458,
0.32767221331596375,
0.21927732229232788,
0.04102684557437897,
0.2052455097436905,
0.5206904411315918,
-0.35919198393821716,
0.9295464754104614,
-0.14616970717906952,
-0.2948462665081024,
0.770178496837616,
0.2395392507314682,
0.5665766596794128,
-0.27902257442474365,
-0.22688470780849457,
-0.009482423774898052,
-0.22603590786457062,
-0.12609128654003143,
-0.760490894317627,
0.49496906995773315,
-0.4518658220767975,
-0.735867977142334,
0.0028591810259968042,
-0.7015054821968079,
-0.19049295783042908,
0.18609632551670074,
0.024283360689878464,
0.7005831599235535,
-0.0017517481464892626,
-0.19063346087932587,
0.5389597415924072,
-0.2631550431251526,
0.5693856477737427,
-0.11069823056459427,
-0.37954989075660706,
-0.20980359613895416,
0.518731415271759,
0.19495569169521332,
0.13447485864162445,
0.45030102133750916,
0.20894880592823029,
-0.5306969285011292,
-0.7773939371109009,
-0.48835575580596924,
0.11750916391611099,
-0.9796125888824463,
-0.08446455746889114,
-0.8230441212654114,
-0.249267116189003,
-0.17418619990348816,
-0.32160627841949463,
0.17724967002868652,
-0.555250346660614,
-0.11727234721183777,
-0.49924030900001526,
0.4929635524749756,
0.8428560495376587,
0.2708297073841095,
0.16757644712924957,
-0.5143564939498901,
0.0699097290635109,
0.17261916399002075,
0.28704410791397095,
0.2892475724220276,
-0.05705137178301811,
-0.1058022603392601,
-0.11653745174407959,
-0.2952248156070709,
-1.0637212991714478,
0.14421391487121582,
-0.1960965245962143,
0.6377601027488708,
0.29558441042900085,
0.069793701171875,
0.6900514364242554,
-0.5588182210922241,
0.690244197845459,
0.200031116604805,
-0.7750192880630493,
1.0124263763427734,
-0.41942283511161804,
0.2520478665828705,
0.2885807454586029,
0.48339560627937317,
-0.6595056653022766,
-0.45951202511787415,
-0.532431423664093,
-0.8253748416900635,
0.34301531314849854,
0.1399119347333908,
-0.13877981901168823,
-0.2994542419910431,
0.3975561857223511,
-0.10786308348178864,
0.21661700308322906,
-0.5877726078033447,
-0.11859733611345291,
-0.020401163026690483,
-0.10768718272447586,
0.4801732897758484,
-0.21586604416370392,
-0.1818525195121765,
-0.1502993106842041,
0.32616984844207764,
-0.42905333638191223,
0.1577250212430954,
0.19696885347366333,
-0.07793176919221878,
0.06201695650815964,
0.4640781283378601,
0.2684113085269928,
0.7665503621101379,
0.11046666651964188,
0.49171170592308044,
0.18320588767528534,
-0.025448784232139587,
0.02806357480585575,
-0.36519336700439453,
-0.5618410706520081,
-0.09803403913974762,
0.6122801303863525,
1.0260131359100342,
0.23124437034130096,
-0.3805304765701294,
-0.07858148217201233,
0.37263283133506775,
-0.1699812412261963,
0.15824708342552185,
0.20895007252693176,
0.29644453525543213,
0.3171331286430359,
0.24069920182228088,
0.03210384398698807,
0.4024490714073181,
-0.6529627442359924,
0.0812951847910881,
0.5261442065238953,
-0.32349756360054016,
-0.5221658945083618,
0.46345433592796326,
0.29603278636932373,
-0.5047624707221985,
0.6646997928619385,
-0.45160186290740967,
-0.5220579504966736,
0.5811414122581482,
0.5805612206459045,
1.0560970306396484,
0.17601507902145386,
0.3231164216995239,
0.632403552532196,
0.4570469260215759,
0.16082607209682465,
0.6044440865516663,
-0.3942010998725891,
-0.7340373992919922,
-0.9019392728805542,
-0.7151688933372498,
-0.37730446457862854,
-0.156265988945961,
-0.3002300560474396,
0.12099803984165192,
-0.6745544672012329,
-0.21491125226020813,
-0.10464134812355042,
0.10506566613912582,
-0.28933990001678467,
-0.12184438854455948,
0.34552696347236633,
1.2129381895065308,
-0.632172167301178,
0.5509031414985657,
0.8388433456420898,
-0.2150024026632309,
-1.0388139486312866,
-0.37888437509536743,
0.12194053083658218,
-0.6221756935119629,
0.7536216378211975,
0.3548598885536194,
-0.39255526661872864,
0.1537744104862213,
-0.4857006072998047,
-0.7688050270080566,
0.9273483157157898,
0.24504148960113525,
-0.7988929748535156,
-0.4628285765647888,
-0.12104588747024536,
0.47680988907814026,
-0.30904266238212585,
0.32635051012039185,
0.5160937905311584,
0.5367945432662964,
0.18854117393493652,
-0.6674025654792786,
0.20955510437488556,
-0.35217157006263733,
0.05794338881969452,
0.3217552900314331,
-0.27811047434806824,
0.6466419100761414,
-0.4736318588256836,
-0.8225535750389099,
-0.1019245907664299,
0.525131344795227,
0.7823531627655029,
0.24195028841495514,
0.5420923233032227,
0.39710506796836853,
1.2673619985580444,
-0.2466937154531479,
1.1141899824142456,
-0.5664771795272827,
0.04187851399183273,
0.8862937092781067,
-0.14914560317993164,
0.548685610294342,
0.5494710206985474,
-0.35968825221061707,
0.827477216720581,
0.9291436672210693,
0.20555779337882996,
0.24974893033504486,
0.513687014579773,
-0.019225280731916428,
-0.12535417079925537,
-0.3807089626789093,
-0.32854315638542175,
0.013333872891962528,
0.3853182792663574,
-0.05925195664167404,
-0.3875412344932556,
-0.26412323117256165,
-0.12719228863716125,
-0.02396502159535885,
-0.4340474009513855,
0.5898056030273438,
0.2335590422153473,
-0.7103641629219055,
0.4962676465511322,
-0.35406413674354553,
0.39750128984451294,
-0.4505641758441925,
0.022119589149951935,
-0.12311416119337082,
-0.37176892161369324,
-0.28976669907569885,
-1.0772439241409302,
0.5369919538497925,
0.024968735873699188,
-0.22447746992111206,
-0.7866485118865967,
0.8192878365516663,
-0.13294291496276855,
-0.11960229277610779,
0.36522364616394043,
0.5774162411689758,
0.1845187246799469,
-0.10490988194942474,
-0.8206052780151367,
0.1373348832130432,
-0.07961930334568024,
-0.3177586793899536,
-0.12409211695194244,
0.7215297222137451,
-0.24711152911186218,
0.8673830628395081,
0.8222432136535645,
0.1635141223669052,
0.02824394404888153,
0.49059152603149414,
1.1599009037017822,
-0.9525052905082703,
-0.7730246186256409,
-1.0730066299438477,
0.4443530738353729,
-0.12699000537395477,
-0.17646825313568115,
0.7014945149421692,
0.5606939792633057,
0.6053231954574585,
0.19293151795864105,
0.46837398409843445,
0.03205613046884537,
0.15113811194896698,
-0.7951505184173584,
0.4210376739501953,
0.008652911521494389,
0.3748040497303009,
-0.36033758521080017,
-0.9787893891334534,
-0.3610638976097107,
0.467070072889328,
-0.26334282755851746,
-0.16769903898239136,
0.8449222445487976,
0.7382684350013733,
0.36404991149902344,
0.4430908262729645,
-0.0719502791762352,
0.27902519702911377,
0.3824688792228699,
0.7113524079322815,
1.3607068061828613,
0.10244035720825195,
0.3436259925365448,
-0.03201701119542122,
-0.11830490827560425,
0.09058587998151779,
-0.8638684749603271,
-0.9615373015403748,
-0.5016445517539978,
-0.32489722967147827,
-0.07843025773763657,
0.012758416123688221,
0.7914286851882935,
0.5330868363380432,
-0.6146190166473389,
-0.22367432713508606,
-0.6541818380355835,
0.6495323777198792,
-0.23141169548034668,
-0.181613951921463,
0.3655737340450287,
-0.7379776835441589,
-0.36828404664993286,
0.7125049829483032,
0.7869482040405273,
-0.10339866578578949,
-0.40937453508377075,
-0.060614053159952164,
-0.17009691894054413,
0.016256581991910934,
0.9684905409812927,
0.1647941917181015,
-0.8291293382644653,
-0.1936175674200058,
0.208882138133049,
0.03407704457640648,
0.11380033195018768,
1.038464069366455,
-1.10948646068573,
0.37523433566093445,
0.8306676149368286,
0.579896867275238,
0.04804321378469467,
0.08333547413349152,
0.5335537791252136,
-0.688534677028656,
-0.03990570828318596,
0.31730902194976807,
0.4258943498134613,
0.20252197980880737,
-0.29540422558784485,
0.6145883798599243,
0.23495565354824066,
-0.30563509464263916,
-0.8866516947746277,
0.6103459596633911,
-0.8582977056503296,
-0.3993367552757263,
0.8988218307495117,
0.18448056280612946,
-0.3442195951938629,
-0.3110373616218567,
-0.4246555268764496,
0.18298818171024323,
-0.12811978161334991,
0.5549635887145996,
0.8209041953086853,
-0.3843420147895813,
-0.25443944334983826,
-0.4128533601760864,
0.6138073205947876,
0.22365234792232513,
-1.0100528001785278,
0.30095916986465454,
0.5698606371879578,
-0.07969260215759277,
0.3725075423717499,
0.8093073964118958,
0.05371902883052826,
-0.09403981268405914,
-0.03664199262857437,
-0.08202406764030457,
-0.15419384837150574,
-0.5983835458755493,
-0.19379301369190216,
0.5651935338973999,
0.11573214083909988,
0.048471417278051376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14280v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14280v3 | RomanSetu: Efficiently unlocking multilingual capabilities of Large Language Models via Romanization | 2024-01-25T16:11:41 | 2024-06-23T11:40:20 | Jaavid Aktar Husain, Raj Dabre, Aswanth Kumar, Jay Gala, Thanmay Jayakumar, Ratish Puduppully, Anoop Kunchukuttan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study addresses the challenge of extending Large Language Models (LLMs)
to non-English languages that use non-Roman scripts. We propose an approach
that utilizes the romanized form of text as an interface for LLMs,
hypothesizing that its frequent informal use and shared tokens with English
enhance cross-lingual alignment. Our approach involves the continual
pretraining of an English LLM like Llama 2 on romanized text of non-English,
non-Roman script languages, followed by instruction tuning on romanized data.
The results indicate that romanized text not only reduces token fertility by
2x-4x but also matches or outperforms native script representation across
various NLU, NLG, and MT tasks. Moreover, the embeddings computed on romanized
text exhibit closer alignment with their English translations than those from
the native script. Our approach presents a promising direction for leveraging
the power of English LLMs in languages traditionally underrepresented in NLP.
Our code is available on https://github.com/AI4Bharat/romansetu. | [
0.03230071812868118,
-0.38300999999046326,
0.34898602962493896,
0.3359806537628174,
-0.47074002027511597,
0.20052900910377502,
-0.9327471256256104,
-0.37199482321739197,
0.48895150423049927,
0.30458372831344604,
-0.2339099645614624,
-0.7008354663848877,
-0.5849770903587341,
0.3725823760032654,
-0.053173962980508804,
0.9958925247192383,
-0.32655584812164307,
0.33908581733703613,
-0.0924762487411499,
-0.20416943728923798,
-0.3129166066646576,
-0.2570270597934723,
-0.45330891013145447,
-0.19900394976139069,
0.7645822167396545,
0.5995734333992004,
0.4756592810153961,
0.6839677691459656,
0.40119948983192444,
0.2860517203807831,
0.40477362275123596,
0.305299311876297,
-0.5379675626754761,
0.16216117143630981,
0.024495799094438553,
-0.7392350435256958,
-0.41089141368865967,
-0.031067656353116035,
1.0453356504440308,
0.48580923676490784,
-0.16605904698371887,
0.23018954694271088,
-0.11788204312324524,
0.14978280663490295,
-0.5178751349449158,
0.10281931608915329,
-0.7146579623222351,
-0.3174108862876892,
-0.6417883634567261,
-0.46808964014053345,
-0.6755083799362183,
-0.296856164932251,
-0.32653555274009705,
-0.8072220683097839,
-0.23209059238433838,
0.03546154126524925,
0.9727222919464111,
0.445746511220932,
-0.43664059042930603,
-0.27966371178627014,
-0.7720475196838379,
0.9987586140632629,
-0.6172131299972534,
0.5886943936347961,
0.35072335600852966,
-0.13886424899101257,
0.018516017124056816,
-0.6336751580238342,
-0.3247378468513489,
-0.21505576372146606,
-0.22326205670833588,
0.18193215131759644,
0.0028250599279999733,
-0.0343363992869854,
0.15187735855579376,
0.16115017235279083,
-0.8805587291717529,
0.6316103339195251,
-0.26467224955558777,
0.03201907500624657,
0.48026472330093384,
-0.19775572419166565,
0.8198909759521484,
-0.06419478356838226,
-0.6122796535491943,
0.17577384412288666,
-0.9665110111236572,
-0.3310568928718567,
0.5562277436256409,
0.5884793400764465,
-0.2975780665874481,
0.6850096583366394,
0.4983670711517334,
0.6315228343009949,
-0.1655108481645584,
-0.37888848781585693,
0.09033384174108505,
-0.2513601779937744,
-0.13916777074337006,
0.06150767579674721,
0.7075773477554321,
0.17477206885814667,
0.4180304706096649,
-0.4400123953819275,
0.023318767547607422,
-0.01503138430416584,
-0.03779628872871399,
-0.8240190148353577,
0.265824556350708,
0.05941121280193329,
-0.14573337137699127,
0.21237096190452576,
-0.1456877887248993,
-0.5316417813301086,
-0.09641727060079575,
-0.4664419889450073,
0.062098752707242966,
-0.6195337176322937,
-0.4245431423187256,
-0.14294570684432983,
-0.038720984011888504,
0.47872716188430786,
0.31885215640068054,
-1.1153558492660522,
0.047081585973501205,
0.7603707909584045,
0.680112361907959,
0.11788038909435272,
-0.538100004196167,
-0.6167327761650085,
0.4636531472206116,
-0.4725862741470337,
0.5591102838516235,
-0.7603586316108704,
-0.2474759817123413,
-0.0416576974093914,
0.024503428488969803,
-0.46229949593544006,
-0.3064478039741516,
0.5427089929580688,
-0.7268415689468384,
0.10544285178184509,
0.04004611447453499,
-0.5328338146209717,
0.08540711551904678,
0.3232700526714325,
-0.6205331683158875,
1.1607751846313477,
-0.058335866779088974,
-0.8130972981452942,
0.4400308132171631,
-0.4341394007205963,
-0.6002277135848999,
0.35873326659202576,
-0.2635270357131958,
-0.35535433888435364,
0.04409119486808777,
0.09038896858692169,
0.2506769001483917,
-0.230011448264122,
0.4869224727153778,
-0.30698394775390625,
-0.3709675669670105,
-0.020652377977967262,
-0.21228837966918945,
0.5132028460502625,
0.16914109885692596,
-0.24845494329929352,
0.20952057838439941,
-0.6175788044929504,
0.1097811907529831,
0.016773846000432968,
-0.4393382668495178,
-0.6945884227752686,
-0.18167908489704132,
0.3391852080821991,
-0.14593099057674408,
0.5392448902130127,
-0.5321905016899109,
0.4926833212375641,
-0.19898031651973724,
0.4072370231151581,
0.6523193717002869,
-0.5608901381492615,
0.694770336151123,
-0.004357632249593735,
0.6706413626670837,
-0.36413607001304626,
-0.21794195473194122,
-0.15027017891407013,
-0.3330926299095154,
-0.6974372267723083,
-0.637822151184082,
0.7293769717216492,
0.67255699634552,
-0.737210214138031,
0.076774001121521,
-0.6851013898849487,
-0.46813490986824036,
-0.5216325521469116,
0.5503477454185486,
0.4804401099681854,
-0.04153000935912132,
0.20204943418502808,
0.035861510783433914,
-0.8753594756126404,
-0.8200867772102356,
-0.08075369149446487,
-0.34159138798713684,
0.058603666722774506,
0.10486166924238205,
0.3772622048854828,
-0.3536987602710724,
0.7543245553970337,
-0.07308243960142136,
-0.3918860852718353,
-0.5109772086143494,
0.07480594515800476,
-0.08348362147808075,
0.4389635920524597,
0.46622055768966675,
-0.78083735704422,
-0.6201544404029846,
0.4446766674518585,
-0.8978143930435181,
-0.007297124247997999,
-0.07026644796133041,
-0.05401604622602463,
0.32414138317108154,
0.848372220993042,
-0.48707666993141174,
-0.03046722710132599,
0.8799951672554016,
-0.07728683203458786,
0.3732313811779022,
-0.37095561623573303,
0.05145230144262314,
-1.4972692728042603,
0.32798564434051514,
0.034096378833055496,
-0.3042301535606384,
-0.588130533695221,
0.3777296841144562,
0.4093892574310303,
-0.1326594203710556,
-0.23178935050964355,
0.8498463034629822,
-0.7770873308181763,
-0.024150032550096512,
-0.12931257486343384,
0.4558173418045044,
-0.15103475749492645,
0.2070198655128479,
0.3751394748687744,
0.9344249367713928,
0.1728646159172058,
-0.2594074010848999,
0.14911723136901855,
0.17045316100120544,
-0.16137133538722992,
0.4124281108379364,
-0.37490227818489075,
0.025996960699558258,
-0.19248534739017487,
0.3485998809337616,
-0.6540236473083496,
-0.2677735984325409,
-0.2148112654685974,
-0.6006243228912354,
0.8172401189804077,
-0.6913421750068665,
-0.5342572927474976,
0.09821711480617523,
-0.16425266861915588,
0.6039124131202698,
0.1576537936925888,
-0.5179737210273743,
0.7067885398864746,
0.2323572039604187,
-0.31068193912506104,
-0.8567067384719849,
-0.6741048097610474,
0.4840022027492523,
-0.6144974827766418,
-0.6735689043998718,
0.3049582242965698,
0.05938029661774635,
-0.4378703534603119,
-0.1609223335981369,
0.5280095338821411,
0.11316417902708054,
0.06910692900419235,
0.016500936821103096,
0.4748300313949585,
-0.5275862812995911,
0.22265170514583588,
0.03091992624104023,
-0.17730838060379028,
-0.39386704564094543,
-0.5661529302597046,
0.6824301481246948,
0.05914730578660965,
-0.02627548575401306,
-0.41120919585227966,
0.38702887296676636,
0.6260409951210022,
-0.48574766516685486,
0.8956246972084045,
0.8973541855812073,
-0.5188133716583252,
-0.21362556517124176,
-0.45065197348594666,
0.11025328934192657,
-0.3879234492778778,
0.412771999835968,
-0.4550349712371826,
-0.8932715058326721,
0.4715869724750519,
-0.15530799329280853,
0.14621548354625702,
0.22741439938545227,
0.7508460283279419,
0.06288152933120728,
0.5251227617263794,
0.9195433855056763,
-0.1545109897851944,
0.6415147185325623,
-0.13279274106025696,
0.2955504357814789,
-0.9665693640708923,
-0.09316255897283554,
-0.4898303747177124,
-0.126563161611557,
-0.8053706884384155,
-0.7501969337463379,
0.1012020856142044,
0.2340032458305359,
0.20704185962677002,
0.661515474319458,
0.10829661041498184,
0.3462179899215698,
0.3603940010070801,
-0.3423166275024414,
0.22645756602287292,
0.06837401539087296,
-0.17337393760681152,
-0.40410417318344116,
-0.6818612217903137,
-0.7700901031494141,
1.3404074907302856,
0.16687123477458954,
0.8700451254844666,
0.3286137580871582,
1.0094406604766846,
0.04126308485865593,
0.6293404698371887,
-0.71347975730896,
0.2547159492969513,
-0.31729525327682495,
-0.6588738560676575,
-0.32207295298576355,
-0.429028183221817,
-1.1573121547698975,
0.12991005182266235,
-0.047383323311805725,
-0.8561225533485413,
-0.08306416869163513,
-0.17369364202022552,
-0.2595900893211365,
0.501430332660675,
-0.994798481464386,
0.6940473318099976,
-0.3340890407562256,
-0.5165159702301025,
-0.060165151953697205,
-0.45743823051452637,
0.33632728457450867,
-0.12144183367490768,
0.5031654238700867,
0.0014639629516750574,
-0.2570197582244873,
0.7853465676307678,
-0.2786865532398224,
0.8692088723182678,
0.05445137247443199,
-0.457038551568985,
0.024076461791992188,
-0.2156800776720047,
0.4421848654747009,
0.3569682240486145,
-0.08633829653263092,
0.10363536328077316,
-0.2082805037498474,
-0.6052162647247314,
-0.45772650837898254,
1.144365906715393,
-0.9607917666435242,
-0.4044494926929474,
-0.3432673513889313,
-0.45197978615760803,
-0.05041540414094925,
0.2818644642829895,
0.22468921542167664,
0.5537070035934448,
-0.4506528973579407,
-0.11922556161880493,
0.45278578996658325,
-0.22420094907283783,
0.4712466299533844,
0.5600208640098572,
-0.2820104658603668,
-0.6954394578933716,
1.0707820653915405,
0.22667019069194794,
0.2563410997390747,
0.6489622592926025,
-0.15792909264564514,
-0.39703336358070374,
-0.5840572714805603,
-1.105685830116272,
0.671533465385437,
-0.5587365031242371,
-0.19139745831489563,
-0.43784022331237793,
0.0634843185544014,
-0.7034859657287598,
-0.15252597630023956,
-0.4255194365978241,
-0.318454772233963,
-0.407071053981781,
-0.25208351016044617,
0.12995100021362305,
0.7775196433067322,
-0.27547451853752136,
0.26759716868400574,
-0.719007670879364,
0.12969057261943817,
0.04759860038757324,
0.3407263159751892,
-0.2988586127758026,
-0.4981466233730316,
-0.43121421337127686,
-0.15681035816669464,
0.13973581790924072,
-0.6545448899269104,
0.45868226885795593,
0.19250302016735077,
0.35935986042022705,
0.5883424282073975,
0.006909597665071487,
0.8678815960884094,
-0.6450416445732117,
0.43226340413093567,
0.1767127364873886,
-0.7450605630874634,
0.25804638862609863,
-0.5893115401268005,
0.022531338036060333,
0.508925199508667,
0.40496310591697693,
-0.8116257190704346,
-0.3786209523677826,
-0.34087616205215454,
-0.9068756699562073,
0.6330745220184326,
0.24861541390419006,
0.23341867327690125,
-0.08010149002075195,
0.30350130796432495,
0.05171824246644974,
-0.1385754495859146,
-0.9101117253303528,
-0.2781399190425873,
0.24333235621452332,
-0.3533734083175659,
-0.43337371945381165,
-0.3202718496322632,
-0.13291198015213013,
0.02708582393825054,
0.7898565530776978,
-0.19871540367603302,
0.05364969000220299,
0.1494356095790863,
-0.5366199016571045,
-0.05431792885065079,
0.5346298813819885,
0.7443663477897644,
0.6274382472038269,
0.08082492649555206,
0.21952788531780243,
0.14790140092372894,
-0.4550451934337616,
0.09743089973926544,
0.45562323927879333,
-0.29536136984825134,
0.038835152983665466,
0.6248301863670349,
0.7142191529273987,
0.3511694371700287,
-0.4489518702030182,
0.13301484286785126,
-0.3406083881855011,
0.14305053651332855,
-0.5997051000595093,
-0.5068672299385071,
0.32345980405807495,
0.003968842327594757,
0.3536776602268219,
-0.24552080035209656,
-0.2750430703163147,
-0.5212896466255188,
0.012027870863676071,
0.4935234487056732,
-0.37149834632873535,
-0.40861210227012634,
0.6578058004379272,
0.32556185126304626,
-0.28227949142456055,
0.5223802328109741,
-0.262969970703125,
-0.5225623846054077,
0.512837290763855,
0.8317122459411621,
0.54970782995224,
-0.3782108426094055,
0.26463159918785095,
0.6281148195266724,
0.6410266757011414,
0.18066753447055817,
-0.003183182794600725,
0.07874738425016403,
-0.7516870498657227,
-0.7342603206634521,
-0.8251833915710449,
-0.22584375739097595,
0.05320600047707558,
-0.6329615712165833,
0.7000526189804077,
-0.314171701669693,
-0.14337798953056335,
-0.23227667808532715,
0.11681923270225525,
-0.378618061542511,
0.13219067454338074,
0.4761824905872345,
0.673492431640625,
-0.9178357124328613,
1.1165721416473389,
0.862722635269165,
-0.21798458695411682,
-0.9331205487251282,
-0.08313463628292084,
-0.18873639404773712,
-0.9308175444602966,
0.49464744329452515,
0.23821032047271729,
-0.09614479541778564,
0.28970712423324585,
-0.2203492373228073,
-1.0075056552886963,
0.916603147983551,
0.5803881883621216,
-0.5689075589179993,
-0.1056644544005394,
0.1598745584487915,
0.5347276329994202,
-0.20373763144016266,
0.4977705478668213,
0.4749380052089691,
0.7264662981033325,
-0.08899673074483871,
-1.0459357500076294,
-0.12071719765663147,
-0.5420175790786743,
-0.13005594909191132,
0.4373103678226471,
-0.7521445751190186,
0.4801192879676819,
-0.5194880962371826,
-0.4884418845176697,
0.419757604598999,
0.6180060505867004,
0.17227335274219513,
0.184748113155365,
0.16993029415607452,
0.9037173986434937,
0.8705275654792786,
-0.22848917543888092,
0.9593637585639954,
-0.38721346855163574,
0.16625766456127167,
1.101498007774353,
-0.35131722688674927,
0.9836655259132385,
0.6257784366607666,
-0.08544284105300903,
0.7904385924339294,
0.7176262736320496,
0.25975438952445984,
-0.0022774033714085817,
0.12919458746910095,
-0.35119664669036865,
-0.4093169569969177,
-0.26049840450286865,
-0.3738926947116852,
0.6019444465637207,
0.4134572446346283,
-0.26435327529907227,
-0.17161336541175842,
0.15115289390087128,
0.5562838315963745,
0.19450567662715912,
-0.11789612472057343,
0.8060035109519958,
0.1408381462097168,
-0.7998542189598083,
0.5545139312744141,
0.46990329027175903,
0.7285085916519165,
-0.8139068484306335,
0.20362262427806854,
-0.3547476828098297,
0.30031800270080566,
-0.2638358473777771,
-0.20088161528110504,
0.02702776901423931,
0.20677828788757324,
-0.06631197780370712,
-0.3075050711631775,
0.23341259360313416,
-0.8702688813209534,
-0.6673946976661682,
0.645835280418396,
0.4195115864276886,
0.2235451638698578,
0.3987639844417572,
-0.2050381898880005,
0.11021546274423599,
-0.05502508580684662,
0.10589922964572906,
0.3466639518737793,
0.3970300853252411,
-0.3460383117198944,
0.49870333075523376,
0.6964781880378723,
0.18273398280143738,
0.22703978419303894,
0.3435612618923187,
0.7079857587814331,
-0.4660528004169464,
-0.3088151514530182,
-0.9776182770729065,
0.2880620062351227,
0.06783119589090347,
-0.2190868854522705,
0.9274933338165283,
0.9366263747215271,
0.9069324731826782,
0.05284438654780388,
0.7932488918304443,
-0.12505732476711273,
0.1188582107424736,
-0.623096764087677,
0.6294005513191223,
-0.7195353507995605,
0.051468636840581894,
-0.06626391410827637,
-0.9262410402297974,
-0.50180584192276,
0.2129305750131607,
-0.4335421621799469,
-0.1129213273525238,
0.7523936629295349,
0.5804378390312195,
-0.06414251029491425,
-0.3788447976112366,
0.4464300274848938,
0.0682547464966774,
0.13745926320552826,
0.4545428454875946,
0.7798372507095337,
-0.4162910282611847,
0.5794059634208679,
0.24598734080791473,
-0.3579040467739105,
-0.015336417593061924,
-0.6329956650733948,
-0.94326251745224,
-0.5132845044136047,
-0.18573129177093506,
-0.184869185090065,
-0.07418009638786316,
0.9562720656394958,
0.6815993189811707,
-0.6007286310195923,
-0.479922354221344,
0.35034939646720886,
0.21673813462257385,
0.36356300115585327,
-0.12352795153856277,
0.2553465664386749,
-0.5346776843070984,
-1.2978626489639282,
0.5315788388252258,
0.41745659708976746,
0.009926218539476395,
-0.27308058738708496,
-0.2848894000053406,
-0.4011303782463074,
-0.010571176186203957,
0.35456520318984985,
0.34613290429115295,
-0.6316444873809814,
0.0840049535036087,
0.19792640209197998,
-0.24010279774665833,
0.07389555126428604,
0.9817315936088562,
-0.3756071925163269,
0.26032382249832153,
0.13888061046600342,
0.3594568073749542,
0.48967620730400085,
-0.032151397317647934,
0.8107625842094421,
-0.8430224061012268,
0.3703766465187073,
-0.008460797369480133,
0.6866014003753662,
0.6938775181770325,
-0.24477419257164001,
0.27412015199661255,
0.07627610862255096,
-0.31766679883003235,
-0.7594924569129944,
0.29689884185791016,
-0.795417070388794,
-0.06068654730916023,
1.5147331953048706,
-0.42199045419692993,
-0.36155590415000916,
-0.007038355339318514,
-0.04189768806099892,
0.5031542181968689,
-0.2979726195335388,
0.41102975606918335,
0.6179587841033936,
0.532282292842865,
-0.08259199559688568,
-0.20156146585941315,
0.36429324746131897,
0.32900357246398926,
-0.8262187242507935,
0.17823083698749542,
0.21824510395526886,
0.5017222166061401,
0.22722294926643372,
0.6365925669670105,
-0.25454771518707275,
0.02401665784418583,
-0.20707190036773682,
0.30264127254486084,
0.16393080353736877,
-0.4047015309333801,
-0.3033932149410248,
-0.147785946726799,
0.33539190888404846,
0.057579997926950455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14267v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14267v2 | Transformers and Cortical Waves: Encoders for Pulling In Context Across Time | 2024-01-25T16:01:49 | 2024-07-03T03:41:07 | Lyle Muller, Patricia S. Churchland, Terrence J. Sejnowski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The capabilities of transformer networks such as ChatGPT and other Large
Language Models (LLMs) have captured the world's attention. The crucial
computational mechanism underlying their performance relies on transforming a
complete input sequence - for example, all the words in a sentence - into a
long "encoding vector" that allows transformers to learn long-range temporal
dependencies in naturalistic sequences. Specifically, "self-attention" applied
to this encoding vector enhances temporal context in transformers by computing
associations between pairs of words in the input sequence. We suggest that
waves of neural activity traveling across single cortical areas or multiple
regions at the whole-brain scale could implement a similar encoding principle.
By encapsulating recent input history into a single spatial pattern at each
moment in time, cortical waves may enable temporal context to be extracted from
sequences of sensory inputs, the same computational principle used in
transformers. | [
-0.44926342368125916,
-0.8676673173904419,
0.7205091118812561,
0.7314338088035583,
-0.10835591703653336,
-0.0587022565305233,
-0.10910914093255997,
-0.48331505060195923,
0.3490317165851593,
0.34134167432785034,
-0.8189020156860352,
0.0800449550151825,
-0.6921327114105225,
0.08176759630441666,
-0.785530686378479,
0.8002707958221436,
0.025831330567598343,
-0.28043705224990845,
0.05610567703843117,
0.11088824272155762,
-0.47607871890068054,
-0.5495290756225586,
-0.6000940799713135,
-0.6939854621887207,
0.7187610268592834,
-0.1096973642706871,
0.6186667680740356,
0.41412338614463806,
0.5810859203338623,
0.21879196166992188,
-0.003897843649610877,
-0.16016767919063568,
-0.332719087600708,
0.32512933015823364,
-0.418506383895874,
-0.35031604766845703,
-0.267911434173584,
-0.17476259171962738,
0.5420325994491577,
0.656817615032196,
-0.12203820049762726,
0.10036387294530869,
0.260738343000412,
0.32522231340408325,
-0.39906948804855347,
0.21479621529579163,
-0.3521682620048523,
0.48211318254470825,
0.0630529373884201,
-0.8672776818275452,
-0.5067157745361328,
-0.08435087651014328,
0.3929971754550934,
-0.3771243393421173,
0.4150247871875763,
-0.03544931858778,
0.8169221878051758,
0.45183661580085754,
-0.5414382815361023,
-0.3257724344730377,
-0.9835028648376465,
0.5308171510696411,
-0.06437836587429047,
0.6469907760620117,
0.32476767897605896,
0.29561617970466614,
-0.2820329964160919,
-1.160088062286377,
-0.35633769631385803,
-0.058546941727399826,
-0.43501487374305725,
0.515138566493988,
-0.3259892165660858,
0.08428365737199783,
0.3439945578575134,
0.13822123408317566,
-0.15531854331493378,
-0.1486569494009018,
-0.6649072766304016,
-0.10967335850000381,
0.34612980484962463,
0.21624855697155,
0.4188181161880493,
-0.21574872732162476,
-0.7447814345359802,
-0.022154426202178,
-0.5307719707489014,
0.1579371839761734,
-0.10100310295820236,
0.022429415956139565,
-0.36901482939720154,
0.40445083379745483,
0.14886997640132904,
0.588793158531189,
0.346966952085495,
-0.020029732957482338,
-0.025125037878751755,
-0.3313922584056854,
-0.04636916518211365,
0.35090890526771545,
0.8270986080169678,
0.0684424489736557,
0.05361729860305786,
-0.7365904450416565,
-0.14227940142154694,
0.05416468530893326,
0.5851909518241882,
-0.4862675070762634,
0.15902119874954224,
0.08042693138122559,
-0.464678555727005,
0.009121538139879704,
-0.1376102715730667,
-1.1702470779418945,
0.02847146801650524,
-0.5352416634559631,
0.5794270038604736,
-0.25099462270736694,
0.017569590359926224,
0.10256437212228775,
-0.3059557378292084,
0.546692967414856,
-0.16728277504444122,
-1.2497670650482178,
0.4381159543991089,
0.5238201022148132,
0.9084710478782654,
-0.4307089149951935,
-0.4285588562488556,
-0.23318320512771606,
0.342420756816864,
-0.11662714928388596,
0.8953555226325989,
-0.5060960650444031,
-0.46208226680755615,
-0.10767579078674316,
0.1606358140707016,
-0.19635875523090363,
-0.12939883768558502,
0.328923761844635,
-0.9480873942375183,
0.13394621014595032,
-0.12251131236553192,
-0.09487944096326828,
0.0156591534614563,
0.017202990129590034,
-0.661327064037323,
0.9295070767402649,
0.1542559415102005,
-0.38635414838790894,
0.19773276150226593,
-0.9446664452552795,
-0.8768203854560852,
0.05047236382961273,
-0.27226999402046204,
-0.22489534318447113,
0.3242736756801605,
0.5073344707489014,
0.31734952330589294,
-0.20513956248760223,
0.3002869188785553,
-0.15606018900871277,
-0.3377169370651245,
0.5465384721755981,
-0.8144999146461487,
0.6144995093345642,
0.33746689558029175,
-0.42725008726119995,
-0.1028028130531311,
-0.44934970140457153,
-0.3915729224681854,
0.15148110687732697,
-0.31275835633277893,
-0.08987964689731598,
0.18336085975170135,
0.0715472623705864,
0.36354103684425354,
0.28734713792800903,
-0.6307438611984253,
0.014208134263753891,
-0.4402223825454712,
0.9793411493301392,
0.625971794128418,
0.27837103605270386,
0.7061111330986023,
-0.026627756655216217,
0.5011506676673889,
0.15133027732372284,
0.17446368932724,
-0.428754985332489,
-0.013187066651880741,
-0.7553868889808655,
-0.19644741714000702,
-0.08725224435329437,
0.2381642758846283,
-0.6496458053588867,
0.26136964559555054,
-0.5448238849639893,
-0.20871485769748688,
-0.21583357453346252,
-0.3067028224468231,
-0.17799803614616394,
0.5468506813049316,
0.6338192820549011,
-0.24070420861244202,
-0.6382904648780823,
-0.9227447509765625,
-0.02051755040884018,
0.33990734815597534,
-0.1219746321439743,
0.309954434633255,
0.3074836730957031,
-0.35306084156036377,
1.4035252332687378,
-0.5510964393615723,
-0.29968976974487305,
0.01618819870054722,
0.07989826053380966,
0.2515851557254791,
0.23212799429893494,
0.3617854714393616,
-0.7007079720497131,
-0.0009667663834989071,
0.01765533722937107,
-0.867748498916626,
0.028117608278989792,
-0.3157818913459778,
-0.17066986858844757,
-0.2836299538612366,
0.9283291697502136,
-0.6377411484718323,
0.34036678075790405,
0.5644190311431885,
-0.37027767300605774,
-0.02217620052397251,
-0.22911521792411804,
-0.009047304280102253,
-1.012929916381836,
-0.11247017979621887,
-0.19498980045318604,
-0.17053984105587006,
-0.46513110399246216,
-0.2913394272327423,
0.16745267808437347,
-0.24145321547985077,
-0.40787622332572937,
0.5941596627235413,
-0.5392271876335144,
-0.18150638043880463,
-0.211821049451828,
0.2887938916683197,
-0.13458378612995148,
0.8493966460227966,
0.04267997667193413,
0.5335396528244019,
0.41592779755592346,
-0.7441855669021606,
0.3570547103881836,
0.20946040749549866,
-0.0732191950082779,
0.37154558300971985,
-0.9031016230583191,
0.38245242834091187,
-0.4361700415611267,
0.22750535607337952,
-1.0901000499725342,
-0.05538707226514816,
0.01938844472169876,
-0.17894883453845978,
0.3003586232662201,
0.19293197989463806,
-0.14642402529716492,
-0.4075010418891907,
0.3376249670982361,
0.6515781879425049,
0.5917912125587463,
-0.9309751391410828,
0.9973747730255127,
0.3151535987854004,
0.13174989819526672,
-0.4541780948638916,
-0.8887672424316406,
-0.031047483906149864,
-0.13681074976921082,
-0.3336554765701294,
0.4573590159416199,
0.36611151695251465,
0.14481903612613678,
0.015748988837003708,
-0.2509917914867401,
0.12131881713867188,
-0.005636459682136774,
0.5118814706802368,
0.04183298721909523,
-0.044602762907743454,
0.20949193835258484,
0.09190784394741058,
-0.23389439284801483,
0.26245036721229553,
-0.42660820484161377,
0.8920325040817261,
0.1788060963153839,
-0.4418281018733978,
-0.13529439270496368,
0.20548813045024872,
0.591779887676239,
-0.3440493941307068,
0.45138153433799744,
0.7042550444602966,
-0.281788170337677,
-0.2334679216146469,
-0.3576640188694,
-0.4664289653301239,
-0.5478732585906982,
0.5264413952827454,
-0.46668145060539246,
-1.117025375366211,
0.3763331472873688,
-0.17643368244171143,
-0.1976882666349411,
0.561498761177063,
0.5964963436126709,
-0.37106508016586304,
0.8723171949386597,
0.6258869767189026,
-0.11363779008388519,
0.7767162919044495,
-0.17451214790344238,
0.4385532736778259,
-0.9659412503242493,
-0.25812628865242004,
-0.27181845903396606,
-0.6418341994285583,
-0.4631420373916626,
-0.22900572419166565,
0.3779955804347992,
-0.13174770772457123,
-0.16250135004520416,
0.3424261510372162,
-0.6205970644950867,
0.4577493369579315,
0.33698368072509766,
0.32351937890052795,
0.11160038411617279,
0.3134559690952301,
-0.004208147991448641,
-0.1300552636384964,
-0.8249717354774475,
-0.10688584297895432,
0.7737854719161987,
0.638357937335968,
0.8967370986938477,
-0.1919931024312973,
0.3815893828868866,
0.23201410472393036,
0.31353768706321716,
-0.878446638584137,
0.3653435707092285,
-0.09334620833396912,
-0.5070508122444153,
-0.21923652291297913,
-0.08671998977661133,
-1.390219807624817,
0.10385661572217941,
-0.010516475886106491,
-0.7660388946533203,
0.390153706073761,
-0.10385322570800781,
-0.5521470904350281,
0.01902764104306698,
-0.5079568028450012,
0.5116009712219238,
-0.32247474789619446,
-0.3699392080307007,
-0.3157040476799011,
-0.5375455021858215,
-0.014857803471386433,
-0.00278779910877347,
0.06333181262016296,
-0.04673026502132416,
-0.1346215158700943,
0.4966544806957245,
0.10141905397176743,
1.066740870475769,
0.14363116025924683,
-0.16911543905735016,
0.33398866653442383,
0.11314351856708527,
0.19431942701339722,
0.09732451289892197,
0.6272650957107544,
0.47348088026046753,
-0.06988184154033661,
-0.24227391183376312,
-0.5323535799980164,
0.5087268948554993,
-0.9563348889350891,
-0.47512292861938477,
-0.2766137719154358,
-0.6991351842880249,
0.011276078410446644,
0.12888287007808685,
0.5536025762557983,
0.7580172419548035,
-0.2713448703289032,
0.13046544790267944,
0.5400499701499939,
0.07709398120641708,
1.0289993286132812,
0.18528644740581512,
-0.31968045234680176,
-0.30191779136657715,
0.5903265476226807,
0.21162639558315277,
0.08323656022548676,
0.6347326040267944,
-0.049509432166814804,
-0.3421008288860321,
-0.022052109241485596,
0.05486080422997475,
0.1519618034362793,
-0.7029728889465332,
-0.046225983649492264,
-0.8395117521286011,
-0.4238819479942322,
-0.08556769788265228,
-0.2191421240568161,
-0.3169230818748474,
-0.3229665756225586,
-0.002868395997211337,
0.09222051501274109,
0.13923996686935425,
0.7880816459655762,
0.03153775632381439,
0.5202610492706299,
-0.8859266638755798,
0.6380695104598999,
0.7022743225097656,
0.46554070711135864,
0.23553627729415894,
-0.5060451030731201,
-0.3391822278499603,
-0.007118178531527519,
-0.33767807483673096,
-0.742398202419281,
0.6055688261985779,
0.12064018100500107,
0.5669077038764954,
0.05548027530312538,
-0.47977215051651,
0.6827976703643799,
-0.8330040574073792,
0.775199830532074,
0.27609631419181824,
-0.8709490895271301,
0.5019103288650513,
-0.2822583317756653,
0.8995672464370728,
-0.10183090716600418,
0.41575270891189575,
-0.9182001352310181,
-0.14981047809123993,
-0.3713711202144623,
-0.7500910758972168,
0.7436762452125549,
0.19291594624519348,
0.17123058438301086,
-0.3103657364845276,
0.4414249062538147,
-0.03088926151394844,
-0.14772005379199982,
-0.5745000839233398,
-0.22243714332580566,
-0.21087124943733215,
-0.2564646005630493,
-0.2349865734577179,
-0.20854923129081726,
-0.4092223346233368,
-0.11196136474609375,
0.034757405519485474,
-0.22823448479175568,
0.8884354829788208,
0.832214891910553,
-0.26260706782341003,
-0.040574073791503906,
0.2745817303657532,
0.6037616729736328,
0.41440337896347046,
0.09847687929868698,
0.433542400598526,
0.4250103831291199,
-0.7280356287956238,
0.19399917125701904,
-0.07008868455886841,
-0.06566432863473892,
-0.11473143100738525,
0.4014664590358734,
0.739917516708374,
0.5515469908714294,
-0.07610100507736206,
0.1711323857307434,
-0.39281949400901794,
-0.017293032258749008,
-0.5569713711738586,
-0.08962146192789078,
0.1908133625984192,
0.5603208541870117,
0.6057892441749573,
0.2206159383058548,
-0.00006289218435995281,
-0.3709600567817688,
0.2903244197368622,
0.2336800992488861,
-0.7973541021347046,
-0.572117269039154,
0.8382547497749329,
0.09661877900362015,
-0.5207340121269226,
0.7903674840927124,
0.4073929488658905,
-0.3458242416381836,
0.7987480759620667,
0.9919683337211609,
1.0843178033828735,
-0.1233246847987175,
-0.4525463879108429,
0.5137079358100891,
0.28582966327667236,
-0.22471852600574493,
-0.008890324272215366,
-0.3998323380947113,
-0.8560113906860352,
-0.6563246846199036,
-0.7036339640617371,
0.015150276012718678,
-0.14845377206802368,
-0.6466881632804871,
0.1612473726272583,
-0.417599618434906,
-0.48808205127716064,
-0.14970847964286804,
-0.7781723141670227,
-0.961360514163971,
0.10350225120782852,
0.4273422062397003,
0.7566311359405518,
-0.6316471099853516,
0.858436644077301,
0.395809143781662,
-0.3115701973438263,
-0.5756171345710754,
-0.08905959129333496,
-0.5264981985092163,
-0.7861119508743286,
0.9132749438285828,
0.1213633194565773,
-0.38450315594673157,
0.19923235476016998,
-0.7320759892463684,
-1.294831395149231,
1.118850827217102,
0.18153971433639526,
-0.7778928875923157,
-0.29956841468811035,
0.35186898708343506,
0.6918978095054626,
-0.4436752498149872,
0.285519003868103,
0.854991614818573,
0.13106508553028107,
-0.10173338651657104,
-0.8036566972732544,
0.0035842983052134514,
-0.06784441322088242,
0.03099248930811882,
0.4436934292316437,
-0.8211225867271423,
0.5284114480018616,
0.11754448711872101,
-0.4433671236038208,
-0.3750882148742676,
0.8803540468215942,
-0.16886621713638306,
0.03590067848563194,
0.1813553422689438,
0.32789692282676697,
0.20094850659370422,
-0.4965156316757202,
1.1394529342651367,
-0.5747182965278625,
0.5752099752426147,
1.0273165702819824,
0.24210110306739807,
0.544121265411377,
0.7648974657058716,
-0.17455390095710754,
0.36202844977378845,
0.3211713135242462,
0.011374937370419502,
0.7628393173217773,
-0.2951498031616211,
-0.07134581357240677,
-0.1551852971315384,
-0.05204640328884125,
-0.2505122721195221,
0.6567254066467285,
0.6274492144584656,
-0.5053515434265137,
-0.18927831947803497,
0.18054036796092987,
-0.28090205788612366,
-0.28442031145095825,
-0.4657306373119354,
0.6391106843948364,
0.5762982368469238,
-0.8658338189125061,
0.20299850404262543,
-0.47111976146698,
0.7408784031867981,
-0.7311553359031677,
-0.032931819558143616,
-0.11902356892824173,
0.2715536653995514,
-0.22944240272045135,
-0.5997031927108765,
0.4146566390991211,
-0.43840232491493225,
-0.1716245859861374,
-0.5900131464004517,
0.7759814858436584,
-0.47531795501708984,
-0.16523171961307526,
0.647094190120697,
0.2982933521270752,
-0.27657756209373474,
0.3073323369026184,
-0.2778625786304474,
-0.06915207207202911,
-0.3123725950717926,
-0.4094420075416565,
0.17150762677192688,
0.1805819422006607,
0.18408754467964172,
0.5821223258972168,
0.3411044478416443,
-0.12600088119506836,
0.34445616602897644,
0.05985990911722183,
0.6209917664527893,
-1.0979634523391724,
-0.5834259986877441,
-1.088152527809143,
0.18811273574829102,
0.20864585041999817,
-0.2353695034980774,
0.6651272177696228,
0.27428585290908813,
0.7136185765266418,
-0.10570573061704636,
0.48936423659324646,
-0.052971117198467255,
-0.021311618387699127,
-0.3478618860244751,
0.5727969408035278,
-0.2494848221540451,
-0.1926785409450531,
0.2512167990207672,
-1.013513207435608,
-0.13247078657150269,
0.4645116627216339,
-0.5371169447898865,
-0.07408720254898071,
1.0195307731628418,
0.48695725202560425,
-0.07881370931863785,
0.3884018063545227,
0.3360951840877533,
0.21241018176078796,
0.3239677846431732,
0.7334506511688232,
1.0153651237487793,
-0.5410568118095398,
0.4343808889389038,
-0.18712149560451508,
0.09377242624759674,
0.13538111746311188,
-0.7063732147216797,
-0.7343586683273315,
-0.6124162077903748,
-0.031463734805583954,
-0.2830696403980255,
-0.11736555397510529,
0.9046911001205444,
0.646843671798706,
-0.6357026696205139,
-0.30976402759552,
-0.04835471883416176,
-0.29219850897789,
-0.4055542051792145,
-0.2312791645526886,
0.43323391675949097,
-0.6831472516059875,
-0.7587178349494934,
0.5552660822868347,
0.6302428841590881,
0.08335113525390625,
-0.34238162636756897,
0.2676849067211151,
-0.06823411583900452,
0.02335534058511257,
0.9784270524978638,
0.26950734853744507,
-0.4965341091156006,
-0.5253631472587585,
0.34869274497032166,
-0.5322893857955933,
0.36422836780548096,
1.0533156394958496,
-1.0624436140060425,
0.4182289242744446,
0.554449200630188,
0.6372644901275635,
1.1076807975769043,
-0.34903982281684875,
0.7301111221313477,
-0.6939330697059631,
0.3701072931289673,
0.08665627241134644,
0.4572296440601349,
0.07998315244913101,
-0.5040953159332275,
0.5557259321212769,
0.041323959827423096,
-0.6945632100105286,
-0.244782954454422,
0.20167644321918488,
-1.0537333488464355,
-0.0988694503903389,
1.0748193264007568,
0.27008524537086487,
-0.6633195877075195,
-0.3357457220554352,
-0.05001473426818848,
0.559141218662262,
-0.15722306072711945,
0.9359898567199707,
0.800944447517395,
-0.39654800295829773,
-0.14838452637195587,
-0.4953514039516449,
0.2905748188495636,
0.45855337381362915,
-0.436872661113739,
-0.25886207818984985,
0.11594812572002411,
0.26188358664512634,
0.5050967931747437,
0.49655672907829285,
-0.38155460357666016,
0.23338405787944794,
0.22043275833129883,
0.01260585431009531,
0.27617722749710083,
-0.3355720043182373,
-0.6445615291595459,
0.6607564687728882,
-0.33233198523521423,
-0.13381072878837585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14242v1 | Improving Natural Language Capability of Code Large Language Model | 2024-01-25T15:33:20 | 2024-01-25T15:33:20 | Wei Li, Daoguang Zan, Bei Guan, Ailun Yu, Xiaolin Chen, Yongji Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code large language models (Code LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
performance in code generation. Nonetheless, most existing works focus on
boosting code LLMs from the perspective of programming capabilities, while
their natural language capabilities receive less attention. To fill this gap,
we thus propose a novel framework, comprising two modules: AttentionExtractor,
which is responsible for extracting key phrases from the user's natural
language requirements, and AttentionCoder, which leverages these extracted
phrases to generate target code to solve the requirement. This framework
pioneers an innovative idea by seamlessly integrating code LLMs with
traditional natural language processing tools. To validate the effectiveness of
the framework, we craft a new code generation benchmark, called MultiNL-H,
covering five natural languages. Extensive experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed framework. | [
-0.5623813271522522,
-0.4410814642906189,
0.2649897336959839,
0.2601124048233032,
-0.15836386382579803,
0.4424537420272827,
-0.41399091482162476,
-0.649231493473053,
0.1284560114145279,
0.6188821196556091,
-0.37992003560066223,
-0.492086261510849,
-0.3491033613681793,
0.42618685960769653,
-0.37547096610069275,
0.8870824575424194,
0.11645226925611496,
-0.2713460326194763,
-0.1708454191684723,
-0.09963534027338028,
-0.378790944814682,
-0.5000318288803101,
-0.44550999999046326,
-0.15500815212726593,
0.4944729208946228,
0.5047995448112488,
0.5114540457725525,
0.4604059159755707,
0.9060665369033813,
0.31739917397499084,
0.002411388559266925,
0.23950886726379395,
-0.26653099060058594,
-0.04070894420146942,
0.1237734854221344,
-0.3364601135253906,
-0.5010147094726562,
-0.3267553746700287,
0.6016106009483337,
0.32687172293663025,
-0.01037666853517294,
0.3546098470687866,
0.16121570765972137,
0.7080861330032349,
-0.564141571521759,
0.18131513893604279,
-0.6126464605331421,
-0.024690067395567894,
-0.09658514708280563,
-0.31417790055274963,
-0.3365151882171631,
-0.5021658539772034,
0.13129384815692902,
-0.2919696271419525,
0.24468575417995453,
-0.07620159536600113,
0.5699681639671326,
0.31794312596321106,
-0.3913643956184387,
-0.19947461783885956,
-0.48922285437583923,
0.7906180024147034,
-0.9175916314125061,
0.2503678798675537,
0.09025776386260986,
0.39114871621131897,
-0.03052421659231186,
-0.7613652944564819,
-0.4214889407157898,
-0.48225754499435425,
0.0020468453876674175,
-0.22764499485492706,
-0.08363591134548187,
-0.042682185769081116,
0.49573034048080444,
0.5588714480400085,
-0.5876981019973755,
-0.03703950718045235,
-0.2691713571548462,
-0.344340980052948,
0.680810809135437,
0.11488958448171616,
0.27549096941947937,
-0.2885455787181854,
-0.3076183497905731,
0.13111954927444458,
-0.6479443311691284,
-0.020244689658284187,
0.3220788538455963,
0.3283337354660034,
-0.1894005686044693,
0.6107801795005798,
-0.45207202434539795,
0.7264577150344849,
-0.1807442158460617,
-0.13290759921073914,
0.5242927074432373,
-0.5091521143913269,
-0.20266355574131012,
0.09713881462812424,
0.49446579813957214,
0.3172128200531006,
0.29276177287101746,
-0.21100959181785583,
-0.21504315733909607,
0.26037195324897766,
0.4304369390010834,
-0.8497823476791382,
-0.14513741433620453,
0.23818354308605194,
-0.40886610746383667,
-0.3313128352165222,
0.005483535584062338,
-0.9546833038330078,
-0.35635924339294434,
-0.342440128326416,
-0.01700318232178688,
-0.31293952465057373,
-0.3954598009586334,
0.1015491709113121,
-0.044596027582883835,
0.44822752475738525,
0.04411446303129196,
-0.6627960801124573,
0.03884110227227211,
0.686443567276001,
0.816222608089447,
-0.3869822919368744,
-0.014772473834455013,
-0.8392380475997925,
0.14730346202850342,
-0.1838177889585495,
0.604436457157135,
-0.505341649055481,
-0.013707214035093784,
0.2427782565355301,
-0.22543860971927643,
0.12356515973806381,
-0.6317582726478577,
0.4591486155986786,
-0.5300506353378296,
-0.08352091908454895,
0.05504040792584419,
-0.4949164390563965,
-0.0033804408740252256,
0.5773370862007141,
-0.739448070526123,
1.185066819190979,
0.21071304380893707,
-0.6369271874427795,
0.31860899925231934,
-0.991999626159668,
-0.6173966526985168,
0.38958337903022766,
-0.20069335401058197,
-0.4502730071544647,
0.22580686211585999,
0.16926002502441406,
0.3814811408519745,
-0.38875412940979004,
0.39553675055503845,
-0.2760082483291626,
-0.27038711309432983,
0.3781494200229645,
-0.2861323356628418,
0.45914414525032043,
0.2780166268348694,
-0.4344314932823181,
0.366904079914093,
-1.1488947868347168,
0.32041624188423157,
0.038339875638484955,
-0.8535075187683105,
0.04244336113333702,
-0.1643172949552536,
0.3410387635231018,
0.32695573568344116,
0.29763099551200867,
-0.38051801919937134,
-0.04825596883893013,
-0.7514908909797668,
0.5305831432342529,
0.31177520751953125,
-0.06982430815696716,
0.5060042142868042,
-0.10436879843473434,
0.7034932374954224,
-0.25173765420913696,
-0.07772122323513031,
-0.39198988676071167,
-0.39474496245384216,
-0.757487416267395,
-0.3308396339416504,
0.17157553136348724,
0.13815155625343323,
-0.729273796081543,
0.5777737498283386,
-0.336656391620636,
-0.24740973114967346,
-0.5025701522827148,
0.676513135433197,
0.6189441680908203,
0.1230124980211258,
0.4217197000980377,
-0.29380735754966736,
-0.6863504648208618,
-0.8867464661598206,
-0.39989742636680603,
0.19960767030715942,
-0.15156716108322144,
0.1401047259569168,
0.3819684684276581,
-0.4666815996170044,
0.9750873446464539,
-0.49544787406921387,
-0.21248917281627655,
-0.6733371615409851,
0.16194695234298706,
0.3008681833744049,
0.46146851778030396,
0.2934609055519104,
-0.814752995967865,
-0.4759436845779419,
0.0700276643037796,
-0.46282297372817993,
0.046339843422174454,
0.06731153279542923,
-0.2170780748128891,
0.3875751495361328,
0.6222163438796997,
-0.3295997083187103,
0.40381884574890137,
0.5810158252716064,
-0.10986148566007614,
0.5045870542526245,
-0.14673128724098206,
-0.09632427990436554,
-1.107564091682434,
0.41409236192703247,
0.05198637768626213,
-0.24665413796901703,
-0.6755636930465698,
0.5455326437950134,
0.4217834174633026,
-0.18830974400043488,
-0.6404749155044556,
0.4503903090953827,
-0.6402449607849121,
-0.31970617175102234,
-0.3717903792858124,
0.0034338331315666437,
0.14608649909496307,
0.5796627402305603,
-0.05193803086876869,
0.6893110275268555,
0.3695882260799408,
-0.7590094804763794,
0.6082215905189514,
-0.03438475355505943,
-0.5756404995918274,
0.3486253023147583,
-0.6970598697662354,
0.25729212164878845,
0.07850480824708939,
-0.03820386156439781,
-1.0261268615722656,
-0.5113368630409241,
-0.1578962653875351,
-0.3263533115386963,
0.3936844766139984,
-0.04493599385023117,
-0.6676989793777466,
-0.7806472182273865,
-0.37430498003959656,
0.14402922987937927,
0.3258926272392273,
-0.43948328495025635,
0.516319990158081,
0.18421177566051483,
0.009482542052865028,
-0.24377602338790894,
-0.7897469401359558,
0.4181360602378845,
-0.2205520123243332,
-0.5304093360900879,
0.3689402639865875,
-0.2222568243741989,
-0.11532505601644516,
-0.1790439784526825,
-0.14665618538856506,
-0.1448454111814499,
0.22177596390247345,
-0.09424489736557007,
0.225294291973114,
-0.41554832458496094,
0.23395273089408875,
-0.24797476828098297,
-0.315339058637619,
0.14647763967514038,
-0.3004082143306732,
0.5880017876625061,
-0.023692550137639046,
-0.25920552015304565,
-0.24535101652145386,
0.30677926540374756,
0.6994968056678772,
-0.8264113664627075,
0.35375380516052246,
0.7665246725082397,
-0.3050955832004547,
-0.2554885745048523,
-0.6880816221237183,
-0.04070459306240082,
-0.4808185398578644,
0.5707482695579529,
-0.2651691436767578,
-0.9583382606506348,
0.2948666512966156,
-0.08762741833925247,
0.20612458884716034,
0.03888874500989914,
0.5247688889503479,
0.3940570652484894,
1.0939445495605469,
0.7719551920890808,
-0.17698580026626587,
0.3920218348503113,
-0.08547903597354889,
0.22350621223449707,
-0.9650737643241882,
-0.026522764936089516,
-0.6888988614082336,
-0.23390692472457886,
-0.45799535512924194,
-0.3826933205127716,
0.16164566576480865,
-0.01710573025047779,
-0.09112491458654404,
0.4482644200325012,
-0.6407608985900879,
0.48675093054771423,
0.5758032202720642,
-0.07374608516693115,
0.29172268509864807,
0.05668162927031517,
-0.13436755537986755,
0.02668210119009018,
-0.567194938659668,
-0.5830957293510437,
1.1506317853927612,
0.32872703671455383,
0.6874784827232361,
0.40492379665374756,
0.6804385781288147,
0.07323184609413147,
0.4207942485809326,
-0.708939790725708,
0.537774384021759,
-0.026647120714187622,
-0.7388426065444946,
-0.12109348922967911,
-0.5378047823905945,
-0.5891884565353394,
0.028936661779880524,
0.06472975015640259,
-0.635657787322998,
-0.27575621008872986,
0.18705913424491882,
-0.5536895990371704,
-0.10003908723592758,
-0.7528306245803833,
1.0692745447158813,
-0.36518043279647827,
-0.6114001870155334,
-0.15254758298397064,
-0.5534366965293884,
0.48142296075820923,
-0.2830843925476074,
0.20732440054416656,
-0.11777833849191666,
-0.10958746820688248,
0.5088123083114624,
-0.13293226063251495,
0.8168416023254395,
-0.09571485966444016,
-0.4395762085914612,
0.2545212209224701,
-0.08805574476718903,
0.5705581903457642,
0.2614477276802063,
-0.2218569964170456,
-0.21506981551647186,
-0.5163511037826538,
-0.2138744741678238,
-0.2622326910495758,
0.7424561381340027,
-0.2959626615047455,
-0.3677343428134918,
-0.05917395278811455,
-0.5847000479698181,
-0.2940974533557892,
0.2970770299434662,
0.09007150679826736,
0.6673570871353149,
-0.1640801727771759,
0.3594430685043335,
0.653110921382904,
-0.4505816698074341,
0.7568671703338623,
0.3217660188674927,
-0.307023823261261,
-0.4499492049217224,
0.7555841207504272,
-0.19986899197101593,
0.3397432565689087,
0.511292040348053,
0.07654467970132828,
-0.41815486550331116,
-0.5312253832817078,
-0.30239298939704895,
-0.08639787137508392,
-0.5806068181991577,
-0.47998565435409546,
-0.7068502902984619,
-0.19634346663951874,
-0.525730550289154,
-0.07679364830255508,
-0.3042260408401489,
0.026453731581568718,
-0.16882196068763733,
0.06091374531388283,
0.2904874384403229,
0.47308507561683655,
0.4020427167415619,
0.09378913789987564,
-1.1591986417770386,
0.5725423693656921,
0.3602394163608551,
0.5295036435127258,
-0.06060191988945007,
-0.4570276439189911,
-0.43667128682136536,
-0.12628820538520813,
-0.25591275095939636,
-0.5395877361297607,
0.5236194133758545,
0.25848907232284546,
0.6751317381858826,
0.37833845615386963,
0.06806968152523041,
0.5976100564002991,
-0.4304138123989105,
0.5159396529197693,
0.34808582067489624,
-1.0111796855926514,
0.7089067697525024,
-0.2417806088924408,
0.8336632251739502,
0.5150490403175354,
-0.07134035229682922,
-0.3030019998550415,
-0.6477867960929871,
-0.33636802434921265,
-0.7506994009017944,
0.6797847747802734,
0.18075767159461975,
0.34829357266426086,
-0.07993757724761963,
0.16536758840084076,
-0.06971766799688339,
0.3643321692943573,
-0.904016375541687,
0.09715750813484192,
0.08007882535457611,
-0.3074357509613037,
-0.191734179854393,
-0.2937907576560974,
0.08700962364673615,
-0.1738162785768509,
0.33156803250312805,
-0.6345983147621155,
0.26166898012161255,
-0.010243061929941177,
-0.2809712588787079,
-0.08959747105836868,
0.4676183760166168,
0.625706136226654,
0.7468305230140686,
-0.10640709847211838,
0.2635018527507782,
0.09877190738916397,
-0.41002407670021057,
-0.0660029724240303,
0.12029782682657242,
-0.030562134459614754,
-0.026640569791197777,
0.3753432035446167,
0.56253582239151,
0.6672832369804382,
-0.8777759671211243,
0.40865591168403625,
-0.08283077925443649,
-0.19850483536720276,
-0.24789512157440186,
0.3887287974357605,
0.30516573786735535,
0.1730557382106781,
0.41034311056137085,
0.18361912667751312,
0.15087653696537018,
-0.35063645243644714,
0.35606610774993896,
0.382257342338562,
-0.36602699756622314,
-0.1485537439584732,
0.5572038292884827,
0.5498430728912354,
-0.3853580951690674,
0.3298354148864746,
-0.4036029875278473,
-0.7160552740097046,
0.8537598252296448,
0.6706209778785706,
0.9092177152633667,
-0.01149972528219223,
0.05959700420498848,
0.4639953672885895,
0.39323756098747253,
0.029092542827129364,
0.4199488162994385,
-0.051267120987176895,
-0.5675016045570374,
-0.7935888767242432,
-0.7057582139968872,
-0.1044897586107254,
0.04171092063188553,
-0.6025434136390686,
0.40308472514152527,
-0.35026809573173523,
-0.1237005814909935,
-0.19329771399497986,
0.12890265882015228,
-0.8029258251190186,
-0.046343911439180374,
0.36053070425987244,
0.8721667528152466,
-0.2694063186645508,
0.9601397514343262,
0.788796067237854,
-0.2804112434387207,
-0.6579622626304626,
0.05718626454472542,
-0.056841105222702026,
-0.5983080863952637,
0.6802257299423218,
0.7329232096672058,
0.0006191771244630218,
0.2498881071805954,
-0.45902490615844727,
-0.8939529657363892,
0.8224555253982544,
0.35189661383628845,
-0.8305347561836243,
0.10961774736642838,
0.18925216794013977,
0.4350473880767822,
-0.5002453923225403,
0.026582805439829826,
0.5856593251228333,
0.4385131001472473,
-0.0711413100361824,
-0.8166609406471252,
-0.03046819381415844,
-0.2759362459182739,
0.16506896913051605,
0.3846466839313507,
-0.30585044622421265,
0.554725706577301,
-0.41865792870521545,
-0.2533508837223053,
0.06761026382446289,
0.5224704146385193,
0.23234283924102783,
0.20992501080036163,
0.1810079962015152,
0.4912374019622803,
0.6396077871322632,
0.049817707389593124,
1.0450363159179688,
-0.5344245433807373,
0.2218938171863556,
1.1678423881530762,
-0.6556825637817383,
0.9238306283950806,
0.4873904883861542,
-0.1819625347852707,
0.30014753341674805,
0.1529444307088852,
-0.06226636469364166,
0.4022080898284912,
0.4831393361091614,
-0.20238934457302094,
-0.20315736532211304,
-0.03897589445114136,
-0.465759813785553,
0.5261912941932678,
0.11374447494745255,
-0.368768572807312,
-0.04101460054516792,
0.0384211428463459,
-0.2192978709936142,
0.1515531986951828,
-0.2143917828798294,
0.9027485251426697,
-0.015612572431564331,
-0.6920223832130432,
0.5868420004844666,
0.16529406607151031,
0.9540936350822449,
-0.5713539123535156,
-0.0751240998506546,
-0.2434452325105667,
0.4612548351287842,
-0.1787118762731552,
-0.38902732729911804,
0.3109360933303833,
0.36984723806381226,
-0.089664526283741,
-0.08606430143117905,
0.7140361070632935,
-0.4016997814178467,
-0.6620400547981262,
0.4320312440395355,
0.42135754227638245,
-0.2312907576560974,
-0.16909624636173248,
-0.6844038367271423,
0.2107616513967514,
0.1682492345571518,
-0.09483607858419418,
0.27271223068237305,
0.40310415625572205,
0.42842647433280945,
0.5480183959007263,
0.8339730501174927,
0.015623195096850395,
0.36775800585746765,
0.22909343242645264,
0.8482528924942017,
-0.782739520072937,
-0.5636787414550781,
-0.8784675598144531,
0.5505527853965759,
-0.40295204520225525,
-0.4866268038749695,
0.8123302459716797,
0.7201459407806396,
0.7038624286651611,
-0.11457857489585876,
0.8028618693351746,
-0.11365575343370438,
0.4358195662498474,
-0.5331740975379944,
0.4918700158596039,
-0.41509583592414856,
0.42987963557243347,
-0.39884182810783386,
-1.2671189308166504,
-0.6186848878860474,
0.4930424690246582,
-0.00028117859619669616,
-0.001772862859070301,
0.7934085726737976,
0.9229035377502441,
0.014670059084892273,
-0.15098509192466736,
0.24188672006130219,
-0.1163656935095787,
0.46335139870643616,
0.7495132684707642,
0.8426685333251953,
-0.3377837836742401,
0.844800591468811,
-0.14059902727603912,
-0.18936726450920105,
-0.35427597165107727,
-1.0587997436523438,
-1.0444217920303345,
0.013230916112661362,
-0.48016151785850525,
-0.15818069875240326,
-0.21632350981235504,
1.123916506767273,
0.6701135039329529,
-0.822868287563324,
-0.20356711745262146,
-0.4638088047504425,
-0.015041165985167027,
-0.18996626138687134,
-0.24832582473754883,
0.12292148917913437,
-0.7931987643241882,
-0.6692891716957092,
0.43932241201400757,
0.422788143157959,
-0.16719169914722443,
-0.4372348487377167,
-0.3706667721271515,
-0.17530207335948944,
-0.14575107395648956,
0.7332993745803833,
0.08740559220314026,
-0.5049642324447632,
-0.16020715236663818,
0.17544259130954742,
-0.3822823762893677,
0.09799850732088089,
0.9514656066894531,
-0.5361320972442627,
0.3288362920284271,
0.40467968583106995,
0.9687803387641907,
0.1246790960431099,
-0.1798134446144104,
0.5365709662437439,
-0.9533926248550415,
0.043474435806274414,
0.21299396455287933,
0.29801926016807556,
0.3893333077430725,
-0.21988019347190857,
0.5739439129829407,
-0.004286303650587797,
-0.32607483863830566,
-0.8466517925262451,
0.26278018951416016,
-0.6180189847946167,
-0.15085676312446594,
1.3095461130142212,
0.02010529860854149,
-0.123526930809021,
-0.42258602380752563,
-0.2089124172925949,
0.06692424416542053,
-0.43861955404281616,
0.5356772541999817,
0.4950070083141327,
0.11750035732984543,
-0.14399771392345428,
-0.7091264724731445,
0.5032923817634583,
0.38981592655181885,
-1.1327909231185913,
0.2503209710121155,
0.5415512919425964,
0.005988443735986948,
0.38179534673690796,
0.4292985200881958,
-0.22341397404670715,
0.4264678955078125,
-0.27239522337913513,
0.3554016053676605,
0.0007979556685313582,
-0.4018053412437439,
-0.4446781277656555,
0.3513330817222595,
0.22781400382518768,
-0.009369179606437683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14240v1 | Enhanced Labeling Technique for Reddit Text and Fine-Tuned Longformer Models for Classifying Depression Severity in English and Luganda | 2024-01-25T15:28:07 | 2024-01-25T15:28:07 | Richard Kimera, Daniela N. Rim, Joseph Kirabira, Ubong Godwin Udomah, Heeyoul Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Depression is a global burden and one of the most challenging mental health
conditions to control. Experts can detect its severity early using the Beck
Depression Inventory (BDI) questionnaire, administer appropriate medication to
patients, and impede its progression. Due to the fear of potential
stigmatization, many patients turn to social media platforms like Reddit for
advice and assistance at various stages of their journey. This research
extracts text from Reddit to facilitate the diagnostic process. It employs a
proposed labeling approach to categorize the text and subsequently fine-tunes
the Longformer model. The model's performance is compared against baseline
models, including Naive Bayes, Random Forest, Support Vector Machines, and
Gradient Boosting. Our findings reveal that the Longformer model outperforms
the baseline models in both English (48%) and Luganda (45%) languages on a
custom-made dataset. | [
-0.3540019392967224,
-0.9374757409095764,
0.5776980519294739,
0.5055624842643738,
-0.28571945428848267,
-0.08654908090829849,
-0.4800380766391754,
-0.9344858527183533,
0.5554643869400024,
0.21523192524909973,
-0.5727297067642212,
-0.7362157702445984,
-0.9345554113388062,
0.5607680082321167,
-0.061647552996873856,
1.265076994895935,
-0.06809577345848083,
0.03158104792237282,
-0.13702668249607086,
0.09629402309656143,
-0.40338069200515747,
-0.47778159379959106,
-0.9358368515968323,
-0.28540563583374023,
0.9460577368736267,
0.03363003954291344,
0.6800386905670166,
0.05195188149809837,
0.7906002402305603,
0.23604434728622437,
-0.5568985939025879,
-0.018925411626696587,
-0.5383146405220032,
0.0255589559674263,
-0.4117136001586914,
-0.34096160531044006,
-0.6899242401123047,
-0.24359025061130524,
0.032329585403203964,
0.5353416800498962,
-0.0032528196461498737,
0.23991577327251434,
0.34740951657295227,
0.45446866750717163,
-0.5162321925163269,
0.02763230912387371,
0.019431019201874733,
0.0004417395393829793,
-0.23911219835281372,
0.24202752113342285,
-0.27882009744644165,
-0.546529233455658,
-0.010252855718135834,
-0.5025358200073242,
0.13243357837200165,
-0.3908765912055969,
0.841302216053009,
0.37635788321495056,
-0.49968454241752625,
-0.3863523602485657,
-0.9006118774414062,
0.8970822095870972,
-0.45968788862228394,
0.21691952645778656,
0.41479605436325073,
0.3788870573043823,
0.17787915468215942,
-0.7200230956077576,
-0.17917218804359436,
0.2952767014503479,
-0.4694596529006958,
0.04479654133319855,
-0.4000164866447449,
0.02625386416912079,
0.30632078647613525,
0.3764673173427582,
-0.635263204574585,
0.4580156207084656,
-0.6695353388786316,
-0.07648447155952454,
0.7673358917236328,
-0.07433831691741943,
0.3009571135044098,
-0.5339550971984863,
-0.32506507635116577,
0.39469921588897705,
-0.12604565918445587,
0.0008393157040700316,
-0.14256419241428375,
0.10698703676462173,
0.025689205154776573,
0.6021910309791565,
-0.14172394573688507,
0.6756604313850403,
0.012610508129000664,
-0.22166815400123596,
0.12841467559337616,
-0.23151594400405884,
-0.27724820375442505,
0.07514127343893051,
0.6465844511985779,
0.8686698079109192,
0.137172132730484,
0.15043315291404724,
-0.27480316162109375,
0.4587516188621521,
0.3753410577774048,
-0.7665143013000488,
-0.4058445394039154,
0.41346636414527893,
-0.7942714095115662,
-0.06099614128470421,
-0.38990524411201477,
-1.1843886375427246,
-0.6198563575744629,
-0.1678120344877243,
0.40305885672569275,
-0.29190337657928467,
-0.24257300794124603,
0.2760622203350067,
-0.04852871596813202,
-0.360932856798172,
0.34507906436920166,
-0.6259196400642395,
0.2055569440126419,
0.7381091713905334,
0.9940676689147949,
-0.389654278755188,
0.34638962149620056,
-0.17476552724838257,
-0.057537514716386795,
-0.08887555450201035,
0.9576399326324463,
-0.5102916955947876,
-0.3242117464542389,
0.2059638500213623,
0.21426112949848175,
0.001661840477026999,
-0.4253182113170624,
0.9922698140144348,
-0.2422516793012619,
0.2091548591852188,
-0.031010471284389496,
-0.6220195293426514,
-0.16778616607189178,
0.1554081290960312,
-0.7778016328811646,
0.7867674231529236,
0.37715163826942444,
-0.8665400147438049,
0.25256413221359253,
-0.6870608329772949,
-0.42542901635169983,
0.2701685130596161,
0.37277090549468994,
-0.3793353736400604,
0.1861870139837265,
0.42568907141685486,
0.8244389891624451,
-0.12677805125713348,
0.2565102279186249,
-0.3077675998210907,
-0.2769542634487152,
0.24874792993068695,
-0.2458389401435852,
0.5666015148162842,
0.24042867124080658,
-0.06076116859912872,
0.035336934030056,
-0.9605545997619629,
-0.01941964030265808,
-0.11559854447841644,
-0.4088072180747986,
-0.833310067653656,
-0.04563087224960327,
0.22940704226493835,
0.09772022813558578,
0.3755103349685669,
-0.5566422939300537,
-0.03416476026177406,
-0.42716285586357117,
0.5138158798217773,
0.4536799192428589,
0.3460465669631958,
-0.031013013795018196,
-0.13062116503715515,
0.712340235710144,
-0.06650861352682114,
0.32220759987831116,
-0.05459219962358475,
-0.6658879518508911,
-0.47224491834640503,
-0.6837230920791626,
0.3399926424026489,
0.6720276474952698,
-0.18452556431293488,
0.7815663814544678,
-0.23936377465724945,
-0.5724136829376221,
-0.9444348216056824,
0.08446909487247467,
0.28095921874046326,
0.3803149163722992,
0.7367728352546692,
-0.05267787352204323,
-0.3940063416957855,
-1.0162463188171387,
-0.07826129347085953,
0.37131571769714355,
0.01294449158012867,
0.11019666492938995,
0.3429643213748932,
-0.8241485357284546,
0.46168196201324463,
-0.9316263198852539,
-0.5307221412658691,
-0.3606846034526825,
0.43501541018486023,
0.42239001393318176,
0.22780866920948029,
0.3287927210330963,
-0.5627636313438416,
-0.5674077272415161,
0.23021824657917023,
-0.6038098931312561,
-0.21200065314769745,
-0.01859164796769619,
-0.1304822564125061,
0.18820859491825104,
0.33644017577171326,
-0.7246646881103516,
0.5366316437721252,
0.44640496373176575,
-0.25006479024887085,
0.26322808861732483,
-0.13950131833553314,
0.0032473825849592686,
-1.144201636314392,
0.11398562788963318,
0.5290319919586182,
-0.34467244148254395,
-0.3972431421279907,
-0.2904125154018402,
0.11577114462852478,
-0.2818011939525604,
-0.0728754848241806,
0.2114444375038147,
-0.11440384387969971,
0.4309156537055969,
-0.20105837285518646,
0.12195184081792831,
0.16967865824699402,
-0.02505900338292122,
-0.023943327367305756,
0.39266452193260193,
0.5541791319847107,
-0.5119503736495972,
0.48864826560020447,
0.16855919361114502,
-0.5424941778182983,
0.737206220626831,
-0.7751630544662476,
-0.3238146901130676,
-0.39274412393569946,
0.2653544843196869,
-1.0965873003005981,
-0.21664047241210938,
0.13675881922245026,
-0.2308320850133896,
0.23284566402435303,
0.06318169087171555,
-0.20446321368217468,
-0.6893125772476196,
-0.12484154105186462,
0.48464545607566833,
0.43090134859085083,
-0.30449143052101135,
0.07065801322460175,
0.19056010246276855,
-0.6361863613128662,
-0.3957531154155731,
-0.7182831764221191,
0.05171144753694534,
-0.5244701504707336,
-0.3429545760154724,
0.6089562177658081,
-0.1773054152727127,
-0.25819525122642517,
-0.11085359752178192,
0.20156970620155334,
-0.19947704672813416,
0.12310786545276642,
0.1844663918018341,
-0.01005179900676012,
-0.12123122811317444,
0.46619415283203125,
0.18049408495426178,
-0.27123820781707764,
0.2337835282087326,
0.43698862195014954,
0.6050084233283997,
0.3015742599964142,
0.11644379049539566,
-0.9515640735626221,
0.6805749535560608,
0.33631089329719543,
-0.14770172536373138,
0.7616780400276184,
0.4777590036392212,
-0.6424171924591064,
-0.3524695038795471,
-0.31514671444892883,
-0.07591771334409714,
-0.41485506296157837,
0.4304560720920563,
-0.08506066352128983,
-0.6998099088668823,
0.2897808849811554,
-0.2760562598705292,
-0.18111063539981842,
0.38597989082336426,
0.25489339232444763,
-0.2523479163646698,
1.2453681230545044,
1.0006937980651855,
-0.1104264184832573,
0.16143469512462616,
-0.040070608258247375,
0.4627801179885864,
-0.3853128254413605,
-0.050813689827919006,
-0.5051469206809998,
-0.4571097493171692,
-0.4819457530975342,
-0.28894689679145813,
0.3796907067298889,
0.24774031341075897,
0.001102831563912332,
0.04853648319840431,
-0.7932683825492859,
0.42932918667793274,
0.15000441670417786,
0.41920238733291626,
0.3120211660861969,
0.0057042804546654224,
0.5195212364196777,
-0.5616284608840942,
-0.31923747062683105,
-0.5662313103675842,
0.7269824147224426,
0.6005647778511047,
0.8326718807220459,
-0.026123959571123123,
0.7199190855026245,
0.602290689945221,
0.5107128620147705,
-0.9335501790046692,
0.22229933738708496,
-0.35289663076400757,
-0.35470011830329895,
-0.09163085371255875,
-0.23894591629505157,
-1.0523810386657715,
-0.2449209839105606,
-0.0428742878139019,
-0.6106175780296326,
0.26255518198013306,
0.006361085921525955,
-0.6533014178276062,
-0.13701602816581726,
-0.8367020487785339,
0.8157500624656677,
-0.2567004859447479,
0.09705616533756256,
-0.35176482796669006,
-0.5560812950134277,
0.427703320980072,
-0.30357035994529724,
0.3706021308898926,
-0.017695249989628792,
0.06407256424427032,
0.8641741871833801,
-0.10829248279333115,
1.107399344444275,
0.04367349296808243,
-0.49506494402885437,
-0.15820030868053436,
-0.14457111060619354,
0.16731402277946472,
0.19878244400024414,
-0.12951166927814484,
-0.07652665674686432,
-0.00612301891669631,
-0.37720125913619995,
-0.6547115445137024,
0.6645871996879578,
-0.7118051648139954,
-0.44527667760849,
-0.23752745985984802,
-0.017409678548574448,
-0.013242115266621113,
0.3209458589553833,
0.47017648816108704,
0.24200546741485596,
-0.25824451446533203,
-0.03608711063861847,
0.6166866421699524,
-0.43084752559661865,
0.2333325892686844,
0.14415116608142853,
-0.3024596571922302,
-0.7407209873199463,
0.6667711734771729,
0.2941840887069702,
-0.07021228969097137,
0.3756377100944519,
0.06474114209413528,
-0.16298706829547882,
-0.20642660558223724,
0.14088864624500275,
0.6693626642227173,
-0.838394045829773,
-0.5178464651107788,
-0.5761098265647888,
-0.38320791721343994,
-0.2770216464996338,
-0.3431112468242645,
-0.24625955522060394,
-0.37253883481025696,
-0.6004641652107239,
-0.570817768573761,
0.5046067237854004,
0.9623233079910278,
0.06469829380512238,
0.32020458579063416,
-0.79136061668396,
0.40327656269073486,
0.22320397198200226,
0.5655538439750671,
-0.1634497493505478,
0.07681591063737869,
-0.298772931098938,
0.02042244002223015,
-0.26254817843437195,
-1.0251034498214722,
0.42724522948265076,
0.21842879056930542,
0.22232066094875336,
0.6900923252105713,
0.355135440826416,
0.8297045230865479,
-0.08541790395975113,
0.7620804309844971,
0.31231072545051575,
-0.7460900545120239,
0.9967082142829895,
-0.022085612639784813,
0.08871742337942123,
0.3416474163532257,
1.1328585147857666,
-0.6898000836372375,
-0.327421098947525,
-0.2633608877658844,
-0.892389714717865,
0.45313212275505066,
-0.050831880420446396,
0.19432605803012848,
-0.3587919771671295,
0.44173863530158997,
0.33636292815208435,
-0.16902892291545868,
-0.9112094640731812,
-0.16372548043727875,
-0.08736951649188995,
-0.46556735038757324,
-0.5537065863609314,
-0.6794219017028809,
-0.2767527401447296,
-0.43095624446868896,
0.413189560174942,
0.2552295923233032,
0.24822010099887848,
0.47608888149261475,
-0.29385095834732056,
-0.20852310955524445,
0.3464965224266052,
0.2758910357952118,
0.8519042730331421,
-0.24517357349395752,
0.26933586597442627,
-0.21139302849769592,
-0.09301675111055374,
-0.0703454315662384,
0.35205963253974915,
-0.2107854038476944,
0.24704235792160034,
0.3301354944705963,
0.7605294585227966,
0.1558634489774704,
-0.6488341093063354,
0.3952232003211975,
-0.08367036283016205,
-0.15954114496707916,
-0.21904784440994263,
0.004880087915807962,
0.10713644325733185,
0.33729514479637146,
0.09992371499538422,
-0.16836735606193542,
0.08470037579536438,
-0.2488318532705307,
0.17001710832118988,
0.1727471798658371,
-0.4856158196926117,
-0.5378068089485168,
0.41274091601371765,
0.3827114999294281,
-0.6515992879867554,
0.49314144253730774,
-0.09355366230010986,
-0.36875852942466736,
0.4578305780887604,
0.712958037853241,
0.5247979760169983,
-0.3700628876686096,
0.5838052034378052,
0.4910816252231598,
0.13307170569896698,
-0.19208109378814697,
0.452248752117157,
0.135658398270607,
-0.33191999793052673,
-0.3220031261444092,
-0.8365114331245422,
0.008771106600761414,
0.4435073733329773,
-0.8662450313568115,
0.5191052556037903,
-0.38887184858322144,
-0.6803366541862488,
0.29635217785835266,
-0.09031956642866135,
-0.31663280725479126,
0.43865326046943665,
0.2678152024745941,
0.8182833194732666,
-0.8618735074996948,
0.321036696434021,
0.9874944686889648,
-0.15562404692173004,
-0.03177008405327797,
0.08956781774759293,
-0.35214194655418396,
-0.14817053079605103,
0.34002190828323364,
0.685711681842804,
0.16791482269763947,
0.01886684261262417,
-0.34742599725723267,
-0.7816304564476013,
0.7020222544670105,
-0.04540419951081276,
-0.48534339666366577,
0.1787131428718567,
-0.0006019846186973155,
0.9425041079521179,
-0.13362441956996918,
0.11077225208282471,
0.4816007614135742,
0.5474790930747986,
-0.40067392587661743,
-0.9140000939369202,
-0.007701626978814602,
-0.3808251917362213,
-0.029276039451360703,
0.3127819001674652,
-0.4579401910305023,
0.5835023522377014,
-0.0552811473608017,
-0.45700693130493164,
-0.06621745973825455,
0.6138331294059753,
-0.15778270363807678,
0.26486656069755554,
0.36878347396850586,
0.7576239705085754,
1.090612769126892,
0.23637959361076355,
0.8154739141464233,
-0.24475359916687012,
0.5399868488311768,
0.611698567867279,
-0.19445495307445526,
0.9828192591667175,
0.07101918756961823,
-0.19019541144371033,
0.5848987102508545,
0.7557187080383301,
-0.09365873783826828,
0.42961055040359497,
0.091797836124897,
-0.35386738181114197,
-0.23371131718158722,
-0.19899310171604156,
-0.36962422728538513,
0.030724622309207916,
0.6307113170623779,
-0.645079493522644,
-0.41913068294525146,
0.4918626546859741,
0.3184477686882019,
0.31581228971481323,
-0.47969868779182434,
0.8099637627601624,
0.12549462914466858,
-0.6580439209938049,
1.031670093536377,
0.1586427092552185,
0.9302719831466675,
-0.3296055793762207,
0.11519119888544083,
-0.26119232177734375,
0.4643886089324951,
-0.31898853182792664,
-0.7749364972114563,
0.6064355373382568,
0.3069741129875183,
-0.5065667033195496,
-0.3213699758052826,
0.7587943077087402,
-0.47422343492507935,
-1.0059428215026855,
0.658865213394165,
0.44938012957572937,
0.0073856571689248085,
-0.0194697268307209,
-0.6155297160148621,
-0.1799110770225525,
-0.13133572041988373,
-0.19102594256401062,
0.2885589599609375,
0.531073272228241,
-0.11072732508182526,
0.7979706525802612,
0.13490715622901917,
0.2262779176235199,
-0.23811666667461395,
-0.028220074251294136,
0.6846082210540771,
-0.8736152052879333,
-0.4393218755722046,
-0.8205231428146362,
0.36894556879997253,
-0.2431333214044571,
-0.43123018741607666,
0.5195865631103516,
0.3695831596851349,
0.5634468197822571,
-0.15000809729099274,
0.6441053748130798,
0.0229171272367239,
0.9518415927886963,
-0.1730147898197174,
0.7846122980117798,
-0.7358391284942627,
-0.09502299875020981,
-0.22312921285629272,
-0.696618378162384,
-0.6555237770080566,
0.5757257342338562,
-0.1947775036096573,
-0.16044485569000244,
0.7701830267906189,
0.7139090299606323,
-0.1397807002067566,
-0.09823688119649887,
-0.01227383129298687,
0.5028638243675232,
0.2327268123626709,
0.5052640438079834,
0.7895904779434204,
-0.05222231522202492,
0.392687052488327,
-0.6370984315872192,
-0.21546834707260132,
-0.16284771263599396,
-0.6627514958381653,
-0.9750592112541199,
-0.3867047131061554,
-0.6766307353973389,
-0.21437138319015503,
0.0977633073925972,
0.7534319162368774,
0.2517448961734772,
-0.5885481834411621,
0.1333293318748474,
0.32923319935798645,
0.3450670838356018,
-0.40778031945228577,
-0.3354254364967346,
0.4430009424686432,
-0.3534599542617798,
-0.715968668460846,
0.05093103274703026,
0.14874374866485596,
0.08041157573461533,
-0.07709251344203949,
0.33851194381713867,
-0.031193658709526062,
-0.1740591824054718,
0.79571533203125,
-0.21745921671390533,
-0.5117744207382202,
-0.03922124207019806,
-0.28310903906822205,
-0.27719175815582275,
0.1660149097442627,
0.4544036090373993,
-0.6215729713439941,
0.16661107540130615,
0.47836771607398987,
0.29502177238464355,
-0.015353952534496784,
0.4258233904838562,
0.5409647822380066,
-0.5410565733909607,
-0.17699168622493744,
0.2800396978855133,
0.113343745470047,
0.38429197669029236,
-0.7587279677391052,
0.23098789155483246,
0.1315871775150299,
-0.6075868010520935,
-0.8160181641578674,
0.04709957540035248,
-0.8785802125930786,
-0.725250244140625,
1.1122140884399414,
-0.31251394748687744,
-0.34767386317253113,
-0.3265921473503113,
-0.43761375546455383,
0.18877723813056946,
-0.4173124134540558,
1.2588707208633423,
0.8010430932044983,
-0.010190870612859726,
-0.24685873091220856,
-0.513516902923584,
0.6936459541320801,
0.24730049073696136,
-0.6732087135314941,
0.141443133354187,
0.42072561383247375,
0.0945022851228714,
0.2797006368637085,
0.48365646600723267,
0.12410886585712433,
0.08764942735433578,
-0.7471899390220642,
0.022055665031075478,
0.501164436340332,
-0.12811662256717682,
-0.4189898669719696,
0.3056246042251587,
-0.34411153197288513,
0.1617235690355301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14228v1 | Assessing the Portability of Parameter Matrices Trained by Parameter-Efficient Finetuning Methods | 2024-01-25T15:11:07 | 2024-01-25T15:11:07 | Mohammed Sabry, Anya Belz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As the cost of training ever larger language models has grown, so has the
interest in reusing previously learnt knowledge. Transfer learning methods have
shown how reusing non-task-specific knowledge can help in subsequent
task-specific learning. In this paper, we investigate the inverse: porting
whole functional modules that encode task-specific knowledge from one model to
another. We designed a study comprising 1,440 training/testing runs to test the
portability of modules trained by parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT)
techniques, using sentiment analysis as an example task. We test portability in
a wide range of scenarios, involving different PEFT techniques and different
pretrained host models, among other dimensions. We compare the performance of
ported modules with that of equivalent modules trained (i) from scratch, and
(ii) from parameters sampled from the same distribution as the ported module.
We find that the ported modules far outperform the two alternatives tested, but
that there are interesting performance differences between the four PEFT
techniques. We conclude that task-specific knowledge in the form of
structurally modular sets of parameters as produced by PEFT techniques is
highly portable, but that degree of success depends on type of PEFT and on
differences between originating and receiving pretrained models. | [
-0.5653817057609558,
-0.6367359757423401,
0.6727648377418518,
0.15146692097187042,
-0.4580004811286926,
-0.29887551069259644,
-0.464084655046463,
-0.07224982976913452,
-0.09334196150302887,
0.4073951840400696,
-0.3181125223636627,
-0.154689759016037,
-0.5644301176071167,
0.06814498454332352,
-0.6882877945899963,
0.8917308449745178,
-0.2148059606552124,
-0.06696582585573196,
-0.5056133270263672,
-0.23807884752750397,
-0.26273420453071594,
-0.6217184662818909,
-0.4516025483608246,
-0.06730647385120392,
0.4773639738559723,
0.43185997009277344,
0.46584028005599976,
0.35400059819221497,
0.4946401119232178,
0.2393755316734314,
0.16214965283870697,
-0.3200185298919678,
-0.4394362270832062,
-0.12129012495279312,
-0.5533595681190491,
-0.8823518753051758,
-0.43145492672920227,
0.003533498151227832,
0.6871833205223083,
0.8480237126350403,
0.05371834710240364,
0.700096070766449,
0.6023977994918823,
0.6480674147605896,
-0.46276336908340454,
0.24303853511810303,
-0.7085743546485901,
0.08529339730739594,
-0.0705379992723465,
-0.17125429213047028,
-0.6623632907867432,
-0.34749937057495117,
0.23705853521823883,
-0.5597668290138245,
0.21431167423725128,
-0.20971903204917908,
0.7877174019813538,
0.18105071783065796,
-0.46836790442466736,
0.2598206400871277,
-0.8866733312606812,
0.952831506729126,
-0.7658610939979553,
0.5984593629837036,
0.40080973505973816,
0.5290637016296387,
0.1471083164215088,
-0.7073736190795898,
-0.34607356786727905,
-0.4086231291294098,
-0.2820219397544861,
-0.09959229826927185,
-0.13145840167999268,
0.24152660369873047,
0.22692686319351196,
0.14133337140083313,
-0.46653908491134644,
-0.24326728284358978,
-0.6979362964630127,
-0.14664004743099213,
0.46705570816993713,
-0.28436279296875,
0.21032388508319855,
-0.11915095895528793,
-0.2624858021736145,
-0.14584311842918396,
-0.7695925831794739,
0.2458510547876358,
0.48895859718322754,
0.5625910758972168,
-0.045677147805690765,
0.39622995257377625,
-0.280408650636673,
0.9204871654510498,
0.33303990960121155,
-0.177035853266716,
0.23634816706180573,
-0.3175504505634308,
-0.20094870030879974,
-0.4116652309894562,
0.4011942148208618,
0.08591524511575699,
0.21996532380580902,
-0.34197357296943665,
-0.21877945959568024,
-0.5638082027435303,
0.8902167081832886,
-0.7126883268356323,
-0.11511432379484177,
-0.06358299404382706,
-0.9341747164726257,
-0.11616701632738113,
0.018553225323557854,
-0.5403630137443542,
0.09421979635953903,
-0.6846097111701965,
1.1750465631484985,
-0.34422945976257324,
-0.3241516649723053,
-0.09021243453025818,
0.02642945572733879,
0.3730315566062927,
0.29954418540000916,
-0.8026763796806335,
0.27568137645721436,
0.8496018052101135,
0.7488694787025452,
-0.44073429703712463,
-0.3070668876171112,
-0.5183163285255432,
-0.2933841943740845,
-0.03151097148656845,
0.8455497622489929,
-0.3436993360519409,
-0.08460959792137146,
-0.1185590922832489,
0.27607184648513794,
-0.46692541241645813,
-0.5512855648994446,
0.3695879876613617,
-0.3987494111061096,
-0.2593749165534973,
-0.2607403099536896,
-0.07584329694509506,
-0.5890747904777527,
0.5707906484603882,
-0.47555285692214966,
0.6036934852600098,
0.3680170178413391,
-0.48590409755706787,
0.29982924461364746,
-0.2039533108472824,
-0.5971134901046753,
-0.4744288921356201,
-0.04104532673954964,
-0.22082583606243134,
0.2969174087047577,
-0.46726343035697937,
0.8387798070907593,
-0.3166469633579254,
0.22606173157691956,
-0.5092938542366028,
-0.5629175901412964,
0.1296646147966385,
-0.4014992117881775,
0.3853732943534851,
0.3356323838233948,
-0.5998208522796631,
-0.1257558912038803,
-0.8825494050979614,
-0.09390881657600403,
-0.4167238175868988,
-0.6929842829704285,
-0.468906044960022,
0.024310162290930748,
-0.1813882291316986,
0.20149093866348267,
0.05106629058718681,
-0.6780231595039368,
0.07709445804357529,
-0.560719907283783,
0.3767043352127075,
0.5710537433624268,
-0.29782378673553467,
0.5960122346878052,
-0.48712223768234253,
0.5983875393867493,
0.022126827389001846,
0.32369688153266907,
0.27995914220809937,
-0.28843265771865845,
-0.8865383863449097,
-0.08713353425264359,
0.2528586983680725,
0.39758816361427307,
-0.5693396925926208,
0.1742708832025528,
-0.09486908465623856,
-0.7849621176719666,
-0.17296956479549408,
0.03979239612817764,
0.25634345412254333,
0.47148260474205017,
0.22097362577915192,
-0.4194560647010803,
-0.3985237777233124,
-1.228009581565857,
-0.43138131499290466,
-0.28357619047164917,
0.0681999996304512,
0.16257815062999725,
0.35657256841659546,
-0.015195404179394245,
0.8040139079093933,
-0.1640651524066925,
0.10848306864500046,
-0.3366502523422241,
-0.007342229131609201,
0.2316340208053589,
0.8695809841156006,
0.7320526242256165,
-0.49933773279190063,
-0.5733013153076172,
0.1340165138244629,
-0.3782464563846588,
0.08813101798295975,
-0.22004912793636322,
-0.22604435682296753,
-0.007875137031078339,
0.34590089321136475,
-0.546525239944458,
0.25125694274902344,
0.3477610945701599,
-0.11333385109901428,
0.5857457518577576,
-0.24822382628917694,
0.2820853888988495,
-1.0403666496276855,
0.4583485722541809,
-0.2785341739654541,
-0.4226396083831787,
-0.7111550569534302,
0.14579126238822937,
-0.053637612611055374,
-0.11417552083730698,
-0.4920263886451721,
0.28570693731307983,
-0.247297465801239,
-0.054475776851177216,
-0.16263233125209808,
-0.16416218876838684,
-0.11819018423557281,
0.5187366604804993,
-0.20315030217170715,
0.6020632982254028,
0.5839414596557617,
-0.6549042463302612,
0.15521381795406342,
0.07218880951404572,
-0.1529458910226822,
0.8073728084564209,
-0.4124733507633209,
0.11786257475614548,
-0.2809617817401886,
-0.24758343398571014,
-1.5560616254806519,
0.3424786627292633,
0.10987129807472229,
-0.366892546415329,
0.3374973237514496,
-0.41518905758857727,
-0.09210308641195297,
-0.04682089760899544,
-0.2210582196712494,
0.5311740040779114,
0.9183937311172485,
-0.5061757564544678,
0.8303676247596741,
0.0713423416018486,
-0.17804884910583496,
-0.5214540362358093,
-0.7892234921455383,
-0.597292959690094,
-0.6165974736213684,
-0.3905773162841797,
0.20623178780078888,
0.06263945996761322,
0.09147263318300247,
-0.14632689952850342,
-0.4320085346698761,
-0.4409050941467285,
0.4088153839111328,
0.4037730097770691,
-0.029614176601171494,
-0.4873194396495819,
0.10287607461214066,
0.2488187551498413,
-0.11367341876029968,
0.18585997819900513,
-0.44522613286972046,
0.2610708177089691,
-0.06181280314922333,
-0.4370794892311096,
-0.27795273065567017,
0.18215982615947723,
0.5391468405723572,
-0.1518501490354538,
0.7061157822608948,
0.7656898498535156,
-0.22012071311473846,
-0.35644400119781494,
-0.69500333070755,
-0.12272834777832031,
-0.47284936904907227,
0.287964791059494,
-0.567037045955658,
-0.7747964859008789,
0.4734855592250824,
-0.1976308375597,
0.14847904443740845,
0.42531266808509827,
0.1862582117319107,
-0.03904978185892105,
0.7419797778129578,
0.9618266224861145,
0.24080437421798706,
0.4585464596748352,
-0.24031348526477814,
0.2827153205871582,
-0.4563703238964081,
-0.050670869648456573,
-0.7371554374694824,
-0.5997130274772644,
-0.4370904564857483,
-0.4143696129322052,
0.07540524005889893,
0.13639304041862488,
-0.37036776542663574,
0.7544394135475159,
-0.25603124499320984,
0.22219689190387726,
0.6309301853179932,
0.20721574127674103,
0.34853142499923706,
0.2895791828632355,
-0.23266540467739105,
0.1343149095773697,
-0.7087833881378174,
-0.5870082378387451,
1.3613561391830444,
0.11545956879854202,
0.6093999743461609,
-0.054088249802589417,
0.6174851655960083,
0.1964714527130127,
0.4671407639980316,
-0.7871819138526917,
0.8013572692871094,
-0.537937343120575,
-0.4140932261943817,
-0.004979526158422232,
-0.4347466230392456,
-0.8537335395812988,
0.1943475306034088,
-0.24214188754558563,
-0.8141425251960754,
0.3610994517803192,
0.2568807899951935,
-0.6275941729545593,
0.5835000872612,
-0.7175931930541992,
0.9598546624183655,
0.03544105589389801,
-0.26621267199516296,
-0.587539553642273,
-0.6497988700866699,
0.15190991759300232,
-0.3577044904232025,
0.02527371048927307,
-0.030604487285017967,
0.08919302374124527,
0.9367096424102783,
-0.20303623378276825,
0.7278279066085815,
-0.3801966607570648,
0.01832481101155281,
0.26870259642601013,
0.37631040811538696,
0.10844849795103073,
-0.0923774316906929,
-0.21480295062065125,
-0.10426498204469681,
0.7359245419502258,
-0.42768535017967224,
-0.6756018400192261,
0.7031543850898743,
-0.8254798054695129,
-0.7399120926856995,
-0.0056046792306005955,
-0.4546336829662323,
-0.5989252924919128,
0.08945051580667496,
0.01493222825229168,
0.6051168441772461,
-0.13460727035999298,
0.3504196107387543,
0.6153772473335266,
-0.3488067388534546,
0.24001280963420868,
0.6802423000335693,
0.10235732793807983,
0.020930614322423935,
1.1356854438781738,
0.3699864149093628,
0.40714702010154724,
0.6478986740112305,
0.11367776989936829,
0.0600113607943058,
-0.6711464524269104,
-0.26112455129623413,
0.09940029680728912,
-0.4775460362434387,
-0.15613535046577454,
-0.43441545963287354,
-0.03840138018131256,
0.0984891802072525,
-0.22581934928894043,
-0.6508858799934387,
-0.6316435933113098,
-0.20384739339351654,
-0.11182659864425659,
0.044795844703912735,
0.5264868140220642,
-0.2735966444015503,
0.3011457026004791,
-0.9097419381141663,
-0.0025936926249414682,
0.56556236743927,
0.5362517833709717,
0.16754138469696045,
-0.685951292514801,
-0.08172675967216492,
-0.012275516986846924,
-0.23875421285629272,
-1.0223593711853027,
-0.045657265931367874,
0.10755300521850586,
0.7899491190910339,
0.4650905728340149,
0.11221514642238617,
0.4820505380630493,
-0.2882048189640045,
0.8375234603881836,
-0.04726814851164818,
-0.8551594018936157,
0.36730706691741943,
-0.3443140387535095,
-0.1273777335882187,
1.0038347244262695,
0.6575433015823364,
-0.07041411846876144,
-0.1393033117055893,
-0.6446372270584106,
-0.5636839270591736,
0.727705717086792,
-0.13598574697971344,
0.45745113492012024,
0.36026450991630554,
0.7478688955307007,
0.7419044375419617,
0.2490726113319397,
-0.44732218980789185,
-0.04293029010295868,
0.002311564050614834,
-0.2774212956428528,
-0.1924050897359848,
-0.1826554387807846,
0.13219964504241943,
-0.5917119383811951,
0.6809457540512085,
-0.11408334970474243,
0.7405204772949219,
0.18360945582389832,
-0.3088790476322174,
0.30522260069847107,
0.4645291268825531,
0.4353978931903839,
0.8304075002670288,
-0.26196059584617615,
0.49853605031967163,
0.3307202160358429,
-0.4866144359111786,
0.5983246564865112,
0.22049830853939056,
-0.1037093997001648,
-0.07058700174093246,
-0.03928985446691513,
0.49190449714660645,
0.0173189714550972,
-0.7190290689468384,
0.5612338185310364,
0.10036912560462952,
-0.23632174730300903,
0.06942550092935562,
0.08997675031423569,
-0.05688207969069481,
0.4016683101654053,
-0.04582381993532181,
0.4274479150772095,
0.33136898279190063,
-0.605444073677063,
0.30830487608909607,
0.3875962793827057,
-0.6354814171791077,
-0.7721589207649231,
0.5414286851882935,
0.1753677874803543,
-0.12573957443237305,
0.282868355512619,
-0.1004938930273056,
-0.15527378022670746,
0.46610569953918457,
0.5312694311141968,
0.7586693167686462,
-0.10354866087436676,
0.36372488737106323,
0.47913381457328796,
0.4257675111293793,
-0.20933805406093597,
0.26081085205078125,
-0.5199349522590637,
-0.40793561935424805,
-0.629889965057373,
-0.6325851082801819,
-0.20919464528560638,
-0.05355524644255638,
-0.7748607397079468,
0.024692263454198837,
-0.40438106656074524,
-0.4663061499595642,
-0.4367885887622833,
-0.3753202259540558,
-0.7653118968009949,
0.01726601831614971,
0.01539353746920824,
0.914609432220459,
-1.0936537981033325,
0.6761512756347656,
1.1667219400405884,
-0.2763412892818451,
-1.0768656730651855,
-0.073725625872612,
-0.3465697765350342,
-0.6287727952003479,
0.7767648696899414,
0.03196297958493233,
0.20092765986919403,
-0.037711407989263535,
-0.06143057718873024,
-0.9576725363731384,
0.8611220717430115,
0.9002434015274048,
-0.3316601514816284,
-0.08076462894678116,
0.3823854625225067,
0.3439866006374359,
0.05585325136780739,
0.3472895622253418,
0.7885159254074097,
0.3334874212741852,
-0.32477861642837524,
-1.3226103782653809,
0.35457655787467957,
-0.19532634317874908,
-0.14009572565555573,
0.09143316745758057,
-0.7530434131622314,
0.7748720645904541,
0.17508845031261444,
0.16008427739143372,
0.19615192711353302,
0.45353788137435913,
-0.2026621699333191,
0.022492369636893272,
0.7908341884613037,
0.2761691212654114,
0.37628892064094543,
-0.07511817663908005,
0.5825473666191101,
-0.12004164606332779,
0.4760581851005554,
0.5007011294364929,
0.28604045510292053,
1.1903531551361084,
0.7671506404876709,
-0.33965903520584106,
0.4243444800376892,
0.24409128725528717,
0.21429301798343658,
0.5166282653808594,
0.39799103140830994,
-0.045647233724594116,
-0.4693818986415863,
0.18931059539318085,
-0.2905975580215454,
0.32038259506225586,
-0.1333085149526596,
-0.43801042437553406,
-0.37570422887802124,
0.5827032327651978,
0.04857154190540314,
-0.0743473693728447,
-0.3908957242965698,
0.5809126496315002,
0.24571779370307922,
-0.8874262571334839,
0.6868109107017517,
-0.06344547122716904,
0.8061290383338928,
-0.7187092304229736,
0.1004701629281044,
-0.32302024960517883,
0.336105078458786,
-0.29731717705726624,
-0.4886184334754944,
0.7647960782051086,
-0.11732196062803268,
-0.0888255164027214,
-0.5435149669647217,
0.9532237648963928,
-0.1695496290922165,
-0.19592919945716858,
0.0909709706902504,
0.7851568460464478,
0.34808874130249023,
-0.2151861935853958,
-0.3085853159427643,
-0.29107820987701416,
0.14688973128795624,
-0.234826922416687,
0.736198902130127,
-0.0732416957616806,
0.2714625298976898,
0.5069432258605957,
0.2423604130744934,
0.09478802978992462,
0.10839691013097763,
-0.46955832839012146,
0.6706843972206116,
-0.36502230167388916,
-0.31984981894493103,
-0.8015496730804443,
0.5225475430488586,
0.42746925354003906,
-0.12283394485712051,
0.69398432970047,
0.4153802692890167,
0.7859908938407898,
-0.5809685587882996,
0.569987416267395,
-0.12697406113147736,
0.19667212665081024,
-0.2795479893684387,
0.8643470406532288,
-0.6588074564933777,
0.031615983694791794,
-0.29788142442703247,
-1.095432162284851,
-0.04920315369963646,
0.720131516456604,
-0.5067991614341736,
-0.1657772660255432,
0.6811841130256653,
0.6609317064285278,
-0.6770380139350891,
0.004179980605840683,
0.3817223310470581,
0.05952698737382889,
-0.11557048559188843,
0.815352201461792,
0.9080691933631897,
-0.27695292234420776,
0.711429238319397,
-0.3873072862625122,
-0.06642231345176697,
-0.028938474133610725,
-0.6615923047065735,
-0.9319462180137634,
-0.8889579772949219,
-0.41263049840927124,
-0.18110497295856476,
0.17527364194393158,
0.69859778881073,
1.066239595413208,
-0.6667090058326721,
-0.35052216053009033,
0.06521570682525635,
-0.1866525262594223,
-0.5765451192855835,
-0.17904525995254517,
0.437094122171402,
-0.3709688186645508,
-0.24416078627109528,
0.21302530169487,
-0.07126567512750626,
-0.08628915995359421,
-0.18646320700645447,
0.4210413992404938,
0.11952603608369827,
0.1711878776550293,
0.795884370803833,
0.26558294892311096,
-0.22570450603961945,
-0.617243766784668,
0.022301483899354935,
0.30041855573654175,
-0.022212957963347435,
0.7737374305725098,
-0.9296245574951172,
0.19374018907546997,
1.067976474761963,
1.0177699327468872,
0.39818820357322693,
0.00793631561100483,
0.7628341317176819,
-0.5486976504325867,
0.12134671956300735,
-0.2073797583580017,
0.4268120229244232,
0.050268616527318954,
-0.04989700764417648,
0.26120680570602417,
0.1646420657634735,
-0.4413142502307892,
-0.7481744289398193,
-0.06534389406442642,
-1.2749390602111816,
-0.11567598581314087,
1.1849632263183594,
-0.47219914197921753,
-0.1388898491859436,
-0.0185223575681448,
-0.36505264043807983,
0.21463444828987122,
0.1405784785747528,
0.5886732935905457,
0.4707757532596588,
-0.11081301420927048,
0.19911327958106995,
-0.672334611415863,
0.3762442469596863,
0.8120208978652954,
-0.8297443389892578,
-0.2571410834789276,
-0.05863195285201073,
0.861025333404541,
0.15291893482208252,
0.5424051284790039,
-0.008365086279809475,
0.24113157391548157,
-0.22939306497573853,
-0.1771431714296341,
-0.12462607771158218,
-0.24898990988731384,
-0.3245776891708374,
0.5266568660736084,
0.4824819564819336,
-0.2524995803833008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14215v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14215v3 | Commonsense-augmented Memory Construction and Management in Long-term Conversations via Context-aware Persona Refinement | 2024-01-25T14:54:33 | 2024-02-12T12:27:18 | Hana Kim, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Seoyeon Kim, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Memorizing and utilizing speakers' personas is a common practice for response
generation in long-term conversations. Yet, human-authored datasets often
provide uninformative persona sentences that hinder response quality. This
paper presents a novel framework that leverages commonsense-based persona
expansion to address such issues in long-term conversation. While prior work
focuses on not producing personas that contradict others, we focus on
transforming contradictory personas into sentences that contain rich speaker
information, by refining them based on their contextual backgrounds with
designed strategies. As the pioneer of persona expansion in multi-session
settings, our framework facilitates better response generation via human-like
persona refinement. The supplementary video of our work is available at
https://caffeine-15bbf.web.app/. | [
-0.4669966995716095,
-0.7613242268562317,
0.5283941626548767,
0.30968937277793884,
-0.053889889270067215,
-0.17108182609081268,
-0.4623764157295227,
-0.4441254436969757,
0.18787434697151184,
0.6977225542068481,
-0.8403078317642212,
-0.07226739078760147,
0.0017062771366909146,
-0.04917748272418976,
0.2262304425239563,
0.9577683210372925,
0.4154803454875946,
-0.34844154119491577,
-0.597847044467926,
-0.5076565146446228,
-1.009493350982666,
-0.456551730632782,
-0.5639958381652832,
-0.2676331400871277,
0.7777029871940613,
0.6252132058143616,
0.5811420679092407,
0.30490413308143616,
0.04566365107893944,
0.2885124683380127,
0.00750562222674489,
0.3905838131904602,
-0.8168225288391113,
0.3064029812812805,
-0.6377372741699219,
0.0405312180519104,
-0.6101747751235962,
-0.26901623606681824,
0.41599276661872864,
0.8215275406837463,
-0.17140647768974304,
-0.02652151510119438,
0.07536575943231583,
0.512872576713562,
-0.8586702346801758,
0.044594429433345795,
-0.40383386611938477,
-0.06174797564744949,
-0.15884919464588165,
-0.3597358465194702,
-0.6515591144561768,
0.12770533561706543,
0.32240763306617737,
-0.5782409906387329,
0.08455132693052292,
0.0787057876586914,
0.557163655757904,
0.10630602389574051,
-0.493740051984787,
-0.15482737123966217,
-0.7673649191856384,
0.9688585996627808,
-0.5426957011222839,
0.3175885081291199,
0.34790363907814026,
0.4482138752937317,
-0.3049086630344391,
-0.6394198536872864,
-0.526702344417572,
-0.07127002626657486,
-0.4911392629146576,
0.13892166316509247,
-0.0960015133023262,
0.007382398005574942,
0.31370654702186584,
0.11778945475816727,
-0.3763895332813263,
0.0022546793334186077,
-0.5212904810905457,
-0.06770879775285721,
0.6114498376846313,
0.21341218054294586,
0.1458025574684143,
-0.15572041273117065,
-0.7044689655303955,
0.3065696656703949,
-0.37931662797927856,
-0.3508606255054474,
0.1746133267879486,
0.4457024931907654,
0.1874038428068161,
0.36714768409729004,
-0.29858168959617615,
0.6303054690361023,
0.2190484255552292,
-0.18872840702533722,
0.2186727523803711,
-0.04590494930744171,
-0.11454247683286667,
0.033187221735715866,
0.4740098714828491,
0.5370635986328125,
0.17996789515018463,
-0.38694220781326294,
-0.0050258026458323,
-0.19225141406059265,
0.45802146196365356,
-0.7798497676849365,
-0.3264557421207428,
0.527934730052948,
-0.3097507059574127,
-0.00776439206674695,
-0.128248393535614,
-1.1185029745101929,
-0.5001288056373596,
-0.33076614141464233,
0.09246931970119476,
-0.5195272564888,
-0.35469135642051697,
0.26620346307754517,
-0.07300932705402374,
0.19986146688461304,
0.2283967137336731,
-0.8977102041244507,
0.4652470052242279,
0.6513550281524658,
0.41965651512145996,
-0.2661181688308716,
-0.27572983503341675,
-0.7871441841125488,
0.6120865345001221,
0.04525555297732353,
0.8588016033172607,
-0.6258185505867004,
-0.4988587498664856,
0.15173617005348206,
-0.2128758728504181,
0.0846346989274025,
-0.6659561991691589,
0.6814570426940918,
-0.3787141442298889,
0.6945589780807495,
-0.5024842619895935,
-0.46512046456336975,
0.20943871140480042,
0.28024759888648987,
-0.3773692846298218,
0.6990758180618286,
0.286710262298584,
-0.7191056609153748,
0.251101016998291,
-0.9490087628364563,
-0.5882374048233032,
0.3987402021884918,
-0.0534379668533802,
-0.18745645880699158,
0.08266846835613251,
0.2687827944755554,
0.650202751159668,
-0.11671016365289688,
0.4687250554561615,
-0.33250266313552856,
-0.2739778161048889,
0.421709805727005,
-0.2754634618759155,
0.371287077665329,
0.37226763367652893,
-0.2089749425649643,
0.06160349026322365,
-0.7383705377578735,
-0.04879722744226456,
-0.06910839676856995,
-0.10016153007745743,
-0.4571259617805481,
-0.07868589460849762,
0.10192974656820297,
0.14100751280784607,
0.2585815489292145,
-0.47271546721458435,
-0.14805610477924347,
-0.2314433455467224,
0.508689284324646,
0.7675670981407166,
0.18574266135692596,
0.4374839961528778,
-0.5984175801277161,
-0.07026239484548569,
0.29933327436447144,
-0.07520819455385208,
-0.7816253900527954,
-0.2038656622171402,
-0.6273388862609863,
-0.3148520588874817,
-0.3723658323287964,
0.2760598957538605,
-0.5214131474494934,
0.519899845123291,
-0.8037609457969666,
-0.04349001497030258,
-0.09750260412693024,
0.16535376012325287,
0.43513065576553345,
1.098584771156311,
0.5872955918312073,
-0.34563592076301575,
-0.3491855263710022,
-1.1794856786727905,
-0.33208924531936646,
-0.1299329251050949,
-0.16382735967636108,
0.7495790123939514,
0.10994433611631393,
-0.2922479212284088,
1.2138617038726807,
-0.8480163812637329,
-0.06510009616613388,
-0.1309247463941574,
0.1905573159456253,
-0.26749473810195923,
0.6356129050254822,
0.35760173201560974,
-0.9563596248626709,
-0.2211119830608368,
-0.35579004883766174,
-0.39977288246154785,
0.012439941056072712,
-0.6016393899917603,
-0.20869244635105133,
0.008062654174864292,
0.39805513620376587,
-0.7890925407409668,
0.1265619993209839,
-0.1496540904045105,
-0.34833571314811707,
0.5093689560890198,
-0.0805518850684166,
0.21052832901477814,
-1.30402410030365,
0.3526405990123749,
0.1612720787525177,
-0.2725585699081421,
-0.799647867679596,
0.057939328253269196,
-0.057489607483148575,
-0.30275723338127136,
-0.5803614258766174,
0.9001820087432861,
-0.45119816064834595,
-0.11216595023870468,
-0.3421279788017273,
0.3815551996231079,
0.013066362589597702,
0.9632723927497864,
0.12170973420143127,
0.8000158667564392,
0.19136400520801544,
-0.6687494516372681,
0.33065664768218994,
0.4435482323169708,
-0.167567640542984,
1.493448257446289,
-0.4786110818386078,
0.28455182909965515,
-0.46100133657455444,
0.6106976270675659,
-1.2343802452087402,
-0.6276321411132812,
0.40579450130462646,
-0.19416768848896027,
0.2341446429491043,
-0.05748334899544716,
-0.45693349838256836,
-0.37117496132850647,
0.045679401606321335,
0.44149503111839294,
0.283443421125412,
-0.8745682239532471,
0.7079577445983887,
0.19157269597053528,
-0.35337427258491516,
-0.4144808053970337,
-0.7514874935150146,
0.3221372961997986,
-0.5727933645248413,
-0.5169979929924011,
0.3925022482872009,
-0.4065842628479004,
-0.3873632848262787,
-0.36628589034080505,
-0.10286522656679153,
-0.21989576518535614,
-0.2150929570198059,
0.1401822865009308,
-0.04932991415262222,
0.06213655695319176,
0.4203455150127411,
0.06934592872858047,
0.0018368905875831842,
0.10241095721721649,
-0.10214878618717194,
0.6814821362495422,
-0.103780597448349,
-0.17353546619415283,
-0.5783424377441406,
0.5774324536323547,
0.6817504167556763,
-0.12733063101768494,
0.42844006419181824,
0.6350199580192566,
-0.12886057794094086,
-0.09919502586126328,
-0.8419198989868164,
-0.3110487163066864,
-0.5575330853462219,
0.23588405549526215,
-0.46344059705734253,
-1.030258297920227,
0.6511747241020203,
-0.3490414321422577,
0.17762064933776855,
0.17502059042453766,
0.22563686966896057,
-0.16091768443584442,
0.41744300723075867,
0.20031526684761047,
0.03240940719842911,
0.26642733812332153,
0.3033921420574188,
0.04950660467147827,
-1.094667673110962,
-0.35172978043556213,
-0.06572043150663376,
-0.5535774827003479,
-0.37011292576789856,
-0.36259764432907104,
-0.18222559988498688,
-0.5499222278594971,
-0.3660317659378052,
0.33980321884155273,
-0.3241368234157562,
0.5635595917701721,
0.22532008588314056,
0.2869400084018707,
-0.11440232396125793,
-0.2382880300283432,
0.42025521397590637,
-0.38507986068725586,
-0.4225960671901703,
-0.2125525027513504,
0.8385619521141052,
0.385081946849823,
0.5083924531936646,
0.40475213527679443,
0.6642788648605347,
0.27289921045303345,
0.35562536120414734,
-0.5652072429656982,
0.7510632276535034,
0.18085646629333496,
-0.56777024269104,
-0.16174054145812988,
-0.5487725138664246,
-0.8926550149917603,
0.17866668105125427,
0.010112889111042023,
-0.9884359240531921,
0.19747859239578247,
0.23252011835575104,
-0.6173549890518188,
0.06895018368959427,
-0.7246102094650269,
0.7350277304649353,
-0.3347060978412628,
-0.9815464615821838,
-0.28615814447402954,
-0.7644503116607666,
0.5179823040962219,
0.16666699945926666,
-0.11571645736694336,
-0.0476403646171093,
-0.025804195553064346,
0.6114899516105652,
-0.22613082826137543,
0.9701273441314697,
-0.1628381609916687,
-0.17630060017108917,
0.23028826713562012,
-0.0854707881808281,
0.359136164188385,
0.4880521595478058,
0.15278498828411102,
-0.46988385915756226,
-0.3471303880214691,
-0.7927143573760986,
-0.9403480887413025,
1.1085575819015503,
-0.41760915517807007,
-0.7797722220420837,
-0.09920131415128708,
-0.5131996870040894,
-0.6661050915718079,
0.3022519648075104,
0.02247173897922039,
0.4714863896369934,
-0.6043965816497803,
0.19852617383003235,
1.148324966430664,
-0.40726175904273987,
0.331938773393631,
0.31036433577537537,
0.09834662824869156,
-0.6086005568504333,
0.6638424396514893,
-0.3945849537849426,
0.1976507008075714,
0.5178326964378357,
0.16004955768585205,
-0.34152480959892273,
-0.12444104254245758,
-0.1993655413389206,
0.10322465002536774,
-0.5091437697410583,
-0.16877582669258118,
-0.6815840005874634,
0.2617320418357849,
-0.7373666167259216,
-0.2054879367351532,
-0.2784070670604706,
-0.29115667939186096,
-0.4771736264228821,
-0.040241487324237823,
0.11776665598154068,
0.05003299564123154,
0.10970738530158997,
0.5203762650489807,
-0.4992212653160095,
0.4543321132659912,
0.8319176435470581,
0.41208383440971375,
0.05343162268400192,
-0.42065319418907166,
0.008350249379873276,
0.19356930255889893,
-0.29337772727012634,
-0.8150265216827393,
0.4211728572845459,
0.14750659465789795,
0.5057293176651001,
0.683948278427124,
0.13658976554870605,
1.1535793542861938,
-0.4256877899169922,
0.9006112217903137,
0.356937050819397,
-0.5517167448997498,
0.5981231331825256,
-0.7925155162811279,
0.5767822265625,
0.9220982193946838,
-0.10526856034994125,
-0.7348581552505493,
0.18444757163524628,
-0.8565617203712463,
-0.9315169453620911,
0.33995017409324646,
-0.04527859389781952,
0.7872067093849182,
-0.31638532876968384,
0.5992342233657837,
0.09471823275089264,
0.302567720413208,
-0.4542502462863922,
-0.15659646689891815,
-0.306054025888443,
0.2632012665271759,
-0.10539332777261734,
-0.4942271411418915,
-0.44651859998703003,
-0.06678164005279541,
0.3475843071937561,
-0.207780659198761,
0.4343838691711426,
0.03801107406616211,
0.019533148035407066,
0.20142461359500885,
0.628455400466919,
1.0382401943206787,
0.6793333292007446,
-0.30594557523727417,
0.012218717485666275,
0.17577338218688965,
0.014000832103192806,
-0.32821160554885864,
-0.09066695719957352,
0.32482296228408813,
-0.14585527777671814,
-0.08712022751569748,
0.6802285313606262,
0.8311835527420044,
-0.7537200450897217,
0.44001543521881104,
0.07987827807664871,
0.02135348878800869,
-0.46277016401290894,
0.14357201755046844,
0.19495968520641327,
-0.05948954448103905,
0.3673836290836334,
0.007778574712574482,
0.27693846821784973,
-0.7420286536216736,
0.5746477246284485,
0.25572291016578674,
-0.29962924122810364,
-0.15405233204364777,
0.6567379236221313,
0.6603232622146606,
-0.24852809309959412,
0.8972062468528748,
-0.014177780598402023,
-0.03825202211737633,
-0.007835399359464645,
0.8349193930625916,
0.9438452124595642,
-0.10596492141485214,
0.2860807180404663,
0.46251484751701355,
-0.4403846859931946,
-0.09726092219352722,
-0.0836419016122818,
-0.5713691115379333,
-0.5598680377006531,
-0.2084718644618988,
-0.22231270372867584,
-0.3133500814437866,
0.5041646361351013,
-0.9359139800071716,
0.03778897598385811,
-0.6364309191703796,
-0.21303057670593262,
-0.33166253566741943,
0.12459196895360947,
-0.378095418214798,
0.20416423678398132,
-0.012029982171952724,
0.9605786204338074,
-0.5880876779556274,
0.48645099997520447,
0.4492258131504059,
-0.17616607248783112,
-0.04171926900744438,
0.12972457706928253,
-0.012789609842002392,
-0.38721907138824463,
0.34254300594329834,
0.2835218012332916,
-0.10366196185350418,
-0.29113176465034485,
-0.5519577264785767,
-0.5659518241882324,
1.2242215871810913,
0.17498573660850525,
-0.40266236662864685,
0.0028412076644599438,
0.22019515931606293,
0.6855657696723938,
-0.45141905546188354,
-0.11770665645599365,
0.3954750597476959,
0.3768733739852905,
0.5537895560264587,
-0.6226223707199097,
-0.005084401927888393,
-0.2803794741630554,
0.10499418526887894,
0.07163193821907043,
-1.0586779117584229,
0.377988338470459,
-0.11595620214939117,
-0.3199293911457062,
0.22240011394023895,
1.3068076372146606,
0.42159518599510193,
0.5016996264457703,
0.3390246331691742,
0.5926448106765747,
0.9057002067565918,
0.1965455412864685,
0.5542774796485901,
-0.1383887529373169,
-0.26072680950164795,
2.012338876724243,
-0.42443591356277466,
0.8380066156387329,
0.7242613434791565,
0.3882402181625366,
0.711223304271698,
0.23050716519355774,
0.03467054292559624,
0.5024176239967346,
0.124652199447155,
-0.45047903060913086,
-0.3182316720485687,
-0.1820371448993683,
-0.16007396578788757,
0.2900315225124359,
0.5036264657974243,
-0.23188090324401855,
-0.1410028487443924,
0.01919960230588913,
0.22421841323375702,
0.5642363429069519,
-0.09959603101015091,
0.6641337275505066,
-0.14915718138217926,
-1.0196750164031982,
0.35153502225875854,
-0.09692446887493134,
0.8561683893203735,
-0.2762179672718048,
0.2213488221168518,
-0.5462217330932617,
0.05659661069512367,
-0.08642112463712692,
-0.7108288407325745,
0.3389342725276947,
-0.17303983867168427,
-0.10449165850877762,
-0.5211557149887085,
0.7265521883964539,
-0.632743775844574,
0.09453380107879639,
-0.24898511171340942,
0.384678453207016,
-0.048990968614816666,
0.1889003962278366,
-0.593233048915863,
-0.14182375371456146,
-0.14847584068775177,
0.000001651175466577115,
0.4647764563560486,
0.29617026448249817,
0.07826903462409973,
0.8337286114692688,
0.43230822682380676,
-0.32589131593704224,
-0.45880430936813354,
-0.010025729425251484,
0.8830427527427673,
-0.46160945296287537,
-0.6503996849060059,
-0.6310538649559021,
0.7238045334815979,
-0.6220383048057556,
-0.5969324707984924,
0.6644212603569031,
0.8424444198608398,
0.7657479047775269,
-0.0647001639008522,
0.5548632740974426,
0.19797281920909882,
0.5333163142204285,
-0.1462077647447586,
0.642885148525238,
-0.21746979653835297,
0.4105236232280731,
-0.2380797266960144,
-0.6598926782608032,
-0.23308691382408142,
0.385993629693985,
-0.35967087745666504,
0.17812319099903107,
0.2364162653684616,
0.7909649014472961,
-0.35370558500289917,
-0.05627528205513954,
0.3155978322029114,
-0.06041125953197479,
0.5201634168624878,
0.7396581768989563,
0.5383149981498718,
-0.16744326055049896,
0.4297191798686981,
-0.03510228171944618,
0.0370052196085453,
-0.10606513917446136,
-0.8104402422904968,
-0.9742278456687927,
-0.8341813683509827,
-0.5048407912254333,
-0.25431159138679504,
0.1883261501789093,
0.7030680179595947,
0.6492974758148193,
-0.4978964328765869,
-0.05570090562105179,
0.056174542754888535,
-0.17186884582042694,
-0.09209296107292175,
-0.3115263879299164,
0.1303066462278366,
-0.4451916813850403,
-0.6747939586639404,
0.44667747616767883,
0.40185266733169556,
-0.008473786525428295,
-0.28594133257865906,
-0.2311580777168274,
-0.14351828396320343,
0.3607085347175598,
0.6004452109336853,
0.7705519795417786,
-0.5561219453811646,
-0.41567113995552063,
-0.03184488043189049,
-0.008446114137768745,
0.21796922385692596,
0.912421464920044,
-1.0578614473342896,
0.5969616770744324,
0.14103840291500092,
0.4955589175224304,
0.3701229989528656,
0.3426986336708069,
0.7264228463172913,
-1.085416555404663,
0.1022251695394516,
0.32139307260513306,
0.03813859075307846,
0.6398412585258484,
-0.4834139049053192,
0.22670112550258636,
0.09398364275693893,
-0.47361260652542114,
-0.8308348059654236,
0.5757620930671692,
-1.2314121723175049,
-0.44798019528388977,
1.3644152879714966,
-0.0755019560456276,
-0.2380908578634262,
-0.1662289947271347,
-0.27674323320388794,
-0.19245915114879608,
-0.5244878530502319,
0.9947195053100586,
0.40758398175239563,
-0.40294867753982544,
-0.38895246386528015,
-0.08011340349912643,
0.6030375957489014,
0.3383430242538452,
-0.8954848647117615,
0.611240804195404,
1.0304160118103027,
0.2512660026550293,
0.4213029146194458,
0.8754968643188477,
-0.02104865200817585,
0.330217182636261,
-0.1479664146900177,
-0.5761250853538513,
-0.25910913944244385,
-0.33086830377578735,
0.08535322546958923,
0.390622079372406,
-0.38710424304008484,
0.07610216736793518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14212v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14212v2 | Explicitly Representing Syntax Improves Sentence-to-layout Prediction of Unexpected Situations | 2024-01-25T14:53:30 | 2024-04-16T14:25:39 | Wolf Nuyts, Ruben Cartuyvels, Marie-Francine Moens | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recognizing visual entities in a natural language sentence and arranging them
in a 2D spatial layout require a compositional understanding of language and
space. This task of layout prediction is valuable in text-to-image synthesis as
it allows localized and controlled in-painting of the image. In this
comparative study it is shown that we can predict layouts from language
representations that implicitly or explicitly encode sentence syntax, if the
sentences mention similar entity-relationships to the ones seen during
training. To test compositional understanding, we collect a test set of
grammatically correct sentences and layouts describing compositions of entities
and relations that unlikely have been seen during training. Performance on this
test set substantially drops, showing that current models rely on correlations
in the training data and have difficulties in understanding the structure of
the input sentences. We propose a novel structural loss function that better
enforces the syntactic structure of the input sentence and show large
performance gains in the task of 2D spatial layout prediction conditioned on
text. The loss has the potential to be used in other generation tasks where a
tree-like structure underlies the conditioning modality. Code, trained models
and the USCOCO evaluation set are available via github. | [
-0.13355043530464172,
-0.7718152403831482,
0.9521856904029846,
0.576063334941864,
-0.06829856336116791,
-0.11353759467601776,
-0.21037378907203674,
-0.2421448528766632,
-0.07072926312685013,
0.2795940041542053,
-0.4325103461742401,
-0.5551381707191467,
-0.25981369614601135,
0.09550300240516663,
-0.2699829041957855,
0.6357943415641785,
-0.42905935645103455,
0.17076918482780457,
-0.49602463841438293,
0.0004180153482593596,
-0.6426191329956055,
-0.3203662931919098,
-0.19415496289730072,
-0.11158907413482666,
0.20516683161258698,
-0.16017235815525055,
0.5906897187232971,
0.6574278473854065,
0.5560055375099182,
0.371474027633667,
0.004461517557501793,
0.15532590448856354,
-0.2884133458137512,
-0.10835645347833633,
-0.08548750728368759,
-0.5557514429092407,
0.029143862426280975,
-0.2172808051109314,
0.8328704237937927,
1.125866174697876,
-0.17690102756023407,
-0.4615521728992462,
0.013374737463891506,
0.623366117477417,
-0.5164413452148438,
0.41492506861686707,
-0.594071626663208,
0.49957454204559326,
0.21101073920726776,
-0.3238479197025299,
-0.816243588924408,
-0.14023123681545258,
0.14517620205879211,
-0.8658362627029419,
0.09554094076156616,
0.1020035520195961,
0.7710341215133667,
0.39545154571533203,
-0.41406986117362976,
-0.08606412261724472,
-0.537517786026001,
0.22757907211780548,
-0.17051437497138977,
0.6563891172409058,
0.17315225303173065,
0.03939831256866455,
-0.2786101698875427,
-0.5779966711997986,
-0.45249998569488525,
-0.40473413467407227,
-0.6188962459564209,
0.4564999043941498,
0.012938396073877811,
0.21945832669734955,
0.22353285551071167,
0.1166297048330307,
-0.6405191421508789,
-0.2867601811885834,
-0.39899471402168274,
-0.21108384430408478,
0.4600946009159088,
0.04832552373409271,
0.6823425889015198,
-0.30129578709602356,
-0.47933506965637207,
-0.21853971481323242,
-0.7017348408699036,
-0.021973151713609695,
0.14315077662467957,
0.09536907821893692,
-0.3033747971057892,
0.6962903738021851,
0.13370221853256226,
0.5869647264480591,
0.09238801151514053,
0.15123909711837769,
0.04198978468775749,
-0.37930426001548767,
-0.45833465456962585,
-0.02933959849178791,
0.7601954936981201,
0.4831351041793823,
0.3256022036075592,
-0.29861897230148315,
0.06336459517478943,
0.3784918189048767,
0.31143179535865784,
-0.5686078071594238,
-0.576324462890625,
-0.33028239011764526,
-0.31703445315361023,
-0.18581421673297882,
0.23019008338451385,
-0.2147296667098999,
-0.21749532222747803,
-0.28639382123947144,
0.060928501188755035,
-0.7056818604469299,
0.19932304322719574,
0.2299269735813141,
-0.31267961859703064,
-0.0662817656993866,
0.33876273036003113,
-0.7877917289733887,
0.3072124123573303,
0.3639543652534485,
0.6927123069763184,
-0.04804353043437004,
-0.3642743229866028,
-0.4022245407104492,
0.38832494616508484,
-0.7357891798019409,
0.8100511431694031,
-0.45886489748954773,
-0.4164848029613495,
0.016452642157673836,
-0.11786296218633652,
-0.4566720724105835,
-0.38159945607185364,
0.32169291377067566,
-0.2414780557155609,
0.45989790558815,
-0.03412598744034767,
-0.4741058051586151,
-0.05214888975024223,
-0.004762202966958284,
-0.7818130850791931,
0.649081289768219,
0.13526944816112518,
-0.8130816221237183,
0.43837031722068787,
-0.35755813121795654,
-0.8207261562347412,
-0.11659784615039825,
-0.5087442398071289,
-0.5197917819023132,
0.33883431553840637,
0.19512759149074554,
0.44322967529296875,
0.5440706014633179,
0.19519652426242828,
-0.4301910996437073,
-0.311583548784256,
0.2285039722919464,
0.1153811663389206,
0.45419251918792725,
-0.022144781425595284,
-0.2650719881057739,
-0.17688718438148499,
-0.6897358298301697,
0.08858827501535416,
0.10134539008140564,
-0.5963238477706909,
-0.3740467131137848,
0.17846333980560303,
-0.0095171257853508,
-0.004801667761057615,
-0.11983588337898254,
-0.4212853014469147,
0.07638762891292572,
-0.6820490956306458,
0.30351582169532776,
0.5021945834159851,
0.1366598904132843,
1.189834713935852,
0.2232975959777832,
0.5985000729560852,
-0.0791691243648529,
-0.3526676297187805,
-0.6248495578765869,
-0.1972617506980896,
-0.43814077973365784,
-0.17565104365348816,
-0.10021527111530304,
0.5778224468231201,
-0.8617501854896545,
0.34710797667503357,
-0.31345903873443604,
-0.05991675704717636,
0.057164888828992844,
0.03211977332830429,
0.659002423286438,
0.412026584148407,
0.1608678102493286,
-0.17648835480213165,
-0.9195846319198608,
-0.9484066963195801,
-0.15922987461090088,
-0.30027687549591064,
0.14406313002109528,
0.09675037115812302,
0.3581311106681824,
0.07606132328510284,
0.7073603272438049,
-0.7280869483947754,
-0.3328031897544861,
-0.5246434211730957,
-0.14352351427078247,
-0.30703669786453247,
0.4713990092277527,
0.8033106923103333,
-0.5984154939651489,
-0.47774434089660645,
0.2084438055753708,
-0.7059489488601685,
0.06956794112920761,
-0.40388697385787964,
-0.37617290019989014,
0.3815225660800934,
0.6399499177932739,
-1.0097476243972778,
0.7492842674255371,
0.3354942202568054,
-0.4513653814792633,
0.27278605103492737,
-0.1882598102092743,
-0.12153996527194977,
-0.9722659587860107,
-0.11178405582904816,
0.20454978942871094,
-0.09806083887815475,
-0.34905532002449036,
0.14885933697223663,
0.2703186273574829,
-0.1635175496339798,
-0.07839145511388779,
0.3603104054927826,
-0.49216073751449585,
-0.24515748023986816,
0.2154725342988968,
0.019333573058247566,
0.4619537889957428,
0.7363601922988892,
0.397259920835495,
0.7978876233100891,
0.31040051579475403,
-0.25020360946655273,
-0.2991258502006531,
0.5605147480964661,
-0.4384300410747528,
0.40351602435112,
-0.6539785861968994,
-0.1579994261264801,
-0.38779139518737793,
0.6613174080848694,
-1.269167423248291,
-0.3404090702533722,
0.13881470263004303,
-0.48655807971954346,
0.39201977849006653,
-0.07095618546009064,
-0.4597294330596924,
-0.23136673867702484,
-0.19163575768470764,
0.21640942990779877,
0.12633448839187622,
-0.35710805654525757,
0.4124961197376251,
0.14655202627182007,
0.16977840662002563,
-0.2771906554698944,
-1.1388118267059326,
-0.15627403557300568,
-0.25071030855178833,
-0.683367133140564,
0.557383120059967,
-0.0031993126031011343,
-0.19521981477737427,
-0.05737931281328201,
-0.09676767885684967,
-0.09461142867803574,
0.14865876734256744,
0.3889934718608856,
0.33006149530410767,
-0.17241278290748596,
0.27694323658943176,
0.06436923146247864,
0.10065259784460068,
0.40698063373565674,
-0.305707722902298,
0.3797878623008728,
0.0860753133893013,
-0.25969019532203674,
-0.30003172159194946,
0.3906002640724182,
0.05331149324774742,
-0.26869186758995056,
0.5960978269577026,
0.341999888420105,
-0.31048253178596497,
-0.5923046469688416,
0.011571922339498997,
0.14644119143486023,
-0.456027626991272,
0.6687924861907959,
-0.4031345546245575,
-0.5304835438728333,
0.3401411771774292,
0.1559244841337204,
-0.22779235243797302,
0.34354928135871887,
0.21221427619457245,
-0.5760881900787354,
0.9481701850891113,
0.7356939911842346,
0.29918795824050903,
0.564798891544342,
-0.4331791400909424,
0.40049463510513306,
-0.6671823263168335,
-0.5709310173988342,
-0.266757994890213,
-0.26004695892333984,
-0.4211040735244751,
-0.42621681094169617,
0.5998680591583252,
-0.043457284569740295,
-0.15830858051776886,
0.4283233880996704,
-0.46446335315704346,
0.675321102142334,
0.36355093121528625,
0.23779822885990143,
0.06693874299526215,
0.4047183096408844,
-0.3893982470035553,
-0.19039902091026306,
-0.49329668283462524,
-0.37454283237457275,
0.7613033652305603,
0.18646176159381866,
0.6159192323684692,
-0.07808004319667816,
0.7160319089889526,
-0.01930892840027809,
0.0015675402246415615,
-0.6328486204147339,
0.5342811346054077,
-0.169713094830513,
-0.1632755845785141,
-0.1407623440027237,
-0.434326171875,
-0.8504288196563721,
0.1627569943666458,
-0.005967115517705679,
-0.6783285140991211,
0.1412236988544464,
0.20717790722846985,
-0.31536537408828735,
0.08722244948148727,
-0.9810276031494141,
0.873433530330658,
-0.23827791213989258,
-0.24174053966999054,
0.06390071660280228,
-0.636867880821228,
0.31408175826072693,
0.3152095377445221,
0.006800422444939613,
0.21059975028038025,
0.11288483440876007,
0.26908203959465027,
-0.35482674837112427,
0.8033076524734497,
-0.044528547674417496,
0.019406454637646675,
0.14545878767967224,
0.4581906497478485,
0.31564489006996155,
0.1154949739575386,
0.13150489330291748,
-0.33963721990585327,
-0.2815600633621216,
-0.04530324786901474,
-0.9268001317977905,
0.5164632201194763,
-0.6763180494308472,
-0.2833307087421417,
0.037859395146369934,
-0.4970501661300659,
-0.22924739122390747,
-0.02376442961394787,
0.5918081402778625,
0.5292819142341614,
-0.4115429222583771,
-0.005463050212711096,
0.697052001953125,
-0.2914542257785797,
0.4355314373970032,
-0.2412908375263214,
-0.20491616427898407,
-0.464229941368103,
0.3710905611515045,
-0.09467542916536331,
0.1071494072675705,
0.8324329257011414,
-0.07402560859918594,
-0.36382541060447693,
-0.4689352214336395,
-0.5277680158615112,
0.1047302633523941,
-0.9131219983100891,
-0.2656624913215637,
-0.6474823355674744,
-0.15870460867881775,
-0.13329234719276428,
-0.3895287811756134,
-0.022014647722244263,
-0.7158989906311035,
-0.14224976301193237,
-0.534656822681427,
-0.0306008979678154,
0.7764648795127869,
0.24125635623931885,
0.24744680523872375,
-0.2670435309410095,
0.11120293289422989,
-0.12370516359806061,
0.3834112286567688,
-0.20090094208717346,
-0.3535034954547882,
-0.19475500285625458,
-0.19993989169597626,
-0.475589781999588,
-0.9375765323638916,
0.30586501955986023,
0.4476974308490753,
0.5058729648590088,
0.23317794501781464,
-0.34294360876083374,
0.9293627738952637,
-0.8494520783424377,
0.4569404721260071,
0.360870361328125,
-0.8450049161911011,
0.8920503258705139,
-0.42579761147499084,
0.39929699897766113,
0.4863705635070801,
0.03758102282881737,
-0.19664429128170013,
-0.410739004611969,
-0.5852911472320557,
-0.6272130012512207,
0.583951473236084,
0.48695826530456543,
0.3135182559490204,
-0.18710178136825562,
0.3196899890899658,
-0.12090703845024109,
0.05331583693623543,
-1.178683876991272,
-0.019757717847824097,
-0.30122458934783936,
-0.38875842094421387,
0.02959904633462429,
-0.09827013313770294,
-0.05994857847690582,
-0.35672974586486816,
0.30905357003211975,
-0.04733732342720032,
0.49515500664711,
0.40786227583885193,
-0.32030683755874634,
-0.13170452415943146,
-0.004651800729334354,
0.5242774486541748,
0.5099549293518066,
0.16078738868236542,
0.165164053440094,
-0.002947782864794135,
-0.05730538070201874,
0.034726403653621674,
0.2128068208694458,
-0.3146197199821472,
0.1922178715467453,
0.8174517750740051,
0.9118582010269165,
0.5642629861831665,
-0.5982053279876709,
0.6040893197059631,
0.0893034115433693,
-0.37273478507995605,
-0.3529182970523834,
0.03595983609557152,
0.1028926894068718,
0.015147593803703785,
-0.009506180882453918,
0.227223739027977,
0.4563230574131012,
-0.6796016097068787,
0.28689584136009216,
0.38724038004875183,
-0.13856372237205505,
-0.4596446752548218,
0.7717113494873047,
-0.010900815948843956,
0.051183730363845825,
0.5722833871841431,
-0.32441335916519165,
-0.642188549041748,
0.8213966488838196,
0.7019638419151306,
0.6887141466140747,
0.017181552946567535,
0.6047351956367493,
0.5904285907745361,
0.26169025897979736,
0.10712774097919464,
0.13431504368782043,
-0.09762313216924667,
-0.7272889614105225,
-0.3582114577293396,
-0.48650306463241577,
0.103355273604393,
-0.29993516206741333,
-0.384535551071167,
0.04595453292131424,
-0.7471504807472229,
0.07947338372468948,
-0.020666012540459633,
-0.20942243933677673,
-0.6535586714744568,
0.18883632123470306,
0.4973231554031372,
0.7351685762405396,
-0.8274824023246765,
0.38657161593437195,
1.1761741638183594,
-0.42447739839553833,
-1.0103427171707153,
-0.10797031968832016,
-0.2219596803188324,
-0.6015514731407166,
0.6971606016159058,
0.40727734565734863,
0.09953559190034866,
-0.5160680413246155,
-0.4971914291381836,
-0.7938446402549744,
0.8999826312065125,
0.7028094530105591,
-0.38380783796310425,
-0.20089863240718842,
0.302521288394928,
0.8041241765022278,
-0.5565184950828552,
0.0043741678819060326,
0.40269362926483154,
0.4061664938926697,
0.11623923480510712,
-0.7018666863441467,
0.16381943225860596,
-0.424722820520401,
0.5469069480895996,
0.2870810031890869,
-0.2557799816131592,
0.536753237247467,
-0.40981796383857727,
-0.5586859583854675,
0.3205833435058594,
0.6506534218788147,
0.34392863512039185,
0.40299007296562195,
0.308540940284729,
0.6783230304718018,
0.4999454617500305,
-0.3677665591239929,
1.3404141664505005,
0.051845889538526535,
0.0312962643802166,
1.2744066715240479,
-0.03525860607624054,
0.7483617663383484,
0.3848148286342621,
-0.15890808403491974,
0.8036345839500427,
0.5810971260070801,
0.05041060224175453,
0.9719045162200928,
0.18140578269958496,
0.2251122146844864,
-0.10692953318357468,
0.10203132778406143,
-0.09884534776210785,
0.41191449761390686,
0.2687188684940338,
-0.6208853125572205,
-0.09592922776937485,
0.04895526170730591,
0.08765752613544464,
0.7645986676216125,
-0.07724446058273315,
0.8243498802185059,
0.004216795787215233,
-0.8586188554763794,
0.28723374009132385,
-0.053376879543066025,
0.053756799548864365,
-0.3307388722896576,
-0.05368231609463692,
-0.48789912462234497,
0.13815468549728394,
-0.3104308843612671,
-0.8627185225486755,
0.5197107791900635,
-0.6177157759666443,
-0.07514340430498123,
-0.3659556806087494,
0.5110255479812622,
-0.6882814764976501,
-0.665762186050415,
0.18370909988880157,
0.2255784422159195,
-0.2993321418762207,
-0.077203169465065,
-0.4761557877063751,
0.21911625564098358,
0.04024747386574745,
0.04033830761909485,
0.04443566873669624,
0.7098063826560974,
-0.2176998108625412,
0.46808719635009766,
0.26680177450180054,
-0.07276905328035355,
0.0555451437830925,
0.19036951661109924,
0.8126775026321411,
-0.37707579135894775,
-0.7448074817657471,
-0.6934730410575867,
0.5230238437652588,
-0.18622133135795593,
-0.19443605840206146,
0.4776732921600342,
0.681704580783844,
0.9162854552268982,
-0.369998574256897,
0.558695375919342,
0.0033979725558310747,
-0.21970373392105103,
-0.7191165685653687,
0.5217713713645935,
-0.4139871597290039,
0.2080506980419159,
-0.3211282193660736,
-0.9673332571983337,
-0.4477226436138153,
0.8685625195503235,
-0.30294108390808105,
-0.017360897734761238,
1.0356694459915161,
0.5574609041213989,
-0.0833108052611351,
-0.23958948254585266,
0.16862843930721283,
0.053826287388801575,
0.1382564753293991,
0.5777822136878967,
0.863250195980072,
-0.33405953645706177,
0.4788719713687897,
-0.46698814630508423,
0.23537521064281464,
0.21208687126636505,
-0.5606825947761536,
-1.0429508686065674,
-0.7863579988479614,
-0.29466044902801514,
-0.024274956434965134,
0.1108405664563179,
0.5830296277999878,
0.8126503825187683,
-0.4039561450481415,
0.053717028349637985,
-0.4790666401386261,
0.004698844160884619,
-0.0512511245906353,
-0.2031085342168808,
0.44775184988975525,
-0.3488290011882782,
-0.49234122037887573,
0.41854047775268555,
0.5130329728126526,
0.19342643022537231,
-0.000925848784390837,
-0.05456780269742012,
0.009603106416761875,
-0.16742496192455292,
0.7451746463775635,
-0.09528209269046783,
-0.7426534295082092,
-0.2355528324842453,
-0.0665648877620697,
-0.22376133501529694,
0.2455945461988449,
0.7871196269989014,
-0.7646419405937195,
0.29966986179351807,
0.5528061985969543,
0.5646832585334778,
0.25084173679351807,
0.11616500467061996,
0.8751034736633301,
-1.2079960107803345,
0.29788339138031006,
-0.01650591380894184,
0.7692864537239075,
0.5200926065444946,
-0.6388724446296692,
0.7901468276977539,
-0.007056225091218948,
0.001446964219212532,
-0.5012233257293701,
0.27168044447898865,
-1.1210150718688965,
-0.32558673620224,
0.9412996172904968,
-0.18986070156097412,
-0.32522714138031006,
0.4961259365081787,
-0.257357120513916,
-0.01682787388563156,
-0.2859695255756378,
0.753227949142456,
0.5334457159042358,
-0.0010828934609889984,
-0.2818397283554077,
-0.16878379881381989,
0.5309526920318604,
0.5830926299095154,
-0.9890602827072144,
-0.11205000430345535,
0.901115357875824,
0.01065299566835165,
0.2648535668849945,
0.4988012909889221,
0.007225183770060539,
0.5437836050987244,
-0.22614561021327972,
-0.09542600810527802,
0.07447466254234314,
-0.4917394816875458,
-0.0782451331615448,
0.15691730380058289,
-0.19337405264377594,
-0.12898090481758118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14440v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14440v2 | Semantic Sensitivities and Inconsistent Predictions: Measuring the Fragility of NLI Models | 2024-01-25T14:47:05 | 2024-01-31T10:52:52 | Erik Arakelyan, Zhaoqi Liu, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Recent studies of the emergent capabilities of transformer-based Natural
Language Understanding (NLU) models have indicated that they have an
understanding of lexical and compositional semantics. We provide evidence that
suggests these claims should be taken with a grain of salt: we find that
state-of-the-art Natural Language Inference (NLI) models are sensitive towards
minor semantics preserving surface-form variations, which lead to sizable
inconsistent model decisions during inference. Notably, this behaviour differs
from valid and in-depth comprehension of compositional semantics, however does
neither emerge when evaluating model accuracy on standard benchmarks nor when
probing for syntactic, monotonic, and logically robust reasoning. We propose a
novel framework to measure the extent of semantic sensitivity. To this end, we
evaluate NLI models on adversarially generated examples containing minor
semantics-preserving surface-form input noise. This is achieved using
conditional text generation, with the explicit condition that the NLI model
predicts the relationship between the original and adversarial inputs as a
symmetric equivalence entailment. We systematically study the effects of the
phenomenon across NLI models for $\textbf{in-}$ and $\textbf{out-of-}$ domain
settings. Our experiments show that semantic sensitivity causes performance
degradations of $12.92\%$ and $23.71\%$ average over $\textbf{in-}$ and
$\textbf{out-of-}$ domain settings, respectively. We further perform ablation
studies, analysing this phenomenon across models, datasets, and variations in
inference and show that semantic sensitivity can lead to major inconsistency
within model predictions. | [
-0.4720062017440796,
-1.1653488874435425,
0.3659771680831909,
0.02606651373207569,
0.1806165724992752,
-0.5025962591171265,
-0.24852298200130463,
-0.49358677864074707,
-0.3223526179790497,
0.32882019877433777,
-0.7451723217964172,
-0.24786992371082306,
-0.9725989699363708,
0.26873886585235596,
-0.48623383045196533,
0.9552733898162842,
0.14916659891605377,
-0.15306608378887177,
-0.367678701877594,
-0.3568277060985565,
-0.5688106417655945,
-0.25522443652153015,
-0.5268163084983826,
-0.2443927675485611,
0.3693233132362366,
-0.2626645863056183,
1.286590576171875,
0.5210025906562805,
0.6453729867935181,
0.3392433822154999,
-0.35936179757118225,
-0.2301856130361557,
-0.1021917387843132,
0.3339407742023468,
-0.18788599967956543,
-0.8712658286094666,
-0.2702564299106598,
-0.08205439895391464,
0.5397546291351318,
1.0452052354812622,
-0.020600004121661186,
-0.09586402773857117,
0.13589900732040405,
0.46094951033592224,
-0.888771116733551,
-0.07601039856672287,
-1.1910825967788696,
-0.05299362167716026,
-0.03476634994149208,
0.10704939067363739,
-0.6580049991607666,
0.17237533628940582,
0.40327081084251404,
-0.8277549743652344,
0.4667818248271942,
-0.22796007990837097,
1.0113955736160278,
0.806232750415802,
-0.3893505930900574,
-0.311379075050354,
-0.636850893497467,
1.0601428747177124,
-0.8654419183731079,
0.4282169044017792,
0.4720291793346405,
0.02433130145072937,
-0.29501110315322876,
-0.6334207057952881,
-0.5132444500923157,
-0.32294929027557373,
-0.24823135137557983,
0.3584353029727936,
-0.6701781749725342,
0.030233776196837425,
0.46990132331848145,
0.13432638347148895,
-0.6626273989677429,
0.11736487597227097,
0.09352601319551468,
-0.34284794330596924,
0.3507241904735565,
0.225690096616745,
0.395067423582077,
-0.1571335643529892,
-0.45484164357185364,
-0.051214542239904404,
-0.5112290382385254,
0.09766092151403427,
0.4158220589160919,
0.45465222001075745,
-0.1819114238023758,
0.5670260787010193,
0.03302277624607086,
0.9484657049179077,
-0.007019377779215574,
-0.05976863577961922,
-0.1062728613615036,
-0.4657152593135834,
-0.35104236006736755,
-0.00012056424020556733,
0.6304672360420227,
0.32234612107276917,
0.10666682571172714,
-0.42214080691337585,
-0.08931397646665573,
0.6445774435997009,
0.43353065848350525,
-0.6416345834732056,
-0.2638293504714966,
0.2021501511335373,
-0.3265218138694763,
-0.43642446398735046,
0.03508462384343147,
-0.5455358028411865,
-0.4676746726036072,
-0.32656943798065186,
0.5895014405250549,
-0.6968667507171631,
-0.41043174266815186,
0.12959815561771393,
-0.30050337314605713,
0.1896546185016632,
0.13615861535072327,
-0.6908777952194214,
0.2612042725086212,
0.738287091255188,
0.6534358859062195,
-0.3626190721988678,
-0.5005204081535339,
-0.2248459905385971,
-0.02107330411672592,
-0.14828912913799286,
0.5989961624145508,
-0.3957693874835968,
-0.34256166219711304,
-0.17747314274311066,
-0.08724777400493622,
-0.543386697769165,
-0.572587788105011,
0.6782493591308594,
-0.41158974170684814,
0.22723518311977386,
-0.10001768171787262,
-0.5415859818458557,
-0.010492701083421707,
0.24276451766490936,
-0.7372459769248962,
0.7870144248008728,
0.028478533029556274,
-1.1364859342575073,
0.5216061472892761,
-0.4154612123966217,
-0.32212528586387634,
-0.34045523405075073,
0.06322313845157623,
-0.49394622445106506,
0.23369111120700836,
-0.1178223267197609,
-0.0018430876079946756,
-0.22384069859981537,
0.4093065559864044,
-0.5131925940513611,
-0.07756878435611725,
0.7519159317016602,
-0.8509158492088318,
1.0845974683761597,
0.07255983352661133,
-0.39962834119796753,
0.07836535573005676,
-0.9036536812782288,
-0.15781737864017487,
0.015214899554848671,
-0.08610273152589798,
-0.3673289120197296,
0.11636762320995331,
-0.24452471733093262,
0.18404221534729004,
0.06570740789175034,
-0.5277502536773682,
-0.38164108991622925,
-0.8030113577842712,
0.24348314106464386,
0.7462352514266968,
-0.07298203557729721,
0.5632612705230713,
-0.3907321095466614,
0.23252426087856293,
0.2858048677444458,
0.2100096046924591,
0.1478598266839981,
-0.5169476866722107,
-0.8311883211135864,
-0.1740315556526184,
0.2359815537929535,
0.48440051078796387,
-0.6129781603813171,
0.5159038305282593,
-0.34980282187461853,
-0.3033255934715271,
-0.4158959686756134,
0.06436645984649658,
0.2503208816051483,
0.8291090130805969,
0.2672853171825409,
-0.009211968630552292,
-0.34123238921165466,
-0.9716796875,
-0.547333836555481,
-0.39188438653945923,
-0.24583084881305695,
0.09096521139144897,
0.47052326798439026,
-0.19798977673053741,
1.100346326828003,
-0.12084472179412842,
-0.033961277455091476,
-0.15596207976341248,
0.2162904441356659,
-0.06054968014359474,
0.24785813689231873,
0.6165784597396851,
-1.0005511045455933,
-0.12691862881183624,
-0.22427555918693542,
-0.6871459484100342,
-0.06185091659426689,
-0.02067340724170208,
-0.33620283007621765,
0.4403728246688843,
0.3550625145435333,
-0.8096908926963806,
0.6823635101318359,
0.6168748140335083,
-0.5045865774154663,
0.2437349557876587,
0.0923493504524231,
-0.18716295063495636,
-0.8390102982521057,
0.15354977548122406,
0.07443167269229889,
0.12212853133678436,
-0.8647266030311584,
0.060750845819711685,
-0.15735343098640442,
0.12437205761671066,
-0.34535443782806396,
0.31700730323791504,
-0.029763346537947655,
0.20653031766414642,
-0.423250675201416,
0.17884394526481628,
0.2903897166252136,
0.37672674655914307,
-0.0001356054563075304,
0.5875394940376282,
0.4440230429172516,
-0.7089526653289795,
-0.0015986603684723377,
0.15224434435367584,
-0.040054742246866226,
0.555705726146698,
-0.8337302207946777,
-0.30441924929618835,
-0.16080345213413239,
-0.006868768949061632,
-0.9016123414039612,
-0.2498033195734024,
0.2498786449432373,
-0.5681296586990356,
0.2902142405509949,
-0.045917849987745285,
-0.15142543613910675,
0.08846389502286911,
-0.16435259580612183,
0.17525768280029297,
0.2688252627849579,
-0.3113994002342224,
1.0689918994903564,
0.2329634130001068,
0.09158377349376678,
-0.5830032825469971,
-0.9059280753135681,
-0.10315652936697006,
-0.3231378495693207,
-0.7693251967430115,
0.15772227942943573,
-0.0522395595908165,
-0.5665681958198547,
0.2543054521083832,
-0.22556933760643005,
-0.04159035161137581,
0.792812168598175,
0.4435473680496216,
0.4355332851409912,
-0.32943204045295715,
0.01805347204208374,
0.01353989914059639,
-0.11629512906074524,
0.5025712251663208,
-0.021154336631298065,
0.17971555888652802,
-0.31278058886528015,
-0.47941192984580994,
-0.30807483196258545,
0.269051194190979,
0.5294399857521057,
-0.23199833929538727,
0.9815090298652649,
0.5340125560760498,
-0.5342050194740295,
-0.1931399554014206,
-0.23313403129577637,
-0.16224482655525208,
-0.41153013706207275,
0.248533695936203,
-0.5159800052642822,
-0.5863815546035767,
0.7589061856269836,
0.1971144825220108,
-0.06557518243789673,
0.7868967652320862,
0.4659152925014496,
0.16556228697299957,
1.0938588380813599,
0.4545566439628601,
0.1915196031332016,
0.21229402720928192,
-0.1182379350066185,
0.13885712623596191,
-0.6368562579154968,
0.05637805536389351,
-0.618797242641449,
-0.11457829177379608,
-0.8446768522262573,
0.1152009591460228,
0.1557823121547699,
0.03197006508708,
-0.2475084811449051,
0.28863221406936646,
-0.3087558448314667,
0.1468411684036255,
0.3839113414287567,
0.13114432990550995,
0.17932376265525818,
-0.23012709617614746,
0.11192995309829712,
-0.13475681841373444,
-0.8292990922927856,
-0.42689040303230286,
0.8850376009941101,
0.3469579219818115,
0.6955745816230774,
0.5349966287612915,
0.14858084917068481,
0.06469067186117172,
0.2577299177646637,
-0.7168048024177551,
0.23590593039989471,
-0.23460708558559418,
-0.6425904035568237,
-0.28555792570114136,
-0.5130561590194702,
-0.9504798054695129,
0.2394985556602478,
-0.35831084847450256,
-0.737373411655426,
0.4636717140674591,
0.053243715316057205,
-0.29079315066337585,
0.2253427952528,
-0.8301897644996643,
1.1617915630340576,
0.11849379539489746,
-0.4242994487285614,
0.235722616314888,
-0.9628515839576721,
0.3842955231666565,
-0.03127538785338402,
0.02637477032840252,
-0.32552236318588257,
0.017163410782814026,
0.3200463056564331,
-0.20748105645179749,
1.0129833221435547,
-0.16345028579235077,
-0.14711163938045502,
0.25922197103500366,
0.43249210715293884,
0.3286000192165375,
0.025507409125566483,
-0.35022273659706116,
0.24148176610469818,
0.023094508796930313,
-0.3849025070667267,
-0.9080137014389038,
0.665511429309845,
-0.8436105847358704,
-0.4889872372150421,
-0.25532928109169006,
-0.6701716184616089,
-0.23362140357494354,
0.19022420048713684,
0.694520890712738,
0.5877847075462341,
-0.2587559223175049,
0.15494580566883087,
0.8355779051780701,
-0.12193252146244049,
0.33247578144073486,
0.37155839800834656,
0.2910394072532654,
-0.07839222252368927,
0.8100287318229675,
-0.005439174827188253,
0.7092493772506714,
0.21177199482917786,
0.21801377832889557,
-0.3306179642677307,
-0.5840669274330139,
-0.3465801775455475,
-0.09163487702608109,
-0.710773766040802,
-0.29565733671188354,
-0.6202231049537659,
-0.25359320640563965,
-0.19963011145591736,
-0.038374628871679306,
-0.34434422850608826,
-0.38142886757850647,
-0.22955892980098724,
0.016667719930410385,
0.24631820619106293,
0.3942716121673584,
0.2076922506093979,
0.14161129295825958,
-0.3899570405483246,
0.20585165917873383,
0.01802862621843815,
0.22711186110973358,
-0.17209658026695251,
-0.796657383441925,
0.15435174107551575,
0.22241780161857605,
-0.14560888707637787,
-0.7351216077804565,
0.13656574487686157,
0.3818480372428894,
0.5372216701507568,
0.2140440195798874,
0.40277206897735596,
0.3188241422176361,
-0.0758436992764473,
0.7286084890365601,
-0.0758289247751236,
-1.0545926094055176,
0.6321703791618347,
-0.31754106283187866,
0.4591217041015625,
0.8010540008544922,
0.19385899603366852,
-0.1519414484500885,
-1.081227421760559,
-0.7092798948287964,
-0.8027100563049316,
0.6712592840194702,
0.27534064650535583,
0.11761035025119781,
-0.15952688455581665,
0.19817301630973816,
0.2486160546541214,
-0.047331552952528,
-0.7134058475494385,
-0.31567975878715515,
-0.3843151926994324,
-0.3769766390323639,
0.11419873684644699,
-0.19279171526432037,
-0.3101038634777069,
0.13972297310829163,
0.648105800151825,
-0.279485285282135,
0.11037880927324295,
0.29101184010505676,
-0.342235267162323,
0.028371423482894897,
0.28483298420906067,
0.5987616181373596,
0.7944414019584656,
-0.1730925589799881,
0.403692364692688,
0.32604753971099854,
-0.4212166965007782,
-0.06842546164989471,
0.25060322880744934,
-0.45610445737838745,
0.009259365499019623,
0.6140257120132446,
0.9659627079963684,
0.23681268095970154,
-0.500863790512085,
0.802972674369812,
-0.3291306495666504,
-0.18723677098751068,
-0.27522504329681396,
0.054965727031230927,
-0.185453861951828,
-0.22263889014720917,
0.0015818251995369792,
0.687835693359375,
0.3157304525375366,
-0.284633994102478,
0.23727650940418243,
0.5847039818763733,
-0.5452300310134888,
-0.34822121262550354,
0.7687448859214783,
-0.1257748156785965,
0.09918107837438583,
0.5184929966926575,
-0.1164393275976181,
-0.3171234428882599,
0.5918090343475342,
0.4986771047115326,
0.8229645490646362,
0.02009064331650734,
-0.002540442394092679,
0.1838921159505844,
0.44895488023757935,
0.2813893258571625,
-0.19061066210269928,
0.1488087773323059,
-1.0709939002990723,
-0.32648763060569763,
-0.5854875445365906,
-0.24676033854484558,
-0.003325343830510974,
-0.9852755069732666,
0.017901532351970673,
-0.319365531206131,
-0.4333255887031555,
0.3187691867351532,
-0.29475492238998413,
-0.4932255148887634,
0.19244085252285004,
0.1128096953034401,
0.9002129435539246,
-1.070967435836792,
0.4179520308971405,
0.6233359575271606,
-0.23329246044158936,
-0.6303523182868958,
0.25175321102142334,
0.1301228106021881,
-0.4527934193611145,
0.4171004891395569,
0.08561071008443832,
-0.44754287600517273,
-0.23832617700099945,
-0.24079889059066772,
-0.6794992089271545,
0.7653526663780212,
0.662924587726593,
0.03211387246847153,
0.13718070089817047,
0.29032281041145325,
0.6077740788459778,
-0.005414248909801245,
0.24996931850910187,
0.8095859289169312,
0.39757874608039856,
-0.12877944111824036,
-0.7088099122047424,
0.1784464567899704,
-0.37376782298088074,
0.11828300356864929,
0.18610763549804688,
-0.35828620195388794,
0.6367266774177551,
-0.02326137013733387,
-0.5234037041664124,
0.20073020458221436,
0.704714834690094,
-0.006483597680926323,
0.4178621172904968,
0.6760982275009155,
0.8085799217224121,
0.5235426425933838,
-0.3585808277130127,
1.2227094173431396,
-0.4528537094593048,
0.17988838255405426,
1.0519343614578247,
-0.16496139764785767,
0.7452797889709473,
0.4863147735595703,
-0.05800800025463104,
0.43147197365760803,
0.23276282846927643,
0.07428725063800812,
0.3913160562515259,
-0.12133914232254028,
-0.44063445925712585,
-0.2832663357257843,
-0.4414037764072418,
-0.10581407696008682,
0.7197946906089783,
0.30307233333587646,
-0.16173036396503448,
-0.3068366050720215,
0.023466581478714943,
0.060231707990169525,
0.37123221158981323,
0.13529063761234283,
0.9826915264129639,
-0.09364363551139832,
-0.8234392404556274,
0.5180439949035645,
0.057043105363845825,
0.6411933302879333,
-0.6987121105194092,
0.33164963126182556,
-0.09362230449914932,
0.3148568868637085,
-0.21582847833633423,
-0.6933491230010986,
0.8259580135345459,
-0.13451077044010162,
-0.4409463107585907,
0.09126663953065872,
0.8223189115524292,
-0.25876179337501526,
-0.5174911022186279,
0.4602240025997162,
0.4152061939239502,
-0.32058030366897583,
0.04737820103764534,
-0.7979198694229126,
0.33054327964782715,
-0.1282694935798645,
-0.3037237226963043,
0.3697299659252167,
0.5496836304664612,
0.18211610615253448,
0.5125680565834045,
0.44997018575668335,
-0.15320956707000732,
0.2944921553134918,
0.22382327914237976,
0.7258971929550171,
-0.1014355719089508,
-0.04018243029713631,
-0.8767516613006592,
0.5753424167633057,
0.01869254559278488,
-0.5135390758514404,
0.7743995785713196,
0.39292141795158386,
0.8253298997879028,
0.14928951859474182,
0.7167915105819702,
-0.05629097670316696,
0.366706520318985,
-0.583278238773346,
0.5369147658348083,
-0.39755868911743164,
0.22426699101924896,
-0.050617992877960205,
-0.6352472901344299,
-0.4320456385612488,
0.35305893421173096,
-0.35038644075393677,
-0.07976216822862625,
0.4914925992488861,
0.9735092520713806,
-0.029572580009698868,
0.1530887484550476,
0.2383636236190796,
0.22539278864860535,
0.11266428232192993,
0.4333339333534241,
0.8829904198646545,
-0.5670926570892334,
0.502828061580658,
-0.47050976753234863,
-0.06376628577709198,
0.23758463561534882,
-0.6846741437911987,
-0.6661251187324524,
-0.46059712767601013,
-0.4953620433807373,
-0.6210542321205139,
0.08226504176855087,
0.42065221071243286,
0.23909729719161987,
-0.8693662285804749,
0.2563265562057495,
-0.561660647392273,
0.1978638470172882,
0.006220098584890366,
-0.31271520256996155,
0.3317309021949768,
-0.5124115943908691,
-0.6465237140655518,
0.25066983699798584,
0.06582918018102646,
0.1461695283651352,
-0.06302293390035629,
0.09981612861156464,
0.013638803735375404,
0.19787880778312683,
0.3446817398071289,
0.19167295098304749,
-1.002616286277771,
-0.35590875148773193,
0.10791446268558502,
-0.26002737879753113,
-0.20947130024433136,
0.43783819675445557,
-0.4545757472515106,
0.4431907832622528,
0.3736184537410736,
0.7164674997329712,
-0.1311085820198059,
0.05608360469341278,
0.5528082251548767,
-0.6697888970375061,
0.3343043625354767,
0.11770825833082199,
0.330424040555954,
0.37395474314689636,
-0.22624093294143677,
0.24797490239143372,
0.2788533568382263,
-0.30827975273132324,
-0.8569833636283875,
0.48356691002845764,
-0.8513099551200867,
-0.46862027049064636,
0.9027475714683533,
-0.20677633583545685,
-0.3709048926830292,
-0.061635423451662064,
0.2239677906036377,
0.163277730345726,
0.05245499685406685,
0.5942912101745605,
0.762493371963501,
-0.1143130511045456,
0.20943914353847504,
-0.5267683863639832,
0.6531913876533508,
0.7097495794296265,
-0.414622962474823,
0.27999594807624817,
0.31749629974365234,
0.11682520806789398,
0.3574374318122864,
0.009426794946193695,
-0.15061116218566895,
0.334258496761322,
0.45424818992614746,
-0.19629283249378204,
0.144138902425766,
-0.17907610535621643,
-0.5344871282577515,
0.11824601888656616,
0.26845186948776245,
0.02629598043859005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14196v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14196v2 | DeepSeek-Coder: When the Large Language Model Meets Programming -- The Rise of Code Intelligence | 2024-01-25T14:17:53 | 2024-01-26T09:23:11 | Daya Guo, Qihao Zhu, Dejian Yang, Zhenda Xie, Kai Dong, Wentao Zhang, Guanting Chen, Xiao Bi, Y. Wu, Y. K. Li, Fuli Luo, Yingfei Xiong, Wenfeng Liang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid development of large language models has revolutionized code
intelligence in software development. However, the predominance of
closed-source models has restricted extensive research and development. To
address this, we introduce the DeepSeek-Coder series, a range of open-source
code models with sizes from 1.3B to 33B, trained from scratch on 2 trillion
tokens. These models are pre-trained on a high-quality project-level code
corpus and employ a fill-in-the-blank task with a 16K window to enhance code
generation and infilling. Our extensive evaluations demonstrate that
DeepSeek-Coder not only achieves state-of-the-art performance among open-source
code models across multiple benchmarks but also surpasses existing
closed-source models like Codex and GPT-3.5. Furthermore, DeepSeek-Coder models
are under a permissive license that allows for both research and unrestricted
commercial use. | [
-0.2708360254764557,
-0.10427943617105484,
0.4526017904281616,
0.1447695940732956,
-0.07420017570257187,
0.24024522304534912,
-0.36701709032058716,
-0.5626678466796875,
-0.32067838311195374,
0.7877495884895325,
-0.2742060720920563,
-0.5610102415084839,
-0.5418856739997864,
-0.20649491250514984,
-0.5530692338943481,
1.0129573345184326,
0.03960448503494263,
0.0050062332302331924,
-0.03256421536207199,
0.2074594497680664,
-0.3295488655567169,
-0.660728394985199,
-0.006646901369094849,
-0.12698179483413696,
0.3389517664909363,
0.6392937302589417,
0.8860785365104675,
0.509839653968811,
0.8735505938529968,
0.18634556233882904,
0.2483416497707367,
-0.26011502742767334,
-0.598417341709137,
-0.047992173582315445,
-0.04075605422258377,
-0.30688154697418213,
-0.5351191163063049,
0.07257639616727829,
0.1751748025417328,
0.6581084728240967,
-0.03888217359781265,
0.42066478729248047,
-0.1963679939508438,
0.8232617974281311,
-0.7011067867279053,
0.15951211750507355,
-0.6351739764213562,
-0.05067940801382065,
-0.25303688645362854,
0.21428680419921875,
-0.5231735706329346,
-0.4186677038669586,
-0.06773797422647476,
-0.45707079768180847,
0.158641055226326,
-0.384429931640625,
0.6265803575515747,
0.3466443419456482,
-0.033061012625694275,
-0.3129211962223053,
-0.9889670610427856,
0.6340013742446899,
-1.1171437501907349,
0.3848380744457245,
0.30935993790626526,
0.3158601224422455,
0.037943772971630096,
-0.8856639266014099,
-0.429777055978775,
-0.4747626483440399,
0.27227890491485596,
-0.06683138012886047,
0.025489099323749542,
-0.13819554448127747,
0.4803917407989502,
0.6758424639701843,
-0.6402403712272644,
0.26500850915908813,
-0.7847693562507629,
0.17944785952568054,
0.5260944962501526,
0.032212842255830765,
0.35901355743408203,
0.1598258912563324,
-0.06470482051372528,
0.11252980679273605,
-0.8527440428733826,
-0.1519792377948761,
0.2789354920387268,
0.14991366863250732,
-0.21115057170391083,
0.6782934665679932,
-0.1620289385318756,
0.4840438961982727,
-0.20956262946128845,
0.250836044549942,
0.289233535528183,
-0.26862961053848267,
-0.5059787631034851,
-0.08767069876194,
0.4806176424026489,
0.04136741906404495,
0.4484737515449524,
-0.2043844759464264,
-0.32517024874687195,
0.2610267996788025,
0.4325958490371704,
-1.178579568862915,
-0.5510826706886292,
0.29268279671669006,
-0.6424334049224854,
-0.32794761657714844,
0.12723037600517273,
-0.5544832944869995,
-0.6418552994728088,
-0.5820854306221008,
-0.006623559165745974,
-0.38788923621177673,
-0.6446249485015869,
0.37973299622535706,
0.0741044282913208,
0.37577036023139954,
0.2251286506652832,
-0.6837825179100037,
0.16441962122917175,
1.0633381605148315,
0.730983316898346,
0.2387564331293106,
-0.2657664716243744,
-0.4275025725364685,
0.015814529731869698,
-0.8258058428764343,
0.2776211202144623,
-0.8666875958442688,
-0.14095745980739594,
0.12233414500951767,
-0.3198155164718628,
0.37408536672592163,
-0.4202180504798889,
0.2009943276643753,
-0.825053870677948,
-0.2553718686103821,
0.08888084441423416,
-0.8128594756126404,
0.05417945235967636,
0.04125513508915901,
-0.6338974237442017,
0.8363440632820129,
0.35268741846084595,
-0.44063520431518555,
0.507557213306427,
-0.7543902397155762,
-0.17698106169700623,
0.4512016475200653,
-0.26083242893218994,
-0.1603941023349762,
0.3625473976135254,
0.03601687401533127,
0.5154823064804077,
-0.4024884104728699,
0.25907662510871887,
-0.41091763973236084,
-0.49706342816352844,
0.21615645289421082,
-0.04767498001456261,
0.6628237962722778,
0.5271097421646118,
-0.19161510467529297,
0.4247540533542633,
-0.6811894178390503,
-0.04267577826976776,
0.10500580072402954,
-0.40001538395881653,
-0.27522554993629456,
-0.17622368037700653,
0.020339565351605415,
0.26952919363975525,
0.03987531363964081,
-0.7334480285644531,
0.24510768055915833,
-0.5723127126693726,
0.6876160502433777,
0.5428300499916077,
-0.3137264847755432,
0.4675423800945282,
-0.028624676167964935,
0.5304542183876038,
-0.03711716830730438,
0.27919262647628784,
-0.5333142876625061,
-0.28992506861686707,
-0.7620957493782043,
-0.4002683460712433,
0.4444427490234375,
0.2925598621368408,
-0.28316783905029297,
0.25175556540489197,
-0.4104447662830353,
-0.8591373562812805,
-0.5054773688316345,
0.29293113946914673,
0.25648951530456543,
-0.02768845111131668,
0.15722908079624176,
-0.2692684531211853,
-0.5387124419212341,
-0.657808244228363,
-0.1415502429008484,
0.15724247694015503,
-0.2000139355659485,
0.2465125471353531,
0.6250870227813721,
-0.39827847480773926,
0.7175083160400391,
-0.6502944231033325,
-0.017497817054390907,
-0.24370940029621124,
-0.08421377092599869,
0.555007815361023,
0.7105180025100708,
0.6607396602630615,
-0.7240092754364014,
-0.5203592777252197,
0.21052449941635132,
-0.5412827730178833,
0.3564532399177551,
0.08382533490657806,
-0.11816748231649399,
0.1419370472431183,
1.0468122959136963,
-0.5131266713142395,
0.4450210630893707,
0.618591845035553,
-0.3548479974269867,
0.45980745553970337,
-0.3331749439239502,
-0.12531860172748566,
-0.9769731163978577,
0.403592586517334,
-0.3454028069972992,
-0.061439018696546555,
-0.41770297288894653,
0.6623461246490479,
0.26329606771469116,
-0.7720066905021667,
-0.40910854935646057,
0.37789827585220337,
-0.43269971013069153,
-0.008260617963969707,
-0.32137995958328247,
-0.4269638955593109,
-0.1375187337398529,
0.3228713870048523,
-0.245109423995018,
0.9324772357940674,
0.5424417853355408,
-0.44325682520866394,
0.48676174879074097,
0.12927857041358948,
-0.7996804118156433,
-0.2597790062427521,
-0.8277194499969482,
0.544975757598877,
0.09786159545183182,
-0.0176923256367445,
-0.6229768991470337,
-0.45784300565719604,
-0.11189085990190506,
-0.5344118475914001,
0.28516891598701477,
-0.46634116768836975,
-0.5998041033744812,
-0.5628859400749207,
-0.1393735110759735,
0.5194575786590576,
0.8511383533477783,
-0.5737317800521851,
0.419042706489563,
0.28461208939552307,
-0.3420603573322296,
-0.4048600494861603,
-0.6562848687171936,
0.23865702748298645,
0.2454187422990799,
-0.5104278326034546,
0.005442757159471512,
-0.19184468686580658,
-0.21192646026611328,
0.12486511468887329,
-0.008647960610687733,
-0.20603697001934052,
0.07250254601240158,
0.557685136795044,
0.30329662561416626,
-0.5994131565093994,
0.15614287555217743,
-0.3558335602283478,
-0.2658933699131012,
-0.00648140162229538,
-0.7139545679092407,
0.6450725197792053,
-0.23827996850013733,
-0.469678670167923,
0.14372579753398895,
0.47330644726753235,
0.836713969707489,
-0.9502767324447632,
0.6563628911972046,
0.27008479833602905,
-0.3193000257015228,
-0.11747577786445618,
-0.600182831287384,
0.21031926572322845,
-0.451359361410141,
0.5613192319869995,
-0.5518319606781006,
-1.1748607158660889,
0.3232145309448242,
-0.1380067616701126,
0.28281429409980774,
0.3682822585105896,
0.639747679233551,
0.31092679500579834,
0.8353787660598755,
1.0905927419662476,
-0.28492745757102966,
0.43799588084220886,
-0.29409000277519226,
0.28160643577575684,
-0.4341839551925659,
-0.09937974065542221,
-0.6558518409729004,
-0.021889425814151764,
-0.3300469219684601,
-0.5741034746170044,
-0.15692192316055298,
0.13837315142154694,
-0.7460580468177795,
0.2632482945919037,
-0.5316747426986694,
0.8796311616897583,
0.6941540837287903,
-0.0839124321937561,
0.007128943223506212,
-0.12488918751478195,
0.17191636562347412,
0.2960098087787628,
-0.5840296149253845,
-0.4406523108482361,
1.3342852592468262,
0.6212093830108643,
0.9197955131530762,
0.25089767575263977,
0.6174710392951965,
0.3257063031196594,
0.3316302001476288,
-0.5381702780723572,
0.32351958751678467,
-0.4148399531841278,
-0.7389615178108215,
-0.21899287402629852,
-0.2090965062379837,
-0.6321444511413574,
-0.4479260742664337,
0.16125166416168213,
-0.3298770487308502,
0.27058395743370056,
0.06587278097867966,
-0.5995429754257202,
0.3673078715801239,
-0.8539867401123047,
1.2189394235610962,
-0.07691507041454315,
-0.13166363537311554,
-0.49465852975845337,
-0.4119642674922943,
0.3511967957019806,
-0.22502639889717102,
0.049397729337215424,
-0.2927817404270172,
-0.09628696739673615,
0.4363948404788971,
-0.4260280132293701,
0.7977813482284546,
-0.22424207627773285,
-0.18586739897727966,
0.2807367146015167,
0.4507051408290863,
0.5942361354827881,
0.08006680756807327,
-0.1394553780555725,
0.2554757595062256,
-0.26728788018226624,
-0.5959168076515198,
-0.36110708117485046,
0.8461340665817261,
-0.767429530620575,
-0.43675854802131653,
-0.17838770151138306,
-0.46591609716415405,
0.005165403708815575,
0.4316677749156952,
0.13419899344444275,
0.6038378477096558,
-0.1916312277317047,
0.5575668215751648,
0.6148024201393127,
-0.558178186416626,
0.43829643726348877,
0.4213993549346924,
-0.397577166557312,
-0.2893119752407074,
0.9900728464126587,
-0.20366427302360535,
0.2062014788389206,
0.20470090210437775,
-0.03816118463873863,
0.21905112266540527,
-0.7619704604148865,
-0.45734596252441406,
0.02925005555152893,
-0.5223384499549866,
-0.3973066508769989,
-0.5250011086463928,
-0.5179160833358765,
-0.4723764657974243,
-0.31056129932403564,
-0.6164966821670532,
-0.16390635073184967,
-0.05214393883943558,
-0.04168842360377312,
0.4710806906223297,
1.0744543075561523,
0.14940837025642395,
-0.10340814292430878,
-1.120876669883728,
0.26665061712265015,
0.17089392244815826,
1.0014407634735107,
0.1313161700963974,
-0.3258800506591797,
-0.7092804908752441,
-0.15676948428153992,
0.10508397966623306,
-0.5115880370140076,
0.29691216349601746,
-0.11786626279354095,
0.20359395444393158,
0.31295105814933777,
0.06806366890668869,
0.33195680379867554,
-0.5680604577064514,
0.7011358141899109,
0.22294548153877258,
-0.9478622078895569,
0.5601149797439575,
-0.59794020652771,
0.47610852122306824,
0.44702109694480896,
0.0872102603316307,
-0.43134352564811707,
-0.45212259888648987,
-0.34615322947502136,
-0.8111258745193481,
0.694603681564331,
0.2288733869791031,
0.39144614338874817,
0.20235313475131989,
0.31777888536453247,
0.2881167531013489,
0.23158960044384003,
-0.46566057205200195,
0.47951027750968933,
-0.7135536670684814,
-0.2844025194644928,
-0.11604823917150497,
-0.4805718660354614,
0.08798322826623917,
-0.22682495415210724,
0.5203187465667725,
-0.2645176351070404,
0.17649278044700623,
-0.14571839570999146,
-0.24157941341400146,
-0.112058624625206,
0.26550614833831787,
0.5980867147445679,
1.133950114250183,
-0.2948208153247833,
-0.06745096296072006,
-0.39103519916534424,
-0.6243745684623718,
-0.16373787820339203,
0.2473156750202179,
-0.09249226003885269,
-0.4801529347896576,
0.4658508598804474,
0.8280457854270935,
-0.06786653399467468,
-0.8343634605407715,
0.6635239124298096,
0.08138149976730347,
0.0157060194760561,
-0.4862794280052185,
0.26644426584243774,
0.08298880606889725,
0.4014630913734436,
0.223872572183609,
0.3383287191390991,
0.09984062612056732,
-0.305216521024704,
0.1312127560377121,
0.15530607104301453,
-0.4593728482723236,
-0.11609268933534622,
0.6670441031455994,
0.47457361221313477,
-0.17680752277374268,
0.9564436674118042,
-0.03534816950559616,
-0.3706822693347931,
0.8925226330757141,
0.3041176497936249,
1.086909294128418,
0.12294583767652512,
-0.09228873252868652,
0.39041513204574585,
0.40180468559265137,
0.06339811533689499,
0.29272717237472534,
0.14949311316013336,
-0.5068894624710083,
-0.8509470224380493,
-0.6311221718788147,
-0.19698286056518555,
0.42996126413345337,
-0.40627121925354004,
0.10685279220342636,
-0.6028417348861694,
0.13129286468029022,
0.0702136754989624,
0.1496824324131012,
-0.8142017126083374,
0.07696852833032608,
0.4552081227302551,
1.5072859525680542,
-0.3870891332626343,
1.160885214805603,
0.6148490905761719,
-0.7276234030723572,
-0.9279575347900391,
0.00040031870594248176,
-0.27191945910453796,
-0.5480359792709351,
0.6603242754936218,
0.24115386605262756,
0.2130601853132248,
0.15369448065757751,
-0.8447970151901245,
-0.8597891926765442,
0.740938127040863,
0.5077000260353088,
-0.7168841361999512,
-0.13366487622261047,
0.04595964401960373,
0.4246787130832672,
-0.38644495606422424,
-0.0338815376162529,
0.4161817133426666,
0.2130899578332901,
-0.19513586163520813,
-0.8602210879325867,
-0.12037749588489532,
-0.5229178071022034,
0.12276177853345871,
0.46910566091537476,
-0.5328748822212219,
0.9039024114608765,
-0.5530176758766174,
0.14967408776283264,
0.3358822464942932,
0.7083325386047363,
0.04940344765782356,
-0.14325696229934692,
0.07156214118003845,
0.33163246512413025,
0.48650938272476196,
0.11610593646764755,
1.251309871673584,
-0.6350820660591125,
0.14199401438236237,
1.1687846183776855,
-0.3850097954273224,
0.8551741242408752,
0.0588257759809494,
-0.08410077542066574,
0.4633074104785919,
0.3686142861843109,
-0.4326782524585724,
0.28004565834999084,
0.1330939531326294,
0.04101910442113876,
-0.32990559935569763,
0.12526316940784454,
-0.6378881335258484,
0.29884791374206543,
0.09102832525968552,
-0.23348984122276306,
0.056691598147153854,
-0.018049757927656174,
-0.07683297246694565,
0.15263646841049194,
-0.44515880942344666,
0.5623051524162292,
0.20926687121391296,
-0.45754340291023254,
0.3493434190750122,
0.014977150596678257,
0.5358550548553467,
-0.728223979473114,
-0.1529470533132553,
-0.42228055000305176,
0.7258589267730713,
-0.06343546509742737,
-0.8138370513916016,
0.21408627927303314,
0.21822576224803925,
-0.4099648892879486,
-0.018017007037997246,
0.684933602809906,
-0.11101951450109482,
-0.6036962270736694,
0.358517050743103,
0.27753910422325134,
-0.10876817256212234,
-0.377895712852478,
-0.4240794777870178,
0.10856413096189499,
-0.1495668590068817,
-0.09282789379358292,
0.25291088223457336,
0.6362331509590149,
0.2533186376094818,
0.5637519955635071,
0.8631158471107483,
0.05061124265193939,
0.18860895931720734,
0.18704262375831604,
1.1746282577514648,
-0.8354024291038513,
-0.5740957260131836,
-0.7805513739585876,
0.42255857586860657,
-0.0668983906507492,
-0.3648207187652588,
0.7438817024230957,
0.9604604244232178,
1.1099915504455566,
-0.5809364914894104,
0.809613823890686,
-0.08981953561306,
0.5706788301467896,
-0.3501376211643219,
0.9323762655258179,
-0.3655620515346527,
0.17182251811027527,
-0.5202380418777466,
-0.7639478445053101,
-0.3365737199783325,
0.1123104840517044,
-0.2775140106678009,
0.048516612499952316,
0.19075308740139008,
0.7020532488822937,
-0.23485611379146576,
-0.04874221980571747,
0.26638150215148926,
0.421779990196228,
0.5015126466751099,
0.8656752109527588,
0.9807559251785278,
-0.18505872786045074,
0.6491184830665588,
-0.04292888566851616,
-0.3258621394634247,
-0.3145865499973297,
-0.7342902421951294,
-0.9292238354682922,
-0.2785411477088928,
-0.1324414163827896,
-0.25468161702156067,
-0.17651821672916412,
0.9573140740394592,
0.9695413112640381,
-1.0174479484558105,
-0.34716880321502686,
-0.3364410102367401,
-0.25095197558403015,
-0.21680065989494324,
-0.12625597417354584,
0.2176472246646881,
-0.6220578551292419,
-0.36572518944740295,
0.409938782453537,
0.30379462242126465,
-0.04615351930260658,
-0.4005712568759918,
-0.4756740927696228,
0.14079907536506653,
0.26348423957824707,
0.5760237574577332,
0.313788503408432,
-0.38651713728904724,
0.10705085843801498,
0.2926170229911804,
-0.34907904267311096,
0.009563656523823738,
1.2512099742889404,
-0.8625006079673767,
0.3052978217601776,
0.3889756202697754,
0.8140767216682434,
0.4130023121833801,
-0.33318638801574707,
0.6692999005317688,
-0.5596165060997009,
0.40595200657844543,
0.42389217019081116,
0.0627904012799263,
0.12044793367385864,
-0.29398810863494873,
0.6932900547981262,
-0.1284368634223938,
-0.6390011310577393,
-0.9801463484764099,
0.2829401195049286,
-0.5039194226264954,
-0.6503055691719055,
0.9058987498283386,
-0.07775536179542542,
0.13894788920879364,
-0.018652716651558876,
-0.1653466522693634,
0.07691141963005066,
-0.35657942295074463,
0.4116916060447693,
0.48257163166999817,
0.20598715543746948,
-0.19428439438343048,
-0.7068796753883362,
0.6404159665107727,
-0.06036101281642914,
-0.7326386570930481,
0.36614087224006653,
0.5255889296531677,
0.1256583333015442,
0.20439185202121735,
0.6398196220397949,
-0.18811753392219543,
0.40568503737449646,
0.3610975742340088,
0.38835984468460083,
-0.5143429636955261,
-0.616610586643219,
-0.19611188769340515,
0.42480403184890747,
0.4433572590351105,
-0.006700558587908745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14194v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14194v3 | Parameter-Efficient Conversational Recommender System as a Language Processing Task | 2024-01-25T14:07:34 | 2024-02-25T03:00:48 | Mathieu Ravaut, Hao Zhang, Lu Xu, Aixin Sun, Yong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational recommender systems (CRS) aim to recommend relevant items to
users by eliciting user preference through natural language conversation. Prior
work often utilizes external knowledge graphs for items' semantic information,
a language model for dialogue generation, and a recommendation module for
ranking relevant items. This combination of multiple components suffers from a
cumbersome training process, and leads to semantic misalignment issues between
dialogue generation and item recommendation. In this paper, we represent items
in natural language and formulate CRS as a natural language processing task.
Accordingly, we leverage the power of pre-trained language models to encode
items, understand user intent via conversation, perform item recommendation
through semantic matching, and generate dialogues. As a unified model, our
PECRS (Parameter-Efficient CRS), can be optimized in a single stage, without
relying on non-textual metadata such as a knowledge graph. Experiments on two
benchmark CRS datasets, ReDial and INSPIRED, demonstrate the effectiveness of
PECRS on recommendation and conversation. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/Ravoxsg/efficient_unified_crs. | [
-0.2729705274105072,
-0.5068537592887878,
0.37790346145629883,
0.14809982478618622,
-0.5043249130249023,
-0.11272504925727844,
-0.5675395131111145,
-0.2408677190542221,
0.04334090277552605,
0.6516886949539185,
-0.5095592141151428,
-0.5094017386436462,
-0.3322623670101166,
-0.06254717707633972,
-0.13187171518802643,
1.200453758239746,
0.20774146914482117,
0.03822357952594757,
-0.212422177195549,
-0.1710037738084793,
-0.6035825610160828,
-0.4994763433933258,
-0.7099243998527527,
-0.49963894486427307,
0.4330172836780548,
0.5464928150177002,
0.751876711845398,
0.27141648530960083,
0.3763642907142639,
0.3065485656261444,
0.19851408898830414,
0.3976285457611084,
-0.6047040224075317,
0.5970944762229919,
-0.20264287292957306,
0.11605007201433182,
-0.1997177004814148,
-0.2833113670349121,
0.21317239105701447,
0.6995449066162109,
-0.28228822350502014,
0.14954876899719238,
0.4341571629047394,
0.563621997833252,
-0.525855302810669,
0.23984961211681366,
-0.7272405624389648,
-0.2153645157814026,
-0.00939906295388937,
-0.12601810693740845,
-0.5046738982200623,
-0.41960692405700684,
0.6184866428375244,
-0.7769653797149658,
-0.03673401474952698,
0.1674221009016037,
0.6726170778274536,
0.01520014088600874,
-0.14963041245937347,
-0.37815380096435547,
-0.9244426488876343,
1.0154844522476196,
-0.502017617225647,
0.8133783936500549,
0.45645397901535034,
0.23731990158557892,
-0.05959631875157356,
-0.7954869866371155,
-0.26199615001678467,
-0.32807064056396484,
-0.2595891058444977,
-0.24195291101932526,
-0.1529315561056137,
0.12799246609210968,
-0.10477297753095627,
0.1095116138458252,
-0.5354577302932739,
-0.24844278395175934,
-0.07245912402868271,
-0.38679930567741394,
0.42116960883140564,
0.31419122219085693,
0.22177006304264069,
-0.0981668010354042,
-0.37849101424217224,
-0.09495700150728226,
-0.384712278842926,
0.14062556624412537,
0.36419564485549927,
0.6016054749488831,
0.055733419954776764,
0.5051092505455017,
-0.5020277500152588,
0.880146324634552,
0.1755293309688568,
-0.0711759701371193,
-0.04036881774663925,
-0.7881776094436646,
-0.12772300839424133,
-0.11900237202644348,
1.0181536674499512,
0.4868449568748474,
0.40499716997146606,
-0.42426568269729614,
0.006592349614948034,
0.11625170707702637,
0.4131025969982147,
-0.9014853835105896,
-0.47769758105278015,
-0.19751174747943878,
-0.3002054989337921,
-0.1949976533651352,
-0.050603557378053665,
-0.5114412903785706,
-0.0024930445943027735,
-0.4480384290218353,
0.20032517611980438,
-0.5052810907363892,
0.25118571519851685,
0.35337570309638977,
-0.01283139269798994,
-0.12328784912824631,
0.31976398825645447,
-0.7783256769180298,
0.5047196745872498,
0.24192097783088684,
0.4321732223033905,
0.0016431226395070553,
0.05435885861515999,
-0.42388206720352173,
0.1932998150587082,
0.034425217658281326,
1.1717193126678467,
-1.0144110918045044,
-0.49813181161880493,
-0.06669183075428009,
-0.14419136941432953,
-0.21727897226810455,
-0.3309888541698456,
0.8420900106430054,
-0.48031604290008545,
0.37404295802116394,
-0.23157237470149994,
-0.39958706498146057,
-0.16855190694332123,
0.19325236976146698,
-0.1266244351863861,
1.047967553138733,
-0.04111746326088905,
-0.4902913272380829,
0.3371357023715973,
-0.7882065176963806,
-0.4019909203052521,
0.30563417077064514,
-0.0990901067852974,
-0.01030699536204338,
-0.26830998063087463,
0.36238086223602295,
0.6356109976768494,
-0.5473006367683411,
0.3328126072883606,
-0.15389592945575714,
-0.33925196528434753,
0.09695518761873245,
-0.48086416721343994,
0.12690125405788422,
0.41911619901657104,
0.0146343307569623,
0.1218293085694313,
-0.4031903147697449,
0.31848007440567017,
0.050828974694013596,
-0.611748218536377,
-0.28765979409217834,
0.24098452925682068,
0.234913632273674,
-0.13698263466358185,
0.47825145721435547,
-0.4980437457561493,
0.06329808384180069,
-0.5235706567764282,
0.38031864166259766,
0.428693950176239,
0.0720534697175026,
0.7872287034988403,
-0.0944831594824791,
0.18300370872020721,
-0.326607882976532,
0.23409855365753174,
-0.2525244355201721,
-0.421251505613327,
-0.7680976986885071,
-0.033389635384082794,
0.19592054188251495,
0.47737357020378113,
-0.5829480886459351,
0.7333598136901855,
-0.02571878582239151,
-0.5297565460205078,
-0.22628581523895264,
0.34608128666877747,
0.5674211382865906,
0.5032395124435425,
0.2062014937400818,
-0.3200441896915436,
-0.5978947877883911,
-0.9742639660835266,
-0.447645902633667,
-0.23573321104049683,
-0.18698729574680328,
0.555342435836792,
-0.15547117590904236,
-0.26796644926071167,
0.8586465120315552,
-0.5663387775421143,
-0.30549344420433044,
-0.4064798653125763,
0.0382407121360302,
0.002828958909958601,
0.28232431411743164,
0.15977032482624054,
-0.5602161884307861,
-0.6342352628707886,
-0.044309183955192566,
-0.4273326098918915,
-0.20991429686546326,
0.17488710582256317,
-0.2660980522632599,
0.12980633974075317,
0.2180740386247635,
-0.32447901368141174,
0.35936540365219116,
0.2375321239233017,
-0.4082576036453247,
0.2673858106136322,
-0.46597298979759216,
0.21665316820144653,
-0.9877748489379883,
-0.004063821863383055,
0.2798171043395996,
-0.23622572422027588,
-0.7107140421867371,
-0.39296525716781616,
-0.2335645705461502,
-0.23108181357383728,
-0.28176799416542053,
0.26462292671203613,
-0.16935132443904877,
0.3701895773410797,
-0.2646220624446869,
0.3648156225681305,
0.2597370445728302,
0.8581844568252563,
0.20258869230747223,
0.4271512031555176,
0.44276002049446106,
-0.7888101935386658,
0.22243720293045044,
0.36440223455429077,
-0.2535841166973114,
0.7034634351730347,
-0.6541956663131714,
0.36479634046554565,
0.13822466135025024,
0.22060325741767883,
-0.889051616191864,
0.1696477085351944,
0.44867831468582153,
-0.045464515686035156,
-0.13729800283908844,
-0.20673395693302155,
-0.306967169046402,
-0.25712350010871887,
-0.1352417767047882,
0.3974241018295288,
0.3163427710533142,
-0.3177688717842102,
0.5439758896827698,
0.5238616466522217,
-0.30309733748435974,
-0.2232300192117691,
-0.053422946482896805,
0.06133691594004631,
-0.05983104184269905,
-0.6275614500045776,
0.5075783133506775,
-0.4558369219303131,
-0.0750984251499176,
-0.030569812282919884,
0.013259412720799446,
-0.1781514286994934,
-0.16630305349826813,
0.31561142206192017,
0.24522919952869415,
-0.024824999272823334,
0.25251948833465576,
-0.13432084023952484,
-0.2574288249015808,
-0.3134586215019226,
-0.4311434328556061,
0.8953667879104614,
-0.4295167922973633,
-0.394491970539093,
-0.9090436697006226,
0.3226785957813263,
0.5025801062583923,
-0.19964346289634705,
0.4377792477607727,
0.4509519338607788,
-0.05567299574613571,
0.0027374541386961937,
-0.6733996868133545,
-0.1820414662361145,
-0.5171878933906555,
0.26826176047325134,
-0.2858705222606659,
-0.7143195867538452,
0.20938542485237122,
0.12855176627635956,
0.06826858967542648,
0.1730935424566269,
0.40853098034858704,
-0.05291931331157684,
1.208168864250183,
0.43990546464920044,
-0.1275191456079483,
0.6559640765190125,
-0.15366725623607635,
0.5281549096107483,
-0.6710432171821594,
-0.43275776505470276,
-0.7498190402984619,
-0.09463515132665634,
-0.19438225030899048,
-0.3481169044971466,
0.1248449981212616,
0.07216430455446243,
-0.2917170226573944,
0.6535043716430664,
-0.8134680986404419,
0.5194470286369324,
0.7025303840637207,
0.2495773732662201,
0.32994192838668823,
0.03949351608753204,
-0.13475526869297028,
-0.12784282863140106,
-0.7373924851417542,
-0.7839956283569336,
1.063541054725647,
-0.01592310518026352,
0.9299496412277222,
-0.4293892979621887,
0.44015270471572876,
0.2770506739616394,
-0.2231246531009674,
-0.8402021527290344,
0.7731001377105713,
-0.14719270169734955,
-0.03338851407170296,
-0.365775465965271,
-0.06818978488445282,
-1.005667805671692,
0.05092645063996315,
-0.44738489389419556,
-0.8223747611045837,
0.06773962080478668,
0.08310054242610931,
-0.34566041827201843,
0.11093907803297043,
-0.7511903047561646,
0.831588625907898,
-0.2519076466560364,
-0.1433209627866745,
-0.5193315744400024,
-0.37945693731307983,
-0.26794669032096863,
0.14178046584129333,
-0.07025931030511856,
-0.1407872885465622,
0.3258483409881592,
0.9821645021438599,
-0.35202261805534363,
0.5805647373199463,
-0.2498537003993988,
0.29187437891960144,
0.5581048130989075,
0.22874729335308075,
0.552893877029419,
0.17605292797088623,
-0.1965259313583374,
0.1300678253173828,
0.10128743946552277,
-0.16453814506530762,
-0.6846940517425537,
0.7102732062339783,
-0.5128107070922852,
-0.5336262583732605,
-0.07550803571939468,
-0.5634804368019104,
-0.12987367808818817,
0.17237593233585358,
0.036276157945394516,
0.679438591003418,
-0.39879506826400757,
0.3541468381881714,
0.44285643100738525,
-0.054222170263528824,
0.3729042410850525,
0.6587185263633728,
0.03081298992037773,
-0.33569619059562683,
0.8218485713005066,
-0.0746392235159874,
0.009446077048778534,
0.3792165517807007,
0.13853968679904938,
-0.4026184380054474,
-0.624253511428833,
-0.43954652547836304,
-0.008804277516901493,
-0.41713035106658936,
-0.08297707140445709,
-0.8174729943275452,
0.1384662687778473,
-0.4730026423931122,
-0.2898557484149933,
-0.37104514241218567,
-0.15439872443675995,
-0.2478645145893097,
0.1308857947587967,
0.2992459535598755,
0.8325146436691284,
0.4348377585411072,
0.26322853565216064,
-0.7659891247749329,
0.29970183968544006,
0.4763263165950775,
0.535694420337677,
-0.20543017983436584,
-0.5014464259147644,
-0.36395907402038574,
0.17502044141292572,
-0.43914929032325745,
-0.5935829877853394,
0.32013100385665894,
0.263412743806839,
0.8070777058601379,
0.7510325312614441,
0.3315856158733368,
0.6556586027145386,
-0.516232967376709,
0.7577266097068787,
0.25779011845588684,
-0.7832072377204895,
0.5975637435913086,
-0.38218244910240173,
0.3157007098197937,
0.9253404140472412,
0.09908537566661835,
-0.533353865146637,
-0.3114343285560608,
-0.4484238624572754,
-0.7189682722091675,
0.8564598560333252,
0.374933123588562,
0.20514154434204102,
-0.05849446356296539,
0.14534807205200195,
0.08613470941781998,
0.12038810551166534,
-0.42838045954704285,
-0.14048044383525848,
-0.1591528356075287,
-0.36811205744743347,
-0.08032537996768951,
-0.31445491313934326,
-0.021976526826620102,
-0.27295035123825073,
0.7490228414535522,
-0.07362951338291168,
0.226437047123909,
0.16037072241306305,
-0.16410261392593384,
-0.20095449686050415,
0.3416638970375061,
0.21807150542736053,
0.4450647234916687,
-0.19396840035915375,
-0.1878432035446167,
0.1545141190290451,
-0.148991659283638,
-0.09045656770467758,
0.022155798971652985,
0.1619785875082016,
-0.2187063992023468,
-0.28076857328414917,
0.7447097301483154,
0.655451774597168,
-0.7913960218429565,
0.46250879764556885,
-0.4680802822113037,
0.037732187658548355,
-0.19823305308818817,
0.14072713255882263,
0.21777060627937317,
0.15015944838523865,
0.09453407675027847,
0.3746703863143921,
0.17871810495853424,
-0.48869386315345764,
0.09990127384662628,
0.5915045738220215,
-0.6127599477767944,
-0.2259267270565033,
0.19872155785560608,
0.6822824478149414,
-0.8363940119743347,
0.5530839562416077,
-0.023014498874545097,
-0.39686205983161926,
-0.06771480292081833,
0.467342346906662,
0.7995405197143555,
-0.03368654474616051,
0.42261582612991333,
0.1928170770406723,
-0.10152836889028549,
-0.0984252393245697,
-0.11315688490867615,
-0.5994351506233215,
-0.9389268159866333,
-0.14708131551742554,
-0.8151581883430481,
-0.5182573795318604,
-0.1773301512002945,
-0.5767186284065247,
0.39939671754837036,
-0.3296853005886078,
-0.1261042207479477,
-0.08240411430597305,
-0.07443159818649292,
-0.9043638110160828,
0.09650464355945587,
0.07846121490001678,
0.5183749198913574,
-0.5519615411758423,
0.7801534533500671,
0.7179883122444153,
-0.14427867531776428,
-0.9356290698051453,
-0.3169184625148773,
-0.5844835638999939,
-0.5623742341995239,
0.6462953686714172,
-0.06434820592403412,
-0.41669711470603943,
-0.2206653654575348,
-0.16693446040153503,
-0.6868639588356018,
0.754153311252594,
0.4369189441204071,
-0.4343195855617523,
0.055562205612659454,
0.15662021934986115,
0.5567453503608704,
-0.6721903085708618,
0.42182761430740356,
0.42533478140830994,
0.4376675486564636,
0.11335849016904831,
-1.0026472806930542,
0.04246048629283905,
-0.3667146861553192,
-0.1035776361823082,
0.38154336810112,
-0.3224356472492218,
0.3877233862876892,
0.015641720965504646,
-0.2724165618419647,
0.14214403927326202,
0.2636506259441376,
0.14170853793621063,
0.23325879871845245,
0.741276741027832,
0.5732784271240234,
0.6098877191543579,
-0.027500439435243607,
0.927412211894989,
-0.5391466021537781,
0.04686260223388672,
1.023810625076294,
-0.35478901863098145,
0.7117249965667725,
0.24632681906223297,
-0.1307704746723175,
0.9646088480949402,
0.46387362480163574,
0.22713018953800201,
0.4863252639770508,
-0.15559980273246765,
-0.3723527193069458,
-0.6661898493766785,
-0.23411588370800018,
-0.08905692398548126,
0.5198125243186951,
0.20331507921218872,
-0.3708750009536743,
-0.3659782409667969,
0.010808802209794521,
-0.21492931246757507,
0.2733093798160553,
-0.010619662702083588,
1.1637308597564697,
-0.11406344920396805,
-0.7655949592590332,
0.49176251888275146,
-0.17613838613033295,
0.6318864822387695,
-0.8552024960517883,
-0.12787656486034393,
0.1547618806362152,
0.010571165941655636,
0.04406323283910751,
-0.4821619391441345,
-0.03570713475346565,
0.045402176678180695,
-0.3178181052207947,
-0.4489186108112335,
1.1028810739517212,
-0.41224178671836853,
-0.4945036768913269,
0.2950819730758667,
0.3792063295841217,
0.1956610232591629,
-0.26912251114845276,
-0.7031357884407043,
-0.32188618183135986,
0.12466519325971603,
-0.29572293162345886,
0.3310401737689972,
0.15343259274959564,
-0.036898478865623474,
0.8574690222740173,
0.8198623657226562,
0.06523892283439636,
-0.34966331720352173,
0.2858794629573822,
0.8257526159286499,
-0.5582062602043152,
-0.6836228370666504,
-0.5384772419929504,
0.31800228357315063,
-0.06906382739543915,
-0.16062332689762115,
0.6816589832305908,
0.5271497964859009,
0.7970808148384094,
0.14432421326637268,
0.5785871148109436,
0.15229792892932892,
0.41439712047576904,
-0.18691731989383698,
0.5511412620544434,
-0.08723950386047363,
0.5924941897392273,
-0.2315371185541153,
-1.125876784324646,
-0.16420957446098328,
0.48314106464385986,
-0.4547899067401886,
0.011217514984309673,
0.6487396955490112,
0.9388539791107178,
0.06929805874824524,
0.3310057520866394,
0.3071136772632599,
-0.26362475752830505,
0.10340806841850281,
0.4457554817199707,
0.6898871660232544,
-0.2719055116176605,
0.932067334651947,
-0.2491188645362854,
0.06642410904169083,
-0.2572818100452423,
-0.5379759073257446,
-0.7156444191932678,
-0.5541055798530579,
-0.26520949602127075,
-0.14409781992435455,
0.3155499994754791,
1.2162522077560425,
1.0523263216018677,
-0.8083056211471558,
-0.3928656280040741,
-0.16205787658691406,
0.047548845410346985,
-0.04854600876569748,
-0.2551491856575012,
0.29054054617881775,
-0.5150418877601624,
-0.8547939658164978,
0.7466352581977844,
0.37731167674064636,
-0.19191491603851318,
-0.043961577117443085,
-0.32741302251815796,
-0.006898180581629276,
0.146233931183815,
0.562384307384491,
0.0671723410487175,
-0.6682639122009277,
-0.4304291307926178,
-0.12918424606323242,
-0.043748050928115845,
-0.04157976061105728,
1.1367549896240234,
-1.0455039739608765,
0.5574504137039185,
0.5336927771568298,
0.31357771158218384,
0.3219076693058014,
0.06677962839603424,
0.8709843158721924,
-0.4192693531513214,
0.05195974186062813,
0.31170377135276794,
0.4138147234916687,
0.2905634939670563,
-0.3471873700618744,
0.1991700977087021,
0.04695660248398781,
-0.8303161859512329,
-0.6514821648597717,
0.27768486738204956,
-1.1616966724395752,
-0.2584577798843384,
1.0052130222320557,
-0.10669617354869843,
0.08119132369756699,
-0.5468902587890625,
-0.5638375282287598,
0.23009201884269714,
-0.9398587346076965,
0.482578843832016,
0.2730465829372406,
-0.3571719229221344,
0.2691091299057007,
0.05640517547726631,
0.37164515256881714,
0.4495181441307068,
-0.3407159447669983,
0.18504752218723297,
0.36271631717681885,
0.29264816641807556,
0.024695511907339096,
0.7323456406593323,
0.0017258594743907452,
-0.04443676397204399,
-0.3281470537185669,
0.14802762866020203,
-0.05148037523031235,
-0.3428075909614563,
-0.004821001086384058,
0.4094316363334656,
0.17130793631076813,
-0.2223500907421112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14192v2 | How Can Large Language Models Understand Spatial-Temporal Data? | 2024-01-25T14:03:15 | 2024-05-17T03:10:20 | Lei Liu, Shuo Yu, Runze Wang, Zhenxun Ma, Yanming Shen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | While Large Language Models (LLMs) dominate tasks like natural language
processing and computer vision, harnessing their power for spatial-temporal
forecasting remains challenging. The disparity between sequential text and
complex spatial-temporal data hinders this application. To address this issue,
this paper introduces STG-LLM, an innovative approach empowering LLMs for
spatial-temporal forecasting. We tackle the data mismatch by proposing: 1)
STG-Tokenizer: This spatial-temporal graph tokenizer transforms intricate graph
data into concise tokens capturing both spatial and temporal relationships; 2)
STG-Adapter: This minimalistic adapter, consisting of linear encoding and
decoding layers, bridges the gap between tokenized data and LLM comprehension.
By fine-tuning only a small set of parameters, it can effectively grasp the
semantics of tokens generated by STG-Tokenizer, while preserving the original
natural language understanding capabilities of LLMs. Extensive experiments on
diverse spatial-temporal benchmark datasets show that STG-LLM successfully
unlocks LLM potential for spatial-temporal forecasting. Remarkably, our
approach achieves competitive performance on par with dedicated SOTA methods. | [
-0.16595101356506348,
-0.7965036034584045,
0.8547179102897644,
0.5466699004173279,
-0.4204014837741852,
0.24424110352993011,
-0.2578214406967163,
-0.6464125514030457,
0.15381205081939697,
0.2251262068748474,
-0.6376003623008728,
-0.6358993053436279,
-0.7327751517295837,
-0.2372802346944809,
-0.06776872277259827,
0.7707977294921875,
-0.12616227567195892,
0.12617988884449005,
0.14831607043743134,
-0.026184892281889915,
-0.4256848692893982,
-0.4772970974445343,
-0.7895845174789429,
-0.43167316913604736,
0.5258030891418457,
0.17453110218048096,
1.022976279258728,
0.9726313948631287,
0.2236863672733307,
0.29193904995918274,
-0.007090976927429438,
0.4001096189022064,
-0.5724073648452759,
-0.45581650733947754,
-0.09808437526226044,
-0.05608278140425682,
-0.4088200032711029,
-0.2868560552597046,
0.8518149852752686,
0.9193258881568909,
-0.25518175959587097,
0.0683891549706459,
-0.09385193884372711,
0.46138545870780945,
-0.014754779636859894,
0.36276084184646606,
-0.6859174370765686,
0.21069389581680298,
-0.23099234700202942,
-0.3139841854572296,
-0.3066456615924835,
-0.2063121646642685,
0.013333264738321304,
-0.7799683213233948,
0.12044953554868698,
0.4814055263996124,
0.9928116202354431,
0.35080981254577637,
-0.5514501929283142,
0.17542795836925507,
-0.9904438853263855,
0.518150806427002,
-0.6087772846221924,
0.5406001806259155,
0.011313471011817455,
0.7572700381278992,
-0.3504241704940796,
-0.6561480760574341,
-0.6316293478012085,
0.3151492178440094,
-0.19793500006198883,
0.22361360490322113,
-0.1255125105381012,
-0.18479858338832855,
0.06429672241210938,
0.01337103545665741,
-0.8179358839988708,
0.26127007603645325,
-0.2592221200466156,
0.2857215404510498,
0.4842507541179657,
0.2963900566101074,
0.31621676683425903,
-0.2571539878845215,
-0.689398467540741,
0.2958071231842041,
-0.7564191222190857,
-0.12997500598430634,
0.12664274871349335,
0.5515760779380798,
-0.25010615587234497,
0.45068755745887756,
0.2770826518535614,
0.3146974742412567,
0.027432072907686234,
0.3162393867969513,
-0.0009615776361897588,
-0.5137869715690613,
-0.4115356504917145,
0.05029468610882759,
0.8603692054748535,
0.2629453241825104,
0.13828058540821075,
-0.3953413665294647,
0.10567740350961685,
-0.11503420770168304,
-0.08701849728822708,
-0.5999853014945984,
-0.27919888496398926,
-0.01910180039703846,
-0.2779265344142914,
0.060354139655828476,
0.005369680002331734,
-0.9512235522270203,
-0.27538108825683594,
-0.44199830293655396,
0.13052617013454437,
-0.28438663482666016,
-0.11472676694393158,
0.22798952460289001,
-0.15073323249816895,
-0.015898216515779495,
0.34136587381362915,
-1.0210175514221191,
0.11695892363786697,
0.9058102965354919,
0.8838531970977783,
-0.07060406357049942,
-0.5876791477203369,
-0.39874207973480225,
0.4095040261745453,
-0.43614986538887024,
0.8783681988716125,
-0.6762802600860596,
-0.3056899607181549,
-0.29929524660110474,
0.04045707732439041,
-0.14529725909233093,
-0.21817582845687866,
0.18540534377098083,
-0.6633571982383728,
0.009285667911171913,
-0.14489072561264038,
-0.22979584336280823,
-0.03578648716211319,
0.06180818751454353,
-0.4375438988208771,
1.4375807046890259,
0.030939333140850067,
-0.6858090162277222,
0.7603790760040283,
-0.3172369599342346,
-0.12043899297714233,
0.14886009693145752,
-0.21167561411857605,
-0.258476585149765,
0.19035859405994415,
0.5779780745506287,
0.21442635357379913,
-0.11250424385070801,
0.6453909277915955,
-0.4563443064689636,
-0.3714476525783539,
-0.19471794366836548,
-0.13997648656368256,
0.23778511583805084,
0.2527783215045929,
0.021604040637612343,
0.4612174332141876,
-0.599994421005249,
-0.006473960820585489,
0.3549356162548065,
-0.3652631938457489,
-0.1998206526041031,
0.2794296145439148,
0.246693417429924,
0.17911465466022491,
0.4215974807739258,
-0.4261043667793274,
0.29019924998283386,
-0.6802622079849243,
0.6719837784767151,
1.0026723146438599,
-0.275948703289032,
0.896740198135376,
-0.17633768916130066,
0.38698726892471313,
0.11180772632360458,
0.033851031213998795,
0.014610318467020988,
-0.2660698890686035,
-0.43612876534461975,
-0.35295698046684265,
-0.023210864514112473,
0.4620884358882904,
-0.9222118258476257,
0.4108622074127197,
-1.0258705615997314,
-0.9279876351356506,
-0.2007686346769333,
-0.013365635648369789,
-0.19967250525951385,
0.2768864631652832,
0.20439359545707703,
0.3341914415359497,
-0.8913801312446594,
-0.3433511555194855,
-0.5335416793823242,
-0.07154946774244308,
-0.20871110260486603,
0.6559712290763855,
0.4409763514995575,
-0.6405436396598816,
0.8685555458068848,
-0.548686683177948,
-0.07678712904453278,
-0.4175676703453064,
-0.026547720655798912,
0.6658478379249573,
0.22172975540161133,
0.8100182414054871,
-0.4112749397754669,
-0.4969007968902588,
0.22102110087871552,
-0.6562304496765137,
-0.19467559456825256,
0.045135289430618286,
-0.34592124819755554,
-0.19668544828891754,
0.4288419187068939,
-0.4186013340950012,
0.3529936969280243,
0.7858704924583435,
-0.8950434327125549,
0.42457401752471924,
-0.3177186846733093,
-0.06795356422662735,
-0.8627448678016663,
-0.15454675257205963,
-0.2605254352092743,
-0.3912748694419861,
-0.7212167382240295,
-0.005101810675114393,
-0.15958239138126373,
-0.48789554834365845,
-0.32849591970443726,
0.8368260860443115,
-0.04633592441678047,
-0.2787459194660187,
-0.07672450691461563,
0.2784944772720337,
-0.12746252119541168,
0.353292316198349,
0.23737399280071259,
0.5785391330718994,
0.30263552069664,
-0.3694166839122772,
0.08456772565841675,
0.3334328830242157,
-0.3436295688152313,
-0.09311404824256897,
-0.7667195796966553,
0.30520185828208923,
-0.41786864399909973,
0.30446410179138184,
-0.9531005620956421,
0.02219673991203308,
0.08384930342435837,
-0.07700406014919281,
-0.11679689586162567,
-0.5637206435203552,
-0.7752835750579834,
-0.25752905011177063,
-0.04034610837697983,
0.5491713285446167,
0.12918129563331604,
-0.9966895580291748,
1.0788577795028687,
0.3128872215747833,
-0.3822878897190094,
-0.2127683460712433,
-0.7180064916610718,
0.21531324088573456,
-0.11747322976589203,
-0.7752677202224731,
0.30666688084602356,
-0.035003744065761566,
0.10775396227836609,
-0.039633363485336304,
-0.08155057579278946,
0.06698637455701828,
0.043192069977521896,
0.35801923274993896,
0.6997319459915161,
-0.19839200377464294,
-0.15800592303276062,
-0.2964085638523102,
-0.45175546407699585,
-0.2104160338640213,
-0.8050487637519836,
0.7661044001579285,
0.04960382729768753,
-0.3482220470905304,
0.0428556427359581,
0.20128659904003143,
0.3976455330848694,
0.14026090502738953,
0.6665204763412476,
0.6635139584541321,
-0.6104675531387329,
-0.21337777376174927,
-0.11583755165338516,
0.08461003750562668,
-0.496654212474823,
0.3270176947116852,
-0.2902517020702362,
-0.9695267677307129,
0.44784966111183167,
-0.1272232085466385,
0.10548338294029236,
0.1498357057571411,
0.2801227569580078,
-0.11069394648075104,
0.972507119178772,
0.40012162923812866,
-0.2906796932220459,
0.7551052570343018,
0.12327765673398972,
0.7170709371566772,
-0.34458720684051514,
-0.10961824655532837,
-0.37784621119499207,
-0.6499723792076111,
-0.41334736347198486,
-0.5537888407707214,
0.305886447429657,
0.10404734313488007,
-0.5791493654251099,
0.1870318502187729,
-0.4512472152709961,
0.42435920238494873,
0.1861797422170639,
-0.11067251861095428,
0.20935483276844025,
0.2359720915555954,
-0.0529511533677578,
-0.6112293601036072,
-0.7418894171714783,
-0.49909910559654236,
0.6053121089935303,
0.5979145765304565,
0.8854838013648987,
0.05714305117726326,
0.22692905366420746,
-0.015211145393550396,
0.06530550867319107,
-0.5744726657867432,
0.5288434028625488,
-0.5653895139694214,
-0.11256291717290878,
-0.19842974841594696,
-0.6177850365638733,
-0.7800632119178772,
0.46117308735847473,
-0.22351142764091492,
-0.7073091268539429,
0.14931361377239227,
-0.011940110474824905,
-0.2320438176393509,
0.48778995871543884,
-0.616020143032074,
0.9835535287857056,
-0.506808340549469,
-0.07743319123983383,
-0.046027712523937225,
-0.13273467123508453,
-0.19856350123882294,
0.07208988815546036,
0.6580761671066284,
-0.46725529432296753,
-0.10232079774141312,
0.7125384211540222,
-0.3062038719654083,
0.7319374680519104,
-0.5097105503082275,
0.20212039351463318,
-0.13304653763771057,
0.16098228096961975,
0.7825137376785278,
0.1654352992773056,
0.06267133355140686,
0.6884878277778625,
0.047085296362638474,
-0.5449251532554626,
-0.5487576723098755,
0.7223137021064758,
-0.9581993222236633,
-0.2672863006591797,
-0.3832942545413971,
-0.6088096499443054,
-0.2313707023859024,
0.20809832215309143,
0.05964083969593048,
0.25984588265419006,
-0.23588109016418457,
-0.2835942804813385,
0.13458621501922607,
-0.2445749193429947,
0.38472893834114075,
0.6294482350349426,
-0.5673412084579468,
-0.6074572801589966,
0.7467771172523499,
0.0948110818862915,
-0.10123898088932037,
0.5048506855964661,
0.44206076860427856,
-0.39999839663505554,
-0.5606946349143982,
-0.45764872431755066,
0.408739298582077,
-0.5439786314964294,
0.027102423831820488,
-0.5386614799499512,
-0.21358028054237366,
-0.2787007987499237,
-0.4784144163131714,
-0.17351439595222473,
-0.17585167288780212,
-0.3114144504070282,
-0.4705179035663605,
0.4152148962020874,
0.8657796382904053,
0.15570475161075592,
0.47773322463035583,
-0.8924175500869751,
0.18942487239837646,
0.06008264049887657,
0.278563529253006,
-0.18641582131385803,
-0.6007671356201172,
-0.20318672060966492,
-0.04762063920497894,
0.16338123381137848,
-0.4210626184940338,
0.7769726514816284,
0.2613695561885834,
0.09872105717658997,
0.3830256760120392,
-0.3862660825252533,
1.467345118522644,
-1.0756419897079468,
0.930858850479126,
0.003558643162250519,
-0.8411362767219543,
0.5561525225639343,
-0.6208123564720154,
0.41832512617111206,
0.10037670284509659,
-0.03256630524992943,
-0.828884482383728,
-0.279337078332901,
-0.2720580995082855,
-1.0856456756591797,
0.6658782362937927,
-0.3281564712524414,
-0.1082591637969017,
-0.01997631974518299,
0.2682732939720154,
0.21328698098659515,
0.1988966166973114,
-0.6334113478660583,
-0.12272986024618149,
-0.4475286304950714,
-0.4457475543022156,
-0.5038338303565979,
-0.4421703517436981,
-0.031842511147260666,
-0.13246917724609375,
0.13244327902793884,
-0.3322139084339142,
0.40392330288887024,
0.0334753580391407,
0.06408396363258362,
-0.19184806942939758,
0.4097442924976349,
0.25112098455429077,
0.6536809206008911,
0.06509925425052643,
0.39963850378990173,
0.603294849395752,
-0.29903194308280945,
-0.06295788288116455,
0.26696622371673584,
-0.1264553666114807,
0.12421049922704697,
0.5528018474578857,
0.7273226380348206,
0.9173018336296082,
-0.5555198192596436,
0.28749507665634155,
-0.03108430840075016,
-0.058140430599451065,
-0.44356569647789,
-0.35403087735176086,
0.17645585536956787,
0.3784583806991577,
0.506630003452301,
0.2985192537307739,
-0.3387712836265564,
-0.3513355255126953,
-0.1140141487121582,
0.24727681279182434,
-0.2643176019191742,
-0.653064489364624,
1.10484778881073,
-0.16998110711574554,
0.02633383311331272,
0.34734001755714417,
-0.0438384935259819,
-0.544243335723877,
0.5016028881072998,
0.7848168015480042,
0.5646562576293945,
0.1875150352716446,
-0.15117217600345612,
0.26806700229644775,
0.17842316627502441,
0.021071476861834526,
0.5742975473403931,
0.2910122573375702,
-0.8392659425735474,
-0.4625127613544464,
-0.6706950664520264,
0.083702452480793,
-0.21657338738441467,
-0.2912571430206299,
0.0937739908695221,
-0.9155857563018799,
-0.12530486285686493,
-0.07198449969291687,
0.03808040916919708,
-0.947787344455719,
-0.10382825881242752,
0.14574052393436432,
1.2477779388427734,
-0.9236277937889099,
0.7784082889556885,
0.8138154149055481,
0.20498351752758026,
-0.6855347752571106,
-0.4323224425315857,
-0.09341561794281006,
-1.0782597064971924,
0.8413764834403992,
-0.13889677822589874,
-0.0619208849966526,
-0.029120713472366333,
-0.32887208461761475,
-0.8155141472816467,
1.2262532711029053,
0.4072592556476593,
-0.7854349613189697,
-0.41321900486946106,
0.36188554763793945,
0.5573347806930542,
-0.36442768573760986,
0.010418394580483437,
0.5805845856666565,
0.718134343624115,
0.1831679344177246,
-0.883246898651123,
-0.026678120717406273,
-0.1210835799574852,
0.18432177603244781,
0.33451348543167114,
-0.43787428736686707,
0.6327796578407288,
-0.09146300703287125,
-0.7318161725997925,
-0.0813940167427063,
0.6800886988639832,
0.3007453382015228,
0.5822214484214783,
0.5481622219085693,
0.6191344261169434,
0.8070496320724487,
-0.6663094162940979,
0.784591794013977,
-0.2793300449848175,
0.19338218867778778,
1.204870581626892,
-0.46917396783828735,
1.004917025566101,
0.41120433807373047,
-0.3038216829299927,
0.3721138834953308,
0.6329447627067566,
-0.03769904002547264,
0.5203762054443359,
-0.25852903723716736,
-0.1627528816461563,
-0.33319491147994995,
-0.1723802238702774,
-0.10490261763334274,
0.2852911353111267,
0.42241936922073364,
0.08528003841638565,
-0.3475077748298645,
-0.07420632988214493,
0.012948589399456978,
0.2771923840045929,
-0.542928159236908,
0.9444820284843445,
0.07398831844329834,
-0.17661677300930023,
0.045571234077215195,
-0.0015737187350168824,
0.6117544174194336,
-0.8022392392158508,
0.3145263195037842,
0.1427963674068451,
0.24067635834217072,
-0.27724871039390564,
-0.8042611479759216,
0.6015455722808838,
0.0044888718985021114,
-0.21944384276866913,
-0.5610786080360413,
0.6444692611694336,
-0.5437558889389038,
-0.49355629086494446,
0.5283159613609314,
0.38988175988197327,
-0.2712876498699188,
0.13071699440479279,
-0.434279203414917,
0.04853129759430885,
-0.28289875388145447,
0.2947649657726288,
0.16827324032783508,
0.7073168158531189,
0.17088176310062408,
0.7849149703979492,
0.8666412234306335,
0.5758021473884583,
0.09626439958810806,
0.17337533831596375,
0.8338726758956909,
-1.0108668804168701,
-0.8733075857162476,
-1.0256537199020386,
0.178118497133255,
0.19772930443286896,
0.08508458733558655,
0.7799227833747864,
0.6399690508842468,
0.4842400550842285,
-0.01965017430484295,
0.6800971031188965,
0.32619571685791016,
0.3288382589817047,
-0.5386598110198975,
0.6324066519737244,
-0.23220708966255188,
0.29810211062431335,
0.13224774599075317,
-0.5298272967338562,
-0.26544639468193054,
0.326704740524292,
-0.7448997497558594,
-0.1824592798948288,
0.49042680859565735,
0.5752278566360474,
0.07449657469987869,
0.06020919233560562,
0.2018977552652359,
0.27919065952301025,
0.5547295212745667,
0.6937353014945984,
1.0739425420761108,
-0.3154972791671753,
0.6383116245269775,
0.34237492084503174,
-0.1544964462518692,
-0.16677641868591309,
-0.9638774991035461,
-0.9786705374717712,
-0.23032422363758087,
0.17079105973243713,
-0.09069407731294632,
0.019565286114811897,
1.0152621269226074,
0.7435854077339172,
-0.7409032583236694,
-0.03812260925769806,
0.034659650176763535,
0.13257759809494019,
-0.2232547402381897,
-0.249652698636055,
0.36280426383018494,
0.01711517572402954,
-0.769038736820221,
0.7098381519317627,
0.5912991762161255,
0.24045945703983307,
0.1193763017654419,
-0.04844158515334129,
0.3454976975917816,
-0.008327655494213104,
0.6459932923316956,
0.05172532796859741,
-0.6068977117538452,
-0.6040281653404236,
-0.08135957270860672,
-0.03159644082188606,
0.12372994422912598,
0.9399321675300598,
-0.6188596487045288,
0.35203859210014343,
0.5690863728523254,
0.5676875710487366,
0.6219792366027832,
-0.009836927987635136,
0.5994716286659241,
-1.0554324388504028,
0.3384290039539337,
-0.0133938267827034,
0.7611083984375,
0.13943034410476685,
-0.4964783191680908,
0.406623899936676,
0.20233769714832306,
-0.6888318657875061,
-0.5288498997688293,
0.29187285900115967,
-0.9251474142074585,
-0.07704012095928192,
0.9532415866851807,
0.11015627533197403,
-0.2944871485233307,
-0.21838578581809998,
-0.2622242867946625,
-0.07530688494443893,
-0.3514069616794586,
0.6624178290367126,
0.5428943037986755,
0.26365941762924194,
-0.1932239979505539,
-0.5382241010665894,
0.28005537390708923,
-0.11815350502729416,
-0.652816653251648,
0.29381662607192993,
0.3475821912288666,
0.29343006014823914,
-0.2071780413389206,
0.5995053648948669,
-0.0911315530538559,
-0.00783210527151823,
-0.01620618626475334,
-0.5234022736549377,
-0.32379379868507385,
-0.24726149439811707,
-0.25078558921813965,
-0.021716466173529625,
0.16769881546497345,
-0.020819485187530518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14166v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14166v3 | BayesPrompt: Prompting Large-Scale Pre-Trained Language Models on Few-shot Inference via Debiased Domain Abstraction | 2024-01-25T13:20:47 | 2024-03-20T08:52:42 | Jiangmeng Li, Fei Song, Yifan Jin, Wenwen Qiang, Changwen Zheng, Fuchun Sun, Hui Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As a novel and effective fine-tuning paradigm based on large-scale
pre-trained language models (PLMs), prompt-tuning aims to reduce the gap
between downstream tasks and pre-training objectives. While prompt-tuning has
yielded continuous advancements in various tasks, such an approach still
remains a persistent defect: prompt-tuning methods fail to generalize to
specific few-shot patterns. From the perspective of distribution analyses, we
disclose that the intrinsic issues behind the phenomenon are the
over-multitudinous conceptual knowledge contained in PLMs and the abridged
knowledge for target downstream domains, which jointly result in that PLMs
mis-locate the knowledge distributions corresponding to the target domains in
the universal knowledge embedding space. To this end, we intuitively explore to
approximate the unabridged target domains of downstream tasks in a debiased
manner, and then abstract such domains to generate discriminative prompts,
thereby providing the de-ambiguous guidance for PLMs. Guided by such an
intuition, we propose a simple yet effective approach, namely BayesPrompt, to
learn prompts that contain the domain discriminative information against the
interference from domain-irrelevant knowledge. BayesPrompt primitively
leverages known distributions to approximate the debiased factual distributions
of target domains and further uniformly samples certain representative features
from the approximated distributions to generate the ultimate prompts for PLMs.
We provide theoretical insights with the connection to domain adaptation.
Empirically, our method achieves state-of-the-art performance on benchmarks. | [
-0.6435367465019226,
-0.9806497097015381,
0.8337354063987732,
0.03571164608001709,
-0.32329145073890686,
-0.12288489937782288,
-0.09882957488298416,
0.22154316306114197,
-0.39397627115249634,
0.3264808654785156,
-1.0977447032928467,
-0.6279229521751404,
-0.6737833619117737,
-0.08468293398618698,
0.03424727916717529,
0.8496583700180054,
0.3466089963912964,
-0.2004905492067337,
0.18095077574253082,
0.17333532869815826,
-0.590471088886261,
-0.19800877571105957,
-0.8965719938278198,
-0.06058692932128906,
0.45229944586753845,
0.42516982555389404,
0.6559092402458191,
0.1790081113576889,
0.2918963134288788,
0.18359261751174927,
0.08896232396364212,
0.1423172503709793,
-0.37212157249450684,
0.08318085968494415,
-0.4381776750087738,
-0.43794870376586914,
-0.02473517507314682,
0.1014334037899971,
0.6197507977485657,
1.1027907133102417,
0.01890798658132553,
-0.012466046027839184,
0.38012754917144775,
0.6104474067687988,
-1.0126062631607056,
0.14134126901626587,
-0.7220925688743591,
-0.2234210968017578,
-0.2830941081047058,
-0.317818284034729,
-0.4692225754261017,
-0.1704591065645218,
0.18214449286460876,
-0.7339997291564941,
0.4804304242134094,
0.0970892384648323,
0.42307794094085693,
0.5958441495895386,
-0.30775195360183716,
0.05736035853624344,
-0.4827515482902527,
0.8157449960708618,
-0.42685505747795105,
0.09364420175552368,
0.4647666811943054,
0.45675668120384216,
-0.5820336937904358,
-0.3426995277404785,
-0.5430890917778015,
0.08467186987400055,
0.21501563489437103,
0.13790184259414673,
-0.5402137041091919,
0.25986436009407043,
0.4972022473812103,
-0.1556960791349411,
-0.5751071572303772,
0.304528146982193,
0.10542647540569305,
0.006896547507494688,
0.38454392552375793,
0.07473724335432053,
0.13770617544651031,
0.13457754254341125,
-0.31402498483657837,
-0.04771459102630615,
-0.9325127005577087,
0.2282027304172516,
0.34686407446861267,
0.4501568078994751,
-0.0747779980301857,
0.05841189622879028,
-0.2818681001663208,
1.094466209411621,
0.4406198263168335,
0.08433636277914047,
0.011615406721830368,
0.18153034150600433,
-0.2650415301322937,
0.02520710788667202,
0.6980265378952026,
0.29458704590797424,
0.3981878459453583,
0.11042450368404388,
0.004125460982322693,
0.18624918162822723,
0.21234387159347534,
-0.45911940932273865,
-0.3920446038246155,
0.2608991861343384,
-0.28032276034355164,
0.1866542100906372,
-0.08632633090019226,
-0.7822278141975403,
-0.5562194585800171,
-0.41966551542282104,
0.715388834476471,
-0.4444451332092285,
-0.2164909988641739,
0.24988533556461334,
-0.3760138154029846,
0.09036421775817871,
0.38070473074913025,
-0.9194887280464172,
0.10119353979825974,
0.6888101100921631,
0.6992921829223633,
-0.18334168195724487,
-0.3183140456676483,
-0.7238759398460388,
0.043501950800418854,
-0.4623633921146393,
1.0307027101516724,
-0.6284302473068237,
-0.4007923901081085,
0.00006967362423893064,
-0.006029410753399134,
-0.35979998111724854,
-0.6734892725944519,
0.33887091279029846,
-0.3229271471500397,
-0.10504306107759476,
-0.39011356234550476,
-0.5607106685638428,
0.047306060791015625,
-0.16332338750362396,
-0.3930257558822632,
0.5608149170875549,
0.2456800788640976,
-0.7694648504257202,
0.6140919327735901,
-0.4004291296005249,
-0.1962001770734787,
0.017188705503940582,
-0.16417548060417175,
-0.18107685446739197,
0.3048131763935089,
0.3347195088863373,
0.6009695529937744,
-0.20607346296310425,
0.31381532549858093,
-0.550447404384613,
-0.32508569955825806,
0.05556580424308777,
-0.4456060528755188,
0.9570042490959167,
0.2582497000694275,
-0.250681608915329,
0.007188094314187765,
-0.5867742300033569,
-0.28812354803085327,
-0.17467038333415985,
0.4567188024520874,
-0.53313148021698,
0.13795359432697296,
-0.6121669411659241,
0.07449597120285034,
-0.1262177675962448,
-0.25020357966423035,
0.31568342447280884,
-0.5369676947593689,
0.09472427517175674,
0.8554332256317139,
0.5139318704605103,
0.7082102298736572,
-0.39427921175956726,
0.6855804920196533,
0.29362866282463074,
0.4984043836593628,
-0.2502751648426056,
-0.648202121257782,
-0.3091467022895813,
-0.5573468208312988,
0.01385646965354681,
0.5507597327232361,
-0.7692915201187134,
0.5388517379760742,
0.03353211656212807,
-0.28605055809020996,
-0.47126927971839905,
0.06417841464281082,
0.14567530155181885,
0.5187816023826599,
0.3292924463748932,
-0.2139151692390442,
-0.16886258125305176,
-0.8156213164329529,
-0.49377450346946716,
0.09044068306684494,
-0.10019814968109131,
-0.1695326864719391,
0.19212709367275238,
-0.11863094568252563,
1.1155927181243896,
-0.6613379716873169,
-0.25140511989593506,
-0.14674341678619385,
0.351828396320343,
0.5097028017044067,
0.5158697366714478,
0.7583149671554565,
-0.4561706483364105,
-0.5086501240730286,
-0.3978445529937744,
-0.16045717895030975,
-0.33045637607574463,
-0.19925840198993683,
-0.27372118830680847,
-0.016507375985383987,
0.3559613823890686,
-0.7999070882797241,
0.26808029413223267,
0.33409348130226135,
-0.33610764145851135,
0.5405170917510986,
-0.03244323655962944,
0.07484299689531326,
-0.7849690914154053,
-0.13685205578804016,
0.13114921748638153,
-0.050212662667036057,
-0.4160020649433136,
-0.23218931257724762,
-0.1207968220114708,
-0.047151003032922745,
-0.19706255197525024,
0.6598720550537109,
-0.2967853844165802,
0.22676490247249603,
-0.4014669954776764,
0.2637590169906616,
-0.1300758570432663,
0.3572981357574463,
0.08715162426233292,
0.7355383634567261,
1.0700576305389404,
-1.0100077390670776,
0.03941033408045769,
0.3021479845046997,
-0.5017505884170532,
0.8282304406166077,
-0.33579447865486145,
-0.27656909823417664,
-0.4057563245296478,
-0.02919314056634903,
-1.1922757625579834,
-0.01628868468105793,
0.3422495126724243,
-0.36338627338409424,
0.35639438033103943,
-0.40075814723968506,
-0.2705937922000885,
-0.25596150755882263,
-0.2316649705171585,
0.1916402280330658,
0.9006322622299194,
-0.6120904088020325,
0.09883739054203033,
0.13437752425670624,
-0.5696010589599609,
-0.5040621757507324,
-0.2239357829093933,
-0.36148929595947266,
-0.2736321985721588,
-0.160649836063385,
0.26563096046447754,
-0.19977529346942902,
-0.3445731997489929,
-0.17845746874809265,
-0.27651065587997437,
-0.1406625658273697,
0.2845858037471771,
0.2297595739364624,
-0.03285738453269005,
-0.05581843852996826,
0.18249273300170898,
0.649824857711792,
-0.21822866797447205,
0.18098047375679016,
-0.45985907316207886,
0.22192852199077606,
0.4803686738014221,
-0.5522986650466919,
-0.4079016149044037,
0.2685926854610443,
0.1406947672367096,
0.14479853212833405,
0.5349065661430359,
0.32505103945732117,
-0.16368800401687622,
-0.8432942032814026,
-0.36410173773765564,
-0.41967692971229553,
-0.44934895634651184,
-0.1123284175992012,
-0.5767434239387512,
-0.7326199412345886,
0.4802582263946533,
-0.592346727848053,
-0.04088651016354561,
0.488402783870697,
0.33699655532836914,
-0.05241010710597038,
1.2047665119171143,
0.6475244164466858,
0.06799985468387604,
0.4801740348339081,
-0.03571547195315361,
0.11492897570133209,
-0.47071680426597595,
0.13135729730129242,
-0.6587295532226562,
-0.2007775455713272,
-0.47656017541885376,
-0.22384688258171082,
0.4059200584888458,
0.3702995181083679,
-0.4191627502441406,
0.013646341860294342,
-0.14284831285476685,
0.5002210736274719,
0.7610486149787903,
0.16986505687236786,
0.12690328061580658,
0.06804860383272171,
-0.22500476241111755,
-0.15356241166591644,
-0.9328328967094421,
-0.21359199285507202,
0.7430227398872375,
-0.012734908610582352,
0.7353693246841431,
-0.019277216866612434,
0.7050433158874512,
0.34352096915245056,
0.010853113606572151,
-0.7683880925178528,
0.14607135951519012,
-0.285961776971817,
-0.5381048321723938,
-0.18553325533866882,
-0.3366827070713043,
-1.105771780014038,
0.06620808690786362,
-0.029557738453149796,
-0.7095557451248169,
0.6049644947052002,
0.4184816777706146,
-0.8930975794792175,
-0.08434925228357315,
-0.7708543539047241,
1.1599042415618896,
0.16550171375274658,
-0.3511294424533844,
-0.19673410058021545,
-0.6659448146820068,
0.39190787076950073,
-0.3029245138168335,
0.3108752965927124,
-0.3044939935207367,
0.05647582560777664,
0.5683047771453857,
-0.28522437810897827,
1.1866620779037476,
-0.5973020792007446,
-0.27789872884750366,
0.3447449505329132,
0.20648790895938873,
0.41308364272117615,
0.21021458506584167,
0.05876040831208229,
-0.06501208990812302,
0.09308616816997528,
-0.5580595135688782,
-0.7758029699325562,
0.5319186449050903,
-0.6321454644203186,
-0.7585967779159546,
-0.23471611738204956,
-0.26466622948646545,
-0.6574921607971191,
-0.002634126925840974,
0.5978559851646423,
0.3904780149459839,
-0.09700974076986313,
-0.3596491813659668,
0.9299871921539307,
-0.403953492641449,
0.484173983335495,
0.7221733331680298,
0.11498577147722244,
-0.151066392660141,
0.5737751722335815,
-0.05644276738166809,
0.25744369626045227,
0.37885597348213196,
0.06435531377792358,
-0.4612932503223419,
-0.6187671422958374,
-0.33041951060295105,
0.13384777307510376,
-0.6367079019546509,
-0.43331030011177063,
-0.4042890965938568,
0.14247791469097137,
-0.4400888681411743,
-0.22664158046245575,
-0.11465498805046082,
-0.2265079766511917,
-0.46757686138153076,
0.09583095461130142,
0.48836952447891235,
0.47927430272102356,
-0.1550220102071762,
0.9389697909355164,
-0.9103366732597351,
0.48304200172424316,
0.2612411379814148,
0.28038933873176575,
-0.3346215784549713,
-0.8489474058151245,
0.020774321630597115,
0.05924715846776962,
-0.28711026906967163,
-1.0316729545593262,
0.3243511915206909,
0.4122878909111023,
0.8209734559059143,
0.6295115947723389,
0.3907737731933594,
0.604280412197113,
-0.5896797776222229,
0.7560961842536926,
0.1895778924226761,
-0.9878446459770203,
0.8769552707672119,
-0.4052494168281555,
0.5255179405212402,
0.7118697166442871,
0.7751622796058655,
-0.21072223782539368,
-0.4342673420906067,
-0.6605459451675415,
-0.41954880952835083,
0.7670259475708008,
-0.2508907914161682,
0.04121607914566994,
-0.4086957275867462,
0.3559640049934387,
0.6598454117774963,
0.21318228542804718,
-0.083030566573143,
-0.27849116921424866,
0.09438157826662064,
-0.4578329622745514,
-0.3647332489490509,
-0.16931554675102234,
0.07576008141040802,
-0.34144628047943115,
0.6207993626594543,
-0.26595526933670044,
0.1670791357755661,
0.060497384518384933,
-0.25462934374809265,
-0.18398767709732056,
0.36761030554771423,
0.3443884551525116,
0.9085187315940857,
-0.04844730719923973,
0.27307504415512085,
-0.14163973927497864,
-0.20380449295043945,
0.2136334776878357,
0.31721532344818115,
-0.29109832644462585,
0.1705358773469925,
0.18145205080509186,
0.9724034667015076,
0.267810583114624,
-0.5118593573570251,
0.6818553805351257,
0.2950383722782135,
-0.1650567501783371,
-0.011758837848901749,
0.32458212971687317,
-0.3759796917438507,
0.40234437584877014,
0.547046959400177,
0.175484299659729,
0.2075996845960617,
-0.41002267599105835,
0.28718605637550354,
0.7124707102775574,
-0.26082849502563477,
-0.436723917722702,
0.4827404320240021,
0.14122727513313293,
0.1305813044309616,
0.37630152702331543,
-0.5063027739524841,
-0.29755905270576477,
0.3306291997432709,
0.4183392822742462,
0.9071577787399292,
-0.46085092425346375,
0.5259670615196228,
0.3771243691444397,
0.2012089639902115,
-0.4259359538555145,
0.409365177154541,
-0.16816845536231995,
-0.666144847869873,
-0.7972025871276855,
-0.7344332933425903,
-0.20872323215007782,
0.07343830168247223,
-0.49920371174812317,
0.268688440322876,
-0.5733456015586853,
-0.4039587676525116,
-0.004377442412078381,
-0.16079476475715637,
-0.6363243460655212,
-0.0013377523282542825,
-0.045840274542570114,
0.9535879492759705,
-1.154872179031372,
0.6845139265060425,
0.498504638671875,
-0.26802048087120056,
-0.4675354063510895,
0.1359359472990036,
-0.028151657432317734,
-0.6347882151603699,
0.6592110991477966,
-0.10755454003810883,
0.054905958473682404,
0.5989812612533569,
-0.5838152766227722,
-0.6283769607543945,
0.5390998125076294,
0.629493772983551,
-0.925216794013977,
0.2697192430496216,
-0.09188707917928696,
0.12077439576387405,
-0.1043710932135582,
0.014980724081397057,
0.8323847055435181,
0.48475417494773865,
-0.08283981680870056,
-0.8159611225128174,
0.05508163571357727,
0.10476483404636383,
-0.23265469074249268,
0.3955887258052826,
-0.18243594467639923,
0.6656479835510254,
-0.34835729002952576,
-0.3121466338634491,
-0.05792763829231262,
0.1771601289510727,
0.3131885528564453,
0.3652831017971039,
0.40072235465049744,
0.4736701548099518,
0.7096577286720276,
-0.10015441477298737,
0.9173958897590637,
-0.21202664077281952,
0.18959422409534454,
0.9899054765701294,
-0.37345364689826965,
0.6035388708114624,
0.37536582350730896,
-0.4172664284706116,
0.45222774147987366,
0.8159651756286621,
0.1717076152563095,
0.8900483250617981,
0.10410425812005997,
-0.460688054561615,
-0.4499412477016449,
0.06958793103694916,
-0.2748229503631592,
0.17715021967887878,
0.4820167124271393,
-0.2143159955739975,
-0.5400068163871765,
0.2426064908504486,
-0.39499786496162415,
0.019486406818032265,
-0.5326167941093445,
0.9671363234519958,
0.33340880274772644,
-0.7977471947669983,
0.7258790731430054,
-0.27997779846191406,
0.5552754998207092,
-0.7201426029205322,
0.0189252607524395,
-0.2766040563583374,
0.08436723053455353,
0.03094589337706566,
-0.6225032806396484,
0.14511947333812714,
-0.17069244384765625,
-0.19664281606674194,
-0.23695889115333557,
0.6745021343231201,
-0.2340790033340454,
-0.08738873898983002,
-0.006984233856201172,
0.8042817115783691,
0.04128745198249817,
-0.7160828709602356,
-0.6891177892684937,
-0.1837417632341385,
-0.21729643642902374,
-0.15532895922660828,
0.31864213943481445,
0.76390141248703,
0.018156766891479492,
0.42278340458869934,
0.30361878871917725,
0.18129907548427582,
0.061853308230638504,
0.3909578323364258,
0.5649254322052002,
-0.581802248954773,
-0.49582087993621826,
-1.032928466796875,
0.4772666394710541,
0.21732355654239655,
-0.29219532012939453,
0.7596819996833801,
0.08596359193325043,
0.710686206817627,
-0.4738854467868805,
0.9563760161399841,
0.2392936646938324,
0.4357759356498718,
-0.7284528613090515,
0.3926664888858795,
-0.3667779862880707,
0.07861417531967163,
-0.18615679442882538,
-1.0055989027023315,
-0.32030853629112244,
0.52510666847229,
-0.5257555842399597,
-0.028505636379122734,
0.7482900023460388,
0.6507596373558044,
-0.13967476785182953,
-0.11408836394548416,
0.36846551299095154,
0.07968609035015106,
-0.21955014765262604,
0.6875270009040833,
0.9852147698402405,
0.003514228155836463,
0.10660988092422485,
-0.0793951228260994,
-0.4958816170692444,
-0.20540551841259003,
-0.762467622756958,
-0.8411457538604736,
-0.5629441142082214,
-0.5770642161369324,
0.15240415930747986,
0.2734936475753784,
0.9333789348602295,
0.5864811539649963,
-0.9074327349662781,
0.2252875417470932,
-0.4555931091308594,
0.1867683231830597,
-0.4150199294090271,
-0.1663215011358261,
0.25790128111839294,
-0.8742241263389587,
-0.7122007608413696,
0.4025980234146118,
0.1957928091287613,
0.20417574048042297,
0.018018314614892006,
0.15472982823848724,
0.14564993977546692,
-0.061124544590711594,
0.6231714487075806,
0.1616174429655075,
-0.47774630784988403,
-0.10052472352981567,
-0.1725458949804306,
0.18798528611660004,
-0.3170502483844757,
0.899079442024231,
-1.001444697380066,
0.25603294372558594,
0.5136294364929199,
0.5941709876060486,
0.04348668083548546,
0.17499594390392303,
0.5809876322746277,
-0.9878197312355042,
0.2908446192741394,
0.10879899561405182,
0.1314808577299118,
0.007472862955182791,
-0.3254794478416443,
0.13308638334274292,
0.4255348742008209,
-0.3479856848716736,
-0.4553554654121399,
0.6187121868133545,
-0.8768483996391296,
-0.7953922152519226,
1.0547465085983276,
-0.0717521458864212,
-0.19082048535346985,
-0.36147913336753845,
-0.23867768049240112,
0.2098841518163681,
-0.37711432576179504,
0.77011638879776,
0.47876793146133423,
-0.09586784988641739,
-0.22798550128936768,
-0.547511100769043,
0.9095182418823242,
0.47002115845680237,
-0.6010187268257141,
0.2739264667034149,
0.707970380783081,
0.27895984053611755,
-0.22932083904743195,
0.6887145042419434,
0.38564831018447876,
0.3683891296386719,
0.013216540217399597,
-0.17533516883850098,
0.33223891258239746,
-0.40802913904190063,
-0.5667477250099182,
0.13596798479557037,
0.4568723738193512,
-0.1346028745174408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14151v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14151v2 | True Knowledge Comes from Practice: Aligning LLMs with Embodied Environments via Reinforcement Learning | 2024-01-25T13:03:20 | 2024-03-11T03:15:58 | Weihao Tan, Wentao Zhang, Shanqi Liu, Longtao Zheng, Xinrun Wang, Bo An | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the impressive performance across numerous tasks, large language
models (LLMs) often fail in solving simple decision-making tasks due to the
misalignment of the knowledge in LLMs with environments. On the contrary,
reinforcement learning (RL) agents learn policies from scratch, which makes
them always align with environments but difficult to incorporate prior
knowledge for efficient explorations. To narrow the gap, we propose TWOSOME, a
novel general online framework that deploys LLMs as decision-making agents to
efficiently interact and align with embodied environments via RL without
requiring any prepared datasets or prior knowledge of the environments.
Firstly, we query the joint probabilities of each valid action with LLMs to
form behavior policies. Then, to enhance the stability and robustness of the
policies, we propose two normalization methods and summarize four prompt design
principles. Finally, we design a novel parameter-efficient training
architecture where the actor and critic share one frozen LLM equipped with
low-rank adapters (LoRA) updated by PPO. We conduct extensive experiments to
evaluate TWOSOME. i) TWOSOME exhibits significantly better sample efficiency
and performance compared to the conventional RL method, PPO, and prompt tuning
method, SayCan, in both classical decision-making environment, Overcooked, and
simulated household environment, VirtualHome. ii) Benefiting from LLMs'
open-vocabulary feature, TWOSOME shows superior generalization ability to
unseen tasks. iii) Under our framework, there is no significant loss of the
LLMs' original ability during online PPO finetuning. | [
-0.26515018939971924,
-0.8617070913314819,
0.679548442363739,
0.134308323264122,
0.009938377887010574,
0.06851606070995331,
-0.3828924894332886,
-0.30468493700027466,
0.02744191884994507,
0.39000624418258667,
-0.6043745279312134,
-0.37413573265075684,
-0.07234840840101242,
-0.12124629318714142,
0.466060996055603,
0.9234431982040405,
-0.00862361490726471,
0.04549015313386917,
-0.35626423358917236,
-0.28279605507850647,
-0.5084301829338074,
0.01602024771273136,
-0.7698898911476135,
-0.4991191625595093,
0.5997337698936462,
0.2960726320743561,
0.8727126121520996,
0.4719333350658417,
0.031628143042325974,
0.336441308259964,
-0.009471980854868889,
0.7956448197364807,
-0.7498863935470581,
0.10011260956525803,
-0.5443674921989441,
-0.626391589641571,
-0.3299998939037323,
-0.0873817652463913,
0.3125447630882263,
0.2742135226726532,
-0.33630940318107605,
-0.1369607299566269,
0.1002177819609642,
0.5647451877593994,
-0.6141239404678345,
0.15412771701812744,
-0.22883641719818115,
0.34585103392601013,
0.30172738432884216,
-0.02784307673573494,
-0.4228810966014862,
-0.5148100256919861,
0.13496823608875275,
-1.1465734243392944,
-0.2169150561094284,
0.33296072483062744,
0.7100955843925476,
0.6531304121017456,
-0.5841964483261108,
-0.3710102140903473,
-0.7017296552658081,
0.6640938520431519,
-0.46527233719825745,
0.3768182396888733,
0.3360252380371094,
0.38989391922950745,
-0.47249704599380493,
-0.648918867111206,
-0.7376827597618103,
-0.11726811528205872,
-0.27539584040641785,
0.31469038128852844,
0.07287345826625824,
0.0756828710436821,
-0.027878673747181892,
-0.12228616327047348,
-0.6338427662849426,
0.4848161041736603,
-0.22170481085777283,
-0.2599135637283325,
0.5384889841079712,
0.05512533336877823,
0.3523620665073395,
0.06973160803318024,
-0.7740134000778198,
-0.20131991803646088,
-0.621627926826477,
0.4221062660217285,
0.3127323091030121,
0.16643355786800385,
-0.21747742593288422,
0.2776258885860443,
0.1923566609621048,
0.39338698983192444,
0.21655750274658203,
-0.1392568200826645,
0.08320097625255585,
0.0812445729970932,
-0.005634119268506765,
-0.10111553966999054,
0.6232944130897522,
0.41699323058128357,
0.10693328082561493,
-0.30723732709884644,
-0.17772218585014343,
0.028203709051012993,
0.5571929812431335,
-0.46059632301330566,
0.03221835568547249,
0.14054767787456512,
-0.18834750354290009,
-0.3139649033546448,
-0.01024853065609932,
-0.6841334104537964,
-0.6963028311729431,
-0.589743435382843,
0.7558158040046692,
-0.10186947882175446,
-0.5240275859832764,
-0.20088382065296173,
-0.07795433700084686,
0.6170485615730286,
0.326650470495224,
-0.8854535818099976,
0.4676021337509155,
0.8843604326248169,
0.6463439464569092,
-0.3128068447113037,
-0.3011900782585144,
-0.5660640597343445,
0.1060769185423851,
-0.7506649494171143,
0.7116701006889343,
-0.2646590769290924,
-0.16015100479125977,
0.10370354354381561,
0.016599401831626892,
-0.010954772122204304,
-0.41945570707321167,
0.25280076265335083,
-0.7875812649726868,
0.19710756838321686,
-0.3142090439796448,
-0.5714760422706604,
-0.16158735752105713,
0.4054739475250244,
-0.5877105593681335,
0.8576629757881165,
0.004473195876926184,
-0.4142177999019623,
0.43425729870796204,
-0.6905670762062073,
-0.31585729122161865,
-0.2145739495754242,
-0.38998764753341675,
-0.4886091649532318,
0.006905379705131054,
0.09286708384752274,
0.20952878892421722,
0.043240174651145935,
0.4154648780822754,
-0.48013606667518616,
-0.6170581579208374,
0.46841204166412354,
0.03945161774754524,
0.6511497497558594,
0.1235005110502243,
-0.23220552504062653,
0.41605252027511597,
-0.31983649730682373,
0.035150814801454544,
0.08808641135692596,
-0.3797796368598938,
-0.10370688885450363,
0.06047239899635315,
-0.26612529158592224,
0.3382866084575653,
0.026797309517860413,
-0.41867300868034363,
0.38284987211227417,
-0.5959089994430542,
0.4167405664920807,
0.8854889273643494,
-0.11147081851959229,
0.889201283454895,
-0.519252359867096,
0.499504953622818,
-0.23880675435066223,
0.05753724277019501,
0.3380417823791504,
-0.3627772033214569,
-0.6775566935539246,
-0.13302932679653168,
0.1388445645570755,
0.7104141712188721,
-0.9347764849662781,
0.3771931827068329,
0.0002807319106068462,
-0.2469581961631775,
-0.429512619972229,
0.1585298627614975,
0.7016157507896423,
0.31708937883377075,
0.37871819734573364,
0.010015190578997135,
-0.4108651876449585,
-0.6145682334899902,
-0.11115004122257233,
-0.040576159954071045,
-0.2521175742149353,
0.43098184466362,
0.3753564655780792,
-0.22682221233844757,
1.1312519311904907,
-0.36980441212654114,
-0.3569665849208832,
-0.2620152533054352,
-0.0012663331581279635,
-0.03477036580443382,
0.41851887106895447,
0.31146034598350525,
-0.7106674313545227,
-0.12050851434469223,
0.10014233738183975,
-1.1584666967391968,
0.3224821090698242,
-0.04825195297598839,
-0.5754297375679016,
0.3360055685043335,
0.36862730979919434,
-0.46612584590911865,
0.1767561286687851,
0.3322107493877411,
-0.41522452235221863,
0.22951851785182953,
-0.6520476937294006,
-0.19206883013248444,
-0.8539752960205078,
-0.32967039942741394,
-0.08102841675281525,
-0.3135758638381958,
-0.5978504419326782,
0.2262275665998459,
0.15450111031532288,
-0.07299881428480148,
-0.5323302745819092,
0.9431179165840149,
-0.40054675936698914,
-0.36651068925857544,
-0.37906837463378906,
0.4319404363632202,
0.005597283132374287,
1.0834174156188965,
0.22892482578754425,
0.6873176097869873,
0.4421972632408142,
-0.9139042496681213,
0.3843017518520355,
0.40735065937042236,
-0.11926170438528061,
0.6190938949584961,
-0.42502477765083313,
0.4098087251186371,
-0.31402650475502014,
0.5284480452537537,
-0.7190585136413574,
-0.24896007776260376,
0.39325594902038574,
-0.2992323935031891,
0.39737915992736816,
0.13909858465194702,
-0.2760268449783325,
-0.10444357246160507,
-0.4238629639148712,
0.12155319005250931,
0.612258791923523,
-0.7728820443153381,
0.8712198734283447,
0.4971853494644165,
0.03922316059470177,
-0.40189698338508606,
-0.705514132976532,
-0.22200284898281097,
-0.30246463418006897,
-0.43328723311424255,
0.35648706555366516,
0.0413844957947731,
-0.2803620398044586,
0.013684311881661415,
-0.13136886060237885,
-0.09631656110286713,
0.09177451580762863,
0.23434369266033173,
0.41107845306396484,
-0.027699515223503113,
0.5295235514640808,
0.24295026063919067,
-0.19088871777057648,
-0.008214023895561695,
-0.5255412459373474,
0.16285502910614014,
-0.07430148869752884,
-0.0666971355676651,
-0.3062126636505127,
0.06848136335611343,
0.12108420580625534,
-0.06097191944718361,
0.5717222690582275,
0.7274696826934814,
-0.3253541886806488,
-0.5138731002807617,
-0.3513898253440857,
-0.35297369956970215,
-0.47634047269821167,
0.19918471574783325,
-0.2626829445362091,
-0.8415705561637878,
0.3166297376155853,
-0.23076976835727692,
0.3142130970954895,
-0.14735065400600433,
0.3941417336463928,
-0.3444238603115082,
0.6736453771591187,
0.716082751750946,
0.3810598850250244,
0.2710896134376526,
-0.145664244890213,
0.1331009864807129,
-0.9442976117134094,
-0.46076029539108276,
0.02698471210896969,
-0.5136601328849792,
-0.7827026844024658,
-0.6464179158210754,
0.547688901424408,
0.13270947337150574,
-0.49936264753341675,
0.14964629709720612,
-0.35149452090263367,
0.4533739984035492,
0.5883685350418091,
0.7084864974021912,
0.1288277506828308,
-0.15205073356628418,
-0.45590299367904663,
0.03212687745690346,
-0.5271300673484802,
-0.6244990825653076,
1.0700743198394775,
0.21688984334468842,
0.6439046859741211,
0.5128883719444275,
0.5654414296150208,
0.37354421615600586,
0.16781117022037506,
-0.6716642379760742,
0.4214138984680176,
0.22849631309509277,
-0.5901753306388855,
-0.4915149509906769,
-0.30792731046676636,
-0.9232358932495117,
0.5292491912841797,
-0.44623905420303345,
-0.7588486671447754,
0.19395564496517181,
0.3200118839740753,
-0.5636674165725708,
0.1640545278787613,
-0.5119286179542542,
0.7644231915473938,
-0.5558748841285706,
-0.9880103468894958,
-0.38158172369003296,
-0.8869137167930603,
0.377296507358551,
0.22983188927173615,
0.3426019549369812,
-0.020093409344553947,
-0.4584665298461914,
0.592947781085968,
-0.20065820217132568,
0.9713427424430847,
-0.26745733618736267,
-0.13318590819835663,
0.2813514471054077,
0.027770616114139557,
0.7100593447685242,
0.26997923851013184,
-0.0407504178583622,
-0.2614781856536865,
-0.3567678928375244,
-0.3676644265651703,
-0.8174117803573608,
0.7145265936851501,
-0.9813451170921326,
-0.45482346415519714,
-0.3600269854068756,
-0.31265583634376526,
-0.5719006061553955,
-0.11844698339700699,
0.12038450688123703,
0.39250192046165466,
-0.2679225206375122,
-0.042662911117076874,
0.9737613797187805,
-0.3740202486515045,
0.29171305894851685,
0.7211538553237915,
-0.4231450855731964,
-0.5059726238250732,
0.9882254600524902,
-0.0698646530508995,
0.11428746581077576,
0.5333287119865417,
0.3896346986293793,
-0.6503076553344727,
0.08508247882127762,
-0.615885317325592,
0.10690082609653473,
-0.6272605657577515,
-0.06958399713039398,
-0.5801665782928467,
0.0720376968383789,
-0.2866688668727875,
-0.3362499177455902,
-0.20554496347904205,
-0.11084654927253723,
-0.26366594433784485,
-0.36317381262779236,
0.17062848806381226,
0.7600632309913635,
-0.3118515908718109,
-0.06969889253377914,
-0.4125765860080719,
0.4581297039985657,
0.8824084997177124,
0.20491650700569153,
-0.005756045691668987,
-0.39443784952163696,
0.0559789277613163,
-0.006301138550043106,
-0.519775927066803,
-0.8483341336250305,
0.06347156316041946,
0.22375765442848206,
0.7441585659980774,
0.4264867603778839,
0.3572522699832916,
0.48415407538414,
-0.11741001158952713,
0.4683179259300232,
-0.008284127339720726,
-0.5751475691795349,
0.45767271518707275,
-0.20997709035873413,
0.07175909727811813,
0.39592739939689636,
0.4031986594200134,
-0.2926699221134186,
-0.18033280968666077,
-0.3965570330619812,
-0.5837458372116089,
0.8138387203216553,
0.1389876753091812,
0.0767676904797554,
0.3212176561355591,
0.14245139062404633,
0.2413170337677002,
0.30404770374298096,
-0.6316959857940674,
-0.12818726897239685,
-0.22366945445537567,
-0.0050106835551559925,
0.18118533492088318,
-0.0695294514298439,
-0.22279833257198334,
-0.15763112902641296,
0.7740277647972107,
-0.38237079977989197,
0.28300634026527405,
0.11257349699735641,
-0.2591351866722107,
-0.007817704230546951,
0.38704925775527954,
0.5298973917961121,
0.5550826787948608,
0.05413605645298958,
0.04032665491104126,
0.5028409361839294,
0.14216262102127075,
0.30864787101745605,
-0.15047025680541992,
-0.22632545232772827,
-0.5578495264053345,
0.34070342779159546,
0.9762935042381287,
0.734039843082428,
-0.6914552450180054,
0.3743145167827606,
-0.1036689430475235,
-0.15684522688388824,
-0.3279951810836792,
0.31160372495651245,
0.33220210671424866,
0.4749586284160614,
-0.04178938269615173,
-0.03901495039463043,
-0.014904269948601723,
-0.7638736367225647,
0.166987344622612,
0.17618978023529053,
-0.45325741171836853,
-0.19595584273338318,
0.4746290445327759,
0.3703332543373108,
-0.2524368464946747,
0.7158383131027222,
-0.701034426689148,
-0.4281848073005676,
0.6019022464752197,
0.5691543817520142,
0.5578289031982422,
0.05455395206809044,
0.5405774712562561,
0.4231604337692261,
-0.06640294939279556,
-0.1644800752401352,
0.2427370846271515,
-0.3820720613002777,
-0.953215479850769,
-0.1409328728914261,
-0.6151056885719299,
-0.5201529860496521,
-0.25264495611190796,
-0.527999758720398,
0.23889011144638062,
-0.6618126034736633,
-0.006895098835229874,
-0.521710216999054,
0.029944248497486115,
-0.6975032091140747,
-0.09594893455505371,
0.2270866334438324,
0.34175214171409607,
-0.6515055298805237,
0.6531525254249573,
0.9366915225982666,
-0.36563363671302795,
-1.1111831665039062,
-0.14875856041908264,
0.41471290588378906,
-0.8433255553245544,
0.21498265862464905,
0.29480257630348206,
-0.14970913529396057,
0.05797518417239189,
-0.39314958453178406,
-0.6962569952011108,
1.3038175106048584,
0.25520437955856323,
-0.5622572898864746,
-0.2938483953475952,
-0.29974010586738586,
0.557396650314331,
-0.24681642651557922,
0.3809514343738556,
0.5443162322044373,
0.684489905834198,
0.24651655554771423,
-0.812694787979126,
0.15027692914009094,
-0.08366300910711288,
-0.0008247172809205949,
0.12445894628763199,
-0.7118242383003235,
0.5477191805839539,
-0.5235080718994141,
-0.3144640624523163,
-0.025023067370057106,
0.6708042621612549,
0.6077630519866943,
0.5349217057228088,
0.4509790539741516,
0.5494785308837891,
0.8968311548233032,
-0.13147296011447906,
0.6581653952598572,
0.1391395628452301,
0.3035297095775604,
1.2069154977798462,
-0.47114402055740356,
0.7265743017196655,
0.2247968167066574,
-0.17523853480815887,
0.5798848271369934,
0.5461393594741821,
0.15834569931030273,
0.61049884557724,
0.3436148166656494,
-0.13974373042583466,
-0.5518243312835693,
-0.2423475980758667,
-0.1623924970626831,
0.3937484920024872,
0.2988196015357971,
0.24242092669010162,
-0.20246626436710358,
0.34312304854393005,
0.0401572547852993,
0.5614078044891357,
-0.27575287222862244,
1.3047358989715576,
0.16939321160316467,
-0.9974472522735596,
0.22043593227863312,
-0.23695231974124908,
0.8092725872993469,
-0.5057278275489807,
-0.12167594581842422,
-0.23862427473068237,
0.23140889406204224,
-0.2763623595237732,
-0.7237411141395569,
0.07773948460817337,
-0.14245088398456573,
0.19791404902935028,
-0.1899174153804779,
0.6080747842788696,
-0.3901851177215576,
-0.1490962654352188,
0.39773717522621155,
0.46303534507751465,
0.037012092769145966,
0.29152196645736694,
-0.5199929475784302,
-0.12304641306400299,
-0.2719036042690277,
-0.20245850086212158,
0.455545037984848,
0.3732362985610962,
-0.2118724286556244,
0.7645195126533508,
0.5829666256904602,
-0.0297088660299778,
-0.1697515994310379,
-0.11089113354682922,
0.8514060378074646,
-0.6086593270301819,
-0.7872056365013123,
-0.43603605031967163,
0.5121588706970215,
-0.037780243903398514,
-0.3323066830635071,
0.30369699001312256,
0.2771572768688202,
0.8967258334159851,
0.041620995849370956,
0.5330339074134827,
-0.020040690898895264,
0.2096996009349823,
-0.8769527673721313,
0.5285491943359375,
-0.5199110507965088,
0.13723716139793396,
0.3562610447406769,
-0.7810397148132324,
0.022548090666532516,
0.6869387030601501,
-0.34733814001083374,
-0.02668934315443039,
0.5769362449645996,
1.0319335460662842,
0.1324053257703781,
-0.05477837845683098,
0.3893766701221466,
0.05926160886883736,
0.29822710156440735,
0.5367382168769836,
0.864561915397644,
-0.10783364623785019,
0.5084823369979858,
-0.1497444212436676,
-0.23410700261592865,
-0.2172553837299347,
-0.6105369329452515,
-0.935975193977356,
-0.30595171451568604,
-0.0914258062839508,
-0.060702405869960785,
0.4794251322746277,
1.347313404083252,
0.7287232279777527,
-0.5329636931419373,
-0.06383492797613144,
-0.3678893446922302,
0.36209389567375183,
-0.4269537925720215,
-0.2299051135778427,
0.17445535957813263,
-0.46685996651649475,
-0.45448949933052063,
0.6210625767707825,
0.14896413683891296,
-0.13157090544700623,
-0.42110106348991394,
-0.698793351650238,
-0.16877128183841705,
0.042767249047756195,
0.39032959938049316,
0.39539211988449097,
-0.8562703132629395,
-0.10649701952934265,
-0.1587427258491516,
-0.32123589515686035,
-0.04625801742076874,
0.7476248741149902,
-0.9917346239089966,
0.4889940917491913,
0.45909860730171204,
0.5727590322494507,
0.4063867926597595,
0.011819979175925255,
0.6663393378257751,
-0.520528256893158,
0.040674008429050446,
0.27672892808914185,
0.0688990131020546,
0.22110745310783386,
-0.34622928500175476,
0.47113144397735596,
-0.07722123712301254,
-0.7516541481018066,
-0.4439324140548706,
0.3682946264743805,
-0.8162762522697449,
-0.4410319924354553,
1.0868852138519287,
-0.27278220653533936,
-0.3504982590675354,
-0.09668414294719696,
-0.26716479659080505,
0.4124131202697754,
-0.6164244413375854,
0.6634714603424072,
0.1923137605190277,
-0.22593557834625244,
-0.07677005976438522,
-0.5425950884819031,
0.5419692397117615,
0.2579542398452759,
-0.8689190149307251,
-0.2696287930011749,
0.40062424540519714,
0.2304968386888504,
0.05698688328266144,
0.4282269775867462,
0.2834446430206299,
0.352368026971817,
-0.09764011204242706,
-0.03469755873084068,
-0.39099422097206116,
-0.44646522402763367,
-0.26302221417427063,
0.008597062900662422,
0.06389959156513214,
-0.1582556813955307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14135v1 | Convolutional Neural Networks can achieve binary bail judgement classification | 2024-01-25T12:31:41 | 2024-01-25T12:31:41 | Amit Barman, Devangan Roy, Debapriya Paul, Indranil Dutta, Shouvik Kumar Guha, Samir Karmakar, Sudip Kumar Naskar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | There is an evident lack of implementation of Machine Learning (ML) in the
legal domain in India, and any research that does take place in this domain is
usually based on data from the higher courts of law and works with English
data. The lower courts and data from the different regional languages of India
are often overlooked. In this paper, we deploy a Convolutional Neural Network
(CNN) architecture on a corpus of Hindi legal documents. We perform a bail
Prediction task with the help of a CNN model and achieve an overall accuracy of
93\% which is an improvement on the benchmark accuracy, set by Kapoor et al.
(2022), albeit in data from 20 districts of the Indian state of Uttar Pradesh. | [
-0.07256921380758286,
-0.38554811477661133,
0.3691461384296417,
0.20823052525520325,
-0.5250523090362549,
0.27647489309310913,
-0.21730521321296692,
-0.5530759692192078,
-0.0516057126224041,
0.20752371847629547,
0.14516380429267883,
-0.5984452962875366,
-0.977422833442688,
-0.01767425611615181,
-0.834376871585846,
0.9767171740531921,
0.41509175300598145,
0.6660903096199036,
0.04592033848166466,
-0.09587154537439346,
-0.6343794465065002,
-0.4857938885688782,
-0.6287156939506531,
-0.25248289108276367,
0.39773261547088623,
0.5995160341262817,
0.6495670080184937,
0.04238291084766388,
0.6882953643798828,
0.43469130992889404,
-0.1426743119955063,
0.1367122083902359,
-0.11369681358337402,
-0.4471804201602936,
-0.27460870146751404,
-0.677902340888977,
0.14207130670547485,
-0.13853059709072113,
0.41350117325782776,
0.18864433467388153,
-0.3255842924118042,
-0.4668467044830322,
-0.42033255100250244,
0.9909597039222717,
-0.776193380355835,
0.024482741951942444,
-0.4272370934486389,
0.47020232677459717,
-0.1457323282957077,
0.2211686372756958,
-0.6601852774620056,
-0.8356305360794067,
0.2863335907459259,
-0.2587404251098633,
0.39488106966018677,
0.3121221661567688,
0.8563662767410278,
0.39365702867507935,
-0.4279646575450897,
-0.5251193642616272,
-0.7947447299957275,
0.2787168025970459,
-0.7837162017822266,
0.2762647569179535,
0.33792465925216675,
0.6684678792953491,
-0.18487173318862915,
-0.6535534858703613,
-0.699731707572937,
-0.40557563304901123,
-0.534583568572998,
0.07090376317501068,
0.3074401617050171,
0.04447128623723984,
0.005330522079020739,
0.24582147598266602,
-0.3684481084346771,
0.0404232032597065,
-1.0125691890716553,
-0.2553962469100952,
0.7611327171325684,
-0.1464856117963791,
0.21737706661224365,
-0.427082896232605,
-0.4417944550514221,
0.12333565950393677,
-0.37538883090019226,
0.4657497704029083,
0.28209999203681946,
0.4222046136856079,
-0.2927248775959015,
0.5663207769393921,
-0.03214148059487343,
0.6508172154426575,
0.5365004539489746,
-0.11908280104398727,
0.13696329295635223,
-0.1365535706281662,
-0.20330297946929932,
1.0421329736709595,
0.9309731125831604,
0.5080637335777283,
0.5403977632522583,
-0.050723087042570114,
-0.338840126991272,
-0.08561026304960251,
0.6100378632545471,
-0.49516913294792175,
0.08434692770242691,
-0.008330745622515678,
-0.39175644516944885,
-0.36646604537963867,
0.18287137150764465,
-0.7818108797073364,
-1.1068410873413086,
-0.44684454798698425,
0.017092866823077202,
-0.7008203864097595,
-0.030431639403104782,
0.06991284340620041,
0.08632699400186539,
0.571366548538208,
0.4626205861568451,
-0.8617919087409973,
0.21854904294013977,
0.7346481084823608,
1.005245566368103,
0.06541337072849274,
0.150112122297287,
-0.5775712728500366,
-0.17673438787460327,
-0.43063589930534363,
0.8658242225646973,
-0.6648500561714172,
-0.38700371980667114,
0.1734050065279007,
0.013487511314451694,
-0.08949707448482513,
-0.3611525595188141,
1.117503046989441,
-0.737757682800293,
-0.2949758768081665,
0.3290189206600189,
-0.5234982371330261,
-0.6831016540527344,
0.5094230771064758,
-0.4945225715637207,
0.45269775390625,
0.08429185301065445,
-0.713482141494751,
0.9253309965133667,
-0.3173518180847168,
-0.8210086822509766,
0.1635371744632721,
-0.36740732192993164,
-0.6542332768440247,
0.1355055421590805,
0.09575505554676056,
0.5988667011260986,
-0.034385792911052704,
0.8181681036949158,
-0.21113379299640656,
-1.0263943672180176,
-0.19469106197357178,
-0.09261678159236908,
0.5317878127098083,
0.5135917663574219,
-0.4327176511287689,
0.004375376272946596,
-0.9964450597763062,
-0.406423956155777,
-0.2580256760120392,
-0.5712941288948059,
-0.2250327616930008,
0.1223287433385849,
0.004961899947375059,
0.28663673996925354,
-0.04869668558239937,
-0.9577097296714783,
0.04028040170669556,
-0.5330975651741028,
0.27444297075271606,
0.5649197101593018,
-0.2143464982509613,
0.47058770060539246,
0.03603757917881012,
0.3111491799354553,
0.44090351462364197,
-0.1885131299495697,
0.5831034183502197,
-0.4441046416759491,
-0.5757917761802673,
0.17333339154720306,
0.7429068088531494,
0.9552518129348755,
-0.20871944725513458,
0.03934105858206749,
-0.30050283670425415,
-0.6434376239776611,
-0.38256728649139404,
-0.04528683051466942,
0.3182990550994873,
0.55423903465271,
0.08707323670387268,
-0.00888746790587902,
-0.828885555267334,
-0.9927117824554443,
-0.15241600573062897,
0.056570399552583694,
0.5715060830116272,
0.2423781454563141,
0.5528338551521301,
-0.07604911923408508,
0.8495159149169922,
0.034846607595682144,
-0.5074928998947144,
-0.1389235109090805,
0.1323133111000061,
0.5389336347579956,
0.6731323599815369,
0.4124520719051361,
-1.690364122390747,
-0.6665797233581543,
0.3723251223564148,
-0.8849066495895386,
0.6275423765182495,
-0.20421576499938965,
0.04616108536720276,
0.4312325119972229,
0.7023753523826599,
-0.4749792516231537,
0.949112057685852,
-0.0419858954846859,
-0.6482495069503784,
0.6381385326385498,
-0.6175956130027771,
0.23877979815006256,
-0.845669686794281,
-0.2992987632751465,
0.240109384059906,
-0.4494505524635315,
-0.4449368119239807,
-0.31761491298675537,
0.2748042345046997,
-0.037117306143045425,
-0.6316275596618652,
0.2989884614944458,
-0.054506514221429825,
-0.05160587280988693,
-0.08319003134965897,
0.18159006536006927,
-0.45366141200065613,
0.4917553961277008,
0.06312525272369385,
0.6960453987121582,
0.3766419589519501,
-0.5384194850921631,
0.5063013434410095,
0.4111274480819702,
-0.5935679078102112,
0.6319443583488464,
-0.5119513869285583,
-0.20757661759853363,
-0.26438280940055847,
0.1426234394311905,
-0.8587855696678162,
-0.2526061534881592,
0.2778042256832123,
-0.3298007845878601,
0.6777518391609192,
-0.4131438732147217,
-0.42676877975463867,
-0.37123173475265503,
-0.023948034271597862,
0.21954841911792755,
0.2247563749551773,
-0.33042269945144653,
0.6765552163124084,
0.22482120990753174,
0.2567446827888489,
-0.9424724578857422,
-1.0360115766525269,
0.10988783836364746,
-0.09857475012540817,
-0.26600247621536255,
-0.028157152235507965,
0.22167320549488068,
-0.2736288905143738,
0.19342434406280518,
0.3901376724243164,
-0.042523276060819626,
0.04836520552635193,
0.7571430802345276,
-0.05074436962604523,
-0.2659056484699249,
0.24853138625621796,
-0.0048074000515043736,
-0.04843263328075409,
0.003759812330827117,
-0.24268625676631927,
0.39601120352745056,
-0.46677571535110474,
-0.2742231786251068,
-0.3258608877658844,
0.2448766976594925,
0.5903979539871216,
-0.1309296190738678,
0.6325705051422119,
0.4319193661212921,
-0.48416322469711304,
0.11930415034294128,
-0.4189215898513794,
0.5990729928016663,
-0.44837260246276855,
0.007188055198639631,
-0.4059935212135315,
-0.6808558702468872,
0.38212084770202637,
-0.08596432209014893,
-0.3765367269515991,
0.7127408385276794,
0.7556810975074768,
0.14321354031562805,
0.5253629088401794,
0.7443235516548157,
-0.2882394790649414,
0.43424859642982483,
-0.16568587720394135,
0.9724629521369934,
-0.38130444288253784,
-0.5360926985740662,
-0.31990572810173035,
-0.5024157762527466,
-0.9192728400230408,
-0.022212786599993706,
0.18361881375312805,
0.30214613676071167,
-0.2099381685256958,
0.31954672932624817,
-0.8142967820167542,
0.5280372500419617,
0.8368567824363708,
0.4418090581893921,
0.1988794058561325,
-0.2338918000459671,
-0.6151419281959534,
0.3677871525287628,
-0.291830450296402,
-0.5915631651878357,
0.9927393794059753,
-0.030457787215709686,
0.30495211482048035,
-0.08230124413967133,
0.6713395118713379,
0.8868584632873535,
0.1937507688999176,
-0.6284501552581787,
0.41361409425735474,
-0.5829516053199768,
-0.6756453514099121,
-0.2525891065597534,
-0.029664646834135056,
-0.6402580738067627,
0.047179996967315674,
-0.31988492608070374,
-0.6942642331123352,
0.784576952457428,
-0.3322705626487732,
-0.8799009919166565,
0.47570037841796875,
-1.1554648876190186,
0.6760125756263733,
-0.1883649230003357,
-0.20415343344211578,
-0.37758585810661316,
-0.7537596821784973,
0.7260518670082092,
-0.30794620513916016,
0.28148016333580017,
-0.15205828845500946,
0.45419612526893616,
0.5322375297546387,
-0.8205655217170715,
0.5109489560127258,
-0.41373783349990845,
0.2841593325138092,
0.545823872089386,
-0.07052666693925858,
0.48194462060928345,
0.3390316069126129,
-0.540576159954071,
-0.19421552121639252,
0.029458777979016304,
-0.3648380637168884,
-0.6792627573013306,
0.635635256767273,
-0.5240867733955383,
-0.4083516299724579,
-0.7031847834587097,
-0.6387137174606323,
0.0020450011361390352,
0.0622321218252182,
0.1718374490737915,
0.4103988707065582,
0.28437235951423645,
0.043524906039237976,
0.12262631952762604,
-0.11688688397407532,
0.740864098072052,
0.32983556389808655,
-0.014903560280799866,
-0.0876828283071518,
0.8647286891937256,
0.2533578872680664,
-0.6146594285964966,
0.2769152820110321,
0.32411837577819824,
-0.4252270460128784,
-0.8801257014274597,
-0.7072193026542664,
-0.11867859959602356,
-0.9789866805076599,
-0.26457613706588745,
-0.5095807909965515,
-0.4619183838367462,
-0.4931564927101135,
-0.48875996470451355,
-0.1036808118224144,
-0.45842084288597107,
0.12918393313884735,
-0.283332884311676,
0.6414411067962646,
1.0395992994308472,
-0.1588219851255417,
0.08504106104373932,
-0.7968055605888367,
0.16280309855937958,
0.06070679798722267,
0.7269485592842102,
-0.014359993860125542,
-0.597615122795105,
-0.43469271063804626,
-0.023203246295452118,
-0.10058295726776123,
-0.24208985269069672,
0.29440706968307495,
0.1634083241224289,
0.27155861258506775,
0.581683874130249,
0.0395394004881382,
0.6330347061157227,
-0.7984880805015564,
0.7268345952033997,
0.2545114755630493,
-0.5838491916656494,
0.721915602684021,
-0.11803852021694183,
-0.3097294867038727,
0.6501815915107727,
0.39220738410949707,
-0.2865690290927887,
-0.23472890257835388,
-0.30979540944099426,
-0.5566701889038086,
0.94697505235672,
-0.1336609125137329,
0.16436506807804108,
0.31118378043174744,
0.6517719030380249,
0.06774350255727768,
0.15352372825145721,
-0.4944130778312683,
0.035182349383831024,
-0.08859341591596603,
-0.3979873061180115,
-0.29636502265930176,
-0.3310045301914215,
0.3247785270214081,
-0.7764489650726318,
0.5144500136375427,
0.24897997081279755,
0.1976192146539688,
0.5191439986228943,
-0.14640188217163086,
0.1337352693080902,
0.11908259242773056,
1.1958760023117065,
0.603851854801178,
-0.4791407287120819,
0.10524909943342209,
0.2542741000652313,
-0.6671950817108154,
0.5867394208908081,
0.23127463459968567,
-0.3385155200958252,
0.0029507458675652742,
0.11264490336179733,
0.7120161056518555,
0.27035510540008545,
-0.6616605520248413,
0.49117541313171387,
-0.38675937056541443,
-0.30980542302131653,
-0.733344554901123,
0.032826103270053864,
-0.11450757831335068,
0.6056414246559143,
0.2729661166667938,
0.5985196232795715,
0.35687100887298584,
-0.28149306774139404,
0.5587469935417175,
-0.00022982961672823876,
-0.6056186556816101,
0.3630017042160034,
0.613586962223053,
0.016793154180049896,
-0.8078944087028503,
0.6795525550842285,
-0.6343395709991455,
-0.7284717559814453,
0.6704601049423218,
0.2441309243440628,
0.651120662689209,
0.20347929000854492,
0.07301964610815048,
0.49826139211654663,
0.05928144231438637,
-0.3328055441379547,
-0.03153372183442116,
-0.07871351391077042,
-0.547429084777832,
-0.28721538186073303,
-1.022287368774414,
-0.4214365482330322,
-0.38463374972343445,
-0.16109183430671692,
0.37128040194511414,
-0.9778149724006653,
0.09929244965314865,
-0.18791840970516205,
0.08970308303833008,
-0.38676515221595764,
0.6340086460113525,
0.5099976658821106,
0.9148496389389038,
-0.26150965690612793,
0.8958572745323181,
0.5667937397956848,
-0.5027090907096863,
-0.870217502117157,
-0.4751684367656708,
-0.14870662987232208,
-0.4527932107448578,
1.1096247434616089,
0.3940173089504242,
-0.2296345978975296,
-0.35989561676979065,
-0.6508976817131042,
-0.742855429649353,
0.7948715686798096,
0.1051390990614891,
-0.8777545690536499,
0.07734033465385437,
0.2681303918361664,
0.7248462438583374,
-0.3126252591609955,
0.06451256573200226,
0.7520254850387573,
0.5500707626342773,
0.16004133224487305,
-0.5288035273551941,
-0.005010104272514582,
-0.5615354180335999,
-0.31942158937454224,
0.23550942540168762,
-0.6174086928367615,
0.62616366147995,
-0.287218302488327,
0.03092053160071373,
-0.41014599800109863,
0.7434240579605103,
-0.0907689705491066,
0.6647276878356934,
0.6699258685112,
0.8333103656768799,
0.9541884064674377,
-0.33046379685401917,
1.4715479612350464,
-0.14206019043922424,
0.31091150641441345,
1.0850286483764648,
-0.1590481698513031,
0.7065437436103821,
0.2542916536331177,
-0.09262807667255402,
0.685958743095398,
0.8299891352653503,
-0.6230344772338867,
0.6196052432060242,
0.4999796450138092,
-0.04495086520910263,
-0.198711559176445,
-0.266720712184906,
0.2127303183078766,
0.7199620604515076,
0.3084051311016083,
-0.20764099061489105,
-0.19342707097530365,
0.17552191019058228,
-0.29363009333610535,
0.3928482234477997,
-0.7647006511688232,
0.6197546720504761,
0.12390615791082382,
-0.5192791819572449,
0.4348674416542053,
0.14418527483940125,
0.8357841372489929,
-0.19980943202972412,
-0.22699633240699768,
-0.07372961938381195,
0.6555965542793274,
-0.46892213821411133,
-0.7963448762893677,
0.6660072207450867,
0.18867075443267822,
-0.3983340859413147,
0.1135222315788269,
0.8309728503227234,
-0.23869095742702484,
-1.1024218797683716,
0.40999093651771545,
-0.2531886398792267,
0.39234206080436707,
-0.007806629873812199,
-0.5935980081558228,
-0.4592542350292206,
-0.4209389388561249,
-0.024038786068558693,
0.18889181315898895,
0.6501959562301636,
-0.3540988862514496,
0.664370059967041,
0.4404488503932953,
-0.00630825012922287,
0.7033884525299072,
0.014270761981606483,
0.644182026386261,
-0.8090102672576904,
-0.4202525317668915,
-0.9476273059844971,
0.524435818195343,
-0.31745991110801697,
-0.27993983030319214,
0.26974257826805115,
0.5662083625793457,
1.0273123979568481,
-0.0025028581731021404,
0.5732389688491821,
-0.3181730806827545,
0.43721193075180054,
-0.6666642427444458,
1.0727331638336182,
-0.5328956842422485,
-0.1974063664674759,
-0.027290547266602516,
-0.23539069294929504,
-0.4960431158542633,
0.45522958040237427,
-0.5584242343902588,
-0.05939221754670143,
0.5570405721664429,
0.7129014730453491,
-0.055501390248537064,
0.12814779579639435,
0.5330533385276794,
-0.09988807141780853,
0.0891563817858696,
0.6629221439361572,
0.8361149430274963,
-0.7275348901748657,
0.634038507938385,
-0.498434454202652,
0.48562994599342346,
-0.45116594433784485,
-0.6193895936012268,
-0.7566576600074768,
-0.29772838950157166,
0.15051892399787903,
-0.2539086639881134,
-0.11250180006027222,
0.8998560309410095,
0.8996802568435669,
-1.4006260633468628,
-0.10474162548780441,
-0.4529680907726288,
0.5081902742385864,
0.24351133406162262,
-0.12974317371845245,
0.7866328954696655,
-0.5637483596801758,
-0.6813564300537109,
0.23164339363574982,
0.14400964975357056,
-0.13690802454948425,
0.12604795396327972,
-0.23342864215373993,
-1.005690097808838,
-0.15461304783821106,
0.48197343945503235,
-0.012441728264093399,
-0.646053671836853,
-0.28327375650405884,
-0.8369200825691223,
-0.43158233165740967,
0.40080416202545166,
0.9620721936225891,
-0.5529265999794006,
0.47396135330200195,
0.18643011152744293,
0.9508414268493652,
0.4550093710422516,
0.13459157943725586,
0.43880560994148254,
-0.5227363705635071,
0.45403435826301575,
0.15133237838745117,
0.6413414478302002,
0.3753902316093445,
-1.033613681793213,
0.6638901233673096,
0.14897197484970093,
-0.5470485687255859,
-0.3710334599018097,
-0.4491930305957794,
-0.9635074734687805,
-0.17815592885017395,
0.631400465965271,
-0.34318938851356506,
-0.5492571592330933,
-0.3226347267627716,
-0.4595494270324707,
0.4291749596595764,
-0.4931638836860657,
0.7452765107154846,
0.7343043088912964,
0.21594633162021637,
-0.2687888443470001,
-0.6784436106681824,
0.6432814598083496,
0.3022400438785553,
-0.38882899284362793,
-0.6127306222915649,
0.16908180713653564,
-0.007912698201835155,
0.6260057687759399,
0.32054176926612854,
-0.16930735111236572,
0.5081282258033752,
-0.07670611143112183,
-0.0858331099152565,
-0.11409229785203934,
-0.13065433502197266,
-0.6065753698348999,
0.5136269927024841,
-0.4158976972103119,
-0.3472282886505127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14113v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14113v2 | On the Affinity, Rationality, and Diversity of Hierarchical Topic Modeling | 2024-01-25T11:47:58 | 2024-02-01T03:47:28 | Xiaobao Wu, Fengjun Pan, Thong Nguyen, Yichao Feng, Chaoqun Liu, Cong-Duy Nguyen, Anh Tuan Luu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hierarchical topic modeling aims to discover latent topics from a corpus and
organize them into a hierarchy to understand documents with desirable semantic
granularity. However, existing work struggles with producing topic hierarchies
of low affinity, rationality, and diversity, which hampers document
understanding. To overcome these challenges, we in this paper propose Transport
Plan and Context-aware Hierarchical Topic Model (TraCo). Instead of early
simple topic dependencies, we propose a transport plan dependency method. It
constrains dependencies to ensure their sparsity and balance, and also
regularizes topic hierarchy building with them. This improves affinity and
diversity of hierarchies. We further propose a context-aware disentangled
decoder. Rather than previously entangled decoding, it distributes different
semantic granularity to topics at different levels by disentangled decoding.
This facilitates the rationality of hierarchies. Experiments on benchmark
datasets demonstrate that our method surpasses state-of-the-art baselines,
effectively improving the affinity, rationality, and diversity of hierarchical
topic modeling with better performance on downstream tasks. | [
-0.6697390079498291,
-0.6548864841461182,
0.44838669896125793,
0.03673623874783516,
-0.2726086378097534,
-0.04347352683544159,
0.27555492520332336,
-0.18580710887908936,
0.4553668200969696,
0.32822686433792114,
-0.5521838665008545,
-0.43377047777175903,
-0.7440972924232483,
-0.30141574144363403,
-0.29499784111976624,
0.8536673784255981,
0.10499834269285202,
-0.46686428785324097,
-0.12364736199378967,
-0.024341294541954994,
-0.5437207818031311,
-0.32856959104537964,
-0.12597526609897614,
-0.10789413005113602,
0.498200386762619,
0.38027423620224,
0.7843710780143738,
0.7773683071136475,
0.3839513659477234,
0.3317447304725647,
-0.740598201751709,
-0.05157880112528801,
-0.5234156250953674,
-0.02081613428890705,
-0.5903764367103577,
-0.17244018614292145,
-0.7071578502655029,
-0.03659290075302124,
0.631743311882019,
0.9692177176475525,
-0.2970507740974426,
-0.41322392225265503,
0.07676875591278076,
0.6456940770149231,
-0.664421021938324,
-0.16894906759262085,
-0.7399706840515137,
0.035717036575078964,
-0.15944184362888336,
-0.5626787543296814,
-0.33873632550239563,
0.31197020411491394,
0.5146827697753906,
-0.8120214939117432,
0.31295764446258545,
-0.054251205176115036,
0.9259455800056458,
0.09496025741100311,
-0.9574873447418213,
-0.3713090121746063,
-0.6561049222946167,
0.8327849507331848,
-0.4052748382091522,
0.23806653916835785,
0.47869473695755005,
0.27124547958374023,
0.011862087063491344,
-0.723217785358429,
-0.2629441022872925,
0.1526222825050354,
-0.282352089881897,
0.11248553544282913,
-0.27744531631469727,
-0.014016455039381981,
0.022183528169989586,
0.42640626430511475,
-0.6962937116622925,
0.03134322911500931,
-0.029780155047774315,
-0.11558845639228821,
0.08052066713571548,
0.4665844142436981,
0.5080832839012146,
-0.3808516263961792,
-0.2500222623348236,
0.2928055226802826,
-0.5405195355415344,
-0.16966693103313446,
0.1095888689160347,
0.17280566692352295,
-0.2573029398918152,
0.2689158022403717,
-0.42958348989486694,
0.5121929049491882,
0.36597442626953125,
-0.21122302114963531,
0.05676228180527687,
-0.3865235447883606,
0.0030983395408838987,
0.01554640382528305,
0.2789243757724762,
0.08701824396848679,
-0.33285126090049744,
-0.35392892360687256,
0.0736345499753952,
-0.013737503439188004,
0.4232116639614105,
-1.0196212530136108,
0.14328612387180328,
0.49363383650779724,
-0.6837971806526184,
-0.19606488943099976,
-0.1998712122440338,
-0.9110315442085266,
-0.034865207970142365,
-0.29781243205070496,
0.09705562889575958,
-0.4640686511993408,
-0.38550448417663574,
0.3709581196308136,
-0.11364123970270157,
0.012863866984844208,
0.6436448693275452,
-1.496019959449768,
0.20237252116203308,
0.8809539675712585,
0.945608377456665,
-0.1737476885318756,
-0.4682360291481018,
-0.4231422543525696,
0.672627866268158,
-0.2788642644882202,
1.0359764099121094,
-0.43106818199157715,
-0.3582979738712311,
-0.13292880356311798,
0.028990421444177628,
0.015947602689266205,
-0.20890505611896515,
0.4744962751865387,
-0.6995907425880432,
0.3787417411804199,
-0.37211617827415466,
-0.4828139841556549,
0.044444579631090164,
0.6026257276535034,
-0.6381192207336426,
0.5543241500854492,
0.08953245729207993,
-1.3302935361862183,
0.3492247462272644,
-0.6162171363830566,
-0.44077974557876587,
-0.034051429480314255,
-0.04571199044585228,
-0.07289028912782669,
-0.0860213115811348,
0.17244362831115723,
0.10061941295862198,
-0.1312997043132782,
0.8946843147277832,
-0.09375,
-0.33259013295173645,
-0.4562160074710846,
-0.2698844373226166,
0.8648433089256287,
0.21399205923080444,
-0.2703559696674347,
0.41512200236320496,
-0.5006167888641357,
-0.48248419165611267,
-0.2916925847530365,
-0.22755742073059082,
-0.7750054001808167,
0.2766198217868805,
-0.1414341926574707,
0.2987454831600189,
0.20729972422122955,
0.04448021203279495,
0.33539459109306335,
-0.5740569233894348,
0.596328854560852,
0.7277008891105652,
0.20760667324066162,
0.9312766194343567,
-0.4514107406139374,
0.2077721208333969,
0.5511316657066345,
-0.09614153206348419,
0.021889036521315575,
-0.5036317110061646,
-0.3367443084716797,
-0.37599560618400574,
0.09130609035491943,
0.31119564175605774,
-0.6466479301452637,
0.8446089625358582,
-0.4296868145465851,
-0.43783023953437805,
-0.0619446225464344,
-0.6837244033813477,
-0.29580816626548767,
0.783593475818634,
0.23097160458564758,
0.0012776890071108937,
-0.2596128284931183,
-0.7933400869369507,
0.23155036568641663,
-0.3165913224220276,
0.036767613142728806,
0.09749053418636322,
0.8323541879653931,
-0.6766215562820435,
0.981921374797821,
-0.4441155791282654,
-0.165432870388031,
-0.13469752669334412,
0.5287455320358276,
0.048242874443531036,
0.6325694918632507,
0.5819429755210876,
-0.9867202639579773,
-0.24397258460521698,
-0.03242984414100647,
-0.5105013847351074,
0.1936449259519577,
-0.13931670784950256,
-0.8196436762809753,
-0.1825530081987381,
0.019916541874408722,
-0.7758693099021912,
0.20004485547542572,
0.12112018465995789,
-0.6323387026786804,
0.2493336945772171,
-0.33315718173980713,
0.30539190769195557,
-1.5319923162460327,
0.1418960690498352,
-0.34996601939201355,
-0.04628455638885498,
-0.7723230123519897,
-0.1599198281764984,
0.051111478358507156,
-0.34283244609832764,
-0.3699071407318115,
0.41586896777153015,
-0.0785563737154007,
-0.051872655749320984,
-0.49814486503601074,
-0.07649483531713486,
0.11861944198608398,
0.47220394015312195,
0.45942285656929016,
0.5827249884605408,
0.737765371799469,
-0.5810196399688721,
-0.2013668268918991,
0.5982440114021301,
-0.011388396844267845,
0.4541916847229004,
-0.6262437701225281,
-0.17095352709293365,
-0.3965021073818207,
0.3142731785774231,
-0.7296055555343628,
-0.08968602865934372,
0.006353401578962803,
-0.05956844240427017,
0.18563315272331238,
-0.34438973665237427,
-0.353201687335968,
0.11888861656188965,
-0.27433204650878906,
0.314859002828598,
0.33411797881126404,
-0.5217032432556152,
0.6464890241622925,
0.845076322555542,
-0.19906224310398102,
-0.6594346165657043,
-0.5156459808349609,
-0.056474603712558746,
-0.5476603507995605,
-0.8394771218299866,
1.0108102560043335,
-0.08465955406427383,
-0.09517692029476166,
0.17012961208820343,
-0.24684885144233704,
-0.39568471908569336,
0.19320090115070343,
0.13822580873966217,
0.08621954172849655,
-0.02579057589173317,
0.1092429831624031,
0.47444280982017517,
-0.3753404915332794,
-0.1124861016869545,
-0.6143229007720947,
0.5240722894668579,
-0.20302195847034454,
0.057519424706697464,
-0.2870975434780121,
0.7242528200149536,
0.8543273210525513,
-0.31845277547836304,
0.7643771171569824,
0.31673914194107056,
-0.552726686000824,
-0.11282142251729965,
0.18625926971435547,
-0.1616172194480896,
-0.49214646220207214,
0.33834308385849,
-0.5313868522644043,
-1.214073657989502,
0.6075868010520935,
-0.22549372911453247,
0.047302164137363434,
0.461581289768219,
0.7464416027069092,
0.023587390780448914,
0.7990461587905884,
0.9093042612075806,
-0.0764104425907135,
0.5249289870262146,
-0.41945359110832214,
0.09690063446760178,
-0.5631839036941528,
-0.010449125431478024,
-0.6768361330032349,
-0.14274069666862488,
-0.9511228799819946,
-0.21029776334762573,
0.19419799745082855,
0.05267941579222679,
-0.2556893229484558,
0.2581632137298584,
-0.5419807434082031,
0.12935127317905426,
0.2311258316040039,
-0.16614733636379242,
0.3997626304626465,
0.19842495024204254,
0.11796553432941437,
-0.11710351705551147,
-0.7285929322242737,
-0.6611586213111877,
0.35187554359436035,
0.4151463508605957,
0.6832687258720398,
0.09457606077194214,
0.6516382098197937,
0.2717716097831726,
-0.09123384207487106,
-0.7030237317085266,
0.5247777700424194,
-0.31824424862861633,
-0.6209707856178284,
-0.4273392856121063,
-0.5042889714241028,
-1.0767967700958252,
0.6321553587913513,
0.061334267258644104,
-0.8166863322257996,
0.880305290222168,
-0.049708858132362366,
0.014591407030820847,
0.3317583501338959,
-0.1730085164308548,
0.9910879731178284,
0.20061901211738586,
-0.3975260555744171,
-0.2988658845424652,
-0.5552335977554321,
0.25105059146881104,
0.13669276237487793,
-0.01456803735345602,
-0.08911117911338806,
-0.2253144532442093,
0.8503730893135071,
-0.4803619682788849,
0.5472396612167358,
-0.017714740708470345,
-0.27447593212127686,
0.2509322464466095,
0.06977451592683792,
0.2996480464935303,
0.3478308618068695,
-0.1606558859348297,
0.0431327223777771,
0.02240213192999363,
-0.5935970544815063,
-0.4024235010147095,
0.7679860591888428,
-0.7866196632385254,
-0.6915547847747803,
-0.4553930163383484,
-1.0915889739990234,
-0.22485029697418213,
0.4670886695384979,
0.417149156332016,
0.48152291774749756,
-0.039149653166532516,
0.14054681360721588,
0.7337884306907654,
-0.018326817080378532,
0.38963648676872253,
0.6870328783988953,
0.22347381711006165,
-0.23389431834220886,
0.8352489471435547,
0.1508086919784546,
0.046998292207717896,
0.9098548293113708,
0.31982138752937317,
-0.23222501575946808,
-0.570330798625946,
-0.1894126981496811,
-0.015179235488176346,
-0.6818939447402954,
0.254768431186676,
-1.0766947269439697,
-0.17056863009929657,
-0.3250074088573456,
-0.5047498345375061,
-0.5025838017463684,
-0.5087321400642395,
-0.33944472670555115,
-0.06429015100002289,
0.07221043854951859,
0.19956430792808533,
-0.07501983642578125,
0.3517214059829712,
-0.6113244891166687,
0.6348138451576233,
0.39788076281547546,
0.04369198530912399,
0.1053447276353836,
-0.6218615770339966,
-0.20955891907215118,
-0.12803435325622559,
-0.5142244100570679,
-0.7814884781837463,
0.5639578104019165,
-0.40300416946411133,
0.6123998165130615,
0.4039267897605896,
0.31672388315200806,
0.6579270362854004,
-0.335944265127182,
0.4395856559276581,
-0.09011053293943405,
-0.9701471328735352,
0.9246858358383179,
-0.67951899766922,
0.2203463464975357,
0.5357241034507751,
0.6697409152984619,
-0.19401592016220093,
-0.46411290764808655,
-0.6706393957138062,
-0.778290867805481,
0.7655292749404907,
0.43805477023124695,
-0.04579547792673111,
-0.007553488947451115,
-0.1261008232831955,
0.20273487269878387,
0.1714659184217453,
-0.5574743151664734,
0.015451586805284023,
-0.32145535945892334,
-0.0033734466414898634,
0.4483751058578491,
-0.40992316603660583,
0.04241929575800896,
-0.15851111710071564,
0.4318664073944092,
0.08966824412345886,
0.17102043330669403,
0.07733991742134094,
0.1552327275276184,
-0.13491393625736237,
0.5761959552764893,
0.474722295999527,
0.7751277089118958,
-0.571422278881073,
0.5742479562759399,
-0.1654496192932129,
-0.5086654424667358,
0.43633365631103516,
0.10429065674543381,
-0.4415614902973175,
0.10660048574209213,
0.4351018965244293,
0.5972881317138672,
-0.06113666296005249,
-0.32385608553886414,
0.10802070796489716,
-0.13013656437397003,
-0.24459218978881836,
0.46799853444099426,
-0.17458267509937286,
0.3176679313182831,
-0.16057458519935608,
0.022403253242373466,
0.08097497373819351,
0.48253703117370605,
-0.6283408403396606,
0.3720099627971649,
0.10642595589160919,
-0.2557166516780853,
-0.09634847193956375,
0.4498947262763977,
0.38762179017066956,
0.07079103589057922,
0.5342040061950684,
-0.17523184418678284,
-0.36276981234550476,
0.7689841389656067,
0.6597428917884827,
0.6429350972175598,
-0.05658750236034393,
0.38684168457984924,
0.3950350284576416,
0.3575739562511444,
-0.06548044085502625,
0.28568601608276367,
-0.22181421518325806,
-0.6267067790031433,
-0.21160100400447845,
-0.25691115856170654,
-0.33809906244277954,
0.05653093382716179,
-0.6196778416633606,
0.12791922688484192,
0.06216917186975479,
-0.025024523958563805,
0.0013019464677199721,
0.17279207706451416,
0.13970834016799927,
0.09928269684314728,
-0.38338884711265564,
0.7997871041297913,
-0.707243025302887,
0.9721624851226807,
0.7565194368362427,
-0.09789992868900299,
-0.34896525740623474,
0.527416467666626,
-0.298398494720459,
-0.06500179320573807,
0.5608466267585754,
0.10361044853925705,
0.0289483442902565,
-0.019093001261353493,
-0.03448560833930969,
-0.7984046339988708,
1.2129801511764526,
0.21695920825004578,
-0.5540552735328674,
-0.2457115203142166,
0.1361946314573288,
0.5097195506095886,
-0.3798174560070038,
0.10017359256744385,
0.13991397619247437,
0.25734633207321167,
0.43304482102394104,
-0.42932406067848206,
-0.012534614652395248,
-0.23528313636779785,
0.2755564749240875,
0.3319285213947296,
-0.339515745639801,
0.9260501861572266,
0.05525808781385422,
-0.3259439766407013,
-0.16144895553588867,
0.5987990498542786,
0.5838884115219116,
0.5524017810821533,
0.46735647320747375,
0.48664650321006775,
0.7212178707122803,
0.11741429567337036,
0.7589718699455261,
-0.3310964107513428,
0.46070384979248047,
0.9934988617897034,
-0.34368667006492615,
0.44595685601234436,
0.48827457427978516,
0.23886463046073914,
0.31260424852371216,
0.7964733839035034,
0.5346212387084961,
1.2056819200515747,
-0.048935018479824066,
-0.07891702651977539,
-0.16240164637565613,
-0.34426063299179077,
-0.572566032409668,
0.17220215499401093,
0.3671269118785858,
0.11901538819074631,
-0.662951648235321,
0.035463519394397736,
-0.23126694560050964,
-0.126114159822464,
-0.27159780263900757,
0.6115949749946594,
-0.11770518124103546,
-0.5313710570335388,
0.6235101222991943,
0.11313693225383759,
0.5220285058021545,
-0.5878861546516418,
0.02859443426132202,
-0.33958977460861206,
-0.18055780231952667,
-0.09661881625652313,
-0.7931987643241882,
0.7186460494995117,
-0.12218069285154343,
-0.6049085855484009,
-0.3441918194293976,
0.8324900269508362,
-0.4233953654766083,
-0.11575017124414444,
0.24157214164733887,
0.507605254650116,
-0.21001562476158142,
0.1547141969203949,
-0.4816393554210663,
-0.1498439460992813,
-0.2201099693775177,
-0.20110926032066345,
0.4961882531642914,
0.891152560710907,
-0.3526747524738312,
0.5136686563491821,
0.2264777272939682,
-0.14682935178279877,
-0.4270516037940979,
-0.09039240330457687,
0.9367042779922485,
-0.6410018801689148,
-1.215470314025879,
-0.7061724662780762,
0.6916645765304565,
0.057952575385570526,
-0.34024158120155334,
0.13758161664009094,
0.5773912072181702,
0.49955520033836365,
-0.11738782376050949,
0.3433499038219452,
-0.04681671783328056,
0.1460495889186859,
-0.4740135371685028,
0.6203888058662415,
-0.6479724049568176,
0.6139299273490906,
-0.1690390557050705,
-0.4446854591369629,
-0.007868309505283833,
0.5835912227630615,
-0.4679342806339264,
-0.2419603168964386,
0.7712159156799316,
0.8123983144760132,
-0.47764697670936584,
0.07551918923854828,
0.2780619263648987,
-0.14037775993347168,
0.42045965790748596,
0.7752980589866638,
1.2224715948104858,
-0.13205043971538544,
0.23601743578910828,
-0.4236498475074768,
-0.3902134299278259,
-0.19464635848999023,
-0.746477484703064,
-0.8244975209236145,
-0.7776985168457031,
-0.450277179479599,
-0.014677639119327068,
0.040805745869874954,
0.14462822675704956,
1.2118613719940186,
-0.594688892364502,
-0.3385528326034546,
-0.5910272598266602,
0.6708390712738037,
-0.009296832606196404,
-0.2814486026763916,
0.6148454546928406,
-0.18707649409770966,
-0.4591755270957947,
0.11249665170907974,
0.5791298747062683,
0.1763429194688797,
0.13411130011081696,
-0.16938503086566925,
-0.3056887090206146,
-0.016989490017294884,
0.6498774290084839,
-0.12713579833507538,
-0.5184963345527649,
0.04311017319560051,
-0.14677520096302032,
-0.5321624875068665,
0.16755403578281403,
0.9101768732070923,
-0.4779772460460663,
-0.043657634407281876,
0.9366641640663147,
0.41080257296562195,
0.6100811958312988,
0.14116212725639343,
0.26942774653434753,
-0.3289547562599182,
0.5549176335334778,
0.324019193649292,
0.4307267665863037,
-0.26692530512809753,
-0.5265805721282959,
0.4549869894981384,
0.26646658778190613,
-0.4846734404563904,
-0.6442599296569824,
0.2598859667778015,
-1.299440860748291,
-0.6841539740562439,
0.6849532723426819,
0.009472939185798168,
-0.13021022081375122,
-0.23182637989521027,
-0.20658761262893677,
0.05501439794898033,
-0.3834891617298126,
0.9024470448493958,
0.3401951491832733,
-0.08142715692520142,
-0.11697173863649368,
-0.37412482500076294,
0.1847187727689743,
0.34314897656440735,
-1.2918001413345337,
0.09244173020124435,
0.40266260504722595,
-0.03949309140443802,
0.4467494785785675,
0.9162148237228394,
-0.15392270684242249,
0.19660638272762299,
0.1862160712480545,
-0.36306044459342957,
0.2637789845466614,
-0.6639575958251953,
0.1594022512435913,
0.4769054353237152,
-0.21811966598033905,
-0.11897590756416321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01708v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01708v2 | Not My Voice! A Taxonomy of Ethical and Safety Harms of Speech Generators | 2024-01-25T11:47:06 | 2024-05-15T15:26:42 | Wiebke Hutiri, Oresiti Papakyriakopoulos, Alice Xiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, eess.AS | The rapid and wide-scale adoption of AI to generate human speech poses a
range of significant ethical and safety risks to society that need to be
addressed. For example, a growing number of speech generation incidents are
associated with swatting attacks in the United States, where anonymous
perpetrators create synthetic voices that call police officers to close down
schools and hospitals, or to violently gain access to innocent citizens' homes.
Incidents like this demonstrate that multimodal generative AI risks and harms
do not exist in isolation, but arise from the interactions of multiple
stakeholders and technical AI systems. In this paper we analyse speech
generation incidents to study how patterns of specific harms arise. We find
that specific harms can be categorised according to the exposure of affected
individuals, that is to say whether they are a subject of, interact with,
suffer due to, or are excluded from speech generation systems. Similarly,
specific harms are also a consequence of the motives of the creators and
deployers of the systems. Based on these insights we propose a conceptual
framework for modelling pathways to ethical and safety harms of AI, which we
use to develop a taxonomy of harms of speech generators. Our relational
approach captures the complexity of risks and harms in sociotechnical AI
systems, and yields a taxonomy that can support appropriate policy
interventions and decision making for the responsible development and release
of speech generation models. | [
-0.17950031161308289,
-0.675305962562561,
0.3213895857334137,
-0.05796893313527107,
0.32708775997161865,
0.324783593416214,
0.22895872592926025,
-0.612032949924469,
0.018083782866597176,
0.7297292351722717,
-0.6646758913993835,
0.030931992456316948,
-0.4794095456600189,
-0.03156967833638191,
-0.6474538445472717,
1.1086513996124268,
0.7138417959213257,
-0.1725034862756729,
-0.12752561271190643,
-0.08400101214647293,
-0.30040356516838074,
-0.6913632154464722,
-0.6901686787605286,
0.2451474666595459,
0.749264657497406,
0.1488102674484253,
0.6777137517929077,
0.46840018033981323,
0.2341054081916809,
0.4468778073787689,
-0.13353542983531952,
-0.38957545161247253,
-0.2719838321208954,
0.2763301134109497,
-0.18770310282707214,
-0.319841206073761,
-0.09943380951881409,
0.32690197229385376,
0.3190525472164154,
0.5416445732116699,
-0.17117784917354584,
0.4907775819301605,
0.025769870728254318,
0.2710740864276886,
-0.6022977232933044,
-0.03370498865842819,
-0.6275625228881836,
0.08482221513986588,
-0.3379965126514435,
-0.29463911056518555,
-0.5642117857933044,
-0.5678727626800537,
0.03577572479844093,
-0.24378752708435059,
0.04635530710220337,
-0.06708747893571854,
0.38310813903808594,
0.4916791021823883,
-0.3512967526912689,
-0.44003233313560486,
-0.8571653366088867,
0.82306307554245,
-0.44403883814811707,
0.05885367467999458,
0.1303313672542572,
0.3974936902523041,
-0.03397441282868385,
-0.5491881966590881,
-0.7659775018692017,
-0.18387530744075775,
0.07130918651819229,
0.10080567002296448,
-0.5890296101570129,
0.28623056411743164,
0.3557955026626587,
-0.17623141407966614,
-0.5377094745635986,
0.19530199468135834,
-0.578734815120697,
-0.20626914501190186,
1.0052785873413086,
0.2943088710308075,
0.7785013914108276,
-0.6720489859580994,
-0.34059324860572815,
-0.13178125023841858,
-0.7259300351142883,
0.11466285586357117,
1.1131983995437622,
0.5021569728851318,
-0.1874939203262329,
0.5577191114425659,
0.30293363332748413,
0.4958924949169159,
-0.13160833716392517,
-0.33262723684310913,
0.1980302929878235,
-0.1728082150220871,
-0.08072132617235184,
0.5810692310333252,
0.9522138237953186,
0.09340861439704895,
0.27604952454566956,
-0.0649246871471405,
0.23446300625801086,
0.08314477652311325,
0.628215491771698,
-0.32490405440330505,
0.24198411405086517,
0.21785074472427368,
-0.5044095516204834,
-1.045165777206421,
-0.2293415069580078,
-0.8206214904785156,
-0.6957559585571289,
-0.1440591812133789,
0.4454413950443268,
-0.26875707507133484,
-0.5782502293586731,
-0.4814176857471466,
-0.34916597604751587,
0.19296421110630035,
-0.41414332389831543,
-0.7302119731903076,
0.055108100175857544,
0.5888580083847046,
0.6336821913719177,
0.4098000228404999,
-0.09444894641637802,
-0.4827851951122284,
0.2563449442386627,
-0.4264993965625763,
0.47617512941360474,
-0.5568550825119019,
-0.751541793346405,
0.04229581356048584,
-0.2964020371437073,
-0.09352537989616394,
-0.6520168781280518,
0.6112328767776489,
-0.0025481481570750475,
0.14036449790000916,
0.06788245588541031,
-0.13625985383987427,
-0.259776771068573,
-0.3652346730232239,
-0.17234240472316742,
0.3799249231815338,
-0.06737354397773743,
-0.5775770545005798,
0.3402808606624603,
-0.8914811611175537,
-0.5688692331314087,
0.32683834433555603,
-0.5556572079658508,
-0.23730739951133728,
-0.13104191422462463,
-0.4987359642982483,
0.41270574927330017,
-0.19184519350528717,
0.539239764213562,
-0.21722334623336792,
0.03854008764028549,
0.10604926198720932,
-0.5038655400276184,
1.2789989709854126,
0.3481358289718628,
-0.5855449438095093,
0.3658851385116577,
-0.7719659805297852,
0.17102880775928497,
-0.09820407629013062,
-0.03909124433994293,
-0.3381590247154236,
0.20757248997688293,
0.3742503225803375,
0.5933266282081604,
-0.17242315411567688,
-0.5716875791549683,
-0.6090134978294373,
-0.3933253288269043,
0.7284151911735535,
1.0484588146209717,
0.36172154545783997,
0.3011135160923004,
-0.5928055047988892,
0.5635403990745544,
0.13613583147525787,
0.5479992628097534,
0.053089503198862076,
-0.7013559937477112,
-0.2728487551212311,
-0.006592829246073961,
-0.026856575161218643,
0.6570010185241699,
-0.5649627447128296,
0.6441382169723511,
-0.22965167462825775,
-0.6196034550666809,
-0.517365038394928,
-0.36248522996902466,
0.5375590920448303,
0.8029728531837463,
0.16407360136508942,
0.26015251874923706,
-0.48005548119544983,
-1.0834589004516602,
-0.4551885426044464,
-0.7129592299461365,
-0.03595824912190437,
0.49837321043014526,
0.30097976326942444,
-0.29098549485206604,
1.0013937950134277,
0.11331524699926376,
-0.3546143174171448,
-0.09478829056024551,
0.46074017882347107,
-0.3959351181983948,
0.7543035745620728,
0.46951285004615784,
-0.8967123627662659,
-0.19891871511936188,
-0.28259414434432983,
-0.8675686717033386,
-0.24786415696144104,
-0.44439607858657837,
0.16524727642536163,
0.05639684572815895,
0.4627997875213623,
-0.5326590538024902,
0.4541560411453247,
0.46477749943733215,
-0.018085535615682602,
0.5017575025558472,
0.29352375864982605,
-0.2898091673851013,
-1.251192331314087,
0.05935240164399147,
-0.1645115315914154,
0.1965845227241516,
-0.8981744050979614,
-0.00031044523348100483,
-0.5473892688751221,
-0.4870733618736267,
-0.7001766562461853,
0.17003148794174194,
0.13672134280204773,
-0.04552845284342766,
0.08065489679574966,
-0.06612329930067062,
-0.2666228711605072,
0.13702388107776642,
-0.1361290067434311,
0.7725138068199158,
0.5321109890937805,
-0.6247555613517761,
0.10461597889661789,
0.4285133481025696,
-0.16001327335834503,
0.6302067637443542,
-0.5529870986938477,
0.08029871433973312,
-0.19789576530456543,
-0.08181985467672348,
-0.4320164918899536,
-0.32948586344718933,
0.4849773943424225,
-0.7674762010574341,
0.06093568354845047,
-0.04114464670419693,
-0.27858951687812805,
-0.010550196282565594,
-0.1895064264535904,
0.2855055630207062,
0.5733197927474976,
-0.32330819964408875,
0.5774077773094177,
0.9604320526123047,
-0.5587469339370728,
-0.6394223570823669,
-0.7096278071403503,
0.4510558545589447,
-0.6344982981681824,
-0.8062613010406494,
-0.001957172527909279,
0.08973497152328491,
-0.6800078749656677,
-0.11194568127393723,
0.0805264338850975,
-0.0037565133534371853,
0.24052894115447998,
0.8181759715080261,
-0.32181891798973083,
0.0778227373957634,
0.32124748826026917,
0.15630687773227692,
-0.22719979286193848,
0.3653367757797241,
0.33913615345954895,
0.21742163598537445,
0.060758378356695175,
-0.020196525380015373,
-0.4695512056350708,
0.9333614110946655,
0.6126494407653809,
-0.2064083069562912,
0.4774267077445984,
0.37920019030570984,
-0.4939149022102356,
-0.09731743484735489,
-0.3200131058692932,
-0.13479430973529816,
-0.5694101452827454,
0.24845249950885773,
0.03076193854212761,
-0.635054349899292,
0.17741817235946655,
-0.12974488735198975,
0.2146657556295395,
0.35071900486946106,
0.4485359787940979,
-0.1984681934118271,
1.1831203699111938,
0.5690720677375793,
-0.10785971581935883,
0.37870386242866516,
-0.0008950104238465428,
0.6681786775588989,
-0.5396673083305359,
-0.39589419960975647,
-0.6892527937889099,
-0.02249189466238022,
-0.9803116917610168,
-0.22518807649612427,
0.6099340319633484,
-0.36864081025123596,
-0.4381249248981476,
0.10325487703084946,
-0.5600268840789795,
0.14738476276397705,
0.6467830538749695,
-0.3555935323238373,
0.13336902856826782,
-0.09387146681547165,
0.22688698768615723,
0.06824791431427002,
-0.6894699931144714,
-0.9707912802696228,
0.6631589531898499,
0.19884850084781647,
0.6421213150024414,
0.4653627574443817,
1.0277466773986816,
0.45760560035705566,
0.04346829652786255,
-0.657375156879425,
0.5582515597343445,
0.12621961534023285,
-0.9873319864273071,
-0.4585721790790558,
-0.5398187041282654,
-1.076779842376709,
-0.04333481192588806,
-0.19737014174461365,
-0.7751970887184143,
0.41102030873298645,
-0.057162217795848846,
-0.5714514851570129,
0.21148157119750977,
-0.6236770749092102,
0.5826902985572815,
-0.30965712666511536,
-0.14093078672885895,
-0.32015275955200195,
-1.0542199611663818,
0.3483850955963135,
-0.11862075328826904,
0.5352961421012878,
-0.3723750710487366,
0.16202615201473236,
0.8685482740402222,
-0.38940486311912537,
1.029941201210022,
-0.17433808743953705,
0.07151219993829727,
0.7067394852638245,
0.024715954437851906,
0.08747289329767227,
-0.07076101750135422,
-0.034192364662885666,
0.1893124282360077,
0.07599318027496338,
0.03249185159802437,
-0.17532220482826233,
0.7309780120849609,
-0.8255074620246887,
-0.56905198097229,
-0.5683785080909729,
-0.304627925157547,
-0.38908639550209045,
0.2930769622325897,
0.5497125387191772,
0.29201480746269226,
-0.3118504285812378,
-0.08461147546768188,
0.28274300694465637,
-0.535706102848053,
0.6778439879417419,
0.22839957475662231,
0.3972129821777344,
-0.05999382957816124,
1.2221198081970215,
0.30787524580955505,
0.10405317693948746,
-0.257703572511673,
0.23867559432983398,
-0.3883945643901825,
-0.2915824353694916,
-0.34865838289260864,
-0.1440502554178238,
-0.5972354412078857,
-0.2083962857723236,
-0.6445381045341492,
-0.3732089698314667,
-0.6387139558792114,
0.04135379567742348,
-0.021936191245913506,
-0.24088174104690552,
-0.398283988237381,
-0.3445347547531128,
0.22650589048862457,
0.9416671395301819,
-0.4185072183609009,
0.25712472200393677,
-0.8257824778556824,
0.2022293508052826,
0.5010294318199158,
0.18888543546199799,
-0.18485236167907715,
0.020920101553201675,
0.33156803250312805,
0.17685003578662872,
-0.5678063035011292,
-0.9610676169395447,
0.3627440333366394,
0.3358575999736786,
0.5904838442802429,
0.3790631890296936,
0.4227643609046936,
0.6338839530944824,
-0.7398458123207092,
0.9771542549133301,
0.47144412994384766,
-1.0750740766525269,
0.5334587693214417,
-0.41877540946006775,
-0.384761244058609,
0.33758142590522766,
0.4275916516780853,
-0.719284176826477,
-0.5599093437194824,
-0.9704283475875854,
-1.048861026763916,
0.62284916639328,
0.5060179233551025,
0.6245726346969604,
-0.20738793909549713,
0.031066425144672394,
-0.17153505980968475,
0.3721714913845062,
-0.755987823009491,
-0.3250139355659485,
-0.3151666820049286,
-0.14808820188045502,
-0.16091831028461456,
-0.16958564519882202,
-0.503221869468689,
0.1858191341161728,
0.6352738738059998,
0.07680398970842361,
0.3726133704185486,
-0.03543548285961151,
0.11515109986066818,
-0.44298386573791504,
0.39924535155296326,
0.5425534248352051,
0.20458173751831055,
0.27415475249290466,
-0.05518225207924843,
-0.364785760641098,
-0.22282321751117706,
0.3907124996185303,
-0.10281965136528015,
-0.09530838578939438,
-0.0029268458019942045,
0.3548072278499603,
0.527504563331604,
-0.05156097561120987,
-0.8351066708564758,
0.6024994850158691,
0.10858429968357086,
-0.09849676489830017,
-0.6958828568458557,
0.1987704187631607,
-0.22465525567531586,
0.2721747159957886,
0.22789974510669708,
0.4948081970214844,
0.6288186311721802,
-0.5930718779563904,
0.3858765959739685,
0.48077279329299927,
-0.4412992298603058,
-0.2539885640144348,
0.8225735425949097,
0.4529580771923065,
-0.639239490032196,
0.3181595504283905,
0.07225045561790466,
-0.058255307376384735,
0.707961916923523,
0.15575532615184784,
1.1640355587005615,
-0.4968453049659729,
0.49124062061309814,
0.19304701685905457,
0.48271334171295166,
0.514293372631073,
0.21515533328056335,
0.25177010893821716,
-0.5299530625343323,
-0.058017484843730927,
-0.5202149152755737,
-0.3841909170150757,
0.293825626373291,
-0.66123366355896,
-0.12570905685424805,
-0.8362593054771423,
-0.5262606739997864,
0.4120467007160187,
-0.5764432549476624,
-0.10271014273166656,
0.17628778517246246,
0.4285122752189636,
0.3220337927341461,
-0.9170475602149963,
0.2785688638687134,
0.20096029341220856,
-0.3733772337436676,
-0.80301833152771,
0.2476954311132431,
0.3599635660648346,
-0.4505949914455414,
0.46120718121528625,
0.09350351989269257,
-0.404737263917923,
-0.002501423005014658,
-0.4094632863998413,
-0.7297639846801758,
0.6310211420059204,
0.5629257559776306,
-0.4430679678916931,
0.03786662593483925,
0.3938387930393219,
0.6194268465042114,
-0.13981039822101593,
-0.2438240647315979,
0.14591452479362488,
0.4350070357322693,
-0.14923739433288574,
-0.8667510151863098,
-0.05156608670949936,
-0.20745694637298584,
0.0641508549451828,
0.13021759688854218,
-0.7392566204071045,
0.7593333125114441,
-0.330828458070755,
-0.48137399554252625,
0.17793980240821838,
-0.04262705519795418,
-0.09877829998731613,
0.31146085262298584,
0.42688804864883423,
0.24132393300533295,
0.727971613407135,
0.1439417004585266,
1.08333158493042,
-0.17436820268630981,
-0.1580134481191635,
0.8975368738174438,
-0.290603369474411,
0.5099305510520935,
0.4705197513103485,
0.03858358412981033,
0.3186107873916626,
0.4108656048774719,
0.14098474383354187,
0.42745551466941833,
0.39486587047576904,
-0.5904805064201355,
-0.1504652053117752,
-0.5033692717552185,
-0.469550758600235,
0.7655479311943054,
0.46239572763442993,
-0.6185446977615356,
-0.06534470617771149,
0.26659858226776123,
-0.1428440660238266,
0.13513725996017456,
-0.11113951355218887,
0.9920328259468079,
0.18803715705871582,
-0.3416668772697449,
0.29941412806510925,
0.10681348294019699,
0.372305691242218,
-0.37113550305366516,
-0.04130161553621292,
0.4109779894351959,
-0.2741788923740387,
-0.3660154640674591,
-0.4780862629413605,
0.7088423371315002,
0.0932299867272377,
0.032452136278152466,
-0.3462631106376648,
0.4253193438053131,
0.03923386335372925,
-0.4690840244293213,
0.39899942278862,
0.5643108487129211,
0.1251872032880783,
0.16281208395957947,
-0.8663341999053955,
-0.22280672192573547,
-0.18183380365371704,
0.06383852660655975,
0.30968177318573,
-0.10347868502140045,
-0.27325311303138733,
0.8551650643348694,
0.8587574362754822,
0.023876037448644638,
0.4609758257865906,
0.010048429481685162,
0.49896758794784546,
-0.6008469462394714,
-0.5626683831214905,
-0.7166714072227478,
0.4332975745201111,
0.0629507303237915,
-0.47560983896255493,
0.4356469213962555,
0.33769530057907104,
0.4350970387458801,
0.029312748461961746,
1.2895808219909668,
-0.36367395520210266,
0.5341633558273315,
-0.07055582106113434,
1.1286981105804443,
-0.3316803276538849,
0.0716686099767685,
-0.5023562908172607,
-0.49876439571380615,
-0.26498398184776306,
0.5457406044006348,
-0.2511788606643677,
0.008439295925199986,
0.021176913753151894,
0.7330197691917419,
0.4190829396247864,
0.14921565353870392,
0.49929410219192505,
0.3668258786201477,
0.40593475103378296,
0.0816059559583664,
1.1464844942092896,
-0.164025217294693,
0.7280569076538086,
-0.30345210433006287,
-0.05094124376773834,
0.09213893115520477,
-0.5873161554336548,
-0.49346572160720825,
-0.6654430031776428,
-0.3410598039627075,
-0.17420896887779236,
0.01968076266348362,
0.7226613163948059,
0.759221076965332,
-0.6308003067970276,
-0.2911563217639923,
-0.08732502907514572,
0.23820607364177704,
-0.05083427578210831,
-0.27989646792411804,
-0.12641510367393494,
-0.28132712841033936,
-0.6186543703079224,
0.528994083404541,
0.24623501300811768,
0.10244520753622055,
-0.14704374969005585,
0.05559530109167099,
0.014398012310266495,
0.3467922806739807,
0.6530317068099976,
0.39620277285575867,
-0.8447482585906982,
-0.5600534081459045,
-0.40338653326034546,
0.027809476479887962,
-0.13887140154838562,
0.5751198530197144,
-0.5743276476860046,
0.42278245091438293,
0.0954810082912445,
0.43029388785362244,
-0.42529916763305664,
-0.14851394295692444,
0.46405351161956787,
-0.9871562123298645,
0.23597174882888794,
0.8419246077537537,
0.04291411116719246,
0.0999768078327179,
-0.7809062600135803,
0.4049067497253418,
0.028345802798867226,
-0.4002332389354706,
-1.1813342571258545,
0.5445852279663086,
-0.6971914768218994,
-0.08457624912261963,
0.8954006433486938,
0.08847839385271072,
0.08804206550121307,
-0.3664005696773529,
-0.17791883647441864,
0.3960818946361542,
-0.3736070394515991,
0.9276975393295288,
-0.005570815876126289,
-0.3483653962612152,
-0.025659287348389626,
-0.5386688709259033,
0.9088338613510132,
0.09565002471208572,
-0.6796196103096008,
0.11917499452829361,
0.5547346472740173,
0.27334916591644287,
0.5792562365531921,
0.26856565475463867,
-0.31489232182502747,
0.3145020306110382,
0.20227709412574768,
-0.01881558634340763,
0.136659637093544,
-0.39075154066085815,
-0.44141173362731934,
0.3546202480792999,
-0.11796608567237854,
-0.22192279994487762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14109v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14109v2 | CompactifAI: Extreme Compression of Large Language Models using Quantum-Inspired Tensor Networks | 2024-01-25T11:45:21 | 2024-05-13T10:48:36 | Andrei Tomut, Saeed S. Jahromi, Abhijoy Sarkar, Uygar Kurt, Sukhbinder Singh, Faysal Ishtiaq, Cesar Muñoz, Prabdeep Singh Bajaj, Ali Elborady, Gianni del Bimbo, Mehrazin Alizadeh, David Montero, Pablo Martin-Ramiro, Muhammad Ibrahim, Oussama Tahiri Alaoui, John Malcolm, Samuel Mugel, Roman Orus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, quant-ph | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and LlaMA are advancing rapidly
in generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), but their immense size poses
significant challenges, such as huge training and inference costs, substantial
energy demands, and limitations for on-site deployment. Traditional compression
methods such as pruning, distillation, and low-rank approximation focus on
reducing the effective number of neurons in the network, while quantization
focuses on reducing the numerical precision of individual weights to reduce the
model size while keeping the number of neurons fixed. While these compression
methods have been relatively successful in practice, there is no compelling
reason to believe that truncating the number of neurons is an optimal strategy.
In this context, this paper introduces CompactifAI, an innovative LLM
compression approach using quantum-inspired Tensor Networks that focuses on the
model's correlation space instead, allowing for a more controlled, refined and
interpretable model compression. Our method is versatile and can be implemented
with - or on top of - other compression techniques. As a benchmark, we
demonstrate that a combination of CompactifAI with quantization allows to
reduce a 93% the memory size of LlaMA 7B, reducing also 70% the number of
parameters, accelerating 50% the training and 25% the inference times of the
model, and just with a small accuracy drop of 2% - 3%, going much beyond of
what is achievable today by other compression techniques. Our methods also
allow to perform a refined layer sensitivity profiling, showing that deeper
layers tend to be more suitable for tensor network compression, which is
compatible with recent observations on the ineffectiveness of those layers for
LLM performance. Our results imply that standard LLMs are, in fact, heavily
overparametrized, and do not need to be large at all. | [
-0.2890615165233612,
-0.7481518983840942,
0.4313569664955139,
0.2310987412929535,
-0.5476672053337097,
0.24845831096172333,
-0.4935145080089569,
-0.28469565510749817,
0.35584041476249695,
0.18151532113552094,
-0.3553457260131836,
-0.30887657403945923,
-0.620720624923706,
0.045136261731386185,
-0.4350852072238922,
0.5128822326660156,
0.10722730308771133,
-0.13673731684684753,
0.061186615377664566,
-0.20223645865917206,
-0.2566043436527252,
-0.23110240697860718,
-0.7699477672576904,
-0.31376969814300537,
0.4199315011501312,
0.2110351175069809,
0.9995659589767456,
0.6927589774131775,
0.42571738362312317,
0.38987699151039124,
-0.4907439053058624,
0.24745482206344604,
-0.6186224222183228,
-0.014378719963133335,
0.41639193892478943,
-0.7982246279716492,
-0.06228457763791084,
-0.4394271671772003,
0.9476397037506104,
0.45882469415664673,
-0.41686007380485535,
0.0998389795422554,
-0.1347748190164566,
0.6976000070571899,
-0.8238982558250427,
0.013539450243115425,
-0.3546192944049835,
0.37943124771118164,
-0.09240797907114029,
-0.1936480849981308,
-0.18478600680828094,
-0.24296477437019348,
-0.21893104910850525,
-0.6581408381462097,
0.11016639322042465,
0.0916426032781601,
0.7088952660560608,
0.5620256662368774,
-0.40329036116600037,
0.1989246904850006,
-0.901272714138031,
0.8010431528091431,
-0.6705236434936523,
0.38965702056884766,
0.07002110779285431,
0.25290361046791077,
-0.2303604632616043,
-0.5699682831764221,
-0.7599294781684875,
-0.09361401200294495,
0.13784362375736237,
0.24893859028816223,
-0.4698905944824219,
0.15948976576328278,
0.3017633259296417,
0.4576108455657959,
-0.7780466675758362,
0.35924264788627625,
-0.27143704891204834,
0.12989534437656403,
0.5644068121910095,
0.012665827758610249,
0.256494402885437,
-0.00009520355524728075,
-0.33107706904411316,
-0.5114638209342957,
-0.8649377226829529,
-0.22299888730049133,
0.30026113986968994,
-0.12474724650382996,
-0.08581096678972244,
0.38108351826667786,
-0.3460324704647064,
0.4804750084877014,
-0.27364370226860046,
-0.11794187128543854,
-0.1339133083820343,
0.0436120480298996,
-0.41088253259658813,
0.19809839129447937,
1.2678155899047852,
0.1138385534286499,
0.15155839920043945,
-0.2810947299003601,
-0.2556881904602051,
0.13205964863300323,
0.013028920628130436,
-0.9516680240631104,
-0.3512797951698303,
0.41384240984916687,
-0.6217910051345825,
-0.31042784452438354,
-0.2705402076244354,
-0.5651047229766846,
-0.37671956419944763,
-0.2216402143239975,
0.5143682360649109,
-0.5080728530883789,
-0.27473923563957214,
0.22970984876155853,
-0.14320893585681915,
0.1768709123134613,
0.25305673480033875,
-0.8626349568367004,
0.3631756901741028,
0.6356648206710815,
1.0369590520858765,
0.1686667650938034,
-0.10513870418071747,
-0.26579636335372925,
0.23658058047294617,
-0.3517957329750061,
0.8156821727752686,
-0.3756066858768463,
-0.49936971068382263,
-0.24292509257793427,
-0.5350544452667236,
0.2809537947177887,
-0.6643583178520203,
0.6726652383804321,
-0.536636471748352,
-0.4118763208389282,
0.16198322176933289,
-0.32379117608070374,
-0.17663031816482544,
0.09571785479784012,
-0.8354406356811523,
0.5678187608718872,
0.02945702336728573,
-0.4734135866165161,
-0.17130401730537415,
-0.40995895862579346,
-0.43172743916511536,
0.19534175097942352,
-0.26396605372428894,
-0.5120602250099182,
0.4507591426372528,
0.4156639575958252,
0.6469690203666687,
-0.834677517414093,
0.47487521171569824,
-0.2197224199771881,
-0.4796110987663269,
0.35263779759407043,
-0.5420681834220886,
0.7544909119606018,
0.47158506512641907,
-0.20763364434242249,
0.2342161238193512,
-0.7760229110717773,
0.040548115968704224,
0.48012402653694153,
-0.208060622215271,
-0.22536121308803558,
-0.27457094192504883,
-0.09720629453659058,
-0.12112803012132645,
0.12652941048145294,
-0.5455835461616516,
0.26437827944755554,
-0.18876585364341736,
1.1204488277435303,
0.7749919891357422,
-0.19202929735183716,
0.4538675546646118,
-0.44733360409736633,
0.4404129385948181,
-0.1578349769115448,
0.44650307297706604,
0.18012617528438568,
-0.2609195113182068,
-0.9183281660079956,
-0.46844419836997986,
0.4406569004058838,
0.3924921751022339,
-0.7027348875999451,
0.5392324328422546,
-0.8004094958305359,
-0.6930738091468811,
-0.3991844356060028,
0.15279771387577057,
0.23677197098731995,
0.004784039221704006,
0.11941736936569214,
-0.1860569417476654,
-0.5329017043113708,
-0.925888180732727,
0.030097460374236107,
-0.2503940463066101,
-0.055904362350702286,
0.12229101359844208,
0.40818196535110474,
-0.19282855093479156,
0.6638690829277039,
-0.4563978314399719,
-0.21581685543060303,
-0.06783716380596161,
-0.012173647992312908,
0.2017725259065628,
0.7490097284317017,
0.09079160541296005,
-1.1806273460388184,
-0.1193460151553154,
-0.11082720756530762,
-0.6991457343101501,
0.2631019055843353,
-0.24626755714416504,
-0.11384357511997223,
-0.3345831036567688,
0.27208325266838074,
-1.1455844640731812,
0.1762838214635849,
0.7759740352630615,
0.09773547947406769,
0.38919925689697266,
-0.003271735506132245,
-0.07824605703353882,
-1.1575273275375366,
0.04135068878531456,
0.03370853513479233,
-0.27367451786994934,
-0.4580487310886383,
0.5729053020477295,
0.01310733426362276,
-0.33738619089126587,
-0.2639862895011902,
0.4501785933971405,
-0.2858954668045044,
0.1490006446838379,
-0.11900679767131805,
0.020589083433151245,
0.04060087352991104,
0.563421905040741,
-0.08221162855625153,
0.7376561760902405,
0.38472840189933777,
-0.4938125014305115,
0.6319198608398438,
0.3868567943572998,
-0.4143458604812622,
0.05654231458902359,
-0.9024558663368225,
0.11345911026000977,
-0.04662327095866203,
0.5658271908760071,
-0.7705767154693604,
-0.08828386664390564,
0.023600587621331215,
-0.31205078959465027,
0.48039767146110535,
0.03583694249391556,
-0.9142286777496338,
-0.11581659317016602,
-0.45522958040237427,
0.6607959270477295,
0.78982013463974,
-0.7275981307029724,
0.8571933507919312,
0.20779235661029816,
0.20187987387180328,
-0.4739728569984436,
-1.0730477571487427,
0.282120019197464,
-0.4809732735157013,
-0.6409711241722107,
0.6211620569229126,
-0.3535667657852173,
-0.07655132561922073,
0.029131850227713585,
-0.10085786879062653,
0.039807312190532684,
0.313081830739975,
0.24553780257701874,
0.08414659649133682,
-0.2639295756816864,
0.06802938133478165,
0.19546760618686676,
0.046254001557826996,
-0.2165229320526123,
-0.3858500123023987,
0.6955798864364624,
-0.2214580774307251,
0.1059202328324318,
-0.7023131847381592,
0.3683185875415802,
0.31029826402664185,
-0.17087103426456451,
0.8712345361709595,
0.7381709218025208,
-0.29785415530204773,
-0.19517090916633606,
-0.5623622536659241,
-0.11021476238965988,
-0.512850284576416,
0.1483364999294281,
-0.4401150941848755,
-1.2657335996627808,
0.45621412992477417,
-0.5455588698387146,
-0.1420632153749466,
0.31966784596443176,
0.3389105498790741,
0.2591589689254761,
1.0466790199279785,
0.5619335770606995,
-0.05911412462592125,
0.547826886177063,
-0.5962346792221069,
0.3909669518470764,
-1.1322569847106934,
0.06222451478242874,
-0.47398412227630615,
-0.4870409071445465,
-0.6828774213790894,
-0.3444804549217224,
0.37151792645454407,
0.47668176889419556,
-0.3593875467777252,
0.343158483505249,
-0.6578510999679565,
0.5736098885536194,
0.6041821241378784,
0.34196406602859497,
0.10745175927877426,
0.025258157402276993,
0.2242426872253418,
0.606134831905365,
-0.9995478391647339,
-0.14790739119052887,
1.019856572151184,
0.27451321482658386,
0.6807824969291687,
0.5829633474349976,
0.8203771710395813,
-0.02631380222737789,
0.0314863920211792,
-1.0358219146728516,
0.6167234182357788,
-0.17093928158283234,
-0.07304668426513672,
-0.3531305193901062,
-0.915905237197876,
-0.9425960183143616,
0.16939538717269897,
-0.37267908453941345,
-0.6674959063529968,
0.22764433920383453,
-0.13509653508663177,
-0.7383638024330139,
0.36188796162605286,
-0.7956407070159912,
0.2870815396308899,
0.051214657723903656,
-0.20596759021282196,
-0.3044308125972748,
-0.6334671974182129,
0.5249395370483398,
-0.09949509054422379,
0.09576045721769333,
0.03117179311811924,
-0.08223553001880646,
0.8430915474891663,
-0.47469577193260193,
0.8881779909133911,
0.28550952672958374,
-0.024428635835647583,
0.29259124398231506,
0.27029940485954285,
0.5933226943016052,
0.18272660672664642,
0.07778728008270264,
0.31234505772590637,
0.07943201065063477,
-0.590286135673523,
-0.9385716915130615,
0.8454157710075378,
-1.0805473327636719,
-0.6975781321525574,
-0.03907168284058571,
-0.5882387161254883,
-0.13152649998664856,
0.16086889803409576,
0.2540356516838074,
0.5825209617614746,
0.13370490074157715,
0.3502722382545471,
0.833797812461853,
-0.20347873866558075,
0.37777623534202576,
0.03511996939778328,
0.1422058790922165,
-0.6234311461448669,
0.9908317923545837,
0.02328682504594326,
-0.016215797513723373,
0.7800830006599426,
0.5943660736083984,
-0.02419745735824108,
-0.785385012626648,
-0.3949262797832489,
0.35945796966552734,
-0.7287570238113403,
-0.5969945788383484,
-0.4733027517795563,
-0.26627811789512634,
-0.6455637216567993,
-0.11876047402620316,
-0.4370407462120056,
-0.6914201378822327,
-0.18356584012508392,
0.19401371479034424,
0.3190515339374542,
0.6154811382293701,
-0.009537058882415295,
0.7348559498786926,
-0.9313761591911316,
0.28093066811561584,
0.46151986718177795,
0.18187254667282104,
0.26213255524635315,
-0.3588188588619232,
-0.1366797387599945,
-0.23490680754184723,
-0.2840622067451477,
-0.33141574263572693,
0.4094119071960449,
0.4495052397251129,
0.19420018792152405,
0.5126972198486328,
0.21247713267803192,
0.79996258020401,
-0.4387492835521698,
0.6857429146766663,
0.36739757657051086,
-0.8247700333595276,
0.3377401530742645,
-0.1050725132226944,
0.49207189679145813,
0.09700775891542435,
0.5003176927566528,
-0.2474455088376999,
-0.030609332025051117,
-0.733127236366272,
-0.659555971622467,
0.1832265853881836,
0.3664887547492981,
0.2721911370754242,
0.057779256254434586,
0.5795699954032898,
-0.22454939782619476,
0.14157621562480927,
-0.47603344917297363,
-0.14019349217414856,
0.03373851254582405,
-0.5582713484764099,
-0.15821650624275208,
-0.3950065076351166,
-0.3544636368751526,
0.008484162390232086,
0.5913810133934021,
-0.25165095925331116,
0.6155776977539062,
0.289455771446228,
-0.0008742446079850197,
-0.0330711267888546,
0.1338324397802353,
0.6333196759223938,
0.3204290568828583,
0.047459181398153305,
0.12361209839582443,
0.06954365223646164,
-0.44302037358283997,
0.10473828762769699,
0.050793375819921494,
-0.06768421828746796,
-0.3676232099533081,
0.5079551339149475,
1.048423409461975,
0.09871451556682587,
-0.7368391156196594,
0.4810321033000946,
-0.5317434072494507,
-0.06416216492652893,
-0.4551352858543396,
0.1838948279619217,
-0.15558922290802002,
0.6495236158370972,
0.15221677720546722,
0.07817737758159637,
0.2896991968154907,
-0.41866788268089294,
-0.38078030943870544,
0.38777750730514526,
-0.0818144828081131,
-0.23984581232070923,
0.5292726755142212,
-0.05407930165529251,
-0.27990293502807617,
0.6421736478805542,
0.10994036495685577,
-0.4361014664173126,
0.4597700238227844,
0.6535984873771667,
0.8806796073913574,
-0.13958565890789032,
0.04038258269429207,
0.27958106994628906,
0.16001930832862854,
-0.30142590403556824,
-0.061633601784706116,
-0.49396389722824097,
-0.7469949126243591,
-0.658223032951355,
-0.776296079158783,
-0.24511580169200897,
0.06764083355665207,
-0.44988659024238586,
0.12923817336559296,
-0.8780829310417175,
-0.10732050240039825,
-0.22233325242996216,
0.11844617128372192,
-0.41225919127464294,
0.2675480842590332,
0.3058508038520813,
0.9018570184707642,
-0.5732179284095764,
0.8202270269393921,
0.4697471559047699,
-0.1858530044555664,
-0.9108962416648865,
-0.2285379022359848,
-0.11678661406040192,
-0.8084467649459839,
0.44788968563079834,
0.129685640335083,
-0.0447806678712368,
0.27002981305122375,
-0.7136672139167786,
-0.9430621862411499,
1.3016822338104248,
0.5838552117347717,
-0.7003881931304932,
-0.19395653903484344,
-0.042195551097393036,
0.3778661787509918,
0.029173875227570534,
0.25343045592308044,
0.5054992437362671,
0.06221228465437889,
0.20731182396411896,
-0.6759930849075317,
0.3025422990322113,
-0.4142601490020752,
0.5529078245162964,
0.43037667870521545,
-1.222800850868225,
0.7178008556365967,
0.05173321068286896,
-0.3289192020893097,
0.533898651599884,
0.7741528749465942,
0.25908419489860535,
-0.3494078814983368,
0.49105143547058105,
0.8887211084365845,
0.8052049875259399,
0.11987493187189102,
1.231781005859375,
-0.31937161087989807,
0.22420723736286163,
0.6818022131919861,
0.04943488910794258,
0.9416844844818115,
0.5344452857971191,
-0.13067062199115753,
0.3795965611934662,
0.48995664715766907,
0.08349788933992386,
0.3633368909358978,
0.41103044152259827,
-0.39531490206718445,
-0.3547656238079071,
-0.34509238600730896,
0.013940781354904175,
0.4777056574821472,
0.3889698386192322,
-0.017138592898845673,
0.2207372933626175,
0.11505146324634552,
-0.0798293873667717,
-0.08994173258543015,
-0.29014357924461365,
0.5762934684753418,
0.34270617365837097,
-0.2903040051460266,
0.9308325052261353,
-0.0005206420901231468,
0.757117748260498,
-0.6171364188194275,
0.040894363075494766,
-0.15993370115756989,
-0.012297376058995724,
-0.11137085407972336,
-0.5082272887229919,
-0.03744612634181976,
-0.23643793165683746,
0.14529402554035187,
-0.04250338301062584,
0.541893720626831,
-0.0002510208869352937,
-0.24464744329452515,
0.046574268490076065,
0.036050908267498016,
0.11670871824026108,
-0.1570792943239212,
-0.6072493195533752,
0.46109867095947266,
-0.14353962242603302,
-0.30674290657043457,
0.3772425949573517,
0.4091849625110626,
0.021739259362220764,
0.8988395929336548,
0.7877585291862488,
0.25704360008239746,
-0.05370325967669487,
-0.00358908181078732,
1.108901023864746,
-0.5226736664772034,
-0.4603056311607361,
-0.7356974482536316,
0.0337352380156517,
0.031117254868149757,
-0.322248637676239,
0.2853755056858063,
0.32658058404922485,
0.7544212341308594,
0.3090687096118927,
0.44740062952041626,
0.12615928053855896,
-0.16315332055091858,
-0.8964706659317017,
0.6024765968322754,
-0.6505405306816101,
0.18364457786083221,
0.0477730892598629,
-1.0280084609985352,
-0.6597506999969482,
0.5480118989944458,
0.03527092561125755,
-0.03478596359491348,
0.6229368448257446,
0.6557546257972717,
0.03523434326052666,
0.18605530261993408,
0.5124418139457703,
0.2845749855041504,
0.5054548978805542,
0.853958785533905,
0.9311294555664062,
-0.7074340581893921,
0.7188787460327148,
-0.6529892683029175,
-0.1906336098909378,
-0.03789137676358223,
-0.6289106011390686,
-0.7776482105255127,
-0.5333021879196167,
-0.49955421686172485,
-0.09224816411733627,
-0.06323493272066116,
0.8540715575218201,
0.9396247863769531,
-0.5428855419158936,
-0.09290701150894165,
-0.4055980443954468,
-0.1619747132062912,
-0.05390838533639908,
-0.1337856948375702,
0.5767620205879211,
0.08475623279809952,
-0.72233647108078,
0.4608677625656128,
0.16538593173027039,
0.17853862047195435,
-0.37280014157295227,
0.059777189046144485,
0.021385444328188896,
-0.029739923775196075,
0.6322746276855469,
0.22540505230426788,
-0.5727851390838623,
-0.14360396564006805,
-0.259627103805542,
0.09078437089920044,
-0.03359762579202652,
0.6659484505653381,
-0.9611896276473999,
0.12094613164663315,
0.46496638655662537,
0.7988519668579102,
0.3903101980686188,
-0.24649110436439514,
0.4012415409088135,
-0.6641176342964172,
0.4427717626094818,
0.3678913116455078,
0.4212912917137146,
0.37843000888824463,
-0.5979338884353638,
0.5154101252555847,
0.07993011176586151,
-0.731622040271759,
-0.8631255626678467,
0.15011312067508698,
-1.037062406539917,
-0.4040675163269043,
1.2149358987808228,
-0.16127757728099823,
-0.8995111584663391,
0.5976448059082031,
-0.15845786035060883,
0.533405601978302,
-0.4547574520111084,
0.7439389824867249,
0.2837497591972351,
-0.0818636491894722,
-0.5207621455192566,
-0.3962901532649994,
0.17549236118793488,
0.6985569596290588,
-0.39771556854248047,
-0.1428287923336029,
0.11902279406785965,
-0.20693352818489075,
0.3010668456554413,
0.1759936511516571,
0.14944972097873688,
0.17102503776550293,
0.2370598167181015,
-0.050632186233997345,
-0.027121443301439285,
-0.3158026933670044,
-0.717612624168396,
0.09045061469078064,
0.1626482605934143,
0.13040956854820251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14067v1 | Ta'keed: The First Generative Fact-Checking System for Arabic Claims | 2024-01-25T10:43:00 | 2024-01-25T10:43:00 | Saud Althabiti, Mohammad Ammar Alsalka, Eric Atwell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces Ta'keed, an explainable Arabic automatic fact-checking
system. While existing research often focuses on classifying claims as "True"
or "False," there is a limited exploration of generating explanations for claim
credibility, particularly in Arabic. Ta'keed addresses this gap by assessing
claim truthfulness based on retrieved snippets, utilizing two main components:
information retrieval and LLM-based claim verification. We compiled the
ArFactEx, a testing gold-labelled dataset with manually justified references,
to evaluate the system. The initial model achieved a promising F1 score of 0.72
in the classification task. Meanwhile, the system's generated explanations are
compared with gold-standard explanations syntactically and semantically. The
study recommends evaluating using semantic similarities, resulting in an
average cosine similarity score of 0.76. Additionally, we explored the impact
of varying snippet quantities on claim classification accuracy, revealing a
potential correlation, with the model using the top seven hits outperforming
others with an F1 score of 0.77. | [
-0.2322930544614792,
-0.7833093404769897,
0.5547033548355103,
0.2148161679506302,
-0.34231284260749817,
0.1532437950372696,
0.0205399040132761,
-0.41958484053611755,
0.10023919492959976,
0.2347189038991928,
-0.16866998374462128,
-0.8243181109428406,
-0.9589487314224243,
0.3707246482372284,
-0.4731760323047638,
1.3428415060043335,
-0.19376863539218903,
-0.4172655940055847,
0.008117660880088806,
-0.301424503326416,
-0.15417726337909698,
-0.2790023982524872,
-0.6162299513816833,
-0.31506600975990295,
0.6316854953765869,
0.7102120518684387,
0.958441436290741,
0.6001912951469421,
0.31100887060165405,
0.20971640944480896,
0.10401726514101028,
0.334286093711853,
0.1412501335144043,
0.0446259044110775,
-0.18269796669483185,
-0.4909089207649231,
-0.18038475513458252,
-0.12434790283441544,
0.48196735978126526,
0.2223120629787445,
-0.26495444774627686,
0.38334721326828003,
-0.07002849131822586,
0.6832567453384399,
-0.8352083563804626,
0.12557339668273926,
-0.43148159980773926,
0.27754178643226624,
-0.16301684081554413,
0.01273308601230383,
-0.4424925148487091,
-0.8058404326438904,
0.2596014142036438,
-0.19743213057518005,
0.3105490505695343,
0.020887600257992744,
1.0986456871032715,
0.2221812903881073,
-0.7982329726219177,
-0.5825253129005432,
-0.42501962184906006,
0.5250744819641113,
-0.5247477889060974,
0.4299542307853699,
0.36484360694885254,
0.45189252495765686,
-0.19827014207839966,
-0.8304187059402466,
-0.9242412447929382,
-0.3777274191379547,
-0.01663176529109478,
0.17087113857269287,
-0.37911438941955566,
-0.001801622100174427,
0.09034109115600586,
0.6223263740539551,
-0.49905115365982056,
-0.09793984144926071,
0.2393307089805603,
-0.7228075861930847,
0.5085967183113098,
-0.4217029809951782,
0.4975738823413849,
-0.19220058619976044,
-0.7597895860671997,
-0.08919215202331543,
-0.8476015329360962,
-0.02216326631605625,
0.12670037150382996,
0.18974728882312775,
-0.20714986324310303,
0.8100003004074097,
-0.37767472863197327,
0.33543550968170166,
0.0023545303847640753,
-0.35819607973098755,
-0.3132317364215851,
-0.34689927101135254,
-0.45532259345054626,
0.6144793629646301,
0.5971462726593018,
0.3084201514720917,
0.10039252787828445,
-0.3180944621562958,
-0.22902102768421173,
0.2047940343618393,
-0.004022983834147453,
-0.9074431657791138,
-0.012682859785854816,
0.24344216287136078,
-0.45626702904701233,
-0.39952367544174194,
0.31697189807891846,
-0.5316411852836609,
-0.3525683581829071,
0.2186654806137085,
0.7231228351593018,
-0.4856760799884796,
-0.3828376531600952,
0.06012802943587303,
0.07307682931423187,
0.020930321887135506,
0.4118131995201111,
-0.2843347489833832,
0.15136539936065674,
0.4091147780418396,
0.9988468885421753,
-0.2494789958000183,
-0.07935641705989838,
-0.5096768140792847,
-0.029519740492105484,
-0.41493088006973267,
0.772447407245636,
-0.2057534158229828,
-0.24030648171901703,
0.2976233661174774,
-0.3874906301498413,
0.3355139195919037,
-0.5251930356025696,
0.9498215913772583,
-1.0131036043167114,
0.2180090844631195,
-0.620680034160614,
-0.6888110041618347,
-0.5638453364372253,
0.5018114447593689,
-0.8085281252861023,
1.0752508640289307,
0.09440158307552338,
-0.7255836129188538,
0.7793008685112,
-0.8320690393447876,
-0.34152549505233765,
0.1328737735748291,
-0.1587444543838501,
-0.6450130939483643,
0.022780517116189003,
0.12672309577465057,
0.190267413854599,
-0.21729186177253723,
0.4848015308380127,
0.290974497795105,
-0.08051836490631104,
0.4348962604999542,
-0.5317841172218323,
0.9395992755889893,
0.6950348019599915,
-0.5803015232086182,
-0.25050002336502075,
-0.6322470903396606,
0.07160069793462753,
0.15965591371059418,
-0.6690470576286316,
0.03350059315562248,
-0.20020878314971924,
-0.13884654641151428,
-0.09970390796661377,
0.3813530206680298,
-0.9988718628883362,
0.13169725239276886,
-0.40206578373908997,
-0.07608052343130112,
0.48552629351615906,
0.08066646754741669,
-0.24075433611869812,
-0.5419598817825317,
0.4002237319946289,
0.2668627202510834,
-0.11622808128595352,
-0.20814472436904907,
-0.19137224555015564,
-1.022927165031433,
-0.20604097843170166,
0.8793607354164124,
0.3330381512641907,
-0.808437168598175,
0.4783264398574829,
-0.23331117630004883,
-0.46628424525260925,
-0.12976211309432983,
-0.07673927396535873,
0.3585747182369232,
0.5627908110618591,
0.2981964349746704,
-0.22639043629169464,
-0.29352205991744995,
-1.1230956315994263,
-0.638598620891571,
-0.530419647693634,
0.22095583379268646,
-0.07470575720071793,
0.6036580801010132,
-0.09020620584487915,
1.1141630411148071,
-0.19459006190299988,
0.02752687782049179,
-0.013388251885771751,
0.4262271225452423,
0.12392076849937439,
0.19974792003631592,
0.6533154249191284,
-0.7435535192489624,
-0.5712316036224365,
0.10565894097089767,
-0.6004959344863892,
-0.2319357842206955,
-0.001649658428505063,
0.03186802938580513,
0.3428105413913727,
-0.0922911986708641,
-0.7342401146888733,
0.9272907972335815,
0.29223117232322693,
-0.7954975366592407,
0.8054264187812805,
0.014882965013384819,
0.46310511231422424,
-0.860577404499054,
-0.1774924099445343,
-0.033957526087760925,
-0.42164260149002075,
-0.22261369228363037,
0.1327071636915207,
-0.10594247281551361,
0.09273272007703781,
-0.28942376375198364,
0.3075075149536133,
-0.123370461165905,
-0.041910894215106964,
-0.616851270198822,
-0.48112931847572327,
0.1551893651485443,
0.2212662547826767,
-0.33503761887550354,
1.1381505727767944,
0.43672916293144226,
-0.9078875780105591,
0.2736935615539551,
0.12965674698352814,
-0.8244493007659912,
0.45429661870002747,
-0.5017514228820801,
0.2476682811975479,
0.1295187920331955,
0.07656197994947433,
-1.1824886798858643,
-0.2347954511642456,
0.15052752196788788,
-0.49720099568367004,
-0.12420352548360825,
-0.1551072746515274,
-0.9278920888900757,
0.01267164759337902,
0.1418234407901764,
0.4309391975402832,
0.23620188236236572,
-0.9708324074745178,
0.8290843367576599,
-0.09197746962308884,
-0.34193140268325806,
-0.787041187286377,
-0.43330293893814087,
0.4934331178665161,
-0.10718423873186111,
-0.34878087043762207,
0.4529017508029938,
0.36124831438064575,
-0.44158923625946045,
0.10890612006187439,
-0.5759355425834656,
-0.1211160197854042,
0.2503723204135895,
0.20279283821582794,
-0.006955584045499563,
-0.35948193073272705,
0.317172646522522,
0.16741915047168732,
-0.1496146023273468,
0.3087274730205536,
-0.09916844964027405,
0.26685580611228943,
-0.3343631327152252,
-0.6839455962181091,
-0.7526558637619019,
0.3243623971939087,
0.6608185172080994,
-0.07696771621704102,
0.9083365201950073,
0.4710426926612854,
-0.45614951848983765,
0.07545839250087738,
-0.7561896443367004,
0.09975895285606384,
-0.4217911660671234,
0.2741289734840393,
-0.44952884316444397,
-0.7562817335128784,
0.38432133197784424,
-0.2845248878002167,
0.2682594656944275,
0.9189292192459106,
0.5992454290390015,
-0.15487903356552124,
0.8714904189109802,
0.7096964716911316,
0.108284592628479,
0.07617314159870148,
0.14713728427886963,
0.11067979037761688,
0.2714989185333252,
-0.31103843450546265,
-0.5378943681716919,
-0.1392485797405243,
-0.46663832664489746,
-0.03840893879532814,
0.6053178310394287,
-0.0022084717638790607,
-0.5609336495399475,
-0.1225610300898552,
-0.28254902362823486,
0.6895201206207275,
0.5919564366340637,
0.16177836060523987,
0.6977118253707886,
0.4048804044723511,
-0.38631629943847656,
0.08298121392726898,
-0.6453448534011841,
-0.7629713416099548,
0.9134645462036133,
0.41422706842422485,
0.3982086181640625,
0.7810442447662354,
0.5354892611503601,
1.1960535049438477,
0.635162889957428,
-0.9432735443115234,
0.4499243497848511,
0.17188464105129242,
-0.6019570231437683,
-0.0014793203445151448,
-0.13602787256240845,
-0.6769137382507324,
0.04000097140669823,
-0.3984520435333252,
-0.3776014745235443,
-0.14235225319862366,
0.1251804083585739,
-0.6043722629547119,
0.3888721466064453,
-0.6761541366577148,
0.3939770758152008,
-0.3670441210269928,
-0.2131296843290329,
-0.4870546758174896,
-0.47257140278816223,
0.37059152126312256,
0.020614540204405785,
0.008913152851164341,
0.008108213543891907,
0.086446113884449,
1.0564719438552856,
-1.0317476987838745,
0.7368274927139282,
-0.357931911945343,
-0.2733142077922821,
0.5093491673469543,
0.49921876192092896,
0.46482613682746887,
-0.07435568422079086,
-0.24523472785949707,
0.26703470945358276,
0.38856640458106995,
-0.5427948236465454,
-0.8376649022102356,
0.47324177622795105,
-0.8361168503761292,
-0.7748673558235168,
-0.894851803779602,
-0.346134752035141,
-0.04605180770158768,
0.2921143174171448,
0.10647521913051605,
0.3320688307285309,
-0.3077315390110016,
0.07763155549764633,
0.5725768804550171,
-0.28853094577789307,
0.30596792697906494,
0.7211652398109436,
-0.37733712792396545,
-0.4500216245651245,
0.6459932327270508,
0.024318167939782143,
-0.030361903831362724,
0.25786980986595154,
0.4254627823829651,
-0.6608227491378784,
-0.5769224166870117,
-0.6309597492218018,
-0.015368999913334846,
-0.8134896159172058,
-0.4441027343273163,
-0.32734400033950806,
-0.17463354766368866,
-0.003086969256401062,
0.20870649814605713,
-0.4234028160572052,
-0.45445674657821655,
0.4116955101490021,
-0.3261726498603821,
0.6723300218582153,
0.9899768233299255,
-0.007205069996416569,
0.41445523500442505,
-0.5945496559143066,
0.371252179145813,
0.3615313172340393,
0.5992125272750854,
-0.21194832026958466,
-0.6134818196296692,
-0.36124223470687866,
0.16740114986896515,
-0.18647991120815277,
-1.0256438255310059,
-0.07302194088697433,
0.1284210979938507,
0.1887602061033249,
0.5763123035430908,
0.3244873285293579,
0.29671454429626465,
-0.2967431843280792,
0.8024264574050903,
0.20706702768802643,
-0.9285717606544495,
0.7242520451545715,
0.13417237997055054,
-0.07245442271232605,
0.5355173945426941,
0.4028879404067993,
-0.3963668644428253,
-0.1426716446876526,
-0.6967028975486755,
-0.340364545583725,
0.4087071120738983,
0.46770966053009033,
-0.19445733726024628,
-0.06540821492671967,
0.7145922780036926,
0.656765341758728,
-0.03818652778863907,
-0.7762831449508667,
-0.6919817328453064,
-0.3691382110118866,
-0.5076307058334351,
0.4190393388271332,
-0.6234609484672546,
-0.3469310402870178,
-0.0008137719123624265,
0.7472336888313293,
0.025826947763562202,
0.3770929276943207,
0.5466284155845642,
-0.412513792514801,
-0.07555349171161652,
0.5466001629829407,
0.5401701927185059,
0.8015362024307251,
-0.06644371896982193,
0.6517337560653687,
0.07380171120166779,
-0.6396570205688477,
0.5213696956634521,
-0.003313233610242605,
-0.3134532868862152,
0.4343525171279907,
0.31569230556488037,
0.36200642585754395,
-0.4595218896865845,
-0.5049723982810974,
0.6404236555099487,
0.05224237218499184,
-0.23857666552066803,
-0.3055211901664734,
0.030407262966036797,
-0.44230887293815613,
0.13319624960422516,
0.5499687790870667,
0.08157128840684891,
-0.05239870399236679,
-0.4470770061016083,
0.3540958762168884,
0.2204955518245697,
-0.06562098860740662,
-0.1845080554485321,
0.4876944124698639,
0.15907607972621918,
-0.3448474109172821,
0.3647015392780304,
-0.10149486362934113,
-0.640042781829834,
0.6019468903541565,
0.520636796951294,
0.6335216760635376,
-0.09036563336849213,
0.3949679732322693,
0.3400457203388214,
0.3096950650215149,
0.14507795870304108,
0.2536605894565582,
-0.458903431892395,
-0.9683184027671814,
-0.5655432343482971,
-0.45822933316230774,
-0.5535492300987244,
0.22392818331718445,
-0.6720348596572876,
-0.03659253194928169,
-0.6975498795509338,
-0.3513719141483307,
0.04253966733813286,
0.15047521889209747,
-0.8233107924461365,
0.507331132888794,
0.04194360226392746,
1.2100830078125,
-0.9648167490959167,
0.590448796749115,
0.6981827616691589,
-0.5578015446662903,
-0.640947699546814,
0.24995099008083344,
-0.046221327036619186,
-1.2739946842193604,
0.9932109117507935,
0.029334906488656998,
-0.6848069429397583,
0.17269784212112427,
-0.7314733266830444,
-0.6966566443443298,
0.7747967839241028,
0.47128060460090637,
-0.15595316886901855,
0.46837055683135986,
0.3747752904891968,
0.08957674354314804,
-0.10579174011945724,
0.26045146584510803,
0.4852004945278168,
0.4280829429626465,
0.09959163516759872,
-0.8338652849197388,
0.21466606855392456,
-0.03209851682186127,
-0.41550007462501526,
-0.05378223955631256,
-0.6431770920753479,
0.2494894117116928,
-0.3330848217010498,
-0.5948903560638428,
0.1393781304359436,
1.0408005714416504,
0.2611181437969208,
0.42855802178382874,
0.8146034479141235,
0.8983299136161804,
0.8679075837135315,
-0.17016126215457916,
1.0268737077713013,
-0.2089267373085022,
0.15604665875434875,
0.882759153842926,
0.05291241407394409,
0.5933611392974854,
0.3219897449016571,
-0.4979718327522278,
1.098934531211853,
0.7070932388305664,
0.18503016233444214,
0.5088958740234375,
-0.09084843844175339,
-0.7493833899497986,
-0.36749228835105896,
-0.5438624024391174,
-0.35835397243499756,
0.6739874482154846,
0.35476154088974,
-0.41561272740364075,
-0.5241398811340332,
-0.12744086980819702,
0.02266349084675312,
0.08868752419948578,
-0.19659821689128876,
0.7094740867614746,
-0.15214790403842926,
-0.745516836643219,
0.4204024374485016,
0.3223983645439148,
0.30221667885780334,
-0.407257616519928,
-0.27597591280937195,
-0.20610187947750092,
-0.23543792963027954,
-0.41331732273101807,
-0.898800790309906,
0.12611867487430573,
0.4154626429080963,
-0.323159784078598,
-0.007842442020773888,
0.7126786708831787,
-0.24969321489334106,
-0.38137564063072205,
-0.5502128005027771,
0.7042890191078186,
0.23963287472724915,
-0.08138158917427063,
-0.6482142210006714,
-0.034193456172943115,
0.11119189858436584,
-0.03125762194395065,
-0.09980683773756027,
0.5669886469841003,
-0.07716463506221771,
0.7694476842880249,
0.4649566113948822,
-0.08908340334892273,
-0.29173529148101807,
0.125757098197937,
0.5450171232223511,
-0.8249955773353577,
-0.6444724798202515,
-1.2054131031036377,
0.2552569806575775,
0.19213911890983582,
0.13907229900360107,
0.8468163013458252,
0.7328295111656189,
0.3713572919368744,
0.18031427264213562,
1.0197877883911133,
0.028570594266057014,
0.6864566206932068,
-0.6788033843040466,
0.8178427219390869,
-0.371316134929657,
0.10739608854055405,
0.26529303193092346,
-0.7130067944526672,
-0.2552240192890167,
0.6328238248825073,
-0.004760419484227896,
0.03637241572141647,
0.6976360082626343,
0.6096796989440918,
-0.053860973566770554,
0.24400301277637482,
0.03952436521649361,
0.452093243598938,
0.1896820366382599,
0.2657863199710846,
1.161757230758667,
-0.6255357265472412,
0.5667609572410583,
-0.006065858993679285,
-0.051162511110305786,
-0.23157183825969696,
-1.1708918809890747,
-0.6022213697433472,
-0.3255562484264374,
-0.8345980644226074,
-0.8135319948196411,
-0.0996691957116127,
0.9746638536453247,
0.4262487590312958,
-1.061335802078247,
0.23308812081813812,
-0.12394227087497711,
0.3901878297328949,
-0.026518795639276505,
-0.2400577813386917,
0.7701787352561951,
-0.043220508843660355,
-0.29820823669433594,
0.21525299549102783,
0.2064514309167862,
0.3623292148113251,
-0.013751855120062828,
0.03087146207690239,
-0.006611329969018698,
-0.039677735418081284,
0.5863332152366638,
0.4433972239494324,
-1.111375331878662,
-0.6727197170257568,
-0.3259523808956146,
-0.08243700861930847,
0.1825583130121231,
0.59292072057724,
-0.9000980854034424,
0.5764040946960449,
-0.08468222618103027,
0.9529632925987244,
0.30220767855644226,
0.09472247213125229,
0.42821556329727173,
-0.7897129654884338,
-0.12579850852489471,
0.06601935625076294,
0.2738688886165619,
0.1780107319355011,
-0.412885844707489,
0.28098616003990173,
0.21621033549308777,
-0.3287604749202728,
-0.731936514377594,
0.4660335183143616,
-0.9911608695983887,
0.13648560643196106,
0.848922610282898,
-0.18858762085437775,
-0.020433740690350533,
-0.4908195436000824,
-0.2723607122898102,
0.5806136131286621,
-0.2704639136791229,
1.194011926651001,
1.1204299926757812,
-0.036854058504104614,
0.036956787109375,
-0.2233908623456955,
0.6038534641265869,
0.7609075903892517,
-0.41017842292785645,
-0.10858441889286041,
0.4568156898021698,
0.5371772050857544,
0.13250957429409027,
0.4543376863002777,
-0.02854199707508087,
0.6705533862113953,
-0.09737448394298553,
0.17080269753932953,
-0.24168089032173157,
-0.1417488157749176,
0.04710739105939865,
0.2592579424381256,
0.5020272731781006,
-0.4589104950428009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14043v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14043v2 | Towards Goal-oriented Prompt Engineering for Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-01-25T09:47:55 | 2024-06-18T02:58:37 | Haochen Li, Jonathan Leung, Zhiqi Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown prominent performance in various
downstream tasks and prompt engineering plays a pivotal role in optimizing
LLMs' performance. This paper, not only as an overview of current prompt
engineering methods, but also aims to highlight the limitation of designing
prompts based on an anthropomorphic assumption that expects LLMs to think like
humans. From our review of 36 representative studies, we demonstrate that a
goal-oriented prompt formulation, which guides LLMs to follow established human
logical thinking, significantly improves the performance of LLMs. Furthermore,
We introduce a novel taxonomy that categorizes goal-oriented prompting methods
into five interconnected stages and we demonstrate the broad applicability of
our framework. With four future directions proposed, we hope to further
emphasize the power and potential of goal-oriented prompt engineering in all
fields. | [
-0.301199346780777,
-0.9436619281768799,
1.0242218971252441,
0.5569935441017151,
-0.0872681587934494,
-0.003681137692183256,
-0.30148935317993164,
-0.19714142382144928,
-0.003763555083423853,
0.2577285170555115,
-0.9284492135047913,
-0.4079403579235077,
-0.2823416590690613,
0.4861339330673218,
-0.05791565030813217,
0.40639668703079224,
-0.07589516788721085,
-0.006811385974287987,
-0.16916823387145996,
0.42767083644866943,
-0.9025523662567139,
-0.3437579572200775,
-1.019609808921814,
-0.1632886379957199,
0.8395372629165649,
0.5252051949501038,
0.42241722345352173,
0.623392641544342,
0.12412211298942566,
0.2677030861377716,
-0.22962360084056854,
-0.09035080671310425,
-0.06994227319955826,
0.4452999532222748,
-0.1598236858844757,
-0.4223608374595642,
-0.24747483432292938,
0.21050472557544708,
0.6392509937286377,
0.8765978217124939,
0.0839090421795845,
0.2426777333021164,
0.28728681802749634,
0.5106937885284424,
-0.40228280425071716,
0.3702811300754547,
-0.30436885356903076,
-0.03848690539598465,
0.04291455075144768,
-0.28910428285598755,
-0.5711053013801575,
-0.36898165941238403,
-0.0788714662194252,
-0.44786351919174194,
-0.2227744609117508,
0.46291181445121765,
0.3177940845489502,
0.16939030587673187,
-0.24215644598007202,
-0.30410587787628174,
-0.41174954175949097,
1.0364652872085571,
-0.8223148584365845,
0.3804744780063629,
0.12789411842823029,
0.24017538130283356,
-0.5460187196731567,
-0.14623688161373138,
-0.35624921321868896,
-0.44120824337005615,
0.10918182879686356,
-0.13841655850410461,
0.10206751525402069,
0.2979480028152466,
0.575560450553894,
-0.26873350143432617,
-0.6538920402526855,
0.6226726174354553,
-0.0783580094575882,
-0.2564067244529724,
0.6577973961830139,
0.22106477618217468,
0.3710838258266449,
-0.1699950098991394,
-0.48706868290901184,
0.30545496940612793,
-0.9472393989562988,
0.34734880924224854,
0.39555624127388,
0.7846303582191467,
0.10116010904312134,
0.5801337361335754,
-0.3587564527988434,
0.8569449186325073,
-0.1386677473783493,
-0.2844655513763428,
-0.15548530220985413,
-0.1554742008447647,
0.010426394641399384,
0.11970759183168411,
0.7100978493690491,
0.362121045589447,
0.3605802357196808,
0.0883634090423584,
-0.5679367184638977,
0.026784271001815796,
0.06467733532190323,
-0.829043984413147,
0.2565450668334961,
0.2964693307876587,
-0.5541214942932129,
-0.0984220951795578,
-0.2674977779388428,
-0.5940107107162476,
-0.5343170762062073,
-0.7980443239212036,
0.16482241451740265,
-0.29801952838897705,
-0.020601876080036163,
0.20866575837135315,
0.05857951194047928,
0.2966599762439728,
0.45121848583221436,
-0.9306269288063049,
0.03226782754063606,
1.0032694339752197,
0.84004807472229,
-0.14399884641170502,
-0.3521560728549957,
-0.7192201614379883,
-0.1486455798149109,
-0.4237087070941925,
0.927973210811615,
-0.7239148020744324,
-0.7062690258026123,
0.06951803714036942,
-0.28158360719680786,
0.08051319420337677,
-0.2958076596260071,
0.7745084166526794,
-0.4410073459148407,
0.1268407702445984,
-0.6023939251899719,
-0.5067557692527771,
-0.2951017916202545,
0.3789806365966797,
-0.3107689619064331,
0.5736398100852966,
-0.21128907799720764,
-0.37841498851776123,
0.0721505805850029,
-0.7819680571556091,
-0.4307921528816223,
0.17505097389221191,
-0.3120217025279999,
0.1841319054365158,
0.25926512479782104,
0.2728593349456787,
0.5357017517089844,
-0.7426419854164124,
0.5572644472122192,
-0.09472626447677612,
-0.24615688621997833,
0.2026079148054123,
-0.2816711962223053,
0.9833279252052307,
0.3361397087574005,
0.006477902177721262,
0.40210843086242676,
-0.36561647057533264,
-0.03077865205705166,
0.07792481780052185,
-0.23744772374629974,
-0.24233077466487885,
0.1112806499004364,
-0.08551779389381409,
0.3566569685935974,
0.4311687648296356,
-0.5458711385726929,
0.45916542410850525,
-0.32014867663383484,
0.4891932010650635,
1.0265839099884033,
-0.03906877711415291,
0.39282047748565674,
-0.4102049171924591,
0.8089537620544434,
-0.3682304620742798,
0.3199016749858856,
-0.4551105499267578,
-0.5682159662246704,
-0.3589983880519867,
-0.31221804022789,
-0.07030218839645386,
0.5352194905281067,
-0.49540945887565613,
0.4850563704967499,
0.17256328463554382,
-0.34403011202812195,
-0.061812009662389755,
0.04359843209385872,
0.19399751722812653,
0.8192440271377563,
0.10565569251775742,
-0.055055420845746994,
-0.5558119416236877,
-0.8747012615203857,
-0.3193802535533905,
-0.5479586124420166,
-0.1293168067932129,
0.19451220333576202,
0.26766687631607056,
-0.04898676648736,
1.1930363178253174,
-0.5894415974617004,
0.11157489567995071,
-0.48207542300224304,
0.0899103656411171,
0.703618049621582,
0.3364173471927643,
0.5628294348716736,
-0.7843186855316162,
-0.41776493191719055,
-0.31876569986343384,
-0.6656060218811035,
-0.5504599213600159,
-0.027111899107694626,
0.0674600675702095,
-0.0702960342168808,
0.8085407018661499,
-0.8750940561294556,
-0.08788159489631653,
0.2218395173549652,
-0.455007404088974,
1.0201382637023926,
0.07736280560493469,
0.2871032655239105,
-0.887921154499054,
0.029429281130433083,
0.30928099155426025,
0.03456313535571098,
-0.7126112580299377,
0.11281690001487732,
-0.10866052657365799,
-0.43135252594947815,
-0.5268334746360779,
0.9584863781929016,
-0.5426103472709656,
0.09378046542406082,
-0.5096575617790222,
0.08479154109954834,
-0.20932333171367645,
0.3750152885913849,
-0.059356436133384705,
0.8835219144821167,
0.8652288317680359,
-0.8005982041358948,
0.5001958608627319,
0.37758657336235046,
-0.2696073651313782,
0.7250303626060486,
-0.892911434173584,
-0.13844501972198486,
-0.4081292748451233,
0.2317432165145874,
-1.0040825605392456,
-0.24493664503097534,
0.37420836091041565,
-0.41298192739486694,
0.2977372109889984,
0.052342645823955536,
-0.48966851830482483,
-0.5881362557411194,
-0.3643832504749298,
0.2866952121257782,
0.7316436171531677,
-0.3215280771255493,
0.4838310480117798,
0.06217830628156662,
-0.8342815637588501,
-0.4229516386985779,
-0.2345830500125885,
0.29513370990753174,
-0.41521698236465454,
-0.5427303910255432,
0.07448365539312363,
-0.2789517045021057,
-0.46207505464553833,
-0.3962954580783844,
-0.015116690658032894,
0.2560228407382965,
0.34240880608558655,
0.0011432544561102986,
0.5376275777816772,
-0.12710680067539215,
0.2623880207538605,
-0.17903868854045868,
-0.15103575587272644,
0.41150152683258057,
-0.4621375501155853,
0.5810946822166443,
0.23263168334960938,
-0.3560493588447571,
-0.6292657852172852,
0.5671693682670593,
0.3756124675273895,
-0.3205220103263855,
0.2820584774017334,
-0.11282600462436676,
-0.3465048670768738,
-0.2535182535648346,
-0.5142305493354797,
-0.39938172698020935,
-0.5243853330612183,
0.3341575860977173,
-0.4714548885822296,
-0.8518680930137634,
0.4232741594314575,
-0.3063352704048157,
0.39309147000312805,
0.2117118388414383,
0.31134170293807983,
-0.23713211715221405,
1.0537736415863037,
0.8194760680198669,
-0.06404399126768112,
0.6737069487571716,
0.33735859394073486,
0.24776431918144226,
-0.7753862738609314,
-0.05679691582918167,
-0.8531116247177124,
-0.18824473023414612,
-0.29947537183761597,
-0.2049902081489563,
0.32847195863723755,
0.1826995462179184,
-0.4922601282596588,
0.11745848506689072,
-0.3640052080154419,
0.4535692036151886,
0.3215296268463135,
-0.23587821424007416,
0.1549638956785202,
-0.2834694981575012,
-0.1282944679260254,
0.12392853200435638,
-0.709985613822937,
-0.87343430519104,
0.5873932242393494,
0.4542611539363861,
0.8765525817871094,
-0.13766101002693176,
0.7046996355056763,
0.1803969442844391,
0.20122765004634857,
-1.1920642852783203,
1.02009117603302,
0.4233349859714508,
-0.48080959916114807,
-0.585645318031311,
-0.29558447003364563,
-0.887834370136261,
-0.04599675536155701,
0.11333229392766953,
-0.9726539254188538,
0.135398268699646,
0.08385616540908813,
-0.33565977215766907,
-0.03622102737426758,
-0.6075267791748047,
0.821600079536438,
-0.35385164618492126,
0.013952775858342648,
-0.08268194645643234,
-0.641637921333313,
0.2215167135000229,
-0.12318839132785797,
0.3935059905052185,
-0.31452107429504395,
-0.3854362368583679,
0.5990025997161865,
-0.33379560708999634,
0.9475349187850952,
-0.40604811906814575,
-0.5118423700332642,
0.5319206714630127,
0.015159684233367443,
0.7882176041603088,
-0.14135576784610748,
-0.2566778361797333,
-0.28542637825012207,
-0.5255979299545288,
-0.36676517128944397,
-0.736383855342865,
0.6421739459037781,
-0.37618300318717957,
-1.0781874656677246,
-0.15249277651309967,
-0.665605366230011,
-0.5231792330741882,
0.27897706627845764,
-0.016051139682531357,
0.4390217959880829,
-0.16331149637699127,
-0.3714613914489746,
0.7690807580947876,
-0.30530163645744324,
0.7725943922996521,
0.3030926585197449,
-0.41999420523643494,
-0.06251068413257599,
0.7406148314476013,
-0.07860573381185532,
0.2265373021364212,
0.4747234582901001,
0.23948749899864197,
-0.5978765487670898,
-0.6941854357719421,
-0.5097796320915222,
0.4016091823577881,
-0.8167998194694519,
-0.02916060760617256,
-0.6028998494148254,
0.04108811542391777,
-0.4120805561542511,
-0.4295981228351593,
-0.13350160419940948,
-0.16089273989200592,
-0.45534491539001465,
0.024165766313672066,
0.27717098593711853,
0.6776395440101624,
0.3038102090358734,
0.236345574259758,
-0.8202553391456604,
0.07317259162664413,
0.3830234110355377,
0.2260463386774063,
0.17464973032474518,
-0.37230154871940613,
0.11544686555862427,
-0.0453173853456974,
-0.23911473155021667,
-0.8034225702285767,
0.19167162477970123,
-0.19982972741127014,
0.7947660088539124,
0.32304903864860535,
0.1956859529018402,
0.24703076481819153,
-0.8350237607955933,
0.8481629490852356,
0.4752431809902191,
-0.919741153717041,
0.6843562722206116,
-0.60379558801651,
0.36719727516174316,
0.20543691515922546,
0.6148444414138794,
-0.779670000076294,
-0.13192817568778992,
-0.1277555674314499,
-0.6978649497032166,
0.5068979263305664,
-0.183303564786911,
0.11008657515048981,
-0.14230532944202423,
0.4427791237831116,
0.2013174146413803,
0.20984065532684326,
-0.3119691014289856,
-0.1403493881225586,
0.14040939509868622,
-0.23260848224163055,
-0.32493501901626587,
-0.2276199758052826,
0.09573611617088318,
0.08070343732833862,
0.7461872100830078,
-0.3485616445541382,
0.27463027834892273,
0.11845839023590088,
0.08987287431955338,
0.03061399981379509,
0.6035877466201782,
0.6720713973045349,
0.7900652885437012,
0.1437099725008011,
-0.10214501619338989,
0.07895740121603012,
-0.13570210337638855,
0.47889387607574463,
0.06953518092632294,
-0.39131292700767517,
-0.26899635791778564,
0.203024759888649,
0.6221723556518555,
-0.012937149032950401,
-0.7174145579338074,
0.30071163177490234,
0.15947593748569489,
0.05176951363682747,
0.03646792471408844,
0.15879002213478088,
0.17910847067832947,
0.4513617157936096,
0.6842837333679199,
-0.15054979920387268,
0.1900337040424347,
-0.5877670645713806,
-0.2538859248161316,
0.5045899748802185,
-0.40793630480766296,
-0.3230478763580322,
0.8130506277084351,
0.4204165041446686,
-0.6216244101524353,
0.44098567962646484,
-0.11739520728588104,
-0.38116657733917236,
0.5944080948829651,
0.6227694749832153,
1.1476739645004272,
-0.31200793385505676,
0.2310125231742859,
0.47367364168167114,
0.1989986151456833,
-0.2075849026441574,
0.39846643805503845,
-0.006934920325875282,
-0.41316360235214233,
-0.904791533946991,
-0.7081682085990906,
-0.42794662714004517,
-0.25590693950653076,
-0.12751273810863495,
0.5704203248023987,
-0.3325743079185486,
-0.22753196954727173,
-0.09468670189380646,
-0.19668428599834442,
-0.3011193871498108,
0.12746398150920868,
0.23280002176761627,
1.2074315547943115,
-0.7282996773719788,
0.2916775345802307,
1.0207324028015137,
-0.10533718764781952,
-0.9494128227233887,
-0.004075153265148401,
0.10509982705116272,
-0.45137473940849304,
0.7979676127433777,
0.39681318402290344,
-0.06287286430597305,
0.19197291135787964,
-0.6585140824317932,
-0.7391203045845032,
0.8450706601142883,
0.4099704921245575,
-0.8195189833641052,
-0.42029139399528503,
-0.10844561457633972,
0.18872880935668945,
-0.5048013925552368,
0.056995294988155365,
0.23707036674022675,
0.6184607148170471,
0.17171108722686768,
-0.932499885559082,
0.2846127152442932,
-0.15746569633483887,
0.30285215377807617,
0.19792227447032928,
-0.6237052083015442,
0.6408076882362366,
-0.4001525342464447,
-0.38640958070755005,
0.263668954372406,
0.7292019128799438,
0.5357502102851868,
0.17552873492240906,
0.5624643564224243,
-0.044803496450185776,
0.6334112882614136,
0.038663748651742935,
0.9779148697853088,
-0.20805980265140533,
0.05753038078546524,
0.7149118781089783,
-0.42246872186660767,
0.4354248046875,
0.5086828470230103,
-0.14336681365966797,
0.16307321190834045,
0.8224717974662781,
0.27609309554100037,
0.24039965867996216,
0.3357539772987366,
-0.30067378282546997,
-0.47315269708633423,
-0.5523281097412109,
-0.1380375772714615,
0.26130396127700806,
0.2157743126153946,
-0.19412699341773987,
-0.22540633380413055,
0.2185811847448349,
-0.1692078709602356,
0.13446666300296783,
-0.7225704789161682,
0.4992159605026245,
0.28404125571250916,
-0.850954532623291,
0.4409436583518982,
-0.07163319736719131,
0.7515178918838501,
-0.548898458480835,
0.08325429260730743,
0.007275496143847704,
-0.38430359959602356,
0.08673258870840073,
-0.855034589767456,
-0.006589470896869898,
0.02835642546415329,
-0.25424641370773315,
-0.5830592513084412,
0.6895931959152222,
-0.063286691904068,
-0.23251886665821075,
-0.0730036050081253,
0.6644383072853088,
0.105411097407341,
-0.04291468858718872,
-0.5856491327285767,
0.0865420252084732,
-0.07992023974657059,
-0.45004433393478394,
0.08438163250684738,
0.611501157283783,
-0.29551225900650024,
0.9370765686035156,
0.6240582466125488,
0.12931902706623077,
-0.27649322152137756,
-0.019733335822820663,
0.8351964950561523,
-0.9093303680419922,
-0.5880691409111023,
-1.112259864807129,
0.47189009189605713,
0.17247067391872406,
-0.15197180211544037,
0.6738678216934204,
0.43170449137687683,
0.43136346340179443,
-0.22293412685394287,
0.9235736131668091,
-0.06149575114250183,
0.5151770710945129,
-0.44722074270248413,
0.378643661737442,
-0.2983567416667938,
0.14914466440677643,
-0.33716607093811035,
-1.2710955142974854,
-0.3538200855255127,
0.350475549697876,
-0.3670356571674347,
0.1461009681224823,
0.45373043417930603,
0.7546507120132446,
0.2861281633377075,
0.21244990825653076,
0.3704725205898285,
0.09261760115623474,
0.494968980550766,
0.48726528882980347,
1.2606624364852905,
0.20925195515155792,
0.09241780638694763,
0.23193085193634033,
-0.3824027478694916,
-0.15065759420394897,
-0.9576274752616882,
-0.9495688080787659,
-0.5240979790687561,
-0.2668682932853699,
0.1767549067735672,
-0.06641163676977158,
1.3783092498779297,
0.4249855577945709,
-0.4850473403930664,
-0.28152716159820557,
-0.24183741211891174,
0.24868689477443695,
-0.09328622370958328,
-0.16876870393753052,
0.10812079161405563,
-0.7475957870483398,
-0.9112511873245239,
0.4026537537574768,
0.43981751799583435,
0.1479908674955368,
-0.35747456550598145,
-0.03924097493290901,
-0.1476166844367981,
0.18290796875953674,
0.7856406569480896,
0.36801573634147644,
-0.6775783896446228,
-0.27721574902534485,
0.28234294056892395,
-0.1452302187681198,
-0.11742508411407471,
1.0216317176818848,
-0.6239084601402283,
0.10365378111600876,
0.5533905625343323,
0.6174840331077576,
-0.2741148769855499,
0.07278165221214294,
0.614544689655304,
-0.4563569724559784,
0.02883080206811428,
0.5450284481048584,
0.38999444246292114,
0.2856725752353668,
-0.36240601539611816,
0.23766493797302246,
0.052550897002220154,
-0.7990670800209045,
-0.6525423526763916,
0.65494704246521,
-0.8741070628166199,
-0.39202985167503357,
1.387822151184082,
-0.013129490427672863,
-0.24670274555683136,
-0.1051371693611145,
-0.6830395460128784,
0.1304304003715515,
-0.47586384415626526,
0.5157811641693115,
0.744410514831543,
-0.32302695512771606,
-0.3011317551136017,
-0.6897282600402832,
0.29840150475502014,
0.3283798098564148,
-0.8877812623977661,
0.35811281204223633,
0.7961805462837219,
0.1512364149093628,
0.10596943646669388,
0.5833659768104553,
0.20394450426101685,
0.10613179951906204,
-0.3217869997024536,
0.011176086030900478,
0.045509207993745804,
-0.45792752504348755,
-0.21808668971061707,
0.029309818521142006,
0.5232640504837036,
0.11276021599769592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14040v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14040v3 | (Chat)GPT v BERT: Dawn of Justice for Semantic Change Detection | 2024-01-25T09:36:58 | 2024-04-29T07:07:45 | Francesco Periti, Haim Dubossarsky, Nina Tahmasebi | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the universe of Natural Language Processing, Transformer-based language
models like BERT and (Chat)GPT have emerged as lexical superheroes with great
power to solve open research problems. In this paper, we specifically focus on
the temporal problem of semantic change, and evaluate their ability to solve
two diachronic extensions of the Word-in-Context (WiC) task: TempoWiC and
HistoWiC. In particular, we investigate the potential of a novel, off-the-shelf
technology like ChatGPT (and GPT) 3.5 compared to BERT, which represents a
family of models that currently stand as the state-of-the-art for modeling
semantic change. Our experiments represent the first attempt to assess the use
of (Chat)GPT for studying semantic change. Our results indicate that ChatGPT
performs significantly worse than the foundational GPT version. Furthermore,
our results demonstrate that (Chat)GPT achieves slightly lower performance than
BERT in detecting long-term changes but performs significantly worse in
detecting short-term changes. | [
-0.2108580768108368,
-0.8753902316093445,
0.6442050933837891,
0.054570019245147705,
-0.15051279962062836,
-0.04758388176560402,
-0.17599470913410187,
-0.8263165354728699,
-0.016475291922688484,
0.09106364846229553,
-0.8845133185386658,
-0.08313402533531189,
-0.8056889176368713,
0.034024618566036224,
-0.6856404542922974,
1.0593209266662598,
-0.06420554965734482,
-0.07223882526159286,
0.5174204111099243,
0.04349798709154129,
-0.6015028953552246,
-0.33840957283973694,
-0.6000287532806396,
-0.4320927858352661,
0.590348482131958,
-0.1690332442522049,
1.1325242519378662,
0.1383017897605896,
0.7259259223937988,
0.2762899696826935,
-0.3844089210033417,
-0.3493478000164032,
-0.31590282917022705,
0.2890327572822571,
-0.22516876459121704,
-0.2837580144405365,
-0.18651458621025085,
0.07091931998729706,
0.5246532559394836,
0.6710383892059326,
-0.0859571248292923,
0.010713906027376652,
-0.15222372114658356,
0.7380448579788208,
-0.6886083483695984,
0.5183658003807068,
-1.1576348543167114,
0.04922093451023102,
-0.4507116675376892,
-0.046827416867017746,
-0.29208070039749146,
-0.025707527995109558,
0.2290995717048645,
-0.6138736605644226,
0.32250306010246277,
-0.10529275238513947,
1.1053615808486938,
0.5328685641288757,
-0.22119025886058807,
-0.2816135585308075,
-1.0838159322738647,
0.5746915340423584,
-0.8232132792472839,
0.6845362186431885,
0.13205792009830475,
0.5483060479164124,
-0.6121278405189514,
-1.0770893096923828,
-1.0014375448226929,
-0.3369598984718323,
0.20972947776317596,
0.38231924176216125,
-0.4383016526699066,
-0.12928564846515656,
0.20532330870628357,
0.23904365301132202,
-0.32478225231170654,
0.12167418003082275,
-0.033622805029153824,
-0.09781896322965622,
0.17630571126937866,
0.212208092212677,
0.23489150404930115,
-0.3550999164581299,
-0.38330766558647156,
-0.1481548398733139,
-0.5947589874267578,
-0.10995252430438995,
0.3011583089828491,
0.3043646514415741,
0.3173249065876007,
0.24569764733314514,
-0.06927736848592758,
0.5554935932159424,
-0.13317057490348816,
0.061732642352581024,
-0.02129744179546833,
-0.28293776512145996,
-0.20717419683933258,
-0.003602414857596159,
0.45923247933387756,
0.22565658390522003,
0.0049212900921702385,
-0.2061799317598343,
-0.18590709567070007,
0.27679258584976196,
0.14015047252178192,
-0.6566125750541687,
-0.4829150438308716,
-0.06645890325307846,
-0.3865862786769867,
-0.1436750590801239,
-0.09963661432266235,
-0.2646561563014984,
-0.36017003655433655,
-0.39824676513671875,
0.6615421772003174,
-0.7832866311073303,
-0.19192004203796387,
0.21783439815044403,
-0.251392126083374,
0.679421603679657,
0.6303484439849854,
-0.875764787197113,
0.03461768850684166,
0.9024222493171692,
0.7307108044624329,
-0.09591004252433777,
-0.06616626679897308,
-0.111034095287323,
-0.058042917400598526,
-0.4632544219493866,
0.831885039806366,
-0.585171639919281,
-0.501325249671936,
-0.02983696386218071,
0.10144136846065521,
-0.13396908342838287,
-0.18346548080444336,
0.5429200530052185,
-0.9004402756690979,
0.4476144313812256,
-0.4303584396839142,
-0.7989133596420288,
0.22554443776607513,
0.2651143968105316,
-0.6499532461166382,
1.1808669567108154,
0.11674800515174866,
-1.1889564990997314,
0.8541373014450073,
-0.8663082122802734,
-0.14318983256816864,
0.32651275396347046,
0.08030131459236145,
-0.4202774465084076,
-0.14480294287204742,
0.02110123820602894,
0.07710865139961243,
0.12671466171741486,
0.17045889794826508,
-0.054217882454395294,
-0.5695697069168091,
0.2847677767276764,
-0.5308767557144165,
0.8556732535362244,
0.13852952420711517,
-0.520149290561676,
-0.14429053664207458,
-0.6053891777992249,
-0.25875726342201233,
0.19958065450191498,
-0.2805340886116028,
-0.31855884194374084,
0.5592787861824036,
0.09654776006937027,
0.22018571197986603,
0.20153585076332092,
-0.9073153734207153,
0.08939148485660553,
-0.18382994830608368,
0.4994798004627228,
1.0459270477294922,
-0.1669365018606186,
0.0027483718004077673,
-0.26514506340026855,
-0.19694022834300995,
-0.1392463892698288,
0.4970800578594208,
0.007642153650522232,
-1.019889235496521,
-0.6605247855186462,
-0.08916831761598587,
0.4901651442050934,
0.5328922271728516,
-1.0501644611358643,
0.2940911650657654,
-0.45323339104652405,
-0.3147781789302826,
-0.39686205983161926,
-0.4132208228111267,
-0.1668427586555481,
0.4783131182193756,
0.6417540907859802,
-0.2110711634159088,
-0.2766782343387604,
-0.6847692728042603,
-0.5991320013999939,
-0.6510431170463562,
-0.19904030859470367,
0.06075703352689743,
0.6937312483787537,
-0.4214918613433838,
1.4821722507476807,
-0.2929314374923706,
-0.09173525869846344,
0.04159373790025711,
0.4168912172317505,
0.12468884140253067,
0.07976063340902328,
0.4325707256793976,
-1.0521974563598633,
-0.2673206925392151,
-0.2399298995733261,
-0.3421509265899658,
-0.31642311811447144,
-0.06105076149106026,
0.19530928134918213,
0.24714121222496033,
0.5256232023239136,
-0.40700632333755493,
0.6237376928329468,
0.5630269050598145,
-0.6118207573890686,
0.8838617205619812,
-0.11303430795669556,
0.3001641631126404,
-0.7897228598594666,
-0.21457183361053467,
-0.5912585258483887,
-0.19363977015018463,
-0.841678261756897,
-0.23315873742103577,
0.16797886788845062,
0.03474239632487297,
-0.5779305100440979,
0.39892518520355225,
0.025769731029868126,
-0.010736110620200634,
-0.40966713428497314,
0.09935003519058228,
-0.3965809941291809,
0.2758830487728119,
-0.008243313059210777,
0.7587757110595703,
-0.004028291441500187,
-0.5933842658996582,
0.13989755511283875,
0.32536038756370544,
-0.3136390745639801,
0.28963416814804077,
-0.5602599382400513,
0.22438085079193115,
-0.12032416462898254,
0.3411414325237274,
-1.000279426574707,
0.0723409652709961,
0.1878075748682022,
-0.5166265964508057,
0.05295143648982048,
-0.30752748250961304,
-0.9210827350616455,
-0.3804493844509125,
-0.27620354294776917,
0.07569034397602081,
0.673359215259552,
-0.7001687288284302,
0.2712523937225342,
-0.0699315220117569,
-0.003692920319736004,
-0.27686890959739685,
-0.7490342855453491,
0.42138105630874634,
0.08330088108778,
-0.8137163519859314,
0.8186114430427551,
0.00904224906116724,
-0.48978638648986816,
0.3554631769657135,
-0.272485613822937,
-0.019453659653663635,
0.018665703013539314,
0.01676195301115513,
0.3044854402542114,
-0.022059641778469086,
0.43285930156707764,
-0.08974378556013107,
-0.38617777824401855,
-0.12231823801994324,
-0.24157918989658356,
0.425694078207016,
-0.25584909319877625,
-0.4739965796470642,
-0.17326383292675018,
0.19664128124713898,
0.26107239723205566,
-0.11820168793201447,
0.8554744720458984,
1.0399701595306396,
-0.25278323888778687,
0.27341634035110474,
-0.6651164889335632,
-0.19105583429336548,
-0.4225567579269409,
0.1656268835067749,
-0.1681360900402069,
-1.0439389944076538,
0.5354320406913757,
0.0011504406575113535,
0.20834246277809143,
0.6717991232872009,
0.8504683375358582,
-0.12510858476161957,
0.8079332709312439,
0.709929883480072,
0.0038050732109695673,
1.186400055885315,
0.09411570429801941,
0.4213300347328186,
-0.8479277491569519,
0.20260189473628998,
-0.4596971869468689,
-0.21408700942993164,
-1.0895698070526123,
-0.25835752487182617,
0.667393147945404,
-0.3154356777667999,
-0.15701502561569214,
0.6361594200134277,
-0.3027886748313904,
0.08445549011230469,
0.25907859206199646,
0.08343737572431564,
0.463969349861145,
-0.4236508905887604,
0.13741062581539154,
-0.272489994764328,
-0.399715781211853,
-0.3846687376499176,
0.7651342153549194,
0.15889787673950195,
0.6498070955276489,
0.24786047637462616,
0.5393322706222534,
0.2854534983634949,
0.27293774485588074,
-0.6149467825889587,
0.5819658637046814,
-0.27069222927093506,
-0.5692999362945557,
-0.5264893174171448,
-0.3757549524307251,
-1.225329875946045,
0.5819485783576965,
-0.11980107426643372,
-0.7976159453392029,
0.14040569961071014,
-0.2585289180278778,
0.10711928457021713,
0.6598412394523621,
-0.5753480195999146,
0.7868345975875854,
0.30995187163352966,
-0.2200048267841339,
-0.2895215153694153,
-0.7620646357536316,
-0.06128249317407608,
0.14439822733402252,
0.19009727239608765,
-0.5752922296524048,
-0.09279349446296692,
0.7445662021636963,
-0.5860884785652161,
0.7916542887687683,
-0.2534319758415222,
-0.18434488773345947,
0.28663647174835205,
0.22780072689056396,
0.6945834755897522,
-0.07574383169412613,
0.275469034910202,
0.0479707308113575,
0.15657757222652435,
-0.35951927304267883,
-0.6679368019104004,
0.43159130215644836,
-0.41783830523490906,
-0.4918985366821289,
-0.4250040054321289,
-0.5119194388389587,
-0.2353457659482956,
-0.04655018821358681,
0.2178320288658142,
0.27908456325531006,
-0.3676083981990814,
-0.15194088220596313,
0.564204752445221,
-0.023805728182196617,
0.8243627548217773,
0.9146928191184998,
-0.07047326862812042,
0.3908174932003021,
0.5440002083778381,
0.16454581916332245,
0.3552291691303253,
0.36182111501693726,
0.4947112500667572,
-0.005280106328427792,
-0.387412965297699,
-0.20824043452739716,
0.038368839770555496,
-0.7068094611167908,
0.1013471707701683,
-0.4558541774749756,
-0.059946294873952866,
-0.3367733359336853,
-0.050733476877212524,
-0.3862123489379883,
-0.40615493059158325,
0.1612885594367981,
0.4984959065914154,
0.6104823350906372,
0.6680915951728821,
-0.007404322735965252,
0.19496022164821625,
-0.6083474159240723,
0.1578889787197113,
0.622589647769928,
0.16877208650112152,
-0.5964137315750122,
-0.456073522567749,
0.1414802223443985,
-0.06488556414842606,
-0.24728497862815857,
-1.0482509136199951,
0.06026572361588478,
0.10439728945493698,
0.2884364128112793,
0.012803888879716396,
-0.0057260929606854916,
0.5425669550895691,
-0.7813735604286194,
1.1908905506134033,
-0.08423686772584915,
-0.914544403553009,
0.5530720949172974,
-0.37618640065193176,
0.5448734164237976,
0.21130256354808807,
-0.006737563293427229,
-1.0482909679412842,
-0.6079649925231934,
-0.7576174139976501,
-0.7257487177848816,
0.33276882767677307,
0.6804565787315369,
0.09730321168899536,
-0.06149551272392273,
0.22632119059562683,
0.10809418559074402,
0.018230166286230087,
-0.39651721715927124,
0.12244388461112976,
-0.23144526779651642,
0.19203776121139526,
0.21817240118980408,
-0.07149893790483475,
0.272312730550766,
-0.1206875592470169,
0.5359422564506531,
-0.05318615213036537,
0.5517821907997131,
0.4782542884349823,
-0.21164293587207794,
0.2970511317253113,
0.6943676471710205,
0.18500815331935883,
0.5548049211502075,
-0.2652829885482788,
-0.03636384382843971,
0.35632893443107605,
-0.6142534613609314,
-0.24685345590114594,
0.18614926934242249,
-0.18751253187656403,
0.4040878117084503,
0.719020426273346,
0.7630507349967957,
0.6758257150650024,
-0.3565579354763031,
0.6393376588821411,
-0.05351228639483452,
-0.10007842630147934,
-0.28586524724960327,
-0.15431615710258484,
-0.2820558547973633,
0.21886949241161346,
0.27178117632865906,
-0.0414293073117733,
0.43854525685310364,
-0.6651790142059326,
0.1559327095746994,
0.2964611351490021,
-0.6262537837028503,
-0.38950785994529724,
0.5482076406478882,
-0.19852453470230103,
-0.03891673684120178,
0.5910194516181946,
-0.386793315410614,
-0.7866401076316833,
0.26823416352272034,
0.48409730195999146,
0.923855185508728,
-0.27362650632858276,
0.05904271453619003,
-0.12564723193645477,
0.21439270675182343,
0.11274923384189606,
-0.014496899209916592,
-0.21698105335235596,
-1.0817800760269165,
-0.5219385027885437,
-0.31256505846977234,
-0.592877209186554,
-0.15402717888355255,
-0.45407193899154663,
0.0005575561081059277,
0.011209055781364441,
-0.47362425923347473,
0.1300567090511322,
-0.06376166641712189,
-0.6035872101783752,
-0.22325198352336884,
-0.04696712642908096,
0.8268429636955261,
-0.5628146529197693,
0.8696970343589783,
0.504814088344574,
-0.19485852122306824,
-0.2441285252571106,
0.3322513699531555,
0.09652867168188095,
-0.7069680690765381,
0.7717888951301575,
-0.18206526339054108,
-0.31090104579925537,
-0.2478216588497162,
-0.626947820186615,
-0.42468854784965515,
1.1337461471557617,
0.20659159123897552,
-0.3763643503189087,
-0.19464394450187683,
0.0213126540184021,
0.7508822083473206,
0.37184906005859375,
0.025355592370033264,
0.8587093353271484,
0.6214560270309448,
0.2017780840396881,
-1.3091601133346558,
-0.36827221512794495,
0.11709240823984146,
0.38979941606521606,
0.7136565446853638,
-0.3273840546607971,
1.157861351966858,
-0.06685763597488403,
-0.6792739629745483,
-0.11519643664360046,
0.558396577835083,
-0.2696445882320404,
-0.11076878756284714,
0.7163122892379761,
0.5550563335418701,
0.5088812708854675,
-0.4948926568031311,
1.084000587463379,
-0.24190311133861542,
0.6360125541687012,
0.8661913871765137,
-0.3340942859649658,
0.909633219242096,
0.6034864783287048,
-0.5495540499687195,
0.6759950518608093,
0.44706523418426514,
0.20567023754119873,
0.5830795168876648,
0.039385199546813965,
-0.5024759769439697,
-0.2719285786151886,
0.21575821936130524,
-0.3770003914833069,
0.400621622800827,
0.29653242230415344,
0.2377815842628479,
-0.7454056143760681,
0.01858588494360447,
0.4257441461086273,
-0.17110291123390198,
-0.2620537281036377,
0.9336555004119873,
-0.15829987823963165,
-0.035054709762334824,
0.20101429522037506,
0.13863003253936768,
0.7409883141517639,
-0.7489592432975769,
-0.07985401898622513,
0.13700039684772491,
0.3991817533969879,
0.028637869283556938,
-0.9363192319869995,
0.5037198662757874,
-0.14992091059684753,
0.10753657668828964,
-0.054390162229537964,
0.916375994682312,
-0.16077256202697754,
-0.2551731467247009,
0.6276293992996216,
0.39526811242103577,
-0.10418184846639633,
-0.23994599282741547,
-0.8473523855209351,
0.14781460165977478,
-0.47700485587120056,
-0.2793012857437134,
0.25824296474456787,
0.45351892709732056,
-0.28241902589797974,
0.6608426570892334,
0.652256965637207,
-0.05775554105639458,
0.31452634930610657,
0.2069629728794098,
0.8826074004173279,
-0.48981204628944397,
-0.5408300161361694,
-0.8266252279281616,
0.06758686155080795,
0.04379241168498993,
-0.3003946840763092,
0.5375791192054749,
0.10222674906253815,
0.8110654354095459,
0.05642436817288399,
0.527391791343689,
-0.5251557230949402,
0.43971800804138184,
-0.7414723038673401,
0.3936079740524292,
-0.24491296708583832,
0.03385657072067261,
-0.39324459433555603,
-0.7047252655029297,
-0.24889835715293884,
0.3861951529979706,
-0.5109133124351501,
-0.09594836086034775,
0.9611868858337402,
0.6573696732521057,
0.23410247266292572,
0.4911668598651886,
0.38368192315101624,
0.2491496056318283,
0.8063145279884338,
0.5325635075569153,
0.8497418761253357,
-0.6368793845176697,
0.40399837493896484,
-0.04380062222480774,
-0.3273102939128876,
-0.15569338202476501,
-0.9919329881668091,
-0.7031736969947815,
-1.0393664836883545,
-0.27278876304626465,
-0.16846409440040588,
0.5496703386306763,
0.8214524388313293,
0.36832278966903687,
-0.7885725498199463,
0.2897290885448456,
-0.010981005616486073,
-0.11585313081741333,
-0.480778306722641,
-0.23469732701778412,
0.5015902519226074,
-0.8283143043518066,
-0.528319776058197,
0.4966699779033661,
0.30754411220550537,
0.05891028046607971,
-0.017476337030529976,
0.21918606758117676,
-0.09776180982589722,
0.12133707106113434,
0.9852842092514038,
0.10042735189199448,
-0.7909469604492188,
-0.9604130983352661,
-0.20837923884391785,
-0.010504872538149357,
0.060819581151008606,
1.1431511640548706,
-0.8933688998222351,
0.466668963432312,
0.5590212345123291,
0.605330765247345,
0.752659261226654,
-0.3915756642818451,
0.25787076354026794,
-0.43718400597572327,
0.1848514974117279,
0.16355934739112854,
0.5042600631713867,
0.1643587052822113,
-0.01716463826596737,
0.587644636631012,
0.6139327883720398,
-0.7260165810585022,
-0.47183647751808167,
0.39604195952415466,
-0.7470445036888123,
-0.31742534041404724,
0.8613767027854919,
0.08163774758577347,
-0.22111876308918,
-0.3547937572002411,
-0.27056968212127686,
0.25114905834198,
-0.31398773193359375,
0.9267091751098633,
0.9062706232070923,
-0.36279165744781494,
0.24004733562469482,
-0.7472892999649048,
0.6111986041069031,
0.1878615915775299,
-0.5729843378067017,
0.0831533744931221,
0.10838175565004349,
0.29204797744750977,
0.32304254174232483,
0.5784819722175598,
-0.5758939385414124,
0.2618657052516937,
0.0848504975438118,
-0.09997957199811935,
0.16685284674167633,
-0.07208210974931717,
-0.23254577815532684,
-0.2959558963775635,
-0.06565805524587631,
-0.2017868310213089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14021v1 | Accelerating Retrieval-Augmented Language Model Serving with Speculation | 2024-01-25T09:06:44 | 2024-01-25T09:06:44 | Zhihao Zhang, Alan Zhu, Lijie Yang, Yihua Xu, Lanting Li, Phitchaya Mangpo Phothilimthana, Zhihao Jia | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval-augmented language models (RaLM) have demonstrated the potential to
solve knowledge-intensive natural language processing (NLP) tasks by combining
a non-parametric knowledge base with a parametric language model. Instead of
fine-tuning a fully parametric model, RaLM excels at its low-cost adaptation to
the latest data and better source attribution mechanisms. Among various RaLM
approaches, iterative RaLM delivers a better generation quality due to a more
frequent interaction between the retriever and the language model. Despite the
benefits, iterative RaLM usually encounters high overheads due to the frequent
retrieval step. To this end, we propose RaLMSpec, a speculation-inspired
framework that provides generic speed-up over iterative RaLM while preserving
the same model outputs through speculative retrieval and batched verification.
By further incorporating prefetching, optimal speculation stride scheduler, and
asynchronous verification, RaLMSpec can automatically exploit the acceleration
potential to the fullest. For naive iterative RaLM serving, extensive
evaluations over three language models on four downstream QA datasets
demonstrate that RaLMSpec can achieve a speed-up ratio of 1.75-2.39x,
1.04-1.39x, and 1.31-1.77x when the retriever is an exact dense retriever,
approximate dense retriever, and sparse retriever respectively compared with
the baseline. For KNN-LM serving, RaLMSpec can achieve a speed-up ratio up to
7.59x and 2.45x when the retriever is an exact dense retriever and approximate
dense retriever, respectively, compared with the baseline. | [
-0.37525662779808044,
-0.7505477666854858,
0.5563280582427979,
0.3089340329170227,
-0.07881315797567368,
0.24893508851528168,
-0.3924746811389923,
-0.6416354775428772,
0.34110262989997864,
0.697498619556427,
-0.5815619826316833,
-0.26678553223609924,
-0.5048587918281555,
-0.08143238723278046,
-0.6744363307952881,
0.789061963558197,
0.09681271016597748,
-0.4236060082912445,
-0.18717747926712036,
-0.024261845275759697,
-0.24646839499473572,
-0.24812082946300507,
-0.6546275615692139,
-0.12070879340171814,
0.5683993697166443,
0.5664013624191284,
0.8789339661598206,
0.6875852346420288,
0.2578096091747284,
0.245026096701622,
0.11699480563402176,
0.3345910906791687,
-0.5007540583610535,
0.6730112433433533,
-0.18155136704444885,
-0.22908923029899597,
-0.21225367486476898,
-0.26254165172576904,
0.5452356338500977,
0.43347397446632385,
-0.5874527096748352,
0.33563393354415894,
-0.22099347412586212,
0.7359107732772827,
-0.9768199324607849,
-0.24903884530067444,
-0.831054151058197,
-0.3407987654209137,
-0.508999228477478,
-0.4587874710559845,
-0.7302485704421997,
-0.44560062885284424,
0.1241680160164833,
-0.6968528628349304,
0.19440841674804688,
0.6702854037284851,
0.9713497757911682,
0.2684483230113983,
0.06626740097999573,
-0.19569554924964905,
-0.9147984981536865,
0.7160272598266602,
-0.9266400933265686,
0.436196893453598,
0.4684750735759735,
0.5598935484886169,
-0.059972699731588364,
-1.0495023727416992,
-0.361465185880661,
-0.38291943073272705,
0.028752418234944344,
-0.32927364110946655,
-0.11082716286182404,
-0.04066000506281853,
0.41298192739486694,
0.4607844948768616,
-0.6637104749679565,
0.051706910133361816,
-0.16916576027870178,
-0.2569364309310913,
0.5895287990570068,
0.3182518780231476,
0.23294323682785034,
0.1650271862745285,
-0.29673105478286743,
-0.0816565603017807,
-0.726085364818573,
-0.045518964529037476,
0.21491925418376923,
0.4222799241542816,
0.31094714999198914,
0.5930318832397461,
-0.5742007493972778,
0.8845789432525635,
-0.1845356673002243,
0.10522165894508362,
0.12241018563508987,
-0.3410380184650421,
-0.033367738127708435,
-0.022665055468678474,
0.7910394072532654,
0.01690252125263214,
-0.11532527953386307,
-0.3399343490600586,
-0.38641685247421265,
0.04819496348500252,
0.39787787199020386,
-0.9494895935058594,
-0.001454899087548256,
0.22690105438232422,
-0.053920041769742966,
-0.09605222195386887,
-0.1791418343782425,
-0.8592994809150696,
-0.07237222045660019,
0.00028843586915172637,
0.5307613015174866,
-0.5859854221343994,
-0.2265825718641281,
0.41058847308158875,
0.13065354526042938,
-0.07062681019306183,
0.25339797139167786,
-0.764274537563324,
0.4715408384799957,
0.6924472451210022,
0.7591540217399597,
-0.31919610500335693,
-0.16965995728969574,
-0.728877067565918,
-0.08272615820169449,
-0.4402850568294525,
1.1277580261230469,
-0.8990421295166016,
-0.11525756120681763,
-0.0022553298622369766,
-0.24969685077667236,
-0.1212545782327652,
-0.19617649912834167,
0.9950070381164551,
-1.0428800582885742,
0.2772635817527771,
-0.42245277762413025,
-0.7388203144073486,
0.019715124741196632,
0.17081710696220398,
-0.6642469763755798,
1.6324251890182495,
-0.1637769341468811,
-1.0334091186523438,
0.32258448004722595,
-0.6649008393287659,
-0.5354582071304321,
0.2367122769355774,
0.03636356443166733,
-0.157864049077034,
0.08319900929927826,
0.29717856645584106,
0.11980926245450974,
-0.6342079639434814,
0.1240030974149704,
-0.11181048303842545,
-0.6407918930053711,
-0.04095867648720741,
-0.2757009267807007,
0.534963071346283,
0.4904676079750061,
-0.28978002071380615,
0.11262006312608719,
-0.7213519811630249,
0.3942837715148926,
0.007691247388720512,
-0.09207800030708313,
-0.4379655122756958,
0.26888757944107056,
-0.2362319678068161,
0.2445044070482254,
0.34458327293395996,
-0.5760883092880249,
0.1739283800125122,
-0.5680021643638611,
0.06420563906431198,
0.5143253207206726,
0.07442213594913483,
0.47720998525619507,
-0.21965235471725464,
0.7257965207099915,
-0.5106920599937439,
0.24910855293273926,
-0.1834876835346222,
-0.5371151566505432,
-0.7942662835121155,
-0.18851502239704132,
0.34740015864372253,
0.30987271666526794,
-1.0995959043502808,
-0.0031166928820312023,
-0.26468828320503235,
-0.49342671036720276,
-0.8228246569633484,
-0.242892324924469,
0.3179899752140045,
0.6570653915405273,
0.34899312257766724,
0.1047346219420433,
-0.5249106287956238,
-0.7913388609886169,
-0.5368208885192871,
0.0017452666070312262,
0.08190081268548965,
0.34908896684646606,
0.10433970391750336,
0.04158115014433861,
0.8663741946220398,
-0.48172810673713684,
0.09363241493701935,
-0.08418504148721695,
0.40171265602111816,
0.32471081614494324,
0.3649553656578064,
0.4694731831550598,
-0.5213748216629028,
-0.7534754872322083,
0.15065863728523254,
-0.3304855227470398,
-0.1730251908302307,
0.2532328963279724,
-0.1753014475107193,
0.22314274311065674,
0.2679034471511841,
-0.551159679889679,
0.26266223192214966,
0.42024746537208557,
-0.29528218507766724,
0.6903504133224487,
-0.4724561274051666,
0.46159252524375916,
-0.7476626634597778,
0.1396910548210144,
-0.46767139434814453,
-0.15655389428138733,
-0.7507058382034302,
0.2627057135105133,
0.23071323335170746,
-0.016081392765045166,
-0.2595437467098236,
0.7060384750366211,
-0.5150550603866577,
-0.3240673840045929,
-0.4954981505870819,
0.23105736076831818,
0.11242616176605225,
0.21763154864311218,
0.059366822242736816,
1.3020975589752197,
0.8342305421829224,
-0.8112310767173767,
-0.06858332455158234,
-0.24545013904571533,
-0.4581493139266968,
-0.19593583047389984,
-0.5165475010871887,
0.40944135189056396,
0.03233036398887634,
-0.04727720469236374,
-0.6572251915931702,
-0.021658649668097496,
-0.07526491582393646,
-0.34046563506126404,
0.004147589672356844,
0.11206863075494766,
-0.7939544916152954,
-0.6037399172782898,
-0.31121131777763367,
0.4337314963340759,
0.5338678359985352,
-0.5419749021530151,
0.7950433492660522,
0.03485635295510292,
0.018218504264950752,
-1.0773729085922241,
-0.36087945103645325,
0.060697123408317566,
0.11827395111322403,
-0.71573805809021,
0.4295249283313751,
0.012146912515163422,
-0.12471708655357361,
0.08319501578807831,
-0.03231562301516533,
-0.03643506392836571,
0.06902766227722168,
0.08631149679422379,
0.2328311949968338,
-0.3311547636985779,
0.03302207216620445,
0.14320389926433563,
-0.007643619552254677,
-0.16223019361495972,
-0.3109719753265381,
0.6442802548408508,
-0.02383175678551197,
-0.43692806363105774,
-0.18620967864990234,
0.20365186035633087,
0.533383309841156,
-0.29355642199516296,
0.6541833877563477,
0.4043329358100891,
-0.24867044389247894,
-0.3210456967353821,
-0.9096289277076721,
-0.34047722816467285,
-0.5131998658180237,
0.35308122634887695,
-0.30521848797798157,
-0.9192927479743958,
0.6568776965141296,
0.16135168075561523,
0.4288668930530548,
0.5088104009628296,
0.5203039050102234,
0.18308036029338837,
0.9867680072784424,
0.6147555708885193,
0.061434805393218994,
0.38376089930534363,
0.11891698837280273,
0.2278304547071457,
-0.5741583108901978,
-0.1871592402458191,
-0.8453822731971741,
0.008848685771226883,
-0.32652661204338074,
-0.8850690722465515,
0.01646309904754162,
0.08307047188282013,
-0.08288776874542236,
0.4899939000606537,
-0.463763952255249,
0.4105830192565918,
0.4084475636482239,
-0.1622960865497589,
0.6223354935646057,
0.09733004868030548,
-0.3664935231208801,
-0.17970970273017883,
-0.8545010685920715,
-0.28808096051216125,
1.0340867042541504,
0.08417018502950668,
0.7510606050491333,
-0.06876225024461746,
0.37647148966789246,
0.4907313585281372,
0.43231576681137085,
-0.35563933849334717,
0.5439931154251099,
-0.06017129868268967,
-0.7617708444595337,
-0.03833122178912163,
-0.34650877118110657,
-0.5720214247703552,
0.26470476388931274,
-0.23989470303058624,
-0.650772213935852,
0.16616855561733246,
0.3968249559402466,
-0.3616877794265747,
0.3643363118171692,
-0.5166895389556885,
0.37744536995887756,
-0.13857075572013855,
-0.6131235957145691,
-0.6330468654632568,
-0.548270046710968,
0.4481279253959656,
0.07628748565912247,
0.12583956122398376,
-0.18521153926849365,
-0.07217760384082794,
0.5763224363327026,
-0.5142955780029297,
0.2260756492614746,
-0.27010491490364075,
-0.07360383123159409,
0.25302430987358093,
0.33805471658706665,
0.9435248374938965,
0.041654136031866074,
-0.5268791913986206,
-0.2654758095741272,
-0.18105891346931458,
-0.4662802219390869,
-0.8310248255729675,
0.7065974473953247,
-0.43592575192451477,
-0.6757509708404541,
-0.3469201624393463,
-0.7437970042228699,
-0.5531579256057739,
0.18080873787403107,
0.22250446677207947,
0.40682825446128845,
0.04464476555585861,
-0.0381174236536026,
0.6171492338180542,
-0.1835981011390686,
0.2833177447319031,
0.9109021425247192,
-0.6220965385437012,
0.012495461851358414,
0.8942864537239075,
-0.1710062474012375,
0.4711354970932007,
0.44145667552948,
0.07392919808626175,
-0.4209631383419037,
-0.6514115333557129,
-0.42274075746536255,
0.15429367125034332,
-0.47876062989234924,
-0.3335818350315094,
-0.9035570621490479,
-0.21633806824684143,
-0.24046051502227783,
-0.03516901656985283,
-0.7826027274131775,
-0.6475191116333008,
-0.027569610625505447,
0.05784311890602112,
0.8572297096252441,
0.5717366337776184,
0.08284838497638702,
0.23212607204914093,
-0.5293002724647522,
0.098602294921875,
0.013230840675532818,
0.420705646276474,
0.18376852571964264,
-0.8947876691818237,
-0.2804468274116516,
-0.021653972566127777,
0.24422548711299896,
-0.4102390706539154,
0.5005341172218323,
0.2607579231262207,
0.4804539978504181,
0.45427295565605164,
0.24301151931285858,
0.8448728322982788,
-0.6675103306770325,
0.7023887634277344,
-0.2756863534450531,
-0.5726705193519592,
0.3789205253124237,
-0.061328258365392685,
-0.07287710905075073,
0.7671322822570801,
0.39697393774986267,
-0.4250033497810364,
-0.5561699867248535,
-0.502469003200531,
-1.0007463693618774,
0.7035666108131409,
0.18918545544147491,
-0.0029279773589223623,
-0.20789746940135956,
0.6504389643669128,
0.2228020429611206,
0.21702837944030762,
-0.17606428265571594,
-0.4248378574848175,
-0.0290471613407135,
0.16929516196250916,
0.2836305797100067,
-0.5241291522979736,
0.11603766679763794,
-0.1298442780971527,
0.9344803094863892,
-0.01567978225648403,
0.3315294086933136,
0.048516858369112015,
-0.2189139425754547,
-0.07759104669094086,
0.32405999302864075,
0.693580150604248,
0.6082785129547119,
-0.4795573055744171,
0.21657146513462067,
0.0008666595094837248,
-0.3653665781021118,
-0.11472120136022568,
0.17417557537555695,
-0.261587530374527,
0.1361740529537201,
0.10884139686822891,
1.0416516065597534,
0.3789815306663513,
-0.9304618835449219,
0.20846468210220337,
-0.2630693316459656,
-0.09924683719873428,
0.09843990206718445,
0.05060580000281334,
0.021487098187208176,
0.11184293776750565,
0.7013648748397827,
0.2970722019672394,
0.22992435097694397,
-0.17649278044700623,
0.5205895900726318,
0.45150938630104065,
-0.04550407454371452,
-0.35646146535873413,
0.7316563725471497,
-0.08492088317871094,
-0.3033248782157898,
0.5338103175163269,
-0.3275417387485504,
-0.4360654950141907,
0.27311447262763977,
0.7051123976707458,
0.8121330142021179,
-0.26134151220321655,
0.19424813985824585,
0.5213010907173157,
0.18945007026195526,
-0.4841249883174896,
0.2671979069709778,
-0.23917652666568756,
-0.7184236645698547,
-0.949767529964447,
-0.7813464999198914,
-0.3900340497493744,
-0.3326073884963989,
-0.8412328958511353,
0.07214342802762985,
-0.27466481924057007,
-0.033067453652620316,
-0.34601154923439026,
0.07868313789367676,
-0.539466142654419,
-0.17085815966129303,
-0.1888757348060608,
1.3182913064956665,
-0.7554327249526978,
1.274715781211853,
0.41964927315711975,
-0.20133531093597412,
-0.8502482175827026,
0.03222193941473961,
-0.45176953077316284,
-0.9892600178718567,
0.7133597731590271,
-0.13548347353935242,
-0.33977100253105164,
0.1980799287557602,
-0.16484208405017853,
-1.2014877796173096,
1.040747880935669,
0.4130055606365204,
-0.7661745548248291,
-0.28204280138015747,
-0.06525453180074692,
0.6521234512329102,
-0.47486162185668945,
0.4096209704875946,
0.4507741630077362,
0.4483523368835449,
0.30309247970581055,
-0.6641851663589478,
0.2124207615852356,
-0.12133412808179855,
0.11753854900598526,
0.12656164169311523,
-0.2605416476726532,
0.8155694007873535,
-0.25558340549468994,
-0.4470849931240082,
0.24491308629512787,
0.8086026310920715,
0.4256800711154938,
0.008981719613075256,
0.5583600997924805,
0.6124398708343506,
0.8600810766220093,
0.09878958016633987,
1.361948013305664,
-0.6396534442901611,
0.3719308376312256,
1.2529349327087402,
-0.5299542546272278,
1.0462825298309326,
0.4503155052661896,
-0.1335860788822174,
0.6623502969741821,
0.44432803988456726,
0.47067320346832275,
0.4854348599910736,
-0.2915872037410736,
-0.2897437810897827,
-0.24581333994865417,
-0.17597629129886627,
-0.3092409372329712,
-0.004014843609184027,
0.3630344271659851,
-0.1499125063419342,
-0.4535265862941742,
0.037985749542713165,
-0.13506637513637543,
0.22855797410011292,
-0.20577372610569,
0.3998352587223053,
-0.30140024423599243,
-0.8058465719223022,
0.6243333220481873,
-0.045250002294778824,
0.8249949812889099,
-0.7088048458099365,
0.1268424391746521,
-0.18673457205295563,
-0.03725528344511986,
-0.028712093830108643,
-0.4814092218875885,
0.4083136022090912,
-0.07509692013263702,
-0.17538699507713318,
-0.2957206964492798,
0.9576556086540222,
-0.4295874536037445,
-0.4280567765235901,
0.450074702501297,
0.3872739374637604,
-0.09849736094474792,
-0.15898126363754272,
-0.7707937955856323,
0.32120805978775024,
-0.010141703300178051,
-0.46899253129959106,
0.35611751675605774,
0.41552844643592834,
-0.1583728790283203,
0.9707940220832825,
0.7049071192741394,
0.24432149529457092,
0.4115558862686157,
0.24516765773296356,
1.0280745029449463,
-0.5224611163139343,
-0.38500887155532837,
-0.659296989440918,
0.2814880907535553,
-0.08403265476226807,
0.06259389966726303,
0.924110472202301,
0.5673550367355347,
0.3317294418811798,
0.14632642269134521,
0.23208601772785187,
-0.2982981204986572,
0.7995185256004333,
-0.4859023988246918,
0.6416410207748413,
-0.5987507700920105,
0.4809598922729492,
-0.12282230705022812,
-0.7541642189025879,
-0.11730311065912247,
0.3851653039455414,
-0.2941652834415436,
-0.06092052906751633,
0.7101737260818481,
0.9662590622901917,
0.1205979585647583,
0.21094180643558502,
0.30730485916137695,
0.28576305508613586,
0.20186665654182434,
0.15823239088058472,
0.6817319989204407,
-0.4535311162471771,
0.40490081906318665,
-0.508844792842865,
-0.019260084256529808,
-0.18554092943668365,
-0.906985342502594,
-0.511292040348053,
-0.4685554802417755,
-0.10868635028600693,
-0.3498671054840088,
0.3100091814994812,
0.8730918765068054,
0.6217595338821411,
-0.7201071977615356,
-0.040769707411527634,
-0.27538105845451355,
0.07616791129112244,
-0.4814828932285309,
-0.340010404586792,
0.321631520986557,
-0.7120715379714966,
-0.6152850985527039,
0.6799270510673523,
0.4366287887096405,
-0.509982168674469,
-0.28175610303878784,
-0.06571092456579208,
-0.5166926980018616,
0.07068478316068649,
0.5403791069984436,
0.5364652872085571,
-0.7084227204322815,
-0.14149808883666992,
0.2491728961467743,
-0.024042725563049316,
0.004386688582599163,
1.104203701019287,
-1.060640573501587,
0.499330073595047,
0.43933719396591187,
0.9910131692886353,
0.7956612706184387,
0.11783263832330704,
0.6837331056594849,
-0.8730725049972534,
0.39600688219070435,
0.5465751886367798,
0.16952916979789734,
0.11882546544075012,
-0.4652844965457916,
0.21189676225185394,
-0.035298798233270645,
-0.6447961330413818,
-1.1627177000045776,
0.1370067298412323,
-0.6621518731117249,
-0.1830662190914154,
0.9164555668830872,
-0.02621634677052498,
-0.26196882128715515,
-0.14956995844841003,
0.08966794610023499,
-0.16715189814567566,
-0.6602665781974792,
0.6207461953163147,
0.28451451659202576,
-0.10676423460245132,
-0.19673016667366028,
-0.8232926726341248,
0.7555323839187622,
0.6912021040916443,
-0.7275854349136353,
0.510295569896698,
0.2528035640716553,
0.2801389694213867,
0.13740657269954681,
0.8347281217575073,
-0.22653573751449585,
0.25264450907707214,
-0.09094495326280594,
0.21004286408424377,
-0.11605598777532578,
-0.2003486305475235,
0.10405369848012924,
0.2817998230457306,
0.3207627534866333,
0.18820714950561523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14019v1 | Unitxt: Flexible, Shareable and Reusable Data Preparation and Evaluation for Generative AI | 2024-01-25T08:57:33 | 2024-01-25T08:57:33 | Elron Bandel, Yotam Perlitz, Elad Venezian, Roni Friedman-Melamed, Ofir Arviv, Matan Orbach, Shachar Don-Yehyia, Dafna Sheinwald, Ariel Gera, Leshem Choshen, Michal Shmueli-Scheuer, Yoav Katz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the dynamic landscape of generative NLP, traditional text processing
pipelines limit research flexibility and reproducibility, as they are tailored
to specific dataset, task, and model combinations. The escalating complexity,
involving system prompts, model-specific formats, instructions, and more, calls
for a shift to a structured, modular, and customizable solution. Addressing
this need, we present Unitxt, an innovative library for customizable textual
data preparation and evaluation tailored to generative language models. Unitxt
natively integrates with common libraries like HuggingFace and LM-eval-harness
and deconstructs processing flows into modular components, enabling easy
customization and sharing between practitioners. These components encompass
model-specific formats, task prompts, and many other comprehensive dataset
processing definitions. The Unitxt-Catalog centralizes these components,
fostering collaboration and exploration in modern textual data workflows.
Beyond being a tool, Unitxt is a community-driven platform, empowering users to
build, share, and advance their pipelines collaboratively. Join the Unitxt
community at https://github.com/IBM/unitxt! | [
-0.2717721462249756,
-0.7140312194824219,
0.6795284152030945,
0.30644214153289795,
0.041246090084314346,
0.34806767106056213,
-0.25141066312789917,
-0.0910177156329155,
0.35537809133529663,
0.5913975238800049,
-0.5414814949035645,
-0.8451492190361023,
-0.03829444572329521,
0.05811886489391327,
-0.6233155727386475,
0.9249964356422424,
-0.17182588577270508,
-0.27562546730041504,
-0.8791822791099548,
-0.5616496205329895,
-0.5279237031936646,
-0.5826760530471802,
-0.6934413313865662,
-0.6150879263877869,
0.7406114935874939,
0.4685264229774475,
0.9325571060180664,
0.5688446760177612,
0.2782449722290039,
0.40270093083381653,
0.25627419352531433,
-0.13031506538391113,
-0.2394144982099533,
0.8331089615821838,
-0.153345987200737,
-0.45007047057151794,
-0.809717059135437,
-0.04858091473579407,
0.6832519173622131,
0.8049266934394836,
-0.33123254776000977,
-0.01576412282884121,
-0.17396686971187592,
0.6613062024116516,
-0.574827253818512,
0.06125375255942345,
-0.3845900297164917,
0.17569147050380707,
-0.34622880816459656,
0.07905454933643341,
-0.6241247057914734,
-0.2373926043510437,
-0.05623820796608925,
-0.9174019694328308,
0.3462457060813904,
-0.1543920487165451,
0.4307718276977539,
0.38481834530830383,
0.09312956035137177,
0.07591273635625839,
-0.6978374719619751,
0.6669866442680359,
-0.3647432327270508,
0.42319023609161377,
0.2678065299987793,
0.3419170081615448,
-0.03197808563709259,
-1.288955569267273,
-0.6332644820213318,
-0.0010122733656316996,
-0.1359453946352005,
0.22525261342525482,
-0.5031061172485352,
0.0854228064417839,
0.044708482921123505,
0.34552329778671265,
-0.7435573935508728,
0.20472678542137146,
0.16295164823532104,
-0.08430939167737961,
0.6832077503204346,
0.3277273178100586,
0.4996510446071625,
-0.13154441118240356,
-0.2640444338321686,
-0.24193689227104187,
-0.6353527307510376,
-0.3336219787597656,
0.06276827305555344,
0.11719713360071182,
-0.052840378135442734,
0.5665368437767029,
-0.29874387383461,
0.4507569372653961,
-0.3892882168292999,
0.42857810854911804,
0.3480200469493866,
-0.16943885385990143,
-0.5464569926261902,
-0.057003676891326904,
1.1051936149597168,
-0.03938746452331543,
-0.3407142162322998,
-0.33308812975883484,
-0.4253010153770447,
-0.0011568971676751971,
0.5749636888504028,
-0.7162843942642212,
-0.28563278913497925,
0.46136555075645447,
-0.4622099995613098,
-0.3982103168964386,
-0.19528576731681824,
-0.8631690740585327,
-0.3377578556537628,
-0.6407682299613953,
0.24147121608257294,
-0.45222216844558716,
-0.2772071957588196,
-0.04024071991443634,
-0.16397756338119507,
0.023568395525217056,
0.4391399621963501,
-0.8630164861679077,
0.27296704053878784,
0.9250158667564392,
0.7948691248893738,
-0.45754125714302063,
-0.26548489928245544,
-0.6312881708145142,
-0.1113537922501564,
-0.13679274916648865,
0.7476660013198853,
-0.7829788327217102,
-0.5718373656272888,
-0.08369340002536774,
-0.14942657947540283,
-0.017597105354070663,
-0.501810610294342,
0.6268473267555237,
-0.4723148047924042,
-0.026645367965102196,
0.1530800461769104,
-0.640794038772583,
0.32410624623298645,
0.10545612126588821,
-0.8612932562828064,
1.2547171115875244,
0.4560947120189667,
-0.5077829360961914,
0.18516890704631805,
-0.7958495616912842,
-0.48707863688468933,
0.6695360541343689,
-0.566425085067749,
-0.48318275809288025,
0.28654244542121887,
0.06742608547210693,
0.4267391860485077,
-0.22224989533424377,
0.3692645728588104,
-0.1431988626718521,
-0.08195941895246506,
0.2593621015548706,
-0.5135995745658875,
0.6901496052742004,
0.5033907890319824,
-0.12135376036167145,
0.5922768712043762,
-0.9748154878616333,
0.2213335782289505,
0.007844503037631512,
-0.3305458724498749,
-0.47602909803390503,
-0.19606450200080872,
0.3358561396598816,
-0.3882874846458435,
0.12868350744247437,
-0.40615877509117126,
0.4907297194004059,
0.051842834800481796,
0.3960947096347809,
0.6207446455955505,
-0.5809902548789978,
0.5322756767272949,
-0.1033281683921814,
0.7976162433624268,
-0.3727668225765228,
0.13508136570453644,
-0.4282630980014801,
-0.4969596564769745,
-0.8855668902397156,
-0.28089433908462524,
0.34863215684890747,
0.42560502886772156,
-1.2714585065841675,
0.3733471632003784,
-0.19537094235420227,
-0.7537683844566345,
-0.8541733026504517,
-0.08185260742902756,
0.22565597295761108,
0.4320673942565918,
0.3178132176399231,
-0.3931131362915039,
-0.8251744508743286,
-0.7965110540390015,
0.32108768820762634,
-0.22031784057617188,
-0.3384142816066742,
-0.00669652596116066,
0.24905042350292206,
-0.6721575260162354,
1.265800952911377,
-0.6209675669670105,
-0.0842350646853447,
-0.5446931719779968,
0.5540184378623962,
-0.08203653991222382,
0.5564910769462585,
0.3023017942905426,
-0.745901882648468,
-0.21025992929935455,
0.15583428740501404,
-1.0922021865844727,
-0.3419840335845947,
-0.20977364480495453,
-0.32447317242622375,
0.15002137422561646,
0.6609286069869995,
-0.5740756392478943,
0.4117722511291504,
0.6430647373199463,
-0.4192698001861572,
0.5574665665626526,
-0.3339385688304901,
-0.03881027549505234,
-1.1766893863677979,
0.29924848675727844,
-0.3539131283760071,
-0.42625030875205994,
-0.7506318688392639,
0.4303339123725891,
-0.09988666325807571,
-0.16437874734401703,
-0.23376694321632385,
0.3673975467681885,
-0.029051801189780235,
-0.13202117383480072,
-0.11734712868928909,
0.08023843169212341,
0.3520388603210449,
-0.08763159066438675,
0.29716309905052185,
0.8426313996315002,
0.41026750206947327,
-0.29996535181999207,
0.5414623618125916,
0.38340291380882263,
-0.26752176880836487,
0.7260881662368774,
-0.7779660224914551,
0.35296785831451416,
-0.05607551708817482,
0.045682016760110855,
-0.4887159764766693,
-0.17818808555603027,
-0.010606538504362106,
-0.38946080207824707,
0.17702707648277283,
-0.05045969784259796,
-0.3939533233642578,
-0.001752024400047958,
-0.17237399518489838,
0.5612189769744873,
0.3416929244995117,
-0.6340750455856323,
0.8133330941200256,
0.41356799006462097,
-0.12221381068229675,
-0.3720666170120239,
-0.5973701477050781,
0.3919084370136261,
-0.06494753062725067,
-0.5945767760276794,
0.6653653979301453,
-0.34222158789634705,
-0.38481202721595764,
0.12561200559139252,
0.3297045826911926,
-0.17936238646507263,
0.21299228072166443,
0.36839738488197327,
0.35416021943092346,
-0.3038420081138611,
0.36414459347724915,
0.08192373812198639,
-0.38406819105148315,
-0.21855860948562622,
0.03782716020941734,
0.6204149127006531,
-0.13976691663265228,
-0.22851653397083282,
-0.4821931719779968,
0.5512211918830872,
0.43264588713645935,
0.007990959100425243,
0.4729765057563782,
0.9057677984237671,
-0.41370049118995667,
-0.25667494535446167,
-0.25962531566619873,
0.11999396234750748,
-0.491029292345047,
0.12239807844161987,
-0.49457043409347534,
-0.9081147909164429,
0.07265979051589966,
0.055674515664577484,
0.12629976868629456,
0.3839947283267975,
0.5731943845748901,
-0.058665111660957336,
0.6900182366371155,
0.7782014608383179,
-0.081497922539711,
0.31014761328697205,
-0.22485078871250153,
0.01252760086208582,
-0.9134031534194946,
-0.2269064486026764,
-0.6287738680839539,
-0.18096426129341125,
-0.4394661784172058,
-0.5075922608375549,
0.216713547706604,
-0.19544099271297455,
-0.06835345923900604,
0.5026868581771851,
-0.6878419518470764,
0.5188548564910889,
0.5978402495384216,
-0.394252210855484,
0.6176137328147888,
-0.07700455188751221,
0.06558176130056381,
-0.18680542707443237,
-0.6248785257339478,
-0.5478017330169678,
1.0567305088043213,
0.14650031924247742,
0.7495301365852356,
-0.023119639605283737,
0.7640520334243774,
0.6051448583602905,
0.7274999618530273,
-0.8802607655525208,
0.6439952254295349,
-0.2657204866409302,
-0.07402444630861282,
-0.33918800950050354,
-0.45870402455329895,
-1.2838969230651855,
0.12294942885637283,
-0.18437716364860535,
-0.693964421749115,
0.10274534672498703,
-0.2093542516231537,
-0.4232746660709381,
0.28528088331222534,
-0.6412349343299866,
0.850865364074707,
0.0902334600687027,
-0.23018379509449005,
-0.059194207191467285,
-0.18655693531036377,
0.07340579479932785,
0.042612213641405106,
0.04488716274499893,
-0.01810123585164547,
-0.04277011752128601,
0.6330457925796509,
-0.6574087738990784,
0.7145259380340576,
0.10457175225019455,
0.12682917714118958,
0.2140444964170456,
0.17898854613304138,
0.034158144146203995,
0.37772825360298157,
-0.3586554527282715,
0.21275658905506134,
0.005872239358723164,
-0.10674849897623062,
-0.6452889442443848,
0.7216160893440247,
-0.8826976418495178,
-0.45115727186203003,
-0.4146620035171509,
-0.6718662977218628,
0.07005457580089569,
0.15896108746528625,
0.11450188606977463,
0.4117540419101715,
-0.6848545670509338,
0.4399506151676178,
0.6058458685874939,
-0.19375580549240112,
0.5274525880813599,
0.2709999978542328,
-0.47378918528556824,
-0.4698200225830078,
0.9548766016960144,
-0.3574540913105011,
0.14567725360393524,
0.591880202293396,
0.12150402367115021,
-0.0025766193866729736,
-0.42943301796913147,
-0.667071521282196,
-0.27364835143089294,
-0.4516112208366394,
-0.39172327518463135,
-0.6154779195785522,
-0.34164053201675415,
-0.1995459944009781,
-0.4363662004470825,
-0.7493152618408203,
-0.4709341824054718,
-0.39257511496543884,
-0.08932750672101974,
0.35053563117980957,
0.822807788848877,
-0.033857304602861404,
0.324373722076416,
-0.6765325665473938,
0.1719585806131363,
0.4104909598827362,
0.35490894317626953,
-0.20235373079776764,
0.09773813188076019,
-0.05521348491311073,
-0.28288039565086365,
-0.2976011037826538,
-0.4269111156463623,
0.5051631927490234,
0.03903902322053909,
0.3431834876537323,
0.2549225986003876,
0.195846289396286,
0.3911115229129791,
-0.39560920000076294,
0.7445377707481384,
0.24756738543510437,
-1.0818467140197754,
0.6111703515052795,
-0.10391192138195038,
0.30562397837638855,
0.6346104741096497,
0.2557905614376068,
-0.7937607169151306,
-0.2648722529411316,
-0.6403721570968628,
-1.098211407661438,
0.4838930070400238,
0.6665142774581909,
0.06049134582281113,
0.2928686738014221,
0.37839221954345703,
0.4258558750152588,
0.1602018028497696,
-0.4424622356891632,
-0.35970890522003174,
-0.373683899641037,
-0.46231257915496826,
0.07870588451623917,
-0.12450922280550003,
-0.3610554039478302,
-0.2683775722980499,
0.4212048053741455,
-0.3200918138027191,
0.3257864713668823,
0.1807173490524292,
-0.027779050171375275,
0.20882169902324677,
0.4696364998817444,
0.156721293926239,
0.4887714087963104,
-0.14452281594276428,
0.2012156993150711,
-0.13658128678798676,
-0.637106716632843,
0.055727072060108185,
0.35570529103279114,
-0.48279914259910583,
0.24410034716129303,
0.4302908778190613,
0.7982559204101562,
0.0984085202217102,
-0.7909361124038696,
0.11258161067962646,
-0.6054343581199646,
-0.0962924137711525,
-0.3870899975299835,
0.2267751842737198,
0.06645036488771439,
0.05660833790898323,
0.23504717648029327,
0.040544960647821426,
0.1384602040052414,
-0.4903527498245239,
0.3147755265235901,
0.0476241298019886,
-0.47540777921676636,
-0.37323495745658875,
0.8021652698516846,
0.2122502475976944,
-0.47348830103874207,
0.8814289569854736,
-0.3381231427192688,
-0.061169352382421494,
0.5183632969856262,
0.34538665413856506,
1.1111459732055664,
-0.25920653343200684,
0.7755885124206543,
0.07279469817876816,
0.08514831215143204,
0.36975446343421936,
0.09218776226043701,
-0.12308377772569656,
-0.9590798020362854,
-0.20734307169914246,
-0.828936755657196,
-0.6572455763816833,
0.14910975098609924,
-0.8017333149909973,
0.18930895626544952,
-0.44107499718666077,
-0.06314802914857864,
0.27995094656944275,
-0.30768921971321106,
-0.6670305132865906,
0.1422956883907318,
0.042420268058776855,
0.8068253993988037,
-0.5395645499229431,
1.0189018249511719,
0.7636123895645142,
-0.5356665253639221,
-0.41582703590393066,
-0.32105398178100586,
0.10566400736570358,
-0.6708191633224487,
0.1884385049343109,
0.13867104053497314,
0.2440476417541504,
-0.17220108211040497,
-0.3507319688796997,
-0.5596157312393188,
1.397813081741333,
0.21710559725761414,
-0.48426616191864014,
0.19119124114513397,
0.4314754605293274,
0.7513856291770935,
-0.5998805165290833,
0.3295166492462158,
0.9487778544425964,
0.3833431005477905,
0.20951877534389496,
-0.46095773577690125,
0.11695165932178497,
-0.30457428097724915,
0.2566312849521637,
-0.024846157059073448,
-0.45369091629981995,
0.574722170829773,
0.16980387270450592,
-0.2592127323150635,
0.4238389730453491,
0.6238351464271545,
0.24031810462474823,
0.5544567108154297,
0.509335458278656,
0.8391404151916504,
0.9452046155929565,
-0.4376372694969177,
0.9786929488182068,
0.1722659319639206,
0.08548684418201447,
1.2534116506576538,
-0.36708396673202515,
0.9354502558708191,
0.24139925837516785,
-0.3221763074398041,
0.7044378519058228,
0.35749155282974243,
0.08730676770210266,
0.03545991703867912,
-0.0016693990910425782,
-0.6358757615089417,
-0.2014167755842209,
-0.3704909086227417,
-0.17769156396389008,
0.48051926493644714,
0.49175703525543213,
-0.14149591326713562,
-0.017847871407866478,
-0.00415900768712163,
0.24292553961277008,
0.2537967264652252,
-0.13749225437641144,
0.7099441885948181,
0.03722729533910751,
-0.6126086711883545,
0.22759117186069489,
-0.0644930824637413,
0.48702409863471985,
-0.4821876287460327,
0.08410772681236267,
-0.5190803408622742,
0.11799576133489609,
-0.35851991176605225,
-1.0275954008102417,
0.737341046333313,
0.06443759053945541,
-0.20063748955726624,
-0.5443111062049866,
0.6526591777801514,
-0.30844902992248535,
-0.4829324185848236,
0.2292894721031189,
0.5766478776931763,
0.03189634159207344,
0.07779094576835632,
-0.6463584899902344,
0.5344365835189819,
0.039414163678884506,
-0.2645626366138458,
0.3884776830673218,
0.35878312587738037,
0.06827658414840698,
0.6953251957893372,
0.7510058283805847,
-0.13108325004577637,
-0.44592079520225525,
0.6399524211883545,
0.9804071187973022,
-0.649100661277771,
-0.0036978605203330517,
-0.6220427751541138,
0.7700472474098206,
-0.2410443127155304,
-0.23985232412815094,
0.38723066449165344,
0.6680396199226379,
0.7815474271774292,
0.10469337552785873,
0.9275044202804565,
-0.38019850850105286,
-0.0955815315246582,
-0.44278383255004883,
1.008173942565918,
-0.46557697653770447,
0.3644491136074066,
-0.15280409157276154,
-0.717361569404602,
-0.5214941501617432,
0.27868902683258057,
0.1977464109659195,
-0.132269024848938,
0.6055833697319031,
0.6025939583778381,
0.0768883004784584,
0.2616345286369324,
0.4753754734992981,
0.14637300372123718,
0.643791913986206,
0.214359313249588,
0.5944384932518005,
-0.27443382143974304,
0.4424073398113251,
-0.21311789751052856,
-0.35971322655677795,
0.0029644975438714027,
-0.8385012745857239,
-0.5123441219329834,
-0.8231428861618042,
-0.6133639812469482,
-0.1363232582807541,
-0.0762195959687233,
0.7775009274482727,
0.6426213383674622,
-0.7171717286109924,
-0.28095826506614685,
-0.30736276507377625,
0.40930232405662537,
-0.1609821915626526,
-0.3349955081939697,
0.3291444182395935,
-0.4142000079154968,
-0.9359195232391357,
0.632972240447998,
0.5159348249435425,
-0.03227273002266884,
-0.4031250774860382,
0.03599715977907181,
0.11788008362054825,
-0.16767184436321259,
0.9125233292579651,
0.3937821686267853,
-0.2352716028690338,
-0.021409165114164352,
-0.23567505180835724,
-0.048471033573150635,
0.13127586245536804,
0.9932736158370972,
-1.012664556503296,
0.8367406129837036,
0.4957759380340576,
0.827402651309967,
0.2850349545478821,
-0.22201938927173615,
0.9644206166267395,
-1.0205929279327393,
0.15656617283821106,
0.30955949425697327,
0.43521735072135925,
0.6168370842933655,
-0.34006935358047485,
0.8504345417022705,
0.35584133863449097,
-0.6664007306098938,
-0.6982036828994751,
0.1743500679731369,
-1.1283646821975708,
-0.1667300909757614,
0.8455010652542114,
-0.2382095754146576,
-0.09620486944913864,
-0.04391958937048912,
-0.1333223283290863,
0.08589881658554077,
-0.5105046033859253,
0.6415425539016724,
0.3999195396900177,
-0.14284507930278778,
-0.14983943104743958,
-0.4169498682022095,
0.3980679512023926,
0.32250064611434937,
-1.221280574798584,
0.13631969690322876,
0.3842446506023407,
-0.06610681861639023,
0.15077053010463715,
0.6743054389953613,
0.09167134016752243,
0.07735827565193176,
0.09305460751056671,
0.37113499641418457,
0.08181827515363693,
-0.24192190170288086,
-0.2510552704334259,
0.0867348164319992,
-0.11948917806148529,
0.0004365585627965629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14016v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14016v3 | Towards Uncertainty-Aware Language Agent | 2024-01-25T08:48:21 | 2024-05-30T13:26:38 | Jiuzhou Han, Wray Buntine, Ehsan Shareghi | cs.CL | cs.CL | While Language Agents have achieved promising success by placing Large
Language Models at the core of a more versatile design that dynamically
interacts with the external world, the existing approaches neglect the notion
of uncertainty during these interactions. We present the Uncertainty-Aware
Language Agent (UALA), a framework that orchestrates the interaction between
the agent and the external world using uncertainty quantification. Compared
with other well-known counterparts like ReAct, our extensive experiments across
3 representative tasks (HotpotQA, StrategyQA, MMLU) and various LLM sizes
demonstrate that UALA brings a significant improvement of performance, while
having a substantially lower reliance on the external world (i.e., reduced
number of tool calls and tokens). Our analyses provide various insights
including the great potential of UALA compared with agent fine-tuning, and
underscore the unreliability of verbalised confidence of LLMs as a proxy for
uncertainty. | [
-0.20639093220233917,
-0.8637603521347046,
0.5975094437599182,
0.1153574213385582,
0.32731524109840393,
0.5187501907348633,
-0.14289873838424683,
-0.8732982277870178,
0.1891259253025055,
0.015843773260712624,
-0.3185429573059082,
-0.09850004315376282,
-0.4113336503505707,
-0.009360291995108128,
-0.2067955583333969,
0.3148181140422821,
-0.05753285437822342,
-0.270085871219635,
-0.10794135928153992,
-0.12357686460018158,
-0.03470779210329056,
-0.3911771774291992,
-0.9860841631889343,
-0.48132115602493286,
0.4491080939769745,
0.22650785744190216,
1.3622136116027832,
0.5274449586868286,
0.42071518301963806,
0.45184963941574097,
-0.17391672730445862,
0.0019421876640990376,
0.00858044158667326,
0.3924843370914459,
-0.29227057099342346,
-0.7194197177886963,
-0.6117109656333923,
-0.15229235589504242,
0.6541722416877747,
0.5163454413414001,
-0.22641299664974213,
0.030637269839644432,
-0.011508566327393055,
0.5461953282356262,
-0.783770740032196,
0.26156938076019287,
-0.551497757434845,
0.08909188210964203,
-0.05978088453412056,
0.19037450850009918,
-0.2602009177207947,
0.025304129347205162,
-0.14126314222812653,
-0.6623653173446655,
-0.36609548330307007,
0.23862212896347046,
0.47507187724113464,
0.7026714086532593,
-0.29892677068710327,
-0.21120226383209229,
-1.0674434900283813,
0.5870485305786133,
-0.5325821042060852,
0.6503920555114746,
0.36356401443481445,
0.2819626033306122,
-0.2345699965953827,
-0.6121558547019958,
-0.6639890074729919,
-0.08166693150997162,
0.30931562185287476,
-0.06537560373544693,
-0.39855194091796875,
0.3478548526763916,
-0.07312674075365067,
0.10198266804218292,
-0.24191679060459137,
0.365167498588562,
0.2213161587715149,
-0.5388100147247314,
0.40377703309059143,
0.1165492907166481,
0.15847021341323853,
0.33830714225769043,
-0.16289527714252472,
0.04198688268661499,
-0.6319648623466492,
0.4098494350910187,
0.3736055791378021,
0.49045395851135254,
-0.18845294415950775,
0.4705481231212616,
-0.4273087978363037,
0.48521673679351807,
-0.1443382352590561,
-0.1379941999912262,
-0.11715298146009445,
0.0052118548192083836,
-0.2371574342250824,
-0.16457350552082062,
0.6991702318191528,
-0.059319086372852325,
0.10672260820865631,
-0.06979430466890335,
-0.390483021736145,
0.14609183371067047,
0.18771256506443024,
-0.43104127049446106,
0.020939504727721214,
0.6673146486282349,
0.10966275632381439,
-0.2238568663597107,
-0.08662620186805725,
-0.35243237018585205,
-0.6904154419898987,
-0.19608888030052185,
0.5263137221336365,
-0.27617236971855164,
-0.32844409346580505,
-0.060574330389499664,
0.167038694024086,
0.18365801870822906,
0.4551728069782257,
-0.5562663674354553,
0.2356802523136139,
0.5668625831604004,
0.5662928223609924,
-0.060158632695674896,
-0.3908658027648926,
-0.5385600328445435,
0.15155386924743652,
-0.674589991569519,
0.8340374231338501,
-0.646611213684082,
-0.34523534774780273,
-0.03389955684542656,
-0.46391531825065613,
0.15675003826618195,
-0.20814822614192963,
0.2718493640422821,
-0.6187437176704407,
-0.2858026623725891,
-0.1673038899898529,
-0.315417617559433,
0.17211374640464783,
0.19639462232589722,
-0.7035559415817261,
1.151394009590149,
0.2456786334514618,
-0.42747610807418823,
0.32619208097457886,
-0.5939340591430664,
-0.21644823253154755,
0.15044882893562317,
-0.21290002763271332,
-0.1427222192287445,
0.14277440309524536,
0.045197706669569016,
0.2313791662454605,
-0.15687838196754456,
0.048717185854911804,
-0.326461523771286,
-0.48151832818984985,
0.6957617998123169,
-0.6212574243545532,
0.38528621196746826,
0.5260896682739258,
-0.20230045914649963,
0.3721412420272827,
-0.5658774971961975,
0.22747018933296204,
-0.19512075185775757,
-0.4527529180049896,
-0.14439131319522858,
-0.11954707652330399,
-0.07126019895076752,
0.1751042902469635,
0.45779934525489807,
-0.33557891845703125,
0.04882746934890747,
-0.5824747085571289,
0.18049810826778412,
0.9440550804138184,
-0.15788893401622772,
0.8775061964988708,
-0.30878764390945435,
0.9531707167625427,
-0.41300734877586365,
0.4202900528907776,
0.2792094051837921,
-0.46040797233581543,
-0.8300581574440002,
-0.21437877416610718,
0.24527983367443085,
0.45960795879364014,
-0.8752878308296204,
0.17600564658641815,
0.000007162338533817092,
-0.3433243930339813,
-0.7486620545387268,
0.1778174191713333,
0.29096755385398865,
-0.09945982694625854,
-0.04067219793796539,
-0.012567265890538692,
-0.4873216152191162,
-0.4344322383403778,
-0.25161850452423096,
-0.5348840355873108,
0.15189892053604126,
-0.03270936757326126,
0.2838740646839142,
-0.3677959740161896,
1.2457056045532227,
-0.14228087663650513,
-0.11220213025808334,
-0.3664925694465637,
0.04882965609431267,
-0.16442826390266418,
0.3193680942058563,
0.23846527934074402,
-0.8497596383094788,
-0.6362651586532593,
0.3148668706417084,
-0.5962830185890198,
-0.03781745210289955,
-0.09755288064479828,
0.05235105752944946,
0.5177561640739441,
0.615628182888031,
-0.8919392824172974,
0.44536706805229187,
0.5490845441818237,
-0.2145994007587433,
0.46212008595466614,
-0.30214107036590576,
-0.09334901720285416,
-1.0265084505081177,
-0.10057548433542252,
-0.39813172817230225,
-0.18513993918895721,
-0.7435600757598877,
0.41130781173706055,
0.04384564235806465,
-0.010294235311448574,
-0.713290274143219,
0.8559578657150269,
-0.586359441280365,
-0.16630853712558746,
-0.3989616632461548,
0.03739795833826065,
0.014544849283993244,
0.18521876633167267,
-0.03224093094468117,
0.9966585040092468,
0.9110292196273804,
-0.5256420969963074,
0.26456329226493835,
-0.19238795340061188,
-0.2732802629470825,
0.4951342046260834,
-0.4690021276473999,
0.1452610194683075,
0.0367216058075428,
-0.029150743037462234,
-0.860541582107544,
-0.2689894139766693,
0.3209598660469055,
-0.3805133104324341,
0.4085821807384491,
0.049785103648900986,
-0.5546252131462097,
-0.4075305163860321,
-0.23346978425979614,
0.2479499876499176,
0.21922370791435242,
-0.003181867068633437,
0.8632920384407043,
0.4173479378223419,
-0.2135101705789566,
-0.8517931699752808,
-0.6352912783622742,
0.14901180565357208,
-0.18098101019859314,
-0.2556280195713043,
-0.15389692783355713,
-0.36540624499320984,
-0.9427471160888672,
-0.09841559082269669,
-0.45841357111930847,
-0.2476271241903305,
0.4477851688861847,
0.45920372009277344,
-0.27619487047195435,
-0.036848440766334534,
0.4009529948234558,
0.05420547351241112,
-0.0894569531083107,
-0.01693296991288662,
-0.2449226826429367,
0.29072242975234985,
-0.43468278646469116,
-0.6835141181945801,
-0.42261141538619995,
0.17781049013137817,
0.5035911798477173,
-0.17863956093788147,
0.6455256342887878,
0.5756153464317322,
-0.5054419636726379,
-0.41773340106010437,
-0.40414106845855713,
0.036233577877283096,
-0.6456087231636047,
0.015069454908370972,
-0.7024368643760681,
-0.8454534411430359,
0.7990589141845703,
0.006190239917486906,
-0.20989178121089935,
0.25036588311195374,
0.3251311182975769,
-0.17649146914482117,
0.7160822153091431,
0.8846669793128967,
-0.15332530438899994,
0.4618118703365326,
-0.016936663538217545,
0.0415223054587841,
-0.48056432604789734,
0.06675197184085846,
-0.5045015215873718,
0.00694303261116147,
-0.39104074239730835,
-0.709488570690155,
0.24697239696979523,
-0.11654554307460785,
-0.1911659985780716,
0.1174798235297203,
-0.26651567220687866,
0.4924180507659912,
0.5067733526229858,
-0.26723527908325195,
0.43941226601600647,
-0.41764557361602783,
-0.06331738829612732,
0.30620577931404114,
-0.6251590251922607,
-0.520269513130188,
0.9191203713417053,
0.3781639039516449,
1.1081461906433105,
0.43250247836112976,
0.47356978058815,
0.4245362877845764,
0.26377615332603455,
-0.7748385071754456,
0.5881908535957336,
0.7009443044662476,
-0.6547192335128784,
-0.8551997542381287,
-0.32013043761253357,
-1.1220537424087524,
0.4114591181278229,
-0.23202572762966156,
-0.9671539068222046,
0.04728968068957329,
0.128170907497406,
-0.6084649562835693,
0.2444353997707367,
-0.63604336977005,
0.4313555955886841,
-0.05288343131542206,
-0.25102975964546204,
0.009085576049983501,
-0.6946449279785156,
-0.2061084806919098,
-0.29545238614082336,
0.5478503108024597,
-0.2513594329357147,
-0.37638628482818604,
0.15476098656654358,
-0.2806457579135895,
0.9769849181175232,
0.018217705190181732,
-0.6506037712097168,
0.6663297414779663,
0.4347769021987915,
0.8653618693351746,
0.16838772594928741,
-0.4284804165363312,
-0.11191760003566742,
-0.14550276100635529,
-0.23136155307292938,
-0.5707245469093323,
0.5697150230407715,
-0.6034089922904968,
-0.6078150272369385,
-0.5123764276504517,
-1.120371699333191,
-0.4830629825592041,
0.18516665697097778,
0.06291963905096054,
0.21230310201644897,
-0.24606281518936157,
-0.09480269998311996,
0.5286052227020264,
-0.1124870777130127,
0.7121970653533936,
0.8351837992668152,
-0.22824326157569885,
0.20065240561962128,
0.660893976688385,
0.23789122700691223,
0.41602152585983276,
0.8074465990066528,
0.1036292016506195,
-0.4077359735965729,
-0.5396888852119446,
-0.14167501032352448,
-0.27903345227241516,
-0.6102400422096252,
-0.17747515439987183,
-0.4298771321773529,
-0.15187755227088928,
-0.4599407911300659,
-0.35446256399154663,
-0.6074772477149963,
-0.4641081988811493,
-0.12887832522392273,
-0.3276119828224182,
0.46345117688179016,
0.8645244836807251,
-0.261908620595932,
0.6025294065475464,
-0.2653343677520752,
0.08836011588573456,
0.319805383682251,
0.6439061164855957,
-0.20378164947032928,
-0.37690213322639465,
-0.34633684158325195,
0.17947454750537872,
-0.037166446447372437,
-0.5585238337516785,
0.1664099544286728,
0.40606528520584106,
0.7087222337722778,
0.5320566296577454,
0.3937891125679016,
0.41711434721946716,
-0.2557424008846283,
0.5896235704421997,
-0.22715641558170319,
-1.1277984380722046,
0.5225380063056946,
-0.3330385684967041,
0.5878553986549377,
0.3563379943370819,
0.06414789706468582,
-0.3266119956970215,
-1.0999939441680908,
-0.5829669833183289,
-0.780800461769104,
0.4816147983074188,
0.40616723895072937,
0.038357820361852646,
0.32002028822898865,
0.1138525903224945,
0.01078185997903347,
0.352903813123703,
-0.706030011177063,
-0.28579333424568176,
0.2758467495441437,
-0.11768331378698349,
-0.24604974687099457,
-0.1500871181488037,
0.01782921329140663,
0.021139955148100853,
0.5411478877067566,
-0.24026869237422943,
0.3254411518573761,
0.014837335795164108,
-0.28473398089408875,
-0.3827371895313263,
0.5904052257537842,
0.4488382935523987,
0.699824869632721,
-0.19545689225196838,
0.41594311594963074,
0.22581301629543304,
-0.2957664728164673,
0.28227555751800537,
0.10995317250490189,
0.07840399444103241,
-0.27354881167411804,
0.40594467520713806,
0.3533684015274048,
0.10636016726493835,
-0.8972013592720032,
0.1703605204820633,
-0.052029799669981,
0.14516472816467285,
-0.3611207902431488,
0.044711243361234665,
0.03106570616364479,
0.5835118889808655,
0.44523629546165466,
0.12552939355373383,
0.26849955320358276,
-0.5044685006141663,
0.3321056365966797,
0.40501442551612854,
-0.5925103425979614,
-0.34103870391845703,
0.7029723525047302,
0.1463058441877365,
-0.4719524681568146,
-0.0733565166592598,
-0.4814199209213257,
-0.17400816082954407,
0.5577154159545898,
0.3715761601924896,
0.5527845621109009,
-0.5634227991104126,
0.35348284244537354,
-0.4268035590648651,
0.6843184232711792,
0.0904141440987587,
0.6263989806175232,
0.05589713156223297,
-0.9407346844673157,
-0.43554189801216125,
-0.5464547872543335,
-0.8114213943481445,
-0.17646585404872894,
-0.45807498693466187,
-0.3740326464176178,
-0.3502691686153412,
-0.414971262216568,
-0.28623703122138977,
0.05790068209171295,
-0.5465138554573059,
0.07275597751140594,
-0.040924422442913055,
0.8070425391197205,
-0.6765281558036804,
0.9898863434791565,
0.9095213413238525,
-0.17279669642448425,
-0.872176468372345,
0.09630637615919113,
0.2114349752664566,
-0.7048229575157166,
0.15911507606506348,
0.08499758690595627,
-0.5622817873954773,
-0.10447496175765991,
-0.17346952855587006,
-1.0758219957351685,
1.0613739490509033,
0.7038198709487915,
-0.18656988441944122,
0.30223748087882996,
0.45502668619155884,
0.801996111869812,
-0.06685715913772583,
0.05626986548304558,
0.43362462520599365,
0.42101386189460754,
-0.04086695984005928,
-0.9685948491096497,
0.04822613671422005,
-0.08870501071214676,
0.06557730585336685,
0.35835906863212585,
-0.8096861839294434,
0.8004649877548218,
-0.4129294455051422,
-0.3975171148777008,
0.19291222095489502,
0.8508244156837463,
-0.2714628279209137,
0.3221632242202759,
0.37736988067626953,
0.28564155101776123,
1.0296741724014282,
-0.04002011939883232,
1.0030667781829834,
-0.3730684220790863,
0.16070611774921417,
1.2108893394470215,
-0.5385633111000061,
0.9046580195426941,
0.6768134236335754,
-0.4064016342163086,
0.23084253072738647,
0.4670667350292206,
0.7137377858161926,
0.1211770698428154,
0.2113296091556549,
-0.5141818523406982,
-0.24061964452266693,
-0.40422704815864563,
-0.1622060388326645,
0.5431241393089294,
0.5982617735862732,
0.1618933230638504,
0.002309181494638324,
0.19470956921577454,
-0.1874268800020218,
0.29828593134880066,
-0.366402804851532,
0.6746530532836914,
0.18517182767391205,
-0.38397082686424255,
0.2536793053150177,
-0.12510791420936584,
0.4195042848587036,
-0.6076884269714355,
0.29279154539108276,
-0.18816442787647247,
0.18816424906253815,
0.26081857085227966,
-0.9327340722084045,
0.37284159660339355,
-0.3320188820362091,
0.24268290400505066,
-0.3179650604724884,
0.767076849937439,
-0.34411048889160156,
-0.3607097268104553,
0.34988054633140564,
0.8604483604431152,
0.0700821503996849,
-0.4437832534313202,
-0.5779840350151062,
0.3242359161376953,
-0.3932282328605652,
-0.31209367513656616,
0.29924094676971436,
0.7869017720222473,
-0.04284639284014702,
1.4806125164031982,
0.18064041435718536,
0.0721791535615921,
-0.06418804079294205,
-0.09687640517950058,
0.4725968837738037,
-0.2437475323677063,
-0.44340240955352783,
-0.5862382054328918,
0.444809228181839,
0.29600247740745544,
-0.203645721077919,
0.816825270652771,
0.2879581153392792,
0.6001439690589905,
0.08629166334867477,
0.7088062763214111,
-0.06678582727909088,
0.03404515981674194,
-0.47894516587257385,
0.7358534336090088,
-0.4002164304256439,
0.3539927303791046,
-0.3407534062862396,
-0.6273991465568542,
-0.2415667474269867,
0.4677638113498688,
0.15380112826824188,
-0.10921894758939743,
0.49168866872787476,
0.8883917927742004,
0.23937568068504333,
-0.2126273512840271,
0.6216003894805908,
0.15840400755405426,
0.17482201755046844,
0.28956782817840576,
0.9540620446205139,
-0.1475483477115631,
0.7632264494895935,
-0.29883691668510437,
-0.016831712797284126,
-0.006155184004455805,
-0.665621817111969,
-0.616913378238678,
-0.767873227596283,
-0.17457637190818787,
0.016854174435138702,
0.015570584684610367,
0.9666710495948792,
0.6622991561889648,
-0.6290220618247986,
-0.25063657760620117,
-0.030194027349352837,
0.4942227602005005,
-0.4725209176540375,
-0.18348197638988495,
0.04204944893717766,
-0.3786264657974243,
-0.8107705116271973,
0.5725601315498352,
0.26418158411979675,
0.4090960919857025,
-0.1730654537677765,
-0.2994634509086609,
-0.06695542484521866,
0.45516854524612427,
0.6271994709968567,
0.45181939005851746,
-0.80972820520401,
-0.5329838395118713,
-0.1901041716337204,
-0.21747931838035583,
-0.08619210869073868,
0.3332276940345764,
-0.5040544867515564,
0.5155124664306641,
-0.030828552320599556,
0.657182514667511,
-0.030290383845567703,
-0.05056750029325485,
0.7453945279121399,
-1.0405198335647583,
0.3488508462905884,
0.12288078665733337,
0.3341946601867676,
0.13874371349811554,
-0.6334877014160156,
0.5360518097877502,
-0.26439452171325684,
-0.49180540442466736,
-0.6886722445487976,
0.5292725563049316,
-0.9770312309265137,
-0.3863367438316345,
1.3531514406204224,
-0.02492488920688629,
0.11734303832054138,
-0.4016389846801758,
-0.2237595021724701,
0.12025082856416702,
-0.7202543616294861,
0.5762577056884766,
0.6462380886077881,
-0.15214410424232483,
-0.0952974185347557,
-0.42613354325294495,
0.579056441783905,
0.23547671735286713,
-0.8963820338249207,
0.07909254729747772,
0.3283068835735321,
-0.1193755492568016,
0.22547951340675354,
0.7917307019233704,
0.44586044549942017,
0.05985535681247711,
0.18245188891887665,
0.2395792454481125,
0.1824507713317871,
-0.6091777086257935,
-0.3816065192222595,
0.08194784075021744,
0.7875866889953613,
0.012283547781407833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14011v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14011v3 | CMMU: A Benchmark for Chinese Multi-modal Multi-type Question Understanding and Reasoning | 2024-01-25T08:22:10 | 2024-05-08T07:34:06 | Zheqi He, Xinya Wu, Pengfei Zhou, Richeng Xuan, Guang Liu, Xi Yang, Qiannan Zhu, Hua Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM | Multi-modal large language models(MLLMs) have achieved remarkable progress
and demonstrated powerful knowledge comprehension and reasoning abilities.
However, the mastery of domain-specific knowledge, which is essential for
evaluating the intelligence of MLLMs, continues to be a challenge. Current
multi-modal benchmarks for domain-specific knowledge concentrate on
multiple-choice questions and are predominantly available in English, which
imposes limitations on the comprehensiveness of the evaluation. To this end, we
introduce CMMU, a novel benchmark for multi-modal and multi-type question
understanding and reasoning in Chinese. CMMU consists of 3,603 questions in 7
subjects, covering knowledge from primary to high school. The questions can be
categorized into 3 types: multiple-choice, multiple-response, and
fill-in-the-blank, bringing greater challenges to MLLMs. In addition, we
propose an evaluation strategy called Positional Error Variance for assessing
multiple-choice questions. The strategy aims to perform a quantitative analysis
of position bias. We evaluate seven open-source MLLMs along with GPT4-V,
Gemini-Pro, and Qwen-VL-Plus. The results demonstrate that CMMU poses a
significant challenge to the recent MLLMs. The data and code are available at
https://github.com/FlagOpen/CMMU. | [
-0.48359695076942444,
-0.9669701457023621,
0.8036901354789734,
0.3191816508769989,
-0.0945642814040184,
0.01562497578561306,
-0.31759074330329895,
0.044089555740356445,
-0.3699285387992859,
0.05036580562591553,
-0.40456393361091614,
-0.41197630763053894,
-0.4866417944431305,
-0.027269765734672546,
0.0836978554725647,
0.4398152828216553,
-0.131988987326622,
0.5379245281219482,
-0.36748647689819336,
-0.5878512263298035,
-0.5691205859184265,
-0.7674071192741394,
-0.5498651266098022,
0.042201120406389236,
0.736361026763916,
0.23793575167655945,
0.6957390904426575,
0.29461124539375305,
0.47296661138534546,
0.25121772289276123,
-0.06009355187416077,
0.5384232401847839,
-0.10047359764575958,
-0.1441507339477539,
-0.005336297210305929,
-0.4531594514846802,
-0.28984639048576355,
0.11213716119527817,
0.8976929187774658,
0.8431957960128784,
0.07700905948877335,
0.10292106866836548,
-0.050029557198286057,
0.4346071779727936,
-0.8649393320083618,
-0.11225026100873947,
-0.6335420608520508,
0.07099229097366333,
-0.173285111784935,
-0.3421971797943115,
-0.4563266932964325,
-0.32677537202835083,
-0.015500742010772228,
-0.5383490324020386,
0.03923916816711426,
-0.01746024377644062,
0.6123960018157959,
0.016075806692242622,
-1.0409939289093018,
0.1218888983130455,
-0.22835440933704376,
0.9034583568572998,
-0.6331015825271606,
0.528521716594696,
0.30735594034194946,
0.6323163509368896,
-0.108248770236969,
-0.2909926474094391,
-0.4474036693572998,
-0.4131115674972534,
-0.13892614841461182,
0.30959364771842957,
0.4094076454639435,
-0.13998346030712128,
0.16897514462471008,
0.25561749935150146,
-0.6678547859191895,
-0.11852690577507019,
-0.1810239553451538,
-0.062229763716459274,
0.5578501224517822,
0.31080690026283264,
0.23333105444908142,
-0.19731539487838745,
-0.4672251045703888,
-0.054007094353437424,
-0.5431650280952454,
0.3529796600341797,
0.2832299768924713,
0.1077144667506218,
0.008965026587247849,
0.5553725957870483,
0.020150460302829742,
0.7882938385009766,
-0.09236396849155426,
-0.1704341024160385,
0.18257860839366913,
-0.37240391969680786,
-0.3207598328590393,
-0.516377329826355,
0.7928280234336853,
0.24645699560642242,
-0.2030739039182663,
0.15984362363815308,
-0.03986082598567009,
-0.2077186107635498,
0.11965122073888779,
-0.5243433713912964,
0.006056217011064291,
0.4595782458782196,
-0.5803336501121521,
-0.006615117192268372,
0.31011489033699036,
-0.3706437349319458,
-0.46546244621276855,
-0.3590596914291382,
0.5433573722839355,
-0.5688053369522095,
-0.5025894045829773,
-0.028087416663765907,
-0.09287966042757034,
0.46986547112464905,
0.3534420430660248,
-0.6514831185340881,
-0.07155970484018326,
0.8319737315177917,
0.6007611155509949,
-0.5582509636878967,
-0.6953518986701965,
-0.4487869441509247,
0.013085387647151947,
-0.3888792395591736,
0.699310839176178,
-0.5739882588386536,
-0.46974483132362366,
-0.15904740989208221,
0.05208604410290718,
-0.5696616768836975,
-0.6317596435546875,
0.5592678189277649,
-0.33820462226867676,
0.46236932277679443,
-0.5776816010475159,
-0.3583585321903229,
-0.27460581064224243,
0.8422568440437317,
-0.5139752626419067,
1.072638750076294,
0.07428498566150665,
-0.7212440371513367,
0.2758628726005554,
-0.5856625437736511,
-0.4516448974609375,
-0.18628640472888947,
-0.5107414722442627,
-0.26422345638275146,
-0.04978946968913078,
0.21718758344650269,
0.3144787847995758,
-0.34537097811698914,
0.6521780490875244,
-0.5940682888031006,
-0.4387875199317932,
0.5792754292488098,
-0.8552939891815186,
1.0082491636276245,
0.19798125326633453,
-0.3219202756881714,
0.2602008283138275,
-0.790939450263977,
0.24258440732955933,
0.07768125087022781,
-0.529002845287323,
-0.3489261567592621,
-0.012053552083671093,
-0.16961507499217987,
0.39160284399986267,
0.31504806876182556,
-0.1428314596414566,
0.2221560925245285,
0.155338317155838,
0.08250497281551361,
0.6495986580848694,
-0.23801636695861816,
0.1446956843137741,
-0.40135055780410767,
0.386393666267395,
0.47285211086273193,
0.5035558938980103,
-0.23037609457969666,
-0.4937933087348938,
-0.6556299924850464,
-0.12313663214445114,
0.12173397839069366,
0.4714345633983612,
-0.8556615710258484,
0.16921252012252808,
0.1604541540145874,
-0.5734177827835083,
-0.551244854927063,
-0.07244716584682465,
0.24556565284729004,
0.404325395822525,
0.5801931023597717,
0.183452770113945,
-0.2197529375553131,
-0.8364476561546326,
-0.22145500779151917,
-0.10828401893377304,
-0.1796087771654129,
0.4355776011943817,
0.23999172449111938,
-0.10640442371368408,
0.5059901475906372,
-0.424819678068161,
0.1291007101535797,
0.04210663586854935,
0.1679012030363083,
0.013592441566288471,
0.4457744061946869,
0.3401837646961212,
-1.0340226888656616,
-0.20502318441867828,
0.0995197519659996,
-0.7870240807533264,
0.040889713913202286,
-0.19879700243473053,
-0.4027153551578522,
0.07591060549020767,
0.262894868850708,
-0.700946569442749,
-0.05105844885110855,
0.7171723246574402,
-0.547066330909729,
0.9591408371925354,
-0.15754687786102295,
0.5512821078300476,
-0.9511209726333618,
0.3128128945827484,
-0.16830597817897797,
0.010187877342104912,
-0.43470099568367004,
0.3549731969833374,
0.6177993416786194,
0.04200182482600212,
-0.5484045743942261,
0.3834393322467804,
-0.5201794505119324,
-0.08244619518518448,
-0.08978003263473511,
0.4404691159725189,
0.19566859304904938,
0.5932484865188599,
-0.07271499186754227,
0.6916269659996033,
0.4578281342983246,
-0.7308533787727356,
0.37536394596099854,
-0.1858566254377365,
-0.2753291428089142,
0.7006664276123047,
-0.33250173926353455,
0.07308602333068848,
-0.0191314909607172,
0.04964431747794151,
-1.041374921798706,
0.2791835069656372,
0.06520134955644608,
-0.47308287024497986,
0.022760476917028427,
0.12171782553195953,
-0.21756459772586823,
-0.4443001449108124,
-0.40980300307273865,
0.5514231324195862,
-0.11057785898447037,
-0.45383960008621216,
0.6800892949104309,
0.08777306228876114,
0.24823811650276184,
-0.9312928318977356,
-0.32766062021255493,
-0.08359430730342865,
-0.1463850736618042,
-0.5092897415161133,
0.1366266906261444,
-0.6207027435302734,
-0.27835139632225037,
-0.18068572878837585,
-0.1907014101743698,
-0.14424225687980652,
0.3799261450767517,
-0.22553867101669312,
0.48452550172805786,
-0.6391614079475403,
0.1543181985616684,
0.03417942672967911,
0.05308692902326584,
0.16831061244010925,
-0.15852884948253632,
0.39425981044769287,
-0.1908995509147644,
-0.769254207611084,
-0.02293379046022892,
0.2443297654390335,
0.7878040075302124,
-0.3907327950000763,
0.5021514296531677,
0.8491844534873962,
-0.2091781347990036,
-0.012040735222399235,
-0.5296557545661926,
0.034134794026613235,
-0.4234395921230316,
0.34958168864250183,
-0.6759627461433411,
-0.639140248298645,
0.25402525067329407,
0.16224274039268494,
0.26918137073516846,
0.43221327662467957,
0.6175816059112549,
0.1447199136018753,
1.3254863023757935,
0.12302698194980621,
-0.049923546612262726,
0.11120076477527618,
0.035035476088523865,
-0.0894923061132431,
-0.7403228878974915,
-0.25532305240631104,
-0.4294963777065277,
-0.21844011545181274,
-0.16235807538032532,
-0.8164698481559753,
0.36462312936782837,
-0.08325761556625366,
-0.2801954448223114,
0.09118427336215973,
-0.21248020231723785,
0.23800182342529297,
0.6508259177207947,
-0.014119676314294338,
0.5217465162277222,
-0.7444767951965332,
-0.5805080533027649,
0.07920367270708084,
-0.5707243084907532,
-0.3781582713127136,
0.9320715665817261,
0.1931084245443344,
0.3617244064807892,
0.37749066948890686,
0.02678803540766239,
0.009325547143816948,
0.389900267124176,
-0.8729647397994995,
0.49980029463768005,
0.009228559210896492,
-0.7636091113090515,
-0.42399436235427856,
-0.5946269035339355,
-0.8130521774291992,
1.1140462160110474,
-0.174019917845726,
-0.2557201385498047,
-0.18109558522701263,
-0.06876417249441147,
-0.2912430763244629,
0.4906488060951233,
-0.704521119594574,
1.0095418691635132,
-0.6677008271217346,
-0.24595078825950623,
-0.01723465509712696,
-0.5773996710777283,
0.6937851905822754,
-0.03995152935385704,
0.314559668302536,
-0.37023189663887024,
-0.18618257343769073,
0.4510043263435364,
-0.1720573902130127,
0.2995903491973877,
-0.33173668384552,
-0.16722407937049866,
0.23681502044200897,
0.06489420682191849,
0.054530948400497437,
0.25526344776153564,
-0.17459380626678467,
0.004239543341100216,
0.4398730397224426,
-0.5282342433929443,
-0.6508703827857971,
0.5508192777633667,
-0.8306907415390015,
-0.8893862962722778,
-0.22710731625556946,
-0.6333644986152649,
-0.5691044926643372,
0.28582119941711426,
0.05931992456316948,
0.4817402958869934,
-0.3755548298358917,
0.33780500292778015,
0.6487053632736206,
-0.4286368489265442,
0.39057931303977966,
0.811610221862793,
-0.29067954421043396,
-0.3228708505630493,
0.7457224130630493,
0.1351301521062851,
0.26111194491386414,
0.6815397143363953,
0.41039156913757324,
-0.2714307904243469,
-0.3947726786136627,
-0.6479663252830505,
0.07063815742731094,
-0.6387381553649902,
-0.09582571685314178,
-0.7495554089546204,
-0.22796234488487244,
-0.3914566934108734,
0.011236662976443768,
-0.26492318511009216,
-0.1131969690322876,
-0.0761994943022728,
0.003369648940861225,
-0.3679566979408264,
0.3356669247150421,
0.22032344341278076,
-0.14711971580982208,
-0.6500483751296997,
0.5838977098464966,
0.5082660913467407,
0.37791866064071655,
0.0685332790017128,
-0.3061234652996063,
-0.1678423285484314,
0.08372291177511215,
-0.6616469025611877,
-0.7716183066368103,
-0.039275046437978745,
-0.28919804096221924,
0.9902095794677734,
0.7010645270347595,
0.0667647123336792,
0.6456195116043091,
-0.28298473358154297,
0.9708999395370483,
0.08015912026166916,
-0.946929931640625,
0.39540255069732666,
-0.3252224326133728,
0.6521955728530884,
0.561812162399292,
0.46928760409355164,
-0.7821817994117737,
-0.4320835471153259,
-0.41058358550071716,
-0.39227989315986633,
0.44472524523735046,
-0.09331286698579788,
-0.1997796595096588,
-0.06600096076726913,
-0.2064986377954483,
0.2584748864173889,
0.11466628313064575,
-0.657587468624115,
-0.542649507522583,
-0.20327144861221313,
-0.11806225776672363,
-0.058087367564439774,
-0.07313494384288788,
-0.12703156471252441,
-0.38566020131111145,
0.5372904539108276,
-0.38562074303627014,
0.09302079677581787,
0.10726691037416458,
-0.2842298150062561,
0.1374526470899582,
0.4194389283657074,
0.8322545886039734,
0.9877437949180603,
-0.17917948961257935,
0.4100111424922943,
0.5047343969345093,
-0.40483367443084717,
0.03727304935455322,
0.18480369448661804,
-0.02726202830672264,
0.051167089492082596,
-0.03590450808405876,
0.39438551664352417,
0.2828318476676941,
-0.7099530696868896,
0.6586663126945496,
-0.19060443341732025,
-0.2594256103038788,
-0.20763187110424042,
-0.21438132226467133,
0.12094645947217941,
0.06626170128583908,
0.5388544201850891,
-0.054838627576828,
0.11197284609079361,
-0.5066021680831909,
0.110871322453022,
0.5216929912567139,
-0.4213743209838867,
-0.1529722660779953,
0.7411624789237976,
0.1074267029762268,
0.11553221940994263,
0.14293906092643738,
0.005241259001195431,
-0.4183492362499237,
0.623620331287384,
0.4086054265499115,
0.5637837648391724,
-0.3269007205963135,
0.21980971097946167,
0.4641491174697876,
0.39832690358161926,
0.03198578953742981,
0.4324253797531128,
-0.06790050119161606,
-0.8288052678108215,
-0.1797701120376587,
-0.14026276767253876,
-0.735291063785553,
0.29707735776901245,
-0.42847564816474915,
0.5231553316116333,
-0.5877462029457092,
-0.136175274848938,
-0.1299154907464981,
0.09069807827472687,
-0.5578598976135254,
0.22852589190006256,
0.3516143262386322,
1.0049011707305908,
-0.344623327255249,
0.957470178604126,
0.785399854183197,
-0.2019026279449463,
-0.7039873600006104,
-0.12753291428089142,
0.22865405678749084,
-0.8109114766120911,
0.156533882021904,
0.43394044041633606,
-0.14600418508052826,
-0.5309219360351562,
-0.2611766457557678,
-0.7597653269767761,
1.2579821348190308,
0.11119081825017929,
-0.19933541119098663,
0.12329516559839249,
0.06589926779270172,
0.16970878839492798,
-0.22653914988040924,
0.6230469346046448,
0.6708600521087646,
0.7332438230514526,
-0.2543190121650696,
-0.7781438231468201,
0.04359974339604378,
-0.27201488614082336,
-0.21945856511592865,
0.16816984117031097,
-0.9714382290840149,
1.196629524230957,
-0.17146462202072144,
-0.07627607882022858,
-0.04241741821169853,
0.5218289494514465,
0.7126502990722656,
0.6547010540962219,
0.5185126662254333,
0.14590443670749664,
1.0324838161468506,
-0.1576436460018158,
0.7241453528404236,
-0.2401452362537384,
0.3269076645374298,
0.9042349457740784,
-0.1912899762392044,
0.8426440954208374,
0.3437361717224121,
-0.22326409816741943,
0.32755473256111145,
0.6159561276435852,
-0.11452095955610275,
0.027014978229999542,
0.16790661215782166,
-0.23733024299144745,
-0.3266820013523102,
0.1952328234910965,
-0.6429932117462158,
0.45538508892059326,
0.2984468340873718,
-0.10910866409540176,
0.08235795795917511,
-0.04519948735833168,
0.1812845766544342,
0.0209952462464571,
-0.28575143218040466,
0.4246450662612915,
-0.0015150740509852767,
-0.9516537189483643,
0.7250934839248657,
0.2229074239730835,
0.9058425426483154,
-0.7035619616508484,
0.2956576645374298,
-0.3606153130531311,
0.06483816355466843,
-0.010643837042152882,
-0.6847626566886902,
-0.0078030978329479694,
-0.31564995646476746,
0.041893307119607925,
0.10021506994962692,
0.4695984125137329,
-0.5500081777572632,
-0.3413045406341553,
0.29543519020080566,
0.8271954655647278,
-0.11608070135116577,
-0.2732127010822296,
-0.8236653208732605,
-0.16224955022335052,
-0.18320225179195404,
-0.3423810601234436,
0.26059988141059875,
0.6276423335075378,
0.050622060894966125,
0.6992498636245728,
0.5714083313941956,
-0.2695866823196411,
0.09481897205114365,
0.33552631735801697,
0.6510011553764343,
-0.8693373799324036,
-0.35952839255332947,
-0.8244914412498474,
0.39781805872917175,
-0.03487451374530792,
-0.5563452839851379,
0.9501021504402161,
0.7364553213119507,
0.7614299654960632,
-0.050008974969387054,
0.8766385316848755,
0.050421226769685745,
0.3677254021167755,
-0.4457433223724365,
0.7309321165084839,
-0.7891233563423157,
0.023507555946707726,
-0.20346763730049133,
-0.7892984747886658,
-0.3390085995197296,
0.20149771869182587,
-0.42522552609443665,
0.08516787737607956,
1.0331300497055054,
0.6029540300369263,
-0.13506579399108887,
0.04075739532709122,
0.9367855787277222,
-0.08031365275382996,
0.2271633744239807,
0.8142068386077881,
1.202481746673584,
-0.4398972690105438,
0.8917990326881409,
-0.1816844344139099,
-0.18223264813423157,
-0.18198515474796295,
-0.5617188811302185,
-0.9068502187728882,
-0.630612850189209,
-0.03827448934316635,
-0.15764358639717102,
-0.38891032338142395,
0.915674090385437,
0.732487142086029,
-0.86989426612854,
-0.3486757278442383,
0.5819925665855408,
0.5655031800270081,
-0.6084137558937073,
-0.26934364438056946,
0.37321001291275024,
-0.4333270788192749,
-0.7615949511528015,
0.4193979799747467,
0.24865904450416565,
-0.07403614372015,
-0.3386670649051666,
-0.08402367681264877,
-0.4620762765407562,
0.06228313222527504,
1.035069465637207,
0.08210106939077377,
-0.7665945291519165,
-0.22111444175243378,
0.30070093274116516,
-0.3375820815563202,
0.21177341043949127,
1.1337757110595703,
-0.4118614196777344,
0.2589738965034485,
0.38668373227119446,
0.7442723512649536,
-0.007655569352209568,
0.10922360420227051,
0.5091262459754944,
-0.47715288400650024,
-0.08345286548137665,
-0.007685214746743441,
0.7115441560745239,
0.36158615350723267,
-0.22550995647907257,
0.3229307234287262,
0.3793122172355652,
-0.4620978832244873,
-0.44038549065589905,
0.024177055805921555,
-1.0521003007888794,
-0.7506529688835144,
1.2850931882858276,
-0.08181394636631012,
0.036919377744197845,
-0.2737221419811249,
-0.5976194143295288,
0.12885263562202454,
-0.018870608881115913,
0.6874842047691345,
0.844153881072998,
0.06039974093437195,
-0.3709242641925812,
-0.6275257468223572,
0.17082805931568146,
0.6383700966835022,
-0.9036779999732971,
0.14514294266700745,
0.5432611107826233,
0.24937725067138672,
-0.09424830973148346,
0.599936306476593,
-0.33245572447776794,
0.4379279613494873,
-0.036766715347766876,
-0.28008198738098145,
-0.061170097440481186,
-0.2883375585079193,
-0.13807110488414764,
0.4902046322822571,
0.09517616778612137,
-0.36007753014564514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14003v1 | ConstraintChecker: A Plugin for Large Language Models to Reason on Commonsense Knowledge Bases | 2024-01-25T08:03:38 | 2024-01-25T08:03:38 | Quyet V. Do, Tianqing Fang, Shizhe Diao, Zhaowei Wang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning over Commonsense Knowledge Bases (CSKB), i.e. CSKB reasoning, has
been explored as a way to acquire new commonsense knowledge based on reference
knowledge in the original CSKBs and external prior knowledge. Despite the
advancement of Large Language Models (LLM) and prompt engineering techniques in
various reasoning tasks, they still struggle to deal with CSKB reasoning. One
of the problems is that it is hard for them to acquire explicit relational
constraints in CSKBs from only in-context exemplars, due to a lack of symbolic
reasoning capabilities (Bengio et al., 2021). To this end, we proposed
**ConstraintChecker**, a plugin over prompting techniques to provide and check
explicit constraints. When considering a new knowledge instance,
ConstraintChecker employs a rule-based module to produce a list of constraints,
then it uses a zero-shot learning module to check whether this knowledge
instance satisfies all constraints. The acquired constraint-checking result is
then aggregated with the output of the main prompting technique to produce the
final output. Experimental results on CSKB Reasoning benchmarks demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method by bringing consistent improvements over all
prompting methods. Codes and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/ConstraintChecker}. | [
-0.5250673294067383,
-0.575839638710022,
0.8756275773048401,
0.30242523550987244,
-0.09138882160186768,
-0.24759438633918762,
-0.1978328973054886,
-0.24462783336639404,
-0.1678541749715805,
0.5429120659828186,
-0.863491415977478,
-0.4767951965332031,
-0.19013409316539764,
0.22421927750110626,
-0.2489464282989502,
0.6610116362571716,
-0.09260427206754684,
-0.23837698996067047,
-0.8155412673950195,
0.2214384526014328,
-0.9623711109161377,
-0.1424197405576706,
-0.036275386810302734,
-0.5359526872634888,
0.43725085258483887,
0.7892990708351135,
0.5004831552505493,
0.33969593048095703,
-0.0025049580726772547,
0.29483047127723694,
-0.34980618953704834,
0.5083523988723755,
-0.32103231549263,
0.15385492146015167,
-0.622584879398346,
-0.3218635618686676,
0.18061110377311707,
-0.28487855195999146,
0.36484912037849426,
0.6232914924621582,
0.02291778288781643,
0.04406260326504707,
-0.09376734495162964,
0.29314008355140686,
-1.008314609527588,
0.1884005218744278,
-0.612804114818573,
0.07693656533956528,
0.026268931105732918,
-0.15093617141246796,
-0.5307597517967224,
-0.38684555888175964,
-0.06730271875858307,
-0.7824147939682007,
0.05333557352423668,
0.15770180523395538,
1.048935055732727,
0.47852829098701477,
-0.6184821724891663,
-0.18727093935012817,
-0.4179772734642029,
0.8087010979652405,
-0.7286785840988159,
0.5473629832267761,
0.40110060572624207,
0.2693570554256439,
-0.4550359845161438,
-0.5299171805381775,
-0.7404027581214905,
-0.498126745223999,
-0.42085930705070496,
0.0808577761054039,
0.0022543456871062517,
0.06217154115438461,
0.6886202692985535,
0.28593873977661133,
-0.6274281740188599,
0.03987157717347145,
-0.36193087697029114,
-0.467775821685791,
0.40132176876068115,
0.11293821036815643,
0.07271569222211838,
-0.37950238585472107,
-0.18889474868774414,
0.15522684156894684,
-0.7796437740325928,
0.1106385737657547,
0.35670140385627747,
0.08549048751592636,
-0.08666667342185974,
0.33354076743125916,
-0.7994369864463806,
1.0794609785079956,
0.24232913553714752,
0.10685379058122635,
0.04281621798872948,
-0.09343431144952774,
-0.1534113734960556,
-0.03916585072875023,
0.4773927628993988,
0.17143122851848602,
-0.02829841896891594,
-0.05929902195930481,
0.038239236921072006,
0.05726306512951851,
0.0016737048281356692,
-0.6870889663696289,
-0.5275559425354004,
0.38615718483924866,
-0.15661293268203735,
-0.33365386724472046,
-0.031718991696834564,
-0.4909288287162781,
-0.5452302098274231,
-0.514434814453125,
0.2299317866563797,
-0.5709919333457947,
-0.42857834696769714,
0.15120914578437805,
-0.26587390899658203,
0.39444318413734436,
0.44864219427108765,
-0.572832465171814,
-0.16311977803707123,
0.9559783339500427,
0.6465045809745789,
-0.12257621437311172,
-0.2730617821216583,
-0.5184558629989624,
0.14088572561740875,
-0.28174176812171936,
0.9415156841278076,
-0.4894399046897888,
-0.35692018270492554,
0.07145250588655472,
0.054186295717954636,
0.3912327289581299,
-0.5339006185531616,
0.7172119617462158,
-0.5212745070457458,
-0.20565277338027954,
-0.8784728646278381,
-0.7205595374107361,
-0.10887172818183899,
0.5361867547035217,
-0.6373398900032043,
0.8478409647941589,
0.143077090382576,
-0.461797297000885,
0.5951991081237793,
-0.47696730494499207,
-0.4950319528579712,
0.4262252449989319,
-0.2926134467124939,
-0.12016459554433823,
-0.1459953635931015,
0.3593560457229614,
0.37526753544807434,
-0.2533823549747467,
0.4609344005584717,
-0.5963246822357178,
-0.1797996312379837,
0.33175724744796753,
0.17618943750858307,
1.2036566734313965,
0.42675378918647766,
-0.0065102847293019295,
0.06256071478128433,
-0.6101766228675842,
0.23742303252220154,
-0.11010956764221191,
-0.31875598430633545,
-0.2851652204990387,
-0.023143606260418892,
-0.3762753903865814,
0.2730746269226074,
0.18927477300167084,
-0.5545286536216736,
0.3100934326648712,
-0.1544528752565384,
0.39477676153182983,
0.7620471119880676,
0.19387774169445038,
0.1483616828918457,
-0.061925485730171204,
0.33302465081214905,
-0.11194870620965958,
0.1118549332022667,
-0.14525896310806274,
-0.19188012182712555,
-0.6293298006057739,
-0.1817668229341507,
0.11385709047317505,
0.5878975987434387,
-0.6292788982391357,
0.6408519148826599,
0.07537525147199631,
-0.4747869074344635,
-0.03195137158036232,
0.4438876211643219,
0.36748236417770386,
0.7151976823806763,
0.28873977065086365,
0.046077243983745575,
-0.5762602686882019,
-0.9394693374633789,
-0.2827090919017792,
-0.24446038901805878,
-0.020009221509099007,
0.40889033675193787,
0.48630964756011963,
-0.09205059707164764,
1.0507731437683105,
-0.6921684741973877,
0.014656915329396725,
-0.34299564361572266,
0.2587710916996002,
0.3414382040500641,
0.5770834684371948,
0.27290502190589905,
-0.6681357622146606,
-0.3309929370880127,
0.060847654938697815,
-0.7144843935966492,
-0.7549170851707458,
-0.29643064737319946,
-0.402121901512146,
-0.031823065131902695,
0.7900055646896362,
-0.9637832045555115,
0.10414925217628479,
0.4245830476284027,
-0.390685498714447,
1.1367148160934448,
0.30525049567222595,
-0.03716351091861725,
-0.6486474275588989,
0.33070388436317444,
-0.4510951638221741,
-0.24059167504310608,
-0.32448485493659973,
0.3231358528137207,
0.3703634738922119,
-0.1268005073070526,
-0.3409856855869293,
0.4164814352989197,
-0.38653483986854553,
0.32487159967422485,
-0.29645392298698425,
0.05401261895895004,
0.09396249055862427,
0.4610971212387085,
0.06327196955680847,
0.5259497165679932,
0.5134917497634888,
-0.751778244972229,
0.847361147403717,
0.48738089203834534,
-0.4351639151573181,
0.957646906375885,
-0.6016836166381836,
0.1332038789987564,
-0.0064695728942751884,
0.31598931550979614,
-0.8915408253669739,
-0.44324424862861633,
0.016652483493089676,
-0.38711556792259216,
0.27209070324897766,
-0.37276118993759155,
-0.5138198137283325,
-0.7042250633239746,
0.008569370023906231,
0.15558509528636932,
0.17579950392246246,
-0.7912710905075073,
0.5669304132461548,
0.13642212748527527,
0.12268849462270737,
-0.7631527185440063,
-0.4683590233325958,
0.0024861381389200687,
0.2081015259027481,
-0.67191082239151,
0.08053311705589294,
-0.10510163009166718,
-0.15469595789909363,
0.33194422721862793,
-0.45064643025398254,
-0.24760136008262634,
0.11153798550367355,
0.11588715016841888,
0.37926504015922546,
-0.006586059927940369,
0.20737236738204956,
0.39109301567077637,
-0.17815376818180084,
0.309279203414917,
-0.5213791728019714,
0.266406774520874,
-0.16572409868240356,
-0.5673802495002747,
-0.21675357222557068,
0.15908744931221008,
0.21985264122486115,
-0.1850002557039261,
0.4454920291900635,
0.35397523641586304,
-0.2122214138507843,
-0.5371294021606445,
-0.8955105543136597,
-0.3929479122161865,
-0.5667651295661926,
0.4046911299228668,
-0.5739991664886475,
-1.2011183500289917,
0.3152906596660614,
-0.37851670384407043,
0.13116863369941711,
0.09576684236526489,
0.5519609451293945,
0.030705291777849197,
0.9030284285545349,
0.37643587589263916,
-0.0046809338964521885,
0.11349648237228394,
0.05331689491868019,
0.23301661014556885,
-0.5005649924278259,
-0.048346929252147675,
-0.44661179184913635,
-0.23004117608070374,
-0.33536237478256226,
-0.17395979166030884,
0.23142696917057037,
0.1909024715423584,
-0.19252274930477142,
0.44845059514045715,
-0.5972779989242554,
1.019774079322815,
0.6722416877746582,
-0.0698811486363411,
0.17715610563755035,
-0.5005242824554443,
-0.39650285243988037,
0.14653602242469788,
-0.5180233120918274,
-0.01962626352906227,
0.5878903269767761,
-0.18774613738059998,
0.6881992220878601,
0.11715350300073624,
0.5752785205841064,
-0.03476399928331375,
0.1981615275144577,
-0.8175373673439026,
0.8232893943786621,
0.25550660490989685,
-1.0002433061599731,
-0.13199371099472046,
-0.5967731475830078,
-0.6193843483924866,
0.005826900713145733,
-0.17592692375183105,
-0.8414173722267151,
0.3343646824359894,
0.7644833922386169,
-0.44331634044647217,
0.20165735483169556,
-0.6169467568397522,
1.1499226093292236,
-0.12321049720048904,
-0.6422594785690308,
-0.22345812618732452,
-0.5518786311149597,
0.7967739701271057,
0.2487199455499649,
-0.06598671525716782,
-0.03905890882015228,
0.32814422249794006,
0.07950787991285324,
-0.5623971223831177,
0.8723863959312439,
-0.37893879413604736,
-0.068504199385643,
0.4913419783115387,
0.592902421951294,
0.8279427289962769,
0.16598647832870483,
0.26979175209999084,
-0.1148398146033287,
0.21241740882396698,
-0.28924503922462463,
-0.7419739961624146,
0.9401183128356934,
-0.5666999816894531,
-0.8126885890960693,
-0.25349387526512146,
-0.7782823443412781,
-0.3946742117404938,
0.40343916416168213,
0.11973997950553894,
0.09386958926916122,
0.01348197553306818,
0.29932206869125366,
0.7579013705253601,
-0.46016260981559753,
-0.14688949286937714,
0.6761335134506226,
-0.13518288731575012,
-0.1301109492778778,
0.8558006882667542,
-0.15378573536872864,
0.2539754807949066,
0.6130759716033936,
0.5188673734664917,
-0.17178742587566376,
-0.20387248694896698,
-0.2827007472515106,
0.1714269369840622,
-0.8934518098831177,
-0.546906054019928,
-0.48818153142929077,
-0.18722207844257355,
-0.5235916972160339,
-0.3219224810600281,
-0.1553604155778885,
-0.5360866785049438,
0.20705676078796387,
-0.15506647527217865,
0.4140361249446869,
0.3657584488391876,
-0.31318408250808716,
-0.016939515247941017,
-0.5683070421218872,
0.13881711661815643,
0.7577646970748901,
0.22948749363422394,
-0.17641441524028778,
-0.25152111053466797,
-0.07580681890249252,
-0.5211527347564697,
-0.4391327500343323,
-1.0265276432037354,
-0.05470016971230507,
-0.2802976369857788,
0.5597294569015503,
0.593631386756897,
0.2965999245643616,
0.6276413202285767,
-0.22496354579925537,
0.5930160880088806,
-0.04105117917060852,
-1.0315839052200317,
0.6017307043075562,
-0.37154582142829895,
0.698019802570343,
0.5306034684181213,
0.12075388431549072,
-0.9066252708435059,
-0.591006875038147,
-0.36656975746154785,
-0.7281190752983093,
0.7385416626930237,
-0.04775397479534149,
-0.16212327778339386,
0.0515151247382164,
0.2989096939563751,
0.120133176445961,
0.2517978847026825,
-0.7169177532196045,
0.09301920980215073,
-0.24781709909439087,
-0.09506184607744217,
0.6064761281013489,
-0.34556037187576294,
-0.12350422888994217,
-0.19731923937797546,
0.9820599555969238,
-0.22488833963871002,
0.03162159398198128,
0.23893995583057404,
-0.38123926520347595,
-0.18187090754508972,
0.530212938785553,
0.5221490263938904,
0.7035687565803528,
-0.10481487959623337,
0.30627545714378357,
0.497854083776474,
-0.13374494016170502,
-0.08056889474391937,
0.21778404712677002,
-0.5945982933044434,
-0.13656409084796906,
0.2141224592924118,
0.561169445514679,
0.07446304708719254,
-0.7804881930351257,
0.5396173000335693,
0.40832647681236267,
-0.3769254684448242,
-0.3152870237827301,
0.17776554822921753,
0.21129171550273895,
0.10677635669708252,
-0.18354766070842743,
-0.15136407315731049,
0.23772168159484863,
0.00676565570756793,
0.17641960084438324,
0.5166335701942444,
-0.19638855755329132,
-0.0736888125538826,
0.5374075174331665,
0.24881358444690704,
0.10194507241249084,
0.5719545483589172,
-0.5946551561355591,
-0.6826829314231873,
0.45092737674713135,
0.5803707242012024,
0.7312560677528381,
-0.23622189462184906,
0.18416380882263184,
0.6587818264961243,
0.5748142004013062,
0.06588131189346313,
0.27227452397346497,
-0.5637804865837097,
-0.8793717622756958,
-0.9384219646453857,
-0.23827984929084778,
-0.6490235328674316,
0.5203333497047424,
-0.22223685681819916,
0.5966819524765015,
-0.6938207745552063,
0.2773148715496063,
0.008944596163928509,
-0.19071027636528015,
-0.6667507290840149,
-0.2285248339176178,
0.08633651584386826,
1.1470376253128052,
-0.8430607914924622,
0.46161413192749023,
0.7310991287231445,
-0.33923470973968506,
-0.9481518864631653,
-0.429516077041626,
0.5269051790237427,
-0.6358785629272461,
0.7895498871803284,
0.2858525812625885,
-0.17380696535110474,
-0.3340567350387573,
-1.1242610216140747,
-0.7680914402008057,
0.6525866389274597,
0.36335116624832153,
-0.7508582472801208,
0.1615854650735855,
0.058617882430553436,
0.12788355350494385,
0.22022747993469238,
-0.08785261958837509,
0.6173787713050842,
0.8900958895683289,
0.11547661572694778,
-0.754916787147522,
0.46596524119377136,
-0.27348798513412476,
-0.39201226830482483,
0.42584580183029175,
-0.49859359860420227,
0.6035115122795105,
-0.13291339576244354,
-0.023115484043955803,
0.10086718201637268,
0.6725133657455444,
0.5631089210510254,
0.24004055559635162,
0.7996817231178284,
0.7391343116760254,
0.7240126132965088,
-0.10911619663238525,
0.6951837539672852,
-0.1264135241508484,
0.2868061065673828,
1.374549388885498,
-0.40399637818336487,
0.34639519453048706,
0.5557631850242615,
-0.0048584300093352795,
0.6972728967666626,
0.19768281280994415,
-0.2494272142648697,
0.35021862387657166,
0.2702449560165405,
-0.304878830909729,
-0.8186396360397339,
-0.18549653887748718,
-0.15657837688922882,
0.201353520154953,
0.4166753888130188,
-0.02704145759344101,
-0.1694394052028656,
-0.2539921998977661,
0.08868160098791122,
0.06524992734193802,
-0.09811630100011826,
0.5786163210868835,
0.06742484867572784,
-1.0099483728408813,
0.502839982509613,
-0.12795430421829224,
0.2626967132091522,
-0.732991635799408,
-0.0818457156419754,
0.06940406560897827,
0.26207759976387024,
-0.3468899726867676,
-0.8601402640342712,
0.2154383808374405,
-0.22945931553840637,
-0.033222269266843796,
-0.018559088930487633,
1.1209303140640259,
-0.4121663570404053,
-0.17843641340732574,
-0.03490680083632469,
0.43314334750175476,
0.010846533812582493,
-0.07236839085817337,
-0.6028008460998535,
-0.06399740278720856,
0.008877599611878395,
-0.012969817034900188,
-0.20615261793136597,
0.7062720060348511,
-0.08466962724924088,
0.6269965767860413,
0.8239460587501526,
0.14761854708194733,
-0.2249082773923874,
0.07659609615802765,
1.0401694774627686,
-0.4833371043205261,
-0.7687047719955444,
-0.6244710683822632,
0.4351935386657715,
-0.5673974752426147,
-0.22051019966602325,
0.7526179552078247,
0.46767786145210266,
0.9735867977142334,
-0.2525530457496643,
0.8861092329025269,
-0.5140021443367004,
0.5769274830818176,
-0.3540770411491394,
0.42017611861228943,
-0.39425116777420044,
0.0704512670636177,
-0.31219640374183655,
-0.643325924873352,
-0.3922296464443207,
0.7015761137008667,
-0.5435189604759216,
-0.23064057528972626,
0.7903841733932495,
1.102476716041565,
-0.30589085817337036,
0.12076636403799057,
0.24744229018688202,
0.3306623101234436,
0.2739802300930023,
0.8323999643325806,
1.2146798372268677,
0.3746531903743744,
0.8839700222015381,
-0.3782424032688141,
-0.3270520865917206,
-0.28675031661987305,
-1.174418568611145,
-1.200487494468689,
-0.40830305218696594,
-0.25489985942840576,
-0.4899413585662842,
-0.08815301954746246,
1.047668218612671,
0.7298972010612488,
-1.0708314180374146,
-0.0665469542145729,
-0.47430822253227234,
0.40002885460853577,
-0.43598514795303345,
-0.3239520788192749,
0.10226589441299438,
-0.5522826313972473,
-0.30592548847198486,
0.3875415623188019,
0.09780221432447433,
-0.44146862626075745,
-0.2718096077442169,
-0.12416889518499374,
-0.14362700283527374,
-0.03700961172580719,
0.43738237023353577,
0.7126495838165283,
-0.5918117761611938,
-0.47251877188682556,
-0.005147678777575493,
0.1523321568965912,
-0.34933313727378845,
1.195121169090271,
-0.8644990921020508,
0.5419859290122986,
0.7591195106506348,
0.7186316251754761,
0.48456209897994995,
-0.3440456986427307,
0.5546973347663879,
-1.0555025339126587,
0.1891845315694809,
0.1763005405664444,
0.43868833780288696,
0.2514735162258148,
-0.43479254841804504,
0.34383633732795715,
0.26877522468566895,
-0.6870086789131165,
-0.9439112544059753,
0.8272284865379333,
-0.8948467373847961,
-0.4682873487472534,
1.1550571918487549,
0.042976852506399155,
-0.14625367522239685,
-0.35334354639053345,
-0.4036915898323059,
0.09295117110013962,
-0.5475201606750488,
0.8697425127029419,
0.8932952284812927,
0.07414700835943222,
-0.2664148211479187,
-0.3875851333141327,
0.6398086547851562,
0.6227535009384155,
-0.8866336345672607,
0.3500334620475769,
0.853405773639679,
0.33185774087905884,
0.333897203207016,
0.2292344719171524,
0.052436500787734985,
0.7065916061401367,
-0.2216525673866272,
0.12073355913162231,
-0.5518901944160461,
-0.103473000228405,
0.13113248348236084,
-0.013852659612894058,
-0.01677139662206173,
0.2554715871810913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13996v1 | Investigate-Consolidate-Exploit: A General Strategy for Inter-Task Agent Self-Evolution | 2024-01-25T07:47:49 | 2024-01-25T07:47:49 | Cheng Qian, Shihao Liang, Yujia Qin, Yining Ye, Xin Cong, Yankai Lin, Yesai Wu, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces Investigate-Consolidate-Exploit (ICE), a novel strategy
for enhancing the adaptability and flexibility of AI agents through inter-task
self-evolution. Unlike existing methods focused on intra-task learning, ICE
promotes the transfer of knowledge between tasks for genuine self-evolution,
similar to human experience learning. The strategy dynamically investigates
planning and execution trajectories, consolidates them into simplified
workflows and pipelines, and exploits them for improved task execution. Our
experiments on the XAgent framework demonstrate ICE's effectiveness, reducing
API calls by as much as 80% and significantly decreasing the demand for the
model's capability. Specifically, when combined with GPT-3.5, ICE's performance
matches that of raw GPT-4 across various agent tasks. We argue that this
self-evolution approach represents a paradigm shift in agent design,
contributing to a more robust AI community and ecosystem, and moving a step
closer to full autonomy. | [
-0.41978567838668823,
-0.3955199718475342,
0.27776628732681274,
-0.014237773604691029,
-0.04166124388575554,
0.356058269739151,
0.033492561429739,
-0.4593049883842468,
0.3222584128379822,
0.5040588974952698,
-0.7107812762260437,
-0.042393047362565994,
-0.39647361636161804,
-0.043883610516786575,
-0.3832114636898041,
1.1178044080734253,
-0.13163800537586212,
-0.48346975445747375,
-0.2740899324417114,
-0.22387029230594635,
-0.6320317387580872,
-0.26491454243659973,
-0.7928380966186523,
-0.25155219435691833,
0.37458688020706177,
0.4915080666542053,
0.694022536277771,
0.7719190716743469,
0.5040920376777649,
0.36706387996673584,
0.5675031542778015,
0.27813252806663513,
-0.6222876310348511,
0.34282347559928894,
-0.4549339711666107,
-0.5007622241973877,
-0.5325027704238892,
0.09185948967933655,
0.28028997778892517,
-0.036339640617370605,
-0.2519918978214264,
0.15997369587421417,
0.19133780896663666,
0.35301005840301514,
-0.8370899558067322,
0.18252640962600708,
-0.42418137192726135,
-0.1852591335773468,
-0.006184157449752092,
-0.14899201691150665,
-0.38627418875694275,
0.4315198063850403,
0.16338907182216644,
-0.5817210078239441,
0.1038387268781662,
-0.2162122130393982,
0.3558838963508606,
0.5197410583496094,
-0.15552933514118195,
0.008233325555920601,
-0.8779487609863281,
0.5659821033477783,
-0.18836919963359833,
-0.12296631932258606,
-0.021040435880422592,
0.5855922102928162,
-0.17819149792194366,
-1.258481502532959,
-0.3873123526573181,
-0.3646547198295593,
-0.020785067230463028,
0.20296373963356018,
-0.6196507215499878,
-0.07276421785354614,
-0.2913884222507477,
0.056844521313905716,
-0.44296780228614807,
0.2666487991809845,
-0.2742551565170288,
0.06596847623586655,
0.8797945380210876,
0.24961552023887634,
0.4931028485298157,
0.4214583933353424,
-0.619188129901886,
-0.3551709055900574,
-0.48977044224739075,
0.14152006804943085,
0.08032406866550446,
0.36082202196121216,
-0.058701034635305405,
0.1404832899570465,
-0.09638898074626923,
0.07979879528284073,
0.34715694189071655,
0.18085524439811707,
0.24431677162647247,
-0.09105021506547928,
-0.39160412549972534,
-0.09334585815668106,
0.6220546364784241,
0.18682579696178436,
-0.5210179686546326,
-0.4807601571083069,
-0.260114848613739,
-0.18583136796951294,
0.8142684698104858,
-0.5283839106559753,
-0.362816721200943,
0.4078945517539978,
-0.3653389513492584,
-0.5012401938438416,
-0.4002479314804077,
-0.5230215191841125,
-0.07181185483932495,
-0.12621989846229553,
0.5865278244018555,
-0.4629192054271698,
-0.40868711471557617,
-0.11042730510234833,
-0.26601263880729675,
0.5007096529006958,
0.4615989923477173,
-0.6871351599693298,
0.6350904703140259,
0.8683214783668518,
0.7592438459396362,
-0.5041482448577881,
-0.8223757743835449,
-0.5791251063346863,
0.1396535336971283,
-0.36178719997406006,
0.8298979997634888,
-0.2962208688259125,
-0.33019477128982544,
-0.17401407659053802,
-0.1429644227027893,
-0.04555243253707886,
-0.5472738146781921,
0.21750116348266602,
-0.4915916621685028,
0.19491411745548248,
-0.12437137216329575,
-0.2740885317325592,
-0.28122371435165405,
0.42868372797966003,
-0.5834702849388123,
0.9768496751785278,
0.46911153197288513,
-0.30238133668899536,
0.5516481399536133,
-1.4016964435577393,
-0.1884024739265442,
0.4933299720287323,
-0.19158494472503662,
-0.4181090295314789,
-0.14521238207817078,
0.07950295507907867,
0.3561423122882843,
-0.4186735153198242,
-0.18951000273227692,
-0.3356987535953522,
-0.09291694313287735,
-0.059923186898231506,
-0.028825795277953148,
0.7073025703430176,
0.47886383533477783,
-0.8157718181610107,
0.34767597913742065,
-0.19957475364208221,
0.07571015506982803,
0.17952212691307068,
0.16109541058540344,
-0.229923278093338,
-0.007079958450049162,
-0.43336209654808044,
0.21660089492797852,
0.14492924511432648,
-0.24784593284130096,
0.6687859892845154,
0.1409584879875183,
0.43200942873954773,
0.6979660987854004,
-0.07591027766466141,
0.7126175165176392,
-0.7073550820350647,
0.819950520992279,
-0.0643370971083641,
0.5128288865089417,
-0.18142688274383545,
-0.06626155972480774,
-0.4281340539455414,
-0.5015431046485901,
-0.03842298313975334,
0.6328574419021606,
-0.8771139979362488,
0.118155837059021,
-0.283818781375885,
-0.8637206554412842,
-0.4275478720664978,
0.18085937201976776,
0.33312639594078064,
0.24695198237895966,
0.6427199244499207,
-0.283487468957901,
-0.08424215763807297,
-0.8163966536521912,
-0.36770525574684143,
-0.14009103178977966,
0.11796867102384567,
0.20234040915966034,
0.6414430141448975,
-0.38061872124671936,
0.9765759110450745,
-0.4245973527431488,
-0.33476513624191284,
-0.42021217942237854,
0.6193574666976929,
-0.24540632963180542,
0.899919331073761,
1.041790246963501,
-0.9166415929794312,
-0.5402526259422302,
0.00858300644904375,
-0.8696373701095581,
0.34960174560546875,
-0.2895453870296478,
-0.16159963607788086,
0.013033651746809483,
0.5679599642753601,
-0.7827139496803284,
0.4129786193370819,
0.1658182144165039,
-0.39173445105552673,
0.6103779673576355,
-0.39480021595954895,
0.22150300443172455,
-0.8827493786811829,
-0.08155780285596848,
-0.36664772033691406,
-0.10031477361917496,
-0.8091527819633484,
0.6460976004600525,
0.10559333860874176,
-0.104109987616539,
-0.3560578525066376,
0.41732701659202576,
-0.9219772815704346,
0.09308668971061707,
-0.5162913203239441,
-0.0708293467760086,
-0.4184474050998688,
0.392015665769577,
-0.4938053488731384,
0.8841297030448914,
0.8296825289726257,
-0.5084782242774963,
0.30551716685295105,
0.000951901136431843,
0.27705252170562744,
0.47720780968666077,
-0.30182233452796936,
0.6538611650466919,
-0.2501288652420044,
0.15326108038425446,
-0.8791127800941467,
-0.013636386953294277,
0.2812131643295288,
-0.4764856994152069,
0.5058164000511169,
-0.2601066529750824,
-0.24373577535152435,
-0.27070343494415283,
-0.5236337184906006,
0.6215097308158875,
0.6179719567298889,
-0.6592646837234497,
1.0712485313415527,
0.31319886445999146,
-0.115676648914814,
-0.7584048509597778,
-0.47414663434028625,
0.4529227614402771,
-0.606198787689209,
-0.7970803380012512,
0.49158111214637756,
-0.23923750221729279,
-0.46629124879837036,
0.283698707818985,
-0.015043919906020164,
-0.041909780353307724,
0.31641319394111633,
0.00012892291124444455,
0.21038207411766052,
-0.29516056180000305,
-0.003550524590536952,
0.010252919979393482,
-0.019419962540268898,
0.08886927366256714,
-0.552956759929657,
0.37970679998397827,
-0.12048741430044174,
-0.25117412209510803,
-0.22455337643623352,
0.4306245446205139,
0.7540333867073059,
-0.4033565819263458,
0.546901285648346,
0.4989043176174164,
-0.04496369883418083,
-0.33394765853881836,
-0.566859245300293,
-0.3471192419528961,
-0.4984143376350403,
0.22539584338665009,
-0.5102043151855469,
-0.7635067701339722,
0.3792721629142761,
-0.37912285327911377,
0.4443506598472595,
0.5024166107177734,
0.2697339355945587,
-0.03406371548771858,
0.7046604752540588,
0.8936245441436768,
-0.26813846826553345,
0.36175039410591125,
-0.49889907240867615,
0.02634972147643566,
-0.6705153584480286,
-0.1617681086063385,
-0.28495272994041443,
-0.5222601890563965,
-0.5328544974327087,
-0.6062857508659363,
0.29584982991218567,
-0.2356550246477127,
-0.11555726826190948,
0.39316365122795105,
-0.43933016061782837,
0.4855981171131134,
0.326967716217041,
0.014778723940253258,
-0.06906820088624954,
-0.25548940896987915,
0.47627943754196167,
0.25358694791793823,
-0.7295174598693848,
-0.08782999962568283,
1.1212434768676758,
0.03649959713220596,
0.5945723056793213,
0.24872609972953796,
1.1341137886047363,
0.9866846203804016,
0.3048843741416931,
-0.3336254954338074,
0.25975745916366577,
0.05635514855384827,
-0.4542204439640045,
-0.6960164904594421,
-0.05022016167640686,
-1.3482210636138916,
0.47920507192611694,
0.018513759598135948,
-0.8602621555328369,
0.25216758251190186,
0.3332464396953583,
-0.29247793555259705,
0.263938844203949,
-0.851688802242279,
0.9414382576942444,
-0.39318811893463135,
-0.4554827809333801,
-0.6352091431617737,
-0.6424489617347717,
0.3371809422969818,
-0.0209082942456007,
0.11023969948291779,
0.047278087586164474,
-0.38337036967277527,
0.2979278564453125,
-0.38612794876098633,
0.8111859560012817,
-0.25722840428352356,
0.1403559148311615,
0.6012986302375793,
0.28641477227211,
0.8292155265808105,
-0.18568721413612366,
0.2438843995332718,
-0.20388002693653107,
-0.4196350574493408,
-0.7785758972167969,
-0.9493435621261597,
0.42671704292297363,
-0.8509095907211304,
-0.7129299640655518,
-0.2784190773963928,
-0.5694752335548401,
0.16609817743301392,
0.1460658311843872,
0.12475688755512238,
0.3189011216163635,
-0.20785552263259888,
0.06771013140678406,
0.3033844828605652,
0.4151802361011505,
0.5962677001953125,
0.48437783122062683,
0.2053547352552414,
-0.1553734391927719,
0.7856668829917908,
0.13515475392341614,
0.46724432706832886,
0.28732478618621826,
0.24076667428016663,
-0.011707374826073647,
-0.6876813173294067,
-0.02977748215198517,
-0.023018255829811096,
-0.5484364628791809,
-0.3243253231048584,
-0.6459146738052368,
0.03905278444290161,
-0.691745936870575,
-0.3905399739742279,
-0.451053649187088,
-0.21191196143627167,
-0.16678757965564728,
-0.023435303941369057,
0.2001827508211136,
0.7073055505752563,
-0.6686100363731384,
0.49261265993118286,
-0.5692100524902344,
0.08876814693212509,
0.40060293674468994,
-0.21418307721614838,
-0.15590453147888184,
-0.4457797110080719,
-0.13194379210472107,
-0.16716481745243073,
-0.48498064279556274,
-0.8544805645942688,
0.624644935131073,
0.15828856825828552,
0.9281476140022278,
0.2942561209201813,
0.38585034012794495,
0.725048303604126,
0.08133623749017715,
0.751874566078186,
0.08818399161100388,
-0.8728597164154053,
0.4119187891483307,
-0.4566255509853363,
0.3243360221385956,
0.4645133912563324,
0.6395770907402039,
-0.13023939728736877,
-0.3304620683193207,
-1.0308970212936401,
-1.0085028409957886,
0.8560076951980591,
0.4016515016555786,
0.03587344288825989,
0.3891753852367401,
0.45403507351875305,
0.12319675087928772,
0.026549383997917175,
-0.587394654750824,
-0.33049848675727844,
-0.20447953045368195,
0.3085351884365082,
-0.18753907084465027,
0.039156731218099594,
-0.589672327041626,
-0.1831260472536087,
0.5577748417854309,
-0.499097615480423,
0.38107171654701233,
0.2118116021156311,
-0.20418421924114227,
0.2440870702266693,
0.16952598094940186,
0.35031425952911377,
0.6852432489395142,
0.08125702291727066,
0.11810924857854843,
0.45057618618011475,
-0.43290749192237854,
0.17044836282730103,
0.28178009390830994,
0.07572915405035019,
-0.6965168118476868,
0.5531424880027771,
0.5232294797897339,
-0.016175633296370506,
-0.5098600387573242,
0.35918501019477844,
-0.2760073244571686,
-0.4068606495857239,
-0.23360498249530792,
0.35379302501678467,
-0.444695383310318,
0.8856136798858643,
0.4835028350353241,
0.14273609220981598,
0.4243701100349426,
-0.9573895335197449,
0.3828193247318268,
0.12424946576356888,
-0.47269725799560547,
-0.31113436818122864,
0.23000836372375488,
0.030203431844711304,
-0.34694573283195496,
0.6633450984954834,
-0.7406253814697266,
-0.45824187994003296,
0.8729501366615295,
0.6657580137252808,
1.3598802089691162,
-0.4402856230735779,
0.40948107838630676,
0.002236182801425457,
0.3539574444293976,
0.05078477784991264,
0.2322530299425125,
-0.3376239836215973,
-0.547475278377533,
-0.2859601676464081,
0.259866863489151,
-0.13569030165672302,
0.021982109174132347,
-0.5648876428604126,
0.18618662655353546,
-0.10639654099941254,
0.20204485952854156,
-0.17919129133224487,
-0.21350862085819244,
-0.5638635158538818,
-0.04877764359116554,
-0.16551661491394043,
0.9603676199913025,
-0.611228346824646,
0.7773613333702087,
0.7796622514724731,
-0.3040027618408203,
-0.7853952646255493,
0.1553610861301422,
0.15003588795661926,
-0.8565276265144348,
0.5806432962417603,
-0.0852787122130394,
-0.20209328830242157,
-0.09443279355764389,
-0.8363795280456543,
-1.1377942562103271,
1.5086818933486938,
0.3318541646003723,
-0.05902979522943497,
0.03863406553864479,
-0.22363175451755524,
0.5768306255340576,
-0.6816887259483337,
0.264020174741745,
0.7313110828399658,
0.37253499031066895,
0.110884889960289,
-0.8288964033126831,
0.19417941570281982,
-0.35718369483947754,
-0.43421265482902527,
0.37867724895477295,
-0.8273239731788635,
0.9380747675895691,
-0.5123181343078613,
-0.19528362154960632,
-0.10800465196371078,
0.8443300724029541,
-0.09089984744787216,
0.2746320962905884,
0.7795368432998657,
0.387099027633667,
0.6265996694564819,
0.27578413486480713,
0.8864755034446716,
-0.23641332983970642,
0.35534748435020447,
1.2673823833465576,
-0.12459690868854523,
0.6210266947746277,
0.18904009461402893,
0.051775798201560974,
0.5691768527030945,
0.258747398853302,
-0.06484178453683853,
0.6842722296714783,
0.06461384892463684,
-0.23457792401313782,
-0.23825517296791077,
0.1815338432788849,
-0.07032833248376846,
0.9082574248313904,
0.2083304077386856,
0.060631394386291504,
-0.3407640755176544,
0.019993804395198822,
0.3457770049571991,
-0.2271333634853363,
-0.3459795117378235,
0.8914287686347961,
-0.2810302972793579,
-1.1591336727142334,
0.33503738045692444,
-0.43318289518356323,
0.29113131761550903,
-0.6850879788398743,
-0.1885085105895996,
-0.28163251280784607,
0.4159843921661377,
-0.17666023969650269,
-0.5820021629333496,
0.18853655457496643,
-0.33491045236587524,
0.2727837860584259,
-0.27587318420410156,
0.8276602625846863,
-0.04952451214194298,
0.16747410595417023,
0.627914309501648,
0.45399364829063416,
0.034428440034389496,
-0.22537672519683838,
-0.7988720536231995,
-0.2117343693971634,
-0.08043785393238068,
0.06704123318195343,
0.582538366317749,
0.41279464960098267,
-0.03961896523833275,
0.9817796349525452,
0.44998303055763245,
-0.3572753965854645,
0.043460309505462646,
-0.5849536061286926,
1.154162049293518,
-0.5985292196273804,
-0.6220549941062927,
-0.8792921304702759,
0.7100270986557007,
-0.18179045617580414,
-0.2627260386943817,
0.4836506247520447,
0.5657293200492859,
0.5828522443771362,
0.10835683345794678,
1.000582218170166,
-0.45079565048217773,
-0.034283146262168884,
-0.2551265358924866,
0.5076198577880859,
-0.7382852435112,
0.00875604897737503,
-0.15695662796497345,
-0.47762173414230347,
0.14677616953849792,
-0.05171871557831764,
-0.01349704060703516,
0.0827932059764862,
0.7150342464447021,
0.3956361711025238,
-0.17988434433937073,
-0.13371722400188446,
0.2872087359428406,
0.16732841730117798,
0.7035432457923889,
0.2487313449382782,
0.837968647480011,
-0.16608436405658722,
0.6781586408615112,
-0.2800338566303253,
-0.8173007965087891,
-0.14092737436294556,
-0.7659577131271362,
-0.7927952408790588,
-0.7029496431350708,
-0.2784358859062195,
-0.056623466312885284,
0.2969535291194916,
0.9327753782272339,
0.9560365676879883,
-0.2396095097064972,
-0.45211195945739746,
0.08665309846401215,
-0.2890159487724304,
-0.8271902203559875,
-0.16862432658672333,
0.23085932433605194,
-1.0015166997909546,
-0.36743101477622986,
0.6989967226982117,
0.27420127391815186,
0.0018586103105917573,
-0.3152633011341095,
-0.1215069442987442,
-0.02326704002916813,
-0.14665472507476807,
0.5039301514625549,
0.8489133715629578,
-0.2093169391155243,
-0.14828605949878693,
0.026258911937475204,
0.2841101288795471,
0.1813293695449829,
1.103814721107483,
-0.7275996208190918,
0.45722368359565735,
0.25051993131637573,
0.755603015422821,
0.8559150695800781,
-0.1959816813468933,
0.8296163082122803,
-0.3579775393009186,
-0.056338418275117874,
0.1966596096754074,
0.15530073642730713,
-0.1981554627418518,
-0.7683925032615662,
0.7817543745040894,
-0.031658612191677094,
-0.851406455039978,
-0.6128513216972351,
0.15367820858955383,
-0.9312511086463928,
-0.4330058693885803,
0.5640274286270142,
-0.4247303307056427,
-0.17798948287963867,
-0.16962571442127228,
-0.10809734463691711,
0.03642537444829941,
-0.6124821901321411,
1.1426259279251099,
0.16915728151798248,
-0.846131443977356,
-0.20543693006038666,
-0.26662662625312805,
0.672250509262085,
0.33094292879104614,
-1.2956573963165283,
0.22062449157238007,
0.1014181599020958,
0.19853296875953674,
0.4640321731567383,
0.6512772440910339,
0.13500787317752838,
0.5618414282798767,
0.334351122379303,
0.013584788888692856,
-0.0002635132404975593,
-0.6498026251792908,
-0.2719937264919281,
0.2411784678697586,
0.18803435564041138,
-0.4701017737388611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13986v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13986v1 | Towards Consistent Natural-Language Explanations via Explanation-Consistency Finetuning | 2024-01-25T07:04:30 | 2024-01-25T07:04:30 | Yanda Chen, Chandan Singh, Xiaodong Liu, Simiao Zuo, Bin Yu, He He, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) often generate convincing, fluent explanations.
However, different from humans, they often generate inconsistent explanations
on different inputs. For example, an LLM may generate the explanation "all
birds can fly" when answering the question "Can sparrows fly?" but meanwhile
answer "no" to the related question "Can penguins fly?". Explanations should be
consistent across related examples so that they allow a human to simulate the
LLM's decision process on multiple examples. We propose explanation-consistency
finetuning (EC-finetuning), a method that adapts LLMs to generate more
consistent natural-language explanations on related examples. EC-finetuning
involves finetuning LLMs on synthetic data that is carefully constructed to
contain consistent explanations. Across a variety of question-answering
datasets in various domains, EC-finetuning yields a 10.0% relative explanation
consistency improvement on four finetuning datasets, and generalizes to seven
out-of-distribution datasets not seen during finetuning (+4.5% relative). Code
is available at https://github.com/yandachen/explanation-consistency-finetuning . | [
-0.3093028962612152,
-1.1221537590026855,
0.7398064136505127,
0.3618144690990448,
-0.22260653972625732,
-0.25860458612442017,
-0.8156101107597351,
-0.38656604290008545,
-0.050463609397411346,
0.2718440294265747,
-0.7179062962532043,
-0.44824787974357605,
-0.22076044976711273,
0.38770565390586853,
-0.312134712934494,
0.8614664077758789,
-0.21846909821033478,
-0.05844588950276375,
-0.2102886140346527,
0.05997296795248985,
-0.3994176685810089,
-0.035617757588624954,
-0.7431217432022095,
-0.33015912771224976,
0.7021579146385193,
0.7653399109840393,
0.9094764590263367,
1.0435351133346558,
0.22715988755226135,
0.17101430892944336,
0.022052614018321037,
0.6480953693389893,
-0.43745577335357666,
0.06914465874433517,
-0.4126822054386139,
-0.5464288592338562,
-0.030345888808369637,
-0.16048391163349152,
0.5298765897750854,
0.9876857399940491,
-0.24872490763664246,
-0.3532981872558594,
0.4007398188114166,
0.528613269329071,
-0.45557427406311035,
0.09420064836740494,
-0.6553589105606079,
-0.2506580650806427,
0.020482175052165985,
-0.3842184245586395,
-0.3183387517929077,
-0.4637308716773987,
0.12699636816978455,
-1.0269355773925781,
0.289775550365448,
0.12087058275938034,
0.9951820373535156,
0.20738616585731506,
-0.18648351728916168,
-0.1780460774898529,
-0.8765061497688293,
0.7457924485206604,
-0.8815154433250427,
0.39364469051361084,
0.3824971616268158,
0.4034961462020874,
-0.3861753046512604,
-0.5818817615509033,
-0.7916613221168518,
-0.19921322166919708,
-0.10849051922559738,
-0.004580385982990265,
0.01642904430627823,
0.13333763182163239,
0.1761663258075714,
0.2833893597126007,
-0.6420424580574036,
0.20594234764575958,
0.07820229232311249,
-0.38844016194343567,
0.5343247652053833,
0.026777971535921097,
0.18430225551128387,
0.036741387099027634,
-0.14460070431232452,
0.06564053893089294,
-0.7864163517951965,
0.0761227160692215,
0.13110634684562683,
0.45364809036254883,
-0.31069207191467285,
0.5312703847885132,
-0.42863479256629944,
0.8707064986228943,
0.45107656717300415,
0.09307807683944702,
-0.1287996470928192,
-0.41079244017601013,
-0.30455905199050903,
0.014344103634357452,
0.6053577065467834,
0.5870465040206909,
0.528592050075531,
-0.36619454622268677,
-0.02339673414826393,
0.052624206990003586,
-0.08665374666452408,
-0.6162737607955933,
-0.27235954999923706,
0.4565166234970093,
-0.35537421703338623,
-0.2081443965435028,
-0.0006508287624455988,
-0.8433936834335327,
-0.5529787540435791,
-0.7910499572753906,
0.4180624186992645,
-0.40875008702278137,
-0.3068190813064575,
0.33628225326538086,
0.1308811604976654,
0.35916396975517273,
0.3707509934902191,
-1.1211191415786743,
0.46126800775527954,
0.890109658241272,
0.7727000117301941,
-0.10732907056808472,
-0.4415593147277832,
-0.8277580142021179,
0.23288550972938538,
-0.42518332600593567,
0.9016555547714233,
-0.29650750756263733,
0.2532699406147003,
0.1135023981332779,
0.14145946502685547,
0.18600405752658844,
-0.5723848342895508,
0.5997664332389832,
-0.16146346926689148,
0.13537804782390594,
-0.3475922644138336,
-0.8170893788337708,
-0.2105034440755844,
0.40675678849220276,
-0.2869097888469696,
0.5979869961738586,
-0.4075043201446533,
-0.624191164970398,
0.39503929018974304,
-0.44146379828453064,
-0.29927051067352295,
-0.26012346148490906,
-0.2942907512187958,
-0.3931550681591034,
0.06137619912624359,
0.36263057589530945,
0.5444542169570923,
-0.31733283400535583,
0.3602965772151947,
-0.44969984889030457,
-0.4102030098438263,
0.21812619268894196,
-0.7214856147766113,
0.7623573541641235,
0.26272639632225037,
-0.3290005922317505,
-0.014930183999240398,
-0.7810953855514526,
0.04223078489303589,
0.24428486824035645,
-0.2837156355381012,
-0.08503077179193497,
0.18390437960624695,
-0.1688445806503296,
-0.15962624549865723,
0.37343549728393555,
-0.4973592460155487,
0.13924847543239594,
-0.42883801460266113,
0.4769958257675171,
0.5785140991210938,
0.0643329992890358,
0.5754250288009644,
-0.7208366394042969,
0.3304969370365143,
0.055995892733335495,
0.009351078420877457,
-0.39864712953567505,
-0.26619186997413635,
-0.6112845540046692,
-0.0260247103869915,
0.1684296727180481,
0.2869873642921448,
-0.440915048122406,
0.2665863633155823,
-0.3831121623516083,
-0.30335623025894165,
-0.4383535385131836,
0.08057823032140732,
0.24165065586566925,
0.5537558794021606,
0.337677538394928,
0.3672712445259094,
-0.7992410063743591,
-0.8107268214225769,
-0.6149929761886597,
0.034729573875665665,
-0.27699410915374756,
0.09160004556179047,
0.08496633172035217,
-0.10832589864730835,
1.0609759092330933,
-0.18338747322559357,
0.16737176477909088,
-0.14257746934890747,
0.31885069608688354,
0.17387157678604126,
0.5280741453170776,
0.34110793471336365,
-0.6971919536590576,
-0.5310771465301514,
0.14804789423942566,
-0.5357705354690552,
-0.22859063744544983,
-0.6354747414588928,
-0.10084889084100723,
0.2025441974401474,
0.5817965269088745,
-0.4522894322872162,
-0.03655953332781792,
0.5776817798614502,
-0.17011383175849915,
0.6056139469146729,
-0.4565364718437195,
-0.09598740190267563,
-0.9518745541572571,
-0.21078015863895416,
0.16702809929847717,
-0.44195857644081116,
-0.6054726839065552,
0.17542393505573273,
-0.04994586855173111,
0.37893614172935486,
-0.21142812073230743,
0.4314730167388916,
-0.3339836001396179,
0.3146352767944336,
0.03377777338027954,
0.3886873424053192,
0.270084023475647,
0.38355937600135803,
-0.133097305893898,
0.5523289442062378,
0.8568089604377747,
-0.6845893859863281,
0.3654237985610962,
0.05474131926894188,
-0.17518757283687592,
0.5418208837509155,
-0.8077058792114258,
0.01704125851392746,
-0.34036412835121155,
0.21408185362815857,
-1.094294786453247,
-0.580341637134552,
0.24699966609477997,
-0.25270146131515503,
0.11429675668478012,
-0.49188312888145447,
-0.5286743640899658,
-0.030305908992886543,
-0.3220880627632141,
0.053284645080566406,
0.4293164312839508,
-0.8179423809051514,
0.8481743335723877,
-0.2530340552330017,
-0.04838841035962105,
-0.335110068321228,
-0.7600193619728088,
0.008244729600846767,
-0.3255951404571533,
-0.6855363249778748,
0.39997610449790955,
-0.4156953990459442,
-0.38931524753570557,
-0.18187452852725983,
-0.4483555257320404,
-0.2111777365207672,
0.31331342458724976,
0.0259880218654871,
0.12136110663414001,
-0.45318499207496643,
0.18541599810123444,
0.04944423958659172,
0.08686183393001556,
-0.010973728261888027,
-0.39291876554489136,
0.3840401768684387,
-0.30601951479911804,
-0.2763836979866028,
-0.6552686095237732,
0.3202606737613678,
0.4725853502750397,
-0.0007725998875685036,
0.7688800096511841,
0.4587050676345825,
-0.4713411033153534,
-0.16140338778495789,
-0.5132426619529724,
-0.42209216952323914,
-0.4650578796863556,
-0.04972909390926361,
-0.5443559885025024,
-0.5623078346252441,
0.7820470333099365,
-0.08606509119272232,
0.5328640937805176,
0.5003044605255127,
0.3368329703807831,
-0.37738949060440063,
1.2242684364318848,
0.5032011270523071,
0.3049542009830475,
0.2866300940513611,
0.037277646362781525,
0.04555710405111313,
-0.4284520149230957,
-0.17191678285598755,
-0.5938311815261841,
-0.1824180632829666,
-0.7252660989761353,
-0.03368959203362465,
-0.1466374397277832,
0.56219482421875,
-0.3396212160587311,
0.03508699685335159,
-0.347636342048645,
0.8242904543876648,
0.41944777965545654,
-0.046539679169654846,
0.4969172775745392,
0.19986781477928162,
-0.28338417410850525,
0.10873352736234665,
-0.7113821506500244,
-0.6890109777450562,
0.8943271636962891,
0.20971082150936127,
0.8550183773040771,
0.14915581047534943,
0.8130631446838379,
-0.04704948514699936,
0.34184733033180237,
-0.671535074710846,
0.23246712982654572,
-0.2611761689186096,
-0.49919968843460083,
-0.45386794209480286,
-0.6051675081253052,
-1.0238444805145264,
0.0735817477107048,
-0.3677941560745239,
-0.7107105255126953,
-0.08463043719530106,
0.6105897426605225,
-0.5611118078231812,
0.012397555634379387,
-0.7885510921478271,
0.9239795804023743,
-0.16842809319496155,
-0.400490403175354,
-0.08794119954109192,
-0.5692726373672485,
0.22357772290706635,
-0.05587053298950195,
0.43826767802238464,
-0.06566101312637329,
0.2659350633621216,
0.5849913954734802,
-0.4765864908695221,
0.8219612240791321,
-0.11989334970712662,
-0.21017791330814362,
0.20556095242500305,
0.25375446677207947,
0.6991462707519531,
0.08183971047401428,
-0.2873486876487732,
0.05552203953266144,
0.13494941592216492,
-0.40799039602279663,
-0.9605023264884949,
0.8313819169998169,
-0.5994777679443359,
-0.591093122959137,
0.14146140217781067,
-0.5513449907302856,
-0.1394067108631134,
0.10701592266559601,
0.29506006836891174,
0.5808718800544739,
0.1011989489197731,
0.2665102183818817,
0.7737162113189697,
-0.09554063528776169,
0.20822902023792267,
0.6059833765029907,
-0.17869383096694946,
-0.24141834676265717,
0.835878312587738,
0.00782540999352932,
0.22454071044921875,
0.5289369225502014,
0.6814568042755127,
-0.4734737277030945,
-0.6632375121116638,
-0.42102938890457153,
0.2990887463092804,
-0.6200342178344727,
-0.09044584631919861,
-0.34658315777778625,
0.06941191852092743,
-0.037599511444568634,
-0.3438863754272461,
-0.18447230756282806,
-0.4164259433746338,
-0.20250505208969116,
0.05064260959625244,
0.565601646900177,
0.6436150074005127,
-0.16970215737819672,
0.3113289773464203,
-0.605888307094574,
0.6404513716697693,
0.39926958084106445,
0.6129228472709656,
0.01372666098177433,
-0.659662663936615,
-0.17676568031311035,
0.7334898114204407,
-0.22458013892173767,
-0.7636033892631531,
-0.1344582587480545,
0.4855799973011017,
0.429559588432312,
0.5351800918579102,
0.17532587051391602,
1.0160702466964722,
-0.5770014524459839,
0.7959164977073669,
0.11217774450778961,
-0.9425138831138611,
0.4100029170513153,
-0.6247742772102356,
0.30772778391838074,
0.44755280017852783,
0.08624429255723953,
-0.8301856517791748,
-0.7308335900306702,
-0.5774002075195312,
-0.683962881565094,
0.49604278802871704,
0.13850295543670654,
0.04690379276871681,
-0.14136891067028046,
0.6430720686912537,
0.3179647922515869,
-0.27697625756263733,
-0.7711498141288757,
-0.27926531434059143,
-0.20381972193717957,
-0.6804904341697693,
-0.10852687805891037,
-0.02609892003238201,
-0.2947969138622284,
-0.11321409791707993,
0.5105570554733276,
-0.3854292333126068,
0.09588038176298141,
0.23898154497146606,
-0.08418770879507065,
-0.3398683965206146,
0.3508613705635071,
1.0093740224838257,
0.871338963508606,
0.024176442995667458,
0.6807357668876648,
0.02004370093345642,
-0.062272537499666214,
-0.18561628460884094,
0.24180367588996887,
-0.07010689377784729,
0.04614226520061493,
0.43302348256111145,
0.36951032280921936,
0.06568491458892822,
-0.636340320110321,
0.3560725450515747,
-0.13500431180000305,
-0.38626423478126526,
-0.24466411769390106,
0.10841480642557144,
0.3861319422721863,
0.12547099590301514,
0.27842453122138977,
0.08629046380519867,
-0.20967894792556763,
-0.5165110230445862,
0.1533534973859787,
0.30794572830200195,
0.005551744252443314,
-0.2720145881175995,
0.8615138530731201,
0.03953967243432999,
-0.32076209783554077,
0.3910110890865326,
-0.13209225237369537,
-0.2573230266571045,
0.6760379076004028,
0.45856449007987976,
0.6372105479240417,
0.18691571056842804,
0.08981160074472427,
0.19902963936328888,
0.10545919835567474,
-0.4731265604496002,
0.4940250515937805,
-0.10866955667734146,
-0.7554784417152405,
-0.7668546438217163,
-0.29339122772216797,
-0.5846356153488159,
0.09191157668828964,
-0.5445060729980469,
0.27695170044898987,
-0.39970171451568604,
0.4324072301387787,
0.45369333028793335,
-0.14572525024414062,
-0.6627842783927917,
0.0652962252497673,
0.08556847274303436,
0.9940406680107117,
-0.8211811780929565,
0.5952728986740112,
0.5854123830795288,
-0.5396910309791565,
-1.1564581394195557,
0.36925840377807617,
-0.06346996873617172,
-0.6158968806266785,
0.28377479314804077,
0.08488285541534424,
-0.12540455162525177,
-0.01779012568295002,
-0.8409649133682251,
-0.6550372838973999,
0.9218315482139587,
0.6766141653060913,
-0.9401727914810181,
0.2903037369251251,
0.1671462208032608,
0.6212019324302673,
-0.24129265546798706,
0.003877230454236269,
0.5188847184181213,
0.6395900249481201,
-0.12960031628608704,
-0.907401442527771,
0.07678641378879547,
0.2431846261024475,
-0.33357664942741394,
-0.028348581865429878,
-0.242063507437706,
0.46671172976493835,
-0.3584196865558624,
-0.11669553071260452,
0.3238782286643982,
0.6975308060646057,
0.390924870967865,
0.36591044068336487,
0.5265287756919861,
0.32555437088012695,
1.1433881521224976,
-0.3015132248401642,
1.0722709894180298,
-0.3879255950450897,
0.4763284921646118,
1.3528811931610107,
0.1635562777519226,
0.8226463794708252,
0.630608856678009,
0.05780038982629776,
0.6258906722068787,
0.7641983032226562,
0.17853592336177826,
0.36692702770233154,
0.22861772775650024,
-0.1266942024230957,
-0.5023089051246643,
-0.048726774752140045,
0.044644784182310104,
0.29452458024024963,
0.05023994669318199,
-0.2189267873764038,
-0.2840723693370819,
-0.024382807314395905,
-0.034639280289411545,
0.26847952604293823,
-0.39450934529304504,
0.6609823703765869,
-0.04564506933093071,
-0.7998462319374084,
1.2587828636169434,
-0.02765033021569252,
0.5011418461799622,
-0.298132985830307,
-0.21294037997722626,
-0.39960911870002747,
0.25393030047416687,
-0.29089444875717163,
-0.9834786057472229,
0.3331970274448395,
0.1219782680273056,
-0.3748854100704193,
-0.39912185072898865,
0.27792924642562866,
-0.8056067228317261,
-0.10236740112304688,
-0.27901336550712585,
0.41784846782684326,
0.3359842896461487,
0.07318726181983948,
-0.43883687257766724,
0.05791987478733063,
0.06775161623954773,
0.06262606382369995,
-0.04317782446742058,
0.8023853302001953,
-0.05307905748486519,
0.7748813629150391,
0.5403006672859192,
0.05153987184166908,
0.2615429759025574,
0.20031234622001648,
0.48095858097076416,
-0.2732069790363312,
-0.44422808289527893,
-1.032143473625183,
0.5136927366256714,
-0.03485487401485443,
-0.08140237629413605,
0.661675214767456,
0.4687359929084778,
0.772965669631958,
-0.11949590593576431,
0.6140455007553101,
0.10331234335899353,
0.5071659088134766,
-0.6980611085891724,
0.3936542868614197,
-0.5573421120643616,
0.40956050157546997,
0.02453584410250187,
-0.9854874610900879,
-0.4085277020931244,
0.870917558670044,
0.06940317898988724,
-0.1499945968389511,
0.7501440048217773,
0.7004492282867432,
-0.42155545949935913,
0.14736442267894745,
0.2418452948331833,
0.6325969696044922,
0.3447391986846924,
0.2785837948322296,
0.6819713711738586,
-0.16149604320526123,
0.6681982278823853,
-0.27239853143692017,
-0.051347021013498306,
-0.11834709346294403,
-1.2396364212036133,
-0.6037387251853943,
-0.28166261315345764,
-0.5760942697525024,
-0.22215740382671356,
-0.008479919284582138,
1.0556716918945312,
0.8296964168548584,
-0.857426643371582,
-0.019124401733279228,
-0.7868067026138306,
0.35626456141471863,
-0.6360505819320679,
-0.2898644506931305,
0.2406083643436432,
-0.38920533657073975,
-0.6260986328125,
0.25695738196372986,
0.006742141675204039,
0.18871742486953735,
-0.1680128276348114,
-0.22920410335063934,
0.23396871984004974,
0.2765447795391083,
0.25311973690986633,
0.43518057465553284,
-1.0625402927398682,
-0.6840627193450928,
-0.07356666773557663,
0.07456600666046143,
0.13537180423736572,
0.6604918837547302,
-0.5743712782859802,
0.4174858331680298,
0.3221873342990875,
0.7693308591842651,
0.12851731479167938,
0.07558542490005493,
0.6645084023475647,
-0.876430094242096,
-0.17535941302776337,
-0.02109350822865963,
0.3978782892227173,
0.45122700929641724,
-0.2779451906681061,
0.18670877814292908,
-0.08549188077449799,
-0.5170580148696899,
-0.54830002784729,
0.3150945007801056,
-1.2875994443893433,
-0.16193142533302307,
1.3970332145690918,
-0.3304632008075714,
0.00516453105956316,
-0.28563717007637024,
-0.2651353180408478,
0.30860599875450134,
-0.31840792298316956,
0.8655135631561279,
0.7584468722343445,
-0.09767066687345505,
-0.3056771755218506,
-0.4808158576488495,
0.5589178800582886,
0.5451444387435913,
-0.91079181432724,
0.6562394499778748,
0.44555720686912537,
0.7801358699798584,
-0.058390334248542786,
0.12993793189525604,
0.2371804267168045,
0.36253952980041504,
-0.373463898897171,
-0.222051203250885,
-0.061240971088409424,
-0.2779163718223572,
-0.49362441897392273,
-0.14944949746131897,
0.2947361171245575,
-0.13921776413917542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13979v1 | Leeroo Orchestrator: Elevating LLMs Performance Through Model Integration | 2024-01-25T06:45:32 | 2024-01-25T06:45:32 | Alireza Mohammadshahi, Ali Shaikh, Majid Yazdani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose an architecture to harness the collective knowledge
of multiple trained LLMs to create a new state-of-the-art. At the core of this
framework is a LLM-based orchestrator that is adept at picking the right
underlying LLM experts for optimal task execution. Inspired by self-play in
reinforcement learning, we created a loop of query generation, orchestration,
and evaluation to generate training data for the orchestrator. Our evaluation
focused on the MMLU benchmark, employing models with 7B, 13B, and 34B
parameters available on Hugging Face. The results demonstrate new
state-of-the-art open-source models: Our Leeroo orchestrator achieves
performance on par with the Mixtral model while incurring only two-thirds of
its cost. Moreover, increasing the allowed cost surpasses Mixtral's accuracy by
over 5% at the same cost level, reaching an accuracy of 75.9%. Further
enhancements were observed when integrating GPT4 into the underlying model
pool. The Leeroo orchestrator nearly matches GPT4's performance at half the
cost and even exceeds GPT4's results with a 25% cost reduction. These findings
illustrate the potential of our architecture in creating state-of-the-art and
cost-effective LLMs by optimizing the synergy between multiple LLMs to achieve
superior performance outcomes. | [
-0.39579734206199646,
-0.28625860810279846,
0.47396475076675415,
0.21662922203540802,
0.01589878275990486,
0.17358052730560303,
0.22260618209838867,
-0.6492432355880737,
0.15413571894168854,
0.5188086032867432,
-0.6096763610839844,
-0.23118650913238525,
-0.38537272810935974,
-0.17474989593029022,
-0.30993980169296265,
0.7651572227478027,
0.12352430075407028,
0.19755850732326508,
-0.24619659781455994,
-0.3769584894180298,
-0.28442227840423584,
-0.17041851580142975,
-0.7138036489486694,
-0.5969824194908142,
0.29386016726493835,
0.3162974417209625,
0.5576170682907104,
0.3296433985233307,
0.24991178512573242,
0.42843708395957947,
-0.2975755035877228,
0.5757468938827515,
-0.5731385350227356,
0.00008020275708986446,
-0.36707714200019836,
-0.5200015306472778,
-0.964626133441925,
0.462057501077652,
0.29941004514694214,
0.1402214914560318,
-0.6270771622657776,
0.17124700546264648,
-0.10147453099489212,
0.8718396425247192,
-0.5193523168563843,
-0.016665181145071983,
-0.6800095438957214,
0.28270119428634644,
0.1597992181777954,
-0.09069536626338959,
-0.28145188093185425,
-0.3323357105255127,
-0.023482292890548706,
-0.8198089003562927,
-0.29732340574264526,
-0.020462995395064354,
0.3152740001678467,
0.5086599588394165,
-0.1794298142194748,
-0.3071976602077484,
-0.7121837735176086,
0.5088635087013245,
-0.507863461971283,
0.3422030806541443,
-0.23414039611816406,
0.7790656685829163,
0.029424937441945076,
-0.546334445476532,
-0.17688055336475372,
-0.16803880035877228,
0.21511326730251312,
0.626864492893219,
-0.14267949759960175,
0.15716660022735596,
0.05705168843269348,
0.5126137137413025,
-0.5299223065376282,
0.3891063630580902,
-0.4608626067638397,
0.006851051934063435,
0.9376387596130371,
0.32508227229118347,
-0.0806245431303978,
-0.0015911502996459603,
-0.6701003909111023,
0.05869603902101517,
-0.4626634418964386,
0.030128739774227142,
0.2942616045475006,
-0.1861002892255783,
-0.11368241161108017,
0.32553499937057495,
-0.10105607658624649,
0.49063608050346375,
0.3546943962574005,
-0.1821599155664444,
0.2881343364715576,
-0.24736906588077545,
-0.3764536380767822,
-0.07150424271821976,
0.8919186592102051,
0.3268525004386902,
0.2685597240924835,
-0.3110952377319336,
-0.5372207164764404,
0.12486107647418976,
0.48846063017845154,
-0.5559703707695007,
-0.16543294489383698,
0.2632704973220825,
-0.22421181201934814,
-0.7786175608634949,
0.14785432815551758,
-0.7059704661369324,
-0.43331342935562134,
-0.4348768889904022,
0.4832000136375427,
-0.3960437774658203,
-0.5345085263252258,
-0.09653420001268387,
-0.01942722126841545,
0.2527928948402405,
0.709225058555603,
-0.6560075879096985,
0.6670916676521301,
0.8388733863830566,
0.9989493489265442,
-0.48656266927719116,
-0.49633532762527466,
-0.9904601573944092,
0.29213809967041016,
-0.4074323773384094,
0.5035906434059143,
-0.0880889743566513,
-0.587139368057251,
-0.1526561677455902,
-0.19603155553340912,
-0.1787412017583847,
-0.8787407279014587,
0.2851814329624176,
-0.8689014315605164,
-0.1094459742307663,
0.31716346740722656,
-0.8006555438041687,
-0.21240626275539398,
0.2307511568069458,
-0.734176516532898,
1.0666481256484985,
0.3063468337059021,
-0.09258236736059189,
0.0365048348903656,
-0.9776235818862915,
-0.18144623935222626,
0.2440648078918457,
-0.34193676710128784,
-0.3078421652317047,
0.31311535835266113,
0.25273165106773376,
0.48156487941741943,
-0.46741366386413574,
0.24033184349536896,
-0.2896692156791687,
-0.48029765486717224,
0.2616450786590576,
0.10771041363477707,
0.5067973136901855,
0.40183186531066895,
-0.12418068200349808,
0.6353344917297363,
-0.8990613222122192,
0.031977102160453796,
-0.12674053013324738,
-0.20825529098510742,
-0.03281934931874275,
-0.24050898849964142,
-0.029301131144165993,
0.4118826985359192,
0.1257026046514511,
-0.06916387379169464,
0.19030821323394775,
-0.09684672206640244,
0.39887216687202454,
1.105168342590332,
-0.26188549399375916,
0.8670315146446228,
-0.49793383479118347,
1.0484007596969604,
-0.026433000341057777,
0.5145137310028076,
-0.0461479127407074,
-0.22392724454402924,
-0.29825282096862793,
-0.3616579473018646,
-0.014117720536887646,
0.4492587447166443,
-0.6128182411193848,
0.19181779026985168,
0.007359303068369627,
-0.6309695839881897,
-0.9358906745910645,
0.3061099946498871,
0.18620319664478302,
0.5916531085968018,
0.3550718426704407,
-0.12014711648225784,
-0.4451019763946533,
-0.7798661589622498,
0.04493735358119011,
0.1096816435456276,
0.12329073995351791,
0.4616067409515381,
0.4754769802093506,
-0.2532135546207428,
0.6458982229232788,
-0.08993782848119736,
-0.3478921353816986,
-0.13547319173812866,
0.04912551864981651,
0.46074405312538147,
0.5031007528305054,
0.5607962608337402,
-0.6721206307411194,
-0.43349847197532654,
0.3914409279823303,
-1.033452033996582,
-0.0017923469422385097,
0.0669943317770958,
-0.3312416076660156,
0.13750387728214264,
0.46504974365234375,
-0.567344069480896,
0.1126471534371376,
1.0130105018615723,
0.13862504065036774,
0.8905451893806458,
-0.1586703509092331,
0.19741611182689667,
-0.9957501292228699,
0.0071917143650352955,
-0.2937808334827423,
-0.26282063126564026,
-0.6230500340461731,
0.2822154462337494,
0.19107282161712646,
-0.14583773910999298,
-0.4780298173427582,
0.5277654528617859,
-0.4997876286506653,
-0.6341545581817627,
-0.4528573751449585,
0.43430057168006897,
-0.11287429183721542,
0.4801841676235199,
-0.28446170687675476,
0.9820907711982727,
0.7388530373573303,
-0.8899060487747192,
0.5931398272514343,
0.06913144141435623,
-0.3743583858013153,
0.8714750409126282,
-0.8200607299804688,
0.16685202717781067,
0.28930068016052246,
0.03782978281378746,
-0.5603318214416504,
-0.18152771890163422,
0.10913269221782684,
-0.21045531332492828,
-0.007834792137145996,
-0.5675027966499329,
-0.30256387591362,
-0.1589956432580948,
-0.30426907539367676,
0.1380099654197693,
0.6767039895057678,
-0.827689528465271,
1.1743359565734863,
0.3262844979763031,
0.5140517950057983,
-0.34281405806541443,
-0.551025927066803,
-0.19350817799568176,
-0.3646237850189209,
-0.9786400198936462,
0.5272338390350342,
-0.24658699333667755,
-0.1431904137134552,
-0.07175285369157791,
-0.3391021490097046,
0.1310553103685379,
0.35684874653816223,
0.3866414725780487,
0.2152498960494995,
-0.14397181570529938,
0.1205626130104065,
-0.12486272305250168,
-0.1357118934392929,
0.07085275650024414,
-0.5840558409690857,
0.3757269084453583,
-0.17812947928905487,
-0.471834272146225,
-0.5119493007659912,
-0.003823035629466176,
0.8763363361358643,
-0.4997674524784088,
0.6732137799263,
0.5336002111434937,
-0.006590857170522213,
-0.5876306295394897,
-0.6203551888465881,
-0.028387414291501045,
-0.5477290153503418,
0.08665333688259125,
-0.4930635392665863,
-0.712823748588562,
0.7929326295852661,
-0.5112814903259277,
0.03533191978931427,
0.06319517642259598,
0.32418179512023926,
-0.3533781170845032,
0.7007835507392883,
0.38005152344703674,
-0.2031397670507431,
0.7419120669364929,
-0.4837074875831604,
-0.5161436200141907,
-1.1838457584381104,
-0.19143405556678772,
0.0628368929028511,
-0.3078915476799011,
-0.593771755695343,
-0.6881579160690308,
0.6537210941314697,
0.18855828046798706,
-0.15135863423347473,
0.04095812514424324,
-0.4100300073623657,
0.3538859188556671,
0.510301411151886,
0.10860631614923477,
0.45341673493385315,
-0.47647836804389954,
-0.019449377432465553,
0.4923894703388214,
-0.8889923095703125,
-0.476673424243927,
1.0912330150604248,
0.24479840695858002,
0.9154163002967834,
0.27728530764579773,
0.9939447641372681,
0.36098140478134155,
0.39993956685066223,
-0.5851600170135498,
0.5485599637031555,
0.21476462483406067,
-0.3174108564853668,
-0.3191808760166168,
-0.4218481481075287,
-0.5311868786811829,
0.8224667310714722,
0.024474570527672768,
-0.5487987995147705,
0.025480465963482857,
0.2691222131252289,
-0.1891784816980362,
0.14042600989341736,
-0.38439619541168213,
0.7838639616966248,
-0.5603582262992859,
-0.5743856430053711,
-0.2978438436985016,
-0.27533069252967834,
0.759917676448822,
-0.057962317019701004,
0.4018550515174866,
-0.24238468706607819,
-0.13797704875469208,
0.48284536600112915,
-0.37535151839256287,
0.41172704100608826,
-0.22440214455127716,
-0.122859425842762,
0.23070338368415833,
0.13804136216640472,
0.9405938982963562,
0.1619904488325119,
-0.393093466758728,
-0.010201120749115944,
-0.46501606702804565,
-0.11251606792211533,
-0.836667537689209,
0.8200863003730774,
-0.7664524912834167,
-0.4789515435695648,
-0.15480925142765045,
-0.5910604596138,
-0.06612566858530045,
-0.1975380778312683,
-0.19186349213123322,
0.134942889213562,
-0.32149067521095276,
-0.066170834004879,
0.7256467938423157,
0.14808276295661926,
0.32274752855300903,
0.7322763204574585,
-0.47968316078186035,
-0.7726780772209167,
0.4754839539527893,
-0.047005340456962585,
0.5192260146141052,
0.13158018887043,
0.1372617483139038,
-0.011621152050793171,
-0.6310930848121643,
-0.4582013189792633,
0.12159007787704468,
-0.557238757610321,
-0.1782500296831131,
-0.44028979539871216,
-0.06807077676057816,
-0.203039288520813,
-0.1950022280216217,
-0.5878985524177551,
-0.14024344086647034,
-0.4645068645477295,
-0.33277156949043274,
0.3297703266143799,
0.8444789052009583,
-0.2649819254875183,
0.627117395401001,
-0.5163629651069641,
0.07621167600154877,
0.3691607415676117,
0.30628442764282227,
0.21415700018405914,
-0.6011688709259033,
-0.46148431301116943,
-0.3243725001811981,
-0.37748122215270996,
-1.033949851989746,
0.3298184871673584,
-0.02308848686516285,
0.9408223032951355,
0.4305504858493805,
-0.22164404392242432,
0.7516202330589294,
-0.6440926790237427,
0.3576728403568268,
0.2743852734565735,
-0.9716874957084656,
0.771878719329834,
-0.3899550139904022,
0.17490379512310028,
0.4567730128765106,
0.3903254568576813,
-0.3378168046474457,
-0.29728150367736816,
-0.7374745607376099,
-0.5610633492469788,
0.9767127633094788,
-0.020195716992020607,
-0.39919549226760864,
0.5139598250389099,
0.3910909593105316,
-0.033446282148361206,
0.29493361711502075,
-0.6671907901763916,
-0.09593772888183594,
-0.14033430814743042,
-0.04038190841674805,
-0.31477487087249756,
0.03162592276930809,
-0.4420866072177887,
-0.08788210898637772,
0.7520155906677246,
-0.3949775993824005,
-0.006490970961749554,
-0.06929166615009308,
-0.42999187111854553,
-0.12226235121488571,
0.022284196689724922,
0.5736203193664551,
0.7536193132400513,
-0.07564474642276764,
-0.10253766179084778,
0.23623932898044586,
0.1775055080652237,
0.11952728033065796,
0.06989561766386032,
-0.09659373015165329,
-0.34446677565574646,
0.3419250547885895,
0.8759246468544006,
0.6728513836860657,
-0.5084162354469299,
0.25881245732307434,
0.27267715334892273,
-0.45581620931625366,
-0.429536372423172,
0.5359609127044678,
0.4670437276363373,
0.857862651348114,
0.3062180280685425,
0.07875751703977585,
0.26177477836608887,
-0.4757981598377228,
0.2393306940793991,
0.5242103934288025,
-0.1524726003408432,
-0.3950614929199219,
0.7918179631233215,
0.4244235157966614,
-0.35544124245643616,
0.40025487542152405,
-0.02687714621424675,
-0.5484872460365295,
0.7319257259368896,
0.178593248128891,
0.8506645560264587,
-0.5401753783226013,
0.28857001662254333,
0.2265869677066803,
0.3438689708709717,
-0.14195922017097473,
0.3469846844673157,
-0.11249195784330368,
-0.6057448983192444,
-0.38679349422454834,
-0.4997078776359558,
-0.6286339163780212,
-0.005729670636355877,
-0.8518781065940857,
0.19561459124088287,
-0.5138309001922607,
0.02927296981215477,
-0.22361458837985992,
-0.061537276953458786,
-0.7185347676277161,
-0.19970600306987762,
0.0895337164402008,
1.018803596496582,
-0.7863781452178955,
0.7573283910751343,
0.7211083173751831,
-0.49726617336273193,
-0.6596447825431824,
-0.40596699714660645,
0.2034764140844345,
-0.8784540295600891,
0.4709058701992035,
0.03834481164813042,
-0.29187846183776855,
0.03490067645907402,
-0.4080817699432373,
-0.9150075316429138,
1.7734662294387817,
0.09764926880598068,
-0.7865697145462036,
0.13416516780853271,
-0.37695613503456116,
0.5333073139190674,
-0.7930431365966797,
0.48632460832595825,
0.41748449206352234,
0.3159492313861847,
0.31228387355804443,
-0.9297562837600708,
-0.16707433760166168,
0.18566958606243134,
0.06664275377988815,
0.0043183062225580215,
-0.8357901573181152,
0.8745663166046143,
-0.18868272006511688,
0.08232753723859787,
0.006124970968812704,
0.8251194953918457,
0.6766635775566101,
0.40354451537132263,
0.47197863459587097,
0.2911742329597473,
1.0122932195663452,
0.19853521883487701,
1.0416603088378906,
-0.39868664741516113,
0.28328490257263184,
1.3345520496368408,
-0.4817434251308441,
0.47787004709243774,
0.45483002066612244,
-0.2580554485321045,
0.3023410141468048,
0.5133287310600281,
-0.01435684971511364,
0.594887912273407,
0.30481472611427307,
-0.27313780784606934,
-0.16701772809028625,
0.13175617158412933,
-0.10755900293588638,
0.4602612853050232,
0.04435798153281212,
-0.33017611503601074,
0.0675787627696991,
-0.027641788125038147,
-0.32422301173210144,
0.1554463505744934,
-0.5944628715515137,
1.0496524572372437,
0.0035552806220948696,
-0.6174419522285461,
0.2239750772714615,
-0.35615110397338867,
0.8974369168281555,
-0.6585456728935242,
0.08748903125524521,
-0.43211886286735535,
0.2772713005542755,
-0.3334023356437683,
-0.44562986493110657,
0.0490044467151165,
-0.22848235070705414,
0.12409523874521255,
-0.14102599024772644,
0.44688430428504944,
-0.373944491147995,
-0.10886586457490921,
0.8021071553230286,
0.7837368845939636,
0.22165881097316742,
0.024792209267616272,
-0.7596362829208374,
0.21642142534255981,
-0.22667841613292694,
-0.2323489487171173,
0.27423176169395447,
0.3758920431137085,
0.166225865483284,
0.8183659911155701,
0.582964301109314,
0.029400473460555077,
0.21686089038848877,
0.2838113307952881,
0.8291196227073669,
-0.465925008058548,
-0.5766063928604126,
-0.6640956401824951,
0.6884170174598694,
-0.3644937574863434,
-0.18331512808799744,
0.609777569770813,
0.45334625244140625,
0.9999925494194031,
-0.10709992051124573,
0.6360104084014893,
0.33307546377182007,
0.17027723789215088,
-0.5950101613998413,
0.5315337181091309,
-0.8084365725517273,
0.32896068692207336,
-0.38597723841667175,
-0.7876980304718018,
0.3178766071796417,
0.5392857789993286,
-0.10480489581823349,
0.20420221984386444,
0.20650042593479156,
0.7238574028015137,
-0.15387365221977234,
0.2128652036190033,
0.7068198323249817,
0.08062490820884705,
0.44658762216567993,
0.503486156463623,
1.0689661502838135,
-0.41804981231689453,
0.3603995740413666,
-0.3217935860157013,
-0.3384004533290863,
-0.4407493770122528,
-0.8150508403778076,
-0.8062403798103333,
-0.2006051242351532,
-0.31908711791038513,
0.14387717843055725,
0.21846547722816467,
0.7829330563545227,
0.8802211284637451,
-0.5143967866897583,
-0.7410089373588562,
-0.17760248482227325,
0.30359482765197754,
-0.6681903600692749,
-0.19603198766708374,
-0.10540366172790527,
-0.39832672476768494,
-0.7572301626205444,
0.9135498404502869,
0.2451789826154709,
-0.057047825306653976,
-0.6031925678253174,
-0.7428356409072876,
-0.2012902796268463,
-0.02321082353591919,
0.6515198945999146,
-0.08182457834482193,
-0.7556414008140564,
0.026836678385734558,
-0.031059930101037025,
-0.07684904336929321,
0.03934823349118233,
0.5675560832023621,
-0.6486656069755554,
0.2289598435163498,
0.07409149408340454,
0.6042999625205994,
0.9011328816413879,
0.03666858375072479,
0.5860034823417664,
-0.5005625486373901,
-0.16258640587329865,
0.23806822299957275,
0.3582526445388794,
0.03552133962512016,
-0.33988112211227417,
1.1613619327545166,
0.02738211676478386,
-0.7399721741676331,
-0.7975619435310364,
0.15621352195739746,
-0.9934296607971191,
-0.042684197425842285,
0.7392969727516174,
-0.0492948479950428,
-0.16999420523643494,
0.4622938334941864,
0.14986184239387512,
0.01663370430469513,
-0.4378274083137512,
0.48421815037727356,
0.5420514345169067,
-0.574384868144989,
-0.585573673248291,
-0.8180066347122192,
0.34588655829429626,
0.269314169883728,
-1.0153483152389526,
-0.16657546162605286,
0.5244988799095154,
0.4004681706428528,
0.1196717619895935,
0.5775108337402344,
-0.09876462072134018,
0.6788164377212524,
-0.07338458299636841,
0.3095428943634033,
-0.5814946889877319,
-0.48414531350135803,
-0.6741736531257629,
0.18151359260082245,
-0.08012495189905167,
-0.26879721879959106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13927v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13927v2 | Adaptive Text Watermark for Large Language Models | 2024-01-25T03:57:12 | 2024-06-09T03:52:21 | Yepeng Liu, Yuheng Bu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to increasing
concerns about the misuse of AI-generated text, and watermarking for
LLM-generated text has emerged as a potential solution. However, it is
challenging to generate high-quality watermarked text while maintaining strong
security, robustness, and the ability to detect watermarks without prior
knowledge of the prompt or model. This paper proposes an adaptive watermarking
strategy to address this problem. To improve the text quality and maintain
robustness, we adaptively add watermarking to token distributions with high
entropy measured using an auxiliary model and keep the low entropy token
distributions untouched. For the sake of security and to further minimize the
watermark's impact on text quality, instead of using a fixed green/red list
generated from a random secret key, which can be vulnerable to decryption and
forgery, we adaptively scale up the output logits in proportion based on the
semantic embedding of previously generated text using a well designed semantic
mapping model. Our experiments involving various LLMs demonstrate that our
approach achieves comparable robustness performance to existing watermark
methods. Additionally, the text generated by our method has perplexity
comparable to that of \emph{un-watermarked} LLMs while maintaining security
even under various attacks. | [
0.022702204063534737,
-0.7695391178131104,
0.4817153513431549,
0.17566195130348206,
-0.7539064288139343,
0.14297133684158325,
-0.2600674033164978,
-0.3953205645084381,
0.2142278105020523,
0.8162111043930054,
-0.2911909520626068,
-0.6984525322914124,
-0.9311876893043518,
0.05616331100463867,
-0.44671717286109924,
0.8728067874908447,
-0.007157523650676012,
-0.2612277567386627,
0.01643928326666355,
-0.3631311058998108,
-0.5240606665611267,
-0.627679705619812,
-0.645282506942749,
-0.1835668832063675,
0.30865538120269775,
0.031498417258262634,
0.716650128364563,
0.8295535445213318,
0.554731547832489,
0.3295731544494629,
-0.25856268405914307,
0.23673677444458008,
-0.3864714801311493,
0.5740556120872498,
-0.3456284701824188,
-0.3470506966114044,
-0.36382731795310974,
-0.3508552014827728,
0.8286901712417603,
0.1459445208311081,
0.10161404311656952,
-0.04414060339331627,
0.0923536866903305,
0.5714680552482605,
-0.7138380408287048,
0.14852696657180786,
-1.2224621772766113,
-0.12097396701574326,
-0.17123930156230927,
-0.3734896779060364,
-0.41685062646865845,
-0.0859074518084526,
-0.10169818997383118,
-0.7048957943916321,
-0.13793425261974335,
0.27621448040008545,
0.8547217845916748,
0.29140031337738037,
-0.049179960042238235,
-0.35470297932624817,
-0.8064144253730774,
0.7832553386688232,
-0.9775509834289551,
0.2161625623703003,
0.3582477867603302,
0.14803944528102875,
-0.33474040031433105,
-0.7331880331039429,
-0.640906572341919,
0.04888754338026047,
0.454956591129303,
0.16385672986507416,
-0.2824879586696625,
-0.3553334176540375,
0.08478174358606339,
0.1020418033003807,
-0.3035255968570709,
0.1715368926525116,
0.1673581302165985,
-0.27532508969306946,
0.5409052968025208,
0.3868923783302307,
0.40165960788726807,
0.3223784267902374,
-0.47922155261039734,
-0.4109129011631012,
-0.594761848449707,
-0.19799600541591644,
0.42012664675712585,
0.5035833120346069,
-0.08873022347688675,
0.4788472354412079,
-0.08328528702259064,
0.5247849225997925,
-0.14826054871082306,
-0.210743248462677,
0.08319468796253204,
-0.18517561256885529,
-0.057740673422813416,
0.2688163220882416,
0.8014724254608154,
0.2755942642688751,
0.39227139949798584,
0.002915675053372979,
-0.4140506684780121,
-0.17660480737686157,
0.13530077040195465,
-0.9130604267120361,
-0.16755855083465576,
0.04402048513293266,
-0.4048619568347931,
-0.33467382192611694,
-0.0033501056022942066,
-0.7884329557418823,
-0.80633944272995,
-0.1425083875656128,
0.606590986251831,
-0.4452744722366333,
-0.30318009853363037,
0.20927520096302032,
-0.16247594356536865,
-0.036630529910326004,
0.3963181674480438,
-0.9316990971565247,
0.18694578111171722,
0.6630202531814575,
0.816681981086731,
-0.30774322152137756,
-0.16509966552257538,
-0.6282231211662292,
0.6605548858642578,
-0.3476797342300415,
0.7632239460945129,
-0.6789426207542419,
-0.08972758799791336,
0.0981324091553688,
-0.1090032085776329,
0.0855637714266777,
-0.48758959770202637,
0.3229281008243561,
-0.8646435141563416,
0.03984394297003746,
-0.007065941579639912,
-0.8954511880874634,
0.06270391494035721,
0.37465107440948486,
-0.6476889252662659,
0.7930094003677368,
-0.07423603534698486,
-1.1004196405410767,
0.28261831402778625,
-0.6288495063781738,
-0.33564305305480957,
0.09636563062667847,
0.1159859225153923,
-0.6585674285888672,
-0.0027831934858113527,
0.34319594502449036,
0.4151378273963928,
-0.1564359962940216,
0.06949847936630249,
-0.3229339122772217,
-0.20391105115413666,
0.49869441986083984,
-0.6502558588981628,
0.5234295129776001,
-0.12350345402956009,
-0.21555081009864807,
0.3653871715068817,
-0.8538309931755066,
0.0777493491768837,
0.2620784640312195,
-0.49515971541404724,
-0.5305511951446533,
0.14950062334537506,
0.10713797062635422,
-0.26771730184555054,
0.5272036194801331,
-0.34891486167907715,
-0.06535010039806366,
-0.44686514139175415,
0.40161433815956116,
1.0811675786972046,
0.20387610793113708,
0.35430216789245605,
-0.23335130512714386,
0.31802454590797424,
0.1953832358121872,
0.004804519936442375,
-0.30357980728149414,
-0.48582661151885986,
-0.663159191608429,
-0.5914962887763977,
0.6652888059616089,
0.5414798259735107,
-0.788122296333313,
0.6719937920570374,
-0.5113592147827148,
-0.47286227345466614,
-0.26511821150779724,
0.3601326644420624,
0.026878617703914642,
0.12604859471321106,
0.4274013340473175,
-0.24191449582576752,
-0.122438944876194,
-0.49042022228240967,
-0.4969727694988251,
-0.4358742833137512,
-0.14534766972064972,
0.17005157470703125,
0.6004756689071655,
-0.2251754254102707,
0.8559122085571289,
-0.5571668744087219,
-0.3793690800666809,
-0.07594774663448334,
0.10675306618213654,
0.022680923342704773,
0.5310099124908447,
0.44772207736968994,
-0.6956852078437805,
-0.334684282541275,
0.10958556830883026,
-0.40433281660079956,
-0.2051757127046585,
-0.15215599536895752,
-0.19957338273525238,
0.20247624814510345,
0.6059783697128296,
-0.44241243600845337,
0.2987273633480072,
0.7166598439216614,
-0.6410881876945496,
0.3051324188709259,
-0.49765437841415405,
-0.18147405982017517,
-1.2930423021316528,
0.05276177078485489,
-0.30828094482421875,
-0.4157479405403137,
-0.413842111825943,
0.21028082072734833,
0.09030859917402267,
-0.12283443659543991,
-0.20183753967285156,
0.7510085701942444,
-0.29881051182746887,
0.20525148510932922,
-0.7251962423324585,
-0.10654530674219131,
0.1753370314836502,
0.15797948837280273,
-0.08001077175140381,
0.5375931262969971,
0.5233445167541504,
-0.4160997271537781,
0.505158007144928,
-0.010550257749855518,
-0.2139495611190796,
0.42630302906036377,
-0.5485879778862,
0.14050638675689697,
-0.16013994812965393,
0.2743527591228485,
-0.8249083161354065,
-0.01208010595291853,
0.35749006271362305,
-0.3541458547115326,
0.44762706756591797,
-0.08164504915475845,
-0.6248183846473694,
0.3064548075199127,
-0.33520445227622986,
0.28251057863235474,
0.5047878623008728,
-0.5012032389640808,
0.8575204014778137,
0.14593328535556793,
-0.4201447069644928,
-0.18820179998874664,
-0.48949331045150757,
0.49030280113220215,
-0.3971061706542969,
-0.5051517486572266,
0.6052398085594177,
-0.13237646222114563,
-0.12673261761665344,
0.07149410247802734,
-0.029208827763795853,
-0.24942906200885773,
0.3918634355068207,
0.12028688192367554,
0.051190171390771866,
-0.38345080614089966,
0.06590602546930313,
0.11116078495979309,
-0.3071100413799286,
-0.08446400612592697,
-0.3758855164051056,
0.4935380518436432,
0.32139354944229126,
-0.3601556122303009,
-0.4615749716758728,
0.3967097997665405,
0.7472618818283081,
-0.2793646454811096,
0.9391412138938904,
0.6669163703918457,
-0.7623950839042664,
-0.3070428967475891,
-0.38386955857276917,
-0.22935818135738373,
-0.5069149732589722,
0.3184140622615814,
-0.02635381557047367,
-0.9641766548156738,
0.6390344500541687,
-0.029863612726330757,
0.1808728277683258,
0.4296824634075165,
0.6186512112617493,
0.042179256677627563,
0.6210726499557495,
0.6150802969932556,
-0.362517774105072,
0.6842727661132812,
0.31156426668167114,
0.23195530474185944,
-0.6982642412185669,
0.030282052233815193,
-0.6191039085388184,
-0.09561887383460999,
-0.5655336976051331,
-0.538480281829834,
0.0250100027769804,
0.2353629618883133,
-0.38319987058639526,
0.1794179528951645,
-0.35893315076828003,
0.3404713571071625,
0.5651172995567322,
0.15190359950065613,
0.3651502728462219,
0.2766074538230896,
-0.009929400868713856,
0.003178794402629137,
-0.4086934030056,
-0.6016440987586975,
0.8755882978439331,
0.3675100803375244,
0.9687138795852661,
0.210693359375,
0.6409332156181335,
0.38864484429359436,
0.3991912305355072,
-0.3347405195236206,
0.3603016436100006,
-0.17263296246528625,
-0.3286961019039154,
-0.5514146685600281,
-0.5478918552398682,
-0.8560727834701538,
0.28080564737319946,
-0.42042696475982666,
-0.6128690242767334,
-0.2441018968820572,
-0.02368866838514805,
-0.1466148942708969,
0.3601427972316742,
-0.4164634048938751,
0.5857706069946289,
-0.18090343475341797,
-0.3849448263645172,
-0.0414382703602314,
-0.20972563326358795,
-0.16763271391391754,
-0.47352364659309387,
0.3614753782749176,
-0.3428460359573364,
-0.4134235680103302,
0.9536336660385132,
-0.36785849928855896,
0.933648407459259,
-0.35056576132774353,
-0.35273218154907227,
0.21854551136493683,
0.12975363433361053,
0.9173696637153625,
0.11422635614871979,
-0.16691653430461884,
-0.03195834904909134,
-0.12211394309997559,
-0.49420496821403503,
-0.613422691822052,
0.6143002510070801,
-0.6241747140884399,
-0.776153028011322,
-0.40276387333869934,
-0.5762928128242493,
-0.09881410002708435,
0.476685494184494,
0.049353986978530884,
0.2031225860118866,
0.08021082729101181,
0.23283036053180695,
0.5874850749969482,
-0.5679782629013062,
0.7014244794845581,
0.42069384455680847,
0.09897799789905548,
-0.6720380187034607,
1.0888402462005615,
-0.01995238848030567,
0.20853203535079956,
0.4356570541858673,
0.4558432400226593,
-0.3046548068523407,
-0.9561662673950195,
-0.5676634907722473,
-0.06153777986764908,
-0.7962465286254883,
-0.5491057634353638,
-0.5467410087585449,
-0.3543721139431,
-0.24177587032318115,
-0.11178841441869736,
-0.32405775785446167,
-0.21256032586097717,
-0.6151556968688965,
0.2591231167316437,
0.8042995929718018,
0.3493451178073883,
0.47361496090888977,
0.2675609588623047,
-0.7994676828384399,
0.3401719331741333,
0.4086839556694031,
0.50046306848526,
0.06995660811662674,
-1.0085161924362183,
-0.029295863583683968,
0.14563393592834473,
-0.3651019334793091,
-0.4617314338684082,
0.333321750164032,
0.3123752176761627,
0.31906837224960327,
0.28171610832214355,
0.3882330060005188,
0.5932649374008179,
-0.6200692057609558,
0.8997946381568909,
0.2878909409046173,
-1.0189762115478516,
0.25573980808258057,
-0.32194313406944275,
0.4714897572994232,
0.2230151891708374,
-0.13617661595344543,
-0.16294021904468536,
-0.7061192393302917,
-0.41024184226989746,
-1.019378423690796,
0.2567160725593567,
0.4057365953922272,
0.8118728399276733,
0.18596585094928741,
0.35855206847190857,
0.0009721203241497278,
-0.09640755504369736,
-0.9502320289611816,
0.06233472004532814,
-0.39522841572761536,
-0.6726660132408142,
0.18416324257850647,
-0.411435604095459,
0.06144268065690994,
0.07601219415664673,
0.8867935538291931,
-0.39297163486480713,
0.1684313714504242,
0.014100353233516216,
0.011948846280574799,
-0.028972677886486053,
0.36688295006752014,
0.6664500832557678,
0.43895307183265686,
0.11166305840015411,
0.30712375044822693,
0.33521661162376404,
-0.47867757081985474,
0.20313145220279694,
-0.03826136142015457,
-0.19960443675518036,
-0.03752119094133377,
0.7675427794456482,
0.7761346697807312,
-0.01273342315107584,
-0.798905611038208,
0.5875586867332458,
-0.044382356107234955,
-0.057088229805231094,
-0.046390634030103683,
0.2527194917201996,
0.35905203223228455,
0.29786011576652527,
0.5251312255859375,
-0.17802508175373077,
-0.4103414714336395,
-0.22157564759254456,
-0.032623931765556335,
0.5057054162025452,
-0.2914441227912903,
-0.20272228121757507,
0.6326887607574463,
0.10008092224597931,
-0.39206141233444214,
0.3702165484428406,
0.30808892846107483,
-0.6524707078933716,
0.4366316497325897,
0.8816882371902466,
0.8145247101783752,
-0.18462656438350677,
-0.22792629897594452,
0.15634001791477203,
0.46833476424217224,
-0.13550768792629242,
0.2821364998817444,
0.1745814085006714,
-1.0058692693710327,
-0.1525048464536667,
-0.8504064083099365,
-0.3613203167915344,
0.19137617945671082,
-0.2723526656627655,
0.10811757296323776,
-0.7137783765792847,
-0.15678304433822632,
-0.1062811017036438,
-0.32976746559143066,
-0.3443402051925659,
0.308529257774353,
0.09886164218187332,
0.8661737442016602,
-0.7502612471580505,
0.7248024940490723,
0.48697009682655334,
0.20911072194576263,
-0.35930660367012024,
0.27539753913879395,
-0.40593671798706055,
-0.8092013597488403,
0.12017147243022919,
0.05003218725323677,
0.05155056715011597,
0.0515756718814373,
-0.4003809690475464,
-0.9919506311416626,
0.9631891846656799,
0.5828850865364075,
-0.4589254856109619,
0.3670042157173157,
0.28897950053215027,
0.6633080244064331,
-0.31446316838264465,
-0.3252270221710205,
0.11597207188606262,
0.460846483707428,
-0.2453681081533432,
-0.3622529208660126,
0.4642867147922516,
-0.2278333306312561,
0.2794932425022125,
0.03213876113295555,
-0.4962402880191803,
0.3789640963077545,
0.2392001450061798,
-0.1827741414308548,
0.29394519329071045,
0.7582094669342041,
0.34127703309059143,
0.08075442910194397,
0.5056479573249817,
0.395952969789505,
0.6906125545501709,
-0.044686201959848404,
0.8105317950248718,
-0.39027783274650574,
0.20293763279914856,
1.089652180671692,
-0.4663279950618744,
1.0389291048049927,
0.6928051114082336,
0.07370371371507645,
0.31717631220817566,
0.3587892949581146,
-0.19316154718399048,
0.5721914172172546,
0.5171263217926025,
-0.3470951020717621,
-0.35915911197662354,
-0.22341753542423248,
-0.34512609243392944,
0.3320637345314026,
0.2824929654598236,
-0.7516849637031555,
0.024334535002708435,
-0.053988564759492874,
-0.20674708485603333,
0.1827600598335266,
-0.21608980000019073,
0.9723201394081116,
0.05152611434459686,
-0.2145737260580063,
0.5088523626327515,
0.47975650429725647,
0.6806962490081787,
-0.4723348319530487,
0.06995886564254761,
-0.06676951050758362,
0.1631985306739807,
0.10557673126459122,
-0.6230486035346985,
0.15538886189460754,
0.14151111245155334,
-0.2248305231332779,
-0.26177287101745605,
0.8917836546897888,
-0.4378868341445923,
-0.7897984981536865,
0.33814185857772827,
0.1327141374349594,
-0.12371527403593063,
-0.11453164368867874,
-0.5857740044593811,
0.49645423889160156,
-0.21238118410110474,
-0.39532411098480225,
0.34092530608177185,
0.717971920967102,
-0.19831916689872742,
0.7084503769874573,
0.7866764068603516,
0.21699655055999756,
0.17163223028182983,
0.10516151785850525,
0.7634459733963013,
-0.5563987493515015,
-0.6995221376419067,
-1.2852015495300293,
0.20107422769069672,
-0.10151776671409607,
-0.24021735787391663,
0.4817862808704376,
0.26276904344558716,
0.5045435428619385,
-0.023183953016996384,
0.753938615322113,
0.41252994537353516,
-0.02583981677889824,
-0.7253965139389038,
1.0129903554916382,
-0.4689834415912628,
0.2977920472621918,
-0.6276143193244934,
-1.0415065288543701,
-0.6609500050544739,
0.4618843197822571,
0.2823937237262726,
-0.11150205135345459,
0.34979820251464844,
0.8413026332855225,
-0.014344992116093636,
-0.043519653379917145,
0.4096674621105194,
0.13934791088104248,
0.5130732655525208,
0.3299950957298279,
0.7863951921463013,
-0.5153337121009827,
0.543306827545166,
0.21199429035186768,
-0.13215839862823486,
-0.09975584596395493,
-1.2330225706100464,
-0.8621124029159546,
-0.5242211222648621,
-0.6117494106292725,
-0.3949536085128784,
0.02132246643304825,
0.6372678875923157,
0.4526943266391754,
-0.8908140063285828,
0.22333939373493195,
-0.038485269993543625,
0.1640067845582962,
-0.12064415216445923,
-0.2206549346446991,
0.6718959808349609,
0.02219439670443535,
-0.5157307386398315,
0.14565247297286987,
0.44698312878608704,
0.532219648361206,
-0.07742579281330109,
-0.10564802587032318,
0.21083945035934448,
0.43248334527015686,
0.4010431468486786,
-0.18008318543434143,
-0.6157324910163879,
-0.6897920966148376,
-0.40920552611351013,
-0.1358555406332016,
-0.14714084565639496,
0.6439389586448669,
-0.21538545191287994,
0.29998114705085754,
0.4236830770969391,
1.0518617630004883,
0.2771097719669342,
-0.1715908795595169,
0.33318009972572327,
-0.6804659962654114,
0.08913326263427734,
0.15556377172470093,
0.3929354250431061,
0.6575248837471008,
-0.3645436763763428,
-0.04170680791139603,
0.26385587453842163,
-0.11592152714729309,
-0.9207910895347595,
0.02370891533792019,
-0.8121404051780701,
-0.37766000628471375,
1.1939753293991089,
-0.4546157717704773,
-0.27784463763237,
-0.11998553574085236,
-0.18813541531562805,
0.21246285736560822,
-0.34500429034233093,
0.9780451059341431,
0.8193278908729553,
0.5730500817298889,
0.018980558961629868,
0.010210997425019741,
0.21257779002189636,
0.42636531591415405,
-0.8562918305397034,
0.47811344265937805,
0.003137495368719101,
0.5624639987945557,
0.06595351547002792,
0.31908270716667175,
-0.19573159515857697,
0.10713963210582733,
-0.043553855270147324,
-0.09764460474252701,
-0.020473740994930267,
-0.08585432171821594,
-0.24617794156074524,
0.2577992379665375,
0.3298019766807556,
-0.07978825271129608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13920v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13920v3 | LocMoE: A Low-Overhead MoE for Large Language Model Training | 2024-01-25T03:36:39 | 2024-05-23T10:03:35 | Jing Li, Zhijie Sun, Xuan He, Li Zeng, Yi Lin, Entong Li, Binfan Zheng, Rongqian Zhao, Xin Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The Mixtures-of-Experts (MoE) model is a widespread distributed and
integrated learning method for large language models (LLM), which is favored
due to its ability to sparsify and expand models efficiently. However, the
performance of MoE is limited by load imbalance and high latency of All-to-All
communication, along with relatively redundant computation owing to large
expert capacity. Load imbalance may result from existing routing policies that
consistently tend to select certain experts. The frequent inter-node
communication in the All-to-All procedure also significantly prolongs the
training time. To alleviate the above performance problems, we propose a novel
routing strategy that combines load balance and locality by converting partial
inter-node communication to that of intra-node. Notably, we elucidate that
there is a minimum threshold for expert capacity, calculated through the
maximal angular deviation between the gating weights of the experts and the
assigned tokens. We port these modifications on the PanGu-Sigma model based on
the MindSpore framework with multi-level routing and conduct experiments on
Ascend clusters. The experiment results demonstrate that the proposed LocMoE
reduces training time per epoch by 12.68% to 22.24% compared to classical
routers, such as hash router and switch router, without impacting the model
accuracy. | [
-0.6256035566329956,
-0.8229996562004089,
0.2832390367984772,
0.09074165672063828,
-0.24102783203125,
-0.12049853801727295,
-0.40926966071128845,
-0.5798011422157288,
0.44686031341552734,
0.637220561504364,
-0.4765866696834564,
-0.40267881751060486,
-0.6353508234024048,
-0.08992274105548859,
-0.15532128512859344,
0.4913480579853058,
0.2629626393318176,
0.026793329045176506,
-0.10940012335777283,
-0.029037313535809517,
-0.15012714266777039,
-0.20662137866020203,
-0.8762341737747192,
-0.3190077543258667,
0.4161534905433655,
0.5392094850540161,
0.4146629273891449,
0.6626041531562805,
0.4486786127090454,
0.34435126185417175,
-0.2648506462574005,
0.2905452847480774,
-0.592652440071106,
-0.17541061341762543,
-0.26081302762031555,
-0.6981324553489685,
-0.6981881260871887,
-0.29715481400489807,
0.7574966549873352,
0.8290379047393799,
-0.5664126873016357,
-0.11382163316011429,
0.01831783913075924,
0.7249975800514221,
-0.7419300675392151,
-0.18440090119838715,
-1.1614432334899902,
0.04497380927205086,
-0.22390136122703552,
-0.037884972989559174,
-0.48112380504608154,
0.11247588694095612,
0.12444383651018143,
-0.566148042678833,
0.10971204936504364,
0.2369990050792694,
0.46666035056114197,
0.4129849076271057,
-0.4390028417110443,
-0.0625748261809349,
-0.4357788860797882,
0.921205997467041,
-0.9904158711433411,
0.14247797429561615,
0.45523297786712646,
0.28905487060546875,
-0.07780294865369797,
0.005736451596021652,
-0.45306605100631714,
0.11179374903440475,
0.23194774985313416,
0.30610015988349915,
0.1670195460319519,
0.21952898800373077,
-0.09921020269393921,
0.42141157388687134,
-0.05133386328816414,
0.6451475620269775,
-0.37915515899658203,
0.036986544728279114,
0.7118739485740662,
0.001434417674317956,
-0.06657835096120834,
0.010839338414371014,
-0.5544761419296265,
0.3019789159297943,
-0.6371751427650452,
-0.16199937462806702,
0.47190630435943604,
0.33495911955833435,
-0.13384944200515747,
0.4833255708217621,
-0.46900445222854614,
0.7227899432182312,
0.2515687048435211,
-0.5000717639923096,
0.16301456093788147,
0.28245213627815247,
-0.04722199961543083,
0.28619903326034546,
0.9129444360733032,
0.2495814561843872,
-0.12949533760547638,
-0.24308690428733826,
-0.1849941611289978,
-0.2548767328262329,
0.2900671660900116,
-0.8037785291671753,
-0.08000877499580383,
0.05659111961722374,
-0.19148026406764984,
-0.45256057381629944,
-0.06237674131989479,
-0.9804695248603821,
-0.34891900420188904,
-0.13955208659172058,
0.3667583763599396,
-0.5191500186920166,
-0.39525002241134644,
0.06482039391994476,
0.38469159603118896,
-0.05842418223619461,
0.494249165058136,
-0.8750417828559875,
0.5350465774536133,
0.5850471258163452,
0.8635761141777039,
-0.3955821096897125,
-0.34511348605155945,
-0.5764994621276855,
0.28676876425743103,
-0.09225493669509888,
0.55515456199646,
-0.6317468881607056,
-0.531301736831665,
-0.25085684657096863,
-0.3607664108276367,
-0.22183509171009064,
-0.6385014653205872,
0.2929942309856415,
-0.5754287838935852,
0.04610355570912361,
-0.062000952661037445,
-0.6032648086547852,
-0.2019737958908081,
0.30071496963500977,
-0.4814797639846802,
0.9909607768058777,
-0.010060613974928856,
-0.6747117042541504,
-0.11616549640893936,
-0.6464016437530518,
-0.64862060546875,
0.006086151581257582,
-0.1860414445400238,
-0.18706350028514862,
0.12853097915649414,
0.32390862703323364,
0.3752587139606476,
-0.474081814289093,
0.10002245008945465,
-0.19861693680286407,
-0.4023297429084778,
-0.09998781234025955,
-0.35243740677833557,
0.7255297303199768,
0.24278917908668518,
-0.39672666788101196,
-0.12742625176906586,
-1.031909704208374,
-0.03033914975821972,
0.11130713671445847,
-0.7146790623664856,
-0.5254483819007874,
0.15449830889701843,
-0.3952890932559967,
0.13497890532016754,
0.2878294587135315,
-0.5581896305084229,
0.37349411845207214,
-0.6021822094917297,
0.4084213078022003,
1.017473816871643,
-0.19537831842899323,
0.696765661239624,
-0.08480621129274368,
0.2911822497844696,
0.4792831242084503,
0.05201566591858864,
0.0032550112809985876,
-0.5575602054595947,
-1.0940940380096436,
-0.5030630230903625,
0.12347723543643951,
0.6064260005950928,
-0.9169403910636902,
0.6607570648193359,
-0.34958788752555847,
-0.6155186891555786,
-1.0433191061019897,
0.5039021372795105,
0.3934820592403412,
0.6670565009117126,
0.4533303380012512,
-0.21491317451000214,
-0.07364269345998764,
-0.8520240187644958,
-0.016179678961634636,
0.2110012024641037,
0.30403706431388855,
0.38316285610198975,
0.23354865610599518,
-0.4100465774536133,
0.9494536519050598,
-0.5909140110015869,
-0.24110974371433258,
-0.20173762738704681,
0.01126230601221323,
0.2553449273109436,
0.6165909171104431,
0.511512041091919,
-0.5135195255279541,
-0.5866286158561707,
0.3326530456542969,
-0.5212672352790833,
-0.16001997888088226,
0.4041520953178406,
-0.42465871572494507,
0.1777399331331253,
0.4217708706855774,
-0.5894966125488281,
0.11191599071025848,
0.8341069221496582,
0.12844324111938477,
0.27813461422920227,
-0.05887024849653244,
0.09966252744197845,
-1.170818567276001,
-0.25722798705101013,
-0.22866928577423096,
-0.15565606951713562,
-0.3348689675331116,
0.3084234297275543,
-0.28420695662498474,
-0.2743781805038452,
-0.4263034462928772,
0.673951268196106,
-0.30677011609077454,
0.13722221553325653,
-0.21435663104057312,
0.45282191038131714,
-0.2030017226934433,
0.8655162453651428,
-0.21854844689369202,
0.5340535044670105,
0.9402211308479309,
-0.9008817076683044,
0.4439617693424225,
-0.061857182532548904,
-0.21500049531459808,
1.0428112745285034,
-0.39727523922920227,
0.20788514614105225,
-0.10600412636995316,
-0.0563599094748497,
-0.7203084230422974,
-0.07409878075122833,
0.14439615607261658,
-0.30274757742881775,
0.16736973822116852,
-0.23813556134700775,
-0.5484207272529602,
-0.2934536337852478,
-0.056947849690914154,
0.5030957460403442,
0.6319229602813721,
-0.4980863034725189,
0.9491061568260193,
0.2897784113883972,
0.06038669869303703,
-0.5220966339111328,
-0.6864499449729919,
-0.20688501000404358,
-0.20534472167491913,
-0.5391481518745422,
0.0798296332359314,
-0.12727653980255127,
-0.13802719116210938,
-0.013047314248979092,
-0.0701160579919815,
-0.06117381528019905,
0.14574530720710754,
0.08614818006753922,
-0.11476711183786392,
-0.2853398323059082,
0.20182281732559204,
0.3273014426231384,
-0.1276538223028183,
-0.1688445806503296,
-0.5250281095504761,
0.7617785334587097,
-0.006242956966161728,
-0.8087166547775269,
-0.6119685173034668,
0.49732348322868347,
0.6050003170967102,
-0.31691038608551025,
1.2000762224197388,
0.5312272906303406,
-0.22386892139911652,
-0.22410884499549866,
-0.7630243301391602,
-0.1637968122959137,
-0.5185388922691345,
0.5224143266677856,
-0.21679748594760895,
-0.7610860466957092,
0.3961986303329468,
-0.3736632466316223,
0.2620292603969574,
0.3637440502643585,
0.2955014407634735,
-0.11147333681583405,
0.6686386466026306,
0.5232923030853271,
-0.5252227187156677,
0.36717912554740906,
-0.17669282853603363,
0.3396880030632019,
-0.8098599314689636,
0.09194343537092209,
-0.33571910858154297,
-0.4457532465457916,
-0.38089311122894287,
-0.6285825967788696,
0.5738174319267273,
0.32659924030303955,
-0.22028027474880219,
-0.019022047519683838,
-0.21355143189430237,
0.36080437898635864,
0.699289858341217,
0.43043068051338196,
0.4881259799003601,
0.3507477045059204,
-0.11043450236320496,
0.3000905215740204,
-1.153086543083191,
-0.1488121896982193,
0.9326708912849426,
0.16893020272254944,
0.8046080470085144,
0.22465471923351288,
0.7435081005096436,
0.18757374584674835,
0.23869793117046356,
-0.7644369602203369,
0.906766414642334,
-0.20663605630397797,
-0.44766342639923096,
-0.4301801919937134,
-0.8467090129852295,
-0.6753827929496765,
0.6162531971931458,
-0.3743588924407959,
-0.685428261756897,
-0.0713588073849678,
0.36136916279792786,
-0.0741252601146698,
0.9583513736724854,
-0.6537373065948486,
0.2567180395126343,
-0.27514585852622986,
-0.2456934005022049,
-0.5120874047279358,
-0.5244176983833313,
0.3345595598220825,
-0.17510473728179932,
0.4467127025127411,
-0.0308904517441988,
-0.04262053966522217,
0.741582453250885,
-0.7349836826324463,
0.952747642993927,
-0.20670746266841888,
-0.2946194112300873,
0.5800450444221497,
-0.04693983122706413,
0.8710018992424011,
-0.27604132890701294,
-0.4734440743923187,
0.39235079288482666,
-0.7628402709960938,
-0.6779019832611084,
-0.3911217749118805,
0.7734879851341248,
-1.0915772914886475,
-0.34786510467529297,
0.24060778319835663,
-0.4108770489692688,
-0.3394632041454315,
0.33299973607063293,
0.4522763192653656,
0.3549676835536957,
0.12059883028268814,
0.16318662464618683,
0.8891920447349548,
-0.1810678243637085,
0.14948831498622894,
0.5991490483283997,
-0.007589390501379967,
-0.5558327436447144,
0.877269983291626,
0.06801090389490128,
0.8026307225227356,
0.5525310635566711,
0.26570969820022583,
0.36769893765449524,
-0.3041236400604248,
-0.3694300055503845,
0.2796604335308075,
-0.6391032934188843,
-0.08149966597557068,
-0.7945318818092346,
-0.11887884885072708,
-0.25199028849601746,
-0.36995697021484375,
-0.9368105530738831,
-0.15980559587478638,
-0.21047569811344147,
0.03807415813207626,
0.35868483781814575,
0.31629326939582825,
0.23192766308784485,
1.2127819061279297,
-0.573121190071106,
0.12885108590126038,
0.4043855369091034,
0.4768635332584381,
0.5203301906585693,
-0.46325743198394775,
-0.5565847158432007,
0.13218101859092712,
-0.2885793149471283,
-0.5059338808059692,
-0.08838167786598206,
0.12162784487009048,
0.5067197680473328,
0.9313856363296509,
0.18206173181533813,
0.8160271644592285,
-0.6886841058731079,
0.3807712197303772,
0.5356001853942871,
-0.909633457660675,
0.5150458216667175,
-0.4333209693431854,
0.1225944459438324,
0.4829463064670563,
0.26613280177116394,
-0.20461471378803253,
-0.3376883864402771,
-0.6018908619880676,
-0.9098871946334839,
0.616361677646637,
0.03886338695883751,
-0.08508752286434174,
-0.018297286704182625,
0.1851315051317215,
0.09105603396892548,
0.4936472475528717,
-0.6612918376922607,
-0.11840437352657318,
0.25583574175834656,
-0.27281227707862854,
0.19095127284526825,
-0.12431273609399796,
-0.17284980416297913,
-0.16276009380817413,
0.7724600434303284,
-0.05612355098128319,
0.2834133207798004,
-0.09532302618026733,
-0.08170222491025925,
-0.3207041025161743,
0.31810063123703003,
0.29833275079727173,
0.6284014582633972,
-0.0617288276553154,
0.07100524008274078,
0.4909229576587677,
-0.36725184321403503,
-0.04403841122984886,
-0.2601199746131897,
-0.19782906770706177,
-0.19148671627044678,
0.35104355216026306,
0.8496626615524292,
0.2843954265117645,
-0.6245536804199219,
0.427400141954422,
0.5936911106109619,
-0.23764736950397491,
-0.015210450626909733,
0.4213843047618866,
0.13998666405677795,
0.27067801356315613,
0.2546406388282776,
0.2849155366420746,
-0.225209042429924,
-0.3646667003631592,
-0.3854021728038788,
0.23815874755382538,
-0.19861991703510284,
-0.11459263414144516,
0.391235888004303,
0.7413372993469238,
-0.22742542624473572,
0.6502124667167664,
-0.14189742505550385,
-0.5251174569129944,
0.4247864782810211,
0.4306780695915222,
0.4923586845397949,
-0.48378849029541016,
-0.22776058316230774,
0.1889798790216446,
0.5110389590263367,
-0.16647976636886597,
-0.08743184059858322,
-0.0040060533210635185,
-0.7220416069030762,
-0.2820371687412262,
-0.6230107545852661,
-0.3307569622993469,
-0.23037931323051453,
-0.7452329397201538,
0.27329668402671814,
-0.4617452621459961,
-0.10611926019191742,
-0.8316264748573303,
-0.3109927773475647,
-0.5482737421989441,
0.2618274688720703,
0.024455316364765167,
0.8261781930923462,
-0.7364373803138733,
0.7379960417747498,
0.6917687058448792,
0.1717631220817566,
-0.358569473028183,
-0.13896574079990387,
-0.2024301141500473,
-1.0653314590454102,
0.3833368718624115,
0.03190026432275772,
-0.5094114542007446,
0.2660411298274994,
-0.7198972702026367,
-0.7656470537185669,
1.0755735635757446,
0.12446634471416473,
-0.9118610620498657,
0.018077567219734192,
-0.005362373776733875,
0.25101810693740845,
-0.2598077952861786,
0.018093043938279152,
-0.04854394122958183,
0.20427963137626648,
0.24970127642154694,
-0.8031270503997803,
-0.33014583587646484,
-0.06767124682664871,
-0.019842633977532387,
0.29820239543914795,
-1.0630302429199219,
0.94221431016922,
-0.15185445547103882,
0.08739471435546875,
-0.04635125771164894,
0.9055434465408325,
0.3830876648426056,
0.19505679607391357,
0.7979029417037964,
0.9851496815681458,
1.0373722314834595,
0.18236319720745087,
0.7932280898094177,
-0.3331843614578247,
0.3899388313293457,
1.1274068355560303,
-0.40144434571266174,
1.0363770723342896,
0.49334535002708435,
-0.1359018087387085,
0.3017134964466095,
0.35810303688049316,
0.37655627727508545,
0.6230182647705078,
0.2549322247505188,
-0.2580253779888153,
-0.36647528409957886,
0.18388482928276062,
-0.4561525881290436,
0.13031263649463654,
0.27297091484069824,
-0.03474925085902214,
-0.10527355223894119,
0.20625166594982147,
0.39816930890083313,
-0.17682740092277527,
-0.7761073708534241,
0.5887582302093506,
0.05793014168739319,
-0.4934752583503723,
0.4336385726928711,
0.09337548911571503,
1.007154941558838,
-0.8033221364021301,
0.35569095611572266,
-0.17598198354244232,
0.330517441034317,
-0.13965503871440887,
-0.3482188284397125,
-0.15952254831790924,
-0.13690973818302155,
-0.21944141387939453,
0.2206777185201645,
0.28058475255966187,
-0.5653234124183655,
-0.6985263824462891,
0.3581484258174896,
0.32609203457832336,
0.2210456132888794,
-0.11360110342502594,
-0.4796975255012512,
-0.16432501375675201,
-0.20122675597667694,
-0.18300697207450867,
0.4506852626800537,
0.8827298879623413,
0.11881125718355179,
0.8921478986740112,
0.46402621269226074,
0.26758483052253723,
0.3693298399448395,
-0.1148807629942894,
0.9653423428535461,
-0.4066980481147766,
-0.7381342649459839,
-0.7223696708679199,
0.4036162495613098,
-0.12402593344449997,
-0.25647804141044617,
0.5776760578155518,
0.3688380718231201,
0.8462203741073608,
-0.04066610708832741,
0.6734246611595154,
-0.03687996417284012,
0.39615464210510254,
-0.8257419466972351,
0.529312252998352,
-0.8634687066078186,
0.3559311628341675,
-0.3156004548072815,
-0.859104573726654,
0.2891125977039337,
0.5737196207046509,
-0.27852073311805725,
0.1612360030412674,
0.5379271507263184,
0.5799460411071777,
-0.30438631772994995,
-0.25697484612464905,
0.32001861929893494,
0.5471240282058716,
0.1967417597770691,
0.5482664108276367,
0.3811919093132019,
-0.2837158441543579,
0.30463290214538574,
-0.20330007374286652,
-0.32368090748786926,
-0.6798376441001892,
-0.6914828419685364,
-1.180668830871582,
-0.12113278359174728,
-0.31050920486450195,
-0.020871400833129883,
-0.020855452865362167,
1.0958843231201172,
0.8865708112716675,
-0.5022137761116028,
-0.35238116979599,
0.0709875077009201,
0.13276012241840363,
-0.30734512209892273,
-0.18561561405658722,
0.24473614990711212,
-0.23509468138217926,
-0.6872515678405762,
0.2707788944244385,
0.32430973649024963,
-0.17829586565494537,
-0.28166431188583374,
-0.17472922801971436,
-0.2790343165397644,
0.10409833490848541,
0.8011292815208435,
-0.14200927317142487,
-0.6811057329177856,
0.25900036096572876,
-0.32927119731903076,
-0.11645007133483887,
0.11509887129068375,
0.4662790298461914,
-0.41978776454925537,
0.41305121779441833,
0.2512679994106293,
0.9352288246154785,
0.1630757749080658,
0.13943900167942047,
0.3199913501739502,
-0.726895272731781,
0.44796642661094666,
-0.009134689345955849,
0.3958319425582886,
0.12782566249370575,
-0.49777376651763916,
0.4106285870075226,
0.4882853925228119,
-0.37992793321609497,
-0.5560153126716614,
0.24840545654296875,
-1.1501684188842773,
-0.2206350713968277,
1.0900969505310059,
-0.010922673158347607,
-0.3249337077140808,
0.2543177306652069,
-0.31052473187446594,
-0.09750396013259888,
-0.5613806247711182,
0.7324290871620178,
0.6903411746025085,
0.07950349152088165,
-0.24336124956607819,
-0.8021068572998047,
-0.2709468901157379,
0.4075702130794525,
-0.9054064750671387,
-0.3249014616012573,
0.1137458086013794,
0.1584373563528061,
0.243373304605484,
0.65279221534729,
0.17343910038471222,
-0.31904032826423645,
-0.1367029845714569,
0.22024895250797272,
-0.07716602087020874,
-0.32986775040626526,
0.23536662757396698,
-0.012077092193067074,
-0.012125018984079361,
-0.19192014634609222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13919v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13919v4 | WebVoyager: Building an End-to-End Web Agent with Large Multimodal Models | 2024-01-25T03:33:18 | 2024-06-06T18:37:34 | Hongliang He, Wenlin Yao, Kaixin Ma, Wenhao Yu, Yong Dai, Hongming Zhang, Zhenzhong Lan, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) has led to a new era
marked by the development of autonomous applications in real-world scenarios,
which drives innovation in creating advanced web agents. Existing web agents
typically only handle one input modality and are evaluated only in simplified
web simulators or static web snapshots, greatly limiting their applicability in
real-world scenarios. To bridge this gap, we introduce WebVoyager, an
innovative Large Multimodal Model (LMM) powered web agent that can complete
user instructions end-to-end by interacting with real-world websites. Moreover,
we establish a new benchmark by compiling real-world tasks from 15 popular
websites and introduce an automatic evaluation protocol leveraging multimodal
understanding abilities of GPT-4V to evaluate open-ended web agents. We show
that WebVoyager achieves a 59.1% task success rate on our benchmark,
significantly surpassing the performance of both GPT-4 (All Tools) and the
WebVoyager (text-only) setups, underscoring the exceptional capability of
WebVoyager. The proposed automatic evaluation metric achieves 85.3% agreement
with human judgment, indicating its effectiveness in providing reliable and
accurate assessments of web agents. | [
-0.5847019553184509,
-0.5958103537559509,
0.43370264768600464,
0.15220768749713898,
-0.09977426379919052,
0.12783093750476837,
-0.2251388132572174,
-0.47400927543640137,
-0.22413520514965057,
0.12475714087486267,
-0.5691761374473572,
-0.45178931951522827,
-0.38663890957832336,
0.11747866868972778,
-0.40011075139045715,
0.50895756483078,
0.12142878770828247,
-0.007333741057664156,
-0.5809343457221985,
0.23456652462482452,
0.007353929337114096,
-0.3988540470600128,
-0.4556862711906433,
-0.30547651648521423,
0.6132342219352722,
0.13482949137687683,
0.8320571780204773,
0.26363569498062134,
0.6330550312995911,
0.5742918252944946,
0.4928337633609772,
0.28128811717033386,
-0.1595185101032257,
0.168749138712883,
-0.36225587129592896,
-0.5522995591163635,
-0.7706003189086914,
0.018627261742949486,
0.16999724507331848,
0.22256390750408173,
-0.3611874580383301,
0.0984681025147438,
-0.3123026490211487,
0.2031657099723816,
-0.8416969180107117,
0.2029542773962021,
-0.5012282133102417,
-0.03201022744178772,
0.12858210504055023,
-0.1571047306060791,
-0.3629053831100464,
-0.23266388475894928,
-0.01583786867558956,
-0.7986122965812683,
0.11409534513950348,
-0.2500310242176056,
0.7704586982727051,
0.4269537329673767,
-0.6100022196769714,
-0.005582793150097132,
-0.6196243166923523,
0.78953617811203,
-0.6476659178733826,
0.7264583110809326,
0.3899393379688263,
0.8779983520507812,
-0.2415202260017395,
-0.8071507811546326,
-0.8402632474899292,
-0.4945089519023895,
0.44209736585617065,
0.3619874119758606,
-0.6163396835327148,
0.13343402743339539,
-0.07872883230447769,
-0.0957285463809967,
-0.7573960423469543,
0.3084133267402649,
0.0009483856847509742,
-0.4963851869106293,
0.40674278140068054,
0.28928372263908386,
0.31336018443107605,
-0.023244787007570267,
-0.20717591047286987,
-0.13862244784832,
-0.09730783104896545,
0.05229942128062248,
0.40412527322769165,
0.2877255082130432,
0.0924171507358551,
0.3906567692756653,
-0.4663100242614746,
0.7065587639808655,
-0.11846750974655151,
-0.38437923789024353,
0.1657797396183014,
-0.2709652781486511,
-0.21638286113739014,
-0.4396105110645294,
0.9030160903930664,
0.6858083605766296,
0.21160000562667847,
-0.299603134393692,
-0.358395516872406,
0.30127808451652527,
0.6261602640151978,
-0.8395549058914185,
0.14183878898620605,
0.3752385377883911,
-0.4606170058250427,
-0.04951176047325134,
0.12538638710975647,
-0.7155104875564575,
-0.5135498642921448,
-0.1463269740343094,
0.6740996837615967,
-0.28532636165618896,
-0.4015488624572754,
0.1510525941848755,
-0.35020527243614197,
0.5500476360321045,
0.723224937915802,
-0.3340395390987396,
0.34967565536499023,
0.5867980718612671,
0.8249899744987488,
-0.15085871517658234,
-0.3954150378704071,
-0.6174872517585754,
0.1466498076915741,
-0.21742947399616241,
0.672755241394043,
-0.5258817672729492,
-0.21327587962150574,
0.2946487069129944,
0.015977643430233,
0.36970436573028564,
-0.238808736205101,
0.3496902883052826,
-0.6263078451156616,
-0.07141771912574768,
0.09951197355985641,
-0.2600385248661041,
-0.32414790987968445,
0.750424325466156,
-0.6376566886901855,
0.48967117071151733,
-0.06476370990276337,
-0.16014568507671356,
0.3524117171764374,
-0.3686312437057495,
-0.26778680086135864,
0.10895725339651108,
0.10635636746883392,
-0.25608906149864197,
0.012461498379707336,
0.1437484472990036,
0.5530032515525818,
-0.659825325012207,
-0.15446701645851135,
-0.3962785303592682,
-0.34982454776763916,
0.3853367865085602,
-0.7747257947921753,
0.4223288893699646,
0.016202155500650406,
-0.2726866602897644,
0.3438725471496582,
-0.9640050530433655,
0.06961556524038315,
0.22326324880123138,
-0.482650488615036,
-0.209192156791687,
-0.18144765496253967,
0.2419273853302002,
0.21062211692333221,
0.543170154094696,
-0.6809732913970947,
0.4655861556529999,
0.16410349309444427,
0.1809127926826477,
0.8004335165023804,
-0.33183524012565613,
0.14009514451026917,
-0.2569199800491333,
0.958497166633606,
-0.38271597027778625,
0.6088623404502869,
-0.12804628908634186,
-0.35998135805130005,
-0.9304342269897461,
-0.37781357765197754,
0.10335636883974075,
0.4739033877849579,
-0.7826096415519714,
0.34807124733924866,
-0.47059565782546997,
-1.0145792961120605,
-0.4367051422595978,
0.11390940845012665,
0.52588951587677,
-0.14803311228752136,
0.24643194675445557,
-0.49016714096069336,
-0.21458494663238525,
-1.0087618827819824,
-0.1033816710114479,
-0.27418866753578186,
-0.0630958080291748,
-0.058424778282642365,
0.40983420610427856,
-0.692318856716156,
1.0177638530731201,
-0.2240142822265625,
-0.30335214734077454,
-0.28531768918037415,
0.33993759751319885,
-0.1722775250673294,
0.07972259074449539,
0.27922961115837097,
-0.7818624973297119,
-0.31896793842315674,
0.21093039214611053,
-0.8201984167098999,
-0.13087895512580872,
-0.06493935734033585,
0.08488892018795013,
-0.11350557953119278,
0.13752982020378113,
-0.9917669892311096,
0.23416900634765625,
0.49249762296676636,
0.11326932162046432,
0.7532676458358765,
-0.29902681708335876,
0.3038587272167206,
-0.807638943195343,
-0.23174253106117249,
0.3327159285545349,
-0.6140942573547363,
-0.4687246084213257,
0.29799365997314453,
0.20275132358074188,
0.048985522240400314,
-0.5091922879219055,
0.5375914573669434,
-0.5986788868904114,
-0.3187843859195709,
-0.43438419699668884,
0.25675439834594727,
0.011082013137638569,
0.5131132006645203,
-0.41636452078819275,
0.7293232679367065,
0.3940003514289856,
-0.6176237463951111,
1.0319719314575195,
0.011626020073890686,
-0.04590850695967674,
0.46377095580101013,
-0.48186126351356506,
0.15901975333690643,
0.01538675557821989,
0.4503327012062073,
-1.0178050994873047,
-0.3481026291847229,
-0.04043839871883392,
-0.5486523509025574,
-0.00783779937773943,
-0.15579861402511597,
-0.6877887845039368,
-0.5672404766082764,
-0.46014535427093506,
-0.0374169796705246,
0.4306016266345978,
-0.380951464176178,
0.8539214134216309,
0.2997957170009613,
-0.06838422268629074,
-0.46028485894203186,
-0.3698083460330963,
0.3509649634361267,
0.14956925809383392,
-0.5811948776245117,
0.1687961369752884,
-0.1753973364830017,
-0.3717840909957886,
-0.1605144739151001,
-0.09354246407747269,
-0.45004576444625854,
-0.012303798459470272,
0.19968046247959137,
0.05943185091018677,
0.102474145591259,
-0.0010278667323291302,
-0.057044971734285355,
-0.16856694221496582,
0.038657285273075104,
-0.11060329526662827,
0.4891241788864136,
-0.24912409484386444,
-0.8056276440620422,
-0.7954072952270508,
0.05681651458144188,
0.9573692083358765,
-0.45572081208229065,
0.23114171624183655,
0.8636754751205444,
-0.3491370975971222,
-0.12346390634775162,
-0.6201938390731812,
0.1307668387889862,
-0.5415670275688171,
0.49263301491737366,
-0.6739969253540039,
-0.642642080783844,
0.26600438356399536,
-0.22273023426532745,
0.280804306268692,
0.14408446848392487,
0.6348995566368103,
0.06559906899929047,
1.2444308996200562,
0.7161602973937988,
0.02789890766143799,
0.4296000003814697,
-0.06659850478172302,
-0.14199933409690857,
-0.2880890369415283,
-0.21690921485424042,
-0.29900097846984863,
-0.0882146954536438,
-0.4179677963256836,
-0.5814638733863831,
0.4691977798938751,
-0.0464891642332077,
-0.03511131927371025,
0.32601332664489746,
-0.29942962527275085,
0.12386573851108551,
0.43501195311546326,
0.0262538343667984,
0.34383195638656616,
-0.22738398611545563,
0.023959200829267502,
0.33239614963531494,
-0.33202970027923584,
-0.5165525674819946,
1.048479437828064,
0.24608838558197021,
0.9923403859138489,
0.664315402507782,
0.30257391929626465,
0.655511200428009,
0.30453717708587646,
-0.9869999289512634,
0.8383156657218933,
0.2115347981452942,
-0.39119693636894226,
-0.33214128017425537,
-0.10275407880544662,
-0.9314587116241455,
0.7417359948158264,
0.10350240021944046,
-0.5367298722267151,
-0.15430447459220886,
0.09053347259759903,
-0.22891975939273834,
-0.04933755472302437,
-0.6053640842437744,
0.8116966485977173,
-0.46470847725868225,
-0.6763761043548584,
-0.48542898893356323,
-0.481218546628952,
0.3574794828891754,
0.06787688285112381,
0.3062190115451813,
-0.11402478814125061,
-0.48909392952919006,
0.28012606501579285,
-0.6269299387931824,
0.9492515325546265,
-0.32694655656814575,
-0.3172226548194885,
0.19882182776927948,
0.0687989592552185,
0.49909669160842896,
-0.19758561253547668,
0.1468246430158615,
0.011535310186445713,
-0.19431380927562714,
-0.32772278785705566,
-0.7909425497055054,
0.5652608275413513,
-0.8906995058059692,
-0.6354759335517883,
-0.6299428939819336,
-0.2605655789375305,
-0.43307530879974365,
0.0930911973118782,
-0.21327915787696838,
0.43747851252555847,
-0.38406914472579956,
0.08248236030340195,
0.2912399172782898,
-0.3353561758995056,
0.6907233595848083,
0.9585518836975098,
-0.4342730939388275,
-0.2544836401939392,
0.9356643557548523,
-0.2792798578739166,
0.2507447302341461,
0.632352352142334,
0.08818471431732178,
-0.3630000650882721,
-0.3619656562805176,
-0.9201793074607849,
-0.06023266538977623,
-0.7924032807350159,
-0.2687515318393707,
-0.7204340100288391,
-0.05153927952051163,
-0.3362070322036743,
-0.09410465508699417,
-0.5238459706306458,
-0.2208145707845688,
0.05198311060667038,
0.029501840472221375,
0.25839754939079285,
0.6784932017326355,
-0.03840815648436546,
0.4378008544445038,
-1.0609207153320312,
0.3326840400695801,
0.834528386592865,
0.07064594328403473,
0.09946650266647339,
-0.17195743322372437,
-0.33739760518074036,
-0.22847792506217957,
-0.4659534990787506,
-0.9338789582252502,
0.24966010451316833,
0.09627839177846909,
0.830079197883606,
0.6786524057388306,
-0.3662469983100891,
0.7304848432540894,
-0.38367384672164917,
0.893291175365448,
0.4903908371925354,
-0.9476311802864075,
0.22105351090431213,
-0.6474876403808594,
0.6851644515991211,
0.29453274607658386,
0.448697954416275,
-0.4730208218097687,
-0.217856302857399,
0.13001368939876556,
-0.6419174671173096,
0.2886899709701538,
0.06062130257487297,
0.017929384484887123,
0.08683805167675018,
0.059659216552972794,
0.3753165304660797,
0.3734109699726105,
-0.7265982031822205,
0.20374417304992676,
-0.4241727590560913,
-0.0827309712767601,
-0.02121254988014698,
0.13205406069755554,
0.23594000935554504,
-0.0884673148393631,
0.6015499234199524,
-0.4652177095413208,
0.31477054953575134,
-0.07178041338920593,
-0.6602014303207397,
-0.10456996411085129,
0.5060062408447266,
0.44964489340782166,
1.0388637781143188,
-0.12781651318073273,
0.24082542955875397,
0.04431983083486557,
-0.38765668869018555,
0.365084171295166,
0.4019099175930023,
0.2390350103378296,
-0.17825627326965332,
0.5294622778892517,
0.40151771903038025,
0.082150399684906,
-1.130155324935913,
0.8660707473754883,
-0.4219209551811218,
0.13770292699337006,
-0.5525659918785095,
0.09078680723905563,
0.07437793165445328,
0.43760067224502563,
0.5965852737426758,
-0.23420453071594238,
0.37429195642471313,
-0.5365772247314453,
0.17233656346797943,
0.5667523741722107,
-0.5539450645446777,
-0.5384964346885681,
0.6082817316055298,
0.5480748414993286,
-0.32681804895401,
0.3265821635723114,
-0.518492579460144,
-0.5918469429016113,
0.5693632364273071,
0.4425259530544281,
1.0377203226089478,
-0.5058972239494324,
0.19653354585170746,
-0.02735811658203602,
0.4856521487236023,
0.14686869084835052,
0.32875293493270874,
-0.12903271615505219,
-0.5555734634399414,
-0.47153037786483765,
-0.9666299223899841,
-0.5901508927345276,
-0.019140399992465973,
-0.43682968616485596,
0.03815526142716408,
-0.41206973791122437,
-0.3268074095249176,
0.025308363139629364,
-0.2718994915485382,
-0.764297604560852,
0.3363212049007416,
0.004823167342692614,
0.7513757348060608,
-0.4614168405532837,
0.7250403761863708,
0.8198091387748718,
-0.7437991499900818,
-0.1087774783372879,
0.07800226658582687,
0.430764764547348,
-0.6325726509094238,
0.44354116916656494,
0.4280740022659302,
-0.4721309542655945,
-0.03525161370635033,
-0.21779878437519073,
-0.5925095081329346,
1.144006609916687,
0.17952068150043488,
-0.8351143598556519,
-0.023881494998931885,
0.16966493427753448,
0.49014756083488464,
-0.0333394780755043,
0.7682462334632874,
0.1188068762421608,
0.6663236618041992,
-0.20731237530708313,
-1.3173516988754272,
0.0009327854495495558,
-0.3847412168979645,
0.004697872791439295,
0.15921325981616974,
-1.0188045501708984,
0.7940069437026978,
0.01092442311346531,
0.14622728526592255,
0.17706289887428284,
0.5896227955818176,
-0.08597873896360397,
0.06191787123680115,
0.8202614784240723,
0.4541187286376953,
0.3573441207408905,
0.23869149386882782,
1.0127474069595337,
-0.0713774710893631,
0.030110754072666168,
0.7661061882972717,
-0.3665951192378998,
0.7200931310653687,
0.1019168272614479,
-0.3334404230117798,
0.39460158348083496,
0.5606560111045837,
0.0377337783575058,
0.3470812737941742,
0.24917027354240417,
-0.5010286569595337,
-0.589433491230011,
-0.2334805130958557,
0.026971619576215744,
0.9726589918136597,
0.11857759952545166,
0.09176657348871231,
-0.33965978026390076,
0.27798476815223694,
-0.060287877917289734,
-0.0022069832775741816,
-0.427190363407135,
0.6877249479293823,
-0.12325949221849442,
-0.5717637538909912,
0.30087900161743164,
0.34392982721328735,
0.8093883991241455,
-1.0182429552078247,
-0.13382689654827118,
0.12752765417099,
0.3758188784122467,
-0.01607377827167511,
-0.3215908706188202,
-0.239956796169281,
0.17190569639205933,
0.006861429661512375,
-0.22110570967197418,
0.9005250930786133,
-0.0066635883413255215,
-0.3487655818462372,
0.49367430806159973,
0.7675842046737671,
0.22198687493801117,
-0.2750537693500519,
-0.5859091877937317,
0.23969949781894684,
-0.19317872822284698,
-0.3883500099182129,
0.4593949317932129,
0.2687734067440033,
-0.1816304475069046,
1.0751934051513672,
0.808038055896759,
-0.2952715754508972,
0.17075896263122559,
0.3033747673034668,
0.8141521215438843,
-0.6280151009559631,
-0.3923281729221344,
-0.7848207354545593,
0.47937577962875366,
-0.13521401584148407,
-0.23279955983161926,
0.8979018330574036,
0.7450081706047058,
0.4883153736591339,
0.0832684114575386,
1.3185558319091797,
0.016260812059044838,
0.15700997412204742,
-0.07329248636960983,
0.6211493611335754,
-0.8216336965560913,
-0.27440211176872253,
-0.22487610578536987,
-0.8810296654701233,
0.04183673858642578,
0.493698388338089,
0.1840212494134903,
0.16730313003063202,
0.33500513434410095,
0.638729453086853,
-0.18913356959819794,
-0.1749311238527298,
0.8241921663284302,
0.1675373613834381,
0.6499229073524475,
0.3187757134437561,
0.991165041923523,
-0.14973251521587372,
0.9455434679985046,
0.05461464822292328,
-0.5899391174316406,
-0.27359703183174133,
-0.6637216806411743,
-1.0019004344940186,
-0.48834243416786194,
0.022349756211042404,
0.011732557788491249,
0.24495910108089447,
0.9431384205818176,
0.7522719502449036,
-0.18913677334785461,
-0.31364738941192627,
0.09593689441680908,
-0.24475577473640442,
-0.3838109076023102,
-0.1766376793384552,
-0.3924218714237213,
-0.14090216159820557,
-0.9078428745269775,
0.546208381652832,
0.48606643080711365,
-0.14652325212955475,
-0.9731960892677307,
-0.08317837119102478,
-0.13444335758686066,
0.2603740990161896,
0.7712069153785706,
0.024775095283985138,
-1.0471261739730835,
-0.21682164072990417,
-0.10445725917816162,
-0.2247190773487091,
-0.16419337689876556,
0.5021803379058838,
-0.7079387903213501,
0.7275636792182922,
0.28512707352638245,
0.7050515413284302,
0.5794222950935364,
-0.02895093895494938,
0.6085353493690491,
-0.4436681270599365,
0.11041618883609772,
0.1362219601869583,
0.37109264731407166,
0.39409735798835754,
0.020920705050230026,
0.30552610754966736,
0.08581400662660599,
-0.38869166374206543,
-0.4777340888977051,
0.3282287120819092,
-1.0878188610076904,
-0.4383961856365204,
1.0909910202026367,
-0.21634170413017273,
-0.16620928049087524,
-0.11859181523323059,
-0.036744944751262665,
0.41606923937797546,
-0.5617305040359497,
0.5493801832199097,
0.5396324992179871,
-0.1421169936656952,
-0.30199670791625977,
-0.7451403737068176,
0.004630766808986664,
-0.09276363253593445,
-1.2176710367202759,
-0.12106414884328842,
0.8122968673706055,
0.16327041387557983,
0.309235155582428,
0.5653781294822693,
0.4200320243835449,
0.45012179017066956,
0.2116304188966751,
0.6345357298851013,
-0.31432145833969116,
-0.3531750738620758,
-0.006147014442831278,
0.352897047996521,
-0.003931504674255848,
-0.2534722685813904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01706v1 | MULTIVERSE: Exposing Large Language Model Alignment Problems in Diverse Worlds | 2024-01-25T02:57:40 | 2024-01-25T02:57:40 | Xiaolong Jin, Zhuo Zhang, Xiangyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Model (LLM) alignment aims to ensure that LLM outputs match
with human values. Researchers have demonstrated the severity of alignment
problems with a large spectrum of jailbreak techniques that can induce LLMs to
produce malicious content during conversations. Finding the corresponding
jailbreaking prompts usually requires substantial human intelligence or
computation resources. In this paper, we report that LLMs have different levels
of alignment in various contexts. As such, by systematically constructing many
contexts, called worlds, leveraging a Domain Specific Language describing
possible worlds (e.g., time, location, characters, actions and languages) and
the corresponding compiler, we can cost-effectively expose latent alignment
issues. Given the low cost of our method, we are able to conduct a large scale
study regarding LLM alignment issues in different worlds. Our results show that
our method outperforms the-state-of-the-art jailbreaking techniques on both
effectiveness and efficiency. In addition, our results indicate that existing
LLMs are extremely vulnerable to nesting worlds and programming language
worlds. They imply that existing alignment training focuses on the real-world
and is lacking in various (virtual) worlds where LLMs can be exploited. | [
-0.22275227308273315,
-0.8356019854545593,
0.4550739526748657,
0.11894916743040085,
0.11576798558235168,
0.5466699600219727,
-0.1846645027399063,
-0.597144365310669,
0.01855495385825634,
0.5456610918045044,
-0.6781530976295471,
-0.39994752407073975,
-0.5361774563789368,
-0.16578558087348938,
-0.12014107406139374,
0.8782138824462891,
0.07853873819112778,
-0.14327850937843323,
-0.2435329109430313,
-0.2616175711154938,
-0.4953592121601105,
-0.6776929497718811,
0.008517087437212467,
-0.02438381128013134,
0.41705718636512756,
0.5856277346611023,
0.7028518319129944,
0.6061786413192749,
0.7994493842124939,
0.324447900056839,
-0.14558032155036926,
0.3355831801891327,
-0.649487316608429,
0.11050501465797424,
-0.19560839235782623,
-0.3430824279785156,
-0.5245663523674011,
-0.027715737000107765,
0.45770004391670227,
0.5547252893447876,
-0.07683374732732773,
0.2252453863620758,
0.007919732481241226,
0.6276828050613403,
-0.7430942058563232,
-0.31994688510894775,
-0.7030473351478577,
0.11874933540821075,
-0.42845577001571655,
0.07495872676372528,
-0.2669023275375366,
-0.18758510053157806,
-0.06153631955385208,
-0.5439298748970032,
-0.07671456038951874,
0.2289053350687027,
0.6181508898735046,
0.3521050810813904,
-0.6667869091033936,
-0.1981220692396164,
-0.839000940322876,
0.8749698996543884,
-0.7193340063095093,
0.4378794729709625,
-0.04397488757967949,
0.41783204674720764,
-0.45705461502075195,
-0.24293546378612518,
-0.8634636402130127,
0.05147593095898628,
0.18264254927635193,
-0.054890137165784836,
0.03832771256566048,
-0.13478858768939972,
0.3306497037410736,
0.2960912883281708,
-0.6448870301246643,
0.45587289333343506,
-0.16698694229125977,
-0.3764682710170746,
0.4811665713787079,
0.3856891393661499,
0.542108952999115,
-0.08717168867588043,
-0.3176538050174713,
-0.12036760151386261,
-1.030940055847168,
0.013504019007086754,
0.7698163390159607,
0.4163741171360016,
-0.3082846701145172,
0.7201741337776184,
0.31348323822021484,
1.0674525499343872,
-0.17097526788711548,
-0.6775159239768982,
0.08587931841611862,
-0.4925341010093689,
0.06585204601287842,
-0.04862457513809204,
0.6628780364990234,
0.5890157222747803,
0.038866471499204636,
-0.18092839419841766,
0.05808992311358452,
-0.07993371784687042,
0.3367205858230591,
-0.6257599592208862,
0.17186668515205383,
0.3579200506210327,
-0.22652019560337067,
-0.284470796585083,
-0.06786395609378815,
-0.7535601854324341,
-0.798866868019104,
-0.22914966940879822,
0.1001838892698288,
-0.38106247782707214,
-0.19686266779899597,
-0.11485770344734192,
0.07955358922481537,
0.480613112449646,
0.19015930593013763,
-0.9326556324958801,
0.13934466242790222,
0.9593952894210815,
0.8828937411308289,
-0.059971582144498825,
-0.443291574716568,
-0.5450840592384338,
0.2961188852787018,
-0.057836029678583145,
0.687362015247345,
-0.5121625065803528,
-0.1378205120563507,
-0.17020362615585327,
-0.23521842062473297,
0.11477364599704742,
-0.4514394998550415,
0.3567816913127899,
-0.5648322105407715,
-0.06593460589647293,
-0.16146831214427948,
-0.6069850921630859,
0.23542268574237823,
0.4313693940639496,
-0.6693881154060364,
0.5884917378425598,
-0.06384216994047165,
-0.9138333797454834,
0.1678643822669983,
-0.44920602440834045,
-0.3787168562412262,
-0.24800057709217072,
-0.21045367419719696,
-0.5736706256866455,
0.04557793214917183,
0.36940282583236694,
0.3947993814945221,
-0.16172225773334503,
0.52461838722229,
-0.35892900824546814,
-0.399553507566452,
0.41160640120506287,
-0.39204859733581543,
1.029510736465454,
0.40256911516189575,
-0.377232164144516,
0.11378961056470871,
-0.6367977857589722,
-0.13298150897026062,
0.24275361001491547,
-0.16013163328170776,
-0.5106808543205261,
0.10621389746665955,
-0.030607961118221283,
0.4505288302898407,
0.29017913341522217,
-0.6881459951400757,
0.5576164722442627,
-0.45923563838005066,
0.48031941056251526,
0.7526135444641113,
-0.302584707736969,
0.5099334120750427,
-0.23951326310634613,
0.5240495800971985,
0.05201321840286255,
0.11693885922431946,
-0.0911533460021019,
-0.35884201526641846,
-0.3276064693927765,
-0.2340211421251297,
0.1350802779197693,
0.7523695826530457,
-0.10045391321182251,
0.5198466777801514,
-0.4517591595649719,
-0.50960773229599,
-0.5945212244987488,
0.29037556052207947,
0.5137859582901001,
0.3994481563568115,
0.09654515981674194,
0.0010578801156952977,
-0.6974686980247498,
-0.9476057887077332,
-0.46840211749076843,
0.02687975764274597,
0.33141472935676575,
0.4138617217540741,
0.4342114329338074,
-0.28608229756355286,
1.092708706855774,
-0.46389031410217285,
-0.16300372779369354,
-0.08787694573402405,
-0.3949624001979828,
0.09241130203008652,
0.4626616835594177,
0.42661765217781067,
-0.8454501628875732,
-0.4585229158401489,
0.03996843844652176,
-0.8387772440910339,
0.023323703557252884,
-0.1359892040491104,
-0.13255657255649567,
0.032113127410411835,
0.710433304309845,
-0.2510179877281189,
0.13658949732780457,
1.0220074653625488,
-0.3433491587638855,
0.6020368337631226,
-0.10410457104444504,
0.022680699825286865,
-1.3120530843734741,
0.06814377009868622,
-0.06949038803577423,
-0.22915460169315338,
-0.4974742531776428,
0.45546236634254456,
0.2983390986919403,
-0.29200801253318787,
-0.4794420599937439,
0.5448662042617798,
-0.6962378621101379,
-0.1752932071685791,
-0.16211678087711334,
0.3958180248737335,
-0.1733570545911789,
0.27871084213256836,
-0.23930808901786804,
0.8779282569885254,
0.2782353162765503,
-0.16066336631774902,
0.48949894309043884,
0.2449735552072525,
-0.456011563539505,
0.5290613770484924,
-0.2505720853805542,
0.34786728024482727,
-0.008436361327767372,
0.3258419334888458,
-0.9180445671081543,
-0.14676453173160553,
-0.023043185472488403,
-0.19358982145786285,
0.27811259031295776,
-0.231958270072937,
-0.5511419773101807,
-0.24692176282405853,
-0.18788057565689087,
0.4306574761867523,
0.3184308707714081,
-0.696162760257721,
0.3352227210998535,
0.7004989981651306,
-0.06847577542066574,
-1.1085032224655151,
-0.5026364922523499,
0.46811380982398987,
-0.5712055563926697,
-0.8390318751335144,
0.4107758700847626,
-0.1882684975862503,
-0.5515769720077515,
-0.1425188183784485,
-0.19915685057640076,
0.1897510290145874,
0.4312724173069,
0.45424044132232666,
0.23288032412528992,
-0.18349814414978027,
-0.3665291666984558,
0.044493332505226135,
0.027435850352048874,
-0.13072293996810913,
-0.46983039379119873,
0.47645634412765503,
-0.21176297962665558,
-0.5408452153205872,
-0.14869971573352814,
0.5265912413597107,
0.6833598017692566,
-0.32961902022361755,
0.9762178063392639,
0.19554123282432556,
-0.470956414937973,
-0.14946697652339935,
-0.6225132346153259,
0.2829958200454712,
-0.4757554829120636,
0.4755042493343353,
-0.3190407156944275,
-1.3246291875839233,
0.7349553108215332,
-0.3637811243534088,
0.233586847782135,
0.09447696059942245,
0.6036273837089539,
0.05608876049518585,
0.9262000918388367,
1.0164971351623535,
-0.27706554532051086,
0.36540672183036804,
0.04700665920972824,
0.5818775296211243,
-1.0736113786697388,
-0.2687426507472992,
-0.4340592920780182,
-0.5067690014839172,
-0.47348007559776306,
-0.46985486149787903,
0.2843908369541168,
0.3658355176448822,
-0.21994906663894653,
0.4783344864845276,
-0.34151744842529297,
0.9653025269508362,
0.19671842455863953,
-0.2438570261001587,
0.3830661177635193,
0.020374929532408714,
-0.3853902518749237,
-0.2687000334262848,
-0.5416226983070374,
-0.6638412475585938,
1.2662180662155151,
0.21436148881912231,
0.7543547749519348,
0.6552119851112366,
0.760713517665863,
-0.05454835295677185,
0.35479170083999634,
-0.7080068588256836,
0.2916046380996704,
-0.11663606762886047,
-0.7557245492935181,
-0.3890342712402344,
-0.274173766374588,
-0.9579592347145081,
0.3768072724342346,
-0.24280835688114166,
-1.0821295976638794,
-0.06793700903654099,
0.10327836126089096,
-0.5186790823936462,
0.44073939323425293,
-0.6387349367141724,
1.057374119758606,
-0.5949758887290955,
-0.37202954292297363,
-0.048459216952323914,
-1.0007191896438599,
0.6336538195610046,
-0.33006954193115234,
0.6398442983627319,
-0.12187178432941437,
0.087230384349823,
0.42857009172439575,
-0.5301610827445984,
1.1424405574798584,
-0.042324986308813095,
-0.6077277064323425,
0.08171486109495163,
0.009390589781105518,
0.534647524356842,
0.09368981420993805,
0.12053661793470383,
0.08557804673910141,
-0.2759091258049011,
-0.3548620343208313,
-0.43830016255378723,
1.0426782369613647,
-0.9426953196525574,
-0.6323007941246033,
-0.42285650968551636,
-0.8811683058738708,
-0.382153183221817,
0.24872492253780365,
0.24002708494663239,
0.2665419280529022,
-0.46362027525901794,
-0.2376636415719986,
0.6348963975906372,
-0.5402663946151733,
0.25277021527290344,
0.44557827711105347,
-0.34340134263038635,
-0.23390693962574005,
1.001543402671814,
0.061125777661800385,
0.2879883348941803,
0.4164654612541199,
0.10987060517072678,
-0.08545248955488205,
-0.5992190837860107,
-0.5621665716171265,
0.10082163661718369,
-0.6027976274490356,
-0.3227161467075348,
-0.6400710344314575,
-0.13237670063972473,
-0.6579354405403137,
-0.35252904891967773,
-0.3720642328262329,
-0.40061625838279724,
0.04023587331175804,
-0.019197197631001472,
0.15525701642036438,
0.5274389982223511,
-0.08609692007303238,
0.44185158610343933,
-1.0966813564300537,
0.253871351480484,
0.17877162992954254,
0.3054961562156677,
-0.03903035447001457,
-0.43276581168174744,
-0.2996411621570587,
-0.003348259488120675,
-0.44943010807037354,
-0.8091774582862854,
0.2939893305301666,
0.19634585082530975,
0.5710329413414001,
0.32213878631591797,
-0.06864802539348602,
1.1680169105529785,
-0.8163569569587708,
0.6529854536056519,
0.21459414064884186,
-1.0576826333999634,
0.5309559106826782,
-0.31376463174819946,
0.11951209604740143,
0.4208574891090393,
0.22387424111366272,
-0.8955029249191284,
-0.6690132021903992,
-0.4766291081905365,
-1.049768328666687,
0.5705020427703857,
-0.08865679055452347,
0.2229110598564148,
0.16280178725719452,
0.4913640022277832,
0.26498815417289734,
0.0013757437700405717,
-0.7060660719871521,
-0.30991724133491516,
0.0690007135272026,
-0.20821411907672882,
-0.124990314245224,
-0.0984642431139946,
-0.3837704658508301,
-0.09814510494470596,
0.2958640158176422,
-0.22614306211471558,
0.09458287805318832,
-0.1974431574344635,
-0.5318140983581543,
-0.13604265451431274,
0.32584136724472046,
0.7531882524490356,
0.7110524773597717,
0.04999605566263199,
0.23751594126224518,
-0.04676492512226105,
-0.3217266798019409,
0.44953420758247375,
-0.08171581476926804,
0.08817053586244583,
-0.6005179286003113,
0.5426008105278015,
0.6234764456748962,
0.06394042074680328,
-0.9676188826560974,
0.768573522567749,
-0.1137227863073349,
0.031065111979842186,
-0.4508160352706909,
0.15083621442317963,
0.4578476846218109,
0.44356557726860046,
0.11314753443002701,
0.028517624363303185,
-0.11877759546041489,
-0.5171505808830261,
0.13569112122058868,
0.5928105711936951,
-0.11827470362186432,
-0.23862408101558685,
0.6933920383453369,
0.1473499834537506,
-0.36597540974617004,
0.9421212673187256,
-0.26562410593032837,
-0.557930588722229,
0.6297607421875,
0.9941883087158203,
0.5188504457473755,
-0.11483856290578842,
-0.10194743424654007,
0.16603654623031616,
0.3968118131160736,
-0.019544389098882675,
0.15734630823135376,
0.20839570462703705,
-1.1205559968948364,
-0.9004517197608948,
-0.6041814684867859,
-0.4888025224208832,
0.060426510870456696,
-0.485055148601532,
0.08201669901609421,
-0.4486579895019531,
0.05376489832997322,
-0.1284123808145523,
-0.0755368173122406,
-0.3950120210647583,
-0.2400938868522644,
0.5129722356796265,
0.6992520093917847,
-1.0332430601119995,
0.7819325923919678,
0.7879964113235474,
0.02609519474208355,
-0.6044526100158691,
0.12477808445692062,
0.6150413751602173,
-0.8604538440704346,
0.6215888857841492,
0.33236029744148254,
-0.12436608970165253,
-0.08341718465089798,
-0.8317945003509521,
-1.074556589126587,
0.8926162719726562,
0.6242154836654663,
-1.0155383348464966,
0.040923215448856354,
0.11670312285423279,
0.4486570358276367,
-0.36400648951530457,
-0.2554945945739746,
0.5519552230834961,
0.38543203473091125,
-0.2176058292388916,
-0.9287680983543396,
0.12784087657928467,
-0.267941415309906,
-0.16051778197288513,
0.5566425323486328,
-0.7782387733459473,
0.5888955593109131,
-0.6318117380142212,
-0.10998715460300446,
0.055325694382190704,
0.628410816192627,
0.5184313058853149,
0.05537468567490578,
0.4116130769252777,
0.774677574634552,
1.01314377784729,
0.11023422330617905,
0.864666223526001,
-0.3206861615180969,
0.28201767802238464,
1.148065447807312,
-0.6036738157272339,
0.6417931914329529,
0.6935771703720093,
-0.17317405343055725,
0.3975110948085785,
0.4818182587623596,
0.022142594680190086,
0.45699530839920044,
0.563174843788147,
-0.10631731152534485,
-0.2789543569087982,
0.12998053431510925,
-0.1578087955713272,
0.4202742874622345,
0.4744008779525757,
0.21146626770496368,
-0.07386374473571777,
0.15006306767463684,
0.029423704370856285,
0.12551391124725342,
0.04434219002723694,
0.7459221482276917,
0.09653830528259277,
-0.4472563862800598,
0.37371888756752014,
0.09692414104938507,
0.9045118093490601,
-0.29517248272895813,
0.09715882688760757,
-0.14707991480827332,
0.23943546414375305,
-0.38300850987434387,
-0.5514956712722778,
0.5048620700836182,
0.29848840832710266,
-0.026892350986599922,
-0.15719926357269287,
0.46367427706718445,
-0.15254993736743927,
-0.31313613057136536,
0.3676283359527588,
0.6229544878005981,
0.21353967487812042,
0.03990450128912926,
-0.7122991681098938,
0.09251386672258377,
-0.04622561112046242,
-0.09745892137289047,
0.7644243836402893,
0.49426889419555664,
-0.3218720257282257,
0.6021500825881958,
0.7271775603294373,
0.03903771936893463,
0.2105158120393753,
-0.13469885289669037,
0.7577641010284424,
-0.93662428855896,
-0.3485599756240845,
-1.095706820487976,
0.5063555240631104,
-0.1807883381843567,
-0.3206040859222412,
0.8322818279266357,
0.7128706574440002,
0.9367765188217163,
0.323155015707016,
0.8839872479438782,
-0.17503495514392853,
0.1595337837934494,
-0.5186597108840942,
0.561019778251648,
-0.5347549915313721,
0.5366460084915161,
-0.4853930175304413,
-1.1325442790985107,
-0.6123105883598328,
0.5839459896087646,
-0.12878288328647614,
-0.3962290585041046,
0.6266337037086487,
0.7298293709754944,
-0.1658533364534378,
-0.16693048179149628,
0.18567705154418945,
0.07490123808383942,
0.45130783319473267,
0.6056503653526306,
1.0536481142044067,
-0.1109846979379654,
0.5222768783569336,
-0.1894737184047699,
-0.22163157165050507,
-0.1848839670419693,
-1.158207654953003,
-0.6849212646484375,
-0.3260466754436493,
-0.2493935078382492,
-0.40243303775787354,
-0.010241267271339893,
0.8817205429077148,
0.49196740984916687,
-0.7326021194458008,
-0.35043713450431824,
0.1685982644557953,
0.20401707291603088,
-0.3451177179813385,
-0.09768746793270111,
0.3021296560764313,
-0.09516449272632599,
-0.7030506730079651,
0.6926035284996033,
0.3803164064884186,
-0.023694736883044243,
-0.35686826705932617,
-0.054031867533922195,
-0.1042410209774971,
-0.34484562277793884,
0.4366447627544403,
0.2617916166782379,
-0.7554266452789307,
-0.43280676007270813,
0.20444868505001068,
-0.3683556318283081,
0.24772383272647858,
0.9803172945976257,
-0.3870058059692383,
0.26990610361099243,
0.3178292512893677,
0.8760737776756287,
0.15181602537631989,
0.03183802217245102,
0.6549473404884338,
-0.9908994436264038,
0.1772870421409607,
0.106287881731987,
0.4260929226875305,
0.4662196934223175,
-0.4778779447078705,
0.21335364878177643,
0.10632660984992981,
-0.7083330154418945,
-0.8240589499473572,
0.4588054120540619,
-0.8241338133811951,
-0.4851526618003845,
1.009594202041626,
-0.10336961597204208,
-0.2997920513153076,
-0.14804628491401672,
-0.0812474936246872,
0.20643050968647003,
-0.12477793544530869,
0.686196506023407,
0.8433835506439209,
-0.1833706498146057,
0.1788506805896759,
-0.5028151869773865,
0.0854397788643837,
0.2725364863872528,
-0.7447876930236816,
0.31199416518211365,
0.6974578499794006,
0.4386518597602844,
0.33501937985420227,
0.4343942105770111,
-0.3859713673591614,
-0.19233401119709015,
-0.08239638060331345,
0.18174690008163452,
0.04817481338977814,
-0.3065594434738159,
-0.6385914087295532,
0.11979914456605911,
0.15943285822868347,
0.34636107087135315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13907v1 | No More Distractions: an Adaptive Up-Sampling Algorithm to Reduce Data Artifacts | 2024-01-25T02:54:53 | 2024-01-25T02:54:53 | Han Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Researchers recently found out that sometimes language models achieve high
accuracy on benchmark data set, but they can not generalize very well with even
little changes to the original data set. This is sometimes due to data
artifacts, model is learning the spurious correlation between tokens and
labels, instead of the semantics and logic. In this work, we analyzed SNLI data
and visualized such spurious correlations. We proposed an adaptive up-sampling
algorithm to correct the data artifacts, which is simple and effective, and
does not need human edits or annotation. We did an experiment applying the
algorithm to fix the data artifacts in SNLI data and the model trained with
corrected data performed significantly better than the model trained with raw
SNLI data, overall, as well as on the subset we corrected. | [
0.02254898101091385,
-0.6397370100021362,
0.441361665725708,
0.22863076627254486,
-0.1871516853570938,
0.27189090847969055,
-0.15152499079704285,
-0.4821794629096985,
0.5329627990722656,
0.6126576066017151,
-0.3065887689590454,
-0.2662666141986847,
-0.47788482904434204,
-0.1623544991016388,
-0.6147561073303223,
1.0690585374832153,
0.11294116079807281,
0.14674904942512512,
-0.09195318073034286,
-0.3124445080757141,
-0.7417897582054138,
-0.11164995282888412,
-0.9893537759780884,
-0.048851512372493744,
0.18116118013858795,
0.5011545419692993,
0.6617744565010071,
1.130695104598999,
0.3238605260848999,
0.2389369159936905,
-0.3052956461906433,
0.2313377857208252,
-0.5924713611602783,
0.04528619349002838,
-0.019849533215165138,
-0.5016434192657471,
-0.5277417302131653,
-0.4053644835948944,
0.9147081971168518,
0.9729536771774292,
-0.1955508291721344,
0.3533671796321869,
0.09530375152826309,
0.8753625154495239,
-0.48549070954322815,
0.02445315197110176,
-0.6861358284950256,
-0.3454308807849884,
-0.6001527905464172,
-0.37659257650375366,
-0.347456693649292,
-0.09565419703722,
-0.048979006707668304,
-0.8643151521682739,
0.41499063372612,
0.1597137302160263,
0.7884140610694885,
0.42940348386764526,
-0.040171023458242416,
-0.10105877369642258,
-0.6535522937774658,
1.0885961055755615,
-0.604724109172821,
0.1776350736618042,
0.2587650716304779,
0.07295181602239609,
-0.3734365701675415,
-0.6210408210754395,
-0.4057621359825134,
0.024100858718156815,
-0.06793565303087234,
0.25778302550315857,
0.06295286118984222,
-0.35732796788215637,
0.2912636995315552,
0.16989977657794952,
-0.21870917081832886,
0.2214197814464569,
-0.4627184271812439,
-0.1676359474658966,
0.757270097732544,
0.2738592326641083,
0.2793881893157959,
-0.03640596196055412,
-0.28793466091156006,
-0.10835584253072739,
-0.7593420147895813,
-0.1001623272895813,
-0.010493790730834007,
0.39457467198371887,
-0.0023623488377779722,
0.13832436501979828,
-0.34547004103660583,
0.9151286482810974,
-0.17457260191440582,
0.30830419063568115,
0.284433513879776,
-0.6157389283180237,
-0.16384842991828918,
-0.06513312458992004,
0.1496814340353012,
0.42205527424812317,
0.3050428330898285,
-0.20725774765014648,
-0.022449320182204247,
-0.01106309611350298,
0.22715091705322266,
-0.2225693315267563,
-0.49204719066619873,
0.3736656904220581,
-0.329802930355072,
-0.48078396916389465,
-0.22379598021507263,
-0.9476975798606873,
-0.5676649212837219,
-0.5136653780937195,
0.25219693779945374,
-0.21739231050014496,
0.036675017327070236,
-0.07652893662452698,
-0.1205165907740593,
-0.5600419044494629,
0.6086664199829102,
-0.5808004140853882,
0.2594742476940155,
0.44921430945396423,
0.9151551723480225,
-0.20342132449150085,
-0.437417209148407,
-0.5940420031547546,
0.30582502484321594,
-0.4554404616355896,
0.7450059056282043,
-0.4132991433143616,
-0.27649015188217163,
-0.1150057464838028,
-0.2874317467212677,
-0.19208726286888123,
-0.5561482906341553,
0.4817048907279968,
-0.46610379219055176,
0.02527577057480812,
-0.37023887038230896,
-0.686845600605011,
-0.06564204394817352,
-0.03991854563355446,
-0.87070631980896,
1.5988776683807373,
-0.036761004477739334,
-0.9782212972640991,
0.565540611743927,
-0.7626501321792603,
0.004119356162846088,
0.0034606207627803087,
-0.16342772543430328,
-0.4620630741119385,
0.2248302698135376,
0.441694974899292,
0.28622543811798096,
-0.06451337784528732,
0.5457823276519775,
-0.4266962707042694,
-0.63768070936203,
0.2875600755214691,
-0.1524694412946701,
0.9337566494941711,
0.297502726316452,
-0.20685334503650665,
0.36303406953811646,
-1.2811552286148071,
-0.3357056677341461,
0.023686731234192848,
-0.3877045512199402,
-0.6627514958381653,
0.244782954454422,
0.17341487109661102,
0.10535057634115219,
-0.14832280576229095,
-0.5819616317749023,
0.2970568537712097,
-0.14889538288116455,
0.11647175997495651,
1.0394859313964844,
-0.1603747010231018,
0.5301000475883484,
-0.8109291791915894,
-0.19407613575458527,
0.15910886228084564,
-0.06972073018550873,
-0.1968323141336441,
-0.6525269746780396,
-1.0494017601013184,
-0.4157693386077881,
0.46108171343803406,
0.4112734794616699,
-0.9590769410133362,
0.36548876762390137,
-0.8334210515022278,
-0.3775085508823395,
-0.5663146376609802,
0.26044192910194397,
0.1514708399772644,
0.7558656930923462,
0.43453896045684814,
-0.4805891811847687,
-0.7240430116653442,
-0.205162912607193,
-0.3253221809864044,
0.01255726907402277,
-0.49023109674453735,
0.11392486840486526,
0.2797401249408722,
0.14734680950641632,
0.9494983553886414,
-0.4602459669113159,
-0.4437400996685028,
0.19824305176734924,
0.3902635872364044,
0.12303825467824936,
0.6820769906044006,
0.4889848530292511,
-0.3979785144329071,
-0.3737797737121582,
-0.16093029081821442,
-0.5197832584381104,
-0.28704121708869934,
-0.34046170115470886,
-0.1730085164308548,
0.057522356510162354,
0.7718351483345032,
-0.23036907613277435,
0.5829330682754517,
0.32973721623420715,
-0.23172876238822937,
0.3042910695075989,
-0.364253431558609,
0.004638679791241884,
-1.1822689771652222,
0.3179842531681061,
-0.20886120200157166,
0.04471520334482193,
-1.1909385919570923,
0.02472127228975296,
0.09965220838785172,
-0.09250837564468384,
-0.11489052325487137,
0.48702892661094666,
-0.3926070034503937,
0.049321990460157394,
-0.3211701810359955,
0.15374016761779785,
-0.003961397800594568,
0.20160698890686035,
0.2532918453216553,
0.5984428524971008,
0.8010662198066711,
-0.749502420425415,
0.08303729444742203,
0.13713504374027252,
-0.5392705202102661,
0.3374793827533722,
-0.31730568408966064,
0.22111958265304565,
-0.3144363760948181,
0.23646856844425201,
-1.221996545791626,
-0.3929753601551056,
0.29728466272354126,
-0.11120015382766724,
0.3649263381958008,
0.5496183633804321,
-0.2699437439441681,
0.02766227163374424,
-0.5785368084907532,
0.5394019484519958,
0.3022788166999817,
-0.8283500075340271,
0.6703037619590759,
0.4409925639629364,
0.0035390767734497786,
-0.6531657576560974,
-0.7038273811340332,
-0.032414019107818604,
-0.22575071454048157,
-0.5035014152526855,
0.637402355670929,
-0.16985151171684265,
0.03692292794585228,
-0.08674672245979309,
0.02715761959552765,
-0.4291692078113556,
0.08193133771419525,
-0.11334333568811417,
0.30106493830680847,
0.04770274832844734,
0.4757018983364105,
-0.47894370555877686,
0.006370828486979008,
-0.23366236686706543,
0.019258491694927216,
0.3835943341255188,
0.36958956718444824,
-0.25210726261138916,
-0.40093666315078735,
-0.05547774210572243,
0.5254937410354614,
0.36132892966270447,
0.32108569145202637,
0.4967843294143677,
-0.32128939032554626,
0.053310416638851166,
-0.6350261569023132,
-0.10586363077163696,
-0.41897350549697876,
0.3209085464477539,
-0.18116438388824463,
-0.5951412320137024,
0.8103242516517639,
0.0029490352608263493,
0.13982316851615906,
0.03969735652208328,
0.2041078805923462,
-0.11307474970817566,
0.8549644351005554,
0.45552298426628113,
-0.5699023008346558,
0.7161397933959961,
0.1893279105424881,
-0.02451127953827381,
-0.7915586233139038,
0.07288633286952972,
-0.7517441511154175,
-0.2422637790441513,
-0.4946213662624359,
-0.5507384538650513,
0.08460982888936996,
-0.028748180717229843,
0.036283742636442184,
-0.037111539393663406,
-0.5430743098258972,
0.3448089063167572,
0.7069097757339478,
0.41748952865600586,
0.44133055210113525,
0.2607106864452362,
0.16547830402851105,
-0.06832904368638992,
-0.8281972408294678,
-0.03098510019481182,
1.336006999015808,
0.2091851383447647,
0.7626147866249084,
-0.033542998135089874,
0.4495663344860077,
0.39954450726509094,
0.3695918619632721,
-0.18147724866867065,
0.2938823103904724,
-0.20332492887973785,
-0.6019921898841858,
-0.5042457580566406,
-0.4491632878780365,
-0.8857274055480957,
-0.07729938626289368,
-0.35000497102737427,
-1.1109670400619507,
0.43621131777763367,
0.4457775056362152,
-0.37382131814956665,
0.5012111067771912,
-0.5594088435173035,
0.2955118715763092,
0.13028958439826965,
-0.3501121401786804,
-0.0447893925011158,
-0.5056153535842896,
0.3784370720386505,
-0.5381729602813721,
0.6047998666763306,
-0.07922415435314178,
0.30387118458747864,
0.8517237901687622,
-0.3082822561264038,
0.8555702567100525,
-0.049163300544023514,
0.10443173348903656,
0.20811934769153595,
0.10945866256952286,
0.6044553518295288,
-0.23650884628295898,
-0.32203370332717896,
0.23601506650447845,
-0.11603046953678131,
-1.0709655284881592,
-0.7512430548667908,
0.46140897274017334,
-0.5064330697059631,
-0.3911043107509613,
-0.20892512798309326,
-0.7344312071800232,
0.055055201053619385,
-0.04843289405107498,
0.1487583965063095,
0.36985331773757935,
0.06803949922323227,
0.181915745139122,
0.29289939999580383,
0.1557309478521347,
0.6196514964103699,
0.5013036727905273,
-0.2360323965549469,
-0.1395116150379181,
1.0122679471969604,
0.3826409876346588,
0.03376020863652229,
0.09811142086982727,
0.19277560710906982,
-0.2018604874610901,
-0.6512300372123718,
-0.609700083732605,
0.015195980668067932,
-0.7977087497711182,
-0.1110745295882225,
-0.2971104681491852,
0.1855321228504181,
-0.4083283841609955,
-0.07868969440460205,
-0.37004274129867554,
-0.5834829807281494,
-0.24871134757995605,
0.2099309265613556,
0.45430320501327515,
0.5991446375846863,
-0.06163397058844566,
0.6345183849334717,
-0.7786509394645691,
-0.21067401766777039,
0.1264602541923523,
0.3401547074317932,
-0.009599990211427212,
-0.7526723146438599,
-0.3253811299800873,
0.02116478607058525,
-0.016086777672171593,
-0.6429458260536194,
0.2537589371204376,
0.4337058663368225,
0.3872538208961487,
0.25970518589019775,
0.04041476175189018,
1.1888772249221802,
-0.12492678314447403,
0.7653453946113586,
-0.10674390941858292,
-1.2871785163879395,
0.36527833342552185,
-0.11730145663022995,
0.35700154304504395,
0.5331665277481079,
0.12388622760772705,
-0.500775158405304,
-0.36984097957611084,
-0.6809866428375244,
-0.7250150442123413,
0.8503678441047668,
0.2107941210269928,
0.051428116858005524,
0.38020774722099304,
0.42656633257865906,
-0.23529936373233795,
0.04980374500155449,
-0.5999693870544434,
-0.16526345908641815,
-0.016409410163760185,
-0.3703983426094055,
-0.12410081923007965,
-0.2183719426393509,
-0.2555755376815796,
-0.3020462393760681,
0.7634645700454712,
-0.12017310410737991,
0.03725286200642586,
0.10647623240947723,
-0.20038564503192902,
-0.1898522973060608,
0.15438617765903473,
0.6317676305770874,
0.7727071046829224,
-0.40996479988098145,
0.16858138144016266,
0.6791510581970215,
-0.6526087522506714,
-0.11832567304372787,
-0.02956317737698555,
-0.4820520281791687,
0.04705052822828293,
0.16421519219875336,
0.7161505222320557,
0.25194740295410156,
-0.5536717772483826,
0.398281455039978,
-0.11051590740680695,
0.2822234332561493,
-0.06962171196937561,
-0.04094855859875679,
-0.30379539728164673,
-0.21300069987773895,
0.3025651276111603,
0.5582114458084106,
0.08440593630075455,
-0.19591400027275085,
0.5160815119743347,
0.056115761399269104,
-0.4860399663448334,
-0.34115535020828247,
0.5333377718925476,
0.14940518140792847,
-0.22960089147090912,
0.6005575656890869,
0.2265169769525528,
-0.02608417719602585,
0.37682345509529114,
0.4285773038864136,
0.3081858158111572,
-0.4328102469444275,
0.1252490133047104,
0.17830993235111237,
0.15471017360687256,
-0.18926966190338135,
0.2659989595413208,
-0.06189432740211487,
-1.0479018688201904,
-0.6815898418426514,
-0.27588966488838196,
-0.37049996852874756,
0.4281514585018158,
-0.8108213543891907,
0.40976911783218384,
-0.2670412063598633,
0.10857882350683212,
0.24359457194805145,
-0.34056684374809265,
-0.6258664727210999,
0.40366098284721375,
-0.25180354714393616,
0.9586624503135681,
-1.2586873769760132,
1.1594005823135376,
0.5670486092567444,
-0.2939605414867401,
-0.7509810924530029,
0.10385815054178238,
-0.0033414119388908148,
-0.7220075130462646,
0.5685177445411682,
-0.05975119024515152,
0.11294880509376526,
0.26880866289138794,
-0.5052340030670166,
-1.1521005630493164,
0.7844595909118652,
0.01660115458071232,
-0.31429511308670044,
0.3503464460372925,
0.05133907496929169,
0.5505641102790833,
-0.36631014943122864,
0.4627796709537506,
0.9088415503501892,
0.3268579840660095,
-0.14355741441249847,
-0.7241075038909912,
0.3676658868789673,
-0.4194702208042145,
0.26193544268608093,
-0.04576893150806427,
-0.385397344827652,
0.9286085963249207,
0.219853013753891,
-0.36922940611839294,
0.14164988696575165,
0.4608004093170166,
0.42092132568359375,
0.5561493635177612,
0.5461322069168091,
0.6137916445732117,
1.0309420824050903,
-0.2249055653810501,
0.8796795606613159,
-0.3288191556930542,
0.44352009892463684,
1.2260714769363403,
-0.5399125814437866,
0.7194353938102722,
0.7429437637329102,
-0.13043095171451569,
0.4282837212085724,
0.570510983467102,
-0.18287257850170135,
0.36743980646133423,
0.13171522319316864,
-0.2131536900997162,
-0.004983875434845686,
-0.1937667429447174,
-0.29955339431762695,
0.692781925201416,
0.34693387150764465,
-0.15012383460998535,
-0.3841596245765686,
-0.19470608234405518,
0.04208759218454361,
0.18199366331100464,
-0.1386612355709076,
0.6685819029808044,
-0.5488468408584595,
-0.7050932049751282,
0.6523822546005249,
-0.309253066778183,
0.6770254969596863,
-0.2125336080789566,
-0.017377937212586403,
-0.2372889667749405,
0.0949806496500969,
-0.23670394718647003,
-0.4975033402442932,
0.4979623258113861,
-0.31505516171455383,
-0.06400571763515472,
0.031353674829006195,
0.8398415446281433,
-0.3577299118041992,
-0.5170475840568542,
0.16025061905384064,
0.4377574622631073,
0.32149142026901245,
0.12989197671413422,
-0.6488852500915527,
0.1817312240600586,
0.10727296769618988,
-0.06226155906915665,
0.26830142736434937,
0.11443432420492172,
-0.3055974543094635,
0.6284506916999817,
0.9358835220336914,
0.37276557087898254,
0.26573076844215393,
0.25032833218574524,
0.9197190999984741,
-0.6052255630493164,
-0.573401153087616,
-0.5690761804580688,
0.6859673857688904,
-0.6648816466331482,
-0.3168916702270508,
0.6051517128944397,
0.43107399344444275,
1.00327730178833,
-0.2748568058013916,
0.5441433191299438,
0.158911794424057,
0.9842022657394409,
-0.7066482901573181,
0.4946359097957611,
-0.5560697913169861,
0.6609182953834534,
-0.28674864768981934,
-0.639748215675354,
-0.8646177053451538,
0.3998408913612366,
-0.09145469963550568,
-0.052954595535993576,
0.47595033049583435,
1.168088436126709,
-0.0288867074996233,
0.12836886942386627,
0.35128939151763916,
0.11591221392154694,
0.10004060715436935,
0.12862524390220642,
0.8075712323188782,
-0.6046294569969177,
0.4109334349632263,
-0.49080589413642883,
-0.37833619117736816,
-0.18309330940246582,
-1.0855071544647217,
-0.6497969031333923,
-0.3690102994441986,
-0.3853171765804291,
-0.3592947721481323,
0.08749385178089142,
0.66975998878479,
0.7889394760131836,
-1.3307039737701416,
-0.4424392580986023,
-0.5012814998626709,
0.031858574599027634,
-0.5658676624298096,
-0.24769499897956848,
0.8509964346885681,
-0.526800811290741,
-0.900255560874939,
0.4678054451942444,
0.1396389603614807,
0.06291570514440536,
0.218242809176445,
0.18314482271671295,
-0.4247044026851654,
0.14070525765419006,
0.21231767535209656,
0.22812551259994507,
-0.5108816027641296,
-0.8340020775794983,
-0.0895160362124443,
0.181214839220047,
0.3301132321357727,
0.9738921523094177,
-0.4706169664859772,
1.0264790058135986,
0.6662735939025879,
0.689669668674469,
0.48879554867744446,
0.23941004276275635,
0.37457865476608276,
-1.386476755142212,
0.38537952303886414,
-0.33331310749053955,
0.3998160660266876,
0.39524179697036743,
-0.4664716422557831,
0.6205906867980957,
0.38502267003059387,
-0.6713031530380249,
-1.009395718574524,
0.14570458233356476,
-0.8273742198944092,
-0.3981984555721283,
0.6447634696960449,
-0.18482132256031036,
-0.345750093460083,
-0.8010857701301575,
-0.32164525985717773,
0.5630990862846375,
-0.1866685152053833,
1.5362863540649414,
0.7079225182533264,
-0.2377859354019165,
-0.02712874673306942,
-0.4874410927295685,
0.8656340837478638,
1.0162413120269775,
-0.7006815671920776,
0.2051737904548645,
0.23415826261043549,
0.41887566447257996,
0.5294491648674011,
0.9039931297302246,
0.12170079350471497,
0.21434535086154938,
0.16038712859153748,
0.006653845775872469,
0.1363748013973236,
-0.22214524447917938,
-0.7165289521217346,
-0.06981030106544495,
0.0037485749926418066,
-0.4718620479106903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13905v1 | Dynamic embedded topic models and change-point detection for exploring literary-historical hypotheses | 2024-01-25T02:50:03 | 2024-01-25T02:50:03 | Hale Sirin, Tom Lippincott | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a novel combination of dynamic embedded topic models and
change-point detection to explore diachronic change of lexical semantic
modality in classical and early Christian Latin. We demonstrate several methods
for finding and characterizing patterns in the output, and relating them to
traditional scholarship in Comparative Literature and Classics. This simple
approach to unsupervised models of semantic change can be applied to any
suitable corpus, and we conclude with future directions and refinements aiming
to allow noisier, less-curated materials to meet that threshold. | [
-0.3097171187400818,
-1.053017258644104,
0.8196699619293213,
-0.29402315616607666,
-0.4449097216129303,
0.08629537373781204,
-0.038560301065444946,
-0.4823604226112366,
0.6071751117706299,
0.5272740721702576,
-0.687645673751831,
-0.6161445379257202,
-0.5081077218055725,
0.046182118356227875,
-0.818392276763916,
0.5753646492958069,
-0.34046804904937744,
-0.05873822420835495,
0.0858321264386177,
-0.04751354083418846,
-0.2278422713279724,
-0.10662873834371567,
-0.2843727171421051,
-0.15650878846645355,
0.5300219058990479,
0.04156852886080742,
0.8742855787277222,
0.667976438999176,
0.5009477734565735,
0.3041098415851593,
-0.6217014789581299,
0.05197657272219658,
-0.18369032442569733,
0.948488175868988,
-0.46218615770339966,
-0.6861396431922913,
-0.32276633381843567,
0.0587596669793129,
0.9174419641494751,
0.6533828377723694,
0.04806601628661156,
-0.03471353277564049,
-0.13839808106422424,
0.3410782217979431,
-0.4820745885372162,
0.12715007364749908,
-1.183456540107727,
-0.045926533639431,
-0.5899236798286438,
-0.7595424652099609,
-0.2845131754875183,
-0.05717383325099945,
0.02662310190498829,
-0.6674935221672058,
0.7536330223083496,
-0.2433316856622696,
0.8300931453704834,
0.1768205612897873,
-0.5068646669387817,
-0.454587459564209,
-0.9067713022232056,
0.8205649256706238,
-0.570963978767395,
0.3472518026828766,
0.11470301449298859,
0.0016896107699722052,
-0.21767744421958923,
-1.056756854057312,
-0.5398316979408264,
-0.2352433204650879,
0.06151284649968147,
-0.0015407375758513808,
-0.27735161781311035,
-0.4002016484737396,
-0.01678864099085331,
0.3274979889392853,
-0.4094789922237396,
0.013639223761856556,
0.03864629194140434,
0.029654743149876595,
0.30865591764450073,
0.5223062634468079,
0.43369531631469727,
-0.22683048248291016,
0.026069670915603638,
-0.09487074613571167,
-0.8271297216415405,
-0.13112808763980865,
0.46751028299331665,
0.17246200144290924,
0.007945488207042217,
0.33513885736465454,
0.14465081691741943,
0.5617140531539917,
0.2827899754047394,
-0.18925917148590088,
-0.08338908851146698,
-0.6539700627326965,
0.2581978738307953,
0.08692578971385956,
0.17148642241954803,
0.12549500167369843,
-0.15033775568008423,
0.09101851284503937,
-0.2553938329219818,
0.3185102343559265,
0.18384550511837006,
-0.5654541254043579,
-0.3172352910041809,
-0.19731055200099945,
-0.5952069163322449,
-0.39570677280426025,
0.10387984663248062,
-0.7288267016410828,
-0.36979153752326965,
-0.5161259174346924,
-0.10955193638801575,
-0.36197999119758606,
-0.4508902430534363,
0.07284633815288544,
-0.15951316058635712,
0.05666583031415939,
0.8263040781021118,
-0.9386676549911499,
0.28238528966903687,
0.8857985734939575,
0.954748809337616,
-0.47454994916915894,
-0.11701962351799011,
-0.1944953054189682,
0.3011329770088196,
-0.5013293027877808,
0.9372060894966125,
-1.0078076124191284,
-0.47254225611686707,
0.2739656865596771,
0.3554992973804474,
-0.14734067022800446,
-0.4804946780204773,
0.6276692152023315,
-0.7521224021911621,
0.17669034004211426,
-0.1673572063446045,
-0.608035683631897,
-0.06300098448991776,
0.2497132122516632,
-0.8667028546333313,
1.348285436630249,
0.045136209577322006,
-0.9263251423835754,
0.39704713225364685,
-0.4643099904060364,
-0.048689015209674835,
0.0025658311787992716,
-0.45000359416007996,
-0.19520284235477448,
0.2874610424041748,
-0.29475167393684387,
-0.016765212640166283,
-0.29832106828689575,
0.4602429270744324,
-0.2332397699356079,
-0.5261369347572327,
0.606488823890686,
-0.4901403784751892,
0.49119770526885986,
0.18698598444461823,
-0.7064533233642578,
0.10857916623353958,
-0.8784447312355042,
-0.43518325686454773,
0.031786881387233734,
-0.16864871978759766,
-0.9412985444068909,
0.5300700664520264,
0.3363935351371765,
-0.06977283954620361,
0.32117363810539246,
-0.5161474943161011,
0.3965111970901489,
-0.19584092497825623,
0.36761167645454407,
0.4309713840484619,
0.2485029250383377,
0.22118309140205383,
-0.31007662415504456,
0.44122108817100525,
0.1842852085828781,
-0.2057759314775467,
-0.3275306820869446,
-0.5053343176841736,
-0.7315584421157837,
-0.2625897526741028,
0.45135998725891113,
0.35522356629371643,
-0.7031612396240234,
0.3018341362476349,
0.01233756449073553,
-0.35093411803245544,
-0.36143597960472107,
-0.036612190306186676,
-0.18665394186973572,
0.14319157600402832,
0.3144627809524536,
-0.20655551552772522,
-0.12388169020414352,
-0.5092718601226807,
-0.14247366786003113,
-0.4391670525074005,
0.16951574385166168,
-0.12028111517429352,
0.7182570695877075,
-0.17484474182128906,
0.6947284936904907,
-0.5736804604530334,
0.17350296676158905,
-0.049902401864528656,
0.5771912932395935,
0.2199920266866684,
0.4598664343357086,
0.8327776193618774,
-1.186973214149475,
-0.3627757430076599,
-0.13466161489486694,
-0.19298338890075684,
-0.2719632089138031,
-0.278314471244812,
-0.10248025506734848,
-0.016797902062535286,
0.9800238609313965,
-0.29487618803977966,
0.5758748650550842,
0.2149936407804489,
-0.8266288042068481,
0.5432948470115662,
-0.16311681270599365,
0.47084516286849976,
-1.2236790657043457,
-0.09429940581321716,
-0.32006675004959106,
-0.19315002858638763,
-0.4265992343425751,
-0.02695774845778942,
0.026133691892027855,
0.09833846986293793,
-0.3099202811717987,
0.43429407477378845,
-0.5592539310455322,
0.22725357115268707,
-0.6443257927894592,
0.22005097568035126,
-0.0533926747739315,
0.02508171647787094,
0.3943524956703186,
0.4469864070415497,
0.4218095541000366,
-0.417525976896286,
0.294371634721756,
0.12989147007465363,
-0.28105998039245605,
0.5711276531219482,
-0.5691906213760376,
-0.23979654908180237,
-0.23377130925655365,
0.19080793857574463,
-1.1443253755569458,
0.133213073015213,
-0.05854622647166252,
-0.3185793459415436,
0.3903123736381531,
-0.4192391335964203,
-0.5750287175178528,
0.27228376269340515,
-0.3807123303413391,
0.6617699265480042,
0.11967171728610992,
-0.022549070417881012,
0.27593526244163513,
0.09408777207136154,
-0.4642389416694641,
-0.1619751751422882,
-0.4683157801628113,
0.04812701418995857,
-0.3824801445007324,
-0.6126234531402588,
1.1707582473754883,
-0.14223481714725494,
-0.7458529472351074,
0.38079437613487244,
0.03944911062717438,
-0.159227654337883,
0.2953590154647827,
0.04524169862270355,
0.40799272060394287,
-0.5050306916236877,
0.26346561312675476,
0.42543214559555054,
-0.14685913920402527,
-0.30317267775535583,
-0.11389689147472382,
0.6499372124671936,
-0.05641068145632744,
-0.3918266296386719,
-0.44037124514579773,
0.6950897574424744,
0.842852771282196,
-0.41267091035842896,
0.624869704246521,
0.6911913752555847,
-0.4619099795818329,
0.1764334738254547,
-0.2890682816505432,
-0.3689101040363312,
-0.406488299369812,
0.18138810992240906,
-0.23560096323490143,
-0.8483637571334839,
0.7253737449645996,
-0.2491513043642044,
0.06850340217351913,
0.7573359608650208,
0.9946132898330688,
-0.07665586471557617,
0.5370755195617676,
0.5488269925117493,
0.7571620345115662,
1.0574655532836914,
-0.3247906267642975,
-0.1481899619102478,
-0.6394080519676208,
0.003038030117750168,
-0.6538553237915039,
-0.45252683758735657,
-1.0450390577316284,
-0.6310303211212158,
0.4786013066768646,
0.15920314192771912,
0.07116156816482544,
0.2195691466331482,
-0.032392751425504684,
0.21544881165027618,
0.3939969539642334,
-0.05769401788711548,
0.5661518573760986,
-0.26625609397888184,
-0.33673718571662903,
-0.41213303804397583,
-0.12973538041114807,
-0.7207288146018982,
0.8735665082931519,
0.24288557469844818,
0.8074361681938171,
0.6993144750595093,
0.6933121085166931,
0.6707989573478699,
0.0038008021656423807,
-0.6055603623390198,
0.4203210771083832,
-0.0865834429860115,
-0.6930841207504272,
-0.17720794677734375,
0.09533675760030746,
-1.201238989830017,
0.2933252155780792,
-0.5006967186927795,
-0.6985808610916138,
0.8168806433677673,
0.0036106850020587444,
-0.28835076093673706,
0.4352904260158539,
0.04430486261844635,
0.9233907461166382,
0.1835043579339981,
-0.6003689169883728,
-0.4295910894870758,
-0.3848304748535156,
-0.013783995993435383,
-0.06157202273607254,
-0.03776177018880844,
-0.1339653581380844,
-0.4659997224807739,
0.635936975479126,
-0.19638851284980774,
0.9996347427368164,
0.17284560203552246,
-0.10847203433513641,
0.4698600769042969,
0.7506201863288879,
0.4138135313987732,
0.32466790080070496,
-0.14831149578094482,
-0.271858811378479,
0.6843107342720032,
-0.43377459049224854,
-0.5356019139289856,
0.92572021484375,
-0.5209869742393494,
-0.4922785758972168,
-0.8429474830627441,
-0.6675083637237549,
0.06470827013254166,
0.004661688581109047,
-0.009798724204301834,
0.7931299805641174,
-0.5152689218521118,
0.25072380900382996,
0.7748021483421326,
-0.040320560336112976,
0.7820383310317993,
1.0025125741958618,
0.012679931707680225,
-0.06049288064241409,
0.19466935098171234,
0.020850155502557755,
0.19694975018501282,
0.6178371906280518,
0.12138498574495316,
-0.12925474345684052,
-0.8699579834938049,
-0.3280538320541382,
0.38473960757255554,
-0.6337871551513672,
0.3027039170265198,
-0.36678263545036316,
0.16832853853702545,
-0.4761984646320343,
-0.3777713477611542,
-0.5459036231040955,
-0.4468798041343689,
-0.6913754343986511,
0.055528197437524796,
0.35290244221687317,
0.6725136041641235,
-0.21095061302185059,
0.2380550503730774,
-0.7401639223098755,
-0.13648541271686554,
-0.0419088639318943,
-0.20967014133930206,
-0.2151651829481125,
-0.6075494289398193,
0.001147633884102106,
-0.37843039631843567,
-0.6524338722229004,
-1.393510341644287,
0.5302351713180542,
0.20767952501773834,
0.48440685868263245,
0.6092744469642639,
0.2120298594236374,
0.19550135731697083,
-0.5904186964035034,
0.918849527835846,
0.02939099632203579,
-0.8102607131004333,
0.5935738682746887,
-0.6944468021392822,
0.3257840871810913,
0.6512898206710815,
0.5469859838485718,
-0.6743050813674927,
-0.30917656421661377,
-0.7133009433746338,
-0.7656655311584473,
0.1285332441329956,
0.04122166335582733,
0.20989890396595,
-0.21183085441589355,
0.37755337357521057,
0.437400221824646,
0.055344171822071075,
-0.5392804145812988,
-0.22721916437149048,
0.09269393980503082,
-0.1114586666226387,
0.13801296055316925,
-0.2546630799770355,
-0.15588875114917755,
-0.598560631275177,
0.39991679787635803,
-0.10146627575159073,
0.2601834535598755,
0.29372841119766235,
-0.23000818490982056,
-0.15940715372562408,
0.5171035528182983,
0.9403417110443115,
1.1132431030273438,
-0.36192065477371216,
0.5739175081253052,
-0.30733320116996765,
-0.5425503849983215,
-0.03184229135513306,
0.32790645956993103,
-0.6481091976165771,
0.6110003590583801,
0.6545377969741821,
0.6895853281021118,
0.6496623158454895,
-0.317548543214798,
0.30325767397880554,
0.04351143166422844,
0.14819230139255524,
-0.6865474581718445,
-0.18362100422382355,
0.05197759345173836,
0.540527880191803,
0.27866190671920776,
-0.04865528643131256,
0.16171082854270935,
-1.2611196041107178,
0.3620576858520508,
0.08556600660085678,
-0.6766541004180908,
-0.7001582980155945,
0.5531904101371765,
0.030333204194903374,
-0.21633440256118774,
0.043033767491579056,
-0.22542358934879303,
-0.5889321565628052,
0.3206777274608612,
0.5912402868270874,
0.7150203585624695,
-0.33588555455207825,
0.6265290975570679,
0.08344754576683044,
-0.05603918805718422,
0.19075971841812134,
0.3194311559200287,
-0.12617935240268707,
-0.7316319942474365,
-0.14645123481750488,
-0.5551446676254272,
-0.2794225215911865,
0.04708443209528923,
-0.6721428036689758,
0.49585825204849243,
0.08453672379255295,
-0.13729263842105865,
0.40828901529312134,
-0.09549038857221603,
-0.30809485912323,
-0.32801276445388794,
0.005845723208039999,
0.6378185153007507,
-0.7967619299888611,
1.0240060091018677,
0.9172312617301941,
-0.2732710838317871,
0.07598064094781876,
0.31423476338386536,
0.3444918096065521,
-0.39385101199150085,
0.7860777378082275,
-0.5744041204452515,
-0.22814008593559265,
-0.07572855055332184,
-0.30016398429870605,
-0.9192660450935364,
1.2295814752578735,
-0.019240735098719597,
-0.48174503445625305,
-0.2426435947418213,
-0.16312743723392487,
0.750790536403656,
-0.48491719365119934,
0.37903690338134766,
0.4632398784160614,
0.39981257915496826,
0.45009446144104004,
-0.6527104377746582,
-0.11286577582359314,
-0.1840837001800537,
-0.2853114902973175,
0.7626929879188538,
-0.28734666109085083,
1.2506053447723389,
0.2013314813375473,
-0.330889493227005,
0.29727792739868164,
0.6687685251235962,
-0.11290331184864044,
0.6234561204910278,
0.41672393679618835,
0.4061781167984009,
0.7004768252372742,
-0.2485639899969101,
0.6807219982147217,
-0.5777055025100708,
0.41256940364837646,
0.864036500453949,
-0.18738007545471191,
0.8279191851615906,
0.601331889629364,
-0.12614987790584564,
1.0832931995391846,
0.9887644648551941,
0.1807565987110138,
0.6400419473648071,
0.2497667670249939,
-0.6598257422447205,
-0.5535278916358948,
-0.20353306829929352,
-0.7515825033187866,
0.5596742033958435,
0.5365440249443054,
-0.5860556364059448,
-0.44616690278053284,
-0.18178366124629974,
0.38637813925743103,
0.2461044043302536,
-0.13737377524375916,
0.5301065444946289,
-0.0333881601691246,
-0.6301826238632202,
0.5687642693519592,
0.2867704927921295,
0.5339986681938171,
-0.6818113327026367,
-0.23473186790943146,
-0.1621077060699463,
0.21824264526367188,
0.2771402597427368,
-0.4462594985961914,
0.4667322635650635,
-0.124073326587677,
-0.3560728430747986,
-0.2173297256231308,
0.7975381016731262,
-0.5642277002334595,
-0.647278368473053,
0.20585274696350098,
0.7917612791061401,
-0.0016592082101851702,
0.1402435600757599,
-0.6854262948036194,
0.1853407323360443,
-0.23254233598709106,
-0.08311546593904495,
0.2073340266942978,
0.6262561678886414,
-0.3480542302131653,
0.021995237097144127,
0.4453538954257965,
0.19744259119033813,
-0.03664947301149368,
-0.009911047294735909,
0.8744930624961853,
-0.9893776774406433,
-0.5493276119232178,
-0.7526760697364807,
0.2822405993938446,
-0.02360212616622448,
-0.6161037087440491,
0.3919403553009033,
0.2682863175868988,
0.5522201657295227,
0.05185848847031593,
0.1926555335521698,
-0.04294600337743759,
0.5167214870452881,
-0.5580049753189087,
0.47369441390037537,
-0.8535366654396057,
0.45603370666503906,
-0.45319294929504395,
-0.7810562252998352,
-0.1711011379957199,
0.30947721004486084,
-0.31961071491241455,
-0.4731236398220062,
1.1802654266357422,
0.6453090906143188,
-0.25214555859565735,
0.1931302845478058,
0.29246339201927185,
0.22782978415489197,
0.38188597559928894,
0.04251464456319809,
1.046949028968811,
-0.0321655310690403,
-0.012270200997591019,
0.08484882861375809,
-0.4237445294857025,
-0.3670690059661865,
-1.0106837749481201,
-0.5282722115516663,
-1.0756574869155884,
-0.741746187210083,
-0.3464182913303375,
0.15393169224262238,
0.817065954208374,
0.12598633766174316,
-0.9177346229553223,
-0.10410521924495697,
0.052049413323402405,
0.13020746409893036,
-0.35493141412734985,
-0.2389906495809555,
0.6075435876846313,
-0.02984955534338951,
-0.8967288136482239,
0.6839950680732727,
0.25594663619995117,
0.26481392979621887,
-0.5633459091186523,
0.40986377000808716,
-0.5458892583847046,
0.44869863986968994,
0.5066370368003845,
0.08072159439325333,
-0.7606836557388306,
-0.3715280294418335,
0.07010693103075027,
0.02707814984023571,
0.03356979042291641,
1.5208373069763184,
-0.4288070797920227,
0.30714699625968933,
0.8616280555725098,
0.33570680022239685,
0.8410719633102417,
-0.09847013652324677,
0.3913542926311493,
-0.19198393821716309,
0.3127047121524811,
0.42248842120170593,
0.6623249650001526,
0.17372135818004608,
0.062173716723918915,
0.3409280776977539,
1.1659815311431885,
-0.21309076249599457,
-0.910042405128479,
0.553403913974762,
-1.1468592882156372,
-0.668100893497467,
0.998430609703064,
-0.1444508135318756,
-0.09174620360136032,
-0.46287891268730164,
-0.022638147696852684,
0.10070362687110901,
-0.13222332298755646,
0.8211156725883484,
0.8195027709007263,
-0.24347059428691864,
-0.112894207239151,
-0.5565862059593201,
0.34328576922416687,
0.34352144598960876,
-0.5403367280960083,
-0.27125924825668335,
0.6721201539039612,
0.27920395135879517,
0.4269520938396454,
0.2227102816104889,
-0.44908541440963745,
0.10634774714708328,
0.08645498007535934,
-0.2240484207868576,
0.2851831614971161,
-0.40753796696662903,
0.10191375762224197,
0.2142341583967209,
0.058204494416713715,
0.06364583969116211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13887v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13887v1 | A comparative study of zero-shot inference with large language models and supervised modeling in breast cancer pathology classification | 2024-01-25T02:05:31 | 2024-01-25T02:05:31 | Madhumita Sushil, Travis Zack, Divneet Mandair, Zhiwei Zheng, Ahmed Wali, Yan-Ning Yu, Yuwei Quan, Atul J. Butte | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Although supervised machine learning is popular for information extraction
from clinical notes, creating large annotated datasets requires extensive
domain expertise and is time-consuming. Meanwhile, large language models (LLMs)
have demonstrated promising transfer learning capability. In this study, we
explored whether recent LLMs can reduce the need for large-scale data
annotations. We curated a manually-labeled dataset of 769 breast cancer
pathology reports, labeled with 13 categories, to compare zero-shot
classification capability of the GPT-4 model and the GPT-3.5 model with
supervised classification performance of three model architectures: random
forests classifier, long short-term memory networks with attention (LSTM-Att),
and the UCSF-BERT model. Across all 13 tasks, the GPT-4 model performed either
significantly better than or as well as the best supervised model, the LSTM-Att
model (average macro F1 score of 0.83 vs. 0.75). On tasks with high imbalance
between labels, the differences were more prominent. Frequent sources of GPT-4
errors included inferences from multiple samples and complex task design. On
complex tasks where large annotated datasets cannot be easily collected, LLMs
can reduce the burden of large-scale data labeling. However, if the use of LLMs
is prohibitive, the use of simpler supervised models with large annotated
datasets can provide comparable results. LLMs demonstrated the potential to
speed up the execution of clinical NLP studies by reducing the need for
curating large annotated datasets. This may result in an increase in the
utilization of NLP-based variables and outcomes in observational clinical
studies. | [
0.10254984349012375,
-0.7046838402748108,
0.8604716658592224,
-0.027353772893548012,
-0.10942931473255157,
-0.11762779951095581,
-0.1748589277267456,
-0.6483567357063293,
-0.06245935335755348,
0.816474974155426,
-0.30988895893096924,
-0.7112566828727722,
-0.9031268358230591,
0.20167529582977295,
-0.5509927272796631,
1.1719294786453247,
0.004452370572835207,
0.11961933225393295,
-0.05122533440589905,
-0.0795871913433075,
-0.29526978731155396,
-0.4939238131046295,
-0.7684556841850281,
-0.35716772079467773,
0.9328798055648804,
-0.0637694001197815,
0.4186645448207855,
0.9397539496421814,
0.6269396543502808,
0.24057933688163757,
0.043706703931093216,
-0.030934100970625877,
-0.2515897750854492,
0.09301766008138657,
-0.14839380979537964,
-0.5367429852485657,
-0.422563374042511,
0.044054266065359116,
0.3390851318836212,
0.9212005138397217,
0.24695059657096863,
-0.04033423215150833,
-0.0014985093148425221,
0.5490994453430176,
-0.8106074333190918,
0.4861176013946533,
-0.30422547459602356,
0.24956034123897552,
-0.19232358038425446,
-0.2399301677942276,
-0.543208658695221,
-0.27044084668159485,
0.37105080485343933,
-0.44146549701690674,
0.18383772671222687,
-0.2952924966812134,
0.7784676551818848,
0.24028244614601135,
-0.576267421245575,
-0.10172658413648605,
-0.6575126051902771,
0.8904045224189758,
-0.8728359341621399,
0.17618994414806366,
0.36205267906188965,
0.3165656626224518,
-0.006493831984698772,
-0.5712653398513794,
-0.14623335003852844,
-0.2072967290878296,
-0.02047007903456688,
0.1629665642976761,
-0.35412612557411194,
0.3049437999725342,
0.5135777592658997,
0.14080841839313507,
-0.5337100625038147,
0.5562010407447815,
-0.3894226551055908,
-0.37689003348350525,
0.4715980291366577,
0.1295739710330963,
0.12819907069206238,
-0.06206010282039642,
-0.002055062912404537,
0.10677935183048248,
-0.922122061252594,
-0.3205414414405823,
-0.27341705560684204,
0.5742015838623047,
0.12334626168012619,
0.49084997177124023,
-0.4657619893550873,
1.0431209802627563,
-0.3560100495815277,
-0.37504634261131287,
0.11786341667175293,
-0.206863135099411,
-0.5720895528793335,
0.15244725346565247,
0.862689197063446,
0.2931807041168213,
0.33330756425857544,
-0.3017048239707947,
0.3564720153808594,
0.20785506069660187,
0.02338637411594391,
-1.002718448638916,
-0.2859640121459961,
0.14587077498435974,
-0.3910978138446808,
-0.16605235636234283,
-0.26998043060302734,
-0.47495514154434204,
-0.3376140892505646,
-0.2465168684720993,
0.47180062532424927,
-0.24644866585731506,
0.10729105025529861,
0.33085182309150696,
0.23619577288627625,
-0.13944989442825317,
0.7269553542137146,
-0.59064120054245,
0.1631522923707962,
0.5051389932632446,
1.1009674072265625,
-0.325893759727478,
0.06455427408218384,
-0.8163597583770752,
0.4712616801261902,
-0.3975072503089905,
0.6801488399505615,
-0.5025323629379272,
-0.1496587097644806,
0.051204681396484375,
0.14831627905368805,
-0.25216010212898254,
-0.34280315041542053,
0.4790629744529724,
-0.18989939987659454,
0.37815678119659424,
-0.2691343128681183,
-0.6072949767112732,
-0.47622671723365784,
0.1708449274301529,
-0.5467777252197266,
0.49520349502563477,
0.2965107262134552,
-0.585133969783783,
0.5299778580665588,
-0.38894563913345337,
-0.3695268929004669,
0.16889744997024536,
-0.19531069695949554,
-0.35360878705978394,
-0.14349399507045746,
0.33155325055122375,
1.1194595098495483,
-0.27008047699928284,
0.16677796840667725,
-0.6456474661827087,
-0.49980857968330383,
0.06897508352994919,
-0.28547948598861694,
0.6685166954994202,
0.17196357250213623,
-0.45573896169662476,
-0.0674733966588974,
-0.6247345805168152,
-0.2037283182144165,
0.031999487429857254,
-0.18881088495254517,
-0.39175423979759216,
-0.15304818749427795,
-0.4441395103931427,
0.4049046039581299,
-0.20914919674396515,
-0.7060818672180176,
0.3378683626651764,
-0.477054625749588,
0.48547232151031494,
0.29565900564193726,
-0.03696359694004059,
0.2177327573299408,
-0.35060736536979675,
0.4177057445049286,
0.14464929699897766,
-0.10496304929256439,
-0.19962310791015625,
-0.664952278137207,
-0.6280032992362976,
-0.701384425163269,
0.30591678619384766,
0.5796985030174255,
-0.6438111066818237,
0.10349515080451965,
-0.40491336584091187,
-0.3668248951435089,
-0.6228726506233215,
0.0026106182485818863,
0.4779982268810272,
0.646628201007843,
0.6157069206237793,
-0.36855390667915344,
-0.250653475522995,
-0.904150664806366,
0.18092595040798187,
-0.0156533382833004,
-0.19926728308200836,
0.4589502215385437,
0.23200109601020813,
-0.047562528401613235,
0.6002790927886963,
-0.515470564365387,
-0.48268839716911316,
-0.21060127019882202,
0.2332172989845276,
0.2050848752260208,
0.1637081503868103,
0.5734483599662781,
-0.18861107528209686,
-0.47275516390800476,
0.3830084204673767,
-0.8294528126716614,
-0.4187200665473938,
-0.02142672799527645,
0.0963987484574318,
0.43249040842056274,
0.2137710303068161,
-0.762961208820343,
0.7157594561576843,
0.3171819746494293,
-0.03535156324505806,
0.26113077998161316,
-0.08493310213088989,
0.294391930103302,
-0.7547539472579956,
-0.07037387043237686,
0.1451719105243683,
-0.3932599723339081,
-0.5389464497566223,
-0.4766635298728943,
-0.02754533663392067,
0.26146119832992554,
-0.3345257043838501,
0.5447795391082764,
-0.3729571998119354,
-0.28075018525123596,
-0.14653551578521729,
-0.10033927857875824,
0.05163590610027313,
0.26191607117652893,
0.3595682382583618,
0.4714528024196625,
0.6116573810577393,
-0.45151764154434204,
0.22056812047958374,
0.1128964051604271,
-0.2847461998462677,
0.27122968435287476,
-0.3191893994808197,
-0.06242484226822853,
0.09665030241012573,
0.42694753408432007,
-0.9223424196243286,
-0.27299433946609497,
0.21487115323543549,
-0.2559463083744049,
0.5402849912643433,
-0.21479296684265137,
-0.4921128749847412,
-0.5199714303016663,
-0.2601950466632843,
-0.041190460324287415,
0.44857850670814514,
-0.2630341053009033,
0.1266125589609146,
-0.10121964663267136,
-0.42506372928619385,
-0.44653305411338806,
-1.1539232730865479,
0.03793487697839737,
-0.28387194871902466,
-0.2486949861049652,
0.15222902595996857,
0.16561953723430634,
0.10096713900566101,
-0.12133462727069855,
0.032763876020908356,
-0.04686529561877251,
-0.10751504451036453,
0.24192863702774048,
0.3228472173213959,
-0.32046225666999817,
0.3464529812335968,
0.002063443185761571,
0.04540150240063667,
-0.19669203460216522,
-0.06160561367869377,
0.16623014211654663,
0.1786782294511795,
-0.4770232141017914,
-0.6111207008361816,
0.1749851405620575,
0.6047747731208801,
-0.01163770817220211,
0.6640613079071045,
0.35325750708580017,
-0.2472475916147232,
-0.07531411945819855,
-0.6800124049186707,
-0.25010111927986145,
-0.2583746612071991,
0.3450019657611847,
-0.1734379082918167,
-1.3938937187194824,
0.2563510835170746,
0.037647850811481476,
0.10394643992185593,
0.4941580593585968,
0.8224853277206421,
0.031560931354761124,
0.9875240921974182,
0.3319244682788849,
-0.31107187271118164,
0.33648788928985596,
-0.05928804352879524,
0.15059281885623932,
-0.5520257353782654,
-0.025265343487262726,
-0.5686560273170471,
-0.047885335981845856,
-0.46077993512153625,
-0.5830631852149963,
0.2031845599412918,
-0.2862767279148102,
-0.44741374254226685,
0.10667296499013901,
-0.8202424645423889,
0.1058429405093193,
0.11901133507490158,
0.32756370306015015,
0.429415225982666,
0.07455678284168243,
0.3650478422641754,
-0.06148760765790939,
-0.82590252161026,
-0.330812007188797,
1.56236732006073,
0.34707462787628174,
0.38483935594558716,
0.021229341626167297,
0.5807166695594788,
0.10208848118782043,
0.6310946941375732,
-0.8850265145301819,
0.4211600720882416,
-0.4737260937690735,
-0.4589231014251709,
-0.19679206609725952,
-0.5921167135238647,
-1.0363423824310303,
0.2493191361427307,
-0.2014576941728592,
-0.9772883653640747,
0.024008531123399734,
-0.08613064140081406,
-0.6915631890296936,
0.3332991302013397,
-0.7730519771575928,
0.7087876796722412,
-0.18789425492286682,
-0.5116710066795349,
0.23421454429626465,
-0.6049210429191589,
0.5256698131561279,
-0.32429632544517517,
0.2534908354282379,
-0.26121264696121216,
-0.07685462385416031,
0.7756270170211792,
-0.34219157695770264,
0.888569712638855,
-0.045593634247779846,
-0.013014810159802437,
0.14804278314113617,
0.24865223467350006,
0.24235591292381287,
-0.3798746168613434,
-0.1296050101518631,
0.20303727686405182,
0.19896693527698517,
-0.4648950397968292,
-0.5032777190208435,
0.8548732995986938,
-0.5897217392921448,
-0.3933488428592682,
-0.4314429461956024,
-0.7385732531547546,
-0.3634359538555145,
0.06366994976997375,
0.12368129193782806,
0.242360457777977,
0.32592469453811646,
0.3223184645175934,
0.5148245692253113,
-0.16705633699893951,
0.3961350917816162,
0.5973665118217468,
-0.16324946284294128,
0.020960427820682526,
0.6824698448181152,
0.49867624044418335,
0.30686596035957336,
0.4725554883480072,
0.18045933544635773,
-0.09410689771175385,
-0.8674885630607605,
-0.21506042778491974,
0.24141450226306915,
-0.4307638108730316,
-0.4323192238807678,
-0.9694178700447083,
-0.2900436520576477,
-0.4231514632701874,
-0.17363375425338745,
-0.1988227814435959,
-0.5093775391578674,
-0.34829917550086975,
-0.2992861866950989,
0.6942844986915588,
0.5201529860496521,
-0.014408945105969906,
0.430757999420166,
-0.7890228033065796,
-0.061693113297224045,
0.10308371484279633,
0.009684795513749123,
-0.07678455859422684,
-0.7299368381500244,
-0.13342855870723724,
-0.17225009202957153,
-0.14469219744205475,
-0.9680494070053101,
0.5084409117698669,
0.3068363070487976,
0.2970823645591736,
0.4922047555446625,
-0.1612662523984909,
0.6360487341880798,
-0.1772286295890808,
0.6550154089927673,
0.20668160915374756,
-0.5275237560272217,
0.4417041838169098,
-0.6120827198028564,
0.3802766501903534,
0.33717578649520874,
0.6424359083175659,
-0.13925524055957794,
-0.31158560514450073,
-0.45679983496665955,
-0.6376240253448486,
0.8797786831855774,
0.1804031878709793,
-0.3054860532283783,
-0.05986880138516426,
0.46136876940727234,
0.22150373458862305,
0.17090074717998505,
-0.7138742208480835,
0.1191689744591713,
0.13607338070869446,
-0.1864759474992752,
-0.3568323850631714,
-0.20673544704914093,
-0.21520502865314484,
-0.4102608263492584,
0.5793671011924744,
-0.26070040464401245,
0.32207009196281433,
0.2403242141008377,
0.14159397780895233,
0.027674797922372818,
0.24759437143802643,
0.3371613621711731,
0.3572510778903961,
-0.48181095719337463,
0.19138559699058533,
0.3386856019496918,
-0.3444635272026062,
-0.02452952042222023,
0.17615573108196259,
-0.10397471487522125,
-0.04468984156847,
0.9439482688903809,
0.7946443557739258,
0.22655153274536133,
-0.5048935413360596,
0.5472850203514099,
0.3196507692337036,
-0.43946248292922974,
0.3604734241962433,
0.05923748388886452,
0.17101223766803741,
0.19734148681163788,
-0.02039238251745701,
-0.3882119059562683,
0.35943403840065,
-0.3963775932788849,
0.11708373576402664,
0.2384565770626068,
-0.5365119576454163,
-0.12429763376712799,
0.4470207095146179,
-0.12022081017494202,
0.16792955994606018,
0.560358464717865,
0.2308751791715622,
0.08771056681871414,
0.5483426451683044,
0.51105135679245,
0.4383310377597809,
-0.3759631812572479,
0.29160717129707336,
0.3403177261352539,
0.12650202214717865,
-0.31053823232650757,
-0.13163292407989502,
0.005583152174949646,
-0.42546314001083374,
-0.9601421356201172,
-0.7178415656089783,
-0.3910727798938751,
0.43473803997039795,
-0.49982142448425293,
0.13622170686721802,
-0.49707743525505066,
-0.21680256724357605,
0.48194774985313416,
-0.028175044804811478,
-0.5310500264167786,
0.43901360034942627,
0.1208011731505394,
0.5991925597190857,
-0.966472864151001,
1.0107725858688354,
0.43387916684150696,
-0.32583123445510864,
-0.6730417013168335,
-0.4608982801437378,
0.2606697678565979,
-0.5897723436355591,
0.7078050971031189,
0.4894692599773407,
0.19885839521884918,
-0.14283476769924164,
-0.4911283850669861,
-0.7728338837623596,
1.1263182163238525,
0.47035086154937744,
-0.7275665402412415,
-0.088431216776371,
0.17924346029758453,
0.7555151581764221,
-0.4169715642929077,
0.40081465244293213,
0.7529994249343872,
0.26801779866218567,
0.46610498428344727,
-1.0565425157546997,
0.13815179467201233,
0.3535785973072052,
-0.15716184675693512,
0.24003024399280548,
-0.298692911863327,
0.7540565729141235,
-0.1442141830921173,
0.04702454060316086,
0.1058565080165863,
0.2301977127790451,
0.17839616537094116,
0.4358101487159729,
-0.028125900775194168,
0.6939831376075745,
0.5255997776985168,
-0.28420644998550415,
1.0987128019332886,
0.08453770726919174,
0.3243326246738434,
0.8788242936134338,
-0.5277169346809387,
0.771780788898468,
0.25586286187171936,
-0.4927900731563568,
0.25063711404800415,
0.6903207302093506,
-0.0017466237768530846,
0.3477430045604706,
0.21298007667064667,
-0.2872267961502075,
-0.4712729752063751,
-0.16791275143623352,
-0.3233080804347992,
0.19156856834888458,
0.4533652663230896,
-0.5216460227966309,
-0.43700098991394043,
0.17223884165287018,
0.3999727964401245,
-0.20439140498638153,
-0.3757169544696808,
0.7412421703338623,
0.21224935352802277,
-0.3037879168987274,
0.521260678768158,
-0.3493974804878235,
0.6066623330116272,
-0.6652119159698486,
-0.005087072495371103,
-0.15262790024280548,
0.21006473898887634,
-0.48793214559555054,
-0.8024522662162781,
0.45493221282958984,
0.04174550250172615,
-0.0012807820457965136,
0.020453814417123795,
0.654957115650177,
-0.3050420880317688,
-0.6138240098953247,
0.45575815439224243,
0.5154217481613159,
0.5390795469284058,
-0.22646886110305786,
-0.547461986541748,
0.0958828553557396,
-0.00763193191960454,
-0.3752436637878418,
0.6889539361000061,
0.3431032598018646,
-0.40008553862571716,
0.7523659467697144,
0.6924490928649902,
0.41783538460731506,
-0.19466407597064972,
-0.09365510195493698,
0.6992663145065308,
-0.4827892780303955,
0.05546946078538895,
-0.9667035341262817,
-0.017580416053533554,
-0.017790451645851135,
0.11086739599704742,
0.671413004398346,
0.39105331897735596,
0.5445176959037781,
0.03898376598954201,
0.8012857437133789,
0.25649115443229675,
0.824202299118042,
-0.5151541233062744,
0.5330418944358826,
-0.5434377789497375,
0.11692794412374496,
-0.2877163290977478,
-0.6846545338630676,
-0.9242520928382874,
0.5473294258117676,
-0.8106195330619812,
0.295987993478775,
0.678310751914978,
0.5310047268867493,
-0.048149291425943375,
-0.16681203246116638,
0.5413443446159363,
0.49308526515960693,
0.43354883790016174,
0.9086719155311584,
0.26427778601646423,
-0.10445961356163025,
0.31600379943847656,
-0.26169097423553467,
-0.47460058331489563,
-0.34934452176094055,
-0.8894104957580566,
-0.9707916378974915,
-0.27613604068756104,
-0.5081107020378113,
-0.2857227623462677,
0.38405489921569824,
0.6784307360649109,
0.961260199546814,
-0.7965388894081116,
0.09972381591796875,
0.11164765805006027,
-0.18370331823825836,
0.004918878432363272,
-0.15850016474723816,
0.7037201523780823,
0.03485706076025963,
-0.6231275200843811,
0.3523961305618286,
0.6430314779281616,
0.054291870445013046,
0.03429989516735077,
0.28660067915916443,
-0.3059922158718109,
-0.042500246316194534,
0.9424253702163696,
0.3750852644443512,
-0.6879581809043884,
-0.22336852550506592,
-0.3055928349494934,
-0.18452535569667816,
0.007802513428032398,
0.3801842927932739,
-0.8726593852043152,
0.451776921749115,
0.1867450326681137,
0.7437647581100464,
0.7438822388648987,
-0.24193178117275238,
0.33738699555397034,
-0.24422483146190643,
0.061100199818611145,
0.299001544713974,
0.2535644769668579,
0.3936179280281067,
-0.4471707046031952,
0.65522301197052,
0.31291285157203674,
-0.6056832671165466,
-0.7236350178718567,
0.06480722874403,
-1.267216682434082,
-0.4835644066333771,
1.417766809463501,
-0.37561917304992676,
-0.27016499638557434,
-0.3279074430465698,
-0.2062930464744568,
0.3071073591709137,
-0.33326512575149536,
0.7301018238067627,
0.6575177311897278,
-0.5746671557426453,
-0.3889941871166229,
-0.9849146008491516,
0.4525260329246521,
0.5046254396438599,
-0.9719002842903137,
-0.00642374437302351,
0.6396773457527161,
0.3816893994808197,
-0.018718913197517395,
0.7164227366447449,
-0.252191960811615,
0.20878437161445618,
-0.459077924489975,
0.059919700026512146,
-0.24776135385036469,
-0.1521565318107605,
-0.2987951636314392,
0.2932502329349518,
-0.1372624933719635,
0.019676389172673225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01705v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01705v2 | Beyond Behaviorist Representational Harms: A Plan for Measurement and Mitigation | 2024-01-25T00:54:10 | 2024-05-06T21:00:00 | Jennifer Chien, David Danks | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Algorithmic harms are commonly categorized as either allocative or
representational. This study specifically addresses the latter, focusing on an
examination of current definitions of representational harms to discern what is
included and what is not. This analysis motivates our expansion beyond
behavioral definitions to encompass harms to cognitive and affective states.
The paper outlines high-level requirements for measurement: identifying the
necessary expertise to implement this approach and illustrating it through a
case study. Our work highlights the unique vulnerabilities of large language
models to perpetrating representational harms, particularly when these harms go
unmeasured and unmitigated. The work concludes by presenting proposed
mitigations and delineating when to employ them. The overarching aim of this
research is to establish a framework for broadening the definition of
representational harms and to translate insights from fairness research into
practical measurement and mitigation praxis. | [
-0.20646783709526062,
-0.5745794773101807,
0.7626809477806091,
0.1191144809126854,
0.09444930404424667,
-0.051848601549863815,
0.194490447640419,
-0.5235379934310913,
0.5241453647613525,
0.6442848443984985,
-0.2517533302307129,
-0.0956074595451355,
-0.9408313632011414,
-0.5878799557685852,
-0.17117643356323242,
1.0825138092041016,
-0.24349908530712128,
-0.032211724668741226,
-0.19929754734039307,
-0.309110552072525,
-1.1077513694763184,
-0.8103668093681335,
-0.49784839153289795,
-0.11790002882480621,
0.7881293892860413,
0.09670577943325043,
0.8522229790687561,
0.4218813180923462,
0.5635602474212646,
0.3070046603679657,
-0.049752604216337204,
-0.367376446723938,
-0.3746497333049774,
0.052757155150175095,
-0.15600450336933136,
-0.7356489300727844,
-0.3808061480522156,
0.12781628966331482,
0.5827338695526123,
0.9918609857559204,
-0.3971877098083496,
0.05641039088368416,
-0.2599526643753052,
0.642581582069397,
-1.2200961112976074,
0.19063535332679749,
-0.4037615656852722,
0.4838794469833374,
-0.38820815086364746,
0.02763183042407036,
-0.24648314714431763,
-0.35130050778388977,
-0.33425524830818176,
-0.42496782541275024,
-0.4437209367752075,
0.0034514721482992172,
0.48564618825912476,
0.48580506443977356,
-0.7486854195594788,
-0.48904892802238464,
-0.9105374217033386,
0.8246449828147888,
-0.553926408290863,
0.20520420372486115,
0.29658687114715576,
0.2836202383041382,
-0.01962995156645775,
-0.37890952825546265,
-0.4707733988761902,
-0.33208784461021423,
-0.24289028346538544,
0.018707813695073128,
-0.6802377700805664,
0.4602033495903015,
0.4726278781890869,
0.36992064118385315,
-0.17957372963428497,
0.13066869974136353,
-0.40358927845954895,
-0.424028217792511,
1.0087915658950806,
0.7255668044090271,
0.5604771971702576,
-0.1619451940059662,
-0.13502372801303864,
-0.24276421964168549,
-0.6366720199584961,
-0.04895242676138878,
0.8127755522727966,
0.07143321633338928,
0.0027384955901652575,
0.7554305195808411,
0.5186166167259216,
0.17116869986057281,
-0.33985570073127747,
0.40011516213417053,
0.025620058178901672,
-0.27861741185188293,
-0.16521131992340088,
0.2787530720233917,
0.5558951497077942,
0.31023454666137695,
0.09513738006353378,
-0.10631334036588669,
-0.5216750502586365,
0.5567818284034729,
0.744998037815094,
-0.7260069847106934,
-0.08832249790430069,
0.08454510569572449,
-0.4177128076553345,
-0.3745873272418976,
-0.0032746312208473682,
-0.658841609954834,
-0.9419039487838745,
-0.27157798409461975,
0.5093792676925659,
-0.35783350467681885,
-0.6153581142425537,
0.16728095710277557,
-0.09977226704359055,
-0.03855622559785843,
-0.12880204617977142,
-0.8344082832336426,
0.3314070999622345,
0.7977590560913086,
0.7361652255058289,
-0.1610681414604187,
0.20325641334056854,
-0.05775237828493118,
0.178201824426651,
-0.8881583213806152,
0.6253647804260254,
-0.6349262595176697,
-0.6678453087806702,
0.14792793989181519,
-0.26325926184654236,
-0.12733621895313263,
-0.5619121193885803,
0.8666241765022278,
-0.16324661672115326,
-0.2136530727148056,
-0.5421549677848816,
-0.5180377960205078,
-0.4263111352920532,
0.23602604866027832,
-0.7462639808654785,
0.6341882944107056,
0.280191034078598,
-0.6960325837135315,
0.49463799595832825,
-1.0951160192489624,
-0.5950868129730225,
0.020876603201031685,
-0.38453176617622375,
-0.5162450075149536,
0.676814615726471,
-0.29894793033599854,
0.2862406373023987,
0.09900964051485062,
0.3890562653541565,
-0.26134487986564636,
-0.40468132495880127,
0.160710871219635,
-0.5183194279670715,
0.6064572930335999,
0.19627860188484192,
-0.37940120697021484,
0.8154121041297913,
-0.5130372047424316,
-0.015451151877641678,
0.11363448947668076,
-0.06458205729722977,
-0.4693889617919922,
0.24323830008506775,
0.17639340460300446,
0.21767354011535645,
0.09155573695898056,
-0.49720320105552673,
-0.2479894757270813,
-0.5680626034736633,
0.4867091178894043,
1.1239680051803589,
-0.08583375811576843,
0.5960648655891418,
-0.3777520954608917,
0.752901017665863,
0.08846655488014221,
0.45981279015541077,
-0.008823199197649956,
0.057270798832178116,
-0.5599831938743591,
-0.38945272564888,
0.01247370894998312,
0.41092225909233093,
-0.5843880772590637,
0.2912815511226654,
-0.25136786699295044,
-0.5633615255355835,
-0.13441339135169983,
-0.6124160885810852,
0.5271414518356323,
0.1502312868833542,
-0.04172753915190697,
-0.6567068099975586,
-0.4806738793849945,
-1.0309176445007324,
-0.3863280415534973,
-0.3244280517101288,
0.15189789235591888,
0.4534001052379608,
0.7089363932609558,
-0.20706050097942352,
0.5292980670928955,
-0.4164905846118927,
-0.6068686246871948,
0.31169992685317993,
0.06878011673688889,
-0.08390557765960693,
0.42906710505485535,
0.5569990873336792,
-0.4683345556259155,
0.11483710259199142,
-0.3009980022907257,
-0.8999355435371399,
0.05029847472906113,
-0.14134670794010162,
-0.10346834361553192,
0.013576717115938663,
0.4570515751838684,
-0.4836028218269348,
0.8118159770965576,
0.1984017789363861,
-0.4813709557056427,
0.7813102602958679,
-0.22431181371212006,
0.28216591477394104,
-0.5604181289672852,
0.1998140662908554,
-0.08447565138339996,
0.3094845712184906,
-0.5389472842216492,
0.39133432507514954,
-0.1586739867925644,
-0.36226311326026917,
-0.5684185028076172,
0.49167582392692566,
-0.20714034140110016,
-0.2825969457626343,
-0.15256990492343903,
-0.16965530812740326,
-0.3232720196247101,
0.24016450345516205,
-0.304431289434433,
0.7972656488418579,
0.3196919858455658,
-0.5539566278457642,
0.3196465075016022,
0.16972185671329498,
-0.16627991199493408,
1.1030174493789673,
-0.6727368831634521,
-0.10756376385688782,
-0.2929953932762146,
0.13405700027942657,
-0.9545252323150635,
0.02687162347137928,
0.5711525082588196,
-0.453410267829895,
-0.00519656902179122,
0.21601282060146332,
-0.5069996118545532,
-0.1427861750125885,
-0.3967055678367615,
0.723427414894104,
0.061142370104789734,
-0.24256856739521027,
0.6090984344482422,
0.7774119973182678,
0.11775603890419006,
-0.37028947472572327,
-0.7134857773780823,
0.43564480543136597,
-0.6851445436477661,
-0.47819989919662476,
0.3350569009780884,
0.030668864026665688,
-0.4560640752315521,
-0.304454505443573,
-0.1319078654050827,
0.09978621453046799,
0.3541772961616516,
0.5197165608406067,
-0.14710326492786407,
-0.09246358275413513,
0.3680099844932556,
-0.1395966112613678,
-0.3557946979999542,
0.6754003167152405,
0.14804525673389435,
0.28755897283554077,
0.14181210100650787,
-0.8192045092582703,
-0.05912087485194206,
0.9210493564605713,
0.31554946303367615,
-0.5237030982971191,
0.5028164982795715,
0.2613639533519745,
-0.6302319169044495,
0.3354388177394867,
-0.37369653582572937,
-0.20300306379795074,
-0.45885366201400757,
0.6197804808616638,
-0.24603092670440674,
-0.7641029953956604,
0.8034595847129822,
-0.08310326933860779,
0.07576528936624527,
0.188802108168602,
0.3516481816768646,
0.2087523192167282,
1.485799789428711,
0.666117787361145,
-0.15631940960884094,
0.6982681155204773,
0.013823773711919785,
0.6337454915046692,
-0.746882438659668,
-0.13439926505088806,
-0.6021151542663574,
-0.22717048227787018,
-0.7401071190834045,
-0.38578054308891296,
0.530053436756134,
-0.1260741949081421,
-0.809360921382904,
-0.08884741365909576,
-0.7320443987846375,
0.2617127001285553,
0.3109162747859955,
0.08875994384288788,
-0.004640148486942053,
0.018823539838194847,
0.19374939799308777,
-0.4422203004360199,
-0.2673802077770233,
-0.635362446308136,
1.018862247467041,
0.5037873387336731,
0.7222796082496643,
0.35377222299575806,
0.5470209717750549,
0.17642059922218323,
0.39244773983955383,
-1.0602341890335083,
0.46253150701522827,
0.25218164920806885,
-1.0848369598388672,
-0.3925037384033203,
-0.3710799217224121,
-1.2216835021972656,
0.35526466369628906,
0.16302362084388733,
-1.043967843055725,
0.24326521158218384,
0.1754506677389145,
-0.03564371541142464,
0.5504714846611023,
-0.4673028886318207,
1.120239019393921,
-0.32989758253097534,
-0.12716077268123627,
-0.5485963821411133,
-0.38437312841415405,
0.36581751704216003,
0.13860207796096802,
0.4056212902069092,
-0.017451195046305656,
-0.13128206133842468,
1.0465277433395386,
-0.29753100872039795,
0.8007964491844177,
-0.5213321447372437,
-0.3646988272666931,
0.13931553065776825,
0.5024728178977966,
0.3643442988395691,
-0.4088820815086365,
0.04037397727370262,
0.16763156652450562,
0.5012664198875427,
-0.653745174407959,
-0.5499987006187439,
0.47765621542930603,
-0.5167552828788757,
-0.4945465922355652,
-0.7718384861946106,
-0.558286190032959,
-0.3587999939918518,
0.1212034672498703,
-0.28945392370224,
0.02147522009909153,
-0.45634183287620544,
-0.2931445240974426,
0.8360879421234131,
-0.4522932767868042,
0.5500867962837219,
0.6152764558792114,
0.12965086102485657,
-0.13557440042495728,
1.1742984056472778,
0.0455004945397377,
0.014848364517092705,
-0.0853089988231659,
0.2184334546327591,
-0.3290956914424896,
-0.6467034220695496,
-0.1414458304643631,
-0.031877920031547546,
-0.8549956679344177,
-0.08796865493059158,
-0.30781471729278564,
0.16411587595939636,
-0.19950594007968903,
-0.047014061361551285,
-0.46719035506248474,
0.06054404005408287,
-0.20740263164043427,
-0.28504425287246704,
0.015860464423894882,
0.6969006657600403,
-0.3636786937713623,
0.4598527252674103,
-0.37745749950408936,
-0.004957252647727728,
-0.05049912631511688,
0.5079548358917236,
0.31022512912750244,
-0.31198057532310486,
-0.03266633674502373,
0.06892446428537369,
-0.578046441078186,
-1.013567566871643,
0.2361566424369812,
-0.16405963897705078,
0.7277750372886658,
0.42449915409088135,
0.27373284101486206,
0.6024977564811707,
-0.5190932154655457,
0.8028044104576111,
0.6989248991012573,
-0.9688431620597839,
0.523553729057312,
-0.2288060337305069,
-0.14740552008152008,
0.39752572774887085,
0.27738988399505615,
-0.9504297375679016,
-0.1346709132194519,
-0.48653459548950195,
-1.0308200120925903,
0.4497271180152893,
-0.03496676683425903,
0.885406494140625,
-0.3738037049770355,
0.37350937724113464,
-0.30811941623687744,
0.28835010528564453,
-0.6529124975204468,
-0.21901296079158783,
-0.006448107305914164,
-0.32703858613967896,
-0.06700742989778519,
-0.310226172208786,
-0.5738872289657593,
-0.08976776897907257,
0.514938473701477,
-0.10720044374465942,
0.47767385840415955,
-0.19361047446727753,
-0.18968410789966583,
-0.2996601164340973,
0.3020888566970825,
0.5641446709632874,
0.8243116140365601,
0.4063829779624939,
0.15204152464866638,
-0.0549127422273159,
-0.35787996649742126,
0.27687835693359375,
0.1592654585838318,
0.06000214070081711,
-0.6165662407875061,
0.5277801752090454,
0.8901923298835754,
0.17568740248680115,
-0.8771572709083557,
0.7602596879005432,
0.27504679560661316,
0.07047396898269653,
-0.43474850058555603,
-0.176742821931839,
-0.26442861557006836,
0.1417263150215149,
0.007836572825908661,
-0.1341848075389862,
0.47017771005630493,
-0.7187175154685974,
0.2555510699748993,
0.8143021464347839,
-1.0697273015975952,
-0.24096086621284485,
0.6433585286140442,
0.13712650537490845,
-0.36437225341796875,
0.4170433282852173,
-0.09078780561685562,
-0.3716443181037903,
0.6533029079437256,
0.2038760632276535,
0.7262868285179138,
-0.34570860862731934,
0.45481666922569275,
0.2036430537700653,
0.5348830223083496,
0.3189166784286499,
0.23522640764713287,
0.23215040564537048,
-0.6977991461753845,
-0.2208620309829712,
-0.3278912603855133,
-0.2774852514266968,
-0.07085851579904556,
-0.8008033633232117,
-0.32353484630584717,
-0.7247583866119385,
-0.08836104720830917,
0.2764812707901001,
-0.05703674629330635,
-0.3726254999637604,
0.2066493034362793,
0.06976582854986191,
0.23497679829597473,
-1.1538269519805908,
-0.09251123666763306,
0.6683213710784912,
-0.8225924372673035,
-0.7656370997428894,
-0.09971526265144348,
0.11906761676073074,
-1.103575587272644,
0.46448206901550293,
0.011959432624280453,
0.1797834187746048,
-0.5205999612808228,
-0.4695887267589569,
-0.6348364353179932,
0.6738447546958923,
0.7239580750465393,
-0.4317324757575989,
0.04128270968794823,
0.4305112063884735,
0.6423775553703308,
0.1820894330739975,
0.5334256887435913,
0.8165461421012878,
0.7452350854873657,
-0.0443996861577034,
-0.9044554233551025,
0.4387343227863312,
0.1881287693977356,
0.34183892607688904,
0.5749857425689697,
-0.29513782262802124,
0.6046074032783508,
-0.23290637135505676,
-0.5098361968994141,
-0.29584142565727234,
0.42691612243652344,
0.09804141521453857,
0.3473501205444336,
0.6439689993858337,
0.723564624786377,
0.5315365791320801,
-0.013895745389163494,
1.2419791221618652,
0.20043708384037018,
-0.04152093455195427,
0.7339435815811157,
-0.16544537246227264,
0.30278337001800537,
0.8179996609687805,
-0.6025014519691467,
-0.065001480281353,
0.808380126953125,
0.2373027354478836,
0.35766875743865967,
1.137669324874878,
-0.3928505480289459,
-0.059422314167022705,
-0.5414995551109314,
-0.15479660034179688,
0.2557801306247711,
0.46149325370788574,
-0.20535048842430115,
-0.17800389230251312,
0.43055784702301025,
0.21051888167858124,
0.5389469861984253,
-0.2791786193847656,
0.8303336501121521,
0.03504309430718422,
-0.5370053648948669,
0.24953192472457886,
0.24731305241584778,
0.8205505013465881,
-0.31659984588623047,
-0.20348632335662842,
-0.14052022993564606,
0.14942114055156708,
-0.2148839384317398,
-1.018844723701477,
0.7734928131103516,
-0.6411846280097961,
-0.13016194105148315,
-0.023757299408316612,
0.4158773422241211,
0.17611044645309448,
-0.5688328146934509,
0.5582567453384399,
0.3764398694038391,
0.21528495848178864,
-0.5244057178497314,
-0.8467923402786255,
0.4203283488750458,
-0.32185885310173035,
0.03173365443944931,
0.4165026545524597,
0.3681882917881012,
-0.6266370415687561,
0.6193352937698364,
0.2739432454109192,
0.18430152535438538,
0.01814957894384861,
0.11002178490161896,
0.812861442565918,
-0.6406075954437256,
-0.5846531987190247,
-0.5915979146957397,
0.5375924110412598,
0.11975142359733582,
-0.245840385556221,
0.18735027313232422,
0.38194966316223145,
0.6089706420898438,
0.3790150582790375,
0.5957176685333252,
-0.17426453530788422,
0.048895273357629776,
-0.16109327971935272,
0.4777161180973053,
-0.5921964645385742,
0.24025858938694,
-0.449247270822525,
-0.8021990060806274,
-0.2464374303817749,
0.745234489440918,
-0.48791781067848206,
0.3185085356235504,
0.4532374441623688,
0.8429054617881775,
0.14908289909362793,
-0.0769733190536499,
0.4621911346912384,
-0.0037792541552335024,
0.7302567362785339,
0.6643540859222412,
1.0892717838287354,
-0.456893652677536,
0.4365570843219757,
0.04065706953406334,
-0.38965678215026855,
0.10882221907377243,
-0.7190494537353516,
-0.6849687695503235,
-0.8399863243103027,
-0.4512016773223877,
-0.27484428882598877,
0.23583978414535522,
0.16344161331653595,
0.6483011841773987,
-0.6774409413337708,
-0.2434217780828476,
-0.11469195783138275,
0.38734421133995056,
-0.14025261998176575,
-0.2626907527446747,
0.51324462890625,
-0.11597169935703278,
-0.3109177350997925,
-0.10893898457288742,
0.12251521646976471,
-0.2105230689048767,
-0.6103770136833191,
-0.05439634993672371,
0.2652725577354431,
0.3324826955795288,
0.7643488049507141,
0.11010806262493134,
-0.707789957523346,
-0.7312796115875244,
-0.589250385761261,
0.006140103098005056,
-0.01262935996055603,
1.1191703081130981,
-0.18243896961212158,
0.45251578092575073,
0.23609080910682678,
0.5381150841712952,
0.17158730328083038,
-0.5022108554840088,
0.43299543857574463,
-0.8596996665000916,
0.11700490862131119,
0.665534257888794,
0.3123125731945038,
0.18947692215442657,
-0.732878565788269,
0.3787549138069153,
-0.16302984952926636,
-0.21116986870765686,
-1.1021602153778076,
0.6645933389663696,
-0.5379330515861511,
-0.3878509998321533,
0.7372444272041321,
-0.16154702007770538,
0.07576996833086014,
0.19474320113658905,
-0.45064204931259155,
0.08906387537717819,
-0.1756724864244461,
0.8812193870544434,
0.677710235118866,
-0.20546521246433258,
-0.2649134695529938,
-0.7322578430175781,
0.3313167095184326,
0.49360689520835876,
-0.9958329796791077,
0.2162606120109558,
0.7703282237052917,
0.1683962345123291,
0.33807051181793213,
0.8171006441116333,
-0.5120757222175598,
0.11313535273075104,
0.03787992149591446,
0.416908860206604,
0.0978950709104538,
0.13693490624427795,
-0.4471927583217621,
0.0021084139589220285,
-0.10316202044487,
-0.19498591125011444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13867v1 | Unmasking and Quantifying Racial Bias of Large Language Models in Medical Report Generation | 2024-01-25T00:34:16 | 2024-01-25T00:34:16 | Yifan Yang, Xiaoyu Liu, Qiao Jin, Furong Huang, Zhiyong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models like GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4 hold promise for
healthcare professionals, but they may inadvertently inherit biases during
their training, potentially affecting their utility in medical applications.
Despite few attempts in the past, the precise impact and extent of these biases
remain uncertain. Through both qualitative and quantitative analyses, we find
that these models tend to project higher costs and longer hospitalizations for
White populations and exhibit optimistic views in challenging medical scenarios
with much higher survival rates. These biases, which mirror real-world
healthcare disparities, are evident in the generation of patient backgrounds,
the association of specific diseases with certain races, and disparities in
treatment recommendations, etc. Our findings underscore the critical need for
future research to address and mitigate biases in language models, especially
in critical healthcare applications, to ensure fair and accurate outcomes for
all patients. | [
-0.18180479109287262,
-0.24051134288311005,
0.6818272471427917,
0.01875126361846924,
0.028693921864032745,
0.27659061551094055,
-0.18588456511497498,
-0.7284639477729797,
0.24561867117881775,
0.3391059637069702,
-0.3819518983364105,
-0.19746620953083038,
-0.8527613282203674,
-0.15021821856498718,
-0.1988578885793686,
1.2933650016784668,
0.1466159075498581,
0.4349547326564789,
0.06780744343996048,
-0.12230435013771057,
-0.2471267133951187,
-0.7803575992584229,
-0.5264286994934082,
-0.29997894167900085,
0.453480988740921,
0.04124471917748451,
0.9365066885948181,
0.5060427188873291,
0.29184219241142273,
0.13088972866535187,
-0.026903502643108368,
-0.24831146001815796,
-0.5226020216941833,
0.150022491812706,
-0.023519126698374748,
-0.28052666783332825,
-0.3760160505771637,
0.07570719718933105,
0.46711084246635437,
0.9206452369689941,
-0.06183866783976555,
0.23897171020507812,
-0.12442176789045334,
0.5251651406288147,
-0.7488567233085632,
0.12032696604728699,
-0.469357430934906,
0.16284073889255524,
-0.417348176240921,
0.014445453882217407,
-0.25816652178764343,
-0.5815219879150391,
0.18421347439289093,
-0.4487386643886566,
0.5634059906005859,
-0.14164549112319946,
0.5918366312980652,
0.127669095993042,
-0.7289317846298218,
-0.22953854501247406,
-0.8908913135528564,
0.6610801219940186,
-0.9392133355140686,
0.23980072140693665,
0.3129408657550812,
0.3644753694534302,
-0.111173115670681,
-0.825264573097229,
-0.45473289489746094,
-0.2780471444129944,
-0.13336145877838135,
0.08909742534160614,
-0.06657665222883224,
0.15215741097927094,
0.7009377479553223,
0.4807564616203308,
-0.5357484221458435,
0.2609389126300812,
-0.7446010708808899,
-0.4302861988544464,
0.5356870889663696,
0.2977568507194519,
0.7021023631095886,
0.02678287960588932,
0.2296096235513687,
0.19583892822265625,
-0.8063309788703918,
-0.3035203814506531,
0.4304957687854767,
0.15276272594928741,
-0.290036141872406,
0.4915774166584015,
-0.1542806625366211,
0.4199085235595703,
-0.40864425897598267,
-0.11376532167196274,
0.3872949779033661,
-0.3500784933567047,
-0.0021199160255491734,
0.2533608376979828,
0.6916903853416443,
0.469725638628006,
0.4703940749168396,
-0.036259137094020844,
0.07901414483785629,
0.340835839509964,
0.30263492465019226,
-0.9760396480560303,
-0.2328236699104309,
0.11039196699857712,
-0.48329514265060425,
-0.3066462278366089,
-0.18364931643009186,
-1.0449047088623047,
-0.6267231702804565,
-0.01903514750301838,
-0.11763773113489151,
-0.14201565086841583,
-0.44680705666542053,
0.03797558695077896,
-0.07366224378347397,
0.1023467630147934,
0.06942193955183029,
-1.1662229299545288,
0.1949712336063385,
0.6389237642288208,
0.7191520929336548,
-0.0051746428944170475,
0.06634616106748581,
-0.31158626079559326,
0.12004601955413818,
-0.19278259575366974,
0.3876567482948303,
-0.5572548508644104,
-0.39232829213142395,
0.25690165162086487,
-0.16748137772083282,
0.2319670468568802,
-0.5807479023933411,
0.5550395250320435,
-0.07415083050727844,
0.26887214183807373,
-0.5323988795280457,
-0.29605501890182495,
0.10952607542276382,
-0.0669676810503006,
-0.6331088542938232,
0.6710545420646667,
0.5586369633674622,
-0.9904384613037109,
0.6835078001022339,
-0.643040657043457,
-0.49613386392593384,
0.23120616376399994,
-0.5121714472770691,
-0.6302425861358643,
0.43276408314704895,
0.35889628529548645,
0.21968719363212585,
-0.6258904933929443,
0.31512510776519775,
-0.4054029583930969,
-0.3301176130771637,
-0.09958649426698685,
-0.2292478382587433,
1.0329300165176392,
0.2613450288772583,
-0.7880668044090271,
-0.06278715282678604,
-0.5696141123771667,
-0.21411269903182983,
0.4958967864513397,
0.11627668142318726,
-0.5085863471031189,
-0.03753041476011276,
-0.0904109850525856,
0.26802968978881836,
-0.1980452686548233,
-0.6425630450248718,
-0.013917636126279831,
-0.32847437262535095,
0.4440830647945404,
0.5548566579818726,
-0.09786158055067062,
0.3253454267978668,
-0.16101232171058655,
0.891402006149292,
0.13619469106197357,
0.38010236620903015,
-0.15765555202960968,
-0.5899375081062317,
-0.5107091665267944,
-0.20104482769966125,
0.448998361825943,
0.07491008937358856,
-0.4277099072933197,
-0.25569388270378113,
-0.14395610988140106,
-0.39291366934776306,
-0.7495564222335815,
-0.41175422072410583,
0.300632506608963,
0.7811568379402161,
0.19478553533554077,
-0.16595494747161865,
-0.45233649015426636,
-1.1726150512695312,
-0.28901487588882446,
-0.1596541851758957,
-0.13835236430168152,
0.21074122190475464,
0.5686406493186951,
-0.4027879238128662,
0.7075868844985962,
-0.6247180700302124,
0.06974402815103531,
0.028171729296445847,
0.12296043336391449,
-0.1390255093574524,
0.5366900563240051,
0.8117902874946594,
-0.7152856588363647,
-0.4738083779811859,
-0.08527292311191559,
-0.6008267998695374,
-0.31560811400413513,
0.04217594116926193,
0.06589639186859131,
0.006990640424191952,
0.37036192417144775,
-0.2806932330131531,
0.5598790645599365,
0.7967067956924438,
-0.32252687215805054,
0.7761774063110352,
0.05037243291735649,
0.12682655453681946,
-0.9313592314720154,
0.1311112493276596,
0.3090427815914154,
-0.039773087948560715,
-0.6542450785636902,
-0.04626592621207237,
0.03288513794541359,
-0.056650806218385696,
-0.08564797043800354,
0.5556305050849915,
-0.6601768136024475,
-0.17432822287082672,
-0.15175019204616547,
-0.28771767020225525,
-0.058475200086832047,
0.09852630645036697,
-0.1411188840866089,
0.8230478763580322,
0.317404568195343,
-0.13429535925388336,
-0.016455139964818954,
-0.03748583048582077,
-0.5140942931175232,
0.22614599764347076,
-0.6309182643890381,
-0.010463908314704895,
-0.13108228147029877,
0.4000591039657593,
-0.5882824659347534,
-0.19954966008663177,
0.07402961701154709,
-0.5421956181526184,
0.13019907474517822,
-0.2263752818107605,
-0.4622231721878052,
-0.7068421244621277,
-0.08587950468063354,
0.8573234677314758,
0.7488694190979004,
-0.16112400591373444,
0.1823030710220337,
0.8118611574172974,
-0.5565226674079895,
-0.5134673714637756,
-0.6918023228645325,
-0.2008446455001831,
-0.18006737530231476,
-0.2879803776741028,
0.11808305978775024,
0.0379878468811512,
-0.5317277908325195,
-0.2235592007637024,
-0.08977178484201431,
-0.18491315841674805,
0.06667099893093109,
0.20147839188575745,
0.3634336590766907,
-0.25199562311172485,
-0.012090706266462803,
0.0917942151427269,
0.18318024277687073,
0.4346001446247101,
-0.27066633105278015,
0.4036436080932617,
0.2795848250389099,
-0.42147326469421387,
0.1160183772444725,
0.5559958219528198,
0.8223590850830078,
-0.3983796238899231,
0.8203031420707703,
0.4860781133174896,
-0.5470262765884399,
0.13789694011211395,
-0.7330560684204102,
-0.39300060272216797,
-0.38733765482902527,
0.7015438675880432,
0.05338982865214348,
-1.1532893180847168,
0.6822330355644226,
0.098788321018219,
0.09002716094255447,
0.45177793502807617,
0.9258520007133484,
0.24700887501239777,
1.324231505393982,
0.6070418357849121,
-0.03281573951244354,
0.3252832591533661,
0.04287261888384819,
0.3173988461494446,
-0.7897741794586182,
-0.23618142306804657,
-0.6540836095809937,
0.01437779888510704,
-0.8803526759147644,
-0.22069096565246582,
0.6598480939865112,
-0.4379705786705017,
-0.21173414587974548,
-0.5293657779693604,
-0.6616199016571045,
0.5209721326828003,
0.577704668045044,
0.06368236988782883,
0.15768977999687195,
-0.14748793840408325,
-0.15707123279571533,
-0.3257063627243042,
-0.6377283930778503,
-0.19590969383716583,
1.3232247829437256,
0.5407187342643738,
0.35354048013687134,
-0.06238873675465584,
0.336203932762146,
0.24461984634399414,
0.6183416247367859,
-0.43482205271720886,
0.023381343111395836,
-0.02935962751507759,
-0.9995899796485901,
-0.1310974806547165,
-0.6050909161567688,
-0.8591317534446716,
0.20993486046791077,
-0.11300195008516312,
-0.5181195139884949,
0.125132754445076,
0.40336111187934875,
-0.35180383920669556,
0.33475351333618164,
-0.7758917212486267,
0.9212482571601868,
-0.1744614988565445,
-0.11134130507707596,
0.05536795035004616,
-0.659825325012207,
0.8494815826416016,
-0.4203450083732605,
0.27844083309173584,
-0.3548191785812378,
0.31365159153938293,
0.7258791923522949,
-0.5381951928138733,
0.6281776428222656,
-0.366717666387558,
-0.21562035381793976,
-0.13190996646881104,
0.05997638776898384,
0.3087349832057953,
0.05058480426669121,
-0.0701507106423378,
0.41854774951934814,
-0.052811816334724426,
-0.6991400122642517,
-0.3795676529407501,
0.5615226030349731,
-0.6185998320579529,
-0.36458730697631836,
-0.5686426758766174,
-0.7172698974609375,
-0.5240511894226074,
0.2626432180404663,
0.3843589425086975,
0.5009569525718689,
-0.11902395635843277,
-0.40065282583236694,
0.3363257348537445,
-0.5051379799842834,
-0.07503095269203186,
0.4634658992290497,
-0.06421387940645218,
-0.21092478930950165,
0.5982027053833008,
0.10486476868391037,
0.39569470286369324,
-0.20964278280735016,
0.3773842453956604,
-0.12942200899124146,
-0.9290934205055237,
-0.200118750333786,
0.5337317585945129,
-0.31838729977607727,
-0.03379319608211517,
-0.7034598588943481,
-0.31586459279060364,
-0.5997467637062073,
-0.07440262287855148,
-0.2683309018611908,
-0.4112646281719208,
-0.11122100800275803,
-0.1980130821466446,
0.17352962493896484,
0.8406110405921936,
0.11174925416707993,
0.33519303798675537,
-0.6509934663772583,
0.23243699967861176,
0.18202653527259827,
0.41227102279663086,
0.1492970734834671,
-0.5361977815628052,
-0.5370305776596069,
0.22178654372692108,
-0.18746212124824524,
-0.7744439840316772,
0.38795557618141174,
-0.41901955008506775,
0.41234293580055237,
0.22217093408107758,
0.02928418479859829,
0.39401891827583313,
-0.8031784892082214,
0.8083950281143188,
0.47922056913375854,
-0.6671754717826843,
0.37616148591041565,
-0.6513073444366455,
0.367160439491272,
0.576176643371582,
0.5600146651268005,
-0.5451653003692627,
-0.5858120322227478,
-0.6096189022064209,
-0.8127775192260742,
0.5850921273231506,
0.02478628419339657,
0.01796874776482582,
-0.09298934787511826,
0.35545802116394043,
0.10404884070158005,
0.041231635957956314,
-0.6997954249382019,
-0.36558598279953003,
-0.14289167523384094,
-0.30397698283195496,
-0.018482713028788567,
-0.7235855460166931,
-0.13954858481884003,
-0.24512438476085663,
0.3761848211288452,
-0.14873802661895752,
0.15985189378261566,
-0.041209377348423004,
0.07280775159597397,
0.027478821575641632,
0.3081202805042267,
1.0080419778823853,
0.8603406548500061,
-0.21335749328136444,
-0.03562215343117714,
-0.07138707488775253,
-0.882212221622467,
0.23947718739509583,
0.2375830113887787,
-0.16196127235889435,
0.037378691136837006,
0.3938911259174347,
0.7223121523857117,
-0.10748477280139923,
-0.6625970005989075,
0.6489948034286499,
-0.041928332298994064,
-0.18244856595993042,
-0.27163761854171753,
-0.23850387334823608,
-0.013583716005086899,
-0.007627599872648716,
0.21857485175132751,
-0.1863124519586563,
0.4230847954750061,
-0.6389943361282349,
0.008987750858068466,
0.43179380893707275,
-0.38815081119537354,
-0.5206199884414673,
0.8285788297653198,
0.4636921286582947,
0.09661299735307693,
0.6704928874969482,
0.05846311151981354,
-0.606347918510437,
0.574971616268158,
0.5765395760536194,
0.8608084917068481,
-0.31217628717422485,
0.20834429562091827,
0.41103115677833557,
0.4270230531692505,
-0.1821097582578659,
-0.13266044855117798,
0.4524916708469391,
-0.6283531785011292,
-0.6611183285713196,
-0.41601747274398804,
-0.3655095398426056,
0.2698971629142761,
-0.6742033958435059,
0.041703883558511734,
-0.2567852735519409,
-0.3788279891014099,
0.3621028661727905,
-0.2250889241695404,
-0.4481436610221863,
0.2512606382369995,
0.5518734455108643,
0.6273443698883057,
-0.9343380928039551,
0.6501842141151428,
0.40003708004951477,
-0.3947547674179077,
-0.686674177646637,
0.23821014165878296,
0.24615859985351562,
-0.7750577330589294,
0.7542684078216553,
-0.030751081183552742,
0.23905383050441742,
-0.26417219638824463,
-0.1911715865135193,
-0.47053807973861694,
0.5815454125404358,
0.8181682229042053,
-0.7036210298538208,
-0.5004879236221313,
0.359131395816803,
0.5596836805343628,
-0.30487069487571716,
0.5156311392784119,
0.8871397972106934,
0.25823959708213806,
-0.28712785243988037,
-1.251583218574524,
0.17810603976249695,
-0.02171078883111477,
0.054228488355875015,
0.41628360748291016,
-0.45096680521965027,
0.8204069137573242,
-0.4595719873905182,
-0.04263482242822647,
-0.43740007281303406,
0.220468208193779,
0.2090533971786499,
0.3873288631439209,
0.318880558013916,
0.31192848086357117,
0.7264887690544128,
-0.19074074923992157,
1.3744078874588013,
-0.16877129673957825,
0.1755858212709427,
1.0957783460617065,
-0.5149426460266113,
-0.08296914398670197,
0.3217296600341797,
-0.2645246088504791,
0.2785751223564148,
0.3928832709789276,
0.064224012196064,
0.28013575077056885,
0.55232173204422,
-0.4230882525444031,
0.2797297239303589,
-0.3541705906391144,
-0.574168860912323,
0.32506948709487915,
0.3023231029510498,
-0.5970078110694885,
0.01467693131417036,
-0.10273432731628418,
0.40301287174224854,
-0.020742027088999748,
-0.3581591844558716,
0.5794752836227417,
0.01836288534104824,
-0.5977030992507935,
0.398204505443573,
-0.2625593841075897,
0.5768306255340576,
-0.6150820255279541,
-0.11332571506500244,
-0.3775745630264282,
-0.06258642673492432,
-0.17264549434185028,
-0.3729715049266815,
0.25575119256973267,
0.07585886120796204,
-0.4891488254070282,
0.07891075313091278,
0.4702533185482025,
-0.3665831983089447,
-0.5975266098976135,
0.1898827999830246,
0.40651339292526245,
-0.08165453374385834,
-0.20586667954921722,
-0.5883744955062866,
0.30331161618232727,
0.2869272828102112,
0.07364603877067566,
0.49286407232284546,
0.37524014711380005,
-0.22939656674861908,
0.4794660806655884,
0.47943681478500366,
0.7860044240951538,
0.23940910398960114,
0.37689781188964844,
0.6898684501647949,
-0.7082524299621582,
-0.47881293296813965,
-1.0657780170440674,
0.37522614002227783,
-0.22736547887325287,
-0.11458232998847961,
0.5756187438964844,
0.6914923191070557,
0.7055566906929016,
0.08818293362855911,
1.0314048528671265,
0.23654776811599731,
0.6824032664299011,
-0.33939260244369507,
0.8646720051765442,
-0.40538445115089417,
0.019692854955792427,
-0.4803007245063782,
-0.6288073062896729,
-0.3456830084323883,
0.255487322807312,
-0.26474687457084656,
0.5103635787963867,
0.6842005848884583,
0.5270035862922668,
0.027272013947367668,
-0.0014868335565552115,
0.22691772878170013,
0.32077497243881226,
0.5234312415122986,
0.3639295697212219,
0.6240707039833069,
-0.11588083952665329,
0.23758649826049805,
-0.17782849073410034,
-0.43200477957725525,
-0.15880823135375977,
-0.5946212410926819,
-0.6482397317886353,
-0.23747123777866364,
-0.4600822627544403,
-0.4076448976993561,
0.07465440034866333,
0.5392635464668274,
0.7495424151420593,
-0.9431119561195374,
-0.003915286622941494,
0.26883071660995483,
-0.10043130815029144,
0.06862848997116089,
-0.23635095357894897,
0.2982940077781677,
0.03365297615528107,
-0.7001827359199524,
-0.21159586310386658,
0.2508273124694824,
0.2346922606229782,
-0.3763580024242401,
0.06888940185308456,
0.3015071749687195,
-0.018942371010780334,
0.5706791877746582,
0.40948551893234253,
-0.6425417065620422,
-0.04845695570111275,
-0.41616544127464294,
-0.2574349343776703,
0.0506412647664547,
1.2737654447555542,
-0.5873379707336426,
0.3678895831108093,
0.07268355041742325,
0.6971874237060547,
0.46104001998901367,
-0.20673446357250214,
0.9494324326515198,
-0.46012258529663086,
0.1960347443819046,
0.5835134387016296,
0.5089870691299438,
0.4327833652496338,
-0.37286514043807983,
0.5804258584976196,
0.20971651375293732,
-0.7012730836868286,
-1.335959553718567,
0.19334542751312256,
-0.5793439745903015,
-0.16475336253643036,
1.0307689905166626,
0.1875680387020111,
0.1744993031024933,
-0.2145082801580429,
-0.0290676262229681,
0.33549055457115173,
-0.32705745100975037,
0.8718411326408386,
0.556193470954895,
-0.10304385423660278,
-0.12626174092292786,
-1.1596770286560059,
0.8678841590881348,
0.4683822691440582,
-0.8370369076728821,
0.37993916869163513,
0.7445665597915649,
0.36389780044555664,
-0.12322333455085754,
0.9938461780548096,
-0.4359089136123657,
0.34943845868110657,
-0.05385860055685043,
0.2739749848842621,
0.025697441771626472,
0.01912003755569458,
-0.36638128757476807,
-0.055567704141139984,
0.059527914971113205,
0.10460405796766281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13849v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13849v1 | TPD: Enhancing Student Language Model Reasoning via Principle Discovery and Guidance | 2024-01-24T23:11:33 | 2024-01-24T23:11:33 | Haorui Wang, Rongzhi Zhang, Yinghao Li, Lingkai Kong, Yuchen Zhuang, Xiusi Chen, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently showcased remarkable reasoning
abilities. However, larger models often surpass their smaller counterparts in
reasoning tasks, posing the challenge of effectively transferring these
capabilities from larger models. Existing approaches heavily rely on extensive
fine-tuning data or continuous interactions with a superior teacher LLM during
inference. We introduce a principle-based teacher-student framework called
``Teaching via Principle Discovery'' (TPD) to address these limitations.
Inspired by human learning mechanisms, TPD mimics the interaction between a
teacher and a student using a principle-based approach. The teacher LLM
generates problem-solving instructions and corrective principles based on the
student LLM's errors. These principles guide the refinement of instructions and
the selection of instructive examples from a validation set. This enables the
student model to learn from both the teacher's guidance and its own mistakes.
Once the student model begins making inferences, TPD requires no further
intervention from the teacher LLM or humans. Through extensive experiments
across eight reasoning tasks, we demonstrate the effectiveness of TPD. Compared
to standard chain-of-thought prompting, TPD significantly improves the student
model's performance, achieving $6.2\%$ improvement on average. | [
0.013782977126538754,
-0.623795747756958,
0.9680575728416443,
-0.011953001841902733,
-0.2077764868736267,
0.1442694365978241,
-0.3449508547782898,
0.11581173539161682,
-0.15601007640361786,
0.7513932585716248,
-0.286436527967453,
-0.4917905926704407,
-0.27909934520721436,
-0.3484383225440979,
-0.23957572877407074,
0.36860620975494385,
-0.02355979010462761,
0.4095555543899536,
-0.07218533009290695,
0.4244527816772461,
-0.41721105575561523,
-0.3050207197666168,
-0.8627188205718994,
-0.6434600949287415,
0.16422529518604279,
0.9875372648239136,
0.3485794961452484,
0.6782726049423218,
0.18929515779018402,
0.18388143181800842,
-0.16387607157230377,
0.2814370393753052,
-0.25396427512168884,
-0.04457060620188713,
-0.7191308736801147,
-0.7350583076477051,
-0.22613970935344696,
-0.010219424031674862,
0.6563699841499329,
1.1477407217025757,
-0.36844685673713684,
-0.40045294165611267,
0.11484839022159576,
0.5956571102142334,
-0.445264995098114,
0.1151779294013977,
-0.3505004048347473,
0.10712897032499313,
-0.06931761652231216,
-0.33140432834625244,
-0.6846781969070435,
-0.41570335626602173,
0.3564062714576721,
-0.46737825870513916,
0.6073005199432373,
0.05482269078493118,
0.6606264114379883,
0.06701615452766418,
-0.5267224907875061,
-0.08296182006597519,
-0.6371897459030151,
0.7693032026290894,
-0.6821295619010925,
0.5342718958854675,
0.4297013282775879,
0.2125970721244812,
-0.4729662537574768,
-0.5967305302619934,
-0.6340700387954712,
-0.30138900876045227,
0.08910353481769562,
-0.3031693398952484,
0.3601590394973755,
0.3896239995956421,
0.4669802188873291,
0.17916478216648102,
-0.2721966505050659,
0.001957337837666273,
-0.27752989530563354,
-0.09233420342206955,
0.40423649549484253,
0.016694169491529465,
0.258204847574234,
-0.39745816588401794,
-0.2531799376010895,
-0.31658560037612915,
-0.8891879320144653,
0.050411004573106766,
0.12327667325735092,
0.36185717582702637,
0.12765416502952576,
0.5579028129577637,
-0.09806619584560394,
0.63731449842453,
0.038980770856142044,
-0.3353886008262634,
-0.24457398056983948,
-0.14519843459129333,
-0.13347095251083374,
0.16646356880664825,
0.48502135276794434,
0.34181177616119385,
0.27090463042259216,
-0.17301781475543976,
-0.1418391317129135,
0.14973033964633942,
-0.00882378127425909,
-0.7203420996665955,
-0.620000422000885,
-0.12020570039749146,
-0.3580954074859619,
-0.43817394971847534,
-0.04458397254347801,
-0.8374059200286865,
-0.5172853469848633,
-0.5290772318840027,
0.551424503326416,
-0.527837336063385,
-0.4625394642353058,
0.5732735991477966,
-0.20903781056404114,
0.13974161446094513,
0.5005744695663452,
-0.9977362155914307,
0.4350228011608124,
0.7628520727157593,
0.4674406349658966,
0.15993453562259674,
-0.2718811333179474,
-0.49209725856781006,
0.557956337928772,
-0.5720890760421753,
0.7217705845832825,
-0.8085265159606934,
-0.6146578192710876,
-0.17513327300548553,
-0.15653012692928314,
-0.12013720721006393,
-0.4500916004180908,
0.8407707810401917,
-0.15043669939041138,
0.33993005752563477,
-0.597068727016449,
-0.9110418558120728,
-0.2525511384010315,
0.05923815816640854,
-0.15379612147808075,
0.8713434338569641,
-0.11733046174049377,
-0.4448094367980957,
0.4085879325866699,
-0.8180609345436096,
-0.3855894207954407,
0.003801564686000347,
-0.3149920403957367,
-0.058657027781009674,
0.14257484674453735,
0.25692060589790344,
0.5282268524169922,
-0.5172857642173767,
0.6131505370140076,
-0.3233899772167206,
-0.15088403224945068,
-0.06283583492040634,
-0.18900257349014282,
0.8118614554405212,
0.04199676960706711,
-0.4198986291885376,
0.19908243417739868,
-0.7595459222793579,
-0.07272415608167648,
0.24293281137943268,
-0.17122644186019897,
-0.42547351121902466,
0.16262787580490112,
-0.31876900792121887,
-0.04701612889766693,
-0.14205549657344818,
-0.4483514130115509,
0.5418087840080261,
-0.22203148901462555,
0.6164161562919617,
0.8443080186843872,
0.2740504741668701,
0.5914345979690552,
-0.35253649950027466,
0.304076224565506,
-0.24756719172000885,
-0.12257429212331772,
-0.3030816912651062,
-0.362295001745224,
-1.0491878986358643,
-0.015474987216293812,
0.22664232552051544,
0.26595360040664673,
-0.6950036287307739,
0.21085874736309052,
-0.13138392567634583,
-0.3037634491920471,
-0.2405634969472885,
0.32856255769729614,
0.3675924241542816,
0.997211217880249,
0.38958367705345154,
-0.2773944139480591,
-0.46174874901771545,
-0.5802100300788879,
-0.13472230732440948,
-0.3578040897846222,
-0.09640689939260483,
0.2083333134651184,
0.28532326221466064,
0.03556641563773155,
0.9442117810249329,
-0.7469075918197632,
-0.07742688804864883,
-0.4567214846611023,
0.22525550425052643,
-0.027317479252815247,
0.811458945274353,
0.3834211230278015,
-0.5652919411659241,
-0.3618510365486145,
-0.30525442957878113,
-0.6928936243057251,
-0.24388322234153748,
-0.2097601443529129,
-0.36138904094696045,
0.09098464250564575,
0.5239889025688171,
-0.4853498041629791,
0.21830789744853973,
-0.09772688150405884,
-0.6340484023094177,
0.4570627212524414,
-0.33657243847846985,
-0.09030123054981232,
-1.116419792175293,
-0.34787631034851074,
0.09755342453718185,
-0.19800452888011932,
-0.5475529432296753,
0.30952638387680054,
0.14433157444000244,
-0.33710184693336487,
-0.09736066311597824,
0.42506930232048035,
-0.09065672755241394,
0.12269946932792664,
-0.37471064925193787,
0.02028554119169712,
0.22061920166015625,
0.3283303380012512,
0.31268391013145447,
0.6962037086486816,
0.7561172842979431,
-0.6504955887794495,
0.33366063237190247,
0.015207278542220592,
-0.2756255567073822,
0.5977224111557007,
-0.6682876348495483,
0.3253207802772522,
0.11452871561050415,
0.2706197500228882,
-0.8587262630462646,
-0.2222096472978592,
0.3023822605609894,
-0.16230973601341248,
0.462584525346756,
-0.30799633264541626,
-0.7860599756240845,
-0.14588500559329987,
-0.1709439903497696,
-0.10996420681476593,
0.4336042106151581,
-0.953825831413269,
0.8081870079040527,
-0.06719962507486343,
-0.035775862634181976,
-0.30532556772232056,
-0.3569117784500122,
0.35068169236183167,
-0.06047552451491356,
-0.6942388415336609,
0.23322294652462006,
-0.020087772980332375,
-0.32454657554626465,
-0.013908687978982925,
-0.32184645533561707,
-0.04108763486146927,
0.326554536819458,
0.019956009462475777,
0.09157000482082367,
-0.09471136331558228,
0.4712708294391632,
0.2173731029033661,
-0.11926387995481491,
0.30424249172210693,
-0.4881601631641388,
0.741387128829956,
-0.10173003375530243,
-0.3168829381465912,
-0.5043138265609741,
0.11553715914487839,
0.29485297203063965,
-0.22479596734046936,
0.5502669215202332,
0.13053077459335327,
-0.33214041590690613,
-0.5452449917793274,
-0.5584785342216492,
-0.6368449330329895,
-0.506619393825531,
0.03544019162654877,
-0.6296200156211853,
-0.46804866194725037,
-0.003066295525059104,
-0.3435588777065277,
-0.06640543043613434,
-0.05601338669657707,
-0.025671038776636124,
-0.19279775023460388,
0.8747372031211853,
0.7259939312934875,
0.031608011573553085,
0.3862191438674927,
-0.34317997097969055,
0.19222131371498108,
-0.610008180141449,
-0.41048383712768555,
-0.5321621894836426,
0.1885857731103897,
-0.2527502775192261,
-0.6563368439674377,
0.06403949856758118,
0.49541863799095154,
-0.3656052052974701,
0.20518143475055695,
-0.2512222230434418,
0.6377473473548889,
0.9016508460044861,
0.5106250047683716,
0.3739444613456726,
-0.013224764727056026,
-0.4880475699901581,
-0.147661492228508,
-0.6074836254119873,
-0.8410030603408813,
1.4141055345535278,
0.31381773948669434,
0.8572705388069153,
0.3599497079849243,
0.9432787299156189,
0.06563486158847809,
-0.007721163332462311,
-0.6484893560409546,
1.0697249174118042,
0.06435518711805344,
-0.4502940773963928,
-0.27722203731536865,
-0.5091118216514587,
-0.3673152029514313,
0.3488784432411194,
-0.22194357216358185,
-0.6527480483055115,
0.006210976280272007,
0.21205049753189087,
0.08225340396165848,
0.45976758003234863,
-0.895289957523346,
0.7478796243667603,
-0.1716563105583191,
-0.6213510632514954,
-0.6345959901809692,
-0.36195969581604004,
0.2451537400484085,
0.007863608188927174,
-0.11839127540588379,
0.11476996541023254,
0.1313302367925644,
0.6453990936279297,
-0.5939176678657532,
1.05478036403656,
-0.39403587579727173,
-0.3391267955303192,
0.17178265750408173,
0.25815683603286743,
0.5307083129882812,
-0.07185245305299759,
-0.047748371958732605,
-0.5018355846405029,
-0.30902400612831116,
-0.45294132828712463,
-0.7835171222686768,
0.5234225392341614,
-0.47908955812454224,
-1.1756625175476074,
-0.15729893743991852,
-0.7172701358795166,
-0.3279332220554352,
0.4200952649116516,
-0.29816579818725586,
0.4821993410587311,
0.23589162528514862,
0.14614544808864594,
0.9693471789360046,
-0.11467062681913376,
0.3507993221282959,
0.7930975556373596,
-0.39912518858909607,
0.04496201500296593,
1.0353083610534668,
-0.09095895290374756,
0.4557330310344696,
0.5559823513031006,
0.7324093580245972,
-0.4283830523490906,
-0.42420467734336853,
-0.3081788122653961,
0.3735969364643097,
-0.9521686434745789,
0.22644208371639252,
-0.5804969072341919,
0.2373608648777008,
-0.5796900987625122,
-0.2644590735435486,
-0.12487612664699554,
-0.7241183519363403,
-0.23733504116535187,
-0.3021436631679535,
0.053487904369831085,
0.37499624490737915,
-0.18106286227703094,
0.32379230856895447,
-0.3745201826095581,
0.35868319869041443,
0.7699962854385376,
0.1669047474861145,
0.01747618429362774,
-0.6429947018623352,
0.3606053292751312,
-0.0320463702082634,
-0.6031787991523743,
-0.7342663407325745,
0.09788105636835098,
0.1894233375787735,
0.4420434832572937,
0.8383049964904785,
0.27175572514533997,
0.5805740356445312,
-0.4531760811805725,
0.6105265617370605,
0.0923478826880455,
-1.3512836694717407,
0.9834851026535034,
-0.34358662366867065,
-0.2472168207168579,
0.08289054781198502,
0.039093270897865295,
-0.3647656738758087,
-0.44468170404434204,
-0.7837323546409607,
-0.30688440799713135,
0.596279501914978,
-0.25915420055389404,
-0.03846454992890358,
0.33615100383758545,
0.5353226661682129,
-0.31658482551574707,
0.20961815118789673,
-0.5464149713516235,
-0.08383522182703018,
-0.2484656572341919,
-0.3098507523536682,
-0.07302270084619522,
-0.3568291664123535,
-0.36208978295326233,
-0.33120572566986084,
0.5711398124694824,
-0.3392927348613739,
-0.11426331102848053,
0.06294659525156021,
0.11911600828170776,
-0.33116549253463745,
0.40271568298339844,
0.7040259838104248,
0.8541685938835144,
-0.349226713180542,
0.4353460371494293,
0.09789671748876572,
-0.06877993792295456,
0.1748761236667633,
0.15348006784915924,
-0.2985278367996216,
-0.20521488785743713,
0.48671433329582214,
0.6378646492958069,
0.3317345082759857,
-0.6781423687934875,
0.3367566764354706,
0.028734078630805016,
-0.1745743602514267,
-0.15544496476650238,
0.5812551975250244,
0.10688155889511108,
0.4333059787750244,
0.5281720161437988,
-0.03910111263394356,
0.12165279686450958,
-0.5376431345939636,
0.21489860117435455,
0.12557224929332733,
-0.047755759209394455,
-0.23588338494300842,
0.6732115745544434,
0.16441667079925537,
-0.37341442704200745,
0.3095628321170807,
-0.002283775946125388,
-0.8161987662315369,
0.6156389117240906,
0.7322635650634766,
0.5730592608451843,
-0.4142442047595978,
0.500176727771759,
0.2266402244567871,
0.2796635031700134,
-0.5332219004631042,
0.45319056510925293,
-0.2972123622894287,
-0.9325484037399292,
-0.46719011664390564,
-0.05056603625416756,
-0.9887346625328064,
-0.03896117955446243,
-0.6479492783546448,
0.34347254037857056,
-0.7688976526260376,
0.3968324065208435,
0.1409062296152115,
0.3360424339771271,
-0.0917808935046196,
0.3102303147315979,
-0.05061043053865433,
0.9674978852272034,
-0.9138410091400146,
1.2172232866287231,
0.822044312953949,
-0.35478702187538147,
-1.2863577604293823,
0.2319735437631607,
0.09628255665302277,
-0.7137868404388428,
0.9460371732711792,
0.08884459733963013,
0.003199085360392928,
0.09145401418209076,
-0.7923926115036011,
-0.30055102705955505,
0.9268061518669128,
0.555361807346344,
-0.5434299111366272,
-0.041387420147657394,
0.1001138687133789,
0.45199859142303467,
-0.2864861786365509,
-0.12646940350532532,
0.45413219928741455,
0.229643777012825,
0.5062349438667297,
-0.6083204746246338,
0.197576105594635,
0.2129516750574112,
-0.17160215973854065,
0.1993929147720337,
-0.4053359031677246,
0.7796795964241028,
-0.6978322863578796,
-0.12193838506937027,
-0.1509988158941269,
0.5932861566543579,
0.5176255702972412,
0.4331103265285492,
0.6080986857414246,
0.8783544898033142,
1.1011098623275757,
-0.0674976333975792,
0.9620107412338257,
-0.10571731626987457,
0.3618452250957489,
1.1129124164581299,
-0.24819914996623993,
0.7068267464637756,
0.5803045630455017,
-0.05907687917351723,
0.455617219209671,
0.502140998840332,
0.059094689786434174,
0.630149245262146,
0.12078538537025452,
-0.4197928309440613,
-0.6593305468559265,
-0.483930379152298,
-0.2679578363895416,
0.08149904757738113,
0.5193483233451843,
-0.3879064619541168,
-0.2669247090816498,
0.018209213390946388,
0.2150929868221283,
0.39043641090393066,
-0.420224130153656,
0.36507534980773926,
0.045320503413677216,
-0.5967673659324646,
0.5073220133781433,
0.04713495820760727,
0.22920522093772888,
-0.14073128998279572,
-0.29220518469810486,
-0.28056126832962036,
0.3670712113380432,
-0.00835451390594244,
-0.8008076548576355,
-0.21808165311813354,
-0.2051163613796234,
-0.19318750500679016,
-0.42218583822250366,
0.6732503771781921,
-0.6044670939445496,
-0.42981189489364624,
0.045834556221961975,
0.19001807272434235,
-0.09423400461673737,
0.27980315685272217,
-0.37284743785858154,
-0.07238113880157471,
0.2439102828502655,
0.11757789552211761,
0.02830434963107109,
0.5596364140510559,
0.11655177921056747,
1.0738247632980347,
0.5741270184516907,
0.2936263978481293,
-0.160256490111351,
0.13476961851119995,
0.9361912608146667,
-0.6699588298797607,
-0.3257942795753479,
-0.5911187529563904,
0.11551473289728165,
-0.18046122789382935,
0.02632511593401432,
0.7056612968444824,
0.22411690652370453,
0.8974727392196655,
0.02379261888563633,
0.6273434162139893,
0.1848968118429184,
0.9130709171295166,
-0.8196476697921753,
0.23351846635341644,
-0.3679908812046051,
0.5977686047554016,
-0.3448442220687866,
-0.7468551993370056,
-0.24687559902668,
1.0273641347885132,
-0.5365036725997925,
-0.2497999221086502,
0.7414074540138245,
0.8391470313072205,
-0.12181151658296585,
0.35912248492240906,
0.20226921141147614,
0.13548330962657928,
0.8856986165046692,
0.5853234529495239,
0.7513909339904785,
-0.14445452392101288,
0.32270872592926025,
-0.6414994597434998,
-0.1590723693370819,
-0.11046158522367477,
-0.8594459295272827,
-1.3344711065292358,
-0.31678441166877747,
-0.4055650234222412,
-0.3744216561317444,
0.027080250903964043,
1.279044508934021,
0.7633832097053528,
-0.6227295994758606,
-0.2605876922607422,
-0.66182541847229,
0.337653249502182,
-0.02431255392730236,
-0.2713044583797455,
0.48550719022750854,
-0.6167492866516113,
-0.8308150768280029,
0.6562389731407166,
-0.24395500123500824,
0.2553116977214813,
-0.18797536194324493,
-0.20443324744701385,
-0.03442443162202835,
-0.01078090164810419,
0.30362585186958313,
0.24683283269405365,
-0.6861050128936768,
-0.4058355987071991,
-0.19705717265605927,
-0.0114473607391119,
-0.2691468596458435,
0.9357032179832458,
-0.5599040389060974,
0.6324113607406616,
0.22114825248718262,
0.6919859051704407,
0.5015791654586792,
-0.13937583565711975,
0.8699476718902588,
-0.6033953428268433,
0.23070815205574036,
0.11447322368621826,
0.4595770239830017,
0.4024796485900879,
-0.13822224736213684,
0.7273820042610168,
0.5376951098442078,
-0.2724897265434265,
-1.1324430704116821,
0.22462813556194305,
-0.6716617941856384,
-0.3270190954208374,
0.9997019171714783,
-0.3057238459587097,
0.1787092089653015,
-0.008497344329953194,
-0.400903582572937,
0.06804640591144562,
-0.5141328573226929,
0.8524129390716553,
0.611287534236908,
0.028739647939801216,
-0.6864692568778992,
-0.3761146664619446,
0.4083128273487091,
0.7701092958450317,
-0.7610567212104797,
-0.020290689542889595,
0.35596054792404175,
0.37684059143066406,
0.13942286372184753,
0.2633569836616516,
0.23068298399448395,
0.1993708610534668,
-0.08286341279745102,
-0.041438665241003036,
-0.080336794257164,
-0.6344143152236938,
-0.05163115635514259,
0.2928197383880615,
0.28223198652267456,
-0.1628674417734146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01704v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01704v2 | States as Strings as Strategies: Steering Language Models with Game-Theoretic Solvers | 2024-01-24T22:22:00 | 2024-02-06T08:53:11 | Ian Gemp, Yoram Bachrach, Marc Lanctot, Roma Patel, Vibhavari Dasagi, Luke Marris, Georgios Piliouras, Siqi Liu, Karl Tuyls | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.GT | Game theory is the study of mathematical models of strategic interactions
among rational agents. Language is a key medium of interaction for humans,
though it has historically proven difficult to model dialogue and its strategic
motivations mathematically. A suitable model of the players, strategies, and
payoffs associated with linguistic interactions (i.e., a binding to the
conventional symbolic logic of game theory) would enable existing
game-theoretic algorithms to provide strategic solutions in the space of
language. In other words, a binding could provide a route to computing stable,
rational conversational strategies in dialogue. Large language models (LLMs)
have arguably reached a point where their generative capabilities can enable
realistic, human-like simulations of natural dialogue. By prompting them in
various ways, we can steer their responses towards different output utterances.
Leveraging the expressivity of natural language, LLMs can also help us quickly
generate new dialogue scenarios, which are grounded in real world applications.
In this work, we present one possible binding from dialogue to game theory as
well as generalizations of existing equilibrium finding algorithms to this
setting. In addition, by exploiting LLMs generation capabilities along with our
proposed binding, we can synthesize a large repository of formally-defined
games in which one can study and test game-theoretic solution concepts. We also
demonstrate how one can combine LLM-driven game generation, game-theoretic
solvers, and imitation learning to construct a process for improving the
strategic capabilities of LLMs. | [
-0.3452413082122803,
-0.962998628616333,
0.7656732201576233,
-0.020468007773160934,
-0.042037151753902435,
0.44952914118766785,
-0.3066093325614929,
-0.2882292568683624,
0.17662283778190613,
0.5175541043281555,
-0.5192453861236572,
-0.11266449093818665,
-0.3428117334842682,
-0.039599593728780746,
-0.08376214653253555,
0.8351283669471741,
-0.016686156392097473,
0.26086747646331787,
-0.11419668048620224,
-0.045023683458566666,
-0.20639945566654205,
-0.615121603012085,
-0.7534841895103455,
-0.5404554009437561,
0.3415030241012573,
0.21566076576709747,
0.6726532578468323,
0.5644662380218506,
0.2883128225803375,
0.4162556231021881,
-0.2259308248758316,
-0.10916759073734283,
-0.7810930013656616,
0.36340081691741943,
-0.27310648560523987,
-0.7780035138130188,
0.07710559666156769,
0.24683983623981476,
0.634784460067749,
0.582878589630127,
-0.6119231581687927,
-0.1569846123456955,
-0.003225679975003004,
0.5497578382492065,
-0.23851536214351654,
0.34766459465026855,
-0.7469349503517151,
0.12751378118991852,
-0.0060387905687093735,
-0.3579350709915161,
-0.2635982632637024,
-0.50220787525177,
0.5187668204307556,
-0.9730405211448669,
-0.03543858602643013,
0.23111853003501892,
0.85345458984375,
-0.14077192544937134,
-0.37683603167533875,
-0.5378749370574951,
-0.9446227550506592,
0.7912310361862183,
-0.8654610514640808,
0.20363081991672516,
0.14220502972602844,
0.28923898935317993,
-0.730097234249115,
-0.25071412324905396,
-0.5417296290397644,
-0.21984484791755676,
0.2125316858291626,
0.1424526423215866,
-0.29480844736099243,
0.39941293001174927,
0.534066915512085,
0.08100526034832001,
-0.09163418412208557,
-0.08609475940465927,
-0.25874045491218567,
0.04357398673892021,
0.779651403427124,
0.2128773182630539,
0.4170498549938202,
0.13041432201862335,
-0.33075088262557983,
0.08169131726026535,
-0.807191014289856,
0.2866783142089844,
0.42179933190345764,
0.3605954051017761,
0.04721759632229805,
0.6390820741653442,
0.05326719582080841,
0.7267428040504456,
0.3899156153202057,
-0.37768277525901794,
-0.5176540613174438,
-0.23531785607337952,
0.027694812044501305,
0.29312369227409363,
0.7345851063728333,
0.39095935225486755,
0.1775611937046051,
-0.05278738960623741,
-0.24103453755378723,
0.3030328154563904,
0.16071175038814545,
-0.606777548789978,
-0.08854211121797562,
-0.12211733311414719,
-0.26545849442481995,
-0.4006318151950836,
-0.34931930899620056,
-0.8826311230659485,
-0.49964091181755066,
-0.39842888712882996,
0.5402107834815979,
-0.4441218376159668,
-0.21775110065937042,
0.07528538256883621,
-0.10939320921897888,
0.5396444797515869,
0.03305865451693535,
-1.1898365020751953,
0.6871312856674194,
0.7210816144943237,
0.7905368804931641,
0.06110762432217598,
0.07840518653392792,
-0.2767235040664673,
0.38371142745018005,
-0.7327938079833984,
0.6663166284561157,
-0.5525657534599304,
-0.7946134805679321,
0.2502618134021759,
-0.3230245113372803,
0.17575965821743011,
-0.4002408981323242,
0.33502092957496643,
-0.5328588485717773,
0.2289174199104309,
-0.39005643129348755,
-0.8763324022293091,
-0.24068641662597656,
0.34677398204803467,
-0.7222579717636108,
0.4273203909397125,
-0.31984254717826843,
-0.3220653533935547,
0.13633711636066437,
-0.803062915802002,
-0.561355710029602,
0.2453673928976059,
-0.36525100469589233,
-0.17667321860790253,
0.3828786015510559,
-0.21727804839611053,
0.04646306112408638,
-0.777978241443634,
0.40396997332572937,
-0.2095627635717392,
-0.30812886357307434,
0.43568989634513855,
-0.2314617782831192,
0.6113772392272949,
0.21914668381214142,
-0.28297582268714905,
0.1810312569141388,
-0.25220659375190735,
0.1273171305656433,
0.3728257417678833,
-0.5582239627838135,
-0.23197516798973083,
0.6745043992996216,
-0.4805344343185425,
0.10301254689693451,
0.04286592826247215,
-0.34703147411346436,
0.3571650981903076,
-0.5816063284873962,
0.6872933506965637,
0.5980108380317688,
0.08814241737127304,
0.7582043409347534,
-0.28848332166671753,
0.6674937605857849,
-0.10391227155923843,
-0.0683957189321518,
0.11695145070552826,
-0.5157991051673889,
-0.663821816444397,
0.025755487382411957,
0.3383188843727112,
0.6084233522415161,
-0.9194086790084839,
0.18816158175468445,
-0.08204028010368347,
-0.34212303161621094,
-0.4974203109741211,
-0.10696516931056976,
0.3085351884365082,
0.18747547268867493,
-0.17279067635536194,
-0.14721092581748962,
-0.6183564066886902,
-0.7556825280189514,
-0.2944585382938385,
-0.3462619483470917,
0.29469165205955505,
0.31349432468414307,
0.2919946014881134,
0.26772063970565796,
1.1390019655227661,
-0.5416900515556335,
-0.14612168073654175,
-0.4946373701095581,
0.115938700735569,
0.2027214765548706,
0.32643112540245056,
0.2005002498626709,
-0.7674583196640015,
-0.18884536623954773,
0.03797140717506409,
-0.7045505046844482,
0.19534921646118164,
-0.12191165238618851,
-0.12207736819982529,
0.29124540090560913,
0.4289785623550415,
-0.4939098060131073,
0.22299465537071228,
0.6450234055519104,
-0.2995891571044922,
0.6000706553459167,
-0.23736239969730377,
0.18111124634742737,
-0.9569919109344482,
-0.20001859962940216,
0.18590781092643738,
-0.02846471779048443,
-0.9308391809463501,
0.24645382165908813,
-0.5462936162948608,
-0.4125690758228302,
-0.17130082845687866,
0.39122524857521057,
-0.5304215550422668,
-0.052250009030103683,
-0.13787560164928436,
0.3272629678249359,
-0.2748974859714508,
0.4863314628601074,
0.23724931478500366,
0.8564624190330505,
0.5015445947647095,
-0.6546692848205566,
0.5580187439918518,
0.11555511504411697,
-0.4527170658111572,
0.5990935564041138,
-0.5785751938819885,
-0.1646663099527359,
0.04230599105358124,
0.3008655607700348,
-0.8783660531044006,
0.05129603296518326,
0.2933181822299957,
-0.11517881602048874,
0.14555399119853973,
-0.3110807240009308,
-0.21351926028728485,
-0.23956981301307678,
-0.033535391092300415,
0.407344251871109,
0.704751193523407,
-0.20781144499778748,
0.6059336066246033,
0.759351372718811,
-0.2436991184949875,
-0.20593981444835663,
-0.39981040358543396,
0.07824777811765671,
-0.36583927273750305,
-0.33736833930015564,
0.16218885779380798,
-0.1421750783920288,
-0.4248737692832947,
-0.06882356852293015,
-0.05084818974137306,
-0.150442972779274,
0.2310878038406372,
0.09399671107530594,
0.1894187480211258,
-0.31533104181289673,
-0.04744696244597435,
0.013715779408812523,
-0.20244354009628296,
0.15131382644176483,
-0.6810853481292725,
0.3928956985473633,
-0.28322887420654297,
-0.23515699803829193,
-0.10439105331897736,
0.517267644405365,
0.31760290265083313,
-0.20446881651878357,
0.5246740579605103,
-0.25084996223449707,
-0.21173682808876038,
-0.10869630426168442,
-0.34836143255233765,
-0.2313823699951172,
-0.4908408224582672,
0.23110122978687286,
-0.5861365795135498,
-0.9694860577583313,
0.5625048875808716,
-0.5648985505104065,
0.15906895697116852,
0.04585370048880577,
0.5009375810623169,
-0.1769050657749176,
1.3238385915756226,
0.4465443193912506,
-0.05868137627840042,
0.4099118709564209,
-0.21091154217720032,
0.4608297049999237,
-0.521862804889679,
-0.07009997218847275,
-0.2578474283218384,
-0.4440464377403259,
-0.7968370318412781,
-0.44227302074432373,
0.3595643937587738,
0.27716708183288574,
-0.17726047337055206,
0.15482790768146515,
-0.13046984374523163,
0.8761433362960815,
0.6225549578666687,
-0.1597646027803421,
0.08826515078544617,
-0.0633411854505539,
-0.42930132150650024,
-0.19614307582378387,
-1.1789308786392212,
-0.4811514616012573,
0.6204385161399841,
0.1927097588777542,
0.7446426153182983,
0.46330925822257996,
0.7881913781166077,
-0.06732675433158875,
-0.047789931297302246,
-1.0476163625717163,
0.8423908948898315,
0.25158509612083435,
-0.6212952733039856,
-0.5921055674552917,
-0.6087133884429932,
-1.0636924505233765,
0.14889942109584808,
-0.6378268003463745,
-0.8341914415359497,
-0.05084025859832764,
0.2132396250963211,
-0.4270298182964325,
0.48505735397338867,
-0.44094976782798767,
0.793846607208252,
-0.3408053517341614,
-0.4855686128139496,
-0.3635733723640442,
-0.3207124173641205,
0.4911225736141205,
0.21750186383724213,
0.26270022988319397,
-0.0360359251499176,
0.029173025861382484,
0.7303972840309143,
-0.20205198228359222,
0.701185941696167,
0.09815745800733566,
-0.593883216381073,
0.49292629957199097,
0.6088449954986572,
0.4161498546600342,
-0.2912941575050354,
0.10742950439453125,
-0.15815435349941254,
0.19109036028385162,
-0.28566256165504456,
-0.7007638216018677,
0.7909427285194397,
-0.5656039118766785,
-0.9964382648468018,
-0.5463135838508606,
-0.5272600650787354,
-0.2387378215789795,
0.07834039628505707,
0.13794627785682678,
0.5115718841552734,
-0.5850176811218262,
-0.2578229308128357,
0.7665985226631165,
-0.18130764365196228,
0.23101110756397247,
0.5122706294059753,
-0.24866533279418945,
-0.1453685164451599,
1.3749805688858032,
0.12175372987985611,
0.3998352587223053,
0.2377256602048874,
0.4031221270561218,
-0.422904908657074,
-0.31268826127052307,
-0.13231918215751648,
0.15879900753498077,
-0.4200783669948578,
-0.1572422981262207,
0.19943773746490479,
-0.28029996156692505,
0.02931743673980236,
-0.2972727417945862,
-0.048107851296663284,
-0.17045007646083832,
-0.09680689871311188,
-0.023273471742868423,
0.26153630018234253,
1.0019770860671997,
-0.27922767400741577,
0.3259508013725281,
-0.41308361291885376,
0.091290682554245,
0.4083554148674011,
0.4999033510684967,
0.05732530355453491,
-0.10487876832485199,
-0.0798768624663353,
0.29740652441978455,
-0.3023163378238678,
-1.2290724515914917,
0.29493483901023865,
0.09418506920337677,
0.5194401144981384,
0.43519702553749084,
-0.1717151403427124,
0.66481614112854,
-0.8551937937736511,
0.742365300655365,
0.42021802067756653,
-1.1381127834320068,
0.39408034086227417,
-0.6888580918312073,
0.12881821393966675,
0.21894089877605438,
0.33737918734550476,
-0.7174578309059143,
-0.28747400641441345,
-0.7136956453323364,
-0.49168580770492554,
0.7487795948982239,
-0.004778621252626181,
-0.15873011946678162,
-0.006526794750243425,
0.2844991683959961,
-0.3999195396900177,
0.24158617854118347,
-0.4298734962940216,
-0.17760582268238068,
0.2263098806142807,
-0.1855517327785492,
-0.13593415915966034,
-0.3466796278953552,
-0.48641762137413025,
-0.02690592221915722,
0.7355709075927734,
-0.09817592799663544,
0.21567951142787933,
-0.11108224093914032,
0.19091716408729553,
-0.31466764211654663,
0.4322313964366913,
0.6884483695030212,
0.5364513993263245,
0.18481098115444183,
0.03300120308995247,
0.12893258035182953,
0.11696041375398636,
0.6991474628448486,
-0.06639271229505539,
-0.4846951961517334,
-0.27964603900909424,
0.037298042327165604,
0.7426257133483887,
0.6716278195381165,
-0.7060115337371826,
0.153996542096138,
0.04691886156797409,
-0.4644118547439575,
-0.04342420771718025,
0.10078893601894379,
0.2749370336532593,
0.4415038526058197,
0.18714027106761932,
-0.332348495721817,
0.13098464906215668,
-0.771176278591156,
0.20031745731830597,
0.8385226726531982,
-0.39309582114219666,
-0.29252928495407104,
0.41059213876724243,
0.5775226950645447,
-0.6810981035232544,
0.28644540905952454,
-0.40148285031318665,
-0.893563449382782,
0.3038957118988037,
0.7842768430709839,
0.5378313660621643,
-0.21807612478733063,
0.5241730809211731,
0.25221502780914307,
-0.11928430199623108,
-0.2764292061328888,
0.234613299369812,
0.0950348973274231,
-0.8472646474838257,
-0.5304352045059204,
-0.3478257358074188,
-0.459932804107666,
-0.07247603684663773,
-0.5521271824836731,
-0.09104932844638824,
-0.5794379115104675,
-0.33205950260162354,
-0.1778639256954193,
0.36049410700798035,
-0.2394515424966812,
-0.4335266351699829,
0.455716609954834,
0.5182338356971741,
-0.5529400706291199,
0.3688463270664215,
0.5509822368621826,
-0.2503407299518585,
-0.739716112613678,
-0.15531869232654572,
0.24351286888122559,
-0.45626646280288696,
0.5352327823638916,
-0.40581923723220825,
-0.2762574851512909,
0.2571262717247009,
-0.7690026760101318,
-0.9685644507408142,
0.6858025789260864,
0.46214157342910767,
-0.7571895718574524,
-0.09716199338436127,
0.055401116609573364,
0.4024170935153961,
-0.34745630621910095,
0.01947915367782116,
0.8097357153892517,
0.335652232170105,
0.2954823076725006,
-0.7780696749687195,
-0.03271939605474472,
0.05209732800722122,
0.14977911114692688,
0.596548318862915,
-0.48339805006980896,
0.433289110660553,
-0.4258538484573364,
-0.5323832035064697,
0.35953715443611145,
0.8579376339912415,
0.6148308515548706,
-0.1369798332452774,
0.39254075288772583,
0.3903302252292633,
0.5459877848625183,
-0.3040916919708252,
0.8844337463378906,
-0.35097113251686096,
0.35511550307273865,
0.5988805890083313,
-0.5257200002670288,
0.80389004945755,
0.5190209150314331,
-0.19617986679077148,
0.5411995649337769,
0.32297784090042114,
0.10142243653535843,
0.27668315172195435,
0.9714440107345581,
-0.38488632440567017,
-0.4368125796318054,
-0.2783714532852173,
0.047637198120355606,
0.41257768869400024,
0.5310940146446228,
0.2627851665019989,
-0.3362491726875305,
-0.23053458333015442,
-0.03500247374176979,
0.45678576827049255,
-0.2502672076225281,
1.070005178451538,
-0.006091669667512178,
-0.67041015625,
0.2961590588092804,
-0.0821743756532669,
0.5579630732536316,
-0.8435091972351074,
-0.32175809144973755,
0.0403585322201252,
0.02445903979241848,
0.3308406472206116,
-0.8079919815063477,
-0.2251686453819275,
-0.07451941072940826,
0.013413938693702221,
-0.15537822246551514,
0.45990732312202454,
-0.8274118900299072,
-0.5373478531837463,
0.12156309187412262,
0.5029400587081909,
-0.04854937642812729,
0.5369569659233093,
-0.8913086652755737,
0.27072688937187195,
-0.039048146456480026,
-0.02045021764934063,
0.35130733251571655,
0.5002840757369995,
0.04834849387407303,
0.8361490368843079,
0.6168606877326965,
0.40987545251846313,
-0.1091037169098854,
-0.3795020580291748,
0.5302612781524658,
-0.7262619733810425,
-0.6716671586036682,
-0.6794040203094482,
0.030201302841305733,
-0.0507592037320137,
-0.09759610891342163,
0.5324631333351135,
0.4545176029205322,
0.567489743232727,
0.08567322790622711,
0.7663636803627014,
-0.025796126574277878,
0.06189286708831787,
-0.6500358581542969,
0.6602265238761902,
-0.22617536783218384,
0.07316882908344269,
-0.13780762255191803,
-0.7563506364822388,
0.050443511456251144,
0.8191344738006592,
-0.31749165058135986,
-0.18074525892734528,
0.294653981924057,
0.5673130750656128,
0.14859135448932648,
0.1379769891500473,
0.3639332950115204,
0.2687470018863678,
0.543434739112854,
0.8368159532546997,
1.141600251197815,
-0.18650686740875244,
0.4432404339313507,
0.12335392832756042,
-0.23686420917510986,
0.013642817735671997,
-0.8413105607032776,
-0.731659471988678,
-0.8228756785392761,
-0.18183937668800354,
-0.29389601945877075,
0.262190580368042,
1.1586946249008179,
0.6071419715881348,
-0.613988995552063,
-1.0174435377120972,
-0.08806881308555603,
0.3043449819087982,
-0.26986774802207947,
-0.22317519783973694,
-0.08933437615633011,
-0.2947028875350952,
-0.6442620158195496,
0.47585350275039673,
0.1186201423406601,
0.36779776215553284,
-0.3846651315689087,
-0.2712305784225464,
-0.42820867896080017,
0.5970627665519714,
0.7137585878372192,
0.7839637994766235,
-0.9959281086921692,
-0.17812053859233856,
-0.13286833465099335,
0.03894348815083504,
-0.20008467137813568,
1.17225980758667,
-0.8218368291854858,
0.44849392771720886,
0.19413921236991882,
0.5697281360626221,
0.12694522738456726,
0.019420884549617767,
1.2774989604949951,
-0.33650606870651245,
0.1971624791622162,
0.24994251132011414,
0.20512135326862335,
0.11580028384923935,
0.12183152884244919,
0.33217450976371765,
0.09231936186552048,
-0.3299505412578583,
-0.7623658180236816,
0.5227097272872925,
-0.49610403180122375,
-0.3219453990459442,
1.0363259315490723,
0.05823816359043121,
-0.33867698907852173,
0.26475071907043457,
-0.38056015968322754,
0.11013534665107727,
-0.5762447714805603,
0.6504093408584595,
0.8424603939056396,
-0.07851070910692215,
-0.0643080472946167,
-0.31158605217933655,
0.9915434718132019,
0.32951438426971436,
-0.653322160243988,
0.1790398359298706,
0.6055551767349243,
-0.13986362516880035,
0.30015286803245544,
0.3362089991569519,
0.3563723564147949,
0.061298079788684845,
-0.026493601500988007,
-0.16329795122146606,
0.35290542244911194,
-0.17970003187656403,
-0.347378134727478,
-0.08572133630514145,
0.12437384575605392,
0.07786671072244644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13835v1 | The Calibration Gap between Model and Human Confidence in Large Language Models | 2024-01-24T22:21:04 | 2024-01-24T22:21:04 | Mark Steyvers, Heliodoro Tejeda, Aakriti Kumar, Catarina Belem, Sheer Karny, Xinyue Hu, Lukas Mayer, Padhraic Smyth | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | For large language models (LLMs) to be trusted by humans they need to be
well-calibrated in the sense that they can accurately assess and communicate
how likely it is that their predictions are correct. Recent work has focused on
the quality of internal LLM confidence assessments, but the question remains of
how well LLMs can communicate this internal model confidence to human users.
This paper explores the disparity between external human confidence in an LLM's
responses and the internal confidence of the model. Through experiments
involving multiple-choice questions, we systematically examine human users'
ability to discern the reliability of LLM outputs. Our study focuses on two key
areas: (1) assessing users' perception of true LLM confidence and (2)
investigating the impact of tailored explanations on this perception. The
research highlights that default explanations from LLMs often lead to user
overestimation of both the model's confidence and its' accuracy. By modifying
the explanations to more accurately reflect the LLM's internal confidence, we
observe a significant shift in user perception, aligning it more closely with
the model's actual confidence levels. This adjustment in explanatory approach
demonstrates potential for enhancing user trust and accuracy in assessing LLM
outputs. The findings underscore the importance of transparent communication of
confidence levels in LLMs, particularly in high-stakes applications where
understanding the reliability of AI-generated information is essential. | [
-0.46338048577308655,
-0.3965080976486206,
0.90486741065979,
-0.010915127582848072,
0.17867301404476166,
0.05357278883457184,
-0.42943406105041504,
-0.7310465574264526,
-0.38280439376831055,
0.1132328063249588,
-0.31129878759384155,
-0.33771178126335144,
-0.5907502174377441,
0.15221098065376282,
-0.12077601999044418,
0.41307640075683594,
-0.22218060493469238,
0.16417638957500458,
-0.5733490586280823,
0.14532622694969177,
-0.6072903275489807,
-0.653562068939209,
-0.43334126472473145,
-0.803413450717926,
0.6192154884338379,
0.39122483134269714,
1.0193616151809692,
0.39698582887649536,
0.3193499445915222,
0.3061128556728363,
-0.07243677973747253,
0.118252232670784,
-0.5719255805015564,
0.09338449686765671,
-0.34674298763275146,
-0.7926830649375916,
-0.23654785752296448,
0.10160166025161743,
0.6474766731262207,
0.6446294784545898,
-0.0729544535279274,
0.18433833122253418,
0.46363142132759094,
0.6858090758323669,
-0.723990261554718,
0.17493891716003418,
-0.5122525095939636,
-0.2681138515472412,
-0.15012705326080322,
-0.18735091388225555,
-0.6054881811141968,
-0.3913414776325226,
0.08030442893505096,
-0.36886775493621826,
-0.029775751754641533,
0.14260515570640564,
0.8016433715820312,
0.33584120869636536,
-0.5573633909225464,
-0.34391477704048157,
-0.8697505593299866,
0.7631056308746338,
-0.8825572729110718,
0.33576348423957825,
0.5846755504608154,
0.29470834136009216,
-0.3822532892227173,
-0.3717404305934906,
-0.5879110097885132,
-0.35651081800460815,
-0.09161481261253357,
-0.016730844974517822,
0.04532014578580856,
0.1274402141571045,
0.054604992270469666,
0.36245250701904297,
-0.4378022849559784,
0.47961118817329407,
-0.198907732963562,
-0.4573729932308197,
0.7429850101470947,
-0.0027588147204369307,
-0.04290681704878807,
0.08889760076999664,
-0.1693703681230545,
-0.2566760778427124,
-0.867287814617157,
0.18651244044303894,
0.7264920473098755,
0.22387036681175232,
-0.09992706775665283,
0.5454502701759338,
0.028821827843785286,
0.7074471712112427,
0.005430745892226696,
-0.18844757974147797,
0.0698329359292984,
-0.23052187263965607,
-0.24379336833953857,
0.06877519190311432,
0.7016717791557312,
0.4839809536933899,
0.624675989151001,
0.06616734713315964,
-0.17887310683727264,
0.18165376782417297,
0.24074402451515198,
-0.6286348104476929,
0.05168778821825981,
0.33636146783828735,
-0.2183099389076233,
-0.13006648421287537,
0.513919472694397,
-0.40110814571380615,
-0.6245737671852112,
-0.3066222369670868,
0.5151427984237671,
-0.08136942237615585,
-0.18358947336673737,
0.12502790987491608,
0.21301919221878052,
0.07647408545017242,
0.523320734500885,
-0.6532584428787231,
0.21271547675132751,
0.594014585018158,
0.6066027879714966,
-0.13695253431797028,
-0.2664836049079895,
-0.3719695210456848,
0.16861934959888458,
-0.6227512359619141,
0.4138232469558716,
-0.27507010102272034,
-0.3414669334888458,
0.0003526147629600018,
-0.13622577488422394,
-0.09964211285114288,
-0.45159903168678284,
0.5093628764152527,
-0.43992191553115845,
0.36961421370506287,
-0.42944973707199097,
-0.6868619322776794,
-0.2536429464817047,
0.2176678329706192,
-0.4749552309513092,
0.8676344752311707,
0.03544187918305397,
-0.7432783246040344,
0.23178187012672424,
-0.19210122525691986,
-0.040794193744659424,
-0.163887619972229,
-0.33217135071754456,
-0.07968950271606445,
0.31422513723373413,
0.2168726623058319,
0.41953784227371216,
-0.3613740801811218,
0.15596410632133484,
-0.6509601473808289,
-0.6071891784667969,
1.004401445388794,
-0.759560763835907,
0.5654686093330383,
0.09188281744718552,
-0.11234799027442932,
-0.13368821144104004,
-0.41403642296791077,
0.20336365699768066,
-0.1097494438290596,
-0.3322838842868805,
-0.16880202293395996,
-0.10831312835216522,
-0.285623699426651,
0.27947863936424255,
0.3844545781612396,
-0.4395219385623932,
-0.12396884709596634,
-0.5209107995033264,
0.467533677816391,
1.0442343950271606,
-0.11352095752954483,
0.38146963715553284,
-0.5123706459999084,
0.39983272552490234,
-0.06934770941734314,
0.11320971697568893,
-0.22968684136867523,
-0.5917742848396301,
-0.5127636194229126,
0.16769811511039734,
0.38991183042526245,
0.3179757595062256,
-0.13154450058937073,
0.4870763123035431,
-0.2606308162212372,
-0.39067769050598145,
-0.652413547039032,
0.3890827000141144,
0.3859180212020874,
0.578063428401947,
-0.10714594274759293,
-0.37152230739593506,
-0.19637146592140198,
-0.9101853370666504,
-0.35557103157043457,
-0.7013984322547913,
-0.3195537328720093,
0.5253536701202393,
0.4635847508907318,
-0.18531779944896698,
0.8933964371681213,
-0.2540644407272339,
0.001052520121447742,
-0.009802675805985928,
0.043921563774347305,
0.042714908719062805,
0.18556319177150726,
0.1649218499660492,
-0.9189925193786621,
-0.5501160621643066,
-0.07622300088405609,
-0.5548338294029236,
0.01152328122407198,
-0.04146948084235191,
0.02187764272093773,
0.30596184730529785,
0.32294994592666626,
-0.5944423079490662,
0.5172296166419983,
0.8426418304443359,
-0.16417263448238373,
0.535054087638855,
-0.4027569591999054,
0.41272830963134766,
-1.0376819372177124,
-0.051189545542001724,
-0.020505405962467194,
-0.41453245282173157,
-0.4244232773780823,
0.027377061545848846,
0.06148245930671692,
0.41548678278923035,
-0.26557657122612,
0.6405351758003235,
-0.5832793712615967,
-0.29242685437202454,
-0.17452186346054077,
0.3775920867919922,
0.20974789559841156,
0.10268869251012802,
-0.31110647320747375,
0.8957240581512451,
0.48504531383514404,
-0.4851338863372803,
0.17209984362125397,
0.20106859505176544,
-0.5348820090293884,
0.6489731669425964,
-0.6773463487625122,
0.359414279460907,
-0.034096572548151016,
0.3514742851257324,
-1.4967904090881348,
-0.563113808631897,
0.0594949796795845,
-0.8340364098548889,
0.36872655153274536,
-0.11625233292579651,
-0.6070765256881714,
-0.3708430528640747,
-0.17613695561885834,
0.24483725428581238,
0.5579508543014526,
-0.41847148537635803,
0.49616438150405884,
0.2570085823535919,
-0.11498447507619858,
-0.5242615342140198,
-1.0983471870422363,
0.19523224234580994,
-0.09743905067443848,
-0.931573212146759,
0.22767853736877441,
-0.273648202419281,
-0.6345839500427246,
-0.28772321343421936,
-0.24549123644828796,
-0.1765557825565338,
0.19379760324954987,
0.6665836572647095,
0.2887100577354431,
-0.18385711312294006,
0.25209930539131165,
-0.3823084831237793,
0.013968338258564472,
0.14388321340084076,
0.15606029331684113,
0.34656935930252075,
-0.2293439656496048,
-0.783296525478363,
-0.6571168899536133,
-0.02891765907406807,
0.5717035531997681,
0.17316411435604095,
0.9782114624977112,
0.3881671130657196,
-0.3819182217121124,
-0.009392612613737583,
-0.7583475708961487,
-0.4123179018497467,
-0.5154145359992981,
0.01063173171132803,
-0.2614128589630127,
-0.8568125367164612,
0.5550060868263245,
0.13887184858322144,
-0.09167324751615524,
0.36033058166503906,
0.6913123726844788,
-0.2516285479068756,
1.2415417432785034,
0.7705159187316895,
-0.08660530298948288,
0.00027676450554281473,
0.35856571793556213,
0.14127510786056519,
-0.7535689473152161,
-0.2651573419570923,
-0.6028152108192444,
-0.30740997195243835,
-0.4660049378871918,
-0.5093745589256287,
0.2435266375541687,
0.18774260580539703,
-0.22891263663768768,
-0.11412134021520615,
-0.21282672882080078,
0.47991782426834106,
0.5138624310493469,
0.09334976226091385,
0.5279356837272644,
-0.11417639255523682,
-0.020660292357206345,
-0.29249539971351624,
-0.4916341304779053,
-0.8441842794418335,
0.8900914192199707,
0.716823399066925,
1.1520212888717651,
0.1594354808330536,
0.4913775622844696,
0.28379204869270325,
0.37988200783729553,
-0.5656037926673889,
0.21164871752262115,
0.2145605981349945,
-0.7467151880264282,
-0.3637765049934387,
-0.5193489789962769,
-0.6238059401512146,
0.1288110762834549,
-0.19558504223823547,
-0.9994835257530212,
0.06349974125623703,
0.4497501254081726,
-0.4675399661064148,
0.17471636831760406,
-0.8423526287078857,
0.6129423975944519,
-0.24331560730934143,
-0.30329272150993347,
-0.08814778923988342,
-0.8015483617782593,
0.4408464729785919,
-0.29940617084503174,
0.23378092050552368,
-0.23065544664859772,
0.03023538552224636,
0.3472234904766083,
-0.21019335091114044,
0.9591951966285706,
0.08993454277515411,
-0.29409483075141907,
0.2272644340991974,
0.20910367369651794,
0.6018618941307068,
0.12847746908664703,
-0.4280025064945221,
0.24064019322395325,
-0.15360091626644135,
-0.10721486061811447,
-0.6547583937644958,
0.7683261036872864,
-0.7527028918266296,
-0.7356996536254883,
-0.43039312958717346,
-0.5754095315933228,
-0.4425411522388458,
-0.12619024515151978,
0.24361242353916168,
0.20535683631896973,
-0.20620690286159515,
0.27099937200546265,
0.7528582811355591,
-0.4383380115032196,
0.06865772604942322,
0.4141102433204651,
-0.16100765764713287,
0.05072757974267006,
0.3089929223060608,
-0.0799546167254448,
0.6707351207733154,
0.3004937469959259,
0.34971097111701965,
-0.640291690826416,
-0.41546937823295593,
-0.4403539001941681,
0.2864364981651306,
-0.780070960521698,
-0.06435283273458481,
-0.013075380586087704,
-0.29975512623786926,
-0.4110487997531891,
-0.18139901757240295,
-0.3837270140647888,
-0.13052448630332947,
-0.5765681266784668,
-0.15874408185482025,
0.14736153185367584,
0.9576575756072998,
-0.014387566596269608,
0.396450400352478,
-0.5825265645980835,
0.08979900926351547,
0.2546447217464447,
0.2892133891582489,
0.002108487067744136,
-0.9093479514122009,
-0.14140181243419647,
0.4652005136013031,
-0.12638455629348755,
-0.8872736096382141,
0.18165259063243866,
0.07117277383804321,
0.5664438605308533,
0.5216947197914124,
-0.019989661872386932,
0.7593886256217957,
-0.23823335766792297,
0.8442586064338684,
0.16279540956020355,
-0.9096344113349915,
0.21145734190940857,
-0.03650921210646629,
0.3481953740119934,
0.5940937995910645,
0.38205960392951965,
-0.5622930526733398,
-0.5811073780059814,
-0.3248394727706909,
-0.538808286190033,
0.5743855237960815,
0.13604240119457245,
0.17564648389816284,
0.3228691518306732,
0.42152413725852966,
0.05523638799786568,
0.12158497422933578,
-0.6587966084480286,
-0.16605867445468903,
0.1394512951374054,
-0.07395747303962708,
-0.492548406124115,
-0.4109087288379669,
-0.3051142394542694,
0.18393005430698395,
0.514037549495697,
-0.14805631339550018,
0.09296052157878876,
0.2093648910522461,
-0.13839466869831085,
-0.3585950434207916,
0.4079303741455078,
0.6277953386306763,
1.2281125783920288,
-0.22548235952854156,
0.2952999770641327,
0.13035675883293152,
-0.1558634489774704,
0.037718381732702255,
-0.14882631599903107,
0.14060357213020325,
-0.06741355359554291,
0.4483620822429657,
0.5992283821105957,
0.0646355152130127,
-0.5599228143692017,
0.6934060454368591,
-0.17414067685604095,
-0.1887967586517334,
-0.37615641951560974,
0.08770658075809479,
0.3937186598777771,
0.18668502569198608,
0.3547240197658539,
0.09025757759809494,
-0.19396264851093292,
-0.5508741140365601,
0.081955686211586,
0.48887982964515686,
-0.44047945737838745,
-0.3320755362510681,
0.6726322770118713,
0.019279176369309425,
-0.36023709177970886,
0.6401528120040894,
0.2165706753730774,
-0.3183082640171051,
0.42475542426109314,
0.43238574266433716,
0.6244922876358032,
-0.3476565480232239,
0.18865913152694702,
0.20320916175842285,
0.492978572845459,
-0.3541525900363922,
0.05167203024029732,
0.2567916214466095,
-0.8925880193710327,
-0.5696419477462769,
-0.4615854322910309,
-0.7298034429550171,
0.1520000696182251,
-0.768505871295929,
-0.03166472539305687,
-0.18239901959896088,
-0.40427902340888977,
-0.21257302165031433,
-0.1220121830701828,
-0.63228839635849,
0.14453890919685364,
0.372563898563385,
0.9919877052307129,
-0.8297861218452454,
0.7138137221336365,
0.32141438126564026,
-0.2784895598888397,
-1.0662416219711304,
0.18418574333190918,
0.10616253316402435,
-1.0426392555236816,
0.5331857800483704,
0.3738173246383667,
-0.30202725529670715,
-0.3473717272281647,
-0.5846714973449707,
-0.7865854501724243,
1.078960657119751,
0.7550334930419922,
-0.7522025108337402,
-0.044236693531274796,
0.37191158533096313,
0.6807651519775391,
-0.30369624495506287,
0.3176538646221161,
0.37743687629699707,
0.6826051473617554,
0.21543581783771515,
-1.1750279664993286,
0.03511478751897812,
0.22244462370872498,
0.15014727413654327,
0.004831928294152021,
-0.47503045201301575,
0.8049820065498352,
-0.408252477645874,
-0.2349986433982849,
0.17928312718868256,
0.4925386607646942,
0.3293260633945465,
0.22772379219532013,
0.533421516418457,
0.2417551577091217,
0.8850776553153992,
-0.11917193979024887,
1.183366298675537,
-0.39104244112968445,
0.16047286987304688,
1.1944893598556519,
-0.36336958408355713,
0.9851135015487671,
0.6102320551872253,
-0.14720338582992554,
0.6076026558876038,
0.7181468605995178,
0.26190781593322754,
0.005734074395149946,
0.3002258837223053,
-0.17905451357364655,
-0.36965563893318176,
-0.02350020594894886,
-0.274705708026886,
0.3222619295120239,
0.3636202812194824,
-0.49827778339385986,
0.057146910578012466,
-0.35332584381103516,
-0.10055583715438843,
0.11611554771661758,
-0.30030015110969543,
0.5333753228187561,
0.38032424449920654,
-0.8407146334648132,
0.5060049891471863,
0.09850266575813293,
0.49578285217285156,
-0.582571268081665,
0.0896516814827919,
-0.08584775030612946,
0.35658496618270874,
-0.3391672670841217,
-1.119275450706482,
-0.03366700932383537,
-0.15657255053520203,
-0.019875384867191315,
-0.2241484522819519,
0.745564341545105,
-0.42384040355682373,
-0.2887599468231201,
0.23006080090999603,
0.5873130559921265,
0.3527683615684509,
-0.3023240864276886,
-0.6014748215675354,
0.21062515676021576,
0.014447780326008797,
-0.38203999400138855,
0.2405911386013031,
0.15431439876556396,
0.0212786253541708,
0.9450342059135437,
0.5619266629219055,
0.16063106060028076,
0.011361067183315754,
0.13326284289360046,
0.4698747992515564,
-0.2843698561191559,
-0.32078179717063904,
-1.066515564918518,
0.3941921591758728,
-0.013512699864804745,
-0.22830462455749512,
0.9313262701034546,
0.3768790066242218,
0.8585594296455383,
0.16149044036865234,
0.7607982754707336,
0.42814525961875916,
0.5133832097053528,
-0.464338481426239,
0.6562745571136475,
-0.5360264182090759,
0.39046093821525574,
-0.13029244542121887,
-0.8710364699363708,
-0.09271201491355896,
0.6463077068328857,
-0.2303050458431244,
0.2842143774032593,
0.5442717671394348,
0.9137256145477295,
-0.0038162730634212494,
-0.23602603375911713,
0.5299827456474304,
0.4782395660877228,
0.191160649061203,
0.6416756510734558,
0.9153945446014404,
-0.15965615212917328,
0.5111425518989563,
-0.04989536106586456,
-0.2010047733783722,
-0.24725055694580078,
-1.0995657444000244,
-0.8239181041717529,
-0.44914913177490234,
-0.07853953540325165,
-0.40190380811691284,
0.003987154457718134,
0.6377521753311157,
0.7398725748062134,
-0.619363009929657,
-0.4635924696922302,
0.04251522943377495,
0.11010680347681046,
0.1990717053413391,
-0.22635461390018463,
0.006260262336581945,
0.038654036819934845,
-0.6586794257164001,
0.2533474266529083,
0.23439788818359375,
0.32443228363990784,
-0.778380811214447,
-0.39320382475852966,
0.2885718047618866,
0.31286147236824036,
0.16075588762760162,
0.26273199915885925,
-0.9309118390083313,
-0.42652153968811035,
-0.05537674203515053,
-0.32530373334884644,
0.24977119266986847,
0.48359206318855286,
-0.5786545276641846,
0.5090464949607849,
0.3791402280330658,
0.5186062455177307,
0.4221304953098297,
0.27544498443603516,
1.0141267776489258,
-0.7524007558822632,
-0.1309836059808731,
0.08838231861591339,
0.23467831313610077,
0.7651737332344055,
-0.45037493109703064,
0.3129022717475891,
-0.2027142196893692,
-0.8185420632362366,
-0.9301538467407227,
0.29692721366882324,
-0.7752952575683594,
-0.2176065742969513,
1.3341869115829468,
-0.2134561836719513,
-0.0626576840877533,
-0.09276943653821945,
-0.18912865221500397,
0.015267198905348778,
-0.35801589488983154,
0.8485809564590454,
1.188745141029358,
-0.0402921661734581,
0.04996121674776077,
-0.6181163191795349,
0.4494420289993286,
0.11611945927143097,
-0.7583990097045898,
0.23398427665233612,
0.47491440176963806,
0.3640874922275543,
0.18696053326129913,
0.575676441192627,
0.024543195962905884,
0.19614987075328827,
-0.20562885701656342,
-0.15568041801452637,
-0.08297102153301239,
-0.265514075756073,
-0.4613657593727112,
0.04330350458621979,
0.5058550238609314,
0.08187039941549301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13810v1 | Automated Root Causing of Cloud Incidents using In-Context Learning with GPT-4 | 2024-01-24T21:02:07 | 2024-01-24T21:02:07 | Xuchao Zhang, Supriyo Ghosh, Chetan Bansal, Rujia Wang, Minghua Ma, Yu Kang, Saravan Rajmohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Root Cause Analysis (RCA) plays a pivotal role in the incident diagnosis
process for cloud services, requiring on-call engineers to identify the primary
issues and implement corrective actions to prevent future recurrences.
Improving the incident RCA process is vital for minimizing service downtime,
customer impact and manual toil. Recent advances in artificial intelligence
have introduced state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4, which
have proven effective in tackling various AIOps problems, ranging from code
authoring to incident management. Nonetheless, the GPT-4 model's immense size
presents challenges when trying to fine-tune it on user data because of the
significant GPU resource demand and the necessity for continuous model
fine-tuning with the emergence of new data. To address the high cost of
fine-tuning LLM, we propose an in-context learning approach for automated root
causing, which eliminates the need for fine-tuning. We conduct extensive study
over 100,000 production incidents, comparing several large language models
using multiple metrics. The results reveal that our in-context learning
approach outperforms the previous fine-tuned large language models such as
GPT-3 by an average of 24.8\% across all metrics, with an impressive 49.7\%
improvement over the zero-shot model. Moreover, human evaluation involving
actual incident owners demonstrates its superiority over the fine-tuned model,
achieving a 43.5\% improvement in correctness and an 8.7\% enhancement in
readability. The impressive results demonstrate the viability of utilizing a
vanilla GPT model for the RCA task, thereby avoiding the high computational and
maintenance costs associated with a fine-tuned model. | [
-0.40446123480796814,
-0.9626036286354065,
0.7448251247406006,
0.10297054052352905,
-0.34629422426223755,
0.01547821145504713,
-0.03652895614504814,
-0.6479062438011169,
-0.39792370796203613,
0.3179003596305847,
-0.8656200170516968,
-0.3511013090610504,
-0.4503318965435028,
0.017780911177396774,
-0.48441082239151,
1.0320886373519897,
-0.1801413595676422,
-0.13516028225421906,
-0.04469278082251549,
0.18520525097846985,
-0.7928674817085266,
-0.7196593880653381,
-1.2165591716766357,
0.006337090861052275,
0.11468646675348282,
0.8207290768623352,
0.34408512711524963,
0.49624010920524597,
0.6936623454093933,
0.3113381266593933,
0.13945633172988892,
0.1194542795419693,
-0.31133273243904114,
-0.026947960257530212,
0.07279469072818756,
-0.12540441751480103,
-0.36804911494255066,
-0.35239556431770325,
0.34568020701408386,
0.1442607343196869,
-0.35178160667419434,
-0.09558679908514023,
0.06892246007919312,
0.33100029826164246,
-0.501456081867218,
0.16878093779087067,
-1.140830636024475,
-0.03838345408439636,
0.028778718784451485,
-0.4195253252983093,
-0.2562699615955353,
-0.06997939199209213,
0.050165701657533646,
-0.6230274438858032,
0.6386099457740784,
-0.2232663780450821,
0.8490343689918518,
0.572780430316925,
-0.38536518812179565,
-0.49359503388404846,
-0.5860903263092041,
0.7308847308158875,
-0.7308040261268616,
0.14448384940624237,
0.3604101538658142,
0.368620902299881,
-0.21793602406978607,
-0.5363913178443909,
-0.5631020069122314,
0.03820594400167465,
0.16469773650169373,
0.2350669503211975,
-0.20384979248046875,
-0.04199798032641411,
0.23921208083629608,
-0.02454707957804203,
-0.3706923723220825,
0.5623196363449097,
-0.1698734164237976,
-0.1774064004421234,
0.6503843069076538,
0.5621138215065002,
0.3590901494026184,
-0.1303030252456665,
-0.2493065595626831,
0.14128869771957397,
-0.9134710431098938,
0.021208131685853004,
0.06744758784770966,
0.3326008915901184,
0.04738175496459007,
-0.11703411489725113,
-0.17945243418216705,
0.486057847738266,
0.08589836955070496,
-0.0157233364880085,
-0.07892574369907379,
-0.2746334969997406,
-0.5434635281562805,
0.24799664318561554,
0.6675583124160767,
0.11218497902154922,
-0.04449167847633362,
-0.2743454873561859,
-0.21068483591079712,
0.0375654511153698,
0.6669947504997253,
-0.8050051331520081,
-0.22175629436969757,
0.21588578820228577,
0.16680839657783508,
-0.30605411529541016,
-0.10387720912694931,
-0.4122205078601837,
-0.5165205597877502,
-0.5599954128265381,
0.2912313938140869,
-0.6080102324485779,
-0.10984820872545242,
-0.2108895629644394,
0.28453299403190613,
0.3251783549785614,
0.4699403643608093,
-0.7650319933891296,
0.17035599052906036,
0.8682791590690613,
0.913570761680603,
-0.03327203169465065,
-0.2720757722854614,
-0.7913322448730469,
0.16351944208145142,
-0.5572494864463806,
0.8669630289077759,
-0.07966577261686325,
-0.24697580933570862,
0.06495892256498337,
-0.046450719237327576,
0.19714820384979248,
-0.6065489053726196,
0.8199687004089355,
-0.5110042095184326,
-0.1434076726436615,
-0.26326945424079895,
-0.4519220292568207,
-0.20948660373687744,
0.3473300039768219,
-0.20493797957897186,
0.7951236367225647,
0.16217979788780212,
-0.30776697397232056,
0.7134805917739868,
-0.7189322113990784,
-0.3797456920146942,
0.46841439604759216,
-0.27109503746032715,
-0.8985055088996887,
0.06136736273765564,
0.46243390440940857,
0.7953028678894043,
-0.40229499340057373,
0.5361937284469604,
-0.01230647787451744,
0.009772674180567265,
-0.26486915349960327,
-0.11967452615499496,
0.6955083012580872,
0.07928140461444855,
-0.5911285281181335,
0.30052489042282104,
-0.6479386687278748,
-0.14092354476451874,
0.08075301349163055,
0.0651898980140686,
-0.3354042172431946,
0.04795056954026222,
-0.06838849931955338,
0.32538264989852905,
-0.15828272700309753,
-0.5314198732376099,
0.07164070755243301,
-0.25543370842933655,
0.4125942885875702,
0.8411208391189575,
0.4183292090892792,
0.3653252124786377,
-0.016672469675540924,
0.45733529329299927,
0.35126158595085144,
0.40740808844566345,
-0.0874711349606514,
-0.4095190763473511,
-0.6780378222465515,
-0.22887267172336578,
-0.3657328188419342,
0.5352330207824707,
-0.6767230033874512,
0.18739667534828186,
-0.10646236687898636,
-0.5498247742652893,
-0.14672885835170746,
0.3031656742095947,
0.2954746186733246,
1.062302827835083,
0.5140846967697144,
-0.2201148271560669,
-0.690133273601532,
-0.8004662990570068,
0.03339970484375954,
-0.059402454644441605,
-0.15052127838134766,
0.4614771008491516,
0.3985372483730316,
-0.6258764863014221,
1.24477219581604,
-0.5567768812179565,
-0.6823341250419617,
-0.023585205897688866,
0.39494648575782776,
0.09540190547704697,
0.32112428545951843,
0.7057064771652222,
-0.7820087671279907,
-0.5305281281471252,
0.2340298593044281,
-0.8973429203033447,
-0.22173044085502625,
-0.19505301117897034,
0.23828357458114624,
0.5101508498191833,
0.5900930166244507,
-0.27154433727264404,
0.5029914379119873,
0.38122060894966125,
-0.39963498711586,
0.6833902597427368,
-0.39528653025627136,
0.04157134145498276,
-1.0382580757141113,
-0.24200159311294556,
0.18291008472442627,
0.0017478932859376073,
-0.8333328366279602,
-0.0601576566696167,
0.44402727484703064,
-0.27887898683547974,
-0.5886821746826172,
0.11217920482158661,
-0.48195892572402954,
-0.1669333577156067,
-0.2762086093425751,
0.05785335227847099,
-0.2931073009967804,
0.41885048151016235,
-0.0006263761315494776,
0.8171945810317993,
0.6131616830825806,
-1.0087064504623413,
0.395603746175766,
0.28447258472442627,
-0.44603613018989563,
0.38043808937072754,
-0.5409435629844666,
0.05177372321486473,
-0.001236153650097549,
0.05785990133881569,
-0.7346837520599365,
-0.35496604442596436,
0.07209143042564392,
-0.230478435754776,
0.12317998707294464,
-0.2937505543231964,
-0.5595458745956421,
-0.0415550097823143,
0.2720887064933777,
0.3070594072341919,
0.41644930839538574,
-0.6650456786155701,
0.5803064107894897,
0.39226359128952026,
-0.48103880882263184,
-0.2795886695384979,
-0.41119757294654846,
0.39167478680610657,
-0.567648708820343,
-0.6903793215751648,
0.4283706843852997,
0.133399099111557,
-0.10155711323022842,
-0.3059704303741455,
0.024966003373265266,
-0.4123736619949341,
0.5471147298812866,
0.36155062913894653,
0.1624058037996292,
-0.13956192135810852,
0.21732567250728607,
-0.034381549805402756,
-0.16495226323604584,
0.29845595359802246,
-0.05722036585211754,
0.3518733084201813,
-0.4069376289844513,
-0.1722235381603241,
-0.5563087463378906,
0.23307523131370544,
0.7748500108718872,
-0.036407388746738434,
0.5792206525802612,
0.1706150472164154,
-0.4305638074874878,
-0.20991060137748718,
-0.4332212805747986,
-0.4417240619659424,
-0.46411779522895813,
0.4969862103462219,
-0.23134028911590576,
-0.5810093283653259,
0.6735774874687195,
-0.19551923871040344,
0.11417462676763535,
0.4900285601615906,
0.42786312103271484,
-0.09931912273168564,
0.9296376705169678,
0.8325760960578918,
-0.5789521932601929,
0.601548969745636,
-0.3482345938682556,
0.41626280546188354,
-0.7189880013465881,
-0.02093002013862133,
-0.49645212292671204,
0.24637021124362946,
-0.13991720974445343,
-0.0113011933863163,
0.8157047629356384,
0.11276928335428238,
-0.44515570998191833,
0.23682615160942078,
-0.21311332285404205,
0.3347053527832031,
0.04269665479660034,
0.002064160769805312,
0.31058934330940247,
-0.06443872302770615,
0.1283644586801529,
0.17756287753582,
-0.7879375219345093,
-0.310274213552475,
0.5179012417793274,
0.44924014806747437,
0.1815318465232849,
0.457416296005249,
0.4587709307670593,
0.2699820399284363,
0.5508783459663391,
-0.8125759363174438,
0.30124804377555847,
0.18327103555202484,
-0.33140137791633606,
-0.5790363550186157,
-0.4929449260234833,
-0.9140908718109131,
0.0635400116443634,
-0.02255764976143837,
-0.6222078204154968,
-0.04896280914545059,
0.3882782459259033,
-0.3184335231781006,
0.07286101579666138,
-0.7134102582931519,
0.8280915021896362,
-0.3936786949634552,
-0.12135729938745499,
-0.2600940763950348,
-0.3660937249660492,
0.45522984862327576,
-0.35725441575050354,
0.3997454047203064,
0.22154416143894196,
0.20136453211307526,
0.637742817401886,
-0.7326061129570007,
0.9778478741645813,
-0.3487808406352997,
-0.32319167256355286,
0.3896605372428894,
-0.09032154083251953,
0.9184116721153259,
0.19452504813671112,
0.12479674071073532,
0.20101913809776306,
-0.5317488312721252,
-0.1725737303495407,
-0.6442810297012329,
0.6305517554283142,
-1.0013970136642456,
-0.35248979926109314,
-0.41983887553215027,
-0.3954719603061676,
-0.2835143506526947,
0.12370992451906204,
0.5111185312271118,
0.7032670378684998,
-0.0026589829940348864,
0.22636906802654266,
0.6345919966697693,
-0.2169213443994522,
0.8404560089111328,
0.7926368713378906,
0.17044015228748322,
-0.1854148507118225,
0.7192334532737732,
0.1299677938222885,
0.05416746810078621,
-0.010179705917835236,
0.2627112865447998,
-0.041117630898952484,
-0.7539344429969788,
-0.5138418674468994,
0.07275106757879257,
-0.7155115604400635,
-0.5979809761047363,
-0.7754614353179932,
-0.22013266384601593,
-0.4059831500053406,
-0.40329378843307495,
-0.35778218507766724,
0.15898936986923218,
-0.5599286556243896,
-0.25634363293647766,
0.5082001090049744,
0.4274141192436218,
0.30949997901916504,
0.7250393629074097,
-0.7623712420463562,
0.30182167887687683,
0.18853925168514252,
0.38315871357917786,
0.06009068340063095,
-0.7112329602241516,
-0.3013286292552948,
-0.11691337823867798,
-0.6519349813461304,
-0.7149705290794373,
0.7250728011131287,
0.36859387159347534,
0.4020618796348572,
0.5550085306167603,
0.07974560558795929,
0.992965042591095,
-0.625434935092926,
0.7221925258636475,
0.1433083415031433,
-1.1388307809829712,
0.6496656537055969,
-0.5988454222679138,
0.10731224715709686,
0.4233476519584656,
0.46428656578063965,
-0.6607761383056641,
-0.35936835408210754,
-0.8002713918685913,
-1.1884599924087524,
0.7934279441833496,
0.040582090616226196,
-0.2314087450504303,
-0.06286563724279404,
0.4541214108467102,
-0.12131846696138382,
-0.15437890589237213,
-0.47142958641052246,
0.07314924895763397,
-0.1532944291830063,
0.07623708993196487,
-0.3661295771598816,
-0.19055461883544922,
0.0677887573838234,
-0.2021521031856537,
1.0450323820114136,
-0.35099929571151733,
0.002625657245516777,
0.12679147720336914,
-0.351908802986145,
-0.2776165008544922,
0.23989200592041016,
0.832175076007843,
0.8258860111236572,
-0.09839894622564316,
-0.27301540970802307,
0.567563533782959,
-0.4695534110069275,
-0.03978381305932999,
-0.18098099529743195,
-0.180221289396286,
-0.1720425933599472,
0.3280062973499298,
0.7637378573417664,
0.20648184418678284,
-0.6464831829071045,
0.534970760345459,
-0.20608624815940857,
-0.2638871669769287,
-0.8683907985687256,
0.016591021791100502,
-0.22525331377983093,
-0.055333174765110016,
0.7234143018722534,
-0.2588593363761902,
0.22596773505210876,
-0.5826534628868103,
0.25362420082092285,
0.5580464601516724,
-0.4427284896373749,
-0.11758188903331757,
0.24572260677814484,
0.22236505150794983,
-0.25640204548835754,
0.9877033829689026,
-0.031428802758455276,
-0.7716449499130249,
0.9986864328384399,
0.6725308895111084,
1.005903959274292,
-0.421697735786438,
0.12229044735431671,
0.27134400606155396,
0.3480710983276367,
0.04804668202996254,
-0.04482428357005119,
0.11533892899751663,
-0.8460779786109924,
-0.46947863698005676,
-0.41858479380607605,
-0.6042420864105225,
0.6370320916175842,
-0.46912556886672974,
0.42023777961730957,
-0.5472569465637207,
0.1933813989162445,
-0.24788714945316315,
-0.0766158327460289,
-0.5621072053909302,
0.45811113715171814,
-0.10131563246250153,
0.6371076107025146,
-1.1615023612976074,
0.6954258680343628,
0.515396773815155,
-0.3020000755786896,
-0.9914300441741943,
-0.09804558753967285,
0.11465515196323395,
-0.3536815345287323,
0.6906455755233765,
0.18650367856025696,
0.10359825193881989,
0.09914685040712357,
-0.42075875401496887,
-0.8459879755973816,
1.1752307415008545,
0.19282720983028412,
-0.532564640045166,
0.2840893864631653,
0.11447996646165848,
0.6328129768371582,
-0.3662083148956299,
0.29155513644218445,
0.6426153779029846,
0.08637983351945877,
-0.02374943532049656,
-0.7098197937011719,
-0.010065141133964062,
0.0577838160097599,
-0.2544795274734497,
0.48156630992889404,
-0.4165605902671814,
0.619391679763794,
-0.05878586322069168,
-0.32088160514831543,
-0.5105037093162537,
0.5727742314338684,
0.2445090115070343,
0.6243748068809509,
0.4523065388202667,
0.43516331911087036,
0.8280739784240723,
0.00025662779808044434,
1.2074395418167114,
-0.12586167454719543,
0.3493267595767975,
1.0110551118850708,
-0.20854075253009796,
0.6129829287528992,
0.4210956394672394,
0.1594616323709488,
0.4215598702430725,
0.6511009931564331,
0.1713039129972458,
0.5590066313743591,
-0.17021989822387695,
-0.2525106370449066,
-0.08097836375236511,
0.20594173669815063,
-0.12253846228122711,
0.3780674338340759,
0.5233277678489685,
-0.12343629449605942,
-0.3010464906692505,
0.2139953374862671,
0.013094860129058361,
-0.25178420543670654,
-0.6767200827598572,
1.0942459106445312,
0.0500527061522007,
-0.6778370141983032,
0.678284227848053,
0.026877138763666153,
0.4030470550060272,
-0.5420547723770142,
0.1427716165781021,
-0.27255937457084656,
0.377509742975235,
-0.3826906681060791,
-0.4107365310192108,
0.686180591583252,
0.34344708919525146,
-0.24653169512748718,
-0.16569030284881592,
0.49218156933784485,
0.06501352041959763,
-0.32626426219940186,
0.22929900884628296,
-0.047261372208595276,
0.063714399933815,
-0.49474185705184937,
-0.3596946895122528,
-0.07675597071647644,
-0.14720921218395233,
-0.013393267057836056,
0.4037497043609619,
0.528102457523346,
-0.5711338520050049,
0.8111754655838013,
0.6279464960098267,
-0.035844586789608,
-0.052880629897117615,
0.07068511843681335,
0.8535012006759644,
-0.4652765095233917,
-0.7409856915473938,
-0.9827463030815125,
0.5557785630226135,
-0.16032269597053528,
-0.3599904179573059,
0.5218920111656189,
0.5209528207778931,
0.6510295867919922,
-0.1169576421380043,
1.0725336074829102,
0.06550824642181396,
0.3074277937412262,
-0.49068906903266907,
0.5815463066101074,
-0.4225882589817047,
0.34073472023010254,
-0.641808032989502,
-0.6820342540740967,
-0.42846447229385376,
0.40272340178489685,
-0.5825751423835754,
-0.2965259253978729,
0.6628080606460571,
0.5885100364685059,
-0.16115902364253998,
0.02206765115261078,
0.3490203022956848,
0.4621785283088684,
0.8242114782333374,
0.4554561972618103,
0.7712493538856506,
-0.4209943413734436,
0.5139644742012024,
-0.14134371280670166,
-0.6097745895385742,
-0.39455869793891907,
-1.2685120105743408,
-0.46013325452804565,
-0.727072536945343,
-0.36418163776397705,
0.1181754544377327,
-0.06883759796619415,
0.6149861216545105,
0.6302212476730347,
-0.8698790073394775,
0.09725859016180038,
-0.7292903661727905,
-0.20320966839790344,
-0.38896921277046204,
-0.22820419073104858,
0.28180694580078125,
-0.8024402856826782,
-0.18627141416072845,
0.45580989122390747,
0.09337027370929718,
-0.09670829772949219,
0.16786201298236847,
-0.13199692964553833,
0.18131189048290253,
-0.23738467693328857,
0.7316118478775024,
0.3642825186252594,
-0.6738444566726685,
-0.44317710399627686,
-0.3615381717681885,
0.041610319167375565,
0.0002742124779615551,
0.7952501773834229,
-0.6816834807395935,
-0.012536147609353065,
0.13479962944984436,
0.9988767504692078,
0.5122876763343811,
0.2070528268814087,
0.6064637899398804,
-0.9566799402236938,
-0.03589503839612007,
0.32479462027549744,
0.44006603956222534,
0.41248467564582825,
-1.0135040283203125,
0.49155327677726746,
0.1132068857550621,
-0.9339084029197693,
-0.7855573892593384,
0.3953835964202881,
-0.8085426688194275,
-0.27499550580978394,
0.98238605260849,
0.016748130321502686,
0.0843178778886795,
-0.3740643262863159,
-0.30473169684410095,
0.4301908612251282,
-0.318248987197876,
1.2023892402648926,
0.37190794944763184,
-0.2975546419620514,
-0.5177775025367737,
-0.436997652053833,
0.7234154343605042,
0.30738595128059387,
-1.2412267923355103,
0.13727106153964996,
0.6051645874977112,
0.3948199152946472,
0.041870929300785065,
0.25862500071525574,
0.18477359414100647,
0.42169973254203796,
-0.43001145124435425,
0.13229422271251678,
-0.15222279727458954,
-0.6590802669525146,
-0.6395276188850403,
0.3007483184337616,
-0.08148900419473648,
0.08861854672431946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13802v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13802v3 | Investigating the Efficacy of Large Language Models for Code Clone Detection | 2024-01-24T20:43:36 | 2024-01-30T06:10:29 | Mohamad Khajezade, Jie JW Wu, Fatemeh Hendijani Fard, Gema Rodríguez-Pérez, Mohamed Sami Shehata | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable success in various
natural language processing and software engineering tasks, such as code
generation. The LLMs are mainly utilized in the prompt-based zero/few-shot
paradigm to guide the model in accomplishing the task. GPT-based models are one
of the popular ones studied for tasks such as code comment generation or test
generation. These tasks are `generative' tasks. However, there is limited
research on the usage of LLMs for `non-generative' tasks such as classification
using the prompt-based paradigm. In this preliminary exploratory study, we
investigated the applicability of LLMs for Code Clone Detection (CCD), a
non-generative task. By building a mono-lingual and cross-lingual CCD dataset
derived from CodeNet, we first investigated two different prompts using ChatGPT
to detect Type-4 code clones in Java-Java and Java-Ruby pairs in a zero-shot
setting. We then conducted an analysis to understand the strengths and
weaknesses of ChatGPT in CCD. ChatGPT surpasses the baselines in cross-language
CCD attaining an F1-score of 0.877 and achieves comparable performance to fully
fine-tuned models for mono-lingual CCD, with an F1-score of 0.878. Also, the
prompt and the difficulty level of the problems has an impact on the
performance of ChatGPT. Finally we provide insights and future directions based
on our initial analysis | [
-0.3252677619457245,
-0.8328795433044434,
0.3807969391345978,
0.19930629432201385,
-0.36336615681648254,
0.21559274196624756,
-0.26647868752479553,
-0.3369322717189789,
0.20338809490203857,
0.4224897027015686,
-0.22676992416381836,
-0.6417954564094543,
-0.33385738730430603,
0.2411080151796341,
-0.7081772089004517,
1.0503647327423096,
-0.06482711434364319,
0.09565431624650955,
-0.14430780708789825,
0.10344987362623215,
-0.6169758439064026,
-0.7796931862831116,
-0.6513669490814209,
0.026161450892686844,
0.22616492211818695,
0.3414539396762848,
0.5510925054550171,
0.41576024889945984,
0.2898416817188263,
0.16972914338111877,
-0.10816691070795059,
-0.0857725515961647,
-0.44389644265174866,
0.0011098458198830485,
-0.055202189832925797,
-0.6652279496192932,
-0.16734330356121063,
-0.12859582901000977,
0.4395163655281067,
0.39485740661621094,
0.14767910540103912,
-0.0012393860379233956,
0.13700129091739655,
0.32751819491386414,
-0.3796223998069763,
0.251869261264801,
-0.7296884655952454,
0.058013372123241425,
-0.10778773576021194,
-0.42236703634262085,
-0.5098820924758911,
-0.2954961061477661,
-0.23265115916728973,
-0.4160706102848053,
0.44757595658302307,
-0.011536836624145508,
0.6020463705062866,
-0.15315522253513336,
-0.4001636505126953,
-0.5368819236755371,
-0.5182340145111084,
0.808815598487854,
-0.8603391051292419,
0.039522141218185425,
0.04611308127641678,
0.01440668385475874,
-0.310658723115921,
-0.4485930800437927,
-0.8251925706863403,
-0.659136176109314,
0.10988450795412064,
-0.11593098193407059,
-0.1824289858341217,
-0.14481613039970398,
0.646874725818634,
0.482261061668396,
-0.7325847744941711,
0.3459031879901886,
-0.3579823672771454,
-0.3565659821033478,
0.3049674332141876,
0.0710984319448471,
0.7248976230621338,
-0.45922204852104187,
-0.4846475124359131,
0.00247002812102437,
-0.8515467643737793,
-0.05283346399664879,
0.29666629433631897,
0.41267985105514526,
-0.25901004672050476,
0.5888849496841431,
-0.2707941234111786,
0.5978760719299316,
-0.02840762957930565,
-0.18522481620311737,
0.21529319882392883,
-0.5704455375671387,
-0.09155308455228806,
-0.2731173038482666,
0.8193103075027466,
0.1774982362985611,
0.5108336210250854,
-0.06676482409238815,
-0.23762470483779907,
0.19493278861045837,
0.13912782073020935,
-0.6866798400878906,
-0.29701265692710876,
-0.11516823619604111,
-0.5413575172424316,
-0.5858167409896851,
0.011119193397462368,
-0.6251310706138611,
-0.3014351427555084,
-0.33269593119621277,
0.442432701587677,
-0.6211298704147339,
-0.37916913628578186,
-0.057109687477350235,
-0.09772417694330215,
0.5531635880470276,
0.3153950273990631,
-0.6031025052070618,
-0.23023155331611633,
0.8020528554916382,
1.0853620767593384,
-0.5889038443565369,
-0.37824660539627075,
-0.34178146719932556,
-0.19533707201480865,
-0.5555686950683594,
0.7277174592018127,
-0.3755723536014557,
-0.6812898516654968,
-0.02397255040705204,
0.09170197695493698,
-0.07163337618112564,
-0.7138350009918213,
0.47586143016815186,
-0.635771632194519,
0.10765782743692398,
-0.3352563679218292,
-0.6045451760292053,
-0.07662308216094971,
0.5566906929016113,
-0.6018255352973938,
0.8538045287132263,
0.2570958733558655,
-0.6245653629302979,
0.4100284278392792,
-0.35902029275894165,
-0.5831023454666138,
0.33758047223091125,
-0.271330326795578,
-0.4866577684879303,
0.005785147659480572,
0.07146300375461578,
0.5485267639160156,
-0.2195757031440735,
0.16072353720664978,
-0.349126398563385,
-0.5787527561187744,
0.13272804021835327,
-0.5605278015136719,
0.8091791868209839,
0.3055018186569214,
-0.5007866024971008,
0.05944738909602165,
-0.29997846484184265,
0.07233204692602158,
0.19305723905563354,
-0.14386489987373352,
-0.23310746252536774,
-0.32554513216018677,
0.022294266149401665,
0.38092342019081116,
0.12001416832208633,
-0.5996742248535156,
0.5111716985702515,
0.14338630437850952,
0.3602519929409027,
0.6027886271476746,
0.25425371527671814,
0.2578655779361725,
-0.561117947101593,
1.0377370119094849,
0.04226820915937424,
0.17774496972560883,
-0.5616602301597595,
-0.6640897393226624,
-0.5308833122253418,
-0.47615134716033936,
0.14338234066963196,
0.7198566198348999,
-1.305580973625183,
0.19604983925819397,
-0.3428919315338135,
-0.5158042907714844,
0.007208730559796095,
0.3144747316837311,
0.6165452599525452,
0.07189150154590607,
0.16134320199489594,
-0.495390385389328,
-0.2090609073638916,
-0.7968487739562988,
-0.03639698401093483,
-0.22102026641368866,
0.21020685136318207,
0.21234072744846344,
0.6803457140922546,
-0.06584997475147247,
0.9135580062866211,
-0.2430121749639511,
-0.24478031694889069,
-0.5406419038772583,
0.13596320152282715,
0.16602034866809845,
0.43552398681640625,
0.6942577362060547,
-0.5412222743034363,
-0.7118943333625793,
0.11517333984375,
-0.9158821105957031,
-0.293666809797287,
-0.4050529897212982,
0.1757006198167801,
0.3766293525695801,
0.6503651738166809,
-0.5737944841384888,
0.4357376992702484,
0.6601521968841553,
-0.001189138274639845,
0.9232571125030518,
-0.15565422177314758,
0.3301647901535034,
-1.1686913967132568,
0.07276546955108643,
-0.09739094972610474,
-0.25355198979377747,
-0.6393327116966248,
0.2647567689418793,
0.18549665808677673,
-0.3088637888431549,
-0.5949240922927856,
0.4246051013469696,
-0.5785778164863586,
-0.2677752673625946,
-0.48236796259880066,
-0.04559319093823433,
-0.12440799921751022,
0.5099406242370605,
0.11324193328619003,
1.0484730005264282,
0.5960740447044373,
-0.37270110845565796,
0.3586674630641937,
-0.07001098990440369,
-0.6599054336547852,
0.6012973189353943,
-0.6057154536247253,
0.25025033950805664,
0.17794638872146606,
0.2321828156709671,
-0.9447171092033386,
0.13160845637321472,
0.08467082679271698,
-0.4753490388393402,
0.24923060834407806,
-0.4150398075580597,
-0.8050422072410583,
-0.3686290383338928,
-0.3732287287712097,
0.5631961226463318,
0.6684863567352295,
-0.8184571266174316,
0.06717601418495178,
-0.00018821099365595728,
-0.22640696167945862,
-0.2818376123905182,
-0.5267024636268616,
0.21078437566757202,
-0.030770229175686836,
-0.6226261854171753,
-0.029654836282134056,
0.04072976112365723,
0.012960264459252357,
-0.20221953094005585,
0.06704723834991455,
0.06810354441404343,
-0.044056396931409836,
0.18345363438129425,
0.4752633571624756,
-0.21816429495811462,
-0.15994757413864136,
-0.21937040984630585,
0.016304373741149902,
-0.06196848675608635,
-0.2788809537887573,
0.6163381338119507,
0.09645003080368042,
-0.76997309923172,
-0.39369678497314453,
0.29973292350769043,
0.8046671748161316,
-0.23357994854450226,
0.4830680191516876,
0.357219398021698,
0.08449187874794006,
-0.5543419122695923,
-0.5325363278388977,
-0.01834731362760067,
-0.4041072130203247,
0.44107627868652344,
-0.3895465135574341,
-1.0365406274795532,
0.44981375336647034,
0.13705424964427948,
-0.10830793529748917,
0.03343890607357025,
0.7089101672172546,
0.1862381547689438,
0.6619762182235718,
0.3133513033390045,
-0.515097439289093,
0.6242454648017883,
-0.27427300810813904,
0.3542976975440979,
-0.6540777087211609,
0.009001304395496845,
-0.3539353013038635,
-0.017125345766544342,
-0.6404919624328613,
-0.7937707304954529,
0.2799474000930786,
0.22551560401916504,
0.14843349158763885,
0.5668588876724243,
-0.40768319368362427,
0.5090420842170715,
0.5455445051193237,
-0.02727649174630642,
0.5452301502227783,
-0.019447404891252518,
-0.02172926813364029,
0.30989179015159607,
-0.5986507534980774,
-0.46633023023605347,
1.1769821643829346,
0.11931183934211731,
0.7833988666534424,
0.010296285152435303,
0.6625509262084961,
0.5839343070983887,
0.3037649989128113,
-0.7117056846618652,
0.7692368030548096,
-0.04393849894404411,
-0.5809967517852783,
-0.14130637049674988,
-0.5366110801696777,
-0.8776062726974487,
0.31730201840400696,
0.025093939155340195,
-0.48414602875709534,
-0.08736783266067505,
0.13104155659675598,
-0.10100776702165604,
0.569404661655426,
-0.9090459942817688,
0.7713121175765991,
-0.19392381608486176,
-0.1985100656747818,
-0.0977960154414177,
-0.138029083609581,
0.5428913235664368,
-0.35321280360221863,
0.17167438566684723,
0.03206009417772293,
0.2770691215991974,
0.39077872037887573,
-0.460105836391449,
0.7989199757575989,
-0.2457822859287262,
-0.27626311779022217,
0.6135428547859192,
0.383894145488739,
0.7032262086868286,
-0.15781649947166443,
0.06940802931785583,
0.36730366945266724,
0.14254575967788696,
-0.39401787519454956,
-0.5024498105049133,
0.9473975896835327,
-0.46640172600746155,
-0.5982030630111694,
-0.3203611969947815,
-0.3272302448749542,
0.10304108262062073,
0.11298913508653641,
0.3370613157749176,
0.40505897998809814,
-0.10361218452453613,
0.04217975586652756,
0.4464620053768158,
-0.7225288152694702,
0.44166722893714905,
0.4891088902950287,
-0.5189788937568665,
-0.004735736176371574,
1.1426960229873657,
-0.21546299755573273,
0.6300291419029236,
0.27012306451797485,
-0.14832642674446106,
0.12472087144851685,
-0.7395316362380981,
-0.599331259727478,
0.06083357334136963,
-0.5275148153305054,
-0.1639818400144577,
-0.4102335274219513,
-0.14510773122310638,
-0.2974798381328583,
-0.21456043422222137,
-0.2490091174840927,
-0.21400023996829987,
-0.12827694416046143,
0.07538586854934692,
0.247306689620018,
0.646233856678009,
0.1842670738697052,
0.016136234626173973,
-0.6563513875007629,
0.38078412413597107,
0.19183427095413208,
0.2803416848182678,
0.19029229879379272,
-0.6002858877182007,
-0.014741575345396996,
0.09318246692419052,
-0.2714512348175049,
-0.8121456503868103,
0.3727378249168396,
-0.2946977913379669,
0.4581991136074066,
0.07851292937994003,
-0.032854050397872925,
0.3424433469772339,
-0.18343549966812134,
1.0945159196853638,
0.08412191271781921,
-0.9547526240348816,
0.22555270791053772,
-0.538576066493988,
0.3721608817577362,
0.25712043046951294,
0.025942716747522354,
-0.6428465247154236,
-0.48713764548301697,
-0.20509949326515198,
-0.5132112503051758,
0.6201582551002502,
0.35880333185195923,
0.33054062724113464,
-0.2657003104686737,
0.3887796700000763,
0.16411511600017548,
0.003802817314863205,
-0.8661599159240723,
-0.16642026603221893,
-0.10656086355447769,
0.09125656634569168,
0.08408692479133606,
-0.17409540712833405,
0.5484110116958618,
-0.04816928133368492,
0.5003811717033386,
-0.2511790692806244,
0.35572385787963867,
0.0418880432844162,
-0.2998756766319275,
0.2328873574733734,
0.49014511704444885,
0.6958524584770203,
0.26837417483329773,
0.21439450979232788,
-0.1487080454826355,
0.16506485641002655,
-0.38045215606689453,
0.1725958287715912,
-0.34584784507751465,
-0.43767112493515015,
0.03973259776830673,
0.6193650364875793,
0.6205819845199585,
-0.012789925560355186,
-0.6923319101333618,
1.0318936109542847,
0.18690752983093262,
-0.22292324900627136,
-0.47281065583229065,
-0.018364181742072105,
-0.08380036801099777,
0.10100703686475754,
0.13061140477657318,
-0.06802739948034286,
0.05401149019598961,
-0.7174409031867981,
0.26118937134742737,
0.8532021045684814,
-0.27600598335266113,
-0.41302746534347534,
0.3588677942752838,
0.11286620050668716,
-0.22456306219100952,
0.8265541791915894,
-0.5255308747291565,
-0.7699021697044373,
0.9555076360702515,
0.6072254776954651,
0.769255518913269,
0.06274841725826263,
0.35429099202156067,
0.2136244922876358,
0.19819758832454681,
-0.15637101233005524,
0.2587455213069916,
-0.15653420984745026,
-0.8502911329269409,
-0.6118432879447937,
-0.40272629261016846,
-0.26949238777160645,
0.12303803116083145,
-0.6328398585319519,
0.5517726540565491,
-0.49525654315948486,
0.023673949763178825,
-0.19510120153427124,
-0.43178486824035645,
-0.5402815341949463,
-0.19643595814704895,
0.3177794814109802,
0.7647290229797363,
-0.783238410949707,
1.0245620012283325,
0.4967676103115082,
-0.4408150017261505,
-0.8240405917167664,
0.006647870410233736,
0.07334593683481216,
-0.9377198815345764,
0.6601336598396301,
0.16794335842132568,
0.08495907485485077,
-0.09684821218252182,
-0.4493110179901123,
-0.5579013228416443,
1.0276473760604858,
0.23580080270767212,
-0.5930425524711609,
0.0007966544944792986,
0.21767233312129974,
0.6410946249961853,
-0.13827477395534515,
0.45028695464134216,
0.35063624382019043,
0.1548694521188736,
0.2403268665075302,
-1.2725911140441895,
0.12124791741371155,
-0.2797771096229553,
0.17672601342201233,
0.41959330439567566,
-0.655235230922699,
0.9323351979255676,
-0.43037480115890503,
-0.2639068365097046,
0.46949610114097595,
0.13022547960281372,
0.3936673402786255,
0.06233732029795647,
0.39875972270965576,
0.37832385301589966,
0.304713636636734,
0.08625141531229019,
1.2958742380142212,
-0.4761158227920532,
0.4790927469730377,
0.8981289267539978,
-0.5153725743293762,
0.6934472322463989,
0.30142098665237427,
-0.15044395625591278,
0.6513923406600952,
0.2633472681045532,
-0.4425412118434906,
0.3525891602039337,
0.46359580755233765,
-0.2769714593887329,
-0.013397559523582458,
-0.022028369829058647,
-0.3196253776550293,
0.3145100772380829,
-0.016885774210095406,
-0.5191971659660339,
-0.11220152676105499,
0.27063778042793274,
0.09592380374670029,
-0.10062071681022644,
-0.29894131422042847,
0.7620838284492493,
0.07034298777580261,
-0.7742790579795837,
0.5263450741767883,
0.07606670260429382,
0.954589307308197,
-0.48947301506996155,
-0.06743195652961731,
-0.3448166251182556,
0.18506085872650146,
-0.027518851682543755,
-0.7093238234519958,
0.14159496128559113,
0.20979222655296326,
-0.16380158066749573,
-0.224124014377594,
0.5657956004142761,
-0.30123385787010193,
-0.2388467639684677,
0.2706305980682373,
0.47980162501335144,
0.2090773582458496,
-0.3329167664051056,
-0.46534040570259094,
0.14505302906036377,
0.43745437264442444,
-0.08061791956424713,
0.49443554878234863,
0.4375414252281189,
-0.3346647322177887,
0.6889879703521729,
0.8788167834281921,
0.17432886362075806,
0.14992888271808624,
0.06433068960905075,
0.6740100979804993,
-0.7321848273277283,
-0.3603228032588959,
-0.9826220273971558,
0.0068085091188549995,
0.06571713835000992,
-0.263365238904953,
0.9877414703369141,
0.7658873200416565,
0.9235184788703918,
-0.3633672595024109,
1.1408004760742188,
-0.06956756860017776,
0.34106481075286865,
-0.6090695261955261,
0.3444443941116333,
-0.2208702266216278,
0.5126622319221497,
-0.4275050759315491,
-1.0330390930175781,
-0.17905794084072113,
0.340004563331604,
-0.3313947319984436,
0.23823583126068115,
0.8484991192817688,
1.1237843036651611,
0.08569910377264023,
0.20508834719657898,
0.4526692032814026,
-0.07491359114646912,
0.6076696515083313,
0.7751151919364929,
1.114437460899353,
-0.08445560187101364,
0.7110249996185303,
-0.19832143187522888,
-0.2592381536960602,
0.0370759442448616,
-0.8134960532188416,
-1.1527972221374512,
-0.4031457304954529,
-0.3590363562107086,
-0.24610938131809235,
-0.1521555632352829,
0.8064090013504028,
0.6548160314559937,
-0.8321993947029114,
-0.15417130291461945,
-0.1429372876882553,
-0.08641481399536133,
-0.057452231645584106,
-0.3300476372241974,
0.2312544882297516,
-0.3295091986656189,
-0.5623307824134827,
0.16511592268943787,
0.3223961889743805,
0.15146179497241974,
-0.384846955537796,
0.06489188224077225,
0.10660257935523987,
-0.14934580028057098,
0.6315494179725647,
0.43491947650909424,
-0.7336181402206421,
-0.2972331941127777,
0.10817943513393402,
-0.3048834800720215,
-0.17155419290065765,
1.1454439163208008,
-0.7337787747383118,
0.3543722331523895,
0.44286084175109863,
0.48837143182754517,
0.4667048454284668,
0.15819700062274933,
0.5725146532058716,
-0.6784294247627258,
0.06839174032211304,
-0.014941591769456863,
0.4009688198566437,
0.4211573302745819,
-0.26698821783065796,
0.20232956111431122,
0.4722875952720642,
-0.5118818283081055,
-0.657245397567749,
0.30662521719932556,
-0.9768235087394714,
-0.33020853996276855,
1.7175260782241821,
-0.38794511556625366,
0.14305183291435242,
-0.26183322072029114,
-0.39453405141830444,
-0.06952385604381561,
-0.35256680846214294,
0.6505218744277954,
0.670382022857666,
-0.0292514581233263,
-0.2260124534368515,
-0.4793020486831665,
0.19997751712799072,
0.4186416268348694,
-0.8882444500923157,
-0.00685435114428401,
0.4419121742248535,
0.5773549675941467,
0.11554178595542908,
0.6364231109619141,
-0.31283846497535706,
0.2683974802494049,
-0.06079729273915291,
0.35077977180480957,
-0.20335987210273743,
0.10149943083524704,
-0.43380993604660034,
0.1706283986568451,
0.29696717858314514,
-0.1958460956811905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13789v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13789v3 | A Unified Approach to Emotion Detection and Task-Oriented Dialogue Modeling | 2024-01-24T20:17:11 | 2024-06-28T10:23:29 | Armand Stricker, Patrick Paroubek | cs.CL | cs.CL | In current text-based task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems, user emotion
detection (ED) is often overlooked or is typically treated as a separate and
independent task, requiring additional training. In contrast, our work
demonstrates that seamlessly unifying ED and TOD modeling brings about mutual
benefits, and is therefore an alternative to be considered. Our method consists
in augmenting SimpleToD, an end-to-end TOD system, by extending belief state
tracking to include ED, relying on a single language model. We evaluate our
approach using GPT-2 and Llama-2 on the EmoWOZ benchmark, a version of MultiWOZ
annotated with emotions. Our results reveal a general increase in performance
for ED and task results. Our findings also indicate that user emotions provide
useful contextual conditioning for system responses, and can be leveraged to
further refine responses in terms of empathy. | [
-0.4476023316383362,
-0.5144847631454468,
0.7243636846542358,
-0.041578710079193115,
-0.46254462003707886,
-0.13558897376060486,
-0.09336776286363602,
-0.4210270941257477,
0.20348085463047028,
0.3246273994445801,
-0.8094412088394165,
-0.6921579837799072,
-0.5188546776771545,
0.2138819396495819,
-0.07008925825357437,
1.033240556716919,
-0.09867580235004425,
-0.23376604914665222,
-0.12032230198383331,
-0.2189396768808365,
-0.30559393763542175,
-0.5749713778495789,
-0.5781448483467102,
-0.5550981163978577,
0.3785945177078247,
0.4835350215435028,
0.19616904854774475,
0.03194918483495712,
0.17670223116874695,
0.26077529788017273,
0.12462934851646423,
0.07820268720388412,
-0.20857088267803192,
0.48901358246803284,
0.18166153132915497,
-0.3787286877632141,
-0.6992454528808594,
-0.08724000304937363,
-0.11488739401102066,
0.26433926820755005,
-0.337802916765213,
-0.0904964953660965,
0.17443600296974182,
0.3774072825908661,
-0.5093713998794556,
0.10035733878612518,
-0.24982835352420807,
0.24223244190216064,
0.016936441883444786,
-0.1258576214313507,
-0.28854766488075256,
0.10009260475635529,
0.36837416887283325,
-0.5278614163398743,
0.028769005089998245,
-0.07168897986412048,
0.33402690291404724,
0.5791414976119995,
-0.9738081693649292,
-0.30322378873825073,
-0.291139155626297,
0.7317126393318176,
-0.5420965552330017,
0.22052952647209167,
0.11879174411296844,
-0.1710003763437271,
0.09416312724351883,
-0.32636430859565735,
-0.7387233972549438,
-0.03388024494051933,
0.05270691215991974,
0.6220906972885132,
-0.5056745409965515,
0.5689617395401001,
0.35134315490722656,
0.19880597293376923,
-0.24751417338848114,
0.15318609774112701,
0.2899801731109619,
-0.026992877945303917,
0.4733809232711792,
0.19883166253566742,
0.43875792622566223,
-0.3715656101703644,
-0.6751269698143005,
-0.032000236213207245,
-0.32660505175590515,
0.3050229549407959,
0.3542821705341339,
0.07388981431722641,
-0.2680409252643585,
0.48228639364242554,
-0.28534331917762756,
0.1412496566772461,
-0.07461721450090408,
0.017215613275766373,
0.19065794348716736,
-0.08207158744335175,
-0.5259677171707153,
-0.1576647162437439,
0.7503154277801514,
0.5672969222068787,
0.16024905443191528,
-0.02685522846877575,
-0.3549548387527466,
0.37854400277137756,
0.15047384798526764,
-0.7018021941184998,
-0.08133819699287415,
0.5144322514533997,
-0.3392349183559418,
0.04877329617738724,
-0.3287023603916168,
-0.9373275637626648,
-0.4330321252346039,
-0.4765302836894989,
0.29195261001586914,
-0.23382654786109924,
-0.5195708274841309,
-0.06194394826889038,
-0.18646201491355896,
-0.25773563981056213,
0.804558277130127,
-0.747134804725647,
0.314098596572876,
0.6618732213973999,
0.7110087871551514,
-0.2781705856323242,
-0.044599294662475586,
-0.37498632073402405,
-0.07916499674320221,
-0.08573850989341736,
0.9325993061065674,
-0.5941003561019897,
-0.574779748916626,
0.09252502024173737,
-0.17361779510974884,
-0.013856696896255016,
-0.1610957682132721,
0.8333151340484619,
0.02990199625492096,
0.30613425374031067,
-0.3799310028553009,
-0.4116547405719757,
-0.28817811608314514,
0.3774349093437195,
-0.42903974652290344,
1.269091010093689,
0.08926258236169815,
-0.7267655730247498,
0.25537732243537903,
-1.028517723083496,
-0.27125412225723267,
-0.18993036448955536,
0.10613977909088135,
-0.07064665108919144,
0.4984845817089081,
0.1425824612379074,
0.33539068698883057,
-0.49352648854255676,
0.3020143508911133,
-0.42115774750709534,
-0.27434778213500977,
-0.1500493288040161,
-0.5412200093269348,
0.2785097062587738,
0.26201140880584717,
-0.37249693274497986,
0.23893040418624878,
-0.4933963418006897,
0.05979923903942108,
-0.2563512623310089,
-0.28370094299316406,
-0.6400139331817627,
0.02686166949570179,
0.11856451630592346,
0.19858674705028534,
0.27733105421066284,
-0.9494072794914246,
0.3193342983722687,
-0.1549074351787567,
-0.15526673197746277,
0.9296363592147827,
-0.35868901014328003,
0.1609055995941162,
0.19934768974781036,
0.5496111512184143,
0.2167871594429016,
-0.006012560799717903,
-0.376571387052536,
-0.6137194633483887,
-0.862764835357666,
-0.4074714481830597,
-0.24451544880867004,
0.653374969959259,
-0.6603739857673645,
0.39045125246047974,
0.11994320899248123,
-0.0369655042886734,
-0.6170127391815186,
-0.00868028774857521,
0.5316644906997681,
0.47157415747642517,
0.30771884322166443,
-0.4850669801235199,
-0.42120903730392456,
-0.6748418807983398,
-0.3987230658531189,
-0.29445457458496094,
-0.3891489505767822,
0.3896271884441376,
0.2669978439807892,
-0.34745100140571594,
0.9012241363525391,
-0.3754121661186218,
-0.18563203513622284,
-0.19416390359401703,
0.5934810042381287,
-0.08070187270641327,
0.26702725887298584,
0.3332609236240387,
-0.7442004084587097,
-0.5479984879493713,
0.37473681569099426,
-0.9120123386383057,
-0.4724540412425995,
0.27168557047843933,
0.12395412474870682,
0.2209145575761795,
-0.06644941866397858,
-0.708088755607605,
0.8252010345458984,
0.42515042424201965,
-0.5520803928375244,
0.07570125162601471,
-0.2523075044155121,
0.6752052903175354,
-1.075089693069458,
-0.11446238309144974,
0.38611727952957153,
-0.15175452828407288,
-1.1209975481033325,
-0.3254275321960449,
-0.025535283610224724,
-0.08061835169792175,
-0.20284922420978546,
0.5220026969909668,
-0.3332040011882782,
-0.242635577917099,
-0.45579013228416443,
0.23778751492500305,
-0.034215111285448074,
0.8626672625541687,
-0.010239919647574425,
0.6927517056465149,
0.5035414695739746,
-0.3778219521045685,
0.3896855115890503,
0.23297494649887085,
-0.11530408263206482,
1.1866878271102905,
-0.6594396233558655,
0.5681513547897339,
-0.16864852607250214,
0.06056755408644676,
-1.1773163080215454,
-0.3362109065055847,
0.19573883712291718,
-0.304670512676239,
0.16552385687828064,
-0.17094771564006805,
-0.4599821865558624,
-0.26637378334999084,
-0.328352153301239,
0.09724067151546478,
0.5572671890258789,
-0.7570846676826477,
0.9812101721763611,
0.2121293544769287,
-0.45539286732673645,
-0.24532699584960938,
-0.3110314607620239,
0.08320371806621552,
-0.3769637644290924,
-0.5562109351158142,
0.15605947375297546,
-0.12880438566207886,
-0.2805740535259247,
-0.1530609279870987,
-0.27916228771209717,
-0.313559889793396,
0.27597349882125854,
0.5415858626365662,
0.1656150221824646,
0.13711433112621307,
0.5600629448890686,
0.4689252972602844,
-0.21379122138023376,
0.04430178925395012,
-0.10989212989807129,
0.26214954257011414,
-0.074571892619133,
-0.611077070236206,
-0.7128657698631287,
0.7414190769195557,
0.6245624423027039,
-0.12062670290470123,
0.22752536833286285,
0.7597756385803223,
-0.43029242753982544,
-0.15130309760570526,
-0.4181230664253235,
-0.16579702496528625,
-0.4093840420246124,
0.34734317660331726,
-0.5410798192024231,
-0.9574408531188965,
0.3783190846443176,
-0.42096060514450073,
-0.037868399173021317,
0.2741299867630005,
0.6394299864768982,
-0.3103100657463074,
1.504522681236267,
0.8421351909637451,
0.007010992616415024,
0.5154030323028564,
0.2662810683250427,
0.34006625413894653,
-1.3092293739318848,
-0.300330251455307,
-0.564326286315918,
-0.3301191031932831,
-0.21519295871257782,
-0.10899101197719574,
0.43713465332984924,
0.19325467944145203,
-0.15664632618427277,
-0.02287066914141178,
-0.5127361416816711,
0.10282791405916214,
0.4592196047306061,
0.19563889503479004,
0.282451868057251,
-0.05913930386304855,
0.05805085599422455,
-0.12539708614349365,
-0.29966360330581665,
-0.588926374912262,
1.1561239957809448,
0.26823821663856506,
0.8074325323104858,
0.21451780200004578,
0.8669095039367676,
0.46605685353279114,
0.758313775062561,
-0.7815790176391602,
0.4745613932609558,
-0.06189287081360817,
-0.25262099504470825,
-0.15340247750282288,
-0.1868957281112671,
-0.661064624786377,
0.5310511589050293,
0.19651490449905396,
-1.567652940750122,
0.20422063767910004,
0.2549842298030853,
-0.27237823605537415,
0.1557062268257141,
-1.181877613067627,
0.8671863675117493,
-0.22779729962348938,
-0.18848925828933716,
-0.2748340666294098,
-0.2908214330673218,
0.29448238015174866,
-0.048441994935274124,
0.08670680224895477,
-0.42780885100364685,
-0.0017467839643359184,
0.7585153579711914,
-0.3958981931209564,
1.0218226909637451,
-0.39263221621513367,
-0.209908127784729,
0.2953573763370514,
-0.0460829921066761,
0.6033754348754883,
-0.10060851275920868,
-0.08664307743310928,
-0.13124558329582214,
-0.11237362027168274,
-0.2082347720861435,
-0.6649512052536011,
0.6135339736938477,
-0.5017579197883606,
-0.8427362442016602,
-0.33714115619659424,
-0.799479603767395,
-0.1654481589794159,
-0.20635120570659637,
-0.03412304073572159,
0.3293119966983795,
-0.061737269163131714,
-0.014368546195328236,
0.6246602535247803,
-0.028665291145443916,
0.4587413966655731,
0.4934641122817993,
0.021205157041549683,
-0.1314915120601654,
0.32217592000961304,
-0.4046519994735718,
0.32243621349334717,
0.11683535575866699,
0.09412995725870132,
-0.4298562705516815,
0.0049804807640612125,
-0.36485692858695984,
-0.29435545206069946,
-0.7343510389328003,
-0.14580944180488586,
-0.874553382396698,
0.7507314085960388,
-0.20582503080368042,
0.08975081890821457,
-0.2609899640083313,
0.004156501032412052,
-0.34539586305618286,
-0.1994178295135498,
0.6663872599601746,
0.8029975891113281,
-0.07946828752756119,
0.36413997411727905,
-0.5879986882209778,
0.5201584696769714,
0.44749924540519714,
0.41445237398147583,
-0.010210828855633736,
-0.4113152325153351,
0.004002879839390516,
0.21709029376506805,
-0.45203980803489685,
-0.9588319659233093,
0.4870702028274536,
0.22360576689243317,
0.2933717668056488,
0.5433051586151123,
0.40015047788619995,
0.5034433603286743,
-0.14752325415611267,
0.6654609441757202,
0.5086376070976257,
-1.3214901685714722,
0.7278494238853455,
-0.11253614723682404,
0.14400313794612885,
0.21441690623760223,
0.29291725158691406,
-0.6785585284233093,
-0.11539407819509506,
-0.33583974838256836,
-0.5575136542320251,
0.8919900059700012,
0.04530072957277298,
0.20935137569904327,
-0.02787953056395054,
-0.116372250020504,
0.08462569117546082,
0.27703672647476196,
-0.6065736413002014,
-0.049446940422058105,
-0.08241018652915955,
-0.7492511868476868,
0.10293307900428772,
-0.33024802803993225,
-0.2954253554344177,
-0.011546448804438114,
0.15721356868743896,
-0.3881514072418213,
0.6669933199882507,
0.4841269850730896,
-0.028543774038553238,
-0.2898053526878357,
0.6388236284255981,
0.22188478708267212,
-0.06586036831140518,
-0.17392389476299286,
0.028370169922709465,
0.18538880348205566,
-0.10867930948734283,
0.1811407208442688,
0.10710605978965759,
0.24101510643959045,
-0.015273135155439377,
0.10144724696874619,
1.0954865217208862,
0.3373677730560303,
-0.7624138593673706,
0.5924702882766724,
-0.006017659325152636,
0.11519975960254669,
0.23014095425605774,
-0.06526637077331543,
0.016537241637706757,
0.6325017213821411,
0.4819982349872589,
0.13964545726776123,
0.46021920442581177,
-0.7830130457878113,
0.10918060690164566,
0.3683665990829468,
-0.7508953213691711,
-0.6145118474960327,
0.504052996635437,
0.5489313006401062,
-0.4868040084838867,
0.27078187465667725,
-0.273233026266098,
-1.1251933574676514,
0.7031818628311157,
0.4536912739276886,
1.1176179647445679,
-0.29812920093536377,
0.14655829966068268,
0.06112605705857277,
-0.03742680698633194,
0.004325284622609615,
0.5722881555557251,
-0.5172659754753113,
-0.710085391998291,
-0.22647778689861298,
-0.22751472890377045,
-0.6850598454475403,
-0.46873798966407776,
-0.9694376587867737,
-0.10838702321052551,
-0.04727880284190178,
-0.2885332405567169,
-0.32668161392211914,
-0.23611533641815186,
-0.8881388902664185,
0.452351450920105,
0.2283376306295395,
0.4697711765766144,
-0.8605807423591614,
0.8798224925994873,
0.6068459749221802,
-0.07371162623167038,
-0.624208390712738,
0.08122526109218597,
0.5031625032424927,
-0.5255610942840576,
0.7641313672065735,
0.42745286226272583,
-0.336996853351593,
0.048628974705934525,
-0.3520013391971588,
-0.2824067771434784,
1.0634225606918335,
0.0805310606956482,
-0.4156295955181122,
0.28557273745536804,
-0.37233901023864746,
0.860714852809906,
-0.5646829605102539,
0.6971097588539124,
0.601075291633606,
0.30758756399154663,
-0.06326945126056671,
-0.9530625939369202,
-0.23372098803520203,
-0.516577959060669,
-0.28238850831985474,
0.5016188025474548,
-0.429309219121933,
0.8897891044616699,
-0.250474214553833,
-0.5467272996902466,
0.005760698579251766,
0.40403324365615845,
0.06847507506608963,
0.823087751865387,
0.635540246963501,
0.7179425358772278,
0.7855879664421082,
-0.5237690806388855,
1.3202159404754639,
-0.21728722751140594,
0.5202909111976624,
0.8267478346824646,
-0.5705969333648682,
0.7181615829467773,
0.5285584330558777,
-0.25746461749076843,
0.32673075795173645,
0.6371011137962341,
0.4333992302417755,
0.4530894160270691,
-0.2204018086194992,
-0.5975900888442993,
-0.38135266304016113,
-0.6740159392356873,
-0.19084152579307556,
0.24826587736606598,
0.33549976348876953,
0.0897766724228859,
-0.10964580625295639,
0.21532195806503296,
0.007823457941412926,
-0.13408344984054565,
-0.39375564455986023,
0.817669689655304,
0.18259036540985107,
-0.641672670841217,
0.1502823531627655,
-0.29588213562965393,
1.0156878232955933,
-0.4561956822872162,
0.006615422200411558,
-0.5186610221862793,
-0.08397862315177917,
-0.08649127185344696,
-0.8386043906211853,
-0.16814157366752625,
0.6646536588668823,
0.06324416399002075,
-0.23535802960395813,
0.7811998128890991,
-0.6404374241828918,
-0.11698079109191895,
0.6631890535354614,
0.49032196402549744,
0.14623133838176727,
-0.2592885494232178,
-0.3339138925075531,
0.015663394704461098,
0.24302297830581665,
-0.4846288859844208,
0.3012581467628479,
0.8595523834228516,
0.11808062344789505,
0.8783732056617737,
0.4853244125843048,
-0.4630824029445648,
-0.1804172843694687,
0.3064108192920685,
0.7172411680221558,
-0.5399146676063538,
-0.45547792315483093,
-0.6278032660484314,
0.8423974514007568,
-0.16648681461811066,
-0.4394441545009613,
0.43712547421455383,
-0.04876438528299332,
0.5342142581939697,
-0.1265735924243927,
0.849920928478241,
-0.04375412315130234,
0.46432530879974365,
-0.27871468663215637,
0.10386719554662704,
-0.8191719651222229,
0.16356593370437622,
-0.6600149869918823,
-0.7633190751075745,
0.10504084825515747,
0.3865877389907837,
-0.022379670292139053,
-0.038265857845544815,
0.7101582884788513,
0.2731468379497528,
0.06564027816057205,
0.18548259139060974,
0.42249423265457153,
-0.007522020023316145,
0.32782280445098877,
0.9215638041496277,
0.9254319071769714,
-0.3305167853832245,
0.21284033358097076,
-0.14463688433170319,
-0.27437543869018555,
-0.22133508324623108,
-0.7358145713806152,
-0.8129321932792664,
-0.4517178237438202,
-0.2961030602455139,
0.12016701698303223,
-0.023282211273908615,
0.991605281829834,
0.39747339487075806,
-0.697259247303009,
-0.04357641935348511,
0.051543042063713074,
0.08076556026935577,
0.07691498845815659,
-0.10197703540325165,
0.09834173321723938,
-0.15031994879245758,
-1.046855092048645,
0.3782428503036499,
0.7904810309410095,
0.05270760506391525,
0.1877087652683258,
-0.3717319071292877,
0.26166924834251404,
0.10661668330430984,
0.7486181259155273,
0.09714005887508392,
-1.0026087760925293,
-0.6136554479598999,
-0.1425895243883133,
-0.05887880548834801,
0.13547804951667786,
0.6905897855758667,
-0.47571226954460144,
0.7834531664848328,
0.21729545295238495,
0.43989455699920654,
0.38790708780288696,
0.24830220639705658,
0.5991160869598389,
-0.6446903347969055,
0.274229496717453,
0.07343703508377075,
0.5416132211685181,
0.2322329431772232,
-0.3853590786457062,
0.5490419268608093,
0.16190877556800842,
-0.3947329521179199,
-0.8635298609733582,
0.482717901468277,
-1.1474099159240723,
0.14746858179569244,
0.6848194599151611,
-0.596743106842041,
0.2101772576570511,
-0.20628081262111664,
-0.48687368631362915,
0.23082959651947021,
-0.7715414762496948,
0.6943635940551758,
0.6975711584091187,
-0.3622439503669739,
-0.39420056343078613,
-0.3562472462654114,
0.29548555612564087,
0.6672564744949341,
-1.291601300239563,
0.0731290727853775,
0.4920797646045685,
-0.09660233557224274,
0.09861700236797333,
0.723827064037323,
0.5232226848602295,
0.2327294945716858,
-0.09261985868215561,
0.5205013155937195,
0.11307959258556366,
-0.28936126828193665,
-0.3643956482410431,
0.04792747274041176,
-0.29282552003860474,
-0.12723620235919952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13782v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13782v2 | Tweets to Citations: Unveiling the Impact of Social Media Influencers on AI Research Visibility | 2024-01-24T20:05:49 | 2024-03-03T08:16:52 | Iain Xie Weissburg, Mehir Arora, Xinyi Wang, Liangming Pan, William Yang Wang | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SI | As the number of accepted papers at AI and ML conferences reaches into the
thousands, it has become unclear how researchers access and read research
publications. In this paper, we investigate the role of social media
influencers in enhancing the visibility of machine learning research,
particularly the citation counts of papers they share. We have compiled a
comprehensive dataset of over 8,000 papers, spanning tweets from December 2018
to October 2023, alongside controls precisely matched by 9 key covariates. Our
statistical and causal inference analysis reveals a significant increase in
citations for papers endorsed by these influencers, with median citation counts
2-3 times higher than those of the control group. Additionally, the study
delves into the geographic, gender, and institutional diversity of highlighted
authors. Given these findings, we advocate for a responsible approach to
curation, encouraging influencers to uphold the journalistic standard that
includes showcasing diverse research topics, authors, and institutions. | [
-0.014389208517968655,
-0.27406996488571167,
0.6266416311264038,
0.34293973445892334,
-0.04621370509266853,
0.38382458686828613,
0.11418533325195312,
-0.5911262631416321,
0.3759233057498932,
0.18026122450828552,
0.030517715960741043,
-0.37441885471343994,
-1.3012408018112183,
0.058212243020534515,
-0.7551529407501221,
0.9205054640769958,
-0.049808111041784286,
-0.020809877663850784,
-0.10653112828731537,
-0.0714467242360115,
0.22594305872917175,
-0.25054502487182617,
-0.48334044218063354,
-0.19528372585773468,
1.197489857673645,
0.026519721373915672,
0.6772237420082092,
0.5188454985618591,
0.5320959091186523,
0.31855377554893494,
-0.1398269534111023,
0.20257991552352905,
-0.6118724942207336,
0.21035948395729065,
-0.2820504307746887,
-0.2589392364025116,
-0.02710993029177189,
0.11055360734462738,
0.8478513956069946,
0.6500546932220459,
0.5062491297721863,
0.23432819545269012,
0.5496477484703064,
0.6468206644058228,
-0.6757320761680603,
0.27101099491119385,
-0.5678961873054504,
-0.33852794766426086,
-0.331819087266922,
-0.3691531717777252,
-0.5992979407310486,
-0.6169865727424622,
0.02767975628376007,
-0.6584206819534302,
0.23975828289985657,
-0.2212298959493637,
0.6577805280685425,
0.3509749174118042,
-0.4789622724056244,
-0.07976796478033066,
-1.0515137910842896,
0.8174710273742676,
-0.10108035057783127,
0.011638838797807693,
0.4769155979156494,
0.19368243217468262,
-0.15352410078048706,
-1.0402493476867676,
-0.03106365166604519,
0.2636873126029968,
-0.25343093276023865,
-0.1332104355096817,
-0.5510637760162354,
-0.34837812185287476,
0.16776631772518158,
-0.46788766980171204,
-0.26017701625823975,
-0.13811106979846954,
-0.6273317337036133,
0.2890590727329254,
0.8533844947814941,
-0.3789392113685608,
0.133442685008049,
0.32019278407096863,
0.129852294921875,
0.08541082590818405,
-0.2974013686180115,
-0.06574179977178574,
0.07752633094787598,
0.3291519284248352,
-0.055276524275541306,
0.49447500705718994,
0.09226194024085999,
0.35142984986305237,
-0.16306395828723907,
0.32697078585624695,
0.2156577855348587,
-0.3450169861316681,
-0.2550552785396576,
0.14028999209403992,
0.84088534116745,
-0.052470650523900986,
0.32500743865966797,
-0.35711392760276794,
0.3339890241622925,
-0.47550395131111145,
0.5107603669166565,
-0.9961410760879517,
-0.21341100335121155,
-0.02776324935257435,
-0.6669028401374817,
-0.3949448764324188,
0.8101289868354797,
-0.5322926640510559,
-0.877252459526062,
-0.2974279224872589,
0.47913986444473267,
-0.12903690338134766,
-0.4638473391532898,
-0.49222874641418457,
-0.6954739689826965,
0.1197686716914177,
0.7093168497085571,
-0.4146313965320587,
-0.14800012111663818,
0.8771823644638062,
1.0289491415023804,
0.04941904544830322,
-0.11458895355463028,
-0.3620394468307495,
0.2973248362541199,
-0.7192933559417725,
0.5290707945823669,
-0.6743618845939636,
-0.5151277184486389,
0.288300096988678,
0.061255086213350296,
-0.4288814663887024,
-0.24752631783485413,
0.3772319257259369,
-0.698078989982605,
-0.022200649604201317,
-0.6428787112236023,
-0.4583790600299835,
-0.26088371872901917,
-0.19507953524589539,
-0.5418545603752136,
0.6467670202255249,
0.08416301757097244,
-0.722123384475708,
0.5003037452697754,
-0.9366133213043213,
-0.6062161922454834,
0.37679290771484375,
-0.321992427110672,
-0.5229841470718384,
0.14090117812156677,
0.2556213438510895,
0.49903321266174316,
0.15684068202972412,
0.40060004591941833,
-0.6551560759544373,
-0.23576627671718597,
0.25930553674697876,
-0.15965354442596436,
1.31063711643219,
0.2406817227602005,
-0.5621607303619385,
0.5108816027641296,
-0.632621705532074,
-0.3133201599121094,
0.03712392598390579,
-0.05040912702679634,
-0.605027437210083,
0.2165500819683075,
0.2926686704158783,
-0.003672747639939189,
-0.2261996865272522,
-0.3105548918247223,
0.034746747463941574,
0.4442670941352844,
0.8309519290924072,
0.6515061259269714,
0.474771112203598,
0.37909725308418274,
-0.42528975009918213,
0.37052467465400696,
-0.143222376704216,
-0.007980073802173138,
0.0692562535405159,
-0.6671159267425537,
-0.43994560837745667,
-0.18079893290996552,
0.40054044127464294,
-0.07882563024759293,
-0.6855614185333252,
0.3253224194049835,
-0.22484655678272247,
-0.8962675333023071,
-0.8657773733139038,
0.2675677537918091,
-0.22135043144226074,
0.19682461023330688,
0.27080845832824707,
0.44591814279556274,
-0.6300308704376221,
-0.5888366103172302,
-0.7616627812385559,
-0.04428519681096077,
-0.21020156145095825,
0.4341893494129181,
0.8132702112197876,
-0.34385600686073303,
0.9631268978118896,
-0.055818766355514526,
-0.20576196908950806,
-0.08520142734050751,
0.39151790738105774,
-0.2476252168416977,
0.5672586560249329,
0.792491614818573,
-1.0931769609451294,
-0.7613453269004822,
-0.15159516036510468,
-1.0883833169937134,
0.16287070512771606,
-0.07234431058168411,
-0.26413393020629883,
0.11845910549163818,
0.8783110976219177,
-0.1643049120903015,
0.6474621295928955,
0.32652246952056885,
-0.432108074426651,
0.022327663376927376,
0.29594293236732483,
0.3787151873111725,
-1.0212249755859375,
0.4058092534542084,
0.32172825932502747,
-0.15025226771831512,
-0.5372992157936096,
-0.4098327159881592,
-0.06152547150850296,
-0.08010963350534439,
-0.17522282898426056,
0.5017500519752502,
-0.2673008143901825,
0.08134398609399796,
-0.19703856110572815,
-0.1347987800836563,
0.07061903178691864,
-0.3816241919994354,
-0.3414929211139679,
0.7053052186965942,
0.5509119033813477,
-0.4780633747577667,
-0.4363574683666229,
0.04497458040714264,
-0.4702526330947876,
0.23867890238761902,
-0.9574409127235413,
-0.07363241165876389,
-0.006158696487545967,
0.4363108277320862,
-0.9962883591651917,
-0.2538065016269684,
0.3905326724052429,
-0.7733595371246338,
0.0821182131767273,
-0.3115466237068176,
-0.6985871195793152,
-0.21592563390731812,
-0.25197795033454895,
0.08912231773138046,
0.12389861792325974,
-0.663889467716217,
0.7264994978904724,
0.6975206136703491,
0.040765851736068726,
-0.20630700886249542,
-0.6822292804718018,
0.34044089913368225,
-0.18217776715755463,
-0.6853070259094238,
0.4357296824455261,
-0.0051206303760409355,
-0.7280766367912292,
0.31509697437286377,
0.2830045223236084,
-0.006385110318660736,
0.37710312008857727,
0.5048306584358215,
-0.062971331179142,
-0.22594676911830902,
0.14197105169296265,
0.03166458383202553,
0.27544644474983215,
0.4089163541793823,
-0.48104768991470337,
0.3863014578819275,
-0.095066599547863,
-0.22507119178771973,
-0.5714843273162842,
0.14864955842494965,
0.2757956087589264,
-0.2214847058057785,
1.177813172340393,
1.0472757816314697,
-0.26576825976371765,
-0.011500798165798187,
-0.38414686918258667,
-0.2406746745109558,
-0.4551665186882019,
0.08079081773757935,
0.1364247351884842,
-0.8712233304977417,
0.4199768900871277,
0.11657441407442093,
0.3309093415737152,
0.8030452132225037,
0.49825984239578247,
-0.42533788084983826,
0.9719058275222778,
0.8397725224494934,
-0.39251476526260376,
0.9784586429595947,
-0.35686448216438293,
-0.01111811026930809,
-0.45133453607559204,
-0.292930543422699,
-1.0727852582931519,
-0.5338424444198608,
-0.9626656174659729,
-0.43633103370666504,
0.03641046956181526,
-0.055786632001399994,
-0.24808834493160248,
-0.03760739788413048,
-0.6323013305664062,
0.289054811000824,
1.0198801755905151,
0.24878628551959991,
0.1390867382287979,
0.06678544729948044,
0.5243911743164062,
0.029354097321629524,
-0.5440019369125366,
-0.4830965995788574,
1.070001482963562,
0.2753582298755646,
0.563607931137085,
-0.04890003800392151,
0.8284134864807129,
0.7168917059898376,
0.47416433691978455,
-0.45529094338417053,
0.28467032313346863,
0.08350151032209396,
-0.7823341488838196,
-0.1145830899477005,
-0.28589126467704773,
-1.0968914031982422,
-0.07620710879564285,
0.09365969896316528,
-0.5938470959663391,
0.8232637047767639,
-0.220906063914299,
0.06385636329650879,
0.2858056426048279,
-0.3067811131477356,
0.3614714741706848,
-0.14580027759075165,
-0.61091548204422,
-0.3093065023422241,
-0.6750646829605103,
0.09306570887565613,
-0.012227960862219334,
0.13635921478271484,
0.1803748607635498,
0.10754714906215668,
1.3505600690841675,
-0.23791874945163727,
1.0660358667373657,
-0.2760040760040283,
0.39166611433029175,
0.4499959349632263,
-0.24065448343753815,
0.3948450982570648,
-0.0442417748272419,
-0.32404404878616333,
0.606891393661499,
-0.2910018265247345,
-0.6677130460739136,
-0.15919914841651917,
0.5944541692733765,
-1.0314044952392578,
-0.45788639783859253,
-0.47543108463287354,
-0.5638701915740967,
0.09034189581871033,
0.5224790573120117,
0.10674656182527542,
-0.0882161557674408,
-0.10604348033666611,
0.8655840754508972,
0.4382402300834656,
0.23866479098796844,
0.6218708753585815,
0.24339459836483002,
0.002109956694766879,
-0.3124505281448364,
0.9723491668701172,
0.5275669693946838,
-0.07690127193927765,
0.2878444194793701,
0.33099424839019775,
0.12752753496170044,
-0.6054186224937439,
-0.2836635708808899,
0.26529568433761597,
-0.45026320219039917,
0.1328110247850418,
-0.9580462574958801,
-0.5798830389976501,
-0.9405832886695862,
-0.32167375087738037,
0.04704979807138443,
-0.48087576031684875,
-0.7934022545814514,
-0.23105713725090027,
0.4741279184818268,
0.9075636267662048,
-0.347949355840683,
0.5227755308151245,
-0.40710684657096863,
-0.15701864659786224,
-0.10269952565431595,
0.19004233181476593,
0.225139319896698,
-0.49408456683158875,
-0.6414237022399902,
-0.16427239775657654,
-0.506140947341919,
-0.5523780584335327,
0.38790664076805115,
0.020056549459695816,
0.6664416193962097,
0.9152671694755554,
0.05658658966422081,
0.5537063479423523,
-0.18382520973682404,
0.5393130779266357,
-0.23828217387199402,
-0.46611183881759644,
0.6917636394500732,
-0.6890568137168884,
-0.12169245630502701,
0.6989133358001709,
0.8999719619750977,
-0.02520068548619747,
-0.42960935831069946,
-0.9286434650421143,
-0.8571943044662476,
0.563672661781311,
0.38832491636276245,
-0.012558487243950367,
0.3570934236049652,
-0.031548913568258286,
-0.08416478335857391,
0.2950502336025238,
-0.4971477687358856,
-0.5113266706466675,
-0.292812317609787,
0.16553017497062683,
-0.2914459705352783,
-0.40416616201400757,
-0.44332656264305115,
-0.28273677825927734,
0.8233243823051453,
0.18952663242816925,
0.025133613497018814,
0.09620873630046844,
0.06794567406177521,
-0.20894625782966614,
-0.19138114154338837,
0.6265308856964111,
0.8871200680732727,
-0.41030043363571167,
-0.00846304651349783,
-0.7616922855377197,
-0.3584044277667999,
-0.4837634861469269,
0.5760860443115234,
-0.8431352972984314,
0.4380462169647217,
0.4467369019985199,
0.5349460244178772,
-0.1640579104423523,
0.08697013556957245,
-0.09769663959741592,
-0.11632031947374344,
-0.6566806435585022,
-0.2541108727455139,
0.0941583439707756,
0.29035937786102295,
0.420206755399704,
0.8760249614715576,
0.2890240550041199,
0.21575695276260376,
-0.38663536310195923,
0.18971523642539978,
0.40358951687812805,
-0.9859811067581177,
-0.2944906949996948,
0.8224719762802124,
0.250240683555603,
-0.5275553464889526,
0.30998778343200684,
0.24448779225349426,
-0.36429086327552795,
0.7206079363822937,
0.19527125358581543,
0.9050260186195374,
-0.08346664160490036,
0.21794071793556213,
0.35406258702278137,
0.5137175917625427,
-0.08773151785135269,
-0.23066666722297668,
-0.005452669691294432,
-0.4528082609176636,
0.12572777271270752,
-0.28441354632377625,
-0.5862664580345154,
0.11442162096500397,
-0.5677293539047241,
0.21460087597370148,
-0.27336397767066956,
-0.37831801176071167,
0.6268541812896729,
0.2169577032327652,
-0.5974208116531372,
-0.14636676013469696,
-0.19425350427627563,
0.6847029328346252,
-0.8204474449157715,
0.8016281723976135,
0.5679622292518616,
-0.682056725025177,
-0.5616644620895386,
0.20445069670677185,
0.20462854206562042,
-0.5367048978805542,
0.5858052372932434,
0.26026514172554016,
0.12458457052707672,
0.2076919972896576,
-0.9709956049919128,
-0.9112852811813354,
1.0962671041488647,
0.10087570548057556,
-0.28489601612091064,
0.3034594655036926,
0.10167019814252853,
0.6133485436439514,
-0.4580194652080536,
0.21515093743801117,
0.28761667013168335,
0.6923632025718689,
0.19975148141384125,
-0.28731998801231384,
-0.23146967589855194,
-0.48268547654151917,
-0.11960604786872864,
-0.05835361406207085,
-0.6117759943008423,
0.3033905327320099,
-0.31548357009887695,
-0.002129752654582262,
-0.39043277502059937,
0.9729194045066833,
0.5101556777954102,
0.8327632546424866,
0.1557951122522354,
-0.21431666612625122,
0.8373585343360901,
0.15415188670158386,
1.0326663255691528,
-0.1798037737607956,
-0.15097838640213013,
0.9319969415664673,
0.09054091572761536,
0.6613394618034363,
0.7481434941291809,
-0.12755341827869415,
0.4923768937587738,
0.703686535358429,
-0.5423368215560913,
0.4535011053085327,
-0.04961792752146721,
-0.09781268984079361,
0.016507592052221298,
-0.6269021034240723,
-0.4834715723991394,
-0.06567736715078354,
0.4221217632293701,
-1.1100174188613892,
0.03081991709768772,
0.046874385327100754,
0.25932633876800537,
0.2305213361978531,
-0.3419269025325775,
0.6308483481407166,
0.3152048885822296,
-0.4032354950904846,
-0.1749102622270584,
-0.21167080104351044,
0.5315912961959839,
-0.4027685225009918,
0.1083480566740036,
-0.01865972764790058,
0.3171312212944031,
-0.4219140410423279,
-0.7159708738327026,
0.49845582246780396,
-0.04419442266225815,
-0.4012463390827179,
-0.4902164936065674,
0.9677262306213379,
-0.09532724320888519,
-1.0702520608901978,
0.6501239538192749,
0.5477574467658997,
0.14777562022209167,
-0.2825704514980316,
-0.7169288992881775,
0.11071740835905075,
0.027288656681776047,
-0.3436182737350464,
0.45034363865852356,
0.35602685809135437,
-0.13305537402629852,
0.59561687707901,
0.778809130191803,
0.005564332008361816,
0.05847347900271416,
0.3868865668773651,
0.8252029418945312,
-0.25387129187583923,
-0.0025187896098941565,
-1.1156340837478638,
0.33188396692276,
-0.280769020318985,
-0.15508882701396942,
1.122788906097412,
0.6348455548286438,
0.5826634764671326,
0.1859222650527954,
1.0995234251022339,
-0.15197527408599854,
0.6660425662994385,
0.40732717514038086,
1.3803739547729492,
-0.6176989674568176,
0.16817326843738556,
-0.21211965382099152,
-0.369853138923645,
-0.42854043841362,
0.3764304518699646,
-0.6896969676017761,
0.40949445962905884,
-0.02963748387992382,
0.521118700504303,
0.21972505748271942,
-0.05309150740504265,
0.03652842715382576,
0.4018114507198334,
0.7961202263832092,
-0.49331918358802795,
0.41925114393234253,
-0.4090455174446106,
0.7531284689903259,
-0.38993847370147705,
-0.058645058423280716,
-0.6241417527198792,
-0.8085846900939941,
-0.9962963461875916,
-0.6867440938949585,
-0.4596928060054779,
-0.7098846435546875,
0.45648157596588135,
0.5782350301742554,
0.5882471203804016,
-0.9990452527999878,
-0.1713220328092575,
-0.05968647450208664,
0.678728461265564,
-0.15078651905059814,
-0.32577016949653625,
0.6166520118713379,
-0.2751217484474182,
-0.6610844135284424,
0.10853855311870575,
0.04001571238040924,
-0.28976184129714966,
-0.0833713710308075,
0.06746435910463333,
-0.5478370785713196,
-0.08310715109109879,
0.6077491044998169,
0.14768092334270477,
-0.2604219317436218,
0.272630512714386,
0.18578943610191345,
-0.43417835235595703,
-0.03495044261217117,
0.7724055051803589,
-0.6679489016532898,
0.07355166971683502,
0.5445435643196106,
0.7323691248893738,
0.5869341492652893,
0.2941051423549652,
0.575679361820221,
-0.2761862576007843,
-0.31128761172294617,
0.4446708559989929,
0.1570717692375183,
0.2961357831954956,
-0.3317491114139557,
0.852828860282898,
0.31144651770591736,
-0.8734834790229797,
-0.9476131796836853,
-0.5150623917579651,
-0.9008165001869202,
-0.43539726734161377,
1.1477693319320679,
0.026950625702738762,
-0.11013147234916687,
-0.30915406346321106,
0.3596510887145996,
0.23462139070034027,
-0.8243386149406433,
1.1442334651947021,
0.4518433213233948,
-0.19810491800308228,
-0.25088781118392944,
-0.772527813911438,
0.42604076862335205,
0.13368773460388184,
-0.7630106806755066,
-0.15841378271579742,
-0.01080227829515934,
0.11257680505514145,
0.2853413224220276,
0.5189348459243774,
0.023416247218847275,
-0.09301432967185974,
-0.07320334762334824,
-0.20278574526309967,
-0.10896623879671097,
-0.26307207345962524,
-0.06701542437076569,
0.07055933773517609,
0.0010801681783050299,
-0.2308872938156128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13660v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13660v2 | MambaByte: Token-free Selective State Space Model | 2024-01-24T18:53:53 | 2024-04-03T02:36:27 | Junxiong Wang, Tushaar Gangavarapu, Jing Nathan Yan, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Token-free language models learn directly from raw bytes and remove the
inductive bias of subword tokenization. Operating on bytes, however, results in
significantly longer sequences. In this setting, standard autoregressive
Transformers scale poorly as the effective memory required grows with sequence
length. The recent development of the Mamba state space model (SSM) offers an
appealing alternative approach with a fixed-sized memory state and efficient
decoding. We propose MambaByte, a token-free adaptation of the Mamba SSM
trained autoregressively on byte sequences. In terms of modeling, we show
MambaByte to be competitive with, and even to outperform, state-of-the-art
subword Transformers on language modeling tasks while maintaining the benefits
of token-free language models, such as robustness to noise. In terms of
efficiency, we develop an adaptation of speculative decoding with tokenized
drafting and byte-level verification. This results in a $2.6\times$ inference
speedup to the standard MambaByte implementation, showing similar decoding
efficiency as the subword Mamba. These findings establish the viability of SSMs
in enabling token-free language modeling. | [
-0.17398935556411743,
-0.6237389445304871,
0.16465729475021362,
0.22466817498207092,
-0.7595155239105225,
0.2033226490020752,
-0.09585046023130417,
-0.24310444295406342,
0.6019579768180847,
0.5038946270942688,
-0.27399104833602905,
-0.30667316913604736,
-0.6710516214370728,
-0.18922196328639984,
-0.4942767322063446,
0.6494407653808594,
-0.03461809828877449,
-0.03506246954202652,
-0.07537849992513657,
-0.21372710168361664,
-0.6636258363723755,
-0.7483869194984436,
-0.4003399610519409,
-0.1136762797832489,
0.19119314849376678,
0.22364769876003265,
0.8547506928443909,
0.6247713565826416,
0.33425992727279663,
0.17177844047546387,
-0.1416395604610443,
0.043482065200805664,
-0.19426612555980682,
0.11832823604345322,
-0.0818597599864006,
-0.7488884329795837,
-0.550443708896637,
-0.011899469420313835,
0.6477580070495605,
0.6172000765800476,
-0.41881269216537476,
0.24831907451152802,
-0.32218873500823975,
0.6964763402938843,
-0.8013197779655457,
0.2975602149963379,
-0.9861168265342712,
0.11441656947135925,
-0.04740245267748833,
0.22795701026916504,
-0.7100041508674622,
-0.37464281916618347,
-0.4478723406791687,
-0.4443303346633911,
0.08393428474664688,
0.18354247510433197,
0.8025959730148315,
0.2773289978504181,
-0.40705177187919617,
-0.28524085879325867,
-0.5715216994285583,
0.6967955231666565,
-0.4407613277435303,
0.5637414455413818,
0.4197345972061157,
0.4578150510787964,
-0.32730892300605774,
-0.38735705614089966,
-0.47860315442085266,
-0.41395461559295654,
0.24849189817905426,
0.12493974715471268,
-0.31795692443847656,
0.10104621201753616,
-0.08440651744604111,
0.48324885964393616,
-0.3040587306022644,
-0.018637320026755333,
-0.35439324378967285,
-0.4586317241191864,
0.39959096908569336,
0.26284220814704895,
0.29099538922309875,
-0.40906405448913574,
-0.43468528985977173,
0.06866345554590225,
-0.4588078558444977,
0.05838178098201752,
0.24229197204113007,
0.3817051649093628,
-0.012919074855744839,
0.7186002731323242,
0.05153205245733261,
0.4752052426338196,
0.0928802415728569,
0.20083896815776825,
-0.04876451939344406,
-0.23968259990215302,
-0.2357020080089569,
0.08644315600395203,
0.5908013582229614,
0.14844970405101776,
0.005315886344760656,
-0.38818299770355225,
-0.2302527278661728,
0.2661728858947754,
0.5499873757362366,
-0.9467358589172363,
-0.2767958641052246,
0.18724825978279114,
-0.7042021155357361,
-0.08063798397779465,
-0.19012773036956787,
-0.567095160484314,
-0.32774853706359863,
0.016831370070576668,
0.40176573395729065,
-0.7732524871826172,
-0.63577800989151,
0.23998130857944489,
-0.07030715048313141,
0.03540559485554695,
0.09632693231105804,
-1.11833918094635,
0.27431434392929077,
0.5263689160346985,
1.109330415725708,
-0.3136979639530182,
0.057782869786024094,
-0.27205657958984375,
0.0916304737329483,
-0.8295844197273254,
0.5700026750564575,
-0.6926217079162598,
-0.9805328249931335,
-0.3542270064353943,
0.03540007397532463,
-0.25749915838241577,
-0.4685113728046417,
0.1622115671634674,
-0.6432590484619141,
-0.4019474685192108,
0.007292196154594421,
-0.7322853207588196,
-0.08381422609090805,
-0.2575022876262665,
-0.6836146116256714,
1.0712138414382935,
0.3764091730117798,
-0.3148863613605499,
0.5472981929779053,
-0.858797550201416,
-0.49504467844963074,
-0.042280662804841995,
0.13332512974739075,
-0.2296976000070572,
0.5245614647865295,
0.18331775069236755,
0.4482669532299042,
-0.14521808922290802,
0.1096000000834465,
-0.28712648153305054,
-0.5661312341690063,
0.2996159791946411,
-0.17024831473827362,
0.6917457580566406,
0.6402349472045898,
-0.010071045719087124,
0.09383373707532883,
-0.9615074992179871,
-0.15079821646213531,
0.19034478068351746,
-0.567899227142334,
-0.384148508310318,
0.08747424930334091,
-0.3866901993751526,
-0.026364710181951523,
0.10474146157503128,
-0.6313165426254272,
0.33302655816078186,
-0.34345561265945435,
0.39827224612236023,
0.5727858543395996,
-0.1629832684993744,
0.908663809299469,
0.07057488709688187,
0.7751892805099487,
0.41727402806282043,
0.2919371426105499,
-0.2958727777004242,
-0.31219106912612915,
-1.017533302307129,
-0.6855854392051697,
0.597314715385437,
0.39574557542800903,
-0.7985993027687073,
0.3748582601547241,
-0.2902572751045227,
-0.6519989967346191,
-0.7473630905151367,
-0.0778629258275032,
0.013534476980566978,
0.14772829413414001,
0.641829788684845,
-0.507485568523407,
-0.5617102980613708,
-1.010167121887207,
-0.26037007570266724,
-0.1569186896085739,
0.032621387392282486,
0.23902878165245056,
0.31127339601516724,
-0.11924181133508682,
0.9638650417327881,
-0.24111583828926086,
0.06174086034297943,
-0.43261274695396423,
-0.08617709577083588,
0.02531721629202366,
0.6773083806037903,
0.7678025960922241,
-0.3548011779785156,
-0.18636737763881683,
-0.3432947099208832,
-0.3694276511669159,
0.08188620954751968,
-0.07672040164470673,
-0.2262641340494156,
0.36035844683647156,
0.5651126503944397,
-0.7905991673469543,
0.46633511781692505,
0.5831543803215027,
-0.32186397910118103,
0.16616755723953247,
-0.08590865880250931,
0.004446857143193483,
-1.2884069681167603,
-0.019022151827812195,
-0.39417409896850586,
-0.17095442116260529,
-0.4082494378089905,
0.15604673326015472,
0.5185264348983765,
-0.3190538287162781,
-0.3944392502307892,
0.5651311874389648,
-0.6793619394302368,
-0.2672240734100342,
-0.5592332482337952,
0.07196085900068283,
-0.3194693624973297,
0.3552348017692566,
-0.10274969786405563,
0.9822189211845398,
0.37688082456588745,
-0.7552412748336792,
-0.005463279318064451,
0.0370112806558609,
-0.5214247107505798,
0.06961017847061157,
-0.24858978390693665,
0.20038852095603943,
-0.14061473309993744,
0.3269396722316742,
-1.1329442262649536,
0.17203164100646973,
0.06248107925057411,
-0.5067017078399658,
0.34841451048851013,
-0.523374080657959,
-0.5095556974411011,
-0.3943593204021454,
0.17000386118888855,
0.31468865275382996,
0.6674089431762695,
-0.44793716073036194,
0.8418354988098145,
0.558508574962616,
0.05480360612273216,
-0.5639985203742981,
-0.7603176832199097,
0.1991051584482193,
0.12392042577266693,
-0.14846080541610718,
-0.03663083538413048,
0.12673498690128326,
0.22091813385486603,
0.00953727401793003,
-0.25774630904197693,
0.017891710624098778,
0.4505919814109802,
0.39334362745285034,
0.459506094455719,
-0.34452250599861145,
0.15398377180099487,
0.3720691502094269,
-0.273068904876709,
-0.20864750444889069,
-0.48286932706832886,
0.6930670738220215,
-0.17401261627674103,
-0.18324404954910278,
-0.02839936502277851,
0.25308701395988464,
0.5548778772354126,
-0.24852332472801208,
1.0410923957824707,
0.3278893828392029,
-0.31436699628829956,
-0.32217666506767273,
-0.26106932759284973,
-0.01933090202510357,
-0.46792590618133545,
0.40767839550971985,
-0.6819724440574646,
-0.9333395957946777,
0.5037408471107483,
-0.09709764271974564,
0.10843333601951599,
0.37953323125839233,
0.44547486305236816,
0.3313988149166107,
0.9717179536819458,
0.7436248660087585,
-0.010014267638325691,
0.5689597129821777,
0.01424719113856554,
0.2203313559293747,
-0.7166560292243958,
-0.15899893641471863,
-0.47318336367607117,
-0.36865895986557007,
-0.2833487093448639,
-0.7109380960464478,
-0.32894089818000793,
0.41185495257377625,
0.06007727235555649,
0.8500447273254395,
-0.3583882749080658,
0.5272607207298279,
0.22067371010780334,
-0.10720783472061157,
-0.07757731527090073,
0.04722907766699791,
-0.8167705535888672,
-0.029360760003328323,
-0.8165044784545898,
-0.43924975395202637,
0.9576787948608398,
0.18361571431159973,
0.7231112718582153,
0.22467166185379028,
0.3766374886035919,
0.29789435863494873,
0.37515705823898315,
-0.9061289429664612,
0.8547617793083191,
-0.33257654309272766,
-0.8883996605873108,
-0.03251440450549126,
-0.2788274884223938,
-0.9204904437065125,
0.4669761061668396,
-0.32581260800361633,
-0.7009298801422119,
0.11079494655132294,
0.09693168848752975,
-0.10776685178279877,
0.5434733629226685,
-0.684380054473877,
0.42991146445274353,
0.16284853219985962,
0.047294486314058304,
-0.5324381589889526,
-0.34331950545310974,
0.3440151810646057,
-0.0794498547911644,
0.12499376386404037,
-0.46724754571914673,
-0.2388879358768463,
0.608253538608551,
-0.4665149748325348,
0.7105900645256042,
-0.53889399766922,
0.11228042095899582,
0.4722965657711029,
0.7233474850654602,
0.32645419239997864,
-0.20858338475227356,
-0.28636395931243896,
0.35114502906799316,
0.08412545919418335,
-0.7238544821739197,
-0.489105761051178,
0.45559996366500854,
-0.6974541544914246,
-0.5152896642684937,
-0.11727195233106613,
-0.5814900994300842,
-0.33704549074172974,
0.2448941022157669,
-0.08391183614730835,
0.06729575991630554,
-0.2130727767944336,
0.3315432369709015,
0.27506282925605774,
-0.2634185552597046,
0.5054245591163635,
0.5589295625686646,
-0.615794837474823,
-0.34153932332992554,
0.7745184898376465,
0.2224053591489792,
0.14998267590999603,
0.4560401439666748,
0.024133889004588127,
-0.4553014636039734,
-0.6246872544288635,
-0.7183272242546082,
-0.11103397607803345,
-0.8322659730911255,
-0.11681675165891647,
-0.7330660223960876,
-0.10905791819095612,
-0.25967010855674744,
-0.10554758459329605,
-0.686400294303894,
-1.1202465295791626,
-0.21586738526821136,
-0.3202395439147949,
0.40624183416366577,
0.36926746368408203,
-0.15068259835243225,
0.385365754365921,
-0.9272099733352661,
0.304105281829834,
-0.12008021026849747,
0.4613831341266632,
0.26592394709587097,
-0.6246694326400757,
-0.5048101544380188,
-0.15717411041259766,
0.03462187200784683,
-0.7301408052444458,
0.12085087597370148,
-0.07991338521242142,
0.6665021777153015,
0.1193384900689125,
-0.0886707678437233,
0.6982381939888,
-0.44399696588516235,
1.092063069343567,
0.39234545826911926,
-1.0458459854125977,
0.4913146197795868,
-0.08163070678710938,
0.1977623552083969,
0.3573991656303406,
0.325157105922699,
-0.5362495183944702,
-0.34829381108283997,
-0.36888420581817627,
-0.7504932284355164,
0.5306447744369507,
-0.07318107783794403,
0.3612878918647766,
-0.4909014105796814,
0.6649103760719299,
0.36519789695739746,
0.1847185343503952,
-0.3709546625614166,
-0.12533991038799286,
-0.8474667072296143,
-0.3233931064605713,
-0.03742718696594238,
-0.27213943004608154,
0.44841906428337097,
-0.12872916460037231,
0.6279600262641907,
-0.23861047625541687,
0.5954604744911194,
-0.10502966493368149,
-0.5960139632225037,
0.11547381430864334,
0.35811394453048706,
0.49850940704345703,
0.2150462120771408,
0.12672899663448334,
0.12149790674448013,
0.3627512753009796,
-0.6278170943260193,
0.481175035238266,
-0.1622680425643921,
-0.2611438035964966,
0.21488063037395477,
-0.25165560841560364,
0.9330927729606628,
0.36047086119651794,
-0.31355491280555725,
0.4669153094291687,
-0.09160967916250229,
-0.23614948987960815,
0.059435177594423294,
0.47365236282348633,
0.34075072407722473,
0.07424233853816986,
0.3498385548591614,
0.21606667339801788,
-0.16157659888267517,
-0.2467680424451828,
0.060522012412548065,
0.3897549510002136,
-0.5779255032539368,
-0.2877330482006073,
0.9881843328475952,
0.1613621562719345,
-0.2952010929584503,
0.5752055048942566,
-0.015634657815098763,
0.023088810965418816,
0.5558602213859558,
0.7303400039672852,
0.8782181739807129,
-0.31220370531082153,
0.027676984667778015,
0.49314194917678833,
0.433480441570282,
0.0032432274892926216,
0.37546461820602417,
-0.2821401357650757,
-0.7590509653091431,
-0.27246373891830444,
-1.0517445802688599,
-0.30908218026161194,
0.03230614960193634,
-0.6335301399230957,
-0.01606607623398304,
-0.9686863422393799,
-0.5374736785888672,
-0.22468966245651245,
-0.1412694752216339,
-0.28362149000167847,
0.1359870433807373,
0.10838288813829422,
1.4534856081008911,
-0.36104848980903625,
1.1924439668655396,
0.5314937829971313,
-0.40301963686943054,
-0.7685884833335876,
-0.309075266122818,
-0.14736640453338623,
-0.9560909867286682,
0.3741633892059326,
0.07545700669288635,
-0.33654236793518066,
-0.08031812310218811,
-0.33428800106048584,
-0.988062858581543,
0.9493095874786377,
0.39617711305618286,
-0.5879393815994263,
0.14100563526153564,
0.05475766956806183,
0.2428157925605774,
-0.3647080361843109,
-0.011140182614326477,
0.3448121249675751,
0.11397797614336014,
-0.14008863270282745,
-0.5572760105133057,
0.251015305519104,
-0.23391415178775787,
0.4125435948371887,
0.5738564133644104,
-1.0222212076187134,
0.7092797160148621,
-0.21358676254749298,
-0.37198930978775024,
0.4572780132293701,
1.1258946657180786,
-0.03653869405388832,
-0.3016341030597687,
0.6414053440093994,
0.3152622878551483,
0.8733866810798645,
0.018972918391227722,
0.907879114151001,
-0.5492045283317566,
0.10605680197477341,
0.7774475812911987,
-0.3254677355289459,
1.0132174491882324,
0.3136995732784271,
-0.11665798723697662,
0.7248982191085815,
0.6053494811058044,
-0.03740256279706955,
0.5769860148429871,
0.2040746659040451,
-0.23879261314868927,
-0.4728103280067444,
0.2505861222743988,
-0.1050177663564682,
0.4514736235141754,
0.5383749008178711,
-0.15170712769031525,
-0.020776469260454178,
0.07325465977191925,
-0.013310768641531467,
-0.1256541907787323,
-0.4528379440307617,
0.495106041431427,
0.1562575101852417,
-0.5665409564971924,
0.5555951595306396,
0.3207530677318573,
0.6443172693252563,
-0.7315691709518433,
0.4418477714061737,
-0.46074196696281433,
0.30590054392814636,
0.04613266512751579,
-0.2815254032611847,
0.43901363015174866,
-0.05440615490078926,
-0.1406371295452118,
0.111038438975811,
0.8524571061134338,
-0.21987511217594147,
-0.48774805665016174,
0.36703839898109436,
0.2754534184932709,
0.350781112909317,
0.25262251496315,
-0.7371587157249451,
-0.05585894361138344,
-0.3418128192424774,
-0.22134457528591156,
0.4384460747241974,
0.14931756258010864,
-0.19307780265808105,
0.6799187660217285,
0.8250786662101746,
0.0029688188806176186,
0.4326818287372589,
0.0403071753680706,
0.5019447207450867,
-0.857150137424469,
-0.8226640224456787,
-0.7322791218757629,
0.07954750955104828,
0.22749300301074982,
0.017597541213035583,
0.7815960049629211,
0.7445116639137268,
0.4949805438518524,
-0.17965658009052277,
0.7297617197036743,
0.1502106785774231,
0.46669527888298035,
-0.7726228833198547,
0.8638684153556824,
-0.56263267993927,
-0.06158608943223953,
0.06510692834854126,
-0.6750240921974182,
-0.12066908925771713,
0.6236394643783569,
-0.0064515769481658936,
0.03504243865609169,
0.6081551313400269,
0.7579939365386963,
-0.17303624749183655,
0.31491774320602417,
0.46436795592308044,
0.1611708700656891,
0.13780924677848816,
0.3308083117008209,
0.846534013748169,
-0.41877228021621704,
0.7550835609436035,
0.15319636464118958,
-0.08227264881134033,
-0.3833377957344055,
-0.8366547226905823,
-0.935107409954071,
-0.4534029960632324,
-0.06393636763095856,
-0.36437278985977173,
0.01308391336351633,
0.9807642698287964,
0.8629751205444336,
-0.7099155187606812,
-0.1340770125389099,
-0.012625264935195446,
-0.05927995219826698,
-0.18363414704799652,
-0.17636999487876892,
0.16090457141399384,
-0.34110307693481445,
-0.5591863989830017,
0.7724905610084534,
0.5648738145828247,
0.3713124096393585,
-0.11999869346618652,
0.01913493126630783,
0.05087069794535637,
0.8047093749046326,
0.7324320077896118,
0.1340927630662918,
-0.5812197327613831,
-0.25616952776908875,
0.11435475945472717,
-0.23189020156860352,
0.24525369703769684,
1.033219337463379,
-0.7047081589698792,
0.2129996418952942,
0.19691002368927002,
0.794736385345459,
0.8018708825111389,
-0.2198214828968048,
0.36758700013160706,
-0.5600463151931763,
0.5134082436561584,
-0.023497620597481728,
0.6130555272102356,
0.22040927410125732,
-0.18886272609233856,
0.37688106298446655,
0.23439960181713104,
-0.16284114122390747,
-0.5026159286499023,
0.2816893458366394,
-0.7906413674354553,
-0.7912792563438416,
1.0531493425369263,
-0.05470779910683632,
-0.4740889072418213,
-0.13104645907878876,
-0.1265157163143158,
0.3428165316581726,
-0.4491836130619049,
0.6701517701148987,
0.9261193871498108,
0.11026173830032349,
-0.041698724031448364,
-0.3103724718093872,
0.23980657756328583,
0.5667199492454529,
-0.3621324300765991,
0.2426052689552307,
0.3775036334991455,
0.3813767731189728,
0.05416679382324219,
0.8677451014518738,
-0.3516870141029358,
0.326754629611969,
0.4911342263221741,
0.131973534822464,
-0.3115993142127991,
-0.3219214379787445,
-0.3533918261528015,
0.21665768325328827,
0.16229066252708435,
-0.39473146200180054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13649v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13649v2 | VisualWebArena: Evaluating Multimodal Agents on Realistic Visual Web Tasks | 2024-01-24T18:35:21 | 2024-06-06T02:01:09 | Jing Yu Koh, Robert Lo, Lawrence Jang, Vikram Duvvur, Ming Chong Lim, Po-Yu Huang, Graham Neubig, Shuyan Zhou, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Daniel Fried | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Autonomous agents capable of planning, reasoning, and executing actions on
the web offer a promising avenue for automating computer tasks. However, the
majority of existing benchmarks primarily focus on text-based agents,
neglecting many natural tasks that require visual information to effectively
solve. Given that most computer interfaces cater to human perception, visual
information often augments textual data in ways that text-only models struggle
to harness effectively. To bridge this gap, we introduce VisualWebArena, a
benchmark designed to assess the performance of multimodal web agents on
realistic \textit{visually grounded tasks}. VisualWebArena comprises of a set
of diverse and complex web-based tasks that evaluate various capabilities of
autonomous multimodal agents. To perform on this benchmark, agents need to
accurately process image-text inputs, interpret natural language instructions,
and execute actions on websites to accomplish user-defined objectives. We
conduct an extensive evaluation of state-of-the-art LLM-based autonomous
agents, including several multimodal models. Through extensive quantitative and
qualitative analysis, we identify several limitations of text-only LLM agents,
and reveal gaps in the capabilities of state-of-the-art multimodal language
agents. VisualWebArena provides a framework for evaluating multimodal
autonomous language agents, and offers insights towards building stronger
autonomous agents for the web. Our code, baseline models, and data is publicly
available at https://jykoh.com/vwa. | [
-0.7713921070098877,
-0.767242431640625,
0.5251989960670471,
0.3459602892398834,
-0.1226431131362915,
0.1915927678346634,
-0.14900274574756622,
-0.6957417130470276,
-0.08837641775608063,
0.31257951259613037,
-0.6145764589309692,
-0.4787009656429291,
-0.5147517919540405,
0.2112690955400467,
-0.31400179862976074,
0.4753971993923187,
-0.09469681978225708,
-0.020975645631551743,
-0.7332992553710938,
-0.29571467638015747,
-0.6854581832885742,
-0.08065970987081528,
-0.17858774960041046,
-0.13035893440246582,
0.7649167776107788,
0.29137906432151794,
0.6857991814613342,
0.49812451004981995,
0.6045733690261841,
0.5416545867919922,
0.5272753834724426,
0.37092024087905884,
-0.34163331985473633,
0.3066020905971527,
-0.48015516996383667,
-0.2910648286342621,
-0.39016175270080566,
0.07423482090234756,
0.10845327377319336,
0.39145949482917786,
0.061117298901081085,
0.43103766441345215,
-0.10358494520187378,
0.33935660123825073,
-0.9354268908500671,
0.3319949507713318,
-0.3813951909542084,
-0.1956196427345276,
-0.12454982101917267,
-0.13603010773658752,
-0.21045811474323273,
-0.35771292448043823,
0.021706022322177887,
-0.7832455635070801,
0.035594988614320755,
0.06007580831646919,
0.6988306641578674,
0.5117546319961548,
-0.870011031627655,
-0.1061868667602539,
-0.5611015558242798,
0.5905033946037292,
-0.16902588307857513,
0.6154303550720215,
0.44011545181274414,
0.5127338171005249,
-0.11418084800243378,
-0.8739722967147827,
-0.7851492762565613,
-0.4101552963256836,
0.3226569890975952,
0.40336474776268005,
-0.6994913816452026,
-0.1498471349477768,
0.16258306801319122,
-0.12761290371418,
-0.767166018486023,
0.07653667777776718,
-0.014108282513916492,
-0.14908954501152039,
0.3714125156402588,
0.23784542083740234,
0.4894481599330902,
-0.10995475947856903,
-0.502103328704834,
-0.5362359881401062,
-0.08641278743743896,
0.1674843281507492,
0.255222886800766,
0.10442624241113663,
-0.33151036500930786,
0.721093475818634,
-0.5130797624588013,
0.7649325132369995,
-0.362229585647583,
-0.25064316391944885,
0.09161791950464249,
-0.36999431252479553,
-0.22515395283699036,
-0.4257630407810211,
0.7075231075286865,
0.8260937929153442,
0.5839000940322876,
-0.08195952326059341,
-0.27502885460853577,
0.4786299169063568,
0.6660383939743042,
-0.7202194333076477,
-0.1390623152256012,
0.08221640437841415,
-0.5310835242271423,
-0.08766300976276398,
-0.18623431026935577,
-0.979504406452179,
-0.6732863187789917,
-0.34356528520584106,
0.5438299179077148,
-0.42514532804489136,
-0.1618371307849884,
-0.3317500948905945,
-0.6066204309463501,
-0.012925433926284313,
0.6139931678771973,
-0.4271790385246277,
0.32986849546432495,
0.2775295674800873,
0.5256248712539673,
-0.13134129345417023,
-0.5157613158226013,
-0.4403526782989502,
0.0280328206717968,
-0.29766520857810974,
1.0823835134506226,
-0.4852621555328369,
-0.18767951428890228,
0.13837268948554993,
-0.05520453304052353,
0.0548715703189373,
-0.26256659626960754,
0.3215661644935608,
-0.5633217692375183,
-0.37324947118759155,
-0.15937183797359467,
-0.33676308393478394,
-0.44147205352783203,
0.4957965016365051,
-0.8695287704467773,
0.36120516061782837,
-0.042442686855793,
-0.39132770895957947,
0.5615338087081909,
-0.3039909303188324,
-0.4273569583892822,
0.06093209236860275,
-0.2503827214241028,
-0.06495573371648788,
0.14181742072105408,
0.34033554792404175,
0.34232097864151,
-0.6568548679351807,
-0.265092670917511,
-0.5768214464187622,
-0.2237335741519928,
0.5139975547790527,
-0.756476104259491,
0.5553142428398132,
0.04336076229810715,
-0.3866094946861267,
0.45806875824928284,
-0.9361486434936523,
0.2108316421508789,
0.24495390057563782,
-0.18621648848056793,
-0.41735807061195374,
0.0680694654583931,
0.5168654918670654,
0.0987996757030487,
0.4143151342868805,
-0.35700345039367676,
0.25233086943626404,
0.2473650425672531,
-0.10500874370336533,
0.9419339299201965,
-0.1140463799238205,
0.1838994026184082,
-0.16670039296150208,
0.7225163578987122,
-0.5067156553268433,
0.40830451250076294,
-0.052762698382139206,
-0.44146138429641724,
-0.7586622834205627,
-0.7051637172698975,
0.12166418135166168,
0.5955168008804321,
-1.1655840873718262,
-0.04787394404411316,
-0.3348085284233093,
-0.7560876607894897,
-0.2077208012342453,
0.29408514499664307,
0.5776728391647339,
0.2081831991672516,
0.3622416853904724,
-0.3463194966316223,
-0.4447978436946869,
-0.8967170715332031,
-0.2579260468482971,
-0.14431211352348328,
0.1537826657295227,
0.04546346515417099,
0.654159426689148,
-0.586121678352356,
0.931553065776825,
-0.19448861479759216,
-0.3725825250148773,
-0.22638173401355743,
0.5102719068527222,
-0.216316819190979,
0.27563443779945374,
0.5355547666549683,
-0.9358326196670532,
-0.4624648988246918,
0.12219850718975067,
-1.1453789472579956,
-0.22628211975097656,
-0.0725816935300827,
0.19722315669059753,
-0.03821496292948723,
0.27437400817871094,
-0.6360896825790405,
0.6444253921508789,
0.8556820154190063,
-0.30646342039108276,
0.4866471290588379,
-0.22940130531787872,
0.3912070095539093,
-0.5803110003471375,
-0.011195117607712746,
0.2378259152173996,
-0.5490900278091431,
-0.38544726371765137,
0.2610793113708496,
0.27136772871017456,
-0.03566398471593857,
-0.3192911446094513,
0.7326909899711609,
-0.7008606195449829,
-0.28948208689689636,
-0.4621996283531189,
0.12164249271154404,
-0.017540114000439644,
0.6112986207008362,
-0.3838736116886139,
0.9023674726486206,
0.36534494161605835,
-0.6019135117530823,
0.6700237393379211,
0.14237503707408905,
-0.30970972776412964,
0.9457828402519226,
-0.47827282547950745,
-0.10434897243976593,
-0.03764613717794418,
0.03400103375315666,
-1.0559632778167725,
-0.31541869044303894,
-0.012481579557061195,
-0.44647979736328125,
-0.08709786832332611,
0.01898152567446232,
-0.6476147770881653,
-0.31534117460250854,
-0.40186959505081177,
0.4431796669960022,
0.2534368634223938,
-0.39016491174697876,
0.8050776720046997,
0.32812511920928955,
-0.03137606382369995,
-0.5150336027145386,
-0.40181636810302734,
0.3609354794025421,
0.15103010833263397,
-0.5059679746627808,
0.20845966041088104,
-0.1130518689751625,
-0.4858067035675049,
0.13695615530014038,
-0.07873789221048355,
-0.18798068165779114,
0.21596403419971466,
0.584002673625946,
0.06418871879577637,
0.0617571659386158,
-0.20653852820396423,
-0.1614411175251007,
-0.1225237101316452,
-0.18192774057388306,
0.04102485254406929,
0.6082971692085266,
-0.21950507164001465,
-0.5776227712631226,
-0.6847874522209167,
0.26222601532936096,
0.7635343670845032,
-0.49576157331466675,
0.3175593912601471,
0.7705143094062805,
-0.29759034514427185,
-0.03011350892484188,
-0.6624703407287598,
0.22996802628040314,
-0.4702424108982086,
0.28855615854263306,
-0.5063270926475525,
-0.38048216700553894,
0.37115058302879333,
-0.1691167801618576,
-0.15597283840179443,
0.15748068690299988,
0.5200310945510864,
-0.3506172299385071,
1.2223867177963257,
0.7965067625045776,
0.19013115763664246,
0.5960227847099304,
0.00025921649648807943,
-0.42803755402565,
-0.4209318161010742,
-0.32920119166374207,
-0.4335709512233734,
-0.23468808829784393,
-0.6267900466918945,
-0.49082937836647034,
0.5030547380447388,
-0.028786566108465195,
-0.04443792253732681,
0.4508833885192871,
-0.11307485401630402,
0.09662185609340668,
0.7460659146308899,
0.11835378408432007,
0.21301035583019257,
0.0009294137125834823,
-0.13558967411518097,
0.143984854221344,
-0.3305877149105072,
-0.4822161793708801,
1.0449740886688232,
0.002348262118175626,
0.9861444234848022,
0.32864314317703247,
0.1746540516614914,
0.8483554720878601,
0.3521575629711151,
-0.5950708389282227,
0.7100406885147095,
0.13926514983177185,
-0.32929643988609314,
-0.2396235167980194,
-0.32071372866630554,
-1.2209218740463257,
0.5313069820404053,
-0.3748524785041809,
-0.6860381960868835,
0.30741792917251587,
0.05490005016326904,
0.2325732409954071,
-0.09294893592596054,
-0.5948280096054077,
1.0719306468963623,
-0.5297878980636597,
-0.6055853962898254,
-0.4856429994106293,
-0.40484389662742615,
0.2091909646987915,
0.11541954427957535,
0.2953736186027527,
-0.32039058208465576,
-0.37130007147789,
0.3484812378883362,
-0.3875044286251068,
0.947494626045227,
-0.1677466481924057,
0.02950308844447136,
0.05682944506406784,
0.2070581465959549,
0.42522677779197693,
-0.22454574704170227,
0.28608423471450806,
0.2088741809129715,
-0.07063991576433182,
-0.5226092338562012,
-0.5989757180213928,
0.4160211682319641,
-0.6909418106079102,
-0.31617188453674316,
-0.6227339506149292,
-0.4257238805294037,
-0.47545313835144043,
0.45101243257522583,
-0.05275718495249748,
0.6410925984382629,
-0.5370084047317505,
0.23243221640586853,
0.17965325713157654,
-0.20982420444488525,
0.695327877998352,
0.6811382174491882,
-0.32790741324424744,
-0.7010012269020081,
0.8832489252090454,
-0.09494337439537048,
-0.023378193378448486,
0.5758933424949646,
-0.1609300673007965,
-0.42537155747413635,
-0.6526369452476501,
-0.8383437991142273,
-0.16750386357307434,
-0.9196088910102844,
-0.2396990805864334,
-0.4617311358451843,
0.45105916261672974,
-0.2914058566093445,
-0.018079888075590134,
-0.3096877932548523,
-0.12088070809841156,
0.0137614281848073,
0.22273588180541992,
0.1857168972492218,
0.7213113307952881,
0.0344303622841835,
0.1721441000699997,
-0.6818779110908508,
0.7336460947990417,
0.6739510893821716,
0.1642361581325531,
-0.07670767605304718,
0.2240256369113922,
-0.14062654972076416,
-0.16854099929332733,
-0.1489427387714386,
-0.9170987010002136,
0.2618848383426666,
-0.21504898369312286,
0.8858567476272583,
0.3926149308681488,
-0.04223095253109932,
0.938846230506897,
-0.45242762565612793,
0.48237648606300354,
0.4179576337337494,
-0.9260740280151367,
0.3366796374320984,
-0.4365558624267578,
0.5322552919387817,
0.6332257986068726,
0.21378068625926971,
-0.20119135081768036,
-0.3077489733695984,
0.006082336418330669,
-0.6408898234367371,
0.313129186630249,
0.38874250650405884,
-0.04307964816689491,
0.05419876426458359,
-0.23188850283622742,
-0.056305088102817535,
0.40664321184158325,
-0.7534415125846863,
-0.08488424867391586,
-0.4344993531703949,
-0.2897889018058777,
-0.13834969699382782,
-0.07861439138650894,
-0.12523242831230164,
-0.032604772597551346,
0.18850302696228027,
-0.426886647939682,
0.21745924651622772,
0.07935651391744614,
-0.7588118314743042,
0.025614868849515915,
0.06679441779851913,
0.728158712387085,
1.0488704442977905,
-0.1512230932712555,
0.3380703330039978,
0.017629198729991913,
-0.3634026050567627,
0.1587124913930893,
0.34224531054496765,
0.042622558772563934,
-0.2785467505455017,
0.9025753140449524,
0.6151078343391418,
0.09903155267238617,
-1.3215758800506592,
0.7200186848640442,
-0.5208972692489624,
0.1970614343881607,
-0.3596711754798889,
0.02947620488703251,
-0.1527816206216812,
0.6558327674865723,
0.4655914306640625,
0.3466460406780243,
0.27172476053237915,
-0.7850237488746643,
0.1649971902370453,
0.5063652992248535,
-0.4605782628059387,
-0.2071496546268463,
0.7620512247085571,
0.3820750117301941,
-0.314491331577301,
0.26853257417678833,
-0.11788046360015869,
-0.25472062826156616,
0.7145270109176636,
0.3824620246887207,
0.8558933138847351,
-0.06952208280563354,
0.1307065784931183,
-0.1919333040714264,
0.5480661392211914,
0.28603118658065796,
0.32441964745521545,
-0.250041663646698,
-0.5937791466712952,
-0.09908929467201233,
-0.5493795275688171,
-0.4134405255317688,
-0.3515559732913971,
-0.5505015254020691,
-0.0783570408821106,
-0.5088971257209778,
-0.42821335792541504,
0.013606930151581764,
-0.2905904948711395,
-0.9923595190048218,
0.47678160667419434,
0.06806351244449615,
0.7698098421096802,
-0.40856990218162537,
0.5880971550941467,
0.7364495992660522,
-0.8002548217773438,
-0.1112198457121849,
0.08194587379693985,
0.28691405057907104,
-0.7581931352615356,
0.5783339738845825,
0.23513396084308624,
-0.5388631224632263,
-0.3428177237510681,
-0.3066862225532532,
-0.6499202847480774,
1.051795244216919,
0.28883951902389526,
-0.3924221992492676,
0.31815630197525024,
0.1483636498451233,
0.5888439416885376,
0.003735420061275363,
0.5059127807617188,
0.0618782639503479,
0.7747967839241028,
-0.408141553401947,
-0.9593433141708374,
0.18660321831703186,
-0.5448587536811829,
0.1599961370229721,
-0.19836516678333282,
-0.7439392805099487,
0.8823501467704773,
0.225739985704422,
-0.08497222512960434,
0.2613368630409241,
0.5935528874397278,
-0.005501636769622564,
0.4028094410896301,
0.7625497579574585,
0.4081036448478699,
0.5972315073013306,
0.12641194462776184,
1.2249313592910767,
-0.021419359371066093,
-0.09359002113342285,
0.9143887758255005,
-0.48141902685165405,
0.7825522422790527,
0.2582465708255768,
0.00442075077444315,
0.48412981629371643,
0.43579569458961487,
-0.09024740755558014,
0.6023198962211609,
-0.10016967356204987,
-0.1503901481628418,
-0.4127999246120453,
-0.2756498456001282,
0.011592580005526543,
0.9215829968452454,
0.03561330959200859,
0.15567520260810852,
-0.2239484339952469,
0.5187680125236511,
-0.23755702376365662,
0.4565460681915283,
-0.361497700214386,
0.776997447013855,
-0.2900581359863281,
-0.6720356345176697,
0.4685584604740143,
0.2124650478363037,
0.4747655987739563,
-0.6839765310287476,
-0.1714387834072113,
-0.05813344568014145,
0.21914489567279816,
0.06092024967074394,
-0.46246424317359924,
-0.1916014552116394,
0.35440269112586975,
-0.154699444770813,
-0.3960894048213959,
0.8182393908500671,
0.11731771379709244,
-0.46726226806640625,
0.5816316604614258,
0.7026876211166382,
-0.12736523151397705,
-0.22260527312755585,
-0.6058167219161987,
0.36963316798210144,
-0.12051868438720703,
-0.21629568934440613,
0.3127003312110901,
0.33904626965522766,
-0.3645888864994049,
1.14473295211792,
0.707837700843811,
-0.3147440552711487,
0.08662711828947067,
0.198552206158638,
0.7689300775527954,
-0.7151975631713867,
-0.29338783025741577,
-0.8456435203552246,
0.3897917866706848,
-0.2779993712902069,
-0.3324262201786041,
1.049525499343872,
0.7003483772277832,
0.5161554217338562,
-0.14663809537887573,
0.8824537992477417,
-0.07702798396348953,
0.12182311713695526,
-0.5525979995727539,
0.752374529838562,
-0.9972931742668152,
-0.2660876214504242,
-0.41640347242355347,
-0.8116716146469116,
-0.0757097452878952,
0.44009488821029663,
0.13061128556728363,
0.02461278811097145,
0.4959755837917328,
0.5516642332077026,
-0.09728981554508209,
-0.20916256308555603,
0.5986156463623047,
0.04056356102228165,
0.2803989350795746,
0.10621408373117447,
1.1099979877471924,
-0.13207539916038513,
0.8051312565803528,
-0.1812395453453064,
-0.2970949709415436,
-0.3753587305545807,
-0.7559818029403687,
-1.0987364053726196,
-0.45634689927101135,
-0.010621339082717896,
-0.017132217064499855,
0.17192456126213074,
0.898568332195282,
0.9110599756240845,
-0.42983680963516235,
-0.36479097604751587,
-0.0009769335156306624,
0.1779833883047104,
-0.6070589423179626,
-0.15251818299293518,
-0.17150087654590607,
-0.09747844934463501,
-0.9181342124938965,
0.71599280834198,
0.421405166387558,
0.12654440104961395,
-0.3415426015853882,
0.15335889160633087,
-0.19725826382637024,
0.2237304449081421,
0.6768641471862793,
0.19304217398166656,
-0.7442618608474731,
-0.2593793570995331,
-0.1932820826768875,
-0.32502293586730957,
-0.1575075387954712,
0.5669026374816895,
-0.7835170030593872,
0.6607430577278137,
0.43147334456443787,
0.6518029570579529,
0.7545490860939026,
0.06511928886175156,
0.6299538612365723,
-0.6100467443466187,
0.37543731927871704,
0.06614534556865692,
0.41824570298194885,
0.21562913060188293,
0.22342105209827423,
0.5165642499923706,
0.20425045490264893,
-0.1792752891778946,
-0.6831228137016296,
0.1711471974849701,
-1.288994312286377,
-0.6685016751289368,
0.755313515663147,
0.013042153790593147,
-0.24975967407226562,
-0.12775976955890656,
-0.13261644542217255,
0.3210259675979614,
-0.3574512302875519,
0.4651339650154114,
0.37231892347335815,
-0.14516068994998932,
-0.3100045323371887,
-0.7875043749809265,
0.20897671580314636,
0.10380157083272934,
-1.165459394454956,
-0.15463462471961975,
0.8261661529541016,
0.10820875316858292,
0.13249579071998596,
0.5798066854476929,
0.5046475529670715,
0.4411715567111969,
0.47551625967025757,
0.4912233352661133,
-0.23169302940368652,
-0.559776782989502,
0.050523996353149414,
0.44151583313941956,
-0.16966882348060608,
-0.37476056814193726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01702v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01702v1 | Fluent dreaming for language models | 2024-01-24T17:57:12 | 2024-01-24T17:57:12 | T. Ben Thompson, Zygimantas Straznickas, Michael Sklar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Feature visualization, also known as "dreaming", offers insights into vision
models by optimizing the inputs to maximize a neuron's activation or other
internal component. However, dreaming has not been successfully applied to
language models because the input space is discrete. We extend Greedy
Coordinate Gradient, a method from the language model adversarial attack
literature, to design the Evolutionary Prompt Optimization (EPO) algorithm. EPO
optimizes the input prompt to simultaneously maximize the Pareto frontier
between a chosen internal feature and prompt fluency, enabling fluent dreaming
for language models. We demonstrate dreaming with neurons, output logits and
arbitrary directions in activation space. We measure the fluency of the
resulting prompts and compare language model dreaming with max-activating
dataset examples. Critically, fluent dreaming allows automatically exploring
the behavior of model internals in reaction to mildly out-of-distribution
prompts. Code for running EPO is available at
https://github.com/Confirm-Solutions/dreamy. A companion page demonstrating
code usage is at https://confirmlabs.org/posts/dreamy.html | [
-0.33527883887290955,
-0.8451407551765442,
0.46293729543685913,
0.35388651490211487,
-0.1447376012802124,
0.14052946865558624,
-0.4581371247768402,
-0.20789550244808197,
0.3453873097896576,
0.4581945836544037,
-0.5170150995254517,
-0.5420965552330017,
-0.3131910264492035,
-0.00819313433021307,
-0.060191813856363297,
0.6384809017181396,
0.16488705575466156,
-0.10320068150758743,
-0.3225652873516083,
0.24315325915813446,
-0.5153427720069885,
-0.2911189794540405,
-0.8726305365562439,
0.024077268317341805,
0.25144392251968384,
0.27072539925575256,
0.647972583770752,
0.6156592965126038,
0.12874868512153625,
0.2962520718574524,
-0.007585239131003618,
0.1256537288427353,
-0.8139192461967468,
0.2847956717014313,
0.3632688820362091,
-0.5380501747131348,
-0.141410693526268,
-0.31802481412887573,
0.5201362371444702,
0.9002949595451355,
-0.24624881148338318,
-0.13608002662658691,
0.2523255944252014,
0.42133191227912903,
-0.48383790254592896,
0.40870457887649536,
-0.7920492887496948,
0.32621654868125916,
0.13779699802398682,
-0.2741447389125824,
-0.3897934854030609,
-0.4519174098968506,
0.22316935658454895,
-0.7574087381362915,
0.2745382487773895,
0.09096688032150269,
0.9939682483673096,
0.21003775298595428,
-0.02188720367848873,
-0.24320702254772186,
-0.5443903803825378,
0.9067743420600891,
-0.34364134073257446,
0.4214307367801666,
0.17102178931236267,
0.2853388786315918,
-0.23586612939834595,
-0.6228144764900208,
-0.43607109785079956,
-0.49381113052368164,
0.16202270984649658,
0.11191391944885254,
-0.2834128439426422,
0.5201000571250916,
0.42160823941230774,
-0.010630431585013866,
-0.6780518889427185,
0.1696700155735016,
-0.2778765559196472,
-0.23128126561641693,
0.6797432899475098,
0.22485092282295227,
0.5593461990356445,
0.19542375206947327,
-0.4990660846233368,
-0.187503382563591,
-0.5273427367210388,
0.29108089208602905,
0.370211660861969,
0.3408229947090149,
-0.10892370343208313,
0.2560771107673645,
-0.18001002073287964,
1.0828276872634888,
-0.23291057348251343,
0.29894647002220154,
0.20046934485435486,
0.15152034163475037,
-0.11419689655303955,
-0.0926007404923439,
0.6514413952827454,
0.5736616253852844,
0.3308529853820801,
-0.07783759385347366,
-0.6065008044242859,
0.15316921472549438,
0.24811305105686188,
-0.5758994221687317,
-0.2733161449432373,
0.3159611225128174,
-0.28138870000839233,
-0.3670801818370819,
-0.21020662784576416,
-1.1667840480804443,
-0.5519908666610718,
-0.22333255410194397,
0.13717542588710785,
-0.4471296966075897,
-0.18250860273838043,
0.2303217053413391,
-0.30087167024612427,
0.2597287595272064,
0.2269691377878189,
-1.2844761610031128,
0.13304154574871063,
0.7113941311836243,
0.8661800622940063,
0.07568667083978653,
-0.3256499171257019,
-0.18073837459087372,
-0.3040405511856079,
-0.684677004814148,
0.5637375116348267,
-0.7265869379043579,
-0.33433571457862854,
0.2621980309486389,
-0.6132334470748901,
-0.5153544545173645,
-0.42254242300987244,
0.5408734083175659,
-0.4489540755748749,
-0.02531195431947708,
-0.1884497106075287,
-0.5219883918762207,
-0.23974065482616425,
0.08459728211164474,
-0.6840517520904541,
0.6782100796699524,
0.006335079204291105,
-0.2619921565055847,
0.40250134468078613,
-0.7747939825057983,
0.03905545547604561,
0.24118395149707794,
-0.46148282289505005,
-0.15830989181995392,
0.43020176887512207,
0.24979867041110992,
0.48510482907295227,
-0.20021380484104156,
0.19965174794197083,
-0.22997234761714935,
-0.2724354863166809,
0.21529413759708405,
-0.06535905599594116,
0.8061771392822266,
0.525909960269928,
-0.06628327071666718,
0.2795257866382599,
-0.4865838289260864,
0.010397378355264664,
0.5410003066062927,
-0.0173011664301157,
-0.2462424635887146,
0.17016096413135529,
-0.13859932124614716,
-0.1353747397661209,
0.23225250840187073,
-0.44310662150382996,
0.3251033425331116,
-0.6225248575210571,
0.4263084828853607,
0.6740699410438538,
-0.014841528609395027,
0.4176776111125946,
-0.4216170012950897,
0.7701506018638611,
-0.3070843815803528,
0.13288404047489166,
-0.29711416363716125,
-0.8485525846481323,
-0.8249387145042419,
-0.28082504868507385,
0.06541724503040314,
0.6586965322494507,
-0.8608309030532837,
0.3379109501838684,
-0.19738039374351501,
-0.1596592217683792,
-0.472400963306427,
-0.021633343771100044,
0.2988462448120117,
0.3672748804092407,
0.029666775837540627,
-0.07720187306404114,
-0.558811366558075,
-0.9532585740089417,
-0.32673653960227966,
-0.1659906655550003,
0.001492842915467918,
0.3223746418952942,
0.3051966726779938,
0.13974054157733917,
0.8503501415252686,
-0.6866306066513062,
-0.06451091170310974,
-0.5295370221138,
0.13532817363739014,
0.20993448793888092,
0.5460967421531677,
0.8898558020591736,
-0.7453402280807495,
-0.632469654083252,
0.14997561275959015,
-0.9492796659469604,
-0.00827903114259243,
-0.6233972907066345,
-0.15440072119235992,
-0.15076766908168793,
0.24257229268550873,
-0.5749455690383911,
0.009904859587550163,
0.32193922996520996,
-0.24615010619163513,
0.32360684871673584,
-0.10450088977813721,
0.03744383901357651,
-0.805311918258667,
-0.17047707736492157,
0.1840628832578659,
0.22459833323955536,
-1.0461825132369995,
0.356548547744751,
-0.07113997638225555,
-0.5055598616600037,
-0.08817195892333984,
0.5365993976593018,
-0.5985732078552246,
-0.003806809429079294,
-0.135070338845253,
-0.020794730633497238,
-0.3467741012573242,
0.6844210624694824,
0.1740347295999527,
0.507181704044342,
1.1065770387649536,
-0.37891873717308044,
0.41904082894325256,
0.1016509085893631,
-0.322374552488327,
0.10172917693853378,
-0.5873591303825378,
0.2912510931491852,
-0.4215731918811798,
-0.25224077701568604,
-0.8791863322257996,
-0.32844749093055725,
0.019662776961922646,
-0.758909285068512,
0.5064328908920288,
-0.11641377210617065,
-0.09600123018026352,
-0.31470322608947754,
-0.4490053653717041,
0.1285838782787323,
0.9438245296478271,
-0.4798867404460907,
0.5480929017066956,
0.351690411567688,
-0.1994132548570633,
-0.7219169735908508,
-0.3865843713283539,
0.176793172955513,
-0.25870954990386963,
-0.686269223690033,
0.19631938636302948,
0.09549315273761749,
-0.2263110876083374,
-0.2525867819786072,
0.30140212178230286,
0.17106635868549347,
0.2304573953151703,
-0.029409175738692284,
0.417748361825943,
-0.17752115428447723,
-0.3014644384384155,
0.10281126946210861,
-0.006931939162313938,
0.19632744789123535,
-0.5332736372947693,
0.6724497079849243,
-0.06201072409749031,
-0.09834067523479462,
-0.47425222396850586,
0.3140749931335449,
0.4618266820907593,
-0.134903684258461,
0.47647419571876526,
0.20076203346252441,
-0.6830153465270996,
-0.8695651888847351,
-0.25057098269462585,
-0.28287965059280396,
-0.5078195333480835,
0.5550829172134399,
-0.660296618938446,
-0.4714410603046417,
0.6445415616035461,
-0.013513323850929737,
0.21804752945899963,
0.08741854876279831,
0.24334141612052917,
-0.11259076744318008,
1.1894433498382568,
0.77970951795578,
0.2970365285873413,
0.7320639491081238,
-0.5842733383178711,
-0.055536769330501556,
-0.6288520097732544,
-0.3774566054344177,
-0.3358599841594696,
-0.3987419903278351,
-0.011594455689191818,
-0.4094921052455902,
0.33371710777282715,
0.3225165009498596,
0.13872651755809784,
0.17187929153442383,
-0.6398745775222778,
0.4988819360733032,
0.6471951007843018,
0.14053094387054443,
-0.33490148186683655,
0.32672855257987976,
-0.4659537076950073,
-0.32232457399368286,
-1.0022804737091064,
-0.4165899157524109,
1.0284245014190674,
0.22711710631847382,
0.5659937858581543,
-0.25955307483673096,
0.7466306686401367,
0.10825823992490768,
0.008252434432506561,
-0.8040444254875183,
0.8016577363014221,
0.12494133412837982,
-0.08421427756547928,
-0.2725011110305786,
-0.3427301049232483,
-1.0443865060806274,
0.341689795255661,
-0.26878172159194946,
-0.9097385406494141,
0.5376343131065369,
0.3973461091518402,
-0.6211267709732056,
0.3510622978210449,
-0.7622106075286865,
0.9851942658424377,
-0.14957958459854126,
-0.13659366965293884,
-0.18339574337005615,
-0.470146507024765,
0.2766774296760559,
0.05701971426606178,
-0.059498131275177,
0.08982184529304504,
-0.2776435315608978,
0.5615168809890747,
-0.3361697793006897,
0.9546637535095215,
-0.42915335297584534,
0.3147192597389221,
0.3726571798324585,
0.20807337760925293,
0.7460323572158813,
-0.34633299708366394,
-0.056067317724227905,
-0.03984346240758896,
-0.6746202707290649,
-0.5312390923500061,
-0.691006064414978,
0.7697746157646179,
-0.7480437755584717,
-0.572150707244873,
-0.2751690745353699,
-0.47307682037353516,
-0.34105247259140015,
-0.27951276302337646,
0.3024560511112213,
0.32940277457237244,
-0.2298821359872818,
-0.09706135094165802,
0.8725718259811401,
-0.42415672540664673,
0.5823289752006531,
0.09637246280908585,
-0.2852945923805237,
-0.3592585325241089,
1.218739628791809,
0.04699835181236267,
0.35413703322410583,
0.3259523808956146,
0.24452684819698334,
-0.13412298262119293,
-1.0838861465454102,
-0.7733389139175415,
0.08682964742183685,
-0.7838717103004456,
0.08050898462533951,
-0.6990174651145935,
-0.19093458354473114,
-0.21599212288856506,
-0.5458939075469971,
-0.09103681892156601,
-0.2980007827281952,
-0.3173249065876007,
-0.23037610948085785,
0.2687521278858185,
0.5593100786209106,
0.002052025403827429,
0.09637904167175293,
-0.6242243647575378,
0.03967802971601486,
0.24781672656536102,
0.0674331784248352,
0.1004151701927185,
-0.3550574779510498,
-0.10270148515701294,
0.07010447233915329,
-0.016857000067830086,
-1.0575348138809204,
0.6807452440261841,
0.4076410233974457,
0.9742375016212463,
0.5725926756858826,
-0.08948862552642822,
0.3386589288711548,
-0.2618091404438019,
0.8898249864578247,
0.3168865442276001,
-0.6897359490394592,
0.7857769131660461,
-0.46095359325408936,
0.11018174141645432,
0.29033708572387695,
0.5280487537384033,
-0.46588829159736633,
-0.3072620630264282,
-0.34866148233413696,
-0.7063468098640442,
0.5890044569969177,
0.15864990651607513,
0.29719358682632446,
0.07432668656110764,
0.26705536246299744,
0.2012617588043213,
0.05402717366814613,
-0.47336456179618835,
-0.23919816315174103,
-0.19444601237773895,
-0.3713076710700989,
0.1265755444765091,
-0.18103650212287903,
-0.182432159781456,
-0.0652260109782219,
0.31391075253486633,
-0.32014384865760803,
0.545604407787323,
0.06227894872426987,
-0.1134709045290947,
-0.13119491934776306,
-0.14228181540966034,
0.6407685279846191,
0.46543648838996887,
0.06676037609577179,
-0.2778238356113434,
0.15858420729637146,
-0.4751735031604767,
-0.30926597118377686,
0.05591574311256409,
-0.5669963359832764,
0.05001533776521683,
0.3126460015773773,
1.2868822813034058,
-0.06120622903108597,
-0.6220923662185669,
0.46315860748291016,
0.06839314103126526,
-0.23753423988819122,
-0.2063703089952469,
0.20080848038196564,
-0.1978347897529602,
0.15333667397499084,
0.3984872102737427,
0.4198574125766754,
0.2301659733057022,
-0.363678514957428,
-0.05377081781625748,
0.5605459809303284,
-0.3690909743309021,
-0.4189356863498688,
0.9909323453903198,
0.2717897891998291,
-0.44192036986351013,
0.7828996777534485,
-0.35621702671051025,
-0.5862331390380859,
0.9831359386444092,
0.7071678638458252,
1.222708821296692,
-0.06505591422319412,
0.27305012941360474,
0.5768634080886841,
0.19911527633666992,
0.14147309958934784,
0.7895002961158752,
-0.014955137856304646,
-0.9010045528411865,
-0.18484950065612793,
-0.7660654187202454,
-0.18537573516368866,
-0.20701579749584198,
-0.303331196308136,
0.4053487181663513,
-0.4604812562465668,
0.015820173546671867,
-0.030240636318922043,
-0.39370110630989075,
-0.5768738389015198,
0.09688989818096161,
0.5526896715164185,
0.6823862791061401,
-0.8345544934272766,
0.8554543256759644,
0.7805005311965942,
-0.5001788139343262,
-0.49450570344924927,
-0.26945534348487854,
0.007802467793226242,
-1.090771198272705,
0.4460676610469818,
0.02558857575058937,
0.060588907450437546,
0.30590543150901794,
-0.6537399888038635,
-0.6420010924339294,
0.9795459508895874,
0.492401123046875,
-0.6746659874916077,
-0.10054828226566315,
0.0860048308968544,
0.45971158146858215,
-0.6084588170051575,
0.15528973937034607,
0.3311123549938202,
0.16941438615322113,
0.17042535543441772,
-0.7122818231582642,
0.02179369144141674,
-0.33567553758621216,
0.2895321249961853,
0.1533658504486084,
-0.46653369069099426,
0.7388555407524109,
-0.6321195960044861,
-0.4163866937160492,
0.15271568298339844,
0.6969764828681946,
0.26358652114868164,
0.05606089532375336,
0.6102745532989502,
0.6202157735824585,
0.7921848297119141,
-0.35718849301338196,
1.253983497619629,
-0.6365072131156921,
0.28965458273887634,
0.6131435632705688,
-0.14547555148601532,
0.6783953905105591,
0.3510253429412842,
-0.08319447189569473,
0.32155942916870117,
0.828883707523346,
0.00371361430734396,
0.5956478118896484,
0.43637803196907043,
-0.40101680159568787,
-0.0947432667016983,
0.017212046310305595,
-0.24975693225860596,
0.05282151699066162,
0.7807118892669678,
-0.3726353645324707,
0.11148788779973984,
0.43661630153656006,
-0.16657914221286774,
0.228786900639534,
-0.4210144579410553,
0.7548245191574097,
0.06751570105552673,
-0.7589341402053833,
0.8025641441345215,
-0.370568186044693,
0.6151283383369446,
-0.7587746977806091,
-0.15062282979488373,
-0.3492093086242676,
-0.09040829539299011,
-0.04996626079082489,
-0.6633665561676025,
0.06143864244222641,
-0.22163498401641846,
0.3307984173297882,
-0.3885393738746643,
0.5971186757087708,
-0.47612813115119934,
-0.20712614059448242,
0.18743295967578888,
0.4311443269252777,
0.323507696390152,
-0.07938158512115479,
-0.7944996356964111,
0.19903980195522308,
0.22427916526794434,
-0.2397669106721878,
0.15175022184848785,
0.2200525999069214,
0.002135294722393155,
0.9068738222122192,
0.5787233114242554,
0.27399858832359314,
0.2745070159435272,
0.19726569950580597,
0.7880823612213135,
-0.5821025371551514,
-0.7269406914710999,
-0.705663800239563,
0.551080584526062,
-0.3103067874908447,
-0.5270018577575684,
0.5668655037879944,
0.5624874234199524,
0.813497006893158,
-0.46412768959999084,
0.8523553609848022,
-0.10360337793827057,
-0.14529632031917572,
-0.63204026222229,
0.7230328917503357,
-0.36437997221946716,
0.19807976484298706,
0.07244649529457092,
-1.0152156352996826,
-0.5373206734657288,
0.4244271218776703,
-0.2483065128326416,
-0.031276263296604156,
0.7038589119911194,
1.0127102136611938,
0.13352848589420319,
0.1523120254278183,
0.6869139075279236,
0.13060176372528076,
-0.16909745335578918,
0.7787962555885315,
1.0896073579788208,
0.05877947434782982,
0.31494390964508057,
-0.2722950875759125,
-0.415360689163208,
-0.243325337767601,
-0.4698812961578369,
-0.8939008712768555,
-0.6238125562667847,
-0.3935798704624176,
-0.21077443659305573,
0.3246234655380249,
1.2775343656539917,
0.7969951629638672,
-0.8185328841209412,
-0.41719862818717957,
-0.3270995616912842,
-0.04501337930560112,
-0.4776192605495453,
-0.20939171314239502,
0.18630219995975494,
-0.782187819480896,
-0.9997509717941284,
0.6420764327049255,
0.06441031396389008,
0.26365354657173157,
-0.3577199876308441,
-0.16054968535900116,
0.20822224020957947,
0.19511373341083527,
0.37489786744117737,
0.46034201979637146,
-0.6190947890281677,
-0.03458064794540405,
0.12690502405166626,
-0.05518877133727074,
0.08965563029050827,
0.9690467119216919,
-0.7023587822914124,
0.8593918681144714,
0.7335788011550903,
0.6734161972999573,
0.24330158531665802,
-0.2283598631620407,
0.9607040286064148,
-0.6189174652099609,
0.18077662587165833,
0.5432703495025635,
0.5810170769691467,
0.1609659343957901,
-0.475382536649704,
0.20023560523986816,
0.35674619674682617,
-0.3092699348926544,
-0.7729644775390625,
0.35684752464294434,
-0.9609413743019104,
-0.3600022792816162,
0.8962053060531616,
-0.21148879826068878,
-0.29058197140693665,
-0.054396893829107285,
-0.2618750333786011,
-0.14106306433677673,
-0.5577715039253235,
0.7107933759689331,
0.5321930050849915,
-0.30278870463371277,
-0.11929686367511749,
-0.7662582993507385,
0.9038867354393005,
0.36913931369781494,
-0.5184241533279419,
-0.1276806890964508,
0.5018877983093262,
-0.22844842076301575,
-0.008239702321588993,
0.3836730420589447,
0.19171099364757538,
0.3217175602912903,
0.6316654682159424,
0.2694986164569855,
-0.039516668766736984,
-0.41337740421295166,
-0.758853018283844,
0.44941121339797974,
0.15820463001728058,
-0.41670817136764526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13621v1 | DenoSent: A Denoising Objective for Self-Supervised Sentence Representation Learning | 2024-01-24T17:48:45 | 2024-01-24T17:48:45 | Xinghao Wang, Junliang He, Pengyu Wang, Yunhua Zhou, Tianxiang Sun, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contrastive-learning-based methods have dominated sentence representation
learning. These methods regularize the representation space by pulling similar
sentence representations closer and pushing away the dissimilar ones and have
been proven effective in various NLP tasks, e.g., semantic textual similarity
(STS) tasks. However, it is challenging for these methods to learn fine-grained
semantics as they only learn from the inter-sentence perspective, i.e., their
supervision signal comes from the relationship between data samples. In this
work, we propose a novel denoising objective that inherits from another
perspective, i.e., the intra-sentence perspective. By introducing both discrete
and continuous noise, we generate noisy sentences and then train our model to
restore them to their original form. Our empirical evaluations demonstrate that
this approach delivers competitive results on both semantic textual similarity
(STS) and a wide range of transfer tasks, standing up well in comparison to
contrastive-learning-based methods. Notably, the proposed intra-sentence
denoising objective complements existing inter-sentence contrastive
methodologies and can be integrated with them to further enhance performance.
Our code is available at https://github.com/xinghaow99/DenoSent. | [
-0.21234197914600372,
-0.5513129234313965,
0.2935590147972107,
0.4890291094779968,
-0.5505673885345459,
-0.10962376743555069,
-0.19639147818088531,
-0.27022403478622437,
0.3647671639919281,
0.5552639961242676,
-0.6928508281707764,
-0.6060110926628113,
-0.6108343601226807,
0.24590016901493073,
-0.6683274507522583,
1.055834412574768,
0.19039873778820038,
-0.046257004141807556,
-0.4461725652217865,
0.06140100583434105,
-0.30433884263038635,
-0.3499860167503357,
-0.4048287570476532,
-0.17022505402565002,
0.19790616631507874,
0.07647669315338135,
0.10890661925077438,
0.38232898712158203,
0.6169251203536987,
0.2793867588043213,
0.13908709585666656,
-0.11425220966339111,
-0.5028861165046692,
0.2877304255962372,
-0.05498078092932701,
-0.3481733202934265,
0.07145600765943527,
0.03730609640479088,
0.7102665305137634,
0.5942783951759338,
-0.22826221585273743,
-0.24964539706707,
0.4286205470561981,
0.6748917698860168,
-0.5588436126708984,
0.4954923689365387,
-0.6573637127876282,
0.23451422154903412,
0.10089021921157837,
0.017334969714283943,
-0.23742049932479858,
-0.20211529731750488,
0.09934654831886292,
-0.6712673902511597,
0.13285455107688904,
-0.2593337893486023,
0.9167881608009338,
0.46325889229774475,
-0.1970270723104477,
-0.2568788230419159,
-0.3741830289363861,
0.6392504572868347,
-0.7431880235671997,
0.12764205038547516,
0.2472759485244751,
-0.2563721835613251,
-0.014345244504511356,
-0.8784009218215942,
-0.35570138692855835,
-0.46142077445983887,
-0.4521726071834564,
0.7076433300971985,
-0.2897249460220337,
0.1348849982023239,
-0.10285047441720963,
0.3167042136192322,
-0.5142871141433716,
-0.04365741088986397,
-0.401395708322525,
0.07812490314245224,
0.22624988853931427,
-0.13808225095272064,
0.16083180904388428,
-0.39361417293548584,
-0.6887212991714478,
-0.0023338915780186653,
-0.12992893159389496,
-0.1335866004228592,
0.2881825268268585,
0.31921127438545227,
-0.1840551495552063,
0.20878177881240845,
-0.273858904838562,
0.38428518176078796,
0.11535263061523438,
0.22908622026443481,
0.2903955280780792,
-0.13618123531341553,
-0.10640264302492142,
0.06329633295536041,
0.6209532618522644,
0.6317726969718933,
0.12996505200862885,
-0.3703335225582123,
-0.2091580480337143,
0.2942345142364502,
0.4728010892868042,
-1.064881682395935,
-0.6942481994628906,
-0.2779013514518738,
-0.4860900044441223,
-0.4064585268497467,
0.26145508885383606,
-0.8702978491783142,
-0.15618164837360382,
-0.41477057337760925,
0.47737184166908264,
-0.6159970164299011,
-0.0726223960518837,
0.010144293308258057,
-0.06510947644710541,
-0.013287638314068317,
0.21059107780456543,
-0.9285061955451965,
0.7727054357528687,
0.4873945116996765,
0.9165292382240295,
-0.1823466718196869,
-0.23887333273887634,
-0.6291694641113281,
0.14178359508514404,
-0.2242937684059143,
0.7242866158485413,
-0.6055842041969299,
-0.27176836133003235,
-0.34353509545326233,
-0.12006349116563797,
-0.3241752088069916,
-0.5721661448478699,
0.3691641390323639,
-0.2253982126712799,
0.3171720504760742,
0.13310128450393677,
-0.6601815223693848,
-0.3267790377140045,
0.30089908838272095,
-0.4562140703201294,
1.0708591938018799,
0.30380314588546753,
-0.7097492814064026,
0.2898114025592804,
-0.4580048620700836,
-0.491582453250885,
0.038282427936792374,
-0.27843138575553894,
-0.5230035781860352,
0.10384383797645569,
0.3237830400466919,
0.5082950592041016,
0.13642682135105133,
0.07565471529960632,
-0.1834820955991745,
-0.48390230536460876,
-0.2473282366991043,
-0.44789016246795654,
0.6538115739822388,
0.2192598283290863,
-0.2945355176925659,
0.15228371322155,
-0.8656241297721863,
-0.32893937826156616,
-0.11643874645233154,
-0.12312284857034683,
-0.9630163908004761,
-0.3533695936203003,
-0.19517257809638977,
0.08389872312545776,
0.10461372137069702,
-0.7261555194854736,
0.15150626003742218,
-0.7737299799919128,
0.6331114172935486,
0.733522355556488,
0.24457277357578278,
0.6355650424957275,
-0.32239824533462524,
0.5053797364234924,
0.273541122674942,
-0.11340082436800003,
-0.25386181473731995,
-0.07694489508867264,
-0.5072404146194458,
-0.43093737959861755,
0.21573160588741302,
0.4055858254432678,
-0.3340606689453125,
0.39498192071914673,
-0.1102350503206253,
-0.24424734711647034,
-0.5851627588272095,
0.2619335651397705,
0.3771955370903015,
0.7090651392936707,
0.6315444111824036,
-0.3094289004802704,
-0.6421997547149658,
-0.8745177984237671,
-0.19361567497253418,
-0.0912628322839737,
0.019016524776816368,
-0.1748790293931961,
0.46688756346702576,
-0.31368541717529297,
0.8848326206207275,
-0.4420178234577179,
-0.8615660667419434,
0.030564524233341217,
0.30200299620628357,
0.10114715248346329,
0.7090538144111633,
0.7884754538536072,
-0.7600510716438293,
-0.5273904800415039,
-0.22377368807792664,
-0.7465358972549438,
-0.391918808221817,
-0.37073567509651184,
0.1101287230849266,
0.11167732626199722,
1.2671098709106445,
-0.463040828704834,
0.4317433834075928,
0.6711486577987671,
-0.08561044186353683,
0.4530031383037567,
-0.44491103291511536,
0.09568805992603302,
-1.22659432888031,
-0.2270377278327942,
0.011767477728426456,
-0.1305883675813675,
-0.1954139918088913,
0.015687815845012665,
-0.03694862127304077,
0.15066631138324738,
-0.09276269376277924,
0.4035239815711975,
-0.6052079796791077,
0.1273338496685028,
-0.06873579323291779,
0.5824851393699646,
0.3113499879837036,
0.48319417238235474,
-0.14413808286190033,
0.8340967297554016,
0.4176037609577179,
-0.45486536622047424,
-0.017433803528547287,
0.5238600969314575,
-0.26267433166503906,
0.659713089466095,
-0.5335786938667297,
-0.32334592938423157,
-0.3796401619911194,
0.1134294718503952,
-1.1874144077301025,
0.1659744530916214,
0.2492716759443283,
-0.35112476348876953,
0.14031200110912323,
-0.21254926919937134,
-0.14316913485527039,
0.0530049130320549,
-0.4460306465625763,
0.11570553481578827,
0.4725759029388428,
-0.46728086471557617,
0.44440993666648865,
0.08181837201118469,
-0.2400994449853897,
-0.5328484773635864,
-0.9849584102630615,
0.15031155943870544,
-0.3049309551715851,
-0.21411357820034027,
0.7005755305290222,
0.01776815950870514,
-0.457537978887558,
0.2808040976524353,
-0.2515869736671448,
-0.03844275698065758,
-0.0057115741074085236,
0.40048831701278687,
0.017664026468992233,
-0.16824950277805328,
0.6095220446586609,
0.3474421799182892,
-0.2434232383966446,
0.35524579882621765,
-0.24496710300445557,
0.16783493757247925,
-0.10338503122329712,
-0.10470997542142868,
-0.3165949881076813,
0.34384408593177795,
0.10321816056966782,
-0.10501527786254883,
0.4382953941822052,
0.8398388028144836,
-0.059343449771404266,
-0.40499794483184814,
-0.1540805995464325,
-0.5337600708007812,
-0.4212988317012787,
0.4946339726448059,
-0.7406210899353027,
-0.9578564763069153,
0.29088741540908813,
-0.3367396891117096,
-0.021505363285541534,
0.4083058834075928,
0.11691933125257492,
-0.36297571659088135,
0.36875131726264954,
0.6673862934112549,
-0.11538209766149521,
0.6661370992660522,
-0.34117019176483154,
-0.0026188543997704983,
-0.9537158608436584,
-0.06964104622602463,
-0.43294626474380493,
-0.12197622656822205,
-0.39957958459854126,
-0.2859494686126709,
0.2077612429857254,
0.41008129715919495,
-0.14469876885414124,
0.4554785490036011,
-0.6049764752388,
0.2524826228618622,
0.7346795201301575,
0.32294145226478577,
0.32649508118629456,
0.20051315426826477,
-0.2720649540424347,
-0.33530429005622864,
-0.6159835457801819,
-0.19411711394786835,
0.6228116154670715,
-0.15321433544158936,
0.7788522243499756,
-0.10357441008090973,
1.2076857089996338,
0.556336522102356,
-0.07151790708303452,
-0.48203033208847046,
0.6013718247413635,
-0.7429593205451965,
0.1071903184056282,
-0.27862823009490967,
-0.47883811593055725,
-1.1188697814941406,
0.6468536853790283,
-0.2283964902162552,
-0.7230825424194336,
0.17596881091594696,
-0.13052763044834137,
-0.20873863995075226,
0.2488357126712799,
-0.6692765355110168,
0.946101725101471,
0.312427818775177,
-0.3375856578350067,
-0.3835583031177521,
-0.9359685778617859,
0.17006900906562805,
0.15300296247005463,
0.11997160315513611,
-0.20436929166316986,
0.0057601239532232285,
0.4901530146598816,
-0.22671671211719513,
1.1098833084106445,
-0.08175797760486603,
0.04293614625930786,
0.17385585606098175,
0.38374707102775574,
0.36473920941352844,
0.1386280059814453,
-0.1747385859489441,
0.09920211881399155,
0.02009958028793335,
-0.17370450496673584,
-0.66731858253479,
0.854805588722229,
-0.551841139793396,
-0.545892596244812,
-0.26290151476860046,
-0.5604110360145569,
0.1130763441324234,
0.2603294849395752,
0.06913092732429504,
0.5005427598953247,
-0.3587888777256012,
0.3648383915424347,
0.4831753373146057,
0.20218300819396973,
0.754408597946167,
0.06899093091487885,
-0.14765363931655884,
-0.41819965839385986,
0.709071159362793,
-0.06944598257541656,
0.263781875371933,
0.8407307863235474,
0.2072868049144745,
-0.3045218586921692,
-0.6104053258895874,
-0.0859653577208519,
0.09749402850866318,
-0.7506322860717773,
-0.11939273029565811,
-0.9652665257453918,
-0.2571229636669159,
-0.4555441737174988,
-0.35002538561820984,
-0.1746695190668106,
-0.43616172671318054,
-0.6328859925270081,
-0.10732177644968033,
0.38191625475883484,
0.4645088315010071,
-0.4244302213191986,
0.4069528579711914,
-0.8607855439186096,
0.6808626055717468,
0.2965112328529358,
0.15296702086925507,
-0.414413720369339,
-0.6916298866271973,
0.06877836585044861,
-0.21359068155288696,
0.1218300312757492,
-0.4131931960582733,
0.6216270923614502,
0.27762603759765625,
0.5547305941581726,
0.20026732981204987,
0.6168427467346191,
0.7094932198524475,
-0.036933548748493195,
0.4508868455886841,
0.11101799458265305,
-0.9093807339668274,
0.47681087255477905,
-0.08827675879001617,
0.4407539367675781,
0.8936479687690735,
0.11222971975803375,
-0.274754136800766,
-0.6355858445167542,
-0.5125579833984375,
-0.8479131460189819,
0.4837409257888794,
0.37378787994384766,
0.365483820438385,
-0.14966265857219696,
0.49127766489982605,
0.28215306997299194,
0.3204385042190552,
-1.056389570236206,
0.1179206445813179,
-0.27010682225227356,
-0.46063902974128723,
0.05025029554963112,
-0.219131201505661,
0.10932542383670807,
-0.16191230714321136,
0.521780788898468,
-0.23167994618415833,
0.00876395683735609,
0.6945699453353882,
-0.3384639024734497,
0.2014290988445282,
0.36101701855659485,
0.22358305752277374,
0.1567009538412094,
-0.29236963391304016,
0.40030357241630554,
0.10303057730197906,
-0.6152510643005371,
-0.16350188851356506,
0.32207900285720825,
-0.5838057398796082,
0.015642033889889717,
0.4787302613258362,
0.4421826899051666,
0.3409421741962433,
-0.4992692470550537,
0.594739556312561,
0.15369950234889984,
-0.30432912707328796,
-0.1926688700914383,
-0.0749322772026062,
-0.09111437946557999,
0.4281269311904907,
0.03793470188975334,
0.3259308636188507,
0.4555169939994812,
-0.41420668363571167,
0.6026885509490967,
0.2541426718235016,
-0.9307447671890259,
-0.141357883810997,
0.6977982521057129,
0.08169267326593399,
0.07195437699556351,
0.6211998462677002,
-0.20723609626293182,
-0.3574419915676117,
0.6259863376617432,
0.6089401245117188,
0.9562135338783264,
-0.004017544444650412,
0.3851999342441559,
0.5099685192108154,
0.3835311532020569,
0.0701509490609169,
0.010233240202069283,
-0.18926887214183807,
-0.6078124642372131,
-0.23710940778255463,
-0.6639938354492188,
-0.022969046607613564,
-0.27397823333740234,
-0.6471925973892212,
0.018912557512521744,
-0.2412150353193283,
0.1744672656059265,
-0.13105927407741547,
-0.10330268740653992,
0.14104506373405457,
0.238088920712471,
-0.18942362070083618,
0.32840150594711304,
-0.5730734467506409,
0.8083829879760742,
0.525820255279541,
-0.6452407240867615,
-0.23627305030822754,
0.18516568839550018,
-0.3377798795700073,
-0.48962268233299255,
0.6268284916877747,
0.24828338623046875,
-0.45787450671195984,
0.10177843272686005,
-0.3464251458644867,
-0.3999870717525482,
0.8131579160690308,
0.5752775073051453,
-0.7640445828437805,
-0.035277362912893295,
-0.09271247684955597,
0.5469307899475098,
-0.5292686223983765,
-0.03756025433540344,
0.33019253611564636,
0.3757359981536865,
-0.09587155282497406,
-0.3820513188838959,
0.15518596768379211,
-0.17194676399230957,
0.08164235204458237,
0.05616479739546776,
-0.7107608318328857,
1.0185271501541138,
-0.2986666262149811,
-0.16829147934913635,
0.11838826537132263,
0.6208961606025696,
0.04921223595738411,
0.16026180982589722,
0.5568899512290955,
0.5485551357269287,
0.3713451325893402,
0.05590512230992317,
0.6998029351234436,
-0.24660088121891022,
0.2955074906349182,
1.6443085670471191,
-0.1537313461303711,
0.5563719272613525,
0.8126336336135864,
0.056099411100149155,
0.9555337429046631,
0.2578563988208771,
-0.2536587119102478,
0.8265175819396973,
0.37003228068351746,
-0.07829021662473679,
-0.14767923951148987,
0.02515159361064434,
-0.12431797385215759,
0.44173893332481384,
0.13761812448501587,
-0.36516252160072327,
-0.4944888949394226,
0.1578836441040039,
-0.09182897955179214,
0.9587908983230591,
-0.07131136953830719,
1.018247365951538,
0.22502507269382477,
-0.2907806634902954,
0.23389467597007751,
-0.35533273220062256,
0.6874650120735168,
-0.7567227482795715,
-0.5158840417861938,
-0.2823168635368347,
0.44068458676338196,
-0.09570084512233734,
-0.5926628708839417,
0.4828697144985199,
-0.6478976011276245,
-0.1345868706703186,
-0.3125132620334625,
0.6948995590209961,
-0.5909598469734192,
-0.22642400860786438,
0.7679964900016785,
0.2672390341758728,
0.11643712222576141,
-0.3759942352771759,
-0.7564932703971863,
-0.13266950845718384,
-0.07081598788499832,
-0.17323629558086395,
0.32979440689086914,
0.6263318061828613,
0.02997906133532524,
0.5922641158103943,
0.24934037029743195,
0.03533206507563591,
0.00439650472253561,
0.32077163457870483,
0.8516893982887268,
-0.6132730841636658,
-0.7015593647956848,
-0.8128372430801392,
0.18196356296539307,
-0.2111922949552536,
-0.4689284861087799,
0.8397565484046936,
0.6138864755630493,
0.9545453190803528,
-0.24497172236442566,
0.623731791973114,
-0.06696045398712158,
0.3991355001926422,
-0.664638102054596,
0.49901092052459717,
-0.41922348737716675,
0.32177290320396423,
-0.4344896376132965,
-0.9077468514442444,
-0.5433263778686523,
0.7972949743270874,
-0.16556920111179352,
-0.0939284935593605,
0.8122485280036926,
0.811478316783905,
-0.06410041451454163,
-0.1635987013578415,
0.5201481580734253,
0.419680655002594,
0.010483221150934696,
0.38273927569389343,
0.8128178715705872,
-0.5989435315132141,
0.806875467300415,
-0.5168750882148743,
0.03789914399385452,
-0.06953520327806473,
-0.664819598197937,
-0.8996542096138,
-0.6382313370704651,
-0.45364564657211304,
-0.007404050789773464,
0.39696305990219116,
0.7966363430023193,
0.6377692818641663,
-0.5934510827064514,
-0.15427005290985107,
-0.6765604615211487,
-0.06486240029335022,
-0.4672950208187103,
-0.28228771686553955,
0.48868751525878906,
-0.7524130940437317,
-0.7218151688575745,
0.3703034222126007,
0.4934130907058716,
0.029268886893987656,
-0.09078069031238556,
0.1546279340982437,
-0.4714357554912567,
-0.051560334861278534,
0.8075448870658875,
-0.2090119570493698,
-0.5698217153549194,
-0.3331436812877655,
-0.31247416138648987,
-0.3315671980381012,
0.2093593329191208,
0.6069225668907166,
-1.0099724531173706,
0.4280799329280853,
0.3484332859516144,
0.49853432178497314,
0.8225610852241516,
0.22142809629440308,
0.2798274755477905,
-0.8872677087783813,
0.3654213547706604,
0.35624751448631287,
0.24860042333602905,
0.10190441459417343,
-0.3339412212371826,
0.871123194694519,
0.400892049074173,
-0.2699069380760193,
-0.5185642838478088,
0.11844401061534882,
-1.1186206340789795,
-0.7332368493080139,
0.9673000574111938,
-0.4035170376300812,
-0.005630154628306627,
-0.07670470327138901,
-0.42143410444259644,
0.2003285437822342,
-0.5850774049758911,
1.02100670337677,
0.32164818048477173,
-0.0011555643286556005,
-0.4284789562225342,
-0.33462926745414734,
0.451923131942749,
0.36713770031929016,
-0.9168868064880371,
0.1857917755842209,
0.5896334648132324,
0.1638219654560089,
-0.0037112897261977196,
0.5493879318237305,
-0.21827112138271332,
-0.11312051862478256,
0.5155078768730164,
0.20102062821388245,
-0.04076505824923515,
-0.3545033931732178,
-0.34248387813568115,
0.42164546251296997,
-0.41492918133735657,
-0.3872724175453186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13601v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13601v5 | MM-LLMs: Recent Advances in MultiModal Large Language Models | 2024-01-24T17:10:45 | 2024-05-28T05:36:23 | Duzhen Zhang, Yahan Yu, Jiahua Dong, Chenxing Li, Dan Su, Chenhui Chu, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the past year, MultiModal Large Language Models (MM-LLMs) have undergone
substantial advancements, augmenting off-the-shelf LLMs to support MM inputs or
outputs via cost-effective training strategies. The resulting models not only
preserve the inherent reasoning and decision-making capabilities of LLMs but
also empower a diverse range of MM tasks. In this paper, we provide a
comprehensive survey aimed at facilitating further research of MM-LLMs.
Initially, we outline general design formulations for model architecture and
training pipeline. Subsequently, we introduce a taxonomy encompassing 126
MM-LLMs, each characterized by its specific formulations. Furthermore, we
review the performance of selected MM-LLMs on mainstream benchmarks and
summarize key training recipes to enhance the potency of MM-LLMs. Finally, we
explore promising directions for MM-LLMs while concurrently maintaining a
real-time tracking website for the latest developments in the field. We hope
that this survey contributes to the ongoing advancement of the MM-LLMs domain. | [
-0.528597354888916,
-0.848884105682373,
0.7104310989379883,
0.1254681646823883,
0.1535448580980301,
0.2980029881000519,
-0.42454731464385986,
-0.20565438270568848,
0.14651000499725342,
0.36444202065467834,
-0.7088459134101868,
-0.5152823328971863,
-0.702368974685669,
0.13203103840351105,
-0.14562581479549408,
0.3325348198413849,
-0.134646475315094,
0.4670744240283966,
-0.3713221848011017,
-0.19676154851913452,
-0.30570802092552185,
-0.8249973058700562,
-0.4679340124130249,
-0.22482527792453766,
0.832556426525116,
0.4058436453342438,
0.22943636775016785,
0.3653678596019745,
0.4981289505958557,
0.3608076870441437,
-0.15244877338409424,
0.43914350867271423,
-0.09787964820861816,
0.22930878400802612,
0.043207354843616486,
-0.36628204584121704,
-0.9241631627082825,
0.15994885563850403,
1.0057430267333984,
0.8422130346298218,
-0.20756040513515472,
0.15630711615085602,
-0.10483022779226303,
0.5209835171699524,
-0.7080885171890259,
0.19047141075134277,
-0.4562361538410187,
-0.0417594276368618,
-0.2896929085254669,
-0.11107144504785538,
-0.5687879920005798,
-0.04982835799455643,
0.1882084608078003,
-0.29741737246513367,
-0.229172021150589,
0.014588706195354462,
0.07237385958433151,
-0.060069188475608826,
-0.8210138082504272,
-0.5518200993537903,
-0.7311346530914307,
1.1471225023269653,
-0.6535053253173828,
0.8723405599594116,
0.20181693136692047,
0.5429363250732422,
-0.1656477302312851,
-0.7014275193214417,
-0.33676043152809143,
-0.5175358057022095,
0.4342362582683563,
0.21029028296470642,
-0.0005196175188757479,
-0.040186136960983276,
-0.0007043554214760661,
0.3290657103061676,
-0.46518874168395996,
0.5945501923561096,
-0.010592191480100155,
-0.14446155726909637,
0.4549736976623535,
0.5364584922790527,
0.04823451116681099,
0.11354296654462814,
-0.34014734625816345,
0.04280829057097435,
-0.9221705198287964,
-0.26780441403388977,
0.2663264870643616,
0.09715141355991364,
-0.2902436852455139,
0.7305440306663513,
-0.18836474418640137,
0.8102073669433594,
-0.4317602813243866,
-0.6688241958618164,
0.2749888598918915,
-0.5154395699501038,
-0.20251649618148804,
-0.495591938495636,
0.8149205446243286,
0.424813836812973,
-0.011348065920174122,
-0.04749135673046112,
-0.23318707942962646,
-0.15446323156356812,
-0.12956322729587555,
-0.7029487490653992,
0.13650503754615784,
0.026702076196670532,
-0.5426540374755859,
-0.2096940577030182,
-0.3418159782886505,
-0.7349416613578796,
-0.3885369896888733,
-0.47238993644714355,
0.1290024220943451,
-0.1941615641117096,
-0.5053480267524719,
0.15589961409568787,
-0.08798117935657501,
0.18045926094055176,
0.5668278932571411,
-0.8502944707870483,
0.023091057315468788,
0.505181610584259,
0.8834364414215088,
-0.24817311763763428,
-0.2855774760246277,
-0.28437042236328125,
0.30273616313934326,
-0.17377296090126038,
0.6561126112937927,
-0.7642205953598022,
-0.4510614275932312,
0.28371602296829224,
0.019809722900390625,
-0.14737677574157715,
-0.5938466191291809,
0.34965184330940247,
-0.539358377456665,
0.333482950925827,
-0.2786579132080078,
-0.5295253992080688,
-0.17747019231319427,
0.7576490044593811,
-0.5293724536895752,
0.6562473177909851,
-0.06801040470600128,
-0.5608261823654175,
0.1438344568014145,
-0.6376624703407288,
-0.14986327290534973,
-0.27156445384025574,
-0.07103455811738968,
-0.2779257595539093,
0.1967010498046875,
0.23529070615768433,
0.6909376382827759,
-0.5048366189002991,
0.22474932670593262,
-0.49443498253822327,
-0.08630044013261795,
0.5463535189628601,
-0.7101982831954956,
0.49641039967536926,
0.4730640947818756,
0.202056884765625,
0.221678227186203,
-0.8410581946372986,
-0.28589585423469543,
0.11736710369586945,
-0.652185320854187,
0.07468094676733017,
0.25319528579711914,
0.03808284178376198,
0.3604311943054199,
0.3817768096923828,
-0.4173542559146881,
0.3985063433647156,
-0.01212767232209444,
0.664495050907135,
0.6704632639884949,
-0.19095344841480255,
0.6009527444839478,
-0.294741690158844,
0.5973105430603027,
0.08593498915433884,
0.27586063742637634,
-0.4561239182949066,
-0.34619370102882385,
-0.7504134178161621,
-0.5233855843544006,
0.3461078405380249,
0.4763636589050293,
-0.7840600609779358,
0.014374075457453728,
-0.324674516916275,
-0.5359539985656738,
-0.3342689573764801,
0.16836333274841309,
0.08157079666852951,
-0.007118316367268562,
0.19493244588375092,
-0.20091742277145386,
-0.5516643524169922,
-0.7865884900093079,
0.0742930918931961,
-0.09366349130868912,
-0.047178808599710464,
0.41640955209732056,
0.33712777495384216,
-0.6525182127952576,
0.5894764065742493,
-0.4284306764602661,
-0.12468140572309494,
-0.5246041417121887,
0.055010974407196045,
-0.12460531294345856,
0.2153717279434204,
0.5038507580757141,
-0.5276337265968323,
-0.22802883386611938,
-0.06428444385528564,
-0.6329380869865417,
-0.038544993847608566,
0.16193802654743195,
0.3745109736919403,
0.18469101190567017,
0.6514906883239746,
-0.6876624822616577,
-0.3247549533843994,
0.9436922669410706,
0.12674076855182648,
0.7466375827789307,
-0.11881525069475174,
0.1468343585729599,
-1.2380605936050415,
-0.1347901076078415,
0.020150797441601753,
-0.043725281953811646,
-0.4995814859867096,
0.15240857005119324,
0.07928327471017838,
0.1759139895439148,
-0.650128185749054,
0.6474079489707947,
-0.731376588344574,
-0.1598193496465683,
-0.2719108760356903,
0.24211987853050232,
-0.2749744653701782,
0.32102811336517334,
-0.026649391278624535,
0.7091948986053467,
0.6106123924255371,
-0.6062512993812561,
0.5959206223487854,
-0.08697669953107834,
-0.3003084063529968,
0.5236240029335022,
-0.20119981467723846,
-0.08216889202594757,
-0.17171184718608856,
0.24449022114276886,
-0.9259634017944336,
-0.23823893070220947,
0.14183786511421204,
-0.3303825557231903,
0.34191468358039856,
-0.2489052563905716,
-0.730830192565918,
-0.29950547218322754,
-0.4554886221885681,
0.25460079312324524,
0.3287884294986725,
-0.3031885623931885,
0.7274560928344727,
0.4618925452232361,
-0.30525338649749756,
-0.40656447410583496,
-0.633751392364502,
0.3499496877193451,
-0.3150927722454071,
-0.49689239263534546,
0.0487615205347538,
-0.38391736149787903,
-0.4099554717540741,
-0.4732830822467804,
0.2431475967168808,
-0.023091088980436325,
0.1111108586192131,
-0.061833009123802185,
0.13848862051963806,
-0.2826845347881317,
0.11283251643180847,
-0.2236642837524414,
0.0016577234491705894,
0.19261573255062103,
-0.11386475712060928,
0.7693641185760498,
-0.01586456038057804,
-0.5455870628356934,
-0.12026301771402359,
0.29276004433631897,
0.7374846935272217,
-0.3505406975746155,
0.6666775345802307,
0.7655050158500671,
-0.07952801138162613,
-0.056973762810230255,
-0.8265296220779419,
0.01636483706533909,
-0.45583102107048035,
0.5133678317070007,
-0.35938549041748047,
-1.1744507551193237,
0.2758128046989441,
-0.582727313041687,
0.19719262421131134,
0.18510150909423828,
0.9469629526138306,
-0.18703818321228027,
1.2334682941436768,
0.7071460485458374,
-0.10775014013051987,
0.6426145434379578,
-0.062139544636011124,
-0.09763979911804199,
-0.9535680413246155,
-0.4823198616504669,
-0.334208220243454,
-0.0846409723162651,
-0.6513460874557495,
-0.6527082920074463,
0.32079562544822693,
-0.25859150290489197,
-0.010639525949954987,
-0.03598250076174736,
0.07636836916208267,
0.10696682333946228,
0.33851808309555054,
-0.18055759370326996,
0.3358595669269562,
-0.07612166553735733,
-0.4171184301376343,
-0.012605685740709305,
-0.7542445063591003,
-0.6591170430183411,
1.1880241632461548,
0.6572968363761902,
1.0603654384613037,
0.39086517691612244,
0.19918005168437958,
0.10623463243246078,
0.3078369200229645,
-0.7610467672348022,
0.6483396887779236,
-0.10607364773750305,
-0.6562463641166687,
-0.05006548762321472,
-0.4651808440685272,
-0.6190937161445618,
0.438519686460495,
-0.10212742537260056,
-0.23591965436935425,
-0.28404101729393005,
0.1076231524348259,
0.08349177986383438,
0.3650759160518646,
-0.7116788625717163,
0.7209452986717224,
-0.6067950129508972,
-0.19133855402469635,
-0.327454149723053,
-0.5485303997993469,
0.5151408910751343,
-0.14299337565898895,
0.3581700623035431,
-0.33696696162223816,
-0.38223162293434143,
0.40883737802505493,
0.05774640664458275,
0.830180823802948,
-0.13982950150966644,
-0.38514581322669983,
0.11218858510255814,
-0.26722005009651184,
0.3431333601474762,
-0.13033513724803925,
0.01921505481004715,
0.03039407916367054,
-0.21368150413036346,
-0.13919782638549805,
-0.2355547845363617,
0.8558279275894165,
-0.5430086255073547,
-0.3735477328300476,
-0.31695815920829773,
-0.6727328300476074,
-0.5170361995697021,
0.14219734072685242,
-0.12740549445152283,
0.6318029165267944,
-0.3338721990585327,
0.32400691509246826,
0.8165956735610962,
-0.4259796440601349,
0.639019787311554,
0.6651886105537415,
-0.5491192936897278,
-0.582767903804779,
0.8022943139076233,
0.244465172290802,
0.4161830246448517,
0.7232651710510254,
0.05080622062087059,
-0.5083767175674438,
-0.9294376969337463,
-0.3978862464427948,
0.2387811243534088,
-0.6329317092895508,
0.03554653003811836,
-0.7646235227584839,
-0.005155349150300026,
-0.458840012550354,
0.0036158005241304636,
-0.3574952483177185,
-0.34187713265419006,
-0.2637420892715454,
0.05060582607984543,
0.11867830157279968,
0.8256977796554565,
0.15564794838428497,
0.5142590999603271,
-0.8140797019004822,
0.10550177097320557,
0.4173664450645447,
0.41881388425827026,
0.016997812315821648,
-0.29074791073799133,
-0.30982139706611633,
0.14291076362133026,
-0.3792659342288971,
-0.5373859405517578,
0.38014984130859375,
0.02373146452009678,
0.803076982498169,
0.39306262135505676,
-0.40134483575820923,
0.5771584510803223,
-0.6806548237800598,
0.9319557547569275,
0.3972359597682953,
-0.5122202634811401,
0.2570543885231018,
-0.46793755888938904,
0.5841794610023499,
0.041948460042476654,
0.5881145596504211,
-0.5202671885490417,
-0.2609237730503082,
-0.0606987327337265,
-0.5132633447647095,
0.3978339433670044,
-0.17895133793354034,
0.26840823888778687,
0.012871339917182922,
-0.05118875205516815,
0.022662119939923286,
0.3193775415420532,
-0.5921458601951599,
-0.2581557333469391,
0.0500105582177639,
-0.2422385960817337,
-0.32873407006263733,
-0.4921519458293915,
0.06938599795103073,
-0.13682155311107635,
0.49468281865119934,
-0.2085457295179367,
0.29634591937065125,
-0.373083233833313,
-0.40389350056648254,
0.23845045268535614,
0.5787651538848877,
0.8651652336120605,
0.9269559979438782,
-0.23977600038051605,
0.34181949496269226,
0.3781132698059082,
-0.33431747555732727,
0.1876305192708969,
0.07703319936990738,
0.19212670624256134,
0.02769528143107891,
0.2182951718568802,
0.7464671730995178,
0.4019320011138916,
-0.9970825910568237,
0.45602598786354065,
-0.05304352566599846,
-0.39067965745925903,
-0.41309574246406555,
-0.10446567088365555,
0.4873899519443512,
0.4252110719680786,
0.18072479963302612,
-0.17324326932430267,
-0.044116098433732986,
-0.6514102220535278,
-0.15345601737499237,
0.755245566368103,
-0.11523595452308655,
-0.3901066184043884,
0.5816324353218079,
0.21233627200126648,
0.027363192290067673,
0.3914851248264313,
0.014615262858569622,
-0.2904179096221924,
0.06294890493154526,
0.3916938006877899,
0.5771862268447876,
-0.25919413566589355,
-0.07141342014074326,
0.06142788007855415,
0.28853657841682434,
0.0683564692735672,
0.12345368415117264,
-0.12108145654201508,
-0.5904366970062256,
-0.5277453660964966,
-0.6486015915870667,
-0.6914414167404175,
0.17752957344055176,
-0.23765155673027039,
0.37154287099838257,
-0.26631319522857666,
-0.43527042865753174,
-0.05676541477441788,
-0.011423652060329914,
-0.4023396372795105,
0.11387699842453003,
0.47542038559913635,
1.035014271736145,
-0.4759008586406708,
0.9085586071014404,
0.9333627223968506,
-0.2728312313556671,
-0.18745578825473785,
-0.4401317834854126,
0.30984920263290405,
-0.7809036374092102,
0.422993928194046,
0.007637736853212118,
-0.167301744222641,
-0.06333230435848236,
-0.4327750504016876,
-0.8376531004905701,
1.2076761722564697,
0.2976749837398529,
-0.5460581183433533,
-0.16738566756248474,
0.4572153091430664,
0.3018963038921356,
-0.3405676484107971,
0.317745178937912,
0.387207567691803,
0.37041857838630676,
0.2562451660633087,
-0.969207227230072,
-0.5709306001663208,
-0.01604972593486309,
0.040618471801280975,
0.23594307899475098,
-0.7881126999855042,
0.7420142889022827,
0.025732461363077164,
0.06189201772212982,
0.2380451112985611,
0.4983535408973694,
0.5161967873573303,
0.23924759030342102,
0.2433021366596222,
0.5918470025062561,
0.31386828422546387,
-0.20611529052257538,
0.778878927230835,
-0.01214625220745802,
0.11551037430763245,
0.7917330861091614,
-0.4201386868953705,
1.00407874584198,
0.4756554961204529,
-0.2737416625022888,
0.16578811407089233,
0.6296800971031189,
-0.07300325483083725,
0.3990931212902069,
0.06684956699609756,
-0.43502119183540344,
-0.2021140605211258,
-0.25404709577560425,
-0.43235376477241516,
0.4565039575099945,
0.58722323179245,
-0.4151090383529663,
-0.3332369327545166,
0.25389865040779114,
0.10295487195253372,
-0.3040326237678528,
-0.43294546008110046,
0.8397859334945679,
0.21141009032726288,
-0.4944906234741211,
0.1659829020500183,
0.3473547399044037,
1.1162428855895996,
-0.8894115686416626,
0.15249638259410858,
-0.17064222693443298,
0.18689583241939545,
0.08492835611104965,
-0.7444680333137512,
0.026856379583477974,
0.00014071041368879378,
-0.36556658148765564,
-0.6727009415626526,
0.7542268633842468,
-0.5790448188781738,
-0.4340573251247406,
0.1590730994939804,
0.9908967018127441,
0.014243152923882008,
0.049130890518426895,
-0.6250056624412537,
0.4857400357723236,
-0.33546897768974304,
-0.10753945261240005,
0.4886927604675293,
0.33137768507003784,
0.04516226425766945,
0.9915599226951599,
0.5586691498756409,
0.10403124243021011,
0.5196722149848938,
0.28412166237831116,
0.7256338000297546,
-0.7007770538330078,
-0.08998008072376251,
-0.7799283266067505,
0.3279852271080017,
0.11087563633918762,
-0.097213014960289,
1.0029277801513672,
0.6242552995681763,
0.9057834148406982,
-0.22880065441131592,
0.6333770751953125,
0.2647697627544403,
0.6552653908729553,
-0.7042698860168457,
0.4775645434856415,
-0.7073325514793396,
0.23273494839668274,
-0.1700514703989029,
-0.9014206528663635,
-0.17868748307228088,
0.09204739332199097,
-0.12619023025035858,
0.1756918877363205,
0.373081773519516,
0.6572609543800354,
0.026672203093767166,
-0.10826361179351807,
0.38117945194244385,
0.00027643400244414806,
0.4841981530189514,
0.34161412715911865,
1.3957152366638184,
-0.036888640373945236,
0.2900618016719818,
-0.0893399566411972,
0.01907709427177906,
-0.3223847448825836,
-0.9547411799430847,
-0.8033502101898193,
-0.4356330633163452,
-0.21196390688419342,
0.3868153691291809,
-0.26760390400886536,
1.0940371751785278,
0.8471522331237793,
-0.5068137049674988,
-0.5324069261550903,
0.23179244995117188,
0.022049609571695328,
0.0626509040594101,
-0.11103285849094391,
-0.099759042263031,
-0.36917591094970703,
-0.9258129596710205,
0.6119389533996582,
0.40357476472854614,
0.25153303146362305,
-0.6063368916511536,
-0.28989169001579285,
-0.43739578127861023,
0.026025373488664627,
1.3028069734573364,
-0.04726555198431015,
-0.9578045010566711,
0.16182003915309906,
0.2830997407436371,
-0.14335142076015472,
-0.0674397200345993,
0.8218110799789429,
-0.3697145879268646,
0.42261672019958496,
0.44919323921203613,
0.6870442628860474,
0.35934269428253174,
-0.49247902631759644,
0.4957553446292877,
-0.7198742032051086,
0.03621472418308258,
0.10637498646974564,
0.6136513352394104,
0.41749337315559387,
0.422633558511734,
0.35644152760505676,
0.24105556309223175,
-0.47635236382484436,
-0.8073712587356567,
0.2086257040500641,
-1.0868617296218872,
-0.307445228099823,
1.1864341497421265,
0.2208111733198166,
0.19824789464473724,
0.044051703065633774,
-0.0391119047999382,
0.06166284903883934,
-0.007133085746318102,
0.2566825747489929,
0.9538094401359558,
0.0013164932606741786,
-0.5478100776672363,
-0.8788394927978516,
0.09403175860643387,
0.15699699521064758,
-0.9715073108673096,
-0.13210134208202362,
0.870179295539856,
0.32092922925949097,
-0.04995078966021538,
0.46815168857574463,
-0.32811081409454346,
-0.07492300868034363,
-0.2653573155403137,
-0.16873586177825928,
-0.13762396574020386,
-0.4439955949783325,
-0.33465713262557983,
0.24584196507930756,
0.4392148554325104,
-0.05317976698279381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13598v1 | Consistency Guided Knowledge Retrieval and Denoising in LLMs for Zero-shot Document-level Relation Triplet Extraction | 2024-01-24T17:04:28 | 2024-01-24T17:04:28 | Qi Sun, Kun Huang, Xiaocui Yang, Rong Tong, Kun Zhang, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level Relation Triplet Extraction (DocRTE) is a fundamental task in
information systems that aims to simultaneously extract entities with semantic
relations from a document. Existing methods heavily rely on a substantial
amount of fully labeled data. However, collecting and annotating data for newly
emerging relations is time-consuming and labor-intensive. Recent advanced Large
Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and LLaMA, exhibit impressive long-text
generation capabilities, inspiring us to explore an alternative approach for
obtaining auto-labeled documents with new relations. In this paper, we propose
a Zero-shot Document-level Relation Triplet Extraction (ZeroDocRTE) framework,
which generates labeled data by retrieval and denoising knowledge from LLMs,
called GenRDK. Specifically, we propose a chain-of-retrieval prompt to guide
ChatGPT to generate labeled long-text data step by step. To improve the quality
of synthetic data, we propose a denoising strategy based on the consistency of
cross-document knowledge. Leveraging our denoised synthetic data, we proceed to
fine-tune the LLaMA2-13B-Chat for extracting document-level relation triplets.
We perform experiments for both zero-shot document-level relation and triplet
extraction on two public datasets. The experimental results illustrate that our
GenRDK framework outperforms strong baselines. | [
-0.1221151277422905,
-0.8382440209388733,
0.7595911026000977,
0.18309880793094635,
-0.35805821418762207,
0.21946440637111664,
-0.20201241970062256,
-0.45024433732032776,
0.04540635272860527,
0.6555894613265991,
-0.47334375977516174,
-0.9897438883781433,
-0.5417087078094482,
0.2572823464870453,
-0.485785573720932,
1.1193283796310425,
-0.17194756865501404,
-0.2966346740722656,
-0.18405523896217346,
0.20849819481372833,
-0.3293716311454773,
-0.41259992122650146,
-0.503627359867096,
-0.4202935993671417,
0.3236192762851715,
0.4742545783519745,
0.5829880237579346,
0.7654744982719421,
0.298755943775177,
0.0833594873547554,
-0.10521338880062103,
0.32108548283576965,
-0.8533904552459717,
0.6025965809822083,
0.09133037179708481,
-0.20428839325904846,
-0.5800968408584595,
0.05052294582128525,
0.7361388206481934,
0.42978349328041077,
-0.12424301356077194,
-0.15346042811870575,
0.09185140579938889,
0.589371383190155,
-0.49598369002342224,
0.5089181661605835,
-0.7230932116508484,
-0.032128363847732544,
-0.1777430772781372,
-0.26295924186706543,
-0.29352954030036926,
-0.3482428789138794,
-0.12969651818275452,
-0.8297436833381653,
0.5037590861320496,
-0.1863190233707428,
1.1750625371932983,
0.0021488149650394917,
-0.42961886525154114,
-0.25459814071655273,
-0.8112742304801941,
0.6239348649978638,
-0.662421464920044,
0.59751296043396,
0.575794517993927,
0.04530339315533638,
-0.41329020261764526,
-0.5728582739830017,
-0.6919583678245544,
-0.26963546872138977,
-0.005363228265196085,
0.3783891797065735,
0.0207829587161541,
0.09244772791862488,
0.14498759806156158,
0.4970058798789978,
-0.3904403746128082,
0.051087282598018646,
-0.2148682326078415,
-0.07949430495500565,
0.5231174230575562,
-0.06403198838233948,
0.1608218401670456,
-0.46874240040779114,
-0.45462846755981445,
-0.08806347101926804,
-0.8484097719192505,
-0.6734373569488525,
0.3916356563568115,
0.06364253163337708,
0.1465001255273819,
0.7334806323051453,
-0.45505204796791077,
0.6619417667388916,
0.15678082406520844,
-0.3186039626598358,
0.20950672030448914,
-0.5506137609481812,
-0.20188890397548676,
-0.07693731784820557,
0.9005295038223267,
0.38816308975219727,
0.19814297556877136,
-0.3665732443332672,
-0.1853887289762497,
-0.06422629207372665,
-0.04894270375370979,
-0.7228672504425049,
-0.16078169643878937,
-0.003785389009863138,
-0.16393393278121948,
-0.536656379699707,
-0.06555378437042236,
-0.8663243055343628,
-0.3371129631996155,
-0.3081940710544586,
0.2509850859642029,
-0.508137583732605,
-0.24612076580524445,
0.039563123136758804,
0.007973205298185349,
0.37332022190093994,
0.447314590215683,
-0.9424110054969788,
0.23163306713104248,
0.848396897315979,
0.8384376764297485,
-0.23890560865402222,
-0.10769651085138321,
-0.40884843468666077,
0.6747002005577087,
-0.39908188581466675,
0.7397130727767944,
-0.3004380166530609,
-0.5902714729309082,
-0.13929176330566406,
-0.12274432927370071,
0.09142802655696869,
-0.49521103501319885,
0.40919244289398193,
-0.5853630900382996,
0.2628916800022125,
0.0019619660452008247,
-0.728361964225769,
0.14580196142196655,
0.5360022783279419,
-0.5923678874969482,
1.2193593978881836,
0.12373774498701096,
-0.681499719619751,
0.29814612865448,
-0.2596054971218109,
-0.41666460037231445,
0.11409387737512589,
-0.4978007972240448,
-0.40822044014930725,
-0.34100770950317383,
0.321897029876709,
0.5815708041191101,
-0.2697899341583252,
0.2722489535808563,
-0.3559161126613617,
-0.09477182477712631,
-0.353583961725235,
-0.5421249270439148,
0.5440446138381958,
0.1561279296875,
-0.1732783168554306,
-0.2705908715724945,
-1.0571755170822144,
-0.26744344830513,
0.1657986044883728,
-0.5054062604904175,
-0.3372068405151367,
-0.22296768426895142,
-0.5141581296920776,
0.11529146134853363,
0.38339972496032715,
-1.0121411085128784,
0.4041454493999481,
-0.2207251340150833,
0.2276090532541275,
0.45456013083457947,
0.5644820332527161,
0.4781409502029419,
-0.23333510756492615,
0.4948683977127075,
-0.07655708491802216,
0.001807380118407309,
-0.12877888977527618,
-0.601615309715271,
-0.679070770740509,
-0.19363926351070404,
0.11941884458065033,
0.41682112216949463,
-0.8415424227714539,
0.32286131381988525,
-0.6760081052780151,
-0.2510896623134613,
-0.36073124408721924,
0.41401708126068115,
0.39598339796066284,
0.8912491798400879,
0.3260546028614044,
-0.11173160374164581,
-0.4853936731815338,
-0.8666946887969971,
0.06095736101269722,
-0.1442796140909195,
-0.2487926036119461,
0.21450264751911163,
0.16078470647335052,
-0.2482483983039856,
0.9727239608764648,
-0.6793828010559082,
-0.4676855504512787,
0.01282068993896246,
0.503192126750946,
0.12930558621883392,
0.2803923487663269,
0.15551385283470154,
-0.655193030834198,
-0.6880693435668945,
0.21709437668323517,
-0.911206066608429,
-0.07678086310625076,
-0.08823349326848984,
-0.18386393785476685,
0.39897507429122925,
0.6108166575431824,
-0.6012064218521118,
0.5762212872505188,
0.31546729803085327,
0.1311056762933731,
0.4550153315067291,
-0.2473120540380478,
0.06836436688899994,
-1.2663977146148682,
0.028813155367970467,
-0.23232491314411163,
-0.31119510531425476,
-0.7582709193229675,
-0.26610884070396423,
0.25961530208587646,
-0.039576321840286255,
-0.12540799379348755,
0.5888820886611938,
-0.7513924837112427,
0.023392219096422195,
0.06317819654941559,
0.6188300251960754,
0.41738200187683105,
0.37432748079299927,
0.20291531085968018,
0.4986143112182617,
0.15510234236717224,
-0.3039989471435547,
0.32403478026390076,
0.6277068853378296,
0.0011165556497871876,
0.7938383221626282,
-0.2952018976211548,
0.40763723850250244,
-0.17982088029384613,
0.26670607924461365,
-0.8645176887512207,
-0.08320918679237366,
0.31212204694747925,
-0.5378479957580566,
0.4913509786128998,
-0.6327396631240845,
-0.764342188835144,
-0.1220213994383812,
-0.478359192609787,
-0.017465509474277496,
0.31770646572113037,
-0.48579996824264526,
0.4844823479652405,
0.287397176027298,
-0.2899703085422516,
-0.7455396056175232,
-0.5421705842018127,
0.29450058937072754,
0.2602187395095825,
-0.6702334880828857,
0.37121477723121643,
0.07267537713050842,
0.05467915162444115,
0.025407981127500534,
-0.47623610496520996,
-0.2853584289550781,
-0.17704112827777863,
0.4108027219772339,
0.4613378345966339,
0.034457746893167496,
0.19489015638828278,
-0.10274682939052582,
-0.06602167338132858,
-0.24054691195487976,
-0.08843612670898438,
0.37226903438568115,
0.01770949922502041,
-0.19507494568824768,
-0.12636734545230865,
0.2903285324573517,
0.3913755416870117,
-0.0023730043321847916,
0.5698171854019165,
0.6684156060218811,
-0.23455017805099487,
-0.03102033957839012,
-0.8409382700920105,
-0.023243146017193794,
-0.3916674256324768,
0.015574944205582142,
-0.5583401918411255,
-0.9108356237411499,
0.5146985054016113,
0.17716792225837708,
0.12948107719421387,
0.4522538483142853,
0.2952938973903656,
-0.03286410868167877,
0.6180390119552612,
0.49719059467315674,
-0.08555404096841812,
0.32215654850006104,
-0.3031325936317444,
0.1902032494544983,
-0.9383023381233215,
-0.5300940871238708,
-0.43705880641937256,
0.3145851790904999,
-0.3507477939128876,
-0.20838920772075653,
0.2706684470176697,
0.2948191463947296,
0.08778180927038193,
0.41649287939071655,
-0.3891585171222687,
0.3789803087711334,
0.39136549830436707,
0.1039518266916275,
0.8784680962562561,
0.2848832607269287,
-0.1725359708070755,
0.1653718650341034,
-0.5138987898826599,
-0.32728052139282227,
1.1911063194274902,
0.0888194665312767,
0.7059351801872253,
-0.015108060091733932,
1.2331879138946533,
0.09387186914682388,
0.24800331890583038,
-0.7292242646217346,
0.5526479482650757,
-0.09057560563087463,
-0.5132337808609009,
-0.31824252009391785,
-0.7813650369644165,
-1.2349127531051636,
0.04252338036894798,
-0.13098973035812378,
-0.5044839382171631,
0.3125708997249603,
-0.09085692465305328,
-0.23624898493289948,
0.32878804206848145,
-0.5942754745483398,
0.45763224363327026,
0.15312586724758148,
-0.4783925414085388,
-0.06728800386190414,
-0.609944224357605,
0.40381601452827454,
-0.3183317482471466,
0.11825533956289291,
-0.18138810992240906,
-0.025070920586586,
0.8514909744262695,
-0.32529446482658386,
0.7367614507675171,
0.041634608060121536,
-0.5863292813301086,
0.24436400830745697,
0.5118250250816345,
0.6998989582061768,
0.09669582545757294,
-0.24454696476459503,
0.33479923009872437,
0.16485460102558136,
-0.1862463802099228,
-0.6622415781021118,
0.8968924880027771,
-0.6411175727844238,
-0.5155739784240723,
-0.22715936601161957,
-0.5665898323059082,
-0.27208903431892395,
0.6233077645301819,
0.006402124185115099,
0.3330819010734558,
-0.24062587320804596,
0.18105743825435638,
0.6411533951759338,
-0.020375853404402733,
0.29379117488861084,
0.7493597865104675,
-0.14466562867164612,
-0.5944858193397522,
0.8553767800331116,
0.23153351247310638,
0.37380945682525635,
0.4386081397533417,
-0.09686996787786484,
-0.37716057896614075,
-0.46087151765823364,
-0.2829115688800812,
0.3452996611595154,
-0.6526138782501221,
-0.4531269967556,
-0.7289658784866333,
-0.3961176872253418,
-0.7311864495277405,
0.05571921914815903,
-0.3345619738101959,
-0.500995397567749,
-0.4782658815383911,
-0.10468247532844543,
0.39404428005218506,
1.0413522720336914,
-0.33565571904182434,
0.115887351334095,
-1.0116968154907227,
0.8292309045791626,
0.2515213191509247,
0.4642763137817383,
-0.15073318779468536,
-0.37749168276786804,
0.019752224907279015,
0.12323759496212006,
-0.1523798406124115,
-0.8435466885566711,
0.3863329291343689,
0.0780877023935318,
0.39381229877471924,
0.28409841656684875,
0.14699022471904755,
0.6679120659828186,
-0.2521373927593231,
0.5084328651428223,
0.08972381055355072,
-0.5962631702423096,
0.5216978788375854,
-0.6779573559761047,
0.020500827580690384,
0.5650233626365662,
0.21018299460411072,
-0.6162758469581604,
-0.27078092098236084,
-0.8845954537391663,
-0.7880818843841553,
0.6100976467132568,
0.5223256945610046,
-0.0733565017580986,
-0.22556552290916443,
0.5884429216384888,
0.15585443377494812,
0.32335570454597473,
-0.5595950484275818,
-0.0373406708240509,
-0.1355501264333725,
-0.327123761177063,
0.18774186074733734,
-0.5919072031974792,
-0.2091481238603592,
0.01952621527016163,
0.6558409929275513,
0.09474141150712967,
0.13926000893115997,
0.44589683413505554,
-0.14867858588695526,
-0.1817934513092041,
0.45688751339912415,
0.41302984952926636,
0.45261451601982117,
-0.7356566190719604,
0.19480013847351074,
-0.264419287443161,
-0.7151543498039246,
0.16096444427967072,
0.25393733382225037,
-0.5663865804672241,
-0.031769391149282455,
0.3222402036190033,
0.39882221817970276,
0.11153865605592728,
-0.09756778180599213,
0.57028728723526,
0.09631192684173584,
-0.450872540473938,
-0.1951231211423874,
-0.13208387792110443,
0.04288935288786888,
-0.16414162516593933,
0.2945593297481537,
-0.36616218090057373,
-0.2258400321006775,
-0.40011683106422424,
0.46454131603240967,
0.43176963925361633,
-0.21125571429729462,
-0.043473511934280396,
0.45517998933792114,
0.17705611884593964,
-0.0518055260181427,
0.7471387386322021,
-0.23688992857933044,
-0.1634392887353897,
0.3687765300273895,
0.4357236623764038,
0.6368321180343628,
0.10816539078950882,
0.4102402925491333,
0.3634047210216522,
0.22629259526729584,
-0.3100711405277252,
0.10810486972332001,
-0.32041579484939575,
-0.8541043400764465,
-0.4064735174179077,
-0.6489627361297607,
-0.3931639790534973,
0.27668583393096924,
-0.598921000957489,
0.1128368079662323,
-0.4994816482067108,
0.08538295328617096,
-0.17039023339748383,
0.32787957787513733,
-0.5058856010437012,
-0.09586989879608154,
0.11236374825239182,
0.5375224351882935,
-0.5265728831291199,
1.1385329961776733,
0.041864439845085144,
-0.6281965374946594,
-0.8677027821540833,
-0.17646601796150208,
-0.03885633498430252,
-0.9535249471664429,
0.6765354871749878,
-0.17837738990783691,
-0.16724491119384766,
0.3644174039363861,
-0.4835360646247864,
-0.8243292570114136,
1.2563350200653076,
0.3677293062210083,
-0.719389796257019,
-0.04565409943461418,
0.27043840289115906,
0.48144039511680603,
-0.25011423230171204,
0.11710188537836075,
0.5431006550788879,
0.5824110507965088,
0.43093371391296387,
-0.8324748873710632,
0.12711508572101593,
-0.06894584000110626,
-0.13671621680259705,
0.10739907622337341,
-0.3893938660621643,
0.5832493305206299,
-0.02767517790198326,
-0.5158647298812866,
0.005167240276932716,
0.4020245671272278,
0.2653834819793701,
0.12718810141086578,
0.18721096217632294,
0.7362250089645386,
0.7326545119285583,
0.1818668097257614,
0.8765292763710022,
-0.11051087826490402,
0.47094660997390747,
1.5409449338912964,
-0.5287554860115051,
0.7294893264770508,
0.42745092511177063,
-0.017205441370606422,
0.6022384762763977,
0.40853404998779297,
-0.3283891975879669,
0.22000962495803833,
-0.1633923202753067,
-0.2742593288421631,
-0.13707895576953888,
-0.10696123540401459,
-0.2227049320936203,
0.14209634065628052,
0.219466432929039,
-0.24429473280906677,
-0.5846248865127563,
-0.39246484637260437,
0.3587334156036377,
-0.16329634189605713,
0.06302257627248764,
0.9705204963684082,
0.06810137629508972,
-0.46924319863319397,
0.8904544115066528,
-0.2641388177871704,
0.4712291657924652,
-0.5299310088157654,
-0.3214994966983795,
-0.48275691270828247,
-0.13594426214694977,
-0.26405447721481323,
-0.9581754803657532,
-0.08736531436443329,
-0.18318277597427368,
-0.2529103755950928,
-0.19874577224254608,
1.0200520753860474,
-0.7337026596069336,
-0.35568767786026,
0.3063088059425354,
0.6145040988922119,
0.24797813594341278,
-0.16249088943004608,
-0.4264511466026306,
-0.12093456834554672,
0.19615508615970612,
-0.21163170039653778,
0.2549631595611572,
0.481572687625885,
0.056653425097465515,
0.6049366593360901,
0.9514917731285095,
0.3676116466522217,
0.17346297204494476,
0.11122501641511917,
0.7809239029884338,
-0.4306582510471344,
-0.13506987690925598,
-0.6930004954338074,
-0.025128992274403572,
-0.409362256526947,
0.11193851381540298,
0.8566820621490479,
0.575110912322998,
0.7070326805114746,
0.17730680108070374,
0.8010050654411316,
-0.12458506226539612,
0.5581594705581665,
-0.4261837303638458,
0.6736442446708679,
-0.21624940633773804,
0.5107730031013489,
-0.19144807755947113,
-1.039364218711853,
-0.5906669497489929,
0.22427140176296234,
-0.3091600239276886,
-0.24212481081485748,
0.5627983808517456,
1.0967636108398438,
-0.1213720440864563,
-0.25339192152023315,
0.4525642693042755,
0.38471004366874695,
0.510859489440918,
0.4729149043560028,
0.6034610271453857,
-0.4740593433380127,
1.0331323146820068,
-0.40188172459602356,
-0.14266759157180786,
-0.04087379202246666,
-0.9364171028137207,
-0.7335635423660278,
-0.38572171330451965,
-0.22508642077445984,
-0.3782825767993927,
0.16712278127670288,
0.39563649892807007,
0.5652545690536499,
-0.39935043454170227,
0.043781157582998276,
-0.21645888686180115,
0.2640107572078705,
0.2661192715167999,
-0.2736784517765045,
0.5896593332290649,
-0.3313581049442291,
-0.3679502308368683,
0.5779068470001221,
0.34608498215675354,
0.3991060256958008,
-0.11171239614486694,
-0.07978487014770508,
-0.35155192017555237,
-0.14876119792461395,
0.5277008414268494,
0.44008883833885193,
-0.33237186074256897,
-0.3274568021297455,
-0.17984214425086975,
-0.24535247683525085,
0.36699265241622925,
0.5185975432395935,
-0.7724087834358215,
0.5700246095657349,
0.5762442946434021,
0.3551420271396637,
0.8958252668380737,
0.12503273785114288,
0.7008669972419739,
-0.953241765499115,
-0.17284929752349854,
0.146040141582489,
0.008793136104941368,
0.48444828391075134,
-0.5738093852996826,
0.8676490783691406,
0.4041820466518402,
-0.5543954968452454,
-0.6180214881896973,
0.16117140650749207,
-1.0885215997695923,
-0.12855680286884308,
1.4844982624053955,
-0.2481076866388321,
-0.14145734906196594,
-0.35843634605407715,
-0.06233539432287216,
0.5243421196937561,
-0.5618395209312439,
0.8369548916816711,
0.528152585029602,
-0.13476620614528656,
-0.2113078385591507,
-0.6696025133132935,
0.4987151026725769,
0.1524249166250229,
-0.5895647406578064,
0.37212443351745605,
0.5958428382873535,
0.5782186388969421,
0.14404654502868652,
0.7571204900741577,
-0.3309095799922943,
-0.18058571219444275,
-0.06463904678821564,
0.27787846326828003,
-0.2803797423839569,
-0.16006861627101898,
-0.12080571800470352,
0.15898914635181427,
-0.16260026395320892,
-0.03324194252490997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13594v1 | Graph Guided Question Answer Generation for Procedural Question-Answering | 2024-01-24T17:01:42 | 2024-01-24T17:01:42 | Hai X. Pham, Isma Hadji, Xinnuo Xu, Ziedune Degutyte, Jay Rainey, Evangelos Kazakos, Afsaneh Fazly, Georgios Tzimiropoulos, Brais Martinez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | In this paper, we focus on task-specific question answering (QA). To this
end, we introduce a method for generating exhaustive and high-quality training
data, which allows us to train compact (e.g., run on a mobile device),
task-specific QA models that are competitive against GPT variants. The key
technological enabler is a novel mechanism for automatic question-answer
generation from procedural text which can ingest large amounts of textual
instructions and produce exhaustive in-domain QA training data. While current
QA data generation methods can produce well-formed and varied data, their
non-exhaustive nature is sub-optimal for training a QA model. In contrast, we
leverage the highly structured aspect of procedural text and represent each
step and the overall flow of the procedure as graphs. We then condition on
graph nodes to automatically generate QA pairs in an exhaustive and
controllable manner. Comprehensive evaluations of our method show that: 1)
small models trained with our data achieve excellent performance on the target
QA task, even exceeding that of GPT3 and ChatGPT despite being several orders
of magnitude smaller. 2) semantic coverage is the key indicator for downstream
QA performance. Crucially, while large language models excel at syntactic
diversity, this does not necessarily result in improvements on the end QA
model. In contrast, the higher semantic coverage provided by our method is
critical for QA performance. | [
-0.2190534919500351,
-1.3544684648513794,
0.7351917624473572,
-0.13433419167995453,
-0.37561672925949097,
0.2213412970304489,
0.2873990833759308,
-0.10368026047945023,
0.1742546260356903,
0.739258348941803,
-0.8076597452163696,
-0.6226884722709656,
-0.28679049015045166,
0.17216309905052185,
-0.3148227334022522,
1.0068014860153198,
-0.15746834874153137,
-0.010433772578835487,
-0.35208576917648315,
-0.014085283502936363,
-0.6183634400367737,
-0.4837649464607239,
-0.7498719692230225,
-0.11378179490566254,
0.5848530530929565,
0.18172651529312134,
0.6264864206314087,
0.7310857772827148,
0.29445475339889526,
0.28446584939956665,
0.06598787009716034,
0.3553590178489685,
-0.7536951303482056,
0.30598726868629456,
0.07949582487344742,
-0.22860589623451233,
-0.2798323929309845,
-0.061928849667310715,
0.5087409615516663,
0.8300888538360596,
-0.08837664872407913,
0.28769999742507935,
-0.004325599409639835,
0.37652698159217834,
-0.184304341673851,
0.4088623821735382,
-0.8193254470825195,
-0.13955457508563995,
-0.018389998003840446,
-0.4139026701450348,
-0.24916550517082214,
-0.7330904603004456,
-0.03224289417266846,
-0.9157516956329346,
0.3990059494972229,
-0.08012425154447556,
0.751335620880127,
0.3123546838760376,
-0.6058741211891174,
-0.4982091188430786,
-0.5788125395774841,
0.19134794175624847,
-0.4153422713279724,
0.17278027534484863,
0.23365303874015808,
0.31963106989860535,
-0.09245865046977997,
-1.054038166999817,
-0.5049574971199036,
0.03409527614712715,
0.18371424078941345,
0.2283245474100113,
0.026542484760284424,
0.24189265072345734,
0.31665560603141785,
0.14162437617778778,
-0.9054701924324036,
-0.32471734285354614,
-0.3296695947647095,
-0.19868595898151398,
0.5654897093772888,
0.45572084188461304,
0.41843271255493164,
-0.2210138440132141,
0.11100081354379654,
0.006155447568744421,
-0.7884042263031006,
0.3228660225868225,
0.36630547046661377,
0.2865371108055115,
0.4034656882286072,
0.678994357585907,
-0.4642075300216675,
0.8888311982154846,
0.156350240111351,
-0.008710898458957672,
0.00851241871714592,
-0.6376278400421143,
0.0042332676239311695,
-0.26654568314552307,
0.8110803365707397,
0.05802423134446144,
0.19253340363502502,
-0.4155714809894562,
-0.05271780490875244,
-0.059030868113040924,
0.32120293378829956,
-1.0513322353363037,
-0.2125592976808548,
0.3564618229866028,
0.0513843297958374,
-0.23226363956928253,
-0.25683921575546265,
-0.3194526433944702,
-0.23139478266239166,
-0.25864920020103455,
0.1677674949169159,
-0.2872912585735321,
-0.07652255892753601,
-0.03537379577755928,
-0.22303177416324615,
0.19741570949554443,
0.20663228631019592,
-0.7102661728858948,
0.3057306110858917,
0.4889143407344818,
0.5919865369796753,
-0.07733406871557236,
-0.06219543144106865,
-0.8472583293914795,
0.1168740913271904,
-0.48419511318206787,
0.818495512008667,
-0.6126607656478882,
-0.5969277620315552,
0.06756823509931564,
0.10877259820699692,
-0.30994749069213867,
-0.49948665499687195,
0.07713840901851654,
-0.8402422666549683,
0.3262622356414795,
-0.2809326648712158,
-0.5341030955314636,
-0.18899813294410706,
0.2472935914993286,
-0.562098503112793,
1.079870343208313,
0.60821533203125,
-0.773601770401001,
0.1977197676897049,
-0.46458208560943604,
-0.3250206410884857,
0.34914806485176086,
-0.21858248114585876,
-0.33477750420570374,
-0.27630162239074707,
0.2248852699995041,
0.14381034672260284,
-0.21649861335754395,
0.13551092147827148,
-0.16796641051769257,
-0.25566667318344116,
0.10059430450201035,
0.002855610102415085,
0.7077884674072266,
0.011051290668547153,
-0.23226125538349152,
0.35127750039100647,
-0.6549841165542603,
0.5363365411758423,
0.27515798807144165,
-0.1781906634569168,
-0.06939779967069626,
-0.14144989848136902,
-0.1537013202905655,
0.3618624210357666,
0.19851835072040558,
-0.7570109963417053,
0.039847586303949356,
-0.2755962610244751,
0.6681557893753052,
0.6991293430328369,
0.5117865204811096,
0.1333383321762085,
-0.23335710167884827,
1.0847200155258179,
-0.32446175813674927,
0.10498364269733429,
-0.05902424827218056,
-0.7710791230201721,
-0.31159305572509766,
-0.09724061191082001,
0.3650892674922943,
0.8017176389694214,
-1.1377910375595093,
0.07573184370994568,
-0.1517132669687271,
-0.5159162282943726,
-0.328338623046875,
0.2203422635793686,
0.45590904355049133,
0.884346604347229,
0.13198958337306976,
-0.4317460358142853,
-0.169791117310524,
-0.4347272515296936,
0.014656655490398407,
-0.18817806243896484,
0.03594754636287689,
0.6834363341331482,
0.3390624523162842,
0.10295816510915756,
1.0538791418075562,
-0.9020591974258423,
0.1399901807308197,
-0.2959420680999756,
-0.07824447005987167,
0.01622483879327774,
0.22814716398715973,
0.23240800201892853,
-0.7882038950920105,
-0.6500383019447327,
-0.08900651335716248,
-0.8622673153877258,
-0.01728030852973461,
-0.013415114022791386,
-0.35392633080482483,
-0.22458836436271667,
0.2785087823867798,
-0.6622800230979919,
0.20148417353630066,
0.31676092743873596,
-0.4005792438983917,
0.5075276494026184,
-0.0836687982082367,
0.020066699013113976,
-1.035017490386963,
0.06479975581169128,
-0.22030490636825562,
-0.3710916340351105,
-0.6943337321281433,
0.29182514548301697,
-0.19533102214336395,
-0.6534685492515564,
-0.31469860672950745,
0.623443603515625,
-0.17631492018699646,
0.08038165420293808,
-0.20090888440608978,
0.41695865988731384,
0.0888412669301033,
0.7682217955589294,
0.08576472103595734,
0.8723657727241516,
0.36406078934669495,
-0.465906023979187,
0.44363561272621155,
0.5781457424163818,
0.03445413336157799,
0.27823129296302795,
-1.1190898418426514,
0.5851711630821228,
-0.12868700921535492,
0.27820903062820435,
-1.117889642715454,
-0.1967916190624237,
0.2616341710090637,
-0.4158616065979004,
0.07774171233177185,
-0.2276647686958313,
-0.425579309463501,
-0.5148610472679138,
0.06668203324079514,
0.4747800827026367,
0.7547213435173035,
-0.07432299852371216,
0.3911404311656952,
0.3684106171131134,
-0.6982229351997375,
-0.1873149871826172,
-0.27478280663490295,
-0.18032319843769073,
0.0007957638008520007,
-0.9352901577949524,
0.03524219989776611,
-0.1406920999288559,
0.2228781282901764,
-0.0704430565237999,
-0.044026657938957214,
-0.45381462574005127,
-0.06121436133980751,
0.27573755383491516,
0.09201522916555405,
-0.18910127878189087,
0.07361903786659241,
0.20542018115520477,
-0.08713023364543915,
0.12175675481557846,
-0.5741223692893982,
0.6825055480003357,
0.11243773251771927,
-0.3488195240497589,
-0.3822685480117798,
0.6018760800361633,
0.13577190041542053,
-0.6050599813461304,
0.34542208909988403,
0.3092402517795563,
-0.11640781909227371,
-0.08027900755405426,
-0.13840782642364502,
-0.12886422872543335,
-0.4680003523826599,
0.5139575004577637,
-0.4317023456096649,
-0.8649882674217224,
0.7818154692649841,
0.16112738847732544,
0.17265470325946808,
0.37178003787994385,
0.5151345133781433,
0.06239040195941925,
1.3248481750488281,
0.40669161081314087,
0.5319138169288635,
0.462399423122406,
-0.32750585675239563,
0.074935182929039,
-0.486890971660614,
-0.22543323040008545,
-0.5340481996536255,
0.21418657898902893,
-0.7766254544258118,
-0.41869303584098816,
0.6036431193351746,
0.04366284981369972,
-0.3144865036010742,
0.13478371500968933,
-0.7960854768753052,
0.34215012192726135,
0.661559522151947,
0.3001621961593628,
0.2889431416988373,
-0.01476468238979578,
0.02736096829175949,
0.2693966031074524,
-0.9684279561042786,
-0.4768182337284088,
1.3607186079025269,
0.037959545850753784,
0.4142726957798004,
-0.297576367855072,
0.8718191385269165,
0.058253102004528046,
0.11992200464010239,
-0.48214825987815857,
0.5368245840072632,
0.04951192066073418,
-0.36872443556785583,
-0.6836380362510681,
-0.6240764260292053,
-1.1506373882293701,
0.1473381519317627,
0.2685091197490692,
-0.26211613416671753,
-0.14168980717658997,
0.19630067050457,
-0.3444041609764099,
-0.01859222538769245,
-0.7610815167427063,
1.0480329990386963,
0.16256989538669586,
-0.23356033861637115,
0.12883153557777405,
-0.6317999958992004,
0.1993790715932846,
-0.03179100528359413,
-0.16767381131649017,
0.12225723266601562,
0.07511746138334274,
0.6541284918785095,
-0.6211519241333008,
0.754549503326416,
-0.45537662506103516,
-0.13284918665885925,
0.8577663898468018,
0.07401036471128464,
0.8458329439163208,
0.05924111604690552,
0.1870213747024536,
-0.26130950450897217,
0.2501923143863678,
-0.8112151026725769,
-0.7207359075546265,
0.35955333709716797,
-0.622690737247467,
-0.6859242916107178,
-0.10915892571210861,
-0.8869458436965942,
-0.5188213586807251,
0.3429063856601715,
0.24660387635231018,
0.7909147143363953,
-0.13759419322013855,
-0.2608467936515808,
0.8429484963417053,
-0.07418382167816162,
-0.011321444064378738,
0.2485237568616867,
0.0189314316958189,
-0.3157837688922882,
1.170530080795288,
0.181127667427063,
0.47566282749176025,
0.2508709728717804,
-0.05414380133152008,
-0.5198996067047119,
-0.9433900713920593,
-0.7351542115211487,
0.23731441795825958,
-0.7423302531242371,
0.02350628562271595,
-0.7480753064155579,
-0.3282042145729065,
-0.385118693113327,
0.029794229194521904,
0.14620918035507202,
-0.642719566822052,
-0.04129992797970772,
-0.028505839407444,
0.3454422950744629,
0.9427616000175476,
0.5556073784828186,
0.32819879055023193,
-0.7166836857795715,
0.5666161775588989,
0.6526480913162231,
0.056213006377220154,
-0.38874635100364685,
-0.169150710105896,
0.06364578008651733,
0.25811392068862915,
-0.506193995475769,
-0.9598246812820435,
0.21607589721679688,
-0.012885761447250843,
0.4401785135269165,
-0.013776537962257862,
-0.03344384953379631,
0.44540029764175415,
-0.6132804155349731,
0.879582405090332,
-0.08569636195898056,
-0.6257069706916809,
0.5493738055229187,
-0.8390392661094666,
0.3902655839920044,
0.5384237170219421,
0.25439465045928955,
-0.5204695463180542,
-0.8840610384941101,
-0.7497355937957764,
-0.7406458258628845,
0.5545291900634766,
0.30692240595817566,
0.26966625452041626,
-0.29499518871307373,
0.5534068942070007,
0.13744612038135529,
0.32692286372184753,
-0.4419758915901184,
-0.0008456258219666779,
-0.6225634217262268,
-0.40831080079078674,
0.1549372375011444,
0.045483049005270004,
-0.24342218041419983,
0.11827772110700607,
0.6352586150169373,
-0.5553412437438965,
0.32878410816192627,
0.2225395292043686,
-0.08057216554880142,
0.1351623833179474,
0.020083000883460045,
0.4145086109638214,
1.0704890489578247,
-0.04278424009680748,
-0.3136289715766907,
0.005810112226754427,
-0.6631157398223877,
0.11301934719085693,
0.26334699988365173,
-0.6322207450866699,
0.038470156490802765,
0.16457650065422058,
0.5867601633071899,
-0.454262375831604,
-0.6970964074134827,
0.26415422558784485,
-0.039294593036174774,
-0.35158154368400574,
0.037125468254089355,
0.27463236451148987,
0.11260992288589478,
0.002347958507016301,
0.2507998049259186,
-0.4243199825286865,
0.12424595654010773,
-0.4521379768848419,
0.2333037108182907,
0.5493351817131042,
-0.549340009689331,
-0.21441613137722015,
0.6953822374343872,
0.24942365288734436,
-0.23018601536750793,
0.7245128750801086,
-0.530685544013977,
-0.39909496903419495,
1.0027945041656494,
0.46356236934661865,
0.7610566020011902,
0.020226726308465004,
0.631992757320404,
0.35531821846961975,
0.08941089361906052,
0.350292831659317,
0.6489725708961487,
-0.07449983805418015,
-0.3077019155025482,
-0.4925721287727356,
-0.28402480483055115,
-0.410183310508728,
-0.06661844998598099,
-0.5230951905250549,
-0.30296698212623596,
-0.44047561287879944,
-0.03538273647427559,
-0.09120389074087143,
0.106952965259552,
-0.547836184501648,
0.39411595463752747,
-0.35103195905685425,
0.6992667317390442,
-0.4259341359138489,
0.5779889822006226,
0.6085681319236755,
-0.6538640856742859,
-1.0334751605987549,
-0.0683576688170433,
-0.4118969440460205,
-0.9240195751190186,
0.5453923344612122,
-0.1522512137889862,
-0.06196059659123421,
0.28003957867622375,
-0.4039030075073242,
-0.6762474179267883,
1.1970651149749756,
0.3334459364414215,
-0.17566335201263428,
-0.5001043081283569,
0.45384472608566284,
0.5582790374755859,
-0.4235363304615021,
0.2967030704021454,
0.24198760092258453,
0.13061507046222687,
0.3859979212284088,
-0.718000054359436,
0.33575159311294556,
-0.28930866718292236,
0.11878422647714615,
0.1960621029138565,
-0.6197936534881592,
0.5533023476600647,
-0.16219845414161682,
-0.28088605403900146,
0.30394378304481506,
0.47193387150764465,
0.3658778965473175,
0.24760183691978455,
0.377647340297699,
0.15163055062294006,
1.029248595237732,
-0.2591768503189087,
1.3268035650253296,
-0.5133558511734009,
0.12360840290784836,
1.0095247030258179,
-0.20075999200344086,
0.4348558187484741,
0.14752373099327087,
-0.05741775780916214,
0.43561553955078125,
1.0374423265457153,
0.25579002499580383,
0.3943119943141937,
0.42289623618125916,
-0.06176750361919403,
-0.4408719837665558,
-0.3249737024307251,
-0.38798215985298157,
0.26897138357162476,
0.03023792803287506,
-0.11739999800920486,
-0.33493277430534363,
-0.15231506526470184,
-0.12145379185676575,
0.17257565259933472,
-0.3654896020889282,
0.8262034058570862,
-0.2630864977836609,
-0.9390546083450317,
0.7710266709327698,
-0.23004236817359924,
-0.07505017518997192,
-0.9288100004196167,
-0.08880185335874557,
-0.3477436304092407,
-0.3285183906555176,
-0.04705836996436119,
-0.6917762756347656,
0.13676764070987701,
-0.03588179871439934,
-0.2066168487071991,
-0.2465674877166748,
0.47665733098983765,
-0.49241453409194946,
-0.5585352778434753,
-0.34840768575668335,
0.7041178941726685,
0.07326054573059082,
-0.21837714314460754,
-0.6276907324790955,
-0.5980184078216553,
0.04528364539146423,
-0.14152449369430542,
0.17427976429462433,
0.6192055940628052,
-0.25613629817962646,
0.7092265486717224,
0.6883830428123474,
-0.018597261980175972,
0.36459529399871826,
0.09227534383535385,
1.0948495864868164,
-0.507562518119812,
-0.7786880135536194,
-0.15188603103160858,
0.29175326228141785,
-0.122629314661026,
-0.37230339646339417,
0.6843335628509521,
0.6433591842651367,
0.5488747358322144,
0.13663117587566376,
0.820749044418335,
-0.009703152813017368,
0.6069117188453674,
-0.5270780920982361,
0.3703763484954834,
-0.2743411362171173,
-0.1403113752603531,
-0.1087927520275116,
-0.7479898929595947,
0.13060477375984192,
0.11868707090616226,
-0.32540369033813477,
0.29616788029670715,
0.8568564057350159,
0.748050332069397,
0.15974624454975128,
0.10573448985815048,
0.06802321970462799,
-0.06649308651685715,
0.41292667388916016,
0.8036862015724182,
0.7338306307792664,
-0.4076184928417206,
0.8558222055435181,
-0.06390317529439926,
-0.17193564772605896,
0.3442288339138031,
-0.3710035979747772,
-0.8751072883605957,
-0.5827043652534485,
-0.3712594211101532,
-0.6251947283744812,
0.1013292744755745,
0.2988073527812958,
0.6966120600700378,
-0.6492900252342224,
-0.0010374695993959904,
-0.4044952392578125,
0.2771567404270172,
-0.3297368884086609,
-0.2522956430912018,
0.5569638609886169,
-0.645813524723053,
-0.6981222033500671,
0.12795735895633698,
0.017236899584531784,
0.06099129840731621,
-0.16926497220993042,
-0.09797857701778412,
0.08566924184560776,
0.2297183871269226,
0.42546501755714417,
0.4308721721172333,
-0.43368664383888245,
-0.08721019327640533,
0.4517754316329956,
-0.1363876610994339,
0.0892067477107048,
1.0082610845565796,
-0.7525116205215454,
0.4163326323032379,
0.6288048028945923,
0.816888689994812,
0.6798121929168701,
0.2499629706144333,
0.6533340811729431,
-0.7430060505867004,
-0.14847059547901154,
0.44758903980255127,
-0.055876825004816055,
0.1440584808588028,
-0.5405982136726379,
0.5432958006858826,
0.31580957770347595,
-0.5702593326568604,
-0.6914927363395691,
0.4262060821056366,
-1.0138107538223267,
-0.22178742289543152,
1.3243169784545898,
-0.20947717130184174,
-0.2720967233181,
-0.542475700378418,
-0.3121102452278137,
0.31371939182281494,
-0.2894597053527832,
0.64568030834198,
0.5282448530197144,
-0.3855193257331848,
0.11083205044269562,
-0.5757764577865601,
0.597640872001648,
0.2365420162677765,
-1.1516774892807007,
0.14973875880241394,
0.558745265007019,
0.45031407475471497,
0.015263749286532402,
1.010658860206604,
-0.15732596814632416,
0.6527191996574402,
0.18184834718704224,
-0.2014225870370865,
-0.5034453868865967,
-0.04996885731816292,
-0.030927199870347977,
0.5927765369415283,
0.05153371021151543,
-0.2492336630821228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13588v1 | Evaluation of General Large Language Models in Contextually Assessing Semantic Concepts Extracted from Adult Critical Care Electronic Health Record Notes | 2024-01-24T16:52:37 | 2024-01-24T16:52:37 | Darren Liu, Cheng Ding, Delgersuren Bold, Monique Bouvier, Jiaying Lu, Benjamin Shickel, Craig S. Jabaley, Wenhui Zhang, Soojin Park, Michael J. Young, Mark S. Wainwright, Gilles Clermont, Parisa Rashidi, Eric S. Rosenthal, Laurie Dimisko, Ran Xiao, Joo Heung Yoon, Carl Yang, Xiao Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | The field of healthcare has increasingly turned its focus towards Large
Language Models (LLMs) due to their remarkable performance. However, their
performance in actual clinical applications has been underexplored. Traditional
evaluations based on question-answering tasks don't fully capture the nuanced
contexts. This gap highlights the need for more in-depth and practical
assessments of LLMs in real-world healthcare settings. Objective: We sought to
evaluate the performance of LLMs in the complex clinical context of adult
critical care medicine using systematic and comprehensible analytic methods,
including clinician annotation and adjudication. Methods: We investigated the
performance of three general LLMs in understanding and processing real-world
clinical notes. Concepts from 150 clinical notes were identified by MetaMap and
then labeled by 9 clinicians. Each LLM's proficiency was evaluated by
identifying the temporality and negation of these concepts using different
prompts for an in-depth analysis. Results: GPT-4 showed overall superior
performance compared to other LLMs. In contrast, both GPT-3.5 and
text-davinci-003 exhibit enhanced performance when the appropriate prompting
strategies are employed. The GPT family models have demonstrated considerable
efficiency, evidenced by their cost-effectiveness and time-saving capabilities.
Conclusion: A comprehensive qualitative performance evaluation framework for
LLMs is developed and operationalized. This framework goes beyond singular
performance aspects. With expert annotations, this methodology not only
validates LLMs' capabilities in processing complex medical data but also
establishes a benchmark for future LLM evaluations across specialized domains. | [
-0.19814608991146088,
-1.0005755424499512,
0.9323464632034302,
0.0680781677365303,
-0.3986678123474121,
0.0676087886095047,
-0.48902764916419983,
-0.7239716649055481,
-0.14066515862941742,
0.46151480078697205,
-0.2557557225227356,
-0.8558179140090942,
-0.6708844304084778,
0.1357574462890625,
-0.28111720085144043,
0.8438680768013,
-0.16186457872390747,
0.29540878534317017,
-0.11943364888429642,
0.04032362252473831,
-0.48637932538986206,
-0.6117549538612366,
-0.6548418402671814,
-0.38584113121032715,
0.2933681011199951,
0.268879234790802,
0.49292805790901184,
0.37630128860473633,
0.9582510590553284,
0.3263914883136749,
-0.27655139565467834,
0.0918794721364975,
-0.26189932227134705,
0.16676340997219086,
0.03463778272271156,
-0.13658496737480164,
-0.7201999425888062,
-0.2144869863986969,
0.8348239064216614,
0.705476701259613,
-0.33188265562057495,
0.17097486555576324,
-0.06755254417657852,
0.559288501739502,
-0.5699204206466675,
0.25242382287979126,
-0.4909076392650604,
0.19774170219898224,
0.042235132306814194,
-0.28120091557502747,
-0.4988061785697937,
-0.40535658597946167,
0.690338671207428,
-0.6195212602615356,
0.27994516491889954,
-0.2303016483783722,
0.5658663511276245,
0.04476703703403473,
-0.42819786071777344,
-0.5989274382591248,
-0.848633348941803,
0.3497043251991272,
-1.001074194908142,
0.34083470702171326,
0.010753018781542778,
0.4213939905166626,
-0.009131229482591152,
-0.9378167986869812,
-0.5622933506965637,
-0.4482487142086029,
-0.11812189221382141,
0.23185738921165466,
-0.032676853239536285,
0.5002953410148621,
0.3150310218334198,
0.40580490231513977,
-0.6462424397468567,
0.21991556882858276,
-0.3572315573692322,
-0.030654948204755783,
0.54637610912323,
0.5377373099327087,
0.37226855754852295,
-0.11448399722576141,
-0.43859994411468506,
0.26741090416908264,
-0.3890116810798645,
0.07646066695451736,
-0.2416829764842987,
0.04199677333235741,
-0.28687289357185364,
0.45950859785079956,
-0.2006341814994812,
0.5886494517326355,
-0.23919129371643066,
-0.43900519609451294,
0.2177659422159195,
-0.29008948802948,
-0.33138197660446167,
-0.048067547380924225,
0.8608791828155518,
0.61397385597229,
0.4175042510032654,
-0.2834572196006775,
-0.1317993551492691,
-0.0007469988777302206,
0.31893742084503174,
-0.6818819642066956,
-0.06058694049715996,
0.2989296317100525,
-0.4575526714324951,
-0.06778404116630554,
-0.06347597390413284,
-0.6858741044998169,
-0.3576107323169708,
-0.5473371744155884,
0.2118891030550003,
-0.36159220337867737,
-0.17469793558120728,
0.31031227111816406,
0.06483101099729538,
0.13654464483261108,
0.6543088555335999,
-0.5627990365028381,
0.5159816145896912,
0.7508718967437744,
0.917921245098114,
-0.4007108509540558,
0.0016416549915447831,
-0.29614490270614624,
0.06850719451904297,
-0.38763514161109924,
0.7289870977401733,
-0.5410974025726318,
-0.5468368530273438,
0.32899144291877747,
0.02240958996117115,
-0.3486170768737793,
-0.7230981588363647,
0.87265545129776,
-0.4372333288192749,
-0.12716935575008392,
-0.10583465546369553,
-0.5415830612182617,
-0.20002621412277222,
0.389390230178833,
-0.48530176281929016,
0.6121436357498169,
0.11735808104276657,
-0.4162032902240753,
0.3995005488395691,
-0.5942399501800537,
-0.44662371277809143,
0.3104014992713928,
-0.3377092480659485,
-0.32786858081817627,
0.14926429092884064,
0.07668381184339523,
0.7452453970909119,
-0.6268185973167419,
0.4759658873081207,
-0.11489596962928772,
-0.4404986798763275,
0.36729392409324646,
-0.3968278467655182,
0.16760769486427307,
0.21783827245235443,
-0.29206112027168274,
0.25505775213241577,
-0.7144580483436584,
0.0102118831127882,
0.06139213591814041,
-0.43267562985420227,
-0.17862431704998016,
-0.04516231268644333,
0.10706821084022522,
0.2803425192832947,
0.001108356867916882,
-0.40785083174705505,
0.27411869168281555,
-0.3477631211280823,
0.6266126036643982,
0.241338312625885,
0.36597740650177,
0.18958009779453278,
-0.22817254066467285,
0.6895328760147095,
0.03371523693203926,
0.38297662138938904,
-0.1310102343559265,
-0.45111215114593506,
-0.6012516617774963,
-0.34653404355049133,
0.06827966868877411,
0.4905537962913513,
-0.46444645524024963,
0.17301148176193237,
-0.5174292325973511,
-0.40372368693351746,
-0.4299868047237396,
-0.12254555523395538,
0.43055737018585205,
0.7243993878364563,
0.5283625721931458,
-0.2501217722892761,
-0.16661939024925232,
-1.0879734754562378,
-0.03962766006588936,
-0.13478176295757294,
-0.002154906978830695,
0.3233966827392578,
0.5134833455085754,
-0.4293716549873352,
0.48762989044189453,
-0.583233654499054,
-0.30679062008857727,
-0.22023342549800873,
0.17454956471920013,
0.04070575535297394,
0.3461189568042755,
0.16380634903907776,
-0.5107924938201904,
-0.29765579104423523,
0.2344595193862915,
-0.7477737665176392,
-0.04714389890432358,
-0.08791858702898026,
0.14611166715621948,
0.08729533851146698,
0.44514650106430054,
-0.6161407828330994,
0.45579034090042114,
0.320401132106781,
-0.22083717584609985,
0.5840776562690735,
-0.3666486442089081,
0.3444596827030182,
-0.6519702076911926,
0.2350401133298874,
-0.0569511242210865,
-0.14961585402488708,
-0.799788236618042,
0.15979863703250885,
0.03098333813250065,
0.005789592862129211,
-0.47017616033554077,
0.42744457721710205,
-0.4836517572402954,
0.1124015524983406,
-0.018073000013828278,
0.3491193950176239,
0.036984603852033615,
0.26136234402656555,
0.1999872922897339,
0.5010262131690979,
0.2057678997516632,
-0.43421030044555664,
0.1145537868142128,
0.043415289372205734,
-0.336026132106781,
0.5077388286590576,
-0.8300927877426147,
-0.023469865322113037,
-0.027025830000638962,
0.343587189912796,
-1.1285407543182373,
-0.10436233133077621,
0.08856659382581711,
-0.2658347189426422,
0.5307338237762451,
-0.11258421838283539,
-0.42740708589553833,
-0.39995741844177246,
-0.009869704023003578,
0.3170303702354431,
0.23480579257011414,
0.11999975889921188,
0.5814288854598999,
0.2134525328874588,
-0.33490633964538574,
-0.30351459980010986,
-0.5848020911216736,
0.18163534998893738,
-0.16586154699325562,
-0.5020313262939453,
0.22254373133182526,
-0.04338532313704491,
-0.4048324227333069,
-0.2569814920425415,
-0.03140203654766083,
-0.15158943831920624,
0.24925017356872559,
0.23429059982299805,
0.41953712701797485,
-0.32618987560272217,
0.28279027342796326,
0.07553335279226303,
0.006467324681580067,
0.1903858333826065,
0.03960684314370155,
0.45489799976348877,
-0.46192389726638794,
-0.4440567195415497,
-0.5524420738220215,
0.37439781427383423,
0.7671615481376648,
-0.2524188160896301,
0.5894513726234436,
0.6507765054702759,
-0.5863903164863586,
0.011403581127524376,
-0.8195227384567261,
-0.0890207439661026,
-0.3135855197906494,
0.3889837861061096,
-0.34354686737060547,
-0.9660983085632324,
0.6541455984115601,
0.008340814150869846,
-0.06460560113191605,
0.5884197354316711,
0.7510550022125244,
0.0716610997915268,
0.6999756693840027,
0.12713108956813812,
0.2528488337993622,
-0.00989426951855421,
-0.5009050369262695,
0.1711529791355133,
-1.1034969091415405,
-0.32964888215065,
-0.3856787085533142,
-0.009101780131459236,
-0.4926574230194092,
-0.7037255167961121,
0.7630026936531067,
0.12634722888469696,
-0.24078261852264404,
-0.24795372784137726,
-0.5758517980575562,
0.11145765334367752,
-0.1623687595129013,
0.2573181688785553,
0.5697076320648193,
-0.23706531524658203,
-0.19122979044914246,
0.07245327532291412,
-0.5009474158287048,
-0.8531338572502136,
1.1361360549926758,
0.7767478227615356,
0.38228175044059753,
0.16825304925441742,
0.36208438873291016,
0.25136423110961914,
0.6783154010772705,
-1.0062190294265747,
0.4779796898365021,
-0.09314309060573578,
-0.662118136882782,
-0.3240257203578949,
-0.3000694513320923,
-0.7368952035903931,
0.46389350295066833,
-0.21268342435359955,
-0.678644061088562,
0.0505094937980175,
-0.15284129977226257,
-0.6419637203216553,
0.08210035413503647,
-0.7513272762298584,
0.8054717779159546,
-0.24766506254673004,
-0.2535441815853119,
-0.23962551355361938,
-0.7008522748947144,
0.48360008001327515,
-0.19845956563949585,
0.14220747351646423,
-0.09162867069244385,
-0.4262481927871704,
0.5041194558143616,
-0.24014811217784882,
0.7901075482368469,
-0.019550062716007233,
-0.1393054574728012,
0.2597852647304535,
0.12025702744722366,
0.2224518060684204,
0.3193187713623047,
-0.051218464970588684,
0.42026883363723755,
0.321239173412323,
-0.1599106639623642,
-0.6315538287162781,
0.7274778485298157,
-0.7068326473236084,
-0.5784997344017029,
-0.505220890045166,
-0.26877307891845703,
-0.433261901140213,
0.13890543580055237,
0.11918600648641586,
0.7402378916740417,
-0.40687841176986694,
0.23047786951065063,
0.6041509509086609,
-0.351278692483902,
0.2060304880142212,
0.9015304446220398,
0.10920640081167221,
-0.4316262900829315,
0.41401174664497375,
0.19336073100566864,
0.4668346643447876,
0.4766598343849182,
0.3155643939971924,
-0.3895721435546875,
-1.0118873119354248,
-0.49275892972946167,
0.31148481369018555,
-0.8533759117126465,
0.10159692168235779,
-0.9932276606559753,
-0.21356649696826935,
-0.3328227400779724,
-0.15953586995601654,
-0.026896610856056213,
-0.2914187014102936,
-0.1054672822356224,
-0.05380783975124359,
0.14818249642848969,
0.7680060863494873,
0.4059683382511139,
0.2933146357536316,
-0.8866925239562988,
0.1500883847475052,
0.05444558337330818,
0.31552618741989136,
0.2872718274593353,
-0.4071105122566223,
-0.2485426366329193,
-0.17172686755657196,
-0.2988988757133484,
-0.7354947328567505,
0.14512330293655396,
0.19501866400241852,
0.6613039970397949,
0.31658118963241577,
-0.1472131609916687,
0.6977246403694153,
-0.6821062564849854,
0.9496965408325195,
0.11919838190078735,
-0.8650881052017212,
0.32415971159935,
-0.6098412275314331,
0.2942419946193695,
0.6964399218559265,
0.3804984986782074,
-0.5270737409591675,
-0.183852881193161,
-0.49837085604667664,
-1.1123265027999878,
0.39097970724105835,
-0.0925917774438858,
-0.1931266039609909,
-0.22244516015052795,
0.6908000707626343,
-0.14920178055763245,
0.27205514907836914,
-0.38623055815696716,
-0.07253295183181763,
0.28691425919532776,
-0.3039092719554901,
-0.35309672355651855,
-0.4035862386226654,
-0.21325281262397766,
-0.12645171582698822,
0.19345718622207642,
-0.17941437661647797,
0.34061199426651,
0.684675395488739,
-0.14623653888702393,
-0.17167654633522034,
0.5118838548660278,
0.9918463826179504,
0.9245985150337219,
-0.18543361127376556,
-0.05703269690275192,
0.3069295287132263,
-0.7400596737861633,
0.08830107748508453,
0.04739002883434296,
-0.04299607500433922,
-0.14132770895957947,
0.9004668593406677,
0.62159264087677,
0.332726389169693,
-0.7269737720489502,
0.6100084185600281,
-0.23379652202129364,
-0.0025394598487764597,
-0.4907994866371155,
-0.08550183475017548,
0.15997405350208282,
0.16533829271793365,
0.07177946716547012,
-0.16861920058727264,
0.43335747718811035,
-0.4436548352241516,
0.08275485038757324,
0.21999719738960266,
-0.4700985550880432,
-0.3011308014392853,
0.3496776223182678,
0.07118035852909088,
-0.04730489104986191,
0.4234183728694916,
0.2409549057483673,
-0.4587269425392151,
0.5764726996421814,
0.44325360655784607,
0.9759804010391235,
-0.12085022032260895,
0.08759220689535141,
0.387848436832428,
0.37246546149253845,
-0.04607989266514778,
0.13608619570732117,
-0.07395874708890915,
-0.40528595447540283,
-0.595061182975769,
-0.462970495223999,
-0.5351725816726685,
0.21645449101924896,
-0.8411368727684021,
0.07735370844602585,
-0.6423693299293518,
-0.3612057566642761,
-0.0264043640345335,
0.022312087938189507,
-0.90595543384552,
0.39458757638931274,
0.17829251289367676,
0.8257843255996704,
-0.5580370426177979,
0.5680968165397644,
0.7650473713874817,
-0.428812712430954,
-0.8284146785736084,
0.07727835327386856,
0.07276729494333267,
-0.6713928580284119,
0.7478101849555969,
0.05809115618467331,
-0.04317425563931465,
-0.2785734534263611,
0.009836004115641117,
-0.46764901280403137,
1.0924307107925415,
-0.0777086541056633,
-0.7860416769981384,
-0.1432628631591797,
0.3282528817653656,
1.0837558507919312,
-0.5521824955940247,
0.6389049887657166,
0.6796377897262573,
0.4316435158252716,
0.023889118805527687,
-1.1273185014724731,
0.12009675800800323,
-0.18475864827632904,
-0.09424059838056564,
0.05371405929327011,
-0.59353107213974,
0.6093643307685852,
-0.2134554386138916,
-0.12743721902370453,
0.04080634191632271,
0.21821419894695282,
0.204782173037529,
0.5571025013923645,
0.32252052426338196,
0.5241810083389282,
0.6646358370780945,
-0.22524325549602509,
1.1090729236602783,
-0.33391690254211426,
0.16353406012058258,
0.9432088136672974,
-0.5754426717758179,
0.9300098419189453,
0.22612284123897552,
-0.10484997928142548,
0.41713231801986694,
0.4672006368637085,
0.40306562185287476,
0.10596093535423279,
0.3863849341869354,
-0.39711636304855347,
-0.2017924189567566,
-0.10403992980718613,
-0.5293565988540649,
0.26790493726730347,
0.7102581262588501,
-0.5166524648666382,
0.03217431902885437,
-0.12106674909591675,
0.1450173407793045,
0.11725801229476929,
-0.2260999232530594,
0.9748857021331787,
0.25597354769706726,
-0.7427394986152649,
0.8377576470375061,
-0.06741161644458771,
0.19122432172298431,
-0.6599453687667847,
-0.1754288524389267,
0.07716453075408936,
0.3601493537425995,
-0.23727533221244812,
-0.7758205533027649,
0.2127564400434494,
0.07616522908210754,
-0.12919461727142334,
0.09188884496688843,
0.45447272062301636,
-0.3079893887042999,
-0.3979185223579407,
0.309273898601532,
0.35835179686546326,
0.041239168494939804,
0.14927659928798676,
-0.6612011194229126,
0.2033432573080063,
-0.28963664174079895,
-0.22215642035007477,
0.1892518550157547,
0.6564733386039734,
-0.15717004239559174,
0.6605708003044128,
0.5484232902526855,
0.44641292095184326,
-0.2180819809436798,
0.4026525616645813,
0.794904887676239,
-0.5598040223121643,
-0.2761947810649872,
-0.7259079217910767,
0.5236868262290955,
0.16035878658294678,
-0.6306562423706055,
0.4784663915634155,
0.44398143887519836,
0.6317839026451111,
-0.043921392410993576,
0.8050236105918884,
0.46189945936203003,
0.6549239158630371,
-0.6187949180603027,
0.5462779402732849,
-0.41844049096107483,
0.3652952015399933,
-0.5425874590873718,
-0.6343395113945007,
-0.5358697175979614,
0.44036465883255005,
-0.7507095336914062,
-0.08203276246786118,
0.7402223944664001,
0.3442446291446686,
0.2559701204299927,
0.215015709400177,
0.3611052632331848,
0.2953374981880188,
0.699712336063385,
0.6803240776062012,
0.9703909754753113,
-0.28785941004753113,
0.02630023844540119,
-0.09601271897554398,
-0.2727164030075073,
-0.30628886818885803,
-0.7849778532981873,
-0.894702136516571,
-0.27481961250305176,
-0.1902637630701065,
-0.1927388310432434,
0.13613010942935944,
1.0368379354476929,
0.49571993947029114,
-0.6514779329299927,
-0.09373024106025696,
0.2993479073047638,
-0.3058216869831085,
-0.11300906538963318,
-0.17018862068653107,
0.5963159799575806,
-0.1269293576478958,
-0.31187453866004944,
0.2569600045681,
0.3903521001338959,
0.033446136862039566,
-0.4235536754131317,
-0.03656206652522087,
-0.10734567791223526,
-0.08474578708410263,
0.8532564640045166,
-0.1729695200920105,
-0.884330153465271,
-0.10067836195230484,
0.0876222774386406,
-0.23489642143249512,
-0.02798892930150032,
1.0449637174606323,
-0.363545298576355,
0.6103869080543518,
0.5187574625015259,
0.5344429612159729,
0.32341286540031433,
0.0979417935013771,
0.3608098030090332,
-0.020138336345553398,
-0.11767558753490448,
0.6287040710449219,
0.4357258379459381,
0.3529037833213806,
-0.3589194118976593,
0.46144503355026245,
0.24482569098472595,
-0.7031761407852173,
-0.7154563069343567,
-0.09924493730068207,
-0.9564738273620605,
-0.12325433641672134,
1.2490148544311523,
-0.36888086795806885,
0.16688473522663116,
-0.3188629746437073,
-0.23625628650188446,
0.1864343285560608,
-0.2979227900505066,
0.46821489930152893,
0.6953456997871399,
-0.08115144073963165,
0.07751338183879852,
-1.1281071901321411,
0.3353117108345032,
0.1779918074607849,
-0.6699020862579346,
-0.09245471656322479,
0.5661143064498901,
0.406730979681015,
0.10462190955877304,
0.7619251012802124,
-0.5370640754699707,
0.29823482036590576,
-0.5633857250213623,
0.06819015741348267,
-0.03311942145228386,
-0.2702440023422241,
-0.49010512232780457,
0.24204674363136292,
0.2465110719203949,
0.207845538854599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13586v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13586v3 | Instruction Fine-Tuning: Does Prompt Loss Matter? | 2024-01-24T16:51:23 | 2024-06-18T10:37:08 | Mathew Huerta-Enochian, Seung Yong Ko | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present a novel study analyzing the effects of various prompt loss token
weights (PLW) for supervised instruction fine-tuning (SIFT). While
prompt-masking (PLW = 0) is common for SIFT, some fine-tuning APIs support
fractional PLWs and suggest that using a small non-zero PLW can help stabilize
learning when fine-tuning on short-completion data. However, there has never
been a study confirming this claim, and OpenAI, a major cloud-based SIFT
provider, recently removed this parameter from their fine-tuning API. We found
that performance of models fine-tuned on short-completion data had a
statistically-significant negative quadratic relationship with PLW. Using small
values (0.01 - 0.5) of PLW produced better results on multiple-choice and
short-generation benchmarks (outperforming models fine-tuned on long-completion
data) while large values (~ 1.0) of PLW produced better results on
long-generation benchmarks. We explained this effect and verified its
importance through additional experiments. This research serves as a warning to
API providers about the importance of providing a PLW parameter for SIFT. | [
-0.4932261109352112,
-0.6029523015022278,
0.5904386043548584,
0.18321624398231506,
-0.4065156877040863,
-0.37649089097976685,
-0.280058890581131,
-0.23842421174049377,
-0.2104884535074234,
0.4113263487815857,
-0.6693002581596375,
-0.4504021406173706,
-0.6433191895484924,
0.01164138875901699,
-0.2800074815750122,
0.9655699729919434,
0.0864904597401619,
0.21755895018577576,
-0.34290358424186707,
-0.30358779430389404,
-1.0768535137176514,
-0.27642375230789185,
-1.0089775323867798,
-0.09091434627771378,
0.6517536044120789,
0.6943405270576477,
0.6403089761734009,
0.8271018266677856,
0.28496554493904114,
0.15828654170036316,
-0.2346992939710617,
0.20883764326572418,
-0.4735291600227356,
-0.12946465611457825,
0.07237804681062698,
-0.98391193151474,
-0.37161892652511597,
0.33555787801742554,
0.6180429458618164,
1.1117509603500366,
0.10288167744874954,
0.46744343638420105,
0.4200071096420288,
0.844789981842041,
-0.6547337770462036,
-0.005477527156472206,
-0.46983063220977783,
0.31853756308555603,
-0.3361153304576874,
-0.37268587946891785,
-0.5977969765663147,
-0.31226545572280884,
0.21502479910850525,
-0.710162341594696,
0.48342230916023254,
0.3771192133426666,
0.6092976927757263,
0.7605196237564087,
-0.3372323215007782,
-0.23992499709129333,
-0.3769976496696472,
0.9357654452323914,
-0.7260078191757202,
0.17343465983867645,
0.44400539994239807,
0.028562836349010468,
-0.12344636768102646,
-0.43356823921203613,
-0.14411240816116333,
-0.10942801833152771,
-0.07109086215496063,
0.10707352310419083,
-0.040674515068531036,
0.6095431447029114,
0.7408807873725891,
0.42847442626953125,
-0.14727720618247986,
0.3713200092315674,
-0.6546340584754944,
-0.3968624770641327,
0.33195552229881287,
0.32410740852355957,
0.09570224583148956,
0.10124079138040543,
-0.30135032534599304,
0.06361975520849228,
-0.8263986706733704,
0.6078154444694519,
0.7007274627685547,
0.3951203525066376,
-0.06787527352571487,
0.5200788378715515,
-0.1438046544790268,
0.9069426655769348,
0.4099564254283905,
-0.24008476734161377,
0.13382169604301453,
-0.10761883109807968,
-0.19318044185638428,
0.2934357225894928,
0.41855600476264954,
0.7102418541908264,
0.16644315421581268,
-0.039399463683366776,
-0.1273113340139389,
-0.3135685324668884,
-0.06004972383379936,
-0.9472435116767883,
-0.23409368097782135,
-0.04546019807457924,
-0.6546540260314941,
-0.1465318202972412,
0.34710225462913513,
-0.307732492685318,
-0.6710072159767151,
-0.7030649185180664,
0.6146707534790039,
-0.3813400864601135,
0.37891584634780884,
-0.026033863425254822,
-0.47653016448020935,
0.16976429522037506,
0.5206913352012634,
-0.6227531433105469,
0.21526315808296204,
0.9108068943023682,
0.991269588470459,
-0.3856525421142578,
-0.4611664116382599,
-1.1112059354782104,
-0.3881843090057373,
-0.4961246848106384,
0.33004525303840637,
-0.46626850962638855,
-0.36882492899894714,
-0.14943933486938477,
0.27534350752830505,
-0.18239142000675201,
-0.6735824942588806,
0.4821145534515381,
-0.309894323348999,
0.289220929145813,
-0.4856598973274231,
-0.776599645614624,
-0.12426218390464783,
-0.2834949493408203,
-0.7059177160263062,
0.5200819969177246,
-0.06253498792648315,
-0.6817178726196289,
0.7042335867881775,
-0.23246082663536072,
-0.5916827321052551,
0.03601410612463951,
-0.1042306199669838,
-0.4142093360424042,
0.4319577217102051,
0.009315595962107182,
0.3511238694190979,
-0.0902673602104187,
-0.09531650692224503,
-0.3297064006328583,
-0.9612599611282349,
0.13183197379112244,
-0.655487596988678,
0.740606963634491,
0.06675683706998825,
-0.4487486183643341,
-0.008559240959584713,
-0.7125771045684814,
-0.016462774947285652,
-0.3595229685306549,
-0.35378792881965637,
-0.3887322247028351,
0.05662616342306137,
-0.6126735210418701,
-0.1367117315530777,
0.25923022627830505,
-0.6403355598449707,
0.16094522178173065,
-0.5000541806221008,
0.4415810704231262,
0.9539873600006104,
0.15863971412181854,
0.7838132381439209,
-0.45199209451675415,
0.5313125848770142,
0.02730926312506199,
0.3910205364227295,
-0.384869247674942,
-0.7295281291007996,
-0.6495120525360107,
-0.23973748087882996,
0.5007457733154297,
0.3389761447906494,
-0.4471803903579712,
0.17655827105045319,
0.3940272927284241,
-0.25730276107788086,
-0.9593327641487122,
0.1018645390868187,
0.4645744562149048,
0.9173959493637085,
0.3660702407360077,
-0.05684790760278702,
-0.34850773215293884,
-0.7790960669517517,
-0.3601115047931671,
0.12313207238912582,
-0.27889156341552734,
0.46043509244918823,
-0.1430833786725998,
0.1294553428888321,
0.8823869824409485,
-0.5133683681488037,
-0.3814713954925537,
0.11029725521802902,
0.3548276126384735,
0.17678982019424438,
0.5360448360443115,
0.6298908591270447,
-0.6058799624443054,
-0.42228493094444275,
-0.44827622175216675,
-0.18165774643421173,
-0.4533648192882538,
-0.4422578811645508,
0.0086203096434474,
0.3589373528957367,
0.3203464150428772,
-0.4922970235347748,
0.6524710059165955,
0.38296204805374146,
-0.34798112511634827,
0.46377307176589966,
-0.43869221210479736,
0.0866427794098854,
-0.45832329988479614,
-0.17251946032047272,
-0.06238238140940666,
0.008228243328630924,
-0.31163179874420166,
-0.09167468547821045,
0.27725186944007874,
-0.2374843806028366,
-0.5351587533950806,
0.4964003562927246,
-0.09767996519804001,
-0.04433213546872139,
-0.33922794461250305,
-0.23898005485534668,
0.25491195917129517,
0.5219228863716125,
-0.2478734701871872,
1.3036155700683594,
0.4343487620353699,
-0.8428511023521423,
-0.23385046422481537,
-0.05351300910115242,
-0.06433569639921188,
0.3205716013908386,
-0.8496288657188416,
-0.06301248073577881,
-0.15954744815826416,
0.13748055696487427,
-0.8692359924316406,
-0.07982057332992554,
0.35911279916763306,
-0.42182472348213196,
0.2186170518398285,
-0.3008674681186676,
-0.2715528607368469,
-0.25533586740493774,
-0.7319737076759338,
0.24501891434192657,
0.7614055275917053,
-0.6150716543197632,
0.16718849539756775,
-0.051821980625391006,
0.029379799962043762,
-0.37168604135513306,
-0.7770394086837769,
-0.4987461268901825,
-0.4036843180656433,
-0.3397260010242462,
0.4728183150291443,
-0.36308717727661133,
0.2518596649169922,
-0.31156572699546814,
-0.49638962745666504,
0.11711383610963821,
0.4936206042766571,
0.5441305637359619,
0.17194056510925293,
-0.2815132439136505,
0.1453614979982376,
0.3589632511138916,
-0.12057888507843018,
0.26878848671913147,
-0.2238992601633072,
0.3538622260093689,
-0.13954101502895355,
-0.3909030258655548,
-0.805002748966217,
0.1320890337228775,
0.41997140645980835,
-0.15736693143844604,
0.8455734252929688,
0.856430172920227,
-0.01754717528820038,
-0.3568846583366394,
-0.37668493390083313,
-0.16006554663181305,
-0.5217889547348022,
-0.2031038999557495,
-0.05140930414199829,
-0.8660606741905212,
0.5576985478401184,
-0.08728934079408646,
0.06526614725589752,
0.5374395847320557,
0.0285196490585804,
-0.5394150614738464,
1.4021607637405396,
0.7370554804801941,
0.19933514297008514,
0.7428746223449707,
-0.1960432231426239,
0.04666498675942421,
-0.8186133503913879,
-0.12079598009586334,
-0.5280395746231079,
-0.7197605967521667,
-0.5953220725059509,
0.03931868076324463,
0.35779285430908203,
0.3966386020183563,
-0.5434542298316956,
-0.02196158841252327,
-0.7512811422348022,
0.49125057458877563,
1.10158109664917,
0.254180371761322,
0.018653851002454758,
-0.05725623667240143,
0.22543735802173615,
-0.2681252658367157,
-0.6523794531822205,
-0.24170246720314026,
0.8844203352928162,
0.2510031461715698,
0.7614220976829529,
-0.3812905550003052,
0.6996198296546936,
0.5739051103591919,
-0.3574976623058319,
-0.8933555483818054,
0.5768536925315857,
-0.5016025900840759,
-0.09136036038398743,
-0.48842471837997437,
-0.5969417095184326,
-0.9484474658966064,
-0.18846160173416138,
0.18473438918590546,
-0.39730143547058105,
0.24336816370487213,
0.42944714426994324,
-0.8699676394462585,
0.0968116819858551,
-1.110105037689209,
0.873529851436615,
-0.20424219965934753,
-0.10372037440538406,
-0.08413141220808029,
-0.6193106770515442,
0.18964596092700958,
0.06646107137203217,
-0.1159798800945282,
-0.16410386562347412,
-0.28149041533470154,
1.1470129489898682,
-0.6646448373794556,
0.9433135390281677,
-0.691196858882904,
0.08736519515514374,
0.405853807926178,
-0.07258009165525436,
0.3072368800640106,
0.058138132095336914,
-0.0509493388235569,
0.09955709427595139,
0.2643504738807678,
-0.35672152042388916,
-0.5390942096710205,
0.6383416652679443,
-0.8833523988723755,
-0.6709831953048706,
-0.1112854927778244,
-0.3993864953517914,
-0.10433482378721237,
0.2854878008365631,
0.4458842873573303,
0.679206907749176,
0.73387211561203,
0.54081791639328,
1.1055532693862915,
-0.34030187129974365,
0.3545673191547394,
0.4334132671356201,
0.33908316493034363,
-0.1978001743555069,
1.167868971824646,
0.6181027293205261,
0.2875383794307709,
0.02198995091021061,
0.4611796736717224,
0.1806146800518036,
-0.6902972459793091,
-0.4086912274360657,
-0.04584493115544319,
-0.5983534455299377,
-0.4621533453464508,
-0.09305200725793839,
-0.06385176628828049,
-0.2761474847793579,
-0.2030084878206253,
-0.13196925818920135,
-0.3744165897369385,
-0.8057603240013123,
0.17052745819091797,
0.38462087512016296,
0.28232496976852417,
0.10054050385951996,
0.6659023761749268,
-0.7966649532318115,
0.25513705611228943,
0.2249913364648819,
0.5652127861976624,
0.02899980917572975,
-0.6907081604003906,
-0.2561066448688507,
0.16245867311954498,
-0.13933303952217102,
-0.6465170979499817,
-0.14224958419799805,
0.4356825351715088,
0.5693286061286926,
0.5091654658317566,
0.41344258189201355,
0.9667196273803711,
-0.4409120976924896,
1.1028445959091187,
0.13745850324630737,
-0.8560459613800049,
0.5312442779541016,
-0.09298396855592728,
0.6378682851791382,
0.7473612427711487,
0.11698216944932938,
-0.3221113085746765,
-0.23896054923534393,
-0.5070189833641052,
-0.83815598487854,
1.098905086517334,
-0.3426901400089264,
0.22551128268241882,
0.03439588099718094,
0.43049535155296326,
0.6441189050674438,
0.46367713809013367,
-0.1283804327249527,
-0.3820887804031372,
-0.009584542363882065,
-0.2423669695854187,
0.30891090631484985,
-0.4094497561454773,
-0.00930848065763712,
-0.3507116138935089,
0.5572792887687683,
-0.22373700141906738,
0.09446382522583008,
0.023431312292814255,
-0.06155474856495857,
-0.2754296660423279,
0.0749257355928421,
0.6027646064758301,
0.3842628300189972,
-0.21472644805908203,
-0.06862325966358185,
0.19773559272289276,
-0.44576624035835266,
-0.341755211353302,
0.0787135437130928,
-0.5799592137336731,
-0.18997082114219666,
0.3840617537498474,
0.9730961322784424,
0.399321049451828,
-0.6130374670028687,
0.7744739055633545,
-0.13913919031620026,
-0.2262534499168396,
-0.09029834717512131,
0.45402953028678894,
-0.5258192420005798,
0.17046865820884705,
0.5349577069282532,
0.5528739094734192,
0.3860406279563904,
-0.21864329278469086,
0.061154499650001526,
0.254873663187027,
-0.32259219884872437,
-0.23322664201259613,
0.7212837338447571,
0.12435190379619598,
-0.1995641142129898,
0.6652925610542297,
-0.30398979783058167,
-0.17820259928703308,
0.8303003907203674,
0.2921793460845947,
0.7137147188186646,
0.244954451918602,
0.2881019711494446,
0.22702129185199738,
0.19484233856201172,
-0.09573683887720108,
0.037553369998931885,
-0.3729507625102997,
0.07751985639333725,
-0.39424729347229004,
-0.6091185212135315,
-0.47506043314933777,
-0.0332195982336998,
-0.8285970091819763,
0.266018807888031,
-0.7457563281059265,
-0.1884239763021469,
-0.05417837202548981,
0.2545340359210968,
-0.8284856081008911,
0.06048309803009033,
0.4660710394382477,
1.0642753839492798,
-0.5818800926208496,
0.40247946977615356,
0.5679032206535339,
-0.458297997713089,
-0.8412346243858337,
0.019638678058981895,
-0.1662893295288086,
-0.6044291257858276,
0.3746626079082489,
0.42237401008605957,
-0.04380858317017555,
-0.15531042218208313,
-0.6297392845153809,
-0.9199072122573853,
1.3165980577468872,
0.585902750492096,
-0.5887932777404785,
-0.3374301791191101,
0.16606591641902924,
0.4241396188735962,
-0.2113218754529953,
-0.03096224181354046,
0.6347881555557251,
0.32842329144477844,
0.08551457524299622,
-0.8745335936546326,
-0.014869460836052895,
0.34533584117889404,
-0.015248921699821949,
0.16305695474147797,
-0.8802960515022278,
1.2931617498397827,
-0.15161414444446564,
-0.3585956394672394,
0.13841181993484497,
0.5461270213127136,
0.0836275964975357,
0.9775433540344238,
0.4509466588497162,
0.3687058687210083,
0.966314435005188,
-0.09882665425539017,
0.843634307384491,
-0.3394743502140045,
0.022191355004906654,
1.2434298992156982,
0.10022109001874924,
0.5561995506286621,
0.47920146584510803,
-0.029099900275468826,
0.042120691388845444,
0.7957608103752136,
0.005847488064318895,
0.6023585796356201,
0.014088178053498268,
0.20318803191184998,
-0.028707850724458694,
-0.17204265296459198,
-0.40759748220443726,
-0.037735603749752045,
0.2756061553955078,
-0.32309237122535706,
-0.07962333410978317,
0.36509543657302856,
0.032417308539152145,
-0.08907901495695114,
-0.7896881699562073,
0.7757806777954102,
0.08319137990474701,
-0.7712633609771729,
0.49149492383003235,
-0.05187537148594856,
0.7918170094490051,
-0.44969406723976135,
-0.015178090892732143,
-0.42891982197761536,
0.1857995241880417,
-0.41935625672340393,
-0.7923240065574646,
0.19044069945812225,
-0.16070085763931274,
-0.3614219129085541,
-0.20486314594745636,
0.773767352104187,
-0.3512822389602661,
-0.11866264790296555,
-0.08289200067520142,
0.237600177526474,
-0.0559970922768116,
-0.08838441967964172,
-0.6531306505203247,
0.23268260061740875,
0.04593714326620102,
-0.27867069840431213,
0.4466666281223297,
0.5166290998458862,
0.05030219629406929,
0.4170057773590088,
0.5343963503837585,
0.013289830647408962,
0.2975371479988098,
0.28461354970932007,
0.6784600019454956,
-0.3929027020931244,
-0.5545924305915833,
-0.7070956826210022,
0.48700669407844543,
-0.14745645225048065,
-0.4890592694282532,
0.9338679909706116,
0.37500664591789246,
0.9874371290206909,
-0.09029603749513626,
0.531277060508728,
0.12593500316143036,
0.4982493221759796,
-0.6357254981994629,
0.47123560309410095,
-0.5755407810211182,
0.36677515506744385,
0.11621066927909851,
-0.6146084070205688,
-0.1088176891207695,
0.08022091537714005,
-0.5930569767951965,
-0.2544529438018799,
0.462570458650589,
0.5119419693946838,
0.06376031786203384,
0.020500516518950462,
0.2958885133266449,
-0.1851591020822525,
0.09681683033704758,
0.2676651179790497,
0.5891035795211792,
-0.4139314591884613,
0.5606802701950073,
-0.3925485610961914,
-0.22868143022060394,
-0.304117351770401,
-0.6443309187889099,
-0.990673840045929,
-0.3745668828487396,
-0.3849971890449524,
0.048913583159446716,
-0.01300661638379097,
0.8852185010910034,
0.5812832713127136,
-0.815882682800293,
0.2808806002140045,
-0.14303307235240936,
0.2055610567331314,
-0.44032996892929077,
-0.23107269406318665,
0.4016174077987671,
-0.7867797613143921,
-0.4737760126590729,
0.2246590107679367,
0.006487729027867317,
0.125505730509758,
0.0007304947939701378,
-0.22866907715797424,
0.5007213354110718,
0.027957435697317123,
0.5369676947593689,
0.3128981292247772,
-0.8018254637718201,
-0.2905663847923279,
0.06967789679765701,
-0.0019907045643776655,
-0.13299940526485443,
0.8296809196472168,
-1.0003104209899902,
0.41056033968925476,
0.5459464192390442,
0.8885124921798706,
-0.11865148693323135,
0.21851937472820282,
0.3309660851955414,
-1.051049828529358,
0.16921736299991608,
0.1642778515815735,
0.3013249933719635,
0.04942653328180313,
-0.5590407848358154,
0.23198235034942627,
0.10982572287321091,
-0.653713047504425,
-0.9684736728668213,
-0.09648053348064423,
-0.8466591835021973,
-0.23637838661670685,
0.9601402878761292,
0.00786995142698288,
-0.35152366757392883,
0.40500906109809875,
-0.6279624700546265,
0.16779562830924988,
-0.6614189147949219,
0.6167564392089844,
0.5981578230857849,
-0.2485605925321579,
-0.13956311345100403,
-0.6053016185760498,
0.7757274508476257,
0.48177289962768555,
-0.14296899735927582,
0.10663152486085892,
0.5664932727813721,
0.06837810575962067,
-0.05911113694310188,
0.2753126919269562,
0.293071448802948,
0.5878937840461731,
-0.15950177609920502,
-0.6178011894226074,
-0.5015677809715271,
-0.5055082440376282,
-0.5657680034637451,
0.28545671701431274,
0.2326716184616089,
-0.5935239791870117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13565v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13565v3 | Large Malaysian Language Model Based on Mistral for Enhanced Local Language Understanding | 2024-01-24T16:21:28 | 2024-02-04T06:52:28 | Husein Zolkepli, Aisyah Razak, Kamarul Adha, Ariff Nazhan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present significant advancements in the pretraining of
Mistral 7B, a large-scale language model, using a dataset of 32.6 GB,
equivalent to 1.1 billion tokens. We explore the impact of extending the
context length, releasing models with context lengths of 4096 and 32768 tokens,
and further refining performance with a specialized 16384 context length
instruction-tuned model, we called it Malaysian Mistral.
Our experiments demonstrate the efficacy of continue pretraining and the
influence of extended context lengths on Mistral 7B's language understanding
capabilities. Additionally, we release a model specifically tuned with a 16384
context length instruction, showcasing its potential for capturing nuanced
language intricacies.
Furthermore, our research contributes to the benchmarking of Malaysian
Mistral against prominent language models, including ChatGPT3.5 and Claude 2.
We present compelling results indicating Malaysian Mistral's superior
performance on Tatabahasa (Malay grammar) test set, particularly when
fine-tuned with instructions.
All models released at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mesolitica/malaysian-mistral-7b-6528f2ec825f4bba46c1700c | [
-0.40906065702438354,
-0.8540555238723755,
0.17957757413387299,
0.5118895769119263,
-0.48269277811050415,
-0.2645881175994873,
-0.584969162940979,
-0.4398440420627594,
-0.15008977055549622,
0.6084742546081543,
-0.20176135003566742,
-0.33500751852989197,
-0.6593736410140991,
0.2820923328399658,
-0.29689791798591614,
0.5726330876350403,
-0.1532173454761505,
0.003643475938588381,
0.08917484432458878,
-0.21771590411663055,
-0.5570330619812012,
-0.7983905673027039,
-0.736565113067627,
-0.14277473092079163,
0.3258388936519623,
0.2840113937854767,
0.6686941385269165,
0.907630443572998,
0.5296406745910645,
0.27095672488212585,
-0.3908052146434784,
-0.15495605766773224,
-0.6121679544448853,
0.11272543668746948,
-0.0774558037519455,
-0.5359014272689819,
-0.38948291540145874,
-0.41751331090927124,
0.7814187407493591,
0.757329523563385,
-0.3700298070907593,
0.3272141218185425,
0.034024737775325775,
0.6421892046928406,
-0.6035807132720947,
0.3708866238594055,
-0.37221866846084595,
-0.13125330209732056,
-0.5866426825523376,
0.08086629956960678,
-0.26476404070854187,
-0.12220810353755951,
0.1739775836467743,
-0.6844625473022461,
0.14680317044258118,
-0.2536240220069885,
0.6673699617385864,
0.48874977231025696,
-0.6476788520812988,
-0.2916560769081116,
-0.6497948169708252,
0.560999870300293,
-0.9327990412712097,
0.6300427913665771,
0.49960848689079285,
0.5826010704040527,
-0.11955547332763672,
-0.9413625001907349,
-0.47076529264450073,
-0.379738986492157,
0.16942115128040314,
0.015769729390740395,
-0.05171874910593033,
0.28167811036109924,
0.2230207473039627,
0.3968942165374756,
-0.4347967803478241,
0.16233861446380615,
-0.4679689407348633,
-0.17525652050971985,
0.24414631724357605,
0.16771523654460907,
-0.03771769627928734,
-0.0841643363237381,
-0.16888654232025146,
-0.10104890912771225,
-0.8446542620658875,
0.420089453458786,
0.1787988394498825,
0.25982803106307983,
-0.12221162766218185,
0.3878743648529053,
-0.37505102157592773,
0.899852991104126,
0.12226909399032593,
-0.20433726906776428,
0.1208348423242569,
-0.3642115890979767,
-0.3140421211719513,
0.16304798424243927,
0.4715915024280548,
-0.0026155272498726845,
0.1556297093629837,
0.12721997499465942,
-0.2501499652862549,
-0.0916578471660614,
0.01833321712911129,
-1.1668614149093628,
-0.19310389459133148,
0.03852000832557678,
-0.6419051289558411,
-0.04399028420448303,
0.274191677570343,
-0.3493269085884094,
-0.42598941922187805,
-0.5359623432159424,
0.38623282313346863,
-0.4709528684616089,
-0.7544954419136047,
0.49162915349006653,
0.16578254103660583,
0.31163954734802246,
0.42763519287109375,
-0.7140381336212158,
0.24215389788150787,
0.6771291494369507,
0.7257031798362732,
-0.0016014287248253822,
-0.36051294207572937,
-0.18167239427566528,
0.025728119537234306,
-0.3817206025123596,
0.48220476508140564,
-0.794763445854187,
-0.46160072088241577,
-0.02248198911547661,
-0.11318987607955933,
-0.11617137491703033,
-0.8935848474502563,
0.4363732635974884,
-0.5471952557563782,
0.29667341709136963,
-0.2959640324115753,
-0.3787641227245331,
-0.37902235984802246,
-0.03436975181102753,
-0.8799276947975159,
1.265781283378601,
0.34824448823928833,
-0.9720842838287354,
0.2950570285320282,
-0.6158167719841003,
-0.5501992106437683,
-0.05989788472652435,
0.020008189603686333,
-0.0055533768609166145,
0.3799460232257843,
0.27793431282043457,
0.5212153196334839,
-0.22401422262191772,
0.5629238486289978,
-0.17871668934822083,
-0.6013700366020203,
0.08910984545946121,
-0.7170397639274597,
0.7619348764419556,
0.3891444504261017,
-0.4999616742134094,
0.1443796157836914,
-0.7211861610412598,
-0.2692900598049164,
-0.13039134442806244,
-0.3940923810005188,
-0.24228976666927338,
-0.543785572052002,
0.14502522349357605,
0.5306793451309204,
0.6855722069740295,
-0.15324664115905762,
0.026920059695839882,
-0.28743016719818115,
0.16735652089118958,
0.6935573816299438,
-0.1252710372209549,
0.4101337194442749,
-0.0377127043902874,
0.8458737134933472,
0.2488914132118225,
0.3620709478855133,
-0.6174064874649048,
-0.09917961061000824,
-0.8618110418319702,
-0.37234312295913696,
0.480169415473938,
0.10329580307006836,
-0.6451506614685059,
0.29626986384391785,
-0.33356964588165283,
-0.46226221323013306,
-0.7241743206977844,
0.05109071359038353,
0.3151959478855133,
0.3516082167625427,
0.21620185673236847,
-0.3239549398422241,
-0.6591741442680359,
-0.8320946097373962,
-0.23368725180625916,
-0.1281757801771164,
0.19803661108016968,
0.34784725308418274,
0.21666856110095978,
-0.4829590618610382,
1.1098716259002686,
-0.10150046646595001,
0.00878611858934164,
-0.41236773133277893,
-0.0531291626393795,
0.3896065950393677,
0.26106926798820496,
0.4554920494556427,
-0.5687153935432434,
-0.5088070034980774,
0.3055685758590698,
-0.6140390634536743,
-0.4542193114757538,
0.0248356182128191,
-0.03220459446310997,
0.1918322890996933,
0.8905152082443237,
-0.5952256917953491,
0.36533668637275696,
0.6679797172546387,
-0.408467173576355,
0.7584817409515381,
-0.3715999126434326,
-0.00799038540571928,
-1.4192113876342773,
0.23843824863433838,
-0.1259521245956421,
-0.3006475269794464,
-0.6024785041809082,
0.10003171116113663,
0.22660697996616364,
0.002437304938212037,
-0.43497753143310547,
0.8695810437202454,
-0.5394107103347778,
0.12181037664413452,
-0.4966461658477783,
-0.14219877123832703,
-0.2298455834388733,
0.3257860243320465,
0.15816566348075867,
0.8702899217605591,
0.6608457565307617,
-0.7122186422348022,
0.1261398196220398,
-0.17958559095859528,
-0.5540776252746582,
0.09680616855621338,
-0.6806455254554749,
-0.10033341497182846,
-0.23967444896697998,
0.3946231007575989,
-0.6039491891860962,
-0.24155260622501373,
0.06813634932041168,
-0.2743111848831177,
0.28043097257614136,
-0.07677321881055832,
-0.305248498916626,
-0.09697460383176804,
-0.008036555722355843,
0.5950927734375,
0.36494532227516174,
-0.6538613438606262,
0.6522039175033569,
0.24485963582992554,
-0.45391222834587097,
-0.858084499835968,
-0.12995938956737518,
0.03493933007121086,
-0.4352828562259674,
-0.36836299300193787,
0.023733913898468018,
0.3221675753593445,
-0.3415386378765106,
-0.2451530396938324,
-0.3192087411880493,
-0.12932103872299194,
0.12896311283111572,
0.46571066975593567,
-0.07397746294736862,
-0.6188357472419739,
-0.04984573647379875,
0.3038853108882904,
-0.07048454135656357,
0.19493596255779266,
-0.09311215579509735,
0.8428896069526672,
-0.17217551171779633,
-0.13138249516487122,
-0.6025519371032715,
-0.022508900612592697,
0.601202666759491,
-0.4610600769519806,
1.0401654243469238,
0.8660061955451965,
-0.3391374945640564,
-0.04131517559289932,
-0.5125258564949036,
-0.0568937212228775,
-0.5282282829284668,
0.7157570719718933,
-0.6532185077667236,
-1.3232637643814087,
0.5845329761505127,
-0.32426124811172485,
-0.04480530321598053,
0.5041937828063965,
0.560431718826294,
0.33203426003456116,
0.8139210939407349,
0.962466299533844,
-0.5434055328369141,
0.7986313104629517,
0.05848165974020958,
0.110501229763031,
-0.4789288341999054,
-0.012179450131952763,
-0.5494742393493652,
0.2098292112350464,
-0.3027622699737549,
-0.6165552139282227,
0.06745020300149918,
0.7719456553459167,
-0.49074581265449524,
0.23300403356552124,
0.03890429809689522,
0.5243509411811829,
0.24889793992042542,
-0.13056029379367828,
0.26406073570251465,
-0.030113469809293747,
-0.21137700974941254,
0.04444415494799614,
-0.6963797211647034,
-0.5791770815849304,
0.9624042510986328,
0.6115065813064575,
0.9182277917861938,
0.2072731852531433,
0.44135305285453796,
-0.0623541995882988,
0.5391335487365723,
-0.41028478741645813,
0.19371728599071503,
0.29570478200912476,
-0.6291167736053467,
-0.2912255823612213,
-0.6913543939590454,
-1.1144312620162964,
0.5006729364395142,
0.16301706433296204,
-0.48895263671875,
-0.1739589273929596,
0.05082766339182854,
-0.14894023537635803,
-0.12932781875133514,
-0.9099112749099731,
0.9767827391624451,
-0.14724552631378174,
0.027812600135803223,
-0.4133492410182953,
-0.4870128631591797,
0.5287163853645325,
-0.2251823991537094,
0.18563193082809448,
0.15296491980552673,
0.08549660444259644,
0.8282551169395447,
-0.32684534788131714,
0.8845115900039673,
-0.39211201667785645,
-0.47496262192726135,
0.17481735348701477,
-0.08902627229690552,
0.03004426509141922,
0.21358752250671387,
-0.027486898005008698,
0.3330981731414795,
0.23279879987239838,
-0.37425634264945984,
-0.5607081651687622,
0.4500696361064911,
-0.858987033367157,
-0.6199239492416382,
-0.2393789291381836,
-0.352104127407074,
-0.10011909902095795,
0.4017954468727112,
0.21252091228961945,
0.7272274494171143,
-0.3162521719932556,
0.35013076663017273,
0.4611338675022125,
-0.3837117552757263,
0.408454567193985,
0.6267923712730408,
-0.6286413073539734,
-0.43971437215805054,
0.7011474967002869,
-0.14442120492458344,
0.25142714381217957,
0.3922351598739624,
0.19188790023326874,
-0.670319139957428,
-0.4279586672782898,
-0.2498100996017456,
0.3213324546813965,
-0.6629199981689453,
-0.0976247638463974,
-0.5733873844146729,
-0.1193169429898262,
-0.6503688097000122,
0.1303519904613495,
-0.5084642171859741,
-0.309547483921051,
-0.13951890170574188,
0.010491423308849335,
0.17999038100242615,
1.170064926147461,
-0.09039437770843506,
0.8506751656532288,
-0.7385185956954956,
0.1618872880935669,
-0.050979550927877426,
0.3763629198074341,
0.4191233217716217,
-1.1055172681808472,
-0.6789414286613464,
0.11278454959392548,
-0.0494367778301239,
-0.4193344712257385,
0.39009949564933777,
0.00814767461270094,
0.5304854512214661,
0.8980717658996582,
-0.21613840758800507,
0.984027624130249,
-0.35999321937561035,
0.5259767174720764,
-0.09047016501426697,
-1.0247397422790527,
0.28666481375694275,
-0.5020437836647034,
0.6492511034011841,
0.5991975665092468,
0.1897018551826477,
-0.8381120562553406,
-0.27996477484703064,
-0.6292113661766052,
-0.7237318158149719,
0.7196560502052307,
0.09816988557577133,
0.18719279766082764,
0.1308310329914093,
0.7114060521125793,
0.3928329050540924,
0.15062539279460907,
-0.47172877192497253,
-0.2543429434299469,
-0.07735150307416916,
-0.3153270184993744,
-0.3196395933628082,
-0.33454227447509766,
0.29904937744140625,
-0.4685724079608917,
0.5958163738250732,
0.11195731163024902,
0.07843279093503952,
-0.1845899373292923,
-0.5296831727027893,
0.23023207485675812,
0.06670907884836197,
0.6498002409934998,
0.9136701226234436,
-0.14152754843235016,
0.10750643908977509,
0.156629279255867,
-1.0305771827697754,
-0.06735525280237198,
0.325032114982605,
0.3532608449459076,
0.09551399946212769,
0.5861719250679016,
0.790703296661377,
0.0771976038813591,
-0.6965165734291077,
0.486894428730011,
-0.4865165054798126,
0.2138456106185913,
-0.18369653820991516,
0.02446228824555874,
0.17009365558624268,
0.19389761984348297,
0.27052637934684753,
-0.09257906675338745,
-0.22359971702098846,
-0.14025691151618958,
0.19831305742263794,
0.10260280966758728,
-0.4517563283443451,
-0.5080282092094421,
0.539194643497467,
0.12620887160301208,
0.033537838608026505,
0.413047194480896,
0.012506231665611267,
-0.6241227984428406,
0.5501424670219421,
0.8587269186973572,
0.3655816912651062,
-0.6908178329467773,
0.10498179495334625,
0.4104290008544922,
0.33898627758026123,
-0.46076083183288574,
0.18300968408584595,
-0.3558286130428314,
-0.6747512817382812,
-0.5956023335456848,
-0.7248324751853943,
-0.3691207468509674,
0.255768358707428,
-0.8599012494087219,
0.16333375871181488,
-0.44582703709602356,
-0.0037813126109540462,
-0.4953269958496094,
0.24725167453289032,
-0.5797896385192871,
0.21331088244915009,
-0.027832766994833946,
1.1520692110061646,
-0.7055256962776184,
1.0497972965240479,
0.7469218373298645,
-0.12107648700475693,
-0.9316199421882629,
-0.015191270969808102,
-0.3897615969181061,
-0.637728214263916,
0.5444859266281128,
0.6518502831459045,
-0.0652819499373436,
0.08248197287321091,
-0.3445312976837158,
-1.0616790056228638,
0.9426521062850952,
0.5485626459121704,
-0.557247519493103,
0.25687289237976074,
0.32330042123794556,
0.5726168751716614,
-0.10211498290300369,
0.4071146547794342,
0.8307221531867981,
0.27648675441741943,
-0.14016875624656677,
-1.1010160446166992,
-0.1522337943315506,
-0.4197864234447479,
0.06275290250778198,
0.18338100612163544,
-0.4763387143611908,
0.8326330780982971,
0.11067746579647064,
-0.27790701389312744,
0.13114337623119354,
1.041983723640442,
0.30294787883758545,
-0.1206217110157013,
0.38755694031715393,
0.6420111656188965,
0.925703763961792,
0.18859830498695374,
1.0368337631225586,
-0.39298906922340393,
0.1522253006696701,
1.1825597286224365,
-0.18710936605930328,
0.9465933442115784,
0.1960507035255432,
-0.019653813913464546,
0.28200334310531616,
0.8349265456199646,
0.7855902910232544,
0.3865317106246948,
0.11623954772949219,
-0.5806295275688171,
-0.12501260638237,
-0.19366031885147095,
-0.7391101717948914,
0.553081750869751,
0.34086862206459045,
-0.20664124190807343,
-0.22531385719776154,
0.02194942906498909,
0.23670899868011475,
-0.19929422438144684,
-0.3839532136917114,
0.5679134726524353,
0.25774893164634705,
-0.5268094539642334,
0.7511370778083801,
0.30225810408592224,
0.821027934551239,
-0.3764919340610504,
0.1944323629140854,
-0.47501474618911743,
0.45946699380874634,
0.02160116471350193,
-0.43469345569610596,
-0.21383526921272278,
0.026450829580426216,
0.08769601583480835,
-0.07257747650146484,
0.6199605464935303,
-0.47704192996025085,
-0.36141276359558105,
-0.007047529798001051,
0.6123318076133728,
0.0997958853840828,
-0.39995408058166504,
-0.48165538907051086,
0.18529988825321198,
-0.059753306210041046,
-0.29396381974220276,
0.28750482201576233,
0.9689404964447021,
-0.32297199964523315,
0.5622003674507141,
0.5085994005203247,
0.019836589694023132,
0.3561343252658844,
0.3944029211997986,
0.7769259810447693,
-0.9164003133773804,
-0.5713709592819214,
-0.8563027381896973,
0.1451447457075119,
0.013613199815154076,
-0.7453110218048096,
0.8110432624816895,
0.7223994731903076,
1.028885006904602,
-0.010663243941962719,
0.7221910357475281,
0.20363667607307434,
0.261439710855484,
-0.4231016933917999,
0.7133122086524963,
-0.19529065489768982,
-0.004392370581626892,
-0.0996571034193039,
-1.0477203130722046,
-0.23498813807964325,
0.8604810237884521,
-0.28835976123809814,
0.23336732387542725,
0.6267238259315491,
0.853665292263031,
-0.2446659803390503,
0.024612559005618095,
0.20075680315494537,
0.4261241555213928,
0.3501224219799042,
0.37543657422065735,
1.1605844497680664,
-0.1946134865283966,
0.22416427731513977,
-0.18489228188991547,
-0.3036237359046936,
-0.08356878906488419,
-0.5454526543617249,
-1.2738019227981567,
-0.6347073912620544,
0.19562405347824097,
-0.225991353392601,
-0.19481121003627777,
0.9754834771156311,
0.5362759232521057,
-0.608498752117157,
-0.43386149406433105,
0.002240580739453435,
-0.2531038224697113,
-0.02388797514140606,
-0.19625692069530487,
0.4974343776702881,
-0.3650248050689697,
-0.4442642033100128,
0.16771985590457916,
0.33399200439453125,
-0.015607637353241444,
-0.2136417180299759,
-0.28230270743370056,
0.1949516236782074,
-0.10286269336938858,
0.8160315155982971,
0.16459821164608002,
-0.7221036553382874,
0.14382001757621765,
0.08730799704790115,
-0.27463603019714355,
-0.10981021076440811,
0.7851940393447876,
-0.8407204151153564,
0.29358017444610596,
0.2608878016471863,
0.8666409254074097,
0.5618206262588501,
0.1469683200120926,
0.8282472491264343,
-0.5581952333450317,
0.41048330068588257,
-0.13030938804149628,
0.4076191484928131,
0.36204656958580017,
-0.21562877297401428,
0.2443041205406189,
-0.1342550367116928,
-0.30727696418762207,
-0.7317642569541931,
0.012788109481334686,
-0.8080825805664062,
-0.24955174326896667,
1.2832180261611938,
0.0066431681625545025,
-0.3364790081977844,
-0.22732003033161163,
-0.6964986324310303,
0.48071029782295227,
-0.2816441059112549,
0.7870301008224487,
0.7241367101669312,
0.20946623384952545,
-0.2959394156932831,
-0.4953383207321167,
0.5673748254776001,
0.6358199119567871,
-0.8911781907081604,
0.37186554074287415,
0.3779497444629669,
0.16952162981033325,
-0.3140132427215576,
0.9014989733695984,
-0.1385939121246338,
0.35999011993408203,
-0.11911967396736145,
-0.05096437782049179,
-0.08801579475402832,
-0.3691422641277313,
-0.8697946071624756,
-0.11207028478384018,
0.38482019305229187,
0.13326844573020935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13527v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13527v2 | SpeechGPT-Gen: Scaling Chain-of-Information Speech Generation | 2024-01-24T15:25:01 | 2024-01-25T17:24:52 | Dong Zhang, Xin Zhang, Jun Zhan, Shimin Li, Yaqian Zhou, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Benefiting from effective speech modeling, current Speech Large Language
Models (SLLMs) have demonstrated exceptional capabilities in in-context speech
generation and efficient generalization to unseen speakers. However, the
prevailing information modeling process is encumbered by certain redundancies,
leading to inefficiencies in speech generation. We propose Chain-of-Information
Generation (CoIG), a method for decoupling semantic and perceptual information
in large-scale speech generation. Building on this, we develop SpeechGPT-Gen,
an 8-billion-parameter SLLM efficient in semantic and perceptual information
modeling. It comprises an autoregressive model based on LLM for semantic
information modeling and a non-autoregressive model employing flow matching for
perceptual information modeling. Additionally, we introduce the novel approach
of infusing semantic information into the prior distribution to enhance the
efficiency of flow matching. Extensive experimental results demonstrate that
SpeechGPT-Gen markedly excels in zero-shot text-to-speech, zero-shot voice
conversion, and speech-to-speech dialogue, underscoring CoIG's remarkable
proficiency in capturing and modeling speech's semantic and perceptual
dimensions. Code and models are available at
https://github.com/0nutation/SpeechGPT. | [
-0.4476846158504486,
-0.8296719193458557,
0.1272961050271988,
0.032574672251939774,
-0.3718855381011963,
-0.03230784833431244,
-0.14481773972511292,
-0.3248092532157898,
0.012583223171532154,
0.49751636385917664,
-0.6103492379188538,
-0.30367010831832886,
-0.47793078422546387,
-0.3921005427837372,
-0.6513133645057678,
1.1447371244430542,
0.5861994624137878,
-0.07388404756784439,
0.05092447251081467,
0.189825639128685,
-0.07281003147363663,
-0.6371110081672668,
-0.7981163859367371,
-0.48616743087768555,
0.5136545300483704,
0.40006160736083984,
0.6279773712158203,
0.8802029490470886,
0.48626208305358887,
0.12806890904903412,
0.06719975918531418,
-0.14450618624687195,
-0.6771225333213806,
0.09185708314180374,
-0.21587194502353668,
0.07833831012248993,
-0.7544664144515991,
-0.07777866721153259,
0.9175821542739868,
0.9534369707107544,
-0.4875327944755554,
0.4461982548236847,
0.019376583397388458,
0.352205753326416,
-0.5006799697875977,
0.24117226898670197,
-0.9214296936988831,
-0.060786496847867966,
-0.1367931365966797,
-0.27911269664764404,
-0.4336514174938202,
-0.12453436106443405,
0.247956320643425,
-0.5153821706771851,
0.29363128542900085,
0.09744446724653244,
0.748629629611969,
0.37507009506225586,
-0.18075568974018097,
-0.28835979104042053,
-0.9366012811660767,
0.5144291520118713,
-0.9300453662872314,
0.4711248278617859,
0.011373588815331459,
0.0983196422457695,
-0.21016794443130493,
-0.9902744889259338,
-0.5853506922721863,
-0.25937706232070923,
0.2999858260154724,
0.11789959669113159,
-0.45017993450164795,
0.264797568321228,
0.32710304856300354,
0.3512688875198364,
-0.7246323227882385,
0.031117990612983704,
-0.18364153802394867,
-0.025066621601581573,
0.6559338569641113,
-0.12925978004932404,
0.2854422330856323,
-0.11500668525695801,
-0.6040194630622864,
-0.31226956844329834,
-0.7466440796852112,
-0.5913099050521851,
0.4689902067184448,
0.46801474690437317,
-0.03211868926882744,
0.48492631316185,
-0.3302996754646301,
0.9231972694396973,
0.4287489056587219,
-0.15385907888412476,
0.23260153830051422,
-0.5558387041091919,
-0.4281913936138153,
0.6324098706245422,
0.8386463522911072,
0.03708828240633011,
-0.08071751892566681,
-0.1048911064863205,
0.1787317842245102,
-0.13463546335697174,
0.01810295879840851,
-0.9671726226806641,
-0.30975064635276794,
-0.15512138605117798,
-0.2814539074897766,
-0.24413233995437622,
0.05681459978222847,
-0.855225145816803,
-0.135184183716774,
-0.09640289843082428,
0.5078834891319275,
-0.27267178893089294,
-0.5745383501052856,
0.0952904224395752,
-0.3812965750694275,
0.46007633209228516,
0.0013228210154920816,
-0.9354947209358215,
0.14967860281467438,
0.48129621148109436,
0.6678750514984131,
0.026239721104502678,
-0.11891113221645355,
-0.8114324808120728,
0.4979247450828552,
-0.22889463603496552,
0.3243178129196167,
-0.4744991064071655,
-0.07637082785367966,
-0.2930479347705841,
-0.407378613948822,
-0.008833498694002628,
-0.5839760899543762,
0.48589110374450684,
-0.33543673157691956,
-0.016778582707047462,
0.02605418674647808,
-0.7300682663917542,
0.03863656520843506,
-0.0889957919716835,
-0.4366181790828705,
0.6826145648956299,
0.049383703619241714,
-0.8564021587371826,
0.5355231761932373,
-0.7316758632659912,
-0.24989864230155945,
0.48937612771987915,
-0.3308354914188385,
-0.4358508586883545,
0.05402607470750809,
0.03152007237076759,
0.3600895404815674,
-0.427323579788208,
0.5494994521141052,
-0.3023707866668701,
0.06494279205799103,
-0.3196908235549927,
-0.6004133224487305,
0.5184073448181152,
0.4862343668937683,
-0.42613711953163147,
-0.02614232897758484,
-1.127362847328186,
0.18567398190498352,
0.18311037123203278,
-0.2975291907787323,
-0.1640593260526657,
0.05639464408159256,
-0.13367514312267303,
0.18410031497478485,
0.32765793800354004,
-0.46375390887260437,
0.17289137840270996,
-0.2068222314119339,
0.7720601558685303,
0.34105655550956726,
0.12149033695459366,
0.5146191120147705,
0.022868260741233826,
0.3730056583881378,
-0.10384625196456909,
0.05109291896224022,
-0.27930888533592224,
-0.40330249071121216,
-0.6819804906845093,
-0.22664715349674225,
0.19407705962657928,
0.5063861608505249,
-0.7320998907089233,
0.7053025364875793,
-0.35802820324897766,
-0.5676746368408203,
-0.17095504701137543,
-0.11606920510530472,
0.2763294279575348,
0.8641787171363831,
0.21186240017414093,
-0.2204499989748001,
-0.6020534634590149,
-0.7717333436012268,
-0.2882155478000641,
-0.4061617851257324,
-0.31524088978767395,
0.22791574895381927,
0.15329724550247192,
-0.059563785791397095,
0.9832878708839417,
-0.42834752798080444,
0.20480023324489594,
-0.2686779201030731,
0.43343934416770935,
0.16250573098659515,
0.5311973690986633,
0.10528408735990524,
-0.7268925309181213,
-0.11578946560621262,
0.04627901315689087,
-0.6157143712043762,
-0.3216871917247772,
0.14115291833877563,
-0.12660326063632965,
-0.3173109292984009,
0.48294946551322937,
-0.3668578565120697,
0.24801227450370789,
0.8448083996772766,
-0.42940962314605713,
0.3638925552368164,
-0.4542306363582611,
-0.06861456483602524,
-1.0873836278915405,
0.1489623337984085,
-0.1815265268087387,
-0.23635947704315186,
-0.9996320009231567,
0.03061177395284176,
-0.2722439765930176,
-0.5237686634063721,
-0.3544815182685852,
0.27400678396224976,
-0.386695921421051,
-0.1642252802848816,
-0.14272437989711761,
0.4349833130836487,
-0.11264503002166748,
0.34807127714157104,
-0.13663238286972046,
0.7961390018463135,
0.43982622027397156,
-0.6330325603485107,
0.5754274725914001,
0.08452349901199341,
-0.30187246203422546,
0.5835296511650085,
-0.5874857306480408,
0.401707261800766,
-0.09456168115139008,
0.3685615360736847,
-0.8729708194732666,
-0.5917406678199768,
-0.04850558191537857,
-0.42433086037635803,
0.18113142251968384,
-0.15043793618679047,
-0.567679762840271,
-0.16588936746120453,
0.05428727716207504,
0.616852879524231,
0.6924190521240234,
-0.7469611763954163,
0.6307220458984375,
0.5521950721740723,
-0.48410850763320923,
-0.15712106227874756,
-0.7228264212608337,
0.33921176195144653,
-0.27279672026634216,
-0.9459042549133301,
0.3413533866405487,
0.07588247954845428,
-0.15471582114696503,
-0.14476586878299713,
0.11001791059970856,
-0.041304707527160645,
-0.3880669176578522,
-0.045377057045698166,
0.12203213572502136,
-0.24464502930641174,
0.42864716053009033,
-0.003323850454762578,
0.07671660929918289,
-0.16275371611118317,
-0.9000394344329834,
0.778637170791626,
-0.1274726539850235,
-0.1708439588546753,
-0.24584166705608368,
0.4919082522392273,
0.4206790626049042,
-0.22777540981769562,
0.3434610068798065,
0.7293427586555481,
0.008967144414782524,
-0.18391306698322296,
-0.4876835346221924,
-0.008083711378276348,
-0.40797534584999084,
0.6040583848953247,
-0.2950258255004883,
-0.8327123522758484,
0.2282668799161911,
-0.34716659784317017,
-0.2813017666339874,
0.5195059776306152,
0.5524996519088745,
0.12723076343536377,
0.8701314926147461,
0.5804324746131897,
-0.06724284589290619,
0.7929607033729553,
-0.20927074551582336,
0.34835508465766907,
-0.7013739943504333,
0.06737824529409409,
-0.29601573944091797,
0.0006495616398751736,
-0.6434504389762878,
-0.4925265312194824,
0.4287365674972534,
0.28478679060935974,
-0.475436270236969,
0.25539064407348633,
-0.5646724104881287,
0.0354948453605175,
0.7732675671577454,
-0.14824113249778748,
0.3740254342556,
0.30123835802078247,
0.005207838024944067,
0.4425375461578369,
-1.1823240518569946,
-0.26331421732902527,
0.7374256253242493,
0.26861289143562317,
0.9630745649337769,
-0.20155435800552368,
0.5694317817687988,
0.09709305316209793,
-0.255729079246521,
-0.5173928141593933,
0.595822274684906,
-0.48002561926841736,
-0.27323585748672485,
-0.49097421765327454,
-0.7470768094062805,
-0.7260633111000061,
0.10107071697711945,
-0.0810762420296669,
-0.7579513788223267,
0.23382560908794403,
0.48673152923583984,
-0.1481071263551712,
0.3914228081703186,
-0.8194593787193298,
0.5451231002807617,
0.10155516117811203,
-0.2744925916194916,
-0.15244778990745544,
-0.7521122097969055,
0.17556406557559967,
0.02341904677450657,
0.01109258458018303,
-0.07203444093465805,
0.11523975431919098,
0.7594627737998962,
-0.6575559973716736,
0.5414791107177734,
-0.30297502875328064,
-0.294134259223938,
0.5317070484161377,
-0.30695194005966187,
0.7578649520874023,
-0.19429606199264526,
-0.06997567415237427,
0.32583191990852356,
-0.36101317405700684,
-0.1873781979084015,
-0.5147466659545898,
0.6126596331596375,
-0.46237531304359436,
-0.37643465399742126,
0.13224194943904877,
-0.694908618927002,
-0.11047349870204926,
0.14222405850887299,
0.6209028363227844,
0.5409814715385437,
-0.0452168807387352,
0.24883471429347992,
0.6502947807312012,
-0.17608524858951569,
0.3396361470222473,
0.11902503669261932,
-0.12579959630966187,
-0.6531175374984741,
1.053886890411377,
0.25649121403694153,
0.8453978300094604,
0.2710084915161133,
0.4124380052089691,
-0.2927184998989105,
-0.30661264061927795,
-0.4860285818576813,
0.24207361042499542,
-0.4940176010131836,
0.053235072642564774,
-0.4544733166694641,
-0.5233340859413147,
-0.4267651438713074,
0.23104651272296906,
-0.34467974305152893,
-0.4343106746673584,
-0.07471808046102524,
-0.04750562086701393,
0.18526504933834076,
0.7403565645217896,
-0.20866085588932037,
0.5462131500244141,
-0.39263010025024414,
0.28476011753082275,
0.5431079864501953,
0.21358978748321533,
-0.05422499030828476,
-0.47533681988716125,
-0.06989488005638123,
0.06332062184810638,
-0.13220638036727905,
-0.6043162941932678,
0.31584811210632324,
0.37416234612464905,
0.3060418665409088,
0.3220502436161041,
-0.08570404350757599,
0.8805135488510132,
-0.5869197249412537,
0.8304023742675781,
0.5169563293457031,
-1.1137895584106445,
0.6527370810508728,
-0.5556081533432007,
0.6932241916656494,
0.17446348071098328,
-0.15957526862621307,
-0.5067066550254822,
-0.6699981689453125,
-0.8367660045623779,
-1.0653886795043945,
0.46181967854499817,
0.3063278794288635,
-0.0002816262422129512,
-0.0585961788892746,
0.3694310486316681,
-0.0673554390668869,
0.4308076500892639,
-0.38238441944122314,
-0.018443020060658455,
-0.3524818420410156,
-0.26147571206092834,
0.0012116121361032128,
-0.2760668992996216,
0.08027226477861404,
-0.1665544956922531,
0.6129062175750732,
-0.09188573807477951,
0.31047216057777405,
0.4141864478588104,
0.1858920305967331,
-0.014804611913859844,
0.39185667037963867,
0.6162490844726562,
0.5073421001434326,
-0.11686264723539352,
0.2835613787174225,
-0.027079299092292786,
-0.6856338381767273,
0.19806890189647675,
-0.00032782554626464844,
-0.37443485856056213,
0.05545341223478317,
0.41248205304145813,
1.248238205909729,
-0.14525502920150757,
-0.38751697540283203,
0.512543797492981,
0.06560955196619034,
-0.43845775723457336,
-0.2169571965932846,
0.07816854864358902,
0.03075410984456539,
0.24844606220722198,
0.4242412745952606,
-0.11039641499519348,
0.18583723902702332,
-0.6022603511810303,
0.3465075194835663,
0.40581268072128296,
-0.2784389555454254,
-0.19702443480491638,
0.7703614830970764,
0.16033925116062164,
-0.308865487575531,
0.6587673425674438,
-0.24157877266407013,
-0.04663935676217079,
0.3439996838569641,
0.7094252705574036,
1.0287014245986938,
-0.27737078070640564,
0.05796762928366661,
0.30870258808135986,
-0.026211101561784744,
-0.009318514727056026,
0.10702336579561234,
-0.2677014172077179,
-0.5489466190338135,
-0.5244774222373962,
-0.5902784466743469,
-0.25112491846084595,
0.2910100221633911,
-0.5945756435394287,
0.17910273373126984,
-0.3563072383403778,
-0.36457347869873047,
-0.12291748821735382,
-0.3565681576728821,
-0.47798699140548706,
0.24387216567993164,
0.36269551515579224,
0.6410680413246155,
-0.5828872919082642,
0.9502872824668884,
0.19834783673286438,
-0.2925730049610138,
-1.1567356586456299,
0.26778480410575867,
-0.30125218629837036,
-0.6867968440055847,
0.8988251090049744,
-0.27548500895500183,
-0.4798724949359894,
0.4622855484485626,
-0.6272704005241394,
-1.0669559240341187,
1.266872763633728,
0.8167884349822998,
-0.9606421589851379,
-0.40193015336990356,
0.10933899879455566,
0.35990676283836365,
-0.5776572823524475,
-0.01491769403219223,
0.5128951668739319,
0.2829071581363678,
0.7815799117088318,
-1.0738797187805176,
-0.13148365914821625,
0.08248991519212723,
0.21562011539936066,
0.3837696611881256,
-0.561059296131134,
1.0006734132766724,
-0.12248509377241135,
-0.39244967699050903,
-0.07762676477432251,
0.43851566314697266,
0.11532413959503174,
0.0639677569270134,
0.7220236659049988,
0.6538693308830261,
0.8969051241874695,
0.038789767771959305,
0.7634270787239075,
-0.4306183457374573,
0.47092071175575256,
1.5558990240097046,
-0.11730847507715225,
0.9051600694656372,
0.3958391547203064,
0.10326012223958969,
0.25780677795410156,
0.12056248635053635,
0.006977483630180359,
0.5862669348716736,
0.48390454053878784,
-0.5446079969406128,
-0.0823885127902031,
-0.2456880360841751,
-0.33427947759628296,
0.6290796995162964,
0.255763441324234,
-0.528327226638794,
-0.39991241693496704,
0.07610169053077698,
-0.048149723559617996,
-0.43217289447784424,
-0.4938465356826782,
1.01300847530365,
-0.0913267582654953,
-0.37279316782951355,
0.6737942695617676,
-0.3564440906047821,
0.2989761233329773,
-0.6647290587425232,
-0.24717822670936584,
0.1356612592935562,
0.061725419014692307,
-0.22676841914653778,
-0.3811310827732086,
0.1897663176059723,
0.13075047731399536,
-0.2063271850347519,
-0.2519131004810333,
0.8381971120834351,
-0.8385537266731262,
-0.4355316460132599,
0.42407068610191345,
0.2540920078754425,
0.24049416184425354,
-0.07092470675706863,
-0.37689387798309326,
0.08990757912397385,
-0.14701862633228302,
0.057646699249744415,
0.05068144574761391,
0.41035738587379456,
0.0919998437166214,
0.4016580283641815,
0.49171605706214905,
0.3752596378326416,
0.5101063251495361,
0.3612504303455353,
0.68085777759552,
-0.5889757871627808,
-0.5048274993896484,
-0.9744808077812195,
0.25982993841171265,
-0.23124510049819946,
-0.029520398005843163,
0.5018144845962524,
0.5728269219398499,
0.8224606513977051,
0.0848269909620285,
0.9953187108039856,
-0.13264065980911255,
0.38926801085472107,
-0.5028542876243591,
0.5687078237533569,
-0.2212998867034912,
-0.08325828611850739,
-0.37203410267829895,
-0.7816407680511475,
-0.08012571930885315,
0.36119234561920166,
-0.25534576177597046,
-0.017646588385105133,
0.46726295351982117,
0.5887497067451477,
0.11306216567754745,
-0.02639835886657238,
0.6164916157722473,
0.39061227440834045,
0.45954880118370056,
0.516633927822113,
0.6540360450744629,
-0.35921698808670044,
0.6430478096008301,
0.14471717178821564,
-0.5015257596969604,
-0.10604336857795715,
-0.9348076581954956,
-0.42783042788505554,
-0.5611553192138672,
-0.32210060954093933,
-0.13972711563110352,
0.08092433214187622,
0.7639176249504089,
1.0424513816833496,
-0.23471952974796295,
-0.43770503997802734,
-0.6221374869346619,
-0.40960755944252014,
0.0030987246427685022,
-0.21373817324638367,
0.06831193715333939,
-0.44374772906303406,
-0.4785234034061432,
0.4759780168533325,
0.7144654989242554,
0.033102165907621384,
-0.3921763300895691,
-0.0065873232670128345,
-0.15248669683933258,
0.3656093180179596,
0.7218875885009766,
0.11578045040369034,
-0.6866975426673889,
-0.3009115755558014,
-0.38999736309051514,
0.12001199275255203,
0.23634129762649536,
0.7956216335296631,
-0.6081318259239197,
0.5827041864395142,
0.5610934495925903,
0.4111519455909729,
0.8265560269355774,
0.26480430364608765,
0.8126299381256104,
-0.7843079566955566,
0.17653802037239075,
0.17596407234668732,
0.045185551047325134,
0.22762256860733032,
-0.37793025374412537,
0.31659600138664246,
0.12430799752473831,
-0.7027068734169006,
-0.5654987692832947,
0.6641525030136108,
-0.9953488111495972,
0.1527058184146881,
1.137213945388794,
-0.13080072402954102,
-0.243857741355896,
0.25284543633461,
-0.07508449256420135,
0.4988557994365692,
-0.4400348365306854,
0.292834609746933,
0.6765679717063904,
-0.3688523769378662,
-0.11053095757961273,
-0.4507932662963867,
0.36375105381011963,
0.07262325286865234,
-0.8384501934051514,
0.31681883335113525,
0.36300626397132874,
0.18767619132995605,
0.2996987998485565,
0.6819532513618469,
-0.04673614725470543,
-0.09387119859457016,
0.4026772975921631,
0.12384414672851562,
0.0815446525812149,
-0.235275000333786,
-0.3452914357185364,
0.43773409724235535,
0.055534977465867996,
-0.2720681428909302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13512v1 | Can GPT-3.5 Generate and Code Discharge Summaries? | 2024-01-24T15:10:13 | 2024-01-24T15:10:13 | Matúš Falis, Aryo Pradipta Gema, Hang Dong, Luke Daines, Siddharth Basetti, Michael Holder, Rose S Penfold, Alexandra Birch, Beatrice Alex | cs.CL | cs.CL | Objective: To investigate GPT-3.5 in generating and coding medical documents
with ICD-10 codes for data augmentation on low-resources labels.
Materials and Methods: Employing GPT-3.5 we generated and coded 9,606
discharge summaries based on lists of ICD-10 code descriptions of patients with
infrequent (generation) codes within the MIMIC-IV dataset. Combined with the
baseline training set, this formed an augmented training set. Neural coding
models were trained on baseline and augmented data and evaluated on a MIMIC-IV
test set. We report micro- and macro-F1 scores on the full codeset, generation
codes, and their families. Weak Hierarchical Confusion Matrices were employed
to determine within-family and outside-of-family coding errors in the latter
codesets. The coding performance of GPT-3.5 was evaluated both on prompt-guided
self-generated data and real MIMIC-IV data. Clinical professionals evaluated
the clinical acceptability of the generated documents.
Results: Augmentation slightly hinders the overall performance of the models
but improves performance for the generation candidate codes and their families,
including one unseen in the baseline training data. Augmented models display
lower out-of-family error rates. GPT-3.5 can identify ICD-10 codes by the
prompted descriptions, but performs poorly on real data. Evaluators note the
correctness of generated concepts while suffering in variety, supporting
information, and narrative.
Discussion and Conclusion: GPT-3.5 alone is unsuitable for ICD-10 coding.
Augmentation positively affects generation code families but mainly benefits
codes with existing examples. Augmentation reduces out-of-family errors.
Discharge summaries generated by GPT-3.5 state prompted concepts correctly but
lack variety, and authenticity in narratives. They are unsuitable for clinical
practice. | [
-0.49781522154808044,
-0.07397875934839249,
0.6399986743927002,
0.21181553602218628,
-0.4210257828235626,
0.036150362342596054,
0.11877134442329407,
-0.5942228436470032,
0.09590118378400803,
0.3562414348125458,
-0.4711940288543701,
-0.4348716735839844,
-0.5094270706176758,
0.34244590997695923,
-0.1240878626704216,
1.3820760250091553,
-0.2875555157661438,
0.10754918307065964,
0.08195053786039352,
-0.12170373648405075,
-0.3101784288883209,
-0.8383716344833374,
-0.3634577691555023,
-0.308556467294693,
0.18429630994796753,
0.3065377473831177,
0.5531303286552429,
0.5745192170143127,
0.6578742265701294,
0.11876556277275085,
-0.10110408067703247,
0.223650261759758,
-0.29658058285713196,
-0.13208863139152527,
0.1794060468673706,
-0.029152046889066696,
-0.9083771109580994,
-0.039923038333654404,
0.46850940585136414,
0.647889256477356,
-0.14877623319625854,
0.0547410324215889,
0.09726297110319138,
0.5600512623786926,
-0.4425255060195923,
0.1757199764251709,
-0.13613489270210266,
0.12871144711971283,
0.04580423980951309,
-0.31860965490341187,
-0.2410796582698822,
-0.3689773976802826,
-0.027317119762301445,
-0.5482751727104187,
0.5713759064674377,
-0.10777680575847626,
0.7291885614395142,
-0.01996651664376259,
-0.0931672602891922,
-0.5454167127609253,
-0.713624119758606,
0.05756686255335808,
-0.7557157278060913,
-0.06516219675540924,
0.37502336502075195,
0.1405409425497055,
0.2037404626607895,
-0.9325559735298157,
-0.4820553660392761,
-0.20084622502326965,
-0.3918931782245636,
0.34166309237480164,
-0.3419698476791382,
0.3851254880428314,
0.8459308743476868,
0.8745059967041016,
-0.6362650990486145,
0.009807867929339409,
-0.66724693775177,
-0.16163420677185059,
0.5012761354446411,
0.405914306640625,
0.4632674753665924,
-0.25695106387138367,
-0.2722489833831787,
0.14259754121303558,
-0.7867106199264526,
-0.3051622211933136,
0.4320508539676666,
-0.08915861696004868,
-0.6210889220237732,
0.5868580341339111,
-0.2598852217197418,
0.3034016489982605,
0.28177016973495483,
-0.29621443152427673,
0.6291558742523193,
-0.4913690388202667,
-0.21924912929534912,
0.2308037132024765,
0.5724770426750183,
0.6333913803100586,
0.048479918390512466,
0.06614585220813751,
-0.43003201484680176,
-0.12655210494995117,
0.41190364956855774,
-0.7732608914375305,
-0.40496861934661865,
0.0919579565525055,
-0.7260775566101074,
-0.46512311697006226,
0.07243365794420242,
-0.4573959708213806,
-0.28529542684555054,
-0.1308010369539261,
0.19147583842277527,
-0.6168604493141174,
-0.03567415848374367,
-0.04472934827208519,
-0.2000972330570221,
0.037228044122457504,
0.3317341208457947,
-0.9430042505264282,
0.4361010193824768,
0.23568975925445557,
0.8184654116630554,
-0.002581201959401369,
-0.16908861696720123,
-0.3631979823112488,
0.2612106204032898,
-0.26672282814979553,
0.6911165118217468,
-0.24570348858833313,
-0.862301766872406,
-0.03454257547855377,
-0.057941216975450516,
-0.029386550188064575,
-0.6374170184135437,
0.4875594675540924,
-0.18691450357437134,
0.18469493091106415,
0.023623721674084663,
-0.42738333344459534,
0.013630143366754055,
-0.05867443233728409,
-0.7681953310966492,
0.6837997436523438,
0.8408638834953308,
-0.6000567078590393,
0.4062848389148712,
-0.5722290873527527,
-0.562431275844574,
0.23405903577804565,
-0.3125438392162323,
-0.4882526695728302,
0.1504412442445755,
0.45589643716812134,
0.29691043496131897,
-0.0893576517701149,
-0.040471095591783524,
0.1257397085428238,
-0.5211475491523743,
-0.2916746735572815,
-0.42459404468536377,
0.47309428453445435,
0.3667227327823639,
-0.20596057176589966,
-0.1664215624332428,
-0.8311492204666138,
-0.0741904079914093,
-0.0670623630285263,
-0.3546237349510193,
0.11155114322900772,
-0.43935132026672363,
-0.12869571149349213,
0.20260977745056152,
-0.10908369719982147,
-0.407087504863739,
0.5472217798233032,
-0.34640493988990784,
-0.10670407861471176,
0.430714875459671,
0.5947544574737549,
0.32977724075317383,
-0.7367872595787048,
0.9853550791740417,
0.23193944990634918,
0.1752403974533081,
-0.5290352702140808,
-0.6447868943214417,
-0.2508091926574707,
-0.11461014300584793,
0.09530811011791229,
0.35848456621170044,
-1.0648651123046875,
0.18928606808185577,
-0.40756186842918396,
-0.3077106773853302,
-0.45734086632728577,
-0.14091049134731293,
0.5197198390960693,
0.9055030941963196,
0.5539261102676392,
-0.1711152046918869,
-0.5748044848442078,
-0.9142249226570129,
0.3132670521736145,
-0.07977250963449478,
-0.11670064181089401,
0.27473780512809753,
0.4894728660583496,
-0.26673173904418945,
0.5067715644836426,
-0.5389893651008606,
-0.25110575556755066,
-0.5361847281455994,
0.27953824400901794,
0.2700592577457428,
0.6258252859115601,
0.5234383344650269,
-0.29284873604774475,
-0.4249230623245239,
0.17829327285289764,
-0.6136465072631836,
-0.059138115495443344,
-0.3254794776439667,
0.4833921194076538,
0.2849422097206116,
0.12289685755968094,
-0.30092841386795044,
0.6293495297431946,
0.3071887493133545,
-0.05682994797825813,
0.6159921288490295,
-0.7697653770446777,
0.3533322215080261,
-1.0491676330566406,
0.11398450285196304,
-0.15582971274852753,
-0.02962692268192768,
-0.6388153433799744,
-0.0514506921172142,
0.3930267095565796,
-0.1357649266719818,
-0.4912627935409546,
0.4355071783065796,
-0.461138516664505,
0.1471591740846634,
-0.21357707679271698,
-0.3100043833255768,
0.09911900013685226,
0.36805135011672974,
-0.10087206214666367,
1.0411837100982666,
0.3351918160915375,
-0.5416491031646729,
0.3414536416530609,
0.1821802258491516,
-0.24646252393722534,
0.46090081334114075,
-0.4291415810585022,
-0.01893431507050991,
-0.06544727832078934,
0.42502355575561523,
-0.5146175622940063,
-0.5421481132507324,
0.3081497550010681,
-0.41057348251342773,
0.5041244626045227,
-0.17482033371925354,
-0.45606061816215515,
-0.6019260287284851,
-0.4413760304450989,
0.5168638229370117,
0.9229989051818848,
-0.41827696561813354,
0.3787132501602173,
0.0013730676146224141,
-0.22931797802448273,
-0.197722926735878,
-0.7260768413543701,
-0.07933695614337921,
-0.08384738117456436,
-0.35600441694259644,
0.420452743768692,
0.19203786551952362,
0.009465713985264301,
-0.110565185546875,
-0.12437721341848373,
-0.07821585237979889,
-0.30828773975372314,
0.13738363981246948,
0.27064383029937744,
-0.21490228176116943,
-0.022409692406654358,
0.1763693243265152,
-0.06258472800254822,
-0.026065373793244362,
-0.08257575333118439,
0.4184121787548065,
-0.03662091866135597,
-0.5442265868186951,
-0.3479069471359253,
0.474337637424469,
0.43026652932167053,
0.08435530960559845,
0.3981042206287384,
0.7043988704681396,
-0.6246176958084106,
0.06904946267604828,
-0.6342854499816895,
0.04737374186515808,
-0.3779926598072052,
0.041059672832489014,
-0.3355572521686554,
-0.5907720327377319,
0.8179178237915039,
0.2306540459394455,
-0.3544028401374817,
0.6736758351325989,
0.41733691096305847,
-0.1546989232301712,
1.0356107950210571,
0.5322903990745544,
0.1571577787399292,
0.08017251640558243,
-0.5264863967895508,
0.11621294915676117,
-1.3074411153793335,
-0.18948213756084442,
-0.1868993192911148,
-0.03365221247076988,
-0.530276358127594,
-0.18855129182338715,
0.7491806745529175,
0.10512014478445053,
-0.11182952672243118,
-0.04462883993983269,
-0.8055427074432373,
0.44213154911994934,
0.43342381715774536,
0.3688533306121826,
0.3034355342388153,
0.06702384352684021,
-0.017061835154891014,
-0.07769559323787689,
-0.6896255016326904,
-0.5030360817909241,
1.2524218559265137,
0.26931390166282654,
0.7910163402557373,
-0.022310711443424225,
0.860349178314209,
0.3487435281276703,
0.6250232458114624,
-0.4227406680583954,
0.12940777838230133,
-0.2458837330341339,
-0.2516970932483673,
0.29497379064559937,
-0.2794133126735687,
-0.6994507312774658,
-0.1925732046365738,
0.2059141993522644,
-0.8361852765083313,
0.40572816133499146,
0.3193452060222626,
-0.8393986821174622,
0.2998502552509308,
-1.0075840950012207,
0.7146225571632385,
-0.06409603357315063,
-0.043863311409950256,
0.19216537475585938,
-0.5980880260467529,
0.7090280652046204,
-0.3395010530948639,
-0.07509732246398926,
0.2729054391384125,
-0.1877634972333908,
0.46494901180267334,
-0.8112197518348694,
0.5926763415336609,
-0.07570690661668777,
-0.20832739770412445,
0.24417230486869812,
-0.17188076674938202,
0.5441084504127502,
0.19845059514045715,
0.10562662035226822,
-0.06910227984189987,
0.09299425035715103,
-0.20181597769260406,
-0.6698324680328369,
0.6330040693283081,
-0.6143215298652649,
-0.44220617413520813,
-0.517179012298584,
-0.36155152320861816,
-0.22009147703647614,
-0.0014298808528110385,
0.6061646938323975,
0.8866240382194519,
0.272966206073761,
-0.053840719163417816,
0.6108037233352661,
-0.4315859079360962,
0.38986220955848694,
0.15266604721546173,
0.01945890113711357,
-0.6951435804367065,
1.0126869678497314,
0.22019550204277039,
0.46095582842826843,
0.1538604199886322,
-0.05175646394491196,
-0.2198314219713211,
-0.7004518508911133,
-0.6536898612976074,
0.26675087213516235,
-0.6825082302093506,
-0.3643152117729187,
-0.5961403250694275,
-0.4938269257545471,
-0.38954347372055054,
-0.31853219866752625,
0.12503139674663544,
-0.30155298113822937,
-0.26772016286849976,
-0.19530008733272552,
0.31226882338523865,
1.0477722883224487,
-0.2821511924266815,
0.4257941246032715,
-0.9596509337425232,
0.5583317875862122,
-0.10165028274059296,
0.5195541381835938,
-0.06405666470527649,
-0.4199460446834564,
-0.4477694034576416,
0.0657103955745697,
-0.3883005380630493,
-1.0419721603393555,
0.3075384497642517,
-0.1445380449295044,
0.3580566942691803,
0.2037811279296875,
-0.16893132030963898,
0.8909881114959717,
-0.44897064566612244,
1.139801025390625,
0.3195455074310303,
-0.7907896041870117,
0.6429277062416077,
-0.7257564067840576,
0.4520946145057678,
0.25441309809684753,
0.18415464460849762,
-0.2707522511482239,
-0.26854732632637024,
-1.2077621221542358,
-0.8403127789497375,
1.1165207624435425,
0.4386832118034363,
0.05276640132069588,
-0.22289349138736725,
0.5208255052566528,
0.08686936646699905,
0.15685783326625824,
-0.3685596287250519,
-0.4723942279815674,
-0.2725861966609955,
-0.25060325860977173,
0.054929014295339584,
-0.46239954233169556,
-0.0938386470079422,
-0.25959426164627075,
0.4236364960670471,
-0.14384031295776367,
0.5947044491767883,
0.42500853538513184,
0.30841973423957825,
-0.056859228760004044,
0.096694216132164,
0.9773197174072266,
0.7608647346496582,
-0.14193618297576904,
-0.009520388208329678,
0.2519787549972534,
-1.0379844903945923,
0.2021796703338623,
0.42470866441726685,
-0.19286108016967773,
0.013649800792336464,
0.41746747493743896,
0.7038006782531738,
-0.014872321859002113,
-0.435152143239975,
0.6124573945999146,
-0.1414339542388916,
-0.5127400755882263,
-0.100287526845932,
0.12424521893262863,
-0.09809868037700653,
-0.12782607972621918,
0.30456098914146423,
0.18371251225471497,
0.1942937672138214,
-0.2968388497829437,
0.3679245710372925,
0.04285050928592682,
-0.21401746571063995,
-0.2579699158668518,
0.6544058322906494,
0.016211507841944695,
0.08613559603691101,
0.6651269793510437,
-0.34932461380958557,
-0.10053594410419464,
0.7577620148658752,
0.6533463597297668,
0.8132182955741882,
-0.039050646126270294,
0.18180321156978607,
0.3912326395511627,
0.3102310001850128,
0.016383782029151917,
0.48621422052383423,
-0.12365628033876419,
-0.49571311473846436,
-0.4295394718647003,
-0.30877622961997986,
-0.304042249917984,
0.5972343683242798,
-0.9006162881851196,
0.15133962035179138,
-0.49853038787841797,
0.028150158002972603,
-0.4289046823978424,
-0.20745982229709625,
-0.5267503261566162,
0.3778587877750397,
0.2365846186876297,
0.8430033922195435,
-0.4711875021457672,
0.47557252645492554,
0.8448792099952698,
-0.9079173803329468,
-1.2181050777435303,
0.12207487970590591,
-0.11282311379909515,
-0.5900689959526062,
0.3623000979423523,
-0.11009719222784042,
0.09642624855041504,
0.12617741525173187,
-0.2352476865053177,
-0.5581701397895813,
1.179001808166504,
0.19074983894824982,
0.026472914963960648,
-0.22095179557800293,
0.04101444035768509,
0.7206204533576965,
-0.4176981449127197,
0.46500951051712036,
0.526190996170044,
0.13814759254455566,
0.0527406744658947,
-1.2255253791809082,
0.05531531572341919,
-0.4128042161464691,
0.0002625698980409652,
0.05388960614800453,
-0.42030173540115356,
0.5261200070381165,
-0.35110604763031006,
-0.21950003504753113,
0.05754389241337776,
0.12556199729442596,
0.4007965326309204,
0.33894455432891846,
-0.11132430285215378,
0.5055187344551086,
0.5299563407897949,
-0.28783145546913147,
1.5579124689102173,
-0.6075370907783508,
0.15251384675502777,
0.9112703204154968,
-0.16208280622959137,
0.1748351901769638,
0.27906128764152527,
-0.21819570660591125,
0.09953399002552032,
0.5619322061538696,
0.07570218294858932,
0.37753719091415405,
-0.013715279288589954,
-0.5894803404808044,
0.30039405822753906,
0.009308073669672012,
-0.8216992616653442,
-0.13084721565246582,
0.2853398323059082,
-0.6524121761322021,
-0.31368184089660645,
0.14996971189975739,
0.07967997342348099,
-0.239272341132164,
-0.37076160311698914,
1.0554667711257935,
0.00906809139996767,
-0.6347855925559998,
0.7538233399391174,
-0.16260923445224762,
0.22873975336551666,
-0.4782663881778717,
-0.34807536005973816,
-0.4320814311504364,
0.08072305470705032,
-0.48535051941871643,
-0.7749453186988831,
0.29789426922798157,
0.12722201645374298,
-0.32762351632118225,
-0.4819154143333435,
0.45024609565734863,
-0.10816109925508499,
-0.3981955647468567,
-0.4377571940422058,
0.5854710936546326,
0.04585224762558937,
0.2125140130519867,
-0.29357749223709106,
-0.09717715531587601,
0.3382793366909027,
0.017901809886097908,
0.34447526931762695,
0.5015648007392883,
-0.008792443200945854,
0.4462873041629791,
0.3472854197025299,
0.5453135371208191,
0.03746001049876213,
0.4557713270187378,
1.246692419052124,
-0.3408749997615814,
-0.5495756268501282,
-0.5900600552558899,
0.5139329433441162,
0.032228466123342514,
-0.4691672921180725,
0.45638003945350647,
0.8298981189727783,
0.7892085909843445,
-0.384174644947052,
1.0321651697158813,
-0.051012467592954636,
0.5638830065727234,
-0.6889922022819519,
0.562894344329834,
-0.17207498848438263,
0.43191835284233093,
-0.31107550859451294,
-0.6610239148139954,
-0.3983615040779114,
0.36676710844039917,
-0.34360820055007935,
0.2391698807477951,
0.9009624719619751,
0.5776292681694031,
-0.2440607100725174,
0.023989474400877953,
0.21200235188007355,
-0.11602494865655899,
0.4244462847709656,
0.4779924750328064,
0.740934431552887,
-0.492428719997406,
0.5049668550491333,
-0.6273592710494995,
-0.15902751684188843,
-0.0664927139878273,
-0.49165570735931396,
-0.4842085540294647,
-0.30000928044319153,
-0.30405285954475403,
-0.4459036588668823,
0.10761066526174545,
0.7526737451553345,
0.48701000213623047,
-0.5966335535049438,
0.22915588319301605,
-0.14422284066677094,
-0.07132713496685028,
-0.263011634349823,
-0.18769454956054688,
0.5568833947181702,
-0.355286180973053,
-0.4782377779483795,
0.11377101391553879,
0.3550819158554077,
0.5997750163078308,
0.04666003957390785,
-0.3094906806945801,
0.3097062110900879,
-0.7443153262138367,
0.3422735929489136,
0.22649618983268738,
-0.6167232394218445,
-0.14541243016719818,
-0.18779636919498444,
-0.1034492552280426,
0.17278185486793518,
0.9580507874488831,
-0.7624012231826782,
0.49121081829071045,
0.23152314126491547,
0.3532043695449829,
0.38267478346824646,
0.5890432596206665,
0.5038520693778992,
-0.8129879832267761,
-0.06286096572875977,
0.40089669823646545,
0.47235623002052307,
0.16476686298847198,
-0.5979740023612976,
0.44800475239753723,
0.3734091520309448,
-0.4214637577533722,
-0.7815409302711487,
0.1824476718902588,
-0.7432934045791626,
0.3410298824310303,
1.141437292098999,
-0.05008614808320999,
0.17578662931919098,
-0.40074074268341064,
-0.5274419188499451,
-0.003186563029885292,
-0.29811885952949524,
0.4673137962818146,
0.567277729511261,
-0.6997674703598022,
-0.3306508958339691,
-0.6290504336357117,
1.0054072141647339,
-0.07294054329395294,
-0.7744203209877014,
-0.19582274556159973,
0.6430834531784058,
0.04415350779891014,
0.13841910660266876,
0.9210171699523926,
-0.41512954235076904,
0.7369739413261414,
0.21528251469135284,
0.062323231250047684,
-0.35737475752830505,
0.12811027467250824,
-0.6598942279815674,
0.22736310958862305,
-0.04178537800908089,
-0.14592254161834717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13481v1 | How AI Ideas Affect the Creativity, Diversity, and Evolution of Human Ideas: Evidence From a Large, Dynamic Experiment | 2024-01-24T14:29:39 | 2024-01-24T14:29:39 | Joshua Ashkinaze, Julia Mendelsohn, Li Qiwei, Ceren Budak, Eric Gilbert | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Exposure to large language model output is rapidly increasing. How will
seeing AI-generated ideas affect human ideas? We conducted an experiment (800+
participants, 40+ countries) where participants viewed creative ideas that were
from ChatGPT or prior experimental participants and then brainstormed their own
idea. We varied the number of AI-generated examples (none, low, or high
exposure) and if the examples were labeled as 'AI' (disclosure). Our dynamic
experiment design -- ideas from prior participants in an experimental condition
are used as stimuli for future participants in the same experimental condition
-- mimics the interdependent process of cultural creation: creative ideas are
built upon prior ideas. Hence, we capture the compounding effects of having
LLMs 'in the culture loop'. We find that high AI exposure (but not low AI
exposure) did not affect the creativity of individual ideas but did increase
the average amount and rate of change of collective idea diversity. AI made
ideas different, not better. There were no main effects of disclosure. We also
found that self-reported creative people were less influenced by knowing an
idea was from AI, and that participants were more likely to knowingly adopt AI
ideas when the task was difficult. Our findings suggest that introducing AI
ideas into society may increase collective diversity but not individual
creativity. | [
-0.44769927859306335,
-0.7183759212493896,
0.4393846392631531,
0.3557211458683014,
-0.14499273896217346,
0.43806755542755127,
-0.1758003979921341,
-0.826159656047821,
0.30692058801651,
0.12708328664302826,
-0.3847493529319763,
-0.09688705205917358,
-0.7090089917182922,
-0.019137810915708542,
-0.44178488850593567,
0.8909648060798645,
0.17096945643424988,
-0.273247092962265,
-0.1406344473361969,
-0.041301194578409195,
-0.4447397291660309,
-0.4291653335094452,
-0.4462758004665375,
-0.246731698513031,
0.5847314596176147,
0.6558571457862854,
0.6258490681648254,
0.60960453748703,
0.4479283392429352,
0.4568423628807068,
-0.34457018971443176,
-0.13298656046390533,
-0.6319602131843567,
0.02687740884721279,
-0.11291190981864929,
-0.9467598795890808,
-0.04685124009847641,
0.3411947190761566,
0.7226020097732544,
0.5075643658638,
0.08067560940980911,
0.171163871884346,
0.01838596723973751,
0.617854654788971,
-0.2618500590324402,
-0.06581923365592957,
-0.5598627924919128,
0.21668635308742523,
-0.16584844887256622,
-0.05191629379987717,
0.053695447742938995,
-0.11202071607112885,
0.37466028332710266,
-0.543463408946991,
0.069632388651371,
-0.07307080179452896,
0.4648665189743042,
0.26940616965293884,
-0.2243225872516632,
-0.5174985527992249,
-0.9775038957595825,
0.6024178266525269,
-0.45679032802581787,
-0.32688236236572266,
-0.13255025446414948,
-0.03507533296942711,
-0.3886440098285675,
-0.6065709590911865,
-0.9392598271369934,
-0.24484482407569885,
0.33143705129623413,
0.23823794722557068,
-0.12237930297851562,
-0.2443086802959442,
0.39599478244781494,
0.28519338369369507,
-0.4004831612110138,
0.2310107797384262,
-0.4183890223503113,
0.05005911365151405,
0.8810624480247498,
0.14729662239551544,
0.6661363244056702,
0.2735787034034729,
-0.16838011145591736,
-0.14841331541538239,
-0.5826188921928406,
0.24704837799072266,
0.48313891887664795,
-0.2415044903755188,
-0.22036613523960114,
0.6666415333747864,
-0.19829034805297852,
-0.05552243813872337,
-0.10324353724718094,
-0.005300707649439573,
0.3446126878261566,
-0.5955648422241211,
0.027703916653990746,
-0.16274996101856232,
0.7120932936668396,
0.23958705365657806,
0.28304511308670044,
-0.1403292864561081,
-0.017463382333517075,
0.20191055536270142,
-0.1430969387292862,
-0.8109864592552185,
-0.023163484409451485,
-0.2583761215209961,
-0.3975429832935333,
-0.4184512197971344,
0.4704422652721405,
-0.34468868374824524,
-0.8283969759941101,
-0.05212511494755745,
0.3220515549182892,
0.08522509783506393,
-0.31628409028053284,
0.05538113787770271,
-0.8284134268760681,
0.1022677794098854,
0.37650689482688904,
-0.7445864081382751,
-0.012311621569097042,
0.7572876811027527,
0.5886008143424988,
-0.28653258085250854,
-0.49156224727630615,
0.1319570690393448,
-0.028349310159683228,
-0.5884988903999329,
0.9184238910675049,
-0.4366402328014374,
-0.5453892946243286,
-0.5604804754257202,
-0.3119119107723236,
0.2302892953157425,
-0.8051710724830627,
0.06873571872711182,
-0.1890067756175995,
0.3420567512512207,
-0.16986671090126038,
-0.36071673035621643,
0.14710655808448792,
-0.3841303586959839,
-0.4394802749156952,
0.20609508454799652,
-0.2814902067184448,
-0.6005385518074036,
0.5182556509971619,
-1.052418828010559,
-0.6508244872093201,
0.39582422375679016,
-0.8031759858131409,
-0.20053544640541077,
0.33883458375930786,
-0.07020328938961029,
-0.2641763687133789,
-0.20828597247600555,
0.2848973572254181,
-0.21341970562934875,
-0.5427120327949524,
0.848982036113739,
-0.660025417804718,
0.9664254188537598,
0.440044641494751,
-0.7889089584350586,
0.22641748189926147,
-0.2999725341796875,
-0.3141225576400757,
0.35270607471466064,
-0.30101507902145386,
-0.15835484862327576,
-0.05157249793410301,
-0.26014867424964905,
0.34604036808013916,
-0.15370596945285797,
-0.5197311639785767,
0.46318259835243225,
-0.4059295654296875,
0.5127358436584473,
0.9463136792182922,
0.4452270567417145,
0.476386696100235,
-0.7711382508277893,
0.6676744222640991,
0.11430882662534714,
0.061857979744672775,
-0.12673057615756989,
-0.9647833704948425,
-0.6382895112037659,
-0.1333611011505127,
-0.11481089144945145,
0.5317052006721497,
-0.4627423584461212,
0.1864997297525406,
0.05239591747522354,
-0.6566874980926514,
-0.6440616846084595,
0.18181680142879486,
-0.07761994749307632,
0.16274771094322205,
-0.4170594811439514,
-0.435815691947937,
-0.06594063341617584,
-1.0375677347183228,
-0.5734508633613586,
-0.1787073016166687,
-0.4680563509464264,
0.594926655292511,
0.6352678537368774,
-0.35873332619667053,
0.8847516179084778,
-0.6074029803276062,
-0.18962788581848145,
-0.30774036049842834,
0.797473669052124,
0.2774006128311157,
0.5035293102264404,
0.4769895374774933,
-0.829521119594574,
-0.3793773055076599,
-0.37075862288475037,
-0.5914928317070007,
-0.09645257145166397,
-0.4120487868785858,
-0.29052504897117615,
0.12586644291877747,
0.1501312255859375,
-0.6621196269989014,
0.7054159641265869,
0.11153319478034973,
-0.3396552801132202,
0.3107914626598358,
-0.007542560808360577,
0.13255393505096436,
-1.1318877935409546,
-0.11309759318828583,
-0.24612616002559662,
0.5116222500801086,
-0.23276804387569427,
-0.24855349957942963,
-0.30772215127944946,
-0.3225872814655304,
-0.5497663021087646,
0.6083678603172302,
-0.3106476664543152,
0.04005834087729454,
-0.4719003736972809,
0.07431010901927948,
-0.01689988747239113,
0.12470193952322006,
-0.0388106144964695,
0.8784051537513733,
0.4868694841861725,
-0.34116822481155396,
0.4293529689311981,
0.09409435093402863,
-0.7991782426834106,
0.03067128360271454,
-0.46783459186553955,
0.48126420378685,
-0.4293280839920044,
0.49919581413269043,
-0.9357606172561646,
-0.25419825315475464,
0.10970926284790039,
-0.6335470080375671,
-0.3035804331302643,
0.5651492476463318,
-0.4343796968460083,
-0.4628880023956299,
-0.37480223178863525,
0.346529483795166,
0.5192553997039795,
-0.25832444429397583,
0.34440353512763977,
0.37712979316711426,
-0.3819446563720703,
-0.41190317273139954,
-1.063944935798645,
0.41116708517074585,
-0.5541889667510986,
-0.8740615844726562,
0.39740586280822754,
-0.6264154314994812,
-0.7790738940238953,
0.16412940621376038,
0.09989943355321884,
0.18867677450180054,
0.637320876121521,
0.242970272898674,
-0.1447405368089676,
-0.19160252809524536,
0.2058667689561844,
-0.24235382676124573,
0.21828924119472504,
0.20572900772094727,
0.07217411696910858,
0.42535898089408875,
-0.23700374364852905,
-0.37395912408828735,
-0.7456976175308228,
0.5460171103477478,
0.6632499694824219,
-0.13780827820301056,
0.6989955902099609,
0.5592370629310608,
-0.11193492263555527,
-0.4764070212841034,
-0.28858596086502075,
-0.33972078561782837,
-0.5975536108016968,
0.5974209308624268,
-0.017060911282896996,
-0.7260769009590149,
0.5458053350448608,
0.053627315908670425,
0.14775288105010986,
0.3892673850059509,
0.7177866101264954,
-0.44351670145988464,
0.8682034015655518,
0.7411640286445618,
-0.06479670107364655,
0.9874784350395203,
-0.4016592502593994,
0.3259609341621399,
-0.6820089221000671,
0.027663182467222214,
-0.35291123390197754,
-0.772706151008606,
-0.777800977230072,
-0.28224027156829834,
0.28394296765327454,
-0.04598267003893852,
-0.13236097991466522,
-0.4636402130126953,
-0.28663164377212524,
0.5856124758720398,
0.9903964400291443,
-0.03206298500299454,
0.30674079060554504,
-0.2042584866285324,
0.3211713433265686,
0.24068719148635864,
-0.7282703518867493,
-0.25623899698257446,
1.1129581928253174,
0.2019738405942917,
0.927627444267273,
0.2916630208492279,
0.8230756521224976,
0.716482937335968,
0.5906290411949158,
-0.6919617056846619,
0.37615615129470825,
0.23165419697761536,
-0.5669799447059631,
-0.32597067952156067,
-0.21223731338977814,
-0.8342927694320679,
-0.1743393987417221,
-0.3505331873893738,
-0.7176621556282043,
0.2422904670238495,
-0.023275360465049744,
-0.3274180591106415,
0.1897692233324051,
-0.8189293146133423,
0.29020532965660095,
-0.45929470658302307,
-0.3360712230205536,
-0.5491512417793274,
-0.6024637222290039,
0.3426293730735779,
-0.46157488226890564,
0.29526931047439575,
-0.062101904302835464,
0.29831060767173767,
0.902730405330658,
0.08836420625448227,
0.9780559539794922,
0.13032592833042145,
-0.09134940803050995,
0.823486328125,
-0.16970112919807434,
0.42979052662849426,
0.2841792106628418,
0.02545941434800625,
-0.024851525202393532,
-0.7180132865905762,
-0.23483321070671082,
-0.6724947690963745,
0.5364370942115784,
-1.034057378768921,
-1.2744697332382202,
-0.25399261713027954,
-1.1836766004562378,
0.36305615305900574,
-0.04159999266266823,
0.36803385615348816,
0.08997661620378494,
-0.06617420166730881,
0.4301743805408478,
0.15051323175430298,
-0.6270277500152588,
0.4669061005115509,
0.2737782597541809,
0.022079283371567726,
-0.19702725112438202,
0.7027501463890076,
0.34364062547683716,
0.49280422925949097,
-0.07885228842496872,
0.5432800650596619,
0.11027556657791138,
-0.35580798983573914,
-0.3285640776157379,
0.2321895956993103,
-0.6588493585586548,
0.3557805120944977,
-0.2167845368385315,
-0.06120705604553223,
-0.6676632165908813,
-0.11342218518257141,
-0.13692207634449005,
-0.5056782960891724,
-0.25006797909736633,
0.018107427284121513,
0.08428582549095154,
0.9719229936599731,
-0.26923868060112,
0.07561977952718735,
-0.342113196849823,
0.1570006012916565,
0.46501433849334717,
0.19317743182182312,
0.24946041405200958,
-0.3912164270877838,
-0.3256996273994446,
0.38613009452819824,
-0.5876803398132324,
-0.5873672366142273,
0.07989729195833206,
0.0963851734995842,
0.7073628902435303,
0.740139901638031,
0.10022418946027756,
0.43054434657096863,
-0.18834996223449707,
0.9399102330207825,
-0.08079308271408081,
-0.5764049291610718,
0.3296162784099579,
-0.24345411360263824,
0.6587268710136414,
0.13136693835258484,
-0.08668989688158035,
-0.7586255073547363,
-0.8247659206390381,
-0.7451029419898987,
-0.6504594683647156,
0.3947669565677643,
0.25995075702667236,
0.46904245018959045,
-0.008844263851642609,
0.07373514026403427,
0.08944021910429001,
0.3013903796672821,
-0.8805488348007202,
-0.2497226893901825,
0.10972665250301361,
0.14736191928386688,
0.10902979969978333,
0.12305931746959686,
-0.1799330860376358,
-0.42940062284469604,
0.299988716840744,
0.30308249592781067,
0.6141098737716675,
0.14836597442626953,
0.15050598978996277,
-0.42981162667274475,
0.3027472198009491,
0.8794593811035156,
0.8615415096282959,
0.06272262334823608,
0.06995148956775665,
0.00252139731310308,
-0.3056785464286804,
0.1272207647562027,
-0.22966724634170532,
-0.3089093863964081,
-0.4297051727771759,
0.48682504892349243,
0.8432334661483765,
-0.7143257856369019,
-0.8356779217720032,
0.18724317848682404,
-0.3346765637397766,
-0.13171948492527008,
-0.5221863985061646,
0.636871874332428,
0.3181019425392151,
0.6536653637886047,
0.5384007096290588,
0.6093934178352356,
-0.05011725053191185,
-1.1278337240219116,
0.13794611394405365,
0.4670199155807495,
0.21254508197307587,
-0.4666520357131958,
0.8318671584129333,
0.1735938936471939,
-0.9397778511047363,
0.7248818874359131,
-0.12948553264141083,
-0.41295647621154785,
1.2384109497070312,
0.8966447710990906,
0.7650941610336304,
-0.07639429718255997,
-0.005764597095549107,
-0.2605704665184021,
0.26979634165763855,
0.4140474796295166,
0.06882352381944656,
-0.045672014355659485,
-0.9483861327171326,
-0.2968534529209137,
-0.14686641097068787,
-0.2794228792190552,
0.31347179412841797,
-0.05373750999569893,
0.15135546028614044,
-0.0727500393986702,
-0.11149553954601288,
0.00974007323384285,
-0.23175501823425293,
-0.8536846041679382,
-0.1289716362953186,
0.5067451000213623,
0.7340092062950134,
-0.9964654445648193,
0.7303890585899353,
0.6241514682769775,
-0.4650404453277588,
-0.5957131385803223,
0.43555518984794617,
0.1071993038058281,
-0.625287652015686,
0.6553900837898254,
0.22434702515602112,
-0.12742510437965393,
0.07239467650651932,
-0.6492335796356201,
-1.2483162879943848,
1.0912479162216187,
0.12689805030822754,
-0.289775013923645,
0.12155097723007202,
0.28311070799827576,
0.6911808848381042,
-0.6522995233535767,
-0.09870980679988861,
0.37461143732070923,
0.5366537570953369,
0.1909860521554947,
-0.7239350080490112,
-0.36985042691230774,
-0.5425654053688049,
-0.25459524989128113,
-0.18856334686279297,
-0.6015564203262329,
0.8636150360107422,
-0.8849793672561646,
-0.3919040858745575,
0.17838741838932037,
0.6846798062324524,
0.22143994271755219,
0.39828944206237793,
0.4458369314670563,
0.22743932902812958,
0.7298038601875305,
0.49934035539627075,
1.139603614807129,
-0.07571268081665039,
-0.1988588273525238,
0.808804452419281,
-0.2580789625644684,
0.5227892398834229,
0.4228324592113495,
0.15579377114772797,
0.3670179545879364,
0.38671427965164185,
-0.11663372069597244,
0.5719461441040039,
0.5698334574699402,
-0.24342948198318481,
0.4352676272392273,
-0.5026383996009827,
-0.3601028025150299,
0.526394248008728,
0.35723647475242615,
-0.46971747279167175,
0.38005706667900085,
0.3844028413295746,
0.1287975162267685,
-0.07132725417613983,
0.028822951018810272,
0.7992145419120789,
0.1281934231519699,
-0.7376802563667297,
0.34969767928123474,
-0.29461124539375305,
0.7718936800956726,
-0.15671253204345703,
-0.02958408184349537,
-0.47194865345954895,
0.13574497401714325,
0.01264492329210043,
-0.8984125852584839,
0.21631312370300293,
-0.05010698735713959,
0.06452285498380661,
-0.133991539478302,
0.49129223823547363,
-0.2575051486492157,
-0.4251128137111664,
0.03908972814679146,
0.714702844619751,
0.265689492225647,
0.04880264773964882,
-0.34348568320274353,
-0.1534505933523178,
0.12522341310977936,
-0.35338667035102844,
0.17563830316066742,
0.6682683229446411,
-0.230399027466774,
0.5900532007217407,
0.5214064121246338,
0.20495833456516266,
-0.07513349503278732,
-0.0332302451133728,
0.9999546408653259,
-0.8455431461334229,
-0.6121945977210999,
-0.9038954377174377,
0.40230849385261536,
-0.15790638327598572,
-0.49078673124313354,
0.4655705988407135,
0.41757431626319885,
0.7640335559844971,
-0.047504592686891556,
1.086374044418335,
-0.0428553931415081,
0.06709767878055573,
0.019796032458543777,
1.0416145324707031,
-0.42701318860054016,
0.4310382604598999,
-0.40745824575424194,
-0.9094928503036499,
-0.16012130677700043,
0.3297007083892822,
-0.3653382360935211,
-0.06818011403083801,
0.5698408484458923,
0.5153990387916565,
0.34531259536743164,
-0.12399905920028687,
0.026943551376461983,
0.5856267213821411,
0.6895549893379211,
0.18154969811439514,
1.253529667854309,
0.45383942127227783,
0.24882833659648895,
-0.39662182331085205,
-0.5462035536766052,
0.031593047082424164,
-0.7535463571548462,
-0.5743222236633301,
-0.4583342969417572,
-0.21805261075496674,
0.1958586573600769,
-0.19573161005973816,
1.011786699295044,
0.20447950065135956,
-0.3493747115135193,
-0.32762637734413147,
-0.13600987195968628,
0.15560734272003174,
-0.12231892347335815,
-0.2807585597038269,
0.356023371219635,
0.08132604509592056,
-0.6939438581466675,
0.4034142792224884,
0.1602269560098648,
0.20807331800460815,
-0.301780641078949,
0.1279902160167694,
-0.05878182128071785,
0.3241267800331116,
0.5688709616661072,
0.053720586001873016,
-0.7057873010635376,
-0.4316735863685608,
0.019376259297132492,
-0.06511730700731277,
0.18971550464630127,
0.6620526313781738,
-0.7202017307281494,
0.44771742820739746,
0.5376418828964233,
0.5288136601448059,
0.21985934674739838,
0.20397257804870605,
0.7338235974311829,
-0.339211642742157,
0.5928501486778259,
0.5060729384422302,
0.23218519985675812,
-0.07730460166931152,
-0.4924886226654053,
0.2377399355173111,
0.48926839232444763,
-0.6117784976959229,
-0.5343307852745056,
0.5227542519569397,
-0.4715547263622284,
-0.6392214894294739,
0.8835301995277405,
0.12282980233430862,
-0.325668603181839,
0.12962818145751953,
-0.3813353180885315,
0.1921236664056778,
-0.5271416902542114,
1.4563909769058228,
0.7547879219055176,
-0.7427473664283752,
0.06794525682926178,
-0.6149301528930664,
0.35443124175071716,
0.4485229551792145,
-0.8829951882362366,
-0.1382966935634613,
0.3267960846424103,
0.1262751668691635,
0.1857396811246872,
0.6012567281723022,
0.13942566514015198,
0.2977339029312134,
0.021544579416513443,
0.15828482806682587,
0.02708548866212368,
-0.31393882632255554,
0.019355572760105133,
-0.08238649368286133,
0.3912402391433716,
-0.08051566034555435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13478v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13478v2 | SciMMIR: Benchmarking Scientific Multi-modal Information Retrieval | 2024-01-24T14:23:12 | 2024-06-11T10:18:08 | Siwei Wu, Yizhi Li, Kang Zhu, Ge Zhang, Yiming Liang, Kaijing Ma, Chenghao Xiao, Haoran Zhang, Bohao Yang, Wenhu Chen, Wenhao Huang, Noura Al Moubayed, Jie Fu, Chenghua Lin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | Multi-modal information retrieval (MMIR) is a rapidly evolving field, where
significant progress, particularly in image-text pairing, has been made through
advanced representation learning and cross-modality alignment research.
However, current benchmarks for evaluating MMIR performance in image-text
pairing within the scientific domain show a notable gap, where chart and table
images described in scholarly language usually do not play a significant role.
To bridge this gap, we develop a specialised scientific MMIR (SciMMIR)
benchmark by leveraging open-access paper collections to extract data relevant
to the scientific domain. This benchmark comprises 530K meticulously curated
image-text pairs, extracted from figures and tables with detailed captions in
scientific documents. We further annotate the image-text pairs with two-level
subset-subcategory hierarchy annotations to facilitate a more comprehensive
evaluation of the baselines. We conducted zero-shot and fine-tuning evaluations
on prominent multi-modal image-captioning and visual language models, such as
CLIP and BLIP. Our analysis offers critical insights for MMIR in the scientific
domain, including the impact of pre-training and fine-tuning settings and the
influence of the visual and textual encoders. All our data and checkpoints are
publicly available at https://github.com/Wusiwei0410/SciMMIR. | [
-0.13510467112064362,
-0.24265365302562714,
0.2912905812263489,
0.12728410959243774,
-0.3894520103931427,
0.3605802357196808,
-0.015228300355374813,
-0.4952090382575989,
0.14159278571605682,
0.11385296285152435,
-0.27474692463874817,
-0.18799227476119995,
-0.5842178463935852,
0.5388666391372681,
0.0913843885064125,
0.7056156396865845,
0.013379259966313839,
0.5178189277648926,
-0.7294877767562866,
-0.5336335301399231,
-0.16627615690231323,
-0.30784836411476135,
0.003463996108621359,
-0.053273677825927734,
0.7626801133155823,
0.21961988508701324,
0.39131951332092285,
0.6491724252700806,
1.3272076845169067,
0.23575440049171448,
0.1083231046795845,
0.4594461917877197,
-0.5210549235343933,
0.19829410314559937,
-0.040344927459955215,
-0.068461574614048,
-0.2229469269514084,
0.13878902792930603,
0.9436233639717102,
0.4394737184047699,
0.0681862086057663,
0.2026657611131668,
-0.28399932384490967,
0.5986377596855164,
-0.9055947065353394,
0.5308618545532227,
-0.4959055185317993,
0.1172427088022232,
-0.4937739074230194,
-0.7381474375724792,
-0.4591883718967438,
-0.09522180259227753,
0.07114715874195099,
-0.8233233094215393,
0.22408367693424225,
0.2993159890174866,
0.8033967614173889,
0.30149707198143005,
-0.48256391286849976,
-0.0925828069448471,
-0.3331907093524933,
0.751243531703949,
-0.29085037112236023,
0.7639759182929993,
0.2831130027770996,
0.46992674469947815,
0.011135909706354141,
-0.7191413044929504,
-0.5142835974693298,
-0.4422987997531891,
-0.2658388912677765,
0.42545321583747864,
-0.26229745149612427,
-0.2585713565349579,
0.32041114568710327,
0.05251084268093109,
-0.7047556042671204,
-0.33619818091392517,
-0.9332093000411987,
-0.18899883329868317,
0.2397421896457672,
-0.030666174367070198,
-0.08261603862047195,
-0.3470742404460907,
-0.44978591799736023,
-0.5208711624145508,
-0.584937334060669,
-0.02352423034608364,
0.03558731824159622,
0.1494484841823578,
0.12295149266719818,
0.9833441972732544,
-0.23727622628211975,
0.5058330297470093,
-0.13590878248214722,
-0.2567785084247589,
0.5364696383476257,
-0.6744213104248047,
-0.05927206948399544,
-0.05807797238230705,
1.034680962562561,
0.6143684983253479,
-0.23843994736671448,
-0.15270143747329712,
0.021021634340286255,
0.033923860639333725,
0.08229972422122955,
-1.1209825277328491,
-0.07434158027172089,
-0.243474081158638,
-0.3667413592338562,
-0.09702657908201218,
0.2831973731517792,
-0.7494784593582153,
-0.26022598147392273,
-0.13569548726081848,
0.5908594727516174,
-0.5362045168876648,
0.02690620720386505,
-0.14597326517105103,
-0.4081377685070038,
-0.06268370896577835,
0.0908515527844429,
-0.5258834958076477,
0.015426195226609707,
0.5498258471488953,
1.1818933486938477,
-0.0007241397979669273,
-0.29492253065109253,
-0.7037262916564941,
0.5334481000900269,
-0.15636515617370605,
0.8175067901611328,
-0.8430778980255127,
-0.48788249492645264,
-0.5314210653305054,
0.047222696244716644,
-0.3976026177406311,
-0.32831838726997375,
0.5962714552879333,
-0.5982834100723267,
0.28777775168418884,
-0.36593571305274963,
-0.08869429677724838,
-0.14286302030086517,
0.19064341485500336,
-0.7702603340148926,
0.8653132319450378,
-0.22038182616233826,
-0.9867790937423706,
0.6660280227661133,
-0.7540623545646667,
-0.24128353595733643,
0.2477286458015442,
-0.4648514688014984,
-0.3145783245563507,
-0.04612796753644943,
0.13736492395401,
0.358634889125824,
-0.5584895014762878,
0.2214869260787964,
-0.44515514373779297,
-0.22994296252727509,
0.31724679470062256,
-0.2188231199979782,
-0.09718397259712219,
0.26823222637176514,
0.04021882265806198,
0.15285947918891907,
-0.7977208495140076,
-0.07558730244636536,
-0.12090366333723068,
0.03240760415792465,
-0.6740128397941589,
0.12525418400764465,
0.29485711455345154,
0.38002151250839233,
0.12627962231636047,
-0.913407564163208,
0.17264005541801453,
0.10990245640277863,
0.7350274324417114,
0.31757214665412903,
-0.17443247139453888,
0.15374977886676788,
-0.3928064703941345,
0.14542020857334137,
0.09878785163164139,
0.12029869854450226,
-0.46347716450691223,
-0.3952586054801941,
-0.21336765587329865,
-0.8175997734069824,
0.3792671263217926,
0.3236234188079834,
-0.7343798279762268,
-0.10166528820991516,
-0.5034350156784058,
-0.5481427311897278,
-0.9204049110412598,
-0.05957513302564621,
0.5670391321182251,
0.7827736735343933,
0.5623171925544739,
-0.7034608721733093,
-0.3837474286556244,
-0.9273862838745117,
0.1768474578857422,
-0.06124758720397949,
0.005124041344970465,
0.5884957909584045,
0.6951087713241577,
-0.24761159718036652,
0.7719422578811646,
-0.3257008492946625,
-0.39283207058906555,
0.5123891830444336,
0.519603967666626,
-0.006415406707674265,
0.39770928025245667,
0.34313422441482544,
-0.9853975772857666,
-0.32167086005210876,
0.25139564275741577,
-0.8403156399726868,
0.1089586541056633,
0.1131276860833168,
-0.013773486018180847,
0.08732274919748306,
0.4857345521450043,
-0.5796875953674316,
0.11467885971069336,
0.3497505784034729,
-0.2649979293346405,
0.48226243257522583,
-0.37781867384910583,
0.8139846920967102,
-0.8858338594436646,
0.7284677624702454,
0.16668634116649628,
0.09900283813476562,
-0.3041543960571289,
0.06044190749526024,
0.5165814161300659,
0.004899412393569946,
-0.28397417068481445,
0.3344566822052002,
-0.5236529111862183,
-0.03977407142519951,
0.09347273409366608,
-0.012752268463373184,
0.23674550652503967,
-0.031211044639348984,
0.037605803459882736,
1.0897797346115112,
0.387321799993515,
-0.11895901709794998,
-0.2063644975423813,
0.3109663724899292,
-0.3205808997154236,
0.7898585200309753,
-0.9537032246589661,
-0.019780393689870834,
-0.2789962887763977,
0.18196432292461395,
-0.8312325477600098,
-0.1531611829996109,
0.17615699768066406,
-0.31363245844841003,
0.37451043725013733,
-0.166617751121521,
-0.6524588465690613,
-0.20905376970767975,
-0.4879257380962372,
0.6379650831222534,
0.01865399070084095,
-0.26985472440719604,
0.48972129821777344,
0.10985884815454483,
-0.11513742059469223,
-0.9360383749008179,
-0.35912472009658813,
0.263738751411438,
0.06580410897731781,
-0.5922427773475647,
0.518494725227356,
-0.33864444494247437,
-0.13439351320266724,
0.014808137901127338,
-0.2866324186325073,
0.06802431493997574,
-0.3651391267776489,
0.5097617506980896,
0.3464943766593933,
-0.3227868974208832,
-0.18529683351516724,
0.0014361337525770068,
-0.13984966278076172,
-0.14138823747634888,
0.21203948557376862,
0.28947770595550537,
-0.2124619334936142,
-0.43216440081596375,
-0.1591181457042694,
0.3842293322086334,
0.9270344972610474,
-0.5367387533187866,
0.49136242270469666,
0.62879878282547,
-0.10873420536518097,
0.5932255983352661,
-0.7144356369972229,
-0.1671862155199051,
-0.4478434920310974,
0.30439355969429016,
-0.5510281324386597,
-0.831068217754364,
0.14319513738155365,
0.10816904902458191,
-0.105779267847538,
0.3363187909126282,
0.2654549479484558,
-0.21789073944091797,
1.0096360445022583,
0.6204327940940857,
0.011734718456864357,
0.13770471513271332,
-0.1291598528623581,
-0.14481021463871002,
-0.8234879374504089,
-0.7964027523994446,
-0.5858786702156067,
-0.010000624693930149,
-0.3800957202911377,
-0.9155853390693665,
0.5822111368179321,
0.11813220381736755,
-0.04625983536243439,
0.164072647690773,
-0.5200580954551697,
0.5011981129646301,
0.6177676320075989,
0.0898476168513298,
0.5369030833244324,
0.1079370528459549,
-0.48045769333839417,
-0.36676037311553955,
-0.4542262554168701,
-0.5144640803337097,
0.9212796688079834,
0.025885727256536484,
0.7101036310195923,
0.0035900126677006483,
0.3021317720413208,
0.2026234269142151,
0.18799296021461487,
-0.6352649331092834,
0.35407376289367676,
-0.09879551082849503,
-0.3003442883491516,
0.16291815042495728,
-0.5576736330986023,
-0.864285409450531,
0.5507401823997498,
-0.4634079933166504,
-0.15080773830413818,
0.32503369450569153,
-0.17390184104442596,
0.04630210995674133,
0.02944732829928398,
-0.6365004181861877,
0.7738870978355408,
-0.35598018765449524,
-0.48182734847068787,
-0.49221867322921753,
-0.9611201882362366,
0.2330220639705658,
-0.2500365674495697,
0.2904479205608368,
-0.1713293045759201,
-0.23089967668056488,
0.7605116963386536,
0.09811918437480927,
0.5072871446609497,
0.09877202659845352,
0.605812132358551,
-0.40164485573768616,
0.1377560943365097,
-0.17218640446662903,
-0.08493262529373169,
-0.1536904126405716,
0.4430796504020691,
0.5603200197219849,
-0.29372864961624146,
-0.180349200963974,
0.742450475692749,
-0.7811833620071411,
-0.08263805508613586,
-0.8630208969116211,
-0.7679332494735718,
0.011254155077040195,
0.44348058104515076,
-0.018134474754333496,
0.4232041835784912,
-0.29110148549079895,
0.5323153734207153,
0.4959069490432739,
0.10296336561441422,
0.5069164037704468,
0.8838318586349487,
0.15685045719146729,
-0.8766554594039917,
0.8266384601593018,
0.08828422427177429,
-0.05918414890766144,
0.6918337941169739,
0.009906996972858906,
-0.251345694065094,
-0.3519420325756073,
-0.5605114102363586,
0.4859243929386139,
-0.40210190415382385,
-0.47141891717910767,
-0.7716875672340393,
0.057142212986946106,
-0.3213824927806854,
-0.019697507843375206,
-0.09387076646089554,
-0.4255741238594055,
-0.306844025850296,
0.2578924894332886,
0.4942367970943451,
0.6044148802757263,
-0.2749194800853729,
-0.08568146824836731,
-0.7686262726783752,
0.2772674262523651,
-0.10825885087251663,
0.334341436624527,
-0.26659366488456726,
-0.2744779884815216,
-0.15224133431911469,
-0.20417311787605286,
-0.3075280487537384,
-0.5565087199211121,
0.4284553825855255,
0.6209715008735657,
0.6143692135810852,
0.5620801448822021,
-0.13802102208137512,
0.9528467655181885,
-0.8321610689163208,
0.45178958773612976,
0.49674683809280396,
-0.4901743531227112,
0.5279929041862488,
-0.21496069431304932,
0.13179630041122437,
0.7196608781814575,
0.7945306897163391,
-0.5360007286071777,
-0.1567753106355667,
-0.16786405444145203,
-0.7399090528488159,
0.4256322681903839,
-0.043059106916189194,
-0.29142192006111145,
0.014125201851129532,
0.04324641823768616,
0.3148074150085449,
0.36858004331588745,
-0.45264214277267456,
0.0745965987443924,
-0.42946547269821167,
-0.10744321346282959,
-0.3205694556236267,
0.004272432532161474,
-0.5544218420982361,
-0.3754105269908905,
0.3196961283683777,
-0.38557085394859314,
0.24129098653793335,
0.3877294063568115,
-0.32662615180015564,
-0.39870190620422363,
0.1699070930480957,
0.7552666664123535,
0.7529555559158325,
-0.5297276973724365,
0.28992611169815063,
-0.3659074306488037,
-0.7501201629638672,
-0.1790640652179718,
0.6692100167274475,
-0.1789190024137497,
-0.09798084944486618,
0.19923067092895508,
0.5265517234802246,
0.3157684803009033,
-0.9479129910469055,
0.43796801567077637,
-0.0960814505815506,
-0.3211606442928314,
0.228398397564888,
-0.22253747284412384,
-0.14430876076221466,
0.4194084107875824,
0.8164594173431396,
0.34819310903549194,
0.3027264177799225,
-0.44708967208862305,
0.40685757994651794,
0.7545081377029419,
-0.42328399419784546,
-0.4859679043292999,
0.8111906051635742,
-0.21006351709365845,
0.1296379417181015,
0.2983233630657196,
0.04180573672056198,
-0.16552041471004486,
0.19755135476589203,
0.43596190214157104,
0.2423146367073059,
0.23144549131393433,
0.42002958059310913,
0.38528305292129517,
0.3820011615753174,
0.014420181512832642,
0.343620628118515,
-0.14857551455497742,
-0.24475538730621338,
-0.43853259086608887,
-0.5094809532165527,
-0.7971404194831848,
-0.33165740966796875,
-0.60643070936203,
0.1848612129688263,
-0.3111327886581421,
-0.11888556182384491,
0.4403711259365082,
0.11392832547426224,
-0.547519326210022,
-0.16098220646381378,
-0.01560917403548956,
0.892632246017456,
-0.7329699397087097,
0.7007245421409607,
0.7275221347808838,
-0.798647940158844,
-0.2759307324886322,
-0.5021926760673523,
0.048101190477609634,
-0.6127938628196716,
0.8251796960830688,
0.3501361310482025,
-0.310242623090744,
-0.23659348487854004,
-0.5164507627487183,
-0.8775040507316589,
1.5107089281082153,
0.16464863717556,
-0.5806269645690918,
0.2913239300251007,
0.07822295278310776,
0.665008008480072,
-0.3132847249507904,
0.7740745544433594,
0.0780106633901596,
0.5401925444602966,
0.5389494299888611,
-0.9944946765899658,
0.08450167626142502,
-0.6178461909294128,
-0.28608202934265137,
0.2852407693862915,
-0.8444876670837402,
0.6597366333007812,
-0.1795748770236969,
-0.12017618119716644,
0.15584774315357208,
0.5919823050498962,
0.4316880702972412,
0.7954418659210205,
0.1799769401550293,
0.5118483304977417,
0.708560049533844,
-0.18167373538017273,
0.6433007121086121,
-0.39546239376068115,
0.014540821313858032,
0.6930469274520874,
-0.6046576499938965,
1.1620861291885376,
0.928253710269928,
0.16206760704517365,
0.29966774582862854,
0.4811491072177887,
-0.5059840679168701,
0.9207190871238708,
-0.2565805912017822,
-0.11363101005554199,
0.16712792217731476,
-0.4922698140144348,
-0.6871821284294128,
0.21230970323085785,
0.30014893412590027,
-0.2192387580871582,
-0.10185934603214264,
0.13921643793582916,
-0.17932458221912384,
-0.18599280714988708,
-0.058151181787252426,
0.6504762172698975,
-0.12969502806663513,
-0.23092418909072876,
0.28729352355003357,
-0.10642735660076141,
0.9118872284889221,
-0.7422777414321899,
-0.0897272527217865,
-0.025992972776293755,
-0.04778365045785904,
-0.17791007459163666,
-0.5409168004989624,
-0.05982200801372528,
-0.23180140554904938,
-0.35261595249176025,
-0.0773082748055458,
0.5317056179046631,
-0.4100393056869507,
-0.5026527047157288,
0.1518733650445938,
0.5656731128692627,
0.08503121137619019,
0.38157927989959717,
-0.6265424489974976,
0.02789176069200039,
-0.3988003134727478,
0.0409938283264637,
0.436996191740036,
0.34817036986351013,
-0.056267157196998596,
0.5356971621513367,
0.928667426109314,
-0.008368530310690403,
0.04365602880716324,
-0.01799418404698372,
1.044580101966858,
-0.630814254283905,
0.08105312287807465,
-0.4605758488178253,
0.377407044172287,
-0.17181560397148132,
-0.4547642171382904,
0.8419173359870911,
1.1058989763259888,
0.7302219867706299,
-0.12068241834640503,
0.37136295437812805,
-0.2066478580236435,
0.21932648122310638,
-0.23942139744758606,
0.8667833805084229,
-0.6197130680084229,
-0.11955015361309052,
-0.40511390566825867,
-0.6118369102478027,
-0.6423277854919434,
0.541293203830719,
-0.1290339082479477,
-0.2859749495983124,
0.7308682799339294,
1.1137046813964844,
-0.44387656450271606,
-0.03663511201739311,
0.20266009867191315,
0.051887836307287216,
0.15143166482448578,
0.020093198865652084,
0.8605278730392456,
-0.39957690238952637,
0.5863707661628723,
-0.3344970941543579,
-0.28404244780540466,
-0.20006759464740753,
-1.0439845323562622,
-0.7289880514144897,
-0.7818220853805542,
-0.33455243706703186,
-0.09511110186576843,
0.2534503936767578,
0.8318874835968018,
0.8989876508712769,
-0.6455374956130981,
-0.13084545731544495,
0.5719339847564697,
-0.343966543674469,
-0.2567453682422638,
-0.14212153851985931,
0.4058420956134796,
-0.08919788897037506,
-0.37399715185165405,
0.6995652318000793,
0.575822114944458,
-0.052657973021268845,
-0.10467951744794846,
-0.12012669444084167,
-0.45498961210250854,
-0.10614306479692459,
0.7524213790893555,
0.42832374572753906,
-0.4612676203250885,
-0.09545326977968216,
0.4276147484779358,
-0.23455911874771118,
0.36848339438438416,
0.9405602812767029,
-0.6194912195205688,
0.6943560838699341,
0.4864221215248108,
0.4477956295013428,
0.7331113815307617,
-0.21690621972084045,
0.21607238054275513,
-0.6466208696365356,
0.03325935825705528,
0.33032479882240295,
0.2830897271633148,
0.46645215153694153,
0.024088818579912186,
0.725326657295227,
0.42593514919281006,
-0.6751939058303833,
-1.0648343563079834,
-0.37737637758255005,
-1.5213807821273804,
-0.06950995326042175,
0.7212659120559692,
0.1286875158548355,
-0.13254059851169586,
0.18361793458461761,
-0.19539524614810944,
0.027655383571982384,
-0.594961941242218,
0.746786892414093,
0.38353872299194336,
-0.07762866467237473,
-0.2825888991355896,
-0.6152821779251099,
0.16478563845157623,
0.2967813313007355,
-0.5151985883712769,
-0.3494921326637268,
0.8275363445281982,
0.21107368171215057,
0.41135427355766296,
0.3185023367404938,
-0.336197167634964,
0.34725889563560486,
-0.18361222743988037,
0.12189816683530807,
-0.42844364047050476,
-0.5168214440345764,
-0.18094876408576965,
0.3741356134414673,
-0.21795208752155304,
-0.0034489694517105818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13463v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13463v2 | SpeechDPR: End-to-End Spoken Passage Retrieval for Open-Domain Spoken Question Answering | 2024-01-24T14:08:38 | 2024-03-18T06:08:31 | Chyi-Jiunn Lin, Guan-Ting Lin, Yung-Sung Chuang, Wei-Lun Wu, Shang-Wen Li, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Hung-yi Lee, Lin-shan Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.SD, eess.AS | Spoken Question Answering (SQA) is essential for machines to reply to user's
question by finding the answer span within a given spoken passage. SQA has been
previously achieved without ASR to avoid recognition errors and
Out-of-Vocabulary (OOV) problems. However, the real-world problem of
Open-domain SQA (openSQA), in which the machine needs to first retrieve
passages that possibly contain the answer from a spoken archive in addition,
was never considered. This paper proposes the first known end-to-end framework,
Speech Dense Passage Retriever (SpeechDPR), for the retrieval component of the
openSQA problem. SpeechDPR learns a sentence-level semantic representation by
distilling knowledge from the cascading model of unsupervised ASR (UASR) and
text dense retriever (TDR). No manually transcribed speech data is needed.
Initial experiments showed performance comparable to the cascading model of
UASR and TDR, and significantly better when UASR was poor, verifying this
approach is more robust to speech recognition errors. | [
-0.3716060221195221,
-1.056264877319336,
0.31600943207740784,
0.032087311148643494,
-0.3314017653465271,
-0.06275461614131927,
-0.017269236966967583,
-0.22878679633140564,
-0.08670172095298767,
0.5803747177124023,
-0.3577321767807007,
-0.06147616729140282,
-0.491632342338562,
-0.012143773958086967,
-0.5908416509628296,
0.6518353223800659,
0.1655251532793045,
0.12055124342441559,
-0.3794160783290863,
0.016542984172701836,
-0.24470987915992737,
-0.6720998287200928,
-0.6578657031059265,
-0.25574707984924316,
0.22178271412849426,
0.39404505491256714,
0.5402125120162964,
0.14973004162311554,
0.3123653531074524,
0.27093616127967834,
-0.40943604707717896,
-0.18523193895816803,
-0.565603494644165,
0.1831471472978592,
-0.08664968609809875,
-0.3615703880786896,
-0.018474925309419632,
-0.2853320837020874,
0.7474313974380493,
0.8406838774681091,
-0.37127020955085754,
0.0246698260307312,
-0.16991214454174042,
0.6323850154876709,
-0.5655661821365356,
-0.12610535323619843,
-0.41352415084838867,
0.17576898634433746,
-0.2704375684261322,
-0.38077235221862793,
-0.4233753979206085,
-0.3637460172176361,
0.5184071660041809,
-0.542593777179718,
0.023691022768616676,
-0.1719793677330017,
0.6137468814849854,
0.3318483829498291,
-0.5493867993354797,
-0.45256251096725464,
-0.9718139171600342,
0.5689483880996704,
-0.5858368873596191,
0.5847257971763611,
0.32245880365371704,
0.5875608325004578,
-0.2181967794895172,
-0.8347285985946655,
-0.9078202247619629,
0.026838252320885658,
0.24255965650081635,
0.2664825916290283,
-0.49461451172828674,
0.018051650375127792,
0.03546390309929848,
0.3532450497150421,
-0.8055585622787476,
-0.11463045328855515,
-0.7797702550888062,
-0.14296577870845795,
0.36719179153442383,
-0.09787429124116898,
0.36426839232444763,
0.014811370521783829,
-0.6223565936088562,
-0.1620853841304779,
-0.5346733927726746,
0.19120319187641144,
-0.026950301602482796,
0.23786966502666473,
0.1858380138874054,
0.8518059253692627,
-0.39452311396598816,
0.6267216205596924,
-0.07364535331726074,
0.12270933389663696,
0.1875075101852417,
0.01978583075106144,
-0.2450387328863144,
0.3474039137363434,
0.5171504020690918,
-0.04937279224395752,
0.3500048518180847,
-0.2600069046020508,
-0.355267196893692,
-0.29634952545166016,
0.07949332892894745,
-0.904984712600708,
0.021256159991025925,
0.3132309317588806,
-0.31718623638153076,
0.24771353602409363,
0.15472756326198578,
-0.7070949077606201,
-0.0494123175740242,
-0.17608259618282318,
0.7526043057441711,
-0.4578039050102234,
-0.3058238923549652,
0.32741880416870117,
-0.2000659853219986,
0.6383064389228821,
0.09240660816431046,
-0.3571237027645111,
0.6618315577507019,
0.7064266204833984,
0.7271862626075745,
0.03638101741671562,
0.053285613656044006,
-0.9710346460342407,
0.05088748037815094,
-0.20508551597595215,
0.7650300860404968,
-0.6060753464698792,
-0.5432332158088684,
-0.04331192746758461,
-0.24779558181762695,
-0.11777066439390182,
-0.6258338093757629,
0.783805251121521,
-0.9467743635177612,
0.6499711275100708,
-0.18069250881671906,
-0.8297020792961121,
-0.2208184152841568,
-0.17472998797893524,
-0.7385129928588867,
0.913960337638855,
0.06924794614315033,
-0.6941981315612793,
0.17821823060512543,
-0.6174523234367371,
-0.3457106947898865,
0.13539913296699524,
-0.1985359787940979,
-0.19206979870796204,
0.09067472070455551,
0.2955530881881714,
0.1971118301153183,
-0.2107526659965515,
0.1206255555152893,
0.20322191715240479,
-0.34572017192840576,
0.32389193773269653,
-0.5443435311317444,
0.8491403460502625,
0.3597504794597626,
0.006547776982188225,
-0.019465923309326172,
-0.7091758847236633,
0.14459766447544098,
0.21655279397964478,
-0.40117284655570984,
-0.523675799369812,
0.022041870281100273,
0.07193239033222198,
0.25201037526130676,
0.20900721848011017,
-0.943693995475769,
-0.30896633863449097,
-0.42353832721710205,
0.4357147216796875,
0.44068431854248047,
0.11356359720230103,
0.47490280866622925,
-0.26576659083366394,
0.430049329996109,
0.1265125572681427,
-0.011014387011528015,
-0.09195268154144287,
-0.5922333002090454,
-0.4964313209056854,
-0.15330800414085388,
0.22066311538219452,
0.7222790122032166,
-0.5851278901100159,
0.37937408685684204,
-0.26860177516937256,
-0.2747562527656555,
-0.5610457062721252,
-0.2424488216638565,
0.5347030758857727,
0.5960988998413086,
0.4588363766670227,
-0.45628827810287476,
-0.4447501003742218,
-0.5472099184989929,
0.02526155486702919,
-0.24669308960437775,
-0.07014745473861694,
0.30077287554740906,
0.27910250425338745,
0.021007239818572998,
1.345462679862976,
-0.6530349254608154,
-0.5994206666946411,
-0.3371286690235138,
-0.07444215565919876,
0.09631925821304321,
0.2659042477607727,
0.042090147733688354,
-1.0902390480041504,
-0.3629825711250305,
-0.05633598566055298,
-0.5462188124656677,
-0.11693859845399857,
0.08606179058551788,
-0.028497034683823586,
0.00007228056347230449,
0.44421854615211487,
-1.004003882408142,
0.3276044726371765,
0.21077127754688263,
-0.2590706944465637,
0.34195664525032043,
-0.21338288486003876,
-0.1296442747116089,
-0.9144004583358765,
0.31234511733055115,
-0.3078334927558899,
-0.0861072838306427,
-0.8838897347450256,
-0.17865696549415588,
-0.10806124657392502,
-0.4387896955013275,
-0.38533324003219604,
0.6866956353187561,
-0.39335641264915466,
-0.40347743034362793,
-0.10786203294992447,
0.5505258440971375,
0.02835136093199253,
0.1996259093284607,
0.3349446952342987,
1.0043132305145264,
0.376960426568985,
-0.6126375794410706,
0.2480473518371582,
0.6931911706924438,
-0.2535870671272278,
0.5332446098327637,
-0.9836557507514954,
0.4921039342880249,
-0.42246922850608826,
0.07697921246290207,
-0.9722633361816406,
0.025132348760962486,
-0.0014467929722741246,
-0.8005787134170532,
0.28674042224884033,
-0.09207163751125336,
-0.15872570872306824,
-0.2647956311702728,
0.2557624578475952,
0.3840716779232025,
0.506743311882019,
-0.49282732605934143,
0.49101823568344116,
0.5396810173988342,
-0.5800788998603821,
-0.7692996859550476,
-0.38581156730651855,
-0.02621067687869072,
0.09615912288427353,
-0.6481027603149414,
0.21574632823467255,
-0.10181523114442825,
-0.2439572960138321,
-0.08433519303798676,
-0.4317118525505066,
-0.5103673934936523,
-0.3217739760875702,
-0.16518114507198334,
-0.19303208589553833,
-0.32380005717277527,
-0.016648579388856888,
0.11908632516860962,
-0.2239256501197815,
0.17794528603553772,
-0.17871958017349243,
0.4591156244277954,
0.011384124867618084,
-0.3581617772579193,
-0.26370978355407715,
0.7814739346504211,
0.31569403409957886,
-0.6193650364875793,
0.4560299217700958,
0.4044986665248871,
-0.5247005224227905,
-0.23115655779838562,
-0.4621250033378601,
-0.22319942712783813,
-0.42566046118736267,
0.3091718852519989,
-0.5388917922973633,
-1.0078282356262207,
0.3121896982192993,
0.05159438028931618,
-0.12679405510425568,
0.013928118161857128,
0.33011746406555176,
-0.03648025169968605,
0.5637472867965698,
0.5880953073501587,
-0.04422197863459587,
0.2774367928504944,
-0.11116047948598862,
0.2019849568605423,
-0.6492542028427124,
-0.575484037399292,
-0.7639343738555908,
0.10100660473108292,
0.1727430522441864,
-0.5798064470291138,
0.5315477848052979,
0.340069442987442,
-0.1301625519990921,
0.15295076370239258,
-0.3441786468029022,
0.415154367685318,
0.6923196911811829,
-0.0018689422868192196,
0.4064788222312927,
-0.01495752390474081,
-0.0875031054019928,
0.17807839810848236,
-0.5845548510551453,
-0.3517915904521942,
0.7165278792381287,
0.2307594120502472,
0.6299847364425659,
0.3893725872039795,
0.5777016878128052,
0.24732671678066254,
-0.37788963317871094,
-0.6484502553939819,
0.6453683376312256,
0.016747405752539635,
-0.4928324818611145,
-0.745319128036499,
-0.5933189988136292,
-0.9832487106323242,
0.4742918610572815,
0.26053953170776367,
-0.5059068202972412,
0.3525388240814209,
-0.23980191349983215,
-0.30489498376846313,
0.12873025238513947,
-0.46597591042518616,
0.7182384729385376,
0.022439826279878616,
0.16633573174476624,
0.010151254944503307,
-1.0949516296386719,
0.07057280093431473,
0.030567338690161705,
-0.01606716401875019,
0.1972752958536148,
-0.04764677584171295,
0.8420259952545166,
-0.48377370834350586,
0.6376248002052307,
-0.5847691893577576,
-0.12024688720703125,
0.5475605726242065,
0.011753051541745663,
0.4462222456932068,
-0.28981462121009827,
-0.12786298990249634,
-0.170845165848732,
0.19508124887943268,
-0.24646267294883728,
-0.6954792737960815,
0.20687298476696014,
-0.890002965927124,
-0.35602837800979614,
-0.44202008843421936,
-0.1304822862148285,
-0.17936651408672333,
0.28378453850746155,
0.25412023067474365,
0.6484518647193909,
-0.5737457275390625,
0.2798740863800049,
1.1073697805404663,
-0.1869436651468277,
0.27851736545562744,
0.7974987626075745,
-0.00826747715473175,
-0.4764561355113983,
0.6883567571640015,
-0.008222519420087337,
0.27076786756515503,
0.9177002906799316,
0.13989897072315216,
-0.6911584138870239,
-0.7369327545166016,
-0.6057042479515076,
0.17880810797214508,
-0.6733062863349915,
-0.26192334294319153,
-0.8387781381607056,
-0.5667305588722229,
-0.29999056458473206,
0.1390918791294098,
-0.2162930965423584,
-0.6275497078895569,
-0.5098271369934082,
-0.13140976428985596,
0.30124804377555847,
0.4110721945762634,
-0.13592137396335602,
0.3224230706691742,
-0.7932223677635193,
0.4813414216041565,
0.3087514042854309,
0.12982821464538574,
-0.20645944774150848,
-0.7942692637443542,
-0.004106569103896618,
0.05667635798454285,
-0.05554414168000221,
-0.8831679821014404,
0.5177364349365234,
0.7321811318397522,
0.5963149070739746,
0.41542717814445496,
0.41775357723236084,
0.6148515343666077,
-0.5184662938117981,
0.6692371368408203,
0.04927145317196846,
-0.9174875617027283,
0.6343130469322205,
0.007796131540089846,
0.20241551101207733,
0.34473899006843567,
0.513654351234436,
-0.6993454098701477,
-0.024048704653978348,
-0.1528341919183731,
-0.8850025534629822,
0.5491386651992798,
0.22350098192691803,
0.0835936889052391,
-0.1706460416316986,
0.2713946998119354,
0.1003800481557846,
0.13567422330379486,
-0.2634524703025818,
-0.010012161917984486,
-0.29137781262397766,
-0.03791850805282593,
-0.1586592048406601,
-0.26053065061569214,
0.04054144024848938,
0.13006864488124847,
0.582321047782898,
-0.1572151929140091,
0.47625070810317993,
0.764190673828125,
-0.40126508474349976,
-0.42312324047088623,
0.702981173992157,
0.24648024141788483,
0.49347150325775146,
-0.33514687418937683,
0.078386589884758,
-0.03413751721382141,
-0.5173360109329224,
0.12707187235355377,
0.3972238302230835,
-0.3017999827861786,
-0.06484720855951309,
0.07169825583696365,
0.5806636810302734,
-0.019532710313796997,
-1.1044775247573853,
0.9240732192993164,
-0.008571118116378784,
-0.0662708431482315,
-0.5825170278549194,
-0.2537020742893219,
-0.14371490478515625,
0.394889771938324,
0.8104053139686584,
-0.2566351592540741,
0.44283977150917053,
-0.4652538299560547,
0.7476805448532104,
0.5049063563346863,
-0.7511828541755676,
-0.13856849074363708,
0.7279932498931885,
0.02184678055346012,
-0.21228894591331482,
0.8428307771682739,
0.01940317638218403,
-0.4721188247203827,
0.3298899829387665,
0.7504552602767944,
0.793919026851654,
-0.47911328077316284,
0.30061060190200806,
0.013722611591219902,
0.16870974004268646,
0.2198285013437271,
0.727135956287384,
-0.19018399715423584,
-0.521528422832489,
-0.5248913168907166,
-0.7392934560775757,
-0.4519529342651367,
-0.18875128030776978,
-0.9741598963737488,
-0.12748053669929504,
-0.15102240443229675,
0.06602475792169571,
-0.25276675820350647,
0.010270301252603531,
-0.21588951349258423,
0.36154162883758545,
0.017148837447166443,
1.2327779531478882,
-0.41585278511047363,
0.7768680453300476,
0.4282413423061371,
-0.559585452079773,
-0.5347815155982971,
-0.13864769041538239,
-0.11518018692731857,
-0.49874305725097656,
0.5289968252182007,
-0.09837210923433304,
-0.2167278677225113,
0.3219214975833893,
-0.1708044558763504,
-0.8145564198493958,
1.1504732370376587,
0.18607865273952484,
-0.4009540379047394,
-0.14448794722557068,
0.4233142137527466,
0.5522753000259399,
-0.14773932099342346,
0.31163284182548523,
0.3586691915988922,
-0.011993901804089546,
0.46708428859710693,
-1.0291165113449097,
0.003218518104404211,
-0.3034043312072754,
-0.03614358231425285,
0.19835014641284943,
-0.600242018699646,
0.7487651705741882,
-0.3862461447715759,
-0.4458833336830139,
0.3053628206253052,
1.077657699584961,
0.16465993225574493,
0.5058334469795227,
0.33210331201553345,
0.5779985189437866,
0.7582117915153503,
-0.03609739989042282,
0.6946505308151245,
0.10681849718093872,
0.04389984905719757,
0.9937241077423096,
-0.45634129643440247,
1.4012248516082764,
0.3633529841899872,
-0.13071484863758087,
0.24265360832214355,
0.32283395528793335,
0.5138721466064453,
0.8047716021537781,
0.2757393419742584,
-0.5674839615821838,
-0.05495629459619522,
-0.06137377768754959,
-0.42064782977104187,
0.4370274245738983,
0.46575602889060974,
0.0060510034672915936,
-0.2407488077878952,
0.15317849814891815,
-0.15605756640434265,
0.1088562160730362,
-0.1344565898180008,
1.0750788450241089,
0.27739930152893066,
-0.3768852949142456,
0.6174607872962952,
-0.19873155653476715,
0.2834719121456146,
-0.6875295042991638,
-0.02244761399924755,
-0.37432846426963806,
0.11056281626224518,
0.04313146695494652,
-0.845426619052887,
0.3868758976459503,
-0.039540037512779236,
-0.17495284974575043,
-0.04488582909107208,
0.8206823468208313,
-0.6846596002578735,
-0.05294438824057579,
0.4011470377445221,
0.7740654945373535,
0.4121823012828827,
-0.3206104040145874,
-0.5184158086776733,
-0.10273759067058563,
-0.3053729236125946,
-0.20808735489845276,
0.23570455610752106,
0.688077449798584,
0.08604274690151215,
0.9117658138275146,
0.6768578886985779,
-0.12057383358478546,
0.46399828791618347,
0.2109934240579605,
1.054516077041626,
-0.6114446520805359,
-0.5839794278144836,
-0.19298183917999268,
0.36185935139656067,
0.06846342980861664,
-0.15078458189964294,
0.4855514466762543,
0.9075578451156616,
0.8358869552612305,
0.14098133146762848,
0.7904693484306335,
-0.07151540368795395,
0.9177771210670471,
-0.4897952079772949,
0.5781248807907104,
-0.40736931562423706,
0.10492271184921265,
-0.18433430790901184,
-0.8970804214477539,
-0.19068729877471924,
0.5655578970909119,
-0.029380271211266518,
-0.01872241497039795,
0.4596501290798187,
0.8478724956512451,
-0.12689687311649323,
0.2814210057258606,
0.5214151740074158,
0.27447524666786194,
0.25239744782447815,
0.6304368376731873,
0.9334948658943176,
-0.43655550479888916,
0.8881664276123047,
-0.014297197572886944,
-0.3749929666519165,
-0.05916302651166916,
-0.23629598319530487,
-0.5221886038780212,
-0.8143628835678101,
-0.04890890419483185,
-0.22833898663520813,
0.396484375,
0.702937662601471,
0.4690210521221161,
-0.7608333826065063,
-0.21255476772785187,
0.04089109227061272,
-0.1460423618555069,
-0.279954731464386,
-0.2214280515909195,
0.4049467444419861,
-0.19604824483394623,
-0.5688360929489136,
0.8208933472633362,
0.15870773792266846,
-0.03177464008331299,
-0.13756437599658966,
-0.21492372453212738,
-0.10097424685955048,
0.3033592104911804,
0.684212863445282,
0.6580233573913574,
-0.6339713931083679,
-0.0880291759967804,
0.2405093014240265,
0.1400996744632721,
0.059055279940366745,
0.9114366173744202,
-0.8973167538642883,
0.47492554783821106,
0.573708713054657,
0.822483479976654,
0.6233054399490356,
0.14447414875030518,
0.554223358631134,
-0.7175705432891846,
-0.2050754278898239,
0.5692557692527771,
0.1367114633321762,
0.2653990387916565,
-0.13552774488925934,
0.305423378944397,
0.12019439041614532,
-0.6419051289558411,
-0.6854653358459473,
0.18621033430099487,
-1.3805482387542725,
-0.19401559233665466,
0.9646036028862,
-0.12833288311958313,
-0.03163764998316765,
-0.5747403502464294,
-0.33317479491233826,
0.28150129318237305,
-0.6201981902122498,
0.40318769216537476,
0.20389458537101746,
0.0012321085669100285,
-0.39829105138778687,
-0.4813215136528015,
0.34368547797203064,
0.23977603018283844,
-0.6774332523345947,
0.15807360410690308,
0.5584834218025208,
0.14031945168972015,
-0.05722891911864281,
1.0941590070724487,
-0.29670628905296326,
0.19925566017627716,
0.030729519203305244,
-0.13284923136234283,
-0.04448949545621872,
-0.4721878468990326,
-0.4478858709335327,
0.41735613346099854,
-0.04542715474963188,
-0.2439512014389038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01700v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01700v1 | Question answering systems for health professionals at the point of care -- a systematic review | 2024-01-24T13:47:39 | 2024-01-24T13:47:39 | Gregory Kell, Angus Roberts, Serge Umansky, Linglong Qian, Davide Ferrari, Frank Soboczenski, Byron Wallace, Nikhil Patel, Iain J Marshall | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Objective: Question answering (QA) systems have the potential to improve the
quality of clinical care by providing health professionals with the latest and
most relevant evidence. However, QA systems have not been widely adopted. This
systematic review aims to characterize current medical QA systems, assess their
suitability for healthcare, and identify areas of improvement.
Materials and methods: We searched PubMed, IEEE Xplore, ACM Digital Library,
ACL Anthology and forward and backward citations on 7th February 2023. We
included peer-reviewed journal and conference papers describing the design and
evaluation of biomedical QA systems. Two reviewers screened titles, abstracts,
and full-text articles. We conducted a narrative synthesis and risk of bias
assessment for each study. We assessed the utility of biomedical QA systems.
Results: We included 79 studies and identified themes, including question
realism, answer reliability, answer utility, clinical specialism, systems,
usability, and evaluation methods. Clinicians' questions used to train and
evaluate QA systems were restricted to certain sources, types and complexity
levels. No system communicated confidence levels in the answers or sources.
Many studies suffered from high risks of bias and applicability concerns. Only
8 studies completely satisfied any criterion for clinical utility, and only 7
reported user evaluations. Most systems were built with limited input from
clinicians.
Discussion: While machine learning methods have led to increased accuracy,
most studies imperfectly reflected real-world healthcare information needs. Key
research priorities include developing more realistic healthcare QA datasets
and considering the reliability of answer sources, rather than merely focusing
on accuracy. | [
-0.2799517810344696,
-0.5224190950393677,
1.062576174736023,
0.09961453080177307,
-0.14798703789710999,
0.1813478320837021,
0.4592258632183075,
-0.602379322052002,
0.4683363139629364,
0.255275696516037,
-0.41416043043136597,
-0.16558896005153656,
-0.5791739225387573,
0.3970247805118561,
-0.11965605616569519,
0.6845767498016357,
-0.11272472888231277,
0.5320935845375061,
-0.2934204936027527,
-0.32994741201400757,
-0.5037440061569214,
-0.47330838441848755,
-0.5323842763900757,
0.019122684374451637,
0.6085928678512573,
0.22164957225322723,
0.812072217464447,
0.11858507245779037,
0.831700325012207,
0.21649809181690216,
-0.254479318857193,
0.2120458036661148,
-0.13654394447803497,
0.22222112119197845,
-0.06682189553976059,
-0.35426339507102966,
-0.5355396270751953,
-0.2613162100315094,
0.48585984110832214,
0.783154308795929,
-0.1899731457233429,
0.49917230010032654,
-0.18933026492595673,
0.6655469536781311,
-0.7201831340789795,
-0.20539939403533936,
0.045409802347421646,
0.04190853238105774,
0.21207864582538605,
-0.39249804615974426,
-0.11124838888645172,
-0.9690269231796265,
0.5304222702980042,
-0.6688590049743652,
-0.06364002823829651,
0.03309062123298645,
0.4667973220348358,
0.24267442524433136,
-0.37505650520324707,
-0.4512081444263458,
-0.7567246556282043,
0.5004589557647705,
-0.8392757177352905,
0.30632540583610535,
0.0944766253232956,
0.515461802482605,
-0.03632839024066925,
-0.6313127279281616,
-0.18952810764312744,
0.0900375172495842,
-0.13733521103858948,
0.3368840515613556,
-0.056630104780197144,
0.23195958137512207,
0.20217467844486237,
0.1595948189496994,
-0.6608982086181641,
-0.35155755281448364,
-0.6812020540237427,
-0.05858365073800087,
0.5629849433898926,
0.4347301125526428,
0.6147211194038391,
-0.02172314189374447,
-0.19547782838344574,
0.16428762674331665,
-0.5127275586128235,
0.34823179244995117,
-0.31442660093307495,
-0.18031424283981323,
0.41871166229248047,
0.5641404390335083,
-0.4205573499202728,
0.2464127242565155,
-0.03543626517057419,
-0.32147279381752014,
0.014757336117327213,
-0.3691574037075043,
-0.26051637530326843,
-0.2299635410308838,
0.6074619293212891,
0.5136094689369202,
-0.2574115991592407,
-0.29740333557128906,
-0.16147345304489136,
-0.09220213443040848,
0.5351986885070801,
-0.4882233738899231,
0.17893444001674652,
0.9404765963554382,
-0.640871524810791,
-0.15043577551841736,
0.06225459277629852,
-0.35095885396003723,
-0.1217753067612648,
0.004975434392690659,
0.3691718280315399,
-0.31962451338768005,
-0.22997631132602692,
0.27360209822654724,
-0.4347662329673767,
0.3710116147994995,
0.4550202786922455,
-0.3601970374584198,
0.3009372651576996,
0.3385673761367798,
0.6863038539886475,
0.0030535103287547827,
0.09439730644226074,
-0.030033038929104805,
-0.18066413700580597,
-0.6031455397605896,
0.9734516143798828,
-0.3617689311504364,
-0.5998475551605225,
0.3161177635192871,
0.30947592854499817,
-0.15465867519378662,
-0.7764017581939697,
0.49875742197036743,
-0.7626076340675354,
0.3023061752319336,
-0.5809797644615173,
-0.35342320799827576,
0.05561254173517227,
0.2636273503303528,
-0.35584503412246704,
0.5367037057876587,
0.0944306030869484,
-0.6927866339683533,
0.20585785806179047,
-0.5518454909324646,
-0.26114821434020996,
0.19260036945343018,
-0.09900422394275665,
-0.2857392728328705,
0.12755122780799866,
0.1068798080086708,
0.0995929017663002,
-0.4439454674720764,
0.1825740486383438,
-0.21898236870765686,
-0.6180712580680847,
0.5053237676620483,
0.06418066471815109,
0.8760666847229004,
0.437655508518219,
-0.18355001509189606,
0.07005187124013901,
-0.4999080300331116,
0.3409074544906616,
-0.2123042643070221,
-0.24762991070747375,
-0.20432423055171967,
-0.0892433226108551,
-0.170817032456398,
0.4343758523464203,
0.07479360699653625,
-0.8152710795402527,
-0.01531026791781187,
-0.3403797149658203,
0.38069048523902893,
0.2641178071498871,
0.46046167612075806,
0.22325654327869415,
-0.7819613814353943,
0.938757061958313,
-0.07626000791788101,
0.7832585573196411,
0.11007902026176453,
-0.7299532890319824,
-0.28666526079177856,
0.12179254740476608,
0.19433122873306274,
0.7850075364112854,
-0.7117664813995361,
0.2654576897621155,
0.03675652667880058,
-0.3436288833618164,
-0.7692081332206726,
-0.4410541355609894,
0.5260212421417236,
0.49089515209198,
0.4556479752063751,
-0.5426355600357056,
-0.13173961639404297,
-1.0329169034957886,
-0.179667666554451,
-0.5910009145736694,
-0.3404448330402374,
0.2858205735683441,
0.24334324896335602,
-0.16140538454055786,
0.7449497580528259,
-0.45831581950187683,
0.06420564651489258,
0.1644381284713745,
-0.25789546966552734,
-0.09710483253002167,
0.11039847880601883,
0.14471867680549622,
-0.5396956205368042,
-0.22199875116348267,
-0.24417082965373993,
-0.8051595091819763,
-0.1442943811416626,
0.3402336835861206,
-0.028353901579976082,
-0.3101760149002075,
0.20268778502941132,
-0.414034366607666,
0.4175693094730377,
0.21851684153079987,
-0.20899377763271332,
0.47313961386680603,
-0.16510801017284393,
0.5608755946159363,
-0.6646907925605774,
0.44769948720932007,
-0.2823534309864044,
0.02524452470242977,
-0.7061783671379089,
-0.036240354180336,
0.1867225170135498,
-0.28630760312080383,
-0.28110501170158386,
0.4570700526237488,
-0.24236300587654114,
0.11015406250953674,
-0.26174864172935486,
-0.03151426464319229,
0.11604717373847961,
0.1424398124217987,
-0.2446208894252777,
0.485578328371048,
0.1518172323703766,
-0.4577810764312744,
0.36946484446525574,
0.6306175589561462,
-0.09114044904708862,
0.9141420722007751,
-0.9845520853996277,
0.10950639843940735,
-0.22886045277118683,
0.34444037079811096,
-1.1182746887207031,
-0.22817659378051758,
0.4411308169364929,
-0.5983099937438965,
-0.0457657165825367,
0.17698514461517334,
0.030773773789405823,
-0.4707251787185669,
-0.1654108315706253,
0.26985105872154236,
0.5654608607292175,
0.2569493353366852,
0.07033463567495346,
0.47541120648384094,
-0.6913260817527771,
-0.7112523317337036,
-0.41870999336242676,
-0.04466560482978821,
0.1987122893333435,
-0.4428083598613739,
-0.17256338894367218,
-0.052940577268600464,
-0.34177425503730774,
-0.058085184544324875,
-0.32519325613975525,
-0.3410111665725708,
0.07955237478017807,
0.1821778267621994,
0.24450188875198364,
0.010003122501075268,
0.5524459481239319,
0.3296002745628357,
0.012666738592088223,
0.3358992338180542,
0.0001450063136871904,
0.020347511395812035,
-0.042576227337121964,
-0.5063391327857971,
-0.6422375440597534,
0.6763842701911926,
0.48849406838417053,
-0.23313237726688385,
0.2865279018878937,
0.2747420072555542,
-0.38832250237464905,
0.2735469937324524,
-0.5177667737007141,
-0.37447482347488403,
-0.3192019760608673,
0.19072473049163818,
-0.08453305810689926,
-0.8735470175743103,
0.4797173738479614,
0.12020464241504669,
0.3772854506969452,
0.5760372281074524,
0.24604202806949615,
-0.5997830033302307,
1.1161195039749146,
0.27123403549194336,
0.5706931352615356,
0.0028078733012080193,
0.0614716075360775,
0.30101174116134644,
-0.6159387826919556,
-0.2788030505180359,
-0.7322118282318115,
-0.3277309536933899,
-0.60280841588974,
-0.24780991673469543,
0.7945746779441833,
0.1136801466345787,
-0.1890678107738495,
-0.15208125114440918,
-0.7691548466682434,
-0.17787858843803406,
0.3920332193374634,
0.5059469938278198,
0.3610354959964752,
-0.5043987035751343,
-0.18423809111118317,
0.2678793966770172,
-0.8294317722320557,
-0.7060766816139221,
1.1577900648117065,
0.7297695279121399,
0.5429040193557739,
-0.01263768132776022,
0.5829107761383057,
0.2247992753982544,
0.6067360043525696,
-0.561504065990448,
0.33416512608528137,
0.19961529970169067,
-1.0110026597976685,
-0.7043865919113159,
-0.2548258304595947,
-0.7783458828926086,
-0.0024540149606764317,
-0.18311165273189545,
-0.17081134021282196,
0.5556525588035583,
0.030918054282665253,
-0.8643593788146973,
0.01660446636378765,
-0.43483766913414,
0.5557058453559875,
-0.11244051158428192,
-0.20077064633369446,
0.21420758962631226,
-0.9701853394508362,
0.14940549433231354,
0.07740385830402374,
0.1550043374300003,
-0.1661614626646042,
-0.1840238720178604,
0.7978143692016602,
-0.47887131571769714,
0.5484734177589417,
-0.3159703314304352,
-0.09806697815656662,
0.412420392036438,
-0.10495053976774216,
0.19421589374542236,
0.3995804786682129,
0.03159191459417343,
-0.07278551906347275,
1.2168008089065552,
-0.7772668600082397,
-0.663280189037323,
0.13641051948070526,
-0.5795018672943115,
-0.6582903861999512,
-0.5358148813247681,
-0.17850366234779358,
-0.6985419392585754,
0.11089278012514114,
0.2153942883014679,
0.43829619884490967,
-0.3141891658306122,
0.01915966533124447,
0.7140612006187439,
-0.45937609672546387,
-0.294226735830307,
0.33234143257141113,
-0.08942697942256927,
-0.47288066148757935,
0.37420159578323364,
0.22689229249954224,
0.15813805162906647,
0.2908850610256195,
0.008011868223547935,
-0.35036811232566833,
-0.7118179798126221,
-0.6471880674362183,
0.28230342268943787,
-0.40428081154823303,
-0.08104495704174042,
-0.6536029577255249,
-0.5011566877365112,
-0.5018174052238464,
0.11031032353639603,
0.08087362349033356,
-0.4120061993598938,
-0.10622932761907578,
0.12852612137794495,
-0.008199981413781643,
0.9507340788841248,
0.38365620374679565,
0.20125168561935425,
-0.8924034833908081,
0.3397473394870758,
0.5866370797157288,
0.5903660655021667,
-0.21396690607070923,
-0.41535836458206177,
-0.11211352795362473,
-0.07039199769496918,
-0.30358415842056274,
-1.1082853078842163,
0.20899897813796997,
-0.1881692111492157,
0.4430781304836273,
0.3457028865814209,
0.16604995727539062,
0.30252206325531006,
-0.30015888810157776,
0.7216476202011108,
0.26892516016960144,
-0.3957938253879547,
0.48925840854644775,
-0.2578807473182678,
0.5374346375465393,
0.8114458322525024,
0.695171058177948,
-0.8862661123275757,
-0.42013418674468994,
-0.7091948390007019,
-0.5514060258865356,
0.3742310404777527,
-0.0045987693592906,
-0.24308650195598602,
-0.11714059859514236,
0.5432981848716736,
-0.05763765797019005,
0.20409318804740906,
-0.12712502479553223,
-0.2868143320083618,
-0.09784876555204391,
-0.165496826171875,
0.10782092064619064,
-0.22366835176944733,
-0.46505942940711975,
0.2541079819202423,
0.5245987176895142,
-0.2774844467639923,
0.4869382977485657,
0.881556510925293,
0.07424788177013397,
-0.2553218901157379,
0.7457139492034912,
0.2576030194759369,
1.2616851329803467,
-0.4462584853172302,
-0.1260547637939453,
0.18833185732364655,
-0.6797580122947693,
0.4615825116634369,
-0.04314708337187767,
-0.5660722255706787,
0.20578986406326294,
0.007564375177025795,
0.09998822212219238,
0.03780551254749298,
-0.848240315914154,
0.35038816928863525,
-0.15181469917297363,
-0.5736759305000305,
-0.115961454808712,
0.04284018278121948,
0.09712754935026169,
0.17719902098178864,
0.3729025423526764,
0.023556895554065704,
0.5300952196121216,
-0.4408505856990814,
0.06256578862667084,
0.38972708582878113,
-1.1033741235733032,
-0.20587986707687378,
0.4040253162384033,
0.09827021509408951,
-0.3504100739955902,
0.16779795289039612,
0.3782670497894287,
0.02816055156290531,
0.5520579218864441,
0.18664397299289703,
0.5429167747497559,
-0.4239111840724945,
0.5726683139801025,
0.4506872892379761,
0.4232131242752075,
-0.10413925349712372,
0.8361398577690125,
0.31824585795402527,
-0.25988930463790894,
-0.2593175768852234,
-0.375730961561203,
-0.9918932914733887,
-0.0005887658917345107,
-0.6101431846618652,
-0.2716253995895386,
-0.6345627307891846,
-0.5757458806037903,
-0.1119130328297615,
0.023338332772254944,
-0.5795084238052368,
0.5567664504051208,
-0.286404550075531,
1.118523120880127,
-0.5268967151641846,
0.23368322849273682,
1.084671974182129,
-0.49389171600341797,
-0.6721169352531433,
-0.18512839078903198,
-0.2815963923931122,
-0.4543903172016144,
-0.033421989530324936,
-0.3689766526222229,
0.09426786750555038,
-0.31098443269729614,
-0.56960129737854,
-0.8686443567276001,
1.1896562576293945,
0.13489291071891785,
-0.3790057301521301,
-0.4037652015686035,
0.14711648225784302,
0.8901196122169495,
-0.12955103814601898,
0.60829097032547,
0.3910704255104065,
0.25351232290267944,
-0.092825748026371,
-1.0397493839263916,
0.14445127546787262,
-0.21631719172000885,
0.027862900868058205,
-0.1473497897386551,
-0.7908366322517395,
0.25760671496391296,
-0.18113799393177032,
-0.3524586856365204,
0.2976146340370178,
0.1636064648628235,
0.516719400882721,
0.7135578989982605,
0.23070970177650452,
0.23204374313354492,
0.7499452829360962,
-0.16541312634944916,
0.8244949579238892,
-0.05846887826919556,
-0.02047577127814293,
0.4576646089553833,
-0.3635348677635193,
0.7667054533958435,
0.55833899974823,
-0.6374716758728027,
0.3563646972179413,
0.8074949383735657,
0.6088173389434814,
0.24105530977249146,
0.2795727849006653,
-0.26119205355644226,
-0.2266940027475357,
-0.1617867350578308,
-0.6276745796203613,
-0.1353912502527237,
0.2265760898590088,
-0.423182874917984,
0.14568117260932922,
0.043931566178798676,
-0.4012502431869507,
-0.16114087402820587,
-0.08917202800512314,
0.872021496295929,
0.1600918173789978,
-0.6364954113960266,
0.6043304800987244,
-0.15157684683799744,
0.19722014665603638,
-0.6888548731803894,
0.039377156645059586,
-0.4485121965408325,
-0.37008675932884216,
-0.4431960880756378,
-0.596343457698822,
0.21121016144752502,
-0.15207228064537048,
-0.08534299582242966,
-0.2193291336297989,
0.7814225554466248,
0.04126040264964104,
-0.22287550568580627,
-0.11865401268005371,
0.9973454475402832,
0.31559258699417114,
0.12535102665424347,
-0.5835172533988953,
-0.3756096661090851,
-0.2502172291278839,
-0.18469779193401337,
0.187866672873497,
0.2537912130355835,
-0.06604312360286713,
0.6798875331878662,
0.6000550389289856,
0.4500444233417511,
0.06317783147096634,
-0.12477993965148926,
0.7371963262557983,
-0.7185978889465332,
-0.3326856791973114,
-0.01632457971572876,
0.3122626543045044,
0.11718051135540009,
-0.5265575647354126,
0.501372218132019,
0.30151572823524475,
0.3801208436489105,
-0.0758776068687439,
0.9662114381790161,
0.18229661881923676,
1.0959672927856445,
-0.09203898906707764,
0.6182795166969299,
-0.5430423617362976,
0.032807908952236176,
-0.1358700692653656,
-0.6222109198570251,
-0.4793659746646881,
0.15330879390239716,
-0.4116884768009186,
0.037148140370845795,
0.8576168417930603,
0.5107978582382202,
0.20392821729183197,
0.30325743556022644,
0.48155784606933594,
0.04407075420022011,
0.12752902507781982,
0.36700260639190674,
1.0942957401275635,
-0.7721361517906189,
0.43913859128952026,
-0.05259573459625244,
-0.47209078073501587,
-0.2918696999549866,
-0.16701343655586243,
-0.2596091330051422,
-0.4120447039604187,
-0.1756540983915329,
-0.5629643201828003,
0.48394715785980225,
0.5632404685020447,
0.6136409640312195,
-0.9679897427558899,
0.0019779051654040813,
0.32998359203338623,
0.19602376222610474,
-0.5291303992271423,
-0.12605756521224976,
0.39888662099838257,
-0.3704248368740082,
-0.30479466915130615,
0.21159154176712036,
0.523837685585022,
-0.20250704884529114,
-0.20967896282672882,
0.00045925326412543654,
-0.11198284476995468,
0.20862476527690887,
0.4522863030433655,
0.6116248369216919,
-0.5121088027954102,
-0.026511361822485924,
0.7475724220275879,
-0.5664284825325012,
0.15268516540527344,
0.748643696308136,
-0.34728309512138367,
0.3084705173969269,
0.7856154441833496,
0.7031634449958801,
-0.03572153300046921,
0.07694374769926071,
0.4017794132232666,
0.23976969718933105,
-0.6686367392539978,
0.6502098441123962,
0.30233436822891235,
-0.13705460727214813,
-0.17480306327342987,
0.1688845306634903,
0.19846530258655548,
-0.8673399686813354,
-0.6252222657203674,
0.01446298323571682,
-0.8373210430145264,
-0.278205931186676,
0.8808281421661377,
-0.06992991268634796,
-0.22010715305805206,
-0.8540042042732239,
-0.508303165435791,
0.05279841646552086,
-0.16386957466602325,
0.9199544787406921,
0.6032087206840515,
-0.42339205741882324,
-0.0069913133047521114,
-0.6667695641517639,
0.5618389844894409,
0.5488894581794739,
-1.0566537380218506,
-0.2776980400085449,
0.5713344812393188,
0.37045466899871826,
0.1502603441476822,
1.1430246829986572,
-0.5985978841781616,
0.8398466110229492,
-0.3925558924674988,
0.152906596660614,
0.36928653717041016,
-0.17108124494552612,
-0.45212045311927795,
0.5144496560096741,
0.3000638782978058,
0.019973475486040115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13444v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13444v1 | Clue-Guided Path Exploration: An Efficient Knowledge Base Question-Answering Framework with Low Computational Resource Consumption | 2024-01-24T13:36:50 | 2024-01-24T13:36:50 | Dehao Tao, Feng Huang, Yongfeng Huang, Minghu Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent times, large language models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable
capabilities. However, updating their knowledge poses challenges, potentially
leading to inaccuracies when confronted with unfamiliar queries. While
integrating knowledge graphs with LLMs has been explored, existing approaches
treat LLMs as primary decision-makers, imposing high demands on their
capabilities. This is particularly unsuitable for LLMs with lower computational
costs and relatively poorer performance. In this paper, we introduce a
Clue-Guided Path Exploration framework (CGPE) that efficiently merges a
knowledge base with an LLM, placing less stringent requirements on the model's
capabilities. Inspired by the method humans use to manually retrieve knowledge,
CGPE employs information from the question as clues to systematically explore
the required knowledge path within the knowledge base. Experiments on
open-source datasets reveal that CGPE outperforms previous methods and is
highly applicable to LLMs with fewer parameters. In some instances, even
ChatGLM3, with its 6 billion parameters, can rival the performance of GPT-4.
Furthermore, the results indicate a minimal invocation frequency of CGPE on
LLMs, suggesting reduced computational overhead. For organizations and
individuals facing constraints in computational resources, our research offers
significant practical value. | [
-0.27253255248069763,
-0.5179325938224792,
1.0341465473175049,
-0.12479710578918457,
-0.2452131062746048,
0.1885773092508316,
-0.3751192092895508,
-0.46804195642471313,
-0.0838957130908966,
0.461879163980484,
-0.8139001131057739,
-0.7708855271339417,
-0.562324047088623,
-0.279563844203949,
-0.0772179588675499,
0.5624755620956421,
-0.02368113584816456,
-0.2854181230068207,
-0.24328571557998657,
0.11141528189182281,
-0.30541664361953735,
-0.21424737572669983,
-0.7936566472053528,
-0.14946456253528595,
0.7717658281326294,
0.4589538276195526,
0.5631111264228821,
0.6932408213615417,
0.48973217606544495,
0.12936285138130188,
-0.15952236950397491,
0.3950212299823761,
-0.6685368418693542,
0.2333109974861145,
-0.18628129363059998,
-0.3782409727573395,
-0.19720162451267242,
-0.11950675398111343,
0.29194381833076477,
0.9344605207443237,
-0.17418110370635986,
0.13998138904571533,
0.002372095128521323,
0.5796024799346924,
-0.6343873739242554,
0.432021826505661,
-0.6875241994857788,
-0.17362450063228607,
-0.24780771136283875,
-0.17180514335632324,
-0.15609973669052124,
-0.5825191736221313,
0.45299720764160156,
-0.7363359332084656,
0.09751976281404495,
0.22298070788383484,
0.3885136842727661,
0.38370707631111145,
-0.23487895727157593,
-0.4353756606578827,
-0.5818691253662109,
0.4908396303653717,
-0.5774792432785034,
0.3047373294830322,
0.008237867616117,
0.48452863097190857,
-0.32953548431396484,
-0.5197591781616211,
-0.2708124816417694,
0.06802016496658325,
-0.018172573298215866,
-0.2880748510360718,
-0.21635094285011292,
0.2698122262954712,
0.3105762004852295,
0.07084814459085464,
-0.6423043608665466,
-0.02486502006649971,
-0.3266373872756958,
-0.3013954162597656,
0.41877779364585876,
0.12461673468351364,
0.3418574333190918,
-0.03862475976347923,
-0.296050488948822,
-0.021398862823843956,
-0.9301227331161499,
0.12977297604084015,
0.10859350115060806,
0.47873854637145996,
0.4148753881454468,
0.5366211533546448,
-0.3639645278453827,
1.0182839632034302,
-0.15782830119132996,
-0.21587786078453064,
-0.1584792137145996,
-0.227523073554039,
0.022350095212459564,
0.14434359967708588,
0.7770360112190247,
0.4379783272743225,
0.16659362614154816,
-0.6352149248123169,
0.14200760424137115,
-0.17360001802444458,
-0.1495533138513565,
-0.862842321395874,
-0.3584027588367462,
0.2148001343011856,
0.06772880256175995,
-0.03223555162549019,
-0.3784277141094208,
-0.7311073541641235,
-0.8011175990104675,
0.1418362706899643,
0.1086077094078064,
-0.6091117858886719,
-0.23148976266384125,
0.22657178342342377,
-0.31292369961738586,
0.43954965472221375,
0.5943226218223572,
-0.8184542059898376,
0.14601664245128632,
0.6805736422538757,
0.8439339995384216,
-0.14936895668506622,
0.12326846271753311,
-0.5393019914627075,
0.3380034863948822,
-0.27949339151382446,
0.6320621371269226,
-0.5004012584686279,
-0.661085307598114,
-0.20353762805461884,
-0.33185166120529175,
-0.035451095551252365,
-0.3582952618598938,
0.5709534287452698,
-0.8833844065666199,
0.03283007815480232,
-0.6873936057090759,
-0.595706582069397,
-0.48835915327072144,
0.5157182812690735,
-0.471614271402359,
0.8887432813644409,
0.2413872480392456,
-0.7160802483558655,
0.3110920786857605,
-0.7932367920875549,
-0.24494563043117523,
0.33404651284217834,
-0.3771466314792633,
0.28348788619041443,
-0.3030942976474762,
0.46281492710113525,
0.2347794473171234,
-0.6559756994247437,
0.16125686466693878,
-0.155682772397995,
-0.5397841930389404,
-0.35476815700531006,
-0.2258671373128891,
0.9401470422744751,
0.024349244311451912,
-0.2909058630466461,
-0.23912595212459564,
-0.4606650173664093,
0.13718320429325104,
0.17154890298843384,
-0.4429473280906677,
-0.5377498865127563,
0.12611894309520721,
-0.5973853468894958,
0.22340181469917297,
0.5281074047088623,
-0.4944266080856323,
0.5378912687301636,
-0.49384936690330505,
0.11430571973323822,
0.6702929139137268,
0.27518054842948914,
0.4954262971878052,
-0.29044800996780396,
0.7735406756401062,
-0.08686260133981705,
0.03269461542367935,
0.0452827513217926,
-0.766296923160553,
-0.5788065791130066,
-0.04507594183087349,
0.08261831104755402,
0.6634564995765686,
-0.632392942905426,
0.18760134279727936,
-0.43847987055778503,
-0.5441333651542664,
-0.5597968697547913,
0.3851032555103302,
0.08372659236192703,
0.5751277804374695,
0.3832138478755951,
0.16540317237377167,
-0.341034471988678,
-0.567670464515686,
-0.3831319510936737,
-0.42689958214759827,
-0.16916722059249878,
0.8867245316505432,
-0.0624672994017601,
-0.12421023100614548,
1.1035205125808716,
-0.7419569492340088,
0.15866616368293762,
-0.13094502687454224,
-0.15061359107494354,
0.4774385392665863,
0.03998392075300217,
0.2732444405555725,
-0.6271093487739563,
-0.46224546432495117,
0.2013656497001648,
-0.759018063545227,
-0.0855185016989708,
0.27071765065193176,
-0.31562539935112,
-0.28175055980682373,
0.45277705788612366,
-0.7499052882194519,
-0.01958508789539337,
0.40120068192481995,
-0.28805050253868103,
0.3405570685863495,
0.10084092617034912,
0.060112450271844864,
-0.7834004163742065,
0.055635496973991394,
-0.15455679595470428,
0.022951018065214157,
-0.5385082364082336,
-0.00756242498755455,
-0.019900286570191383,
-0.14506450295448303,
-0.2277154177427292,
0.7821502685546875,
-0.6360383033752441,
0.10343912243843079,
0.1566423773765564,
0.699901282787323,
-0.11931414902210236,
0.600721538066864,
-0.10133691877126694,
0.60975182056427,
0.823719322681427,
-0.6700723767280579,
0.4694705903530121,
0.24030561745166779,
-0.3376261293888092,
0.19648127257823944,
-0.21150030195713043,
0.4396468997001648,
-0.2635691165924072,
-0.09036827832460403,
-0.8409204483032227,
-0.08245614916086197,
0.4262329638004303,
-0.2005852609872818,
0.14617158472537994,
-0.5198739767074585,
-0.3897658586502075,
-0.3987417221069336,
-0.26125726103782654,
0.3643002212047577,
0.5462324023246765,
-0.6793203949928284,
0.7463693022727966,
0.21541304886341095,
-0.2510755658149719,
-0.7611567974090576,
-0.36093807220458984,
0.24813154339790344,
-0.28009578585624695,
-0.9688656330108643,
0.21608015894889832,
-0.1954275667667389,
-0.20059262216091156,
0.10425920784473419,
-0.20408111810684204,
0.21023787558078766,
0.07594122737646103,
0.010018972679972649,
0.1872585415840149,
-0.2565045952796936,
0.15156881511211395,
-0.1557333916425705,
0.2237958461046219,
0.21509337425231934,
-0.6824262142181396,
0.47076869010925293,
0.08537201583385468,
-0.4924386739730835,
0.06779451668262482,
0.1914810836315155,
0.5654433369636536,
-0.1620989739894867,
0.342056006193161,
0.39762717485427856,
-0.40312767028808594,
-0.2346159666776657,
-0.5710906982421875,
-0.02595788799226284,
-0.49932777881622314,
0.3714931309223175,
-0.2193920761346817,
-0.9832515716552734,
0.36159127950668335,
-0.490152508020401,
0.12686020135879517,
0.2342749387025833,
0.1306404322385788,
-0.05955231189727783,
0.7703761458396912,
0.5330936312675476,
-0.1629679650068283,
0.16657547652721405,
-0.27168458700180054,
0.523784339427948,
-0.8572442531585693,
-0.4206385016441345,
-0.37325844168663025,
-0.13500207662582397,
-0.7008201479911804,
-0.7769638895988464,
0.5551867485046387,
0.3421548306941986,
-0.03231293335556984,
0.10642527788877487,
-0.4754161536693573,
0.5046799778938293,
0.4409100115299225,
0.059481315314769745,
0.43211111426353455,
-0.2578204572200775,
-0.28583040833473206,
0.17330293357372284,
-1.1903479099273682,
-0.3481258153915405,
1.085436224937439,
0.031320977956056595,
0.7708823680877686,
0.3397277891635895,
0.8323816657066345,
-0.07777006924152374,
0.3338378071784973,
-0.8712377548217773,
0.7021744847297668,
0.05752498283982277,
-0.4725736081600189,
-0.4569580554962158,
-0.5620770454406738,
-0.6083455085754395,
0.13128185272216797,
-0.16069002449512482,
-0.974543571472168,
0.21138368546962738,
0.2571870684623718,
-0.4904060959815979,
0.4458032250404358,
-0.7097072601318359,
0.7613893747329712,
-0.3406107723712921,
-0.3734078109264374,
0.0684201642870903,
-0.4433058202266693,
0.4940107464790344,
0.04733295366168022,
0.19933590292930603,
-0.09587172418832779,
-0.07000946998596191,
0.6716004610061646,
-0.1797381341457367,
0.5629894137382507,
-0.5772953033447266,
-0.15673860907554626,
0.4454844295978546,
0.28519290685653687,
1.032396912574768,
-0.04850561544299126,
-0.05579490587115288,
-0.18362899124622345,
-0.30329546332359314,
-0.24545374512672424,
-0.868822455406189,
0.7624160051345825,
-0.4004702866077423,
-1.0145751237869263,
-0.21880275011062622,
-0.5722946524620056,
-0.7758730053901672,
0.34544095396995544,
0.011988037265837193,
0.26217949390411377,
-0.213660329580307,
-0.007622718811035156,
0.9045073986053467,
-0.3229869306087494,
0.2579757571220398,
0.4838988184928894,
-0.28430473804473877,
0.03645540401339531,
0.7292575836181641,
-0.1104128360748291,
0.20593656599521637,
0.354007363319397,
0.30687710642814636,
-0.5758085250854492,
-0.8391065001487732,
-0.393166184425354,
0.17011141777038574,
-0.7747192978858948,
-0.10686077177524567,
-0.7411739826202393,
-0.1448584347963333,
-0.13346654176712036,
-0.0834188237786293,
0.05698671564459801,
-0.2635830342769623,
-0.03764990717172623,
-0.08868849277496338,
0.6574026346206665,
0.6337152123451233,
-0.038233768194913864,
0.3538103699684143,
-0.6998305916786194,
0.01140592247247696,
0.5970072746276855,
0.34591183066368103,
-0.03330390900373459,
-0.005156629253178835,
-0.23165547847747803,
0.11363142728805542,
0.03612054884433746,
-0.9966278076171875,
-0.023480627685785294,
-0.0973699688911438,
0.6668978333473206,
0.4521186649799347,
0.0025262003764510155,
0.5178142786026001,
-0.27472972869873047,
0.6516810655593872,
0.11131340265274048,
-0.5153743624687195,
0.48736920952796936,
-0.7553432583808899,
0.23443177342414856,
0.4669966697692871,
0.40118274092674255,
-0.7166326642036438,
-0.26520130038261414,
-0.527441680431366,
-0.8248030543327332,
0.5952057242393494,
0.010372113436460495,
-0.42503324151039124,
0.12016291916370392,
0.5777145028114319,
-0.4380398094654083,
0.2762005627155304,
-0.2709296941757202,
-0.2392539083957672,
0.19658014178276062,
-0.13518306612968445,
0.0194256454706192,
-0.1455216407775879,
-0.19099168479442596,
-0.1367456316947937,
0.6360006332397461,
-0.17395344376564026,
0.1234980896115303,
0.0705779641866684,
-0.12097322940826416,
-0.03586412966251373,
0.1798742115497589,
0.07549013942480087,
0.4999725818634033,
-0.5449748039245605,
0.1067846417427063,
0.24170736968517303,
-0.2807956337928772,
-0.05870532989501953,
0.21129751205444336,
-0.26978790760040283,
-0.07051882892847061,
0.1439618021249771,
0.602258026599884,
0.1548001766204834,
-0.6929993033409119,
0.5560669898986816,
-0.030581505969166756,
-0.037041276693344116,
0.04656794294714928,
0.4306997060775757,
0.5565012693405151,
0.34425830841064453,
0.3809526860713959,
0.14053863286972046,
0.1956254541873932,
-0.3296549618244171,
-0.08248034864664078,
0.6644271016120911,
-0.34304994344711304,
0.14546693861484528,
0.3785953223705292,
0.20968672633171082,
-0.29472652077674866,
0.5801441073417664,
-0.5073184370994568,
-0.5736271142959595,
0.44734987616539,
0.1999271810054779,
0.6669960618019104,
0.0049993242137134075,
0.12830239534378052,
0.3244975507259369,
0.6120986938476562,
-0.09097409248352051,
0.22693102061748505,
-0.11107687652111053,
-0.7757811546325684,
-0.650778591632843,
-0.46273377537727356,
-0.4919162690639496,
0.027354806661605835,
-0.22395233809947968,
0.2680070698261261,
-0.36215534806251526,
0.0942389965057373,
-0.38643649220466614,
0.17691101133823395,
-0.7670891284942627,
0.02694784104824066,
0.06651920825242996,
1.2556322813034058,
-0.3723095953464508,
0.6581951379776001,
0.44010964035987854,
0.018939882516860962,
-0.9763340353965759,
-0.00038401284837163985,
-0.0467386469244957,
-0.8854541182518005,
0.35603994131088257,
-0.06336671113967896,
-0.5190097689628601,
0.2849116325378418,
-0.4891398251056671,
-0.9768077731132507,
1.4589520692825317,
0.5024030804634094,
-0.6088817715644836,
-0.4554554522037506,
0.05419682711362839,
0.30417943000793457,
-0.20076879858970642,
0.016806742176413536,
0.740698516368866,
0.8552115559577942,
0.33562418818473816,
-0.47688236832618713,
0.2362341731786728,
-0.006553326733410358,
-0.22385860979557037,
0.2714906334877014,
-0.4595209062099457,
0.5043679475784302,
-0.4748139977455139,
-0.4767264723777771,
-0.17314296960830688,
0.2328953742980957,
0.3128357231616974,
-0.003599749179556966,
0.5900954604148865,
0.368802934885025,
1.2820978164672852,
-0.13312596082687378,
0.8506028652191162,
-0.46348023414611816,
0.16708789765834808,
0.9701070189476013,
-0.14184078574180603,
0.4187939763069153,
0.4944317638874054,
-0.17824412882328033,
0.43677616119384766,
0.6602071523666382,
0.3061387836933136,
0.541807234287262,
0.3232109546661377,
-0.46601590514183044,
-0.37021633982658386,
-0.05054086074233055,
-0.14092513918876648,
0.3941202163696289,
0.5119262933731079,
-0.0353296734392643,
-0.605635941028595,
-0.5713555216789246,
0.07532341778278351,
-0.2068384885787964,
-0.3919925391674042,
0.5944489240646362,
-0.08142123371362686,
-0.744969367980957,
0.4318433701992035,
-0.19086062908172607,
0.552152693271637,
-0.7928411364555359,
-0.12188515812158585,
-0.22937338054180145,
-0.21613259613513947,
-0.09105674177408218,
-0.5051789283752441,
0.0185093991458416,
0.018842788413167,
0.005947532132267952,
-0.1013098657131195,
0.6927047967910767,
-0.5034306049346924,
-0.34493541717529297,
0.3917052149772644,
0.8359996676445007,
-0.14627239108085632,
-0.2891615033149719,
-0.4119582176208496,
-0.3156358599662781,
0.16058072447776794,
-0.08538838475942612,
0.08829901367425919,
0.6393788456916809,
0.13556566834449768,
0.8879293203353882,
0.6714919805526733,
0.18475013971328735,
0.1354101598262787,
-0.2683938145637512,
0.9642016887664795,
-0.7192670106887817,
-0.5533130764961243,
-0.7106613516807556,
0.24379633367061615,
-0.13047751784324646,
-0.014148097485303879,
0.6402255892753601,
0.5272580981254578,
0.3162820339202881,
0.317857027053833,
1.0557749271392822,
-0.09809184819459915,
0.5219067931175232,
-0.6331391930580139,
0.5332096815109253,
-0.3043656647205353,
0.6036650538444519,
-0.1385289579629898,
-0.6607387661933899,
-0.13302329182624817,
0.3615702688694,
-0.4017276465892792,
0.02938409149646759,
0.5953463912010193,
0.9985959529876709,
0.04755594953894615,
0.011264443397521973,
0.13285419344902039,
0.24017544090747833,
0.4176955223083496,
1.03743314743042,
0.8238505125045776,
-0.07322250306606293,
0.8478103280067444,
-0.0554075762629509,
-0.33840373158454895,
-0.09863908588886261,
-1.0043388605117798,
-0.8050544857978821,
-0.260694682598114,
-0.08291886746883392,
-0.14988023042678833,
0.2524505853652954,
0.7953069806098938,
0.6119667291641235,
-0.4216310679912567,
-0.11387426406145096,
-0.1415347307920456,
0.4222486615180969,
-0.20439781248569489,
-0.17448769509792328,
0.45124220848083496,
-0.15058623254299164,
-0.45457249879837036,
0.6969539523124695,
0.3163992464542389,
-0.17414692044258118,
-0.404525488615036,
-0.1526230275630951,
-0.3141951262950897,
-0.041987426578998566,
0.330588698387146,
0.3722352385520935,
-0.38531458377838135,
-0.24362686276435852,
0.31853732466697693,
0.018948091194033623,
0.07074948400259018,
0.891924262046814,
-0.6971215009689331,
0.4961547255516052,
0.3118099868297577,
0.9211136698722839,
0.8170006275177002,
-0.07745297253131866,
0.618948221206665,
-0.7375655770301819,
-0.11453135311603546,
0.3945959806442261,
0.3934144973754883,
0.45417124032974243,
-0.6203370094299316,
0.44386693835258484,
0.1896117627620697,
-0.18963679671287537,
-0.459509938955307,
0.2998832166194916,
-1.0092028379440308,
-0.17793625593185425,
1.3050976991653442,
-0.08629431575536728,
-0.1789596974849701,
-0.15902623534202576,
-0.22122004628181458,
0.10011513531208038,
-0.33991169929504395,
0.5846068263053894,
0.7284184098243713,
-0.3253777027130127,
-0.08126096427440643,
-0.45514172315597534,
0.8084154725074768,
-0.09032151848077774,
-0.6833483576774597,
0.2909921705722809,
0.4991508722305298,
0.3131922781467438,
0.16700972616672516,
0.8475023508071899,
0.04303787276148796,
0.14951182901859283,
-0.175053671002388,
-0.10673800110816956,
-0.20856450498104095,
-0.2005714476108551,
0.06155569106340408,
0.25381696224212646,
0.4542231559753418,
0.007722221314907074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13398v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13398v1 | Text Categorization Can Enhance Domain-Agnostic Stopword Extraction | 2024-01-24T11:52:05 | 2024-01-24T11:52:05 | Houcemeddine Turki, Naome A. Etori, Mohamed Ali Hadj Taieb, Abdul-Hakeem Omotayo, Chris Chinenye Emezue, Mohamed Ben Aouicha, Ayodele Awokoya, Falalu Ibrahim Lawan, Doreen Nixdorf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper investigates the role of text categorization in streamlining
stopword extraction in natural language processing (NLP), specifically focusing
on nine African languages alongside French. By leveraging the MasakhaNEWS,
African Stopwords Project, and MasakhaPOS datasets, our findings emphasize that
text categorization effectively identifies domain-agnostic stopwords with over
80% detection success rate for most examined languages. Nevertheless,
linguistic variances result in lower detection rates for certain languages.
Interestingly, we find that while over 40% of stopwords are common across news
categories, less than 15% are unique to a single category. Uncommon stopwords
add depth to text but their classification as stopwords depends on context.
Therefore combining statistical and linguistic approaches creates comprehensive
stopword lists, highlighting the value of our hybrid method. This research
enhances NLP for African languages and underscores the importance of text
categorization in stopword extraction. | [
-0.6367838382720947,
-0.8000806570053101,
0.2587619423866272,
0.3174263536930084,
-0.5188672542572021,
0.44691261649131775,
-0.37087753415107727,
-0.8308910131454468,
0.46011582016944885,
0.6114709377288818,
0.035177167505025864,
-0.22250734269618988,
-1.0790568590164185,
0.668358564376831,
-0.3595980107784271,
0.847442090511322,
-0.33505091071128845,
-0.19160042703151703,
0.01792110688984394,
-0.288890540599823,
-0.17417414486408234,
-0.8827533721923828,
-0.731052041053772,
-0.4632534384727478,
0.4908192455768585,
0.1332629919052124,
0.6623179316520691,
0.6503623127937317,
0.5016928911209106,
0.29109376668930054,
-0.15576522052288055,
0.44626203179359436,
0.05843328312039375,
0.17684073746204376,
-0.24456103146076202,
-0.41438913345336914,
0.008253505453467369,
0.10200723260641098,
0.011819218285381794,
0.6693931221961975,
-0.2429245263338089,
-0.07517609000205994,
-0.04523712769150734,
0.6017324924468994,
-0.9020728468894958,
-0.16231288015842438,
-0.7468340396881104,
0.0020577344112098217,
-0.5760560035705566,
-0.6210247278213501,
-0.33116206526756287,
-0.24632489681243896,
0.1286398023366928,
-0.3060833811759949,
0.3923451900482178,
-0.053242020308971405,
0.9839996695518494,
0.05601110681891441,
-0.35030269622802734,
-0.8149483799934387,
-0.6852243542671204,
0.9215347170829773,
-0.41154810786247253,
0.4483341574668884,
0.6508647799491882,
0.21854205429553986,
-0.046434517949819565,
-0.6471343636512756,
-0.7354556918144226,
0.22881992161273956,
0.10704907774925232,
0.03200431168079376,
-0.23928429186344147,
0.08213680982589722,
0.03843450918793678,
0.7252171635627747,
-0.5662183165550232,
0.19673755764961243,
-0.25233757495880127,
-0.38929063081741333,
0.5961718559265137,
-0.26255232095718384,
0.8881801962852478,
-0.2056189775466919,
-0.22591125965118408,
0.20026211440563202,
-0.4756915271282196,
0.10324068367481232,
0.32915157079696655,
0.4949049651622772,
0.1496039628982544,
0.39184024930000305,
-0.3834289610385895,
0.9629756808280945,
-0.3588409423828125,
-0.2556142508983612,
0.255753755569458,
-0.3504517078399658,
-0.22864502668380737,
0.32565414905548096,
0.8839027881622314,
0.20799966156482697,
0.5160523056983948,
-0.40981826186180115,
-0.12742599844932556,
0.45911139249801636,
0.38279613852500916,
-0.8213311433792114,
-0.16513796150684357,
0.12831704318523407,
-0.44787299633026123,
-0.2650725543498993,
-0.2088184952735901,
-0.7761191129684448,
-0.1052040085196495,
-0.13856346905231476,
0.2000417858362198,
-0.25487419962882996,
-0.031566448509693146,
0.45280715823173523,
-0.2635800838470459,
0.14417926967144012,
0.26290953159332275,
-1.0407592058181763,
0.5280582308769226,
0.4558091163635254,
0.9945992827415466,
-0.4991728961467743,
0.12477190792560577,
-0.364802747964859,
-0.1882670670747757,
-0.5173963904380798,
0.7530012130737305,
-0.829017162322998,
-0.3936605155467987,
0.22315147519111633,
0.14465372264385223,
-0.09120692312717438,
-0.6555511951446533,
1.0082404613494873,
-0.5933188796043396,
0.22703741490840912,
-0.05278001353144646,
-0.41733843088150024,
-0.5290471911430359,
0.20056073367595673,
-0.6925727725028992,
1.0519628524780273,
-0.2564714848995209,
-0.5940532684326172,
0.6623825430870056,
-0.42427635192871094,
-0.8847042322158813,
0.29930925369262695,
-0.1964840143918991,
-0.4756382703781128,
0.2504799962043762,
0.335222989320755,
0.36836355924606323,
-0.18909548223018646,
0.19264498353004456,
0.1329568326473236,
0.059671733528375626,
0.19633907079696655,
-0.35934334993362427,
0.826680600643158,
0.32751935720443726,
-0.447759211063385,
-0.45947062969207764,
-0.7591609358787537,
0.130006805062294,
-0.059897132217884064,
-0.4430236518383026,
-0.8800158500671387,
0.22529907524585724,
0.1843138188123703,
0.5480687022209167,
0.0043830410577356815,
-0.8762789964675903,
0.08422022312879562,
-0.4387214779853821,
0.27862218022346497,
0.16192898154258728,
0.10932186990976334,
0.22266876697540283,
0.05698803439736366,
0.6673925518989563,
-0.2168986052274704,
-0.3716774880886078,
-0.11783824861049652,
-0.8313392400741577,
-0.8409826755523682,
-0.3626559376716614,
0.7637437582015991,
0.703482449054718,
-1.178369164466858,
0.40660202503204346,
-0.15977859497070312,
-0.3447999358177185,
-0.44777077436447144,
0.13036610186100006,
0.40717601776123047,
0.1314835399389267,
0.6180515289306641,
-0.604630172252655,
-0.645669162273407,
-0.8571180701255798,
-0.5560827851295471,
0.07642323523759842,
0.030017688870429993,
-0.18368522822856903,
0.6065126657485962,
-0.09135565906763077,
0.8527314066886902,
-0.4841495454311371,
-0.36374929547309875,
-0.3372247815132141,
0.37651559710502625,
0.03801499307155609,
0.2990197241306305,
0.6722670197486877,
-0.9984725117683411,
-0.5133379697799683,
0.2980153262615204,
-0.5288086533546448,
-0.21407659351825714,
0.024255963042378426,
-0.022121816873550415,
0.23469504714012146,
0.343938410282135,
-0.46867263317108154,
0.8108214139938354,
0.29958176612854004,
-0.05990690365433693,
0.20527297258377075,
0.027451196685433388,
-0.04066219553351402,
-0.7941882610321045,
-0.12784233689308167,
0.03389883413910866,
-0.2998914122581482,
-0.9376003742218018,
-0.05012284964323044,
-0.12649080157279968,
0.15245933830738068,
-0.22511984407901764,
0.6070971488952637,
-0.5620233416557312,
0.1547863781452179,
-0.7398516535758972,
0.24799245595932007,
-0.045600034296512604,
0.1891719251871109,
0.5134211182594299,
0.7174251675605774,
0.3503872752189636,
-0.9228427410125732,
0.038208577781915665,
0.3960539698600769,
-0.47775810956954956,
0.14160850644111633,
-0.42454835772514343,
-0.20504921674728394,
0.06394064426422119,
0.09554655849933624,
-0.7757235765457153,
0.010043912567198277,
0.21899384260177612,
-0.6292307376861572,
0.405250608921051,
0.20856213569641113,
-0.5524440407752991,
-0.29694926738739014,
-0.14557433128356934,
0.10862583667039871,
0.3018833100795746,
-0.5613213777542114,
0.23325438797473907,
0.5285231471061707,
-0.3734314441680908,
-0.6695085167884827,
-1.0509834289550781,
0.40497031807899475,
-0.010455059818923473,
0.03056991659104824,
0.3067771792411804,
0.09348302334547043,
-0.2006097435951233,
-0.20008844137191772,
-0.34939974546432495,
-0.19723348319530487,
0.3121455907821655,
-0.1530793458223343,
-0.01169066596776247,
0.2007802575826645,
0.14927372336387634,
0.09414751827716827,
-0.011916524730622768,
-0.21155932545661926,
-0.3238774240016937,
0.6146113276481628,
0.3206350803375244,
0.21184469759464264,
-0.07893989235162735,
0.28496453166007996,
0.011991879902780056,
-0.5738083124160767,
0.9210793375968933,
0.5352618098258972,
-0.3278370797634125,
-0.5290355086326599,
-0.25376084446907043,
0.1462419182062149,
-0.414046049118042,
-0.10301796346902847,
-0.3633967936038971,
-1.072845697402954,
0.3611132800579071,
-0.12093961983919144,
0.07746993005275726,
0.4648989737033844,
0.7199068069458008,
0.2006840705871582,
0.6884568333625793,
0.89341139793396,
0.08852503448724747,
0.2225414663553238,
0.012369715608656406,
0.5708764791488647,
-0.5694512128829956,
-0.03401215746998787,
-1.0074230432510376,
-0.07613292336463928,
-0.9702988862991333,
-0.3659566342830658,
-0.22110803425312042,
0.2254616767168045,
0.5962053537368774,
0.6394039392471313,
-0.763371467590332,
0.2729363441467285,
0.07544084638357162,
-0.16534511744976044,
0.35896533727645874,
0.4760293662548065,
-0.2444850206375122,
-0.11468759924173355,
-0.6656551361083984,
-0.7593018412590027,
0.8633637428283691,
0.10966125875711441,
0.34316202998161316,
-0.002527031349018216,
0.8843160271644592,
0.5363878011703491,
0.4669216275215149,
-0.9615698456764221,
0.3704277575016022,
-0.4206293523311615,
-0.6389732956886292,
-0.0009743960108608007,
-0.33266356587409973,
-1.2107104063034058,
0.5186758637428284,
0.06538292020559311,
-0.7370069026947021,
0.6389482021331787,
-0.22559437155723572,
-0.06084239110350609,
0.22369642555713654,
-0.20435459911823273,
0.5846627950668335,
-0.12267740070819855,
0.1812501847743988,
0.14502181112766266,
-0.3479805588722229,
0.2895171344280243,
-0.4527245759963989,
0.49156785011291504,
-0.08256350457668304,
-0.46803075075149536,
1.0498539209365845,
-0.6560155749320984,
0.4565281569957733,
0.32132139801979065,
-0.3440764844417572,
0.576057493686676,
0.01942075975239277,
-0.01819225773215294,
-0.43102481961250305,
0.08399634063243866,
0.5306954979896545,
-0.3502829074859619,
-0.3990604877471924,
-0.19083288311958313,
0.3838158845901489,
-0.43425264954566956,
-0.08813729882240295,
-0.6419282555580139,
-0.013840137049555779,
-0.16634400188922882,
0.3450947701931,
0.6704322695732117,
0.5330176949501038,
-0.03424149006605148,
0.18169467151165009,
0.6621885299682617,
-0.23980353772640228,
0.8235712647438049,
0.4925931990146637,
-0.2837028205394745,
-0.4740823805332184,
1.0889955759048462,
0.2703310549259186,
0.22288896143436432,
0.6570054888725281,
-0.04164353013038635,
-0.28303682804107666,
-0.8337622880935669,
-0.42265477776527405,
0.0016551761655136943,
-0.7108312249183655,
-0.23845027387142181,
-1.018334984779358,
-0.2266705483198166,
-0.05372736230492592,
-0.38231751322746277,
0.07815317809581757,
-0.7845063209533691,
-0.1734141707420349,
-0.1967734396457672,
0.17294150590896606,
0.215815469622612,
-0.10180550813674927,
0.711854875087738,
-0.8838542699813843,
0.6748400926589966,
0.07825220376253128,
0.31353604793548584,
-0.04055309668183327,
-0.32674506306648254,
-0.4045468270778656,
-0.4028485417366028,
-0.39501672983169556,
-0.8945350050926208,
0.5721980929374695,
0.43400731682777405,
0.7551682591438293,
0.39382466673851013,
0.14833135902881622,
0.3688814043998718,
-0.6395806670188904,
1.014134407043457,
0.4054984450340271,
-1.060755729675293,
0.5152671337127686,
-0.11728578805923462,
0.3021688461303711,
0.7545318603515625,
0.8744089603424072,
-0.5798880457878113,
-0.6340963244438171,
-0.43648761510849,
-0.8113572001457214,
0.5329439043998718,
0.7741779088973999,
-0.010282441973686218,
-0.536126971244812,
0.03996031731367111,
0.28316816687583923,
0.46854090690612793,
-0.6605232954025269,
-0.3532911539077759,
-0.03519414737820625,
-0.10775968432426453,
-0.19687403738498688,
-0.21600939333438873,
0.15199211239814758,
-0.028227854520082474,
0.6070513725280762,
0.004637621343135834,
0.11171816289424896,
0.4297472834587097,
-0.3188364505767822,
-0.18618258833885193,
0.49834269285202026,
0.505334198474884,
0.724738359451294,
-0.06016509234905243,
0.11236973851919174,
-0.15218031406402588,
-0.9236853122711182,
0.3245193064212799,
0.19912174344062805,
-0.3732287883758545,
0.6943994164466858,
0.6163769960403442,
0.5102517604827881,
-0.17712901532649994,
-0.5977419018745422,
0.12227801233530045,
-0.11568000167608261,
-0.28820788860321045,
0.12869252264499664,
-0.0721900537610054,
-0.27591633796691895,
-0.41314637660980225,
0.5279430150985718,
0.1311240792274475,
0.4687942564487457,
-0.6224378347396851,
0.3943353593349457,
0.4905398488044739,
-0.3732663691043854,
-0.22310450673103333,
0.5761353969573975,
0.3811371922492981,
-0.356132835149765,
-0.053852248936891556,
-0.1105489432811737,
-0.9319149851799011,
0.7219899296760559,
0.3376218378543854,
1.1707364320755005,
-0.6451108455657959,
0.336369127035141,
0.2896675765514374,
0.6725401878356934,
-0.1750205159187317,
0.46117275953292847,
-0.3710162341594696,
-0.9402605295181274,
-0.6473039984703064,
-1.1387346982955933,
-0.3566153049468994,
0.06292302906513214,
-0.5980495810508728,
0.18772171437740326,
-0.3220665752887726,
-0.322562575340271,
0.5030219554901123,
0.10406073182821274,
-0.3265550434589386,
0.586281955242157,
0.3439708352088928,
0.8609896898269653,
-0.6574878692626953,
0.6979279518127441,
0.8043727874755859,
-0.1853586882352829,
-0.28807398676872253,
0.0071946256794035435,
-0.1288299709558487,
-0.35387152433395386,
0.6150997281074524,
0.47093096375465393,
-0.17147189378738403,
-0.34804531931877136,
-0.6123737692832947,
-0.4167015850543976,
0.4386623203754425,
-0.45865005254745483,
-0.6673309803009033,
0.42896226048469543,
0.36975008249282837,
0.7656471729278564,
-0.49910953640937805,
0.02311338111758232,
0.589065432548523,
0.31043246388435364,
-0.02166917361319065,
-1.0205519199371338,
-0.10542473196983337,
-0.13519728183746338,
0.11280720680952072,
0.7128207683563232,
-0.37849363684654236,
0.6073996424674988,
0.2962610423564911,
-0.47065117955207825,
-0.051742151379585266,
0.38477885723114014,
-0.17289108037948608,
0.46353015303611755,
0.4724697172641754,
0.5859880447387695,
0.38197827339172363,
-0.15534839034080505,
1.0737711191177368,
-0.1955968737602234,
0.2703520953655243,
0.7827496528625488,
-0.16670481860637665,
0.7212858200073242,
0.17906199395656586,
-0.3555911183357239,
0.5627486705780029,
0.7943490147590637,
0.36011695861816406,
0.527624249458313,
0.08442237228155136,
-0.38544848561286926,
-0.3159838914871216,
-0.2727552652359009,
-0.1492232382297516,
0.6845905184745789,
0.574620246887207,
-0.32624760270118713,
-0.4493793249130249,
0.22620262205600739,
0.27408748865127563,
0.25568830966949463,
-0.47511759400367737,
0.5860872268676758,
0.45746302604675293,
-0.43977510929107666,
0.7350105047225952,
0.10113415867090225,
0.7643207311630249,
-0.6750615835189819,
0.024206005036830902,
0.017769647762179375,
-0.09995533525943756,
-0.22436779737472534,
-0.7135200500488281,
0.4332255721092224,
0.07565812021493912,
-0.17837293446063995,
-0.23245841264724731,
1.1107490062713623,
-0.5280628800392151,
-0.32777464389801025,
0.45181164145469666,
0.5423105359077454,
0.14325986802577972,
-0.00011991014616796747,
-0.5616506338119507,
-0.04036610201001167,
0.11077286303043365,
-0.11725994944572449,
0.20870642364025116,
0.4261891841888428,
-0.2630431354045868,
0.6229763031005859,
0.8296391367912292,
0.2922155261039734,
-0.02727925032377243,
-0.23311789333820343,
0.6849560737609863,
-0.7343619465827942,
-0.7749006748199463,
-0.9993492364883423,
0.03685493394732475,
-0.22997553646564484,
-0.31160762906074524,
1.0198955535888672,
0.5632612705230713,
0.8352324962615967,
0.018989885225892067,
0.9126415252685547,
-0.15776503086090088,
0.5641125440597534,
-0.36657509207725525,
0.4662322998046875,
-0.6983730792999268,
-0.15156793594360352,
-0.31012892723083496,
-1.0640556812286377,
-0.3724291920661926,
0.31936973333358765,
-0.33025968074798584,
-0.3576156198978424,
0.6610312461853027,
0.04696119576692581,
0.12025350332260132,
0.11426596343517303,
0.3652570843696594,
-0.24045778810977936,
0.22821000218391418,
-0.041650209575891495,
0.5981009006500244,
-0.41137945652008057,
0.6039705276489258,
-0.1904871165752411,
-0.21002274751663208,
-0.12932643294334412,
-0.7121086716651917,
-0.9531000256538391,
-0.3226819932460785,
-0.346942663192749,
-0.19062592089176178,
-0.11019403487443924,
0.4165979027748108,
0.318512886762619,
-1.1281683444976807,
-0.05391812324523926,
-0.04136337339878082,
0.1709885150194168,
-0.21728110313415527,
-0.2987927496433258,
0.162433460354805,
-0.5327146649360657,
-0.6778112053871155,
0.2205849438905716,
0.5365332365036011,
-0.05412186682224274,
0.16041450202465057,
0.2354847490787506,
-0.6523536443710327,
0.42101821303367615,
0.9685410857200623,
0.4959770143032074,
-0.591223955154419,
0.12180813401937485,
-0.18301700055599213,
-0.046154290437698364,
0.08627105504274368,
0.8254044651985168,
-0.7405477166175842,
0.8194525241851807,
0.5030381083488464,
0.8247931003570557,
0.21556425094604492,
0.03768518194556236,
0.4715709686279297,
-0.6448685526847839,
0.4125610888004303,
0.16391052305698395,
0.17325949668884277,
0.37191829085350037,
-0.2520486116409302,
0.8167421817779541,
0.36563870310783386,
-0.4596877992153168,
-0.684114396572113,
0.2909925580024719,
-0.9031620621681213,
-0.3420027196407318,
0.9048627614974976,
0.009424973279237747,
-0.15049581229686737,
-0.6679996848106384,
0.03843400254845619,
0.11831340938806534,
-0.3060261011123657,
0.530501127243042,
1.0288679599761963,
0.07887628674507141,
-0.30375418066978455,
-0.8482550382614136,
0.7277745604515076,
0.29764559864997864,
-0.8714463114738464,
-0.3949948251247406,
0.22031135857105255,
-0.02487769164144993,
0.7556479573249817,
0.7087063789367676,
-0.01998578943312168,
0.054756052792072296,
-0.22113198041915894,
0.3545621931552887,
0.4716666638851166,
-0.1809859722852707,
-0.31007707118988037,
0.038462404161691666,
-0.43760260939598083,
-0.4681002199649811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01698v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01698v1 | Large language model empowered participatory urban planning | 2024-01-24T10:50:01 | 2024-01-24T10:50:01 | Zhilun Zhou, Yuming Lin, Yong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Participatory urban planning is the mainstream of modern urban planning and
involves the active engagement of different stakeholders. However, the
traditional participatory paradigm encounters challenges in time and manpower,
while the generative planning tools fail to provide adjustable and inclusive
solutions. This research introduces an innovative urban planning approach
integrating Large Language Models (LLMs) within the participatory process. The
framework, based on the crafted LLM agent, consists of role-play, collaborative
generation, and feedback iteration, solving a community-level land-use task
catering to 1000 distinct interests. Empirical experiments in diverse urban
communities exhibit LLM's adaptability and effectiveness across varied planning
scenarios. The results were evaluated on four metrics, surpassing human experts
in satisfaction and inclusion, and rivaling state-of-the-art reinforcement
learning methods in service and ecology. Further analysis shows the advantage
of LLM agents in providing adjustable and inclusive solutions with natural
language reasoning and strong scalability. While implementing the recent
advancements in emulating human behavior for planning, this work envisions both
planners and citizens benefiting from low-cost, efficient LLM agents, which is
crucial for enhancing participation and realizing participatory urban planning. | [
-0.4127029478549957,
-0.783614456653595,
0.7918367385864258,
0.20417441427707672,
0.06918788701295853,
0.2510443925857544,
-0.5552541613578796,
-0.39308464527130127,
0.3945513367652893,
0.4270617663860321,
-0.25735488533973694,
-0.5570755004882812,
-0.15123040974140167,
-0.10592039674520493,
-0.09269893914461136,
0.3080211579799652,
-0.1351933777332306,
0.13134799897670746,
0.09117104858160019,
0.025703247636556625,
-0.522513210773468,
-0.3493819832801819,
-0.8068096041679382,
-0.5751842856407166,
0.5279211401939392,
0.5886763334274292,
1.022430658340454,
0.4004611670970917,
0.1409260779619217,
0.29234108328819275,
-0.04567490890622139,
0.22538922727108002,
-0.31130123138427734,
-0.2558465003967285,
-0.37963759899139404,
-0.20266105234622955,
-0.6999157667160034,
-0.25602006912231445,
0.5310375690460205,
0.5763419270515442,
-0.571304202079773,
-0.0671696662902832,
-0.031241275370121002,
0.5217092037200928,
-0.5068795680999756,
0.4077160060405731,
-0.6520920395851135,
-0.017229273915290833,
0.06849747151136398,
-0.18536587059497833,
-0.026919661089777946,
-0.15028733015060425,
-0.3415040075778961,
-0.5239885449409485,
-0.23073160648345947,
-0.1364399492740631,
-0.17000500857830048,
0.2533922493457794,
-0.26829537749290466,
-0.4973488450050354,
-1.173154354095459,
0.6601319909095764,
-0.7662368416786194,
0.29285329580307007,
0.24807439744472504,
0.46129631996154785,
-0.5524592995643616,
-0.3604828119277954,
-0.9383938312530518,
-0.05996683984994888,
0.17207680642604828,
0.1752087026834488,
0.11456664651632309,
0.18716217577457428,
0.02010590210556984,
0.01705467328429222,
-0.452375590801239,
0.5373864769935608,
-0.16995860636234283,
0.09612362831830978,
0.7987534999847412,
0.2897980809211731,
-0.07207627594470978,
-0.22522814571857452,
-0.5008665919303894,
0.13536368310451508,
-0.7078943848609924,
0.32539984583854675,
0.39042291045188904,
0.47445493936538696,
-0.013694409281015396,
0.5859569311141968,
-0.3443542718887329,
0.20758312940597534,
-0.29861515760421753,
-0.14950738847255707,
-0.08734975755214691,
-0.22604474425315857,
-0.2808130383491516,
-0.08703739941120148,
0.6456322073936462,
0.09006035327911377,
0.26669108867645264,
-0.14921648800373077,
-0.4298613667488098,
-0.3830597698688507,
0.10156801342964172,
-0.554220974445343,
0.04998007416725159,
0.4584279954433441,
-0.1885574907064438,
-0.05050353705883026,
-0.18623526394367218,
-0.7364388108253479,
-0.4384573996067047,
-0.506740391254425,
0.05160786584019661,
-0.21207644045352936,
-0.4637238383293152,
0.4032038748264313,
0.309371680021286,
0.3277893364429474,
0.7440269589424133,
-0.9906319379806519,
0.1551124006509781,
0.9187586307525635,
0.3498847782611847,
0.1489505022764206,
-0.46727868914604187,
-0.18629203736782074,
0.35777053236961365,
-0.27984297275543213,
0.7285579442977905,
-0.624583899974823,
-0.5162334442138672,
0.2163439691066742,
-0.2888971269130707,
0.26850470900535583,
-0.516166090965271,
0.39023998379707336,
-0.3487759232521057,
-0.24996960163116455,
-0.21002785861492157,
-0.11061257869005203,
-0.08359143137931824,
0.5166293978691101,
-0.6830713748931885,
1.107432246208191,
0.20722496509552002,
-0.16916021704673767,
0.5612165927886963,
-0.8683027029037476,
-0.2477961927652359,
0.5091414451599121,
-0.22748160362243652,
-0.0985308289527893,
0.04334600269794464,
0.357085645198822,
0.47798699140548706,
-0.15096542239189148,
0.5719047784805298,
-0.13184911012649536,
-0.16015999019145966,
0.301616907119751,
-0.23302075266838074,
0.5327062606811523,
0.2005818486213684,
-0.1791505068540573,
0.6007490754127502,
-0.5336790680885315,
-0.22179070115089417,
0.13063852488994598,
-0.7193787097930908,
0.09659435600042343,
0.1867693066596985,
0.06710781157016754,
0.2889407277107239,
0.4412677586078644,
-0.4872428774833679,
0.5484593510627747,
-0.2639082670211792,
0.28639358282089233,
0.7619195580482483,
-0.16364732384681702,
0.6897671818733215,
-0.38205644488334656,
0.666477382183075,
-0.4158520996570587,
0.29013052582740784,
-0.026684803888201714,
-0.41639333963394165,
-0.45227858424186707,
-0.27976664900779724,
0.03721469268202782,
0.3129119873046875,
-0.9226089119911194,
0.4499437212944031,
-0.22416163980960846,
-0.5747932195663452,
-0.1729518324136734,
0.06117592379450798,
-0.20790930092334747,
-0.0373074933886528,
-0.0010759108699858189,
-0.07551506906747818,
-0.34666240215301514,
-0.37930554151535034,
0.20247434079647064,
-0.35698816180229187,
0.01631239429116249,
0.19763976335525513,
0.6080323457717896,
-0.0762774869799614,
0.8395341634750366,
-0.2711237072944641,
-0.18593266606330872,
-0.7623270750045776,
-0.0530015230178833,
0.13805657625198364,
0.11715470254421234,
0.5459038019180298,
-0.8157369494438171,
-0.29761987924575806,
-0.11723979562520981,
-0.3420330882072449,
0.0949188619852066,
-0.12059131264686584,
-0.18023037910461426,
-0.195841446518898,
0.286366730928421,
-0.6842859983444214,
0.3672889769077301,
0.44242823123931885,
-0.3660971522331238,
0.5741193294525146,
-0.35921335220336914,
-0.06702350080013275,
-1.1717824935913086,
-0.15096727013587952,
-0.07596656680107117,
-0.29129722714424133,
-0.4900948703289032,
0.46362531185150146,
-0.19395485520362854,
-0.29137638211250305,
-0.40561407804489136,
0.756893515586853,
-0.3282511532306671,
-0.13888560235500336,
-0.41284361481666565,
-0.05516253039240837,
-0.32314902544021606,
0.582879900932312,
0.29932424426078796,
0.6539900898933411,
0.18971148133277893,
-0.3901389539241791,
0.41487744450569153,
0.3292817175388336,
-0.2925224304199219,
0.25820663571357727,
-0.3413812816143036,
0.12552392482757568,
-0.2850697934627533,
0.5802950859069824,
-0.5952976942062378,
-0.35115090012550354,
0.07035455107688904,
-0.10956421494483948,
-0.09059858322143555,
0.018422838300466537,
-0.9579085111618042,
-0.4760097861289978,
-0.41902437806129456,
0.2178676575422287,
0.25967833399772644,
-0.42519792914390564,
0.8732726573944092,
0.5565245151519775,
-0.2398761510848999,
-0.10461917519569397,
-0.37859752774238586,
0.1890317052602768,
-0.07713617384433746,
-0.3585927188396454,
-0.07242608815431595,
-0.28086549043655396,
-0.3554385006427765,
-0.27899205684661865,
0.3986910879611969,
-0.0249469093978405,
0.24426543712615967,
0.1908755898475647,
-0.11346904933452606,
0.07535701990127563,
0.1415937840938568,
-0.23594346642494202,
-0.0994424968957901,
-0.1602325588464737,
0.02300509251654148,
0.7701038122177124,
0.3256845772266388,
-0.473640501499176,
-0.18861310184001923,
0.6153236627578735,
0.8403425812721252,
-0.613957405090332,
0.5164246559143066,
0.3602966070175171,
-0.5255829095840454,
-0.24090732634067535,
-0.24494753777980804,
-0.038812052458524704,
-0.415651798248291,
0.35418185591697693,
-0.2938673496246338,
-0.994391918182373,
0.44411545991897583,
-0.3454172611236572,
0.3897871971130371,
-0.17884688079357147,
0.7198063731193542,
-0.06926881521940231,
0.8371443748474121,
0.754203736782074,
0.21366240084171295,
0.4872210919857025,
-0.009489757008850574,
0.3945475220680237,
-0.7640413641929626,
-0.35050272941589355,
-0.4676688611507416,
-0.5406613945960999,
-0.3872421979904175,
-0.8941066861152649,
0.3133952021598816,
0.21798279881477356,
-0.10893271863460541,
0.22677551209926605,
-0.3494243025779724,
0.12516511976718903,
0.28942108154296875,
-0.13233377039432526,
0.4249464273452759,
-0.2197900116443634,
0.172357439994812,
0.06411049515008926,
-0.5928610563278198,
-0.7485851049423218,
0.9233734011650085,
0.5384485125541687,
0.6639661192893982,
0.48013031482696533,
0.6753042936325073,
0.35685232281684875,
0.3720248341560364,
-0.9204388856887817,
0.8040697574615479,
0.03796924650669098,
-0.4311774969100952,
-0.644584059715271,
-0.061243508011102676,
-0.9613564014434814,
0.21206817030906677,
-0.6483492851257324,
-0.8759697675704956,
0.31678956747055054,
-0.0739402025938034,
-0.41126200556755066,
0.5219985246658325,
-0.405801922082901,
0.3828405439853668,
-0.33356258273124695,
-0.20365571975708008,
-0.4723455309867859,
-0.03903340548276901,
-0.057369496673345566,
-0.30373772978782654,
0.6225228309631348,
-0.395807147026062,
0.15183591842651367,
0.38412007689476013,
-0.09115135669708252,
0.7376362681388855,
-0.4545886516571045,
-0.17470361292362213,
0.3008529543876648,
0.04040620103478432,
0.8781339526176453,
0.06105984374880791,
-0.49408283829689026,
-0.03400496020913124,
-0.6073962450027466,
-0.4548358619213104,
-0.5050035715103149,
0.5872460603713989,
-0.6109254360198975,
-0.38158857822418213,
0.0380014032125473,
-0.8526772856712341,
-0.24431651830673218,
-0.09243115782737732,
-0.34587419033050537,
0.21981129050254822,
-0.45781800150871277,
-0.006050468422472477,
0.3579506278038025,
-0.2563294470310211,
0.7701693177223206,
0.7196676731109619,
-0.6379848718643188,
-0.23341211676597595,
0.5785282850265503,
0.08545684069395065,
0.15072059631347656,
0.4153383672237396,
0.34242403507232666,
-0.16512075066566467,
-0.835702657699585,
-0.2270389050245285,
0.010138106532394886,
-0.28559410572052,
-0.041093047708272934,
-0.5264335870742798,
-0.1625344604253769,
-0.3994501829147339,
-0.6150593757629395,
-0.4381409287452698,
-0.1855991780757904,
0.12654195725917816,
-0.29499441385269165,
0.007222587708383799,
0.9369577169418335,
-0.1611458659172058,
0.1949697732925415,
-0.5320099592208862,
0.1232917308807373,
0.3824850618839264,
-0.0310693196952343,
0.2385319620370865,
0.22328555583953857,
-0.3846924901008606,
0.02890934608876705,
-0.18259088695049286,
-0.6549956202507019,
0.40427371859550476,
-0.45728400349617004,
0.6225539445877075,
0.3331209719181061,
0.22592858970165253,
0.412046879529953,
-0.3813306391239166,
0.8009926676750183,
0.09084273129701614,
-0.2923220694065094,
0.4131050407886505,
-0.5993747115135193,
0.6778990030288696,
0.5060287117958069,
0.030477385967969894,
-0.3089246451854706,
-0.47388142347335815,
-0.361172080039978,
-1.0679675340652466,
0.28463202714920044,
0.07499369233846664,
0.15782064199447632,
0.15300844609737396,
0.07071153074502945,
0.3889935612678528,
0.3496733605861664,
-0.9037286639213562,
0.21060235798358917,
0.0010314960964024067,
0.026526907458901405,
-0.10458634048700333,
-0.508002758026123,
-0.2167576104402542,
-0.5612632036209106,
0.4270670413970947,
-0.2687864303588867,
0.18058092892169952,
0.11542998254299164,
0.09988758713006973,
-0.24250860512256622,
0.748133659362793,
0.6570581793785095,
0.8173491954803467,
-0.14259570837020874,
0.09257402271032333,
0.24282005429267883,
-0.2793329060077667,
0.04053330793976784,
0.19447863101959229,
-0.24058765172958374,
-0.5066092014312744,
0.3826088011264801,
0.5353649258613586,
0.31343111395835876,
-0.5117751359939575,
0.23502911627292633,
-0.044629015028476715,
-0.1854531317949295,
-0.5696044564247131,
-0.19201470911502838,
0.3007315993309021,
0.67274409532547,
0.6675344705581665,
-0.22215910255908966,
-0.08236994594335556,
-0.7128942012786865,
-0.21461455523967743,
0.26507630944252014,
-0.5712746381759644,
-0.2418314516544342,
0.5181573033332825,
0.6923384666442871,
-0.5075810551643372,
0.27636411786079407,
-0.46463000774383545,
-0.48530566692352295,
0.45132339000701904,
0.46133729815483093,
0.8057540655136108,
-0.23542898893356323,
0.2847050726413727,
0.261367529630661,
0.5307157039642334,
0.1963016539812088,
0.5650107860565186,
-0.09767632186412811,
-0.9140579104423523,
-0.6286876797676086,
-0.8114327788352966,
-0.2354169487953186,
0.04061136767268181,
-0.19616246223449707,
0.1036287397146225,
-0.5157654285430908,
0.016474759206175804,
-0.25963303446769714,
0.3193034529685974,
-0.5157473683357239,
-0.04047151654958725,
0.16477832198143005,
1.2650171518325806,
-0.7817968130111694,
0.7891278266906738,
1.1302884817123413,
-0.18186873197555542,
-1.025846242904663,
0.397040992975235,
-0.19990688562393188,
-0.7621007561683655,
0.22098268568515778,
-0.12415216118097305,
-0.06924977898597717,
-0.12812471389770508,
-0.5225231647491455,
-0.4873075485229492,
1.314606785774231,
0.24495337903499603,
-0.6765554547309875,
-0.0867466852068901,
0.3143184185028076,
0.5134490132331848,
-0.3603742718696594,
0.05927981808781624,
0.3670438230037689,
0.7681751251220703,
0.34525781869888306,
-1.0740326642990112,
0.14561371505260468,
0.24250946938991547,
-0.01990443468093872,
0.379304975271225,
-0.735847532749176,
0.7177509665489197,
-0.23635762929916382,
-0.08747275173664093,
0.20831534266471863,
0.754788339138031,
0.2456628978252411,
0.44368237257003784,
0.6356726884841919,
0.4423404037952423,
0.6813425421714783,
0.07058806717395782,
0.7548626065254211,
-0.3216603398323059,
0.15742778778076172,
0.8908183574676514,
-0.5499002933502197,
1.0424623489379883,
0.3836214542388916,
-0.2473350614309311,
0.3871547281742096,
0.23819957673549652,
0.49153611063957214,
0.5425536632537842,
0.14374753832817078,
-0.6654390096664429,
-0.4974248707294464,
-0.23223112523555756,
0.08113391697406769,
0.877509593963623,
0.3115442991256714,
0.3356873095035553,
-0.4863303303718567,
0.12742431461811066,
0.1336718648672104,
0.553267240524292,
-0.5196802020072937,
0.7805004715919495,
0.054007288068532944,
-0.40722349286079407,
-0.32855406403541565,
0.05545639991760254,
0.5738199949264526,
-0.5824339985847473,
-0.25469771027565,
-0.07678131759166718,
0.017101529985666275,
-0.15389114618301392,
-1.0987530946731567,
0.15124374628067017,
-0.2709704637527466,
-0.23372824490070343,
-0.4527924954891205,
0.6289242506027222,
-0.3480115830898285,
-0.3058551251888275,
0.4018856883049011,
0.4164891541004181,
-0.08484800904989243,
-0.1203584223985672,
-0.3886460065841675,
-0.15067943930625916,
-0.04829520359635353,
-0.11717204004526138,
0.3411417305469513,
0.6362981796264648,
-0.40928640961647034,
0.6574438214302063,
0.9165112376213074,
0.23554940521717072,
-0.22254228591918945,
0.01260093878954649,
0.8835544586181641,
-0.7330803275108337,
-0.5019463896751404,
-0.4919421374797821,
0.689797043800354,
-0.2571965157985687,
-0.020130759105086327,
0.3687492609024048,
0.6412025690078735,
0.608237087726593,
0.12854042649269104,
0.6774147152900696,
-0.06753285974264145,
0.3066457509994507,
-0.4895346164703369,
0.44130343198776245,
-0.28986799716949463,
0.5042389035224915,
0.06583847850561142,
-1.0628770589828491,
-0.1326238512992859,
0.40141528844833374,
-0.3330102562904358,
-0.09047140926122665,
0.22989754378795624,
0.5417696833610535,
0.06556110084056854,
-0.25933802127838135,
0.6464931964874268,
-0.04243651404976845,
0.6657288670539856,
0.7607980966567993,
0.8889698386192322,
0.29428184032440186,
0.10825344175100327,
0.08982541412115097,
-0.467286080121994,
-0.31047555804252625,
-0.6764118671417236,
-0.7056487798690796,
-0.41668766736984253,
0.08380220830440521,
0.11636143922805786,
0.02896989695727825,
1.2337431907653809,
0.7297332882881165,
-0.4329872131347656,
-0.2909395694732666,
-0.03258418291807175,
0.271369606256485,
0.030999643728137016,
-0.27451273798942566,
0.06666965782642365,
0.3138240873813629,
-0.7685347199440002,
0.557020366191864,
0.5253850817680359,
-0.05355924740433693,
-0.7983618378639221,
-0.40789932012557983,
-0.1437571942806244,
0.17978788912296295,
0.7383772134780884,
0.5651999711990356,
-0.5206572413444519,
-0.18500861525535583,
-0.3200450539588928,
-0.2117992341518402,
-0.043382540345191956,
0.963685154914856,
-0.6437551379203796,
0.3753044009208679,
0.2556401193141937,
0.2537282705307007,
0.44625258445739746,
-0.20941674709320068,
0.673496663570404,
-0.6966063380241394,
0.49865010380744934,
0.3338424861431122,
0.2604362368583679,
0.34616366028785706,
-0.42760559916496277,
0.46669575572013855,
-0.3689174950122833,
-0.751953661441803,
-0.43957990407943726,
0.5103673338890076,
-1.095827341079712,
-0.29092198610305786,
1.310241460800171,
0.19976651668548584,
-0.05096013844013214,
-0.15136156976222992,
-0.4839576780796051,
0.11342978477478027,
-0.7481252551078796,
0.7652214765548706,
0.39870303869247437,
-0.2864944338798523,
-0.15136203169822693,
-0.6094595193862915,
0.12992995977401733,
-0.2221796065568924,
-1.002724528312683,
0.16860142350196838,
0.4807361364364624,
-0.13157397508621216,
0.13127534091472626,
1.2167190313339233,
0.1060825064778328,
0.059299711138010025,
-0.1429273933172226,
0.5517237186431885,
-0.1778983175754547,
-0.331251323223114,
-0.052441295236349106,
0.175603985786438,
0.6683374643325806,
0.17892388999462128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01697v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01697v4 | APT-Pipe: A Prompt-Tuning Tool for Social Data Annotation using ChatGPT | 2024-01-24T10:09:11 | 2024-02-20T07:54:12 | Yiming Zhu, Zhizhuo Yin, Gareth Tyson, Ehsan-Ul Haq, Lik-Hang Lee, Pan Hui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent research has highlighted the potential of LLM applications, like
ChatGPT, for performing label annotation on social computing text. However, it
is already well known that performance hinges on the quality of the input
prompts. To address this, there has been a flurry of research into prompt
tuning -- techniques and guidelines that attempt to improve the quality of
prompts. Yet these largely rely on manual effort and prior knowledge of the
dataset being annotated. To address this limitation, we propose APT-Pipe, an
automated prompt-tuning pipeline. APT-Pipe aims to automatically tune prompts
to enhance ChatGPT's text classification performance on any given dataset. We
implement APT-Pipe and test it across twelve distinct text classification
datasets. We find that prompts tuned by APT-Pipe help ChatGPT achieve higher
weighted F1-score on nine out of twelve experimented datasets, with an
improvement of 7.01% on average. We further highlight APT-Pipe's flexibility as
a framework by showing how it can be extended to support additional tuning
mechanisms. | [
-0.5609078407287598,
-0.6685344576835632,
0.394440621137619,
0.2504308223724365,
-0.6614758372306824,
0.4708760380744934,
-0.06176525354385376,
-0.08680140972137451,
0.48087647557258606,
0.2096145749092102,
-0.7377156615257263,
-0.6107608079910278,
-0.7981500029563904,
0.36695754528045654,
-0.3040071129798889,
1.4208166599273682,
0.35858601331710815,
-0.2601863443851471,
0.03731594234704971,
0.10080448538064957,
-0.8872294425964355,
-0.13101918995380402,
-1.1725871562957764,
-0.0066776885651052,
1.0315485000610352,
0.7728404402732849,
0.9587137699127197,
1.0288711786270142,
0.5890747904777527,
0.22843165695667267,
-0.008405403234064579,
0.3573662042617798,
-0.5958106517791748,
0.5593636631965637,
-0.026089899241924286,
-0.28888317942619324,
-0.19278183579444885,
-0.028263425454497337,
0.584959864616394,
0.23662512004375458,
0.3361961245536804,
0.28222018480300903,
0.2709531784057617,
0.7447172403335571,
-0.4796541929244995,
0.4547994136810303,
-0.7052307724952698,
-0.13677379488945007,
-0.3680366277694702,
-0.6522745490074158,
-0.30805397033691406,
-0.7890604138374329,
-0.15520134568214417,
-0.7224521636962891,
0.1634473204612732,
0.438723623752594,
0.7948368191719055,
0.8296791315078735,
-0.18316109478473663,
-0.17422540485858917,
-0.30042484402656555,
0.2851969003677368,
-0.30307987332344055,
0.15676294267177582,
0.483456015586853,
0.48562225699424744,
-0.12385335564613342,
-0.667582631111145,
-0.23211482167243958,
0.19272908568382263,
-0.042030218988657,
0.05947912111878395,
0.043915219604969025,
0.10452162474393845,
0.21162614226341248,
0.1511591374874115,
-0.5866187214851379,
0.03547043353319168,
-0.23927651345729828,
-0.37224745750427246,
0.6838740110397339,
0.06170377880334854,
0.3091987371444702,
-0.1759473979473114,
-0.029014650732278824,
-0.17649467289447784,
-0.5905528664588928,
0.023596951737999916,
0.4819706678390503,
0.6486403346061707,
0.00846933200955391,
0.6090843677520752,
-0.36728307604789734,
0.6391066312789917,
-0.008819403126835823,
0.36991065740585327,
0.18573442101478577,
-0.0701466053724289,
0.11169788241386414,
0.5594826936721802,
0.7832702398300171,
0.5612647533416748,
0.6251773834228516,
0.06256198137998581,
-0.07990463823080063,
0.15186800062656403,
0.08959772437810898,
-0.912849485874176,
-0.7628202438354492,
0.1967596709728241,
-0.14286969602108002,
-0.5645660161972046,
0.05091681331396103,
-0.6083916425704956,
-0.9170644879341125,
-0.37430810928344727,
0.34420254826545715,
-0.38216346502304077,
-0.02443905547261238,
-0.24461475014686584,
-0.5784050822257996,
0.07081443071365356,
0.39197105169296265,
-0.7802438735961914,
-0.1021871343255043,
1.1625176668167114,
1.2418420314788818,
-0.07618086785078049,
-0.20856834948062897,
-1.2676782608032227,
-0.2297343909740448,
-0.27813199162483215,
1.298465371131897,
-0.9120681881904602,
-0.27647581696510315,
-0.10268139839172363,
0.10690724104642868,
0.030262205749750137,
-0.08687666058540344,
0.7575892210006714,
-0.3167994022369385,
0.12970639765262604,
-0.5356336832046509,
-0.7360275387763977,
0.23891466856002808,
-0.011958776041865349,
-0.42469125986099243,
1.0813864469528198,
0.015526305884122849,
-0.9941919445991516,
0.6451563835144043,
-0.7265917658805847,
-0.5007452964782715,
0.44988611340522766,
0.06539686024188995,
-0.49168670177459717,
-0.07821255922317505,
0.4496152997016907,
0.6616750359535217,
-0.08719746768474579,
0.15049928426742554,
-0.6218143701553345,
-0.7506935000419617,
0.16174602508544922,
-0.41643643379211426,
0.727744460105896,
0.3314703702926636,
-0.13719536364078522,
0.308682382106781,
-0.5050540566444397,
0.001689577242359519,
-0.3301573693752289,
-0.13650164008140564,
-0.2405392974615097,
-0.05157031863927841,
-0.05290982499718666,
-0.3056659698486328,
0.05755893886089325,
-0.5392956137657166,
0.272621750831604,
-0.3980507254600525,
0.6644746661186218,
1.1304271221160889,
0.02551795169711113,
0.26106685400009155,
-0.5413616299629211,
0.5620913505554199,
-0.46513354778289795,
0.1455366611480713,
-0.35006484389305115,
-1.0788228511810303,
-0.41605621576309204,
-0.5418680906295776,
0.556688666343689,
0.7195990681648254,
-0.7913513779640198,
0.4940837323665619,
-0.34122273325920105,
-0.5816470384597778,
-0.8197834491729736,
0.08742845058441162,
-0.04035118222236633,
0.48088034987449646,
0.0661279708147049,
-0.1672615259885788,
-0.38933995366096497,
-0.5394111275672913,
-0.442219614982605,
-0.4325263500213623,
-0.27405279874801636,
0.49546459317207336,
0.05090327933430672,
-0.060079965740442276,
1.1923779249191284,
-0.6162745356559753,
-0.2909088730812073,
0.15273579955101013,
0.36137643456459045,
0.1863696426153183,
0.1842586100101471,
0.32370781898498535,
-0.6029248237609863,
-0.7434881925582886,
0.08629893511533737,
-0.22865167260169983,
-0.7415552139282227,
0.20335598289966583,
-0.35632631182670593,
0.01820201799273491,
0.33858180046081543,
-0.40590840578079224,
0.2203061282634735,
0.4446219801902771,
-0.7125850319862366,
0.5003958344459534,
-0.04518743231892586,
0.3936563730239868,
-0.9351959228515625,
-0.1518392264842987,
0.1067468598484993,
-0.43980103731155396,
-0.21476677060127258,
-0.4450395107269287,
0.09811240434646606,
-0.46083369851112366,
-0.25716888904571533,
0.7100086808204651,
-0.04158659651875496,
0.14391295611858368,
-0.31317564845085144,
0.1978551298379898,
-0.012353525497019291,
0.0906171202659607,
-0.19855360686779022,
0.8911641240119934,
0.7720661163330078,
-0.414024293422699,
0.5891343355178833,
0.03676419332623482,
-0.017151903361082077,
0.7930163741111755,
-0.6992829442024231,
0.255836546421051,
-0.24105259776115417,
0.17313185334205627,
-1.661730170249939,
-0.44980284571647644,
0.4990001916885376,
-0.7760372757911682,
0.17938271164894104,
-0.44799908995628357,
-0.5867236256599426,
-0.12248776108026505,
-0.5971086621284485,
-0.03458763659000397,
0.6137357950210571,
-0.582737922668457,
0.3076702654361725,
0.2279863953590393,
-0.4316747188568115,
-0.33145871758461,
-0.18495094776153564,
0.03798960894346237,
-0.5463080406188965,
-0.710961639881134,
0.17217424511909485,
-0.13801206648349762,
0.17063046991825104,
-0.058074165135622025,
0.08035384863615036,
-0.05003483593463898,
0.18120257556438446,
0.3902137279510498,
0.0013046193635091186,
0.11613143235445023,
0.36822131276130676,
0.38864782452583313,
-0.40718650817871094,
-0.07775309681892395,
-0.18738523125648499,
0.3889165222644806,
0.05959607660770416,
-0.09621012210845947,
-0.5446150302886963,
-0.0808173418045044,
0.3255142569541931,
-0.05239790678024292,
0.35198864340782166,
1.02765691280365,
-0.08486606180667877,
-0.1330772489309311,
-0.41710251569747925,
-0.3584607243537903,
-0.5536530017852783,
-0.06393584609031677,
-0.16483274102210999,
-1.0193461179733276,
0.3655667006969452,
-0.269928514957428,
0.24752138555049896,
0.09993340820074081,
0.2438277304172516,
-0.38011598587036133,
1.1548633575439453,
0.3184473514556885,
-0.29953882098197937,
0.7415081858634949,
0.1827564388513565,
0.10295678675174713,
-0.4682686924934387,
0.3158451318740845,
-0.8368749022483826,
-0.4135504961013794,
-0.6958050727844238,
-0.2424009144306183,
0.44244080781936646,
-0.09063103795051575,
-0.45536163449287415,
0.12384401261806488,
-1.1162086725234985,
0.6817870140075684,
0.5346686244010925,
0.09590432792901993,
0.25337499380111694,
-0.06624670326709747,
0.31126296520233154,
0.10333971679210663,
-0.6688259243965149,
-0.6061702370643616,
0.8646318912506104,
0.37255942821502686,
0.587382435798645,
-0.30283376574516296,
0.6810997128486633,
0.615624189376831,
0.4635861814022064,
-0.7902940511703491,
0.38977059721946716,
-0.18937960267066956,
-0.3846355974674225,
-0.4745909571647644,
-0.4391694664955139,
-0.9958998560905457,
-0.18075500428676605,
-0.03803686425089836,
-0.5372921228408813,
-0.027374936267733574,
0.5929458737373352,
-0.30864977836608887,
-0.08705811202526093,
-1.0410996675491333,
0.800983190536499,
-0.07334038615226746,
-0.13666588068008423,
0.2626817524433136,
-0.56365966796875,
-0.01077943667769432,
0.05257713794708252,
0.1598159372806549,
-0.5251046419143677,
-0.19561639428138733,
0.6165210604667664,
-0.5389851331710815,
0.9992719888687134,
-0.47047847509384155,
0.02215438336133957,
0.2795918583869934,
-0.059779372066259384,
0.7688044905662537,
0.4843060076236725,
-0.16524547338485718,
0.13526298105716705,
0.18049052357673645,
-0.23343650996685028,
-0.705619752407074,
0.7005133032798767,
-0.6614792943000793,
-0.450623482465744,
-0.28956636786460876,
-0.2489093840122223,
-0.03459257632493973,
0.003598471637815237,
0.32915621995925903,
0.34703049063682556,
0.2875041663646698,
0.25466111302375793,
0.600631833076477,
-0.11706904321908951,
0.3229902982711792,
0.028029480949044228,
-0.16196313500404358,
-0.5496006011962891,
1.0357551574707031,
0.11709042638540268,
-0.11717844754457474,
0.39330995082855225,
0.472385972738266,
-0.6090589165687561,
-0.14588525891304016,
-0.7008863687515259,
-0.07830419391393661,
-0.5700446963310242,
-0.5644988417625427,
-0.5267256498336792,
-0.043206144124269485,
-0.4071943759918213,
-0.32744869589805603,
-0.2488487958908081,
-0.5668579936027527,
-0.4818550646305084,
-0.017486441880464554,
1.2910232543945312,
0.3954896032810211,
0.014259439893066883,
0.5110207796096802,
-0.528846025466919,
0.11520092934370041,
0.4273868501186371,
0.6933163404464722,
-0.3393573462963104,
-0.36184680461883545,
0.07200047373771667,
0.02010120265185833,
-0.2641374468803406,
-0.8323491811752319,
0.14517998695373535,
0.531282365322113,
0.06348076462745667,
0.35782337188720703,
0.4918319582939148,
0.5692221522331238,
-0.41884100437164307,
0.7025120854377747,
-0.24698929488658905,
-0.8350282311439514,
0.857792317867279,
-0.5662308931350708,
0.4138740003108978,
0.5801790356636047,
0.3350675106048584,
-0.6426437497138977,
-0.6385006308555603,
-0.25791147351264954,
-0.8877086639404297,
0.5915210247039795,
0.2784263789653778,
0.07697807997465134,
-0.14441457390785217,
0.5115772485733032,
0.29858335852622986,
0.16253818571567535,
-0.3645400106906891,
-0.3233289122581482,
-0.465487539768219,
-0.40300092101097107,
-0.12280983477830887,
-0.02340564876794815,
0.21576115489006042,
-0.38666149973869324,
0.6476632952690125,
-0.44930702447891235,
0.1494106501340866,
0.12696874141693115,
0.29246652126312256,
-0.07141589373350143,
0.11355414241552353,
0.06378885358572006,
0.5041776299476624,
-0.11471201479434967,
0.11459650844335556,
0.06143060699105263,
-0.4777665436267853,
0.03478079289197922,
0.3063185214996338,
-0.28893324732780457,
0.15268421173095703,
0.08770142495632172,
0.9490718245506287,
-0.010727794840931892,
-0.4325377345085144,
0.26503896713256836,
-0.3813464343547821,
0.047983698546886444,
-0.02762593701481819,
0.525867223739624,
0.007214491255581379,
0.07628995925188065,
0.4123627543449402,
-0.04734204709529877,
0.2715253531932831,
-0.3054487705230713,
0.15991531312465668,
0.42976465821266174,
-0.5779695510864258,
-0.05310388281941414,
0.6067622900009155,
0.3064081072807312,
-0.8265371918678284,
0.519271969795227,
-0.4425031542778015,
-0.3777207136154175,
0.5302605032920837,
0.012290406972169876,
1.065392017364502,
-0.12014651298522949,
0.5394826531410217,
0.18456411361694336,
0.1364915370941162,
0.1465388387441635,
0.33767154812812805,
-0.27906620502471924,
-0.425014466047287,
-0.6130871772766113,
-0.5717830061912537,
-0.594286322593689,
-0.3185822665691376,
-0.2521305978298187,
0.8290615081787109,
-0.3751465976238251,
-0.26414230465888977,
0.2355697602033615,
0.04273229464888573,
-0.5820510387420654,
-0.03387582302093506,
-0.11693057417869568,
0.6805598735809326,
-0.8957282900810242,
0.5440159440040588,
0.9201648831367493,
0.17715489864349365,
-0.7651404142379761,
-0.18921229243278503,
0.06626340746879578,
-0.6792380213737488,
0.3005436360836029,
0.3989696204662323,
-0.0417444221675396,
0.4259396195411682,
-0.5844550728797913,
-0.7232041358947754,
0.9944533705711365,
0.42204058170318604,
-0.5878060460090637,
0.44233542680740356,
0.09438429772853851,
0.5326557159423828,
-0.26829373836517334,
0.5826583504676819,
0.3941761553287506,
0.7423166632652283,
0.21156251430511475,
-0.9967367649078369,
0.03433552384376526,
-0.37418726086616516,
-0.0009362989221699536,
0.2635945975780487,
-0.7133763432502747,
0.4140608012676239,
0.125404492020607,
-0.3540462255477905,
-0.25668391585350037,
0.21981924772262573,
0.5037974715232849,
0.705566942691803,
0.6035729050636292,
0.29072701930999756,
1.0226542949676514,
-0.4381691813468933,
0.8292943239212036,
-0.43441399931907654,
0.2725663185119629,
0.8624509572982788,
-0.2025545835494995,
0.42113715410232544,
0.22177225351333618,
0.03665364533662796,
0.1212906613945961,
1.1141695976257324,
0.05011245235800743,
0.4957447052001953,
0.22615182399749756,
-0.04635965824127197,
-0.17749318480491638,
-0.31194543838500977,
-0.3897228240966797,
0.15155276656150818,
0.28468406200408936,
-0.219516322016716,
-0.010385529138147831,
-0.028828075155615807,
0.06301876157522202,
-0.19502109289169312,
-0.4151257276535034,
0.9574693441390991,
0.04545034095644951,
-0.7187632918357849,
0.5051140189170837,
-0.34833502769470215,
0.8119542598724365,
-0.3030393421649933,
-0.17485862970352173,
-0.17438405752182007,
-0.21030250191688538,
-0.29234620928764343,
-0.979515790939331,
0.3283226191997528,
0.02633439004421234,
0.0013890600530430675,
-0.3545457124710083,
1.0625888109207153,
-0.006465668324381113,
-0.4602823555469513,
-0.10915413498878479,
0.1675177663564682,
0.3648199439048767,
-0.38936740159988403,
-0.6634719371795654,
0.32505765557289124,
0.008767220191657543,
-0.13069480657577515,
0.07210707664489746,
1.0384849309921265,
0.14152850210666656,
0.8804583549499512,
0.7140306830406189,
0.25348490476608276,
0.007742782589048147,
0.16596190631389618,
0.8841765522956848,
-0.474361777305603,
-0.7205414772033691,
-1.0184983015060425,
0.5442978739738464,
-0.30419787764549255,
-0.5345408916473389,
0.5560317039489746,
0.4971790313720703,
0.6282182335853577,
0.1889200657606125,
0.9103059768676758,
-0.09407179802656174,
0.6345124840736389,
-0.2757795751094818,
0.7779649496078491,
-0.2822173535823822,
0.36467722058296204,
-0.5807504057884216,
-1.0215787887573242,
-0.31098806858062744,
0.606891393661499,
-0.32110264897346497,
-0.10428692400455475,
0.4957701563835144,
0.8898202776908875,
0.05775793641805649,
0.34456178545951843,
-0.05595933273434639,
-0.1856638342142105,
0.4277699589729309,
0.16414515674114227,
0.8028877973556519,
-0.17639751732349396,
0.7055500149726868,
-0.28910350799560547,
-0.3110371530056,
-0.2145961970090866,
-1.173118233680725,
-0.997795045375824,
-0.6181618571281433,
-0.6957845091819763,
-0.1114363819360733,
0.40341708064079285,
0.8609145879745483,
0.8397920727729797,
-0.5271421074867249,
0.10571695119142532,
-0.17654949426651,
0.3303191065788269,
-0.14061236381530762,
-0.3471185863018036,
0.32640257477760315,
-0.712685227394104,
-0.5460296869277954,
-0.032558098435401917,
0.3682049810886383,
-0.21759216487407684,
-0.09565363079309464,
0.0339699313044548,
0.2898140549659729,
-0.21572750806808472,
0.5865375995635986,
0.03719428554177284,
-0.2546358108520508,
-0.6272556781768799,
-0.0865732878446579,
0.34652605652809143,
0.05746277794241905,
0.6493802666664124,
-0.8474981784820557,
0.425422340631485,
0.6674664616584778,
0.6718629002571106,
0.20976537466049194,
0.38582727313041687,
0.49957141280174255,
-1.1527175903320312,
-0.20665618777275085,
0.19436447322368622,
0.09946462512016296,
0.42677828669548035,
-0.8384273052215576,
0.5412895679473877,
0.0989515408873558,
-1.049880862236023,
-0.8203928470611572,
-0.08943379670381546,
-0.7769953012466431,
-0.15866032242774963,
1.1955076456069946,
0.05666390433907509,
-0.07364680618047714,
-0.4153127670288086,
-0.7609878778457642,
0.4011719822883606,
-1.0573270320892334,
1.086565375328064,
0.8042510747909546,
-0.18181554973125458,
-0.39447006583213806,
-0.44300806522369385,
0.7443963885307312,
0.2544207274913788,
-0.7546660304069519,
0.22356241941452026,
0.4815705120563507,
0.2138826996088028,
-0.10180709511041641,
0.7340009808540344,
0.3622824549674988,
0.2340572327375412,
-0.395175039768219,
-0.4029189348220825,
-0.08810856938362122,
-0.35842910408973694,
-0.11029613763093948,
0.11010564118623734,
0.28180184960365295,
-0.17661428451538086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13313v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13313v1 | InstructDoc: A Dataset for Zero-Shot Generalization of Visual Document Understanding with Instructions | 2024-01-24T09:09:37 | 2024-01-24T09:09:37 | Ryota Tanaka, Taichi Iki, Kyosuke Nishida, Kuniko Saito, Jun Suzuki | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We study the problem of completing various visual document understanding
(VDU) tasks, e.g., question answering and information extraction, on real-world
documents through human-written instructions. To this end, we propose
InstructDoc, the first large-scale collection of 30 publicly available VDU
datasets, each with diverse instructions in a unified format, which covers a
wide range of 12 tasks and includes open document types/formats. Furthermore,
to enhance the generalization performance on VDU tasks, we design a new
instruction-based document reading and understanding model, InstructDr, that
connects document images, image encoders, and large language models (LLMs)
through a trainable bridging module. Experiments demonstrate that InstructDr
can effectively adapt to new VDU datasets, tasks, and domains via given
instructions and outperforms existing multimodal LLMs and ChatGPT without
specific training. | [
-0.20981451869010925,
-0.6351669430732727,
0.6942210793495178,
-0.05905880033969879,
-0.2229272425174713,
0.0019397977739572525,
-0.12217143923044205,
-0.10144497454166412,
-0.299792617559433,
0.6140732765197754,
-0.6598175764083862,
-0.9032161831855774,
-0.5895886421203613,
-0.17353519797325134,
-0.41506314277648926,
0.8794878721237183,
-0.11366792023181915,
0.14689642190933228,
-0.815873920917511,
-0.015529815107584,
-0.4150157868862152,
0.05605446174740791,
-0.24386870861053467,
-0.1982683390378952,
0.33619096875190735,
0.8926382064819336,
0.3165573477745056,
0.7472716569900513,
0.5766720175743103,
0.20683367550373077,
0.2994753420352936,
0.02788049355149269,
-0.47546276450157166,
-0.10924027115106583,
-0.2395569384098053,
-0.693612277507782,
-0.16365361213684082,
-0.06809788197278976,
0.4822113811969757,
0.7224138379096985,
-0.19583222270011902,
0.07395630329847336,
-0.05672838166356087,
0.341733455657959,
-0.6872463822364807,
0.4001544713973999,
-0.3077680766582489,
-0.07025055587291718,
0.10807837545871735,
-0.2638208866119385,
-0.617267370223999,
-0.10287714749574661,
0.1491057276725769,
-0.9135470390319824,
0.7292893528938293,
-0.1392182558774948,
0.6590002775192261,
0.000510240497533232,
-0.4182692766189575,
-0.4873464107513428,
-0.6214838027954102,
0.5334262847900391,
-0.32548919320106506,
0.4378693699836731,
0.3219556510448456,
0.5317603945732117,
-0.05422437563538551,
-0.84641432762146,
-0.57523512840271,
-0.0015699497889727354,
0.09920333325862885,
0.5607998967170715,
-0.13084521889686584,
0.35515183210372925,
0.36463215947151184,
0.39959225058555603,
-0.8413335084915161,
0.1568204015493393,
-0.5625229477882385,
0.24057258665561676,
0.2166220098733902,
0.1883714646100998,
0.42219558358192444,
-0.040355220437049866,
-0.37423741817474365,
-0.1631886512041092,
-0.6261069774627686,
-0.04834010452032089,
0.14497382938861847,
-0.18308454751968384,
-0.37080463767051697,
0.44885796308517456,
-0.3433402478694916,
1.0169346332550049,
-0.2105625569820404,
0.09958154708147049,
-0.04633285477757454,
-0.24744486808776855,
-0.5824001431465149,
-0.019446494057774544,
0.5289451479911804,
0.3467849791049957,
0.31182149052619934,
-0.3882400691509247,
0.08793029189109802,
-0.04207468405365944,
0.6256939768791199,
-0.9184126257896423,
-0.1637408584356308,
0.011762701906263828,
-0.39016616344451904,
-0.2625977396965027,
0.1829935759305954,
-0.6917828917503357,
-0.49266883730888367,
-0.6582087278366089,
0.5100634098052979,
-0.5453055500984192,
0.18312400579452515,
0.25728821754455566,
-0.3427617847919464,
0.6946819424629211,
0.792575478553772,
-0.9201934933662415,
0.39606308937072754,
0.7022702693939209,
0.8402442336082458,
0.2529040575027466,
-0.35566896200180054,
-0.630526065826416,
0.30256691575050354,
-0.3292218744754791,
0.9092141389846802,
-0.6049159169197083,
-0.6551783680915833,
0.06633715331554413,
0.3226068317890167,
-0.11620500683784485,
-0.31625986099243164,
0.4815059304237366,
-0.2189706265926361,
0.3272307515144348,
-0.045660585165023804,
-0.6665404438972473,
-0.17517955601215363,
0.2445208728313446,
-0.3567444086074829,
0.30660757422447205,
0.28327956795692444,
-0.693116307258606,
0.2534831464290619,
-0.6745779514312744,
-0.4165966212749481,
0.331149160861969,
-0.6169408559799194,
-0.06756608933210373,
0.07978010922670364,
0.4653564989566803,
0.6814746260643005,
-0.48757901787757874,
-0.1885669231414795,
-0.26444822549819946,
-0.6382297873497009,
-0.18409757316112518,
-0.35725635290145874,
0.78794926404953,
0.06071261316537857,
-0.1180606409907341,
0.2033618539571762,
-0.6352956295013428,
-0.2379753589630127,
0.15942402184009552,
-0.1177908405661583,
-0.38450637459754944,
-0.26202481985092163,
-0.16435562074184418,
-0.10195021331310272,
-0.06725633889436722,
-0.7893348336219788,
0.6031544804573059,
-0.1279328167438507,
0.4349123537540436,
0.7958782315254211,
0.10332783311605453,
0.5598240494728088,
-0.09116575866937637,
0.7349309325218201,
-0.027745716273784637,
0.24249906837940216,
-0.6570106148719788,
-0.5527456998825073,
-0.7096851468086243,
-0.3157001733779907,
0.07474707812070847,
0.5674400925636292,
-0.8865818977355957,
-0.07544977962970734,
-0.43846961855888367,
-0.43533778190612793,
-0.6018947958946228,
0.13740554451942444,
0.5927096009254456,
0.9627419114112854,
0.18897856771945953,
-0.08785498887300491,
-0.0334894061088562,
-0.847808837890625,
0.2741132080554962,
0.15937580168247223,
-0.2765365540981293,
0.19253599643707275,
0.6058861613273621,
-0.2103746384382248,
0.586639404296875,
-0.682927668094635,
-0.33909010887145996,
-0.19198071956634521,
0.39566051959991455,
0.23844164609909058,
0.22702869772911072,
0.42834699153900146,
-0.6537154316902161,
-0.43490251898765564,
0.2534337043762207,
-1.0969992876052856,
0.1425662785768509,
-0.4038422703742981,
-0.18667274713516235,
-0.14581365883350372,
0.8981857895851135,
-0.3966746926307678,
0.4789518713951111,
0.27941566705703735,
-0.17171302437782288,
0.2575789988040924,
-0.7167898416519165,
0.29441922903060913,
-1.0673160552978516,
-0.25435176491737366,
0.20357877016067505,
-0.1065865084528923,
-0.4743003845214844,
0.06380733102560043,
0.5610111951828003,
-0.4065394401550293,
-0.49343353509902954,
0.4928549528121948,
-0.6746311783790588,
0.01876392774283886,
0.07750369608402252,
0.09020344913005829,
0.14664609730243683,
0.5803320407867432,
0.06372352689504623,
0.6418310403823853,
0.7726191878318787,
-0.28545981645584106,
0.46084901690483093,
0.5002251863479614,
-0.39903315901756287,
0.948421835899353,
-0.6903451085090637,
0.29931628704071045,
-0.7027717232704163,
-0.05271822214126587,
-0.9022299647331238,
-0.3669491112232208,
0.23523184657096863,
-0.2999899387359619,
0.5164803266525269,
-0.5617660880088806,
-0.3699273467063904,
-0.2619033455848694,
-0.21437731385231018,
-0.06149262189865112,
0.3390903174877167,
-0.6999489665031433,
0.48321613669395447,
-0.015631478279829025,
0.03970383107662201,
-0.5533215999603271,
-0.6940804123878479,
-0.044797349721193314,
0.1797957718372345,
-0.5601412057876587,
0.2631394565105438,
-0.1636701226234436,
-0.05312006548047066,
0.21514877676963806,
-0.019610827788710594,
-0.11557089537382126,
-0.18381500244140625,
0.6875869631767273,
0.21149411797523499,
-0.02413789927959442,
0.20109149813652039,
0.235879048705101,
-0.024442452937364578,
-0.19101375341415405,
-0.435772180557251,
0.1744614839553833,
-0.03963671997189522,
-0.6441925764083862,
-0.42774391174316406,
0.41215622425079346,
0.5845337510108948,
-0.3261745870113373,
0.49724891781806946,
0.42769426107406616,
-0.293684720993042,
-0.4902532994747162,
-0.19128446280956268,
0.16512617468833923,
-0.43844887614250183,
0.3029493987560272,
-0.3928234875202179,
-0.7085936069488525,
0.05663081258535385,
-0.10701888799667358,
0.17612794041633606,
0.07533847540616989,
0.37239858508110046,
-0.5708980560302734,
0.4940197765827179,
0.7807800769805908,
0.11069713532924652,
0.6334674954414368,
-0.7717006802558899,
-0.14430181682109833,
-0.627082109451294,
-0.2968581020832062,
-0.2269292026758194,
-0.11063969880342484,
-0.2025037407875061,
-0.6092714071273804,
0.29383280873298645,
-0.05199247971177101,
0.02453146129846573,
0.30294886231422424,
-0.6692637801170349,
0.778527557849884,
0.6752731204032898,
0.2309790700674057,
0.17826129496097565,
0.11666115373373032,
0.10520628839731216,
0.16970059275627136,
-0.5258564352989197,
-0.23424981534481049,
1.4181199073791504,
0.055473584681749344,
0.9695255160331726,
-0.22061049938201904,
0.7678009867668152,
0.4425773024559021,
0.1759185791015625,
-0.7810266017913818,
0.38039106130599976,
-0.42168062925338745,
-0.17235596477985382,
-0.17308157682418823,
-0.21308238804340363,
-0.983359158039093,
0.13147275149822235,
-0.04871522635221481,
-0.5178216099739075,
0.28716006875038147,
-0.010676796548068523,
-0.1331852376461029,
0.15957985818386078,
-1.027142882347107,
1.1153664588928223,
-0.2866310179233551,
-0.17294223606586456,
-0.27943477034568787,
-0.5267488360404968,
0.2989254593849182,
0.32496437430381775,
0.07329356670379639,
0.3118305802345276,
0.08146264404058456,
0.5197677612304688,
-0.30567601323127747,
0.7779096364974976,
-0.2532401978969574,
0.13258863985538483,
0.18821831047534943,
-0.07855899631977081,
0.2927350401878357,
-0.07410493493080139,
0.011693309061229229,
0.03164367750287056,
0.09787512570619583,
-0.49578872323036194,
-0.9367771744728088,
0.658629298210144,
-0.7159395217895508,
-0.32800427079200745,
-0.24763038754463196,
-0.6046034693717957,
-0.07441941648721695,
0.15625886619091034,
0.441284716129303,
0.9670102000236511,
-0.47246870398521423,
0.48258134722709656,
1.075308084487915,
-0.21054910123348236,
0.18234147131443024,
0.45754656195640564,
0.16834132373332977,
-0.3388891816139221,
0.9978333115577698,
0.08701056241989136,
0.29243284463882446,
0.7572144269943237,
-0.08256638050079346,
-0.006140700075775385,
-0.6386162638664246,
-0.6753738522529602,
0.18421570956707,
-0.8724328279495239,
0.012747049331665039,
-0.597915768623352,
-0.14051757752895355,
-0.3929676115512848,
-0.5129648447036743,
0.03187292069196701,
-0.01302312221378088,
-0.39771151542663574,
-0.20762912929058075,
0.24564503133296967,
0.9148803353309631,
0.15689581632614136,
0.6173324584960938,
-0.5663084983825684,
0.6934319734573364,
0.5716701149940491,
0.32398733496665955,
-0.29072168469429016,
-0.38840192556381226,
-0.4265282154083252,
-0.0705714300274849,
-0.1840716451406479,
-0.7861000895500183,
0.13201086223125458,
0.14147146046161652,
0.6824915409088135,
0.6506961584091187,
-0.07275008410215378,
0.4215015172958374,
-0.36847150325775146,
0.329395055770874,
0.1449200063943863,
-0.581352949142456,
0.6694808602333069,
-0.5371816158294678,
0.6146669387817383,
0.4309875965118408,
0.5425121188163757,
-0.6891680955886841,
-0.11591976135969162,
-0.4697052538394928,
-0.5276333689689636,
0.8711018562316895,
0.042510103434324265,
0.07107291370630264,
0.21997825801372528,
0.39844074845314026,
0.21111547946929932,
0.19236443936824799,
-0.07650963962078094,
0.2668554484844208,
-0.30040663480758667,
-0.5056518316268921,
-0.09585173428058624,
-0.1761281043291092,
-0.28198403120040894,
-0.30262160301208496,
0.21606989204883575,
-0.24906352162361145,
0.3195274770259857,
0.2712312340736389,
-0.46301841735839844,
0.15943917632102966,
0.1920395791530609,
0.5672205686569214,
0.731989860534668,
-0.4802018702030182,
0.1137533113360405,
-0.11572590470314026,
-0.6568989157676697,
-0.052596498280763626,
0.028773654252290726,
-0.26826274394989014,
-0.18311373889446259,
0.7389730215072632,
0.903052806854248,
0.27824467420578003,
-0.5994695425033569,
0.6412038207054138,
-0.36985376477241516,
-0.4517309367656708,
-0.19129756093025208,
0.2494809478521347,
0.12342285364866257,
0.09087666124105453,
-0.038933347910642624,
-0.21894413232803345,
0.04307618737220764,
-0.5533559322357178,
0.1648375242948532,
0.32644355297088623,
-0.5516771078109741,
-0.1760307401418686,
0.7115638256072998,
0.2558128833770752,
-0.17271658778190613,
0.8596878051757812,
-0.3012097477912903,
0.08384924381971359,
0.8171294331550598,
0.32139694690704346,
0.7594081163406372,
0.19868211448192596,
0.6333105564117432,
0.15623600780963898,
0.47323498129844666,
0.17540325224399567,
0.41254308819770813,
-0.46076399087905884,
-0.41441810131073,
-0.12707199156284332,
-0.41611573100090027,
-0.8050172328948975,
0.03512067347764969,
-0.6265279650688171,
0.2157205194234848,
-0.6682137250900269,
0.5500743985176086,
0.07442756742238998,
-0.2440072000026703,
-0.8560479879379272,
0.2445194125175476,
0.012580658309161663,
0.8098928332328796,
-0.7314369082450867,
1.0338964462280273,
0.625182032585144,
-0.8123223781585693,
-0.365471750497818,
-0.06944886595010757,
0.0625854954123497,
-0.6206272840499878,
0.4628874957561493,
0.13362722098827362,
-0.05942220985889435,
0.03166348859667778,
-0.9028608202934265,
-0.09337279200553894,
1.3148033618927002,
0.5895151495933533,
-0.5903505086898804,
-0.2179068773984909,
0.18963053822517395,
0.4117400348186493,
-0.3609318733215332,
0.3620256781578064,
0.17747116088867188,
0.23063026368618011,
0.20758621394634247,
-0.3096276819705963,
-0.30766886472702026,
-0.29499784111976624,
-0.11546149104833603,
-0.025338994339108467,
-0.312565416097641,
0.7676945924758911,
-0.2794409692287445,
-0.288943350315094,
-0.17847725749015808,
0.47950929403305054,
-0.25848090648651123,
0.2961519956588745,
0.29211437702178955,
0.6506825089454651,
0.656719446182251,
0.02312478981912136,
1.3016726970672607,
0.028631970286369324,
-0.047564782202243805,
1.4940156936645508,
0.15912553668022156,
0.4240753948688507,
0.19781920313835144,
0.028656085953116417,
0.3379298150539398,
0.3327416181564331,
-0.2776361405849457,
0.41195744276046753,
0.006168730556964874,
-0.21773067116737366,
-0.30147817730903625,
-0.09506633877754211,
-0.19455642998218536,
0.3942306935787201,
0.32465603947639465,
-0.3267470598220825,
-0.46819353103637695,
0.09643793851137161,
-0.12868839502334595,
0.0969519317150116,
-0.27821773290634155,
0.7798347473144531,
-0.057825833559036255,
-0.2316771149635315,
0.3940922021865845,
-0.19823722541332245,
0.4947793483734131,
-0.7696203589439392,
-0.449096143245697,
-0.2728387713432312,
0.17299970984458923,
-0.18523985147476196,
-1.203373908996582,
-0.022752150893211365,
0.025875868275761604,
-0.31063857674598694,
-0.41543111205101013,
0.6710419654846191,
-0.43444713950157166,
-0.6291559934616089,
0.3620283305644989,
0.30463987588882446,
0.21230562031269073,
-0.25099873542785645,
-0.1886628419160843,
-0.3034505546092987,
-0.05681762099266052,
0.05714443325996399,
0.5142739415168762,
0.5952156186103821,
-0.1593283712863922,
0.6814355850219727,
0.5597962141036987,
-0.11068344116210938,
0.06425882875919342,
0.2806517481803894,
0.6700688004493713,
-0.5056212544441223,
-0.3165395259857178,
-0.35935455560684204,
0.5581474900245667,
-0.18461129069328308,
-0.315878301858902,
0.5299827456474304,
0.45506560802459717,
1.1085259914398193,
-0.49061909317970276,
0.8601307272911072,
0.10631334781646729,
0.08115369081497192,
-0.41552215814590454,
0.9258567094802856,
-0.613118052482605,
-0.31336310505867004,
-0.16400693356990814,
-0.5492079257965088,
-0.22211886942386627,
0.17862728238105774,
-0.29968342185020447,
-0.4824332892894745,
0.4415135979652405,
0.93827223777771,
-0.4559204578399658,
-0.015108400955796242,
0.5113058090209961,
0.01737952046096325,
0.4611247777938843,
0.4347137212753296,
0.5459067225456238,
-0.2203676700592041,
0.6879910230636597,
-0.5061271786689758,
-0.3609246015548706,
-0.03773767501115799,
-0.5625975728034973,
-0.9512916207313538,
-0.7157975435256958,
-0.3368845582008362,
0.1866547018289566,
0.16284602880477905,
0.5209928154945374,
0.6567123532295227,
-0.5448087453842163,
-0.29591163992881775,
-0.27868491411209106,
0.29984164237976074,
-0.20099779963493347,
-0.15694278478622437,
0.3923974335193634,
-0.2283192276954651,
-0.7921053767204285,
0.6085584163665771,
0.5360220670700073,
-0.07283662259578705,
-0.08916963636875153,
-0.10133755952119827,
-0.20949935913085938,
-0.0006588705582544208,
0.5619770288467407,
0.4299701750278473,
-0.23668725788593292,
-0.03185860067605972,
0.059507668018341064,
-0.10566576570272446,
0.11891777068376541,
0.8129593729972839,
-0.5537795424461365,
1.1483409404754639,
0.7143430113792419,
0.6116030216217041,
0.6812022924423218,
-0.06670819222927094,
0.5129996538162231,
-0.5880913138389587,
0.28505685925483704,
-0.10787937045097351,
0.42771488428115845,
0.24910761415958405,
-0.2643168866634369,
0.6627102494239807,
0.2214018553495407,
-0.34389060735702515,
-0.5343420505523682,
0.16208438575267792,
-1.2199996709823608,
-0.3691060543060303,
0.6868472099304199,
-0.26305001974105835,
-0.4751487374305725,
0.060787130147218704,
-0.46980422735214233,
0.31914177536964417,
-0.3524577021598816,
0.4125121831893921,
0.3926923871040344,
-0.12258360534906387,
-0.5117969512939453,
-0.7475472092628479,
0.0016600938979536295,
-0.22656066715717316,
-1.0762639045715332,
0.1278163194656372,
0.5799424052238464,
0.20224857330322266,
-0.17694102227687836,
0.585654079914093,
0.041983477771282196,
0.4207417070865631,
0.19200803339481354,
0.4085841774940491,
-0.5955780148506165,
-0.5671961903572083,
-0.4329858124256134,
0.17804397642612457,
-0.21612486243247986,
-0.6130357384681702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13303v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13303v2 | MaLA-500: Massive Language Adaptation of Large Language Models | 2024-01-24T08:57:39 | 2024-04-03T08:23:06 | Peiqin Lin, Shaoxiong Ji, Jörg Tiedemann, André F. T. Martins, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have advanced the state of the art in natural
language processing. However, their predominant design for English or a limited
set of languages creates a substantial gap in their effectiveness for
low-resource languages. To bridge this gap, we introduce MaLA-500, a novel
large language model designed to cover an extensive range of 534 languages. To
train MaLA-500, we employ vocabulary extension and continued pretraining on
LLaMA 2 with Glot500-c. Our intrinsic evaluation demonstrates that MaLA-500 is
better at predicting the given texts of low-resource languages than existing
multilingual LLMs. Moreover, the extrinsic evaluation of in-context learning
shows that MaLA-500 outperforms previous LLMs on SIB200 and Taxi1500 by a
significant margin, i.e., 11.68% and 4.82% marco-average accuracy across
languages. We release MaLA-500 at https://huggingface.co/MaLA-LM | [
-0.3598119914531708,
-0.5121012926101685,
0.41308677196502686,
0.5685424208641052,
-0.173213392496109,
0.19967466592788696,
-0.47549259662628174,
-0.6503840088844299,
0.34490203857421875,
0.5138828158378601,
-0.38508114218711853,
-0.4235977530479431,
-0.6646968722343445,
0.4804339110851288,
-0.18246188759803772,
0.8119699358940125,
0.1422244757413864,
0.15996819734573364,
0.25323978066444397,
-0.2957530617713928,
-0.7183486819267273,
-0.41839128732681274,
-0.8383466601371765,
-0.016037514433264732,
0.6482688784599304,
0.2589937746524811,
0.28432855010032654,
0.29400572180747986,
0.3627239167690277,
0.25395095348358154,
-0.010486548766493797,
0.093806691467762,
-0.5994113683700562,
-0.041952069848775864,
-0.3693593740463257,
-0.6136119365692139,
-0.9595567584037781,
-0.3483869433403015,
0.6425533890724182,
0.9313539266586304,
-0.3091434836387634,
0.2638155519962311,
0.08596912771463394,
0.5454776883125305,
-0.7504557967185974,
0.12409855425357819,
-0.8446944355964661,
-0.15442904829978943,
-0.5523151159286499,
0.10555673390626907,
-0.7432625889778137,
-0.074250727891922,
-0.08244466781616211,
-0.7800560593605042,
-0.061562418937683105,
0.17662429809570312,
0.3453179597854614,
0.25551021099090576,
-0.4533141553401947,
-0.279374361038208,
-0.5697445273399353,
0.8542256355285645,
-0.6785562634468079,
0.28889256715774536,
0.582547664642334,
0.4463818073272705,
-0.17246948182582855,
-0.5004733204841614,
-0.6110414862632751,
-0.27753886580467224,
0.3868316113948822,
-0.0877118706703186,
-0.1178676038980484,
0.08430345356464386,
0.2901318669319153,
0.3079436719417572,
-0.5453956127166748,
0.3329799175262451,
-0.6007909178733826,
-0.04168158769607544,
0.7124049663543701,
0.21495944261550903,
0.12750943005084991,
-0.010905805043876171,
-0.26363605260849,
0.15320439636707306,
-0.9853078126907349,
-0.24111054837703705,
-0.05122923105955124,
0.3672148585319519,
-0.20814275741577148,
0.32808369398117065,
-0.0811954215168953,
0.7818490862846375,
-0.11176048964262009,
-0.38964390754699707,
0.3855398893356323,
-0.051808685064315796,
-0.45483532547950745,
0.11615496873855591,
0.777029812335968,
0.06480381637811661,
0.24065084755420685,
0.0026532714255154133,
-0.2132384181022644,
-0.29790425300598145,
-0.023749448359012604,
-0.6125790476799011,
0.14190936088562012,
-0.19726435840129852,
-0.12781912088394165,
-0.042915888130664825,
-0.32751861214637756,
-0.7037867307662964,
-0.7731417417526245,
-0.07168826460838318,
0.4817945659160614,
-0.30985262989997864,
-0.23184113204479218,
0.3480021357536316,
0.4090057909488678,
0.11781169474124908,
0.6609547734260559,
-0.9827461838722229,
0.29943835735321045,
0.47413212060928345,
1.037741780281067,
0.07266666740179062,
-0.27026304602622986,
-0.690314769744873,
0.5129266977310181,
-0.5721023678779602,
0.6303632855415344,
-0.6914466619491577,
-0.37567296624183655,
-0.09235192835330963,
0.14827372133731842,
-0.06451795995235443,
-0.7315033674240112,
0.29565590620040894,
-0.44673407077789307,
0.16576990485191345,
-0.3533618748188019,
-0.15297192335128784,
-0.36056336760520935,
0.13500484824180603,
-0.86944580078125,
1.137186884880066,
0.25515109300613403,
-0.2598915100097656,
0.3409477472305298,
-0.6552676558494568,
-0.3139815032482147,
0.0696800947189331,
0.327894389629364,
0.21526122093200684,
0.36616450548171997,
0.20825086534023285,
0.32733404636383057,
-0.7799155712127686,
0.16721875965595245,
-0.5745125412940979,
-0.46921154856681824,
0.14270736277103424,
-0.2640051543712616,
0.7007588148117065,
0.29476848244667053,
-0.13690435886383057,
0.05402953550219536,
-0.8070125579833984,
-0.3769572377204895,
-0.10156816989183426,
-0.48324546217918396,
-0.48926958441734314,
-0.3323807120323181,
0.15509846806526184,
0.42076483368873596,
0.2104126363992691,
-0.476378858089447,
0.28626635670661926,
-0.6661798357963562,
0.27306362986564636,
0.8844983577728271,
-0.4107803702354431,
0.49677595496177673,
-0.009633424691855907,
0.806613564491272,
-0.08332590758800507,
0.004152373876422644,
-0.2522774040699005,
-0.4262792766094208,
-0.9871344566345215,
-0.5131241679191589,
0.4389086365699768,
0.5059531331062317,
-0.5649963021278381,
0.32918789982795715,
-0.40119409561157227,
-0.16607870161533356,
-0.8762883543968201,
0.5409262776374817,
0.3000974953174591,
0.16738981008529663,
0.4295850694179535,
-0.6427081227302551,
-0.6362861394882202,
-0.7126646041870117,
-0.0008629242074675858,
0.03098023310303688,
-0.08191841095685959,
0.13310985267162323,
0.3136577606201172,
-0.4649428725242615,
0.5970495343208313,
-0.20161324739456177,
-0.33950158953666687,
-0.7053301930427551,
-0.24535158276557922,
0.22051866352558136,
0.2255377173423767,
0.6533253192901611,
-0.24958664178848267,
-0.7588604092597961,
0.23646406829357147,
-0.6594650149345398,
-0.13295738399028778,
-0.08191026002168655,
-0.031588342040777206,
0.39929038286209106,
0.5660303831100464,
-0.3702748715877533,
0.17544378340244293,
0.617916464805603,
0.08318035304546356,
0.2339148223400116,
-0.2899377942085266,
-0.2606881260871887,
-1.55692720413208,
0.2652164697647095,
0.019899755716323853,
-0.41207262873649597,
-0.5700352191925049,
-0.15890450775623322,
0.0549531914293766,
-0.06693877279758453,
-0.24124351143836975,
0.9051276445388794,
-0.36994045972824097,
-0.146188884973526,
-0.4476451575756073,
0.1258203238248825,
-0.19916699826717377,
0.2996480464935303,
-0.0977151021361351,
0.7324943542480469,
0.5527952313423157,
-0.4313342571258545,
0.4676481783390045,
0.009108860045671463,
-0.7268636226654053,
0.4418419301509857,
-0.44032078981399536,
0.059857677668333054,
-0.20781055092811584,
0.6082700490951538,
-0.8444874882698059,
-0.32092592120170593,
0.11156022548675537,
-0.019174661487340927,
0.3465469181537628,
0.2390611171722412,
-0.3018932640552521,
-0.3013978898525238,
-0.14129014313220978,
0.4946964383125305,
0.33091092109680176,
-0.5071032047271729,
0.3289403021335602,
0.43957358598709106,
-0.5448779463768005,
-0.7562857866287231,
-0.573062539100647,
0.599450409412384,
-0.2517150640487671,
-0.19926631450653076,
-0.18168064951896667,
-0.07834261655807495,
-0.26445913314819336,
-0.3239988684654236,
0.11879510432481766,
-0.031186463311314583,
0.1460084766149521,
0.13254904747009277,
0.1091013252735138,
-0.35424211621284485,
0.2846837639808655,
-0.023884523659944534,
-0.18392936885356903,
-0.17367906868457794,
-0.07312937825918198,
0.7459360957145691,
-0.010100333020091057,
-0.20423755049705505,
-0.3411044776439667,
0.248857319355011,
0.6716964840888977,
-0.1770634800195694,
0.9002017974853516,
0.5515056848526001,
-0.46055570244789124,
-0.37823134660720825,
-0.6336479187011719,
0.1963750720024109,
-0.4390473961830139,
0.9255824089050293,
-0.5688253045082092,
-0.8066698312759399,
0.29961156845092773,
-0.26456475257873535,
-0.08938107639551163,
0.36849352717399597,
0.5802416801452637,
0.1900145411491394,
0.9529371857643127,
1.0928343534469604,
-0.5168728828430176,
0.29471176862716675,
-0.0690334364771843,
0.22647932171821594,
-0.9735446572303772,
-0.2177758663892746,
-0.25856298208236694,
-0.29861700534820557,
-0.35517770051956177,
-0.6289031505584717,
0.305568665266037,
0.26306864619255066,
-0.24785563349723816,
0.3369891345500946,
0.2850498557090759,
0.564971923828125,
0.10621029883623123,
-0.05196443200111389,
0.2999294698238373,
0.046705201268196106,
0.014850870706140995,
0.132987841963768,
-0.6413994431495667,
-0.4897204637527466,
1.246741771697998,
0.4362149238586426,
0.7410995364189148,
0.3938024044036865,
0.2981312572956085,
0.17801512777805328,
0.8655034899711609,
-0.6958423852920532,
0.5497366786003113,
-0.28753384947776794,
-0.6976212859153748,
-0.15603528916835785,
-0.25587576627731323,
-0.792780876159668,
0.2547643184661865,
-0.06228863447904587,
-0.5903266072273254,
0.07464864104986191,
-0.07047875225543976,
-0.4840051233768463,
0.11533030867576599,
-0.647087574005127,
0.6403676271438599,
-0.12278512120246887,
-0.24138346314430237,
-0.5844824910163879,
-0.4251191318035126,
0.7276666760444641,
-0.7936350703239441,
0.5705388188362122,
-0.25342288613319397,
-0.43637654185295105,
0.5254590511322021,
-0.2958287298679352,
0.9236597418785095,
0.00829383172094822,
-0.3868604302406311,
-0.10427581518888474,
0.006706136744469404,
0.2612592875957489,
0.046547822654247284,
-0.43429550528526306,
0.1081031784415245,
-0.252549946308136,
-0.6278936862945557,
-0.42495596408843994,
0.7542454600334167,
-0.618142306804657,
-0.756887674331665,
-0.5250028967857361,
-0.7318369150161743,
-0.4378109276294708,
0.075914666056633,
0.019717497751116753,
0.2920231223106384,
-0.30038711428642273,
0.16985799372196198,
0.4257713258266449,
-0.6916458606719971,
0.47618433833122253,
0.6503801941871643,
-0.43794673681259155,
-0.6432192325592041,
0.8094443678855896,
-0.09329287707805634,
0.5312060713768005,
0.39510011672973633,
-0.04541292414069176,
-0.2107877880334854,
-0.3798857033252716,
-0.657856822013855,
0.4998425543308258,
-0.6100873947143555,
-0.1561276614665985,
-0.47954049706459045,
0.054904237389564514,
-0.3985607326030731,
-0.2896811366081238,
-0.14403314888477325,
-0.356866717338562,
-0.0588265024125576,
0.01878896914422512,
0.1407177448272705,
1.1700618267059326,
-0.0925782173871994,
0.3898254930973053,
-0.582972526550293,
0.04296209290623665,
0.2825314700603485,
0.16615355014801025,
0.12882299721240997,
-0.9302478432655334,
-0.4352608919143677,
0.05479736626148224,
-0.10554104298353195,
-0.7247321605682373,
0.6142417788505554,
0.6154274940490723,
0.3128441274166107,
0.537554919719696,
-0.2719738185405731,
0.9815224409103394,
-0.6105313897132874,
0.6057151556015015,
0.5169445276260376,
-0.9543703198432922,
0.3068467676639557,
-0.27226585149765015,
0.40976694226264954,
0.42708882689476013,
0.4389724135398865,
-0.7607589960098267,
-0.19858580827713013,
-0.13596253097057343,
-0.7356351017951965,
0.7417299747467041,
-0.4191448390483856,
0.25968241691589355,
0.012902223505079746,
0.3927295506000519,
0.34321582317352295,
0.1727605164051056,
-0.8981452584266663,
0.13235056400299072,
0.11131330579519272,
-0.3161256015300751,
-0.6851198673248291,
-0.39104950428009033,
0.0619974210858345,
-0.25235873460769653,
0.5417260527610779,
-0.29380548000335693,
-0.0771062970161438,
-0.3099251687526703,
-0.49117597937583923,
-0.1797834187746048,
0.28373757004737854,
0.7412026524543762,
0.7944655418395996,
-0.16888514161109924,
0.16326174139976501,
0.9396788477897644,
-0.7202284932136536,
0.1820519119501114,
-0.03939172253012657,
0.2706656754016876,
-0.12484036386013031,
0.5951979160308838,
0.8727146983146667,
0.4253007471561432,
-0.936486005783081,
0.3610575497150421,
0.11355096101760864,
0.13271059095859528,
-0.08369181305170059,
0.1459730565547943,
0.1945037990808487,
0.1637827754020691,
0.42131859064102173,
-0.04206249490380287,
-0.11159003525972366,
-0.847007155418396,
-0.2061605155467987,
0.3772429823875427,
-0.3384377360343933,
-0.5942423343658447,
0.5723789930343628,
0.38081803917884827,
0.06068750098347664,
0.22254550457000732,
-0.11689812690019608,
-0.32159996032714844,
0.39587584137916565,
0.8282990455627441,
0.6385589241981506,
-0.5992256999015808,
0.009168276563286781,
0.5844438672065735,
0.4863901734352112,
-0.22992321848869324,
0.08816950768232346,
0.012764045037329197,
-0.34201839566230774,
-0.8095347881317139,
-1.0829898118972778,
-0.2754110097885132,
0.4242269694805145,
-0.5066704154014587,
0.3705798387527466,
-0.5932232141494751,
0.0814395472407341,
-0.10648452490568161,
0.13053499162197113,
-0.4471876919269562,
0.18041330575942993,
0.28459396958351135,
1.3787285089492798,
-0.79100501537323,
1.29127836227417,
0.6859085559844971,
-0.27186450362205505,
-0.4895555078983307,
-0.07312007248401642,
-0.020710568875074387,
-0.9588803052902222,
0.8042542338371277,
0.2835765480995178,
0.06400023400783539,
0.11184607446193695,
-0.30504268407821655,
-1.041285514831543,
1.1110115051269531,
0.8492240309715271,
-0.9106785655021667,
0.137674018740654,
0.36072978377342224,
0.471094012260437,
-0.3714599013328552,
0.2683379054069519,
0.42314013838768005,
0.256323903799057,
0.08716373890638351,
-1.397606372833252,
0.017887786030769348,
-0.10480618476867676,
0.1577555239200592,
0.1615620106458664,
-0.6558989882469177,
0.5853025317192078,
-0.3774661123752594,
-0.03254261612892151,
0.439280241727829,
0.5296297073364258,
0.18052959442138672,
0.17359037697315216,
0.4480067193508148,
0.6682489514350891,
1.0016273260116577,
0.16242440044879913,
0.944201648235321,
-0.07790791988372803,
0.035495780408382416,
0.9877164363861084,
-0.6831367611885071,
1.0860459804534912,
0.14996162056922913,
-0.2577466070652008,
0.5474180579185486,
0.6892645359039307,
0.46889692544937134,
0.4406297504901886,
0.18772371113300323,
-0.8351660966873169,
-0.35108304023742676,
-0.1792556196451187,
-0.6111453771591187,
0.3810470402240753,
0.6541250348091125,
-0.13136787712574005,
-0.08395494520664215,
0.3249385952949524,
0.1280863732099533,
-0.23152406513690948,
-0.5702471137046814,
0.6256556510925293,
0.29348331689834595,
-0.453998327255249,
0.7278151512145996,
0.19188393652439117,
0.7173159718513489,
-0.6491581201553345,
0.25312474370002747,
-0.4688262939453125,
0.3894449472427368,
-0.10671382397413254,
-0.30459678173065186,
0.08570952713489532,
0.26581302285194397,
-0.15015773475170135,
-0.07680191844701767,
0.43916139006614685,
-0.4887743890285492,
-0.5283255577087402,
0.345028817653656,
0.28769198060035706,
0.15454652905464172,
0.1109876036643982,
-0.514075756072998,
0.20967641472816467,
-0.10765282064676285,
-0.08103945851325989,
0.6099864840507507,
0.5895967483520508,
-0.24360930919647217,
0.6581412553787231,
0.6430338621139526,
0.30830174684524536,
0.16142897307872772,
0.033028896898031235,
0.7449695467948914,
-0.7702521681785583,
-0.36201947927474976,
-0.6792040467262268,
0.21153897047042847,
-0.03504000976681709,
-0.4107629060745239,
0.7706487774848938,
0.6343967318534851,
0.8056015968322754,
-0.1737949550151825,
0.8621805906295776,
0.06800074875354767,
0.4099498987197876,
-0.392286092042923,
0.519080400466919,
-0.6729270219802856,
0.39428311586380005,
-0.13622140884399414,
-1.1404318809509277,
-0.3930600881576538,
0.7266009449958801,
-0.4433249235153198,
0.012914789840579033,
0.6127433776855469,
0.8799343705177307,
-0.1656651347875595,
-0.19652535021305084,
0.4434908330440521,
0.5165616869926453,
0.1784900724887848,
0.9259044528007507,
0.6994754672050476,
-0.3461477756500244,
0.3231314420700073,
0.129004567861557,
-0.5199357271194458,
-0.2694971561431885,
-0.7362843751907349,
-0.8770034313201904,
-0.5785538554191589,
0.0845407247543335,
-0.24679790437221527,
0.06949831545352936,
1.024145483970642,
0.7688371539115906,
-0.8824419379234314,
-0.5772430300712585,
0.08231514692306519,
-0.15450476109981537,
0.05490285903215408,
-0.10090827196836472,
0.12155894935131073,
-0.4514058530330658,
-0.8663241267204285,
0.7335070967674255,
0.5791948437690735,
-0.2892332971096039,
-0.4230990707874298,
-0.32031676173210144,
-0.28549227118492126,
0.16923834383487701,
0.8844976425170898,
0.4140136241912842,
-0.6361103653907776,
0.05119121074676514,
-0.05130621790885925,
-0.28018173575401306,
-0.27961134910583496,
0.5957204103469849,
-0.7586199641227722,
0.5011778473854065,
0.12486246228218079,
0.6269500255584717,
0.39211151003837585,
-0.41135916113853455,
0.8929771780967712,
-0.6328675150871277,
0.5901175141334534,
-0.11572710424661636,
0.39908885955810547,
0.41668859124183655,
0.011678281240165234,
0.5105974078178406,
0.2997988760471344,
-0.19783350825309753,
-1.1327580213546753,
0.07995773106813431,
-0.9547386169433594,
-0.21815530955791473,
1.3478676080703735,
0.045016977936029434,
-0.24065370857715607,
-0.2350357472896576,
-0.36382582783699036,
0.012990683317184448,
-0.07061179727315903,
0.9406499266624451,
0.7165651321411133,
0.35966649651527405,
-0.21658246219158173,
-0.8722585439682007,
0.43523645401000977,
0.49953728914260864,
-0.9171462059020996,
-0.058241233229637146,
0.35937556624412537,
0.2846403419971466,
-0.023362616077065468,
0.7350453734397888,
0.08417060971260071,
0.38031840324401855,
-0.38119739294052124,
0.027361232787370682,
0.23117053508758545,
-0.3425803482532501,
-0.635162889957428,
0.08248785138130188,
0.40729549527168274,
0.14238795638084412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13298v1 | Towards Explainable Harmful Meme Detection through Multimodal Debate between Large Language Models | 2024-01-24T08:37:16 | 2024-01-24T08:37:16 | Hongzhan Lin, Ziyang Luo, Wei Gao, Jing Ma, Bo Wang, Ruichao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The age of social media is flooded with Internet memes, necessitating a clear
grasp and effective identification of harmful ones. This task presents a
significant challenge due to the implicit meaning embedded in memes, which is
not explicitly conveyed through the surface text and image. However, existing
harmful meme detection methods do not present readable explanations that unveil
such implicit meaning to support their detection decisions. In this paper, we
propose an explainable approach to detect harmful memes, achieved through
reasoning over conflicting rationales from both harmless and harmful positions.
Specifically, inspired by the powerful capacity of Large Language Models (LLMs)
on text generation and reasoning, we first elicit multimodal debate between
LLMs to generate the explanations derived from the contradictory arguments.
Then we propose to fine-tune a small language model as the debate judge for
harmfulness inference, to facilitate multimodal fusion between the harmfulness
rationales and the intrinsic multimodal information within memes. In this way,
our model is empowered to perform dialectical reasoning over intricate and
implicit harm-indicative patterns, utilizing multimodal explanations
originating from both harmless and harmful arguments. Extensive experiments on
three public meme datasets demonstrate that our harmful meme detection approach
achieves much better performance than state-of-the-art methods and exhibits a
superior capacity for explaining the meme harmfulness of the model predictions. | [
-0.4150306284427643,
-1.1575225591659546,
0.6084343194961548,
-0.001028544153086841,
-0.5250040888786316,
-0.3449622690677643,
-0.07374724745750427,
-0.5810564756393433,
0.051310598850250244,
0.5473124980926514,
-0.7611179351806641,
-0.21973972022533417,
-0.6979433298110962,
-0.02282143197953701,
-0.29940566420555115,
0.8695429563522339,
0.15160666406154633,
-0.2686309814453125,
-0.021823646500706673,
-0.23253370821475983,
-0.6228110194206238,
-0.23178976774215698,
-0.905628502368927,
0.06569784879684448,
0.9611355662345886,
0.5296367406845093,
0.6776435375213623,
0.30472373962402344,
0.2813691198825836,
0.4453006684780121,
0.006295247934758663,
0.21185505390167236,
-0.4424225986003876,
0.3124292492866516,
-0.5791767239570618,
-0.36964938044548035,
-0.36027124524116516,
0.11894124001264572,
0.14864127337932587,
0.3656839430332184,
0.1421688050031662,
-0.12785691022872925,
-0.03659617528319359,
0.3737194538116455,
-0.46225687861442566,
-0.259909987449646,
-0.8826437592506409,
-0.17896178364753723,
-0.2609615921974182,
-0.4577692151069641,
-0.6203135251998901,
-0.24578168988227844,
-0.06264864653348923,
-0.21278148889541626,
-0.18073157966136932,
-0.1437082290649414,
0.6077395677566528,
0.06926711648702621,
-0.6948765516281128,
-0.49125173687934875,
-0.6805556416511536,
0.9429296851158142,
-0.7748549580574036,
0.29472479224205017,
0.17087191343307495,
0.4350842535495758,
-0.17545877397060394,
-0.49538835883140564,
-0.8471795916557312,
-0.2405179888010025,
0.003671259619295597,
-0.11846011132001877,
-0.6591756939888,
-0.20206713676452637,
0.11619684100151062,
-0.07605190575122833,
-0.6702307462692261,
0.19621701538562775,
-0.179234579205513,
-0.43474116921424866,
0.5186647176742554,
0.13566718995571136,
0.5102528929710388,
-0.6003246307373047,
-0.5726633071899414,
0.07191970944404602,
-0.6868407130241394,
-0.18750502169132233,
0.48645755648612976,
-0.010486484505236149,
-0.04415113478899002,
0.49008187651634216,
0.1525648832321167,
0.24521119892597198,
-0.0888868123292923,
-0.25606706738471985,
-0.1833338439464569,
-0.31098487973213196,
-0.048623066395521164,
-0.2065407931804657,
0.8452218770980835,
0.7629101276397705,
0.32822462916374207,
0.12876291573047638,
0.038675457239151,
0.3405787944793701,
0.2826472520828247,
-0.9863387942314148,
-0.07884322851896286,
0.22824980318546295,
-0.5632075667381287,
-0.2664097845554352,
-0.3838939070701599,
-1.0309077501296997,
-0.6757662892341614,
-0.06443039327859879,
0.33361074328422546,
-0.39652812480926514,
-0.5434142351150513,
0.14443029463291168,
-0.13514108955860138,
-0.10208964347839355,
0.41954320669174194,
-0.610975444316864,
-0.35473698377609253,
0.4808535873889923,
0.6082579493522644,
0.3120185434818268,
0.21501106023788452,
-0.2235054224729538,
0.3906419575214386,
-0.27889397740364075,
1.0478285551071167,
-0.6351465582847595,
-0.0014527628663927317,
-0.24677340686321259,
0.3316831588745117,
0.12257339060306549,
-0.448360413312912,
0.7918558120727539,
-0.37228935956954956,
0.19996583461761475,
-0.16253213584423065,
-0.18944336473941803,
-0.745384931564331,
0.3520737886428833,
-0.6179193258285522,
0.13311360776424408,
-0.447955459356308,
-0.8192111253738403,
0.3079253137111664,
-0.6362991333007812,
-0.28647714853286743,
-0.018397821113467216,
0.15066184103488922,
-0.5779151916503906,
-0.18601788580417633,
0.049892060458660126,
0.9533954858779907,
-0.1813158392906189,
0.3721641004085541,
-0.9207772016525269,
0.020253483206033707,
0.3626435697078705,
-0.9775725603103638,
0.8368116617202759,
0.607201874256134,
-0.38484567403793335,
0.3402072787284851,
-0.3842402994632721,
-0.25283849239349365,
0.30003291368484497,
-0.0439646914601326,
-0.7196624279022217,
0.2008802443742752,
-0.18032298982143402,
0.43739989399909973,
-0.10598339885473251,
-0.5216906666755676,
-0.2736387550830841,
-0.10385067760944366,
0.6695547699928284,
0.9783748984336853,
0.11462359130382538,
0.37739992141723633,
-0.5151161551475525,
0.28190189599990845,
0.1043502613902092,
0.508034884929657,
-0.30592361092567444,
-0.5554747581481934,
-0.23453517258167267,
-0.34952881932258606,
-0.2666599750518799,
0.3256756663322449,
-0.8175432085990906,
0.006756636779755354,
-0.17351117730140686,
-0.37669116258621216,
-0.22796018421649933,
0.12141670286655426,
0.2409348487854004,
0.42000284790992737,
0.26315826177597046,
0.11371582001447678,
-0.34283366799354553,
-1.1521557569503784,
-0.4501759707927704,
-0.1183430477976799,
0.05301092937588692,
0.47802305221557617,
0.3693060576915741,
-0.539823591709137,
0.17604683339595795,
-0.16949795186519623,
0.03254791721701622,
-0.06716368347406387,
0.3721810281276703,
0.020137237384915352,
0.49634066224098206,
0.6338483691215515,
-0.8745195865631104,
-0.23018763959407806,
-0.20508843660354614,
-0.7384640574455261,
-0.45867037773132324,
-0.4706111550331116,
-0.1645137369632721,
-0.09333408623933792,
0.6813686490058899,
-0.31050246953964233,
0.08180428296327591,
0.5503888130187988,
-0.6217250227928162,
0.5448400974273682,
0.08907457441091537,
0.47681596875190735,
-1.0042366981506348,
-0.13470564782619476,
0.18755799531936646,
-0.4162437915802002,
-0.5290300250053406,
0.09833809733390808,
-0.05227568745613098,
-0.04700468108057976,
-0.47985610365867615,
0.4763992130756378,
-0.2867240011692047,
0.6506155729293823,
-0.2828421890735626,
0.19876693189144135,
0.2078201025724411,
0.3045542240142822,
-0.39116212725639343,
0.41453319787979126,
0.24463315308094025,
-0.40969711542129517,
0.2164057046175003,
-0.10539373755455017,
-0.13650690019130707,
0.6146761775016785,
-0.4643017053604126,
-0.11308389902114868,
-0.2715945839881897,
0.209961399435997,
-1.2478047609329224,
-0.16535665094852448,
0.7128026485443115,
-0.37923464179039,
0.2240179181098938,
-0.22627779841423035,
-0.45520973205566406,
-0.29437127709388733,
-0.5695159435272217,
0.6913356781005859,
0.19524817168712616,
-0.6914246678352356,
0.4735230803489685,
0.5065833330154419,
-0.2946256101131439,
-0.477012574672699,
-0.3358328938484192,
0.22521770000457764,
-0.7682533860206604,
-1.0955123901367188,
-0.046723268926143646,
-0.22012588381767273,
-0.4113072454929352,
0.029465964064002037,
-0.08829374611377716,
-0.10887367278337479,
0.39090123772621155,
0.46869346499443054,
0.0711885318160057,
-0.27017727494239807,
0.32077741622924805,
0.2990044355392456,
-0.32939597964286804,
0.20363791286945343,
0.16676737368106842,
0.29152870178222656,
-0.2654074728488922,
-0.4641975164413452,
-0.3267754018306732,
0.6255777478218079,
0.858792781829834,
-0.08675209432840347,
0.5676445960998535,
0.4406280517578125,
-0.47809892892837524,
-0.3090258538722992,
-0.6761673092842102,
-0.3296965956687927,
-0.540904700756073,
0.21225424110889435,
-0.2622799873352051,
-0.7853999733924866,
0.30231213569641113,
-0.4483671188354492,
0.03530183434486389,
0.39322561025619507,
0.5750945210456848,
-0.1324145793914795,
1.3745412826538086,
0.06122861057519913,
0.23291146755218506,
0.440685510635376,
-0.03943518549203873,
0.39801025390625,
-0.3038714528083801,
-0.36595433950424194,
-0.39066505432128906,
-0.13345232605934143,
-0.45036637783050537,
-0.6394067406654358,
0.4718145728111267,
0.06878192722797394,
-0.17409683763980865,
0.09644253551959991,
-0.3664724826812744,
0.6375821232795715,
0.21702298521995544,
0.3699239492416382,
0.1583125740289688,
-0.019978301599621773,
-0.1686740666627884,
-0.00383943528868258,
-0.3427234888076782,
-0.9321839809417725,
0.5619017481803894,
0.5098526477813721,
1.049406886100769,
0.4836229085922241,
0.02344459481537342,
0.43177223205566406,
0.35620659589767456,
-0.6106279492378235,
0.5222452282905579,
-0.2882275879383087,
-1.0361448526382446,
-0.12106397747993469,
-0.24220424890518188,
-1.065451979637146,
0.38956689834594727,
-0.6575024724006653,
-0.5548697113990784,
-0.206078439950943,
0.30773696303367615,
0.03362423926591873,
0.4789135456085205,
-0.8264988660812378,
1.0689700841903687,
-0.26210659742355347,
-0.7125384211540222,
-0.7588551044464111,
-0.5598213076591492,
0.6961658596992493,
0.09206411987543106,
0.6265162229537964,
-0.3557768166065216,
0.16058757901191711,
0.5469953417778015,
-0.18430626392364502,
1.0769253969192505,
-0.26428329944610596,
-0.25032415986061096,
0.46339958906173706,
0.34626853466033936,
0.11821160465478897,
0.10092673450708389,
-0.002028913237154484,
0.2160988301038742,
-0.18993739783763885,
-0.479289174079895,
-0.36508041620254517,
0.9832004904747009,
-0.29432862997055054,
-0.6298540234565735,
0.009173789992928505,
-0.48886242508888245,
0.04591687023639679,
0.25839903950691223,
-0.2123691439628601,
0.40978574752807617,
-0.0795922726392746,
0.2832210659980774,
0.7451926469802856,
-0.6539657115936279,
0.25088655948638916,
0.4600732922554016,
0.05736926943063736,
-0.10590722411870956,
1.2099076509475708,
-0.10688810795545578,
0.12886369228363037,
0.2652358114719391,
0.5280968546867371,
-0.5419341325759888,
-0.5640494227409363,
-0.4720243513584137,
0.1349310576915741,
-0.922101616859436,
-0.1407073587179184,
-0.7761635184288025,
0.259886771440506,
0.0020524384453892708,
-0.2022043615579605,
-0.1170603334903717,
-0.26557332277297974,
0.026379220187664032,
0.011369014158844948,
0.08872342109680176,
0.6942269206047058,
-0.24970847368240356,
0.26302412152290344,
-0.8559777736663818,
0.47497010231018066,
0.5491803884506226,
0.39294278621673584,
0.21683324873447418,
-0.33198824524879456,
0.2319425493478775,
0.273815780878067,
-0.5696172118186951,
-1.2501791715621948,
-0.00376055552624166,
-0.07687903195619583,
0.6240392327308655,
1.1966137886047363,
0.11929085850715637,
0.4762355089187622,
-0.40415817499160767,
0.46641460061073303,
0.3558107018470764,
-0.7542318105697632,
0.533210277557373,
-0.5343760251998901,
-0.21443647146224976,
0.16291731595993042,
0.5379678606987,
-0.5642778277397156,
-0.7113587260246277,
-0.4419734477996826,
-0.6998510360717773,
0.25976133346557617,
0.10024154186248779,
0.5006019473075867,
-0.3945373296737671,
0.28570622205734253,
0.4120243489742279,
-0.23734693229198456,
-1.1697170734405518,
0.029378235340118408,
-0.20540831983089447,
0.10789933800697327,
0.04621108993887901,
-0.6367223858833313,
-0.26216647028923035,
-0.1056239902973175,
0.8213798403739929,
-0.039770226925611496,
0.18735036253929138,
-0.11548783630132675,
-0.28656142950057983,
-0.38137173652648926,
0.5187200903892517,
0.6023709177970886,
0.4662216901779175,
0.03312920406460762,
0.8864080309867859,
-0.14694450795650482,
-0.036046579480171204,
0.24769823253154755,
-0.11341508477926254,
0.1608743816614151,
-0.2302052229642868,
0.5178723335266113,
0.3880631923675537,
0.2074265033006668,
-0.8214710354804993,
0.8035382032394409,
-0.10736633092164993,
-0.06321470439434052,
0.032950323075056076,
-0.012648563832044601,
0.43893876671791077,
0.5472333431243896,
0.008111117407679558,
0.14206019043922424,
0.27856627106666565,
-0.49530673027038574,
0.4136556386947632,
0.846286952495575,
-0.2840183973312378,
-0.5586233735084534,
0.8569051027297974,
0.32144373655319214,
0.1760103404521942,
0.008544634096324444,
-0.015586011111736298,
-0.5159144997596741,
0.6301717758178711,
0.5763430595397949,
0.6085113883018494,
-0.3059042692184448,
0.45212268829345703,
0.4549952745437622,
0.6572688817977905,
0.4555707573890686,
0.16060730814933777,
0.22177723050117493,
-0.6944611668586731,
-0.36863863468170166,
-0.21899054944515228,
-0.04618138074874878,
0.713924765586853,
-0.10986089706420898,
0.18230053782463074,
-0.47647351026535034,
0.10284999758005142,
0.8566819429397583,
-0.5683874487876892,
-0.10979650914669037,
0.09944429248571396,
0.4785906970500946,
0.5896349549293518,
-1.2224910259246826,
0.15070338547229767,
0.38255032896995544,
-0.3603326678276062,
-0.521232008934021,
0.023114632815122604,
0.2361329346895218,
-0.8758350610733032,
0.06757824867963791,
0.46982112526893616,
-0.3416610658168793,
-0.46636372804641724,
-0.9113485813140869,
-0.17547444999217987,
0.6390280723571777,
0.635025680065155,
-0.40368402004241943,
0.49900680780410767,
-0.1671152114868164,
0.3944944739341736,
0.05491102486848831,
0.2510712146759033,
-0.11615228652954102,
0.5777516961097717,
0.20821666717529297,
-0.3315606713294983,
0.5695679187774658,
-0.34091049432754517,
-0.34563952684402466,
0.36077195405960083,
-0.41253599524497986,
0.7228111028671265,
-0.4707035422325134,
-0.393106609582901,
-0.1851346641778946,
0.3523530960083008,
-0.08216723799705505,
0.6202559471130371,
1.0091584920883179,
0.23833240568637848,
0.3841867744922638,
0.21637055277824402,
1.0059400796890259,
0.07712579518556595,
0.0824127346277237,
0.7897563576698303,
0.34289413690567017,
0.5695412158966064,
0.5650479197502136,
0.1479165256023407,
0.631831169128418,
0.6621081233024597,
0.025537405163049698,
0.355614572763443,
0.21742156147956848,
-0.547601580619812,
-0.7442030310630798,
-0.23371559381484985,
-0.15867255628108978,
0.4796806275844574,
0.5523514747619629,
-0.4548928737640381,
-0.5854400992393494,
0.2875217795372009,
0.38527393341064453,
0.21557912230491638,
-0.2931694984436035,
0.807115375995636,
0.025063157081604004,
-0.5714887976646423,
0.7192866802215576,
0.2633580267429352,
0.5408617258071899,
-0.377705842256546,
-0.24378681182861328,
0.14294691383838654,
0.2959257662296295,
-0.19214986264705658,
-0.7656498551368713,
0.6003037095069885,
-0.06571516394615173,
-0.14414386451244354,
-0.07919938117265701,
1.1837117671966553,
-0.46394193172454834,
-0.1588587909936905,
0.5952165722846985,
0.7079551219940186,
0.37501710653305054,
-0.1458175778388977,
-0.9996048808097839,
-0.2612222135066986,
-0.009165464900434017,
-0.12327848374843597,
0.13725066184997559,
0.7082080841064453,
-0.5001816749572754,
0.8341711759567261,
0.7312771677970886,
-0.3979683518409729,
0.20317605137825012,
0.13473300635814667,
1.0132086277008057,
-0.3663995862007141,
-0.3374944031238556,
-1.1334973573684692,
0.5265385508537292,
0.011754131875932217,
0.2802902162075043,
0.5861408710479736,
0.09387243539094925,
0.3849460780620575,
-0.05454155430197716,
0.6218199729919434,
-0.09493879973888397,
0.31660524010658264,
-0.33331727981567383,
0.7462788820266724,
-0.9426773190498352,
0.29391273856163025,
-0.40421104431152344,
-0.4143187701702118,
-0.2784404158592224,
0.6721565127372742,
-0.16940410435199738,
-0.16753928363323212,
0.5006709694862366,
0.9268633127212524,
-0.36511465907096863,
0.24483133852481842,
0.360322505235672,
0.7610073685646057,
0.4722502529621124,
0.5468905568122864,
1.3633922338485718,
0.06117833033204079,
0.8680976033210754,
-0.2588112950325012,
-0.5374690890312195,
-0.2766493260860443,
-1.1875309944152832,
-1.1199464797973633,
-0.5720592737197876,
-0.15396921336650848,
-0.42321792244911194,
-0.055222414433956146,
0.6501630544662476,
0.6024203896522522,
-0.760294497013092,
0.2989320158958435,
0.11901348829269409,
0.5917652249336243,
0.010961399413645267,
-0.25570082664489746,
0.017360109835863113,
0.07181204855442047,
-0.6619062423706055,
0.3525015413761139,
0.25586873292922974,
0.03655869513750076,
-0.15377861261367798,
0.007087649777531624,
-0.49184826016426086,
0.3396705389022827,
0.8947197794914246,
0.09715553373098373,
-0.8656102418899536,
-0.7289139628410339,
-0.35156556963920593,
0.046373359858989716,
-0.2751759886741638,
0.6678199768066406,
-0.16170987486839294,
0.687513530254364,
0.43640556931495667,
0.29431116580963135,
0.07403838634490967,
-0.13873104751110077,
0.3240381181240082,
-0.5555054545402527,
0.18153078854084015,
0.16658231616020203,
0.4395814538002014,
0.3024629056453705,
-0.4793379008769989,
0.3188231885433197,
0.18182134628295898,
-0.3399973213672638,
-0.7669899463653564,
0.36823976039886475,
-1.1306474208831787,
-0.8616923093795776,
1.2027831077575684,
-0.234317347407341,
-0.031666189432144165,
-0.49217888712882996,
-0.4576640725135803,
0.3268609344959259,
-0.28686338663101196,
1.0010590553283691,
0.5193548798561096,
0.10420243442058563,
-0.05802543833851814,
-0.5879703760147095,
0.2620314657688141,
0.4133318066596985,
-0.8029859662055969,
0.20476530492305756,
0.7162449955940247,
0.4783557653427124,
0.23127689957618713,
0.47999778389930725,
-0.2719980776309967,
0.387312650680542,
-0.012602182105183601,
-0.1805296540260315,
-0.09390745311975479,
-0.46564191579818726,
-0.09110426157712936,
0.2889816164970398,
-0.197693333029747,
-0.20553509891033173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.13275v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.13275v2 | Can AI Assistants Know What They Don't Know? | 2024-01-24T07:34:55 | 2024-01-28T09:07:13 | Qinyuan Cheng, Tianxiang Sun, Xiangyang Liu, Wenwei Zhang, Zhangyue Yin, Shimin Li, Linyang Li, Zhengfu He, Kai Chen, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, AI assistants based on large language models (LLMs) show surprising
performance in many tasks, such as dialogue, solving math problems, writing
code, and using tools. Although LLMs possess intensive world knowledge, they
still make factual errors when facing some knowledge intensive tasks, like
open-domain question answering. These untruthful responses from the AI
assistant may cause significant risks in practical applications. We believe
that an AI assistant's refusal to answer questions it does not know is a
crucial method for reducing hallucinations and making the assistant truthful.
Therefore, in this paper, we ask the question "Can AI assistants know what they
don't know and express them through natural language?" To answer this question,
we construct a model-specific "I don't know" (Idk) dataset for an assistant,
which contains its known and unknown questions, based on existing open-domain
question answering datasets. Then we align the assistant with its corresponding
Idk dataset and observe whether it can refuse to answer its unknown questions
after alignment. Experimental results show that after alignment with Idk
datasets, the assistant can refuse to answer most its unknown questions. For
questions they attempt to answer, the accuracy is significantly higher than
before the alignment. | [
-0.45432090759277344,
-0.9342055916786194,
0.8293660879135132,
-0.16212524473667145,
0.18878957629203796,
0.18513989448547363,
-0.15475423634052277,
-0.5942563414573669,
-0.11841761320829391,
0.41855698823928833,
-0.8409393429756165,
-0.2181772142648697,
-0.6006322503089905,
0.28949543833732605,
-0.40255022048950195,
0.7047892808914185,
-0.07748258858919144,
0.14932121336460114,
-0.602477490901947,
-0.3634381592273712,
-0.6430992484092712,
-0.17333891987800598,
-0.531371533870697,
-0.14734117686748505,
0.11263875663280487,
0.5226839780807495,
0.8565753102302551,
0.6505188941955566,
0.36427390575408936,
0.3113560676574707,
0.03226297348737717,
0.35100916028022766,
-0.20222927629947662,
-0.10863476991653442,
-0.10444322973489761,
-0.8505356311798096,
-0.287445604801178,
-0.08939218521118164,
0.28709980845451355,
0.9657244682312012,
0.25698989629745483,
0.17910967767238617,
-0.008876542560756207,
0.7108802795410156,
-0.4704459309577942,
-0.02109721302986145,
-0.7489616274833679,
0.06714142858982086,
0.04137153550982475,
0.023875797167420387,
-0.4093298614025116,
-0.2860645353794098,
0.22474144399166107,
-0.7694294452667236,
0.24774809181690216,
0.14654932916164398,
0.9458062052726746,
0.8851824998855591,
-0.16952009499073029,
-0.42737460136413574,
-1.007805585861206,
0.5564096570014954,
-0.6693920493125916,
0.07149190455675125,
0.8910279870033264,
0.47545844316482544,
0.00817866064608097,
-0.07137314975261688,
-1.0224088430404663,
-0.24273531138896942,
-0.45314106345176697,
-0.23287811875343323,
-0.09719739854335785,
-0.00843389518558979,
0.40489983558654785,
0.25795459747314453,
-0.7008176445960999,
0.0857660174369812,
-0.363973468542099,
-0.05105280876159668,
0.628936231136322,
0.24733532965183258,
0.4291858673095703,
0.16715309023857117,
-0.3053895831108093,
-0.06029174104332924,
-0.44674432277679443,
0.07929769903421402,
0.19262005388736725,
0.040644410997629166,
-0.13567319512367249,
0.8051791191101074,
-0.018506795167922974,
0.7830746173858643,
0.21056710183620453,
0.0763789489865303,
-0.12239372730255127,
0.15094880759716034,
-0.37476375699043274,
0.02256019599735737,
0.5395042300224304,
0.16947612166404724,
0.38821542263031006,
-0.521807074546814,
-0.1279570758342743,
0.12035737186670303,
0.44435542821884155,
-0.003934216685593128,
-0.03152564540505409,
0.454116553068161,
-0.15763980150222778,
-0.0005912542110309005,
-0.06844957172870636,
-0.7142958641052246,
-0.6477313041687012,
-0.36406463384628296,
0.8368156552314758,
-0.28140026330947876,
0.04424918815493584,
-0.14919373393058777,
0.0033963725436478853,
0.5431951880455017,
0.506047248840332,
-0.4985414147377014,
0.7263257503509521,
0.4279903769493103,
0.6119886040687561,
-0.15261457860469818,
-0.3024868667125702,
-0.44599536061286926,
-0.02716515026986599,
-0.6033493280410767,
0.5653965473175049,
-0.34438464045524597,
-0.2509682774543762,
-0.19544203579425812,
-0.042247191071510315,
-0.33124852180480957,
-0.7581005692481995,
0.12457641214132309,
-0.4582485556602478,
0.13025322556495667,
-0.26698145270347595,
-0.5451644062995911,
-0.1268620491027832,
0.33635738492012024,
-0.6283755302429199,
0.4908973276615143,
-0.0879378691315651,
-0.5183505415916443,
-0.12217956781387329,
-0.5144405364990234,
-0.4383610785007477,
-0.24918678402900696,
-0.36127927899360657,
-0.23237256705760956,
0.025085438042879105,
0.42245620489120483,
0.1429087370634079,
-0.20020416378974915,
0.24970245361328125,
-0.21358971297740936,
-0.3652723729610443,
0.5733634829521179,
-0.4938211441040039,
0.8260043859481812,
0.015214618295431137,
-0.18699800968170166,
-0.3006460666656494,
-0.7330682277679443,
-0.24204649031162262,
0.1859837770462036,
-0.024085691198706627,
-0.2896023690700531,
-0.2530982494354248,
-0.603271484375,
0.18725019693374634,
0.30897700786590576,
-0.6604390740394592,
0.257032573223114,
-0.3684663474559784,
0.01207364909350872,
1.0475417375564575,
-0.27933812141418457,
0.5480462908744812,
-0.8028510808944702,
0.6902276277542114,
-0.04549308866262436,
-0.14109113812446594,
0.10537038743495941,
-0.5746045708656311,
-0.9835726022720337,
0.1979658156633377,
0.15260367095470428,
0.8231416940689087,
-0.7966766953468323,
0.4579913020133972,
0.01424430962651968,
-0.48072633147239685,
-0.9902661442756653,
0.11445266008377075,
0.5857222676277161,
1.1556079387664795,
0.5022770166397095,
0.2764270007610321,
-0.34090733528137207,
-0.9900920987129211,
-0.42660439014434814,
-0.34244126081466675,
0.06587721407413483,
0.5930119752883911,
0.4793643653392792,
0.21229547262191772,
0.8299061059951782,
-0.5435240268707275,
-0.3193049728870392,
0.010743780061602592,
0.2687205374240875,
-0.07566038519144058,
0.2711995840072632,
0.29885753989219666,
-0.7295403480529785,
-0.10718989372253418,
-0.11713387072086334,
-1.0392086505889893,
0.10392636805772781,
-0.25063490867614746,
0.1134813204407692,
0.23924079537391663,
0.45048102736473083,
-0.7964698076248169,
0.719848096370697,
0.4646138846874237,
-0.21440131962299347,
0.2905205190181732,
-0.4341188967227936,
-0.06424792110919952,
-0.911744236946106,
0.19805794954299927,
-0.24613972008228302,
0.03897703066468239,
-0.6884119510650635,
-0.3228282928466797,
-0.07405488938093185,
-0.043589454144239426,
-0.42061930894851685,
1.037746787071228,
-0.30337420105934143,
-0.23524942994117737,
-0.27422377467155457,
0.06417020410299301,
0.020432444289326668,
0.7630226612091064,
0.08595914393663406,
0.9811585545539856,
0.5706169009208679,
-0.8992636203765869,
0.044744718819856644,
0.6491224765777588,
-0.21470767259597778,
0.6804686188697815,
-0.5165343284606934,
0.44916293025016785,
-0.5334624648094177,
-0.04095245897769928,
-1.1590750217437744,
-0.2377421110868454,
0.3074398934841156,
-0.8500776290893555,
0.2138032615184784,
0.021301040425896645,
-0.22725558280944824,
-0.11771853268146515,
0.13926570117473602,
0.19937656819820404,
0.33025285601615906,
-0.5666761994361877,
0.683656632900238,
0.32693007588386536,
-0.04209001734852791,
-0.8905177116394043,
-0.9108612537384033,
-0.11069239675998688,
-0.14004747569561005,
-0.4463687837123871,
0.11790203303098679,
-0.34529152512550354,
-0.671637237071991,
0.3165990114212036,
-0.14316615462303162,
-0.3126920461654663,
0.32483556866645813,
0.47553959488868713,
0.29389822483062744,
-0.12561102211475372,
0.42874106764793396,
-0.15761837363243103,
0.028301429003477097,
0.07281970977783203,
0.1740390807390213,
0.3944738209247589,
0.03248212859034538,
-0.5377327799797058,
-0.6655030846595764,
0.1630244255065918,
0.5880661606788635,
-0.06790238618850708,
0.7919045686721802,
0.2039724886417389,
-0.6830121874809265,
0.05156952887773514,
-0.5787285566329956,
-0.3035072088241577,
-0.41458404064178467,
0.009928521700203419,
-0.21179784834384918,
-0.6134324669837952,
0.5386489033699036,
0.27676770091056824,
0.013033977709710598,
0.41344624757766724,
0.33604350686073303,
-0.34170427918434143,
1.0261123180389404,
0.5397082567214966,
-0.33698222041130066,
-0.26790300011634827,
-0.1330396980047226,
0.23724661767482758,
-0.7813895344734192,
-0.22022709250450134,
-0.8352339863777161,
-0.5124690532684326,
-0.47052380442619324,
-0.14063571393489838,
0.44630569219589233,
-0.2868647575378418,
-0.04219316691160202,
0.07966625690460205,
-0.2894464135169983,
0.2642524242401123,
0.6309726238250732,
0.08200813829898834,
0.27374333143234253,
-0.31378868222236633,
0.4088917374610901,
0.321873277425766,
-0.2278788834810257,
-0.6651175022125244,
1.0311639308929443,
0.13662834465503693,
0.7457578778266907,
0.041984450072050095,
0.3205210864543915,
0.35529428720474243,
-0.15639232099056244,
-0.5976209044456482,
0.5396444201469421,
0.24781474471092224,
-0.5799325108528137,
-0.5325770974159241,
-0.2183268517255783,
-0.7935324311256409,
-0.19712714850902557,
-0.08696259558200836,
-0.6572500467300415,
0.10694998502731323,
0.2728404402732849,
-0.5729977488517761,
0.48648810386657715,
-0.8131067752838135,
0.5789294242858887,
-0.261484831571579,
-0.06453265994787216,
0.15796636044979095,
-0.669392466545105,
0.20758259296417236,
0.06655028462409973,
0.2018980085849762,
0.00031548074912279844,
-0.10458049923181534,
0.8906724452972412,
-0.45921337604522705,
0.8204529285430908,
-0.09043915569782257,
-0.008798603899776936,
0.4107584059238434,
0.23893681168556213,
0.6095290184020996,
0.12050223350524902,
-0.30078640580177307,
0.03354785591363907,
-0.17067693173885345,
-0.29838746786117554,
-0.8053910732269287,
0.6317398548126221,
-1.0008535385131836,
-0.8106126189231873,
-0.38845810294151306,
-0.5470853447914124,
-0.5769872665405273,
0.06551714241504669,
0.3409234583377838,
-0.031089648604393005,
-0.05556737259030342,
-0.2651630938053131,
0.5424031615257263,
-0.15234585106372833,
0.2774375081062317,
0.42559701204299927,
0.21765494346618652,
0.10130304098129272,
0.7389450669288635,
0.32230427861213684,
0.17917658388614655,
0.47866368293762207,
0.14127151668071747,
-0.12109297513961792,
-0.4483361840248108,
-0.620441734790802,
0.32828226685523987,
-0.6342612504959106,
-0.05239247903227806,
-0.6878733038902283,
-0.32008153200149536,
-0.4135434031486511,
-0.13108409941196442,
-0.050643499940633774,
-0.5775810480117798,
-0.4823421835899353,
-0.2963479459285736,
0.514079213142395,
0.8933683037757874,
0.058443356305360794,
0.12262457609176636,
-0.41547614336013794,
0.49621039628982544,
0.613660991191864,
0.1427682638168335,
0.07519999891519547,
-0.4701961278915405,
0.1121438592672348,
0.36576735973358154,
-0.17683415114879608,
-0.8994522094726562,
0.3550404906272888,
-0.03500998392701149,
0.39296218752861023,
0.194842129945755,
0.47152984142303467,
0.6966679096221924,
-0.10562482476234436,
0.7431274652481079,
-0.5942143797874451,
-0.7943847179412842,
0.5480014681816101,
-0.028789984062314034,
0.15322816371917725,
0.5429245829582214,
0.42090409994125366,
-0.28602516651153564,
-0.5099629759788513,
-0.6556180715560913,
-0.22440862655639648,
1.0122374296188354,
0.16990084946155548,
0.09573881328105927,
0.19513484835624695,
0.39165470004081726,
0.16552186012268066,
0.4023883640766144,
-0.4851645529270172,
-0.4670795202255249,
0.036470163613557816,
-0.15924066305160522,
-0.0443403534591198,
0.1478295624256134,
-0.3069489598274231,
-0.08312900364398956,
0.5744984149932861,
-0.2399325668811798,
0.571139395236969,
0.2645387053489685,
-0.1346605122089386,
-0.2825474739074707,
0.14694494009017944,
0.7571253776550293,
0.7151801586151123,
-0.25546249747276306,
0.21108795702457428,
0.3580966889858246,
-0.28275537490844727,
0.1389072686433792,
0.03602934628725052,
-0.17013972997665405,
-0.32418444752693176,
0.5150526165962219,
0.680319607257843,
-0.7085082530975342,
-0.988823652267456,
0.47985896468162537,
-0.28752171993255615,
-0.18738840520381927,
-0.5865208506584167,
0.19531559944152832,
-0.07803094387054443,
0.03411625698208809,
0.10470206290483475,
0.34609538316726685,
-0.03553946688771248,
-0.44776761531829834,
-0.03931349143385887,
0.6615034937858582,
-0.5157273411750793,
-0.35838112235069275,
0.5767458081245422,
-0.2427070289850235,
-0.5710052847862244,
0.800082266330719,
0.1425313651561737,
-0.1484026312828064,
1.0176767110824585,
0.42462578415870667,
0.6841934323310852,
-0.12980251014232635,
0.14334623515605927,
0.07767894119024277,
0.2700946629047394,
0.3076655864715576,
0.21025970578193665,
-0.0877915546298027,
-0.7716069221496582,
-0.033876724541187286,
-0.20970188081264496,
-0.5222449898719788,
0.49395668506622314,
-0.6423923969268799,
0.10614491254091263,
-0.84992516040802,
0.21406325697898865,
-0.15295204520225525,
-0.24198850989341736,
-0.9802596569061279,
0.38537004590034485,
-0.09542626142501831,
0.7045441269874573,
-0.909229576587677,
0.45559510588645935,
0.584286630153656,
-0.4135732650756836,
-0.7897994518280029,
0.3985811769962311,
0.14906184375286102,
-1.158127784729004,
0.3746444880962372,
-0.010558468289673328,
0.016178490594029427,
-0.3043411374092102,
-0.6103417873382568,
-0.7269234657287598,
0.9183065295219421,
0.32401978969573975,
-0.2632703483104706,
-0.35002008080482483,
0.3864382207393646,
0.6418876051902771,
-0.16259834170341492,
0.2853601574897766,
0.25246673822402954,
0.6602566242218018,
0.06880995631217957,
-0.974690318107605,
-0.06405030190944672,
-0.1894095242023468,
-0.39605212211608887,
-0.2255001962184906,
-0.7052192687988281,
1.0066367387771606,
-0.486123651266098,
0.015160073526203632,
0.23746506869792938,
0.43288713693618774,
-0.20735733211040497,
0.49786433577537537,
0.3230828046798706,
0.5976503491401672,
0.9703145623207092,
0.04838774353265762,
0.9390673041343689,
-0.1818474978208542,
-0.1821138709783554,
1.1190810203552246,
-0.37041789293289185,
0.6266706585884094,
0.44955143332481384,
0.10465628653764725,
0.2423008680343628,
0.2414918690919876,
0.2636583745479584,
0.40004441142082214,
-0.11680996417999268,
-0.028877990320324898,
-0.26852741837501526,
-0.15371204912662506,
-0.13320009410381317,
0.5481616854667664,
0.40203022956848145,
-0.1826058030128479,
0.030054328963160515,
0.1345885545015335,
0.05105524882674217,
0.28298723697662354,
-0.0836678296327591,
1.1510907411575317,
-0.044802118092775345,
-1.0743125677108765,
0.7342965602874756,
-0.1478147655725479,
0.08816925436258316,
-0.21887975931167603,
-0.19097205996513367,
-0.2534503936767578,
0.24082167446613312,
-0.048246290534734726,
-1.1111712455749512,
0.4618977904319763,
-0.09004451334476471,
-0.16176128387451172,
0.10189683735370636,
0.42071670293807983,
-0.13761918246746063,
-0.34022659063339233,
-0.04082471504807472,
0.5870392918586731,
0.09733125567436218,
0.06375967711210251,
-0.6055307388305664,
-0.22802278399467468,
-0.11808408796787262,
0.15695959329605103,
0.2592107653617859,
0.2779047191143036,
-0.07161565870046616,
1.0712671279907227,
0.38885197043418884,
0.13988851010799408,
0.054155100136995316,
-0.4796774387359619,
0.6667906045913696,
-0.3094030022621155,
-0.11744816601276398,
-0.7590107917785645,
0.3369080424308777,
0.01817500591278076,
-0.3038754463195801,
0.6743379831314087,
0.2151438593864441,
0.9129534363746643,
-0.09884121268987656,
1.1165183782577515,
-0.028161462396383286,
0.8117912411689758,
-0.5930903553962708,
0.38217610120773315,
-0.6920165419578552,
0.3325692415237427,
-0.1997213214635849,
-0.3999266028404236,
-0.20321902632713318,
0.5637493133544922,
-0.5833402872085571,
0.06286028772592545,
0.4350452125072479,
0.8706099987030029,
0.15652717649936676,
0.15234717726707458,
0.30825409293174744,
0.4146030843257904,
0.2941132187843323,
0.6043134331703186,
0.8126335144042969,
-0.46667832136154175,
0.6544707417488098,
-0.43710193037986755,
-0.003999676555395126,
-0.12533266842365265,
-0.32702991366386414,
-1.1046758890151978,
-0.7686301469802856,
-0.21225538849830627,
-0.33527371287345886,
0.20134605467319489,
0.6534144878387451,
0.45973166823387146,
-0.7005645632743835,
0.05928036570549011,
-0.08590099960565567,
0.5041214823722839,
-0.27167630195617676,
-0.14253060519695282,
0.5393134951591492,
-0.10807809978723526,
-0.700404942035675,
0.4585517942905426,
0.11169236153364182,
0.28481325507164,
-0.2807769775390625,
-0.22095972299575806,
-0.3906094431877136,
0.261991411447525,
-0.1389916092157364,
0.6318865418434143,
-0.6885578036308289,
-0.2897331118583679,
0.2735244631767273,
0.018882667645812035,
0.24151809513568878,
0.4672369062900543,
-0.824025571346283,
0.4332123100757599,
0.35900038480758667,
0.8822358846664429,
-0.2009088397026062,
0.28000909090042114,
0.34403178095817566,
-0.7490237355232239,
-0.019212115556001663,
0.41490328311920166,
0.1338987499475479,
0.3337422013282776,
-0.7925833463668823,
0.22350923717021942,
-0.07493338733911514,
-0.5058969855308533,
-0.5864744782447815,
0.1443130075931549,
-0.6120140552520752,
-0.34347474575042725,
0.782436192035675,
0.06713949888944626,
-0.4733494520187378,
-0.35100799798965454,
-0.34709101915359497,
0.1157967820763588,
-0.2334672212600708,
0.9695095419883728,
0.7709327340126038,
-0.4011974334716797,
-0.12381064891815186,
-0.49231958389282227,
0.8066371083259583,
0.56967693567276,
-0.8220385313034058,
0.16894155740737915,
0.12709331512451172,
0.15326999127864838,
0.33862945437431335,
0.7076870799064636,
0.147861510515213,
0.30145660042762756,
-0.281327486038208,
-0.34432315826416016,
-0.1817455142736435,
-0.4905698299407959,
-0.316840797662735,
0.07387640327215195,
0.42368820309638977,
-0.46189698576927185
] |